diff --git "a/Data/transcripts/4F_RBc1akC8_20241225194724.txt" "b/Data/transcripts/4F_RBc1akC8_20241225194724.txt" deleted file mode 100644--- "a/Data/transcripts/4F_RBc1akC8_20241225194724.txt" +++ /dev/null @@ -1,3338 +0,0 @@ -[Music] -welcome to the hubman lab guest Series -where I and an expert guest discuss -science and science-based tools for -everyday -life I'm Andrew huberman and I'm a -professor of neurobiology and -Opthalmology at Stanford school of -medicine today March the 3D episode in -our sixth episode series all about sleep -with expert guest Dr Matthew Walker -during today's episode we discuss how to -structure your sleep for optimal mental -health physical health and performance -we discuss monophasic sleep schedules -which are the more typical sleep -schedule where you go to sleep at night -and then wake up in the morning so -sleeping in one bout as opposed to -polyphasic sleep schedules which are -when you sleep in two or more bouts -either at night or perhaps a shorter -bout of sleep at night and another bout -of sleep during the day we also discuss -naps including how to nap how long your -nap should be whether or not naps are -good or bad in particular whether or not -they're good or bad for you it turns out -this varies according to individual we -also discuss how your needs for sleep -and naps vary across the lifespan and we -discuss body position during sleep which -might seem excessively detailed but it -turns out that body position during -sleep is critical for ensuring that the -sleep you get is optimally restorative -as with the first two episodes of this -six episode series today's third episode -is filled with both science that is the -biology of sleep and napping and body -position and how those relate to one -another as well as practical tools that -you can use to vastly improve your sleep -before we begin I'd like to emphasize -that this podcast is separate from my -teaching and research roles at Stanford -it is however part of my desire and -effort to bring zero cost to Consumer -information about science and science -related tools to the general public in -keeping with that theme I'd like to -thank the sponsors of today's podcast -our first sponsor is betterhelp -betterhelp offers Professional Therapy -with a licensed therapist carried out -online now I've been doing therapy for -well over 30 years initially I had to do -therapy against my will but of course I -continued to do it voluntarily over time -because I really believe that doing -regular therapy with a quality therapist -is one of the best things that we can do -for our mental health indeed for many -people it's as beneficial as getting -regular physical exercise the great -thing about better help is that it makes -it very easy to find a therapist that's -optimal for your needs and I think it's -fair to say that we can define a great -therapist as somebody with whom you have -excellent Rapport somebody with whom you -can talk about a variety of different -issues and who can provide you not just -support but also insight and with better -help they make it extremely conven vent -so that it's matched to your schedule -and other aspects of your life if you'd -like to try betterhelp you can go to -betterhelp.com huberman to get 10% off -your first month again that's -betterhelp.com -huberman today's episode is also brought -To Us by element element is an -electrolyte drink that has everything -you need and nothing you don't that -means plenty of the electrolytes -magnesium potassium and sodium and no -sugar as I mentioned before on this -podcast I'm a big fan of salt now I want -to be clear people who already consume a -lot of salt or who have high blood -pressure or who happen to consume a lot -of processed foods that typically -contain salt need to control their salt -intake however if you're somebody who -eats pretty clean and you're somebody -who exercises and you're drinking a lot -of water there's a decent chance that -you could benefit from ingesting more -electrolytes with your liquids the -reason for that is that all the cells in -our body including the nerve cells the -neurons require the electrolytes in -order to function properly so we don't -just want to be hydrated we want to be -hydrated with proper electrolyte levels -with element that's very easy to do what -I do is when I wake up in the morning I -consume about 16 to 32 ounces of water -and I'll dissolve a packet of element in -that water I'll also do the same when I -exercise especially if it's on a hot day -and I'm sweating a lot and sometimes -I'll even have a third element packet -dissolved in water if I'm exercising -really hard or sweating a lot or if I -just noticed that I'm not consuming -enough salt with my food if you'd like -to try element you can go to drink -element spelled LM nt.com huberman to -claim a free element sample pack with -your purchase again that's drink element -LM -t.com today's episode is also brought To -Us by waking up waking up is a -meditation app that has hundreds of -different meditations as well as scripts -for Yoga Nidra and non-sleep deep rest -or nsdr protocols by now there is an -abundance of data showing that even -short daily meditations can greatly -improve our mood reduce anxiety improve -our ability to focus and can improve our -memory and while there are many -different forms of meditation most -people find it difficult to find and -stick to a meditation practice in a way -that is most beneficial for them the -waking up app makes it extremely easy to -learn how to meditate and to carry out -your daily meditation practice in a way -that's going to be most effective and -efficient for you it includes a variety -of different types of meditations of -different duration as well as things -like Yoga Nidra which place the brain -and body into a sort of pseudo sleep -that allows you to emerge feeling -incredibly mentally refreshed in fact -the science around Yoga Nidra is really -impressive showing that after a yoga -needra session levels of dopamine in -certain areas of the brain are enhanced -by up to 60% which places the brain and -body into a state of enhanced Readiness -for mental work and for physical work -another thing I really like about the -waking up app is that it provides a -30-day introduction course so for those -of you that have not meditated before or -getting back to a meditation practice -that's fantastic or if you're somebody -who's already a skilled and regular -meditator waking up has more advanced -meditations and yoga needer sessions for -you as well if you'd like to try The -Waking Up app you can go to waking -up.com huberman and access a free 30-day -trial again that's waking up.com -huberman and now for my conversation -with Dr Matthew Walker Dr Walker welcome -back Dr huberman an absolute pleasure -let's talk about the different types of -sleep because I think most people think -of sleep as just one thing most people -sleep at night some people also nap a -topic we'll also discuss today -but turns out there are a lot of -different different types of sleep what -are the different types of sleep and -what do they do for us and um I guess -everyone's probably wondering already I -certainly am what types of sleep are we -already engaging in meaning am I -involved in or having multiple types of -sleep each night this is a fascinating -question and it comes back to something -we've discussed in a previous episode -the different stages of sleep and how -they unfold we've described that -fascinating stuff what you're already -asking though is is an incredibly sort -of subtle but relevant question how -should I be sleeping in terms of the -phases of sleep should I have one phase -should I have two phases of sleep or -should I have many phases of sleep in -some ways you can answer that question -on the basis of the lifespan because how -it is that we sleep in terms of those -chunking sessions changes as we -develop to be clear in -nomenclature I'm saying monophasic basic -polyphasic unpack that monophasic -obviously just simply means a single -phase monophasic when you say phase you -mean one bout of sleep correct so that -would be within a 24-hour period you are -having a single bout of sleep basic then -means that within that 24-hour phase you -are having two bouts of sleep and we'll -speak about how those bouts are split up -are they split up between two halves in -the middle of the night or are they -split up in terms of longer at night -Siesta like nap in the afternoon and -then we can speak about polyphasic sleep -polyphasic sleep we in sleep science -have been using for many years in the -context of infancy because there as any -new parents will know infants do not -just simply have a nice single bout of -sleep they're up they're down they're up -they're down and have many bouts of -sleep within that 24-hour period and -that's polyphasic sleep the other term -or the other application of that term -polyphasic sleep has been used more so -in the sort of interesting biohacker -movement and we can we'll come back to -that perhaps later on so how do these -different phases of sleep change across -the lifespan well we've already said -that when you're an infant and you're -first born within the first year of life -you are incredibly poly phasic and you -are probably going through wake sleep -phases every 2 hours why do you do that -why can't you just simply be born and -sleep in a monophasic way it's for at -least two reasons first an infant needs -to feed every two hours so their energy -needs and their food intake requirements -dictate that you can't sleep for very -long because you need to be awake to -feed and then you go back to -sleep Within probably the first six -months things will start to to change a -little bit but the second reason that -you are highly polyphasic when you are -first born is because your super -chiasmatic nucleus and in another -episode we spoke about this Central -master 24-hour clock that beats out your -Cadian Rhythm the rise and the fall the -wake and the sleep that has not yet -developed it hasn't been glued into -place into the brain this 24-hour clock -so the infant seemingly knows nothing -about when it's light or when it's dark -outside that just awake or sleep awake a -sleeve so that's the second reason -energy feeding needs is the first and -then an absence of yet a fully developed -24-hour clock in the brain to beat out -that beautiful dictated Rhythm by about -age one that number of phases of sleep -are starting to decrease but it's still -highly polyphasic it's not not until you -get to probably age two or three that -now you're starting to see this -consolidation of sleep what do I mean by -that sleep is now happening more -dominantly in the night phase of the -24-hour cycle and there a few abouts of -sleep during the -daytime then perhaps by the time you're -in kindergarten you may be down to just -two sleeps so now we've switched from -polyphasic sleep as infants to basic -sleep as kindergarten could you describe -that it was basic patterns I recall in -kindergarten um having nap time in the -afternoon yeah they put out these little -mats and every every kid would just kind -like roll up it's actually sounds really -nice it's one you know wouldn't and -we'll speak about how some adults do -this too but almost every kindergarten -system that I've inquired about around -the world different nations they all -have this nap time and Any teacher will -tell you if one of those children does -not nap during that period of time they -are the Loose Canon they are the live -wire and in subsequent episodes we'll -speak about exactly how sleep harnesses -and improves our emotional and mental -health and how it falls apart when we -don't so that that's how it certainly is -emerging biologically and that's how we -as a society respect that and -accommodate that -and then probably by the age of starting -school so sort of five or six now we're -starting to see fully monophasic sleep -children sleeping long bouts at night -and then being able to sustain -wakefulness during the day at that point -you have locked in your monophasic -pattern and that will continue -throughout adulthood and into old age -with a few caveats that we'll speak -about so that's how sleep sleep unfolds -in the monophasic biphasic polyphasic -sleep across the lifespan it doesn't -quite tell you however how those -different stages of sleep change across -the lifespan so I've shown you the view -of sleep across the lifespan through one -lens of the microscope if we click down -one lens and focus more deeply on the -different stages of sleep there we see a -fascinating -story in uo for the most part you are in -a sleep likee State as a fetus once you -get to a certain point of -development in utero that sleep-like -state seems to be more so something that -looks like REM sleep now it's not fully -fledged full fat REM sleep yet but it -seems to be something very much like REM -sleep I say this because in the first -episode I told you as we go into REM -sleep -and we start to as adults dream the -brain paralyzes the body so that the -mind can dream safely those kicks and -those punches and those elbows that uh a -mother will feel from the fetus seem to -be during this dream state often and I -don't want to shatter any illusions of -you start singing or you're cing and you -get these bumps and these elbows and -these legs kicking and it's beautiful it -is beautiful but it turns out that it's -probably the REM sleep state but the -muscle sort of paralysis has not yet -developed so you're getting these -electrical burst this frenetic activity -of REM sleep that we described but -you're not getting any of the blockade -of the motor output and so it expresses -itself as these kicks and these -bumps and then during the first six -months of life and at that point in the -first 6 months those infants are -sleeping anywhere between 14 to 17 hours -a day that's it's immense isn't it I -mean it's right up there if you look -across the across philogyny and you ask -which is by the way a fascinating Topic -at some point we should do a a separate -podcast on sleep across different -species because I know like me you love -you know the whole variety of sweet but -you've got elephants who will sleep as -little as 4 hours and then you've got -the little brown bat who is the rock -star of sleep and it will sleep sleep -almost 17 to 18 hours a day it nudges -out the sloth in that sense wow can I -ask you a question about that little -brown P yeah does it sleep hanging -upside down does so it can't have sleep -paralysis in its little claws so it it -will it will not have that paralysis but -it goes through the stages of sleep very -quickly and this happens with birds as -well so birds that flock on a branch -they will sleep and they sleep in some -fascinating ways what some sometimes -with one half of the brain sometimes -with both halves but then you say well -if I'm on a branch and there's this -wonderful Force called gravity -underneath me and I go into REM sleep -and I have that muscle paralysis which -they do how does that work well they -only have very brief REM sleep periods -that last just for a few seconds and -then they regain their muscle tone got -it couldn't couldn't help but ask it's -genius the Flora and the fauna I -especially that the fauna um enchant me -that much so I don't want to draw us off -course but now we know that they they -can that's why the bats don't fall -that's why the birds Don't Fall correct -um so when you are then as an infant -sleeping 14 to 17 hours what's happening -with those different stages of sleep -non-rem and REM at that point we can't -really Define and separate the different -stages of non-r because it's not yet -fully formed but we have what looks like -a REM sleep active State and a a deep -non-rem sleep passive state almost 50% -of the time that an infant a newborn is -asleep is spent in REM sleep why do I -say that with some kind of wonder in my -voice because as adults we're perhaps -down to maybe 20% of our time spent -asleep is in REM sleep but 50% of the -time when an infant is asleep they are -in rem why would this be the case and -across all species that have REM and -non-rem the time when we see REM sleep -in highest volume amount is always after -birth there is something special about -REM sleep and its function during that -early period and we now start to -understand why when you are first born -you are still going through a huge -amount of brain -maturation and the recipe for the day -there unlike when we are teenagers is -exploding the brain with synapses all of -these connections throughout the brain -what we've discovered is that REM sleep -acts as an electrical fertilizer to -stimulate the growth of these -connections within the brain it's almost -as though you could think about an -internet service provider with this huge -new neighborhood and the first call of -business is to go in and wire up each -one of those homes with these Fiber -Optic Cables that's what REM sleep is -doing and if you start to deprive and -these were studies gosh done many years -ago by Howard rthor and others if you -deprive animals of REM sleep you stunt -the developmental growth of the brain -and presumably the whole animal and the -yeah as a consequence I mean if you look -at its social behavior even just that -it's profoundly abnormal because you -don't have that REM sleep developed -brain I mention this not because there -is any causal evidence but we have seen -REM sleep deep impairments in certain -developmental -disorders such as autism as well as ADHD -I don't think there is any supportive -evidence yet to come out with a claim -that part of the trajectory underlying -those conditions is abnormalities of REM -sleep but I it's a very active area of -research so it's a fascinating time -though during infancy when you get these -huge amounts of REM sleep why because of -what we call synaptogenesis is which is -simply the creation of sinapsis -Genesis then as you move from 6 months -across the next 18 months something odd -happens Total Sleep time starts to -decrease REM sleep starts to decrease -but non-rem sleep actually increases -even though Total Sleep time is -decreasing and there's a strange peak in -lighter stage nonrem what we call stage -two nonr and those sleep spindles that I -was describing in the first episode -These bursts of electrical -activity we will speak about the role of -those sleep spindles in improving motor -skill learning and we've done a many -many years of work in this area why is -that relevant to this phase of life -that's right around the time when -infants start to coordinate their limbs -in a skilled way and begin to walk and -we believe that it is part of the -process of the development of the motor -system enabling walking to begin amazing -so then things will change further sleep -time continues to decrease and by about -age five or six now the cocktail blend -of nonrem and REM is down to a stable -ratio that will remain throughout the -lifespan which is a 4:1 ratio so about -20% of the time that you're asleep will -be REM sleep and the remaining time time -will be 80% of that time will be non-rem -sleeping provided one is getting -sufficient total amounts of sleep -correct and getting it at the right -moments in time that we described in the -first episode getting that sort of that -appropriate chronotype match to the -24-hour clock that will certainly alter -those things too so that's how sleep -unfolds both at the first level of the -lens monophasic basic polyphasic and -then double clicking how the different -stages of sleep unfold and what the -reasons are behind that I then said once -we're adults we become -monophasic yes to a degree but there is -some contention about the way that we -sleep in modernity that we may not be -sleeping in the way that we were -designed to sleep which brings us back -to basic sleep in the first episode we -spoke about this strange after afternoon -dip in our alertness that happens called -the postprandial dip and it happens -somewhere between the 1 to 4:00 p.m. -region and it's measurable and it seems -to be biologically wired into -us if you look at certain cultures that -are not touched by modernity so we and -others have studied studied hunter -gatherer tribes they don't quite sleep -the way that we do and they don't sleep -the way that we do for at least two -reasons the first is that they will -often have a siesta like pattern of -behavior where especially in the hot dry -season they will take a nap in the -afternoon in the wet cooler season that -may not be the case but they certainly -have more of a basic pattern where -they'll sleep longer at night and then -have a short nap Siesta like and then of -course there are Latin and Mediterranean -cultures and they have this practice of -the Siesta like Behavior coming back to -the hunter gather tribes the way that -they also do not sleep in a similar -manner to that which we do is the timing -of sleep they don't go to sleep as the -sun goes down they will usually on -average as a group they will usually go -to sleep about 2 hours after Sundown and -then they will wake up not with the -rising of the sun they wake up just -before that and you think how are they -predictive of the light no the thing -that changes first before the sun truly -Rises is -temperature and temperature is a very -strong predictor that forces them -awake so when you think about how -they're sleeping then consider the term -midnight most of us never really think -about what the term means midnight -refers to the fact that it is the middle -of the night but for most of us in the -modern world that's the time when we're -thinking about sending our last email or -posting to social media midnight is no -longer midnight for society but it is -for them so should we be thinking about -midnight as the middle of the night in -the context of the uh extreme early -person morning person who you know -presumably likes to go to bed around -8:00 P.M wake up around 4:00 a.m. most -people hear 4:00 a.m. and they go oh -goodness you know that's early sort of -um you know like the the mighty Joo -willink is is uh famous for posting -images of his of his uh digital watch -usually I think it's 4:30 a.m. wake up -and that's when he starts his workout so -his Twitter and I guess they call X now -feed and and Instagram is a replete with -images of his watch 4:30 and people -think goodness that's early right but he -was a guest on this podcast spoken to -him before but he goes to bed pretty -early that's right most nights so in -some sense you know midnight for him or -for somebody with a similar schedule is -truly middle of the night that's right -right but for the other chronotypes for -people that uh prefer to go to sleep or -who naturally um get sleepy around 10 or -11 p.m. or even later um how should they -think about this biphasic polyphasic -business because um at at some level um -we all have to -reconcile uh our sleep schedule with the -with the demands of work and family and -so on that's right so I was very -specific when I said the hunter gather -of tribes on average that's the way that -they will sleep but like the rest of -society there's a huge distribution and -there will be some proportion of them -who are a little bit like Joo who will -be on the early side of that on the very -early side of that but then there are -other people who are clear night owls -and they may not be going to bed until -you know 10: or 11: and waking up -later so there is a distribution there -you don't have to worry that my -statement of midnight on average that -does seem to be when we are dislocated -from all of the trappings of modernity -how a group of Representative humans on -average will sleep but there is huge as -I said differences from one individual -to the next by the way you can ask the -question why do we have these things -called chronotypes why is there such -variability in how people have a -preference for when they sleep wouldn't -it just be easier if -biology designed us all to be asleep at -the same time not so we mentioned in the -first episode that sleep is truly -idiotic in the sense that you know -you're not protecting yourself or the -people that you care about and if -everyone slept at the same moment in -time you as a collective and as an -individual would be vulnerable for an 8 -hour period 7 to n hour period but by -way of this wonderful injection of -variability as to preferences for when -people sleep maybe there are some people -who are going to bed at 8:00 p.m. and -there are other people and they're -waking up at 4: a.m. there are other -people who go to bed at midnight and -wake up at 8:00 a.m. so then think about -that at some point what you've done is -that there will always be someone or -collection of people awake until -midnight and then will always be a -collection of people who are awake -starting at 4:00 a.m. -so as an individual everyone gets their -8-hour opportunity but as a collective -as a clan you are you've reduced your -vulnerability down by 50% because Mother -Nature injected the variability by way -of genetics of chronotype to distribute -that and lessen the burden does that -make any sense it does and it reminds me -of how the Circadian rhythm which we -discussed in episode one is about 24 -hours not exactly 24 hours the rhythm of -the supermatic nucleus neurons that -generate the Circadian rhythm as I -recall uh is rarely exactly 24 hours -it's 24.2 or 24.4 and the idea in mind -the just so story uh is that that -variation allows for entrainment -matching to the outside light dark cycle -which changes across the year so you -don't want it rigidly 24 hours because -if there's any variation in light dark -which of course there is you know even -at the equator across the year there's -subtle variations but certainly As you -move away from the equator and so these -these uh variations in you know your -circadian rhythm uh clock scn supermatic -nucleus might be 24.2 mine might be 24.6 -24 someone else -24.1 and in that sense um allows some uh -malleability to to matching the -Circadian rhythm to outside light dark -rhythms is that is that a a decent -parallel for what we're talking about -it's a beautiful demonstration that -there is always some it's almost wiggle -room in how biology is programmed -because some degree of sort of noise -almost sarcastic noise can be very -beneficial and it's much more predictive -of the way in which the world works and -it's much more adaptive for a species to -enact and to embrace that kind of -variability and yours was a beautiful -example -that it's about 24 hours but it's -certainly responsive to changes in light -duration across the year and it has to -be because we need to buckle ourselves -to the light dark cycle for optimal -survival and here is another -demonstration of where it's not about -the Cadian Rhythm but it's about the -chronotype distribution not within an -individual across the year but across -individuals at any one moment in time -and that variability once again provides -a biological -benefit in the first episode and again -now you're discussing chronotypes and -one one thing that I've been meaning to -ask is you said that chronotype is -genetically determined but that -necessarily mean it is directly -inherited from Mom Andor dad meaning if -your parents are both extreme early -morning types will you grow up to be an -extreme early morning type you already -established that during infancy and -development uh adolescence Etc that our -chronotype is somewhat masked by some of -the developmental uh um uh Necessities -um but once we reach young adulthood and -and our chronotype has been established -uh can we look to our parents to -determine whether or not we are more -likely to be in morning person or or -late shifted it's very unlikely to find -find anyone whose parents were both -extreme morning types who is a neutral -or an evening type and vice versa so my -guess is that people with if they know -of their biological parents and they -know of their rhythms it's highly likely -that you will at some point acquas in -your lifetime to being very similar to -them now there are certain life -conditions and contexts where you can -you know fight that um if you're really -into you know if you're someone who is -in punk rock band and you're touring all -the time even though your mom and dad -may be morning types and you may be a -morning type you're on the road you're -playing gigs there's no chance but at -some point let's say you retire and you -give yourself the opportunity to express -your natural Rhythm you will go back to -that so yes it's highly genetic it's not -enre highly genetic there is some degree -of modification that happens on the -basis of context and I've just given you -a good example of context and also your -exposure to light you can be someone who -is let's say a neutral like me but if -you're constantly invaded by Electric -Light at night you're drinking too much -caffeine and you're on your laptop and -your computer and your phone and you're -always activated by social media it's -very easy for someone like me to drift -and become a 1 a.m. to you know 9 a.m. -person that's not my natural type but -context and the environment have shifted -me but for the most part yes to your -question I'd like to take a brief break -and acknowledge our sponsor ag1 ag1 is a -vitamin mineral probiotic drink that -also contains adaptogens and is designed -to meet all of your foundational -nutritional needs by now I'm sure you've -all heard me say that I've been taking -ag1 since 201 12 and indeed that is true -now of course I do consume regular Whole -Foods every day I strive to get those -Foods mostly from unprocessed or -minimally processed sources however I do -find it hard to get enough servings of -fruits and vegetables each day so with -ag1 I ensure that I get enough of the -vitamins minerals Prebiotic fiber and -other things typically found in fruits -or vegetables and of course I still make -sure to eat fruits and vegetables and in -that way provide a sort of insurance -that I'm getting enough of what I need -in addition the adaptogens and other -micro nutrients in ag1 really help -buffer against stress and ensure that -the cells and organs and tissues of my -body are getting the things they need -people often ask me that if they were -going to take Just One supplement what -that supplement should be and I always -answer ag1 if you'd like to try ag1 you -can go to drink a1.com huberman to claim -a special offer you'll get five free -travel packs plus a year supply of -vitamin D3 K2 again that's drink a1.com -huberman okay so getting back to these -different uh phase opportunities for -Sleep uh clearly I'm getting the -language wrong here but vacular -monophasic basic and polyphasic um could -you give us a few more examples of -different types of biphasic and -polyphasic sleep so coming back to basic -sleep I describe one version once we are -adults which is the Siesta like notion -one long bout at night short bout during -the day and that bout during the day is -usually matching that drop in alertness -that we described it sort of hits that -sweet spot right there and it's quite -easy for some people to fall asleep in a -period between somewhere between one and -four 1 to four yeah and I know it's a -large window but that just allows us to -sort of know okay if you're someone like -yourself who's a morning type you would -probably start to want to nap a little -bit earli or if you were basic someone -like me a neutral probably an hour and a -half two hours later still -but there is a different version of -basic sleep for adults that has been -described in the literature and it's -fascinating but I don't think it's -biological it's the notion that some -people will have heard called