id
stringlengths
33
33
doc_url
stringlengths
33
33
title
stringlengths
13
211
publication_date
timestamp[s]
update_date
timestamp[s]
authors
stringlengths
6
16.6k
category_primary
stringclasses
60 values
category_all
stringlengths
5
132
abstract
stringlengths
123
1.99k
embeddings
listlengths
768
768
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01334v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01334v1
Augmenting NER Datasets with LLMs: Towards Automated and Refined Annotation
2024-03-30T12:13:57
2024-03-30T12:13:57
Yuji Naraki, Ryosuke Yamaki, Yoshikazu Ikeda, Takafumi Horie, Hiroki Naganuma
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.LG
In the field of Natural Language Processing (NLP), Named Entity Recognition (NER) is recognized as a critical technology, employed across a wide array of applications. Traditional methodologies for annotating datasets for NER models are challenged by high costs and variations in dataset quality. This research introduces a novel hybrid annotation approach that synergizes human effort with the capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs). This approach not only aims to ameliorate the noise inherent in manual annotations, such as omissions, thereby enhancing the performance of NER models, but also achieves this in a cost-effective manner. Additionally, by employing a label mixing strategy, it addresses the issue of class imbalance encountered in LLM-based annotations. Through an analysis across multiple datasets, this method has been consistently shown to provide superior performance compared to traditional annotation methods, even under constrained budget conditions. This study illuminates the potential of leveraging LLMs to improve dataset quality, introduces a novel technique to mitigate class imbalances, and demonstrates the feasibility of achieving high-performance NER in a cost-effective way.
[ -0.5650379061698914, -0.3922235667705536, 0.08485337346792221, 0.011663144454360008, -0.3959009647369385, 0.5310962796211243, -0.2795064151287079, -0.9647891521453857, 0.5564149618148804, 0.6925099492073059, -0.2672334313392639, -0.4216117858886719, -0.5153301358222961, 0.49733901023864746, -0.3696820139884949, 1.05721914768219, -0.03681545332074165, 0.16596584022045135, -0.29527661204338074, -0.4143659770488739, -0.3557162284851074, -0.6698755621910095, -0.6930395364761353, -0.6869324445724487, 0.5085077285766602, 0.13991455733776093, 0.6051617860794067, 0.626397967338562, 0.5555601119995117, 0.2228023260831833, -0.12175939977169037, 0.5775325894355774, -0.082057885825634, 0.10210637003183365, -0.058438777923583984, -0.31814637780189514, -0.6080493927001953, -0.11148174852132797, 0.9029212594032288, 0.7427031397819519, 0.029438327997922897, 0.08984458446502686, 0.19220513105392456, 0.44434282183647156, -0.64701908826828, 0.039706502109766006, -0.722525954246521, 0.050068892538547516, -0.4852747619152069, -0.29632365703582764, -0.2306143045425415, -0.13523800671100616, 0.16072788834571838, -0.7071294188499451, 0.03702215850353241, 0.22593136131763458, 0.931348979473114, 0.4571579098701477, -0.16606219112873077, -0.017962241545319557, -0.8132089376449585, 0.6851292252540588, -0.7594183087348938, 0.23529139161109924, 0.2191256582736969, 0.1699659824371338, -0.17271097004413605, -0.40291744470596313, -0.7008428573608398, 0.0363616906106472, -0.31527045369148254, -0.0833357647061348, 0.044549211859703064, 0.058068446815013885, 0.4100251793861389, 0.6574890613555908, -0.15321679413318634, 0.5361778736114502, -0.14851100742816925, -0.41264399886131287, 0.6804207563400269, 0.1270839273929596, 0.41795241832733154, -0.06991273909807205, -0.45681455731391907, 0.061526428908109665, -0.6554991602897644, -0.15919062495231628, 0.4594208002090454, 0.5033612251281738, 0.0515969842672348, 0.8129225373268127, -0.2944266200065613, 0.749357283115387, -0.19766215980052948, -0.2599790692329407, 0.5777595043182373, -0.25487157702445984, -0.261305570602417, 0.27106502652168274, 0.7281591892242432, 0.41449373960494995, 0.3016154170036316, -0.23645497858524323, -0.6087167263031006, 0.14648400247097015, -0.011673533357679844, -0.5057918429374695, -0.2321947067975998, -0.014985363930463791, -0.12118435651063919, -0.34014949202537537, -0.13855266571044922, -0.929880678653717, -0.6434841156005859, -0.6666651964187622, 0.45494532585144043, -0.22712427377700806, -0.2860274910926819, -0.06632811576128006, -0.02133610099554062, 0.21266518533229828, 0.4345546364784241, -0.78322833776474, 0.5616186857223511, 0.6815293431282043, 0.7474108338356018, -0.2582114040851593, -0.05277165025472641, -0.4265712797641754, 0.2526146173477173, -0.029367489740252495, 0.8674182295799255, -0.5434163212776184, -0.19742776453495026, -0.30356329679489136, -0.25670719146728516, 0.01429491676390171, -0.8562391400337219, 0.4935407042503357, -0.5512692928314209, 0.06645923107862473, -0.037713441997766495, -0.7135321497917175, -0.2276759147644043, 0.22340814769268036, -0.8819770812988281, 1.3903528451919556, 0.05597585812211037, -0.9157890677452087, 0.6558095216751099, -0.4582875967025757, -0.52960604429245, 0.5433575510978699, -0.3232574164867401, -0.47061386704444885, -0.007817085832357407, 0.5355329513549805, 0.3310091197490692, -0.3750206530094147, 0.500637412071228, -0.1303609013557434, -0.3398367464542389, 0.2507680356502533, -0.16216488182544708, 0.41360849142074585, -0.1334347277879715, -0.28825080394744873, -0.02728627249598503, -1.0192406177520752, -0.0624244287610054, 0.04055933654308319, -0.4324771761894226, -0.6688279509544373, -0.0563541054725647, 0.22739377617835999, 0.16029883921146393, 0.13999217748641968, -0.4735894203186035, 0.09864582866430283, -0.5502821207046509, 0.23446205258369446, 0.535045325756073, 0.015283824875950813, 0.5145562291145325, -0.353250652551651, 0.2985037565231323, -0.1067928746342659, -0.19047047197818756, -0.018480537459254265, -0.39565110206604004, -1.0849299430847168, -0.5512306094169617, 0.7351958155632019, 0.769020140171051, -0.7353095412254333, 0.56795734167099, -0.36601683497428894, -0.33325791358947754, -0.9361389875411987, 0.11614549905061722, 0.17611251771450043, 0.5946767330169678, 0.7323744297027588, -0.3115870952606201, -0.8676081895828247, -1.0848385095596313, -0.20257890224456787, 0.08998962491750717, 0.04025965929031372, 0.2973247766494751, 0.5215436816215515, -0.31699666380882263, 1.1028549671173096, 0.003947262652218342, -0.4113259017467499, -0.32147708535194397, 0.17665806412696838, 0.02818004973232746, 0.5845709443092346, 0.15624327957630157, -0.7810750603675842, -0.10472187399864197, -0.014533447101712227, -0.6329399943351746, -0.3018608093261719, -0.24988283216953278, -0.019839541986584663, 0.2363840937614441, 0.45618900656700134, -0.18094563484191895, 0.3809468746185303, 0.3859775960445404, 0.10839974880218506, 0.33021360635757446, -0.0254390649497509, -0.007518854457885027, -0.8864181041717529, -0.06037826091051102, 0.23423413932323456, -0.20235881209373474, -0.4444754719734192, -0.21073634922504425, 0.1058809831738472, 0.09861499816179276, -0.21889056265354156, 0.7081283330917358, -0.6574206948280334, -0.01977616921067238, -0.4540921747684479, 0.1327494978904724, -0.002471764339134097, 0.15890873968601227, 0.16823917627334595, 0.8035237789154053, 0.4550478756427765, -0.5325289964675903, 0.27863216400146484, 0.006859681569039822, -0.16255056858062744, 0.6207281351089478, -0.5172461867332458, -0.11899229884147644, -0.28631460666656494, 0.2534807622432709, -0.4409690201282501, -0.31141397356987, 0.44370684027671814, -0.126895472407341, 0.576490581035614, -0.24856939911842346, -0.8779165148735046, -0.054712846875190735, -0.0805443599820137, 0.2815932631492615, 0.25003358721733093, -0.6557461023330688, 1.0082106590270996, 0.7215357422828674, -0.05837863311171532, -0.4436703026294708, -0.8069993257522583, 0.5689548850059509, -0.3072633147239685, -0.3723948895931244, 0.6655191779136658, 0.3009711802005768, -0.31427088379859924, 0.13043053448200226, -0.0815676674246788, 0.09147875756025314, 0.1000693142414093, 0.281044602394104, 0.5126192569732666, -0.13732439279556274, 0.2363077998161316, 0.07728467881679535, -0.3349369168281555, -0.13181312382221222, -0.26841142773628235, 0.31542104482650757, 0.0007655517547391355, -0.24587169289588928, -0.5580292344093323, 0.23556554317474365, 0.20953015983104706, -0.45206597447395325, 0.7748196125030518, 0.482824444770813, -0.8211828470230103, -0.32754409313201904, -0.9235929846763611, -0.07868043333292007, -0.4200650453567505, 0.18644271790981293, -0.2048180103302002, -0.9039064049720764, 0.46445295214653015, -0.18431255221366882, 0.11710452288389206, 0.5000618100166321, 0.2392081618309021, -0.06941857188940048, 0.4690777063369751, 0.3924356997013092, -0.20786090195178986, 0.3922910690307617, -0.08483495563268661, 0.19663795828819275, -1.0752573013305664, -0.446785569190979, -0.3836134374141693, -0.5326608419418335, -0.7240274548530579, -0.5390175580978394, 0.008138634264469147, 0.010438116267323494, 0.0977514386177063, 0.2252383530139923, -0.5205051302909851, 0.5926409959793091, 0.7094724774360657, 0.015026052482426167, 0.4504817724227905, 0.07346080988645554, -0.014958241954445839, -0.23524770140647888, -0.39739376306533813, -0.8284631967544556, 1.089086890220642, 0.23163481056690216, 0.5529759526252747, -0.0985642820596695, 1.052315354347229, 0.12796209752559662, 0.474764347076416, -0.5743398070335388, 0.7559627294540405, -0.056240953505039215, -0.4508734345436096, -0.14319270849227905, -0.5023808479309082, -0.6629936099052429, 0.4291878938674927, -0.736972987651825, -0.6947951316833496, 0.1999039649963379, 0.19268621504306793, -0.29475945234298706, 0.6143863201141357, -0.5748922824859619, 0.4661632180213928, -0.4388684332370758, -0.21378915011882782, 0.18025510013103485, -0.5573738217353821, 0.20106273889541626, -0.27212387323379517, 0.2358676642179489, -0.3009679615497589, -0.35479429364204407, 0.7939621210098267, -0.2801119089126587, 0.7099210619926453, -0.006741976365447044, -0.0058848802000284195, 0.1536751389503479, -0.26299849152565, 0.5891396999359131, 0.11660045385360718, -0.13862352073192596, 0.3385012149810791, -0.529819905757904, -0.17642498016357422, -0.4837847948074341, 0.727888286113739, -0.570161759853363, -0.3139077126979828, -0.6286580562591553, -0.6139777898788452, -0.21766315400600433, 0.16800373792648315, 0.0788111686706543, 0.28949305415153503, 0.21792221069335938, -0.10362213104963303, 0.6977618336677551, -0.20993345975875854, 0.43265214562416077, 0.14519630372524261, -0.036144427955150604, -0.9225051999092102, 0.9220423698425293, 0.39373666048049927, 0.1749705672264099, 0.4349873960018158, -0.10489340126514435, -0.15752778947353363, -0.7369927763938904, -0.4161442518234253, 0.2556707262992859, -0.5686158537864685, -0.27747616171836853, -0.9815179109573364, -0.25523701310157776, -0.1549922376871109, -0.04473648965358734, -0.2282445877790451, -0.5442222356796265, -0.49412432312965393, -0.19491106271743774, 0.34603601694107056, 0.45134401321411133, 0.086407870054245, 0.31887704133987427, -0.5426195859909058, 0.2152009755373001, 0.1272267997264862, 0.38442039489746094, 0.016719991341233253, -0.3397592306137085, -0.06914186477661133, -0.15141849219799042, 0.08766405284404755, -0.7061029076576233, 0.3577362895011902, 0.2360873520374298, 0.7040959000587463, -0.028308618813753128, 0.09250359982252121, 0.7186493277549744, -0.28061938285827637, 0.4412934482097626, 0.05053582042455673, -0.7945831418037415, 0.5027335286140442, -0.1377348154783249, -0.03504400700330734, 0.7459556460380554, 0.06250825524330139, -0.3458377718925476, -0.3934929668903351, -0.6385209560394287, -1.4319127798080444, 0.5487067103385925, 0.25526005029678345, -0.08771021664142609, 0.1316758692264557, 0.3920367360115051, 0.13016173243522644, 0.20718595385551453, -1.0135024785995483, -0.5405495166778564, 0.22838947176933289, -0.2869049310684204, -0.1023310124874115, -0.17894954979419708, 0.08633158355951309, -0.2165900617837906, 1.0066685676574707, 0.08867182582616806, -0.19371990859508514, 0.12239708751440048, -0.3548196852207184, 0.004609506111592054, 0.3590143322944641, 0.2769472599029541, 0.2133171707391739, -0.12262082099914551, 0.23964928090572357, 0.5034464001655579, -0.34730541706085205, 0.06133445352315903, 0.49424445629119873, -0.5638483166694641, 0.14852748811244965, 0.21995067596435547, 0.7889966368675232, 0.27480584383010864, -0.6135838627815247, 0.11801150441169739, 0.137010395526886, 0.11330311745405197, -0.31293556094169617, 0.13665255904197693, 0.06964542716741562, 0.2713487446308136, 0.49346670508384705, 0.1598721742630005, 0.14619959890842438, 0.0089243920519948, 0.13347309827804565, 0.3977417051792145, -0.1681889295578003, 0.03094414249062538, 0.4814549386501312, 0.28457069396972656, -0.3548213839530945, 0.5432735681533813, -0.2791789174079895, -0.4022027850151062, 0.45555707812309265, 0.35939595103263855, 0.7581754922866821, 0.1183214783668518, -0.04400739073753357, 0.39436355233192444, 0.6271374225616455, -0.20041730999946594, 0.10025441646575928, 0.06253334879875183, -0.6783261299133301, -0.5478653311729431, -0.8282213807106018, -0.6448178887367249, 0.21998076140880585, -0.6175163388252258, 0.5277532935142517, -0.4169982373714447, -0.2485704869031906, 0.18583868443965912, -0.09802663326263428, -0.5915431976318359, 0.3970509469509125, 0.5848833918571472, 0.6008870005607605, -0.8223040699958801, 0.5551254153251648, 0.8973900079727173, -0.4046526551246643, -0.6046991348266602, -0.0878291055560112, 0.0353391170501709, -0.4920574128627777, 0.6203157901763916, 0.3872389495372772, 0.04202481731772423, 0.07843691855669022, -0.06563635915517807, -0.9153481125831604, 0.9591370224952698, 0.2629877030849457, -0.782929003238678, 0.037503328174352646, 0.3254362940788269, 0.5067375898361206, -0.4363393485546112, 0.0744670182466507, 0.514141857624054, 0.48030126094818115, -0.05160916969180107, -0.8249596953392029, 0.005426883697509766, -0.3141978085041046, 0.04925430938601494, 0.5841031074523926, -0.15429925918579102, 0.5485476851463318, -0.23021577298641205, -0.3146180510520935, -0.25643405318260193, 0.7609198689460754, 0.296682208776474, 0.47719332575798035, 0.5071837306022644, 0.9572088122367859, 0.9926750659942627, -0.2677053213119507, 0.6599954962730408, -0.02234305813908577, 0.14327272772789001, 1.4134783744812012, -0.550733208656311, 0.7375461459159851, 0.6761314868927002, -0.22372139990329742, 0.3003082871437073, 0.6639864444732666, -0.35167884826660156, 0.21464784443378448, 0.47370338439941406, -0.48894575238227844, -0.2734072804450989, -0.44340744614601135, -0.3145328760147095, 0.1721450239419937, 0.374031662940979, -0.3608217239379883, -0.24999850988388062, 0.10268018394708633, -0.07098282128572464, 0.02806394174695015, -0.31896859407424927, 0.9194773435592651, -0.021238600835204124, -0.22420606017112732, 0.15089303255081177, -0.07263138145208359, 1.1036741733551025, -0.1855575442314148, -0.028321104124188423, 0.03288568556308746, -0.031379785388708115, -0.3961842954158783, -0.565613329410553, 0.16043224930763245, -0.01305896695703268, -0.20067308843135834, -0.14685320854187012, 0.6851434707641602, -0.489702433347702, -0.6991921067237854, 0.42902258038520813, 0.38411444425582886, 0.03083767183125019, 0.0744921863079071, -0.4700624346733093, -0.0012459486024454236, -0.22429770231246948, 0.1038539782166481, 0.27716442942619324, 0.35562196373939514, -0.16325394809246063, 0.5481671094894409, 0.7244206070899963, 0.5150366425514221, 0.1159043163061142, 0.25144800543785095, 0.8183528184890747, -0.6136016249656677, -0.27677497267723083, -0.9836254715919495, 0.5629259943962097, -0.3614633083343506, -0.26768824458122253, 0.558927059173584, 0.7241635918617249, 1.1208256483078003, 0.2668600380420685, 0.8737653493881226, 0.1575707346200943, 0.637946367263794, -0.4154486358165741, 0.41883066296577454, -0.47605496644973755, 0.5848153233528137, -0.37389394640922546, -0.9269706606864929, -0.7108268141746521, 0.4309510588645935, -0.28619420528411865, -0.07206898182630539, 0.18304042518138885, 0.7381965517997742, 0.1274247169494629, 0.16344062983989716, 0.03061605803668499, -0.22772088646888733, 0.16181273758411407, 0.2094237208366394, 0.9053000807762146, -0.3885166645050049, 0.2813357710838318, -0.5577918291091919, -0.04825586825609207, -0.20262998342514038, -0.9910010099411011, -0.8201238512992859, -0.20245446264743805, -0.7903376817703247, -0.25697746872901917, 0.11012304574251175, 1.2133234739303589, 0.4593263268470764, -0.9026256799697876, 0.026306098327040672, 0.010463624261319637, -0.06462186574935913, -0.07834118604660034, -0.20482461154460907, 0.199097141623497, -0.17310218513011932, -0.7097859978675842, 0.25834357738494873, 0.44305893778800964, 0.44761162996292114, -0.07942100614309311, 0.12126556783914566, -0.2979709506034851, -0.13261432945728302, 0.3187642991542816, 0.183508962392807, -0.8619676232337952, 0.09406168013811111, -0.32429131865501404, -0.07614513486623764, 0.137650266289711, 0.598711371421814, -0.9503735303878784, 0.3899371027946472, 0.16571584343910217, 1.0269194841384888, 0.18100038170814514, -0.06480727344751358, 0.3357694447040558, -0.6629197597503662, 0.0023479426745325327, 0.5630940794944763, 0.5550686120986938, 0.8152332901954651, -0.4003331959247589, 0.5629013180732727, 0.23824407160282135, -0.29621854424476624, -1.0556412935256958, -0.18932154774665833, -0.9187148213386536, 0.22414924204349518, 1.0511659383773804, 0.2069220393896103, 0.05880061164498329, -0.22727873921394348, -0.15302926301956177, 0.27924320101737976, -0.4889069199562073, 0.4515568017959595, 0.6128126978874207, -0.08120414614677429, -0.2002958357334137, -0.6109809875488281, 0.2734798491001129, 0.3629301190376282, -0.9601510167121887, -0.07135619968175888, 0.5495286583900452, 0.13972154259681702, 0.15468430519104004, 0.2697511613368988, -0.1382288932800293, -0.17025704681873322, -0.3686399459838867, 0.4499686360359192, -0.14318156242370605, -0.17416411638259888, -0.3935122489929199, 0.08150026202201843, -0.05061456933617592, -0.11589859426021576 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00303v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00303v1
A Comprehensive Study on NLP Data Augmentation for Hate Speech Detection: Legacy Methods, BERT, and LLMs
2024-03-30T09:55:58
2024-03-30T09:55:58
Md Saroar Jahan, Mourad Oussalah, Djamila Romaissa Beddia, Jhuma kabir Mim, Nabil Arhab
cs.CL
cs.CL
The surge of interest in data augmentation within the realm of NLP has been driven by the need to address challenges posed by hate speech domains, the dynamic nature of social media vocabulary, and the demands for large-scale neural networks requiring extensive training data. However, the prevalent use of lexical substitution in data augmentation has raised concerns, as it may inadvertently alter the intended meaning, thereby impacting the efficacy of supervised machine learning models. In pursuit of suitable data augmentation methods, this study explores both established legacy approaches and contemporary practices such as Large Language Models (LLM), including GPT in Hate Speech detection. Additionally, we propose an optimized utilization of BERT-based encoder models with contextual cosine similarity filtration, exposing significant limitations in prior synonym substitution methods. Our comparative analysis encompasses five popular augmentation techniques: WordNet and Fast-Text synonym replacement, Back-translation, BERT-mask contextual augmentation, and LLM. Our analysis across five benchmarked datasets revealed that while traditional methods like back-translation show low label alteration rates (0.3-1.5%), and BERT-based contextual synonym replacement offers sentence diversity but at the cost of higher label alteration rates (over 6%). Our proposed BERT-based contextual cosine similarity filtration markedly reduced label alteration to just 0.05%, demonstrating its efficacy in 0.7% higher F1 performance. However, augmenting data with GPT-3 not only avoided overfitting with up to sevenfold data increase but also improved embedding space coverage by 15% and classification F1 score by 1.4% over traditional methods, and by 0.8% over our method.
[ -0.6346040368080139, -1.0070133209228516, 0.18779940903186798, -0.17258279025554657, -0.3054095208644867, 0.07154693454504013, -0.18746034801006317, -0.8064932227134705, 0.2783183753490448, 0.39845165610313416, -0.5385672450065613, -0.3920886814594269, -0.730241060256958, 0.07681047916412354, -0.6214535236358643, 1.0882253646850586, 0.21098536252975464, 0.17823278903961182, -0.013425041921436787, -0.23560984432697296, -0.4950528144836426, -0.7969779968261719, -0.6144077777862549, -0.3177056312561035, 0.6895468235015869, 0.05715359374880791, 1.028398036956787, 0.47449788451194763, 0.46172723174095154, 0.17331308126449585, -0.31270018219947815, 0.09985286742448807, -0.43809595704078674, 0.26177579164505005, -0.23084263503551483, -0.07455158978700638, -0.295082151889801, 0.03352554142475128, 0.391737699508667, 0.6236693263053894, 0.190530464053154, -0.19284217059612274, -0.018298575654625893, 0.5149486660957336, -0.6410083770751953, -0.3858563005924225, -1.1633208990097046, 0.1518644541501999, -0.38988447189331055, -0.06975603848695755, -0.017065279185771942, -0.41606858372688293, 0.22577928006649017, -0.4509282112121582, 0.2944597005844116, 0.072385273873806, 0.5331649780273438, 0.2640153169631958, -0.05216250941157341, -0.4704107344150543, -0.6174156069755554, 0.9602931141853333, -0.9888315200805664, 0.5033813118934631, 0.30932775139808655, 0.1646624505519867, -0.23435191810131073, -0.5696341395378113, -0.937128484249115, -0.38457489013671875, 0.008641510270535946, 0.05260336026549339, -0.44457757472991943, 0.2516614496707916, 0.4312608242034912, 0.495828777551651, -0.5842834115028381, 0.5179787278175354, -0.2888180911540985, -0.36258363723754883, 0.482403427362442, -0.02585907280445099, 0.3671219050884247, -0.13224045932292938, -0.5138822197914124, -0.14197713136672974, -0.6128027439117432, -0.3499128520488739, 0.5844036340713501, 0.4838917553424835, 0.20686767995357513, 0.46035370230674744, -0.03037177585065365, 0.8186089992523193, -0.18740837275981903, 0.034898873418569565, 0.5064385533332825, -0.17551153898239136, -0.3334261476993561, 0.07995012402534485, 0.5135290622711182, 0.388234943151474, 0.2796456217765808, -0.30790388584136963, -0.1209980845451355, 0.24409981071949005, 0.29051893949508667, -0.5699445009231567, -0.10096064954996109, 0.08158992975950241, -0.11304698139429092, -0.16358883678913116, -0.2614765465259552, -0.7213224768638611, -0.6079686284065247, -0.5052832961082458, 0.5432091355323792, -0.8405318260192871, 0.04987523332238197, -0.06483697146177292, -0.48610660433769226, 0.26971009373664856, 0.44299593567848206, -0.5552050471305847, 0.1995118111371994, 0.7522302269935608, 0.7982068657875061, -0.6537572145462036, -0.030483290553092957, -0.40007007122039795, -0.04281004145741463, -0.19769187271595, 0.38535812497138977, -0.7129960656166077, -0.20179468393325806, 0.08985201269388199, -0.30071279406547546, 0.3090043067932129, -0.7064662575721741, 0.8734495639801025, -0.7114127278327942, 0.286178857088089, -0.07046183943748474, -0.8340246677398682, -0.38178062438964844, 0.3594450056552887, -0.5595972537994385, 1.1758719682693481, 0.17447783052921295, -0.7319431304931641, 0.5387315154075623, -0.4757824242115021, -0.503913164138794, 0.20078711211681366, 0.06707888096570969, -0.614953339099884, -0.0022103835362941027, 0.3452216684818268, 0.36886999011039734, 0.08273737877607346, 0.2663455903530121, -0.5315633416175842, -0.4163464605808258, 0.17544226348400116, -0.5685768127441406, 0.7785318493843079, 0.23825012147426605, -0.3902159631252289, -0.02811995893716812, -0.616786777973175, -0.2851681411266327, -0.0695435181260109, 0.023903364315629005, -0.5376731157302856, 0.0012822933495044708, 0.32519346475601196, 0.1962849497795105, 0.00788422953337431, -0.8800916075706482, -0.29104122519493103, -0.603742241859436, 0.04554341733455658, 0.8984475135803223, -0.18603849411010742, 0.13988518714904785, -0.5743919610977173, 0.3508826196193695, -0.06469856947660446, 0.04020306095480919, 0.16470305621623993, -0.6492403149604797, -0.5332055687904358, -0.22856362164020538, 0.06986706703901291, 0.5536507964134216, -0.9009418487548828, 0.6013636589050293, -0.218558669090271, -0.3549792766571045, -0.3743208348751068, 0.04770908132195473, 0.014605425298213959, 0.7125489115715027, 0.8873240947723389, -0.2948462963104248, -1.0332025289535522, -1.0124949216842651, -0.4855286180973053, 0.05931631848216057, -0.07491325587034225, 0.24638289213180542, 0.4871300756931305, -0.1844368726015091, 1.1255427598953247, -0.25293999910354614, -0.3760937750339508, -0.21285593509674072, 0.05212979391217232, 0.1459200531244278, 0.3847900629043579, 0.5974287390708923, -0.931551456451416, -0.5893104672431946, -0.1913321167230606, -0.18540097773075104, -0.2917998433113098, 0.07037732750177383, 0.2662067711353302, 0.17173969745635986, 0.2951607406139374, 0.16739946603775024, 0.5547969937324524, 0.5687405467033386, -0.07095739990472794, 0.5886642336845398, 0.17375926673412323, 0.25071826577186584, -0.8029469847679138, -0.2452620416879654, 0.07647209614515305, -0.3350928723812103, -1.042288064956665, 0.118711918592453, -0.23302291333675385, 0.01522460300475359, -0.5966774821281433, 0.4259655475616455, -0.062307100743055344, 0.16723592579364777, -0.4506188929080963, 0.263618141412735, -0.378407746553421, 0.25521865487098694, -0.037960488349199295, 0.7526591420173645, 0.2397390604019165, -0.5158719420433044, 0.6718020439147949, 0.19367563724517822, -0.2984020709991455, 0.6461254954338074, -0.399033784866333, 0.22421254217624664, -0.23129840195178986, 0.3603958189487457, -1.0530710220336914, 0.00590050034224987, 0.4552403390407562, -0.5874960422515869, 0.10447565466165543, -0.14012862741947174, -0.6050933003425598, -0.435333251953125, -0.550105631351471, 0.37368059158325195, 0.5629831552505493, -0.8077637553215027, 0.38559213280677795, 0.3549213409423828, -0.23585863411426544, -0.5965430736541748, -1.0121426582336426, 0.3948533535003662, -0.3741525411605835, -0.5887508392333984, 0.7637868523597717, -0.09545288234949112, -0.07309413701295853, -0.1887345314025879, 0.05630604550242424, -0.14128129184246063, -0.02631494216620922, 0.16196247935295105, 0.24296784400939941, 0.14638155698776245, 0.29871949553489685, 0.0846785306930542, 0.318430095911026, -0.16815805435180664, -0.07624244689941406, 0.6569402813911438, 0.3128880262374878, -0.1984366923570633, -0.2684777081012726, 0.3210739493370056, 0.2757435739040375, 0.2747437059879303, 0.722953736782074, 1.1291626691818237, -0.5694124102592468, 0.013289232738316059, -0.8850638270378113, -0.15093077719211578, -0.39823615550994873, 0.27003470063209534, -0.04914200305938721, -1.292725920677185, 0.38924160599708557, 0.38110101222991943, 0.05170067027211189, 0.1939140409231186, 0.4921361207962036, 0.008994814939796925, 0.6613296866416931, 0.0526445098221302, -0.48724326491355896, 0.7383679747581482, 0.20935668051242828, 0.3583373725414276, -0.8085334300994873, 0.1566297858953476, -0.3134506642818451, -0.46549591422080994, -0.5911058783531189, -0.6940242648124695, 0.6192545890808105, -0.23181568086147308, -0.02658039890229702, 0.28028932213783264, -0.6073088645935059, 0.23072528839111328, 0.3740674555301666, 0.22441929578781128, 0.220279261469841, 0.46006378531455994, 0.26933780312538147, -0.4760998785495758, -0.3161269724369049, 0.0029828250408172607, 1.1675167083740234, 0.43612179160118103, 0.417243093252182, 0.20955437421798706, 0.5596198439598083, 0.6431410312652588, 0.33850106596946716, -0.8222959637641907, 0.49318361282348633, -0.4457324743270874, -0.7038517594337463, -0.23893582820892334, -0.41742101311683655, -0.7117384076118469, 0.3809904158115387, -0.34651613235473633, -0.693213164806366, 0.03977194428443909, 0.1376795768737793, -0.13623031973838806, 0.595015823841095, -0.432542085647583, 0.33570408821105957, -0.0002872782351914793, -0.29654595255851746, -0.3513740003108978, -0.2534341812133789, 0.2960342764854431, -0.29821187257766724, 0.2897742688655853, -0.03907155618071556, -0.1624983847141266, 0.8231816291809082, -0.5132476687431335, 0.715480387210846, -0.3466466963291168, -0.25423663854599, 0.0702398419380188, -0.20354969799518585, 0.7915682792663574, -0.4619176387786865, -0.23661041259765625, 0.20205003023147583, -0.41926082968711853, -0.15625905990600586, -0.566731870174408, 0.7636640667915344, -0.24161428213119507, -0.54632568359375, -0.2305499166250229, -0.7891494631767273, -0.3510533273220062, -0.10915428400039673, 0.06712117046117783, 0.24136583507061005, -0.10586211830377579, 0.3560122549533844, 0.6006770730018616, -0.5288301706314087, 0.28048625588417053, 0.330401748418808, -0.1381848305463791, -0.5452020168304443, 0.931934654712677, 0.1636304408311844, 0.3100837767124176, 0.12643972039222717, 0.2667541205883026, -0.46672192215919495, -0.8457768559455872, -0.21085822582244873, -0.08307313174009323, -0.4169729948043823, -0.15442146360874176, -0.7756684422492981, -0.1678440123796463, -0.729275643825531, -0.3032488524913788, 0.03018401749432087, -0.4510979652404785, -0.016998743638396263, 0.05209199711680412, 0.6876453757286072, 0.3052756190299988, -0.4479837715625763, 0.4685269892215729, -0.324162095785141, 0.5727745890617371, 0.2030300348997116, 0.2414177656173706, -0.058612629771232605, -0.9771276116371155, -0.11645897477865219, 0.21645291149616241, -0.1457017958164215, -1.0995179414749146, 0.5571773052215576, 0.09354405850172043, 0.2958751320838928, -0.08543630689382553, -0.011419174261391163, 0.7658004760742188, -0.46253469586372375, 0.9204118251800537, 0.23631088435649872, -0.7830538749694824, 0.5035187602043152, -0.3284479081630707, -0.01992560364305973, 0.36273178458213806, 0.49127912521362305, -0.7593405842781067, -0.44319581985473633, -0.5374733805656433, -1.0133825540542603, 0.5892794728279114, 0.2943114638328552, 0.3277820646762848, 0.0817880854010582, 0.08321553468704224, 0.21673573553562164, 0.20178784430027008, -0.8825328946113586, -0.579071044921875, -0.017910920083522797, -0.07354264706373215, 0.12355085462331772, -0.1883881837129593, 0.08669015765190125, -0.5475015640258789, 0.9497680068016052, 0.27883222699165344, 0.06628745049238205, 0.14792917668819427, -0.16399620473384857, 0.23637549579143524, 0.5309843420982361, 0.35380569100379944, 0.32513535022735596, -0.3630341589450836, -0.21969616413116455, 0.5035405158996582, -0.460991233587265, 0.04395650327205658, 0.399078369140625, -0.3320264220237732, 0.41108646988868713, 0.05763276293873787, 0.7832856178283691, -0.03637943044304848, -0.5008089542388916, 0.459629088640213, 0.42528823018074036, -0.22718584537506104, -0.38822007179260254, -0.006660799030214548, -0.3727605640888214, -0.04711414873600006, 0.5102665424346924, -0.22739560902118683, 0.41481709480285645, -0.38975366950035095, 0.4117458760738373, 0.7401929497718811, -0.4363957345485687, 0.08423874527215958, 0.42768073081970215, -0.16948175430297852, -0.1598602682352066, 0.3248322308063507, -0.2017226368188858, -0.7284302711486816, 0.26980504393577576, 0.604414165019989, 0.7078347206115723, -0.43327125906944275, 0.21913887560367584, 0.39440807700157166, 0.21423785388469696, 0.4039227068424225, 0.008934013545513153, -0.07183656841516495, -0.9562594890594482, -0.5117784738540649, -0.6729791760444641, -0.4647822380065918, 0.6758089065551758, -0.4852173328399658, 0.07406169921159744, -0.41687753796577454, -0.04072021320462227, 0.14175856113433838, -0.07732031494379044, -0.5401303172111511, 0.39128413796424866, 0.4407148063182831, 0.8060936331748962, -0.7477946877479553, 0.696575939655304, 0.5196841359138489, -0.10528004169464111, -0.4162991940975189, -0.07713072746992111, 0.21132051944732666, -0.8411059975624084, 0.5219959020614624, 0.1436437964439392, -0.030796745792031288, -0.023168930783867836, -0.5247954726219177, -0.6198978424072266, 0.5675172805786133, 0.015737520530819893, -0.5607401728630066, -0.0059025585651397705, 0.4059504568576813, 0.6267343759536743, -0.10399758070707321, 0.09680354595184326, 0.7483775019645691, 0.5661218762397766, 0.18765509128570557, -0.6757230162620544, -0.011712799780070782, 0.15082867443561554, 0.13470380008220673, 0.27748891711235046, -0.01989865116775036, 0.5993217825889587, 0.32283496856689453, -0.20606155693531036, -0.0045008244924247265, 0.45308852195739746, 0.13492411375045776, 0.23762483894824982, 0.7761025428771973, 0.8680472373962402, 0.4909583628177643, -0.08254881203174591, 0.7678855061531067, 0.1441269814968109, 0.17992204427719116, 1.0910760164260864, -0.08786008507013321, 0.6395198702812195, 0.4699300527572632, -0.4504323899745941, 0.43100419640541077, 0.4113227427005768, -0.2522416114807129, 0.25748732686042786, 0.4641890525817871, -0.43561455607414246, 0.07524105906486511, -0.36244773864746094, -0.4836916923522949, 0.26396414637565613, 0.663379430770874, -0.4760330021381378, -0.45707789063453674, 0.33654308319091797, 0.19307933747768402, 0.15689165890216827, -0.3717903196811676, 0.6498916745185852, -0.16797173023223877, -0.2594606876373291, 0.6663966178894043, 0.027757542207837105, 1.3005369901657104, -0.4817420542240143, 0.08990886807441711, -0.02638229727745056, -0.0012637078762054443, -0.2578496038913727, -0.8520992398262024, 0.4839366376399994, 0.20207782089710236, -0.05405664071440697, -0.2674715220928192, 0.7583407759666443, -0.6305245161056519, -0.1697203367948532, 0.40220189094543457, 0.2079542726278305, 0.24624840915203094, -0.27301570773124695, -0.9017006754875183, 0.29106733202934265, 0.11543793231248856, 0.13072770833969116, 0.2931690514087677, -0.15170753002166748, 0.1771058291196823, 0.3703996241092682, 0.82364422082901, 0.49110421538352966, 0.2068726271390915, 0.26496243476867676, 0.9023693203926086, -0.5834078192710876, -0.3922858238220215, -0.9248024821281433, 0.19157008826732635, -0.3724457323551178, -0.07456734031438828, 0.87803715467453, 0.5849904417991638, 1.0815167427062988, 0.10754651576280594, 0.9062792658805847, -0.15766292810440063, 1.045385718345642, -0.5281221866607666, 0.3902071416378021, -0.5097259879112244, 0.1302350014448166, -0.6405139565467834, -0.9143970608711243, -0.5548602342605591, 0.46613970398902893, -0.5899060368537903, -0.03439405933022499, 0.3433487117290497, 1.0008403062820435, -0.06914817541837692, 0.1651880294084549, 0.5168404579162598, 0.15997759997844696, 0.5468604564666748, 0.3939398527145386, 0.6543557047843933, -0.6159257292747498, 0.47445550560951233, -0.3129996359348297, -0.21906323730945587, -0.22002995014190674, -0.7537935376167297, -0.5941567420959473, -0.5283570289611816, -0.3339904844760895, -0.32962146401405334, 0.36660492420196533, 0.9004192352294922, 0.49835237860679626, -1.042157769203186, 0.12780560553073883, -0.00966374110430479, 0.12121489644050598, -0.03894472122192383, -0.3372286558151245, 0.13222505152225494, -0.3927929103374481, -0.9472665190696716, 0.6899251937866211, 0.13674134016036987, 0.09228644520044327, 0.002188171027228236, 0.11357724666595459, -0.3631577491760254, 0.001066446304321289, 0.7293073534965515, 0.15387281775474548, -0.9075743556022644, -0.48941871523857117, -0.4453565776348114, 0.16209393739700317, 0.09815637022256851, 0.7756012082099915, -0.9343010783195496, 0.6144123673439026, 0.3597167432308197, 1.077832579612732, 0.22934721410274506, 0.09663625806570053, 0.36970558762550354, -0.9289617538452148, 0.20167124271392822, 0.48365482687950134, 0.33022332191467285, 0.5526966452598572, -0.1932992786169052, 0.4161464273929596, 0.4018594026565552, -0.37074434757232666, -0.9424371719360352, 0.3750450313091278, -0.8555778861045837, -0.2998180091381073, 1.0334259271621704, 0.21261592209339142, 0.05805253982543945, -0.47173798084259033, -0.1830747127532959, 0.13841040432453156, -0.49220791459083557, 0.5592479705810547, 0.7934635281562805, -0.10734117031097412, -0.07114472985267639, -0.31497153639793396, 0.6512923836708069, 0.5436076521873474, -0.546073853969574, -0.032026130706071854, 0.8679917454719543, 0.04691430926322937, 0.21829403936862946, 0.26011812686920166, -0.11262201517820358, 0.13065768778324127, -0.37298694252967834, 0.03198211267590523, -0.07601895183324814, 0.12236771732568741, -0.5086390376091003, 0.11098460108041763, -0.43966153264045715, -0.07295385748147964 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00297v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00297v2
TRABSA: Interpretable Sentiment Analysis of Tweets using Attention-based BiLSTM and Twitter-RoBERTa
2024-03-30T09:20:43
2024-05-16T14:35:36
Md Abrar Jahin, Md Sakib Hossain Shovon, M. F. Mridha, Md Rashedul Islam, Yutaka Watanobe
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.LG
Sentiment analysis is crucial for understanding public opinion and consumer behavior. Existing models face challenges with linguistic diversity, generalizability, and explainability. We propose TRABSA, a hybrid framework integrating transformer-based architectures, attention mechanisms, and BiLSTM networks to address this. Leveraging RoBERTa-trained on 124M tweets, we bridge gaps in sentiment analysis benchmarks, ensuring state-of-the-art accuracy. Augmenting datasets with tweets from 32 countries and US states, we compare six word-embedding techniques and three lexicon-based labeling techniques, selecting the best for optimal sentiment analysis. TRABSA outperforms traditional ML and deep learning models with 94% accuracy and significant precision, recall, and F1-score gains. Evaluation across diverse datasets demonstrates consistent superiority and generalizability. SHAP and LIME analyses enhance interpretability, improving confidence in predictions. Our study facilitates pandemic resource management, aiding resource planning, policy formation, and vaccination tactics.
[ -0.10427896678447723, -0.5005123615264893, 0.213588684797287, 0.6645548939704895, -0.5235623717308044, 0.7740066647529602, -0.21995583176612854, -0.4006945490837097, 0.3801850378513336, 0.26357224583625793, -0.4038214683532715, -0.6417694687843323, -0.6956954598426819, -0.18971702456474304, -0.41670510172843933, 1.368033528327942, 0.17375566065311432, 0.06574293226003647, 0.19237284362316132, -0.5749122500419617, -0.28942692279815674, -0.25540104508399963, -0.48416852951049805, 0.029099062085151672, 0.6807056069374084, 0.42938002943992615, 0.7694426774978638, -0.2820318937301636, 0.681128203868866, 0.13373565673828125, -0.22737646102905273, 0.31276196241378784, -0.457313597202301, -0.057245634496212006, -0.46011680364608765, -0.10999809950590134, -0.5663097500801086, -0.058422185480594635, 0.36054444313049316, 0.5097033381462097, -0.1914074569940567, 0.590295672416687, 0.04570973291993141, 0.6107975840568542, -0.5692301392555237, -0.03612399846315384, -0.4098506569862366, 0.04057442769408226, -0.13618312776088715, -0.0071563865058124065, -0.4240943193435669, -0.6908494234085083, 0.5550532937049866, 0.18068383634090424, 0.28552332520484924, -0.14069178700447083, 0.8380538821220398, 0.0361289456486702, -0.5241531729698181, 0.06635931134223938, -0.936561107635498, 1.0368481874465942, -0.508110523223877, 0.27038177847862244, -0.1258062869310379, 0.551525354385376, 0.25457051396369934, -0.7389171123504639, -0.4848615527153015, 0.17521825432777405, 0.044824883341789246, 0.3896979093551636, -0.4068952202796936, 0.0008558111148886383, -0.100341796875, 0.38349488377571106, -0.8265407085418701, -0.49430981278419495, -0.33045440912246704, 0.009475447237491608, 0.357831209897995, 0.14388573169708252, 0.10056190192699432, -0.3853326141834259, -0.5218459367752075, -0.07757660001516342, -0.33391791582107544, 0.10871236026287079, -0.2273145169019699, 0.32454293966293335, -0.5568520426750183, 0.4250440299510956, 0.2422560155391693, 0.5355660319328308, -0.40961596369743347, 0.23417386412620544, 0.2839171588420868, -0.32276642322540283, -0.700877845287323, -0.32154521346092224, 0.7431598901748657, 0.310066282749176, 0.1854570358991623, -0.23384642601013184, -0.08784984052181244, 0.17643512785434723, 0.5280338525772095, -0.43268173933029175, -0.22741957008838654, 0.38517332077026367, -0.6925604343414307, -0.5312548875808716, 0.3253769278526306, -1.2748687267303467, -0.5095005035400391, 0.1465684175491333, 0.17965048551559448, -0.16741161048412323, -0.33845314383506775, 0.019294843077659607, -0.48680680990219116, 0.17446015775203705, 0.2289058417081833, -0.2426096796989441, 0.1902501881122589, 0.39010998606681824, 1.1469857692718506, -0.031987790018320084, 0.2936149835586548, -0.39950495958328247, 0.36666715145111084, -0.2874710261821747, 0.835614025592804, -0.701812744140625, -0.5542927384376526, -0.01681297831237316, -0.482057124376297, -0.04892667382955551, -0.3509272038936615, 0.39455148577690125, -0.6447867751121521, 0.11040479689836502, -0.26862630248069763, 0.08974859118461609, -0.4244406819343567, 0.46119555830955505, -0.6613513231277466, 0.8916797637939453, 0.34759315848350525, -0.7259619235992432, 0.1703740805387497, -1.0394618511199951, -0.7386506199836731, -0.15732988715171814, 0.44951331615448, -0.45615410804748535, 0.4452398717403412, 0.36050426959991455, 0.49269282817840576, -0.48082858324050903, 0.3264907896518707, -0.5813194513320923, 0.12207293510437012, 0.2654222548007965, -0.24244242906570435, 0.7097242474555969, 0.29424652457237244, -0.29643842577934265, 0.33013302087783813, -0.42851200699806213, 0.047262780368328094, 0.17494826018810272, 0.009224830195307732, -0.1643880158662796, 0.005941139534115791, 0.4748210608959198, 0.1640443503856659, 0.18147724866867065, -0.5822479128837585, -0.0532403327524662, -0.4041818380355835, 0.7543351650238037, 0.6443411707878113, 0.313498318195343, 0.35377082228660583, -0.13187038898468018, 0.7525028586387634, 0.28572699427604675, 0.6210454702377319, 0.22513718903064728, -0.44415873289108276, -0.4877289831638336, -0.2618944048881531, 0.1523360162973404, 0.4198245108127594, -0.5616165995597839, 0.21742279827594757, -0.6327206492424011, -0.7046907544136047, -0.5489989519119263, -0.17491760849952698, 0.17563354969024658, 0.5717846155166626, 0.5886219143867493, -0.09389843046665192, -0.8020111918449402, -0.9211768507957458, -0.5792387127876282, -0.12744766473770142, 0.2708205580711365, 0.008555355481803417, 0.26779499650001526, -0.26106616854667664, 0.9959620237350464, -0.324870765209198, -0.3920123875141144, -0.8756255507469177, 0.3550429046154022, 0.09121140092611313, -0.09513530135154724, 0.5859759449958801, -0.944987416267395, -0.5957614779472351, 0.04283054918050766, -0.5158265829086304, 0.061388179659843445, -0.0045885262079536915, 0.0545012541115284, 0.18951836228370667, -0.3093598186969757, -0.3813163638114929, 0.6456649899482727, 0.6781345009803772, -0.13061903417110443, 0.1270664930343628, 0.2224694788455963, -0.05738823115825653, -1.3204143047332764, 0.1487056165933609, 0.35737180709838867, -0.4649771451950073, -0.6823928952217102, -0.22618843615055084, 0.08561866730451584, -0.1560457944869995, -0.39949315786361694, 0.49269258975982666, -0.06114472821354866, -0.35713842511177063, -0.11392149329185486, 0.046964846551418304, 0.45320358872413635, 0.1495031714439392, -0.1459726244211197, 0.7760438323020935, 0.1795787215232849, -0.21882906556129456, 0.35701245069503784, 0.18924440443515778, -0.35592231154441833, 0.21956603229045868, -0.8525018692016602, 0.05948186293244362, 0.08049588650465012, 0.6260005831718445, -1.0803720951080322, -0.02634298801422119, 0.3644137382507324, -0.4593789577484131, 0.1009097471833229, 0.2773813307285309, -0.4261139929294586, -0.6833796501159668, -0.5143029689788818, 0.2086542397737503, 0.4112744927406311, -0.5063257217407227, 1.1106911897659302, 0.5530765652656555, 0.1065174788236618, -0.6511973142623901, -0.7811923623085022, 0.44459113478660583, -0.3095249533653259, -0.4867778718471527, -0.04172959178686142, 0.30166807770729065, -0.34913820028305054, 0.10632430762052536, -0.1718069463968277, -0.029256358742713928, 0.1301751583814621, 0.08539985865354538, 0.29792284965515137, -0.0006776804802939296, 0.036630839109420776, -0.08780478686094284, 0.028499897569417953, -0.06864402443170547, -0.45810380578041077, 0.6042154431343079, -0.3889158070087433, 0.2099924385547638, -0.5060815811157227, 0.4490942656993866, 0.7153588533401489, -0.5653029680252075, 0.816493570804596, 0.6232231855392456, -0.24811506271362305, -0.24084040522575378, -0.4238171875476837, 0.1298433542251587, -0.35815849900245667, 0.17583875358104706, -0.09136544913053513, -0.40593641996383667, 0.532987654209137, 0.15161532163619995, 0.11889242380857468, 0.22396212816238403, 0.6674051284790039, -0.43775925040245056, 0.9939950108528137, 0.5954105257987976, -0.3752109706401825, 0.5692136287689209, -0.44294336438179016, 0.609848141670227, -0.7101576328277588, -0.3868425488471985, -0.4570780396461487, -0.5411893725395203, -0.33273524045944214, -0.33899086713790894, 0.46121954917907715, -0.6705113649368286, -0.15537883341312408, 0.2693038582801819, -0.3333573341369629, 0.20113405585289001, 0.3727950155735016, 0.37601980566978455, -0.19714881479740143, 0.0086806146427989, 0.3800784945487976, 0.1179194450378418, -0.45341193675994873, -0.5764899253845215, 0.9059687256813049, 0.33336544036865234, 0.7019335031509399, 0.3707424998283386, 0.49069952964782715, 0.9278134107589722, 0.4736226201057434, -0.783669650554657, 0.4591812193393707, -0.3702743947505951, -0.6060982942581177, 0.025548642501235008, -0.31848660111427307, -0.7175502181053162, 0.07835769653320312, -0.0457712784409523, -0.6352648735046387, 0.17320190370082855, -0.024788150563836098, -0.3839685618877411, 0.3854859471321106, -0.8495177626609802, 0.7981052994728088, -0.11095649003982544, -0.23073121905326843, -0.7120165824890137, -0.7604780197143555, 0.33598828315734863, 0.15815694630146027, 0.3178202211856842, -0.04614141210913658, -0.1737038642168045, 0.7710441946983337, -0.2032068520784378, 0.9856802225112915, -0.18492735922336578, 0.1455923467874527, 0.2621670961380005, -0.006607935298234224, 0.31624940037727356, -0.008852867409586906, -0.24589094519615173, 0.28659114241600037, -0.011529123410582542, -0.7456294894218445, -0.586240291595459, 0.5038954615592957, -0.796476423740387, -0.5207270383834839, -0.4904910922050476, -0.5724647641181946, -0.48415809869766235, -0.04772619530558586, 0.005426596384495497, 0.4615253210067749, -0.40258994698524475, 0.18426083028316498, 0.46581074595451355, -0.05823817849159241, 0.4601062834262848, 0.038781262934207916, 0.038743432611227036, -0.5901007056236267, 0.9186146259307861, -0.04088142141699791, 0.04563179239630699, 0.6546814441680908, 0.4189002513885498, -0.3538794219493866, -0.29374411702156067, -0.24287991225719452, 0.14372488856315613, -0.49631914496421814, -0.38933444023132324, -0.6672320365905762, 0.0802890956401825, -0.4505102336406708, -0.12404529750347137, -0.21379800140857697, -0.45011043548583984, -0.2549375891685486, -0.29695287346839905, 0.28405144810676575, 0.9414101839065552, 0.013943636789917946, 0.5412700176239014, -1.1909406185150146, 0.4731283485889435, -0.08730589598417282, 0.13462163507938385, 0.22083987295627594, -0.313230037689209, -0.38925701379776, 0.18412591516971588, -0.27315282821655273, -1.1759974956512451, 0.5727698802947998, 0.1925676167011261, 0.08024546504020691, 0.6222119927406311, 0.2121438831090927, 0.8290471434593201, 0.14842253923416138, 0.9703781604766846, 0.2690114676952362, -1.210304856300354, 0.700378954410553, -0.24530825018882751, 0.07342377305030823, 0.331855833530426, 0.05945228412747383, -0.522809624671936, -0.487499475479126, -0.6273863315582275, -0.5232182741165161, 0.758328378200531, 0.0897127240896225, 0.2372819185256958, -0.019788121804594994, -0.19272546470165253, 0.057548172771930695, 0.21407261490821838, -0.450732558965683, -0.015486054122447968, -0.5040836930274963, -0.6448562145233154, -0.19738206267356873, -0.36832916736602783, -0.22816894948482513, -0.12074985355138779, 0.5088688731193542, 0.22508259117603302, 0.15864425897598267, -0.04520706087350845, -0.27495434880256653, -0.19088877737522125, 0.16697412729263306, 0.6547481417655945, 0.7344526052474976, -0.3263426423072815, 0.04754132032394409, 0.05054323747754097, -0.4723897874355316, -0.07860743999481201, -0.2664524018764496, -0.007841270416975021, 0.13276498019695282, 0.4779956042766571, 0.6950986385345459, 0.14922408759593964, -0.6419472694396973, 0.4934980869293213, -0.21790863573551178, 0.15626998245716095, -0.23020707070827484, -0.12900930643081665, 0.005984703544527292, 0.3008105158805847, 0.3716948926448822, 0.3467310667037964, 0.10654383152723312, -0.5346783399581909, -0.0952635109424591, 0.5096152424812317, -0.5277778506278992, -0.7533641457557678, 0.4569247364997864, 0.34649884700775146, -0.08763022720813751, 0.35295620560646057, 0.31727808713912964, -0.6781560182571411, 0.6494206190109253, 0.2611708641052246, 1.107904076576233, -0.28097933530807495, 0.7282939553260803, 0.08190973848104477, 0.3794744610786438, 0.29292377829551697, 0.5882431864738464, -0.10367154330015182, -0.5212668180465698, -0.08822328597307205, -0.509804368019104, -0.5314813852310181, -0.03133726865053177, -0.9978331923484802, 0.13992689549922943, -0.8163224458694458, -0.39046400785446167, 0.14181780815124512, -0.07508930563926697, -0.7492921948432922, 0.48770445585250854, -0.08994492888450623, 1.0962289571762085, -0.9547485709190369, 0.7723084688186646, 1.0437405109405518, -0.5108129382133484, -0.6588435173034668, 0.36183661222457886, -0.21350666880607605, -0.8952707648277283, 0.41562193632125854, 0.17742006480693817, -0.10133055597543716, -0.0670999139547348, -0.5079013705253601, -0.598794162273407, 0.9624376893043518, -0.04826481640338898, -0.16122537851333618, 0.09004192054271698, 0.1880737990140915, 0.6754050254821777, -0.28807806968688965, 0.24541984498500824, 0.628728985786438, 0.5957185626029968, 0.06885426491498947, -0.4514046609401703, -0.22030751407146454, -0.004159876611083746, 0.03842620179057121, 0.28475382924079895, -0.8217772841453552, 0.31864187121391296, -0.34406760334968567, -0.22541676461696625, -0.3208255171775818, 0.8241368532180786, -0.20825831592082977, 0.6221994757652283, 0.42578351497650146, 0.5463139414787292, 0.681891143321991, -0.07666558772325516, 1.0528634786605835, 0.02553626522421837, 0.32081496715545654, 0.9480630159378052, -0.4297417104244232, 0.8277156352996826, 0.46436747908592224, -0.32386043667793274, 0.8861277103424072, 0.6440261602401733, 0.024803776293992996, 0.7629415392875671, -0.3092021942138672, -0.25777876377105713, -0.20813925564289093, -0.4150630533695221, -0.03706631809473038, 0.43843287229537964, 0.6656777858734131, -0.26626259088516235, -0.5338595509529114, 0.4140148460865021, -0.3119809329509735, -0.11293959617614746, -0.2842817008495331, 0.7547940015792847, 0.2998346984386444, -0.24182216823101044, 0.03926903009414673, -0.07683809101581573, 0.1786949783563614, -0.47475987672805786, 0.30281710624694824, -0.2725871503353119, 0.32571184635162354, -0.2608684003353119, -1.0835766792297363, 0.644969642162323, 0.31187573075294495, -0.277578204870224, -0.1496068388223648, 0.5294865965843201, -0.01468057930469513, -0.47479546070098877, 0.5343005061149597, 0.5445992946624756, -0.18941061198711395, -0.01888999342918396, -0.7589738368988037, 0.103690005838871, 0.06381475180387497, -0.5409648418426514, -0.018097897991538048, 0.27453428506851196, -0.2176395207643509, 0.7656129598617554, 0.5593564510345459, 0.20428283512592316, -0.10954604297876358, 0.34120360016822815, 0.7871631383895874, -0.6966495513916016, -0.6019937992095947, -0.8676816821098328, 0.5781335234642029, -0.31353259086608887, -0.05972417816519737, 0.5745416283607483, 0.3954213559627533, 0.29043737053871155, -0.11058554798364639, 1.1726223230361938, -0.11730100214481354, 0.8186864852905273, 0.004191078245639801, 0.45271867513656616, -0.5273366570472717, 0.14856480062007904, 0.003970359917730093, -0.8156520128250122, -0.4820171296596527, 0.24781662225723267, -0.6261361241340637, -0.023295659571886063, 0.534395158290863, 0.5575298070907593, -0.061512336134910583, 0.2184453308582306, 0.09107840061187744, 0.27698031067848206, 0.5919708013534546, 0.34095990657806396, 0.8043467402458191, -0.21745696663856506, 0.835281252861023, -0.270910382270813, -0.1768433302640915, -0.4569430947303772, -0.7020032405853271, -1.0776338577270508, -0.3924831748008728, -0.03167887032032013, -0.6123756766319275, 0.13729281723499298, 0.8876646161079407, 0.43603193759918213, -1.08301842212677, 0.015879549086093903, 0.08199959248304367, 0.23041170835494995, -0.2878105044364929, -0.3305460214614868, 0.5875535607337952, -0.3323119580745697, -0.5823590755462646, -0.027937188744544983, 0.45271047949790955, -0.027677282691001892, -0.17919610440731049, 0.2228146642446518, -0.04725627228617668, 0.4508455991744995, 0.6247768402099609, 0.14655841886997223, -0.7772398591041565, -0.2815151810646057, 0.08053457736968994, -0.32896479964256287, 0.05396702140569687, 0.6910340189933777, -0.7340039610862732, 0.37989094853401184, 0.5834359526634216, 0.5034416913986206, 0.3167928159236908, 0.2834184765815735, 0.5273850560188293, -0.6635319590568542, 0.07984544336795807, 0.6125850677490234, 0.3356175124645233, 0.4774540066719055, -0.0786956399679184, 0.39591893553733826, 0.10930173844099045, -0.03553295508027077, -0.8933070302009583, 0.11679952591657639, -1.400607943534851, -0.18470528721809387, 1.0251106023788452, -0.08498411625623703, -0.3962959051132202, -0.25291907787323, -0.004699306562542915, 0.36937209963798523, -0.6321263313293457, 0.9468746781349182, 0.38466325402259827, 0.35984745621681213, -0.23977777361869812, -0.22136543691158295, 0.128378227353096, 0.37898045778274536, -0.6617055535316467, 0.03366519510746002, 0.09983136504888535, 0.04213116317987442, -0.02658846788108349, 0.32137438654899597, 0.028397582471370697, 0.22064246237277985, -0.5678473711013794, 0.00903338473290205, 0.05189560726284981, -0.5067611336708069, -0.23416930437088013, 0.30935561656951904, -0.30202406644821167, -0.47597798705101013 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00284v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00284v1
A Likelihood Ratio Test of Genetic Relationship among Languages
2024-03-30T08:35:08
2024-03-30T08:35:08
V. S. D. S. Mahesh Akavarapu, Arnab Bhattacharya
cs.CL
cs.CL, I.2.7
Lexical resemblances among a group of languages indicate that the languages could be genetically related, i.e., they could have descended from a common ancestral language. However, such resemblances can arise by chance and, hence, need not always imply an underlying genetic relationship. Many tests of significance based on permutation of wordlists and word similarity measures appeared in the past to determine the statistical significance of such relationships. We demonstrate that although existing tests may work well for bilateral comparisons, i.e., on pairs of languages, they are either infeasible by design or are prone to yield false positives when applied to groups of languages or language families. To this end, inspired by molecular phylogenetics, we propose a likelihood ratio test to determine if given languages are related based on the proportion of invariant character sites in the aligned wordlists applied during tree inference. Further, we evaluate some language families and show that the proposed test solves the problem of false positives. Finally, we demonstrate that the test supports the existence of macro language families such as Nostratic and Macro-Mayan.
[ -0.4099930226802826, -0.6836138367652893, 0.5102087259292603, 0.2057558298110962, 0.07261526584625244, 0.08568277955055237, -0.055352430790662766, -0.3935057818889618, 0.6106052994728088, 0.13214647769927979, -0.5039636492729187, -0.12272176146507263, -0.3553943336009979, 0.601569414138794, -0.45907026529312134, 0.4166475832462311, 0.04687314108014107, 0.05945213884115219, -0.05094868689775467, -0.7642483115196228, 0.13964509963989258, -0.706210196018219, -0.6683546304702759, -0.033189695328474045, 0.6496339440345764, 0.09921850264072418, 1.001941442489624, 0.7089119553565979, 0.6592146158218384, 0.22896863520145416, -0.13810181617736816, -0.31570908427238464, -0.22898411750793457, 0.13626709580421448, -0.20894929766654968, -0.545725405216217, -0.20695796608924866, -0.04333765059709549, 0.6241299510002136, 1.1799359321594238, 0.28260883688926697, 0.17921565473079681, 0.07638102769851685, 0.7901012301445007, -0.4840187132358551, -0.1725999414920807, -0.7928617596626282, 0.15590862929821014, -0.5228263139724731, -0.3554784953594208, -0.07526375353336334, -0.7130192518234253, 0.02335887774825096, -0.35895639657974243, 0.5318636894226074, 0.15042808651924133, 0.8433762192726135, -0.01475425437092781, -0.4647888243198395, -0.13973723351955414, -0.5452293753623962, 0.5549249053001404, -0.6797733306884766, 0.5641474723815918, 0.5259667038917542, -0.009491624310612679, -0.5825442671775818, -0.18343494832515717, -0.8079607486724854, -0.7933308482170105, -0.10605863481760025, 0.0466473326086998, -0.25653764605522156, -0.07835108041763306, 0.5549889802932739, 0.8463943600654602, -1.1271789073944092, -0.31346750259399414, 0.020455380901694298, -0.2276998609304428, 0.27886655926704407, -0.23005512356758118, 1.0315730571746826, 0.2145010083913803, -0.17619574069976807, -0.2192617952823639, -1.0069772005081177, -0.0425698459148407, 0.6653351783752441, 0.2630252540111542, -0.10998889058828354, 0.9850507974624634, 0.15600156784057617, 0.7935842275619507, -0.18121843039989471, -0.20280185341835022, 0.18074335157871246, -0.6102086901664734, 0.2040528953075409, 0.303731769323349, 0.6930631995201111, 0.3005383610725403, 0.635067343711853, -0.1966530829668045, 0.1393231451511383, 0.47378459572792053, -0.305756151676178, -0.3859565556049347, -0.06421276181936264, -0.2938013970851898, -0.5399081707000732, -0.30957695841789246, 0.12929441034793854, -0.7187259793281555, 0.06981714069843292, 0.027909351512789726, 0.4302811920642853, -0.6404279470443726, -0.40370887517929077, -0.06656798720359802, -0.43173524737358093, 0.4008028507232666, -0.6000821590423584, -0.9741252064704895, 0.310994952917099, 0.7040107846260071, 0.9049080610275269, -0.14592085778713226, -0.415258526802063, -0.40033915638923645, 0.0004897617036476731, -0.3767525255680084, 0.4759090542793274, -0.8317647576332092, -0.4348890483379364, -0.0893695056438446, -0.006544624455273151, -0.1902325600385666, -0.6223804950714111, 0.006064736749976873, -0.21837612986564636, 0.2832016050815582, -0.4578505754470825, -0.5578997731208801, -0.2746974527835846, 0.1809305101633072, -0.7275691628456116, 0.895209014415741, 0.5598398447036743, -1.1135962009429932, 0.5354360342025757, 0.12410078942775726, -0.6936522126197815, -0.03444813936948776, -0.6439185738563538, -0.4980812072753906, 0.11308087408542633, -0.20985771715641022, -0.09550381451845169, -0.2832174599170685, -0.07875905185937881, -0.9239985942840576, -0.16798214614391327, 0.3175392150878906, -0.3306090533733368, 1.1762789487838745, 0.12783706188201904, -0.6993040442466736, -0.28314340114593506, -0.6202780604362488, -0.09371958673000336, 0.04634619876742363, -0.2522168755531311, -0.6352288722991943, 0.19350400567054749, -0.4711344838142395, -0.0810239389538765, -0.09251400083303452, -0.5577329397201538, 0.5164508819580078, -0.3708247244358063, -0.06571892648935318, 0.3513460159301758, 0.1671425849199295, 0.2813492715358734, -0.553834855556488, 0.605202853679657, -0.2896904945373535, -0.09031525999307632, 0.27237454056739807, -0.8775666952133179, -0.8444318175315857, 0.08130593597888947, 0.4759345054626465, 0.614738404750824, -0.6583184003829956, 0.7328977584838867, -0.5042386054992676, -0.2759399712085724, -0.1717357188463211, 0.15800005197525024, 0.4204842746257782, 0.3537352979183197, -0.10376192629337311, -0.9091573357582092, -0.44860348105430603, -0.9424299001693726, -0.30077868700027466, -0.5979495644569397, -0.12482328712940216, 0.19909857213497162, 0.2053889036178589, -0.08785681426525116, 0.8757863640785217, -0.12086979299783707, 0.15629298985004425, -0.17973896861076355, -0.021382585167884827, 0.21529796719551086, 0.11243879050016403, 1.2175493240356445, -0.4577294588088989, -0.537429690361023, 0.4878280460834503, -0.6723154187202454, -0.16674284636974335, 0.3624330759048462, -0.013872935436666012, 0.3537786304950714, 0.6085928678512573, -0.008824566379189491, 0.5387693047523499, 0.96734219789505, -0.6921982765197754, 0.33563756942749023, -0.005287977401167154, 0.3121556341648102, -1.0123684406280518, 0.238679900765419, -0.11640235781669617, 0.025036660954356194, -0.3187665641307831, 0.11997298896312714, -0.12645666301250458, 0.01787896454334259, -0.12280764430761337, 0.49165967106819153, -0.11885613948106766, -0.3339385688304901, -0.04757041111588478, -0.28741031885147095, -0.5140591859817505, 0.15796016156673431, 0.03347510099411011, 0.97796231508255, 0.48973092436790466, -0.6044489741325378, 0.14493753015995026, -0.061233941465616226, -0.23978391289710999, 0.4325377345085144, -0.442915141582489, -0.19194987416267395, 0.1256071776151657, -0.009094461798667908, -0.947368860244751, -0.04898307844996452, 0.15320046246051788, -0.5891116261482239, -0.026653876528143883, -0.1690812110900879, -0.37925082445144653, -0.21930979192256927, -0.36194366216659546, 0.6659241318702698, 0.5405504703521729, -0.4362425208091736, 0.33942508697509766, 0.165403351187706, -0.2459288090467453, -0.4161751866340637, -0.6811208724975586, -0.18796169757843018, -0.5815908312797546, -0.7425170540809631, 0.038813039660453796, -0.059231456369161606, -0.6094179153442383, 0.054320111870765686, -0.22786013782024384, -0.1337132751941681, 0.12206684052944183, 0.1004456877708435, 0.32454714179039, -0.7649129629135132, -0.022238431498408318, 0.02865242399275303, 0.10418543219566345, -0.10882707685232162, -0.4811025857925415, 0.3620767295360565, -0.033189594745635986, -0.15428470075130463, 0.1054198145866394, 0.21696870028972626, 0.841113805770874, -0.039842963218688965, 0.8062489628791809, 0.19910971820354462, -0.2739669680595398, 0.3523443937301636, -0.6255089640617371, -0.3001556396484375, -0.3789931535720825, 0.09920457750558853, -0.625754177570343, -0.7970713973045349, 0.5141541361808777, -0.06679768115282059, -0.24114711582660675, 0.6473861336708069, 0.4096051752567291, -0.047045379877090454, 0.4491795003414154, 0.6941018104553223, -0.6631559729576111, 0.24546636641025543, 0.22925807535648346, 0.30449819564819336, -0.3914982080459595, 0.26715657114982605, -0.8530827760696411, -0.042555589228868484, -1.1615406274795532, -0.2355343997478485, 0.28995129466056824, 0.13081808388233185, -0.187596395611763, 0.925456702709198, 0.08218241482973099, 0.7092500925064087, 0.5294728875160217, -0.24919721484184265, 0.48155638575553894, 0.32747605443000793, -0.5151562094688416, 0.04219917580485344, -0.7140870094299316, -0.4331704080104828, 1.0181888341903687, -0.17282141745090485, 0.23217378556728363, 0.4786207377910614, 0.6260917782783508, 0.12863001227378845, 0.18756170570850372, -0.3936477303504944, 0.5337035059928894, -0.5254270434379578, -0.5614243149757385, -0.36696717143058777, -0.6798965334892273, -1.2076036930084229, -0.06646657735109329, -0.3202454447746277, -0.8155578374862671, 0.39959967136383057, 0.056213367730379105, -0.11320175975561142, 0.3006961941719055, -0.5805991291999817, 0.7186954617500305, -0.364055335521698, -0.10600282996892929, -0.0012423077132552862, -0.6343732476234436, 0.45736807584762573, -0.34203895926475525, 0.07511899620294571, -0.19496014714241028, 0.26793017983436584, 0.6304294466972351, -0.5225867033004761, 0.35644760727882385, 0.58836430311203, -0.06879758089780807, 0.2111356258392334, 0.7716205716133118, -0.04046867787837982, -0.11440149694681168, -0.3988437056541443, 0.2912328243255615, 0.21331468224525452, -0.4841098189353943, -0.6984462738037109, 0.8982393145561218, -0.4480825960636139, -0.3241328001022339, -0.5521113872528076, -0.3094530403614044, -0.1174493357539177, 0.323349267244339, 0.27818846702575684, 0.1840478926897049, -0.30606910586357117, 0.04093705862760544, 0.3454046845436096, -0.20316925644874573, 0.46728238463401794, 0.38632500171661377, -0.45047780871391296, -0.24507568776607513, 1.067495584487915, -0.22783271968364716, 0.5582140684127808, 0.39658212661743164, 0.545232892036438, -0.18385228514671326, -0.1901044249534607, -0.08825958520174026, 0.23311077058315277, -0.009305814281105995, 0.15587784349918365, -0.12980297207832336, -0.1450282633304596, -0.4107113182544708, -0.19756107032299042, 0.007236687932163477, -0.6451137661933899, 0.3642325699329376, 0.06784962117671967, 0.35846012830734253, 0.7738927602767944, -0.035356633365154266, -0.2013816237449646, -0.6418372988700867, 0.4305221736431122, 0.6074635982513428, 0.08628588169813156, -0.092254638671875, -0.44906193017959595, 0.7448862791061401, 0.042406115680933, -0.2082132250070572, -0.9806382060050964, 0.35139161348342896, 0.6109380722045898, 0.5028789639472961, 0.5480425357818604, -0.3106265664100647, 0.5131987929344177, -0.5205422043800354, 0.564373791217804, 0.2959389388561249, -0.7776088118553162, 0.27725353837013245, -0.48444226384162903, -0.18231147527694702, 0.686541736125946, 0.7316007614135742, -0.5714734792709351, -0.7792839407920837, -0.7834608554840088, -0.5259213447570801, 0.23028959333896637, 0.8229618072509766, -0.07559239119291306, -0.22027909755706787, 0.20439526438713074, 0.1424606889486313, -0.2652195990085602, -0.6577070951461792, -0.5331516861915588, 0.32954445481300354, -0.1981205940246582, -0.22720946371555328, -0.16311492025852203, 0.16804403066635132, -0.40451836585998535, 0.29165634512901306, 0.09351528435945511, 0.11946934461593628, 0.16372822225093842, 0.11813317984342575, -0.440242737531662, 0.19837352633476257, 0.5124514698982239, 0.6976813673973083, -0.207353875041008, 0.6161822080612183, 0.28756359219551086, -0.6502888202667236, 0.39766740798950195, -0.1765894740819931, -0.18913598358631134, 0.19843362271785736, 0.5981006622314453, 0.20162683725357056, 0.15376988053321838, -0.3521805703639984, 0.4541957378387451, -0.1046147570014, -0.13443954288959503, -0.10436896234750748, -0.07021909207105637, 0.3452954888343811, -0.13422228395938873, 0.1190701574087143, -0.005626159720122814, 0.11853162944316864, -1.222977638244629, 0.5088831782341003, 0.4991746246814728, -0.17930984497070312, -0.18952138721942902, 0.3429417014122009, 0.1826997995376587, -0.49056339263916016, 0.6879478693008423, -0.43837618827819824, -0.8388885855674744, 0.8823411464691162, 0.5359531044960022, 0.505558967590332, -0.5814374685287476, 0.021054258570075035, 0.6109852194786072, 0.43131616711616516, 0.08471564203500748, 0.23108205199241638, 0.15860971808433533, -0.6821959018707275, -0.27875128388404846, -0.8744127750396729, -0.13452830910682678, 0.13815733790397644, -0.3672651946544647, 0.3151407241821289, 0.02289249747991562, -0.11790016293525696, 0.10479364544153214, -0.28890490531921387, -0.09104837477207184, -0.11600705981254578, 0.25351983308792114, 0.6372674107551575, -1.0438767671585083, 0.8730359673500061, 0.26220330595970154, -0.23497527837753296, -0.7187507152557373, 0.4324599802494049, 0.09217724204063416, -0.6287364959716797, 0.7555853128433228, 0.07220301032066345, -0.05208265036344528, -0.20175209641456604, 0.11924517899751663, -1.0519226789474487, 0.7425937652587891, 0.8258715867996216, -0.8078764081001282, 0.3140389621257782, 0.29384303092956543, 0.6177237629890442, 0.007923136465251446, 0.13711236417293549, 0.6773557662963867, 0.3348132073879242, 0.10783545672893524, -1.1171716451644897, 0.1581716388463974, -0.07732444256544113, 0.09796924889087677, 0.6960462331771851, -0.14905846118927002, 0.5898858308792114, -0.0761181116104126, -0.24035003781318665, 0.30014777183532715, 0.6240267157554626, 0.39999210834503174, 0.29617759585380554, 0.6184366345405579, 0.6258741617202759, 0.47000181674957275, -0.06901794672012329, 1.20366632938385, -0.6954200267791748, 0.34619513154029846, 0.8284466862678528, -0.2251160591840744, 0.7287760972976685, 0.6098378300666809, -0.5747493505477905, 0.44326964020729065, 0.4648277759552002, 0.0884469673037529, 0.18254266679286957, 0.5437779426574707, -0.6207271218299866, -0.04358455538749695, -0.11580047756433487, -0.5346476435661316, 0.2477245032787323, 0.38264772295951843, -0.49635130167007446, -0.2926173508167267, -0.5524768829345703, -0.04730048403143883, 0.1067030280828476, 0.003932058345526457, 0.3436008393764496, 0.16749534010887146, -0.6913908123970032, 0.39802679419517517, -0.35281166434288025, 0.6061712503433228, -0.6703252792358398, -0.22742871940135956, -0.533584713935852, -0.04924149811267853, -0.27103710174560547, -0.6493380665779114, 0.4823291599750519, -0.16156625747680664, 0.08700732886791229, 0.3737386167049408, 0.46104884147644043, -0.610987663269043, -0.7090718150138855, 0.4843163788318634, 0.5405855178833008, 0.292571097612381, 0.12593722343444824, -0.359331876039505, -0.2603188157081604, 0.10237254947423935, 0.01628238707780838, 0.18187129497528076, 0.18186743557453156, -0.4605911672115326, 0.5250221490859985, 0.6773184537887573, 0.41801831126213074, 0.44343024492263794, -0.014279072172939777, 0.25315502285957336, -0.5546618700027466, -0.057225409895181656, -1.1480250358581543, -0.4462774991989136, 0.17046956717967987, -0.15411131083965302, 0.9791625142097473, 0.8436045050621033, 0.9442855715751648, -0.20091991126537323, 0.6668391823768616, -0.2935287058353424, 0.06503531336784363, -0.4723953902721405, 0.6105890274047852, -0.4806038737297058, -0.2861849069595337, -0.3772154152393341, -1.4350411891937256, -0.5291187763214111, 0.6201469302177429, -0.0826696902513504, -0.022861698642373085, 1.3608306646347046, 0.842835009098053, -0.39501914381980896, -0.13407579064369202, 0.43829405307769775, -0.03595481812953949, -0.16188423335552216, 0.586478590965271, 0.5894590020179749, -0.2594269812107086, 0.5012562870979309, -0.5261133313179016, -0.32630324363708496, 0.09204074740409851, -0.7921345829963684, -0.8468261957168579, -0.7329801321029663, -0.39129799604415894, -0.6172479391098022, 0.36288073658943176, 0.7690014243125916, 0.07795656472444534, -0.8874070644378662, -0.5116183161735535, -0.48132193088531494, 0.18111354112625122, -0.2622174322605133, -0.20615749061107635, 0.3154647648334503, 0.052749332040548325, -0.4871407747268677, 0.329222708940506, 0.32833942770957947, 0.5739412307739258, 0.022933781147003174, 0.0012180530466139317, -0.116904616355896, -0.019070453941822052, 0.38352805376052856, 0.7527868151664734, -0.7704794406890869, -0.41876471042633057, 0.016953079029917717, -0.23889032006263733, -0.0720655545592308, 1.2018409967422485, -0.49451470375061035, 0.26004838943481445, 0.7248759865760803, 0.3972438871860504, -0.10017430037260056, -0.27930402755737305, 0.8905984163284302, -0.5736923217773438, 0.21881651878356934, -0.024589166045188904, 0.5757134556770325, 0.06060025468468666, -0.18093432486057281, 0.825772762298584, 0.45905643701553345, -0.27015936374664307, -0.5366954207420349, 0.5450202822685242, -1.2421525716781616, 0.0021101878955960274, 1.392510175704956, -0.09411479532718658, -0.3482346534729004, -0.35324811935424805, -0.08741486072540283, 0.1234520822763443, 0.10214123129844666, 0.8869078755378723, 0.4789445400238037, 0.13515357673168182, 0.40635740756988525, -0.08962451666593552, 0.3785427510738373, 0.7108328342437744, -0.38096553087234497, -0.14890173077583313, -0.06556165218353271, 0.5722466111183167, 0.3095819652080536, 0.47597813606262207, -0.1569937914609909, 0.3446120321750641, -0.000798331864643842, 0.023061323910951614, 0.5577490925788879, 0.06767672300338745, -0.30931591987609863, -0.15653547644615173, 0.3750760853290558, -0.11845873296260834 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00282v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00282v1
Survey on Large Language Model-Enhanced Reinforcement Learning: Concept, Taxonomy, and Methods
2024-03-30T08:28:08
2024-03-30T08:28:08
Yuji Cao, Huan Zhao, Yuheng Cheng, Ting Shu, Guolong Liu, Gaoqi Liang, Junhua Zhao, Yun Li
cs.LG
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.RO
With extensive pre-trained knowledge and high-level general capabilities, large language models (LLMs) emerge as a promising avenue to augment reinforcement learning (RL) in aspects such as multi-task learning, sample efficiency, and task planning. In this survey, we provide a comprehensive review of the existing literature in $\textit{LLM-enhanced RL}$ and summarize its characteristics compared to conventional RL methods, aiming to clarify the research scope and directions for future studies. Utilizing the classical agent-environment interaction paradigm, we propose a structured taxonomy to systematically categorize LLMs' functionalities in RL, including four roles: information processor, reward designer, decision-maker, and generator. Additionally, for each role, we summarize the methodologies, analyze the specific RL challenges that are mitigated, and provide insights into future directions. Lastly, potential applications, prospective opportunities and challenges of the $\textit{LLM-enhanced RL}$ are discussed.
[ -0.39954128861427307, -0.8956324458122253, 0.49482110142707825, 0.09066027402877808, 0.06448273360729218, 0.32787850499153137, -0.5249654054641724, -0.5484158992767334, 0.12278132885694504, 0.6321890950202942, -0.5073636770248413, -0.19503101706504822, -0.6298251748085022, 0.1496167927980423, -0.1658196598291397, 1.0219415426254272, -0.01387690007686615, 0.008873309008777142, -0.19065642356872559, 0.12118347734212875, -0.306772917509079, -0.7411295771598816, -0.9437139630317688, -0.6000843048095703, 0.8526310920715332, 0.2535264790058136, 0.25843513011932373, 0.29578888416290283, 0.4323641061782837, 0.4197123646736145, -0.2439093440771103, 0.35233086347579956, -0.391738623380661, 0.44214069843292236, -0.14504383504390717, -0.1727466881275177, -0.602588415145874, -0.07350166887044907, 0.9188227653503418, 0.42710885405540466, -0.2366361767053604, 0.037741657346487045, 0.1748008280992508, 0.44417911767959595, -0.7762006521224976, 0.4208933115005493, -0.4042605757713318, 0.22002790868282318, -0.03705209121108055, -0.3629453182220459, -0.4457314610481262, -0.062043629586696625, 0.14101430773735046, -0.5585885643959045, -0.40908223390579224, -0.059663113206624985, 0.3536268472671509, 0.1837044507265091, -0.6514222621917725, -0.33079269528388977, -0.9653733968734741, 0.896389901638031, -0.49580052495002747, 0.40382394194602966, 0.13217498362064362, 0.2768981158733368, -0.21895600855350494, -0.6885207891464233, -0.2667404115200043, -0.5820719003677368, 0.014807634055614471, 0.2386951744556427, 0.014412790536880493, 0.29415518045425415, 0.32800668478012085, 0.23803508281707764, -0.2634800970554352, 0.5101022124290466, -0.16725210845470428, -0.1676001399755478, 0.7461813688278198, 0.3249003291130066, 0.07341265678405762, 0.03372466564178467, -0.4023037850856781, -0.2761501669883728, -0.7342982292175293, 0.2501406967639923, 0.31465935707092285, 0.2805807888507843, 0.11608526855707169, 0.43652862310409546, -0.321086585521698, 0.7064284682273865, -0.24278004467487335, -0.12589330971240997, 0.23554006218910217, -0.29182568192481995, -0.14891564846038818, -0.2443775087594986, 0.5549896955490112, -0.02381771244108677, 0.024663977324962616, -0.029621928930282593, -0.6437394618988037, -0.4423710107803345, 0.14508232474327087, -0.7702440023422241, 0.12844209372997284, 0.0790213942527771, -0.3829439878463745, -0.23573291301727295, 0.03922434523701668, -0.6092011332511902, -0.48023101687431335, -0.4050418436527252, 0.30465197563171387, -0.1375703662633896, -0.754372775554657, -0.027721617370843887, -0.095542311668396, 0.4168640971183777, 0.32078176736831665, -0.737321674823761, 0.3581736981868744, 0.8237277865409851, 0.5324913263320923, -0.44147107005119324, -0.3880774676799774, -0.7384384274482727, 0.10567092150449753, -0.13768714666366577, 0.7955241203308105, -0.7101444005966187, -0.43279245495796204, 0.436950147151947, -0.1330704540014267, 0.06537625193595886, -0.5207396149635315, 0.5034439563751221, -0.7458653450012207, 0.030736982822418213, -0.11741436272859573, -0.4258147180080414, -0.2294449359178543, 0.6660144925117493, -0.6594986319541931, 0.833595871925354, -0.14966340363025665, -0.4727688431739807, 0.23802433907985687, -0.7601006031036377, -0.4636159837245941, 0.27293264865875244, -0.17646026611328125, -0.3739273250102997, 0.029628830030560493, 0.11613281816244125, 0.6828553080558777, -0.1081145778298378, 0.4014661908149719, -0.12777535617351532, -0.18625493347644806, 0.5854483842849731, -0.3782936930656433, 0.4202112555503845, 0.3408357799053192, -0.06108784303069115, 0.6741530895233154, -0.4671224355697632, -0.00020637553825508803, 0.1421356350183487, -0.6960639357566833, -0.3257872760295868, 0.08095260709524155, 0.1945406049489975, 0.43967244029045105, 0.5507792830467224, -0.38110777735710144, 0.18503959476947784, -0.2734452486038208, 0.36597490310668945, 0.8430410027503967, 0.0991726964712143, 0.37191447615623474, -0.28837019205093384, 0.7672467231750488, -0.16266949474811554, 0.2744652330875397, -0.0828235074877739, -0.01931965909898281, -0.5313776731491089, -0.34328097105026245, 0.23314426839351654, 0.4624018967151642, -0.8336596488952637, 0.3983016908168793, -0.11272726953029633, -0.32099467515945435, -0.11221975833177567, 0.18876294791698456, 0.5074278116226196, -0.07449425011873245, 0.22719641029834747, -0.2643628716468811, -0.56741863489151, -0.630495011806488, -0.15291684865951538, -0.03495582938194275, 0.22233380377292633, 0.5698598623275757, 0.528960108757019, -0.31914687156677246, 0.6903054714202881, -0.40927591919898987, -0.06591587513685226, -0.7473554611206055, -0.16069310903549194, -0.020025456324219704, 0.26366791129112244, 0.16732913255691528, -0.7898311614990234, -0.35748133063316345, -0.010731346905231476, -0.40871790051460266, 0.08170891553163528, -0.050022661685943604, 0.20858070254325867, 0.19964857399463654, 0.6905394792556763, -0.5607112050056458, -0.027100753039121628, 0.4699769616127014, -0.2618570029735565, 0.67918461561203, -0.47196856141090393, 0.06214098259806633, -0.8664177656173706, 0.017386995255947113, 0.12168765813112259, -0.06675373017787933, -0.7802351713180542, 0.38376396894454956, 0.016256975010037422, 0.13861984014511108, -0.31298115849494934, 0.6665704250335693, -0.5174249410629272, -0.4747220575809479, -0.6153936982154846, 0.25795692205429077, -0.45369982719421387, 0.43150556087493896, 0.4629492163658142, 0.6502068638801575, 0.47636091709136963, -0.8025115132331848, 0.4290637671947479, 0.10274181514978409, -0.25183597207069397, 0.34677764773368835, -0.5818542242050171, -0.11845115572214127, -0.022602388635277748, 0.3904096484184265, -0.7497761845588684, -0.12812958657741547, 0.0937676727771759, -0.3908230662345886, 0.40721559524536133, 0.27512478828430176, -0.6666223406791687, -0.2722932696342468, -0.2755294144153595, 0.3460218608379364, 0.5065056681632996, -0.4879756569862366, 0.5442312359809875, 0.47960513830184937, -0.3137412667274475, -0.6932739019393921, -0.2565464675426483, 0.04805924743413925, -0.423033207654953, -0.030936861410737038, 0.2480284869670868, -0.012950833886861801, -0.3869621157646179, -0.21855631470680237, 0.14815926551818848, 0.08186182379722595, 0.3742723762989044, 0.0014906625729054213, 0.2867199778556824, 0.03255392611026764, 0.3603459894657135, -0.2953108251094818, -0.013785198330879211, 0.19938001036643982, -0.1420358121395111, 0.6283878684043884, -0.06609902530908585, -0.23735395073890686, 0.15776585042476654, 0.09112334996461868, 0.2027382254600525, -0.7657528519630432, 0.5683069825172424, 0.6532975435256958, -0.09528433531522751, -0.35203391313552856, -0.380138635635376, -0.3613974452018738, -0.4790506660938263, 0.8295964002609253, -0.22951172292232513, -1.2809832096099854, 0.3600301146507263, -0.45425018668174744, 0.2563415467739105, 0.32595089077949524, 0.6913244724273682, 0.1992195099592209, 0.9756043553352356, 0.6471505761146545, -0.10661853849887848, 0.794325053691864, -0.25587520003318787, 0.055389124900102615, -1.0950603485107422, -0.3898123800754547, -0.40759989619255066, -0.0530615858733654, -0.5859392285346985, -0.3705005347728729, 0.3544272482395172, -0.24179603159427643, -0.4765464961528778, 0.04958704859018326, -0.2071644812822342, 0.05034526437520981, 0.2639372944831848, -0.05505088344216347, 0.284504234790802, -0.10048181563615799, -0.04501331225037575, 0.42797088623046875, -0.7011709809303284, -0.2118457406759262, 1.1096806526184082, 0.5494995713233948, 0.7391266226768494, 0.2981970012187958, 0.649583101272583, 0.21671928465366364, 0.13197843730449677, -0.8198798298835754, 0.7241652607917786, 0.31915587186813354, -0.5908364653587341, -0.6509684324264526, -0.45596691966056824, -1.1130648851394653, 0.4479880630970001, -0.50441974401474, -0.5325779914855957, -0.36028966307640076, 0.09777145832777023, -0.18952873349189758, 0.24765098094940186, -0.2956351339817047, 0.6601296067237854, -0.670911967754364, -0.5468997359275818, -0.6444715261459351, -0.4365232586860657, 0.5285590291023254, -0.05500773712992668, 0.3218590319156647, 0.25354260206222534, -0.3804357051849365, 0.6581887602806091, 0.030290286988019943, 0.715229868888855, -0.31924790143966675, -0.3730953633785248, 0.13043677806854248, -0.23271061480045319, 0.8247184157371521, -0.12332312762737274, 0.14464975893497467, -0.30254799127578735, -0.14373083412647247, -0.1669175773859024, -0.36325985193252563, 0.6913150548934937, -0.7324619293212891, -0.5099597573280334, -0.5215808749198914, -0.6184161901473999, -0.5973442792892456, -0.021942108869552612, -0.2869480848312378, 0.3534814715385437, -0.3370806872844696, 0.22801770269870758, 0.88667893409729, -0.507529079914093, 0.4518168568611145, 0.7183113694190979, -0.459502637386322, -0.31133413314819336, 0.9718475937843323, -0.09432406723499298, 0.4119839668273926, 0.5670915842056274, 0.08605791628360748, -0.529883086681366, -0.8113192915916443, 0.11613892018795013, 0.06762775778770447, -0.5612438917160034, 0.11091793328523636, -0.6253584623336792, -0.3551596999168396, -0.3966280519962311, 0.1648186892271042, -0.18044786155223846, -0.16297145187854767, -0.10059954971075058, -0.24527156352996826, 0.3480282425880432, 0.9422999620437622, -0.040870264172554016, 0.3923490643501282, -0.6376276016235352, 0.10640871524810791, 0.3627675175666809, 0.42432913184165955, 0.3183346390724182, -0.39060163497924805, -0.44936591386795044, -0.2680683732032776, -0.1611132174730301, -0.44129741191864014, 0.4360602796077728, 0.0495324581861496, 0.9926387667655945, 0.290115624666214, -0.03603444993495941, 0.31302106380462646, -0.4093916118144989, 0.708676278591156, 0.21037432551383972, -0.5273566842079163, 0.32005223631858826, -0.38830244541168213, 0.17791472375392914, 0.13213251531124115, 0.20670533180236816, -0.6403232216835022, -0.27450069785118103, -0.5574110150337219, -1.0204360485076904, 0.5761775374412537, -0.2099996656179428, 0.09494936466217041, 0.06856659799814224, 0.09479624032974243, -0.029956532642245293, 0.32399582862854004, -0.9010100364685059, -0.18982437252998352, 0.1462157815694809, 0.08526308834552765, -0.5186229348182678, -0.37060773372650146, 0.11079710721969604, -0.20477649569511414, 0.7950634360313416, -0.11651524156332016, 0.19331368803977966, -0.09695601463317871, -0.22734300792217255, 0.08738256990909576, 0.7778149247169495, 0.7374802231788635, 0.48385077714920044, -0.049717485904693604, 0.010093623772263527, 0.3183477818965912, -0.2449372410774231, 0.1442561000585556, 0.08852468430995941, 0.009911068715155125, -0.5657818913459778, 0.4293085038661957, 0.8736202120780945, 0.2846194803714752, -1.0251051187515259, 0.25466975569725037, 0.046386413276195526, -0.2222319394350052, -0.6344524025917053, 0.20788699388504028, 0.0070671625435352325, 0.588566780090332, 0.4269702732563019, -0.38372084498405457, 0.18201139569282532, -0.6458666920661926, 0.14373360574245453, 0.8469700217247009, -0.38815009593963623, -0.07495500147342682, 0.1810884028673172, 0.4111506938934326, -0.12537363171577454, 0.4001480042934418, -0.23797136545181274, -0.563854992389679, 0.5932969450950623, 0.5761709213256836, 0.7988119721412659, -0.17627651989459991, 0.10720530897378922, 0.30617856979370117, 0.2641243040561676, -0.08700256049633026, 0.1759437769651413, -0.1845368891954422, -0.7577553987503052, -0.7061687111854553, -0.534457802772522, -0.4918714761734009, 0.4308650493621826, -0.47140929102897644, -0.04582231119275093, -0.40133771300315857, -0.03201553225517273, -0.3500177562236786, 0.2551775574684143, -0.5537460446357727, -0.07289909571409225, 0.3033617436885834, 0.8500367403030396, -0.6349272727966309, 0.9079874157905579, 1.0090142488479614, -0.31344228982925415, -0.7495128512382507, -0.05612611770629883, -0.18889650702476501, -0.5940538048744202, 0.8562881946563721, -0.12717249989509583, -0.18467189371585846, 0.1296006143093109, -0.33586475253105164, -0.7594740390777588, 1.183505892753601, -0.13733819127082825, -0.4357655346393585, -0.08371424674987793, -0.010253196582198143, 0.47737202048301697, -0.5465630292892456, 0.4567141532897949, 0.5936684608459473, 0.5800907015800476, -0.009713385254144669, -0.8699709177017212, -0.12290912121534348, -0.17900170385837555, 0.16062839329242706, 0.20322202146053314, -0.6748473644256592, 0.6958823204040527, 0.05745742842555046, 0.0812692642211914, 0.04853927716612816, 0.7025384902954102, 0.33603331446647644, 0.1064184308052063, 0.5619316697120667, 0.2627118229866028, 0.549964964389801, 0.12285448610782623, 1.0178440809249878, -0.2777068018913269, 0.2830311357975006, 0.9707609415054321, -0.44071823358535767, 0.8255583047866821, 0.3672279715538025, -0.17528435587882996, 0.33624786138534546, 0.6659111976623535, 0.051260922104120255, 0.49150633811950684, 0.4357585310935974, -0.3950479030609131, -0.5076247453689575, -0.27709707617759705, -0.21540409326553345, 0.4365951418876648, 0.6095176339149475, -0.17585009336471558, -0.23336759209632874, 0.2680943012237549, -0.3707108199596405, 0.21947509050369263, -0.8519529700279236, 0.9802957773208618, 0.050233032554388046, -0.6588039398193359, 0.07385055720806122, 0.13203978538513184, 1.0267711877822876, -0.7882554531097412, -0.08432465046644211, 0.04590141773223877, 0.22572456300258636, -0.10755126178264618, -0.8861063122749329, -0.09913273900747299, -0.06570101529359818, 0.12948158383369446, -0.4119488000869751, 0.9288628101348877, -0.4750329554080963, -0.03312182053923607, 0.4420989453792572, 0.720592737197876, -0.06343885511159897, 0.16762706637382507, -0.765794038772583, 0.06753519922494888, -0.31544384360313416, -0.37176546454429626, 0.6361384391784668, 0.15366984903812408, -0.00979633629322052, 0.9191158413887024, 0.31489673256874084, 0.28085172176361084, -0.06981796771287918, 0.018765466287732124, 0.7709898352622986, -0.6525051593780518, -0.48517298698425293, -0.6773735880851746, 0.43255680799484253, -0.20136110484600067, -0.13933996856212616, 0.8274348974227905, 0.5317398905754089, 0.9953304529190063, -0.13288062810897827, 0.9723312258720398, 0.015938816592097282, 0.4994816780090332, -0.6230127215385437, 0.2978496849536896, -0.5641390681266785, 0.18888498842716217, -0.198873370885849, -0.7700984477996826, 0.03446927294135094, 0.4040478467941284, -0.4397664964199066, 0.30920976400375366, 0.5718784332275391, 0.6353554725646973, 0.09176868945360184, -0.28958025574684143, 0.38193029165267944, -0.06355856359004974, 0.35772472620010376, 0.5883333086967468, 1.320777416229248, 0.27877935767173767, 0.3754042983055115, 0.14076612889766693, -0.06467770785093307, -0.445961594581604, -0.6834152340888977, -0.9176018834114075, -0.6725999116897583, -0.19023409485816956, -0.07257390767335892, 0.09579934179782867, 1.3068658113479614, 0.49420875310897827, -0.5020387172698975, -0.4854044020175934, -0.04368891194462776, 0.2316361963748932, -0.3697846531867981, -0.1387510448694229, 0.16624508798122406, -0.4922926425933838, -0.6759884357452393, 0.4131496846675873, 0.17354558408260345, -0.22132916748523712, -0.5709768533706665, -0.5837067365646362, -0.12984906136989594, -0.03950708359479904, 0.8774166703224182, 0.5621616244316101, -0.6458418369293213, -0.1621699035167694, -0.12859828770160675, -0.1651890128850937, -0.30679571628570557, 0.9836645722389221, -0.6082794666290283, 0.07746007293462753, 0.3935086131095886, 0.8317586779594421, 0.4000749886035919, -0.23908884823322296, 0.47732871770858765, -0.6517141461372375, 0.042798880487680435, 0.27671581506729126, 0.2723545432090759, 0.10211102664470673, -0.17366299033164978, 0.3077903091907501, -0.10842819511890411, -0.5969502925872803, -0.71840500831604, 0.5557810068130493, -0.9278701543807983, -0.5448747277259827, 1.4948410987854004, -0.014231925830245018, -0.02725161425769329, -0.03724588826298714, -0.11371465772390366, 0.25476160645484924, -0.38451114296913147, 0.41777172684669495, 0.5132201313972473, -0.15476936101913452, -0.510549008846283, -0.8234058618545532, 0.6543216109275818, 0.11719944328069687, -1.0376224517822266, 0.17265836894512177, 0.8024285435676575, 0.05063917860388756, -0.12947289645671844, 0.48447614908218384, 0.017723478376865387, 0.2840074598789215, -0.4651731848716736, 0.2847684621810913, -0.3839320242404938, -0.3427601158618927, -0.6559098958969116, 0.19127656519412994, 0.7860215306282043, 0.15933574736118317 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00267v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00267v2
Secret Keepers: The Impact of LLMs on Linguistic Markers of Personal Traits
2024-03-30T06:49:17
2024-04-03T17:29:12
Zhivar Sourati, Meltem Ozcan, Colin McDaniel, Alireza Ziabari, Nuan Wen, Ala Tak, Fred Morstatter, Morteza Dehghani
cs.CL
cs.CL
Prior research has established associations between individuals' language usage and their personal traits; our linguistic patterns reveal information about our personalities, emotional states, and beliefs. However, with the increasing adoption of Large Language Models (LLMs) as writing assistants in everyday writing, a critical question emerges: are authors' linguistic patterns still predictive of their personal traits when LLMs are involved in the writing process? We investigate the impact of LLMs on the linguistic markers of demographic and psychological traits, specifically examining three LLMs - GPT3.5, Llama 2, and Gemini - across six different traits: gender, age, political affiliation, personality, empathy, and morality. Our findings indicate that although the use of LLMs slightly reduces the predictive power of linguistic patterns over authors' personal traits, the significant changes are infrequent, and the use of LLMs does not fully diminish the predictive power of authors' linguistic patterns over their personal traits. We also note that some theoretically established lexical-based linguistic markers lose their reliability as predictors when LLMs are used in the writing process. Our findings have important implications for the study of linguistic markers of personal traits in the age of LLMs.
[ -0.14569908380508423, -0.36677610874176025, 0.825874388217926, 0.08573070913553238, 0.0459846556186676, 0.02643311768770218, -0.3109584450721741, -0.8250939249992371, 0.3601473569869995, 0.7509832382202148, -0.6774728894233704, -0.5693084001541138, -0.9179689288139343, 0.5023346543312073, -0.12902124226093292, 0.9975566267967224, 0.015873504802584648, 0.261209100484848, -0.04147052764892578, -0.024135537445545197, -0.1944597214460373, -0.9301661252975464, -0.4091702103614807, -0.23689839243888855, 0.7890118360519409, 0.1917283684015274, 0.7532997727394104, 0.9951175451278687, 0.6317853927612305, 0.21816563606262207, -0.30417323112487793, -0.020781511440873146, -0.4828176498413086, 0.43396565318107605, 0.006602858658879995, -1.0119667053222656, -0.3508584201335907, 0.3769678473472595, 0.43195706605911255, 0.6845081448554993, 0.1177501305937767, 0.26694443821907043, -0.12695367634296417, 0.8401731848716736, -0.6047900915145874, 0.27705198526382446, -0.4802095592021942, 0.0384686142206192, -0.4945085942745209, -0.13522768020629883, -0.21226851642131805, -0.5039438605308533, -0.031531188637018204, -0.46077409386634827, 0.2313930094242096, -0.03032221831381321, 0.6535399556159973, 0.15762007236480713, -0.42097097635269165, -0.5608011484146118, -0.6842347383499146, 0.752199113368988, -0.7696791291236877, 0.05917862430214882, 0.7481575608253479, -0.06780503690242767, -0.2224394530057907, -0.14297382533550262, -0.5152662992477417, -0.3238987624645233, -0.2658154368400574, -0.11580581963062286, 0.13421611487865448, -0.07223460078239441, 0.48954540491104126, 0.25146034359931946, -0.15083061158657074, 0.2757010757923126, -0.3635922968387604, -0.23083098232746124, 0.5494640469551086, 0.4202307462692261, 0.4132678210735321, 0.048426054418087006, 0.017878804355859756, 0.22786970436573029, -1.157178282737732, 0.048667412251234055, 0.756044864654541, 0.3931049406528473, 0.03993712738156319, 0.650025486946106, -0.07287629693746567, 0.43648093938827515, -0.1182088851928711, -0.40066492557525635, 0.11223381012678146, -0.17973610758781433, 0.3658182919025421, -0.12058724462985992, 0.7922474145889282, 0.39794936776161194, 0.8600957989692688, -0.1529453992843628, 0.07996688038110733, 0.19666843116283417, -0.32761064171791077, -0.5418840646743774, -0.1992970108985901, -0.2415306121110916, -0.5014857649803162, -0.2910241484642029, 0.1147397980093956, -0.5020148158073425, -0.9103527069091797, -0.11115102469921112, -0.09383979439735413, -0.23892487585544586, -0.1490297019481659, -0.03768639266490936, -0.3053804039955139, 0.27130553126335144, 0.35095906257629395, -1.1906423568725586, 0.44550102949142456, 0.7720164060592651, 0.6959596872329712, -0.2681148946285248, -0.452241450548172, -0.42172640562057495, 0.21916678547859192, -0.421582967042923, 0.49433669447898865, -0.9951906800270081, -0.5546814203262329, 0.20534537732601166, -0.047099411487579346, -0.0916280448436737, -0.4492018520832062, 0.49627116322517395, -0.2512318789958954, 0.25491660833358765, -0.6942733526229858, -0.5979489088058472, 0.2595093846321106, -0.2740428149700165, -0.6209360361099243, 0.8306199908256531, -0.07796598970890045, -0.4150390625, 0.4762815535068512, -0.2196296900510788, -0.330806702375412, -0.03543136641383171, -0.1653120368719101, -0.4513322710990906, 0.4165467619895935, -0.1366376429796219, 0.7375059723854065, -0.11564433574676514, 0.033488333225250244, -0.33241596817970276, -0.573322057723999, 0.9158456325531006, -0.11772297322750092, 0.48368000984191895, -0.1646062582731247, -0.20362918078899384, -0.3340321481227875, -0.6017897129058838, -0.23547466099262238, -0.03631846234202385, -0.5817865133285522, -0.1858365833759308, 0.12326613068580627, -0.3524519205093384, 0.16045325994491577, 0.38169363141059875, -0.7004270553588867, 0.3772730827331543, 0.0928545594215393, 0.2297825962305069, 0.9656323194503784, 0.0757448673248291, 0.3609342575073242, -0.49296388030052185, 0.7146626114845276, -0.3441946506500244, 0.14409685134887695, -0.1160515770316124, -0.8618638515472412, -0.6604540944099426, -0.3624821901321411, 0.061779119074344635, 0.4368247389793396, -0.05184728279709816, 0.7017532587051392, -0.1787583976984024, -0.539311945438385, -0.4318160116672516, 0.5656643509864807, 0.7534084320068359, -0.1710246354341507, 0.0823768600821495, 0.09157320111989975, -0.3965860605239868, -0.7743965983390808, -0.9784224033355713, -0.42109209299087524, 0.005385646130889654, 0.12435252964496613, 0.4151064157485962, -0.11752237379550934, 0.8001846075057983, -0.6368368864059448, -0.5173413157463074, -0.4396001100540161, -0.06832295656204224, 0.22118182480335236, 0.16328953206539154, 0.5877033472061157, -0.41230496764183044, -0.49438512325286865, -0.23797492682933807, -0.3706633746623993, -0.5868276953697205, 0.10972939431667328, -0.05431455373764038, 0.12787695229053497, 0.5797361731529236, -0.613824188709259, 0.4634972810745239, 0.8783817291259766, -0.7565581798553467, 0.7619214057922363, 0.2098008245229721, -0.20188802480697632, -0.6987537741661072, -0.19298674166202545, -0.05448049679398537, 0.09536749124526978, -0.7983559370040894, -0.17209984362125397, 0.05464865639805794, 0.1578761637210846, -0.08788950741291046, 0.7067543268203735, -0.7137159109115601, 0.13434448838233948, -0.0640815794467926, -0.16359440982341766, -0.014060108922421932, 0.28831303119659424, 0.047268569469451904, 0.8001078963279724, 0.45025378465652466, -0.4060501158237457, -0.19040261209011078, 0.23030398786067963, -0.348976194858551, 0.28772228956222534, -0.20304584503173828, 0.36780521273612976, -0.15436048805713654, 0.0589250773191452, -0.7318211793899536, -0.1131570041179657, 0.1675182580947876, -0.41455382108688354, 0.39410990476608276, 0.08416088670492172, -0.5306798815727234, 0.005080954637378454, -0.4773884415626526, -0.31802377104759216, 0.4697188138961792, -0.08091526478528976, 0.7411928176879883, 0.2704918086528778, -0.4097558259963989, -0.3633684515953064, -0.9537914991378784, 0.21356375515460968, -0.15421822667121887, -0.2983306348323822, 0.12386370450258255, -0.4128166437149048, -0.5045878887176514, -0.1148369088768959, -0.09823719412088394, 0.08010076731443405, 0.1645573079586029, 0.5522749423980713, 0.25408798456192017, -0.04301806539297104, 0.2645716071128845, -0.12542153894901276, -0.1730281412601471, 0.11427289247512817, 0.28420913219451904, 0.4573926627635956, -0.3757784068584442, 0.05458834767341614, -0.4338676929473877, 0.3224446177482605, 0.6534715294837952, -0.31413334608078003, 1.2434406280517578, 0.3962923288345337, -0.004398277960717678, -0.11802805215120316, -0.9111120700836182, -0.11093156784772873, -0.46399596333503723, 0.19160687923431396, -0.42401787638664246, -0.9086238145828247, 0.8138126730918884, 0.170468270778656, -0.3419046700000763, 0.3921762704849243, 0.44705602526664734, -0.30184534192085266, 0.7126312851905823, 0.8988653421401978, -0.2050921767950058, 0.7427818179130554, -0.051052626222372055, 0.20901526510715485, -1.017883539199829, -0.07672283798456192, -0.49278688430786133, -0.44206008315086365, -0.8534126281738281, -0.1645895093679428, 0.23121434450149536, 0.024493461474776268, -0.008742027916014194, 0.056633930653333664, -0.30605563521385193, 0.6830883026123047, 0.464150071144104, 0.0968550592660904, 0.4852055311203003, -0.31818005442619324, 0.3903287351131439, -0.343672513961792, -0.2309560626745224, -0.905223548412323, 1.242330551147461, 0.4498116970062256, 0.8747016787528992, 0.19183683395385742, 0.6466289162635803, 0.36953309178352356, 0.43455564975738525, -0.37501510977745056, 0.8375449776649475, -0.3507513701915741, -0.5673686861991882, -0.3655950129032135, -0.4007391035556793, -0.5689895749092102, -0.13428691029548645, -0.19326215982437134, -1.0130882263183594, 0.46378061175346375, -0.008314868435263634, -0.13475462794303894, 0.23176494240760803, -0.7381063103675842, 0.4832841157913208, -0.28557005524635315, -0.1627332717180252, 0.2510654926300049, -0.6346731781959534, 0.11908691376447678, -0.20314009487628937, 0.010036868043243885, -0.8182157278060913, -0.5858194828033447, 0.931011974811554, -0.3390922248363495, 1.2754238843917847, -0.04057511314749718, -0.15550768375396729, -0.08104275166988373, 0.3388061225414276, 0.7437328696250916, -0.1433262825012207, -0.48898351192474365, 0.5045070648193359, 0.011172429658472538, -0.06020825356245041, -0.6072709560394287, 0.8190007209777832, -1.0373276472091675, -0.7627149820327759, -0.5990685820579529, -0.4869045615196228, -0.12680824100971222, 0.09150558710098267, 0.25683140754699707, 0.21948839724063873, -0.08437561988830566, -0.00859907642006874, 0.3578142821788788, -0.023174213245511055, 0.4265947937965393, 0.7977722883224487, -0.0025104014202952385, -0.29528823494911194, 0.5732327103614807, 0.2042488008737564, 0.5235322117805481, 0.3396435081958771, 0.6748552918434143, 0.06188027933239937, -0.5338975191116333, 0.043976590037345886, 0.7510923743247986, -0.7874391674995422, 0.04439311847090721, -0.6705618500709534, -0.05407591909170151, -0.3777860999107361, -0.29106056690216064, 0.004325360991060734, -0.5316051244735718, -0.5062450170516968, -0.10572551190853119, 0.6797870993614197, 1.0331308841705322, 0.16372379660606384, 0.46813663840293884, -0.5307753682136536, 0.15518006682395935, 0.14454986155033112, 0.18943741917610168, -0.46939408779144287, -0.4221130907535553, -0.11367077380418777, -0.31416186690330505, -0.01784518174827099, -1.2135974168777466, 0.29981565475463867, 0.491863876581192, 0.45024096965789795, 0.5969380736351013, -0.37752875685691833, 0.3066825270652771, -0.27607402205467224, 0.9411200881004333, -0.06374884396791458, -1.0926867723464966, 0.24853923916816711, -0.5696566104888916, 0.42477384209632874, 0.6728898286819458, 0.17605699598789215, -0.9121596217155457, -0.9039408564567566, -0.29501521587371826, -0.40753743052482605, 0.5079750418663025, 0.24429398775100708, 0.24814487993717194, -0.08650811016559601, 0.6204405426979065, 0.3895398676395416, 0.36824628710746765, -0.8349376320838928, -0.34138694405555725, 0.290591835975647, -0.05903808772563934, -0.198799267411232, -0.6592772006988525, 0.12211635708808899, -0.2892929017543793, 0.3920672833919525, -0.1916991025209427, 0.14590565860271454, -0.09417753666639328, 0.20909640192985535, -0.15170159935951233, 0.2797154486179352, 0.5517136454582214, 0.5764620900154114, -0.06888508796691895, 0.1756424754858017, 0.24019041657447815, -0.7552862763404846, 0.07839274406433105, -0.22819887101650238, -0.31344595551490784, -0.006190119311213493, 0.7363811135292053, 0.5613762140274048, 0.16457366943359375, -0.3842563033103943, 0.5604975819587708, 0.04852928966283798, 0.05178981274366379, -0.6460017561912537, 0.292257696390152, 0.2662208080291748, 0.03303058445453644, 0.23248541355133057, 0.21757155656814575, -0.16635264456272125, -0.891792893409729, -0.40051308274269104, 0.42892611026763916, -0.3220689296722412, -0.46263325214385986, 0.28945809602737427, 0.12857164442539215, -0.4929424524307251, 0.31074413657188416, -0.16475532948970795, -0.6951755285263062, 0.4364032745361328, 0.4098604917526245, 1.0646058320999146, -0.5193033218383789, 0.11199766397476196, -0.13121099770069122, 0.37128686904907227, 0.13701722025871277, 0.4625436067581177, 0.016953494399785995, -0.9095454812049866, -0.22869262099266052, -0.8790081739425659, -0.4270523190498352, -0.1715586632490158, -0.5570446848869324, 0.23804090917110443, -0.4490710198879242, -0.35696738958358765, -0.27649223804473877, 0.18055322766304016, -0.8567584753036499, -0.022245245054364204, 0.24003855884075165, 0.568453848361969, -0.9038124680519104, 0.5783719420433044, 0.43941235542297363, -0.13971035182476044, -0.3983794152736664, 0.04905388504266739, 0.3289739787578583, -0.8443732261657715, 0.8375794291496277, 0.15326769649982452, -0.2148754894733429, -0.23635725677013397, -0.41981241106987, -1.1327018737792969, 0.9103329181671143, 0.3141386806964874, -0.5601337552070618, -0.30994197726249695, 0.4628937840461731, 0.7987913489341736, -0.3539758324623108, 0.24531295895576477, 0.7997263669967651, 0.7290011048316956, -0.35849204659461975, -0.8894554972648621, 0.06901019811630249, -0.33401304483413696, -0.011517158709466457, 0.43786871433258057, -0.711612343788147, 0.8057884573936462, -0.5046405792236328, -0.2697986960411072, 0.42269688844680786, 0.3574305474758148, 0.10123182833194733, -0.19271965324878693, 0.16968345642089844, 0.2568027973175049, 0.8223291039466858, -0.23421832919120789, 0.9878121018409729, -0.5450899004936218, -0.18595300614833832, 0.8523947596549988, -0.3666013777256012, 0.8552873134613037, 0.4851021468639374, -0.08327535539865494, 0.8094716668128967, 0.06801389902830124, -0.16180181503295898, 0.32012590765953064, 0.3006543815135956, -0.3356699049472809, -0.0016969391144812107, -0.31141743063926697, -0.2933357059955597, 0.5512299537658691, 0.5019957423210144, -0.748892068862915, 0.3352265954017639, -0.1565355509519577, 0.687657356262207, 0.17846566438674927, -0.1671917587518692, 0.7868876457214355, 0.3108205199241638, -0.407901793718338, 0.024996187537908554, -0.178679421544075, 0.7457647919654846, -0.9279921054840088, 0.2118074744939804, -0.1793808937072754, 0.31476834416389465, -0.2831712067127228, -1.109639048576355, 0.05325144901871681, 0.06337907165288925, -0.38634008169174194, -0.7160739898681641, 0.7879374623298645, -0.3769018352031708, -0.4853496849536896, 0.31197020411491394, 0.7043144702911377, 0.10947198420763016, -0.2662077248096466, -0.1337536722421646, 0.22974206507205963, -0.2349328100681305, -0.4757041335105896, 0.30833667516708374, 0.3837278485298157, 0.06376899778842926, 0.7269940972328186, 0.8305482268333435, 0.7131270170211792, 0.2699618935585022, 0.1879635751247406, 0.644770622253418, -0.9412977695465088, -0.3215523958206177, -1.0033690929412842, 0.11868321895599365, 0.01683676429092884, -0.8109100461006165, 1.1334855556488037, 0.3764842748641968, 0.5353900194168091, -0.30009105801582336, 0.7710264921188354, 0.25638335943222046, 0.5179890990257263, -0.6783018112182617, 0.9500003457069397, 0.021525045856833458, 0.22342590987682343, -0.3132840692996979, -0.9839382767677307, -0.2550031542778015, 0.11066742241382599, -0.6568336486816406, 0.3311469554901123, 0.8142125606536865, 0.8479583263397217, 0.7672114372253418, 0.11787337064743042, 0.450977623462677, 0.23357714712619781, 0.35590916872024536, 0.41696640849113464, 1.1476008892059326, 0.0563274621963501, 0.2791379392147064, -0.4814542829990387, -0.24766261875629425, -0.09025385230779648, -0.844407320022583, -1.1890709400177002, -0.459743469953537, -0.30944815278053284, -0.11824654787778854, 0.24751833081245422, 0.6357865929603577, 0.26521751284599304, -0.46417519450187683, -0.28588157892227173, 0.10503790527582169, -0.05706912279129028, -0.15155060589313507, -0.2441740781068802, 0.18717758357524872, 0.09065531194210052, -0.48452430963516235, 0.1651330143213272, 0.4307505488395691, 0.1623518317937851, -0.4475526809692383, -0.11225724220275879, 0.1393502801656723, 0.05388469994068146, 0.37150633335113525, 0.1603918820619583, -1.0563684701919556, -0.23667454719543457, 0.26800113916397095, -0.25006288290023804, -0.07040902972221375, 0.9293516874313354, -0.5476496815681458, 0.3845727741718292, 0.548941433429718, -0.2532825171947479, 0.10111504793167114, -0.03823861479759216, 0.706072986125946, -0.5792756676673889, -0.21338555216789246, 0.328482985496521, 0.5349665284156799, 0.45660459995269775, -0.7598164081573486, 0.5202015042304993, 0.31726160645484924, -0.5701785683631897, -0.5705828666687012, 0.25760218501091003, -0.656995415687561, 0.029769431799650192, 1.5000011920928955, 0.09723813831806183, -0.16292065382003784, -0.06108751893043518, -0.18512196838855743, -0.21286071836948395, -0.5423179864883423, 0.6823508143424988, 0.8146283030509949, -0.20920224487781525, -0.2219180315732956, -0.5152837038040161, 0.8084136247634888, 0.2964337468147278, -0.6912627816200256, 0.2989256680011749, 0.28885477781295776, 0.21929816901683807, 0.197382852435112, 0.6642862558364868, -0.015016592107713223, 0.09239792823791504, -0.10117793083190918, 0.09215269237756729, -0.1641746312379837, -0.22935880720615387, -0.20301036536693573, -0.1345752775669098, 0.20301954448223114, 0.16666948795318604 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00264v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00264v1
DiLM: Distilling Dataset into Language Model for Text-level Dataset Distillation
2024-03-30T06:40:54
2024-03-30T06:40:54
Aru Maekawa, Satoshi Kosugi, Kotaro Funakoshi, Manabu Okumura
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.LG
Dataset distillation aims to compress a training dataset by creating a small number of informative synthetic samples such that neural networks trained on them perform as well as those trained on the original training dataset. Current text dataset distillation methods create each synthetic sample as a sequence of word embeddings instead of a text to apply gradient-based optimization; however, such embedding-level distilled datasets cannot be used for training other models whose word embedding weights are different from the model used for distillation. To address this issue, we propose a novel text dataset distillation approach, called Distilling dataset into Language Model (DiLM), which trains a language model to generate informative synthetic training samples as text data, instead of directly optimizing synthetic samples. We evaluated DiLM on various text classification datasets and showed that distilled synthetic datasets from DiLM outperform those from current coreset selection methods. DiLM achieved remarkable generalization performance in training different types of models and in-context learning of large language models. Our code will be available at https://github.com/arumaekawa/DiLM.
[ -0.15817750990390778, -0.9076074957847595, 0.35877206921577454, 0.203817218542099, -0.4691827595233917, 0.016289932653307915, -0.6473190784454346, -0.10835057497024536, -0.007526470813900232, 0.41700342297554016, -0.33171555399894714, -0.5563847422599792, -0.621418297290802, 0.24415045976638794, -0.752162754535675, 1.1960901021957397, -0.03707382455468178, 0.13976231217384338, -0.3173690438270569, -0.03924303129315376, -0.4983888566493988, -0.5668583512306213, -0.5240389108657837, -0.599432647228241, 0.1848943680524826, 0.3305719196796417, 0.2845422327518463, 0.823131263256073, 0.4596726596355438, 0.30250439047813416, -0.06031692773103714, 0.2886851131916046, -0.5240851044654846, 0.3030606210231781, 0.13941769301891327, -0.6538481116294861, -0.06673531979322433, 0.2618922293186188, 0.6470929384231567, 0.8138969540596008, -0.28230053186416626, 0.03738289698958397, 0.26282671093940735, 0.9155786037445068, -0.5138955116271973, 0.2793383002281189, -0.9353941679000854, 0.03967159986495972, -0.09294253587722778, -0.0020342289935797453, -0.39258506894111633, -0.4594172537326813, 0.27317801117897034, -0.5107244849205017, 0.4332159459590912, 0.06953369081020355, 0.636901319026947, 0.3975733816623688, -0.20636796951293945, -0.391206830739975, -1.0787208080291748, 1.014815092086792, -0.7353020906448364, 0.02287059649825096, 0.4374474287033081, 0.4232847988605499, 0.147735595703125, -0.880395233631134, -0.7286807298660278, -0.09619858860969543, 0.026811612769961357, -0.0916384756565094, -0.07095374912023544, -0.049570273607969284, 0.1879153996706009, 0.791363537311554, -0.45407819747924805, -0.272259384393692, -0.22426433861255646, 0.20960916578769684, 0.6221301555633545, -0.032806478440761566, 0.2343088686466217, 0.14238163828849792, -0.2782333195209503, -0.2607593536376953, -0.5028550624847412, -0.4077466130256653, 0.40116196870803833, 0.6099097728729248, 0.1027960479259491, 0.5339164137840271, -0.1369616538286209, 0.7265182137489319, 0.01619739457964897, -0.0221041701734066, 0.45963263511657715, -0.3763849139213562, -0.3934284746646881, 0.2945573627948761, 0.7533530592918396, 0.12280693650245667, 0.6922466158866882, -0.1157103031873703, -0.36794185638427734, -0.029051953926682472, 0.2501167356967926, -1.0962201356887817, -0.5390998721122742, 0.27912989258766174, -0.4095953106880188, -0.6674536466598511, 0.1300266534090042, -0.7089328169822693, -0.37413743138313293, -0.4880143404006958, 0.2678194046020508, -0.38047608733177185, -0.2323054075241089, 0.25177380442619324, -0.3327237665653229, -0.03300528973340988, -0.059697024524211884, -0.952631950378418, 0.47812145948410034, 0.5526832342147827, 0.955630362033844, -0.263215571641922, -0.12158416211605072, -0.3118673861026764, -0.04849608242511749, -0.1905810534954071, 0.5445722341537476, -0.5829945206642151, -0.5142918825149536, -0.009314345195889473, -0.21280093491077423, 0.10375382751226425, -0.8918842673301697, 0.5346670150756836, -0.4194953441619873, 0.24677680432796478, 0.0695221945643425, -0.763431966304779, -0.15505699813365936, 0.4521353542804718, -0.9171056747436523, 1.1124446392059326, -0.1692778468132019, -0.9359806776046753, 0.3547319173812866, -0.5055431127548218, -0.49922558665275574, -0.060042500495910645, -0.162282332777977, -0.5704387426376343, 0.2902843654155731, 0.4198240637779236, 0.3822295367717743, -0.4573633372783661, 0.43060797452926636, -0.19975079596042633, -0.3013850152492523, 0.2665102183818817, -0.5494306683540344, 0.6027320027351379, 0.15655633807182312, -0.00958226528018713, -0.315822571516037, -0.8295848965644836, -0.12366543710231781, 0.16868768632411957, -0.48852142691612244, -0.8479754328727722, 0.057422664016485214, 0.1498185247182846, 0.03414759039878845, 0.31920090317726135, -0.5954382419586182, 0.4693698287010193, -0.503939688205719, 0.4848591685295105, 0.4638347029685974, -0.007425722200423479, 0.6281574964523315, -0.19183041155338287, 0.294329971075058, 0.16076380014419556, -0.1351759135723114, -0.19443178176879883, -0.3548348546028137, -0.8830102682113647, -0.42366838455200195, 0.739775538444519, 0.5295261144638062, -0.8123639225959778, 0.5557530522346497, -0.515950620174408, -0.45918357372283936, -0.394123375415802, 0.16079963743686676, 0.2776440978050232, 0.5362908840179443, 0.30892765522003174, 0.07198724150657654, -0.5451374650001526, -0.9379251003265381, -0.26257559657096863, -0.07451892644166946, -0.11430049687623978, 0.03068818524479866, 0.49925297498703003, -0.15738710761070251, 1.3311843872070312, -0.8634876608848572, -0.4949103593826294, -0.43715596199035645, 0.27083620429039, 0.3837953209877014, 0.5696111917495728, 0.3929841220378876, -1.025747537612915, -0.6822422742843628, 0.004996421746909618, -0.6995622515678406, -0.2378169745206833, -0.04476184397935867, 0.08013070374727249, -0.16099801659584045, 0.595510721206665, -0.09100384265184402, 0.20970624685287476, 0.549689769744873, -0.02297850139439106, 0.34986603260040283, -0.2855096757411957, -0.10798807442188263, -1.613988995552063, 0.24722406268119812, 0.11136569827795029, -0.36943039298057556, -0.7571349740028381, -0.2588350474834442, 0.07150943577289581, -0.18206416070461273, -0.36365339159965515, 0.45128878951072693, -0.5175795555114746, 0.2950132191181183, -0.4812906086444855, -0.07246504724025726, 0.3075130879878998, 0.33073967695236206, 0.0563509501516819, 0.6837943196296692, 0.6187496781349182, -0.6422088742256165, 0.6026974320411682, 0.43185892701148987, -0.4509323835372925, 0.172125905752182, -0.8433583974838257, 0.0849912017583847, -0.21826353669166565, 0.18466079235076904, -0.8460835218429565, 0.04305832460522652, -0.09594618529081345, -0.2622755467891693, 0.4806636571884155, -0.3467777669429779, -0.5362879633903503, -0.12125765532255173, -0.29198843240737915, 0.4494635760784149, 0.5390461087226868, -0.5472047924995422, 0.4983169734477997, 0.47926658391952515, -0.16152456402778625, -0.5850643515586853, -1.1372485160827637, -0.020979203283786774, -0.5337150692939758, -0.3029600977897644, 0.5618832111358643, -0.1058647409081459, -0.2722240090370178, -0.08055990189313889, -0.032362546771764755, -0.4613306224346161, -0.04467300698161125, 0.07222649455070496, 0.44941598176956177, 0.19232040643692017, 0.3697361648082733, 0.31813961267471313, -0.11426256597042084, -0.0356614850461483, -0.5858837962150574, 0.6084142327308655, 0.18624168634414673, -0.0008345990208908916, -0.2774675488471985, 0.2499198317527771, 0.28894612193107605, -0.18492157757282257, 0.8985739946365356, 0.37445691227912903, -0.5555983781814575, -0.5892325639724731, -0.30474555492401123, -0.2870429456233978, -0.4711958169937134, 0.4167978763580322, -0.38412418961524963, -0.7762040495872498, 0.33170169591903687, -0.30321744084358215, 0.19310198724269867, 0.24434706568717957, 0.527757465839386, 0.0941464751958847, 0.834925651550293, 0.7430714964866638, -0.3362877070903778, 0.6727002859115601, -0.5188748240470886, 0.16408482193946838, -0.5793800354003906, -0.10518793761730194, -0.7388306856155396, -0.5814958810806274, -0.49755948781967163, -0.5459646582603455, 0.18752776086330414, 0.053205110132694244, 0.19398123025894165, 0.263111412525177, -0.47819602489471436, 0.8507319688796997, 0.35063207149505615, -0.07267693430185318, 0.522715151309967, 0.5041791200637817, -0.22939713299274445, 0.04923725128173828, -0.5960603356361389, -0.5802837014198303, 1.22404944896698, 0.3589688837528229, 0.9092825651168823, -0.2762521505355835, 0.8883353471755981, 0.3303951025009155, 0.2673574388027191, -0.9069259762763977, 0.39147037267684937, -0.6268004179000854, -0.6846564412117004, -0.3365280032157898, -0.6835856437683105, -0.7434196472167969, 0.193648099899292, -0.05504121258854866, -0.29815682768821716, 0.25753942131996155, 0.05724025517702103, -0.13335399329662323, 0.18330097198486328, -0.594911515712738, 0.6173632740974426, 0.17355993390083313, -0.06449343264102936, -0.15922889113426208, -0.3814156651496887, 0.31034988164901733, -0.4247090816497803, 0.15152586996555328, -0.11796901375055313, -0.0418081060051918, 0.7973672747612, -0.5928326845169067, 0.7943945527076721, -0.2331390529870987, -0.32724156975746155, 0.4709573984146118, -0.022741645574569702, 0.46883827447891235, 0.18068476021289825, -0.28219330310821533, 0.27103179693222046, -0.20285913348197937, -0.10830298811197281, -0.7067001461982727, 0.7791398763656616, -0.6695905923843384, -0.15353713929653168, -0.3711729347705841, -0.5292201638221741, -0.24661460518836975, 0.15994839370250702, 0.3244152069091797, 0.5832810401916504, -0.5008977055549622, 0.31848520040512085, 0.79939866065979, -0.1422470062971115, 0.5666074752807617, 0.26496121287345886, -0.2987249195575714, -0.4552679657936096, 1.0110831260681152, 0.03083132952451706, 0.20794308185577393, 0.5325663089752197, 0.20768915116786957, -0.4830087125301361, -0.6998267769813538, -0.41836249828338623, 0.009276148863136768, -0.4823165237903595, -0.19092686474323273, -0.5654872059822083, -0.27082836627960205, -0.12389947474002838, 0.34458598494529724, -0.5635276436805725, -0.6008356809616089, -0.38638851046562195, 0.02644926682114601, 0.334256649017334, 0.6067273020744324, 0.15314403176307678, 0.2850092947483063, -0.9800031781196594, 0.3821580111980438, 0.27935847640037537, 0.26154834032058716, -0.24140526354312897, -0.7096783518791199, -0.4832073152065277, 0.35028401017189026, -0.14961320161819458, -0.5913665294647217, 0.6024455428123474, 0.6424728035926819, 0.3422655761241913, 0.2093013972043991, 0.11346679925918579, 0.37936875224113464, -0.7136991620063782, 0.574934720993042, 0.17544205486774445, -0.869583249092102, 0.6458680033683777, -0.2119876891374588, 0.3298773467540741, 0.9716315865516663, 0.5379905700683594, -0.5028992891311646, -0.1777801662683487, -0.2378513365983963, -0.8567633032798767, 0.5755597949028015, 0.4444212019443512, 0.3600398600101471, 0.011510735377669334, 0.39986446499824524, 0.36162036657333374, 0.49290305376052856, -0.6706411838531494, -0.3699512481689453, 0.03536682948470116, -0.5364717245101929, -0.1457650065422058, -0.15049518644809723, -0.048276957124471664, -0.2249043583869934, 0.7488974332809448, -0.22965630888938904, 0.0014017550274729729, 0.15535810589790344, -0.2920471727848053, 0.3076341450214386, 0.1103927418589592, 0.045037493109703064, 0.25006040930747986, -0.13625426590442657, 0.19790571928024292, 0.09172181785106659, -0.8065699934959412, 0.2774723172187805, 0.29101333022117615, -0.20077578723430634, 0.17803815007209778, 0.18825510144233704, 0.7308209538459778, -0.25232401490211487, -0.6431925892829895, 0.47904834151268005, -0.45491066575050354, -0.25834617018699646, -0.15737208724021912, 0.11521367728710175, 0.07408910244703293, 0.12902043759822845, 0.4177224934101105, -0.22612632811069489, 0.2937511205673218, -0.3795506954193115, 0.16870489716529846, 0.08080676943063736, -0.3874795436859131, -0.19713838398456573, 0.40411844849586487, 0.32634788751602173, 0.11749725788831711, 0.8955996036529541, -0.04490051791071892, -0.2562920153141022, 0.4536106586456299, 0.4607682228088379, 1.1416120529174805, -0.048455726355314255, 0.19300277531147003, 0.3930422365665436, 0.10713569819927216, -0.31224140524864197, 0.20939847826957703, -0.006809325888752937, -0.8544921875, -0.49046191573143005, -0.9972671270370483, -0.1584307849407196, 0.25264981389045715, -0.578316330909729, 0.24537944793701172, -0.38892418146133423, -0.255473792552948, -0.11907986551523209, 0.05076880007982254, -0.38265201449394226, 0.3145415484905243, 0.22477836906909943, 0.8947897553443909, -1.0011690855026245, 1.008753776550293, 0.7094417214393616, -0.2771981656551361, -0.5148147940635681, 0.3569510579109192, -0.3301298916339874, -0.27145394682884216, 0.6005380153656006, 0.30963748693466187, 0.3051721751689911, 0.03248850256204605, -0.5183003544807434, -0.5208544135093689, 1.0067154169082642, 0.5464426875114441, -0.9201540946960449, -0.0998450368642807, 0.5117385387420654, 0.5968600511550903, -0.5409374237060547, -0.07145118713378906, 0.7030205726623535, 0.27415522933006287, 0.03282011300325394, -0.6838705539703369, -0.17227108776569366, -0.47068384289741516, 0.3955920338630676, 0.0763448178768158, -0.45911434292793274, 0.8025228977203369, 0.1685200333595276, -0.22361335158348083, -0.05687844380736351, 0.7269062995910645, 0.15396243333816528, 0.05337141081690788, 0.5720314979553223, 0.7659662961959839, 0.7513248324394226, -0.2131049931049347, 0.8243235349655151, -0.2303263247013092, 0.4328259229660034, 1.3913540840148926, -0.3240931034088135, 0.6518308520317078, 0.5238091945648193, -0.1317552775144577, 0.3808133900165558, 0.4242645800113678, -0.01725063845515251, 0.7315604090690613, 0.38844528794288635, -0.5220290422439575, -0.033400945365428925, -0.07953828573226929, -0.3600877821445465, 0.5665286779403687, 0.23401525616645813, -0.5340554714202881, -0.24709458649158478, 0.2151077836751938, -0.18433088064193726, 0.14149591326713562, 0.04509638622403145, 0.8928225636482239, 0.12514105439186096, -0.5079464912414551, 0.5841652750968933, 0.12800084054470062, 0.7263567447662354, -0.5992223620414734, -0.037964921444654465, -0.22758693993091583, 0.4310184121131897, 0.03612470254302025, -0.5276389122009277, 0.5333971381187439, 0.21008987724781036, -0.4972652792930603, -0.346976637840271, 0.883354127407074, -0.8326061367988586, -0.7631489634513855, 0.09289614856243134, 0.5051836371421814, 0.16537931561470032, -0.38559070229530334, -0.6302369832992554, 0.007888929918408394, 0.07391662150621414, -0.41171953082084656, 0.23200871050357819, 0.6383057236671448, 0.2074965387582779, 0.5476639270782471, 0.6798021197319031, 0.18942198157310486, -0.07242336869239807, 0.29403212666511536, 1.1201444864273071, -0.4102306365966797, -0.5204654932022095, -1.1708812713623047, 0.4033392369747162, -0.2766326665878296, -0.14803223311901093, 0.6403275728225708, 0.8559343218803406, 0.8195751905441284, -0.2099938839673996, 1.1133328676223755, -0.07645399868488312, 0.40986400842666626, -0.4764016568660736, 0.9808679223060608, -0.452236145734787, 0.2700727581977844, -0.06143771857023239, -1.248218297958374, -0.13389995694160461, 0.5821405053138733, -0.2695348560810089, 0.17711761593818665, 0.6730376482009888, 0.7238689661026001, -0.1118026003241539, 0.11964487284421921, 0.24961452186107635, 0.1341550350189209, 0.35277703404426575, 0.2913128733634949, 0.6730366945266724, -0.4445323646068573, 0.4794313609600067, -0.3914707601070404, -0.2750842869281769, 0.00877810176461935, -1.0527753829956055, -1.1122448444366455, -0.6989092826843262, -0.41563481092453003, -0.15113085508346558, -0.09871430695056915, 0.8082399964332581, 0.6567279100418091, -0.8420163989067078, -0.17879745364189148, -0.510800302028656, -0.29571905732154846, -0.015373045578598976, -0.2176361382007599, 0.1456562727689743, -0.355570524930954, -1.324773907661438, 0.38796892762184143, 0.018502715975046158, 0.2069380283355713, -0.4020404815673828, 0.2177320271730423, -0.23052369058132172, 0.0728568509221077, 0.40863165259361267, -0.14774475991725922, -0.012757464312016964, 0.33544376492500305, -0.27511903643608093, -0.14797650277614594, 0.037178486585617065, 0.9792233109474182, -0.8475387096405029, 0.4330555498600006, 0.6832414269447327, 0.7988221645355225, 0.6119776368141174, -0.1036878377199173, 0.7903282642364502, -1.2870724201202393, 0.3452361822128296, 0.2756618857383728, 0.30972233414649963, 0.4899373948574066, -0.1677389144897461, 0.4956226348876953, 0.1852896362543106, -0.3411678373813629, -0.7757482528686523, 0.10346182435750961, -0.8013582825660706, -0.35686683654785156, 1.2589768171310425, -0.19592340290546417, -0.33576640486717224, 0.11955130100250244, -0.3246949315071106, 0.531253457069397, -0.3724670708179474, 0.8248947858810425, 0.7867688536643982, 0.48487308621406555, 0.3274478614330292, -0.2239702045917511, 0.5113150477409363, 0.1913360059261322, -0.8640623092651367, 0.43581631779670715, 0.394482284784317, 0.227861687541008, 0.0666060745716095, 0.24390080571174622, -0.1865178644657135, -0.35477685928344727, -0.004163992591202259, 0.07585745304822922, -0.328241229057312, -0.5110087990760803, -0.502699077129364, 0.06435969471931458, -0.12201236933469772, -0.3587576448917389 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00246v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00246v1
Your Co-Workers Matter: Evaluating Collaborative Capabilities of Language Models in Blocks World
2024-03-30T04:48:38
2024-03-30T04:48:38
Guande Wu, Chen Zhao, Claudio Silva, He He
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
Language agents that interact with the world on their own have great potential for automating digital tasks. While large language model (LLM) agents have made progress in understanding and executing tasks such as textual games and webpage control, many real-world tasks also require collaboration with humans or other LLMs in equal roles, which involves intent understanding, task coordination, and communication. To test LLM's ability to collaborate, we design a blocks-world environment, where two agents, each having unique goals and skills, build a target structure together. To complete the goals, they can act in the world and communicate in natural language. Under this environment, we design increasingly challenging settings to evaluate different collaboration perspectives, from independent to more complex, dependent tasks. We further adopt chain-of-thought prompts that include intermediate reasoning steps to model the partner's state and identify and correct execution errors. Both human-machine and machine-machine experiments show that LLM agents have strong grounding capacities, and our approach significantly improves the evaluation metric.
[ -0.5239918828010559, -0.9717302918434143, 0.7606965899467468, 0.43419191241264343, 0.082553431391716, 0.47580552101135254, -0.12161000818014145, -0.8008822798728943, 0.19846419990062714, 0.4635818898677826, -0.5107678174972534, -0.21289753913879395, -0.487205445766449, 0.14834578335285187, -0.2719382345676422, 0.7240546941757202, -0.10899339616298676, -0.016816647723317146, -0.7959312796592712, 0.04741577431559563, -0.7567397952079773, -0.4142535328865051, -0.5684162974357605, -0.6151012778282166, 0.225333109498024, 0.42379021644592285, 0.9017159938812256, 0.4838111102581024, 0.5659488439559937, 0.4779721796512604, 0.050991520285606384, 0.09817828983068466, -0.5279452204704285, 0.28644511103630066, -0.3985670506954193, -0.11766654998064041, -0.7968560457229614, 0.09465327858924866, 0.1608663946390152, 1.0428305864334106, 0.1673935204744339, 0.02701263315975666, -0.1089792400598526, 0.44855520129203796, -0.2681342661380768, 0.36674314737319946, -0.4468902051448822, 0.06731974333524704, 0.3356255888938904, 0.08065720647573471, -0.31627583503723145, -0.27507513761520386, 0.21231259405612946, -0.574832558631897, 0.03420666232705116, 0.32898688316345215, 0.5100739598274231, 0.13385933637619019, -0.37806111574172974, -0.383948415517807, -0.6917147040367126, 0.668640673160553, -0.2474106252193451, 0.33149370551109314, 0.5701632499694824, -0.023038828745484352, -0.4885644018650055, -0.6777138113975525, -0.4244135022163391, -0.41983115673065186, -0.03234269469976425, 0.21762044727802277, -0.181141197681427, 0.3322302997112274, 0.0189825426787138, 0.6704389452934265, -0.47242650389671326, 0.08976028859615326, -0.3165307939052582, -0.3092009425163269, 0.8659158945083618, 0.29570162296295166, 0.7288503050804138, 0.34849148988723755, -0.14361120760440826, -0.02833896316587925, -0.19853271543979645, -0.053530845791101456, 0.439418226480484, 0.16440293192863464, -0.2804733216762543, 0.43242064118385315, -0.2145022302865982, 0.8487300872802734, 0.11479713022708893, 0.0005310012493282557, -0.24662555754184723, -0.5677589178085327, -0.29014691710472107, -0.3074813485145569, 0.6563599109649658, 0.34570011496543884, 0.22024565935134888, -0.4632019102573395, -0.13049213588237762, 0.06185859441757202, 0.43720656633377075, -0.3760223686695099, -0.14715979993343353, 0.2914004325866699, -0.2848520874977112, -0.1830248385667801, 0.06263495981693268, -0.26158541440963745, -0.6624021530151367, -0.47246313095092773, 0.5222281813621521, 0.06246238574385643, -0.27453404664993286, -0.03677840903401375, -0.31242236495018005, -0.12068510800600052, 0.4699711501598358, -0.877700924873352, 0.992579460144043, 0.8231565356254578, 0.6013195514678955, -0.2542133033275604, -0.81905597448349, -0.6173998713493347, -0.2544611096382141, -0.4111746847629547, 0.5785434246063232, -0.3505549132823944, -0.3227781653404236, -0.14022819697856903, -0.08964347094297409, -0.06979335099458694, -0.5559609532356262, 0.10583954304456711, -0.4960286617279053, 0.19938580691814423, -0.3565598428249359, -0.5978600382804871, -0.04925438016653061, 0.40445587038993835, -0.8407428860664368, 0.7050303220748901, 0.29084181785583496, -0.5376652479171753, 0.15723679959774017, -0.8449849486351013, -0.4760916233062744, 0.30848270654678345, -0.33405643701553345, -0.12015402317047119, 0.1565822809934616, -0.28124046325683594, 0.5823559761047363, -0.40801817178726196, 0.19725219905376434, -0.17872855067253113, -0.40043091773986816, 0.38536837697029114, -0.016917303204536438, 0.7644654512405396, -0.09828078001737595, -0.3514746427536011, 0.3844683766365051, -0.4642709791660309, 0.04335244372487068, 0.10470157861709595, -0.38824763894081116, -0.24861176311969757, 0.0433163046836853, -0.08311023563146591, 0.40347805619239807, 0.4803568422794342, -0.2965580224990845, -0.009628762491047382, -0.045725949108600616, 0.15747162699699402, 0.652015209197998, 0.11118658632040024, 0.5180288553237915, -0.5386964082717896, 0.6225947141647339, -0.44470667839050293, 0.1928780972957611, 0.18178045749664307, -0.6523814797401428, -0.5456839799880981, -0.22242210805416107, -0.20083989202976227, 0.4368929862976074, -0.5402387976646423, 0.7146453857421875, -0.06618838757276535, -0.5901371240615845, -0.34919285774230957, 0.34165751934051514, 0.4220438599586487, 0.32182180881500244, 0.1743474155664444, -0.7073606848716736, -0.6157324314117432, -0.7658102512359619, -0.21358941495418549, -0.32575276494026184, 0.22299166023731232, 0.29790207743644714, 0.6654099225997925, -0.23546668887138367, 1.3187097311019897, -0.31184646487236023, -0.05511603131890297, -0.5793052911758423, 0.0077397460117936134, 0.014199388213455677, 0.3675655424594879, -0.1272539496421814, -0.8948140144348145, -0.7202467918395996, 0.08822333812713623, -0.8500000834465027, -0.3550270199775696, -0.08218744397163391, -0.04612692445516586, 0.055963337421417236, 0.3989129960536957, -0.333867609500885, 0.2598629593849182, 0.9202336668968201, -0.7164517641067505, 0.594329833984375, -0.5021278858184814, 0.11590511351823807, -0.7332932353019714, 0.03353812173008919, -0.2836342751979828, -0.4974275231361389, -0.6795005202293396, 0.18325673043727875, -0.23721586167812347, -0.16999709606170654, -0.25884708762168884, 0.4554451107978821, -0.6262117624282837, -0.4467000961303711, -0.31376269459724426, 0.4703616499900818, 0.16847777366638184, 0.26845860481262207, 0.07635792344808578, 0.633435845375061, 0.4260096848011017, -0.5420656204223633, 0.601287305355072, 0.1494523584842682, -0.3768080174922943, 0.7246554493904114, -0.6195605397224426, 0.665648877620697, 0.33146166801452637, 0.20068581402301788, -0.6749507784843445, -0.24559034407138824, -0.09191033989191055, -0.22732636332511902, -0.10662788897752762, 0.05881241708993912, -0.7368122339248657, -0.4139730632305145, -0.20934130251407623, 0.1662781983613968, 0.13314107060432434, -0.24783210456371307, 0.4160943031311035, 0.7826870679855347, 0.022696537896990776, -0.42347434163093567, -0.7875467538833618, 0.3246036171913147, 0.12657947838306427, -0.8982564806938171, 0.340282142162323, -0.5085567831993103, -0.8793677687644958, 0.17281661927700043, -0.0845981016755104, -0.45357102155685425, 0.6128419041633606, 0.5579245090484619, 0.04037893936038017, 0.23883973062038422, -0.15680305659770966, -0.14821888506412506, -0.10064887255430222, 0.1939304769039154, -0.06187983602285385, 0.7451550960540771, -0.487496942281723, -0.42879554629325867, -0.27287352085113525, 0.42092153429985046, 0.783177375793457, -0.16404671967029572, 0.7932993173599243, 0.4614744186401367, -0.5755608677864075, -0.07390443235635757, -0.5631940960884094, -0.07929511368274689, -0.4429767429828644, 0.5356625318527222, -0.20413164794445038, -0.9513822793960571, 0.5677822232246399, 0.006166699342429638, -0.23257750272750854, 0.09824007749557495, 0.7505775690078735, 0.045786213129758835, 0.6578149199485779, 0.9769582748413086, -0.13962087035179138, 0.18510746955871582, -0.19633615016937256, 0.28245827555656433, -0.6561172604560852, -0.23375961184501648, -0.20123834908008575, -0.00839073397219181, -0.34115833044052124, -0.5098865628242493, 0.29933056235313416, 0.040025435388088226, 0.008267821744084358, 0.6007835865020752, -0.2729017734527588, 0.718683123588562, 0.3797979950904846, -0.038108352571725845, 0.5002726316452026, -0.322247713804245, -0.18196594715118408, -0.03705659881234169, -0.4239838421344757, -0.5872765183448792, 0.5304378271102905, 0.3567065894603729, 0.7310348749160767, 0.008405622094869614, 0.7155712842941284, 0.6988272070884705, 0.14436131715774536, -0.8218751549720764, 0.6750636100769043, 0.13299588859081268, -0.7202109694480896, -0.39010071754455566, -0.20260804891586304, -0.9665619730949402, 0.3547527492046356, -0.22553260624408722, -0.6648778319358826, -0.3166664242744446, -0.11637631058692932, -0.1652851551771164, 0.20954526960849762, -0.7301614880561829, 1.0913232564926147, -0.1987948715686798, -0.579240083694458, -0.6590498089790344, -0.39896082878112793, 0.003197985701262951, -0.06298670172691345, 0.5073117017745972, -0.11703728139400482, -0.16141600906848907, 0.5388597249984741, -0.39271172881126404, 1.0612207651138306, 0.09712707251310349, -0.1637064516544342, 0.39199891686439514, 0.44300419092178345, 0.3508571684360504, -0.22698213160037994, -0.36194607615470886, -0.02012256719172001, -0.296098917722702, -0.27127954363822937, -0.34943780303001404, 0.6681467890739441, -0.8203672766685486, -0.5690137147903442, -0.2756303548812866, -0.8728365898132324, -0.05192252993583679, 0.31758856773376465, -0.07677755504846573, 0.30311548709869385, -0.8106135129928589, 0.20170868933200836, 0.05412772670388222, 0.0683443546295166, 0.4993925094604492, 0.5302696228027344, -0.3122625946998596, -0.3845290243625641, 0.7645398378372192, 0.08092430979013443, 0.5971865653991699, 0.249590203166008, 0.23401392996311188, 0.029740167781710625, -0.3930075168609619, -0.21542343497276306, -0.030634591355919838, -0.9379673600196838, 0.15534144639968872, -0.48747971653938293, 0.10735905170440674, -0.1391705721616745, -0.5103664398193359, -0.2965138554573059, 0.07841270416975021, 0.008211172185838223, 0.06835906952619553, 0.04358300939202309, 1.2794413566589355, -0.10256904363632202, 0.003979007247835398, -0.7607073783874512, 0.06146327033638954, 0.7141551375389099, 0.21257930994033813, -0.04508772864937782, -0.038205336779356, -0.6041708588600159, -0.2394208461046219, -0.3223908841609955, -0.882284939289093, 0.3740175664424896, -0.24721360206604004, 0.656669557094574, -0.257806658744812, 0.02167305164039135, 0.5255860090255737, -0.168549582362175, 0.7938584685325623, 0.11933627724647522, -1.494778037071228, 0.22213676571846008, -0.34352749586105347, 0.09833095222711563, 0.5754114389419556, 0.2734690010547638, -0.8188647031784058, -0.44054678082466125, -0.7549905776977539, -0.5711550712585449, 0.6288305521011353, 0.39760535955429077, -0.04326019063591957, 0.07107372581958771, -0.04900270700454712, 0.06299163401126862, 0.2620517909526825, -0.9390326142311096, -0.20799002051353455, 0.3543369472026825, -0.11922910809516907, 0.20317065715789795, 0.014961401000618935, -0.146188423037529, 0.013906426727771759, 0.2549854815006256, -0.23185846209526062, 0.13004475831985474, 0.425216406583786, -0.29210802912712097, -0.49292027950286865, 0.23340539634227753, 0.5137583613395691, 0.980465292930603, -0.004246146883815527, 0.32845133543014526, 0.5926420092582703, -0.34004053473472595, 0.15323005616664886, -0.2142433375120163, 0.4508742690086365, -0.42171475291252136, 0.5940249562263489, 0.6139370203018188, -0.016126923263072968, -0.664183497428894, 0.7062661051750183, -0.33867108821868896, -0.003449772484600544, -0.3668837249279022, 0.22733058035373688, 0.4014856815338135, 0.3359767496585846, 0.22796499729156494, 0.18065914511680603, 0.001370331272482872, -0.9219629764556885, 0.04301176965236664, 0.2803865373134613, -0.5414257049560547, -0.4769783318042755, 0.15670166909694672, 0.4110409915447235, -0.8449927568435669, 0.14362917840480804, -0.6946566700935364, -0.7898103594779968, 0.972720742225647, 0.7502495646476746, 0.8742316961288452, -0.03005164861679077, 0.04060043394565582, -0.2218826413154602, 0.435719758272171, -0.10178916156291962, 0.20163287222385406, 0.023881280794739723, -0.8050518035888672, -0.600531816482544, -0.05977831035852432, -1.004921317100525, 0.06838861852884293, -0.3682035505771637, 0.1011984720826149, -0.575080931186676, 0.05283417925238609, -0.3915291428565979, 0.5593391060829163, -0.7079290151596069, 0.2923860549926758, 0.21524327993392944, 0.48476484417915344, -1.0500502586364746, 0.59397953748703, 0.8253654837608337, -0.23098509013652802, -0.36740076541900635, 0.062301233410835266, -0.034892819821834564, -0.5586299300193787, 0.7633276581764221, 0.25178858637809753, -0.317401647567749, -0.08910125494003296, -0.46000880002975464, -0.6941344738006592, 1.1832610368728638, 0.3279695212841034, -0.4388401508331299, 0.2526845932006836, 0.038570620119571686, 0.7644538283348083, -0.6049255728721619, 0.3917348384857178, 0.2932184040546417, 0.39043962955474854, -0.5415417551994324, -1.516838550567627, 0.2468802034854889, -0.13688963651657104, -0.19602259993553162, -0.09175285696983337, -0.7552616596221924, 0.9740933775901794, -0.14164075255393982, -0.029915031045675278, -0.1491185426712036, 0.4037187695503235, 0.2899446189403534, 0.3361254036426544, 0.8596106171607971, 0.31430959701538086, 1.0842660665512085, 0.29912957549095154, 1.0931419134140015, -0.27806684374809265, 0.31246498227119446, 1.083279013633728, -0.3465130627155304, 0.5865787267684937, 0.3262500464916229, -0.16987362504005432, 0.6533891558647156, 0.2222311943769455, 0.16826796531677246, 0.044076692312955856, 0.5407963991165161, -0.2626173496246338, -0.35656285285949707, -0.45589709281921387, 0.02094211056828499, 0.49070027470588684, 0.2657305598258972, 0.020381515845656395, 0.1811949461698532, -0.1344405710697174, -0.024798065423965454, 0.5044638514518738, -0.09144469350576401, 0.6567296981811523, 0.1750943511724472, -0.8286058306694031, 0.1047310158610344, -0.032941658049821854, 0.5087910294532776, -0.23751790821552277, 0.028357338160276413, 0.04206624627113342, 0.21602734923362732, -0.3748623728752136, -0.7727246284484863, 0.4685387909412384, -0.029292326420545578, -0.21525125205516815, -0.42246827483177185, 0.818063497543335, -0.4604707360267639, 0.030162567272782326, 0.8228169679641724, 0.7545344233512878, 0.18359686434268951, -0.18001775443553925, -0.7299495935440063, 0.5608634948730469, -0.24750030040740967, 0.08677034825086594, 0.20058226585388184, 0.1691257357597351, -0.02977699041366577, 0.7028714418411255, 0.5261045098304749, 0.014538227580487728, -0.18584293127059937, 0.1536843180656433, 0.742743194103241, -0.580920934677124, -0.49578920006752014, -0.8732632398605347, 0.46867769956588745, -0.3097960650920868, -0.07396768033504486, 0.7515377998352051, 0.6299790143966675, 0.7871894836425781, -0.05880067124962807, 0.7727882862091064, -0.3301539123058319, 0.09318628162145615, -0.24344275891780853, 0.7350375056266785, -0.3937609791755676, -0.046605631709098816, -0.35388290882110596, -0.6843447685241699, -0.21900992095470428, 0.5602102875709534, -0.41211366653442383, 0.024989161640405655, 0.9530134797096252, 0.49152323603630066, 0.13388024270534515, -0.08738553524017334, 0.5959291458129883, 0.08617148548364639, 0.5312671661376953, 0.5634945631027222, 1.1017249822616577, -0.3783596456050873, 0.44992637634277344, -0.40488848090171814, -0.09555625170469284, -0.15300005674362183, -1.0658965110778809, -1.0762888193130493, -0.7428492903709412, -0.5883840322494507, -0.37502825260162354, -0.20975947380065918, 1.3821017742156982, 0.9453882575035095, -0.5350742340087891, -0.8033801913261414, -0.5125158429145813, 0.48332229256629944, -0.1842595338821411, -0.18735797703266144, -0.02751351334154606, -0.30873262882232666, -0.7941082119941711, 0.8696832060813904, 0.39465996623039246, -0.038899146020412445, -0.5541192889213562, -0.44686153531074524, -0.22303073108196259, -0.09159089624881744, 0.49664974212646484, 0.007772861048579216, -0.5627879500389099, -0.19494161009788513, 0.11133589595556259, -0.4091995060443878, -0.08415576815605164, 0.831264853477478, -0.5020108819007874, 0.7149563431739807, 0.8225929737091064, 0.6789624094963074, 0.23573996126651764, -0.1648504137992859, 0.9476792216300964, -0.6114205718040466, 0.009829984977841377, 0.17046499252319336, 0.3731723725795746, 0.5509310960769653, -0.40498924255371094, 0.574669361114502, 0.4700148105621338, -0.9106594920158386, -0.593379020690918, 0.0662127211689949, -0.8484687209129333, -0.15858450531959534, 0.8042328953742981, -0.33145540952682495, -0.1401357501745224, -0.6328431367874146, -0.3365381062030792, 0.2926616370677948, -0.22947266697883606, 0.7050597667694092, 0.8242501616477966, -0.17852003872394562, 0.1830511838197708, -0.3803792893886566, 0.3776147961616516, 0.46790191531181335, -1.0805076360702515, -0.06838720291852951, 0.32477468252182007, 0.09334386885166168, 0.49562498927116394, 0.928520143032074, 0.4107511639595032, 0.2188159078359604, 0.11380279809236526, 0.18253853917121887, -0.1602465957403183, -0.30704641342163086, -0.43362006545066833, 0.001027858816087246, 0.4922421872615814, 0.02166844718158245 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00242v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00242v2
DeFT: Decoding with Flash Tree-attention for Efficient Tree-structured LLM Inference
2024-03-30T04:34:54
2024-05-29T18:46:41
Jinwei Yao, Kaiqi Chen, Kexun Zhang, Jiaxuan You, Binhang Yuan, Zeke Wang, Tao Lin
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI
Given the increasing demand for tree-structured interactions with LLMs, we introduce DeFT (Decoding with Flash Tree-Attention), an IO-aware tree attention algorithm tailored for tree-structured inference. Unlike traditional sequence-based decoding, tree-structured decoding better accommodates modern task requirements, including self-consistency, few-shot prompting, multi-step reasoning, and multi-model/head coordination. However, existing sequence-based inference systems are ill-suited for tree-structured decoding, resulting in redundancy in computation, memory footprints, and memory access, thereby undermining inference efficiency. To address this challenge, DeFT maintains memory-efficient attention calculation with low memory footprints through two key stages: (1) QKV Preparation: We propose a KV-Guided Grouping Strategy with Tree Split to intelligently group QKV, optimizing GPU resource utilization while minimizing memory reads/writes for KV cache between GPU global memory and on-chip shared memory; (2)Attention Calculation: We compute partial attention of each QKV group in a fused kernel and employ a Tree-topology-aware Global Reduction strategy to obtain final attention. By reducing 73-99% KV cache IO and nearly 100% IO for partial results during attention calculation (e.g., Softmax), DeFT achieves up to 2.52/3.82x speedup in the end-to-end/attention latency across three practical tree-based workloads: namely, few-shot prompting, multi-step reasoning, and speculative decoding, over state-of-the-art attention algorithms.
[ 0.01694534346461296, -0.7955538034439087, 0.5052024126052856, 0.2056434452533722, -0.48030856251716614, 0.15707708895206451, 0.20649734139442444, -0.41525936126708984, 0.1422726958990097, -0.015658512711524963, -0.8056067824363708, -0.3649720251560211, -0.24739670753479004, 0.01729164831340313, -0.5346881747245789, 0.785068154335022, 0.18687738478183746, -0.3316842317581177, -0.23878365755081177, 0.007968815974891186, -0.41897132992744446, -0.20447809994220734, -0.3983480930328369, 0.18831320106983185, 0.5892703533172607, 0.47821101546287537, 0.3666263520717621, 0.8553779721260071, 0.4428246021270752, 0.2710084319114685, -0.23476587235927582, -0.0352543406188488, -0.6766945719718933, 0.07511632144451141, 0.2654326260089874, -0.37911587953567505, -0.7632266879081726, -0.4188140630722046, 0.7379071712493896, 0.23620538413524628, -0.08940550684928894, 0.2854940891265869, 0.04006253182888031, 0.7198639512062073, -0.8999661207199097, 0.33508431911468506, -0.7241554856300354, 0.1359502673149109, -0.035031966865062714, -0.3960864841938019, -0.6429623961448669, -0.169793039560318, 0.06414138525724411, -0.8132158517837524, 0.4535471498966217, -0.00280527351424098, 0.5324018001556396, 0.7055374979972839, -0.36092525720596313, 0.41340023279190063, -0.637553870677948, 0.7140893936157227, -0.4315217137336731, 0.5933108329772949, 0.5673325657844543, 0.1329130381345749, 0.03317275643348694, -0.8728563189506531, -0.2006521075963974, 0.17678309977054596, -0.014730780385434628, 0.6252620816230774, -0.14492999017238617, 0.488069087266922, 0.3735024929046631, 0.4567852318286896, -0.4757203459739685, -0.40786460041999817, 0.0355074368417263, -0.06583468616008759, 0.49232912063598633, 0.10656251758337021, -0.06709475815296173, -0.04167289286851883, -0.35911014676094055, 0.03469492495059967, -0.8630629777908325, 0.08311579376459122, -0.11073186248540878, -0.058552335947752, 0.0962926596403122, 0.1968315690755844, -0.39282748103141785, 0.5969288349151611, 0.18778516352176666, -0.19479437172412872, -0.2585259675979614, -0.6655274033546448, -0.7265031933784485, 0.26556992530822754, 0.5520749092102051, 0.22218042612075806, 0.1320972889661789, -0.17957136034965515, -0.09458108246326447, -0.07113070040941238, 0.18103617429733276, -0.800757646560669, -0.44714465737342834, 0.38236939907073975, -0.40953806042671204, -0.120877705514431, -0.23572000861167908, -0.6445997953414917, 0.11204337328672409, 0.12324543297290802, 0.2102314829826355, -0.5855587124824524, -0.31562021374702454, 0.038350921124219894, -0.028235651552677155, 0.4749508202075958, 0.5808336734771729, -1.0538547039031982, 0.37494465708732605, 0.7183509469032288, 0.85335773229599, 0.12430019676685333, 0.009151014499366283, -0.8305606842041016, 0.45224183797836304, -0.09461921453475952, 0.7681939601898193, -0.47476139664649963, -0.2296861857175827, -0.46198058128356934, -0.23518645763397217, -0.05203057453036308, -0.18215040862560272, 0.40219682455062866, -0.5473498106002808, -0.12911456823349, -0.21578393876552582, -0.38900259137153625, -0.36271169781684875, 0.20482905209064484, -0.5626206994056702, 1.109127402305603, 0.27003374695777893, -0.9715259075164795, 0.44311994314193726, -0.5105676651000977, -0.607181191444397, 0.5177119970321655, 0.0336432121694088, -0.43910491466522217, 0.3884642422199249, 0.19245584309101105, 0.3886021375656128, -0.14365015923976898, 0.0605776272714138, -0.2681753933429718, -0.522521436214447, -0.23853327333927155, -0.475786030292511, 0.6058664321899414, 0.1517726182937622, -0.25681233406066895, 0.48209741711616516, -0.4284684658050537, 0.20327730476856232, 0.15941454470157623, -0.15617400407791138, -0.27570536732673645, 0.4238491356372833, -0.015970641747117043, -0.24741896986961365, -0.03634876757860184, -0.4834688901901245, 0.3605462908744812, -0.48235899209976196, 0.7389553785324097, 0.7580975890159607, -0.1759861558675766, 0.14596031606197357, 0.08169032633304596, 0.4866655468940735, -0.07037804275751114, 0.24946534633636475, -0.7037404775619507, -0.47147059440612793, -0.47592633962631226, -0.44051799178123474, 0.2999357581138611, 0.5135179758071899, -0.6194441914558411, 0.20246030390262604, -0.42322617769241333, 0.04755720496177673, -0.6511818766593933, -0.16579651832580566, 0.5879636406898499, 0.7406055331230164, 0.32205650210380554, -0.22294899821281433, -0.44127339124679565, -0.8644818663597107, 0.10039738565683365, -0.36069008708000183, 0.13964365422725677, 0.1761198788881302, 0.34972599148750305, 0.08927691727876663, 1.046664834022522, -0.4254860281944275, -0.11630859971046448, -0.1902138739824295, -0.2294435352087021, -0.072087861597538, 0.16016116738319397, 0.1391201764345169, -0.7349836230278015, -0.7179504036903381, 0.11391150951385498, -0.16155336797237396, 0.05273820087313652, -0.12681028246879578, 0.057299286127090454, 0.3500638008117676, 0.283855140209198, -0.5756869316101074, 0.6982782483100891, 0.2700522840023041, -0.3897383511066437, 0.5608158111572266, -0.0892615020275116, 0.1541733592748642, -0.9766605496406555, 0.1087498813867569, -0.3168178200721741, -0.6467653512954712, -0.5043447613716125, -0.054997678846120834, 0.24866554141044617, 0.5557032227516174, -0.5607155561447144, 0.27756404876708984, -0.549900233745575, -0.40192386507987976, -0.02690637856721878, -0.2235623002052307, 0.001746957190334797, 0.6340914368629456, 0.19454047083854675, 0.9262844324111938, 0.4974362552165985, -0.46065807342529297, 0.2833903133869171, 0.11188460886478424, -0.008389277383685112, 0.509674072265625, -0.620938777923584, 0.3056783676147461, 0.04156298562884331, 0.3138085603713989, -1.2694998979568481, -0.20640119910240173, 0.10145583003759384, -0.49597203731536865, 0.3527474105358124, -0.37881410121917725, -0.6705772876739502, -0.2820810377597809, -0.663921594619751, 0.8180243968963623, 0.6556919813156128, -0.5087831616401672, 0.5496331453323364, 0.07283778488636017, 0.2631152272224426, -0.5309078693389893, -0.8408801555633545, -0.12980639934539795, -0.3625560402870178, -0.710957407951355, 0.4277464747428894, -0.0713237076997757, -0.027040744200348854, 0.22382564842700958, -0.6126987338066101, -0.23369921743869781, 0.2822982370853424, 0.2707936763763428, -0.06435903906822205, -0.48429468274116516, -0.16833150386810303, 0.007922214455902576, -0.2683127522468567, -0.042046669870615005, -0.5022864937782288, 0.2125559151172638, -0.2296377718448639, -0.32094457745552063, -0.6923859119415283, 0.3305518627166748, 0.614387571811676, -0.25471335649490356, 0.28563159704208374, 0.5003738403320312, -0.411314457654953, 0.04174663871526718, -0.4464215040206909, -0.4044741988182068, -0.4623849391937256, 0.41162821650505066, -0.6109642386436462, -1.0180268287658691, 0.36698269844055176, 0.025644393637776375, 0.09090858697891235, 0.3342731297016144, 0.5125295519828796, -0.35563889145851135, 1.2231831550598145, 0.5140132308006287, -0.16963854432106018, 0.5524467825889587, -0.276799738407135, 0.059992995113134384, -0.9390416741371155, -0.06882867217063904, 0.04542790725827217, -0.5927395820617676, -0.15061166882514954, -0.2839869558811188, 0.31149470806121826, 0.26280272006988525, -0.09510113298892975, 0.04228179529309273, -0.7803359031677246, 0.8668311238288879, 0.607984721660614, -0.0039678518660366535, 0.4754132926464081, 0.13241182267665863, 0.1373230516910553, -0.043494679033756256, -1.0595574378967285, 0.050898097455501556, 0.8870869278907776, 0.35939493775367737, 0.49943092465400696, -0.0688231959939003, 0.624544620513916, 0.2512551546096802, 0.3081727921962738, -1.0588219165802002, 0.6747110486030579, 0.15327270328998566, -0.2775115668773651, -0.1531827449798584, -0.4236666262149811, -1.087000846862793, 0.162152498960495, 0.44819512963294983, -0.9049582481384277, -0.16294439136981964, 0.485617995262146, -0.7557803392410278, 0.37095895409584045, -1.059665322303772, 0.9527350664138794, -0.0297751072794199, -0.6475646495819092, -0.5498226881027222, -0.9139257073402405, 0.8144873976707458, 0.11355429887771606, -0.1429218053817749, 0.10558443516492844, -0.14855258166790009, 0.5756902098655701, -0.4720609486103058, 0.8227167129516602, -0.13315348327159882, 0.14815686643123627, 0.5571120381355286, 0.1864825040102005, 0.4628915786743164, 0.20423947274684906, 0.40493258833885193, -0.21367062628269196, 0.4370059669017792, -0.4126940071582794, -0.40816205739974976, 0.4270178973674774, -0.5667526721954346, -0.5424502491950989, -0.5333203673362732, -0.7089583277702332, -0.011028534732758999, 0.16081461310386658, 0.014499814249575138, 0.28293636441230774, -0.14942072331905365, 0.23976701498031616, 0.8697075247764587, 0.20905299484729767, 0.7027084827423096, 0.44174280762672424, -0.018673745915293694, -0.5309430956840515, 0.8364343643188477, -0.22369089722633362, 0.4230353832244873, 0.6951786875724792, 0.1761195957660675, -0.36571383476257324, -0.6892901659011841, -0.3153853118419647, 0.18478427827358246, -0.37437930703163147, -0.603120744228363, -0.5259186625480652, -0.20310494303703308, -0.27041614055633545, 0.0027835771907120943, -0.41343432664871216, -0.3449987769126892, -0.12255500257015228, -0.02355753630399704, 0.8721458315849304, 0.6515246033668518, 0.04108979552984238, 0.7965934872627258, -0.8515167236328125, 0.5687768459320068, 0.2014487236738205, 0.4024712145328522, 0.013470422476530075, -0.45682838559150696, -0.2360166311264038, -0.21260711550712585, -0.22914710640907288, -1.0907536745071411, 0.4199299216270447, 0.28526464104652405, 0.18370960652828217, 0.5128541588783264, 0.029669199138879776, 1.0282998085021973, -0.37767693400382996, 0.28933361172676086, 0.08464816212654114, -0.8803107738494873, 0.6913765668869019, -0.2678816616535187, 0.6105468273162842, 0.47578164935112, 0.010917630977928638, -0.49580371379852295, -0.16558198630809784, -0.8750426769256592, -0.9718832969665527, 1.4073677062988281, 0.24680499732494354, -0.32946673035621643, 0.027276823297142982, 0.3158811330795288, -0.1945841759443283, -0.050880808383226395, -0.6350544095039368, -0.03763705864548683, -0.15406446158885956, -0.3528529405593872, 0.3694111108779907, -0.48062875866889954, -0.04689578711986542, -0.5411248207092285, 0.36098170280456543, -0.25366446375846863, 0.42273086309432983, 0.5851874351501465, -0.27091357111930847, -0.2752722501754761, 0.041828643530607224, 0.5531760454177856, 0.15479297935962677, -0.5235275030136108, 0.39386874437332153, 0.3561551570892334, -0.9179671406745911, -0.003140270011499524, 0.0009876422118395567, -0.28385335206985474, -0.3710956275463104, 0.3782731890678406, 0.6545987725257874, 0.22342737019062042, -0.5220947265625, 0.2434569001197815, -0.3706956207752228, -0.34930649399757385, 0.1426117867231369, 0.0765332281589508, 0.21794117987155914, 0.2454404979944229, 0.3993229269981384, -0.23509420454502106, 0.13103240728378296, -0.1860460489988327, 0.3278782069683075, 0.5471997857093811, -0.12975884974002838, -0.6549742817878723, 0.700320839881897, 0.26357603073120117, -0.28505709767341614, 0.7027274370193481, -0.3127458095550537, -0.5748147368431091, 0.7510039210319519, 0.4470258951187134, 1.3300719261169434, -0.44384461641311646, -0.15876367688179016, 0.4172261655330658, 0.3009112775325775, 0.020798763260245323, 0.48315301537513733, -0.7753762006759644, -0.30438145995140076, -0.8757338523864746, -0.5387942790985107, -0.1544245332479477, 0.23919188976287842, -0.29029905796051025, 0.06206710264086723, -0.6319121718406677, 0.17831158638000488, -0.4813153147697449, 0.050268687307834625, -0.32984811067581177, 0.15209007263183594, 0.050055164843797684, 0.815051794052124, -0.4866892695426941, 1.2151974439620972, 0.38145381212234497, 0.04913496598601341, -0.6142016053199768, 0.08290813863277435, 0.04522957280278206, -0.7221136093139648, 0.4271499514579773, 0.4849754869937897, -0.2962087392807007, 0.6115150451660156, -0.37992268800735474, -1.0239040851593018, 1.4000164270401, 0.31351804733276367, -0.737732470035553, 0.15239237248897552, -0.1397915929555893, 0.18641452491283417, -0.0732542872428894, 0.6700385212898254, 0.6660330891609192, 0.3748374581336975, 0.44540196657180786, -0.7515913844108582, 0.05047332122921944, -0.09880369156599045, -0.2767259478569031, 0.34459608793258667, -0.8208827376365662, 0.26427018642425537, -0.4065197706222534, -0.5831282138824463, -0.26734164357185364, 0.9486891627311707, 0.24422167241573334, 0.4149565100669861, 0.5696684122085571, 0.7015553116798401, 0.6460623145103455, -0.16691350936889648, 1.139879584312439, -0.49053633213043213, 0.16837243735790253, 0.9839088916778564, 0.034646838903427124, 0.8098040819168091, 0.42325955629348755, -0.43568286299705505, -0.13264591991901398, 1.0292249917984009, 0.39114949107170105, 0.8091712594032288, -0.12101376801729202, -0.4459087550640106, -0.21358628571033478, 0.05756043270230293, -0.30417805910110474, 0.09648777544498444, 0.528301477432251, 0.005043163429945707, -0.1997772753238678, -0.5170746445655823, -0.34511682391166687, -0.5391055941581726, -0.43474578857421875, 0.8628436923027039, -0.007673102896660566, -0.6359041333198547, 0.7180260419845581, -0.14368703961372375, 0.5833777785301208, -0.7296132445335388, -0.03423071280121803, -0.3376821279525757, 0.2147430032491684, -0.45457959175109863, -0.7987996935844421, 0.5874810218811035, -0.017562881112098694, -0.30389922857284546, -0.5499711036682129, 0.7995454668998718, -0.41013002395629883, -0.3092925548553467, 0.041265372186899185, 0.2483060359954834, 0.32419437170028687, -0.3581261932849884, -0.6611936092376709, 0.17504101991653442, 0.2819713354110718, -0.5412907004356384, 0.26765891909599304, 0.5862479209899902, -0.13787122070789337, 0.6646648049354553, 0.5506900548934937, -0.2672003507614136, 0.175922229886055, 0.008786482736468315, 0.7386820316314697, -0.7821202874183655, -0.5018088817596436, -1.108443021774292, 0.6074988842010498, 0.3255826234817505, -0.13615839183330536, 0.5869508981704712, 0.7784214019775391, 0.4018438160419464, 0.1288263201713562, 0.5653206706047058, 0.01538857165724039, -0.115024134516716, -0.438738614320755, 0.3147484064102173, -0.5822579264640808, 0.17723727226257324, -0.024866221472620964, -0.9035824537277222, -0.27573373913764954, 0.6158867478370667, -0.12670795619487762, 0.10040178894996643, 0.8691877722740173, 0.517911434173584, -0.4179309904575348, -0.01286215428262949, 0.3177558481693268, 0.3400316536426544, 0.25427135825157166, 1.1942973136901855, 0.6718834638595581, -0.24594826996326447, 0.6924075484275818, -0.12611782550811768, -0.2557790279388428, -0.2838672399520874, -0.9573274254798889, -0.4777149558067322, -0.45985421538352966, -0.6294711232185364, -0.09226498007774353, 0.09995350986719131, 0.5042367577552795, 0.8690048456192017, -0.5385954976081848, -0.011565910652279854, -0.6163216233253479, 0.3242494761943817, -0.24916766583919525, -0.25597867369651794, 0.5727699995040894, -0.21461613476276398, -0.5816921591758728, 0.4683012366294861, 0.7893332242965698, -0.02446439303457737, -0.28246012330055237, -0.16544587910175323, -0.22174662351608276, -0.22043120861053467, 0.7735130786895752, 0.40736860036849976, -0.9022655487060547, -0.0818958729505539, 0.1387345790863037, -0.05373454466462135, 0.4527064859867096, 0.7263162732124329, -1.2129989862442017, 0.39154064655303955, 0.66639244556427, 0.7327879071235657, 0.9019397497177124, 0.2783135771751404, 0.348328560590744, -0.9485553503036499, 0.1135605126619339, 0.520962655544281, 0.15329521894454956, 0.18793581426143646, -0.46937647461891174, 0.5834711790084839, 0.6240147948265076, -0.5029929876327515, -0.9531285762786865, 0.29900112748146057, -1.2692140340805054, -0.1876285821199417, 1.1717679500579834, 0.043539803475141525, -0.8390481472015381, -0.10127139091491699, -0.2746145725250244, 0.15832051634788513, -0.4515523910522461, 0.49910908937454224, 0.6319959163665771, -0.4171908497810364, -0.6795902252197266, -0.605593204498291, 0.7516252994537354, 0.7285997271537781, -0.7138597965240479, 0.5131126046180725, 0.48946475982666016, 0.12903574109077454, -0.2912926971912384, 0.9368874430656433, 0.22825847566127777, 0.5858397483825684, 0.044794175773859024, -0.05591367185115814, -0.09017273783683777, -0.4757978320121765, -0.3245998024940491, 0.051254115998744965, 0.0040192496962845325, -0.36162087321281433 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00236v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00236v1
Enhancing Content-based Recommendation via Large Language Model
2024-03-30T03:56:53
2024-03-30T03:56:53
Wentao Xu, Qianqian Xie, Shuo Yang, Jiangxia Cao, Shuchao Pang
cs.IR
cs.IR, cs.CL
In real-world applications, users express different behaviors when they interact with different items, including implicit click/like interactions, and explicit comments/reviews interactions. Nevertheless, almost all recommender works are focused on how to describe user preferences by the implicit click/like interactions, to find the synergy of people. For the content-based explicit comments/reviews interactions, some works attempt to utilize them to mine the semantic knowledge to enhance recommender models. However, they still neglect the following two points: (1) The content semantic is a universal world knowledge; how do we extract the multi-aspect semantic information to empower different domains? (2) The user/item ID feature is a fundamental element for recommender models; how do we align the ID and content semantic feature space? In this paper, we propose a `plugin' semantic knowledge transferring method \textbf{LoID}, which includes two major components: (1) LoRA-based large language model pretraining to extract multi-aspect semantic information; (2) ID-based contrastive objective to align their feature spaces. We conduct extensive experiments with SOTA baselines on real-world datasets, the detailed results demonstrating significant improvements of our method LoID.
[ -0.5102986097335815, -0.6782172322273254, 0.7106252312660217, 0.02995036356151104, -0.3605949580669403, -0.23433558642864227, -0.20739267766475677, -0.543494462966919, 0.47493231296539307, 0.6482289433479309, -0.7288579940795898, -0.7123152017593384, -0.34500181674957275, -0.369293749332428, -0.28884556889533997, 1.416593313217163, 0.008106197230517864, -0.08158879727125168, -0.323122501373291, -0.10438419878482819, -0.5571187734603882, -0.28523656725883484, -0.4203106164932251, -0.4038655161857605, 0.8436194062232971, 0.458022803068161, 0.4957011342048645, 0.21686607599258423, 0.6134853363037109, 0.2308010309934616, -0.06289657950401306, 0.3356534242630005, -0.6077803373336792, 0.029429754242300987, -0.6758081912994385, -0.11031188815832138, -0.627109944820404, -0.3009476661682129, 0.3347175717353821, 0.6699292063713074, 0.21678699553012848, -0.14393581449985504, 0.2141743302345276, 0.608174204826355, -0.5986542701721191, 0.13162016868591309, -0.3817439079284668, -0.16213710606098175, 0.019968051463365555, -0.016788458451628685, -0.17465242743492126, -0.33135518431663513, 0.7462369799613953, -0.9283540844917297, -0.03967026248574257, 0.22305716574192047, 0.8242159485816956, -0.03318313881754875, -0.5394389033317566, -0.20468923449516296, -0.8350999355316162, 0.8608148097991943, -0.6375622153282166, 0.1244770959019661, 0.5113416314125061, -0.0870460495352745, -0.07962660491466522, -0.31625601649284363, -0.6772136688232422, -0.07360387593507767, -0.11982157081365585, -0.07479111105203629, 0.18035654723644257, -0.10316959023475647, 0.20859888195991516, 0.35820212960243225, -0.2703940272331238, 0.1386304348707199, -0.1854024976491928, 0.004060139413923025, 0.6737356781959534, -0.17398545145988464, 0.4350825548171997, -0.1253829151391983, -0.5889812111854553, -0.22733229398727417, -0.7273439168930054, 0.0014020277885720134, 0.2555750608444214, 0.24605068564414978, -0.1532721221446991, 0.606678307056427, -0.3639370799064636, 0.39977240562438965, 0.14607872068881989, -0.049568526446819305, 0.47098061442375183, -0.7505130171775818, 0.08304755389690399, -0.06955104321241379, 0.7037967443466187, 0.6540511846542358, 0.28335726261138916, -0.035100050270557404, -0.023065460845828056, -0.12076805531978607, 0.21900583803653717, -0.9683305621147156, -0.1811620593070984, 0.03885131701827049, -0.2791171371936798, -0.2897651493549347, 0.424623966217041, -0.6636762619018555, -0.6133230924606323, -0.3419623076915741, 0.6568896174430847, -0.6340267062187195, -0.2775973379611969, 0.1376221626996994, 0.04951727017760277, 0.007457339204847813, 0.42418962717056274, -0.8942571878433228, 0.28263115882873535, 0.719272792339325, 0.5114293694496155, -0.47421637177467346, -0.4219932556152344, -0.5559611320495605, 0.28425484895706177, 0.08668997883796692, 1.2541874647140503, -0.6278310418128967, -0.25534501671791077, 0.22927898168563843, 0.14079467952251434, 0.2311447709798813, -0.3650877773761749, 0.5120096802711487, -0.662651002407074, 0.13553591072559357, -0.5414970517158508, -0.4838011860847473, -0.4194391965866089, 0.35624757409095764, -0.636422872543335, 0.847476065158844, 0.13694308698177338, -0.82747882604599, 0.38848739862442017, -0.7820334434509277, -0.5406562089920044, -0.18804079294204712, 0.22955980896949768, -0.27339404821395874, 0.02064882218837738, 0.37694624066352844, 0.2882935404777527, -0.2306373566389084, 0.24491006135940552, -0.5525559782981873, -0.3396885395050049, 0.3288877308368683, 0.0609288290143013, 0.2975180447101593, 0.13752730190753937, -0.014672615565359592, 0.543773353099823, -0.4845963716506958, -0.14517095685005188, -0.018029382452368736, -0.09201259911060333, -0.7375731468200684, -0.21117210388183594, 0.2056899070739746, 0.16946175694465637, 0.3910911977291107, -0.5961372256278992, 0.33225366473197937, -0.5786267518997192, 0.18551933765411377, 0.6299653053283691, 0.236500546336174, 0.7603253126144409, -0.40808865427970886, 0.11684675514698029, 0.319550096988678, 0.00877411663532257, -0.1723724603652954, -0.18799161911010742, -0.6574403047561646, -0.126302108168602, 0.4995797574520111, 0.24675016105175018, -0.7350376844406128, 0.9837194681167603, -0.4447249472141266, -0.32888174057006836, -0.32802316546440125, 0.43804091215133667, 0.22067691385746002, 0.10071450471878052, 0.32504987716674805, -0.5556132197380066, -0.3989681005477905, -0.5338752269744873, 0.012662200257182121, -0.032748837023973465, -0.0021936162374913692, 0.5077573657035828, 0.18620476126670837, -0.45077431201934814, 0.7658315896987915, -0.7734248042106628, -0.7181159853935242, -0.42894622683525085, -0.05905413627624512, 0.17258715629577637, 0.45009157061576843, 0.21495261788368225, -0.6035148501396179, -0.5285187363624573, 0.07878201454877853, -0.46757772564888, -0.054202545434236526, 0.2365712970495224, -0.588370680809021, -0.1750182807445526, 0.3527704179286957, -0.5085934400558472, 0.31915467977523804, 0.38890230655670166, -0.5283820629119873, 0.24128828942775726, -0.25972139835357666, 0.30719253420829773, -1.2674238681793213, -0.008084651082754135, 0.1378321498632431, -0.09909636527299881, -0.28887638449668884, -0.014296404086053371, -0.15419256687164307, -0.022742778062820435, -0.4190925061702728, 0.7890943288803101, -0.027352171018719673, 0.12094220519065857, -0.4942016005516052, 0.5494573712348938, 0.3241666853427887, 0.6064711809158325, 0.047733746469020844, 0.33859768509864807, 0.5087113976478577, -0.6051770448684692, 0.3844260275363922, 0.36866649985313416, -0.46788230538368225, 0.9071149230003357, -0.5740705132484436, 0.17585285007953644, 0.06175956502556801, 0.3505401015281677, -1.0252685546875, 0.041370898485183716, -0.020004065707325935, -0.0038124588318169117, -0.09093411266803741, -0.2328777313232422, -0.3873441517353058, 0.12660548090934753, -0.5315368175506592, 0.5710811018943787, 0.26381421089172363, -0.5855473875999451, 0.7234523892402649, 0.3718883693218231, -0.4035645127296448, -0.4453444480895996, 0.012222020886838436, -0.2581310570240021, -0.0718802958726883, -0.5545686483383179, 0.7100017666816711, -0.4352576732635498, -0.0986613780260086, 0.29793262481689453, 0.05677655339241028, -0.03724651411175728, -0.04932952672243118, 0.46886101365089417, 0.5855443477630615, -0.18177464604377747, 0.4126899838447571, 0.052403151988983154, -0.21221859753131866, -0.23056700825691223, -0.5896305441856384, 0.6020030975341797, 0.06184431165456772, -0.5016295909881592, -0.3979852497577667, 0.345834344625473, 0.4456847310066223, -0.45975106954574585, 0.6377124190330505, 0.9251340627670288, -0.06574928760528564, -0.17421948909759521, -0.6902901530265808, -0.3559117019176483, -0.38622164726257324, 0.6357271075248718, -0.3428826332092285, -0.9312160015106201, 0.2362586259841919, -0.29437509179115295, 0.07051098346710205, 0.4651860296726227, 0.34353697299957275, -0.2244686633348465, 0.8471123576164246, 0.8028738498687744, -0.34729528427124023, 0.8034797310829163, -0.3943580687046051, 0.4245419502258301, -1.1386827230453491, -0.07035616040229797, -0.32217860221862793, -0.4678078591823578, -0.15021276473999023, -0.19994065165519714, 0.1771077811717987, 0.17164278030395508, -0.09411311149597168, 0.3425145149230957, -0.1335456371307373, 0.4079693555831909, 0.5676661729812622, 0.3314894437789917, 0.4416675567626953, 0.11509112268686295, -0.17922340333461761, -0.05337667465209961, -0.3281139135360718, -0.09948127716779709, 1.053203821182251, 0.1564009189605713, 0.9621197581291199, 0.2621147930622101, 0.3679123818874359, 0.42129382491111755, 0.011660588905215263, -0.9171989560127258, 0.4172436594963074, -0.32889893651008606, -0.2274724841117859, -0.4047001600265503, -0.05135231092572212, -0.7938525080680847, -0.0709470883011818, -0.714093804359436, -0.5852324366569519, 0.24250388145446777, -0.16414973139762878, -0.495342880487442, 0.1525450050830841, -0.5836402773857117, 0.7743061184883118, -0.16724495589733124, -0.5454277396202087, -0.5794243216514587, -0.2538827359676361, 0.06016724556684494, -0.1519908756017685, 0.10121311247348785, -0.16561293601989746, 0.2482244074344635, 0.7446318864822388, -0.40483227372169495, 0.6863572597503662, -0.22530066967010498, -0.2823060154914856, 0.20637297630310059, 0.1501627117395401, 0.6713525652885437, 0.07988717406988144, 0.0028528408147394657, 0.1284496933221817, 0.0384034588932991, -0.09159758687019348, -0.881791889667511, 1.169321894645691, -0.827387273311615, -0.5991330146789551, -0.031979188323020935, -0.7407405972480774, -0.21953321993350983, 0.33982306718826294, -0.06411850452423096, 0.47394859790802, -0.23465293645858765, 0.2529575228691101, 0.8627373576164246, -0.02048472873866558, 0.06462158262729645, 0.6353703141212463, -0.49347352981567383, -0.384537011384964, 1.0703341960906982, -0.008745272643864155, 0.02048889547586441, 0.44630327820777893, 0.28353151679039, -0.32309645414352417, -0.36674952507019043, -0.20246386528015137, 0.5391206741333008, -0.6054246425628662, -0.05328580364584923, -0.895045280456543, -0.2710410952568054, -0.38204503059387207, -0.11550735682249069, -0.21568100154399872, -0.08715447783470154, -0.10298798233270645, -0.13513225317001343, 0.531767725944519, 0.7194986343383789, 0.40917426347732544, 0.2646476924419403, -0.6109530925750732, 0.32006093859672546, 0.49968579411506653, 0.6715853214263916, 0.06412255764007568, -0.5917529463768005, -0.569434404373169, -0.19550901651382446, -0.13195715844631195, -0.32254791259765625, 0.11240951716899872, 0.09298243373632431, 0.3514588475227356, 0.7217264175415039, 0.41483956575393677, 0.5603529810905457, -0.3205975890159607, 0.5514788031578064, 0.06967564672231674, -0.7326173782348633, 0.42050880193710327, -0.14116159081459045, 0.2859298884868622, 0.6308885216712952, 0.3721694350242615, -0.4232129752635956, -0.008734439499676228, -0.5095607042312622, -0.7367684245109558, 0.5282672643661499, -0.16980908811092377, 0.2476186752319336, 0.3353823125362396, 0.13362248241901398, 0.25787782669067383, -0.02469099685549736, -0.6034010648727417, 0.10263731330633163, -0.0724889263510704, -0.4338681995868683, -0.05744457617402077, -0.5045243501663208, -0.19985970854759216, -0.05661280080676079, 0.9595909714698792, -0.2513470947742462, -0.08040504157543182, 0.12930743396282196, -0.24400702118873596, -0.024381963536143303, 0.4192867875099182, 0.309884250164032, 0.7125368714332581, -0.2655649781227112, -0.016515130177140236, 0.08153823763132095, -0.31764665246009827, 0.028889533132314682, 0.053985532373189926, -0.1434326320886612, -0.3999268114566803, 0.048374637961387634, 0.8334486484527588, 0.3798752427101135, -0.5937857031822205, 0.8817106485366821, -0.15303082764148712, -0.0035512845497578382, -0.322272926568985, 0.2707681655883789, 0.0944787934422493, 0.28921088576316833, -0.09307515621185303, 0.08855187892913818, 0.17924563586711884, -0.6483467221260071, 0.017571544274687767, 0.520699143409729, -0.9374369978904724, -0.33752769231796265, 0.019180720672011375, 0.6006461381912231, -0.12774905562400818, 0.46015089750289917, 0.09480740129947662, -0.2738247513771057, -0.013690048828721046, 0.6530027389526367, 0.7745068073272705, 0.16504988074302673, 0.02600114978849888, 0.28144821524620056, -0.22925762832164764, 0.03080049715936184, 0.04992753267288208, -0.3069964349269867, -1.043430209159851, -0.5427106618881226, -0.5782556533813477, -0.24846187233924866, 0.031581152230501175, -0.49333810806274414, 0.5485520958900452, -0.4631655216217041, -0.09724774956703186, 0.0718308612704277, 0.18506355583667755, -0.7072252631187439, -0.010770635679364204, -0.05981529504060745, 0.5763418078422546, -0.8122614026069641, 1.0016106367111206, 0.8280940651893616, -0.4400389790534973, -0.5448724031448364, 0.12888778746128082, -0.22065378725528717, -0.4605913460254669, 0.445468932390213, 0.0055290949530899525, -0.27986034750938416, -0.0391559824347496, -0.41002681851387024, -0.7816079258918762, 0.8703630566596985, -0.01464389730244875, -0.379210889339447, 0.15351340174674988, -0.36166054010391235, 0.6423160433769226, -0.7687313556671143, 0.3645801246166229, 0.23588724434375763, 0.4339161217212677, 0.3755168318748474, -0.7147735953330994, 0.14271239936351776, -0.37992340326309204, 0.00925844069570303, 0.01477961428463459, -0.3910079896450043, 0.4651508331298828, -0.3163743317127228, 0.07773110270500183, 0.10217106342315674, 0.7206214666366577, 0.2049514651298523, 0.12982118129730225, 0.786393940448761, 0.5751478672027588, 0.4706050753593445, 0.25894811749458313, 0.971742570400238, -0.33957427740097046, 0.10401315987110138, 1.0898419618606567, -0.7918257713317871, 1.0285067558288574, 0.3519628643989563, -0.0036952137015759945, 1.0257980823516846, 0.331746906042099, -0.09099525213241577, 0.579443097114563, -0.02939404919743538, -0.3160110116004944, -0.19033591449260712, -0.7045443058013916, -0.2561301290988922, 0.2703467905521393, 0.2750651240348816, -0.2063038945198059, 0.17182230949401855, 0.07899272441864014, -0.02737504057586193, 0.07399243861436844, -0.13316717743873596, 1.4651213884353638, -0.09409802407026291, -0.8766430020332336, 0.18942858278751373, 0.04835370555520058, 0.8493757247924805, -0.7835033535957336, -0.31480517983436584, -0.13152067363262177, 0.10597044229507446, -0.3321708142757416, -0.8184542059898376, -0.11571706086397171, -0.1793605387210846, -0.66389399766922, 0.20454643666744232, 0.9209365248680115, -0.5961959362030029, -0.4221169054508209, 0.3481675684452057, 0.32514622807502747, -0.04500940814614296, -0.22922201454639435, -0.26694750785827637, -0.14441463351249695, 0.016576295718550682, 0.3020666241645813, 0.4690883159637451, 0.4437303841114044, -0.17221471667289734, 0.581054151058197, 0.892959475517273, 0.3102184236049652, -0.5460130572319031, 0.40118277072906494, 0.8911924958229065, -0.7029324769973755, -0.8442926406860352, -0.6088250875473022, 0.3570449948310852, -0.1839897632598877, -0.026003744453191757, 0.5519150495529175, 0.24441953003406525, 0.863286554813385, -0.047547198832035065, 0.7440482974052429, 0.0358387753367424, 0.6013720035552979, -0.529674768447876, 0.5734713077545166, -0.34201937913894653, 0.5973038077354431, -0.38128501176834106, -1.5209144353866577, -0.04602751135826111, 0.2510210871696472, -0.5223493576049805, 0.08427120000123978, 0.9028125405311584, 0.8012916445732117, -0.20594348013401031, -0.17742960155010223, 0.3242724537849426, 0.3135666847229004, 0.16298837959766388, 0.40483617782592773, 0.6518400311470032, -0.3734918236732483, 0.49106425046920776, -0.062267571687698364, -0.18172800540924072, -0.39045366644859314, -0.6570670008659363, -0.8892849087715149, -0.6069759130477905, -0.46077612042427063, -0.5475761890411377, -0.005105238873511553, 1.0971910953521729, 0.8809699416160583, -0.969253420829773, -0.1757335364818573, 0.3841288387775421, 0.44354212284088135, -0.25207918882369995, -0.18788623809814453, 0.6820877194404602, -0.07986222952604294, -0.6844141483306885, 0.22512346506118774, 0.3856782615184784, -0.19024820625782013, -0.5445764064788818, -0.13355182111263275, -0.25289344787597656, 0.03296356648206711, 0.6181423664093018, -0.0291665680706501, -0.6411665678024292, -0.35776177048683167, -0.28787001967430115, -0.08145821839570999, -0.011838403530418873, 0.8057524561882019, -0.7865570187568665, 0.47150227427482605, 0.6011584997177124, 0.5234136581420898, 0.4456441402435303, 0.24888263642787933, 0.668644368648529, -0.5595091581344604, 0.05357486009597778, -0.3909565210342407, 0.28319546580314636, 0.372393399477005, -0.37506189942359924, 0.23419387638568878, 0.21330799162387848, -0.4663471281528473, -0.24640005826950073, 0.21375273168087006, -1.1009008884429932, -0.1321793645620346, 1.1898804903030396, -0.42495197057724, -0.26644107699394226, -0.15923580527305603, -0.5733474493026733, -0.11151544004678726, -0.6343245506286621, 0.7299766540527344, 0.4992518424987793, 0.2562159597873688, 0.06985096633434296, -0.16832679510116577, 0.43221941590309143, 0.3349507451057434, -0.7350590825080872, -0.10319384187459946, 0.3968716859817505, 0.4521334171295166, 0.14865143597126007, 0.33649852871894836, -0.17559359967708588, 0.1477462500333786, -0.38243338465690613, 0.283157616853714, -0.02242642641067505, -0.4787721633911133, -0.22517555952072144, 0.17044329643249512, 0.3321991264820099, 0.13028930127620697 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00227v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00227v1
A Survey of using Large Language Models for Generating Infrastructure as Code
2024-03-30T02:57:55
2024-03-30T02:57:55
Kalahasti Ganesh Srivatsa, Sabyasachi Mukhopadhyay, Ganesh Katrapati, Manish Shrivastava
cs.SE
cs.SE, cs.CL
Infrastructure as Code (IaC) is a revolutionary approach which has gained significant prominence in the Industry. IaC manages and provisions IT infrastructure using machine-readable code by enabling automation, consistency across the environments, reproducibility, version control, error reduction and enhancement in scalability. However, IaC orchestration is often a painstaking effort which requires specialised skills as well as a lot of manual effort. Automation of IaC is a necessity in the present conditions of the Industry and in this survey, we study the feasibility of applying Large Language Models (LLM) to address this problem. LLMs are large neural network-based models which have demonstrated significant language processing abilities and shown to be capable of following a range of instructions within a broad scope. Recently, they have also been adapted for code understanding and generation tasks successfully, which makes them a promising choice for the automatic generation of IaC configurations. In this survey, we delve into the details of IaC, usage of IaC in different platforms, their challenges, LLMs in terms of code-generation aspects and the importance of LLMs in IaC along with our own experiments. Finally, we conclude by presenting the challenges in this area and highlighting the scope for future research.
[ -0.6799793839454651, -0.4988405108451843, 0.45342695713043213, 0.4234788715839386, -0.020634762942790985, -0.09396874904632568, -0.27482059597969055, -0.4772094786167145, 0.11969822645187378, 0.6415470838546753, -0.30274778604507446, -0.501579225063324, -0.3403578996658325, 0.47680363059043884, -0.8565241694450378, 0.8815432190895081, -0.16651269793510437, 0.02752416580915451, -0.19344542920589447, -0.2677477300167084, -0.5562384724617004, -0.8485506772994995, -0.5609298348426819, -0.2050294578075409, 0.30208486318588257, 0.4668354392051697, 0.40854889154434204, 0.683214008808136, 0.7080414891242981, 0.4037502408027649, -0.07981931418180466, 0.13654188811779022, -0.020202413201332092, -0.05020616948604584, -0.0467493012547493, -0.38440364599227905, -0.5608540177345276, -0.27480101585388184, 0.7161378860473633, 0.7057462930679321, -0.2864447832107544, 0.30998504161834717, -0.06571144610643387, 0.7476844191551208, -0.612906813621521, 0.3663148581981659, -0.9071653485298157, -0.16580581665039062, -0.02690735273063183, -0.01610773615539074, -0.33242523670196533, 0.020549554377794266, -0.29749637842178345, -0.06557036936283112, -0.40613576769828796, 0.2337183952331543, 0.6819795966148376, 0.22915248572826385, -0.6007701754570007, -0.8222320675849915, -0.8092966079711914, 0.6426623463630676, -0.8172642588615417, 0.17045582830905914, 0.2539553642272949, 0.24888397753238678, -0.1452413648366928, -0.8837407827377319, -0.5369873046875, -0.5922620296478271, 0.1717699021100998, -0.16500085592269897, -0.04081152379512787, -0.12924526631832123, 0.23666143417358398, 0.3855743110179901, -0.3000469207763672, 0.658203661441803, -0.5750580430030823, 0.005728567950427532, 0.4705716073513031, 0.43925386667251587, 0.47980621457099915, -0.2202252745628357, -0.18098147213459015, 0.2426561415195465, -1.119036078453064, -0.2431793510913849, 0.4855603575706482, 0.07917889952659607, -0.1574467420578003, 0.6237119436264038, -0.039392128586769104, 0.5360997319221497, -0.5636712908744812, 0.22050541639328003, -0.05970867723226547, -0.12647821009159088, -0.26062139868736267, -0.16275468468666077, 0.6464811563491821, 0.02685592882335186, 0.5200518369674683, -0.15693315863609314, -0.5246481895446777, 0.18221062421798706, 0.7584598660469055, -0.5632258653640747, -0.1615259200334549, 0.4466390311717987, -0.5840451717376709, -0.34012478590011597, -0.11223488301038742, -0.5228497385978699, -0.03722983971238136, -0.6702303290367126, -0.10174380242824554, 0.0453316867351532, -0.39495763182640076, -0.01825880818068981, 0.34408143162727356, 0.5804483890533447, 0.09494749456644058, -0.73435378074646, 0.22779375314712524, 0.7955331802368164, 1.0330390930175781, -0.17717407643795013, -0.2764759361743927, -0.23407219350337982, 0.09932085126638412, -0.4918917119503021, 0.6675770878791809, 0.044201336801052094, -0.555422842502594, 0.3208094835281372, -0.08713972568511963, 0.3387600779533386, -0.497721791267395, 0.11469319462776184, -0.7701956629753113, -0.38182663917541504, 0.3679390251636505, -0.3764323592185974, 0.2977096736431122, 0.32291048765182495, -0.7541230320930481, 0.4481103718280792, -0.0611119382083416, -0.5853550434112549, -0.0355679988861084, -0.9295551776885986, -0.5123444199562073, 0.053275901824235916, -0.3671964108943939, -0.48563140630722046, 0.1862371563911438, 0.088930644094944, 0.41257089376449585, -0.5623911619186401, 0.5088703632354736, -0.28626731038093567, -0.1605350375175476, 0.5421314835548401, -0.3475615680217743, 0.631533682346344, 0.54339998960495, -0.5944188237190247, 0.06528972834348679, -0.6859554052352905, -0.08710114657878876, -0.08664276450872421, -0.5604385733604431, 0.068947933614254, 0.22478756308555603, 0.3464799225330353, 0.32948049902915955, 0.17954951524734497, -0.2500942349433899, 0.3483017086982727, -0.3444822430610657, 0.875182569026947, 0.9706250429153442, -0.2710433006286621, 0.4470357298851013, -0.07613661885261536, 0.5569824576377869, -0.008126141503453255, 0.0185528751462698, -0.22337104380130768, -0.34004926681518555, -0.9060814380645752, -0.11968669295310974, 0.4686361253261566, 0.4469985067844391, -0.7743611335754395, 0.33560341596603394, -0.39300447702407837, -0.4760721027851105, -0.2729358971118927, 0.1731569468975067, 0.22323428094387054, 0.07422106713056564, -0.07433868944644928, -0.0984957292675972, -0.7536981701850891, -1.1577976942062378, 0.2424430102109909, -0.2891407012939453, 0.0203291904181242, 0.5681006908416748, 0.8548125624656677, -0.5543538331985474, 0.7712609767913818, -0.48079702258110046, -0.12170416116714478, -0.23902088403701782, 0.024218672886490822, 0.1662120521068573, 0.5749548077583313, 0.3722115457057953, -0.8964259028434753, -0.1779606193304062, 0.18736092746257782, -0.891903817653656, -0.11297612637281418, 0.05616897717118263, 0.03729855641722679, 0.6260731816291809, 0.9502180814743042, -0.5022224187850952, 0.35790860652923584, 0.8140098452568054, 0.016761012375354767, 0.7468969225883484, -0.27641725540161133, 0.1871107816696167, -1.2383100986480713, 0.5724206566810608, -0.32397156953811646, -0.08347044885158539, -0.41846004128456116, 0.6279946565628052, -0.013967804610729218, -0.49509865045547485, -0.44557639956474304, 0.3972795903682709, -0.7198776602745056, -0.36329513788223267, -0.4874173700809479, -0.1375102549791336, -0.25280871987342834, 0.39117711782455444, -0.040947023779153824, 1.0027159452438354, 0.708200991153717, -0.8553061485290527, 0.23702885210514069, 0.26921364665031433, -0.8374614715576172, 0.2340036779642105, -0.7112815380096436, 0.3505796492099762, -0.022469542920589447, 0.33414483070373535, -0.6770170331001282, -0.22842182219028473, -0.20406919717788696, -0.10829023271799088, 0.018305711448192596, -0.0682799443602562, -0.8181459903717041, -0.37287360429763794, 0.340808629989624, 0.4599071145057678, 0.6879483461380005, -0.6117262244224548, 0.5413733720779419, 0.5961477756500244, -0.1487581878900528, -0.3829953372478485, -1.0766085386276245, 0.6291495561599731, -0.42706596851348877, -0.7099385261535645, 0.024687251076102257, -0.16648760437965393, -0.5517933368682861, -0.35098540782928467, 0.22813744843006134, -0.13227048516273499, 0.3086317777633667, 0.6637210249900818, 0.20240214467048645, -0.44327840209007263, 0.1192900538444519, -0.4144824147224426, -0.05338399484753609, 0.268688440322876, -0.5241997241973877, 0.5431054830551147, -0.26409173011779785, -0.5399471521377563, -0.3332284092903137, 0.8693493008613586, 0.9619360566139221, -0.45812171697616577, 0.964413046836853, 0.14068672060966492, -0.23295080661773682, -0.3914429247379303, -0.626703679561615, -0.036731280386447906, -0.49023357033729553, 0.4223698675632477, -0.35515284538269043, -0.9722084999084473, 0.8205474615097046, -0.5246779322624207, 0.3515571653842926, 0.2085755318403244, 0.7459633350372314, -0.13613149523735046, 0.9798521995544434, 0.7299043536186218, -0.33495232462882996, 0.30722662806510925, -0.3752082288265228, 0.4101332724094391, -0.5480291247367859, -0.03065537102520466, -0.9501515626907349, -0.2652551829814911, -0.6557013988494873, -0.13561563193798065, 0.592551052570343, -0.08925433456897736, -0.3367869257926941, 0.24823075532913208, -0.2651374638080597, 0.15381678938865662, 0.13941633701324463, -0.12304969877004623, 0.31556975841522217, 0.04121483862400055, 0.21621297299861908, 0.4681822657585144, -0.6806795597076416, -0.6500357389450073, 1.0705211162567139, 0.5501809120178223, 0.5570833683013916, 0.3413744568824768, 0.3803982734680176, 0.35461312532424927, 0.5233035683631897, -0.6325929164886475, 0.526593804359436, -0.146697998046875, -0.6623805165290833, -0.20960772037506104, -0.5362930297851562, -0.9000135064125061, -0.33766475319862366, 0.04561852291226387, -0.6491941809654236, 0.03026859275996685, 0.15836407244205475, -0.021835392341017723, 0.45223966240882874, -0.5717372298240662, 0.513299822807312, -0.21977342665195465, 0.0865253210067749, -0.34248241782188416, -0.33766621351242065, 0.306861937046051, -0.2245119959115982, 0.5286753177642822, 0.3746226131916046, -0.1397346705198288, 0.36323612928390503, -0.606853187084198, 0.5656676292419434, 0.22308358550071716, -0.3842291533946991, 0.6778194904327393, -0.0319935642182827, 0.8588435649871826, 0.0655275210738182, -0.32361283898353577, 0.4282475411891937, -0.45769616961479187, -0.3511319160461426, -0.3950742185115814, 0.9966063499450684, -0.8328766822814941, -0.5940272808074951, 0.02066859044134617, -0.5936669707298279, -0.09116416424512863, -0.14047771692276, 0.0805908814072609, 0.7707218527793884, -0.04248857498168945, 0.4459376931190491, 0.5179001092910767, -0.16695353388786316, 0.8640937805175781, 0.45219752192497253, -0.23450593650341034, -0.3710329830646515, 0.6519520282745361, 0.0664042979478836, 0.24345619976520538, 0.11217350512742996, -0.3740907907485962, -0.022221151739358902, -0.9567317962646484, -0.5955419540405273, -0.0908552035689354, -0.5987495183944702, -0.3377387821674347, -0.7874476313591003, -0.3724013566970825, -0.2920454442501068, -0.3980466425418854, -0.3670436143875122, -0.039130210876464844, -0.31275126338005066, 0.03328457847237587, 0.25964924693107605, 1.0552676916122437, 0.21133773028850555, 0.4216536283493042, -0.5840699672698975, 0.19621558487415314, 0.17808176577091217, 0.6195731163024902, 0.0792955830693245, -0.15961672365665436, -0.5451967716217041, -0.11722365021705627, -0.011698873713612556, -0.7261044979095459, 0.4116232097148895, -0.12130332738161087, 0.24313496053218842, -0.038405001163482666, -0.24060462415218353, 0.4165320098400116, -0.6157221794128418, 0.7824516892433167, 0.017073016613721848, -0.8731256127357483, 0.3586984872817993, -0.38250893354415894, 0.3842383623123169, 0.44925928115844727, 0.22941738367080688, -0.2602657377719879, -0.267890989780426, -0.5348344445228577, -1.0429970026016235, 0.38566622138023376, 0.2722610533237457, 0.25475257635116577, 0.050286829471588135, 0.3971326947212219, -0.33046960830688477, 0.4087601602077484, -0.8418822288513184, -0.08147744089365005, 0.0795564204454422, 0.08484388142824173, -0.021563030779361725, -0.15145090222358704, 0.004543049726635218, 0.3651580810546875, 0.6419990658760071, -0.2883218824863434, 0.12888853251934052, -0.06610435247421265, -0.07911764830350876, 0.09278123825788498, 0.48968350887298584, 0.4420463442802429, 0.8691455125808716, 0.27977797389030457, -0.09411922842264175, 0.25481116771698, -0.13208936154842377, 0.10527738183736801, -0.4879085421562195, -0.03127256780862808, -0.26727065443992615, 0.31204894185066223, 0.6485293507575989, -0.035872407257556915, -0.9659311175346375, 0.47229868173599243, -0.007491044234484434, -0.22284525632858276, -0.8229893445968628, -0.06899693608283997, 0.3093307614326477, 0.17088238894939423, 0.20378662645816803, -0.016094811260700226, 0.005754532292485237, -0.5527639985084534, 0.07812094688415527, 0.6391699314117432, -0.25747784972190857, 0.16731247305870056, 0.4305887520313263, 0.3573629558086395, -0.5157476663589478, 1.0706491470336914, 0.07794724404811859, -0.17792704701423645, 1.0756405591964722, 0.5478660464286804, 0.7568462491035461, 0.24147529900074005, -0.24435646831989288, 0.07944868505001068, 0.3967222571372986, -0.015054319053888321, 0.1854095309972763, 0.08622942864894867, -0.4333065450191498, -0.6765594482421875, -0.8460425734519958, -0.09007309377193451, 0.37726879119873047, -0.3321186602115631, 0.4938381016254425, -0.6608671545982361, -0.0735572800040245, -0.33675336837768555, -0.36855348944664, -0.7034577131271362, 0.011831838637590408, 0.3159511089324951, 1.197494387626648, -0.8665452599525452, 0.7987397313117981, 0.957068681716919, -0.3085089921951294, -1.300282597541809, -0.26608139276504517, -0.3094342350959778, -0.42491021752357483, 0.6787850260734558, -0.07413724809885025, 0.12107807397842407, 0.09908115118741989, -0.653223991394043, -0.5898522138595581, 1.088752269744873, 0.2046125829219818, -0.6711630821228027, -0.1619444340467453, 0.3183148205280304, 0.6264679431915283, -0.7499736547470093, 0.29066115617752075, 0.3664959669113159, 0.4615683853626251, -0.144539475440979, -0.9356153011322021, -0.26411569118499756, -0.46334922313690186, 0.32903966307640076, 0.14981664717197418, -0.6546420454978943, 0.881930947303772, 0.09501425176858902, -0.00299911224283278, 0.31977441906929016, 0.79021155834198, 0.38580596446990967, 0.06093074008822441, 0.5988465547561646, 0.17081701755523682, 0.12476655840873718, 0.2723521888256073, 1.0935479402542114, -0.620943009853363, 0.0363692045211792, 0.7582316994667053, -0.13688835501670837, 0.7761095762252808, 0.5894585847854614, -0.11391329765319824, 0.7008636593818665, 0.34348535537719727, -0.009225703775882721, -0.061571668833494186, 0.6475980877876282, -0.10560696572065353, -0.1713275909423828, -0.15448720753192902, -0.3423610031604767, 0.8119055032730103, 0.3332243859767914, -0.39742234349250793, 0.08559301495552063, 0.054890912026166916, -0.07526689022779465, 0.11787743866443634, -0.7090209722518921, 0.9336456656455994, 0.4414576292037964, -0.8267504572868347, 0.44890540838241577, 0.23347409069538116, 0.6603918075561523, -0.6352350115776062, -0.08701791614294052, -0.17643694579601288, 0.03272721916437149, -0.2458128184080124, -0.567145824432373, 0.4569442868232727, 0.25241631269454956, -0.30256980657577515, -0.33484527468681335, 0.4826946258544922, -0.06976133584976196, -0.3935677409172058, 0.1392693966627121, 0.264574259519577, 0.19964154064655304, -0.12459538131952286, -0.32893797755241394, 0.23353993892669678, 0.010677608661353588, 0.04959183931350708, 0.5432695746421814, 0.3557455241680145, -0.1571507751941681, 0.9900383949279785, 0.6605987548828125, 0.3217276334762573, -0.04795566573739052, -0.007485900539904833, 0.845252513885498, -0.35564863681793213, -0.6958195567131042, -0.7530492544174194, 0.7822631001472473, 0.14973744750022888, -0.41609251499176025, 0.43783843517303467, 0.4247452914714813, 0.46154284477233887, -0.4696342647075653, 0.7430980801582336, -0.04776434972882271, -0.1482771784067154, -0.5542533993721008, 0.9337446093559265, -0.5082577466964722, 0.6536426544189453, -0.21426725387573242, -0.9745422601699829, -0.03549422323703766, -0.025519022718071938, -0.03781510889530182, -0.15030474960803986, 0.4886046350002289, 1.1354304552078247, -0.12428289651870728, 0.06956280767917633, 0.2862362861633301, 0.1523577868938446, 0.4299926459789276, 0.43965309858322144, 0.9044999480247498, -0.28813299536705017, 0.7549611926078796, 0.17951254546642303, -0.11213988065719604, -0.18169425427913666, -0.9366090297698975, -0.7177377343177795, -0.7946685552597046, -0.3400996923446655, -0.37551215291023254, -0.004514879547059536, 0.8023682832717896, 0.6824935078620911, -0.966210126876831, -0.5147935748100281, -0.44724929332733154, -0.007581185549497604, 0.13132157921791077, -0.10553053021430969, 0.1783573031425476, -0.258483350276947, -0.665211021900177, 0.2535494565963745, 0.35798314213752747, -0.0866505429148674, -0.879821240901947, -0.04463542625308037, -0.2744068503379822, 0.006591953337192535, 0.4545525312423706, 0.3164665997028351, -0.5305289626121521, -0.22343944013118744, -0.11844519525766373, -0.46631568670272827, -0.1770690232515335, 1.1956169605255127, -0.6860133409500122, -0.11934473365545273, 0.3760877251625061, 0.9769859313964844, 0.15208548307418823, -0.3107319474220276, 0.788776695728302, -0.5616212487220764, 0.08418016135692596, 0.189191997051239, 0.4441201388835907, 0.21759578585624695, -0.33296912908554077, 0.4154965877532959, -0.2510400712490082, -0.9989613890647888, -0.9214706420898438, 0.4917742908000946, -0.7371746301651001, -0.3925726115703583, 1.2581216096878052, -0.15480197966098785, -0.34998565912246704, -0.20171913504600525, -0.03138202428817749, 0.030602339655160904, 0.04480834677815437, 0.8607895374298096, 0.4759272038936615, 0.18991023302078247, -0.05168941244482994, -0.6125230193138123, 0.24187719821929932, 0.3996800184249878, -1.1013987064361572, 0.0011052752379328012, 0.4483383893966675, 0.18874907493591309, 0.20808683335781097, 0.5051234364509583, -0.1352919638156891, 0.0804411768913269, 0.05316950008273125, 0.26536354422569275, -0.11117757111787796, -0.5371940732002258, -0.4220678508281708, 0.5367278456687927, 0.3644508719444275, 0.22995080053806305 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00226v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00226v2
Design as Desired: Utilizing Visual Question Answering for Multimodal Pre-training
2024-03-30T02:56:54
2024-04-08T13:05:11
Tongkun Su, Jun Li, Xi Zhang, Haibo Jin, Hao Chen, Qiong Wang, Faqin Lv, Baoliang Zhao, Yin Hu
cs.CV
cs.CV, cs.CL
Multimodal pre-training demonstrates its potential in the medical domain, which learns medical visual representations from paired medical reports. However, many pre-training tasks require extra annotations from clinicians, and most of them fail to explicitly guide the model to learn the desired features of different pathologies. To the best of our knowledge, we are the first to utilize Visual Question Answering (VQA) for multimodal pre-training to guide the framework focusing on targeted pathological features. In this work, we leverage descriptions in medical reports to design multi-granular question-answer pairs associated with different diseases, which assist the framework in pre-training without requiring extra annotations from experts. We also propose a novel pre-training framework with a quasi-textual feature transformer, a module designed to transform visual features into a quasi-textual space closer to the textual domain via a contrastive learning strategy. This narrows the vision-language gap and facilitates modality alignment. Our framework is applied to four downstream tasks: report generation, classification, segmentation, and detection across five datasets. Extensive experiments demonstrate the superiority of our framework compared to other state-of-the-art methods. Our code will be released upon acceptance.
[ -0.5089266896247864, -0.7386937737464905, 0.6828436255455017, -0.13234850764274597, -0.503699541091919, -0.21496810019016266, 0.2217392921447754, -0.513195812702179, 0.49545031785964966, 0.538291335105896, -0.8311601281166077, -0.24375103414058685, -0.6565766334533691, 0.01899290829896927, -0.18614071607589722, 1.129787802696228, -0.18016119301319122, 0.5146037340164185, -0.5498898029327393, -0.2216191440820694, -0.4778861403465271, -0.43147340416908264, -0.1631166785955429, 0.09759558737277985, 0.7146691083908081, 0.211959108710289, 0.3776443302631378, 0.38268962502479553, 0.7864055633544922, 0.34477120637893677, 0.4423641562461853, 0.1152082085609436, -0.1927638053894043, 0.047755151987075806, 0.06036282703280449, -0.5726203322410583, -0.5914573073387146, -0.012056875042617321, 0.31124743819236755, 0.5944514870643616, 0.09019941836595535, 0.21182332932949066, -0.2656116485595703, 0.24518311023712158, -0.5103282928466797, -0.028525682166218758, -0.20014990866184235, 0.23840078711509705, -0.20490844547748566, -0.6263416409492493, -0.11157966405153275, -0.18180513381958008, 0.4588899612426758, -0.9686600565910339, 0.0935031995177269, -0.004436273593455553, 1.0482889413833618, 0.42620253562927246, -0.541347086429596, -0.15696404874324799, -0.3211374878883362, 0.4830322861671448, -0.2722392678260803, 0.24418294429779053, 0.4838624894618988, 0.5881775617599487, 0.4553338587284088, -1.1509448289871216, -0.546277642250061, -0.008561996743083, -0.45027515292167664, 0.34213680028915405, 0.005285842809826136, 0.16388174891471863, 0.03147999197244644, 0.28875255584716797, -0.8833743929862976, -0.224293515086174, -0.4750749468803406, -0.45254844427108765, 0.344472736120224, 0.34930872917175293, 0.45574238896369934, -0.15769705176353455, -0.5832475423812866, -0.033497098833322525, -0.28011050820350647, 0.08894991874694824, -0.3278721868991852, -0.03697039559483528, -0.2102423459291458, 0.4792603552341461, -0.27167731523513794, 0.591635525226593, -0.06366132199764252, -0.30501842498779297, 0.6519047021865845, -0.7697101831436157, -0.07000042498111725, -0.28085896372795105, 0.5587683916091919, 0.5042450428009033, 0.01546318456530571, -0.05339604988694191, -0.012246677652001381, 0.016432490199804306, 0.5861740112304688, -0.981703519821167, -0.40120619535446167, 0.17891958355903625, -0.7359392642974854, -0.3622948229312897, -0.11191671341657639, -0.7921829223632812, -0.15877461433410645, -0.2550918161869049, 0.7793295383453369, -0.39307260513305664, -0.242839515209198, 0.13274818658828735, -0.11424873024225235, 0.23194600641727448, 0.5616350173950195, -0.6282103657722473, 0.05863066762685776, -0.10102035105228424, 0.35154062509536743, 0.14715182781219482, -0.2978866696357727, -0.7231554388999939, 0.3375406563282013, -0.10710673034191132, 0.8688409924507141, -0.6460185050964355, -0.20595033466815948, -0.0845436081290245, 0.19274431467056274, -0.1886219084262848, -0.40812233090400696, 0.1884823441505432, -0.48000437021255493, 0.500571608543396, -0.3770817518234253, -0.0030230458360165358, -0.12648524343967438, 0.5440144538879395, -0.5607049465179443, 0.5717270970344543, 0.3991382122039795, -0.8469352722167969, 0.4290417730808258, -0.6769512891769409, -0.36318695545196533, 0.269243985414505, -0.539810836315155, -0.42806947231292725, 0.02732997201383114, 0.6365277171134949, 0.3782127797603607, -0.21477225422859192, 0.12547677755355835, -0.09465402364730835, -0.16801850497722626, 0.22456374764442444, -0.2607170045375824, 0.3039262294769287, 0.11686109006404877, -0.21255414187908173, 0.591349184513092, -0.6025529503822327, 0.26958560943603516, 0.15658468008041382, -0.15044693648815155, -0.20652706921100616, -0.35737594962120056, 0.12080998718738556, 0.4515833854675293, 0.23300613462924957, -0.40597158670425415, 0.08399413526058197, -0.19188947975635529, 0.19357195496559143, 0.499783456325531, -0.06818071752786636, 0.32018542289733887, -0.3988775312900543, 0.9337180852890015, 0.46826252341270447, 0.5973495244979858, -0.4710029363632202, -0.36426156759262085, -0.567558765411377, -0.6218714118003845, 0.16745205223560333, 0.5765187740325928, -1.4352625608444214, -0.25099921226501465, -0.35452887415885925, -0.2252325862646103, -0.6940696239471436, -0.011698376387357712, 0.7903217077255249, 0.7316337823867798, 0.7549196481704712, -0.47143620252609253, -0.458453893661499, -1.017594337463379, 0.199671670794487, -0.1569167524576187, 0.012571718543767929, 0.39845871925354004, 0.41797688603401184, -0.2945406436920166, 0.634479284286499, -0.6454320549964905, -0.5017607808113098, -0.21410779654979706, 0.1275676041841507, -0.3495783805847168, 0.2285768836736679, 0.69759202003479, -1.2935899496078491, -0.16663841903209686, -0.052670277655124664, -0.7691503763198853, 0.02393566071987152, -0.0020149119663983583, 0.03982706367969513, -0.20398736000061035, 0.6088553071022034, -0.33860090374946594, 0.5960854291915894, 0.422234445810318, -0.11875437200069427, 0.47283706068992615, -0.35195377469062805, 0.6103788614273071, -1.2460120916366577, 0.1371457427740097, -0.1911913901567459, -0.2679579555988312, -0.628528356552124, 0.008816909976303577, 0.10136362910270691, -0.13323168456554413, -0.6088714599609375, 0.48036572337150574, -0.20032070577144623, 0.37923693656921387, 0.1437014490365982, -0.19708898663520813, 0.14445412158966064, 0.4146459400653839, 0.1756146252155304, 0.6815038919448853, 0.650958240032196, -0.4878404140472412, 0.13781176507472992, 0.4460051953792572, -0.05006705969572067, 0.9149924516677856, -0.5339857935905457, -0.07573778927326202, -0.5276736617088318, 0.12064193189144135, -0.9863704442977905, -0.45270904898643494, 0.2632635831832886, -0.5484232902526855, 0.21390849351882935, -0.05807960778474808, -0.08220837265253067, -0.5211648344993591, -0.3267103433609009, 0.7200914621353149, 0.20409034192562103, -0.09491720795631409, 0.6740437746047974, 0.31528106331825256, -0.26125413179397583, -0.6186791658401489, -0.7901450395584106, -0.08214177191257477, -0.19474612176418304, -0.5853797793388367, 0.29414236545562744, -0.2768482267856598, 0.16431812942028046, 0.009655858390033245, -0.08764195442199707, -0.49656641483306885, -0.16877445578575134, 0.14946602284908295, 0.29500332474708557, -0.4505821168422699, 0.37001854181289673, -0.08516333997249603, -0.20955118536949158, -0.11734840273857117, -0.07786468416452408, 0.3553428649902344, -0.0987754613161087, -0.47726377844810486, -0.36433660984039307, 0.724864661693573, 0.4440315365791321, -0.7110629677772522, 0.3507186770439148, 0.848358154296875, -0.15328045189380646, 0.2105025351047516, -0.3727039098739624, -0.17079736292362213, -0.43984028697013855, 0.73906010389328, -0.526168167591095, -0.9249649047851562, 0.16917046904563904, -0.03762282431125641, -0.22573941946029663, 0.13882865011692047, 0.5606224536895752, -0.5377963781356812, 0.8318098187446594, 0.8857227563858032, 0.5614506602287292, 0.3239606022834778, -0.022207723930478096, 0.09905838221311569, -0.49559706449508667, -0.5210669040679932, -0.1693606674671173, -0.13809537887573242, -0.2133263349533081, -0.5822606086730957, 0.7147439122200012, -0.067183718085289, 0.1316218376159668, 0.011962879449129105, -0.5242876410484314, 0.28614065051078796, 0.3316337764263153, 0.4207810163497925, -0.09192130714654922, -0.1937669813632965, -0.03174658119678497, -0.11026418209075928, -0.6549225449562073, -0.2675330936908722, 1.0799325704574585, 0.16487976908683777, 0.6974267959594727, -0.11104603111743927, 0.6902269124984741, -0.08302687853574753, 0.32491201162338257, -0.5181399583816528, 0.4105410873889923, -0.17037822306156158, -0.6656048893928528, -0.2868095636367798, -0.2403860241174698, -0.7614253759384155, 0.33541977405548096, -0.5256898403167725, -0.22377780079841614, 0.1058245375752449, 0.5026987195014954, -0.5857606530189514, 0.08182612806558609, -0.7618188261985779, 1.2606948614120483, -0.5910576581954956, -0.08788053691387177, 0.1385151743888855, -1.100821614265442, 0.20455563068389893, -0.01870052143931389, 0.26219040155410767, 0.29045212268829346, -0.19100269675254822, 0.49438008666038513, -0.27826184034347534, 0.8074750304222107, -0.21209277212619781, 0.25426894426345825, 0.022296039387583733, -0.24552768468856812, -0.19534964859485626, 0.24346095323562622, 0.6082547903060913, -0.14879333972930908, 0.5311108827590942, -0.58536297082901, -0.49907195568084717, 0.06994269043207169, -0.4967859983444214, -0.49545818567276, -0.31511637568473816, -0.566204309463501, -0.4301406741142273, 0.20034489035606384, 0.3862311542034149, 0.6307427883148193, -0.08221632242202759, 0.14046703279018402, 0.9087170958518982, -0.21445788443088531, 0.3150102496147156, 0.2548619210720062, -0.135629341006279, -0.4338744282722473, 0.9324718117713928, -0.20280589163303375, 0.3383159339427948, 0.6441422700881958, 0.048750631511211395, -0.12470318377017975, -0.7980316281318665, -0.6501590609550476, 0.06062724068760872, -0.6374590396881104, -0.08638165146112442, -0.6832869648933411, -0.2945074141025543, -0.22774067521095276, -0.08376924693584442, -0.08001316338777542, 0.005079198163002729, -0.3288140594959259, 0.13638445734977722, -0.018017368391156197, 0.5081164836883545, 0.28859633207321167, 0.24900628626346588, -0.9749540090560913, 0.8084611296653748, 0.7466027736663818, 0.1959695667028427, -0.4197871685028076, -0.27031272649765015, -0.2570241093635559, -0.03562350571155548, -0.19112341105937958, -0.7600883841514587, 0.18786032497882843, 0.25734981894493103, 0.6370155811309814, 0.296739399433136, -0.11290976405143738, 0.8204622268676758, -0.5695711970329285, 0.7204091548919678, 0.6468763947486877, -0.4535285234451294, 0.7377251982688904, -0.017319634556770325, 0.3754553496837616, 0.8546105027198792, 0.7283284068107605, -0.21071220934391022, -0.0597832128405571, -0.27992910146713257, -0.5629278421401978, 0.5247159004211426, 0.05875434726476669, 0.19623160362243652, 0.02224588952958584, 0.09482607245445251, 0.33395445346832275, 0.42668354511260986, -0.7016619443893433, -0.2473272830247879, -0.6863660216331482, -0.30365490913391113, -0.24369192123413086, -0.24598295986652374, -0.47576266527175903, -0.43201744556427, 0.04301068186759949, -0.4941001534461975, 0.3439665734767914, 0.43103912472724915, -0.5723766684532166, 0.19949692487716675, 0.34997597336769104, 0.7111697793006897, 0.8508144617080688, -0.016720673069357872, 0.33002451062202454, 0.05810529366135597, -0.7951998114585876, 0.059361305087804794, 0.2421792447566986, 0.13227814435958862, -0.01372093241661787, 0.5330954790115356, 0.7944493293762207, -0.022442245855927467, -0.8148753643035889, 1.0014668703079224, -0.34678712487220764, -0.45563414692878723, -0.07585150748491287, -0.05454849451780319, 0.1389668881893158, 0.2736206650733948, 0.08275043964385986, 0.13889378309249878, 0.22804702818393707, -0.47096899151802063, 0.3982091546058655, 0.35080796480178833, -0.8067789673805237, -0.43591922521591187, 0.6861345171928406, 0.23937372863292694, 0.1427534967660904, 0.42237555980682373, 0.1224413812160492, -0.4585852026939392, 0.41499951481819153, 0.2625412046909332, 0.3258013427257538, -0.16008953750133514, 0.4871698021888733, -0.02219904400408268, 0.29291871190071106, 0.47479405999183655, 0.6908824443817139, -0.2088574469089508, -0.33414334058761597, -0.36580559611320496, -0.5605301260948181, 0.06371015310287476, 0.04207581281661987, -0.5583798289299011, 0.2888062298297882, -0.24732579290866852, -0.1659066379070282, 0.23289939761161804, -0.5321982502937317, -0.7176341414451599, 0.8010165095329285, 0.2685695290565491, 0.5231602191925049, -0.8413884043693542, 0.8402667045593262, 1.0501335859298706, -0.9631590247154236, -0.6129530668258667, -0.021748123690485954, -0.11424153298139572, -0.8414633870124817, 0.7379888296127319, 0.14968900382518768, 0.05973152443766594, -0.24861270189285278, -0.5215016007423401, -0.5375343561172485, 1.001888632774353, 0.40990129113197327, -0.1633048951625824, -0.4242607355117798, 0.2765558362007141, 0.5166938304901123, -0.37960365414619446, 0.44806185364723206, 0.062297362834215164, 0.2720501124858856, 0.2886730134487152, -1.1257861852645874, 0.007407679688185453, -0.4575962722301483, -0.12956321239471436, 0.15823622047901154, -0.33204391598701477, 0.8172655701637268, -0.44708117842674255, 0.15190215408802032, 0.016378670930862427, 0.23906555771827698, -0.03663598373532295, 0.4135981798171997, 0.4608006179332733, 0.4581024944782257, 0.5343943238258362, -0.165496364235878, 1.0862829685211182, 0.05627603456377983, -0.0822262391448021, 0.894568145275116, 0.1375940889120102, 0.5372175574302673, 0.7218025326728821, -0.04677960276603699, 0.3583442270755768, 0.4982362687587738, 0.33735424280166626, 0.6511468291282654, 0.11216259002685547, -0.18515700101852417, -0.6019390225410461, -0.11061764508485794, -0.7267595529556274, 0.47460198402404785, 0.06050780043005943, -0.39084991812705994, -0.19131983816623688, 0.3604835867881775, -0.41360732913017273, -0.16141530871391296, -0.31873252987861633, 0.8656057715415955, 0.1324165016412735, -0.24236011505126953, 0.5675386190414429, -0.4390649199485779, 0.5558720231056213, -0.9765241146087646, -0.22834688425064087, -0.08536933362483978, -0.11728570610284805, -0.21666619181632996, -0.6753948330879211, 0.13004212081432343, -0.48758402466773987, -0.3269336521625519, -0.2790822684764862, 0.4527736008167267, -0.46392709016799927, -0.4218493103981018, 0.0014893646584823728, 0.7244396209716797, 0.044627923518419266, 0.0481758750975132, -0.6058779358863831, -0.24246926605701447, -0.13809897005558014, -0.12092951685190201, 0.442687451839447, 0.5381753444671631, -0.3808002471923828, 0.5741271376609802, 0.43757981061935425, -0.12588751316070557, 0.1019022986292839, 0.1865183562040329, 1.1986536979675293, -0.4380302131175995, -0.514995813369751, -0.35471490025520325, 0.8168203234672546, -0.0071682194247841835, -0.49633657932281494, 0.21577803790569305, 0.2499755620956421, 0.824264407157898, -0.34251928329467773, 0.5212736129760742, -0.08645382523536682, 0.2082376480102539, -0.5865246653556824, 0.7412850260734558, -1.0791345834732056, -0.16462376713752747, -0.26540547609329224, -0.5421051383018494, -0.29572442173957825, 0.3292008936405182, -0.20257186889648438, 0.22108341753482819, 1.194830298423767, 0.7063272595405579, -0.11414751410484314, -0.14071010053157806, 0.5342697501182556, -0.06388048827648163, 0.1703941971063614, 0.7274746298789978, 0.9033153057098389, -0.2663787603378296, 0.8221620321273804, -0.2656117379665375, -0.29858362674713135, -0.07571814209222794, -0.56586092710495, -0.9916759133338928, -0.7934721112251282, -0.19141098856925964, -0.15716654062271118, 0.09516941010951996, 0.5102283358573914, 1.1501072645187378, -0.6076274514198303, 0.2809338867664337, 0.47700396180152893, -0.44625383615493774, 0.009142929688096046, -0.07351525127887726, 0.439436137676239, -0.35214781761169434, -0.19193346798419952, 0.05043724551796913, 0.4068465828895569, 0.04108789563179016, -0.002062648767605424, -0.02318672090768814, -0.23853591084480286, -0.3198383152484894, 0.5911962985992432, 0.12412092089653015, -0.5197939872741699, -0.19172367453575134, 0.15419992804527283, -0.19703900814056396, 0.3646363615989685, 0.9504464268684387, -0.9002325534820557, 0.7146496176719666, 0.229233056306839, 0.7874929904937744, 0.5610414147377014, -0.0033764520194381475, 0.28993627429008484, -0.4465113878250122, 0.24432192742824554, 0.5760997533798218, 0.10695046931505203, 0.11359252035617828, -0.24512742459774017, 0.0870247483253479, 0.25784602761268616, -0.13656143844127655, -0.5408594012260437, 0.3668825924396515, -1.1641719341278076, -0.43055880069732666, 0.656390368938446, -0.23215961456298828, -0.17455051839351654, -0.37743788957595825, -0.5606617331504822, -0.02949049510061741, 0.1946020871400833, 0.41869744658470154, 0.3450831174850464, -0.3337114453315735, -0.44365230202674866, -0.5287667512893677, 0.6265670657157898, 0.4779108166694641, -1.223754644393921, -0.5763841271400452, 0.5198826789855957, 0.35021480917930603, 0.07894547283649445, 1.0346771478652954, -0.47132405638694763, 0.7014079689979553, -0.122370645403862, 0.15702389180660248, -0.3033295273780823, -0.5253970623016357, -0.1574847549200058, 0.3924594819545746, -0.08547236770391464, -0.38717734813690186 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00224v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00224v1
Classification and Clustering of Sentence-Level Embeddings of Scientific Articles Generated by Contrastive Learning
2024-03-30T02:52:14
2024-03-30T02:52:14
Gustavo Bartz Guedes, Ana Estela Antunes da Silva
cs.CL
cs.CL
Scientific articles are long text documents organized into sections, each describing aspects of the research. Analyzing scientific production has become progressively challenging due to the increase in the number of available articles. Within this scenario, our approach consisted of fine-tuning transformer language models to generate sentence-level embeddings from scientific articles, considering the following labels: background, objective, methods, results, and conclusion. We trained our models on three datasets with contrastive learning. Two datasets are from the article's abstracts in the computer science and medical domains. Also, we introduce PMC-Sents-FULL, a novel dataset of sentences extracted from the full texts of medical articles. We compare the fine-tuned and baseline models in clustering and classification tasks to evaluate our approach. On average, clustering agreement measures values were five times higher. For the classification measures, in the best-case scenario, we had an average improvement in F1-micro of 30.73\%. Results show that fine-tuning sentence transformers with contrastive learning and using the generated embeddings in downstream tasks is a feasible approach to sentence classification in scientific articles. Our experiment codes are available on GitHub.
