#!/usr/bin/env python3 """Compute and plot VD/HD/HV entanglement metrics across all layers for all scales. Definitions (values come from the delta-similarity CSV heatmaps, where each cell is the cosine similarity between the mean delta vector of row-category and col-category): VD-entanglement = 1/4 * (mean(above-far, below-close) - mean(above-close, below-far)) HD-entanglement = 1/4 * (mean(left-far, right-close) - mean(left-close, right-far)) HV-entanglement = 1/4 * (mean(left-above, right-below) - mean(left-below, right-above)) Note: 'below' is stored as 'under' in the CSV. The script handles both transparently. Positive value = the two axes are more entangled in the "expected" direction (e.g. above↔far, left↔above) than in the "unexpected" direction. Single directory: color by scale (vanilla=blue, 80k=orange, …) Multiple directories: color by model family, linestyle by scale Usage (single dir): python plot_entanglement.py results_short_answer/molmo python plot_entanglement.py results_short_answer/molmo --subset both_correct Usage (multiple dirs — compare families): python plot_entanglement.py results_short_answer/molmo results_short_answer/nvila results_short_answer/qwen python plot_entanglement.py results_short_answer/molmo results_short_answer/nvila --out-dir /tmp/compare """ import argparse import re from pathlib import Path from collections import defaultdict import numpy as np import pandas as pd import matplotlib matplotlib.use('Agg') import matplotlib.pyplot as plt # ── Scale ordering and colors (kept in sync with swap_analysis.py) ──────────── SCALE_ORDER = [ 'vanilla', '80k', '80k-5pct', '80k-10pct', '80k-20pct', '80k-30pct', '400k', '400k-5pct', '800k', '800k-5pct', '2m', 'roborefer', 'molmo2', 'qwen3_32b', 'qwen3_235b', ] # Used in single-dir mode (one color per scale) SCALE_COLORS = { 'vanilla': '#1f77b4', '80k': '#ff7f0e', '400k': '#2ca02c', '800k': '#d62728', '2m': '#9467bd', 'roborefer': '#8c564b', 'molmo2': '#17becf', 'qwen3_32b': '#bcbd22', 'qwen3_235b':'#e377c2', '80k-5pct': '#b2dfdb', '80k-10pct': '#00b894', '80k-20pct': '#00897b', '80k-30pct': '#004d40', '400k-5pct': '#66bb6a', '800k-5pct': '#ef9a9a', } SCALE_DISPLAY_NAMES = { '80k-5pct': '80k 5%', '80k-10pct': '80k 10%', '80k-20pct': '80k 20%', '80k-30pct': '80k 30%', '400k-5pct': '400k 5%', '800k-5pct': '800k 5%', } # Used in multi-dir mode (one color per model family, one linestyle per scale) FAMILY_COLOR_CYCLE = [ '#1f77b4', # blue '#d62728', # red '#2ca02c', # green '#ff7f0e', # orange '#9467bd', # purple '#8c564b', # brown '#e377c2', # pink '#17becf', # cyan '#bcbd22', # yellow-green ] SCALE_LINESTYLE_CYCLE = [ 'solid', 'dashed', 'dotted', 'dashdot', (0, (5, 1)), # long dash (0, (3, 1, 1, 1)), # dash-dot-dot (0, (1, 1)), # dotted dense (0, (5, 5)), # long dash sparse ] # ── CSV helpers ──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────── _CSV_RE = re.compile(r'^delta_similarity_(.+)_L(\d+)_(all_pairs|both_correct)\.csv$') def _loc(df: pd.DataFrame, row: str, col: str) -> float: """Look up (row, col) with 'under' ↔ 'below' aliasing.""" aliases = {'below': 'under', 'under': 'below'} r = row if row in df.index else aliases.get(row, row) c = col if col in df.columns else aliases.get(col, col) if r not in df.index or c not in df.columns: return float('nan') return float(df.loc[r, c]) def compute_entanglement(df: pd.DataFrame) -> dict: """Compute VD, HD, HV entanglement from a 6×6 delta-similarity DataFrame. Each metric is the difference of two means of cosine similarities (range [-2, 2]), divided by 4 to normalise to [-0.5, 0.5]. """ vd = (_loc(df, 'above', 'far') + _loc(df, 'below', 'close') - _loc(df, 'above', 'close') - _loc(df, 'below', 'far')) / 4 hd = (_loc(df, 'left', 'far') + _loc(df, 'right', 'close') - _loc(df, 'left', 'close') - _loc(df, 'right', 'far')) / 4 hv = (_loc(df, 'left', 'above') + _loc(df, 'right', 'below') - _loc(df, 'left', 'below') - _loc(df, 'right', 'above')) / 4 return {'VD': vd, 'HD': hd, 'HV': hv} def load_entanglement(csv_dir: Path, subset: str) -> dict: """ Returns: {scale: {layer_int: {'VD': float, 'HD': float, 'HV': float}}} """ data = defaultdict(dict) for fname in sorted(csv_dir.iterdir()): m = _CSV_RE.match(fname.name) if not m: continue scale, layer_str, file_subset = m.group(1), m.group(2), m.group(3) if file_subset != subset: continue layer = int(layer_str) try: df = pd.read_csv(fname, index_col=0) except Exception as e: print(f" [warn] Could not read {fname.name}: {e}") continue data[scale][layer] = compute_entanglement(df) return dict(data) def _scale_sort_key(s): return SCALE_ORDER.index(s) if s in SCALE_ORDER else 99 # ── Plotting ────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────── METRICS = [ ('VD', 'Vertical-Distance Entanglement\nmean(above-far, below-close) − mean(above-close, below-far)'), ('HD', 'Horizontal-Distance Entanglement\nmean(left-far, right-close) − mean(left-close, right-far)'), # ('HV', 'HV-Entanglement\nmean(left-above, right-below) − mean(left-below, right-above)'), ] def plot_entanglement_single(scale_data: dict, model_type: str, subset: str, save_path: Path): """Single directory: color by scale.""" fig, axes = plt.subplots(1, 2, figsize=(12, 5)) for ax, (metric_key, metric_label) in zip(axes, METRICS): for scale in SCALE_ORDER: if scale not in scale_data: continue layer_dict = scale_data[scale] layers = sorted(layer_dict.keys()) vals = [layer_dict[l][metric_key] for l in layers] if not any(np.isfinite(v) for v in vals): continue ax.plot( layers, vals, '-', color=SCALE_COLORS.get(scale, 'gray'), label=SCALE_DISPLAY_NAMES.get(scale, scale), linewidth=2, ) _style_ax(ax, metric_label) tag = 'Both-Correct' if subset == 'both_correct' else 'All Pairs' fig.suptitle( f'{model_type.upper()} — Entanglement Metrics Across Layers [{tag}]', fontsize=13, fontweight='bold', ) _save(fig, save_path) def plot_entanglement_multi(family_data: dict, subset: str, save_path: Path): """Multiple directories: color by family, linestyle by scale.""" # Collect all scales across all families (in canonical order) all_scales = sorted( {s for scales in family_data.values() for s in scales}, key=_scale_sort_key, ) families = list(family_data.keys()) # preserve insertion order # Assign colors to families and linestyles to scales family_color = {f: FAMILY_COLOR_CYCLE[i % len(FAMILY_COLOR_CYCLE)] for i, f in enumerate(families)} scale_ls = {s: SCALE_LINESTYLE_CYCLE[i % len(SCALE_LINESTYLE_CYCLE)] for i, s in enumerate(all_scales)} fig, axes = plt.subplots(1, 2, figsize=(12, 5)) for ax, (metric_key, metric_label) in zip(axes, METRICS): for family in families: scale_data = family_data[family] color = family_color[family] for scale in all_scales: if scale not in scale_data: continue layer_dict = scale_data[scale] layers = sorted(layer_dict.keys()) vals = [layer_dict[l][metric_key] for l in layers] if not any(np.isfinite(v) for v in vals): continue scale_disp = SCALE_DISPLAY_NAMES.get(scale, scale) ax.plot( layers, vals, color=color, linestyle=scale_ls[scale], label=f'{family} {scale_disp}', linewidth=2, ) _style_ax(ax, metric_label) tag = 'Both-Correct' if subset == 'both_correct' else 'All Pairs' title_families = ' vs '.join(f.upper() for f in families) fig.suptitle( f'{title_families} — Entanglement Metrics Across Layers [{tag}]', fontsize=13, fontweight='bold', ) _save(fig, save_path) def _style_ax(ax, title: str): ax.axhline(y=0, color='gray', linestyle='--', alpha=0.5, linewidth=1) ax.set_xlabel('Layer Index', fontsize=11) ax.set_ylabel('Entanglement', fontsize=11) ax.set_ylim(-1, 1) ax.set_title(title, fontsize=10, fontweight='bold') ax.legend(fontsize=9) ax.grid(True, alpha=0.3) def _save(fig, save_path: Path): plt.tight_layout() save_path.parent.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True) plt.savefig(save_path, dpi=300, bbox_inches='tight') plt.close() print(f"Saved: {save_path}") # ── Main ────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────── def main(): parser = argparse.ArgumentParser( description='Plot VD/HD/HV entanglement metrics from saved delta-similarity CSVs.', formatter_class=argparse.RawDescriptionHelpFormatter, epilog=__doc__, ) parser.add_argument('results_dirs', nargs='+', type=str, help='One or more results directories ' '(e.g. results_short_answer/molmo results_short_answer/nvila)') parser.add_argument('--subset', choices=['all_pairs', 'both_correct'], default='all_pairs', help='Which CSV subset to use (default: all_pairs)') parser.add_argument('--scales', nargs='+', default=None, help='Restrict to these scales (default: all found)') parser.add_argument('--out-dir', type=str, default=None, help='Output directory. Single dir default: {results_dir}/plots/entanglement/. ' 'Multi dir default: {common_parent}/entanglement_compare/') args = parser.parse_args() # Resolve and validate all directories dirs = [] for p in args.results_dirs: d = Path(p).resolve() if not d.is_dir(): parser.error(f'Directory not found: {d}') csv_dir = d / 'csv' if not csv_dir.is_dir(): parser.error(f'No csv/ subdirectory in: {d}') dirs.append(d) multi = len(dirs) > 1 subset = args.subset tag = 'Both-Correct' if subset == 'both_correct' else 'All Pairs' # Determine output path if args.out_dir: out_dir = Path(args.out_dir) elif multi: common = dirs[0].parent out_dir = common / 'entanglement_compare' else: out_dir = dirs[0] / 'plots' / 'entanglement' print(f"Subset : {subset}") print(f"Output dir : {out_dir}") print() # Load data from all directories family_data = {} # {model_type: {scale: {layer: entanglement}}} for d in dirs: model_type = d.name scale_data = load_entanglement(d / 'csv', subset) if not scale_data: print(f"[warn] No matching CSVs in {d}/csv — skipping") continue if args.scales: scale_data = {s: v for s, v in scale_data.items() if s in args.scales} found = sorted(scale_data.keys(), key=_scale_sort_key) print(f" {model_type}: {len(found)} scales — {found}") for s in found: layers = sorted(scale_data[s].keys()) deepest = layers[-1] e = scale_data[s][deepest] vd = f"{e['VD']:>7.4f}" if np.isfinite(e['VD']) else ' nan' hd = f"{e['HD']:>7.4f}" if np.isfinite(e['HD']) else ' nan' hv = f"{e['HV']:>7.4f}" if np.isfinite(e['HV']) else ' nan' print(f" {s:<15} L{deepest:>2} VD={vd} HD={hd} HV={hv}") family_data[model_type] = scale_data if not family_data: print("[error] No data loaded from any directory.") return print() if multi: families_tag = '_'.join(family_data.keys()) save_path = out_dir / f'entanglement_{families_tag}_{subset}.png' plot_entanglement_multi(family_data, subset, save_path) else: model_type = list(family_data.keys())[0] save_path = out_dir / f'entanglement_{subset}.png' plot_entanglement_single(family_data[model_type], model_type, subset, save_path) if __name__ == '__main__': main()