first -sleep second sleep and now you are -splitting your sleep into two phases but -they're split across the night so the -idea is that you fall asleep and you'll -maybe have 4ish hours and then you wake -up and you then are awake for several -hours and then you go back to sleep for -another 3 or 4 -hours if you look in history and the the -record of of human history it's very -clear that there were some cultures -doing this particularly if you look at -some of the European cultures Great -Britain in particular there is good -evidence that somewhere between about -the 15th to 19th century seems to have -ended during the kind of dezian -era people were describing this behavior -and they would wake up in the middle of -the night after about 4 hours they would -make food they would play music they -would write they would make love it was -a real thing and I'm not suggesting that -it did not happen it clearly did and -there's a there a great book that -outlines this but is it the way that we -were designed to sleep bif phasically -versus the Siesta like and I don't think -it is there is no good collection of -evidence if you look at the biology of -our human rhythms that argues that there -is this magical period of a huge spike -in Arcadian Rhythm that happens right in -the middle of the night that should -force us -awake there is one paper that's often -cited for this and in truth that paper -if you read it says nothing about first -sleep second sleep doesn't speak about -basic sleep at all -and that paper I think is unfairly used -as a justification of first sleep and -second sleep and the paper to me has at -least three problem it's a great paper -there's no no problem with the paper and -its hypothesis but its use as -justification for first sleep second -sleep has three -problems the first is the artificial -nature of the study they weren't -designing it to test the hypothesis but -they had individuals in bed for 14 hours -relative to a standard 8 hour period and -sure enough what they found was that -when you force people night after night -to be in bed for 14 hours somewhere -after about 6 or 7 hours they wake up -and then you can't get out of bed in the -study so you just lie awake and then at -some point I don't know if it's through -boredom or you drift back off into sleep -and that was argued as a clear -demonstration of this split sleep but as -I said they're awake usually for about -six and a half seven -hours also there was no magical -Awakening period it's a probability -distribution and what that means is if -you look at the data it's just more -likely that people will wake up after -about 6 or seven hours and they're more -likely that they will go back down into -sleep it wasn't as though the whole -experiment demonstrated a very clear -termination of sleep that everyone had -at that moment in time so that's the -first -issue um and the second issue which is -first issue it's kind of an abnormal -thing 14 hours forced in bed the second -is it wasn't a clear separation it's -just simply higher probability the final -issue is that it was a study done in -only seven individuals healthy males and -so I have yet to see it you know scaled -up did it happen first sleep second -sleep yes it did is there any strong -evidence that that's how we naturally -were designed and have evolved to sleep -I in truth I don't think so at least I -don't see good evidence right now -supporting that but remain open to it in -episode one we talked a little bit about -body position during sleep uh and how -different uh degrees of uh incline or -decline might impact uh some of the -features of sleep and I can't help but -ask now as you uh described this basic -pattern for people that were essentially -experimentally restricted to to the bed -um is there something about being -horizontal that makes us -sleepy there is and it's perhaps not for -the reasons that you would think which -is okay I'm just pre-programmed when I -lie down and my head hits the pillow it -turns out that it seems to be -temperature that when your body is -recumbent lying flat -horizontal the distribution of how your -body is able to move blood around the -different regions and decrease your core -body temperature meaning it can push -blood warm blood out of the core of your -body to these surface areas and when you -push it out to the surface areas you -release that heat it's this huge thermal -dissipation that happens when we move -Blood Out Of The Core to the surface you -emit that heat and your core body -temperature plummets when your body -temperature your core body temperature -decreases you have a higher likelihood -of sleepiness in fact it's very -difficult for you to fall asleep if your -core body temperature does not drop and -by lying down the body's what we call -vasoactive ability to distribute that -blood in a way that is permissive for -thermal dissipation of core body -temperature is superior and that's the -reason why we find it easier to fall -asleep lying down than let's say -semi-recumbent or certainly propped all -the way up and it's probably the reason -naturally we evolve just to lie down on -the floor very -interesting maybe now is a good time to -talk -about basic sleep in the context of a -about of sleep at night and the -afternoon nap you've mentioned this -postp parial dip that most people -experience between 1: and 400 p.m. that -many people try and combat with caffeine -we will also talk about Caffe -uh this episode um such an interesting -substance and I think the most commonly -used drug it is a drug after all -worldwide I think more than -90% of adults worldwide consume caffeine -on a daily basis that's correct and I -believe it is after oil it may -be perhaps the second or at least the -third most traded commodity on this -planet and it is what we call a -psychoactive stimulant is a stimulant -and it's probably one of the only -stimulants that we will readily give to -our children and you know not be too -concerned about it we'll get to caffeine -in depth uh a little bit later in this -episode but I can't help but uh just -mention that someone I think it was -Michael Polland said that you know -caffeine is one of the few drugs that -almost everybody takes just to quote -unquote feel normal yeah exactly you -know it's sort of I think sometimes you -know sleep deprivation is is -simply just the absence of of caffeine -and um so it's a very interesting -chemical which I have in truth changed -my mind on and I'm happy to speak about -why I've changed my mind but also some -God rails too well we'll we'll go there -meanwhile I'll take a sip of my uh -Triple Espresso here as we discuss as we -discuss naps are naps good for us should -we nap what if we don't like naps why do -we wake up from naps groggy sometimes -and other times we feel refreshed tell -us about -napping naps are both good and bad -depending on the situation naps can be a -double-edged sword in other words we and -others have done lots of studies on naps -and the benefits are fascinating and St -I'll tell you about one study we did we -had participants assigned to one of two -groups and at midday they all learned a -whole list of new facts so it was a -study about learning in memory and then -one group took a 90-minute sleep -opportunity sort of focused right around -that drop in alertness the other just -remained awake lying on a bed and they -just watched a nature -documentary and then 5 hours later we -had them do another learning session and -so they've woken up after the 90-minute -nap they've got through that sort of -initial lull that we'll discuss what -that is after you wake up everyone's now -back to operating temperature so in -other words I've had you try to cram in -a whole list of facts at midday and then -a whole list of facts new facts again at -5 p.m. and I can ask what is the -learning capacity of your brain at -midday and at 5:00 p.m. and is there any -difference in your learning ability when -you have had a nap in between versus not -and sure enough what happened in the -group that did not nap their learning -capacity gradually declined across the -day the nap group they were able to -sustain their learning and in fact if -anything improve it and the difference -between those two groups at 5:00 p.m. -was about -20% so that's certainly non-trivial in -terms of if you to say you know here's a -new compound that can boost your -learning capacity by 20% would you take -it I suspect it would probably make some -money so that's a demonstration of for -learning in memory we did another study -very much like that in terms of its -design but we looked at your emotional -brain and we were showing people -different types of emotional expressions -and having them rate them and we did -that firstly before an appp and then -after a na versus um that same time in -sort of midday versus 5:00 p.m. and -another group did not nap and sure -enough the group that did not nap -by about 5:00 p.m. they were starting to -rate fearful faces and angry faces as -much more fearful and much more angry -but if you looked at the group that -napped it was different they actually -lessened the response to fear and they -blunted the normal increase in Anger -sensitivity across the day and the nap -seemed to boost how positively you rated -happy faces -so a nap there had the ability to reset -the magnetic north of your emotional -compass and there was a beneficial -almost added Rose tint to your world viw -glasses after You' napped what was also -interesting in those two studies two -different types of sleep were -transacting those benefits in the nap -group that was doing the learning the -learning benefit that they got wasn't -just about them napping and sleeping it -was about them having these sleep -spindles the more of those sleep -spindles that you had the greater the -restoration of your learning capacity -when you wake up for the emotional -recalibration that I described in the -nap that had nothing to do with sleep -spindles or even non-rem sleep it -required REM sleep to produce that -benefit so there are certainly many -benefits and we've look downstairs in -the body blood pressure cardiovascular -measures immune Health they all seem to -benefit so at that point everyone may be -thinking of course this sounds good not -to mention the basics which is your -attention your concentration your focus -and your energy all improve by way of -naps even your decision- making you said -decision making yeah even your -decision-making is improved so your -capacity to make the correct decisional -outcomes based on this weight of -evidence that you're facing that's also -improved so almost all areas of -cognition that we've looked at and many -areas of your emotional and mood Health -we've looked at seem to benefit by way -of a nap at that point you're thinking -so then what's the problem the problem -is that when you nap you release some of -that sleep pressure that's been building -up so in the first episode we spoke -about a chemical called adenosine and -the longer that you're awake the more -adenosine that builds up the more -adenosine that builds up the sleepy you -will feel and after about 16 hours of -being awake you should have lots of -healthy sleepiness of adenosine in your -brain to put you asleep and keep you -asleep and when we sleep we are able to -clear that adenosine from the brain so -we wake up after 7 to 9 hours and if -it's been good quality sleep we're -refreshed because we've cleansed the -brain in part of that -adenosine when you take a -nap like a pressure valve on a steam -cooker you just Rel relase some of that -healthy sleepiness that you've been -building up so the the Dark Side of -napping is if you are struggling with -sleep and you suffer from insomnia the -advice is do not nap during the day -because you're setting yourself up for -an even higher probability of failure at -night why because when you nap you -release some of that good sleepiness -that we need to build up for you as -someone who is struggling with sleep to -give you the greatest chance of awai of -sleepiness on your -shoulders so if you are not struggling -with sleep and you can nap regularly I -would say naps are just fine and we can -unpack what is an optimal nap and the -protocol for what napping should -be I would say that's great the only -caveat is make sure that you're not -napping too late into the day and this -is one of the components of the protocol -of how to nap because napping late in -the day is too close to sleep and you -can think of it almost like snacking -before your main meal a nap late in the -day just takes the appetite edge off -your sleepiness so that when it comes -time for sleep you're not as hungry -anymore so just keep that in mind but we -can unpack perhaps the optimal way to -nap if you are going to nap and exactly -the dos and the don'ts of that if that -sounds of somewhat interest yeah that is -uh of immen interest to me and I know -many other people I'm a huge believer in -naps I've always enjoyed um short naps -of about 10 to 30 minutes unless I'm -somehow sleep deprived in which case I -will sleep for an hour or even a little -bit more but I make sure I set an alarm -U really based on advice that you gave -me which was to um first of all decide -whether or not a nap is beneficial for -for for me or for whoever is considering -that um but then to make sure that -however long that nap is zero to 90 -minutes that it not be longer than 90 -minutes because the real goal is to not -disrupt nighttime sleep that's right -which is essentially just a a more -long-winded way of saying what you just -said so how does one determine the -optimal duration of nap um and in -particular to avoid the problem of -disrupting nighttime sleep by napping -but also this uh rather common -phenomenon of waking up and feeling kind -of groggy or even I'm kind of grumpy the -post-nap face uh or we should call the -post-nap expression -right right the P NE what's your P are -do you wake up um in the and for morning -too some people wake up and they're like -that that face and then there's the like -good morning you know and I think people -that wake up with the good morning are -particularly delightful unless you're of -the post Snap expression that is kind of -the the crumpled face and then you just -you don't want to be around those people -right no absolutely -um yeah and this probably relates to -spirit animals and things like that some -people wake up like a like a cheerful -chipmunk and other people seem to wake -up like my Bulldog Costello where it's -you know um jowls still in contact with -the floor yeah so um P I'm trying to -hold it together and not Absol just fall -apart it's brilliant please trademarket -so firstly to your question how to -optimally nap the word optimal is -interesting because -when you people say how long should I -nap what's the optimal nap duration the -question I have back to them is what are -you trying to optimize because once I -understand what you're trying to -optimize I can give you a better -prescription non-medical I'm talking -about here the a better sort of you know -protocol piece of advice for how to nap -I mentioned the study about emotional -faces in part for a specific reason cuz -I told you there the benefit came by way -not of non REM sleep but REM sleep and -in our first episode we said that when -you go through these on average 90minut -Cycles you get most of your non-rem -sleep first and then you'll have this -bout of REM sleep at the end and it -always seems to go that way when you are -a healthy normal person you go into -non-rem sleep and then you go into REM -sleep it's very rare that you ever go -directly into REM sleep there are only -two reasons when that seems to happen -the first is a clinical condition called -noopsy where you can have sleep onset -REM sleep and very rare the second is if -you are horrifically deprived of REM -sleep night after night after