[ -0.08386065810918808, -0.6134999394416809, 0.5922577977180481, 0.09788630157709122, -0.35111868381500244, -0.0041044107638299465, -0.24482892453670502, -0.43665051460266113, 0.25303828716278076, 0.2565360367298126, -0.13651803135871887, -0.7899582386016846, -0.8535268306732178, 0.6210929751396179, -0.545803427696228, 1.2514755725860596, -0.043494224548339844, 0.213986337184906, -0.5221559405326843, -0.08954226225614548, -0.015784092247486115, -0.121332548558712, -0.38429516553878784, -0.1750241219997406, 0.617186963558197, 0.20047402381896973, 0.30869442224502563, 0.8210156559944153, 0.558738112449646, 0.3075728416442871, -0.3592863082885742, 0.16718660295009613, -0.35985442996025085, -0.0033205777872353792, -0.27498239278793335, -0.4915753901004791, 0.006733816582709551, 0.005897048395127058, 0.5460107326507568, 0.8074905276298523, -0.07917658984661102, -0.03451072424650192, 0.22014105319976807, 0.4604654908180237, -0.26347601413726807, 0.30216094851493835, -0.5568862557411194, 0.3755192160606384, -0.01819896325469017, -0.06709855049848557, -0.5983837842941284, -0.28323617577552795, 0.16800467669963837, -0.4978085160255432, 0.47146573662757874, 0.21126295626163483, 0.7821429967880249, 0.21346518397331238, -0.4470340609550476, -0.4864632785320282, -0.40366947650909424, 0.8933822512626648, -0.6699776649475098, 0.18916791677474976, 0.03521591052412987, -0.21834000945091248, 0.08986609429121017, -0.8813671469688416, -0.38564613461494446, -0.2666678726673126, -0.3928416967391968, 0.1485312134027481, -0.5518060922622681, -0.06401446461677551, 0.10941062122583389, 0.2834007143974304, -0.675225555896759, 0.3386628329753876, -0.6257088780403137, 0.15811645984649658, 0.47110244631767273, 0.2216930091381073, 0.05927640572190285, -0.24750101566314697, 0.014515546150505543, -0.041558098047971725, -0.6776586174964905, -0.3108498454093933, 0.04219694435596466, 0.18153969943523407, -0.19788990914821625, 0.7084791660308838, -0.24946388602256775, 0.45041581988334656, 0.29014381766319275, 0.20948538184165955, 0.5037919282913208, -0.6023992300033569, -0.02438158541917801, 0.12203032523393631, 0.9312262535095215, 0.3685016930103302, -0.04182290658354759, -0.24193324148654938, 0.06746412813663483, 0.18652044236660004, 0.543586015701294, -0.8791801929473877, -0.27379414439201355, 0.04406941309571266, -0.5669093728065491, -0.6464170813560486, 0.29941555857658386, -0.7162043452262878, -0.26051077246665955, -0.1370815932750702, 0.16365386545658112, -0.24989306926727295, 0.2056712806224823, 0.1199917197227478, 0.1258222758769989, -0.26205235719680786, 0.10478490591049194, -0.6196370124816895, 0.362795889377594, 0.5353645086288452, 1.0556561946868896, -0.4681835174560547, -0.13521507382392883, -0.2169118970632553, 0.036175478249788284, -0.24393151700496674, 0.9443861842155457, -0.5279743075370789, -0.2726922929286957, 0.1376020610332489, 0.10143695026636124, -0.22768442332744598, -0.677172839641571, 0.6484929323196411, -0.343169242143631, 0.47631433606147766, 0.16636385023593903, -0.7211426496505737, 0.0046615879982709885, 0.14014452695846558, -0.44376277923583984, 0.5520896911621094, -0.011594444513320923, -1.041194200515747, 0.24878764152526855, -0.7641838192939758, -0.7253453731536865, -0.17824724316596985, -0.16794578731060028, -0.665384829044342, 0.2583880126476288, 0.2179124802350998, 0.7544158101081848, -0.13448293507099152, 0.39921116828918457, -0.03171917796134949, -0.05944081023335457, 0.462867796421051, 0.036433104425668716, 0.2765065133571625, 0.4347180128097534, -0.29149484634399414, 0.299180269241333, -0.7848598957061768, -0.3771180808544159, -0.07867884635925293, -0.3758960962295532, -0.4749411940574646, 0.09907866269350052, -0.008551734499633312, 0.12641644477844238, -0.01574772410094738, -0.8894075751304626, 0.1468140333890915, -0.49660253524780273, 0.735828161239624, 0.2936440706253052, 0.21376246213912964, 0.48551610112190247, -0.2274438887834549, 0.2377413809299469, 0.5175309181213379, 0.0013358441647142172, -0.2247297614812851, -0.431043803691864, -0.7946737408638, -0.041533276438713074, 0.3988698422908783, 0.4509868025779724, -0.6521633863449097, 0.8070499300956726, -0.22566579282283783, -0.6052023768424988, -0.6773875951766968, -0.0894894152879715, 0.4926929175853729, 0.6784814596176147, 0.7055196762084961, 0.03734533116221428, -0.47804537415504456, -0.9989451169967651, -0.09958872944116592, 0.2443995624780655, -0.13606968522071838, 0.15896977484226227, 0.7466615438461304, -0.4289776384830475, 0.469194233417511, -0.9294891357421875, -0.18518884479999542, -0.011425470933318138, 0.4776056706905365, 0.29576095938682556, 0.6494956612586975, 0.3037787675857544, -0.7313960790634155, -0.5321506261825562, 0.21731647849082947, -0.8142386674880981, -0.15241169929504395, -0.09461021423339844, 0.16344469785690308, 0.14200860261917114, 0.8505693078041077, -0.6078323721885681, 0.16329705715179443, 0.39346665143966675, -0.3997218906879425, 0.6183749437332153, -0.1851908564567566, 0.1424797773361206, -1.269716739654541, 0.03954179212450981, 0.3618951737880707, -0.11721652746200562, -0.5358724594116211, -0.10986532270908356, -0.11031459271907806, -0.0906514897942543, -0.2824159562587738, 0.06043757125735283, -0.32401612401008606, 0.3079116940498352, -0.2996654808521271, -0.00459816912189126, -0.0650586262345314, 0.061478231102228165, 0.08486776798963547, 0.5872604846954346, 0.38961896300315857, -0.49041804671287537, -0.010592849925160408, 0.49105218052864075, -0.4681394696235657, 0.38173916935920715, -0.8341736197471619, -0.16811971366405487, -0.11041982471942902, 0.26517221331596375, -0.6535163521766663, -0.03443033993244171, 0.020701110363006592, -0.25682616233825684, 0.23544880747795105, 0.4245571792125702, -0.4774894714355469, -0.3542899787425995, -0.25040552020072937, 0.11632435768842697, 0.45547762513160706, -0.2620355188846588, 0.1769513040781021, 0.15391746163368225, -0.505217432975769, -0.20487481355667114, -0.649203360080719, -0.09549035876989365, -0.2065911889076233, -0.3483738899230957, 0.6711674332618713, 0.0018500674050301313, -0.1557513326406479, 0.38984838128089905, -0.11793272942304611, -0.0017586477333679795, -0.2549041211605072, 0.28151068091392517, 0.03242221847176552, -0.3422435522079468, 0.22293592989444733, 0.604892373085022, -0.12207441031932831, -0.007276235613971949, -0.11143461614847183, 0.4155709445476532, -0.13133971393108368, -0.01799808070063591, -0.3989212214946747, 0.47460517287254333, 0.36958834528923035, 0.016365783289074898, 0.841831624507904, 0.5956102609634399, -0.23544777929782867, -0.04533454030752182, -0.39166513085365295, -0.3196355104446411, -0.41016650199890137, 0.5020022988319397, -0.024450218304991722, -1.2029184103012085, 0.22123152017593384, -0.1296345740556717, -0.06671880930662155, 0.824934720993042, 0.38921552896499634, -0.29298532009124756, 0.9201431274414062, 0.6609053015708923, 0.14043688774108887, 0.28511011600494385, -0.1937689632177353, 0.13749465346336365, -0.5813716650009155, -0.48820769786834717, -0.9038315415382385, -0.2584357261657715, -0.5562120079994202, -0.41188356280326843, 0.4697639048099518, -0.012342356145381927, -0.24891336262226105, 0.34347063302993774, -0.7477395534515381, 0.57173752784729, 0.4793093800544739, 0.3317984342575073, 0.3915611505508423, 0.28738152980804443, -0.10208876430988312, -0.1798919290304184, -0.6854551434516907, -0.5121490955352783, 0.7990882396697998, 0.2585209906101227, 0.6979240775108337, -0.3739306628704071, 0.7877712845802307, 0.22623860836029053, 0.25032323598861694, -0.6635180115699768, 0.2700282335281372, -0.5922558307647705, 0.06124705821275711, 0.04741612449288368, -0.5791576504707336, -1.1559207439422607, 0.16614064574241638, -0.5348545908927917, -0.3299984931945801, 0.308670312166214, -0.21814575791358948, -0.27852511405944824, 0.11601007729768753, -0.6236333847045898, 0.8340954184532166, 0.061830662190914154, 0.021806033328175545, -0.5605347752571106, -0.7547699213027954, 0.11028725653886795, -0.09862339496612549, 0.05938633531332016, 0.31942543387413025, 0.014718310907483101, 0.9389781355857849, 0.0035335347056388855, 0.9718533158302307, 0.07881366461515427, 0.16917750239372253, -0.042876336723566055, -0.15058806538581848, 0.2063167691230774, 0.04323725774884224, 0.06403254717588425, 0.19450430572032928, 0.007346602156758308, -0.3955317437648773, -0.34886741638183594, 0.7924778461456299, -0.7320208549499512, -0.3441399037837982, -0.6524454355239868, -0.4409213662147522, -0.09823767095804214, 0.08607558906078339, 0.42522943019866943, 0.11506731063127518, -0.24985001981258392, 0.534548819065094, 0.726655125617981, -0.39971375465393066, 0.2587619721889496, 0.5718066096305847, 0.22246167063713074, -0.42605069279670715, 0.726672351360321, -0.10315019637346268, -0.06634272634983063, 0.6376518607139587, 0.20538096129894257, 0.030902227386832237, -0.948529839515686, 0.1252438724040985, 0.4404779076576233, -0.3074999749660492, -0.5185526013374329, -0.9501314759254456, -0.36702319979667664, -0.4465736150741577, -0.3180188238620758, -0.038882359862327576, -0.335683137178421, -0.8364794850349426, -0.4057542085647583, 0.12567712366580963, 1.0047781467437744, 0.04418734461069107, 0.24448071420192719, -1.012896180152893, 0.20471803843975067, -0.050222333520650864, 0.1485772430896759, -0.08621387183666229, -0.34770843386650085, -0.5302407741546631, -0.1819518655538559, -0.6400032043457031, -0.7909221649169922, 0.38545161485671997, 0.36861634254455566, 0.4654303193092346, 0.5815622210502625, 0.00025033592828549445, 0.3551182746887207, -0.7238278985023499, 0.8365997076034546, 0.476380318403244, -0.7732090353965759, 0.6807243824005127, -0.16881811618804932, 0.20685546100139618, 0.5172037482261658, 0.7141732573509216, -0.2774513065814972, -0.5753508806228638, -0.646859884262085, -0.9339757561683655, 0.3775913119316101, 0.05894035845994949, 0.17413529753684998, -0.38038647174835205, 0.38442131876945496, 0.4671381413936615, 0.33506739139556885, -0.8463366031646729, 0.15204481780529022, -0.09373907744884491, -0.5852476358413696, -0.2770746052265167, -0.21013014018535614, -0.2352105677127838, -0.3825841248035431, 0.6416494250297546, -0.08869605511426926, 0.21723327040672302, 0.32842275500297546, -0.3769672214984894, -0.006644173990935087, 0.4534955620765686, 0.7092554569244385, 0.4693314731121063, 0.05384863540530205, 0.32823702692985535, -0.01959269307553768, -0.44525066018104553, -0.06485889852046967, 0.2471695840358734, -0.3333491384983063, 0.05498373135924339, 0.4055180847644806, 0.7049514651298523, 0.32966092228889465, -0.6395726799964905, 0.38372212648391724, 0.19618485867977142, -0.3142986595630646, 0.09671937674283981, -0.07792476564645767, 0.17369979619979858, 0.4055303931236267, 0.29735320806503296, 0.24651333689689636, 0.38224300742149353, -0.22437113523483276, 0.2922728359699249, 0.13887768983840942, -0.3291057348251343, -0.5303903222084045, 0.4550161063671112, 0.27062976360321045, 0.09894782304763794, 0.5684507489204407, -0.16524110734462738, -0.27064305543899536, 0.5089936852455139, 0.886883020401001, 0.6675142645835876, -0.14626175165176392, 0.5550826191902161, 0.41634005308151245, 0.17019891738891602, -0.14127181470394135, -0.11678209900856018, 0.21386002004146576, -0.56344074010849, -0.4885123670101166, -0.83514404296875, -0.28268253803253174, 0.008397180587053299, -0.6019396781921387, 0.06867699325084686, -0.11801144480705261, 0.05630863457918167, 0.35208800435066223, -0.1043141707777977, -0.36603859066963196, -0.03368135541677475, -0.07050337642431259, 0.7743123769760132, -1.2609226703643799, 0.6146005988121033, 0.8411521911621094, -0.4487413465976715, -0.20021814107894897, -0.21810339391231537, -0.3780786395072937, -0.29975852370262146, 0.6179106831550598, 0.2127329409122467, 0.24005889892578125, -0.10815103352069855, -0.6917252540588379, -0.45778965950012207, 0.9667014479637146, 0.18462221324443817, -0.7138960957527161, -0.04724970832467079, 0.023315759375691414, 0.9402509331703186, -0.7700119018554688, -0.18048609793186188, 0.3084515631198883, 0.30873963236808777, -0.09001810848712921, -0.7657249569892883, 0.09346324950456619, -0.41966909170150757, -0.11010770499706268, 0.0014999399427324533, -0.2980998754501343, 0.7721512317657471, -0.14502885937690735, 0.014511920511722565, 0.15941180288791656, 0.7202271819114685, 0.1850181221961975, 0.5848230719566345, 0.22558560967445374, 0.7525932788848877, 0.6324933767318726, -0.1656554937362671, 0.7856100797653198, -0.08956988900899887, 0.42647042870521545, 0.8097834587097168, -0.23373304307460785, 0.9813722968101501, 0.5650511980056763, -0.31207308173179626, 0.8410006761550903, 0.5317241549491882, -0.5810031294822693, 0.7296382188796997, 0.3261567950248718, -0.1799396276473999, 0.14551110565662384, -0.21865761280059814, -0.42695361375808716, 0.13959841430187225, 0.49161359667778015, -0.7467454075813293, -0.12408964335918427, 0.4037041664123535, 0.09913229942321777, 0.39716553688049316, -0.3481454849243164, 1.0297181606292725, 0.3272913694381714, -0.45150747895240784, 0.25280722975730896, 0.021543124690651894, 1.0315357446670532, -0.33151763677597046, 0.03698071837425232, -0.1149166002869606, 0.12823063135147095, -0.49262040853500366, -0.6594007015228271, 0.5419319272041321, 0.15436463057994843, -0.46156397461891174, -0.050589315593242645, 0.613354504108429, -0.6898401975631714, -0.5699225068092346, -0.04579726234078407, 0.42743995785713196, 0.11705127358436584, 0.07677114754915237, -0.5059229135513306, -0.24152891337871552, -0.051558688282966614, -0.08158468455076218, 0.45482489466667175, 0.21665959060192108, 0.13321565091609955, 0.3006882667541504, 0.5273875594139099, 0.19692714512348175, -0.020511893555521965, -0.004691731184720993, 0.8851431012153625, -0.6210041642189026, -0.5734451413154602, -0.6615585684776306, 0.2808099091053009, -0.2655409872531891, -0.1830405294895172, 0.5276231169700623, 0.8327381610870361, 0.6865065097808838, -0.6217648983001709, 0.5100282430648804, -0.0013448450481519103, 0.5201049447059631, -0.5733512043952942, 0.7834407091140747, -0.41306304931640625, -0.062491435557603836, -0.14003944396972656, -0.7876096367835999, -0.682011604309082, 0.6191737651824951, -0.10345780104398727, -0.1838262528181076, 1.184428334236145, 0.46536803245544434, -0.28533604741096497, 0.08444651961326599, -0.06615709513425827, 0.5579838752746582, 0.12862533330917358, 0.37711241841316223, 0.5387916564941406, -0.23606190085411072, 0.4250165820121765, -0.3332565426826477, -0.0635671392083168, -0.16904643177986145, -0.804230272769928, -0.7959088683128357, -0.5859944224357605, -0.6550936102867126, -0.2802247107028961, 0.10793784260749817, 0.7324348092079163, 0.46578529477119446, -1.1510761976242065, -0.04261504486203194, -0.36222198605537415, -0.15652385354042053, -0.30421504378318787, -0.2602168917655945, 0.6425366401672363, -0.545406699180603, -0.5505051016807556, 0.3814336061477661, 0.14212606847286224, -0.041976265609264374, 0.1490764021873474, 0.16836407780647278, -0.3029633164405823, -0.16994445025920868, 0.7378962635993958, 0.1316910684108734, -0.6040163040161133, -0.13129788637161255, 0.05312269553542137, -0.1767372190952301, 0.17442482709884644, 0.9039314389228821, -0.6191635727882385, 0.09700921177864075, 0.4295085370540619, 0.5937910676002502, 0.6279005408287048, -0.06851699203252792, 0.34016305208206177, -0.8783311247825623, -0.060399845242500305, 0.3682017922401428, 0.35728198289871216, 0.3324175179004669, -0.30010005831718445, 0.5526635050773621, 0.14519725739955902, -0.7156360149383545, -0.7764644622802734, -0.0423479825258255, -1.1583551168441772, -0.46015027165412903, 1.0396831035614014, -0.2239724099636078, -0.05875879526138306, 0.034837864339351654, -0.16986587643623352, 0.4962616562843323, -0.3225102722644806, 1.0986804962158203, 0.5315520167350769, -0.3041657507419586, -0.1497584581375122, -0.13082005083560944, 0.33775627613067627, 0.36164095997810364, -1.188672423362732, -0.27818629145622253, 0.4959023594856262, 0.29496604204177856, 0.600869357585907, 0.027601871639490128, -0.37601348757743835, 0.06845992803573608, -0.10781089961528778, -0.10734467953443527, -0.12180828303098679, -0.3263798952102661, -0.5250993967056274, 0.4615015387535095, -0.2641257643699646, 0.03336489200592041 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00217v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00217v1
Rationale-based Opinion Summarization
2024-03-30T02:22:57
2024-03-30T02:22:57
Haoyuan Li, Snigdha Chaturvedi
cs.CL
cs.CL
Opinion summarization aims to generate concise summaries that present popular opinions of a large group of reviews. However, these summaries can be too generic and lack supporting details. To address these issues, we propose a new paradigm for summarizing reviews, rationale-based opinion summarization. Rationale-based opinion summaries output the representative opinions as well as one or more corresponding rationales. To extract good rationales, we define four desirable properties: relatedness, specificity, popularity, and diversity and present a Gibbs-sampling-based method to extract rationales. Overall, we propose RATION, an unsupervised extractive system that has two components: an Opinion Extractor (to extract representative opinions) and Rationales Extractor (to extract corresponding rationales). We conduct automatic and human evaluations to show that rationales extracted by RATION have the proposed properties and its summaries are more useful than conventional summaries. The implementation of our work is available at https://github.com/leehaoyuan/RATION.
[ -0.7657956480979919, -0.20923200249671936, 0.3287113308906555, 0.477277010679245, -0.5267499089241028, -0.23663409054279327, -0.08899632096290588, 0.06156834214925766, 0.7580419778823853, 0.4355643093585968, -0.37863877415657043, -0.3576486110687256, -0.36075013875961304, 0.1646036058664322, -0.17759805917739868, 1.476275086402893, 0.10072246938943863, 0.36009758710861206, 0.04446638375520706, -0.4774858057498932, -0.4004616141319275, -0.5573918223381042, -0.28880733251571655, -0.3115886151790619, 0.6644937992095947, 0.3876861035823822, 0.6373770833015442, 0.4262554943561554, 0.36739033460617065, 0.2017127424478531, -0.038903478533029556, 0.26715102791786194, -0.42019376158714294, -0.005063244141638279, -0.26339104771614075, -0.21051926910877228, -0.5954968929290771, 0.41950029134750366, 0.39247044920921326, 0.6172302961349487, -0.22746923565864563, 0.24899360537528992, 0.1942952424287796, 1.1642149686813354, -0.6508530378341675, 0.23515933752059937, -0.34795859456062317, 0.010022269561886787, 0.10817133635282516, -0.31983160972595215, -0.15174920856952667, -0.7376136779785156, 0.23449787497520447, -0.7414457201957703, 0.36024245619773865, -0.19243671000003815, 0.7193909287452698, -0.10935445874929428, -0.3346883952617645, -0.3652456998825073, -0.6954128742218018, 1.0590150356292725, -0.8387174606323242, -0.08678212761878967, -0.16962797939777374, 0.503213107585907, 0.030885329470038414, -0.5001104474067688, -0.6289031505584717, 0.09709157049655914, -0.14376454055309296, 0.6037175059318542, 0.06770691275596619, -0.15236099064350128, 0.329471617937088, 0.6451482176780701, -0.2944774627685547, -0.6830815076828003, -0.2997116446495056, 0.11952907592058182, 0.8318789601325989, 0.09905476123094559, 0.21725474298000336, -0.4519190490245819, -0.3534935414791107, 0.05065471678972244, -0.461357444524765, 0.13889241218566895, 0.2867729365825653, -0.15039019286632538, 0.16505993902683258, 0.742400050163269, -0.5075052380561829, 0.11591663956642151, 0.11395000666379929, -0.24055594205856323, 0.20562325417995453, -0.3003365993499756, -0.19321022927761078, 0.0776602104306221, 0.8548487424850464, 0.9101442694664001, 0.4703562259674072, 0.13996149599552155, -0.32649388909339905, 0.056654252111911774, 0.020180759951472282, -0.7492442727088928, -0.24226334691047668, 0.3517029881477356, -0.912659764289856, -0.6302872896194458, 0.5529531240463257, -1.0387697219848633, -0.4544694423675537, -0.5771889686584473, 0.020593684166669846, -0.20571404695510864, -0.48066219687461853, -0.07205961644649506, -0.9529476761817932, 0.254591703414917, 0.6247080564498901, -0.822672963142395, 0.19942256808280945, 0.7240975499153137, 0.9763436317443848, -0.6101471185684204, -0.05037042498588562, 0.005318829789757729, 0.2339528650045395, -0.1857171505689621, 1.1295838356018066, -0.26908984780311584, -0.457873672246933, -0.2003369927406311, -0.05388345196843147, 0.27565810084342957, -0.6935136318206787, 0.15546244382858276, -0.40350544452667236, 0.2915104925632477, -0.7378023862838745, -0.5290812849998474, -0.35294660925865173, 0.37536659836769104, -0.8983306288719177, 0.53746497631073, 0.20610369741916656, -0.9404182434082031, 0.28162312507629395, -0.7150452136993408, -0.33620214462280273, -0.12921227514743805, -0.15623226761817932, -0.19678889214992523, 0.14727424085140228, 0.505485475063324, 0.19166690111160278, -0.45398032665252686, 0.2880173623561859, -0.3861037790775299, -0.09910877794027328, 0.592801034450531, -0.43314695358276367, 1.0588963031768799, 0.6105741858482361, 0.07567166537046432, 0.3973024785518646, -0.4447563588619232, -0.045688875019550323, -0.059812385588884354, -0.2383064180612564, -0.08364027738571167, 0.013608918525278568, 0.1107591763138771, 0.07100647687911987, 0.17629997432231903, -0.37637192010879517, 0.04197198152542114, -0.3360331356525421, 0.33147338032722473, 0.6998282670974731, 0.5580754280090332, 0.8041794300079346, -0.81767338514328, 0.679542601108551, -0.05993159860372543, 0.11498269438743591, -0.3040476441383362, -0.14966550469398499, -0.3415317237377167, -0.5300560593605042, 0.3493955433368683, 0.6668739318847656, -0.4948493540287018, 0.5076404213905334, -0.2569535970687866, -0.30753013491630554, -0.10014531016349792, 0.12819525599479675, -0.041716352105140686, 0.479094922542572, 0.1725645661354065, -0.37578284740448, -0.5410356521606445, -0.9207059741020203, -0.6081125140190125, -0.17374642193317413, -0.40025052428245544, -0.0035309356171637774, 0.15637685358524323, 0.22243592143058777, 1.2455698251724243, -0.7504064440727234, -0.27286863327026367, -0.8999159932136536, 0.09665760397911072, 0.25386399030685425, 0.19434164464473724, 0.31225553154945374, -0.7057003974914551, -0.3114246428012848, -0.030972279608249664, -1.0246742963790894, -0.24524646997451782, -0.1436827927827835, -0.21214905381202698, -0.02163912169635296, 0.2434224784374237, -0.7893558144569397, 0.17624664306640625, -0.22991973161697388, 0.2627289295196533, 0.5811384916305542, 0.1376560926437378, 0.25475385785102844, -1.222176194190979, 0.041626427322626114, 0.15556596219539642, 0.006062818691134453, -0.1368463784456253, -0.22718574106693268, -0.1907861828804016, -0.0975041463971138, -0.3144625723361969, 0.4639785885810852, -0.23305733501911163, -0.01286911778151989, -0.43238508701324463, 0.1658892035484314, 0.3401840031147003, 0.5807410478591919, 0.13163705170154572, 0.3658946752548218, -0.06628749519586563, -0.285186767578125, 0.5932650566101074, 0.08947627991437912, -0.25651615858078003, 0.4493057131767273, -0.6314290761947632, -0.39104577898979187, -0.4971283972263336, 0.6739229559898376, -0.6850053071975708, -0.4600365161895752, 0.22038553655147552, -0.4685736298561096, -0.08269914984703064, -0.22170796990394592, 0.11201633512973785, -0.06742178648710251, -0.9712288975715637, 0.2819480299949646, 0.5577742457389832, -0.3984566032886505, 0.727052628993988, 0.8588334918022156, -0.5851060748100281, -0.477737694978714, -0.15955105423927307, -0.39787161350250244, -0.43296492099761963, -0.3570788502693176, -0.09988652169704437, 0.01402654591947794, -0.6596971750259399, -0.048548515886068344, -0.3401099443435669, -0.09400547295808792, -0.2711827754974365, -0.011143598705530167, 0.4549504518508911, -0.08058290183544159, -0.0906129702925682, 0.16856077313423157, -0.338672399520874, 0.4301470220088959, -0.1723858118057251, 0.08050470054149628, -0.06214786693453789, 0.16009576618671417, -0.25066426396369934, 0.8869425654411316, 0.9359949231147766, 0.0013814916601404548, 0.13913829624652863, 0.14122238755226135, -0.34439510107040405, -0.43876367807388306, -0.467663437128067, -0.22722016274929047, -0.3440462648868561, 0.3195069432258606, -0.10422185808420181, -0.4503963887691498, 0.5661917328834534, -0.203599750995636, 0.37982454895973206, 0.6186695694923401, 0.6386380195617676, -0.33967089653015137, 1.0915101766586304, 0.17564818263053894, -0.2613283693790436, 0.5800251960754395, -0.23318901658058167, 0.24253049492835999, -0.6228599548339844, -0.18492908775806427, -0.27339643239974976, -0.25481992959976196, -0.3422415554523468, 0.23849157989025116, 0.35259681940078735, 0.13906779885292053, 0.13610759377479553, -0.061309024691581726, -0.4804987907409668, 0.8606834411621094, 0.3976544439792633, -0.037604399025440216, 0.3291305899620056, 0.16508400440216064, 0.20106127858161926, -0.013330578804016113, -0.7038578391075134, -0.8400513529777527, 1.0832586288452148, 0.12939807772636414, 0.52480149269104, -0.04716802388429642, 0.5132875442504883, 0.4632439911365509, 0.804706871509552, -0.8632737398147583, 0.6050930619239807, 0.02951415441930294, -0.5019521117210388, -0.5177725553512573, -0.4793737828731537, -0.616992712020874, 0.5981522798538208, -0.1644279956817627, -0.1285792887210846, 0.2054167240858078, 0.275864839553833, -0.391658753156662, -0.009871093556284904, -0.8458941578865051, 0.8120965361595154, 0.07185133546590805, 0.016196127980947495, -0.4238644242286682, -0.5524439215660095, 0.7506242990493774, 0.1740482747554779, 0.18180912733078003, -0.3176531493663788, 0.3224477469921112, 0.776587963104248, -0.7663958072662354, 0.2644090950489044, -0.24705010652542114, 0.14032761752605438, 0.5621266961097717, -0.020341424271464348, 0.09618312865495682, 0.6296449303627014, 0.006009637378156185, 0.32118654251098633, 0.08348151296377182, -0.49022048711776733, -1.1035408973693848, 0.7736523151397705, -0.6487970948219299, -0.5702266097068787, -0.7538096904754639, -0.6705747842788696, -0.04318804666399956, 0.039614707231521606, 0.4174840748310089, 0.39187318086624146, -0.3426910638809204, -0.025484474375844002, 0.4826008081436157, 0.04332626610994339, 0.4903111457824707, 0.19600294530391693, -0.24566267430782318, -1.136709213256836, 0.9656355977058411, 0.4264494776725769, -0.044662222266197205, 0.23238018155097961, 0.3476995825767517, -0.1631009578704834, -0.25029632449150085, -0.6034842729568481, 0.049914732575416565, -0.5901707410812378, -0.17904412746429443, -0.5578893423080444, -0.30192941427230835, -0.28264084458351135, -0.2810489535331726, -0.12852339446544647, -0.9923439025878906, 0.07879858464002609, -0.09936796873807907, 0.21342509984970093, 0.6813530325889587, 0.05073145031929016, 0.19970296323299408, -0.7633596658706665, 0.6273002624511719, 0.46524399518966675, 0.12043940275907516, 0.06012062355875969, -0.21492335200309753, -0.08230631053447723, -0.09385946393013, -0.5608773231506348, -0.9885502457618713, 0.6608005166053772, -0.3568602204322815, 0.17219649255275726, 0.6072130799293518, 0.3681231737136841, 0.3763512969017029, -0.12246859073638916, 0.7786025404930115, 0.46276259422302246, -0.6970351934432983, 0.5267314314842224, -0.5442238450050354, 0.3082770109176636, 0.5501086711883545, 0.2379167675971985, -0.21689163148403168, -0.21303385496139526, -0.567110538482666, -0.8044120669364929, 0.5494603514671326, 0.3167537748813629, -0.23893922567367554, -0.15636463463306427, 0.2923086881637573, 0.3612903952598572, 0.371845006942749, -0.5978022217750549, -0.09609024226665497, -0.776189386844635, -0.3468392491340637, 0.09401444345712662, -0.33895570039749146, -0.26136863231658936, -0.13647113740444183, 0.7253581285476685, 0.043759819120168686, -0.0833926722407341, 0.3735160231590271, -0.014189768582582474, 0.13217276334762573, 0.48355212807655334, 0.43462470173835754, 0.7975711226463318, -0.3909023106098175, 0.038748085498809814, 0.24028633534908295, -0.29344725608825684, -0.09313593059778214, -0.05675654485821724, -0.5811068415641785, 0.18013741075992584, 0.16132405400276184, 0.19609813392162323, -0.29618263244628906, -0.43700307607650757, 0.7286611795425415, -0.26684197783470154, -0.020262250676751137, -0.5479303598403931, -0.05611918866634369, -0.1633760929107666, -0.1006254106760025, 0.18526121973991394, 0.40333616733551025, 0.3625940680503845, -0.5040380358695984, 0.15569521486759186, 0.5615987181663513, -0.11350419372320175, -0.3577365279197693, 0.18393896520137787, 0.3921648859977722, 0.09535577893257141, 0.0948328897356987, -0.043609730899333954, -0.10749727487564087, 0.6601170897483826, 0.3729168176651001, 1.064884066581726, -0.045109935104846954, 0.17484349012374878, 0.5402433276176453, 0.05973181128501892, -0.3310301899909973, 0.3202272057533264, -0.132097065448761, -0.5824706554412842, -0.4567199647426605, -0.34811729192733765, -0.5135546922683716, -0.030557069927453995, -0.6897039413452148, 0.2963859736919403, -0.6371604204177856, -0.11553563922643661, 0.1749824583530426, -0.31010594964027405, 0.18418850004673004, 0.052822016179561615, -0.4717726409435272, 0.7471706867218018, -0.6331439018249512, 0.4196983575820923, 0.4224896728992462, -0.631668210029602, -0.7891644239425659, -0.025898465886712074, 0.025138016790151596, -0.0908360630273819, 0.06042361259460449, 0.13939937949180603, -0.16476933658123016, -0.3461032509803772, -0.615840494632721, -0.3855334222316742, 1.1077826023101807, 0.4400285482406616, -0.2863050103187561, 0.2662579119205475, -0.35023781657218933, 0.3171883821487427, -0.7667824625968933, 0.3113537132740021, 0.43891534209251404, 0.3666954040527344, 0.15162748098373413, -0.2816987633705139, -0.04378017038106918, -0.5509719252586365, -0.014821851626038551, 0.11515629291534424, -0.6110931634902954, 0.5125764608383179, -0.19309651851654053, -0.17186352610588074, -0.05005612596869469, 0.8422918915748596, 0.41586875915527344, 0.6839554309844971, 0.32721975445747375, 0.34037870168685913, 0.6442444324493408, 0.07627354562282562, 1.174975872039795, -0.2849704325199127, 0.17038661241531372, 0.971781313419342, -0.31676286458969116, 0.5524290204048157, 0.5187937617301941, 0.06136676296591759, 0.4809994399547577, 0.2791558504104614, 0.1474848985671997, 0.3791902959346771, 0.19531692564487457, -0.5155957937240601, -0.04603997990489006, -0.07907494902610779, -0.2934191823005676, -0.17915695905685425, 0.1468418389558792, -0.2630501985549927, -0.2394273579120636, -0.386820912361145, 0.007010119967162609, 0.11381848901510239, -0.4451708495616913, 1.0135737657546997, 0.2721259295940399, -1.0679916143417358, 0.10805892944335938, 0.006209323648363352, 0.24653534591197968, -0.6080176830291748, -0.3820752203464508, -0.402472585439682, 0.0891827866435051, -0.4006732702255249, -0.611445426940918, 0.3242371678352356, 0.0764579251408577, -0.7892494201660156, -0.29045024514198303, 0.5712321400642395, -0.3549986779689789, -0.3855641484260559, -0.23902782797813416, 0.5348670482635498, 0.06458575278520584, -0.07981111109256744, -0.17640899121761322, -0.36167168617248535, 0.06156649813055992, -0.3330361545085907, 0.28462034463882446, 0.7557709813117981, -0.32074180245399475, 0.3812542259693146, 0.9910044074058533, 0.3192453980445862, -0.34720751643180847, 0.36860907077789307, 0.7717801332473755, -0.7727636694908142, -0.7053929567337036, -0.9322960376739502, 0.356693297624588, -0.48728397488594055, -0.3697691559791565, 0.9231842160224915, 0.8087066411972046, 0.4589778780937195, -0.3915156424045563, 1.1958768367767334, 0.14753851294517517, 0.6234310865402222, -0.35510000586509705, 0.6883938908576965, 0.008718276396393776, 0.5413203835487366, -0.21327468752861023, -1.271574854850769, -0.3122256100177765, 0.7674207091331482, -0.12325240671634674, -0.07312870025634766, 0.8804022669792175, 0.8245386481285095, 0.11991949379444122, 0.3978938162326813, -0.12771710753440857, -0.0692184790968895, 0.14002977311611176, 0.1944311112165451, 0.8648704290390015, -0.10896322131156921, 0.5031298995018005, 0.13486306369304657, -0.5775754451751709, 0.1057361513376236, -0.8309326171875, -0.805277943611145, -0.22693678736686707, -0.29023224115371704, -0.5739019513130188, -0.32010725140571594, 1.1659389734268188, 0.4045132100582123, -1.1162906885147095, -0.42306846380233765, -0.34133830666542053, 0.4571383595466614, -0.2684711217880249, -0.3252849876880646, 0.2626205384731293, -0.15459862351417542, -0.42586174607276917, -0.006731921341270208, 0.37296754121780396, -0.010518018156290054, -0.09963434189558029, -0.26878440380096436, 0.36680173873901367, 0.4284551441669464, 0.632161557674408, 0.44271349906921387, -0.6311402916908264, 0.08613211661577225, -0.15962575376033783, 0.04928263649344444, 0.021466441452503204, 1.4027459621429443, -0.6127111315727234, 0.17457948625087738, 0.7233613729476929, 0.27725937962532043, 0.21217282116413116, 0.4513167440891266, 0.8874343037605286, -0.379001259803772, -0.1407204270362854, 0.09954076260328293, 0.4866710603237152, 0.042779628187417984, -0.11256539821624756, 0.3501627743244171, 0.4299885630607605, -0.3508951961994171, -0.490409255027771, 0.3064846694469452, -1.4105470180511475, -0.23387742042541504, 1.3315112590789795, -0.13848544657230377, -0.14434871077537537, -0.2526262402534485, -0.6590231657028198, 0.07965599745512009, -0.7857599258422852, 1.0398133993148804, 0.7596098184585571, -0.23101656138896942, 0.0284721776843071, -0.13551034033298492, 0.5096339583396912, 0.3030186593532562, -0.9436582922935486, 0.29765957593917847, 0.7100328803062439, 0.30897489190101624, 0.13018140196800232, 0.6716861128807068, -0.6134116053581238, 0.4516493082046509, -0.23322221636772156, 0.15444470942020416, -0.08906814455986023, -0.21836814284324646, -0.42087018489837646, 0.7673329710960388, -0.22690625488758087, 0.004900031257420778 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00216v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00216v1
Is Factuality Decoding a Free Lunch for LLMs? Evaluation on Knowledge Editing Benchmark
2024-03-30T02:08:28
2024-03-30T02:08:28
Baolong Bi, Shenghua Liu, Yiwei Wang, Lingrui Mei, Xueqi Cheng
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI
The rapid development of large language models (LLMs) enables them to convey factual knowledge in a more human-like fashion. Extensive efforts have been made to reduce factual hallucinations by modifying LLMs with factuality decoding. However, they also pose risks of hindering knowledge updates, as they make models overly confident in known facts. In this work, we first revisite the current factuality decoding methods and verified their effectiveness in enhancing factual accuracy. Subsequently, we conduct further evaluation of several strong factuality decoding methods on the knowledge editing benchmark. All these decoding methods significantly diminish the performance of llama2 models compared to their original decoding, with the largest decrease being a staggering 81.3\%. This further indicates that the current existing decoding methods still cannot perfectly address the factual hallucinations, as they overlook the importance of preserving the flexibility for knowledge editing. Therefore, our work suggests that research into factual alignment should simultaneously focus on the effectiveness of knowledge editing.
[ 0.06729504466056824, -0.6351754069328308, 0.7443914413452148, 0.023993032053112984, -0.366758793592453, 0.09951430559158325, -0.32127586007118225, -0.7006153464317322, 0.06768810003995895, 0.5067510604858398, -0.23816122114658356, -0.645893931388855, -0.6807650923728943, 0.43392375111579895, -0.46778082847595215, 0.8436909914016724, -0.10495039075613022, 0.07939983159303665, -0.6276635527610779, -0.22996146976947784, -0.47997280955314636, -0.5536123514175415, -0.2493857443332672, -0.16330842673778534, 0.2843800187110901, 0.4095952808856964, 0.6998597383499146, 0.8676862120628357, 0.49218660593032837, 0.18477843701839447, -0.40952032804489136, 0.40922829508781433, -0.7758628129959106, 0.06570582091808319, -0.1504536122083664, -0.8368724584579468, -0.5293843150138855, -0.006797832902520895, 0.6892020106315613, 0.7874031662940979, -0.13145694136619568, 0.30667558312416077, 0.06090829148888588, 0.8011907935142517, -0.7420238852500916, 0.1628507673740387, -0.7829509973526001, 0.14287236332893372, -0.09795229882001877, -0.15097320079803467, -0.5419613122940063, -0.6624506711959839, -0.13450118899345398, -0.6274803876876831, 0.304028183221817, 0.1757916510105133, 0.5774810910224915, 0.5044487714767456, -0.43843337893486023, -0.35279133915901184, -0.8065200448036194, 0.578911304473877, -0.7364100217819214, 0.5415483117103577, 0.22870099544525146, 0.015051421709358692, -0.13931669294834137, -0.5872002840042114, -0.6704810261726379, -0.08559279888868332, 0.0449996180832386, 0.030655961483716965, -0.3674319088459015, 0.09636778384447098, 0.5075932741165161, 0.32180485129356384, -0.4156777560710907, 0.02919074520468712, -0.31391283869743347, -0.33446601033210754, 0.5648230314254761, 0.30002525448799133, 0.09645245969295502, -0.09796328097581863, -0.39560285210609436, -0.17024123668670654, -0.7730781435966492, -0.003704371163621545, 0.23868240416049957, -0.029867857694625854, 0.13061870634555817, 0.7696886658668518, -0.43450090289115906, 0.3516017496585846, -0.18070538341999054, -0.4894421696662903, 0.11662787199020386, -0.41527554392814636, -0.2646101117134094, 0.43174511194229126, 0.39676523208618164, 0.8287601470947266, 0.09571929275989532, -0.5272213816642761, -0.15348580479621887, 0.20925934612751007, 0.1375914067029953, -0.6653727889060974, -0.0807807594537735, 0.0817454531788826, -0.4914363920688629, -0.34803134202957153, -0.11119326204061508, -0.7441183924674988, -0.6227671504020691, -0.020905766636133194, 0.16737529635429382, -0.42488476634025574, -0.09480949491262436, 0.39183780550956726, -0.06329841166734695, 0.37123173475265503, 0.5126197934150696, -0.8106228709220886, 0.3197629153728485, 0.7926493287086487, 0.7647415995597839, -0.003807788947597146, -0.13278783857822418, -0.2290133535861969, 0.3288850486278534, -0.5927500128746033, 1.059403657913208, -0.39465662837028503, -0.519880473613739, -0.028277290984988213, -0.16188323497772217, -0.050228483974933624, -0.664523720741272, 0.812869668006897, -0.7757505774497986, -0.15174755454063416, -0.9967659711837769, -0.8994964361190796, -0.38577577471733093, 0.3957501947879791, -0.7076515555381775, 0.6786588430404663, -0.16740992665290833, -0.8222432732582092, 0.31237301230430603, -0.2698245346546173, -0.3867993652820587, -0.3167988955974579, 0.05379139259457588, -0.237447589635849, 0.21662747859954834, 0.3915115296840668, 0.11344585567712784, -0.3135205805301666, 0.22607742249965668, -0.20715153217315674, -0.5013725161552429, 0.5696477293968201, -0.610837459564209, 0.5266636610031128, 0.08862186223268509, -0.38364753127098083, -0.11267735809087753, -0.8588312268257141, -0.20113131403923035, 0.04695793613791466, -0.5704942941665649, -0.051522694528102875, 0.1353183090686798, -0.4184190332889557, 0.06245177611708641, 0.13096211850643158, -0.4692266881465912, 0.3211861252784729, -0.27959081530570984, -0.20151160657405853, 0.8708255887031555, 0.1137932538986206, 0.2906225621700287, -0.5179811120033264, 0.39347121119499207, 0.058395467698574066, -0.12500664591789246, 0.1678108125925064, -0.44452738761901855, -0.9256996512413025, -0.2980155646800995, 0.4697035253047943, 0.8760389089584351, -0.5986369848251343, 0.21431632339954376, -0.36569371819496155, -0.25281134247779846, -0.8317490220069885, 0.19808506965637207, 0.45281413197517395, 0.7831668257713318, 0.39703568816185, -0.22490188479423523, -0.7004209160804749, -0.8882099390029907, -0.6102705597877502, -0.29859811067581177, 0.18851688504219055, -0.0803200975060463, 0.3403255045413971, -0.28476396203041077, 0.8515816926956177, -0.43963009119033813, 0.030278736725449562, -0.16532032191753387, -0.0988052561879158, -0.0757199376821518, 0.26522549986839294, 0.41788384318351746, -0.3459179401397705, -0.038326699286699295, -0.27829307317733765, -1.0025182962417603, 0.0026495554484426975, 0.023250538855791092, -0.05360310524702072, 0.638996422290802, 0.3279917240142822, -0.8986707925796509, 0.46130868792533875, 0.36147060990333557, -0.363939106464386, 0.8259618878364563, -0.04396172985434532, 0.4027698040008545, -0.7635124325752258, 0.09816844016313553, -0.25560086965560913, -0.060410209000110626, -0.5857357978820801, -0.10850165039300919, 0.23401674628257751, 0.15711228549480438, -0.1581689417362213, 0.28297215700149536, -0.4905279278755188, -0.16031143069267273, -0.16899073123931885, 0.20504483580589294, 0.07450727373361588, 0.23219133913516998, -0.2588789165019989, 0.9095608592033386, 0.23755012452602386, -0.44492700695991516, 0.3584062457084656, 0.29953593015670776, -0.881067156791687, 0.23867639899253845, -0.4403057098388672, 0.18289221823215485, -0.18273480236530304, 0.2949807345867157, -0.8697953820228577, -0.1375381499528885, 0.3715541660785675, -0.22545966506004333, 0.32207244634628296, 0.14672282338142395, -0.7556623220443726, 0.03006775490939617, -0.5217862725257874, 0.2919628918170929, 0.5667780041694641, -0.5811623930931091, 0.23929274082183838, 0.21011188626289368, 0.08266318589448929, -0.8126567006111145, -0.7376049160957336, 0.3888793885707855, -0.00728138443082571, -0.7349361181259155, 0.2279590219259262, -0.18732330203056335, -0.5377610921859741, 0.3431578278541565, -0.42164283990859985, 0.29212746024131775, 0.1466086059808731, -0.12487031519412994, 0.3669252097606659, -0.31130871176719666, -0.06751599162817001, 0.09698832035064697, -0.08108527213335037, 0.4232337772846222, -0.021260589361190796, 0.06493077427148819, 0.007685788907110691, -0.40453022718429565, -0.7846018075942993, 0.040762387216091156, 0.5144941210746765, -0.27195900678634644, 1.0431727170944214, 0.3901629149913788, -0.3797508776187897, 0.010997654870152473, -0.9234616160392761, -0.0691719725728035, -0.42966243624687195, 0.34241124987602234, -0.18049177527427673, -0.9126977920532227, 0.5395784378051758, -0.13958121836185455, -0.19042064249515533, 0.465567409992218, 0.2937226891517639, -0.017185302451252937, 0.6822778582572937, 0.5679026246070862, -0.06703951209783554, -0.037887874990701675, -0.17056308686733246, 0.2737577259540558, -0.8188353180885315, -0.5578457713127136, -0.39950329065322876, -0.16181731224060059, -0.4240188002586365, -0.4971652328968048, 0.2273203283548355, 0.13381360471248627, 0.4194914996623993, -0.1211339682340622, -0.1652320772409439, 0.6228300929069519, 0.25482454895973206, 0.19694127142429352, 0.48936372995376587, 0.17954646050930023, -0.1407518982887268, -0.16567908227443695, -0.7497225999832153, -0.6393277049064636, 1.306322693824768, 0.30009225010871887, 0.6833052039146423, 0.25084537267684937, 0.3970849812030792, 0.45079728960990906, 0.21362419426441193, -0.7404382824897766, 0.6586431264877319, 0.011172236874699593, -0.4549199938774109, -0.12362059205770493, -0.4813717007637024, -0.4576773941516876, 0.13721156120300293, -0.4722875952720642, -0.5342453718185425, 0.2580104172229767, 0.15756766498088837, -0.28077608346939087, 0.7546086311340332, -0.6289129853248596, 0.6827889680862427, -0.054372530430555344, -0.39030495285987854, -0.32930898666381836, -0.4789228141307831, 0.6808995008468628, 0.09353364259004593, 0.45479366183280945, -0.14537300169467926, -0.04048750177025795, 0.8440342545509338, -0.22265498340129852, 0.834682047367096, -0.14306354522705078, -0.2838233411312103, 0.2643936574459076, 0.1961066871881485, 0.6864885091781616, 0.20746161043643951, -0.34430938959121704, 0.08526203781366348, 0.07740554958581924, -0.39527079463005066, -0.7150811553001404, 0.5152009129524231, -0.754599392414093, -0.9198517799377441, -0.43053126335144043, -0.6944102644920349, -0.4354504942893982, -0.011855928227305412, 0.10209491103887558, 0.40438804030418396, -0.3153039515018463, 0.10566995292901993, 1.08439302444458, -0.009426100179553032, 0.12921220064163208, 0.38499635457992554, 0.1211789920926094, -0.5916693806648254, 0.7833067774772644, 0.21337637305259705, 0.1829480677843094, 0.4081204831600189, -0.015482340939342976, -0.36306992173194885, -0.9504333138465881, -0.2545749545097351, 0.39004257321357727, -1.0364793539047241, -0.2521946132183075, -0.6703203320503235, -0.06345460563898087, -0.7374834418296814, -0.12776699662208557, -0.28739312291145325, -0.6175574064254761, -0.39778566360473633, -0.30852293968200684, 0.31630152463912964, 0.8832588791847229, -0.21120083332061768, -0.045908331871032715, -0.7918549180030823, 0.43246254324913025, 0.3142337501049042, 0.3603982627391815, -0.0014440609375014901, -0.5558604001998901, -0.3735978305339813, -0.021212926134467125, -0.026705345138907433, -0.9436175227165222, 0.020929237827658653, -0.19420476257801056, 0.6367964148521423, 0.39477697014808655, 0.2744000256061554, 0.7317838668823242, -0.42632272839546204, 0.7453452348709106, -0.06760738790035248, -0.9531345963478088, 0.2695704996585846, 0.1456991583108902, 0.07633701711893082, 0.5579977631568909, 0.21572402119636536, -0.5437554717063904, -0.17189757525920868, -0.4254237115383148, -0.5407533645629883, 0.7037116289138794, 0.09050936996936798, -0.08878233283758163, 0.09072453528642654, 0.5478291511535645, 0.24395354092121124, 0.23892490565776825, -0.44011279940605164, -0.20160658657550812, -0.09307325631380081, -0.16599644720554352, -0.03224821388721466, -1.080823540687561, -0.30718985199928284, -0.37780407071113586, 0.7910153269767761, 0.2392992228269577, 0.25451454520225525, 0.37201595306396484, -0.38144025206565857, -0.1261388212442398, 0.4993819296360016, 0.8307944536209106, 0.704940915107727, -0.42706966400146484, 0.2597419023513794, 0.555547833442688, -0.4381466507911682, 0.10039237886667252, -0.07286364585161209, -0.18086393177509308, 0.029099592939019203, 0.603074848651886, 0.8683388829231262, 0.32690149545669556, -0.624337375164032, 0.34487518668174744, -0.20634107291698456, -0.33712196350097656, 0.04971083626151085, 0.28193801641464233, 0.09097351878881454, 0.4351637661457062, 0.22959831357002258, 0.29163846373558044, 0.11044950038194656, -0.4086899757385254, -0.10995391756296158, 0.37019333243370056, 0.11334188282489777, -0.36211809515953064, 0.6640082597732544, 0.1968485414981842, -0.03256728872656822, 0.6103716492652893, -0.28252437710762024, -0.47164902091026306, 0.47158828377723694, 0.7786495089530945, 0.7866566777229309, -0.10023367404937744, 0.03431806340813637, 0.4053778052330017, 0.7481946349143982, -0.26497340202331543, 0.016645094379782677, -0.1132095456123352, -0.7941311001777649, -0.2821427881717682, -0.5739220976829529, -0.6123162508010864, 0.05410071834921837, -0.6376060843467712, 0.05492419749498367, -0.3954954147338867, 0.09436101466417313, -0.4875662922859192, 0.10725543648004532, -0.4048830568790436, 0.14216259121894836, 0.09951464831829071, 1.1389610767364502, -0.590503990650177, 0.7747949361801147, 0.5228150486946106, -0.030913520604372025, -0.5452426075935364, 0.268694132566452, 0.09311901777982712, -0.5238898992538452, 0.29056718945503235, 0.13263890147209167, -0.4396947920322418, -0.09852977842092514, -0.5844167470932007, -1.0261552333831787, 1.2338266372680664, 0.719450831413269, -0.46418896317481995, -0.13296997547149658, 0.31990012526512146, 0.345328152179718, -0.18923915922641754, -0.18334650993347168, 0.7838843464851379, 0.4971988797187805, 0.02435070462524891, -0.5580738186836243, 0.3691213130950928, -0.12304222583770752, 0.0720461755990982, -0.3167673945426941, -0.5139795541763306, 0.5501049160957336, -0.3832797408103943, -0.4643073081970215, 0.0033401104155927896, 0.7553467154502869, 0.12687276303768158, 0.41518744826316833, 0.30227401852607727, 0.779071033000946, 1.0373162031173706, 0.1039135605096817, 0.9993011355400085, -0.36094608902931213, 0.24826805293560028, 0.9074972867965698, -0.4535287320613861, 0.7505587339401245, 0.4405195713043213, -0.19373829662799835, 0.5077343583106995, 0.3904843330383301, 0.00995713658630848, 0.5514039397239685, -0.1672801673412323, -0.42275479435920715, -0.21330496668815613, 0.04262274503707886, -0.5802572965621948, 0.3276713490486145, 0.37976008653640747, -0.04704156890511513, -0.15547581017017365, -0.22794021666049957, 0.359836608171463, 0.12218564003705978, -0.0802612155675888, 0.6241787672042847, -0.1748197376728058, -0.4928897023200989, 0.7759309411048889, 0.26357322931289673, 0.5043277144432068, -0.4079172909259796, 0.05586719512939453, -0.4680149555206299, 0.02556927688419819, -0.2841462790966034, -0.6458337903022766, 0.40144863724708557, 0.33342450857162476, -0.31683000922203064, 0.08355189114809036, 0.8011780381202698, -0.30730313062667847, -0.386774480342865, 0.1586260050535202, 0.3080165684223175, 0.030374323949217796, 0.12800131738185883, -0.41280215978622437, 0.5241047143936157, 0.050923917442560196, -0.19376865029335022, 0.05788809433579445, 0.3635711371898651, 0.23838195204734802, 0.45557790994644165, 0.6857097744941711, 0.0873940959572792, 0.11685473471879959, -0.1175105944275856, 0.9439917802810669, -0.8236536979675293, -0.1904517561197281, -0.8874881863594055, 0.40878918766975403, -0.039141710847616196, 0.05677154287695885, 0.978672444820404, 0.6515009999275208, 0.9892657995223999, -0.14883849024772644, 0.766950786113739, 0.2663711607456207, 0.22623251378536224, -1.0243383646011353, 0.8487104177474976, -0.35067304968833923, 0.5557915568351746, -0.1667392998933792, -0.865409791469574, -0.4741438031196594, 0.21737392246723175, -0.33990922570228577, -0.18344391882419586, 0.8793630003929138, 0.9454655051231384, 0.1428631842136383, 0.2600482106208801, 0.39262452721595764, 0.4124099612236023, 0.10696301609277725, 0.2419442981481552, 0.896950364112854, -0.4597390294075012, 0.5380948185920715, -0.46021419763565063, -0.1625448316335678, -0.4093649089336395, -0.7671712040901184, -0.8033508658409119, -0.18198926746845245, -0.279265433549881, -0.4321470260620117, 0.4656166434288025, 0.8519971966743469, 0.1754518300294876, -0.6800823211669922, -0.22770462930202484, 0.19508740305900574, 0.4357314705848694, -0.2440827637910843, -0.14141187071800232, 0.3702370226383209, -0.41281482577323914, -0.379116952419281, 0.6040616631507874, 0.24764278531074524, -0.018943961709737778, 0.15791404247283936, -0.08145797997713089, -0.2295941412448883, 0.2925994098186493, 0.7666549682617188, 0.24711973965168, -0.6899003982543945, -0.4238543212413788, 0.12483806163072586, -0.13837577402591705, 0.16908010840415955, 0.7684248685836792, -0.719996988773346, 0.5133470892906189, 0.25846150517463684, 0.9080796241760254, 0.24758251011371613, 0.02080848440527916, 0.10317770391702652, -0.4124412536621094, 0.14055468142032623, -0.12692584097385406, 0.35775285959243774, 0.5295029282569885, -0.5078265070915222, 0.3181951940059662, 0.6567839980125427, -0.5547470450401306, -1.0772541761398315, -0.02856072410941124, -1.0097200870513916, -0.17715778946876526, 1.1906042098999023, 0.0849403664469719, -0.5605778098106384, 0.07675860822200775, -0.15598347783088684, 0.5728165507316589, -0.18539641797542572, 1.0310877561569214, 0.8320347666740417, -0.1334245353937149, 0.013517062179744244, -0.5169125199317932, 0.5903034806251526, 0.4123067259788513, -0.806402325630188, 0.2676094174385071, 0.6839207410812378, 0.4103620648384094, -0.15214617550373077, 0.4433320164680481, -0.10785257816314697, 0.39131879806518555, 0.23108793795108795, 0.10772134363651276, -0.2184249460697174, -0.3351340889930725, -0.49063992500305176, 0.08726830780506134, 0.3494076132774353, -0.11098156124353409 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00213v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00213v2
Injecting New Knowledge into Large Language Models via Supervised Fine-Tuning
2024-03-30T01:56:07
2024-04-02T20:09:45
Nick Mecklenburg, Yiyou Lin, Xiaoxiao Li, Daniel Holstein, Leonardo Nunes, Sara Malvar, Bruno Silva, Ranveer Chandra, Vijay Aski, Pavan Kumar Reddy Yannam, Tolga Aktas, Todd Hendry
cs.CL
cs.CL
In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable performance in generating human-like text, proving to be a valuable asset across various applications. However, adapting these models to incorporate new, out-of-domain knowledge remains a challenge, particularly for facts and events that occur after the model's knowledge cutoff date. This paper investigates the effectiveness of Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT) as a method for knowledge injection in LLMs, specifically focusing on the domain of recent sporting events. We compare different dataset generation strategies -- token-based and fact-based scaling -- to create training data that helps the model learn new information. Our experiments on GPT-4 demonstrate that while token-based scaling can lead to improvements in Q&A accuracy, it may not provide uniform coverage of new knowledge. Fact-based scaling, on the other hand, offers a more systematic approach to ensure even coverage across all facts. We present a novel dataset generation process that leads to more effective knowledge ingestion through SFT, and our results show considerable performance improvements in Q&A tasks related to out-of-domain knowledge. This study contributes to the understanding of domain adaptation for LLMs and highlights the potential of SFT in enhancing the factuality of LLM responses in specific knowledge domains.
[ -0.30835074186325073, -1.0018582344055176, 0.5132125616073608, -0.1625148057937622, -0.18445655703544617, 0.010614721104502678, -0.4712558090686798, -0.39260292053222656, -0.13926544785499573, 0.5229614973068237, -0.5363194942474365, -0.43354371190071106, -0.5737341046333313, -0.14338427782058716, -0.24701008200645447, 1.2918890714645386, 0.008968265727162361, -0.05417964980006218, -0.32029616832733154, -0.1582413613796234, -0.6239221692085266, -0.7160136699676514, -0.9120941162109375, -0.29841744899749756, 0.1985776573419571, 0.40763264894485474, 0.6038539409637451, 0.790010929107666, 0.7224563360214233, 0.22744964063167572, 0.01664706878364086, 0.69241863489151, -0.7996965050697327, -0.1427432745695114, -0.5316454768180847, -0.596799910068512, -0.36918315291404724, 0.05296172946691513, 0.6125801205635071, 0.7089012265205383, -0.07462739944458008, 0.1846754252910614, 0.021466055884957314, 0.6811774969100952, -0.5314983129501343, 0.4199541509151459, -0.9898754954338074, -0.05501966550946236, -0.1754225343465805, -0.549927294254303, -0.2958786189556122, -0.2196185290813446, 0.1234113797545433, -0.916576623916626, 0.36987143754959106, 0.17389114201068878, 0.9172640442848206, 0.4752873182296753, -0.3791184723377228, -0.32978248596191406, -0.5830695033073425, 0.7193653583526611, -0.788331925868988, 0.28960803151130676, 0.31107082962989807, 0.2624010145664215, -0.3959333896636963, -0.44918879866600037, -0.3937978446483612, -0.021062850952148438, -0.12963467836380005, -0.07952172309160233, -0.10833802819252014, -0.007711863610893488, 0.3474937677383423, 0.045432835817337036, -0.250477135181427, 0.18796832859516144, -0.18169187009334564, 0.07567128539085388, 0.747715175151825, 0.2830545902252197, 0.11413990706205368, 0.012816999107599258, -0.1800547093153, 0.19955404102802277, -0.894749104976654, 0.12284740060567856, 0.10648223012685776, 0.677033007144928, 0.025477547198534012, 0.44066280126571655, -0.5783386826515198, 0.6555544137954712, 0.5014903545379639, -0.37549665570259094, 0.0746970921754837, -0.3960132598876953, -0.16795599460601807, -0.0595819316804409, 0.34910139441490173, 0.5997046232223511, 0.4442216455936432, -0.35271725058555603, -0.07955668866634369, -0.32078027725219727, 0.0028191711753606796, -1.0038689374923706, -0.31027042865753174, -0.09659310430288315, -0.18540263175964355, -0.4117165505886078, 0.11299257725477219, -0.26963576674461365, -0.4724704325199127, -0.632603108882904, 0.6492001414299011, -0.3969321846961975, -0.11585625261068344, 0.40872594714164734, -0.2114700973033905, 0.0903576910495758, 0.5262964963912964, -1.0318686962127686, 0.16153325140476227, 0.7065653204917908, 0.5541021227836609, -0.3590347170829773, -0.11097966134548187, -0.9179127216339111, 0.2895985245704651, -0.3416654169559479, 0.8171107172966003, -0.40342578291893005, 0.08101753890514374, 0.14597533643245697, 0.032276496291160583, 0.004670846741646528, -0.7200984954833984, 0.21413922309875488, -0.6464014649391174, -0.029826976358890533, -0.38514959812164307, -0.8657745718955994, 0.06215163692831993, 0.28985291719436646, -0.17174305021762848, 1.0515753030776978, 0.06915971636772156, -0.6976391673088074, 0.8607288002967834, -0.7056604027748108, -0.6487507224082947, 0.04798804596066475, -0.04725218936800957, -0.33208444714546204, 0.15173204243183136, 0.6437398195266724, 0.7879709005355835, -0.13112686574459076, 0.3894772231578827, -0.26184844970703125, -0.36125269532203674, 0.2512509822845459, -0.24236281216144562, 0.41709133982658386, -0.07111652940511703, -0.11186937987804413, -0.08951295167207718, -0.8063149452209473, -0.09245702624320984, -0.07408615201711655, -0.4853857159614563, -0.38669249415397644, 0.0842733234167099, -0.2919754981994629, 0.15577059984207153, 0.13513724505901337, -0.43480637669563293, 0.4055822789669037, -0.5148440003395081, 0.49585723876953125, 0.6748096942901611, 0.4325810968875885, 0.6065495014190674, -0.35638636350631714, 0.24199478328227997, 0.23057696223258972, 0.18599975109100342, -0.08709758520126343, -0.21893931925296783, -0.6053764224052429, -0.21703040599822998, 0.23959393799304962, 0.41604581475257874, -1.0013010501861572, 0.38013431429862976, -0.4011748731136322, -0.3368811309337616, -0.223260760307312, 0.23266929388046265, 0.0010289406636729836, 0.6737417578697205, 0.36656248569488525, -0.15610872209072113, -0.42165273427963257, -0.6554628014564514, -0.37465745210647583, -0.09271562844514847, -0.06870695948600769, 0.6027290225028992, 0.3811171054840088, 0.057136669754981995, 0.987531840801239, -0.7368319630622864, -0.5014137625694275, -0.02968033403158188, 0.1370219588279724, 0.1112988144159317, 0.42612573504447937, 0.6974254846572876, -0.6810039281845093, -0.35374489426612854, 0.1565854549407959, -0.7168323993682861, -0.016402913257479668, -0.3141995072364807, -0.10054915398359299, 0.15944482386112213, 0.6331089735031128, -0.2732699513435364, 0.1806843876838684, 0.4332670569419861, -0.32399675250053406, 0.5286471843719482, -0.2019098401069641, 0.38756322860717773, -0.9904587268829346, -0.19246003031730652, -0.0618598610162735, -0.43748801946640015, -0.6471865177154541, -0.06104466691613197, 0.10530491918325424, 0.20600047707557678, -0.6679346561431885, 0.49130141735076904, -0.24475763738155365, 0.16092535853385925, -0.3628329038619995, 0.1638803780078888, 0.01750759780406952, 0.38513076305389404, 0.1147383451461792, 0.9186840653419495, 0.485243558883667, -0.7222399711608887, 0.27027779817581177, 0.24448497593402863, -0.6652297973632812, 0.5711667537689209, -0.19858889281749725, -0.05960520729422569, -0.10715068876743317, 0.15720021724700928, -0.6802924871444702, -0.31445616483688354, -0.16348963975906372, -0.26886576414108276, 0.3573213815689087, -0.3496256470680237, -0.6533599495887756, -0.09880366176366806, -0.1177726536989212, 0.35313791036605835, 0.3729996681213379, -0.730299174785614, 0.2767133414745331, 0.5291597247123718, -0.22908511757850647, -0.23054160177707672, -0.5626650452613831, -0.030974015593528748, -0.3727515935897827, -0.4990290701389313, 0.09574974328279495, -0.011517379432916641, -0.10920840501785278, -0.04983878508210182, -0.1497659832239151, -0.239580899477005, 0.1540808081626892, -0.04598909243941307, -0.013355118222534657, -0.49245166778564453, 0.360749214887619, 0.24474281072616577, 0.219319149851799, -0.030943265184760094, -0.4980449378490448, 0.16034376621246338, 0.09678356349468231, -0.19226829707622528, -0.5685886740684509, 0.03848498314619064, 0.25265875458717346, -0.14307591319084167, 0.8463389873504639, 0.44396042823791504, -0.2285068929195404, -0.37869149446487427, -0.6119521856307983, -0.4995303750038147, -0.44437286257743835, 0.5243200063705444, -0.36500445008277893, -1.3701425790786743, 0.37111249566078186, -0.5510044097900391, 0.014160417951643467, 0.49701204895973206, 0.6490111947059631, -0.30138757824897766, 0.9989036321640015, 0.657277524471283, -0.105172298848629, 0.7093544006347656, -0.03764015808701515, 0.10881610959768295, -0.6932671666145325, 0.09750232100486755, -0.36699289083480835, -0.24897998571395874, -0.46331706643104553, -0.5931131839752197, 0.3176705539226532, 0.17238667607307434, -0.21390417218208313, 0.25552111864089966, -0.18632002174854279, 0.7443742752075195, 0.34878289699554443, 0.20205806195735931, 0.49509397149086, -0.13015635311603546, 0.23482845723628998, -0.09908515959978104, -0.9433548450469971, -0.13632884621620178, 1.207122564315796, 0.21093936264514923, 0.7326176762580872, 0.016229944303631783, 0.45635828375816345, 0.24119259417057037, 0.5235903859138489, -0.7286208868026733, 0.10024000704288483, -0.29767099022865295, -0.6873189210891724, -0.6717931032180786, -0.5139870047569275, -0.5564239621162415, 0.05545127019286156, -0.3159043490886688, -0.5283032059669495, 0.22410887479782104, 0.2014303058385849, -0.5333504676818848, 0.36012113094329834, -0.7576045393943787, 0.44626784324645996, -0.020106812939047813, -0.2716330289840698, 0.07331714034080505, -0.39132165908813477, 0.3622833490371704, -0.5188391208648682, 0.45224717259407043, -0.2007117122411728, 0.18904931843280792, 0.7225835919380188, -0.39423251152038574, 0.8862580060958862, -0.18817906081676483, -0.2803618609905243, 0.20487454533576965, -0.0023498639930039644, 0.8303254246711731, 0.3631919026374817, -0.05468999966979027, -0.04890226200222969, 0.044817425310611725, -0.3989909589290619, -0.9322327971458435, 0.5843490958213806, -0.6346892714500427, -0.7469913363456726, 0.13084477186203003, -0.8941847085952759, -0.615468442440033, 0.0821208581328392, -0.01523960568010807, 0.39022117853164673, -0.1778309941291809, 0.37728047370910645, 0.8222484588623047, -0.17371317744255066, 0.009545520879328251, 0.7684972286224365, -0.0431433841586113, -0.11321631819009781, 0.8737905621528625, 0.24696655571460724, 0.3249894380569458, 0.6228257417678833, 0.22081880271434784, -0.2331002652645111, -0.8429808616638184, -0.4622562527656555, 0.1861620992422104, -0.4037085771560669, -0.5784897208213806, -0.44369685649871826, -0.0009375248337164521, -0.5539418458938599, -0.24952954053878784, -0.32644474506378174, -0.5750685334205627, -0.235129252076149, -0.26689544320106506, 0.6435834169387817, 0.6750922203063965, -0.14267392456531525, 0.4907704293727875, -0.5749423503875732, 0.12920841574668884, 0.17110902070999146, 0.3381492793560028, -0.3166630268096924, -0.8680645823478699, -0.6669722199440002, 0.06986211985349655, -0.1538272649049759, -0.3692024052143097, 0.12472105026245117, 0.4371371567249298, 0.333658903837204, 0.4160445034503937, 0.0935778096318245, 0.748918890953064, -0.6044186949729919, 0.7980828285217285, -0.12322765588760376, -0.7486403584480286, 0.6540095806121826, -0.6438566446304321, 0.3150765597820282, 0.6075310707092285, 0.1901872754096985, -0.39068982005119324, -0.5860272645950317, -0.533467710018158, -0.5778034329414368, 0.7874660491943359, -0.03627949208021164, 0.2676754295825958, 0.010416273958981037, 0.7779432535171509, 0.2639566659927368, 0.4121491014957428, -0.2626804709434509, -0.037275876849889755, 0.15160688757896423, -0.09729331731796265, -0.3053896129131317, -0.06164943054318428, -0.02955077961087227, -0.5095533132553101, 0.839959442615509, -0.42801740765571594, -0.15124301612377167, -0.13817226886749268, -0.18286007642745972, -0.2174193561077118, 0.1038513109087944, 0.49657341837882996, 0.7216545343399048, -0.22027945518493652, 0.03883933275938034, 0.5828006863594055, -0.2388206124305725, -0.12291256338357925, -0.0033264958765357733, -0.2660076916217804, -0.2730269730091095, 0.38001179695129395, 0.7200227379798889, 0.4862039387226105, -0.5315062403678894, 0.5031952857971191, 0.194277822971344, -0.5680553317070007, 0.42369723320007324, 0.23933930695056915, 0.014722367748618126, 0.4149423837661743, 0.27691009640693665, -0.06088631600141525, -0.0148215526714921, -0.620259702205658, 0.5193601846694946, 0.3814806342124939, -0.30308225750923157, -0.07602608948945999, 0.6819539070129395, 0.1266154646873474, 0.20942997932434082, 0.408683180809021, 0.020130811259150505, -0.3847663700580597, 0.331479012966156, 0.5190039277076721, 0.28391537070274353, 0.07070907205343246, 0.19650793075561523, 0.3645859360694885, 0.08684103190898895, -0.07844579964876175, 0.09707459062337875, 0.004845384508371353, -0.8890854120254517, -0.7508332133293152, -0.7577423453330994, -0.2246069312095642, 0.15356577932834625, -0.6097530126571655, 0.10946197807788849, -0.2857097387313843, -0.18197228014469147, 0.12752197682857513, 0.20078672468662262, -0.8650674819946289, 0.2680443227291107, -0.2861942946910858, 0.9836908578872681, -1.031715750694275, 0.9333640933036804, 0.724420428276062, -0.46519842743873596, -0.8169984221458435, 0.038492608815431595, -0.11630932241678238, -0.7588894963264465, 0.7966398000717163, -0.46123990416526794, 0.23725444078445435, 0.293973445892334, -0.5993576645851135, -0.856945812702179, 0.9455711245536804, 0.4320266544818878, -0.39705225825309753, -0.045280516147613525, 0.39739957451820374, 0.5432910919189453, -0.28138136863708496, -0.2292594164609909, 0.7864494919776917, 0.45466694235801697, 0.12915295362472534, -0.8825544714927673, 0.13512209057807922, 0.35906824469566345, -0.2472991645336151, 0.3011544346809387, -0.6882808208465576, 0.5495907664299011, -0.31905168294906616, 0.02227247878909111, -0.1575734168291092, 0.8279674053192139, -0.02125486731529236, 0.010805214755237103, 0.3126005530357361, 0.39715588092803955, 1.000067114830017, -0.14522811770439148, 0.8571116328239441, -0.022484680637717247, 0.4881044626235962, 1.219484806060791, -0.14501667022705078, 0.7718523144721985, 0.486907958984375, -0.14119967818260193, 0.09718720614910126, 0.46055862307548523, -0.13555055856704712, 0.6355834603309631, 0.3541088104248047, -0.06401000916957855, -0.5181699991226196, -0.2433018833398819, -0.213235542178154, 0.38275599479675293, 0.3601016402244568, -0.15640348196029663, -0.3939819931983948, 0.1472441703081131, 0.1562955379486084, 0.06020239740610123, -0.35783249139785767, 1.0896297693252563, -0.12291552126407623, -0.4979267120361328, 0.44433847069740295, 0.02074168249964714, 0.6669832468032837, -0.32067885994911194, 0.06643754243850708, -0.36279672384262085, 0.2616191804409027, -0.11889399588108063, -0.7396402359008789, 0.18669123947620392, 0.1447775512933731, -0.4139854907989502, -0.23740118741989136, 0.659744918346405, -0.5232440233230591, -0.44729453325271606, -0.21887440979480743, 0.5361761450767517, 0.15607868134975433, -0.32573962211608887, -0.4633505642414093, -0.06541793793439865, -0.08168920874595642, -0.19894251227378845, 0.5458172559738159, 0.953372597694397, -0.2393243908882141, 0.47160670161247253, 0.7645103335380554, 0.31358444690704346, 0.08559925854206085, 0.20063470304012299, 0.8539100289344788, -0.3286944031715393, -0.24922823905944824, -0.6947965025901794, 0.2240666300058365, 0.06318580359220505, -0.1764860898256302, 0.7175599336624146, 0.8252096176147461, 0.9865683913230896, -0.10702277719974518, 0.950249195098877, 0.22430160641670227, 0.42005422711372375, -0.5614908337593079, 0.8661739230155945, -0.6583912372589111, -0.10166408866643906, -0.09107552468776703, -0.3381757438182831, -0.5338910818099976, 0.2818673253059387, -0.3972298502922058, -0.18748286366462708, 0.4951775074005127, 0.8078410625457764, -0.04665400832891464, 0.0002087625180138275, 0.5364731550216675, 0.3617631196975708, 0.5179628133773804, 0.4917915165424347, 0.5848044753074646, -0.43358147144317627, 0.3589378297328949, -0.018334385007619858, -0.42933112382888794, -0.36628443002700806, -0.9225867390632629, -1.1345282793045044, -0.6054571270942688, -0.43208247423171997, -0.0683646947145462, 0.5117804408073425, 0.8084312677383423, 0.8594475388526917, -0.9815300703048706, 0.10782186686992645, 0.05574655905365944, -0.07965806871652603, -0.35709643363952637, -0.2192264348268509, 0.5908809900283813, -0.7373467683792114, -0.6865062713623047, 0.36614564061164856, 0.12276070564985275, -0.03954214230179787, 0.173553004860878, 0.14946183562278748, -0.13123081624507904, 0.19010308384895325, 0.9807640910148621, 0.13596580922603607, -0.463401734828949, -0.7105787396430969, -0.09851869940757751, 0.10498183220624924, 0.004163598176091909, 0.8115426898002625, -0.8229537606239319, 0.142997145652771, 0.32760855555534363, 0.886980414390564, 0.48286038637161255, 0.1909414380788803, 0.6568480730056763, -0.9827892780303955, -0.009465256705880165, -0.13057588040828705, 0.018936684355139732, 0.20876763761043549, -0.5189761519432068, 0.45549407601356506, 0.30431872606277466, -0.5324316620826721, -0.8147282004356384, -0.0703732892870903, -0.7201470136642456, -0.26781728863716125, 1.3609611988067627, 0.22613757848739624, -0.015522544272243977, -0.17305415868759155, -0.3119359314441681, 0.32986077666282654, -0.3530368208885193, 0.908085286617279, 0.8658626675605774, -0.267782986164093, 0.1777333766222, -0.7128793001174927, 0.9116684794425964, 0.1348382830619812, -0.8764165043830872, 0.4876404404640198, 0.3146226704120636, 0.45169976353645325, -0.3969898521900177, 0.5306228399276733, 0.10541494190692902, 0.10873755812644958, -0.37550660967826843, -0.2754095196723938, -0.22183647751808167, -0.3129514455795288, 0.12571981549263, 0.1511961817741394, 0.0773213654756546, 0.04290182888507843 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00211v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00211v1
Multi-Conditional Ranking with Large Language Models
2024-03-30T01:26:05
2024-03-30T01:26:05
Pouya Pezeshkpour, Estevam Hruschka
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.LG
Utilizing large language models (LLMs) to rank a set of items has become a common approach in recommendation and retrieval systems. Typically, these systems focus on ordering a substantial number of documents in a monotonic order based on a given query. However, real-world scenarios often present a different challenge: ranking a comparatively smaller set of items, but according to a variety of diverse and occasionally conflicting conditions. In this paper, we define and explore the task of multi-conditional ranking by introducing MCRank, a benchmark tailored for assessing multi-conditional ranking across various item types and conditions. Our analysis of LLMs using MCRank indicates a significant decrease in performance as the number and complexity of items and conditions grow. To overcome this limitation, we propose a novel decomposed reasoning method, consisting of EXtracting and Sorting the conditions, and then Iterativly Ranking the items (EXSIR). Our extensive experiments show that this decomposed reasoning method enhances LLMs' performance significantly, achieving up to a 12% improvement over existing LLMs. We also provide a detailed analysis of LLMs performance across various condition categories, and examine the effectiveness of decomposition step. Furthermore, we compare our method with existing approaches such as Chain-of-Thought and an encoder-type ranking model, demonstrating the superiority of our approach and complexity of MCR task. We released our dataset and code.
[ -0.4556449353694916, -0.5884084701538086, 0.8258702754974365, 0.10821794718503952, -0.2203780710697174, 0.19284453988075256, -0.3717307150363922, -0.1770070493221283, 0.20299476385116577, 0.42220887541770935, -0.3571152687072754, -0.816207766532898, -0.9559715986251831, 0.17828375101089478, -0.1536523550748825, 0.820647120475769, 0.20711377263069153, -0.0905633494257927, -0.42214563488960266, -0.3382675349712372, -0.34411299228668213, -0.7547205090522766, -0.710668683052063, -0.27138325572013855, 0.6187335252761841, 0.564461886882782, 0.7051803469657898, 0.20792075991630554, 0.7830058336257935, 0.43164199590682983, -0.18316423892974854, 0.3391822874546051, -0.5341903567314148, 0.4777053892612457, -0.28016212582588196, -0.19769157469272614, -0.42308005690574646, 0.11062473058700562, 0.42551735043525696, 0.6308161616325378, -0.46838322281837463, 0.20590965449810028, -0.019496580585837364, 0.6040318608283997, -0.7498437166213989, 0.30258309841156006, -0.6035550236701965, -0.138853058218956, -0.032077331095933914, -0.33526411652565, -0.7168684601783752, -0.369698166847229, -0.029759446159005165, -0.22378800809383392, -0.02678440697491169, 0.27477648854255676, 0.3580600619316101, 0.24722564220428467, -0.7434678673744202, -0.15376998484134674, -0.3126012086868286, 0.8894868493080139, -0.5858396291732788, 0.6823177337646484, 0.2608213424682617, 0.5016379952430725, -0.19784949719905853, -0.7647284269332886, -0.34999942779541016, -0.27686527371406555, -0.17340227961540222, 0.13913820683956146, 0.09266528487205505, 0.13820752501487732, 0.35355445742607117, 0.33851340413093567, -0.4957026541233063, 0.038163937628269196, -0.08636736124753952, -0.10313813388347626, 0.3662055432796478, 0.16114205121994019, 0.22755056619644165, -0.17734935879707336, -0.3455578088760376, -0.21438893675804138, -0.4839042127132416, 0.26274290680885315, 0.22500158846378326, 0.4899384081363678, 0.1154063493013382, 0.8979361653327942, -0.6124438643455505, 0.7849069237709045, -0.15253034234046936, -0.5088536739349365, 0.29308414459228516, -0.4613269567489624, -0.1707550287246704, 0.07663033157587051, 0.5093708038330078, 0.5338633060455322, -0.014830236323177814, -0.21237419545650482, -0.23759540915489197, 0.22069406509399414, -0.10489450395107269, -1.0391851663589478, -0.28842616081237793, 0.18073241412639618, -0.624782383441925, -0.01064556185156107, 0.020825298503041267, -0.631054699420929, -0.5078879594802856, -0.3356975018978119, 0.4345659613609314, -0.19525828957557678, -0.09336725622415543, 0.2141972780227661, -0.10247813910245895, -0.17976373434066772, 0.3364129662513733, -0.6206800937652588, 0.20930594205856323, 0.7572672367095947, 0.607522189617157, -0.1386599838733673, -0.3695662021636963, -0.8214340209960938, 0.12299608439207077, -0.1819680631160736, 0.823695182800293, -0.8995563983917236, -0.2978050112724304, -0.0966414362192154, -0.14706437289714813, -0.024162571877241135, -0.5727630257606506, 0.9508922100067139, -0.5746980309486389, 0.016861144453287125, -0.467886358499527, -0.5014306902885437, 0.029175641015172005, 0.4940612018108368, -0.5250808596611023, 0.8528323173522949, -0.142624169588089, -0.7450443506240845, 0.41175398230552673, -0.3096528649330139, -0.4827982187271118, -0.2298535406589508, -0.03052377700805664, -0.1426120400428772, -0.026405831798911095, 0.19615502655506134, 0.5487673878669739, -0.5317627787590027, 0.44515788555145264, -0.7582139372825623, -0.32298755645751953, 0.10830440372228622, -0.37602925300598145, 0.2940883934497833, 0.2619606554508209, -0.032909490168094635, -0.06759937852621078, -0.45131462812423706, 0.257869690656662, -0.21053729951381683, -0.8427879214286804, -0.4537113606929779, 0.22501929104328156, -0.4488053023815155, 0.5106489062309265, 0.2685179114341736, -0.5246111750602722, 0.45353129506111145, -0.30331090092658997, 0.39913350343704224, 0.5677818059921265, 0.17974382638931274, 0.47329601645469666, -0.3048533499240875, 0.3134940266609192, -0.1496058702468872, 0.2446075826883316, -0.10430669039487839, -0.5498730540275574, -0.9569574594497681, -0.4550524652004242, 0.25714415311813354, 0.38414832949638367, -0.8813298940658569, 0.040574390441179276, -0.3481215834617615, -0.08017727732658386, -0.5112684965133667, 0.07729355990886688, 0.5774053335189819, 0.19831426441669464, 0.5842500329017639, 0.303606778383255, -0.406329482793808, -0.8948114514350891, -0.33835503458976746, -0.041556891053915024, 0.11759559065103531, 0.14354480803012848, 0.16332094371318817, -0.30500954389572144, 0.45704081654548645, -0.6138194799423218, -0.2903268337249756, -0.1794365644454956, 0.10167396068572998, 0.6158695816993713, 0.13907180726528168, 0.14184650778770447, -0.8250899910926819, -0.2337445616722107, -0.1844780445098877, -0.3815467357635498, 0.0031703056301921606, 0.3407716751098633, -0.1880248486995697, 0.13314251601696014, 0.6466349363327026, -0.6099311113357544, 0.3431994616985321, 0.6067153215408325, -0.2731894254684448, 0.4310707747936249, -0.3702353239059448, 0.5482673048973083, -0.8065841794013977, -0.14390520751476288, 0.007717838045209646, -0.32956644892692566, -0.21744313836097717, 0.2813151180744171, 0.02195410430431366, -0.25265195965766907, -0.2309209257364273, 0.4374532699584961, -0.388672798871994, 0.03386850655078888, -0.02679741568863392, 0.07167382538318634, 0.014084775000810623, 0.5499057769775391, 0.020874863490462303, 0.4019887149333954, 0.36958047747612, -0.7594977021217346, 0.027907736599445343, 0.15003377199172974, -0.5623440742492676, 0.6697307229042053, -0.48455533385276794, -0.12742990255355835, 0.0027232824359089136, 0.4081806540489197, -0.9629824757575989, 0.2838751971721649, -0.12333675473928452, -0.16414056718349457, 0.30567666888237, -0.4499104619026184, -0.8431891798973083, -0.3029334247112274, -0.43662434816360474, 0.523924708366394, 0.044825177639722824, -0.6948040127754211, 0.5225851535797119, 0.3624440133571625, -0.35787147283554077, -0.6311090588569641, -0.27671217918395996, 0.18998801708221436, -0.0702207162976265, -0.5573886036872864, 0.7886722087860107, -0.5561149716377258, -0.43915772438049316, -0.010893839411437511, -0.42873817682266235, 0.24428103864192963, -0.07338129729032516, 0.12728124856948853, 0.07201377302408218, -0.0033412682823836803, 0.09119036048650742, 0.23622173070907593, -0.31732627749443054, -0.20703797042369843, -0.045801255851984024, 0.4491352438926697, -0.1197652667760849, -0.45837366580963135, 0.11710254102945328, 0.4188895523548126, 0.8519619703292847, -0.35607102513313293, 0.7270864844322205, 0.2733614146709442, -0.126060351729393, -0.39179155230522156, -0.7342051267623901, 0.016223326325416565, -0.5304002165794373, 0.07519087940454483, -0.7394915819168091, -0.7288471460342407, 0.21573908627033234, -0.13294410705566406, -0.027112124487757683, 0.24569958448410034, 0.6617166996002197, 0.055238109081983566, 1.5923194885253906, 0.4750257134437561, -0.07715702801942825, 0.21820592880249023, -0.3431106209754944, 0.49212342500686646, -0.8346556425094604, -0.5964337587356567, -0.6479880213737488, -0.34188106656074524, -0.7631622552871704, -0.49450716376304626, 0.41153016686439514, 0.17064690589904785, -0.3899986147880554, -0.0851178839802742, -0.3943876624107361, 0.6264369487762451, 0.5155020952224731, 0.33084744215011597, 0.556193470954895, -0.32747194170951843, -0.8010799884796143, 0.419792115688324, -0.6623271703720093, -0.21382761001586914, 0.9604296684265137, -0.14493940770626068, 0.6272239089012146, 0.5754140615463257, 0.8146526217460632, 0.530915379524231, 0.3634777069091797, -0.87687748670578, 0.6692438721656799, -0.37728700041770935, -0.40932828187942505, -0.2543986439704895, -0.6491845846176147, -0.859668493270874, 0.767570972442627, -0.2786537706851959, -0.610072672367096, 0.27851811051368713, -0.2599751949310303, -0.02689094841480255, 0.06247555837035179, -0.7234545946121216, 0.6500594019889832, -0.25908422470092773, -0.16843251883983612, -0.19969794154167175, -0.4556441605091095, 0.5083275437355042, 0.06615182012319565, 0.49834856390953064, -0.33928924798965454, -0.096490778028965, 0.5550728440284729, -0.5276339650154114, 0.21582449972629547, -0.118584044277668, 0.12351417541503906, -0.20524339377880096, 0.19182026386260986, 0.7114550471305847, 0.35904377698898315, -0.6343721747398376, -0.05300785228610039, 0.34268251061439514, -0.35600364208221436, -0.6425957083702087, 1.2610998153686523, -0.5174096822738647, -0.7813835740089417, -0.42273858189582825, -0.36675602197647095, -0.4045514464378357, 0.4066064953804016, 0.1509724259376526, 0.5225077867507935, 0.17461617290973663, 0.35518360137939453, 0.5362675786018372, -0.18274250626564026, 0.34590479731559753, 0.7119074463844299, -0.34844473004341125, -0.44977495074272156, 0.8597603440284729, 0.10771985352039337, -0.04810693860054016, 0.7000587582588196, 0.21076928079128265, -0.560829222202301, -0.6698142290115356, 0.06976936012506485, 0.2751114070415497, -1.158262014389038, -0.3208616375923157, -0.6446475982666016, 0.2238987386226654, -0.43891870975494385, 0.0899384394288063, -0.09789661318063736, -0.37485700845718384, 0.08599241077899933, -0.09328533709049225, -0.09130498021841049, 0.3828464150428772, 0.2978614270687103, -0.3797347843647003, -0.5625970959663391, 0.7369467616081238, 0.3250713348388672, 0.7049628496170044, 0.007265251595526934, -0.36811181902885437, -0.11881373822689056, -0.2364027202129364, 0.045687150210142136, -0.5820101499557495, 0.23862069845199585, 0.11926838755607605, 1.1395777463912964, 0.29776686429977417, 0.4889658987522125, 0.6194557547569275, -0.5799494981765747, 0.238722026348114, 0.09872586280107498, -0.6905629634857178, 0.2680792212486267, -0.1772395223379135, 0.28847387433052063, 0.8640797138214111, 0.34426069259643555, -0.27078771591186523, -0.43441635370254517, -0.3592338263988495, -0.9960070848464966, 0.532685399055481, 0.18269751965999603, -0.20953184366226196, -0.21933233737945557, 0.12470471113920212, -0.09891503304243088, 0.3262801468372345, -0.6385220289230347, -0.5410183668136597, 0.06960585713386536, -0.09089986979961395, -0.6288414597511292, -0.5009663105010986, -0.014068529941141605, -0.4729536771774292, 0.6848166584968567, 0.09091769903898239, 0.23187974095344543, -0.035543303936719894, -0.41410648822784424, 0.3877243995666504, 0.4831870496273041, 0.5447349548339844, 0.7093365788459778, -0.4556315839290619, 0.45582273602485657, 0.08612461388111115, 0.0852712020277977, 0.3098032772541046, 0.09467712789773941, 0.2860376834869385, -0.16844616830348969, 0.15198731422424316, 0.3104526102542877, 0.5663578510284424, -0.5883658528327942, 0.4310380220413208, -0.25752022862434387, -0.006084994878619909, 0.12902867794036865, -0.07943373918533325, 0.26150819659233093, 0.3872743844985962, 0.23478876054286957, 0.11108642816543579, 0.39659354090690613, -0.649297297000885, 0.08960732072591782, 0.3606187403202057, -0.0728190466761589, 0.06454634666442871, 0.1780957281589508, 0.23240765929222107, -0.25073564052581787, 0.5250881910324097, -0.39917850494384766, -0.6384390592575073, 0.37788981199264526, 0.4419696629047394, 0.4145009219646454, -0.03166966885328293, 0.24281136691570282, 0.19342420995235443, 0.47969764471054077, -0.4143957197666168, 0.256425142288208, -0.2958402931690216, -0.6078543663024902, -0.3806755840778351, -0.8149716258049011, -0.5762293338775635, -0.07778935879468918, -0.6053715944290161, 0.40826696157455444, -0.277660995721817, -0.28191182017326355, 0.17439040541648865, 0.012204687111079693, -0.890012264251709, 0.17499850690364838, -0.0010140538215637207, 0.7885485887527466, -0.5599137544631958, 0.7225571870803833, 0.6762136220932007, -0.36677172780036926, -0.598101794719696, -0.059400178492069244, -0.13266074657440186, -0.529045045375824, 0.6597262024879456, 0.2931310534477234, -0.4492127001285553, 0.08074401319026947, 0.06577230244874954, -1.0486783981323242, 0.8964341878890991, 0.5369393229484558, -0.4060668349266052, 0.330009788274765, -0.21814943850040436, 0.44046664237976074, -0.24513494968414307, 0.5595000982284546, 0.4257540702819824, 0.7436924576759338, -0.013109768740832806, -0.636410117149353, 0.18967857956886292, -0.4822886884212494, -0.11644931882619858, 0.5302027463912964, -0.6455248594284058, 0.7321851253509521, -0.27943411469459534, -0.04826308786869049, 0.10364970564842224, 0.2044288069009781, 0.395480751991272, 0.5089006423950195, 0.4416034519672394, 0.8524560928344727, 0.8373162746429443, -0.022563006728887558, 1.3637937307357788, -0.2571464776992798, 0.42699992656707764, 1.0747336149215698, -0.4915905296802521, 1.0156728029251099, 0.2252625972032547, -0.1436036378145218, 0.6854057908058167, 0.7536238431930542, 0.2558118402957916, 0.7507208585739136, 0.3707333505153656, -0.09725595265626907, -0.6885020732879639, -0.00403257692232728, -0.35360994935035706, 0.404196172952652, 0.18362538516521454, -0.2458239048719406, -0.23635339736938477, 0.14303311705589294, -0.13705679774284363, -0.1110072210431099, -0.27410855889320374, 0.7258588075637817, 0.09682086855173111, -0.8276680707931519, 0.6366135478019714, 0.3911401927471161, 0.7665163278579712, -0.36638790369033813, -0.12938891351222992, -0.4108075797557831, 0.14858800172805786, -0.14587385952472687, -0.48058244585990906, -0.2330622524023056, -0.14778435230255127, -0.6389843821525574, -0.428332656621933, 0.6334912776947021, -0.24259018898010254, -0.8185712099075317, 0.4621953070163727, 0.3713824152946472, -0.04587709903717041, -0.20463141798973083, -0.7292997241020203, 0.12232465296983719, -0.30599814653396606, -0.24234800040721893, 0.7183581590652466, 0.4052416682243347, -0.014284292235970497, 1.0636820793151855, 0.7800861597061157, -0.09230778366327286, -0.17733390629291534, 0.3900025486946106, 0.7617760896682739, -0.5713301301002502, -0.49425312876701355, -0.8391662240028381, 0.14236564934253693, -0.08983896672725677, 0.13547614216804504, 0.8192025423049927, 0.6410487294197083, 0.6078935265541077, 0.4101656377315521, 0.4732586443424225, 0.3741047978401184, 0.5427976846694946, -0.7226088047027588, 0.4937467575073242, -0.6983523964881897, 0.8524226546287537, -0.40617531538009644, -1.0907988548278809, -0.29943448305130005, 0.16673965752124786, -0.30993443727493286, 0.19487130641937256, 0.9924976825714111, 0.6973023414611816, -0.14633311331272125, -0.40374618768692017, 0.41740670800209045, 0.1018511950969696, 0.2657177150249481, 0.36330994963645935, 0.9268771409988403, 0.011886381544172764, 0.8455267548561096, -0.24880513548851013, -0.14104530215263367, -0.29502248764038086, -0.9814661145210266, -0.7648205757141113, -0.3432614207267761, -0.3434021770954132, -0.27192771434783936, 0.055245861411094666, 0.8470745086669922, 0.6447840929031372, -0.6362262964248657, -0.12827889621257782, 0.39502424001693726, 0.6939495205879211, -0.30534908175468445, -0.19805125892162323, 0.3788733184337616, -0.17003671824932098, -0.6466195583343506, 0.716440737247467, 0.38630974292755127, -0.5348250865936279, 0.0077685206197202206, -0.12019646167755127, -0.39823853969573975, 0.03903147205710411, 1.0761277675628662, -0.16539885103702545, -0.8431598544120789, -0.2191467434167862, -0.07622456550598145, 0.02831427752971649, -0.1598360240459442, 0.8246222138404846, -0.8232784271240234, 0.5034961104393005, 0.8068089485168457, 0.36523759365081787, 0.7085168957710266, 0.09405549615621567, 0.1767234206199646, -0.6459458470344543, -0.3134302496910095, 0.06839781999588013, 0.5962193012237549, 0.12334872037172318, -0.11147490888834, 0.3645620346069336, -0.06894194334745407, -0.5255323648452759, -0.9646627306938171, 0.1813197284936905, -1.034135103225708, -0.5752174854278564, 1.339568018913269, -0.08842356503009796, 0.47153928875923157, -0.13122931122779846, -0.05581330507993698, 0.02785619907081127, -0.6265208721160889, 0.7704026699066162, 0.4449349045753479, -0.14414852857589722, -0.19524134695529938, -0.36519983410835266, 0.11464328318834305, 0.318596750497818, -0.6996676325798035, -0.2624932527542114, 0.45463937520980835, 0.37209394574165344, -0.029377559199929237, 0.5837754607200623, 0.04695675149559975, -0.07588895410299301, -0.43490487337112427, -0.2408803403377533, -0.159978985786438, -0.4518512189388275, -0.006801716051995754, 0.6390484571456909, 0.2715476453304291, 0.10463227331638336 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00209v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00209v1
EventGround: Narrative Reasoning by Grounding to Eventuality-centric Knowledge Graphs
2024-03-30T01:16:37
2024-03-30T01:16:37
Cheng Jiayang, Lin Qiu, Chunkit Chan, Xin Liu, Yangqiu Song, Zheng Zhang
cs.CL
cs.CL
Narrative reasoning relies on the understanding of eventualities in story contexts, which requires a wealth of background world knowledge. To help machines leverage such knowledge, existing solutions can be categorized into two groups. Some focus on implicitly modeling eventuality knowledge by pretraining language models (LMs) with eventuality-aware objectives. However, this approach breaks down knowledge structures and lacks interpretability. Others explicitly collect world knowledge of eventualities into structured eventuality-centric knowledge graphs (KGs). However, existing research on leveraging these knowledge sources for free-texts is limited. In this work, we propose an initial comprehensive framework called EventGround, which aims to tackle the problem of grounding free-texts to eventuality-centric KGs for contextualized narrative reasoning. We identify two critical problems in this direction: the event representation and sparsity problems. We provide simple yet effective parsing and partial information extraction methods to tackle these problems. Experimental results demonstrate that our approach consistently outperforms baseline models when combined with graph neural network (GNN) or large language model (LLM) based graph reasoning models. Our framework, incorporating grounded knowledge, achieves state-of-the-art performance while providing interpretable evidence.
[ -0.1558191478252411, -0.719528079032898, 1.1597424745559692, 0.05902225896716118, -0.3006693720817566, -0.14116166532039642, 0.02162250690162182, -0.2281777560710907, -0.0425519123673439, 0.5518225431442261, -0.5859095454216003, -0.7176156044006348, -0.5899312496185303, -0.30265018343925476, -0.39767202734947205, 1.1992311477661133, -0.275003045797348, -0.5528097748756409, -0.4275505840778351, -0.39594629406929016, -0.5642977952957153, -0.7264890074729919, -0.5109547972679138, -0.49401283264160156, 0.4400648772716522, 0.4654539227485657, 0.5453863143920898, 0.7219198346138, -0.1601872742176056, 0.142586350440979, -0.1394670456647873, 0.1517464965581894, -0.46557363867759705, 0.27958929538726807, -0.2980846166610718, -0.25718027353286743, 0.024335592985153198, 0.14936614036560059, 0.49627014994621277, 0.95834881067276, 0.10423029214143753, -0.11609375476837158, 0.15630419552326202, 0.33678287267684937, -0.3488788306713104, 0.34516218304634094, -0.5214095711708069, 0.20953680574893951, -0.019714849069714546, -0.3820357620716095, -0.667945384979248, -0.08420690149068832, 0.04926663264632225, -0.8281130790710449, 0.1961076706647873, 0.09505472332239151, 0.8310748338699341, 0.019608095288276672, -0.49966737627983093, -0.3933669626712799, -0.4254225790500641, 0.4360868036746979, -0.26853078603744507, 0.25024735927581787, 0.3676498532295227, 0.09803630411624908, -0.26749658584594727, -0.8346744775772095, -0.5076172351837158, -0.12503667175769806, -0.21363063156604767, 0.24574963748455048, -0.16102351248264313, -0.02108452469110489, 0.23643073439598083, -0.11341787129640579, -0.47924962639808655, -0.13712124526500702, 0.3278658390045166, 0.05956188216805458, 0.13337840139865875, 0.2186286747455597, 0.4580615162849426, -0.382425457239151, -0.3843330144882202, 0.17250996828079224, -0.6733262538909912, 0.3162148594856262, 0.09602183103561401, 0.2795465290546417, -0.2421756088733673, 0.6443615555763245, -0.35529065132141113, 0.730702817440033, 0.09167612344026566, 0.02150864340364933, -0.04634230211377144, -0.22122834622859955, -0.1590503305196762, 0.24677878618240356, 0.350212037563324, 0.5530439615249634, 0.1078091710805893, -0.5263373851776123, 0.18961262702941895, 0.11485535651445389, -0.005709241144359112, -0.5915766954421997, 0.09706690162420273, 0.3461015522480011, -0.4412122070789337, -0.3839091360569, -0.24210131168365479, -0.45316392183303833, -0.6403787136077881, -0.5269534587860107, 0.22012150287628174, -0.7005280256271362, -0.2398674339056015, -0.17557238042354584, -0.4172888696193695, 0.07718340307474136, 0.5341543555259705, -0.4735330641269684, -0.11171703040599823, 0.6181350946426392, 0.8450474143028259, 0.08752597868442535, -0.24257291853427887, -0.5758421421051025, 0.7363204956054688, -0.26123902201652527, 0.9083872437477112, -0.22111321985721588, -0.13434897363185883, -0.08004166185855865, 0.07906065136194229, -0.11781328171491623, 0.10330633819103241, 0.817983865737915, -0.588444173336029, 0.2437199354171753, -0.2526121139526367, -0.6592968702316284, -0.24203284084796906, 0.463538259267807, -0.2714797854423523, 0.8127023577690125, -0.06880062818527222, -1.0739638805389404, 0.502605140209198, -0.07732341438531876, -0.5894582271575928, 0.04394299536943436, -0.4160398542881012, 0.07721972465515137, 0.03490174189209938, 0.3952392637729645, 0.4677087366580963, -0.06396783143281937, 1.0259480476379395, -0.13595740497112274, -0.23492255806922913, -0.019595200195908546, -0.3739020526409149, 0.6292179226875305, -0.02708202414214611, -0.47542932629585266, 0.054969582706689835, -0.9667190313339233, -0.018503110855817795, 0.06836847960948944, 0.01013438031077385, -0.4982665777206421, 0.510250985622406, -0.1556626856327057, 0.33282190561294556, -0.003340726485475898, -0.16133694350719452, 0.07988274842500687, -0.40122392773628235, 0.037546370178461075, 0.6589401364326477, 0.1548071801662445, 0.5650896430015564, -0.07863494008779526, 0.14989835023880005, 0.13434627652168274, -0.248917818069458, -0.7422047853469849, -0.6625673174858093, -0.7819331884384155, 0.03965865075588226, -0.0812084898352623, 0.6435979008674622, -0.9929343461990356, 0.5660692453384399, -0.18917042016983032, -0.17293857038021088, 0.314190536737442, -0.5092655420303345, 0.3201131522655487, 0.9699510931968689, 0.4058740437030792, 0.2337132841348648, -0.8300058841705322, -0.6711938381195068, -0.32717105746269226, -0.3732743263244629, 0.006782351527363062, 0.025234879925847054, 0.011991125531494617, -0.0474991574883461, 1.4454662799835205, -0.3890312910079956, -0.19589126110076904, -0.550420343875885, 0.30120357871055603, 0.37849104404449463, 0.47165414690971375, 0.3827674984931946, -0.7594296932220459, -0.10985074937343597, 0.1815282255411148, -1.2783576250076294, -0.22352609038352966, -0.20638161897659302, -0.29233595728874207, -0.006817246787250042, 0.4199468195438385, -0.6869313716888428, 0.5947693586349487, 0.09716877341270447, -0.8895087242126465, 0.37482941150665283, 0.04634782671928406, 0.16925041377544403, -0.8906370997428894, 0.0694877877831459, -0.024713804945349693, -0.3754090964794159, -0.7795733213424683, -0.16529853641986847, -0.1514539271593094, -0.25617802143096924, 0.04289203882217407, 0.7686752676963806, -0.26945731043815613, -0.032782986760139465, -0.36353451013565063, 0.44585785269737244, 0.2621130645275116, 0.43102020025253296, 0.3753698170185089, 0.4159329831600189, 0.22212564945220947, -0.4627564549446106, -0.07428386807441711, 0.2497798502445221, -0.13542385399341583, 0.4186107814311981, -0.28315114974975586, -0.16977086663246155, -0.4780891239643097, 0.4734954237937927, -0.8622969388961792, -0.26341941952705383, 0.31355589628219604, -0.6280384659767151, 0.1635431945323944, -0.6402294635772705, -0.4139536917209625, -0.1132817268371582, 0.22650885581970215, 0.04416891187429428, 0.38714799284935, -0.4691416025161743, 0.7011245489120483, 0.36799466609954834, -0.21741555631160736, -0.5662067532539368, -0.3334011435508728, 0.24649235606193542, -0.17865891754627228, -0.7488468289375305, 0.23516468703746796, 0.17476686835289001, -0.43908485770225525, 0.2305174618959427, -0.07068562507629395, -0.06625346839427948, 0.03395229950547218, 0.4037944972515106, 0.10657527297735214, -0.22275881469249725, 0.06828690320253372, 0.37324053049087524, -0.7347675561904907, -0.07259717583656311, -0.7565594911575317, 0.386332631111145, 0.007721609435975552, -0.43164482712745667, -0.09064967185258865, 0.5539426803588867, 0.3174293339252472, 0.2599389851093292, 0.8991372585296631, 0.3138105571269989, -0.7495534420013428, 0.08753195405006409, -0.6288187503814697, 0.31161001324653625, -0.31617245078086853, 0.19546376168727875, -0.3249737620353699, -0.8464637994766235, 0.6343809366226196, -0.21446692943572998, -0.039524003863334656, 0.6262602210044861, 0.4296022653579712, -0.1078462302684784, 1.0114084482192993, 0.4894177317619324, 0.3414553999900818, 0.21676099300384521, 0.015595446340739727, 0.14776305854320526, -0.5143985152244568, -0.45783981680870056, -0.39412954449653625, 0.1667279303073883, 0.29840996861457825, -0.4745056629180908, 0.25180044770240784, 0.636191189289093, -0.26840436458587646, 0.23318283259868622, -0.21933689713478088, 0.639075756072998, 0.2876286506652832, -0.22608917951583862, 0.5230979323387146, 0.11339414119720459, -0.4764965772628784, -0.2051372528076172, -0.6614730954170227, -0.8654749989509583, 0.6512191891670227, 0.11137975752353668, -0.0692615881562233, -0.2661382853984833, 0.28098490834236145, 0.2208545207977295, 0.4742881953716278, -0.14566543698310852, 0.3686162829399109, 0.09698083996772766, -0.5772534608840942, -0.2616159915924072, -0.35731449723243713, -0.6574582457542419, 0.5886441469192505, 0.07976740598678589, -1.2716543674468994, 0.31501078605651855, -0.21451662480831146, -0.2423621267080307, 0.2612391710281372, -0.7001320719718933, 0.9945844411849976, -0.0545487105846405, -0.44232064485549927, 0.18014244735240936, -0.8275217413902283, 0.19846534729003906, 0.26885926723480225, 0.7763476967811584, -0.4372059404850006, 0.25898563861846924, 0.6978954672813416, -0.2585963010787964, 0.7840282917022705, -0.4178662896156311, 0.10390310734510422, 0.6867998242378235, 0.2176867425441742, 0.6685701608657837, 0.47122684121131897, -0.23908808827400208, 0.13253481686115265, -0.0977446436882019, -0.21111120283603668, -0.6057173013687134, 0.47997087240219116, -0.6711463332176208, -0.5048049092292786, -0.35466188192367554, -0.4504393935203552, -0.5615490078926086, 0.34857964515686035, 0.4151810109615326, 0.6929105520248413, -0.33231237530708313, -0.048723842948675156, 0.5728309154510498, -0.0873914510011673, 0.4341203272342682, 0.5484193563461304, -0.32570308446884155, -0.5600439310073853, 0.7525822520256042, 0.1368579864501953, -0.2326725870370865, 0.37237244844436646, 0.03599013015627861, -0.15279485285282135, -0.6195119619369507, -0.8979114890098572, -0.25593310594558716, -1.0872352123260498, -0.3495081067085266, -1.1774914264678955, -0.30365005135536194, -0.10257644951343536, -0.6620166301727295, -0.1186002716422081, -0.5912793874740601, -0.5793737769126892, -0.5570753812789917, 0.14030146598815918, 0.40209031105041504, -0.1594438999891281, 0.49446791410446167, -0.8429366946220398, 0.47575643658638, -0.2847217917442322, 0.08110637217760086, 0.11941447854042053, -0.3480644226074219, -0.3463250398635864, -0.09088685363531113, -0.2967846393585205, -1.0101549625396729, 0.291482150554657, -0.24699512124061584, 0.7618396282196045, 0.5307233333587646, 0.061898503452539444, 0.6339021921157837, -0.6419538855552673, 0.7008590698242188, 0.43786031007766724, -1.0035114288330078, 0.8771488070487976, -0.6545944809913635, -0.08556029945611954, 0.6387187242507935, 0.28782331943511963, -0.8172434568405151, -0.40784499049186707, -0.8410838842391968, -1.0530751943588257, 1.000354528427124, 0.5349254608154297, -0.12466707080602646, -0.12769873440265656, 0.4919739365577698, 0.31630560755729675, 0.1825375109910965, -0.9387941360473633, -0.1761355996131897, -0.17894919216632843, -0.3521133363246918, -0.1472533494234085, -0.43602803349494934, -0.2072891891002655, -0.19672466814517975, 0.579318642616272, -0.31439098715782166, -0.02394312620162964, 0.25092455744743347, -0.2867148220539093, -0.054018523544073105, 0.16062764823436737, 0.13361428678035736, 0.75130695104599, -0.02570217475295067, 0.32780325412750244, 0.15802153944969177, -0.057452257722616196, 0.421570360660553, 0.42649808526039124, -0.535185694694519, -0.057372353971004486, 0.7329153418540955, 0.8866868019104004, 0.4196925163269043, -0.6789255738258362, 0.6303326487541199, -0.08555694669485092, 0.047688961029052734, -0.27507224678993225, -0.18127159774303436, 0.14892299473285675, 0.34815263748168945, 0.6396559476852417, -0.029173364862799644, -0.022652775049209595, -0.34904158115386963, 0.40718263387680054, 0.013920368626713753, -0.5566279292106628, -0.20810049772262573, 0.6697334051132202, 0.027328647673130035, 0.11641786247491837, 0.4808056354522705, -0.37252897024154663, -0.3858660161495209, 0.8316270112991333, 0.6230088472366333, 0.6194329857826233, 0.20788061618804932, 0.33830881118774414, 0.2675447463989258, 0.2939930856227875, 0.09198666363954544, -0.07215776294469833, 0.009695402346551418, -0.8713150024414062, -0.46498534083366394, -0.6196116805076599, -0.2487821877002716, -0.12746764719486237, -0.26436033844947815, 0.3412007689476013, -0.19625233113765717, 0.08568873256444931, -0.32274144887924194, -0.27468812465667725, -0.2746548354625702, 0.4348904490470886, 0.393571674823761, 0.701972246170044, -0.7800132036209106, 0.3711280822753906, 0.6066038608551025, -0.46419650316238403, -0.6667906045913696, 0.06946519017219543, -0.18824124336242676, -0.4949416220188141, 0.5474052429199219, 0.5804020762443542, 0.2030699998140335, -0.034884143620729446, -0.2887531816959381, -1.0468130111694336, 1.1073777675628662, 0.41692590713500977, -0.3684864044189453, -0.2842887043952942, -0.06277267634868622, 0.4637606739997864, -0.5937072038650513, 0.36180904507637024, 0.3619837164878845, 0.3998875617980957, 0.4030250608921051, -0.16694393754005432, 0.08651857823133469, -0.13219939172267914, -0.19919012486934662, -0.059259384870529175, -0.22267864644527435, 0.577290952205658, -0.052380699664354324, -0.4454093873500824, -0.11159507930278778, 0.8755133748054504, 0.6618233919143677, 0.9852828979492188, 0.320561945438385, 0.8031085133552551, 0.8490298390388489, -0.2735358476638794, 1.0526416301727295, -0.2973966896533966, 0.22915346920490265, 1.0835058689117432, -0.48245880007743835, 0.24708542227745056, 0.20898614823818207, 0.07295376062393188, 0.5832088589668274, 0.7027212977409363, 0.6941912174224854, 0.7274497747421265, 0.05403272062540054, -0.3066266179084778, -0.4544166624546051, -0.26062145829200745, -0.5086300373077393, 0.10905242711305618, 0.49080172181129456, -0.23402799665927887, -0.5720468759536743, 0.23519714176654816, 0.2273402214050293, -0.07036854326725006, -0.33204400539398193, 0.7143256664276123, 0.13424468040466309, -0.7247815728187561, 0.02183612436056137, 0.30950647592544556, -0.019301295280456543, -0.6703398823738098, -0.023025134578347206, -0.14586244523525238, 0.1410878747701645, -0.017203330993652344, -0.7745883464813232, 0.46048009395599365, 0.1505824476480484, -0.42379501461982727, -0.4349530339241028, 1.175931692123413, -0.1833982914686203, -0.464135080575943, 0.3986460864543915, 0.7740775942802429, -0.21162056922912598, -0.2562614679336548, -0.13131926953792572, 0.00745416758581996, -0.08133646845817566, -0.4450003504753113, 0.375515878200531, 1.0392812490463257, -0.1956707388162613, 0.38170352578163147, 0.6679108738899231, -0.29229816794395447, -0.22844412922859192, 0.11765987426042557, 1.0857759714126587, -0.6570640802383423, -1.054903268814087, -0.8290076851844788, 0.7570721507072449, -0.2972629964351654, -0.13561803102493286, 0.5707178711891174, 0.5300110578536987, 0.15554887056350708, 0.3047828674316406, 0.9094874262809753, -0.024072324857115746, 0.3831656873226166, -0.717258632183075, 0.689239501953125, -0.2693052589893341, 0.02519204095005989, -0.37801042199134827, -0.6041340231895447, -0.4343988001346588, 0.4819917380809784, -0.3201322853565216, -0.19060146808624268, 0.7727790474891663, -0.15157029032707214, 0.09966862201690674, 0.46595361828804016, 0.2679674029350281, -0.07296024262905121, 0.26270791888237, 0.5566797852516174, 1.2389659881591797, -0.14855057001113892, 0.41801002621650696, 0.05367103964090347, -0.5617873072624207, 0.026204753667116165, -1.2097221612930298, -0.750732958316803, -0.6169267892837524, -0.18503740429878235, -0.45556366443634033, 0.4747840166091919, 0.555117130279541, 0.5212789177894592, -0.6025524735450745, 0.2046489119529724, -0.4709063768386841, 0.4216170608997345, 0.1462293267250061, -0.22648966312408447, 0.37678036093711853, -0.48039501905441284, -0.03327533230185509, 0.6007810235023499, 0.4617598056793213, 0.017892131581902504, 0.36337560415267944, -0.012523970566689968, -0.066650390625, 0.06797368079423904, 0.7416984438896179, 0.15833722054958344, -0.462876558303833, -0.5529280304908752, -0.41577404737472534, 0.12012466043233871, 0.1323976069688797, 1.1293812990188599, -1.1716482639312744, 0.007762903813272715, 0.11736194044351578, 0.61083984375, 0.5684822797775269, 0.06285079568624496, 0.5306901335716248, -1.0422520637512207, 0.573855459690094, 0.19593045115470886, 0.5774976015090942, 0.2309056967496872, -0.6462451815605164, 0.5988090634346008, 0.7037011384963989, -0.2418893575668335, -0.7212318778038025, 0.19276410341262817, -0.84687340259552, -0.3277966380119324, 1.29245126247406, -0.21564532816410065, 0.1275877207517624, -0.4554440379142761, -0.18963991105556488, 0.5623995661735535, -0.0799965113401413, 0.20198634266853333, 1.0242925882339478, -0.2311202585697174, -0.04906247928738594, -0.4514831602573395, 0.18262867629528046, 0.10133522003889084, -0.954478919506073, 0.38622763752937317, 0.7649131417274475, -0.08717566728591919, 0.18559530377388, 1.206477165222168, -0.04415920004248619, -0.07082556188106537, 0.2169341892004013, -0.027900341898202896, -0.2326427847146988, -0.661364734172821, -0.05102693662047386, 0.6030554175376892, -0.36173689365386963, 0.42746588587760925 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00207v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00207v1
Causal Inference for Human-Language Model Collaboration
2024-03-30T01:08:25
2024-03-30T01:08:25
Bohan Zhang, Yixin Wang, Paramveer S. Dhillon
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
In this paper, we examine the collaborative dynamics between humans and language models (LMs), where the interactions typically involve LMs proposing text segments and humans editing or responding to these proposals. Productive engagement with LMs in such scenarios necessitates that humans discern effective text-based interaction strategies, such as editing and response styles, from historical human-LM interactions. This objective is inherently causal, driven by the counterfactual `what-if' question: how would the outcome of collaboration change if humans employed a different text editing/refinement strategy? A key challenge in answering this causal inference question is formulating an appropriate causal estimand: the conventional average treatment effect (ATE) estimand is inapplicable to text-based treatments due to their high dimensionality. To address this concern, we introduce a new causal estimand -- Incremental Stylistic Effect (ISE) -- which characterizes the average impact of infinitesimally shifting a text towards a specific style, such as increasing formality. We establish the conditions for the non-parametric identification of ISE. Building on this, we develop CausalCollab, an algorithm designed to estimate the ISE of various interaction strategies in dynamic human-LM collaborations. Our empirical investigations across three distinct human-LM collaboration scenarios reveal that CausalCollab effectively reduces confounding and significantly improves counterfactual estimation over a set of competitive baselines.
[ -0.36332961916923523, -1.2075963020324707, 0.6783635020256042, 0.4140569865703583, 0.04317515343427658, 0.05349016189575195, -0.32090994715690613, -0.701862633228302, 0.5105797052383423, 0.6012904047966003, -0.8591994047164917, -0.31389057636260986, -0.4932892918586731, 0.23436734080314636, -0.36194944381713867, 0.7613449096679688, -0.035119134932756424, 0.05508798733353615, -0.3713580369949341, -0.25770995020866394, -1.0281741619110107, -0.30543211102485657, -0.788414716720581, -0.46787407994270325, 0.8261957168579102, 0.47809192538261414, 0.7324109077453613, 0.4322570860385895, 0.4788440465927124, 0.4308393597602844, 0.09406303614377975, -0.042889561504125595, -0.46928495168685913, 0.2080155462026596, -0.39427122473716736, -0.2916284501552582, -0.3656962811946869, 0.11354081332683563, 0.3329635262489319, 0.7652052640914917, -0.14552484452724457, -0.06672538071870804, 0.10240117460489273, 0.6683090329170227, -0.49267157912254333, -0.09518639743328094, -0.4609659016132355, -0.16142719984054565, -0.14662064611911774, -0.4238593876361847, -0.6103712916374207, -0.33320364356040955, 0.24032706022262573, -0.5814829468727112, 0.15191522240638733, 0.033387549221515656, 0.7745476365089417, 0.3258551061153412, -0.35699793696403503, -0.33767086267471313, -0.7215822339057922, 0.6680764555931091, -0.7296653389930725, 0.43133479356765747, 0.3864409029483795, -0.18649686872959137, -0.5111503601074219, -0.6779466271400452, -0.5750659704208374, -0.23996670544147491, -0.3951379060745239, 0.012094497680664062, -0.214786559343338, 0.1790614277124405, 0.36170074343681335, -0.09991280734539032, -0.5756794214248657, 0.28793564438819885, -0.2194315642118454, -0.08094083517789841, 0.7487754225730896, 0.1928279846906662, 0.7691271901130676, 0.0336800254881382, -0.2948119044303894, 0.11189732700586319, -0.5745869278907776, 0.05544283613562584, 0.15309715270996094, 0.13199220597743988, -0.19975817203521729, 0.36003196239471436, 0.03225927799940109, 0.4532437026500702, 0.18379037082195282, 0.12131417542695999, -0.24594435095787048, -0.7195972204208374, -0.3816101551055908, 0.1876899152994156, 0.7353858351707458, 0.34694257378578186, 0.17562761902809143, -0.2575508654117584, 0.20525571703910828, 0.1097520962357521, 0.36653634905815125, -0.5243635177612305, -0.2652495801448822, 0.15020684897899628, -0.19714029133319855, -0.2802944779396057, -0.008393170312047005, -0.8033728003501892, -0.529358446598053, -0.6643583178520203, 0.6005809307098389, -0.2137506753206253, -0.09953878819942474, -0.11063040792942047, -0.26589033007621765, -0.11503120511770248, 0.3871206045150757, -0.6958645582199097, 0.3031609058380127, 0.4206714332103729, 0.6706758737564087, -0.0001299859577557072, -0.6415294408798218, -0.4060317873954773, 0.11286298930644989, -0.49272048473358154, 0.8208832740783691, -0.36516132950782776, -0.5772087574005127, -0.16660885512828827, -0.08173110336065292, -0.28755253553390503, -0.24872645735740662, 0.5245479345321655, -0.3772142827510834, 0.6615172028541565, -0.4462900459766388, -0.6923201680183411, -0.11379744112491608, -0.04835142567753792, -0.7674155831336975, 0.6902406215667725, -0.13478077948093414, -1.0058488845825195, 0.577958345413208, -0.5568446516990662, -0.3781111538410187, -0.039766594767570496, -0.28042030334472656, -0.7561317682266235, -0.09769648313522339, -0.1670277863740921, 0.12282394617795944, -0.5688855051994324, 0.7154616117477417, -0.5198175311088562, -0.39835336804389954, 0.3801860213279724, -0.28033050894737244, 0.7659741044044495, -0.06395294517278671, -0.4735667407512665, 0.5987377762794495, -0.5391068458557129, -0.24064891040325165, 0.06815469264984131, -0.1142730861902237, -0.7200631499290466, 0.1916797012090683, -0.06923907995223999, 0.25709983706474304, 0.15913617610931396, -0.4530172646045685, 0.16893836855888367, 0.08505513519048691, 0.027380825951695442, 0.7372714877128601, 0.4611351191997528, 0.475496768951416, -0.5402281880378723, 0.2855492830276489, -0.4792349636554718, 0.22876757383346558, 0.031051691621541977, -0.37079480290412903, -0.595045268535614, -0.47846150398254395, -0.08696126192808151, 0.3076142966747284, -0.7838217616081238, 0.2641565799713135, -0.06367357820272446, -0.38742995262145996, -0.12604784965515137, 0.12884145975112915, 0.57973313331604, 0.5422042608261108, 0.3317480981349945, -0.21683716773986816, -0.6063331365585327, -0.9277978539466858, -0.6320600509643555, -0.3339143991470337, 0.009980319067835808, 0.10516088455915451, 0.2537551820278168, -0.1713552325963974, 1.2415465116500854, -0.3980671167373657, -0.0874953493475914, -0.1997036337852478, 0.7277318239212036, 0.005608012434095144, 0.4967942237854004, 0.5291349291801453, -0.6795172095298767, -0.5074161887168884, -0.3984518349170685, -0.7372257709503174, -0.7292487621307373, -0.5367242097854614, -0.32820963859558105, 0.32911160588264465, 0.9976493716239929, -0.30545398592948914, 0.5416688323020935, 0.5739708542823792, -0.6190075874328613, 0.7952467799186707, -0.2850319445133209, 0.6028973460197449, -0.7780892848968506, 0.16684888303279877, 0.2406059205532074, 0.22914209961891174, -0.785836398601532, -0.24693475663661957, 0.03567912429571152, 0.05476256087422371, -0.2314842790365219, 0.6773772835731506, -0.30341365933418274, 0.18834833800792694, -0.025719426572322845, 0.282116562128067, 0.052120547741651535, 0.69072425365448, 0.19155052304267883, 0.4859123229980469, -0.03185135871171951, -0.38582804799079895, -0.25662490725517273, 0.14982560276985168, -0.14566205441951752, 0.9360210299491882, -0.7253677248954773, 0.11692556738853455, -0.05234841629862785, 0.3254148066043854, -1.2150506973266602, -0.22263842821121216, 0.029535552486777306, -0.32589563727378845, 0.24661552906036377, 0.04039517417550087, -0.6097750663757324, -0.1378522366285324, -0.44397926330566406, 0.30866220593452454, -0.06897256523370743, -0.4317307472229004, 0.5642518401145935, 0.17082445323467255, -0.3616572618484497, -0.2634810507297516, -0.46816879510879517, 0.4198783338069916, -0.48299846053123474, -0.8968490958213806, 0.402555376291275, -0.3342864513397217, -0.6133543252944946, -0.05060550197958946, 0.21698182821273804, -0.2585029602050781, 0.36701563000679016, 0.2598426640033722, 0.5162220597267151, 0.1898425668478012, 0.05074174329638481, 0.2247627079486847, -0.0018142558401450515, 0.14674361050128937, 0.3077886998653412, 0.3780674636363983, 0.30737441778182983, -0.33428552746772766, -0.6069037914276123, 0.3089894950389862, 0.5801442265510559, -0.2690410315990448, 0.8440362215042114, 0.4353920519351959, -0.0442984439432621, -0.009604240767657757, -0.6710085868835449, -0.3789694309234619, -0.44583860039711, 0.41164809465408325, -0.0659005418419838, -0.6265288591384888, 0.4636819660663605, 0.0387350469827652, 0.021176159381866455, 0.1903066486120224, 0.5039351582527161, -0.015207105316221714, 0.7748863697052002, 0.5507110953330994, -0.111306332051754, 0.7865958213806152, 0.16672050952911377, -0.03242911398410797, -0.6710511445999146, -0.23987360298633575, -0.6154727935791016, -0.4621295630931854, -0.7306554317474365, -0.08799523115158081, 0.5798512101173401, 0.0757017731666565, -0.3084075450897217, 0.5801617503166199, -0.024467239156365395, 0.2917056083679199, 0.6152211427688599, 0.14209245145320892, 0.460117369890213, -0.4078962802886963, -0.20194309949874878, -0.10060854256153107, -0.5972051620483398, -0.15143366158008575, 0.5372574329376221, 0.11650807410478592, 0.6561995148658752, 0.44586142897605896, 0.5048816204071045, 0.37515324354171753, 0.4576672315597534, -0.37470918893814087, 0.5672448873519897, 0.19181916117668152, -0.6652936935424805, -0.5158491134643555, -0.3475552797317505, -1.0676652193069458, 0.3419898450374603, -0.5870906710624695, -1.0133236646652222, 0.23949488997459412, 0.15826916694641113, 0.1027827188372612, 0.06455840170383453, -0.75728839635849, 0.9264137148857117, 0.02230202965438366, -1.0094974040985107, -0.4800199866294861, -0.7714064717292786, 0.4240661561489105, -0.423922061920166, 0.421423077583313, 0.12432694435119629, 0.3279131352901459, 0.7668772339820862, -0.4848044216632843, 1.0455249547958374, 0.052589330822229385, -0.1562587469816208, 0.09562475979328156, 0.4840392470359802, 0.620281457901001, -0.20031780004501343, -0.05012673884630203, 0.25317350029945374, -0.11432334035634995, -0.2622440755367279, -0.6551119685173035, 0.7567193508148193, -0.4775976240634918, -0.5944553017616272, -0.2330855131149292, -0.7317500710487366, -0.35558801889419556, 0.17225615680217743, 0.22916701436042786, 0.7163872122764587, -0.5457866191864014, 0.12162305414676666, 0.21325550973415375, -0.42516157031059265, 0.6409367322921753, 0.8452953100204468, -0.09523976594209671, -0.42455828189849854, 0.45934954285621643, -0.006008025724440813, 0.4376313090324402, 0.43748870491981506, 0.4635508954524994, -0.23931242525577545, -0.17652933299541473, -0.21914274990558624, 0.48136457800865173, -0.4525607228279114, 0.30254971981048584, -0.4555075466632843, 0.2968381345272064, -0.14822664856910706, -0.6685492396354675, -0.03241720423102379, -0.09916872531175613, -0.26818525791168213, 0.210286483168602, 0.18559813499450684, 0.7112855911254883, -0.03806457296013832, 0.15485815703868866, -0.6674408912658691, -0.17710208892822266, 0.19806700944900513, 0.06638142466545105, 0.20553937554359436, -0.5208652019500732, -0.37796664237976074, -0.14068961143493652, -0.273429811000824, -0.8409547209739685, 0.2749288082122803, -0.11397377401590347, 0.3864700496196747, 0.11570680141448975, -0.02592562697827816, 0.7407673597335815, -0.5297742486000061, 0.5998402833938599, 0.28055092692375183, -0.9226040840148926, 0.14658141136169434, -0.641810417175293, 0.4012913703918457, 0.501103937625885, 0.26126495003700256, -1.0428909063339233, -0.651435911655426, -0.6667599081993103, -0.7224732637405396, 0.6741573214530945, 0.26895689964294434, -0.2890907824039459, -0.15272629261016846, 0.20422297716140747, -0.11063510924577713, 0.14316189289093018, -0.4592963755130768, -0.14552044868469238, 0.3315608501434326, -0.08387479186058044, -0.007716998923569918, -0.2499762773513794, -0.05935516580939293, 0.0439874641597271, 0.7227476239204407, 0.27415502071380615, -0.03673849254846573, 0.30824264883995056, -0.18714922666549683, -0.4954453110694885, 0.29686465859413147, 0.8054513931274414, 0.709231972694397, -0.26037609577178955, 0.10432667285203934, 0.10542601346969604, -0.13266871869564056, -0.011539621278643608, 0.019095776602625847, -0.005071396008133888, -0.1512436419725418, 0.9836254119873047, 0.7184967398643494, 0.588458240032196, -0.5154665112495422, 0.412178099155426, -0.19530059397220612, -0.15122437477111816, -0.036764826625585556, -0.061742257326841354, -0.025513464584946632, 0.20249199867248535, 0.0807603970170021, 0.0790271908044815, 0.10863526910543442, -0.5050901770591736, 0.5150963664054871, 0.4354400038719177, -0.6136389970779419, -0.4582226276397705, 0.7678898572921753, 0.27238622307777405, -0.4798901379108429, 0.22429227828979492, -0.036073096096515656, -0.4263055920600891, 0.6354645490646362, 0.37535446882247925, 1.0162906646728516, -0.34059879183769226, 0.17768335342407227, 0.32331860065460205, 0.03332765772938728, 0.12927640974521637, -0.19471395015716553, 0.18877331912517548, -0.6620360612869263, -0.5329026579856873, -0.19943785667419434, -0.43859171867370605, -0.015276983380317688, -0.4620574116706848, 0.519926130771637, -0.1618972271680832, 0.04201583191752434, 0.1721191704273224, -0.08233706653118134, -0.37961915135383606, 0.021363109350204468, -0.19549624621868134, 0.4089570641517639, -0.9905383586883545, 0.6749149560928345, 0.5334293842315674, -0.6907381415367126, -0.7234923839569092, 0.09082377701997757, 0.7136667966842651, -0.46176472306251526, 0.79001384973526, -0.29351353645324707, -0.2713914215564728, -0.011121883988380432, -0.4291519522666931, -0.6656742095947266, 1.0231866836547852, 0.2062363475561142, -0.5307808518409729, 0.13707225024700165, -0.0024677820038050413, 0.6710336804389954, 0.17549459636211395, 0.27301865816116333, 0.5110611319541931, 0.4846198856830597, 0.08634094893932343, -1.0981180667877197, 0.2358158975839615, -0.1369783729314804, -0.12683109939098358, 0.5051925182342529, -0.6021139025688171, 0.6379609107971191, -0.18398305773735046, -0.23510031402111053, 0.2119431495666504, 0.3749871850013733, 0.15668265521526337, 0.33802688121795654, 0.6198692917823792, 0.4027441740036011, 0.5797269940376282, 0.22122691571712494, 1.1511417627334595, -0.24442121386528015, 0.3353215456008911, 1.3493798971176147, -0.15746177732944489, 0.44849416613578796, 0.5339680910110474, -0.14018656313419342, 0.6789172887802124, 0.42277827858924866, 0.3000338077545166, 0.31675222516059875, -0.010224680416285992, -0.402957946062088, 0.013885603286325932, -0.356805682182312, 0.025922004133462906, 0.28440260887145996, -0.013057795353233814, -0.22030259668827057, -0.1523245871067047, -0.220321923494339, 0.692328691482544, 0.3386565148830414, 0.08051050454378128, 0.87429279088974, -0.1800868660211563, -0.909268856048584, 0.2975884974002838, -0.026829799637198448, 0.4935075044631958, -0.595572829246521, -0.09641530364751816, -0.3021528422832489, 0.08481913059949875, -0.1462736874818802, -0.5417454838752747, 0.1441648006439209, -0.2209436148405075, -0.19462941586971283, 0.016893748193979263, 0.480045884847641, -0.9365352988243103, -0.2090701311826706, 0.44664105772972107, 0.3627282679080963, -0.3547617197036743, 0.07471194118261337, -0.6360377669334412, 0.22306424379348755, -0.0903373658657074, -0.0352034829556942, 0.4305524230003357, 0.3790425956249237, -0.33165472745895386, 0.45584481954574585, 0.655265748500824, -0.05075586587190628, -0.4603031873703003, 0.21033966541290283, 0.6094181537628174, -0.468295156955719, -0.3744106590747833, -1.1145598888397217, 0.5072473287582397, -0.11315373331308365, -0.057377416640520096, 0.9662775993347168, 0.2152104526758194, 0.4987606704235077, 0.04659901186823845, 0.517598032951355, 0.035801783204078674, 0.30283570289611816, -0.5250296592712402, 0.6449910998344421, -0.6100732684135437, 0.3340204358100891, -0.9519658088684082, -0.6215684413909912, -0.41070282459259033, 0.1775510311126709, -0.3960879147052765, -0.07759813964366913, 1.0665572881698608, 0.7352423071861267, 0.30354759097099304, 0.12696576118469238, 0.23077595233917236, 0.37219157814979553, 0.6376876831054688, 0.08911246061325073, 0.5662789344787598, 0.03226761147379875, 0.07510823756456375, -0.26784127950668335, -0.3757726550102234, -0.16454161703586578, -1.0951275825500488, -0.71563321352005, -0.7468944191932678, -0.4313083291053772, -0.2813131809234619, 0.045447882264852524, 1.2456337213516235, 0.18952880799770355, -0.4122719466686249, -0.5486207008361816, -0.2705155313014984, 0.3145412504673004, -0.14482559263706207, -0.270917683839798, 0.5148832201957703, -0.3277687132358551, -0.7401137948036194, 0.27088677883148193, 0.418883740901947, -0.1529264897108078, -0.1638711541891098, 0.05676274374127388, -0.7006539106369019, 0.43155568838119507, 0.7395454049110413, 0.2988705635070801, -0.5473638772964478, -0.5014708638191223, -0.05752595141530037, 0.010654076933860779, -0.11413640528917313, 1.1229201555252075, -0.41484978795051575, 0.7561456561088562, 0.5001246929168701, 0.4726979732513428, 0.1769188493490219, 0.1219925582408905, 0.7278587222099304, -0.7518094778060913, 0.15328578650951385, -0.2798795700073242, 0.4441870450973511, 0.20797625184059143, -0.3044866621494293, 0.6335332989692688, 0.5730641484260559, -0.7359240055084229, -0.5655561089515686, 0.06610025465488434, -0.6938361525535583, -0.5941508412361145, 1.0852282047271729, 0.051516782492399216, 0.09965287894010544, -0.2654244005680084, -0.4380180537700653, 0.31414517760276794, -0.3008965253829956, 0.9769970774650574, 0.7408857345581055, -0.36654892563819885, 0.22102229297161102, -0.2308187335729599, 0.5363314151763916, 0.4118373692035675, -0.8773598074913025, 0.15177367627620697, 0.8230569958686829, 0.06686854362487793, 0.07516653835773468, 0.7306913733482361, 0.09385645389556885, 0.20255370438098907, -0.19100268185138702, 0.2830415964126587, 0.11467260122299194, -0.28784316778182983, 0.00968940183520317, -0.31155821681022644, 0.10055802762508392, 0.3340302109718323 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00205v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00205v1
Conceptual and Unbiased Reasoning in Language Models
2024-03-30T00:53:53
2024-03-30T00:53:53
Ben Zhou, Hongming Zhang, Sihao Chen, Dian Yu, Hongwei Wang, Baolin Peng, Dan Roth, Dong Yu
cs.CL
cs.CL
Conceptual reasoning, the ability to reason in abstract and high-level perspectives, is key to generalization in human cognition. However, limited study has been done on large language models' capability to perform conceptual reasoning. In this work, we bridge this gap and propose a novel conceptualization framework that forces models to perform conceptual reasoning on abstract questions and generate solutions in a verifiable symbolic space. Using this framework as an analytical tool, we show that existing large language models fall short on conceptual reasoning, dropping 9% to 28% on various benchmarks compared to direct inference methods. We then discuss how models can improve since high-level abstract reasoning is key to unbiased and generalizable decision-making. We propose two techniques to add trustworthy induction signals by generating familiar questions with similar underlying reasoning paths and asking models to perform self-refinement. Experiments show that our proposed techniques improve models' conceptual reasoning performance by 8% to 11%, achieving a more robust reasoning system that relies less on inductive biases.
[ -0.3554723560810089, -0.5481647849082947, 1.0115211009979248, -0.013320756144821644, -0.13446010649204254, 0.04608410969376564, -0.15356869995594025, -0.5409198999404907, -0.2028454840183258, 0.3842018246650696, -0.27057355642318726, -0.48295292258262634, -0.4487331807613373, -0.035240642726421356, -0.582586944103241, 0.641086220741272, -0.08745936304330826, 0.0001359782472718507, -0.5626924633979797, -0.14524969458580017, -0.32860326766967773, -0.4170987010002136, -0.6494324207305908, -0.6959575414657593, 0.20357386767864227, 0.17481008172035217, 0.8793494701385498, 0.574439287185669, 0.3423182964324951, 0.2685648798942566, -0.15283940732479095, 0.1748129278421402, -0.07931958138942719, 0.4295596778392792, -0.6640217304229736, -0.4730265438556671, -0.17681026458740234, -0.06061408296227455, 0.43554651737213135, 0.961124837398529, -0.3696766495704651, 0.11587850749492645, -0.2717611789703369, 0.5156658887863159, -0.777808427810669, 0.3121388554573059, -0.985443651676178, -0.06097962334752083, 0.10951519012451172, 0.09144438058137894, -0.44122079014778137, -0.10147657245397568, 0.2220613807439804, -0.8591020703315735, 0.22018489241600037, 0.09527598321437836, 0.7278622984886169, 0.3165506422519684, -0.27995508909225464, -0.16334232687950134, -0.7969006896018982, 0.7758461236953735, -0.8124656677246094, 0.4527210295200348, 0.395943284034729, 0.2209084928035736, -0.1324852854013443, -0.8036743402481079, -0.6819034814834595, -0.4817905128002167, -0.2001524120569229, -0.19363954663276672, -0.21210318803787231, -0.12277702242136002, 0.2810600697994232, 0.1417647749185562, -0.13911284506320953, -0.09050644189119339, -0.3257158696651459, -0.11809609085321426, 0.8332193493843079, -0.03312120586633682, 0.20529697835445404, -0.10339613258838654, -0.09432435780763626, 0.05077053979039192, -0.8095595836639404, -0.21773800253868103, 0.11830171942710876, 0.07784374058246613, 0.06287968903779984, 0.4659758508205414, -0.5503110289573669, 0.5851820707321167, 0.1507710963487625, 0.21088074147701263, 0.040511127561330795, -0.3713722825050354, -0.07538186758756638, 0.023562222719192505, 0.645785391330719, 0.22548699378967285, 0.6934214234352112, -0.12254101037979126, -0.34829801321029663, 0.4000193178653717, 0.2918093502521515, -0.5782761573791504, -0.2050502747297287, 0.47287607192993164, -0.30599698424339294, -0.36942458152770996, -0.00809356477111578, -0.30399900674819946, -0.3202856481075287, -0.377762109041214, 0.24368324875831604, -0.44082894921302795, -0.5186274647712708, 0.5177875757217407, -0.3441670835018158, 0.008634653873741627, 0.6011014580726624, -0.9847314357757568, 0.15026554465293884, 0.5711286664009094, 0.4679688811302185, -0.034562986344099045, -0.12640827894210815, 0.06547029316425323, 0.4691692292690277, -0.6551758050918579, 0.9025812745094299, -0.724875271320343, -0.33287644386291504, -0.009830428287386894, -0.4446503818035126, 0.18106450140476227, -0.49915629625320435, 0.31325846910476685, -0.4044390022754669, 0.10474513471126556, -0.3462544083595276, -0.47810372710227966, -0.03306002542376518, 0.21426606178283691, -0.47259610891342163, 0.9227858185768127, -0.049208831042051315, -0.8224729299545288, 0.3867257237434387, -0.8499831557273865, -0.43524593114852905, -0.0667521059513092, -0.4002635180950165, 0.009823990054428577, 0.35039815306663513, 0.3453984260559082, 0.5277448296546936, -0.588982343673706, 0.4579378664493561, -0.5792853832244873, -0.042277991771698, 0.4180310368537903, -0.03181198611855507, 0.6377783417701721, 0.5351992249488831, -0.2878316342830658, 0.13754169642925262, -0.7063635587692261, 0.1918395608663559, 0.41053250432014465, 0.09325454384088516, -0.7337346076965332, 0.08088492602109909, -0.25639861822128296, 0.15924958884716034, -0.035336412489414215, -0.4686881899833679, -0.09031853079795837, -0.552419126033783, 0.7279257774353027, 0.6150893568992615, -0.015409215353429317, 0.6421938538551331, -0.1586860865354538, 0.10481822490692139, 0.3329854905605316, -0.15580463409423828, -0.05258273333311081, -0.4448797106742859, -0.6613842248916626, -0.08424193412065506, 0.4518367052078247, 0.20647409558296204, -0.6285018920898438, 0.40608328580856323, -0.17242082953453064, -0.358134925365448, -0.7114068269729614, 0.011051044799387455, 0.38274484872817993, 0.5511800050735474, 0.21210017800331116, -0.2591463029384613, -0.2961103916168213, -0.8324292898178101, -0.2783820629119873, -0.30568215250968933, -0.11746670305728912, -0.31177884340286255, 0.8767995834350586, 0.08320920914411545, 1.0064984560012817, -0.49852874875068665, 0.11552377045154572, -0.20507454872131348, 0.11401601135730743, 0.0035236054100096226, 0.5837106704711914, 0.27780720591545105, -0.6576736569404602, -0.07842530310153961, 0.08682255446910858, -1.1978528499603271, 0.07867974042892456, -0.1005912497639656, -0.2154310792684555, -0.11969591677188873, 0.6501932740211487, -1.1414361000061035, 0.41304537653923035, -0.0532444603741169, -0.406129390001297, 0.4887332618236542, -0.16112902760505676, -0.27374762296676636, -0.9751564264297485, -0.14822836220264435, 0.14447037875652313, -0.018947942182421684, -0.42092573642730713, 0.5144175887107849, -0.2266339808702469, -0.009333760477602482, -0.12338273972272873, 0.9250586628913879, -0.504196047782898, 0.066999651491642, -0.2693203389644623, 0.2231837511062622, 0.1791917085647583, 0.2088494747877121, 0.35189810395240784, 0.5786982178688049, 0.5102041363716125, -0.5913570523262024, 0.3089383840560913, 0.2072077840566635, -0.5285775661468506, 0.6039149165153503, -1.0415738821029663, 0.046185579150915146, -0.40252819657325745, 0.3500230610370636, -0.9122249484062195, -0.19449195265769958, 0.06620723754167557, -0.5728868842124939, 0.21015705168247223, 0.2001916915178299, -0.45426684617996216, -0.14243187010288239, -0.05691050738096237, 0.5415071249008179, 0.4002566933631897, -0.46695542335510254, 0.6241111755371094, 0.3528882563114166, 0.040315207093954086, -0.5637169480323792, -0.4663870334625244, -0.19664469361305237, -0.029458368197083473, -0.7654710412025452, 0.38442710041999817, 0.185832217335701, -0.820123553276062, 0.3244279623031616, -0.42241281270980835, -0.10226397216320038, 0.21070237457752228, 0.11624345183372498, 0.05230182036757469, -0.214223250746727, 0.3447125554084778, 0.4310791492462158, -0.2641187012195587, 0.4069611728191376, -0.6639423966407776, 0.251505970954895, -0.018504740670323372, -0.6083605885505676, -0.44241097569465637, 0.48001378774642944, 0.6847802400588989, -0.5576633810997009, 0.7185415029525757, 0.2995670735836029, -0.6147434115409851, -0.3380010426044464, -0.5952600240707397, -0.5519430041313171, -0.37849465012550354, 0.37918832898139954, -0.5739821195602417, -0.8688976168632507, 0.4621681571006775, -0.04390803724527359, 0.05018724873661995, 0.5090067386627197, 0.7599971294403076, -0.10793155431747437, 1.2866051197052002, 0.38956010341644287, 0.11852402985095978, -0.002656630240380764, -0.14138107001781464, 0.4051054120063782, -0.5722245573997498, -0.30492302775382996, -0.6552481651306152, 0.08313215523958206, -0.22365941107273102, -0.39031389355659485, 0.06225697696208954, 0.0482851043343544, -0.43855372071266174, -0.09042840451002121, -0.6094437837600708, 0.45056992769241333, 0.6350065469741821, -0.1406327784061432, 0.5906075239181519, 0.011800595559179783, -0.5355748534202576, 0.21448080241680145, -0.4420197308063507, -0.5791403651237488, 1.0915449857711792, 0.48840826749801636, 0.8126077055931091, -0.12094927579164505, 0.504507839679718, 0.2021530717611313, 0.2676609456539154, -0.48493993282318115, 0.3793468177318573, 0.36944299936294556, -1.1056207418441772, -0.5425330996513367, -0.21152853965759277, -0.524095892906189, 0.5751839280128479, -0.3293096125125885, -0.7371026277542114, 0.16720621287822723, 0.15159620344638824, -0.4142068326473236, 0.16015754640102386, -0.6670436263084412, 0.7299564480781555, 0.09743276983499527, -0.13784357905387878, -0.42947784066200256, -0.5036513209342957, 0.5527291297912598, 0.00012241168587934226, 0.22560381889343262, -0.30094054341316223, 0.2812197804450989, 0.46129584312438965, -0.4876736104488373, 0.6390414237976074, -0.1730567365884781, -0.36381062865257263, 0.4109128713607788, 0.10082072019577026, 0.42396634817123413, 0.2898782789707184, -0.10033339262008667, 0.20534366369247437, 0.20287877321243286, -0.40562522411346436, -1.1453185081481934, 0.5109012722969055, -0.566467821598053, -0.9549233913421631, -0.45032280683517456, -0.5617747902870178, -0.451726496219635, 0.13491351902484894, 0.20486831665039062, -0.014006093144416809, -0.036726344376802444, 0.08417528122663498, 0.7345724701881409, 0.14003729820251465, -0.0501474067568779, 0.34182116389274597, -0.3987562358379364, -0.09772276133298874, 0.3633999824523926, -0.12468645721673965, 0.4152558147907257, 0.3190295100212097, 0.1276455670595169, -0.5432944893836975, -0.6641587615013123, -0.24311603605747223, 0.3242313861846924, -0.8878991007804871, -0.019859183579683304, -0.47609880566596985, -0.27689164876937866, -0.4345778822898865, -0.03654744476079941, -0.4979856312274933, -0.8088254928588867, 0.2515852451324463, -0.3650830388069153, 0.05721917748451233, 0.483100950717926, 0.061599250882864, 0.16820847988128662, -0.3144448697566986, 0.2643817067146301, 0.4605562686920166, 0.10248876363039017, 0.4018781781196594, -0.37441664934158325, -0.01227449532598257, 0.1629602313041687, -0.2224983423948288, -0.6174688935279846, -0.08153831958770752, -0.20658192038536072, 0.47841426730155945, 0.5656712651252747, 0.19580191373825073, 0.4976748526096344, -0.476486474275589, 0.4431113302707672, 0.4092681407928467, -1.0069187879562378, 0.6101891398429871, -0.3288632929325104, 0.29013487696647644, 0.3233736455440521, 0.2574482560157776, -0.3554854989051819, -0.6430783867835999, -0.5465317964553833, -0.49067920446395874, 0.34417569637298584, 0.3748222589492798, 0.27453845739364624, -0.0949464961886406, 0.547218382358551, -0.12171342968940735, 0.181444451212883, -0.6218125820159912, -0.11490846425294876, -0.3193894326686859, -0.21173691749572754, 0.14777547121047974, -0.1317974179983139, -0.2984742522239685, -0.6978470683097839, 0.5687386393547058, -0.27473774552345276, 0.16892419755458832, 0.1494791954755783, 0.13742280006408691, -0.20106063783168793, 0.37791451811790466, 0.2863522171974182, 0.8979558944702148, -0.009812966920435429, 0.173485666513443, 0.20329225063323975, -0.011120853014290333, 0.2895740568637848, -0.02120424434542656, -0.4286189675331116, 0.042530979961156845, 0.43356087803840637, 0.7182676792144775, 0.1714625209569931, -0.5106092691421509, 0.332034170627594, 0.00973221380263567, -0.26934531331062317, -0.42281007766723633, 0.12192834168672562, 0.5315741300582886, 0.21031127870082855, 0.2913418710231781, 0.03953271359205246, -0.04691603034734726, -0.49251896142959595, 0.060914523899555206, 0.7258390784263611, -0.1762273907661438, -0.32681047916412354, 0.8733634948730469, 0.08584620803594589, 0.2557063400745392, 0.6874303817749023, -0.11234655976295471, -0.12000483274459839, 0.42220479249954224, 0.764279842376709, 0.6861840486526489, -0.2802312970161438, 0.3664321303367615, 0.2740841209888458, 0.2809869050979614, -0.2836478054523468, 0.14663827419281006, -0.17919854819774628, -1.3488481044769287, -0.5749704837799072, -0.6884083151817322, -0.28417345881462097, 0.15786315500736237, -0.503147542476654, 0.0022895478177815676, -0.6770853996276855, -0.24497215449810028, 0.3553123474121094, -0.2835361957550049, -0.40188854932785034, 0.47698697447776794, -0.04843912273645401, 1.0115073919296265, -0.6269968152046204, 0.8386194109916687, 0.8576205968856812, -0.5883992314338684, -0.8214043378829956, -0.17021708190441132, -0.1584835797548294, -0.7927663922309875, 0.7378582954406738, -0.011069032363593578, -0.3224937915802002, -0.15481889247894287, -0.7825839519500732, -0.934038519859314, 0.8650013208389282, 0.5026872754096985, -0.24294596910476685, -0.38755542039871216, -0.029795954003930092, 0.5605402588844299, -0.6663732528686523, 0.27493050694465637, 0.7302144765853882, 0.5094242095947266, 0.5503221154212952, -0.7424391508102417, 0.3301429748535156, -0.27123478055000305, 0.2383631467819214, 0.07863526791334152, -0.23253655433654785, 0.7707464098930359, -0.49211016297340393, -0.22258637845516205, 0.040404073894023895, 1.0267122983932495, 0.40698134899139404, 0.35605770349502563, 0.3751184046268463, 0.8809463381767273, 0.7713526487350464, 0.00693779531866312, 1.0243611335754395, -0.22759555280208588, 0.22429108619689941, 0.9896518588066101, -0.47916334867477417, 0.7141211032867432, 0.5055209994316101, -0.025824369862675667, 0.7470515370368958, 0.41015559434890747, 0.26601487398147583, 0.5176712870597839, 0.2913420498371124, -0.2811574637889862, -0.7346497774124146, -0.17189925909042358, -0.5548815131187439, 0.6222571730613708, 0.37303897738456726, -0.2813873291015625, -0.2906549870967865, -0.3802534341812134, 0.3024652302265167, 0.39662623405456543, -0.1872767210006714, 0.4512377977371216, 0.38793474435806274, -0.8389321565628052, 0.5169250965118408, 0.28796181082725525, 0.2099054455757141, -0.5379785895347595, -0.027367496863007545, -0.1625548154115677, 0.27304351329803467, -0.1460811048746109, -0.5634921193122864, 0.3910636603832245, -0.195764422416687, -0.26924678683280945, 0.014502796344459057, 0.7530297040939331, -0.23625606298446655, -0.4959888458251953, 0.13698598742485046, 0.8801703453063965, -0.20176677405834198, -0.3306005299091339, -0.5767796039581299, -0.19878803193569183, -0.16740603744983673, 0.012594949454069138, 0.2942638099193573, 0.6498628258705139, -0.42168116569519043, 0.9216705560684204, 0.8638849258422852, 0.1993226706981659, -0.28574010729789734, 0.09909871965646744, 0.7767218947410583, -0.6722180247306824, -0.4494568109512329, -0.847229540348053, 0.5029934048652649, -0.3077457845211029, -0.26619741320610046, 0.6381555795669556, 0.09964963793754578, 1.1615324020385742, -0.20668169856071472, 1.0731000900268555, 0.11789044737815857, 0.40528595447540283, -0.6024792194366455, 0.793900728225708, -0.5314680337905884, 0.24180904030799866, -0.3082728385925293, -0.8357340693473816, -0.42087408900260925, 1.0104979276657104, -0.40729567408561707, 0.18104863166809082, 0.875331461429596, 0.6074360013008118, -0.1092732697725296, 0.19219772517681122, 0.30014586448669434, 0.14922183752059937, 0.2135196477174759, 0.3980070650577545, 1.2145226001739502, -0.12230674922466278, -0.006171553861349821, -0.14023138582706451, -0.043060678988695145, 0.29665815830230713, -0.7686779499053955, -1.0655064582824707, -0.6433079838752747, -0.35585376620292664, -0.3244090676307678, 0.09980051219463348, 0.8967324495315552, 0.8323681950569153, -0.9296149015426636, -0.24355852603912354, -0.14261099696159363, 0.48517391085624695, -0.1866498738527298, -0.2202223837375641, 0.1709216684103012, -0.6547566652297974, -0.46991199254989624, 0.14391064643859863, 0.24677051603794098, -0.21430490911006927, -0.46596160531044006, -0.053450826555490494, -0.1181066483259201, 0.4061102569103241, 0.5343976616859436, 0.1424926519393921, -0.9762922525405884, -0.4566139876842499, -0.2909303605556488, 0.12394195795059204, -0.06800583004951477, 0.8956747651100159, -0.7052438259124756, 0.26875555515289307, 0.2504483461380005, 0.49907785654067993, 0.40194272994995117, 0.016142623499035835, 0.7777849435806274, -0.5476567149162292, 0.15432165563106537, 0.1378592699766159, 0.491590678691864, 0.26473915576934814, -0.17896446585655212, 0.5181287527084351, 0.32103580236434937, -0.13218048214912415, -0.8580889105796814, 0.6036248207092285, -0.4489286541938782, -0.5536441206932068, 1.0356968641281128, -0.06782214343547821, -0.21449525654315948, -0.13065993785858154, 0.047975655645132065, 0.06469468027353287, -0.45661601424217224, 0.9495344758033752, 0.9490867853164673, -0.13970652222633362, -0.0114771518856287, -0.22385330498218536, 0.545383095741272, 0.5964186787605286, -0.8664016723632812, 0.03614043444395065, 0.5062242150306702, 0.3527916967868805, 0.4748465120792389, 0.669808030128479, -0.22126390039920807, 0.29139378666877747, 0.13122907280921936, -0.054265428334474564, -0.06158822402358055, -0.44970306754112244, -0.09419987350702286, 0.2906113266944885, 0.3585038483142853, 0.02792098931968212 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00189v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00189v1
GPTA: Generative Prompt Tuning Assistant for Synergistic Downstream Neural Network Enhancement with LLMs
2024-03-29T23:04:04
2024-03-29T23:04:04
Xiao Liu, Jiawei Zhang
cs.CL
cs.CL
This study introduces GPTA, a Large Language Model assistance training framework, that enhances the training of downstream task models via prefix prompt. By minimizing data exposure to LLM, the framework addresses the security and legal challenges of applying LLM in downstream task model training. GPTA utilizes a new synergistic training approach, optimizing the downstream models with parameter gradients and LLMs with the novel ``dialogue gradient''. The framework not only demonstrates significant improvements in model performance across six NLP benchmark datasets, but also reduces overfitting in low-resource scenarios effectively. The detailed analyses further validate that our pioneer framework provides a cost-efficient and adaptive method for downstream task model training with LLM support.
[ -0.3248627781867981, -0.6705593466758728, 0.5334702730178833, 0.304679274559021, -0.2869304120540619, 0.17923301458358765, -0.0500323511660099, -0.4240007996559143, 0.14500023424625397, 0.4016555845737457, -0.9461966156959534, -0.40436258912086487, -0.6541728973388672, 0.344116747379303, -0.05499222129583359, 0.958230197429657, 0.26651519536972046, 0.5024794936180115, 0.10962388664484024, -0.030520550906658173, -0.9166456460952759, -0.4947545826435089, -1.4390923976898193, -0.11283683031797409, 0.7002727389335632, 0.1947164684534073, 0.47025352716445923, 0.33909592032432556, 0.4558809995651245, 0.35937198996543884, -0.20138317346572876, 0.08417598903179169, -0.13723991811275482, 0.434909850358963, -0.1739533245563507, -0.6611689925193787, -0.6103715300559998, -0.36362794041633606, 0.615780770778656, 0.5890911817550659, -0.1987438201904297, 0.13958469033241272, 0.23348525166511536, 0.7638222575187683, -0.6124860048294067, 0.16535955667495728, -0.7038853764533997, -0.09816134721040726, -0.15950985252857208, -0.5301706790924072, -0.368834912776947, -0.11077806353569031, -0.14081083238124847, -0.6898325681686401, 0.31060731410980225, 0.11651885509490967, 0.6864917278289795, 0.6799600124359131, -0.1683516502380371, 0.01615183800458908, -0.4288497865200043, 0.46742352843284607, -0.7340205311775208, 0.2048662155866623, 0.106907419860363, 0.4900702238082886, -0.3658694922924042, -0.9420632719993591, -0.5685228109359741, -0.18656094372272491, -0.007640950847417116, 0.020869486033916473, -0.29373136162757874, 0.4749164879322052, 0.48153600096702576, 0.4282303750514984, -0.5626577734947205, 0.4134408235549927, 0.04065012186765671, -0.34175047278404236, 0.32800599932670593, 0.5334478616714478, 0.40554332733154297, 0.045679137110710144, -0.3125908076763153, -0.0033153234981000423, -0.8508053421974182, 0.07569479197263718, 0.5620108246803284, 0.7321041822433472, -0.09886576980352402, 0.2785584032535553, -0.4100426435470581, 0.9331125617027283, -0.06857027113437653, 0.10629789531230927, 0.18711891770362854, -0.3927690386772156, -0.5106165409088135, -0.09369675070047379, 0.7089092135429382, 0.1428339034318924, -0.05869840085506439, -0.17182868719100952, -0.3433261513710022, 0.004824215080589056, 0.11121691018342972, -0.7638348937034607, -0.1176062524318695, 0.011712848208844662, -0.3325175940990448, -0.08745285868644714, -0.22861969470977783, -0.751451313495636, -0.6015992760658264, -0.5736333727836609, 0.27143001556396484, -0.027067899703979492, -0.29247036576271057, 0.016031824052333832, -0.3079439699649811, 0.3553387522697449, 0.34184131026268005, -1.2769429683685303, 0.28039348125457764, 0.7649402022361755, 1.0327779054641724, -0.02129334770143032, -0.15241482853889465, -0.9589529037475586, 0.003742888802662492, -0.13681866228580475, 0.8472176194190979, -0.5585561990737915, -0.5296927094459534, -0.06871941685676575, 0.3245662748813629, -0.2602469027042389, -0.5470578074455261, 0.5318844318389893, -0.7024909853935242, 0.05561227351427078, -0.47142332792282104, -0.35681381821632385, -0.10675323009490967, -0.0320916548371315, -0.8019861578941345, 0.9198907613754272, 0.23100759088993073, -0.6038453578948975, 0.4994678795337677, -0.8533337712287903, -0.2505801320075989, 0.4601805806159973, -0.13945193588733673, -0.18026697635650635, -0.10087741911411285, 0.3908505439758301, 0.378662109375, -0.5171196460723877, 0.3563360571861267, -0.08017148077487946, -0.3162209987640381, -0.13599824905395508, -0.38903072476387024, 0.8659588098526001, 0.15811310708522797, -0.2456197589635849, 0.7234376668930054, -0.7419920563697815, -0.1115989238023758, -0.025551464408636093, -0.4366223216056824, -0.21130169928073883, -0.2903517782688141, 0.16468869149684906, 0.09537866711616516, 0.09082596004009247, -0.2493656575679779, 0.33668532967567444, -0.35467633605003357, 0.4122873842716217, 0.8412637710571289, 0.1928083449602127, 0.3902915120124817, -0.14445613324642181, 1.0872087478637695, -0.2517697215080261, 0.13249683380126953, -0.21841324865818024, -0.7138266563415527, -0.8109634518623352, -0.39989686012268066, 0.37449225783348083, 0.655674159526825, -0.8542331457138062, 0.6232067942619324, -0.20274385809898376, -0.09784168750047684, -0.5852898955345154, 0.39071211218833923, 0.1776304543018341, 0.8374353051185608, 0.41462188959121704, -0.3102453947067261, -0.8187747597694397, -0.8958883881568909, -0.17391560971736908, 0.04783836007118225, -0.17496417462825775, 0.05033387988805771, 0.21353529393672943, 0.0033198101446032524, 0.9481525421142578, -0.07095664739608765, -0.3581061065196991, -0.5664457082748413, 0.14090916514396667, 0.43025460839271545, 0.45172229409217834, 0.5059846043586731, -0.6522195935249329, -0.5441881418228149, -0.2563067078590393, -0.4438278079032898, -0.27466025948524475, -0.14720067381858826, -0.2248593419790268, 0.16792887449264526, 0.6127288341522217, -0.7405851483345032, 0.06308478116989136, 0.674981415271759, -0.5302814841270447, 0.4327213764190674, -0.06975672394037247, 0.0074578989297151566, -1.4209587574005127, 0.2366260439157486, 0.10792778432369232, -0.2331855595111847, -0.6209847927093506, -0.022109096869826317, -0.07437566667795181, -0.07742493599653244, -0.18207146227359772, 0.4357490539550781, -0.5940729975700378, -0.1269630491733551, -0.4963528513908386, -0.2358788251876831, -0.10944289714097977, 0.5432496070861816, 0.16035959124565125, 1.3199968338012695, 0.8592725992202759, -0.5680616497993469, 0.5037806630134583, 0.34129855036735535, -0.24397942423820496, 0.5184100866317749, -0.7233859300613403, 0.09006756544113159, -0.11996529996395111, 0.21734538674354553, -1.0698407888412476, -0.1684991717338562, 0.4821198582649231, -0.30625489354133606, 0.5408465266227722, -0.4167580306529999, -0.3981475532054901, -0.15691299736499786, -0.09045179188251495, 0.11034785956144333, 0.6808745265007019, -0.6907517910003662, 0.6549651026725769, 0.1409497708082199, -0.5967181324958801, -0.673693835735321, -0.4446617662906647, 0.33073076605796814, -0.4535387456417084, -0.37024104595184326, 0.32285648584365845, 0.05488346517086029, 0.03442886844277382, -0.3754325807094574, 0.11567337065935135, 0.1030629351735115, 0.30264708399772644, 0.19978053867816925, 0.4113098680973053, -0.27280038595199585, 0.12149839103221893, 0.11001703888177872, -0.29835739731788635, 0.23862224817276, -0.1619415283203125, 0.6336299777030945, 0.07485179603099823, -0.038964029401540756, -0.6322920918464661, 0.32835546135902405, 0.10714639723300934, -0.16118158400058746, 0.5896614193916321, 0.5548595786094666, 0.05763137340545654, -0.2915382981300354, -0.2677471339702606, -0.24586324393749237, -0.5977116823196411, 0.43565645813941956, -0.3957366943359375, -0.8471035957336426, 0.6439633369445801, -0.13868124783039093, -0.2372053563594818, 0.30040791630744934, 0.5129089951515198, 0.3521851599216461, 1.0096862316131592, 0.8596299886703491, -0.40550297498703003, 0.8324629068374634, -0.1537899374961853, 0.023420367389917374, -0.9702579975128174, -0.13573963940143585, -0.6018320918083191, -0.18643541634082794, -0.48094961047172546, -0.19421866536140442, 0.3010387122631073, 0.26831287145614624, -0.33644720911979675, 0.20621411502361298, -0.48839864134788513, 0.3761293292045593, 0.5907925367355347, 0.11552638560533524, 0.3492463529109955, -0.04965279623866081, 0.057111963629722595, 0.11456643044948578, -0.8638908267021179, -0.4507567286491394, 0.9602169394493103, 0.49783918261528015, 0.6167458891868591, 0.09886806458234787, 0.28396719694137573, 0.3633731007575989, 0.47001779079437256, -0.9613835215568542, 0.6573205590248108, 0.17169085144996643, -0.34162020683288574, -0.3633577525615692, -0.3858920633792877, -0.788592517375946, 0.15500955283641815, -0.03802797570824623, -0.693462610244751, 0.18928100168704987, 0.3601621091365814, -0.4955582916736603, 0.21624387800693512, -0.6436142325401306, 0.8774682283401489, 0.02034645900130272, -0.27902600169181824, -0.028043655678629875, -0.7141188383102417, 0.2820855677127838, 0.07476665079593658, -0.2926928400993347, -0.20358622074127197, -0.37860190868377686, 0.6429522037506104, -0.6073617339134216, 0.968710720539093, -0.6452873349189758, -0.3199504017829895, 0.0331258699297905, -0.23776860535144806, 0.7779021859169006, 0.09103637933731079, 0.16733407974243164, 0.03171208128333092, -0.5372297167778015, -0.29941728711128235, -0.7347643375396729, 0.5087942481040955, -0.39791086316108704, -0.8238917589187622, -0.13062238693237305, -0.5902219414710999, -0.6040754914283752, -0.06488451361656189, 0.2671358287334442, 0.3606943190097809, 0.2654884457588196, -0.1713898777961731, 0.46551990509033203, -0.05554712191224098, 0.7592428922653198, 0.47504881024360657, 0.2568003237247467, -0.5001521706581116, 0.6148770451545715, -0.4686514437198639, 0.24315932393074036, 0.34537816047668457, -0.11818978190422058, -0.6398779153823853, -0.8673458695411682, -0.6765645146369934, -0.09516298025846481, -0.8907697200775146, -0.5771833062171936, -0.5600796341896057, -0.1129019483923912, -0.23299981653690338, 0.22463054955005646, 0.012115021236240864, -0.3491225242614746, -0.38918471336364746, -0.1813713014125824, 0.7775601148605347, 0.45562297105789185, 0.12491928786039352, 0.6462087631225586, -0.7017896771430969, 0.12601660192012787, 0.3366161286830902, 0.3527193069458008, 0.07189743965864182, -0.6158699989318848, -0.11584233492612839, -0.24380506575107574, -0.14247025549411774, -0.8115524053573608, 0.35621389746665955, 0.31304410099983215, 0.7199215888977051, 0.17348414659500122, -0.24489371478557587, 0.6099103093147278, -0.5075459480285645, 0.9603816270828247, 0.3537691831588745, -1.0024482011795044, 0.6416463255882263, -0.5005936622619629, 0.19459249079227448, 0.5438621044158936, 0.4050711393356323, -0.2494141310453415, -0.3409207761287689, -0.1689816415309906, -0.8961001634597778, 0.604560136795044, -0.14245955646038055, 0.28843992948532104, 0.10783340036869049, 0.3053849935531616, 0.16108596324920654, 0.2192302644252777, -0.6151204705238342, -0.26248374581336975, -0.03267621994018555, -0.3574807345867157, -0.1245265081524849, -0.18519507348537445, -0.07386454939842224, -0.3773064911365509, 0.702312171459198, -0.5473490953445435, 0.27033114433288574, 0.08457288891077042, 0.06717982143163681, -0.03534230962395668, 0.3623978793621063, 0.5177039504051208, 0.5601149201393127, 0.0796462669968605, -0.31869012117385864, 0.33374160528182983, -0.5685229301452637, 0.3286891281604767, 0.23500540852546692, -0.14735440909862518, 0.07355676591396332, 0.27828192710876465, 1.1643542051315308, 0.08627503365278244, -0.5382543802261353, 0.38224413990974426, -0.14112451672554016, -0.11393449455499649, -0.07486502081155777, 0.41854915022850037, 0.03189413994550705, 0.32549381256103516, 0.5750036239624023, 0.07138334959745407, 0.4407397210597992, -0.18915009498596191, -0.04817619174718857, 0.6222413182258606, -0.2048497051000595, -0.27473652362823486, 0.7766022682189941, 0.40197068452835083, -0.24050432443618774, 0.45990467071533203, -0.06150246039032936, -0.3770638406276703, 0.6005932688713074, 0.5198264718055725, 1.176584005355835, -0.35659393668174744, 0.20639586448669434, 0.37544772028923035, 0.05471262335777283, -0.009415410459041595, 0.4895839989185333, -0.2693028151988983, -0.5874515175819397, -0.7955800294876099, -0.7077970504760742, -0.4288843870162964, 0.36828741431236267, -0.7068343162536621, 0.2084561288356781, -0.46336597204208374, -0.38624274730682373, 0.049546703696250916, -0.1699826419353485, -0.4788047969341278, 0.07330822944641113, 0.01525398250669241, 1.0675170421600342, -0.7742084264755249, 0.9426933526992798, 0.640688955783844, -0.5826773047447205, -0.9379416108131409, -0.03773370385169983, -0.3070860505104065, -0.783333420753479, 0.9516768455505371, 0.14653337001800537, -0.1909935176372528, 0.39719000458717346, -0.4905228316783905, -0.6732531785964966, 1.1595489978790283, 0.6999707221984863, -0.8137933015823364, -0.17345045506954193, 0.028790565207600594, 0.49668920040130615, -0.40328410267829895, 0.18568161129951477, 0.6430911421775818, 0.3294944167137146, -0.031859397888183594, -1.0240778923034668, 0.39501723647117615, -0.38207772374153137, 0.46952372789382935, 0.16681347787380219, -0.42797523736953735, 0.5978328585624695, -0.10739663988351822, -0.3923640549182892, 0.40262824296951294, 0.519715428352356, 0.23065608739852905, -0.011674858629703522, 0.5908195972442627, 0.44179224967956543, 0.6389676928520203, -0.15681152045726776, 1.0649073123931885, -0.39483848214149475, 0.05799882858991623, 1.1171233654022217, -0.2915652096271515, 0.6960071921348572, 0.8042314648628235, -0.278943806886673, 0.5559179186820984, 0.8724460601806641, -0.17450901865959167, 0.7162005305290222, 0.2093847393989563, -0.5485923290252686, -0.19892184436321259, -0.35137882828712463, -0.43219661712646484, 0.11848381906747818, 0.30082014203071594, -0.4419354498386383, -0.27466776967048645, 0.10803404450416565, -0.30323663353919983, -0.08896778523921967, -0.6026597023010254, 1.0210434198379517, 0.08939631283283234, -0.6264318823814392, 0.7328391075134277, -0.08309084922075272, 0.829367995262146, -0.7888864874839783, -0.08404186367988586, -0.38549143075942993, -0.07514870911836624, -0.1919339895248413, -0.2977471649646759, 0.1430322229862213, -0.02343248762190342, -0.16367098689079285, -0.14447328448295593, 0.6375243067741394, -0.31244146823883057, -0.11000404506921768, 0.40052109956741333, 0.4762861728668213, -0.2280840426683426, -0.1101570874452591, -0.8833655714988708, 0.0032546287402510643, -0.26598021388053894, -0.21571549773216248, 0.2992086410522461, 0.03608940541744232, 0.1576736867427826, 0.7451935410499573, 0.7446485757827759, 0.35601162910461426, 0.06602028757333755, 0.6599146723747253, 1.0448644161224365, -0.5925285816192627, -0.7800106406211853, -0.8114402294158936, 0.6691295504570007, -0.17278717458248138, -0.3050866425037384, 0.6175124049186707, 0.3610632121562958, 0.6068371534347534, -0.2673695683479309, 0.884463369846344, 0.16554701328277588, 0.3410167396068573, -1.0808502435684204, 0.4842514395713806, -0.3278345465660095, 0.4312942326068878, 0.044438887387514114, -0.9349389672279358, -0.14387503266334534, 0.21566987037658691, -0.17085452377796173, 0.2559731900691986, 0.5814751386642456, 1.1572495698928833, -0.04363078251481056, 0.15177534520626068, 0.21971186995506287, -0.2868099510669708, 0.1424093395471573, 0.613853394985199, 1.0359151363372803, -0.245737224817276, 0.21764244139194489, 0.07396378368139267, -0.09641489386558533, 0.01297792885452509, -0.765412449836731, -0.8936309814453125, -0.5164604783058167, -0.2417200207710266, -0.13035017251968384, 0.20166568458080292, 0.8920667171478271, 0.8344569802284241, -0.8719266653060913, -0.10368044674396515, -0.7049529552459717, -0.18437738716602325, -0.19030779600143433, -0.3303551971912384, 0.16618220508098602, -1.0475374460220337, -0.8142266273498535, 0.7623357772827148, 0.1293143481016159, 0.3565484881401062, -0.3860805630683899, -0.2281547635793686, 0.1283787190914154, -0.23723025619983673, 0.26912084221839905, 0.28535333275794983, -0.6010903716087341, 0.06887982040643692, -0.17422142624855042, 0.0463765412569046, 0.1674930304288864, 1.107839822769165, -0.7203134894371033, 0.20690378546714783, 0.45274582505226135, 0.871609628200531, 0.07204125821590424, 0.07496461272239685, 0.9707228541374207, -1.007727026939392, 0.5327960252761841, 0.1689385324716568, 0.4957655966281891, 0.5804434418678284, -0.745890736579895, 0.39118361473083496, 0.17126989364624023, -0.3668452799320221, -0.7001804709434509, 0.23448465764522552, -0.9607201814651489, -0.13413439691066742, 1.0600756406784058, -0.15625058114528656, 0.03528954088687897, -0.26902151107788086, -0.21166832745075226, 0.13922220468521118, -0.46455618739128113, 0.46611183881759644, 0.4113132357597351, -0.07266075909137726, -0.3986094295978546, -0.7037195563316345, 1.0783721208572388, 0.5949543714523315, -1.0639845132827759, 0.023117654025554657, 0.47298943996429443, 0.3238620162010193, -0.1934807002544403, 0.6820034384727478, 0.18502244353294373, 0.3802417516708374, -0.07239052653312683, -0.0017984433798119426, -0.26935243606567383, -0.28724226355552673, -0.9375503659248352, -0.016066493466496468, 0.31723782420158386, -0.3673815429210663 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00188v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00188v1
DataAgent: Evaluating Large Language Models' Ability to Answer Zero-Shot, Natural Language Queries
2024-03-29T22:59:34
2024-03-29T22:59:34
Manit Mishra, Abderrahman Braham, Charles Marsom, Bryan Chung, Gavin Griffin, Dakshesh Sidnerlikar, Chatanya Sarin, Arjun Rajaram
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI
Conventional processes for analyzing datasets and extracting meaningful information are often time-consuming and laborious. Previous work has identified manual, repetitive coding and data collection as major obstacles that hinder data scientists from undertaking more nuanced labor and high-level projects. To combat this, we evaluated OpenAI's GPT-3.5 as a "Language Data Scientist" (LDS) that can extrapolate key findings, including correlations and basic information, from a given dataset. The model was tested on a diverse set of benchmark datasets to evaluate its performance across multiple standards, including data science code-generation based tasks involving libraries such as NumPy, Pandas, Scikit-Learn, and TensorFlow, and was broadly successful in correctly answering a given data science query related to the benchmark dataset. The LDS used various novel prompt engineering techniques to effectively answer a given question, including Chain-of-Thought reinforcement and SayCan prompt engineering. Our findings demonstrate great potential for leveraging Large Language Models for low-level, zero-shot data analysis.
[ -0.2265872359275818, -1.0296152830123901, 0.5900350213050842, 0.1934000551700592, -0.0316135548055172, 0.08519481867551804, -0.30058154463768005, -0.3609854578971863, -0.19193246960639954, 0.3913339078426361, -0.3850032389163971, -0.537108302116394, -0.3625514507293701, 0.19146917760372162, -0.5188555717468262, 0.9577583074569702, -0.20920920372009277, -0.08417326211929321, -0.023904964327812195, 0.06594111770391464, -0.7037075757980347, -0.41334372758865356, -0.6811748147010803, -0.27954575419425964, 0.4921285808086395, 0.5100385546684265, 0.9283902049064636, 0.5080059170722961, 0.5108045935630798, 0.24115528166294098, 0.18939952552318573, -0.18590183556079865, -0.44673335552215576, 0.2530094087123871, -0.05543370917439461, -0.6722532510757446, -0.2101469337940216, 0.15670914947986603, 0.47881221771240234, 0.928750216960907, -0.05274128541350365, 0.31098446249961853, -0.35260871052742004, 0.5650414228439331, -0.5074811577796936, 0.5937340259552002, -0.5541410446166992, 0.05532409995794296, -0.28754889965057373, -0.07615751028060913, -0.5406132340431213, -0.49403539299964905, 0.24078309535980225, -0.6746872663497925, 0.22967395186424255, -0.048804134130477905, 0.7122480869293213, 0.3839631974697113, -0.13690683245658875, -0.23699457943439484, -0.8948343396186829, 0.851141631603241, -0.5536401867866516, 0.17958834767341614, 0.47226178646087646, 0.6378416419029236, -0.12844063341617584, -0.4099046289920807, -0.589886486530304, -0.38407063484191895, 0.03023187443614006, 0.10211700946092606, -0.2553926408290863, -0.22510619461536407, 0.5014320611953735, 0.27187037467956543, -0.8897772431373596, 0.17405255138874054, -0.31890812516212463, 0.07649822533130646, 0.504086971282959, 0.2689038813114166, 0.4427621364593506, -0.11715225875377655, 0.10130050033330917, -0.2127813696861267, -0.52275550365448, -0.10026463866233826, 0.24598221480846405, 0.5599634051322937, -0.014920245856046677, 0.6830056309700012, -0.5182345509529114, 0.9256024956703186, -0.5399957299232483, 0.34371811151504517, 0.16971440613269806, -0.25042644143104553, -0.30241337418556213, 0.04812643676996231, 0.7855421900749207, 0.022549007087945938, 0.5490151047706604, -0.3562157154083252, -0.08859626203775406, 0.13555555045604706, 0.057724159210920334, -0.9078654050827026, -0.2613699734210968, 0.4974477291107178, -0.1887676864862442, -0.4142073094844818, 0.024189190939068794, -0.8992190957069397, -0.4516134262084961, -0.3500276803970337, 0.28187912702560425, -0.29363709688186646, -0.3614906072616577, 0.09101993590593338, -0.17254456877708435, 0.3502746522426605, 0.18756602704524994, -0.49810224771499634, 0.322892963886261, 0.6135830283164978, 1.0991634130477905, -0.15994158387184143, -0.2891346216201782, -0.6421167850494385, -0.019984319806098938, -0.6360623240470886, 0.7022116184234619, -0.8061209321022034, -0.404659628868103, -0.18401668965816498, -0.17560872435569763, -0.06268932670354843, -0.39972808957099915, 0.36731791496276855, -0.5897628664970398, 0.2110862284898758, -0.1886133998632431, -0.34902170300483704, 0.17774906754493713, 0.13471241295337677, -0.7822205424308777, 0.9756503105163574, 0.3099501132965088, -0.5552604794502258, 0.38533392548561096, -0.9193174242973328, -0.2410571426153183, 0.26846471428871155, -0.40255433320999146, 0.0028016124852001667, 0.08115483820438385, 0.43944862484931946, 0.47517967224121094, -0.7729406952857971, 0.4393300712108612, -0.3008159101009369, -0.5332303643226624, 0.3605022430419922, -0.549767792224884, 0.6330862641334534, 0.27032551169395447, -0.12736018002033234, -0.18596327304840088, -0.7592082619667053, 0.044930923730134964, 0.30843132734298706, -0.02704296074807644, -0.32344183325767517, -0.0813681036233902, -0.04327062517404556, 0.07717391103506088, -0.17251120507717133, -0.7377328276634216, 0.471279114484787, -0.510333776473999, 0.1896362602710724, 0.4760160446166992, -0.04991858825087547, 0.10872474312782288, -0.1535697728395462, 0.5242978930473328, -0.17100413143634796, -0.08658145368099213, -0.2882091701030731, -0.612946093082428, -0.42257747054100037, -0.14595595002174377, 0.216067373752594, 0.5640488862991333, -1.3103466033935547, 0.0312933586537838, -0.4306536912918091, -0.8544122576713562, -0.5990545749664307, -0.03282990679144859, 0.21957948803901672, 0.6708565950393677, 0.4119875133037567, -0.010004391893744469, -0.4437849819660187, -0.7157707810401917, -0.3113763630390167, -0.32910069823265076, -0.22702108323574066, 0.13262145221233368, 0.5824007987976074, 0.06319193542003632, 1.256042718887329, -0.9148876070976257, 0.13256022334098816, -0.18990303575992584, 0.5931551456451416, 0.7094979882240295, 0.2836175262928009, 0.3680587410926819, -0.6947375535964966, -0.5126563310623169, 0.22314311563968658, -1.0720298290252686, -0.2321327179670334, 0.0769728422164917, 0.12023280560970306, 0.08878831565380096, 0.20429201424121857, -0.8367889523506165, 0.3931853771209717, 0.10398837924003601, -0.14717544615268707, 0.5420271754264832, -0.07211685180664062, 0.3300493359565735, -0.7835737466812134, 0.5312604308128357, 0.13232573866844177, 0.18182016909122467, -1.0217437744140625, -0.0276297926902771, -0.08517836034297943, -0.6223997473716736, -0.35494521260261536, 0.5677030086517334, -0.3100341260433197, -0.1248563677072525, -0.42642098665237427, -0.11727667599916458, -0.32413357496261597, 0.32257625460624695, 0.07433470338582993, 1.0618412494659424, 0.748569667339325, -0.5964676141738892, 0.6816102862358093, 0.20777782797813416, -0.4355880916118622, 0.4996005594730377, -0.9112815856933594, 0.4076695740222931, -0.309309720993042, 0.0801110565662384, -1.0095465183258057, -0.47256404161453247, -0.0314704030752182, -0.5179814696311951, 0.23309044539928436, -0.3343459963798523, -0.8241789937019348, -0.591272234916687, -0.22325703501701355, 0.26574331521987915, 0.4189196228981018, -0.4373116195201874, 0.1673225462436676, 0.2451275885105133, -0.508054256439209, -0.3918643891811371, -0.6269479393959045, 0.15586978197097778, -0.12274651974439621, -0.48041462898254395, -0.07815162092447281, 0.005661443341523409, -0.34780585765838623, -0.12796559929847717, -0.11594343930482864, -0.39973002672195435, 0.09120070189237595, -0.09375817328691483, 0.5209218263626099, -0.2618125379085541, 0.13729247450828552, -0.35253193974494934, -0.31350085139274597, 0.09696638584136963, -0.012909279204905033, 0.49720385670661926, -0.20245970785617828, -0.3876390755176544, -0.09001728147268295, 0.22930285334587097, 0.559948205947876, -0.18130648136138916, 0.6039947867393494, 0.4559178948402405, -0.3706972599029541, 0.027460815384984016, -0.3627634048461914, 0.022436201572418213, -0.42344552278518677, 0.44694387912750244, -0.4641474485397339, -0.6126881241798401, 0.405312716960907, 0.14043094217777252, 0.15099723637104034, 0.2226814478635788, 0.3464023470878601, 0.26219454407691956, 1.1214656829833984, 0.3752991855144501, -0.4075362980365753, 0.1298484206199646, -0.1573694497346878, 0.14852410554885864, -0.36035314202308655, 0.05553048849105835, -0.847568154335022, 0.0105742784217, -0.4687696397304535, -0.36527323722839355, 0.38110053539276123, -0.2854245603084564, -0.34079304337501526, 0.4001568555831909, -0.5084483623504639, 0.6286523342132568, 0.32319188117980957, -0.1950984001159668, 0.34128350019454956, -0.09926579147577286, 0.3898875117301941, 0.22353073954582214, -0.4292277693748474, -0.4526273310184479, 1.2340565919876099, 0.27332594990730286, 1.0024129152297974, 0.08413516730070114, 0.27540141344070435, 0.16804878413677216, 0.2929634749889374, -0.7908684611320496, 0.48892447352409363, -0.006404335144907236, -0.5174508094787598, -0.45931363105773926, -0.7594649791717529, -0.9170675277709961, 0.07080429792404175, 0.30283811688423157, -0.8588957786560059, 0.08744210004806519, -0.21926437318325043, -0.2524835467338562, 0.022717991843819618, -0.8605766296386719, 0.8530847430229187, -0.052609119564294815, -0.24626079201698303, 0.16918881237506866, -0.5489456653594971, 0.3361376225948334, -0.2755080759525299, 0.2078951746225357, -0.11520234495401382, -0.036549050360918045, 0.6628488302230835, -0.2687370479106903, 0.6040205359458923, -0.5595704317092896, -0.12498420476913452, 0.35900744795799255, 0.22747497260570526, 0.4346408545970917, 0.001837104675360024, -0.43073540925979614, 0.045399200171232224, 0.16425231099128723, -0.49561429023742676, -0.8944301009178162, 0.7529920339584351, -0.7867772579193115, -0.5095174908638, -0.3479408919811249, -0.6848858594894409, -0.43558138608932495, 0.002464655786752701, -0.12376881390810013, 0.34180453419685364, -0.22264470160007477, 0.21589238941669464, 0.4761960506439209, -0.15321382880210876, 0.5450294613838196, 0.7363287806510925, -0.2197873592376709, -0.20080813765525818, 1.1537799835205078, 0.3355564475059509, 0.1978953629732132, 0.290607213973999, 0.2635706663131714, -0.06585218012332916, -0.2592969834804535, -0.7125447988510132, -0.030634533613920212, -0.40673232078552246, -0.21286064386367798, -0.41677072644233704, -0.19828732311725616, -0.20164735615253448, 0.11144766211509705, -0.3259759247303009, -0.3447530269622803, 0.05758245661854744, 0.048584483563899994, 0.4202076494693756, 0.7159207463264465, 0.393446683883667, 0.29856422543525696, -0.6989285945892334, 0.2691374123096466, 0.23914481699466705, 0.37940114736557007, -0.11110313981771469, -0.19331872463226318, -0.2592642605304718, -0.016765478998422623, 0.002999628195539117, -1.0453706979751587, 0.2516043782234192, -0.004170308820903301, 0.527186393737793, -0.02869752049446106, 0.008266572840511799, 0.6010628938674927, -0.20930607616901398, 0.8837223649024963, -0.18051853775978088, -0.7891031503677368, 0.8046053647994995, -0.5483397245407104, 0.636050820350647, 0.4732097089290619, 0.5443089604377747, -0.5056101679801941, -0.21102790534496307, -0.23871088027954102, -0.7189337611198425, 0.9449957013130188, 0.5430318713188171, -0.028042059391736984, -0.04284465312957764, 0.28057870268821716, 0.19652357697486877, 0.4320693612098694, -0.37661898136138916, -0.0953325629234314, -0.2554660737514496, -0.2580639123916626, -0.08314135670661926, 0.28923499584198, 0.00621268292888999, -0.15422146022319794, 0.5739888548851013, -0.5188589096069336, 0.3037041425704956, 0.21275267004966736, -0.09174466878175735, -0.01953900419175625, 0.5257095694541931, 0.2509501278400421, 0.6934131979942322, -0.31266677379608154, -0.06035032868385315, 0.11905597150325775, -0.5668166875839233, 0.1903088390827179, 0.4848896265029907, -0.23412850499153137, -0.06918808072805405, 0.2759840190410614, 0.5016856789588928, -0.14657804369926453, -0.6822131872177124, 0.4512699842453003, -0.0770546942949295, 0.10307447612285614, 0.13781100511550903, 0.07186106592416763, -0.3143708407878876, -0.21169719099998474, 0.5211023688316345, -0.2718328833580017, 0.06980020552873611, -0.5836189985275269, 0.16711169481277466, 0.127816304564476, -0.49126818776130676, -0.4084470570087433, 0.3307708501815796, 0.029208142310380936, 0.016423260793089867, 0.7968910336494446, 0.061707671731710434, -0.02817658707499504, 0.8350474834442139, 0.5328518748283386, 0.7982010245323181, -0.21679678559303284, 0.4760606288909912, 0.17208650708198547, 0.25922298431396484, -0.056770209223032, 0.48595094680786133, 0.13448087871074677, -0.5131717920303345, -0.7964417338371277, -0.3390388786792755, -0.5900055170059204, 0.22271540760993958, -0.6300055980682373, 0.2908337712287903, -0.32717472314834595, 0.08519817888736725, 0.16250306367874146, -0.002917185425758362, -0.939039945602417, 0.2223435789346695, -0.09764328598976135, 0.9511132836341858, -0.9044634699821472, 0.6906719207763672, 0.6978207230567932, -0.722028911113739, -0.7430310249328613, -0.035251684486866, -0.008313652127981186, -0.8111414313316345, 0.7005919814109802, 0.2909316420555115, 0.20278100669384003, 0.005426553077995777, -0.8201106786727905, -0.7284085154533386, 1.0664591789245605, 0.4357199966907501, -0.21408432722091675, -0.017967918887734413, 0.35989195108413696, 0.7113633155822754, -0.20444978773593903, 0.8186901211738586, 0.8021782040596008, 0.4637056291103363, 0.1589716672897339, -1.027068018913269, 0.07977035641670227, -0.397386759519577, -0.08961916714906693, 0.25833696126937866, -0.5144578814506531, 0.8437355756759644, 0.11984355002641678, -0.06599290668964386, 0.04086285084486008, 0.508395254611969, 0.21897859871387482, 0.3551861345767975, 0.30966559052467346, 0.37738388776779175, 0.8360170125961304, -0.0970248356461525, 1.1487197875976562, -0.23737666010856628, 0.3173501193523407, 1.1719824075698853, -0.7034433484077454, 0.68571537733078, 0.3237338364124298, -0.31084081530570984, 0.3015827536582947, 0.2956255376338959, -0.23435647785663605, 0.44800248742103577, 0.2832252085208893, -0.16155312955379486, 0.05968554690480232, -0.43727537989616394, -0.36335858702659607, 0.5019705891609192, 0.26822996139526367, 0.039151158183813095, -0.45332810282707214, 0.0953892394900322, -0.08680366724729538, -0.2680788040161133, -0.16995054483413696, 0.6119511127471924, -0.11476719379425049, -0.7422534823417664, 0.4527861773967743, -0.17883650958538055, 0.1963355988264084, -0.6604326367378235, -0.2265249341726303, -0.22454561293125153, -0.030948618426918983, -0.08315467834472656, -1.1026633977890015, 0.37306928634643555, 0.4344295561313629, 0.1148374006152153, -0.008384707383811474, 0.7071420550346375, -0.06750493496656418, -0.3706434369087219, -0.021674808114767075, 0.7153742909431458, 0.4102792739868164, -0.34440672397613525, -0.48019200563430786, -0.018315637484192848, -0.28868281841278076, -0.2839159071445465, 0.014047891832888126, 0.3251866102218628, -0.050620127469301224, 0.7871453762054443, 0.7162111401557922, 0.15785473585128784, -0.21634405851364136, 0.43877100944519043, 1.0406887531280518, -0.7889847159385681, -0.12375862151384354, -0.9385473728179932, 0.3356488049030304, -0.1821153163909912, -0.22226932644844055, 0.6875757575035095, 0.7295547127723694, 0.6745168566703796, -0.04548421874642372, 1.0422266721725464, -0.1958206295967102, 0.5877870917320251, -0.4015425145626068, 0.46068936586380005, -0.1279212087392807, 0.18843190371990204, -0.4640822112560272, -0.8855751156806946, -0.21531468629837036, 0.2857849895954132, -0.5530256628990173, 0.04251595586538315, 0.5433921217918396, 0.8088263273239136, -0.07619038969278336, 0.43773382902145386, 0.30635249614715576, 0.26734018325805664, 0.6367225646972656, 0.5259005427360535, 0.9449102878570557, -0.42962414026260376, 0.6582366228103638, -0.03179805353283882, -0.38915055990219116, 0.28962382674217224, -0.5089284777641296, -0.9735392332077026, -0.19627633690834045, -0.20642894506454468, 0.03851216286420822, 0.0016228046733886003, 0.8296144604682922, 0.5992065668106079, -0.7827544808387756, -0.3580525517463684, -0.25805217027664185, -0.07300130277872086, 0.04706796631217003, -0.3022614121437073, 0.28579097986221313, -0.3406658172607422, -0.704740047454834, 0.7285639643669128, 0.19313429296016693, -0.002129418309777975, -0.3621082901954651, 0.1600799411535263, -0.10308992862701416, -0.03869452327489853, 0.3841569125652313, 0.29235824942588806, -0.34646305441856384, -0.25095653533935547, 0.30102330446243286, -0.01880115456879139, -0.020487941801548004, 0.8275005221366882, -0.8595441579818726, 0.7005107998847961, 0.4848899245262146, 0.8182333707809448, 0.38876545429229736, 0.04692333564162254, 0.8104239106178284, -0.8741549253463745, -0.01893107406795025, 0.19379788637161255, 0.05191422253847122, 0.34824398159980774, -0.4246804118156433, 0.8090119361877441, 0.09565001726150513, -0.5996858477592468, -0.7881835103034973, 0.14258533716201782, -0.5801369547843933, -0.17678390443325043, 1.0007342100143433, 0.032061006873846054, -0.18713946640491486, -0.35670924186706543, -0.3134349286556244, 0.1478879153728485, -0.47818058729171753, 0.5558123588562012, 0.8988931775093079, -0.18164922297000885, -0.004047076217830181, -1.1023727655410767, 0.19492322206497192, 0.31046146154403687, -1.1391229629516602, 0.211574524641037, 0.31427904963493347, 0.07483511418104172, 0.2343287169933319, 0.5669057369232178, -0.024355817586183548, 0.18812769651412964, 0.04060865566134453, -0.0490386039018631, -0.10217452794313431, -0.3778267204761505, -0.28950223326683044, 0.1832888424396515, 0.02597871609032154, -0.08055353164672852 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01332v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01332v1
Wait, It's All Token Noise? Always Has Been: Interpreting LLM Behavior Using Shapley Value
2024-03-29T22:49:43
2024-03-29T22:49:43
Behnam Mohammadi
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
The emergence of large language models (LLMs) has opened up exciting possibilities for simulating human behavior and cognitive processes, with potential applications in various domains, including marketing research and consumer behavior analysis. However, the validity of utilizing LLMs as stand-ins for human subjects remains uncertain due to glaring divergences that suggest fundamentally different underlying processes at play and the sensitivity of LLM responses to prompt variations. This paper presents a novel approach based on Shapley values from cooperative game theory to interpret LLM behavior and quantify the relative contribution of each prompt component to the model's output. Through two applications-a discrete choice experiment and an investigation of cognitive biases-we demonstrate how the Shapley value method can uncover what we term "token noise" effects, a phenomenon where LLM decisions are disproportionately influenced by tokens providing minimal informative content. This phenomenon raises concerns about the robustness and generalizability of insights obtained from LLMs in the context of human behavior simulation. Our model-agnostic approach extends its utility to proprietary LLMs, providing a valuable tool for marketers and researchers to strategically optimize prompts and mitigate apparent cognitive biases. Our findings underscore the need for a more nuanced understanding of the factors driving LLM responses before relying on them as substitutes for human subjects in research settings. We emphasize the importance of researchers reporting results conditioned on specific prompt templates and exercising caution when drawing parallels between human behavior and LLMs.
[ 0.05622291564941406, -0.9426639676094055, 0.6486774682998657, 0.3846754729747772, -0.1635342389345169, -0.007678920868784189, -0.21331940591335297, -0.5170494914054871, 0.42328140139579773, 0.3814378082752228, -0.5533992648124695, -0.18536213040351868, -0.411105751991272, -0.15577566623687744, -0.1710221767425537, 0.7780218124389648, 0.44807368516921997, 0.4829752445220947, -0.4459730386734009, 0.024267645552754402, -0.4673287570476532, -0.935649037361145, -0.8371062874794006, -0.42431673407554626, 0.5722561478614807, 0.24271941184997559, 0.6830152869224548, 0.2868015468120575, 0.2434336245059967, 0.2422250360250473, -0.2949999272823334, -0.19147886335849762, -0.5553880929946899, 0.19879138469696045, 0.048420753329992294, -0.6517466902732849, -0.31999120116233826, 0.2810652256011963, 0.4100034832954407, 0.8802382946014404, -0.05910395830869675, 0.24129430949687958, 0.22191192209720612, 0.4358307123184204, -0.48773714900016785, 0.27473166584968567, -0.49466630816459656, -0.07724948972463608, -0.29805833101272583, -0.22155196964740753, -0.3205030560493469, -0.1063559427857399, -0.10944405198097229, -0.675390899181366, 0.012841015122830868, 0.3665359914302826, 0.795020580291748, 0.10001226514577866, -0.2349579781293869, -0.46269431710243225, -0.39044663310050964, 1.1342037916183472, -0.5703292489051819, 0.1845143437385559, 0.3255297839641571, -0.2144538164138794, -0.4668985605239868, -0.4613519012928009, -0.6332386136054993, -0.46446868777275085, 0.07853880524635315, 0.21871140599250793, -0.32361704111099243, 0.17747268080711365, 0.20138321816921234, 0.3496443033218384, 0.1557764708995819, 0.19986394047737122, -0.3959922194480896, -0.5029503107070923, 0.4805219769477844, 0.5475825667381287, 0.2873755097389221, -0.37207046151161194, -0.5179411768913269, 0.13598164916038513, -0.36647555232048035, 0.8633923530578613, 0.5884358882904053, 0.1695464551448822, -0.22428113222122192, 0.42083999514579773, 0.10732176154851913, 0.6049812436103821, 0.39897021651268005, -0.19295494258403778, 0.015508590266108513, -0.4616900086402893, 0.015922119840979576, -0.0009896871633827686, 0.7947178483009338, 0.4551791250705719, 0.15192236006259918, -0.25382909178733826, -0.19131582975387573, -0.0924145057797432, -0.004154193680733442, -0.7541161775588989, -0.32220253348350525, 0.3013371229171753, -0.822917640209198, -0.7946835160255432, -0.025341028347611427, -0.6493820548057556, -0.6365270018577576, -0.40834081172943115, 0.2589541971683502, -0.3390960991382599, -0.4076516628265381, 0.04616159200668335, -0.2631746530532837, 0.3439283072948456, 0.10464104264974594, -0.8895205855369568, 0.4709441363811493, 0.931874692440033, 0.9690269827842712, -0.9271150827407837, -0.40031397342681885, -0.7148318290710449, -0.02825109288096428, -0.449112206697464, 0.8763815760612488, -0.6099135279655457, -0.6304932832717896, -0.24280068278312683, -0.30660751461982727, 0.1179700493812561, -0.5935609340667725, 0.7885664701461792, -0.4912412762641907, -0.05002494156360626, -0.8692806363105774, -0.41488274931907654, 0.2517756223678589, 0.19154562056064606, -0.6021959185600281, 0.8421503305435181, 0.11035983264446259, -0.6499833464622498, 0.542743444442749, -0.7145765423774719, -0.44289934635162354, 0.10769321769475937, -0.3810863792896271, -0.24796445667743683, 0.28965139389038086, -0.07285810261964798, 0.12798020243644714, -0.12992124259471893, 0.4721987247467041, -0.4550721347332001, -0.6161618828773499, 1.0926393270492554, -0.6615238785743713, 0.9491504430770874, 0.18140316009521484, -0.08330097794532776, 0.23493176698684692, -0.39939916133880615, -0.08242829889059067, -0.04847467318177223, -0.3495772182941437, -0.19845589995384216, -0.23346199095249176, -0.0828949585556984, 0.10834488272666931, 0.4013324975967407, -0.3910963833332062, -0.18170154094696045, -0.12239344418048859, 0.520065426826477, 1.1225980520248413, 0.1764897257089615, 0.48912158608436584, -0.5646504759788513, 0.7070951461791992, 0.3391101360321045, 0.388658732175827, -0.17279665172100067, -0.6380012035369873, -0.5650585889816284, -0.526849627494812, 0.2128654569387436, 0.09634289890527725, -0.18616154789924622, 0.07010556012392044, -0.024321215227246284, 0.1354583352804184, -0.34400877356529236, -0.1418907344341278, 0.0030471435748040676, 0.49287381768226624, -0.09447300434112549, -0.213109090924263, -0.6471675038337708, -0.6988263726234436, -0.5640574097633362, -0.3097825050354004, 0.022428620606660843, 0.5317167639732361, 0.27588754892349243, 0.24849693477153778, 1.145168423652649, -0.2170175462961197, -0.07995790988206863, -0.038077209144830704, 0.12253197282552719, 0.3340759575366974, 0.08429527282714844, 0.2908998727798462, -0.5129323601722717, 0.0002685988729353994, -0.49319085478782654, -0.4246048331260681, -0.3926015794277191, -0.19084323942661285, -0.10883268713951111, 0.04166117683053017, 0.3955341875553131, -0.41085243225097656, 0.1883421391248703, 0.6457635164260864, -0.5255044102668762, 0.9102271199226379, 0.12662620842456818, 0.2121235430240631, -0.7419010400772095, 0.08427520841360092, -0.3385164737701416, -0.022306391969323158, -0.4000870883464813, -0.2317100167274475, -0.3192460536956787, 0.00802308414131403, -0.3355022072792053, 0.6199413537979126, -0.3286532759666443, -0.3339320719242096, -0.35433149337768555, 0.01704726368188858, 0.07438437640666962, 0.33380043506622314, -0.24488966166973114, 1.3184102773666382, 0.41142383217811584, -0.8368781208992004, 0.3164626359939575, 0.14545109868049622, -0.27341488003730774, 0.9466098546981812, -0.684580385684967, -0.06710338592529297, -0.07671119272708893, 0.16440361738204956, -1.0428251028060913, -0.15062586963176727, 0.4877168536186218, -0.5413777828216553, -0.2600243091583252, -0.11260039359331131, -0.3912311792373657, -0.06397648900747299, -0.4078470468521118, 0.5413442850112915, 0.6119922995567322, -0.3686150908470154, 0.6674361228942871, 0.622000515460968, -0.11890798807144165, -0.44512367248535156, -0.6592664122581482, 0.3337574005126953, -0.38378286361694336, -0.6955068707466125, 0.08538524061441422, -0.27311912178993225, -0.7651399970054626, -0.2174307405948639, -0.20363907516002655, -0.022148624062538147, 0.2888028919696808, 0.7171065807342529, 0.4130120575428009, -0.016794566065073013, 0.06330959498882294, -0.39282000064849854, -0.24033977091312408, 0.6815511584281921, -0.50345778465271, 0.6246877312660217, -0.08944439142942429, -0.4646896719932556, -0.2694677412509918, -0.0005884345155209303, 0.1848793625831604, 0.06745266169309616, 0.379597932100296, 0.5633505582809448, 0.15554659068584442, -0.07997294515371323, -0.5117409825325012, -0.24336610734462738, -0.5543482303619385, 0.23444508016109467, -0.21785247325897217, -0.7565743923187256, 0.7753873467445374, -0.11427353322505951, -0.33073192834854126, 0.015993015840649605, 0.5297564268112183, -0.3571033477783203, 0.7556232810020447, 0.3167043626308441, -0.12678176164627075, 0.7019418478012085, 0.17474369704723358, 0.06525510549545288, -0.829610288143158, -0.45744654536247253, -0.3321557641029358, -0.35954365134239197, -0.20968610048294067, -0.5233962535858154, 0.4933862090110779, 0.0013991448795422912, -0.10399198532104492, -0.5965843200683594, -0.22828666865825653, 0.726653516292572, 0.5314156413078308, 0.278159499168396, 0.5717074871063232, 0.006048595067113638, 0.03902314230799675, -0.21840323507785797, -0.6557781100273132, -0.33573922514915466, 1.0198031663894653, 0.05279281735420227, 0.6403518319129944, 0.06429008394479752, 0.554844081401825, 0.5234147310256958, 0.22130243480205536, -1.039367437362671, 0.5466426610946655, 0.24820178747177124, -0.47859126329421997, -0.2984485626220703, -0.44499024748802185, -1.2179992198944092, 0.12756408751010895, -0.16496224701404572, -0.7042824625968933, 0.02048921212553978, 0.015328355133533478, -0.581121563911438, 0.2793560028076172, -0.2843194007873535, 0.4782852530479431, -0.46328651905059814, -0.5611249208450317, -0.2611270844936371, -0.2030440717935562, 0.6497539281845093, 0.017232386395335197, 0.4950890839099884, -0.2718442976474762, -0.2548288106918335, 1.016093134880066, -0.1687205284833908, 1.1702628135681152, 0.05986306816339493, -0.14115558564662933, 0.46268975734710693, 0.33658960461616516, 0.58623868227005, 0.07837559282779694, -0.22666528820991516, 0.4423670470714569, 0.05372203141450882, -0.6753905415534973, -0.35393160581588745, 0.8113423585891724, -0.8789442181587219, -0.5648310780525208, -0.5281602740287781, -0.8435446619987488, -0.051435645669698715, 0.1380225121974945, 0.11706110090017319, 0.260763019323349, -0.4044886827468872, -0.217321515083313, 0.7080410122871399, -0.08789531141519547, 0.49454164505004883, 0.40169575810432434, -0.25508493185043335, -0.3482554256916046, 0.749384343624115, -0.13387471437454224, 0.227533757686615, -0.12100350111722946, 0.5270664095878601, -0.4079793095588684, -0.7319537997245789, -0.018342209979891777, 0.1121058240532875, -0.7271108627319336, 0.07436240464448929, -0.47974446415901184, 0.32881778478622437, -0.10859134793281555, -0.1974547803401947, 0.04147150367498398, -0.2667448818683624, -0.3440322279930115, -0.03368394449353218, 0.34158989787101746, 0.814808189868927, -0.2486649751663208, 0.1807226538658142, -0.4830171465873718, 0.28925397992134094, 0.4723758101463318, 0.49513810873031616, 0.18874773383140564, -0.589260458946228, -0.08284936845302582, 0.29891014099121094, -0.09751243144273758, -0.7598689794540405, 0.0194358192384243, -0.155877485871315, 0.6805004477500916, 0.36266449093818665, 0.13633958995342255, 0.7946805953979492, 0.08835539221763611, 1.321799874305725, 0.329618364572525, -1.243859052658081, -0.01714668609201908, -0.5139943361282349, -0.11496853083372116, 0.4810977578163147, -0.28762587904930115, -0.6884600520133972, 0.023565256968140602, -0.8074750900268555, -0.5082305073738098, 0.6235557198524475, 0.07115201652050018, 0.2623102366924286, -0.1457759290933609, 0.49367931485176086, 0.14409798383712769, 0.30569157004356384, -0.6448668837547302, -0.21707770228385925, -0.010783180594444275, 0.009224694222211838, 0.24478207528591156, -0.4160730242729187, -0.14716379344463348, -0.08233441412448883, 0.33490854501724243, -0.0359724722802639, 0.038334619253873825, 0.024824898689985275, -0.017715096473693848, -0.2966548800468445, 0.12144424021244049, 0.43178874254226685, 0.6721976399421692, 0.07441867142915726, 0.19060833752155304, 0.35932913422584534, -0.3605101406574249, 0.0905432477593422, -0.5043977499008179, -0.23326101899147034, -0.05459971725940704, 0.3335144817829132, 0.43044421076774597, 0.5652052760124207, -0.800043523311615, 1.078565239906311, 0.13883471488952637, -0.15980055928230286, -0.5170409679412842, 0.08938764035701752, 0.09785463660955429, 0.2795184254646301, 0.2822387218475342, 0.2730892598628998, 0.19665464758872986, -0.5743544697761536, 0.3224790394306183, 0.7201257944107056, -0.5040782690048218, -0.5328543186187744, 0.7852849364280701, 0.3977889120578766, -0.4634177088737488, 0.45876824855804443, -0.30875614285469055, -0.21006102859973907, 0.5883258581161499, 0.4245929718017578, 0.6914803981781006, 0.37510740756988525, 0.3462885320186615, 0.02435353398323059, -0.12237867712974548, -0.16051283478736877, 0.29217153787612915, -0.08450533449649811, -0.7561733722686768, -0.6027011871337891, -0.41988736391067505, -0.5991606116294861, 0.11877530068159103, -0.7739042043685913, 0.19457384943962097, -0.5593399405479431, -0.3892756700515747, -0.1052035465836525, -0.030404210090637207, -0.6496946811676025, -0.41937315464019775, 0.17514494061470032, 0.48765382170677185, -0.6408035755157471, 0.4094257950782776, 0.4070024788379669, -0.5054581761360168, -0.654369056224823, 0.2625119388103485, -0.05506505072116852, -1.3981207609176636, 0.7483335733413696, -0.13349774479866028, -0.3490784466266632, -0.14120493829250336, -0.9540464878082275, -0.8051832318305969, 1.0460766553878784, 0.2709263563156128, -0.2930481433868408, 0.24543364346027374, 0.47459203004837036, 0.35037267208099365, -0.23321408033370972, 0.30837976932525635, 0.6447951793670654, 0.6778580546379089, 0.24975739419460297, -0.6271073222160339, 0.22211946547031403, 0.21514232456684113, -0.051354069262742996, -0.1834026724100113, -0.9641542434692383, 1.0726828575134277, -0.47371572256088257, -0.2540093958377838, 0.011323615908622742, 0.5170801877975464, 0.7181479334831238, 0.5036446452140808, 0.5270944237709045, -0.07804699242115021, 1.1172658205032349, 0.10800770670175552, 0.8286718130111694, -0.4286125600337982, 0.10974253714084625, 0.7251771092414856, -0.195354625582695, 0.4398360252380371, 0.8895881175994873, -0.4709240198135376, 0.3912471532821655, 0.4706498980522156, -0.018430324271321297, 0.11838003247976303, 0.5998137593269348, -0.15353962779045105, -0.4895048439502716, -0.3949449062347412, 0.05884323641657829, 0.28224632143974304, 0.2348262220621109, -0.06903939694166183, 0.08220306783914566, -0.3333396017551422, 0.2494119554758072, 0.030566511675715446, -0.2807418704032898, 0.6506543159484863, 0.23803283274173737, -0.39531177282333374, 0.2069973200559616, -0.23743541538715363, 1.1278700828552246, -0.41783463954925537, 0.05768442898988724, -0.22503671050071716, -0.12957914173603058, -0.16518628597259521, -0.7985700368881226, 0.023347951471805573, -0.21512585878372192, -0.2600266933441162, -0.1781049519777298, 0.49809756875038147, -0.07936985790729523, -0.44824889302253723, 0.0073853847570717335, 0.6201213598251343, 0.3071027398109436, -0.3196684718132019, -0.7248209118843079, 0.3766552209854126, 0.042565617710351944, -0.06377644836902618, 0.3762371838092804, 0.5224705338478088, -0.000673821079544723, 0.6690186858177185, 1.1241177320480347, 0.2700801491737366, 0.033716458827257156, -0.020397061482071877, 0.7109214067459106, -0.8517884016036987, -0.7712162137031555, -0.9980524778366089, 0.38531649112701416, -0.25071945786476135, -0.4543968439102173, 0.6678647994995117, 0.507442831993103, 0.3779333233833313, 0.2121463567018509, 0.9609231948852539, 0.3275609016418457, -0.0189555361866951, -0.5656547546386719, 0.5390404462814331, 0.08320590108633041, 0.6371560096740723, -0.016332631930708885, -0.4338006377220154, 0.0648682489991188, 0.3015146851539612, -0.26701995730400085, 0.01889839395880699, 0.5043418407440186, 0.6347731351852417, 0.14654654264450073, 0.19679495692253113, 0.43148595094680786, 0.22093217074871063, 0.46161088347435, 0.12747913599014282, 1.3650085926055908, -0.07478270679712296, 0.7867995500564575, 0.031628482043743134, -0.059618089348077774, -0.30684465169906616, -0.8902336955070496, -0.9687433242797852, -0.4511934518814087, -0.07053061574697495, -0.6634571552276611, 0.014408671297132969, 0.8568906784057617, 0.5484610199928284, -0.6919271945953369, -0.2979035973548889, 0.10500260442495346, 0.11547654867172241, -0.41163700819015503, -0.31356772780418396, 0.20386558771133423, -0.5267029404640198, -0.4717852771282196, 0.23337043821811676, -0.01263225357979536, 0.0988832339644432, -0.3589501678943634, -0.2512815594673157, 0.533064067363739, 0.4643944203853607, 0.416561484336853, -0.06513054668903351, -0.9473153352737427, -0.19869297742843628, 0.23207418620586395, -0.09191723167896271, 0.2891852557659149, 1.172629714012146, -0.7815289497375488, 0.12777744233608246, 0.2589089274406433, 0.14523479342460632, 0.3923664093017578, 0.1989137828350067, 0.4778553545475006, -0.6472323536872864, 0.2657422721385956, 0.3289678692817688, 0.14190299808979034, 0.21902291476726532, -0.5584705471992493, 0.04823784530162811, 0.30785703659057617, -0.38432952761650085, -0.7074617743492126, 0.4350492060184479, -1.0938900709152222, -0.41650670766830444, 1.5063973665237427, 0.17617209255695343, -0.4880092442035675, -0.3838483691215515, -0.3942408561706543, -0.15204760432243347, -0.869868278503418, 1.115599274635315, 0.789743185043335, -0.3719712197780609, -0.13759388029575348, -0.3560025095939636, 0.52131587266922, 0.43296897411346436, -0.4545789659023285, 0.2569243609905243, 0.5300365686416626, 0.5547277927398682, -0.10171245038509369, 0.8981379270553589, -0.06061336398124695, 0.05455614998936653, 0.2831161916255951, -0.08098728954792023, -0.5987666845321655, 0.36713308095932007, -0.5363332033157349, 0.05516301095485687, 0.35166308283805847, -0.2510434091091156 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00184v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00184v1
Word Ladders: A Mobile Application for Semantic Data Collection
2024-03-29T22:41:40
2024-03-29T22:41:40
Marianna Marcella Bolognesi, Claudia Collacciani, Andrea Ferrari, Francesca Genovese, Tommaso Lamarra, Adele Loia, Giulia Rambelli, Andrea Amelio Ravelli, Caterina Villani
cs.CL
cs.CL
Word Ladders is a free mobile application for Android and iOS, developed for collecting linguistic data, specifically lists of words related to each other through semantic relations of categorical inclusion, within the Abstraction project (ERC-2021-STG-101039777). We hereby provide an overview of Word Ladders, explaining its game logic, motivation and expected results and applications to nlp tasks as well as to the investigation of cognitive scientific open questions
[ -0.29066821932792664, -0.533095121383667, 0.027966750785708427, 0.5035884380340576, -0.3064253330230713, 0.14155985414981842, 0.39693909883499146, -0.45918506383895874, 0.6318200826644897, 0.3938257694244385, -0.5511184334754944, -0.9500336050987244, -0.5511285662651062, -0.27475836873054504, -0.8118646740913391, 0.9961711764335632, -0.00709516741335392, -0.17237906157970428, -0.2880808413028717, -0.36772868037223816, -0.5374982357025146, -0.18051907420158386, -0.482143372297287, -0.4038688540458679, 0.590593159198761, 0.8442574739456177, 1.2157418727874756, 0.8908454775810242, 0.9067575335502625, 0.17498861253261566, 0.08060510456562042, -0.153605654835701, -0.37464413046836853, 0.1755346655845642, -0.35752975940704346, -0.7384134531021118, -0.3262418806552887, 0.22402293980121613, 0.36019349098205566, 0.291301965713501, -0.3833034932613373, 0.866918683052063, -0.1776570826768875, 1.0602092742919922, -0.8940978646278381, 0.37357646226882935, -0.6803664565086365, 0.4667096436023712, -0.3271217942237854, -0.65784752368927, -0.14833080768585205, -0.587384819984436, -0.17658917605876923, -0.5002546310424805, -0.02444116398692131, 0.2622874081134796, 0.8137248158454895, 0.11689886450767517, -0.565233051776886, -1.0311763286590576, -0.41739675402641296, 0.4814889430999756, -0.14206086099147797, 0.5398280024528503, 0.6682626008987427, 0.3447846472263336, -0.3786465525627136, -0.780400812625885, -0.5256856679916382, -0.197463721036911, 0.15648894011974335, 0.22741584479808807, -0.20953768491744995, -0.06086176261305809, -0.07842035591602325, 0.6184743642807007, -0.48618781566619873, -0.13688687980175018, -0.4833216667175293, -0.08122491091489792, 0.8062530159950256, 0.5511505007743835, 0.8725429773330688, -0.26693782210350037, -0.4234910011291504, -0.06798145920038223, -0.8180281519889832, 0.655035138130188, 0.11077312380075455, 0.153290256857872, -0.3147856891155243, 1.3810514211654663, -0.005353952292352915, 0.8175546526908875, -0.37317198514938354, -0.23167066276073456, 0.2809280455112457, -0.21952199935913086, 0.07728418707847595, 0.47055160999298096, 0.7878002524375916, 0.9282087683677673, 0.1148144006729126, -0.45130598545074463, 0.04828496277332306, 0.6790339350700378, -0.1668163388967514, -0.4773653745651245, -0.20427504181861877, 0.6576713919639587, -0.6216074824333191, -0.4922719895839691, -0.4039607048034668, -0.6163062453269958, -0.6332162022590637, 0.18548594415187836, 0.2568662762641907, -0.3236932158470154, -0.08128376305103302, 0.28056395053863525, -0.842676043510437, 0.5044175982475281, -0.25188377499580383, -1.1006157398223877, 0.3607824146747589, 0.6430658102035522, 1.1061944961547852, 0.07774844020605087, -0.16038137674331665, -0.8122897744178772, -0.009047280997037888, -0.601360559463501, 0.5221803188323975, -0.6927446126937866, -0.981486976146698, -0.09110072255134583, -0.18019643425941467, -0.11691294610500336, -0.4384644031524658, 0.9319193363189697, -0.5748301148414612, -0.0225206445902586, -0.06904836744070053, -0.685111939907074, -0.10215456038713455, 0.18831394612789154, -0.6684181094169617, 1.3300412893295288, -0.2997641861438751, -1.2603113651275635, 0.43349796533584595, -0.7604357004165649, -0.2030465453863144, 0.20466075837612152, -0.24583198130130768, 0.29771295189857483, 0.0141514977440238, 0.11093035340309143, 0.46734103560447693, -0.3147425353527069, -0.07425019145011902, -0.02053729258477688, -0.31168895959854126, -0.024196013808250427, 0.49763402342796326, 0.8622916340827942, 0.6258375644683838, -0.12054166197776794, 0.25545889139175415, -0.7413963675498962, 0.19324612617492676, -0.08542750775814056, -0.381460577249527, -0.7604528665542603, 0.8430436849594116, -0.28744396567344666, 0.5374748706817627, 0.26810356974601746, -0.9894158244132996, 0.20175422728061676, -0.13614463806152344, 0.14316587150096893, 0.21361717581748962, -0.3850170969963074, 0.3765716254711151, -0.37009817361831665, 0.5425881147384644, 0.319252610206604, -0.26081132888793945, 0.07133150100708008, -0.9063429236412048, -0.37993645668029785, -0.19005900621414185, 0.5810986161231995, 1.2826558351516724, -1.1031272411346436, 0.528177797794342, -0.6695224642753601, -0.9715391993522644, -0.5311577320098877, 0.1245059072971344, 0.22026224434375763, 0.3078809678554535, 0.1253204047679901, -0.2945981025695801, -0.41897058486938477, -0.6220105886459351, -0.580163300037384, -0.2530294358730316, -0.3543270230293274, 0.3180539906024933, 0.687140941619873, -0.19581076502799988, 1.2944542169570923, -0.3442593514919281, -0.6467152237892151, -0.1404201090335846, 0.15696480870246887, 0.06797725707292557, 0.2747201919555664, 0.3765907287597656, -0.7152317762374878, -0.28715673089027405, -0.06706323474645615, -0.9685368537902832, 0.14612160623073578, 0.1942533403635025, -0.0111460005864501, -0.5878104567527771, 0.5852987170219421, -0.5368372201919556, 0.4123532176017761, 0.9759177565574646, -0.8103975653648376, 0.06803064048290253, -0.04527328163385391, -0.15144221484661102, -1.281473159790039, 0.012057237327098846, 0.07407505810260773, -0.020887263119220734, -0.34998080134391785, 0.4027452766895294, -0.11419999599456787, -0.1357075721025467, -0.46064135432243347, 0.5786436796188354, -0.35238417983055115, -0.09655649960041046, 0.004502458963543177, 0.9001356959342957, -0.566882312297821, -0.06547361612319946, 0.197652205824852, 0.6304812431335449, 0.7485735416412354, -0.6772753000259399, 0.6140304207801819, 0.5282701253890991, -0.3579943776130676, 0.22158513963222504, -0.3763136863708496, -0.1667804718017578, -0.31234389543533325, 0.13479025661945343, -1.0787495374679565, 0.013387419283390045, 0.13679327070713043, -0.7653377652168274, -0.7127262949943542, 0.3960663974285126, -0.43278443813323975, -0.6470839381217957, -0.7320564389228821, 0.22145429253578186, 0.5038999319076538, -0.5365357398986816, 0.329824298620224, 1.0600227117538452, 0.016694920137524605, -0.7261115312576294, -0.8568058013916016, 0.2146289348602295, -0.20415715873241425, -0.7258369326591492, 0.04947001487016678, 0.4263855814933777, -0.36482590436935425, 0.273850679397583, -0.06712574511766434, -0.05759967491030693, -0.21941326558589935, 0.43938523530960083, 0.08298305422067642, -0.2371705323457718, 0.4079466462135315, -0.12800759077072144, 0.07428321242332458, 0.1445542722940445, 0.1186118796467781, 0.5076930522918701, -0.36326920986175537, 0.041797734797000885, -0.17115028202533722, 0.25838857889175415, 0.49269625544548035, -0.3990256190299988, 0.6454449892044067, 0.1942981630563736, -0.3111308217048645, 0.1975909024477005, -0.16379474103450775, 0.46601247787475586, -0.4715763330459595, -0.044983599334955215, -0.4819098711013794, -1.055190920829773, 0.7957218885421753, -0.032652415335178375, 0.4024474024772644, 0.5437484979629517, 0.35176870226860046, 0.2257252037525177, 1.193528652191162, 0.38838693499565125, -0.41802939772605896, -0.0832940861582756, -0.13699831068515778, 0.1401187628507614, -0.7889261841773987, -0.570029079914093, -0.9469172954559326, -0.6426638960838318, -0.9452744126319885, -0.4393523335456848, -0.11347144842147827, 0.18222574889659882, -0.068478524684906, 0.25702476501464844, -0.7531671524047852, 0.5020116567611694, 0.5456711053848267, -0.02709144353866577, 0.5325939655303955, -0.09305911511182785, -0.4762880504131317, -0.13146206736564636, -0.6787745356559753, -0.4439311623573303, 1.0582942962646484, 0.46920034289360046, 0.8891234397888184, 0.02815965935587883, 0.9510351419448853, 0.2590080201625824, 0.1609286069869995, -1.3770850896835327, 0.9004841446876526, -0.1599522829055786, -0.8145992159843445, -0.2925814092159271, -0.21010199189186096, -1.244258999824524, 0.22996050119400024, -0.3056177496910095, -1.1040687561035156, 0.2366308718919754, 0.15994134545326233, 0.055433131754398346, 0.4298817217350006, -0.48914816975593567, 0.665939450263977, -0.22246341407299042, -0.15178841352462769, -0.25316527485847473, -0.703498363494873, 0.5764793753623962, 0.24325136840343475, 0.6101008057594299, -0.21674256026744843, -0.2345813363790512, 1.0995066165924072, -0.540030837059021, 0.3295647203922272, -0.34851908683776855, -0.10285292565822601, 0.8727173805236816, 0.4486592710018158, 0.40661656856536865, -0.2187686413526535, 0.18396922945976257, 0.011010061018168926, 0.4209338426589966, -0.15531419217586517, -0.17027761042118073, 0.6264474987983704, -0.27603575587272644, -0.13219094276428223, -0.6863008737564087, -0.7168881297111511, -0.4044901430606842, 0.23576919734477997, 0.16189931333065033, 0.16217856109142303, -0.07041455805301666, 0.5838102698326111, 0.20960542559623718, -0.2719685733318329, 0.39205867052078247, 0.1603698581457138, -0.820832371711731, 0.0631331130862236, 1.1125261783599854, -0.03676004335284233, -0.42907992005348206, 0.3783956468105316, 0.3075505197048187, -0.5954511165618896, -0.5333975553512573, -0.5047716498374939, -0.1725589483976364, -0.30558010935783386, -0.044642675668001175, -0.3017048239707947, -0.13541030883789062, 0.24112339317798615, -0.054395537823438644, -0.04935089126229286, -0.807249903678894, 0.32936593890190125, -0.2725222706794739, 0.563313901424408, 0.670006513595581, -0.06823404133319855, 0.3457387685775757, -1.2471250295639038, 0.6806772351264954, 0.103004589676857, 0.5280447006225586, -0.12356407940387726, 0.3002915680408478, -0.03784593567252159, 0.3532862365245819, -0.34273794293403625, -0.7946879863739014, 0.2614505887031555, 0.38009992241859436, 0.24867947399616241, 0.2104397863149643, -0.17561957240104675, 0.7570803165435791, -0.6858850717544556, 1.3196063041687012, 0.6668097376823425, -1.0094075202941895, 0.6103723645210266, -0.5417404770851135, 0.2946457862854004, 0.4199031889438629, 0.6772672533988953, -0.7303166389465332, -0.47520536184310913, -0.42408353090286255, -0.8385034203529358, 0.6055189371109009, 0.29306063055992126, 0.11674627661705017, -0.40577754378318787, 0.11047722399234772, -0.4748934507369995, 0.23787128925323486, -0.6005557179450989, -0.2135104238986969, -0.21107684075832367, -0.40125223994255066, -0.081362284719944, -0.18708443641662598, -0.10433011502027512, -0.46094390749931335, 0.2932588756084442, 0.31389760971069336, 0.10486387461423874, 0.22167515754699707, -0.19121532142162323, 0.03623013198375702, 0.25412002205848694, 0.2292981743812561, 0.2163536101579666, -0.23777379095554352, 0.151824951171875, -0.038299620151519775, -1.082841396331787, 0.169514000415802, -0.3503860831260681, 0.14984478056430817, 0.2519392967224121, 0.07212977856397629, 0.326019823551178, 0.0019745647441595793, -0.9650959372520447, 0.4074932932853699, -0.10050173848867416, -0.33349427580833435, -0.027748605236411095, -0.003240843303501606, 0.6338545083999634, 0.0201720017939806, 0.3839271068572998, -0.34171998500823975, 0.4382249116897583, -0.7399666905403137, 0.4259975254535675, 0.673503577709198, -0.5894256234169006, 0.20021453499794006, 0.8695034384727478, 0.20749445259571075, -0.5518043041229248, 0.7176644802093506, -0.12340765446424484, -0.12682463228702545, 0.46301135420799255, 0.5029258131980896, 0.6174825429916382, -0.4663061797618866, 0.5889849662780762, 0.2225504219532013, 0.3808113634586334, -0.09526853263378143, 0.714177668094635, -0.14579252898693085, -0.7780325412750244, -0.2554888129234314, -0.749442994594574, -0.36464348435401917, -0.28350090980529785, -0.5779678821563721, 0.3303106725215912, -0.3165479600429535, -0.346535861492157, 0.09270063042640686, -0.39200887084007263, -0.2231217920780182, 0.3963904082775116, -0.023998279124498367, 1.5530792474746704, -0.5468908548355103, 0.6631661653518677, 0.5796474814414978, -0.3391530513763428, -1.0443884134292603, -0.3336891531944275, 0.10636534541845322, -0.8076989054679871, 1.1964662075042725, -0.1302689164876938, -0.7018807530403137, 0.145228311419487, -0.48027631640434265, -0.7090767621994019, 0.9416784644126892, -0.10308478027582169, -0.08001120388507843, -0.43029651045799255, 0.5881919264793396, 0.6233561635017395, -0.3868445158004761, 0.0074081458151340485, 0.42216363549232483, 0.2115388810634613, 0.21910615265369415, -0.9622189402580261, 0.024119535461068153, -0.5960732698440552, -0.1006903275847435, 0.44237077236175537, -0.008747447282075882, 0.636414647102356, -0.012265058234333992, -0.4316542446613312, 0.030839953571558, 0.424075722694397, 0.14514847099781036, 0.5180744528770447, 0.2920858860015869, 0.8458147644996643, 0.5426685810089111, -0.06869547069072723, 1.1099963188171387, -0.6048744916915894, 0.36282482743263245, 0.9160228371620178, -0.182099848985672, 1.1803557872772217, 0.3614671528339386, -0.14858309924602509, 0.7258481383323669, 0.6544338464736938, 0.3225468099117279, 0.4033113718032837, 0.43528908491134644, -0.16144374012947083, 0.32449662685394287, -0.1497860997915268, -0.4825327396392822, 0.7105622887611389, 0.8832367658615112, -0.2693440020084381, -0.7650709748268127, -0.1327323317527771, -0.1412130445241928, -0.12283532321453094, -0.7003872394561768, 0.46453148126602173, 0.11805523931980133, -0.4822881817817688, 0.6423354744911194, 0.07922498136758804, 0.5508080720901489, -0.6720004677772522, 0.09514380991458893, 0.1374584436416626, 0.16323931515216827, -0.7193140983581543, -1.0039154291152954, 0.48470285534858704, 0.0182654932141304, 0.4369578957557678, 0.12788808345794678, 0.7017480134963989, -0.1914367377758026, -0.23997370898723602, 0.34422194957733154, 0.6663138270378113, 0.2622781991958618, 0.2451755255460739, -0.6924296021461487, -0.27376773953437805, -0.36582204699516296, -0.1162227988243103, 0.03791934624314308, 0.12793231010437012, -0.36267179250717163, 1.0589696168899536, 0.689923882484436, 0.28186100721359253, 0.43168655037879944, -0.4793725311756134, 0.6377803087234497, -0.9421810507774353, -0.7575464844703674, -0.6328000426292419, 0.5540165305137634, -0.01033030729740858, -0.30186623334884644, 1.2152785062789917, 1.1952403783798218, 0.5011057257652283, -0.13413608074188232, 0.5155084133148193, -0.4561806917190552, 0.6432794332504272, -0.4290359318256378, 0.6470080018043518, -0.6581922173500061, 0.03812762722373009, -0.3384646773338318, -0.9087977409362793, -0.5584953427314758, 0.4704894423484802, -0.27769583463668823, -0.6197763681411743, 0.8451648354530334, 0.5395530462265015, -0.033087506890296936, 0.49368026852607727, -0.10563253611326218, -0.300548255443573, -0.05817307531833649, 0.5025664567947388, 0.8376863598823547, -0.45482006669044495, 0.3604338765144348, -0.03154321759939194, -0.41402727365493774, -0.002067200606688857, -0.581985354423523, -0.8403910994529724, -0.8434083461761475, 0.18626247346401215, -0.4101986289024353, 0.019646869972348213, 0.832863450050354, 0.02547336369752884, -0.7110452651977539, -0.8599578738212585, -0.34285542368888855, 0.13904520869255066, 0.024279534816741943, -0.26479336619377136, 0.3995722830295563, -0.2055501639842987, -0.3068581223487854, 0.14293192327022552, 0.0698566809296608, -0.4042808413505554, 0.2700740098953247, 0.08002286404371262, -0.5712559819221497, 0.15737925469875336, 1.0854147672653198, 0.6386623978614807, -0.2931780517101288, -0.2005940079689026, 0.05565962940454483, 0.017888283357024193, 0.056198786944150925, 0.9165726900100708, -0.871741533279419, 0.5737916231155396, 0.8380159139633179, 0.620844304561615, 0.3132615089416504, 0.09557855874300003, 0.25491252541542053, -0.6043730974197388, 0.5633112788200378, 0.22147361934185028, 0.13418430089950562, -0.16416501998901367, -0.05988656356930733, 0.748862087726593, -0.03199493885040283, -0.35424938797950745, -0.7922785878181458, 0.18550457060337067, -0.831760823726654, 0.0024717857595533133, 0.9094095826148987, 0.283493310213089, -0.17795489728450775, -0.16680708527565002, -0.1698949635028839, 0.009583871811628342, -0.14557743072509766, 0.7210441827774048, 0.9238647818565369, -0.5614021420478821, 0.2752995193004608, -0.7809639573097229, 0.7095008492469788, 0.09855274856090546, -0.6580959558486938, -0.21867844462394714, 0.5380526185035706, 0.018863052129745483, 0.5823338627815247, 0.7413910031318665, -0.4989369213581085, 0.22272048890590668, 0.2482094168663025, -0.02240808494389057, 0.3414231836795807, -0.08658551424741745, -0.136041522026062, 0.3525078296661377, -0.06806234270334244, -0.8023071885108948 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00176v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00176v1
The LSCD Benchmark: a Testbed for Diachronic Word Meaning Tasks
2024-03-29T22:11:54
2024-03-29T22:11:54
Dominik Schlechtweg, Shafqat Mumtaz Virk, Nikolay Arefyev
cs.CL
cs.CL
Lexical Semantic Change Detection (LSCD) is a complex, lemma-level task, which is usually operationalized based on two subsequently applied usage-level tasks: First, Word-in-Context (WiC) labels are derived for pairs of usages. Then, these labels are represented in a graph on which Word Sense Induction (WSI) is applied to derive sense clusters. Finally, LSCD labels are derived by comparing sense clusters over time. This modularity is reflected in most LSCD datasets and models. It also leads to a large heterogeneity in modeling options and task definitions, which is exacerbated by a variety of dataset versions, preprocessing options and evaluation metrics. This heterogeneity makes it difficult to evaluate models under comparable conditions, to choose optimal model combinations or to reproduce results. Hence, we provide a benchmark repository standardizing LSCD evaluation. Through transparent implementation results become easily reproducible and by standardization different components can be freely combined. The repository reflects the task's modularity by allowing model evaluation for WiC, WSI and LSCD. This allows for careful evaluation of increasingly complex model components providing new ways of model optimization.