night and -I let you sleep then at that point REM -sleep the pressure for REM sleep has -been built to to the point of being -almost just insatiable and your brain -goes straight into REM sleep but with -those two things aside you go into -non-rem sleep first so I brought up the -emotional study of resetting your sort -of mood uh compass -because to get that REM sleep you had to -nap for a longer period of time because -you had to get through the non-rem sleep -first before you get the REM sleep but -let's come back to then assuming optimal -is for most people when they speak about -naps I just want the quick reboot I want -my alertness and concentration which are -failing because I'm staring at the -screen or I just can't concentrate on -the work that I'm doing I want my -alertness and my concentration to be -improved proved I want that sort of -slight boost in brain energy where I -know I can sustain myself for now a -longer period of time and I've got the -motivation which is really in some ways -how I like to think about energy as well -I've got the motivation the drive to -keep going which is just starting to -fail me to get those basic things which -is what most people nap for aim for 20 -minute nap why 20 minutes if I thin -slice the nap duration and and those -Studies have been done where we look at -essentially what's called a dose -response curve I give you 5 minutes of a -nap 10 minutes of a nap 15 minutes 20 -minutes 30 minutes 45 minutes 90 -minutes after 5 or 10 minutes you don't -really get very much you will wake up -and you'll have some degree of improved -alertness and your basic reaction time -may be a little bit quicker but that -Fades very quickly and you don't sustain -that -benefit once you get past about 15 to 17 -minutes now things start to look -different you get these nice benefits -for concentrational alertness and -motivation and those things sustain so -once you wake up out of that probably -really I would say 20 minute nap at that -point you've got some good wind in your -concentration and energy sales for the -brain and that will sustain you -throughout the rest of the afternoon and -into the -evening the benefit of the 20-minute nap -is that you don't get the -PNE trademark Andrew hubman you don't -get that almost sleep hangover so some -people will say it's strange I nap maybe -I'll nap 45 minutes 50 minutes and I -wake up and to be honest Matt I almost -feel worse after the nap than I did -before and I don't understand it it's -something called Sleep inertia -and an extreme version of this is in the -first two hours of your night of sleep -you get a phone call or an alarm goes -off and you wake up and you are just -kind of lost in the ocean you're looking -around at your surroundings you're just -in this groggy State you're half awake -half asleep and you can respond and you -can do things but boy does it feel -miserable and it's almost as though -you're going from the ground floor right -up to the penthouse suite but you get -stuck somewhere in between kind of you -know floor 13 and it's this rough -state if you go out into sleep light -stage one nonrem then stage two nonr and -just before you get into the very -deepest stages of non Ram 3 and four -that starts to happen around 30 to 40 -minutes for most people but by cutting -your nap off at 20 minutes you still get -these nice benefits from a good chunk of -healthy non-rem sleep but you're not -going so far into the cycle so deep into -your nonr that when you wake up after 20 -minutes you're not in that what we call -Sleep inertia phase that sleep -grogginess that sleep hangover phase so -it's a nice benefit that you get all of -these improvements in your brain but you -wake up and very quickly you're back up -to operating temperature and you don't -suffer that inertia now that's not to -say that when you sleep or you nap -longer -you don't start to get more benefits you -do and those benefits are both greater -in their magnitude and sustain for a -longer period of time they do it's just -that you have to understand the tradeoff -that you will suffer which is I will get -more bang for my book and I will get -more benefits but I will in the first -sort of hour or so have to understand -that at that point I may even be -functioning worse than than that which I -did before I even started napping but if -you're patient and you go through it the -rewards on the other side are -significantly better still so that's the -first piece of advice and when it comes -to how to nap I would say the dose and -the timing make the poison and poison is -hyperbole in here it's simply just the -poison being how much sleep and nurs -you're going to suffer so aim for about -20 minutes that's the do the timing -comes back to that which we described -before do not nap too late into the day -so what's the rule of thumb here for a -protocol on average for the average -adult I would say don't nap after about -300 p.m. 20 minute naps sometime between -300 p.m. and if you're struggling with -sleep don't do this at all if you're not -and you're able to get to sleep fine -this seems to be a good ingredient for -the basic return on your investment -again if you tell me what's the optimal -nap duration we need to have a -conversation to understand what is it -that you're going after here what are -the benefits and then I can sort of you -know create a finger Buffet Kaleidoscope -match to what you need and we can think -about the nap duration as a consequence -thank you that's very informative um I -have a colleague at Stanford who's a -Howard Hughes investigator which for -those that don't know is a a rather -elite club of uh academic research they -have to essentially try out for it they -can every 5 years they go up for Renewal -it's it's a lot of money which makes -gives them a greater capacity to uh take -on greater risk uh work higher risk work -um and he's also a member of the -National Academy and he was one of these -people that graduated high school at 15 -years of age one of these phenoms and he -is so religious about his napping such -that when he travels to give seminars at -other schools he insists that they -schedule a nap time for him after lunch -and in his office um you know at between -12:30 and and 1: p.m. he's napping -everyone knows this and um and I mention -this because I think that um oftentimes -people think of the Nappers as the lazy -ones but um his output is um near -superhuman and he attributes U much of -that output uh to the nap not just the -post-nap work that he's able to perform -but his ability to uh just kind of -manage so many ideas he has enormous -laboratory and that's just one example I -think there are examples from sport of -um sprinters taking naps on the you know -on the side of the the track field I -mean so it seems that a capacity to nap -is also something worth considering -because I think many people listening to -this are thinking well I can't nap -should I nap you know um and can one -teach themselves to nap so that's the -question um if one would want to explore -napping and um is that something that -one should even consider doing if you -don't have a propensity to nap should -you avoid it if you want to try naps how -could one teach oneself to nap you just -mentioned earlier uh lying down uh -relates to body temperature body -temperature uh relates to sleepiness and -then as a third question I promise I'll -repeat these if we need to uh as a third -question I'd like to have a little bit -of a discussion about some of the pseudo -naap states that um I certainly am -intrigued by you know for instance just -lying down and I'm doing a progressive -bodily relaxation things like Yoga Nidra -uh non-sleep deep rest which is an -acronym ioin simply to to um make it -clear what I was talking about but it's -very similar to Yoga Nidra um things of -that sort in other words but simply -should everyone think about having an -early to mid-afternoon -protocol to reset their cognition and -their body we call it a nap but does it -have to be a nap and if we're not good -Nappers should we try and if so how -should we go about it yeah so TI your -three questions firstly if you're not a -natural Napper should you start doing it -um if you want to start doing it how -should you do it and then the third is -is there some kind of you know -substitute for a like kind which would -be these Li these I I'd love the -phraseology that you use these Lial -states do they mimic that are they -different to that how should we think -about those the first thing I would say -to point number one if you are not a -natural Napper don't necessarily Force -yourself to be as long as you're getting -the sleep that you feel you need at -night and you feel refreshed and -restored during the day and you don't -have that sort of postrenal drop to the -point of thinking I almost need to nap -during the day there is no pressure -based on anything I've been telling you -for you to start napping nor should -there be any reason that you do start -napping but let's say that you want to -try what would be the right protocol to -improve and increase the likelihood -the best way you can do this is to mimic -nighttime as best you can so wherever -you are if you can shut off the -lights make sure that you can block out -you know curtains blinds if you can't do -that fully and many people won't be able -to develop an IM mask procedure um so -put an IM mask on make sure you block -out noise earplugs you can use a sound -machine if you want and we can speak -about sort of sound machines and whether -or not they're good or bad on sleep and -then you can lie down make sure that you -try to take your shoes off and get under -some kind of a blanket because we're so -Contex cued by having something wrapped -around us called a blanket or a duvet -that to do it without that if you are -not a natural Napper can help you again -that some people will say I can just -kick my feet up on my desk sit back in -my reclining chair in the office and I -can fall asleep that's great but if -you're not a natural person I'm just -trying to tell you things that increase -the probability of that and then set the -alarm I like your idea of making sure -that if you do fall asleep you don't -accidentally go too long and then just -feel miserable so mimic the conditions -that you're trying to get that you would -normally get at night that will increase -the probability mask out noise mask out -light kick your shoes off have some kind -of a blanket wrapping around you that's -probably the best and then time it based -on this sort of post pral drop you will -know yourself everyone has fallen prey -to it you know W it's usually around -about 3 4 p.m. that I do start to feel -this decline or it's around 1 p.m. try -to match it in accordance with that so -those are the first I think two -questions should you not necessarily if -you would like to and I'm not normally -doing it how can you do it the final -point I think is fascinating which is -these alternate states -of conscious brain activity the most -obvious is when we're awake and when -we're asleep those are the two most -dramatic changes in Consciousness that -we experience on a daily basis short of -anesthesia I've become like you very -fascinated by these sort of both -meditative States or these linal states -I think at some point you and I should -collaborate and we should do some work -and really unpack this but the reason I -find this interesting is because I'm -going to guess you are having sleep -likee States but you are not fully -asleep how would I Define a sleep-like -state what we've learned is that your -brain the way it sleeps isn't on mass -it's not as though your entire brain -sleeps different territories of your -brain can sleep in different -ways and what we've also known and -there's some argument even individual -brain cells seem to have a period where -they go into sleep and these individual -neurons will start to show what look -like these beautiful big powerful deep -slow waves in terms of their firing rate -at least in terms of those neurons -firing away I bring this up because if -that means that your brain can have -local sleep rather than Global sleep if -you are in global sleep you're out like -a light you are a sleep but perhaps -these Lial States the reason that they -give these benefits is because you are -still awake not Global sleep so if -you're in global sleep you're asleep but -you're awake so you're not in global -sleep but you may be having local sleep -now using special um setups in my -laboratory we can apply tens maybe -hundreds of electrodes all over your -head and we can map the the sort of the -the different places where your brain is -having sleep in much higher resolution -so rather than a you know 480 DPI movie -on YouTube I'm now in 4K resolution I -can really dismantle what's going on um -analytically in your brain I'm going to -guess that when you're going into these -states and you report coming out of -those states and I ask you on a scale of -1 to 10 how would you rate that as an -experience based on your common -experience the greater the intensity of -the lional benefit and state that you -experienced I'm going to predict is -directly related to the extent of this -this local deep non-rem slow wave sleep -that's happening you're still awake but -some parts of your brain for maybe -seconds of time or maybe even tens of -seconds of time I'm going to bed will be -oscillating in what look like slow wave -sleep deep sleep States and if all I -would be able to look at is that one -part of your brain and that small -cluster of electrodes and someone said -to me is this person awake or asleep I -would say oh they're asleep they're in -deep sleep but then if you slowly reveal -and back out and show me the rest of the -brain and what it's doing I would say oh -my goodness no this person must be awake -but that local territory that District -up there in their brain they were having -slow wave -sleep I think that's what we could find -and that may predict some of the -benefits that you get some of the -productivity energy benefits by the way -I should note that with all of this nap -racket NASA figured this out back in the -1980s they were looking at ways to -optimize their astronauts because when -you are up in orbit depending on what -orbit you're in you are rotating around -the planet maybe 10 and 20 times per 24 -hours so you're seeing 10 to you know 20 -sunsets and sunrises so your sleep is a -total mess and you can safety check -almost everything in terms of Technology -but the one weak Link in a space mission -is this thing called the human being -that's where errors typically happen so -how do you drisk a human error up in -space because if you make an error up -there I mean on the ground not great up -there kind of -catastrophic you can try to optimize -their ability to sleep and their ability -to maintain Focus concentration -alertness and productivity and what they -found was that these naps produced -almost a 20% boost in short naaps 20% -boost in their alertness and almost a -50% boost in their task productivity and -it was so powerful that it translated to -the terrestrial um employees of NASA on -the ground and it became what was known -as the NASA nap -culture and from there on we had what we -called power naaps Power naaps by the -way why are they called power naaps and -you think well just because it Powers me -up it's a good idea but it's wrong it -has a very specific story a fascinating -one two legends in my field David dingis -uh and Mark Rose kind they were looking -at how to instigate -risk mitigation not in astronauts but in -pilots who are doing long haul -flights because the most dangerous -aspect of a long haul flight is when it -is coming down to land and that's when -they can sometimes have these things -called a catastrophic hole loss which is -a euphemistic phrase for a terrible -plane crash and they were