[ -0.45232242345809937, -0.5314913988113403, 0.5095179080963135, 0.036367133259773254, -0.3025393784046173, -0.207838773727417, -0.25394096970558167, -0.5475618839263916, -0.06398601084947586, 0.2555927336215973, -0.8154146075248718, -0.8290899395942688, -0.3674049377441406, 0.0917244553565979, -0.4594179689884186, 0.7904726266860962, -0.4214726388454437, 0.05016900599002838, -0.18491216003894806, -0.4558864235877991, -0.3760513663291931, -0.2634461522102356, -0.17063108086585999, -0.3038303852081299, 0.48338207602500916, 0.14507026970386505, 0.6757851839065552, 0.40644001960754395, 0.439439594745636, 0.22833141684532166, -0.3203046917915344, -0.017545204609632492, -0.2900964915752411, 0.25519365072250366, -0.5184688568115234, -0.292725533246994, -0.39616841077804565, 0.14747902750968933, 0.5049753189086914, 0.9805676341056824, -0.46620434522628784, 0.33515045046806335, 0.10564019531011581, 0.5930575132369995, -1.2160316705703735, 0.48107126355171204, -0.7833291888237, 0.018932463601231575, -0.35363447666168213, 0.30072471499443054, -0.13289207220077515, -0.2744003236293793, -0.01601114310324192, -0.6146655082702637, 0.28158414363861084, -0.1596904695034027, 0.8317931294441223, 0.4150879383087158, -0.10583269596099854, -0.2940550148487091, -0.49902644753456116, 0.7050512433052063, -0.8146133422851562, 0.8709288239479065, 0.3181377351284027, 0.45721137523651123, -0.1005922332406044, -0.8879135847091675, -0.662991464138031, -0.1921357810497284, 0.13987794518470764, 0.2329900562763214, -0.20084916055202484, 0.06854201853275299, 0.3609691858291626, 0.3510054647922516, -0.2948724329471588, 0.31674686074256897, -0.12614133954048157, -0.38348087668418884, 0.4405953288078308, 0.40508443117141724, -0.06453114002943039, -0.150141179561615, -0.20005643367767334, -0.28248631954193115, -0.5012239217758179, 0.00043687777360901237, 0.08760347962379456, 0.3878525197505951, -0.12177831679582596, 0.6095624566078186, -0.602898359298706, 0.7637360095977783, -0.19099061191082, -0.028503980487585068, 0.5141529440879822, -0.5487951636314392, -0.3077976107597351, 0.23005911707878113, 0.35245198011398315, 0.4470440149307251, 0.0713479071855545, -0.05971101298928261, -0.49263033270835876, 0.7431075572967529, 0.06886688619852066, -0.7521308064460754, -0.08280792832374573, 0.0113443061709404, -0.5100055932998657, -0.2082638442516327, -0.08359743654727936, -0.41126149892807007, -0.3227218687534332, -0.5364995002746582, 0.1022176668047905, -0.4990612864494324, -0.11042382568120956, 0.3021918535232544, -0.1305515319108963, 0.04023691266775131, 0.17878271639347076, -0.7603691220283508, 0.5360336303710938, 0.6959799528121948, 0.6002626419067383, -0.6386739015579224, -0.4175868630409241, -0.18775051832199097, -0.027322296053171158, -0.5350512266159058, 0.7941192984580994, -0.25065404176712036, -0.47908031940460205, -0.02504093572497368, 0.15809859335422516, -0.041015006601810455, -0.6808366775512695, 0.5200194716453552, -0.5671250224113464, -0.1253255158662796, -0.4437810778617859, -0.7383107542991638, 0.20254787802696228, 0.37811073660850525, -0.7090139389038086, 1.4924559593200684, 0.49215614795684814, -1.0048528909683228, 0.7528809309005737, -0.457601398229599, -0.06337351351976395, 0.31695738434791565, -0.2004876285791397, -0.17970706522464752, 0.09391508251428604, -0.1030762642621994, 0.34221288561820984, -0.24414490163326263, 0.2458917498588562, -0.2493436187505722, -0.48795077204704285, 0.16419176757335663, -0.14763115346431732, 0.5363805294036865, 0.3944230079650879, -0.3110543191432953, 0.04082869738340378, -0.8951351642608643, 0.15693871676921844, 0.005435058381408453, -0.29111552238464355, -0.8652355074882507, 0.25397753715515137, 0.04921923205256462, 0.0917045846581459, 0.33961284160614014, -0.7781150937080383, -0.038101647049188614, -0.23803234100341797, 0.3203083276748657, 0.765539824962616, -0.10114631056785583, 0.11077571660280228, -0.09753682464361191, 0.13655157387256622, 0.33713677525520325, 0.41709765791893005, -0.003031112952157855, -0.34455421566963196, -0.5107866525650024, -0.18513980507850647, 0.27170199155807495, 0.3835611045360565, -0.5699924826622009, 0.47092506289482117, -0.19509580731391907, -0.6618961691856384, -0.5461558103561401, -0.05873062089085579, 0.33794012665748596, 0.48269158601760864, 0.5311427712440491, -0.5072861909866333, -0.23081812262535095, -1.084538459777832, -0.24763117730617523, -0.13363425433635712, 0.08698195219039917, 0.1104937195777893, 0.6067021489143372, -0.42914947867393494, 1.0218712091445923, -0.6253035664558411, -0.15874597430229187, 0.041960399597883224, 0.17049062252044678, 0.21297048032283783, 0.10263052582740784, 0.2397981882095337, -0.7029598355293274, -0.06591678410768509, -0.18329733610153198, -0.6056488752365112, -0.475001722574234, 0.10768865793943405, 0.09051031619310379, 0.20042535662651062, 0.951133131980896, -0.39854559302330017, 0.628649115562439, 0.6021741628646851, -0.4159134030342102, 1.0392310619354248, -0.1450098603963852, 0.2133375108242035, -0.923791229724884, -0.0698808804154396, -0.17518076300621033, 0.041456714272499084, -0.3887573778629303, 0.38419607281684875, 0.5548350214958191, 0.034852296113967896, -0.658685028553009, 0.28017595410346985, -0.325919508934021, -0.5116475224494934, -0.05193552374839783, 0.30641940236091614, -0.12612435221672058, 0.11925176531076431, -0.11607173830270767, 0.8139252066612244, 0.26366204023361206, -0.672637403011322, 0.30761265754699707, 0.0611310638487339, -0.8564465045928955, 0.7226000428199768, -0.6676512360572815, -0.1376418173313141, -0.028259113430976868, 0.14036546647548676, -0.8203516602516174, 0.26483824849128723, -0.05279768258333206, 0.07549190521240234, -0.12536433339118958, 0.41346803307533264, -0.7357819676399231, -0.46385636925697327, -0.3476138710975647, 0.6303457617759705, 0.24011893570423126, -0.5344908833503723, 0.25897398591041565, 0.13370947539806366, 0.21071745455265045, -0.32533153891563416, -0.720096230506897, -0.07094420492649078, 0.09077689796686172, -0.37223848700523376, 0.8028485774993896, -0.29562684893608093, -0.5080015063285828, 0.30042245984077454, -0.32060447335243225, 0.1697247326374054, 0.10693854093551636, 0.2527067959308624, 0.28851234912872314, -0.14213433861732483, 0.20495840907096863, 0.13391928374767303, -0.18433068692684174, -0.08615005761384964, 0.06641088426113129, 0.6228650212287903, -0.03860441595315933, -0.7542658448219299, -0.46622413396835327, 0.2602097690105438, 0.5533149838447571, -0.24553905427455902, 0.46459221839904785, 0.4962421655654907, -0.548198401927948, -0.38098740577697754, -0.5429856777191162, -0.15600953996181488, -0.4615325927734375, 0.5261976718902588, -0.6023213267326355, -0.8046116828918457, 0.5084293484687805, -0.22472356259822845, 0.1398651897907257, 0.4910700023174286, 0.5967112183570862, 0.03993146866559982, 0.9137650728225708, 0.39775142073631287, -0.034144848585128784, 0.4019540250301361, -0.05496296286582947, -0.023749837651848793, -1.0546008348464966, -0.255470871925354, -0.6284216642379761, -0.29050007462501526, -0.682425856590271, -0.4880124628543854, 0.3082565665245056, 0.24400265514850616, -0.3922249674797058, 0.4842771887779236, -0.5876364707946777, 0.27327555418014526, 0.11540043354034424, 0.1796456128358841, 0.33226796984672546, -0.34528473019599915, -0.4748845398426056, -0.3763197362422943, -0.3340844213962555, -0.26146674156188965, 0.8252749443054199, 0.04384452849626541, 0.84038907289505, -0.048834625631570816, 0.7174262404441833, 0.5146759748458862, 0.14827023446559906, -0.7352715730667114, 0.855646550655365, -0.262782484292984, -0.08075413852930069, -0.12814414501190186, -0.09339100122451782, -0.9507091045379639, 0.31140029430389404, -0.23540396988391876, -0.8041250705718994, 0.3149692416191101, -0.18371467292308807, 0.10528144240379333, 0.2815011739730835, -0.4454258680343628, 0.8200179934501648, 0.18541470170021057, -0.07976116985082626, -0.5811931490898132, -0.20203986763954163, 0.282585471868515, -0.13995611667633057, 0.4078470766544342, -0.4013890326023102, -0.20010235905647278, 0.7578241229057312, -0.4563811719417572, 0.7379218935966492, -0.25486332178115845, -0.152897909283638, 0.062048375606536865, 0.3772013485431671, 0.5043726563453674, -0.2585427165031433, -0.41610294580459595, 0.20993050932884216, 0.3799925446510315, -0.1930048018693924, -0.33173832297325134, 0.818993091583252, -0.7785176634788513, -0.38971182703971863, -0.46036842465400696, -0.681160032749176, -0.267804890871048, 0.20705781877040863, 0.05459807068109512, 0.35329657793045044, -0.5459656119346619, -0.12867170572280884, 0.6080169677734375, -0.20002979040145874, 0.40995174646377563, 0.6066666841506958, -0.09589527547359467, 0.17347243428230286, 0.42298421263694763, 0.017299965023994446, 0.5095553398132324, -0.04916655644774437, 0.282026082277298, -0.17237092554569244, -0.6932200789451599, -0.2332376092672348, 0.08555338531732559, -1.0500576496124268, -0.1192701980471611, -0.28122130036354065, -0.24592235684394836, -0.32319703698158264, -0.1856231689453125, -0.5495601892471313, -0.20576176047325134, -0.15480683743953705, -0.012695026583969593, 0.33530697226524353, 0.5560392141342163, 0.0562133863568306, -0.15215793251991272, -0.47539567947387695, 0.39869239926338196, 0.14996042847633362, 0.34719523787498474, -0.15316933393478394, -0.20723412930965424, -0.06867551803588867, 0.08050992339849472, -0.14102725684642792, -0.8897279500961304, 0.012936312705278397, 0.17502982914447784, 0.7235743999481201, 0.2817946672439575, 0.12895599007606506, 0.64128577709198, -0.443729966878891, 1.0308268070220947, 0.33830559253692627, -1.0653079748153687, 0.5483996868133545, 0.00016654795035719872, 0.6992591023445129, 0.6815702319145203, 0.20119494199752808, -0.773177981376648, -0.33359596133232117, -0.4401283264160156, -0.7932952046394348, 0.5031218528747559, -0.18531978130340576, -0.1149640753865242, -0.19209043681621552, 0.39632660150527954, 0.2404031604528427, 0.040840767323970795, -0.26164400577545166, -0.10548634082078934, -0.2254020720720291, -0.1732068955898285, -0.026295583695173264, -0.12724660336971283, -0.16579559445381165, -0.336575448513031, 0.4280039370059967, -0.22333897650241852, -0.07216644287109375, 0.2524317502975464, -0.2500516176223755, 0.24363592267036438, 0.39576995372772217, 0.301199734210968, 0.6955249309539795, -0.12749864161014557, 0.18966037034988403, 0.5269221663475037, -0.590191662311554, -0.23488204181194305, 0.051919639110565186, -0.30719226598739624, 0.08359230309724808, 0.386702299118042, 0.8049657940864563, 0.6292781829833984, -0.7521406412124634, 0.5000967979431152, 0.062127381563186646, -0.3700413405895233, -0.12533725798130035, 0.06421848386526108, 0.28500720858573914, 0.1994401067495346, 0.2176888883113861, -0.061191439628601074, 0.2111913412809372, -0.6709669232368469, 0.2830391526222229, 0.2780005633831024, -0.5383015275001526, -0.22393251955509186, 0.5317828059196472, -0.33658862113952637, -0.1401228904724121, 0.6288471817970276, -0.35110193490982056, -0.3458559811115265, 0.5423024296760559, 0.5927071571350098, 0.7347774505615234, -0.29356685280799866, 0.2166435420513153, 0.3672042191028595, 0.07683554291725159, -0.07325177639722824, 0.3979783356189728, -0.36353397369384766, -1.1489877700805664, -0.04931672662496567, -0.7338513731956482, -0.4173627197742462, -0.031301457434892654, -1.1794978380203247, 0.43556472659111023, -0.31516632437705994, -0.2706657350063324, 0.29665520787239075, -0.19756431877613068, -0.784409761428833, 0.21381978690624237, 0.17333778738975525, 1.256301999092102, -0.7659710049629211, 0.9377388954162598, 0.5376425385475159, -0.0049473000690341, -0.659541666507721, -0.10055303573608398, 0.11744082719087601, -0.8028044700622559, 0.6979569792747498, -0.01853136159479618, -0.21727469563484192, -0.16924840211868286, -0.3280082046985626, -0.5864090919494629, 1.427510380744934, 0.007104027550667524, -0.9313492178916931, 0.23109464347362518, 0.21100082993507385, 0.6735979914665222, -0.2814862132072449, 0.1015477105975151, 0.9448482990264893, 0.5619462728500366, -0.04328830540180206, -1.0026806592941284, 0.2352105975151062, -0.05064132809638977, 0.37203919887542725, 0.3114936351776123, -0.2010836899280548, 1.039587378501892, -0.12370974570512772, -0.48545482754707336, 0.08093155175447464, 0.34963348507881165, 0.5359319448471069, 0.2839093506336212, 0.9799563884735107, 0.8392458558082581, 0.6897158026695251, -0.3098052740097046, 0.9245093464851379, -0.39786297082901, 0.3707790672779083, 1.074785828590393, -0.703960120677948, 1.090973973274231, 0.6101458668708801, -0.4306911528110504, 0.7554190754890442, 0.8588767051696777, -0.08060429245233536, 0.8961356282234192, 0.4971172511577606, -0.28919360041618347, -0.06982763111591339, -0.3574255406856537, -0.4615345597267151, 0.381840318441391, 0.5476756691932678, -0.09797927737236023, -0.6866808533668518, -0.06538209319114685, -0.08170069754123688, 0.2671273946762085, -0.4482898712158203, 0.6516029834747314, -0.05360768735408783, -0.5334275960922241, 0.6684409379959106, 0.2040819525718689, 0.7812983989715576, -0.8542590141296387, 0.2478625774383545, -0.12583711743354797, 0.4456821084022522, -0.24601449072360992, -0.715422511100769, 0.42165178060531616, -0.243852898478508, -0.09648226201534271, 0.03268669173121452, 0.6558127403259277, -0.2327042818069458, -0.3417879641056061, 0.7628793716430664, 0.4548088610172272, 0.023944688960909843, 0.093428835272789, -1.0251872539520264, 0.5425000190734863, -0.3117648661136627, -0.26383596658706665, 0.5043073296546936, 0.27059870958328247, -0.69371098279953, 0.37303784489631653, 0.7085185050964355, 0.26891908049583435, -0.10482712090015411, 0.6879681944847107, 1.0477479696273804, -0.5599979758262634, -0.6001566648483276, -0.5778356194496155, 0.06960933655500412, -0.06591682136058807, -0.4950932264328003, 0.4716014564037323, 0.5721927285194397, 0.9113266468048096, 0.09293796122074127, 0.4850425720214844, -0.10071878880262375, 0.3200834095478058, -0.4781290590763092, 0.5355498790740967, -0.5253365635871887, 0.23968128859996796, -0.3964809775352478, -1.0562317371368408, -0.10751989483833313, 0.2640521824359894, -0.033974193036556244, -0.28367310762405396, 1.1621965169906616, 1.007470965385437, -0.1131720244884491, 0.46003457903862, 0.22564683854579926, 0.23812106251716614, 0.09968486428260803, 0.46900317072868347, 0.6725854277610779, -0.40308040380477905, 0.1006992980837822, -0.3659454584121704, -0.4065387547016144, 0.2691187262535095, -1.0213651657104492, -0.5433856248855591, -0.9988366961479187, -0.5353854298591614, -0.4103187620639801, 0.27302998304367065, 0.5621590614318848, 0.5182691812515259, -0.902116596698761, -0.23721624910831451, -0.15962718427181244, -0.2588129937648773, -0.6594874262809753, -0.2842305600643158, 0.6665481328964233, -0.27288806438446045, -0.4925062656402588, 0.45039838552474976, 0.16989582777023315, -0.21049535274505615, -0.38708028197288513, -0.020748471841216087, -0.13091683387756348, 0.002017518738284707, 0.6947405338287354, -0.02644030749797821, -0.7268678545951843, -0.4882909059524536, -0.12495029717683792, -0.2829623818397522, -0.34215325117111206, 0.8927367925643921, -0.8634348511695862, 0.35788071155548096, 0.4686652719974518, 0.43885383009910583, 0.8943540453910828, -0.28146037459373474, 0.09128718823194504, -0.5279725193977356, 0.39456719160079956, 0.0245802141726017, 0.41984087228775024, 0.26503974199295044, -0.04813230037689209, 0.5742828249931335, 0.4875967800617218, -0.27670830488204956, -0.8500924706459045, 0.262680321931839, -1.105266809463501, -0.5703086853027344, 1.1764839887619019, -0.11785540729761124, -0.25166231393814087, -0.1408638060092926, 0.13078472018241882, 0.19909697771072388, -0.0896216630935669, 0.742689847946167, 0.7495088577270508, -0.011037766002118587, 0.1719730943441391, -0.5355290770530701, 0.4391157329082489, 0.3128226101398468, -0.7801674008369446, 0.18611463904380798, 0.42688077688217163, 0.5388665199279785, -0.00930178165435791, 0.6225128173828125, -0.40406057238578796, 0.29048895835876465, 0.03932410106062889, 0.4065510034561157, -0.06600376963615417, 0.15733972191810608, -0.03391970694065094, -0.10633861273527145, -0.11115007847547531, -0.24427232146263123 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00165v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00165v1
Individual Text Corpora Predict Openness, Interests, Knowledge and Level of Education
2024-03-29T21:44:24
2024-03-29T21:44:24
Markus J. Hofmann, Markus T. Jansen, Christoph Wigbels, Benny Briesemeister, Arthur M. Jacobs
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.LG
Here we examine whether the personality dimension of openness to experience can be predicted from the individual google search history. By web scraping, individual text corpora (ICs) were generated from 214 participants with a mean number of 5 million word tokens. We trained word2vec models and used the similarities of each IC to label words, which were derived from a lexical approach of personality. These IC-label-word similarities were utilized as predictive features in neural models. For training and validation, we relied on 179 participants and held out a test sample of 35 participants. A grid search with varying number of predictive features, hidden units and boost factor was performed. As model selection criterion, we used R2 in the validation samples penalized by the absolute R2 difference between training and validation. The selected neural model explained 35% of the openness variance in the test sample, while an ensemble model with the same architecture often provided slightly more stable predictions for intellectual interests, knowledge in humanities and level of education. Finally, a learning curve analysis suggested that around 500 training participants are required for generalizable predictions. We discuss ICs as a complement or replacement of survey-based psychodiagnostics.
[ -0.47529247403144836, -0.3548574149608612, 0.6869247555732727, -0.010658306069672108, 0.18672430515289307, -0.09430186450481415, -0.54253089427948, -0.397216260433197, 0.15147201716899872, 0.20005866885185242, -0.6826127767562866, -0.7883581519126892, -0.5828111171722412, 0.05386755242943764, -0.34413427114486694, 1.148697018623352, 0.10075129568576813, 0.07938754558563232, -0.5019593834877014, 0.023853043094277382, -0.28843528032302856, -0.693814218044281, -0.42294174432754517, -0.11824528127908707, 0.5064303874969482, 0.2793566584587097, 0.5479176640510559, 0.3499152660369873, 0.4171746075153351, 0.23005171120166779, -0.13089676201343536, -0.2477046400308609, -0.5197268128395081, -0.1279284954071045, -0.3688819408416748, -0.5977365374565125, -0.22136183083057404, 0.39709746837615967, 0.30720072984695435, 0.8314142227172852, 0.1301456242799759, 0.09390610456466675, 0.3412620723247528, 0.5347722768783569, -0.46634817123413086, 0.03178061544895172, -0.7517631649971008, 0.06723964214324951, -0.016390370205044746, -0.15496711432933807, -0.3203599154949188, -0.44977256655693054, 0.5377745628356934, -0.6339120268821716, 0.5489924550056458, -0.028337793424725533, 0.6117997169494629, 0.06324011832475662, -0.23565921187400818, -0.5651935935020447, -0.5964961647987366, 0.5949596166610718, -0.3273089528083801, 0.28190675377845764, 0.6949872374534607, 0.17741034924983978, 0.03724820539355278, -0.4359634220600128, -0.4870362877845764, -0.2651626765727997, -0.2707030177116394, 0.19762100279331207, -0.10052582621574402, -0.09441991150379181, -0.0015232764417305589, 0.30135220289230347, -0.6964230537414551, 0.3748786151409149, -0.8064712882041931, -0.20759117603302002, 0.47855448722839355, 0.2330848127603531, 0.3003486096858978, 0.06129970774054527, -0.48686328530311584, -0.2284749448299408, -0.4157901108264923, 0.3811349868774414, 0.9892845749855042, 0.30441173911094666, -0.14957639575004578, 0.6616744995117188, -0.21096399426460266, 0.21592631936073303, -0.05598590895533562, -0.11856704950332642, 0.3487677276134491, -0.297288179397583, 0.1195349246263504, 0.17168916761875153, 0.811214804649353, 0.08600457012653351, 0.6014693975448608, -0.41537678241729736, 0.05524352937936783, 0.27904728055000305, 0.5736449956893921, -0.6170317530632019, -0.33125776052474976, 0.3832320272922516, -0.7258793711662292, -0.2492419183254242, 0.3721058964729309, -0.9141998887062073, -0.19552600383758545, -0.27979907393455505, -0.10769149661064148, -0.8039411306381226, -0.20144298672676086, -0.03707198426127434, -0.07179857045412064, -0.319809228181839, 0.2742881774902344, -1.0819610357284546, 0.45575180649757385, 0.5738519430160522, 0.8505386114120483, -0.5603471994400024, -0.499328076839447, -0.14289037883281708, -0.31129276752471924, -0.3186177909374237, 0.82930588722229, -0.7574106454849243, -0.34943968057632446, 0.1785411536693573, -0.1778937578201294, -0.03932013362646103, -0.3865727484226227, 0.4683755338191986, -0.492292195558548, 0.41597434878349304, -0.1373516172170639, -0.5184595584869385, -0.09220974892377853, 0.17252562940120697, -0.6243959069252014, 0.752888560295105, 0.4362476170063019, -0.9591637253761292, 0.44121840596199036, -0.6550713181495667, 0.09997272491455078, -0.02098250202834606, -0.29850202798843384, -0.01482636108994484, 0.11441048234701157, -0.06824314594268799, 0.3984929919242859, 0.1176186203956604, 0.24422870576381683, -0.5887187123298645, -0.28793761134147644, 0.6585451364517212, -0.13607117533683777, 0.5922409296035767, 0.05253664776682854, -0.14908559620380402, 0.1879318654537201, -0.7615251541137695, 0.05722887068986893, -0.3607884347438812, -0.5724226832389832, -0.6416053175926208, 0.05972704663872719, -0.14847591519355774, 0.3772977888584137, 0.34254908561706543, -0.8128128051757812, 0.28937360644340515, -0.6015288829803467, -0.04074184224009514, 1.0799381732940674, -0.16713955998420715, 0.3871579170227051, 0.01292613334953785, 0.5760868191719055, 0.34010452032089233, -0.20153813064098358, 0.0849689245223999, -0.6224847435951233, -0.1538936197757721, -0.3402343690395355, 0.2293671816587448, 0.36415037512779236, -0.033822063356637955, 0.5433140397071838, -0.36975058913230896, -0.4152044355869293, -0.636426568031311, 0.043407730758190155, 0.4708811938762665, 0.23399244248867035, 0.33997419476509094, -0.3414449095726013, -0.5403045415878296, -1.09181809425354, -0.30766159296035767, -0.23923268914222717, -0.607244074344635, 0.45147785544395447, 0.7389559149742126, -0.11660698056221008, 1.0166325569152832, -0.7074480652809143, -0.3292197585105896, 0.32547324895858765, 0.2356971651315689, -0.010109671391546726, 0.13940389454364777, 0.36787721514701843, -0.7039549946784973, -0.30152392387390137, 0.042348574846982956, -0.832410454750061, 0.3061519265174866, 0.2491927146911621, -0.014222812838852406, 0.07564008235931396, 0.3540952205657959, -0.12381032854318619, 0.6610325574874878, 0.5032144784927368, -0.7689967155456543, 0.6480317115783691, -0.19538800418376923, -0.11409210413694382, -0.7575212121009827, 0.10715889185667038, 0.41772595047950745, 0.2785528302192688, -0.28478384017944336, -0.18399940431118011, -0.051017265766859055, 0.12033999711275101, -0.0809967964887619, 0.6042073965072632, -0.3715791702270508, -0.22592392563819885, -0.20856569707393646, 0.23472581803798676, -0.45353835821151733, 0.4996131658554077, 0.0012381597189232707, 0.9870431423187256, 0.44274061918258667, -0.6392984390258789, -0.034467749297618866, 0.5025250315666199, -0.5739020705223083, 0.31348463892936707, -0.4802219271659851, 0.21582773327827454, -0.3907771110534668, -0.006978530902415514, -1.2211227416992188, -0.37787431478500366, -0.2587674856185913, -0.8603243827819824, -0.13031403720378876, 0.479972779750824, -0.2819356918334961, -0.38579311966896057, -0.34173810482025146, 0.04266631230711937, 0.3315557539463043, -0.572928249835968, 0.3845728039741516, 0.11477204412221909, -0.18971571326255798, -0.40936633944511414, -0.571073591709137, -0.18009565770626068, -0.13295531272888184, -0.6164894104003906, 0.5011534690856934, -0.4372129738330841, -0.3949213922023773, 0.21579714119434357, 0.20169028639793396, -0.15457715094089508, 0.04675578325986862, 0.5278961062431335, 0.5271503925323486, -0.05396304279565811, 0.36768659949302673, -0.17532335221767426, 0.053552962839603424, 0.22785766422748566, -0.23837962746620178, 0.5911517143249512, -0.36896997690200806, -0.034383539110422134, -0.18477174639701843, 0.39533472061157227, 0.3282468616962433, -0.21517786383628845, 0.9627312421798706, 0.5195538401603699, -0.23858776688575745, -0.06345114856958389, -0.3629049062728882, -0.3483511209487915, -0.3610682785511017, 0.39547526836395264, -0.48130083084106445, -1.0345468521118164, 0.6955761909484863, 0.16088923811912537, -0.3161354959011078, 0.5502314567565918, 0.678064227104187, 0.027357980608940125, 0.8645537495613098, 0.9138175249099731, -0.014259793795645237, 0.12734809517860413, -0.09482114017009735, 0.15531553328037262, -1.0214377641677856, -0.4908333122730255, -0.5299426317214966, -0.28858625888824463, -1.088773250579834, 0.03357089310884476, 0.5028237104415894, -0.14743532240390778, -0.3991265892982483, -0.02193431183695793, -0.739511251449585, 0.22157339751720428, 0.6995276212692261, 0.25547292828559875, 0.20714527368545532, 0.21512176096439362, -0.34584492444992065, -0.23601920902729034, -0.07455532252788544, -0.6221709251403809, 1.456785798072815, 0.3537713885307312, 0.47885987162590027, 0.15155109763145447, 0.3971349000930786, 0.11702436953783035, 0.34110361337661743, -0.6747585535049438, 0.33226972818374634, -0.281912624835968, -0.8572956323623657, -0.37786662578582764, -0.1610994040966034, -0.7926006317138672, -0.129959836602211, -0.24474388360977173, -1.3837579488754272, 0.2231578826904297, -0.15554137527942657, -0.3658827245235443, 0.22549811005592346, -0.4432362914085388, 0.5124915242195129, -0.04836905375123024, -0.2237975150346756, -0.11952444911003113, -0.7543054819107056, 0.44763270020484924, -0.2747404873371124, 0.05198176950216293, 0.05430614948272705, -0.2824225127696991, 0.7209782600402832, 0.023908639326691628, 0.8391225934028625, 0.16495776176452637, 0.28494080901145935, 0.10772164911031723, -0.03538170084357262, 0.2523307800292969, -0.17477598786354065, -0.2579666078090668, 0.12162121385335922, -0.1647958606481552, -0.10793103277683258, -0.45285412669181824, 0.8209356665611267, -1.255969762802124, -0.2670113742351532, -0.4582902789115906, -0.3304367661476135, -0.37630459666252136, -0.009560744278132915, 0.6439954042434692, 0.22316260635852814, -0.4621894359588623, 0.4165831208229065, 0.8815736770629883, -0.3220681846141815, 0.2620103061199188, 0.27193352580070496, -0.07473068684339523, -0.3740454912185669, 0.5838282704353333, -0.023538094013929367, 0.12866497039794922, 0.3018600642681122, 0.3990950286388397, -0.1895987093448639, -0.43491223454475403, 0.03282549977302551, 0.20361216366291046, -0.5445114374160767, 0.13635319471359253, -0.9311226606369019, -0.08859171718358994, -0.6929975748062134, -0.17204178869724274, -0.14551186561584473, 0.008365689776837826, -0.6250002980232239, -0.2889308035373688, 0.24851104617118835, 0.8584488034248352, 0.0303371399641037, 0.2013561874628067, -0.2957383394241333, 0.15363214910030365, 0.2155635505914688, 0.6440461277961731, 0.13989312946796417, -0.4440136253833771, -0.13291311264038086, -0.13397593796253204, -0.44247910380363464, -0.909683346748352, 0.5450146794319153, 0.05228516459465027, 0.5426690578460693, 0.7635713815689087, -0.1884022206068039, 0.14457263052463531, -0.2766990065574646, 0.8664005994796753, 0.38639533519744873, -0.5272573232650757, 0.48740291595458984, -0.4878283441066742, 0.009674958884716034, 0.8463069796562195, 1.0547940731048584, -0.3335597515106201, -0.2516148090362549, -0.6847950220108032, -0.5967839360237122, 0.68079674243927, 0.05458599701523781, 0.05660353600978851, -0.18053197860717773, 0.3539884686470032, 0.4989219009876251, 0.20937557518482208, -0.6868222951889038, -0.244477778673172, -0.31967735290527344, -0.32157668471336365, -0.056937359273433685, -0.22894683480262756, 0.015626363456249237, -0.2828747034072876, 0.6289334297180176, -0.37970051169395447, 0.5387251377105713, 0.29494932293891907, 0.6029328107833862, 0.0279396940022707, 0.3561912477016449, 0.4267342984676361, 0.7504289746284485, -0.4765295088291168, -0.04801206663250923, -0.10074044018983841, -0.6724044680595398, 0.005303340032696724, -0.10567519068717957, 0.039232414215803146, -0.06346433609724045, 0.10021904110908508, 0.7365761399269104, 0.07740247994661331, -0.7798839211463928, 0.7538284659385681, -0.024134770035743713, -0.24074901640415192, -0.8560227751731873, 0.05841097608208656, 0.25481274724006653, 0.0211945828050375, 0.3416934907436371, -0.0431654267013073, 0.23477521538734436, -0.9072144627571106, -0.06896853446960449, 0.32155463099479675, -0.6675001382827759, -0.5544041991233826, 0.7090659141540527, -0.22387810051441193, -0.2664712965488434, 0.8583186268806458, -0.30163300037384033, -0.2966456413269043, 0.5695369243621826, 0.47460225224494934, 0.961000382900238, -0.1490054875612259, 0.1253063976764679, 0.7636640667915344, 0.1454375833272934, -0.06620382517576218, 0.03833848983049393, 0.32800158858299255, -0.7980397939682007, -0.006022199522703886, -0.8882045149803162, -0.27077963948249817, 0.45156124234199524, -0.7662707567214966, 0.364185094833374, -0.3801031708717346, 0.053802214562892914, 0.12319598346948624, -0.005169730633497238, -1.08049476146698, 0.5625700950622559, 0.14606735110282898, 0.8985373377799988, -0.7664575576782227, 0.6506218314170837, 0.77254319190979, -0.5467764139175415, -0.7899790406227112, 0.11332815885543823, 0.14428937435150146, -0.5395205616950989, 0.8366978764533997, 0.2741107940673828, 0.1972969025373459, -0.4706561863422394, -0.5625534653663635, -1.0336856842041016, 1.0394372940063477, -0.07208887487649918, -0.40284445881843567, -0.580258309841156, -0.1040101870894432, 0.7791013121604919, -0.8361746072769165, 0.4414733350276947, 0.3724500238895416, 0.25657889246940613, -0.10172819346189499, -0.6873098015785217, -0.15440092980861664, -0.2726570963859558, 0.1110391765832901, -0.09268331527709961, -0.38909876346588135, 1.0906497240066528, -0.30719077587127686, -0.09287834912538528, 0.15881548821926117, 0.8117079734802246, 0.2595788538455963, 0.3327462375164032, 0.427325576543808, 0.4248315989971161, 0.9463378190994263, 0.19939307868480682, 1.1078696250915527, -0.39144060015678406, 0.20537340641021729, 1.1922703981399536, 0.0030187692027539015, 0.9569786190986633, 0.1548430621623993, -0.3150745630264282, 0.9667595624923706, 0.6899951100349426, -0.11917246133089066, 0.6766709089279175, 0.1961965411901474, -0.2604365348815918, 0.08183149993419647, 0.0461999885737896, -0.1530095785856247, 0.8697453141212463, 0.3586893379688263, -0.8409318923950195, 0.03953729197382927, 0.2368854135274887, 0.12260045856237411, 0.3643782436847687, -0.22672037780284882, 0.7460944652557373, -0.22848454117774963, -1.0546592473983765, 0.006916186772286892, -0.10987158864736557, 1.035820722579956, -0.5910184383392334, 0.2280627340078354, 0.08235643804073334, 0.17635752260684967, -0.33013227581977844, -0.9376571178436279, 0.22523528337478638, 0.05059041455388069, -0.5245832800865173, -0.04756106808781624, 0.8304623365402222, -0.2557045817375183, -0.3204840421676636, 0.45333266258239746, 0.5869737863540649, 0.5254835486412048, -0.3572011888027191, -0.05086033046245575, -0.44582828879356384, 0.15905329585075378, -0.2827867865562439, 0.7228294014930725, 0.4272627830505371, 0.08798617124557495, 0.48915278911590576, 0.5597700476646423, 0.22141093015670776, -0.10383104532957077, -0.34141507744789124, 0.9136055111885071, -0.6764135956764221, -0.7186988592147827, -0.6063259840011597, 0.31293803453445435, -0.1069401279091835, -0.8884933590888977, 0.4758110046386719, 0.7155458927154541, 1.0243322849273682, -0.16579070687294006, 1.1262494325637817, 0.24509093165397644, 0.7302358150482178, -0.2277422845363617, 0.5782859921455383, -0.3470924496650696, -0.07330020517110825, -0.06872673332691193, -0.7148945927619934, 0.41178590059280396, 0.32382407784461975, -0.622554361820221, 0.12206753343343735, 0.966640055179596, 0.5032961964607239, -0.05165651813149452, 0.22337941825389862, 0.3046989440917969, 0.19925345480442047, -0.03629237040877342, 0.4506557285785675, 0.3409773111343384, 0.021665304899215698, 0.48222553730010986, -0.331515908241272, -0.5032039880752563, -0.12876789271831512, -0.46404293179512024, -1.0044069290161133, -0.9167879819869995, -0.07465355843305588, -0.5310929417610168, -0.10018204897642136, 0.7124961018562317, 0.36338576674461365, -0.4916979968547821, -0.03699205070734024, -0.04702227562665939, -0.3074832260608673, -0.12264510244131088, -0.3047463297843933, 0.3967595398426056, -0.23484136164188385, -0.5638633966445923, 0.16252537071704865, 0.0724853053689003, -0.13429933786392212, -0.7351056933403015, 0.2703656852245331, -0.13241486251354218, 0.062249865382909775, 0.4276752471923828, 0.10037924349308014, -0.7629454135894775, -0.5018957257270813, 0.34002670645713806, -0.2616625726222992, 0.2658509612083435, 0.7323033213615417, -1.0760141611099243, 0.4772515892982483, 0.31779348850250244, 0.24800024926662445, 0.36314621567726135, 0.08433186262845993, 0.28492870926856995, -0.608248770236969, -0.1318056434392929, 0.38625264167785645, 0.2221214920282364, 0.36254799365997314, -0.8071850538253784, 0.6344082355499268, 0.05791931599378586, -0.5152420401573181, -0.4356628656387329, 0.07732460647821426, -0.9401983618736267, -0.4670277237892151, 1.3134738206863403, -0.3485806882381439, -0.3905735909938812, -0.0619480162858963, 0.10377522557973862, 0.06785248965024948, -0.5444301962852478, 1.0403529405593872, 0.9620539546012878, -0.267577201128006, 0.38918450474739075, -0.752690851688385, 0.3640539348125458, 0.0196481104940176, -0.7774133086204529, -0.1651206612586975, 0.36084920167922974, 0.4441324770450592, 0.5035434365272522, 0.6052486896514893, -0.1976039856672287, 0.10238896310329437, 0.23184771835803986, 0.3483651578426361, 0.09475063532590866, -0.43807220458984375, -0.14772860705852509, 0.5126802921295166, -0.19074875116348267, -0.07187545299530029 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01331v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01331v2
LLaVA-Gemma: Accelerating Multimodal Foundation Models with a Compact Language Model
2024-03-29T21:32:50
2024-06-10T20:59:48
Musashi Hinck, Matthew L. Olson, David Cobbley, Shao-Yen Tseng, Vasudev Lal
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI
We train a suite of multimodal foundation models (MMFM) using the popular LLaVA framework with the recently released Gemma family of large language models (LLMs). Of particular interest is the 2B parameter Gemma model, which provides opportunities to construct capable small-scale MMFMs. In line with findings from other papers in this space, we test the effect of ablating three design features: pretraining the connector, utilizing a more powerful image backbone, and increasing the size of the language backbone. The resulting models, which we call LLaVA-Gemma, exhibit moderate performance on an array of evaluations, but fail to improve past the current comparably sized SOTA models. Closer analysis of performance shows mixed effects; skipping pretraining tends to reduce performance, larger vision models sometimes improve performance, and increasing language model size has inconsistent effects. We publicly release training recipes, code and weights for our models for the LLaVA-Gemma models.
[ -0.30568939447402954, -0.7855543494224548, 0.3246849477291107, 0.8073565363883972, -0.4044654071331024, -0.09479571133852005, -0.07553162425756454, -0.7643974423408508, 0.39695289731025696, 0.3890409767627716, -0.38592997193336487, -0.022489722818136215, -0.9393942356109619, 0.09675545245409012, -0.4730825126171112, 0.4222753942012787, -0.14975319802761078, 0.4130571186542511, -0.30192941427230835, -0.17667274177074432, -0.5822556018829346, -0.1881372481584549, -0.5666057467460632, -0.3920052647590637, 0.54476398229599, 0.5462222099304199, 0.7664370536804199, 0.5138086080551147, 0.6510970592498779, 0.2211398333311081, -0.18983674049377441, 0.2010345458984375, -0.5626528859138489, 0.0010693430667743087, 0.16855917870998383, -0.45464572310447693, -0.730014443397522, -0.10854189097881317, 0.7848798632621765, 0.7457119822502136, 0.07234460115432739, 0.29953891038894653, 0.0524691678583622, 0.5765228867530823, -0.8224390745162964, 0.29512158036231995, -0.3089410066604614, -0.05964727699756622, -0.3360808491706848, -0.2897993326187134, -0.6264482140541077, 0.08237574994564056, -0.2448241263628006, -0.2735227644443512, -0.05421433225274086, 0.052494484931230545, 0.8333970308303833, 0.2931869924068451, -0.7234531044960022, -0.2558456063270569, -0.5952709913253784, 0.7011271715164185, -0.19380247592926025, 0.7388160228729248, 0.39135515689849854, 0.4443361759185791, -0.17380651831626892, -0.8948894143104553, -0.33885493874549866, -0.29165565967559814, 0.026748914271593094, -0.028967617079615593, -0.03237944841384888, 0.16560347378253937, -0.04605830833315849, 0.5521494746208191, -0.4303891062736511, 0.1098136454820633, -0.42593446373939514, -0.07585647702217102, 0.5176992416381836, 0.3546537756919861, -0.05710894614458084, 0.27151986956596375, -0.5405628085136414, -0.17403024435043335, -1.2435659170150757, 0.03538110852241516, 0.2934202551841736, 0.27269813418388367, -0.3784020245075226, 0.8804265856742859, -0.29263779520988464, 0.8389297127723694, 0.22394369542598724, -0.6494837403297424, 0.20471522212028503, -0.4512571692466736, -0.38993945717811584, -0.2572546601295471, 0.5382593870162964, 0.21874427795410156, 0.06457597017288208, 0.028619010001420975, -0.17625021934509277, 0.3206683397293091, -0.017387794330716133, -1.3056608438491821, -0.1808292418718338, 0.11323949694633484, -0.5159192085266113, -0.23753730952739716, -0.5529903769493103, -0.6621151566505432, -0.3947310149669647, -0.10227295011281967, 0.510978102684021, -0.08783674240112305, -0.40720468759536743, 0.4653078019618988, 0.18122908473014832, 0.3999931812286377, 0.3969210088253021, -1.3334754705429077, 0.28769031167030334, 0.11520741134881973, 0.6015990376472473, -0.00035255163675174117, -0.36713117361068726, -0.4978477656841278, 0.006025059148669243, -0.46223947405815125, 0.9425795674324036, -0.731109619140625, -0.6434909701347351, -0.15813902020454407, -0.05151047185063362, -0.10426262021064758, -0.43030819296836853, 0.29557543992996216, -0.4714161157608032, -0.1497262865304947, -0.15930098295211792, -0.1722220778465271, -0.004533582832664251, 0.21550528705120087, -0.682458221912384, 0.9702305197715759, 0.16546723246574402, -0.5990391969680786, 0.3154398500919342, -0.4446476995944977, -0.4350292980670929, -0.2956843376159668, -0.35387131571769714, -0.3767145872116089, 0.228182852268219, 0.2828953266143799, 0.5480673909187317, -0.7271334528923035, 0.26739245653152466, -0.34348970651626587, -0.42905277013778687, -0.045334286987781525, -0.3617667853832245, 0.8181678056716919, 0.2779123783111572, -0.22817842662334442, 0.1074337363243103, -0.9128270149230957, -0.3493187427520752, 0.2904624342918396, -0.5530101656913757, 0.15292002260684967, -0.23984697461128235, 0.12656620144844055, 0.22926151752471924, 0.34747228026390076, -0.3018583357334137, 0.11656446009874344, 0.03156145662069321, 0.04368787258863449, 0.5420452356338501, -0.3025524318218231, 0.49824315309524536, -0.3269069492816925, 0.6974866390228271, 0.11387382447719574, 0.3697723150253296, -0.3371483385562897, -0.8174172639846802, -0.852279782295227, -0.6536513566970825, 0.37664270401000977, 0.10676679760217667, -0.687881350517273, -0.22315482795238495, -0.2635195255279541, -0.5296042561531067, -0.4100169837474823, 0.43905824422836304, 0.625900387763977, 0.13120487332344055, 0.27581846714019775, -0.7657279372215271, -0.5629900097846985, -0.9632083177566528, 0.11403366178274155, -0.36029672622680664, 0.14396493136882782, 0.3489135801792145, 0.44512516260147095, -0.4613708555698395, 0.858325183391571, -0.2987746000289917, -0.3591442406177521, -0.4192275404930115, -0.046129316091537476, -0.044103968888521194, 0.3027206063270569, 0.9868004322052002, -0.888032853603363, -0.28889185190200806, -0.24676156044006348, -0.6615861058235168, -0.05046137794852257, 0.17544667422771454, 0.16301372647285461, -0.0588819719851017, 0.3155718743801117, -0.8613811731338501, 0.3672352433204651, 1.0982403755187988, -0.4080999195575714, 0.8773874044418335, 0.158452108502388, 0.10545196384191513, -1.039246678352356, -0.23036326467990875, -0.25202295184135437, -0.20028987526893616, -0.4956035912036896, 0.5805248618125916, 0.24598069489002228, -0.1286020278930664, -0.880895733833313, 0.7630202770233154, -0.6974990367889404, -0.4151957631111145, -0.18174196779727936, 0.17502819001674652, 0.3519245982170105, 0.4647192358970642, -0.054371125996112823, 1.0533201694488525, 0.7446229457855225, -0.6104715466499329, 0.2806706130504608, 0.315365195274353, -0.28616735339164734, 0.3890872001647949, -0.6843180656433105, -0.04249069467186928, -0.06518319249153137, 0.19105923175811768, -1.2466171979904175, -0.5002949237823486, -0.08488558977842331, -0.3163553774356842, 0.5806546807289124, -0.16323356330394745, -0.6502567529678345, -0.11007339507341385, -0.38373780250549316, 0.7122494578361511, 0.20568083226680756, -0.8223341703414917, 1.0540765523910522, 0.4346112012863159, 0.045907191932201385, -0.6133278012275696, -0.8285351991653442, 0.09191631525754929, -0.23564855754375458, -1.101400375366211, 0.3960433602333069, -0.14306947588920593, -0.29831570386886597, -0.23528707027435303, 0.08107279986143112, -0.3260766565799713, 0.3234814405441284, 0.35357144474983215, 0.030583467334508896, -0.4522232115268707, 0.12710626423358917, -0.016252130270004272, 0.06371022015810013, -0.026188166812062263, 0.08997826278209686, 0.644843339920044, -0.38324517011642456, -0.2581959366798401, -0.24745169281959534, 0.10494261234998703, 0.5122081637382507, -0.3402436673641205, 0.9577463865280151, 0.5336929559707642, -0.15957948565483093, 0.2578190565109253, -0.44696786999702454, 0.013976482674479485, -0.4932132661342621, 0.3464416563510895, -0.7360970377922058, -1.0526918172836304, 0.36847397685050964, -0.33019185066223145, 0.043580181896686554, 0.21951572597026825, 0.9158002138137817, 0.17577619850635529, 0.8730100393295288, 1.0509523153305054, 0.2299458086490631, 0.5611695051193237, -0.28560295701026917, -0.005011416971683502, -0.8230940699577332, -0.2157430350780487, -0.45518195629119873, -0.009877712465822697, -0.3605116307735443, -0.6683739423751831, 0.07780595123767853, 0.3638978898525238, 0.15093286335468292, 0.4231540858745575, 0.203027606010437, 0.3655349314212799, -0.03503980115056038, -0.04568113759160042, 0.34285011887550354, -0.05196903273463249, -0.3576403856277466, 0.3027069568634033, -0.6991274952888489, -0.3874339759349823, 1.4111195802688599, 0.47653332352638245, 1.1458662748336792, 0.5962446928024292, 0.334833025932312, -0.05289728567004204, 0.5020514726638794, -0.7437134981155396, 0.508964478969574, -0.10230640321969986, -0.8152139782905579, -0.021524421870708466, -0.16654862463474274, -0.8338595628738403, 0.501725971698761, -0.5007439851760864, -0.5474141836166382, 0.3660963177680969, 0.33338338136672974, -0.1191578060388565, -0.034499697387218475, -0.8529244661331177, 0.758657693862915, -0.0967985987663269, -0.6285631656646729, -0.36951982975006104, -0.40222832560539246, 0.7492387294769287, -0.2845563292503357, 0.11739892512559891, -0.10348787158727646, 0.15991704165935516, 0.27694037556648254, -0.006480358075350523, 0.9504907131195068, -0.009227513335645199, -0.16845570504665375, 0.30982914566993713, 0.15387386083602905, 0.478514701128006, 0.13180671632289886, 0.08201897144317627, 0.11677047610282898, -0.36664196848869324, -0.6536489725112915, -0.40581709146499634, 0.4597375690937042, -0.7340031266212463, -0.7803753018379211, 0.1172741949558258, -0.5455594062805176, -0.41858968138694763, 0.10511444509029388, 0.08632373809814453, 0.856108546257019, -0.15429165959358215, 0.6123680472373962, 0.5558685660362244, 0.13578388094902039, 0.4702700078487396, 0.304800420999527, -0.744698703289032, -0.21671032905578613, 0.40543389320373535, -0.14198645949363708, 0.5159914493560791, 0.37462738156318665, -0.025685332715511322, -0.35280126333236694, -0.8024004697799683, -0.7190645933151245, 0.26160454750061035, -0.8090118765830994, -0.04001876711845398, -0.5365318655967712, 0.026406805962324142, -0.4323463439941406, 0.0791269913315773, -0.6871558427810669, -0.7179862856864929, -0.2894674837589264, -0.040239155292510986, 0.05604559928178787, 0.8720159530639648, 0.3115782141685486, 0.7262430787086487, -0.6352499723434448, 0.27672070264816284, 0.49722811579704285, 0.35084301233291626, -0.2094660848379135, -0.6091555953025818, -0.48633211851119995, -0.1885552555322647, -0.6437734365463257, -0.5742855668067932, 0.0480581633746624, 0.3985670208930969, 0.3532409965991974, 0.6315509080886841, -0.4161347448825836, 1.0047684907913208, -0.46323123574256897, 0.8736459016799927, 0.4164028465747833, -0.5446984171867371, 0.26535525918006897, -0.2648177146911621, 0.22943294048309326, 0.3925287127494812, 0.4114198386669159, 0.2916746139526367, -0.31240683794021606, -0.3385603427886963, -0.5029110908508301, 0.06652694195508957, 0.27336156368255615, 0.199181467294693, -0.20353443920612335, 0.1865377277135849, 0.06666099280118942, 0.13889703154563904, -0.832234799861908, -0.21802297234535217, -0.18681788444519043, -0.08089026063680649, -0.191571444272995, -0.8549257516860962, -0.03872472420334816, -0.005466626025736332, 0.4702211320400238, -0.36529242992401123, 0.3142499625682831, -0.020596811547875404, -0.477217435836792, -0.19066068530082703, -0.05131009966135025, 0.8666377663612366, 0.8945611715316772, -0.1263725459575653, 0.16818784177303314, 0.14435766637325287, -0.6948639750480652, 0.23421676456928253, -0.12227896600961685, 0.20026962459087372, -0.14021220803260803, 0.5609183311462402, 0.8101828098297119, 0.5236185789108276, -0.6948432326316833, 0.7511926889419556, -0.4325411319732666, -0.25714200735092163, -0.3612731695175171, 0.11382579058408737, 0.328180730342865, 0.38621899485588074, 0.10830169916152954, 0.1298333704471588, 0.03159452974796295, -0.5707082748413086, 0.030836235731840134, 0.37511125206947327, -0.21382732689380646, -0.4593198597431183, 0.7771672606468201, 0.28183528780937195, -0.07810769230127335, 0.29713472723960876, 0.07374296337366104, 0.13304045796394348, 0.4518529176712036, 0.8734776377677917, 0.6131279468536377, -0.33224743604660034, -0.06347787380218506, 0.053405869752168655, 0.3241690993309021, -0.15852442383766174, 0.19086961448192596, -0.17387107014656067, -0.8612256050109863, -0.6673830151557922, -0.9707443714141846, -0.30927515029907227, -0.13473644852638245, -0.5685825943946838, 0.45251962542533875, -0.5249476432800293, -0.2947799861431122, -0.1807275265455246, 0.12181168049573898, -0.641003429889679, 0.39648252725601196, -0.06953932344913483, 1.3083224296569824, -1.0070217847824097, 1.2448649406433105, 0.6956918835639954, -0.4142802655696869, -0.79769366979599, -0.1905881017446518, 0.06784526258707047, -0.8476923704147339, 0.8691264986991882, 0.42609840631484985, -0.5299577713012695, -0.04366239532828331, -0.18332462012767792, -1.1030080318450928, 1.4749984741210938, 0.6402701735496521, -0.47255468368530273, 0.06434313207864761, 0.17239534854888916, 0.4027750492095947, -0.8455809354782104, 0.25539782643318176, 0.5023729205131531, 0.12040978670120239, 0.3116574287414551, -0.9431478381156921, -0.2296636551618576, -0.3188604712486267, 0.13441519439220428, 0.06057470664381981, -0.9691764116287231, 1.0890382528305054, -0.24884675443172455, -0.19346383213996887, 0.4338337481021881, 0.6750657558441162, 0.548544704914093, -0.012800188735127449, 0.5427344441413879, 0.6988957524299622, 0.4641602039337158, 0.08330488950014114, 1.316278100013733, -0.4380227327346802, 0.29305723309516907, 0.9306745529174805, -0.3106766939163208, 0.8698806166648865, 0.6531901359558105, -0.13698601722717285, 0.42512568831443787, 0.776884913444519, 0.44023653864860535, 0.6274476051330566, -0.2346791923046112, -0.25236573815345764, -0.26955753564834595, -0.28435155749320984, -0.4160887598991394, 0.7724570035934448, 0.3755153715610504, -0.3100104331970215, -0.10098812729120255, -0.054668206721544266, -0.019717056304216385, -0.16359692811965942, -0.36172401905059814, 0.2670985162258148, 0.2226766049861908, -0.20955690741539001, 0.757925271987915, 0.09949345141649246, 0.3538488447666168, -0.54758220911026, 0.0029980053659528494, -0.5654100775718689, 0.03970390558242798, -0.0578332357108593, -0.38858914375305176, 0.3456094563007355, -0.20721527934074402, -0.06774383038282394, -0.14484168589115143, 0.7214859127998352, -0.21481792628765106, -0.4026324152946472, 0.7532986998558044, 0.3490716516971588, 0.17649833858013153, 0.2785274088382721, -0.4454610347747803, 0.30497053265571594, -0.2800220251083374, -0.33012717962265015, 0.5117641687393188, 0.17991697788238525, -0.16421093046665192, 0.8719744682312012, 0.6169849634170532, -0.028451846912503242, 0.24603183567523956, 0.26616498827934265, 1.1689953804016113, -0.3921666145324707, -0.3242534101009369, -0.7964295148849487, 0.48967593908309937, 0.32127368450164795, -0.3414868116378784, 0.5964298844337463, 0.4752459228038788, 0.6187304854393005, -0.07531466335058212, -0.02206738106906414, 0.09243740886449814, -0.13316582143306732, -0.8905075192451477, 0.35841813683509827, -0.8567179441452026, 0.43636640906333923, -0.1608767956495285, -1.135577917098999, -0.5346563458442688, 0.2894963026046753, 0.06910774856805801, 0.06388434022665024, 0.7928835153579712, 1.002610683441162, -0.11425884068012238, -0.046297550201416016, 0.6630576252937317, 0.35995396971702576, 0.32786381244659424, 0.4596010148525238, 0.8389438390731812, -0.44189712405204773, 0.5475624799728394, -0.07076245546340942, -0.307899534702301, -0.5303640961647034, -0.8865436315536499, -1.233284831047058, -0.36830201745033264, 0.06898408383131027, -0.06841390579938889, 0.05237346142530441, 0.6238394975662231, 0.9152119755744934, -0.40050581097602844, -0.33549270033836365, 0.12602192163467407, -0.09663017839193344, 0.03404466435313225, -0.09949464350938797, 0.18911951780319214, -0.2401488572359085, -0.515791118144989, 0.7101949453353882, 0.4359636604785919, 0.1906687170267105, -0.5458978414535522, -0.2515254020690918, -0.2637464106082916, 0.1704171597957611, 0.8418789505958557, 0.012399278581142426, -0.6768600344657898, -0.32495930790901184, -0.11616217344999313, -0.12287130206823349, 0.18586190044879913, 0.6051256656646729, -0.719577431678772, 0.3053484857082367, 0.14880862832069397, 0.7248548269271851, 0.8497462272644043, -0.21086013317108154, 0.42774611711502075, -0.9197589755058289, 0.7944610714912415, -0.328422874212265, 0.7999387979507446, 0.407373309135437, -0.16252250969409943, 0.6228541135787964, 0.1562139093875885, -0.3254794478416443, -0.7189139127731323, 0.5785146951675415, -0.8407553434371948, -0.08938881754875183, 0.9811908006668091, -0.2116217464208603, -0.45292729139328003, 0.044021233916282654, 0.031651560217142105, -0.20503312349319458, 0.15295252203941345, 0.716453492641449, 0.5688672065734863, -0.10022146254777908, -0.34922128915786743, -0.567354142665863, 0.2079392522573471, 0.40458157658576965, -0.5430605411529541, -0.20939858257770538, 0.37173882126808167, 0.41528934240341187, 0.2584531903266907, 1.0341027975082397, -0.4627455174922943, 0.5712026357650757, 0.4367493987083435, 0.01284805592149496, -0.17726103961467743, -1.0373026132583618, -0.43980786204338074, 0.2008056491613388, 0.6435591578483582, 0.04678214713931084 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00152v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00152v2
On-the-fly Definition Augmentation of LLMs for Biomedical NER
2024-03-29T20:59:27
2024-04-23T17:43:31
Monica Munnangi, Sergey Feldman, Byron C Wallace, Silvio Amir, Tom Hope, Aakanksha Naik
cs.CL
cs.CL
Despite their general capabilities, LLMs still struggle on biomedical NER tasks, which are difficult due to the presence of specialized terminology and lack of training data. In this work we set out to improve LLM performance on biomedical NER in limited data settings via a new knowledge augmentation approach which incorporates definitions of relevant concepts on-the-fly. During this process, to provide a test bed for knowledge augmentation, we perform a comprehensive exploration of prompting strategies. Our experiments show that definition augmentation is useful for both open source and closed LLMs. For example, it leads to a relative improvement of 15\% (on average) in GPT-4 performance (F1) across all (six) of our test datasets. We conduct extensive ablations and analyses to demonstrate that our performance improvements stem from adding relevant definitional knowledge. We find that careful prompting strategies also improve LLM performance, allowing them to outperform fine-tuned language models in few-shot settings. To facilitate future research in this direction, we release our code at https://github.com/allenai/beacon.
[ -0.26106083393096924, -0.842758059501648, 0.5243915915489197, 0.000013127384590916336, -0.22170595824718475, 0.22113090753555298, -0.21599377691745758, -0.6932811737060547, 0.2784160077571869, 0.14260300993919373, -0.5251472592353821, -0.38095635175704956, -0.520951509475708, 0.6018401980400085, -0.19326095283031464, 1.063683032989502, 0.045305900275707245, 0.20626609027385712, -0.5363534092903137, -0.10317634791135788, -0.30892547965049744, -0.16004377603530884, -0.6584038734436035, -0.5375921726226807, 0.7903659343719482, 0.3300897181034088, 0.4226045608520508, 0.8499388694763184, 0.7852067351341248, 0.23031842708587646, -0.4955379068851471, 0.4535246193408966, -0.40665483474731445, 0.10814559459686279, -0.20358385145664215, -0.3333786725997925, -0.6256440281867981, -0.3774547278881073, 0.5849827527999878, 0.8184481859207153, 0.011185734532773495, 0.003666053293272853, 0.0759781152009964, 0.6345816850662231, -0.6131139397621155, -0.05045866593718529, -0.49941450357437134, -0.051153846085071564, -0.06009799987077713, -0.459762305021286, -0.15408508479595184, -0.42499667406082153, 0.2923949658870697, -0.8138651251792908, 0.25594326853752136, -0.2545211911201477, 0.7647863626480103, 0.5251138806343079, -0.30225566029548645, -0.3216479420661926, -0.440069317817688, 0.309782475233078, -0.6415772438049316, 0.4775484502315521, 0.2547331154346466, 0.11793393641710281, -0.16631774604320526, -0.9039697647094727, -0.47861090302467346, -0.35136470198631287, -0.30206942558288574, 0.13428166508674622, -0.10856595635414124, 0.3983299434185028, 0.4573749899864197, 0.16241855919361115, -0.3328138291835785, 0.16247129440307617, -0.5833746194839478, -0.31258052587509155, 0.3301357924938202, 0.1925242394208908, -0.049285415560007095, -0.04181927442550659, -0.2945803999900818, 0.052813366055488586, -0.8006812334060669, -0.12124501168727875, -0.11684564501047134, 0.16892467439174652, -0.18052056431770325, 0.7969971895217896, -0.45603829622268677, 0.7964755892753601, 0.441878080368042, 0.16633760929107666, 0.6565770506858826, -0.6829333901405334, -0.027807142585515976, 0.008681997656822205, 0.4646271765232086, 0.25920799374580383, -0.2958906590938568, -0.12457575649023056, -0.2940187156200409, -0.1369224488735199, 0.186086505651474, -1.0137580633163452, -0.06588687747716904, 0.0973488837480545, -0.08102837204933167, -0.3436755836009979, -0.3985435962677002, -0.6506149768829346, -0.6823132634162903, -0.3044638931751251, 0.7984936833381653, -0.7706385850906372, 0.05544237419962883, 0.2174365073442459, -0.2933095693588257, 0.5382459759712219, 0.37149685621261597, -0.6215818524360657, -0.0017385226674377918, 0.49320605397224426, 0.9701948761940002, 0.024321118369698524, 0.09535498172044754, -0.7198452353477478, 0.20606909692287445, -0.23082593083381653, 0.7921158075332642, -0.3837616443634033, -0.5835148096084595, -0.37310007214546204, -0.24674606323242188, -0.013880249112844467, -0.47769030928611755, 0.19471760094165802, -0.5870359539985657, 0.14909355342388153, -0.13717958331108093, -0.8166791200637817, -0.032670095562934875, 0.259472131729126, -0.38654565811157227, 0.8512689471244812, 0.19040793180465698, -0.695393979549408, 0.4427502155303955, -1.2309666872024536, -0.6633426547050476, 0.4491417706012726, -0.3843177556991577, -0.11285136640071869, 0.30224698781967163, 0.43234896659851074, 0.5142873525619507, 0.09580958634614944, 0.09187673777341843, -0.014024555683135986, -0.36416277289390564, 0.408930242061615, 0.0012025253381580114, 0.5110943913459778, -0.07644058763980865, -0.29990723729133606, 0.1578037291765213, -0.8538114428520203, 0.20603960752487183, -0.36471980810165405, -0.44289934635162354, -0.09724835306406021, -0.18563085794448853, -0.43394607305526733, -0.14641764760017395, 0.336641401052475, -0.4865657091140747, 0.17145448923110962, -1.0010565519332886, 0.24787549674510956, 0.6874908804893494, 0.28088709712028503, 0.4596503973007202, -0.4808531701564789, 0.4611896574497223, -0.25732019543647766, 0.14596125483512878, -0.14465102553367615, -0.497273325920105, -0.7681494951248169, -0.49715176224708557, 0.3671668469905853, 0.6515786051750183, -0.8378288149833679, 0.45899727940559387, -0.22055280208587646, -0.5143937468528748, -0.7686557769775391, 0.14906518161296844, 0.4276571571826935, 0.8970698118209839, 0.7512832283973694, -0.009045129641890526, -0.680638313293457, -0.7473466396331787, 0.13728170096874237, -0.040129367262125015, -0.2746824026107788, 0.31403258442878723, 0.3919133245944977, -0.7686145305633545, 0.9822469353675842, -0.36609458923339844, -0.13636481761932373, -0.16194167733192444, -0.008342262357473373, 0.3835645020008087, 0.30554521083831787, -0.014124397188425064, -0.45209723711013794, -0.19765786826610565, 0.2677675783634186, -0.7198339104652405, -0.3822760283946991, 0.053953975439071655, 0.09197484701871872, 0.035451218485832214, 0.7212773561477661, -0.4347786605358124, 0.498457670211792, 0.2573665380477905, -0.2068442851305008, 0.573136568069458, -0.590661883354187, 0.09154454618692398, -1.122314214706421, 0.22117923200130463, -0.2507037818431854, -0.011045310646295547, -0.7409613132476807, 0.11573943495750427, 0.18456043303012848, 0.3469625413417816, -0.6663945317268372, 0.7375928163528442, -0.48613396286964417, 0.29847076535224915, -0.47128793597221375, 0.10360875725746155, 0.14555567502975464, -0.2259419560432434, -0.07855742424726486, 0.8649091720581055, 0.8791631460189819, -1.0268980264663696, 0.2958467900753021, 0.6295483708381653, -0.20955587923526764, 0.3394998013973236, -0.9002670645713806, 0.09045179188251495, -0.29936766624450684, 0.17039038240909576, -0.7397003769874573, -0.48082447052001953, 0.151947021484375, -0.6327252984046936, 0.3697172999382019, 0.10607212781906128, -0.2951548993587494, -0.31750503182411194, -0.11640285700559616, 0.2848817706108093, 0.6611062288284302, -0.5833345055580139, 0.6521340608596802, 0.10560285300016403, 0.10231464356184006, -0.4404330253601074, -0.8012729287147522, -0.0026567059103399515, -0.1892755776643753, -0.5673434138298035, 0.7069262266159058, -0.31006503105163574, -0.22425547242164612, -0.17761902511119843, 0.06800701469182968, 0.09648730605840683, -0.0030016209930181503, 0.3030328154563904, 0.35494834184646606, -0.04010686278343201, 0.5075548887252808, 0.17084141075611115, -0.04208900034427643, -0.06983991712331772, 0.014753645285964012, 0.2672313153743744, -0.07205107808113098, -0.24189451336860657, -0.49649542570114136, -0.16164174675941467, 0.15944407880306244, -0.025575105100870132, 0.5758054256439209, 0.891399085521698, -0.26599034667015076, -0.07868050783872604, -0.6398636698722839, -0.7629851698875427, -0.5896168351173401, 0.2212693989276886, -0.38012248277664185, -1.2002384662628174, 0.4680878221988678, -0.1884489357471466, -0.20932133495807648, 0.11712713539600372, 0.44932979345321655, -0.1986822634935379, 0.6494452357292175, 0.8737424612045288, 0.29411280155181885, 0.24812883138656616, -0.16158641874790192, -0.025819264352321625, -1.101362943649292, -0.3671559989452362, -0.18912050127983093, -0.31478384137153625, -0.4653300344944, -0.9520642161369324, 0.86380535364151, 0.08928858488798141, 0.06858355551958084, 0.027530107647180557, -0.6079318523406982, 0.6590698957443237, 0.1731185019016266, 0.5567574501037598, 0.2898149788379669, 0.031450506299734116, -0.412931352853775, 0.18679772317409515, -0.8281499147415161, -0.23935048282146454, 1.31650972366333, 0.27391061186790466, 0.6890624165534973, -0.1467577964067459, 0.7546363472938538, 0.02786075696349144, 0.3791165053844452, -0.920513927936554, 0.5865339040756226, 0.24339677393436432, -0.3584439158439636, -0.19009588658809662, -0.49304088950157166, -1.0722085237503052, -0.20662274956703186, -0.36135435104370117, -0.488420695066452, 0.15877804160118103, 0.3536829948425293, -0.8409510254859924, -0.01608654297888279, -0.3524303436279297, 0.32166367769241333, -0.27205953001976013, -0.3503999710083008, -0.2260051667690277, -0.7665380239486694, 0.1631835699081421, -0.3891068398952484, 0.10310110449790955, -0.062120769172906876, -0.6110439896583557, 0.6726229190826416, -0.3730962574481964, 0.9220390915870667, -0.028828291222453117, 0.10227175801992416, 0.20193050801753998, -0.2450140416622162, 0.53819340467453, 0.11151288449764252, -0.38300821185112, 0.1866942048072815, -0.20561668276786804, -0.21215473115444183, -0.49432623386383057, 0.5695056915283203, -0.45869550108909607, -0.40890127420425415, -0.06728865206241608, -0.5992559790611267, -0.46540945768356323, 0.13336601853370667, 0.5043232440948486, 0.41722571849823, -0.0961821973323822, 0.28586265444755554, 0.9641409516334534, -0.422947496175766, 0.2578865587711334, 0.8144586682319641, -0.19292238354682922, -0.675548791885376, 0.5942202806472778, -0.11162470281124115, 0.3042452931404114, 0.4108886420726776, 0.43679022789001465, -0.5916827321052551, -0.9419327974319458, -0.34406018257141113, 0.31520241498947144, -0.49701830744743347, -0.33949822187423706, -0.6983788013458252, -0.13209211826324463, -0.5140208005905151, -0.3440186083316803, 0.05466736480593681, -0.37312397360801697, -0.44026073813438416, -0.32908114790916443, 0.8932822346687317, 0.6915248036384583, -0.3560134768486023, 0.5034132599830627, -0.9303860068321228, 0.2221725583076477, 0.03280813619494438, 0.3920823335647583, -0.5391730666160583, -0.85053950548172, -0.48058876395225525, 0.10749061405658722, -0.07959853857755661, -0.8093379735946655, 0.2902472913265228, 0.44433459639549255, 0.6542144417762756, 0.3489709198474884, -0.17044426500797272, 0.8687784671783447, -0.4013771414756775, 0.48133835196495056, 0.19017766416072845, -0.7325466871261597, 0.8168113827705383, -0.345263808965683, 0.29343879222869873, 0.6785333752632141, 0.32926177978515625, -0.17735745012760162, -0.3292630910873413, -0.43139347434043884, -0.9102811217308044, 0.33011865615844727, -0.04922067001461983, 0.15313151478767395, -0.11369100958108902, 0.718861997127533, 0.12264384329319, 0.1843511164188385, -0.3599635064601898, -0.10960555076599121, 0.2601935565471649, -0.041522204875946045, -0.14024244248867035, 0.08989524841308594, -0.2387448400259018, -0.5734490156173706, 0.7006181478500366, -0.39988332986831665, 0.28469082713127136, 0.4276549518108368, -0.06365044414997101, -0.11563882976770401, 0.11105074733495712, 0.48465561866760254, 0.7266775965690613, -0.05543074011802673, -0.16682752966880798, 0.5916997194290161, -0.3498890995979309, 0.023056650534272194, 0.3086104094982147, -0.35376015305519104, -0.10610339045524597, 0.20426276326179504, 0.7912569642066956, 0.11097823083400726, -0.7906164526939392, 0.26432710886001587, 0.25836750864982605, -0.4127247631549835, 0.10968230664730072, 0.3071090877056122, 0.008419271558523178, 0.29310309886932373, 0.3098693788051605, 0.014248279854655266, 0.20631596446037292, -0.045733824372291565, 0.5248372554779053, 0.5522470474243164, -0.2464180290699005, -0.131593257188797, 0.5462877750396729, 0.19870924949645996, 0.056798968464136124, 0.43335574865341187, -0.4020411968231201, -0.20910319685935974, 0.39074447751045227, 0.5873396992683411, 0.56230628490448, -0.1976536512374878, 0.23380301892757416, 0.4668422341346741, 0.23759983479976654, 0.09005765616893768, 0.4335363805294037, 0.012242535129189491, -0.884816586971283, -0.981412947177887, -0.7112001180648804, -0.5726200938224792, 0.20795182883739471, -0.40902936458587646, 0.5072520971298218, -0.6063705086708069, -0.2852209508419037, 0.018019352108240128, -0.17960485816001892, -0.5726907253265381, 0.099178247153759, 0.06436581909656525, 1.0713573694229126, -0.41128435730934143, 0.5760524868965149, 0.9657288789749146, -0.29112178087234497, -0.9128182530403137, -0.20310750603675842, -0.0018660014029592276, -0.8321411609649658, 0.5480457544326782, 0.2383827418088913, -0.049618303775787354, 0.3178254961967468, -0.4119778573513031, -0.9458845257759094, 1.1777334213256836, 0.08314549177885056, -0.5238702297210693, -0.08568908274173737, 0.11320202052593231, 0.728356659412384, -0.19655533134937286, 0.48704859614372253, 0.3564299941062927, 0.7199890613555908, 0.22383864223957062, -1.0011675357818604, 0.05314771458506584, -0.18259622156620026, -0.3315905034542084, 0.17712058126926422, -0.1989506185054779, 0.3235284686088562, -0.6129012703895569, -0.15376533567905426, -0.000040676699427422136, 0.5634385347366333, 0.1779477745294571, 0.6102579236030579, 0.17633381485939026, 0.5199236273765564, 0.9888786673545837, 0.08313445001840591, 0.7983241677284241, -0.40292009711265564, -0.16597487032413483, 0.9669414758682251, -0.2932569086551666, 0.725358784198761, 0.6171236634254456, -0.08853773027658463, 0.4290572702884674, 0.525885283946991, 0.019460108131170273, 0.2646618187427521, 0.3496358394622803, -0.5713443756103516, -0.0262331310659647, -0.35468125343322754, -0.557003915309906, 0.39386042952537537, 0.8097295761108398, -0.17795492708683014, -0.3209679126739502, 0.46226510405540466, -0.2924558222293854, -0.12256160378456116, -0.4783165156841278, 1.122925877571106, -0.09374048560857773, -0.3636004626750946, 0.7788277268409729, -0.18035972118377686, 0.914717972278595, -0.7200788259506226, 0.07879683375358582, -0.18320061266422272, 0.02547489106655121, -0.3510335683822632, -0.5734506845474243, 0.44190195202827454, -0.08609449118375778, -0.08383196592330933, -0.12135866284370422, 0.9546735286712646, -0.37471097707748413, -0.381542444229126, 0.22682201862335205, 0.9296246767044067, 0.20090124011039734, 0.011310260742902756, -0.6346706748008728, -0.08744089305400848, 0.05411136895418167, -0.1049404963850975, 0.22361409664154053, 0.30735915899276733, 0.06759002059698105, 0.8053923845291138, 0.7890610098838806, 0.35598427057266235, 0.1419333815574646, -0.029339753091335297, 1.0791231393814087, -0.5312391519546509, -0.16723981499671936, -0.822628378868103, 0.5093804597854614, 0.06652478128671646, -0.12793803215026855, 0.5777173638343811, 0.6571162939071655, 0.6655106544494629, -0.08364620804786682, 0.705348014831543, -0.17493866384029388, 0.7838426232337952, -0.44980093836784363, 0.68826824426651, -0.3879562318325043, 0.2960022985935211, 0.18511547148227692, -0.5601861476898193, -0.5092222690582275, 0.5592648386955261, -0.37009096145629883, -0.10550983995199203, 0.6397985219955444, 1.3660467863082886, 0.14430725574493408, -0.20381231606006622, 0.3648342192173004, 0.2988470196723938, 0.14545828104019165, 0.42590007185935974, 0.8527299761772156, -0.14767636358737946, 0.4375690817832947, -0.23243187367916107, -0.37310221791267395, -0.22694846987724304, -1.1527246236801147, -0.7816942930221558, -0.180622860789299, -0.5369114875793457, -0.47331833839416504, 0.2591687738895416, 1.0186210870742798, 0.6926580667495728, -0.5200405120849609, 0.1278769075870514, -0.36500874161720276, -0.03468875586986542, -0.136331707239151, -0.1845645308494568, 0.16774575412273407, -0.609448254108429, -0.3803826570510864, 1.1586681604385376, 0.18038825690746307, 0.22550548613071442, 0.1303374469280243, -0.2766277492046356, -0.09937944263219833, 0.16497904062271118, 0.5131421089172363, 0.2196654975414276, -0.3858209550380707, -0.07226463407278061, 0.20686455070972443, -0.08768531680107117, -0.008541188202798367, 0.539723813533783, -1.265058994293213, 0.5714023113250732, 0.4636330306529999, 0.9560443162918091, 0.28404462337493896, 0.1377185732126236, 0.43545809388160706, -0.9149572253227234, -0.20642241835594177, 0.4559597671031952, 0.004175023175776005, 0.4880613386631012, -0.5566094517707825, 0.6001561880111694, 0.31527280807495117, -0.5695984363555908, -0.668932318687439, 0.033662088215351105, -0.9595395922660828, 0.05526543781161308, 1.2321720123291016, 0.28446242213249207, -0.09193092584609985, -0.11035019159317017, -0.10105667263269424, 0.32168975472450256, -0.262407124042511, 0.726150631904602, 0.21323251724243164, -0.5118762254714966, 0.09155917167663574, -0.45857858657836914, 0.8510177731513977, 0.4807109236717224, -1.007800579071045, -0.2948767840862274, 0.732020378112793, 0.3398256003856659, 0.07289093732833862, 0.77942955493927, -0.09682810306549072, 0.37836530804634094, -0.47787514328956604, 0.06769473105669022, -0.4235275089740753, -0.16474705934524536, -0.5593687295913696, -0.05001417547464371, -0.1122240200638771, -0.15122371912002563 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00141v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00141v1
Classifying Conspiratorial Narratives At Scale: False Alarms and Erroneous Connections
2024-03-29T20:29:12
2024-03-29T20:29:12
Ahmad Diab, Rr. Nefriana, Yu-Ru Lin
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.SI
Online discussions frequently involve conspiracy theories, which can contribute to the proliferation of belief in them. However, not all discussions surrounding conspiracy theories promote them, as some are intended to debunk them. Existing research has relied on simple proxies or focused on a constrained set of signals to identify conspiracy theories, which limits our understanding of conspiratorial discussions across different topics and online communities. This work establishes a general scheme for classifying discussions related to conspiracy theories based on authors' perspectives on the conspiracy belief, which can be expressed explicitly through narrative elements, such as the agent, action, or objective, or implicitly through references to known theories, such as chemtrails or the New World Order. We leverage human-labeled ground truth to train a BERT-based model for classifying online CTs, which we then compared to the Generative Pre-trained Transformer machine (GPT) for detecting online conspiratorial content. Despite GPT's known strengths in its expressiveness and contextual understanding, our study revealed significant flaws in its logical reasoning, while also demonstrating comparable strengths from our classifiers. We present the first large-scale classification study using posts from the most active conspiracy-related Reddit forums and find that only one-third of the posts are classified as positive. This research sheds light on the potential applications of large language models in tasks demanding nuanced contextual comprehension.
[ -0.8223927021026611, -1.025057077407837, 0.7641372680664062, -0.05129777640104294, -0.2700018882751465, 0.025709301233291626, -0.3334680497646332, -0.5364734530448914, 0.14165757596492767, 0.27894705533981323, -0.28349781036376953, -0.250900000333786, -0.9124993681907654, 0.12926085293293, -0.7741033434867859, 1.0325661897659302, 0.23535461723804474, -0.16733354330062866, -0.0029064235277473927, 0.20557594299316406, -0.058779116719961166, -0.6190930604934692, -0.48552700877189636, 0.04382945969700813, 0.7376542091369629, 0.11563971638679504, 0.5509825348854065, 0.5778716206550598, 0.5916191935539246, 0.3419042229652405, -0.000996193615719676, 0.05061502382159233, -0.49080049991607666, -0.08564487099647522, -0.2389933168888092, -0.4977869391441345, 0.14783325791358948, 0.16452813148498535, 0.06376774609088898, 0.6078307032585144, -0.07299397885799408, 0.08563727140426636, -0.16578401625156403, 0.11205003410577774, -0.5504025220870972, 0.009476798586547375, -0.6429577469825745, -0.23303267359733582, 0.09395114332437515, 0.0818004310131073, -0.702862024307251, -0.6697071194648743, 0.4049605429172516, -0.6556749939918518, 0.45726943016052246, -0.015382424928247929, 0.7368336915969849, 0.05604991689324379, -0.8102729916572571, -0.6844158172607422, -0.8300474286079407, 0.6545484662055969, -0.30994969606399536, 0.13574305176734924, 0.21342577040195465, 0.3766075074672699, 0.017535222694277763, -0.7341325283050537, -0.7938742637634277, -0.17800456285476685, -0.4037695825099945, -0.2659449279308319, -0.438467800617218, 0.01536377053707838, 0.35343626141548157, 0.2799963057041168, -0.6339734792709351, 0.01261089090257883, -0.3161222040653229, -0.3044164478778839, 0.4120771288871765, -0.06784985959529877, 0.15973041951656342, -0.24358415603637695, -0.28518325090408325, -0.0133864376693964, -0.47006723284721375, 0.04899397864937782, 0.2739173173904419, 0.22437261044979095, -0.28215789794921875, 0.16880016028881073, -0.13451038300991058, 0.5932177901268005, 0.41044458746910095, -0.20533853769302368, -0.03698282688856125, -0.10558053106069565, -0.3116360604763031, 0.10604724287986755, 0.5271393060684204, 0.413395494222641, 0.08982639759778976, -0.028828704729676247, 0.22742094099521637, 0.5249360203742981, 0.5664423704147339, -0.763996958732605, -0.18830688297748566, -0.12416253983974457, -0.3825145363807678, -0.3597077429294586, 0.5206539630889893, -0.6629084348678589, -0.7469619512557983, -0.23075219988822937, 0.4920077621936798, -0.08496322482824326, -0.32188957929611206, -0.08076024800539017, -0.3232695758342743, 0.04987166076898575, 0.8028554916381836, -0.4235210716724396, -0.05338927358388901, 0.6446586847305298, 0.6602063775062561, 0.2766195833683014, 0.13915540277957916, 0.08065816760063171, 0.13570863008499146, -0.39144885540008545, 0.8375126123428345, -0.3233300745487213, -0.11578437685966492, 0.2773554027080536, 0.05028491094708443, 0.20231123268604279, 0.09683850407600403, 0.7488343119621277, -0.7861126661300659, 0.5473523736000061, -0.33760759234428406, -0.6151807308197021, -0.40169140696525574, 0.6305614113807678, -0.4752567410469055, 0.31267377734184265, -0.21600650250911713, -0.973971962928772, 0.5409660935401917, -0.49182525277137756, -0.6063368320465088, -0.17566145956516266, -0.31458351016044617, -0.3341927230358124, 0.030491093173623085, 0.06723340600728989, 0.4731448292732239, -0.27146634459495544, 0.5477758646011353, -0.033437520265579224, -0.24045276641845703, 0.38299763202667236, -0.40044304728507996, 0.6561873555183411, 0.5280928015708923, -0.6309573650360107, -0.030482036992907524, -0.6205596327781677, -0.20486752688884735, -0.11564935743808746, -0.2702333629131317, -0.42133209109306335, 0.03832980990409851, -0.1589115709066391, 0.09459613263607025, 0.08239293843507767, -0.5851143598556519, 0.17234641313552856, -0.21317633986473083, 0.34131744503974915, 0.53983473777771, 0.2513136863708496, 0.3391454517841339, -0.3209126889705658, -0.02578582428395748, 0.10868241637945175, 0.3006543815135956, -0.07321014255285263, -0.6091185808181763, -1.1096689701080322, -0.000719615607522428, -0.21526920795440674, 0.31307700276374817, -0.6855597496032715, 0.6464899182319641, -0.31056877970695496, -0.9279446005821228, 0.11767160892486572, -0.6090577840805054, 0.3424641489982605, 0.3516882359981537, 0.5583305954933167, 0.4462462067604065, -0.5687052607536316, -0.9051315784454346, -0.4014091491699219, -0.471910297870636, -0.46610701084136963, -0.08878990262746811, 0.3278736174106598, -0.15788035094738007, 0.8652833104133606, -0.6287615895271301, -0.0999443382024765, -0.08269617706537247, 0.6917068958282471, 0.28965988755226135, 0.25340890884399414, 0.3100283145904541, -1.0803695917129517, -0.4032095968723297, 0.05517156422138214, -0.6014766097068787, 0.35916614532470703, -0.24997542798519135, 0.32333478331565857, 0.01267988607287407, 0.5850620269775391, -0.5856387615203857, 0.33420461416244507, 0.17024394869804382, -0.6087795495986938, 0.14618197083473206, 0.0019402768230065703, 0.6599340438842773, -0.9029393792152405, -0.12637634575366974, 0.07863038778305054, 0.03261146321892738, -0.9372140169143677, -0.07786282151937485, 0.1397632211446762, 0.1912318468093872, -0.3564624488353729, -0.18265290558338165, -0.18840782344341278, 0.36603179574012756, -0.2146288901567459, -0.04010368138551712, -0.21104903519153595, 0.42154958844184875, 0.10863552242517471, 0.053938403725624084, 0.349481999874115, -0.5368028283119202, 0.33008497953414917, 0.19696877896785736, -0.5795362591743469, 0.5424633026123047, -0.03901190683245659, 0.19495022296905518, -0.10533929616212845, 0.62260901927948, -1.0663424730300903, -0.6117312908172607, 0.017458515241742134, -0.5905666947364807, 0.16931840777397156, -0.35150569677352905, -0.34441620111465454, -0.1910780370235443, -0.18911463022232056, 0.1978437602519989, 0.5014162063598633, -0.4630785882472992, 0.46039438247680664, 0.46349138021469116, 0.3151504099369049, -0.26940301060676575, -0.7469013333320618, 0.09481297433376312, -0.46111738681793213, -0.4478735327720642, 0.04706569388508797, 0.1922735571861267, -0.606516420841217, -0.23744092881679535, -0.14214155077934265, -0.2741185426712036, 0.08441649377346039, 0.46766865253448486, -0.07473508268594742, -0.1733425110578537, 0.37920939922332764, -0.23154601454734802, -0.015813235193490982, 0.3259059190750122, -0.1820414513349533, 0.3016323149204254, -0.0011629064101725817, -0.11011495441198349, -0.48439985513687134, 0.3020680248737335, 0.7775559425354004, 0.3924042582511902, 1.0327609777450562, 0.5132902264595032, -0.506562352180481, -0.24832205474376678, -0.8332377672195435, -0.25842228531837463, -0.3982848525047302, 0.08422151207923889, -0.07157032936811447, -1.1761432886123657, 0.28824007511138916, -0.08745771646499634, 0.04424862563610077, 0.7429018020629883, 0.3910790979862213, -0.1366003006696701, 0.7563499212265015, 0.5906704068183899, 0.08504705876111984, 0.309650719165802, -0.04644414037466049, 0.3711245059967041, -0.12315325438976288, -0.2052365392446518, -0.7037580013275146, -0.1637263000011444, -0.7238280177116394, -0.1717870533466339, 0.37937188148498535, -0.15831929445266724, -0.5421090722084045, 0.41178008913993835, -0.5830685496330261, 0.6356454491615295, 0.2524263858795166, 0.08584941923618317, 0.23258541524410248, 0.021576091647148132, 0.44077157974243164, 0.21593418717384338, -0.4816882610321045, -0.5363085865974426, 1.0173351764678955, 0.30270853638648987, 0.6047166585922241, 0.44141682982444763, 0.16244468092918396, 0.6495093703269958, 0.7519714832305908, -0.5077569484710693, 0.45293742418289185, 0.015120734460651875, -0.8800883889198303, -0.41965606808662415, -0.45754578709602356, -0.7909358143806458, 0.11560028791427612, -0.27642759680747986, -0.4719931185245514, 0.25783759355545044, -0.05989339202642441, -0.48469847440719604, 0.5217204093933105, -0.7681747674942017, 0.6955119967460632, 0.05389073118567467, 0.1532457023859024, -0.6286550164222717, -0.8699857592582703, 0.41264665126800537, -0.17601467669010162, 0.5465161800384521, 0.08740316331386566, 0.187509223818779, 0.6590873003005981, -0.14636600017547607, 0.8869054317474365, -0.17203561961650848, -0.18956418335437775, 0.3388321101665497, 0.12726040184497833, 0.3522535562515259, 0.15570920705795288, 0.2232077270746231, 0.4599805772304535, -0.18973512947559357, -0.20666834712028503, -0.41684266924858093, 0.7157501578330994, -1.0027885437011719, -0.7984426021575928, -0.3474006652832031, -0.2236952930688858, -0.09585887938737869, 0.019537227228283882, 0.5317596793174744, 0.41107484698295593, -0.2809605300426483, 0.4361443519592285, 0.7638835310935974, -0.039240773767232895, 0.15738844871520996, 0.27345162630081177, 0.13284066319465637, -0.16178494691848755, 0.5926584005355835, 0.21385769546031952, 0.29915717244148254, 0.774896502494812, 0.23296846449375153, -0.17358918488025665, -0.749091386795044, -0.06960557401180267, -0.07891729474067688, -1.0118324756622314, -0.30228185653686523, -0.6642938852310181, -0.11405524611473083, -0.3774913251399994, -0.4817465543746948, -0.09686630964279175, -0.3574109673500061, -0.09082658588886261, -0.1777500957250595, 0.18187260627746582, 0.9146227240562439, 0.031150827184319496, 0.44823741912841797, -0.47143375873565674, 0.31007659435272217, 0.5438698530197144, 0.0631825402379036, -0.3050641119480133, -0.5836513638496399, -0.40430256724357605, 0.09192893654108047, -0.2542080283164978, -1.0203107595443726, 0.017282256856560707, -0.22725224494934082, 0.3321237862110138, 0.8420357704162598, 0.513529896736145, 0.5534504652023315, -0.11788058280944824, 0.869897186756134, 0.2983325123786926, -0.8223029375076294, 0.681830108165741, -0.5534653067588806, -0.09936752170324326, 0.2923712730407715, 0.7659029364585876, -0.4051559865474701, -0.6088990569114685, -0.8059892654418945, -0.336048424243927, 0.6388001441955566, 0.2086227685213089, -0.0012796010123565793, -0.3184780180454254, 0.1608240306377411, 0.20583288371562958, 0.2038390189409256, -0.8364906907081604, -0.21585536003112793, -0.2777084708213806, -0.07585836201906204, 0.0064857774414122105, -0.17515873908996582, -0.4480118751525879, -0.013578896410763264, 0.4674520492553711, -0.19093136489391327, 0.36132121086120605, 0.30594658851623535, -0.2703991234302521, -0.2747654616832733, 0.3377244174480438, 0.6830036640167236, 1.016088843345642, 0.02401083894073963, 0.7137996554374695, 0.1982005536556244, -0.47979235649108887, 0.22410836815834045, -0.2137998342514038, -0.02400784008204937, -0.1405649334192276, 0.7664180397987366, 0.33564043045043945, 0.1771751195192337, -0.2917867600917816, 0.6725747585296631, -0.31479936838150024, -0.17991903424263, -0.49862560629844666, 0.0340702123939991, -0.09298617392778397, 0.3134496808052063, 0.5903822779655457, 0.2964974641799927, -0.058475613594055176, -0.7959489822387695, 0.1664925068616867, 0.23614680767059326, 0.026372652500867844, -0.3791441023349762, 0.24191363155841827, 0.3318554162979126, -0.14347170293331146, 0.60071861743927, -0.13238319754600525, -0.5936445593833923, 0.5431720018386841, 0.043086882680654526, 0.76255863904953, -0.30536115169525146, 0.19605667889118195, 0.7708582282066345, 0.6959563493728638, 0.04181889817118645, -0.44853582978248596, -0.000814862665720284, -0.8845154047012329, -0.12211252003908157, -0.42599308490753174, -0.18539415299892426, 0.4178428053855896, -0.3664560317993164, 0.3587365448474884, -0.7787320613861084, -0.16260887682437897, 0.2000737339258194, -0.1202789843082428, -0.47234681248664856, 0.21052949130535126, 0.3665005564689636, 0.7412768602371216, -1.0412554740905762, 0.6447373628616333, 0.32749873399734497, -0.33263933658599854, -0.4118082523345947, 0.4109421968460083, 0.2545367181301117, -0.22510573267936707, 0.46451854705810547, 0.4361764192581177, 0.1397181898355484, -0.10377523303031921, -0.6159563064575195, -0.7946675419807434, 0.7837113738059998, 0.18111468851566315, -0.47756436467170715, -0.03919363394379616, 0.24602527916431427, 0.5226044058799744, -0.4031679630279541, 0.2733004093170166, 0.3130340278148651, 0.6896092891693115, 0.1651584953069687, -0.8804924488067627, 0.22798384726047516, 0.08192458748817444, -0.5231664776802063, 0.43244507908821106, -0.3810722529888153, 0.7975748777389526, -0.027680937200784683, -0.4186655879020691, -0.23905345797538757, 0.559569776058197, -0.37270388007164, 0.4364137351512909, 0.841352105140686, 0.4722244441509247, 0.47746923565864563, -0.5013776421546936, 0.7975102663040161, 0.026824068278074265, 0.5124273896217346, 0.5957001447677612, 0.3060113489627838, 0.4700284004211426, 0.40471750497817993, -0.3707987368106842, 0.6620436906814575, 0.6880026459693909, -0.02591932937502861, 0.48185545206069946, 0.19810526072978973, -0.11496743559837341, -0.49359259009361267, 0.14702017605304718, -0.2967352271080017, 0.21823325753211975, 0.5788078904151917, -0.23595276474952698, -0.3464793562889099, 0.02123311534523964, 0.13913594186306, 0.12459069490432739, -0.42213350534439087, 0.8807072639465332, -0.19855815172195435, -0.6281983852386475, 0.411123663187027, -0.001119585707783699, 0.6250482797622681, -0.6306950449943542, 0.024898486211895943, -0.016070136800408363, 0.26325514912605286, -0.3480846881866455, -0.7204475402832031, 0.38535115122795105, 0.15357473492622375, -0.07439488917589188, -0.23361708223819733, 0.47568249702453613, -0.24273253977298737, -0.20950466394424438, 0.035988397896289825, 0.2966367304325104, -0.03211452439427376, -0.3048577606678009, -0.16785335540771484, 0.11004970222711563, 0.10427389293909073, -0.28533005714416504, 0.2421625256538391, 0.6184174418449402, -0.19703297317028046, 0.393124520778656, 0.8171727657318115, -0.5868827700614929, -0.020250914618372917, -0.09868732839822769, 0.9169427752494812, -0.5959734320640564, -0.8316763043403625, -0.9013188481330872, 0.4583298861980438, -0.29086220264434814, -0.2529575824737549, 0.9508799314498901, 0.4455438256263733, 0.9490563273429871, -0.06065545231103897, 0.7188631296157837, -0.3234018385410309, 0.545012891292572, -0.24240466952323914, 0.7637999057769775, -0.11941228806972504, 0.23661617934703827, -0.1772528737783432, -0.5267150402069092, -0.47713208198547363, 0.7478302717208862, -0.4642488956451416, -0.16689948737621307, 0.731620728969574, 0.4741443693637848, -0.0006427858024835587, 0.4199751615524292, 0.3853408992290497, 0.5332964062690735, 0.43228814005851746, 0.4400765597820282, 1.2942665815353394, -0.1056547537446022, 0.7060273289680481, -0.10252171754837036, -0.38189417123794556, -0.48816484212875366, -0.6896997690200806, -1.1228587627410889, -0.7028297781944275, -0.4129381775856018, -0.1320265531539917, -0.2401292771100998, 0.7524144649505615, 0.6416428685188293, -0.6975144147872925, -0.03830074146389961, -0.43581846356391907, 0.2323753982782364, 0.17268632352352142, -0.27200910449028015, 0.28992223739624023, -0.12475861608982086, -0.39974910020828247, 0.24930478632450104, 0.09195294231176376, -0.1448468565940857, -0.3457750678062439, 0.12878631055355072, -0.2669253647327423, 0.21731343865394592, 0.5071519613265991, -0.005683883558958769, -0.974096953868866, -0.7644372582435608, -0.3263810873031616, -0.06996887922286987, -0.20343650877475739, 1.0640615224838257, -0.675609290599823, 0.10011306405067444, 0.4462668001651764, 0.46578776836395264, 0.3291018009185791, -0.17091788351535797, 0.1836896687746048, -0.5648525953292847, -0.010999077931046486, 0.18058374524116516, 0.24396514892578125, 0.09456184506416321, -0.5994139909744263, 0.2604181170463562, 0.41211265325546265, -0.5927029252052307, -0.631998598575592, 0.28433525562286377, -0.8532522916793823, -0.6668722033500671, 0.946779727935791, -0.2217479795217514, 0.13382349908351898, -0.5615836381912231, -0.028671249747276306, 0.3730034828186035, -0.23227114975452423, 1.207576870918274, 0.7130684852600098, -0.1832253485918045, 0.06828269362449646, -0.2890951931476593, 0.6806530356407166, -0.3307473659515381, -0.985032856464386, 0.14802713692188263, 0.7462170124053955, -0.08107873052358627, 0.8386749625205994, 0.174396350979805, 0.23900847136974335, 0.2618847191333771, 0.019366631284356117, -0.34578731656074524, 0.066517673432827, -0.36012277007102966, -0.07322514057159424, 0.7936112880706787, -0.4158955216407776, 0.10734029114246368 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00124v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00124v1
Where Are You From? Let Me Guess! Subdialect Recognition of Speeches in Sorani Kurdish
2024-03-29T19:27:04
2024-03-29T19:27:04
Sana Isam, Hossein Hassani
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
Classifying Sorani Kurdish subdialects poses a challenge due to the need for publicly available datasets or reliable resources like social media or websites for data collection. We conducted field visits to various cities and villages to address this issue, connecting with native speakers from different age groups, genders, academic backgrounds, and professions. We recorded their voices while engaging in conversations covering diverse topics such as lifestyle, background history, hobbies, interests, vacations, and life lessons. The target area of the research was the Kurdistan Region of Iraq. As a result, we accumulated 29 hours, 16 minutes, and 40 seconds of audio recordings from 107 interviews, constituting an unbalanced dataset encompassing six subdialects. Subsequently, we adapted three deep learning models: ANN, CNN, and RNN-LSTM. We explored various configurations, including different track durations, dataset splitting, and imbalanced dataset handling techniques such as oversampling and undersampling. Two hundred and twenty-five(225) experiments were conducted, and the outcomes were evaluated. The results indicated that the RNN-LSTM outperforms the other methods by achieving an accuracy of 96%. CNN achieved an accuracy of 93%, and ANN 75%. All three models demonstrated improved performance when applied to balanced datasets, primarily when we followed the oversampling approach. Future studies can explore additional future research directions to include other Kurdish dialects.
[ -0.6815333366394043, -0.7827732563018799, 0.32430505752563477, -0.29341933131217957, -0.6344959735870361, 0.276372492313385, -0.23915165662765503, -0.31672167778015137, 0.35134169459342957, 0.44281187653541565, -0.779312252998352, -0.5840772986412048, -0.8157187104225159, 0.12274675071239471, -0.23178668320178986, 0.8320131301879883, 0.21195627748966217, 0.5771586298942566, -0.022655252367258072, -0.3519751727581024, -0.30754390358924866, -0.636126697063446, -0.48901116847991943, -0.29876989126205444, 0.05546054244041443, 0.6427247524261475, 0.3304990530014038, -0.09105804562568665, -0.09347239881753922, 0.20370560884475708, -0.3353430926799774, 0.09897095710039139, -0.3019309937953949, -0.07194835692644119, -0.303743839263916, -0.4473663568496704, 0.22444860637187958, 0.16665540635585785, 0.4611811935901642, 0.5927487015724182, -0.24693842232227325, 0.44370728731155396, -0.2737025022506714, 0.3729669451713562, -0.6815044283866882, -0.4248266816139221, -0.5005807280540466, 0.5483523011207581, -0.17178258299827576, -0.10538146644830704, 0.03876098245382309, -0.6984546780586243, 0.5197412371635437, -0.004610121715813875, 0.5371562838554382, -0.1604996621608734, 0.7525842189788818, 0.12219136208295822, -0.5531657338142395, -0.21820221841335297, -0.7511285543441772, 0.7731709480285645, -0.8063629865646362, 0.6016841530799866, 0.803837239742279, 0.6233153939247131, -0.12010390311479568, -0.5795071721076965, -0.5708814263343811, -0.20322468876838684, -0.10360421985387802, 0.13934792578220367, -0.4322037100791931, -0.40260082483291626, 0.33701983094215393, 0.2644515633583069, -0.6214438080787659, 0.09976296126842499, -0.8075827956199646, -0.3711439073085785, 0.640658974647522, -0.20877951383590698, 0.054199934005737305, -0.22756066918373108, -0.15930916368961334, 0.2641570568084717, -0.6824134588241577, 0.3046053349971771, 0.6301097869873047, 0.36732718348503113, -0.05994288995862007, 0.6640253663063049, -0.5011740326881409, 0.47992515563964844, 0.23907873034477234, -0.10414326936006546, 0.11277183890342712, -0.312755286693573, -0.3880380690097809, 0.4670853614807129, 0.9709416031837463, 0.05784491449594498, 0.3890383243560791, 0.11682187765836716, 0.37680214643478394, -0.3207612931728363, -0.12589389085769653, -0.46439772844314575, -0.3547886312007904, 0.05865328013896942, -0.7033811211585999, -0.08407585322856903, -0.3942568898200989, -0.6763275265693665, -0.6972464919090271, -0.1398610770702362, -0.13203276693820953, -0.36532047390937805, -0.40492966771125793, -0.2137261927127838, 0.1632179170846939, 0.045783597975969315, 0.033972326666116714, -1.1358615159988403, 0.30296221375465393, 0.5158841609954834, 0.7757726907730103, 0.2785681188106537, -0.06162933260202408, -0.6067754030227661, -0.5296554565429688, -0.4710177481174469, 0.8042954802513123, -0.5733591318130493, -0.5801214575767517, -0.06942791491746902, 0.05496302619576454, -0.03746595233678818, -0.8889302611351013, 0.7400527596473694, -0.4247035086154938, 0.4488086998462677, -0.42708444595336914, -0.24492454528808594, -0.29856717586517334, 0.13320200145244598, -0.4433184266090393, 1.1261820793151855, 0.14391155540943146, -0.910832941532135, 0.6069474816322327, 0.20195931196212769, -0.4214157462120056, 0.15186019241809845, -0.5302113890647888, -0.42836740612983704, 0.2183411866426468, 0.5970757007598877, 0.5252915024757385, -0.2703467011451721, 0.2864614427089691, 0.15023916959762573, -0.32866188883781433, 0.3548498749732971, -0.5938487648963928, 1.1240662336349487, 0.3339291214942932, -0.4848613142967224, -0.0685330405831337, -0.783669650554657, -0.11193764954805374, -0.2324640452861786, -0.46691325306892395, -0.09816104918718338, 0.034643493592739105, 0.0573127381503582, 0.14631229639053345, 0.09416425228118896, -0.8950764536857605, 0.024836160242557526, -0.3804333806037903, 0.3632224500179291, 0.5531261563301086, 0.028282439336180687, 0.4161214232444763, -0.04807982221245766, 0.8012017011642456, 0.048552487045526505, -0.18155577778816223, 0.48071157932281494, -0.25815632939338684, -0.6223590970039368, -0.16335344314575195, 0.6986111402511597, 0.6811789870262146, -0.5380818247795105, 0.21558478474617004, -0.1882132738828659, -0.7852103114128113, -0.6301845908164978, -0.11160653829574585, 0.18555086851119995, 0.7028478384017944, 0.3788766860961914, -0.2672041356563568, -1.146832823753357, -1.0408834218978882, -0.08022510260343552, -0.31164973974227905, -0.2249917834997177, 0.4899917244911194, 0.2816937565803528, -0.13792026042938232, 0.9291722774505615, -0.1483023315668106, -0.559408962726593, -0.6872678995132446, 0.2406933605670929, 0.35572150349617004, 0.3286019563674927, 0.3480973541736603, -0.8192594051361084, -0.6847207546234131, 0.24332712590694427, -0.5357793569564819, -0.018581444397568703, 0.2326010763645172, 0.13303595781326294, 0.43021318316459656, 0.7715468406677246, -0.4702678918838501, 0.3846984803676605, 0.58255535364151, -0.2661980390548706, 0.6003392934799194, 0.10566940158605576, 0.05808023363351822, -1.0673034191131592, -0.10392571985721588, -0.289067804813385, -0.27002453804016113, -0.5055791139602661, -0.3943946957588196, -0.343833327293396, -0.06565599143505096, -0.5091155171394348, 0.12396620213985443, -0.16061115264892578, -0.06237729638814926, 0.19963562488555908, -0.12989360094070435, -0.504149854183197, 0.24596768617630005, 0.24234841763973236, 0.863470733165741, 0.695681095123291, -0.1593378186225891, 0.5618079304695129, 0.18359628319740295, -1.1228615045547485, 0.6500344276428223, -0.4413723647594452, 0.23566065728664398, -0.32684800028800964, 0.44625696539878845, -0.9056000113487244, -0.34671199321746826, 0.4628007113933563, -0.6424630284309387, 0.06719645112752914, -0.5147764086723328, -0.1496822088956833, 0.10476647317409515, 0.3667167127132416, 0.4062727093696594, 0.5338342785835266, -0.3550700843334198, 1.0216121673583984, 0.6071998476982117, -0.48219776153564453, -0.6333501935005188, -0.6201332807540894, -0.042119767516851425, -0.5732200741767883, -0.1920095682144165, -0.2551615834236145, 0.5242462158203125, -0.3891041874885559, -0.10277862846851349, -0.13967108726501465, -0.0941874161362648, -0.1795233190059662, 0.39750972390174866, -0.18201693892478943, -0.39654847979545593, 0.06286200881004333, -0.06666342169046402, 0.18675841391086578, -0.08765077590942383, -0.3353334367275238, 0.7239518761634827, 0.0738142728805542, -0.15515950322151184, -0.6349854469299316, 0.5730938911437988, 0.4911121726036072, -0.07817858457565308, 0.4990735948085785, 0.8001280426979065, -0.36232030391693115, -0.015231848694384098, -0.6451094150543213, -0.03247366473078728, -0.40296536684036255, 0.5969110131263733, -0.43546706438064575, -0.9184127449989319, 0.4913693368434906, -0.23400746285915375, -0.18580754101276398, 0.12864331901073456, 0.49679964780807495, -0.5062013864517212, 0.8350809812545776, 0.4819619059562683, -0.4829748570919037, 0.3636360466480255, -0.18856118619441986, 0.46201542019844055, -0.558350145816803, -0.4152580797672272, -0.5093103647232056, -0.506470799446106, -0.7991970181465149, -0.42739877104759216, 0.29627683758735657, 0.1060963124036789, -0.00032994610955938697, 0.2307896912097931, -0.05501467362046242, 0.47159141302108765, 0.894581139087677, 0.09028999507427216, -0.002967802807688713, 0.20442567765712738, -0.2152685672044754, -0.3117183446884155, -0.9048908352851868, -0.4350349009037018, 0.9298403859138489, 0.3619091510772705, 0.8119589686393738, 0.22070743143558502, 0.6788904070854187, 0.29664212465286255, -0.02482740581035614, -0.6337599158287048, 0.5719952583312988, -0.3432610332965851, -0.3986925780773163, -0.5311132073402405, -0.2902681529521942, -0.964493989944458, 0.059822894632816315, -0.2972416579723358, -0.7946856021881104, 0.2513284981250763, 0.08050144463777542, -0.7422620058059692, 0.1291913241147995, -0.5019699931144714, 0.7440518736839294, -0.004534831270575523, 0.22727644443511963, -0.043315909802913666, -0.710481584072113, 0.04521363228559494, 0.25565844774246216, 0.5370575785636902, -0.3363499641418457, 0.6721557378768921, 0.7473199367523193, -0.27600663900375366, 0.6596128344535828, -0.25902310013771057, 0.05419178679585457, 0.48012372851371765, 0.1491374671459198, 0.19312317669391632, 0.09105872362852097, -0.003265158273279667, 0.41655194759368896, 0.1737302541732788, -0.3421957492828369, -0.558253824710846, 0.6323003172874451, -1.013408899307251, -0.572913646697998, -0.40488526225090027, -0.27074429392814636, -0.2788451611995697, 0.1091349720954895, 0.8257405757904053, 0.6601340174674988, -0.2725409269332886, 0.35394272208213806, 0.6499963402748108, -0.2425767183303833, 0.23657597601413727, 0.34733039140701294, -0.09536940604448318, -0.36604252457618713, 0.854930579662323, 0.33353474736213684, 0.04474901035428047, 0.23305389285087585, 0.38608062267303467, -0.6381107568740845, -0.486327588558197, -0.6197268962860107, -0.04636174067854881, -0.9653298258781433, 0.22512008249759674, -0.5685141086578369, -0.34774869680404663, -0.8780832290649414, 0.14388607442378998, -0.24267101287841797, -0.42936161160469055, -0.27439549565315247, -0.6782117486000061, 0.11523846536874771, 0.6287960410118103, -0.2216981053352356, 0.22471509873867035, -0.6745328307151794, 0.09653894603252411, 0.6234821081161499, -0.13718204200267792, -0.2879103422164917, -0.6648603081703186, -0.1521681249141693, 0.032642584294080734, 0.003703039139509201, -0.8522099256515503, 0.6106011867523193, 0.4420928955078125, 0.5498467683792114, 0.09153054654598236, 0.17561163008213043, 0.7123289704322815, -0.5582435131072998, 1.0030264854431152, -0.14358992874622345, -0.6971534490585327, 0.6595149636268616, -0.022903570905327797, 0.405810683965683, 0.6457603573799133, 0.5821646451950073, -0.6095190048217773, -0.3632121980190277, -0.5003272891044617, -0.7815002799034119, 0.5192004442214966, 0.055033717304468155, 0.25468775629997253, 0.22779369354248047, 0.005975752603262663, 0.19913411140441895, 0.026820890605449677, -0.539406418800354, -0.24680720269680023, -0.26027992367744446, -0.18041320145130157, -0.41300785541534424, -0.35741063952445984, -0.3040156960487366, -0.03688374161720276, 0.594791829586029, -0.012741127982735634, 0.013515423983335495, 0.44786956906318665, -0.02799270674586296, -0.2556232213973999, 0.4497915506362915, 0.7347200512886047, 0.738278865814209, -0.1755918562412262, 0.5840469598770142, 0.761772096157074, -0.5242925882339478, 0.05565900728106499, 0.10864083468914032, -0.20154818892478943, 0.48661327362060547, 0.5245152711868286, 0.7942665815353394, -0.10355319082736969, -0.9473199248313904, 0.3159390985965729, -0.47748231887817383, -0.10314317792654037, -0.7417057156562805, -0.17609916627407074, -0.0842270702123642, 0.6602542996406555, 0.6480125784873962, 0.1176522821187973, 0.1823783665895462, -0.6937538981437683, -0.023293085396289825, 0.3989913761615753, -0.7559022307395935, -0.12330740690231323, 0.36622509360313416, -0.07304511964321136, -0.45995521545410156, 0.7915945053100586, 0.15117143094539642, -0.84396892786026, 0.6120932698249817, 0.13912223279476166, 0.8921064138412476, -0.2027912586927414, 0.33941569924354553, 0.57632976770401, 0.2125389724969864, 0.4688040614128113, 0.4086073637008667, -0.4748723804950714, -0.7294411659240723, -0.3012315034866333, -0.7695703506469727, -0.3042618930339813, 0.2798153758049011, -0.6893982291221619, 0.184866264462471, -0.39940062165260315, -0.1537408083677292, -0.14690805971622467, 0.05631024017930031, -0.5594453811645508, 0.3985108733177185, 0.39959201216697693, 1.0210319757461548, -1.3962563276290894, 0.7476867437362671, 0.6823630928993225, 0.05221311375498772, -0.7960448265075684, 0.12255137413740158, -0.05138275772333145, -0.6370465755462646, 0.8613425493240356, -0.07762204855680466, -0.08345510810613632, 0.03311753645539284, -0.4578956067562103, -0.9832206964492798, 0.6546114683151245, 0.07623520493507385, -0.6531636118888855, 0.20017202198505402, 0.2163756638765335, 0.3987850248813629, -0.06190519779920578, -0.011217853985726833, 0.9579026699066162, -0.07703487575054169, 0.058697473257780075, -1.1706867218017578, -0.20106789469718933, -0.019832158461213112, -0.21235699951648712, -0.08065083622932434, -0.5937941074371338, 0.6677706837654114, -0.022233372554183006, -0.22128190100193024, 0.29774218797683716, 0.7729166746139526, 0.4310908615589142, 0.24513648450374603, 0.36069655418395996, 0.5849149227142334, 0.6429902911186218, -0.09730813652276993, 0.6866880059242249, 0.28252843022346497, 0.17504671216011047, 1.2411843538284302, 0.08759428560733795, 0.8555206656455994, 0.6238008737564087, -0.3747561275959015, 0.5100235342979431, 1.1874957084655762, 0.2183285504579544, 1.0303704738616943, 0.0521240234375, -0.6790755391120911, -0.2958599627017975, -0.620888888835907, -0.5148329138755798, 0.6967053413391113, 0.37103271484375, -0.17040471732616425, -0.23177826404571533, 0.21493346989154816, -0.33160731196403503, -0.07037939131259918, -0.3364305794239044, 0.8107606768608093, 0.09037087857723236, -0.8774166703224182, 0.5479779839515686, -0.21699394285678864, 0.2946814298629761, -0.4614393413066864, 0.01890811324119568, -0.3028084635734558, 0.05888434126973152, -0.3921443223953247, -0.5301868915557861, 0.27162930369377136, -0.07883729040622711, -0.17062297463417053, -0.2310187816619873, 0.4563889503479004, -0.5692301392555237, -0.6964327692985535, -0.12348354607820511, 0.26557666063308716, 0.4994629919528961, 0.3006618022918701, -0.31576383113861084, 0.18401505053043365, 0.120952308177948, 0.1857946813106537, 0.32229170203208923, 0.5340014696121216, -0.22260782122612, 0.4396708011627197, 0.6503503322601318, 0.33209219574928284, 0.35513585805892944, 0.21103081107139587, 0.5863458514213562, -0.22525529563426971, -0.4426611661911011, -0.8691069483757019, 0.20276528596878052, 0.25901100039482117, -0.6127083897590637, 0.8787782788276672, 0.7026882171630859, 1.3741868734359741, -0.12149165570735931, 1.0981663465499878, -0.23798154294490814, 1.012913703918457, -0.6546667218208313, 0.5925586819648743, -0.2550862729549408, -0.10085416585206985, -0.12164545059204102, -0.5837673544883728, 0.043356653302907944, 1.0356334447860718, -0.4485883116722107, -0.29572951793670654, 0.3065469563007355, 0.7586309909820557, -0.03741631284356117, 0.11588358134031296, 0.3693104386329651, 0.2500185966491699, 0.06858081370592117, 0.2970285415649414, 1.1982369422912598, -0.2983700633049011, 0.388786256313324, -0.5181015133857727, -0.16388504207134247, -0.13211499154567719, -0.5316895842552185, -0.9465634226799011, -0.5873494148254395, -0.31781843304634094, -0.30486777424812317, -0.02031766064465046, 1.1669833660125732, 0.9759440422058105, -1.2687779664993286, -0.3306097388267517, -0.04403538629412651, 0.07050859928131104, -0.05632827803492546, -0.17420519888401031, 0.39569148421287537, 0.3631265461444855, -0.8540184497833252, 0.668789803981781, -0.09562782943248749, 0.07425851374864578, -0.12593050301074982, 0.13400091230869293, -0.36876413226127625, -0.4284496009349823, 0.35541653633117676, 0.5792905688285828, -0.9791566729545593, -0.41849640011787415, 0.1021123081445694, 0.012100393883883953, -0.2822321951389313, 0.7849522829055786, -0.9459752440452576, 0.6501640677452087, 0.5537747740745544, 0.4692845940589905, 0.5301358699798584, 0.333763062953949, 0.738798201084137, -0.9354361891746521, 0.38707610964775085, 0.606524646282196, 0.5294048190116882, 0.4330752491950989, -0.35555538535118103, 0.4148104190826416, 0.16525527834892273, -0.554965078830719, -0.9093496799468994, 0.3124576508998871, -0.5619825720787048, -0.21571846306324005, 1.0552855730056763, -0.3686663806438446, 0.11016335338354111, -0.5700819492340088, -0.6451238989830017, 0.410617858171463, 0.026990769430994987, 0.9180618524551392, 0.7155760526657104, -0.3730977177619934, -0.6659854054450989, -0.5897156596183777, 0.6364842057228088, 0.5524071455001831, -0.2924014925956726, -0.42011210322380066, 0.4117802381515503, 0.45788994431495667, 0.08453977853059769, 0.8956323862075806, 0.2958486080169678, 0.45348089933395386, -0.1755954921245575, -0.41289037466049194, 0.38647547364234924, -0.21911457180976868, -0.46238839626312256, 0.09235356003046036, -0.11010080575942993, -0.473876029253006 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20331v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20331v1
Unsolvable Problem Detection: Evaluating Trustworthiness of Vision Language Models
2024-03-29T17:59:53
2024-03-29T17:59:53
Atsuyuki Miyai, Jingkang Yang, Jingyang Zhang, Yifei Ming, Qing Yu, Go Irie, Yixuan Li, Hai Li, Ziwei Liu, Kiyoharu Aizawa
cs.CV
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
This paper introduces a novel and significant challenge for Vision Language Models (VLMs), termed Unsolvable Problem Detection (UPD). UPD examines the VLM's ability to withhold answers when faced with unsolvable problems in the context of Visual Question Answering (VQA) tasks. UPD encompasses three distinct settings: Absent Answer Detection (AAD), Incompatible Answer Set Detection (IASD), and Incompatible Visual Question Detection (IVQD). To deeply investigate the UPD problem, extensive experiments indicate that most VLMs, including GPT-4V and LLaVA-Next-34B, struggle with our benchmarks to varying extents, highlighting significant room for the improvements. To address UPD, we explore both training-free and training-based solutions, offering new insights into their effectiveness and limitations. We hope our insights, together with future efforts within the proposed UPD settings, will enhance the broader understanding and development of more practical and reliable VLMs.
[ -0.310024231672287, -0.5435238480567932, 0.9877878427505493, 0.09052255749702454, -0.2645426094532013, 0.27197563648223877, 0.17424003779888153, -0.4875623285770416, -0.3571247160434723, 0.6534829139709473, -0.4867253303527832, -0.2884160876274109, -0.605664074420929, -0.18222087621688843, -0.7487240433692932, 0.6176875233650208, -0.23083892464637756, 0.12795622646808624, -0.6635763049125671, -0.2728866636753082, -0.6063864827156067, -0.5959922075271606, -0.657757580280304, -0.18247896432876587, -0.14069347083568573, 0.336814820766449, 0.71092689037323, 0.576497495174408, 0.7691119313240051, 0.32894185185432434, -0.2610193192958832, 0.04420416057109833, -0.17534182965755463, 0.06543297320604324, 0.012772646732628345, -0.4777466356754303, -0.0664261057972908, -0.1459725797176361, 0.5543215870857239, 0.6347647309303284, -0.2982378900051117, 0.21511167287826538, 0.039196185767650604, 0.6883732676506042, -0.696811318397522, 0.1418047547340393, -0.9744749665260315, 0.06311843544244766, -0.2972407341003418, 0.0559699647128582, -0.17816750705242157, -0.040631599724292755, 0.16931170225143433, -0.4577983617782593, 0.14747227728366852, -0.062333930283784866, 0.9398005604743958, 0.528872549533844, -0.21659938991069794, -0.10158607363700867, -0.7697104811668396, 0.6570616364479065, -0.5838971138000488, 0.22059182822704315, 0.3077821731567383, 0.3926229774951935, -0.15358681976795197, -0.5810121297836304, -0.8683302402496338, -0.10991725325584412, 0.17699646949768066, 0.06111682951450348, -0.5146061182022095, -0.06895983964204788, 0.2732536494731903, 0.3345651626586914, -0.5601014494895935, -0.11518476158380508, -0.3626977205276489, -0.2332042008638382, 0.33611544966697693, 0.378278523683548, 0.3239354193210602, -0.10926174372434616, -0.3433924913406372, 0.09167266637086868, -0.44656267762184143, 0.41271018981933594, -0.06408686935901642, -0.27081093192100525, 0.04598241671919823, 0.717450737953186, -0.39071956276893616, 0.8868973255157471, -0.27129900455474854, 0.31122538447380066, 0.19729016721248627, -0.33676308393478394, -0.312106728553772, -0.412778377532959, 0.2914181649684906, 0.4693734645843506, 0.6528242826461792, 0.04843214899301529, -0.39073070883750916, 0.21273839473724365, 0.3329254984855652, -0.16917400062084198, -0.2763599753379822, 0.24462297558784485, -0.3308090567588806, -0.6542560458183289, -0.20639826357364655, -0.5768767595291138, -0.48133158683776855, -0.1268029361963272, 0.6294676065444946, -0.2363765388727188, -0.318835586309433, 0.1254650354385376, -0.14004731178283691, 0.4661535322666168, 0.5557152032852173, -0.5427367687225342, -0.09325739741325378, 0.35829776525497437, 0.6871136426925659, -0.2971181869506836, -0.3007151484489441, -0.5299524068832397, -0.1990509182214737, -0.5181211829185486, 0.7654595971107483, -0.4327174425125122, -0.2472991943359375, 0.033670853823423386, -0.10757359117269516, -0.1700386255979538, -0.6651422381401062, 0.3594093918800354, -0.3338521420955658, 0.08780023455619812, -0.4114227890968323, -0.5633413195610046, 0.0092432526871562, 0.6676804423332214, -0.3883519172668457, 1.0923207998275757, 0.433096319437027, -0.8653578162193298, 0.2360904961824417, -0.6481537818908691, 0.2208523452281952, 0.34122660756111145, -0.4148350656032562, -0.30496475100517273, 0.31866106390953064, 0.14738726615905762, 0.46325522661209106, -0.13550031185150146, 0.14058561623096466, -0.5596750378608704, -0.2976614832878113, 0.38812118768692017, -0.6898171901702881, 1.0585423707962036, 0.21700789034366608, -0.35908472537994385, 0.1507258415222168, -1.1596323251724243, 0.37491124868392944, 0.3981463611125946, -0.1907796859741211, -0.533155083656311, -0.09424711018800735, -0.029482297599315643, 0.17750586569309235, 0.2411251962184906, -0.8465365171432495, -0.19979947805404663, -0.111017607152462, 0.3678668141365051, 0.8968012928962708, -0.05111825093626976, -0.11018025130033493, 0.03700944036245346, 0.4870803952217102, 0.34898924827575684, 0.5008499622344971, 0.043403785675764084, -0.718405544757843, -1.0397582054138184, 0.08127409219741821, -0.11055424809455872, 0.6878849267959595, -1.3554173707962036, -0.382203072309494, 0.13839282095432281, -0.2942934036254883, -0.5846805572509766, 0.20011654496192932, 0.9595786929130554, 0.783540666103363, 0.5014989376068115, -0.30162855982780457, -0.33680450916290283, -0.9819363951683044, -0.24654443562030792, -0.4217468500137329, 0.1822347790002823, 0.008075840771198273, 0.7449210286140442, -0.053147345781326294, 0.8611122369766235, -0.4920452833175659, -0.3312893807888031, -0.10496194660663605, -0.05530574172735214, -0.25485959649086, 0.28473493456840515, 0.541657030582428, -1.0190855264663696, -0.478448748588562, -0.09621424973011017, -1.091374158859253, 0.16570934653282166, 0.3000856041908264, 0.46856969594955444, 0.4559057950973511, 0.7461509108543396, -0.4519025981426239, 1.0042790174484253, 0.5892543792724609, -0.5594797730445862, 0.5690741539001465, -0.5004952549934387, 0.17256218194961548, -0.849219024181366, -0.09630519896745682, 0.059289295226335526, -0.14327777922153473, -0.7419424653053284, 0.19167862832546234, 0.040442366153001785, -0.16418394446372986, -0.7801605463027954, 0.380373477935791, -0.4333038628101349, -0.36884742975234985, 0.0124425133690238, 0.0741603896021843, -0.0909363329410553, 0.3655630648136139, 0.059796690940856934, 0.7945979833602905, 0.6336526274681091, -0.3918258547782898, 0.5772204399108887, 0.3709879517555237, -0.4612019956111908, 0.8407062292098999, -0.9428986310958862, -0.007902507670223713, -0.13858212530612946, -0.39046940207481384, -1.1602269411087036, -0.033249080181121826, 0.44531112909317017, -0.6573202610015869, 0.13205602765083313, -0.08242686837911606, -0.14930972456932068, -0.6641788482666016, -0.069353848695755, 0.44532567262649536, 0.46438342332839966, -0.5862255096435547, 0.3727789521217346, 0.3462892174720764, 0.15846872329711914, -0.8025690913200378, -0.6542580127716064, 0.06760327517986298, -0.11784002184867859, -0.7549974322319031, -0.07755210250616074, -0.26235175132751465, -0.5808841586112976, 0.38521841168403625, -0.3104361295700073, -0.5395171046257019, 0.19201652705669403, 0.10121992975473404, 0.29272258281707764, -0.1141083687543869, -0.10741259157657623, -0.5207388997077942, -0.24867917597293854, 0.2083595246076584, -0.18641720712184906, 0.262783408164978, -0.6741408109664917, -0.6997271180152893, -0.23538829386234283, 0.5087809562683105, 0.7841163277626038, -0.5928483605384827, 0.6319094300270081, 0.5651001334190369, -0.5043897032737732, -0.12127439677715302, -0.43381744623184204, 0.285954087972641, -0.4793633818626404, 0.3984339237213135, -0.3752790689468384, -0.9194958209991455, 0.6192619800567627, 0.39259156584739685, -0.16239479184150696, 0.09097890555858612, 0.49306720495224, -0.4130277931690216, 1.08305025100708, 0.9536138772964478, 0.26252683997154236, 0.1357661336660385, -0.12750118970870972, 0.08147631585597992, -0.7788647413253784, -0.4930780231952667, -0.5502970814704895, 0.26631030440330505, -0.3577733337879181, -0.30161193013191223, 0.4102012813091278, 0.07241351157426834, -0.007704010233283043, 0.20884037017822266, -0.5389795303344727, 0.6391945481300354, 0.5180080533027649, -0.09825001657009125, 0.4689181447029114, -0.16490203142166138, -0.1832696497440338, -0.07521916180849075, -0.6394544243812561, -0.22334003448486328, 1.1729097366333008, 0.21868246793746948, 0.4827374815940857, 0.030460329726338387, 0.42657291889190674, 0.20351488888263702, 0.0327693335711956, -0.41867995262145996, 0.6291050910949707, -0.15888631343841553, -0.623795747756958, -0.6201290488243103, -0.21699358522891998, -0.626434326171875, 0.45779654383659363, -0.2019045501947403, -1.0950894355773926, 0.2776290774345398, 0.42803868651390076, -0.09690016508102417, 0.48988401889801025, -0.6378584504127502, 1.1020952463150024, -0.30282527208328247, -0.04600627347826958, 0.14203697443008423, -0.6937102675437927, 0.4904114305973053, -0.13040345907211304, 0.09459924697875977, -0.013990460895001888, 0.27157092094421387, 0.648262083530426, -0.37312623858451843, 0.477386474609375, -0.2848779559135437, -0.1437866985797882, 0.33864131569862366, -0.04615697264671326, 0.27127692103385925, -0.05319259315729141, 0.4716552793979645, 0.16588610410690308, 0.34835284948349, -0.5597714185714722, -0.7422133088111877, 0.4916595220565796, -0.5227052569389343, -0.7261527180671692, -0.7277191281318665, -0.5016216039657593, -0.5929657816886902, 0.2721572518348694, 0.4526633620262146, 0.6198475956916809, 0.05515589937567711, 0.3425811529159546, 1.0670323371887207, -0.14091140031814575, 0.6658481359481812, 0.7323088049888611, -0.4716998338699341, -0.012819530442357063, 0.8446816205978394, -0.040989313274621964, 0.47516199946403503, 0.0838160291314125, -0.31029605865478516, -0.33512642979621887, -1.0647597312927246, -0.5802576541900635, -0.06581291556358337, -0.961315929889679, 0.03464177995920181, -0.24768611788749695, -0.48923832178115845, 0.00978192500770092, 0.23847632110118866, -0.7168962955474854, -0.2134968489408493, -0.1437564641237259, 0.019046906381845474, 0.12980520725250244, 0.6563838124275208, -0.015422731637954712, 0.03490104898810387, -0.7387586832046509, 0.5379624366760254, 0.4301239252090454, 0.4499034583568573, -0.2700745165348053, -0.539350152015686, -0.14858099818229675, 0.15775546431541443, -0.02437220700085163, -0.7916494011878967, 0.1504354327917099, -0.1689591407775879, 0.6433467864990234, 0.16936083137989044, 0.20066390931606293, 0.5071897506713867, -0.18409916758537292, 0.7619476318359375, 0.22810226678848267, -1.0147323608398438, 0.5864431262016296, -0.18263579905033112, 0.12930980324745178, 0.5245453715324402, 0.33407866954803467, -0.37349826097488403, -0.441231369972229, -0.5345543622970581, -0.6218777298927307, 0.33285826444625854, 0.43537643551826477, -0.05851640924811363, 0.235556498169899, 0.35642197728157043, -0.5063638687133789, 0.2949722111225128, -0.6562011241912842, -0.4280799627304077, -0.20413726568222046, -0.026791227981448174, -0.08166056871414185, -0.36801522970199585, -0.240963414311409, -0.3051941394805908, 0.3663976192474365, -0.06535433232784271, 0.10483257472515106, 0.3553520739078522, -0.0672934353351593, -0.057273827493190765, 0.31292280554771423, 0.6512787938117981, 0.8810786008834839, -0.3898642361164093, -0.07476268708705902, -0.020211251452565193, -0.5546836256980896, 0.20861656963825226, -0.12852656841278076, -0.4088282585144043, -0.10979793220758438, 0.32123225927352905, 0.7794262766838074, -0.14300383627414703, -0.7409304976463318, 0.8986479043960571, -0.4225636124610901, -0.42668044567108154, -0.6255596280097961, 0.055797066539525986, -0.06674806028604507, 0.3598650097846985, 0.41317591071128845, 0.5022537708282471, 0.025959791615605354, -0.4295172393321991, 0.34395208954811096, 0.8329772353172302, -1.0083822011947632, 0.025204114615917206, 0.6677613258361816, 0.0966334417462349, -0.26533493399620056, 0.7146098017692566, -0.18413661420345306, -0.6972380876541138, 0.6949803829193115, 0.28282487392425537, 0.6460716128349304, -0.018830666318535805, 0.633552074432373, -0.4171525835990906, 0.5695695877075195, 0.1157303974032402, 0.53855299949646, 0.2379528284072876, -1.2595866918563843, -0.4132049083709717, -0.37497973442077637, -0.5815094709396362, 0.5276129245758057, -1.1501845121383667, -0.18763132393360138, -0.30677181482315063, 0.12737344205379486, -0.038488805294036865, -0.12166683375835419, -0.6066470146179199, 0.5096247792243958, 0.08460216969251633, 0.8158533573150635, -0.6982004642486572, 0.9274684190750122, 0.9121568202972412, -0.4411403238773346, -0.8899618983268738, -0.03541211411356926, 0.3414101004600525, -1.2124829292297363, 0.46342670917510986, -0.10902033001184464, -0.30875688791275024, 0.22666335105895996, -0.6347374320030212, -0.5919322967529297, 1.0780267715454102, 0.5070509314537048, -0.19909971952438354, 0.1360231637954712, 0.04486309736967087, 0.5556755661964417, -0.27349114418029785, -0.011748628690838814, 0.784055769443512, 0.4749397933483124, 0.17152373492717743, -1.049504041671753, -0.16851483285427094, -0.456155002117157, 0.213612362742424, -0.005647188052535057, -0.4725506901741028, 0.8520365357398987, -0.5983267426490784, -0.15915486216545105, 0.26875388622283936, 0.4253127872943878, 0.24436098337173462, 0.5573675632476807, 0.5457243919372559, 0.7890284657478333, 0.608333170413971, -0.2686828374862671, 1.0389492511749268, 0.014779660850763321, 0.4338494837284088, 0.9138146042823792, -0.06422951072454453, 0.8871219754219055, 0.7754461765289307, -0.02982001006603241, 0.11840587854385376, 0.38766923546791077, -0.11988759785890579, 0.5841670632362366, 0.09186770021915436, -0.13875432312488556, -0.6386491060256958, -0.005194228142499924, -0.6208510398864746, 0.8923942446708679, -0.0031199250370264053, 0.05427086353302002, -0.3479008078575134, 0.1874016672372818, -0.22347509860992432, 0.3346237540245056, -0.5175684690475464, 0.3961156904697418, 0.012363731861114502, -0.4943487346172333, 0.6864985227584839, -0.26352643966674805, 0.3440912067890167, -0.39771971106529236, -0.16416960954666138, -0.5035550594329834, 0.5510169267654419, 0.008991006761789322, -1.1256405115127563, 0.3824460804462433, 0.10489849001169205, -0.19590343534946442, 0.015251684002578259, 0.7967981696128845, -0.4351542592048645, -0.46815890073776245, 0.38159462809562683, 0.8603817224502563, -0.002861557062715292, -0.2536982595920563, -0.839672327041626, 0.19244876503944397, 0.2397412806749344, -0.1313486248254776, 0.5624240040779114, 0.5363107323646545, -0.055912431329488754, 1.3466907739639282, 0.5733944773674011, 0.06442283093929291, 0.17585992813110352, -0.3037693500518799, 0.8543644547462463, -0.364113986492157, -0.27293404936790466, -0.6066141724586487, 0.7448422312736511, -0.13040822744369507, -0.4823668897151947, 0.9572301506996155, 0.013059131801128387, 1.1345471143722534, -0.22697198390960693, 0.7884344458580017, 0.14576414227485657, 0.5481075644493103, -0.673108696937561, 0.6832444667816162, -0.7806287407875061, 0.5401163697242737, -0.4401096701622009, -0.8262110352516174, -0.4047218859195709, 0.5508312582969666, 0.06659847497940063, -0.08509841561317444, 0.8939305543899536, 0.5594848990440369, 0.21742942929267883, -0.17353807389736176, 0.6815147995948792, 0.08151732385158539, 0.30433574318885803, 0.7640247344970703, 1.143600583076477, -0.27469149231910706, 0.983855664730072, -0.33210429549217224, -0.11638917773962021, 0.033361535519361496, -0.8775241374969482, -0.8368582725524902, -0.8230530619621277, -0.3876589834690094, -0.4383886456489563, 0.20187145471572876, 0.1006404459476471, 0.4897138476371765, -0.85914146900177, 0.13999097049236298, -0.23801247775554657, 0.25046995282173157, -0.1549670547246933, -0.20527377724647522, 0.23919756710529327, -0.1381441205739975, -0.27533334493637085, 0.12033475190401077, 0.3881535232067108, 0.3799484968185425, -0.313125342130661, -0.12525013089179993, 0.13235290348529816, 0.02387162670493126, 0.4693957269191742, 0.5919811725616455, -0.8142275810241699, -0.7608512043952942, 0.0404241606593132, 0.14281179010868073, -0.11919379979372025, 0.6316518783569336, -0.6491891741752625, 0.5132295489311218, 0.16993209719657898, 0.72132408618927, 0.35850805044174194, -0.015391352586448193, 0.4133111536502838, -0.5641624927520752, -0.06276044249534607, -0.05781331658363342, 0.46488893032073975, 0.3556111454963684, -0.09162133187055588, 0.5093786716461182, 0.5206649303436279, -0.4438258707523346, -1.0563831329345703, 0.44378283619880676, -1.0388140678405762, -0.19557738304138184, 0.9028634428977966, -0.3815942406654358, -0.11442188173532486, -0.5656170845031738, -0.11495087295770645, -0.24894113838672638, 0.04068879410624504, 0.5177943706512451, 0.7947205305099487, -0.276766836643219, -0.46750321984291077, -0.6277642846107483, 0.6935242414474487, 0.42169293761253357, -0.6496005654335022, 0.2257356196641922, 0.5586729049682617, 0.4116246700286865, 0.20151670277118683, 0.8918678164482117, -0.18234194815158844, 0.46411532163619995, 0.03837844729423523, -0.2498599737882614, -0.551070511341095, -0.5597453117370605, -0.5578409433364868, 0.2456274777650833, 0.1812184751033783, -0.5040903091430664 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20329v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20329v1
ReALM: Reference Resolution As Language Modeling
2024-03-29T17:59:06
2024-03-29T17:59:06
Joel Ruben Antony Moniz, Soundarya Krishnan, Melis Ozyildirim, Prathamesh Saraf, Halim Cagri Ates, Yuan Zhang, Hong Yu, Nidhi Rajshree
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
Reference resolution is an important problem, one that is essential to understand and successfully handle context of different kinds. This context includes both previous turns and context that pertains to non-conversational entities, such as entities on the user's screen or those running in the background. While LLMs have been shown to be extremely powerful for a variety of tasks, their use in reference resolution, particularly for non-conversational entities, remains underutilized. This paper demonstrates how LLMs can be used to create an extremely effective system to resolve references of various types, by showing how reference resolution can be converted into a language modeling problem, despite involving forms of entities like those on screen that are not traditionally conducive to being reduced to a text-only modality. We demonstrate large improvements over an existing system with similar functionality across different types of references, with our smallest model obtaining absolute gains of over 5% for on-screen references. We also benchmark against GPT-3.5 and GPT-4, with our smallest model achieving performance comparable to that of GPT-4, and our larger models substantially outperforming it.
[ -0.38473957777023315, -0.39269495010375977, 0.7133136987686157, -0.19188615679740906, -0.23913981020450592, 0.15204493701457977, -0.2024139016866684, -0.7297526597976685, -0.013833558186888695, 0.6829510927200317, -0.2761559784412384, -0.24061763286590576, -0.3143543303012848, 0.1128162294626236, -0.4497818350791931, 0.6786536574363708, -0.047894641757011414, -0.1590907722711563, -0.5115970373153687, -0.3324607312679291, -0.3566821217536926, -0.8321681022644043, -0.3518334627151489, -0.5401750206947327, 0.39388811588287354, 0.6087823510169983, 0.6436895132064819, 0.6685095429420471, 0.8012893795967102, 0.3544630706310272, 0.008744672872126102, 0.4426955282688141, -0.623397946357727, 0.28243184089660645, -0.4523034989833832, -0.39842507243156433, -0.4619784355163574, 0.1717638075351715, 0.6404833197593689, 0.7335717678070068, -0.12687312066555023, -0.036302048712968826, -0.05882434919476509, 0.6456664800643921, -0.36779022216796875, 0.08538505434989929, -0.8931771516799927, -0.08488629013299942, -0.2961350381374359, -0.48082810640335083, -0.6429973840713501, 0.0771247148513794, 0.09896165877580643, -0.7667376399040222, 0.47603848576545715, 0.5245034694671631, 0.91314297914505, 0.23833011090755463, -0.7017079591751099, -0.1652788668870926, -1.07003653049469, 0.7605447173118591, -0.5407878160476685, 0.661477267742157, 0.23205822706222534, 0.24781258404254913, -0.043056733906269073, -0.7169484496116638, -0.5479404330253601, -0.3311522901058197, -0.0017398108029738069, -0.04994450882077217, -0.3363453149795532, 0.2025124579668045, 0.49173909425735474, 0.38631996512413025, -0.18929515779018402, -0.060117367655038834, -0.3033987581729889, -0.29016390442848206, 0.03212442994117737, 0.31204885244369507, 0.07298263162374496, -0.19736625254154205, -0.2433541864156723, 0.3890727758407593, -1.0918444395065308, -0.5432713031768799, -0.35288095474243164, 0.46259257197380066, 0.15744182467460632, 0.39593467116355896, 0.03130695968866348, 0.9190664887428284, 0.3130219876766205, -0.37311121821403503, -0.19706693291664124, -0.013832240365445614, -0.28123944997787476, -0.39985933899879456, 0.25908905267715454, 0.46128585934638977, -0.26237642765045166, -0.38254135847091675, -0.26455143094062805, -0.1249665841460228, 0.32582077383995056, -0.8534350395202637, -0.07136227935552597, -0.2098010778427124, -0.32881882786750793, 0.0980827584862709, -0.4189954102039337, -0.21436695754528046, -0.5428333878517151, -0.617871105670929, 0.16850706934928894, -0.39711615443229675, -0.1050683781504631, -0.4834452271461487, 0.34248414635658264, -0.10261669009923935, 0.6389381289482117, -0.9230494499206543, 0.4516240954399109, 0.4380166828632355, 0.9241631627082825, -0.14696431159973145, 0.2544880509376526, -0.6840742826461792, 0.4142070710659027, -0.3925003409385681, 0.9363682866096497, -0.42242544889450073, -0.8733514547348022, -0.11849120259284973, -0.290092408657074, 0.03290355205535889, -0.8737257122993469, 0.4801657497882843, -0.96339350938797, -0.05839750915765762, -0.24232672154903412, -0.6489284038543701, -0.14705444872379303, 0.25376421213150024, -0.7765886187553406, 0.7239564657211304, 0.24035102128982544, -0.320712685585022, -0.03901436924934387, -0.5322411060333252, 0.1642671674489975, 0.396575003862381, -0.11789620667695999, -0.015822863206267357, 0.31738775968551636, -0.17791667580604553, 0.24490255117416382, -0.7046955823898315, 0.20675893127918243, -0.10234478861093521, -0.2250959426164627, 0.15729637444019318, -0.12486608326435089, 0.16158242523670197, 0.4922817647457123, 0.2174517959356308, 0.025923985987901688, -0.6284748315811157, -0.027303028851747513, -0.0744432583451271, -0.36904218792915344, -0.6836490035057068, 0.032056163996458054, -0.06529296189546585, 0.21924221515655518, 0.24642124772071838, -0.33389413356781006, 0.12423673272132874, -0.14927110075950623, 0.4423029124736786, 0.2806158661842346, -0.19767096638679504, 0.5418024659156799, -0.29785260558128357, 0.19962207973003387, 0.15132993459701538, -0.28153249621391296, -0.05391674116253853, -0.3626561164855957, -1.101271629333496, 0.010444292798638344, 0.2803993821144104, 0.26363855600357056, -1.1754708290100098, -0.15707151591777802, -0.4704916477203369, -0.42905086278915405, -0.03184408321976662, 0.21735797822475433, 0.34967562556266785, 0.7894383072853088, 0.3395439386367798, -0.12818479537963867, -0.569226861000061, -0.7278050780296326, -0.16951151192188263, -0.644015371799469, -0.12815609574317932, 0.5945755243301392, 0.3058594763278961, -0.31252729892730713, 1.1981230974197388, -0.23903563618659973, -0.2936825454235077, -0.04042881354689598, -0.0518060028553009, 0.2291622757911682, 0.3772725760936737, 0.2677634656429291, -1.0258702039718628, -0.35980528593063354, 0.18110573291778564, -0.7729330062866211, -0.38958483934402466, 0.07269096374511719, 0.05681692436337471, 0.22351373732089996, 0.6166866421699524, -0.28460779786109924, -0.0016840866301208735, 0.8099035024642944, -0.3106783926486969, 0.571163535118103, -0.268820196390152, 0.139287531375885, -0.8803127408027649, 0.31276625394821167, 0.27530577778816223, -0.6096422672271729, -0.7400445938110352, 0.38815364241600037, 0.25696519017219543, -0.42854997515678406, -0.600382387638092, 0.612271249294281, -0.6229986548423767, -0.05241333693265915, -0.386965274810791, 0.5166020393371582, -0.0319649763405323, 0.4056973159313202, 0.23874953389167786, 0.8846340179443359, -0.011854355223476887, -0.7985352277755737, 0.7738768458366394, 0.10715878009796143, -0.22397401928901672, 0.7517310380935669, -0.2260589301586151, 0.4674227237701416, 0.021760743111371994, 0.14677029848098755, -0.6546727418899536, -0.0023816442117094994, 0.00438457727432251, -0.13942313194274902, 0.31992021203041077, -0.10805370658636093, -0.40575525164604187, -0.22725076973438263, 0.12054815143346786, 0.5523288249969482, 0.18431219458580017, -0.6313897371292114, 0.7966404557228088, 0.525160014629364, -0.12124466896057129, 0.013469000346958637, -0.5155903100967407, 0.17633457481861115, -0.18897515535354614, -0.3957771360874176, 0.907309353351593, -0.23678788542747498, -0.4174674153327942, 0.11606117337942123, -0.21721406280994415, -0.22582292556762695, -0.2775605618953705, 0.278819739818573, 0.5537954568862915, -0.3381115198135376, 0.24383869767189026, -0.29282015562057495, -0.3641459047794342, -0.2344668060541153, -0.15655165910720825, 0.16984441876411438, -0.37893614172935486, -0.5525968074798584, -0.02871229127049446, 0.2692722678184509, 0.6476112008094788, 0.12368644028902054, 0.584549069404602, -0.1614856719970703, -0.6335549354553223, 0.10534123331308365, -0.8736482262611389, -0.09122458100318909, -0.4758186638355255, 0.3059595823287964, -0.6755568385124207, -1.2447795867919922, 0.5965412855148315, -0.46630170941352844, 0.08366481214761734, 0.21953052282333374, 0.5374212861061096, 0.10412637144327164, 0.6653713583946228, 0.7947875261306763, 0.06730584800243378, 0.5692821145057678, -0.030674276873469353, 0.4714336693286896, -1.139080286026001, -0.21060152351856232, -0.6934649348258972, 0.11860262602567673, -0.5271937847137451, -0.84397953748703, 0.30591055750846863, 0.3656962513923645, -0.10955223441123962, 0.5324963927268982, -0.1992809921503067, 0.5678050518035889, 0.4270794093608856, 0.02436286211013794, 0.8492307066917419, 0.019868038594722748, -0.3552710711956024, -0.5206834673881531, -0.6900300979614258, -0.8059683442115784, 0.5750234127044678, 0.4787119925022125, 0.6990684866905212, 0.37655335664749146, 0.3937167525291443, 0.33965614438056946, 1.079850673675537, -0.9908817410469055, 0.7388046979904175, -0.3576885461807251, -0.7162542939186096, -0.2042856365442276, -0.5216708183288574, -0.5367000699043274, 0.6624208688735962, 0.10484367609024048, -0.8091204166412354, 0.24402669072151184, 0.1559770256280899, -0.40059220790863037, 0.5090299844741821, -0.5721631050109863, 0.5306639075279236, 0.24048775434494019, -0.6520221829414368, -0.2065541297197342, -0.15892016887664795, 0.28850072622299194, -0.19730685651302338, 0.16933922469615936, -0.2757452726364136, -0.2216944843530655, 0.7144685983657837, -0.6419551968574524, 0.7715867161750793, 0.07966578751802444, -0.20133796334266663, 0.561219334602356, 0.3575904965400696, 0.35661789774894714, 0.02008442021906376, -0.2879692614078522, 0.073013074696064, 0.015082287602126598, -0.1465151160955429, -0.6873093843460083, 1.048410177230835, -0.7371267676353455, -0.8045855164527893, -0.33538907766342163, -0.5615159869194031, -0.4762411415576935, 0.2260257750749588, 0.013991889543831348, 0.6400756239891052, -0.327117383480072, 0.07268665730953217, 0.6699994802474976, 0.12246163934469223, 0.2419975996017456, 1.2576630115509033, -0.5007104277610779, -0.20094899833202362, 1.0250669717788696, 0.1395977884531021, 0.2779408097267151, 0.53737872838974, -0.2570852041244507, -0.48955899477005005, -0.34650421142578125, -0.48585131764411926, 0.4250919818878174, -1.0329607725143433, -0.4614867866039276, -0.27220380306243896, -0.30084019899368286, -0.19498345255851746, 0.023113109171390533, -0.14552344381809235, -0.2753698527812958, -0.3162184953689575, 0.025883179157972336, 0.03425990417599678, 0.6149916052818298, -0.09763562679290771, 0.3437712788581848, -0.9877854585647583, 0.3412746489048004, 0.5921708345413208, 0.3286602795124054, -0.1698760986328125, -0.7524557709693909, -0.2755781412124634, -0.11478804796934128, -0.5410640835762024, -0.8263092637062073, 0.6092182397842407, 0.1353822499513626, 0.4365371763706207, 0.2181294858455658, 0.02828245237469673, 0.8699754476547241, -0.6679283380508423, 0.7598273754119873, 0.2074078470468521, -1.0846059322357178, 0.24129721522331238, -0.42489856481552124, 0.20585866272449493, 0.3635256290435791, 0.15367715060710907, -1.0565062761306763, -0.3513413965702057, -0.6319608092308044, -0.6755449771881104, 0.6808366775512695, 0.21200528740882874, 0.07784120738506317, -0.04845871031284332, 0.6053208708763123, -0.3099444508552551, 0.21891455352306366, -0.7265855073928833, -0.27766987681388855, 0.1769220530986786, 0.2804073989391327, -0.022690366953611374, -0.47468066215515137, 0.0473836250603199, -0.12674535810947418, 0.8091898560523987, -0.08598362654447556, 0.5293797254562378, 0.04783302918076515, -0.26549863815307617, -0.40110668540000916, 0.25262266397476196, 0.5072565078735352, 0.5570852160453796, -0.07473410665988922, 0.3638741970062256, 0.4081999361515045, -0.26493287086486816, 0.16947411000728607, -0.1277545690536499, -0.028760815039277077, 0.11177923530340195, 0.2923298180103302, 0.7062792181968689, 0.421561062335968, -0.47470226883888245, 0.1022682785987854, 0.0597742535173893, 0.023109277710318565, -0.0658545270562172, -0.08367149531841278, 0.22053579986095428, 0.02184389904141426, 0.5608423352241516, 0.22779902815818787, 0.04752008989453316, -0.44440996646881104, 0.07039685547351837, 0.18923254311084747, -0.6340895295143127, -0.1519280970096588, 0.594127893447876, 0.8902692794799805, -0.3365497291088104, 0.8504530787467957, -0.01586531102657318, -0.5240676403045654, 0.40937888622283936, 0.9737570881843567, 0.5391712188720703, -0.36370640993118286, 0.09660151600837708, 0.20528897643089294, -0.024243734776973724, 0.165988951921463, -0.201920747756958, -0.1824558973312378, -1.2603613138198853, -0.5149422287940979, -0.4165220260620117, -0.9371120929718018, 0.40305444598197937, -0.4602286219596863, -0.06780340522527695, -0.39919522404670715, -0.44295036792755127, -0.08927464485168457, 0.15957461297512054, -0.5623772144317627, 0.1934012472629547, 0.2071777731180191, 0.9614053964614868, -0.5748905539512634, 0.8869070410728455, 0.942111611366272, -0.20960646867752075, -0.5890284180641174, -0.11590361595153809, 0.0971565693616867, -0.5511848330497742, 0.864371120929718, 0.04587075114250183, -0.4169032871723175, 0.24474121630191803, -0.3098834753036499, -0.9096803665161133, 0.8553358316421509, 0.48525547981262207, -0.7977498769760132, -0.1586090475320816, 0.021637974306941032, 0.6444054841995239, -0.42359286546707153, 0.3069896399974823, 0.5178888440132141, 0.2575985789299011, 0.22076082229614258, -1.183648705482483, 0.14584477245807648, -0.2837631106376648, 0.6007139086723328, 0.2809176743030548, -0.6890169382095337, 0.6024894118309021, -0.12689904868602753, -0.4409891963005066, 0.14245040714740753, 1.0181151628494263, 0.439401775598526, 0.018263543024659157, 0.4543144404888153, 0.26826727390289307, 0.6572032570838928, -0.20985084772109985, 0.789605438709259, -0.5043621063232422, 0.5233787298202515, 0.8458644151687622, -0.601737916469574, 0.786262571811676, 0.7029352188110352, -0.3068600296974182, 0.5002720355987549, 0.4652348756790161, 0.5493870973587036, 0.4492049217224121, 0.16198652982711792, -0.7409328818321228, -0.5205162763595581, -0.37471723556518555, -0.2255748212337494, -0.14342418313026428, 0.7359316349029541, -0.11339061707258224, -0.4140223562717438, 0.017311343923211098, -0.2929318845272064, 0.33348962664604187, -0.516527533531189, 0.5535693168640137, 0.24466873705387115, -0.5806804299354553, 0.4296581447124481, 0.3508431315422058, 0.5439051985740662, -0.38482430577278137, -0.09526387602090836, -0.18610075116157532, 0.2875077724456787, -0.2379266768693924, -0.20886535942554474, 0.4256177246570587, 0.10223390907049179, -0.43047547340393066, -0.375720739364624, 0.920935869216919, -0.3732665479183197, -0.20485134422779083, 0.21352681517601013, 0.600149393081665, 0.24806565046310425, -0.02668025717139244, -0.44341394305229187, 0.04283351078629494, 0.07112058252096176, -0.06540336459875107, 0.24848312139511108, 0.40719807147979736, -0.26594093441963196, 0.8875892162322998, 0.46846163272857666, 0.1166684478521347, -0.1446816623210907, 0.1021091416478157, 0.9500006437301636, -0.6917053461074829, -0.2584277093410492, -0.5616007447242737, 0.16433706879615784, -0.051943495869636536, -0.07710772007703781, 0.5414221286773682, 0.5954269170761108, 0.5815334320068359, -0.04004323109984398, 0.6664557456970215, -0.11039941012859344, 0.7355443239212036, -0.48868685960769653, 0.22576728463172913, -0.3893415629863739, 0.5961176156997681, -0.09822183102369308, -0.9609541296958923, -0.5676110982894897, 0.6919770240783691, -0.4675140380859375, 0.12877856194972992, 0.8985130786895752, 0.7817456126213074, 0.02107710763812065, 0.02494768239557743, 0.8163702487945557, 0.09526567906141281, 0.5836551189422607, 0.551210880279541, 0.886115550994873, -0.3437389135360718, 0.6323999166488647, -0.06337634474039078, -0.2556990683078766, -0.4920957386493683, -1.0587671995162964, -0.6022992134094238, -0.8089848756790161, -0.3999241292476654, -0.4433179497718811, 0.04014299064874649, 0.7786177396774292, 0.929126501083374, -0.7941172122955322, -0.3372196555137634, 0.225486159324646, 0.028632478788495064, 0.10928456485271454, -0.17197482287883759, -0.1213911697268486, -0.29300302267074585, -0.8653228282928467, 0.5575367212295532, 0.26681992411613464, 0.12639489769935608, -0.3588627278804779, -0.21355988085269928, 0.33518269658088684, 0.0033358922228217125, 0.7591192126274109, 0.3756655752658844, -0.7886592149734497, -0.4096803069114685, -0.11007949709892273, -0.6438125371932983, 0.043450977653265, 1.2344765663146973, -1.0730829238891602, 0.34847909212112427, 0.2703406512737274, 0.3380228579044342, 0.7371690273284912, 0.1605450063943863, 0.48787370324134827, -0.7784140110015869, 0.12728111445903778, 0.2864430546760559, 0.4647558331489563, 0.47184494137763977, -0.28575944900512695, 0.46643030643463135, 0.4732644259929657, -0.5271644592285156, -0.48111817240715027, 0.357444167137146, -0.8476346135139465, -0.07714441418647766, 0.9826599359512329, -0.07297651469707489, -0.13116106390953064, -0.28041765093803406, -0.3622543513774872, 0.12568224966526031, -0.4886040985584259, 0.5282308459281921, 0.8636248707771301, -0.41273120045661926, -0.2128194123506546, -0.4650486409664154, 0.31361016631126404, 0.3103218674659729, -0.6154840588569641, 0.1596044898033142, 0.8255760073661804, 0.2758733630180359, 0.7204277515411377, 0.9452120661735535, -0.12600365281105042, -0.0045492639765143394, -0.1985333412885666, -0.05734605714678764, -0.030888667330145836, -0.23731672763824463, -0.10633309185504913, 0.18892647325992584, 0.5108929872512817, 0.1409304141998291 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20327v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20327v1
Gecko: Versatile Text Embeddings Distilled from Large Language Models
2024-03-29T17:56:40
2024-03-29T17:56:40
Jinhyuk Lee, Zhuyun Dai, Xiaoqi Ren, Blair Chen, Daniel Cer, Jeremy R. Cole, Kai Hui, Michael Boratko, Rajvi Kapadia, Wen Ding, Yi Luan, Sai Meher Karthik Duddu, Gustavo Hernandez Abrego, Weiqiang Shi, Nithi Gupta, Aditya Kusupati, Prateek Jain, Siddhartha Reddy Jonnalagadda, Ming-Wei Chang, Iftekhar Naim
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI
We present Gecko, a compact and versatile text embedding model. Gecko achieves strong retrieval performance by leveraging a key idea: distilling knowledge from large language models (LLMs) into a retriever. Our two-step distillation process begins with generating diverse, synthetic paired data using an LLM. Next, we further refine the data quality by retrieving a set of candidate passages for each query, and relabeling the positive and hard negative passages using the same LLM. The effectiveness of our approach is demonstrated by the compactness of the Gecko. On the Massive Text Embedding Benchmark (MTEB), Gecko with 256 embedding dimensions outperforms all existing entries with 768 embedding size. Gecko with 768 embedding dimensions achieves an average score of 66.31, competing with 7x larger models and 5x higher dimensional embeddings.
[ -0.3258736729621887, -0.9221094846725464, 0.5580884218215942, 0.1577625274658203, -0.6367738842964172, 0.1901923418045044, -0.4777136743068695, -0.41505303978919983, 0.33478161692619324, 0.44322469830513, 0.15560400485992432, -0.6971743106842041, -0.7627653479576111, -0.007130251731723547, -0.6100031137466431, 1.0250483751296997, 0.0960313156247139, -0.08293768018484116, -0.24540826678276062, -0.09883378446102142, -0.32565727829933167, -0.5903252363204956, -0.20591719448566437, -0.4877459406852722, 0.42501938343048096, 0.41561073064804077, 0.9297300577163696, 0.8383830785751343, 0.20086254179477692, 0.2751195430755615, -0.39003267884254456, 0.1465810090303421, -0.7185065150260925, 0.29221147298812866, -0.2572018504142761, -0.3786841928958893, -0.06296001374721527, 0.07518273591995239, 0.6707712411880493, 0.6084349751472473, -0.7125638127326965, -0.10403163731098175, 0.353762686252594, 0.5173100829124451, -0.7396904826164246, 0.13257969915866852, -0.6686145067214966, 0.1352621614933014, -0.44165313243865967, 0.10997992753982544, -0.7313423752784729, -0.658422589302063, 0.17566071450710297, -0.6389901638031006, 0.25055742263793945, 0.16075898706912994, 0.7580638527870178, -0.016999218612909317, -0.6179566383361816, -0.685127854347229, -0.7417038679122925, 0.911651611328125, -0.5412558913230896, 0.28810736536979675, 0.32996734976768494, 0.45438164472579956, -0.09613481909036636, -1.0859589576721191, -0.48328810930252075, -0.2643916606903076, -0.11509587615728378, -0.2905274033546448, -0.25025200843811035, -0.12475963681936264, 0.03897968307137489, 0.7253826260566711, -0.5463716387748718, -0.0200826283544302, -0.05672203749418259, -0.21721813082695007, 0.5231257677078247, 0.0770455002784729, 0.3865509033203125, -0.05821072682738304, -0.29558974504470825, -0.2733542323112488, -0.6166983842849731, -0.19114381074905396, 0.5686317682266235, 0.2577912211418152, 0.4783630669116974, 0.529258668422699, -0.09862954914569855, 0.6272538304328918, -0.0271715447306633, -0.005656309891492128, 0.13585294783115387, -0.2797737419605255, -0.1266554892063141, 0.21430684626102448, 0.9155294895172119, 0.16159971058368683, 0.18242132663726807, -0.19250619411468506, -0.3014967441558838, -0.07625516504049301, 0.3816238045692444, -1.028041958808899, -0.44065338373184204, -0.16542929410934448, -0.33510059118270874, -0.44461846351623535, 0.06608663499355316, -0.8556900024414062, -0.551989734172821, 0.09569990634918213, 0.33488205075263977, -0.6853565573692322, -0.08898954838514328, 0.3456145226955414, -0.5870034694671631, 0.236794576048851, 0.38090282678604126, -1.25199556350708, 0.533024251461029, 0.7178772687911987, 0.6762831807136536, 0.26056018471717834, -0.003832306480035186, -0.6009037494659424, 0.11661963909864426, -0.46080759167671204, 0.6340840458869934, -1.1732653379440308, -0.8086491227149963, -0.04946763068437576, -0.07609618455171585, 0.33843478560447693, -0.5017436146736145, 0.6166654825210571, -0.638632595539093, 0.13786408305168152, -0.4014948010444641, -0.6884352564811707, -0.414458692073822, 0.29880571365356445, -0.7974756360054016, 1.098794937133789, 0.04365554824471474, -0.7302184700965881, 0.17128188908100128, -0.032398492097854614, -0.4651723802089691, 0.02530713379383087, 0.04213754087686539, -0.2648695707321167, 0.14396682381629944, 0.2096220999956131, 0.4496404826641083, -0.5116546750068665, 0.10028678923845291, -0.46762678027153015, -0.38953474164009094, 0.08689526468515396, -0.30844932794570923, 0.3553028404712677, 0.11110614240169525, 0.17643815279006958, -0.37283656001091003, -0.6388363242149353, 0.06083165481686592, 0.27050524950027466, -0.51229327917099, -0.9561908841133118, 0.13181918859481812, -0.021471599116921425, -0.04341398552060127, 0.45940038561820984, -0.6488251686096191, 0.4553127884864807, -0.20958058536052704, 0.7532345652580261, 0.5383720397949219, -0.11259303241968155, 0.5291140675544739, 0.12655875086784363, 0.386178582906723, -0.2632025182247162, 0.008257828652858734, 0.0668494701385498, -0.48929721117019653, -0.46089833974838257, -0.12488437443971634, 0.48896872997283936, 0.3653883934020996, -0.7599598169326782, 0.21026991307735443, -0.21719981729984283, -0.8785703182220459, -0.3317165970802307, 0.5411572456359863, 0.5220674276351929, 0.335195928812027, 0.2756858468055725, -0.3318653702735901, -0.1003817468881607, -0.9053269624710083, -0.060571350157260895, 0.146297425031662, 0.003415043232962489, 0.42283007502555847, 0.5010624527931213, -0.3791186809539795, 0.6396545767784119, -0.8485052585601807, -0.13576757907867432, -0.36163705587387085, 0.2164151966571808, 0.2314203530550003, 0.2302364557981491, 0.5833144783973694, -0.8539710640907288, -0.748028576374054, 0.2567041218280792, -0.8596615791320801, 0.28405410051345825, 0.37150904536247253, -0.0456157848238945, -0.20607520639896393, 0.38353028893470764, -0.3804817497730255, 0.03978164866566658, 0.7005413770675659, -0.27106186747550964, 0.44545868039131165, -0.6369399428367615, 0.033982161432504654, -1.160849690437317, 0.14933955669403076, 0.16180196404457092, -0.4425603449344635, -0.37790802121162415, 0.09555021673440933, 0.40997034311294556, -0.16274197399616241, -0.3522489368915558, 0.3045409917831421, -0.67586350440979, 0.018753791227936745, -0.0940336212515831, 0.7347294688224792, 0.3063321113586426, 0.1544298529624939, -0.4572562873363495, 0.8523783683776855, 0.29236146807670593, -0.5750395059585571, 0.7778130769729614, 0.41183629631996155, -0.44817203283309937, 0.17884410917758942, -1.0198142528533936, 0.34286731481552124, 0.04545794054865837, 0.3768376410007477, -1.065258502960205, -0.24398086965084076, -0.1262379288673401, -0.18703912198543549, 0.6647417545318604, -0.1352580338716507, -0.662058413028717, -0.47608482837677, -0.6859577894210815, 0.3288537561893463, 0.5511857271194458, -0.49956369400024414, 0.42017072439193726, 0.7548343539237976, -0.4565693140029907, -0.8374828696250916, -0.5846622586250305, 0.3284681737422943, -0.12188234180212021, -0.5536552667617798, 0.4820115864276886, 0.12240243703126907, -0.026605993509292603, 0.38734692335128784, 0.15683592855930328, -0.04550887644290924, 0.0005615449044853449, -0.056783758103847504, 0.23356178402900696, -0.13391558825969696, 0.25051140785217285, 0.1942339688539505, -0.2742825448513031, -0.37121158838272095, -0.25195547938346863, 0.6420167684555054, -0.2428217977285385, -0.20309405028820038, -0.04549098387360573, 0.3331657946109772, 0.37918493151664734, -0.36625200510025024, 0.6679893136024475, 0.33398178219795227, -0.2611464262008667, -0.44568994641304016, -0.3153812885284424, 0.14602625370025635, -0.5193505883216858, 0.3441013693809509, -0.2570205628871918, -1.0285841226577759, 0.5854999423027039, -0.07454916089773178, -0.11166540533304214, 0.37805458903312683, 0.40460842847824097, 0.16235248744487762, 1.0723425149917603, 0.8341502547264099, -0.28719255328178406, 0.4908963441848755, -0.12438487261533737, 0.05791780725121498, -0.8368638753890991, -0.2151222825050354, -0.7038047313690186, -0.3886967897415161, -0.5651983022689819, -0.4612540602684021, 0.009091468527913094, 0.3140767216682434, 0.028770234435796738, 0.6466338038444519, -0.7773250341415405, 0.7017054557800293, 0.5515180230140686, -0.01380300521850586, 0.2354516088962555, -0.1991012990474701, -0.4770788550376892, -0.011039376258850098, -0.21206139028072357, -0.7889569997787476, 1.3103355169296265, 0.14041045308113098, 1.2532274723052979, 0.2747425436973572, 0.6327098608016968, 0.3802531957626343, 0.16026003658771515, -0.7791920304298401, 0.5797359347343445, -0.4880942702293396, -0.5824198722839355, -0.39413267374038696, -0.22586388885974884, -0.9020693302154541, 0.5145776867866516, -0.035369161516427994, -0.9586606025695801, -0.12280985713005066, -0.012806903570890427, -0.18671053647994995, 0.22235575318336487, -0.6470350623130798, 0.8029875159263611, 0.06900658458471298, -0.2778087556362152, -0.541731059551239, -0.3958706855773926, 0.3432810306549072, -0.16145643591880798, -0.13992373645305634, -0.11560425907373428, -0.0864180475473404, 0.5905876755714417, -0.42768216133117676, 0.6801185607910156, -0.13800328969955444, -0.2530306279659271, 0.39437341690063477, 0.16347669064998627, 0.8874140381813049, 0.16122233867645264, -0.4128659665584564, -0.028581013903021812, -0.08380988985300064, -0.1529955267906189, -0.7720341682434082, 1.0091006755828857, -0.7521965503692627, -0.684145450592041, -0.3483189046382904, -0.10875967144966125, -0.09107398986816406, 0.33044710755348206, 0.21174398064613342, 0.7192268371582031, -0.5682937502861023, 0.9133214354515076, 0.950124204158783, -0.4912946820259094, 0.32687658071517944, 0.41689836978912354, -0.3960762321949005, -0.48297828435897827, 0.9587485790252686, 0.19286708533763885, 0.11433860659599304, 0.6340216398239136, 0.20456866919994354, -0.6712043285369873, -0.44061794877052307, -0.426475465297699, 0.25221049785614014, -0.9478596448898315, -0.04466026648879051, -0.5899242758750916, -0.16587112843990326, -0.1431368589401245, -0.17472317814826965, -0.5950881838798523, -0.2688103914260864, -0.3875870108604431, -0.1363905668258667, 0.16777218878269196, 1.0177631378173828, 0.09539671987295151, 0.1465309113264084, -1.0251741409301758, 0.15016011893749237, 0.5774151682853699, 0.35519149899482727, -0.09835992753505707, -0.4665151536464691, -0.19796426594257355, -0.017866572365164757, -0.48616480827331543, -0.8637421727180481, 0.4683857560157776, 0.30401182174682617, 0.777381956577301, 0.5338969826698303, 0.13264615833759308, 0.42402908205986023, -0.7267391085624695, 0.9779388308525085, 0.1562039703130722, -1.0158374309539795, 0.7564370036125183, -0.2958758473396301, -0.21789886057376862, 0.47250428795814514, 0.37904801964759827, -0.5896193981170654, -0.2723609507083893, -0.44659167528152466, -0.7794433236122131, 0.3997375965118408, 0.03422514721751213, 0.43227893114089966, -0.07957223802804947, 0.30091527104377747, 0.27228838205337524, 0.2095465064048767, -0.2790262699127197, -0.042442772537469864, -0.11284680664539337, -0.07707132399082184, -0.5504019260406494, -0.576104462146759, -0.08238090574741364, -0.10323753952980042, 0.5967591404914856, -0.07678039371967316, 0.17852739989757538, -0.13370700180530548, -0.31241098046302795, 0.29109859466552734, 0.32590270042419434, 0.4815112054347992, 0.32648417353630066, -0.1802096664905548, 0.2600118815898895, 0.2371172308921814, -0.6988316774368286, 0.23559263348579407, 0.1985989809036255, 0.26986783742904663, 0.19133616983890533, 0.1382751613855362, 0.5095087289810181, 0.4597540497779846, -0.44951972365379333, 0.563984751701355, -0.2848917841911316, 0.08713244646787643, -0.02165982685983181, 0.4064289331436157, 0.3245566785335541, 0.13298891484737396, 0.25816288590431213, -0.4240249991416931, 0.3494371771812439, -0.503899097442627, 0.23654401302337646, 0.32395607233047485, -0.40269172191619873, -0.34187543392181396, 0.6886293888092041, 0.3299923241138458, -0.06087283417582512, 0.7973646521568298, -0.18591082096099854, -0.24888865649700165, 0.5180820226669312, 0.6369953751564026, 0.800159215927124, -0.19609545171260834, 0.3214414119720459, 0.1924639493227005, 0.052390147000551224, -0.34082600474357605, -0.01720942184329033, -0.07984589785337448, -0.6942999362945557, -0.17295774817466736, -0.788476824760437, -0.6880950927734375, -0.3051374852657318, -0.8398964405059814, 0.27712082862854004, -0.45733949542045593, -0.22046299278736115, 0.20666374266147614, 0.28814607858657837, -0.5042312741279602, -0.0993214100599289, 0.15556178987026215, 1.086064100265503, -0.6189731359481812, 1.24254310131073, 0.6550543904304504, -0.42899009585380554, -0.8804788589477539, -0.156865656375885, 0.14582571387290955, -0.8694475293159485, 0.37567952275276184, 0.22748038172721863, -0.12637946009635925, 0.019615575671195984, -0.4620544910430908, -0.7356788516044617, 1.3767104148864746, 0.589910089969635, -0.8472345471382141, 0.06766051799058914, -0.11807896196842194, 0.5882657170295715, -0.0972953587770462, 0.16531097888946533, 0.4241786599159241, 0.22987766563892365, 0.18029730021953583, -0.7814817428588867, 0.13318192958831787, -0.4417930543422699, 0.4256272614002228, 0.39195358753204346, -0.7365339994430542, 1.013461947441101, -0.07670817524194717, -0.2990926504135132, -0.06726078689098358, 0.43330681324005127, 0.04706258699297905, -0.0937235951423645, 0.19213709235191345, 0.7993184328079224, 1.2218000888824463, -0.20751407742500305, 1.3800897598266602, -0.3512641191482544, 0.6877521276473999, 1.0030115842819214, -0.47132086753845215, 1.1077067852020264, 0.25236010551452637, -0.11100442707538605, 0.8102871775627136, 0.45952072739601135, 0.07653652876615524, 0.7562249898910522, 0.08637940883636475, -0.38770413398742676, -0.4279491603374481, 0.11341921985149384, -0.6485096216201782, 0.41752704977989197, 0.4963633120059967, -0.47830408811569214, -0.5285909175872803, 0.05819598585367203, -0.05970391258597374, 0.15271024405956268, 0.11383199691772461, 0.6398962736129761, 0.29396501183509827, -0.42497777938842773, 0.36880937218666077, 0.11402737349271774, 0.5655915141105652, -0.7645788192749023, -0.09341612458229065, -0.22474098205566406, 0.5511481165885925, 0.16737616062164307, -1.3087658882141113, 0.02040947414934635, -0.07946726679801941, -0.21202509105205536, -0.22582928836345673, 1.0413740873336792, -0.31485414505004883, -0.1567627638578415, 0.4838015139102936, 0.07248630374670029, 0.05178631842136383, -0.07250815629959106, -0.41191479563713074, 0.1933322548866272, -0.027067257091403008, -0.5911926031112671, 0.39732295274734497, 0.8936046361923218, 0.14931245148181915, 0.9327287673950195, 0.6582518815994263, -0.11193164438009262, -0.2028585523366928, -0.11362884938716888, 1.2184827327728271, -0.7711146473884583, -0.6415877938270569, -1.065012812614441, 0.2942662537097931, -0.2991771996021271, -0.24645684659481049, 1.047652006149292, 0.6349997520446777, 0.46212640404701233, 0.041386209428310394, 0.8091788291931152, 0.06874538213014603, 0.22887161374092102, -0.37790656089782715, 0.7942031025886536, -0.5775352120399475, 0.18992368876934052, -0.30861756205558777, -0.9673593044281006, -0.15284375846385956, 0.546741247177124, -0.3725799024105072, -0.2615576684474945, 0.3878980278968811, 0.7793235182762146, -0.15212130546569824, 0.23070970177650452, 0.38649362325668335, -0.032665714621543884, 0.6870265007019043, 0.7103240489959717, 0.8541954159736633, -0.38882145285606384, 0.7773534655570984, 0.09644681215286255, -0.11282327771186829, -0.65636146068573, -0.8719197511672974, -0.7305200099945068, -0.3525325059890747, -0.10657098144292831, -0.2242475003004074, -0.0907672792673111, 0.5033488869667053, 0.5446150302886963, -0.6401655673980713, 0.20828816294670105, 0.1207524761557579, 0.19570787250995636, 0.028104448691010475, -0.17750871181488037, 0.11462737619876862, -0.32245269417762756, -0.8684783577919006, 0.2697782814502716, 0.4830426573753357, 0.004642080515623093, -0.29653191566467285, -0.20027068257331848, -0.013846883550286293, 0.15502166748046875, 0.6872379183769226, 0.23628035187721252, -0.37854209542274475, -0.5865492224693298, -0.15769250690937042, -0.7622465491294861, -0.1652044802904129, 0.5306052565574646, -0.5570729970932007, 0.7571840286254883, 0.6716120839118958, 0.7187843918800354, 0.7180001139640808, -0.13797922432422638, 0.6648111939430237, -0.9002795219421387, 0.24009369313716888, 0.18159501254558563, 0.5322319865226746, 0.31747597455978394, -0.25359153747558594, 0.4062267243862152, 0.13358914852142334, -0.6092804074287415, -0.636181652545929, -0.232334166765213, -0.9111665487289429, -0.4309976398944855, 1.3274028301239014, -0.26835203170776367, -0.192421555519104, 0.15379726886749268, -0.30457815527915955, 0.09283486008644104, -0.45385363698005676, 0.5188572406768799, 1.051682472229004, 0.30811429023742676, 0.18797597289085388, -0.5532181859016418, 0.17228108644485474, -0.1721707433462143, -0.48378491401672363, -0.026856383308768272, 0.5089617967605591, 0.5303606986999512, 0.3589409291744232, 0.5088660717010498, -0.27737823128700256, -0.029231104999780655, 0.47037506103515625, -0.009970685467123985, -0.14475053548812866, -0.3822300136089325, -0.0858171135187149, 0.42022985219955444, 0.062195468693971634, -0.33102381229400635 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20322v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20322v2
Towards a Framework for Evaluating Explanations in Automated Fact Verification
2024-03-29T17:50:28
2024-05-19T15:07:07
Neema Kotonya, Francesca Toni
cs.CL
cs.CL
As deep neural models in NLP become more complex, and as a consequence opaque, the necessity to interpret them becomes greater. A burgeoning interest has emerged in rationalizing explanations to provide short and coherent justifications for predictions. In this position paper, we advocate for a formal framework for key concepts and properties about rationalizing explanations to support their evaluation systematically. We also outline one such formal framework, tailored to rationalizing explanations of increasingly complex structures, from free-form explanations to deductive explanations, to argumentative explanations (with the richest structure). Focusing on the automated fact verification task, we provide illustrations of the use and usefulness of our formalization for evaluating explanations, tailored to their varying structures.
[ -0.23756714165210724, -1.0039443969726562, 0.9467993974685669, 0.3882354199886322, -0.08496557176113129, -0.3858242332935333, -0.3268146216869354, -0.21843384206295013, -0.1686939150094986, -0.0498305968940258, -0.493974506855011, -0.26138681173324585, -0.5297554731369019, 0.1960311084985733, -0.5005834698677063, 0.9475641250610352, -0.22363074123859406, 0.0680885836482048, -0.5010877251625061, 0.03499530255794525, -0.4238071143627167, -0.24948398768901825, -0.5980222821235657, -0.621215283870697, 0.6940771341323853, 0.20800501108169556, 1.036365032196045, 1.1541192531585693, 0.2815261483192444, 0.439924031496048, 0.021917076781392097, 0.2186000943183899, -0.07923424988985062, 0.2674870491027832, -0.4684545695781708, -0.4131578505039215, -0.4239727854728699, 0.07958350330591202, 0.5384536981582642, 1.2684822082519531, 0.18733720481395721, 0.1287553757429123, -0.09022043645381927, 0.7908989191055298, -0.5047332048416138, 0.4194544553756714, -0.461373895406723, 0.2227623164653778, 0.3405277132987976, -0.4385300576686859, -0.3430444002151489, -0.4738742411136627, 0.3810453414916992, -0.6209661364555359, 0.35659509897232056, 0.1657918393611908, 0.9346381425857544, 0.28343552350997925, -0.44463634490966797, -0.3318607807159424, -0.8691760897636414, 0.5957843661308289, -0.44752079248428345, 0.4778470993041992, 0.3436752259731293, 0.6643387675285339, -0.13460969924926758, -0.7116003036499023, -0.4708091616630554, -0.4281577467918396, -0.4066764712333679, -0.02508087456226349, -0.09556566923856735, 0.39539244771003723, 0.39801061153411865, 0.5718885660171509, -0.5819672346115112, -0.15800626575946808, -0.25553619861602783, -0.3802870213985443, 0.8098269701004028, 0.09654460102319717, 0.30144184827804565, -0.08387918025255203, -0.4566856026649475, 0.3498126268386841, -0.4380249083042145, 0.07404754310846329, 0.3194408416748047, 0.010390576906502247, -0.1477118283510208, 0.5618001818656921, -0.25538215041160583, 0.6036327481269836, 0.22411543130874634, 0.1772267073392868, -0.1881144642829895, -0.4153743088245392, -0.5487440228462219, 0.24187219142913818, 0.39483845233917236, 0.33909881114959717, 0.205083429813385, -0.4821282625198364, -0.33755287528038025, 0.3184259831905365, 0.020538020879030228, -0.8891354203224182, -0.2335319072008133, 0.7996903657913208, -0.7909089922904968, -0.28723111748695374, -0.04777269810438156, -0.49315476417541504, -0.4021012485027313, -0.78841233253479, 0.22980843484401703, -0.16009242832660675, -0.1575315147638321, 0.6921226978302002, -0.30871322751045227, 0.11550066620111465, 0.6671128869056702, -0.9208624362945557, 0.3191089630126953, 0.9700465202331543, 0.634905993938446, 0.14803321659564972, -0.12891517579555511, -0.4222312271595001, -0.15841060876846313, -0.7323287725448608, 0.8171971440315247, -0.3096114993095398, 0.28139108419418335, -0.05415915325284004, 0.05774499848484993, -0.005072326865047216, -0.1686868518590927, 0.7841106057167053, -0.611096203327179, 0.2880711853504181, -0.45515894889831543, -0.6776978969573975, -0.7258573174476624, 0.5659494400024414, -0.6538496017456055, 0.2490919828414917, -0.03182480111718178, -0.6505159139633179, 0.6158576607704163, -1.1568503379821777, -0.33448028564453125, 0.03452480956912041, -0.011203007772564888, -0.07012764364480972, 0.052588313817977905, 0.18023619055747986, 0.6194936633110046, -0.4728889763355255, 0.7803885340690613, -0.5428654551506042, -0.16520343720912933, 0.5653952360153198, -0.6668662428855896, 1.095890760421753, 0.3450336456298828, -0.6628493070602417, 0.3740859925746918, -0.9440978169441223, 0.0058905817568302155, -0.025294609367847443, -0.061749495565891266, -0.13027805089950562, 0.24714890122413635, -0.5418352484703064, -0.13621820509433746, 0.1390359103679657, -0.25929129123687744, -0.12056510895490646, -0.722815990447998, 0.4999745488166809, 0.7117594480514526, 0.1305285543203354, 0.7789044976234436, -0.26673007011413574, 0.5138941407203674, 0.004416535142809153, 0.3172730803489685, -0.35925838351249695, -0.19133415818214417, -0.699866533279419, -0.437020480632782, 0.4842032790184021, 0.3294127583503723, -0.0881800428032875, 0.4713299572467804, -0.11741766333580017, -0.1182137057185173, -0.05721300095319748, -0.24510662257671356, 0.2525061070919037, 0.6765488386154175, 0.313379168510437, 0.24875588715076447, -0.9498723149299622, -1.1729135513305664, -0.37006211280822754, -0.19608961045742035, -0.2734110653400421, 0.07742463052272797, 0.6638081669807434, -0.3630644977092743, 1.1330260038375854, 0.06101889908313751, 0.32769274711608887, -0.0935395210981369, 0.30474215745925903, 0.25287944078445435, 0.49860623478889465, 0.4263288974761963, -0.8969363570213318, 0.1838247925043106, -0.2911131680011749, -0.8830924034118652, -0.008326551876962185, -0.6005289554595947, -0.20668838918209076, -0.17053362727165222, 0.3922794759273529, -0.6559106111526489, 0.3991125822067261, 0.11499561369419098, -0.49910789728164673, 0.5543356537818909, -0.01899406872689724, 0.14893104135990143, -0.30278003215789795, 0.0803285464644432, -0.041706569492816925, -0.378900945186615, -0.4484885334968567, 0.21800892055034637, -0.3815076947212219, 0.1693853735923767, -0.003773732343688607, 0.3890259563922882, -0.33192577958106995, -0.09477472305297852, 0.05767675116658211, 0.34256500005722046, 0.5247914791107178, 0.311271607875824, -0.12112332135438919, 0.14466272294521332, 0.5479100346565247, -0.8581991791725159, 0.5458256602287292, 0.06639104336500168, -0.37178176641464233, 0.29464414715766907, -1.2148497104644775, -0.4385344088077545, -0.3246447741985321, 0.47384053468704224, -1.0573214292526245, -0.44887813925743103, 0.39846929907798767, -0.360420823097229, -0.18302659690380096, -0.6495397686958313, -0.35320815443992615, -0.18591350317001343, -0.2017642706632614, 0.3615114390850067, 0.14790090918540955, -0.7541829347610474, 0.8121308088302612, -0.0307783056050539, 0.3112485408782959, -0.6149887442588806, -0.5813684463500977, 0.0006741235265508294, -0.31595224142074585, -1.0769293308258057, 0.4423786699771881, -0.1766916811466217, -0.9207621216773987, -0.05953940749168396, -0.42482659220695496, -0.35981839895248413, 0.8066277503967285, 0.4219419062137604, 0.16451674699783325, -0.748406708240509, 0.29076483845710754, 0.09339002519845963, -0.2992027699947357, 0.4456706941127777, -0.4444139897823334, -0.03872325271368027, -0.5530700087547302, -0.42949602007865906, -0.38328883051872253, 0.32940369844436646, 0.5777402520179749, -0.10572203248739243, 0.5327487587928772, 0.46695640683174133, -0.5776877403259277, -0.40721580386161804, -0.3519838750362396, -0.43970540165901184, -0.39796197414398193, -0.06846648454666138, -0.44177743792533875, -0.6484458446502686, 0.758171796798706, -0.0785963386297226, 0.2512519955635071, 0.8823157548904419, 0.7444371581077576, 0.056564975529909134, 1.3872874975204468, 0.44931960105895996, 0.630241870880127, -0.19554823637008667, -0.17854538559913635, 0.5297558903694153, -0.24577617645263672, -0.49239930510520935, -0.6433223485946655, -0.06266575306653976, -0.33311256766319275, -0.3222256004810333, -0.1300325095653534, 0.5175645351409912, -0.21599096059799194, -0.033602628856897354, -0.5232292413711548, 0.6815198659896851, 0.04297170788049698, -0.36022433638572693, 0.2432471066713333, -0.23411031067371368, -0.033651307225227356, 0.3295425772666931, -0.7855478525161743, -0.8789147138595581, 0.5542530417442322, 0.8648661971092224, 0.44442325830459595, -0.0907844677567482, 0.2923222780227661, 0.4102553427219391, 0.47937843203544617, -1.1284520626068115, 0.4042898714542389, 0.14529931545257568, -0.9877603054046631, -0.5955371260643005, -0.28484073281288147, -0.8966349959373474, 0.5499110221862793, -0.14259040355682373, -0.3561890125274658, 0.4081142842769623, 0.4825076162815094, -0.7485381364822388, -0.15572893619537354, -0.7593187093734741, 1.125349521636963, -0.3550155758857727, -0.21395277976989746, -0.35443779826164246, -0.3670172095298767, 0.7213984727859497, 0.36554062366485596, 0.2398177534341812, -0.3029559552669525, 0.058214619755744934, 0.5136841535568237, -0.6218091249465942, 0.7122823596000671, -0.37433984875679016, -0.21654658019542694, 0.25324004888534546, 0.21883675456047058, 0.1329667568206787, 0.5236783623695374, -0.3856828808784485, -0.04329543933272362, -0.03129523620009422, -0.25756222009658813, -1.1466912031173706, 0.3192903697490692, -0.35502925515174866, -0.6836196780204773, -0.13965760171413422, -0.4411624073982239, 0.07717733085155487, 0.14337338507175446, 0.01788732223212719, 0.7175172567367554, -0.11104931682348251, 0.4346567988395691, 0.8983225226402283, 0.11990196257829666, 0.2225133776664734, 0.2457049936056137, -0.11877065896987915, -0.13144294917583466, 0.5554459095001221, -0.039645005017519, -0.35447487235069275, 0.3355959951877594, 0.69188392162323, -0.5586974620819092, -0.7701070308685303, -0.6238648295402527, -0.21191942691802979, -1.0484875440597534, -0.011670570820569992, -0.5628310441970825, 0.11748417466878891, -0.1451701521873474, -0.3896767199039459, -0.07952291518449783, -0.9419806599617004, -0.06905465573072433, -0.3476634621620178, 0.2625061869621277, 0.6571690440177917, -0.08217360824346542, -0.08484439551830292, -0.47960442304611206, 0.7433956265449524, 0.4112759828567505, 0.6613271236419678, 0.007719190791249275, -0.5008811354637146, -0.07231698930263519, 0.3764084577560425, 0.20775483548641205, -0.5667292475700378, -0.1015838161110878, 0.1714470237493515, 0.6340136528015137, 0.43733450770378113, 0.08670436590909958, 0.7175675630569458, -0.34026506543159485, 0.7205324769020081, -0.03511343151330948, -1.1495826244354248, 0.6309168934822083, -0.22135041654109955, -0.22551032900810242, 0.3985271453857422, 0.5158692598342896, -0.27178359031677246, -0.02118069678544998, -0.7867364883422852, -0.9039974808692932, 0.313075989484787, 0.059989504516124725, -0.05698559060692787, 0.10888222604990005, 0.5788403749465942, 0.20416128635406494, 0.06262551248073578, -0.8553350567817688, -0.07753462344408035, -0.529384434223175, -0.16521498560905457, 0.3131871521472931, -0.48403650522232056, -0.8024395704269409, 0.02434445731341839, 0.6513164639472961, -0.31743013858795166, 0.09341147541999817, 0.6198897957801819, -0.4194425940513611, -0.03143462911248207, 0.34257054328918457, 0.766594648361206, 1.1651884317398071, 0.07539155334234238, 0.3007209300994873, -0.11932416260242462, 0.40758129954338074, 0.05859030410647392, 0.1593911498785019, -0.22955431044101715, 0.1567748337984085, 0.7749567031860352, 0.7577975392341614, 0.21397218108177185, -0.40916427969932556, 0.6657942533493042, -0.0516904816031456, -0.5249284505844116, -0.33551642298698425, 0.009468967095017433, -0.1387544423341751, 0.28110024333000183, 0.15855425596237183, 0.21521131694316864, 0.5823975801467896, -0.5165878534317017, 0.27414703369140625, 0.29540085792541504, -0.17471551895141602, -0.4088188409805298, 0.5009530186653137, 0.1593737155199051, 0.08356155455112457, 0.23555698990821838, -0.2399236112833023, -0.7037029266357422, 0.8340473771095276, 0.1868501454591751, 1.1212912797927856, 0.18361036479473114, 0.3144136667251587, 0.31101322174072266, 0.3497235178947449, -0.14018180966377258, 0.07950419932603836, -0.48959600925445557, -0.6063265204429626, -0.8581483960151672, -0.5302705764770508, -0.4961658716201782, 0.05798622965812683, -0.24158665537834167, 0.014478973113000393, -0.7522236704826355, 0.2250915765762329, 0.7204669117927551, -0.21881084144115448, -0.32568061351776123, 0.5860360860824585, 0.17639827728271484, 0.9112645387649536, -0.7911388278007507, 0.25068387389183044, 0.510363757610321, -0.5669170618057251, -0.8267229795455933, -0.17176814377307892, -0.01052449457347393, -0.6524520516395569, 0.9099737405776978, 0.16364900767803192, -0.491286039352417, -0.7825431823730469, -0.7524082064628601, -0.6746601462364197, 0.542328417301178, 0.6115246415138245, -0.30896803736686707, 0.014693633653223515, -0.08819273859262466, 0.7659945487976074, -0.5555050373077393, 0.2650555372238159, 0.46456366777420044, 0.9559777975082397, -0.12590284645557404, -0.25385093688964844, 0.36743786931037903, -0.10728128254413605, -0.13378040492534637, -0.3695002496242523, 0.01528359204530716, 0.4853469729423523, -0.372546523809433, -0.3327373266220093, -0.07306952029466629, 0.7855392694473267, -0.025002403184771538, 0.4011373817920685, 0.9036534428596497, 0.04710249602794647, 0.767834484577179, -0.3872380554676056, 1.1002404689788818, -0.3134535253047943, 0.05367521569132805, 1.000060796737671, 0.1942855268716812, 0.05002346262335777, 0.22872981429100037, 0.06676512956619263, 0.8280304670333862, 0.8521620035171509, -0.22414401173591614, 0.021143190562725067, 0.6242032051086426, 0.19782233238220215, -0.46205243468284607, -0.08444885164499283, -0.15288779139518738, 0.5817479491233826, 0.4049129784107208, -0.5012518167495728, -0.37560009956359863, -0.39276742935180664, -0.08067718148231506, 0.18354369699954987, -0.41868215799331665, 0.5527324676513672, -0.09056560695171356, -1.0320779085159302, 0.8662697076797485, 0.24870575964450836, -0.01793225295841694, -0.47807538509368896, -0.19668515026569366, 0.08988829702138901, 0.23305076360702515, -0.635940432548523, -0.7213221192359924, 0.7093397378921509, -0.1283542513847351, -0.6367512941360474, -0.6808804273605347, 0.6551523208618164, -0.41896262764930725, -0.045667048543691635, 0.046261850744485855, 0.1567515879869461, 0.01257230993360281, -0.07601548731327057, -1.0143611431121826, 0.012125015258789062, -0.14005489647388458, -0.4125373363494873, -0.2904008626937866, 0.8460701107978821, -0.16957904398441315, 0.6123362183570862, 0.8457333445549011, -0.3563280999660492, -0.23613926768302917, 0.4820719063282013, 0.5089623332023621, -0.3241494596004486, -0.47904396057128906, -1.1525144577026367, 0.8097702860832214, 0.009936883114278316, -0.07121314108371735, 0.6793975234031677, 0.5538375377655029, 0.35629376769065857, 0.02686285227537155, 0.6403727531433105, -0.02481560781598091, 0.15091679990291595, -0.5823860764503479, 0.453194260597229, -0.4391108751296997, 0.4594959318637848, 0.061960265040397644, -0.7996056079864502, -0.6369068026542664, 0.9457753896713257, -0.21802616119384766, -0.13535679876804352, 0.6338256597518921, 0.5411156415939331, -0.15481160581111908, 0.4690088629722595, 0.1321338713169098, 0.5649594664573669, 0.10803979635238647, -0.061368487775325775, 1.0543664693832397, -0.2880665361881256, 0.4679279327392578, -0.25674498081207275, -0.358023464679718, -0.2625899016857147, -1.5022954940795898, -0.7023811936378479, -0.5336127281188965, -0.6196382641792297, -0.4643550217151642, 0.000018073666069540195, 0.8126718997955322, 1.032021164894104, -0.9363847374916077, -0.0037796138785779476, -0.4920823574066162, 0.8477931022644043, -0.3953377902507782, -0.22365234792232513, 0.3689440190792084, -0.6372593641281128, -0.24299384653568268, 0.6165304780006409, 0.4828864336013794, -0.04154479131102562, -0.4532686769962311, 0.026496712118387222, 0.212457075715065, 0.49638766050338745, 0.8887163996696472, 0.17577075958251953, -0.9513036012649536, -0.4299163818359375, -0.13246257603168488, 0.19717593491077423, 0.12341330945491791, 1.1431773900985718, -0.6705349087715149, 0.24691297113895416, 0.749262809753418, 0.7011484503746033, -0.11625128984451294, -0.037832215428352356, 0.9776036143302917, -0.2210296094417572, -0.09801122546195984, 0.42886966466903687, 0.66644287109375, 0.3280051350593567, -0.4327930510044098, 0.5699020624160767, 0.0821952372789383, -0.3475145101547241, -1.0349242687225342, 0.34696176648139954, -0.9796708822250366, -0.2702799141407013, 0.9134409427642822, -0.42441627383232117, -0.2272202968597412, -0.4389767050743103, 0.10117898136377335, 0.19871975481510162, -0.055788956582546234, 0.8949148654937744, 0.7176522016525269, -0.03148282691836357, 0.16212645173072815, -0.21413569152355194, 0.777557909488678, 0.48545128107070923, -0.9432783722877502, 0.5893991589546204, 0.7165551781654358, 0.11210862547159195, 0.3208460211753845, 0.201242133975029, -0.31301072239875793, 0.6785999536514282, -0.09568093717098236, -0.38570472598075867, -0.09476251900196075, -0.6492658257484436, -0.44843173027038574, 0.35227078199386597, -0.032635971903800964, 0.0864047110080719 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20308v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20308v1
ChainNet: Structured Metaphor and Metonymy in WordNet
2024-03-29T17:22:53
2024-03-29T17:22:53
Rowan Hall Maudslay, Simone Teufel, Francis Bond, James Pustejovsky
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI
The senses of a word exhibit rich internal structure. In a typical lexicon, this structure is overlooked: a word's senses are encoded as a list without inter-sense relations. We present ChainNet, a lexical resource which for the first time explicitly identifies these structures. ChainNet expresses how senses in the Open English Wordnet are derived from one another: every nominal sense of a word is either connected to another sense by metaphor or metonymy, or is disconnected in the case of homonymy. Because WordNet senses are linked to resources which capture information about their meaning, ChainNet represents the first dataset of grounded metaphor and metonymy.
[ -0.345389187335968, -0.4167252779006958, 0.4390955865383148, -0.0322360061109066, -0.24455265700817108, 0.13923437893390656, 0.059606533497571945, -0.5677191019058228, 0.7260440587997437, 0.3153182566165924, -0.5913704633712769, -0.22810053825378418, -0.3294859230518341, 0.07479860633611679, -0.5388240814208984, 0.6856149435043335, -0.17653322219848633, -0.14317841827869415, -0.17528977990150452, -0.46595150232315063, -0.0767047181725502, -0.8290216326713562, -0.5901098251342773, -0.4880472719669342, 1.098474144935608, 0.07893723994493484, 0.9871629476547241, 0.9257979393005371, 0.5115697383880615, 0.3760749101638794, -0.2975584864616394, 0.15835723280906677, -0.3555927276611328, -0.07138693332672119, -0.6963274478912354, -0.2642498314380646, -0.13831782341003418, 0.39403292536735535, 0.6898826956748962, 1.1835606098175049, -0.10402176529169083, 0.26642903685569763, 0.18404966592788696, 0.9115447998046875, -0.828263521194458, -0.015533083118498325, -0.7988470792770386, 0.2624684274196625, -0.26187658309936523, -0.5436950922012329, -0.0441066138446331, 0.05983869358897209, 0.07798688858747482, -0.8573634624481201, 0.0651572123169899, 0.5346261858940125, 1.1684516668319702, -0.15312625467777252, -0.3271894156932831, -0.34333738684654236, -0.4320060908794403, 0.40485328435897827, -0.08359924703836441, 0.4020445942878723, 0.4866229295730591, 0.26549649238586426, -0.2005111277103424, -1.0678126811981201, -0.6919516921043396, -0.4155527949333191, -0.17779985070228577, 0.32195985317230225, 0.09650728851556778, 0.12717249989509583, 0.19923771917819977, 0.6714575886726379, -0.4996569752693176, -0.08675499260425568, -0.5731425285339355, -0.1511681228876114, 0.23416996002197266, 0.2227916419506073, 0.47464653849601746, -0.31412506103515625, -0.8623861074447632, -0.16511578857898712, -0.5253900289535522, -0.16403622925281525, 0.6237367391586304, 0.4490290880203247, -0.14410050213336945, 0.6355829238891602, -0.01974017359316349, 0.6191949248313904, -0.41473522782325745, -0.11521321535110474, 0.19890771806240082, -0.21491265296936035, -0.4660387337207794, 0.34248360991477966, 0.6705501079559326, -0.00604618014767766, 0.5668565630912781, -0.310520738363266, -0.17147400975227356, 0.40303802490234375, 0.3219618499279022, -0.3261990547180176, -0.15328316390514374, 0.10745655000209808, -0.7738123536109924, -0.6295790076255798, 0.5455328822135925, -0.21336901187896729, -0.2627721428871155, -0.3422558903694153, 0.510715663433075, -0.07125578075647354, -0.3309697210788727, -0.06250607967376709, -0.7700065970420837, 0.05387295410037041, -0.08560999482870102, -0.5654550790786743, 0.8584148287773132, 0.6201919317245483, 1.0499131679534912, -0.10197893530130386, -0.6533712148666382, -0.19033357501029968, 0.21215474605560303, -0.4148145914077759, 0.5629849433898926, -0.33574455976486206, 0.0706339180469513, -0.05370670557022095, 0.3494223654270172, 0.26230350136756897, -0.5561862587928772, -0.24489016830921173, -0.5518977642059326, 0.3067459464073181, -0.05618222802877426, -0.6916924715042114, -0.30832481384277344, 0.4266280233860016, -0.9786933660507202, 0.8483071327209473, 0.11172418296337128, -1.2432873249053955, 0.4005966782569885, -0.39234381914138794, -0.07099955528974533, 0.3905697762966156, -0.2187652587890625, 0.7237099409103394, 0.14932160079479218, -0.46879512071609497, 0.08293375372886658, -0.2109820544719696, 0.14358630776405334, -0.33343711495399475, -0.2945977449417114, 0.4262996315956116, -0.17565569281578064, 0.7281416058540344, 0.20664310455322266, 0.048345889896154404, 0.15325942635536194, -0.892381489276886, -0.04771820455789566, 0.021329622715711594, -0.13083964586257935, -1.0448071956634521, 0.17728115618228912, 0.1485273391008377, 0.45572152733802795, 0.06863858550786972, -0.6295239925384521, 0.11012428998947144, -0.6954893469810486, 0.408195823431015, 0.8510456085205078, -0.08526179194450378, 0.19883999228477478, -0.4133469760417938, 0.2889939844608307, 0.40665826201438904, -0.058556247502565384, 0.03890150785446167, -0.31354475021362305, -0.6327131986618042, 0.13332994282245636, 0.40736517310142517, 0.4635295867919922, -0.7758519053459167, 0.1623917520046234, -0.2919309139251709, -0.2703266143798828, -0.11267378181219101, -0.15828491747379303, 0.19042432308197021, 0.33439263701438904, 0.16221855580806732, -0.5015838146209717, -0.5232340097427368, -0.9426890015602112, -0.4869627058506012, -0.3817770779132843, -0.19789747893810272, 0.34933724999427795, 0.7242355942726135, -0.07059381157159805, 0.6464235186576843, -0.2258751094341278, -0.2603133022785187, 0.1720600575208664, -0.10250001400709152, 0.45928481221199036, 0.2673055827617645, 0.1597733050584793, -0.5808239579200745, 0.047855060547590256, 0.06306048482656479, -0.9498286843299866, 0.12958559393882751, -0.09739972651004791, -0.4471059739589691, -0.4916379153728485, 0.46846452355384827, -0.18997874855995178, 0.4302876591682434, 0.648568868637085, -0.58381587266922, 0.7277295589447021, 0.052221015095710754, -0.16486971080303192, -1.3987385034561157, 0.12662257254123688, -0.4939826726913452, -0.21323442459106445, -0.27509260177612305, 0.3139328956604004, -0.23580574989318848, -0.12005044519901276, -0.6692947149276733, 0.7800644636154175, -0.6763666272163391, -0.27225786447525024, -0.25388020277023315, 0.5248336791992188, 0.3443252444267273, 0.26552513241767883, -0.030780337750911713, 0.8141059279441833, 0.6933865547180176, -0.6445106267929077, 0.6479007601737976, 0.2212727814912796, -0.33152276277542114, 0.5581463575363159, -0.6798736453056335, 0.1009618416428566, -0.20968574285507202, -0.18204905092716217, -0.6808385252952576, -0.38004836440086365, 0.21340784430503845, -0.10459607094526291, -0.1884109079837799, 0.16233763098716736, -0.5414849519729614, -0.4996413588523865, -0.24691419303417206, 0.7599400877952576, -0.05526876449584961, -0.7668843269348145, 0.1891096830368042, 0.3525245487689972, 0.7287139892578125, -0.4774886965751648, -1.0338795185089111, 0.1488361805677414, -0.12221844494342804, -0.4391387104988098, 0.34804755449295044, 0.07422925531864166, -0.6951940655708313, 0.18050335347652435, -0.34108391404151917, -0.5519829988479614, 0.1196046769618988, 0.4949658513069153, -0.060657281428575516, -0.16445264220237732, 0.530204176902771, -0.35178908705711365, 0.04836658760905266, 0.17820550501346588, -0.7659143209457397, 0.3248724639415741, -0.09451691806316376, -0.03477385640144348, -0.08649386465549469, 0.5611317157745361, 0.5901216864585876, 0.24356898665428162, 1.0942119359970093, 0.03407002612948418, -0.6285856366157532, -0.2783972918987274, -0.05963088199496269, -0.11273209750652313, -0.43257975578308105, -0.14988741278648376, -0.6793590784072876, -0.8039940595626831, 0.6405088305473328, -0.26001283526420593, -0.4246504604816437, 0.4459553360939026, -0.0017217618878930807, -0.19806008040905, 0.10479462891817093, 0.2391207218170166, -0.071644626557827, 0.14605756103992462, 0.09560076147317886, 0.021479999646544456, -0.8729820251464844, -0.10501597076654434, -0.4275837242603302, -0.6160421371459961, -0.8277395367622375, -0.039959970861673355, 0.24609827995300293, 0.4504483640193939, -0.5305510759353638, 0.557734489440918, -0.3887561857700348, 0.28396156430244446, 0.7617272734642029, 0.41159623861312866, 0.29140815138816833, 0.24709337949752808, -0.8689832091331482, 0.2562813460826874, -0.9425793290138245, -0.5349498391151428, 0.5482069253921509, 0.19382864236831665, 0.5670722126960754, -0.06053006276488304, 0.5344412922859192, 0.3044566810131073, -0.07132986932992935, -0.9119167923927307, 0.7141739130020142, 0.15252813696861267, -0.6406230330467224, 0.09193803369998932, -0.44370144605636597, -1.2241202592849731, 0.0667395070195198, -0.1838482916355133, -0.8874942660331726, 0.2993665337562561, 0.026840876787900925, 0.15530367195606232, 0.5320736169815063, -0.19396629929542542, 0.536696195602417, -0.07697886973619461, -0.4536309540271759, -0.049815308302640915, -0.6355642080307007, 0.45469656586647034, 0.14444613456726074, 0.27612388134002686, -0.16829556226730347, -0.16245555877685547, 0.9529004693031311, -0.8879159688949585, 0.5929241180419922, 0.3682572841644287, 0.3193971514701843, 0.44730693101882935, 0.4846497178077698, 0.25465646386146545, -0.3192395567893982, -0.061193909496068954, 0.5756323337554932, 0.25127121806144714, -0.37461480498313904, -0.451435923576355, 0.5164909958839417, -0.46284300088882446, -0.11223351210355759, -0.6502523422241211, -0.3241586685180664, 0.11824055016040802, 0.3665546178817749, 0.20463617146015167, 0.640106201171875, -0.2514582574367523, 0.14785587787628174, 0.03492429107427597, -0.2133520543575287, 0.3948744833469391, -0.02850230596959591, -0.30612677335739136, -0.37699633836746216, 0.3450407385826111, 0.22584007680416107, 0.17266282439231873, 0.4177022874355316, 0.525813102722168, -0.08335688710212708, -0.07853369414806366, 0.013576623983681202, 0.011304512619972229, -0.7020136713981628, -0.2797629237174988, -0.11547110229730606, -0.5731500387191772, 0.326061874628067, 0.03622591495513916, -0.235965758562088, -0.3340242803096771, -0.00013753892562817782, -0.3216772675514221, 0.5668354630470276, 0.9106147289276123, -0.08032850921154022, 0.38050493597984314, -0.6809009313583374, 0.4910624325275421, 0.2930682599544525, 0.815403163433075, 0.04862338304519653, -0.12856195867061615, -0.3559596538543701, -0.12135380506515503, 0.35367873311042786, -1.2260032892227173, 0.24325451254844666, 0.17647111415863037, 0.2630715072154999, 0.7466249465942383, -0.2765877842903137, 0.8188813328742981, -0.6536028981208801, 0.9264034628868103, 0.4224180579185486, -1.0030088424682617, 0.5298678278923035, -0.4091992974281311, 0.2008502036333084, 0.4551243782043457, 0.5312368869781494, -0.7356938123703003, -0.05395539477467537, -0.8699609041213989, -0.9504889249801636, 0.33188316226005554, 0.29109349846839905, 0.019428089261054993, -0.5639962553977966, 0.387568861246109, 0.18670926988124847, 0.7120653390884399, -0.8900727033615112, -0.47359636425971985, -0.0844833105802536, 0.10015042126178741, 0.17062363028526306, -0.4004485011100769, -0.2923972010612488, -0.336090624332428, 0.1089128777384758, 0.10047682374715805, 0.26340171694755554, 0.36902347207069397, -0.2526348829269409, -0.12422257661819458, -0.020319964736700058, 0.1731564849615097, 0.8821154236793518, 0.03856409713625908, 1.004535436630249, -0.15679170191287994, -0.7287213206291199, 0.2480846643447876, -0.5823319554328918, 0.10070640593767166, 0.16646942496299744, 0.7295302748680115, 0.8177930116653442, 0.4122219979763031, -0.3441552221775055, 0.25575095415115356, 0.4277912974357605, -0.25415530800819397, -0.4692480266094208, 0.004627407994121313, -0.12204069644212723, 0.11173373460769653, 0.3168830871582031, -0.08381284028291702, 0.2381247729063034, -0.7836179137229919, 0.38625568151474, 0.35808202624320984, -0.32759103178977966, -0.2593196928501129, 0.4675023853778839, -0.33979296684265137, -0.35691022872924805, 0.6030798554420471, -0.030636854469776154, -0.48342275619506836, 0.3759559988975525, 0.6430023908615112, 1.0279157161712646, -0.01978432945907116, -0.015868227928876877, 0.5095438957214355, 0.5845585465431213, -0.015391817316412926, 0.5324066877365112, -0.154869943857193, -1.2173033952713013, 0.09557359665632248, -0.8138028979301453, -0.17260566353797913, 0.3500497043132782, -0.7352310419082642, -0.27482181787490845, -0.5548627972602844, -0.03612562268972397, -0.21560464799404144, -0.3161526620388031, -0.807870090007782, 0.3469110131263733, 0.09531736373901367, 1.1797230243682861, -0.8232135772705078, 0.7307206988334656, 0.6423118710517883, -0.47324129939079285, -1.3982661962509155, 0.007079176604747772, -0.19753067195415497, -0.5899432301521301, 0.9201450943946838, 0.21206048130989075, -0.26194849610328674, 0.1616668850183487, -0.7443140745162964, -0.8254544138908386, 0.945050835609436, -0.05807553604245186, -0.5554735064506531, 0.053164780139923096, 0.0634457990527153, 0.3434334695339203, -0.4485371708869934, 0.3554230034351349, 0.20433859527111053, 0.5929273962974548, -0.22349442541599274, -0.771232545375824, 0.29452598094940186, -0.42359209060668945, 0.4137309193611145, 0.18495239317417145, -0.2333465814590454, 1.1438099145889282, 0.5080395936965942, -0.5585445761680603, -0.24290484189987183, 0.4772680699825287, 0.12096293270587921, 0.1350805163383484, 0.5312166810035706, 0.6095086336135864, 0.7583440542221069, 0.11218897253274918, 1.0495364665985107, -0.3468046486377716, 0.09449402987957001, 1.0398693084716797, -0.283357173204422, 0.753427267074585, 0.864124059677124, -0.2814149260520935, 0.8418387174606323, 0.7905565500259399, 0.1353101134300232, 0.3388870358467102, 0.6082539558410645, -0.25277262926101685, 0.17569947242736816, -0.14636735618114471, -0.27368712425231934, 0.6863744854927063, 0.2977238893508911, -0.5874406695365906, -0.27278846502304077, -0.15821309387683868, -0.38423746824264526, 0.04540890082716942, -0.5718615055084229, 0.922376811504364, 0.34503278136253357, -0.2848699390888214, 0.6342228651046753, -0.34751811623573303, 0.346285343170166, -0.581624448299408, -0.16806790232658386, -0.07832372188568115, -0.21869182586669922, -0.24980442225933075, -0.7556109428405762, 0.455546498298645, -0.4413103759288788, -0.29878607392311096, -0.021010853350162506, 1.0459102392196655, -0.3207484781742096, -0.22547340393066406, 0.7728779911994934, 0.8377664685249329, 0.692793071269989, -0.1766754537820816, -0.5376055836677551, -0.13466711342334747, -0.79115229845047, -0.32465383410453796, 0.11459317058324814, 0.6817563772201538, -0.10072224587202072, 0.2959071695804596, 0.7522783875465393, 0.4450472295284271, 0.09852389991283417, 0.10611860454082489, 0.8288624882698059, -1.0647015571594238, -0.7875353097915649, -0.9365077614784241, 0.2742959260940552, -0.16226549446582794, -0.24191072583198547, 0.787000298500061, 0.2467787265777588, 0.9226939082145691, -0.17794141173362732, 0.36322182416915894, 0.038419611752033234, 0.05253978073596954, -0.46669259667396545, 0.7431629300117493, -0.6488956212997437, -0.10775517672300339, -0.3104180693626404, -0.9805772304534912, -0.05977018550038338, 0.5981572270393372, 0.21181103587150574, -0.05594419687986374, 1.2205119132995605, 0.701522171497345, -0.4216160774230957, -0.23043307662010193, 0.47485417127609253, 0.19818098843097687, -0.6291140913963318, 0.24321895837783813, 0.9854316711425781, -0.49411675333976746, -0.12706540524959564, -0.08346746116876602, -0.09990756213665009, 0.14380739629268646, -0.8873773813247681, -0.7658732533454895, -0.7908068299293518, 0.05275016278028488, -0.6809055805206299, 0.2306804209947586, 0.8773065805435181, 0.6268854141235352, -0.5870211124420166, -0.6074633598327637, -0.7281011343002319, 0.17796413600444794, -0.3788548409938812, -0.3279936909675598, 0.1359683871269226, -0.13502895832061768, -0.09372261166572571, 0.7085771560668945, 0.43766871094703674, -0.1528712809085846, -0.43961071968078613, 0.20873084664344788, -0.49635592103004456, 0.2490077167749405, 0.6482730507850647, 0.05709770694375038, -0.6250821352005005, -0.5421726107597351, -0.3507542312145233, -0.2646927833557129, 0.03175312653183937, 0.8643621206283569, -1.0231096744537354, 0.48280686140060425, 0.7398934364318848, 0.2181335687637329, 0.19468452036380768, 0.03565521165728569, 0.5215259790420532, -1.0306309461593628, 0.783923864364624, -0.043966006487607956, 0.421842485666275, 0.04893920198082924, -0.31765204668045044, 0.6102309823036194, 0.70497727394104, -0.011299661360681057, -0.5944201946258545, 0.46019574999809265, -1.055136799812317, -0.48017966747283936, 0.9870363473892212, -0.05330485478043556, -0.42357680201530457, -0.06243950501084328, 0.2542262077331543, 0.4159890413284302, 0.28299349546432495, 0.3573668599128723, 0.8718489408493042, 0.375553160905838, -0.014596423134207726, -0.5631346106529236, 0.21092447638511658, -0.02180270291864872, -0.557066023349762, -0.5198286771774292, 0.43706732988357544, 0.15686297416687012, 0.17833955585956573, 0.40776950120925903, 0.10712455958127975, -0.11667530983686447, 0.42751169204711914, 0.19852164387702942, -0.06879872828722, -0.7251309752464294, -0.019150760024785995, 0.5573506951332092, -0.2120855748653412, -0.5701332092285156 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20289v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20289v1
Emotion-Anchored Contrastive Learning Framework for Emotion Recognition in Conversation
2024-03-29T17:00:55
2024-03-29T17:00:55
Fangxu Yu, Junjie Guo, Zhen Wu, Xinyu Dai
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
Emotion Recognition in Conversation (ERC) involves detecting the underlying emotion behind each utterance within a conversation. Effectively generating representations for utterances remains a significant challenge in this task. Recent works propose various models to address this issue, but they still struggle with differentiating similar emotions such as excitement and happiness. To alleviate this problem, We propose an Emotion-Anchored Contrastive Learning (EACL) framework that can generate more distinguishable utterance representations for similar emotions. To achieve this, we utilize label encodings as anchors to guide the learning of utterance representations and design an auxiliary loss to ensure the effective separation of anchors for similar emotions. Moreover, an additional adaptation process is proposed to adapt anchors to serve as effective classifiers to improve classification performance. Across extensive experiments, our proposed EACL achieves state-of-the-art emotion recognition performance and exhibits superior performance on similar emotions. Our code is available at https://github.com/Yu-Fangxu/EACL.