trying to say -how could you use nap -strategically to drisk that and improve -their -alertness and they asked a very -interesting question if they can nap for -only a certain period of time because -they have to be at work on the plane at -the for the rest of it when should you -place that nap should you do it at the -start of the long call flight in the -middle or towards the end and most -people would bet like they I think did -it's best to place it at the end when -you're really starting to struggle get -that boost and then you wake up you're -not in sleep in OA cuz it's been brief -and then you're energized for landing -they didn't find that they found that -the most optimal time to nap was early -on in that long haul flight and it -sustained them throughout the rest of -the flight now they took their findings -to the FAA who were funding the work um -and the Federal Aviation Authority here -in the United States and they said we've -got some great findings and we think we -should implement this and we would like -to use a term to help Pilots understand -this and it's called prophylactic -napping and of course there were many -Chuckles throughout the room perhaps -inappropriate and they just said look -you've got to understand our Pilots the -you know kind of alpha male guys and if -you're starting to say you need to -prophylactically NAB it's not going to -be adopted that's a nogo so they looked -around the room because it's an alpha -male culture it's a mostly masculine -culture at that time they said what -could we and there's a lot of beard -stroking and they said I've got it power -naaps it's got to be about power and so -that is where if you've ever wondered -where the term power naaps come from -it's not because it reboosts your power -which it does and boost it back up it's -because there was Chuckles at the time -prophylactic napping I'd like to take a -brief break and acknowledge our sponsor -eight sleep eight sleep makes Smart -mattress covers with cooling Heating and -sleep tracking capacity many times on -this podcast we discuss how in order to -fall and stay deeply asleep your body -temperature actually needs to drop by -about 1 to 3° and in order to wake up -feeling maximally refreshed and -energized your body temperature needs to -heat up by about 1 to 3° eight sleep -makes it very easy to control the -temperature of your sleeping environment -so that it's easy to fall and stay -asleep and wake up feeling refreshed I -started sleeping on an eight- Sleep -mattress cover several years ago and it -has completely and positively -transformed my sleep so much so that -when I travel to hotels or airbnbs I -really miss my eight sleep I've even -shipped my eight sleep out to hotels -that I've been staying in because it -improves my sleep that much if you'd -like to try eightsleep you can go to -8sleep.com -huberman to save $150 off their pod 3 -cover eight sleep currently ships to the -USA Canada UK select countries in the EU -and Australia again that's 8sleep.com SL -huberman the naming of things fascinates -me especially in um the uh landscape of -health and well-being um also um and -that's one reason why um having become a -real fan and practitioner of Yoga Nidra -which I think translates to yoga sleep -which is this process of lying down for -a period of 30 to 60 Minutes Progressive -relaxation this is these are scripts -that are readily available as this is a -a uh age-old practice um in in India um -that is meant to restore mental and -physical Vig Vigor by placing one into -one of these Lial States the um and I -have great respect for the uh ner -tradition um but um sometimes the names -are a separator so people who hear Yoga -Nidra and they think oh it must be yoga -movement and that's of course not true -or they think um that there must be some -mystical component to it which is not -necessarily true sometimes they include -intentions and things like that but -often not so that's why I coin this um -uh phrase non-sleep deep rest which is -essentially maintains the -critical components of Yoga Nidra um but -doesn't include intentions and um has -these shorter uh 10 or 20 minute um -protocols so it'd be um great fun and um -I think very interesting for us to do -that project to explore what are the -brains uh activation States or -deactivation States as the case may be -in these um non-traditional or Lial -State uh practices now um along the -lines of power napping specifically and -the naming of power napping I think it's -more than than just a a um anecdote -because I think it is very important for -people to understand that um that these -protocols these tools that NASA and that -Laboratories have have developed um -often times are are for other purposes -but they translate to a kind of broader -significance and what I'm hearing and -what I'm starting to integrate as we -have today's conversation is that it -seems that there is pretty good reason -to ex at least explore basic sleep right -that that for the non-nappers to to -really think about whether or not they -would like to explore napping as you -mentioned they don't have to and then -for people who are already um napping to -really think about the placement of that -nap uh within the day and the duration -of that nap what you told us a few -moments ago suggests that I should be -doing or anyone that's doing naps or -entering these Lial States like nsdr -might want to shift them a little bit -earlier than uh the period in which they -first become sleepy to take that nap is -that right I mean like so for instance -should I do as my colleague and you know -finish lunch and and lie down for 10 15 -minutes um rather than wait until 2 or 3 -p.m. is that is that something that that -could make a meaningful difference I -think it could and I think it really -again depends on how much of a struggle -sleep becomes in the evening for you if -it is becoming the later that you nap if -your sleep becomes either a more -difficult to initiate in the evening or -maybe you don't have any problems -falling asleep but for some reason when -I look back I'm now starting to wake up -more throughout the night that in part -again it's not just that if you nap late -in the day you struggle to fall asleep -you may not the other consequence that -can happen which is non-mutually -exclusive is that you then stay in not -as deep as sleep and your sleep is more -some more fragile in that sense so the -probability that you will wake up -because because you had the nap so late -in the day is higher in the middle of -the night and then when you wake up like -many of us do and you go to the restroom -or It's Perfectly Natural but the speed -with which you can then fall back asleep -is compromised why because you've -jettisoned some of that sleepiness by -way of the nap and there isn't as much -to take you back down into sleep after -you've woken up so I would just say that -if you are seeing that pattern that the -later napping that you're doing if -you're doing that and again there's no -reason that you need to nap only if you -choose to nap if that's the case then -consider not necessarily obviating the -nap that may not be required just bring -it back earlier take it after lunch see -how things work out do the experiment -and when you do the experiment make sure -that you do what I would describe as the -onof on experiment which is where you're -napping as you normally do and you've -noticed perhaps some problems with your -sleep then do so that's sort of the the -well it's sort of the on off on phase so -then change your nap protocol and move -it earlier so now you've Switched Off -Your Standard protocol and you've moved -on to something different so you're on -your standard protocol and then you come -off it and when you come off it meaning -you go to an earlier nap and you say -gosh things do seem to be better maybe -he he had something there and it does -seem to -improve good but I don't trust that -because maybe it's just a placebo effect -that you you know hear some dulit -British tones and you get convinced that -maybe that would work and you've now -instead after about two weeks of doing -that and things have improved go back to -your original schedule go back on to -your original protocol I'm not as -interested about the fact that things -got better when we changed it I'm -interested in the question do things get -worse when we stop it and so when we -stop the intervention if things got -worse again now I'm I'm believing it a -lot more so just as a tip if you are a -self- tinkerer and you don't have to do -that but if you're idiotic like me and a -scientist and you want to do it with -this city riger that's the way I would -suggest doing it I don't think it's -idiotic at all I think it's systematic -and what you just described is uh both a -negative control and a positive control -experiment so you're you are a scientist -through and -through are there any individuals that -should absolutely avoid napping you know -I'm heard lore of you know um elderly -folks um folks with certain conditions -um you know can't imagine um which but -um I'm sure you'll tell us that for whom -napping is harmful to their health it's -a very I think interesting question -because the strongest evidence comes -back to that which we we've mentioned -before which is insomnia and really the -recommendation there is just avoid naps -it's and what's problematic about -insomnia when you are having such tough -times with sleep at night and you are -just dragging through the day it is -miserable and I am you know I I'm very -protective of my sleep um for the most -part I -sleep pretty well but I've I'm I'm not -immune to the vagaries of sleep I've had -two bouts of insomnia throughout my life -both have been what we call reactive -insomnia reactive to an event or -something happening and I know how just -desperate and hungry you are for sleep -and if it's happening week after week -month after month I'll just do anything -to get sleep when I can and the -Temptation therefore to nap when you are -suffering from insomnia is that much -higher and therefore the advice is that -much harder to adopt but trust me that -is one of the components that we have in -the psychological treatment bucket that -we use for insomnia which is called -cognitive behavioral therapy for -insomnia or cbti for short and you can -just look it up or um on my own podcast -I done a six-part series on on uh -insomnia so I would say try to back away -in that circumstance but you brought up -a another example which is in aging -there I think the evidence is a little -less causal so you have to be more -cautious about recommending the absence -as I was with insomnia of abstaining -from naps but the data has now become -quite strong that when you get past -about 65 years old and you look at -napping behavior in large -epidemiological studies and you say is -there a positive benefit in aging for -napping or is there no benefit at all -and they looked at that because they -thought well that perhaps based on the -work in healthy adults that I've -described that would be good for older -adults not only did they find that it -wasn't good they found that it was -deleterious that napping in older adults -was predictive of worse Health outcomes -and it also seemed to predict a higher -likelihood of early -mortality so at this point we're -thinking well how does that fit with -everything you've been telling us it -comes back to this notion of bad sleep -at night it's probably not necessarily -that napping during the day is bad for -older -adults it's that the Naps reflect a -problem with the night of sleep for -older adults and as we get older -something I didn't mention during -development was that yes we get this -sort of State Lael ratio of 4 to1 of one -part REM sleep four parts non-rem in our -7 to9 hours and I described these -changes in rem early in development I -didn't mention two things about non-rem -slow wave activity first as we go into -our teenage years and we shift our sort -of timing of sleep where we want to go -to bed later and wake up later that's -biologically determined it's not -teenagers fault something happens with -their deep sleep however their deep -sleep starts to do a -different or different action to the -brain that REM sleep was doing as an -infant I said that during infancy we -have huge amounts of REM sleep and were -growing sinapsis syap Genesis and we -wiring up all of those new territories -all of these new neighborhoods with -fiberoptic cable but let's say that -you've now run the experiment across -many years through until teenagehood of -those neighborhoods and you've been -measuring the bandwidth consumption of -each individual house and you've started -to realize well I wanted to create a big -spread across the brain and then I'm -just going to let experience over the -next years time tell me which parts of -the brain seem to enjoy that high -bandwidth and which parts don't seem to -use it very much and as we go through -into our teenage years we go through -something called synaptic pruning where -the brain actually calls and takes away -copses from certain parts of the brain -it seems to be that this change in slow -wave sleep that happens around these -adolescent years is performing the act -of final cortical -maturation that it's downscaling the -synapses and fine-tuning the brain so -you've got this beautiful efficiency and -now you've throttled back some of the -bandwidth from some of those -neighborhoods because they just don't -use it very much and you can move it -over into the territories that are -demanding more bandwidth and net net the -brain is downscaled but it's improved -its efficiency in the sense that those -regions that need it and are working -hard based on what we think this -organism has been doing over the past -you know 13 years that's where we need -to now place our bets but as we get -through into our older years and this -will come back to this issue of napping -don't -worry stick with me here folks um the -reason is that as we're getting older -our sleep de -deines but it's not just all sleep -declines deep sleep declines most -dramatically and we all think of aging -from brain perspective as cognitive -decline that our learning and memory -abilities begin to fade and Decline and -they do but I would argue that a -physiological signature of Aging is that -your sleep gets worse and particularly -your deep sleep what's perhaps -concerning for people listening to this -right now is that that decline in deep -Sleep doesn't start happening in your -60s or your 50s or even your 40s we can -start to pick up that great sleep -decline beginning in your mid to late -30s and then it just decreases and by -age 50 you are down to about 50% of the -deep non-rem sleep that you were having -when you were 17 or 18 by age 65 and -over or certainly by age 75 you are down -to about just 5% of the deep sleep that -you had when you were 17 or 18 which is -a stunning -decline what that means comes back to -the first episode we spoke about the -four macros of good sleep quantity -quality timing and regularity one of the -measures of quality that I described to -you was this electrical quality of deep -sleep the other measure of quality sleep -I spoke about was how consolid ated and -consistent your sleep is versus how -fragmented your sleep is the measure of -Sleep Quality is markedly compromised as -we get older we're waking up many more -times our sleep is much more fragmented -and therefore our sleep efficiency is -worse and we've got this huge decline in -our deep non-rm sleep so no wonder then -when you are awake during the day as an -older adult Your Sleep Quality is so -compr promised at that stage you perhaps -try to compensate by way of napping but -that compromised quality of sleep that -you're having at night is probably the -reason that you start to get sick more -that you have a higher probability of -illness and disease and why also you -probably have a higher risk of premature -mortality so in other words it's the bad -quality of sleep at night that leads to -this behavior that we call daytime -napping in older adults -that seems to indirectly suggest oh my -goodness it's daytime napping that's bad -and that causes these problems when in -fact it's that daytime napping is a -proxy for the bad sleep that's happening -at night and it's really the bad sleep -that's happening at night that is more -directly related to the health and -mortality concerns in older adults so -that's why I think right now as a field -I'm still open to evidence that napping -for some reason that we just do not -understand right now is problematic and -does causally predict worse health and a -shorter lifespan in older adults I think -the best evidence that we have right now -is that it's actually the bad quality of -sleep at night and thus we should not be -necessarily jumping to recommendations -that all older adults should stop -napping I think we need more evidence -and I'm open to both sides of that let's -talk about caffeine uh I've heard the -ter term is it -napino yeah I I I think it um refers to -a practice of drinking some caffeine -then laying down for a nap and then -supposedly waking up um feeling more -refreshed my understanding and you'll -tell us more of course is that caffeine -um is effectively uh an adenosine -antagonist although it's a competitive -Agonist and you'll explain I'm sure um -and napping as you mentioned before uh -removes some of the Sleep pressure AKA -uh wipes away some of that uh adenosine -that's accumulated um both of which -sound great but as you mentioned earlier -there's a warning there as well uh the -warning label on uh both those things -should be that having sufficient -adenosine built up in your brain is one -of the ways in which you feel sleepy at -night and fall asleep and stay asleep -yeah so what's the story with caffeine -how does it work uh to make us feel more -alert and -um what is the rationale for the -nappuccino the nappuccino also known as -the caffeine nap caffeine is a very -interesting compound in relationship to -sleep and wake obviously everyone knows -that caffeine can help you stay awake -it's no coincidence that those two words -that you've used about these chemical -compounds caffeine and adenosine sound -the same it's because the re receptor -that or the receptor systems that -caffeine Targets in your brain are the -adenosine -receptors and you think well Matt was -telling me that the more adenosine that -builds up in other words the more -adenosine that's latching onto those -adenosine receptors in your brain the -sleepier that you feel and I'm telling -you that caffeine works on those same -receptors that doesn't make sense -caffeine if it's working on those same -receptors should increase your -sleepiness it doesn't because it when it -binds onto those adenosine receptors -those welcome sites in the brain it -simply blocks them it doesn't deactivate -them nor does it activate them it simply -blocks them so think about it almost a -little bit like um a room that's full of -chairs and at some point these adenosine -which is one collection of people with -the name badges of adenosine they would -normally like to come in and start -sitting down on those seats which are -the adenosine receptors and as they sit -down on those seats you're building up -this signal of sleepiness well caffeine -which is another group of people with -caffeine badges they race into the room -and they start to hijack the seats and -they start to sit down on them and all -of a sudden adenosine can't find any -seats to sit on so your brain is still -flooding that room with adenosine so the -adenosine is still building up but the -reason that you don't feel sleepy -anymore when you've had a shot of -caffeine is because caffeine is raced in -it's latched onto the -receptors and it has essentially hit the -mute button on your -sleepiness so now your brain was -thinking gosh I've been awake for about -13 or 14 hours I'm starting to feel it -I'm just going to take a quick espresso -shot and you get that you don't think -well hang on a second you know 20 30 -minutes later I don't feel as tied -anymore why it's not because caffeine -came in and removed the adenosine it -didn't caffeine has come in blocked the -sights but the the adenosine is still -building -up and then at some point the caffeine -wors off and therefore not only do you -go back to the same level of Denine of -adenosine that you did 2 hours ago it's -that plus the additional 2 hours of -adenosine that has been building up and -what you experience is something called -a caffeine crash and now you need even -more caffeine not just to get you back -to where you were but to recover the -crash that you've had and go -further caffeine in relationship to the -caffeine nap though the -napino is relevant because of its -timing caffeine has an instigating -action of around uh 12 14 to 17 minutes -so when you come through in the morning -and you grab your first cup of coffee -and within the first four or five -minutes you you say I just I just feel -better I've just had a couple of sips -I've had half a cup of coffee and I -already feel better I just needed that -if it's within the first five minutes -that you're experiencing that it's got -nothing to do with the caffeine because -the peak plasma concentration of your -caffeine is not going to arrive with you -until about you know 12 to 17 minutes so -why do you feel better some of it is -Placebo because you're smelling the -coffee and you associate it with the L -it's really not that though or or um -when you say Placebo I also wonder -whether or not it's possibly a a -conditioned effect you know like a -pavlovian thing because the smell of the -coffee the taste of the coffee the the -hum of the machine the walking into the -cafe -to to um and ordering it from the -Barista also creates an anticipatory -arousal like here the the alertness is -coming and in that anticipation there's -its own form of alertness I think that's -that's certainly a big component of it -the other component however if you look -at the data is that it's got nothing to -do with the caffeine in that moment it's -the temperature that most people take -their caffeine warm either it's tea or -it's coffee or it's perhaps something -else that Andrew hubman would drink but -many people yamate since since I was 5 -years old I don't I don't know if I -should have been drinking uh caffein -yerbamate so young maybe even four years -old there's a photo of me on my -grandfather's lap drinking out of the -mate gourd half my family is Argentine -and um so I was caffeinated from a young -age this brain developed in a -caffeinated millu this explains so much -about what I've known of you over these -no I'm kidding you um so um but we need -to speak later no so what's interesting -about that is it's the -temperature and I told you in the first -episode that we need to cool down -to stay asleep but we need to initially -warm up to fall asleep because warming -up at that moment I was telling you is -warming up at the periphery a warm up to -cool down to fall asleep so you need to -warm up to cool down to fall asleep then -you need to stay cool to stay asleep and -then you need to warm up to wake up the -warming up to cool down to fall asleep -is not warming up in the middle deep -core of your body it's about warming up -the hands and the feet and the head to -dissipate the heat hence warm up the -outer surfaces to cool down the inner -core to fall asleep but then I told you -you have to warm up to wake up and when -we take a hot drink in the morning -usually caffeinated the change in your -core body temperature can happen with -within a handful of minutes so the -initial benefit that you get from the -hot cup of coffee in the morning or hot -tea is from the temperature rise and -then you get this beautiful second kick -from the caffeine itself and that -caffeine can then sustain for a longer -period of -time so we mentioned this problem with -napping that even at 25 or 30 minutes of -a nap you wake up with that kind of -grogginess that sleep -inertia and what however if I could give -you the benefits of a nap and have you -come out of the nap with zero sleep -inertia and that's what some folks -started to cleverly think -about what if I could look at the timing -of the optimal nap maybe 20 minutes and -think about the timing of when Peak -plasma concentration of caffeine emerges -and I told you really starts to kick -into gear around 17 minutes and it's in -full swing by 20 what if I was creative -I'm going to withhold from saying -idiotic enough but creative enough to -get into bed just before I turn the -light out for my nap in the afternoon I -Swig a quick -espresso light goes -off I close my eyes eye mask earplugs -and I'm going to drift off fine because -the the caffeine is not going to kick in -and for another 17 20 minutes perhaps at -its full threshold so now you you fall -in to sleep and you're going down into -sleep and if you perhaps don't make it -too large in terms of its serving the -temperature change is not going to -affect you in a negative way and then -just as your alarm clock is about to go -off after 20 minutes you're on the -beautiful ascending swing of upward -plasma concentration of caffeine and you -get ejected out the other side with both -the benefits of the nap together with -the benefits of the caffeine so you get -your cake and you can eat it too you get -the nap absent the Sleep inertia and -hence this created what we call the -caffeine nap I love it the nappuccino -the the nappuccino um maybe I'll give it -a try uh this is the first time I've -ever heard the um the rationale and the -the the fine structure of the nappuccino -but it makes sense um uh at a logical -and mechanistic level I have to ask is -there anything besides caffeine and -sleep that can clear -adenosine you know can exercise clear -adenosine can uh cold shower clear -adenosine I mean and I understand that -there are a bunch of competing -mechanisms in the body like presumably a -spike in norepinephrine or adrenaline or -both is going to impact the adenosine -system I I once heard a great quote um -from a former uh -member of the National Academy of -Sciences a brilliant guy he said you -know a a drug is a substance that when -injected into an animal or a human -produces a scientific publication -meaning meaning it is it is rare to find -a paper that doesn't see some effect of -some drug especially on sleep I'm told -as I recall if you put aspirin REM sleep -into PubMed you're going to see some -effect on REM sleep people take aspir -pretty much any substance that one takes -is going to to alter um some feature of -sleep or of wakeful States if one is -looking with a fine enough uh instrument -or is that an overstatement no I don't -think it is an overstatement and it -comes back to the first episode where we -described the complexity this incredible -beautiful physiological ballet certainly -one of the recommendations when people -say I get this afternoon this post -prandy will drop in my alertness what -can I do I say you could nap but another -way is just get outside and walk around -be physically active some of that has to -do with the fact that you'll probably -get some daylight and daylight can be a -stimulator of alertness as long you've -told us and educated us on we also know -that physical activity by itself can -increase the amount of endorphins and -dorphin and those are wake promoting but -none of those are really necessarily -going to be altering adenosine they're -simply overriding the adenosine that is -still building up it really does seem to -be for the most part at least as all -that I know it's only sleep and -particularly non-rem sleep that has the -capacity to or give the brain the chance -to remove that adenosine now what could -be interesting I think is two -circumstances one is where your brain -becomes less metabolically active for -another reason and I told you that it's -not joring it's not as though during -deep non-rm sleep that there is some -special pulsing cleansing mechanism for -adenosine there is a cleansing system -called the glymphatic system which -removes the toxic metabolic byproducts -of the waking day wakefulness in some -ways is biochemically low-level brain -damage and sleep is sanitary salvation -in that regard knew um but which is -again it's humoristic and it's it's it's -going too far but it makes a point the -idea here however is that it's not that -there is a special system that is -removing the adenosine during deep nonm -sleep it's just that your brain is less -metabolically active and therefore it's -not producing as much adenosine so the -natural mechanisms that are always -occurring in the background to be -clearing adenosine and degrading it -simply get the chance to do that just as -effectively as they have but you're no -longer working against the opposite tide -that is growing the adenosine now the -adenosine increase has dissipated -because you're no long longer -metabolically active during deep sleep -and you get the chance to cleanse it all -of which is to say therefore that and I -think that would mimic that such as for -example anesthesia my guess is that you -probably do jettison some sleep pressure -when you are in -anesthesia I also think that these Lial -States non sleep deep rest could be a -fascinating territory there because at -that point I'm going to guess and we'll -be able to see with the e G and we may -also be able to do some Imaging -depending on how we you and I design the -study to look at what changes in the -brain in terms of its activation State -my guess is that if it does put you into -something like slow wave activity -patterns that means that those -territories of the brain are -metabolically less active and that -allows the brain to dissipate the -adenosine so to your point I don't think -things like necessarily exercise or -light change adenosine level -they do give a nice alertness benefit -for other reasons but is there an -alternative way of dissipating adenosine -yes I think anything that mimics a non -or a less metabolically active brain -could produce these beautiful adenosine -benefits thank you for that this brings -me to a question about the period -immediately after waking from the -nightly bout of sleep um I've been uh -touting the benefits of delaying one's -caffeine intake by 90 to 120 minutes -after waking there's a little bit of a -misconception out there I think people -um ran with the ball uh assuming that I -was mandating this or think or -suggesting that everyone should do this -and that's simply not the case uh I -actually wake up and I'll hydrate and -drink caffeine very close to waking if -I'm going to exercise soon after yeah um -which I often do um but I've experienced -and I know others um have experienced if -they are not going to exercise -immediately or they don't need caffeine -to exercise for whatever reason I've -heard these people exist I'm no such M -mutant um that delaying their caffeine -intake by 90 to 120 Minutes in some -cases can offset the afternoon crash now -I want to be clear some of that may be -offsetting the afternoon consumption of -more caffeine because by delaying your -caffeine intake in the morning then -perhaps there's less of an incentive or -requirement to drink caffeine in the -afternoon and all of which dominoes to -as we'll talk about more in the series -to better sleep at night because you -you're not ingesting caffeine close to -bedtime but at risk of taking a massive -tangent here's what I'd like to know -based on what you just told -us if -indeed -sleep and -lower metabolic activity in certain -brain regions can help reduce adenosine -levels in the -brain one could imagine that upon -waking it is either a step function from -okay you know