[ -0.5052102208137512, -0.42331087589263916, 0.32009387016296387, 0.12441006302833557, -0.1841111034154892, 0.11212124675512314, -0.3030831813812256, -0.6840678453445435, 0.42856529355049133, 0.07629416882991791, -0.6169747710227966, -0.6102015972137451, -0.4403541684150696, 0.15561582148075104, 0.009864592924714088, 1.0145602226257324, -0.03903210535645485, -0.060014452785253525, -0.27690961956977844, -0.6216843128204346, -0.14767195284366608, -0.5704714059829712, -0.7794978022575378, -0.43533432483673096, 0.4023192226886749, 0.7528106570243835, 0.08908890932798386, 0.2901618182659149, 0.17731745541095734, 0.32344087958335876, -0.21941663324832916, 0.2583621144294739, -0.6562526822090149, 0.3635012209415436, 0.25637733936309814, -0.3269684314727783, -0.39931485056877136, -0.31359750032424927, 0.2202993482351303, 0.3590238690376282, -0.38713201880455017, -0.2822403907775879, 0.3210783004760742, 0.8102848529815674, -0.6576088070869446, 0.40090683102607727, -0.49584701657295227, 0.2122521698474884, 0.2231086790561676, -0.1840347945690155, -0.48908594250679016, -0.11943462491035461, 0.3430856466293335, -0.43264079093933105, -0.023585127666592598, 0.3035098910331726, 0.7245656251907349, 0.02269846573472023, -0.5881844758987427, -0.6259227991104126, -0.3737087845802307, 0.5641102194786072, -0.47728458046913147, 0.5357686281204224, 0.30604955554008484, 0.04330001398921013, 0.2843210995197296, -0.4165329039096832, -0.4420279264450073, 0.02169288508594036, 0.1625933051109314, 0.5514559149742126, -0.17124339938163757, 0.40716126561164856, 0.00848302710801363, 0.382403165102005, -0.6778112053871155, 0.04829517379403114, 0.009881232865154743, 0.005117293447256088, 0.34682995080947876, 0.21561568975448608, 0.15542732179164886, 0.20246486365795135, -0.3508135974407196, -0.25434568524360657, -0.6584309339523315, 0.23625873029232025, 0.32668378949165344, 0.18650005757808685, -0.29963773488998413, -0.052584439516067505, -0.2638794183731079, 0.17843520641326904, 0.33254483342170715, 0.2171713262796402, 0.6978363990783691, 0.5168238282203674, -0.09740762412548065, 0.5602831840515137, 0.44082319736480713, 0.4841592013835907, 0.04525056853890419, 0.21293090283870697, -0.09093908965587616, 0.09768959879875183, 0.05448492243885994, -0.7832264304161072, -0.4313082993030548, 0.41219934821128845, -0.5119295716285706, -0.2199406772851944, 0.11606790125370026, -0.8335630893707275, -0.38338083028793335, 0.003884269157424569, 0.16274940967559814, -0.18561293184757233, -0.15236693620681763, 0.07482336461544037, 0.15979623794555664, 0.2746921181678772, 0.25067830085754395, -0.9921292066574097, 0.512178897857666, 0.5606632232666016, 0.6485931277275085, -0.19618695974349976, 0.032934918999671936, -0.5647670030593872, 0.04885927960276604, -0.2512649893760681, 0.7710455656051636, -0.6140598058700562, -0.5293682813644409, 0.46689489483833313, -0.003014062298461795, 0.2580924332141876, -0.42004263401031494, 0.7169585824012756, -0.5956915616989136, 0.010224876925349236, -0.23902565240859985, -0.6798194646835327, -0.31155645847320557, 0.4698701798915863, -0.6467869877815247, 0.8416469097137451, -0.22748355567455292, -0.7488555312156677, 0.0714382752776146, -0.5943564772605896, -0.44384658336639404, -0.04775629937648773, 0.04325098544359207, -0.5297703742980957, 0.32869085669517517, 0.10343313217163086, 0.29057908058166504, -0.01049044169485569, -0.2816433310508728, -0.5073944926261902, -0.33380967378616333, 0.40871939063072205, -0.2129231095314026, 0.2947203814983368, 0.34999945759773254, -0.293466180562973, 0.19124163687229156, -0.95341557264328, -0.06486468762159348, -0.11916837841272354, -0.30970728397369385, -0.48239895701408386, 0.15355443954467773, 0.020462926477193832, 0.21562035381793976, 0.06678678840398788, -0.5631592869758606, -0.2679607570171356, -0.41896817088127136, 0.024378273636102676, 0.8792126178741455, -0.03448071330785751, 0.45164570212364197, -0.05311806872487068, 0.34468597173690796, 0.40441060066223145, -0.21377360820770264, -0.4945509731769562, -0.3938711881637573, -1.2066144943237305, -0.04510826990008354, -0.026447070762515068, 0.4225986897945404, -0.550512969493866, 0.42690756916999817, 0.0502106137573719, -0.23246517777442932, -0.6359511017799377, -0.10310348123311996, 0.5048561692237854, 0.7290714383125305, 0.41911694407463074, -0.26164230704307556, -0.6775786876678467, -0.5763357281684875, -0.06482317298650742, -0.38720953464508057, -0.0611257329583168, 0.6912453770637512, 0.26871830224990845, -0.12791107594966888, 0.5928933620452881, -0.598260760307312, -0.22286461293697357, -0.04368557780981064, 0.5867326259613037, -0.13773654401302338, 0.5520706176757812, 0.30855289101600647, -1.0081011056900024, -0.6898359656333923, 0.23574189841747284, -0.6012813448905945, -0.3543231785297394, 0.0646573156118393, 0.010133453644812107, 0.3867587745189667, 0.4613262712955475, -0.010114180855453014, 0.3136732578277588, 0.6085684895515442, -0.23074303567409515, 0.20531675219535828, -0.13393670320510864, 0.4651956856250763, -0.8948302268981934, -0.18326126039028168, -0.07009460777044296, -0.2567294239997864, -0.7559276819229126, -0.543150007724762, 0.17521913349628448, -0.11353836953639984, -0.5582280158996582, 0.29817748069763184, -0.5284082889556885, 0.046156469732522964, -0.27425095438957214, 0.05668680742383003, 0.14092756807804108, 0.7209462523460388, 0.5435672402381897, 0.2410784363746643, 0.5672693252563477, -0.5283524394035339, 0.26506856083869934, 0.348819762468338, -0.09001951664686203, 1.043960452079773, -0.5341494679450989, 0.45980945229530334, -0.27914202213287354, 0.3450402617454529, -1.0635017156600952, -0.3432096838951111, 0.21039484441280365, -0.37454038858413696, 0.4622526168823242, 0.03669239953160286, 0.09148519486188889, -0.032486848533153534, -0.35123175382614136, 0.3879660367965698, 0.6549537777900696, -0.8814457058906555, 0.8140869140625, 0.22783423960208893, -0.35359910130500793, -0.43726107478141785, -0.8788851499557495, -0.2974831759929657, -0.36085250973701477, -0.31968292593955994, 0.4880804121494293, -0.2472621351480484, 0.11097199469804764, 0.09362237900495529, -0.18207503855228424, -0.04329884797334671, -0.0551036037504673, 0.5635793209075928, -0.005454674828797579, -0.14503182470798492, 0.4496997892856598, 0.1933368742465973, -0.128434956073761, 0.1881239265203476, -0.07222405821084976, 0.3253697156906128, -0.5250371098518372, -0.4894239902496338, -0.2870783507823944, 0.6907193660736084, 0.2730330526828766, -0.16216915845870972, 0.7651879787445068, 0.717134416103363, -0.5595272779464722, -0.24876463413238525, -0.5046772360801697, -0.09545546025037766, -0.49544796347618103, 0.6594113111495972, -0.3541310727596283, -1.069239616394043, 0.854754626750946, -0.17209653556346893, -0.13933895528316498, 0.280299574136734, 0.4553937613964081, -0.30387404561042786, 1.0939873456954956, 0.583275318145752, -0.06886183470487595, 0.6807003021240234, 0.21295174956321716, 0.10428163409233093, -0.8887008428573608, -0.3471046984195709, -0.48784536123275757, -0.3233080208301544, -0.40456125140190125, -0.27393874526023865, 0.12225845456123352, -0.19306708872318268, -0.3559958040714264, 0.008390188217163086, -0.2806283235549927, 0.451701283454895, 0.1113336905837059, 0.21456901729106903, 0.1473848968744278, -0.21719740331172943, 0.13129214942455292, -0.28919899463653564, -0.5634625554084778, -0.25497668981552124, 0.6539968848228455, 0.4226284623146057, 0.799222469329834, 0.035513270646333694, 1.1096382141113281, 0.1696528196334839, 0.6207501292228699, -0.6523563265800476, 0.42375752329826355, 0.07545579224824905, -0.2791382968425751, 0.2187817394733429, -0.5414643883705139, -0.5738850235939026, -0.0030105288606137037, -0.36388760805130005, -1.0786356925964355, 0.46172478795051575, 0.25026607513427734, -0.07472629100084305, 0.07798273116350174, -0.620603621006012, 0.8598437905311584, -0.3194831609725952, -0.32703399658203125, -0.23444080352783203, -0.7894337773323059, 0.057041291147470474, 0.1585541069507599, 0.08933781832456589, 0.029269983991980553, -0.03982524201273918, 0.7394643425941467, -0.19383762776851654, 0.767163872718811, -0.05725906416773796, 0.07224433869123459, 0.4810674488544464, 0.024126674979925156, 0.49929359555244446, -0.05051148310303688, -0.11447449773550034, -0.03161897510290146, -0.5090460181236267, -0.15618564188480377, -0.7017620205879211, 0.6994784474372864, -0.440463662147522, -0.2710475027561188, -0.3245205283164978, -0.3480518162250519, -0.2713456451892853, -0.2654002606868744, 0.1370210200548172, 0.35143160820007324, -0.6374741792678833, 0.3024386763572693, 0.8965644836425781, -0.3479127883911133, 0.3767632842063904, 0.3986826241016388, 0.01364787295460701, -0.6001509428024292, 1.1331840753555298, -0.32192254066467285, 0.15790587663650513, 0.487739622592926, -0.0618683397769928, -0.4366493225097656, -0.2755621373653412, 0.09168042242527008, -0.08138332515954971, -0.9986754059791565, -0.35716426372528076, -0.5981906056404114, 0.18495845794677734, -0.17053979635238647, -0.3982740640640259, -0.3728342354297638, -0.010751103982329369, -0.6164767146110535, -0.276380330324173, 0.4026954770088196, 0.5889450907707214, -0.24900799989700317, 0.20009441673755646, -0.8524081110954285, 0.0774787962436676, 0.5391955971717834, 0.4516932964324951, 0.0981118381023407, -0.5189881920814514, -0.25890350341796875, -0.10220465809106827, -0.4052317142486572, -1.041552186012268, 0.6103496551513672, 0.6727882027626038, 0.2841269373893738, 1.001868486404419, 0.4809853136539459, 0.6462997198104858, -0.45214658975601196, 0.5167073011398315, 0.4891689121723175, -1.2087022066116333, 0.39085692167282104, 0.040126580744981766, 0.17116335034370422, 0.653120756149292, 0.5696201920509338, -0.5154702663421631, 0.054492853581905365, -0.6901507377624512, -1.082741618156433, 0.6664611101150513, 0.08247484266757965, 0.04963526874780655, -0.20869296789169312, -0.020351693034172058, -0.13159194588661194, 0.31233420968055725, -0.7413516640663147, -0.36573854088783264, -0.06747632473707199, -0.6611323952674866, 0.1667352318763733, -0.5182864665985107, -0.09654387086629868, 0.24727709591388702, 0.6172847151756287, -0.30819904804229736, 0.4408837556838989, 0.3046274483203888, -0.198460191488266, -0.16534151136875153, 0.3180483281612396, 0.30977320671081543, -0.26911821961402893, -0.4118860363960266, 0.17592763900756836, 0.5893927216529846, -0.11598215997219086, 0.019201599061489105, 0.09085728228092194, 0.5501185655593872, -0.11859700083732605, 0.1402582824230194, 0.9946032166481018, 0.5996505618095398, -0.8578795194625854, 0.4699656069278717, -0.07133948057889938, -0.09330307692289352, -0.047350551933050156, -0.23269693553447723, 0.27477189898490906, 0.46101492643356323, 0.3901321589946747, -0.10205892473459244, 0.51949143409729, -0.7017994523048401, 0.2531399130821228, 0.035353515297174454, -0.7606451511383057, -0.29133331775665283, 0.4617730677127838, 0.6553007960319519, -0.362094908952713, 0.4884784519672394, -0.32695236802101135, -1.108680009841919, 0.5088500380516052, 0.641389787197113, 1.0761771202087402, -0.5593652129173279, 0.05777508765459061, 0.24465411901474, -0.2940785586833954, 0.20963476598262787, 0.3525913953781128, -0.5104243159294128, -0.6700472831726074, 0.007216268219053745, -0.31487584114074707, -0.8562912344932556, -0.4077775776386261, -1.0243366956710815, -0.004835550207644701, -0.21658557653427124, 0.08781209588050842, -0.6502037048339844, -0.24042586982250214, -0.5992847681045532, 0.17168472707271576, 0.6899868845939636, 0.5750744342803955, -1.0545679330825806, 0.48402008414268494, 0.8460564613342285, -0.09134283661842346, -0.5922114849090576, -0.2124975472688675, 0.2569272518157959, -0.2650430500507355, 0.5088377594947815, 0.5986148118972778, -0.2852189838886261, -0.07162891328334808, -0.3421172797679901, -0.3530842959880829, 0.9533997774124146, 0.08696764707565308, -0.5846847295761108, 0.2631700038909912, -0.11128731817007065, 0.7592487931251526, -0.9909582734107971, 0.5170149803161621, 0.26671335101127625, 0.07492686063051224, 0.1983162760734558, -0.39274871349334717, -0.17342910170555115, -0.36585357785224915, -0.15422478318214417, -0.13821104168891907, -0.5931683778762817, 0.5950145721435547, -0.022564200684428215, -0.25437238812446594, -0.16612565517425537, 1.1024008989334106, 0.48546287417411804, 0.664238691329956, 0.5231101512908936, 0.41920414566993713, 0.8087778687477112, -0.3005591928958893, 0.5418195724487305, -0.3618806302547455, 0.48345932364463806, 1.216868281364441, -0.5016898512840271, 1.112755537033081, 0.3342292606830597, -0.03358115255832672, 0.710192859172821, 0.6496895551681519, 0.33956658840179443, 0.5248846411705017, 0.12691353261470795, -0.4992845356464386, -0.21795715391635895, -0.4088418483734131, -0.23630326986312866, 0.26446691155433655, 0.7418808937072754, -0.3972425162792206, 0.08139974623918533, 0.0764148160815239, -0.22036391496658325, -0.003694299142807722, -0.49037283658981323, 0.9492141604423523, 0.2929503917694092, -0.33468592166900635, 0.3177611827850342, -0.5335232615470886, 0.6454795598983765, -0.5044359564781189, -0.35391440987586975, -0.09717638045549393, 0.14737433195114136, -0.47423550486564636, -0.6988322138786316, 0.06836557388305664, 0.16663578152656555, 0.01752197928726673, -0.09924740344285965, 0.7777845859527588, -0.9657074213027954, 0.07566145062446594, 0.4673016369342804, 0.07670975476503372, 0.15116412937641144, 0.07114649564027786, -0.5997616052627563, 0.48299410939216614, 0.04904644191265106, -0.4914221465587616, 0.31489142775535583, 0.6440603733062744, 0.5087553858757019, 0.5246958136558533, 0.25606802105903625, -0.2546362578868866, -0.26821085810661316, 0.11569561809301376, 0.9070497155189514, -0.5030614137649536, -0.8903518915176392, -0.5597445368766785, 0.8756165504455566, -0.24280042946338654, -0.24791844189167023, 0.28112614154815674, 0.20632784068584442, 0.691061794757843, -0.20079222321510315, 0.4152202606201172, 0.03411347046494484, 0.17645815014839172, -0.3607204258441925, 0.4400966763496399, -0.6125909090042114, 0.17431876063346863, -0.6853404641151428, -0.9483959078788757, -0.3132026791572571, 0.9286704659461975, 0.06772235035896301, 0.031400877982378006, 0.677616536617279, 0.5981425642967224, 0.1351335346698761, 0.3941698372364044, 0.38883742690086365, 0.1906815767288208, 0.2478029578924179, 1.0993034839630127, 0.7900383472442627, -0.3750835657119751, 0.714783251285553, -0.12284647673368454, -0.23973101377487183, -0.539784848690033, -1.149979829788208, -0.7440319061279297, -0.7400990128517151, -0.568856418132782, -0.3945152163505554, 0.24020081758499146, 1.203419804573059, 0.540407657623291, -0.9409123659133911, -0.07014480978250504, -0.1511441320180893, -0.04153553768992424, -0.1330411732196808, -0.21236516535282135, 0.42467960715293884, -0.1174289882183075, -0.8851795196533203, 0.2642405331134796, 0.4500892162322998, 0.12255757302045822, 0.319357305765152, -0.6120781302452087, -0.0851249024271965, -0.026690399274230003, 0.41989365220069885, 0.6199391484260559, -0.39457717537879944, -0.48119011521339417, -0.3020380437374115, 0.013727877289056778, 0.343963623046875, 0.6314426064491272, -0.5498356223106384, 0.7975348234176636, 0.45667850971221924, 0.9278164505958557, 0.5785796046257019, 0.12377818673849106, 0.5105239152908325, -0.7614046931266785, 0.10691437870264053, 0.3748590350151062, 0.5691038370132446, 0.48138946294784546, -0.24873819947242737, 0.2980802655220032, -0.05045916512608528, -0.7111625075340271, -0.7654823064804077, 0.41315045952796936, -1.2583760023117065, 0.29184332489967346, 0.7619466185569763, -0.7025755643844604, -0.18487796187400818, 0.03436465561389923, -0.5131400227546692, 0.3310151696205139, -0.8489550352096558, 0.623466968536377, 0.7261220216751099, -0.42555439472198486, -0.4125194251537323, 0.2689465582370758, 0.48773181438446045, 0.5469031929969788, -0.8303957581520081, 0.10092897713184357, 0.42189821600914, -0.08008545637130737, 0.17718248069286346, 0.3814215064048767, 0.08281763643026352, 0.4113372266292572, 0.18271952867507935, 0.2236902117729187, 0.006840547546744347, -0.2702239751815796, -0.7652139067649841, 0.20471613109111786, -0.05944612994790077, -0.142922043800354 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20288v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20288v2
Can LLMs Correct Physicians, Yet? Investigating Effective Interaction Methods in the Medical Domain
2024-03-29T16:59:13
2024-05-06T14:13:51
Burcu Sayin, Pasquale Minervini, Jacopo Staiano, Andrea Passerini
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI
We explore the potential of Large Language Models (LLMs) to assist and potentially correct physicians in medical decision-making tasks. We evaluate several LLMs, including Meditron, Llama2, and Mistral, to analyze the ability of these models to interact effectively with physicians across different scenarios. We consider questions from PubMedQA and several tasks, ranging from binary (yes/no) responses to long answer generation, where the answer of the model is produced after an interaction with a physician. Our findings suggest that prompt design significantly influences the downstream accuracy of LLMs and that LLMs can provide valuable feedback to physicians, challenging incorrect diagnoses and contributing to more accurate decision-making. For example, when the physician is accurate 38% of the time, Mistral can produce the correct answer, improving accuracy up to 74% depending on the prompt being used, while Llama2 and Meditron models exhibit greater sensitivity to prompt choice. Our analysis also uncovers the challenges of ensuring that LLM-generated suggestions are pertinent and useful, emphasizing the need for further research in this area.
[ -0.19118528068065643, -0.80682772397995, 1.3784555196762085, 0.16469919681549072, -0.14539624750614166, -0.04246083274483681, -0.34439709782600403, -0.8543599247932434, 0.040504638105630875, 0.31132930517196655, -0.4380435645580292, -0.2740640938282013, -0.6757057309150696, 0.2823999226093292, -0.06544075906276703, 0.4837765693664551, -0.03291884809732437, 0.6528692841529846, -0.38679978251457214, -0.11434929072856903, -0.7153578400611877, -0.8493229150772095, -0.9764503836631775, -0.584704577922821, 0.7171936631202698, 0.20704177021980286, 0.9909934401512146, 0.42404991388320923, 0.5800768733024597, 0.32777005434036255, -0.43645182251930237, 0.3529384136199951, -0.2631472051143646, 0.3913768529891968, -0.359102338552475, -0.578218400478363, -0.44957825541496277, 0.0075620682910084724, 0.267215371131897, 1.0182621479034424, -0.2701168656349182, -0.08981502801179886, 0.1565765142440796, 0.4225410223007202, -0.07232663035392761, -0.0346984900534153, -0.32072874903678894, -0.0111005250364542, -0.09174887835979462, -0.33134549856185913, -0.4221968948841095, -0.20008043944835663, 0.31219732761383057, -0.48689213395118713, -0.08800439536571503, 0.1278722733259201, 0.5565245747566223, 0.5406872034072876, -0.5258777141571045, -0.4787764847278595, -0.9057369828224182, 0.5473276376724243, -0.9344912171363831, 0.3627578318119049, 0.5509199500083923, 0.1992633044719696, -0.5185506939888, -0.7573716044425964, -0.42023909091949463, -0.3435971736907959, -0.18725743889808655, 0.07087765634059906, -0.4525201916694641, 0.388313889503479, 0.5548171401023865, 0.017863744869828224, -0.040267858654260635, 0.5151598453521729, -0.34317833185195923, -0.011030259542167187, 0.528369128704071, 0.5020091533660889, 0.37856045365333557, -0.11318153142929077, -0.0722212940454483, 0.4295062720775604, -0.8295316100120544, 0.2176249623298645, -0.08375702053308487, 0.02458362840116024, 0.04116188362240791, 0.8668158650398254, 0.09666626155376434, 1.0726059675216675, 0.23259863257408142, -0.21266402304172516, -0.14765767753124237, -0.43302008509635925, -0.21739636361598969, -0.08739404380321503, 0.7325883507728577, 0.6900465488433838, 0.10675075650215149, 0.09552222490310669, -0.22633293271064758, -0.13737450540065765, 0.49020668864250183, -0.6133190989494324, -0.19318802654743195, 0.6807935237884521, -0.6428584456443787, -0.3389197289943695, -0.29543575644493103, -0.4060375690460205, -0.8183755278587341, -0.5813462138175964, 0.4680528938770294, -0.2142191380262375, -0.10683372616767883, 0.25459808111190796, -0.026755450293421745, 0.03376009315252304, 0.6738791465759277, -0.5620918869972229, 0.2701061964035034, 0.5523607730865479, 0.6095837950706482, -0.07649080455303192, -0.057411931455135345, -0.609025776386261, -0.012942139059305191, -0.5942803621292114, 0.9205236434936523, -0.52718186378479, -0.7506895661354065, -0.09905102103948593, -0.2271750420331955, -0.220493346452713, -0.8574703335762024, 0.39498499035835266, -0.3386107087135315, 0.240937739610672, -0.5564936995506287, -0.6956536769866943, 0.07456272840499878, 0.20162531733512878, -0.6368823647499084, 0.6511892676353455, -0.004337316378951073, -0.7772772312164307, 0.19201962649822235, -0.49734094738960266, -0.2787366509437561, 0.06573931872844696, -0.6870341300964355, -0.12154620885848999, 0.27443763613700867, 0.25373995304107666, 0.49299925565719604, -0.45664310455322266, 0.4894152879714966, -0.08216048032045364, -0.10385480523109436, 0.9244635701179504, -0.3201749622821808, 0.5105918049812317, 0.06108064949512482, -0.12540775537490845, 0.21827876567840576, -0.5130206346511841, -0.11900150030851364, 0.03943769633769989, -0.44001325964927673, -0.33061322569847107, 0.12829802930355072, -0.2642700970172882, 0.28482377529144287, 0.10260776430368423, -0.39014768600463867, 0.3508593738079071, -0.15697142481803894, 0.4054547846317291, 0.7326664924621582, 0.2908696234226227, 0.17784851789474487, -0.6357204914093018, 0.7406758666038513, -0.2636629045009613, 0.3140881359577179, -0.13706950843334198, -0.7250144481658936, -0.604545533657074, -0.34952932596206665, 0.4358231723308563, 0.4454919397830963, -0.9380336999893188, 0.07316750288009644, 0.06760876625776291, -0.5521172285079956, -0.5213578939437866, 0.08882968127727509, 0.41158241033554077, 0.8638634085655212, 0.10768300294876099, -0.09834074974060059, -0.2576676607131958, -0.6672211289405823, -0.35407549142837524, -0.36836862564086914, 0.013418584130704403, 0.603024959564209, 0.05309564247727394, -0.17131729423999786, 1.0577208995819092, -0.452565461397171, 0.1531110554933548, -0.3272791802883148, -0.08554171770811081, 0.4416047930717468, 0.1798863410949707, 0.582777202129364, -0.6165083646774292, -0.26781320571899414, -0.03588089346885681, -0.8808546662330627, -0.5128371119499207, -0.27167144417762756, 0.09613046050071716, -0.014337379485368729, 0.5543046593666077, -0.7333298325538635, 0.21601128578186035, 0.4882424473762512, -0.34081509709358215, 0.4913017749786377, -0.4973563253879547, 0.3288940489292145, -1.029282808303833, 0.1072772741317749, 0.11955518275499344, -0.26502060890197754, -1.106581449508667, -0.1662723273038864, 0.05248258635401726, 0.10249978303909302, -0.5464562773704529, 0.7740622758865356, -0.287404865026474, 0.2853717505931854, -0.31440696120262146, -0.1208408921957016, -0.24162273108959198, -0.07782476395368576, 0.047987453639507294, 0.9204974174499512, 0.44482043385505676, -0.7061572670936584, 0.26210838556289673, 0.34754684567451477, -0.3414742052555084, 0.8385437726974487, -1.0166833400726318, 0.10147982835769653, -0.16084076464176178, 0.1971450299024582, -1.0542584657669067, -0.40844959020614624, 0.4792938828468323, -0.4926425516605377, 0.23837798833847046, -0.2715161442756653, -0.6272193193435669, -0.36638811230659485, -0.03321629762649536, 0.5044496655464172, 0.3571088910102844, -0.5094301104545593, 0.6471868753433228, 0.16718894243240356, -0.6585128307342529, -0.3502345383167267, -0.5417659878730774, 0.2250005006790161, -0.0963631421327591, -0.4090384542942047, 0.09405568242073059, -0.23500733077526093, -0.5164927244186401, -0.2390250265598297, -0.1454695761203766, -0.08017830550670624, 0.010894193314015865, 0.4256005883216858, 0.667466938495636, 0.23323595523834229, 0.2879498600959778, 0.03131508454680443, -0.06643423438072205, 0.1782183200120926, 0.2605704367160797, 0.4978683292865753, 0.33880606293678284, -0.7222319841384888, -0.47771546244621277, 0.20344333350658417, 0.6711996793746948, -0.19235198199748993, 0.560267448425293, 0.1454460173845291, -0.4989362955093384, 0.20140020549297333, -0.7118359804153442, -0.22706376016139984, -0.46951183676719666, 0.1726892590522766, -0.24181221425533295, -1.010897159576416, 0.4868204593658447, -0.20056016743183136, 0.2592809498310089, 0.20379957556724548, 0.6642557382583618, -0.3331250846385956, 1.2468942403793335, 0.36785081028938293, 0.22234101593494415, 0.1675412505865097, 0.08576879650354385, 0.17129535973072052, -0.8619714379310608, -0.6060014367103577, -0.5149521231651306, -0.21391735970973969, -0.30902406573295593, -0.5299627184867859, 0.7187243103981018, 0.06317782402038574, 0.04799230024218559, -0.014190456829965115, -0.4332787096500397, 0.25655752420425415, 0.4543822705745697, 0.2987450361251831, 0.22642958164215088, -0.21684347093105316, -0.2569952607154846, -0.16059577465057373, -0.8803685903549194, -0.404043972492218, 0.937831699848175, 0.5447323322296143, 1.079299807548523, 0.2165040224790573, 0.6743008494377136, 0.15289045870304108, 0.32409003376960754, -0.9475007057189941, 0.4594406485557556, 0.2390427440404892, -0.42493098974227905, 0.021390222012996674, -0.4225063621997833, -1.1171056032180786, 0.16322128474712372, -0.490852028131485, -0.5802770853042603, 0.12995664775371552, 0.1927853375673294, -0.7276121377944946, 0.10871231555938721, -0.5196001529693604, 0.3988366425037384, -0.529777467250824, -0.2589607238769531, -0.13641656935214996, -0.7551084756851196, 0.03564664348959923, -0.27414366602897644, 0.28082314133644104, -0.0031834698747843504, -0.3775976002216339, 0.5485463738441467, -0.38188955187797546, 1.0573663711547852, 0.02402113750576973, -0.505135715007782, 0.040808986872434616, 0.18876703083515167, 0.18318238854408264, 0.1138610765337944, -0.19123436510562897, 0.17279236018657684, 0.03479323908686638, -0.05958632752299309, -0.6766508221626282, 0.4949510395526886, -0.5816896557807922, -0.89817214012146, -0.6202762722969055, -0.460717111825943, -0.3952415883541107, 0.137819305062294, 0.17603008449077606, 0.6487488150596619, -0.08531929552555084, -0.23131203651428223, 0.6923077702522278, -0.34403738379478455, 0.21543793380260468, 0.7345165610313416, -0.22934770584106445, -0.4282844364643097, 0.33898991346359253, 0.2182714194059372, 0.26517704129219055, 0.04891448840498924, 0.24177733063697815, -0.3927640914916992, -0.5503221154212952, -0.4387851357460022, 0.5485954284667969, -0.7272193431854248, -0.21343563497066498, -0.5752343535423279, -0.3147684335708618, 0.0841187909245491, -0.1427454799413681, 0.027919327840209007, -0.19273538887500763, -0.31818023324012756, -0.05374906584620476, 0.3224041759967804, 1.1271986961364746, 0.053689710795879364, 0.26030588150024414, -1.106366515159607, 0.10571758449077606, 0.25787433981895447, 0.31987467408180237, 0.020319702103734016, -0.3675048053264618, 0.09409742802381516, -0.18912610411643982, -0.08740430325269699, -1.0854333639144897, -0.05440124496817589, -0.24235761165618896, 0.9214851260185242, 0.4307158291339874, -0.14686697721481323, 0.49582114815711975, -0.7373161315917969, 1.0402060747146606, 0.389172226190567, -0.7083081603050232, 0.6003141403198242, -0.31994980573654175, 0.35590478777885437, 0.30464261770248413, 0.4304618239402771, -0.7786917686462402, -0.42940136790275574, -0.4619339406490326, -0.5022407174110413, 0.48377326130867004, 0.13465148210525513, 0.1309453397989273, -0.17182306945323944, 0.6410906314849854, 0.10498961806297302, 0.20298032462596893, -0.3932664096355438, -0.2503906190395355, 0.629190981388092, -0.23498181998729706, 0.07470385730266571, -0.4383980631828308, -0.4802398681640625, -0.17529653012752533, 0.16962838172912598, 0.08481049537658691, 0.19393210113048553, 0.47218775749206543, 0.2939619719982147, -0.2196831852197647, 0.3757239282131195, 0.7124911546707153, 1.1046245098114014, 0.16238468885421753, 0.22689741849899292, 0.30160775780677795, -0.2078050673007965, 0.13025158643722534, 0.08341352641582489, 0.14452849328517914, 0.14847293496131897, 0.4948592483997345, 0.3828071355819702, 0.04209928214550018, -0.9209312200546265, 0.5508171916007996, -0.3243584930896759, -0.17664051055908203, 0.035323090851306915, 0.09610237181186676, 0.1505778729915619, 0.6415042281150818, 0.18357256054878235, 0.2583322823047638, 0.014900095760822296, -0.2256627231836319, 0.05404256284236908, 0.5890689492225647, -0.24280700087547302, -0.0571160614490509, 0.7853577733039856, 0.4269975423812866, -0.4674086272716522, 0.447043240070343, 0.2996140122413635, -0.6095501184463501, 0.5080989599227905, 0.5017552971839905, 0.27435827255249023, -0.34022992849349976, 0.04711553081870079, 0.1232529804110527, 0.06782566010951996, -0.19563435018062592, 0.3141424059867859, 0.050165556371212006, -0.6255438923835754, -0.679609477519989, -0.06315288692712784, -0.844586968421936, 0.009366658516228199, -0.5281074643135071, 0.12284591794013977, -0.4401898980140686, -0.74077969789505, 0.24569173157215118, -0.2506493926048279, -0.6121167540550232, 0.05649666488170624, 0.10144666582345963, 0.8888704776763916, -0.5247774720191956, 0.5662878155708313, 1.0692023038864136, -0.250579833984375, -0.9781609773635864, -0.0596245713531971, 0.18408378958702087, -0.8496378064155579, 0.548736572265625, -0.03491615876555443, -0.1247280091047287, -0.3315232992172241, -0.6390976309776306, -0.5499134063720703, 1.0083802938461304, 0.3371632695198059, -0.5314175486564636, -0.011400078423321247, 0.04835924133658409, 0.6461824774742126, -0.10061412304639816, 0.24457500874996185, 0.4544002413749695, 0.34101033210754395, 0.17305393517017365, -1.2955163717269897, 0.0672014057636261, -0.2411574125289917, 0.03906296193599701, 0.2277788519859314, -0.4668298065662384, 0.666120707988739, -0.6018038988113403, 0.011639165692031384, 0.42704567313194275, 0.24564604461193085, 0.47967326641082764, 0.3921552300453186, 0.530453085899353, 0.3608602285385132, 1.0022650957107544, 0.019631901755928993, 1.234422206878662, -0.36246994137763977, 0.04864533990621567, 0.9027853608131409, -0.43809032440185547, 0.8097078204154968, 0.7794767022132874, -0.18314801156520844, 0.09755434840917587, 0.8179868459701538, 0.05626161769032478, 0.21649052202701569, 0.12116783857345581, -0.4900854527950287, -0.3687117099761963, -0.34464335441589355, -0.5203506946563721, 0.06791877001523972, 0.47629302740097046, -0.4330916404724121, 0.1002269983291626, -0.06643316149711609, 0.29903942346572876, 0.014018249697983265, -0.26700395345687866, 0.7985450029373169, 0.312160462141037, -0.8305783271789551, 0.39743709564208984, -0.05647430196404457, 0.46159544587135315, -0.44270238280296326, -0.2440127283334732, -0.1302531361579895, -0.06744059175252914, -0.44365400075912476, -1.0579229593276978, -0.2530471980571747, 0.0983530580997467, -0.1391536146402359, -0.027198776602745056, 0.7932155728340149, -0.4414307475090027, -0.32210835814476013, 0.03863475099205971, 0.953032374382019, 0.05861853435635567, 0.2851780951023102, -0.5007063150405884, 0.22229519486427307, -0.08166361600160599, -0.10575583577156067, 0.16460494697093964, 0.18990373611450195, 0.15812495350837708, 0.9003058671951294, 0.6522336006164551, 0.46848562359809875, -0.09271323680877686, 0.2257445603609085, 0.8637217879295349, -0.41788893938064575, -0.12264005094766617, -0.910486102104187, 0.36362650990486145, -0.16072794795036316, -0.00812765397131443, 0.560017466545105, 0.1537657529115677, 0.5036545395851135, -0.0023584775626659393, 0.7458812594413757, 0.15976077318191528, 0.4871468245983124, -0.6970021724700928, 0.47386884689331055, -0.508462131023407, 0.5061622858047485, -0.040346790105104446, -0.7215207815170288, -0.40061700344085693, 0.5519923567771912, -0.3516976833343506, 0.23637329041957855, 0.6272818446159363, 0.675115168094635, 0.022770922631025314, -0.06791016459465027, 0.3023265600204468, 0.24134986102581024, 0.4869159162044525, 0.47094541788101196, 1.1986132860183716, 0.12386960536241531, 0.1887115091085434, -0.041247133165597916, -0.37935933470726013, -0.23944371938705444, -0.6219325661659241, -1.0325427055358887, -0.25251880288124084, -0.2098887413740158, -0.43575602769851685, 0.07970186322927475, 1.390320062637329, 0.47449791431427, -0.2805010676383972, -0.16622404754161835, 0.3008805215358734, -0.020150037482380867, -0.06272370368242264, -0.0870666429400444, 0.20894908905029297, -0.3168729543685913, -0.6749577522277832, 0.4282200336456299, 0.32937610149383545, 0.31564128398895264, 0.09375324845314026, -0.18149416148662567, 0.2634466588497162, 0.23670418560504913, 0.6491991281509399, 0.06421449780464172, -0.881281852722168, -0.2169424593448639, 0.15567071735858917, -0.3758614659309387, 0.09430038928985596, 1.0067033767700195, -0.5730937719345093, 0.6175788640975952, 0.17983950674533844, 0.8917706608772278, -0.12956160306930542, 0.18438905477523804, 0.7293509840965271, -0.35292816162109375, -0.3299424648284912, 0.17249801754951477, 0.5299262404441833, 0.30611589550971985, -0.5076732635498047, 0.4285842478275299, -0.0637146383523941, -0.7746843695640564, -0.5943371653556824, 0.24527691304683685, -1.0199021100997925, -0.30636948347091675, 1.4916263818740845, 0.09803851693868637, 0.13214923441410065, -0.18898357450962067, -0.9483128190040588, 0.03727946802973747, -0.2754056453704834, 0.6641119718551636, 0.7531605362892151, -0.7074667811393738, -0.16576099395751953, -0.7760762572288513, 0.5460038781166077, 0.6432992219924927, -0.7979972958564758, -0.15956386923789978, 0.6469224691390991, 0.4275760352611542, -0.06633176654577255, 0.9114746451377869, -0.13581231236457825, 0.4555627405643463, -0.49162212014198303, -0.3204065263271332, -0.04695397987961769, -0.1482677310705185, -0.6075994968414307, -0.2757715582847595, 0.8093318939208984, -0.054983001202344894 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20284v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20284v1
LayerNorm: A key component in parameter-efficient fine-tuning
2024-03-29T16:53:11
2024-03-29T16:53:11
Taha ValizadehAslani, Hualou Liang
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.LG
Fine-tuning a pre-trained model, such as Bidirectional Encoder Representations from Transformers (BERT), has been proven to be an effective method for solving many natural language processing (NLP) tasks. However, due to the large number of parameters in many state-of-the-art NLP models, including BERT, the process of fine-tuning is computationally expensive. One attractive solution to this issue is parameter-efficient fine-tuning, which involves modifying only a minimal segment of the model while keeping the remainder unchanged. Yet, it remains unclear which segment of the BERT model is crucial for fine-tuning. In this paper, we first analyze different components in the BERT model to pinpoint which one undergoes the most significant changes after fine-tuning. We find that output LayerNorm changes more than any other components when fine-tuned for different General Language Understanding Evaluation (GLUE) tasks. Then we show that only fine-tuning the LayerNorm can reach comparable, or in some cases better, performance to full fine-tuning and other parameter-efficient fine-tuning methods. Moreover, we use Fisher information to determine the most critical subset of LayerNorm and demonstrate that many NLP tasks in the GLUE benchmark can be solved by fine-tuning only a small portion of LayerNorm with negligible performance degradation.
[ -0.7453243732452393, -0.7457780838012695, 0.2816142141819, 0.24506226181983948, -0.4229453504085541, -0.2135997861623764, -0.5525026917457581, -0.5744732618331909, -0.25896820425987244, 0.6821551322937012, -0.728542685508728, -0.3832240104675293, -0.6111527681350708, -0.22185055911540985, -0.24345965683460236, 1.0385347604751587, 0.08820941299200058, -0.1608102172613144, -0.157459557056427, -0.05386192724108696, -0.1981883943080902, -0.20335161685943604, -0.8896570801734924, -0.555290162563324, 0.7164925932884216, 0.40593889355659485, 0.716469407081604, 0.7407538294792175, 0.621345043182373, 0.2526898682117462, -0.2944684326648712, 0.4608008563518524, -0.5437099933624268, 0.17648863792419434, -0.2046854943037033, -0.50027996301651, -0.35714778304100037, 0.049920834600925446, 0.5839630365371704, 0.9628609418869019, 0.1282663643360138, 0.4265303611755371, 0.44050854444503784, 1.0111693143844604, -0.5367042422294617, 0.061830561608076096, -0.9513364434242249, -0.03761693835258484, -0.06718150526285172, -0.3181529939174652, -0.23737342655658722, -0.12886165082454681, 0.4098717272281647, -0.233904629945755, 0.3457840383052826, -0.05100175365805626, 1.1171245574951172, 0.5831325054168701, -0.17278048396110535, 0.008781367912888527, -0.8926404118537903, 0.9511273503303528, -0.9121045470237732, 0.5553492307662964, 0.3114170432090759, -0.013673737645149231, -0.26586487889289856, -0.5257864594459534, -0.35282638669013977, -0.1535923331975937, 0.059402819722890854, -0.09313057363033295, 0.02457551099359989, 0.33345717191696167, 0.041887808591127396, 0.2377542406320572, -0.27513962984085083, 0.49495524168014526, -0.3796083629131317, -0.17370820045471191, 0.4067403972148895, -0.05502690374851227, 0.21648620069026947, -0.3354893922805786, -0.5915119051933289, -0.09509078413248062, -0.4570229947566986, 0.2584987282752991, 0.4015149474143982, 0.5059041976928711, 0.16493768990039825, 0.3790697157382965, -0.03888422250747681, 0.8254976868629456, 0.00857383944094181, 0.025356194004416466, -0.1250346153974533, -0.07449186593294144, -0.4785847067832947, 0.13436147570610046, 0.4446554183959961, 0.22150331735610962, 0.44522935152053833, -0.24688465893268585, -0.22838644683361053, -0.18181835114955902, 0.45495447516441345, -0.7940033674240112, -0.42056646943092346, 0.4268646538257599, -0.4608321487903595, -0.0742337554693222, -0.1873919665813446, -0.1513936072587967, -0.02707603946328163, -0.7617401480674744, 0.5074240565299988, -0.7052575349807739, 0.01858655922114849, 0.37595200538635254, -0.16244322061538696, 0.30713286995887756, 0.436630517244339, -0.8456971049308777, 0.19974364340305328, 1.1305598020553589, 0.7121345400810242, -0.16219866275787354, -0.27307966351509094, -0.4074859917163849, 0.1526661366224289, -0.4308508634567261, 0.6391344666481018, -0.5547558069229126, 0.23415569961071014, -0.17889715731143951, -0.13335570693016052, -0.3457532227039337, -0.8324524760246277, 0.790145218372345, -0.5032230019569397, 0.1383003294467926, -0.35561299324035645, -0.7517809867858887, -0.30562737584114075, 0.0765659436583519, -0.5674428939819336, 0.9711946845054626, 0.03175053372979164, -0.5883477926254272, 0.4304482936859131, -0.4640858471393585, -0.4317188560962677, -0.0653279721736908, 0.22332921624183655, -0.4527617394924164, 0.3727036714553833, 0.4071348309516907, 0.8136868476867676, -0.17755462229251862, -0.012242777273058891, -0.1647881716489792, -0.394053190946579, -0.03948802873492241, -0.2575159966945648, 0.8538106679916382, 0.030159957706928253, -0.23816967010498047, -0.01736285723745823, -0.8725476264953613, 0.09125038236379623, -0.2090408056974411, -0.4856480062007904, -0.49359840154647827, 0.14645832777023315, -0.07003062963485718, 0.06429629027843475, 0.36970335245132446, -0.5569317936897278, -0.021425282582640648, -0.46744227409362793, 0.4715762436389923, 0.9400296807289124, 0.06049967184662819, 0.572583019733429, -0.28649312257766724, 0.15261544287204742, 0.2253042608499527, 0.21130044758319855, 0.08406912535429001, -0.5931270718574524, -1.1878657341003418, -0.2736339569091797, 0.5733314752578735, 0.24152663350105286, -0.42068201303482056, 0.4567095935344696, 0.2323986440896988, -0.5763687491416931, -0.8664478659629822, 0.4658420979976654, 0.3090328872203827, 0.5816690325737, 0.5042569637298584, -0.1914377510547638, -0.5049272775650024, -1.2991825342178345, -0.5647470951080322, -0.04163990169763565, -0.2105073183774948, 0.3575831651687622, 0.08113528043031693, -0.3603420853614807, 0.7692789435386658, -0.23409439623355865, -0.5590872764587402, -0.2194414585828781, 0.2916954755783081, 0.3795316815376282, 0.8109710812568665, 0.5698816776275635, -0.3931281268596649, -0.48064279556274414, -0.026653263717889786, -0.1917741447687149, -0.144813671708107, -0.4111793339252472, -0.33029481768608093, 0.10180406272411346, 0.5158020257949829, -0.6107178926467896, -0.018944745883345604, 0.6213604211807251, 0.04746627062559128, 0.33194655179977417, -0.5949678421020508, -0.2543690800666809, -0.49071580171585083, -0.1950334906578064, 0.08127967268228531, -0.16017478704452515, -0.6823278069496155, 0.35954520106315613, 0.14093463122844696, 0.1068546324968338, -0.3242960274219513, 0.0343528687953949, -0.48113277554512024, 0.2264413833618164, -0.005602933466434479, 0.22652393579483032, 0.099779412150383, 0.766177773475647, -0.30759888887405396, 0.6562296748161316, 0.34952566027641296, -0.8608880639076233, -0.0638425201177597, -0.03601809963583946, -0.5909156799316406, 0.16152837872505188, -0.8644622564315796, 0.3596612811088562, -0.3786216974258423, -0.2752971649169922, -0.86495041847229, 0.1368618607521057, -0.0812935084104538, -0.036147382110357285, 0.508125901222229, -0.16022130846977234, -0.5156106948852539, -0.08671138435602188, -0.386740118265152, 0.0393994003534317, 0.5396620631217957, -0.6545469760894775, 0.5877022743225098, 0.33219635486602783, 0.026359517127275467, -0.34097054600715637, -0.5557217597961426, -0.17086507380008698, -0.044201675802469254, -0.8489879965782166, 0.6836769580841064, -0.050773974508047104, 0.1832423061132431, -0.18342603743076324, -0.29801520705223083, -0.011473932303488255, 0.2530357539653778, 0.05984539911150932, -0.06403671950101852, -0.41918623447418213, -0.12491874396800995, 0.3710562586784363, -0.28670763969421387, 0.24027562141418457, -0.210007905960083, 0.6973138451576233, -0.24474145472049713, -0.222917839884758, -0.4900408089160919, 0.02800552174448967, 0.3696305453777313, -0.2955690026283264, 0.7889536619186401, 0.8864924907684326, -0.2776540517807007, -0.7644854187965393, -0.6903670430183411, -0.14167068898677826, -0.5248023867607117, 0.43252265453338623, -0.26490840315818787, -0.9027870893478394, 0.6626112461090088, -0.14069809019565582, 0.060115307569503784, 0.48309826850891113, 0.3369486331939697, -0.5066184997558594, 1.1170951128005981, 0.6045246720314026, -0.12093738466501236, 0.3120231032371521, -0.36857593059539795, 0.31545424461364746, -1.1880463361740112, -0.22199657559394836, -0.6675764322280884, -0.8464024662971497, -0.6406792402267456, -0.4951467514038086, 0.31495997309684753, 0.510355532169342, -0.1070549264550209, 0.5631071925163269, -0.5736929178237915, 0.6428912878036499, 0.8700929880142212, 0.23633088171482086, 0.10832537710666656, -0.07542138546705246, -0.2525113523006439, -0.15579195320606232, -0.8270694017410278, -0.5160664916038513, 0.6712919473648071, 0.5488804578781128, 0.5111768841743469, 0.09664486348628998, 0.6810072064399719, -0.04611937701702118, -0.54351407289505, -0.6335359215736389, 0.7375701069831848, -0.732938826084137, -0.44435355067253113, -0.25814855098724365, -0.24581551551818848, -0.9481989145278931, 0.12249725311994553, -0.10031688213348389, -0.687164306640625, 0.46887439489364624, 0.2252851277589798, -0.45856159925460815, 0.3957107663154602, -0.8321974873542786, 0.7182093262672424, 0.08321856707334518, -0.24781641364097595, -0.33481791615486145, -0.5798584222793579, 0.17562831938266754, 0.06817008554935455, -0.3894822597503662, -0.42572593688964844, 0.01834767311811447, 0.6699656248092651, -0.1765318214893341, 0.6973141431808472, -0.32679834961891174, -0.2259744256734848, -0.022999927401542664, 0.1943780779838562, 0.3811168372631073, 0.15354971587657928, -0.12395749241113663, 0.26969000697135925, 0.07151953876018524, -0.37239983677864075, -0.5370969176292419, 0.8510632514953613, -0.9997981786727905, -0.6967900395393372, 0.006489054765552282, -0.5363390445709229, -0.32461169362068176, -0.03968357294797897, 0.054953791201114655, 0.5230793356895447, 0.11730913817882538, 0.7019596099853516, 1.0423983335494995, -0.4132195711135864, 0.48917850852012634, 0.24929971992969513, 0.04663272574543953, 0.3032917380332947, 0.9296349883079529, 0.2460731714963913, 0.2982217073440552, 0.5316892862319946, 0.21923425793647766, 0.026075299829244614, -0.79987633228302, -0.18628884851932526, 0.09348836541175842, -0.5387519001960754, -0.24234850704669952, -0.6115860342979431, -0.6686424016952515, 0.08929356932640076, -0.12638399004936218, -0.6506724953651428, -0.5639876127243042, -0.5787171721458435, 0.11836158484220505, 0.14783164858818054, 0.42104026675224304, -0.10211449861526489, 0.17380324006080627, -0.6765892505645752, 0.5658739805221558, 0.7133512496948242, 0.6759082674980164, 0.15376384556293488, -0.4957650601863861, -0.2563912868499756, 0.18127994239330292, -0.050703175365924835, -0.22142276167869568, 0.11833067238330841, 0.706605076789856, 0.5609191060066223, 0.5498612523078918, 0.02899881638586521, 1.0064557790756226, -0.5715663433074951, 0.9004167318344116, -0.366401731967926, -0.9086478352546692, 0.5875306129455566, -0.24103669822216034, 0.4177628755569458, 0.5683561563491821, 0.1371190845966339, -0.15879735350608826, -0.5862910747528076, -0.4604964554309845, -0.9913833141326904, 0.7393912672996521, 0.2531527876853943, 0.398682177066803, 0.1853126436471939, 0.40405553579330444, 0.2140989899635315, 0.04055773466825485, -0.185216024518013, -0.2472195327281952, 0.0722736194729805, 0.07365171611309052, -0.008087154477834702, -0.5718513131141663, 0.013056941330432892, -0.6853764653205872, 0.6730106472969055, 0.05820098891854286, 0.20792673528194427, 0.14210011065006256, -0.30288729071617126, -0.20649613440036774, 0.170397087931633, 0.6738390326499939, 0.6758868098258972, -0.8369224667549133, 0.30867061018943787, 0.09312782436609268, -0.3923274576663971, -0.42824888229370117, -0.008093215525150299, -0.2736271321773529, 0.13700824975967407, 0.5090319514274597, 1.0195096731185913, 0.4623897075653076, -0.405635267496109, 0.20880644023418427, 0.11539172381162643, -0.26717063784599304, -0.0461149737238884, 0.6815309524536133, 0.06604594737291336, 0.4088907837867737, 0.45521560311317444, 0.46238812804222107, 0.06555932015180588, -0.3795052766799927, 0.12757037580013275, 0.5658939480781555, -0.47016316652297974, -0.26518702507019043, 0.724772572517395, 0.07791232317686081, -0.37774163484573364, 0.6711748242378235, 0.014455331489443779, -0.568135678768158, 0.6130303144454956, 0.34796443581581116, 0.9539036154747009, -0.03240169584751129, 0.34926488995552063, 0.11326944082975388, 0.6003636717796326, 0.21399863064289093, 0.1948426514863968, -0.05216306447982788, -0.866577684879303, -0.45508837699890137, -0.8856810331344604, -0.21415975689888, 0.179816335439682, -0.8469229340553284, 0.10891187191009521, -0.7466607689857483, -0.06310847401618958, 0.2636496424674988, 0.046577055007219315, -0.968860924243927, 0.24319733679294586, 0.19148346781730652, 0.9893150329589844, -0.37893643975257874, 0.8935248851776123, 0.4581359326839447, -0.0694531574845314, -0.7196469902992249, -0.08224066346883774, -0.4166232645511627, -0.908054530620575, 0.576748788356781, -0.017270922660827637, -0.18578435480594635, 0.04964043200016022, -0.591748058795929, -0.7472013831138611, 0.7012069225311279, 0.7041577100753784, -0.7020047903060913, 0.02427428960800171, 0.3652042746543884, 0.756661593914032, -0.24454377591609955, 0.09827569872140884, 0.837763786315918, 0.31554362177848816, -0.2595512568950653, -0.8357076644897461, -0.21823273599147797, -0.0046887085773050785, 0.574044406414032, 0.256282240152359, -0.660724937915802, 1.0357292890548706, -0.0670127421617508, -0.16488395631313324, -0.20209379494190216, 0.5921841859817505, -0.036162566393613815, -0.22714975476264954, 0.6702802181243896, 0.503714919090271, 0.5964794158935547, -0.22218146920204163, 0.7710520625114441, -0.5765657424926758, 0.25722745060920715, 1.1577479839324951, 0.1772833913564682, 1.1054054498672485, 0.6615463495254517, -0.07213443517684937, 0.5877057909965515, 0.4190925061702728, 0.06200635805726051, 0.5867409706115723, 0.002414700808003545, 0.21513552963733673, -0.4296831786632538, 0.011356293223798275, -0.28394460678100586, 0.5595915913581848, 0.19803692400455475, -0.3780663013458252, -0.18199051916599274, -0.15956133604049683, -0.19575633108615875, -0.06445644795894623, -0.3253960907459259, 0.9774178266525269, 0.13500697910785675, -0.40336519479751587, 0.8109537959098816, 0.17131808400154114, 0.5667449235916138, -0.6578155755996704, 0.1463867574930191, -0.19038823246955872, 0.4559938609600067, -0.2142743319272995, -0.6558341383934021, 0.2791062593460083, -0.33794429898262024, -0.3072468638420105, -0.4700475335121155, 0.8269577026367188, -0.5701552033424377, -0.41050440073013306, 0.4641505181789398, 0.24338297545909882, -0.19981324672698975, -0.2337249219417572, -0.8204202055931091, 0.06363528966903687, 0.050565704703330994, -0.41043585538864136, 0.36333906650543213, 0.46781253814697266, 0.48809298872947693, 0.6653339266777039, 0.7406980991363525, 0.31450405716896057, 0.287055104970932, 0.40437760949134827, 0.9215043783187866, -0.5536491870880127, -0.2890913784503937, -0.7341762185096741, 0.6572346091270447, -0.11157313734292984, -0.4427163898944855, 0.7433238625526428, 0.36768460273742676, 1.026422381401062, -0.1210109293460846, 0.26728731393814087, 0.39114266633987427, 0.6481425762176514, -0.7260615825653076, 0.7994642853736877, -0.5125512480735779, 0.5372301340103149, -0.41892462968826294, -1.2806978225708008, -0.18077832460403442, 0.7033731937408447, 0.026704439893364906, -0.15755991637706757, 0.46382153034210205, 0.692886233329773, -0.25118905305862427, 0.2911064922809601, 0.10329724103212357, 0.4175427556037903, 0.16106055676937103, 0.45493084192276, 0.5591149926185608, -0.6274589896202087, 0.13733260333538055, -0.7527939677238464, 0.1610923707485199, -0.08839743584394455, -0.9212526679039001, -1.0634651184082031, -0.6246402859687805, -0.507960855960846, 0.030546389520168304, -0.02816479094326496, 0.9314613938331604, 0.8713614344596863, -1.0983810424804688, -0.12410316616296768, 0.006101649254560471, 0.060944609344005585, -0.4778047800064087, -0.22840242087841034, 0.34199774265289307, -0.7758792638778687, -0.7250454425811768, 0.3024445176124573, 0.5850374698638916, -0.3256995379924774, -0.4713069498538971, 0.11875637620687485, -0.25403162837028503, 0.23561067879199982, 0.8477047085762024, -0.2269650399684906, -0.8935439586639404, -0.5517252683639526, -0.17843207716941833, 0.10140358656644821, 0.11808215081691742, 0.6441122889518738, -0.6374949216842651, 0.58130943775177, 0.4378539025783539, 0.9193258285522461, 0.6518287658691406, -0.03799585625529289, 0.6822429895401001, -1.0727224349975586, 0.1519620716571808, 0.3273332715034485, 0.185276061296463, 0.1877194046974182, -0.2812613248825073, 0.3303276002407074, -0.30742892622947693, -0.6308554410934448, -0.9140591621398926, -0.04949524253606796, -1.094804048538208, -0.3475787043571472, 0.9257808327674866, 0.22155272960662842, -0.23053620755672455, -0.024538224563002586, -0.21907645463943481, 0.0767126977443695, -0.22900016605854034, 0.7581843137741089, 0.6410956382751465, -0.13271789252758026, -0.5238177180290222, -0.4169062674045563, 0.8084887266159058, 0.6812500953674316, -0.35527026653289795, -0.11634952574968338, -0.11954312771558762, 0.07178640365600586, 0.12210094928741455, -0.02520298771560192, 0.35557857155799866, -0.21344493329524994, -0.46608245372772217, -0.4386154115200043, -0.11281085759401321, -0.5056152939796448, -0.06393647938966751, 0.312854140996933, 0.09128446877002716, -0.1893443465232849 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20279v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20279v1
LUQ: Long-text Uncertainty Quantification for LLMs
2024-03-29T16:49:24
2024-03-29T16:49:24
Caiqi Zhang, Fangyu Liu, Marco Basaldella, Nigel Collier
cs.CL
cs.CL
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capability in a variety of NLP tasks. Despite their effectiveness, these models are prone to generate nonfactual content. Uncertainty Quantification (UQ) is pivotal in enhancing our understanding of a model's confidence in its generated content, thereby aiding in the mitigation of nonfactual outputs. Existing research on UQ predominantly targets short text generation, typically yielding brief, word-limited responses. However, real-world applications frequently necessitate much longer responses. Our study first highlights the limitations of current UQ methods in handling long text generation. We then introduce \textsc{Luq}, a novel sampling-based UQ approach specifically designed for long text. Our findings reveal that \textsc{Luq} outperforms existing baseline methods in correlating with the model's factuality scores (negative coefficient of -0.85 observed for Gemini Pro). With \textsc{Luq} as the tool for UQ, we investigate behavior patterns of several popular LLMs' response confidence spectrum and how that interplays with the response' factuality. We identify that LLMs lack confidence in generating long text for rare facts and a factually strong model (i.e. GPT-4) tends to reject questions it is not sure about. To further improve the factual accuracy of LLM responses, we propose a method called \textsc{Luq-Ensemble} that ensembles responses from multiple models and selects the response with the least uncertainty. The ensembling method greatly improves the response factuality upon the best standalone LLM.
[ -0.182680144906044, -0.9366025328636169, 0.8503896594047546, 0.1871793270111084, -0.221573606133461, 0.22627580165863037, -0.12803533673286438, -0.5728852152824402, 0.24474479258060455, 0.37370792031288147, -0.4340694546699524, -0.49254941940307617, -0.47986647486686707, 0.08663929253816605, -0.7288029193878174, 1.002573013305664, 0.10161685198545456, -0.28787961602211, -0.38781651854515076, -0.053959522396326065, 0.00014586832548957318, -0.5120726227760315, -0.49826979637145996, -0.2632569670677185, 0.6034412980079651, 0.1529841423034668, 0.8948771357536316, 0.13151013851165771, 0.5363616943359375, 0.2040836066007614, -0.11299733817577362, 0.1935902088880539, -0.479651540517807, 0.20962226390838623, 0.05318068340420723, -0.5224321484565735, -0.602573812007904, -0.11733226478099823, 0.6591190695762634, 0.6520470976829529, -0.2808619439601898, 0.20893478393554688, 0.11214254051446915, 0.7393129467964172, -0.8950866460800171, -0.23253971338272095, -0.640545666217804, 0.1043832078576088, -0.3013884723186493, 0.1054576113820076, -0.3936702609062195, -0.2758582532405853, 0.029468810185790062, -0.6211016774177551, 0.0815090462565422, 0.3261413872241974, 0.8028700351715088, 0.3028997778892517, -0.6306023597717285, -0.21113941073417664, -1.0622532367706299, 1.0105839967727661, -0.9598122835159302, 0.19179831445217133, 0.37555983662605286, 0.0042707291431725025, -0.13410913944244385, -0.8180046677589417, -0.723615288734436, -0.12642791867256165, 0.09291023761034012, 0.4663203954696655, -0.11016866564750671, 0.16758882999420166, 0.13761945068836212, 0.42743226885795593, -0.6459510922431946, 0.12787245213985443, -0.19318006932735443, -0.3999718725681305, 0.7250400185585022, 0.1671973317861557, -0.14159546792507172, -0.2360675036907196, -0.4500056803226471, 0.005103166215121746, -0.7751161456108093, 0.13057424128055573, 0.43258136510849, -0.15458762645721436, 0.18467000126838684, 0.7461761832237244, -0.24803125858306885, 0.5958799123764038, 0.030014201998710632, -0.33012813329696655, -0.062166664749383926, -0.3356413245201111, -0.45537346601486206, 0.007815388031303883, 1.0360805988311768, 0.2335124909877777, -0.14320488274097443, 0.09887714684009552, -0.4895293116569519, -0.06143464893102646, 0.04171273112297058, -0.6492917537689209, 0.05829382315278053, 0.6402165293693542, -0.2138243466615677, -0.3697669804096222, 0.14839622378349304, -0.769117534160614, -0.314470499753952, -0.11294548958539963, 0.6429502964019775, -0.44999077916145325, -0.06324809789657593, 0.022729741409420967, 0.14286847412586212, 0.12162800133228302, 0.37012797594070435, -0.642331063747406, 0.15125274658203125, 0.5153312087059021, 0.5113734006881714, -0.34757983684539795, -0.06134764850139618, -0.49761220812797546, 0.14219602942466736, -0.5691839456558228, 0.5445238351821899, -0.28615233302116394, -0.5150085091590881, 0.05122285708785057, -0.31080618500709534, 0.07483760267496109, -0.3243121802806854, 0.7734856605529785, -0.64387047290802, 0.3420161008834839, -0.08824874460697174, -0.885367751121521, 0.12703999876976013, 0.2868064045906067, -0.6720643043518066, 1.3644053936004639, 0.11579243838787079, -0.9360376000404358, 0.2535916864871979, -0.3283286988735199, -0.16576603055000305, 0.1181807667016983, -0.2715553939342499, -0.4604087769985199, 0.2965599000453949, 0.2835046052932739, 0.49768343567848206, -0.28381019830703735, 0.25518444180488586, -0.26931092143058777, -0.46868205070495605, 0.7557011842727661, -0.5927103161811829, 0.26167142391204834, 0.36320990324020386, -0.0861620306968689, 0.0017609643982723355, -0.7090091705322266, 0.2824905812740326, -0.05411352589726448, -0.3729059398174286, -0.23588143289089203, 0.03511880710721016, -0.061553481966257095, -0.0587172657251358, 0.423532634973526, -0.5343673825263977, -0.039263296872377396, -0.5265452265739441, 0.29177963733673096, 0.5693151354789734, 0.07917921245098114, 0.4347241222858429, -0.3113350570201874, 0.4928188920021057, -0.07431920617818832, 0.21169207990169525, 0.04631383344531059, -0.5747421383857727, -0.7456854581832886, -0.13146372139453888, 0.4952104389667511, 0.6129639148712158, -0.9110209345817566, 0.5361937284469604, -0.24448223412036896, -0.38931897282600403, -0.40313199162483215, 0.07333708554506302, 0.18314366042613983, 0.41388070583343506, 0.22031836211681366, 0.026730915531516075, -0.3515132963657379, -0.7527030110359192, -0.22869673371315002, -0.29689908027648926, -0.2781379520893097, 0.020219463855028152, 0.5789366960525513, -0.19581104815006256, 1.1197348833084106, -0.5068175196647644, 0.18989773094654083, -0.07309108227491379, 0.4361147880554199, 0.4492627680301666, 0.10883873701095581, 0.3873736560344696, -0.7776317596435547, -0.387910395860672, -0.30594247579574585, -0.7099886536598206, 0.24917326867580414, -0.24232496321201324, -0.045658405870199203, 0.48822689056396484, 0.3991207182407379, -0.9564513564109802, 0.5564443469047546, 0.6881229877471924, -0.026868877932429314, 0.561603844165802, -0.1940770149230957, 0.18885937333106995, -1.0964500904083252, 0.007558309938758612, -0.11108724027872086, -0.19222478568553925, -0.40908849239349365, 0.040958065539598465, 0.1881541758775711, 0.10441578179597855, -0.3824639618396759, 0.4001300036907196, -0.26058104634284973, -0.14473170042037964, -0.24371320009231567, 0.2057397961616516, 0.10374915599822998, 0.15316352248191833, -0.006219474598765373, 0.6794415712356567, 0.3252969980239868, -0.6622759103775024, 0.5480772256851196, -0.09950391948223114, -0.5593171119689941, 0.5441925525665283, -0.7168717384338379, 0.19219310581684113, -0.14896245300769806, 0.260101318359375, -1.0145865678787231, -0.5030319690704346, 0.057604964822530746, -0.5576503276824951, 0.22973410785198212, 0.06508541852235794, -0.5113644599914551, -0.5703888535499573, -0.4000073969364166, 0.24300801753997803, 0.6215805411338806, -0.24927417933940887, 0.5284677147865295, -0.018535098060965538, -0.2069820761680603, -0.9077686667442322, -0.6855717301368713, 0.059389740228652954, -0.27900731563568115, -0.7650492191314697, 0.4263630509376526, -0.35654762387275696, -0.4493867754936218, -0.23399929702281952, -0.3503818213939667, -0.08354803919792175, 0.12622444331645966, 0.11330538988113403, 0.24258887767791748, -0.15329910814762115, 0.4702449142932892, 0.12027961015701294, 0.1015506312251091, 0.08842867612838745, -0.20883044600486755, 0.3010638952255249, -0.09845723956823349, -0.5418111085891724, -0.17678456008434296, 0.2465531826019287, 0.35820436477661133, -0.07428337633609772, 0.69858717918396, 0.8690902590751648, -0.3419118821620941, -0.23378214240074158, -0.4619065225124359, -0.26628589630126953, -0.45504748821258545, 0.2524678111076355, -0.08385351300239563, -1.0128133296966553, 0.44182315468788147, 0.15212976932525635, 0.03643125295639038, 0.5539718866348267, 0.4756079912185669, -0.5300605893135071, 0.8001754879951477, 0.5484426021575928, -0.1551402360200882, 0.053686585277318954, 0.16120068728923798, 0.247713103890419, -0.4580622613430023, 0.04647932946681976, -0.3955606520175934, -0.14301760494709015, -0.5033289790153503, -0.5874756574630737, 0.5254186391830444, 0.2012357860803604, -0.15857738256454468, -0.26067233085632324, -0.24782618880271912, 0.35324105620384216, 0.5589754581451416, 0.10948066413402557, 0.41748160123825073, 0.014075029641389847, 0.11552652716636658, -0.19281359016895294, -0.40326330065727234, -0.4542352855205536, 1.2487465143203735, 0.39234450459480286, 1.0825787782669067, 0.3698413074016571, 0.7516610026359558, 0.3161468803882599, 0.15251807868480682, -0.8265816569328308, 0.4439467489719391, 0.1586330085992813, -0.6225837469100952, -0.6354107856750488, -0.6325992345809937, -0.9266830682754517, -0.06143933907151222, -0.5455278754234314, -0.6161511540412903, -0.1263059377670288, 0.1756526231765747, -0.9348635673522949, 0.18975843489170074, -0.2706734538078308, 0.20470106601715088, -0.28286024928092957, -0.3160659074783325, 0.06479498744010925, -0.84375, 0.5242588520050049, -0.5233029723167419, 0.34353384375572205, -0.12199611216783524, -0.19844366610050201, 0.5626530051231384, -0.25488752126693726, 0.822034478187561, 0.2880033254623413, -0.5401545166969299, 0.5462759137153625, 0.1732178032398224, 0.8795171976089478, 0.5180150866508484, -0.11441489309072495, -0.13402359187602997, 0.06286655366420746, -0.4282699227333069, -0.504149854183197, 0.6069657206535339, -0.7381809949874878, -0.3677055537700653, -0.5107668042182922, -0.4840949475765228, -0.3260973393917084, -0.10334005206823349, 0.7305617928504944, 0.17056524753570557, -0.20067070424556732, 0.2412257194519043, 0.9955337643623352, -0.4221414029598236, 0.5926032662391663, 0.35950711369514465, -0.3806876242160797, -0.34526991844177246, 0.5261597633361816, -0.018260130658745766, 0.39306512475013733, 0.6260650157928467, 0.12306509166955948, -0.4200392961502075, -0.5821573734283447, -0.11964038014411926, 0.051403142511844635, -0.5754560232162476, -0.2714884877204895, -0.35182905197143555, -0.35066941380500793, -0.5570054054260254, 0.06824878603219986, -0.40067988634109497, -0.4720199406147003, -0.2918497920036316, -0.19304288923740387, 0.3523777425289154, 0.7724452614784241, -0.008894086815416813, 0.45305249094963074, -1.0331110954284668, 0.23406651616096497, 0.569273829460144, -0.0018716570921242237, -0.4938870668411255, -0.728573739528656, -0.23951473832130432, 0.21947290003299713, -0.21888504922389984, -0.9366446137428284, 0.5249715447425842, 0.323513001203537, 0.45853275060653687, 0.37352511286735535, 0.4243713915348053, 0.26825860142707825, -0.08814522624015808, 1.1134542226791382, 0.13207027316093445, -0.9767122864723206, 0.5061002373695374, -0.4577484428882599, 0.1550184190273285, 0.2897074520587921, 0.37270912528038025, -0.4218190610408783, -0.4408990740776062, -0.7278968095779419, -1.0926671028137207, 0.1968051940202713, 0.5819599628448486, 0.22000928223133087, 0.10098405927419662, 0.6517208814620972, -0.15560327470302582, 0.44308724999427795, -0.951472818851471, -0.24783286452293396, -0.09158477932214737, -0.4403683841228485, -0.09441932290792465, -0.504391074180603, -0.260095477104187, 0.10944217443466187, 0.5663872361183167, -0.36524853110313416, 0.3856551945209503, 0.39690014719963074, -0.10697071999311447, -0.2332233488559723, 0.4932915270328522, 0.6641657948493958, 0.6170134544372559, -0.4939180016517639, 0.13920056819915771, 0.3318632245063782, -0.3520534634590149, -0.06339196860790253, -0.10179149359464645, -0.18714936077594757, 0.061665162444114685, 0.4354037046432495, 0.488402783870697, -0.016165994107723236, -0.6527729034423828, 0.6096903681755066, -0.063404880464077, -0.2974897027015686, -0.582543134689331, -0.030957967042922974, 0.1401941329240799, 0.10961685329675674, 0.608238160610199, 0.0003177708713337779, 0.13783711194992065, -0.405827134847641, 0.15968863666057587, 0.33926689624786377, -0.31254199147224426, -0.12893421947956085, 0.5155336856842041, 0.16826386749744415, 0.11990965157747269, 0.7092441916465759, -0.25670692324638367, -0.18732154369354248, 0.6695706844329834, 0.3737625479698181, 0.37580201029777527, -0.0665537491440773, 0.30782097578048706, 0.41885796189308167, 0.3538161516189575, -0.24543315172195435, 0.37216585874557495, 0.33927759528160095, -0.9214701056480408, -0.7988376021385193, -0.638764500617981, -0.5095036029815674, 0.28284043073654175, -0.7905110120773315, -0.029980234801769257, -0.37108129262924194, -0.4915275275707245, -0.43447428941726685, -0.0498618520796299, -0.32444775104522705, 0.3347044587135315, 0.3465731739997864, 0.7475984692573547, -0.6865492463111877, 0.7951157689094543, 0.4883502721786499, -0.12506818771362305, -0.8032167553901672, 0.1660131961107254, 0.07297433912754059, -0.6828499436378479, 0.47749942541122437, -0.09476179629564285, -0.07805657386779785, -0.028728369623422623, -1.0364049673080444, -0.9732416868209839, 1.227562427520752, 0.287476509809494, -0.7580599784851074, 0.0780792161822319, 0.302363783121109, 0.4709838032722473, -0.007085474207997322, 0.2233399599790573, 0.41500723361968994, 0.4549623727798462, 0.2583194971084595, -0.7325611114501953, -0.0659388080239296, 0.1889428049325943, -0.08287927508354187, 0.29933276772499084, -0.6288439035415649, 1.0175236463546753, -0.28139957785606384, -0.19352494180202484, 0.5005958676338196, 1.0538712739944458, 0.4770926237106323, 0.39469221234321594, 0.3785691559314728, 0.5403093099594116, 1.2143499851226807, -0.1458931863307953, 0.9405498504638672, -0.35122841596603394, 0.5894487500190735, 1.1472256183624268, -0.3681938648223877, 1.0282119512557983, 0.6458612680435181, -0.38993966579437256, 0.30114972591400146, 0.7936399579048157, 0.054641012102365494, 0.08935222029685974, 0.3095715045928955, -0.5991026759147644, -0.4772387444972992, 0.1313508301973343, -0.36314520239830017, 0.25790882110595703, 0.6891692876815796, -0.17460447549819946, 0.11136980354785919, -0.2508920729160309, 0.10297819972038269, -0.00690593384206295, -0.2152225524187088, 0.443552702665329, 0.29133641719818115, -0.623842179775238, 0.40404805541038513, 0.10393333435058594, 0.994284451007843, -0.680629312992096, 0.2657116651535034, -0.42690861225128174, 0.02000189758837223, -0.19401364028453827, -0.9525488615036011, 0.08427465707063675, -0.1697908341884613, -0.0673094168305397, 0.046864140778779984, 0.7114062309265137, -0.40457582473754883, -0.6608534455299377, 0.014389128424227238, 0.7582643032073975, 0.1445835828781128, -0.3287912905216217, -0.6395193338394165, -0.18726545572280884, 0.03887813910841942, -0.436083048582077, 0.3116571605205536, 0.65155428647995, 0.13700367510318756, 0.6880437135696411, 0.5212422609329224, -0.07063563913106918, -0.0375530906021595, -0.12545239925384521, 0.3690017759799957, -0.6705554127693176, -0.04129545018076897, -0.8496365547180176, 0.40474608540534973, -0.09079714119434357, -0.3779422342777252, 0.8045777082443237, 0.40053993463516235, 0.467421293258667, -0.09707237035036087, 0.7814753651618958, -0.012880060821771622, 0.574972927570343, -0.8802981376647949, 0.5582031607627869, -0.593889594078064, 0.43118566274642944, -0.13586218655109406, -0.8564813733100891, -0.2471293807029724, 0.486268013715744, 0.13048161566257477, 0.06987091898918152, 0.8039107322692871, 0.7374100685119629, 0.26775744557380676, -0.09245876967906952, 0.6097918748855591, 0.19475212693214417, 0.11791536211967468, 0.6434215903282166, 1.125280737876892, -0.4741297662258148, 0.7599624395370483, -0.20624379813671112, 0.05296868458390236, -0.09949389100074768, -1.0754541158676147, -0.6527144312858582, -0.3439709544181824, -0.22594209015369415, -0.5245051980018616, -0.12937898933887482, 0.8718706965446472, 0.6346416473388672, -0.5785574316978455, -0.07243211567401886, 0.08618538826704025, 0.11967268586158752, 0.02379666455090046, -0.21469756960868835, 0.3699553906917572, -0.2752368748188019, -0.6775246858596802, 0.4306435286998749, 0.08313161879777908, 0.49726930260658264, -0.1975715458393097, -0.05937827751040459, 0.1349722295999527, 0.3773196339607239, 0.6160106658935547, 0.1240331307053566, -0.6571685671806335, -0.361065149307251, 0.20673559606075287, -0.2715631127357483, -0.09304475039243698, 0.4493561089038849, -0.5897186398506165, -0.02381134033203125, 0.3957100212574005, 0.38530421257019043, 0.5250465869903564, -0.02626856416463852, 0.6431758403778076, -1.2020628452301025, -0.05720259249210358, 0.3577043414115906, 0.33914807438850403, 0.23572367429733276, -0.5280486345291138, 0.5807105898857117, 0.2730502784252167, -0.7265040278434753, -0.7146797776222229, 0.39730799198150635, -1.109660267829895, -0.4114193916320801, 1.2963272333145142, -0.07684949785470963, -0.20550201833248138, 0.053351111710071564, -0.033530864864587784, 0.006068766582757235, -0.5589191317558289, 0.6263651251792908, 0.811893880367279, -0.12164794653654099, -0.11565697193145752, -0.6503521203994751, 0.5630341172218323, 0.4942135810852051, -0.9016860723495483, -0.146067813038826, 0.4493618607521057, 0.12580452859401703, 0.2974064350128174, 0.5178375840187073, 0.17148293554782867, 0.046218886971473694, -0.17023847997188568, 0.1206376850605011, 0.5177525281906128, -0.12093427777290344, -0.06635243445634842, 0.21794047951698303, 0.2504335045814514, 0.17496442794799805 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20266v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20266v1
Latxa: An Open Language Model and Evaluation Suite for Basque
2024-03-29T16:16:48
2024-03-29T16:16:48
Julen Etxaniz, Oscar Sainz, Naiara Perez, Itziar Aldabe, German Rigau, Eneko Agirre, Aitor Ormazabal, Mikel Artetxe, Aitor Soroa
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
We introduce Latxa, a family of large language models for Basque ranging from 7 to 70 billion parameters. Latxa is based on Llama 2, which we continue pretraining on a new Basque corpus comprising 4.3M documents and 4.2B tokens. Addressing the scarcity of high-quality benchmarks for Basque, we further introduce 4 multiple choice evaluation datasets: EusProficiency, comprising 5,169 questions from official language proficiency exams; EusReading, comprising 352 reading comprehension questions; EusTrivia, comprising 1,715 trivia questions from 5 knowledge areas; and EusExams, comprising 16,774 questions from public examinations. In our extensive evaluation, Latxa outperforms all previous open models we compare to by a large margin. In addition, it is competitive with GPT-4 Turbo in language proficiency and understanding, despite lagging behind in reading comprehension and knowledge-intensive tasks. Both the Latxa family of models, as well as our new pretraining corpora and evaluation datasets, are publicly available under open licenses at https://github.com/hitz-zentroa/latxa. Our suite enables reproducible research on methods to build LLMs for low-resource languages.
[ -0.14970707893371582, -0.6920865178108215, 0.7202761769294739, 0.2944280207157135, -0.04296284541487694, 0.30397361516952515, -0.376028448343277, -0.4560517370700836, -0.02017408050596714, 0.8187863230705261, -0.18552061915397644, -0.5081851482391357, -0.48506125807762146, 0.001299321069382131, -0.6118797063827515, 0.815671980381012, -0.3848378360271454, -0.026570316404104233, 0.06907354295253754, -0.20916399359703064, -0.32010942697525024, -0.44419416785240173, -0.7927314639091492, -0.4146537482738495, 0.6458256244659424, 0.6262302398681641, 0.7254415154457092, 0.2789596617221832, 0.03506039083003998, 0.2699921429157257, 0.0032123494893312454, -0.1891138255596161, -0.7159321308135986, -0.030649948865175247, 0.019154442474246025, -0.844446063041687, -0.32630643248558044, -0.1870259940624237, 0.7465572357177734, 0.48457640409469604, -0.22347678244113922, 0.24105170369148254, -0.09240161627531052, 0.5302561521530151, -0.5726734399795532, -0.139834463596344, -0.5647047758102417, -0.05001898482441902, -0.4440195858478546, 0.17865347862243652, -0.3230782747268677, -0.742850124835968, 0.049471665173769, -0.32433292269706726, -0.10652841627597809, -0.16460146009922028, 0.6493750214576721, 0.46145784854888916, -0.3329278528690338, -0.13872088491916656, -0.5743366479873657, 0.8925178647041321, -0.464565247297287, 0.6588506102561951, 0.5072158575057983, 0.3609178364276886, -0.12557125091552734, -0.7971445322036743, -0.44258883595466614, -0.33462250232696533, 0.47327661514282227, 0.2237313985824585, -0.421430766582489, -0.15303482115268707, 0.003127551404759288, 0.1757764220237732, -0.6696925759315491, 0.4776376187801361, -0.7240225672721863, -0.011970018967986107, 0.4139830768108368, 0.07218685001134872, 0.26927050948143005, 0.35545700788497925, -0.3890273869037628, -0.175164595246315, -1.0006223917007446, 0.07851994782686234, 0.5787578225135803, 0.07788047939538956, -0.18697509169578552, 0.5238386988639832, -0.06839364767074585, 0.681206226348877, -0.36044836044311523, -0.038220684975385666, 0.3756923973560333, -0.09488669782876968, -0.17123769223690033, -0.0949222594499588, 0.9090903997421265, 0.01556318998336792, 0.2249433845281601, -0.35184022784233093, -0.07370666414499283, 0.17823052406311035, 0.18057149648666382, -0.39412033557891846, 0.20552951097488403, 0.7088600397109985, -0.20359361171722412, -0.1404900997877121, -0.33596882224082947, -0.9839821457862854, -0.14175134897232056, -0.17616191506385803, 0.4438565671443939, -0.28585556149482727, -0.3144894540309906, 0.6954732537269592, 0.03127281367778778, 0.2425428181886673, 0.5439003705978394, -0.5114998817443848, 0.5161609649658203, 0.4874346852302551, 0.7238102555274963, -0.4487355053424835, -0.5195155739784241, -0.4943837523460388, -0.33905792236328125, -0.213897705078125, 1.0620732307434082, -0.5804266929626465, -0.3958699405193329, -0.1410558968782425, -0.1309138834476471, -0.15785029530525208, -0.540826141834259, 0.836750864982605, -0.585571825504303, 0.28165701031684875, 0.029544707387685776, -0.19009758532047272, -0.07864933460950851, 0.019000360742211342, -0.9127379059791565, 1.6973459720611572, 0.42937663197517395, -0.45547735691070557, -0.15891972184181213, -0.7599389553070068, 0.3299318253993988, 0.025545503944158554, -0.08900012075901031, -0.10190615057945251, 0.058617983013391495, -0.004080857615917921, 0.25147145986557007, -0.7588779926300049, 0.15051975846290588, -0.13884767889976501, -0.33692869544029236, 0.1257036328315735, -0.14860881865024567, 0.864265501499176, 0.44432178139686584, -0.2259994000196457, 0.2002572864294052, -0.8128206729888916, 0.3968290090560913, 0.0371260866522789, -0.41893529891967773, -0.23348340392112732, -0.2648765444755554, 0.15728053450584412, 0.25944197177886963, 0.365594744682312, -0.6234238743782043, 0.010971834883093834, -0.4457240700721741, 0.38596346974372864, 0.7186903953552246, -0.31847500801086426, 0.22581179440021515, 0.013701612129807472, 0.9402491450309753, -0.3936093747615814, 0.17587019503116608, 0.13717487454414368, -0.5520190596580505, -0.6860895752906799, -0.16359682381153107, 0.5385439991950989, 0.652070939540863, -0.5180779695510864, 0.3069716989994049, -0.19121232628822327, -0.6728528738021851, -0.5758695602416992, -0.00745371775701642, 0.4996262490749359, 0.2296489030122757, 0.16867545247077942, -0.17714756727218628, -0.3266720771789551, -0.993070662021637, -0.036283738911151886, 0.010265476070344448, -0.03222154453396797, -0.11152887344360352, 0.7420198917388916, -0.24818551540374756, 0.7513828277587891, -0.39540645480155945, 0.17142130434513092, -0.44667017459869385, 0.014444287866353989, 0.31577298045158386, 0.01503563579171896, 0.7652207016944885, -0.3209734857082367, -0.5782453417778015, 0.2223092019557953, -0.25249871611595154, -0.2473842352628708, 0.49677765369415283, -0.19719715416431427, 0.05880702659487724, 0.284603476524353, -0.3591889441013336, 0.1762104332447052, 0.8344318866729736, -0.5273573994636536, 0.5496318340301514, -0.0826450064778328, 0.0017187532503157854, -1.055059790611267, 0.07152640074491501, -0.3847251236438751, -0.30698907375335693, -0.5849401950836182, 0.12445026636123657, 0.032269712537527084, -0.08348187804222107, -0.8117128014564514, 1.0124907493591309, -0.1356392204761505, -0.08287502080202103, -0.05361809581518173, 0.32660073041915894, -0.15749011933803558, 0.43414223194122314, 0.08713018149137497, 0.882781445980072, 0.5016252398490906, -0.3729091286659241, 0.3987904489040375, 0.22765935957431793, -0.577965497970581, 0.3021584749221802, -0.8676678538322449, 0.34703242778778076, -0.072171650826931, 0.10368840396404266, -0.6143032312393188, -0.0839138999581337, 0.05341900512576103, -0.22183771431446075, -0.24616484344005585, 0.12831445038318634, -0.5987387895584106, -0.36622658371925354, -0.4259772002696991, 0.45038434863090515, 0.4876072406768799, -0.6616135835647583, 0.3317375183105469, 0.5194402933120728, -0.2995789647102356, -0.768322765827179, -0.2793627679347992, 0.0003885386395268142, -0.320619136095047, -0.6275733113288879, 0.04609239101409912, -0.2060946524143219, -0.3936872184276581, -0.08378014713525772, 0.04462072253227234, -0.3576577305793762, 0.08370314538478851, 0.010944876819849014, 0.006329592317342758, -0.19904503226280212, 0.2061735987663269, -0.24977973103523254, -0.04427856579422951, -0.260811984539032, -0.11425310373306274, 0.8724149465560913, -0.38823097944259644, -0.23468448221683502, -0.0951208844780922, 0.24235382676124573, 0.4865403473377228, -0.346421480178833, 0.5388311743736267, 0.43700844049453735, -0.3239496946334839, -0.4456232488155365, -0.518777072429657, 0.29371577501296997, -0.3922143876552582, 0.493387907743454, -0.34550583362579346, -1.095308780670166, 0.7223540544509888, -0.06867143511772156, 0.004996560979634523, 0.5317941904067993, 0.868813157081604, 0.2596544623374939, 0.5606125593185425, 0.48783671855926514, -0.14233548939228058, 0.28582894802093506, -0.2206396907567978, -0.047687262296676636, -0.5075101852416992, -0.10085579007863998, -1.1082665920257568, -0.010433470830321312, -0.30480995774269104, -0.7452606558799744, 0.4763822853565216, 0.20770174264907837, -0.33621227741241455, 0.40376442670822144, -0.2217193990945816, 0.8078072667121887, 0.6406562924385071, -0.012941503897309303, 0.3606586754322052, 0.06520532071590424, -0.26031336188316345, 0.06237778067588806, -0.698279857635498, -0.7849109172821045, 1.6644374132156372, 0.6531027555465698, 0.8188214302062988, 0.21752433478832245, 0.6914492249488831, 0.13238412141799927, 0.22992044687271118, -0.723717212677002, 0.3968726694583893, -0.03553517907857895, -0.5022379755973816, -0.3080250918865204, -0.2806224524974823, -1.1032015085220337, 0.10330403596162796, -0.02406257949769497, -1.07147216796875, 0.014831866137683392, -0.12281017750501633, -0.5237680077552795, 0.2674074172973633, -0.7282650470733643, 0.8977089524269104, -0.6286892294883728, -0.5325817465782166, -0.24582377076148987, -0.27764448523521423, 0.4789358973503113, -0.48632073402404785, 0.13236533105373383, 0.001389018027111888, -0.236763596534729, 0.870975911617279, -0.3678473234176636, 0.6996846795082092, 0.1037280336022377, -0.4099714457988739, 0.43584975600242615, -0.16716670989990234, 0.34502819180488586, -0.029207872226834297, -0.397681325674057, 0.27836209535598755, 0.38661372661590576, -0.3290760815143585, -0.45676419138908386, 0.7284100651741028, -1.1426295042037964, -0.11933419853448868, -0.5475338101387024, -0.2972196042537689, -0.356632262468338, 0.2131626009941101, 0.07080078125, 0.2731163799762726, -0.48955237865448, 0.2708079218864441, 0.6562355756759644, -0.5141703486442566, 0.28240320086479187, 0.4997146725654602, -0.4884713292121887, -0.668017566204071, 0.6940826177597046, -0.11060716211795807, 0.29869768023490906, 0.2684669494628906, 0.18098048865795135, -0.6094760298728943, -0.5905166268348694, -0.32471731305122375, 0.4057377874851227, -0.5576909780502319, -0.03565641865134239, -0.40862077474594116, -0.03458074480295181, 0.02873939462006092, 0.16644518077373505, -0.656458854675293, -0.6881639957427979, 0.09129982441663742, 0.015534203499555588, 0.258122980594635, 1.1808416843414307, 0.22334249317646027, 0.6221026182174683, -0.781099796295166, 0.2967228889465332, 0.14855174720287323, 0.7738521099090576, -0.28087446093559265, -0.38811302185058594, -0.3119713366031647, -0.19244098663330078, -0.4704388678073883, -0.9116955399513245, 0.2137451171875, -0.09438459575176239, 0.6539303064346313, 0.1044350266456604, -0.05901944264769554, 0.3774750828742981, -0.5940672159194946, 0.8420603275299072, 0.2581920623779297, -0.833953320980072, 0.3606211245059967, -0.38508641719818115, 0.12810876965522766, 0.4797993004322052, 0.4100591540336609, -0.3041999936103821, -0.2547807991504669, -0.6586157083511353, -0.6712443232536316, 0.7844306826591492, 0.2937171161174774, -0.17582714557647705, 0.12473531067371368, 0.3772379159927368, 0.47071272134780884, 0.148031085729599, -0.9520844221115112, 0.020105458796024323, 0.041047949343919754, -0.31523025035858154, -0.28327450156211853, -0.3185150623321533, -0.14810825884342194, -0.030403250828385353, 0.6235426664352417, 0.004984376952052116, 0.27202531695365906, -0.15204468369483948, 0.08799361437559128, -0.057677652686834335, 0.6444094777107239, 0.718487024307251, 0.7991419434547424, -0.2926521301269531, -0.15465638041496277, 0.2747177481651306, -0.6182202696800232, 0.07768028974533081, 0.08224917948246002, 0.001739343861117959, -0.07659491896629333, 0.23683848977088928, 0.8406980037689209, 0.16932091116905212, -1.1631158590316772, 0.18849922716617584, -0.1720963567495346, -0.33170342445373535, -0.5559223890304565, 0.07375646382570267, 0.0900903046131134, 0.30216288566589355, 0.030667489394545555, -0.26738977432250977, -0.23375776410102844, -0.5233278870582581, -0.10792702436447144, 0.27702227234840393, -0.14280085265636444, -0.5130934715270996, 0.6574622392654419, 0.24463751912117004, -0.09981001168489456, 0.2107572704553604, 0.22445763647556305, -0.4921261966228485, 0.4663068354129791, 0.40245044231414795, 0.7775403261184692, -0.4217793941497803, 0.2760641276836395, 0.3862355947494507, 0.3600035309791565, -0.5830278992652893, 0.7931422591209412, 0.11863770335912704, -0.600007176399231, -0.34225764870643616, -0.9841864109039307, -0.6106331944465637, 0.5208802819252014, -0.3208602964878082, 0.5787242650985718, -0.1936233788728714, -0.15374991297721863, -0.3609471321105957, -0.013538249768316746, -0.6948134303092957, 0.036152131855487823, -0.07167772948741913, 1.1762772798538208, -0.7146164774894714, 1.0357773303985596, 0.5672784447669983, -0.4650253653526306, -0.6878736615180969, -0.22007176280021667, -0.2749660313129425, -0.8952004313468933, 0.7753076553344727, -0.1311470866203308, -0.32432320713996887, 0.06452013552188873, -0.35846763849258423, -1.0103243589401245, 0.981242299079895, 0.8124567270278931, -0.5355784893035889, -0.14536094665527344, 0.5262088179588318, 0.6145508885383606, -0.3041209578514099, 0.4741241931915283, 0.7544981241226196, 0.4474409520626068, -0.18161694705486298, -1.407668948173523, -0.40807417035102844, -0.19520165026187897, -0.24421349167823792, 0.2809029817581177, -0.7493571639060974, 0.9167293906211853, 0.03300434350967407, -0.08250760287046432, 0.2895165681838989, 0.046850044280290604, 0.23463231325149536, 0.017771098762750626, 0.3175598382949829, 0.9166520237922668, 0.7340137362480164, -0.24283723533153534, 1.014063835144043, -0.3084893822669983, 0.20167694985866547, 1.3025743961334229, -0.29450422525405884, 1.3165065050125122, 0.4136885404586792, -0.5537390112876892, 0.3743753135204315, 0.7002373933792114, 0.4998382031917572, 0.1390434056520462, 0.2321651726961136, -0.2992931306362152, -0.16254568099975586, 0.007543359883129597, -0.5217936635017395, 0.7188245058059692, 0.42621517181396484, -0.19677208364009857, -0.49577364325523376, -0.24293997883796692, 0.0700589120388031, 0.25684604048728943, -0.501243531703949, 0.37489351630210876, 0.05985162407159805, -0.758561909198761, 0.8183835744857788, 0.05576902627944946, 0.30081358551979065, -0.8831756114959717, 0.03823848068714142, -0.12817993760108948, 0.25233104825019836, -0.10582497715950012, -0.9507122039794922, 0.14440582692623138, 0.2839905917644501, 0.19610992074012756, -0.2560383975505829, 0.4235387444496155, -0.33957087993621826, -0.45021727681159973, 0.6009137630462646, 0.8000719547271729, 0.36397284269332886, -0.006819032598286867, -0.5944082140922546, 0.42196857929229736, -0.07870631664991379, -0.24113641679286957, 0.24146704375743866, 0.27811360359191895, -0.312257319688797, 0.5668769478797913, 0.395717054605484, 0.20000384747982025, 0.21610282361507416, 0.24014881253242493, 0.7663087248802185, -0.5559176206588745, -0.513676643371582, -0.401153028011322, 0.5213020443916321, 0.17871882021427155, -0.46288788318634033, 0.5055423378944397, 0.6967924237251282, 0.8425976037979126, -0.17657482624053955, 0.9652449488639832, 0.14716187119483948, 0.8005121350288391, -0.6494697332382202, 0.5276035666465759, -0.5410932302474976, 0.330745130777359, -0.021293791010975838, -1.0744720697402954, -0.2778531610965729, 0.36498695611953735, -0.4060051143169403, -0.016933314502239227, 0.7445830702781677, 0.662522554397583, -0.14415374398231506, -0.037816282361745834, 0.46893325448036194, 0.3669487237930298, 0.026021746918559074, 0.793114960193634, 1.0302752256393433, -0.3903716802597046, 0.5846796631813049, -0.05659910663962364, -0.41757073998451233, 0.054443709552288055, -0.7450647354125977, -1.0107998847961426, -0.6263317465782166, 0.035898640751838684, -0.29213622212409973, 0.17465321719646454, 1.0105174779891968, 0.26984065771102905, -0.6765630841255188, -0.7295295596122742, 0.054391320794820786, 0.054273102432489395, 0.22187167406082153, -0.12157567590475082, 0.41432657837867737, -0.15639738738536835, -0.8976240158081055, 0.5681077837944031, 0.20389775931835175, -0.1542738527059555, -0.31809666752815247, -0.2775822877883911, -0.11073266714811325, -0.0617113895714283, 0.5868200063705444, 0.5907757878303528, -0.7916813492774963, -0.264847993850708, 0.02366115152835846, 0.20188197493553162, 0.11635737121105194, 0.5164672136306763, -0.8267107605934143, 0.3729647994041443, 0.36834728717803955, 0.48097673058509827, 0.42667362093925476, -0.30709823966026306, 0.6494928002357483, -0.3489091992378235, 0.29851797223091125, 0.24517345428466797, 0.3171161413192749, -0.0011810521828010678, -0.0011605743784457445, 0.7380306124687195, -0.15001697838306427, -0.5193891525268555, -0.8883859515190125, 0.24608460068702698, -1.07297682762146, 0.03674871474504471, 1.049306869506836, 0.0578513965010643, -0.30458134412765503, -0.24432474374771118, -0.35534045100212097, -0.16275274753570557, -0.4039561450481415, 0.5863900184631348, 0.6548993587493896, -0.25722330808639526, -0.27297934889793396, -1.16998291015625, 0.42212995886802673, 0.20605699717998505, -0.9867417812347412, -0.053940463811159134, 0.4270336925983429, 0.5005197525024414, 0.08076129108667374, 0.8970986604690552, -0.35043880343437195, 0.5312889218330383, -0.14961153268814087, 0.2886604368686676, 0.2382894903421402, -0.34712645411491394, -0.41855713725090027, 0.22149665653705597, 0.3843629062175751, 0.05860652029514313 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20262v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20262v1
ELITR-Bench: A Meeting Assistant Benchmark for Long-Context Language Models
2024-03-29T16:13:31
2024-03-29T16:13:31
Thibaut Thonet, Jos Rozen, Laurent Besacier
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
Research on Large Language Models (LLMs) has recently witnessed an increasing interest in extending models' context size to better capture dependencies within long documents. While benchmarks have been proposed to assess long-range abilities, existing efforts primarily considered generic tasks that are not necessarily aligned with real-world applications. In contrast, our work proposes a new benchmark for long-context LLMs focused on a practical meeting assistant scenario. In this scenario, the long contexts consist of transcripts obtained by automatic speech recognition, presenting unique challenges for LLMs due to the inherent noisiness and oral nature of such data. Our benchmark, named ELITR-Bench, augments the existing ELITR corpus' transcripts with 271 manually crafted questions and their ground-truth answers. Our experiments with recent long-context LLMs on ELITR-Bench highlight a gap between open-source and proprietary models, especially when questions are asked sequentially within a conversation. We also provide a thorough analysis of our GPT-4-based evaluation method, encompassing insights from a crowdsourcing study. Our findings suggest that while GPT-4's evaluation scores are correlated with human judges', its ability to differentiate among more than three score levels may be limited.
[ -0.30988648533821106, -0.6816942095756531, 0.8765340447425842, 0.14709721505641937, -0.0018619034672155976, -0.2699677050113678, -0.5103323459625244, -0.840243935585022, -0.19559040665626526, 0.2741042971611023, -0.3273814916610718, -0.43459296226501465, -0.5175075531005859, 0.3568892180919647, -0.622611939907074, 0.7088618278503418, -0.15592996776103973, 0.006124999839812517, -0.467534601688385, -0.43496111035346985, -0.4028674066066742, -0.5457825660705566, -0.5457271933555603, -0.15057288110256195, 0.44039246439933777, 0.21456725895404816, 0.37063315510749817, 0.5411405563354492, 0.30544033646583557, 0.3394125998020172, -0.114905945956707, -0.013057904317975044, -0.13295988738536835, 0.19575563073158264, -0.06729999929666519, -0.17476622760295868, -0.6454809904098511, 0.2930656671524048, 0.69194495677948, 0.8607819080352783, -0.32199403643608093, 0.2501402497291565, 0.2081030160188675, 0.5425732135772705, -0.3920363783836365, 0.18779908120632172, -0.6611316800117493, -0.20023804903030396, -0.265339195728302, 0.2508450746536255, -0.19991062581539154, -0.1623728722333908, 0.24054086208343506, -0.4551422595977783, 0.1377294510602951, -0.005621855612844229, 0.6903306841850281, 0.34436264634132385, -0.3743972182273865, -0.135403111577034, -0.5716124773025513, 0.7003403306007385, -0.6039050817489624, 0.6351466774940491, 0.6402547955513, 0.6237824559211731, -0.041251447051763535, -0.8029289245605469, -0.5783824324607849, -0.5400875806808472, 0.07223638147115707, -0.051431965082883835, -0.09329067170619965, -0.0786830484867096, 0.5381222367286682, 0.17365990579128265, -0.5623615384101868, 0.09384123980998993, -0.16747908294200897, 0.1061197817325592, 0.2293771356344223, 0.07851553708314896, -0.08089188486337662, -0.08101200312376022, -0.24482889473438263, 0.13312126696109772, -0.5116743445396423, -0.10967337340116501, -0.13519054651260376, 0.2188853621482849, -0.11074025183916092, 0.36649417877197266, -0.34581097960472107, 0.7290716767311096, -0.0867404118180275, 0.1626160442829132, 0.2566557824611664, -0.353609174489975, -0.13315115869045258, -0.23820370435714722, 0.7521465420722961, 0.4514366686344147, 0.18491634726524353, -0.29752910137176514, -0.2718137800693512, -0.3687349259853363, -0.07990465313196182, -0.7210891842842102, 0.08807772397994995, 0.12905460596084595, -0.19607847929000854, 0.2371014803647995, -0.11958301812410355, -0.722015380859375, -0.2972882091999054, -0.46980053186416626, 0.44560933113098145, -0.2085566520690918, -0.11062917858362198, -0.21994921565055847, 0.05466402322053909, 0.36792948842048645, 0.540828287601471, -0.6638001203536987, 0.7774026393890381, 0.7009440064430237, 0.8974117040634155, -0.34796589612960815, -0.4810883104801178, -0.9619082808494568, 0.10963268578052521, -0.1362314075231552, 0.8087199926376343, -0.346506804227829, -0.4170414209365845, -0.09234828501939774, -0.13554763793945312, -0.0461483933031559, -0.6734339594841003, 0.5113855600357056, -0.2163732945919037, 0.36389464139938354, -0.37250202894210815, -0.6054648160934448, 0.2714414596557617, 0.48880812525749207, -0.6112647652626038, 1.1939103603363037, 0.27360567450523376, -0.26371335983276367, 0.554839015007019, -0.6735527515411377, -0.3397202491760254, 0.25235268473625183, -0.6652761697769165, -0.3203398585319519, -0.16831211745738983, 0.33241134881973267, 0.267959862947464, -0.4664025604724884, 0.2516127824783325, -0.28911298513412476, -0.32934248447418213, 0.37786006927490234, -0.401029109954834, 0.28613224625587463, -0.024269111454486847, -0.4508568346500397, 0.08959885686635971, -0.8839952349662781, 0.14528712630271912, -0.15868352353572845, -0.37038785219192505, -0.232615128159523, 0.04588155448436737, 0.17863817512989044, 0.09798583388328552, 0.3347676694393158, -0.5051577091217041, -0.12886245548725128, -0.1977187842130661, 0.4139648973941803, 0.8611215353012085, -0.20523974299430847, 0.16884687542915344, -0.39071884751319885, 0.29423731565475464, -0.44651326537132263, 0.03420582041144371, -0.014262939803302288, -0.379423052072525, -0.4853228032588959, -0.3940015733242035, 0.3235107362270355, 0.2538576126098633, -0.15715931355953217, 0.618690550327301, -0.5089390873908997, -0.34112873673439026, -0.333091676235199, 0.1646914929151535, 0.4207916557788849, 0.5665138959884644, 0.44199973344802856, -0.2008344680070877, -0.31973111629486084, -0.9186630845069885, -0.4740571677684784, -0.03554101660847664, -0.3434576094150543, 0.5755112767219543, 0.415621817111969, 0.01916569471359253, 1.116314172744751, -0.06319238245487213, -0.3470437228679657, -0.04578404873609543, 0.29755011200904846, 0.3281245827674866, 0.2203557789325714, 0.4365747272968292, -0.583842396736145, -0.6482251882553101, 0.013809158466756344, -0.5236672759056091, -0.34696856141090393, 0.15341536700725555, 0.27402931451797485, 0.26638391613960266, 0.5086638927459717, -0.6772091388702393, 0.4069129228591919, 0.5024971961975098, -0.1800604611635208, 0.47164130210876465, -0.1523277908563614, 0.2580512464046478, -0.8747028708457947, 0.28495028614997864, -0.06225793808698654, -0.5060462951660156, -0.3499700129032135, -0.1860792189836502, 0.183111771941185, -0.21223969757556915, -0.41935786604881287, 0.875599205493927, -0.539473831653595, -0.5133143067359924, -0.25969699025154114, 0.31985631585121155, -0.05687765032052994, 0.48909491300582886, 0.10896726697683334, 1.0837976932525635, 0.143715500831604, -0.44435006380081177, 0.18631325662136078, 0.2846371829509735, -0.5738807320594788, 0.8272718191146851, -0.8567619323730469, 0.5057283639907837, 0.4038873016834259, 0.38221657276153564, -0.7871196866035461, -0.3985627293586731, -0.2638426125049591, -0.33997640013694763, 0.10344558209180832, -0.17619608342647552, -0.665202260017395, -0.22079414129257202, -0.24034947156906128, 0.5392366051673889, 0.3818035125732422, -0.6247559189796448, 0.6111946105957031, 0.306225061416626, -0.3147064745426178, -0.27578964829444885, -0.4862569570541382, 0.32072895765304565, -0.14418599009513855, -0.3903382420539856, 0.4206693470478058, -0.30249595642089844, -0.3462812602519989, -0.2247234731912613, -0.32604530453681946, -0.1450893133878708, -0.1050219014286995, 0.3128235936164856, -0.024555126205086708, -0.1538265496492386, 0.005783757660537958, -0.3302374482154846, 0.07999914884567261, 0.13947443664073944, 0.1833379864692688, 0.45410001277923584, -0.40658038854599, -0.4987236559391022, -0.38742128014564514, 0.5058788061141968, 0.7492523193359375, -0.11673778295516968, 0.407561719417572, 0.2080160230398178, -0.48618704080581665, -0.0012487791245803237, -0.9539053440093994, 0.1328856199979782, -0.46403536200523376, 0.48428139090538025, -0.5115032196044922, -0.759508490562439, 0.5654036402702332, -0.04593944177031517, 0.041429948061704636, 0.245383620262146, 0.5911628007888794, 0.16963274776935577, 0.7547353506088257, 0.3282136917114258, -0.3167715072631836, 0.502838134765625, 0.23838956654071808, -0.26198810338974, -0.9132848381996155, 0.00428303238004446, -0.6689419150352478, -0.07823249697685242, -0.23494094610214233, -0.42979854345321655, 0.5439161658287048, -0.22197726368904114, -0.3053096830844879, 0.4869779348373413, -0.3014913499355316, 0.6441838145256042, 0.5674459338188171, -0.06857533752918243, 0.25426018238067627, -0.45897868275642395, 0.08418560028076172, 0.15933139622211456, -0.24229030311107635, -0.5381910800933838, 1.0847049951553345, 0.2871522903442383, 0.3596951365470886, 0.12810567021369934, 0.6783143281936646, 0.12604451179504395, 0.4389098286628723, -0.45320504903793335, 0.7202355861663818, 0.16473080217838287, -0.6284326314926147, -0.5971371531486511, -0.4630531370639801, -0.940096914768219, 0.19077445566654205, 0.13460464775562286, -0.9151684045791626, -0.07096944749355316, -0.1595926433801651, -0.26241931319236755, -0.07723814994096756, -0.6331292986869812, 0.9797553420066833, -0.43900299072265625, -0.44783908128738403, 0.015290391631424427, -0.516075849533081, -0.03351471945643425, -0.2963303029537201, 0.2922827899456024, -0.4297156035900116, -0.18883903324604034, 0.8874460458755493, -0.3492249548435211, 0.6524617075920105, -0.129479318857193, 0.030975477769970894, 0.07227747142314911, -0.14605771005153656, 0.5285294651985168, 0.007902250625193119, -0.3723110854625702, 0.12859106063842773, 0.13044893741607666, -0.2409646362066269, -0.3838875889778137, 0.8820995688438416, -0.7528035640716553, -0.5040742754936218, -0.3676871359348297, -0.45834171772003174, -0.6492037773132324, 0.3846406042575836, -0.03507736697793007, 0.4571710228919983, -0.5834876894950867, 0.272856205701828, 0.0899055078625679, -0.08706845343112946, 0.39560067653656006, 0.8294088244438171, -0.0374162420630455, -0.4428163766860962, 0.3270149827003479, 0.1766512393951416, 0.17858654260635376, 0.2815173268318176, 0.12072250247001648, -0.3598252534866333, -0.6026305556297302, -0.3179146349430084, 0.05933539196848869, -0.6196213960647583, -0.1699012815952301, -0.36737483739852905, -0.04108206927776337, -0.5081737041473389, 0.14853797852993011, -0.2958061993122101, -0.3646591901779175, -0.10769074410200119, -0.08432549238204956, 0.30009904503822327, 0.5177845358848572, 0.09124666452407837, 0.009163402952253819, -0.7164228558540344, 0.37748461961746216, 0.5868523120880127, 0.7228283286094666, -0.30412325263023376, -0.5080752372741699, -0.16071151196956635, -0.13569054007530212, -0.24762332439422607, -0.6811327338218689, 0.1409863531589508, 0.2979324460029602, 0.7609586715698242, 0.003120322711765766, -0.04529480263590813, 0.7874401807785034, -0.7507627606391907, 0.7448636293411255, 0.12641941010951996, -0.9068355560302734, 0.4818699359893799, -0.6299741268157959, 0.45036354660987854, 0.9536962509155273, 0.0793018490076065, -0.4158076047897339, -0.31818172335624695, -0.4072250425815582, -0.8820096254348755, 0.612820565700531, 0.2761687636375427, -0.024217747151851654, -0.3520643711090088, 0.24521583318710327, 0.22178737819194794, 0.18730176985263824, -0.9104815125465393, 0.1975879967212677, 0.04465154930949211, -0.040055349469184875, -0.06313944607973099, -0.10734983533620834, -0.23206372559070587, -0.3018505573272705, 0.2543213963508606, 0.018810026347637177, 0.1749807894229889, 0.19214458763599396, -0.06777024269104004, -0.20898093283176422, 0.48395833373069763, 0.48117509484291077, 0.9032320976257324, -0.5256913900375366, -0.017360102385282516, 0.6260665059089661, -0.06026303023099899, -0.21296310424804688, 0.6225239038467407, 0.40090951323509216, -0.03189072012901306, 0.38834479451179504, 0.4911139905452728, 0.4078539311885834, -0.8196754455566406, 0.737372636795044, -0.20619387924671173, -0.36807358264923096, -0.6206212639808655, -0.118438221514225, -0.01265642698854208, 0.19212432205677032, 0.5131067037582397, -0.29718631505966187, 0.13937677443027496, -0.5963683128356934, 0.34942156076431274, 0.4278985559940338, -0.3341376781463623, -0.1559351086616516, 0.6709806323051453, 0.482659250497818, -0.5614238977432251, 0.5267472863197327, 0.06626637279987335, -0.20836547017097473, 0.3897057771682739, 0.2400435209274292, 0.8176003098487854, -0.24120333790779114, -0.43541398644447327, 0.30153530836105347, -0.0482107438147068, -0.13781464099884033, 0.028728565201163292, -0.33933430910110474, -0.31935086846351624, -0.43412846326828003, -0.5624077916145325, -0.8376839756965637, 0.48172736167907715, -0.7348716855049133, 0.3020060956478119, -0.27438074350357056, -0.18902461230754852, 0.009950650855898857, -0.005775555036962032, -0.7993057370185852, -0.05646445229649544, 0.061441920697689056, 0.9101336598396301, -0.39754271507263184, 0.8493368029594421, 0.4252876043319702, -0.221429705619812, -0.6296893358230591, -0.009430650621652603, -0.030733304098248482, -0.6440061926841736, 0.495966374874115, 0.5658950805664062, -0.0830126628279686, -0.2584308087825775, -0.3273804485797882, -0.6022810935974121, 1.2407864332199097, 0.25966906547546387, -0.8134578466415405, -0.20444878935813904, 0.2374529391527176, 0.5701047778129578, -0.2089604288339615, 0.3368803560733795, 0.6615967750549316, 0.5451202392578125, -0.12636709213256836, -1.607276201248169, 0.04943631961941719, -0.33075717091560364, -0.3771270513534546, 0.18474817276000977, -0.41791680455207825, 0.6756796836853027, 0.25947266817092896, -0.08416784554719925, 0.6184011101722717, 0.5202884078025818, 0.320108026266098, 0.4183286428451538, 0.6461251378059387, 0.41342732310295105, 0.5865389704704285, 0.0457330159842968, 0.9680261015892029, -0.3352498412132263, 0.10761147737503052, 1.4888042211532593, -0.81935054063797, 1.1236411333084106, 0.5291487574577332, -0.34393152594566345, 0.3361997902393341, 0.30102595686912537, -0.0224418006837368, 0.36380326747894287, 0.34331443905830383, -0.3284168243408203, -0.028631962835788727, 0.12608689069747925, -0.4807065725326538, 0.35691189765930176, 0.2839619219303131, -0.16721875965595245, -0.35340386629104614, -0.1010664701461792, -0.25663408637046814, 0.2848574221134186, -0.12017160654067993, 0.8982653021812439, 0.18489320576190948, -0.8588712811470032, 0.5169848799705505, -0.24237845838069916, 0.368102103471756, -0.5408587455749512, -0.04321121796965599, -0.18156903982162476, 0.25756868720054626, 0.17721207439899445, -0.6899489164352417, 0.07510126382112503, 0.2909523546695709, -0.024463046342134476, -0.27674734592437744, 0.21096114814281464, -0.3014656901359558, -0.19009998440742493, 0.31877458095550537, 0.6629830002784729, 0.33336955308914185, -0.26234424114227295, -0.6715565919876099, 0.08327256888151169, -0.5365315675735474, -0.39666464924812317, 0.5895293354988098, 0.5542668104171753, -0.024812670424580574, 0.4391785264015198, 0.4066659212112427, -0.06189381331205368, -0.2708268165588379, 0.35802727937698364, 0.8282776474952698, -0.6941297054290771, -0.35672399401664734, -0.6576682329177856, 0.12940268218517303, -0.329438716173172, -0.5182260274887085, 0.5551368594169617, 0.7831979990005493, 0.5308033227920532, 0.23492883145809174, 0.6002562642097473, 0.10203777998685837, 1.0836974382400513, -0.43022266030311584, 0.6096154451370239, -0.3899051547050476, 0.4197330176830292, -0.266912043094635, -0.9257215857505798, -0.16402065753936768, 0.5869643092155457, -0.5973036885261536, 0.3482707440853119, 0.7351352572441101, 0.6108466982841492, -0.1468491554260254, -0.13084717094898224, 0.40083637833595276, 0.09627452492713928, 0.4436661899089813, 0.6454336047172546, 0.8748243451118469, -0.1888561248779297, 0.7520118951797485, 0.027652958407998085, -0.40708619356155396, -0.1674460768699646, -1.0550141334533691, -0.9711831212043762, -0.6565568447113037, -0.1453976035118103, -0.044086653739213943, 0.23344464600086212, 1.020419955253601, 0.7932938933372498, -0.4928617775440216, -0.40509140491485596, -0.09354908764362335, -0.32001376152038574, -0.18047387897968292, -0.18603217601776123, 0.47162798047065735, -0.13680799305438995, -0.7625298500061035, 0.6692391633987427, 0.10316411405801773, -0.05263548344373703, 0.08431416749954224, -0.12612521648406982, -0.08677282184362411, -0.029846079647541046, 0.4548705816268921, 0.4522444009780884, -0.7682868242263794, -0.5959607362747192, -0.07220611721277237, -0.14935104548931122, 0.08340800553560257, 0.4885649085044861, -0.8698194026947021, 0.1926598995923996, 0.05298028141260147, 0.5909995436668396, 0.6491953730583191, -0.017262715846300125, 0.7330162525177002, -0.9229310750961304, -0.09173893183469772, 0.3084486126899719, 0.576345682144165, 0.4398956596851349, 0.06640727818012238, 0.6660685539245605, -0.14459730684757233, -0.8417834043502808, -0.9832846522331238, 0.08762157708406448, -1.3069937229156494, -0.07607262581586838, 1.3055392503738403, -0.10078980773687363, -0.13496547937393188, -0.11889662593603134, -0.1894325166940689, 0.09946826100349426, -0.3998226821422577, 0.8096142411231995, 0.7601512670516968, -0.21128232777118683, -0.14552439749240875, -0.6777878403663635, 0.41171059012413025, 0.3114914298057556, -1.0091125965118408, 0.4433850646018982, 0.5783928036689758, 0.37811994552612305, -0.012031384743750095, 0.9489630460739136, -0.2006276547908783, 0.5565102696418762, -0.3408106565475464, -0.1392292082309723, -0.21765661239624023, -0.043410010635852814, -0.08023080974817276, 0.0480879582464695, 0.3362840414047241, -0.06404037028551102 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20252v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20252v1
Using LLMs to Model the Beliefs and Preferences of Targeted Populations
2024-03-29T15:58:46
2024-03-29T15:58:46
Keiichi Namikoshi, Alex Filipowicz, David A. Shamma, Rumen Iliev, Candice L. Hogan, Nikos Arechiga
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
We consider the problem of aligning a large language model (LLM) to model the preferences of a human population. Modeling the beliefs, preferences, and behaviors of a specific population can be useful for a variety of different applications, such as conducting simulated focus groups for new products, conducting virtual surveys, and testing behavioral interventions, especially for interventions that are expensive, impractical, or unethical. Existing work has had mixed success using LLMs to accurately model human behavior in different contexts. We benchmark and evaluate two well-known fine-tuning approaches and evaluate the resulting populations on their ability to match the preferences of real human respondents on a survey of preferences for battery electric vehicles (BEVs). We evaluate our models against their ability to match population-wide statistics as well as their ability to match individual responses, and we investigate the role of temperature in controlling the trade-offs between these two. Additionally, we propose and evaluate a novel loss term to improve model performance on responses that require a numeric response.
[ -0.48060673475265503, -0.491676926612854, 0.7066506743431091, 0.13394993543624878, -0.103451207280159, 0.010888328775763512, -0.5145894885063171, -0.20534922182559967, 0.12541253864765167, 0.40716221928596497, -0.30308786034584045, -0.39346426725387573, -0.10158514231443405, -0.04281088709831238, -0.10520671308040619, 0.35065537691116333, -0.011004951782524586, 0.24972271919250488, -0.3976355195045471, -0.018890023231506348, -0.3527884781360626, -0.5704866051673889, -0.6257978677749634, -0.7126345038414001, 0.5320783853530884, 0.6047990918159485, 0.7386282086372375, 0.5451056361198425, 0.34481120109558105, 0.2057512104511261, 0.02570648118853569, 0.2570211887359619, -0.731605052947998, 0.1276576817035675, -0.44871634244918823, -0.3210377097129822, -0.22752675414085388, 0.16951699554920197, 0.40947332978248596, 0.6667463779449463, -0.39868998527526855, 0.15520258247852325, -0.026557113975286484, 0.5125244855880737, -0.6376113295555115, -0.2722031772136688, -0.884555995464325, -0.21371541917324066, 0.12025032937526703, -0.1952032744884491, -0.22267542779445648, -0.5332658886909485, 0.11769433319568634, -0.2856660485267639, 0.2341163456439972, 0.38078823685646057, 0.847628653049469, 0.38851964473724365, -0.616673469543457, -0.14268137514591217, -0.8819659948348999, 1.029537320137024, -0.8648041486740112, 0.377917617559433, 0.5195846557617188, -0.08513926714658737, -0.2699194550514221, 0.11153114587068558, -0.6270578503608704, -0.29209432005882263, 0.05681351199746132, 0.11253837496042252, -0.0010631994809955359, 0.11249266564846039, 0.22390462458133698, 0.19509091973304749, -0.5499704480171204, 0.541905403137207, -0.15102562308311462, -0.09994824975728989, 0.9115539789199829, 0.613105833530426, 0.012063954025506973, -0.0488143190741539, -0.4470711052417755, -0.0163931492716074, -0.6358009576797485, 0.33435672521591187, 0.5057891607284546, 0.5139733552932739, -0.11293809860944748, 0.6800559163093567, -0.3229731023311615, 0.5485028624534607, 0.15276354551315308, -0.1273924857378006, -0.00014088912575971335, -0.28616443276405334, -0.30247238278388977, -0.0537375770509243, 0.5686014890670776, 1.2214081287384033, 0.4697960913181305, 0.07521536201238632, -0.2322589010000229, 0.2358713001012802, 0.2372569888830185, -0.7631115913391113, 0.004366174805909395, 0.05008823797106743, -0.4990384578704834, -0.2711048424243927, -0.12476509809494019, -0.6749672889709473, -0.43360260128974915, -0.7149916887283325, 0.22094175219535828, 0.020621739327907562, -0.3008190989494324, 0.5727465748786926, -0.09806323796510696, 0.4584234058856964, 0.2883254885673523, -1.3448344469070435, 0.5515593886375427, 0.5593071579933167, 0.787492036819458, -0.42199286818504333, 0.047588057816028595, 0.09112995862960815, 0.33739086985588074, -0.21162045001983643, 0.8075070977210999, -0.7959098815917969, -0.7784356474876404, -0.0026234183460474014, -0.1431911140680313, 0.002156561706215143, -0.5718601942062378, 0.2436790019273758, -0.4706120789051056, -0.06677941232919693, -0.8193245530128479, -0.6961516737937927, 0.0057215094566345215, 0.4064445495605469, -0.3560360074043274, 0.7995430827140808, -0.12537528574466705, -0.4511468708515167, 0.4059814512729645, -0.5228773951530457, -0.32825854420661926, -0.2895154058933258, -0.05468805506825447, -0.3898116648197174, 0.21348589658737183, -0.12443364411592484, 0.4609321355819702, -0.4888879656791687, 0.06970183551311493, -0.6727639436721802, -0.3452392816543579, 0.418313205242157, -0.23622457683086395, 0.330292671918869, 0.33937403559684753, 0.0783296674489975, 0.2794897258281708, -0.28015244007110596, -0.07372501492500305, 0.17304080724716187, -0.5230044722557068, -0.584692120552063, 0.3900420069694519, 0.06505186855792999, -0.14388443529605865, 0.5095517039299011, -0.5283596515655518, 0.38132256269454956, -0.29098057746887207, 0.3274897038936615, 0.9156591892242432, -0.07276787608861923, 0.6325844526290894, -0.6448909640312195, 0.6047179698944092, -0.17916956543922424, 0.10493266582489014, 0.3393722176551819, -0.22644372284412384, -0.5596272945404053, 0.09626346826553345, 0.03243560716509819, 0.5683514475822449, -0.1384098082780838, 0.2932877540588379, 0.12260952591896057, -0.5222190022468567, -0.03441227227449417, 0.006905048619955778, 0.11233232915401459, 0.5584192276000977, 0.14895564317703247, -0.16574254631996155, -0.5095972418785095, -1.161232590675354, -0.3491481840610504, -0.3259115517139435, -0.11500076949596405, 0.639835000038147, 0.2278173267841339, -0.1681162565946579, 1.0394794940948486, -0.7058759331703186, 0.20403063297271729, -0.14402274787425995, -0.22370602190494537, 0.1560506969690323, 0.41089776158332825, 0.5824119448661804, -0.7529169917106628, -0.4750334918498993, 0.11646468937397003, -0.4956614077091217, -0.09274375438690186, 0.17557433247566223, 0.04035034030675888, 0.006494860164821148, 0.2576389014720917, -0.4871812164783478, 0.29344692826271057, 0.44286128878593445, -0.03485789895057678, 0.5143866539001465, -0.29068201780319214, 0.4648095667362213, -1.1285326480865479, -0.17716777324676514, 0.6405689716339111, -0.0970751941204071, -0.6304512023925781, -0.32964450120925903, -0.060277219861745834, 0.22581590712070465, -0.6084562540054321, 0.6617927551269531, -0.11717265099287033, -0.006512701511383057, -0.35400182008743286, -0.12694881856441498, -0.10202502459287643, 0.0403100959956646, 0.05418124794960022, 0.9381611347198486, 0.40265092253685, -0.857088565826416, 0.45567917823791504, 0.2806805670261383, -0.1509888917207718, 0.42763662338256836, -0.7368898987770081, 0.28232187032699585, -0.312997430562973, -0.027313293889164925, -0.8281416296958923, -0.42069104313850403, 0.05767085775732994, -0.3427068591117859, 0.024847321212291718, -0.015163155272603035, -0.4282819330692291, -0.17738372087478638, -0.28343886137008667, 0.3256175220012665, 0.7368239760398865, -0.15042069554328918, 0.5373896360397339, 0.5227944850921631, -0.08549059182405472, -0.1910216063261032, -0.27426689863204956, -0.11602412909269333, -0.7488479018211365, -0.38106265664100647, 0.38508355617523193, -0.33028873801231384, -0.6176093220710754, -0.2601829767227173, -0.13197822868824005, 0.08480241149663925, 0.16806231439113617, 0.09651406109333038, 0.310730904340744, -0.046028021723032, 0.3002703785896301, -0.2447262704372406, -0.10894303768873215, 0.004076424520462751, -0.20568811893463135, 0.6518833637237549, -0.08302439749240875, -0.3662933111190796, -0.11005347222089767, 0.45289909839630127, 0.5139375925064087, -0.09971689432859421, 0.6057472825050354, 0.023621708154678345, -0.5331315994262695, -0.016447996720671654, -0.6758580207824707, -0.24300585687160492, -0.5498363971710205, 0.41415345668792725, -0.20388495922088623, -0.97392737865448, 0.4353466331958771, -0.2545231282711029, 0.005418994929641485, 0.044607847929000854, 0.9492706060409546, -0.4203047454357147, 1.296758770942688, 0.7551435828208923, -0.21247512102127075, 0.45873385667800903, 0.2764091193675995, 0.2668924033641815, -0.7622416615486145, -0.29128125309944153, -0.7548439502716064, -0.44399917125701904, -0.67897629737854, -0.09429756551980972, 0.3209853768348694, -0.09592539817094803, -0.4874403178691864, 0.2574145495891571, -0.37554362416267395, 0.5411900281906128, 0.5339133739471436, 0.30882152915000916, 0.04025380313396454, -0.010285085998475552, -0.02765814960002899, -0.2322278469800949, -0.5814246535301208, -1.0100626945495605, 1.0138154029846191, 0.23411519825458527, 1.254717469215393, 0.18610024452209473, 0.39922523498535156, 0.2836853861808777, 0.3287067711353302, -0.8091675639152527, 0.5280042886734009, -0.30492091178894043, -0.7422451972961426, -0.4821591377258301, -0.36761826276779175, -1.0484365224838257, 0.19114209711551666, -0.11460024118423462, -1.018936038017273, -0.04907417669892311, 0.5230536460876465, -0.4275669455528259, 0.4519214928150177, -0.6949148178100586, 0.8015889525413513, -0.5905613899230957, -0.4283992350101471, -0.3592624366283417, -0.4745906591415405, 0.25779956579208374, -0.12164010852575302, 0.11582274734973907, -0.6868462562561035, -0.052421361207962036, 0.5551445484161377, -0.1614599972963333, 0.6900008916854858, -0.05316384881734848, -0.0692761167883873, -0.17929290235042572, -0.22786736488342285, 0.34254416823387146, 0.039705466479063034, -0.5905453562736511, -0.014462720602750778, 0.17621345818042755, -0.4110738933086395, -0.5056788325309753, 0.7298792004585266, -0.8074626326560974, -0.9640113115310669, -0.19554981589317322, -0.6201639771461487, -0.40605592727661133, 0.10614674538373947, 0.03303610906004906, 0.14690358936786652, -0.3688545823097229, -0.0740596279501915, 0.9249767065048218, -0.3677946627140045, 0.08294318616390228, 0.7628288865089417, -0.3120270371437073, -0.1234121173620224, 0.6889734864234924, -0.1285243183374405, 0.5173772573471069, 0.2370935082435608, 0.5181472897529602, -0.42544999718666077, -0.5990023016929626, -0.0039583598263561726, 0.25635433197021484, -0.5757272243499756, -0.06607124209403992, -0.21656660735607147, 0.2123197764158249, -0.41124871373176575, -0.2650618553161621, -0.26174288988113403, 0.23832851648330688, -0.5280013084411621, -0.051089465618133545, 0.3704737722873688, 0.7112535834312439, -0.0027895807288587093, 0.4706912934780121, -0.42423027753829956, 0.3669278919696808, 0.38753822445869446, 0.36313170194625854, -0.22668671607971191, -0.3607170879840851, -0.1344054639339447, 0.31882554292678833, -0.12417817860841751, -0.8552255630493164, 0.3382430076599121, -0.06521623581647873, 0.6745292544364929, 0.2650641202926636, 0.3141307234764099, 0.6688880324363708, -0.43913283944129944, 0.6097612380981445, 0.2005377858877182, -0.7551648020744324, 0.5160154700279236, -0.37704554200172424, 0.15000967681407928, 0.6934893727302551, 0.5435500144958496, -0.7000821232795715, 0.034458693116903305, -0.2832045555114746, -0.5782135128974915, 0.32647785544395447, -0.0736091285943985, 0.40567731857299805, -0.06595513969659805, 0.49296268820762634, 0.017436282709240913, 0.2864433228969574, -0.34815388917922974, -0.20494280755519867, 0.006878898479044437, -0.35510069131851196, -0.24787190556526184, -0.06189515069127083, -0.110061876475811, -0.27822089195251465, 0.6778616309165955, -0.18433751165866852, -0.043870337307453156, -0.08235576003789902, 0.2941746115684509, -0.3237095773220062, 0.2449023276567459, 0.8374086618423462, 0.5747281908988953, -0.47869306802749634, 0.17002055048942566, 0.43069812655448914, 0.002306155627593398, 0.3650470972061157, -0.197245791554451, -0.3340964615345001, -0.3220115900039673, -0.39470338821411133, 0.5345718860626221, 0.2080620527267456, -0.6401655673980713, 0.19710583984851837, -0.2864684760570526, -0.29435786604881287, -0.20084603130817413, 0.2286437749862671, 0.4429437220096588, 0.18046146631240845, 0.09874402731657028, 0.1742863804101944, -0.06369302421808243, -0.5137059092521667, -0.048304103314876556, 1.0043646097183228, -0.41758498549461365, -0.22852951288223267, 0.7486703991889954, 0.32263755798339844, -0.5752062201499939, 0.4386867880821228, 0.10512091964483261, -0.5694146752357483, 0.7198750376701355, 0.4444827437400818, 0.5506114363670349, -0.2619859576225281, -0.18144522607326508, 0.29596394300460815, 0.39818596839904785, -0.27811285853385925, 0.2381526082754135, 0.1993342638015747, -1.1730595827102661, -0.175602525472641, -0.5662235021591187, -0.6924527883529663, 0.0428723581135273, -0.761051595211029, 0.35515958070755005, -0.28719180822372437, -0.4973398447036743, -0.0690748319029808, -0.12244849652051926, -0.8360259532928467, 0.12771594524383545, 0.2644166946411133, 0.8560651540756226, -1.036705732345581, 0.7187969088554382, 0.815517246723175, -0.27608686685562134, -0.8817147016525269, 0.008817202411592007, 0.029917066916823387, -0.9119433164596558, 0.4047607183456421, -0.09219870716333389, -0.29034310579299927, 0.029322531074285507, -0.8944838643074036, -1.0574979782104492, 0.8698725700378418, 0.450154572725296, -0.7288720011711121, 0.04113025218248367, 0.11664167046546936, 0.2565929889678955, -0.46065592765808105, -0.029196491464972496, 0.8248141407966614, 0.5666669011116028, -0.0025982828810811043, -1.0760221481323242, -0.04311489313840866, 0.1168258786201477, 0.04523104429244995, 0.20063094794750214, -0.9652220010757446, 0.5535185933113098, -0.19938351213932037, -0.03865637257695198, 0.10622969269752502, 0.5428296327590942, 0.4585924446582794, 0.5156946182250977, 0.739349365234375, 0.36264464259147644, 0.8076550364494324, 0.0944351926445961, 0.8298789262771606, -0.3376310467720032, 0.5459007024765015, 0.8007510900497437, -0.9505909085273743, 0.687074601650238, 0.6345160603523254, -0.46078309416770935, -0.036793939769268036, 1.000288486480713, 0.021953804418444633, 0.6361500024795532, 0.5486239194869995, -0.33836933970451355, -0.6622432470321655, -0.4047013223171234, -0.2735018730163574, 0.20899537205696106, 0.5502119660377502, -0.0010454405564814806, 0.0007095196051523089, -0.2065667062997818, -0.15613622963428497, 0.24847997725009918, -0.29935789108276367, 0.7443225383758545, 0.13502423465251923, -0.5502479076385498, 0.29661938548088074, 0.08035549521446228, 0.7510668635368347, -0.4329458177089691, 0.2092718929052353, -0.10353561490774155, 0.029042968526482582, -0.3001120686531067, -0.6508792638778687, 0.1857839971780777, -0.0550592802464962, -0.5036408305168152, -0.32614126801490784, 0.732134997844696, -0.4750072956085205, -0.45004427433013916, -0.055517297238111496, 0.3639199435710907, 0.2107997089624405, 0.21843670308589935, -0.5882768630981445, 0.16657952964305878, 0.046613436192274094, -0.1428711861371994, 0.29964643716812134, -0.15786339342594147, 0.07483579218387604, 0.7460214495658875, 0.5684086680412292, 0.10883962363004684, -0.21883144974708557, 0.1702042818069458, 0.7321638464927673, -0.7427841424942017, -0.21194520592689514, -0.989448606967926, 0.235512375831604, -0.06287406384944916, -0.2688550353050232, 0.8244906067848206, 0.7460696697235107, 0.6926556825637817, 0.0655190572142601, 1.122645378112793, 0.3462997376918793, 0.5874272584915161, -0.6355493068695068, 0.2889123260974884, -0.4844402074813843, 0.3351398706436157, -0.013387253507971764, -0.9789934754371643, -0.09977351129055023, 0.6175071001052856, -0.42434757947921753, 0.15958312153816223, 0.326994925737381, 0.9782108068466187, 0.05046440288424492, -0.14982332289218903, 0.4976857304573059, -0.10626635700464249, 0.3956601917743683, 0.4516720771789551, 1.0695229768753052, 0.13123062252998352, 0.009710760787129402, 0.05512506142258644, -0.1486731320619583, -0.2285359501838684, -0.9229881763458252, -0.8509312272071838, -0.1483834981918335, -0.2991965115070343, -0.21924927830696106, -0.0581742487847805, 1.4344006776809692, 0.756450355052948, -0.6959004998207092, -0.5142949819564819, 0.22160892188549042, 0.12419755756855011, 0.1670226752758026, -0.16227613389492035, -0.1787695288658142, -0.05940225347876549, -0.6833195686340332, 0.33727821707725525, 0.30887967348098755, 0.16419954597949982, -0.48790743947029114, -0.2707364559173584, 0.040666043758392334, 0.4855467677116394, 0.3863278031349182, 0.30008938908576965, -0.9876468777656555, -0.5688655972480774, 0.33062392473220825, -0.15636008977890015, 0.16488389670848846, 0.9901043176651001, -0.5017976760864258, 0.19393710792064667, 0.29057368636131287, 0.46527785062789917, 0.5036585927009583, 0.36481162905693054, 0.8615657687187195, -0.40325918793678284, -0.2680165767669678, 0.1470269411802292, 0.5072978734970093, 0.44865545630455017, -0.19102373719215393, 0.14454405009746552, -0.04708830639719963, -0.8272387385368347, -0.6375760436058044, 0.5068665742874146, -1.0690206289291382, -0.1498149037361145, 1.3625929355621338, 0.23503313958644867, 0.00996369868516922, -0.1708996444940567, -0.2343999743461609, 0.11578754335641861, -0.6775358319282532, 0.8073680996894836, 0.6675448417663574, -0.2866150140762329, -0.14965194463729858, -0.5057952404022217, 0.2309962511062622, 0.4333024322986603, -0.7673969864845276, 0.07784619182348251, 0.39443516731262207, 0.4978388845920563, -0.2324587106704712, 0.5259410738945007, 0.5448498725891113, -0.07793979346752167, -0.5460960865020752, 0.05419982969760895, 0.33284270763397217, 0.31883469223976135, -0.45219671726226807, -0.00289081665687263, 0.3503347933292389, 0.01996629685163498 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20222v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20222v1
Shallow Cross-Encoders for Low-Latency Retrieval
2024-03-29T15:07:21
2024-03-29T15:07:21
Aleksandr V. Petrov, Sean MacAvaney, Craig Macdonald
cs.IR
cs.IR, cs.CL
Transformer-based Cross-Encoders achieve state-of-the-art effectiveness in text retrieval. However, Cross-Encoders based on large transformer models (such as BERT or T5) are computationally expensive and allow for scoring only a small number of documents within a reasonably small latency window. However, keeping search latencies low is important for user satisfaction and energy usage. In this paper, we show that weaker shallow transformer models (i.e., transformers with a limited number of layers) actually perform better than full-scale models when constrained to these practical low-latency settings since they can estimate the relevance of more documents in the same time budget. We further show that shallow transformers may benefit from the generalized Binary Cross-Entropy (gBCE) training scheme, which has recently demonstrated success for recommendation tasks. Our experiments with TREC Deep Learning passage ranking query sets demonstrate significant improvements in shallow and full-scale models in low-latency scenarios. For example, when the latency limit is 25ms per query, MonoBERT-Large (a cross-encoder based on a full-scale BERT model) is only able to achieve NDCG@10 of 0.431 on TREC DL 2019, while TinyBERT-gBCE (a cross-encoder based on TinyBERT trained with gBCE) reaches NDCG@10 of 0.652, a +51% gain over MonoBERT-Large. We also show that shallow Cross-Encoders are effective even when used without a GPU (e.g., with CPU inference, NDCG@10 decreases only by 3% compared to GPU inference with 50ms latency), which makes Cross-Encoders practical to run even without specialized hardware acceleration.
[ -0.5507739782333374, -0.4835907518863678, 0.6525250673294067, -0.14702589809894562, -0.2579578459262848, 0.012592188082635403, -0.300398588180542, -0.6695519685745239, 0.12463651597499847, 0.14779731631278992, -0.34451353549957275, -0.3873497545719147, -0.6608661413192749, -0.059083618223667145, -0.44817861914634705, 0.8260560631752014, 0.33320939540863037, -0.04122774675488472, -0.16397841274738312, -0.007015761453658342, -0.20225660502910614, -0.26482269167900085, -0.6688745021820068, -0.43552884459495544, 0.8517484664916992, 0.32545003294944763, 0.964147686958313, 0.24335868656635284, 0.7504430413246155, 0.2040073424577713, -0.26313766837120056, -0.16786012053489685, -0.5978072881698608, 0.05869027227163315, -0.03548307344317436, -0.563407301902771, -0.17734254896640778, -0.17606784403324127, 0.3603935241699219, 0.7385022640228271, 0.006569102872163057, -0.035888154059648514, 0.05830207094550133, 0.6992147564888, -0.7932310104370117, -0.30781957507133484, -0.6081345677375793, 0.41245800256729126, -0.30354538559913635, 0.054580409079790115, -0.484529584646225, -0.16843226552009583, 0.4177461862564087, -0.22760166227817535, 0.7099094390869141, 0.12172757834196091, 0.8202158808708191, 0.44933828711509705, -0.12983839213848114, -0.16413381695747375, -0.9208972454071045, 0.7936184406280518, -0.751537024974823, 0.9595048427581787, 0.2680542767047882, 0.3062860071659088, 0.3783825933933258, -0.8597931861877441, -0.3528091609477997, -0.2636915147304535, -0.3828086853027344, 0.2003186196088791, -0.372577965259552, 0.06685647368431091, 0.47770625352859497, 0.6117157936096191, -0.6611047983169556, 0.2137119024991989, -0.3892862796783447, -0.07156388461589813, 0.31775951385498047, 0.14677196741104126, -0.13645388185977936, -0.18838097155094147, -0.16327394545078278, -0.11089937388896942, -0.421924352645874, 0.2145117223262787, 0.34802645444869995, 0.23068544268608093, -0.19899815320968628, 0.5050464272499084, -0.09113352000713348, 0.3846452832221985, 0.508033812046051, 0.24078154563903809, 0.02149190753698349, -0.5307778120040894, -0.010079281404614449, 0.15280230343341827, 0.7262706756591797, -0.0695708692073822, -0.01062005665153265, -0.6804043054580688, -0.3969537615776062, 0.06986857205629349, 0.5778154730796814, -1.012272596359253, -0.26112523674964905, -0.056508488953113556, -0.7366733551025391, -0.02322809211909771, 0.08365196734666824, -0.7946624159812927, -0.1488465964794159, 0.01418310683220625, 0.38665738701820374, -0.3209884464740753, 0.5984381437301636, 0.10877678543329239, -0.18071073293685913, 0.384613960981369, 0.27483007311820984, -1.015122652053833, 0.5591621994972229, 0.2890057861804962, 0.9119310975074768, -0.20172245800495148, 0.12798640131950378, -0.5001128911972046, -0.0848405510187149, -0.1327827274799347, 0.6228052973747253, -0.8559534549713135, -0.5537497997283936, -0.2737784683704376, 0.05923687294125557, 0.2621259391307831, -0.28418028354644775, 0.7945145964622498, -0.6938360929489136, 0.3928788900375366, -0.3184899687767029, -0.144173726439476, 0.1830720603466034, 0.010595227591693401, -0.9287219643592834, 1.1651878356933594, 0.03463931381702423, -0.8128851056098938, 0.3854781687259674, -0.4282020032405853, -0.639589250087738, -0.11236117780208588, -0.13193818926811218, -0.5357664227485657, 0.24725255370140076, 0.4401565492153168, 0.42669907212257385, -0.6914483904838562, -0.21758532524108887, -0.1630648374557495, -1.005678653717041, -0.3723311126232147, -0.7023336887359619, 0.24784496426582336, 0.08399412035942078, -0.5446937084197998, -0.32934945821762085, -0.3444388210773468, -0.040569424629211426, -0.0594664141535759, -0.425337016582489, -0.2923603951931, -0.07482144236564636, 0.0676591694355011, 0.10101798176765442, 0.20127931237220764, -0.6810619831085205, 0.22406698763370514, -0.49996715784072876, 0.43223312497138977, 0.4072275161743164, -0.233608216047287, 0.8840917348861694, -0.0956287831068039, 0.38430702686309814, 0.0504692904651165, 0.2271697223186493, 0.22427646815776825, -0.5315993428230286, -0.6173920035362244, 0.03387885540723801, 0.638797402381897, 0.4167647063732147, -0.9166488647460938, 0.40582022070884705, -0.5063076615333557, -0.7378142476081848, -0.855741560459137, 0.10470706969499588, 0.21517904102802277, 0.38383588194847107, 0.8158115744590759, -0.49597784876823425, -0.3820633292198181, -0.8896836638450623, -0.0486157089471817, 0.15310707688331604, -0.33183616399765015, 0.8679519891738892, 0.38141220808029175, -0.562425971031189, 0.6684773564338684, -0.4059499502182007, -0.18186378479003906, -0.16522523760795593, 0.15157997608184814, 0.4129358232021332, 0.3398789167404175, 0.5132863521575928, -0.79888916015625, -0.5099129676818848, -0.02678774483501911, -0.4934191107749939, 0.11136084794998169, 0.04114995151758194, 0.09880636632442474, 0.12793001532554626, 0.26727378368377686, -0.6898006796836853, 0.5557891130447388, 0.3910996615886688, -0.01577794924378395, 0.12686540186405182, -0.3383254110813141, 0.14033904671669006, -0.5049004554748535, 0.032185714691877365, 0.10188692063093185, -0.1351727992296219, -0.30899885296821594, -0.4916573762893677, -0.030985631048679352, -0.20463450253009796, -0.32837966084480286, 0.4410107135772705, -0.3110518455505371, -0.10849520564079285, 0.0162716805934906, 0.19351424276828766, 0.06117693707346916, 0.4790492355823517, 0.12407392263412476, 0.8598511815071106, 0.39349332451820374, -0.6267025470733643, 0.224763885140419, 0.13497012853622437, -0.1783117800951004, 0.2818492352962494, -0.9828880429267883, 0.38979393243789673, -0.22871580719947815, 0.22860349714756012, -0.6937863826751709, 0.2707224488258362, -0.008744902908802032, -0.36512255668640137, 0.35116568207740784, -0.29009997844696045, -0.28801169991493225, -0.4355350136756897, -0.3718247413635254, 0.5433091521263123, 0.6830844879150391, -0.7114467620849609, 0.6864024996757507, 0.03416001424193382, 0.051685694605112076, -0.8683002591133118, -1.024063229560852, -0.04471458122134209, 0.17903077602386475, -0.5693026185035706, 0.7780753970146179, -0.018475644290447235, 0.2278331220149994, 0.2502894103527069, -0.3387461304664612, 0.1895042210817337, -0.23622334003448486, 0.26846444606781006, 0.09426369518041611, -0.340526819229126, 0.15623518824577332, -0.020973673090338707, -0.17219887673854828, -0.25229379534721375, -0.556663453578949, 0.4520023465156555, -0.30794259905815125, -0.34408408403396606, -0.005288582295179367, 0.31037595868110657, 0.16518394649028778, 0.02216194011271, 0.6932452917098999, 1.1073737144470215, -0.3420637547969818, -0.12767481803894043, -0.6521948575973511, -0.5138770341873169, -0.4691218137741089, 0.09178726375102997, -0.42012956738471985, -1.0210740566253662, 0.30260971188545227, 0.19019462168216705, -0.3667553961277008, 0.5423498153686523, 0.38943129777908325, -0.20319005846977234, 0.856864869594574, 0.7564799785614014, -0.33452704548835754, 0.4773014783859253, -0.43684467673301697, 0.4451695382595062, -0.7091875672340393, -0.33920273184776306, -0.7504464983940125, -0.8889004588127136, -0.9117946028709412, -0.4973853528499603, 0.35361382365226746, -0.04337526485323906, -0.09837429225444794, 0.3767777979373932, -0.6983908414840698, 0.38817471265792847, 0.8379703760147095, 0.36307835578918457, 0.17296986281871796, 0.0998254343867302, -0.2192395031452179, -0.24438132345676422, -1.0006715059280396, -0.20517536997795105, 0.757664144039154, 0.20893506705760956, 1.4137232303619385, -0.05996726453304291, 0.5899579524993896, 0.5346025824546814, -0.09557073563337326, -0.7306723594665527, 0.33421993255615234, -0.6405326128005981, -0.4336433708667755, -0.43191832304000854, -0.6598235964775085, -1.0180754661560059, 0.006053281482309103, -0.2142517864704132, -0.5439592003822327, 0.7145164012908936, -0.1570025086402893, -0.3411037027835846, 0.5401247143745422, -0.627364456653595, 0.7913540601730347, -0.43437230587005615, -0.721461832523346, -0.11888385564088821, -0.7923856377601624, -0.12085044384002686, 0.09925723820924759, -0.444254606962204, 0.31787094473838806, -0.19922520220279694, 0.6872467398643494, -0.0986807718873024, 0.5380004048347473, -0.24446599185466766, 0.10910336673259735, 0.15669921040534973, -0.02558116242289543, 0.7286692261695862, 0.16034461557865143, -0.23209775984287262, 0.4285649061203003, -0.3485817611217499, -0.43955889344215393, -0.6681596040725708, 0.7752563953399658, -0.8808244466781616, -0.35962074995040894, -0.17019441723823547, -0.231599822640419, -0.12981130182743073, 0.19415946304798126, 0.6360121369361877, 0.1930747777223587, -0.030743999406695366, 0.8418858051300049, 0.9019314050674438, -0.15896907448768616, 0.4485822021961212, 0.13035805523395538, 0.5282335877418518, -0.18467937409877777, 0.6854071021080017, 0.19721607863903046, -0.14119543135166168, 0.8149670958518982, 0.0010753015521913767, -0.337602823972702, -0.47104403376579285, -0.17193208634853363, 0.12432997673749924, -0.5664716362953186, -0.21912001073360443, -0.8895117044448853, -0.2650783956050873, -0.267223596572876, -0.33396226167678833, -0.5554056763648987, -0.33588430285453796, -0.27133798599243164, 0.002933414652943611, 0.0845678523182869, 0.4502837359905243, -0.038771722465753555, 0.4080740511417389, -0.7439664006233215, 0.49846401810646057, 0.3206001818180084, 0.6977958083152771, 0.06478916108608246, -0.5903822779655457, -0.6601722240447998, -0.13267561793327332, -0.15389184653759003, -0.32550668716430664, 0.1806022673845291, -0.002486803336068988, 0.5598602890968323, 0.16130192577838898, 0.08773494511842728, 0.5260668396949768, -0.5212782621383667, 0.8230398297309875, 0.07613375037908554, -0.8467360734939575, 0.444076806306839, 0.11106646060943604, 0.47594815492630005, 0.5720692873001099, 0.6720035076141357, -0.4269395172595978, 0.0718301311135292, -0.5584202408790588, -0.8757305145263672, 0.7452595829963684, 0.36647382378578186, 0.0823233425617218, 0.27229204773902893, 0.31281521916389465, 0.19287265837192535, 0.20365305244922638, -0.5845173001289368, -0.12963196635246277, -0.29910123348236084, -0.15015558898448944, -0.17419928312301636, -0.3103031516075134, 0.20588639378547668, -0.1892254650592804, 0.5785307288169861, -0.2035561352968216, 0.6923595070838928, 0.43206891417503357, -0.14257173240184784, -0.13740739226341248, 0.40801846981048584, 0.197778582572937, 0.03618590533733368, -0.48270270228385925, 0.23163288831710815, 0.43016180396080017, -0.5604671835899353, 0.022239604964852333, 0.27147501707077026, -0.3070773184299469, 0.22126945853233337, 0.36699390411376953, 1.0372648239135742, 0.3584720492362976, -0.2736567556858063, 0.4393784701824188, -0.2937566339969635, -0.005374863278120756, 0.15698528289794922, 0.06996425241231918, -0.12079969048500061, 0.43534529209136963, 0.3539654314517975, 0.2749800682067871, 0.3578685522079468, -0.295075923204422, 0.11441240459680557, 0.5608299970626831, -0.6831158995628357, -0.19163624942302704, 0.8775576949119568, 0.19222292304039001, -0.1360412985086441, 0.8545817136764526, 0.1546526700258255, -0.26311227679252625, 0.3266073167324066, 0.1757943481206894, 1.0144388675689697, 0.147013321518898, -0.07180456072092056, 0.06848632544279099, 0.6910977959632874, -0.09087736159563065, 0.0474429689347744, -0.6173173189163208, -0.446393758058548, -0.19428066909313202, -0.63897705078125, -0.5771464109420776, -0.10883308947086334, -0.5066190958023071, 0.1598530262708664, -0.24589934945106506, -0.45655977725982666, -0.0579814650118351, 0.3263683021068573, -1.146195411682129, 0.26188743114471436, 0.25747451186180115, 0.9563934206962585, -0.3188694417476654, 0.6971166133880615, 0.33632394671440125, -0.4337184727191925, -0.344460666179657, 0.04320424050092697, -0.6520553827285767, -0.36902865767478943, 0.6133556365966797, -0.04081892967224121, -0.324779212474823, -0.21217478811740875, -0.38338515162467957, -0.7136991620063782, 1.2792807817459106, 0.41061970591545105, -0.8781740069389343, -0.6375001668930054, 0.2809785306453705, 0.7759357690811157, -0.19866763055324554, 0.7619566321372986, 0.2929192781448364, 0.5333318710327148, 0.03998672589659691, -0.6794738173484802, 0.06123948469758034, -0.2239023596048355, 0.12771013379096985, 0.08743544667959213, -0.6955370903015137, 0.8315504789352417, -0.3168676197528839, -0.05659247562289238, -0.08817644417285919, 0.45454826951026917, -0.2949414849281311, 0.353848397731781, 0.31966152787208557, 0.5966405272483826, 0.6291422247886658, -0.37299954891204834, 1.3682904243469238, -0.29465338587760925, 0.3648742139339447, 0.7904869914054871, -0.09445833414793015, 0.6442272067070007, 0.42014607787132263, -0.09358574450016022, 0.6169674396514893, 0.47163358330726624, -0.21146802604198456, 0.7152830958366394, -0.22056347131729126, 0.09459127485752106, -0.4451700747013092, -0.059570714831352234, -0.4994787871837616, 0.12484092265367508, 0.0849132314324379, -0.5433799624443054, -0.007167853880673647, -0.030069081112742424, -0.5451200604438782, -0.3847584128379822, -0.24267955124378204, 0.6609774827957153, 0.28555700182914734, -0.2863147258758545, 0.4225299656391144, 0.11019910126924515, 1.0006064176559448, -0.6079031229019165, 0.14545337855815887, -0.3845762610435486, 0.2634526789188385, -0.39564189314842224, -0.6705016493797302, 0.07684320211410522, -0.034432996064424515, -0.527503490447998, -0.1603148877620697, 1.2053288221359253, -0.24557635188102722, -0.4488465189933777, 0.5591642260551453, 0.5947898626327515, -0.07942581921815872, -0.09032969921827316, -0.4785083830356598, -0.044308800250291824, -0.34800755977630615, -0.38489603996276855, 0.19648775458335876, 0.53745436668396, 0.14009061455726624, 0.5483139157295227, 0.5766438245773315, 0.07295194268226624, 0.07882808893918991, 0.2302653044462204, 0.8427741527557373, -0.976325511932373, -0.43278080224990845, -0.5838853716850281, 0.26230916380882263, 0.04701177775859833, 0.1727200746536255, 0.691525936126709, 0.6140344142913818, 0.9828099012374878, -0.11791572719812393, 0.741969645023346, -0.009596766903996468, 0.029925404116511345, -0.4410386383533478, 0.5959910154342651, -0.7175789475440979, 0.49663352966308594, -0.14097590744495392, -0.9807778000831604, -0.01146410871297121, 0.4178711771965027, -0.5524429082870483, 0.48413389921188354, 0.6668769121170044, 0.6544491052627563, -0.4008808732032776, 0.08050177991390228, 0.4875343441963196, 0.024240434169769287, 0.12144319713115692, 0.8229271769523621, 0.6145244836807251, -0.8344091176986694, 0.9287077188491821, -0.3671841621398926, 0.3144257664680481, -0.3435443043708801, -0.37838393449783325, -0.9658433198928833, -0.14496125280857086, -0.017843501642346382, -0.2682270109653473, 0.28432491421699524, 0.5423095226287842, 0.9172899723052979, -0.7462180852890015, 0.07046482712030411, 0.12683677673339844, 0.24661803245544434, -0.15053068101406097, -0.19543930888175964, 0.25592583417892456, -0.2167958915233612, -0.7286437749862671, 0.38729578256607056, 0.2645769715309143, 0.014129618182778358, -0.23978014290332794, -0.3286835551261902, -0.13044941425323486, 0.08921152353286743, 0.5844610333442688, 0.006768033839762211, -0.5044206976890564, -0.3620305061340332, 0.2754664421081543, -0.5092092752456665, 0.2180815041065216, 0.8750503063201904, -1.3387316465377808, 0.1431090384721756, 0.7350085973739624, 0.9587416648864746, 1.080043077468872, -0.09029312431812286, 0.21056398749351501, -0.8785852789878845, -0.09717527776956558, 0.5736927390098572, 0.21982108056545258, 0.2908899784088135, -0.5898100137710571, 0.7193354964256287, 0.33864346146583557, -0.5788375735282898, -0.5509195327758789, -0.20495913922786713, -0.9167706370353699, -0.03197032958269119, 0.7113842368125916, 0.28094539046287537, -0.1735060065984726, 0.16266898810863495, 0.04630829766392708, 0.14214719831943512, -0.6470463275909424, 0.7990005612373352, 0.42214787006378174, -0.15906764566898346, -0.29793107509613037, -0.34966179728507996, 0.3501642048358917, 0.5732679963111877, -0.4756414592266083, -0.44636642932891846, 0.054840076714754105, -0.12313268333673477, 0.3128126859664917, 0.36435937881469727, 0.009527482092380524, 0.16959135234355927, 0.2866877615451813, -0.16054557263851166, 0.10367567092180252, -0.47085538506507874, -0.19862709939479828, 0.47020095586776733, -0.3887289762496948, 0.07980693131685257 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20215v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20215v1
Advancing the Arabic WordNet: Elevating Content Quality
2024-03-29T14:54:19
2024-03-29T14:54:19
Abed Alhakim Freihat, Hadi Khalilia, Gábor Bella, Fausto Giunchiglia
cs.CL
cs.CL
High-quality WordNets are crucial for achieving high-quality results in NLP applications that rely on such resources. However, the wordnets of most languages suffer from serious issues of correctness and completeness with respect to the words and word meanings they define, such as incorrect lemmas, missing glosses and example sentences, or an inadequate, Western-centric representation of the morphology and the semantics of the language. Previous efforts have largely focused on increasing lexical coverage while ignoring other qualitative aspects. In this paper, we focus on the Arabic language and introduce a major revision of the Arabic WordNet that addresses multiple dimensions of lexico-semantic resource quality. As a result, we updated more than 58% of the synsets of the existing Arabic WordNet by adding missing information and correcting errors. In order to address issues of language diversity and untranslatability, we also extended the wordnet structure by new elements: phrasets and lexical gaps.
[ -0.5070289373397827, -0.241884246468544, 0.10608221590518951, 0.13838636875152588, -0.16069871187210083, 0.4163881242275238, 0.008277720771729946, -0.3902845084667206, 0.35897257924079895, 0.4046550989151001, -0.04537690803408623, -0.7969508767127991, -0.9651795625686646, 0.1051587164402008, -0.5598095655441284, 0.9609060287475586, -0.2678993046283722, -0.3796704411506653, 0.2388821542263031, -0.7824745178222656, -0.5295360088348389, -0.22695009410381317, -0.6392531394958496, -0.12940546870231628, 0.7613171935081482, 0.49028438329696655, 1.5269521474838257, 0.5731762051582336, 0.43461281061172485, 0.33415746688842773, -0.42416590452194214, 0.7105709314346313, -0.1490984708070755, 0.05068116635084152, -0.491245299577713, 0.08928095549345016, -0.5054852962493896, -0.42923179268836975, 0.6969640254974365, 0.9350217580795288, -0.20298707485198975, -0.028496408835053444, 0.09644361585378647, 1.238787293434143, -0.9137360453605652, -0.05999035760760307, -0.45425543189048767, 0.004075502045452595, -0.10504934936761856, -0.052889663726091385, 0.21891550719738007, -0.15689484775066376, -0.023010915145277977, -0.4890618622303009, 0.0258538406342268, -0.2135297954082489, 0.8199390172958374, 0.104930579662323, -0.484662264585495, -0.3195536732673645, -0.5510843992233276, 0.4845924973487854, -0.7394152879714966, 0.3663291335105896, 0.5751063823699951, 0.14867103099822998, -0.32946255803108215, -0.753561794757843, -0.44459712505340576, -0.06364242732524872, 0.17080959677696228, 0.14362190663814545, -0.2741774022579193, 0.08911146223545074, -0.0761168822646141, 0.37998664379119873, -0.18513937294483185, -0.12606649100780487, -0.27490517497062683, -0.4012046754360199, 0.6081493496894836, -0.047194480895996094, 0.6583225131034851, 0.14382000267505646, 0.11702662706375122, -0.257451593875885, -0.7156217098236084, -0.127369686961174, 0.41515544056892395, 0.15687063336372375, 0.11631649732589722, 0.6828697323799133, -0.44894537329673767, 0.6043480038642883, -0.6079191565513611, 0.03725710138678551, 0.3606586456298828, -0.7037048935890198, 0.078351229429245, 0.33732539415359497, 0.11422713100910187, 0.26193538308143616, -0.1912631243467331, 0.008235693909227848, -0.3704472780227661, -0.13102467358112335, 0.5703063607215881, -0.5180104970932007, 0.06180693209171295, 0.589635968208313, -0.3744129240512848, -0.00569233950227499, 0.2817208766937256, -0.18836377561092377, -0.45657312870025635, -0.22590003907680511, 0.48955556750297546, -0.6859989762306213, -0.26497673988342285, 0.3744335174560547, -0.15099170804023743, 0.11782169342041016, 0.6216662526130676, -0.48282334208488464, 0.059944286942481995, 0.6871449947357178, 1.0499147176742554, 0.1256018728017807, -0.26252785325050354, -0.021781453862786293, 0.17594783008098602, -0.8353531956672668, 0.47850561141967773, -0.2912727892398834, -0.16264361143112183, 0.3979755938053131, -0.18868307769298553, 0.330231249332428, -0.5581610202789307, 0.640479326248169, -0.8302102088928223, -0.1048179417848587, -0.3878142237663269, -0.4363006353378296, -0.5319152474403381, 0.5492566227912903, -0.7718151807785034, 0.7500845193862915, 0.39444413781166077, -0.7846225500106812, -0.06407466530799866, -0.7243592739105225, -0.3648216724395752, 0.02696836180984974, 0.132780060172081, -0.22593064606189728, 0.2680983543395996, 0.18173173069953918, -0.03359217569231987, 0.1830889731645584, -0.14424757659435272, 0.4414133131504059, -0.3575359880924225, 0.46231740713119507, -0.1429605484008789, 0.5260224938392639, 0.3523814380168915, -0.2195558398962021, 0.2222539782524109, -0.8562917113304138, 0.2086803913116455, -0.3211725652217865, -0.37455400824546814, -0.3281104266643524, 0.08071552217006683, 0.15701676905155182, 0.34921762347221375, 0.3606416881084442, -0.6176056265830994, 0.022476978600025177, -0.6047540307044983, 0.1642758548259735, 0.4952525496482849, 0.007630064617842436, 0.3210957944393158, -0.5571908950805664, 0.3712140619754791, 0.47300904989242554, 0.25993311405181885, -0.0888000875711441, -0.40438732504844666, -1.0740753412246704, 0.055444955825805664, 0.6520950198173523, 0.303691029548645, -1.1496284008026123, 0.4600575566291809, -0.22337999939918518, -0.5240824222564697, -0.5592353343963623, 0.1229354590177536, 0.1294720470905304, -0.14907792210578918, 0.6580348610877991, -0.7210824489593506, -0.2779143750667572, -0.651542067527771, -0.0638132318854332, -0.20507793128490448, -0.051935166120529175, 0.06827644258737564, 0.46008193492889404, -0.4767068028450012, 0.6989296078681946, -0.16447563469409943, -0.5514398813247681, -0.36709439754486084, 0.06913718581199646, 0.2672341465950012, 0.4059033989906311, 0.2087457925081253, -0.6481277942657471, -0.41721582412719727, 0.1432388573884964, -0.3090372383594513, -0.0889696255326271, -0.009642020799219608, -0.2464282214641571, 0.13442300260066986, 0.3713941276073456, -0.38104164600372314, 0.5446480512619019, 0.7125353813171387, -0.535227358341217, 0.4523248076438904, -0.2007177770137787, 0.15179197490215302, -1.2884228229522705, -0.06673509627580643, -0.40447258949279785, 0.04309592768549919, -0.5155778527259827, 0.3355327248573303, -0.21969613432884216, -0.17767560482025146, -0.5119645595550537, 0.441769003868103, -0.3766671419143677, -0.08179735392332077, -0.7040929198265076, 0.15777131915092468, 0.28429168462753296, -0.04326942563056946, -0.49467867612838745, 0.90265953540802, 0.5376113653182983, -0.49046286940574646, 0.5655030012130737, 0.4511430263519287, -0.4043896198272705, 0.3209246098995209, -0.805592954158783, -0.0973266214132309, -0.45174580812454224, 0.17361803352832794, -0.6147978901863098, 0.049419183284044266, 0.23467522859573364, -0.4819084703922272, 0.10936731100082397, 0.1266201138496399, -0.4886157214641571, 0.09949685633182526, -0.32966601848602295, 0.540986180305481, 0.14358076453208923, -0.22321255505084991, 0.4440367817878723, 0.20904937386512756, -0.07052301615476608, -0.9430623054504395, -0.36528298258781433, 0.7170195579528809, 0.5641217231750488, -0.6225908994674683, 0.6007211208343506, 0.4658222198486328, -0.30932655930519104, 0.284165620803833, -0.27190160751342773, -0.2600593566894531, 0.09857700765132904, 0.0460701622068882, -0.37673720717430115, -0.18507391214370728, 0.21707725524902344, -0.05945036932826042, -0.07517315447330475, -0.2732302248477936, -0.7288426160812378, 0.5277992486953735, 0.0497111976146698, -0.4698811173439026, -0.46866312623023987, 0.7282230257987976, 0.3761136829853058, -0.6045502424240112, 1.1081452369689941, 0.812390148639679, -0.46482953429222107, -0.06937576085329056, -0.40754157304763794, 0.007572880480438471, -0.43083450198173523, 0.7002677321434021, -0.12737444043159485, -0.9151690006256104, 0.5373992323875427, 0.07737484574317932, 0.3447306156158447, 0.5994240045547485, 0.19763831794261932, -0.07662396132946014, 0.9592903852462769, 0.8630190491676331, -0.10520965605974197, 0.20699065923690796, -0.11852699518203735, 0.21561259031295776, -0.989030659198761, -0.08544883131980896, -0.7055460810661316, -0.48875993490219116, -0.8489407896995544, -0.625240683555603, 0.3934018909931183, 0.05507807433605194, -0.19335012137889862, 0.4222901165485382, -0.10505225509405136, 0.20901910960674286, 0.5886077284812927, 0.09337025135755539, 0.2488924115896225, 0.3810167610645294, -0.23552311956882477, 0.0825028046965599, -0.6563520431518555, -0.632135808467865, 0.5764180421829224, 0.323760062456131, 0.4499932825565338, 0.8371132016181946, 0.4912647008895874, 0.6611019968986511, 0.012318382039666176, -0.5488269925117493, 0.1797846108675003, -0.1819332391023636, -0.44360432028770447, -0.4289917051792145, -0.401293009519577, -1.08283531665802, 0.3636792302131653, -0.008184054866433144, -0.3333969712257385, 0.15249617397785187, -0.0780261754989624, -0.33907151222229004, 0.35769763588905334, -0.018087096512317657, 0.6178035140037537, 0.2277975082397461, -0.3254624009132385, -0.6098772287368774, -0.49798282980918884, -0.30525386333465576, -0.0018418837571516633, 0.0752391666173935, -0.2970941662788391, -0.444133996963501, 0.6182636618614197, -0.8237155079841614, 0.5114688277244568, 0.06178079918026924, -0.29940181970596313, 0.6715220808982849, 0.24540063738822937, 0.1017412394285202, -0.030232999473810196, -0.1309484988451004, 0.3169059157371521, 0.13506369292736053, -0.9775794148445129, -0.6676012277603149, 0.3901597559452057, -1.0597198009490967, -0.37322935461997986, -0.5618971586227417, -0.47304436564445496, -0.3111315369606018, -0.009381232783198357, -0.23460839688777924, 0.6743600964546204, -0.11048635095357895, 0.12823492288589478, 0.3653343915939331, -0.7255440354347229, 0.29554152488708496, 0.2432561069726944, -0.034337420016527176, -0.4846440851688385, 0.9258099794387817, 0.2622624337673187, 0.14726291596889496, 0.3133084177970886, -0.06091337278485298, -0.3296557366847992, -0.9182530045509338, -0.541804313659668, -0.09408941119909286, -0.7832975387573242, -0.28592512011528015, -0.4558556079864502, -0.6871435046195984, -0.23691587150096893, 0.027182679623365402, -0.4032169580459595, -0.5225861668586731, -0.08235550671815872, 0.12423328310251236, 0.33085739612579346, 0.7459803223609924, -0.264993280172348, 0.46307551860809326, -1.3982102870941162, -0.039655424654483795, 0.06773247569799423, 0.28959500789642334, 0.14848478138446808, -0.8060606718063354, -0.5115750432014465, 0.02709943614900112, -0.41635414958000183, -0.6513137817382812, 0.2431793212890625, 0.3478398323059082, 0.07697270810604095, 0.11600940674543381, -0.08504477143287659, 0.4734547436237335, -0.6062507629394531, 0.8690395951271057, 0.26406943798065186, -0.8712292313575745, 0.5290942788124084, -0.150884747505188, 0.7469263076782227, 0.6846845149993896, 0.297818124294281, -1.3291159868240356, -0.208134725689888, -0.6444608569145203, -1.061255693435669, 0.24602411687374115, 0.49917829036712646, 0.5912331342697144, -0.001540454220958054, 0.39116525650024414, -0.1239488497376442, 0.21851781010627747, -0.09862818568944931, -0.21772053837776184, -0.53081214427948, -0.2991355359554291, 0.19473174214363098, -0.5458276867866516, -0.060543838888406754, 0.024461109191179276, 0.8899917006492615, -0.17455023527145386, 0.056244269013404846, 0.27779117226600647, -0.2667528986930847, 0.22223670780658722, 0.5574887990951538, 0.6866793632507324, 1.1733481884002686, 0.10841292142868042, 0.4443550705909729, 0.1787407100200653, -0.6532016396522522, 0.41137760877609253, -0.12556350231170654, -0.3508611023426056, 0.3031328320503235, 0.5434949398040771, 0.513656735420227, -0.2754223942756653, -0.43213874101638794, 0.5577371120452881, 0.1761016994714737, 0.19890248775482178, -0.30727434158325195, -0.07375377416610718, -0.07271572947502136, 0.006658651866018772, 0.29620784521102905, 0.26772627234458923, 0.07516416907310486, -0.5811572670936584, 0.35092321038246155, -0.026497041806578636, -0.7630681395530701, -0.1809457540512085, -0.08745261281728745, 0.264863520860672, -0.06177650764584541, 0.6901535391807556, -0.34607526659965515, -0.6099457740783691, 0.460785835981369, 0.3044065535068512, 0.35866445302963257, -0.18404266238212585, 0.5059457421302795, 0.4080418348312378, 0.4301416575908661, 0.09122571349143982, 0.690723717212677, 0.27114230394363403, -1.0796213150024414, -0.7425255179405212, -0.6428216695785522, -0.46360287070274353, -0.18504321575164795, -0.2324865460395813, -0.2612011730670929, -0.6008232235908508, -0.25398048758506775, -0.48157328367233276, 0.10256464034318924, -0.33750849962234497, 0.34408190846443176, 0.02563483826816082, 1.150463581085205, -0.3003915250301361, 0.6620092391967773, 0.8428958654403687, -0.46978870034217834, -0.7652410268783569, -0.12374614179134369, -0.30262061953544617, -0.6765503287315369, 0.4925718903541565, -0.01985960267484188, -0.2028598189353943, 0.13830135762691498, -0.2954665422439575, -1.1799523830413818, 0.7284240126609802, -0.04456795006990433, -0.29319873452186584, 0.25580036640167236, 0.5426545143127441, 0.42603662610054016, 0.18985724449157715, 0.2098345160484314, 0.18150462210178375, 0.4509790241718292, 0.0855608731508255, -0.629432201385498, 0.06332343071699142, -0.08817005902528763, 0.4770919978618622, 0.21576964855194092, -0.3915962278842926, 0.5416557192802429, -0.09331242740154266, -0.24199002981185913, 0.19050166010856628, 1.1100480556488037, -0.11828595399856567, -0.24394087493419647, 0.3204270601272583, 0.7975746989250183, 0.5889586210250854, -0.28369078040122986, 0.81680828332901, -0.4654914438724518, 0.026609009131789207, 0.7289148569107056, -0.15949270129203796, 0.7923272848129272, 0.23425069451332092, -0.17154458165168762, 0.46511712670326233, 0.5391712784767151, 0.2638970613479614, 0.2113930732011795, 0.4972671866416931, -0.7814677357673645, 0.046665992587804794, -0.8195371627807617, -0.5266587734222412, 0.711414635181427, 0.4341559112071991, -0.1718313843011856, -0.44925031065940857, -0.21722011268138885, 0.10230568796396255, 0.2087891846895218, -0.5293794870376587, 0.6263300776481628, 0.006844168528914452, -0.3409576117992401, 0.3942756652832031, 0.7494960427284241, 0.47709235548973083, -0.4352531433105469, -0.16673743724822998, -0.4789031445980072, 0.049491509795188904, -0.4175620675086975, -0.7248607873916626, 0.6994680166244507, -0.31801721453666687, 0.12066638469696045, 0.0069755553267896175, 0.7496163249015808, -0.33490750193595886, -0.4842621684074402, 0.13828027248382568, 0.7706118822097778, 0.12418396025896072, -0.2729857861995697, -0.6961125731468201, 0.265982449054718, -0.3243231475353241, 0.3275626301765442, 0.11560200899839401, 0.5550217032432556, -0.0064205084927380085, 0.3106488287448883, 0.6349626183509827, 0.3959081172943115, -0.05422015115618706, 0.49672114849090576, 0.7378132939338684, -0.6988897323608398, -0.38889455795288086, -0.7350050210952759, 0.39289698004722595, -0.3348614275455475, -0.4313817620277405, 0.4913961887359619, 0.3448401689529419, 0.9364342093467712, 0.3650544285774231, 0.5647614598274231, -0.13191528618335724, 0.11498714983463287, -0.47956278920173645, 0.998380720615387, -0.5704574584960938, -0.08037228137254715, -0.015284257009625435, -1.055920958518982, -0.4194595515727997, 0.6990630626678467, 0.419336199760437, 0.06508678197860718, 0.6629927158355713, 0.7925818562507629, 0.05300094932317734, -0.04183918237686157, 0.4911908507347107, 0.21889938414096832, 0.18454766273498535, 0.32847896218299866, 0.9877497553825378, -0.7610251307487488, 0.2749500870704651, -0.23699188232421875, -0.14366060495376587, 0.041377581655979156, -0.7613852024078369, -0.32964062690734863, -0.7606044411659241, -0.557988166809082, -0.7529692053794861, 0.45360785722732544, 1.1526646614074707, 0.44455578923225403, -1.0574594736099243, -0.19884426891803741, 0.06535735726356506, 0.2718871533870697, -0.40239453315734863, -0.09068939834833145, 0.5682792663574219, -0.43402037024497986, -0.28526565432548523, 0.201797753572464, 0.41003867983818054, 0.017255965620279312, -0.16537371277809143, 0.09874431043863297, -0.2602171301841736, 0.04419888183474541, 0.916799783706665, 0.21790766716003418, -0.3955193758010864, -0.596403956413269, -0.27195775508880615, -0.2621067762374878, 0.11303277313709259, 0.5645550489425659, -0.30829963088035583, 0.0811261236667633, 0.37686845660209656, 1.2467371225357056, -0.12523551285266876, -0.2338322103023529, 0.4205676019191742, -0.9128397107124329, 0.13368317484855652, 0.29693514108657837, 0.4125536382198334, 0.7464026808738708, 0.16987168788909912, 0.43026402592658997, 0.07747068256139755, -0.2462203949689865, -0.08376870304346085, 0.5911684632301331, -0.6824389696121216, -0.3045843243598938, 1.1170111894607544, -0.08807165920734406, -0.22154924273490906, -0.3808009624481201, -0.3382759392261505, 0.4693056643009186, -0.13329894840717316, 0.9218522310256958, 0.8648040294647217, 0.28486013412475586, -0.08362829685211182, -0.6236900687217712, 0.3740288019180298, 0.7347267270088196, -0.5620560646057129, -0.3340528905391693, 0.43918633460998535, -0.025309206917881966, 0.3184569478034973, 0.4002549648284912, -0.2765474319458008, 0.3181864619255066, -0.1622815579175949, 0.22248095273971558, 0.15749017894268036, -0.4222961366176605, -0.055003974586725235, 0.10550697147846222, 0.5381180644035339, -0.2024189978837967 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20196v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20196v2
Automatic Alignment of Discourse Relations of Different Discourse Annotation Frameworks
2024-03-29T14:18:26
2024-04-06T13:54:43
Yingxue Fu
cs.CL
cs.CL
Existing discourse corpora are annotated based on different frameworks, which show significant dissimilarities in definitions of arguments and relations and structural constraints. Despite surface differences, these frameworks share basic understandings of discourse relations. The relationship between these frameworks has been an open research question, especially the correlation between relation inventories utilized in different frameworks. Better understanding of this question is helpful for integrating discourse theories and enabling interoperability of discourse corpora annotated under different frameworks. However, studies that explore correlations between discourse relation inventories are hindered by different criteria of discourse segmentation, and expert knowledge and manual examination are typically needed. Some semi-automatic methods have been proposed, but they rely on corpora annotated in multiple frameworks in parallel. In this paper, we introduce a fully automatic approach to address the challenges. Specifically, we extend the label-anchored contrastive learning method introduced by Zhang et al. (2022b) to learn label embeddings during a classification task. These embeddings are then utilized to map discourse relations from different frameworks. We show experimental results on RST-DT (Carlson et al., 2001) and PDTB 3.0 (Prasad et al., 2018).
[ -0.43966174125671387, -0.5047892332077026, 0.5359854698181152, 0.1594959944486618, -0.2418699562549591, 0.27082905173301697, 0.11770527064800262, -0.5953840017318726, 0.214539036154747, 0.35506266355514526, -0.17772403359413147, -0.5595434308052063, -0.5457429885864258, 0.2405218482017517, -0.052116237580776215, 0.911285936832428, -0.3979295790195465, 0.11394736915826797, -0.3019767999649048, -0.6575693488121033, -0.31238722801208496, -0.2427069991827011, -0.2658190429210663, -0.2235456109046936, 0.3810219466686249, 0.021694928407669067, 0.7932546734809875, 0.844999372959137, 0.43178659677505493, 0.3861559331417084, -0.2134992480278015, 0.20054098963737488, -0.08478261530399323, 0.10479210317134857, -0.5591925382614136, 0.016017993912100792, -0.27843567728996277, -0.22475199401378632, 0.5428286194801331, 0.8774751424789429, 0.22460296750068665, 0.06433073431253433, 0.3027130961418152, 0.1532268524169922, -0.7441668510437012, 0.22428886592388153, -0.41116511821746826, 0.1689332276582718, -0.0799768716096878, -0.2654147446155548, -0.4237929880619049, -0.3857663869857788, 0.41033831238746643, -0.715941309928894, -0.09215380251407623, 0.19273065030574799, 1.27396559715271, 0.21821968257427216, -0.7456387877464294, -0.43651342391967773, -0.34999051690101624, 0.6458064913749695, -0.4936893582344055, 0.1636655032634735, 0.15786832571029663, 0.208857461810112, 0.11568786948919296, -0.5172072649002075, -0.18661709129810333, 0.18127353489398956, -0.8272219300270081, 0.09815532714128494, -0.05797545984387398, 0.2846415936946869, 0.12798742949962616, 0.3597092926502228, -0.4123736023902893, 0.3263295292854309, -0.2098524123430252, -0.37677350640296936, 0.11017140001058578, 0.049505699425935745, 0.16942434012889862, -0.25141283869743347, -0.7836889624595642, 0.029222453013062477, -0.5133349895477295, -0.3804117739200592, 0.1732037365436554, 0.16959567368030548, -0.25531813502311707, 0.41545620560646057, 0.3517429828643799, 0.8127660751342773, 0.29087576270103455, -0.012197377160191536, 0.5167730450630188, -0.34534981846809387, -0.3222837746143341, 0.1393451988697052, 1.0424162149429321, 0.195192351937294, -0.13611680269241333, 0.06880215555429459, 0.0847124382853508, -0.11338947713375092, 0.030764281749725342, -0.5501631498336792, -0.24702417850494385, -0.05541457235813141, -0.21380895376205444, -0.2303483486175537, 0.007647084537893534, -0.7671963572502136, -0.44436222314834595, -0.4278658330440521, 0.30364498496055603, -0.24816301465034485, -0.22930942475795746, -0.45000940561294556, 0.1187676414847374, 0.42334210872650146, 0.17444267868995667, -0.8774665594100952, 0.431201696395874, 0.7146196365356445, 0.8190938830375671, -0.4776741862297058, -0.06266497075557709, -0.4875906705856323, 0.5551117658615112, -0.24674595892429352, 0.8961767554283142, -0.7429859042167664, -0.09916950762271881, 0.3565599024295807, 0.21151280403137207, -0.2678239643573761, -0.4537532329559326, 0.5478922724723816, -0.5374311804771423, 0.5706976652145386, -0.17922215163707733, -0.7848924398422241, -0.35453855991363525, 0.4421890079975128, -0.6261028051376343, 0.8957715034484863, 0.14745073020458221, -1.296329140663147, 0.0066028740257024765, -0.45140326023101807, -0.4743991494178772, -0.1078345850110054, -0.41874930262565613, -0.5777546763420105, -0.2987813353538513, 0.3173854947090149, 0.5008793473243713, -0.28942540287971497, 0.5865457653999329, -0.45514369010925293, -0.19886818528175354, 0.1605093777179718, 0.12415198236703873, 1.2040836811065674, 0.026793431490659714, -0.392843633890152, 0.4526359438896179, -0.6746177673339844, -0.18453165888786316, -0.3856503367424011, 0.22645710408687592, -0.6541755795478821, -0.3918803632259369, -0.09509417414665222, 0.16055621206760406, 0.2042081654071808, -0.34826424717903137, -0.0682186633348465, -0.6043820381164551, 0.20893992483615875, 0.8273552656173706, 0.16540715098381042, 0.5753012299537659, -0.09779119491577148, 0.5215804576873779, 0.35749945044517517, -0.2918631434440613, -0.3908751308917999, -0.30197247862815857, -0.8100329041481018, -0.3810233175754547, 0.7473755478858948, 0.7328802943229675, -0.5164223313331604, 0.6151620745658875, -0.2470194548368454, -0.3553389310836792, -0.6273398399353027, -0.10762463510036469, 0.7847784757614136, 0.8390501141548157, 0.6042584776878357, -0.3200554847717285, -0.7018037438392639, -1.0761100053787231, 0.053750187158584595, -0.21138069033622742, 0.012437693774700165, 0.19848820567131042, 0.4950382709503174, -0.0027345840353518724, 1.0005016326904297, -0.6512065529823303, -0.3760159909725189, 0.5112555027008057, 0.5304662585258484, -0.3949314057826996, 0.5497408509254456, 0.6572638154029846, -0.7500597238540649, -0.7677415013313293, 0.25046008825302124, -0.7906913757324219, -0.3703104853630066, -0.08117524534463882, -0.4827914834022522, 0.23453663289546967, 0.5581572651863098, -0.20014981925487518, 0.19491524994373322, 0.3767206370830536, -0.1737068146467209, 0.3711385130882263, 0.1098596453666687, -0.009274509735405445, -1.3841150999069214, 0.12287550419569016, 0.18428033590316772, -0.1589641124010086, -0.3931044638156891, -0.1702101230621338, 0.16716481745243073, 0.11729374527931213, -0.41646429896354675, 0.5748756527900696, -0.5965592265129089, -0.3784604072570801, 0.08874262124300003, 0.3363315165042877, 0.2464417666196823, 0.6099265217781067, 0.280007004737854, 0.5384753346443176, 0.4990823566913605, -0.4848529100418091, -0.0014716850128024817, 0.45793500542640686, -0.005799352657049894, 0.8565154671669006, -0.3429134786128998, 0.024048084393143654, 0.2054881751537323, 0.33822694420814514, -1.1598937511444092, 0.016270838677883148, 0.7177453637123108, -0.16925442218780518, 0.34636834263801575, -0.28834646940231323, -0.27126866579055786, 0.21581843495368958, -0.2877478003501892, 0.3857853412628174, 0.06301003694534302, -0.5468643307685852, 0.6219976544380188, 0.6880291700363159, -0.24162040650844574, -0.900428831577301, -0.5759409666061401, -0.13218358159065247, -0.45605310797691345, -0.4012118875980377, 0.7380182147026062, 0.10876482725143433, -0.40720781683921814, 0.2876585125923157, 0.03746049478650093, -0.2942299544811249, -0.02815190702676773, 0.30486181378364563, 0.3012756407260895, -0.3132873475551605, 0.2250034213066101, 0.48622480034828186, -0.16586461663246155, -0.07103295624256134, -0.29295000433921814, -0.05949170142412186, -0.07744394987821579, -0.3197374939918518, -0.5097777247428894, 0.2905923128128052, 0.3286958336830139, -0.15536989271640778, 0.5922567844390869, 0.4598056375980377, -0.36545345187187195, 0.3966825604438782, -0.5847590565681458, 0.17768549919128418, -0.44288724660873413, -0.02786996029317379, -0.5355086922645569, -0.878593921661377, 0.5512861609458923, -0.28538089990615845, 0.21464550495147705, 0.49709445238113403, 0.2509201467037201, -0.008038101717829704, 0.6848823428153992, 0.6606224179267883, 0.06092125549912453, 0.1640409678220749, 0.1527516394853592, 0.08160421997308731, -0.8627986907958984, -0.00046233265311457217, -0.53761225938797, -0.22867992520332336, -0.8369962573051453, -0.4178353250026703, -0.07423175871372223, -0.08705787360668182, -0.3537786304950714, 0.5139536261558533, -0.5880443453788757, 0.3744443356990814, -0.010586682707071304, -0.36457017064094543, 0.3877449035644531, -0.04434764385223389, -0.5908167362213135, -0.22615759074687958, -0.41933900117874146, -0.580705463886261, 0.6066282391548157, 0.19376109540462494, 0.2116660326719284, 0.04411777853965759, 0.8080406785011292, -0.06703412532806396, 0.7513135671615601, -0.6696462631225586, 0.38825738430023193, -0.020507937297225, -0.35286542773246765, 0.022095724940299988, -0.3333674669265747, -0.9333342909812927, 0.5399470925331116, -0.09553523361682892, -0.7261210083961487, 0.6045853495597839, 0.10439302027225494, -0.30439719557762146, 0.12260232865810394, -0.6316201686859131, 0.9630930423736572, -0.13615307211875916, -0.5577394366264343, 0.27995696663856506, -0.977674663066864, 0.3620753586292267, -0.019944049417972565, 0.294984370470047, -0.1036270409822464, -0.24175509810447693, 0.7834418416023254, -0.15502314269542694, 0.879069983959198, -0.06672298163175583, -0.3023863434791565, 0.13885578513145447, -0.03996862471103668, 0.07377071678638458, -0.29915401339530945, -0.10070010274648666, -0.05580344796180725, 0.07602562755346298, -0.26051533222198486, -0.5773199796676636, 0.6301727890968323, -0.6130572557449341, -0.471928209066391, -0.6469451785087585, -0.39070600271224976, -0.3821718394756317, 0.265640527009964, 0.031158434227108955, 0.19350503385066986, -0.5425624847412109, -0.09739367663860321, 0.6727079749107361, -0.07864765077829361, 0.22660887241363525, 0.5286991596221924, -0.18113987147808075, -0.6931310892105103, 0.8448920845985413, 0.15877105295658112, -0.009727037511765957, 0.753679633140564, 0.13022026419639587, -0.3172150254249573, -0.20247633755207062, -0.3714977204799652, 0.2715534567832947, -0.6979068517684937, -0.5327779650688171, -0.791053831577301, -0.04287325218319893, -0.3239217698574066, -0.4445710778236389, -0.19581159949302673, -0.5597178339958191, -0.4657869040966034, -0.23148569464683533, 0.18328812718391418, 0.47696787118911743, -0.05618469789624214, 0.21712493896484375, -0.588902473449707, 0.1277797818183899, 0.1141391396522522, 0.02948153391480446, -0.011064834892749786, -0.39968597888946533, -0.05113565921783447, -0.2023525983095169, -0.5769737958908081, -1.0905033349990845, 0.138100728392601, 0.11828639358282089, 0.31575626134872437, 0.6225398778915405, 0.17262978851795197, 0.9132541418075562, -0.4008878469467163, 0.5225648880004883, 0.326394647359848, -0.9731922745704651, 0.3936607837677002, -0.4189431667327881, 0.3178553879261017, 0.6621165871620178, 0.7575379014015198, -0.15045860409736633, -0.4065430760383606, -0.7124415040016174, -0.9856084585189819, 0.47571831941604614, 0.07652118057012558, -0.2632903456687927, 0.067372627556324, 0.04662491753697395, 0.36904042959213257, 0.04646073654294014, -0.7365860342979431, -0.13978807628154755, -0.04072800651192665, -0.530225396156311, 0.32454976439476013, -0.2290533483028412, -0.5559160113334656, -0.26353076100349426, 0.814908504486084, -0.24577869474887848, 0.04590315744280815, -0.12863241136074066, -0.28284117579460144, 0.03514302894473076, 0.4127449095249176, 0.3308836817741394, 0.8605247139930725, 0.08972742408514023, 0.3989781439304352, 0.1282472014427185, 0.0060494733043015, 0.3930542469024658, 0.5554011464118958, -0.3718760311603546, 0.1580933779478073, 0.1019657626748085, 0.7386695742607117, 0.7269925475120544, -0.2636796534061432, 0.5414822101593018, 0.033960334956645966, -0.15706153213977814, -0.27415943145751953, -0.4571612477302551, 0.49824368953704834, 0.07865424454212189, 0.0578405037522316, -0.011083421297371387, 0.051296379417181015, -0.3355162739753723, 0.40784239768981934, 0.2621709406375885, -0.5041749477386475, -0.1479087769985199, 0.3292190730571747, 0.40688657760620117, -0.14074736833572388, 0.25946056842803955, -0.4772970974445343, -0.5509288907051086, 0.44028541445732117, 0.4965323209762573, 0.8444862365722656, -0.3681796193122864, 0.37159115076065063, 0.5103333592414856, -0.08695028722286224, 0.027242427691817284, -0.24029415845870972, -0.16617807745933533, -0.5963191390037537, -0.5055102109909058, -0.49831098318099976, -0.7980298399925232, 0.035967789590358734, -0.8598614931106567, 0.3618699014186859, -0.35709264874458313, 0.057631127536296844, 0.21690773963928223, 0.013525913469493389, -0.40189799666404724, -0.07127302139997482, 0.08532669395208359, 0.2900370657444, -0.9989326596260071, 0.7276815176010132, 0.8540306687355042, -0.3709357976913452, -0.5491569638252258, 0.2439710795879364, 0.13193587958812714, -0.3251570463180542, 0.600134551525116, 0.27023255825042725, -0.292575478553772, -0.1311161071062088, -0.035540852695703506, -0.7861717939376831, 0.9624903202056885, 0.6398305296897888, -0.5561352372169495, 0.05540493503212929, 0.05803830176591873, 0.6218327283859253, -0.7149785757064819, 0.343596875667572, 0.43023669719696045, 0.42169344425201416, 0.10229642689228058, -0.9492924213409424, 0.36301544308662415, -0.2623651623725891, -0.03022027015686035, 0.2855839729309082, -0.43273547291755676, 0.26908841729164124, 0.21830599009990692, -0.3855794668197632, 0.022319253534078598, 1.0183337926864624, 0.3298892080783844, 0.3473874032497406, 0.5704805254936218, 0.6138553023338318, 0.7820023894309998, -0.0026772283017635345, 0.10377758741378784, -0.3486272692680359, 0.11014419794082642, 1.5760315656661987, -0.4511619508266449, 0.7041429281234741, 0.42290839552879333, -0.038690440356731415, 0.7948005795478821, 0.7595975399017334, -0.2916598618030548, 0.3532070219516754, 0.07570625096559525, -0.0833919420838356, 0.03053518757224083, -0.2631259858608246, -0.39213207364082336, 0.315184086561203, 0.5969638824462891, -0.5432301759719849, -0.2753998935222626, -0.004484682809561491, 0.2468334436416626, 0.4211976230144501, 0.0751723125576973, 0.9073867201805115, 0.09661158919334412, -0.9831137657165527, 0.6388561725616455, -0.20098213851451874, 0.5587226748466492, -0.2993042469024658, -0.08859361708164215, 0.1600581258535385, -0.013402129523456097, -0.40012601017951965, -0.7347483038902283, 0.4918263852596283, -0.10933081805706024, 0.11803334951400757, -0.2928290367126465, 0.706948459148407, -0.5830290913581848, -0.23359425365924835, 0.592954158782959, 0.42661187052726746, -0.014684938825666904, 0.6357095837593079, -0.7263075113296509, 0.19724418222904205, -0.030405467376112938, -0.02279892936348915, 0.5726350545883179, 0.40958255529403687, -0.08907770365476608, 0.1736905574798584, 0.030739545822143555, -0.42294052243232727, -0.22940874099731445, -0.19807982444763184, 0.8841155171394348, -0.33323967456817627, -0.5625844597816467, -0.6826585531234741, 0.4574074149131775, -0.4889037013053894, -0.2218153476715088, 0.5956175327301025, 0.7118833065032959, 0.8036575317382812, 0.1854298710823059, 0.6295638084411621, 0.0073167551308870316, 0.5958845615386963, -0.2848568260669708, 0.32101479172706604, -0.25464165210723877, 0.2150188386440277, -0.5128312706947327, -1.0523914098739624, -0.44108402729034424, 0.7426285743713379, -0.4871980547904968, -0.37242263555526733, 0.9819655418395996, 0.7081013321876526, -0.25188183784484863, 0.17492175102233887, -0.20476077497005463, 0.1650083214044571, 0.06602349877357483, 0.34644779562950134, 0.4493814706802368, -0.294231653213501, 0.7120838165283203, -0.36778485774993896, -0.23353524506092072, 0.0015906291082501411, -0.9830228090286255, -0.7934694886207581, -0.8900903463363647, -0.901394784450531, -0.19198715686798096, 0.21567955613136292, 0.6908356547355652, 0.31876087188720703, -0.7958996295928955, -0.3612503111362457, -0.0003744333516806364, 0.24437491595745087, -0.3192470371723175, -0.27885082364082336, 0.8888049125671387, -0.20215974748134613, -0.6788532137870789, 0.14205540716648102, 0.2621833384037018, 0.10655399411916733, -0.22873245179653168, 0.1499025672674179, -0.6073814034461975, 0.00311487540602684, 0.38079312443733215, 0.4627198576927185, -0.5747634172439575, -0.28057917952537537, -0.5032004117965698, -0.019812364131212234, 0.3921661972999573, 0.7258506417274475, -0.7298057675361633, 0.4140808582305908, 0.6356863975524902, 0.7622792720794678, 0.4819679856300354, 0.15202714502811432, 0.6325131058692932, -0.8831430077552795, 0.11139736324548721, 0.36791926622390747, 0.3044700026512146, 0.6850969195365906, -0.07468358427286148, 0.6211820840835571, -0.0036978842690587044, -0.4086780250072479, -0.9792717099189758, 0.39878368377685547, -0.991284966468811, -0.18827271461486816, 0.933646559715271, -0.6247742772102356, -0.11731663346290588, -0.3681001365184784, -0.250654935836792, 0.5318169593811035, -0.09629423916339874, 0.6370303630828857, 0.6268942952156067, -0.2923835217952728, -0.127548947930336, -0.1536923497915268, 0.5634034872055054, 0.46096938848495483, -0.7904414534568787, 0.14045767486095428, 0.36023131012916565, 0.04433038830757141, 0.5482797622680664, 0.6979523301124573, -0.2485663741827011, -0.06707176566123962, -0.25858888030052185, -0.3297566771507263, 0.27452629804611206, 0.07327702641487122, -0.12692102789878845, 0.5134469270706177, -0.24084198474884033, -0.1656539887189865 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20184v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20184v1
Exploring Pathological Speech Quality Assessment with ASR-Powered Wav2Vec2 in Data-Scarce Context
2024-03-29T13:59:34
2024-03-29T13:59:34
Tuan Nguyen, Corinne Fredouille, Alain Ghio, Mathieu Balaguer, Virginie Woisard
eess.AS
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD
Automatic speech quality assessment has raised more attention as an alternative or support to traditional perceptual clinical evaluation. However, most research so far only gains good results on simple tasks such as binary classification, largely due to data scarcity. To deal with this challenge, current works tend to segment patients' audio files into many samples to augment the datasets. Nevertheless, this approach has limitations, as it indirectly relates overall audio scores to individual segments. This paper introduces a novel approach where the system learns at the audio level instead of segments despite data scarcity. This paper proposes to use the pre-trained Wav2Vec2 architecture for both SSL, and ASR as feature extractor in speech assessment. Carried out on the HNC dataset, our ASR-driven approach established a new baseline compared with other approaches, obtaining average $MSE=0.73$ and $MSE=1.15$ for the prediction of intelligibility and severity scores respectively, using only 95 training samples. It shows that the ASR based Wav2Vec2 model brings the best results and may indicate a strong correlation between ASR and speech quality assessment. We also measure its ability on variable segment durations and speech content, exploring factors influencing its decision.
[ -0.19737114012241364, -0.5362539291381836, 0.2597765624523163, 0.15716174244880676, -0.508054256439209, 0.1788131147623062, -0.2756076455116272, -0.4966175854206085, 0.19629527628421783, 0.39500635862350464, -0.4411793351173401, -0.2505418062210083, -0.8090423941612244, -0.31460487842559814, -0.24376574158668518, 0.6195544600486755, 0.2575289011001587, 0.5130136609077454, -0.24816356599330902, -0.3706604838371277, -0.8466423749923706, -0.239166721701622, -0.6744981408119202, -0.22613288462162018, 0.17511065304279327, 0.4618263840675354, 0.32964760065078735, 0.6844056248664856, 0.5722914934158325, 0.22170303761959076, -0.09669621288776398, -0.25541940331459045, -0.30056241154670715, 0.3282625675201416, 0.15314391255378723, 0.06495315581560135, -0.3579719662666321, 0.18821260333061218, 0.582355260848999, 0.6173577904701233, -0.29479825496673584, 0.3738865256309509, 0.21063879132270813, 0.488538920879364, -0.5312604308128357, -0.015464836731553078, -0.6072061061859131, 0.03553169220685959, -0.3028065264225006, -0.055405110120773315, 0.06296098977327347, -0.22430013120174408, 0.507300615310669, -0.24952034652233124, -0.06397083401679993, -0.46529194712638855, 0.7004354596138, 0.6541972756385803, -0.23694972693920135, -0.3958401679992676, -0.7370961904525757, 0.6427537798881531, -0.4780634939670563, 0.5281997323036194, 0.5843279957771301, 0.6786026358604431, 0.36999619007110596, -0.7092103958129883, -0.1370343714952469, -0.2387075573205948, 0.3863379955291748, 0.4314505457878113, -0.3979935944080353, -0.05923930183053017, 0.09230301529169083, 0.30744853615760803, -0.7347527146339417, 0.4372543692588806, -0.6304898858070374, -0.7596646547317505, 0.5575893521308899, 0.05137631669640541, 0.14374330639839172, -0.24491651356220245, -0.33095455169677734, -0.07962531596422195, -0.37695151567459106, 0.33804553747177124, -0.0029736808501183987, 0.26785096526145935, 0.18940116465091705, 0.29890602827072144, 0.031975217163562775, 0.42821407318115234, -0.22681814432144165, -0.046587999910116196, 0.4616861045360565, -0.295693963766098, 0.026608353480696678, 0.4268590807914734, 0.9404077529907227, 0.13933460414409637, -0.08501603454351425, 0.05608579143881798, -0.004691981710493565, 0.23979125916957855, 0.3637266159057617, -0.7322453856468201, -0.3762470781803131, 0.46102362871170044, -0.4286324083805084, -0.14108891785144806, -0.05301109328866005, -0.7420698404312134, -0.2423984706401825, -0.15958616137504578, 0.4713064432144165, -0.42554357647895813, -0.42300400137901306, -0.20517437160015106, -0.11213351041078568, 0.0908198356628418, 0.16649986803531647, -0.6465675830841064, 0.420624315738678, 0.3749609589576721, 0.7762050032615662, -0.2972993552684784, 0.18003256618976593, -1.0352662801742554, -0.2602855861186981, -0.28404441475868225, 0.9796929359436035, -0.5383777618408203, -0.5397787690162659, -0.19760935008525848, -0.29377466440200806, 0.22724226117134094, -0.7005454301834106, 0.7996125817298889, -0.14779944717884064, -0.002677223179489374, -0.10134565830230713, -0.29602447152137756, 0.15533851087093353, -0.21480382978916168, -0.5433268547058105, 0.936263918876648, 0.2215154767036438, -0.3598730266094208, 0.5687575340270996, -0.4493250250816345, -0.6431423425674438, 0.3627959191799164, -0.38599687814712524, -0.4003629684448242, 0.07905220985412598, 0.046258531510829926, 0.105339415371418, -0.09313459694385529, 0.06058752164244652, -0.12228956073522568, -0.28273874521255493, 0.3222687840461731, -0.5631989240646362, 0.4235159754753113, 0.25714272260665894, -0.22906732559204102, 0.16521097719669342, -0.9691068530082703, 0.34324684739112854, -0.272743284702301, -0.46276113390922546, -0.3464438319206238, 0.0017777509056031704, 0.13236358761787415, 0.49526527523994446, -0.08869524300098419, -0.6710387468338013, -0.5492731332778931, -0.7110722064971924, 0.49294501543045044, 0.39219942688941956, 0.18955732882022858, 0.09060733765363693, -0.14272058010101318, 0.3505921959877014, -0.2619572579860687, 0.3666118085384369, 0.3309428095817566, -0.5844245553016663, -0.5174460411071777, -0.3314500153064728, 0.49518021941185, 0.5436295866966248, -0.31382879614830017, 0.4432656168937683, -0.27873703837394714, -0.482157438993454, -1.0744645595550537, -0.15498946607112885, 0.5313906669616699, 0.5175356268882751, 0.590358316898346, -0.6779664754867554, -0.4585316479206085, -0.6253945827484131, -0.02941468358039856, -0.1779235452413559, -0.364435613155365, 0.5498987436294556, 0.04234335571527481, -0.12002963572740555, 0.8101175427436829, -0.1589902937412262, -0.571359395980835, -0.07284480333328247, -0.08257731795310974, 0.06906787306070328, 0.5896074175834656, -0.316934734582901, -0.6908295750617981, -0.19741393625736237, -0.28331229090690613, -0.41149961948394775, -0.15794216096401215, 0.24166977405548096, 0.19626571238040924, -0.06283539533615112, 0.28661197423934937, -0.041150692850351334, 0.4376327097415924, 0.5453875660896301, -0.2828496992588043, 0.49663877487182617, -0.2005024403333664, 0.20140273869037628, -0.5845248699188232, -0.10081621259450912, -0.11100956052541733, -0.19154030084609985, -0.7082440257072449, -0.25392428040504456, -0.1839037835597992, -0.38644251227378845, -0.28432175517082214, 0.25792884826660156, -0.2286175936460495, -0.28109097480773926, -0.4149007201194763, 0.12493963539600372, -0.04154329374432564, 0.1396133303642273, 0.1619533747434616, 0.41460365056991577, 0.6076483726501465, -0.27190884947776794, 0.21647274494171143, 0.33438968658447266, -0.43597352504730225, 0.209174245595932, -0.8773528337478638, 0.39029231667518616, 0.32227012515068054, 0.029359659180045128, -0.9542324542999268, -0.16297253966331482, 0.08164777606725693, -0.9477866888046265, 0.46171656250953674, -0.2286762148141861, 0.0737503170967102, -0.4497738480567932, -0.11928366124629974, 0.21601836383342743, 0.8601401448249817, -0.11573808640241623, 0.4021107256412506, 0.7843972444534302, -0.4772321283817291, -0.36372441053390503, -0.6504757404327393, 0.05257478728890419, -0.11820468306541443, -0.6313863396644592, 0.23140378296375275, -0.126278355717659, -0.24518056213855743, -0.0833037793636322, -0.49662548303604126, -0.1706240326166153, 0.06651932746171951, 0.5472701191902161, 0.09381306916475296, -0.34435123205184937, 0.1594802886247635, 0.27930396795272827, -0.3934595286846161, 0.10379662364721298, -0.30855292081832886, 0.4412250816822052, 0.016460109502077103, -0.4430067539215088, -0.8015232086181641, 0.2978370785713196, 0.5557016730308533, -0.46008795499801636, -0.12339824438095093, 0.6815157532691956, -0.5135266780853271, 0.1446220427751541, -0.6939480900764465, -0.17945729196071625, -0.4296727180480957, 0.5182031989097595, -0.40399038791656494, -0.7795080542564392, 0.25067973136901855, -0.048521656543016434, -0.16684819757938385, 0.49876248836517334, 0.5859614014625549, -0.27956217527389526, 0.9088099598884583, -0.01741945929825306, 0.1266285628080368, 0.35523706674575806, -0.1472121626138687, -0.16244767606258392, -0.7514276504516602, -0.3870718777179718, -0.5114415287971497, 0.08133555203676224, -0.488931804895401, -0.6881992220878601, 0.6881113052368164, -0.00980991031974554, 0.08945677429437637, -0.08165126293897629, -0.6793389916419983, 0.15278875827789307, 0.35489150881767273, 0.44016918540000916, -0.06746753305196762, 0.07748464494943619, 0.20036548376083374, -0.24016119539737701, -0.5295442938804626, -0.4137190282344818, 1.0728046894073486, 0.5831419825553894, 0.10129446536302567, -0.01069896575063467, 0.47977715730667114, 0.372508704662323, -0.07629717886447906, -1.0046521425247192, 0.19604730606079102, -0.43334075808525085, -0.264676958322525, -0.7614590525627136, -0.36094775795936584, -0.8431978225708008, 0.1125761941075325, -0.32797732949256897, -0.5504199266433716, 0.3536103069782257, 0.010536499321460724, -0.851263701915741, -0.3697027862071991, -0.23733681440353394, 0.6771063208580017, -0.24047112464904785, -0.35045984387397766, -0.48527732491493225, -0.9610813856124878, -0.00515237171202898, -0.10624449700117111, 0.34450462460517883, -0.22776174545288086, 0.16285201907157898, 1.1769949197769165, -0.5114819407463074, 0.21206878125667572, -0.47431355714797974, 0.30719539523124695, 0.38550326228141785, -0.07098375260829926, 0.2510509192943573, 0.17414630949497223, -0.2694590985774994, 0.39422744512557983, 0.02442510426044464, -0.4304240345954895, -0.6288671493530273, 0.5452665090560913, -0.8525254130363464, -0.3884925842285156, -0.2538083493709564, -0.1347191035747528, -0.6945248246192932, -0.08807066828012466, 0.32670673727989197, 0.9033045172691345, -0.20162765681743622, 0.09173513203859329, 0.7351819276809692, -0.23403623700141907, 0.0940207913517952, 0.5357367396354675, 0.4863799810409546, -0.6248401403427124, 1.1976207494735718, 0.2229551076889038, 0.28340986371040344, -0.12487110495567322, 0.5976153016090393, -0.3916822075843811, -1.0512956380844116, -0.47506096959114075, -0.08040902763605118, -0.468344509601593, -0.013818169943988323, -0.7139186859130859, -0.48936763405799866, -0.4714999198913574, 0.25286632776260376, -0.671802282333374, -0.2984706461429596, -0.3851354122161865, -0.05677966773509979, 0.18441534042358398, 0.45043596625328064, -0.2829960286617279, 0.003958866000175476, -0.5976021885871887, 0.2542628347873688, 0.5035767555236816, 0.16159220039844513, -0.2581155002117157, -0.9696430563926697, -0.1052498072385788, 0.01743864081799984, -0.09357310086488724, -0.5789323449134827, 0.4409294128417969, 0.34084945917129517, 0.48657649755477905, 0.4900369644165039, -0.07625623792409897, 0.7118701338768005, -0.4171389639377594, 0.8407987952232361, 0.3392173945903778, -0.8323628306388855, 0.8637058138847351, 0.11098739504814148, 0.09335853904485703, 0.9921566843986511, 0.11591687053442001, -0.29935333132743835, -0.5269842743873596, -0.7377835512161255, -0.9869691133499146, 0.5539014339447021, 0.3081659972667694, -0.16392096877098083, 0.3054760992527008, 0.21571175754070282, 0.2177930325269699, -0.1977570652961731, -0.010496559552848339, -0.1193392425775528, -0.6697919964790344, -0.08806437999010086, -0.1394682377576828, -0.3811188340187073, -0.07527070492506027, -0.4122432470321655, 0.5630553960800171, 0.07674998044967651, 0.4397730827331543, 0.3612463176250458, -0.019481822848320007, -0.07532617449760437, 0.25425320863723755, 0.2411559671163559, 0.480302631855011, -0.2883511483669281, -0.02283739112317562, 0.190078005194664, -0.7609126567840576, 0.19549354910850525, 0.4282158315181732, 0.2863762676715851, 0.08038279414176941, 0.4401463568210602, 0.9208014011383057, -0.1122262254357338, -0.8069528341293335, 0.9171988368034363, -0.11977784335613251, -0.13548707962036133, -0.39021074771881104, 0.07790814340114594, -0.1207587942481041, 0.2081090211868286, 0.284254252910614, 0.14182357490062714, 0.5349411964416504, -0.2646838128566742, 0.5421574711799622, 0.1886538565158844, -1.3320530652999878, -0.1893187314271927, 0.49576643109321594, 0.3109185993671417, -0.4853720963001251, 0.9267800450325012, -0.10281756520271301, -0.20377042889595032, 0.4604676067829132, 0.27131134271621704, 0.6474928259849548, -0.4833432137966156, 0.004796153865754604, 0.33706390857696533, 0.02933441661298275, 0.17346860468387604, 0.3204127550125122, -0.13674761354923248, -0.41810372471809387, -0.29378682374954224, -0.7657579779624939, -0.22057412564754486, 0.21963997185230255, -1.0181266069412231, 0.1600729376077652, -0.344928115606308, -0.10418800264596939, 0.20449335873126984, 0.20826846361160278, -0.40659981966018677, 0.4425431787967682, 0.42732077836990356, 0.7592161297798157, -0.7884817719459534, 1.0518237352371216, 0.3459080457687378, -0.3354802131652832, -0.9918765425682068, 0.14958156645298004, 0.17341119050979614, -0.9006630182266235, 0.40306705236434937, 0.08718302845954895, -0.13000646233558655, -0.07381609827280045, -0.019745131954550743, -0.895514190196991, 0.9683793783187866, 0.16732487082481384, -0.6610324382781982, 0.2908211946487427, -0.05008341744542122, 0.7742136120796204, 0.02359970286488533, 0.3242982029914856, 0.7951264977455139, 0.28508880734443665, 0.4569259285926819, -1.072935938835144, 0.0813804492354393, -0.31965333223342896, -0.14696848392486572, -0.1275281459093094, -0.3421095907688141, 0.21419182419776917, -0.3223339021205902, -0.39093685150146484, 0.004230665508657694, 0.6572257876396179, 0.28108352422714233, 0.5549055337905884, 0.5889773964881897, 0.23364445567131042, 1.0063825845718384, 0.0011467726435512304, 0.696422278881073, -0.06819333881139755, 0.14119280874729156, 0.8567814826965332, -0.19381530582904816, 0.9180305600166321, 0.3372202515602112, -0.2415919303894043, 0.3931524157524109, 0.7437163591384888, -0.09169851988554001, 0.7238699197769165, 0.4283429980278015, -0.24395427107810974, -0.37902626395225525, -0.37088462710380554, -0.30800631642341614, 0.7827654480934143, 0.4907618761062622, -0.17706793546676636, 0.19469814002513885, 0.37551769614219666, -0.3678439259529114, -0.0716160461306572, -0.19418002665042877, 1.0965681076049805, 0.14573803544044495, -0.38166993856430054, 0.6167479157447815, -0.3283584415912628, 0.3968736231327057, -0.5833975076675415, 0.02359449677169323, -0.04384930804371834, -0.13495254516601562, -0.08665511757135391, -0.6298854351043701, 0.5159045457839966, 0.026527520269155502, -0.1275845319032669, -0.08202225714921951, 0.6859177350997925, -0.23051321506500244, -0.42891496419906616, 0.2657517194747925, 0.3870627284049988, 0.5280411243438721, -0.2201985865831375, -0.6137256622314453, 0.12382007390260696, -0.14949151873588562, -0.09884516894817352, 0.42576834559440613, 0.01807435043156147, 0.14182455837726593, 0.4189871847629547, 0.5209519267082214, 0.42245757579803467, -0.37315866351127625, 0.24205951392650604, 0.693519651889801, -0.29794928431510925, -0.4640054404735565, -0.640746533870697, 0.49675309658050537, -0.09200825542211533, -0.4297310709953308, 0.17912925779819489, 0.5086949467658997, 0.29873037338256836, 0.5850261449813843, 0.7376444935798645, 0.17091283202171326, 0.7209173440933228, -0.5576102137565613, 0.8564406037330627, -0.4725329875946045, 0.21710774302482605, -0.23597824573516846, -0.23455128073692322, -0.21564169228076935, 0.5467069745063782, -0.2902066707611084, -0.2256084829568863, 0.5555692315101624, 0.6378225684165955, 0.12429305911064148, 0.10163693875074387, 0.5159310102462769, 0.43123501539230347, 0.2768315076828003, 0.6973089575767517, 0.9367722272872925, -0.30183878540992737, 0.6897276043891907, -0.043026138097047806, -0.6972756385803223, 0.009582108817994595, -0.10610655695199966, -0.39581945538520813, -0.6244359016418457, -0.45131897926330566, -0.6203504800796509, 0.34382835030555725, 0.9939125776290894, 0.8092355132102966, -0.745856761932373, 0.015466367825865746, 0.13529983162879944, -0.2242833971977234, -0.4277290403842926, -0.14002034068107605, 0.8102424740791321, 0.058132898062467575, -0.16445888578891754, 0.8251433968544006, 0.4080672562122345, -0.15797853469848633, -0.056183867156505585, -0.044017139822244644, 0.4140535295009613, -0.07886064052581787, 0.3623466193675995, 0.14296701550483704, -0.6615737080574036, -0.1872951239347458, -0.3199651539325714, -0.05840843543410301, 0.2599191963672638, 0.6962893009185791, -0.9506477117538452, 0.6624866724014282, 0.19027987122535706, 0.4524320065975189, 0.43790748715400696, 0.052932772785425186, 0.3445488214492798, -0.3370139002799988, -0.1963125765323639, 0.8894824981689453, 0.07421630620956421, 0.326747328042984, -0.31293773651123047, 0.03385750949382782, 0.3114233911037445, -0.4571526348590851, -0.8311933875083923, -0.07167357206344604, -1.1295658349990845, -0.2663436532020569, 1.3818074464797974, -0.1781240701675415, 0.1103101298213005, -0.5030825734138489, -0.01854078099131584, 0.42623040080070496, -0.48565787076950073, 0.5154969692230225, 0.1264081597328186, -0.4180413782596588, 0.17702950537204742, -0.6668412089347839, 0.6823869347572327, 0.20981848239898682, -0.6157848834991455, 0.013816066086292267, 0.45470401644706726, 0.5962876081466675, 0.04415443539619446, 0.6506489515304565, -0.2643372714519501, 0.6046587228775024, 0.19721804559230804, -0.07691863924264908, -0.22705821692943573, -0.20544017851352692, -0.7817094326019287, 0.3164350688457489, 0.056691452860832214, -0.354728639125824 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20180v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20180v1
Measuring Taiwanese Mandarin Language Understanding
2024-03-29T13:56:21
2024-03-29T13:56:21
Po-Heng Chen, Sijia Cheng, Wei-Lin Chen, Yen-Ting Lin, Yun-Nung Chen
cs.CL
cs.CL
The evaluation of large language models (LLMs) has drawn substantial attention in the field recently. This work focuses on evaluating LLMs in a Chinese context, specifically, for Traditional Chinese which has been largely underrepresented in existing benchmarks. We present TMLU, a holistic evaluation suit tailored for assessing the advanced knowledge and reasoning capability in LLMs, under the context of Taiwanese Mandarin. TMLU consists of an array of 37 subjects across social science, STEM, humanities, Taiwan-specific content, and others, ranging from middle school to professional levels. In addition, we curate chain-of-thought-like few-shot explanations for each subject to facilitate the evaluation of complex reasoning skills. To establish a comprehensive baseline, we conduct extensive experiments and analysis on 24 advanced LLMs. The results suggest that Chinese open-weight models demonstrate inferior performance comparing to multilingual proprietary ones, and open-weight models tailored for Taiwanese Mandarin lag behind the Simplified-Chinese counterparts. The findings indicate great headrooms for improvement, and emphasize the goal of TMLU to foster the development of localized Taiwanese-Mandarin LLMs. We release the benchmark and evaluation scripts for the community to promote future research.
[ 0.18349330127239227, -0.999872624874115, 0.708616316318512, 0.433548241853714, -0.5131169557571411, 0.3571988642215729, -0.7156766057014465, -0.1235082820057869, -0.2825241982936859, 0.34024670720100403, 0.04239773750305176, -0.6079093217849731, -0.4498661756515503, 0.11111579090356827, -0.07625202089548111, 0.2698823809623718, -0.24876122176647186, 0.3580937385559082, 0.1678604781627655, -0.25000134110450745, -0.5534219145774841, -0.21623922884464264, -0.9508582353591919, -0.6781687140464783, 0.28979727625846863, 0.3261731266975403, 0.625954806804657, 0.3000342547893524, 0.2322295606136322, 0.20850470662117004, -0.40524056553840637, 0.33674049377441406, -0.7299621105194092, -0.3839850425720215, -0.1198326051235199, -0.43481338024139404, -0.6170849800109863, 0.070272296667099, 0.9250769019126892, 0.6816651225090027, -0.07665220648050308, 0.1662977784872055, 0.14841404557228088, 0.4108118712902069, -0.3554035425186157, 0.1627366989850998, -0.47195374965667725, 0.3461199700832367, -0.17977730929851532, -0.2791604697704315, -0.7550938129425049, -0.41407763957977295, 0.25788766145706177, -0.6170215010643005, -0.3697951138019562, -0.002883685054257512, 0.7464195489883423, -0.035629868507385254, -0.799570620059967, 0.2172783613204956, -0.64349365234375, 0.891056478023529, -0.7989996075630188, 0.5493259429931641, 0.009138896130025387, 0.3256683051586151, -0.14579558372497559, -0.5145070552825928, -0.3604324162006378, -0.6958985924720764, -0.12419974058866501, 0.2632061243057251, -0.23436222970485687, 0.11548931151628494, 0.07044017314910889, 0.488523930311203, -0.8959046006202698, 0.28526467084884644, -0.305734783411026, 0.10471639782190323, 0.5777140259742737, 0.249968484044075, 0.4641555845737457, -0.20604778826236725, -0.4158640503883362, 0.37959328293800354, -0.6822690367698669, 0.08853566646575928, -0.2062174379825592, 0.19866102933883667, -0.30368831753730774, 0.5557685494422913, 0.14102773368358612, 0.8114253878593445, -0.025105994194746017, -0.26453787088394165, 0.023700052872300148, -0.5986698865890503, -0.5989571809768677, -0.050417885184288025, 0.7746837139129639, 0.18640686571598053, 0.5152003765106201, -0.36564910411834717, -0.2285912036895752, -0.4768555462360382, -0.1541842371225357, -0.5479253530502319, -0.05581146106123924, 0.12378642708063126, -0.5631373524665833, -0.0598142184317112, 0.021966230124235153, -0.0015894521493464708, -0.3947828412055969, -0.38033413887023926, 0.39283281564712524, -0.4139459729194641, -0.7541697025299072, 0.1568979173898697, -0.2106407731771469, 0.6677086353302002, 0.5017925500869751, -0.4138406217098236, 0.16193640232086182, 0.820457398891449, 0.8802074193954468, -0.6006622314453125, -0.48946988582611084, -0.24637560546398163, 0.29177749156951904, -0.5472411513328552, 0.4544857144355774, -0.3702127933502197, -0.3913618326187134, -0.31100907921791077, 0.0013303834712132812, -0.2797095477581024, -0.6844038367271423, 0.5706217288970947, -0.22310923039913177, 0.12264502048492432, -0.15420864522457123, -0.5466352105140686, -0.22635656595230103, 0.5285125374794006, -0.5068473219871521, 1.0514122247695923, 0.39650094509124756, -0.5287396311759949, 0.23197698593139648, -0.4757708013057709, -0.4757491648197174, 0.46499425172805786, -0.1613585352897644, -0.11101559549570084, 0.1331036388874054, 0.05530282482504845, 0.3916093111038208, -0.3251016438007355, 0.8597204685211182, -0.28212717175483704, -0.7455654740333557, 0.03541051223874092, -0.49543291330337524, 1.23128080368042, 0.025889644399285316, -0.35248199105262756, 0.4235750734806061, -0.3092920780181885, -0.0033866807352751493, 0.33018049597740173, -0.6011302471160889, -0.23968343436717987, -0.3220139443874359, 0.08746550977230072, -0.060810189694166183, 0.42694729566574097, -0.49791765213012695, 0.017870966345071793, -0.22529789805412292, 0.840553879737854, 0.6676340103149414, -0.354295015335083, 0.4088120758533478, -0.08998168259859085, 0.39896461367607117, 0.08940407633781433, 0.21298016607761383, 0.019999392330646515, -0.23331019282341003, -0.7268799543380737, 0.07488354295492172, 0.12731856107711792, 0.3849271535873413, -0.6461039185523987, 0.32068049907684326, -0.3269985318183899, -0.6734910607337952, -0.3971913456916809, 0.18309155106544495, 0.3294666111469269, 0.520420253276825, 0.21641717851161957, -0.17356203496456146, -0.2523474097251892, -0.6366490721702576, -0.36502307653427124, -0.44127950072288513, -0.2237745225429535, 0.520139217376709, 0.1195623129606247, -0.019181042909622192, 0.42377373576164246, -0.1978559046983719, -0.09775831550359726, -0.7382055521011353, -0.25153231620788574, 0.17704220116138458, 0.18302710354328156, 0.4863812327384949, -0.5343571305274963, -0.4189785420894623, 0.4021865129470825, -0.9098134636878967, 0.10349693149328232, 0.03324202075600624, -0.2628147602081299, 0.23601070046424866, 0.3834019899368286, -0.6966866850852966, 0.15806569159030914, 0.44342297315597534, -0.5260041952133179, 0.8203081488609314, -0.19790732860565186, 0.11622682213783264, -0.8022041916847229, 0.0064789592288434505, 0.1685037612915039, -0.1753137856721878, -0.7943795323371887, 0.4373728632926941, 0.18719011545181274, -0.09467234462499619, -0.607404887676239, 0.7162438631057739, -0.38044625520706177, -0.16869425773620605, -0.0071489387191832066, 0.726709246635437, 0.26623669266700745, 0.31248903274536133, 0.2622342109680176, 0.5343731045722961, 0.12699809670448303, -0.3916681110858917, 0.5015267729759216, -0.2730344533920288, -0.36398258805274963, 0.2758147716522217, -0.827335000038147, 0.057134322822093964, 0.16498339176177979, 0.3269587755203247, -0.9098744988441467, 0.023287571966648102, 0.009005840867757797, -0.29842063784599304, 0.3140278458595276, 0.2149663120508194, -0.33991488814353943, -0.33207276463508606, -0.14906296133995056, 0.3935695290565491, 0.2167736440896988, -0.4389975070953369, 0.8800774812698364, 0.1987893134355545, 0.3292398154735565, -0.4771938621997833, -0.6381032466888428, 0.2272975742816925, -0.42733699083328247, -0.6877704858779907, 0.06543644517660141, 0.054589446634054184, -0.5787521004676819, -0.08656489849090576, -0.12266703695058823, -0.18961985409259796, 0.5062248706817627, -0.37231287360191345, 0.23961570858955383, -0.9229467511177063, 0.25295567512512207, -0.009284586645662785, 0.23837578296661377, 0.285969614982605, -0.3773263990879059, 0.3902687430381775, -0.393827348947525, -0.18032607436180115, -0.28491079807281494, -0.24542850255966187, 0.41153770685195923, -0.32443496584892273, 0.3881914019584656, 0.8379840850830078, -0.42547106742858887, -0.07913751155138016, -0.4618002772331238, 0.1696893274784088, -0.4021378457546234, 0.6838899254798889, -0.44155532121658325, -0.9080976247787476, 0.23897255957126617, 0.12843871116638184, 0.34305793046951294, 0.3595774471759796, 0.6642459630966187, 0.15163715183734894, 0.5811350345611572, 0.37535354495048523, -0.2401713728904724, 0.2849513590335846, 0.051805488765239716, 0.264425665140152, -0.6658781170845032, -0.24674898386001587, -0.2866733968257904, -0.0779985561966896, -0.3756420612335205, -0.7283874750137329, 0.22354307770729065, 0.2333301305770874, -0.5679013729095459, 0.25289052724838257, -0.20195329189300537, 0.44257283210754395, 0.3580425977706909, 0.3357008397579193, 0.7551229000091553, -0.3845716714859009, -0.0013346490450203419, 0.14039647579193115, -0.5622105598449707, -0.7374305129051208, 0.919649600982666, 0.6448953747749329, 0.6036907434463501, 0.33800163865089417, 0.35075628757476807, 0.05604274943470955, 0.31261858344078064, -1.1099916696548462, 0.5919404625892639, -0.4077749252319336, -0.2785645127296448, -0.7003446817398071, -0.6017772555351257, -0.6684364080429077, 0.5369775891304016, 0.18749834597110748, -0.4853903353214264, -0.5713474154472351, -0.0834835022687912, -0.13521774113178253, 0.4545571506023407, -0.8437212109565735, 0.9949349164962769, -0.5930630564689636, 0.010011705569922924, -0.4462076425552368, -0.20833557844161987, 0.9644548892974854, -0.16393785178661346, -0.05264556407928467, -0.3378450274467468, -0.08999474346637726, 0.5831988453865051, 0.020169906318187714, 0.5482276678085327, -0.1265401393175125, -0.23390427231788635, 0.26435983180999756, 0.11112163960933685, -0.08218436688184738, 0.11624433845281601, -0.34593483805656433, 0.3008478581905365, -0.1656257063150406, -0.575188159942627, -0.5738230347633362, 0.5353650450706482, -0.8164350390434265, -0.8980984091758728, 0.06595120579004288, -0.4840187430381775, -0.039129696786403656, 0.27335163950920105, -0.12453523278236389, 0.01025890652090311, -0.5276154279708862, 0.07060621678829193, 0.7275825142860413, -0.6504238843917847, 0.39249393343925476, 0.6984919905662537, -0.2675011157989502, -0.06097671389579773, 0.7135704755783081, -0.04285849258303642, 0.5028318762779236, 0.6121551990509033, 0.8095827102661133, -0.1636360138654709, -0.553634524345398, -0.7356969118118286, 0.2705806791782379, -0.6095385551452637, 0.2102097123861313, -0.2902158796787262, -0.45214056968688965, -0.3047821819782257, 0.08961133658885956, -0.08915573358535767, -0.27296388149261475, -0.3593578040599823, -0.29739782214164734, -0.11090311408042908, 0.9265309572219849, 0.5073164701461792, 0.16106368601322174, -0.7290837168693542, 0.13975144922733307, 0.08401211351156235, 0.14326384663581848, 0.574416995048523, -0.8868749737739563, -0.29511892795562744, -0.15391269326210022, -0.42115649580955505, -0.5262643694877625, 0.08555389195680618, 0.23451875150203705, 0.7623815536499023, 0.5154504179954529, -0.09222106635570526, 0.8552483916282654, -0.35936635732650757, 0.9840732216835022, -0.008719257079064846, -1.294619083404541, 0.6103183627128601, -0.33370304107666016, 0.4582561254501343, 0.07088427990674973, 0.1262575387954712, -0.6247808933258057, -0.6702479124069214, -0.4127526879310608, -0.4114912748336792, 0.543797492980957, -0.06943894922733307, 0.10149186104536057, 0.2946012318134308, 0.39504387974739075, -0.15000662207603455, -0.08624795079231262, -1.1390243768692017, -0.261074960231781, 0.03123592399060726, -0.013231907039880753, -0.09439204633235931, -0.09978634864091873, 0.18564598262310028, -0.43202322721481323, 0.3478601276874542, -0.08082129806280136, -0.1852208375930786, 0.050529416650533676, -0.2695452570915222, -0.2333521991968155, 0.39590245485305786, 0.6741018295288086, 1.0482323169708252, -0.082399882376194, 0.20843523740768433, 0.5652837157249451, -0.4753834009170532, 0.011766837909817696, -0.21211491525173187, 0.06784870475530624, 0.11640402674674988, 0.7799758315086365, 0.7470831871032715, 0.14732226729393005, -0.8117126822471619, 0.4423754811286926, -0.23201368749141693, -0.0046829222701489925, -0.24575242400169373, 0.00007950072176754475, 0.35558924078941345, 0.16898326575756073, 0.4073370695114136, -0.5829742550849915, -0.0029676828999072313, -0.5755297541618347, -0.03226630017161369, 0.3159175515174866, -0.5415264368057251, -0.41183677315711975, 0.5013189315795898, 0.2208263874053955, -0.1625261753797531, 0.633403480052948, -0.027391528710722923, -0.5694634318351746, 0.7528496980667114, 0.49962276220321655, 0.7868843674659729, -0.4704056978225708, 0.10177693516016006, 0.4285988509654999, 0.6462990641593933, 0.0446685291826725, 0.28155744075775146, -0.014199666678905487, -0.7236083745956421, -0.5535709261894226, -0.4785292148590088, -0.5163875222206116, 0.25969207286834717, -0.4661113917827606, 0.511229932308197, -0.406086266040802, 0.1473371386528015, -0.29479777812957764, 0.25299251079559326, -0.3184725046157837, 0.07314804941415787, 0.30173808336257935, 1.2387802600860596, -0.7420362234115601, 1.0705337524414062, 0.687206506729126, -0.11678216606378555, -1.2424687147140503, 0.02968415804207325, -0.11806193739175797, -1.1883801221847534, 0.7127217650413513, 0.19200268387794495, -0.0033823284320533276, -0.26405924558639526, -0.11873559653759003, -0.5661421418190002, 1.1103266477584839, 0.47992056608200073, -0.47595006227493286, -0.3107752203941345, 0.26048025488853455, 0.6899378299713135, -0.2894566059112549, 0.6330291032791138, 1.1104944944381714, 0.5929766297340393, -0.12236586958169937, -1.3096377849578857, 0.16909122467041016, 0.04816962033510208, -0.07387756556272507, -0.03071528486907482, -0.9562557339668274, 0.8355687856674194, -0.32837536931037903, -0.14407069981098175, -0.03851558640599251, 0.5911454558372498, 0.6761556267738342, 0.4646800458431244, 0.43406030535697937, 0.4532085061073303, 0.7214276790618896, -0.28728780150413513, 0.614040195941925, -0.015365456230938435, 0.2767609655857086, 1.0144098997116089, -0.09972177445888519, 0.9024279117584229, 0.28084078431129456, -0.31380897760391235, 0.24565044045448303, 0.9815860986709595, 0.1174248680472374, -0.11851721256971359, 0.4704316258430481, -0.16533075273036957, -0.3262951970100403, -0.40994203090667725, -0.04452366381883621, 0.4846016466617584, 0.5341896414756775, -0.30021655559539795, -0.2456296682357788, -0.13212467730045319, 0.05187563598155975, -0.015804437920451164, -0.6422587633132935, 0.6619492173194885, 0.5692086219787598, -0.6290745139122009, 0.7872632145881653, 0.03688621148467064, 0.45073840022087097, -0.11017774045467377, 0.07550181448459625, -0.34420084953308105, 0.07502151280641556, -0.31219473481178284, -1.1077593564987183, 0.13227233290672302, -0.03098585084080696, 0.35145536065101624, 0.058555830270051956, 0.5717049837112427, -0.5486552119255066, -0.29957982897758484, 0.5637704730033875, 0.6033165454864502, 0.28810250759124756, 0.19370779395103455, -0.6932947635650635, 0.0005877246148884296, 0.13607262074947357, -0.30218586325645447, -0.014894735999405384, 0.8460054397583008, -0.18306151032447815, 0.6619959473609924, -0.0489107221364975, 0.09002450853586197, -0.1660132259130478, 0.5287761688232422, 0.5694130063056946, -0.8418861031532288, -0.09160415083169937, -1.1474025249481201, 0.2824159264564514, 0.15756317973136902, -0.45590540766716003, 0.8978140354156494, 0.6335554718971252, 0.9805940389633179, 0.14598646759986877, 0.6739717721939087, 0.3469153344631195, 0.128470316529274, -0.4739229083061218, 0.6732139587402344, -0.6766847372055054, 0.3054339289665222, -0.17251040041446686, -0.7447499632835388, -0.20487424731254578, 0.2868134677410126, -0.40043389797210693, -0.055603932589292526, 0.580497682094574, 0.21216604113578796, -0.004999829456210136, 0.07139365375041962, 0.6319747567176819, 0.3587009012699127, 0.2936696708202362, 1.0137174129486084, 0.9559323787689209, -0.2797672152519226, 0.5556455254554749, -0.10075584053993225, -0.295828253030777, 0.008030329830944538, -0.6810988187789917, -1.2919574975967407, -0.055274464190006256, -0.08486365526914597, -0.2661668360233307, -0.09487330168485641, 0.7809001207351685, 0.4826112985610962, -0.6467843055725098, -0.711903989315033, 0.209918811917305, 0.5003063678741455, -0.002163222059607506, -0.281394362449646, 0.49557843804359436, -0.21078643202781677, -0.7277634143829346, 0.406216561794281, 0.44665348529815674, 0.05015129595994949, -0.6103341579437256, -0.28059443831443787, 0.22387027740478516, -0.16907502710819244, 0.9873771667480469, -0.172517791390419, -1.288237452507019, -0.20357151329517365, 0.2884831726551056, -0.20127780735492706, 0.2037522941827774, 0.7538983225822449, -0.5035601258277893, 0.27635088562965393, 0.40229323506355286, 0.583454430103302, 0.27734407782554626, -0.04917382076382637, 0.8066058158874512, -0.442699670791626, -0.053365133702754974, 0.22543253004550934, 0.5978691577911377, 0.22620181739330292, -0.35022568702697754, 0.6310555338859558, 0.015544109977781773, -0.42522498965263367, -0.8624776601791382, -0.046394988894462585, -0.9905568957328796, -0.3667236268520355, 1.176647424697876, -0.5447192788124084, -0.18764561414718628, -0.14924104511737823, -0.053035423159599304, 0.3483438789844513, -0.21698974072933197, 0.49507421255111694, 0.7953781485557556, -0.05614679306745529, -0.42260047793388367, -0.4488496780395508, 0.0639258548617363, 0.3840806782245636, -0.7357651591300964, 0.294022798538208, 0.09560594707727432, 0.3002749979496002, -0.21420349180698395, 0.6503639221191406, -0.0768636167049408, 0.42293837666511536, -0.44850221276283264, -0.2847554385662079, 0.19429607689380646, -0.01255941390991211, -0.5683280825614929, -0.2252996563911438, 0.6083097457885742, 0.3457970917224884 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08664v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08664v1
Identifying Banking Transaction Descriptions via Support Vector Machine Short-Text Classification Based on a Specialized Labelled Corpus
2024-03-29T13:15:46
2024-03-29T13:15:46
Silvia García-Méndez, Milagros Fernández-Gavilanes, Jonathan Juncal-Martínez, Francisco J. González-Castaño, Oscar Barba Seara
cs.IR
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CE, cs.CL, cs.LG
Short texts are omnipresent in real-time news, social network commentaries, etc. Traditional text representation methods have been successfully applied to self-contained documents of medium size. However, information in short texts is often insufficient, due, for example, to the use of mnemonics, which makes them hard to classify. Therefore, the particularities of specific domains must be exploited. In this article we describe a novel system that combines Natural Language Processing techniques with Machine Learning algorithms to classify banking transaction descriptions for personal finance management, a problem that was not previously considered in the literature. We trained and tested that system on a labelled dataset with real customer transactions that will be available to other researchers on request. Motivated by existing solutions in spam detection, we also propose a short text similarity detector to reduce training set size based on the Jaccard distance. Experimental results with a two-stage classifier combining this detector with a SVM indicate a high accuracy in comparison with alternative approaches, taking into account complexity and computing time. Finally, we present a use case with a personal finance application, CoinScrap, which is available at Google Play and App Store.