let's say at um 5:45 a.m. -somebody is asleep and adenosine is -still being cleared away because they're -asleep and then they wake up boom does -adenosine clearance immediately stop -well for people who have that um -crumpled face uh grogginess um and they -wake up at 5:45 maybe even by way of -alarm although we don't uh suggest that -right and they stagger into the kitchen -and um ordinarily they'd make their cup -of coffee but they're in a pseudo sleep -state yeah so it stands to reason that -they're still clearing adenosine now if -they are to drink caffeine right away -then they're as you pointed out going to -block those adenosine receptors and -there's going to be a continued buildup -of adenosine as opposed to a clearance -of adenosine so this was um part not the -entire reason but part of the rationale -for suggesting that people at least -explore delaying caffeine slightly and -then there are things like the cortisol -rise and Etc but um does that kind of -framework at least make logical sense -that doesn't mean it would hold up in a -randomized controlled trial but given -that we're talking about essentially -zero risk protocols here um what are -your thoughts on that I think it is good -advice for people to test and it's good -advice for two reasons the first is that -which you describe in some ways by -taking caffeine on early and masking -that -adenosine also caffeine can make your -brain more metabolically active which -means that you're going to build up more -adenosine during the day which means -that sleepiness is going to arrive -earlier which means that perhaps that -postprandial drop is going to be you -know harsher and you're going to perhaps -then need to self-medicate with more -caffeine to and so goes the Vicious -Cycle so I think that's one thing to -keep in mind I think that's one -hypothesis I think the second hypothesis -for me or the second reason I would -advocate for that is if you've been -using caffeine that way for a long -period of time you may also be -masking the quality of your sleep -because you wake up you immediately -medicate with caffeine and you are alert -you're awake and you think well I -looking back on my night I'm awake now -after my caffeine and now is the -important part of that sentence I'm -awake now so there's nothing wrong with -my sleep is that true maybe it is maybe -it's not maybe if you abstain from -caffeine through and you have to get -through the detox period it's not going -to this is not the right test -immediately but do it for about two -weeks and then at that point once you're -free from the detox and the withdrawal -now you're in a somewhat naive state -where you're taking your caffeine on I'm -telling you to stop caffeine you're -taking it on at 11:00 after you've woken -up let's say 7:00 in the morning at that -point we've now got this nice Clear -Window that has been consistently -happening between 7 to 11: in the -morning and I'm going to ask you now do -you feel rested restored and refreshed -and can you operate with cognitive -acumen and -skill in those first morning hours now -don't forget we've got to get past the -natural sleep and Heria period in the -first 90 minutes but after the first 90 -minutes of waking up absent of caffeine -let's say by 900 a.m. in the morning are -you functioning well because if you're -not and you still think you know what I -don't feel restored by my sleep I feel -unrefreshed I want to then start asking -you let's take a look at your sleep and -let's see how we can get you to a more -refreshed state -and by using caffeine first thing in the -morning you don't give yourself the -chance to test whether or not -subjectively you sense your sleep is -good quality now you don't need to do -this forever you can just do a test for -a month and be asking that question and -if all is clear after you've got through -withdrawal and you've got past the first -90 minutes after waking up and you tell -me now in this more caffeine naive state -in the first few hours I feel rest I -feel refreshed I feel restored by my -sleep then that's great we don't need to -be concerned about your sleep so that's -the second reason I like it because it -gives you the opportunity to test out -whether or not your sleep is of good -quality or not I should also note by the -way that I mentioned I've changed my -mind on caffeine and its use and this -comes back to I just raise it because -you had said I made this suggestion and -it wasn't binary it wasn't dictatorial -you don't have to to do it I wasn't -saying that everyone needs to do it and -in fact even I will you know tweak my -schedule if I'm doing one thing in the -morning I will take on board caffeine -fairly soon if I'm not I will hold -off I came out the gate when I first -published um a book and it and I was -very dictatorial about it I and I was -very mono I was very binary you know it -was sleep is absolute and it's -it has to be this way and no other way I -was not in favor of caffeine and I was -telling people about the dangers and -there are dangers to your sleep and we -we can speak about those but it was a -little bit too -heavy-handed I've changed my mind for at -least two reasons -first that's not the way Society works -or people live so there's no amount just -like technology in saying leave your -phone outside of the room for 2 hours -before bed and don't check it for the -first 4 hours that that Genie is out the -bottle so the reason I have changed my -mind on caffeine is because if you look -at the data on on caffeine it's stunning -for -Health it on almost every metric that we -can measure drinking some degree of -caffeine is beneficial now there is a I -knew it there is a U-shaped function to -this which is once you get past sort of -three or four cups of coffee then you -start to go in the downward Direction -and things aren't so great the -contradiction however was that I was -telling people caffeine not good for -your sleep and sleep by the way is -wonderful for Health it transacts all of -these benefits that we have and will -discuss in this series but then you -compare that relative to caffeine and -caffeine transacts many of the same -health benefits so how can you explain -that Mr sleep -scientist well if you look the the data -is very clear it's not the caffeine -that's the benefit most people take on -board caffeine by way of a cup of -coffee and the Coffee Bean is Pack full -not just of caffeine it contains a -whopping dose of -antioxidants and because of our -deficient Western diets were so absent -of these -antioxidants that the humble cup of -coffee has been asked to carry the -Herculean weight of our antioxidant -needs on its shoulders so no wonder it -by itself carries such a strong Health -signal because it's providing you with -this wonderful dose of antioxidants in -addition to caffeine case in point if -you look at decaffeinated coffee you -still get the antioxidants but now now -you don't get the caffeine and lo and -behold you get many of the same health -benefits it's not the caffeine it's the -coffee itself so I think that is a a -perfectly good reason to justify -caffeine but again just like naps the -dose and the timing make the poison if -you're not someone who's sensitive to -caffeine then having a couple of cups of -caffeine and trying to step away from -the use of caffeine I would argue -somewhere between 10 to 12 hours before -you expect to go to bed depending on -your sensitivity and it is different -across people and we know that it's -genetic there is a specific um what we -call polymorphism which just means A -variation in a particular Gene and if -you look at variations in that it will -predict whether you are someone who is -very sensitive to caffeine or not very -sensitive to caffeine and it comes down -to how quickly you can essentially -metabolically remove that caffeine from -the system so if you know that you're a -very sensitive person I would probably -argue try to stay clear maybe 12 to 14 -hours if you're someone who is not as -sensitive then you could maybe go to 8 -hours the danger is for people who say -look I'm one of those people who is you -know really just not sensitive to -caffeine at all and I can have an -espresso with dinner and I fall asleep -fine I stay asleep fine so it's really -not a problem for me I would say that -that that may be true but the inherent -danger here is that and we've done these -studies if I give you a dose of let's -say 200 300 400 milligrams of of -caffeine in the hours before bed which -would be a large you know strong cup of -coffee or you know two espresso with -dinner some people can fall asleep and -some people stay asleep but the amount -of deep sleep that they have is -compromised in fact it can drop your -deep sleep by up to 20% now the danger -is that you wake up in the morning and -there was no signals in your sleep that -said you had problematic sleep because -you're not aware of how much deep sleep -that you had that's the reason that I -think you know sleep trackers can be -helpful in some ways but you then wake -up and you don't feel as refreshed and -restored but you don't remember having a -hard time falling asleep or staying -asleep but now you find yourself -reaching for three cups of coffee to -wake up in the morning rather than the -standard two and so goes the Vicious -Cycle -so and also you see an interesting -interrelationship we did a recent study -we just published in Wall Street Traders -it's not just caffeine use it's also -about alcohol use in the evening that -people who overmedicate with caffeine -during the day they then need something -to bring them down at night and the -principal depressant agent and -depressant not in the sense of -psychiatric depression but in the sense -of brain neural activity depression is -is alcohol so you get this classic cycle -of uppers and downers I need my uppers -during the morning my caffeine and I -need my downers at night to lull me into -sleep and it's this really interesting -trade-off which we we saw in these Wall -Street Traders so coming back to the -notion of caffeine though I am favorable -of it in terms of its health benefits I -think it's very very clear just be -mindful of the dose and be mindful of -the timing dose try to not exceed about -three cups of coffee timing understand -your sensitivity there are certain -genetic tests if you really want to get -nerdy that will tell you if you have -this sensitivity or not but you will -probably know it and therefore just say -okay I'm not that sensitive I could -probably go 8 hours or as close as 8 -hours before sleep or 10 hours if you're -very sensitive 14 15 hours and keep it -to one cup um so those are the ways that -I would see moderating caffeine and -changing my my mind on caffeine which -just comes back to your point where you -were saying I made this recommendation -about caffeine I want to make sure I -modify that so people don't get confused -I certainly um needed to make a -modification to my stance on caffeine so -thank you for letting me say that which -is a long uh winded way of of getting -around it but does that help a little -bit that does help it um very much thank -you for that um addendum to the -legislature -[Laughter] -okay so you told us about the power nap -and you've told us about the caffeine -nap the so-called napino yeah what are -some other types of naps that can be -beneficial for Sleep awake cycles and -alertness so you can think about the -caffeine nap as trying to amplify it -sort of a nap plus as it were but to -your question the study that comes to -mind there was a brilliant investigation -Herculean in its study design from a -great sleep research group out in Japan -and they asked okay the nap is good the -caffeine nap may be a little bit better -but can we go -further um and so they designed a series -of studies they had five different -experimental groups and they tried to -basically create a stack a stacking -system they had across the 5 groups -there was a non naap group that's the -control then there was a nap group then -there was a nap plus caffeine group then -there was a nap Plus Cold face and cold -handwashing immediately after you wake -up I'll come back to explain why that we -think that works and then the final -group was a group that was a nap plus -bright light and again thank you uh me -offering this as the general public to -you Andrew hubman for for your light -Revolution so it was bright light at -2,000 looks immediately afterwards so -they had five groups again there was no -nap group nap group nap plus caffeine -nap plus cold hands and face washing nap -plus immediate brightlight the cold -hands and face washing is interesting I -told you before that there was this -three-part story to to the sleep wake -equation that you need to warm up to -cool down to fall asleep stay cool to -stay asleep warm up to wake up and I'm -saying warm up to wake up but use cold -water on your face and your -hands don't forget that warming up when -I say it in the morning is warming up at -the central core of your body you -reverse engineer what you did in the -evening I said warm up to cool down to -fall asleep so you warm up the periphery -to release the blood from the core and -you cool down well the reason that they -use cold hand and face -washing was because that's this vascular -surface it's the place where we can -modulate temperature quite quickly the -cold water on the face and the hands -therefore caused Vaso -constriction the the vessels and the -capillaries there they all scrunched up -and they force the blood back down into -the core of the body so the core body -temperature increase a little bit now -you also get a bit of an adrenaline shot -when you're splashing very cold water on -your hands and your face so there's some -of that too but that's the justification -so what they find firstly they were -measuring different aspects of your -cognition and your mood and your -sleepiness those were the outcome -measures to assess how did these five -different experimental groups change and -you can imag I mean this is I don't -think I would ever take on a study where -I'm doing five nap groups all within one -study it's bloody amazing so they did -the nonap group and then compared to the -nonap group The Nap group got a -wonderful benefit just as we described -and they showed benefits in their -alertness in their cognitive performance -and also they showed a reduction in -their sleepiness so Point number one on -the scoreboard for a nap then they did -the nap plus the -caffeine and sure enough you got an -added benefit to that which you already -obtained from the nap now it was nowhere -near as sizable as the benefit from the -nap so the addition of caffeine does -give you some nice benefits and I've -used this before when I've worked with -sort of professional athletes we do -instigate these nap um these caffeine -naps when needed so it did give a nice -benefit but then when they looked at the -nap Plus Cold hand and face washing and -the nap plus the bright light those also -added something to The Nap benefit now -they didn't do the sixth Group which is -really what I'm going to do some hand -waving about which is the full St stack -full fat method where they said okay -you're going to do nap plus caffeine -Plus Cold hand and face washing plus -bright light but if you were to put -those together my thought is that -they're probably additive rather than -simply just you know netting each other -out which means that if you really want -to not just do a nap or a nap plus which -would be the the Caffe nap but the nap -plus plus version you can lean into this -study and the protocol there would be -you get into bed you have your espresso -shot before you turn the light you Swig -it go down set your alarm for 20 minutes -you wake up the caffeine is kicking in -you get over the inertia you go straight -out cold hands cold face by way of cold -water and then you get