[ -0.23927417397499084, -0.8206451535224915, 0.3837948143482208, 0.21231241524219513, -0.6384511590003967, 0.40210214257240295, -0.0790732279419899, -0.8273215889930725, 0.4584856629371643, 1.04520845413208, -0.24265480041503906, -0.6154119968414307, -0.5932142734527588, 0.11657046526670456, -0.6362380981445312, 1.1604673862457275, 0.037161361426115036, -0.04562043026089668, -0.4155670702457428, -0.22037605941295624, -0.37941327691078186, -0.7378791570663452, -0.7179017663002014, -0.3235553503036499, 0.1470753401517868, 0.3309980034828186, 0.34661930799484253, 0.43195465207099915, 0.6101571321487427, 0.4297392666339874, -0.07627955824136734, 0.19999073445796967, 0.08458871394395828, 0.003577077528461814, 0.004221503157168627, -0.47016608715057373, -0.20789700746536255, -0.3669533431529999, 0.4221844971179962, 0.3444834351539612, 0.061919040977954865, 0.22081631422042847, 0.2569144666194916, 0.6487438082695007, -0.36767709255218506, 0.2532580494880676, -0.09922304004430771, -0.016047628596425056, -0.47276607155799866, -0.29162806272506714, -0.22486522793769836, -0.41262736916542053, 0.3624953031539917, -0.19363246858119965, 0.2612868547439575, 0.2942357361316681, 0.8086053729057312, -0.22628989815711975, -0.443215012550354, -0.6629712581634521, -0.7743733525276184, 0.662760317325592, -0.26885485649108887, 0.10783806443214417, 0.34291893243789673, 0.6004761457443237, -0.08999605476856232, -0.5042553544044495, -0.18009299039840698, 0.012340014800429344, -0.5358220934867859, -0.2659287750720978, -0.20918171107769012, -0.01536098588258028, 0.11033071577548981, 0.0013571818126365542, -0.5594226121902466, 0.12226550281047821, -0.5878525972366333, -0.49316102266311646, 0.2597019076347351, 0.2202734649181366, -0.3249528706073761, -0.19513022899627686, -0.6371665000915527, -0.09788919240236282, -0.1977134644985199, 0.38499632477760315, 0.383884072303772, 0.4081264138221741, -0.03245999291539192, 0.31851452589035034, -0.17938938736915588, 0.8019748330116272, -0.20448249578475952, -0.304156631231308, 0.1008230596780777, -0.0817088782787323, -0.41642382740974426, 0.3578161597251892, 0.5817270874977112, 0.10091667622327805, -0.004262879025191069, 0.01465703547000885, -0.4738856554031372, -0.19953007996082306, 0.16522395610809326, -0.630052387714386, 0.06856243312358856, -0.15889111161231995, -0.6690961718559265, -0.5284748673439026, 0.16715821623802185, -0.7102292776107788, -0.4378654956817627, -0.30120033025741577, 0.3135049343109131, -0.24791288375854492, 0.2909644544124603, -0.04058176279067993, -0.21856960654258728, 0.03978768736124039, 0.11801828444004059, -0.7407985329627991, 0.7767233848571777, 0.9188919067382812, 0.941163957118988, -0.06223289668560028, 0.1441689431667328, -0.64581698179245, 0.38213828206062317, 0.07118658721446991, 0.9362908005714417, -0.3989187777042389, -0.500866174697876, -0.06298436224460602, -0.06379330158233643, 0.14748822152614594, -0.7410745620727539, 0.6867499351501465, -0.617274820804596, 0.13454513251781464, 0.06761155277490616, -0.8225783705711365, 0.007311076857149601, 0.627508282661438, -0.5486500859260559, 0.689099907875061, 0.34718048572540283, -0.760231614112854, 0.15457232296466827, -0.5214268565177917, -0.671628475189209, 0.48477452993392944, 0.017780885100364685, -0.8944738507270813, -0.021960776299238205, -0.18027333915233612, 0.6350231766700745, -0.39168816804885864, -0.12404901534318924, -0.224455788731575, -0.6579505205154419, 0.7622087597846985, -0.22589732706546783, 0.41360101103782654, 0.21089878678321838, -0.035110194236040115, -0.08715879172086716, -0.8384369015693665, -0.40308886766433716, 0.10881160944700241, -0.2512379586696625, -1.0165624618530273, -0.2349310666322708, 0.19323588907718658, -0.13454730808734894, 0.48305055499076843, -0.3277052044868469, 0.20047679543495178, -0.4394819438457489, 0.5380138158798218, 0.7200116515159607, -0.03708050400018692, 0.5146872401237488, -0.24847973883152008, 0.5309234261512756, 0.32135093212127686, 0.28727400302886963, -0.18953245878219604, -0.39117631316185, -0.505123496055603, -0.30422601103782654, 0.5739242434501648, 0.6943559050559998, -0.387359619140625, 0.47182464599609375, -0.11052305996417999, -0.2691219449043274, -0.037952084094285965, 0.25004032254219055, 0.3282817304134369, 0.7201541662216187, 0.36288052797317505, -0.5142642259597778, -0.4198353588581085, -1.1600720882415771, -0.5721935629844666, -0.14751917123794556, -0.021072683855891228, 0.4259113073348999, 0.28043919801712036, -0.6097931861877441, 1.0043320655822754, -0.8536834716796875, -0.6684951186180115, -0.0010007797973230481, 0.5153809189796448, 0.19337421655654907, 0.3136225938796997, 0.7085240483283997, -0.946418285369873, -0.41018179059028625, 0.08938777446746826, -0.03882497921586037, 0.11756595224142075, -0.47870373725891113, -0.004777506459504366, 0.17480811476707458, 0.20939403772354126, -0.34838032722473145, 0.5127592086791992, 0.12062572687864304, -0.5371163487434387, 0.23564496636390686, -0.4923412799835205, 0.15735463798046112, -1.1121494770050049, -0.27379199862480164, 0.44622159004211426, -0.6477856040000916, -0.5910856127738953, -0.6910512447357178, 0.26326417922973633, 0.07917150110006332, -0.0876808911561966, 0.589684784412384, -0.08730849623680115, -0.32330775260925293, -0.615826427936554, 0.08269601315259933, -0.14881375432014465, 0.34933337569236755, -0.004348207730799913, 0.24114669859409332, 0.42103666067123413, -0.7632740139961243, 0.4455510079860687, 0.1957867294549942, -0.3848455548286438, 0.6544421315193176, -0.30836302042007446, -0.09040883928537369, 0.0371384359896183, 0.20871610939502716, -0.946107804775238, -0.09195055812597275, 0.7277715802192688, -0.3767387270927429, 0.25798216462135315, -0.3543446362018585, -0.379168301820755, -0.629346489906311, -0.12400930374860764, 0.23774904012680054, 0.6253904700279236, -0.5022116303443909, 0.7751575708389282, 0.17685472965240479, -0.16950538754463196, -0.4469325542449951, -0.8055622577667236, 0.059062324464321136, -0.49102988839149475, -0.45926058292388916, 0.3638927936553955, 0.34663060307502747, 0.033435139805078506, 0.08796021342277527, -0.1802230328321457, -0.42610040307044983, 0.40619051456451416, 0.3106708228588104, 0.5307618975639343, 0.05202304571866989, 0.27680131793022156, 0.22647686302661896, -0.3195423185825348, 0.07650258392095566, -0.4551798105239868, 0.2994246184825897, -0.13418027758598328, -0.06668595969676971, -0.38135862350463867, 0.28576067090034485, 0.12887157499790192, -0.1662766933441162, 0.6543119549751282, 0.5807222127914429, -0.384971022605896, -0.17124953866004944, -0.45845335721969604, 0.09548012912273407, -0.5471168160438538, -0.09512190520763397, -0.43139833211898804, -1.115116834640503, 0.6150828003883362, -0.2137218564748764, -0.1966477483510971, 0.518027126789093, 0.24778355658054352, -0.1784714162349701, 0.6081568598747253, 0.7061461806297302, -0.11219443380832672, 0.7310649156570435, 0.012877650558948517, 0.32341548800468445, -0.2180682122707367, -0.39180606603622437, -0.7764479517936707, -0.3081933259963989, -0.4583999812602997, -0.4577080011367798, 0.0783659890294075, 0.07012013345956802, 0.2122095823287964, 0.6831649541854858, -0.46380552649497986, 0.6309087872505188, 0.44954806566238403, -0.08498117327690125, 0.03312169387936592, 0.05557890608906746, -0.07056166231632233, 0.10302238911390305, -0.08510394394397736, -0.4351438581943512, 0.7574533224105835, 0.2951635718345642, 0.7284252643585205, -0.18695497512817383, 1.1122936010360718, 0.953916072845459, 0.3386775851249695, -0.5361921191215515, 0.4648595452308655, -0.30877575278282166, -0.1077975183725357, -0.033709075301885605, -0.7147731781005859, -0.9239152669906616, -0.022065430879592896, -0.21146444976329803, -0.43532711267471313, -0.005089357029646635, -0.030596399679780006, -0.6205139756202698, -0.002764846431091428, -0.6824363470077515, 0.9093362092971802, -0.501244068145752, -0.018831361085176468, -0.18924744427204132, -0.5771855115890503, 0.33333998918533325, -0.2489584982395172, 0.5335879325866699, -0.006004004739224911, -0.1261025071144104, 0.9128479361534119, -0.6048082113265991, 0.5517840385437012, -0.21946442127227783, 0.12976720929145813, 0.44631195068359375, -0.05486515536904335, 0.5739568471908569, 0.09360566735267639, 0.6507250666618347, 0.11670515686273575, 0.18544405698776245, -0.5394118428230286, -0.5085010528564453, 0.7462133169174194, -0.32283392548561096, -0.0996757224202156, -0.5841807126998901, -0.025920648127794266, -0.0825015977025032, 0.3407418727874756, -0.20486487448215485, 0.18338529765605927, -0.2947973310947418, 0.14087611436843872, 0.5905277729034424, -0.10441518574953079, 0.37492579221725464, 0.48864057660102844, -0.13452105224132538, -0.3684576153755188, 0.9355197548866272, -0.132625013589859, -0.28111401200294495, 0.717384397983551, 0.46368032693862915, -0.5415058135986328, -0.45298776030540466, -0.2729431390762329, 0.15044069290161133, -0.6607485413551331, -0.42351436614990234, -0.48983055353164673, 0.1641562432050705, -0.7442558407783508, -0.24756605923175812, -0.042363956570625305, -0.44805556535720825, -0.47517451643943787, 0.025863580405712128, 0.43408289551734924, 0.7141070365905762, 0.03637009486556053, 0.4661088287830353, -1.4120181798934937, 0.4899946451187134, 0.2761749029159546, 0.43100905418395996, -0.1730969399213791, -0.2638039290904999, -0.8514155745506287, -0.21938136219978333, -0.17941559851169586, -0.9455782175064087, 0.5503585934638977, -0.12698696553707123, 0.4076350927352905, 0.6196919679641724, 0.049155935645103455, 0.7013567090034485, -0.05362629517912865, 0.419041246175766, 0.4605023264884949, -0.9154163002967834, 0.37362244725227356, 0.220257967710495, -0.08260306715965271, 0.4233269989490509, 0.3548068106174469, -0.8208736181259155, -0.3172958791255951, -0.5722745656967163, -0.7084854245185852, 0.6902366280555725, 0.069327712059021, -0.05902421846985817, -0.11073143780231476, 0.6228208541870117, 0.33566582202911377, 0.13194841146469116, -0.41526901721954346, -0.12200463563203812, 0.11587585508823395, -0.4813646674156189, -0.03485001251101494, -0.459621399641037, 0.1129242554306984, -0.04935577139258385, 0.6216496229171753, -0.07193292677402496, 0.23251387476921082, -0.06311433017253876, -0.21075573563575745, 0.2165994942188263, 0.36377331614494324, 0.6405152678489685, 0.3687354624271393, -0.06690599024295807, -0.027498045936226845, 0.08321672677993774, -0.4733843505382538, 0.09322448819875717, 0.2995825707912445, -0.20439833402633667, 0.24528108537197113, 0.16527634859085083, 0.34253185987472534, 0.4389626979827881, -0.8144364356994629, 0.7577128410339355, -0.3609659969806671, -0.2080988585948944, -0.7705270648002625, -0.1258305311203003, 0.005865728948265314, 0.5275551676750183, 0.3639242947101593, 0.42216289043426514, 0.5101627111434937, -0.3277123272418976, 0.19866910576820374, 0.244226336479187, -0.508613109588623, -0.04617144912481308, 0.3324602246284485, 0.279085636138916, -0.6015492677688599, 0.5902420282363892, -0.3616047203540802, -0.5933406352996826, 0.6697703003883362, 0.26909035444259644, 1.2167800664901733, -0.002588332165032625, 0.16579437255859375, -0.009519978426396847, 0.03711910545825958, -0.35319483280181885, -0.014687562361359596, -0.5683547258377075, -0.37879425287246704, -0.2747613787651062, -0.8908467292785645, -0.445730060338974, -0.23089130222797394, -0.8352325558662415, 0.6643908023834229, -0.5378482341766357, -0.1803692728281021, 0.2606845498085022, 0.009003699757158756, -0.5155897736549377, -0.03672581911087036, 0.5380620956420898, 0.6484845876693726, -0.8435418605804443, 1.0693583488464355, 0.5338958501815796, 0.10049470514059067, -0.0037659299559891224, -0.41140875220298767, -0.19994132220745087, -0.38920125365257263, 0.6105380058288574, 0.4821021556854248, -0.10090353339910507, -0.7186534404754639, -0.09978560358285904, -0.3057137131690979, 0.9640594124794006, -0.10443364828824997, -0.8813304901123047, 0.006718445103615522, 0.40101489424705505, 0.584856390953064, -0.43136465549468994, -0.1800127476453781, 0.7115287184715271, 0.3680896461009979, 0.12088815122842789, -0.5432435870170593, -0.2749529778957367, 0.2110363245010376, -0.03586077317595482, 0.606613039970398, -0.5554925203323364, 0.6427927017211914, 0.30969998240470886, 0.09394974261522293, 0.20638424158096313, 0.6920549869537354, -0.0177614688873291, 0.7810009121894836, 0.6789973378181458, 0.4839211404323578, 0.8502808213233948, -0.13144934177398682, 0.8956335186958313, -0.06380061060190201, 0.5097056031227112, 0.9021426439285278, -0.07949743419885635, 0.5554867386817932, 0.35089483857154846, -0.08762165158987045, 0.5938786864280701, 0.7270634770393372, -0.1663796454668045, 0.3770372271537781, 0.40146854519844055, -0.22189144790172577, -0.31043723225593567, 0.2630888521671295, -0.022219879552721977, 0.23203371465206146, 0.4704122841358185, -0.5423415899276733, -0.0514138787984848, 0.44253408908843994, -0.3807957172393799, 0.11322357505559921, -0.4878295063972473, 0.823876678943634, 0.1801237314939499, -0.17305772006511688, 0.08170273900032043, 0.47968801856040955, 0.8501964211463928, -0.7499879002571106, 0.10068385303020477, -0.057747967541217804, 0.49577006697654724, -0.0570279136300087, -0.4222324788570404, 0.4120306074619293, 0.06750842928886414, -0.29999101161956787, -0.6579668521881104, 1.2789419889450073, -0.359378844499588, -0.5260648727416992, 0.1878255158662796, -0.025274032726883888, 0.23863573372364044, -0.07591430842876434, -0.846422016620636, -0.29978999495506287, -0.3156905770301819, -0.07219885289669037, 0.5204870104789734, 0.5428759455680847, -0.2830314636230469, 0.5179908871650696, 0.3569573760032654, -0.17799893021583557, -0.02761087380349636, -0.11197493225336075, 0.6211148500442505, -1.2081749439239502, -1.187079906463623, -1.0887961387634277, -0.17651322484016418, -0.300758957862854, -0.05967828258872032, 0.8502044677734375, 1.0234919786453247, 0.8130260109901428, -0.13617371022701263, 0.5677077770233154, 0.3784712553024292, 0.9408065676689148, -0.22042407095432281, 0.275702565908432, -0.3450639843940735, 0.4612429141998291, -0.11785455793142319, -0.7659016251564026, -0.2972661554813385, 0.3867359459400177, -0.2227645218372345, -0.46086105704307556, 0.37267181277275085, 0.3056478500366211, -0.10676121711730957, 0.07534913718700409, 0.13445864617824554, -0.11930698156356812, 0.23893599212169647, 0.4020654261112213, 0.7893583178520203, -0.24045883119106293, 1.0676714181900024, -0.41535741090774536, 0.08515743911266327, -0.8337490558624268, -0.5779241323471069, -1.083969235420227, -0.35969483852386475, -0.4831375479698181, -0.5085592269897461, -0.3940126597881317, 0.8969573974609375, 0.20590068399906158, -0.7265337109565735, -0.42287755012512207, 0.18951693177223206, 0.3142007291316986, -0.3360997438430786, -0.23280782997608185, 0.2771797478199005, -0.12050582468509674, -0.49767935276031494, 0.060541946440935135, 0.6641387343406677, 0.5791189670562744, -0.18613725900650024, -0.1550775021314621, 0.34032925963401794, 0.18216955661773682, 0.5355027914047241, 0.3719078004360199, -0.3362577557563782, -0.19176824390888214, -0.07543360441923141, -0.21383467316627502, -0.10483349114656448, 1.3830829858779907, -0.7172447443008423, 0.1458560973405838, 0.5818632245063782, 0.7586361765861511, 0.8844478726387024, 0.1544453650712967, -0.04556402564048767, -0.7633035182952881, 0.13956929743289948, 0.570110023021698, 0.2480006366968155, 0.10837006568908691, -0.5222187638282776, 0.02442130818963051, 0.4973173141479492, -0.3373042941093445, -0.6344055533409119, -0.04315170645713806, -1.2316350936889648, -0.5927659869194031, 0.657598078250885, -0.14334271848201752, -0.7982043623924255, -0.35812777280807495, -0.3261663615703583, -0.11681077629327774, -0.4029175043106079, 0.7522968649864197, 0.6685094833374023, -0.06716940551996231, 0.23031342029571533, -0.21316573023796082, 0.49210938811302185, 0.07292550057172775, -0.4632095694541931, -0.08649255335330963, 0.4356338083744049, 0.35295653343200684, 0.24910897016525269, 0.8173496723175049, 0.06860048323869705, 0.2613503932952881, -0.44583579897880554, -0.28450649976730347, -0.154342383146286, -0.15431098639965057, -0.5181593894958496, 0.3204789161682129, -0.19971388578414917, -0.2649013102054596 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20158v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20158v1
ChatGPT v.s. Media Bias: A Comparative Study of GPT-3.5 and Fine-tuned Language Models
2024-03-29T13:12:09
2024-03-29T13:12:09
Zehao Wen, Rabih Younes
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI
In our rapidly evolving digital sphere, the ability to discern media bias becomes crucial as it can shape public sentiment and influence pivotal decisions. The advent of large language models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, noted for their broad utility in various natural language processing (NLP) tasks, invites exploration of their efficacy in media bias detection. Can ChatGPT detect media bias? This study seeks to answer this question by leveraging the Media Bias Identification Benchmark (MBIB) to assess ChatGPT's competency in distinguishing six categories of media bias, juxtaposed against fine-tuned models such as BART, ConvBERT, and GPT-2. The findings present a dichotomy: ChatGPT performs at par with fine-tuned models in detecting hate speech and text-level context bias, yet faces difficulties with subtler elements of other bias detections, namely, fake news, racial, gender, and cognitive biases.
[ -0.7440388202667236, -0.8036424517631531, 0.38553667068481445, 0.2579493820667267, -0.09840784221887589, 0.27741774916648865, -0.29175716638565063, -0.3016682267189026, -0.20491239428520203, 0.33421245217323303, -0.7153791189193726, -0.01587073877453804, -0.9318256974220276, -0.20642437040805817, -0.4168547987937927, 1.2125893831253052, 0.25613290071487427, 0.5886310338973999, 0.30842745304107666, -0.08719292283058167, -0.4065260589122772, -0.5366944670677185, -0.5597981214523315, -0.4037000834941864, 0.23198124766349792, 0.19444657862186432, 0.6822129487991333, 0.08163514733314514, 0.6005211472511292, 0.14064829051494598, -0.32171499729156494, -0.04550127312541008, -0.5939656496047974, -0.30661648511886597, -0.21914608776569366, -0.2721399664878845, -0.15671691298484802, 0.4478316605091095, 0.4719635546207428, 0.2817836105823517, 0.10618665814399719, 0.276340514421463, 0.215740367770195, 0.8386763334274292, -0.4541873037815094, -0.05472208932042122, -1.031825304031372, -0.06300880014896393, -0.3080188035964966, -0.25370916724205017, -0.37138208746910095, -0.39943671226501465, 0.19346709549427032, -0.018362700939178467, 0.5345361828804016, 0.1728576272726059, 0.8673352003097534, 0.3775230944156647, -0.6194562315940857, -0.3773021101951599, -0.7236164808273315, 0.6935487389564514, -0.5751903653144836, 0.6085052490234375, 0.34347283840179443, 0.28173917531967163, -0.12443222105503082, -0.2722702920436859, -0.5838189125061035, -0.21778997778892517, 0.2648923099040985, 0.3094410002231598, -0.19351860880851746, -0.034076422452926636, 0.5289998650550842, 0.4917553663253784, -0.6114428639411926, 0.2148078978061676, -0.558334469795227, -0.2523118555545807, 0.33551812171936035, -0.2321767807006836, 0.23426926136016846, -0.30143606662750244, -0.3660432696342468, 0.22116371989250183, -0.7672664523124695, -0.40251481533050537, 0.6727087497711182, 0.08903632313013077, 0.14140687882900238, 0.5167375206947327, -0.29090258479118347, 0.3980894684791565, -0.03619149699807167, -0.15225638449192047, -0.021825134754180908, 0.043697722256183624, -0.2851945757865906, 0.09787889569997787, 0.7732480764389038, 0.6906540393829346, 0.5114078521728516, 0.19877579808235168, -0.06902047246694565, 0.4239945709705353, 0.26621535420417786, -0.7123429775238037, -0.2594427764415741, -0.1812095195055008, -0.5721244812011719, -0.31063294410705566, -0.27956342697143555, -0.6592171788215637, -0.817692756652832, -0.15120886266231537, 0.3390834629535675, -0.3229586184024811, -0.263737291097641, -0.0782749280333519, -0.1802235096693039, 0.3612542152404785, 0.14411069452762604, -0.8550193905830383, 0.2403843253850937, 0.711952805519104, 0.925197184085846, -0.32959067821502686, 0.09846940636634827, -0.19784140586853027, -0.2314280867576599, -0.11033278703689575, 0.9739458560943604, -0.6940670013427734, -0.20235805213451385, -0.04060833156108856, -0.24860155582427979, 0.1891622245311737, -0.6341626644134521, 0.8028472065925598, -0.640958309173584, 0.49002546072006226, -0.573062539100647, -0.5926100611686707, -0.09884704649448395, 0.2618197202682495, -0.7208350896835327, 0.8647136092185974, 0.33244264125823975, -1.1209287643432617, 0.8439913392066956, -0.42957803606987, -0.10999000072479248, -0.22625987231731415, -0.17396153509616852, -0.5778911113739014, -0.016488805413246155, 0.3959694802761078, 0.24030855298042297, -0.3213605284690857, 0.26921504735946655, -0.6421067118644714, -0.4697100520133972, 0.22225233912467957, -0.8754222989082336, 0.7297346591949463, 0.4347494840621948, -0.26089411973953247, -0.1933191865682602, -0.6155731081962585, -0.37050914764404297, -0.03554694727063179, -0.5406032204627991, -0.12919701635837555, 0.22760625183582306, 0.2657628357410431, 0.26345735788345337, -0.10959261655807495, -0.5012246966362, 0.13751721382141113, 0.17584672570228577, 0.510274350643158, 0.6575806736946106, -0.10247490555047989, 0.3361557424068451, -0.24396413564682007, 0.28033772110939026, 0.02457895688712597, -0.0025895105209201574, 0.22425520420074463, -0.5111813545227051, -0.6469897627830505, -0.2808226943016052, 0.3629835247993469, 0.5189617276191711, -0.5170556902885437, -0.016353202983736992, -0.046898145228624344, -0.5075032711029053, -0.41903337836265564, -0.02295515313744545, 0.1806853711605072, 0.4484826624393463, 0.3183087706565857, -0.40627673268318176, -0.6106091141700745, -1.1117050647735596, -0.754837691783905, 0.015267490409314632, -0.14339137077331543, 0.3021647334098816, 0.23314125835895538, -0.09103560447692871, 0.7468932271003723, -0.21683916449546814, -0.41403746604919434, -0.165082648396492, 0.11688866466283798, 0.16201180219650269, 0.025281639769673347, 0.4257998466491699, -0.7546666264533997, -0.4832659363746643, -0.14826858043670654, -0.3154771625995636, -0.7402591705322266, 0.03093099780380726, 0.23455294966697693, -0.1418834775686264, 0.4659966230392456, -0.3740015923976898, 0.2295672744512558, 0.5281913876533508, -0.3536715805530548, 0.6531237363815308, 0.3570319712162018, 0.18240173161029816, -0.7882751226425171, -0.2019277960062027, 0.2671292722225189, -0.2714947760105133, -0.5943078994750977, -0.27015334367752075, -0.0040997667238116264, 0.1654932051897049, -0.42993801832199097, 0.2957775592803955, -0.28627169132232666, -0.33682870864868164, -0.4811449944972992, 0.20212052762508392, -0.37606844305992126, 0.3959352970123291, 0.11459258943796158, 0.8553721904754639, 0.2603810429573059, -0.4429837465286255, 0.11708557605743408, -0.040521204471588135, -0.6488877534866333, 0.7787289023399353, -0.42726215720176697, -0.012697705999016762, -0.1863919347524643, 0.47474631667137146, -1.0550062656402588, -0.16946299374103546, 0.2388598471879959, -0.5089426040649414, 0.11909890174865723, -0.4652678370475769, -0.4294843077659607, -0.21638111770153046, -0.06332665681838989, 0.30842071771621704, 0.55269455909729, -0.30446791648864746, 0.13138709962368011, 0.5872670412063599, -0.1920986920595169, -0.5231691598892212, -0.43517565727233887, -0.2384280413389206, -0.38983654975891113, -0.28479644656181335, 0.05331498384475708, 0.007500378880649805, -0.18496958911418915, -0.31971997022628784, -0.28816866874694824, -0.16739757359027863, -0.15933705866336823, 0.21522308886051178, 0.04249829426407814, -0.24715964496135712, -0.047760531306266785, -0.10417228937149048, 0.1238778755068779, -0.06989985704421997, -0.09873038530349731, 0.7069848775863647, -0.187653049826622, -0.48860976099967957, -0.0449308343231678, 0.05950016528367996, 0.6424714922904968, -0.05083755403757095, 0.1877119094133377, 0.959135890007019, -0.15363150835037231, 0.15470200777053833, -0.9990769028663635, -0.26744982600212097, -0.4113362729549408, 0.43619126081466675, 0.047893259674310684, -1.0557104349136353, 0.44288069009780884, 0.010344399139285088, -0.1899210661649704, 0.24720606207847595, 0.9457089304924011, 0.23600144684314728, 1.1988646984100342, 0.3843369781970978, -0.5029152035713196, 0.7473075985908508, 0.1015719324350357, 0.14987386763095856, -0.8551275134086609, 0.31217631697654724, -0.3822230100631714, -0.3483889400959015, -0.9599389433860779, -0.023806419223546982, 0.18855434656143188, -0.23973453044891357, -0.43580538034439087, 0.12983885407447815, -0.4757141172885895, 0.7054781317710876, 0.5774475336074829, 0.030692419037222862, 0.32515376806259155, 0.049684833735227585, 0.11830246448516846, -0.16125503182411194, -0.5412369966506958, -0.6505371332168579, 0.9910645484924316, 0.5701056122779846, 0.4585701525211334, 0.14509975910186768, 0.24795790016651154, 0.46146535873413086, 0.6851015686988831, -0.7012275457382202, 0.43435102701187134, 0.004120714031159878, -1.1316806077957153, 0.09781933575868607, -0.2031063437461853, -0.5970608592033386, 0.5995837450027466, -0.17146173119544983, -1.048046350479126, 0.04987848177552223, 0.06347855180501938, -0.08777335286140442, 0.32905033230781555, -0.938331663608551, 0.7080532908439636, 0.1129947379231453, -0.5194317698478699, -0.2454874962568283, -0.33234351873397827, 0.5985062718391418, -0.15145143866539001, 0.3427315354347229, -0.5972683429718018, 0.15903790295124054, 0.7314886450767517, -0.05099453777074814, 0.6241300702095032, -0.1119207963347435, 0.15079236030578613, 0.18933187425136566, 0.16233520209789276, 0.16670005023479462, 0.00020213630341459066, 0.11946852505207062, -0.023779647424817085, 0.02184366062283516, -0.31129175424575806, -0.19446641206741333, 0.5564566254615784, -0.768103301525116, -0.42779338359832764, -0.34087440371513367, -0.4602264165878296, -0.4005219638347626, 0.37747421860694885, 0.46181610226631165, 0.17192204296588898, -0.38172903656959534, 0.20467667281627655, 0.6000760197639465, -0.1325509250164032, 0.40306326746940613, 0.7567595839500427, -0.24213646352291107, -0.06125972792506218, 0.8386359214782715, 0.0838349238038063, 0.3663345277309418, 0.09405282139778137, 0.16568465530872345, -0.026672180742025375, -0.4565886855125427, -0.26963287591934204, 0.010429160669445992, -0.558014988899231, -0.04363115504384041, -0.4773973524570465, -0.22530972957611084, 0.01649649813771248, 0.08153437077999115, -0.49132466316223145, -0.03375587239861488, 0.14943812787532806, 0.05349064618349075, -0.046217020601034164, 0.660994291305542, -0.02467847801744938, 0.7614322304725647, -0.311231791973114, 0.42685797810554504, 0.3730521500110626, 0.5627444386482239, -0.3744282126426697, -0.6112024784088135, 0.04114747792482376, 0.08354920893907547, -0.7810847163200378, -1.139710545539856, 0.3395821154117584, -0.1777896136045456, 0.23069722950458527, 0.43998122215270996, -0.3313629925251007, 0.23442235589027405, -0.5778173804283142, 0.7629638910293579, -0.11560065299272537, -0.6326324343681335, 0.30425068736076355, -0.7672311663627625, 0.1493983119726181, 0.48369547724723816, 0.6390461325645447, -0.5248907208442688, -0.5165358185768127, -0.8944894075393677, -0.32125502824783325, 0.6038310527801514, 0.293112188577652, 0.013474765233695507, -0.1619185209274292, -0.32172027230262756, 0.03676295652985573, 0.31963539123535156, -1.0645415782928467, 0.015813780948519707, -0.13449715077877045, 0.1649823635816574, 0.15221993625164032, -0.508411169052124, 0.058552343398332596, -0.02030155062675476, 0.6464729905128479, 0.06185433641076088, 0.465894877910614, 0.09209516644477844, -0.2376784086227417, 0.12102851271629333, 0.4728316366672516, 0.7803846597671509, 0.5234848856925964, -0.4408589005470276, 0.05766652524471283, 0.22479158639907837, -0.7638053297996521, -0.021202409639954567, 0.017272958531975746, -0.2395053505897522, 0.09778434038162231, 0.17405813932418823, 0.6639752984046936, 0.0008947878959588706, -0.359663724899292, 0.7656460404396057, -0.08439838886260986, -0.2585747241973877, -0.11806624382734299, 0.01302323117852211, 0.01456849928945303, 0.36248621344566345, 0.29967981576919556, 0.0965508371591568, 0.3681235611438751, -0.5180152654647827, 0.17799833416938782, 0.7461166977882385, -0.7531564235687256, -0.06844744086265564, 0.7100510597229004, 0.14912329614162445, -0.18139123916625977, 0.46534571051597595, -0.1514156460762024, -0.7991102337837219, 0.4236786663532257, 0.3696375787258148, 0.7478258609771729, -0.23899619281291962, -0.01010450255125761, 0.11365534365177155, 0.50230473279953, -0.2072644829750061, 0.0005866889841854572, 0.08140816539525986, -1.1258522272109985, -0.3775843381881714, -0.45886680483818054, -0.32076218724250793, 0.5529219508171082, -0.5484873652458191, 0.4004868268966675, -0.4947618842124939, -0.39847704768180847, 0.3706227242946625, 0.036830540746450424, -0.7221105694770813, 0.20639629662036896, 0.549205482006073, 0.6906576752662659, -1.0453749895095825, 0.697785496711731, 0.3092004656791687, -0.2457066923379898, -0.626299262046814, 0.3104732930660248, 0.44953447580337524, -0.9535989165306091, 0.48572564125061035, 0.30793148279190063, 0.050292786210775375, -0.07657628506422043, -0.5740994811058044, -0.5054911971092224, 0.6874855160713196, 0.28019705414772034, -0.5025899410247803, 0.24937008321285248, 0.06035767123103142, 0.4395367503166199, -0.16139644384384155, 0.8091979026794434, 0.8620645999908447, 0.2912057936191559, -0.00008655329293105751, -1.2493594884872437, -0.24365396797657013, 0.02991355024278164, -0.13184791803359985, 0.17998789250850677, -0.9249877333641052, 0.5326380729675293, 0.19417797029018402, -0.08439794927835464, -0.5742682814598083, 0.35080868005752563, 0.08736968040466309, 0.24781973659992218, 0.35096025466918945, 0.3231882154941559, 0.43477675318717957, -0.24800966680049896, 0.7853363156318665, -0.267336368560791, 0.40904927253723145, 0.941305935382843, -0.11509580910205841, 0.5886265635490417, 0.35114794969558716, -0.3141193687915802, 0.25292879343032837, 0.8501228094100952, -0.07466189563274384, 0.6459837555885315, 0.19449298083782196, -0.32066044211387634, -0.0880175530910492, -0.09093932062387466, -0.37404096126556396, 0.4921402335166931, 0.6166977882385254, -0.38454800844192505, -0.24611543118953705, -0.11237532645463943, 0.3609265387058258, -0.17734481394290924, -0.4716683328151703, 0.6207228302955627, 0.15660032629966736, -0.741127073764801, 0.29523730278015137, -0.06054003909230232, 0.8414921164512634, -0.37731048464775085, 0.28032389283180237, -0.2148127555847168, 0.16212598979473114, -0.18922868371009827, -0.7903333306312561, 0.2656007707118988, -0.007308724336326122, -0.13168635964393616, 0.08004730939865112, 1.0691560506820679, -0.25632596015930176, -0.13324837386608124, -0.07164376229047775, 0.6058477163314819, 0.029763124883174896, -0.4103376865386963, -0.6989452838897705, 0.35226768255233765, 0.18147654831409454, -0.42332279682159424, 0.32270538806915283, 0.18360383808612823, -0.07277199625968933, 0.8475030660629272, 0.43852534890174866, 0.09671076387166977, 0.13589605689048767, 0.18010734021663666, 0.6740908026695251, -0.3913571238517761, -0.23423904180526733, -1.0785000324249268, 0.0836058035492897, -0.2602013945579529, -0.27611494064331055, 0.6827833652496338, 0.5933778882026672, 0.9156919121742249, -0.19150365889072418, 1.0516563653945923, -0.1137067973613739, 0.7910224199295044, -0.5386390686035156, 0.6247896552085876, -0.05829312279820442, 0.158041313290596, -0.5994775891304016, -1.1679688692092896, -0.2010582983493805, 0.7137365937232971, -0.7855923771858215, 0.275828093290329, 0.6389381289482117, 0.9933930039405823, -0.331051230430603, 0.3453400433063507, 0.06652966141700745, 0.006960251368582249, 0.3200382888317108, 0.4132252335548401, 0.981395423412323, -0.20755250751972198, 0.5814343690872192, 0.17756932973861694, -0.29046207666397095, -0.37891584634780884, -0.9579656720161438, -1.0623699426651, -0.43487003445625305, -0.14383485913276672, -0.2886877655982971, 0.03427518531680107, 0.7731930017471313, 0.7131076455116272, -0.5496171712875366, 0.0581042654812336, 0.09359215945005417, 0.23126369714736938, -0.03951330482959747, -0.25708329677581787, 0.040402043610811234, -0.12198545038700104, -0.7080650329589844, -0.0753883495926857, 0.13318082690238953, -0.08679115027189255, -0.27368786931037903, 0.14913052320480347, 0.030437836423516273, 0.19946090877056122, 0.6451520919799805, 0.2229439914226532, -0.7113658785820007, -0.4729902446269989, -0.21476608514785767, -0.10781831294298172, 0.0636141449213028, 1.0388641357421875, -0.6074626445770264, 0.2340683490037918, 0.42924150824546814, 0.42462703585624695, 0.5776485800743103, -0.03910638019442558, 0.4903530776500702, -0.653067409992218, 0.08143597096204758, 0.09701427817344666, 0.36732950806617737, 0.43390515446662903, -0.053284693509340286, 0.5663847327232361, 0.28831425309181213, -1.0896259546279907, -0.7295252084732056, 0.5134229063987732, -1.062147855758667, -0.0691208764910698, 1.4526594877243042, 0.5051202774047852, 0.17502808570861816, -0.11207249015569687, -0.765678346157074, 0.13752953708171844, -0.3481881022453308, 0.8922765254974365, 1.0373972654342651, 0.058082886040210724, -0.4138650596141815, -1.1641395092010498, 0.7410632967948914, 0.3874492347240448, -0.28367576003074646, -0.019899073988199234, 0.5242060422897339, 0.4434802234172821, -0.08696655184030533, 0.822268545627594, 0.008967248722910881, 0.18179568648338318, -0.14720052480697632, -0.19345343112945557, 0.3085215389728546, 0.1259193867444992, 0.10355586558580399, -0.13313230872154236, 0.17448458075523376, -0.028740422800183296 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20157v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20157v1
A Systematic Analysis of Subwords and Cross-Lingual Transfer in Multilingual Translation
2024-03-29T13:09:23
2024-03-29T13:09:23
Francois Meyer, Jan Buys
cs.CL
cs.CL
Multilingual modelling can improve machine translation for low-resource languages, partly through shared subword representations. This paper studies the role of subword segmentation in cross-lingual transfer. We systematically compare the efficacy of several subword methods in promoting synergy and preventing interference across different linguistic typologies. Our findings show that subword regularisation boosts synergy in multilingual modelling, whereas BPE more effectively facilitates transfer during cross-lingual fine-tuning. Notably, our results suggest that differences in orthographic word boundary conventions (the morphological granularity of written words) may impede cross-lingual transfer more significantly than linguistic unrelatedness. Our study confirms that decisions around subword modelling can be key to optimising the benefits of multilingual modelling.
[ -0.6270032525062561, -0.5002123713493347, 0.13949833810329437, 0.2315618097782135, -0.5770615339279175, -0.13040097057819366, -0.14598630368709564, -0.9003386497497559, 0.30467119812965393, 0.3018186092376709, -0.5015909671783447, -0.13059639930725098, -0.6665247678756714, 0.2463831603527069, -0.2829224765300751, 0.720173716545105, -0.1718318909406662, 0.22155283391475677, -0.21139389276504517, -0.21922940015792847, -0.4404982328414917, -0.7426111698150635, -0.47878625988960266, -0.830598771572113, 0.6930885910987854, -0.061016231775283813, 0.8256334662437439, 0.6194909811019897, 0.6083853244781494, 0.26591333746910095, -0.13785824179649353, 0.06394007802009583, -0.32549214363098145, -0.1534016877412796, -0.6712773442268372, -0.6565796136856079, -0.4278327226638794, -0.05317717790603638, 0.5351690649986267, 1.0418407917022705, 0.05490826442837715, -0.10378367453813553, 0.043004415929317474, 0.5229045748710632, -0.4304531514644623, 0.0853327214717865, -0.42542406916618347, 0.1695028692483902, -0.3846404254436493, -0.027383984997868538, -0.21069426834583282, 0.15015314519405365, 0.33480432629585266, -0.5090109705924988, 0.04109404981136322, 0.3149257302284241, 0.8895010352134705, 0.18791624903678894, -0.11522722244262695, -0.2047414630651474, -0.3435109555721283, 0.868141233921051, -0.6618232131004333, 0.7794723510742188, 0.04494556784629822, -0.11951690167188644, 0.1067798063158989, -0.38318854570388794, -0.34930911660194397, 0.11702042818069458, -0.5261392593383789, 0.10368967801332474, -0.17177924513816833, 0.20658861100673676, 0.09603164345026016, 0.26919010281562805, -0.31834155321121216, 0.35297611355781555, -0.5938708186149597, -0.35843536257743835, 0.5609897971153259, -0.05249820649623871, 0.5833442211151123, -0.1674382984638214, -0.5832983255386353, 0.10238000005483627, -0.6337636113166809, -0.07688213139772415, 0.2687932848930359, 0.579957127571106, -0.29468825459480286, 0.531651496887207, 0.1477564424276352, 0.5644680857658386, -0.02898169308900833, -0.39175623655319214, -0.0467604361474514, -1.0449925661087036, -0.12051694840192795, 0.11256318539381027, 0.6535410284996033, 0.3986136019229889, 0.5962362289428711, -0.30418968200683594, -0.0021636190358549356, 0.12577007710933685, -0.09279714524745941, -0.5435242652893066, -0.18823397159576416, -0.17246416211128235, -0.5391952395439148, 0.2907479703426361, -0.2273949533700943, -0.6412739753723145, -0.1283031404018402, -0.32105904817581177, -0.007655386347323656, -0.5881696939468384, -0.19632790982723236, 0.3015952408313751, -0.27066585421562195, 0.24670395255088806, 0.22510790824890137, -1.030761480331421, 0.3669174909591675, 0.5555316209793091, 0.6308533549308777, -0.3226451575756073, -0.6813677549362183, -0.0751226469874382, 0.17034052312374115, -0.6094436049461365, 0.7513831257820129, -0.4339445233345032, -0.5410926938056946, -0.2312469482421875, 0.21588939428329468, -0.5420396327972412, -0.6506518721580505, 0.023429134860634804, -0.3590412139892578, 0.4033227562904358, -0.22853003442287445, -0.3429383933544159, -0.48777642846107483, -0.006543128285557032, -0.6620990633964539, 0.7037893533706665, 0.07623124867677689, -0.5583822727203369, 0.6241423487663269, -0.5416079759597778, -0.8308702111244202, -0.06931369751691818, 0.12143789231777191, -0.012026544660329819, 0.38077303767204285, 0.42780786752700806, -0.0373261459171772, -0.33134886622428894, -0.18581150472164154, -0.2066417932510376, 0.026296598836779594, 0.049977101385593414, -0.055521439760923386, 0.43946146965026855, 0.15797437727451324, -0.03850726783275604, 0.12158956378698349, -0.06947140395641327, -0.1165599375963211, -0.28950926661491394, -0.208414688706398, -0.7122377753257751, -0.516684353351593, 0.24125796556472778, 0.5582139492034912, 0.37755873799324036, -0.6083139777183533, 0.1484164595603943, -0.2773544192314148, 0.10620333254337311, 0.22736532986164093, -0.053157269954681396, 0.8065482378005981, -0.4594654142856598, 0.6864354610443115, 0.38743269443511963, 0.043801065534353256, 0.12406263500452042, -0.4612438678741455, -0.5694277882575989, -0.29468604922294617, 1.1404951810836792, 0.6560129523277283, -0.8732680678367615, -0.12686744332313538, -0.16098791360855103, -0.2895829975605011, -0.9295547604560852, 0.36097076535224915, 0.6089469194412231, 0.08760529011487961, 0.43076351284980774, -0.7540421485900879, -0.5484781265258789, -1.1335169076919556, -0.3267463743686676, -0.012877648696303368, 0.39824673533439636, 0.1428082436323166, 0.19543340802192688, -0.2869955897331238, 0.600899875164032, 0.14808399975299835, -0.4543893039226532, -0.7890253663063049, 0.3096267580986023, -0.2156977504491806, 0.7100966572761536, 0.8703746199607849, -0.8208389282226562, -0.8073270916938782, 0.38234278559684753, -0.3975171744823456, -0.4942719042301178, -0.2985057532787323, -0.27659088373184204, 0.5313542485237122, 0.5115230679512024, -0.5886535048484802, 0.4202198088169098, 0.7189126014709473, 0.010990185663104057, 0.18142570555210114, -0.24386261403560638, 0.02207851968705654, -0.9058449864387512, 0.11288058012723923, -0.1137702614068985, -0.2841673195362091, -0.446958065032959, 0.16310349106788635, -0.15246106684207916, 0.1153697520494461, -0.9406721591949463, 0.6400930881500244, -0.7182962894439697, -0.3966289460659027, -0.3317141532897949, 0.3600670397281647, -0.0014814079040661454, 0.17267243564128876, 0.21951094269752502, 0.7693886756896973, 0.5065225958824158, -0.3116428554058075, 0.19310230016708374, 0.1317441314458847, -0.19678859412670135, 0.5459378361701965, -0.5541560053825378, -0.08266326785087585, 0.004540775902569294, -0.04292704164981842, -0.7436054944992065, 0.13120771944522858, 0.16188065707683563, -0.17400459945201874, 0.6230347156524658, -0.26920315623283386, -0.48690086603164673, 0.2520272731781006, 0.07594001293182373, 0.6600378751754761, 0.3764392137527466, -0.1176687553524971, 0.5694950819015503, 0.5936368107795715, -0.3798048198223114, -0.09425920993089676, -0.9156895279884338, 0.06157313287258148, -0.19918181002140045, -0.7077730298042297, 0.6058728098869324, 0.25301027297973633, -0.39986005425453186, 0.34442198276519775, -0.04540417343378067, 0.13464611768722534, -0.07193637639284134, -0.2295924872159958, 0.09482046961784363, 0.006722905207425356, -0.3082710802555084, 0.09822652488946915, -0.20536348223686218, -0.33024731278419495, -0.31650274991989136, 0.7140613198280334, 0.19419464468955994, -0.24055445194244385, -0.24304021894931793, 0.7782643437385559, 0.6398937106132507, -0.39485326409339905, 0.6598135828971863, 0.7186052799224854, -0.2852874994277954, -0.18944203853607178, -0.24453739821910858, -0.07471770793199539, -0.327362596988678, 0.3450312614440918, -0.7999100685119629, -0.646837592124939, 0.5328131914138794, -0.1076141968369484, 0.05963965132832527, 0.4006598889827728, 0.5171244144439697, 0.11512809246778488, 0.9225602149963379, 1.188749074935913, -0.07348296046257019, 0.5851481556892395, 0.12232781201601028, 0.3018341362476349, -0.922309935092926, -0.10055836290121078, -0.20429068803787231, -0.5611860752105713, -0.6795674562454224, -0.5435382127761841, 0.2727687954902649, 0.3593088686466217, 0.7716231346130371, 0.6772766709327698, 0.06309594213962555, 0.21307669579982758, 0.5359741449356079, -0.43131023645401, 0.10837674885988235, 0.1428012251853943, -0.6207038164138794, -0.3080618381500244, -1.227800965309143, -0.19864600896835327, 0.23502475023269653, 0.19749492406845093, 1.177456259727478, 0.014136390760540962, 0.6821427941322327, 0.009398872032761574, 0.32098761200904846, -0.8899422287940979, 0.4747309386730194, -0.49592670798301697, -0.626680314540863, -0.27032095193862915, -0.31759920716285706, -1.0345875024795532, 0.7746999263763428, -0.273990660905838, -0.528154730796814, 0.44922176003456116, -0.3038686215877533, -0.30991581082344055, 0.312957763671875, -0.8188892006874084, 0.9489792585372925, -0.2820608913898468, -0.2646196186542511, -0.2692180275917053, -0.5326007604598999, 0.0688021257519722, -0.2779741585254669, 0.3770618438720703, 0.06650146096944809, -0.08975252509117126, 0.6984084248542786, -0.2115943729877472, 0.6769734025001526, 0.3317570984363556, -0.30055028200149536, 0.1983598917722702, 0.3444382846355438, -0.05686713755130768, -0.37100088596343994, 0.10245593637228012, 0.48628777265548706, 0.3553035855293274, -0.5253703594207764, -0.41701561212539673, 0.42554908990859985, -0.5021050572395325, -0.5877421498298645, -0.2651018798351288, -1.0723192691802979, -0.10789890587329865, 0.4607348144054413, 0.373904287815094, 0.12184589356184006, 0.10673517733812332, 0.0869046077132225, 0.330297589302063, -0.17081600427627563, 0.40772339701652527, 0.45790329575538635, -0.5165061354637146, -0.16018152236938477, 0.594143271446228, 0.45963388681411743, 0.4673007130622864, 0.5502799153327942, 0.10679053515195847, -0.521733283996582, -0.5753507614135742, -0.6007779836654663, 0.49255800247192383, -0.593494176864624, 0.19021305441856384, -0.3701993227005005, -0.10596846789121628, -0.8052844405174255, -0.23286868631839752, -0.32448139786720276, -0.49144402146339417, 0.14051151275634766, -0.009997050277888775, -0.11205657571554184, 0.5345052480697632, -0.543395459651947, 0.12291944026947021, -1.0276973247528076, 0.19540159404277802, 0.06886601448059082, -0.10199455916881561, -0.27417078614234924, -0.4051787853240967, -0.54273521900177, -0.10107769072055817, 0.10748288035392761, -0.74805748462677, 0.4153654873371124, 0.0846678838133812, 0.725994348526001, -0.15793463587760925, -0.17225252091884613, 0.9318508505821228, -0.526771605014801, 0.642029881477356, 0.2947159707546234, -1.0202490091323853, 0.05662154033780098, -0.11991798877716064, 0.5306455492973328, 0.3976634442806244, 0.47096461057662964, -0.9086521863937378, -0.1984928697347641, -0.4227314293384552, -0.903302013874054, 0.6010805368423462, -0.08656375110149384, -0.279145210981369, 0.28586992621421814, -0.04910403490066528, 0.2640875279903412, 0.20927026867866516, -0.5876461863517761, 0.09315212070941925, 0.22549809515476227, 0.16099964082241058, -0.12084978073835373, -0.08769569545984268, -0.16116201877593994, 0.09165096282958984, 0.6381849646568298, -0.044241905212402344, -0.20549613237380981, 0.26969942450523376, -0.3209015130996704, -0.35488688945770264, 0.44426676630973816, 0.5079396367073059, 0.6785394549369812, 0.21030476689338684, 0.19199512898921967, 0.3881028890609741, -0.21633799374103546, -0.04130225628614426, 0.2005399465560913, -0.18721915781497955, 0.29315319657325745, 0.8079400658607483, 0.5738124251365662, 0.19784851372241974, -0.22914233803749084, -0.04387796297669411, 0.2292376011610031, -0.2512226104736328, 0.7000211477279663, -0.28436583280563354, 0.20627343654632568, 0.14335644245147705, -0.22814033925533295, 0.07304313033819199, -0.16757774353027344, -0.8964876532554626, 0.26922452449798584, 0.38536354899406433, -0.2415081411600113, -0.5159332156181335, 0.362600713968277, 0.17094962298870087, -0.11520279943943024, 0.2550099492073059, 0.17729824781417847, -0.8933454751968384, 0.3734004497528076, 0.5901094079017639, 0.5757705569267273, -0.19833117723464966, -0.08176929503679276, -0.11876600235700607, 0.720300555229187, 0.16100963950157166, 0.4841306507587433, 0.055209118872880936, -0.6108236908912659, -0.5841322541236877, -0.7030580043792725, -0.4494491219520569, -0.22413483262062073, -0.5956568121910095, -0.10219714790582657, -0.11895018815994263, -0.1964828222990036, 0.1516566127538681, -0.05683249235153198, -0.5443248748779297, 0.1280640959739685, 0.46078038215637207, 0.9312625527381897, -0.7715232968330383, 1.0288243293762207, 1.019868016242981, -0.29014530777931213, -0.7812379598617554, -0.1483716070652008, -0.2685427665710449, -0.5939955711364746, 0.7546691298484802, -0.14177191257476807, -0.2591360807418823, -0.22216948866844177, 0.04992933198809624, -0.8004447221755981, 0.5522280931472778, 0.2178514301776886, -0.6681573987007141, -0.10701373219490051, 0.48544299602508545, 0.7074394226074219, -0.45259106159210205, -0.24204258620738983, 0.5417976975440979, 0.656765341758728, -0.022971224039793015, -1.5795918703079224, 0.16206780076026917, 0.08118859678506851, 0.1303536593914032, 0.49171727895736694, -0.71314936876297, 0.9876497983932495, 0.04194562882184982, -0.41327396035194397, 0.04968073219060898, 0.481999933719635, -0.2666679620742798, -0.058250587433576584, 0.511241614818573, 0.6687732338905334, 0.20468662679195404, -0.11560176312923431, 1.135035514831543, -0.6330597400665283, 0.17565643787384033, 0.7209455966949463, -0.37944895029067993, 0.5141674280166626, 0.8455023765563965, -0.06457106024026871, 0.4180321991443634, 0.6727073788642883, 0.24843107163906097, 0.7438879013061523, 0.13173724710941315, 0.2653399705886841, -0.39479056000709534, -0.5947905778884888, -0.4159691631793976, 0.46414804458618164, 0.3611404001712799, -0.16710789501667023, -0.5921397805213928, -0.08979493379592896, -0.07379437237977982, 0.006997630465775728, -0.4288317859172821, 0.7898762822151184, 0.49548226594924927, -1.0036152601242065, 0.5900715589523315, 0.3395126461982727, 0.7120569944381714, -0.5807340741157532, 0.21252593398094177, -0.5678735971450806, 0.35656440258026123, -0.3380550742149353, -0.5718082785606384, 0.6723318696022034, -0.4664575755596161, -0.025480106472969055, -0.5874361395835876, 0.9608418941497803, -1.0045267343521118, -0.3036099970340729, 0.7068033814430237, 1.092298984527588, 0.17056013643741608, 0.4045998156070709, -0.9501844644546509, -0.05264367163181305, -0.12276887148618698, 0.255289763212204, 0.5183704495429993, 0.7116296291351318, -0.3649595379829407, 0.21511927247047424, 0.6953405737876892, 0.5130460262298584, 0.37529894709587097, 0.2214958667755127, 0.5826462507247925, -0.5327929854393005, -0.6031428575515747, -0.775914192199707, 0.15084673464298248, 0.21382085978984833, -0.20147444307804108, 1.141822338104248, 0.5339509844779968, 1.2885823249816895, -0.11102161556482315, 0.6086798906326294, -0.09287944436073303, 0.19498127698898315, -0.5348449945449829, 0.3876144289970398, -0.7123585343360901, -0.12389782816171646, -0.22608806192874908, -0.8226273655891418, -0.26478835940361023, 0.565461277961731, -0.5536922812461853, -0.13139596581459045, 0.8383052349090576, 0.6120402216911316, -0.2616148591041565, -0.3603164553642273, 0.5269277095794678, -0.22963041067123413, -0.016698943451046944, 0.6046041250228882, 0.7390325665473938, -0.26201164722442627, 0.4028453826904297, -0.41271036863327026, -0.08725948631763458, -0.07946467399597168, -0.6760920882225037, -0.9636322855949402, -0.1702125072479248, -0.27891507744789124, -0.15371733903884888, 0.054833270609378815, 0.719813346862793, 0.9286613464355469, -0.6803768873214722, -0.6566542387008667, 0.19579574465751648, 0.2939244508743286, -0.4816216230392456, -0.18379628658294678, -0.06791573017835617, -0.4802827537059784, -0.9877552390098572, 0.3866632580757141, 0.4743804633617401, 0.2200549840927124, -0.3879355192184448, 0.20072264969348907, -0.552980363368988, 0.30652642250061035, 0.49771541357040405, 0.14251254498958588, -0.5824509263038635, -0.04470477253198624, 0.03591180220246315, -0.2554633319377899, -0.044118840247392654, 0.9714590907096863, -0.36975738406181335, 0.20794375240802765, 0.8143973350524902, 0.6012381911277771, 0.4757823944091797, 0.11836475878953934, 0.7312517762184143, -0.6314072012901306, 0.395701140165329, -0.03491221368312836, 0.5650528073310852, 0.45981094241142273, -0.23794496059417725, 0.5685023069381714, 0.5971822142601013, -0.056674983352422714, -0.5350453853607178, 0.5310623049736023, -0.519987940788269, -0.4920727610588074, 1.1862150430679321, -0.14699587225914001, -0.4621618390083313, -0.15410763025283813, -0.20972061157226562, 0.19864103198051453, -0.07116297632455826, 0.29645127058029175, 1.0097235441207886, -0.30055636167526245, -0.27483612298965454, -0.11210062354803085, 0.37584275007247925, 0.7324740290641785, -0.6447267532348633, -0.15498486161231995, 0.2882818877696991, 0.22319664061069489, 0.5940524339675903, 0.45503562688827515, -0.2713031470775604, 0.13393190503120422, 0.16290199756622314, -0.04888620972633362, 0.05994797125458717, -0.5979354977607727, -0.15285006165504456, 0.14160704612731934, -0.16263730823993683, -0.2213100790977478 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20147v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20147v2
IndiBias: A Benchmark Dataset to Measure Social Biases in Language Models for Indian Context
2024-03-29T12:32:06
2024-04-03T11:59:19
Nihar Ranjan Sahoo, Pranamya Prashant Kulkarni, Narjis Asad, Arif Ahmad, Tanu Goyal, Aparna Garimella, Pushpak Bhattacharyya
cs.CL
cs.CL
The pervasive influence of social biases in language data has sparked the need for benchmark datasets that capture and evaluate these biases in Large Language Models (LLMs). Existing efforts predominantly focus on English language and the Western context, leaving a void for a reliable dataset that encapsulates India's unique socio-cultural nuances. To bridge this gap, we introduce IndiBias, a comprehensive benchmarking dataset designed specifically for evaluating social biases in the Indian context. We filter and translate the existing CrowS-Pairs dataset to create a benchmark dataset suited to the Indian context in Hindi language. Additionally, we leverage LLMs including ChatGPT and InstructGPT to augment our dataset with diverse societal biases and stereotypes prevalent in India. The included bias dimensions encompass gender, religion, caste, age, region, physical appearance, and occupation. We also build a resource to address intersectional biases along three intersectional dimensions. Our dataset contains 800 sentence pairs and 300 tuples for bias measurement across different demographics. The dataset is available in English and Hindi, providing a size comparable to existing benchmark datasets. Furthermore, using IndiBias we compare ten different language models on multiple bias measurement metrics. We observed that the language models exhibit more bias across a majority of the intersectional groups.
[ -0.2526426613330841, -0.24127507209777832, -0.06182292848825455, 0.757550060749054, -0.2242211103439331, 0.2891828119754791, -0.4367580711841583, -0.4922652542591095, 0.24666573107242584, 0.22764889895915985, -0.23028409481048584, -0.3909812867641449, -0.627606987953186, 0.05461110919713974, -0.5298537015914917, 0.7578626871109009, 0.0916648879647255, 0.578829288482666, -0.4318500757217407, -0.5258150696754456, -0.48515915870666504, -0.12457840144634247, -0.32713595032691956, -0.33317556977272034, 0.012415253557264805, 0.48739486932754517, 0.4669024646282196, 0.4624408483505249, 0.33727338910102844, 0.1915929913520813, -0.04879721999168396, 0.22433316707611084, -0.393703818321228, 0.21999786794185638, -0.364815354347229, -0.2932509183883667, 0.22912836074829102, 0.03195034712553024, 0.7774187326431274, 0.8789039850234985, -0.0430913046002388, 0.4986530542373657, 0.08510853350162506, 0.5350946187973022, -0.7627378106117249, 0.1374586820602417, -0.6979974508285522, -0.14784669876098633, -0.6881469488143921, -0.13765452802181244, -0.12447456270456314, -0.8931163549423218, -0.20331746339797974, 0.04811690375208855, 0.0941300317645073, 0.0188294630497694, 0.542242169380188, 0.25151821970939636, -0.3966793715953827, -0.2471364289522171, -0.5079072117805481, 0.6647530794143677, -0.6623241901397705, 0.46696463227272034, 0.34897592663764954, 0.27384400367736816, 0.01885472796857357, -0.2090672254562378, -0.42670273780822754, 0.020781774073839188, -0.05195176973938942, -0.18960173428058624, 0.22867530584335327, -0.5277300477027893, 0.19278259575366974, 0.33704981207847595, -0.29666805267333984, -0.04240455850958824, -0.5396454334259033, -0.007453637197613716, 0.7038875222206116, 0.2438555210828781, 0.49714773893356323, -0.12750402092933655, -0.37052199244499207, -0.08664708584547043, -1.0481653213500977, 0.35642555356025696, 0.7947847247123718, 0.4697216749191284, -0.47272658348083496, 0.3851523697376251, -0.40449440479278564, 0.6558014154434204, -0.09456975758075714, 0.010649741627275944, 0.49508294463157654, -0.22846125066280365, 0.01225487794727087, 0.13219502568244934, 0.79383385181427, 0.2846653461456299, 0.6031769514083862, -0.25954669713974, -0.013818416744470596, 0.436798095703125, -0.21596044301986694, -0.5593783259391785, 0.4165911376476288, -0.014060492627322674, -0.23077194392681122, -0.14657849073410034, -0.3776412308216095, -1.2200394868850708, -0.8308334946632385, -0.36293745040893555, -0.37859830260276794, -0.3670763671398163, -0.32233482599258423, -0.2554171681404114, -0.021445482969284058, 0.7729407548904419, -0.16347934305667877, -1.180043339729309, 0.48325440287590027, 0.6901353001594543, 0.8370293378829956, -0.16134905815124512, -0.3890554904937744, -0.24774155020713806, 0.09273514151573181, -0.4988791346549988, 0.9737917184829712, -1.2923932075500488, -0.3488147556781769, 0.5413421392440796, -0.36005067825317383, 0.09286829829216003, -0.527455747127533, 0.6393861174583435, -0.08744983375072479, -0.2324323058128357, -0.5993891358375549, -0.30374664068222046, 0.03477580100297928, 0.3231058120727539, -0.14201650023460388, 1.130502462387085, 0.03137348219752312, -0.7636792659759521, 0.6518232226371765, -0.36424577236175537, -0.6453823447227478, 0.25878676772117615, -0.8073038458824158, 0.07999629527330399, 0.07070285081863403, 0.3648824989795685, 0.29428523778915405, -0.8616284132003784, 0.41724756360054016, -0.549831211566925, -0.5021291971206665, 0.07244991511106491, -0.2555835247039795, 0.9718479514122009, 0.24487006664276123, -0.14499568939208984, 0.03297832980751991, -0.8336706161499023, -0.1876203566789627, 0.020725294947624207, 0.05030879005789757, -0.7614875435829163, 0.10903896391391754, 0.10064513981342316, 0.14441291987895966, 0.1799769550561905, -0.9209614992141724, -0.1156671792268753, -0.3655383884906769, 0.47703027725219727, 0.8148778676986694, -0.18408933281898499, 0.44070133566856384, -0.20066997408866882, 0.40692809224128723, -0.048722878098487854, 0.34627026319503784, 0.05815739184617996, -0.24588826298713684, -0.706295907497406, -0.15712390840053558, 0.16216343641281128, 0.3523506224155426, -0.24369725584983826, -0.10385089367628098, -0.41530275344848633, -0.7179831862449646, -0.7399526238441467, 0.3468082547187805, 0.5692490935325623, 0.28684544563293457, -0.09654935449361801, -0.42014506459236145, -0.4148135781288147, -1.2745822668075562, -0.646141529083252, 0.11538660526275635, 0.19362087547779083, 0.06409191340208054, 0.40402278304100037, -0.16386809945106506, 0.9086374640464783, 0.06894870847463608, -0.29667747020721436, -0.07416665554046631, -0.13338395953178406, 0.04191428795456886, 0.37808024883270264, 0.45304930210113525, -0.6335721611976624, -0.7588308453559875, -0.10132481157779694, -0.7473297715187073, -0.48200613260269165, 0.2234177440404892, -0.16559110581874847, 0.031544022262096405, 0.38943156599998474, -0.2761002779006958, 0.48684683442115784, 0.6925026178359985, -0.36360543966293335, 0.21821945905685425, 0.1486964225769043, 0.13493096828460693, -1.109250545501709, -0.14561553299427032, 0.4322774112224579, 0.1513063907623291, -0.38777828216552734, -0.1422659009695053, 0.11968635767698288, 0.1757533997297287, -0.41717618703842163, 0.7987008690834045, -0.4092196524143219, -0.3852332830429077, 0.19705556333065033, 0.21257828176021576, -0.33556610345840454, 0.3484419882297516, -0.250948041677475, 0.9648720026016235, 0.5898725986480713, -0.364035427570343, 0.20664618909358978, 0.521734893321991, -0.6558632254600525, 0.8940851092338562, -0.7637022733688354, 0.06363051384687424, -0.2101321816444397, -0.02475164458155632, -0.98812335729599, -0.26873478293418884, 0.17309312522411346, -0.45196333527565, 0.10919862240552902, -0.15585553646087646, -0.5533578395843506, 0.08258897066116333, -0.42635753750801086, 0.5262909531593323, 0.19281098246574402, -0.5356377959251404, 0.6044577360153198, 0.9754177927970886, -0.20831143856048584, -0.7417108416557312, -0.8376767635345459, 0.012706919573247433, -0.3653816878795624, -0.6001625061035156, -0.009126769378781319, -0.04546218365430832, -0.7212387323379517, -0.27447667717933655, 0.14621692895889282, 0.08543667942285538, -0.35189032554626465, 0.554019033908844, 0.04461950063705444, 0.26843148469924927, 0.08266324549913406, 0.13017697632312775, 0.12249365448951721, 0.15486659109592438, 0.3095020651817322, 0.8695580959320068, -0.29622089862823486, -0.3981309235095978, -0.06003537401556969, 0.2714780271053314, 0.7080224752426147, -0.5323154926300049, 0.5078137516975403, 0.4209306836128235, -0.5220859050750732, -0.08680938929319382, -0.9466872215270996, 0.10407037287950516, -0.40099582076072693, 0.12276075780391693, -0.19229529798030853, -0.40655517578125, 0.8454261422157288, 0.10221786797046661, 0.07287236303091049, 0.16913729906082153, 0.6802441477775574, 0.3934774696826935, 0.8376985788345337, 0.5496890544891357, -0.5493646860122681, 0.5160049200057983, -0.0024972136598080397, 0.33044108748435974, -1.1765332221984863, -0.3731130361557007, -0.721438467502594, -0.11575645208358765, -0.6192758083343506, -0.177707701921463, 0.14447546005249023, -0.5319374799728394, -0.5161979794502258, 0.048862989991903305, -0.5903018116950989, 0.5549010038375854, 0.522689700126648, -0.14472778141498566, 0.14113157987594604, 0.08251826465129852, -0.07145902514457703, -0.3363077640533447, -0.456386923789978, -0.6508761048316956, 1.2165769338607788, 0.1719917356967926, 0.8376990556716919, 0.09341088682413101, 0.32327747344970703, 0.5777407884597778, 0.6337292194366455, -0.08100332319736481, 0.5419455170631409, 0.0007442013593390584, -0.8591043949127197, -0.12106825411319733, -0.15677250921726227, -0.654878556728363, 0.3230225145816803, -0.1440659910440445, -0.8250809907913208, 0.5821644067764282, -0.19914227724075317, -0.11026056855916977, 0.2740272581577301, -0.7979774475097656, 0.6624342799186707, -0.35663560032844543, -0.8635010719299316, -0.20030096173286438, -0.5338135361671448, 0.6411793828010559, 0.1884334534406662, 0.5240879058837891, -0.6195492744445801, 0.06735865026712418, 0.693970263004303, -0.20230990648269653, 0.9623184204101562, -0.054536234587430954, 0.24510380625724792, 0.029773680493235588, -0.031087281182408333, 0.3343607187271118, 0.14252398908138275, -0.23648615181446075, 0.4216918647289276, 0.19302843511104584, -0.48140695691108704, -0.013096552342176437, 1.0361253023147583, -0.9375478029251099, -0.016790933907032013, -0.8216881155967712, -0.695456326007843, -0.5573177337646484, -0.07162066549062729, -0.032202333211898804, 0.5868829488754272, -0.2563123404979706, 0.15758900344371796, 0.3567238748073578, -0.2848879098892212, 0.36543628573417664, 0.6379673480987549, -0.05075746402144432, -0.19190075993537903, 0.5778201818466187, 0.13387882709503174, 0.09970870614051819, -0.04346911609172821, 0.018699614331126213, -0.37322482466697693, -0.4231953024864197, -0.48071348667144775, 0.3669390380382538, -0.7674483060836792, -0.1922103613615036, -0.5035006999969482, -0.09161567687988281, -0.7713165879249573, -0.09506680071353912, -0.4455619156360626, 0.15399505198001862, 0.49546223878860474, 0.018969209864735603, 0.4604739248752594, 0.970707893371582, -0.2590329945087433, 0.1806536614894867, -0.2612200677394867, 0.1652986854314804, 0.13739626109600067, 0.793534517288208, -0.05487508699297905, -0.4927845299243927, 0.00743699399754405, 0.0058233304880559444, 0.062159277498722076, -0.8151823878288269, 0.61433345079422, -0.10285072028636932, 0.5425733923912048, 0.3782362639904022, -0.0855787917971611, 0.6458680033683777, -0.2543065845966339, 0.5452446937561035, -0.11466613411903381, -0.8414575457572937, 0.38329610228538513, -0.42162054777145386, 0.14095014333724976, 0.9001615643501282, 0.3253129720687866, -0.9919666647911072, -0.291428804397583, -0.22841957211494446, -0.8945699334144592, 0.5976530313491821, 0.13553830981254578, 0.2330353558063507, -0.2313377410173416, 0.27100318670272827, 0.1987936794757843, 0.17520873248577118, -0.6425685882568359, -0.3567608594894409, 0.08808016777038574, -0.300870805978775, -0.050027117133140564, -0.3941936194896698, -0.26015809178352356, -0.3768981993198395, 0.7891415357589722, 0.14149436354637146, -0.24265465140342712, 0.09836181998252869, -0.14628519117832184, -0.1764170527458191, 0.23454047739505768, 0.3549261689186096, 0.8866020441055298, -0.23850983381271362, -0.19585634768009186, 0.35155221819877625, -0.4237319231033325, -0.10595323890447617, 0.21322697401046753, -0.5132333040237427, -0.08019161224365234, 0.05868338793516159, 0.5579225420951843, 0.10577188432216644, -0.8316538333892822, 0.4253147840499878, -0.3261229991912842, 0.5491167306900024, -0.8801456689834595, -0.3077283501625061, -0.05016500502824783, 0.18613985180854797, 0.32241103053092957, -0.0678938627243042, 0.020415592938661575, -0.6929959058761597, -0.24263057112693787, 0.5482938885688782, -0.677889883518219, -0.08282280713319778, 0.6344099640846252, 0.45723608136177063, -0.486174076795578, 0.3168661594390869, -0.013206301257014275, -0.2854544520378113, 0.5121994018554688, 0.228685662150383, 0.6601161956787109, -0.21276217699050903, 0.1480710357427597, 0.525448203086853, 0.6778243780136108, 0.032638922333717346, 0.10330594331026077, -0.017036065459251404, -0.7369282245635986, -0.16668793559074402, -0.7314538359642029, -0.5916704535484314, 0.03169920668005943, -0.5269752740859985, 0.3728419542312622, -0.4380623400211334, 0.15087862312793732, -0.2879098951816559, -0.03176267445087433, -0.9333012104034424, 0.05031662806868553, 0.252205491065979, 0.8605698943138123, -1.234928011894226, 0.6803430914878845, 0.4717824161052704, -0.6780622601509094, -0.47267797589302063, -0.21778257191181183, 0.07636895775794983, -1.009965181350708, 0.4907527267932892, 0.1695469319820404, -0.1737816035747528, -0.346066951751709, -0.6893782615661621, -1.0164555311203003, 0.7494379878044128, 0.2886424958705902, -0.47695064544677734, 0.3738802671432495, 0.5926620960235596, 0.5774214863777161, -0.6538206338882446, 0.6009422540664673, 1.0009421110153198, 0.41067561507225037, -0.38040637969970703, -0.642869234085083, -0.03133779391646385, -0.5799794793128967, 0.21591369807720184, 0.08675660192966461, -1.0365978479385376, 0.7825735211372375, 0.3107844591140747, -0.1499982625246048, -0.1882741004228592, 0.45146605372428894, 0.1144930049777031, 0.24332179129123688, 0.4096294343471527, 0.4927070140838623, 0.5017901659011841, -0.21152563393115997, 1.1882989406585693, -0.7161018252372742, -0.13682031631469727, 1.2424737215042114, -0.6777696013450623, 0.5659072399139404, 0.5862134099006653, -0.2749614417552948, 0.41456472873687744, 0.6479842066764832, 0.3560616672039032, 0.2903188467025757, 0.24399803578853607, -0.1500493586063385, -0.11499876528978348, -0.6516824960708618, -0.6139224767684937, 0.6411523222923279, 0.6799815893173218, -0.025410054251551628, -0.18734095990657806, -0.2562102675437927, 0.10900291800498962, 0.6292550563812256, -0.2019728273153305, 0.3911650776863098, -0.12861761450767517, -0.7147943377494812, 0.1869758665561676, -0.3828807771205902, 0.9271224737167358, -0.9125646948814392, 0.17148472368717194, -0.7519698143005371, 0.3894875645637512, -0.16193783283233643, -0.74092036485672, 0.39660701155662537, 0.15159855782985687, -0.0027243327349424362, -0.02690870314836502, 0.595649003982544, -0.6265239715576172, -0.731448769569397, 0.5982708930969238, 0.3110508918762207, 0.18828417360782623, 0.13903158903121948, -0.2651277780532837, 0.4921785593032837, -0.07900726050138474, 0.23291964828968048, 0.37401971220970154, 0.2535752058029175, -0.1770283430814743, 0.8460597991943359, 0.4870229959487915, 0.30902695655822754, 0.33836933970451355, 0.24622154235839844, 0.6879842281341553, -0.47083404660224915, -0.1437905877828598, -0.7616016268730164, 0.1797764152288437, -0.5011466145515442, -0.6776201128959656, 1.0349159240722656, 0.6934913396835327, 1.0929783582687378, 0.33944225311279297, 1.0105695724487305, -0.11055105924606323, 0.8330714702606201, 0.05868850648403168, 0.7086071372032166, -0.4276794493198395, 0.18553532660007477, -0.20734599232673645, -0.8736490607261658, 0.021393390372395515, 0.4439748525619507, -0.5732899904251099, -0.05337630584836006, 0.11194493621587753, 0.9379962086677551, 0.03322157636284828, 0.09483817964792252, -0.048297155648469925, 0.1638713777065277, 0.24821442365646362, 0.42476049065589905, 0.7582634687423706, -0.44088226556777954, 0.39824503660202026, -0.39329153299331665, -0.307672381401062, 0.069676473736763, -0.7017817497253418, -0.9698852300643921, -0.6194506883621216, -0.03365691751241684, -0.23451367020606995, 0.23591844737529755, 1.1787043809890747, 0.6281650066375732, -0.8657873272895813, -0.6509508490562439, 0.2854498028755188, 0.14814527332782745, 0.11562953889369965, -0.21877527236938477, 0.1043030396103859, -0.3312756419181824, -0.9847888350486755, 0.16499587893486023, 0.36191442608833313, -0.41985803842544556, -0.6801874041557312, 0.010093620978295803, -0.5037434101104736, 0.2827169895172119, 0.39510080218315125, 0.5582854151725769, -0.431819349527359, -0.0939391627907753, -0.386259526014328, -0.16654418408870697, 0.08438945561647415, 0.7628238797187805, -0.63193279504776, 0.5728621482849121, 0.5619229078292847, 0.5678341388702393, 0.3783261477947235, -0.2811199426651001, 0.5464975833892822, -0.6538904905319214, 0.5836168527603149, 0.11235611140727997, 0.6847584247589111, 0.9735171794891357, 0.03172745555639267, 0.8762270212173462, 0.0628298670053482, -0.44627583026885986, -0.9572967290878296, 0.09042995423078537, -0.7921209931373596, 0.11655396968126297, 1.4855188131332397, 0.4321093261241913, -0.20999497175216675, -0.28593704104423523, -0.012681076303124428, 0.2878406345844269, -0.5525331497192383, 1.1320414543151855, 0.608260452747345, 0.3401786684989929, 0.15960811078548431, -0.5673458576202393, 0.36052238941192627, 0.3954720199108124, -0.6331528425216675, 0.11493643373250961, 0.3217199742794037, 0.36411935091018677, 0.12886148691177368, 0.7846937775611877, -0.2907271385192871, -0.06992363184690475, -0.04074760898947716, 0.3494918942451477, 0.34260818362236023, 0.02638697810471058, -0.17317184805870056, -0.08769562840461731, -0.20450864732265472, -0.08033760637044907 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20145v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20145v2
Fine-tuning Large Language Models for Automated Diagnostic Screening Summaries
2024-03-29T12:25:37
2024-04-04T10:36:48
Manjeet Yadav, Nilesh Kumar Sahu, Mudita Chaturvedi, Snehil Gupta, Haroon R Lone
cs.CL
cs.CL
Improving mental health support in developing countries is a pressing need. One potential solution is the development of scalable, automated systems to conduct diagnostic screenings, which could help alleviate the burden on mental health professionals. In this work, we evaluate several state-of-the-art Large Language Models (LLMs), with and without fine-tuning, on our custom dataset for generating concise summaries from mental state examinations. We rigorously evaluate four different models for summary generation using established ROUGE metrics and input from human evaluators. The results highlight that our top-performing fine-tuned model outperforms existing models, achieving ROUGE-1 and ROUGE-L values of 0.810 and 0.764, respectively. Furthermore, we assessed the fine-tuned model's generalizability on a publicly available D4 dataset, and the outcomes were promising, indicating its potential applicability beyond our custom dataset.
[ -0.43743669986724854, -0.5109606385231018, 0.8922134637832642, 0.060500551015138626, -0.2797749638557434, -0.08913948386907578, -0.2741985619068146, -0.39510053396224976, 0.3821884095668793, 0.6961129903793335, -0.3869786560535431, -0.7069390416145325, -0.8290941715240479, 0.45438387989997864, -0.6425614356994629, 1.4067682027816772, -0.007267418783158064, -0.053944606333971024, 0.2815589904785156, -0.048752207309007645, -0.27355486154556274, -0.20705202221870422, -0.8124371767044067, -0.47518834471702576, 0.26741284132003784, 0.38715028762817383, 0.9305283427238464, 0.46410566568374634, 0.6576303243637085, 0.1751907467842102, 0.009520678780972958, 0.6170775890350342, -0.5810811519622803, 0.20415085554122925, -0.2415604442358017, -0.20529349148273468, -1.0365147590637207, -0.020328139886260033, 0.40808793902397156, 0.738300085067749, -0.27307891845703125, 0.465787798166275, -0.04974254220724106, 0.48370757699012756, -0.6068528294563293, 0.24189679324626923, -0.438323974609375, -0.10308067500591278, 0.13857142627239227, 0.04841596633195877, -0.2506546080112457, -0.4604995548725128, -0.17252220213413239, -0.3252183794975281, 0.283198744058609, -0.3526107370853424, 0.8459060192108154, 0.3567121922969818, -0.4764070212841034, -0.02506893500685692, -0.7686702609062195, 0.4070464074611664, -0.9209095239639282, -0.05589490383863449, 0.6998100876808167, 0.5534998178482056, 0.01002577692270279, -0.7663437128067017, -0.3105505108833313, -0.1545996367931366, -0.16569741070270538, 0.1820642203092575, -0.4105337858200073, 0.2977241277694702, 0.3207463026046753, 0.49638447165489197, -0.4797046184539795, 0.41420623660087585, -0.4098353981971741, -0.31766149401664734, 1.1628056764602661, 0.8808366060256958, 0.14934088289737701, 0.04824221879243851, 0.39409494400024414, 0.13624967634677887, -0.5080860257148743, -0.1430782824754715, 0.050829239189624786, 0.35550692677497864, -0.47501277923583984, 0.61836177110672, -0.6767213940620422, 0.6594295501708984, 0.17471259832382202, -0.365066260099411, -0.2321132868528366, -0.5681053400039673, -0.3033660352230072, -0.40151479840278625, 0.7059076428413391, 0.9978085160255432, 0.6470550298690796, 0.016271838918328285, -0.7091221213340759, 0.11043526977300644, 0.16308853030204773, -1.0468813180923462, -0.4884244203567505, 0.33369359374046326, -0.5174127817153931, -0.16418540477752686, -0.1733371913433075, -0.7162405848503113, -0.6692267656326294, -0.5062728524208069, 0.17020836472511292, -0.3567431569099426, -0.13134007155895233, 0.33806857466697693, 0.0003361667331773788, -0.21126805245876312, 0.4983254671096802, -0.9174768924713135, 0.4729531407356262, 0.5039433836936951, 0.9615628123283386, -0.28006723523139954, 0.08222725242376328, -0.6425818800926208, 0.022732192650437355, -0.4598095417022705, 0.7472045421600342, -0.4767031669616699, -0.4898851215839386, -0.04104119911789894, -0.058351293206214905, -0.05127439275383949, -0.6718924641609192, 0.3546690344810486, -0.12446556240320206, -0.216500386595726, -0.15566368401050568, -0.400383323431015, 0.17343109846115112, 0.3116661012172699, -0.5675921440124512, 0.5268391966819763, 0.49448972940444946, -0.6114232540130615, 0.47082000970840454, -0.39940446615219116, -0.5038392543792725, -0.0439564473927021, -0.04441175237298012, -0.338850200176239, 0.1915937066078186, 0.5648404359817505, 0.6326285004615784, -0.3757440745830536, 0.4749431312084198, -0.3332124650478363, -0.6073983311653137, 0.028796397149562836, -0.26550304889678955, 0.6465664505958557, 0.11339172720909119, -0.1733175367116928, 0.33703067898750305, -0.6727105379104614, -0.06193209066987038, -0.04293674975633621, -0.0764315128326416, -0.1676841676235199, -0.04071979969739914, -0.026541445404291153, 0.09009295701980591, 0.07976197451353073, -0.27866384387016296, 0.1326880007982254, -0.5224363803863525, 0.3004884719848633, 0.41689929366111755, 0.32201844453811646, 0.04551168158650398, -0.448978990316391, 0.8700759410858154, -0.027012482285499573, 0.24523413181304932, -0.39862489700317383, -0.34554338455200195, -0.5534483790397644, -0.8223391175270081, 0.20397254824638367, 0.5469708442687988, -0.2776491940021515, 0.5589888691902161, -0.16936559975147247, -0.5350589752197266, -0.6425108909606934, -0.12708020210266113, 0.10224471986293793, 0.45204421877861023, 0.2925214171409607, -0.2982363998889923, -0.5273821353912354, -1.181531310081482, -0.07993941009044647, 0.010827876627445221, -0.24626295268535614, 0.22700364887714386, 0.6069525480270386, -0.6209522485733032, 0.8363873958587646, -0.9384856820106506, -0.2857523560523987, -0.6252833008766174, -0.14688122272491455, 0.34088900685310364, -0.05084649845957756, 0.6715596318244934, -0.21358047425746918, -0.39068207144737244, 0.018230020999908447, -0.5678470134735107, -0.33821985125541687, 0.11367661505937576, 0.23445813357830048, 0.17772766947746277, 0.3832941949367523, -0.505096971988678, 0.5297386646270752, 0.5131624341011047, -0.37493786215782166, 0.8555757999420166, -0.5343065857887268, 0.12988907098770142, -1.147329568862915, 0.1035454049706459, 0.29198136925697327, -0.4825185239315033, -0.4348744750022888, 0.14431726932525635, -0.005900482647120953, -0.2234247624874115, 0.2199656218290329, 0.736147403717041, -0.05076410621404648, 0.18745435774326324, -0.44161975383758545, 0.2894403636455536, -0.10377677530050278, 0.09304019808769226, -0.2967020571231842, 0.5432558059692383, 0.6180326342582703, -0.7035570740699768, 0.17089349031448364, -0.003034705063328147, -0.18187546730041504, 0.40280959010124207, -0.7370687127113342, -0.379416823387146, -0.03379204496741295, 0.47819188237190247, -0.8317865133285522, -0.6849631667137146, -0.20874761044979095, -0.0021618881728500128, 0.20630064606666565, 0.10828270763158798, -0.5279080867767334, -0.40654391050338745, -0.3016654849052429, 0.2180255800485611, 0.6032626628875732, -0.17392326891422272, 0.07298634201288223, 0.7404685616493225, -0.37181180715560913, -0.16392524540424347, -0.43386489152908325, 0.022529108449816704, -0.296299546957016, -0.31017985939979553, 0.06605113297700882, 0.1608887016773224, -0.4437462389469147, -0.48211929202079773, -0.024173690006136894, -0.1633252054452896, 0.19533538818359375, 0.060559652745723724, 0.19987668097019196, -0.1449737399816513, 0.0032461504451930523, 0.2910154163837433, -0.14565132558345795, 0.11632072925567627, 0.06391338258981705, 0.4801945090293884, -0.10839416831731796, -0.239247664809227, -0.47439441084861755, 0.4221031367778778, 0.7110907435417175, -0.4080714285373688, 0.4591454565525055, 0.45451757311820984, -0.7245987057685852, -0.29234209656715393, -0.24483735859394073, -0.44332751631736755, -0.41284534335136414, 0.6059534549713135, -0.0706377848982811, -0.8575960397720337, 0.6614635586738586, 0.04391422122716904, 0.12312301993370056, 0.4233795404434204, 0.6984187960624695, 0.027938317507505417, 1.5963425636291504, 0.9919542670249939, -0.1507849395275116, 0.08633174747228622, -0.21302133798599243, 0.4293844401836395, -0.6096475124359131, 0.2105763703584671, -0.362167090177536, -0.24322538077831268, -0.7708702683448792, -0.1429549902677536, 0.7402651906013489, -0.06896770000457764, -0.17104974389076233, -0.05020523443818092, -0.29727062582969666, 0.3507208228111267, -0.07455355674028397, 0.16114625334739685, 0.4982587993144989, -0.11672218143939972, -0.10197365283966064, -0.1446353644132614, -0.38415083289146423, -0.8972331881523132, 1.1322834491729736, 0.2940216064453125, 0.921727180480957, 0.03247753903269768, 0.637181282043457, 0.28864359855651855, 0.5339652299880981, -0.6422518491744995, 0.5688394904136658, -0.6195030808448792, -0.3501565456390381, -0.4062524437904358, -0.1710459291934967, -0.9080208539962769, 0.17009972035884857, -0.012658650055527687, -0.9986361265182495, -0.0810837671160698, 0.3772262930870056, -0.7802173495292664, 0.1728091686964035, -0.591923713684082, 0.5807986855506897, 0.07785896956920624, 0.2353716790676117, -0.5258167386054993, -0.3046310245990753, 0.9372048377990723, -0.4258037805557251, 0.023678792640566826, -0.3609429597854614, 0.03169599920511246, 0.41201284527778625, -0.47669926285743713, 0.849053144454956, -0.0045104981400072575, -0.29374489188194275, -0.12658338248729706, 0.11281818151473999, 0.17748841643333435, 0.4746885597705841, -0.3474629819393158, -0.18546554446220398, 0.22409690916538239, -0.18783631920814514, -0.5341893434524536, 0.37346863746643066, -0.4513780176639557, -0.7173013091087341, 0.04742402955889702, -0.7963069677352905, -0.38858509063720703, 0.3502272069454193, 0.2118525207042694, 0.5845965147018433, -0.28464800119400024, -0.31295427680015564, 0.446612685918808, -0.3297818601131439, 0.1628095805644989, 0.711279571056366, -0.47393161058425903, -0.24910135567188263, 0.6443897485733032, 0.18603730201721191, 0.26572415232658386, -0.09653809666633606, 0.23287330567836761, -0.044000472873449326, -0.6730929613113403, -0.4829685688018799, 0.5226548314094543, -0.5114580988883972, -0.3143330514431, -0.792335569858551, -0.35210806131362915, -0.5712723731994629, -0.05694304034113884, -0.24942611157894135, -0.36138445138931274, -0.023041995242238045, -0.181407630443573, 0.3782356083393097, 0.9137675166130066, 0.04183533415198326, 0.25336554646492004, -0.6620000004768372, 0.5955777168273926, -0.06385474652051926, 0.5250362157821655, -0.054880574345588684, -0.7694552540779114, -0.6002533435821533, 0.16569234430789948, -0.423467755317688, -0.8231717348098755, 0.5323479175567627, 0.2690931260585785, 0.3944352865219116, 0.574449360370636, 0.33864736557006836, 0.8242549896240234, -0.2694529592990875, 0.656823456287384, -0.1618446260690689, -0.6329123377799988, 0.7648098468780518, -0.6456502676010132, 0.5691155195236206, 0.6003279685974121, 0.21434113383293152, -0.4676755964756012, -0.9585441946983337, -0.38187745213508606, -0.7898030877113342, 0.6384848952293396, 0.006218914873898029, 0.017208300530910492, -0.04407636448740959, 0.4018738269805908, 0.17126958072185516, -0.02397190034389496, -0.17627550661563873, -0.15770922601222992, 0.17365601658821106, -0.4831083118915558, -0.4366268515586853, -0.08409913629293442, -0.46308353543281555, -0.3598759174346924, 0.3828418254852295, -0.28176143765449524, -0.07186564803123474, 0.2140640914440155, -0.04693097993731499, -0.07237721979618073, 0.11624740064144135, 0.7131112813949585, 0.7515484094619751, -0.1624722182750702, -0.025306109338998795, 0.2393210083246231, -0.7181910276412964, 0.09648455679416656, 0.3095184564590454, -0.3709813058376312, 0.11361489444971085, 0.39086395502090454, 0.7439036965370178, -0.13998113572597504, -0.9478120803833008, 0.33881038427352905, -0.31056714057922363, -0.15905655920505524, -0.05084411799907684, 0.3699634075164795, 0.04729798808693886, 0.24610674381256104, -0.02378278598189354, -0.09496883302927017, 0.3875442147254944, -0.315394788980484, 0.1972809135913849, 0.4672601521015167, -0.12189994752407074, -0.46818217635154724, 0.5376269221305847, 0.07384432852268219, -0.278665691614151, 0.6852743029594421, -0.3714221119880676, -0.14489205181598663, 0.7058491110801697, 0.6289325952529907, 0.843418538570404, -0.10129029303789139, 0.42825832962989807, 0.5835692286491394, 0.5767307281494141, -0.2808537483215332, 0.444218248128891, 0.22002126276493073, -0.5776978135108948, -0.3141065537929535, -0.5981602072715759, -0.5328136682510376, 0.44825226068496704, -0.7792430520057678, 0.456814706325531, -0.32736051082611084, -0.4554000794887543, -0.16597917675971985, 0.04499616101384163, -0.62684166431427, 0.4533456265926361, 0.22761636972427368, 0.9431461691856384, -0.8958647847175598, 0.6379913687705994, 0.630179226398468, -0.2741142511367798, -0.8863477110862732, 0.2416645735502243, -0.1644189953804016, -0.4049876034259796, 0.017549142241477966, 0.2202325463294983, -0.14720991253852844, -0.14211039245128632, -0.19559432566165924, -0.9675113558769226, 0.9680824875831604, 0.7652963399887085, -0.5430856347084045, -0.04869438707828522, -0.009894079528748989, 0.9488962292671204, -0.47587665915489197, 0.4514140188694, 1.1751772165298462, 0.5055304765701294, -0.5392637848854065, -1.272250771522522, 0.016109084710478783, -0.14340908825397491, -0.2289275825023651, 0.18822529911994934, -0.39756542444229126, 0.7251001000404358, -0.6310968399047852, -0.37569713592529297, 0.07641468197107315, 0.2825293242931366, 0.5309548377990723, 0.32693496346473694, 0.30078038573265076, 0.3848474621772766, 1.047465205192566, -0.060268763452768326, 1.3602583408355713, -0.47679805755615234, 0.1852179616689682, 1.206483244895935, -0.45468005537986755, 0.5676897168159485, -0.12966521084308624, -0.10591519623994827, 0.22010833024978638, 0.8264842629432678, -0.0065457746386528015, 0.17225868999958038, 0.1818004548549652, 0.029404232278466225, -0.2549284100532532, -0.0651654377579689, -0.06754689663648605, 0.44674038887023926, 0.6065126657485962, -0.47344663739204407, -0.4133131206035614, -0.09728221595287323, -0.09094216674566269, 0.12494119256734848, -0.5598402619361877, 0.6273250579833984, 0.1992494761943817, -0.8410132527351379, 0.6764267683029175, 0.25554850697517395, 0.4633900225162506, -0.4735352098941803, 0.24377509951591492, -0.6613413691520691, 0.3908589482307434, -0.39357176423072815, -0.7083669304847717, 0.4683224558830261, 0.3854730427265167, -0.25843778252601624, 0.043458156287670135, 0.5043907761573792, -0.4100147783756256, -0.694242537021637, 0.21944430470466614, 0.5171576738357544, 0.22705963253974915, 0.0272075068205595, -0.3844897150993347, -0.2598450481891632, -0.16645407676696777, -0.09619076550006866, 0.31042733788490295, 0.32195723056793213, -0.6528444290161133, 0.7310584187507629, 0.07799927890300751, 0.5281254053115845, -0.22184081375598907, 0.5482103824615479, 0.6390876173973083, -0.6202743649482727, -0.6692315340042114, -0.9613665342330933, 0.4139013886451721, -0.10658444464206696, -0.42666611075401306, 0.5755727291107178, 0.48657089471817017, 0.5536633133888245, 0.0036977031268179417, 0.8085181713104248, 0.33162355422973633, 0.5204068422317505, -0.26373806595802307, 0.9296520352363586, -0.5737199783325195, 0.12213990092277527, -0.2314552515745163, -0.47124800086021423, -0.3373933732509613, 0.30636152625083923, -0.1467444747686386, 0.18909871578216553, 0.6173725128173828, 1.0127776861190796, -0.033893752843141556, -0.21820150315761566, 0.48477765917778015, 0.2626652419567108, 0.3744634985923767, 0.33427831530570984, 0.40798288583755493, -0.14101245999336243, 0.04717887565493584, -0.09497331082820892, -0.33198803663253784, -0.3138653635978699, -0.6321108937263489, -0.8639345169067383, -0.3785874843597412, -0.38627517223358154, -0.0930214673280716, 0.05807836353778839, 0.6906879544258118, 0.731577455997467, -0.8908331990242004, -0.3134376108646393, 0.3306523561477661, 0.018952200189232826, -0.34647464752197266, -0.15682365000247955, 0.2807861566543579, -0.1920785754919052, -0.6870158910751343, 0.17088449001312256, 0.5900171399116516, -0.08686894178390503, -0.43937280774116516, 0.12454966455698013, 0.3822380602359772, 0.2988000810146332, 0.7737274169921875, -0.08198834955692291, -0.7753133177757263, -0.09690620005130768, -0.16585734486579895, -0.45380693674087524, -0.2425881326198578, 0.7310284376144409, -0.7174575924873352, 0.30662456154823303, 0.2859569787979126, 0.3974015414714813, 0.2189287543296814, 0.12350662797689438, 0.9538025856018066, -0.3754529356956482, -0.08685711771249771, 0.28504931926727295, 0.5781639218330383, 0.24604405462741852, -0.4201420843601227, 0.44081956148147583, -0.27763471007347107, -0.48951345682144165, -1.0646984577178955, 0.3818100094795227, -0.672949492931366, -0.06146858260035515, 1.1157792806625366, 0.009034648537635803, 0.1781156212091446, -0.2561888098716736, -0.26018139719963074, 0.4326476454734802, -0.26559653878211975, 1.034340739250183, 0.5473587512969971, -0.497583270072937, 0.07228352129459381, -0.5132138133049011, 0.5869792699813843, 0.2317277491092682, -0.9580084681510925, 0.3235711455345154, 0.4661265015602112, 0.3723437190055847, -0.26746851205825806, 0.938502848148346, -0.04614686593413353, 0.4859027564525604, -0.3503216505050659, -0.09577756375074387, 0.13842402398586273, -0.15329332649707794, -0.6726953387260437, -0.08088923245668411, 0.04780185967683792, 0.36699870228767395 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01327v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01327v1
Entertainment chatbot for the digital inclusion of elderly people without abstraction capabilities
2024-03-29T12:10:21
2024-03-29T12:10:21
Silvia García-Méndez, Francisco de Arriba-Pérez, Francisco J. González-Castaño, José A. Regueiro-Janeiro, Felipe Gil-Castiñeira
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG
Current language processing technologies allow the creation of conversational chatbot platforms. Even though artificial intelligence is still too immature to support satisfactory user experience in many mass market domains, conversational interfaces have found their way into ad hoc applications such as call centres and online shopping assistants. However, they have not been applied so far to social inclusion of elderly people, who are particularly vulnerable to the digital divide. Many of them relieve their loneliness with traditional media such as TV and radio, which are known to create a feeling of companionship. In this paper we present the EBER chatbot, designed to reduce the digital gap for the elderly. EBER reads news in the background and adapts its responses to the user's mood. Its novelty lies in the concept of "intelligent radio", according to which, instead of simplifying a digital information system to make it accessible to the elderly, a traditional channel they find familiar -- background news -- is augmented with interactions via voice dialogues. We make it possible by combining Artificial Intelligence Modelling Language, automatic Natural Language Generation and Sentiment Analysis. The system allows accessing digital content of interest by combining words extracted from user answers to chatbot questions with keywords extracted from the news items. This approach permits defining metrics of the abstraction capabilities of the users depending on a spatial representation of the word space. To prove the suitability of the proposed solution we present results of real experiments conducted with elderly people that provided valuable insights. Our approach was considered satisfactory during the tests and improved the information search capabilities of the participants.
[ -0.5981830954551697, -0.8119706511497498, 0.4682549238204956, 0.16184182465076447, -0.3331787884235382, 0.2108433097600937, -0.12634368240833282, -0.6838759779930115, 0.7038010954856873, 0.06382861733436584, -0.63301020860672, -0.47694313526153564, -0.3446277678012848, -0.19378550350666046, -0.09470552206039429, 0.614625096321106, 0.34602731466293335, -0.08394674211740494, -0.5072166919708252, -0.06403796374797821, -0.40189746022224426, -0.35859325528144836, -0.9110298156738281, -0.1822967380285263, 0.10433094948530197, 0.4948562979698181, 0.8833818435668945, -0.02042240835726261, 0.4198480248451233, 0.46605756878852844, -0.09169367700815201, 0.22322265803813934, -0.4007345139980316, 0.11883573979139328, 0.06238192692399025, -0.7035037279129028, -0.6848855018615723, -0.3893602192401886, -0.11699779331684113, 0.35973605513572693, -0.08942895382642746, -0.17998836934566498, -0.27730804681777954, 1.1238055229187012, -0.5105738043785095, 0.3191133141517639, -0.3409070372581482, 0.1841524988412857, 0.034710709005594254, -0.4078548550605774, -0.024887381121516228, -0.5106387734413147, -0.1105571836233139, -0.5418344736099243, -0.10868681222200394, 0.12076814472675323, 0.648013174533844, 0.6194677948951721, -0.029866967350244522, -0.6809780597686768, -1.184363842010498, 0.5105208158493042, -0.7136955857276917, 0.3725965619087219, 0.8202903866767883, 0.5555036067962646, -0.061248838901519775, -0.18299460411071777, -0.7674807906150818, -0.538271963596344, 0.06891171634197235, 0.3637010157108307, -0.41361111402511597, 0.16409382224082947, -0.3047126233577728, 0.3101368844509125, -0.4497516453266144, -0.11842871457338333, -0.5867305994033813, 0.03374737501144409, 0.5762890577316284, 0.1809777319431305, 0.6246733069419861, -0.20121413469314575, 0.1323482245206833, 0.3176388442516327, -0.1832934468984604, 0.0855659767985344, 0.6670246720314026, -0.21231748163700104, -0.33060452342033386, 0.6670091152191162, -0.5467661023139954, 0.3672814667224884, 0.23397192358970642, -0.0016128559364005923, 0.5351001024246216, -0.12246149778366089, 0.33731499314308167, 0.3509857952594757, 0.43084537982940674, 0.600191056728363, 0.5919860005378723, -0.22518879175186157, 0.006630989722907543, 0.16301240026950836, 0.1626928150653839, -0.2628629207611084, -0.38562577962875366, 0.7469613552093506, -0.5283939838409424, -0.007757426705211401, 0.23024551570415497, -0.6568352580070496, -0.24748706817626953, -0.1083952933549881, 0.1468605250120163, -0.5886473655700684, -0.3561657667160034, 0.23384766280651093, -0.5777297616004944, -0.025729522109031677, 0.46199288964271545, -0.8712783455848694, 0.3094072937965393, 0.24877113103866577, 0.7698284983634949, 0.10766217857599258, 0.3941996693611145, -0.2769301235675812, 0.27927425503730774, 0.28844907879829407, 0.8072783946990967, -0.7149004340171814, -0.45230773091316223, -0.13785240054130554, -0.03370526432991028, 0.4392051100730896, -0.41324490308761597, 0.5030558109283447, -0.6964866518974304, 0.6785826086997986, 0.5249623656272888, -0.1466420292854309, -0.09103666990995407, 0.16379527747631073, -0.6368211507797241, 0.7154231667518616, 0.30112171173095703, -0.48619508743286133, -0.011143374256789684, -1.1289030313491821, -0.4465196430683136, 0.25040769577026367, -0.0018097037682309747, -0.39629456400871277, 0.13987062871456146, 0.4682309329509735, -0.16592992842197418, 0.024435734376311302, -0.19163085520267487, -0.42129141092300415, -0.5363622307777405, 0.25387829542160034, -0.45085978507995605, 0.49189141392707825, 0.35108157992362976, -0.4215426743030548, -0.09517405182123184, -0.5098559260368347, 0.16341166198253632, 0.042511891573667526, -0.3373652398586273, -0.42028966546058655, 0.33741992712020874, 0.28301262855529785, 0.24268889427185059, 0.33357101678848267, -0.5124433040618896, -0.13140863180160522, -0.4130464196205139, 0.5304309725761414, 0.3386315405368805, -0.1700955480337143, 0.6119335889816284, -0.5660313963890076, 0.47931721806526184, 0.014493947848677635, 0.37115320563316345, -0.18843284249305725, -0.3851892054080963, -0.661899983882904, -0.16926807165145874, 0.29027870297431946, 0.8592742681503296, -0.7818517684936523, 0.9930033087730408, -0.5377917289733887, -0.2630007565021515, -0.6082014441490173, 0.05507012829184532, -0.27912887930870056, -0.24877506494522095, 0.20391662418842316, -0.43398964405059814, -0.3927200436592102, -0.5913397073745728, 0.1472889631986618, -0.4312831163406372, -0.5528351664543152, 0.6247392296791077, -0.11752854287624359, -0.31623563170433044, 0.8277787566184998, -0.11254823952913284, -0.6871033310890198, -0.2171689122915268, -0.007811838760972023, 0.056432705372571945, 0.39443716406822205, 0.06733670830726624, -1.183093547821045, -0.04767660051584244, 0.09877949208021164, -0.8177720308303833, -0.2389543205499649, -0.1542264074087143, 0.2970365285873413, 0.15880358219146729, 0.2804650366306305, -0.6264089345932007, 0.5269007682800293, 0.4971798360347748, -0.04517607390880585, 0.0010001001646742225, -0.34397828578948975, 0.2767825126647949, -0.7177848219871521, -0.11659412831068039, -0.195786252617836, -0.18585620820522308, -0.4802497327327728, -0.4844878911972046, -0.47646018862724304, -0.4368179440498352, -0.42155104875564575, 0.4340788424015045, -0.6380480527877808, -0.05688275396823883, -0.3908352851867676, 0.6632394790649414, -0.1326351910829544, 0.3801673948764801, -0.04235411062836647, 0.2159641534090042, 0.32951849699020386, -0.4382399916648865, 0.40371301770210266, 0.1821874976158142, 0.1307513415813446, 0.7530863285064697, -0.5921376943588257, 0.4463517963886261, -0.632168173789978, 0.3803330063819885, -1.2960759401321411, -0.3028164207935333, 0.4904354214668274, -0.8209282159805298, -0.05746671184897423, 0.29399609565734863, -0.07880055159330368, -0.40780606865882874, -0.40949591994285583, 0.3600725531578064, 0.6413847208023071, 0.14111924171447754, 1.0381836891174316, 0.6351066827774048, -0.759292483329773, -0.06732231378555298, -0.5561502575874329, 0.40052828192710876, -0.2907428443431854, -1.0009320974349976, 0.5470921397209167, -0.14553430676460266, -0.30075153708457947, 0.440374493598938, 0.17846830189228058, -0.11588141322135925, -0.13214224576950073, 0.29550623893737793, 0.22983288764953613, -0.1747000813484192, 0.2573760449886322, 0.163516104221344, -0.2280779480934143, -0.28358936309814453, 0.03953293338418007, 0.8525531888008118, -0.3659546673297882, -0.6333879828453064, -0.8162531852722168, 0.6872456669807434, 0.8743827939033508, -0.14113231003284454, 0.5085397362709045, 0.5791804790496826, -0.24861620366573334, 0.17847640812397003, -0.7980625629425049, -0.035914819687604904, -0.5395301580429077, 0.23027275502681732, -0.031284820288419724, -0.8282684087753296, 0.39731714129447937, -0.1926901936531067, 0.0369638130068779, 0.09855163842439651, 0.51750648021698, -0.3032704293727875, 1.1525635719299316, 0.4728550910949707, 0.11627411097288132, 0.8768719434738159, 0.16297020018100739, 0.29192060232162476, -0.4566305875778198, -0.3522232174873352, -0.3414153456687927, -0.6701703667640686, -0.5664862990379333, -0.12233457714319229, 0.29021087288856506, -0.009028545580804348, 0.044253021478652954, -0.12290451675653458, -0.5211917161941528, 0.21470747888088226, 0.5975085496902466, 0.4838000237941742, 0.42889806628227234, -0.20616942644119263, 0.677075982093811, 0.04241468384861946, -0.5962061285972595, -0.5697447061538696, 0.38515979051589966, 0.3487865626811981, 1.0444856882095337, 0.425937682390213, 0.7764996290206909, 0.7840051651000977, 0.34800028800964355, -1.014594554901123, 0.49254536628723145, -0.17741499841213226, -0.5209534764289856, -0.44559016823768616, -0.4297490417957306, -0.8280192017555237, -0.5966280698776245, -0.09060294181108475, -0.7532969117164612, 0.2545401453971863, -0.16258785128593445, -0.41942769289016724, -0.037472911179065704, -0.7931950092315674, 0.06948966532945633, -0.606198787689209, -0.20318058133125305, -0.5096089839935303, -0.7310424447059631, 0.0783679187297821, 0.04166264832019806, 0.6208617687225342, -0.30642619729042053, -0.041874904185533524, 0.3662847578525543, -0.10409160703420639, 0.800870954990387, -0.14435748755931854, 0.46855130791664124, 0.3489600419998169, -0.06870614737272263, 0.3967064619064331, -0.20252694189548492, 0.05502073094248772, 0.06075814738869667, -0.03644183278083801, -0.3959069848060608, -0.5882658362388611, 0.6330471038818359, -0.8546470403671265, -0.8309575319290161, 0.057966213673353195, -0.4916526973247528, -0.10188672691583633, 0.034082502126693726, -0.21542063355445862, 0.33683422207832336, -0.14212125539779663, 0.5666877031326294, 0.19822819530963898, -0.4812552332878113, 0.34272319078445435, 0.3334258794784546, 0.056327514350414276, -0.35267025232315063, 0.8213897943496704, -0.023391684517264366, 0.17399315536022186, 0.3871086537837982, 0.1039464995265007, -0.42303702235221863, -0.3354978859424591, -0.4599890112876892, 0.07936388999223709, -0.6997706890106201, 0.3007928729057312, -0.8796104192733765, -0.22898733615875244, -0.2144414335489273, -0.3032965064048767, 0.15212352573871613, -0.541606068611145, -0.16655994951725006, 0.18862392008304596, 0.23951199650764465, 0.5571738481521606, -0.1639620065689087, 0.44592908024787903, -1.1067616939544678, 0.46507835388183594, 0.3122197389602661, 0.3007837235927582, -0.06375996023416519, 0.02320503257215023, -0.12215548753738403, 0.09366874396800995, -0.4453609883785248, -0.8023803234100342, 0.2683663070201874, 0.5252055525779724, 0.8738524317741394, 0.3171820044517517, 0.2934483289718628, 0.3537355959415436, -0.4028872549533844, 0.8054077625274658, 0.2791149318218231, -0.7040120363235474, 0.5281230807304382, -0.3193409740924835, 0.29136422276496887, 0.6558612585067749, 0.3131794035434723, -0.6470035910606384, -0.6556673049926758, -0.6320951581001282, -0.9934555888175964, 0.29687535762786865, 0.20277585089206696, 0.5812573432922363, -0.06256681680679321, -0.11605769395828247, -0.08521424978971481, 0.3028738498687744, -0.5669371485710144, -0.16969840228557587, -0.42703893780708313, -0.5446217060089111, 0.5351226329803467, 0.04948333278298378, 0.0996459573507309, -0.08510548621416092, 0.4229561686515808, 0.23661087453365326, 0.6537102460861206, 0.1372143030166626, 0.04849449545145035, -0.24846960604190826, 0.28124743700027466, 0.2950012683868408, 0.5690582394599915, -0.26356545090675354, 0.09020036458969116, 0.0021836727391928434, -0.2981632649898529, 0.162111297249794, 0.04476984962821007, 0.2899459898471832, 0.19265390932559967, -0.12319473177194595, 0.409408837556839, 0.1879543960094452, -0.9807486534118652, 0.3277174234390259, -0.3209185004234314, 0.1689164936542511, -0.8417454957962036, 0.39028728008270264, 0.4851115047931671, 0.30185216665267944, 0.5122190117835999, 0.25954657793045044, 0.14566724002361298, -0.8955420851707458, 0.6098015308380127, 0.4509671926498413, -0.7518575191497803, -0.0026550497859716415, 0.8313221335411072, 0.5576201677322388, -1.253038763999939, 0.5373252630233765, -0.2658460736274719, -0.3371472954750061, 0.37175050377845764, 0.30022427439689636, 1.0571885108947754, -0.16977137327194214, 0.2911273241043091, -0.09027357399463654, 0.16588915884494781, 0.30370619893074036, 0.24668572843074799, -0.18118168413639069, -0.670327365398407, -0.2951476275920868, -0.34175828099250793, -0.5018019676208496, -0.12609265744686127, -0.26811039447784424, 0.4025566279888153, -0.3352915644645691, -0.320234477519989, -0.08117502927780151, -0.386880099773407, -0.6920709609985352, 0.05387240648269653, 0.4434662461280823, 0.692244827747345, -0.6530500650405884, 0.40876591205596924, 0.5209136009216309, -0.3431110680103302, -0.04541374742984772, 0.43649253249168396, -0.11899919807910919, -0.6988421082496643, 0.5135952830314636, 0.1530124396085739, -0.3366686999797821, 0.20406393706798553, -0.4045168161392212, -0.4166916012763977, 0.8969017863273621, -0.10344730317592621, -0.29712533950805664, -0.15046727657318115, 0.020706957206130028, 0.6132338643074036, -0.37841445207595825, 0.690525472164154, 0.1364946812391281, 0.6638087034225464, 0.43971359729766846, -0.6859313249588013, -0.2595570981502533, -0.7377626299858093, -0.37639176845550537, 0.19613493978977203, -0.7889732122421265, 0.40249019861221313, -0.12189406156539917, -0.4092039465904236, 0.03957945108413696, 0.6438537836074829, 0.13170082867145538, 0.5869861245155334, 0.8379477262496948, 0.16510720551013947, 0.5598971843719482, -0.04637222737073898, 0.7992708086967468, -0.4277019500732422, 0.04643675312399864, 0.6028422117233276, -0.037634849548339844, 0.5517556667327881, 0.3883545994758606, -0.2337130457162857, 0.8185001015663147, 0.35199737548828125, 0.4311447739601135, 0.7026059627532959, 0.10630287975072861, -0.6591597199440002, -0.04966899752616882, -0.35968995094299316, -0.08977197855710983, 0.46352314949035645, 0.6413022875785828, -0.26548412442207336, -0.3138474225997925, -0.031042136251926422, -0.10911601036787033, 0.07533826678991318, -0.09493538737297058, 0.9178804755210876, 0.12199531495571136, -0.24825958907604218, 0.3469083905220032, -0.003369366517290473, 0.7994790077209473, -0.8097463250160217, -0.15240174531936646, 0.02572641521692276, 0.18243126571178436, -0.2670203745365143, -0.5484848618507385, 0.3581693768501282, -0.36682605743408203, 0.11433624476194382, 0.2581555247306824, 0.8777196407318115, -0.3606829345226288, -0.4081067442893982, 0.1428668349981308, 0.8712427616119385, 0.38932424783706665, -0.03860398009419441, -0.765212893486023, -0.01081645954400301, -0.1148976981639862, -0.022596072405576706, -0.02689511701464653, 0.6377590298652649, -0.05352672189474106, 0.7362380027770996, 0.6786231994628906, 0.2816966772079468, -0.33133310079574585, -0.06482189148664474, 0.8489014506340027, -0.7059615254402161, -0.8326806426048279, -0.6496720910072327, 0.6823192238807678, -0.28324249386787415, -0.3128046989440918, 0.40832993388175964, 0.20477183163166046, 0.31569769978523254, 0.18882079422473907, 0.9521219730377197, -0.5930047035217285, 0.04630384221673012, -0.3051002025604248, 0.6408347487449646, -0.5676722526550293, 0.19166453182697296, -0.08658187091350555, -0.8354823589324951, -0.11109144985675812, 0.4713036119937897, -0.49071386456489563, 0.21674959361553192, 0.351142555475235, 0.8014283180236816, -0.07570061832666397, 0.3213708996772766, 0.5189518332481384, -0.26067063212394714, 0.47624582052230835, 0.6766812205314636, 1.0831270217895508, 0.03663627803325653, 0.4962289333343506, 0.009595773182809353, -0.56846684217453, -0.7271195650100708, -0.6669880151748657, -0.8776419162750244, -0.49737048149108887, 0.22055795788764954, -0.10452073067426682, 0.3001093864440918, 1.1533231735229492, 0.4346406161785126, -0.6829120516777039, 0.13676248490810394, 0.10755807161331177, -0.09225676208734512, -0.30962705612182617, -0.3179885745048523, 0.24097073078155518, -0.049697186797857285, -1.0073741674423218, 0.1792498379945755, 0.5160280466079712, 0.09142836183309555, -0.5931724905967712, 0.1163516566157341, 0.18642756342887878, 0.06591586023569107, 0.405841201543808, 0.2442687302827835, -0.55450439453125, -0.6944873332977295, 0.21706731617450714, 0.0891156867146492, 0.4249557852745056, 0.37254229187965393, -0.6401865482330322, 0.6804064512252808, 0.6369555592536926, 0.5545588135719299, 0.4567996561527252, 0.34594061970710754, 0.5014231204986572, -0.3709578812122345, 0.36364173889160156, 0.622690737247467, 0.08581220358610153, 0.478094220161438, -0.6847918033599854, 0.2250765711069107, 0.061060257256031036, -0.488998144865036, -0.336867094039917, 0.09466581791639328, -0.8591471314430237, -0.22507406771183014, 0.9754205942153931, 0.26544108986854553, -0.328705757856369, -0.889083206653595, -0.5853094458580017, 0.23346850275993347, -0.7224981188774109, 1.4100804328918457, 0.5888289213180542, -0.3526129126548767, -0.2880694270133972, -0.8218057155609131, 0.07061976939439774, 0.20789842307567596, -0.8386965990066528, -0.30667829513549805, 0.4538608491420746, -0.05622566491365433, 0.5063983201980591, 0.8453224897384644, -0.3360845148563385, 0.36915746331214905, 0.06952439993619919, 0.1299041360616684, -0.43988037109375, -0.060546405613422394, -0.03764934837818146, 0.3421592116355896, -0.2200043499469757, -0.23243770003318787 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20134v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20134v1
User Modeling Challenges in Interactive AI Assistant Systems
2024-03-29T11:54:13
2024-03-29T11:54:13
Megan Su, Yuwei Bao
cs.CL
cs.CL
Interactive Artificial Intelligent(AI) assistant systems are designed to offer timely guidance to help human users to complete a variety tasks. One of the remaining challenges is to understand user's mental states during the task for more personalized guidance. In this work, we analyze users' mental states during task executions and investigate the capabilities and challenges for large language models to interpret user profiles for more personalized user guidance.
[ -0.35403895378112793, -0.9560520648956299, 0.9341426491737366, 0.1475142389535904, 0.2798817753791809, 0.0066291652619838715, -0.185537651181221, -0.617648720741272, -0.10552223026752472, 0.6732941269874573, -1.1659313440322876, -0.13698187470436096, -0.5385345816612244, 0.3286952078342438, -0.3364328145980835, 0.8986777663230896, -0.19226647913455963, -0.05101781710982323, -0.3592997193336487, 0.19936247169971466, -1.202048659324646, -0.7576591372489929, -0.8589028120040894, -0.3833521604537964, 0.2146306037902832, 0.4052562117576599, 0.8230729699134827, 0.08243125677108765, 0.6223708391189575, 0.47927847504615784, 0.11460603028535843, 0.1487889587879181, -0.12643232941627502, 0.42185068130493164, -0.1764127016067505, -0.49305784702301025, -0.372397243976593, -0.003399943234398961, 0.18678699433803558, 0.7896658182144165, -0.28178754448890686, 0.24817782640457153, -0.14791730046272278, 0.26912105083465576, -0.41019606590270996, 0.3887680470943451, -0.24088504910469055, 0.11915851384401321, -0.4200790822505951, 0.12063581496477127, -0.3988763689994812, -0.08811569213867188, 0.37299102544784546, -0.90191650390625, -0.04096733406186104, 0.1797076016664505, 0.8656941652297974, 0.5852966904640198, -0.5791339874267578, -0.3762223720550537, -1.2154674530029297, 0.45562493801116943, -0.6945651769638062, 0.1835271567106247, 0.516788125038147, 0.6391966938972473, -0.36927494406700134, -0.5475019216537476, -0.9498401880264282, -0.4017396867275238, -0.20883487164974213, -0.07400459796190262, -0.367986798286438, 0.18335291743278503, 0.6112323999404907, -0.03599768504500389, -0.2309403419494629, 0.14560863375663757, -0.24822527170181274, -0.009125490672886372, 0.8264084458351135, 0.6555453538894653, 0.8012582063674927, -0.12362586706876755, 0.06283269822597504, 0.01501854695379734, -0.006139438133686781, 0.2132001668214798, 0.43869924545288086, -0.00847396720200777, -0.264614075422287, 0.8399969339370728, -0.2938699722290039, 0.7480153441429138, 0.12188823521137238, 0.07298364490270615, 0.11535002291202545, -0.20520566403865814, -0.2849140465259552, -0.4662091135978699, 0.7483059167861938, 0.19804206490516663, 0.6512410044670105, -0.13584840297698975, -0.3488922715187073, -0.11109436303377151, 0.48051249980926514, -0.19994334876537323, -0.30187341570854187, 0.3257017135620117, -0.3076898455619812, 0.2044607549905777, 0.05771363526582718, -0.33810773491859436, -0.6382080912590027, -0.7594599723815918, 0.5321120619773865, -0.5826400518417358, -0.09556093066930771, 0.05333839729428291, -0.04063834622502327, -0.025772763416171074, 0.8972914218902588, -0.9947641491889954, 0.5050750374794006, 0.5908883810043335, 0.6607973575592041, -0.18827933073043823, -0.30465197563171387, -0.20753704011440277, 0.10150659829378128, 0.075115866959095, 0.6784815788269043, -0.728144109249115, -0.5347203612327576, -0.23695050179958344, -0.059911131858825684, -0.38180333375930786, -0.5322951078414917, 0.16030998528003693, -0.5851565599441528, 0.24403513967990875, -0.6016625761985779, -0.4178064465522766, -0.31047990918159485, 0.0931873545050621, -0.5012774467468262, 0.786578893661499, 0.27441084384918213, -0.3948635458946228, 0.0584135428071022, -1.1638906002044678, -0.43990978598594666, 0.351200133562088, -0.20272409915924072, 0.18453720211982727, 0.08567395061254501, 0.145783931016922, 0.5205913782119751, -0.0913873091340065, 0.21912790834903717, -0.17847363650798798, -0.35983407497406006, 0.45622116327285767, -0.11012772470712662, 1.046514868736267, 0.24595141410827637, -0.309113085269928, 0.5420054793357849, -0.5766658186912537, -0.31360259652137756, 0.2068207710981369, -0.1290995180606842, -0.1779518574476242, 0.2614469528198242, 0.232167586684227, 0.20642225444316864, 0.5592926144599915, -0.342288076877594, 0.626787006855011, 0.016970569267868996, 0.26526209712028503, 0.8998561501502991, 0.04550129920244217, -0.048042282462120056, -0.08158327639102936, 0.8345829844474792, -0.028305770829319954, 0.22451958060264587, -0.24157249927520752, -0.809051513671875, -0.43008291721343994, -0.14384566247463226, 0.0002937709796242416, 1.1200029850006104, -0.5720382928848267, 0.5394361019134521, -0.02526588924229145, -0.15373976528644562, -0.6186376810073853, 0.3055521547794342, 0.20567327737808228, 0.5333935022354126, 0.19793380796909332, -0.18338192999362946, -0.17728692293167114, -1.0064071416854858, -0.04080015793442726, -0.23892804980278015, -0.2882128953933716, 0.6718392372131348, 0.5924140214920044, -0.6677080392837524, 0.9402636289596558, -0.6949897408485413, -0.47794726490974426, -0.1152854859828949, 0.41282323002815247, -0.1216839924454689, 0.33626532554626465, 0.34416502714157104, -0.9142967462539673, -0.32905709743499756, 0.2588299512863159, -0.9919961094856262, -0.33316177129745483, -0.5029142498970032, 0.08725210279226303, 0.0799257904291153, 0.4925183355808258, -0.7847743034362793, 0.5670384168624878, 0.02204262465238571, -0.6613485813140869, 0.4857524037361145, -0.48288342356681824, 0.2911643087863922, -0.7558825016021729, 0.2910981774330139, 0.26253724098205566, -0.05617012828588486, -0.6993851065635681, 0.10432898253202438, -0.3347705900669098, -0.40846407413482666, -0.12218707799911499, 0.5260034799575806, -0.3276060223579407, -0.17323002219200134, -0.36444970965385437, 0.20927508175373077, -0.3004138171672821, 0.6244211792945862, -0.1530407965183258, 0.7815510034561157, 0.3474065959453583, -0.36913153529167175, 0.6987189650535583, 0.4328961968421936, -0.30652886629104614, 0.6752300262451172, -0.7859711050987244, 0.350437730550766, -0.18364335596561432, 0.18990665674209595, -0.9940626621246338, -0.5713597536087036, 0.25330328941345215, -0.2986453175544739, 0.1036430299282074, 0.30298227071762085, -0.8068437576293945, -0.3169325292110443, 0.18669059872627258, 0.5241111516952515, 0.42135515809059143, -0.22631949186325073, 0.8694545030593872, 0.46522945165634155, -0.2800915837287903, -0.1903911978006363, -0.22142066061496735, 0.27954500913619995, -0.24210619926452637, -0.6814915537834167, 0.3186788260936737, -0.3171534836292267, -0.6872119903564453, 0.017216363921761513, 0.3866603970527649, 0.11402526497840881, 0.4525202512741089, 0.5179380774497986, 0.28548821806907654, 0.16621047258377075, -0.09588176757097244, 0.028726300224661827, 0.20589220523834229, 0.40904754400253296, 0.3785359263420105, 0.470318078994751, -0.15063117444515228, -0.5921932458877563, -1.3964930772781372, 0.7869311571121216, 0.6316043138504028, -0.3468141555786133, 0.9064611792564392, 0.5887940526008606, -0.668398380279541, 0.31649646162986755, -0.5293663144111633, -0.12191200256347656, -0.5120283961296082, 0.2945774793624878, -0.6743459105491638, -0.7632957100868225, 1.004384994506836, 0.09408494830131531, 0.1974087953567505, 0.33595502376556396, 0.8231982588768005, -0.5287346839904785, 1.847349762916565, 0.7907482385635376, -0.053423911333084106, 0.4660082459449768, -0.02296045795083046, 0.09120997786521912, -0.7201327085494995, -0.7255932092666626, -0.36700642108917236, -0.5318378210067749, -0.2869369685649872, 0.060300540179014206, 0.3764612674713135, 0.017031457275152206, -0.2162204533815384, 0.27082380652427673, -0.3821183145046234, 0.08740238845348358, 0.7135581374168396, 0.16743043065071106, -0.012638320215046406, -0.27563172578811646, 0.2287936508655548, 0.07975699007511139, -0.15746760368347168, -0.5620592832565308, 0.6447679400444031, 0.4080613851547241, 0.896586000919342, 0.28602364659309387, 0.37071219086647034, 0.6540129780769348, -0.028640244156122208, -0.8574734330177307, 0.6062837243080139, 0.06491629034280777, -0.6086121797561646, -0.42296794056892395, -0.11562918871641159, -0.9717537760734558, -0.15605220198631287, -0.40063706040382385, -1.6104047298431396, 0.012019246816635132, 0.4393106698989868, -0.6548904776573181, -0.044369351118803024, -1.0572547912597656, 0.7732858061790466, -0.25577104091644287, 0.147567018866539, -0.34830978512763977, -0.7492505311965942, 0.17447586357593536, 0.00477525545284152, -0.018533479422330856, -0.12240684777498245, 0.13976359367370605, 0.922137975692749, -0.3272646367549896, 0.8373798131942749, -0.2029450535774231, 0.10684677958488464, 0.23590974509716034, -0.07557161897420883, 0.41426560282707214, -0.1439969837665558, -0.11290878057479858, -0.025754578411579132, 0.1860329806804657, -0.3358471095561981, -0.930285632610321, 0.6482973098754883, -0.8933840990066528, -1.1193323135375977, -0.33841314911842346, -0.8651114106178284, -0.29781657457351685, 0.20992110669612885, -0.013715893030166626, 0.2799520492553711, 0.06803097575902939, -0.3442736268043518, 0.45130959153175354, -0.17412132024765015, 0.3100418150424957, 0.31446897983551025, -0.1546705663204193, 0.2680194675922394, 0.7358801960945129, 0.06374090164899826, -0.14389759302139282, 0.01802639849483967, -0.12731529772281647, -0.18669266998767853, -0.5945318341255188, -0.674943208694458, 0.21972058713436127, -0.6209444403648376, 0.27793002128601074, -0.6235781908035278, -0.06645622104406357, -0.468906432390213, 0.03538604453206062, 0.12448015064001083, -0.12803789973258972, -0.7476120591163635, 0.2574862539768219, 0.3081122934818268, 1.334829330444336, 0.3706704080104828, 0.707196056842804, -0.5654974579811096, 0.4407922029495239, 0.37574076652526855, 0.2703736126422882, -0.070276640355587, -0.29425308108329773, -0.27589094638824463, -0.21296846866607666, -0.40658220648765564, -1.3261635303497314, 0.11048979312181473, -0.07934560626745224, 0.7630677223205566, 0.5653286576271057, -0.09884117543697357, 0.6467902064323425, -0.4580223262310028, 0.9165401458740234, -0.32234370708465576, -1.0632102489471436, 0.717415452003479, -0.24607469141483307, 0.5341914892196655, 0.5051513910293579, 0.572059154510498, -0.6582855582237244, -0.12093446403741837, -0.3309039771556854, -0.6022301912307739, 0.8902083039283752, 0.24711763858795166, 0.11615774035453796, 0.09122925996780396, 0.8719655871391296, -0.18689146637916565, -0.004663859028369188, -0.4297199845314026, -0.21218718588352203, 0.2662418782711029, -0.40996068716049194, 0.07241447269916534, 0.09954442828893661, 0.010917040519416332, -0.2273368388414383, 0.4965112805366516, -0.09424705058336258, 0.4096065163612366, -0.03530766814947128, -0.0322953499853611, -0.34186887741088867, -0.0786811038851738, 0.8271834254264832, 0.6445097327232361, -0.3102111518383026, -0.4056858420372009, 0.3457995355129242, -0.2852254807949066, -0.05186900123953819, 0.32025855779647827, 0.0016538493800908327, -0.4058905243873596, 0.5631771087646484, 1.06204092502594, -0.1452789008617401, -0.9547858834266663, 0.27086299657821655, -0.4396764039993286, 0.15558551251888275, -0.5277419686317444, 0.5490914583206177, -0.10693991184234619, 0.43975406885147095, 0.4794197082519531, 0.1617942601442337, 0.30404961109161377, -0.6782604455947876, -0.14403320848941803, 0.7117775082588196, -0.38580432534217834, -0.6759147644042969, 0.763728141784668, 0.11738400161266327, -1.0206390619277954, 0.9487578868865967, 0.0030609958339482546, -0.5092959403991699, 0.574092447757721, 0.46221426129341125, 0.7538910508155823, -0.37637391686439514, -0.10689777135848999, -0.1502375602722168, 0.03559291362762451, 0.07742895185947418, 0.5210546851158142, -0.08031407743692398, -0.5261180996894836, -0.32404640316963196, -0.16806752979755402, -0.6847062706947327, 0.18169547617435455, -0.8081106543540955, 0.37188875675201416, -0.4276248514652252, -0.4992198646068573, 0.28357306122779846, -0.1619693785905838, -0.9457679986953735, 0.41002362966537476, 0.38056400418281555, 0.6794859170913696, -0.8528611063957214, 0.7637733221054077, 1.1389671564102173, -0.22650505602359772, -0.6545843482017517, 0.05118698999285698, 0.21206849813461304, -0.4752468764781952, 0.7140802145004272, -0.03494010120630264, -0.2601205110549927, -0.1487128883600235, -0.4280758202075958, -0.6031774878501892, 0.8577419519424438, 0.3515559732913971, -0.25690948963165283, -0.5212038159370422, 0.002451050328090787, 0.7798510789871216, -0.323040246963501, 0.43492695689201355, 0.6608449220657349, 0.5211677551269531, -0.35648787021636963, -1.1730412244796753, -0.09279023855924606, -0.5374248623847961, -0.07781998068094254, 0.00821832474321127, -0.5289234519004822, 0.9339928030967712, -0.21167322993278503, -0.2622711956501007, 0.1055307686328888, 0.857990026473999, 0.13337673246860504, 0.41557490825653076, 0.8881697654724121, 0.2555522322654724, 0.8297263383865356, 0.14776083827018738, 1.2830195426940918, -0.058445438742637634, 0.04084523394703865, 0.9364840984344482, -0.3351902663707733, 0.8301709294319153, 0.3413355350494385, -0.13998442888259888, 0.7770715355873108, 0.8465895652770996, 0.0977373719215393, 0.030348705127835274, 0.11696316301822662, -0.29457223415374756, -0.23167552053928375, -0.11082521080970764, -0.11001205444335938, 0.5568771362304688, 0.5840332508087158, 0.1192806288599968, 0.2252393513917923, 0.5245980620384216, -0.16409184038639069, 0.22685067355632782, -0.09935325384140015, 0.8059382438659668, -0.18940342962741852, -1.0268957614898682, 0.07759372144937515, 0.15919573605060577, 0.42211174964904785, -0.42612260580062866, -0.29602542519569397, 0.04257988557219505, 0.11219163984060287, -0.25130966305732727, -0.888131856918335, 0.19596980512142181, 0.21306072175502777, -0.2215452939271927, -0.1375553458929062, 0.4555548429489136, 0.01132684201002121, -0.4335694909095764, 0.18348702788352966, 0.2634389400482178, 0.24259091913700104, -0.008023438975214958, -0.9589231610298157, 0.0910576805472374, -0.06128998473286629, -0.547211766242981, 0.20300818979740143, 0.1342763602733612, -0.5099319815635681, 1.1875914335250854, 0.3622294068336487, -0.18447217345237732, -0.007837016135454178, -0.0546683631837368, 0.5979720950126648, -0.8151007890701294, -0.4443066418170929, -0.9163350462913513, 0.40401479601860046, 0.07203304022550583, -0.4552364945411682, 0.6067902445793152, 0.07384217530488968, 0.6585156321525574, -0.2147250771522522, 0.6788561344146729, -0.20987612009048462, 0.2448224425315857, -0.38198375701904297, 0.8154193758964539, -0.7894003987312317, 0.4155416786670685, -0.17607951164245605, -0.45273733139038086, -0.12246067821979523, 0.5097826719284058, -0.30451077222824097, 0.34690412878990173, 0.19756796956062317, 0.46809202432632446, -0.06294338405132294, 0.022569207474589348, -0.005922364536672831, -0.026132188737392426, 0.5260418653488159, 0.5581061244010925, 0.8976880311965942, 0.12300413846969604, -0.0069123427383601665, -0.46507859230041504, -0.25330743193626404, -0.3914792537689209, -0.4871523082256317, -0.9714186787605286, -1.0169506072998047, -0.35373905301094055, -0.032301027327775955, 0.04840730130672455, 1.1186374425888062, 0.9622070789337158, -1.045124888420105, -0.4537698030471802, 0.22519251704216003, -0.061966292560100555, -0.15531903505325317, -0.29440370202064514, 0.22340404987335205, -0.05207769200205803, -1.075061321258545, 0.4332740008831024, 0.04562350735068321, 0.26506367325782776, -0.5535666346549988, 0.1775868535041809, -0.3116280734539032, 0.2623874545097351, 0.4285953640937805, 0.47367262840270996, -1.0003224611282349, -0.5356892943382263, 0.05964948982000351, -0.19145119190216064, -0.2348347157239914, 0.7429293990135193, -0.7788956761360168, 0.592620849609375, 0.35740548372268677, 0.5879093408584595, 0.42104244232177734, 0.3811490535736084, 0.8599339723587036, -0.5141729712486267, -0.0528818741440773, 0.09159956872463226, 0.3114263415336609, 0.22605422139167786, -1.107943058013916, 0.27647528052330017, -0.050973083823919296, -0.5307559967041016, -0.8333452939987183, 0.23567430675029755, -1.3606274127960205, -0.3071863651275635, 0.6866534352302551, -0.4151165187358856, -0.10412677377462387, -0.2769130766391754, -0.7062608599662781, 0.4336349666118622, -0.233030766248703, 0.8715129494667053, 0.8640791773796082, -0.9661297798156738, -0.3079652786254883, -0.7761010527610779, 0.4730037748813629, 0.544421911239624, -1.0874419212341309, -0.18893013894557953, 0.4220016300678253, -0.00887985248118639, 0.1974715292453766, 0.501986026763916, 0.5052697658538818, 0.36499878764152527, -0.4751409590244293, -0.17456088960170746, -0.2618074119091034, -0.4818269908428192, -0.37826117873191833, 0.20692512392997742, 0.0753590315580368, 0.008666463196277618 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15359v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15359v1
Constructing Multilingual Visual-Text Datasets Revealing Visual Multilingual Ability of Vision Language Models
2024-03-29T10:53:07
2024-03-29T10:53:07
Jesse Atuhurra, Iqra Ali, Tatsuya Hiraoka, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Tomoya Iwakura, Taro Watanabe
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.CV
Large language models (LLMs) have increased interest in vision language models (VLMs), which process image-text pairs as input. Studies investigating the visual understanding ability of VLMs have been proposed, but such studies are still preliminary because existing datasets do not permit a comprehensive evaluation of the fine-grained visual linguistic abilities of VLMs across multiple languages. To further explore the strengths of VLMs, such as GPT-4V \cite{openai2023GPT4}, we developed new datasets for the systematic and qualitative analysis of VLMs. Our contribution is four-fold: 1) we introduced nine vision-and-language (VL) tasks (including object recognition, image-text matching, and more) and constructed multilingual visual-text datasets in four languages: English, Japanese, Swahili, and Urdu through utilizing templates containing \textit{questions} and prompting GPT4-V to generate the \textit{answers} and the \textit{rationales}, 2) introduced a new VL task named \textit{unrelatedness}, 3) introduced rationales to enable human understanding of the VLM reasoning process, and 4) employed human evaluation to measure the suitability of proposed datasets for VL tasks. We show that VLMs can be fine-tuned on our datasets. Our work is the first to conduct such analyses in Swahili and Urdu. Also, it introduces \textit{rationales} in VL analysis, which played a vital role in the evaluation.
[ -0.40755367279052734, -0.41645094752311707, 0.5825486779212952, 0.18336910009384155, -0.2546713054180145, -0.05953306332230568, -0.34148257970809937, -0.6292848587036133, -0.19040368497371674, 0.7608391046524048, -0.3595748245716095, -0.5363370180130005, -0.42751631140708923, 0.27538272738456726, -0.40287691354751587, 0.8212155699729919, -0.24433249235153198, 0.31444913148880005, -0.1569167524576187, -0.5347625613212585, -0.6177385449409485, -0.5377062559127808, -0.10479217022657394, 0.04321073740720749, 0.6375882625579834, 0.35491570830345154, 0.416878879070282, 0.5196572542190552, 0.7666208148002625, 0.3186187744140625, 0.17276647686958313, 0.23103751242160797, -0.3244118094444275, -0.023454690352082253, -0.0718800276517868, -0.4819130301475525, -0.07927840203046799, -0.28641778230667114, 0.7918602228164673, 0.5774394869804382, 0.026983918622136116, 0.31851673126220703, 0.12290799617767334, 0.7789517045021057, -0.6261845827102661, 0.3341284692287445, -0.5757104158401489, 0.1212160587310791, -0.4828657805919647, -0.14778199791908264, -0.3447360694408417, 0.03850886598229408, 0.131361186504364, -0.46129781007766724, 0.21001236140727997, 0.0989672914147377, 0.7852968573570251, 0.17294412851333618, -0.5184587240219116, -0.05654333904385567, -0.6253653764724731, 0.8126419186592102, -0.5050142407417297, 0.677945077419281, 0.25467023253440857, 0.5187091827392578, 0.2298036515712738, -0.6144185066223145, -0.5582907795906067, -0.12011103332042694, -0.058168500661849976, 0.19497646391391754, 0.06600131839513779, -0.23259089887142181, 0.33928370475769043, 0.293611079454422, -0.760613203048706, -0.018688997253775597, -0.5595604777336121, -0.18386581540107727, 0.5187438130378723, 0.31039485335350037, 0.4073264002799988, -0.0765385702252388, -0.3220100402832031, -0.08876112103462219, -0.6124776005744934, 0.10362958163022995, 0.10663382709026337, 0.23327478766441345, -0.3712705373764038, 1.0573962926864624, -0.326009064912796, 1.045434594154358, -0.5698849558830261, -0.3685431480407715, 0.2979561388492584, -0.9278231263160706, -0.10667554289102554, -0.2975493371486664, 0.730614423751831, 0.5136047601699829, 0.7843761444091797, 0.07978054881095886, -0.17633752524852753, 0.14796695113182068, -0.007682180497795343, -0.4934382438659668, -0.07977364212274551, -0.23041921854019165, -0.5811527371406555, -0.18660874664783478, -0.0858677551150322, -0.631139874458313, -0.44747617840766907, -0.5042450428009033, 0.20981574058532715, -0.30436021089553833, -0.24810495972633362, 0.11730287969112396, -0.24343138933181763, 0.5293734073638916, 0.32725703716278076, -0.8018765449523926, 0.17688599228858948, 0.253876656293869, 0.6839384436607361, -0.29648274183273315, -0.7665180563926697, -0.35665950179100037, 0.05336346849799156, -0.3765009641647339, 0.807858407497406, -0.5862506031990051, -0.06010659784078598, 0.21907368302345276, -0.061681319028139114, -0.017298851162195206, -0.42265111207962036, 0.3031260669231415, -0.25451862812042236, 0.24281182885169983, -0.5290220975875854, -0.15032410621643066, -0.30422425270080566, 0.4113169014453888, -0.7049330472946167, 0.8149799704551697, -0.00390123319812119, -0.8229284882545471, 0.5192759037017822, -0.3650822043418884, -0.4369017481803894, 0.20200031995773315, -0.5234018564224243, -0.2082425057888031, 0.1603183150291443, 0.48357683420181274, 0.5807099938392639, -0.3593275547027588, 0.11665254831314087, -0.2723432779312134, -0.19427627325057983, 0.23424938321113586, -0.5558369755744934, 0.7108854055404663, -0.03300713747739792, -0.28303608298301697, 0.2655992805957794, -0.6805022358894348, 0.1106005311012268, 0.22983714938163757, -0.2318384349346161, -0.24805095791816711, 0.02400672249495983, 0.3346703350543976, 0.32149967551231384, 0.24717499315738678, -0.21535466611385345, 0.039961207658052444, -0.30608779191970825, 0.24545997381210327, 0.5790445804595947, -0.27484747767448425, 0.27268487215042114, -0.005222504958510399, 0.5188738107681274, 0.07685119658708572, 0.301303893327713, -0.34998199343681335, -0.7000370025634766, -0.9186005592346191, -0.1574758142232895, -0.03887098655104637, 0.664550244808197, -1.2327499389648438, -0.27948880195617676, -0.2903387248516083, -0.36274412274360657, -0.2909330427646637, 0.4007432758808136, 0.5628194212913513, 0.4132657051086426, 0.22465333342552185, -0.17133064568042755, -0.4450133442878723, -1.1268998384475708, -0.34802377223968506, -0.017344793304800987, 0.259322851896286, 0.2830045521259308, 0.5964242815971375, -0.049336981028318405, 0.7173146605491638, -0.39044299721717834, -0.2810763418674469, -0.48585233092308044, -0.20416909456253052, 0.14894834160804749, 0.027724234387278557, 0.7519577145576477, -1.1216591596603394, -0.6160377264022827, 0.33441096544265747, -1.0094068050384521, 0.01861276850104332, 0.09722671657800674, -0.07856753468513489, 0.30625277757644653, 0.3296528160572052, -0.2817838788032532, 0.5384218096733093, 0.5992821455001831, -0.46889352798461914, 0.6845369935035706, -0.17116276919841766, 0.2208082228899002, -0.8936667442321777, -0.09482073038816452, 0.2300235480070114, -0.1527796983718872, -0.6934898495674133, 0.16593150794506073, 0.06475317478179932, -0.15069423615932465, -0.6405154466629028, 0.7758778929710388, -0.6896684765815735, -0.36826470494270325, -0.0996452122926712, 0.09372373670339584, -0.15674738585948944, 0.5690615177154541, 0.24368585646152496, 0.6506668329238892, 0.8448934555053711, -0.4049161672592163, 0.40377670526504517, 0.1804177612066269, -0.4987356662750244, 0.6744951605796814, -0.5434257388114929, -0.2531026601791382, -0.21214820444583893, -0.32915085554122925, -0.7981752157211304, -0.302823543548584, 0.3876658082008362, -0.16184499859809875, 0.0014732906129211187, -0.10386468470096588, -0.39171528816223145, -0.40467214584350586, -0.1776156723499298, 0.46845319867134094, 0.26728254556655884, -0.49012094736099243, 0.5873773097991943, 0.4058305025100708, -0.1859099268913269, -0.620689332485199, -0.7699663639068604, 0.31188538670539856, -0.15090331435203552, -0.5569814443588257, -0.11062102764844894, -0.13789762556552887, -0.37658485770225525, -0.011974543333053589, 0.16833092272281647, -0.21680127084255219, -0.13396814465522766, 0.04205228015780449, 0.4777238667011261, -0.26411548256874084, -0.054363999515771866, -0.3023824989795685, -0.053459133952856064, -0.1311408132314682, -0.2501881420612335, 0.45011043548583984, -0.4098113179206848, -0.5344668030738831, -0.17071950435638428, 0.30539771914482117, 0.48181891441345215, -0.7343533635139465, 0.48356884717941284, 0.8579245209693909, -0.2727148234844208, 0.11700393259525299, -0.5811360478401184, 0.10008282214403152, -0.397040456533432, 0.537041962146759, -0.5729543566703796, -0.8897076845169067, 0.37694084644317627, 0.4159531891345978, 0.023488694801926613, 0.44314485788345337, 0.8010867834091187, -0.0014200457371771336, 1.060578465461731, 0.8273579478263855, 0.016655027866363525, 0.5604854226112366, -0.08184666931629181, 0.16240110993385315, -0.5478376746177673, -0.28357434272766113, -0.2518451511859894, -0.0045729512348771095, -0.6779545545578003, -0.5114463567733765, 0.41655847430229187, -0.15285825729370117, 0.038938891142606735, -0.010891147889196873, -0.34390974044799805, 0.5767278671264648, 0.40085461735725403, -0.018848657608032227, 0.272866815328598, 0.2709655165672302, -0.07475292682647705, -0.22721537947654724, -0.6924501657485962, -0.44428378343582153, 1.187181830406189, 0.129427969455719, 0.577347457408905, 0.0765775591135025, 0.38241732120513916, 0.03726048767566681, 0.10469633340835571, -0.5640600919723511, 0.5655630826950073, -0.2519879639148712, -0.34276145696640015, -0.3333379328250885, -0.2957019507884979, -0.6575911045074463, 0.4876856505870819, -0.3015943765640259, -0.6580832004547119, 0.11390703171491623, 0.13829965889453888, 0.060226183384656906, 0.02044614404439926, -0.81917804479599, 0.986045777797699, -0.5749296545982361, -0.24718037247657776, -0.08820817619562149, -0.612714946269989, 0.49661943316459656, -0.09537875652313232, 0.26574262976646423, -0.08352383226156235, -0.05982290580868721, 0.60634845495224, -0.0667562261223793, 0.8274231553077698, -0.1090092882514, -0.18174850940704346, 0.1247091218829155, -0.2831798493862152, 0.16800279915332794, -0.0187696386128664, 0.1923944354057312, 0.36264845728874207, 0.058192864060401917, -0.5082911252975464, -0.5352903604507446, 0.5651981234550476, -0.35943636298179626, -0.3700505197048187, -0.4176799952983856, -0.528634786605835, -0.1477101892232895, 0.5443906188011169, 0.15546497702598572, 0.6723770499229431, -0.12402123957872391, 0.14423374831676483, 0.47572699189186096, -0.2881007790565491, 0.3740309178829193, 0.5200566053390503, -0.5809357166290283, -0.3511865735054016, 1.0909258127212524, 0.21171002089977264, 0.1680016964673996, 0.33226901292800903, 0.11322188377380371, -0.3000752329826355, -0.6967334151268005, -0.6579970121383667, 0.22599764168262482, -0.8164043426513672, 0.05721614882349968, -0.32055357098579407, -0.1148219034075737, -0.19125787913799286, 0.0329221747815609, -0.09574521332979202, -0.04381689429283142, 0.08298894762992859, 0.15405330061912537, 0.29851633310317993, 0.904778003692627, 0.19070415198802948, -0.03095872513949871, -0.7815827131271362, 0.6810086369514465, 0.31396856904029846, 0.32940247654914856, -0.15315265953540802, -0.22510160505771637, -0.40784135460853577, 0.09718891233205795, 0.13469788432121277, -0.8229257464408875, 0.41779187321662903, 0.28788548707962036, 0.6866807341575623, 0.2153584510087967, -0.3934640884399414, 0.7076758146286011, -0.7713948488235474, 0.7108506560325623, 0.11664260923862457, -0.7498276829719543, 0.4927698075771332, -0.3966911733150482, 0.33093371987342834, 0.2886698842048645, 0.15246164798736572, -0.5019440054893494, -0.31894436478614807, -0.10581757873296738, -0.707651674747467, 0.5214896202087402, 0.44872424006462097, -0.03487279638648033, 0.23957204818725586, 0.24037130177021027, 0.06214619055390358, 0.29625943303108215, -0.8648724555969238, -0.2824297547340393, -0.2621077001094818, -0.4081452190876007, -0.31245866417884827, -0.3616611659526825, -0.0015694714384153485, -0.3722367584705353, 0.18854494392871857, -0.30488765239715576, 0.032906994223594666, -0.009746781550347805, -0.3108404278755188, 0.3048414885997772, 0.11658275127410889, 0.720500111579895, 0.7684018611907959, 0.23252345621585846, 0.21979625523090363, 0.19268907606601715, -0.6127167344093323, 0.027564702555537224, 0.08515898138284683, -0.07532256841659546, -0.1006755456328392, 0.7266674637794495, 0.9668222665786743, 0.09496062994003296, -0.9069623947143555, 0.5107045769691467, -0.2990328371524811, -0.14321188628673553, -0.31860408186912537, -0.06486579030752182, -0.03902066871523857, 0.33297234773635864, 0.1948995739221573, 0.09547503292560577, 0.18379566073417664, -0.4741875231266022, 0.034885428845882416, 0.4403628408908844, -0.3536791503429413, -0.26361095905303955, 0.3789537250995636, 0.017834575846791267, -0.025666767731308937, 0.4060193598270416, -0.027520177885890007, -0.6189647316932678, 0.5172668099403381, 0.4698007106781006, 0.46201804280281067, -0.03718065842986107, 0.25313693284988403, 0.17567268013954163, 0.48350897431373596, -0.14377538859844208, 0.6979662179946899, 0.06421852856874466, -0.8762115836143494, -0.5262877941131592, -0.5971454381942749, -0.20364433526992798, 0.018948882818222046, -0.612507700920105, 0.33297574520111084, -0.061684850603342056, 0.1419646143913269, 0.04077751934528351, -0.282132089138031, -1.0333675146102905, 0.25659841299057007, 0.2452724725008011, 0.5858542323112488, -0.9719547033309937, 0.7599689960479736, 0.8501341342926025, -0.39305153489112854, -0.6398346424102783, -0.18429411947727203, -0.02314346469938755, -1.0225127935409546, 0.8251882791519165, 0.16350670158863068, -0.060574378818273544, -0.08730980008840561, -0.37608325481414795, -0.8352683186531067, 0.766848087310791, 0.4482281804084778, -0.68416827917099, 0.17818203568458557, 0.39377009868621826, 0.5926167368888855, -0.3322041928768158, 0.09248135983943939, 0.46074506640434265, 0.7215082049369812, -0.2186925709247589, -0.9473387002944946, -0.16075456142425537, -0.5136062502861023, 0.11975284665822983, 0.17883476614952087, -0.29893338680267334, 0.7180817127227783, -0.403126060962677, -0.10703569650650024, 0.023168792948126793, 0.5809214115142822, 0.1724124699831009, 0.2600308656692505, 0.42670002579689026, 0.3718503713607788, 0.5199450850486755, -0.15157851576805115, 1.234904170036316, -0.11258043348789215, 0.06644701957702637, 1.0283010005950928, -0.3786948025226593, 0.9071826934814453, 0.5393446087837219, -0.07935668528079987, 0.12419315427541733, 0.3400105834007263, -0.20560015738010406, 0.44501930475234985, -0.012798608280718327, -0.058788251131772995, -0.37966328859329224, -0.20300306379795074, -0.2769627869129181, 0.7184318900108337, 0.17933490872383118, -0.23939110338687897, -0.15457431972026825, 0.4390866160392761, -0.4129708707332611, 0.03301728516817093, -0.2530066668987274, 0.6698645353317261, 0.06928993761539459, -0.36033928394317627, 0.5710656642913818, -0.2639301121234894, 0.46305051445961, -0.5447348952293396, -0.17223554849624634, 0.003912022802978754, 0.10669433325529099, -0.09608209133148193, -1.14661705493927, 0.17972347140312195, 0.3168215751647949, -0.2803867757320404, -0.14849945902824402, 0.7795940041542053, -0.6243849992752075, -0.8782581090927124, 0.21638281643390656, 0.7019526362419128, 0.20154355466365814, -0.07496508955955505, -0.586043119430542, 0.23766666650772095, 0.21999333798885345, -0.16473685204982758, 0.2546398341655731, 0.4518616795539856, -0.4145963788032532, 0.7366541624069214, 0.6042639017105103, 0.27310290932655334, 0.13389377295970917, 0.3924940824508667, 0.7414203882217407, -0.7974666953086853, -0.14278243482112885, -0.9677905440330505, 0.5757491588592529, -0.1215977817773819, -0.4145894944667816, 0.9791796803474426, 0.63592928647995, 0.9206950068473816, -0.25661760568618774, 0.9834606051445007, 0.10006728768348694, 0.23977942764759064, -0.8190289735794067, 0.5987091660499573, -0.8416720628738403, -0.007088109385222197, -0.3372911810874939, -0.9195197820663452, -0.5181071758270264, 0.5841666460037231, -0.2614431083202362, 0.0025622050743550062, 0.6716905832290649, 0.6121787428855896, 0.008077181875705719, -0.2989650368690491, 0.4509507715702057, 0.09688374400138855, 0.2740853726863861, 0.39709511399269104, 0.8296635150909424, -0.28997474908828735, 0.5839409232139587, -0.3090282082557678, -0.13725925981998444, 0.044890113174915314, -0.8544014096260071, -1.1591923236846924, -0.7745105028152466, -0.05630079656839371, 0.08159362524747849, 0.06180540472269058, 0.30886220932006836, 0.4026074707508087, -0.6415131688117981, -0.28517085313796997, -0.0017770344857126474, 0.11279816925525665, -0.1434984803199768, -0.10929885506629944, 0.3348087668418884, -0.07686404883861542, -0.5517044067382812, 0.2672054171562195, 0.5443297028541565, 0.19115906953811646, -0.3765130639076233, -0.17494510114192963, 0.02020544745028019, -0.33461567759513855, 0.9257861375808716, 0.22750264406204224, -0.945625901222229, -0.15158770978450775, 0.15533041954040527, -0.08564361929893494, -0.037800710648298264, 0.570271372795105, -0.6212400794029236, 0.550012469291687, 0.49713045358657837, 0.4454967975616455, 0.39095762372016907, -0.4273986518383026, 0.6698284149169922, -0.4563542604446411, 0.3674056828022003, 0.010930833406746387, 0.6769008636474609, 0.5487668514251709, 0.0021915114484727383, 0.5132815837860107, 0.22742879390716553, -0.22642606496810913, -0.779673159122467, 0.3268822133541107, -1.0432689189910889, -0.07290845364332199, 1.1518384218215942, 0.05222437158226967, -0.25560832023620605, -0.16627241671085358, -0.6813991069793701, 0.0475531704723835, 0.14207370579242706, 0.35575976967811584, 0.7082889080047607, -0.005871251691132784, -0.4777659475803375, -0.7160699963569641, 0.3335617780685425, 0.22951266169548035, -0.9551830291748047, 0.05771995335817337, 0.5190918445587158, 0.09105662256479263, 0.002362521132454276, 0.6597108840942383, -0.023110942915081978, 0.3847994804382324, -0.1314939558506012, 0.022125687450170517, -0.023854108527302742, -0.5295820236206055, -0.3113551735877991, -0.01097728032618761, 0.18166759610176086, -0.0468963161110878 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20103v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20103v1
NLP for Counterspeech against Hate: A Survey and How-To Guide
2024-03-29T10:32:44
2024-03-29T10:32:44
Helena Bonaldi, Yi-Ling Chung, Gavin Abercrombie, Marco Guerini
cs.CL
cs.CL
In recent years, counterspeech has emerged as one of the most promising strategies to fight online hate. These non-escalatory responses tackle online abuse while preserving the freedom of speech of the users, and can have a tangible impact in reducing online and offline violence. Recently, there has been growing interest from the Natural Language Processing (NLP) community in addressing the challenges of analysing, collecting, classifying, and automatically generating counterspeech, to reduce the huge burden of manually producing it. In particular, researchers have taken different directions in addressing these challenges, thus providing a variety of related tasks and resources. In this paper, we provide a guide for doing research on counterspeech, by describing - with detailed examples - the steps to undertake, and providing best practices that can be learnt from the NLP studies on this topic. Finally, we discuss open challenges and future directions of counterspeech research in NLP.
[ -0.8388954401016235, -0.9631442427635193, -0.006267927121371031, 0.297075092792511, -0.15412971377372742, 0.17111796140670776, 0.05764685571193695, -0.6339083313941956, 0.6004199385643005, 0.5042800307273865, -0.807094156742096, -0.17837217450141907, -0.8458224534988403, 0.3560769259929657, -0.6032394766807556, 1.146774411201477, 0.04934662953019142, 0.24379228055477142, -0.24923238158226013, -0.2475680559873581, -0.4458268880844116, -0.8483594059944153, -0.8022933602333069, -0.0038243532180786133, 0.4736088216304779, 0.31899499893188477, 0.3562670350074768, 0.1278328001499176, 0.6062132120132446, 0.23735520243644714, -0.1341022551059723, -0.15299060940742493, -0.5097790956497192, 0.4933658838272095, -0.25787875056266785, -0.1192442923784256, -0.1894761472940445, 0.033581290394067764, 0.16786763072013855, 0.1537327915430069, -0.2793646454811096, 0.2776157259941101, -0.018832977861166, 0.4222192168235779, -0.4732357859611511, -0.28580987453460693, -0.5539962649345398, 0.3164673149585724, -0.6354712843894958, -0.17004957795143127, -0.296076238155365, -0.3476421535015106, -0.2844221889972687, -0.5878415703773499, 0.5312951803207397, 0.031002791598439217, 0.2832944095134735, 0.23911868035793304, -0.17907659709453583, -0.46284908056259155, -0.5706010460853577, 0.9971204400062561, -0.8700898289680481, 0.26930487155914307, 0.5973666310310364, 0.309333473443985, -0.1679610162973404, -0.5029111504554749, -0.6550241708755493, 0.08240329474210739, 0.006457059644162655, 0.11047036200761795, -0.36319175362586975, -0.3339114487171173, 0.6101928353309631, 0.22917835414409637, -0.5704320669174194, 0.0030142904724925756, -0.18018123507499695, -0.11950854957103729, 0.6519296169281006, 0.1901281476020813, 0.47842028737068176, -0.09706040471792221, -0.53606116771698, 0.21163326501846313, -0.4430474638938904, -0.24776466190814972, 0.5639036893844604, 0.3338044285774231, 0.05554616078734398, 0.5315471887588501, -0.3507157564163208, 0.7959963083267212, -0.05152076855301857, -0.0420045480132103, 0.03297365829348564, -0.1961321234703064, 0.18579481542110443, 0.0470321848988533, 0.7154284715652466, 0.6294316649436951, 0.3575443625450134, -0.15192143619060516, 0.018895642831921577, 0.2216641902923584, 0.7701586484909058, -0.7902409434318542, -0.091363824903965, 0.2174091935157776, -0.4270356297492981, -0.3043883442878723, -0.6289055943489075, -1.3024919033050537, -0.5243622660636902, -0.24750913679599762, 0.14431644976139069, -0.3116321265697479, -0.5112112164497375, -0.4542979896068573, -0.5160459280014038, 0.23243898153305054, 0.21845009922981262, -0.8230149745941162, 0.9301507472991943, 0.543031632900238, 0.9447231292724609, -0.30399641394615173, -0.052779752761125565, -0.5534154176712036, -0.3467060923576355, -0.18968990445137024, 0.9533699750900269, -0.35843005776405334, -0.5402113199234009, 0.03496268019080162, -0.48045870661735535, 0.24712872505187988, -0.5113976001739502, 0.42193031311035156, -0.509014368057251, 0.2539776861667633, -0.4097405970096588, -0.514446496963501, -0.015040759928524494, 0.6870453953742981, -0.5652256011962891, 1.1822537183761597, -0.057025425136089325, -1.1178944110870361, -0.016422655433416367, -0.7683435082435608, -0.3989711403846741, 0.18858975172042847, -0.015092762187123299, -0.4485672414302826, 0.1595822274684906, 0.10038356482982635, 0.06387147307395935, -0.3364275395870209, -0.09738782048225403, -0.19834598898887634, 0.20122215151786804, -0.017751876264810562, 0.06563276797533035, 1.3002930879592896, 0.33530110120773315, -0.5770986676216125, 0.10953445732593536, -0.713590681552887, -0.015066379681229591, 0.44946300983428955, 0.17451953887939453, -0.4021538496017456, 0.18627597391605377, 0.232046976685524, 0.15487006306648254, -0.2953612506389618, -0.8645426034927368, 0.09229396283626556, -0.2499237060546875, 0.12072260677814484, 0.5861839652061462, 0.1435478925704956, 0.08802122622728348, -0.2573050856590271, 0.8395746946334839, -0.4050230383872986, 0.38520053029060364, 0.2904526889324188, -0.868767499923706, -0.5536999106407166, 0.28860825300216675, -0.028331665322184563, 0.6007006168365479, -0.837954580783844, -0.01489182934165001, 0.47826531529426575, -0.6572241187095642, -0.3776460289955139, -0.083214670419693, 0.5638864636421204, 1.003936529159546, 1.0532656908035278, -0.660565972328186, -1.119917631149292, -0.5416440963745117, -0.47353678941726685, -0.1398526132106781, 0.16377899050712585, 0.024867495521903038, 0.38310563564300537, -0.007528063375502825, 1.0097821950912476, -0.578092098236084, -0.367299884557724, -0.2643263041973114, 0.6455991268157959, -0.40104278922080994, 0.2507483959197998, 0.5638943314552307, -0.9201750159263611, -0.8283149003982544, -0.6708328723907471, -0.4633578658103943, -0.5082765817642212, 0.34977954626083374, -0.04239087924361229, 0.13463400304317474, 0.6101693511009216, -0.04066506773233414, 0.5987626314163208, 0.4702935516834259, -0.21567972004413605, 0.8107811808586121, 0.7858992218971252, 0.32257455587387085, -1.0891144275665283, 0.039193376898765564, -0.1550251543521881, -0.07369212061166763, -1.0583440065383911, 0.5322142243385315, -0.5979422330856323, -0.14352014660835266, -0.5272063612937927, 0.6091600656509399, -0.011334077455103397, 0.22891554236412048, -0.3247690200805664, -0.07038519531488419, -0.4544640779495239, 0.16103817522525787, 0.2535240650177002, 0.5045455098152161, 0.05129662901163101, -0.4472826421260834, 0.5044214725494385, 0.5209465026855469, -0.3198658525943756, 0.8895610570907593, -0.3749690055847168, 0.2978019714355469, 0.014928797259926796, 0.10197002440690994, -0.6212670207023621, 0.3716605305671692, 0.3817523121833801, -0.8436975479125977, -0.11445450037717819, -0.4359617531299591, -0.2873423099517822, -0.25748202204704285, -0.24528178572654724, 0.5410301685333252, 0.4087972044944763, -0.27729296684265137, 0.5886895060539246, 0.7918980121612549, -0.23424841463565826, -0.9494361877441406, -0.6421056985855103, 0.3455950915813446, -0.29061806201934814, -0.025211572647094727, 0.3042835593223572, -0.5660145282745361, -0.8105461597442627, -0.23475214838981628, 0.31122320890426636, -0.316954642534256, 0.13052286207675934, 0.3650990128517151, -0.23506274819374084, 0.15298523008823395, -0.13815268874168396, -0.5838350653648376, -0.29631590843200684, 0.3093552589416504, 0.10708676278591156, 0.811165452003479, 0.22978591918945312, -0.08172747492790222, 0.14887326955795288, 0.7942177653312683, -0.19038717448711395, -0.08178834617137909, 0.5957537293434143, 0.8459786772727966, -0.37761640548706055, -0.381605327129364, -0.5774605870246887, -0.1860971599817276, -0.3839299976825714, 0.16514936089515686, -0.058821506798267365, -0.744716227054596, 0.4054102599620819, 0.09208974242210388, 0.3517816364765167, 0.6712636947631836, 0.8106104135513306, -0.1805017590522766, 0.6849771738052368, 0.6787258386611938, 0.034595787525177, 0.27377474308013916, 0.13269013166427612, 0.35256069898605347, -0.4583166241645813, -0.2719067633152008, -0.9218068718910217, -0.18530814349651337, -0.28635770082473755, -0.5584049224853516, 0.07076902687549591, -0.11786466091871262, -0.12757758796215057, 0.5897813439369202, -0.8054918050765991, 0.29168105125427246, 0.4570941627025604, -0.40722888708114624, 0.14925600588321686, 0.03424316272139549, -0.0697733536362648, -0.5974615812301636, -0.63527911901474, 0.02533714659512043, 0.675540566444397, -0.08649608492851257, 0.32522913813591003, 0.3815465271472931, 0.6611566543579102, 0.5183627605438232, 0.3895299732685089, -0.8616725206375122, 0.7434813976287842, 0.06098935380578041, -1.014760136604309, -0.32773274183273315, -0.4285714328289032, -0.7648487091064453, -0.042726948857307434, -0.30106231570243835, -0.4516431987285614, -0.2629132866859436, 0.3139607012271881, -0.11582473665475845, 0.652410626411438, -0.21684595942497253, 0.5818431973457336, -0.14566640555858612, -0.06936942040920258, -0.3581680953502655, -0.567791223526001, 0.27448973059654236, 0.04497315734624863, 0.5308904051780701, -0.0760505273938179, 0.22984007000923157, 1.0093636512756348, -0.4783277213573456, 0.9623299241065979, -0.36240607500076294, 0.03702954947948456, 0.524802029132843, 0.32861679792404175, 0.12602514028549194, -0.5198898911476135, -0.010783711448311806, 0.4344160854816437, -0.05608005076646805, -0.3221518397331238, -0.15725098550319672, 0.48036593198776245, -0.3892689347267151, -0.31616365909576416, -0.6742543578147888, -0.3134627640247345, -0.286857008934021, 0.322530597448349, 0.3187950849533081, 0.20221033692359924, -0.6962270140647888, -0.18549728393554688, 0.740559995174408, -0.2944146394729614, 0.45977067947387695, 0.5946211218833923, -0.5743244886398315, -0.4205114245414734, 0.8646789193153381, 0.3614858090877533, 0.03959721699357033, 0.5504367351531982, 0.4204716384410858, -0.4344480633735657, -0.5819833874702454, -0.3865891695022583, -0.24558621644973755, -0.5353339314460754, -0.35178259015083313, -0.7802094221115112, -0.2580362558364868, -0.8377188444137573, -0.16801932454109192, -0.43653616309165955, -0.3734598159790039, 0.010993005707859993, 0.09716291725635529, 0.8751844763755798, 1.0014837980270386, -0.43103426694869995, 0.3853597044944763, -0.3774169683456421, 0.859108030796051, 0.5056644678115845, 0.52284836769104, 0.22964337468147278, -0.5045605897903442, -0.1331305354833603, -0.34253057837486267, 0.044522542506456375, -1.1381750106811523, 0.6762783527374268, -0.32849517464637756, 0.3585168719291687, 0.0039857374504208565, 0.5839714407920837, 0.9054167866706848, -0.7628909349441528, 0.7912495732307434, 0.43983983993530273, -0.6369807720184326, 0.5363674759864807, -0.19147497415542603, 0.12055070698261261, 0.5948045253753662, 0.8892508745193481, -1.0629932880401611, -0.28147584199905396, -0.9231147170066833, -1.0266573429107666, 0.4036560356616974, 0.16611704230308533, -0.006514552515000105, -0.15460315346717834, -0.2517612874507904, 0.03733648359775543, 0.2473679631948471, -0.7336186170578003, -0.26328372955322266, -0.5065637826919556, 0.0721983015537262, 0.03864491358399391, -0.32923123240470886, -0.5243918299674988, -0.1445530354976654, 0.7783063650131226, 0.20845648646354675, 0.13398301601409912, -0.04094015061855316, -0.23806698620319366, -0.11036917567253113, 0.1728215515613556, 0.4775973856449127, 0.418670654296875, -0.23058106005191803, 0.25944632291793823, 0.4232587516307831, -0.5326435565948486, -0.07408344745635986, -0.09813365340232849, -0.3169800043106079, 0.12029608339071274, 0.319391667842865, 0.28460627794265747, -0.07200999557971954, -0.43950051069259644, 0.5123307704925537, -0.2834083139896393, -0.34726476669311523, -0.7746992111206055, -0.23333051800727844, 0.013666735030710697, -0.16745704412460327, 0.29601848125457764, -0.08218888938426971, 0.08382679522037506, -0.27282512187957764, 0.4022534489631653, 0.3163609206676483, -0.47084903717041016, -0.03310130536556244, 0.3820701837539673, 0.23014310002326965, -0.8201738595962524, 0.5847007036209106, -0.40166032314300537, -0.6348832845687866, 0.45051971077919006, 0.6843459010124207, 0.7394245862960815, -0.43009263277053833, 0.3720952272415161, 0.6408944725990295, 0.299634724855423, 0.218861922621727, 0.21210002899169922, -0.15223778784275055, -0.7097547054290771, -0.2696886360645294, -0.8543950319290161, -0.7301539182662964, 0.2863367199897766, -0.6977903842926025, -0.06843005120754242, -0.8845722675323486, -0.07105016708374023, 0.08079604059457779, 0.053436003625392914, -0.45699694752693176, 0.2862668037414551, 0.2017725557088852, 0.8474276065826416, -0.8381796479225159, 0.22169865667819977, 0.37300410866737366, -0.42541635036468506, -0.35124537348747253, -0.1759231686592102, 0.7784637212753296, -0.7857542037963867, 0.40127691626548767, 0.03801756724715233, -0.3741176426410675, -0.03287249058485031, -0.7315750122070312, -0.6101568937301636, 0.044729359447956085, -0.41369879245758057, -0.4248230755329132, 0.32682323455810547, 0.335454523563385, 0.6939352750778198, -0.07772348821163177, 0.3433651924133301, 0.337769478559494, 0.38555601239204407, -0.13468974828720093, -0.5532599687576294, -0.008723560720682144, -0.5328422784805298, -0.48890697956085205, 0.2835952937602997, -0.5305414795875549, 0.7015151977539062, 0.28858715295791626, -0.1577329933643341, -0.11756061762571335, 0.18294158577919006, -0.023586301133036613, 0.21320953965187073, 0.6011015176773071, 1.0752599239349365, 0.07450251281261444, 0.06758660823106766, 0.7966541647911072, 0.07873575389385223, 0.04351760819554329, 1.310465693473816, -0.02075144834816456, 0.9202713370323181, 0.4033965766429901, -0.4747591018676758, 0.5154456496238708, 0.2169460505247116, -0.14224418997764587, -0.040786582976579666, 0.4350757300853729, -0.3405733108520508, 0.010496200062334538, -0.4988226890563965, -0.3041215240955353, 0.40558868646621704, 0.24664999544620514, 0.06074671447277069, -0.5396523475646973, -0.05279811471700668, 0.15409278869628906, 0.5283841490745544, -0.3085567355155945, 0.9956133365631104, 0.04616858810186386, -0.40798842906951904, 0.2503797113895416, 0.13568441569805145, 0.8321736454963684, -0.6910449266433716, -0.16841712594032288, -0.07306630909442902, -0.1529223471879959, -0.35567718744277954, -0.7984876036643982, 0.942281186580658, 0.5232771039009094, -0.35088226199150085, -0.6457907557487488, 0.8233045935630798, -0.0847432091832161, -0.22088322043418884, 0.5245814919471741, 0.391407310962677, 0.44178545475006104, -0.17391730844974518, -1.0476775169372559, -0.009758146479725838, 0.0567411370575428, -0.11801336705684662, 0.7418416738510132, -0.10557680577039719, -0.07578098028898239, 0.5168931484222412, 0.7538751363754272, 0.35695308446884155, 0.13716013729572296, 0.2536465525627136, 0.5280143618583679, -0.9011723399162292, -0.32897239923477173, -0.694206178188324, 0.39482545852661133, -0.3726672828197479, -0.48688024282455444, 0.8982661962509155, 0.5194932818412781, 1.0944690704345703, 0.10469690710306168, 0.6177381277084351, -0.5745030641555786, 1.3477435111999512, -0.050497449934482574, 0.6047565937042236, -0.3216734230518341, -0.3556309938430786, -0.4093441963195801, -0.6419086456298828, -0.47809404134750366, 0.4868188500404358, -0.10457798093557358, -0.3512806296348572, 0.4463089108467102, 0.8177964091300964, 0.22000204026699066, 0.07102464139461517, 0.20949292182922363, 0.24087999761104584, 0.30293744802474976, -0.003205690300092101, 0.7704476118087769, -0.32225629687309265, 0.613614022731781, -0.46014782786369324, -0.14792872965335846, -0.1044107973575592, -0.8826037645339966, -0.6870301961898804, -0.5593850016593933, -0.14380116760730743, -0.4051307439804077, -0.05660378187894821, 0.7467584013938904, 0.36458203196525574, -1.0511844158172607, -0.3705538213253021, 0.0670168548822403, 0.22684694826602936, -0.3138783276081085, -0.19782111048698425, -0.20182767510414124, -0.24351516366004944, -0.6545196175575256, 0.3939491808414459, 0.08603560924530029, -0.1695602685213089, -0.04212618246674538, 0.12683017551898956, -0.5955662131309509, 0.15017803013324738, 0.7138630151748657, 0.8239611387252808, -0.4440978765487671, 0.1165667399764061, -0.2548498213291168, 0.02622547745704651, 0.03556996211409569, 1.2058824300765991, -0.7903251647949219, 0.7827037572860718, 0.5702562928199768, 0.6493502259254456, 0.4080263674259186, -0.05511629953980446, 0.3970456123352051, -0.9295908808708191, 0.07739774882793427, 0.8275545835494995, -0.04263664782047272, 0.2544942796230316, -0.07081267982721329, 0.649704098701477, 0.35698091983795166, -0.4317007064819336, -0.8513182401657104, 0.6951963901519775, -0.6780650019645691, -0.49698129296302795, 0.8444802165031433, 0.23174303770065308, 0.28719785809516907, -0.743434488773346, -0.06611178070306778, 0.5412629842758179, -0.16360162198543549, 1.0736069679260254, 0.59180748462677, -0.3333267867565155, -0.2665310800075531, -0.44645437598228455, 0.968027651309967, 0.448214590549469, -0.818818986415863, 0.21089962124824524, 0.20106293261051178, 0.027772407978773117, 0.43095633387565613, 0.9058893918991089, -0.22574271261692047, -0.010667913593351841, 0.3084028363227844, 0.4308582842350006, 0.15345224738121033, -0.23260730504989624, -0.05251212790608406, 0.37613868713378906, -0.0948776826262474, 0.3918050527572632 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20101v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20101v1
RealKIE: Five Novel Datasets for Enterprise Key Information Extraction
2024-03-29T10:31:32
2024-03-29T10:31:32
Benjamin Townsend, Madison May, Christopher Wells
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
We introduce RealKIE, a benchmark of five challenging datasets aimed at advancing key information extraction methods, with an emphasis on enterprise applications. The datasets include a diverse range of documents including SEC S1 Filings, US Non-disclosure Agreements, UK Charity Reports, FCC Invoices, and Resource Contracts. Each presents unique challenges: poor text serialization, sparse annotations in long documents, and complex tabular layouts. These datasets provide a realistic testing ground for key information extraction tasks like investment analysis and legal data processing. In addition to presenting these datasets, we offer an in-depth description of the annotation process, document processing techniques, and baseline modeling approaches. This contribution facilitates the development of NLP models capable of handling practical challenges and supports further research into information extraction technologies applicable to industry-specific problems. The annotated data and OCR outputs are available to download at https://indicodatasolutions.github.io/RealKIE/ code to reproduce the baselines will be available shortly.
[ -0.23508742451667786, -0.5800396203994751, 0.3861862123012543, -0.07979937642812729, -0.1359010636806488, 0.27679330110549927, -0.19949661195278168, -0.8530552387237549, 0.25416454672813416, 0.9051640033721924, -0.7787800431251526, -0.6505677700042725, -0.45535293221473694, 0.2269476056098938, -0.2370859980583191, 0.8690182566642761, 0.1494055688381195, -0.38799774646759033, -0.0034476229920983315, -0.13691383600234985, -0.5959044098854065, -0.4802042543888092, -0.003511998103931546, 0.23108883202075958, 0.20998533070087433, 0.7684117555618286, 0.42123162746429443, 0.7803069949150085, 0.864854633808136, 0.15036210417747498, 0.11427439749240875, 0.02821395918726921, -0.14251351356506348, 0.45230022072792053, 0.16359466314315796, -0.5135730504989624, -0.3931587040424347, 0.42713114619255066, 0.39349091053009033, 0.3998907208442688, -0.11114314198493958, 0.6436610817909241, -0.48567354679107666, 0.5029494166374207, -0.9301521182060242, 0.48717907071113586, -0.7540245652198792, 0.28824159502983093, -0.39952588081359863, 0.07773887366056442, -0.40378671884536743, -0.41398364305496216, 0.06429596990346909, -1.0121861696243286, 0.18130868673324585, 0.2767072021961212, 1.5917774438858032, 0.0020994532387703657, -0.19486182928085327, -0.6201356649398804, -0.7070200443267822, 0.653127908706665, -0.625680685043335, 0.40826207399368286, 0.2498510181903839, 0.5703495144844055, 0.18531952798366547, -1.3817847967147827, -0.5277311205863953, -0.17326632142066956, 0.02010377123951912, 0.45433610677719116, -0.14262701570987701, -0.04381105303764343, 0.5947602391242981, 0.26053979992866516, -0.17444360256195068, 0.3144455552101135, -0.6601516604423523, 0.013240423984825611, 0.38701701164245605, 0.17098675668239594, 0.04285784438252449, -0.1635153740644455, -0.0964973196387291, -0.3914923667907715, -0.7379734516143799, 0.041923973709344864, 0.6150033473968506, 0.34011122584342957, 0.07147727906703949, 0.5024644732475281, -0.21305027604103088, 0.4228319525718689, -0.06989587843418121, -0.05840890854597092, 0.2925131618976593, -0.4093637764453888, -0.34069719910621643, 0.17664062976837158, 0.4656866192817688, 0.1164955198764801, 0.12127349525690079, -0.34217536449432373, -0.08496968448162079, -0.22444774210453033, 0.49102863669395447, -0.5885084271430969, -0.5520010590553284, 0.5328921675682068, -0.7481315732002258, -0.622440755367279, 0.3498421311378479, -0.9613916277885437, -0.432817280292511, -0.22200851142406464, 0.11400986462831497, -0.2393309473991394, -0.407011479139328, -0.11096099019050598, -0.7111549973487854, 0.5063181519508362, 0.32203495502471924, -0.8429920077323914, 0.2946198582649231, 0.8829253911972046, 0.5899064540863037, 0.30456283688545227, 0.13859547674655914, -0.4879862070083618, 0.2317214161157608, -0.5016313195228577, 0.5906497836112976, -0.7692984938621521, -0.12351217120885849, 0.01252042967826128, 0.03439340367913246, 0.24469232559204102, -0.9331110715866089, 0.7704066038131714, -0.5155462026596069, 0.059077706187963486, -0.43633532524108887, -0.5752749443054199, -0.09704869240522385, 0.1468607485294342, -1.1985853910446167, 0.9206527471542358, 0.21662427484989166, -0.5733336210250854, 0.8014868497848511, -0.7729710936546326, 0.06162070482969284, 0.5622684359550476, -0.5152313113212585, -0.554472029209137, 0.19006431102752686, -0.04588131606578827, 0.5141949653625488, -0.549961507320404, -0.017969626933336258, -0.32692497968673706, 0.09645365178585052, 0.09923484176397324, -0.12340877950191498, 0.7029275298118591, 0.3151649832725525, -0.1881502866744995, -0.27862080931663513, -1.1964644193649292, -0.010642582550644875, 0.42009854316711426, 0.054532647132873535, -0.5204420685768127, -0.278140127658844, 0.1926867514848709, 0.10393565893173218, 0.4328426420688629, -0.5890645384788513, 0.3868774175643921, 0.06843472272157669, 0.3982529044151306, 0.46372243762016296, 0.22765515744686127, 0.12808109819889069, 0.11679203063249588, 0.545658528804779, 0.21334825456142426, 0.37675318121910095, -0.2782970666885376, -0.3087426424026489, -0.36835020780563354, -0.6765846610069275, 0.8749728798866272, 0.7322933673858643, -0.1560729593038559, 0.5535692572593689, -0.5491219758987427, -0.5687621235847473, -0.8522027730941772, -0.15936176478862762, 0.1949121057987213, 0.46009549498558044, 0.25187015533447266, -0.38931065797805786, -0.6394436359405518, -1.232808232307434, -0.3675885796546936, -0.16069982945919037, -0.20424717664718628, -0.047743603587150574, 0.4753577709197998, 0.16012084484100342, 1.1492416858673096, -0.5874317288398743, -0.4622441530227661, -0.178070068359375, 0.5910320281982422, 0.41757485270500183, 0.21476222574710846, 0.2547037899494171, -0.9619361758232117, -0.26766863465309143, 0.06106586754322052, -1.0095964670181274, 0.10027119517326355, -0.49613457918167114, 0.24788612127304077, -0.450662761926651, 0.4500690996646881, -0.5834023952484131, 0.29072505235671997, 0.0055430177599191666, -0.09909605979919434, 0.58591628074646, 0.013112896122038364, -0.06392859667539597, -0.9119515419006348, 0.42315104603767395, -0.026706606149673462, -0.32252946496009827, -0.6670670509338379, 0.15950536727905273, 0.5835645794868469, -0.21535950899124146, -0.22676117718219757, 0.23053628206253052, -0.6765000820159912, -0.2552092969417572, 0.3881918787956238, 0.2931682765483856, 0.3257054090499878, 0.03099125809967518, -0.0055656093172729015, 0.698113739490509, 0.07099532335996628, -0.4113965928554535, 0.585469126701355, 0.5067501664161682, -0.46850472688674927, 0.35470813512802124, -0.34529027342796326, -0.010295775718986988, -0.07750571519136429, 0.025873154401779175, -0.5218613743782043, -0.2457064539194107, 0.1053081825375557, -0.3127237558364868, 0.4222107529640198, -0.2983817458152771, -0.527353048324585, 0.0006632080767303705, -0.5152190327644348, -0.4851997494697571, 0.4443003237247467, -0.3888624608516693, 0.5649811029434204, 0.635868489742279, -0.38194772601127625, -0.5817444324493408, -0.6514828205108643, 0.506203830242157, -0.5317596197128296, -0.3522113561630249, 0.3262503147125244, 0.546206533908844, -0.3920826017856598, 0.22226126492023468, -0.14959493279457092, -0.3399740755558014, 0.32228678464889526, 0.2110096514225006, 0.4020617604255676, -0.08298924565315247, -0.0657929852604866, -0.24063944816589355, -0.2832430899143219, -0.06419124454259872, -0.19929572939872742, -0.13260528445243835, 0.21163588762283325, 0.12321701645851135, -0.4405442774295807, 0.12296919524669647, 0.33105653524398804, -0.27315694093704224, 0.5691174268722534, 0.5042909383773804, -0.7021985650062561, 0.053627148270606995, -0.5708692669868469, -0.07329077273607254, -0.3829101026058197, 0.4763486087322235, -0.8147342205047607, -0.1871383637189865, 0.7904942035675049, -0.44056347012519836, 0.6264006495475769, 0.5813093185424805, 0.2545831501483917, -0.10717526078224182, 0.38196784257888794, 0.6757551431655884, 0.005812947638332844, 0.4603010416030884, -0.6910304427146912, 0.4860226809978485, -0.6586529016494751, -0.27626386284828186, -0.8727810978889465, -0.012548976577818394, -0.5409126877784729, 0.0609554760158062, 0.06612440943717957, 0.11104398965835571, 0.34566518664360046, 0.7279807925224304, -0.3257908225059509, 0.44729313254356384, 0.52250736951828, -0.3141879439353943, 0.215566024184227, -0.1561892181634903, 0.0262849610298872, -0.36383524537086487, -0.4677192270755768, -0.9048299789428711, 1.1858500242233276, 0.6078905463218689, 0.5250281095504761, 0.01975041814148426, 0.7364440560340881, 0.5603450536727905, 0.17410172522068024, -0.4762672185897827, 0.15516315400600433, -0.20670340955257416, -0.7834837436676025, -0.5070582032203674, -0.2444046288728714, -0.7762568593025208, -0.069390669465065, -0.41290268301963806, -0.8166471719741821, 0.5718109607696533, -0.09030041843652725, -0.5794580578804016, 0.059414055198431015, -0.7871922254562378, 1.0586421489715576, -0.026077110320329666, -0.39776286482810974, 0.04043097048997879, -0.7963621020317078, 0.3296481966972351, -0.15166456997394562, 0.3101257085800171, -0.25013628602027893, -0.15557995438575745, 0.9430776238441467, -0.19532261788845062, 0.5079975128173828, -0.3171483874320984, 0.1475074589252472, 0.18548183143138885, -0.0645199865102768, 0.8635185956954956, 0.09389013797044754, -0.0221780426800251, 0.21215324103832245, 0.3702549636363983, -0.2370738387107849, -0.4417857527732849, 0.17304205894470215, -0.38296249508857727, 0.021620482206344604, -0.4843832850456238, 0.06479328870773315, -0.1120988056063652, 0.1707017868757248, 0.32840487360954285, 0.4113989770412445, -0.14742375910282135, 0.4180949628353119, 0.7028728127479553, 0.057610832154750824, 0.3808687627315521, 0.20161953568458557, 0.4172897934913635, -0.5839369893074036, 0.9278075098991394, 0.5718404650688171, -0.04531628265976906, 0.49170079827308655, -0.233096644282341, -0.44614216685295105, -0.4526262879371643, -0.37977921962738037, 0.024971801787614822, -0.9367849826812744, -0.2393311709165573, -0.6821011900901794, 0.04355835169553757, -0.5355738997459412, 0.06417319178581238, -0.5576571822166443, -0.9544540643692017, -0.3624902367591858, -0.43325746059417725, 0.09710772335529327, 0.8516414165496826, 0.23785334825515747, 0.08269140124320984, -1.0660067796707153, 0.5565280318260193, 0.19853293895721436, 0.15274210274219513, -0.3493775427341461, 0.01755627617239952, -0.5569139719009399, -0.3760143518447876, -0.33087095618247986, -0.9971269369125366, 0.43408098816871643, 0.10342589765787125, 0.6342206001281738, 0.20112194120883942, 0.11513371765613556, 0.7055093050003052, -0.10263899713754654, 0.9216742515563965, 0.01948404498398304, -0.576479434967041, 0.27994659543037415, -0.04963907599449158, -0.3537571430206299, 1.0632762908935547, 0.43680980801582336, -0.5511230826377869, -0.17750102281570435, -1.2513771057128906, -1.2506166696548462, 0.6159956455230713, 0.4201376140117645, -0.4859852194786072, 0.31225264072418213, 0.6198006868362427, 0.19614306092262268, 0.37645649909973145, -0.42152485251426697, -0.03322033956646919, 0.04332307353615761, -0.5129360556602478, 0.5067815780639648, -0.30654922127723694, -0.04174165800213814, 0.5259881019592285, 0.6740039587020874, 0.24190030992031097, 0.19687913358211517, 0.2015877068042755, -0.4210539162158966, 0.14224247634410858, 0.030520658940076828, 0.2345968633890152, 0.791037917137146, -0.6673367619514465, -0.11246093362569809, -0.029718752950429916, -0.9318042397499084, -0.09685605019330978, -0.05487316474318504, -0.18352574110031128, 0.224507138133049, 0.7163754105567932, 0.58280348777771, -0.1412041187286377, -0.5708922743797302, 0.36620742082595825, -0.5262339115142822, -0.1154397502541542, -0.7518537640571594, -0.10968944430351257, -0.21083711087703705, 0.13356009125709534, 0.615901529788971, -0.6271263360977173, 0.37010714411735535, -0.42662888765335083, 0.24862664937973022, 0.1231062039732933, -0.29216161370277405, -0.2942458987236023, 0.668839156627655, 0.27561938762664795, -0.021655330434441566, 0.8393803238868713, -0.04908524081110954, 0.01585587114095688, 0.7562512755393982, 0.11590512841939926, 1.0865997076034546, 0.42079150676727295, -0.19727683067321777, 0.25251516699790955, 0.5193068981170654, 0.10724939405918121, 0.14282535016536713, -0.10155056416988373, -0.3638326823711395, -0.11645705997943878, -0.30806565284729004, -0.9432529807090759, 0.5045939087867737, -0.6775804758071899, 0.5509032607078552, -0.5341252088546753, -0.2226942479610443, 0.5059139728546143, 0.46066802740097046, -0.7906941771507263, 0.29100605845451355, -0.16250035166740417, 1.0533303022384644, -0.9696548581123352, 0.6978883147239685, 0.45378243923187256, -0.8164976835250854, -0.35190075635910034, -0.07516826689243317, -0.1345687359571457, -0.46137481927871704, 0.5771932601928711, 0.03455562889575958, 0.5362401604652405, -0.09100823849439621, -0.3771990239620209, -0.37846899032592773, 1.200043797492981, 0.07446719706058502, -0.8393305540084839, -0.22311735153198242, 0.13459764420986176, 0.04017256945371628, -0.39000535011291504, 0.385905385017395, 0.8003764748573303, 0.6836307048797607, -0.46345505118370056, -0.43714672327041626, -0.17263025045394897, -0.21386012434959412, -0.18363037705421448, 0.1120968759059906, -0.48084455728530884, 0.581278920173645, 0.4474269151687622, -0.0979008749127388, -0.309365451335907, 0.6988861560821533, 0.20804323256015778, 0.17792430520057678, 0.39952388405799866, 0.489717960357666, 0.9774941205978394, -0.007822724059224129, 0.6799120306968689, -0.3811463713645935, 0.18487752974033356, 1.0901925563812256, -0.49512481689453125, 0.6579077243804932, 0.462025910615921, -0.208786740899086, 0.22889362275600433, 0.7289488315582275, -0.16294798254966736, 0.44093751907348633, 0.08953245729207993, -0.0892864465713501, 0.1054607629776001, -0.005240979138761759, -0.25098302960395813, 0.21047158539295197, 0.5999511480331421, -0.0404498316347599, 0.10361979901790619, -0.3277515470981598, 0.07184755802154541, -0.20890013873577118, 0.2897462248802185, 1.136009693145752, -0.1360761821269989, -0.1187453642487526, 0.10814428329467773, 0.1917957216501236, 0.3605429530143738, -0.8316471576690674, -0.36135903000831604, -0.10662859678268433, -0.06790939718484879, -0.21123766899108887, -0.5919350385665894, 0.19956153631210327, 0.18370479345321655, -0.05593639239668846, -0.22368501126766205, 0.8124863505363464, -0.0634404718875885, -0.17337588965892792, -0.11814854294061661, -0.021429235115647316, 0.25846800208091736, -0.05470990762114525, -0.5455909371376038, -0.05510368198156357, -0.07962208986282349, -0.35883527994155884, 0.18427377939224243, 0.8021615743637085, -0.29879438877105713, 0.3075230121612549, 0.5661728978157043, 0.5152919888496399, 0.2790650427341461, -0.13056254386901855, 0.5629775524139404, -1.0825061798095703, -0.577346682548523, -0.543355405330658, 0.5951578617095947, -0.7101229429244995, -0.47819268703460693, 0.5190213322639465, 0.9844744801521301, 0.6276105046272278, -0.23408249020576477, 1.1400669813156128, -0.23882246017456055, 0.5894201993942261, -0.6285381317138672, 0.3232771158218384, -0.04279381036758423, 0.24613624811172485, -0.0847112238407135, -0.8501039147377014, -0.19409747421741486, 0.3828350305557251, 0.08110827207565308, -0.5107741951942444, 0.6267080903053284, 0.5865321159362793, -0.20127272605895996, 0.1595582515001297, 0.32964423298835754, 0.1948285698890686, 0.6678698062896729, -0.04474620148539543, 0.47471627593040466, -0.746993362903595, 0.49701160192489624, -0.5211696624755859, -0.17721939086914062, -0.3930535912513733, -1.0398894548416138, -0.2122664600610733, -0.6659207344055176, -0.42464882135391235, -0.3573223352432251, 0.10507644712924957, 0.8964985013008118, 0.7145923376083374, -0.8052615523338318, -0.09146323055028915, -0.10541939735412598, -0.03828734531998634, -0.271538108587265, -0.253685861825943, 0.24232354760169983, -0.5119189620018005, -0.4410879611968994, 0.2577236294746399, 0.4730783700942993, -0.047929808497428894, -0.03680281713604927, 0.35791516304016113, -0.2546679973602295, -0.14502695202827454, 0.11223955452442169, 0.447674959897995, -0.26328155398368835, -0.21676434576511383, -0.07096866518259048, -0.005500829312950373, 0.11315607279539108, 0.7770242094993591, -0.5165426135063171, 0.3636656403541565, 0.5641854405403137, 0.5974000692367554, 0.7503030896186829, 0.059224627912044525, 0.40480974316596985, -0.8383522033691406, 0.4047064483165741, 0.31423220038414, 0.10619321465492249, 0.10017459839582443, -0.48234784603118896, 0.8285765051841736, 0.3636625111103058, -0.24308066070079803, -1.0043988227844238, -0.0912686362862587, -0.7863495945930481, -0.1583929806947708, 0.402463436126709, -0.30126020312309265, -0.5447283983230591, -0.414010226726532, -0.025142142549157143, 0.30266961455345154, -0.3323870003223419, 0.6995648741722107, 0.788522481918335, 0.02700009010732174, -0.09128148853778839, -1.0062390565872192, 0.5643994212150574, -0.07104604691267014, -0.9542939066886902, 0.5601003170013428, 0.45404571294784546, -0.024691108614206314, 0.30299004912376404, 0.6007546782493591, -0.3758556842803955, 0.18061332404613495, 0.3657190501689911, 0.48973923921585083, -0.1019819900393486, -0.5879567265510559, -0.4293201267719269, 0.4248197078704834, 0.25326263904571533, -0.45981791615486145 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20088v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20088v1
An Efficient Approach for Studying Cross-Lingual Transfer in Multilingual Language Models
2024-03-29T09:52:18
2024-03-29T09:52:18
Fahim Faisal, Antonios Anastasopoulos
cs.CL
cs.CL
The capacity and effectiveness of pre-trained multilingual models (MLMs) for zero-shot cross-lingual transfer is well established. However, phenomena of positive or negative transfer, and the effect of language choice still need to be fully understood, especially in the complex setting of massively multilingual LMs. We propose an \textit{efficient} method to study transfer language influence in zero-shot performance on another target language. Unlike previous work, our approach disentangles downstream tasks from language, using dedicated adapter units. Our findings suggest that some languages do not largely affect others, while some languages, especially ones unseen during pre-training, can be extremely beneficial or detrimental for different target languages. We find that no transfer language is beneficial for all target languages. We do, curiously, observe languages previously unseen by MLMs consistently benefit from transfer from almost any language. We additionally use our modular approach to quantify negative interference efficiently and categorize languages accordingly. Furthermore, we provide a list of promising transfer-target language configurations that consistently lead to target language performance improvements. Code and data are publicly available: https://github.com/ffaisal93/neg_inf
[ -0.38385218381881714, -0.6327851414680481, 0.21232180297374725, 0.3818683624267578, -0.06235922500491142, -0.019867241382598877, -0.45296716690063477, -0.6689502596855164, 0.2825337052345276, 0.31292062997817993, -0.3705798387527466, -0.13593074679374695, -0.6693692207336426, 0.0820450559258461, -0.2564416229724884, 0.8445342779159546, -0.16988499462604523, 0.29275840520858765, 0.048768047243356705, -0.14816851913928986, -0.33233681321144104, -0.6796276569366455, -0.5373172760009766, -0.49870482087135315, 0.6210984587669373, 0.4935791790485382, 0.28321871161460876, 0.09352509677410126, 0.4672779142856598, 0.20693840086460114, 0.2791193723678589, -0.42830178141593933, -0.8458390831947327, -0.1516532152891159, -0.645484983921051, -0.4954770803451538, -0.4505808353424072, -0.1684214174747467, 0.7808071970939636, 0.6450886726379395, 0.17674830555915833, 0.3891802728176117, -0.030126161873340607, 0.32879456877708435, -0.8820937275886536, 0.00640996266156435, -0.687985360622406, 0.17774783074855804, -0.4885317087173462, -0.3204405903816223, -0.66099613904953, -0.025804245844483376, -0.041919659823179245, -0.45551565289497375, -0.13004170358181, -0.2573102116584778, 0.5932449102401733, -0.08674521744251251, -0.5952077507972717, 0.05484941229224205, -0.9260408878326416, 0.878248393535614, -0.679736316204071, 0.4449305236339569, 0.23041152954101562, 0.3190785348415375, 0.15816354751586914, -0.2005498707294464, -0.5746408700942993, -0.3080855906009674, -0.21082918345928192, 0.12780986726284027, -0.27820852398872375, -0.028970248997211456, 0.04738890007138252, 0.14642290771007538, -0.6553124785423279, 0.13004912436008453, -0.21595390141010284, -0.2199522703886032, 0.5934005379676819, -0.20170873403549194, 0.6735271215438843, 0.173629492521286, -0.3605538010597229, 0.0004988976288586855, -0.6784724593162537, -0.03401171416044235, 0.34743013978004456, 0.48488849401474, -0.15025973320007324, 0.5462700128555298, -0.14274750649929047, 0.9427000284194946, 0.001492153387516737, -0.1567223072052002, 0.1955806463956833, -0.7834736108779907, -0.01597047969698906, 0.09919959306716919, 0.47490394115448, 0.1113646999001503, 0.5195006728172302, -0.49615946412086487, -0.007529593072831631, -0.07735764235258102, 0.07710787653923035, -1.0253863334655762, -0.01139525230973959, -0.30385640263557434, -0.15776591002941132, 0.057048968970775604, -0.3104557693004608, -0.43841466307640076, 0.037421200424432755, -0.2567817270755768, 0.8860910534858704, -0.3918326199054718, -0.5687029957771301, 0.143964022397995, -0.0002256040315842256, 0.40377673506736755, 0.062068093568086624, -0.8105752468109131, 0.13431794941425323, 0.27517879009246826, 0.7698587775230408, -0.2382727712392807, -0.5940691828727722, -0.7044456005096436, 0.2933706045150757, -0.4248133599758148, 0.7016466856002808, -0.5176172852516174, -0.16280300915241241, -0.07842228561639786, 0.13202212750911713, -0.6300977468490601, -0.3230104148387909, 0.10897670686244965, -0.3460230529308319, 0.12677013874053955, -0.1198931559920311, -0.470790296792984, -0.45095133781433105, 0.3963497281074524, -0.5307349562644958, 0.6134766936302185, 0.1145208403468132, -0.3684181272983551, 0.20580452680587769, -0.6485227346420288, -0.8045053482055664, 0.07527606934309006, 0.05948439985513687, -0.008016607724130154, 0.012097080238163471, -0.03805336728692055, 0.40206101536750793, 0.14720575511455536, 0.026461193338036537, -0.585491955280304, -0.4724830389022827, 0.1279214322566986, -0.4118172526359558, 0.7918753623962402, 0.04487882927060127, -0.5247178673744202, -0.029939601197838783, -0.7286180257797241, 0.007242660969495773, -0.10185303539037704, -0.12375151365995407, -0.461030513048172, -0.49726954102516174, 0.13584329187870026, 0.550349235534668, 0.26691967248916626, -0.5839532017707825, 0.1206684410572052, -0.1516057848930359, -0.10763797909021378, 0.3365778625011444, -0.24587377905845642, 0.9721351861953735, -0.0349760465323925, 0.8629541397094727, -0.001763507490977645, 0.0726805031299591, -0.14467911422252655, -0.10015586018562317, -0.8364555835723877, -0.1578778624534607, 0.32735735177993774, 0.5870843529701233, -1.0160853862762451, -0.0655500665307045, -0.06255150586366653, -0.40612950921058655, -0.5480712652206421, 0.25918737053871155, 0.5406579375267029, 0.47316238284111023, 0.2994534373283386, -0.37459108233451843, -0.2864689528942108, -0.9351571798324585, -0.4843613803386688, -0.017420047894120216, 0.4404592216014862, 0.20610718429088593, 0.15610718727111816, -0.09894473850727081, 0.4302423298358917, -0.14300578832626343, -0.1511121541261673, -0.5707527995109558, 0.033777058124542236, 0.19154798984527588, 0.4583679139614105, 1.073880910873413, -0.4227079749107361, -1.1536989212036133, 0.4976544678211212, -0.6355803608894348, -0.22932901978492737, -0.23001272976398468, -0.552301824092865, 0.43646684288978577, 0.5482816100120544, -0.4242129325866699, 0.15165770053863525, 0.9000166654586792, -0.3649083375930786, 0.5194922089576721, -0.11373069137334824, 0.28786909580230713, -0.8529683351516724, 0.5286691188812256, -0.01691056415438652, -0.3811458647251129, -1.1956208944320679, -0.10746964067220688, 0.28553181886672974, 0.10895098000764847, -0.8149301409721375, 0.8596000075340271, -0.5916200876235962, -0.00887396652251482, -0.344585120677948, 0.0030027353204786777, -0.21595489978790283, 0.6130634546279907, 0.09088420122861862, 0.6708028316497803, 0.7199113965034485, -0.5334793925285339, -0.14018672704696655, -0.13187944889068604, -0.1565961390733719, 0.8663724660873413, -0.22686822712421417, 0.08496065437793732, -0.1866525560617447, 0.010903730988502502, -0.8753312826156616, 0.31838107109069824, 0.637376070022583, -0.3662581145763397, 0.7938258647918701, -0.3743799030780792, -0.04009982571005821, 0.21870140731334686, -0.050709810107946396, 0.6990569829940796, 0.14424410462379456, -0.3542775809764862, 0.37773072719573975, 0.3240368962287903, -0.1688128113746643, -0.7267683148384094, -0.7171446084976196, 0.1825447827577591, -0.3476358652114868, -0.3282719850540161, 0.22229889035224915, -0.23305769264698029, -0.06819915026426315, 0.012959195300936699, -0.058572378009557724, -0.27814608812332153, 0.05723148211836815, -0.2693496346473694, 0.3134804964065552, -0.35879483819007874, -0.06713436543941498, -0.09584013372659683, -0.18517732620239258, -0.16366255283355713, -0.3574550747871399, 0.38465723395347595, -0.04156045243144035, -0.36276763677597046, -0.26835623383522034, 0.28802788257598877, 0.5596820116043091, -0.2955491244792938, 0.7286407947540283, 0.940546989440918, -0.14140255749225616, -0.1870846301317215, -0.30659592151641846, 0.00238204887136817, -0.38377079367637634, 0.6563336849212646, -0.5794076323509216, -0.7744956016540527, 0.41506174206733704, 0.22784985601902008, -0.033702194690704346, 0.3485685884952545, 0.48256346583366394, 0.3281927704811096, 0.9009422063827515, 0.9397715926170349, -0.3133201003074646, 0.8416322469711304, -0.07908764481544495, 0.3567171096801758, -0.503086268901825, -0.05995643138885498, -0.4003024399280548, -0.3100731074810028, -0.3473074734210968, -0.5414714813232422, 0.05190794914960861, 0.46819576621055603, 0.013951062224805355, 0.8040522336959839, 0.11847622692584991, 0.4830164611339569, 0.14697782695293427, -0.42431312799453735, 0.35505813360214233, -0.036351945251226425, -0.012633847072720528, -0.03666830435395241, -0.9995218515396118, -0.09498617053031921, 1.01762056350708, 0.12055286020040512, 0.7877603769302368, 0.4209160804748535, 0.580518901348114, -0.005129262804985046, 0.5521144866943359, -0.698589563369751, 0.3671296536922455, -0.3507921099662781, -0.6640911102294922, -0.3061867356300354, -0.6014283895492554, -0.8580217957496643, 0.6296928524971008, -0.2683923840522766, -0.7691962122917175, 0.20705533027648926, 0.09496521949768066, -0.04938685894012451, 0.3664127588272095, -0.8834306001663208, 1.0233080387115479, -0.4994836449623108, -0.5780274868011475, -0.27451610565185547, -0.37518590688705444, 0.45113518834114075, -0.36519449949264526, 0.18077562749385834, -0.09908564388751984, 0.18060915172100067, 0.36144185066223145, 0.11652112752199173, 0.6173496246337891, -0.12221290916204453, -0.30240410566329956, 0.01309492252767086, 0.43367722630500793, 0.22639185190200806, -0.13755054771900177, -0.15750612318515778, 0.5080764293670654, 0.07761397957801819, -0.6741182208061218, -0.6159855723381042, 0.7071707248687744, -0.5096319317817688, -0.31184640526771545, -0.1223086565732956, -0.6737217903137207, -0.1279677152633667, 0.5380560159683228, 0.18283286690711975, 0.21635562181472778, -0.33313754200935364, -0.03701789304614067, 0.30304771661758423, -0.20670609176158905, 0.6019382476806641, 1.0597329139709473, -0.48244383931159973, 0.07480306178331375, 1.2043190002441406, 0.45335036516189575, 0.6186129450798035, 0.7967336773872375, 0.04071176424622536, -0.4058210551738739, -0.5143693089485168, -0.9064889550209045, 0.29038816690444946, -0.4077731668949127, 0.08634771406650543, -0.4261862635612488, -0.16663821041584015, -0.4722789227962494, -0.08263024687767029, -0.5730774998664856, -0.5514612793922424, -0.17060567438602448, 0.034679725766181946, -0.023540833964943886, 0.6111870408058167, -0.3071928918361664, 0.07067538052797318, -0.9497390389442444, 0.16016799211502075, 0.06763789802789688, 0.34245195984840393, -0.012381373904645443, -0.6092008948326111, -0.5656217932701111, 0.0777866318821907, 0.03751620277762413, -0.8637995719909668, 0.44010108709335327, 0.4810711443424225, 1.0182044506072998, 0.48328423500061035, 0.04842135310173035, 0.8318213820457458, -0.3858046531677246, 0.4152458608150482, 0.3448273241519928, -1.0395900011062622, 0.020923851057887077, -0.2026735246181488, 0.4983837604522705, 0.6610687375068665, 0.5398112535476685, -0.7266448140144348, -0.3088097870349884, -0.266004741191864, -0.7127364873886108, 1.033484697341919, 0.16584689915180206, 0.1016889289021492, 0.1262221485376358, 0.04371581971645355, 0.17687442898750305, 0.16056005656719208, -0.8481020927429199, -0.39953503012657166, -0.015785980969667435, 0.2789478898048401, -0.6342588067054749, 0.061032187193632126, 0.25463059544563293, -0.2551616132259369, 0.7875521779060364, -0.19976021349430084, -0.1473759114742279, -0.020364629104733467, -0.71422278881073, -0.2735944092273712, 0.3682728707790375, 0.6475452780723572, 0.614647626876831, -0.14431782066822052, 0.3832588195800781, 0.48401471972465515, -0.25060391426086426, 0.28888145089149475, 0.05266551300883293, -0.15251491963863373, 0.14343798160552979, 0.3648090958595276, 0.7583684325218201, 0.3391185700893402, -0.44942015409469604, 0.47853150963783264, 0.05415869504213333, -0.1697276532649994, 0.11132129281759262, -0.12995652854442596, 0.15521040558815002, 0.16689613461494446, -0.17651543021202087, 0.035425424575805664, 0.1436738520860672, -0.7055660486221313, 0.2486668825149536, 0.5408058762550354, -0.6465660929679871, -0.7210984230041504, 0.1325504332780838, 0.2872619330883026, -0.25388988852500916, 0.3608105182647705, -0.3447466492652893, -0.5465242862701416, 0.37853336334228516, 0.8568357229232788, 0.7506124973297119, -0.48643794655799866, 0.34202125668525696, 0.4911910593509674, 0.3738774061203003, 0.11452504247426987, -0.02873322181403637, -0.2747932970523834, -0.8337557315826416, -0.8572115302085876, -0.47654685378074646, -0.16424843668937683, 0.10168566554784775, -0.6686476469039917, 0.23756349086761475, 0.15004710853099823, 0.025003014132380486, -0.026810234412550926, -0.09067873656749725, -0.6108565330505371, -0.2643086314201355, 0.6007834672927856, 0.7925410866737366, -0.8701848983764648, 1.1415927410125732, 0.6974234580993652, -0.2078850120306015, -0.6254717111587524, -0.16357195377349854, -0.1863502413034439, -0.8228784799575806, 0.5057895183563232, 0.05267958343029022, -0.47670793533325195, 0.05116072669625282, 0.07717601209878922, -0.8955596685409546, 0.5866794586181641, 0.796911895275116, -0.6903006434440613, 0.3545462191104889, 0.3410716950893402, 0.5167961120605469, -0.19371925294399261, 0.5792830586433411, 0.5879315137863159, 0.5981431603431702, 0.09869759529829025, -1.108378529548645, -0.05508386716246605, -0.35424062609672546, -0.14955684542655945, 0.4605017900466919, -0.5852222442626953, 0.8186296820640564, -0.15434987843036652, -0.25148805975914, -0.16937154531478882, 0.21282650530338287, -0.2377474009990692, 0.26563963294029236, 0.39987844228744507, 0.4351792335510254, 0.3282368779182434, 0.4639108180999756, 0.8085939884185791, -0.5942085981369019, 0.4456941783428192, 1.0744972229003906, -0.4246276915073395, 0.8884720206260681, 0.7204107046127319, 0.0024569230154156685, 0.1967543363571167, 0.2159843146800995, 0.3101021647453308, 0.5077922344207764, 0.2909553349018097, -0.2879266142845154, -0.43052545189857483, -0.08938346803188324, -0.5438152551651001, 0.49653974175453186, -0.05864543095231056, -0.021062210202217102, -0.5909338593482971, 0.09069604426622391, 0.20402684807777405, -0.19121234118938446, -0.23739291727542877, 0.6591055393218994, 0.1051439493894577, -0.7593799829483032, 0.684980571269989, -0.072928287088871, 0.8938713669776917, -0.8396754860877991, -0.1093183159828186, -0.36372554302215576, 0.3918892741203308, -0.27540770173072815, -0.4963192641735077, 0.4996408522129059, -0.13764934241771698, -0.032031841576099396, -0.3887094557285309, 0.8855760097503662, -0.9893114566802979, -0.6039568781852722, 0.8232097625732422, 0.8241379857063293, 0.35238099098205566, -0.11521195620298386, -0.5381008386611938, -0.40799108147621155, 0.2234068661928177, -0.07980258017778397, 0.8114913702011108, 0.2344145029783249, -0.16236433386802673, 0.2149500995874405, 0.6606219410896301, 0.34437012672424316, 0.26561489701271057, 0.14458425343036652, 0.34254029393196106, -0.5747935175895691, -0.33199983835220337, -0.8892676830291748, 0.3094221353530884, 0.2263588160276413, -0.312926322221756, 1.088916540145874, 0.5379624962806702, 1.2501944303512573, -0.15004491806030273, 0.6899707317352295, 0.005798394326120615, 0.10108619183301926, -0.3375411331653595, 0.9392984509468079, -0.7634726762771606, 0.049176618456840515, -0.33688393235206604, -1.048370122909546, -0.32827720046043396, 0.5182397365570068, -0.3218618333339691, -0.18892697989940643, 0.5039622187614441, 0.826787531375885, -0.21827490627765656, -0.3335570991039276, 0.7309786677360535, 0.14108040928840637, 0.24290603399276733, 0.6813141107559204, 0.904363751411438, -0.23734480142593384, 0.778415858745575, -0.4432738721370697, -0.32068946957588196, -0.21398822963237762, -0.904937207698822, -0.8126811385154724, -0.14905226230621338, -0.3249780237674713, 0.0011014404008165002, 0.10102207958698273, 0.5796962380409241, 0.9551818370819092, -0.8391194343566895, -0.8278203010559082, 0.09619409590959549, 0.25729599595069885, -0.32529860734939575, -0.1777680516242981, 0.020234931260347366, -0.530933678150177, -0.7685664892196655, 0.54664546251297, 0.3675057590007782, -0.07032432407140732, -0.22951962053775787, -0.26111048460006714, -0.43360915780067444, -0.04475266858935356, 0.9248488545417786, 0.44074350595474243, -0.20709460973739624, -0.10822223126888275, 0.242152139544487, 0.034091074019670486, -0.11475100368261337, 0.9999268054962158, -0.37982887029647827, 0.560318648815155, 0.5604684352874756, 0.5999767780303955, 0.7050455808639526, -0.346129447221756, 0.7356246113777161, -0.5023377537727356, 0.19300304353237152, 0.033618614077568054, 0.23917679488658905, 0.1560230404138565, -0.26473528146743774, 0.3464771509170532, 0.20958948135375977, -0.14415137469768524, -0.6336132884025574, 0.1730431318283081, -0.8229058384895325, -0.5152326226234436, 1.370461106300354, -0.2060917168855667, -0.09479771554470062, -0.10711777955293655, -0.034040339291095734, 0.24746088683605194, -0.09523642063140869, 0.46395835280418396, 0.7083053588867188, -0.32354629039764404, -0.10107676684856415, -0.41518354415893555, 0.15301772952079773, 0.7013255953788757, -0.7546706199645996, -0.25969362258911133, 0.2294236123561859, 0.44023653864860535, 0.1360405683517456, 0.7713800668716431, -0.1958019733428955, 0.08409129828214645, -0.0598064549267292, 0.19232499599456787, 0.07576490938663483, -0.4955875277519226, -0.7294504046440125, -0.0331236906349659, 0.07303977757692337, -0.31385064125061035 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20084v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20084v1
IPA Transcription of Bengali Texts
2024-03-29T09:33:34
2024-03-29T09:33:34
Kanij Fatema, Fazle Dawood Haider, Nirzona Ferdousi Turpa, Tanveer Azmal, Sourav Ahmed, Navid Hasan, Mohammad Akhlaqur Rahman, Biplab Kumar Sarkar, Afrar Jahin, Md. Rezuwan Hassan, Md Foriduzzaman Zihad, Rubayet Sabbir Faruque, Asif Sushmit, Mashrur Imtiaz, Farig Sadeque, Syed Shahrier Rahman
cs.CL
cs.CL
The International Phonetic Alphabet (IPA) serves to systematize phonemes in language, enabling precise textual representation of pronunciation. In Bengali phonology and phonetics, ongoing scholarly deliberations persist concerning the IPA standard and core Bengali phonemes. This work examines prior research, identifies current and potential issues, and suggests a framework for a Bengali IPA standard, facilitating linguistic analysis and NLP resource creation and downstream technology development. In this work, we present a comprehensive study of Bengali IPA transcription and introduce a novel IPA transcription framework incorporating a novel dataset with DL-based benchmarks.
[ -0.07587604224681854, -0.1990976184606552, 0.01739250309765339, 0.5758102536201477, -0.17842236161231995, 0.14877241849899292, -0.041809771209955215, -0.7003111243247986, 0.41283732652664185, 0.6856156587600708, -0.1661810725927353, -0.46064451336860657, -0.4070172607898712, 0.5731187462806702, -0.08660943061113358, 0.5187458992004395, 0.16185425221920013, 0.03468194231390953, 0.5063318610191345, -0.16237443685531616, -0.5860305428504944, -0.634549081325531, -0.323180228471756, -0.025634825229644775, 0.5002855658531189, 0.22894588112831116, 0.4774750769138336, 0.6127781867980957, 0.6559446454048157, 0.05800168216228485, -0.3950307369232178, 0.22273357212543488, 0.09592276066541672, 0.44596001505851746, 0.08199910074472427, -0.4983097314834595, -0.4860103130340576, -0.14491119980812073, 0.9665394425392151, 1.1578032970428467, 0.23886416852474213, 0.33645856380462646, -0.11844633519649506, 0.740410566329956, -0.7070122957229614, 0.43257543444633484, -0.5558242201805115, -0.048436205834150314, -0.5564287304878235, -0.30037257075309753, -0.610370397567749, -0.48088696599006653, 0.06965071707963943, -0.2492079883813858, -0.10796909034252167, 0.1292472630739212, 0.4684249460697174, 0.31710347533226013, -0.4410950541496277, -0.40915873646736145, -0.5022816061973572, 0.3824324905872345, -0.5098980069160461, 0.48142531514167786, 0.35912808775901794, 0.16566593945026398, -0.03543967753648758, -0.5888082385063171, -0.34071096777915955, 0.14803199470043182, -0.0017192180966958404, 0.07509393990039825, 0.1309983879327774, 0.18144820630550385, -0.04284241423010826, 0.6271433234214783, -0.7566618919372559, -0.0012208451516926289, -0.5913686156272888, -0.27570977807044983, 0.4325506091117859, -0.09068265557289124, 0.47803059220314026, -0.28084099292755127, -0.22938326001167297, 0.0040010674856603146, -0.9388867020606995, 0.2236858457326889, 0.4906412661075592, 0.7692717909812927, -0.004513932857662439, 0.7256461977958679, -0.07991040498018265, 0.921944260597229, -0.10981976240873337, -0.21419373154640198, 0.60451740026474, -0.139947772026062, -0.18332305550575256, 0.689170241355896, 0.3950682580471039, 0.24258838593959808, 0.27191734313964844, -0.07824408262968063, -0.2848583459854126, -0.24251802265644073, 0.21446135640144348, -0.4880703091621399, 0.11612603813409805, 0.25993824005126953, -0.5976489782333374, 0.1961737871170044, 0.11629994213581085, -0.5709431767463684, -0.36770230531692505, -0.4173182249069214, -0.05700493976473808, -0.5708499550819397, -0.49424129724502563, 0.17779085040092468, -0.5740723609924316, 0.2944614589214325, -0.0444452241063118, -1.111013650894165, 0.07053644955158234, 0.6763511896133423, 0.894804835319519, -0.18285265564918518, -0.20981954038143158, -0.035760924220085144, 0.34708118438720703, -0.6706188917160034, 0.8290979862213135, -0.6535188555717468, -0.6992770433425903, 0.39782822132110596, -0.2802020013332367, -0.06895072758197784, -0.9403138756752014, 0.5831073522567749, -0.5047646164894104, -0.35468119382858276, -0.2582021653652191, -0.6087585687637329, -0.20427043735980988, 0.0709262415766716, -0.8306336998939514, 0.9267255663871765, 0.0960078313946724, -0.6725673675537109, 0.4581545293331146, -0.6289259195327759, -0.5769559144973755, 0.3235165774822235, -0.10778097063302994, 0.15106570720672607, 0.10158802568912506, 0.19394585490226746, 0.3072245717048645, -0.15242935717105865, -0.045132383704185486, 0.1361803561449051, -0.7793423533439636, 0.22890333831310272, -0.252024382352829, 1.3913843631744385, 0.28262120485305786, -0.044503312557935715, -0.14660724997520447, -1.1030752658843994, 0.06954940408468246, -0.25363245606422424, -0.4999241232872009, -0.6418406963348389, -0.46622803807258606, 0.14373016357421875, -0.4576842784881592, 0.30679211020469666, -0.5107922554016113, 0.9328275918960571, -0.36738917231559753, 0.3257295787334442, 0.4254288077354431, 0.3248535394668579, 0.4851771593093872, -0.32665571570396423, 0.35307127237319946, -0.3786121904850006, 0.10726942867040634, -0.6537863612174988, -0.6275231242179871, -0.21923744678497314, -0.7224717140197754, 0.7272047400474548, 0.6483570337295532, -0.10633531957864761, 0.7012797594070435, -0.3545093238353729, -0.3275645971298218, -0.9570741057395935, -0.18591777980327606, 0.21335096657276154, 0.20604988932609558, 0.3689083755016327, -0.3614095449447632, -0.9729307293891907, -0.9032830595970154, -0.18754278123378754, -0.7100130319595337, 0.03262721374630928, -0.16058297455310822, -0.048705700784921646, -0.22660240530967712, 0.9254990816116333, 0.08333136141300201, -0.29563143849372864, -0.2713721990585327, 0.5490508675575256, 0.3905874788761139, 0.3126518726348877, 0.6520912051200867, -1.022547960281372, -0.47518283128738403, -0.3087761700153351, -0.5614925026893616, -0.6246727705001831, -0.15942281484603882, 0.2739376425743103, 0.236580953001976, 0.5560064911842346, -0.4290062189102173, 0.3984891474246979, 0.4505861699581146, -0.041571471840143204, 0.6850800514221191, 0.22209897637367249, 0.46804118156433105, -0.6959697604179382, 0.2730235755443573, -0.3891862630844116, 0.1808733493089676, -0.37542444467544556, -0.08127978444099426, 0.2201487421989441, -0.02039078250527382, -0.3124895393848419, 0.5938808917999268, -0.5337556600570679, -0.260588139295578, -0.042406242340803146, -0.3728230893611908, -0.043372031301259995, 0.24388226866722107, 0.014747296459972858, 1.035876750946045, 0.23723088204860687, -0.4473736882209778, -0.03276439383625984, 0.4853499233722687, -0.4542076289653778, 0.43453094363212585, -0.431511253118515, -0.06101426109671593, 0.1614394634962082, 0.17155912518501282, -0.9828498959541321, -0.04855640232563019, 0.186483234167099, -0.7056602835655212, 0.5278040170669556, -0.47601261734962463, -0.7099258303642273, -0.03986276313662529, -0.1233404353260994, 0.477392315864563, 0.6363741755485535, -0.32490602135658264, 0.42319321632385254, 0.6915161609649658, -0.6526044011116028, -0.885761022567749, -0.738359272480011, 0.4405863881111145, 0.08632256835699081, -0.41669946908950806, 0.31845828890800476, 0.03597690165042877, -0.671946108341217, -0.3263792097568512, -0.09742119163274765, -0.19692790508270264, -0.1777666062116623, 0.4143438935279846, 0.06524963676929474, -0.22882375121116638, -0.01904306374490261, 0.08994761109352112, -0.05727564916014671, -0.0001567284925840795, -0.2385130524635315, 0.5370708703994751, 0.1736792027950287, -0.054410628974437714, -0.6677060723304749, 0.6935434937477112, 0.9064962267875671, -0.27179187536239624, 0.2122148722410202, 0.10787384957075119, -0.23677696287631989, -0.2623869478702545, -0.543218731880188, 0.26857736706733704, -0.36918842792510986, 0.04409434273838997, -0.5336437225341797, -0.3053467273712158, 0.7331938743591309, -0.2434791475534439, -0.00199225265532732, 0.14766064286231995, 0.550568163394928, -0.05887182056903839, 0.49912577867507935, 0.48000359535217285, -0.16355352103710175, 0.35063639283180237, -0.12897200882434845, 0.22671422362327576, -0.8879894018173218, -0.19950233399868011, -0.8616827726364136, -0.023735858500003815, -0.44378408789634705, 0.01938534528017044, 0.2573343515396118, 0.007989359088242054, -0.23045025765895844, 0.32428520917892456, -0.5462554693222046, 0.2512000501155853, 0.6816810965538025, -0.27808651328086853, 0.19089044630527496, -0.02324371598660946, -0.3244926333427429, -0.26043999195098877, -0.2740544378757477, -0.7599748969078064, 0.978461742401123, 0.15791022777557373, 0.5554598569869995, 0.1396597921848297, 0.7857558131217957, 0.7160999774932861, -0.03935709223151207, -0.5193890333175659, 0.5177122950553894, -0.1661815494298935, -0.8920901417732239, -0.17972040176391602, 0.004800865892320871, -0.6643741726875305, -0.04424213990569115, 0.14314910769462585, -0.6308318376541138, 0.5482291579246521, 0.026760876178741455, -0.21372324228286743, 0.16410410404205322, -0.7097414135932922, 0.42948174476623535, 0.003208525711670518, 0.09463411569595337, 0.34353211522102356, -0.7891000509262085, -0.03141489997506142, 0.1511199027299881, 0.08722679316997528, 0.02236233651638031, -0.2099221795797348, 0.7706059217453003, -0.0167083777487278, 0.9126745462417603, -0.13477490842342377, -0.3341529965400696, 0.44935935735702515, 0.15108318626880646, -0.07157135754823685, -0.09588390588760376, -0.49912601709365845, 0.590402364730835, 0.054195962846279144, -0.1947646141052246, -0.3879767954349518, 0.2484404742717743, -0.42873722314834595, -0.19909706711769104, -0.38473281264305115, -0.4304056167602539, -0.24390152096748352, 0.4355788826942444, 0.17665036022663116, 0.36140698194503784, -0.056959208101034164, 0.2373146265745163, 0.6358911991119385, -0.12250269949436188, 0.2704128623008728, 0.2673444151878357, -0.17271758615970612, -0.5548810362815857, 0.7106949687004089, 0.5451507568359375, -0.15311065316200256, 0.6161357760429382, -0.04484071582555771, -0.3301953971385956, -0.9877679347991943, -0.46887537837028503, -0.07972431182861328, -0.8347829580307007, -0.1701260656118393, -0.43149372935295105, -0.21428798139095306, -0.9396675825119019, -0.06834710389375687, -0.34072551131248474, -0.5842419266700745, -0.034854065626859665, -0.028050877153873444, 0.08808159083127975, 0.7694383263587952, -0.33449673652648926, 0.043362293392419815, -1.0365995168685913, 0.36867135763168335, 0.11304763704538345, 0.30376020073890686, -0.1871596723794937, -0.3853830397129059, -0.16628070175647736, -0.1788429170846939, 0.16993100941181183, -0.9781752824783325, 0.199031263589859, 0.1820846050977707, 0.5269424319267273, 0.12117835879325867, 0.24827119708061218, 0.5786584615707397, -0.633537769317627, 1.1370463371276855, -0.09480676800012589, -0.9637224078178406, 0.5293641686439514, -0.40970221161842346, 0.2567165493965149, 0.7390446066856384, 0.42554688453674316, -0.6241011023521423, -0.3079562485218048, -0.2831558585166931, -0.9845172762870789, 0.0039343563839793205, 0.13765017688274384, -0.24405018985271454, -0.17056481540203094, 0.63286292552948, 0.5305215120315552, 0.1616024225950241, -0.23847173154354095, -0.2887672185897827, -0.049055539071559906, -0.3786642849445343, 0.3104507029056549, -0.5244273543357849, -0.010950334370136261, -0.09402251988649368, 0.5034517049789429, 0.013281046412885189, 0.2259952276945114, 0.4518658518791199, -0.09987716376781464, 0.19679836928844452, 0.345801442861557, 0.30235710740089417, 0.6432727575302124, -0.3829512298107147, -0.08325056731700897, -0.45422282814979553, -0.776066243648529, 0.19893106818199158, 0.04365316405892372, -0.5060432553291321, 0.2986513078212738, 0.9705791473388672, 0.31095758080482483, 0.15114200115203857, -0.8978923559188843, 0.34375491738319397, -0.04704449325799942, -0.058919262140989304, -0.5951104760169983, 0.02662767469882965, -0.14238241314888, 0.14144226908683777, 0.9779854416847229, 0.16969288885593414, 0.2961926758289337, -0.7074813842773438, 0.18548399209976196, -0.09776182472705841, -0.1247093603014946, -0.35579758882522583, 0.36054548621177673, 0.27060163021087646, -0.589478075504303, 0.5420140624046326, 0.021868698298931122, -0.5115025639533997, 0.5711253881454468, 0.5045424103736877, 0.759819746017456, -0.2022736668586731, -0.112949438393116, 0.2748863399028778, 0.4033501446247101, -0.037745002657175064, 0.6628870368003845, -0.2146957963705063, -0.4966314435005188, -0.34980309009552, -0.6271599531173706, -0.6391875147819519, -0.022390274330973625, -0.9114096164703369, 0.18073590099811554, -0.40145424008369446, -0.24579846858978271, 0.017842154949903488, -0.16693952679634094, -0.3449515998363495, 0.13863083720207214, 0.318413645029068, 1.1566557884216309, -0.6564225554466248, 0.7418904900550842, 0.6345368027687073, -0.43187543749809265, -0.5360970497131348, 0.15539905428886414, -0.02612517960369587, -0.8330246210098267, 1.1551735401153564, 0.35313668847084045, -0.21229998767375946, -0.1539861112833023, -0.5111490488052368, -0.6737353801727295, 0.593845009803772, 0.36911728978157043, -0.6796117424964905, -0.040857117623090744, 0.150654137134552, 0.5548871159553528, -0.4380802512168884, -0.10116837918758392, 0.6071103811264038, 0.72360759973526, -0.15987394750118256, -1.134779691696167, -0.36700376868247986, -0.5131234526634216, -0.12094467878341675, 0.008212900720536709, -0.5303577184677124, 0.7801836133003235, 0.09641623497009277, -0.23895682394504547, 0.2013089805841446, 0.5195342898368835, 0.055096425116062164, 0.08775144070386887, 0.1697380691766739, 0.3050213158130646, 0.8355432748794556, 0.0174173004925251, 0.7721313238143921, -0.39125683903694153, -0.36745211482048035, 1.000454306602478, -0.7991008162498474, 0.9536284804344177, 0.678083598613739, -0.11433235555887222, 0.37588268518447876, 0.8719260692596436, 0.15153130888938904, 0.5199986100196838, 0.19829398393630981, -0.16476251184940338, 0.08683974295854568, -0.2394709587097168, -0.5150631666183472, 0.8151819109916687, 0.5298705697059631, -0.08351657539606094, 0.33736568689346313, -0.027888083830475807, -0.3799484670162201, 0.1819370836019516, -0.3521300256252289, 0.8633316159248352, -0.2772526144981384, -0.6415634155273438, 0.52495276927948, -0.5173618793487549, 0.6596089005470276, -0.7247109413146973, -0.36098572611808777, -0.13407570123672485, 0.04563247039914131, -0.013606743887066841, -0.6312988996505737, 0.5096117258071899, -0.11360006779432297, -0.4245820641517639, -0.28816673159599304, 0.30011066794395447, -0.1538780778646469, -0.21731023490428925, 0.47909003496170044, 0.04296309873461723, 0.21597439050674438, 0.07681956887245178, -0.3240409791469574, 0.6311039328575134, -0.05213071033358574, -0.04487655684351921, 0.0033039681147783995, 0.6012982130050659, 0.2364586591720581, 0.44594040513038635, 0.3746422231197357, 0.5996015071868896, 0.2051887959241867, 0.13588503003120422, 0.23872248828411102, -0.7831906676292419, -0.7151978611946106, -0.41434118151664734, 0.4241867661476135, -0.03985998034477234, -0.6137259602546692, 0.5991129279136658, 0.545221745967865, 0.7686840295791626, -0.1310771256685257, 1.232252597808838, -0.06443072855472565, 0.7745072841644287, -0.7307256460189819, 0.757732629776001, -0.37060895562171936, 0.2139587104320526, -0.01978374272584915, -0.8716012239456177, -0.8340467214584351, 0.5056707859039307, 0.18277083337306976, -0.3448771834373474, 0.5763075351715088, 0.5416690707206726, 0.42525622248649597, 0.33987849950790405, 0.08495605736970901, 0.0762983188033104, 0.3217185139656067, -0.11074148863554001, 0.4942394196987152, -0.4656594693660736, 0.2310003787279129, -0.04811442643404007, -0.20084817707538605, -0.39152202010154724, -0.7778304219245911, -0.6973074078559875, -0.9906094670295715, 0.03856190666556358, -0.20126374065876007, 0.3451952636241913, 1.1451590061187744, 0.533072292804718, -0.6910184025764465, -0.3308706283569336, 0.4457257390022278, -0.005364060401916504, -0.5916107892990112, -0.21747149527072906, 0.6473663449287415, -0.400550901889801, -0.7483640313148499, 0.6808552145957947, 0.5270645022392273, 0.14157693088054657, -0.13516275584697723, 0.1651337444782257, -0.31049999594688416, 0.1060522049665451, 0.2894703149795532, 0.6090292930603027, -0.4958471953868866, -0.29484614729881287, 0.07621673494577408, -0.14193089306354523, 0.23711256682872772, 1.2948096990585327, -0.4502488076686859, 0.5104575753211975, 0.6862008571624756, 0.8960719108581543, -0.047767214477062225, -0.2781318128108978, 0.6848636269569397, -0.8207548260688782, 0.402595579624176, 0.599060595035553, 0.5078963041305542, 0.47856608033180237, -0.2898065447807312, 0.5446566939353943, 0.07988874614238739, -0.4833049178123474, -0.9909989833831787, 0.11100365966558456, -1.1608332395553589, -0.2686096727848053, 1.0257169008255005, -0.14425265789031982, -0.32873865962028503, -0.6379269361495972, -0.5085666179656982, 0.19000910222530365, -0.5730077624320984, 0.6928613781929016, 0.7766602039337158, -0.17631323635578156, 0.11314762383699417, 0.042683977633714676, 0.33341971039772034, 0.03819357976317406, -0.04707326367497444, 0.37914347648620605, 0.28389620780944824, -0.1082039475440979, 0.5293982028961182, 0.8619154691696167, -0.22720967233181, 0.17733310163021088, 0.40024080872535706, 0.30201178789138794, -0.04956113547086716, -0.7031181454658508, -0.4072609841823578, 0.5999846458435059, 0.03135458007454872, 0.026379892602562904 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20056v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20056v1
Cross-Lingual Transfer Robustness to Lower-Resource Languages on Adversarial Datasets
2024-03-29T08:47:15
2024-03-29T08:47:15
Shadi Manafi, Nikhil Krishnaswamy
cs.CL
cs.CL
Multilingual Language Models (MLLMs) exhibit robust cross-lingual transfer capabilities, or the ability to leverage information acquired in a source language and apply it to a target language. These capabilities find practical applications in well-established Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks such as Named Entity Recognition (NER). This study aims to investigate the effectiveness of a source language when applied to a target language, particularly in the context of perturbing the input test set. We evaluate on 13 pairs of languages, each including one high-resource language (HRL) and one low-resource language (LRL) with a geographic, genetic, or borrowing relationship. We evaluate two well-known MLLMs--MBERT and XLM-R--on these pairs, in native LRL and cross-lingual transfer settings, in two tasks, under a set of different perturbations. Our findings indicate that NER cross-lingual transfer depends largely on the overlap of entity chunks. If a source and target language have more entities in common, the transfer ability is stronger. Models using cross-lingual transfer also appear to be somewhat more robust to certain perturbations of the input, perhaps indicating an ability to leverage stronger representations derived from the HRL. Our research provides valuable insights into cross-lingual transfer and its implications for NLP applications, and underscores the need to consider linguistic nuances and potential limitations when employing MLLMs across distinct languages.
[ -0.5417008996009827, -0.637403130531311, 0.22043602168560028, 0.341833233833313, -0.013193920254707336, 0.22853150963783264, -0.45969077944755554, -0.7580406069755554, 0.08003094047307968, 0.4133588969707489, -0.18601255118846893, -0.009990540333092213, -0.8451783061027527, 0.37945908308029175, -0.47086602449417114, 1.012924075126648, -0.25900015234947205, 0.10717685520648956, 0.1659071445465088, -0.37509968876838684, -0.22287815809249878, -0.8634089231491089, -0.8395859599113464, -0.3271663784980774, 0.7748045921325684, 0.042304590344429016, 0.9237710237503052, 0.3726044297218323, 0.649596631526947, 0.26791080832481384, -0.04443288594484329, -0.08186810463666916, -0.40677976608276367, 0.03151712194085121, -0.5014812350273132, -0.4414951205253601, -0.16767878830432892, -0.3144233524799347, 0.9506852626800537, 0.8903524279594421, 0.14631196856498718, 0.08758067339658737, 0.3022614121437073, 0.40775051712989807, -0.7319949865341187, -0.048070747405290604, -0.7924338579177856, 0.2723712921142578, -0.44315385818481445, -0.016684429720044136, -0.4238894283771515, 0.016902094706892967, 0.22695358097553253, -0.5112109184265137, 0.062251828610897064, 0.05635582283139229, 1.0612077713012695, 0.2017279714345932, -0.3230002224445343, -0.21104185283184052, -0.8124622702598572, 0.758918821811676, -0.539050817489624, 0.7807267308235168, 0.49411070346832275, 0.31819093227386475, 0.04113486409187317, -0.48751190304756165, -0.4107135236263275, -0.49885427951812744, -0.3582179546356201, -0.2345806360244751, -0.3777361810207367, -0.35706719756126404, 0.43684011697769165, 0.04225560650229454, -0.6085904836654663, 0.2673361897468567, -0.2729317247867584, -0.3373202383518219, 0.4314383268356323, -0.24678674340248108, 0.6352840662002563, -0.17354382574558258, -0.5771245956420898, -0.08531353622674942, -0.8618230819702148, 0.12173256278038025, 0.3327893018722534, 0.7339276075363159, -0.08035794645547867, 0.630154013633728, 0.16203469038009644, 0.6852310299873352, -0.0031143873929977417, -0.001988924341276288, -0.0445694662630558, -0.645884096622467, -0.12842276692390442, 0.234275683760643, 0.7721344828605652, -0.05986059084534645, 0.3688587248325348, -0.5298588871955872, -0.23622077703475952, -0.2879185676574707, -0.03954005613923073, -0.7084038853645325, -0.2779660224914551, -0.46259215474128723, -0.3288963735103607, -0.048563260585069656, -0.15955223143100739, -0.7474464774131775, -0.41576170921325684, -0.1814134269952774, 0.3451521098613739, -0.54742032289505, -0.22274766862392426, -0.2948623597621918, 0.14839446544647217, 0.2133135348558426, 0.014873532578349113, -0.9195379614830017, 0.3256611227989197, 0.36338889598846436, 0.7106262445449829, -0.5101108551025391, -0.5411446690559387, -0.8401625156402588, 0.11289254575967789, -0.24135150015354156, 0.6607753038406372, -0.5237756967544556, -0.33117300271987915, -0.20753774046897888, 0.21462464332580566, -0.4363536834716797, -0.5336195826530457, 0.3212257921695709, -0.6764718890190125, 0.17120496928691864, -0.4886482059955597, -0.19931812584400177, -0.191318541765213, 0.26101937890052795, -0.96552973985672, 0.867049515247345, 0.16089995205402374, -0.764991044998169, 0.41275379061698914, -0.496827095746994, -0.8710796236991882, -0.021091077476739883, -0.14529158174991608, -0.10080698877573013, -0.1873653531074524, 0.26569920778274536, 0.33481335639953613, -0.2351628839969635, -0.014002138748764992, -0.46088525652885437, -0.1888931393623352, 0.4979369640350342, -0.8110668063163757, 1.0276426076889038, 0.08017314970493317, -0.4810599088668823, -0.3129422664642334, -0.7988693118095398, 0.013060064055025578, 0.22827087342739105, -0.5179415941238403, -0.7768653631210327, -0.34269022941589355, 0.25500917434692383, 0.3013484477996826, 0.1418449729681015, -0.3261090815067291, 0.020899148657917976, -0.14648236334323883, 0.1228134036064148, 0.48301538825035095, -0.26036393642425537, 0.6509941816329956, -0.026772433891892433, 0.696681022644043, -0.14189450442790985, -0.24835087358951569, 0.37338969111442566, -0.2399282455444336, -0.5994954705238342, -0.13182346522808075, 0.7697794437408447, 0.811356782913208, -1.2896593809127808, -0.057868022471666336, -0.25709229707717896, -0.2398824393749237, -0.46973752975463867, 0.3545432388782501, 0.5360459685325623, 0.509749174118042, 0.3456670939922333, -0.20217816531658173, -0.5783126950263977, -1.0059058666229248, -0.2860032320022583, -0.14697742462158203, 0.12598425149917603, 0.39479860663414, 0.3124317526817322, -0.047397155314683914, 0.47728902101516724, 0.01542962808161974, -0.14689406752586365, -0.45473727583885193, 0.12867869436740875, -0.16530901193618774, 0.2568824887275696, 0.9152607321739197, -0.9344454407691956, -0.7687532305717468, 0.40231141448020935, -0.652962863445282, -0.152084082365036, -0.2086368352174759, -0.2367006242275238, 0.4911590814590454, 0.30835336446762085, -0.40086761116981506, 0.10956744104623795, 0.9837743639945984, -0.3523971140384674, 0.39765462279319763, -0.016476811841130257, 0.1862415373325348, -1.0911744832992554, 0.3550263047218323, -0.12526822090148926, -0.20313087105751038, -0.7428916096687317, 0.06322339922189713, 0.027034856379032135, 0.055949434638023376, -0.8110150098800659, 0.9016234874725342, -0.7318953275680542, -0.43871814012527466, -0.12150447070598602, 0.1696714460849762, -0.049528226256370544, 0.40205851197242737, 0.17157970368862152, 0.9757103323936462, 0.5635825395584106, -0.6034104228019714, 0.40527573227882385, 0.07657383382320404, -0.23809392750263214, 0.8985006213188171, -0.45952579379081726, 0.10413606464862823, 0.25092005729675293, -0.24322804808616638, -0.40282267332077026, 0.17590036988258362, 0.4032767415046692, -0.3050151765346527, 0.6423354744911194, -0.3196408450603485, -0.3387823700904846, 0.23265613615512848, 0.17381010949611664, 0.5191466808319092, 0.20648394525051117, -0.6109248995780945, 0.5420372486114502, 0.2930408716201782, -0.3670447766780853, -0.7870284914970398, -1.0858458280563354, 0.3622678220272064, -0.40535852313041687, -0.4896012842655182, 0.352693110704422, 0.1631309986114502, -0.18708080053329468, 0.45940497517585754, 0.18134146928787231, -0.2052851766347885, 0.1352744847536087, -0.012972951866686344, 0.47513607144355774, -0.47816041111946106, -0.13222089409828186, -0.3437475264072418, 0.11351261287927628, -0.037441056221723557, -0.011024653911590576, 0.3539499044418335, -0.11789248138666153, -0.4885026514530182, 0.12124039232730865, 0.28534722328186035, 0.5897426009178162, -0.3067740797996521, 0.8855519890785217, 0.9004234075546265, -0.46754297614097595, -0.19346588850021362, -0.11511967331171036, 0.054311271756887436, -0.3666664659976959, 0.5786009430885315, -0.7164731621742249, -0.7225030064582825, 0.7056939601898193, 0.3644726276397705, -0.0911431610584259, 0.4237230122089386, 0.46684953570365906, 0.21085648238658905, 0.7869467735290527, 0.585253894329071, -0.4388880431652069, 0.6089881062507629, -0.03953665867447853, 0.18267668783664703, -1.0923866033554077, 0.07403261214494705, -0.5421707630157471, -0.36449939012527466, -0.6413543224334717, -0.36163002252578735, -0.10948093235492706, -0.008237805217504501, 0.04461090266704559, 0.7976727485656738, 0.01089647226035595, 0.22218261659145355, 0.5487942099571228, -0.3468708097934723, 0.2814485430717468, 0.22485171258449554, -0.29942044615745544, -0.23754440248012543, -0.8709835410118103, -0.34379029273986816, 0.8635831475257874, 0.20781412720680237, 0.8243128061294556, 0.3556465804576874, 0.4402714967727661, 0.22822071611881256, 0.2911171317100525, -0.5645101070404053, 0.5949123501777649, -0.565580427646637, -0.4956686496734619, -0.40083393454551697, -0.655336320400238, -1.218535304069519, 0.4882964491844177, -0.3987361192703247, -0.7699022889137268, 0.3439582288265228, -0.22952918708324432, -0.22223660349845886, 0.6041836142539978, -0.5190813541412354, 0.721813440322876, -0.7068461775779724, -0.32473453879356384, 0.29812246561050415, -0.41773197054862976, 0.2914506196975708, -0.3763987123966217, 0.1293972283601761, 0.021869411692023277, 0.03428918495774269, 0.5549500584602356, 0.18238131701946259, 0.40310174226760864, 0.1149425134062767, -0.29345178604125977, -0.0944087877869606, 0.3225061893463135, 0.551898717880249, -0.1665945053100586, -0.08447419106960297, 0.4705674350261688, -0.15703999996185303, -0.20195913314819336, -0.7978660464286804, 0.7476771473884583, -0.6286497712135315, -0.4491942226886749, -0.2784300148487091, -0.7020307779312134, -0.17089645564556122, 0.5027279257774353, 0.37393301725387573, 0.24533650279045105, -0.16270029544830322, 0.2763288617134094, 0.4061855375766754, -0.20870552957057953, 0.2816593647003174, 0.6204782724380493, -0.4098067879676819, -0.173440620303154, 1.0881099700927734, 0.42756718397140503, 0.4998871088027954, 0.4979223608970642, -0.15620724856853485, -0.2757691740989685, -0.5505254864692688, -0.9333251714706421, 0.020396923646330833, -0.6454375982284546, 0.07100897282361984, -0.46599653363227844, -0.48684054613113403, -0.2957514524459839, -0.18504813313484192, -0.4290066659450531, -0.45930179953575134, -0.29290345311164856, 0.0791172981262207, -0.09729563444852829, 0.40034401416778564, 0.0016257250681519508, -0.34275317192077637, -0.9775416851043701, 0.4101770222187042, 0.29880180954933167, 0.1552765667438507, -0.28100821375846863, -0.6214449405670166, -0.17686273157596588, 0.1322161853313446, 0.3524278402328491, -0.9990039467811584, 0.4073423147201538, 0.21697767078876495, 0.8831060528755188, 0.07641759514808655, 0.13524305820465088, 0.6467307806015015, -0.37370824813842773, 0.5401556491851807, -0.09915944188833237, -0.71766597032547, 0.06669051945209503, 0.03165313974022865, 0.18024419248104095, 0.4198499321937561, 0.344128280878067, -0.495743066072464, -0.5350669026374817, -0.3530549108982086, -0.6852812767028809, 0.6577332615852356, 0.39303985238075256, -0.04719683155417442, 0.3549032509326935, -0.07642912119626999, -0.021380092948675156, -0.09040237963199615, -0.8280967473983765, -0.23907683789730072, 0.056332990527153015, 0.13195212185382843, -0.10797259211540222, 0.10780664533376694, -0.030447112396359444, 0.25950244069099426, 0.6484860777854919, -0.09394413977861404, -0.08040979504585266, 0.2164113074541092, -0.41822993755340576, -0.08800698816776276, 0.45107612013816833, 0.4520084857940674, 0.19546391069889069, 0.1545509546995163, 0.47021642327308655, 0.5191038846969604, -0.4348084628582001, 0.23101092875003815, 0.6505905985832214, -0.4510123133659363, 0.13081257045269012, 0.5244749784469604, 0.8518723845481873, 0.3902451694011688, -0.4343484938144684, 0.07430125772953033, -0.16809825599193573, 0.06902576237916946, 0.11396409571170807, -0.1848878711462021, -0.013416005298495293, 0.4293842911720276, 0.11593329906463623, 0.17817121744155884, 0.2827613055706024, -0.5421586632728577, 0.055416300892829895, 0.7093096971511841, -0.2599901556968689, -0.40152493119239807, 0.5204798579216003, -0.09366679191589355, -0.13518081605434418, 0.5881775617599487, -0.37047773599624634, -0.7801504135131836, 0.6462686657905579, 0.6625130772590637, 0.7486428022384644, -0.20205068588256836, 0.04254145920276642, 0.08224355429410934, 0.5449614524841309, 0.1756369173526764, -0.1176668182015419, -0.01560923084616661, -0.9535199403762817, -0.4856155514717102, -0.5376163125038147, -0.4616309404373169, 0.1352071762084961, -0.7370064854621887, 0.22265540063381195, -0.05266345664858818, -0.28637418150901794, 0.04832955077290535, -0.0615801066160202, -0.8327605128288269, -0.10631489008665085, 0.5836296677589417, 0.5935368537902832, -0.7601318359375, 0.8846805095672607, 1.076088786125183, -0.2670861780643463, -0.9595189094543457, -0.076581671833992, -0.04864412918686867, -0.8181705474853516, 1.0374736785888672, -0.2649390697479248, -0.19953659176826477, -0.21311402320861816, 0.187922865152359, -1.3507943153381348, 0.8162651062011719, 0.7280347347259521, -0.4314118027687073, -0.15274840593338013, 0.32097890973091125, 0.5723279714584351, -0.17537109553813934, -0.17047220468521118, 0.44920963048934937, 0.5957625508308411, 0.11466328054666519, -1.2553577423095703, 0.4027191400527954, -0.2451559454202652, 0.07650145143270493, 0.306872695684433, -0.4489622116088867, 0.9329423904418945, -0.2998330891132355, -0.5772866606712341, -0.17829540371894836, 0.5387394428253174, 0.28339532017707825, 0.08689812570810318, 0.5587518215179443, 0.42301762104034424, 0.6174417734146118, 0.03828995302319527, 1.081969976425171, -0.44730687141418457, 0.17018812894821167, 1.1365019083023071, -0.5590739846229553, 0.9308209419250488, 0.4689766466617584, -0.33136436343193054, 0.4453350603580475, 0.264140784740448, -0.153366819024086, 0.5076631903648376, 0.003586046863347292, 0.06921358406543732, 0.09028898179531097, -0.25144821405410767, -0.35493606328964233, 0.473537415266037, 0.1639762669801712, -0.3647281229496002, -0.23146869242191315, 0.22413818538188934, 0.1468108892440796, -0.24308058619499207, -0.22583270072937012, 0.4714619517326355, 0.12142932415008545, -0.7357395887374878, 0.5811958312988281, -0.17585116624832153, 0.6775467991828918, -0.509479284286499, 0.005684965290129185, -0.16243909299373627, 0.14410902559757233, -0.16654877364635468, -0.8192418813705444, 0.4484942853450775, 0.18564139306545258, -0.05550871789455414, -0.3210757374763489, 0.9913776516914368, -0.7622529864311218, -0.6220043897628784, 0.7158312797546387, 0.6401796936988831, 0.1818486601114273, 0.11738619208335876, -0.754844069480896, -0.09062665700912476, -0.015465382486581802, -0.34555020928382874, 0.6975172162055969, 0.4389338195323944, -0.16184115409851074, 0.5737941265106201, 0.7778240442276001, 0.705781102180481, 0.2900325655937195, 0.06829490512609482, 0.4992782473564148, -0.4659245014190674, -0.1450207680463791, -0.7717234492301941, 0.08646897971630096, 0.1611328274011612, -0.0018972977995872498, 1.114588975906372, 0.3339356482028961, 1.0740394592285156, 0.16034001111984253, 0.8568850755691528, -0.16593317687511444, 0.19345210492610931, -0.7932517528533936, 0.8333167433738708, -0.5226756930351257, 0.16829818487167358, -0.11927368491888046, -1.009988784790039, -0.18410414457321167, 0.4611065685749054, -0.14835217595100403, 0.07963664084672928, 0.6239827871322632, 0.532209038734436, -0.10032212734222412, -0.4118974804878235, 0.5936608910560608, 0.07197155058383942, 0.13311061263084412, 0.8291751146316528, 0.8129275441169739, -0.14109402894973755, 0.8146263360977173, -0.5108429193496704, 0.1869959682226181, -0.1091533973813057, -0.7723535299301147, -0.7452719211578369, -0.41889724135398865, -0.34549587965011597, -0.35152214765548706, 0.13645368814468384, 0.6338309049606323, 0.62965989112854, -0.882722795009613, -0.03543113172054291, 0.3483853042125702, 0.30193451046943665, -0.21733486652374268, -0.2514210045337677, 0.4184323251247406, -0.06229916587471962, -0.8937777876853943, 0.5586509704589844, 0.12015686929225922, 0.278367280960083, -0.5213513970375061, -0.11803623288869858, -0.20099766552448273, -0.13035297393798828, 0.6316676735877991, 0.5731518268585205, -0.6902386546134949, -0.26399168372154236, 0.2975224554538727, -0.5299716591835022, -0.25717854499816895, 0.6768514513969421, -0.5678960084915161, 0.23913390934467316, 0.5065783262252808, 0.9941350221633911, 0.03445613011717796, -0.14647121727466583, 0.6183468103408813, -0.6789990067481995, -0.007476592902094126, 0.08872142434120178, 0.7201515436172485, 0.6353558301925659, -0.4982612431049347, 0.556709885597229, 0.13751082122325897, -0.3228437602519989, -0.8192538619041443, 0.13069960474967957, -0.6630514860153198, -0.22315433621406555, 1.4655505418777466, -0.35472536087036133, 0.02986891195178032, -0.13415539264678955, -0.08597876876592636, 0.2609933912754059, -0.11536014080047607, 0.42288094758987427, 1.0106699466705322, -0.05986880138516426, -0.3012406826019287, -0.5804889798164368, 0.2986210882663727, 0.5135664939880371, -0.7219277620315552, -0.2069931924343109, 0.1833706498146057, 0.3102734684944153, 0.38581404089927673, 0.3314148485660553, -0.05509142577648163, 0.13964420557022095, 0.02558852732181549, -0.14925594627857208, -0.08421330153942108, -0.3024747371673584, -0.43497711420059204, 0.20688876509666443, 0.0932733491063118, -0.10542672872543335 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20046v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20046v2
Can LLMs Learn from Previous Mistakes? Investigating LLMs' Errors to Boost for Reasoning
2024-03-29T08:30:34
2024-06-07T06:27:50
Yongqi Tong, Dawei Li, Sizhe Wang, Yujia Wang, Fei Teng, Jingbo Shang
cs.CL
cs.CL
Recent works have shown the benefits to LLMs from fine-tuning golden-standard Chain-of-Thought (CoT) rationales or using them as correct examples in few-shot prompting. While humans can indeed imitate correct examples, learning from our mistakes is another vital aspect of human cognition. Hence, a question naturally arises: \textit{can LLMs learn and benefit from their mistakes, especially for their reasoning? } This study investigates this problem from both the prompting and model-tuning perspectives. We begin by introducing \textsc{CoTErrorSet}, a new benchmark with 609,432 questions, each designed with both correct and error references, and demonstrating the types and reasons for making such mistakes. To explore the effectiveness of those mistakes, we design two methods: (1) \textbf{Self-rethinking} prompting guides LLMs to rethink whether they have made similar previous mistakes; and (2) \textbf{Mistake tuning} involves finetuning models in both correct and incorrect reasoning domains, rather than only tuning models to learn ground truth in traditional methodology. We conduct a series of experiments to prove LLMs can obtain benefits from mistakes in both directions. Our two methods offer potentially cost-effective strategies by leveraging errors to enhance reasoning capabilities, which costs significantly less than creating meticulously hand-crafted golden references. We ultimately make a thorough analysis of the reasons behind LLMs' errors, which provides directions that future research needs to overcome. \textsc{CoTErrorSet} will be published soon on \texttt{\url{https://github.com/YookiTong/Learn-from-Mistakes-CotErrorSet}}.
[ -0.16395564377307892, -0.6872084140777588, 0.7392863035202026, -0.02854415401816368, -0.17113034427165985, -0.035121116787195206, 0.0862879827618599, -0.2612629234790802, -0.1792742908000946, 0.724586546421051, -0.9109527468681335, -0.151555597782135, -0.15887410938739777, 0.26168233156204224, -0.02545880898833275, 0.9339159727096558, -0.07803518325090408, 0.2939128279685974, -0.3227179944515228, 0.06451006978750229, -0.9773802757263184, -0.4924166798591614, -0.8648310303688049, -0.5384489297866821, 0.9026185870170593, 0.760069727897644, 0.35013070702552795, 0.4621840715408325, 0.30266883969306946, 0.19674615561962128, -0.08266601711511612, 0.745073676109314, -0.6201666593551636, -0.006898902822285891, -0.47021469473838806, -0.9413961172103882, -0.49862465262413025, 0.33658647537231445, 0.3378804922103882, 0.3885340690612793, -0.20871351659297943, 0.0064049968495965, 0.2984035313129425, 0.9665094614028931, -0.6739442944526672, -0.011713025160133839, -0.921078622341156, -0.020491113886237144, 0.006570156197994947, -0.6908665895462036, -0.5510416626930237, -0.40656110644340515, -0.30462026596069336, -0.46958690881729126, 0.3660137951374054, 0.09135911613702774, 0.6409214735031128, 0.6368377804756165, -0.22324064373970032, -0.31613704562187195, -0.6053913235664368, 0.8147804737091064, -0.6517421007156372, 0.27233609557151794, 0.4074268043041229, 0.30913153290748596, -0.5073373913764954, -0.6868374347686768, -0.4159105718135834, -0.07307131588459015, 0.07153485715389252, 0.23489171266555786, 0.06819245964288712, -0.33974191546440125, 0.5870702266693115, 0.11422179639339447, -0.18276166915893555, 0.01244926918298006, -0.31317323446273804, -0.21916897594928741, 0.6149457693099976, 0.21988967061042786, -0.002441828139126301, -0.13478434085845947, -0.345959335565567, -0.3950326144695282, -1.1599494218826294, -0.029430240392684937, 0.45573890209198, 0.17157705128192902, 0.2063145786523819, 0.361854612827301, -0.0207191314548254, 0.7946699857711792, 0.4488716721534729, -0.03362296149134636, -0.03701689466834068, -0.2919270098209381, -0.1321781426668167, 0.0343649797141552, 0.2823319733142853, 0.43590420484542847, 0.5553976893424988, -0.0663144439458847, -0.2664102613925934, -0.075593963265419, 0.529927670955658, -0.23852592706680298, -0.4324232041835785, -0.07424057275056839, -0.17173515260219574, -0.331337034702301, -0.11926238983869553, -0.6172167658805847, -0.6672545671463013, -0.5369445085525513, 0.3957001566886902, -0.37412703037261963, -0.10926833003759384, 0.2783820927143097, -0.12923206388950348, 0.3845541775226593, 0.6997703313827515, -0.6506294012069702, 0.06501384824514389, 0.6908115148544312, 0.6338226199150085, -0.12328395992517471, -0.49812835454940796, -0.5752943158149719, -0.20263737440109253, -0.4784758687019348, 1.208194375038147, 0.0016490473644807935, -0.6473249793052673, -0.16739940643310547, -0.12023099511861801, -0.18947818875312805, -0.8580800890922546, 0.8200995922088623, -0.4770561754703522, -0.259530246257782, -0.8586265444755554, -0.6102446913719177, -0.10616346448659897, 0.2999093234539032, -0.4792622923851013, 0.6716194748878479, -0.12293045222759247, -0.7440517544746399, 0.2894630432128906, -0.15867595374584198, -0.16611327230930328, -0.3623756170272827, -0.31033721566200256, -0.3855142891407013, 0.3249572813510895, 0.17919538915157318, 0.2950540781021118, -0.30685949325561523, -0.06863801181316376, -0.17470329999923706, -0.23543107509613037, 0.6513774394989014, -0.6289448142051697, 0.8419826030731201, -0.03528733178973198, -0.10804619640111923, -0.25180909037590027, -0.7639102935791016, 0.26249977946281433, 0.11157452315092087, -0.2571284770965576, -0.11675412952899933, 0.009281286038458347, -0.6077980399131775, 0.31822580099105835, -0.027887646108865738, -0.1915300339460373, 0.08302236348390579, -0.07665611803531647, 0.2259981632232666, 0.99901282787323, 0.23021763563156128, 0.18719658255577087, -0.9002733826637268, 0.3629908561706543, 0.1236218586564064, 0.11832280457019806, -0.13205084204673767, -0.23109951615333557, -1.0282509326934814, 0.29190242290496826, 0.23880483210086823, 0.5920667052268982, -0.6580871343612671, 0.08707763254642487, 0.20475785434246063, -0.44218215346336365, -0.3795885145664215, 0.4249956011772156, 0.4267733097076416, 0.8531110286712646, 0.43728283047676086, -0.15788236260414124, -0.6765756011009216, -0.5382369756698608, -0.5645411610603333, -0.3600327670574188, 0.2484954595565796, 0.40903496742248535, 0.4952358603477478, -0.07571237534284592, 0.877952516078949, -0.31171301007270813, 0.016579849645495415, -0.02536199428141117, 0.19746026396751404, 0.01808043196797371, 0.5858295559883118, 0.3554675281047821, -0.6342352628707886, -0.08711723238229752, -0.25319528579711914, -0.6825827956199646, -0.2078016698360443, -0.37704020738601685, -0.31008777022361755, 0.17558139562606812, 0.5695728659629822, -0.49417829513549805, 0.27232685685157776, 0.3648134171962738, -0.20164154469966888, 1.131993055343628, -0.20318648219108582, 0.03808581084012985, -0.7872828245162964, -0.38956040143966675, -0.28097987174987793, -0.13103607296943665, -0.23583431541919708, -0.4312582015991211, 0.20337828993797302, 0.5763344168663025, -0.5369899868965149, 0.44071057438850403, -0.5464353561401367, -0.04311604052782059, -0.34956252574920654, 0.06315771490335464, -0.03178049996495247, 0.4584921598434448, -0.2410220205783844, 0.8078731298446655, 0.27135759592056274, -0.7181685566902161, 0.30122092366218567, 0.08935920149087906, -0.19401505589485168, 1.0240057706832886, -0.688334047794342, 0.37760934233665466, -0.10520392656326294, 0.2482452392578125, -0.8618438243865967, -0.17476065456867218, 0.35589566826820374, -0.6206782460212708, 0.4109434187412262, -0.14858461916446686, -0.4460099935531616, -0.2710111141204834, -0.2534262239933014, 0.10094275325536728, 0.4517906606197357, -0.793278157711029, 0.3732307553291321, -0.05049404501914978, -0.006569788325577974, -0.7281143069267273, -0.6968953013420105, -0.1324765384197235, -0.04366961121559143, -0.4451322555541992, 0.008901325054466724, -0.30249109864234924, -0.348415344953537, -0.04545145481824875, -0.4703063666820526, 0.18088021874427795, 0.23006533086299896, 0.30435308814048767, 0.38675957918167114, -0.10227944701910019, 0.38934701681137085, -0.13816700875759125, -0.4086674451828003, 0.14432546496391296, -0.32725533843040466, 0.3583943545818329, -0.3854402005672455, -0.5512115955352783, -0.3087487816810608, -0.07317572087049484, 0.3604589104652405, -0.18353106081485748, 0.45324257016181946, 0.14475814998149872, -0.23049575090408325, -0.2772383987903595, -0.9483811259269714, -0.39321404695510864, -0.4253286123275757, -0.027923233807086945, -0.17947882413864136, -0.610409677028656, 0.313806414604187, -0.18572686612606049, 0.25012144446372986, 0.3766997456550598, 0.3503844141960144, -0.6736173629760742, 0.7373232841491699, 0.5012121200561523, 0.17918677628040314, 0.4133667051792145, -0.41806548833847046, -0.20189648866653442, -1.061611294746399, -0.011315026320517063, -0.3551216125488281, -0.2551797330379486, -0.49674293398857117, -0.598749577999115, 0.3073843717575073, 0.34077727794647217, -0.2582918703556061, -0.07792103290557861, -0.11554829776287079, 0.6624600887298584, 0.6260329484939575, 0.29000476002693176, 0.47157275676727295, 0.0002578353160060942, -0.20838242769241333, -0.08491232991218567, -0.8260283470153809, -0.6356385946273804, 1.095875859260559, 0.09223590046167374, 1.1386723518371582, -0.14045925438404083, 0.9291292428970337, -0.0034881788305938244, 0.4662901759147644, -0.7182551622390747, 0.4074857234954834, 0.3056558072566986, -0.4254780411720276, -0.06830208003520966, -0.5398851633071899, -0.8192252516746521, 0.1477627158164978, -0.2531335651874542, -0.49405524134635925, 0.44038018584251404, 0.6677553057670593, -0.43679556250572205, 0.37922239303588867, -0.5446609258651733, 0.7545205354690552, -0.6042529940605164, -0.6263911128044128, -0.10518984496593475, -0.6450361609458923, 0.45310959219932556, -0.1098187118768692, -0.04242924973368645, 0.06738496571779251, 0.15206673741340637, 0.6344025135040283, -0.19674596190452576, 1.1138542890548706, 0.09730792790651321, -0.07259906083345413, 0.47950389981269836, 0.22299733757972717, 0.8078594207763672, 0.15711647272109985, -0.07521933317184448, -0.10264361649751663, -0.12570837140083313, -0.26554548740386963, -0.9067306518554688, 0.6586499214172363, -0.7434832453727722, -0.7621332406997681, -0.4443359375, -0.4756655991077423, -0.3814465403556824, 0.14984190464019775, 0.4562273919582367, 0.35128331184387207, 0.062293365597724915, 0.07965313643217087, 0.9577208161354065, 0.056499823927879333, 0.2784261405467987, 0.7521882653236389, 0.0797988548874855, -0.47041723132133484, 0.6072605848312378, 0.2587839365005493, 0.42851972579956055, -0.01947092078626156, 0.18788650631904602, -0.3334388732910156, -0.5307688117027283, -0.18066659569740295, 0.5848569273948669, -0.8082026839256287, -0.45900383591651917, -0.5093920230865479, -0.08393269777297974, -0.17905215919017792, -0.19195176661014557, -0.430501788854599, -0.2522936165332794, -0.5113565921783447, -0.37437134981155396, 0.25168681144714355, 0.5779701471328735, -0.4820948839187622, 0.10217150300741196, -0.7075231075286865, -0.004871884826570749, 0.6035423874855042, 0.10239209979772568, 0.10915450751781464, -0.34232211112976074, -0.1546882838010788, 0.39462751150131226, -0.6659207344055176, -0.9457250237464905, 0.1766679733991623, -0.21808965504169464, 0.6589322686195374, 0.10020625591278076, 0.07490617036819458, 0.8162828683853149, -0.5855187177658081, 0.5870879292488098, 0.05528636649250984, -0.5390504598617554, 0.6928338408470154, -0.11949730664491653, 0.20019285380840302, 0.6273245811462402, 0.09706728160381317, -0.5792437791824341, -0.2051781713962555, -1.0111817121505737, -0.4304006099700928, 0.5427206754684448, -0.011279962956905365, -0.2107560932636261, -0.2013171762228012, 0.9176241159439087, 0.012621465139091015, -0.005410618614405394, -0.5484871864318848, -0.2736574113368988, -0.007327166851609945, 0.18226680159568787, -0.2675275504589081, -0.4017549455165863, -0.22418172657489777, -0.11346765607595444, 0.8059533834457397, -0.3239763379096985, 0.1448894888162613, 0.5432225465774536, -0.29681396484375, -0.26004403829574585, 0.19725249707698822, 0.6335943341255188, 0.8386089205741882, 0.03863603249192238, 0.37048351764678955, 0.5238065123558044, -0.019151799380779266, 0.14191971719264984, -0.24092920124530792, -0.1352260410785675, -0.14754177629947662, 0.3285076320171356, 0.5657650828361511, 0.279191792011261, -0.48044371604919434, 0.17357274889945984, -0.11569005995988846, -0.07459419965744019, -0.3062728941440582, 0.23183979094028473, 0.10551340878009796, 0.47648686170578003, 0.11878658086061478, 0.3598574697971344, -0.08075398206710815, -0.6245316863059998, 0.3482915163040161, 0.32210496068000793, -0.2930891513824463, -0.19327770173549652, 0.42787885665893555, 0.05536426603794098, -0.39206504821777344, 0.47294121980667114, -0.040271226316690445, -0.4130991995334625, 0.5912310481071472, 0.702778160572052, 0.7864164113998413, -0.15257355570793152, 0.3270111680030823, 0.2772093117237091, 0.23998099565505981, -0.5376948118209839, 0.23310650885105133, -0.18417848646640778, -1.022909164428711, -0.33284077048301697, -0.2380455732345581, -0.6891782283782959, -0.1179167702794075, -0.7290186882019043, 0.20877641439437866, -0.5735194087028503, -0.22412174940109253, -0.25133830308914185, -0.046616364270448685, -0.6642478704452515, 0.10687237232923508, -0.06125498190522194, 0.9102808833122253, -0.6022120118141174, 0.38100704550743103, 0.7052854299545288, -0.4292389750480652, -0.9133429527282715, 0.014149082824587822, 0.19014392793178558, -0.8311067223548889, 0.6015142202377319, -0.1038736030459404, -0.4487859904766083, -0.0708557590842247, -0.7489736676216125, -0.7537205219268799, 1.0493849515914917, 0.3237733840942383, -0.7169365882873535, 0.01904553547501564, -0.23743121325969696, 0.36822566390037537, -0.22912712395191193, 0.11650165915489197, 0.7303690910339355, 0.3415026068687439, 0.34008318185806274, -0.6801254749298096, -0.026270147413015366, 0.16341890394687653, -0.12784773111343384, 0.12487279623746872, -0.7971978187561035, 1.0457794666290283, -0.6839358806610107, -0.21391212940216064, 0.06587298959493637, 0.48472481966018677, 0.5287548303604126, 0.3761606216430664, 0.46157175302505493, 0.5049302577972412, 1.3280227184295654, -0.060330506414175034, 0.9833894371986389, 0.06778687238693237, 0.455392450094223, 1.5292662382125854, -0.16250023245811462, 0.8700495362281799, 0.5964450240135193, -0.00767758721485734, 0.4702596366405487, 0.7423774003982544, 0.1497315615415573, 0.4982347786426544, 0.1521877646446228, 0.010907789692282677, -0.526606559753418, 0.2966633141040802, -0.3625496029853821, 0.020953567698597908, 0.5036598443984985, -0.2636776864528656, -0.3087909519672394, -0.2338394671678543, 0.007619304116815329, -0.0474490262567997, -0.36704838275909424, 0.7384700179100037, 0.43159449100494385, -0.7970791459083557, 0.7073377966880798, -0.44555577635765076, 0.46412310004234314, -0.33462801575660706, -0.10860595852136612, -0.4010411500930786, 0.4521327018737793, -0.22645364701747894, -0.7106133699417114, 0.16375645995140076, -0.1710631102323532, -0.21174094080924988, -0.26374468207359314, 0.8966107964515686, -0.18141096830368042, -0.5207141637802124, -0.12799376249313354, 0.8266521096229553, 0.06448912620544434, -0.050271932035684586, -0.7436613440513611, -0.09671154618263245, -0.008214226923882961, 0.10393807291984558, 0.00009765829599928111, 0.4081422984600067, 0.05730118975043297, 0.7895567417144775, 0.5543489456176758, 0.19153837859630585, 0.09035156667232513, -0.09255621582269669, 0.57256680727005, -0.9081844091415405, -0.1712254136800766, -0.883480966091156, 0.49159711599349976, -0.13600587844848633, -0.4133591949939728, 0.7286085486412048, 0.20804235339164734, 1.0532976388931274, -0.09233757853507996, 0.7683905363082886, 0.37419643998146057, 0.6103308796882629, -0.9023701548576355, 0.31883662939071655, -0.6518533229827881, 0.485578328371048, -0.11930438876152039, -0.6297095417976379, -0.2310355007648468, 0.844310462474823, -0.48908594250679016, -0.0063284640200436115, 0.8494694828987122, 0.9668917655944824, 0.2506677806377411, 0.2514280378818512, 0.29659420251846313, 0.3810734748840332, 0.33304059505462646, 0.7571187019348145, 1.3712252378463745, -0.30973413586616516, 0.3161642551422119, -0.12848202884197235, -0.17606481909751892, -0.3905988931655884, -0.8383844494819641, -0.8963223099708557, -0.2106524258852005, -0.395963191986084, -0.5097931623458862, 0.4679587483406067, 0.9509222507476807, 0.2020997554063797, -0.5332013368606567, -0.06864643096923828, -0.4322473704814911, 0.6901458501815796, -0.4007324278354645, -0.09760210663080215, 0.059695616364479065, -0.6537144780158997, -0.34929659962654114, 0.3084684908390045, 0.12919162213802338, 0.35673657059669495, -0.07846919447183609, -0.14957141876220703, -0.007760055363178253, 0.0792665034532547, 0.38604217767715454, 0.4765698313713074, -0.5849472880363464, -0.398152232170105, 0.07931055128574371, -0.02849864400923252, 0.13233792781829834, 1.1851743459701538, -0.8082044124603271, 0.35175713896751404, 0.29831334948539734, 0.5852373242378235, 0.3173096776008606, -0.10741522908210754, 0.6656538248062134, -0.4148775637149811, -0.3590396046638489, 0.1740604043006897, 0.5403591990470886, 0.44712337851524353, -0.40261512994766235, 0.6417357325553894, 0.4173353612422943, -0.7432441711425781, -0.7705660462379456, 0.391156405210495, -0.7189460396766663, -0.07333256304264069, 1.159935474395752, -0.09808394312858582, -0.3033149540424347, 0.02212260477244854, -0.6391855478286743, 0.2537587285041809, -0.06131284683942795, 0.9432047605514526, 0.892322301864624, -0.42760273814201355, -0.3036171495914459, -0.6128862500190735, 0.6880462765693665, 0.6361777782440186, -0.7539207935333252, 0.165396586060524, 0.6216603517532349, 0.5567686557769775, 0.10582484304904938, 0.5114048719406128, -0.1494123488664627, 0.8724863529205322, 0.029850028455257416, -0.4131825566291809, -0.0008101322455331683, -0.4805144965648651, -0.3567642271518707, -0.4024253487586975, 0.28408873081207275, -0.12005635350942612 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20041v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20041v2
Transformer-Lite: High-efficiency Deployment of Large Language Models on Mobile Phone GPUs
2024-03-29T08:26:53
2024-05-21T01:21:19
Luchang Li, Sheng Qian, Jie Lu, Lunxi Yuan, Rui Wang, Qin Xie
cs.CL
cs.CL
The Large Language Model (LLM) is widely employed for tasks such as intelligent assistants, text summarization, translation, and multi-modality on mobile phones. However, the current methods for on-device LLM deployment maintain slow inference speed, which causes poor user experience. To facilitate high-efficiency LLM deployment on device GPUs, we propose four optimization techniques: (a) a symbolic expression-based approach to support dynamic shape model inference; (b) operator optimizations and execution priority setting to enhance inference speed and reduce phone lagging; (c) an FP4 quantization method termed M0E4 to reduce dequantization overhead; (d) a sub-tensor-based technique to eliminate the need for copying KV cache after LLM inference. Furthermore, we implement these methods in our mobile inference engine, Transformer-Lite, which is compatible with both Qualcomm and MTK processors. We evaluated Transformer-Lite's performance using LLMs with varied architectures and parameters ranging from 2B to 14B. Specifically, we achieved prefill and decoding speeds of 121 token/s and 14 token/s for ChatGLM2 6B, and 330 token/s and 30 token/s for smaller Gemma 2B, respectively. Compared with CPU-based FastLLM and GPU-based MLC-LLM, our engine attains over 10x speedup for the prefill speed and 2~3x speedup for the decoding speed.
[ -0.3147994577884674, -0.8620532155036926, 0.6654403805732727, 0.49802517890930176, -0.3902309536933899, 0.1637466996908188, -0.3347310423851013, -0.26538345217704773, 0.04988110810518265, 0.288638174533844, -0.2309139519929886, -0.318001389503479, -0.38346144556999207, -0.10987843573093414, -0.3123859465122223, 0.2915542423725128, 0.043954867869615555, -0.17975306510925293, -0.04342292994260788, 0.01140932459384203, -0.33858874440193176, -0.28301334381103516, -0.6509928703308105, -0.37457865476608276, 0.3545820116996765, 0.3111203610897064, 1.0338141918182373, 0.7430620193481445, 0.4528128206729889, 0.28407755494117737, -0.20930682122707367, 0.16362625360488892, -0.566462516784668, 0.012900169938802719, 0.252421110868454, -0.7122228741645813, -0.423490971326828, -0.11283029615879059, 0.6473111510276794, 0.33035165071487427, -0.31611329317092896, 0.194564551115036, -0.2334194928407669, 0.46565768122673035, -0.9075977802276611, -0.10964856296777725, -0.6203840970993042, 0.16945479810237885, -0.1057203933596611, 0.04569665715098381, -0.6351752877235413, -0.6980617046356201, -0.1495739370584488, -0.6075403690338135, 0.05114752799272537, 0.18333148956298828, 0.7048888802528381, 0.5864741802215576, -0.6094418168067932, 0.03268519788980484, -1.0094923973083496, 0.9424715042114258, -0.7502866983413696, 0.7121744155883789, -0.04423586651682854, 0.36901673674583435, -0.13390278816223145, -1.045332670211792, -0.7258732318878174, -0.030007533729076385, 0.10782875865697861, 0.10484611243009567, -0.1555694043636322, 0.2116139829158783, 0.41697803139686584, 0.43506863713264465, -0.41743889451026917, 0.04673647880554199, -0.01330340001732111, -0.13590462505817413, 0.699068009853363, 0.062295444309711456, 0.2527623474597931, 0.06167112663388252, -0.3135982155799866, 0.08787223696708679, -1.1043370962142944, -0.022165361791849136, 0.19530783593654633, -0.0628768652677536, -0.1935059279203415, 0.418118417263031, 0.1524941325187683, 0.36047878861427307, -0.13284343481063843, -0.48986250162124634, 0.4300168454647064, -0.22355419397354126, -0.3684547543525696, 0.09561970084905624, 0.8218731880187988, 0.27603694796562195, 0.0026485228445380926, -0.27832990884780884, -0.361413836479187, 0.15463997423648834, 0.2658177316188812, -1.1865507364273071, 0.06988593935966492, 0.1276697963476181, -0.6094722151756287, -0.06100684404373169, -0.3579457104206085, -0.812203586101532, -0.2993864417076111, -0.03140660747885704, 0.45326462388038635, -0.17669379711151123, -0.19639702141284943, 0.32398277521133423, 0.14178937673568726, 0.34230515360832214, 0.2537199556827545, -1.1430954933166504, 0.1496620923280716, 0.541203498840332, 0.878710150718689, -0.32187163829803467, 0.10302320867776871, -0.6227001547813416, 0.10499834269285202, -0.1242716908454895, 0.521856963634491, -0.46837154030799866, -0.756489098072052, -0.097158282995224, -0.03376479819417, -0.5209213495254517, -0.5496394634246826, 1.2661086320877075, -0.5110895037651062, -0.0639716163277626, 0.040954623371362686, -0.45537567138671875, -0.3004080057144165, -0.3193107545375824, -0.5553141832351685, 1.406433343887329, 0.048484813421964645, -0.5517892241477966, 0.14391323924064636, -0.5989515781402588, -0.6646769642829895, 0.1516231894493103, -0.12180294096469879, -0.5837465524673462, 0.486216276884079, 0.1420217752456665, 0.5684228539466858, -0.5459479093551636, 0.12544257938861847, 0.012190480716526508, -0.8312767148017883, -0.3126864433288574, -0.35400816798210144, 0.5541827082633972, 0.5753320455551147, -0.6505174040794373, 0.3084365427494049, -0.48154473304748535, 0.05578359216451645, 0.24097909033298492, -0.2693587839603424, -0.028574272990226746, 0.28923335671424866, 0.157595694065094, 0.03393963724374771, 0.12960714101791382, -0.617332398891449, 0.29522058367729187, -0.24247102439403534, 0.6141432523727417, 0.2855072617530823, -0.5076624751091003, 0.6294171214103699, 0.16634607315063477, 0.6530569791793823, -0.2787269651889801, 0.4957115352153778, -0.3353792428970337, -0.576764702796936, -0.6243023872375488, -0.422149121761322, 0.21373751759529114, 0.8189054727554321, -0.8616445660591125, 0.2257106602191925, -0.4853653609752655, -0.5370977520942688, -0.4318851828575134, 0.02687148191034794, 0.29706478118896484, 0.4083835780620575, 0.23114223778247833, 0.3421635925769806, -0.17675934731960297, -0.8655136227607727, -0.2614678144454956, 0.06063510850071907, -0.12877847254276276, 0.5098387002944946, 0.16150188446044922, -0.5446187853813171, 0.7202092409133911, -0.6197366714477539, 0.33762285113334656, -0.3713861107826233, -0.17496703565120697, 0.24219094216823578, 0.21535351872444153, 0.5462135076522827, -0.9147598147392273, -0.41574132442474365, 0.013011670671403408, -0.5980382561683655, -0.15490609407424927, -0.007002803962677717, 0.0015312996692955494, 0.1024550348520279, 0.5107378959655762, -0.857406735420227, 0.3025803565979004, 0.8940430879592896, -0.2647053301334381, 0.39786142110824585, -0.33073243498802185, -0.011954578571021557, -1.1049410104751587, -0.10061199963092804, 0.10368621349334717, -0.22983478009700775, -0.6388969421386719, -0.07104527205228806, 0.3431079685688019, -0.1714906394481659, -0.489463746547699, 0.571704089641571, -0.39082199335098267, 0.005097413435578346, -0.22201350331306458, 0.08768786489963531, 0.009716601110994816, 0.17970728874206543, -0.13959437608718872, 1.3140980005264282, 0.3635066747665405, -0.5337370038032532, 0.18325194716453552, 0.015147121623158455, -0.3198221027851105, 0.04486113041639328, -0.724666953086853, 0.08457162976264954, 0.04189617931842804, 0.11150544136762619, -0.8347008228302002, 0.10204591602087021, -0.21455344557762146, 0.1988963484764099, 0.062047671526670456, -0.0824425145983696, -0.5854405164718628, -0.4240674376487732, -0.2827744483947754, 0.6124708652496338, 0.8067448139190674, -0.8345640897750854, 1.2340582609176636, 0.4914705157279968, 0.0621061772108078, -0.5495454668998718, -0.4623546600341797, 0.08431760221719742, -0.5149046182632446, -1.0713049173355103, 0.8193302750587463, 0.08557500690221786, -0.077217236161232, -0.46500372886657715, -0.11437353491783142, 0.27846452593803406, 0.16457827389240265, 0.4185012876987457, 0.14352688193321228, -0.4008393883705139, -0.05218813195824623, 0.21728381514549255, -0.08250053226947784, -0.04421938210725784, 0.10860943049192429, 0.63885098695755, -0.16547921299934387, -0.19101420044898987, -0.37883299589157104, -0.05402813479304314, 0.5995543599128723, -0.18977969884872437, 0.5785396099090576, 0.9100528359413147, -0.14761969447135925, -0.205905944108963, -0.8360891938209534, -0.15356892347335815, -0.5154187083244324, 0.20024575293064117, -0.6709558963775635, -0.7208133339881897, 0.572914719581604, -0.6154390573501587, 0.1525939702987671, 0.32553786039352417, 0.5839917659759521, 0.20680318772792816, 1.030519723892212, 0.6341639757156372, -0.16256892681121826, 0.6289263963699341, -0.2511999011039734, 0.5729674100875854, -0.8536129593849182, -0.216793954372406, -0.5152292847633362, -0.18041647970676422, -0.6767850518226624, -0.7058343291282654, 0.4186095595359802, 0.33726271986961365, -0.08476308733224869, 0.26760923862457275, -0.40383875370025635, 0.2591594159603119, 0.4050779938697815, 0.07379525154829025, 0.4429645240306854, 0.15180189907550812, -0.2070614993572235, 0.1289348304271698, -0.8743272423744202, -0.6272282600402832, 0.9038370847702026, 0.555180549621582, 1.1420620679855347, -0.011573010124266148, 0.2598295509815216, -0.07719742506742477, 0.2983582615852356, -0.812845766544342, 0.6559699773788452, -0.21518145501613617, -0.1303422600030899, -0.09435921907424927, -0.4834456741809845, -0.8098456859588623, 0.5509160757064819, -0.1629444807767868, -0.557013213634491, 0.045366864651441574, 0.09695177525281906, -0.31793126463890076, 0.2678360641002655, -1.1018182039260864, 0.8540964722633362, -0.2172131985425949, -0.527376651763916, -0.34556666016578674, -0.26364728808403015, 0.4467611610889435, -0.10615306347608566, 0.1309402883052826, -0.20697757601737976, -0.17251014709472656, 0.351413369178772, -0.2651924192905426, 0.25228753685951233, -0.32987841963768005, -0.3350135087966919, 0.2530612051486969, -0.23721690475940704, 0.766327977180481, 0.09816938638687134, -0.3603803515434265, 0.11092543601989746, -0.23512092232704163, -0.2249079793691635, -0.7142871618270874, 0.686711311340332, -0.6451936364173889, -0.43185314536094666, 0.08062729239463806, -0.5434790253639221, -0.1315469592809677, 0.05937429144978523, 0.3917495906352997, 0.28326553106307983, -0.037596628069877625, 0.2735497057437897, 0.861320436000824, -0.5475245714187622, 0.8798171877861023, 0.04726705327630043, -0.4858875274658203, -0.11084670573472977, 0.7824535369873047, -0.13865593075752258, 0.20908492803573608, 0.21765750646591187, 0.2699533700942993, -0.664271891117096, -0.873755931854248, -0.8150864243507385, 0.2921704351902008, -0.22801212966442108, -0.11239852756261826, -0.7112367749214172, -0.13824933767318726, -0.0033271636348217726, -0.1515928953886032, -0.6413461565971375, -0.2657412588596344, -0.0807022750377655, 0.2978493571281433, 0.3660948574542999, 0.3576870858669281, 0.5529904961585999, 1.0572059154510498, -0.5691289305686951, 0.5384774804115295, 0.036199428141117096, 0.31626319885253906, -0.20595429837703705, -0.5805140733718872, -0.3657602071762085, 0.09989837557077408, -0.41565918922424316, -0.3242495656013489, 0.20518995821475983, 0.1580321192741394, 0.49518078565597534, 0.3058644235134125, -0.1731639951467514, 0.6027905344963074, -0.4809594452381134, 0.7087448239326477, 0.14496904611587524, -0.9683003425598145, 0.24134795367717743, -0.3205288052558899, 0.4218214154243469, 0.24038036167621613, 0.27529042959213257, -0.3991764485836029, 0.0030473305378109217, -0.3469617962837219, -0.7574014067649841, 0.3089240491390228, 0.2559010982513428, 0.36401787400245667, 0.20162783563137054, 0.5918554663658142, -0.3066607415676117, 0.09490035474300385, -0.39597004652023315, -0.4022485315799713, -0.1084531918168068, -0.31074705719947815, 0.03915956988930702, -0.4778349995613098, 0.2135964184999466, -0.3475884795188904, 0.629269003868103, -0.24465256929397583, 0.3785126209259033, 0.004207662306725979, -0.37852469086647034, 0.2317124307155609, 0.0640408992767334, 0.958808958530426, 0.6192963123321533, -0.030259599909186363, 0.10197959095239639, 0.35784095525741577, -0.9235145449638367, 0.15802235901355743, 0.17794029414653778, -0.27194511890411377, 0.22319351136684418, -0.1047959253191948, 1.0647470951080322, 0.2726198136806488, -0.6397916078567505, 0.5092877745628357, -0.33565622568130493, -0.004230197984725237, -0.21442456543445587, 0.1997525840997696, 0.40128380060195923, 0.3608105182647705, 0.5201724767684937, -0.3274206221103668, -0.02207198180258274, -0.21635067462921143, -0.09845538437366486, 0.5552845001220703, 0.1606578528881073, -0.2512722313404083, 0.9285498261451721, 0.3242345452308655, -0.2417406290769577, 0.648395299911499, -0.055006250739097595, -0.34821927547454834, 0.40958231687545776, 0.5958694815635681, 0.8324384093284607, -0.6156398057937622, -0.07240623980760574, 0.2618216872215271, 0.22561800479888916, -0.33841222524642944, 0.4643312990665436, 0.1962462067604065, -0.8238081336021423, -0.9212392568588257, -0.8082825541496277, -0.17766331136226654, -0.0003085764474235475, -0.08695871382951736, 0.27645644545555115, -0.188143789768219, -0.3755267560482025, -0.06296215206384659, -0.04739348590373993, -0.4512659013271332, 0.19813820719718933, 0.09172719717025757, 1.0245065689086914, -0.44343456625938416, 1.110549807548523, 0.30240628123283386, 0.19667872786521912, -1.0248913764953613, -0.348165899515152, -0.345647394657135, -0.6951753497123718, 0.6684190034866333, 0.07217381149530411, -0.4619138836860657, 0.22563228011131287, 0.0342896468937397, -0.6971800327301025, 1.2269395589828491, 0.655278205871582, -0.8200432062149048, -0.23389507830142975, 0.32325461506843567, 0.20913580060005188, -0.4123326241970062, 0.8227007389068604, 0.6243678331375122, 0.5745116472244263, 0.08759624511003494, -1.0530874729156494, 0.2132444530725479, -0.05019931495189667, 0.3574434518814087, 0.41913390159606934, -0.8083571195602417, 0.5235694646835327, -0.2789863646030426, -0.1907106637954712, -0.15892955660820007, 0.47458410263061523, 0.01345492247492075, 0.10566316545009613, 0.5431705117225647, 0.6103276014328003, 0.6977613568305969, -0.27887359261512756, 1.0844736099243164, -0.5988793969154358, 0.3306570053100586, 0.5072641372680664, -0.21737320721149445, 0.8934422731399536, 0.42017853260040283, -0.1220681443810463, 0.35501813888549805, 0.48913177847862244, 0.04017212986946106, 0.27713263034820557, 0.25247690081596375, -0.7754877805709839, -0.006673946976661682, 0.0023277648724615574, -0.24685119092464447, 0.46257859468460083, 0.3615463972091675, -0.5778490900993347, -0.1916123777627945, 0.14212566614151, 0.10098171979188919, -0.30434608459472656, -0.3165633976459503, 0.433159202337265, 0.24264174699783325, -0.3997552692890167, 0.9010612964630127, 0.2780323624610901, 0.9044696688652039, -0.2930057644844055, 0.2835536599159241, -0.3663932979106903, 0.29218053817749023, -0.48410290479660034, -0.27844083309173584, 0.2891141176223755, -0.2750336229801178, -0.11532443016767502, -0.32464200258255005, 0.6961935758590698, -0.16507567465305328, -0.39749687910079956, 0.1429690569639206, 0.3657274544239044, 0.15841850638389587, -0.45832523703575134, -0.5267571210861206, 0.6249957084655762, 0.025224052369594574, -0.4946286380290985, 0.18162000179290771, 0.1960439831018448, -0.10970723628997803, 0.9091393947601318, 0.6067298650741577, -0.13501609861850739, 0.46117717027664185, 0.30482736229896545, 0.7808417677879333, -0.6412721872329712, -0.18197430670261383, -1.0797619819641113, 0.4001784324645996, -0.04014796391129494, -0.07786669582128525, 0.8241695761680603, 1.179520845413208, 0.26166480779647827, -0.06096219643950462, 0.4428237974643707, 0.12468299269676208, 0.00640722643584013, -0.6175233125686646, 0.513489305973053, -0.4384172260761261, 0.341328889131546, -0.09755616635084152, -1.398422360420227, -0.18461771309375763, 0.6018646359443665, -0.4053398072719574, -0.07019961625337601, 0.7118198871612549, 0.9152650237083435, -0.3105922043323517, 0.23306205868721008, 0.35314592719078064, -0.12547917664051056, 0.41935044527053833, 0.49096277356147766, 0.530038058757782, -0.7143195867538452, 0.6238263249397278, -0.18606920540332794, -0.05249995365738869, -0.2864609956741333, -0.9895938634872437, -0.6985938549041748, -0.27382364869117737, -0.23228412866592407, -0.21625368297100067, -0.06505284458398819, 0.6735467910766602, 0.966219425201416, -0.12416501343250275, -0.3684660494327545, -0.15842702984809875, 0.09448312222957611, 0.1436348706483841, -0.21304214000701904, 0.42676255106925964, -0.3657439947128296, -0.956936240196228, 0.5658032894134521, 0.42416974902153015, -0.09454969316720963, -0.12959401309490204, -0.06898144632577896, 0.13537786900997162, -0.033846620470285416, 1.1676546335220337, 0.03915436565876007, -0.6478262543678284, -0.048109784722328186, 0.08864621073007584, -0.07598909735679626, 0.3583906888961792, 1.1003831624984741, -0.7212551236152649, 0.012305055744946003, 0.42312484979629517, 0.9209347367286682, 1.0183639526367188, 0.1266593039035797, 0.5998666882514954, -0.28929033875465393, 0.47019463777542114, 0.21146522462368011, 0.36450427770614624, 0.06726701557636261, -0.3631773591041565, 0.4739895761013031, 0.12614791095256805, -0.6591569185256958, -0.815609335899353, 0.2022739052772522, -0.9556200504302979, -0.016379868611693382, 1.1899999380111694, -0.035390455275774, -0.37782785296440125, 0.10356354713439941, -0.23336933553218842, 0.13590766489505768, -0.4159766137599945, 0.5166215896606445, 0.19425594806671143, -0.214588463306427, -0.5187543034553528, -1.0195478200912476, 0.5945160388946533, 0.5659809112548828, -1.0659209489822388, -0.036428485065698624, 0.16920191049575806, 0.20895197987556458, -0.017930438742041588, 0.35604897141456604, -0.01875711977481842, -0.034969691187143326, -0.013134259730577469, 0.26327645778656006, 0.08922109007835388, 0.001154556986875832, -0.1474972665309906, 0.11856300383806229, -0.09007233381271362, -0.0620448961853981 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20026v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20026v1
FSMR: A Feature Swapping Multi-modal Reasoning Approach with Joint Textual and Visual Clues
2024-03-29T07:28:50
2024-03-29T07:28:50
Shuang Li, Jiahua Wang, Lijie Wen
cs.CV
cs.CV, cs.CL
Multi-modal reasoning plays a vital role in bridging the gap between textual and visual information, enabling a deeper understanding of the context. This paper presents the Feature Swapping Multi-modal Reasoning (FSMR) model, designed to enhance multi-modal reasoning through feature swapping. FSMR leverages a pre-trained visual-language model as an encoder, accommodating both text and image inputs for effective feature representation from both modalities. It introduces a unique feature swapping module, enabling the exchange of features between identified objects in images and corresponding vocabulary words in text, thereby enhancing the model's comprehension of the interplay between images and text. To further bolster its multi-modal alignment capabilities, FSMR incorporates a multi-modal cross-attention mechanism, facilitating the joint modeling of textual and visual information. During training, we employ image-text matching and cross-entropy losses to ensure semantic consistency between visual and language elements. Extensive experiments on the PMR dataset demonstrate FSMR's superiority over state-of-the-art baseline models across various performance metrics.
[ -0.3467782139778137, -0.5995896458625793, 0.5962628722190857, -0.13442553579807281, -0.531814455986023, -0.08966309577226639, -0.04008707404136658, -0.5589762926101685, -0.1797807812690735, 0.3090570271015167, -0.5781359076499939, 0.1158861294388771, -0.6508159637451172, 0.06871524453163147, -0.38214510679244995, 0.5906046628952026, -0.35012680292129517, 0.24336056411266327, -0.3563864231109619, -0.23620350658893585, -0.41766560077667236, -0.5336398482322693, -0.18417976796627045, -0.2776190936565399, 0.6852846741676331, 0.06407499313354492, 0.9989001750946045, 0.5658318996429443, 0.7693684697151184, 0.4165268838405609, -0.08875399082899094, 0.2845560610294342, -0.19435109198093414, 0.0581304132938385, -0.35193654894828796, -0.3673228919506073, -0.14529377222061157, -0.23624791204929352, 0.44712507724761963, 0.10181651264429092, 0.16002793610095978, 0.01782948337495327, 0.014003446325659752, 0.21113711595535278, -0.6740059852600098, 0.3184952139854431, -0.7930789589881897, -0.08338738977909088, -0.3406887352466583, -0.43870672583580017, -0.26618319749832153, 0.14304746687412262, 0.13449764251708984, -0.5933548212051392, 0.39672550559043884, 0.013897856697440147, 0.922784686088562, 0.4434601962566376, -0.37626662850379944, 0.008245629258453846, -0.6262156367301941, 0.6561073064804077, -0.34985584020614624, 0.9438022971153259, 0.16639859974384308, 0.40196681022644043, 0.29211294651031494, -0.3638558089733124, -0.9666721820831299, 0.09848558157682419, -0.3042476773262024, -0.16051660478115082, 0.05001743510365486, -0.27511653304100037, 0.01329169049859047, 0.4991799294948578, -0.43261638283729553, -0.5257124304771423, -0.14093001186847687, -0.3616209030151367, 0.32563069462776184, 0.29519888758659363, 0.27412259578704834, -0.015815939754247665, -0.7735241055488586, -0.24941599369049072, -0.0391218364238739, 0.2719135582447052, -0.058756839483976364, 0.41453078389167786, 0.012494002468883991, 0.7521622180938721, -0.06822532415390015, 0.8413252830505371, 0.1319093555212021, -0.40987837314605713, 0.4464190900325775, -0.8192428946495056, -0.32840102910995483, -0.23605945706367493, 0.5143681764602661, 0.5797891616821289, -0.30988478660583496, -0.028687182813882828, -0.5738391876220703, 0.4296128749847412, 0.14754073321819305, -0.6711447238922119, 0.11349708586931229, -0.30605459213256836, -0.904845118522644, -0.0805499404668808, 0.09393108636140823, -0.6725683212280273, -0.19050632417201996, -0.4245176315307617, 0.9144830107688904, -0.6716864109039307, -0.322152704000473, 0.27336597442626953, -0.4502074718475342, 0.27416956424713135, 0.6852882504463196, -0.7875391244888306, -0.07715880125761032, 0.5589832663536072, 0.6596165299415588, -0.024660632014274597, -0.5764721035957336, -0.23004034161567688, 0.38465064764022827, 0.1501852571964264, 0.8054504990577698, -1.1127039194107056, -0.04679928347468376, -0.2681743800640106, 0.18555954098701477, -0.3974280059337616, -0.1402510404586792, 0.08675990998744965, -0.4497346580028534, 0.3732592761516571, -0.38785699009895325, -0.04149290919303894, -0.3733355700969696, 0.47856494784355164, -0.7344754934310913, 0.9862325191497803, -0.01989622972905636, -0.9592791795730591, 0.5133911967277527, -0.4300537109375, -0.24117432534694672, -0.2869713306427002, -0.354554146528244, -0.2865430414676666, 0.06832572817802429, 0.28523948788642883, 0.3249799609184265, -0.4759013056755066, 0.2801734507083893, -0.25621411204338074, -0.439495712518692, 0.6445630192756653, -0.6976134777069092, 0.06329619884490967, 0.21477900445461273, -0.1477208137512207, 0.1653836965560913, -0.4266088306903839, -0.22631041705608368, 0.21483196318149567, -0.33374959230422974, -0.49757325649261475, 0.04631063714623451, 0.5054721236228943, 0.6366134285926819, 0.379192054271698, -0.29103603959083557, -0.06607312709093094, -0.0335613489151001, 0.3155129551887512, 0.3093729615211487, -0.19362081587314606, 0.6160597801208496, -0.5327429175376892, 0.398078590631485, 0.5166724920272827, 0.42328333854675293, -0.7590253949165344, -0.5752290487289429, -0.7433642745018005, -0.4047379195690155, 0.10295657068490982, 0.7526320219039917, -1.175465703010559, 0.1570211946964264, -0.026247354224324226, -0.15809082984924316, -0.7127229571342468, 0.006406690459698439, 0.564993143081665, 0.20766817033290863, 0.6464548110961914, -0.2865811884403229, -0.18343877792358398, -0.7844417691230774, -0.41404131054878235, 0.14673593640327454, 0.15639854967594147, 0.1347721815109253, 0.5189630389213562, -0.478928804397583, 0.8007206320762634, -0.17331624031066895, -0.411716490983963, -0.3531290590763092, 0.1906329095363617, -0.34048429131507874, 0.3538188636302948, 0.4417005479335785, -1.1371991634368896, 0.041585732251405716, 0.1588309109210968, -0.3728194534778595, 0.21687772870063782, -0.37970277667045593, 0.04645361751317978, 0.28069308400154114, 0.42930227518081665, -0.6735489368438721, 0.6531102657318115, 0.18691633641719818, -0.5066353678703308, 0.14743542671203613, -0.0121076088398695, 0.680260956287384, -1.096498966217041, 0.08600559830665588, 0.06799931079149246, -0.08548469096422195, -0.29096418619155884, 0.07199752330780029, 0.07388756424188614, -0.06588112562894821, -0.29452744126319885, 0.8053125143051147, -0.5850970149040222, 0.06518888473510742, -0.2128199189901352, -0.1604013890028, 0.23400670289993286, 0.2740430533885956, 0.07170606404542923, 0.7289161086082458, 0.41711512207984924, -0.18065553903579712, 0.24205292761325836, 0.3705846071243286, -0.30342909693717957, 0.6648781895637512, -0.14846931397914886, -0.16077931225299835, -0.3430417776107788, -0.02074539102613926, -1.0683680772781372, -0.0011091374326497316, 0.4125598967075348, -0.3278009295463562, 0.34769946336746216, -0.10393482446670532, -0.4576405882835388, -0.3371105194091797, -0.10175768285989761, 0.552396297454834, -0.12250082194805145, -0.2953062355518341, 0.9168592095375061, 0.10822504758834839, -0.2308942824602127, -0.808073103427887, -0.7963352203369141, 0.004573876038193703, 0.08775972574949265, -0.576324462890625, 0.6210383772850037, -0.05060567706823349, 0.006001289468258619, 0.22808174788951874, -0.3462834358215332, -0.32295751571655273, -0.3902665972709656, 0.134723499417305, 0.2993738651275635, -0.5355677604675293, 0.2013387680053711, 0.07069381326436996, -0.4881659150123596, -0.3426002562046051, 0.166193887591362, 0.4197554290294647, -0.2921273112297058, -0.6807043552398682, -0.5294496417045593, 0.4929178059101105, 0.7564421892166138, -0.5275891423225403, 0.4610823690891266, 0.7160525918006897, -0.3388163447380066, 0.31709104776382446, -0.7582293152809143, -0.24436159431934357, -0.4326367974281311, 0.364897757768631, -0.7945807576179504, -1.1253842115402222, 0.3410845398902893, 0.013114547356963158, -0.20756404101848602, 0.15143609046936035, 0.5353420376777649, 0.141470268368721, 1.0037946701049805, 0.7678501009941101, 0.19947636127471924, 0.6761730909347534, 0.11217614263296127, 0.3837733268737793, -0.4176713228225708, -0.6403614282608032, -0.31784895062446594, -0.34124889969825745, 0.1016097292304039, -1.3834919929504395, 0.13077372312545776, 0.07288403064012527, -0.14031782746315002, 0.0667944997549057, -0.49160948395729065, 0.7621610164642334, 0.33667662739753723, 0.3645719289779663, 0.28504836559295654, -0.08178770542144775, -0.41938504576683044, -0.2773718535900116, -0.4650532305240631, -0.4282413125038147, 0.4215855598449707, 0.3008231520652771, 1.0759693384170532, -0.009286053478717804, 0.23292376101016998, -0.1214020773768425, -0.043179888278245926, -0.8021356463432312, 0.738736629486084, -0.15480996668338776, -0.3669986426830292, -0.21659262478351593, -0.17062342166900635, -0.49434179067611694, 0.6481772661209106, -0.5087311267852783, -0.26076775789260864, 0.27739113569259644, 0.12959246337413788, -0.04590649530291557, 0.4492289423942566, -0.4599449336528778, 1.0752836465835571, -0.5620877146720886, -0.2070220410823822, -0.38208872079849243, -0.8152731657028198, 0.1834753304719925, 0.10634798556566238, 0.14439767599105835, -0.06337055563926697, -0.17849208414554596, -0.0209792647510767, -0.29561087489128113, 0.8770266175270081, -0.02258158288896084, 0.17390911281108856, -0.13954779505729675, 0.10979447513818741, -0.00047649123007431626, -0.15274982154369354, 0.0010197461815550923, 0.1518225371837616, 0.006412332411855459, -0.020409170538187027, -0.5955122709274292, 0.35928961634635925, -0.579709529876709, -0.41989508271217346, -0.5286969542503357, -0.7807972431182861, 0.17235925793647766, 0.1167478933930397, 0.05813010036945343, 0.4950478971004486, -0.27814602851867676, 0.0998472049832344, 0.6048726439476013, -0.06992583721876144, 0.539350688457489, 0.3537788689136505, -0.32397449016571045, -0.5807271599769592, 0.6985781788825989, -0.20427890121936798, 0.17858052253723145, 0.911877453327179, -0.03275720030069351, -0.41153469681739807, -0.04420624300837517, -0.6640253663063049, 0.13567236065864563, -0.7862379550933838, -0.41464394330978394, -0.7803060412406921, -0.19837826490402222, 0.0377938412129879, -0.4571417570114136, -0.2835046648979187, -0.2625955641269684, -0.19233763217926025, 0.34810423851013184, 0.540054440498352, 0.19854478538036346, 0.1479300558567047, 0.17124979197978973, -0.8742749691009521, 0.6396145224571228, 0.4865089952945709, 0.4316750764846802, -0.0531972236931324, -0.49825096130371094, -0.07644455879926682, -0.009165767580270767, -0.14946842193603516, -0.985697865486145, 0.19002299010753632, 0.05312950536608696, 0.8220928907394409, 0.5101826190948486, -0.3351791203022003, 0.8513100147247314, -0.4941684603691101, 0.6014381051063538, 0.5753368735313416, -1.2465741634368896, 0.5800487399101257, -0.22991156578063965, 0.47816991806030273, 0.43811795115470886, 0.15396545827388763, -0.5282867550849915, -0.4253559410572052, -0.18236742913722992, -0.6272245049476624, 0.6318119168281555, -0.024211492389440536, -0.018678367137908936, 0.060725387185811996, 0.038784753531217575, 0.40811800956726074, 0.2867414057254791, -0.7369867563247681, 0.13232138752937317, -0.70429927110672, -0.29644638299942017, 0.11392492055892944, -0.06832761317491531, -0.07606452703475952, -0.518564760684967, 0.2681185007095337, -0.41190001368522644, 0.5821748971939087, 0.05714539438486099, -0.5405800342559814, -0.17759859561920166, 0.5838391184806824, 0.7161857485771179, 0.6310181617736816, 0.10524832457304001, 0.44242018461227417, 0.06287525594234467, -0.25795111060142517, 0.13240523636341095, 0.4682266414165497, -0.0575154647231102, 0.11447122693061829, -0.036036763340234756, 1.0015004873275757, 0.6174952387809753, -0.45224350690841675, 0.7940659523010254, -0.0997605249285698, -0.0815538540482521, 0.2731310725212097, 0.07360697537660599, 0.09054995328187943, 0.7455966472625732, 0.4048727750778198, 0.6829646229743958, 0.07734736800193787, -0.4052218198776245, 0.33369120955467224, 0.5319178104400635, -0.3256131708621979, -0.18117660284042358, 0.8091264963150024, 0.03446009010076523, -0.17279067635536194, 0.24958491325378418, 0.1555071920156479, -0.5208835601806641, 0.3702794313430786, 0.6821250915527344, 0.5307652354240417, -0.4981662631034851, 0.3958461284637451, 0.042950112372636795, 0.5587964057922363, -0.21909140050411224, 0.7071570754051208, -0.11971072852611542, -0.9461789727210999, -0.2964632213115692, -0.5700399875640869, -0.3009698688983917, -0.14643336832523346, -0.5187048316001892, 0.402113139629364, -0.23036642372608185, -0.21149040758609772, 0.15026016533374786, -0.7251982688903809, -0.7884618639945984, 0.23534104228019714, 0.2509773373603821, 0.8034601211547852, -0.922250509262085, 0.8638788461685181, 0.8927628397941589, -0.7583308815956116, -0.34255024790763855, 0.19393928349018097, 0.2523311972618103, -0.8224046230316162, 0.5220211744308472, 0.5474218726158142, -0.4522300660610199, -0.4058775305747986, -0.17240184545516968, -0.8219859004020691, 1.2699675559997559, 0.33450159430503845, -0.417158842086792, -0.002889067167416215, 0.20263566076755524, 0.2459188848733902, -0.5478935837745667, 0.36123496294021606, 0.05750579014420509, 0.5100702047348022, 0.41630277037620544, -1.0889710187911987, 0.27143579721450806, -0.4774479866027832, 0.45181506872177124, 0.43930548429489136, -0.6055864691734314, 1.1188156604766846, -0.38718482851982117, -0.06617897748947144, 0.13081541657447815, 0.5053486227989197, 0.18874427676200867, 0.5878205299377441, 0.7595701217651367, 0.7140026092529297, 0.4659176766872406, -0.12883853912353516, 0.5387343168258667, -0.22484496235847473, 0.2073473185300827, 0.7310733199119568, -0.5196877717971802, 1.0787367820739746, 0.7936555743217468, 0.21357040107250214, 0.5874457359313965, 0.3516581058502197, -0.016573527827858925, 0.7072065472602844, -0.3830741047859192, -0.2866857349872589, -0.6928970217704773, 0.172582745552063, -0.6242839097976685, 0.631012499332428, 0.3070909380912781, -0.5633540153503418, -0.3965885639190674, 0.34348368644714355, -0.17305375635623932, -0.04683981463313103, -0.21223092079162598, 0.6516990661621094, -0.20565319061279297, -0.22705936431884766, 0.34165188670158386, 0.09162184596061707, 0.9280263781547546, -0.5930601358413696, -0.19368091225624084, 0.1171441450715065, 0.4742048978805542, 0.0881163477897644, -0.8287472128868103, 0.43020352721214294, -0.3035227060317993, -0.8127381801605225, -0.5655837655067444, 1.0998506546020508, -0.7052701115608215, -0.44289839267730713, 0.31079569458961487, 0.6389626860618591, -0.22732727229595184, -0.10959494858980179, -1.0653636455535889, 0.23389771580696106, -0.22803619503974915, 0.05092418193817139, 0.4638037383556366, 0.7729982733726501, -0.10052481293678284, 0.5695778727531433, 0.7171605825424194, -0.4626537561416626, -0.06293334066867828, 0.1229429543018341, 1.1686612367630005, -0.9451435208320618, -0.7045962810516357, -0.6403618454933167, 0.7276889681816101, 0.025253189727663994, -0.2356783151626587, 0.3094662129878998, 0.5940518379211426, 0.6387890577316284, -0.3083811104297638, 0.5889893174171448, 0.06784213334321976, 0.3733948767185211, -0.6676183342933655, 0.7692994475364685, -0.8109052777290344, -0.12221482396125793, -0.27373215556144714, -0.6805194616317749, -0.2751428484916687, 0.9498459696769714, -0.09378760308027267, 0.053086668252944946, 0.9097405672073364, 1.0807933807373047, -0.5241926312446594, 0.213974267244339, 0.2773621380329132, -0.0005083380965515971, -0.13819174468517303, 0.3748180568218231, 1.1196982860565186, -0.42248716950416565, 0.6487066149711609, 0.06864207983016968, -0.15752646327018738, -0.35340210795402527, -0.821136474609375, -0.7974733710289001, -0.9182828068733215, -0.10793039947748184, -0.11903747916221619, -0.059780415147542953, 0.66780024766922, 0.5311843156814575, -0.5230266451835632, 0.02980588749051094, 0.41162851452827454, 0.13651594519615173, -0.526949405670166, -0.2489965409040451, -0.16497541964054108, -0.2530311048030853, -0.2587662637233734, 0.4181346297264099, 0.638796329498291, 0.17220139503479004, -0.22938741743564606, -0.053424328565597534, -0.4846743941307068, 0.18475569784641266, 0.7363160848617554, -0.045202597975730896, -1.2524480819702148, -0.4097626209259033, 0.19478896260261536, -0.34443676471710205, 0.06564608216285706, 1.2301833629608154, -0.8202800750732422, 0.5101209282875061, 0.7516533136367798, 0.7548993825912476, 0.39952436089515686, -0.29756036400794983, 0.43398651480674744, -0.5073379874229431, 0.4572162926197052, -0.12040342390537262, 0.4578406512737274, 0.4154393672943115, -0.2951381504535675, 0.22778989374637604, 0.4088635742664337, -0.31563031673431396, -0.6469665765762329, 0.17730039358139038, -1.2698619365692139, -0.46221923828125, 0.7921506762504578, 0.22582292556762695, 0.036084938794374466, -0.2785206735134125, -0.4310932159423828, 0.21588054299354553, -0.30592384934425354, 0.677446186542511, 0.602535605430603, -0.008804814890027046, -1.0019445419311523, -0.3146626651287079, 0.22961154580116272, 0.3562168478965759, -0.7962759137153625, -0.06851594150066376, 0.7756069898605347, 0.3772521913051605, 0.2583800256252289, 0.7189002633094788, -0.20470720529556274, 0.38582804799079895, 0.036488909274339676, 0.11223303526639938, -0.10395826399326324, -0.5851218700408936, -0.2487763911485672, 0.07229208201169968, -0.3931930661201477, -0.2796568274497986 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20015v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20015v1
Adverb Is the Key: Simple Text Data Augmentation with Adverb Deletion
2024-03-29T07:01:39
2024-03-29T07:01:39
Juhwan Choi, YoungBin Kim
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI
In the field of text data augmentation, rule-based methods are widely adopted for real-world applications owing to their cost-efficiency. However, conventional rule-based approaches suffer from the possibility of losing the original semantics of the given text. We propose a novel text data augmentation strategy that avoids such phenomena through a straightforward deletion of adverbs, which play a subsidiary role in the sentence. Our comprehensive experiments demonstrate the efficiency and effectiveness of our proposed approach for not just single text classification, but also natural language inference that requires semantic preservation. We publicly released our source code for reproducibility.
[ -0.2919028401374817, -1.1978336572647095, 0.33509859442710876, -0.14154188334941864, -0.4732518494129181, -0.3608432710170746, -0.09918605536222458, -0.34392985701560974, 0.21450960636138916, 0.792312741279602, -0.885125458240509, -0.547568142414093, -0.269969642162323, -0.008970464579761028, -0.46930721402168274, 1.0519553422927856, 0.13992471992969513, -0.1560138463973999, -0.4556661546230316, -0.03873765468597412, -0.4960152506828308, -0.11054814606904984, -0.589882493019104, -0.08462755382061005, 0.0977008044719696, 0.6878170967102051, 0.949286699295044, 1.2850157022476196, 0.5607096552848816, 0.18596041202545166, -0.24926164746284485, 0.774311900138855, -0.2080584466457367, 0.1548992246389389, -0.25100812315940857, -0.43830907344818115, -0.5204148292541504, -0.026293883100152016, 0.5848497748374939, 0.712949812412262, -0.2003498077392578, -0.28762704133987427, -0.31302714347839355, 0.9039018750190735, -0.5433422923088074, 0.17429640889167786, -0.8044004440307617, -0.1778569370508194, 0.033949241042137146, -0.18894429504871368, -0.368070125579834, -0.6462185382843018, -0.0727151408791542, -0.529259204864502, 0.4543856084346771, -0.22100116312503815, 0.8887871503829956, 0.34833651781082153, -0.6822383999824524, -0.13808627426624298, -0.6560457348823547, 0.4882301688194275, -0.4066595435142517, 0.21165265142917633, 0.24241331219673157, -0.1827102154493332, -0.5241059064865112, -0.6133748888969421, -0.8827870488166809, 0.11846738308668137, -0.24302560091018677, 0.02742430381476879, 0.08671430498361588, 0.28402113914489746, 0.03977346047759056, 0.4971393942832947, -0.3011872172355652, -0.10192570090293884, -0.2055186778306961, -0.2379879504442215, 0.661815881729126, 0.1569884717464447, 0.5178842544555664, -0.38248521089553833, -0.5443986654281616, -0.07845237106084824, -0.71642005443573, -0.06842639297246933, 0.2697209417819977, 0.4311037063598633, 0.1855367124080658, 0.6892439126968384, -0.2689516544342041, 0.40454697608947754, -0.15541556477546692, -0.09355220198631287, 0.46266189217567444, -0.651005744934082, -0.24158261716365814, 0.05397557094693184, 0.6541243195533752, 0.4409414827823639, 0.19415006041526794, -0.32339906692504883, 0.21640056371688843, 0.5924797058105469, 0.23294028639793396, -0.5325413942337036, -0.35324543714523315, -0.01815536990761757, -0.21718469262123108, -0.3126847445964813, 0.18096661567687988, -0.6183432936668396, -0.5244237780570984, -0.2034604698419571, 0.4484187960624695, -0.6043070554733276, 0.06646521389484406, 0.14902332425117493, -0.37857404351234436, 0.08641337603330612, 0.508101224899292, -0.6305611729621887, 0.562904953956604, 0.8744981288909912, 0.40301668643951416, 0.06613828986883163, -0.16348566114902496, -0.47287553548812866, 0.3074541985988617, -0.42306971549987793, 0.5942246317863464, -0.49485066533088684, -0.4978227913379669, -0.33146578073501587, 0.2483852505683899, 0.1400090754032135, -0.3614482283592224, 1.0321455001831055, -0.42247098684310913, 0.6071606278419495, 0.08881773054599762, -0.7753159403800964, -0.4725131094455719, 0.019847026094794273, -0.6826159358024597, 0.7502080798149109, -0.34200647473335266, -0.6949385404586792, 0.6288377046585083, -0.5756605267524719, -0.9274601340293884, 0.009521221742033958, 0.12132763117551804, -0.5740747451782227, 0.024245617911219597, 0.3487641215324402, 0.13943982124328613, 0.05615861341357231, 0.00309944711625576, -0.22061306238174438, -0.34859028458595276, 0.033298030495643616, -0.697594165802002, 0.5554582476615906, 0.2561802268028259, 0.02211301028728485, -0.39795324206352234, -0.8447523713111877, -0.14947763085365295, -0.042480241507291794, -0.4382030963897705, -0.8341708779335022, 0.20938871800899506, -0.01666673831641674, 0.009094813838601112, 0.08489690721035004, -1.0176199674606323, 0.6400061845779419, -0.9311777949333191, 0.04457388073205948, 0.5201714038848877, 0.2458920031785965, 0.7520381212234497, -0.300504595041275, 0.3564327359199524, -0.005808345507830381, -0.016245855018496513, -0.4041328728199005, -0.2981600761413574, -0.6431729197502136, -0.8833345770835876, 0.28857046365737915, 0.7088921070098877, -0.7645329833030701, 0.5010520815849304, -0.36865100264549255, -0.3869864046573639, -0.5383680462837219, 0.3669305443763733, 0.1003490760922432, 0.508939802646637, 0.4609149098396301, 0.13153530657291412, -0.6466420888900757, -0.9657557606697083, -0.49200311303138733, -0.025229083374142647, 0.1977730244398117, -0.05089407041668892, 0.1635052114725113, -0.3618280589580536, 1.1952275037765503, -0.9257482290267944, -0.5042843818664551, -0.3645187020301819, -0.031677164137363434, -0.08283337950706482, 0.6477630138397217, 0.23814477026462555, -1.3042621612548828, 0.05107726901769638, -0.11252611875534058, -0.5257799029350281, -0.14152885973453522, -0.21369686722755432, -0.19390471279621124, 0.1561248004436493, 0.5202879309654236, -0.8024042844772339, 0.7266412377357483, -0.048750750720500946, -0.4737094044685364, 0.019076844677329063, -0.5290223956108093, 0.21335293352603912, -1.0351818799972534, -0.420948326587677, -0.12250087410211563, -0.4718356132507324, -0.7126976251602173, -0.03555380925536156, 0.3674885332584381, 0.1527179628610611, -0.2960105836391449, 0.5133644938468933, -0.372351735830307, 0.9141649007797241, -0.44082972407341003, 0.20735406875610352, 0.41527697443962097, 0.1409560739994049, 0.12650607526302338, 0.2560098469257355, 0.23715338110923767, -0.9167597889900208, 0.5831705331802368, 0.5282453298568726, -0.07338589429855347, 0.3334948718547821, -0.367876797914505, -0.22418181598186493, -0.7289649248123169, 0.24593649804592133, -1.1443020105361938, -0.05220530182123184, 0.43302762508392334, -0.36204054951667786, 0.2943785786628723, -0.13276872038841248, -0.4809044897556305, -0.210001140832901, -0.6129089593887329, -0.11577290296554565, 0.4867405295372009, -0.5040979385375977, 0.44523125886917114, 0.5833982825279236, -0.08104361593723297, -0.5224490761756897, -0.9598432183265686, 0.29676553606987, -0.48797282576560974, -0.589195966720581, 0.466632217168808, 0.20515525341033936, -0.2203732281923294, 0.2522992789745331, -0.20935899019241333, -0.2538819909095764, 0.1457786113023758, 0.23763872683048248, 0.522874653339386, 0.18509574234485626, 0.7716954350471497, 0.22900651395320892, -0.07291474938392639, -0.13543730974197388, -0.12390599399805069, 0.00257036997936666, 0.1789800077676773, -0.017860325053334236, -0.46505552530288696, 0.3834078311920166, 0.412101686000824, -0.09565442055463791, 0.7389193773269653, 0.5445592403411865, -0.4524707794189453, -0.4635787606239319, -0.37821686267852783, -0.14355386793613434, -0.47656503319740295, 0.2548139989376068, -0.42952489852905273, -0.2898504137992859, 0.11475444585084915, -0.07418208569288254, 0.020501606166362762, 0.2933887839317322, -0.06298013776540756, 0.04414479434490204, 0.7307512164115906, 0.4613809287548065, 0.4197286069393158, 0.4454907476902008, -0.18054284155368805, 0.3065584897994995, -0.4911457896232605, -0.12067458778619766, -0.331697940826416, -0.009631505236029625, -0.811107337474823, -0.2751173973083496, 0.23113180696964264, -0.05291998013854027, 0.3270300030708313, 0.5346090793609619, -0.3253115713596344, 0.5112661719322205, 0.5266065001487732, 0.5667331218719482, 0.42210307717323303, 0.0337817557156086, 0.2606583535671234, -0.2918592393398285, -0.4866422712802887, -0.46514999866485596, 0.8149653673171997, 0.10152963548898697, 0.9266350269317627, 0.18518805503845215, 0.8697385787963867, 0.45222827792167664, -0.22449831664562225, -0.9203854203224182, 0.8437137007713318, -0.5524213314056396, -0.5096986293792725, -0.272493451833725, -0.6589547991752625, -0.8226593732833862, 0.3855319321155548, -0.4653612971305847, -0.49095067381858826, 0.025575513020157814, 0.3752903938293457, 0.08356179296970367, 0.1619994044303894, -1.1290953159332275, 0.9064301252365112, 0.24723318219184875, -0.57972252368927, -0.1439572274684906, -0.49774813652038574, 0.20365189015865326, -0.07088328152894974, 0.4688856303691864, -0.0003779687685891986, -0.4196820855140686, 0.61524897813797, -1.0161807537078857, 0.47329187393188477, -0.266853392124176, 0.04308038577437401, 0.6663034558296204, 0.1417509764432907, 0.8844698071479797, 0.03300439193844795, 0.10567313432693481, -0.6272369027137756, -0.12405537068843842, -0.23517528176307678, -0.8336181044578552, 0.8022283315658569, -0.16552667319774628, -0.34414201974868774, -0.2659682631492615, -0.2589109241962433, -0.36639168858528137, 0.1415979415178299, -0.09933306276798248, 0.6168155074119568, -0.35139361023902893, 0.37340423464775085, 0.5306892991065979, -0.07312989979982376, 0.49409112334251404, 0.3129098415374756, 0.14381591975688934, -0.2856767773628235, 0.8315982222557068, -0.048119187355041504, 0.2846289873123169, 0.5958148241043091, 0.5606355667114258, -0.7203147411346436, -0.4643245339393616, -0.1810808628797531, 0.1775544434785843, -0.7291761636734009, 0.05721568316221237, -0.855221152305603, 0.3722459077835083, -0.7089525461196899, -0.1588621586561203, -0.2857377827167511, -0.8925894498825073, -0.033655911684036255, -0.37203627824783325, 0.8213616609573364, 0.43485477566719055, -0.14051757752895355, 0.39816561341285706, -0.8410608768463135, 0.6154008507728577, 0.20430207252502441, 0.12622980773448944, -0.5022795796394348, -0.3740096986293793, -0.10154137015342712, 0.2512471079826355, -0.028842607513070107, -0.5423125624656677, 0.4656906723976135, 0.622372031211853, 0.44397029280662537, 0.28262194991111755, 0.4622587263584137, 0.7204087972640991, -0.3721140921115875, 0.6996181607246399, 0.04037081077694893, -1.0163081884384155, 0.7413352131843567, -0.3302139341831207, 0.27264678478240967, 0.6688143014907837, 0.09427943825721741, -0.4691096544265747, -0.42941033840179443, -0.7759137749671936, -1.142614722251892, 0.7569413185119629, 0.14353857934474945, 0.2760423719882965, -0.1386328488588333, 0.2951350212097168, 0.2242003232240677, 0.4247395992279053, -0.4217827320098877, -0.30226650834083557, 0.05144628509879112, -0.7665823698043823, 0.13929963111877441, -0.010353699326515198, 0.14111152291297913, -0.12928909063339233, 0.7550253868103027, 0.17965096235275269, -0.30848050117492676, 0.4152469038963318, -0.26697391271591187, 0.3717426061630249, 0.4572920799255371, 0.06353102624416351, 0.16512036323547363, -0.27607718110084534, 0.2006847858428955, 0.0769217237830162, -0.9343684315681458, 0.3528134822845459, -0.09044201672077179, -0.6015369892120361, 0.030822696164250374, 0.21762585639953613, 0.3974444568157196, 0.03519662842154503, -0.47572770714759827, 0.6363547444343567, -0.1246100664138794, -0.23816832900047302, -0.06757497787475586, 0.1782596856355667, -0.15816806256771088, -0.29392489790916443, 0.20981478691101074, 0.35593950748443604, 0.3489833176136017, -0.5362557768821716, 0.7441279292106628, 0.27914538979530334, -0.35564184188842773, 0.10668487101793289, 0.6387609243392944, 0.17805372178554535, -0.09826530516147614, 0.13442391157150269, -0.32095032930374146, -0.3387283384799957, 0.3987084925174713, 0.22322943806648254, 0.852933406829834, 0.16513526439666748, 0.27759313583374023, 0.027327939867973328, 0.4494997560977936, -0.2406509816646576, 0.13416600227355957, 0.14462943375110626, -0.8434255123138428, -0.2837582528591156, -0.2629450857639313, -0.04240255057811737, -0.10987652838230133, -0.4025379419326782, 0.5245091319084167, -0.4286149740219116, -0.06080125644803047, 0.3822616934776306, -0.02984207309782505, -0.35632556676864624, 0.6077121496200562, 0.022226279601454735, 0.6971954703330994, -0.8465062975883484, 0.7878023386001587, 0.9863969087600708, -0.27682018280029297, -0.42770200967788696, -0.009359960444271564, 0.19645047187805176, -0.4029853045940399, 0.5557485818862915, 0.09541819244623184, -0.33155885338783264, -0.2350378781557083, -0.6058184504508972, -0.32518208026885986, 0.44200411438941956, 0.06543344259262085, 0.08019360154867172, -0.002945674117654562, -0.21811871230602264, 0.5518928170204163, -0.1995174139738083, -0.0929681584239006, 0.3478504419326782, 0.47833549976348877, 0.3019562065601349, -0.5242652893066406, 0.14075875282287598, -0.3020671606063843, -0.0076653845608234406, 0.4334024488925934, -0.2988448739051819, 0.7134453654289246, -0.3380412459373474, -0.4948386251926422, -0.04002681374549866, 0.5304632186889648, -0.6227763295173645, 0.12626947462558746, 0.7545323967933655, 0.5376467704772949, 0.629564642906189, -0.22618696093559265, 0.7843033075332642, 0.16202113032341003, 0.42285823822021484, 1.189253807067871, -0.16034068167209625, 0.40773797035217285, 0.4876900613307953, -0.11078350245952606, 0.4467149078845978, 0.12170127779245377, 0.2131243199110031, 0.8631514310836792, 0.14414112269878387, -0.44937416911125183, -0.3512713611125946, -0.11593153327703476, 0.02284291386604309, 0.9839490652084351, 0.35200589895248413, -0.10306993126869202, -0.19088494777679443, 0.06484253704547882, 0.4529854655265808, 0.577877402305603, -0.16503548622131348, 0.9538651704788208, -0.4696838855743408, -0.5261412858963013, 0.3290061056613922, -0.03997310996055603, 0.6294143795967102, -0.609742283821106, -0.21778197586536407, -0.012571110390126705, 0.6645224094390869, -0.2804534435272217, -0.6005232334136963, 0.4631309509277344, -0.2157043218612671, -0.25276127457618713, -0.06141854077577591, 0.8073829412460327, -0.820980429649353, -0.4167126715183258, -0.04069490358233452, 0.16070599853992462, -0.11833100765943527, 0.11610084027051926, -0.19774100184440613, -0.3472420573234558, 0.0997115820646286, -0.06328485161066055, -0.08854827284812927, 0.6801427006721497, 0.18988044559955597, 0.7831696271896362, 0.5588974952697754, 0.5001102089881897, -0.18458864092826843, -0.13809826970100403, 0.6461676359176636, -0.89739990234375, -0.7546848654747009, -0.8771846890449524, 0.4264041781425476, -0.336304247379303, -0.10421887040138245, 1.0560123920440674, 0.5313489437103271, 0.5163627862930298, 0.01754227839410305, 0.9986928105354309, -0.007601057179272175, 0.8809576034545898, -0.5931200981140137, 0.402177631855011, -0.4889496862888336, 0.33397185802459717, -0.6249870657920837, -0.48440468311309814, -0.5597805976867676, 0.3744349181652069, -0.12657883763313293, -0.458655446767807, 0.7413130402565002, 0.9012672901153564, 0.05346788093447685, 0.28496092557907104, -0.044603265821933746, 0.05395491048693657, 0.32328206300735474, 0.3517693281173706, 0.5003935098648071, -0.7825409173965454, 0.6392095685005188, -0.3325769305229187, -0.35889554023742676, -0.16651874780654907, -0.8499887585639954, -0.5165462493896484, -0.2708500623703003, -0.6485995650291443, -0.2964661717414856, -0.0014866921119391918, 1.0734889507293701, 0.36403536796569824, -0.7287543416023254, 0.2856108248233795, -0.2757376730442047, 0.3917716443538666, -0.3922502100467682, -0.299354612827301, 0.45054158568382263, -0.15112100541591644, -0.761302649974823, 0.6427310109138489, -0.05381489917635918, 0.3219752907752991, 0.29613566398620605, 0.34636029601097107, -0.5430353879928589, 0.14600567519664764, 0.5361582636833191, 0.03752274811267853, -0.3571045696735382, -0.35635918378829956, -0.15671220421791077, -0.17884160578250885, -0.04940461739897728, 0.5060655474662781, -0.9063148498535156, 0.7003908157348633, 0.8899937272071838, 0.7028776407241821, 0.24907907843589783, 0.6269589066505432, 0.6851696968078613, -0.8740074634552002, 0.48380789160728455, -0.03357439488172531, 0.1503458470106125, 0.4620530903339386, -0.4330179989337921, 0.5054733753204346, 0.6658560633659363, -0.2545943260192871, -0.7303008437156677, 0.09270638972520828, -0.8723370432853699, -0.42504140734672546, 1.1159404516220093, 0.06089945137500763, -0.2975054383277893, -0.17203666269779205, -0.5530002117156982, 0.2093982845544815, -0.5387398600578308, 0.3313036859035492, 0.42850643396377563, 0.11282705515623093, 0.18917511403560638, -0.14623887836933136, 0.7331317067146301, 0.03748650848865509, -0.6211862564086914, 0.3151681423187256, 0.8780180215835571, 0.18028663098812103, 0.05805932357907295, 0.33063656091690063, 0.020441871136426926, 0.12812435626983643, 0.35249072313308716, 0.059036899358034134, -0.39181604981422424, -0.27316874265670776, -0.3465877175331116, 0.22922979295253754, -0.2995871603488922, -0.764575183391571 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20014v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20014v1
PURPLE: Making a Large Language Model a Better SQL Writer
2024-03-29T07:01:29
2024-03-29T07:01:29
Tonghui Ren, Yuankai Fan, Zhenying He, Ren Huang, Jiaqi Dai, Can Huang, Yinan Jing, Kai Zhang, Yifan Yang, X. Sean Wang
cs.DB
cs.DB, cs.AI, cs.CL
Large Language Model (LLM) techniques play an increasingly important role in Natural Language to SQL (NL2SQL) translation. LLMs trained by extensive corpora have strong natural language understanding and basic SQL generation abilities without additional tuning specific to NL2SQL tasks. Existing LLMs-based NL2SQL approaches try to improve the translation by enhancing the LLMs with an emphasis on user intention understanding. However, LLMs sometimes fail to generate appropriate SQL due to their lack of knowledge in organizing complex logical operator composition. A promising method is to input the LLMs with demonstrations, which include known NL2SQL translations from various databases. LLMs can learn to organize operator compositions from the input demonstrations for the given task. In this paper, we propose PURPLE (Pre-trained models Utilized to Retrieve Prompts for Logical Enhancement), which improves accuracy by retrieving demonstrations containing the requisite logical operator composition for the NL2SQL task on hand, thereby guiding LLMs to produce better SQL translation. PURPLE achieves a new state-of-the-art performance of 80.5% exact-set match accuracy and 87.8% execution match accuracy on the validation set of the popular NL2SQL benchmark Spider. PURPLE maintains high accuracy across diverse benchmarks, budgetary constraints, and various LLMs, showing robustness and cost-effectiveness.
[ 0.027602916583418846, -0.7126666307449341, 0.44584330916404724, 0.3662799298763275, -0.4271612763404846, 0.023328334093093872, -0.3360030949115753, -0.1937030851840973, 0.13252700865268707, 0.7622355818748474, -0.36036795377731323, -0.46230635046958923, -0.4918473958969116, 0.3360624313354492, -0.49839600920677185, 0.855472981929779, 0.26252761483192444, 0.1806456297636032, 0.06746869534254074, -0.1614259034395218, -0.6198379397392273, -0.4743386507034302, -0.5297022461891174, -0.20076492428779602, 0.4373748302459717, 0.16727901995182037, 0.6695885062217712, 0.6243225932121277, 0.34232842922210693, 0.39758652448654175, -0.16914033889770508, 0.48213717341423035, -0.5929813385009766, 0.16530126333236694, -0.22172044217586517, -0.9148380756378174, -0.5087943077087402, -0.11856834590435028, 0.5388350486755371, 0.5653983354568481, -0.4996397793292999, -0.18224425613880157, -0.06354756653308868, 0.6860454082489014, -0.6116888523101807, 0.3619546592235565, -0.9483624696731567, 0.2073848396539688, -0.20162971317768097, -0.25599369406700134, -0.7417992949485779, -0.6180625557899475, -0.28751522302627563, -0.6670608520507812, -0.2602420151233673, 0.10877503454685211, 0.6258260011672974, 0.24936974048614502, -0.9967817068099976, -0.19622032344341278, -0.8249878883361816, 0.9864369630813599, -0.7707623243331909, 0.4779735505580902, 0.0076172975823283195, 0.6888378858566284, -0.29081252217292786, -0.9172654747962952, -0.8438394665718079, -0.2024041712284088, -0.11260179430246353, 0.14372316002845764, -0.21558040380477905, -0.027948958799242973, 0.3401152789592743, 0.274222731590271, -0.1786622852087021, 0.10036181658506393, -0.4530106782913208, -0.22026020288467407, 0.5285444855690002, 0.37079426646232605, 0.1713697612285614, -0.2243361920118332, 0.008412915281951427, 0.08182322978973389, -0.7932847142219543, -0.22874481976032257, 0.21263182163238525, 0.403279185295105, 0.061293501406908035, 0.9206228256225586, -0.17861473560333252, 0.9232839941978455, 0.09245612472295761, -0.27660906314849854, 0.13750502467155457, -0.449720174074173, -0.26716482639312744, -0.1300532966852188, 0.7985638380050659, 0.639234185218811, 0.5615432858467102, -0.21707050502300262, -0.36033833026885986, 0.22333484888076782, 0.22032000124454498, -0.9694675207138062, -0.36325591802597046, 0.32469049096107483, -0.4058195650577545, -0.23096469044685364, -0.32627061009407043, -0.5254788994789124, -0.8030641078948975, -0.7989160418510437, 0.0809125006198883, -0.5799515247344971, -0.3286140561103821, -0.11337726563215256, -0.03458955138921738, 0.2808386981487274, 0.3491747975349426, -0.8636856079101562, 0.2583143711090088, 0.7400273680686951, 0.513917863368988, -0.40836793184280396, 0.0909043550491333, -0.7050243616104126, 0.338868647813797, -0.8008170127868652, 0.5766172409057617, -0.3172420263290405, -0.06743449717760086, 0.04841000959277153, -0.018146265298128128, 0.2178158462047577, -0.7063708305358887, 0.5326622128486633, -0.8156337141990662, 0.27986645698547363, -0.3247523307800293, -0.6784548759460449, 0.007656090892851353, 0.22652624547481537, -0.3769860863685608, 0.7955092787742615, 0.2751031816005707, -0.4704701006412506, 0.4810679256916046, -0.49170660972595215, -0.36321642994880676, 0.16880573332309723, -0.3858809769153595, -0.2005714476108551, 0.15633898973464966, 0.2097979038953781, 0.3827846050262451, -0.24867375195026398, 0.1824415624141693, -0.22531865537166595, -0.41108304262161255, 0.3856884837150574, -0.005158725194633007, 1.0519063472747803, 0.20221738517284393, -0.07634656131267548, 0.326748788356781, -0.7439875602722168, 0.22425824403762817, 0.01895114593207836, -0.43009036779403687, 0.057074788957834244, -0.1298871636390686, -0.014986677095293999, 0.18567150831222534, 0.1303057223558426, -0.3284645974636078, 0.1945226788520813, -0.671758234500885, 0.5341873168945312, 0.7877335548400879, -0.13459794223308563, 0.7331975102424622, 0.019461655989289284, 0.7241775393486023, -0.001938873203471303, 0.014951079152524471, 0.0704665333032608, -0.2175523340702057, -0.7301302552223206, -0.45815548300743103, 0.5718292593955994, 0.8166602253913879, -0.7812620401382446, 0.47046181559562683, -0.1942087560892105, -0.5376515984535217, -0.3494071066379547, 0.20460115373134613, 0.22978921234607697, 0.6830098032951355, 0.406274676322937, -0.08749164640903473, -0.7672578692436218, -1.1226953268051147, -0.30906569957733154, 0.07341141253709793, -0.19315989315509796, 0.23285602033138275, 0.3030930459499359, -0.3483658730983734, 0.7997477650642395, -0.5223595499992371, -0.4417339861392975, -0.3216641843318939, -0.21105161309242249, 0.5730166435241699, 0.2587284445762634, 0.39765721559524536, -0.5441282391548157, -0.7320360541343689, 0.22486774623394012, -0.7688501477241516, -0.05747773125767708, 0.12005183100700378, -0.32693785429000854, 0.591806948184967, 0.6495153307914734, -0.7882195711135864, 0.039522118866443634, 0.38269752264022827, -0.2143525332212448, 0.689576268196106, -0.17883123457431793, 0.14849171042442322, -1.1612260341644287, -0.017606237903237343, -0.18116432428359985, -0.1475154161453247, -0.5394544005393982, 0.07157798856496811, 0.3619106113910675, -0.15139615535736084, -0.45749232172966003, 0.3833387494087219, -0.6453375220298767, -0.14935331046581268, -0.26517197489738464, 0.1683492511510849, -0.21051739156246185, 0.3911747336387634, -0.07783966511487961, 0.7556468844413757, 0.45894232392311096, -0.5807379484176636, 0.6020378470420837, 0.40093764662742615, -0.3074035048484802, 0.7957305312156677, -0.6972202062606812, 0.05455019697546959, -0.0066696335561573505, 0.24915309250354767, -0.8467769026756287, -0.20829445123672485, 0.17684713006019592, -0.2267315834760666, 0.4186345040798187, -0.45167413353919983, -0.7138693332672119, -0.11991938948631287, 0.009550944902002811, -0.390036940574646, 0.8801036477088928, -0.3065604567527771, 0.896902322769165, 0.38288795948028564, -0.32709112763404846, -0.6905457973480225, -0.9367325901985168, 0.3969738483428955, -0.18537916243076324, -0.6736358404159546, 0.33547472953796387, 0.14429044723510742, -0.19764767587184906, -0.38829338550567627, -0.07679065316915512, -0.2536050081253052, 0.019373679533600807, -0.04169486090540886, 0.3038467466831207, -0.29381904006004333, 0.1960386335849762, -0.04719044268131256, -0.1515609472990036, 0.18336880207061768, -0.23885594308376312, 0.5600878596305847, 0.018148798495531082, -0.015997856855392456, -0.3566032350063324, 0.31008902192115784, 0.41368722915649414, -0.3881807327270508, 0.9956226348876953, 0.27737361192703247, -0.16091996431350708, -0.4452604055404663, -0.4544270634651184, -0.5495536923408508, -0.511814296245575, 0.5552189946174622, -0.297590434551239, -0.558015763759613, 0.16319411993026733, -0.0752982348203659, 0.19587156176567078, 0.19542090594768524, 0.39960452914237976, -0.4475139081478119, 1.1558719873428345, 0.7045304775238037, 0.26210951805114746, 0.48683157563209534, -0.020263545215129852, 0.2668806314468384, -0.7162840962409973, -0.15082623064517975, -0.5477946400642395, -0.24278761446475983, -0.591818630695343, -0.5334473848342896, 0.25171151757240295, 0.4475570023059845, -0.299297034740448, 0.2714308798313141, -0.6450921297073364, 0.5706113576889038, 0.4269018769264221, 0.12335603684186935, 0.36172905564308167, 0.45608416199684143, -0.009079353883862495, -0.47754764556884766, -0.549129068851471, -0.5663427114486694, 1.1263436079025269, 0.0769583061337471, 0.5917927622795105, 0.3513897955417633, 0.40795862674713135, -0.1296551525592804, 0.256375253200531, -0.5119050741195679, 0.8110725283622742, -0.29886651039123535, -0.4477904140949249, -0.19444330036640167, -0.5350126624107361, -0.8369248509407043, 0.2134280949831009, -0.4072706699371338, -0.37926238775253296, -0.042012300342321396, 0.6033350229263306, 0.06298433989286423, -0.16586290299892426, -0.6866488456726074, 0.9171872735023499, -0.44122371077537537, -0.2978838086128235, -0.19342626631259918, -0.4613879323005676, 0.3759445548057556, -0.08627968281507492, -0.028333444148302078, 0.3186609447002411, -0.40242913365364075, 0.5935402512550354, -0.4106236398220062, 0.6184909343719482, -0.12554818391799927, -0.18385690450668335, 0.0582018718123436, 0.24353726208209991, 0.9283963441848755, -0.28496742248535156, -0.377905011177063, -0.026655029505491257, -0.3850468397140503, -0.34981369972229004, -0.8780626058578491, 0.46996092796325684, -0.4436921179294586, -0.48506367206573486, -0.2387724220752716, -0.5992936491966248, -0.3345075845718384, 0.2868490517139435, 0.06900112330913544, 0.13026562333106995, 0.39423254132270813, 0.36775898933410645, 0.7592359781265259, -0.2738785445690155, -0.03242968022823334, 0.6223557591438293, -0.41508886218070984, -0.44429144263267517, 0.7991081476211548, 0.1536393016576767, 0.25048398971557617, 0.39634969830513, 0.14590540528297424, -0.6539770364761353, -0.9971293807029724, -0.5075921416282654, 0.41540777683258057, -0.8480961918830872, -0.1575438380241394, -0.9027801752090454, -0.004002797417342663, -0.5143082141876221, -0.12659434974193573, -0.14134779572486877, -0.7239395380020142, -0.15572649240493774, -0.1448790431022644, 0.5323680639266968, 0.35728883743286133, 0.20311690866947174, 0.2906796634197235, -0.5862899422645569, 0.3252509832382202, 0.3851785659790039, 0.11675763875246048, -0.3402014672756195, -0.7348098754882812, 0.1090775579214096, -0.005482443142682314, -0.3270452320575714, -1.1692771911621094, 0.42017123103141785, 0.07963890582323074, 0.5479834675788879, 0.09926465898752213, -0.04607456922531128, 0.8276435732841492, -0.5516820549964905, 0.5780114531517029, 0.4017317295074463, -0.7728907465934753, 0.7005234360694885, -0.42471033334732056, 0.22495843470096588, 0.4797748625278473, 0.27643483877182007, -0.31722891330718994, -0.35853397846221924, -0.25422972440719604, -0.8284300565719604, 0.6522641777992249, 0.19919082522392273, -0.07005736976861954, 0.0727478489279747, 0.33328136801719666, -0.2880082130432129, 0.47887665033340454, -1.127128005027771, -0.23805877566337585, -0.055963821709156036, -0.29731035232543945, -0.0037084005307406187, -0.3554378151893616, -0.08579592406749725, -0.040168456733226776, 0.8089213967323303, -0.2933925986289978, 0.06293097883462906, -0.37022683024406433, -0.1431148201227188, 0.046977899968624115, 0.32769879698753357, 0.22329427301883698, 0.7381245493888855, -0.044733744114637375, -0.1025848388671875, 0.4658559560775757, -0.09094773977994919, -0.019838601350784302, 0.07359566539525986, -0.35200831294059753, -0.11637914925813675, 0.41269877552986145, 0.47451698780059814, -0.12104201316833496, -0.6487449407577515, 0.42270684242248535, 0.048861850053071976, 0.04966878145933151, -0.4002187252044678, 0.2695620059967041, 0.7800360918045044, 0.11156810075044632, 0.02510889805853367, -0.06129227206110954, 0.19768473505973816, -0.6421505808830261, 0.003998418804258108, 0.5838614106178284, -0.3835286796092987, 0.1988610178232193, 0.4409913122653961, 0.3852590322494507, -0.41647836565971375, 0.9809141159057617, -0.2763187289237976, -0.5016503930091858, 0.6410295367240906, 0.5968980193138123, 0.4108215868473053, -0.21327459812164307, -0.14461736381053925, 0.4725947976112366, 0.4048566222190857, 0.017430424690246582, 0.6625926494598389, 0.1251252293586731, -0.5127267837524414, -0.704598605632782, -0.5699908137321472, -0.2536434233188629, -0.14877210557460785, -0.3098703622817993, 0.673613429069519, -0.21372763812541962, 0.11866816878318787, -0.10907787084579468, -0.005862940568476915, -0.3393840193748474, 0.13961778581142426, -0.12355048209428787, 1.0016286373138428, -0.6858921647071838, 0.836700975894928, 0.543095052242279, -0.3446497619152069, -1.0454659461975098, -0.5877755284309387, -0.20651333034038544, -0.42230021953582764, 0.8792756795883179, -0.019453851506114006, 0.225525364279747, -0.1193062961101532, -0.25990307331085205, -0.4606581926345825, 0.9691550135612488, 0.8522619009017944, -0.9696251749992371, 0.007686414755880833, 0.41762638092041016, 0.714436411857605, -0.2736086845397949, 0.5006917119026184, 0.524043083190918, 0.5253623127937317, 0.05891132727265358, -0.645993709564209, 0.02489958517253399, 0.0028007542714476585, 0.057501692324876785, 0.36691945791244507, -0.33926787972450256, 0.8751428723335266, -0.22997726500034332, -0.22862796485424042, 0.09831946343183517, 0.7970716953277588, 0.6208506226539612, -0.03215693309903145, 0.5404462814331055, 0.35314565896987915, 0.8938252925872803, -0.1759490966796875, 1.175675868988037, -0.14526209235191345, -0.11338445544242859, 1.342666745185852, -0.44862866401672363, 0.8613629341125488, 0.4940529465675354, -0.3044266998767853, 0.41622188687324524, 0.3513261377811432, -0.08828351646661758, 0.38469287753105164, 0.4357870817184448, -0.06375623494386673, -0.3938058018684387, -0.046899911016225815, -0.4066811203956604, 0.21479499340057373, 0.2118501216173172, -0.4953320026397705, 0.07982734590768814, -0.28236570954322815, -0.023947110399603844, 0.5300069451332092, -0.16176162660121918, 0.8076701760292053, 0.12692390382289886, -0.803105890750885, 0.6006624102592468, 0.04940301924943924, 0.6288020014762878, -0.7866112589836121, -0.3113640546798706, -0.3762360215187073, 0.3676718771457672, -0.3855266273021698, -0.7595152854919434, 0.3883706331253052, -0.05767709016799927, -0.20593690872192383, -0.20887887477874756, 0.4848475158214569, -0.5115323662757874, -0.6949073076248169, 0.20684528350830078, 0.12575885653495789, 0.1955145299434662, -0.14061062037944794, -0.742899477481842, -0.012259968556463718, 0.1404682695865631, 0.006805781275033951, 0.1489132195711136, 0.7429383397102356, -0.022611448541283607, 0.7007881999015808, 0.7718695998191833, 0.355467289686203, 0.15092356503009796, -0.06058125197887421, 0.4784005880355835, -0.6924371123313904, -0.5582494139671326, -0.7073118686676025, 0.46621963381767273, -0.5826847553253174, -0.217709019780159, 0.9097904562950134, 0.6640650629997253, 0.4939272999763489, -0.35805562138557434, 0.5414391756057739, 0.022445838898420334, 0.6608563661575317, -0.539623498916626, 0.683012068271637, -0.4610210955142975, 0.35344237089157104, -0.039299845695495605, -1.1373836994171143, -0.114669568836689, 0.6690014600753784, -0.004861787892878056, 0.06944289803504944, 0.6989066004753113, 1.2097337245941162, -0.017809022217988968, -0.032908447086811066, 0.27896952629089355, 0.694262683391571, 0.42432886362075806, 0.4903980791568756, 0.9196079969406128, -0.39994457364082336, 0.9081692695617676, -0.20550537109375, -0.13935406506061554, -0.07550956308841705, -1.1417025327682495, -0.9225865006446838, -0.13523352146148682, -0.5133145451545715, -0.5887765884399414, 0.08242620527744293, 0.6836716532707214, 0.9006787538528442, -0.9403097629547119, -0.3082812428474426, -0.2794414460659027, -0.030571045354008675, -0.20260247588157654, -0.1986551731824875, 0.2378542125225067, -0.2568885087966919, -0.7140818238258362, 0.4032979905605316, 0.18640004098415375, -0.15478432178497314, -0.16313181817531586, -0.1996758133172989, 0.0359354168176651, 0.10769834369421005, 0.7796998023986816, -0.06139038875699043, -0.6997377276420593, 0.10845426470041275, -0.002301398664712906, -0.31333020329475403, -0.058809272944927216, 0.46353480219841003, -0.8109672665596008, 0.19239230453968048, 0.40917372703552246, 0.6874700784683228, 0.4720180332660675, -0.40198972821235657, 0.7667123675346375, -0.6139091849327087, -0.0066690100356936455, 0.5342097878456116, 0.46652454137802124, 0.4371052384376526, -0.25564950704574585, 0.7489814162254333, -0.022418836131691933, -0.4485154449939728, -0.8901132345199585, 0.40423086285591125, -1.1537858247756958, -0.279380202293396, 1.2747048139572144, 0.18613722920417786, -0.2760891914367676, -0.07958949357271194, -0.4107654094696045, 0.18478548526763916, -0.33427006006240845, 0.6805014610290527, 0.4316283166408539, 0.05573413148522377, -0.17753292620182037, -0.3904631435871124, 0.38749125599861145, 0.5127286911010742, -1.044404149055481, 0.16183024644851685, 0.72719806432724, 0.4238077998161316, 0.011533222161233425, 0.6102591753005981, -0.3100469708442688, 0.5190857648849487, -0.16925941407680511, 0.1025937870144844, -0.13349850475788116, -0.027586331591010094, -0.2062235027551651, 0.36084693670272827, 0.11415740102529526, 0.23568996787071228 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20009v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20009v1
On Large Language Models' Hallucination with Regard to Known Facts
2024-03-29T06:48:30
2024-03-29T06:48:30
Che Jiang, Biqing Qi, Xiangyu Hong, Dayuan Fu, Yang Cheng, Fandong Meng, Mo Yu, Bowen Zhou, Jie Zhou
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.LG
Large language models are successful in answering factoid questions but are also prone to hallucination.We investigate the phenomenon of LLMs possessing correct answer knowledge yet still hallucinating from the perspective of inference dynamics, an area not previously covered in studies on hallucinations.We are able to conduct this analysis via two key ideas.First, we identify the factual questions that query the same triplet knowledge but result in different answers. The difference between the model behaviors on the correct and incorrect outputs hence suggests the patterns when hallucinations happen. Second, to measure the pattern, we utilize mappings from the residual streams to vocabulary space. We reveal the different dynamics of the output token probabilities along the depths of layers between the correct and hallucinated cases. In hallucinated cases, the output token's information rarely demonstrates abrupt increases and consistent superiority in the later stages of the model. Leveraging the dynamic curve as a feature, we build a classifier capable of accurately detecting hallucinatory predictions with an 88\% success rate. Our study shed light on understanding the reasons for LLMs' hallucinations on their known facts, and more importantly, on accurately predicting when they are hallucinating.
[ -0.17456994950771332, -1.1561152935028076, 1.0783686637878418, 0.05873000621795654, -0.07063699513673782, -0.015980951488018036, -0.22534504532814026, -0.506827712059021, 0.3209887742996216, 0.67601078748703, -0.4905054271221161, -0.4166452884674072, -0.6421051025390625, -0.08355235308408737, -0.6637779474258423, 0.7850866317749023, 0.16214986145496368, 0.10070252418518066, -0.20408444106578827, 0.05139642208814621, -0.4204494059085846, -0.8521746397018433, -0.5541250705718994, -0.326572984457016, 0.6131955981254578, 0.034297794103622437, 0.7423908710479736, 0.7118942737579346, 0.2678205966949463, 0.26749512553215027, -0.17260205745697021, 0.2237471342086792, -0.6592479348182678, 0.5459640026092529, 0.10339060425758362, -0.6843485832214355, -0.16432765126228333, -0.16412533819675446, 0.5063374638557434, 0.7662005424499512, -0.3099000155925751, -0.1331128478050232, 0.07741925120353699, 0.5538252592086792, -0.32653260231018066, 0.18833288550376892, -0.9163249135017395, 0.1431141048669815, -0.1047673299908638, -0.5811649560928345, -0.48537755012512207, -0.5318197011947632, 0.0798286721110344, -0.25923624634742737, 0.37165504693984985, 0.22241002321243286, 0.7922095060348511, 0.6400423049926758, -0.42655816674232483, -0.647361159324646, -0.8199112415313721, 0.4940416216850281, -0.3771843910217285, 0.4837300479412079, 0.4221072494983673, 0.3557552099227905, -0.337809681892395, -0.4939998388290405, -0.559386134147644, -0.5576436519622803, -0.10758551955223083, -0.18326713144779205, 0.1772119551897049, -0.05614588037133217, 0.5273032784461975, 0.227450892329216, -0.4131862223148346, 0.15428997576236725, -0.3549330234527588, -0.31116145849227905, 0.4850817620754242, 0.24268639087677002, 0.19832675158977509, -0.16475562751293182, -0.27769598364830017, 0.27405261993408203, -0.6206560730934143, -0.36799392104148865, 0.42183658480644226, 0.2970365583896637, 0.032157573848962784, 0.6524925827980042, 0.15263405442237854, 0.48970210552215576, 0.024500861763954163, -0.20346949994564056, 0.2404361367225647, 0.06176804006099701, 0.04512089863419533, 0.35112452507019043, 0.44494667649269104, 0.0937349945306778, 0.4821372330188751, -0.5191212892532349, -0.3148268759250641, -0.08981732279062271, 0.2785487174987793, -0.6246477961540222, -0.2922527492046356, 0.4223586916923523, -0.30136242508888245, -0.17402932047843933, 0.04424332082271576, -0.8010661005973816, -0.867186427116394, -0.41334599256515503, 0.5094711184501648, -0.41929203271865845, -0.4367309510707855, 0.27308225631713867, 0.0026513375341892242, 0.3216843605041504, 0.4070587158203125, -0.84453284740448, 0.38019055128097534, 0.8015533685684204, 1.0635749101638794, -0.5150636434555054, -0.39750009775161743, -0.6585863828659058, 0.08913592249155045, -0.4422140121459961, 0.7297417521476746, -0.26249003410339355, 0.016628487035632133, 0.09272009134292603, 0.03434985503554344, -0.15216770768165588, -0.7170838117599487, 0.33044806122779846, -0.7577376961708069, -0.1179192066192627, -0.4789128601551056, -0.7678568959236145, -0.41099992394447327, 0.13831447064876556, -0.7226558923721313, 0.8034576773643494, -0.40705615282058716, -0.7660892605781555, 0.3871651291847229, -0.27226972579956055, -0.25529414415359497, -0.08108320832252502, -0.31920039653778076, -0.16790109872817993, 0.3951638638973236, -0.38227102160453796, 0.6671057939529419, 0.09257486462593079, 0.5532603859901428, -0.38296934962272644, -0.5281935930252075, 0.489266037940979, -0.509334921836853, 0.5478590726852417, 0.05301836133003235, -0.4664607346057892, 0.05573071166872978, -0.858106255531311, -0.4046514630317688, 0.1030566468834877, -0.18855154514312744, -0.1496087610721588, 0.3366386294364929, -0.4148876368999481, -0.046377360820770264, -0.08194805681705475, -0.24477434158325195, 0.2481992542743683, -0.09644143283367157, 0.0014694574056193233, 0.7876530885696411, 0.1889137476682663, -0.011453219689428806, -0.46695441007614136, 0.2913246154785156, 0.1137586385011673, -0.3229106366634369, 0.21034017205238342, -0.4996010959148407, -0.9660691022872925, -0.3200497031211853, 0.05809365212917328, 0.47260260581970215, -0.5723857879638672, 0.2963842749595642, -0.2884010970592499, -0.2108755111694336, -0.15997648239135742, -0.13396337628364563, -0.07729215919971466, 0.4706740975379944, 0.17598123848438263, 0.25256654620170593, -0.5303975939750671, -0.7030970454216003, -0.01858505606651306, -0.27852529287338257, 0.13086462020874023, 0.1121380627155304, 0.6276988387107849, -0.13827364146709442, 0.45366981625556946, -0.46675243973731995, -0.07520497590303421, -0.1667778342962265, 0.3960190713405609, 0.28465232253074646, 0.09450594335794449, 0.3358900249004364, -0.7210236191749573, 0.1178862527012825, -0.11476116627454758, -1.022094964981079, -0.14894261956214905, -0.35839736461639404, -0.0037766878958791494, 0.535408616065979, 0.6709070205688477, -0.725911557674408, 0.3804945647716522, 0.33319854736328125, -0.39277344942092896, 0.735144853591919, -0.19653941690921783, 0.028949910774827003, -0.7380527853965759, -0.25473546981811523, -0.3648250997066498, -0.07678388059139252, -0.5862460136413574, -0.15581022202968597, -0.2990623414516449, 0.6073077917098999, -0.19445107877254486, 0.27966421842575073, -0.5461087226867676, -0.43968895077705383, -0.2637782096862793, 0.29001808166503906, -0.4287714958190918, 0.47954925894737244, 0.2747151255607605, 0.48741164803504944, 0.6830058693885803, -0.9875109195709229, 0.6436453461647034, -0.10247378796339035, -0.5344328880310059, -0.08496321737766266, -0.23495207726955414, 0.033020004630088806, -0.2170901745557785, -0.09015517681837082, -1.0018842220306396, -0.3999772071838379, 0.16578273475170135, -0.3663741648197174, 0.20935148000717163, 0.027262607589364052, -0.6533344388008118, -0.16713890433311462, -0.04075409099459648, 0.10366745293140411, 0.5274299383163452, -0.5736662149429321, 0.6365084648132324, 0.36449891328811646, 0.1389232575893402, -0.6343740224838257, -0.7147188782691956, -0.012558151967823505, -0.240558460354805, -0.4933708906173706, -0.023493461310863495, -0.15716910362243652, -0.5100317001342773, -0.10516106337308884, -0.21930751204490662, 0.14449827373027802, 0.18798963725566864, 0.42741864919662476, 0.20093142986297607, -0.31781241297721863, 0.381034791469574, -0.22391536831855774, 0.12077080458402634, 0.4876859486103058, -0.06701958924531937, 0.987704336643219, -0.022892910987138748, -0.5328330993652344, -0.28217506408691406, 0.0008662269683554769, 0.7888497114181519, 0.2843436598777771, 1.0540227890014648, 0.484786719083786, -0.5376023054122925, -0.22327294945716858, -0.696732223033905, -0.40277963876724243, -0.3442631661891937, 0.35109245777130127, -0.6968927979469299, -0.8242440223693848, 1.0557336807250977, 0.25414565205574036, -0.12547923624515533, 0.302374929189682, 0.8949956297874451, 0.08497732132673264, 0.9876295924186707, 0.3487524688243866, 0.3764110207557678, -0.073863685131073, -0.18981096148490906, 0.3396387994289398, -0.5585342645645142, -0.5614100098609924, -0.3775450885295868, -0.11532702296972275, -0.8122066855430603, -0.35976365208625793, 0.178298681974411, 0.06139817461371422, -0.14533475041389465, -0.20831400156021118, -0.1998121738433838, 0.3904127776622772, 0.3088839054107666, 0.1386622041463852, 0.21235841512680054, 0.03362398222088814, -0.2589108347892761, 0.02564503438770771, -0.45547714829444885, -0.5857518315315247, 0.8317659497261047, 0.40228864550590515, 0.8331672549247742, 0.29323235154151917, 0.665895938873291, 0.32455888390541077, 0.06069304794073105, -0.9618207216262817, 0.707055389881134, 0.3500513434410095, -0.6997545957565308, -0.44436612725257874, -0.43733158707618713, -0.5786110162734985, 0.2631002962589264, -0.19785697758197784, -0.9183288216590881, 0.058982960879802704, 0.13473092019557953, -0.4139668047428131, 0.5956224799156189, -0.2821215093135834, 0.5506710410118103, -0.4409317374229431, -0.611544132232666, -0.13168051838874817, -0.6044685244560242, 0.6629905104637146, -0.25162890553474426, 0.15605194866657257, -0.22196444869041443, 0.03684365749359131, 0.6269170641899109, -0.19936268031597137, 0.8478831648826599, -0.09562664479017258, -0.3250889182090759, 0.23849621415138245, 0.3724377453327179, 0.43925243616104126, -0.019769370555877686, -0.12335801124572754, 0.11312385648488998, -0.04809525981545448, -0.20854128897190094, -0.7352567315101624, 0.7108603715896606, -0.6552460789680481, -1.0258386135101318, -0.6965303421020508, -0.5900821685791016, -0.1666276901960373, -0.16686192154884338, 0.2560710906982422, 0.28299444913864136, 0.012845505960285664, 0.03962928429245949, 1.0481582880020142, -0.2330373227596283, 0.31508973240852356, 0.34534305334091187, -0.861470639705658, 0.10411611944437027, 0.8521103262901306, 0.347970575094223, 0.32081174850463867, 0.21740153431892395, 0.23057003319263458, -0.3637489974498749, -0.743965208530426, -0.2627405524253845, 0.6337881088256836, -0.8459094762802124, 0.10206053406000137, -0.944191038608551, -0.5492240190505981, -0.3592725694179535, 0.16566739976406097, -0.07611244171857834, -0.32824522256851196, -0.31523481011390686, -0.4970288872718811, 0.27890950441360474, 0.9743847846984863, -0.23408520221710205, -0.12879665195941925, -0.46301037073135376, 0.4722660481929779, 0.42842674255371094, 0.12006012350320816, 0.17689445614814758, -0.7540217041969299, 0.010267222300171852, -0.09720316529273987, -0.009761256165802479, -1.162062406539917, 0.2700500786304474, -0.11938945204019547, 0.6485465168952942, 0.6446332931518555, 0.06130099669098854, 0.5458695292472839, -0.3973561227321625, 0.8506301641464233, -0.215348020195961, -0.6885823607444763, 0.20219148695468903, -0.12741965055465698, -0.06452890485525131, 0.14608505368232727, 0.555814266204834, -0.5719867944717407, -0.5887354612350464, -0.44212883710861206, -0.4676074683666229, 0.5592181086540222, -0.02648840844631195, 0.22140009701251984, -0.17100661993026733, 0.41818833351135254, 0.403196781873703, 0.18383577466011047, -0.8395933508872986, -0.1142302006483078, -0.06953758001327515, 0.012316720560193062, 0.23253634572029114, -0.6510484218597412, -0.039996836334466934, -0.3729601204395294, 0.7864598035812378, -0.0361635684967041, 0.3405556380748749, -0.04015812277793884, -0.16568566858768463, -0.13271714746952057, -0.14569009840488434, 0.9871106743812561, 0.8946064114570618, -0.4533170461654663, 0.5666594505310059, 0.19130155444145203, -0.3705497086048126, -0.030110761523246765, -0.22569721937179565, -0.12527012825012207, 0.10235001146793365, 0.6115403771400452, 1.0565747022628784, 0.0037961730267852545, -0.5630965232849121, 0.5322683453559875, -0.041112858802080154, -0.3274931013584137, -0.696255624294281, 0.2315460741519928, 0.16104166209697723, 0.2502370774745941, 0.36932361125946045, 0.0602896474301815, 0.16759555041790009, -0.719670295715332, 0.3063295781612396, 0.4027981162071228, -0.3713959753513336, -0.4537064731121063, 0.68076491355896, -0.1822802573442459, -0.30852586030960083, 0.7385126948356628, -0.33068224787712097, -0.8455332517623901, 0.6307868361473083, 0.6202118992805481, 0.8462209701538086, -0.16308623552322388, 0.17664594948291779, 0.3553476929664612, 0.25102630257606506, -0.15815196931362152, 0.34388548135757446, 0.03818215802311897, -0.9269399046897888, -0.4196869134902954, -0.8389480113983154, -0.046515386551618576, 0.43751347064971924, -0.5496734380722046, 0.4644848108291626, -0.2896204888820648, -0.007160457316786051, -0.0967632457613945, -0.29670798778533936, -0.2762366235256195, -0.06366996467113495, 0.5142291784286499, 0.6616061925888062, -0.90278559923172, 0.7684805393218994, 0.2942562699317932, -0.31920042634010315, -0.5544421076774597, 0.30793893337249756, 0.13403011858463287, -0.9291341304779053, 0.8805391192436218, 0.38008415699005127, -0.5052586793899536, -0.09782934188842773, -0.650314450263977, -0.8841880559921265, 0.7943570613861084, 0.31407690048217773, -0.3997842073440552, -0.2180316001176834, 0.07943999767303467, 0.5931044816970825, -0.3353913426399231, 0.03224988281726837, 0.709735095500946, 0.5351125597953796, 0.5111041069030762, -0.5002881288528442, 0.11714538186788559, 0.21118180453777313, -0.3235021233558655, 0.15527209639549255, -0.4365798532962799, 0.7671598792076111, -0.6435216665267944, -0.40111979842185974, 0.09652327746152878, 0.7461370229721069, 0.3926263451576233, 0.326025128364563, 0.4943479001522064, 0.37596389651298523, 1.0658432245254517, -0.1781427264213562, 0.9765527248382568, -0.3144276440143585, 0.126827210187912, 1.0174541473388672, -0.40677326917648315, 0.710954487323761, 0.5643559694290161, 0.15572711825370789, 0.6092670559883118, 0.6664919853210449, 0.020697252824902534, 0.46044036746025085, 0.5177398324012756, -0.15319819748401642, -0.5357736349105835, 0.08553208410739899, -0.14474786818027496, 0.3959672451019287, 0.47997018694877625, -0.22783596813678741, 0.17426913976669312, 0.11871237307786942, 0.18053027987480164, -0.09603118151426315, -0.05516282469034195, 0.6899767518043518, -0.020358741283416748, -0.6345136165618896, 0.8010921478271484, -0.45138847827911377, 0.32797902822494507, -0.3143024146556854, -0.1661340743303299, -0.29869386553764343, -0.05437036603689194, -0.20519579946994781, -0.749017596244812, 0.38594821095466614, -0.15293174982070923, -0.20332373678684235, 0.06025593355298042, 0.3984586298465729, -0.4790341854095459, -0.31962502002716064, 0.4262160360813141, 0.5914051532745361, 0.7507316470146179, -0.02749168500304222, -0.23771123588085175, 0.20879152417182922, 0.0968790352344513, -0.27111348509788513, -0.08656565845012665, 0.7965956330299377, -0.036184124648571014, 0.921741247177124, 0.25555211305618286, 0.38356807827949524, 0.5584006309509277, 0.19775325059890747, 0.4771479368209839, -0.7002383470535278, -0.09034842997789383, -1.080080270767212, 0.2227083146572113, -0.13003671169281006, -0.12729522585868835, 0.706540048122406, 0.5583153963088989, 0.5484979748725891, 0.00605227192863822, 0.51610267162323, 0.11264379322528839, 0.635223388671875, -0.9683550596237183, 0.7177584767341614, -0.6356281042098999, 0.5818608999252319, 0.20669203996658325, -0.9833167791366577, -0.30824679136276245, 0.5685380697250366, -0.20956559479236603, 0.02705780416727066, 1.0293002128601074, 0.88553786277771, 0.13606111705303192, 0.12257864326238632, 0.6417252421379089, 0.8075855374336243, 0.048402316868305206, 0.28574731945991516, 1.2204341888427734, 0.01536672841757536, 0.2593497335910797, -0.09545659273862839, -0.07759708911180496, -0.41381779313087463, -0.7337065935134888, -0.9316489696502686, -0.8232468366622925, -0.3204159438610077, -0.4663085639476776, 0.03655819967389107, 0.7335270643234253, 0.43075037002563477, -0.9075791835784912, -0.3116104006767273, -0.00958744715899229, 0.4067758619785309, -0.06595592200756073, -0.2778913080692291, 0.455785870552063, -0.4867335259914398, -0.4612570106983185, 0.09546506404876709, 0.284775972366333, 0.19108733534812927, -0.44358548521995544, -0.06422627717256546, -0.17804774641990662, 0.2913450300693512, 0.4724765419960022, -0.06723696738481522, -1.0180835723876953, -0.5885499119758606, 0.09092837572097778, -0.20519249141216278, 0.013988493010401726, 0.7885953783988953, -0.7610108852386475, 0.18185116350650787, 0.3846931457519531, 0.5571944117546082, 0.45662614703178406, -0.25016140937805176, 0.24187606573104858, -0.3433490991592407, -0.010237119160592556, 0.19106914103031158, 0.38507214188575745, 0.39081889390945435, -0.4200749397277832, 0.48847660422325134, 0.4926818907260895, -0.646913468837738, -1.0653705596923828, 0.31188297271728516, -0.8954293131828308, -0.42708444595336914, 1.3790249824523926, 0.29719704389572144, -0.400443434715271, -0.14304180443286896, -0.1560250073671341, 0.4037393629550934, -0.03320879116654396, 1.156341552734375, 1.064078450202942, -0.3645874261856079, -0.10805974155664444, -0.8338901400566101, 0.654640257358551, 0.2166522592306137, -0.599810004234314, 0.4262986481189728, 0.7258586883544922, 0.046310052275657654, 0.3308590352535248, 0.3150167465209961, 0.13464736938476562, -0.005014864727854729, -0.00602853624150157, -0.04158288985490799, 0.2423086017370224, -0.6302675008773804, -0.26741957664489746, 0.3563704788684845, 0.18579339981079102, -0.02992413565516472 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20005v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20005v1
Large Language Model based Situational Dialogues for Second Language Learning
2024-03-29T06:43:55
2024-03-29T06:43:55
Shuyao Xu, Long Qin, Tianyang Chen, Zhenzhou Zha, Bingxue Qiu, Weizhi Wang
cs.CL
cs.CL
In second language learning, scenario-based conversation practice is important for language learners to achieve fluency in speaking, but students often lack sufficient opportunities to practice their conversational skills with qualified instructors or native speakers. To bridge this gap, we propose situational dialogue models for students to engage in conversational practice. Our situational dialogue models are fine-tuned on large language models (LLMs), with the aim of combining the engaging nature of an open-ended conversation with the focused practice of scenario-based tasks. Leveraging the generalization capabilities of LLMs, we demonstrate that our situational dialogue models perform effectively not only on training topics but also on topics not encountered during training. This offers a promising solution to support a wide range of conversational topics without extensive manual work. Additionally, research in the field of dialogue systems still lacks reliable automatic evaluation metrics, leading to human evaluation as the gold standard (Smith et al., 2022), which is typically expensive. To address the limitations of existing evaluation methods, we present a novel automatic evaluation method that employs fine-tuned LLMs to efficiently and effectively assess the performance of situational dialogue models.
[ -0.12437160313129425, -0.885317325592041, 0.5316059589385986, 0.07361994683742523, -0.16954299807548523, 0.30390265583992004, -0.3808544874191284, -0.27618473768234253, -0.16867545247077942, 0.49218103289604187, -0.4135945439338684, -0.4184601306915283, -0.2751220464706421, -0.11602424830198288, -0.11272385716438293, 0.7611304521560669, 0.0880969911813736, 0.3516821265220642, -0.1964600384235382, -0.12711364030838013, -0.8443157076835632, -0.482658326625824, -1.0872772932052612, -0.4885639548301697, 0.2360333502292633, 0.628654420375824, 0.5323617458343506, -0.01695253513753414, 0.328459233045578, 0.3617194890975952, -0.14190776646137238, 0.15649792551994324, -0.3545312285423279, 0.13636043667793274, -0.2648955285549164, -0.33415791392326355, -0.18644726276397705, 0.03214820846915245, 0.7638062834739685, 0.8179188966751099, -0.4297909736633301, -0.026162249967455864, -0.001118169049732387, 0.3607824742794037, -0.18142257630825043, 0.2570064067840576, -0.5460262894630432, 0.1612035483121872, 0.34033137559890747, -0.019015660509467125, -0.45792296528816223, -0.20926164090633392, 0.38795650005340576, -0.2893761992454529, -0.010333213023841381, -0.20253527164459229, 0.4091566205024719, -0.013930002227425575, -0.6013478636741638, -0.24007287621498108, -0.8742430806159973, 0.7436974048614502, -0.7028269171714783, 0.41044652462005615, 0.3108695149421692, 0.594147264957428, -0.2837882936000824, -0.5209430456161499, -0.5519553422927856, -0.6761239171028137, 0.044012777507305145, 0.12427004426717758, 0.13995839655399323, 0.17022591829299927, 0.21042819321155548, 0.31797918677330017, -0.45457321405410767, 0.36463266611099243, -0.265806645154953, -0.14826571941375732, 0.4826279878616333, 0.45187705755233765, 0.3274964988231659, -0.0983884334564209, -0.1224173977971077, -0.06053198128938675, -0.4671640396118164, 0.1814572960138321, 0.3250468969345093, 0.36569109559059143, -0.3170989453792572, 0.48290830850601196, -0.1780640035867691, 0.8083139061927795, -0.2563107907772064, -0.23194320499897003, 0.017998000606894493, -0.20750410854816437, -0.04029223322868347, -0.4781777262687683, 0.5564698576927185, 0.46357473731040955, 0.21500608325004578, -0.08055853843688965, -0.2542184293270111, -0.10397668927907944, 0.12808287143707275, -0.9024595022201538, -0.2237713485956192, 0.22840045392513275, -0.257138192653656, -0.3158893287181854, -0.1767323613166809, -0.8102514743804932, -0.21546496450901031, -0.46234965324401855, 0.25773563981056213, -0.2178037017583847, -0.39851805567741394, 0.005394704174250364, 0.13133087754249573, 0.31215330958366394, 0.6269259452819824, -0.8331233263015747, 0.4165269136428833, 0.6658300161361694, 0.8893574476242065, -0.13532233238220215, -0.15517190098762512, -0.7591853737831116, 0.05516161024570465, -0.5566133856773376, 0.6114383339881897, -0.5930660367012024, -0.7262758016586304, 0.30075013637542725, -0.10103999078273773, -0.0845625251531601, -0.6543198823928833, 0.3814549148082733, -0.40220046043395996, 0.3428354859352112, 0.16769732534885406, -0.506824791431427, -0.04345409944653511, 0.5223733186721802, -0.42526775598526, 0.7381830811500549, 0.22898660600185394, -0.30856257677078247, 0.002287359209731221, -0.7879036664962769, -0.5794046521186829, 0.34485238790512085, -0.2853042781352997, -0.31970417499542236, 0.02913225069642067, -0.20127637684345245, 0.33458054065704346, -0.2670888602733612, 0.5410786271095276, -0.22775888442993164, -0.29309582710266113, 0.39103028178215027, -0.5700626969337463, 0.44095924496650696, 0.23745648562908173, -0.036533206701278687, 0.1620502918958664, -0.39592868089675903, 0.33283790946006775, 0.1340479999780655, -0.4903181493282318, -0.13846012949943542, -0.01058930903673172, 0.20523904263973236, 0.3518921732902527, 0.1741698831319809, -0.18342310190200806, 0.3060508370399475, -0.723250687122345, 0.49780213832855225, 0.3728508949279785, 0.18710532784461975, 0.34477096796035767, -0.16229847073554993, 0.6059192419052124, 0.030433934181928635, -0.02865207940340042, -0.2478378266096115, -0.3932248055934906, -0.9527117609977722, 0.06281600147485733, 0.29149049520492554, 0.805255651473999, -0.5713352560997009, 0.21487876772880554, -0.05536408722400665, -0.39223024249076843, -0.27070170640945435, 0.3407599925994873, 0.548454225063324, 0.4061513841152191, 0.18404971063137054, -0.3243315815925598, -0.5303630828857422, -0.8568220734596252, -0.11090825498104095, -0.30745190382003784, 0.0403427854180336, 0.29969727993011475, 0.48110485076904297, -0.32008376717567444, 0.8809253573417664, -0.5103439688682556, -0.1247837096452713, -0.7219051122665405, 0.24284611642360687, 0.14443598687648773, 0.5540865063667297, 0.2475336492061615, -0.7540159821510315, -0.524205207824707, 0.05569307506084442, -0.4833676815032959, 0.2257181853055954, -0.10383187234401703, 0.1963513344526291, 0.4941554069519043, 0.6820163130760193, -0.4447227418422699, 0.15963885188102722, 0.5652577877044678, -0.2104586511850357, 0.5533450245857239, -0.4740162789821625, 0.0647026002407074, -1.2623226642608643, -0.08211880177259445, 0.20418182015419006, -0.359006404876709, -0.6627208590507507, -0.04447450861334801, -0.08381239324808121, -0.6387133002281189, -0.4498525857925415, 0.9470378160476685, -0.21564075350761414, -0.1312151402235031, -0.3503427803516388, 0.25908151268959045, -0.11569208651781082, 0.4932415783405304, 0.4536605179309845, 0.7004514336585999, 0.3413902223110199, -0.4639304578304291, 0.3401723802089691, 0.3128631114959717, -0.7289058566093445, 0.5741978287696838, -0.7062464356422424, 0.09671252965927124, 0.3087216019630432, 0.6455331444740295, -0.9112256169319153, -0.2838537395000458, 0.18043078482151031, -0.2445157766342163, 0.31366172432899475, -0.46360617876052856, -0.367044597864151, -0.3567579686641693, 0.22913022339344025, 0.19132962822914124, 0.51365065574646, -0.4075655937194824, 0.2087199091911316, 0.3211880624294281, -0.5248532295227051, -0.3403256833553314, -0.32108449935913086, 0.31801125407218933, -0.24395470321178436, -0.4629822373390198, -0.0914003849029541, -0.3081998825073242, -0.4968399405479431, -0.4773116707801819, -0.0010794935515150428, -0.22721950709819794, 0.2394765168428421, 0.20070546865463257, 0.3709111511707306, -0.06524981558322906, 0.34612777829170227, -0.028139151632785797, -0.20630910992622375, -0.10325869172811508, -0.35389259457588196, 0.6438947319984436, -0.3725998103618622, -0.4473845362663269, -0.6585233211517334, 0.5446574091911316, 0.4993910491466522, -0.22905361652374268, 0.6175797581672668, 0.4067751467227936, -0.48276248574256897, -0.2302933782339096, -0.654034435749054, -0.20558753609657288, -0.4499848484992981, 0.7790676951408386, -0.33517858386039734, -0.8987900018692017, 0.3892529308795929, -0.39268624782562256, 0.10567457228899002, 0.08543495088815689, 0.549481213092804, -0.2686062455177307, 1.0601444244384766, 0.5766106843948364, 0.06502210348844528, 0.5518811345100403, -0.3579639196395874, 0.39429864287376404, -0.7271174192428589, -0.4434906244277954, -0.33550626039505005, 0.07868760079145432, -0.2524542510509491, -0.6685453653335571, 0.19645123183727264, 0.1266426295042038, -0.1877642124891281, 0.0009498530416749418, 0.0575144998729229, 0.614202618598938, 0.36745545268058777, -0.03973308205604553, 0.17967237532138824, -0.07147691398859024, -0.16605374217033386, 0.0532722994685173, -0.5109015703201294, -0.720828652381897, 0.8776209354400635, 0.38162854313850403, 0.41219478845596313, 0.2673400938510895, 0.5674600601196289, 0.3552948534488678, 0.25100603699684143, -1.1045082807540894, 0.66438889503479, 0.03575087711215019, -0.3517887592315674, -0.5520775318145752, -0.49976542592048645, -0.8772915005683899, 0.4709134101867676, -0.10083961486816406, -0.8484026789665222, -0.300119549036026, 0.10446867346763611, -0.3672490119934082, 0.12126660346984863, -0.8203575611114502, 1.0670219659805298, -0.23372219502925873, -0.20487754046916962, -0.5476266741752625, -0.4647711217403412, 0.17237628996372223, -0.07312268763780594, 0.2895882725715637, -0.012163013219833374, 0.07901427894830704, 0.5781758427619934, -0.4991086721420288, 1.12552011013031, -0.27380144596099854, -0.2669069170951843, 0.522956371307373, 0.1537463366985321, 0.499565452337265, 0.3867855668067932, 0.035003453493118286, -0.025333497673273087, 0.014324864372611046, -0.3611243665218353, -0.6929718852043152, 0.6318069696426392, -0.685198962688446, -0.7677357196807861, -0.30720821022987366, -0.5029361248016357, -0.6126692891120911, -0.07878740131855011, -0.06358117610216141, 0.5805465579032898, -0.6344382166862488, -0.016980702057480812, 0.5989030003547668, -0.22680282592773438, 0.3443470895290375, 0.8660926222801208, -0.25528690218925476, -0.32711970806121826, 0.9287736415863037, -0.0611494779586792, 0.5468006730079651, 0.3312202990055084, 0.2076311707496643, -0.4533860385417938, -0.6913679242134094, -0.48121941089630127, 0.08762621879577637, -0.7297632098197937, -0.05134182423353195, -0.6237876415252686, -0.1943669319152832, -0.34483420848846436, -0.13132570683956146, -0.29431530833244324, -0.42269569635391235, -0.054774973541498184, -0.08088039606809616, 0.02797592431306839, 0.6106246709823608, -0.06554728001356125, 0.4357241094112396, -0.7245405912399292, 0.12954433262348175, 0.6366621851921082, 0.2742654085159302, -0.09629521518945694, -0.8227198719978333, -0.4041711390018463, 0.19940680265426636, -0.4655592441558838, -0.5008538365364075, 0.3387446105480194, 0.24631772935390472, 0.6948046088218689, 0.3796003460884094, -0.15206225216388702, 0.4836709201335907, -0.586949348449707, 0.6639650464057922, 0.36291977763175964, -0.9307383894920349, 0.8430163860321045, -0.4862639307975769, 0.1070416122674942, 0.5574522614479065, 0.006204204633831978, -0.9400231838226318, -0.30115053057670593, -0.5780776143074036, -0.6896284818649292, 0.6440883874893188, -0.18176406621932983, 0.3197130262851715, 0.023616725578904152, 0.22835677862167358, -0.1589505523443222, 0.12632368505001068, -0.7473233938217163, 0.09076156467199326, 0.029021816328167915, -0.13175885379314423, -0.4973142743110657, -0.27947017550468445, -0.4525163173675537, -0.21051250398159027, 0.5730703473091125, -0.32591572403907776, 0.015343171544373035, -0.16818782687187195, -0.16451141238212585, -0.027290720492601395, 0.550719678401947, 0.6126151084899902, 0.6040640473365784, -0.0739533007144928, -0.2843207120895386, 0.5677088499069214, -0.16058583557605743, 0.2734362483024597, 0.04909161850810051, 0.10963381826877594, -0.08480650931596756, 0.19310545921325684, 0.6835588812828064, 0.5791370868682861, -1.095363974571228, 0.6148125529289246, -0.08374760299921036, 0.06137574464082718, -0.6866716742515564, 0.21716980636119843, 0.21388813853263855, 0.45379093289375305, 0.008937610313296318, -0.03447474166750908, 0.0843871608376503, -0.7949848175048828, 0.03411245346069336, 0.5136042237281799, -0.43065714836120605, -0.15225057303905487, 0.11033900827169418, 0.6231266856193542, -0.7812701463699341, 0.7380525469779968, -0.20435650646686554, -0.5655443668365479, 0.7547106742858887, 0.6530895233154297, 0.6913710236549377, -0.4135723412036896, 0.44756242632865906, 0.5005892515182495, 0.08999145030975342, -0.3241841197013855, 0.09627469629049301, -0.09457443654537201, -0.7464160323143005, -0.38278841972351074, -0.5228382349014282, -0.9434995055198669, 0.4197579622268677, -0.5906035900115967, 0.4047570526599884, -0.38213756680488586, 0.0995161384344101, -0.3051585853099823, 0.3034888505935669, -0.5595284700393677, 0.3361310064792633, 0.279191792011261, 0.8172625303268433, -0.8392425775527954, 0.9594382047653198, 0.830328643321991, -0.17047607898712158, -0.7012181282043457, 0.018936021253466606, -0.029815789312124252, -0.5159938335418701, 0.5386892557144165, 0.3112836480140686, -0.05785105377435684, -0.21351847052574158, -0.2898217737674713, -0.4595860540866852, 0.8426165580749512, 0.24486184120178223, -0.7201328277587891, 0.04934927821159363, 0.10878567397594452, 0.7320271730422974, -0.497936874628067, 0.30885031819343567, 0.4603746831417084, 0.2269110232591629, 0.377190500497818, -0.8039820790290833, -0.3887959420681, -0.2930867373943329, 0.12943807244300842, 0.013125555589795113, -0.8016402125358582, 0.36943677067756653, -0.45998531579971313, -0.037542674690485, 0.32517483830451965, 0.654867947101593, 0.2444767951965332, 0.4015345871448517, 0.6188852787017822, 0.3896913230419159, 0.7900761961936951, 0.024235043674707413, 0.8583115339279175, -0.0775565356016159, 0.29084718227386475, 1.4603677988052368, -0.512946605682373, 1.082642912864685, 0.300049751996994, -0.10874734073877335, 0.48114827275276184, 0.8166127800941467, 0.013262764550745487, 0.3182709515094757, 0.4276902675628662, -0.42376354336738586, -0.6690065264701843, 0.037822261452674866, -0.2920747399330139, 0.5008646249771118, 0.6575008630752563, -0.0016985157271847129, 0.002795983338728547, 0.026820313185453415, -0.11883160471916199, 0.15576669573783875, -0.25528451800346375, 0.8717209696769714, 0.161269411444664, -0.986323893070221, 0.39599135518074036, 0.1444266438484192, 0.3983185291290283, -0.6501134634017944, -0.11122400313615799, -0.2559172511100769, 0.10317978262901306, 0.023666677996516228, -0.6185680031776428, 0.15012973546981812, 0.11326553672552109, 0.009724551811814308, -0.08268976956605911, 0.4292986989021301, -0.6929762959480286, -0.5749512314796448, 0.22435827553272247, 0.5459157824516296, 0.24405322968959808, 0.24331605434417725, -0.5947740077972412, -0.2280193716287613, -0.10178780555725098, -0.15123413503170013, 0.5839375257492065, 0.20945876836776733, -0.09646933525800705, 0.8132922649383545, 0.4370076060295105, -0.11218708008527756, -0.5074295997619629, 0.3940903842449188, 0.562600314617157, -0.5157157182693481, -0.5488113760948181, -0.3834020495414734, 0.5643426775932312, -0.1049237921833992, -0.3792130947113037, 0.3616819977760315, 0.719965398311615, 0.792831540107727, 0.010968313552439213, 1.0082707405090332, 0.3100755512714386, 0.592725932598114, -0.6358690857887268, 0.532012403011322, -0.47064632177352905, 0.3519192636013031, -0.10719335824251175, -0.869360625743866, -0.06329832226037979, 0.9072265028953552, -0.4418819844722748, 0.07162737846374512, 0.5292029976844788, 0.6230313777923584, -0.01792779192328453, 0.16811659932136536, 0.6404440999031067, 0.10113240778446198, 0.41288861632347107, 0.49452710151672363, 1.1652528047561646, -0.12002366036176682, 0.6256964206695557, 0.027909494936466217, -0.2644636332988739, -0.4061289131641388, -0.7021558880805969, -1.0980144739151, -0.7024778127670288, -0.4961458742618561, -0.2978532910346985, 0.29173803329467773, 1.1214728355407715, 0.7453476786613464, -0.7356609106063843, -0.5076183676719666, -0.10259067267179489, 0.02058691903948784, 0.020295090973377228, -0.2041044682264328, 0.04427337273955345, -0.56009441614151, -1.0267544984817505, 0.6965436339378357, 0.11647002398967743, 0.31161513924598694, -0.32343992590904236, -0.35560330748558044, 0.0024162898771464825, 0.15502959489822388, 0.6771985292434692, 0.3975825011730194, -0.6802456974983215, -0.3008419871330261, -0.4531623125076294, -0.0420861653983593, -0.11544448882341385, 1.0109891891479492, -0.6802242994308472, 0.3300451636314392, 0.05423378571867943, 0.6117415428161621, 0.4419812560081482, -0.2374303638935089, 0.6741124391555786, -0.5644745826721191, 0.41909855604171753, 0.37344929575920105, 0.34106534719467163, 0.4521496295928955, -0.1252562552690506, 0.48061349987983704, 0.1626339852809906, -0.44900867342948914, -0.946460485458374, 0.5137172937393188, -0.8763964772224426, -0.17765092849731445, 1.2277047634124756, -0.3426409065723419, 0.5265036821365356, -0.19601547718048096, -0.24985742568969727, 0.1874651461839676, -0.3639684021472931, 0.6866288781166077, 0.7001234889030457, -0.015505403280258179, -0.0909760370850563, -0.7919036149978638, 0.2942725718021393, 0.550775408744812, -0.9753054976463318, 0.03365031257271767, 0.5598733425140381, 0.42597460746765137, -0.0719166100025177, 0.512493371963501, 0.17639900743961334, 0.22257277369499207, -0.26502904295921326, -0.19788715243339539, 0.24029217660427094, -0.4679718017578125, -0.4488983154296875, -0.06073368340730667, 0.2218286097049713, 0.032098013907670975 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19995v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19995v1
Development of Compositionality and Generalization through Interactive Learning of Language and Action of Robots
2024-03-29T06:22:37
2024-03-29T06:22:37
Prasanna Vijayaraghavan, Jeffrey Frederic Queisser, Sergio Verduzco Flores, Jun Tani
cs.AI
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.RO, 68T35, 68T40, I.2.9
Humans excel at applying learned behavior to unlearned situations. A crucial component of this generalization behavior is our ability to compose/decompose a whole into reusable parts, an attribute known as compositionality. One of the fundamental questions in robotics concerns this characteristic. "How can linguistic compositionality be developed concomitantly with sensorimotor skills through associative learning, particularly when individuals only learn partial linguistic compositions and their corresponding sensorimotor patterns?" To address this question, we propose a brain-inspired neural network model that integrates vision, proprioception, and language into a framework of predictive coding and active inference, based on the free-energy principle. The effectiveness and capabilities of this model were assessed through various simulation experiments conducted with a robot arm. Our results show that generalization in learning to unlearned verb-noun compositions, is significantly enhanced when training variations of task composition are increased. We attribute this to self-organized compositional structures in linguistic latent state space being influenced significantly by sensorimotor learning. Ablation studies show that visual attention and working memory are essential to accurately generate visuo-motor sequences to achieve linguistically represented goals. These insights advance our understanding of mechanisms underlying development of compositionality through interactions of linguistic and sensorimotor experience.
[ 0.046386126428842545, -0.7182978987693787, 0.5302395820617676, -0.11048353463411331, -0.09061650931835175, 0.15916000306606293, -0.42358314990997314, -0.2643586993217468, 0.49852630496025085, 0.3743857443332672, -0.3977493941783905, -0.2577941119670868, -0.2987806797027588, -0.22047248482704163, -0.16904419660568237, 0.8250035643577576, -0.014525589533150196, -0.010085460729897022, -0.15436753630638123, -0.026801368221640587, -0.43001946806907654, -0.437381774187088, -0.35216546058654785, -0.6601411700248718, 0.5879015922546387, 0.01594272255897522, 0.570178747177124, 0.9401679635047913, 0.45481154322624207, 0.5071454048156738, 0.11425571143627167, 0.20999601483345032, -0.046989552676677704, 0.18282511830329895, -0.18804195523262024, -0.7509677410125732, -0.18175695836544037, -0.11385349184274673, 0.5995035171508789, 1.0809428691864014, -0.26510244607925415, -0.3299110531806946, 0.12662619352340698, 0.5593351721763611, -0.5803449153900146, 0.4380738437175751, -0.5111722946166992, 0.28820717334747314, 0.44195756316185, -0.07720234245061874, -0.11789863556623459, 0.1441420018672943, -0.05004439502954483, -0.6838632822036743, 0.30618488788604736, -0.31498783826828003, 0.40828409790992737, 0.38444069027900696, -0.29964950680732727, -0.2553730607032776, -0.8510757684707642, 0.6421175599098206, -0.3133871555328369, 0.42180848121643066, 0.3102572560310364, -0.09689141064882278, -0.23512881994247437, -0.4363749027252197, -0.7749289274215698, -0.22744137048721313, -0.1452070027589798, 0.45454561710357666, -0.1820615828037262, 0.36019495129585266, -0.06218048185110092, -0.08145000785589218, -0.6240500807762146, -0.003053209511563182, -0.5281058549880981, -0.08411897718906403, 0.529625415802002, 0.16823096573352814, 0.7770283818244934, -0.16034860908985138, -0.2410643994808197, -0.3741776943206787, -0.08913186937570572, -0.050420112907886505, 0.5009948015213013, 0.4668138027191162, -0.21154481172561646, 0.6658602356910706, -0.20298919081687927, 0.6516631841659546, -0.06344466656446457, 0.13476289808750153, 0.26473015546798706, -0.2786184847354889, -0.12153324484825134, -0.06822940707206726, 0.9079431891441345, 0.3008289933204651, 0.2938244342803955, -0.6140630841255188, -0.21627277135849, 0.5478748083114624, 0.6622506976127625, -0.24156460165977478, -0.440889447927475, 0.19965878129005432, -0.3508974015712738, -0.1466946303844452, 0.3528706729412079, -0.27214279770851135, -0.12846027314662933, -0.6682426929473877, 0.6044830083847046, -0.4503655731678009, -0.407362699508667, 0.32027003169059753, -0.16086357831954956, 0.002055044285953045, 0.05538694187998772, -1.3004083633422852, 0.2997412085533142, 0.7731447219848633, 0.6937695741653442, -0.3186817169189453, -0.6182197332382202, 0.028765954077243805, 0.3083447217941284, -0.4382655620574951, 0.617576003074646, -0.5226888656616211, -0.24043534696102142, -0.09497318416833878, 0.029639074578881264, -0.5330770611763, -0.6269770264625549, -0.2536853849887848, -0.4532051086425781, 0.1806122362613678, 0.17602194845676422, -0.4434744119644165, -0.5649517178535461, -0.06204044446349144, -0.7954714894294739, 0.3565995395183563, 0.2915225028991699, -0.2057981640100479, 0.20315822958946228, -0.9316637516021729, -0.7374000549316406, 0.02370569482445717, -0.23206596076488495, -0.04486306011676788, 0.35336098074913025, -0.38645583391189575, 0.3831576704978943, 0.1823340654373169, 0.23485790193080902, 0.19974610209465027, -0.16301608085632324, 0.5218480229377747, -0.05375196784734726, 0.4272322952747345, 0.011543884873390198, -0.3383592367172241, 0.38228708505630493, -0.622522234916687, -0.14496494829654694, 0.02474665455520153, -0.3701748251914978, -0.251952201128006, 0.12833942472934723, -0.3919188380241394, 0.041760414838790894, 0.28918081521987915, -0.5195103883743286, -0.10766122490167618, -0.6988058090209961, 0.2539372444152832, 0.5908090472221375, 0.17097774147987366, 0.9035263061523438, -0.4234432876110077, 0.505348265171051, 0.059560421854257584, -0.07724647969007492, -0.13192065060138702, -0.16722296178340912, -0.8739424347877502, 0.006398632191121578, -0.19075296819210052, 0.5738766193389893, -0.668555736541748, 0.747980535030365, -0.10114360600709915, -0.3543834984302521, -0.11272002756595612, 0.3704646825790405, 0.41719263792037964, 0.43295615911483765, 0.3055185377597809, -0.6695464253425598, -0.5017039179801941, -0.6983078122138977, 0.12488744407892227, -0.16537317633628845, -0.31039199233055115, 0.021266350522637367, 0.38465559482574463, -0.1602230817079544, 0.6075434684753418, -0.3769262135028839, -0.12586407363414764, -0.25547266006469727, 0.13031640648841858, 0.07909233123064041, 0.6938533186912537, 0.3353177011013031, -0.5948740839958191, -0.10643336176872253, 0.3502153158187866, -1.0762386322021484, 0.29479581117630005, -0.11637533456087112, -0.2133866846561432, 0.052635543048381805, 0.2528887689113617, -0.7969826459884644, 0.15448689460754395, 0.5048167705535889, -0.28977373242378235, 0.1008128970861435, -0.4050751328468323, -0.12088939547538757, -0.9433205127716064, 0.04057954251766205, -0.23495738208293915, 0.4205469489097595, -0.7075414657592773, 0.18537361919879913, -0.3025447130203247, -0.1515994817018509, -0.4669458270072937, 0.31448042392730713, -0.3942563533782959, -0.135425865650177, -0.7726508378982544, -0.14206691086292267, -0.07369592785835266, 0.8571175932884216, 0.24410171806812286, 0.39685043692588806, 0.5682352781295776, -0.8784048557281494, 0.4262147545814514, 0.037613458931446075, -0.18973490595817566, 0.16965645551681519, -0.765762984752655, 0.01731722243130207, -0.3487120270729065, -0.23227529227733612, -0.8103164434432983, -0.32281461358070374, 0.23568090796470642, -0.4816010594367981, 0.30135175585746765, 0.27114632725715637, -0.26348066329956055, -0.14066949486732483, 0.15687711536884308, 0.2214203178882599, 0.4402894377708435, 0.038186121731996536, 1.0093755722045898, 0.22729218006134033, 0.1460047960281372, -0.34445884823799133, -0.7891861796379089, -0.32334721088409424, 0.14570896327495575, -0.4447546899318695, 0.18925942480564117, -0.14239953458309174, -0.3415709435939789, 0.01681915484368801, -0.13516196608543396, -0.014416240155696869, 0.216410294175148, 0.28621289134025574, 0.2583521902561188, -0.06024577096104622, 0.2057960033416748, 0.03874627500772476, -0.01716509647667408, 0.22200492024421692, -0.21740269660949707, 0.8280373811721802, 0.1396637111902237, -0.37745827436447144, -0.38875076174736023, 0.4434089660644531, 0.4529280364513397, -0.26488763093948364, 0.6352484822273254, 0.3842577040195465, -0.30321717262268066, -0.16109015047550201, 0.045993853360414505, -0.6189846992492676, -0.4881317615509033, 0.5050347447395325, -0.15048804879188538, -0.7384731769561768, 0.5887826681137085, 0.15250630676746368, -0.13001404702663422, 0.11169539391994476, 0.5350788831710815, -0.2892732620239258, 0.7040189504623413, 0.7523310780525208, 0.29128554463386536, 0.7798858880996704, -0.577073872089386, -0.07060743868350983, -0.8103950023651123, -0.42841780185699463, -0.01680293120443821, -0.6743423342704773, -0.5824049711227417, -0.6873811483383179, 0.17079445719718933, -0.29210299253463745, -0.37616705894470215, 0.515645444393158, -0.4807033836841583, 0.5447686910629272, 0.6416015625, 0.4950748383998871, -0.048352863639593124, 0.09662428498268127, -0.37207552790641785, 0.2171972692012787, -0.541539192199707, -0.3640890121459961, 1.0148615837097168, -0.14194297790527344, 0.5786527991294861, 0.08623309433460236, 0.6466553807258606, 0.17197364568710327, -0.10665050148963928, -0.9864301085472107, 0.5967990756034851, -0.27510347962379456, -0.47202396392822266, -0.11875907331705093, -0.13243526220321655, -1.151496410369873, 0.28022128343582153, -0.10709109902381897, -0.6454991102218628, 0.2663077414035797, 0.10217510908842087, -0.23874522745609283, 0.3059242069721222, -0.6071678996086121, 0.7979190349578857, -0.43026065826416016, -0.40190666913986206, -0.2967500388622284, -0.9415795803070068, -0.09352527558803558, -0.00855903048068285, -0.002487662946805358, -0.06567338109016418, -0.3184286057949066, 0.59675133228302, -0.11341078579425812, 1.224805474281311, -0.24102769792079926, -0.10980274528265, 0.5154774188995361, 0.18208831548690796, 0.05075550079345703, -0.5993907451629639, -0.0018541604513302445, -0.03156929463148117, -0.7204306125640869, -0.37063243985176086, -0.8963348269462585, 0.28684937953948975, -1.1114929914474487, -0.267938494682312, -0.05037352442741394, -0.5868368148803711, -0.08271870762109756, 0.18601788580417633, 0.08635295182466507, 0.02271573804318905, -0.2904701232910156, 0.11406213790178299, 0.6702474355697632, 0.18312542140483856, 0.631267249584198, 0.45810219645500183, 0.09969528019428253, -0.47137609124183655, 0.9167077541351318, -0.13354016840457916, 0.3448020815849304, 0.7995589971542358, 0.2190694659948349, 0.1076539158821106, -0.23929251730442047, -0.07747363299131393, 0.2345011681318283, -0.5238840579986572, -0.1417793482542038, -0.6633274555206299, -0.18602626025676727, 0.007544389460235834, -0.35589832067489624, -0.4643150269985199, -0.37046584486961365, -0.4872628152370453, -0.31556838750839233, 0.05534372851252556, 0.8975384831428528, -0.3257107734680176, 0.7276709079742432, -0.5175318717956543, 0.3562968969345093, 0.4166570007801056, -0.048432450741529465, 0.330351859331131, -0.3393699526786804, -0.3979327976703644, 0.3104954659938812, -0.44347313046455383, -0.5281567573547363, 0.2927822470664978, 0.29051828384399414, 0.65935879945755, 0.4486222565174103, -0.28163406252861023, 0.13338713347911835, -0.3518361449241638, 0.6866447329521179, 0.4619813561439514, -0.7234415411949158, 0.68114173412323, -0.5236008167266846, 0.3346497118473053, 0.25148943066596985, 0.4678947329521179, -0.4797760844230652, -0.23407240211963654, -0.5606619715690613, -0.8470633029937744, 0.30919596552848816, -0.10767783969640732, 0.592842161655426, -0.20540288090705872, 0.3071448802947998, 0.19081872701644897, 0.4050524830818176, -0.7668569684028625, 0.020839769393205643, -0.3939063847064972, -0.3070424199104309, -0.1735590249300003, 0.2038675993680954, -0.13037662208080292, -0.21337725222110748, 0.1430061310529709, -0.3846907913684845, 0.6137171387672424, 0.011768070980906487, 0.04163156449794769, -0.2536701560020447, -0.033928535878658295, 0.6623319983482361, 0.4722763001918793, 0.31104084849357605, 0.029947008937597275, -0.2995922863483429, -0.44086241722106934, 0.285817414522171, -0.3230387568473816, -0.22280491888523102, -0.27614814043045044, 0.42977312207221985, 0.8923050165176392, 0.18602430820465088, -0.5409829020500183, 0.292295902967453, 0.2916474938392639, -0.25819671154022217, -0.1918431520462036, 0.6233303546905518, 0.11986660957336426, 0.3829650282859802, 0.36783817410469055, 0.3847440183162689, 0.0013449527323246002, -0.7557937502861023, 0.19416385889053345, 0.33587661385536194, -0.4981159567832947, -0.7520373463630676, 0.5940477252006531, -0.07565212994813919, -0.1757224202156067, 0.4947742223739624, 0.015485159121453762, -0.47208908200263977, 0.8346523642539978, 0.5749725103378296, 0.9201316833496094, -0.42279770970344543, 0.160735085606575, 0.2813584506511688, 0.2605838179588318, 0.08810318261384964, 0.5784837007522583, -0.3951874375343323, -1.2510387897491455, -0.45829451084136963, -0.7063760161399841, -0.3044157922267914, -0.3354850709438324, -0.3479391634464264, -0.13314466178417206, -0.6159539818763733, -0.05819643661379814, -0.18611009418964386, -0.26547980308532715, -0.49776872992515564, 0.37478166818618774, 0.11724866926670074, 0.05869646742939949, -1.071521520614624, 0.44380855560302734, 1.016756296157837, -0.6698786616325378, -0.9644540548324585, -0.10195218026638031, -0.3384503722190857, -0.8235791921615601, 0.785483717918396, 0.09682328999042511, -0.25315019488334656, -0.1718253791332245, -0.6369257569313049, -0.7412800192832947, 0.9707080125808716, 0.27695751190185547, -0.18949207663536072, -0.12361230701208115, 0.16526679694652557, 0.7258409857749939, -0.507607638835907, -0.05227335914969444, 0.16099794209003448, 0.24362176656723022, 0.18388499319553375, -0.6212970614433289, -0.18314474821090698, -0.3197169601917267, 0.03806505724787712, 0.22076116502285004, -0.8896309733390808, 0.8839795589447021, -0.22657321393489838, -0.10509487986564636, 0.2189933806657791, 0.7954906225204468, -0.08346898853778839, 0.1123691201210022, 0.06548751145601273, 0.5032602548599243, 0.5317317247390747, 0.14106285572052002, 0.6717454195022583, -0.3092806041240692, -0.09806431084871292, 0.9151725172996521, -0.2122412919998169, 0.7422968745231628, 0.49344801902770996, -0.1081295907497406, 0.8831436038017273, 0.013296602293848991, -0.006314203143119812, 0.6916406154632568, 0.41803163290023804, -0.582265317440033, -0.13318029046058655, -0.2507633566856384, 0.16863027215003967, 1.184865117073059, 0.3631151616573334, -0.557182252407074, 0.19602185487747192, 0.502109706401825, -0.061389483511447906, 0.4608088731765747, -0.1878858208656311, 1.0662965774536133, -0.08732642233371735, -0.660224199295044, 0.15166015923023224, -0.28014159202575684, 0.7256606817245483, -0.7309519648551941, 0.03916159272193909, -0.06634561717510223, 0.1746848225593567, -0.15678440034389496, -0.6201399564743042, 0.3660481572151184, -0.5025734901428223, -0.3309318721294403, -0.14498375356197357, 0.6130642294883728, -0.43578752875328064, -0.2267424762248993, 0.31393691897392273, 0.7843374609947205, 0.2095324695110321, 0.05901481211185455, -0.20896559953689575, 0.03438252583146095, -0.06735259294509888, -0.06790381669998169, 0.28499534726142883, 0.3559848964214325, 0.22106948494911194, 0.5297372937202454, 0.6126187443733215, 0.2200886756181717, -0.040776576846838, -0.03621835634112358, 0.8520747423171997, -0.6667845249176025, -0.32107803225517273, -0.6724709868431091, 0.649078369140625, 0.3027684688568115, -0.050514474511146545, 0.2597820460796356, 0.4721416234970093, 1.0288881063461304, -0.3968123495578766, 0.6891129016876221, -0.10565914213657379, 0.07491496950387955, -0.4860849678516388, 0.8974557518959045, -0.46800100803375244, -0.36819592118263245, -0.035165440291166306, -0.9173680543899536, -0.41945773363113403, 0.9166427254676819, -0.049177832901477814, 0.3492545187473297, 0.7001246213912964, 0.5997005105018616, -0.05180293694138527, -0.12616105377674103, 0.5468873977661133, -0.1608390510082245, -0.026682138442993164, 0.3940044939517975, 0.5828518867492676, -0.34888139367103577, 0.16431525349617004, -0.6294384002685547, -0.16470499336719513, 0.15886624157428741, -0.4477863609790802, -0.6977129578590393, -0.6630758047103882, -0.398898184299469, 0.13874562084674835, 0.03525819629430771, 0.8263571858406067, 0.591133177280426, -0.5426051616668701, -0.6630323529243469, -0.5897979140281677, -0.11916004866361618, -0.25289466977119446, -0.21074727177619934, 0.053424250334501266, -0.5090224146842957, -0.6851022839546204, 0.536642849445343, 0.2948543131351471, 0.31768932938575745, -0.26558616757392883, -0.0029020505025982857, -0.09557367116212845, -0.18954871594905853, 0.7016827464103699, 0.4469391107559204, -0.41368067264556885, -0.1441776603460312, 0.2903206944465637, 0.12516732513904572, 0.11713211238384247, 0.8776669502258301, -0.6202551126480103, 0.5822947025299072, 0.3737425208091736, 0.5386714339256287, 0.08806437253952026, -0.08937856554985046, 0.7024291157722473, -0.7966166138648987, 0.2518080770969391, 0.3606034815311432, 0.39343497157096863, 0.4502818286418915, -0.26909688115119934, 0.44331154227256775, 0.4454078674316406, -0.46335679292678833, -0.09690701216459274, 0.41173413395881653, -1.0438367128372192, -0.1949535757303238, 0.8427172899246216, 0.059469692409038544, -0.5790700316429138, 0.1717604100704193, -0.027732132002711296, 0.6751320362091064, -0.24093098938465118, 0.6061389446258545, 0.5184059739112854, -0.6072413325309753, -0.13016577064990997, -0.1819983571767807, -0.03658577427268028, 0.4367680251598358, -0.5426364541053772, -0.011306816712021828, 0.57394939661026, 0.14879974722862244, 0.50242680311203, 0.23820099234580994, 0.15799680352210999, 0.36026203632354736, 0.2348991483449936, 0.5500950813293457, 0.11569652706384659, -0.4795759320259094, -0.1020113006234169, 0.07433576136827469, -0.08574720472097397, -0.4775547981262207 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19962v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19962v1
Enhancing the General Agent Capabilities of Low-Parameter LLMs through Tuning and Multi-Branch Reasoning
2024-03-29T03:48:12
2024-03-29T03:48:12
Qinhao Zhou, Zihan Zhang, Xiang Xiang, Ke Wang, Yuchuan Wu, Yongbin Li
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
Open-source pre-trained Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibit strong language understanding and generation capabilities, making them highly successful in a variety of tasks. However, when used as agents for dealing with complex problems in the real world, their performance is far inferior to large commercial models such as ChatGPT and GPT-4. As intelligent agents, LLMs need to have the capabilities of task planning, long-term memory, and the ability to leverage external tools to achieve satisfactory performance. Various methods have been proposed to enhance the agent capabilities of LLMs. On the one hand, methods involve constructing agent-specific data and fine-tuning the models. On the other hand, some methods focus on designing prompts that effectively activate the reasoning abilities of the LLMs. We explore both strategies on the 7B and 13B models. We propose a comprehensive method for constructing agent-specific data using GPT-4. Through supervised fine-tuning with constructed data, we find that for these models with a relatively small number of parameters, supervised fine-tuning can significantly reduce hallucination outputs and formatting errors in agent tasks. Furthermore, techniques such as multi-path reasoning and task decomposition can effectively decrease problem complexity and enhance the performance of LLMs as agents. We evaluate our method on five agent tasks of AgentBench and achieve satisfactory results.
[ -0.7066208124160767, -0.9023841023445129, 0.7845515608787537, -0.18028970062732697, -0.2444380670785904, 0.19001665711402893, -0.5641024112701416, -0.5092577338218689, 0.0905579999089241, 0.7697617411613464, -0.6053752899169922, -0.563185453414917, -0.2607966959476471, 0.05902552977204323, 0.09740784019231796, 0.8981922268867493, 0.07384639233350754, -0.007193251978605986, -0.00601950753480196, 0.12248295545578003, -0.4214697480201721, -0.45446306467056274, -0.8554741740226746, -0.4002589285373688, 0.5704990029335022, 0.458702027797699, 0.9045544862747192, 0.6901080012321472, 0.43939605355262756, 0.39318349957466125, 0.010972329415380955, 0.8723888993263245, -0.5204836130142212, 0.2689482271671295, -0.45457956194877625, -0.46283623576164246, -0.7708489298820496, -0.08682221919298172, 0.4476131796836853, 0.3198421597480774, 0.11546894162893295, -0.0939723551273346, -0.003829753492027521, 0.4902271032333374, -0.32217109203338623, 0.435813307762146, -0.8249439597129822, -0.36674121022224426, -0.09240005910396576, -0.44756343960762024, -0.3633843660354614, -0.23730424046516418, -0.23512983322143555, -0.6007157564163208, 0.2793205976486206, -0.008209341205656528, 0.9154577255249023, 0.526055097579956, -0.2798992693424225, -0.34114909172058105, -0.8190531134605408, 0.6304951310157776, -0.7803435921669006, 0.17273057997226715, 0.3621371388435364, 0.3473937213420868, -0.4490634500980377, -0.4366424083709717, -0.1403285712003708, -0.4842126965522766, 0.005126177333295345, -0.16696003079414368, 0.012787689454853535, 0.4393225312232971, 0.43737074732780457, 0.027072476223111153, -0.4383935332298279, 0.27049946784973145, -0.19652095437049866, -0.4020726680755615, 0.5537840723991394, 0.3128567636013031, 0.027319759130477905, 0.15727101266384125, 0.1680540144443512, -0.1347227245569229, -0.6995910406112671, 0.07862478494644165, 0.5638687014579773, 0.7674473524093628, 0.38036206364631653, 0.5045625567436218, -0.4778604805469513, 0.7226651310920715, 0.14759576320648193, -0.20386643707752228, -0.1365852952003479, -0.5066598057746887, -0.10544467717409134, -0.2010263204574585, 0.3959868252277374, -0.024582725018262863, 0.5057335495948792, -0.35888999700546265, -0.38996240496635437, 0.1720377802848816, 0.36833712458610535, -0.8455361127853394, -0.0389016717672348, 0.15119512379169464, -0.21087123453617096, -0.12445968389511108, -0.22153763473033905, -0.4339071214199066, -0.3883987367153168, -0.7337135672569275, 0.37087780237197876, -0.5676213502883911, -0.039480097591876984, 0.04762423038482666, -0.05721411481499672, 0.3019569218158722, 0.5387821197509766, -0.7416442632675171, 0.27867522835731506, 0.5885937213897705, 0.5659724473953247, 0.022606315091252327, -0.2813819348812103, -0.6272827386856079, 0.2997434139251709, -0.5019851326942444, 0.965912938117981, -0.717607855796814, -0.0923382118344307, -0.2153484970331192, 0.11126577109098434, 0.030211282894015312, -0.6846499443054199, 0.3765871524810791, -0.3743584156036377, -0.26866769790649414, -0.2664029598236084, -0.35128456354141235, -0.09392768889665604, 0.32521820068359375, -0.5231372117996216, 0.671532928943634, 0.08662433177232742, -0.24180415272712708, 0.1772068291902542, -0.6594928503036499, -0.37657061219215393, -0.022968070581555367, -0.15990690886974335, -0.30427873134613037, 0.16252081096172333, 0.5664598941802979, 0.6059579849243164, -0.3114950954914093, 0.18119655549526215, -0.2846515476703644, -0.46927183866500854, -0.02965482324361801, -0.31686142086982727, 0.32025039196014404, 0.24272482097148895, -0.22020600736141205, 0.47867724299430847, -0.5085386037826538, 0.31176918745040894, -0.005098959896713495, -0.2915419638156891, -0.14953909814357758, 0.12634587287902832, -0.3580024540424347, 0.060434211045503616, 0.19052597880363464, -0.05191084370017052, 0.4453967809677124, -0.5351069569587708, 0.3862254023551941, 0.775703489780426, -0.013747512362897396, 0.41883325576782227, -0.6137411594390869, 0.5306691527366638, -0.01581496000289917, 0.07149647921323776, -0.04398657754063606, -0.414970725774765, -0.7340860366821289, -0.4702144265174866, 0.03337773308157921, 0.400918185710907, -0.9711658954620361, 0.3911624848842621, -0.07257580757141113, -0.6243190765380859, -0.5414355993270874, 0.39562684297561646, 0.18841898441314697, 0.17087335884571075, 0.46945592761039734, -0.06008607894182205, -0.28050482273101807, -0.8497045040130615, -0.22161705791950226, 0.01297795306891203, -0.02719411440193653, 0.41959524154663086, 0.37239888310432434, -0.30239537358283997, 0.8324851989746094, -0.3745608329772949, -0.1864502727985382, -0.3314779996871948, 0.02488645911216736, 0.1744319647550583, 0.3196627199649811, 0.4011264443397522, -0.42331549525260925, -0.3035561144351959, 0.15918967127799988, -0.527113676071167, -0.07575159519910812, -0.02724805660545826, -0.18902549147605896, 0.2684440016746521, 0.5208534598350525, -0.9312336444854736, 0.256026953458786, 0.16222546994686127, -0.3994262218475342, 0.5892752408981323, -0.42550188302993774, 0.04524587094783783, -0.8535203337669373, -0.2929145097732544, -0.11250719428062439, -0.33171796798706055, -0.7019121646881104, 0.13531190156936646, -0.05487598851323128, 0.007881207391619682, -0.3975450098514557, 0.6500441431999207, -0.8093729615211487, 0.024359047412872314, -0.529574453830719, 0.14025650918483734, -0.20333202183246613, 0.5478991866111755, -0.07298415154218674, 0.811782956123352, 0.6463786363601685, -0.669967770576477, 0.5863856077194214, -0.11553438752889633, -0.08840473741292953, 0.44866615533828735, -0.48084771633148193, 0.27792802453041077, -0.2605350911617279, 0.06402018666267395, -0.6622889041900635, -0.2792254388332367, 0.2624627351760864, -0.24829164147377014, 0.34818723797798157, -0.08264116197824478, -0.6283995509147644, -0.16878095269203186, -0.23141513764858246, 0.0675710067152977, 0.4337424635887146, -0.3653015196323395, 0.7465969920158386, 0.023389499634504318, -0.12050815671682358, -0.29193973541259766, -0.29335546493530273, -0.040664996951818466, -0.3975922763347626, -0.610202431678772, 0.21504446864128113, -0.05926266685128212, -0.3069065511226654, 0.09466942399740219, -0.15821488201618195, 0.08706478029489517, 0.13326676189899445, 0.18250468373298645, 0.007617597933858633, -0.31413090229034424, 0.3764820396900177, 0.2307380586862564, -0.08057735860347748, -0.196595698595047, -0.3316704332828522, 0.5730636715888977, -0.4052123427391052, -0.499921977519989, -0.04964394122362137, 0.14971695840358734, 0.4474039077758789, -0.45217928290367126, 0.6013548970222473, 0.590398371219635, -0.2590782046318054, -0.6112698912620544, -0.5861128568649292, -0.5744063854217529, -0.5159434676170349, 0.3831494152545929, -0.5941430926322937, -0.9044983983039856, 0.5585575103759766, -0.3593314588069916, -0.15003329515457153, 0.1703600436449051, 0.898806095123291, 0.19567134976387024, 1.0547939538955688, 0.42653390765190125, -0.06898608058691025, 0.4469999670982361, -0.1770925372838974, 0.15636374056339264, -0.5911226868629456, 0.0300969909876585, -0.6291446089744568, -0.1680115908384323, -0.6606088280677795, -0.6292770504951477, 0.23836323618888855, 0.09035608172416687, -0.3831133246421814, 0.17236223816871643, -0.6707267761230469, 0.6535264849662781, 0.5179492831230164, 0.22835363447666168, 0.41711118817329407, -0.023129798471927643, 0.023930402472615242, 0.3955206274986267, -0.5110176801681519, -0.7948129177093506, 0.9406094551086426, 0.4022999107837677, 1.0803921222686768, 0.0565282367169857, 0.6544559597969055, 0.06185919791460037, 0.03904013708233833, -0.7879208326339722, 0.6176137924194336, 0.00014221177843865007, -0.701143205165863, -0.7429313063621521, -0.3397785425186157, -1.0576752424240112, 0.4360348880290985, -0.005919128190726042, -0.819945752620697, 0.0009080612217076123, 0.10005701333284378, -0.21519377827644348, 0.10232562571763992, -0.783306896686554, 0.6457942724227905, -0.2827112376689911, -0.34989991784095764, -0.31354662775993347, -0.3654099702835083, 0.1413576751947403, -0.024253100156784058, 0.060302238911390305, -0.38368359208106995, -0.1426287293434143, 0.26988446712493896, -0.48298823833465576, 0.8550917506217957, -0.29572412371635437, -0.12388328462839127, 0.3310730457305908, -0.10439766943454742, 0.8997944593429565, 0.09970293939113617, -0.22562551498413086, -0.19106878340244293, -0.01672365330159664, -0.44933387637138367, -0.6489565968513489, 0.7237721681594849, -0.9300191402435303, -0.9022068381309509, -0.004362225532531738, -0.8515047430992126, -0.5879702568054199, 0.1490612030029297, -0.0890684574842453, 0.23514191806316376, 0.02022472769021988, 0.21315813064575195, 0.541133463382721, -0.04176126420497894, 0.4127810299396515, 0.603654682636261, -0.017877304926514626, -0.10060581564903259, 0.8462560176849365, 0.2223765254020691, 0.35204699635505676, 0.17277857661247253, 0.0314268097281456, -0.2368895709514618, -0.7050469517707825, -0.31991255283355713, 0.2816600799560547, -0.7242077589035034, -0.3148016631603241, -0.2819029688835144, -0.2790739834308624, -0.37215036153793335, -0.09014851599931717, -0.29474925994873047, -0.06830394268035889, -0.3299870789051056, -0.04061288386583328, 0.40345752239227295, 0.4755210876464844, 0.0631699338555336, 0.4361617863178253, -0.5876370072364807, 0.48852428793907166, 0.30586427450180054, 0.34583473205566406, -0.11113719642162323, -0.3219259977340698, -0.4117235541343689, 0.13134825229644775, -0.360137015581131, -0.7745040655136108, 0.28782904148101807, 0.1662045568227768, 0.8323293328285217, 0.2949387729167938, 0.06525824964046478, 0.628395140171051, -0.27587687969207764, 0.4246026277542114, -0.4499013125896454, -0.8708773851394653, 0.6107239127159119, -0.6258683800697327, 0.2899569272994995, 0.32270142436027527, 0.15441858768463135, 0.1992606371641159, -0.8176743388175964, -0.3905613422393799, -0.6656908392906189, 0.914148211479187, 0.25119948387145996, 0.0377233512699604, 0.281361848115921, 0.4733942747116089, -0.045265424996614456, 0.2233550250530243, -0.4367314577102661, 0.06690230220556259, -0.1696789264678955, -0.10931457579135895, -0.3387068510055542, 0.1422732174396515, -0.07869721204042435, -0.36145442724227905, 0.6776936054229736, -0.6171287894248962, 0.13632600009441376, 0.003418827662244439, -0.03918108716607094, -0.15466174483299255, 0.46264904737472534, 0.7030051350593567, 0.7307419180870056, -0.25295084714889526, 0.15149080753326416, 0.2883024513721466, -0.16831079125404358, 0.3404124677181244, 0.20309464633464813, 0.013313510455191135, -0.24621519446372986, 0.3400430679321289, 0.9211495518684387, -0.29674646258354187, -0.6331295371055603, 0.0073096188716590405, 0.06629877537488937, -0.23810593783855438, 0.02773340418934822, 0.5384689569473267, 0.37373510003089905, 0.699673593044281, 0.18714573979377747, -0.16101126372814178, -0.09767882525920868, -0.6810506582260132, -0.03879018500447273, 0.7024233341217041, -0.1188710480928421, -0.12662576138973236, 0.36733120679855347, 0.003961261827498674, -0.27165672183036804, 0.4687078297138214, -0.3767562508583069, -0.14059165120124817, 0.8466230630874634, 0.5666532516479492, 0.6915422081947327, -0.2543915808200836, 0.20361492037773132, -0.004840589594095945, 0.6227430701255798, -0.11420558393001556, 0.3198188543319702, 0.08721096068620682, -0.7730777859687805, -0.6524820327758789, -0.525084376335144, -0.4912063479423523, 0.291098415851593, -0.29426541924476624, 0.3156336545944214, -0.41513893008232117, -0.3061479926109314, -0.03385630249977112, 0.29249152541160583, -0.736564040184021, 0.10182931274175644, -0.03710508346557617, 0.6544495820999146, -0.5527936816215515, 1.0736838579177856, 0.8511400818824768, -0.41433173418045044, -1.0851173400878906, -0.03427766263484955, -0.25866666436195374, -0.7140367031097412, 0.38894787430763245, 0.053185053169727325, -0.2541095018386841, 0.09826506674289703, -0.6154962182044983, -0.7726709842681885, 1.0586163997650146, 0.7474623322486877, -0.4752183258533478, -0.2931688129901886, 0.23069193959236145, 0.8220691084861755, -0.35715657472610474, 0.3983768820762634, 0.6321724653244019, 0.7662056088447571, 0.06241363286972046, -0.9304773807525635, 0.28156328201293945, -0.011521211825311184, -0.007146669551730156, 0.24482408165931702, -0.6233069896697998, 0.9435206651687622, -0.15472403168678284, 0.08139927685260773, -0.021647583693265915, 0.392302006483078, 0.40230950713157654, 0.20207859575748444, 0.3759773373603821, 0.21792861819267273, 0.8911337852478027, -0.22274720668792725, 0.822985053062439, -0.3409479260444641, 0.14243680238723755, 0.9513566493988037, -0.22825023531913757, 0.45792680978775024, 0.37906163930892944, 0.14032778143882751, 0.257104754447937, 0.6000736951828003, -0.060575779527425766, 0.45909300446510315, 0.42138513922691345, 0.033620886504650116, -0.6902254819869995, -0.14146311581134796, -0.23848550021648407, 0.39397236704826355, 0.5255080461502075, -0.07475985586643219, -0.3695656359195709, 0.06375410407781601, -0.10361965000629425, -0.03579051420092583, -0.5078326463699341, 0.8350781798362732, 0.11212023347616196, -0.7456282377243042, 0.7107462882995605, 0.08295517414808273, 0.43361538648605347, -0.6298807859420776, -0.018600426614284515, -0.2539620101451874, 0.3881116807460785, -0.1620306670665741, -0.44512614607810974, 0.28526946902275085, -0.13369068503379822, -0.07137084007263184, -0.12887698411941528, 1.0015344619750977, -0.3545268476009369, -0.2644951343536377, 0.36881208419799805, 0.8488333821296692, 0.24274392426013947, -0.46959006786346436, -0.47101300954818726, -0.02541474811732769, -0.18565423786640167, -0.351226270198822, 0.4319363832473755, 0.7294977307319641, -0.35691189765930176, 0.8135294318199158, 0.605439305305481, 0.44047802686691284, -0.15573422610759735, 0.053806837648153305, 1.0981117486953735, -0.7767111659049988, -0.23391182720661163, -0.8866096138954163, 0.3067435026168823, 0.11778491735458374, 0.07846590876579285, 0.6311910152435303, 0.3129804730415344, 0.6982279419898987, -0.2026991993188858, 0.6950844526290894, 0.26338133215904236, 0.49602246284484863, -0.6269589066505432, 0.459231436252594, -0.5410594940185547, 0.29326725006103516, -0.13905102014541626, -0.9621483683586121, -0.09234510362148285, 0.39904549717903137, -0.35045409202575684, 0.2536073923110962, 0.6296652555465698, 1.205561637878418, -0.019372176378965378, -0.3218039870262146, 0.5525566935539246, 0.14435435831546783, 0.5966512560844421, 0.5502372980117798, 1.0235880613327026, 0.14065231382846832, 0.6579615473747253, 0.013035565614700317, -0.029262706637382507, -0.23770460486412048, -0.5908443927764893, -1.3137766122817993, -0.3067278265953064, -0.0065824431367218494, -0.0006811953498981893, 0.24602164328098297, 0.9358168244361877, 0.8208717703819275, -0.7480396032333374, -0.16005924344062805, -0.002117666881531477, 0.3210841715335846, -0.2430141717195511, -0.17789487540721893, 0.15296609699726105, -0.7996506094932556, -0.7049337029457092, 0.6857780814170837, 0.19450929760932922, -0.002281342400237918, -0.3227934241294861, -0.3365877568721771, 0.09445641934871674, 0.4199647307395935, 0.5348941683769226, -0.006966917309910059, -0.9134345054626465, -0.3959544897079468, 0.007623525336384773, -0.16852553188800812, -0.011147528886795044, 0.6143655776977539, -0.6220018267631531, 0.16372622549533844, 0.4242470860481262, 0.4949806034564972, 0.4668551981449127, 0.30033496022224426, 0.3993319272994995, -0.5681090950965881, 0.12330597639083862, 0.3244384527206421, 0.16610628366470337, 0.06059081479907036, -0.3759763836860657, 0.45821547508239746, -0.06368298828601837, -0.7185674905776978, -0.6431359052658081, 0.20208042860031128, -0.8390844464302063, -0.5373443365097046, 1.1748249530792236, 0.05679503455758095, -0.01161634549498558, -0.23114724457263947, -0.6180038452148438, 0.33411741256713867, -0.5911232829093933, 0.5518331527709961, 0.6895074248313904, -0.46348604559898376, -0.20273496210575104, -0.5427164435386658, 0.6436243653297424, 0.22139334678649902, -1.2080069780349731, -0.015433902852237225, 0.619981050491333, 0.06697101145982742, 0.047248803079128265, 0.6010586023330688, 0.2155640423297882, 0.025537636131048203, -0.03189650550484657, -0.038225848227739334, -0.4805387258529663, -0.5787586569786072, -0.12338291853666306, 0.2618473768234253, 0.5559325218200684, 0.03900612145662308 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19936v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19936v1
SLFNet: Generating Semantic Logic Forms from Natural Language Using Semantic Probability Graphs
2024-03-29T02:42:39
2024-03-29T02:42:39
Hao Wu, Fan Xu
cs.CL
cs.CL
Building natural language interfaces typically uses a semantic parser to parse the user's natural language and convert it into structured \textbf{S}emantic \textbf{L}ogic \textbf{F}orms (SLFs). The mainstream approach is to adopt a sequence-to-sequence framework, which requires that natural language commands and SLFs must be represented serially. Since a single natural language may have multiple SLFs or multiple natural language commands may have the same SLF, training a sequence-to-sequence model is sensitive to the choice among them, a phenomenon recorded as "order matters". To solve this problem, we propose a novel neural network, SLFNet, which firstly incorporates dependent syntactic information as prior knowledge and can capture the long-range interactions between contextual information and words. Secondly construct semantic probability graphs to obtain local dependencies between predictor variables. Finally we propose the Multi-Head SLF Attention mechanism to synthesize SLFs from natural language commands based on Sequence-to-Slots. Experiments show that SLFNet achieves state-of-the-art performance on the ChineseQCI-TS and Okapi datasets, and competitive performance on the ATIS dataset.
[ -0.14731518924236298, -0.7658888101577759, 0.6044026613235474, 0.038583651185035706, 0.07773719727993011, -0.2679639756679535, -0.012447334825992584, -0.4342103898525238, 0.3096005916595459, 0.7160134315490723, -0.7075207233428955, -0.40224888920783997, -0.4877032935619354, 0.03967108950018883, -0.4473722279071808, 0.9001100659370422, 0.23789630830287933, 0.04964402690529823, -0.19344480335712433, -0.21198278665542603, -0.13042064011096954, -0.4700621962547302, -0.8104808926582336, -0.41420766711235046, 0.629764199256897, 0.015261225402355194, 0.8288481831550598, 0.5565670132637024, 0.38651183247566223, 0.39611637592315674, 0.06241472437977791, 0.09068700671195984, -0.1330665796995163, 0.09294422715902328, -0.2373688519001007, -0.32175761461257935, -0.2107619196176529, -0.252282053232193, 0.7143890857696533, 0.905026376247406, 0.06483610719442368, 0.19451625645160675, -0.31229034066200256, 0.7976824641227722, -0.606428861618042, 0.3861153721809387, -0.5598883032798767, 0.4616103172302246, -0.15992328524589539, -0.23437167704105377, -0.5380472540855408, -0.135663241147995, 0.39664387702941895, -0.5845251679420471, 0.01767192967236042, 0.015131481923162937, 0.7088339924812317, 0.1554262340068817, -0.40813279151916504, -0.03667118400335312, -0.4858042299747467, 0.5024635791778564, -0.954716145992279, 0.511045515537262, 0.012261609546840191, 0.2766810357570648, -0.6276147365570068, -1.0813097953796387, -0.4019363522529602, -0.1148974746465683, -0.2387198656797409, 0.039127375930547714, 0.13614600896835327, 0.21008813381195068, 0.305488258600235, -0.12638014554977417, -0.7005735039710999, -0.20405170321464539, -0.257784903049469, -0.14772233366966248, 0.7743235230445862, 0.18590141832828522, 0.2499701827764511, -0.27239492535591125, -0.48281151056289673, 0.03747004643082619, -0.5341508984565735, 0.17016732692718506, 0.2504437267780304, 0.5601351857185364, 0.3508304953575134, 0.6437408924102783, -0.5175307989120483, 1.1695224046707153, -0.11572307348251343, -0.30293095111846924, 0.39034733176231384, -0.3776434063911438, -0.43358340859413147, 0.44524523615837097, 1.0074299573898315, 0.09061256796121597, 0.2840014398097992, -0.24138303101062775, -0.20318603515625, 0.0757102444767952, 0.21515004336833954, -0.6453729867935181, 0.0377054437994957, 0.1606486439704895, -0.4078447222709656, -0.36556413769721985, 0.24886316061019897, -0.26817962527275085, -0.38970106840133667, -0.650303065776825, 0.37134885787963867, -0.5133821368217468, -0.18077796697616577, 0.3783673644065857, -0.09527383744716644, 0.29137012362480164, 0.011372624896466732, -0.627336859703064, 0.5175753235816956, 0.650166928768158, 0.563383936882019, -0.2693776786327362, -0.5410234928131104, -0.7331946492195129, 0.2238338440656662, -0.17064404487609863, 0.703126847743988, -0.2069098800420761, 0.18558384478092194, -0.09127628058195114, -0.20865727961063385, -0.19384372234344482, -0.25795623660087585, 0.34238654375076294, -0.6096419095993042, 0.11799771338701248, 0.17306816577911377, -0.6270372271537781, -0.02694815769791603, -0.09558755159378052, -0.7184147238731384, 0.9334237575531006, -0.04284961521625519, -0.9390957951545715, 0.27566590905189514, -0.7754499316215515, -1.0209811925888062, 0.13911794126033783, -0.43543118238449097, -0.0525299496948719, 0.039331547915935516, -0.13003447651863098, 0.6325863599777222, -0.11257938295602798, 0.559680163860321, -0.4545506238937378, 0.03371801972389221, 0.40779203176498413, -0.16059228777885437, 0.7509774565696716, 0.26043906807899475, -0.3468396067619324, 0.42198771238327026, -0.9372414350509644, 0.21494010090827942, 0.2238214910030365, -0.11108662188053131, -0.22934260964393616, 0.34631821513175964, -0.1817503720521927, 0.7529317736625671, 0.006792346015572548, -0.44839906692504883, -0.3530693054199219, -0.9840939044952393, 0.8812640309333801, 0.645514190196991, -0.09020400792360306, 0.6843795776367188, -0.17094317078590393, 0.08942080289125443, 0.10538940876722336, 0.0874950960278511, 0.03857893496751785, -0.581381618976593, -0.7618136405944824, 0.3348012864589691, -0.03188551217317581, 0.6626580953598022, -0.7236432433128357, 0.6063924431800842, -0.37374264001846313, -0.10061825811862946, -0.15648435056209564, 0.04280532896518707, 0.08019588887691498, 0.6778577566146851, -0.00880110077559948, -0.27123579382896423, -0.5705771446228027, -0.8001714944839478, -0.19249868392944336, -0.05684129148721695, 0.17996437847614288, 0.07938195019960403, 0.2982378900051117, 0.07498165965080261, 1.3867642879486084, -0.6265109777450562, -0.33876511454582214, -0.36812514066696167, -0.028526591137051582, 0.4334612190723419, 0.19017142057418823, 0.34193241596221924, -0.910703182220459, -0.06470886617898941, 0.007018991746008396, -0.7032113075256348, 0.1290353387594223, -0.09673009067773819, -0.646030068397522, 0.3545803725719452, 0.54775071144104, -0.7520073652267456, 0.5493892431259155, 0.08170785754919052, -0.4393368065357208, 0.3012900650501251, -0.0821656882762909, -0.256897509098053, -1.0159213542938232, 0.021778827533125877, -0.017887147143483162, -0.24031560122966766, -0.8251861333847046, -0.015785472467541695, -0.254136323928833, -0.3024241328239441, -0.7055481672286987, 0.6056827902793884, -0.092603899538517, -0.33344900608062744, -0.008081838488578796, 0.2756466269493103, 0.045140478760004044, 0.7562687993049622, 0.3310958445072174, 0.14328783750534058, 0.3696348965167999, -0.5855292081832886, 0.4256024956703186, 0.07581143826246262, -0.2498498558998108, 0.19811594486236572, -0.5410216450691223, -0.0617453008890152, -0.27881115674972534, 0.11384223401546478, -0.9415816068649292, -0.18394020199775696, 0.32955610752105713, -0.46712663769721985, 0.07883556932210922, 0.12662528455257416, -0.51192706823349, -0.39096036553382874, 0.026979144662618637, 0.18750910460948944, 0.0863790288567543, -0.12885628640651703, 0.8027110695838928, 0.40010374784469604, 0.0004639170365408063, -0.5376386642456055, -0.9176343083381653, -0.02490096539258957, 0.10770683735609055, -1.0623068809509277, 0.29297906160354614, 0.08142747730016708, -0.1472029834985733, 0.04036213085055351, -0.0797685980796814, -0.0637439489364624, 0.07986866682767868, 0.2517554461956024, 0.20045234262943268, -0.3913922607898712, 0.28820136189460754, -0.08535032719373703, -0.17762500047683716, 0.38947176933288574, -1.052794098854065, 0.4027640223503113, -0.2563313841819763, -0.3559185564517975, -0.14136840403079987, 0.4865751564502716, 0.38114526867866516, -0.4231834411621094, 0.6592329740524292, 0.605258584022522, -0.6323294043540955, -0.37232694029808044, -0.24930797517299652, -0.1714922934770584, -0.4408404529094696, 0.37175294756889343, -0.2972600758075714, -0.9802392721176147, 0.3030220866203308, 0.15313087403774261, 0.05843948945403099, 0.37602052092552185, 0.30250680446624756, 0.1735975593328476, 1.1379725933074951, 0.3341090977191925, -0.013634965755045414, 0.5541129112243652, -0.07379928976297379, 0.4723142385482788, -0.009065533056855202, 0.015679309144616127, -0.23697330057621002, -0.3167857229709625, -0.4179171919822693, -0.13301345705986023, 0.2608884274959564, 0.05532929301261902, -0.5229583978652954, 0.3677270710468292, -0.4589165151119232, 0.3171316981315613, 0.6643218994140625, 0.14484430849552155, 0.16837850213050842, 0.2863876223564148, -0.30471330881118774, 0.1328553706407547, -0.9503281712532043, -0.20024468004703522, 0.7344213128089905, 0.043034471571445465, 0.5723680257797241, 0.03426102176308632, 0.8869225382804871, 0.20929627120494843, -0.007274170871824026, -0.8815439343452454, 0.7837591171264648, -0.3103298544883728, -0.21493780612945557, -0.5580256581306458, -0.6341557502746582, -0.9038277268409729, -0.018198121339082718, -0.19714072346687317, -0.8509129881858826, -0.1528431475162506, -0.0781569629907608, -0.41360220313072205, 0.07146117091178894, -0.8261770606040955, 0.9585939645767212, -0.40155941247940063, -0.2771347463130951, 0.16420245170593262, -1.1733055114746094, 0.3139512836933136, 0.380795419216156, 0.1959996223449707, -0.06718982756137848, 0.3379867672920227, 0.7266817092895508, -0.6755536794662476, 0.8290261030197144, -0.03074144944548607, 0.04119719937443733, 0.5051371455192566, 0.02351384609937668, 0.35610780119895935, 0.17949143052101135, -0.09299194067716599, -0.15203486382961273, -0.19221235811710358, -0.2034083604812622, -0.8073689937591553, 0.668059229850769, -0.7457616329193115, -0.3639925718307495, -0.46437186002731323, -0.45115700364112854, -0.2564926743507385, 0.6093413829803467, 0.3301515281200409, 0.8267021775245667, 0.028832975775003433, -0.40285632014274597, 0.6513252854347229, 0.0978800430893898, 0.4736194312572479, -0.019229143857955933, -0.26069164276123047, -0.5376836061477661, 1.0454174280166626, 0.21529601514339447, 0.3346095681190491, 0.8402562737464905, 0.31609001755714417, -0.2945488393306732, -0.20917266607284546, -0.33178192377090454, 0.11548293381929398, -0.9384416341781616, -0.29196038842201233, -0.6428484320640564, -0.7996454238891602, -0.7233095765113831, -0.07437651604413986, -0.1719064563512802, -0.6255519390106201, -0.14836083352565765, -0.0890178307890892, 0.6305419206619263, 0.7307742238044739, 0.2661750316619873, 0.019517065957188606, -0.6235446929931641, 0.2730017304420471, 0.22803367674350739, 0.43667861819267273, 0.05496957153081894, -0.08353365957736969, 0.020552977919578552, -0.02295374497771263, -0.02584301307797432, -0.8140788674354553, 0.38381755352020264, 0.35909247398376465, 0.6906225085258484, 0.2869572341442108, 0.17248263955116272, 0.45896491408348083, -0.651160717010498, 0.4401833415031433, 0.4591939449310303, -0.8497002720832825, 0.7929525375366211, -0.17440325021743774, 0.47620517015457153, 0.4004819691181183, 0.1588188260793686, -0.5575259327888489, -0.46127766370773315, -0.7657858729362488, -1.0139713287353516, 1.1226269006729126, 0.2697869539260864, -0.23352321982383728, -0.29841917753219604, 0.2540082037448883, -0.17326413094997406, 0.29397109150886536, -0.7385765314102173, -0.4151981770992279, -0.3693755567073822, -0.5834255218505859, 0.16917061805725098, 0.28120535612106323, 0.036096058785915375, -0.1417539268732071, 0.519467294216156, -0.41664865612983704, 0.48421019315719604, 0.29321667551994324, -0.25255170464515686, 0.2779390513896942, 0.17042724788188934, 0.7003614902496338, 0.5599946975708008, 0.0038345337379723787, 0.3984428942203522, 0.011616487987339497, -0.2582824230194092, 0.045979250222444534, 0.2910190522670746, -0.23081625998020172, -0.06472702324390411, 0.2506691515445709, 1.114551305770874, 0.21164201200008392, -0.6604819893836975, 0.464292973279953, -0.05931027606129646, -0.1341351866722107, -0.4181861877441406, 0.17439818382263184, 0.27782464027404785, 0.08668311685323715, 0.10099928826093674, 0.3179091811180115, 0.38522568345069885, -0.18235377967357635, 0.5006586909294128, 0.14511990547180176, -0.4897534251213074, 0.0036826878786087036, 0.3762202560901642, -0.0198809877038002, -0.41668054461479187, 0.4895015060901642, -0.3111288845539093, -0.45815739035606384, 0.6135875582695007, 0.6153565645217896, 0.7553758025169373, 0.25855574011802673, 0.33938026428222656, 0.3226049244403839, -0.033114660531282425, -0.047460805624723434, 0.23966355621814728, -0.07791952788829803, -0.8684074878692627, -0.5200235843658447, -0.7749337553977966, 0.14928315579891205, 0.016540898010134697, -0.4368566572666168, 0.3080402910709381, -0.7381618618965149, -0.3556640148162842, 0.1253160983324051, -0.2825448513031006, -0.6444974541664124, 0.16679979860782623, 0.4087812304496765, 0.8413269519805908, -0.6501414775848389, 0.6456537246704102, 0.9212216734886169, -0.4141904413700104, -0.8800289630889893, -0.5299431085586548, -0.14382968842983246, -0.535962700843811, 0.8603687882423401, 0.3808489143848419, -0.2207169085741043, 0.03801250085234642, -0.4047272503376007, -1.0438427925109863, 1.0585511922836304, 0.42873871326446533, -0.1719375103712082, -0.22571612894535065, 0.5557070970535278, 0.3407031297683716, -0.573758602142334, 0.2612934410572052, 0.554063081741333, 0.2715449631214142, 0.13890480995178223, -0.42460817098617554, 0.16381417214870453, -0.47232121229171753, 0.3463831841945648, 0.4930281341075897, -0.3121900260448456, 0.5222274661064148, -0.1503879874944687, -0.24642397463321686, -0.07414671778678894, 1.0072814226150513, 0.2736987769603729, 0.11976727843284607, 0.5694381594657898, 0.5995088815689087, 0.4487077295780182, -0.010641482658684254, 0.7652480602264404, -0.2477428913116455, 0.04995822161436081, 1.2929755449295044, -0.5329935550689697, 0.8319681286811829, 0.5613221526145935, 0.00643938547000289, 0.44805899262428284, 0.43332573771476746, 0.3465678095817566, 0.5475246906280518, 0.5590348839759827, -0.1994089037179947, -0.4268174469470978, -0.17803139984607697, 0.062026042491197586, 0.2787077724933624, 0.5156486630439758, -0.4234926700592041, -0.4390868544578552, 0.18571585416793823, -0.23592212796211243, 0.051517605781555176, -0.1765662133693695, 0.9067599177360535, 0.1778544932603836, -0.7615461349487305, 0.29543784260749817, 0.08672497421503067, 0.49419257044792175, -0.9030342102050781, -0.03579796105623245, 0.06453074514865875, 0.17354583740234375, -0.2789636254310608, -0.9207260012626648, 0.3153124153614044, -0.5426840782165527, -0.2984340786933899, -0.29336193203926086, 1.114808201789856, -0.4190426170825958, -0.608774721622467, 0.5604106783866882, 0.33672860264778137, -0.12595833837985992, 0.29791879653930664, -0.837252676486969, -0.34827038645744324, -0.30090272426605225, -0.3089157044887543, 0.3916788697242737, 0.449002742767334, -0.293580025434494, 0.4905213415622711, 0.5999482870101929, -0.0074690585024654865, 0.31232988834381104, 0.45224156975746155, 0.5050761699676514, -0.532915472984314, -0.6958435773849487, -0.6301929950714111, 0.38534942269325256, -0.14601531624794006, -0.4308609068393707, 0.12783819437026978, 0.1420065015554428, 0.9855729341506958, -0.001547977328300476, 0.7070819139480591, -0.31456729769706726, 0.055918365716934204, -0.6944920420646667, 0.7783735990524292, -0.36273321509361267, -0.22188839316368103, -0.20099148154258728, -0.46028873324394226, -0.4471227526664734, 0.7031890153884888, -0.1413201242685318, -0.11985093355178833, 0.6523724794387817, 0.8131746053695679, 0.010197327472269535, 0.2473694384098053, 0.1945955455303192, 0.07725656032562256, 0.026167282834649086, 0.9444519281387329, 0.5867758393287659, -0.41527628898620605, 0.5501296520233154, -0.3861367404460907, -0.031115185469388962, 0.18374580144882202, -1.0378319025039673, -0.8003435134887695, -0.642875611782074, -0.26896932721138, -0.4384121000766754, 0.05269177630543709, 1.186643123626709, 0.6580221056938171, -0.9336899518966675, -0.4323624074459076, -0.5619739890098572, 0.37268608808517456, -0.3032577633857727, -0.295427143573761, 0.38805410265922546, -0.6767228245735168, -0.16820897161960602, 0.21972700953483582, 0.4085428714752197, -0.09164483100175858, -0.1075504869222641, -0.120722196996212, -0.598113477230072, -0.14316359162330627, 0.9223942160606384, 0.15085716545581818, -0.8475929498672485, -0.30130231380462646, 0.24687747657299042, -0.3398456275463104, -0.0013418687740340829, 0.7954740524291992, -0.9365009069442749, 0.19718126952648163, 0.9028021693229675, 1.0070220232009888, 0.2219628095626831, -0.5925871729850769, 0.8129990100860596, -0.8359010219573975, 0.04661848768591881, 0.10469834506511688, 0.49562937021255493, 0.12002979964017868, -0.4458286762237549, 0.4339525103569031, 0.4386174976825714, -0.16669721901416779, -0.3210880160331726, 0.45081743597984314, -0.9815711379051208, -0.25417807698249817, 1.1036409139633179, 0.01502157561480999, -0.6138300895690918, -0.08038037270307541, -0.09737475216388702, 0.393187552690506, -0.4360325336456299, 0.07129538804292679, 0.6056862473487854, -0.3987860083580017, 0.1475464105606079, -0.4655587375164032, 0.5208467245101929, 0.4948931336402893, -0.7938486337661743, -0.18296100199222565, 0.31972551345825195, 0.14170999825000763, 0.3483518958091736, 0.6478724479675293, -0.018566450104117393, 0.2880794405937195, -0.33234357833862305, -0.19113631546497345, -0.02668451890349388, -0.3247022330760956, -0.1625259667634964, 0.22732387483119965, -0.07287666946649551, 0.24587507545948029 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19930v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19930v1
Are LLMs Effective Backbones for Fine-tuning? An Experimental Investigation of Supervised LLMs on Chinese Short Text Matching
2024-03-29T02:36:54
2024-03-29T02:36:54
Shulin Liu, Chengcheng Xu, Hao Liu, Tinghao Yu, Tao Yang
cs.CL
cs.CL
The recent success of Large Language Models (LLMs) has garnered significant attention in both academia and industry. Prior research on LLMs has primarily focused on enhancing or leveraging their generalization capabilities in zero- and few-shot settings. However, there has been limited investigation into effectively fine-tuning LLMs for a specific natural language understanding task in supervised settings. In this study, we conduct an experimental analysis by fine-tuning LLMs for the task of Chinese short text matching. We explore various factors that influence performance when fine-tuning LLMs, including task modeling methods, prompt formats, and output formats.