immediate -daylight for 5 to 10 minutes outside and -at that point you're really in a -supercharged state so that's if you just -because I know there's probably going to -be some audience members who are willing -to give this a try or who really want to -optimize don't give me you know what is -good give me the extreme very best -that's the only suggestion I would have -based on that data I love it and -actually what you just described could -easily be um translocated to the uh the -period after uh waking from the nightly -bout of sleep although one wouldn't -ingest caffeine prior to waking up for -obvious reasons um but it would make -good sense to me to uh wake up obviously -get sunlight in one's eyes um splash -some cold water in one's face or hands -or get cold shower cold plunge um -caffeine or delay caffeine I mean it's -essentially the same set of tools and I -think it really um points to the fact -that circadian rhythm clearance of -adenosine uh temperature modulation and -of course the the way in which these -interact um are really the the levers -and and knobs to to modulate wakefulness -yeah it's it's so it there are I think -we've gone over this notion of naps but -there are ways that you can try to -manipulate the nap system still and -there are ways that you can manipulate -it even further but I like what you're -saying because it just comes back to the -fundamentals let's let's forego the the -nap conversation just go back to the -morning routine you're absolutely right -and think about the cold water and -warmart my guess is that very few people -when they go to bed -they wash their face and their hands -maybe they're probably not washing it -with cold water before they go to bed -correct they're going to be washing it -with warm water why don't they do that -and they just say well why would I -Splash cold water on my face you know -probably wakes me up you ever thought -about why it wakes you up part of it is -the you know the shot of activation but -the other part is Thermo regulation and -the opposite is what what you want to do -if anything you want to be warming your -hands and your feet and that's exactly -what you've always done you've always -medicated your sleep onset by using warm -water on your face and your hands -several times during today's discussion -we talked about polyphasic sleep um and -the different types of polyphasic sleep -that we covered are I wouldn't say -conventional but they're um conventional -is what are some of the more um esoteric -or let's call them high performance Pol -polyphasic uh strategies uh for sleep so -we've spoken about polyphasic sleep in -the natural way it occurs which is -during infancy and sleeping like a baby -means that you're sleeping in a highly -polyphasic way but probably around about -the late 1990s 2000s with the emergence -of the biohacker movement and the -Quantified -self-movement there started to become a -lot of chatter online about this notion -of polyphasic sleep and here no longer -are we infants we're now adults but -we're engaging in a pattern that is -highly -polyphasic polyphasic sleep simply by -definition again means that you're -having multiple phases of sleep within a -24-hour period And there are different -strategies so the way polyphasic sleep -in adults works is that you take the -24-hour period and you think about it -like a pie chart and then you start to -slice that pie up into these quadrants -when it comes to polyphasic sleep the -goal is to put insert multiple phases of -sleep around the 24-hour clock rather -than one single phase but the thinness -of those slices of the pie are very thin -leaving large thick slices of -wakefulness in between the notion that -being that if you were to sort of just -intersperse Little soupson of sleep in -terms of these little thin slices of -sleep you can increase the amount of -time that you're awake and you can -increase all of the benefits of a wake -so if you look at the there is a website -I think it's called the polyphasic -society and there it's not a scientific -Society like the you know psychological -the American Association for uh -psychology or medical um American -Medical Association or British medic -it's not one of those ratified certified -scientific or medical it's just society -that lives online which is great and -they make claims to suggest that -polyphasic sleep can improve aspects of -your mood it can improve aspects of your -productivity it can maybe even improve -aspects of Health I think sometimes -there are claims that it can help with -lifespan and there are a number of -different schedules that they will -describe to you and that you can find -out there of polyphasic sleep there is -is the first one that probably people -have heard of is called the uberman -schedule and by the way there is no h at -the start of that it is simply you I -know it's not this man sitting across -from me who has anything to do with this -schedule and after we discuss the data -he will um reassert that very same fact -then there's something called the -Everyman shedule and then there is the -triphasic schedule and there's lots of -different other flavors of this the -differences between them are in how you -split up that pie chart and how much you -assign to little thin slices of sleep -versus longer periods of wake and how -many of those you insert but they all -follow the same pattern if you look at -the literature however it didn't begin -with the biohacker movement the first -description I can find in the human -record comes from Time Magazine an issue -in -1943 and they describe the protocol of -at the time a fantastic very interesting -designer a guy called book Minster -Fuller and he created a design principle -and that design principle was called the -daxian principle the daxian principle -was principally used initially to build -unique building structures and it uses -this notion of different sort of almost -spokes that interconnect in a central -Hub that create a self-supporting -structure are the most obvious have you -ever been to one of those geodesic domes -and inside you go in it's like a -botanical garden and it's all tropical -despite you being in a let's say being -in England in London and is beautifully -tropical inside of that that structure -that sort of latis structure that comes -in part from his Design This was the -daxian principle and he scaled it to -different things the daxian car the -daxian house the daxian Dome it -fascinating -but he was no fan of sleep and he saw -sleep as a rather significant waste of -time when just like the rest of his -daxian principle he could be harnessing -more efficiency out of the system with -less structure and here less sleep -structure inserted into his 24-hour -period so he was the first one to -describe his schedule and it was called -the daxian schedule of polyphasic sleep -so it may have been a practice earlier -in the record but that's the earliest -one I can find so let's come back to the -claims of polyphasic sleep that it could -improve let's say your mood or your -cognition or your productivity or your -health the a group of scientists at -Harvard some of my old colleagues um -from Harvard they looked at all of the -literature on all of the stes that were -polyphasic like or testing this -claim and the first thing that they -found was to their claims of improved -cognition productivity mood as well as -health they found no supportive evidence -that polyphasic sleep was helpful then -they turned the tables and they said -well could it be hurtful and in fact -that's exactly what they found firstly -the total amount of sleep that you get -on any one of those schedules is -decreased significantly now of course -that's the goal the quality of sleep -that you get though is miserable your -sleep efficiency even when you're having -these short periods of time especially -during the waking hours is very poor -it's not a type of even short sleep that -you would wish for third they found that -it would reduce your REM sleep amounts -so that was the first set of findings -your sleep is no better if anything it's -significantly worse and then they -started to find that there were -significant impairments in many of those -things impairments in cognition in -judgment making and decision- making -impairment in mood and some aspects of -impairment in metabolic Health -particularly glucose -regulation so when it comes to -polyphasic sleep sleeping like a baby if -you're an adult seems to be a rather -unwise piece of advice now yeah I mean -it probably goes along with eating baby -food drinking breast milk and um and uh -having somebody else uh clothe and -change you as an adult it's probably uh -not advisable -it doesn't seem to be at least supported -by the data and again I want to be so -careful here and you're very careful too -I'm not here to necessarily tell anyone -absolutely how to live their life I'm -just a scientist and all I can do is -give you the information just as you do -and then it's up to you to make the best -decisions that you wish to make all I -would say is that I would hope that as -long as you're not hurting yourself and -harming your health and you're not -hurting other people then and it makes -you happy then I say whatever it is in -life good luck I I embrace it I always -say uh do as do as you wish but know -what you're -doing and don't hurt yourself or anybody -else can you get me that T-shirt and I -will wear it five days through Tuesday -so here in this regard though I would -say the evidence would suggest that -maybe you're compromising your health -and your Wellness but that's your choice -voice and I understand it so again no -judgment to the question however of as -long as you're not hurting other people -here I would say that there is a pause -of a caution because what we know is -that when you're not getting sufficient -sleep I described all of the health -consequences in the first episode -there's another danger here which is -road traffic accidents and we describe -these micro sleeps that happen and why -car accidents that are caused by -sleepiness can be so catastrophic -there's a very interesting study that -was done where they looked at people -getting less than 6 hours of sleep for -several nights and they put them into a -driving simulator and they asked what is -the probability that you have a crash or -an off-road event and sleeping less than -6 hours a night resulted in a 30% -increase in you getting into a car -crash now the AAA release some data -showing that when you get down to 5 -hours of sleep there is I think it's -something like two Three Times Higher -likelihood of an accident based on real -data and then when you were on 4 hours -of sleep it was close to a 10 times -greater risk so in other words the less -and less sleep that you get it's not a -linear increase in your risk of a car -accident it's an exponential increase so -I bring this back to polyphasic sleep -because I don't know you know think -about that 30% study let's not go to the -extreme just less than 6 hours of sleep -if this evening you call a taxi and it -turns out two taxis turned up and -outside of your door I said look one of -these two ta you can choose either one -of them but I'll just tell you that one -of these taxis has a 30% higher -likelihood of getting in a crash -relative to the other and it's this one -on the right which would you like to -pick which would you like to put your -wife and children in to S it's very -obvious so I rais that question just to -be mindful no one would wish to cause -harm on someone else to C carry the harm -of someone else by way of your own doing -on your shoulders for the rest of your -life is not one I would wish for and -it's not one that you would wish for -that's the only cautionary note but -other than that I would say you know -sort of live life to the full well that -brings us to the conclusion of yet -another incredible Voyage into the -landscape of sleep most notably on the -different phases monophasic biphasic and -polyphasic sleep -and naps and caffeine and all of their -interactions these are such important -topics at the level of Concepts the -level of mechanisms and as you've also -beautifully described at the level of -protocols that is actionable tools that -people can apply so thank you ever so -much Matt for taking us even further -along this Voyage I'll just remind -people that episodes one and two of this -series that U Matt is uh so generously -providing information about sleep for us -are out and those can be accessed -through links in the show note captions -um those fill in yet other mechanisms -and aspects of sleep and I'm also -particularly excited for the fourth -installment in this series coming up -about the relationship between sleep -memory and creativity so just incredibly -important topics relevant to everybody I -also just want to make note that I -really appreciate you highlighting some -of the develop velopmental shifts that -occur with sleep I often get questions -about um you know sleep in children and -babies and uh elderly adults as well as -um all the ages in between and you've -just um built this incredible tapestry -of of information for people to think -about and act upon should they choose so -thank you Matt ever so much and I look -forward to episode four Andrew thank you -it is such a privilege and it remains -just my absolute Delight to be here with -you thank you thank you for joining me -for today's episode with Dr Matthew -Walker to learn more about Dr Walker's -research and to learn more about his -book and his social media handles please -see the links in our show note captions -if you're learning from and or enjoying -this podcast please subscribe to our -YouTube channel that's a terrific zeroc -cost way to support us in addition -please subscribe to the podcast on both -Spotify and apple and on both Spotify -and apple you can leave us up to a fstar -review please also check out the -sponsors at the beginning and throughout -today's episode that's the best way to -support this podcast if if you have any -questions for me or comments about the -podcast or topics or guests that you'd -like me to feature on the hubman Lab -podcast please put those in the comment -section on YouTube I do read all the -comments on many episodes of The hubman -Lab podcast we discuss supplements while -supplements aren't necessary for -everybody many people derive tremendous -benefit from them for things like -improving sleep for hormone support and -for Focus to learn more about the -supplements discussed on the hubman LA -podcast go to live momentous spelled o -us that's Liv mous.com huberman if -you're if you're not already following -me on social media I'm hubman lab on all -social media platforms so that's -Instagram X LinkedIn Facebook and -threads and on all those platforms I -discuss science and science related -tools some of which overlaps with the -content of the hubman Lab podcast but -much of which is distinct from the -content covered on the hubman Lab -podcast so again it's hubman lab on all -social media platforms if you haven't -already subscribed to our neural network -newsletter our neural network newsletter -is a zeroc cost newsletter that provides -podcast summaries as well as protoc -calls in the form of brief 1 to -three-page PDFs that cover everything -from neuroplasticity and learning to -sleep to deliberate cold exposure and -deliberate heat exposure we have a -foundational Fitness protocol and much -more all of which again is completely -zero cost you simply go to huberman -lab.com go to the menu tab scroll down -to newsletter and by supplying your -email you can subscribe I want to point -out that we do not share your email with -anybody thank you once again for joining -me for today's discussion all about -sleep with Dr Matthew Walker and last -but certainly not least thank you for -your interest in science -[Music] \ No newline at end of file