[ -0.23623625934123993, -0.8246400356292725, 0.7531308531761169, 0.21878008544445038, -0.6675072908401489, -0.20236685872077942, -0.6231988072395325, -0.7244279384613037, -0.07246387749910355, 0.5657406449317932, -0.5178859233856201, -0.6964253783226013, -0.4348848760128021, 0.48608383536338806, -0.3526223599910736, 0.9653676152229309, 0.006098257377743721, 0.12283655256032944, -0.025863757357001305, -0.23553894460201263, -0.5646325945854187, -0.28878557682037354, -1.0168911218643188, -0.5954069495201111, 0.7186794877052307, 0.6020422577857971, 0.7128793597221375, 1.1474424600601196, 0.6042158007621765, 0.24656380712985992, -0.3622590899467468, 0.4246496260166168, -0.7541428208351135, -0.12350956350564957, -0.2914847433567047, -0.7078569531440735, -0.5327796936035156, -0.08820366114377975, 0.8322904706001282, 0.7631127834320068, 0.24421070516109467, 0.17968928813934326, 0.5590336918830872, 0.630555272102356, -0.49136650562286377, -0.05559198930859566, -0.7599490880966187, -0.03137325122952461, -0.5342720746994019, -0.3327092230319977, -0.3306315839290619, -0.12545256316661835, -0.0006084071355871856, -0.6130487322807312, 0.5142032504081726, 0.3138306438922882, 0.9043014049530029, 0.16004876792430878, -0.43835335969924927, -0.32390040159225464, -0.6115475296974182, 0.8163770437240601, -0.9271116256713867, 0.07523683458566666, 0.2881775200366974, 0.15179748833179474, -0.3423091471195221, -0.5235825181007385, -0.3890574872493744, -0.16901537775993347, -0.3919728994369507, -0.00533212348818779, 0.2955990731716156, 0.5481386780738831, 0.35564249753952026, 0.7371637225151062, -0.6231019496917725, 0.8824253678321838, -0.1597675234079361, -0.1628209352493286, 0.6059278845787048, 0.6319794058799744, 0.29255229234695435, -0.21270279586315155, 0.013316747732460499, 0.09052575379610062, -0.6193746328353882, 0.26957157254219055, 0.3546961843967438, 0.7594798803329468, -0.15310825407505035, 0.6617258191108704, -0.552376389503479, 1.0994012355804443, -0.02464601770043373, -0.2128511220216751, -0.24384982883930206, -0.800060510635376, -0.4976104497909546, -0.08185384422540665, 0.6024256944656372, 0.4683123528957367, 0.4924451410770416, -0.18881897628307343, -0.4851396381855011, -0.11327192932367325, -0.11927332729101181, -0.8718493580818176, -0.35617414116859436, -0.04642704129219055, -0.6777665019035339, -0.25160059332847595, -0.07245437800884247, -0.24744737148284912, -0.3795931935310364, -0.5601141452789307, 0.4188193380832672, -0.24504519999027252, 0.15263967216014862, 0.3072091341018677, -0.14175285398960114, 0.5270121097564697, 0.3766493499279022, -1.0921847820281982, 0.28542855381965637, 0.8903325796127319, 0.9732335209846497, -0.5654920935630798, -0.2266456037759781, -0.7461639642715454, -0.07574541121721268, -0.43025028705596924, 0.6654420495033264, -0.34088242053985596, -0.3757014572620392, 0.08371546119451523, 0.19279922544956207, -0.15824159979820251, -0.5967885851860046, 0.7606337666511536, -0.5079646706581116, 0.02778467908501625, -0.36944445967674255, -0.7383449077606201, 0.1460307240486145, 0.3029592037200928, -0.48882201313972473, 0.7384950518608093, -0.2686504125595093, -0.5254785418510437, 0.4379078149795532, -0.4257134795188904, -0.5937128067016602, -0.016814233735203743, 0.056240759789943695, -0.3440623879432678, 0.1563064008951187, 0.2912072539329529, 0.7702336311340332, -0.20705664157867432, -0.05910004675388336, -0.35141298174858093, -0.9887517690658569, 0.05580660328269005, -0.32358723878860474, 0.5352314710617065, 0.06737619638442993, -0.04162495210766792, 0.3094056248664856, -0.683846116065979, -0.13867315649986267, 0.042727116495370865, -0.44881588220596313, -0.48640871047973633, 0.021900998428463936, 0.09821446239948273, -0.10334193706512451, 0.3445882797241211, -0.33996811509132385, 0.2402545064687729, -0.7034543752670288, 0.4338286519050598, 0.7041977047920227, -0.10010991245508194, 0.6381082534790039, -0.43799152970314026, 0.2699233889579773, -0.1923869550228119, -0.08106876164674759, -0.390750527381897, -0.1753339022397995, -0.895793080329895, -0.2218293696641922, 0.42891645431518555, 0.4500837028026581, -0.5788705348968506, 0.18283382058143616, -0.01196968276053667, -0.4294705390930176, -0.3769054710865021, 0.5258477330207825, 0.5113164186477661, 0.29717230796813965, 0.24815544486045837, -0.21201355755329132, -0.301327645778656, -1.0344583988189697, -0.5676242113113403, 0.23034414649009705, -0.2975241541862488, 0.5550830960273743, 0.19481205940246582, -0.11069541424512863, 0.8134722113609314, -0.5284343361854553, -0.6019337773323059, -0.35773104429244995, 0.09255796670913696, 0.52435702085495, 0.3119416832923889, 0.736770749092102, -0.483496755361557, -0.7019595503807068, 0.015582016669213772, -0.4322046935558319, -0.22278332710266113, -0.17313411831855774, 0.024524996057152748, 0.11681529879570007, 0.6616323590278625, -0.39810776710510254, 0.10435572266578674, 0.5965073108673096, -0.10927664488554001, 0.5888242721557617, -0.3549139201641083, 0.1459304541349411, -1.0880731344223022, -0.11737286299467087, 0.3509237766265869, -0.2862212061882019, -0.6926100254058838, 0.15687233209609985, 0.2533556818962097, 0.16169199347496033, -0.5714133381843567, 0.5264584422111511, -0.6284391283988953, -0.07704930007457733, -0.7020902633666992, 0.5575460195541382, -0.035180531442165375, 0.4186488687992096, -0.10950646549463272, 0.8507876396179199, 0.5953484773635864, -0.9301760792732239, 0.17528405785560608, -0.12124369293451309, -0.48343396186828613, 0.4502984583377838, -0.8712577819824219, 0.04358477145433426, -0.03827676922082901, -0.038916610181331635, -1.0545014142990112, -0.355838805437088, 0.012486818246543407, -0.057926028966903687, 0.26224127411842346, -0.08664316684007645, -0.6728914380073547, -0.11639624834060669, -0.364063024520874, 0.3284614086151123, 0.3823407292366028, -0.5484272241592407, 0.243058443069458, -0.20309507846832275, 0.07577959448099136, -0.2942523956298828, -0.5455707311630249, 0.13512301445007324, -0.35107192397117615, -0.4125208258628845, 0.6050506830215454, -0.08162806183099747, -0.1863967925310135, -0.40952572226524353, -0.0488629974424839, -0.03428509086370468, 0.43677011132240295, -0.08180353045463562, 0.00911563541740179, -0.4144867956638336, 0.1369360387325287, 0.06081389635801315, 0.11959224194288254, -0.15596075356006622, -0.023492472246289253, 0.3467496335506439, 0.021870383992791176, -0.271134614944458, -0.6548953056335449, -0.13194821774959564, 0.2684675455093384, -0.09560026973485947, 0.6116428971290588, 0.4787876009941101, -0.3717469573020935, -0.41759026050567627, -0.442401260137558, -0.28916558623313904, -0.5635907649993896, 0.4649321138858795, -0.35211941599845886, -1.1828219890594482, 0.6377720832824707, -0.023750072345137596, 0.05208846181631088, 0.29481780529022217, 0.44782164692878723, -0.28624770045280457, 1.0159695148468018, 0.9777624011039734, -0.41123083233833313, 0.5724194645881653, 0.22571128606796265, -0.0607425831258297, -0.7647855877876282, 0.2549244463443756, -0.691775381565094, -0.510254979133606, -0.8035680651664734, -0.2625546455383301, 0.12028823047876358, 0.3551495671272278, 0.002299300627782941, 0.3605296015739441, -0.3574540615081787, 0.7752093076705933, 0.45897892117500305, 0.15516595542430878, 0.5800063014030457, -0.3991853594779968, 0.0755288228392601, 0.004588630516082048, -0.5444885492324829, -0.6314569711685181, 0.7560491561889648, 0.4086056649684906, 0.922234833240509, -0.0009797908132895827, 0.3928014636039734, 0.03499603271484375, -0.05084602162241936, -0.8385173678398132, 0.6383501887321472, -0.5501856803894043, -0.22067797183990479, -0.5186042189598083, -0.11168374121189117, -1.097623586654663, 0.2545194923877716, -0.20590022206306458, -0.7390341758728027, -0.2789890468120575, 0.25057899951934814, -0.3405396342277527, 0.09651456028223038, -0.38716840744018555, 0.7874575853347778, -0.34714168310165405, -0.18784579634666443, -0.26096272468566895, -0.44927358627319336, 0.4925009310245514, -0.19649678468704224, -0.1549873799085617, -0.165129616856575, 0.06337369233369827, 0.6408501863479614, 0.03178941830992699, 0.9807374477386475, 0.232757106423378, -0.1978766918182373, -0.046946603804826736, -0.14350669085979462, 0.5524437427520752, 0.19911332428455353, -0.1055208295583725, 0.04204273223876953, -0.050252292305231094, -0.34474116563796997, -0.5307217836380005, 0.8216168880462646, -0.6143568158149719, -0.9340700507164001, -0.008583789691329002, -0.6734189987182617, -0.15290719270706177, 0.4135439395904541, 0.2030448168516159, 0.23614725470542908, -0.16809797286987305, 0.5222749710083008, 0.8774384260177612, -0.20227418839931488, 0.5475534200668335, 0.7125245928764343, -0.14589925110340118, 0.15495377779006958, 0.6473453044891357, 0.10696160793304443, 0.3448694944381714, 0.5281410217285156, 0.1616339534521103, -0.0425516702234745, -1.049393892288208, -0.4549944996833801, 0.2573831379413605, -0.46439751982688904, -0.08542729169130325, -0.3357679843902588, -0.23904253542423248, -0.2419293373823166, -0.11310994625091553, -0.2623951733112335, -0.08480828255414963, -0.834611713886261, 0.008653676137328148, 0.20013047754764557, 0.617926299571991, 0.3282081186771393, 0.5101779103279114, -0.802213728427887, 0.48506060242652893, 0.2428189367055893, 0.6404740810394287, -0.15809664130210876, -0.733707845211029, -0.6374915242195129, 0.13996855914592743, -0.12661638855934143, -0.5265173316001892, 0.004870064556598663, 0.3093959093093872, 0.6150595545768738, 0.5005792379379272, 0.037640154361724854, 0.9163514971733093, -0.4254890978336334, 1.0253156423568726, -0.34431105852127075, -0.9257774353027344, 0.5686240196228027, -0.5148817300796509, 0.4810357987880707, 0.4958765208721161, 0.05924740433692932, -0.4099455773830414, -0.5601430535316467, 0.04619371145963669, -0.5695443153381348, 0.7236701846122742, 0.20293042063713074, 0.22664418816566467, 0.23845258355140686, 0.7402263283729553, -0.05357538163661957, -0.021964462473988533, -0.5669587850570679, -0.22511306405067444, 0.3961069881916046, -0.08232623338699341, -0.5137770771980286, -0.2891119718551636, 0.08259258419275284, -0.08526284992694855, 0.38338157534599304, -0.31079626083374023, -0.24109147489070892, -0.006954497657716274, -0.1446748524904251, -0.07925456762313843, 0.25791001319885254, 0.8214436769485474, 0.5489420294761658, -0.13183622062206268, -0.11216988414525986, 0.6047250628471375, -0.2382446825504303, -0.27975428104400635, -0.014979694038629532, -0.14592207968235016, 0.018547911196947098, 0.4874306321144104, 0.8640888333320618, 0.21656566858291626, -0.604964017868042, 0.25133880972862244, -0.054068028926849365, -0.1989583522081375, 0.026396559551358223, 0.4627554714679718, 0.1247808113694191, 0.3937138617038727, 0.2584039866924286, -0.35612952709198, 0.13610512018203735, -0.4920417070388794, 0.011177358217537403, 0.8091925382614136, -0.26177671551704407, -0.17039862275123596, 0.6921254992485046, 0.1559257060289383, -0.42939695715904236, 0.6223775744438171, 0.08263181149959564, -0.3076656758785248, 0.7325800657272339, 0.49357372522354126, 0.6182214617729187, 0.19156311452388763, -0.2802424430847168, 0.16374152898788452, 0.3518437147140503, -0.37920424342155457, -0.135443314909935, -0.11194445937871933, -0.7579221725463867, -0.6132161617279053, -0.6623449325561523, -0.6876756548881531, 0.1433461606502533, -0.7230370044708252, 0.6680010557174683, -0.13589434325695038, -0.05107878893613815, -0.16394159197807312, 0.25858065485954285, -0.707122802734375, 0.3292827010154724, 0.23718971014022827, 1.0980812311172485, -0.7788313031196594, 1.1363388299942017, 0.5992988348007202, -0.10868611186742783, -0.8608143925666809, 0.11433710902929306, -0.21855506300926208, -0.6759039163589478, 0.5187433958053589, 0.28909966349601746, -0.17673704028129578, -0.04079356789588928, -0.5408799648284912, -0.7563432455062866, 1.2627915143966675, 0.29979315400123596, -0.7393234372138977, -0.07656146585941315, 0.4140251576900482, 0.884563148021698, -0.21249213814735413, 0.03225141763687134, 0.8670007586479187, 0.28322410583496094, -0.2860635221004486, -1.371354341506958, -0.06825320422649384, 0.08697553724050522, 0.19640907645225525, 0.04934275150299072, -0.8651792407035828, 0.9452899098396301, -0.10378124564886093, -0.3006044328212738, 0.4537765383720398, 0.7786160707473755, 0.2965494990348816, 0.4242332875728607, 0.4510555863380432, 0.28071051836013794, 0.6886488199234009, -0.08664938062429428, 0.6968006491661072, -0.38343334197998047, 0.3062230944633484, 1.1236082315444946, -0.30152958631515503, 0.7104772329330444, 0.4307463765144348, 0.08226466178894043, 0.18284724652767181, 0.8445165753364563, -0.09631697833538055, 0.40220820903778076, 0.37661316990852356, 0.21118034422397614, -0.39679086208343506, -0.19175244867801666, -0.1535373479127884, 0.40757250785827637, 0.3633315861225128, -0.4778970777988434, -0.08436356484889984, 0.04315915331244469, -0.20684288442134857, 0.2905072271823883, -0.5681167244911194, 0.866644561290741, 0.2052876055240631, -0.6511227488517761, 0.4339359402656555, 0.3627173900604248, 1.0791569948196411, -0.4759867489337921, 0.12226253002882004, -0.3639390468597412, 0.24314633011817932, -0.20705027878284454, -0.9634366631507874, 0.21355032920837402, -0.09343745559453964, -0.24789629876613617, -0.1695169359445572, 1.0258433818817139, -0.4153698682785034, -0.1455017775297165, 0.3329022526741028, 0.3731840252876282, 0.03097282163798809, -0.09192659705877304, -0.4819159209728241, 0.04693663492798805, -0.15601611137390137, -0.33223193883895874, 0.6486862301826477, 0.5320520401000977, -0.03489185497164726, 0.6423249840736389, 0.5276380181312561, 0.050269272178411484, -0.25857630372047424, 0.11941270530223846, 0.6850255131721497, -0.7658506631851196, -0.3762597441673279, -1.1738752126693726, 0.24603964388370514, -0.027921412140130997, -0.2943360209465027, 1.10350501537323, 0.6232984662055969, 0.9850117564201355, -0.09163762629032135, 0.5033613443374634, 0.5790594816207886, 0.443311482667923, -0.7556541562080383, 0.6820360422134399, -0.6715245246887207, 0.25836145877838135, -0.1822330206632614, -0.9442617297172546, -0.4673447012901306, 0.20690131187438965, -0.16044309735298157, -0.11149540543556213, 0.3560047745704651, 0.9655923843383789, -0.012188408523797989, -0.07274536043405533, 0.5667596459388733, 0.07149874418973923, 0.3170264959335327, 0.5494377613067627, 0.5136740207672119, -0.3456423580646515, 0.6370481252670288, -0.2845771610736847, 0.07595054060220718, -0.33375224471092224, -1.0432779788970947, -1.3930878639221191, -0.15530134737491608, -0.05343807116150856, -0.02671811170876026, 0.2234543412923813, 0.7472020983695984, 0.42856618762016296, -0.7467177510261536, -0.30916324257850647, -0.023676421493291855, 0.21575325727462769, -0.26370513439178467, -0.22762347757816315, 0.35257217288017273, -0.5693362951278687, -1.0805277824401855, 0.29502633213996887, 0.30089110136032104, 0.10200347006320953, -0.12471732497215271, -0.06810859590768814, 0.05277165398001671, 0.07258922606706619, 0.7093844413757324, 0.09991514682769775, -0.8508574366569519, -0.46628865599632263, 0.3186989724636078, -0.5172284841537476, -0.10449574887752533, 0.8018152117729187, -0.515072226524353, 0.2657316029071808, 0.5996084213256836, 0.6757699847221375, 0.31479471921920776, 0.2784225344657898, 0.6350088119506836, -0.7636770009994507, 0.006929569877684116, -0.04460180178284645, 0.3955344557762146, 0.2778805196285248, -0.40855634212493896, 0.4128474295139313, -0.0171564519405365, -0.8985529541969299, -0.8314568400382996, -0.0663888081908226, -1.094076156616211, -0.257303923368454, 1.2953201532363892, 0.10086339712142944, 0.11108671873807907, -0.06265918910503387, -0.3679385483264923, 0.3841215968132019, 0.014327466487884521, 0.6407878398895264, 0.7886305451393127, -0.23577365279197693, -0.20972314476966858, -0.48867267370224, 0.6339492797851562, 0.6013845205307007, -0.466539591550827, -0.008607403375208378, 0.1787378191947937, 0.23512525856494904, -0.2659960687160492, 0.44685307145118713, 0.42463618516921997, 0.18411096930503845, -0.5606893301010132, -0.5564901232719421, 0.045535873621702194, -0.026203125715255737, -0.4267423748970032, -0.035554394125938416, 0.5098705291748047, -0.10160141438245773 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19928v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19928v2
DiJiang: Efficient Large Language Models through Compact Kernelization
2024-03-29T02:32:15
2024-04-01T09:17:01
Hanting Chen, Zhicheng Liu, Xutao Wang, Yuchuan Tian, Yunhe Wang
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.LG
In an effort to reduce the computational load of Transformers, research on linear attention has gained significant momentum. However, the improvement strategies for attention mechanisms typically necessitate extensive retraining, which is impractical for large language models with a vast array of parameters. In this paper, we present DiJiang, a novel Frequency Domain Kernelization approach that enables the transformation of a pre-trained vanilla Transformer into a linear complexity model with little training costs. By employing a weighted Quasi-Monte Carlo method for sampling, the proposed approach theoretically offers superior approximation efficiency. To further reduce the training computational complexity, our kernelization is based on Discrete Cosine Transform (DCT) operations. Extensive experiments demonstrate that the proposed method achieves comparable performance to the original Transformer, but with significantly reduced training costs and much faster inference speeds. Our DiJiang-7B achieves comparable performance with LLaMA2-7B on various benchmark while requires only about 1/50 training cost. Code is available at https://github.com/YuchuanTian/DiJiang.
[ -0.3744787573814392, -0.7104968428611755, 0.4748513400554657, 0.4615432322025299, -0.35806500911712646, -0.0926530584692955, -0.5901920199394226, -0.19916552305221558, -0.13231207430362701, 0.08317839354276657, -0.3927015960216522, -0.4005962908267975, -0.6855875253677368, -0.11802373081445694, -0.6135186553001404, 0.6618610620498657, 0.21136926114559174, -0.09239336103200912, 0.11636639386415482, 0.22428983449935913, -0.29454872012138367, -0.2903899848461151, -0.6986296772956848, -0.25248652696609497, 0.5067307353019714, 0.16437333822250366, 0.3715258836746216, 0.380370557308197, 0.5707614421844482, 0.41412484645843506, -0.19217140972614288, -0.0634857565164566, -0.7048143148422241, -0.45588478446006775, 0.11433239281177521, -0.39750170707702637, -0.6113063097000122, -0.06871220469474792, 0.5061777830123901, 0.8538404703140259, -0.40998443961143494, 0.08678600937128067, -0.007026475388556719, 0.5462220907211304, -0.45307183265686035, 0.24198493361473083, -0.7900074124336243, -0.02493310533463955, -0.1357000172138214, 0.16913101077079773, -0.7637446522712708, -0.30561473965644836, 0.233414426445961, -0.9564222693443298, 0.251617431640625, -0.14007464051246643, 0.6245735883712769, 0.588825523853302, -0.529796838760376, -0.11548889428377151, -1.034986972808838, 1.354951024055481, -0.5712205767631531, 0.42703038454055786, 0.20405757427215576, 0.6038202047348022, -0.15197250247001648, -1.1227326393127441, -0.8391757607460022, -0.2669491469860077, -0.3371279835700989, 0.16767071187496185, -0.4569335877895355, 0.024790611118078232, 0.367457777261734, 0.3828945457935333, -0.33354780077934265, -0.22683098912239075, -0.2186887413263321, 0.10059873014688492, 0.5320894122123718, -0.09427694976329803, 0.018257632851600647, 0.10587222129106522, -0.48502206802368164, -0.36157941818237305, -0.47548454999923706, 0.07894567400217056, -0.02349236235022545, -0.007411782629787922, -0.14065766334533691, -0.05518612265586853, -0.2398924082517624, 0.7545821666717529, 0.4256575107574463, -0.40132737159729004, 0.15427079796791077, -0.07769130915403366, -0.3467338979244232, 0.07413513213396072, 0.6755678057670593, -0.05273466557264328, 0.18048910796642303, -0.15443190932273865, -0.30924856662750244, 0.0670447051525116, 0.4202140271663666, -0.8726802468299866, -0.6501930356025696, 0.3839889466762543, -0.45409324765205383, -0.2748432457447052, -0.1451665312051773, -0.7102316617965698, 0.09563689678907394, -0.4115089476108551, 0.40613651275634766, -0.5289024114608765, -0.3417254388332367, 0.1995130330324173, 0.24139092862606049, 0.24925705790519714, 0.6078239679336548, -1.1864672899246216, 0.3799351155757904, 0.7116987109184265, 0.5522406101226807, -0.014922546222805977, 0.10759148001670837, -0.4878283441066742, -0.11826018989086151, -0.3754303753376007, 0.5694794654846191, -0.4290868639945984, -0.2416953593492508, -0.22919712960720062, -0.29911306500434875, -0.038250312209129333, -0.5677176713943481, 0.6353507041931152, -0.8053219318389893, -0.15933842957019806, -0.11799748986959457, -0.024761363863945007, -0.2186240702867508, 0.21996742486953735, -0.6727718114852905, 1.0723766088485718, 0.44345512986183167, -0.6842567920684814, 0.19656246900558472, -0.22333548963069916, -0.44359561800956726, 0.009426766075193882, -0.020810114219784737, -0.4566878080368042, 0.06797824800014496, 0.24786560237407684, 0.4896927773952484, -0.45916011929512024, 0.4365758001804352, -0.11891600489616394, -0.6934859156608582, 0.11249092221260071, -0.41226550936698914, 0.7132222652435303, 0.514713704586029, -0.38803088665008545, -0.0693959891796112, -1.1598031520843506, -0.2861659824848175, 0.20779578387737274, -0.2390778809785843, -0.6949928402900696, -0.06281516700983047, 0.24015699326992035, 0.07708786427974701, 0.24038632214069366, -0.5009670853614807, 0.3988189697265625, -0.5196866989135742, 0.4640568494796753, 0.6025295257568359, -0.4849710762500763, 0.7356101870536804, -0.007313319016247988, 0.20443803071975708, 0.2507361173629761, 0.4454030990600586, -0.08884663879871368, -0.18258501589298248, -0.9646985530853271, -0.6409157514572144, 0.3998304605484009, 0.18829433619976044, -1.040171504020691, 0.28672945499420166, -0.48466092348098755, -0.7603236436843872, -0.43040111660957336, -0.11371051520109177, 0.2580147981643677, 0.5024028420448303, 0.462475448846817, -0.02978474460542202, -0.36253291368484497, -0.8434180617332458, 0.3430524170398712, 0.06924670189619064, -0.31632161140441895, -0.01744745299220085, 0.15145158767700195, -0.2951071858406067, 0.9790648818016052, -0.823180079460144, -0.37621843814849854, -0.18296003341674805, -0.030096327885985374, 0.6521167755126953, 0.2953369617462158, 0.8485763072967529, -1.0107179880142212, -0.8427496552467346, 0.280670702457428, -0.41374051570892334, -0.13984541594982147, -0.08978880196809769, 0.08172047138214111, -0.04729242995381355, 0.3896710276603699, -0.4513972997665405, 0.1497390866279602, 0.8147163391113281, 0.17991390824317932, 0.03882823884487152, -0.08722315728664398, 0.025619912892580032, -1.0642662048339844, 0.12411845475435257, 0.10337058454751968, -0.2308529019355774, -0.9718577861785889, -0.3430614769458771, 0.34796521067619324, 0.1814565360546112, -0.4050768315792084, 0.1556379497051239, -0.40066462755203247, 0.30221685767173767, -0.2975071966648102, 0.2242889106273651, -0.11768876761198044, 0.8459041118621826, 0.05227651447057724, 0.6442136168479919, 0.5026758909225464, -0.6112514138221741, 0.39810043573379517, 0.3202170133590698, -0.4719778895378113, 0.4308611750602722, -0.7541603446006775, 0.13105247914791107, -0.20196135342121124, 0.3703831732273102, -1.0411548614501953, 0.05564681813120842, 0.10688433796167374, -0.09342782944440842, 0.41125917434692383, -0.24729789793491364, -0.15601247549057007, -0.364590585231781, -0.3780421316623688, 0.5932332873344421, 0.8464691042900085, -0.8746278882026672, 0.6069784760475159, 0.5091665983200073, 0.04341491311788559, -0.7612507939338684, -0.4454326629638672, -0.15594179928302765, -0.30830395221710205, -0.580980658531189, 0.542388916015625, -0.0003238363715354353, -0.23730579018592834, -0.2232740968465805, -0.022343892604112625, -0.19756878912448883, 0.04546143487095833, -0.26472243666648865, 0.1008179783821106, -0.18799617886543274, 0.14428642392158508, 0.15124377608299255, -0.34874454140663147, -0.17380444705486298, -0.5078862905502319, 0.7372583150863647, 0.18658895790576935, 0.10304278880357742, -0.42016246914863586, 0.10902750492095947, 0.32382047176361084, -0.3173297047615051, 0.5337532162666321, 0.7090451121330261, -0.35107025504112244, -0.8295772671699524, -0.4232586622238159, -0.07220429182052612, -0.5683736801147461, 0.6426917314529419, -0.5004550218582153, -0.8731719851493835, 0.15424208343029022, -0.33755263686180115, 0.04120411351323128, 0.5020162463188171, 0.7246629595756531, 0.12833938002586365, 0.5982622504234314, 0.7269593477249146, -0.12673170864582062, 0.5659042000770569, -0.250040203332901, 0.4752214252948761, -0.6827653050422668, -0.023989234119653702, -0.3740589916706085, -0.1527886837720871, -0.5124322175979614, -0.6546416282653809, 0.5752628445625305, -0.13694120943546295, 0.13266116380691528, 0.7688669562339783, -0.6866282820701599, 0.334969162940979, 0.35621151328086853, -0.0699775367975235, 0.3206050992012024, -0.08803387731313705, 0.3999026119709015, 0.16843701899051666, -0.7198262810707092, -0.26868534088134766, 0.9871791005134583, 0.3757367730140686, 1.0617741346359253, 0.12579677999019623, 0.42698314785957336, -0.011454952880740166, 0.4280516803264618, -0.6758944988250732, 0.4195541441440582, -0.5170232653617859, -0.049037784337997437, -0.49742692708969116, -0.6267770528793335, -0.8591458797454834, 0.4405891001224518, -0.08891122043132782, -0.5153303146362305, 0.21883687376976013, 0.3094037175178528, -0.48697009682655334, 0.06157471984624863, -0.8870652914047241, 0.5626744031906128, 0.15789279341697693, -0.16789251565933228, -0.41255098581314087, -0.36111000180244446, 0.5707017779350281, -0.7529988884925842, 0.24201282858848572, 0.008479433134198189, 0.44395706057548523, 0.5787161588668823, -0.26214173436164856, 0.7489159107208252, -0.27828922867774963, -0.47047480940818787, 0.35309866070747375, -0.22896458208560944, 0.6986402273178101, 0.23876705765724182, 0.08980907499790192, 0.48949724435806274, 0.09193702042102814, -0.2548150420188904, -0.5192914605140686, 0.8081673383712769, -0.7414862513542175, -0.46026015281677246, -0.2761596143245697, -0.5910838842391968, -0.16064900159835815, 0.03370589017868042, 0.04565441980957985, 0.3370039761066437, -0.151829332113266, 0.24666960537433624, 0.9467771649360657, -0.4681693911552429, 0.5654920339584351, 0.2661406993865967, 0.05745193734765053, -0.28361979126930237, 0.8119505643844604, 0.2296496331691742, 0.19799703359603882, 0.8205042481422424, 0.23990309238433838, -0.09410817921161652, -0.4646659195423126, -0.17538942396640778, 0.185612753033638, -0.5518383383750916, -0.157992884516716, -0.7432628870010376, -0.09206091612577438, -0.4921075403690338, -0.04416145384311676, -0.663016140460968, -0.5254698395729065, 0.2004755586385727, 0.323445200920105, 0.2349943220615387, 0.7011809349060059, 0.16380827128887177, 0.7735843062400818, -0.6226910948753357, 0.39629852771759033, 0.5661046504974365, 0.3315815031528473, 0.37187424302101135, -0.6160696744918823, -0.6373337507247925, -0.15445098280906677, -0.352149099111557, -0.18589596450328827, 0.31220605969429016, 0.01275409385561943, 0.41166946291923523, 0.26085007190704346, 0.1961916983127594, 0.647053062915802, -0.7893665432929993, 0.5296937227249146, 0.23765726387500763, -1.19023859500885, 0.03730522841215134, -0.2821272909641266, 0.23536576330661774, 0.23061171174049377, 0.23279905319213867, -0.6532319188117981, -0.13210530579090118, -0.1749884933233261, -0.907284677028656, 1.1058909893035889, 0.27892035245895386, 0.2432912141084671, 0.07252030819654465, 0.3175560534000397, 0.030940530821681023, -0.00046331214252859354, -0.5951178669929504, -0.30403366684913635, -0.20706534385681152, -0.48696961998939514, -0.15946009755134583, -0.5037290453910828, 0.002827949356287718, -0.28250572085380554, 0.6509451270103455, -0.02765662968158722, 0.2630763351917267, 0.17714740335941315, -0.19437186419963837, 0.0744457095861435, 0.10374286025762558, 0.696187436580658, 0.31816765666007996, -0.09065062552690506, 0.3294703960418701, 0.5060814023017883, -0.8430992960929871, 0.18155984580516815, 0.12426302582025528, 0.10597004741430283, -0.09293941408395767, 0.2860797643661499, 0.46214449405670166, 0.36145541071891785, -0.35585153102874756, 0.6743226051330566, -0.4503442049026489, -0.21233943104743958, -0.5771121978759766, 0.036578722298145294, 0.2080095410346985, 0.30847322940826416, 0.43740954995155334, -0.3183656930923462, 0.176125168800354, -0.010347441770136356, 0.37266477942466736, 0.09989005327224731, -0.273499995470047, -0.5189481973648071, 0.8575582504272461, 0.38000059127807617, 0.15153948962688446, 0.5347798466682434, -0.0031104180961847305, -0.1709379106760025, 0.5325711369514465, 0.42752209305763245, 0.8206402063369751, -0.5175585746765137, -0.08800636231899261, 0.5057505369186401, 0.3215312957763672, -0.04788661748170853, -0.22700487077236176, -0.2650608420372009, -0.5261672139167786, -0.715776801109314, -0.8847644329071045, -0.22743625938892365, 0.07761149108409882, -0.38448455929756165, 0.5424897074699402, -0.41260769963264465, 0.004819830879569054, 0.19680669903755188, -0.19306591153144836, -0.34838029742240906, 0.4684232771396637, 0.277617484331131, 0.7721618413925171, -0.6149834990501404, 1.6018686294555664, 0.26575952768325806, 0.07350502163171768, -0.7875507473945618, 0.06530532985925674, -0.38617509603500366, -0.5309397578239441, 0.703843891620636, 0.10034482926130295, -0.07216587662696838, 0.1250762939453125, -0.26652711629867554, -0.8483530879020691, 1.2131617069244385, 0.39398008584976196, -1.1826577186584473, 0.23211592435836792, 0.36298391222953796, 0.5551619529724121, 0.08619906008243561, 0.33719977736473083, 0.6583740711212158, 0.28895971179008484, 0.22041696310043335, -0.9595714807510376, -0.10587093979120255, -0.10007758438587189, 0.3644104599952698, 0.3957360088825226, -1.1036655902862549, 1.2018381357192993, 0.1658274084329605, -0.21502941846847534, -0.2734263837337494, 0.8810422420501709, -0.17099261283874512, 0.11800894141197205, 0.931617796421051, 0.4311579465866089, 0.5684543251991272, -0.2332339584827423, 0.7828578948974609, -0.44871366024017334, 0.8654462099075317, 0.6763601899147034, -0.4062008857727051, 0.49560320377349854, 0.617977499961853, -0.46783342957496643, 0.08970315754413605, 0.2823387086391449, 0.05253637582063675, 0.8719311356544495, 0.36346930265426636, -0.4600444734096527, -0.21134132146835327, 0.290113627910614, -0.14481905102729797, 0.5525663495063782, 0.037848860025405884, -0.025635067373514175, -0.2949853539466858, -0.029351485893130302, 0.07188168168067932, 0.18716713786125183, -0.05218993499875069, 0.5867822170257568, 0.3381975293159485, -0.473998099565506, 0.8750256896018982, 0.3236365020275116, 0.8429578542709351, -0.8638113141059875, -0.17644235491752625, -0.2572402358055115, 0.5158298015594482, -0.016700921580195427, -0.17276376485824585, 0.4702945947647095, -0.040099095553159714, -0.16404397785663605, -0.2707372307777405, 0.4639810025691986, -0.616454541683197, -0.42948928475379944, 0.3727814257144928, -0.33014947175979614, -0.2146124392747879, -0.13300254940986633, -0.12548068165779114, 0.21420778334140778, 0.07317188382148743, -0.606277585029602, 0.282562792301178, 0.5572910308837891, -0.24774320423603058, 0.3441483676433563, 0.6615129113197327, -0.2945495545864105, -0.04143933579325676, -0.07768332213163376, 1.064250111579895, -0.43221190571784973, -0.361066073179245, -0.8072407841682434, 0.43963301181793213, 0.003759062848985195, -0.013451972976326942, 0.582628607749939, 0.3750219941139221, 0.9874644875526428, -0.40460044145584106, 0.722338855266571, -0.21300143003463745, 0.3347279727458954, -0.5068129301071167, 0.9476010203361511, -0.42775481939315796, 0.3670744299888611, -0.33111467957496643, -1.0296248197555542, -0.310191810131073, 0.7225980758666992, -0.39983558654785156, 0.034848131239414215, 0.6553605794906616, 0.6482862830162048, -0.2958256006240845, -0.25395509600639343, 0.8639388084411621, 0.43662357330322266, 0.6118943095207214, 0.9475874304771423, 0.5882794260978699, -0.6695735454559326, 0.612881064414978, -0.7295770049095154, -0.5970200896263123, -0.027847137302160263, -0.7683565616607666, -0.9939038157463074, -0.7622987031936646, -0.14376099407672882, 0.06451045721769333, -0.3240395188331604, 0.829998254776001, 0.8045268654823303, -0.8480637073516846, -0.10886216163635254, 0.25108855962753296, -0.2000698745250702, -0.24192273616790771, -0.11868410557508469, 0.6573652625083923, -0.4205350875854492, -1.4033335447311401, 0.24931928515434265, 0.328717440366745, -0.3135356307029724, -0.1246504932641983, 0.11747085303068161, 0.06940221041440964, 0.16504502296447754, 0.946983814239502, -0.30031681060791016, -0.3315025269985199, -0.3788498640060425, 0.06491099298000336, -0.21261601150035858, 0.054749682545661926, 0.5528178811073303, -0.6889651417732239, 0.32464301586151123, 0.21314121782779694, 0.5218287706375122, 0.7154433727264404, -0.13403236865997314, 0.35830453038215637, -0.7658002376556396, 0.7416269183158875, -0.07319356501102448, 0.23635117709636688, 0.18279607594013214, -0.2618069648742676, 0.4375724494457245, 0.2781115174293518, -0.43123409152030945, -0.6532110571861267, 0.018659697845578194, -1.4609895944595337, -0.11091292649507523, 1.2004755735397339, -0.14444294571876526, -0.6539878845214844, -0.0416061133146286, -0.4318559169769287, 0.25333648920059204, -0.22835128009319305, 1.1723921298980713, 0.5053499937057495, 0.4869241714477539, 0.05024643614888191, -0.3976324796676636, 0.5645750164985657, 0.21866539120674133, -0.6299934387207031, 0.1879357248544693, 0.0629899874329567, 0.25338855385780334, 0.21063527464866638, 0.6818038821220398, -0.1310398131608963, 0.09576945751905441, 0.14117732644081116, 0.3566974699497223, 0.1913153976202011, -0.2518019676208496, -0.30146998167037964, -0.012392483651638031, 0.00801757536828518, -0.1184382364153862 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19913v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19913v1
MANGO: A Benchmark for Evaluating Mapping and Navigation Abilities of Large Language Models
2024-03-29T01:53:24
2024-03-29T01:53:24
Peng Ding, Jiading Fang, Peng Li, Kangrui Wang, Xiaochen Zhou, Mo Yu, Jing Li, Matthew R. Walter, Hongyuan Mei
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.RO
Large language models such as ChatGPT and GPT-4 have recently achieved astonishing performance on a variety of natural language processing tasks. In this paper, we propose MANGO, a benchmark to evaluate their capabilities to perform text-based mapping and navigation. Our benchmark includes 53 mazes taken from a suite of textgames: each maze is paired with a walkthrough that visits every location but does not cover all possible paths. The task is question-answering: for each maze, a large language model reads the walkthrough and answers hundreds of mapping and navigation questions such as "How should you go to Attic from West of House?" and "Where are we if we go north and east from Cellar?". Although these questions are easy to humans, it turns out that even GPT-4, the best-to-date language model, performs poorly at answering them. Further, our experiments suggest that a strong mapping and navigation ability would benefit large language models in performing relevant downstream tasks, such as playing textgames. Our MANGO benchmark will facilitate future research on methods that improve the mapping and navigation capabilities of language models. We host our leaderboard, data, code, and evaluation program at https://mango.ttic.edu and https://github.com/oaklight/mango/.
[ -0.39179450273513794, -1.0303677320480347, 0.6862091422080994, 0.3458879590034485, -0.24225644767284393, 0.12290419638156891, -0.424844890832901, -0.27451613545417786, -0.1828867793083191, 0.6225109100341797, -0.2661890983581543, -0.6633968949317932, -0.5734117031097412, 0.10513948649168015, -0.5262688398361206, 0.7371902465820312, -0.10566555708646774, -0.42992886900901794, -0.20479542016983032, -0.17286504805088043, -0.9404800534248352, -0.4065740406513214, -0.7805268168449402, -0.16268275678157806, 0.31011682748794556, 0.3406578302383423, 0.8466487526893616, 0.5718503594398499, 0.45180457830429077, 0.299905389547348, 0.1331772655248642, 0.046365972608327866, -0.6929113864898682, 0.38734298944473267, -0.264694482088089, -0.42797866463661194, -0.29354456067085266, 0.04844384640455246, 0.4485093951225281, 0.39952388405799866, -0.13557752966880798, 0.2096565216779709, 0.017872624099254608, 0.6757662892341614, -0.26368623971939087, 0.4235186278820038, -0.6124969124794006, -0.03786999359726906, -0.36355161666870117, 0.02080678381025791, -0.31981322169303894, -0.7481594681739807, 0.18438979983329773, -0.7190658450126648, -0.16165442764759064, 0.366824746131897, 0.788200855255127, 0.2594936788082123, -0.7522268295288086, -0.18279503285884857, -0.5302959084510803, 0.890739917755127, -0.4324221909046173, 0.548517107963562, 0.6381953358650208, 0.6741001009941101, -0.20589487254619598, -0.6270527243614197, -0.4550411105155945, -0.2311438024044037, 0.30042514204978943, 0.023247571662068367, -0.15018054842948914, -0.04279215633869171, 0.22517968714237213, 0.09753496944904327, -0.6531298756599426, -0.2803078889846802, -0.2332499623298645, -0.09787862002849579, 0.6505478024482727, 0.11383676528930664, 0.6335384249687195, -0.09860622882843018, -0.15869037806987762, -0.05075475573539734, -0.6127570867538452, 0.15898263454437256, -0.050161655992269516, 0.09952152520418167, -0.09747222810983658, 0.7405473589897156, -0.16217154264450073, 0.8906581401824951, -0.4190134108066559, -0.13734690845012665, 0.32608047127723694, -0.5584501028060913, -0.0032794992439448833, -0.13790279626846313, 0.8946639895439148, 0.7669920921325684, 0.699671745300293, -0.3532378077507019, -0.25602176785469055, -0.03268172964453697, 0.2933688163757324, -0.7694317698478699, -0.4472896456718445, 0.19781021773815155, -0.24043746292591095, 0.22477994859218597, -0.490549236536026, -1.0823529958724976, -0.6766976714134216, 0.17976480722427368, 0.5913444757461548, -0.6228504180908203, -0.20482434332370758, 0.07626601308584213, -0.14711157977581024, 0.40769731998443604, 0.20593790709972382, -0.9545822143554688, 0.6279512047767639, 0.8913114070892334, 1.0023512840270996, -0.3423479497432709, -0.45064079761505127, -0.697551429271698, -0.15679162740707397, -0.4790850877761841, 0.6145331263542175, -0.83045893907547, -0.6261219382286072, -0.19436301290988922, -0.4039202928543091, -0.3638656437397003, -0.6365980505943298, 0.7783418893814087, -0.18887417018413544, -0.006372109521180391, -0.27213382720947266, -0.4248945713043213, -0.5273657441139221, 0.5801342129707336, -0.5249277949333191, 1.261650800704956, 0.06879059970378876, -0.44663116335868835, -0.0654507428407669, -0.665402352809906, -0.6322730183601379, -0.004527450073510408, -0.2306218296289444, -0.08841440081596375, 0.029675208032131195, 0.6298249363899231, 0.3154986500740051, -0.8123716115951538, 0.4527440071105957, 0.1472722738981247, -0.4892151951789856, 0.2332216203212738, -0.31178411841392517, 0.5795119404792786, 0.14826832711696625, -0.5476619601249695, -0.08924025297164917, -0.5862987637519836, 0.05394710972905159, 0.10517127066850662, -0.5989647507667542, -0.2953411340713501, 0.35655951499938965, -0.09173483401536942, 0.24516627192497253, 0.2217545062303543, -0.48599258065223694, 0.3568832278251648, -0.33711957931518555, 0.24714308977127075, 0.4150696396827698, -0.005153475794941187, 0.3031540513038635, -0.2774368226528168, 0.7212294936180115, -0.20092058181762695, 0.05485288053750992, -0.4740177392959595, -1.2701001167297363, -0.6304250955581665, -0.10595796257257462, 0.3889544904232025, 0.6122793555259705, -0.9043926000595093, 0.11785224080085754, -0.589221179485321, -0.725340723991394, -0.6561793684959412, -0.10353118181228638, 0.3487913906574249, 0.7239210605621338, 0.5443397760391235, -0.40944114327430725, -0.3708021938800812, -0.7005186080932617, -0.4615182876586914, -0.14610596001148224, -0.08953441679477692, 0.6128267645835876, 0.47240591049194336, -0.3190971612930298, 0.9767211675643921, -0.3295637369155884, -0.020625608041882515, -0.09638771414756775, 0.07236205041408539, 0.2750402092933655, 0.20578981935977936, 0.3905434310436249, -0.9099665284156799, -0.5551302433013916, 0.19068589806556702, -0.5856592655181885, -0.23830220103263855, 0.2199263721704483, -0.058604080229997635, -0.3024299740791321, 0.2000511735677719, -0.5731722116470337, 0.24848133325576782, 0.7010613679885864, -0.4361620545387268, 0.3898908793926239, -0.1840684711933136, 0.639083206653595, -0.8253607153892517, 0.1445031613111496, -0.1561380922794342, -0.27340587973594666, -0.6029254198074341, 0.18046291172504425, 0.06004711613059044, -0.256399929523468, -0.21717318892478943, 0.7377489805221558, -0.3026507496833801, -0.17384208738803864, 0.0981132835149765, 0.47584953904151917, -0.1067083477973938, 0.5251802802085876, -0.19624778628349304, 1.024989366531372, 0.706233561038971, -0.5595220327377319, 0.4555519223213196, 0.1315283626317978, -0.5071695446968079, 0.5952005386352539, -0.5584275722503662, 0.15411482751369476, 0.11754677444696426, 0.23971454799175262, -1.3080374002456665, 0.18303805589675903, 0.06707395613193512, -0.4248739182949066, -0.21746711432933807, -0.113152414560318, -0.5137640833854675, -0.40642204880714417, -0.26670295000076294, 0.5687362551689148, 0.9064006209373474, -0.32265159487724304, 0.9120898842811584, 0.6427870988845825, -0.21780820190906525, -0.26771214604377747, -0.638634443283081, 0.38207510113716125, -0.28892141580581665, -0.5745397806167603, -0.03176445886492729, -0.15329045057296753, 0.02672397904098034, -0.20562700927257538, -0.06276049464941025, -0.12400850653648376, 0.18634165823459625, 0.4894678592681885, -0.04935794323682785, -0.3214104175567627, -0.0689118504524231, -0.29309022426605225, -0.13485606014728546, 0.08104152977466583, -0.36307257413864136, 0.5876092314720154, -0.07783636450767517, -0.11004895716905594, 0.1578681915998459, 0.07558482140302658, 0.5608536005020142, -0.7965680360794067, 0.41844800114631653, 0.1153431236743927, -0.3188462555408478, 0.10881637781858444, -0.5455120801925659, 0.31514015793800354, -0.4263938069343567, 0.38049060106277466, -0.6186356544494629, -0.6053007245063782, 0.41813409328460693, -0.29072919487953186, 0.19989773631095886, 0.4119109809398651, 0.48766985535621643, 0.19714072346687317, 0.9040332436561584, 0.36390647292137146, -0.233536496758461, -0.0484621487557888, -0.11113660037517548, 0.29984331130981445, -0.8042083382606506, -0.3674871027469635, -0.9274634718894958, -0.3991735279560089, -0.567839503288269, -0.9860783219337463, 0.2595680356025696, -0.2166912853717804, -0.2194775640964508, 0.4449107348918915, -0.30171915888786316, 0.6452111601829529, 0.5324718952178955, -0.3166006803512573, 0.39223265647888184, -0.44159722328186035, -0.6188727021217346, -0.12110089510679245, -0.7437106966972351, -0.3910340368747711, 1.2336525917053223, 0.23826685547828674, 0.6305635571479797, 0.16276173293590546, 0.6860716938972473, -0.07882526516914368, 0.3425903022289276, -0.5303946733474731, 0.8772733211517334, 0.04619520530104637, -0.6687136292457581, -0.367262601852417, -0.6245298981666565, -1.194093108177185, 0.4080682694911957, -0.14423924684524536, -1.0890928506851196, -0.2632887065410614, -0.14162425696849823, -0.14261561632156372, 0.16435027122497559, -0.8508895635604858, 1.0957566499710083, -0.48477575182914734, -0.24616362154483795, -0.08455398678779602, -0.4462759494781494, 0.3697510361671448, -0.3395308256149292, 0.6678824424743652, -0.22195759415626526, -0.3596937954425812, 0.8111774921417236, -0.09671812504529953, 0.24663709104061127, -0.09988146275281906, -0.0171589907258749, 0.2786017954349518, 0.39436110854148865, 0.297834575176239, -0.29360929131507874, -0.2543882131576538, 0.06305326521396637, -0.11629793792963028, -0.17657968401908875, -0.49547436833381653, 0.8596208095550537, -0.6344737410545349, -0.42590779066085815, -0.3871191143989563, -0.4283450245857239, -0.48429620265960693, 0.3276846408843994, 0.01010396983474493, 0.4507935643196106, -0.24390700459480286, 0.1687633991241455, 0.5845217108726501, -0.42376065254211426, 0.3651845455169678, 0.33655092120170593, -0.8629814982414246, -0.12043337523937225, 1.1343621015548706, 0.15173953771591187, -0.17173786461353302, 0.5066468119621277, 0.22134137153625488, -0.6910128593444824, -0.8582268357276917, -0.5510075688362122, 0.0023023139219731092, -0.48925691843032837, -0.04126710817217827, -0.5461362600326538, -0.029242416843771935, 0.1217469647526741, 0.014547020196914673, -0.476297527551651, -0.2549334466457367, 0.3105252683162689, 0.11603665351867676, 0.059707753360271454, 0.8675940632820129, 0.4298282265663147, -0.05210444703698158, -0.7114071249961853, 0.5690750479698181, 0.458060085773468, 0.5009194016456604, 0.05115439370274544, -0.2850172519683838, -0.11915842443704605, -0.0007272501825354993, -0.3379046320915222, -1.0800074338912964, 0.0500418022274971, 0.18708918988704681, 0.514315128326416, 0.0005852684262208641, -0.13132894039154053, 0.5034013390541077, -0.8510903716087341, 1.0163021087646484, -0.03756039962172508, -0.9212169051170349, 0.5073429942131042, -0.4921516478061676, 0.6842842698097229, 0.6783441305160522, 0.33560794591903687, -0.7414466142654419, -0.5531843304634094, -0.30214065313339233, -0.7857266664505005, 0.3228699564933777, 0.5262925028800964, -0.1604100465774536, -0.11416950821876526, 0.1224023774266243, -0.05477255582809448, 0.3167891800403595, -0.5789843797683716, -0.07780385762453079, -0.060473669320344925, -0.2649179697036743, -0.6690177321434021, -0.011860557831823826, 0.22712182998657227, -0.19034798443317413, 0.48760828375816345, 0.17851564288139343, -0.059348009526729584, -0.11493688076734543, -0.0906195342540741, 0.1381567418575287, 0.13444668054580688, 0.24023796617984772, 0.6726215481758118, -0.12084989994764328, 0.2506893575191498, 0.09546200931072235, -0.6642518043518066, 0.3035939335823059, 0.3929841220378876, -0.14412084221839905, -0.16617168486118317, 0.22685600817203522, 0.4203377962112427, 0.39917197823524475, -1.0471254587173462, 0.5161744952201843, -0.3889034688472748, 0.16451260447502136, 0.5182814002037048, 0.3555724322795868, 0.400377482175827, 0.13073448836803436, 0.32035359740257263, -0.21630121767520905, 0.40540122985839844, -0.6142299175262451, 0.01345750130712986, 0.31466206908226013, -0.3007136583328247, -0.061440806835889816, 0.9675665497779846, 0.5929661989212036, -0.7535132169723511, 0.762691855430603, -0.050931692123413086, -0.6019860506057739, 0.5750986337661743, 0.33599570393562317, 0.7788827419281006, -0.44402986764907837, 0.137907937169075, 0.4740520417690277, 0.6353487968444824, -0.16885457932949066, 0.2843818664550781, -0.23504169285297394, -0.2652120292186737, -0.3531632423400879, -0.5650205612182617, -0.3915765881538391, -0.23411205410957336, -0.028488146141171455, 0.05500809848308563, -0.0063976929523050785, -0.11715538054704666, -0.25601065158843994, 0.12422610074281693, -0.836933434009552, 0.46903204917907715, 0.05074099823832512, 1.1314754486083984, -0.5926027297973633, 0.8736675381660461, 0.5549476742744446, -0.09471765905618668, -0.7552942037582397, 0.042394351214170456, -0.0966256633400917, -0.5826987028121948, 0.12244829535484314, 0.3833237886428833, -0.18870390951633453, 0.09947096556425095, -0.16320209205150604, -0.678859293460846, 0.9144273400306702, 0.20876750349998474, -0.7363618016242981, 0.15250727534294128, 0.3143678605556488, 0.5992372035980225, -0.1820163130760193, 0.49208807945251465, 0.9004512429237366, 0.5884333848953247, -0.13613055646419525, -1.1341325044631958, 0.05359739437699318, -0.3214794993400574, 0.1612447053194046, 0.3919670283794403, -0.3804360628128052, 0.7637889385223389, -0.10153308510780334, -0.22852079570293427, 0.2558998167514801, 0.32638654112815857, 0.16450875997543335, 0.2572387754917145, 0.39922744035720825, 0.5511655807495117, 0.9400859475135803, -0.3972966969013214, 1.3843213319778442, -0.2784835398197174, 0.25264766812324524, 1.008630633354187, -0.2865549325942993, 1.1045681238174438, 0.37481552362442017, -0.18871256709098816, 0.2859761714935303, 0.5473195314407349, 0.3642984628677368, 0.6647929549217224, 0.5637384057044983, 0.11707469820976257, 0.11727133393287659, 0.15071098506450653, -0.36694666743278503, 0.42495661973953247, 0.3291454613208771, 0.15840862691402435, -0.3501066267490387, 0.08642149716615677, 0.017990775406360626, 0.15130655467510223, -0.22298994660377502, 0.5431760549545288, -0.03710152953863144, -1.1266987323760986, 0.627638041973114, 0.12562133371829987, 0.42707559466362, -0.7582101821899414, -0.04797552153468132, -0.5458002686500549, -0.04329879954457283, 0.24022354185581207, -1.018140196800232, -0.054982010275125504, 0.1629793494939804, 0.5359518527984619, 0.006039642263203859, 0.37058937549591064, -0.45870018005371094, -0.22012433409690857, 0.2829030156135559, 0.4517113268375397, 0.27438342571258545, -0.14336523413658142, -0.7070444822311401, 0.3444646894931793, -0.01433870941400528, -0.33139219880104065, -0.018130376935005188, 0.5118122100830078, -0.014088689349591732, 1.0006794929504395, 0.36051100492477417, -0.1633102297782898, 0.22896230220794678, -0.3197527527809143, 0.5168534517288208, -0.7776303291320801, -0.6578974723815918, -0.9679776430130005, 0.4055693745613098, -0.0975189134478569, -0.5527573823928833, 1.083166480064392, 1.157857894897461, 0.35161247849464417, 0.1198565661907196, 0.7092095017433167, 0.08382648229598999, 0.2793179154396057, -0.4843674600124359, 0.6213635206222534, -0.5278650522232056, 0.2978464663028717, -0.3076387047767639, -1.3261812925338745, -0.12410744279623032, 0.5663897395133972, -0.5173811912536621, 0.15329596400260925, 0.8069030046463013, 0.6375771760940552, -0.3260350823402405, 0.05212940648198128, 0.38629260659217834, 0.5229420065879822, 0.4803703725337982, 1.0690889358520508, 0.7652857303619385, -0.4151110053062439, 0.5894356966018677, 0.055195942521095276, -0.34295159578323364, -0.16103151440620422, -0.820632815361023, -0.946132481098175, -0.9121339321136475, -0.17842793464660645, -0.17687879502773285, 0.3318614065647125, 0.47113072872161865, 0.7185170650482178, -0.4429742991924286, -0.49264317750930786, 0.032688725739717484, 0.2588486671447754, -0.2541375458240509, -0.09286093711853027, 0.3080727458000183, 0.06008259579539299, -0.6103561520576477, 0.5306296944618225, 0.7487552165985107, -0.17260776460170746, -0.1368328183889389, -0.15577979385852814, -0.38579505681991577, 0.37525296211242676, 0.4628690183162689, 0.33121249079704285, -0.41706085205078125, -0.09261301159858704, -0.011694351211190224, -0.1751122623682022, 0.23884980380535126, 0.6706581115722656, -0.9307583570480347, 0.8569049835205078, 0.23968012630939484, 1.0485936403274536, 0.7923433184623718, -0.01689259707927704, 0.6390928030014038, -0.5021434426307678, -0.10023471713066101, 0.22191882133483887, 0.2729446589946747, 0.5610869526863098, 0.23168893158435822, 0.723029613494873, -0.2156858891248703, -0.6342132091522217, -0.4452607035636902, 0.0075330412946641445, -0.922031044960022, -0.09571172297000885, 1.1196781396865845, -0.033921048045158386, -0.45445340871810913, -0.3898265063762665, -0.7480667233467102, -0.13620275259017944, -0.2592807412147522, 0.6651905179023743, 0.8814079761505127, 0.12478777021169662, -0.07423681765794754, -0.9667234420776367, 0.47715073823928833, 0.2346176952123642, -1.0618491172790527, 0.009353000670671463, 0.32725077867507935, 0.1895536631345749, -0.06129138916730881, 1.1114811897277832, 0.061619773507118225, 0.2958165407180786, -0.021528244018554688, -0.30514654517173767, 0.2199159860610962, -0.32960808277130127, -0.17077049612998962, 0.22682100534439087, 0.18971993029117584, -0.46444275975227356 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19889v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19889v1
Towards a Robust Retrieval-Based Summarization System
2024-03-29T00:14:46
2024-03-29T00:14:46
Shengjie Liu, Jing Wu, Jingyuan Bao, Wenyi Wang, Naira Hovakimyan, Christopher G Healey
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
This paper describes an investigation of the robustness of large language models (LLMs) for retrieval augmented generation (RAG)-based summarization tasks. While LLMs provide summarization capabilities, their performance in complex, real-world scenarios remains under-explored. Our first contribution is LogicSumm, an innovative evaluation framework incorporating realistic scenarios to assess LLM robustness during RAG-based summarization. Based on limitations identified by LogiSumm, we then developed SummRAG, a comprehensive system to create training dialogues and fine-tune a model to enhance robustness within LogicSumm's scenarios. SummRAG is an example of our goal of defining structured methods to test the capabilities of an LLM, rather than addressing issues in a one-off fashion. Experimental results confirm the power of SummRAG, showcasing improved logical coherence and summarization quality. Data, corresponding model weights, and Python code are available online.
[ -0.07261987030506134, -0.6385235786437988, 0.309026837348938, 0.11484343558549881, -0.2523782253265381, 0.26974910497665405, -0.15304209291934967, -0.34420162439346313, 0.2675393521785736, 0.5258774161338806, -0.11310844123363495, -0.1885632574558258, -0.6515976786613464, 0.32781705260276794, -0.7611156702041626, 1.2362462282180786, 0.17515511810779572, -0.11395692080259323, -0.2866257429122925, -0.3427168130874634, -0.5710718631744385, -0.8153311014175415, -0.37624675035476685, -0.304159939289093, 0.30295509099960327, 0.11044289171695709, 0.6098277568817139, 0.3104972541332245, 0.7264658808708191, 0.30840864777565, -0.3822910785675049, 0.2429911345243454, -0.8573783040046692, 0.7040242552757263, -0.18170705437660217, -0.6567673683166504, -0.8587207198143005, -0.31651321053504944, 0.7943234443664551, 0.6103518009185791, -0.35202714800834656, 0.26149410009384155, 0.1933814436197281, 0.4780861437320709, -0.7474350929260254, -0.11140616983175278, -0.8690639734268188, -0.2485409528017044, 0.03602144494652748, -0.25235438346862793, -0.5632359385490417, -0.2881213426589966, -0.18363553285598755, -0.2927308976650238, 0.08659888803958893, 0.1914442926645279, 0.8952828645706177, 0.3726819157600403, -0.27651143074035645, -0.40054577589035034, -0.6220855116844177, 0.8795589804649353, -0.9084826111793518, 0.28321895003318787, 0.3482789397239685, 0.47352656722068787, -0.2606000006198883, -0.8476553559303284, -0.3454155921936035, -0.20999258756637573, -0.06553211808204651, 0.3038468658924103, 0.028566140681505203, -0.3143112361431122, 0.21429909765720367, 0.602720320224762, -0.6315962672233582, -0.04998888447880745, -0.12053194642066956, -0.11756983399391174, 0.5527293086051941, 0.5025478601455688, 0.3112994134426117, -0.2655094563961029, -0.22261802852153778, 0.18121924996376038, -0.7298834919929504, -0.19596002995967865, 0.3313697278499603, 0.5038629770278931, -0.13214480876922607, 1.0014792680740356, -0.2368478924036026, 0.8165448307991028, -0.20411008596420288, -0.5807520747184753, -0.05091473087668419, -0.5105515718460083, -0.22329667210578918, -0.0867503359913826, 0.5006674528121948, 0.4046019911766052, 0.12356758862733841, -0.06276057660579681, -0.7193461060523987, -0.06828393042087555, 0.31405699253082275, -0.9597983360290527, -0.07346924394369125, 0.3129429221153259, -0.4561674892902374, -0.583702802658081, -0.025178562849760056, -0.4574630558490753, -0.31730595231056213, -0.07202067971229553, 0.6832466721534729, -0.41691088676452637, -0.1715625524520874, 0.08478477597236633, -0.3048937916755676, 0.15534982085227966, 0.31812986731529236, -0.8449692130088806, 0.38138988614082336, 0.8316562175750732, 0.9502810835838318, -0.3126150369644165, 0.013473214581608772, -0.9066369533538818, 0.3401060998439789, -0.27327457070350647, 0.877810001373291, -0.3010518550872803, -0.428995817899704, -0.13716059923171997, -0.2151777744293213, 0.02363257296383381, -0.8846509456634521, 0.5726397633552551, -0.7384204864501953, 0.20866546034812927, 0.0011026812717318535, -0.7109774947166443, 0.05148337036371231, 0.5418219566345215, -0.6659383773803711, 0.8499123454093933, 0.1930883675813675, -1.177114486694336, 0.12635007500648499, -0.15003077685832977, -0.5700711011886597, -0.03898027539253235, -0.17896074056625366, -0.5001710057258606, 0.12042178958654404, 0.05542517453432083, 0.39311617612838745, -0.03927157074213028, 0.39405956864356995, -0.19042079150676727, -0.5747995972633362, 0.25658726692199707, -0.33626601099967957, 0.8040211796760559, 0.36917173862457275, 0.20395077764987946, 0.07425472140312195, -0.7215317487716675, -0.17246519029140472, 0.06822388619184494, -0.685275673866272, -0.42025482654571533, 0.09054969996213913, -0.03571468964219093, -0.1138007715344429, 0.42210230231285095, -0.10187258571386337, 0.11019733548164368, -0.5401896238327026, 0.06281421333551407, 0.4286291301250458, 0.031961631029844284, 0.2504669427871704, -0.7716562151908875, 0.7170373797416687, -0.2384377419948578, -0.35061466693878174, -0.6328634023666382, -0.15871229767799377, -0.5684263706207275, -0.5757527947425842, 0.47275570034980774, 0.7967237234115601, -0.7853838801383972, 0.43075627088546753, -0.41475167870521545, -0.33766934275627136, 0.07599267363548279, 0.13092246651649475, 0.31862109899520874, 0.8514903783798218, 0.12249615043401718, -0.18574361503124237, -0.6884604692459106, -0.6097827553749084, -0.3943279981613159, -0.27337977290153503, -0.286386102437973, -0.07554922997951508, 0.570159375667572, -0.07089869678020477, 0.783378541469574, -0.37745559215545654, 0.016981707885861397, -0.7694032788276672, -0.010270478203892708, 0.495186448097229, 0.31963497400283813, 0.4288514256477356, -0.702570915222168, -0.283467173576355, -0.19973881542682648, -0.8912979960441589, -0.2846095860004425, 0.011783949099481106, 0.14634756743907928, 0.23235031962394714, 0.5902746319770813, -0.49718141555786133, 0.46311625838279724, 0.30607303977012634, -0.008334306068718433, 0.7701101303100586, -0.2235104888677597, -0.009183667600154877, -1.3858031034469604, 0.4052148163318634, -0.38358640670776367, -0.5160419344902039, -0.39036130905151367, 0.34692469239234924, -0.014189068228006363, -0.17728708684444427, -0.2989506125450134, 0.5331376791000366, -0.34683534502983093, -0.3170603811740875, -0.47040873765945435, 0.34462299942970276, 0.09490124136209488, 0.09285293519496918, -0.1926712840795517, 0.896765947341919, 0.22512304782867432, -0.7275373339653015, 0.21514761447906494, 0.33438825607299805, -0.34767699241638184, 0.8814657926559448, -0.9002959132194519, -0.2594284415245056, -0.32181766629219055, 0.3656925857067108, -0.9266183972358704, -0.5639002323150635, -0.17196229100227356, -0.6113963723182678, 0.6175197958946228, -0.09241687506437302, -0.5374787449836731, 0.10761572420597076, -0.39754346013069153, 0.2640819549560547, 0.46682313084602356, -0.379457950592041, 0.6604695916175842, 0.6643040776252747, -0.6663514375686646, -0.6827899217605591, -0.481082558631897, 0.2639754116535187, -0.4803861677646637, -0.5497399568557739, 0.01618312858045101, 0.02616485394537449, -0.5550367832183838, -0.23627795279026031, -0.1597495973110199, 0.07381896674633026, 0.3462117314338684, 0.03961765021085739, 0.5016801953315735, -0.021514536812901497, 0.047800686210393906, -0.05108219012618065, -0.062144313007593155, -0.11014541238546371, -0.07788388431072235, 0.3913886547088623, -0.1003837063908577, -0.2646525204181671, 0.07846303284168243, 0.4047183692455292, 0.3824722170829773, -0.35532307624816895, 0.5808217525482178, 0.43940433859825134, -0.5366412997245789, -0.33564886450767517, -0.3618679940700531, -0.04046392813324928, -0.45360901951789856, 0.52884441614151, -0.25114256143569946, -0.946793258190155, 0.7902489900588989, -0.10070653259754181, 0.27153751254081726, 0.3756362497806549, 0.6768189072608948, -0.24484480917453766, 0.9133103489875793, 0.627083957195282, 0.03185447305440903, 0.24961532652378082, -0.12236465513706207, 0.0324079655110836, -0.8857585787773132, -0.15196357667446136, -0.7255484461784363, -0.15051431953907013, -0.2949022352695465, -0.20019522309303284, 0.6559069752693176, 0.2468731552362442, -0.12950685620307922, 0.10839924216270447, -0.13428433239459991, 0.5079064965248108, 0.1492401659488678, -0.21067842841148376, 0.6630995869636536, -0.03148254007101059, -0.18950386345386505, -0.0401318296790123, -0.8247756361961365, -0.7610090970993042, 0.8770194053649902, 0.17043839395046234, 1.1271519660949707, 0.45928359031677246, 0.5575128197669983, 0.2820323407649994, 0.44955915212631226, -0.829428493976593, 0.5803131461143494, -0.13807237148284912, -0.5579317212104797, -0.29461386799812317, -0.5882039666175842, -1.100448727607727, 0.38621869683265686, -0.28382501006126404, -0.7056742310523987, -0.27841708064079285, 0.022078027948737144, -0.42368438839912415, 0.28440552949905396, -0.33292797207832336, 0.4156641960144043, -0.16776396334171295, -0.33619096875190735, -0.11598998308181763, -0.8038579225540161, 0.6705449223518372, -0.13576923310756683, 0.25813502073287964, 0.07946841418743134, -0.27328401803970337, 0.5943237543106079, -0.6056696772575378, 0.5588420629501343, 0.2912025451660156, -0.24605324864387512, 0.24581705033779144, 0.3370210528373718, 0.4157601594924927, 0.008526066318154335, -0.29091382026672363, -0.38894176483154297, 0.05864954739809036, -0.3030899465084076, -0.7153746485710144, 0.6644061803817749, -0.3477017283439636, -0.5304889678955078, -0.41836994886398315, -0.8184231519699097, -0.3271336555480957, 0.4542873799800873, 0.13513794541358948, 0.868118405342102, -0.1468047797679901, 0.43716156482696533, 0.8277987241744995, -0.41655269265174866, 0.3909141421318054, 0.5121892094612122, -0.6570901870727539, -0.5018648505210876, 1.028740644454956, 0.22854410111904144, 0.3163773715496063, 0.5875771045684814, 0.1522517204284668, -0.3422103524208069, -0.621773362159729, -0.33988022804260254, 0.1567031294107437, -0.7526969313621521, -0.454157292842865, -0.543243944644928, -0.2386632263660431, -0.40630924701690674, 0.027765944600105286, -0.1550433188676834, -0.7543088793754578, -0.13385672867298126, -0.08568823337554932, 0.08122888952493668, 0.846034586429596, 0.1180218979716301, 0.01175379753112793, -0.8984515070915222, 0.49239611625671387, 0.05553867667913437, 0.38309505581855774, -0.057921670377254486, -0.8950055241584778, -0.3917076587677002, -0.22319814562797546, -0.2432352751493454, -0.7884955406188965, 0.6243224740028381, 0.20062477886676788, 0.6001672148704529, 0.07204405963420868, 0.3082544207572937, 0.3966396152973175, -0.32476606965065, 0.741682767868042, -0.2556440532207489, -0.6272600889205933, 0.5646674633026123, -0.8030163645744324, 0.47345224022865295, 0.5407781004905701, 0.19165754318237305, -0.1410120278596878, -0.6990363597869873, -0.5266924500465393, -0.9284515976905823, 0.29256123304367065, 0.11891879886388779, 0.09686519205570221, 0.037589505314826965, 0.4449460804462433, 0.05283231660723686, 0.22853593528270721, -0.3142211437225342, -0.01083724107593298, 0.007591347210109234, -0.39226946234703064, 0.05855987221002579, -0.34270647168159485, -0.04423040896654129, 0.17770256102085114, 0.7447919845581055, -0.07394364476203918, -0.20873084664344788, 0.19847482442855835, -0.3155513405799866, 0.16146880388259888, 0.30427759885787964, 0.7717528939247131, 0.8024142980575562, -0.4123065769672394, 0.3135145902633667, 0.39214950799942017, -0.5196853280067444, 0.0714077353477478, -0.05906863510608673, -0.40430864691734314, 0.18974123895168304, 0.5537887811660767, 0.31924235820770264, 0.309678316116333, -1.0253609418869019, 0.4964733421802521, -0.31572863459587097, 0.10208377242088318, -0.2409389764070511, 0.1397743672132492, 0.12028224766254425, 0.047653865069150925, 0.39374738931655884, -0.04552669823169708, 0.3072842061519623, -0.4903184771537781, 0.3193840980529785, 0.6288199424743652, -0.020006457343697548, -0.11327210068702698, 0.8519007563591003, 0.015659494325518608, -0.28210872411727905, 0.34135743975639343, -0.18546313047409058, -0.48980197310447693, 0.3481094241142273, 0.7150477170944214, 0.5687622427940369, -0.08451493084430695, -0.26746755838394165, 0.4128764569759369, 0.38968074321746826, -0.23594000935554504, 0.27497121691703796, 0.04782535880804062, -0.45628345012664795, -0.6121460199356079, -0.62470942735672, -0.6812692880630493, -0.10545922815799713, -0.797140896320343, 0.2995899021625519, -0.1467134952545166, -0.2222219705581665, -0.518399715423584, -0.011004100553691387, -0.060331836342811584, 0.120895154774189, -0.21189461648464203, 1.036492109298706, -0.5705376267433167, 0.5386855602264404, 0.691633939743042, -0.2148020714521408, -0.8187879323959351, -0.20360787212848663, -0.08911699801683426, -0.4754563868045807, 0.275237500667572, -0.015922171995043755, -0.30298924446105957, -0.31854918599128723, -0.5109076499938965, -0.7121814489364624, 1.2581510543823242, 0.5437077879905701, -0.21852876245975494, 0.107613705098629, -0.17149598896503448, 0.5886073708534241, -0.17210829257965088, 0.1746526062488556, 0.24010728299617767, 0.08823584020137787, 0.22326382994651794, -1.0505015850067139, -0.09476642310619354, -0.38460439443588257, 0.005078561138361692, 0.0751398429274559, -0.7413313984870911, 0.7555895447731018, -0.447806715965271, -0.3203207552433014, 0.4543963074684143, 0.8883742094039917, 0.6543863415718079, 0.27576175332069397, 0.21279777586460114, 0.6635463833808899, 0.9504668116569519, 0.04800938069820404, 1.4060778617858887, -0.23555302619934082, 0.269571989774704, 1.5631035566329956, -0.4166371524333954, 1.1759685277938843, 0.3494703471660614, -0.01734084263443947, 0.31756922602653503, 0.09404513984918594, 0.2878638803958893, 0.2599376440048218, 0.2743194103240967, -0.3019251525402069, -0.17272277176380157, -0.13814280927181244, -0.3623723089694977, 0.35468602180480957, 0.3578891456127167, -0.09413349628448486, -0.2849574685096741, -0.3273479640483856, -0.025357404723763466, 0.3172733783721924, -0.338072806596756, 0.8229334354400635, 0.15988637506961823, -0.761471152305603, 0.5203508734703064, 0.09092419594526291, 0.7835075855255127, -0.5676485896110535, -0.08850643783807755, -0.469589501619339, 0.21832990646362305, -0.285836398601532, -0.6225592494010925, 0.656161904335022, 0.24052220582962036, 0.0014293460408225656, 0.07049235701560974, 1.171770691871643, -0.43162867426872253, -0.6994356513023376, -0.18765690922737122, 0.7661789655685425, 0.2079697698354721, 0.3369152545928955, -0.16472434997558594, 0.37235867977142334, -0.3044176995754242, -0.1972547322511673, 0.5978719592094421, 0.42894256114959717, -0.06872951984405518, 0.9986382722854614, 0.38364896178245544, 0.16394124925136566, -0.11419139057397842, 0.13381770253181458, 0.7256530523300171, -0.4160236120223999, -0.5008823871612549, -0.8452157974243164, 0.5170854926109314, 0.11666105687618256, 0.19292151927947998, 1.0077491998672485, 0.8161925673484802, 0.5596200227737427, 0.02730206400156021, 0.837864339351654, 0.08938080817461014, 0.9239115118980408, -0.44217097759246826, 0.9949772953987122, -0.5232751369476318, 0.6381527781486511, -0.25671514868736267, -0.8312749862670898, -0.48568251729011536, 0.6196005940437317, 0.11208011209964752, 0.09947124123573303, 0.2987719178199768, 0.8710878491401672, -0.016103029251098633, -0.13860191404819489, 0.41535553336143494, 0.1995065063238144, 0.3194352984428406, 0.2189551740884781, 0.987015426158905, -0.3746258616447449, 0.5875664353370667, 0.20907488465309143, -0.10422303527593613, -0.21008923649787903, -1.0829743146896362, -0.9065839052200317, -0.38976094126701355, -0.022145040333271027, -0.4899072051048279, 0.06705697625875473, 0.7187415361404419, 0.3745017647743225, -0.636694610118866, -0.44309279322624207, 0.37054315209388733, 0.22181132435798645, 0.1277788132429123, -0.20820479094982147, 0.09707272797822952, -0.4043092429637909, -0.6181465983390808, 0.3683687746524811, 0.3645836114883423, 0.05440528690814972, -0.22022505104541779, -0.10735809803009033, -0.05521617829799652, 0.14702434837818146, 0.7232180237770081, 0.18686753511428833, -0.3266831934452057, -0.12695837020874023, 0.05345367640256882, -0.18495473265647888, -0.2279418408870697, 0.6267053484916687, -0.7570356130599976, 0.3102630078792572, 0.735824704170227, 0.788547158241272, 0.26417598128318787, 0.34967923164367676, 0.6641876101493835, -0.7478072643280029, -0.030060069635510445, 0.27326899766921997, 0.5359903573989868, 0.5590856075286865, -0.0010847788071259856, 0.5990362167358398, -0.09852439910173416, -0.6938938498497009, -1.1880249977111816, 0.07000309973955154, -1.063766360282898, -0.02751762419939041, 1.045677900314331, -0.2133861631155014, -0.032094646245241165, -0.19368679821491241, -0.25562307238578796, 0.22760291397571564, 0.01010467205196619, 0.6860830783843994, 0.622360110282898, -0.1201648861169815, 0.06428395211696625, -0.5051537156105042, 0.13069115579128265, 0.3652660548686981, -0.8473705649375916, -0.039179135113954544, 0.6219973564147949, 0.40785983204841614, 0.1305857002735138, 0.6188366413116455, -0.33403050899505615, 0.17967230081558228, -0.048429906368255615, -0.38642191886901855, -0.1632070690393448, -0.2827279269695282, -0.47106000781059265, 0.38934236764907837, 0.3000389337539673, 0.3449191153049469 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00076v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00076v2
A Backdoor Approach with Inverted Labels Using Dirty Label-Flipping Attacks
2024-03-29T00:09:48
2024-04-07T04:38:37
Orson Mengara
cs.CR
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.SP
Audio-based machine learning systems frequently use public or third-party data, which might be inaccurate. This exposes deep neural network (DNN) models trained on such data to potential data poisoning attacks. In this type of assault, attackers can train the DNN model using poisoned data, potentially degrading its performance. Another type of data poisoning attack that is extremely relevant to our investigation is label flipping, in which the attacker manipulates the labels for a subset of data. It has been demonstrated that these assaults may drastically reduce system performance, even for attackers with minimal abilities. In this study, we propose a backdoor attack named 'DirtyFlipping', which uses dirty label techniques, "label-on-label", to input triggers (clapping) in the selected data patterns associated with the target class, thereby enabling a stealthy backdoor.
[ -0.19197936356067657, -0.8471297025680542, 0.2218552678823471, -0.005742471665143967, -0.03774990886449814, 0.18767215311527252, 0.5188884139060974, -0.37659940123558044, 0.036282796412706375, 0.9199317097663879, -0.5106543898582458, -0.4887353777885437, -0.7113122940063477, -0.5187914371490479, -0.7842536568641663, 1.3290073871612549, 0.43885374069213867, -0.05326659977436066, 0.20105335116386414, 0.08573172986507416, -0.2798546552658081, -0.7939963936805725, -0.4987640380859375, -0.6797066330909729, 0.6689033508300781, 0.36184126138687134, 1.1764663457870483, 0.44025367498397827, 0.36162373423576355, 0.23330239951610565, -0.13389423489570618, -0.3463422954082489, -0.6468554735183716, 0.26395297050476074, -0.03131940960884094, -0.42641741037368774, -0.5221527218818665, 0.36647170782089233, 0.21659749746322632, 0.4445815980434418, 0.07856447994709015, 0.26791492104530334, -0.27026331424713135, 0.7883143424987793, -1.022148847579956, -0.2370258867740631, -0.7312901616096497, 0.4411202073097229, -0.22275981307029724, -0.38516950607299805, -0.533372163772583, -0.2354605495929718, -0.37578147649765015, -0.36478039622306824, -0.21294356882572174, -0.20242035388946533, 0.5962287187576294, 0.3578239679336548, 0.0173519067466259, -0.14939424395561218, -0.8152937889099121, 0.21251682937145233, -0.6070112586021423, 0.6249490976333618, 0.6329289078712463, 0.36920133233070374, -0.3098059296607971, -0.7499394416809082, -0.48882627487182617, -0.06006738916039467, 0.22667789459228516, 0.4215973913669586, -0.13126824796199799, 0.03759227320551872, 0.4278343915939331, 0.17133153975009918, -0.27462729811668396, 0.38374924659729004, -0.3856969475746155, -0.013978693634271622, 0.746252179145813, 0.0637616217136383, 0.4198346436023712, 0.1079709380865097, -0.8933563828468323, -0.5064411759376526, -0.7918328046798706, 0.04186436906456947, 0.8928812146186829, 0.23267677426338196, 0.07931189239025116, 0.547243058681488, -0.06393221765756607, 0.7363117933273315, 0.24927280843257904, -0.017190517857670784, 0.14920851588249207, -0.07109367847442627, -0.3265589475631714, 0.583300769329071, 0.5767021775245667, 0.4241795241832733, -0.06412366032600403, -0.42650994658470154, -0.5999659895896912, -0.13009947538375854, 0.3705326020717621, -0.7638624310493469, -0.6315640211105347, 0.6104029417037964, -0.41436952352523804, -0.988655149936676, 0.14756670594215393, -0.9381676912307739, -0.5804479122161865, 0.05346400663256645, 0.9844193458557129, -0.3888706862926483, -0.08282821625471115, -0.12125197798013687, -0.6536341309547424, 0.17204070091247559, -0.08552408218383789, -0.6037389636039734, 0.6072681546211243, 1.068232774734497, 0.7773324251174927, 0.0493369996547699, -0.28304898738861084, -0.8933118581771851, 0.4395143687725067, -0.24509651958942413, 0.327559232711792, -0.6573148369789124, -0.465072900056839, -0.16314288973808289, -0.4176415205001831, 0.15291935205459595, -0.6077370643615723, 0.052089475095272064, -0.9835458397865295, -0.06865538656711578, 0.1465919464826584, -0.27096566557884216, -0.30917561054229736, 0.18938429653644562, -0.7611496448516846, 0.8961543440818787, -0.48978880047798157, -0.8771715760231018, 0.3303854465484619, -0.5034725069999695, -0.4338739812374115, -0.22236615419387817, -0.003256911411881447, -0.8162839412689209, -0.0719294622540474, 0.3032006621360779, 0.6370065808296204, 0.3635684549808502, 0.23327569663524628, -0.5173049569129944, -0.7474119067192078, 0.7434131503105164, -0.49454453587532043, 1.3914180994033813, 0.27294114232063293, -0.4547375440597534, -0.13454946875572205, -1.0014241933822632, 0.01341578084975481, 0.03401179984211922, -0.27830758690834045, -0.6290473341941833, -0.22327977418899536, -0.1680527776479721, 0.45842671394348145, -0.3789043426513672, -0.5981584787368774, 0.3669760525226593, -0.38008520007133484, -0.0011166000040248036, 0.6845738887786865, 0.2724229395389557, 0.12658318877220154, -0.37451601028442383, 0.39632487297058105, 0.34989631175994873, 0.2610280215740204, -0.20173968374729156, -0.6699357032775879, -0.27640917897224426, -0.31739354133605957, 0.44594359397888184, 0.7912592887878418, -0.8927316069602966, 0.11093995720148087, -0.07385985553264618, -0.7132627964019775, -0.7031762003898621, 0.10880929231643677, 0.6380471587181091, 0.5479339361190796, 0.5594879984855652, 0.03822837397456169, -0.25920140743255615, -0.8295966386795044, -0.6230266690254211, 0.07810970395803452, -0.12284792214632034, 0.20288227498531342, 0.6333080530166626, -0.21302296221256256, 0.6328288316726685, -0.4025944173336029, -0.41703280806541443, 0.4097408056259155, 0.3322409391403198, 0.17228956520557404, 0.6000881791114807, 0.1886284202337265, -0.9421243667602539, -0.008211402222514153, -0.23668938875198364, -0.42096835374832153, -0.11170752346515656, -0.215618297457695, 0.14752118289470673, -0.06042662262916565, 0.6841201186180115, -0.2173430472612381, 0.8812335729598999, 0.6065444946289062, -0.04593788459897041, 0.47014445066452026, 0.2784470021724701, 0.025590119883418083, -0.6720354557037354, 0.09480562061071396, -0.2729499340057373, 0.10632232576608658, -0.8995183706283569, 0.13194561004638672, -0.01349638868123293, -0.6250259876251221, -0.8693696856498718, 0.2906193733215332, -0.22857017815113068, -0.03767253831028938, -0.08767450600862503, -0.07482194155454636, 0.04360416531562805, 0.39714258909225464, -0.12671612203121185, 0.5175594091415405, 0.5599561929702759, -0.6871405839920044, 0.4939865171909332, 0.09849607944488525, -0.053548309952020645, 0.3144056499004364, -0.34556543827056885, 0.681229829788208, 0.1484527587890625, 0.511902928352356, -1.1974927186965942, -0.053480662405490875, 0.6705902218818665, -0.6967853903770447, 0.8029651045799255, -0.4143296778202057, -0.40382659435272217, -0.24400340020656586, -0.6293298006057739, 0.5414360165596008, 0.25327521562576294, -1.0411876440048218, 0.37425029277801514, 0.39204391837120056, 0.26143017411231995, -0.8406226634979248, -1.1536816358566284, 0.19232498109340668, -0.28057798743247986, -0.5239047408103943, 0.3664940595626831, 0.4100174009799957, -0.32208698987960815, -0.3638455867767334, -0.12417194992303848, -0.03935035318136215, 0.40384605526924133, 0.4691457152366638, -0.12130575627088547, 0.011426573619246483, -0.05491034686565399, 0.08794146031141281, -0.23568949103355408, 0.41029107570648193, -0.3472549617290497, 0.3546387255191803, 0.1812078356742859, -0.30311688780784607, -0.8886146545410156, 0.44101816415786743, 0.4089409112930298, 0.19204524159431458, 0.6176692247390747, 0.33014988899230957, -0.30277112126350403, -0.20632576942443848, -0.22649411857128143, -0.549614429473877, -0.6014536619186401, 0.2273779809474945, -0.4183541238307953, 0.17811287939548492, 0.4381367564201355, -0.07851485908031464, -0.03520327806472778, -0.13315445184707642, 0.240872323513031, -0.5188761949539185, 0.9525009989738464, 0.2283637672662735, -0.09525351226329803, 0.2049715369939804, -0.3861604332923889, 0.07558587193489075, -0.5608590245246887, -0.44540220499038696, -0.5232357382774353, -0.6511853933334351, -0.607684314250946, -0.12046093493700027, 0.15337708592414856, 0.0850701704621315, -0.3072311282157898, -0.0013918132754042745, -0.5947309136390686, 0.2507293224334717, 0.6727250814437866, 0.44710925221443176, 0.3317705988883972, 0.05388672277331352, -0.1187298521399498, 0.20641417801380157, -0.7230924367904663, -0.2374734878540039, 0.92026686668396, 0.6468536257743835, 1.1594066619873047, 0.04384332895278931, 1.138848900794983, 0.19505172967910767, 0.303371399641037, -0.6691142916679382, 0.49324116110801697, -0.005625633988529444, -0.8123009204864502, -0.3356858491897583, -0.09941846132278442, -0.9410420060157776, 0.15648424625396729, -0.12623777985572815, -0.849518895149231, 0.36801114678382874, 0.3034798800945282, -0.10442104190587997, 0.7723212838172913, -0.6671038866043091, 0.39150407910346985, -0.5500835180282593, -0.33295512199401855, 0.2809488773345947, -0.6871351599693298, 0.5512171387672424, -0.04799897223711014, 0.39240097999572754, 0.2768274247646332, -0.04889177531003952, 1.2304376363754272, -0.6450628638267517, 1.2774271965026855, -0.5661123991012573, -0.32921019196510315, 0.23141273856163025, 0.42440682649612427, 0.4330817461013794, 0.10315922647714615, -0.006324675865471363, 0.5940510034561157, -0.22166304290294647, -0.26069778203964233, -0.8675231337547302, 0.4940265417098999, -0.7189720869064331, -0.834945023059845, -0.5151306390762329, -0.15562035143375397, -0.4211292862892151, -0.005780726671218872, 0.4458985924720764, 0.2916112542152405, 0.26673606038093567, 0.01314636506140232, 0.532810628414154, -0.12678630650043488, 0.4865550398826599, 0.3005892336368561, -0.4437423050403595, -0.5908458232879639, 1.284009337425232, 0.32424890995025635, 0.4420109987258911, 0.2995656430721283, 0.4611259698867798, 0.028892027214169502, -0.45973706245422363, -0.38791221380233765, -0.25221994519233704, -0.4823366701602936, -0.40352141857147217, -0.6310606002807617, -0.2039511352777481, -0.45835453271865845, -0.09340266138315201, -0.48868227005004883, -0.6383887529373169, -0.23693546652793884, -0.1903684139251709, 0.38878297805786133, 0.5372970700263977, -0.17063114047050476, 0.46642202138900757, -0.6743773818016052, 0.5110584497451782, 0.3783687651157379, 0.5440368056297302, 0.21607545018196106, -0.5096977949142456, 0.06239723414182663, 0.25756093859672546, -0.6238241195678711, -1.6070517301559448, 0.154759019613266, -0.09330698847770691, 0.3965836763381958, 0.5982128977775574, 0.056914716958999634, 0.421247661113739, -0.2524406313896179, 0.6176489591598511, 0.22247137129306793, -0.8598169684410095, 0.7043682336807251, -0.5570308566093445, 0.09376029670238495, 0.5610229969024658, 0.5828006863594055, -0.478536993265152, -0.5050585269927979, -0.8176196217536926, -1.0997023582458496, 0.703812837600708, 0.20279233157634735, 0.09669842571020126, 0.49861785769462585, 0.138326957821846, 0.3697352409362793, 0.38897809386253357, -0.6841510534286499, -0.6995580196380615, -0.6663322448730469, 0.3183267116546631, 0.09847015142440796, 0.03644660860300064, -0.29905733466148376, -0.2745293378829956, 0.6818234920501709, 0.23340502381324768, 0.24198482930660248, 0.020121751353144646, -0.06507731974124908, 0.2421531081199646, 0.14500372111797333, 0.4123232662677765, 0.07256794720888138, -0.10509058088064194, 0.2603458762168884, 0.08777855336666107, -0.8712270259857178, 0.2755442261695862, -0.012772479094564915, -0.5579553246498108, -0.2032865732908249, 0.2424507737159729, 0.607144296169281, 0.46388623118400574, -0.030853109434247017, 0.5146587491035461, 0.28756704926490784, -0.15235961973667145, -0.0436088927090168, 0.3152115046977997, -0.026555268093943596, -0.046363528817892075, 0.5138605237007141, 0.09752751886844635, 0.4932423233985901, -0.7611316442489624, 0.4830266535282135, 0.32753100991249084, -0.737027108669281, -0.1449761539697647, 0.5996071696281433, 0.12649594247341156, -0.7725280523300171, 0.7800329923629761, 0.5440757274627686, -0.7869858741760254, 0.6651545763015747, 0.7907208800315857, 0.8559072017669678, -0.5043859481811523, 0.18868005275726318, -0.25254562497138977, 0.2189791202545166, 0.49651238322257996, 0.23743730783462524, -0.30842524766921997, -0.4902091324329376, 0.06994488090276718, -0.21878287196159363, -0.6614401340484619, 0.5121676921844482, -0.9671880602836609, 0.12353657186031342, -0.7228231430053711, -0.15738292038440704, 0.1149626150727272, -0.42091211676597595, -0.5546836256980896, 0.47568508982658386, 0.32953429222106934, 0.8622228503227234, -0.9543115496635437, 0.640923023223877, 0.5948947072029114, -0.17553287744522095, -0.4411604106426239, 0.19968682527542114, 0.1591741442680359, -0.6974939703941345, 1.0682024955749512, 0.12122039496898651, -0.4132322669029236, -0.2488502562046051, -0.9235680103302002, -0.682783842086792, 0.4771108031272888, -0.015047749504446983, -0.2629554569721222, 0.17852331697940826, 0.21604520082473755, 0.3334093987941742, 0.1707507073879242, 0.03435107320547104, 0.5730946660041809, 0.8466396331787109, -0.18917807936668396, -0.4597172737121582, 0.07468216866254807, -0.16798964142799377, -0.4440845847129822, -0.007699545007199049, -0.7176045179367065, 0.5138893127441406, -0.21060381829738617, -0.06967070698738098, -0.5191820859909058, 0.6256197690963745, 0.42022353410720825, 0.9552060961723328, 0.37444233894348145, 0.5257047414779663, 0.8348154425621033, -0.09406114369630814, 0.8910245299339294, 0.1814713478088379, -0.13920362293720245, 1.147907018661499, -0.19617733359336853, 0.9360522627830505, 0.7876784801483154, -0.040426481515169144, 0.32297536730766296, 0.32769614458084106, -0.46169108152389526, 0.697966992855072, 0.4593568444252014, 0.06700411438941956, 0.09224553406238556, 0.5118820667266846, -0.49931758642196655, 0.775445818901062, 0.6278102397918701, -0.15920792520046234, 0.12044574320316315, 0.4741903245449066, 0.23508542776107788, -0.10994096845388412, -0.5475969314575195, 0.8923519849777222, 0.10878728330135345, -0.3895663619041443, 0.6359376311302185, -0.15761913359165192, 0.6709195971488953, -0.04196867719292641, -0.16162024438381195, 0.04561222344636917, 0.025718918070197105, -0.5337390899658203, -1.0218669176101685, 0.08889320492744446, -0.3954300284385681, 0.09446971863508224, -0.21860568225383759, 0.8188273310661316, -0.11627496033906937, -0.395995169878006, 0.4471084773540497, -0.014152072370052338, 0.26216766238212585, 0.0668686032295227, -0.6649500131607056, 0.16191186010837555, -0.2096332609653473, -0.5514937043190002, 0.3817732334136963, -0.005725403781980276, -0.010448047891259193, 0.9569663405418396, 0.745857834815979, 0.05607200786471367, 0.4461701512336731, -0.07596077024936676, 1.055773138999939, -0.8217716217041016, -0.7382029294967651, -0.7594056129455566, 0.27302467823028564, -0.2014768421649933, -0.10955818742513657, 0.8163716793060303, 0.694302499294281, 0.7900873422622681, -0.028980866074562073, 0.6249509453773499, 0.6853943467140198, 0.24487866461277008, -0.7061660289764404, 1.3218376636505127, -0.38424548506736755, 0.3588324189186096, -0.7076325416564941, -0.4453911781311035, -0.34477779269218445, 0.13998198509216309, -0.335315078496933, 0.17212481796741486, 0.36683958768844604, 0.57242751121521, -0.24979668855667114, 0.4660693407058716, 0.34791800379753113, 0.6698054075241089, 0.4375995397567749, 0.23857790231704712, 0.9320917129516602, -0.7335967421531677, 0.6329874396324158, -0.7377094030380249, -0.24308976531028748, -0.3756071925163269, -0.7977412939071655, -1.0537829399108887, -0.40933582186698914, -0.5705072283744812, -0.7229442000389099, 0.5117100477218628, -0.05935906991362572, 0.6731448173522949, -0.8516680002212524, 0.15344709157943726, 0.431327223777771, 0.39279279112815857, -0.5596891641616821, -0.24093139171600342, 0.4084053933620453, 0.15593352913856506, -0.29413527250289917, 0.6890716552734375, 0.10664082318544388, 0.08109443634748459, -0.32512715458869934, 0.3673260509967804, -0.27806806564331055, -0.018690768629312515, 0.11163244396448135, 0.5310779809951782, -0.40277642011642456, -0.24004322290420532, -0.4813578426837921, -0.06550174951553345, -0.06885144859552383, 0.7696508169174194, -1.1696213483810425, 0.3982122838497162, 0.4912124574184418, 0.583969235420227, 0.6824467778205872, 0.33823761343955994, 0.25870174169540405, -0.8865731954574585, 0.1955002248287201, 0.49640363454818726, -0.25254327058792114, 0.1455392837524414, -0.8069023489952087, 0.02658843994140625, 0.1241285651922226, -0.35050511360168457, -1.1141413450241089, 0.009366719983518124, -0.6915448904037476, -0.5646688938140869, 1.124395489692688, 0.09300205856561661, -0.5728370547294617, -0.5351240634918213, -0.09635419398546219, 0.20286867022514343, -0.4136553704738617, 0.9637906551361084, 0.2947981357574463, -0.17909342050552368, 0.43723616003990173, -0.454739511013031, 0.5305407643318176, 0.24066941440105438, -0.2968398928642273, 0.04729417338967323, 0.08848144114017487, 0.3471907079219818, 0.3020952641963959, 0.08223726600408554, -0.31934934854507446, 0.4897441864013672, 0.3776438534259796, -0.33156344294548035, -0.6693625450134277, -0.6535267233848572, -0.5306037068367004, 0.6334468126296997, -0.6597921848297119, -0.5821626782417297 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19887v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19887v2
Jamba: A Hybrid Transformer-Mamba Language Model
2024-03-28T23:55:06
2024-07-03T14:30:33
Opher Lieber, Barak Lenz, Hofit Bata, Gal Cohen, Jhonathan Osin, Itay Dalmedigos, Erez Safahi, Shaked Meirom, Yonatan Belinkov, Shai Shalev-Shwartz, Omri Abend, Raz Alon, Tomer Asida, Amir Bergman, Roman Glozman, Michael Gokhman, Avashalom Manevich, Nir Ratner, Noam Rozen, Erez Shwartz, Mor Zusman, Yoav Shoham
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.LG
We present Jamba, a new base large language model based on a novel hybrid Transformer-Mamba mixture-of-experts (MoE) architecture. Specifically, Jamba interleaves blocks of Transformer and Mamba layers, enjoying the benefits of both model families. MoE is added in some of these layers to increase model capacity while keeping active parameter usage manageable. This flexible architecture allows resource- and objective-specific configurations. In the particular configuration we have implemented, we end up with a powerful model that fits in a single 80GB GPU. Built at large scale, Jamba provides high throughput and small memory footprint compared to vanilla Transformers, and at the same time state-of-the-art performance on standard language model benchmarks and long-context evaluations. Remarkably, the model presents strong results for up to 256K tokens context length. We study various architectural decisions, such as how to combine Transformer and Mamba layers, and how to mix experts, and show that some of them are crucial in large scale modeling. We also describe several interesting properties of these architectures which the training and evaluation of Jamba have revealed, and plan to release checkpoints from various ablation runs, to encourage further exploration of this novel architecture. We make the weights of our implementation of Jamba publicly available under a permissive license.
[ -0.7601405382156372, -1.077742338180542, 0.17768926918506622, 0.3503195345401764, -0.16284149885177612, 0.43081891536712646, -0.3945567309856415, -0.5706767439842224, 0.31192588806152344, 0.8279067873954773, 0.006449333857744932, -0.10359759628772736, -0.6388514637947083, -0.2847576141357422, -0.2717010974884033, 0.7040741443634033, 0.13741517066955566, -0.1646568328142166, -0.14700575172901154, -0.1812608540058136, -0.989915668964386, -0.439322292804718, -0.4199836552143097, -0.34875309467315674, 0.17739933729171753, 0.24707923829555511, 0.9627667665481567, 0.5451957583427429, 0.1314539909362793, 0.33862051367759705, -0.3167557120323181, 0.057850975543260574, -0.17156262695789337, -0.09039526432752609, -0.2876436412334442, -0.479743093252182, -0.677700936794281, -0.3423435389995575, 0.6035938858985901, 0.8549391031265259, -0.41551804542541504, 0.06174946203827858, -0.18613803386688232, 0.44160982966423035, -0.7242705821990967, 0.36180028319358826, -0.7633607983589172, -0.252916544675827, -0.49833929538726807, 0.3177175223827362, -0.6579287648200989, 0.07790753245353699, -0.12398622184991837, -0.1892159879207611, -0.25241658091545105, 0.09871765226125717, 0.6448789238929749, 0.29502183198928833, -0.5415064096450806, -0.058174844831228256, -0.9631186127662659, 0.9273845553398132, -0.6499099731445312, 0.43211179971694946, 0.17624123394489288, 0.7388890385627747, -0.1663832664489746, -0.2905585765838623, -0.6235748529434204, -0.28783881664276123, 0.09923439472913742, 0.17186619341373444, -0.1649860292673111, 0.006301434710621834, 0.17272433638572693, 0.7087433934211731, -0.3410061299800873, 0.13543416559696198, -0.5877962112426758, -0.16877853870391846, 0.5145072937011719, 0.25826767086982727, 0.2877333164215088, -0.06150170415639877, -0.21895645558834076, 0.09764906764030457, -0.641566812992096, 0.008373264223337173, 0.38709256052970886, 0.2438131719827652, -0.18315018713474274, 0.3982093334197998, -0.006546332035213709, 1.0054538249969482, -0.16113649308681488, -0.40634945034980774, 0.21110326051712036, 0.043137189000844955, -0.3314763009548187, -0.03340175375342369, 0.8168240189552307, -0.12290042638778687, -0.1316879540681839, -0.17481501400470734, -0.1579103320837021, 0.0031203110702335835, 0.6122584939002991, -0.680268406867981, -0.4405058026313782, 0.05095968022942543, -0.37410110235214233, -0.1657634675502777, -0.1855558604001999, -0.8398462533950806, -0.3661060333251953, -0.1579350382089615, 0.4409366250038147, -0.5443999767303467, -0.651004433631897, 0.11440568417310715, 0.2103070318698883, 0.11699522286653519, 0.18398602306842804, -1.0449843406677246, 0.6460564136505127, 0.6231682300567627, 0.6185551285743713, -0.0530347116291523, 0.03148350864648819, -0.05894875526428223, 0.4331330955028534, -0.33160507678985596, 0.5184870362281799, -0.8983105421066284, -0.7193402647972107, -0.3126925826072693, -0.2971518337726593, 0.026607075706124306, -0.8380823135375977, 0.48602283000946045, -0.6204437613487244, 0.2022695690393448, 0.2261667549610138, -0.41258275508880615, -0.6965879201889038, 0.022075330838561058, -0.8192402124404907, 0.8610537648200989, 0.3951147496700287, -0.33078551292419434, 0.14410819113254547, -0.9453133344650269, -0.7163698673248291, 0.3134237825870514, -0.1926577389240265, -0.5333945751190186, 0.17892926931381226, 0.2540828585624695, 0.3294236660003662, -0.7576252818107605, 0.6266142129898071, -0.165570467710495, -0.23156483471393585, 0.20944592356681824, -0.2375940978527069, 1.1080424785614014, 0.48731452226638794, -0.2208111733198166, 0.061869192868471146, -0.8342041373252869, -0.30625787377357483, 0.28753623366355896, -0.38325080275535583, -0.33837780356407166, -0.15594765543937683, 0.006403428036719561, 0.13428543508052826, 0.3148220479488373, -0.5746816396713257, 0.47122499346733093, -0.07132243365049362, 0.3013558089733124, 0.49695080518722534, -0.25896933674812317, 0.5512921810150146, -0.10704364627599716, 0.620624303817749, 0.24950873851776123, 0.35411033034324646, -0.5659976601600647, -0.9764355421066284, -0.7162140607833862, -0.5197310447692871, 0.41301724314689636, 0.408977746963501, -0.5406585335731506, 0.6334831714630127, -0.03749224916100502, -0.7099799513816833, -0.6680987477302551, 0.13332150876522064, 0.3281637132167816, 0.463055282831192, 0.4671013057231903, -0.55647212266922, -0.4119623899459839, -1.362038016319275, 0.08179519325494766, -0.03299948573112488, 0.0250839963555336, 0.5708916783332825, 0.13610024750232697, -0.2975237965583801, 1.0363024473190308, -0.37989476323127747, -0.015472238883376122, -0.5829361081123352, 0.14052650332450867, 0.5220310091972351, 0.5787387490272522, 0.909841001033783, -0.9469718337059021, -0.3996736407279968, 0.2391507625579834, -0.43107926845550537, -0.16294240951538086, -0.1339365541934967, -0.07782109081745148, 0.08341037482023239, 0.1781592071056366, -0.5854109525680542, -0.06525984406471252, 0.9456666707992554, 0.1396830826997757, 0.45856839418411255, 0.03690972924232483, 0.03036549501121044, -1.4876867532730103, 0.12500768899917603, -0.3364906311035156, -0.1023615375161171, -0.5278828144073486, 0.2969650626182556, 0.22939938306808472, -0.2794577479362488, -0.29276373982429504, 0.5898710489273071, -0.4162740111351013, -0.14777567982673645, -0.5831065773963928, -0.36523208022117615, -0.11051858216524124, 0.5727900266647339, -0.1703086644411087, 0.8895676136016846, 0.7808942794799805, -0.5628275871276855, 0.5996544361114502, 0.19170312583446503, -0.5757473707199097, 0.1569366306066513, -0.5635018944740295, 0.08251123130321503, 0.2161102145910263, 0.4084663987159729, -0.7323557734489441, -0.4087745249271393, 0.12882792949676514, -0.2992430627346039, 0.5746275782585144, -0.3337465524673462, -0.3782776892185211, -0.6717110276222229, 0.2943313717842102, 0.5215925574302673, 1.003051519393921, -0.30494871735572815, 1.248272180557251, 0.9518489837646484, -0.3261919617652893, -0.6392243504524231, -0.6174374222755432, 0.33724015951156616, -0.02616572193801403, -0.5954846143722534, 0.3482842743396759, -0.06359943747520447, -0.13236990571022034, -0.08491791039705276, 0.2490902692079544, -0.30237266421318054, 0.41502630710601807, 0.5122394561767578, 0.35030263662338257, -0.41709277033805847, -0.20053641498088837, 0.26865431666374207, -0.12334074079990387, 0.00533277727663517, -0.244890958070755, 0.8619815707206726, -0.13325117528438568, -0.27275535464286804, -0.14136680960655212, 0.43919384479522705, 0.6742069125175476, -0.5632585883140564, 1.2047450542449951, 0.45957717299461365, -0.34977006912231445, -0.2057512104511261, -0.7250137329101562, 0.23318994045257568, -0.4831036925315857, 0.38860970735549927, -0.6470757722854614, -0.7327948212623596, 0.6424986124038696, -0.23662425577640533, 0.3569898307323456, 0.31887221336364746, 1.112169861793518, 0.262485146522522, 0.8402429819107056, 0.8577744960784912, -0.2989693582057953, 0.5747298002243042, -0.08958081901073456, 0.37063029408454895, -0.8260965347290039, -0.23942162096500397, -0.35981839895248413, -0.3007935583591461, -0.25407108664512634, -0.45189833641052246, 0.32495006918907166, 0.18170757591724396, 0.003315639914944768, 0.5896270871162415, -0.12774167954921722, 0.653917133808136, 0.6607692241668701, -0.11722196638584137, 0.09858058393001556, -0.4101199209690094, -0.24661237001419067, 0.38675758242607117, -0.7736045122146606, -0.48714613914489746, 1.0051919221878052, 0.4323742687702179, 0.6935597062110901, 0.10393934696912766, 0.38349634408950806, -0.11222681403160095, 0.5363407135009766, -0.6142277121543884, 0.656316339969635, 0.07595042884349823, -1.06397545337677, 0.02357960119843483, -0.37568897008895874, -0.6644589900970459, 0.3377377390861511, -0.30289044976234436, -0.6361437439918518, -0.2509533762931824, 0.21988603472709656, -0.3282412886619568, 0.6847862601280212, -0.7912586331367493, 0.8365771770477295, -0.09995143115520477, -0.0829407200217247, -0.3695223927497864, -0.6432836651802063, 0.8596009612083435, -0.41036149859428406, 0.250690221786499, -0.036935627460479736, 0.21160581707954407, 0.5028021335601807, -0.17503879964351654, 0.6331652402877808, -0.05205843970179558, -0.13190221786499023, 0.47405898571014404, 0.2938578128814697, 0.27089723944664, -0.28928831219673157, -0.09563108533620834, 0.5176650285720825, -0.6063686609268188, -0.586518406867981, -0.5743004083633423, 0.5426943302154541, -0.8257571458816528, -0.7048881649971008, 0.14515210688114166, -0.9908016324043274, -0.3892902135848999, 0.24735967814922333, -0.04632921516895294, 0.41163602471351624, -0.010837669484317303, 0.5521497130393982, 0.39588892459869385, -0.5549377202987671, 0.24614952504634857, 0.45356664061546326, -0.4034876823425293, -0.2783128023147583, 0.7947115898132324, -0.049092117697000504, 0.2591300308704376, 0.43584996461868286, 0.1703944057226181, 0.0176747664809227, -0.8213499784469604, -0.6935164928436279, 0.09740426391363144, -0.374765008687973, -0.10023496299982071, -0.9296022057533264, -0.2781940698623657, -0.3756661117076874, -0.2029208391904831, -0.7895678877830505, -0.3563106656074524, 0.208279088139534, 0.05630623549222946, 0.1334184855222702, 0.9130364060401917, 0.3029686212539673, 0.500819206237793, -1.0813525915145874, 0.25455382466316223, 0.16527943313121796, 0.4108295440673828, 0.15084746479988098, -0.4491267204284668, -0.6225481629371643, -0.14016814529895782, -0.5338947176933289, -0.6799187660217285, 0.23963887989521027, -0.29323452711105347, 0.8119809031486511, 0.4001419246196747, -0.12877969443798065, 0.5236015319824219, -0.6666203737258911, 0.9354337453842163, 0.228155717253685, -1.0224080085754395, 0.28760549426078796, -0.4343225061893463, 0.13554628193378448, 0.23237229883670807, 0.2909643054008484, -0.24007005989551544, -0.6696576476097107, -0.5511506795883179, -0.812470018863678, 0.6479088068008423, 0.110215924680233, 0.24981689453125, 0.15929241478443146, 0.022124024108052254, 0.48687711358070374, 0.257834255695343, -0.6486061215400696, -0.33103102445602417, -0.11213548481464386, -0.20743690431118011, -0.02301798015832901, -0.31916847825050354, -0.20086191594600677, -0.04623524844646454, 0.7152848839759827, 0.0668804943561554, 0.12267351150512695, -0.7772284746170044, -0.25997450947761536, -0.09034896641969681, 0.3236958980560303, 0.4153074324131012, 0.6863704323768616, -0.06588403880596161, -0.22797468304634094, 0.28256309032440186, -0.44902554154396057, -0.03568069264292717, 0.01566108874976635, -0.18763233721256256, -0.15228141844272614, 0.06661386042833328, 0.8771823644638062, 0.30138686299324036, -0.7337188124656677, 0.3731018900871277, 0.18990963697433472, 0.06297367066144943, -0.08620068430900574, 0.4221847355365753, 0.3501961827278137, 0.32833075523376465, 0.2933335602283478, 0.26683133840560913, 0.03953486308455467, -0.6103900671005249, 0.0526861846446991, 0.42887574434280396, 0.14819583296775818, -0.30550244450569153, 0.7872130274772644, 0.4635850787162781, -0.20223020017147064, 0.3804463744163513, 0.10016567260026932, -0.5184325575828552, 0.5159304141998291, 0.6553589105606079, 0.7892453074455261, -0.5283612608909607, -0.12517677247524261, 0.2054988294839859, 0.3017980456352234, 0.1931668072938919, -0.12596656382083893, -0.22834330797195435, -0.6591298580169678, -0.5072994828224182, -0.932054340839386, -0.8278734087944031, 0.07477118074893951, -0.6574832797050476, 0.2991449534893036, -0.6026699542999268, -0.11073191463947296, 0.023363256826996803, -0.18772530555725098, -0.2660699784755707, 0.15036775171756744, 0.48849424719810486, 0.9660863280296326, -0.7152373194694519, 1.1476401090621948, 0.6979081034660339, -0.23143984377384186, -0.7938305735588074, -0.28643694519996643, -0.19904106855392456, -0.7557076811790466, 0.398695707321167, 0.1158018633723259, 0.06868472695350647, -0.3015296459197998, -0.21419833600521088, -0.7603179216384888, 1.0887295007705688, 0.4549454152584076, -0.7471343278884888, 0.03254595771431923, -0.03881767392158508, 0.24044068157672882, -0.2287272810935974, 0.3691406548023224, 0.5021248459815979, 0.4209924042224884, 0.16988447308540344, -1.0998797416687012, -0.1646704375743866, -0.25057047605514526, -0.017932819202542305, 0.6008421778678894, -0.9417875409126282, 1.1182420253753662, -0.10115257650613785, -0.07995936274528503, 0.1421186476945877, 0.9711637496948242, 0.11103393137454987, -0.1723347157239914, 0.5788726210594177, 0.5682977437973022, 0.6318467855453491, -0.12408450990915298, 1.3353914022445679, -0.5212075114250183, 0.17987191677093506, 0.9805564880371094, -0.30704250931739807, 0.640548050403595, 0.09367188811302185, -0.29740282893180847, 0.662116527557373, 0.2670959532260895, 0.06520574539899826, 0.3269522190093994, -0.10798507928848267, -0.32004719972610474, -0.28750574588775635, -0.1039753258228302, -0.4173396825790405, 0.4673650562763214, 0.4855192005634308, -0.3265468180179596, -0.044820722192525864, 0.08554971218109131, -0.0030430983752012253, -0.08284498751163483, -0.3331066966056824, 0.6266489624977112, 0.07996215671300888, -0.6021238565444946, 0.32881078124046326, 0.29621198773384094, 0.6919651627540588, -0.757044792175293, 0.24884596467018127, -0.03782553970813751, 0.24545732140541077, 0.07861214131116867, -0.8210828304290771, 0.35720139741897583, -0.09499476850032806, -0.12726068496704102, -0.005991701502352953, 0.5009117126464844, -0.49749118089675903, -0.41142594814300537, 0.3314516246318817, 0.33271604776382446, 0.035253118723630905, 0.07260821014642715, -0.7056530714035034, 0.2787468135356903, -0.22810038924217224, -0.30301493406295776, 0.31869396567344666, 0.1499824970960617, -0.15705956518650055, 0.6064494848251343, 0.6497783064842224, 0.041973792016506195, 0.2933257222175598, 0.08363577723503113, 1.0192149877548218, -0.6856640577316284, -0.7102102041244507, -0.6510837078094482, 0.41337648034095764, -0.015595726668834686, -0.10510294884443283, 0.668239176273346, 0.662879467010498, 0.7889640927314758, -0.15512943267822266, 0.8303653597831726, -0.09700005501508713, 0.4840659499168396, -0.48793986439704895, 0.6476643085479736, -0.5529099106788635, -0.06254667788743973, -0.2507448196411133, -1.1592918634414673, -0.2644924521446228, 0.3233146667480469, -0.2713533639907837, 0.09900907427072525, 0.2680533826351166, 0.6229240894317627, -0.2944672405719757, 0.22744758427143097, 0.6007744669914246, 0.5218730568885803, 0.5960715413093567, 0.8192003965377808, 0.6944584250450134, -0.20946605503559113, 0.4846477508544922, -0.25273507833480835, -0.40733030438423157, -0.4903552830219269, -0.6659886240959167, -0.941620409488678, -0.5420427918434143, -0.11228520423173904, -0.034850575029850006, -0.3316999077796936, 0.8849824666976929, 0.8485377430915833, -0.9224004745483398, -0.2705683708190918, 0.24512845277786255, -0.04284568130970001, -0.12103468179702759, -0.21122565865516663, -0.14053510129451752, -0.029793301597237587, -1.00602388381958, 0.6065623164176941, 0.6966329216957092, 0.028667373582720757, -0.43981269001960754, -0.021063154563307762, 0.072575144469738, 0.25125256180763245, 0.5963386297225952, 0.3268926441669464, -0.7123693227767944, 0.11935579031705856, -0.28773927688598633, -0.15276440978050232, 0.08945038169622421, 0.813279390335083, -0.7879363894462585, 0.5761924386024475, 0.3357369899749756, 1.133592128753662, 0.4333471655845642, -0.14874200522899628, 0.7905973196029663, -0.4932975769042969, 0.4982949495315552, 0.29872357845306396, 0.7857422232627869, 0.2617620527744293, -0.050508830696344376, 0.17768201231956482, 0.042880214750766754, -0.3142188787460327, -0.6790461540222168, 0.38427218794822693, -1.2530754804611206, -0.41271382570266724, 0.8658077120780945, -0.06622439622879028, -0.44166651368141174, -0.12911348044872284, -0.44115424156188965, 0.14047135412693024, -0.2901943325996399, 0.8110882043838501, 0.8158549070358276, 0.1866445094347, -0.22648905217647552, -0.4603653848171234, -0.1833391785621643, 0.42776551842689514, -0.7168473601341248, -0.02275192365050316, 0.39665818214416504, 0.1722290962934494, 0.5057659149169922, 0.38074129819869995, -0.32663825154304504, 0.26580333709716797, 0.1564464271068573, 0.2710209786891937, -0.5128659009933472, -0.6383594870567322, -0.031929463148117065, 0.2848125100135803, -0.18269459903240204, -0.07695327699184418 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19851v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19851v1
Localizing Paragraph Memorization in Language Models
2024-03-28T21:53:24
2024-03-28T21:53:24
Niklas Stoehr, Mitchell Gordon, Chiyuan Zhang, Owen Lewis
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG, stat.ML
Can we localize the weights and mechanisms used by a language model to memorize and recite entire paragraphs of its training data? In this paper, we show that while memorization is spread across multiple layers and model components, gradients of memorized paragraphs have a distinguishable spatial pattern, being larger in lower model layers than gradients of non-memorized examples. Moreover, the memorized examples can be unlearned by fine-tuning only the high-gradient weights. We localize a low-layer attention head that appears to be especially involved in paragraph memorization. This head is predominantly focusing its attention on distinctive, rare tokens that are least frequent in a corpus-level unigram distribution. Next, we study how localized memorization is across the tokens in the prefix by perturbing tokens and measuring the caused change in the decoding. A few distinctive tokens early in a prefix can often corrupt the entire continuation. Overall, memorized continuations are not only harder to unlearn, but also to corrupt than non-memorized ones.
[ 0.0005299272597767413, -1.0759049654006958, 0.4206380844116211, 0.3138020634651184, -0.17457620799541473, -0.11851893365383148, -0.28417375683784485, -0.07928869873285294, 0.002737796865403652, 0.602852463722229, -0.1618223488330841, -0.4685128331184387, -0.28506413102149963, -0.1734953224658966, -0.5281171798706055, 0.987738847732544, -0.15307371318340302, 0.20573262870311737, -0.21377742290496826, -0.2263762205839157, -0.233842134475708, -0.692412257194519, -0.8502794504165649, -0.6527135968208313, 0.5970640182495117, 0.2796551585197449, 0.4214255213737488, 0.9779325127601624, 0.40506306290626526, 0.39056816697120667, -0.42091888189315796, -0.2947874069213867, -0.5950629115104675, -0.13938121497631073, -0.08345302194356918, -0.8948008418083191, -0.2500162422657013, -0.20373934507369995, 0.9243378639221191, 1.2458763122558594, -0.22258535027503967, -0.09204030781984329, 0.13194896280765533, 0.5124990344047546, -0.47274479269981384, 0.008576583117246628, -0.611929714679718, 0.27773627638816833, -0.3225049078464508, -0.26340213418006897, -0.2332591712474823, 0.042522307485342026, 0.2777121961116791, -0.4948994815349579, 0.658453106880188, -0.03720735013484955, 0.593539834022522, 0.0007399017340503633, -0.22841091454029083, -0.009153548628091812, -0.7867913246154785, 0.9164135456085205, -0.6456326842308044, 0.2644442915916443, 0.6171974539756775, -0.1531171053647995, -0.132741317152977, -0.6755251288414001, -0.216150164604187, -0.07358652353286743, -0.06087639555335045, 0.01370900496840477, -0.18656648695468903, 0.09592948108911514, 0.46765485405921936, 0.4689306914806366, -0.41702306270599365, 0.12560445070266724, -0.4106748104095459, -0.3194133937358856, -0.03268558531999588, 0.1841617077589035, 0.49281275272369385, -0.01778045855462551, -0.6308098435401917, 0.11197498440742493, -0.8918789625167847, 0.21676167845726013, 0.19984708726406097, 0.22258919477462769, -0.06339302659034729, 0.4049322009086609, -0.2428579181432724, 0.5144194960594177, 0.04180249199271202, -0.3780210018157959, 0.4249771237373352, -0.2231236696243286, -0.3232412338256836, 0.01687544956803322, 0.5455005764961243, -0.028104230761528015, 0.2076207548379898, -0.44662395119667053, -0.3074144124984741, -0.3619494140148163, 0.2595130503177643, -0.5650513172149658, -0.31659990549087524, -0.05577540025115013, -0.6392557621002197, 0.09114818274974823, -0.10837501287460327, -0.5253461003303528, -0.3449086844921112, -0.4374864101409912, 0.2907160818576813, -0.6768072843551636, -0.05246353894472122, 0.42407381534576416, -0.1807323694229126, 0.19849450886249542, 0.12773896753787994, -0.9183590412139893, 0.304688036441803, 0.5747975707054138, 0.8103928565979004, 0.03282865509390831, -1.1344671249389648, -0.24742521345615387, 0.26957276463508606, -0.12519654631614685, 0.9209149479866028, -0.5459689497947693, -0.1703430563211441, 0.20101140439510345, 0.04462604224681854, -0.5094960331916809, -0.660615861415863, 0.43177318572998047, -0.22976581752300262, 0.14249759912490845, -0.5022687911987305, -0.6524912118911743, -0.17151884734630585, -0.05390157178044319, -0.43676042556762695, 1.068455696105957, 0.054451797157526016, -0.9835516810417175, 0.04624169319868088, 0.07047734409570694, -0.6209745407104492, -0.2963745892047882, 0.1574576050043106, -0.3433355987071991, 0.44474461674690247, 0.1258673071861267, 0.31767767667770386, -0.025634678080677986, -0.0713176429271698, -0.20313145220279694, -0.5606614947319031, 0.23445270955562592, -0.32945770025253296, 0.5548660755157471, -0.05658620223402977, -0.2030683308839798, 0.038325101137161255, -0.8313696384429932, -0.2700238525867462, 0.010081123560667038, -0.44584396481513977, -0.5712769031524658, -0.017418203875422478, -0.34970423579216003, 0.05172637850046158, 0.288897305727005, -0.4729560613632202, 0.09669987112283707, -0.30016231536865234, 0.5307251811027527, 0.5183132290840149, 0.35903942584991455, 0.9227959513664246, -0.4168207049369812, 0.3280194401741028, 0.5695024132728577, -0.10768984258174896, -0.472981721162796, -0.23513413965702057, -1.1036226749420166, -0.429966539144516, 0.1940925270318985, 0.5311042666435242, -0.314633309841156, 0.24479784071445465, -0.044921185821294785, -0.45509639382362366, -0.24959330260753632, 0.09330698847770691, 0.5955691337585449, 0.86175537109375, 0.2766120135784149, -0.4787326753139496, -0.3149828016757965, -0.9277446866035461, -0.23142769932746887, 0.01968914270401001, -0.06820923089981079, 0.09432442486286163, 0.568966269493103, -0.008107361383736134, 0.8716990351676941, -0.3918926417827606, -0.49023136496543884, -0.2711603343486786, 0.49501466751098633, -0.13625428080558777, 0.503771185874939, 0.47611358761787415, -0.27720972895622253, -0.1562906801700592, -0.11068136245012283, -0.5628998279571533, -0.18841443955898285, -0.43014904856681824, -0.0899825319647789, -0.04921984300017357, 0.8355754613876343, -0.7026991248130798, 0.24905723333358765, -0.2104177176952362, -0.41715511679649353, 0.1778687834739685, -0.6516044735908508, -0.40092191100120544, -0.6564151048660278, 0.13949903845787048, -0.18467305600643158, -0.07900664955377579, -0.8617781400680542, 0.06644827872514725, 0.037214282900094986, 0.11422964185476303, -0.3465249538421631, 0.4118216335773468, -0.4499483108520508, -0.23470640182495117, -0.11393311619758606, 0.3373093605041504, 0.05177020654082298, 0.8709140419960022, 0.10255806148052216, 0.6642753481864929, 0.696579098701477, -0.6073618531227112, -0.13067258894443512, 0.21293169260025024, -0.528190553188324, 0.41159671545028687, -0.6322813034057617, 0.00438507366925478, -0.5990290641784668, 0.20970061421394348, -0.8285704851150513, 0.12638689577579498, -0.11897625774145126, -0.17274948954582214, 0.2511827349662781, -0.0177535992115736, -0.2820550203323364, 0.06396985054016113, -0.30265721678733826, 0.4375360906124115, 0.48273807764053345, -0.36803632974624634, 0.2990266978740692, 0.4624158442020416, -0.1631586104631424, -0.6042394042015076, -0.5983691811561584, -0.2906295359134674, -0.3548175096511841, -0.2465026080608368, 0.2759411633014679, 0.23378606140613556, -0.0772458165884018, -0.1627824902534485, -0.16211433708667755, -0.22551226615905762, 0.16294340789318085, 0.20481084287166595, -0.31568005681037903, -0.18187730014324188, 0.028369002044200897, -0.17150574922561646, 0.06446778029203415, 0.035789307206869125, -0.49475446343421936, 0.8253536224365234, -0.10594329237937927, -0.24671638011932373, -0.2802921235561371, 0.41083985567092896, 0.556377649307251, -0.6183781027793884, 0.7073561549186707, 0.7101694345474243, -0.5793490409851074, -0.2931005656719208, -0.5003494024276733, -0.07266035676002502, -0.407178670167923, 0.5125576257705688, -0.3929639160633087, -0.622170090675354, 1.2680448293685913, -0.021292243152856827, -0.2905256152153015, 0.07703649252653122, 0.4218529760837555, -0.1933365911245346, 0.7232130169868469, 0.5593366026878357, -0.27474352717399597, 0.6293014287948608, -0.36289915442466736, 0.2636432647705078, -1.1485358476638794, -0.26058584451675415, -0.6273059844970703, -0.3314501941204071, -0.15661059319972992, -0.3096853494644165, -0.030721625313162804, 0.9573959112167358, -0.28658682107925415, 0.20641514658927917, -0.037150848656892776, 0.831935465335846, 0.8064966797828674, 0.027502724900841713, 0.11368294060230255, 0.34987613558769226, -0.726606011390686, -0.2175503671169281, -0.670080304145813, -0.29956063628196716, 0.7313603162765503, 0.5539485812187195, 0.6691007018089294, -0.12065594643354416, 0.6850844621658325, -0.008007618598639965, -0.13901706039905548, -0.5300326943397522, 0.5486454963684082, -0.10355082899332047, -0.09609045833349228, -0.33691319823265076, -0.3532930910587311, -0.98325115442276, 0.3986688554286957, 0.20379555225372314, -0.9904577136039734, 0.2671893537044525, 0.09056353569030762, -0.24867933988571167, 0.45081910490989685, -0.579344630241394, 0.9777076244354248, 0.12780320644378662, -0.17525406181812286, 0.02888849936425686, -0.4428133964538574, 0.02935822121798992, 0.07450529932975769, 0.02761899121105671, 0.039620812982320786, 0.11285775154829025, 0.7737542986869812, -0.23299863934516907, 1.1107304096221924, -0.1876586377620697, -0.21527673304080963, 0.27804043889045715, 0.20763656497001648, 0.5508100986480713, -0.0813785269856453, 0.20853254199028015, 0.22944192588329315, -0.34521886706352234, -0.4483209252357483, -0.4950428903102875, 0.6232829093933105, -0.8294171094894409, -0.4081326723098755, -0.2343672215938568, -0.47730427980422974, -0.06589829176664352, 0.5124943852424622, 0.46659374237060547, 0.633333683013916, -0.19875980913639069, 0.03902433067560196, 0.9607027769088745, -0.17486272752285004, 0.5028626322746277, 0.7022836208343506, -0.06697409600019455, -0.28768599033355713, 1.2270981073379517, 0.2530358135700226, 0.06217891350388527, 0.6353787779808044, 0.10802938789129257, 0.025791602209210396, -0.8850336670875549, 0.05452939495444298, 0.41481420397758484, -0.8889032006263733, 0.07089823484420776, -0.5098760724067688, -0.1192973256111145, -0.057129453867673874, -0.19065403938293457, -0.2771734595298767, -0.5139438509941101, -0.43374037742614746, -0.18076062202453613, -0.14480257034301758, 0.697023332118988, 0.0010177664225921035, 0.39507269859313965, -0.5881299376487732, 0.1947726607322693, 0.036116015166044235, 0.3269100785255432, 0.25200045108795166, -0.7095740437507629, -0.406692773103714, -0.16845494508743286, -0.14809338748455048, -0.5694242119789124, 0.4769788384437561, 0.10518071055412292, 0.3407704532146454, 0.6375914216041565, -0.2097485512495041, 0.8218244314193726, -0.8362914323806763, 0.7175333499908447, -0.048967551440000534, -1.0005161762237549, 0.1956223100423813, -0.7086185216903687, 0.6855883598327637, 0.3492831289768219, 0.026529882103204727, -0.8763708472251892, -0.800163209438324, -0.41591811180114746, -0.9921789169311523, 0.7021902799606323, -0.17788471281528473, 0.28061363101005554, -0.404493510723114, 0.5463021397590637, -0.13834552466869354, 0.11847848445177078, -0.6024439334869385, -0.16647878289222717, -0.09241153299808502, -0.04883137717843056, 0.13636793196201324, -0.5181465148925781, -0.06901148706674576, -0.24263614416122437, 0.38715529441833496, 0.06624770164489746, 0.49214065074920654, 0.36646512150764465, -0.4170823097229004, -0.0843738466501236, 0.22756655514240265, 0.8745720386505127, 0.7884063720703125, -0.1806684285402298, 0.18532304465770721, 0.255977988243103, -0.4567871689796448, -0.13768260180950165, -0.20869190990924835, -0.6909751296043396, -0.023790322244167328, 0.6457265615463257, 1.0681843757629395, 0.7497681379318237, -0.25904616713523865, 0.4695834219455719, -0.01709909364581108, -0.0907537043094635, -0.491634339094162, -0.11596803367137909, 0.0960303321480751, 0.09414472430944443, 0.1455300897359848, 0.11895610392093658, -0.014451314695179462, -0.4953673779964447, 0.22995784878730774, 0.42288938164711, -0.38258877396583557, -0.45547229051589966, 0.645288348197937, 0.11038941890001297, -0.17850060760974884, 0.8602015376091003, -0.033220574259757996, -0.6371500492095947, 0.5850942730903625, 1.0102248191833496, 0.7769365906715393, -0.20503802597522736, 0.13221870362758636, 0.4535815715789795, 0.27268925309181213, -0.3138972520828247, 0.1858063042163849, -0.15337541699409485, -0.7729709148406982, -0.1346464455127716, -0.5966728925704956, -0.023438122123479843, 0.2230634242296219, -0.8703802227973938, -0.0816727951169014, -0.5783794522285461, 0.009963884949684143, -0.07722525298595428, -0.32492831349372864, -0.3471401333808899, 0.0636618435382843, 0.18609775602817535, 0.8478545546531677, -0.6123586893081665, 0.9670155644416809, 0.5982354879379272, -0.4140567481517792, -0.44097715616226196, 0.07923554629087448, -0.19362173974514008, -0.7652111053466797, 0.6369888782501221, 0.13434965908527374, 0.019018612802028656, -0.10699839144945145, -0.0975269302725792, -1.0580888986587524, 0.9752590656280518, 0.3030829429626465, -0.2893690764904022, -0.3901475667953491, 0.29437053203582764, 0.7285559177398682, -0.20090867578983307, 0.3273863196372986, 0.6231522560119629, -0.05048556625843048, -0.23438389599323273, -0.8693166375160217, -0.29549065232276917, 0.011194760911166668, 0.22641238570213318, 0.3994693458080292, -0.8431275486946106, 1.365192174911499, -0.21413789689540863, -0.37499579787254333, 0.09776639193296432, 0.44487282633781433, -0.2475321739912033, -0.13618583977222443, 0.06014246866106987, 0.9381701350212097, 0.9797861576080322, -0.05528004840016365, 1.0818952322006226, -0.3861865699291229, 0.43207111954689026, 1.2559566497802734, -0.39275652170181274, 0.9908142685890198, 0.4070982038974762, 0.08026877790689468, 0.3117564916610718, 0.28163591027259827, -0.010616935789585114, 0.5604324340820312, 0.30063486099243164, -0.3097543716430664, -0.1688247174024582, -0.13825194537639618, -0.08377674221992493, 0.4996625781059265, 0.16997794806957245, -0.3338741660118103, -0.352352112531662, 0.17200015485286713, 0.2286147028207779, -0.06106274574995041, -0.5855872631072998, 0.8106794953346252, 0.11253227293491364, -0.7266928553581238, 0.6639874577522278, 0.253744512796402, 0.172501340508461, -0.7201043963432312, 0.15534088015556335, -0.7172298431396484, 0.5785109400749207, -0.09099337458610535, -0.35816168785095215, 0.2718023657798767, -0.25933489203453064, -0.37552204728126526, -0.3805030584335327, 0.512373685836792, -0.8187923431396484, -0.1964488923549652, 0.31631699204444885, 0.3020433783531189, -0.0355534702539444, 0.03511091694235802, -0.41033661365509033, -0.27113407850265503, 0.07593788951635361, -0.5028573870658875, 0.5921024084091187, 0.504185140132904, -0.1733066439628601, 0.8818901777267456, 0.47380149364471436, 0.2179882973432541, 0.4505785405635834, 0.3643656075000763, 0.47463127970695496, -0.6930049061775208, -0.542366087436676, -0.7882919907569885, 0.35571637749671936, 0.08566699922084808, -0.4292606711387634, 0.9742093682289124, 0.5086571574211121, 1.1657958030700684, -0.22832822799682617, 0.3750893175601959, 0.4265426993370056, 0.4657898247241974, -0.6876435875892639, 0.647028386592865, -0.17820045351982117, 0.27131423354148865, 0.021538401022553444, -0.9752199649810791, -0.39043867588043213, 0.8467859625816345, -0.14746463298797607, -0.20461241900920868, 1.0950554609298706, 0.6239597201347351, -0.014055761508643627, -0.18631163239479065, 0.23341168463230133, 0.3557923436164856, -0.14968328177928925, 0.591713011264801, 0.6494996547698975, -0.29997435212135315, 0.35286691784858704, -0.3870762586593628, 0.07436902076005936, 0.2184121310710907, -0.5170361995697021, -1.1981910467147827, -0.5507318377494812, -0.2664698660373688, -0.15721102058887482, -0.285714328289032, 0.5903868079185486, 0.3249751627445221, -0.8265814185142517, -0.3318922519683838, -0.3307960629463196, 0.2074180394411087, -0.1771814078092575, -0.19509559869766235, 0.40640997886657715, -0.7391112446784973, -0.6433002352714539, 0.31311914324760437, 0.36617663502693176, 0.22639791667461395, -0.22566071152687073, 0.25801151990890503, -0.10836211591959, 0.11873959749937057, 0.4988069534301758, 0.46503645181655884, -0.7207096815109253, -0.1364188939332962, -0.10108507424592972, -0.2775760591030121, 0.21716496348381042, 1.3842664957046509, -0.7588804960250854, 0.10992276668548584, 0.6412938833236694, 0.38003870844841003, 0.3310040533542633, -0.0906047597527504, 0.5582879781723022, -1.3114311695098877, 0.4077463150024414, -0.046366989612579346, 0.87928307056427, 0.2912755310535431, -0.042907264083623886, 0.18844309449195862, 0.1665205955505371, -0.537094235420227, -0.7956473231315613, 0.20377281308174133, -0.5226864218711853, -0.18058356642723083, 1.0282024145126343, -0.48062095046043396, -0.3546089231967926, -0.050769541412591934, -0.1713075339794159, 0.07790219783782959, -0.05773933231830597, 0.68517005443573, 0.929835319519043, 0.10422221571207047, -0.16638724505901337, -0.32529520988464355, 0.731316864490509, 0.6563521027565002, -0.3952881991863251, 0.47417372465133667, 0.3882279694080353, 0.4519238770008087, 0.2566613256931305, 0.7247791886329651, -0.11405476182699203, 0.06594055891036987, 0.0060570864006876945, -0.15027670562267303, 0.07706036418676376, -0.5481273531913757, -0.8410984873771667, 0.1159074530005455, 0.10636235773563385, 0.013534288853406906 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19839v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19839v1
The New Agronomists: Language Models are Experts in Crop Management
2024-03-28T21:20:27
2024-03-28T21:20:27
Jing Wu, Zhixin Lai, Suiyao Chen, Ran Tao, Pan Zhao, Naira Hovakimyan
cs.LG
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
Crop management plays a crucial role in determining crop yield, economic profitability, and environmental sustainability. Despite the availability of management guidelines, optimizing these practices remains a complex and multifaceted challenge. In response, previous studies have explored using reinforcement learning with crop simulators, typically employing simple neural-network-based reinforcement learning (RL) agents. Building on this foundation, this paper introduces a more advanced intelligent crop management system. This system uniquely combines RL, a language model (LM), and crop simulations facilitated by the Decision Support System for Agrotechnology Transfer (DSSAT). We utilize deep RL, specifically a deep Q-network, to train management policies that process numerous state variables from the simulator as observations. A novel aspect of our approach is the conversion of these state variables into more informative language, facilitating the language model's capacity to understand states and explore optimal management practices. The empirical results reveal that the LM exhibits superior learning capabilities. Through simulation experiments with maize crops in Florida (US) and Zaragoza (Spain), the LM not only achieves state-of-the-art performance under various evaluation metrics but also demonstrates a remarkable improvement of over 49\% in economic profit, coupled with reduced environmental impact when compared to baseline methods. Our code is available at \url{https://github.com/jingwu6/LM_AG}.
[ -0.18828566372394562, -0.8470301628112793, 0.6651337742805481, 0.2934263348579407, 0.12295070290565491, 0.46341264247894287, -0.4326278865337372, -0.3770478069782257, -0.047806184738874435, 0.34247931838035583, -0.538873553276062, -0.3611561059951782, -0.6008344888687134, 0.04979591816663742, -0.45418256521224976, 0.9435621500015259, -0.04295355826616287, 0.0809556394815445, -0.18082405626773834, 0.02392657846212387, -0.3879694938659668, -0.28459757566452026, -0.9261562824249268, -0.6164931654930115, 0.46477317810058594, 0.44342687726020813, 1.0265518426895142, 0.6534649133682251, 0.6201165914535522, 0.3936315178871155, -0.22874458134174347, 0.2747875452041626, -0.10654357820749283, 0.13974341750144958, -0.45697179436683655, -0.2721812427043915, -0.18398797512054443, 0.15069802105426788, 0.3558943569660187, 0.44430011510849, -0.2775437533855438, 0.16148929297924042, -0.12402600795030594, 0.4824194312095642, -0.5298252701759338, 0.2840409278869629, -0.5595560073852539, 0.5009551644325256, 0.36263546347618103, -0.31352680921554565, -0.45458486676216125, -0.5888137221336365, -0.18253852427005768, -0.785533607006073, -0.2939162254333496, -0.06276904046535492, 1.0442081689834595, 0.3981020450592041, -0.22813643515110016, -0.24404121935367584, -1.0691938400268555, 0.5898123979568481, -0.40642985701560974, -0.01287628524005413, 0.19458867609500885, 0.7782106399536133, -0.3081830143928528, -0.5895424485206604, -0.5650442242622375, -0.24224232137203217, 0.22060911357402802, 0.5582038760185242, -0.10546815395355225, 0.07714472711086273, -0.15961766242980957, 0.32218918204307556, 0.04589889571070671, 0.3637479543685913, -0.5513038635253906, -0.11256207525730133, 0.4200891852378845, 0.15181687474250793, 0.30791229009628296, 0.07215950638055801, -0.585496723651886, -0.5327669978141785, 0.0082551259547472, 0.33705103397369385, 0.05693832039833069, 0.30562588572502136, 0.3055054545402527, 0.37823203206062317, -0.2037881314754486, 0.44379591941833496, -0.17435750365257263, -0.03786204010248184, 0.03936468064785004, -0.12311451882123947, -0.5557345151901245, -0.3399936854839325, 0.7378170490264893, 0.31950506567955017, 0.3243056833744049, 0.01628396101295948, -0.5337550044059753, 0.4312070310115814, 0.14341162145137787, -0.4836251437664032, -0.45011237263679504, -0.02998301014304161, -0.12937982380390167, -0.4803401827812195, -0.08385947346687317, -0.5995185971260071, -0.513782799243927, -0.27346205711364746, 0.32620158791542053, -0.8519198894500732, -0.23675842583179474, 0.0967029333114624, -0.13946950435638428, 0.4498661756515503, 0.5057715773582458, -0.4454428255558014, 0.7555964589118958, 0.6544710397720337, 0.7456873059272766, -0.0521942675113678, -0.333257257938385, -0.5073419809341431, -0.1422457993030548, -0.7404980063438416, 0.509132444858551, -0.6463204026222229, -0.2853902280330658, -0.2671985328197479, -0.05897744372487068, -0.3581696152687073, -0.5988979935646057, 0.18060868978500366, -0.6942125558853149, -0.061471257358789444, 0.09790486097335815, -0.5349808931350708, -0.531241238117218, 0.4110848903656006, -0.415086954832077, 0.9945369362831116, 0.20917187631130219, 0.1618064045906067, 0.5186578631401062, -0.6506904363632202, -0.2400037795305252, 0.29116740822792053, -0.4752805531024933, -0.5019726753234863, -0.06480599194765091, 0.08913534879684448, 0.3469955623149872, -0.12037133425474167, 0.5618826150894165, -0.1033250093460083, -0.06575404852628708, 0.3792990744113922, -0.4854016602039337, 0.43040362000465393, 0.5698540210723877, 0.00735618406906724, 0.4384583830833435, -0.4679408371448517, 0.2659817337989807, 0.2700977325439453, -0.6515623927116394, 0.08770119398832321, -0.1335795372724533, 0.12994377315044403, 0.1276671290397644, -0.09719108045101166, -0.3895890712738037, 0.27365875244140625, -0.36108264327049255, 0.6025274991989136, 0.6200432777404785, -0.04474212974309921, 0.7191692590713501, -0.1332576721906662, 0.8531220555305481, 0.1663169115781784, 0.3933470845222473, -0.3094947934150696, 0.10058210045099258, -0.8358996510505676, -0.12035892903804779, 0.3568377196788788, 0.8757696151733398, -0.8960569500923157, 0.0026735933497548103, -0.033664412796497345, -0.23875367641448975, -0.09549053013324738, -0.14573968946933746, 0.3046700060367584, 0.42178353667259216, 0.5476933121681213, -0.17772026360034943, -0.08580804616212845, -0.8037440180778503, -0.34992948174476624, 0.1901458352804184, 0.44299450516700745, 0.25245004892349243, 0.5955644249916077, -0.14657112956047058, 1.1124694347381592, -0.5633808970451355, -0.5054938197135925, -0.4795915484428406, -0.15386360883712769, 0.38657447695732117, 0.4855266213417053, 0.646311342716217, -0.6477525234222412, -0.41202861070632935, 0.35888612270355225, -0.6640020608901978, 0.3273616433143616, -0.25241708755493164, 0.0460815504193306, 0.14582163095474243, 0.6405678987503052, -0.5908848643302917, 0.3501688838005066, 0.4072379767894745, -0.5646839737892151, 0.5350205302238464, -0.683962881565094, -0.11649131029844284, -0.7649635076522827, -0.23659376800060272, 0.21971413493156433, -0.6540956497192383, -0.1630297154188156, 0.3282264173030853, 0.15025901794433594, -0.23005777597427368, -0.5308471322059631, 0.4074733853340149, -0.41522982716560364, -0.41244032979011536, -0.37407588958740234, -0.3501049876213074, 0.11124062538146973, 0.6399800777435303, -0.35587286949157715, 1.1613610982894897, 0.640508770942688, -0.7753618955612183, 0.7099776864051819, 0.1911676675081253, -0.27366310358047485, 0.3784123659133911, -0.37438976764678955, -0.517879068851471, -0.3521278500556946, 0.28062936663627625, -0.4691893756389618, -0.18565282225608826, 0.674736738204956, -0.3401116132736206, 0.21181774139404297, 0.12389548867940903, -0.23014257848262787, -0.45258328318595886, 0.1703251153230667, -0.057536426931619644, 0.7148071527481079, -0.13734453916549683, 0.9305997490882874, 0.14244507253170013, -0.240488201379776, -0.0761207789182663, -0.5547727942466736, 0.2626640498638153, -0.2057252675294876, 0.027594981715083122, -0.09597969800233841, 0.34037959575653076, -0.15375417470932007, 0.2731696665287018, -0.20101282000541687, -0.29134905338287354, 0.3184272050857544, 0.08021248877048492, -0.18708695471286774, 0.03380923345685005, 0.5533825159072876, 0.21762070059776306, -0.16420452296733856, 0.23162506520748138, -0.6927493214607239, 0.40616992115974426, -0.2579921782016754, 0.08453378081321716, -0.5706376433372498, 0.016859441995620728, 0.43930351734161377, -0.5921717286109924, 0.4132249653339386, 0.2519025504589081, -0.17469961941242218, -0.437333345413208, -0.10368795692920685, -0.30694982409477234, -0.4890275001525879, 0.7344534993171692, -0.4352392256259918, -0.37249433994293213, -0.05592193827033043, -0.8429647088050842, 0.048273298889398575, 0.32348865270614624, -0.18227694928646088, -0.19615434110164642, 0.746916651725769, 0.6847526431083679, 0.06242300942540169, 0.5556077361106873, -0.5260052680969238, -0.2927735447883606, -0.6506416201591492, -0.5369074940681458, -0.09474720805883408, -0.29760146141052246, -0.018970783799886703, -0.9645558595657349, 0.32896581292152405, 0.014250801876187325, -0.6547785401344299, 0.1022324189543724, -0.31242644786834717, 0.8260373473167419, 0.6170873045921326, 0.26776444911956787, 0.21015870571136475, 0.09882326424121857, -0.3061855435371399, 0.32465699315071106, -0.9979341626167297, -0.6618403792381287, 0.5532501935958862, 0.6150709390640259, 0.7124683260917664, -0.12854698300361633, 0.5303927063941956, 0.48062664270401, 0.28953254222869873, -0.9736176133155823, 0.6491236686706543, -0.3945498764514923, 0.12989257276058197, -0.45207104086875916, -0.5975432991981506, -0.7300519943237305, 0.3906797766685486, -0.5100500583648682, -0.4748859107494354, -0.04240723326802254, 0.3855360746383667, -0.6241323351860046, 0.3474186062812805, -0.5861527323722839, 0.7335404753684998, -0.6886155009269714, -0.20944000780582428, -0.20535597205162048, -0.35045963525772095, 0.0012796460650861263, 0.10709989070892334, 0.5020871162414551, -0.4101962149143219, 0.01574067957699299, 0.575604259967804, -0.46682417392730713, 0.6917322874069214, -0.2904234230518341, -0.008504634723067284, 0.2890181839466095, 0.295418918132782, 0.5194360017776489, 0.13495030999183655, -0.1729394942522049, -0.20158709585666656, -0.17795637249946594, -0.15848834812641144, -0.388671338558197, 0.7423247694969177, -1.1195096969604492, -0.4966168701648712, -0.753308892250061, -0.629709005355835, -0.07660254836082458, 0.2899022102355957, -0.32170751690864563, -0.07885043323040009, -0.17296484112739563, 0.17023766040802002, 0.6549620032310486, -0.6724123954772949, 0.49887412786483765, 0.3418373465538025, -0.7310464382171631, -0.5176634192466736, 0.8935438394546509, 0.15102408826351166, 0.13611122965812683, 0.2998948097229004, 0.4877121150493622, -0.19021271169185638, -0.27031734585762024, -0.48642733693122864, -0.2751863896846771, -0.6580438017845154, -0.6405720114707947, -0.8967283368110657, -0.36856088042259216, -0.02966029942035675, 0.0982738509774208, -0.4578566253185272, -0.1293330043554306, -0.2686988115310669, -0.5248360633850098, 0.6514983177185059, 0.7036281228065491, 0.1710677295923233, 0.8160938024520874, -0.5258339047431946, 0.18805283308029175, 0.23698194324970245, 0.3493654727935791, -0.012547719292342663, -0.23812386393547058, -0.20716941356658936, 0.2908131778240204, -0.5512992143630981, -0.9226078391075134, 0.7927116751670837, 0.6511856317520142, 0.23740312457084656, -0.06162891164422035, -0.22886255383491516, 0.47910526394844055, -0.45076873898506165, 0.27343064546585083, 0.41690754890441895, -1.0773394107818604, 0.44525429606437683, -0.23016677796840668, 0.5315762162208557, 0.3750283718109131, -0.010458452627062798, -0.4146912395954132, -0.5335440635681152, -0.2678869664669037, -1.1266382932662964, 0.8316850662231445, 0.06904316693544388, 0.04291126877069473, 0.09840641915798187, 0.3815445899963379, 0.2015657275915146, 0.18742771446704865, -0.6130197644233704, -0.004465727601200342, -0.2304881066083908, -0.2431141585111618, -0.08749121427536011, -0.053101133555173874, 0.09406955540180206, -0.3738679587841034, 0.7688630223274231, -0.26421454548835754, -0.290063738822937, 0.23430569469928741, -0.000012052952115482185, -0.04322034493088722, 0.2549988627433777, 0.21576432883739471, 0.6572604179382324, 0.24698017537593842, 0.1628333181142807, 0.4097229242324829, -0.19999843835830688, 0.37761640548706055, 0.10308929532766342, -0.415311723947525, -0.34975680708885193, -0.14936423301696777, 0.9864769577980042, 0.27447590231895447, -0.3141308128833771, 0.3117043673992157, 0.14261791110038757, -0.5502423644065857, -0.5642929077148438, 0.3210735321044922, 0.12147174030542374, 0.6023811101913452, 0.5379470586776733, 0.4400630295276642, 0.04266190901398659, -0.33130931854248047, 0.40174275636672974, 0.1966172456741333, -0.41436895728111267, 0.07404885441064835, 0.6473687291145325, 0.4804377257823944, -0.2699697017669678, 0.5243148803710938, -0.24573856592178345, -0.692906379699707, 1.1944314241409302, 0.46703416109085083, 0.3269243836402893, -0.020028654485940933, 0.8464566469192505, 0.1979532092809677, 0.3668273389339447, -0.15074801445007324, 0.5577380657196045, 0.19106921553611755, -0.6645957231521606, -0.5016701221466064, -0.8186545968055725, -0.3424615263938904, -0.0013983575627207756, -0.4845251142978668, -0.16294927895069122, -0.7620407342910767, -0.3989768624305725, 0.08388315141201019, -0.04950549826025963, -0.9225962162017822, 0.6759583353996277, -0.0006454942049458623, 0.989800751209259, -0.8684551119804382, 0.6779688000679016, 1.098415732383728, -0.3113816976547241, -1.0490354299545288, -0.4442960321903229, -0.48705294728279114, -1.0266917943954468, 0.8121668696403503, 0.17604133486747742, -0.10562720149755478, 0.2636854648590088, -0.42631158232688904, -0.8380789756774902, 1.1224721670150757, 0.13509425520896912, -0.8463187217712402, 0.27069517970085144, 0.1052466407418251, 0.43334975838661194, -0.17724846303462982, 0.2642636001110077, 0.3065790832042694, 0.5979612469673157, 0.17182767391204834, -0.6222760677337646, -0.14792963862419128, 0.057355936616659164, 0.30200818181037903, 0.5176301598548889, -0.765766441822052, 0.9654392004013062, -0.29634764790534973, -0.5046667456626892, -0.0042692492716014385, 1.0314321517944336, 0.03602318838238716, 0.44618961215019226, 0.41553354263305664, 0.5100396275520325, 0.7056367993354797, -0.2952480614185333, 0.8685228228569031, -0.5216743350028992, 0.46312448382377625, 1.0158876180648804, -0.3212280869483948, 0.5344716310501099, 0.6270433068275452, -0.11355536431074142, 0.3502222001552582, 0.6160157322883606, -0.2622426152229309, 0.26569658517837524, 0.5041511654853821, 0.021254856139421463, -0.6033463478088379, -0.25200799107551575, -0.1958726942539215, 0.5591481328010559, 0.39975669980049133, -0.4310239553451538, -0.41230931878089905, 0.3622508943080902, -0.08261200040578842, 0.8123419284820557, -0.6177515983581543, 0.9208792448043823, 0.18708984553813934, -0.4919869601726532, -0.11901216953992844, 0.11430204659700394, 0.4063010811805725, -0.6104175448417664, -0.28574317693710327, -0.2171211689710617, 0.5145761370658875, -0.042942505329847336, -0.9636850953102112, 0.2991817593574524, -0.2579534649848938, -0.07646513730287552, -0.4325670301914215, 0.49746668338775635, -0.5343099236488342, -0.7882916331291199, 0.3443286716938019, 0.5871369242668152, 0.007814304903149605, 0.15242736041545868, -0.6316954493522644, 0.06807613372802734, -0.40521126985549927, -0.08037786930799484, -0.06476102769374847, 0.43176716566085815, -0.18332979083061218, 0.9358757138252258, 0.5505151152610779, 0.4498371183872223, -0.039752718061208725, -0.1980012059211731, 0.9998525977134705, -0.9615415930747986, -0.7163767218589783, -0.7160587310791016, -0.05016661062836647, -0.22678281366825104, -0.14119072258472443, 0.5874862670898438, 0.5858873724937439, 0.9219222068786621, -0.26042842864990234, 1.0136569738388062, 0.1073228195309639, 0.11340328305959702, -0.4408669173717499, 0.560684323310852, -0.33657321333885193, 0.053328175097703934, 0.22177395224571228, -0.7250349521636963, -0.007230151444673538, 0.4809044599533081, -0.5069156289100647, 0.1817881017923355, 0.396474689245224, 0.3398887813091278, -0.016850922256708145, -0.29022619128227234, 0.374772846698761, 0.18289248645305634, 0.34785225987434387, 0.6330968737602234, 1.003401517868042, -0.17397454380989075, 0.5369408130645752, -0.14808718860149384, -0.3503052592277527, -0.09346708655357361, -0.812532365322113, -0.21238097548484802, 0.16873198747634888, -0.25409606099128723, 0.13567288219928741, 0.549777626991272, 1.0895096063613892, 0.5026192665100098, -0.5516687631607056, -0.3174918293952942, -0.6076465845108032, -0.023185361176729202, -0.5640860795974731, -0.30611157417297363, 0.08564546704292297, -0.5094552636146545, -0.5773757100105286, 0.38029155135154724, 0.4769800901412964, 0.17994610965251923, -0.09707381576299667, -0.2170325368642807, -0.05403323471546173, 0.11199891567230225, 0.528542160987854, 0.3988548517227173, -0.5150035619735718, -0.06295495480298996, 0.019940387457609177, -0.08240901678800583, -0.10104891657829285, 0.42963242530822754, -1.1215953826904297, 0.20913341641426086, 0.046585168689489365, 0.7587796449661255, -0.03754833713173866, 0.0473550409078598, 0.6983429193496704, -0.3568820655345917, 0.03271794691681862, 0.49881911277770996, 0.05103283375501633, 0.1959872990846634, -0.4210965037345886, 0.21848903596401215, -0.15744727849960327, -0.40379130840301514, -0.27473756670951843, 0.5361663103103638, -0.6496955156326294, -0.522346019744873, 1.1229537725448608, -0.13180798292160034, -0.49701759219169617, 0.3269267976284027, -0.3459011912345886, 0.30217495560646057, -0.7319938540458679, 0.532009482383728, 0.17816835641860962, 0.23037511110305786, -0.41000494360923767, -0.24515756964683533, 0.4213453531265259, 0.5352808833122253, -0.8854246139526367, -0.31335005164146423, 0.4434331953525543, 0.16023598611354828, -0.05772152543067932, 0.4567475914955139, 0.27752622961997986, 0.12148530036211014, -0.17214660346508026, 0.2616128921508789, -0.5152645707130432, -0.7947800159454346, -0.2290521115064621, 0.04807937517762184, 0.17681638896465302, -0.4600083529949188 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19837v3
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19837v3
Concept-based Analysis of Neural Networks via Vision-Language Models
2024-03-28T21:15:38
2024-04-10T23:47:34
Ravi Mangal, Nina Narodytska, Divya Gopinath, Boyue Caroline Hu, Anirban Roy, Susmit Jha, Corina Pasareanu
cs.LG
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LO
The analysis of vision-based deep neural networks (DNNs) is highly desirable but it is very challenging due to the difficulty of expressing formal specifications for vision tasks and the lack of efficient verification procedures. In this paper, we propose to leverage emerging multimodal, vision-language, foundation models (VLMs) as a lens through which we can reason about vision models. VLMs have been trained on a large body of images accompanied by their textual description, and are thus implicitly aware of high-level, human-understandable concepts describing the images. We describe a logical specification language $\texttt{Con}_{\texttt{spec}}$ designed to facilitate writing specifications in terms of these concepts. To define and formally check $\texttt{Con}_{\texttt{spec}}$ specifications, we build a map between the internal representations of a given vision model and a VLM, leading to an efficient verification procedure of natural-language properties for vision models. We demonstrate our techniques on a ResNet-based classifier trained on the RIVAL-10 dataset using CLIP as the multimodal model.
[ -0.5428612232208252, -0.590209424495697, 0.36213940382003784, -0.11643190681934357, -0.34335705637931824, 0.11513488739728928, -0.2508206367492676, -0.6670535802841187, 0.1340293288230896, 0.6552233695983887, -0.5138631463050842, -0.44990071654319763, -0.3233659863471985, 0.05975686013698578, -0.6392674446105957, 0.41864147782325745, -0.15328678488731384, 0.04203913360834122, -0.43301549553871155, -0.1738690584897995, -0.3969556987285614, -0.38284143805503845, -0.38168829679489136, -0.1071721762418747, 0.4061073064804077, 0.018809115514159203, 0.4589826762676239, 0.3253411054611206, 0.8617823719978333, 0.4278411865234375, -0.11739588528871536, 0.54730623960495, -0.21593865752220154, 0.04339927062392235, -0.26073798537254333, -0.32138001918792725, -0.3250093460083008, 0.043084871023893356, 0.7206000089645386, 0.4983294606208801, 0.08269674330949783, 0.37852245569229126, -0.07755681872367859, 0.5390755534172058, -0.7299948334693909, 0.2923114001750946, -0.6928429007530212, 0.24983826279640198, -0.03278393670916557, -0.3067348897457123, -0.46868932247161865, 0.00012142777268309146, 0.26280516386032104, -0.5351428389549255, 0.23170983791351318, 0.018612081184983253, 1.149768352508545, 0.3459567427635193, -0.3342658579349518, 0.011845267377793789, -0.6683956384658813, 0.5194196701049805, -0.42083871364593506, 0.7199326753616333, 0.20246298611164093, 0.7415585517883301, 0.07293674349784851, -0.9718823432922363, -0.8853853344917297, -0.5353060960769653, -0.41095495223999023, 0.06911216676235199, -0.01681426540017128, 0.1835145801305771, 0.2883435785770416, 0.34665629267692566, -0.3328724801540375, -0.16346345841884613, -0.554408848285675, -0.23899473249912262, 0.7094250917434692, 0.18971964716911316, 0.23820747435092926, -0.09207265079021454, -0.533707857131958, -0.008485700935125351, -0.4980466067790985, -0.03525343909859657, -0.06298729032278061, 0.12876534461975098, -0.17647403478622437, 0.7131320238113403, -0.5250421762466431, 1.0416871309280396, -0.1351304054260254, -0.02333303540945053, 0.1265476793050766, -0.6239372491836548, -0.5037344694137573, -0.22319550812244415, 0.7138842344284058, 0.6674343943595886, 0.5266973972320557, -0.1587572693824768, -0.3223542273044586, 0.4510958790779114, 0.35620808601379395, -0.8333793878555298, -0.27637138962745667, 0.002399926772341132, -0.5382550954818726, -0.5093486309051514, -0.20427845418453217, -0.6860201358795166, -0.5640628337860107, -0.6303896903991699, 0.38725966215133667, -0.4013253450393677, -0.35772475600242615, 0.282431036233902, -0.0978429764509201, 0.2591584324836731, 0.41489166021347046, -0.4237411916255951, 0.24206210672855377, 0.46550825238227844, 0.7988413572311401, 0.10766487568616867, -0.23652422428131104, -0.1910802721977234, -0.19383437931537628, -0.49961310625076294, 0.7049904465675354, -0.32699593901634216, -0.10272173583507538, -0.06631837785243988, -0.06455537676811218, -0.07702778279781342, -0.3842346966266632, 0.3169596195220947, -0.6345218420028687, -0.06247291341423988, -0.07446510344743729, -0.681959331035614, -0.48027217388153076, 0.7799317836761475, -0.7461506724357605, 0.7950754165649414, -0.09822332859039307, -0.6221615076065063, 0.32265985012054443, -0.7403942942619324, -0.4216616153717041, 0.17081066966056824, -0.5497444868087769, -0.178012415766716, 0.19291459023952484, -0.013865663670003414, 0.5534233450889587, -0.3537103533744812, 0.4421178698539734, -0.32988572120666504, -0.15004830062389374, 0.5011716485023499, -0.36573877930641174, 0.7581946849822998, 0.21855324506759644, -0.2996309697628021, 0.24724465608596802, -1.0944405794143677, 0.18433986604213715, 0.0237441249191761, -0.0015772772021591663, -0.2878517508506775, 0.27262231707572937, -0.04025986045598984, 0.25081613659858704, 0.14366556704044342, -0.6045644283294678, -0.03556688129901886, -0.12660765647888184, 0.4876993000507355, 0.5003723502159119, -0.29215458035469055, 0.13975729048252106, 0.07332571595907211, 0.4037458300590515, -0.0009327935986220837, 0.38953641057014465, -0.353401780128479, -0.4163670241832733, -1.0960100889205933, -0.238033726811409, 0.16285109519958496, 0.33624720573425293, -0.9616840481758118, 0.1428096741437912, -0.22007222473621368, -0.39488473534584045, -0.292757511138916, -0.11207704991102219, 0.4575464129447937, 0.906032145023346, 0.3254004716873169, -0.23646903038024902, -0.7534622550010681, -1.1144161224365234, 0.2794497311115265, -0.31255772709846497, 0.40948963165283203, 0.4099152088165283, 0.6727049350738525, -0.07478129118680954, 1.216812252998352, -0.5832696557044983, -0.13230378925800323, -0.21447862684726715, -0.2847772240638733, -0.13152438402175903, 0.2778056263923645, 0.7060930728912354, -1.231979250907898, -0.14296889305114746, 0.05402356758713722, -1.0326608419418335, 0.17538532614707947, -0.02817947417497635, -0.023931216448545456, -0.16066448390483856, 0.7461954951286316, -0.37433040142059326, 0.720028281211853, 0.49191197752952576, -0.4965496361255646, 0.8075589537620544, -0.03399405628442764, 0.010974900797009468, -0.8357030749320984, 0.18980497121810913, 0.45412522554397583, -0.2894531190395355, -0.5743412971496582, 0.5264863967895508, 0.1040533035993576, -0.12000023573637009, -0.5400832295417786, 0.5175509452819824, -0.2710861563682556, -0.1701829582452774, -0.10088810324668884, -0.05779541656374931, 0.4286152422428131, 0.38955792784690857, 0.5788697004318237, 0.5227940678596497, 0.6952232718467712, -0.6973411440849304, 0.8134307861328125, 0.1738448441028595, -0.6359118819236755, 0.741595983505249, -0.7908787131309509, -0.1931210458278656, -0.11192996054887772, 0.18999867141246796, -0.9244932532310486, -0.026544151827692986, 0.3250633776187897, -0.2918069362640381, 0.033890388906002045, -0.27420538663864136, -0.42072010040283203, -0.4529985785484314, 0.22797638177871704, 0.3842923641204834, 0.14949220418930054, -0.5008772611618042, 0.8105579018592834, 0.2632724642753601, 0.5875780582427979, -0.480256587266922, -0.7160816192626953, 0.29406630992889404, -0.02985818311572075, -0.9466432332992554, 0.4574347734451294, -0.03563762083649635, -0.46402475237846375, 0.1730964183807373, 0.17889954149723053, -0.5061333179473877, 0.3570878803730011, 0.3152402937412262, 0.5604361891746521, -0.5588220953941345, 0.21286432445049286, -0.510380208492279, 0.016504278406500816, -0.027510065585374832, -0.3905724585056305, 0.2789965271949768, -0.5081871747970581, -0.3994971513748169, -0.5977612137794495, 0.07754533737897873, 0.8042776584625244, -0.8040052652359009, 0.44872164726257324, 0.4894649386405945, -0.4616585969924927, -0.3157038688659668, -0.4557632803916931, -0.335547536611557, -0.4974185824394226, 0.5304604768753052, -0.5467478036880493, -0.652731716632843, 0.46926891803741455, -0.11129822582006454, -0.17860578000545502, 0.38350579142570496, 0.44537651538848877, -0.35535985231399536, 0.5125677585601807, 0.7933436632156372, 0.4423863887786865, 0.4938952922821045, -0.6376976370811462, 0.04105145111680031, -0.8000518083572388, -0.504751443862915, -0.15479178726673126, -0.6446492671966553, -0.1827324777841568, -0.45819875597953796, 0.1512138992547989, -0.13987256586551666, 0.014842561446130276, 0.4191569685935974, -0.4366928040981293, 0.5869640111923218, 0.4697425663471222, 0.08575499802827835, 0.2221822291612625, -0.08988190442323685, -0.396344393491745, 0.1314029097557068, -0.4284636378288269, -0.2691369950771332, 0.8193321824073792, 0.36206987500190735, 0.6819931268692017, -0.1631663739681244, 0.3519143760204315, 0.10712654143571854, 0.077872633934021, -1.0030674934387207, 0.7703484296798706, -0.42555561661720276, -0.7297360301017761, -0.1345261186361313, -0.2990477979183197, -0.38081496953964233, 0.5031179785728455, -0.30868446826934814, -0.5830999612808228, 0.5282654166221619, 0.2804338335990906, -0.5452595949172974, 0.38785645365715027, -0.5831195712089539, 1.0191125869750977, -0.5155911445617676, -0.20580695569515228, -0.23986025154590607, -0.49945488572120667, 0.6556181311607361, 0.22062702476978302, -0.04579668119549751, -0.1560760885477066, 0.2181389182806015, 0.27084898948669434, -0.4319935142993927, 1.1332683563232422, 0.021621711552143097, -0.14923228323459625, 0.49158814549446106, 0.18837977945804596, 0.1093185693025589, 0.06305541098117828, 0.08901750296354294, 0.15658137202262878, -0.020383987575769424, 0.05374249070882797, -0.7883609533309937, 0.21330665051937103, -0.42311736941337585, -0.20924849808216095, -0.13112957775592804, -0.2808038592338562, -0.15228396654129028, 0.28752490878105164, 0.2203976958990097, 0.951486349105835, -0.11404123157262802, 0.1720871478319168, 0.597834587097168, -0.06482753902673721, 0.3066074848175049, 0.5504128336906433, -0.4987407922744751, -0.08672431856393814, 1.0233968496322632, 0.0341389998793602, 0.23173865675926208, 0.407255619764328, 0.2770611047744751, -0.3634800314903259, -0.7379277944564819, -0.6238804459571838, -0.19896914064884186, -0.7792410850524902, -0.17129260301589966, -0.18519674241542816, -0.5014474987983704, -0.07120277732610703, 0.09232518076896667, -0.5455902218818665, -0.3659673035144806, -0.15731395781040192, 0.006288112141191959, 0.23724110424518585, 0.6074954867362976, 0.21205706894397736, 0.1227479949593544, -0.6761268377304077, 0.5432878732681274, 0.35816290974617004, 0.5964981913566589, -0.09039472788572311, -0.3382422626018524, -0.3143598735332489, 0.10050409287214279, -0.010132404044270515, -0.6638206243515015, 0.09713278710842133, 0.337141215801239, 0.6101990938186646, 0.4234178066253662, -0.059942398220300674, 0.5978718996047974, -0.535086989402771, 0.7002952098846436, 0.34654220938682556, -0.8096303343772888, 0.6385645866394043, 0.1410525143146515, -0.19002951681613922, 0.4000003933906555, -0.07353770732879639, -0.7082036137580872, -0.0607261136174202, -0.435761958360672, -0.44042566418647766, 0.40060871839523315, 0.16436970233917236, 0.05484190583229065, 0.049176763743162155, 0.46214208006858826, -0.28919240832328796, 0.2409772127866745, -0.4698503315448761, -0.24011468887329102, -0.5425168871879578, -0.3527926802635193, 0.03596949949860573, -0.13699162006378174, -0.27552783489227295, -0.3458673059940338, 0.09987716376781464, -0.36177682876586914, -0.10875469446182251, 0.32096847891807556, -0.3056809902191162, 0.4583694040775299, -0.1091088056564331, 0.8811644315719604, 0.7194549441337585, -0.1720035970211029, 0.5327269434928894, -0.11887524276971817, -0.4173769950866699, 0.1928749531507492, -0.026747940108180046, -0.42661210894584656, 0.20516902208328247, 0.5075656771659851, 1.0586388111114502, 0.25362423062324524, -0.738140881061554, 0.5723494291305542, -0.25173985958099365, -0.2649977207183838, -0.15802918374538422, -0.022733096033334732, -0.04835283011198044, 0.37491801381111145, -0.03957526013255119, 0.3541896939277649, 0.13550874590873718, -0.3414483368396759, 0.482237845659256, 0.367797315120697, -0.6482616066932678, -0.43084800243377686, 0.30171114206314087, 0.4940131902694702, 0.006631997413933277, 0.6669244170188904, -0.24063384532928467, -0.7503272891044617, 0.9598744511604309, 0.29787924885749817, 0.8310874104499817, 0.26182830333709717, 0.4288956820964813, 0.3277117908000946, 0.4137245714664459, 0.030929427593946457, 0.31385573744773865, 0.03287925571203232, -1.2175507545471191, -0.5863961577415466, -0.6409975290298462, -0.19574357569217682, 0.04977952688932419, -0.4785536229610443, 0.2648994028568268, -0.6332533955574036, -0.22657708823680878, 0.25797757506370544, -0.40219318866729736, -0.8136569857597351, 0.5889398455619812, 0.5503396391868591, 1.1436946392059326, -0.555129885673523, 0.9320597052574158, 0.7924848794937134, -0.514102041721344, -0.6656194925308228, -0.3666954040527344, -0.09000306576490402, -0.9246404767036438, 1.317775011062622, 0.08585932850837708, -0.39357906579971313, -0.09912923723459244, -0.49865666031837463, -0.7537515163421631, 0.8921950459480286, 0.5376862287521362, -0.6744707226753235, -0.0900283083319664, -0.11003364622592926, 0.4677218496799469, -0.5308986306190491, 0.11191458255052567, 0.3273802399635315, 0.37219032645225525, 0.2863503396511078, -0.9208986163139343, -0.09425859153270721, -0.32471704483032227, -0.04208751022815704, -0.024067305028438568, -0.4907347559928894, 0.9491645693778992, -0.3469289243221283, -0.28651025891304016, -0.0425235889852047, 0.5985810160636902, -0.0889374166727066, 0.14174200594425201, 0.7094852328300476, 0.6816217303276062, 0.708107054233551, 0.019748583436012268, 1.1305127143859863, -0.2503569424152374, 0.40338265895843506, 1.295944094657898, -0.23398612439632416, 0.9344555139541626, 0.4451792538166046, -0.15107423067092896, 0.4638017416000366, 0.43120452761650085, -0.35460883378982544, 0.5011504292488098, 0.33724072575569153, -0.039612267166376114, -0.6129938960075378, -0.2050333470106125, -0.23065528273582458, 0.898540735244751, 0.40874436497688293, -0.5165460109710693, -0.26792699098587036, -0.10138227045536041, -0.6127986311912537, 0.10639000684022903, -0.33635973930358887, 0.6240609288215637, 0.06579206138849258, -0.3811328113079071, 0.5638561248779297, -0.06014573574066162, 0.5391560792922974, -0.4571291506290436, -0.02114979550242424, 0.015569986775517464, 0.3706297278404236, -0.13892197608947754, -0.9032750129699707, 0.4451528489589691, -0.09723084419965744, -0.2663351893424988, 0.015999730676412582, 0.7939850091934204, -0.428939551115036, -0.8021750450134277, 0.2626723349094391, 0.2591807544231415, -0.1443263590335846, -0.2006259560585022, -0.7051147222518921, 0.20945169031620026, -0.29575052857398987, 0.07923616468906403, -0.12101593613624573, 0.2866916060447693, -0.050770506262779236, 0.8370755910873413, 0.530166745185852, 0.09362638741731644, 0.16042421758174896, 0.2142174243927002, 0.7723575234413147, -0.39600372314453125, -0.4273485541343689, -1.04798424243927, 0.6577675938606262, -0.3093235492706299, -0.3735068440437317, 0.43049871921539307, 0.4275156557559967, 0.8506693243980408, -0.02258877083659172, 0.7189767360687256, -0.09213609248399734, -0.004501713439822197, -0.7002032995223999, 0.8312538266181946, -0.8659409284591675, -0.003881278447806835, -0.012813943438231945, -0.5673723816871643, -0.3662868142127991, 0.8229618072509766, 0.0022006588988006115, -0.3462311923503876, 0.6225021481513977, 0.7160843014717102, -0.26210102438926697, 0.05772283673286438, 0.35610663890838623, -0.04329479858279228, 0.3356871008872986, 0.42320379614830017, 1.149106740951538, -0.1911400556564331, 0.5365616679191589, -0.4662337005138397, -0.043037768453359604, -0.2672343850135803, -1.087465524673462, -0.7983680963516235, -0.7052842378616333, -0.5164938569068909, -0.3488873243331909, -0.12981915473937988, 0.48316624760627747, 1.0340549945831299, -0.6845293641090393, -0.16921715438365936, -0.08989617973566055, 0.218233123421669, -0.24690991640090942, -0.13546782732009888, 0.3542211353778839, -0.17563781142234802, -0.36930763721466064, 0.39421573281288147, 0.3426622450351715, 0.196027472615242, -0.7606659531593323, -0.13184741139411926, 0.04416554421186447, -0.06658793240785599, 0.7479814291000366, 0.11183101683855057, -0.9856433868408203, -0.2989014983177185, 0.1149127408862114, -0.1486828476190567, -0.1072869598865509, 0.9532811045646667, -0.8854556083679199, 0.7798143625259399, 0.5304898023605347, 0.6510974764823914, 0.18309283256530762, -0.45264095067977905, 0.6626272201538086, -0.7784813046455383, 0.19820234179496765, 0.1785188615322113, 0.80575031042099, 0.43046659231185913, -0.0671110451221466, 0.5932696461677551, 0.49599704146385193, 0.18371456861495972, -0.8105853796005249, 0.5019751191139221, -1.0457680225372314, -0.3639985918998718, 0.9517681002616882, -0.3564545214176178, -0.21909020841121674, 0.12162161618471146, -0.2622649669647217, 0.06774543225765228, 0.16153877973556519, 0.5998514890670776, 0.6319701671600342, 0.23987840116024017, -0.4161970913410187, -0.5191143751144409, 0.5291719436645508, -0.014105645939707756, -0.7039855122566223, 0.052767589688301086, 0.4060939848423004, 0.1536550670862198, 0.5153311491012573, 0.3548317849636078, -0.02795347012579441, 0.3461301922798157, -0.0003733844787348062, 0.009089460596442223, -0.411170095205307, -0.565157413482666, -0.014987177215516567, 0.2577245533466339, -0.2519218623638153, -0.6368839144706726 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19836v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19836v2
Target Span Detection for Implicit Harmful Content
2024-03-28T21:15:15
2024-06-27T22:28:27
Nazanin Jafari, James Allan, Sheikh Muhammad Sarwar
cs.CL
cs.CL
Identifying the targets of hate speech is a crucial step in grasping the nature of such speech and, ultimately, in improving the detection of offensive posts on online forums. Much harmful content on online platforms uses implicit language especially when targeting vulnerable and protected groups such as using stereotypical characteristics instead of explicit target names, making it harder to detect and mitigate the language. In this study, we focus on identifying implied targets of hate speech, essential for recognizing subtler hate speech and enhancing the detection of harmful content on digital platforms. We define a new task aimed at identifying the targets even when they are not explicitly stated. To address that task, we collect and annotate target spans in three prominent implicit hate speech datasets: SBIC, DynaHate, and IHC. We call the resulting merged collection Implicit-Target-Span. The collection is achieved using an innovative pooling method with matching scores based on human annotations and Large Language Models (LLMs). Our experiments indicate that Implicit-Target-Span provides a challenging test bed for target span detection methods.
[ -0.5917508006095886, -0.8575698733329773, 0.29764580726623535, 0.12270953506231308, -0.06988576054573059, 0.10018563270568848, -0.033486172556877136, -1.0277286767959595, 0.058597415685653687, 0.29465606808662415, -0.8348643779754639, -0.3097681999206543, -1.0107632875442505, -0.013742350041866302, -0.8993493318557739, 1.2781473398208618, -0.016019029542803764, -0.3168178200721741, 0.3310732841491699, 0.056536294519901276, -0.42251893877983093, 0.024105392396450043, -0.9254186749458313, 0.2637280821800232, 0.8876957893371582, 0.13252130150794983, 0.34218645095825195, 0.5843755006790161, 0.37474989891052246, 0.19701829552650452, -0.0007982239476405084, 0.08087920397520065, -0.676189124584198, 0.43438494205474854, -0.03004826232790947, -0.14488066732883453, -0.12725239992141724, 0.18416014313697815, 0.6932703852653503, 0.30912408232688904, 0.5934828519821167, 0.22316043078899384, 0.029223017394542694, 0.3122910261154175, -1.0214086771011353, -0.19643758237361908, -0.7619014978408813, 0.22756899893283844, -0.5066239833831787, 0.09809982031583786, -0.3019677996635437, -0.37061697244644165, -0.13339382410049438, -0.3510138690471649, 0.13817594945430756, 0.12306737154722214, 0.5552137494087219, 0.402516633272171, -0.3808508813381195, -0.48033830523490906, -0.6947906613349915, 0.6331453323364258, -0.3095802962779999, 0.3383466601371765, 0.3838306665420532, 0.2683289349079132, 0.024212678894400597, -0.270553857088089, -0.5596826076507568, -0.29959946870803833, -0.23293007910251617, -0.14121083915233612, -0.9459568858146667, 0.014667007140815258, 0.4203602373600006, 0.03328460827469826, -0.4744184911251068, 0.5652710795402527, -0.5894787311553955, -0.46664926409721375, 0.7740464210510254, -0.057696953415870667, 0.4302811622619629, -0.051995858550071716, -0.5270330309867859, 0.17379014194011688, -0.5736904740333557, -0.36643555760383606, 0.9023008346557617, 0.5466974377632141, -0.0106876902282238, 0.7727574110031128, -0.00756887998431921, 0.40935438871383667, 0.25747984647750854, 0.15411970019340515, -0.03169642388820648, 0.11386410892009735, 0.27919381856918335, 0.46538305282592773, 0.5152440071105957, 0.44866979122161865, 0.5777227282524109, -0.017788702622056007, 0.05416388064622879, 0.5400110483169556, 0.4647815227508545, -0.590374767780304, 0.045271649956703186, 0.009288459084928036, -0.04201193153858185, -0.24927420914173126, -0.13806188106536865, -0.6502602100372314, -0.7493242025375366, 0.03158543258905411, 0.17063739895820618, -0.327296644449234, -0.43817779421806335, -0.31265127658843994, -0.377716988325119, 0.1221565455198288, 0.04640302062034607, -0.7496042847633362, 0.5236687660217285, 0.6932008862495422, 0.6452589631080627, -0.4831107556819916, 0.013472058810293674, -0.8920301198959351, 0.3285146653652191, -0.13531595468521118, 0.6436551809310913, -0.6565825939178467, -0.06296803802251816, 0.16348573565483093, -0.21434377133846283, 0.2769238352775574, -0.3646140396595001, 1.0782896280288696, -0.4174196422100067, 0.09762853384017944, -0.12972575426101685, -0.6784292459487915, -0.09567515552043915, 0.30479252338409424, -0.7939392924308777, 1.1447088718414307, 0.1444181650876999, -0.8673269748687744, 0.5576529502868652, -0.5469833016395569, -0.38204070925712585, 0.10098789632320404, 0.06581615656614304, -0.597562313079834, 0.029978763312101364, 0.05498297140002251, 0.5877487063407898, 0.14262445271015167, -0.15884828567504883, -0.4494854211807251, -0.5083980560302734, -0.06244092434644699, -0.42368459701538086, 0.4749250113964081, 0.12392114847898483, -0.8537979125976562, 0.3176048696041107, -0.44247573614120483, -0.21771663427352905, 0.05943209305405617, 0.0022378265857696533, -0.7361636161804199, 0.026121685281395912, 0.4861908257007599, 0.35166415572166443, 0.10776074975728989, -0.6362990736961365, -0.11822424829006195, 0.037261489778757095, -0.07306059449911118, 1.1013071537017822, -0.1352049708366394, -0.0005306158564053476, -0.1431535929441452, 0.4876421093940735, -0.19702135026454926, 0.2389630377292633, 0.4997732639312744, -0.3824755549430847, -0.48612263798713684, -0.710189938545227, -0.2867838144302368, 0.21322067081928253, -0.09073344618082047, 0.39124923944473267, 0.053585972636938095, -0.40748777985572815, -0.32762789726257324, -0.07984078675508499, 0.7174755930900574, 0.3917836546897888, 0.728077232837677, 0.1704573780298233, -0.9306320548057556, -1.0841299295425415, -0.5950255393981934, -0.18604108691215515, 0.002058675279840827, 0.20097506046295166, 0.5240090489387512, -0.16389888525009155, 0.7561227083206177, -0.5999225974082947, -0.45023009181022644, -0.08227253705263138, 0.34142863750457764, -0.44645723700523376, 0.2171095907688141, 0.5979833602905273, -1.1336952447891235, -0.8101428747177124, -0.49174806475639343, -0.24064794182777405, -0.6624167561531067, 0.1961163878440857, -0.17026756703853607, -0.2016325294971466, 0.5972281098365784, -0.16286197304725647, 0.24667970836162567, 0.5657863616943359, -0.5923665761947632, 0.7275335192680359, 0.7265926003456116, 0.3053285479545593, -0.621955394744873, -0.08267559111118317, 0.40076330304145813, -0.20039020478725433, -0.7506240606307983, -0.3451693058013916, -0.24802741408348083, 0.31431248784065247, -0.6343396902084351, 0.660294234752655, -0.2474968433380127, -0.16688820719718933, -0.42863428592681885, 0.21697011590003967, -0.385883092880249, 0.2592097818851471, 0.11305364966392517, 0.4205586910247803, 0.20348943769931793, -0.37315768003463745, 0.19094380736351013, 0.052502572536468506, -0.0003751426702365279, 0.9309408068656921, -0.40367159247398376, 0.018431581556797028, -0.2311960905790329, 0.2018319070339203, -1.0510073900222778, -0.07886224240064621, 0.7729557156562805, -0.2641465663909912, 0.1136767715215683, -0.36524707078933716, -0.17660661041736603, -0.4179035723209381, -0.5271228551864624, 0.6392335891723633, 0.12621065974235535, -0.3811338543891907, 0.18681298196315765, 0.5360427498817444, 0.021298017352819443, -0.8711942434310913, -0.512442409992218, -0.19650080800056458, -0.5889260768890381, -0.32303154468536377, 0.6704307198524475, -0.08468212187290192, -0.44558241963386536, 0.04847211390733719, -0.27242156863212585, -0.07874168455600739, 0.10114995390176773, 0.7068084478378296, 0.1667761355638504, 0.029351212084293365, -0.0695497915148735, 0.2107115089893341, -0.023601770401000977, 0.2413068562746048, -0.025802336633205414, 0.4558103382587433, -0.036550115793943405, -0.4002639949321747, -0.15894021093845367, 0.6837351322174072, 0.44815680384635925, -0.024903181940317154, 0.5580000877380371, 0.9619283080101013, -0.7355155348777771, -0.4329443871974945, -0.7105887532234192, -0.226023331284523, -0.41407349705696106, 0.3375237286090851, -0.1037638857960701, -1.2707041501998901, 0.21517181396484375, 0.18778859078884125, -0.07387103140354156, 0.6873487234115601, 0.2922798693180084, 0.028612544760107994, 1.11631178855896, 0.6264550089836121, -0.33850759267807007, 0.5242145657539368, 0.1716434359550476, -0.10694950073957443, -0.7601583003997803, -0.1994544267654419, -0.6002177000045776, -0.36098986864089966, -0.34767743945121765, -0.3264833986759186, 0.3706197142601013, -0.07666556537151337, -0.3591587543487549, 0.5636715888977051, -0.5877029299736023, 0.5134604573249817, 0.1977749913930893, 0.03208179399371147, 0.2846250832080841, 0.21650898456573486, 0.14541727304458618, -0.30606991052627563, -0.040275584906339645, -0.2706868350505829, 0.8141793012619019, 0.4594278037548065, 0.31942018866539, 0.13521066308021545, 0.3415219783782959, 0.9220803380012512, 0.5416987538337708, -0.7656210660934448, 0.4557563066482544, -0.18062151968479156, -1.0034376382827759, -0.2696477770805359, -0.32398930191993713, -0.7998755574226379, 0.032619088888168335, -0.28592202067375183, -0.8837280869483948, -0.10069731622934341, 0.12153632193803787, -0.11173339188098907, 0.4112530052661896, -0.17480555176734924, 0.7687679529190063, -0.21082554757595062, -0.4942472279071808, -0.2859410047531128, -0.4305218756198883, 0.5267780423164368, -0.1020994782447815, 0.08524661511182785, -0.5472994446754456, -0.12806487083435059, 0.7839268445968628, -0.006128719542175531, 0.9756714105606079, -0.2605389356613159, -0.1994258165359497, 0.12142868340015411, 0.10166914761066437, 0.40067917108535767, -0.4532243609428406, -0.12529785931110382, 0.1506284922361374, -0.6001836657524109, -0.1441679745912552, -0.15347705781459808, 0.5758446455001831, -0.3686729967594147, -0.10934541374444962, -0.41193926334381104, -0.47230958938598633, -0.32338517904281616, 0.2477402240037918, 0.13610494136810303, -0.04993467405438423, -0.4218571186065674, -0.16683104634284973, 0.6097484827041626, -0.032510604709386826, 0.20708104968070984, 0.5911777019500732, 0.14855313301086426, -0.0010528750717639923, 0.6028042435646057, -0.1887974590063095, 0.06819639354944229, 0.2745276391506195, -0.02524140290915966, -0.6105148196220398, -0.6185261011123657, -0.12638182938098907, 0.17078238725662231, -0.4852679371833801, -0.10412076860666275, -0.6919732689857483, -0.20222145318984985, -0.2824765741825104, -0.41455304622650146, -0.25049251317977905, 0.049060091376304626, -0.08043321222066879, -0.3264999985694885, 0.5114027857780457, 0.805543839931488, -0.37439659237861633, 0.2961423397064209, -0.2554174065589905, 0.4716552793979645, 0.29993700981140137, 0.22544944286346436, -0.4102940261363983, -0.49375173449516296, 0.08762650936841965, -0.03153438866138458, 0.1793958991765976, -1.234970211982727, 0.3302237391471863, 0.023193607106804848, 0.5812164545059204, 0.4121740460395813, 0.16288527846336365, 0.5066859722137451, -0.5190122723579407, 0.37370988726615906, 0.2858687937259674, -0.8195701241493225, 0.7878988981246948, -0.432530015707016, -0.33501628041267395, 0.5454753041267395, 1.0937517881393433, -0.6152130365371704, -0.5207316279411316, -0.3391170799732208, -0.8048878908157349, 0.566014289855957, 0.3338696360588074, 0.03811080381274223, -0.3027714490890503, 0.12522433698177338, 0.07806669920682907, 0.22103090584278107, -1.0568782091140747, -0.4624117612838745, 0.17736175656318665, -0.26275819540023804, 0.30364760756492615, -0.38997340202331543, -0.3462904989719391, -0.03697090968489647, 0.75150066614151, -0.08037517219781876, 0.01979142799973488, -0.26187318563461304, -0.29439911246299744, -0.44501084089279175, 0.183054581284523, 0.2612365484237671, 0.09816595166921616, -0.09798608720302582, 0.23057517409324646, 0.025647325441241264, -0.6047572493553162, 0.1762152761220932, 0.409056156873703, -0.11426571011543274, -0.14442285895347595, 0.2841756343841553, 0.6540474891662598, 0.2524530589580536, -0.882878839969635, 0.7495834827423096, 0.11102595180273056, 0.053984638303518295, -0.4398416578769684, 0.005086482502520084, -0.3432646095752716, 0.3607579469680786, 0.4720351994037628, -0.21464931964874268, 0.45428696274757385, -0.35291051864624023, 0.5643704533576965, 0.5120551586151123, -0.8518895506858826, -0.015775995329022408, 0.6180511713027954, 0.02215346321463585, 0.13149692118167877, 0.5558338761329651, -0.13983845710754395, -0.8165556192398071, 0.499691367149353, 0.6269663572311401, 0.8715171217918396, -0.26730355620384216, 0.43802666664123535, 0.38501274585723877, 0.3872204124927521, 0.3580431044101715, -0.13805006444454193, -0.10504371672868729, -0.6713231205940247, -0.28571122884750366, -0.7747493982315063, -0.11447224020957947, 0.15895183384418488, -0.5457459688186646, 0.3520783483982086, -0.4771188497543335, 0.12350209057331085, 0.36242392659187317, -0.007403660099953413, -0.21479730308055878, 0.2108737826347351, 0.8837912678718567, 0.466877818107605, -1.34064781665802, 0.16364601254463196, 0.16365912556648254, -0.30238956212997437, -0.6953912973403931, 0.03619833290576935, 0.5158710479736328, -0.7879054546356201, 0.8458728790283203, 0.36924999952316284, -0.4825705885887146, -0.03471589460968971, -0.5688039660453796, -0.5944763422012329, 0.5976864099502563, 0.3882113993167877, -0.4986254572868347, -0.03068934939801693, 0.3064763844013214, 0.5071420669555664, -0.3219137489795685, 0.290798157453537, 0.5088924765586853, 0.623087465763092, 0.1463930904865265, -0.6731314063072205, 0.4524291455745697, -0.17943090200424194, -0.4196242690086365, 0.45240914821624756, -0.315860778093338, 0.89573734998703, 0.17116233706474304, -0.24862182140350342, -0.2816745638847351, 0.47701001167297363, 0.47920939326286316, 0.210033118724823, 1.010928750038147, 0.3964273929595947, 0.5334335565567017, -0.16831561923027039, 0.7306180000305176, 0.27468883991241455, -0.12009815126657486, 1.0488756895065308, -0.06532859057188034, 0.6255030632019043, 0.22353529930114746, -0.09964378923177719, 0.584735631942749, 0.41735437512397766, -0.331076055765152, 0.23275156319141388, 0.6543794870376587, -0.6799770593643188, -0.11112696677446365, -0.5841805338859558, -0.2769472002983093, 0.4482347071170807, 0.7576280236244202, -0.3861847519874573, -0.2933140695095062, 0.16514001786708832, 0.4565383791923523, 0.28676673769950867, -0.6175885200500488, 0.5138474702835083, -0.2651899755001068, -0.4234580397605896, 0.2582235634326935, 0.12390217930078506, 1.0418219566345215, -0.6927470564842224, -0.10337534546852112, 0.17576535046100616, -0.03209536150097847, -0.38485822081565857, -0.63045734167099, 0.533346951007843, 0.4190097451210022, -0.10510922223329544, -0.1468455046415329, 1.0210793018341064, -0.5741658806800842, -0.13833177089691162, 0.656547486782074, 0.21753691136837006, 0.1859148144721985, -0.5740545988082886, -0.9414440989494324, 0.36287567019462585, -0.21788300573825836, -0.013277307152748108, 0.15027375519275665, -0.12979094684123993, -0.23521742224693298, 0.3329569697380066, 0.5492098927497864, 0.12629477679729462, 0.47407302260398865, 0.08059630542993546, 0.8096817135810852, -0.3237915337085724, -0.41474905610084534, -0.7737357020378113, 0.5813729763031006, -0.3433680534362793, -0.3388039171695709, 0.9476221203804016, 0.6142334342002869, 0.8996984958648682, 0.09595786780118942, 0.7338768839836121, -0.4167158603668213, 0.6362248659133911, -0.1826661080121994, 0.45174118876457214, -0.567240297794342, -0.041070204228162766, -0.7460580468177795, -1.0104585886001587, -0.37585917115211487, 0.464049756526947, -0.4811597466468811, 0.0852857232093811, 0.3989260494709015, 0.6920958161354065, -0.10377460718154907, -0.12262323498725891, 0.11441701650619507, 0.31091073155403137, 0.24657438695430756, 0.41072380542755127, 1.0915104150772095, -0.2587432563304901, 0.8387706279754639, -0.21582312881946564, -0.11201182007789612, -0.2163340449333191, -0.8922804594039917, -0.7990658283233643, -0.4764613211154938, -0.6199489831924438, -0.39212873578071594, 0.43009084463119507, 0.7880926728248596, 0.8203063607215881, -0.8707190155982971, 0.12257812917232513, -0.0321914441883564, 0.09799139201641083, -0.3475590944290161, -0.2485661804676056, 0.24530863761901855, 0.13581456243991852, -1.1214497089385986, 0.5596478581428528, 0.30310383439064026, 0.01687871851027012, -0.2566802501678467, 0.08078352361917496, -0.4967234134674072, -0.026918010786175728, 0.5371564030647278, 0.5852065086364746, -0.5925217866897583, -0.4986346364021301, -0.2226562201976776, -0.11244366317987442, -0.5203661322593689, 0.739292323589325, -0.4551107585430145, 0.03377789258956909, 0.07932517677545547, 0.5954657196998596, 0.6735982298851013, 0.01613040827214718, 0.19354692101478577, -1.290261149406433, 0.11233188956975937, 0.6154556274414062, 0.18397265672683716, 0.23674315214157104, -0.4848428964614868, 0.45213577151298523, 0.22746042907238007, 0.026672231033444405, -0.8695688843727112, 0.4118797183036804, -1.1211313009262085, -0.40734022855758667, 1.226633906364441, 0.051370423287153244, 0.0590934231877327, -0.3476899266242981, -0.37330925464630127, 0.46300461888313293, -0.3218078315258026, 0.7027700543403625, 0.3253606855869293, -0.04464636743068695, -0.01603180728852749, -0.31908664107322693, 0.8376871943473816, 0.29609644412994385, -0.858634889125824, -0.013916801661252975, 1.0374605655670166, 0.22658111155033112, 0.16698595881462097, 0.4998505711555481, -0.06829128414392471, 0.22123053669929504, 0.04717842862010002, -0.11392337828874588, 0.00041345474892295897, -0.5231102705001831, 0.008116059005260468, 0.4638621509075165, -0.4428466260433197, -0.13010023534297943 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19827v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19827v1
Language Models Learn Rare Phenomena from Less Rare Phenomena: The Case of the Missing AANNs
2024-03-28T20:35:10
2024-03-28T20:35:10
Kanishka Misra, Kyle Mahowald
cs.CL
cs.CL
Language models learn rare syntactic phenomena, but it has been argued that they rely on rote memorization, as opposed to grammatical generalization. Training on a corpus of human-scale in size (100M words), we iteratively trained transformer language models on systematically manipulated corpora and then evaluated their learning of a particular rare grammatical phenomenon: the English Article+Adjective+Numeral+Noun (AANN) construction (``a beautiful five days''). We first compared how well this construction was learned on the default corpus relative to a counterfactual corpus in which the AANN sentences were removed. AANNs were still learned better than systematically perturbed variants of the construction. Using additional counterfactual corpora, we suggest that this learning occurs through generalization from related constructions (e.g., ``a few days''). An additional experiment showed that this learning is enhanced when there is more variability in the input. Taken together, our results provide an existence proof that models learn rare grammatical phenomena by generalization from less rare phenomena. Code available at https://github.com/kanishkamisra/aannalysis
[ -0.1311829835176468, -0.8947917222976685, 0.38261228799819946, 0.08669798821210861, -0.16216716170310974, -0.19379453361034393, -0.15672293305397034, -0.392844557762146, 0.3972190320491791, 0.40844130516052246, -0.496860146522522, -0.2876523435115814, -0.4934523105621338, 0.2966921031475067, -0.722044050693512, 0.848135232925415, 0.29915574193000793, 0.09040097892284393, 0.053689755499362946, -0.2691013813018799, -0.06066460534930229, -0.539287805557251, -0.3812788724899292, -0.17588213086128235, 0.5799002051353455, 0.04996577650308609, 0.8453335165977478, 0.8068685531616211, 0.6013273596763611, 0.22879363596439362, -0.2751571238040924, 0.2078981101512909, -0.26763781905174255, -0.17627820372581482, -0.1445455104112625, -0.7444534301757812, -0.32276391983032227, -0.04335971176624298, 0.6187642812728882, 1.22581946849823, -0.24945364892482758, -0.08807216584682465, -0.08500660955905914, 0.9412166476249695, -0.6713542342185974, 0.11098134517669678, -0.723556399345398, 0.34247228503227234, -0.13526427745819092, 0.33160921931266785, -0.35015371441841125, -0.2637638747692108, 0.131020188331604, -0.6399826407432556, 0.572258710861206, -0.14282001554965973, 1.1330264806747437, 0.18168681859970093, -0.5389575362205505, -0.2825097143650055, -0.8897412419319153, 0.8077054023742676, -0.603986382484436, 0.4795434772968292, 0.45217663049697876, 0.04834560304880142, -0.020614037290215492, -0.6698681712150574, -0.6592500805854797, -0.6153242588043213, -0.026977330446243286, -0.01815509982407093, -0.5285292267799377, 0.024075357243418694, 0.2860586941242218, 0.4680977463722229, -0.8003377318382263, 0.1311100870370865, -0.5677762031555176, -0.11774468421936035, 0.507346510887146, 0.10074499249458313, 0.33750119805336, -0.3840928375720978, 0.10112971812486649, -0.09927747398614883, -0.8382149338722229, -0.18226151168346405, 0.4982842206954956, 0.24708838760852814, -0.3702700138092041, 0.4932921826839447, -0.07703114300966263, 0.5520038604736328, -0.05233011394739151, 0.3272306025028229, 0.48143935203552246, -0.23517678678035736, -0.15397687256336212, -0.33693796396255493, 0.6936575770378113, -0.16603459417819977, 0.3951191008090973, -0.25078079104423523, -0.13940367102622986, 0.38004162907600403, 0.30147629976272583, -0.4028518795967102, -0.6137167811393738, -0.2640079855918884, -0.636137068271637, -0.369722455739975, -0.1034267395734787, -0.19155041873455048, -0.10152272880077362, -0.2539529800415039, 0.2648741602897644, -0.41640084981918335, -0.31031540036201477, -0.043778643012046814, -0.06019199639558792, -0.11240649968385696, 0.16813017427921295, -0.9227030277252197, 0.27696889638900757, 0.535335123538971, 0.6668355464935303, -0.30206596851348877, -0.4533195495605469, -0.48585188388824463, -0.43621864914894104, -0.5738124251365662, 0.7098056077957153, -0.5364466309547424, -0.150010883808136, -0.01971537433564663, 0.07126715034246445, -0.2920929193496704, -0.7547605037689209, 0.2007412612438202, -0.6348481178283691, 0.11382316797971725, 0.08190034329891205, -0.5185657143592834, -0.33750081062316895, 0.09503194689750671, -0.8607689142227173, 0.5788301825523376, -0.023345928639173508, -0.3865288496017456, 0.23053093254566193, -0.5064530372619629, -0.46562114357948303, -0.1993573158979416, -0.10024948418140411, -0.48745808005332947, 0.7443110346794128, -0.24761360883712769, 0.2561056315898895, 0.10641159862279892, 0.1904156655073166, -0.1812441349029541, -0.1366201788187027, 0.2086358368396759, -0.6629791259765625, 0.7763486504554749, 0.2995530962944031, -0.29095515608787537, -0.09220902621746063, -1.2476139068603516, -0.27356913685798645, 0.20942571759223938, -0.528659462928772, -0.5364341735839844, -0.1202159970998764, 0.09507106244564056, 0.07744579762220383, -0.1220138669013977, -0.3931412100791931, 0.27109208703041077, -0.850651741027832, 0.18788379430770874, 0.31627655029296875, -0.014892864041030407, 0.6361817717552185, -0.3020987808704376, 0.23839594423770905, 0.5122455358505249, 0.08234437555074692, -0.10756369680166245, -0.34469422698020935, -1.1822009086608887, 0.05060557276010513, 0.3719330430030823, 0.3182574212551117, -0.6716366410255432, -0.028652725741267204, -0.291811466217041, -0.15026958286762238, -0.4173680543899536, 0.47655293345451355, 0.5602987408638, 0.1277613639831543, 0.3608720600605011, -0.5162373781204224, -0.6712509393692017, -0.9886870980262756, -0.3459436893463135, -0.3435571491718292, 0.08961042016744614, 0.0003373721847310662, 0.5619425773620605, -0.2647664546966553, 0.6243298649787903, -0.20151260495185852, -0.2384163737297058, -0.18403784930706024, 0.5225359201431274, 0.03457259014248848, 0.30445533990859985, 0.6457796096801758, -0.8397804498672485, -0.3221600353717804, -0.1116708517074585, -0.8336631059646606, 0.20771703124046326, -0.08548984676599503, 0.5289103984832764, 0.6619560122489929, 0.6813989281654358, -0.6140450239181519, 0.5450581908226013, 0.5242133140563965, -0.1142471432685852, 0.6563321948051453, -0.17988674342632294, -0.46975094079971313, -0.8206586837768555, -0.22868768870830536, -0.17545606195926666, -0.3086927831172943, -0.6056448817253113, 0.08000059425830841, 0.05851244926452637, 0.15903028845787048, -0.5908402800559998, 0.4603082537651062, -0.5752777457237244, 0.12576334178447723, -0.5455000400543213, -0.38787323236465454, -0.2276206761598587, 0.5239026546478271, 0.16153974831104279, 0.2759471535682678, 0.4702354371547699, -0.7295408844947815, 0.026735423132777214, 0.11515628546476364, -0.13194206357002258, 0.12515728175640106, -0.3186264932155609, 0.2270553559064865, -0.3865529000759125, -0.15885098278522491, -0.5542524456977844, -0.2844897508621216, 0.04673676937818527, -0.3439922630786896, 0.0194871686398983, -0.11801611632108688, -0.24002571403980255, -0.09372420608997345, 0.11921627819538116, 0.17748937010765076, 0.49940812587738037, -0.45780348777770996, 0.7091821432113647, 0.0820372998714447, -0.10235590487718582, -0.40213683247566223, -0.7939777374267578, 0.2583273649215698, -0.06434362381696701, -0.0704389438033104, -0.0045940810814499855, -0.010620485991239548, -0.5543321967124939, 0.4547455608844757, -0.14866364002227783, -0.2909684181213379, 0.4611211121082306, 0.2842235565185547, 0.12530946731567383, -0.4914557635784149, 0.28672361373901367, -0.24769681692123413, 0.08961846679449081, 0.2266509085893631, -0.11768138408660889, 0.5147688984870911, -0.3301399350166321, -0.4227825105190277, -0.28669193387031555, 0.42880120873451233, 0.39738988876342773, 0.03211623430252075, 0.8011070489883423, 0.5369107127189636, -0.5690338015556335, -0.2964900732040405, -0.5144292712211609, -0.22233127057552338, -0.36616823077201843, 0.6212922930717468, -0.3732505738735199, -0.6202101111412048, 0.5077791213989258, 0.26994580030441284, 0.07893028110265732, 0.7911719083786011, 0.26576030254364014, -0.07525894790887833, 0.9256510138511658, 0.9286029934883118, -0.07329313457012177, 0.5930187702178955, -0.3857561945915222, 0.05162777006626129, -0.44148164987564087, -0.059859130531549454, -0.2130497395992279, -0.09240403026342392, -0.8220837116241455, -0.12182411551475525, 0.3771420419216156, -0.04100069776177406, -0.20389585196971893, 0.17305153608322144, 0.07120351493358612, 0.5197146534919739, 0.5589630603790283, 0.04851004481315613, 0.4305303394794464, 0.1234310045838356, -0.4011653959751129, -0.06034616380929947, -0.7340486645698547, -0.49222370982170105, 1.010199785232544, 0.22914083302021027, 0.6370081901550293, 0.1809760183095932, 0.8951555490493774, 0.18155573308467865, 0.28832003474235535, -0.8045117259025574, 0.40295520424842834, -0.5337820053100586, -0.42484307289123535, -0.13729625940322876, -0.6066275835037231, -1.0542314052581787, 0.23276720941066742, -0.3414798974990845, -0.46288421750068665, 0.42806023359298706, 0.2584454119205475, -0.39794400334358215, 0.08062117546796799, -0.5277442932128906, 0.5737969875335693, -0.16606786847114563, -0.20462442934513092, -0.47684863209724426, -0.7894551753997803, 0.3330671787261963, 0.081172876060009, 0.4235544502735138, 0.11402711272239685, 0.2406407594680786, 0.5322301387786865, -0.5099607706069946, 1.1049480438232422, 0.1615375429391861, 0.0002877734659705311, 0.03715471923351288, 0.23240309953689575, 0.41660887002944946, -0.06345558166503906, 0.294148325920105, -0.0003039423027075827, -0.466389924287796, -0.40463513135910034, -0.6184898018836975, 0.5590921640396118, -0.7753777503967285, -0.4034689664840698, -0.5307158827781677, -0.5238171815872192, -0.092866912484169, 0.09234418720006943, 0.3943207859992981, 0.35120585560798645, -0.49445977807044983, 0.15509244799613953, 0.6628754138946533, 0.013846119865775108, 0.8364555835723877, 0.6843493580818176, -0.1724821925163269, -0.14311166107654572, 0.8672600388526917, 0.16231019794940948, 0.368443101644516, 0.35780951380729675, 0.27526426315307617, 0.22938695549964905, -0.5357998609542847, -0.27300792932510376, 0.3241199553012848, -0.6784150004386902, 0.043700121343135834, -0.9458518624305725, -0.5027725100517273, -0.20970189571380615, 0.1791151911020279, -0.6974722146987915, -0.8250707983970642, -0.49763575196266174, -0.18776835501194, 0.28722500801086426, 0.9006608128547668, -0.401288241147995, 0.12664322555065155, -0.8311471343040466, 0.5350120067596436, 0.44082632660865784, 0.017307210713624954, 0.1899891346693039, -0.5961832404136658, -0.2861587405204773, 0.20446448028087616, -0.3886069357395172, -0.6186705827713013, 0.558724045753479, 0.7265833616256714, 0.38693326711654663, 0.4807640016078949, -0.32803666591644287, 0.4826642870903015, -0.5991740226745605, 0.7255867719650269, 0.21611957252025604, -0.6760209798812866, 0.4348696172237396, -0.29654961824417114, 0.5349478721618652, 0.3697861433029175, 0.31787389516830444, -0.6128150820732117, -0.6255364418029785, -0.9605627059936523, -1.1033669710159302, 0.31069469451904297, 0.16587185859680176, 0.5192362666130066, -0.2734377682209015, 0.3791753649711609, 0.23997703194618225, 0.13367803394794464, -1.0732027292251587, -0.6002913117408752, -0.23811301589012146, -0.07982388138771057, -0.15717725455760956, -0.2124953716993332, 0.1436624974012375, -0.07461637258529663, 0.6333582997322083, -0.05500565469264984, 0.0583169087767601, 0.1482064574956894, -0.7686294317245483, 0.01007028017193079, 0.37728285789489746, 0.7689905762672424, 0.5216533541679382, 0.07017210125923157, 0.4617535471916199, 0.19295014441013336, -0.7045068144798279, -0.06614778935909271, -0.04488131403923035, -0.2361379712820053, 0.3818534016609192, 0.6498493552207947, 1.0674742460250854, 0.3698922395706177, -0.3516675531864166, 0.43846043944358826, -0.1161513552069664, -0.16565069556236267, -0.5024213790893555, 0.19072924554347992, 0.16384610533714294, 0.0464773066341877, 0.5648036003112793, 0.4614799916744232, 0.3164708614349365, -0.8938857316970825, 0.18640075623989105, 0.27908942103385925, -0.3829796612262726, -0.8196986317634583, 0.5662596225738525, -0.18696707487106323, -0.2677830159664154, 0.6433098912239075, -0.6522716283798218, -0.48763394355773926, 0.6767873764038086, 0.5517037510871887, 0.9629437327384949, -0.27637287974357605, 0.2775239646434784, 0.27929919958114624, 0.31540441513061523, -0.4163035452365875, 0.27546870708465576, 0.23538576066493988, -0.7454933524131775, -0.23341497778892517, -0.6919782757759094, -0.22432102262973785, 0.2684996426105499, -0.6021572351455688, 0.20651237666606903, -0.4241892993450165, 0.11507418006658554, 0.2152809500694275, -0.3504943549633026, -1.0018174648284912, 0.18338555097579956, 0.2551988959312439, 0.45001503825187683, -1.3566945791244507, 0.5421947240829468, 0.9562813639640808, -0.533821165561676, -0.8278049826622009, -0.07364453375339508, 0.1873159557580948, -0.6847423911094666, 0.8912765383720398, -0.14383158087730408, 0.09635668992996216, -0.08088383823633194, -0.48906928300857544, -0.8425952196121216, 0.22396209836006165, 0.37577393651008606, -0.7918129563331604, -0.16844643652439117, 0.23410695791244507, 0.9753051996231079, -0.27151891589164734, 0.2194637954235077, 0.3887723386287689, 0.09084979444742203, -0.025695925578475, -1.218817949295044, -0.2114216536283493, -0.4255646765232086, -0.06206824257969856, 0.0030192367266863585, -0.5300873517990112, 0.8964931964874268, -0.44504597783088684, -0.10858991742134094, 0.08332687616348267, 0.7328341603279114, -0.12777136266231537, 0.27539196610450745, 0.40158936381340027, 0.7083286643028259, 0.7846226692199707, 0.19248126447200775, 1.0059179067611694, 0.2235744148492813, 0.26316145062446594, 1.0868942737579346, 0.06543731689453125, 0.9139618277549744, 0.4152306914329529, 0.0007602514233440161, 0.6459004878997803, 0.3219815194606781, 0.15099401772022247, 0.710731029510498, 0.1862252801656723, -0.17488232254981995, -0.37645334005355835, -0.06888413429260254, -0.3225053548812866, 0.7951838374137878, 0.2920730412006378, -0.42563116550445557, -0.22976863384246826, 0.5092192888259888, 0.06924554705619812, 0.1285267323255539, -0.37641504406929016, 0.9688477516174316, 0.5119876861572266, -0.4076736867427826, 0.8400161266326904, -0.2399759292602539, 0.5329309701919556, -0.20251283049583435, -0.040298942476511, -0.44375866651535034, 0.2276940494775772, -0.17410248517990112, -0.021853623911738396, 0.6471378207206726, -0.07757662981748581, -0.5471874475479126, -0.025437304750084877, 0.4053709805011749, -0.3766229450702667, -0.8477883338928223, 0.07062861323356628, 0.7510687708854675, 0.2228086292743683, 0.23792007565498352, -0.3667241036891937, -0.18295392394065857, -0.2380155324935913, -0.24162523448467255, 0.37544944882392883, 0.3817500174045563, -0.47683829069137573, 0.7304357290267944, 0.4626443684101105, 0.3828158974647522, 0.2358376830816269, 0.3992898762226105, 0.7401960492134094, -0.6856803894042969, -0.5583060383796692, -0.9268907904624939, 0.27384114265441895, 0.21665550768375397, -0.37386801838874817, 0.6919859647750854, 0.7067603468894958, 0.7876661419868469, -0.4208228588104248, 0.6941047310829163, 0.18592704832553864, 0.5333832502365112, -0.6261283159255981, 0.806692361831665, -0.5630342364311218, 0.43315157294273376, -0.0819506123661995, -0.8194291591644287, -0.5164419412612915, 0.7545323967933655, -0.20258663594722748, -0.1994706243276596, 1.011265754699707, 0.6221853494644165, -0.3639577627182007, -0.06475988775491714, 0.2986173927783966, 0.44099223613739014, -0.030970627442002296, 0.4093288779258728, 1.0267940759658813, -0.4974134862422943, 0.33350715041160583, -0.17374050617218018, 0.25790512561798096, -0.2088719606399536, -0.7982299327850342, -0.816535234451294, -0.6835666298866272, -0.6369626522064209, -0.06847365200519562, 0.45586782693862915, 1.1770641803741455, 0.42049849033355713, -0.9831789135932922, -0.0863463431596756, -0.46680310368537903, 0.19976982474327087, -0.27544429898262024, -0.19886863231658936, 0.35791265964508057, -0.3704637587070465, -0.5714178085327148, 0.4464099407196045, -0.005426737014204264, 0.18528339266777039, -0.012385024689137936, 0.2537517249584198, -0.11758936196565628, -0.11099191755056381, 0.36460110545158386, 0.4547519385814667, -0.677990734577179, -0.35320770740509033, 0.2467208057641983, -0.14772289991378784, 0.26109084486961365, 0.5136610865592957, -0.7294593453407288, 0.1773504614830017, 0.40972602367401123, 0.3392341136932373, 0.4672698974609375, -0.30754658579826355, 0.5176962018013, -0.8238343000411987, 0.15390704572200775, 0.3078312277793884, 0.3886431157588959, 0.35983505845069885, -0.19538721442222595, 0.2714901864528656, 0.46007800102233887, -0.13185371458530426, -0.9083494544029236, 0.34606966376304626, -0.5498028993606567, -0.14888113737106323, 1.2043282985687256, -0.09037162363529205, -0.2607317864894867, -0.23590333759784698, 0.41587334871292114, 0.18976818025112152, -0.07352098822593689, 1.1491373777389526, 0.6643862128257751, -0.16668756306171417, -0.20933929085731506, -0.6142257452011108, 0.534423828125, 0.7538225054740906, -0.581910252571106, -0.3226349949836731, 0.582549512386322, 0.6027118563652039, 0.3643287718296051, 0.2356909215450287, 0.0705479308962822, 0.6693734526634216, -0.10307824611663818, -0.030840201303362846, -0.021517861634492874, -0.5715550780296326, -0.647174060344696, 0.18242794275283813, 0.1434241682291031, -0.12861500680446625 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19822v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19822v1
Multi-Stage Multi-Modal Pre-Training for Automatic Speech Recognition
2024-03-28T20:23:39
2024-03-28T20:23:39
Yash Jain, David Chan, Pranav Dheram, Aparna Khare, Olabanji Shonibare, Venkatesh Ravichandran, Shalini Ghosh
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI
Recent advances in machine learning have demonstrated that multi-modal pre-training can improve automatic speech recognition (ASR) performance compared to randomly initialized models, even when models are fine-tuned on uni-modal tasks. Existing multi-modal pre-training methods for the ASR task have primarily focused on single-stage pre-training where a single unsupervised task is used for pre-training followed by fine-tuning on the downstream task. In this work, we introduce a novel method combining multi-modal and multi-task unsupervised pre-training with a translation-based supervised mid-training approach. We empirically demonstrate that such a multi-stage approach leads to relative word error rate (WER) improvements of up to 38.45% over baselines on both Librispeech and SUPERB. Additionally, we share several important findings for choosing pre-training methods and datasets.
[ -0.44225531816482544, -0.4577699899673462, 0.2633306384086609, 0.1597941666841507, -0.5449303984642029, 0.11921711266040802, -0.24310438334941864, -0.29557284712791443, -0.06907065957784653, 0.11394765228033066, -0.6519522070884705, -0.248337984085083, -0.797042727470398, 0.20359164476394653, -0.4391973316669464, 0.7453048229217529, 0.05114460736513138, 0.6529213190078735, -0.03369045630097389, -0.0401197224855423, -0.3957941234111786, -0.7236437201499939, -0.6221814155578613, -0.33101916313171387, 0.5192287564277649, 0.38751348853111267, 0.2413162887096405, 0.24573242664337158, 0.4063672423362732, 0.3744873106479645, 0.23295435309410095, 0.17661243677139282, 0.03968045487999916, 0.013839841820299625, 0.19927769899368286, -0.14877638220787048, -0.47792190313339233, 0.14251217246055603, 0.7486772537231445, 0.6641497611999512, -0.19067905843257904, 0.188132643699646, 0.2875438928604126, 0.4609580636024475, -0.6985266804695129, 0.1547563523054123, -0.5961199998855591, -0.0018466199981048703, -0.48371684551239014, -0.4966598451137543, -0.2662109434604645, 0.12631168961524963, 0.18091890215873718, -0.7577760219573975, 0.220853790640831, -0.16130124032497406, 0.3712978959083557, 0.5009140968322754, -0.5288033485412598, -0.231547012925148, -0.9326304793357849, 0.635503888130188, -0.6677309274673462, 0.910632848739624, 0.41468489170074463, 0.17912065982818604, 0.056300438940525055, -0.7185903191566467, -0.7435314655303955, -0.16472385823726654, -0.04557808116078377, 0.12360674887895584, -0.05893173813819885, 0.24295544624328613, 0.20616160333156586, 0.13823412358760834, -0.580796480178833, 0.1177908405661583, -0.2547450065612793, -0.531059980392456, 0.382278174161911, -0.2839391231536865, 0.056580908596515656, 0.14833083748817444, -0.35050082206726074, -0.29317522048950195, -0.3574545681476593, 0.2410924881696701, 0.12036944925785065, 0.7289373278617859, 0.021410178393125534, 0.3244430124759674, -0.23965132236480713, 0.7172446846961975, 0.24311861395835876, -0.2939727306365967, 0.6414324641227722, -0.6597331166267395, -0.1012243703007698, 0.28676068782806396, 0.8163107633590698, -0.0754331648349762, 0.33625999093055725, -0.047245606780052185, -0.36300140619277954, 0.21036522090435028, 0.2530597448348999, -0.789885938167572, -0.13341261446475983, -0.0749134048819542, -0.3438141942024231, 0.013820698484778404, 0.2446969896554947, -0.238799050450325, -0.058631643652915955, -0.536638617515564, 0.9604834914207458, -0.23864686489105225, -0.05967680737376213, 0.07163770496845245, 0.13953986763954163, 0.023308316245675087, 0.3401927649974823, -0.48553088307380676, 0.24164843559265137, 0.159309521317482, 0.5735544562339783, 0.11356113851070404, -0.6287583708763123, -1.1183042526245117, 0.2063387930393219, -0.2598266899585724, 0.8187623620033264, -0.5081326365470886, -0.431787371635437, -0.14518247544765472, -0.13120630383491516, -0.42763832211494446, -0.4161166548728943, 0.7094383835792542, -0.3550710678100586, 0.24632646143436432, -0.07025372982025146, -0.3304539620876312, -0.13675454258918762, -0.04506181553006172, -0.540601372718811, 0.8980610966682434, -0.3657820224761963, -0.6553884744644165, 0.6748581528663635, -0.781426727771759, -0.9002732634544373, -0.2231450229883194, -0.14910385012626648, -0.5024840831756592, 0.19765391945838928, 0.5639445781707764, 0.5523096919059753, -0.1486024260520935, 0.15147733688354492, -0.00038434984162449837, -0.23756079375743866, 0.2897593379020691, -0.7251806259155273, 0.29377079010009766, 0.1395084708929062, -0.4147079586982727, 0.3145078718662262, -1.002623438835144, 0.05941173806786537, -0.16488857567310333, -0.5340169072151184, -0.2731574773788452, 0.03010610118508339, 0.27601251006126404, 0.499872088432312, 0.2437308430671692, -0.549585223197937, -0.1814599186182022, -0.2512301802635193, 0.2629885971546173, 0.4612806737422943, -0.18295031785964966, 0.4612779915332794, -0.21401631832122803, 0.28601619601249695, 0.4189537763595581, 0.2558921277523041, -0.25315412878990173, -0.21471431851387024, -0.853013277053833, -0.3510190546512604, 0.435333788394928, 0.6828279495239258, -0.9083541035652161, 0.6415221691131592, -0.05641091987490654, -0.3157275319099426, -0.5053291916847229, 0.11492279917001724, 0.8304234743118286, 0.5231043100357056, 0.693589448928833, -0.6348923444747925, -0.597848653793335, -0.5342985391616821, -0.30356767773628235, -0.022912142798304558, -0.02541765570640564, 0.04402286931872368, 0.1777469962835312, -0.3417571783065796, 0.7325584292411804, -0.23880010843276978, -0.7232673764228821, -0.163198322057724, 0.5355888605117798, -0.008977611549198627, 0.6184023022651672, 0.1586434543132782, -0.801020622253418, -0.49871644377708435, -0.18827363848686218, -0.09027563780546188, -0.1395086944103241, -0.0876399576663971, 0.2801682949066162, 0.16707843542099, 0.6046050190925598, -0.352659672498703, 0.3470623791217804, 0.5714427828788757, -0.10478078573942184, 0.3901205062866211, -0.5240486264228821, 0.3773992657661438, -1.1463806629180908, -0.011089221574366093, -0.07849282771348953, -0.34838372468948364, -1.0154874324798584, -0.5342637300491333, 0.10507375001907349, -0.10439647734165192, -0.39167091250419617, 0.13226056098937988, -0.6062948107719421, -0.2407580465078354, -0.36792612075805664, -0.09004887193441391, -0.11239919066429138, 0.2657219171524048, -0.051522593945264816, 1.0601011514663696, 0.810137152671814, -0.6004654169082642, 0.047027572989463806, 0.23995961248874664, -0.19969326257705688, 0.45858874917030334, -0.510361909866333, 0.3842903971672058, -0.06143781170248985, 0.4518064856529236, -0.9488575458526611, -0.034358300268650055, -0.08128777146339417, -0.45875561237335205, 0.5506526231765747, 0.05353647843003273, -0.5571615099906921, -0.34352344274520874, 0.0610048733651638, 0.502976655960083, 0.09954303503036499, -0.3490823209285736, 0.7798865437507629, 0.3586539626121521, -0.2028460055589676, -0.5315253138542175, -0.4958457946777344, -0.1528807282447815, -0.1330299973487854, -0.18058368563652039, 0.37674281001091003, -0.2727888822555542, 0.38311249017715454, -0.3672706186771393, -0.45697498321533203, -0.2923049330711365, -0.07479377835988998, 0.30737870931625366, -0.024749618023633957, -0.08046377450227737, -0.009058274328708649, -0.060044534504413605, -0.4330371618270874, -0.22604002058506012, -0.5118764042854309, 0.620647668838501, -0.1048777624964714, -0.5422821640968323, -0.8521011471748352, 0.27418360114097595, 0.5713709592819214, -0.7064348459243774, 0.38410818576812744, 0.8575392365455627, -0.4359952509403229, 0.05591338127851486, -0.7756592035293579, -0.24623578786849976, -0.4430931806564331, 0.3749517500400543, -0.4115321636199951, -0.7107340693473816, 0.08642394095659256, -0.1506500095129013, -0.1574275940656662, 0.150191992521286, 0.38481655716896057, -0.1505425125360489, 1.1253737211227417, 0.688291072845459, -0.2661270797252655, 0.7502699494361877, -0.12261940538883209, 0.13594630360603333, -0.6189722418785095, -0.2818399667739868, -0.6170571446418762, -0.16276320815086365, -0.22227004170417786, -0.72598797082901, 0.612431526184082, 0.28810131549835205, -0.1921265870332718, 0.18404346704483032, -0.28757819533348083, 0.2859719395637512, 0.7459183931350708, 0.18491531908512115, 0.43122315406799316, -0.10253395140171051, -0.07432961463928223, 0.11897683888673782, -0.7061175107955933, -0.2084718644618988, 1.1454191207885742, -0.07873684167861938, 0.635097086429596, -0.31166741251945496, 0.6395556330680847, 0.21224911510944366, -0.055217355489730835, -0.6730707287788391, 0.42306986451148987, -0.535581111907959, -0.3504680395126343, -0.5572900772094727, -0.3523598313331604, -0.8345280885696411, 0.29038169980049133, -0.5094313621520996, -0.23390518128871918, 0.1989724040031433, 0.539177417755127, -0.6166205406188965, -0.0954665020108223, -0.6313163638114929, 0.7596117854118347, -0.5112971067428589, 0.31347188353538513, -0.2951831519603729, -0.8972907662391663, -0.2726389169692993, -0.4673673212528229, 0.4721643626689911, 0.08488442748785019, 0.1401001662015915, 0.7931758165359497, -0.18479958176612854, 0.6891483664512634, -0.6217572093009949, 0.1436731368303299, -0.012623501941561699, -0.3468989431858063, 0.5256132483482361, -0.09074994176626205, 0.2360924929380417, 0.17113114893436432, 0.06421662122011185, -0.08995864540338516, -0.46531009674072266, 0.14918066561222076, -0.878842830657959, -0.2830018103122711, -0.5479322671890259, -0.690443217754364, -0.6576038002967834, 0.3305094838142395, 0.3480742573738098, 0.8877670168876648, -0.19466009736061096, 0.2684212923049927, 0.5679101943969727, 0.07402840256690979, 0.4798065423965454, 0.6455568671226501, 0.08101750910282135, -0.4927654564380646, 0.733107328414917, 0.3046635091304779, 0.20384976267814636, 0.5425558686256409, 0.1776396483182907, -0.42452311515808105, -0.8301737904548645, -0.39800235629081726, -0.11945761740207672, -0.363212913274765, -0.20471912622451782, -0.7373278737068176, -0.2982404828071594, -0.5197431445121765, 0.005298350006341934, -0.715300440788269, -0.24244733154773712, -0.36540257930755615, 0.17699389159679413, 0.015164432115852833, 0.43043053150177, -0.29568061232566833, 0.6508392095565796, -0.8309778571128845, 0.6293500065803528, 0.5065243244171143, 0.07648299634456635, -0.4050990045070648, -0.7252390384674072, -0.3470264971256256, 0.16225801408290863, -0.03486655652523041, -0.6317724585533142, 0.2638711929321289, 0.672562837600708, 0.5931090712547302, 0.4544490575790405, -0.0563589408993721, 0.9796925187110901, -1.0104900598526, 0.3518243432044983, 0.525520920753479, -1.041208267211914, 0.7185028195381165, -0.06895973533391953, 0.4485101103782654, 0.7266002893447876, 0.35763686895370483, -0.19250231981277466, -0.15450330078601837, -0.2064109444618225, -0.7315187454223633, 0.6750035881996155, 0.07168827205896378, -0.06193901225924492, 0.48478400707244873, 0.023891447111964226, 0.03732888773083687, 0.42299702763557434, -0.402939110994339, -0.2906516194343567, -0.47532251477241516, -0.040878646075725555, -0.7131816148757935, -0.04098093882203102, -0.2152792066335678, -0.5320298075675964, 0.5863350629806519, -0.23410658538341522, 0.045477066189050674, 0.121855728328228, -0.5250243544578552, -0.016201764345169067, 0.4972146153450012, 0.733399510383606, 0.5236011743545532, -0.09465912729501724, 0.16482384502887726, 0.3004111647605896, -0.678799569606781, 0.36276349425315857, 0.8396275043487549, 0.010426346212625504, -0.06557649374008179, 0.16545626521110535, 1.0864098072052002, 0.42092353105545044, -0.31425443291664124, 0.7219854593276978, -0.1155661791563034, -0.16746927797794342, -0.36395514011383057, -0.2120911180973053, -0.23396611213684082, 0.5713878273963928, 0.7125529646873474, 0.43960776925086975, 0.3046659827232361, -0.4838064908981323, 0.38254326581954956, 0.3621537387371063, -0.4597075283527374, -0.38991791009902954, 0.7068225145339966, 0.2513013184070587, -0.2668895125389099, 0.2949480414390564, -0.02483132854104042, -0.6346859931945801, 0.034196995198726654, 0.6364889740943909, 0.9078624248504639, -0.6646057963371277, 0.14260990917682648, 0.09904906153678894, 0.24935542047023773, -0.1706172227859497, 0.397430956363678, -0.23602968454360962, -0.8105430006980896, -0.5873178243637085, -0.856852114200592, -0.21909865736961365, 0.09333976358175278, -0.7888489961624146, 0.11663392931222916, -0.06366659700870514, -0.18810926377773285, -0.01988900639116764, -0.06377200782299042, -0.768721342086792, 0.6207944750785828, 0.32118257880210876, 0.4879547357559204, -0.8605278134346008, 1.240930438041687, 0.8427332639694214, -0.32095733284950256, -0.8695996999740601, 0.3916219174861908, 0.09104359894990921, -0.4676642417907715, 0.5482663512229919, 0.24857884645462036, -0.4462830424308777, 0.2927038371562958, 0.011500152759253979, -1.114288330078125, 1.0889887809753418, 0.24563537538051605, -0.7233887910842896, -0.0884588360786438, 0.21522732079029083, 0.3815174996852875, -0.38204294443130493, -0.015707628801465034, 0.4083850383758545, 0.32938113808631897, 0.05022621899843216, -1.4310574531555176, -0.3729942739009857, -0.1355236917734146, 0.12457618862390518, 0.06335071474313736, -0.282833069562912, 0.6889743804931641, -0.2050248682498932, -0.12591210007667542, -0.25123265385627747, 0.76985102891922, 0.25523829460144043, 0.40832218527793884, 1.1935280561447144, 0.40354350209236145, 0.700109601020813, 0.0025295752566307783, 0.5720764398574829, -0.4548414647579193, 0.10266968607902527, 1.284088134765625, -0.19552917778491974, 0.9921228885650635, 0.405617892742157, -0.0793546661734581, 0.18508486449718475, 0.3624335527420044, 0.355472594499588, 0.853492021560669, -0.08474578708410263, -0.30223318934440613, -0.4045598804950714, -0.010913044214248657, -0.44469818472862244, 0.8429293632507324, 0.26614630222320557, 0.054234396666288376, -0.11409346014261246, 0.6677588820457458, -0.18295158445835114, -0.04866602644324303, -0.3388054370880127, 0.8711565136909485, 0.03128713369369507, -0.27101555466651917, 0.41229692101478577, -0.26030269265174866, 0.8584610223770142, -0.8028759360313416, 0.2599385678768158, 0.12308381497859955, 0.21577998995780945, -0.06199979409575462, -0.2375829815864563, 0.07100240886211395, 0.01641862653195858, -0.34455743432044983, -0.4961665868759155, 0.713936448097229, -0.5886532664299011, -0.5226879715919495, 0.35643136501312256, 0.6986939311027527, -0.03786660358309746, -0.3908342123031616, -0.675060510635376, -0.00025926801026798785, -0.3642650842666626, -0.3090999126434326, 0.2706325054168701, 0.41588398814201355, 0.004571697674691677, 0.3312751054763794, 0.9062204957008362, 0.10563847422599792, 0.37251049280166626, 0.5332151055335999, 1.028387188911438, -0.3141127824783325, -0.5523355603218079, -0.4342440962791443, 0.659318208694458, 0.09464097768068314, -0.17653727531433105, 0.5859354138374329, 0.6346824765205383, 1.1267738342285156, 0.04919499531388283, 0.7752055525779724, -0.025042157620191574, 0.8041926622390747, -0.5512850284576416, 0.6102666258811951, -0.7045031785964966, -0.07754717022180557, -0.42649710178375244, -0.8409781455993652, -0.4087539315223694, 0.8020358681678772, -0.04409685730934143, 0.21098819375038147, 0.7188515663146973, 0.7238191962242126, -0.07601197063922882, -0.13979342579841614, 0.5013421177864075, 0.19219188392162323, 0.15189193189144135, 0.1807350218296051, 0.7585445046424866, -0.39393338561058044, 0.61191725730896, -0.45659640431404114, -0.3267170488834381, -0.044568270444869995, -0.6501175165176392, -0.7616256475448608, -0.9807819724082947, -0.10740736126899719, 0.004942959640175104, 0.16305841505527496, 1.0293703079223633, 0.9417085647583008, -1.0237151384353638, -0.20771560072898865, 0.08392442017793655, -0.6904459595680237, -0.2715269923210144, 0.018271926790475845, 0.2292705476284027, -0.5733258128166199, -0.6821584701538086, 0.9380065202713013, 0.2636013925075531, 0.01824595220386982, -0.008449270389974117, -0.13278178870677948, -0.31335172057151794, -0.07484453171491623, 0.7173541784286499, 0.12020466476678848, -0.5405492782592773, -0.2262364774942398, -0.18032488226890564, 0.053252264857292175, 0.018561186268925667, 0.969651460647583, -0.8127802014350891, 0.5995503664016724, 0.35667651891708374, 0.5493234992027283, 0.7078526020050049, 0.13860362768173218, 0.5389919281005859, -0.8496124744415283, 0.37863340973854065, 0.1427830159664154, 0.34983009099960327, 0.2802324593067169, 0.04634255915880203, 0.1708253026008606, 0.21584852039813995, -0.6797389388084412, -0.7796396017074585, 0.19368129968643188, -0.9996042251586914, 0.00889541581273079, 0.7929616570472717, -0.017802627757191658, 0.5174977779388428, -0.21635426580905914, -0.2105843722820282, 0.6737737059593201, -0.36214324831962585, 0.529668927192688, 0.3319568336009979, -0.22534319758415222, -0.11441570520401001, -0.5380281805992126, 0.5634818077087402, 0.36740922927856445, -0.8867164254188538, -0.2332085371017456, 0.6576501727104187, 0.15607228875160217, 0.2239946573972702, 0.8439692854881287, 0.0959588885307312, 0.21555708348751068, -0.17735445499420166, 0.07378041744232178, -0.19478529691696167, -0.8146296739578247, -0.4056209623813629, -0.05357314646244049, 0.05639076605439186, -0.524050235748291 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19802v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19802v1
Developing Healthcare Language Model Embedding Spaces
2024-03-28T19:31:32
2024-03-28T19:31:32
Niall Taylor, Dan Schofield, Andrey Kormilitzin, Dan W Joyce, Alejo Nevado-Holgado
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI
Pre-trained Large Language Models (LLMs) often struggle on out-of-domain datasets like healthcare focused text. We explore specialized pre-training to adapt smaller LLMs to different healthcare datasets. Three methods are assessed: traditional masked language modeling, Deep Contrastive Learning for Unsupervised Textual Representations (DeCLUTR), and a novel pre-training objective utilizing metadata categories from the healthcare settings. These schemes are evaluated on downstream document classification tasks for each dataset, with additional analysis of the resultant embedding spaces. Contrastively trained models outperform other approaches on the classification tasks, delivering strong performance from limited labeled data and with fewer model parameter updates required. While metadata-based pre-training does not further improve classifications across the datasets, it yields interesting embedding cluster separability. All domain adapted LLMs outperform their publicly available general base LLM, validating the importance of domain-specialization. This research illustrates efficient approaches to instill healthcare competency in compact LLMs even under tight computational budgets, an essential capability for responsible and sustainable deployment in local healthcare settings. We provide pre-training guidelines for specialized healthcare LLMs, motivate continued inquiry into contrastive objectives, and demonstrates adaptation techniques to align small LLMs with privacy-sensitive medical tasks.
[ -0.034607406705617905, -0.3200267255306244, 0.7275352478027344, -0.13132967054843903, -0.26141852140426636, 0.21094343066215515, -0.2563924193382263, -0.2749482989311218, 0.09561347216367722, 0.7449860572814941, -0.31662553548812866, -0.8236780166625977, -0.7896719574928284, 0.027034519240260124, 0.05052627623081207, 0.8364609479904175, -0.2775117754936218, 0.1501830518245697, -0.5132040977478027, -0.3276992440223694, -0.08242614567279816, -0.8475331664085388, -0.26737621426582336, -0.29565510153770447, 0.37062036991119385, 0.37457847595214844, 0.5222605466842651, 0.6408687233924866, 0.7367622256278992, 0.260822594165802, 0.26062625646591187, 0.2563047707080841, -0.364258348941803, -0.16601446270942688, 0.006471036933362484, -0.339285284280777, -0.32714205980300903, -0.08530375361442566, 0.684596061706543, 0.9297016859054565, -0.31409189105033875, -0.11377162486314774, 0.1640060395002365, 0.41272494196891785, -0.5697644948959351, 0.2203817516565323, -0.45392170548439026, 0.16400641202926636, -0.18354947865009308, -0.1621856540441513, -0.21677309274673462, -0.282241553068161, 0.2941247522830963, -0.5390282869338989, 0.1264212280511856, 0.09985920786857605, 0.7026665806770325, 0.5784533023834229, -0.49879300594329834, -0.4547150433063507, -0.5190289616584778, 0.6154698729515076, -0.7701862454414368, 0.6654781103134155, 0.5416693687438965, 0.16441135108470917, 0.04664748162031174, -1.108066201210022, -0.10131325572729111, -0.17499962449073792, -0.33337342739105225, 0.1088462695479393, -0.1950538158416748, 0.20685109496116638, -0.09211963415145874, 0.3964668810367584, -0.5079313516616821, 0.602922260761261, -0.2211400419473648, -0.04904001206159592, 0.345126211643219, 0.22024179995059967, 0.1179206371307373, 0.1105133593082428, -0.07097990810871124, 0.061879515647888184, -0.7550628185272217, -0.29971057176589966, -0.16735677421092987, 0.16920477151870728, -0.463695228099823, 0.29303085803985596, 0.17594903707504272, 0.3368220031261444, 0.11485061794519424, -0.3522166609764099, 0.42818763852119446, -0.1904001086950302, -0.6055882573127747, -0.08313382416963577, 0.44669806957244873, -0.09790034592151642, -0.0442165769636631, -0.16842880845069885, -0.13535307347774506, 0.026483656838536263, 0.5306666493415833, -0.7585011124610901, -0.4870451092720032, 0.06172574684023857, -0.5988441109657288, -0.17213013768196106, -0.39269644021987915, -0.2804008722305298, -0.6760137677192688, -0.36965131759643555, 0.26887771487236023, -0.1702020764350891, 0.08664064854383469, 0.3821321725845337, 0.42983439564704895, -0.052986763417720795, 0.26594629883766174, -0.923116147518158, 0.7458416819572449, 0.6915041208267212, 0.6930481195449829, -0.2983343303203583, 0.01799844391644001, -0.24705933034420013, 0.0891551673412323, -0.22608520090579987, 0.5289984345436096, -0.47908666729927063, -0.2924487888813019, 0.36464187502861023, 0.3253311812877655, -0.2521705627441406, -0.7301483750343323, 0.5618473291397095, -0.4825218915939331, 0.2118406593799591, 0.08800996094942093, -0.6747655272483826, 0.08222179859876633, 0.34506380558013916, -0.6475926041603088, 0.4934244453907013, 0.6030910015106201, -0.8788734078407288, 0.4568796157836914, -0.6297025680541992, -0.4400499761104584, 0.18183748424053192, -0.4692103862762451, -0.698300302028656, 0.2730793058872223, 0.31078654527664185, 0.6201591491699219, -0.23135145008563995, 0.022547172382473946, -0.18399012088775635, -0.17170073091983795, 0.07580409198999405, 0.05980605632066727, 0.5055250525474548, 0.1579333245754242, -0.026409883052110672, 0.16779844462871552, -0.606154203414917, -0.18430361151695251, 0.02786378003656864, -0.3616017997264862, -0.5366068482398987, -0.06475730985403061, -0.0009885639883577824, -0.026493672281503677, 0.06188367307186127, -0.17305302619934082, -0.015510033816099167, -0.6195597052574158, 0.4950006604194641, 0.406734436750412, -0.009790397249162197, 0.6555166840553284, -0.427900493144989, 0.6452252268791199, 0.2018689513206482, 0.27085790038108826, -0.04822195693850517, -0.19226139783859253, -0.5796420574188232, -0.5619255900382996, 0.39601367712020874, 0.38777029514312744, -0.7027987837791443, 0.6124100685119629, -0.27216148376464844, -0.27837538719177246, -0.8369969725608826, 0.11450088769197464, 0.28776708245277405, 0.6105783581733704, 0.326145201921463, -0.44588813185691833, -0.4333723485469818, -0.9175770878791809, 0.21492134034633636, 0.1722651571035385, -0.030070167034864426, 0.5383592247962952, 0.5616012215614319, -0.871993899345398, 0.5417062044143677, -0.5471032857894897, -0.613847017288208, -0.08598042279481888, -0.24261640012264252, 0.1685197800397873, 0.4827861189842224, 0.39516252279281616, -0.7087463140487671, -0.4604198932647705, 0.1310807168483734, -0.5213848352432251, 0.029777362942695618, 0.10495311766862869, 0.2609144449234009, -0.049050502479076385, 0.6226786375045776, -0.13657033443450928, 0.2689381241798401, 0.9843262434005737, 0.09800375998020172, 0.15923812985420227, -0.5307204723358154, -0.06760863214731216, -1.264777421951294, 0.0029096342623233795, -0.18171891570091248, -0.40090087056159973, -0.7297115325927734, 0.08158435672521591, 0.1040000170469284, -0.16464675962924957, -0.35580283403396606, 0.6583419442176819, -0.6335458159446716, -0.029199013486504555, -0.2400750070810318, -0.16780079901218414, 0.10542137175798416, 0.20929738879203796, 0.3832091987133026, 0.4088965952396393, 0.5435304641723633, -0.4997488260269165, 0.08292818069458008, 0.415349543094635, -0.5127375721931458, 0.27125534415245056, -0.5733579993247986, 0.29941362142562866, 0.037959303706884384, 0.29581454396247864, -0.6041651964187622, -0.3412199318408966, 0.11924466490745544, 0.09888584911823273, 0.46490105986595154, -0.17232854664325714, -0.5686849355697632, -0.17300552129745483, -0.12459075450897217, 0.5380335450172424, 0.6027159690856934, -0.4117355942726135, 0.33466702699661255, 0.8255560994148254, -0.2726801633834839, -0.309560626745224, -0.9362481236457825, -0.19647406041622162, -0.3044917583465576, -0.3471704423427582, 0.6116134524345398, 0.12527137994766235, -0.18957684934139252, 0.02173474244773388, -0.0013814658159390092, -0.36957886815071106, 0.2812095880508423, 0.2638711929321289, -0.04575705900788307, -0.35984665155410767, 0.3464775085449219, 0.1280338317155838, -0.04386918246746063, -0.12707510590553284, -0.48541560769081116, 0.341179758310318, -0.043159324675798416, -0.5865379571914673, -0.2241293340921402, 0.4336189031600952, 0.21073560416698456, -0.08071310073137283, 0.6759670972824097, 0.45079562067985535, -0.7154572010040283, -0.1921253353357315, -0.5150075554847717, -0.17385567724704742, -0.48367342352867126, 0.5580315589904785, 0.004870492033660412, -1.339172124862671, 0.3462214469909668, -0.44722455739974976, 0.04503924399614334, 0.1322128176689148, 0.6855184435844421, -0.2719978392124176, 0.48922866582870483, 1.0688245296478271, 0.052891362458467484, 0.22614221274852753, 0.025130582973361015, 0.08963973820209503, -0.7645507454872131, -0.3047025799751282, -0.5269918441772461, -0.012396696023643017, -0.8537430763244629, -0.8728575706481934, 0.45730721950531006, -0.1454351246356964, -0.2773289382457733, 0.07315584272146225, -0.46005138754844666, 0.20469878613948822, 0.18874847888946533, 0.2664767801761627, 0.09456973522901535, 0.027550112456083298, -0.03530231490731239, -0.2757503390312195, -0.7273856997489929, -0.36365580558776855, 0.9526259899139404, 0.7390059232711792, 1.021315574645996, -0.030912330374121666, 1.0130201578140259, 0.23773884773254395, 0.6595920920372009, -0.653805136680603, -0.07906275987625122, -0.7679577469825745, -0.17314940690994263, -0.12825578451156616, -0.1963895708322525, -1.068726658821106, 0.02023870311677456, -0.2483183741569519, -0.4368145763874054, 0.36938366293907166, 0.11189548671245575, -0.4612257182598114, -0.04353996738791466, -0.508723795413971, 0.8055698871612549, -0.16996680200099945, -0.010626367293298244, 0.07845403999090195, -0.5146483778953552, 0.008033598773181438, -0.5491111874580383, 0.33454880118370056, 0.1073603630065918, -0.35896071791648865, 0.6047233939170837, -0.27147147059440613, 1.0720525979995728, 0.05764446780085564, -0.21697822213172913, -0.16485372185707092, -0.19860661029815674, 0.3557801842689514, -0.014249501749873161, 0.04514284059405327, 0.193916916847229, -0.07143361121416092, -0.45983049273490906, -0.5054706335067749, 0.552590012550354, -0.859488308429718, -0.5725012421607971, -0.16420972347259521, -0.33392539620399475, -0.8186193704605103, 0.188237726688385, 0.2858174741268158, 0.3310520350933075, -0.4852672517299652, 0.35625022649765015, 0.9173762202262878, -0.4810101091861725, -0.09132936596870422, 0.6089823246002197, 0.12782251834869385, -0.37358710169792175, 0.4794386625289917, -0.04022471234202385, 0.11618700623512268, 0.6898483037948608, 0.38300395011901855, -0.3922979235649109, -0.8632831573486328, -0.025634385645389557, 0.31278589367866516, -0.8813415765762329, -0.11690054833889008, -0.6857324242591858, -0.5005608797073364, -0.614948570728302, -0.5184765458106995, -0.21066632866859436, 0.021080834791064262, -0.5187505483627319, -0.14041990041732788, 0.08709994703531265, 0.7319638133049011, 0.07631818950176239, 0.5569536685943604, -0.9794420003890991, 0.08736119419336319, 0.21868079900741577, 0.3379175066947937, -0.38307732343673706, -0.726155698299408, -0.6010255813598633, -0.31083226203918457, 0.16549783945083618, -0.6437194347381592, 0.474452942609787, 0.13628645241260529, 0.771276593208313, 0.3535388708114624, -0.058807551860809326, 0.48975443840026855, -0.7517128586769104, 0.4806830883026123, 0.2416420876979828, -0.7010715007781982, 0.38738930225372314, -0.25691115856170654, 0.25414347648620605, 0.8236178755760193, 0.6176552176475525, -0.28804513812065125, 0.019225258380174637, -0.5760948657989502, -0.5912160277366638, 0.30830809473991394, -0.1253177672624588, 0.3497692942619324, 0.19822527468204498, 0.42948415875434875, 0.21289591491222382, 0.3010985553264618, -0.6209900975227356, -0.08338981866836548, 0.017756730318069458, -0.4265504777431488, -0.28956615924835205, -0.21571548283100128, -0.43678754568099976, -0.13708238303661346, 0.14699286222457886, -0.3317442834377289, 0.22954414784908295, 0.07317667454481125, -0.2837212383747101, 0.32119667530059814, 0.2925596535205841, 0.5120795965194702, 0.5606224536895752, 0.07714710384607315, 0.26599985361099243, 0.23299278318881989, -0.5415045022964478, 0.11922898143529892, 0.20056289434432983, 0.14580625295639038, -0.007154977414757013, 0.570608913898468, 0.7882351875305176, 0.5791888236999512, -0.43046724796295166, 0.6461884379386902, -0.0639626607298851, -0.21918728947639465, -0.1072598472237587, -0.14333508908748627, 0.36148732900619507, 0.045415136963129044, -0.18558135628700256, -0.29782339930534363, 0.07683860510587692, -0.43968093395233154, 0.34052571654319763, 0.03284864127635956, -0.5352451205253601, -0.19372209906578064, 0.3551425337791443, 0.3717484474182129, -0.0917491540312767, 0.4656796455383301, 0.24387140572071075, -0.18058298528194427, 0.3806619942188263, 0.5998127460479736, 0.8506785035133362, -0.3671421706676483, 0.15940867364406586, -0.12637054920196533, 0.35934314131736755, -0.005736104678362608, 0.03731197491288185, -0.010145041160285473, -0.7979757189750671, -0.32968923449516296, -0.6027767658233643, -0.5173620581626892, 0.2413593828678131, -0.5752843618392944, 0.06361046433448792, -0.7052502632141113, -0.08922413736581802, -0.14232756197452545, 0.15103931725025177, -1.1040712594985962, 0.45706334710121155, 0.28776243329048157, 0.8612521290779114, -0.864069938659668, 1.017293095588684, 0.7331057190895081, -0.05598181486129761, -0.6921230554580688, 0.12080026417970657, -0.06078439578413963, -1.0579187870025635, 0.5106345415115356, -0.06362031400203705, 0.08674352616071701, -0.1533081829547882, -0.32899874448776245, -0.6821131706237793, 0.8785580992698669, 0.43311265110969543, -0.7971042990684509, -0.27704599499702454, 0.2385556399822235, 0.7940097451210022, -0.7509082555770874, -0.18766480684280396, 0.5927994847297668, 0.09849057346582413, -0.3711664378643036, -0.9399059414863586, 0.11809855699539185, 0.07984928786754608, -0.10029016435146332, -0.24573750793933868, -0.41180017590522766, 0.6978469491004944, -0.1460598111152649, -0.13161154091358185, -0.016819771379232407, 0.31312277913093567, 0.18718969821929932, 0.2581334412097931, 0.36712536215782166, 0.5413184762001038, 1.13920259475708, 0.03975312411785126, 1.1150635480880737, -0.07543649524450302, 0.11835189163684845, 1.183482050895691, -0.6202198266983032, 0.6145955324172974, 0.2591991424560547, 0.01070156879723072, 0.687003493309021, 0.6494489908218384, 0.013656659983098507, 0.7933018803596497, 0.4335682988166809, -0.38985228538513184, -0.11107365041971207, -0.3129650056362152, -0.5096706748008728, 0.4675142467021942, 0.660302996635437, -0.6554845571517944, -0.10305681079626083, 0.18658430874347687, 0.05350014567375183, 0.1297753006219864, -0.32116225361824036, 0.9840568900108337, 0.5353217720985413, -0.1989983171224594, 0.30276012420654297, 0.04480549320578575, 0.559068500995636, -0.7251833081245422, 0.18250052630901337, -0.20012976229190826, 0.3071388006210327, -0.32727670669555664, -0.3418024182319641, 0.22762256860733032, -0.18161435425281525, -0.19325044751167297, -0.44906753301620483, 0.8580445647239685, -0.2875310778617859, -0.4236036241054535, 0.25185930728912354, 0.5307729244232178, 0.052118971943855286, 0.20275886356830597, -0.7671392560005188, 0.13605521619319916, -0.3098430931568146, -0.010966050438582897, 0.7408074140548706, 0.5220760703086853, -0.05601100996136665, 0.2837190330028534, 0.5961869955062866, 0.3113050162792206, -0.2717552185058594, 0.4878784716129303, 1.0496158599853516, -0.38317328691482544, -0.8166136741638184, -0.578140377998352, 0.22767150402069092, 0.09351665526628494, -0.15751886367797852, 0.4674217700958252, 0.3854725658893585, 0.718698263168335, -0.142746701836586, 0.8242356777191162, 0.49886614084243774, 0.41485995054244995, -0.6774141788482666, 0.8124470114707947, -0.5753207206726074, 0.1358315348625183, 0.01119227521121502, -0.450198233127594, -0.5367223024368286, 0.572253942489624, -0.32131922245025635, -0.005180187989026308, 0.7930498123168945, 0.6076189875602722, -0.09497032314538956, -0.3722672164440155, 0.6104146242141724, 0.06276533752679825, 0.25557228922843933, 0.6473419070243835, 0.7497398257255554, -0.12010671943426132, 0.0648491159081459, -0.16224953532218933, -0.2872684895992279, -0.24048304557800293, -0.9983516335487366, -0.9425756931304932, -0.44848862290382385, -0.5142827033996582, -0.26306721568107605, 0.08346372842788696, 0.8058611154556274, 1.164712905883789, -0.8064128756523132, 0.11484193801879883, 0.15720705687999725, -0.15877576172351837, 0.1094169169664383, -0.07516937702894211, 0.7035592198371887, -0.1509471833705902, -0.4727461636066437, 0.44580313563346863, 0.48047101497650146, 0.17977458238601685, -0.2219008505344391, -0.1051742285490036, 0.20612677931785583, 0.009116914123296738, 0.42849913239479065, 0.23025622963905334, -0.5032107830047607, -0.14484189450740814, -0.011629842221736908, -0.46651124954223633, 0.09827762842178345, 1.1519252061843872, -0.5925036668777466, 0.1779268980026245, 0.13572990894317627, 1.1043671369552612, 0.3824344277381897, -0.0944683700799942, 0.2949996292591095, -0.8787891864776611, 0.30290719866752625, 0.7398967146873474, 0.47601714730262756, 0.5056148767471313, -0.45710289478302, 0.3393690288066864, 0.04503133147954941, -0.5561643242835999, -0.8443302512168884, 0.09529167413711548, -0.8025898337364197, -0.2929615378379822, 1.0777513980865479, -0.46042510867118835, 0.01042303629219532, -0.4433872103691101, 0.08532200753688812, 0.04376962408423424, 0.1461462378501892, 0.6840608716011047, 0.429939329624176, -0.1424492448568344, -0.1868819296360016, -0.250090628862381, 0.7967008948326111, 0.22807949781417847, -1.2542611360549927, -0.05089185759425163, 0.16748489439487457, 0.40000852942466736, 0.029168875887989998, 1.206546664237976, -0.37767428159713745, 0.10765889286994934, -0.026292307302355766, -0.2415277510881424, -0.032904915511608124, -0.18108870089054108, -0.6412155628204346, 0.12821389734745026, 0.12350846827030182, -0.12341418117284775 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19758v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19758v2
Quantum Natural Language Processing
2024-03-28T18:15:07
2024-04-26T18:45:02
Dominic Widdows, Willie Aboumrad, Dohun Kim, Sayonee Ray, Jonathan Mei
quant-ph
quant-ph, cs.AI, cs.CL
Language processing is at the heart of current developments in artificial intelligence, and quantum computers are becoming available at the same time. This has led to great interest in quantum natural language processing, and several early proposals and experiments. This paper surveys the state of this area, showing how NLP-related techniques have been used in quantum language processing. We examine the art of word embeddings and sequential models, proposing some avenues for future investigation and discussing the tradeoffs present in these directions. We also highlight some recent methods to compute attention in transformer models, and perform grammatical parsing. We also introduce a new quantum design for the basic task of text encoding (representing a string of characters in memory), which has not been addressed in detail before. Quantum theory has contributed toward quantifying uncertainty and explaining "What is intelligence?" In this context, we argue that "hallucinations" in modern artificial intelligence systems are a misunderstanding of the way facts are conceptualized: language can express many plausible hypotheses, of which only a few become actual.
[ -0.36704933643341064, -1.2620525360107422, 0.8549855947494507, -0.06787475943565369, -0.21690165996551514, 0.2786385416984558, -0.20642758905887604, -0.6606245636940002, 0.2318955659866333, 0.5312581658363342, -0.2947610020637512, -0.05325085297226906, -0.5021390914916992, 0.2661975920200348, -0.6321437358856201, 0.4135606586933136, 0.2874314486980438, -0.03878122568130493, 0.07916877418756485, -0.02094947174191475, -0.46337369084358215, -0.6465991139411926, -0.8382206559181213, -0.28540918231010437, 0.13241295516490936, -0.0032759460154920816, 1.313003659248352, 0.3026202917098999, 0.5343464016914368, 0.40196532011032104, -0.18030361831188202, 0.053657274693250656, 0.0815797969698906, 0.23663878440856934, -0.09729126840829849, -0.6671827435493469, -0.11982670426368713, -0.025956271216273308, 1.0420633554458618, 0.8358361124992371, -0.12696512043476105, -0.17423735558986664, -0.2045079618692398, 1.047507643699646, -0.5705386996269226, -0.018579311668872833, -0.41384661197662354, 0.6685582995414734, -0.0333714559674263, -0.2564006745815277, -0.42185741662979126, -0.41743507981300354, 0.3254067301750183, -0.4727259576320648, 0.0791456326842308, 0.40135103464126587, 0.4454953968524933, 0.32378098368644714, -0.46162137389183044, -0.43152889609336853, -1.109930396080017, 0.9189822673797607, -0.5784906148910522, 0.939000129699707, 0.5198523998260498, 0.14448249340057373, -0.11800841242074966, -0.6421253085136414, -0.826011598110199, -0.5001616477966309, -0.14031408727169037, -0.1288386583328247, -0.6232336759567261, 0.17169204354286194, 0.2820056080818176, 0.6244232654571533, -0.6997573971748352, -0.32203593850135803, -0.20090720057487488, -0.11284621059894562, 0.49711480736732483, -0.08919757604598999, 0.4654271602630615, -0.25775134563446045, 0.061929818242788315, -0.011799775063991547, -0.22880063951015472, 0.029986219480633736, 0.01619885116815567, -0.018836060538887978, 0.32687288522720337, 0.7934526801109314, -0.45284441113471985, 0.7527086138725281, -0.019830308854579926, 0.2561788558959961, -0.21295635402202606, -0.330432265996933, -0.2523166537284851, 0.43803197145462036, 0.76975417137146, -0.0252157561480999, 0.2936238646507263, -0.48832061886787415, -0.029161496087908745, 0.26911860704421997, 0.5607683658599854, -0.2687736749649048, -0.3158177137374878, 0.364137202501297, -0.30023807287216187, 0.10112854093313217, -0.19604121148586273, -0.5673782229423523, -0.3790128231048584, -0.48137277364730835, 0.3651578426361084, -0.7141857743263245, -0.11908232420682907, 0.4084252715110779, -0.4103577435016632, 0.21160252392292023, 0.0049036708660423756, -1.0190072059631348, 0.7122519612312317, 0.7664171457290649, 0.591009795665741, 0.1878410130739212, 0.016756916418671608, -0.23710528016090393, 0.09344181418418884, -0.5525363683700562, 0.952087938785553, -0.6456857323646545, -0.25486546754837036, -0.0035085678100585938, -0.3375564515590668, 0.12810401618480682, -0.4022983908653259, 0.4110582172870636, -0.6857638955116272, 0.26177120208740234, -0.12276279181241989, -0.7003190517425537, -0.4340932071208954, -0.0066990978084504604, -0.670080304145813, 0.5915582776069641, -0.06452479213476181, -0.5835965871810913, -0.11497323960065842, -0.7575123310089111, -0.6075162291526794, 0.27440565824508667, -0.2535652816295624, -0.0007368212682195008, 0.45064863562583923, 0.09307289868593216, 0.1342291384935379, -0.3298422694206238, 0.22366732358932495, 0.13897044956684113, -0.4089501202106476, 0.787452757358551, -0.28985416889190674, 0.5810054540634155, 0.2455606758594513, -0.23178145289421082, 0.08634837716817856, -0.6915294528007507, 0.16289719939231873, 0.1833842545747757, -0.054370034486055374, -0.32139867544174194, 0.3890615701675415, -0.20538581907749176, -0.1548691987991333, 0.3817357122898102, -0.4480161964893341, -0.06166277453303337, -0.6752196550369263, 0.9223525524139404, 0.37745481729507446, 0.011064562015235424, 0.8776659965515137, -0.16562193632125854, 0.28137707710266113, -0.21253158152103424, 0.17659929394721985, 0.15339037775993347, -0.6821768879890442, -0.8759255409240723, 0.31792309880256653, 0.19470418989658356, 0.6575161218643188, -0.6044862866401672, 0.5593846440315247, -0.13475869596004486, -0.21198493242263794, -0.6463724970817566, -0.15229223668575287, 0.13285855948925018, 0.17296592891216278, 0.34109747409820557, -0.09420128911733627, -0.5442721843719482, -1.182715654373169, -0.8044038414955139, -0.16341832280158997, -0.0066820899955928326, -0.30339089035987854, 0.14374448359012604, -0.16682960093021393, 1.0187501907348633, -0.5160441398620605, -0.022129852324724197, -0.059997398406267166, 0.20220692455768585, -0.0014920808607712388, 0.6175947785377502, -0.08973189443349838, -0.9787876605987549, 0.0326932892203331, -0.06443189084529877, -0.9082845449447632, 0.7183253169059753, -0.08663176000118256, -0.2565598785877228, 0.19929178059101105, 0.44200974702835083, -0.9090961217880249, 0.28334134817123413, 0.1638868749141693, -0.40707311034202576, 0.09083375334739685, -0.03320281207561493, 0.19178351759910583, -0.6547337770462036, -0.29603466391563416, 0.07274045050144196, -0.1712998002767563, -0.9220781922340393, 0.2685778737068176, 0.031917378306388855, -0.10619699954986572, -0.21766744554042816, 0.3240985870361328, -0.20497752726078033, -0.10219606012105942, -0.38340508937835693, 0.3229427933692932, -0.12324335426092148, 0.4744272530078888, 0.17987528443336487, 0.28950509428977966, 0.3913910686969757, -0.6352142095565796, 0.4811280369758606, 0.06533640623092651, -0.1131359338760376, 0.442859947681427, -0.5040903091430664, 0.3832310140132904, -0.22981922328472137, -0.1380074918270111, -0.7182015180587769, -0.037912532687187195, 0.4383682906627655, -0.5864900946617126, 0.09563255310058594, 0.3428881764411926, -0.8409003615379333, -0.3863491714000702, -0.26310956478118896, 0.22308145463466644, 0.7752184867858887, 0.024312660098075867, 0.6347854733467102, 0.5647667050361633, 0.06954099237918854, -0.019016124308109283, -0.8925358057022095, 0.26987725496292114, -0.08570808917284012, -0.435764342546463, 0.4052191972732544, 0.008279840461909771, -0.6526612043380737, 0.3459393382072449, -0.00005059946488472633, -0.27499720454216003, 0.3312850296497345, 0.07385826855897903, -0.01252809539437294, -0.23691973090171814, 0.33592674136161804, 0.08681685477495193, -0.09745560586452484, 0.3871314525604248, -0.36151933670043945, 0.47925591468811035, -0.36644116044044495, -0.0025393241085112095, -0.6874362826347351, 0.4352200925350189, 0.19523103535175323, -0.15619437396526337, 0.6039443016052246, 0.3781238794326782, -0.8953972458839417, -0.05327257141470909, -0.42351657152175903, -0.3069916069507599, -0.48006993532180786, 0.24582569301128387, -0.2130642831325531, -1.1869734525680542, 0.025011833757162094, 0.11342222988605499, -0.017765870317816734, 0.5633643269538879, 0.3548520803451538, -0.1672808676958084, 1.43161940574646, 0.6645469069480896, 0.030589323490858078, 0.6112224459648132, 0.05218761786818504, 0.8750236630439758, -0.7636728286743164, 0.12024719268083572, -0.47307801246643066, -0.11751395463943481, -0.8487470746040344, -0.14022423326969147, 0.2047678530216217, 0.38126614689826965, -0.2988319993019104, 0.18308955430984497, -0.6859735250473022, 0.49260860681533813, 0.9527923464775085, -0.14507417380809784, 0.5195375084877014, 0.0009807756869122386, 0.2772136926651001, 0.13580307364463806, -0.6620917320251465, -0.6944453120231628, 0.750892162322998, 0.28358277678489685, 0.3696810007095337, 0.03550270199775696, 0.48371216654777527, 0.3987540304660797, -0.2383611798286438, -0.8454480171203613, 0.6706295609474182, 0.007552752736955881, -0.49460700154304504, -0.5822691321372986, -0.21516013145446777, -0.9410380721092224, 0.3020975589752197, -0.3607412874698639, -0.8601155281066895, -0.038750745356082916, 0.0032065764535218477, -0.6551130414009094, 0.14918337762355804, -0.7212558388710022, 0.5697374939918518, 0.03589438647031784, -0.02972499653697014, -0.6452454924583435, -0.48932692408561707, 0.6512849926948547, -0.017528221011161804, 0.40127211809158325, -0.07071572542190552, 0.19198466837406158, 0.9537044167518616, -0.09562577307224274, 0.45407095551490784, 0.18273916840553284, -0.2354910969734192, 0.4277843236923218, 0.2149617075920105, 0.07692999392747879, 0.3135988712310791, 0.031490396708250046, 0.002848149510100484, 0.35397234559059143, -0.29745161533355713, -0.6712690591812134, 0.462385356426239, -0.6279289722442627, -0.6954289078712463, -0.6151199340820312, -0.5833863019943237, -0.33790335059165955, 0.17324736714363098, 0.07545258104801178, 0.2934678792953491, -0.08988349884748459, -0.06336730718612671, 0.6841014623641968, -0.20587670803070068, 0.4720744490623474, 0.34569016098976135, -0.3975837230682373, -0.33464285731315613, 1.0007127523422241, 0.1722250133752823, -0.154479518532753, 0.644036054611206, 0.2557504177093506, -0.22266174852848053, -0.3868381083011627, -0.11375056207180023, 0.22909727692604065, -0.7243005037307739, 0.0851389616727829, -0.6973638534545898, -0.4265429377555847, -0.44876888394355774, -0.08348099142313004, -0.32130077481269836, -0.5787834525108337, -0.13211014866828918, 0.12642201781272888, 0.40805110335350037, 0.9405263662338257, 0.06032869219779968, 0.21180175244808197, -0.9702292084693909, 0.7660837769508362, 0.6891483068466187, 0.2680930495262146, 0.18634440004825592, -0.13463866710662842, -0.4451035261154175, 0.21330739557743073, -0.3143736720085144, -0.85187828540802, 0.269756019115448, 0.1821516752243042, 0.453139066696167, 0.07196862995624542, 0.11985693126916885, 0.4360690116882324, -0.6264325976371765, 0.9381057620048523, -0.018837058916687965, -1.2080391645431519, 0.8367043733596802, 0.07447114586830139, 0.4788072407245636, 0.272632360458374, 0.4209986627101898, -0.8211485147476196, -0.7430914044380188, -0.6865836977958679, -0.3318849802017212, 0.38505956530570984, 0.24300876259803772, 0.09732988476753235, -0.3167121112346649, 0.3102319538593292, -0.27201616764068604, 0.3146652579307556, -0.5737406015396118, -0.2347109168767929, 0.09369673579931259, -0.1981000006198883, -0.07903328537940979, -0.21408216655254364, -0.02175508439540863, -0.35769835114479065, 0.3135528266429901, 0.051685720682144165, 0.5811975002288818, 0.3275059759616852, -0.4115212559700012, -0.30770522356033325, 0.35149428248405457, 0.4132351577281952, 0.6534921526908875, -0.022040799260139465, 0.43468427658081055, -0.03490741550922394, -0.35768061876296997, -0.12647654116153717, 0.04486756771802902, -0.21411281824111938, -0.06868244707584381, 0.3868921399116516, 0.6824854016304016, 0.4248703718185425, -0.7594369649887085, -0.06058941036462784, -0.25055015087127686, -0.11335300654172897, -0.5090227723121643, 0.15202641487121582, 0.032837383449077606, 0.6441230177879333, 0.49186256527900696, -0.006320245563983917, 0.7470743060112, -0.9486908912658691, -0.0022041494958102703, 0.5715265870094299, -0.3691879212856293, -0.49467018246650696, 0.5989205837249756, -0.28134438395500183, -0.7298814654350281, 0.8962702751159668, -0.45484110713005066, -0.6638258099555969, 0.27459999918937683, 0.44690147042274475, 0.9858220815658569, -0.05545751750469208, 0.03395015373826027, 0.2270411252975464, 0.35634249448776245, -0.025143371894955635, 0.5793380737304688, -0.2807338237762451, -0.8493118286132812, -0.37647780776023865, -0.7855130434036255, -0.4857169985771179, -0.3314298689365387, -0.5141243934631348, -0.15326805412769318, -0.6379518508911133, -0.34745779633522034, 0.11462294310331345, 0.16541635990142822, -0.602392315864563, 0.08033622056245804, 0.6924348473548889, 0.386328786611557, -0.4621312618255615, 0.7474786639213562, 0.6514080166816711, -0.15012167394161224, -0.27476635575294495, -0.13271108269691467, -0.23449663817882538, -0.5066587924957275, 0.4619888365268707, 0.10933170467615128, -0.047650858759880066, 0.44923004508018494, -0.5180516242980957, -1.0879865884780884, 0.5609700679779053, 0.10089779645204544, -0.48526641726493835, -0.1489340364933014, 0.21438156068325043, 0.516339898109436, 0.2404450625181198, -0.08116781711578369, 0.939355194568634, 0.39559638500213623, -0.49382132291793823, -0.5185089707374573, 0.040826618671417236, -0.22051957249641418, 0.21244554221630096, 0.4879167377948761, -0.3918808698654175, 0.854960024356842, 0.13475365936756134, -0.5763731598854065, -0.05346342921257019, 0.9910863637924194, 0.16386838257312775, 0.0579855740070343, 0.25404950976371765, 0.6217900514602661, 0.8539186120033264, -0.04255100339651108, 1.0908336639404297, -0.4383280277252197, 0.07854489982128143, 0.6336289644241333, -0.04815366491675377, 1.01009202003479, 0.6183679103851318, -0.643108069896698, 0.543228268623352, 0.4244028329849243, 0.16471873223781586, 0.42914795875549316, 0.21825240552425385, -0.18054942786693573, -0.12350459396839142, -0.12068049609661102, -0.05465599521994591, 0.22060924768447876, 0.44519534707069397, 0.0016208125744014978, 0.09874414652585983, 0.3201853334903717, -0.3315342366695404, 0.07488738000392914, -0.3203721046447754, 0.8504865765571594, 0.33229050040245056, -0.6484107971191406, 0.3344728946685791, 0.08219598233699799, 0.5914850831031799, -0.329594224691391, -0.27846306562423706, 0.12251737713813782, -0.09877149760723114, 0.0026013050228357315, -0.8038114309310913, 0.4536226689815521, -0.25997456908226013, -0.1586223989725113, -0.18939872086048126, 0.6709380149841309, -0.07081533223390579, -0.45817214250564575, 0.004168746992945671, 0.46421608328819275, 0.1487780511379242, -0.380720317363739, -0.5451033711433411, 0.13511475920677185, -0.2439628541469574, -0.24763242900371552, 0.12938237190246582, 0.5355880856513977, -0.00014408284914679825, 0.5771523714065552, 0.4848802089691162, -0.042761724442243576, 0.45422837138175964, -0.2528763711452484, 0.43734443187713623, -1.325333833694458, -0.519538402557373, -0.9702313542366028, 0.14441896975040436, 0.24589937925338745, -0.16324956715106964, 0.8123617172241211, 0.30437320470809937, 0.6873483061790466, 0.07487071305513382, 0.5815286636352539, 0.08834218233823776, 0.31626230478286743, -0.7011232972145081, 0.5145699381828308, -0.2872304618358612, -0.12684032320976257, -0.03434055671095848, -0.9152535200119019, -0.34910422563552856, 0.8721346855163574, -0.18433503806591034, -0.2845250964164734, 0.9954425692558289, 0.228253573179245, 0.4872024953365326, 0.79947829246521, 0.19205908477306366, 0.010804434306919575, 0.08549116551876068, 0.6223862171173096, 1.2061370611190796, -0.646332323551178, -0.10739192366600037, -0.7117453813552856, 0.22551481425762177, -0.1843222677707672, -0.38677626848220825, -0.5704706907272339, -0.7870166897773743, -0.4897983968257904, 0.030575037002563477, 0.013990110717713833, 0.7655850648880005, 0.44986391067504883, -0.663854718208313, -0.2352813333272934, -0.5307740569114685, 0.42711347341537476, -0.36571624875068665, -0.20956286787986755, 0.2816302478313446, -0.6497422456741333, -0.7927926778793335, 0.45206117630004883, 0.3873427212238312, 0.11593129485845566, -0.3550778925418854, 0.1461111605167389, -0.24505208432674408, 0.10664936155080795, 0.9376156330108643, 0.2808820307254791, -0.9486545324325562, -0.27551525831222534, 0.07191795110702515, -0.03242496773600578, 0.1510334312915802, 0.5862588882446289, -1.1631622314453125, 0.3518063724040985, 0.4928196370601654, 0.687852680683136, 0.03730909153819084, -0.3157462477684021, 0.542143702507019, -0.15517394244670868, -0.004958371631801128, 0.6428666710853577, 0.1822437345981598, 0.16998711228370667, -0.3541870713233948, 0.3191591203212738, 0.15179134905338287, -0.48794668912887573, -0.9104965329170227, 0.06055872514843941, -0.7440651655197144, -0.5747476816177368, 0.5589219927787781, 0.6820763349533081, -0.5363141894340515, -0.0727539137005806, -0.09071028232574463, 0.5100899934768677, -0.2000555694103241, 0.5801703929901123, 0.8134810924530029, -0.4342906177043915, -0.3479432463645935, -0.8779046535491943, 0.5445395112037659, 0.6175100207328796, -0.5432710647583008, -0.14116108417510986, 0.268169105052948, -0.38331732153892517, 0.5727382302284241, 0.48559507727622986, 0.16839951276779175, 0.2737751603126526, 0.07009519636631012, -0.017273947596549988, 0.6867774724960327, -0.1715671569108963, -0.7034984230995178, 0.1974135786294937, 0.3100345730781555, 0.014423246495425701 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19754v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19754v1
GOLD: Generalized Knowledge Distillation via Out-of-Distribution-Guided Language Data Generation
2024-03-28T18:08:22
2024-03-28T18:08:22
Mohsen Gholami, Mohammad Akbari, Cindy Hu, Vaden Masrani, Z. Jane Wang, Yong Zhang
cs.CL
cs.CL
Knowledge distillation from LLMs is essential for the efficient deployment of language models. Prior works have proposed data generation using LLMs for preparing distilled models. We argue that generating data with LLMs is prone to sampling mainly from the center of original content distribution. This limitation hinders the distilled model from learning the true underlying data distribution and to forget the tails of the distributions (samples with lower probability). To this end, we propose GOLD, a task-agnostic data generation and knowledge distillation framework, which employs an iterative out-of-distribution-guided feedback mechanism for the LLM. As a result, the generated data improves the generalizability of distilled models. An energy-based OOD evaluation approach is also introduced to deal with noisy generated data. Our extensive experiments on 10 different classification and sequence-to-sequence tasks in NLP show that GOLD respectively outperforms prior arts and the LLM with an average improvement of 5% and 14%. We will also show that the proposed method is applicable to less explored and novel tasks. The code is available.
[ 0.04621132090687752, -0.7365704774856567, 0.5835939645767212, -0.010490539483726025, -0.190221905708313, -0.06356648355722427, -0.41215890645980835, 0.03122234344482422, -0.1646849811077118, 0.8508814573287964, -0.5694445967674255, -0.6489424109458923, -0.6526519060134888, 0.2263275384902954, -0.47160783410072327, 1.19496488571167, 0.11372107267379761, -0.31810662150382996, -0.25695133209228516, 0.15277977287769318, -0.18205617368221283, -0.6123195886611938, -0.4175484776496887, -0.6805862784385681, 0.13336117565631866, 0.23202401399612427, 0.45568516850471497, 0.622277021408081, 0.48723936080932617, 0.2982475757598877, -0.09120935201644897, 0.4707617461681366, -0.5042344927787781, 0.12216124683618546, -0.25983282923698425, -0.6859933733940125, -0.3989230692386627, -0.1676701009273529, 0.2604455053806305, 0.7614943385124207, -0.4729275703430176, 0.3161667585372925, 0.26799046993255615, 1.2531689405441284, -0.8025644421577454, 0.2544980049133301, -0.9359946250915527, 0.1090620756149292, -0.35912221670150757, -0.39623475074768066, -0.29339736700057983, -0.16665148735046387, 0.007231066003441811, -0.4741698205471039, 0.4512406885623932, 0.009373560547828674, 0.33887383341789246, 0.5342381596565247, -0.2244691252708435, -0.7154805064201355, -1.0716462135314941, 1.0006885528564453, -0.7644885182380676, 0.0179058238863945, 0.4600420296192169, 0.31942203640937805, -0.27947261929512024, -0.9469899535179138, -0.6157780885696411, -0.11240017414093018, 0.20647667348384857, 0.09562190622091293, -0.24495431780815125, 0.043761998414993286, 0.16145358979701996, 0.7219144701957703, -0.46512067317962646, -0.39690977334976196, -0.12054000049829483, 0.4264317750930786, 0.636837363243103, 0.04316331818699837, -0.11091386526823044, 0.0025392258539795876, -0.05946551635861397, -0.01991743966937065, -0.7071254253387451, -0.46452924609184265, 0.6460157632827759, 0.49435216188430786, 0.185758575797081, 0.7459311485290527, -0.30576199293136597, 0.891042947769165, 0.257495254278183, -0.4140838086605072, 0.30968591570854187, -0.27583441138267517, -0.3638436794281006, 0.09512442350387573, 0.6864356398582458, 0.19576822221279144, 0.17217063903808594, -0.3053663372993469, -0.10175052285194397, 0.08120914548635483, 0.07004879415035248, -0.6336754560470581, -0.526181697845459, 0.18633751571178436, -0.34304189682006836, -0.2404523640871048, -0.010382595472037792, -0.5282990336418152, -0.46120381355285645, -0.19586189091205597, 0.1454763263463974, -0.05318547040224075, -0.43217334151268005, 0.4766269028186798, -0.3314582109451294, -0.5618674159049988, -0.07281558215618134, -1.2481132745742798, 0.49929121136665344, 0.43170443177223206, 0.8260123133659363, -0.2077508121728897, 0.1614508032798767, -0.5027544498443604, 0.43880125880241394, -0.12032922357320786, 0.5135161280632019, -0.1322176158428192, -0.40840327739715576, -0.142551451921463, -0.23535814881324768, 0.14493565261363983, -0.9886471033096313, 0.3373691737651825, -0.41700032353401184, 0.021551303565502167, -0.31481629610061646, -0.6440547108650208, -0.13609246909618378, 0.12050261348485947, -0.6478409767150879, 1.0214771032333374, 0.22927257418632507, -0.8844391703605652, 0.5434101819992065, -0.7620751261711121, -0.20419277250766754, 0.11913130432367325, -0.25878581404685974, -0.3516443371772766, 0.214973583817482, 0.16815818846225739, 0.24438638985157013, -0.3759085237979889, 0.3946848213672638, -0.24832071363925934, -0.1475256085395813, -0.04606785997748375, -0.5619683265686035, 0.5999226570129395, 0.48657360672950745, -0.4750167429447174, -0.36886951327323914, -0.8857271671295166, -0.13293792307376862, 0.1561097353696823, -0.5010031461715698, -0.5811861157417297, 0.2915175259113312, -0.27929186820983887, -0.02451658807694912, 0.20172829926013947, -0.38463112711906433, 0.3517700731754303, -0.31820112466812134, 0.40406784415245056, 0.4185124933719635, 0.16306369006633759, 0.5830968618392944, -0.31674784421920776, 0.33791473507881165, -0.023983092978596687, 0.05836627632379532, 0.12553684413433075, -0.439259797334671, -0.5032837986946106, -0.2308969348669052, 0.17015649378299713, 0.652654767036438, -0.7464451193809509, 0.739914059638977, -0.18926027417182922, -0.40504780411720276, -0.388776570558548, 0.7835845351219177, 0.0963658019900322, 0.6786547899246216, 0.24328014254570007, -0.21914488077163696, -0.5273921489715576, -0.34831202030181885, -0.011770223267376423, -0.3257659673690796, -0.11030136793851852, 0.08929246664047241, 0.3300999701023102, -0.42235267162323, 1.1962703466415405, -0.665145754814148, -0.5573005080223083, -0.4961288273334503, 0.24376794695854187, 0.39116138219833374, 0.2625957131385803, 0.5843855738639832, -0.7420916557312012, -0.4486594498157501, 0.02003377303481102, -0.8362906575202942, -0.3729821443557739, 0.15272703766822815, -0.23288869857788086, 0.22387082874774933, 0.3615020513534546, -0.37697669863700867, 0.2313717007637024, 0.763447105884552, 0.013841788284480572, 0.28722861409187317, -0.5067142248153687, 0.04344905912876129, -1.2124605178833008, 0.291888028383255, -0.07030855864286423, -0.10653888434171677, -0.606418251991272, -0.35254836082458496, -0.14442411065101624, 0.06963298469781876, -0.2643284201622009, 0.3020949959754944, -0.4329116642475128, 0.08211300522089005, -0.506330132484436, 0.11211581528186798, 0.16546879708766937, 0.23816877603530884, 0.21880029141902924, 0.366304486989975, 0.4159795641899109, -0.7506070733070374, 0.6005151271820068, 0.2647413909435272, -0.4382077157497406, 0.3871922492980957, -0.4813331365585327, 0.07511027157306671, -0.17679435014724731, 0.030825836583971977, -0.8963232040405273, -0.011899985373020172, 0.16599121689796448, -0.049616456031799316, 0.32664284110069275, -0.3034679591655731, -0.6811447143554688, -0.27658969163894653, 0.07067299634218216, 0.22238440811634064, 0.7079828977584839, -0.5847583413124084, 0.33330032229423523, 0.32144543528556824, -0.26285988092422485, -0.6642563939094543, -1.098409652709961, -0.07071680575609207, -0.5864331126213074, -0.484860897064209, 0.2894243597984314, -0.23715360462665558, -0.6529385447502136, 0.16829055547714233, -0.04199117422103882, 0.03147515654563904, -0.024448523297905922, 0.1315060704946518, -0.1285773515701294, 0.21908870339393616, 0.20112697780132294, 0.0904737263917923, 0.007852718234062195, 0.0018447291804477572, -0.6257864236831665, 0.39480823278427124, 0.2275712788105011, -0.6509196162223816, -0.025886787101626396, 0.2810164988040924, 0.048822320997714996, 0.2208058089017868, 0.42904308438301086, 0.2656775414943695, -0.0978320986032486, -0.4012371897697449, -0.311119019985199, 0.008681317791342735, -0.5329213738441467, 0.3478606641292572, -0.07176235318183899, -0.6036403775215149, 0.42923372983932495, -0.4073150157928467, 0.4289107024669647, 0.38495126366615295, 0.6723849773406982, 0.05923692137002945, 1.1015883684158325, 0.9758006930351257, -0.16821296513080597, 0.4636499583721161, -0.4651402533054352, 0.2260853350162506, -0.34613320231437683, 0.07937607169151306, -0.5005946755409241, -0.21098820865154266, -0.20677000284194946, -0.24887697398662567, 0.440426766872406, 0.3484346270561218, 0.1653890460729599, -0.11470307409763336, -0.517131507396698, 0.25882118940353394, 0.55149245262146, -0.07749167084693909, 0.6857325434684753, 0.2877485454082489, 0.14728860557079315, 0.08316002041101456, -0.8886396288871765, -0.5450606346130371, 1.408687949180603, -0.03528245911002159, 0.9892569184303284, -0.08557094633579254, 1.078538417816162, 0.5643235445022583, 0.24755147099494934, -0.4457208514213562, 0.20682047307491302, -0.42993199825286865, -0.5685759782791138, -0.08909439295530319, -0.6902010440826416, -0.8072366118431091, -0.026477478444576263, 0.02586308866739273, -0.4321646988391876, -0.20470817387104034, 0.5188825726509094, -0.4380147159099579, 0.3790838420391083, -0.7640675902366638, 0.5395721197128296, -0.2545906603336334, -0.09496083110570908, 0.07353327423334122, -0.4010712504386902, 0.575600266456604, -0.1758318692445755, 0.476238489151001, -0.008609376847743988, 0.3246244788169861, 0.6773971915245056, -0.7084054946899414, 0.7311109900474548, -0.3933609127998352, -0.42279282212257385, 0.7204552888870239, -0.24370349943637848, 0.5478057861328125, 0.08466362953186035, -0.1628752052783966, -0.06621347367763519, -0.2907577157020569, -0.08578930050134659, -0.7579540610313416, 0.6698756217956543, -0.5138303637504578, -0.4481411576271057, -0.17670096457004547, -0.790660560131073, -0.1566077470779419, -0.11685013025999069, 0.5230093598365784, 0.21617287397384644, 0.10861669480800629, -0.07004092633724213, 0.7350202202796936, -0.04126870632171631, 0.42445245385169983, 0.3408852517604828, -0.1338585913181305, -0.3936655819416046, 0.9649713635444641, 0.23982208967208862, 0.4587126076221466, 0.22888505458831787, 0.07207109779119492, -0.5824005007743835, -0.7116230130195618, -0.5819993615150452, 0.10072933882474899, -0.7156825661659241, -0.10641065984964371, -0.4231545031070709, 0.029918760061264038, -0.33416831493377686, -0.036415014415979385, -0.42988795042037964, -0.4064673185348511, -0.4792573153972626, -0.04149894416332245, 0.7137213349342346, 0.8658108115196228, -0.369172602891922, 0.38502103090286255, -0.833560585975647, 0.38830482959747314, 0.40263575315475464, 0.10386987775564194, -0.23679547011852264, -0.3839332163333893, -0.3676062226295471, 0.3698050081729889, -0.4274033010005951, -0.5949068665504456, 0.5254245400428772, 0.5263161659240723, 0.6031132936477661, 0.4038643538951874, 0.3790435492992401, 0.7522518038749695, -0.43883973360061646, 0.9645184874534607, 0.2677672207355499, -0.7026688456535339, 0.6887532472610474, -0.059277284890413284, 0.2967311441898346, 0.6939060091972351, 0.082948699593544, -0.13786844909191132, -0.6736636757850647, -0.6908965706825256, -1.0306557416915894, 0.3866998851299286, 0.12473823875188828, 0.07062818855047226, -0.15499700605869293, 0.43179449439048767, 0.40495601296424866, 0.7027300000190735, -0.5083574652671814, -0.4328221082687378, -0.012524937279522419, -0.3747442960739136, -0.2573699951171875, -0.09080352634191513, -0.2185434103012085, 0.13604822754859924, 0.7911083102226257, -0.22265374660491943, -0.07667958736419678, 0.07951925694942474, -0.26246941089630127, -0.2739395797252655, 0.14489364624023438, 0.2786274254322052, 0.541010320186615, -0.3097250759601593, 0.2786620855331421, -0.008898897096514702, -0.7157900929450989, 0.1237860769033432, -0.016533486545085907, -0.2753371000289917, 0.2702210247516632, -0.053755152970552444, 0.646049439907074, -0.4361594021320343, -0.6314732432365417, 0.1415012925863266, -0.07817229628562927, -0.47073206305503845, -0.20611290633678436, 0.30152764916419983, 0.043504346162080765, 0.43975988030433655, 0.5655196309089661, 0.0029994603246450424, 0.2566593587398529, -0.4308115243911743, 0.1564968079328537, 0.3721189498901367, -0.003399035194888711, -0.262950599193573, 0.565890908241272, 0.04201798141002655, 0.2137131243944168, 0.4773147702217102, -0.4696314334869385, 0.0810428112745285, 0.1914348602294922, 0.4476475715637207, 0.7627415060997009, 0.006828907877206802, 0.12061917781829834, 0.06541742384433746, 0.04127674177289009, -0.4620300233364105, 0.6963001489639282, -0.36678844690322876, -0.5215674042701721, -0.5672242641448975, -0.804877519607544, -0.31331396102905273, 0.33802321553230286, -0.6521909832954407, 0.027157731354236603, -0.04584489390254021, -0.44312188029289246, -0.4821341931819916, 0.2494966983795166, -0.3786439299583435, 0.12396994233131409, 0.07265646755695343, 0.7298206686973572, -0.982656717300415, 0.799799919128418, 0.5090392827987671, -0.06457000225782394, -0.502006471157074, -0.1360558420419693, -0.12937816977500916, -0.42953455448150635, 0.5799333453178406, -0.34877339005470276, 0.011492853052914143, 0.16595235466957092, -0.48715877532958984, -0.7459082007408142, 1.2068309783935547, 0.8830596804618835, -0.6040202379226685, -0.007140249479562044, 0.42638877034187317, 0.4319966733455658, -0.172881081700325, -0.0679648295044899, 0.6900436282157898, 0.37216508388519287, 0.3753899335861206, -0.8868299126625061, -0.39234375953674316, -0.4009513556957245, 0.05681661516427994, 0.02820439636707306, -0.13415172696113586, 0.7721685767173767, -0.16719621419906616, -0.15102754533290863, -0.10153231769800186, 0.7117676138877869, 0.6785792112350464, 0.25431057810783386, 0.4681638479232788, 0.7413788437843323, 0.9023683071136475, -0.017214126884937286, 0.7457047700881958, -0.2510431110858917, 0.3571208119392395, 1.009774923324585, -0.4900740683078766, 0.4985427260398865, 0.7020086646080017, -0.14640679955482483, 0.36681413650512695, 0.30219900608062744, 0.19442567229270935, 1.0921083688735962, 0.46582433581352234, -0.44335633516311646, 0.1424178183078766, -0.04431011527776718, -0.492073655128479, 0.13863131403923035, 0.33628615736961365, -0.46137452125549316, -0.6165527701377869, 0.10527504235506058, -0.1293647587299347, 0.10843171179294586, -0.3754771947860718, 0.8892068862915039, 0.17459528148174286, -0.530852735042572, 0.7879970073699951, -0.1382601410150528, 0.8164724111557007, -0.8318831920623779, -0.11460571736097336, -0.0612015426158905, 0.46782955527305603, -0.27448999881744385, -0.48489120602607727, 0.5328907370567322, 0.24861471354961395, -0.4356168210506439, -0.4762757122516632, 0.7671634554862976, -0.7818759083747864, -0.28894007205963135, 0.009432513266801834, 0.6291985511779785, 0.1878042370080948, -0.2577630579471588, -0.4344252943992615, -0.0687415674328804, -0.041481178253889084, -0.5013666749000549, 0.5124123692512512, 0.6982580423355103, 0.10205143690109253, 0.49354860186576843, 0.4747922718524933, 0.4548216164112091, 0.26157131791114807, 0.15060372650623322, 0.7380961775779724, -0.07553526759147644, -0.5843006372451782, -0.9197289943695068, 0.47793322801589966, 0.1275056004524231, 0.005294295959174633, 0.8066487908363342, 0.38011434674263, 0.8430143594741821, -0.13892237842082977, 1.4038552045822144, -0.23170609772205353, 0.40336254239082336, -0.5263867378234863, 0.7041758298873901, -0.5499147176742554, 0.20948606729507446, -0.35717397928237915, -0.9226109385490417, -0.1158401370048523, 0.4708993434906006, -0.15509408712387085, -0.01990567147731781, 0.37515774369239807, 0.5724242925643921, -0.022967156022787094, -0.1651684045791626, 0.25152939558029175, -0.2937760353088379, 0.3704124391078949, 0.5993364453315735, 0.6344090700149536, -0.3208462595939636, 0.4916952848434448, -0.3182421028614044, -0.23917336761951447, -0.061783671379089355, -1.1336678266525269, -0.7634240388870239, -0.5960605144500732, -0.33906036615371704, -0.15360857546329498, -0.007945934310555458, 0.7259852290153503, 0.5812082886695862, -0.6720021367073059, -0.38993749022483826, -0.7344806790351868, -0.1994602531194687, -0.4988647997379303, -0.155683234333992, 0.2787606120109558, -0.5238808989524841, -0.7449416518211365, 0.38383424282073975, 0.20693305134773254, 0.09459654986858368, -0.28034237027168274, -0.3189420700073242, 0.1333048939704895, -0.08590564876794815, 0.40802866220474243, 0.18196526169776917, -0.267098069190979, 0.1309005618095398, -0.04130725562572479, 0.10086959600448608, -0.24757890403270721, 0.6852518916130066, -0.721363365650177, 0.42665791511535645, 0.39823055267333984, 0.3889290988445282, 0.46514976024627686, 0.10993994027376175, 0.664458155632019, -1.2653440237045288, 0.2572096288204193, 0.08859412372112274, 0.2802748382091522, 0.3051004409790039, -0.33349353075027466, 0.41147905588150024, 0.3803441524505615, -0.5938633680343628, -0.8389662504196167, 0.20389284193515778, -0.7463638782501221, -0.08312118053436279, 1.4060559272766113, -0.3083193302154541, -0.3024325370788574, -0.17626672983169556, -0.184174045920372, 0.46944543719291687, -0.2639457583427429, 1.0963724851608276, 0.4940853416919708, -0.18989399075508118, 0.16364426910877228, -0.49910709261894226, 0.7936225533485413, 0.14336858689785004, -0.8037448525428772, 0.42150601744651794, 0.45512470602989197, 0.22567588090896606, 0.30240553617477417, 0.8845533132553101, -0.05275704711675644, -0.19320236146450043, -0.041075002402067184, 0.1347873955965042, -0.3392274081707001, -0.31956079602241516, -0.08916324377059937, 0.3266647160053253, 0.10135357081890106, -0.09415886551141739 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19651v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19651v2
MagicLens: Self-Supervised Image Retrieval with Open-Ended Instructions
2024-03-28T17:59:20
2024-06-24T23:41:29
Kai Zhang, Yi Luan, Hexiang Hu, Kenton Lee, Siyuan Qiao, Wenhu Chen, Yu Su, Ming-Wei Chang
cs.CV
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.MM
Image retrieval, i.e., finding desired images given a reference image, inherently encompasses rich, multi-faceted search intents that are difficult to capture solely using image-based measures. Recent works leverage text instructions to allow users to more freely express their search intents. However, they primarily focus on image pairs that are visually similar and/or can be characterized by a small set of pre-defined relations. The core thesis of this paper is that text instructions can enable retrieving images with richer relations beyond visual similarity. To show this, we introduce MagicLens, a series of self-supervised image retrieval models that support open-ended instructions. MagicLens is built on a key novel insight: image pairs that naturally occur on the same web pages contain a wide range of implicit relations (e.g., inside view of), and we can bring those implicit relations explicit by synthesizing instructions via foundation models. Trained on 36.7M (query image, instruction, target image) triplets with rich semantic relations mined from the web, MagicLens achieves results comparable with or better than prior best on eight benchmarks of various image retrieval tasks, while maintaining high parameter efficiency with a significantly smaller model size. Additional human analyses on a 1.4M-image unseen corpus further demonstrate the diversity of search intents supported by MagicLens. Code and models are publicly available at https://open-vision-language.github.io/MagicLens/.
[ -0.3626931309700012, -0.3806649148464203, 0.73236083984375, 0.045977964997291565, -0.2815217077732086, -0.5130777955055237, -0.22997640073299408, -0.40462252497673035, -0.09032829105854034, 0.7685254216194153, -0.5065233707427979, -0.5689041614532471, -0.35330915451049805, 0.05027683451771736, -0.3581642210483551, 0.9555924534797668, -0.12882032990455627, 0.09972313046455383, -0.31039154529571533, -0.1914452761411667, -0.15753872692584991, -0.10231662541627884, -0.13202987611293793, 0.23631173372268677, 0.7141798734664917, 0.38604503870010376, 1.1474628448486328, 0.8079067468643188, 0.9445688724517822, 0.3109351098537445, 0.11571751534938812, 0.6366398334503174, -0.5724141001701355, 0.19421076774597168, -0.4123131036758423, -0.3687324821949005, 0.09584738314151764, 0.3565371632575989, 0.3851073980331421, 0.42869463562965393, 0.23901279270648956, 0.25522279739379883, -0.05753674730658531, 0.9974715113639832, -1.1843039989471436, 0.20251336693763733, -0.5574567914009094, 0.352721631526947, -0.27066630125045776, -0.5722845196723938, -0.39136967062950134, -0.3609474003314972, 0.28325212001800537, -0.9218965172767639, 0.37503406405448914, 0.15422607958316803, 0.6878232359886169, -0.05227040499448776, -0.28180545568466187, -0.7120168805122375, -0.5584473013877869, 0.6846217513084412, -0.19835196435451508, 0.39993590116500854, 0.5825309753417969, 0.640789270401001, -0.12927411496639252, -0.8311203718185425, -0.3516089618206024, -0.29175707697868347, -0.48423150181770325, 0.14396651089191437, -0.06674852967262268, 0.028541067615151405, 0.029154304414987564, 0.7448798418045044, -0.4373995363712311, -0.44941607117652893, -0.5398135781288147, 0.1429997831583023, 0.605709969997406, -0.043764520436525345, 0.4918868839740753, -0.014557438902556896, -0.271918922662735, -0.21070905029773712, -0.525774359703064, -0.31012779474258423, 0.36407145857810974, 0.19416455924510956, 0.22136761248111725, 0.8294506072998047, -0.17232811450958252, 0.8233493566513062, -0.07379305362701416, 0.04209507256746292, 0.08229468762874603, -0.2518758475780487, 0.008124037645757198, -0.26637452840805054, 0.7766814827919006, 0.4955485165119171, 0.4741831123828888, -0.5806916952133179, -0.25621098279953003, -0.2666931748390198, 0.3324457108974457, -0.9126005172729492, -0.39646923542022705, -0.22689305245876312, -0.9314672946929932, -0.09451260417699814, 0.367254376411438, -0.6927181482315063, -0.14838257431983948, -0.4257083535194397, 0.6658576130867004, -0.5696362257003784, 0.07709334790706635, -0.003621557494625449, -0.24591177701950073, 0.32667580246925354, 0.2956310212612152, -0.8592079877853394, 0.5347168445587158, 0.5403519868850708, 0.897240936756134, -0.11468151956796646, -0.28348684310913086, -0.6579323410987854, 0.29701629281044006, -0.6184198260307312, 0.7014078497886658, -0.857762336730957, -0.33518093824386597, -0.08763077855110168, 0.06743240356445312, -0.054632097482681274, -0.39656493067741394, 0.463039368391037, -0.9366495013237, 0.537250280380249, -0.09012684971094131, -0.4973256289958954, -0.11423076689243317, 0.11397235095500946, -0.8261747360229492, 0.8426965475082397, -0.19587132334709167, -0.6810696721076965, -0.1726849228143692, -0.9523864984512329, -0.30566316843032837, -0.08949865400791168, -0.3076230585575104, -0.2891201078891754, 0.25231242179870605, 0.17362858355045319, 0.4252910614013672, -0.07880230247974396, -0.362505167722702, -0.5550280809402466, -0.626630425453186, 0.020414212718605995, -0.391042023897171, 0.48725399374961853, 0.1717817485332489, -0.1646258383989334, -0.1171659529209137, -0.50365149974823, 0.20662212371826172, 0.6044140458106995, 0.11850571632385254, -0.8029389977455139, -0.1316816806793213, -0.2973891496658325, 0.097163125872612, 0.466082364320755, -0.47833213210105896, 0.3559635281562805, -0.05650115758180618, -0.0484493151307106, 0.731238067150116, -0.23854628205299377, 0.5596203804016113, 0.11900874227285385, 0.11849560588598251, -0.31140491366386414, 0.5578615665435791, -0.7295699715614319, -0.43624186515808105, -0.6622968912124634, -0.2004970759153366, 0.11301706731319427, 0.42321985960006714, -0.5614478588104248, 0.15990328788757324, -0.35329848527908325, -0.3788142800331116, -0.5259184241294861, 0.28214025497436523, 0.9271485805511475, 0.3125385344028473, 0.7586234211921692, -0.2777116298675537, -0.11277604103088379, -1.1550641059875488, -0.37365394830703735, 0.36131176352500916, -0.07885588705539703, 0.6563215851783752, 0.5663778781890869, -0.13112488389015198, 0.8156557083129883, -0.7364183664321899, -0.6130338907241821, 0.5723222494125366, -0.11853242665529251, 0.1523963063955307, 0.21779218316078186, 0.6515587568283081, -1.288241982460022, -0.6469358801841736, 0.19413937628269196, -0.9143146276473999, 0.08314064890146255, 0.3100106716156006, -0.4372202157974243, -0.026860233396291733, 0.3968379497528076, -0.627448558807373, 0.8633763194084167, 0.31299301981925964, -0.2258053869009018, 0.61204594373703, -0.41438108682632446, 0.49584662914276123, -0.5297138690948486, 0.08187549561262131, 0.05033456161618233, -0.015086316503584385, -0.2900889217853546, 0.2728882431983948, 0.2607339322566986, 0.13194416463375092, -0.34685182571411133, 0.5686290264129639, -0.9436160922050476, -0.46114179491996765, -0.23632848262786865, -0.074355348944664, 0.28291839361190796, 0.5495513677597046, 0.059038013219833374, 0.9679282903671265, 0.5871009826660156, -0.5275049805641174, 0.47877761721611023, 0.1805063933134079, 0.036291610449552536, 0.7444022297859192, -0.4165794849395752, 0.44630101323127747, -0.17814292013645172, -0.08573652058839798, -0.7432056665420532, -0.13108405470848083, 0.22962619364261627, -0.27176496386528015, 0.2871876358985901, -0.3817075192928314, -0.743387758731842, -0.5894230008125305, -0.4463759660720825, 0.4468865394592285, 0.3194626569747925, -0.9274324178695679, 0.5924959778785706, 0.0229899100959301, 0.22669106721878052, -0.5882018208503723, -0.5689423084259033, 0.058316223323345184, 0.1461504101753235, -0.5795757174491882, 0.6245423555374146, -0.1168469488620758, -0.23941698670387268, 0.5333805084228516, -0.1826411634683609, -0.34670186042785645, -0.36520183086395264, 0.20366989076137543, 0.3027259409427643, -0.022723108530044556, 0.1992063820362091, -0.2973923981189728, -0.007280417717993259, -0.20161482691764832, -0.5988368391990662, 0.04881930723786354, -0.3990773856639862, -0.6442353129386902, -0.3366035223007202, 0.5179324150085449, 0.47261759638786316, -0.4018222987651825, 0.5723699331283569, 0.6216208338737488, -0.24300415813922882, 0.13464029133319855, -0.5220004916191101, -0.10092046856880188, -0.5221580266952515, -0.2003033608198166, -0.6400133371353149, -0.602288544178009, 0.29500770568847656, 0.19837549328804016, 0.037757664918899536, 0.29742008447647095, 0.20993293821811676, -0.4763166010379791, 1.1217070817947388, 0.5066850781440735, 0.476706326007843, 0.3648383915424347, -0.4508570432662964, -0.013786813244223595, -0.7242448925971985, -0.5004655122756958, -0.13768227398395538, -0.21386505663394928, -0.4339059889316559, -0.4075203537940979, 0.5057593584060669, 0.0585474893450737, 0.08534916490316391, 0.21927574276924133, -0.8381853699684143, 0.8985806107521057, 0.9930455684661865, 0.5939529538154602, 0.2688561677932739, 0.2576013505458832, -0.40421029925346375, -0.0648505762219429, -0.3906787931919098, -0.37284788489341736, 1.090494990348816, -0.17322584986686707, 0.8551810383796692, 0.002344901440665126, 0.6171050071716309, 0.3838769793510437, 0.2160896211862564, -0.604394257068634, 0.5838688611984253, -0.42434459924697876, -0.4393070340156555, -0.12044671922922134, -0.5103394985198975, -1.2838008403778076, 0.3492327928543091, 0.0469275638461113, -0.3783477544784546, -0.05540664866566658, 0.2312840074300766, -0.12756134569644928, 0.452625572681427, -0.7090036273002625, 0.8148161172866821, -0.604325532913208, -0.7772330045700073, -0.27303019165992737, -0.7814200520515442, 0.460559219121933, 0.14811494946479797, 0.27998417615890503, 0.007676400244235992, -0.0958617776632309, 0.4704906940460205, -0.5183145403862, 0.5777328014373779, -0.013105274178087711, 0.038210656493902206, 0.2921425998210907, 0.27742451429367065, 0.27239513397216797, -0.5344488620758057, 0.1444283127784729, 0.0659560114145279, 0.045830558985471725, -0.35038137435913086, -1.0225757360458374, 0.7866974472999573, -0.5296967029571533, -0.4829293489456177, -0.09989818185567856, -0.3828136920928955, 0.14368654787540436, 0.45719170570373535, 0.1175980195403099, 0.5088623762130737, -0.04360584169626236, 0.08776773512363434, 0.9868546724319458, -0.08095548301935196, 0.45347851514816284, 0.4272983968257904, -0.477640837430954, -0.4374387264251709, 0.9803236722946167, 0.18545937538146973, -0.03525806590914726, 0.45509693026542664, 0.256441205739975, -0.3028601408004761, -0.24349036812782288, -0.5501717329025269, 0.27368825674057007, -0.8120793104171753, -0.38250795006752014, -0.4726739227771759, -0.05990995094180107, -0.33674660325050354, -0.05452088639140129, -0.4619062840938568, -0.26035186648368835, -0.533152163028717, 0.32236769795417786, 0.5758702158927917, 0.7567893266677856, -0.19475200772285461, 0.09400603175163269, -0.9097261428833008, 0.8265615105628967, 0.7467024922370911, 0.8837496638298035, -0.0738840326666832, -0.25372204184532166, -0.3133421838283539, 0.01225128211081028, -0.3041684925556183, -1.1721374988555908, 0.33905139565467834, 0.2709188163280487, 0.6898590326309204, 0.4811194837093353, 0.02802080288529396, 0.8918468356132507, -0.7639138698577881, 0.3985811173915863, 0.2748253047466278, -0.6263763308525085, 0.8325849175453186, -0.3015800714492798, -0.04463821277022362, 0.43206465244293213, 0.4715249240398407, -0.16332493722438812, 0.24533595144748688, -0.5426939129829407, -0.40767550468444824, 0.5002368092536926, 0.6032722592353821, 0.22455061972141266, 0.03877231478691101, 0.49340710043907166, 0.042328670620918274, 0.037042036652565, -0.48127737641334534, -0.39000219106674194, -0.2903864085674286, -0.290402352809906, 0.5136434435844421, -0.0519135519862175, -0.3742809295654297, -0.18515340983867645, 0.4369388222694397, -0.24965591728687286, 0.422097772359848, 0.5413393974304199, -0.17290182411670685, -0.13238759338855743, 0.031102843582630157, 0.16715416312217712, 0.29391297698020935, -0.0766531378030777, 0.37954506278038025, -0.2629116475582123, -0.37679731845855713, -0.07956700772047043, 0.38990506529808044, -0.04268151894211769, -0.041791047900915146, 0.1733098328113556, 0.6258435845375061, 0.1654481142759323, -0.6099228262901306, 0.8197749257087708, -0.19778679311275482, -0.12360657006502151, -0.2978775203227997, 0.17184045910835266, -0.3009491562843323, 0.22399665415287018, 0.7913810610771179, 0.09778789430856705, 0.609210729598999, -0.531123161315918, 0.35716038942337036, 0.8622732162475586, -0.4387452006340027, -0.20082630217075348, 0.41673678159713745, -0.028385182842612267, -0.2711392641067505, 0.5238468050956726, -0.49992474913597107, -0.45076292753219604, 0.40344542264938354, 0.35882583260536194, 0.6670558452606201, -0.058659594506025314, 0.042774394154548645, -0.06308348476886749, 0.2510356903076172, -0.17930617928504944, 0.27522948384284973, -0.2797291874885559, -0.42763271927833557, -0.20110946893692017, -0.3652878999710083, -0.375702440738678, -0.23483461141586304, -0.6246176958084106, 0.213450625538826, -0.1883748471736908, 0.08833920955657959, -0.2569996118545532, -0.11998964101076126, -0.8323854207992554, 0.12778471410274506, 0.25733980536460876, 0.9037458300590515, -0.1981246918439865, 0.5228767395019531, 0.4593055248260498, -0.4664670526981354, -0.4397095739841461, -0.31128931045532227, -0.2406567931175232, -0.8710675835609436, 0.6810706853866577, 0.5572161674499512, -0.25162315368652344, 0.15861709415912628, -0.9315094351768494, -0.7793457508087158, 1.0900905132293701, 0.3838602602481842, -0.20169095695018768, -0.22065630555152893, -0.0707746148109436, 0.36705267429351807, -0.33953726291656494, 0.5448221564292908, 0.2577754855155945, 0.5603281259536743, 0.27593302726745605, -0.9089304208755493, -0.12884166836738586, -0.5563808679580688, -0.0698448196053505, 0.10519778728485107, -0.5003591775894165, 0.6486262679100037, -0.6209325194358826, -0.452734112739563, 0.2699745297431946, 0.7261072397232056, 0.28206825256347656, 0.5423519611358643, 0.35782575607299805, 0.6886013150215149, 0.38679414987564087, 0.19570501148700714, 1.143103003501892, -0.2135685682296753, 0.19491954147815704, 0.953008234500885, 0.10416217148303986, 0.6943809986114502, 0.38885602355003357, -0.04984798654913902, 0.6613731384277344, 0.46247485280036926, -0.22749654948711395, 0.7516277432441711, -0.143422469496727, -0.07818380743265152, -0.21407747268676758, -0.15633344650268555, -0.3589766323566437, 0.21898499131202698, 0.5596950650215149, -0.8488492965698242, -0.3714475929737091, -0.037373363971710205, -0.39039844274520874, 0.2771836817264557, -0.499933660030365, 0.6193979978561401, -0.03631637990474701, -0.4621822237968445, 0.368554025888443, -0.30627140402793884, 0.6935720443725586, -0.4492068886756897, -0.40723755955696106, 0.05900614708662033, -0.015907244756817818, -0.3171953856945038, -1.100563406944275, 0.01298714242875576, -0.29446226358413696, -0.22772783041000366, -0.07281338423490524, 1.0787078142166138, -0.3909176290035248, -0.5474150776863098, 0.2855290472507477, 0.45091673731803894, 0.29213646054267883, -0.24308890104293823, -0.744653046131134, -0.05932187661528587, -0.19893039762973785, -0.46154528856277466, 0.039815571159124374, 0.450885146856308, 0.018767010420560837, 0.5971823930740356, 0.8083556890487671, -0.17272551357746124, 0.36693644523620605, -0.2788560688495636, 0.8331131935119629, -0.523612916469574, -0.18571990728378296, -0.7414107918739319, 0.07805956900119781, -0.25903618335723877, 0.10641298443078995, 0.8216518759727478, 0.6229036450386047, 0.7280898690223694, -0.22863806784152985, 0.6534172892570496, 0.30149850249290466, 0.12299246340990067, -0.5418359041213989, 0.2727360427379608, -0.6663569808006287, -0.22455866634845734, -0.1780652552843094, -0.8536202311515808, -0.4977329671382904, 0.6224741339683533, -0.49565115571022034, 0.13818877935409546, 0.4284578263759613, 0.9184734225273132, -0.6569593548774719, 0.1014474406838417, 0.19446934759616852, -0.3801153600215912, -0.032083429396152496, 0.26914891600608826, 0.8639318943023682, -0.4428497552871704, 0.9133371114730835, -0.41620489954948425, -0.13793396949768066, -0.26385751366615295, -0.7394924163818359, -0.853920578956604, -0.4444306790828705, -0.08647461235523224, -0.11574463546276093, 0.3352615535259247, 0.6514247059822083, 0.9663050174713135, -0.3215106129646301, 0.20195424556732178, -0.19929255545139313, 0.0695093423128128, -0.10076738148927689, -0.2538090646266937, 0.5717822909355164, -0.40427327156066895, -0.6758530139923096, 0.31040069460868835, 0.49341583251953125, 0.39851948618888855, -0.43803268671035767, -0.20158936083316803, -0.05767279118299484, 0.06697265058755875, 0.4557688534259796, 0.38465726375579834, -0.5782322287559509, 0.05609578639268875, 0.3009834885597229, -0.38869088888168335, 0.11587415635585785, 0.9009465575218201, -0.8047772645950317, 0.5598533749580383, 0.4451245069503784, 0.3520592749118805, 0.567803144454956, -0.22146236896514893, 0.2721511721611023, -0.7105445861816406, -0.09923666715621948, 0.049176175147295, 0.33928871154785156, 0.5828618407249451, -0.4513833522796631, 0.7834221720695496, 0.30404314398765564, -0.37268558144569397, -0.5189253687858582, 0.08443258702754974, -0.6488779187202454, -0.6040643453598022, 1.089565634727478, -0.22765254974365234, -0.38828039169311523, 0.30547529458999634, -0.2724693715572357, 0.23820434510707855, -0.20503990352153778, 0.5558613538742065, 0.10038957744836807, -0.226060152053833, -0.3439163267612457, -0.5246058106422424, 0.1487879902124405, 0.12757913768291473, -0.4644804894924164, -0.1573471575975418, 0.5805153250694275, -0.03133885934948921, 0.5126280188560486, 0.4357280433177948, -0.30141547322273254, 0.4150732159614563, -0.3007879853248596, 0.1290971040725708, -0.3167532980442047, -0.5200710296630859, 0.1659034639596939, 0.4317629933357239, -0.49039435386657715, -0.4475072920322418 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19647v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19647v2
Sparse Feature Circuits: Discovering and Editing Interpretable Causal Graphs in Language Models
2024-03-28T17:56:07
2024-03-31T16:54:50
Samuel Marks, Can Rager, Eric J. Michaud, Yonatan Belinkov, David Bau, Aaron Mueller
cs.LG
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
We introduce methods for discovering and applying sparse feature circuits. These are causally implicated subnetworks of human-interpretable features for explaining language model behaviors. Circuits identified in prior work consist of polysemantic and difficult-to-interpret units like attention heads or neurons, rendering them unsuitable for many downstream applications. In contrast, sparse feature circuits enable detailed understanding of unanticipated mechanisms. Because they are based on fine-grained units, sparse feature circuits are useful for downstream tasks: We introduce SHIFT, where we improve the generalization of a classifier by ablating features that a human judges to be task-irrelevant. Finally, we demonstrate an entirely unsupervised and scalable interpretability pipeline by discovering thousands of sparse feature circuits for automatically discovered model behaviors.
[ -0.2561280131340027, -0.7856758236885071, 0.8749681711196899, 0.19110174477100372, 0.15364469587802887, -0.050370510667562485, -0.17056122422218323, -0.37671566009521484, 0.33396485447883606, 0.6588598489761353, -0.7581844925880432, -0.18273648619651794, -0.6598764657974243, -0.2186812460422516, -0.8022649884223938, 0.9075676798820496, 0.058097612112760544, -0.3607962727546692, 0.07653553783893585, -0.15019482374191284, -0.5373885035514832, -0.27399584650993347, -0.49882039427757263, -0.402001291513443, 0.6778801679611206, 0.3041975498199463, 0.8818027973175049, 0.5839896202087402, 0.1214873194694519, 0.4355268180370331, -0.1686498373746872, 0.0035324874334037304, -0.4829968810081482, -0.10359060019254684, -0.3552643358707428, -0.22106362879276276, -0.48493149876594543, -0.2344961166381836, 0.46829789876937866, 1.4451943635940552, 0.2176344245672226, 0.2633814215660095, 0.28319400548934937, 0.5275452733039856, -0.49934813380241394, 0.5799840688705444, -0.7130413055419922, -0.3667718172073364, -0.23573656380176544, -0.2324903905391693, -0.5362147688865662, -0.003139863722026348, -0.06085974723100662, -0.617520272731781, 0.7062846422195435, 0.02462918497622013, 0.6893178224563599, 0.2686782479286194, -0.3401687741279602, -0.13550573587417603, -0.7199565172195435, 0.6177547574043274, -0.04461122676730156, 0.42499813437461853, 0.48202672600746155, -0.03162604570388794, -0.31588029861450195, -1.0005183219909668, -0.1870819479227066, -0.06412361562252045, -0.389288067817688, -0.413565069437027, -0.4591745436191559, 0.3580220937728882, 0.42220836877822876, 0.06986229121685028, -0.496587872505188, 0.11465784162282944, -0.33747899532318115, -0.42084652185440063, 0.5296143889427185, 0.38320595026016235, 0.44736698269844055, -0.14623501896858215, 0.24193976819515228, 0.263616144657135, -0.7529338598251343, 0.05394560843706131, 0.3687000274658203, 0.4871867895126343, 0.10350774228572845, 0.4503263533115387, -0.25989624857902527, 0.7371240258216858, 0.07876163721084595, 0.29721641540527344, 0.052817296236753464, -0.09501080960035324, -0.27808836102485657, 0.006555479019880295, 0.6860198378562927, -0.4120599329471588, 0.3684615194797516, -0.2572917938232422, -0.01888798363506794, -0.235333651304245, 0.4460102617740631, -0.3741479814052582, -0.6563886404037476, -0.04445796459913254, -0.6868897080421448, -0.31358468532562256, -0.1191205158829689, -0.6273935437202454, -0.5147610306739807, -0.34837791323661804, 0.3304557800292969, -0.2741040587425232, -0.12921731173992157, -0.014107606373727322, -0.07552127540111542, -0.32961007952690125, 0.4386260211467743, -1.4713959693908691, 0.533466637134552, 0.4955890476703644, 0.8667853474617004, 0.06959293782711029, -0.5405223369598389, -0.3553796708583832, 0.03172201290726662, -0.19791512191295624, 0.8913798332214355, -0.5102720260620117, 0.05721092224121094, -0.17553669214248657, 0.4893660545349121, -0.3031329810619354, -0.35091397166252136, 0.5944949388504028, -0.5726568102836609, -0.43808799982070923, -0.3420763909816742, -0.1326960325241089, -0.16097740828990936, -0.596767008304596, -0.9018042683601379, 0.8908860683441162, 0.35642001032829285, -0.9305965900421143, 0.2037486433982849, -0.6520909070968628, -0.7263504266738892, -0.1663781702518463, 0.10820482671260834, -0.25704342126846313, 0.3398292660713196, 0.1932939738035202, 0.29085153341293335, -0.05788174271583557, 0.29539430141448975, -0.483447790145874, -0.5502892732620239, 0.4196602404117584, -0.5748968720436096, 1.041885495185852, 0.22482776641845703, -0.45315808057785034, 0.41551998257637024, -0.8746057748794556, -0.3407945930957794, 0.027601782232522964, 0.1674770563840866, -0.3968375027179718, 0.5329739451408386, 0.19864583015441895, 0.014309686608612537, 0.026689404621720314, -0.36839988827705383, -0.08709773421287537, -0.26827701926231384, 0.9550415277481079, 0.856079638004303, 0.06960802525281906, 0.41674670577049255, 0.1642458140850067, 0.16525541245937347, -0.0692984014749527, 0.15006370842456818, -0.2003324031829834, -0.5134149193763733, -0.9710877537727356, -0.19762085378170013, 0.23337417840957642, 0.35636159777641296, -0.5595725178718567, 0.5921216011047363, -0.15807241201400757, -0.03335538133978844, -0.3324679434299469, 0.3091754913330078, 0.04104423150420189, 0.5146675109863281, 0.47563257813453674, -0.1951153576374054, -0.3637579679489136, -0.8682282567024231, -0.21587881445884705, -0.2261865884065628, -0.15661253035068512, 0.09370516240596771, 0.2671537399291992, -0.24449007213115692, 0.7416464686393738, -0.8371648192405701, 0.1496386080980301, -0.377106636762619, 0.4042682349681854, -0.08452221751213074, 0.3798123300075531, 0.2679879367351532, -0.43579205870628357, 0.11564595997333527, -0.005517485551536083, -0.5989953875541687, -0.3754200041294098, -0.40310728549957275, -0.14993759989738464, -0.11325500160455704, 0.775407075881958, -0.47952327132225037, 0.5114683508872986, 0.1581072062253952, -0.2998621165752411, 0.06279167532920837, -0.11034390330314636, -0.007672127336263657, -0.36710450053215027, 0.07228398323059082, -0.000504076830111444, -0.26024681329727173, -0.4929703176021576, -0.21611130237579346, 0.05036591738462448, -0.1393979787826538, -0.015202878043055534, 0.30576902627944946, -0.4541665315628052, -0.5578469634056091, -0.1677771359682083, 0.01939087174832821, -0.0023614189121872187, 0.6578753590583801, -0.07790477573871613, 0.4670282006263733, 0.5036283135414124, -0.35201454162597656, 0.18701204657554626, 0.0799405574798584, -0.40844351053237915, 0.0016630578320473433, -0.4900875389575958, -0.0074721756391227245, -0.11502819508314133, -0.21926799416542053, -1.0932021141052246, -0.31371408700942993, 0.05298900231719017, -0.255969375371933, 0.5201568603515625, -0.2650579512119293, -0.5056955218315125, -0.16442814469337463, 0.009220895357429981, 0.3841688632965088, 0.3072582483291626, -0.5333682298660278, 0.12341560423374176, 0.5670642852783203, -0.16863058507442474, -0.2208070009946823, -0.6610904335975647, -0.06914685666561127, 0.04246286675333977, -0.5086416006088257, -0.04491519555449486, 0.38508519530296326, -0.0662141889333725, 0.21977229416370392, -0.01512951124459505, -0.43477150797843933, 0.41290077567100525, 0.5559019446372986, 0.12187343835830688, -0.16351398825645447, 0.29902383685112, 0.35471227765083313, -0.3369160294532776, 0.0843532457947731, -0.2884197533130646, 0.27529531717300415, -0.04447494447231293, -0.4447036683559418, -0.3896031975746155, 0.2663944661617279, 0.7003931403160095, -0.08799703419208527, 0.3436098098754883, 0.5807272791862488, -0.5080578327178955, -0.18407081067562103, -0.12790052592754364, -0.1365395486354828, -0.4505162835121155, 0.5998162627220154, -0.17185357213020325, -1.3600647449493408, 0.5363985896110535, -0.3444802761077881, -0.5042421817779541, 0.6231695413589478, 0.49824100732803345, 0.0791262537240982, 1.3024208545684814, 0.9708312749862671, -0.057873137295246124, 0.5530680418014526, 0.03484174609184265, 0.6325401663780212, -0.6278499960899353, -0.15032263100147247, -0.6318114399909973, -0.2755850553512573, -0.7812203764915466, -0.2175186574459076, 0.487232506275177, 0.21684132516384125, -0.3365193009376526, 0.488713800907135, -0.4606096148490906, 0.4889983832836151, 0.2883342504501343, 0.17327922582626343, 0.19353574514389038, 0.023689275607466698, -0.15167294442653656, -0.14152853190898895, -0.7862326502799988, -0.24663439393043518, 0.7230585813522339, 0.3637463450431824, 1.0533511638641357, -0.15156540274620056, 0.2605462074279785, 0.26531556248664856, 0.16454830765724182, -0.7576451897621155, 0.3006308972835541, -0.16423797607421875, -0.419924259185791, -0.6121143698692322, -0.4414149820804596, -0.960319995880127, -0.07625846564769745, -0.23960305750370026, -1.353386402130127, 0.5704447627067566, 0.20014090836048126, -0.2617688477039337, 0.28090646862983704, -1.019851803779602, 1.232241153717041, -0.0816853865981102, -0.32192689180374146, -0.33798927068710327, -0.49532005190849304, 0.5541706085205078, 0.008741658180952072, 0.23851285874843597, 0.10368498414754868, 0.21037960052490234, 0.27581289410591125, -0.658682107925415, 1.189339280128479, 0.12736938893795013, 0.2723362445831299, 0.3567185401916504, 0.4042474925518036, 0.314397931098938, 0.1331080198287964, 0.1474258005619049, 0.22471746802330017, -0.24503193795681, -0.2512027621269226, -0.8405101895332336, 0.9434716105461121, -0.7487292289733887, -0.3474475145339966, -0.09414434432983398, -0.7848907709121704, -0.1843690723180771, 0.2628268301486969, 0.079786017537117, 0.6419131755828857, -0.1285572648048401, -0.2845209538936615, 0.7623103260993958, -0.20105059444904327, 0.3960047662258148, 0.064032182097435, 0.10347337275743484, 0.034948889166116714, 1.1656489372253418, 0.19426794350147247, 0.15346238017082214, 0.47392407059669495, 0.011241315864026546, -0.17269489169120789, -0.5353600978851318, -0.4095422029495239, 0.038046445697546005, -0.6960042119026184, 0.027273790910840034, -0.8626989126205444, -0.4172278344631195, -0.3425396978855133, -0.22017189860343933, -0.31078171730041504, -0.9642602801322937, -0.366050124168396, -0.13977965712547302, 0.45524051785469055, 0.9797167778015137, -0.16756099462509155, 0.25343602895736694, -0.6157056093215942, 0.37609562277793884, 0.6096214056015015, 0.5310662388801575, 0.23899778723716736, -0.45369279384613037, -0.49055272340774536, -0.3038570284843445, -0.27608850598335266, -0.8814166188240051, 0.24694253504276276, -0.010120227932929993, 0.5125263929367065, 0.4478107690811157, -0.2136201113462448, 0.9220736026763916, -0.5569607615470886, 0.5404689311981201, 0.013394974172115326, -1.5047258138656616, 0.6813278794288635, -0.11078083515167236, 0.041560713201761246, 0.20316334068775177, 0.42041805386543274, -0.2623293101787567, -0.4487968981266022, -0.6179609298706055, -0.7895673513412476, 0.9803137183189392, 0.30384644865989685, -0.010618259198963642, -0.09212860465049744, 0.4549260139465332, -0.19364188611507416, 0.06902190297842026, -0.5515047907829285, -0.24555964767932892, -0.35281312465667725, -0.14314864575862885, -0.026042642071843147, -0.45362722873687744, 0.088570237159729, -0.4358726143836975, 0.19474977254867554, -0.20221643149852753, 0.1423744559288025, 0.11018914729356766, -0.2683701813220978, -0.4627031981945038, 0.3393096625804901, 0.5665139555931091, 0.8509600162506104, -0.27840855717658997, 0.5019445419311523, 0.04851526394486427, -0.49086713790893555, -0.043252501636743546, 0.17457923293113708, -0.39685672521591187, -0.03022458404302597, 0.7997408509254456, 0.9427236318588257, 0.6238654851913452, -0.5620831251144409, 0.43304723501205444, -0.03639855608344078, 0.04794418811798096, 0.03506305068731308, 0.17748697102069855, 0.11970390379428864, 0.1825972944498062, -0.12795983254909515, 0.3169122040271759, 0.6597247123718262, -0.6833308339118958, 0.14424610137939453, 0.22114135324954987, -0.7955991625785828, -0.5563797950744629, 0.7020928859710693, -0.02101828344166279, 0.03403612598776817, 0.5315057635307312, -0.12086532264947891, -0.3238731920719147, 0.5595542788505554, 0.38513192534446716, 1.1304502487182617, -0.057506758719682693, 0.31497785449028015, 0.36913251876831055, 0.7249566912651062, -0.012487373314797878, -0.13473905622959137, -0.29162687063217163, -0.6971384882926941, -0.6356506943702698, -0.5017288327217102, -0.1101335883140564, 0.19878405332565308, -0.7070466876029968, 0.2984807789325714, -0.529743492603302, 0.21187818050384521, 0.6425969004631042, -0.518204927444458, -0.33745792508125305, -0.1518903225660324, -0.11280149966478348, 0.6001672744750977, -1.2688120603561401, 1.031976580619812, 0.5533178448677063, -0.3961693048477173, -0.7739245891571045, -0.1048169806599617, 0.1528250128030777, -0.8386375904083252, 0.9218544363975525, -0.2131434679031372, -0.12021398544311523, -0.11264894902706146, -0.6201716661453247, -0.8738946318626404, 0.8163557648658752, 0.5998113751411438, -0.4126012325286865, 0.21510884165763855, -0.01842348650097847, 0.5826126933097839, -0.13815727829933167, 0.46244388818740845, 0.8059831857681274, 0.24587053060531616, 0.163859561085701, -0.8081837892532349, 0.3466237187385559, -0.018038973212242126, 0.1432172805070877, 0.5915130972862244, -0.38051837682724, 1.0767054557800293, -0.2819962501525879, -0.2522279918193817, -0.11274732649326324, 0.35141393542289734, -0.22991299629211426, 0.25899314880371094, 0.4695616066455841, 0.36715611815452576, 0.7074431777000427, -0.05041280388832092, 0.8999841213226318, -0.12771399319171906, 0.5757344365119934, 1.068942666053772, -0.19235727190971375, 0.46199995279312134, 0.36036521196365356, -0.20844495296478271, 0.6059677004814148, 0.5542694926261902, 0.24622076749801636, 0.48518645763397217, 0.24636323750019073, -0.19390633702278137, -0.6763364672660828, 0.054823264479637146, 0.17511123418807983, 0.341012179851532, 0.6355791091918945, -0.46342119574546814, -0.4422561228275299, -0.194338858127594, -0.10624586045742035, -0.0880911722779274, -0.42920470237731934, 0.5317785143852234, 0.10681707412004471, -0.390555202960968, 0.4688420295715332, 0.1219702661037445, -0.0046114688739180565, -0.4393693208694458, -0.4748569130897522, -0.04812311381101608, 0.10728781670331955, -0.5022833347320557, -0.89141446352005, 0.6268093585968018, 0.015479014255106449, -0.475763201713562, -0.27575773000717163, 1.0440070629119873, -0.1269281506538391, -0.4694966673851013, 0.33086660504341125, 0.2872069776058197, -0.006803733296692371, -0.057600848376750946, -0.5511026382446289, 0.10267966985702515, -0.057684801518917084, -0.04805564507842064, 0.48563843965530396, 0.8373842835426331, -0.613878607749939, 0.6694228053092957, 0.4738287031650543, 0.05041144788265228, 0.07040462642908096, 0.33638516068458557, 1.0971002578735352, -0.8562377095222473, -0.2673366665840149, -0.5887819528579712, 0.3922324478626251, 0.11874502152204514, -0.07270260155200958, 0.4599999487400055, 0.21999795734882355, 0.6784580945968628, 0.032106902450323105, 0.7307308316230774, -0.1576157957315445, 0.341962605714798, -0.6750451922416687, 0.6225754022598267, -0.25754299759864807, 0.46631112694740295, -0.322152316570282, -0.526229977607727, -0.3712063133716583, 0.6035202741622925, -0.16352862119674683, -0.0761076882481575, 0.9842348098754883, 0.9267061948776245, -0.33739811182022095, 0.12459232658147812, 0.3994057774543762, 0.5746632814407349, -0.023499928414821625, 0.5467125177383423, 0.7687722444534302, -0.29392009973526, 0.4263303577899933, -0.2408541440963745, -0.3365131914615631, -0.03358210250735283, -0.7038969397544861, -1.0249531269073486, -0.7108455300331116, -0.32881301641464233, -0.26116663217544556, -0.06991784274578094, 0.54886394739151, 0.7013198137283325, -1.051723599433899, -0.3040505051612854, -0.49315229058265686, 0.9865306615829468, -0.3206897974014282, -0.28391581773757935, 0.5423523783683777, -0.7620736956596375, -0.37512651085853577, 0.26255640387535095, 0.6898224949836731, -0.36207637190818787, -0.3174572288990021, 0.19796393811702728, -0.07168859988451004, -0.25584694743156433, 0.6534416675567627, 0.5371079444885254, -0.6515030264854431, -0.6509820818901062, -0.14160200953483582, 0.2286195009946823, -0.3007107079029083, 1.423676609992981, -0.658534824848175, 0.5307936072349548, 0.659857451915741, 0.4203893542289734, 0.53664630651474, -0.4346524477005005, 0.306079238653183, -0.7062010765075684, 0.4537626802921295, -0.1467231810092926, 0.5919713377952576, 0.14465199410915375, -0.47378671169281006, 0.3756241798400879, 0.6620549559593201, -0.5965865850448608, -0.6337676644325256, 0.23743918538093567, -1.1971771717071533, -0.318075031042099, 0.7213440537452698, -0.14088121056556702, -0.3299076557159424, -0.659063458442688, 0.05873141810297966, 0.05554625764489174, -0.024322770535945892, 0.651408314704895, 0.47039052844047546, -0.5945980548858643, -0.4680359661579132, -0.8203851580619812, 0.5727186799049377, 0.08263982832431793, -0.6755661964416504, 0.2713529169559479, 0.6615123152732849, 0.3477397561073303, 0.14201198518276215, 0.5207038521766663, -0.2744256556034088, 0.17467039823532104, 0.1468989998102188, 0.04361491650342941, 0.10977666825056076, -0.5163902640342712, -0.4896225929260254, 0.01905914582312107, 0.29119807481765747, 0.15503151714801788 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19634v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19634v1
Asymmetric and trial-dependent modeling: the contribution of LIA to SdSV Challenge Task 2
2024-03-28T17:49:31
2024-03-28T17:49:31
Pierre-Michel Bousquet, Mickael Rouvier
cs.SD
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
The SdSv challenge Task 2 provided an opportunity to assess efficiency and robustness of modern text-independent speaker verification systems. But it also made it possible to test new approaches, capable of taking into account the main issues of this challenge (duration, language, ...). This paper describes the contributions of our laboratory to the speaker recognition field. These contributions highlight two other challenges in addition to short-duration and language: the mismatch between enrollment and test data and the one between subsets of the evaluation trial dataset. The proposed approaches experimentally show their relevance and efficiency on the SdSv evaluation, and could be of interest in many real-life applications.
[ 0.08777059614658356, -0.3943536579608917, 0.6047765016555786, 0.24536852538585663, 0.08531317114830017, -0.19214396178722382, -0.0947931557893753, -0.28721028566360474, -0.051167119294404984, 0.4564499258995056, -0.4897664189338684, 0.013465260155498981, -0.5897405743598938, 0.22060421109199524, -0.6310581564903259, 0.5647845268249512, -0.19392099976539612, 0.3652229309082031, -0.5097603797912598, -0.40470290184020996, -0.8100055456161499, -0.0998130738735199, -0.7680333852767944, -0.29268747568130493, 0.167292982339859, 0.2574199140071869, 0.17110972106456757, 0.5677920579910278, 0.4769807755947113, 0.29206496477127075, -0.24865201115608215, -0.13839653134346008, -0.07755942642688751, 0.2295273095369339, -0.41946539282798767, -0.4851055145263672, 0.08610089123249054, 0.17345130443572998, 1.0357481241226196, 0.8022571802139282, -0.3587041199207306, 0.05521296337246895, -0.009792259894311428, 0.7025424838066101, -0.5587438344955444, -0.12879250943660736, -0.6511481404304504, -0.1955118626356125, -0.4570891857147217, -0.1852513700723648, -0.6264855861663818, -0.07518354803323746, 0.26208773255348206, -0.3013952970504761, 0.4271392822265625, -0.1745656430721283, 0.9603387713432312, 0.27200430631637573, -0.7099540829658508, -0.5294675827026367, -0.997748076915741, 0.862567126750946, -0.29163849353790283, 0.5733898282051086, 0.22649934887886047, 0.4819730222225189, -0.3782249391078949, -0.3249627947807312, -0.3813011348247528, -0.521864116191864, 0.1244916096329689, 0.11386318504810333, -0.21044369041919708, -0.194009467959404, 0.4991439878940582, 0.17977721989154816, -0.5368615984916687, 0.3484208881855011, -0.6702796816825867, -0.32890018820762634, 0.7249175906181335, 0.2027227133512497, 0.10061608254909515, -0.2367541790008545, -0.3313574194908142, -0.09799827635288239, -0.7497244477272034, 0.37567368149757385, 0.3935853838920593, 0.6627638936042786, -0.17656120657920837, 0.8128629922866821, -0.27185583114624023, 0.5761080384254456, -0.5278222560882568, -0.1707850992679596, 0.35556721687316895, -0.5229586362838745, -0.03786350041627884, -0.09355975687503815, 0.6305735111236572, -0.06696552038192749, -0.06609244644641876, 0.05659756809473038, -0.37415704131126404, 0.2621786594390869, -0.06797490268945694, -0.5329104661941528, -0.18251296877861023, 0.09397809207439423, -0.4070645868778229, -0.03648053854703903, 0.19628487527370453, -0.5367596745491028, -0.5216935873031616, -0.2387109249830246, 0.7163128852844238, -0.30753472447395325, -0.3471973240375519, -0.06154577061533928, -0.5344681739807129, -0.10648082196712494, 0.6308689117431641, -0.6224607229232788, 0.5482019186019897, 0.29540207982063293, 0.6562930345535278, -0.5510917901992798, -0.11593510210514069, -0.9661709070205688, 0.03271575644612312, -0.24935439229011536, 0.4598007798194885, -0.19746926426887512, -0.5887881517410278, -0.022896286100149155, -0.0567927286028862, 0.10862920433282852, -0.6066574454307556, 0.4524807929992676, -0.18951165676116943, 0.13690826296806335, -0.6680232286453247, -0.6193779110908508, 0.3269695043563843, -0.10326604545116425, -0.4576875567436218, 1.1118755340576172, 0.1966932862997055, -0.7384359240531921, 0.32210609316825867, -0.46233415603637695, -0.3343357443809509, 0.4063810706138611, -0.5406652688980103, -0.3420003056526184, 0.08382540941238403, -0.3071790337562561, 0.2141731232404709, -0.570317804813385, -0.14346864819526672, -0.014810008928179741, -0.34903717041015625, 0.407446950674057, -0.2979486584663391, 1.1376584768295288, 0.009604273363947868, -0.2812967002391815, -0.1311936378479004, -1.329318881034851, -0.4813386797904968, 0.4463033080101013, -0.28524768352508545, -0.550593376159668, 0.3106108605861664, 0.14212144911289215, -0.11365238577127457, -0.03369176387786865, -0.8027560114860535, -0.07184416055679321, -0.31684014201164246, 0.14163094758987427, 0.7695368528366089, 0.006123586092144251, 0.15650108456611633, -0.09367181360721588, 0.37037143111228943, 0.08264520019292831, 0.036333680152893066, -0.13388673961162567, -0.5288993120193481, -0.8111912608146667, -0.4323902726173401, 0.6966720223426819, 0.7782288789749146, -1.0770416259765625, 0.04395219311118126, -0.04658878594636917, -0.6501733660697937, -0.16626206040382385, -0.021097909659147263, 0.5301606059074402, 0.30695897340774536, 0.18489697575569153, -0.570551335811615, -0.49187153577804565, -1.0039260387420654, -0.1028716117143631, -0.5347732305526733, -0.27266985177993774, 0.570680558681488, 0.7044461369514465, -0.2839268147945404, 1.0298821926116943, -0.4891575276851654, -0.30822208523750305, -0.04079899936914444, 0.052345819771289825, 0.057184986770153046, 0.41351622343063354, 0.612412691116333, -0.9425060153007507, -0.47694462537765503, -0.04783586412668228, -0.48528701066970825, -0.44639554619789124, 0.016845304518938065, 0.682483971118927, 0.20944055914878845, 0.7361880540847778, -0.3972691297531128, 0.6184624433517456, 0.40009188652038574, -0.45630988478660583, 0.9986111521720886, -0.31967803835868835, 0.11716090142726898, -0.6437534093856812, -0.17738759517669678, 0.06778676807880402, -0.25407806038856506, -0.9003075361251831, -0.24841046333312988, 0.053799647837877274, 0.017546851187944412, -0.5807172060012817, 0.4948708117008209, -0.3191066086292267, -0.5506283044815063, -0.0842590257525444, 0.3083506226539612, -0.25049668550491333, 0.029775267466902733, -0.18156315386295319, 0.8047958612442017, 0.5654399991035461, -0.7881171703338623, 0.5395166277885437, 0.24314209818840027, -0.5963005423545837, 0.5826570987701416, -0.7794494032859802, 0.061650823801755905, -0.10604298114776611, 0.11313071101903915, -1.0462472438812256, -0.15529046952724457, 0.1354660540819168, -0.2796154320240021, 0.25022193789482117, 0.02176617458462715, -0.5025008916854858, -0.3029562532901764, -0.01674649491906166, 0.48414140939712524, 0.3715441823005676, -0.27922290563583374, 0.4771362245082855, 0.32805582880973816, -0.2233138084411621, -0.4310973286628723, -0.5640571713447571, -0.16702952980995178, -0.23562736809253693, -0.2715468108654022, 0.543213963508606, 0.03093286231160164, -0.4910367429256439, -0.2070058137178421, -0.02904675342142582, 0.0881960466504097, 0.11688850820064545, 0.396085649728775, 0.3123675286769867, -0.026295483112335205, 0.2282261848449707, -0.13656605780124664, -0.03211995214223862, -0.11774326860904694, 0.33866962790489197, 0.16074097156524658, 0.11913391202688217, -0.6901675462722778, -0.7648721933364868, 0.5296942591667175, 0.354131817817688, -0.016958970576524734, 0.5213958024978638, 0.38531678915023804, -0.5456765294075012, -0.1452367901802063, -0.7077297568321228, 0.07784213870763779, -0.48556557297706604, 0.456953227519989, -0.6014211773872375, -0.9982908368110657, 0.4788896441459656, 0.04269306734204292, -0.29667407274246216, 0.6073740720748901, 0.6929331421852112, -0.06573251634836197, 0.6210969686508179, 0.7737394571304321, 0.2907632887363434, 0.6998077630996704, 0.2415306121110916, -0.08340369164943695, -0.6974830031394958, -0.2474748194217682, -0.8443949818611145, 0.25228986144065857, -0.5807285308837891, -0.3662390410900116, 0.32538703083992004, -0.016789723187685013, 0.006077040918171406, 0.7695215344429016, -0.2919067442417145, 0.2660815119743347, 0.358345091342926, 0.012654529884457588, -0.03976646810770035, -0.49690675735473633, -0.1683407574892044, -0.330696702003479, -0.537572979927063, -0.21406225860118866, 1.076937198638916, 0.6275860071182251, 0.42384734749794006, 0.32398226857185364, 0.5512229800224304, 0.4844724237918854, -0.03032241389155388, -0.5491694211959839, 0.7434564828872681, -0.41513410210609436, -0.44007349014282227, -0.6807335019111633, -0.6759878396987915, -0.814541220664978, -0.03136385232210159, 0.04617761820554733, -1.2284719944000244, 0.5057626962661743, -0.11319182068109512, -0.3975076675415039, -0.3589097857475281, -0.5730611085891724, 0.7485511898994446, -0.05353691428899765, -0.13879568874835968, -0.14405831694602966, -0.6025545597076416, 0.09353834390640259, -0.0045014480128884315, 0.1837230771780014, -0.31621024012565613, 0.35095012187957764, 1.107098937034607, -0.13889309763908386, 0.4596498906612396, -0.41925325989723206, 0.028644761070609093, 0.40923580527305603, -0.015840638428926468, 0.6289730668067932, 0.0896930918097496, 0.0727974995970726, -0.2350279837846756, 0.34391331672668457, -0.260312557220459, -0.4280245304107666, 0.47316956520080566, -0.8388967514038086, -0.5512858629226685, -0.5216458439826965, -0.49498289823532104, -0.3077574074268341, 0.12888041138648987, 0.1374804973602295, 0.47937583923339844, -0.552179217338562, 0.39088255167007446, 0.6783438920974731, -0.27744412422180176, 0.2922855615615845, 0.7147175073623657, -0.33979931473731995, -0.24337084591388702, 0.9857189059257507, 0.20956352353096008, 0.5023587942123413, 0.1962718665599823, -0.016122113913297653, -0.21154999732971191, -0.6189271807670593, -0.2908943295478821, 0.2202371060848236, -0.8830388188362122, -0.06360270082950592, -0.5338047742843628, -0.3392133414745331, -0.46557456254959106, 0.21817505359649658, -0.7935327291488647, -0.5359815359115601, -0.4882011413574219, 0.30122727155685425, -0.05314096063375473, 0.8531349301338196, -0.04232647269964218, 0.36520513892173767, -0.43618208169937134, 0.3461841940879822, 0.6332212686538696, 0.05546979233622551, -0.5015007257461548, -0.6978468298912048, -0.27259814739227295, -0.027683090418577194, -0.25494807958602905, -1.0362650156021118, -0.051132701337337494, 0.18822376430034637, 0.7295989990234375, 0.4448595643043518, -0.26625698804855347, 0.4558272361755371, -0.5616604089736938, 1.0180997848510742, 0.2819395661354065, -1.1864192485809326, 0.7995203137397766, -0.2427198886871338, -0.2603665888309479, 0.5432056188583374, 0.18746787309646606, -0.3170837163925171, -0.020237471908330917, -0.562619149684906, -0.6026961207389832, 0.8615328669548035, 0.7341158390045166, -0.23874600231647491, 0.4912773072719574, 0.5067522525787354, 0.0988023579120636, 0.05362650752067566, -0.5793967247009277, -0.34043949842453003, 0.1366637498140335, 0.24374035000801086, -0.11696925014257431, -0.6015862226486206, -0.3078767657279968, -0.14313609898090363, 0.8447586894035339, 0.10208849608898163, 0.23835834860801697, 0.1200309544801712, -0.022610565647482872, -0.004228859208524227, 0.2834935784339905, 0.830923855304718, 0.4365665912628174, -0.3677883446216583, -0.11749543249607086, 0.6011596918106079, -0.24561193585395813, 0.32178929448127747, 0.2208547294139862, -0.13860926032066345, 0.4370756149291992, 0.19942857325077057, 0.9588340520858765, -0.08216975629329681, -0.7422517538070679, 0.9712370038032532, -0.17108306288719177, -0.27346450090408325, -0.5051406025886536, 0.1147337332367897, -0.1929665356874466, 0.5318593382835388, 0.5214899778366089, 0.1905573010444641, 0.22872093319892883, -0.5222514867782593, 0.25162777304649353, 0.5001076459884644, -0.5834571123123169, -0.26562100648880005, 0.6322311758995056, 0.025354404002428055, -0.7067449688911438, 0.41578683257102966, -0.561798632144928, -0.5076664686203003, 0.7210437059402466, 0.7202016115188599, 0.6633170247077942, -0.7284173965454102, 0.19890731573104858, 0.06002561002969742, 0.182578906416893, -0.49155837297439575, 0.24517235159873962, -0.03828703612089157, -0.8659798502922058, -0.003193782176822424, -0.4748973846435547, -0.6459218859672546, 0.05602903291583061, -0.9795449376106262, 0.908154308795929, -0.0012890782672911882, -0.23528596758842468, 0.45886364579200745, -0.07227455079555511, -0.6995005011558533, 0.21389997005462646, 0.2482464760541916, 1.0012226104736328, -1.4083329439163208, 0.8896479606628418, 0.5974618196487427, 0.12386716902256012, -0.4022150933742523, -0.23407511413097382, 0.17958956956863403, -0.23602814972400665, 0.8052854537963867, 0.0697219967842102, -0.016158098354935646, -0.449556440114975, -0.10864007472991943, -0.8136274218559265, 1.227346658706665, 0.28909802436828613, -0.42454981803894043, 0.06976473331451416, 0.08224685490131378, 0.5510376691818237, -0.4517551362514496, 0.07018821686506271, 0.6354957818984985, 0.019959425553679466, 0.3457099497318268, -1.3167027235031128, -0.12497448921203613, -0.2785853445529938, 0.5636112689971924, -0.13452690839767456, -0.5847124457359314, 0.8888479471206665, -0.017630532383918762, -0.29731687903404236, 0.36777830123901367, 1.094124436378479, 0.6349730491638184, 0.5072741508483887, 0.8249909281730652, 0.22904138267040253, 0.5403236150741577, -0.17133016884326935, 0.7509180307388306, 0.27319079637527466, 0.4137745499610901, 1.048448085784912, -0.6177388429641724, 0.7799216508865356, 0.6053816676139832, -0.8085163235664368, 0.2670357823371887, 0.44186538457870483, -0.19194723665714264, 0.7363495230674744, 0.41643252968788147, -0.21633946895599365, -0.00859210453927517, -0.4272145628929138, -0.42891770601272583, 0.7592775821685791, 0.614094078540802, -0.1087767630815506, 0.03746030479669571, 0.34118956327438354, -0.5230646133422852, -0.005252534989267588, -0.014588825404644012, 0.2641849219799042, 0.09628762304782867, -0.352309912443161, 0.07158906757831573, 0.2891583740711212, 0.3178958594799042, -0.6110977530479431, 0.08165314048528671, 0.3027758002281189, 0.3398439884185791, 0.04526415467262268, -0.32956892251968384, 0.3297053277492523, -0.12143725156784058, -0.010499651543796062, -0.20840398967266083, 0.7661779522895813, -0.3625171482563019, -0.3481660783290863, 0.20593008399009705, 0.3595707416534424, 0.19377459585666656, 0.13673654198646545, -0.46021541953086853, 0.44099822640419006, 0.057108841836452484, -0.17573334276676178, 0.16461685299873352, 0.39370909333229065, -0.11246225982904434, 0.7486041188240051, 0.3276791572570801, 0.25725165009498596, -0.18417413532733917, 0.19799157977104187, 0.6288380026817322, -0.3280832767486572, -0.5449526309967041, -0.7735875844955444, 0.4332086145877838, 0.07507573068141937, -0.38743922114372253, 0.8747701644897461, 0.6926810145378113, 0.7130067944526672, 0.011252614669501781, 0.606369137763977, -0.07419006526470184, 0.9285171627998352, -0.34298402070999146, 0.49904680252075195, -0.7350465059280396, 0.45437902212142944, -0.5427998304367065, -0.6689842939376831, -0.06592507660388947, 0.39596790075302124, -0.026077529415488243, -0.14617523550987244, 0.7320374250411987, 0.7463270425796509, 0.25885075330734253, -0.1116478219628334, 0.25861620903015137, 0.06535732746124268, 0.5122978091239929, 0.5460702776908875, 0.8600667119026184, -0.8302855491638184, 0.2799861431121826, -0.15566298365592957, -0.40766406059265137, -0.3540637493133545, -0.7296191453933716, -0.9953996539115906, -1.197840929031372, -0.6891081929206848, -0.6222863793373108, 0.17963606119155884, 0.9797946810722351, 0.1586538702249527, -1.1199299097061157, -0.45523887872695923, -0.13311932981014252, -0.02927907183766365, -0.3248215615749359, -0.15665090084075928, 0.40332499146461487, 0.34917813539505005, -0.5789135694503784, 0.6935203671455383, 0.5334994196891785, 0.555249810218811, -0.2533370852470398, -0.055104635655879974, -0.12218034267425537, 0.1300085037946701, 0.3660927414894104, 0.2989468276500702, -0.762152373790741, -0.5247939229011536, -0.1400880366563797, -0.2139049470424652, -0.13369199633598328, 0.7674709558486938, -0.6090198755264282, 0.5151177048683167, 0.45083752274513245, 0.5539738535881042, 0.6622520685195923, -0.21068024635314941, 0.45376697182655334, -0.831863522529602, 0.5078831911087036, 0.20746400952339172, 0.5497368574142456, 0.39297032356262207, -0.10802199691534042, 0.5681426525115967, 0.7259854674339294, -0.5317116379737854, -1.5135363340377808, 0.506417989730835, -1.2380397319793701, 0.04367920011281967, 1.397800087928772, -0.21578626334667206, 0.10047309100627899, -0.2606370449066162, -0.020280588418245316, 0.350736528635025, 0.027593528851866722, 0.7369468808174133, 0.9531448483467102, -0.18288862705230713, -0.21149542927742004, -0.7299253344535828, 0.524726390838623, 0.4584006369113922, -0.6773287653923035, -0.21697846055030823, 0.12805569171905518, 0.2959020435810089, 0.38748985528945923, 0.8777549862861633, 0.10900264978408813, 0.43870750069618225, 0.31156641244888306, -0.20087747275829315, 0.09361203014850616, -0.5692561268806458, -0.33951514959335327, -0.044137269258499146, 0.035021401941776276, -0.3732185661792755 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19631v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19631v1
Retrieval-Enhanced Knowledge Editing for Multi-Hop Question Answering in Language Models
2024-03-28T17:47:19
2024-03-28T17:47:19
Yucheng Shi, Qiaoyu Tan, Xuansheng Wu, Shaochen Zhong, Kaixiong Zhou, Ninghao Liu
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown proficiency in question-answering tasks but often struggle to integrate real-time knowledge updates, leading to potentially outdated or inaccurate responses. This problem becomes even more challenging when dealing with multi-hop questions since they require LLMs to update and integrate multiple knowledge pieces relevant to the questions. To tackle the problem, we propose the Retrieval-Augmented model Editing (RAE) framework tailored for multi-hop question answering. RAE first retrieves edited facts and then refines the language model through in-context learning. Specifically, our retrieval approach, based on mutual information maximization, leverages the reasoning abilities of LLMs to identify chain facts that na\"ive similarity-based searches might miss. Additionally, our framework incorporates a pruning strategy to eliminate redundant information from the retrieved facts, which enhances the editing accuracy and mitigates the hallucination problem. Our framework is supported by theoretical justification for its fact retrieval efficacy. Finally, comprehensive evaluation across various LLMs validates RAE's ability in providing accurate answers with updated knowledge.
[ -0.15445487201213837, -1.1957225799560547, 0.905637264251709, 0.05388566106557846, -0.007473255507647991, 0.2955649197101593, -0.10551588982343674, -0.550473153591156, 0.44894254207611084, 0.39490389823913574, -0.39758244156837463, -0.26839888095855713, -0.5212099552154541, 0.2633216381072998, -0.3086259067058563, 0.6261458992958069, 0.04661764204502106, -0.1339654177427292, -0.4115583002567291, -0.22789354622364044, -0.7081024050712585, -0.5933904051780701, -0.48701757192611694, -0.0019567718263715506, 0.6548765301704407, 0.4912838339805603, 0.8489133715629578, 0.6210818886756897, 0.6394959688186646, 0.25515955686569214, -0.5252684354782104, 0.5439136624336243, -0.3612978160381317, 0.44140565395355225, -0.24658280611038208, -0.31865689158439636, -0.7313461899757385, -0.2882404029369354, 0.8738449215888977, 0.7750588655471802, 0.11288300156593323, 0.13834568858146667, -0.1380467563867569, 0.5906320810317993, -0.7505320906639099, -0.09474556148052216, -0.8487517237663269, -0.2240951508283615, -0.049034956842660904, -0.42561668157577515, -0.4711975157260895, -0.5082788467407227, 0.05109945312142372, -0.7003796100616455, -0.11000198870897293, 0.13192299008369446, 0.7058320641517639, 0.24664363265037537, -0.486565500497818, -0.18004493415355682, -0.5160052180290222, 0.5676165223121643, -0.5620756149291992, 0.6416990160942078, 0.40546858310699463, 0.0461413748562336, -0.20251402258872986, -0.648634135723114, -0.499690443277359, -0.08907920867204666, -0.23790229856967926, -0.15846234560012817, -0.05589891970157623, 0.21369142830371857, 0.435397207736969, 0.10350237786769867, -0.45978766679763794, -0.41582170128822327, -0.2543962299823761, -0.2933104932308197, 0.40825390815734863, -0.06685394793748856, 0.3559320867061615, -0.1887998729944229, -0.2580806016921997, 0.04127553105354309, -0.6613881587982178, -0.11629500985145569, 0.07908166944980621, 0.2848535180091858, 0.4696153700351715, 0.8205155730247498, -0.36897391080856323, 0.9440432190895081, 0.08691831678152084, -0.11932812631130219, 0.335853636264801, -0.3952096402645111, -0.09092911332845688, -0.15300534665584564, 0.4861171543598175, 0.39286738634109497, 0.1078249141573906, -0.3245173394680023, -0.15656793117523193, -0.4425135552883148, 0.07132483273744583, -0.6084101796150208, 0.05215229094028473, 0.26559245586395264, -0.11172521859407425, -0.06224323809146881, 0.07730188220739365, -0.7454980611801147, -0.3147505819797516, -0.16697649657726288, 0.761895477771759, -0.43631526827812195, -0.27661165595054626, 0.36293986439704895, -0.24961362779140472, 0.09772875159978867, 0.44208142161369324, -0.3419567346572876, 0.007391053717583418, 0.6149282455444336, 0.9170866012573242, 0.15792934596538544, -0.3980799913406372, -1.0932310819625854, 0.3810281753540039, -0.3104526996612549, 0.7318817973136902, -0.8142446279525757, -0.19584093987941742, -0.2061769962310791, -0.17595981061458588, -0.2125353217124939, -0.4543861150741577, 0.35765066742897034, -1.2910810708999634, -0.033185943961143494, -0.6437757611274719, -0.8255181908607483, -0.28668299317359924, 0.5923563838005066, -0.6784077286720276, 1.02219820022583, -0.11914122849702835, -0.9774489998817444, -0.0909242257475853, -0.695565938949585, -0.418294221162796, -0.13236962258815765, 0.20555910468101501, -0.10813414305448532, 0.002859254367649555, 0.36051371693611145, 0.3691718578338623, 0.022028544917702675, 0.5598325729370117, -0.30770614743232727, -0.2900911867618561, 0.375639945268631, -0.1367744356393814, 0.5766348242759705, 0.05331027880311012, 0.31171131134033203, 0.2244008183479309, -0.6526297330856323, -0.0554748997092247, -0.06178838014602661, -0.4126525819301605, -0.5641944408416748, -0.2458566129207611, -0.37445035576820374, 0.20231331884860992, 0.2882770597934723, -0.6956707835197449, 0.42815932631492615, -0.0977194607257843, 0.050655074417591095, 0.676896333694458, 0.39864569902420044, 0.3646136224269867, -0.7339632511138916, 0.6529616117477417, -0.09817495197057724, 0.137074813246727, -0.1971157342195511, -0.5587037801742554, -0.5376027226448059, -0.14306820929050446, 0.2857859134674072, 0.5389140248298645, -0.8037194013595581, 0.11651410162448883, -0.3248280882835388, -0.24208001792430878, -0.6492377519607544, 0.11609572172164917, 0.15407845377922058, 0.7772456407546997, 0.7536364793777466, 0.032537445425987244, -0.6646764278411865, -0.5224637985229492, -0.6753542423248291, -0.13313181698322296, 0.2797780930995941, 0.26566609740257263, 0.373489111661911, -0.3739781379699707, 1.2294793128967285, -0.62840336561203, -0.08879465609788895, -0.31144076585769653, 0.017257550731301308, 0.07151546329259872, 0.34135326743125916, 0.34087470173835754, -0.7587448358535767, -0.42532363533973694, -0.17722781002521515, -0.656307578086853, -0.16836751997470856, -0.21891380846500397, -0.319813072681427, -0.27727097272872925, 0.5469139218330383, -0.7744379639625549, 0.23932349681854248, 0.310588538646698, -0.3101348280906677, 0.7884722948074341, -0.12829597294330597, 0.4724043309688568, -1.0771870613098145, 0.060949575155973434, -0.2483619898557663, -0.32289883494377136, -0.7228794097900391, 0.33019378781318665, 0.2257111370563507, 0.17212285101413727, -0.3200286328792572, 0.8722468018531799, -0.4098418056964874, -0.12570436298847198, -0.08422365039587021, 0.39345449209213257, 0.3080582916736603, 0.2581532299518585, 0.10832196474075317, 0.8145594000816345, 0.4708035886287689, -0.7804780602455139, 0.3862411081790924, 0.533460259437561, -0.23317986726760864, 0.2804233431816101, -0.527285099029541, 0.4167124927043915, -0.3611253798007965, 0.17609509825706482, -0.6638807654380798, -0.25790348649024963, 0.06500435620546341, -0.5050987005233765, 0.13070036470890045, -0.386004775762558, -0.45178666710853577, 0.14108487963676453, -0.3978235125541687, 0.4869435429573059, -0.037878457456827164, -0.6546728014945984, 0.813109815120697, 0.33569714426994324, -0.2727896571159363, -0.9591683149337769, -0.48634862899780273, 0.10526936501264572, -0.07664512097835541, -0.6702985763549805, 0.29780739545822144, -0.41295933723449707, -0.42724236845970154, 0.1605820208787918, -0.1820894181728363, -0.13982750475406647, 0.12464165687561035, -0.41990548372268677, 0.3100479245185852, -0.041697245091199875, 0.3680792450904846, 0.1762888878583908, -0.025512846186757088, -0.1038413718342781, 0.05548824369907379, 0.3613629937171936, -0.018663985654711723, -0.43744170665740967, -0.3616468608379364, 0.2361038774251938, 0.6383874416351318, -0.6094280481338501, 0.7043086886405945, 0.46284642815589905, -0.4181332588195801, 0.13950520753860474, -0.7436373233795166, -0.3347010612487793, -0.40731480717658997, 0.5586282014846802, -0.7334786653518677, -1.0808979272842407, 0.4975830018520355, -0.19460724294185638, 0.1854826658964157, 0.24545173346996307, -0.04256574437022209, -0.0859278067946434, 0.7364282011985779, 0.39215633273124695, -0.0032557419035583735, 0.46783706545829773, -0.15365749597549438, 0.22517944872379303, -1.2559558153152466, -0.29094722867012024, -0.506010890007019, -0.24945397675037384, -0.0959862545132637, -0.6862601041793823, 0.5367428064346313, 0.37348657846450806, -0.19512680172920227, 0.20820336043834686, -0.02056923881173134, 0.568854808807373, 0.44907790422439575, 0.2108704000711441, 0.7544869780540466, -0.21423624455928802, -0.1283566802740097, -0.021320240572094917, -0.8341109156608582, -0.12540572881698608, 1.102966547012329, 0.16601797938346863, 0.7828162908554077, 0.45721274614334106, 0.5155252814292908, 0.1614653319120407, 0.0707828477025032, -0.742944061756134, 0.5081307888031006, 0.32932621240615845, -0.7563763856887817, -0.2552301585674286, -0.7366421818733215, -0.44212228059768677, 0.38028284907341003, -0.4511243402957916, -0.6083997488021851, 0.19734857976436615, 0.23125244677066803, -0.5350309014320374, 0.5465283393859863, -0.48676037788391113, 0.7370067834854126, -0.21753889322280884, -0.3334151804447174, -0.26720747351646423, -0.6343934535980225, 0.46618908643722534, -0.16529437899589539, 0.4685428738594055, 0.1552865207195282, 0.04540757089853287, 0.6467204093933105, -0.20732994377613068, 0.4685940146446228, -0.19741077721118927, 0.18670117855072021, 0.20578166842460632, 0.516975462436676, 0.696857213973999, 0.18751107156276703, -0.27710962295532227, -0.23225606977939606, 0.14533013105392456, -0.14155162870883942, -0.909503161907196, 0.48338863253593445, -0.5083174705505371, -0.5383577942848206, -0.5142881274223328, -0.7809359431266785, -0.5699005126953125, 0.023181436583399773, -0.23217760026454926, 0.6905643343925476, 0.04026438668370247, 0.28809288144111633, 0.7861355543136597, -0.36920374631881714, 0.18819543719291687, 0.4124928116798401, -0.6054012179374695, -0.35518914461135864, 0.6252418756484985, 0.06427760422229767, 0.4323935806751251, 0.6507315039634705, 0.26483169198036194, -0.5789903402328491, -0.46811264753341675, -0.3556593954563141, 0.4911021590232849, -0.8134865164756775, -0.4147048890590668, -1.169490098953247, -0.2798624038696289, -0.4145270884037018, -0.10752715915441513, -0.3054119050502777, -0.5490984916687012, -0.07504149526357651, -0.24284331500530243, 0.7409754991531372, 0.7296847701072693, -0.3053506910800934, 0.30532586574554443, -1.0686297416687012, 0.5397117733955383, 0.3751484155654907, 0.477122962474823, 0.007547000423073769, -0.8430718183517456, -0.26492971181869507, 0.09069669246673584, 0.0022977625485509634, -1.1125943660736084, 0.07637249678373337, 0.3473150134086609, 0.39602068066596985, -0.05101003497838974, 0.19983570277690887, 1.110851526260376, -0.3570306599140167, 0.4221908748149872, -0.16241423785686493, -0.9141016602516174, 0.5735837817192078, -0.009630931541323662, 0.2333519607782364, 0.5676006078720093, 0.350814551115036, -0.9678547382354736, -0.2947810888290405, -0.4483675956726074, -0.655933678150177, 0.5655410289764404, -0.1852453500032425, 0.03983258828520775, -0.08284978568553925, 0.6827372908592224, -0.05469561740756035, 0.23833131790161133, -0.6411301493644714, -0.1206192895770073, 0.23799021542072296, -0.05010000616312027, 0.2886873483657837, -0.5208266973495483, 0.13063782453536987, -0.4435747563838959, 0.9814898371696472, -0.07652674615383148, 0.004818021785467863, 0.3874475061893463, -0.6551821827888489, -0.1618042141199112, 0.40070146322250366, 0.2936805188655853, 0.8965776562690735, -0.49362438917160034, 0.12598817050457, 0.24086235463619232, -0.3237227499485016, 0.02480398677289486, -0.1345534771680832, -0.40176600217819214, 0.08096214383840561, 0.48370489478111267, 0.577517569065094, 0.17675116658210754, -0.7073208689689636, 0.5078444480895996, -0.17765989899635315, 0.039396654814481735, 0.07792418450117111, -0.02148965746164322, 0.06718488782644272, 0.2662031352519989, 0.36310580372810364, 0.3446333408355713, 0.062025606632232666, -0.45144087076187134, 0.452056348323822, 0.49447107315063477, -0.11323873698711395, -0.16617897152900696, 0.5632782578468323, -0.05286640673875809, -0.2906339466571808, 0.6291964054107666, -0.2238076776266098, -0.6611372828483582, 0.20406219363212585, 0.529342532157898, 0.6461350321769714, -0.24482759833335876, 0.21428367495536804, 0.6283549666404724, 0.332734078168869, -0.12525977194309235, 0.3510376513004303, 0.18756085634231567, -0.9797840714454651, -0.8178624510765076, -0.6340470910072327, -0.4456016719341278, 0.15127748250961304, -0.6450204849243164, 0.17842279374599457, -0.3448646664619446, -0.1264076977968216, -0.4371826648712158, -0.0955532044172287, -0.3636769652366638, 0.07698703557252884, -0.42931607365608215, 0.9042802453041077, -0.7108656764030457, 0.7750018239021301, 0.7825949788093567, -0.4363236725330353, -0.7270140647888184, 0.10182587802410126, -0.07247438281774521, -0.36241263151168823, 0.4240362346172333, -0.1045590490102768, -0.309239000082016, 0.29341045022010803, -0.3349525034427643, -1.1575734615325928, 0.99498051404953, 0.4527360200881958, -0.49773311614990234, -0.12117038667201996, -0.13880178332328796, 0.1834801286458969, -0.17769353091716766, 0.4484403133392334, 0.520043134689331, 0.5062788128852844, 0.3871074914932251, -0.8607885241508484, -0.17049826681613922, -0.04311005771160126, -0.20068669319152832, -0.07485830783843994, -0.4125528335571289, 0.6540722250938416, -0.4693669080734253, 0.07287438958883286, -0.06308126449584961, 0.6696159243583679, 0.38728195428848267, 0.022108176723122597, 0.5329349637031555, 0.5303345322608948, 1.0648962259292603, 0.16310712695121765, 0.7888769507408142, -0.3708997368812561, 0.33421361446380615, 1.427800178527832, -0.19470122456550598, 0.905715823173523, 0.4139467477798462, 0.08815664798021317, 0.33480364084243774, 0.49753084778785706, 0.6450744867324829, 0.37698251008987427, -0.17914143204689026, -0.25812724232673645, -0.3550102412700653, -0.1354261040687561, -0.32572153210639954, 0.47586482763290405, 0.20202845335006714, 0.10139057040214539, -0.10601223260164261, -0.05524054914712906, 0.18656635284423828, 0.10002104192972183, -0.22385844588279724, 0.7502892017364502, -0.18921507894992828, -0.47523191571235657, 0.29020237922668457, 0.1894499659538269, 0.5582911968231201, -0.6121267080307007, -0.18372420966625214, -0.39099082350730896, -0.09646593034267426, -0.1443796455860138, -0.7686079144477844, 0.4901416003704071, 0.35003548860549927, -0.20613989233970642, -0.22420595586299896, 0.6745373010635376, -0.6888778209686279, -0.42385435104370117, 0.4827490746974945, 0.8438629508018494, -0.03733764588832855, -0.36779525876045227, -0.648284375667572, 0.25459495186805725, -0.08333782106637955, -0.17225077748298645, 0.14808227121829987, 0.3834744691848755, 0.15088388323783875, 0.9156287312507629, 0.6357206702232361, 0.35340505838394165, 0.2867584824562073, 0.1442876011133194, 0.8359167575836182, -0.6800330281257629, -0.386376291513443, -0.7146368026733398, 0.5322404503822327, -0.13040423393249512, 0.03945593908429146, 0.6615521311759949, 0.6768420338630676, 0.8409516215324402, 0.04297421872615814, 0.7819346785545349, -0.14707224071025848, 0.8593142628669739, -0.6375319957733154, 0.5305283069610596, -0.616121768951416, 0.4667029082775116, -0.5127260088920593, -1.0449633598327637, -0.4857580363750458, 0.7565087676048279, -0.24749024212360382, 0.051024965941905975, 0.7970664501190186, 1.1063283681869507, -0.13956832885742188, -0.03782268241047859, 0.2882974445819855, 0.44290435314178467, 0.2864692807197571, 0.305006742477417, 0.9330683946609497, -0.5397820472717285, 0.44970542192459106, -0.35777050256729126, -0.1471465677022934, -0.12108603864908218, -0.8327813744544983, -0.6489170789718628, -0.5325613021850586, -0.4221141040325165, -0.2709566354751587, 0.19833463430404663, 1.2189979553222656, 0.47178351879119873, -0.6014431118965149, -0.1689266711473465, 0.3929784297943115, 0.43678605556488037, -0.3098979890346527, -0.23092710971832275, 0.5622943043708801, -0.4889243245124817, -0.435073584318161, 0.7480639219284058, 0.27801313996315, -0.3387037217617035, 0.3120100796222687, -0.08690434694290161, -0.9297546148300171, 0.014872810803353786, 0.7131433486938477, 0.07422184944152832, -0.4020763039588928, -0.6593158841133118, 0.3784928619861603, 0.2374906837940216, 0.1685144603252411, 0.6291234493255615, -0.7227640151977539, 0.7683394551277161, 0.4798065423965454, 1.1416664123535156, 0.20227418839931488, 0.41410839557647705, 0.30154454708099365, -0.8624957203865051, -0.1427379846572876, 0.25625038146972656, 0.30986353754997253, 0.5136924982070923, -0.3402186930179596, 0.24719399213790894, 0.47351378202438354, -0.5494674444198608, -0.7057556509971619, 0.21709024906158447, -0.7857017517089844, -0.20652072131633759, 1.273532509803772, -0.06433219462633133, -0.10358229279518127, -0.2229485958814621, -0.23427359759807587, 0.25708118081092834, -0.1495070606470108, 0.5075027942657471, 0.7143102288246155, -0.09339693933725357, -0.2220923900604248, -0.5868563652038574, 0.469908207654953, 0.24936726689338684, -0.6666748523712158, 0.23698899149894714, 0.81824791431427, 0.42853084206581116, -0.11485762894153595, 0.7580540776252747, -0.08626731485128403, 0.2525230348110199, -0.4206715226173401, -0.00794646330177784, -0.24131456017494202, -0.7351644039154053, -0.29856985807418823, 0.08380439877510071, 0.39615800976753235, -0.020367078483104706 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19603v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19603v1
Semantic Map-based Generation of Navigation Instructions
2024-03-28T17:27:44
2024-03-28T17:27:44
Chengzu Li, Chao Zhang, Simone Teufel, Rama Sanand Doddipatla, Svetlana Stoyanchev
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
We are interested in the generation of navigation instructions, either in their own right or as training material for robotic navigation task. In this paper, we propose a new approach to navigation instruction generation by framing the problem as an image captioning task using semantic maps as visual input. Conventional approaches employ a sequence of panorama images to generate navigation instructions. Semantic maps abstract away from visual details and fuse the information in multiple panorama images into a single top-down representation, thereby reducing computational complexity to process the input. We present a benchmark dataset for instruction generation using semantic maps, propose an initial model and ask human subjects to manually assess the quality of generated instructions. Our initial investigations show promise in using semantic maps for instruction generation instead of a sequence of panorama images, but there is vast scope for improvement. We release the code for data preparation and model training at https://github.com/chengzu-li/VLGen.
[ -0.4523725211620331, -0.5466813445091248, 0.5793392062187195, -0.12051822990179062, -0.4424419105052948, -0.4239415228366852, -0.1189199760556221, -0.03416809067130089, 0.05112064257264137, 0.970452070236206, -1.0162923336029053, -1.1518555879592896, -0.6267090439796448, -0.038424301892519, -0.20577146112918854, 0.7200685143470764, -0.04101114347577095, 0.23146100342273712, -0.3962419033050537, -0.01304969284683466, -0.772469162940979, -0.004717683419585228, -0.1320822536945343, -0.14494775235652924, 0.28779467940330505, 0.7795829772949219, 0.762554407119751, 0.6772280335426331, 0.594133734703064, 0.35620787739753723, 0.4525878429412842, 0.4917633533477783, -0.36992767453193665, 0.11903437972068787, -0.23486478626728058, -0.24410738050937653, -0.1646571010351181, -0.01604115590453148, 0.583958089351654, 0.6524868607521057, 0.07439958304166794, 0.23348911106586456, -0.3063625693321228, 0.8225650787353516, -0.660505473613739, 0.6558206081390381, -0.39466798305511475, 0.18018539249897003, 0.17231538891792297, -0.6018259525299072, -0.429311066865921, -0.46147042512893677, 0.4163341820240021, -1.0634554624557495, 0.20842662453651428, 0.2926015555858612, 0.9155978560447693, 0.4273192286491394, -0.5279595255851746, -0.3927009701728821, -0.4873194992542267, 0.8349472284317017, -0.3051375448703766, 0.08786389976739883, 0.2536987364292145, 0.6572611331939697, -0.5008398294448853, -0.4395841360092163, -0.427663117647171, -0.2445829212665558, 0.19406476616859436, 0.5269454717636108, 0.20831598341464996, -0.18532788753509521, -0.058348268270492554, -0.03133310750126839, -0.6455356478691101, 0.06844979524612427, -0.6091440916061401, -0.07124821841716766, 0.6953444480895996, 0.3997630178928375, 0.5442954897880554, -0.1896516978740692, -0.9306111335754395, -0.4068913757801056, -1.0627906322479248, -0.19280408322811127, -0.04784777760505676, 0.3654498755931854, -0.10269458591938019, 0.7794219851493835, -0.5322826504707336, 1.1976341009140015, -0.15868546068668365, -0.18059185147285461, 0.20427092909812927, -0.20013080537319183, 0.13861137628555298, 0.18250787258148193, 0.5758705139160156, 1.0674889087677002, 0.36157912015914917, -0.24150526523590088, -0.22609958052635193, 0.04868512600660324, 0.6443179845809937, -0.5476258993148804, -0.32489997148513794, -0.05564099922776222, -0.24790778756141663, -0.04191310703754425, 0.32619425654411316, -0.6039974689483643, -0.26389679312705994, -0.5008966326713562, 0.4721618890762329, -0.404794842004776, 0.08454747498035431, 0.23730234801769257, -0.11070441454648972, 0.9573339223861694, 0.5555527806282043, -0.41089046001434326, 0.16999824345111847, 0.49437540769577026, 0.5917470455169678, -0.14364400506019592, -0.395429790019989, -0.5688786506652832, 0.3543839752674103, -0.3370454013347626, 0.7155925035476685, -0.4306698143482208, -0.710063636302948, 0.1431545913219452, -0.07495997101068497, -0.04257948696613312, -0.42299216985702515, 0.12154142558574677, -0.6258138418197632, 0.22073636949062347, -0.1367432326078415, -0.4935847222805023, -0.6384702920913696, 0.19946590065956116, -0.6908321976661682, 0.6179746389389038, 0.34726160764694214, -0.38245871663093567, 0.2850927710533142, -0.8168827295303345, -0.5767077207565308, 0.23564325273036957, -0.22406812012195587, -0.2705172002315521, -0.25938159227371216, 0.40688055753707886, 0.2662133276462555, -0.5265933871269226, -0.19072267413139343, 0.3281710147857666, -0.40803632140159607, 0.003746958915144205, 0.1577596813440323, 0.6099629402160645, 0.09930872917175293, -0.6615319848060608, 0.040573377162218094, -0.541386067867279, 0.08434980362653732, 0.19902867078781128, -0.36986100673675537, -0.14563457667827606, 0.14869607985019684, -0.0455198734998703, 0.21156200766563416, 0.2969614565372467, -0.586083173751831, 0.19386285543441772, -0.4377531409263611, -0.1477622091770172, 0.5055859088897705, 0.17608198523521423, 0.7058722972869873, -0.19261178374290466, 0.45148682594299316, 0.32929450273513794, 0.1619849056005478, -0.45946502685546875, -0.9181885719299316, -1.069364070892334, 0.03886643797159195, 0.35548636317253113, 0.6522917747497559, -1.1421695947647095, 0.5902575850486755, -0.6581240296363831, -0.49194514751434326, -0.32321396470069885, 0.10560011863708496, 0.6349920034408569, 0.6997324228286743, 0.642555296421051, -0.5466974377632141, -0.20119892060756683, -0.4842453896999359, 0.44755664467811584, 0.05842176452279091, -0.05734701082110405, 0.1831406205892563, 0.5311592221260071, -0.22261740267276764, 0.8449417352676392, -0.5329359173774719, -0.2972087562084198, -0.06114731729030609, 0.10476046800613403, -0.4494822025299072, 0.6496958136558533, 0.4434606432914734, -0.8656687140464783, 0.12157908082008362, -0.07657580822706223, -0.9179499745368958, 0.1050136536359787, -0.15614476799964905, -0.5370485782623291, 0.3044038414955139, 0.4058389365673065, -0.4110104441642761, 0.5766347646713257, 0.20700503885746002, -0.14411991834640503, 0.03547823429107666, -0.397154301404953, 0.24457868933677673, -0.8780057430267334, -0.39347580075263977, 0.027687326073646545, 0.015611296519637108, -0.3598582446575165, 0.600902795791626, -0.18691061437129974, -0.29543349146842957, -0.5768583416938782, 0.21572095155715942, -0.6435298323631287, -0.07668696343898773, -0.2764594852924347, 0.45717960596084595, 0.04283982142806053, 0.6326333284378052, 0.509036660194397, 0.1314665824174881, 0.7334055304527283, -0.6087082624435425, 0.6145510673522949, 0.36728963255882263, -0.34029731154441833, 0.380654513835907, -0.34065529704093933, 0.0031776297837495804, -0.12151653319597244, 0.3188062608242035, -1.128371238708496, -0.2512550354003906, 0.47196418046951294, -0.25313305854797363, 0.1685466766357422, -0.16731519997119904, -0.46340060234069824, -0.30477631092071533, -0.06007201224565506, 0.16242291033267975, 0.7722421288490295, -0.5950301885604858, 0.5569234490394592, 0.3194928467273712, 0.20111677050590515, -0.08463917672634125, -0.5903904438018799, -0.16122928261756897, -0.04878558963537216, -0.9683412313461304, 0.09532120078802109, 0.27526143193244934, 0.23008497059345245, -0.04255193844437599, -0.04360920563340187, -0.05479598045349121, -0.0717000663280487, 0.7299384474754333, 0.6240663528442383, -0.25213611125946045, -0.049844492226839066, 0.12989825010299683, -0.330434113740921, 0.174947127699852, -0.6657251119613647, 0.34135714173316956, -0.20222193002700806, -0.43532222509384155, -0.6880113482475281, 0.518171489238739, 0.3484009802341461, -0.47769808769226074, 0.4254387319087982, 0.48775798082351685, -0.07125928997993469, -0.20949596166610718, -0.19199486076831818, -0.14039777219295502, -0.4724074900150299, 0.024605844169855118, -0.2670869827270508, -0.3369153141975403, 0.17050309479236603, -0.718498945236206, 0.13807016611099243, 0.48711344599723816, 0.47092247009277344, -0.29158487915992737, 0.4254511594772339, 0.4082382321357727, 0.33136844635009766, 0.004514331929385662, -0.7493201494216919, 0.042560867965221405, -0.4573463499546051, -0.5636966228485107, -0.2813987731933594, -0.39193838834762573, -0.8836750984191895, -0.836395800113678, 0.6713834404945374, -0.4347107708454132, -0.17662182450294495, 0.2873920500278473, -0.802273154258728, 0.3466726541519165, 1.0137417316436768, 0.29799148440361023, 0.015437542460858822, -0.05550310015678406, -0.030831629410386086, 0.23514707386493683, -1.0649006366729736, -0.49241381883621216, 1.0819134712219238, -0.3391219675540924, 0.8868204355239868, -0.25073525309562683, 1.195583462715149, 0.22284850478172302, -0.1581277847290039, -0.6305323243141174, 0.9060614109039307, 0.24048806726932526, -0.13764840364456177, -0.47559040784835815, -0.4258076846599579, -1.1619161367416382, -0.049135733395814896, -0.5105020999908447, -0.25688812136650085, -0.1934918612241745, 0.01975570246577263, -0.3214839696884155, -0.07783801108598709, -0.9247483611106873, 0.9874899387359619, -0.25384166836738586, -0.09186313301324844, 0.08200595527887344, -1.2412673234939575, 0.18495550751686096, 0.31931987404823303, 0.08377705514431, 0.28509756922721863, -0.09296996891498566, 0.6256815195083618, -0.6395485401153564, 0.7673433423042297, -0.5325558185577393, -0.031705595552921295, 0.7290363311767578, 0.1594931185245514, 0.21363776922225952, -0.25533637404441833, 0.2878899872303009, 0.16229842603206635, -0.32290926575660706, -0.3726832866668701, -0.7060266137123108, 0.6309133172035217, -0.7147698998451233, -0.4563333988189697, -0.1572084277868271, -0.6231768131256104, 0.19744053483009338, 0.029018044471740723, 0.3519180715084076, 0.5878705978393555, 0.08916231244802475, -0.28581562638282776, 0.5310736298561096, -0.5897082686424255, 0.09841033816337585, 0.3447829782962799, 0.06795750558376312, -0.0021881379652768373, 1.4149519205093384, 0.19541698694229126, 0.0364803820848465, 0.5276300311088562, -0.004578763153403997, -0.17386192083358765, -0.539806604385376, -0.8507898449897766, -0.09200480580329895, -0.6472361087799072, -0.2235831469297409, 0.17340026795864105, -0.1997600495815277, -0.20145009458065033, -0.450173020362854, -0.5150812268257141, -0.5740019679069519, -0.05612187087535858, 0.28354206681251526, 0.2756297290325165, 0.8623605370521545, 0.08466924726963043, 0.3872956931591034, -0.7430618405342102, 0.4538964033126831, 0.23811975121498108, -0.2682657539844513, -0.22336134314537048, 0.037935029715299606, -0.2454017847776413, 0.16951769590377808, -0.44696277379989624, -0.6136215925216675, 0.07379084825515747, -0.07203030586242676, 0.3216626048088074, 0.24803796410560608, 0.34949761629104614, 0.3020670413970947, -0.7030979990959167, 0.9477190971374512, 0.29259151220321655, -0.5812997221946716, 1.1028825044631958, -0.192672997713089, 0.724485456943512, 0.13903987407684326, 0.3303129971027374, -0.02976316399872303, -0.6307252049446106, -0.6369225382804871, -0.955708920955658, 0.5177209973335266, 0.29567819833755493, -0.03996626287698746, -0.021540353074669838, 0.396852046251297, 0.08233091235160828, -0.1094844788312912, -0.09665850549936295, -0.17861202359199524, -0.4774998724460602, -0.14777474105358124, 0.13327962160110474, 0.21204742789268494, -0.29173538088798523, -0.01592392846941948, 0.39942771196365356, -0.02746412716805935, 0.3592025637626648, 0.17818444967269897, -0.32501110434532166, 0.24249528348445892, -0.2449617236852646, 0.8042041063308716, 0.5141047239303589, 0.007750869262963533, -0.07190541177988052, -0.16647933423519135, -0.2668648362159729, 0.026640424504876137, -0.07343421876430511, -0.3996970057487488, 0.14103445410728455, 0.23658569157123566, 0.6010562181472778, 0.36342963576316833, -0.5511417388916016, 0.7197315692901611, 0.2845182716846466, -0.16431738436222076, -0.2899637520313263, 0.4547581374645233, 0.07494998723268509, 0.08800587058067322, -0.06077214702963829, -0.14176048338413239, 0.2823774516582489, -0.1429779827594757, 0.14333844184875488, 0.3565515875816345, -0.051615457981824875, 0.18617179989814758, 0.5279777646064758, 0.6030095815658569, -0.21462243795394897, 0.9812366366386414, -0.23041386902332306, -0.3197738230228424, 0.5854864716529846, 0.125649556517601, 0.4637683928012848, -0.020140502601861954, 0.42145833373069763, 0.5039422512054443, 0.35768193006515503, 0.2560290992259979, 0.240592822432518, -0.55936598777771, -0.4000071585178375, -0.18288181722164154, -0.41282427310943604, -0.6220158934593201, -0.5526561737060547, -0.8881829977035522, 0.14283110201358795, -0.2111586183309555, 0.014901659451425076, -0.4141886532306671, -0.32442328333854675, -0.7756857872009277, 0.5988943576812744, 0.48945167660713196, 0.8093836307525635, -0.4515371322631836, 0.5457077622413635, 0.7007410526275635, -0.5998407602310181, -0.45437291264533997, -0.12820512056350708, -0.062454432249069214, -0.9522735476493835, 0.709282636642456, 0.1819269210100174, -0.5231401324272156, -0.20035463571548462, -0.6582193970680237, -0.3408682942390442, 1.1064085960388184, 0.13190957903862, -0.18995092809200287, -0.24946293234825134, 0.5544513463973999, 0.2017228901386261, -0.7618406414985657, -0.09867238253355026, 0.24799135327339172, 0.49289652705192566, 0.3302588164806366, -0.311942994594574, -0.031992532312870026, -0.22608734667301178, 0.5274249911308289, -0.08472024649381638, -0.478037029504776, 0.2539002299308777, -0.5279017090797424, -0.13767606019973755, 0.3996911644935608, 0.7386581897735596, 0.05810903385281563, 0.08250756561756134, 0.4353223741054535, 0.5631701350212097, 0.4362660348415375, -0.5114061236381531, 1.2608163356781006, -0.4358302354812622, -0.09527251124382019, 1.3875415325164795, 0.02768808789551258, 0.6880856156349182, 0.5744781494140625, 0.6623332500457764, 0.7686472535133362, 0.6493576169013977, -0.20509231090545654, 0.8893998861312866, 0.6482420563697815, 0.07978788018226624, -0.41323480010032654, 0.2056727260351181, -0.38305020332336426, 0.9440683722496033, 0.24152877926826477, -0.3628540337085724, -0.7121296525001526, 0.26985275745391846, -0.2934158444404602, 0.13209696114063263, -0.2696123421192169, 0.8389317989349365, -0.39474332332611084, -0.7859488129615784, 0.6610729098320007, 0.09684748947620392, 0.043929923325777054, -0.4511389136314392, -0.4789726734161377, -0.07702433317899704, -0.30504298210144043, 0.003914716653525829, -0.8557162284851074, -0.11582234501838684, -0.10851390659809113, 0.0669800341129303, -0.14396724104881287, 0.34384241700172424, -0.35623374581336975, -0.5053762197494507, -0.090388223528862, 0.5594286918640137, 0.37403202056884766, 0.2901625335216522, -0.23325598239898682, 0.02646559476852417, -0.10981522500514984, -0.2586477994918823, 0.006918987259268761, 0.48332804441452026, -0.08550916612148285, 0.6890622973442078, 0.3008618652820587, -0.18447785079479218, 0.6328579783439636, -0.0826776921749115, 0.7503324151039124, -0.6594990491867065, -0.43712306022644043, -0.21842317283153534, 0.8162745833396912, 0.057567499577999115, -0.4538341760635376, 0.5590015649795532, 0.5751579999923706, 1.1253513097763062, -0.5183137655258179, 0.5816296339035034, 0.1968076080083847, -0.20613928139209747, -0.8760893940925598, 0.7155318260192871, -0.45628753304481506, 0.007498449180275202, -0.058443617075681686, -0.6979665160179138, -0.3745618462562561, 0.6829667091369629, -0.3925459384918213, -0.16633136570453644, 0.4064132571220398, 1.144289255142212, -0.007655105087906122, 0.2010408192873001, 0.11273446679115295, -0.37187469005584717, -0.10270680487155914, 0.8569937348365784, 0.9070608615875244, -0.6411987543106079, 0.44890567660331726, -0.32040172815322876, -0.2320060133934021, -0.12366309762001038, -0.4992186725139618, -0.5613954663276672, -0.8966953754425049, -0.5046073198318481, -0.25695672631263733, 0.10174638032913208, 0.49622154235839844, 0.8096844553947449, -0.3299313485622406, -0.29436707496643066, -0.22981253266334534, 0.30512645840644836, -0.2637895345687866, -0.13340765237808228, 0.3935924470424652, -0.5459147691726685, -0.762969434261322, 0.34444043040275574, 0.31729498505592346, -0.026126809418201447, -0.3864476680755615, -0.4458032250404358, -0.12118139863014221, -0.06530676037073135, 0.49963557720184326, 0.07410305738449097, -0.741483747959137, -0.25994980335235596, -0.19126495718955994, -0.13847233355045319, 0.19709810614585876, 0.6647042632102966, -0.8326623439788818, 0.8506478071212769, 0.17460279166698456, 0.6105886697769165, 0.5967331528663635, -0.18217766284942627, 0.6012848615646362, -0.46745097637176514, 0.1017906442284584, -0.13943596184253693, 0.19312196969985962, 0.5463958382606506, -0.058888521045446396, 0.6786743402481079, -0.0365791991353035, -0.23170281946659088, -0.2681169807910919, 0.17698588967323303, -1.530773639678955, 0.0759037509560585, 1.0362991094589233, -0.36728712916374207, -0.7451172471046448, 0.3019205331802368, -0.40449589490890503, 0.3242376446723938, -0.20046953856945038, 0.7465130686759949, 0.3629950284957886, -0.11109283566474915, 0.14838339388370514, -0.36150187253952026, 0.034400824457407, -0.01793513260781765, -0.6831057667732239, -0.36765235662460327, 0.8243005275726318, 0.035843376070261, 0.47483956813812256, 0.0603654719889164, -0.3481932580471039, 0.8800522089004517, 0.26773127913475037, 0.16336606442928314, -0.10754892230033875, -0.5075174570083618, 0.24028022587299347, 0.29253748059272766, -0.30314210057258606, -0.974597156047821 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11848v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11848v1
Model Of Information System Towards Harmonized Industry And Computer Science
2024-03-28T16:53:08
2024-03-28T16:53:08
Edafetanure-Ibeh Faith, Evah Patrick Tamarauefiye, Mark Uwuoruya Uyi
cs.CY
cs.CY, cs.CL
The aim of attending an educational institution is learning, which in turn is sought after for the reason of independence of thoughts, ideologies as well as physical and material independence. This physical and material independence is gotten from working in the industry, that is, being a part of the independent working population of the country. There needs to be a way by which students upon graduation can easily adapt to the real world with necessary skills and knowledge required. This problem has been a challenge in some computer science departments, which after effects known after the student begins to work in an industry. The objectives of this project include: Designing a web based chat application for the industry and computer science department, Develop a web based chat application for the industry and computer science and Evaluate the web based chat application for the industry and computer science department. Waterfall system development lifecycle is used in establishing a system project plan, because it gives an overall list of processes and sub-processes required in developing a system. The descriptive research method applied in this project is documentary analysis of previous articles. The result of the project is the design, software a web-based chat application that aids communication between the industry and the computer science department and the evaluation of the system. The application is able to store this information which can be decided to be used later. Awareness of the software to companies and universities, implementation of the suggestions made by the industry in the computer science curriculum, use of this software in universities across Nigeria and use of this not just in the computer science field but in other field of study
[ -0.19578146934509277, -0.7835720777511597, -0.03809962794184685, 0.8025057911872864, -0.23600700497627258, -0.013933708891272545, 0.2553437054157257, -0.5096157193183899, 0.35162267088890076, 0.36324062943458557, -0.6196454763412476, -0.26209262013435364, -0.09647787362337112, -0.2060559242963791, -0.6639196872711182, 0.9870883822441101, -0.0420030876994133, 0.0413445308804512, -0.06875167042016983, 0.09055886417627335, -0.7908865213394165, -0.4070517122745514, -0.9424382448196411, -0.41642746329307556, 0.07964589446783066, 0.49752429127693176, 0.43596968054771423, 0.14632627367973328, 0.9044978022575378, 0.4067292809486389, 0.08242345601320267, -0.5717950463294983, -0.4706449806690216, 0.20122404396533966, -0.34473058581352234, -0.587206244468689, -0.3426555395126343, -0.24688278138637543, 0.50904780626297, 0.6115749478340149, -0.5968940854072571, 0.41632017493247986, 0.6037983894348145, 0.6264979243278503, -0.6225634813308716, 0.28152936697006226, -0.08809226751327515, -0.05572659149765968, -0.024787258356809616, -0.38696473836898804, -0.1005304604768753, -0.1795031577348709, 0.06482244282960892, -0.566500186920166, -0.0873136892914772, -0.09719941765069962, 0.8404190540313721, -0.1558992713689804, -0.12294390052556992, -0.5486919283866882, -1.214967131614685, 0.9536805748939514, -0.5351732969284058, 0.2538832724094391, -0.05197849124670029, 0.5574214458465576, -0.5152066946029663, -0.5081334114074707, -0.07906395941972733, 0.22340546548366547, 0.3797953724861145, 0.2270999401807785, 0.18138709664344788, -0.0986674502491951, -0.05204527825117111, 0.4246309697628021, -0.24826815724372864, -0.20286186039447784, -0.8799225091934204, -0.11979412287473679, 0.6068856120109558, 0.48880407214164734, 0.4381086528301239, -0.04181235656142235, -0.5498705506324768, -0.011129540391266346, -0.26144012808799744, 0.2522382140159607, 0.4623824954032898, 0.3571856617927551, -0.2132875919342041, 0.34916508197784424, -0.6484546661376953, 0.4428517520427704, -0.3223441541194916, -0.6322935819625854, 0.08667528629302979, -0.09419851750135422, -0.5016732811927795, 0.06351403146982193, 0.48572811484336853, 0.09604517370462418, -0.06004029139876366, 0.4156196415424347, -0.06415197998285294, 0.39934003353118896, 0.5120659470558167, -0.6289627552032471, 0.238973468542099, 0.2773347496986389, -0.7090522050857544, -0.47318708896636963, 0.0838765949010849, -0.5704038739204407, 0.02811487950384617, -0.6502244472503662, 0.5458329319953918, -0.25953683257102966, -0.40826937556266785, -0.3318445086479187, -0.34921079874038696, 0.1620633453130722, 0.7341533899307251, -0.5450900793075562, 0.37044665217399597, 0.6525477766990662, 0.8726538419723511, 0.0664767399430275, 0.019039804115891457, 0.5733502507209778, 0.2978334426879883, -0.2830246090888977, 0.5595986247062683, -0.23807886242866516, -0.5312625169754028, -0.05185827985405922, -0.08479967713356018, 0.1777298003435135, -0.2951793372631073, 0.4905141592025757, -0.5670514106750488, 0.1094573587179184, 0.2060890644788742, -0.4559892416000366, -0.35636547207832336, 0.29251670837402344, -0.2108670324087143, 0.4793478846549988, -0.0437813326716423, -0.8604878783226013, 0.24531887471675873, -0.7910602688789368, -0.09649550914764404, 0.24437254667282104, -0.37055033445358276, -0.1681082397699356, -0.3090357184410095, -0.5545456409454346, 0.23097151517868042, -0.2679876685142517, 0.5216689109802246, -0.3985093832015991, -0.6839507222175598, 0.031053587794303894, -0.17447927594184875, 1.0965795516967773, 0.7403302788734436, -0.1387658715248108, -0.14594347774982452, -0.6805594563484192, 0.07766823470592499, -0.36143216490745544, -0.6922411918640137, -0.26989296078681946, 0.25155866146087646, 0.22360920906066895, 0.04823853075504303, 0.31087541580200195, -0.5705286264419556, 0.2048724889755249, 0.005388064309954643, 0.19310732185840607, 0.5557195544242859, 0.11858829855918884, 0.25901928544044495, -0.33160772919654846, 0.5166081786155701, 0.16877348721027374, 0.6389387845993042, 0.12225114554166794, -0.22299006581306458, -0.7361037135124207, -0.16392801702022552, 0.46048545837402344, 0.8700299859046936, -0.5142605900764465, 0.21501605212688446, 0.1483684629201889, -0.4459860324859619, -0.32696324586868286, -0.07816599309444427, -0.02744520641863346, 0.36905437707901, -0.16518202424049377, -0.8639771938323975, -0.9099718928337097, -0.8222900629043579, 0.1796717494726181, -0.34932783246040344, -0.07042545825242996, -0.034756239503622055, 0.3006742000579834, -0.41815266013145447, 1.0978965759277344, -0.3997584879398346, -0.5738230347633362, -0.008848697878420353, 0.261111855506897, 0.4649152159690857, 0.5369544625282288, 0.12074717879295349, -1.0025826692581177, -0.36750683188438416, -0.20282858610153198, -1.2089210748672485, 0.06405281275510788, 0.13082216680049896, -0.21088385581970215, 0.014489653520286083, 0.2520216405391693, -0.045363929122686386, 1.0167793035507202, 0.07694057375192642, -0.0362883098423481, 0.5841939449310303, -0.11304756999015808, 0.5331491231918335, -1.1886107921600342, 0.36195018887519836, 0.12884633243083954, 0.12756288051605225, -0.5111570358276367, -0.04732741042971611, -0.39139702916145325, -0.42489930987358093, -0.10584134608507156, 0.2326846569776535, -0.3184196650981903, 0.035671114921569824, -0.8129823803901672, 0.2186744660139084, -0.09794259071350098, 0.21713626384735107, -0.2208545207977295, 0.5439831018447876, 0.729816198348999, -0.9267345666885376, 0.5222625732421875, 0.17850422859191895, -0.3778783082962036, 1.179739236831665, -0.4788326025009155, -0.4622359573841095, -0.001430027186870575, 0.2136588990688324, -0.5630881786346436, -0.18288148939609528, 0.2729508876800537, -0.5360485315322876, 0.2304919958114624, 0.13842417299747467, -0.09438464045524597, -0.5549589395523071, -0.09380057454109192, -0.10139349102973938, 0.5062047243118286, 0.022219277918338776, 0.3320371210575104, 0.5731782913208008, -0.3441261053085327, -0.7613113522529602, -0.7854629755020142, 0.2022535502910614, -0.2147022783756256, -0.9575510025024414, 0.29736199975013733, -0.06517361849546432, -0.4786034822463989, 0.0011078726965934038, 0.023498300462961197, -0.5840789675712585, 0.09731543064117432, 0.6500582695007324, 0.6154634356498718, -0.2563616931438446, -0.009696319699287415, -0.22863657772541046, 0.12353967130184174, -0.0010717181721702218, -0.1250477433204651, 0.13453997671604156, 0.021365515887737274, -0.3889608085155487, -1.0301363468170166, 0.43797293305397034, 0.38361677527427673, 0.63802170753479, 0.9629349112510681, 0.3185647428035736, -0.5458280444145203, -0.031098099425435066, -0.5372601747512817, -0.15172109007835388, -0.5438302755355835, 0.13061577081680298, -0.283851683139801, -0.43054521083831787, 0.5462890267372131, -0.5539251565933228, -0.03356729820370674, 0.25526323914527893, 0.4137701690196991, -0.16250640153884888, 0.7155183553695679, 1.1903795003890991, -0.29949095845222473, 0.7169958353042603, -0.11973879486322403, 0.3087565004825592, -0.8868153095245361, -0.4082164466381073, -0.72108393907547, -0.18743258714675903, -0.5363249182701111, 0.3784758150577545, 0.3211010992527008, 0.5709055066108704, -0.3274277448654175, 0.3534088730812073, -0.6379797458648682, 0.07226873189210892, 0.5849360823631287, 0.32550179958343506, 0.3472311496734619, 0.0666385293006897, -0.16947084665298462, 0.2697666585445404, -0.5147870182991028, -0.7197296619415283, 0.734364926815033, 0.35490304231643677, 1.1830806732177734, 0.018544141203165054, 0.6652625203132629, 0.5002129077911377, 0.35139790177345276, -0.5784425139427185, 0.45711010694503784, 0.15021750330924988, -0.743737518787384, -0.4277535080909729, -0.3239835202693939, -0.8288126587867737, -0.048286065459251404, 0.02004939690232277, -1.0681833028793335, 0.3978049159049988, 0.08239351958036423, -0.04163506254553795, 0.029688643291592598, -0.6517141461372375, 0.40289434790611267, 0.04350805655121803, -0.5914125442504883, -0.6127322912216187, -0.6020436882972717, 0.33476218581199646, -0.04953223839402199, 0.7491340637207031, 0.08416756242513657, 0.396202027797699, 0.9790784120559692, -0.4306162893772125, 0.8186332583427429, -0.069923996925354, 0.19526180624961853, 0.8870846629142761, 0.02919829450547695, -0.1231103241443634, -0.21352112293243408, -0.3337361812591553, -0.019224587827920914, 0.3793526887893677, -0.2390453815460205, -0.2629110813140869, 0.7863300442695618, -0.8851978182792664, -0.5443502068519592, -0.5107998847961426, -0.4306979477405548, -0.009797975420951843, 0.029422670602798462, 0.01731056720018387, 0.46876195073127747, -0.5994724035263062, 0.4524924159049988, 0.39877384901046753, -0.16463033854961395, 0.4191751778125763, 0.49209216237068176, -0.3881840407848358, -0.2714841365814209, 0.5613313317298889, 0.2816624045372009, 0.11217448115348816, 0.16706892848014832, -0.09818370640277863, 0.18133647739887238, -0.08135109394788742, -0.4011060893535614, -0.04456509277224541, -0.8251826167106628, -0.2792149484157562, -0.2820700407028198, -0.5477371215820312, -0.5728673338890076, -0.10918083786964417, 0.13879406452178955, -0.2852109968662262, -0.36122819781303406, 0.6089310050010681, 0.040983714163303375, 1.007279872894287, -0.2602192461490631, 0.423549622297287, -0.6274455785751343, 0.155748188495636, 0.06658995151519775, 0.5163556933403015, 0.13507544994354248, -0.4424089193344116, -0.5074701905250549, 0.10692121088504791, -0.9676694869995117, -0.8473992347717285, 0.09967408329248428, -0.14328303933143616, 0.6826258301734924, 0.6589231491088867, -0.20526613295078278, 0.4536694884300232, 0.016995476558804512, 0.5350109338760376, 0.2983053922653198, -0.9395766854286194, 0.7892026901245117, -0.44946593046188354, 0.08364948630332947, 0.4468129277229309, 0.5904236435890198, -0.8987736701965332, -0.3313908576965332, -0.8846164345741272, -0.6320948600769043, 0.8701831698417664, 0.24175022542476654, 0.05952674150466919, 0.539876401424408, 0.27652084827423096, -0.21973712742328644, 0.35017699003219604, -0.6961094737052917, 0.07150102406740189, 0.1470225304365158, -0.3407817780971527, 0.6479784846305847, -0.07746714353561401, 0.018492594361305237, 0.08359944075345993, 1.073540449142456, 0.330112099647522, 0.20078812539577484, 0.1350916177034378, 0.3107244372367859, -0.15814891457557678, 0.6188059449195862, 0.14695550501346588, 0.8230857849121094, -0.1345861852169037, -0.31104686856269836, -0.031516578048467636, -0.5878699421882629, 0.14676515758037567, -0.47624802589416504, -0.33246585726737976, -0.28485360741615295, -0.030805954709649086, 0.4346064329147339, -0.15134209394454956, -0.3111210763454437, 0.4508487284183502, 0.2450721263885498, 0.02954753115773201, -0.4148481488227844, 0.4801112115383148, 0.37113672494888306, 0.2580411434173584, 0.6222812533378601, 0.09997996687889099, 0.5346107482910156, -0.9918155074119568, 0.2017691284418106, 0.44022709131240845, -0.5012194514274597, 0.19953598082065582, 0.36889469623565674, 0.29640400409698486, -0.7357121109962463, 0.4556877315044403, 0.22918009757995605, -0.22087466716766357, 0.6902748942375183, 0.7414728403091431, 0.337131142616272, -0.8564358353614807, 0.16422809660434723, 0.45266032218933105, 0.18714652955532074, -0.3233426809310913, 0.6496235728263855, 0.058793045580387115, -0.350546658039093, 0.09819595515727997, -0.7011554837226868, -0.6110596060752869, -0.08515632152557373, -0.4213147759437561, 0.9727960228919983, -0.5098065137863159, -0.35551244020462036, -0.31483495235443115, -0.3070014715194702, -0.3251224756240845, 0.7626288533210754, -0.20231366157531738, 0.7676844596862793, -0.7310550212860107, 0.5175154805183411, 0.5121360421180725, -0.44046953320503235, -0.848896861076355, -0.685935914516449, -0.10151636600494385, -0.20143336057662964, 0.8632793426513672, -0.11643709242343903, -0.16467280685901642, -0.29863303899765015, -0.6514456272125244, -1.0988428592681885, 1.245134949684143, -0.1572214514017105, -0.7521288394927979, 0.26612281799316406, 0.027452904731035233, 0.6135088801383972, -0.4867986738681793, 0.4258124828338623, 0.05004911869764328, 0.1633947193622589, 0.5668046474456787, -1.030788540840149, -0.35707956552505493, -0.3712158203125, 0.06103382259607315, 0.3655998706817627, -0.7755662202835083, 0.8827506899833679, 0.20922766625881195, -0.41657963395118713, -0.10460834950208664, 0.56732577085495, 0.10872385650873184, 0.47378426790237427, 0.3778753876686096, 0.36827635765075684, 0.4596936106681824, 0.0851282849907875, 0.36540311574935913, -0.3007407784461975, 0.31991755962371826, 0.9421619772911072, -0.05414289981126785, 0.8858385682106018, 0.394549161195755, -0.39228692650794983, 0.833920955657959, 0.7176186442375183, -0.005526465829461813, 0.23062564432621002, 0.29400375485420227, -0.43346524238586426, 0.2993547320365906, -0.28433024883270264, -0.4458058178424835, 0.5373894572257996, 0.680495023727417, -0.2689324915409088, -0.12063660472631454, 0.41672196984291077, -0.09064911305904388, -0.27626144886016846, -0.3120679557323456, 0.7580686211585999, 0.16969595849514008, -0.5289060473442078, 0.04985351860523224, 0.4152892827987671, 0.5006213188171387, -0.8613840341567993, -0.19031348824501038, 0.15155604481697083, 0.3350431025028229, -0.4128192365169525, -0.5103793740272522, 0.604843258857727, 0.013831577263772488, -0.07658730447292328, 0.1755584478378296, 0.9975165128707886, -0.07546480745077133, -0.4087851345539093, 0.10812883824110031, 0.17055699229240417, 0.45616665482521057, 0.31995272636413574, -0.563952624797821, 0.2022838294506073, -0.11687491834163666, 0.10377886146306992, 0.16847661137580872, 0.3484748303890228, -0.34588268399238586, 0.772158682346344, 0.14013224840164185, 0.16371187567710876, -0.29180485010147095, -0.0038212789222598076, 0.5915657877922058, -0.7402045130729675, -0.8599551320075989, -0.450581431388855, 0.31671714782714844, -0.24597196280956268, -0.037003807723522186, 0.5413250923156738, 0.6777051091194153, 0.595432460308075, 0.24967560172080994, 0.9392358064651489, -0.3937772512435913, 0.44549769163131714, -0.060578685253858566, 0.5305681824684143, -0.30584007501602173, 0.34122830629348755, -0.46077510714530945, -1.0277180671691895, 0.07280945777893066, 0.5332335233688354, -0.07773277163505554, 0.09527764469385147, 0.5135138630867004, 0.6234220862388611, 0.0475926548242569, 0.6547257304191589, 0.10520962625741959, -0.1722506433725357, 0.003871574066579342, 0.08677193522453308, 0.8304678201675415, -0.7260980606079102, 0.4255758821964264, -0.18678708374500275, -0.948600172996521, -0.501209557056427, -0.6990199089050293, -0.37258341908454895, -0.514136016368866, -0.4583924114704132, -0.2320948839187622, 0.011826411820948124, 0.5671839714050293, 0.7090697884559631, -0.8609039187431335, -1.1370904445648193, -0.02667354792356491, -0.13459907472133636, -0.13453659415245056, -0.3659604489803314, -0.12142359465360641, -0.2810514569282532, -0.25333085656166077, -0.058066245168447495, 0.5051541328430176, 0.07586383819580078, -0.6250540018081665, 0.4616442918777466, -0.4449932873249054, 0.16338559985160828, 0.43882837891578674, 0.2947801649570465, -0.335111141204834, -0.18994183838367462, -0.2824060320854187, -0.38127005100250244, 0.09370297938585281, 0.7741771340370178, -0.5091400146484375, 0.24712331593036652, 0.5881591439247131, 0.12137191742658615, 0.44183269143104553, 0.04288935661315918, 0.4434342384338379, -0.29328250885009766, 0.13194049894809723, -0.12985888123512268, 0.2528980076313019, 0.29158854484558105, -0.8689581155776978, 0.549812376499176, 0.20990508794784546, -0.9707307815551758, -0.3457227051258087, 0.10653267055749893, -0.8750433921813965, -0.4787645936012268, 0.5000452399253845, 0.11220145225524902, -0.3947446942329407, -0.4672664999961853, -0.5662243366241455, 0.6675081253051758, -0.2751665413379669, 1.1531305313110352, 0.8631620407104492, -0.6095831394195557, 0.4204235076904297, -0.4655841290950775, 0.07334638386964798, -0.026263637468218803, -0.9489827752113342, -0.41041114926338196, 0.39043480157852173, 0.38840702176094055, 0.5843191742897034, 0.9486236572265625, -0.16037070751190186, 0.010474167764186859, 0.34847888350486755, 0.5001285672187805, 0.6004630923271179, -0.5391701459884644, 0.12816433608531952, 0.5129432082176208, 0.06685490161180496, -0.28059667348861694 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19559v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19559v1
Improving Adversarial Data Collection by Supporting Annotators: Lessons from GAHD, a German Hate Speech Dataset
2024-03-28T16:44:14
2024-03-28T16:44:14
Janis Goldzycher, Paul Röttger, Gerold Schneider
cs.CL
cs.CL
Hate speech detection models are only as good as the data they are trained on. Datasets sourced from social media suffer from systematic gaps and biases, leading to unreliable models with simplistic decision boundaries. Adversarial datasets, collected by exploiting model weaknesses, promise to fix this problem. However, adversarial data collection can be slow and costly, and individual annotators have limited creativity. In this paper, we introduce GAHD, a new German Adversarial Hate speech Dataset comprising ca.\ 11k examples. During data collection, we explore new strategies for supporting annotators, to create more diverse adversarial examples more efficiently and provide a manual analysis of annotator disagreements for each strategy. Our experiments show that the resulting dataset is challenging even for state-of-the-art hate speech detection models, and that training on GAHD clearly improves model robustness. Further, we find that mixing multiple support strategies is most advantageous. We make GAHD publicly available at https://github.com/jagol/gahd.
[ -0.7749948501586914, -0.9754820466041565, 0.09767724573612213, -0.3377843201160431, -0.17233945429325104, 0.08558136224746704, -0.1746574342250824, -0.5204119086265564, 0.21831440925598145, 0.34356608986854553, -0.4209551215171814, -0.276624470949173, -0.9377124905586243, -0.3513427674770355, -0.48184311389923096, 1.6317667961120605, 0.23402757942676544, 0.15270332992076874, -0.08476270735263824, -0.5724803805351257, -0.04668247699737549, -0.7302377223968506, -0.7261579632759094, -0.42133206129074097, 0.811138927936554, 0.13940860331058502, 1.1651290655136108, 0.8302156925201416, 0.3927954137325287, 0.15978601574897766, -0.2089337408542633, 0.0892341211438179, -0.5772855877876282, 0.4518567621707916, -0.008921715430915356, -0.11197631806135178, -0.16470712423324585, 0.016466369852423668, 0.23628917336463928, 0.21149641275405884, 0.04586049169301987, 0.15107205510139465, -0.12949153780937195, 0.08953141421079636, -0.5229831337928772, -0.05373021587729454, -0.5525417327880859, 0.03334226831793785, -0.7156732678413391, 0.3257776200771332, -0.15074215829372406, -0.4550614655017853, 0.22048009932041168, -0.5643487572669983, 0.6560333371162415, -0.3581240475177765, 0.6812465190887451, 0.32552796602249146, -0.12220566719770432, -0.43979766964912415, -0.7800165414810181, 0.4947873651981354, -0.5395298600196838, 0.14520569145679474, 0.3686405420303345, 0.6455162167549133, -0.06326751410961151, -0.5180270075798035, -0.5571750402450562, -0.16154636442661285, 0.20505152642726898, -0.19146788120269775, -0.58526611328125, -0.11873572319746017, 0.4762933850288391, 0.2628074288368225, -0.5186986327171326, 0.2790071964263916, -0.37336695194244385, -0.3740094006061554, 0.8837252855300903, -0.12608690559864044, 0.29881763458251953, 0.05493924021720886, -0.11361055076122284, -0.28387945890426636, -0.4976520240306854, -0.20804227888584137, 0.9407715797424316, 0.45183348655700684, 0.10100437700748444, 0.31991955637931824, 0.08162635564804077, 0.39571520686149597, -0.027415098622441292, 0.26313915848731995, 0.31598785519599915, 0.19389262795448303, 0.00903406087309122, 0.07734429836273193, 0.6421329379081726, 0.17768073081970215, 0.3714047968387604, -0.27393925189971924, -0.14994394779205322, 0.5852721333503723, 0.5249708294868469, -0.6755754947662354, -0.7783411741256714, 0.19086667895317078, -0.1671564280986786, -0.582909107208252, -0.21059182286262512, -0.9899176359176636, -1.2434383630752563, -0.07111503928899765, 0.2843780517578125, -0.4193747043609619, -0.148785799741745, -0.38436028361320496, -0.3962162137031555, -0.02206169068813324, 0.37069812417030334, -0.9487498998641968, 0.16653838753700256, 0.564370334148407, 0.8646076917648315, -0.17727185785770416, -0.07184136658906937, -0.8975385427474976, -0.10660120844841003, -0.15724308788776398, 0.6820572018623352, -0.4370628297328949, -0.31964918971061707, 0.16075390577316284, -0.33409789204597473, 0.26136839389801025, -0.5026401877403259, 0.7246044874191284, -0.6066539883613586, 0.2822677493095398, -0.1663564294576645, -0.47402751445770264, -0.2796385586261749, 0.06298406422138214, -0.8383842706680298, 0.7095967531204224, 0.062257442623376846, -0.7931162118911743, 0.4114254415035248, -0.7501973509788513, -0.6143642663955688, 0.2746325433254242, -0.28637027740478516, -0.7297645807266235, 0.15051378309726715, 0.4343087375164032, 0.45370426774024963, -0.0016393944388255477, 0.25920164585113525, -0.8603615760803223, -0.21432481706142426, 0.10773102194070816, -0.4426805377006531, 1.145126223564148, 0.3574175238609314, -0.4927242398262024, 0.2818528711795807, -0.7416793704032898, -0.4168693721294403, 0.3218682110309601, 0.016414344310760498, -0.3717806339263916, 0.136808842420578, 0.37883198261260986, 0.25187402963638306, -0.24231605231761932, -0.6540363430976868, -0.05991996452212334, -0.07193560898303986, 0.22597448527812958, 1.073372483253479, -0.09158296883106232, 0.11592898517847061, -0.4464551508426666, 0.6516460180282593, -0.07888025045394897, 0.13144277036190033, 0.1584887057542801, -0.37714627385139465, -0.7009152770042419, -0.23790062963962555, 0.12056676298379898, 0.43805837631225586, -0.7473880052566528, 0.023614106699824333, 0.08582941442728043, -0.7031664848327637, -0.751329243183136, 0.17550581693649292, 0.10490924119949341, 0.40544235706329346, 0.4847962260246277, 0.02922908589243889, -0.8012278079986572, -0.77823805809021, -0.08937233686447144, -0.1821872740983963, -0.11493177711963654, 0.2824801206588745, 0.6109651923179626, -0.1481507271528244, 0.5961943864822388, -0.16769179701805115, -0.18641480803489685, -0.22484853863716125, 0.23566216230392456, -0.3392156958580017, 0.21224480867385864, 0.6877949833869934, -1.0217509269714355, -0.3310582935810089, -0.14982634782791138, -0.711820662021637, -0.06424465775489807, 0.060634370893239975, -0.040185634046792984, 0.11666057258844376, 0.16236630082130432, -0.09236457943916321, 0.3354805111885071, 0.5517284870147705, -0.2526225745677948, 0.3939342200756073, 0.20989413559436798, -0.15065878629684448, -0.9316913485527039, -0.11015003174543381, 0.11402729153633118, -0.25788411498069763, -0.9946553707122803, 0.04431574419140816, -0.3259006440639496, -0.08116839081048965, -0.546127200126648, 0.2798722982406616, 0.030032677575945854, 0.36681172251701355, -0.45912349224090576, 0.11304561048746109, -0.45058485865592957, 0.24013718962669373, -0.2582490146160126, 0.6120948195457458, 0.6743107438087463, -0.39534881711006165, 0.8764949440956116, 0.2961830794811249, -0.11924216151237488, 0.7302148938179016, -0.5829039216041565, 0.26041272282600403, -0.30744701623916626, 0.14642533659934998, -0.7964820265769958, -0.44116219878196716, 0.5689247846603394, -0.5510185956954956, 0.17174655199050903, -0.1844099760055542, -0.4536207914352417, -0.29709744453430176, -0.4424460530281067, -0.12734821438789368, 0.32023659348487854, -0.7248050570487976, 0.4458923935890198, 0.9354758262634277, -0.2199496030807495, -0.5262309312820435, -0.632270872592926, 0.13264626264572144, -0.695188045501709, -0.3916516900062561, 0.22894887626171112, -0.00985494814813137, -0.33353984355926514, 0.06591139733791351, -0.021396849304437637, 0.06801645457744598, 0.38200223445892334, 0.38580521941185, 0.1430589109659195, 0.06371043622493744, 0.1779799610376358, -0.4117380678653717, 0.07857079803943634, 0.21809087693691254, -0.10800464451313019, 0.48556315898895264, 0.09549212455749512, -0.24930307269096375, -0.24016664922237396, 0.3547545373439789, 0.46503421664237976, -0.046019040048122406, 0.5363799333572388, 1.064860224723816, -0.5558245182037354, -0.3534482717514038, -0.5143327713012695, -0.10751742124557495, -0.3764481246471405, 0.3182837963104248, -0.008149061352014542, -0.8514781594276428, 0.6046434044837952, 0.5257952809333801, 0.27499592304229736, 0.4026459753513336, 0.5863127708435059, 0.1800389140844345, 1.3400129079818726, 0.4576137959957123, -0.5707750916481018, 0.6493387222290039, -0.21920166909694672, -0.05604825168848038, -0.3140721619129181, 0.030654288828372955, -0.36491966247558594, -0.33489489555358887, -0.45387202501296997, -0.2091914862394333, 0.10279709845781326, -0.33769601583480835, -0.250286728143692, 0.16647517681121826, -0.4706282615661621, 0.2548387944698334, 0.6979361176490784, 0.025170879438519478, -0.18981094658374786, 0.43907973170280457, 0.3328740894794464, -0.1442568153142929, -0.4387216567993164, -0.4530426859855652, 1.1644071340560913, 0.5195008516311646, 0.5319032669067383, 0.18229644000530243, 0.6082509756088257, 0.5741696953773499, 0.3780023455619812, -0.5423710346221924, 0.26501935720443726, -0.1916017085313797, -0.8775894641876221, -0.1678372025489807, -0.38597866892814636, -0.46073582768440247, 0.18745143711566925, -0.14710429310798645, -0.7766200304031372, 0.09517956525087357, 0.2365511655807495, -0.40364760160446167, 0.42986172437667847, -0.3799983561038971, 0.8558886647224426, -0.11299788951873779, -0.33185356855392456, -0.08468228578567505, -0.4843473434448242, 0.12178443372249603, -0.14432795345783234, 0.07916780561208725, -0.1454930603504181, 0.3302088975906372, 1.1820905208587646, -0.24444954097270966, 0.6846216320991516, -0.6933608055114746, -0.05708228051662445, 0.29665157198905945, -0.13888882100582123, 0.5792809724807739, -0.234268456697464, -0.20562192797660828, 0.026212114840745926, -0.47015056014060974, -0.3409459888935089, -0.5191255807876587, 0.5460644364356995, -0.6942347288131714, -0.5209171175956726, -0.4046470820903778, -0.7608277797698975, -0.296671986579895, 0.05485430732369423, 0.34754782915115356, 0.3553397059440613, -0.3005882203578949, 0.3371674716472626, 0.6526970863342285, 0.14953580498695374, 0.25733643770217896, 0.03706090524792671, 0.05176689475774765, -0.6310847401618958, 1.0390198230743408, 0.47167471051216125, 0.08084756135940552, -0.2137865573167801, 0.020915010944008827, -0.4191872477531433, -0.6992813348770142, -0.6551200151443481, -0.2425631284713745, -0.6956831812858582, -0.17244677245616913, -0.7270480394363403, -0.2001369744539261, -0.5274867415428162, -0.2399439960718155, 0.07382749766111374, -0.4388721287250519, -0.14694835245609283, -0.3355679512023926, 0.6771839261054993, 0.6904046535491943, -0.37992534041404724, 0.5394943952560425, -0.11044012010097504, 0.38914841413497925, 0.3645116686820984, 0.09255070984363556, 0.013081342913210392, -0.5661168098449707, -0.39225485920906067, 0.29674115777015686, -0.514879584312439, -0.9255837202072144, 0.29594558477401733, -0.0478106252849102, 0.5852731466293335, 0.4291324317455292, 0.09994302690029144, 0.7561110854148865, -0.23338767886161804, 0.667095959186554, -0.20453327894210815, -0.6568281650543213, 0.5578777194023132, -0.5200903415679932, -0.0882459357380867, 0.48781391978263855, 0.5401779413223267, -0.5606073141098022, -0.6260727047920227, -0.9094516634941101, -0.7813724875450134, 0.8501858115196228, 0.20542114973068237, 0.06936150789260864, 0.196652352809906, -0.17077283561229706, 0.07036953419446945, 0.0854898989200592, -0.48245716094970703, -0.5900200605392456, -0.4995932877063751, -0.25682076811790466, -0.35755276679992676, -0.14763011038303375, -0.5038445591926575, -0.07642731070518494, 0.978090763092041, 0.01729223132133484, -0.11228662729263306, -0.332873672246933, -0.18592236936092377, -0.0029219728894531727, 0.061643242835998535, 0.22123971581459045, 0.2386152744293213, -0.11850561201572418, 0.12182063609361649, 0.2334020882844925, -0.46622321009635925, 0.18730051815509796, 0.7427303194999695, -0.5014700889587402, 0.1379879117012024, 0.13957147300243378, 0.8833858370780945, -0.48439329862594604, -0.5621352195739746, 0.4253815710544586, 0.042750466614961624, -0.13897790014743805, -0.29736414551734924, 0.1827351301908493, -0.10163412243127823, 0.3753927946090698, 0.3829424977302551, -0.007703109178692102, 0.19688637554645538, -0.06066638231277466, 0.543501615524292, 0.5503211617469788, -0.4663631319999695, -0.1911420226097107, 0.9097800254821777, -0.14319665729999542, -0.2971307039260864, 0.3831571340560913, -0.30953118205070496, -0.6555778384208679, 0.4033657908439636, 0.41388335824012756, 0.7521799206733704, -0.3354194760322571, 0.5304998159408569, -0.1008739098906517, 0.05425861105322838, 0.23735280334949493, -0.019269974902272224, -0.07592855393886566, -0.6008915901184082, 0.018873417750000954, -0.36071696877479553, -0.6772511601448059, 0.46812334656715393, -0.6487752795219421, 0.16423329710960388, -0.6302971243858337, -0.13533303141593933, 0.5295748114585876, 0.1794603317975998, -0.5572934746742249, 0.046450115740299225, 0.5597530007362366, 0.4847184121608734, -0.9986661672592163, 0.5980234742164612, 0.7514761090278625, -0.44599220156669617, -0.3039224147796631, -0.1741991639137268, 0.6242489218711853, -0.7745488882064819, 0.2221405953168869, 0.24255868792533875, 0.13430288434028625, -0.17368042469024658, -0.5895710587501526, -0.44055232405662537, 0.5876736640930176, 0.3450242877006531, -0.19370895624160767, 0.12668704986572266, 0.12419966608285904, 0.6920121312141418, -0.21543475985527039, 0.018725592643022537, 0.5270763635635376, 0.24076111614704132, 0.01372175756841898, -0.1875021904706955, -0.014770380221307278, -0.31511786580085754, -0.13557885587215424, 0.21765509247779846, -0.3592042326927185, 0.7614518404006958, 0.00017480793758295476, -0.3063448965549469, -0.19462472200393677, 0.6313188076019287, 0.09554842859506607, 0.30013367533683777, 0.655758261680603, 0.7694097757339478, 1.0215985774993896, -0.009140959940850735, 0.8586596250534058, 0.20984159409999847, 0.1321098804473877, 1.1330053806304932, -0.18233120441436768, 0.472515344619751, 0.13262251019477844, 0.09732958674430847, 0.19512085616588593, 0.4718387722969055, -0.5999412536621094, 0.37438827753067017, 0.3108053207397461, -0.5953388214111328, -0.11397562175989151, -0.5315580368041992, -0.2983740270137787, 0.35593730211257935, 0.32546567916870117, -0.33482226729393005, -0.4566310942173004, 0.47947415709495544, 0.44429004192352295, 0.1212550699710846, -0.17142967879772186, 0.7369409203529358, -0.32097604870796204, -0.201772540807724, 0.4216621220111847, -0.2460326999425888, 0.6579138040542603, -0.4519858956336975, 0.1488657146692276, -0.0200008787214756, 0.41522669792175293, -0.1926332414150238, -0.5472899079322815, 0.38383495807647705, 0.4067554771900177, -0.15928450226783752, -0.10873187333345413, 0.7174091935157776, -0.43376100063323975, -0.2864667773246765, 0.2491624653339386, 0.20973923802375793, 0.020166924223303795, -0.2280230075120926, -0.6125670671463013, 0.17146922647953033, 0.06062695011496544, -0.12281424552202225, 0.33564096689224243, 0.0899747759103775, -0.12631607055664062, 0.48592936992645264, 0.8286353349685669, 0.4587744474411011, -0.04915119707584381, 0.14356860518455505, 0.9028804898262024, -0.41642844676971436, -0.3236590027809143, -1.0727524757385254, 0.24830062687397003, -0.3873824179172516, -0.35056954622268677, 1.0559875965118408, 0.4624096155166626, 1.163705825805664, 0.2806723117828369, 1.2193232774734497, -0.20105913281440735, 0.7271022200584412, 0.11567562818527222, 0.8414064049720764, -0.29476240277290344, -0.11843086034059525, -0.2076813131570816, -0.39095833897590637, -0.6230295300483704, 0.7256782650947571, -0.3292425870895386, -0.19796593487262726, 0.027157315984368324, 0.8827510476112366, -0.15656778216362, 0.32969847321510315, 0.17871610820293427, 0.1416112184524536, 0.9015774130821228, 0.41190263628959656, 0.813761830329895, -0.4807251989841461, 0.8099677562713623, -0.5702913999557495, -0.05428284779191017, -0.2361314594745636, -0.5532654523849487, -0.898292064666748, -0.3178081214427948, -0.4221315085887909, -0.5626792311668396, 0.43294408917427063, 0.965610921382904, 0.6100155711174011, -1.1017804145812988, -0.013530616648495197, 0.08669417351484299, 0.2086956799030304, -0.18083178997039795, -0.215480238199234, 0.33269375562667847, -0.20179519057273865, -0.7395495176315308, 0.24760839343070984, -0.22166748344898224, 0.1569739282131195, -0.21046048402786255, 0.04637150466442108, -0.03494247794151306, -0.12378363311290741, 0.3463222086429596, 0.45549023151397705, -0.5267156958580017, -0.40434014797210693, -0.41590920090675354, 0.015036549419164658, -0.12871341407299042, 0.557559072971344, -0.6589585542678833, 0.6160218715667725, 0.30072611570358276, 1.2158946990966797, 0.22045685350894928, -0.06612680852413177, 0.5063361525535583, -0.5928165316581726, 0.13967372477054596, 0.3810892403125763, 0.30215397477149963, 0.5771258473396301, -0.1988149732351303, 0.4177006185054779, 0.31110331416130066, -0.4379502832889557, -1.099888801574707, 0.1314418464899063, -0.42312365770339966, -0.05310941860079765, 1.0816962718963623, -0.15601828694343567, 0.09619956463575363, -0.16707450151443481, -0.25282761454582214, 0.4385599195957184, -0.534803032875061, 0.8330371379852295, 0.9537581205368042, 0.14490219950675964, 0.0678662657737732, -0.6137576103210449, 0.7446959018707275, 0.2267732471227646, -0.5856873989105225, 0.37812504172325134, 0.8037051558494568, -0.025056280195713043, 0.23468846082687378, 0.37186890840530396, 0.1212950348854065, 0.3483845293521881, 0.1719643622636795, -0.18094846606254578, -0.40462610125541687, -0.4825635850429535, -0.8030954003334045, 0.32513391971588135, -0.25840938091278076, -0.38069841265678406 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19548v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19548v1
WaterJudge: Quality-Detection Trade-off when Watermarking Large Language Models
2024-03-28T16:28:38
2024-03-28T16:28:38
Piotr Molenda, Adian Liusie, Mark J. F. Gales
cs.CL
cs.CL
Watermarking generative-AI systems, such as LLMs, has gained considerable interest, driven by their enhanced capabilities across a wide range of tasks. Although current approaches have demonstrated that small, context-dependent shifts in the word distributions can be used to apply and detect watermarks, there has been little work in analyzing the impact that these perturbations have on the quality of generated texts. Balancing high detectability with minimal performance degradation is crucial in terms of selecting the appropriate watermarking setting; therefore this paper proposes a simple analysis framework where comparative assessment, a flexible NLG evaluation framework, is used to assess the quality degradation caused by a particular watermark setting. We demonstrate that our framework provides easy visualization of the quality-detection trade-off of watermark settings, enabling a simple solution to find an LLM watermark operating point that provides a well-balanced performance. This approach is applied to two different summarization systems and a translation system, enabling cross-model analysis for a task, and cross-task analysis.
[ -0.392672598361969, -0.572344183921814, 0.1925012618303299, 0.18639761209487915, -0.6898345947265625, 0.022668814286589622, 0.06789796054363251, -0.3728261888027191, 0.26605528593063354, 0.5869832038879395, -0.48184818029403687, -0.44684791564941406, -0.9082554578781128, 0.05525164678692818, -0.6738952398300171, 0.9718888401985168, -0.08723079413175583, -0.22486332058906555, -0.5965139865875244, -0.514045238494873, -0.46941491961479187, -0.420910507440567, -0.8189826607704163, -0.6165123581886292, 0.12728600203990936, -0.1480025202035904, 0.910169243812561, 0.5385094285011292, 0.7047176361083984, 0.25148895382881165, -0.6125072240829468, 0.20143486559391022, -0.42507249116897583, 0.33540356159210205, -0.23972249031066895, -0.4920175075531006, -0.35431787371635437, 0.022202100604772568, 0.5087266564369202, 0.42554762959480286, 0.11472853273153305, 0.3811626732349396, 0.27941250801086426, 0.665241539478302, -0.8852059245109558, 0.3484213650226593, -0.44083482027053833, 0.22171081602573395, -0.20953211188316345, -0.26931506395339966, -0.13791480660438538, -0.11957774311304092, -0.05691685900092125, -0.5650444626808167, 0.007128430064767599, 0.08461238443851471, 1.0194505453109741, 0.6466048359870911, -0.038619786500930786, -0.1859673708677292, -0.4549417197704315, 0.8477756381034851, -1.0336631536483765, 0.04338575154542923, 0.340221643447876, 0.28155577182769775, -0.016078053042292595, -0.613162100315094, -0.532975971698761, 0.083152174949646, -0.030374448746442795, 0.4263722002506256, -0.47979775071144104, -0.2501915395259857, 0.1798592507839203, 0.6052342653274536, -0.5480945706367493, 0.025939466431736946, 0.24663132429122925, -0.14959979057312012, 0.7127369046211243, 0.362108051776886, 0.3071490228176117, 0.053684186190366745, -0.26474112272262573, -0.17534326016902924, -0.8769816160202026, 0.11584272235631943, 0.28778237104415894, 0.29858335852622986, -0.06871334463357925, 0.475527822971344, -0.10658799111843109, 0.780163049697876, -0.13662312924861908, -0.28591910004615784, -0.044755514711141586, -0.27882120013237, -0.3926956057548523, -0.1819313019514084, 0.8468611240386963, 0.483212947845459, 0.17259162664413452, -0.028164921328425407, -0.5854068994522095, -0.0815608948469162, 0.13768327236175537, -0.9093302488327026, -0.14265823364257812, 0.00955896731466055, -0.6534227132797241, -0.3180418014526367, -0.11249584704637527, -0.5859916806221008, -0.6586364507675171, -0.16726544499397278, 0.5826013684272766, -0.03885304927825928, -0.24229328334331512, 0.2023322433233261, -0.3657898008823395, 0.02072344534099102, 0.24560905992984772, -0.6077702045440674, 0.2610112130641937, 0.5792478322982788, 0.9079676866531372, -0.6567621231079102, 0.11471280455589294, -0.559855580329895, 0.27368202805519104, -0.30167174339294434, 0.9909150004386902, -0.45230355858802795, -0.46244576573371887, 0.004187314305454493, -0.26254501938819885, 0.1439487636089325, -0.9721250534057617, 0.3799935281276703, -0.6636385917663574, 0.32192283868789673, -0.30720317363739014, -0.9484202265739441, -0.02601410262286663, 0.37147244811058044, -0.9890304803848267, 1.1010205745697021, 0.1745276153087616, -1.0270214080810547, 0.5601552724838257, -0.508426308631897, -0.5778733491897583, 0.2867165803909302, 0.055271368473768234, -0.8086158037185669, -0.006456330418586731, 0.1971409022808075, 0.4479287564754486, -0.4419552981853485, 0.19452917575836182, -0.21140600740909576, -0.6240144371986389, 0.19631806015968323, -0.43800997734069824, 0.7627036571502686, -0.08805172145366669, -0.4957779347896576, 0.2704595923423767, -0.6405363082885742, 0.10694852471351624, 0.20627862215042114, -0.679519534111023, -0.5962422490119934, 0.06721924990415573, 0.012758991681039333, -0.014413286000490189, 0.21264338493347168, -0.023172583431005478, 0.07356686145067215, -0.06621833145618439, 0.14030969142913818, 0.46468406915664673, 0.07084020972251892, 0.20893284678459167, -0.3524361252784729, 0.9139342308044434, -0.018391428515315056, 0.2935020327568054, 0.03731151670217514, -0.6562290191650391, -0.8170526027679443, -0.40982893109321594, 0.6341618895530701, 0.49846768379211426, -1.2152371406555176, 0.471497505903244, -0.47878021001815796, -0.22728964686393738, -0.5532196164131165, 0.2803659439086914, 0.5734378099441528, 0.04237939044833183, 0.5360914468765259, -0.36061978340148926, 0.027993446215987206, -0.9468164443969727, -0.609642505645752, -0.19860363006591797, -0.13738225400447845, 0.03725157678127289, 0.5081384778022766, -0.028532082214951515, 0.9491546750068665, -0.35941365361213684, -0.39486443996429443, -0.4735580086708069, 0.14312349259853363, 0.11694977432489395, 0.2693188190460205, 0.6680842638015747, -0.7698898911476135, -0.3307188153266907, -0.21934957802295685, -0.5214011073112488, -0.5654926300048828, -0.02494269795715809, -0.10944098234176636, -0.04020797461271286, 0.5535050630569458, -0.3667120933532715, 0.652970016002655, 0.9890925884246826, -0.4003075063228607, 0.5903164148330688, -0.014609319157898426, 0.23264655470848083, -0.7876027822494507, 0.2278929501771927, -0.05346670001745224, -0.3601536452770233, -0.48513713479042053, 0.16223905980587006, 0.06613634526729584, 0.22352030873298645, -0.27864015102386475, 0.8226646780967712, -0.2531886398792267, -0.14635533094406128, -0.5774815082550049, 0.04247387871146202, 0.3841831684112549, 0.10592715442180634, -0.1509024053812027, 0.9494250416755676, 0.1560153216123581, -0.4381560683250427, 0.2072647362947464, 0.11558179557323456, -0.4198790490627289, 0.7872807383537292, -0.8394978046417236, -0.1277851015329361, 0.08435294032096863, -0.05332757532596588, -0.9114149212837219, 0.24465079605579376, 0.21997490525245667, -0.34125664830207825, 0.34602582454681396, -0.3537862300872803, -0.5904310345649719, 0.17648302018642426, -0.4827597737312317, 0.23966053128242493, 0.3230721354484558, -0.6785967350006104, 0.5538011789321899, 0.3648190498352051, -0.18747836351394653, -0.43231818079948425, -0.8039853572845459, 0.20844416320323944, -0.40973547101020813, -0.5281173586845398, 0.6675472855567932, 0.05094502493739128, -0.4593142569065094, 0.19723030924797058, -0.17922911047935486, -0.12311065196990967, 0.3006763458251953, 0.25018110871315, 0.012617044150829315, -0.06664469838142395, -0.13704252243041992, 0.436646431684494, -0.27160966396331787, -0.0038314219564199448, 0.09917719662189484, 0.2608186602592468, 0.13501212000846863, -0.340517520904541, -0.21435099840164185, 0.22283795475959778, 0.36241650581359863, -0.2985023558139801, 0.75164794921875, 0.5083081126213074, -0.3699837625026703, -0.3236877918243408, -0.24974243342876434, 0.17836971580982208, -0.45785316824913025, 0.05614576116204262, -0.13535521924495697, -0.7470788955688477, 0.6014742255210876, -0.06718485057353973, 0.18448515236377716, 0.5485150814056396, 0.3519485890865326, -0.14114001393318176, 0.7060143947601318, 0.5575016736984253, -0.3202240467071533, 0.6301857233047485, -0.327236533164978, 0.19048254191875458, -0.7449731826782227, 0.06481751799583435, -0.43163222074508667, -0.16035637259483337, -0.11057472229003906, -0.2970101237297058, 0.27923858165740967, 0.46163180470466614, 0.04353124648332596, 0.3043488562107086, -0.2832567095756531, 0.560259997844696, 0.41161495447158813, -0.2182711362838745, 0.5427156686782837, 0.006453133188188076, -0.009741553105413914, -0.07981957495212555, -0.7099739909172058, -0.7031939625740051, 0.7648205757141113, -0.06851759552955627, 0.5718880295753479, 0.17065288126468658, 0.6307222843170166, 0.8433398008346558, 0.7601792812347412, -0.586794376373291, 0.5860213041305542, -0.2254309058189392, -0.5111342072486877, -0.38408946990966797, -0.5802496075630188, -1.0275856256484985, 0.5098894834518433, -0.3816109299659729, -0.17318987846374512, -0.17292717099189758, 0.04189963638782501, -0.28111547231674194, 0.2559186816215515, -0.3955957591533661, 0.819225549697876, -0.14734159409999847, -0.5019057393074036, -0.09088800102472305, -0.21199215948581696, 0.15869109332561493, -0.012737665325403214, 0.22202742099761963, -0.29931384325027466, -0.14698567986488342, 0.8787146210670471, -0.23025432229042053, 0.5103059411048889, -0.3127816915512085, -0.3524670898914337, 0.23016105592250824, 0.3421888053417206, 0.2750350832939148, -0.06057608500123024, -0.20019076764583588, 0.16416755318641663, -0.10429424792528152, -0.2576645314693451, -0.6671137809753418, 0.49926382303237915, -0.40358227491378784, -0.499904602766037, -0.25904449820518494, -0.3754469156265259, -0.21899862587451935, 0.1688394695520401, 0.27668431401252747, 0.2168130725622177, -0.05068507045507431, -0.061187226325273514, 0.41059499979019165, -0.5016407370567322, 0.5738444924354553, 0.2795123755931854, -0.26146695017814636, -0.41728824377059937, 0.8763600587844849, 0.04483259469270706, 0.278143972158432, 0.18655258417129517, 0.23376168310642242, -0.3831542134284973, -0.9274367094039917, -0.5451407432556152, -0.00861511379480362, -0.8875929713249207, -0.4633576273918152, -0.028289232403039932, -0.07387743145227432, 0.07846125960350037, 0.04049894958734512, -0.4097351133823395, -0.25292468070983887, -0.35696908831596375, 0.14297980070114136, 0.14898145198822021, 0.5699719190597534, 0.3225007951259613, 0.4398971498012543, -0.636577308177948, 0.3586178719997406, 0.2942868769168854, 0.45008039474487305, -0.22377584874629974, -0.8930910229682922, -0.3231101632118225, -0.06436631828546524, -0.3945567309856415, -0.5274121761322021, 0.4558107852935791, 0.2551113963127136, 0.6422728896141052, 0.49935439229011536, 0.13702040910720825, 0.6517074108123779, -0.15174928307533264, 0.9789093136787415, 0.17896515130996704, -1.2881009578704834, 0.45809128880500793, -0.08537959307432175, 0.4200805127620697, 0.46354979276657104, 0.0765921100974083, -0.4234689474105835, -0.513095498085022, -0.5627614259719849, -1.087416172027588, 0.21136076748371124, 0.5376542806625366, 0.010872145183384418, 0.24152390658855438, 0.3474896252155304, 0.14981000125408173, 0.20724788308143616, -0.7901509404182434, -0.3396320641040802, -0.14723467826843262, -0.09533626586198807, 0.043065741658210754, -0.2385423630475998, -0.12088879197835922, -0.13823537528514862, 0.7711420059204102, -0.2590514123439789, 0.2016325443983078, -0.15918612480163574, -0.399713397026062, 0.19746682047843933, 0.18140389025211334, 0.5808903574943542, 0.5702369809150696, 0.09739435464143753, 0.16090618073940277, 0.1089104413986206, -0.24731288850307465, 0.07014047354459763, -0.0748792290687561, -0.4290008246898651, 0.3030773103237152, 1.0122029781341553, 0.8263552188873291, 0.11188069730997086, -0.7522905468940735, 0.6607000231742859, -0.11964014172554016, -0.041620492935180664, 0.2297164350748062, 0.21286533772945404, 0.2828315794467926, 0.2324596494436264, 0.22327913343906403, -0.2660749852657318, 0.22122091054916382, -0.16430214047431946, -0.02517556957900524, 0.5197583436965942, -0.2120789885520935, -0.10014061629772186, 0.6221370100975037, 0.23121985793113708, -0.26029789447784424, 0.32980820536613464, -0.2601604759693146, -0.643519401550293, 0.6374649405479431, 0.20390532910823822, 0.8578596115112305, -0.04763583093881607, -0.04509318619966507, 0.030283764004707336, 0.3545934557914734, -0.14688168466091156, 0.24824780225753784, 0.028273412957787514, -0.8482766151428223, -0.5321111679077148, -0.488189160823822, -0.5767369270324707, 0.30211788415908813, -0.9354591965675354, -0.06996189057826996, -0.27383723855018616, -0.5347392559051514, 0.03393407538533211, -0.13755130767822266, -0.4471057057380676, 0.2829098105430603, 0.16493453085422516, 0.5448535680770874, -0.8907427191734314, 0.5462766885757446, 0.5581429600715637, -0.09190048277378082, -0.22192762792110443, 0.21571926772594452, -0.026167316362261772, -0.6644071340560913, 0.40612247586250305, 0.13606983423233032, -0.3246951997280121, -0.3461246192455292, -0.4757603704929352, -0.7051024436950684, 1.039109468460083, 0.6367591023445129, -0.47939756512641907, 0.6469162106513977, 0.3404325842857361, 0.7850308418273926, -0.031702302396297455, 0.08367264270782471, 0.7523089647293091, 0.47895529866218567, -0.35167691111564636, -0.8126118183135986, 0.20110327005386353, -0.47667190432548523, 0.23100978136062622, 0.18959444761276245, -0.4497385025024414, 0.4148712754249573, 0.16743679344654083, -0.38991114497184753, -0.03351333737373352, 0.3592979609966278, 0.19258861243724823, 0.19677579402923584, 0.6046061515808105, 0.6082130074501038, 0.3602057099342346, -0.3114932179450989, 1.202569842338562, -0.25816893577575684, 0.5425501465797424, 0.9776208996772766, -0.26315373182296753, 0.8424427509307861, 0.6274946928024292, -0.48034602403640747, 0.02518400177359581, 0.5795317888259888, -0.07376629114151001, 0.6854298114776611, 0.5341143608093262, -0.3056177496910095, -0.3033325672149658, -0.18004512786865234, -0.3357611894607544, 0.20274066925048828, 0.25015053153038025, -0.33730870485305786, -0.15953098237514496, -0.16716456413269043, -0.16803190112113953, -0.05910244956612587, -0.3092794418334961, 0.7616016268730164, 0.0999603345990181, -0.456485778093338, 0.6482163667678833, 0.16151182353496552, 1.0023030042648315, -0.2528853714466095, -0.01670551858842373, -0.6778469681739807, 0.12951460480690002, -0.16815628111362457, -0.8568205237388611, 0.4699845314025879, 0.05331773683428764, -0.1601657271385193, -0.3623703420162201, 0.7496567368507385, -0.4135361611843109, -0.2598688304424286, 0.5844151973724365, 0.5795508623123169, 0.07670284062623978, -0.29921868443489075, -0.9159467220306396, 0.27636146545410156, -0.20366448163986206, -0.5475416779518127, 0.3092162311077118, 0.21584123373031616, -0.20046372711658478, 0.854224681854248, 0.5234048366546631, 0.18120750784873962, 0.02865174598991871, 0.3899402618408203, 0.6187155246734619, -0.42426642775535583, -0.3930494487285614, -1.0091400146484375, 0.2879165709018707, -0.3149294853210449, -0.3296625018119812, 0.72752845287323, 0.48523786664009094, 0.7118965983390808, -0.003072148421779275, 0.8459444642066956, 0.23277147114276886, 0.06780727207660675, -0.6216751933097839, 0.9757634401321411, -0.7083348631858826, 0.5208342671394348, -0.48191824555397034, -0.8892743587493896, -0.5928918719291687, 0.5249053835868835, -0.05178838595747948, -0.08271098881959915, 0.5045446753501892, 0.595127284526825, 0.056373678147792816, -0.1214560717344284, 0.4411028325557709, -0.4516870677471161, 0.5874881744384766, 0.2336982786655426, 0.9765569567680359, -0.4420181214809418, 0.5351648926734924, -0.08596325665712357, -0.003327005309984088, -0.13730880618095398, -1.1186697483062744, -0.9594120979309082, -0.38362422585487366, -0.7407669425010681, -0.3196581304073334, 0.1946885585784912, 0.45499134063720703, 0.5435936450958252, -0.9056456685066223, -0.012683656066656113, 0.3120894134044647, 0.14070120453834534, -0.44637614488601685, -0.21546296775341034, 0.5935356616973877, 0.2519074082374573, -0.48300257325172424, 0.1944361925125122, 0.4649201035499573, 0.2881360352039337, -0.07630495727062225, -0.1091773584485054, 0.3033912777900696, 0.15370522439479828, 0.7013642191886902, -0.02549520507454872, -0.48681288957595825, -0.14628323912620544, -0.4742336571216583, -0.10633498430252075, -0.05268551781773567, 0.8007644414901733, -0.40419015288352966, 0.2981417775154114, 0.5408449172973633, 0.8786227703094482, 0.5457709431648254, -0.136676624417305, 0.23460501432418823, -0.8259077668190002, 0.08571242541074753, 0.19352978467941284, 0.5407074689865112, 0.48018649220466614, -0.09725937247276306, 0.5380420684814453, 0.23965954780578613, -0.11150193214416504, -0.7091506719589233, -0.193621426820755, -0.7622865438461304, -0.345783531665802, 1.3234095573425293, -0.5929871797561646, 0.09898071736097336, -0.14047472178936005, -0.04804098978638649, 0.11836069077253342, -0.0685473158955574, 1.013990044593811, 0.9842783212661743, -0.060127176344394684, -0.022496186196804047, -0.3676430583000183, 0.5439137816429138, 0.5863105654716492, -1.27530837059021, -0.06368127465248108, 0.25030380487442017, 0.5283117294311523, 0.07228362560272217, 0.3730759620666504, -0.11258280277252197, 0.16151882708072662, -0.15013286471366882, 0.3186942934989929, -0.1840021163225174, 0.002059293445199728, -0.4840640723705292, 0.15630123019218445, -0.0008421621168963611, -0.2073596864938736 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19521v4
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19521v4
Interpreting Key Mechanisms of Factual Recall in Transformer-Based Language Models
2024-03-28T15:54:59
2024-05-24T15:06:45
Ang Lv, Yuhan Chen, Kaiyi Zhang, Yulong Wang, Lifeng Liu, Ji-Rong Wen, Jian Xie, Rui Yan
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
In this paper, we delve into several mechanisms employed by Transformer-based language models (LLMs) for factual recall tasks. We outline a pipeline consisting of three major steps: (1) Given a prompt ``The capital of France is,'' task-specific attention heads extract the topic token, such as ``France,'' from the context and pass it to subsequent MLPs. (2) As attention heads' outputs are aggregated with equal weight and added to the residual stream, the subsequent MLP acts as an ``activation,'' which either erases or amplifies the information originating from individual heads. As a result, the topic token ``France'' stands out in the residual stream. (3) A deep MLP takes ``France'' and generates a component that redirects the residual stream towards the direction of the correct answer, i.e., ``Paris.'' This procedure is akin to applying an implicit function such as ``get\_capital($X$),'' and the argument $X$ is the topic token information passed by attention heads. To achieve the above quantitative and qualitative analysis for MLPs, we proposed a novel analytic method aimed at decomposing the outputs of the MLP into components understandable by humans. Additionally, we observed a universal anti-overconfidence mechanism in the final layer of models, which suppresses correct predictions. We mitigate this suppression by leveraging our interpretation to improve factual recall confidence. The above interpretations are evaluated across diverse tasks spanning various domains of factual knowledge, using various language models from the GPT-2 families, 1.3B OPT, up to 7B Llama-2, and in both zero- and few-shot setups.
[ -0.3709465265274048, -0.7316147685050964, 0.8725824356079102, -0.17806045711040497, -0.051636796444654465, 0.03750568628311157, -0.11880619078874588, -0.1164979636669159, -0.1181599572300911, 0.690378725528717, -0.6338754296302795, -0.42527344822883606, -0.7372696399688721, 0.11578146368265152, -0.514892041683197, 1.2525430917739868, -0.16833508014678955, -0.36478862166404724, -0.20953519642353058, 0.06266281753778458, -0.5858697295188904, -0.6654279232025146, -0.5681609511375427, -0.39718201756477356, 0.6698217391967773, 0.37436971068382263, 0.3857320547103882, 0.40982094407081604, 0.42277991771698, 0.23881661891937256, -0.0653899684548378, -0.12091579288244247, -0.9610320925712585, -0.009228725917637348, -0.4123862683773041, -0.8698534965515137, -0.15207278728485107, 0.025386907160282135, 0.659986674785614, 0.4678231179714203, -0.07949088513851166, 0.27875789999961853, 0.07635702937841415, 0.6567458510398865, -0.7201704978942871, 0.3779621124267578, -0.9815473556518555, 0.058341506868600845, 0.2288380265235901, -0.590689480304718, -0.5652856826782227, -0.12691989541053772, 0.11062848567962646, -0.25953209400177, 0.6624950766563416, 0.098458431661129, 0.9000087380409241, 0.4398069679737091, -0.537794291973114, -0.2869539260864258, -0.9428479671478271, 0.5785431265830994, -0.2679184675216675, 0.3834129869937897, 0.36853739619255066, 0.09204792231321335, 0.027314677834510803, -0.8398296236991882, -0.7203353047370911, -0.13358980417251587, -0.5436568856239319, 0.26579561829566956, -0.3431863784790039, -0.005852640140801668, 0.5465911030769348, 0.3828740119934082, -0.46947193145751953, -0.17320053279399872, -0.5447728037834167, -0.4461308419704437, 0.2208896428346634, 0.12156540155410767, 0.1378447264432907, -0.15357603132724762, -0.5147812366485596, 0.14495055377483368, -1.0066527128219604, 0.08318490535020828, -0.04523962736129761, 0.4094100892543793, -0.14898930490016937, 0.6162102222442627, -0.07907552272081375, 0.3893558084964752, 0.21422898769378662, -0.04861961677670479, 0.006000970955938101, -0.38093653321266174, -0.294089674949646, 0.16283100843429565, 0.32151278853416443, 0.14718754589557648, 0.3081485331058502, -0.2697685658931732, -0.32354602217674255, 0.2053252011537552, 0.5228748321533203, -0.6036472320556641, -0.10160521417856216, 0.253069132566452, -0.25479447841644287, -0.23842768371105194, -0.057445842772722244, -0.5339578986167908, -0.13763268291950226, -0.4238516092300415, 0.5064164996147156, -0.165861114859581, -0.045989394187927246, 0.032702770084142685, -0.07669376581907272, 0.4515274465084076, 0.04488891363143921, -0.9411554336547852, 0.5504276156425476, 0.8121270537376404, 0.679282009601593, -0.2736729681491852, -0.16144143044948578, -0.6291143298149109, 0.0406782366335392, -0.287617564201355, 0.7527768015861511, -0.342570036649704, -0.33036255836486816, 0.2071727067232132, 0.22519724071025848, -0.3740518093109131, -0.45565223693847656, 0.8122208714485168, -0.7540803551673889, 0.31755027174949646, -0.9258162379264832, -0.5630791783332825, -0.5894947052001953, 0.3972044885158539, -0.8336177468299866, 1.0293569564819336, -0.2322554588317871, -0.7500324845314026, 0.4504906237125397, -0.2658465802669525, -0.3048359751701355, -0.30699822306632996, -0.20540829002857208, -0.31020909547805786, 0.13125814497470856, 0.2732890844345093, 0.6177682876586914, -0.3136425316333771, 0.39874789118766785, 0.12568801641464233, -0.43799856305122375, 0.3151874244213104, -0.8420508503913879, 0.5238462090492249, -0.20539265871047974, -0.5056117177009583, -0.04498147591948509, -0.8049368858337402, -0.6337348818778992, 0.15186308324337006, -0.06109590455889702, -0.023048723116517067, -0.022267038002610207, -0.29539409279823303, 0.5003396272659302, 0.009474973194301128, -0.5308356881141663, -0.14470575749874115, -0.2899633049964905, 0.23089198768138885, 0.6501479148864746, 0.5391018390655518, 0.35476943850517273, -0.22948522865772247, 0.29386863112449646, 0.2496798038482666, -0.20128963887691498, -0.5446456074714661, -0.4189997911453247, -0.9479629397392273, -0.46296611428260803, 0.07944449782371521, 0.8549807667732239, -0.44886550307273865, 0.17700070142745972, -0.27470484375953674, -0.04548988863825798, -0.2722966969013214, -0.06447302550077438, 0.3511143922805786, 0.8640031218528748, 0.30406126379966736, -0.044009849429130554, -0.361352801322937, -0.9640101790428162, -0.0971258282661438, -0.12953253090381622, 0.06110939383506775, 0.03903455287218094, 0.7766158580780029, 0.0016040405025705695, 1.1557183265686035, -0.5387033820152283, -0.1437164545059204, -0.27859118580818176, 0.29195812344551086, 0.33039283752441406, 0.1780245304107666, 0.5298405289649963, -0.9504836201667786, -0.13146819174289703, -0.23453496396541595, -0.6313572525978088, 0.1401418298482895, -0.439849853515625, 0.0034049947280436754, 0.3984459638595581, 0.5890893936157227, -1.0265766382217407, 0.5990116596221924, 0.07162584364414215, -0.346205472946167, 0.6257293224334717, -0.027489079162478447, 0.17587625980377197, -0.7811679244041443, 0.3081628382205963, -0.10182762891054153, -0.24640218913555145, -0.7597230076789856, -0.10600464791059494, -0.05314357951283455, 0.001176878227852285, -0.290814071893692, 0.5309563875198364, -0.3342083692550659, -0.0852547213435173, -0.11226138472557068, 0.351097971200943, 0.21330833435058594, 0.9024479985237122, 0.14379872381687164, 0.6833247542381287, 0.3959481418132782, -0.4914926290512085, 0.16162265837192535, 0.15063537657260895, -0.019063154235482216, 0.5017744898796082, -0.5340085029602051, -0.026828765869140625, -0.5318958163261414, 0.2151719331741333, -1.655677318572998, 0.07291703671216965, 0.5057809948921204, -0.34774231910705566, 0.617570161819458, -0.16723673045635223, -0.37875816226005554, -0.3437999486923218, -0.07516265660524368, -0.016823068261146545, 0.4068143367767334, -0.39896324276924133, 0.7917281985282898, 0.06480752676725388, -0.4900500476360321, -0.7217025756835938, -0.6730875968933105, 0.11098531633615494, -0.23537401854991913, -0.03634732589125633, 0.1926412582397461, 0.21676123142242432, -0.1674140840768814, 0.13412714004516602, -0.40887773036956787, 0.0013436898589134216, 0.047157954424619675, 0.3236384391784668, 0.5852540135383606, -0.1876150369644165, 0.1397506147623062, -0.06998138874769211, -0.36209142208099365, 0.4561038017272949, -0.3532627820968628, 0.18254642188549042, -0.17977815866470337, -0.47241559624671936, -0.5355725884437561, 0.18559770286083221, 0.6849403381347656, -0.2707882225513458, 0.9565097689628601, 0.7092177271842957, -0.38615739345550537, 0.139462411403656, -0.8347451686859131, -0.5194109082221985, -0.3632529675960541, 0.4188873767852783, -0.5369614958763123, -0.8497900366783142, 0.7804558873176575, 0.07749726623296738, 0.12389834970235825, 0.660334050655365, 0.9171397686004639, -0.0022735297679901123, 0.5576527714729309, 0.5764355063438416, -0.25124719738960266, 0.09134175628423691, -0.40789541602134705, 0.4533286392688751, -0.6341557502746582, -0.28838637471199036, -0.4469849169254303, -0.06672564148902893, -0.3956069052219391, -0.4742642939090729, 0.16524161398410797, -0.17638878524303436, -0.1012130007147789, 0.15352381765842438, -0.062284085899591446, 0.45915600657463074, 0.5357893705368042, 0.0014531562337651849, 0.33258315920829773, 0.09529662877321243, -0.3193240165710449, -0.17133544385433197, -0.9016020894050598, -0.5428895354270935, 1.1158493757247925, 0.4079476594924927, 0.3364865779876709, -0.2206258326768875, 0.5473520755767822, 0.2698364555835724, 0.37366047501564026, -0.7080979347229004, 0.4813104569911957, 0.09728904813528061, -0.7863910794258118, -0.22590959072113037, -0.1802043467760086, -0.590655505657196, 0.36796295642852783, -0.3586001694202423, -0.8030493855476379, 0.3285789489746094, 0.2044990062713623, -0.6218922138214111, 0.40275707840919495, -0.5709858536720276, 0.8759031891822815, 0.23088259994983673, -0.4653210937976837, -0.420602411031723, -0.695593535900116, 0.5385686159133911, -0.09245860576629639, 0.0843801200389862, 0.05947624519467354, 0.16692428290843964, 0.37069058418273926, 0.30478420853614807, 1.225356101989746, -0.10721015930175781, -0.12714466452598572, 0.5205668807029724, 0.1777113676071167, 0.8025987148284912, -0.09576600790023804, 0.17348988354206085, 0.16136875748634338, -0.18990707397460938, -0.24846875667572021, -0.7567645907402039, 0.43120166659355164, -0.6358211636543274, -0.7198989987373352, -0.3261454403400421, -0.46784722805023193, -0.019492357969284058, -0.07852333039045334, 0.2843902111053467, 0.6722283959388733, -0.42869481444358826, 0.16216878592967987, 0.8571205735206604, -0.13652047514915466, 0.31548020243644714, 0.5830207467079163, 0.03669288754463196, 0.03956858441233635, 0.9630677103996277, 0.15011872351169586, 0.3589859902858734, 0.7986239790916443, -0.05485856160521507, -0.49701476097106934, -0.35893869400024414, 0.009606659412384033, 0.42673954367637634, -0.9962087273597717, -0.014118957333266735, -0.8345209956169128, -0.2651710510253906, -0.18309219181537628, 0.021746473386883736, -0.26899802684783936, -0.5954439640045166, -0.34752169251441956, -0.5420286059379578, 0.0026176234241575003, 0.4992850720882416, -0.12471840530633926, 0.03434893488883972, -0.7139882445335388, 0.7555766105651855, 0.47795405983924866, -0.018206078559160233, 0.07765603065490723, -0.6810946464538574, -0.23251484334468842, -0.17620384693145752, -0.2026708871126175, -0.7453226447105408, 0.18678776919841766, -0.0949263647198677, 0.7288137078285217, 0.4238356053829193, 0.10273734480142593, 0.30083027482032776, -0.664664089679718, 0.7511792778968811, -0.1498863697052002, -0.8553757071495056, 0.24943912029266357, -0.01903180219233036, 0.1870119571685791, 0.42587241530418396, 0.5665400624275208, -0.6913485527038574, -0.5772864818572998, -0.5732033848762512, -0.7931656837463379, 0.6165352463722229, 0.4178883135318756, 0.023431599140167236, -0.1765507459640503, 0.6362955570220947, 0.05576277896761894, 0.3422975242137909, -0.5660523772239685, -0.31591367721557617, -0.16211073100566864, -0.10152706503868103, -0.02641570009291172, -0.7246980667114258, -0.42807304859161377, 0.026090586557984352, 0.6758058071136475, 0.0028858110308647156, 0.43239012360572815, 0.42981234192848206, -0.19391977787017822, 0.0493575744330883, 0.22802500426769257, 0.782993495464325, 0.7482005953788757, -0.2467019408941269, 0.17674343287944794, 0.2700116038322449, -0.4242633581161499, -0.04339879751205444, -0.05205726623535156, -0.3211977779865265, -0.05345922335982323, 0.7306988835334778, 1.0892976522445679, 0.46107491850852966, -0.4033414125442505, 0.476109117269516, 0.020655060186982155, -0.018134165555238724, -0.32140180468559265, -0.07085181027650833, -0.01238252967596054, 0.28661879897117615, 0.5602512955665588, 0.2510981559753418, 0.19931477308273315, -0.7446134090423584, 0.5520967841148376, 0.3357483148574829, -0.5483413338661194, -0.6284049153327942, 0.6626126170158386, 0.04568763077259064, 0.023976275697350502, 0.5906456708908081, -0.19127213954925537, -0.7601537704467773, 0.5383877754211426, 0.44069838523864746, 1.1617295742034912, 0.0037637229543179274, 0.3311126232147217, 0.5168573260307312, 0.5915049314498901, -0.024919703602790833, 0.07966535538434982, -0.12185656279325485, -0.9691433310508728, -0.8320760130882263, -0.36559566855430603, -0.20933271944522858, -0.027695754542946815, -0.7719772458076477, -0.030955933034420013, -0.13790357112884521, -0.059527765959501266, -0.28985685110092163, -0.20738987624645233, -0.8244824409484863, 0.4021275043487549, 0.584595263004303, 0.8367393612861633, -1.1229199171066284, 0.5884849429130554, 0.12048793584108353, -0.25805869698524475, -0.545017659664154, 0.2595362663269043, 0.30353501439094543, -0.9686265587806702, 0.7691919207572937, 0.054198022931814194, -0.2665174901485443, 0.011436772532761097, -0.37170109152793884, -0.923015832901001, 0.8686401844024658, 0.22496092319488525, -0.597955048084259, -0.12127712368965149, 0.2846483290195465, 0.4600410461425781, -0.38548943400382996, 0.04525221511721611, 1.057273030281067, 0.42417049407958984, 0.3579874336719513, -0.6123671531677246, 0.30952343344688416, 0.15913616120815277, -0.33400169014930725, -0.04721894487738609, -0.37004995346069336, 0.6343769431114197, -0.4332340955734253, -0.36395135521888733, -0.2052050679922104, 0.5710543990135193, 0.18442636728286743, 0.112601637840271, 0.3762264549732208, 0.44354259967803955, 0.819186270236969, -0.12068680673837662, 1.179261565208435, -0.4996059834957123, 0.5485784411430359, 1.1074539422988892, -0.22453351318836212, 0.7541549801826477, 0.5669978857040405, -0.07009343802928925, 0.4576694965362549, 0.21930456161499023, 0.046020105481147766, 0.6169978976249695, -0.21459563076496124, -0.12270934134721756, -0.2634645700454712, 0.0068896859884262085, 0.06599534302949905, 0.4141961634159088, 0.4115523397922516, -0.25439453125, -0.23181915283203125, -0.06649947166442871, 0.17921005189418793, -0.14506278932094574, -0.2979508936405182, 0.6559768319129944, 0.14351318776607513, -0.6982706189155579, 0.6510455012321472, -0.226337268948555, 0.00804882775992155, -0.5234018564224243, -0.09293696284294128, -0.24153222143650055, 0.007984180934727192, 0.08115174621343613, -0.7942354679107666, 0.44341766834259033, -0.10834018141031265, -0.40440163016319275, -0.17214804887771606, 0.7429111003875732, -0.5568652153015137, -0.4861581325531006, 0.139161616563797, 0.4323178827762604, -0.12940450012683868, -0.3714418411254883, -0.6030042767524719, 0.051861196756362915, 0.06924047321081161, -0.6013142466545105, -0.08491427451372147, 0.5882266759872437, -0.0019678811077028513, 0.6624372601509094, 0.5044500827789307, 0.016427351161837578, -0.0031840105075389147, 0.09327835589647293, 0.7674404978752136, -0.7973861694335938, -0.3604450225830078, -0.9853008389472961, 0.6953577995300293, 0.15066084265708923, 0.08690275996923447, 0.6336432099342346, 0.4930371344089508, 0.5660965442657471, -0.09028897434473038, 0.7895727753639221, 0.19743776321411133, 0.469734787940979, -0.7256503701210022, 0.4475986063480377, -0.2822777330875397, 0.16314958035945892, -0.122577004134655, -0.9087908267974854, -0.2616402804851532, 0.2852167785167694, -0.4834308922290802, -0.2898392975330353, 0.8874825835227966, 0.7606518268585205, 0.0162417721003294, -0.05951935052871704, 0.42709946632385254, 0.7325387001037598, 0.18340127170085907, 0.37311121821403503, 0.6415834426879883, -0.38677266240119934, 0.54835045337677, -0.04934517666697502, -0.05160069093108177, -0.298274427652359, -0.7325348258018494, -0.9402783513069153, -0.657834529876709, -0.2897118926048279, -0.1806711107492447, -0.03438958898186684, 0.6148179173469543, 0.3984811007976532, -1.0524719953536987, 0.06837249547243118, -0.03207102045416832, 0.3418193757534027, -0.21427090466022491, -0.2300180345773697, 0.4791581332683563, -0.5450499653816223, -0.5290608406066895, 0.10997790098190308, 0.5617895722389221, -0.02530703879892826, -0.3297850787639618, 0.32297664880752563, -0.0948677659034729, 0.2296222597360611, 0.764483630657196, 0.25141504406929016, -0.9556517004966736, -0.6373896598815918, 0.1101907268166542, -0.050122033804655075, 0.1331217736005783, 1.0195070505142212, -0.9730865955352783, 0.2243499755859375, 0.3818422555923462, 0.5157520174980164, 0.6935893893241882, 0.13205605745315552, 0.6430028080940247, -0.7744438052177429, 0.3593086004257202, -0.01572972536087036, 0.39710912108421326, 0.3359065055847168, -0.40154194831848145, 0.3321683406829834, 0.5709571242332458, -0.32613351941108704, -0.642533004283905, 0.19039250910282135, -0.66924649477005, -0.1874610185623169, 0.9768939018249512, -0.2036333829164505, -0.12585456669330597, -0.2011137753725052, -0.35324105620384216, 0.33180680871009827, -0.08562890440225601, 0.8952938914299011, 0.885122537612915, 0.17935235798358917, -0.2508046627044678, -0.7088310122489929, 0.5323513746261597, 0.18554413318634033, -0.30635717511177063, 0.2200583666563034, 0.36825060844421387, 0.25996336340904236, 0.32707008719444275, 0.5754373669624329, 0.06142912432551384, 0.19588319957256317, 0.07580363005399704, -0.015292756259441376, 0.26081231236457825, -0.7125253081321716, -0.2673056125640869, 0.31244558095932007, -0.34349513053894043, -0.09448250383138657 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01322v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01322v1
A Review of Multi-Modal Large Language and Vision Models
2024-03-28T15:53:45
2024-03-28T15:53:45
Kilian Carolan, Laura Fennelly, Alan F. Smeaton
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI
Large Language Models (LLMs) have recently emerged as a focal point of research and application, driven by their unprecedented ability to understand and generate text with human-like quality. Even more recently, LLMs have been extended into multi-modal large language models (MM-LLMs) which extends their capabilities to deal with image, video and audio information, in addition to text. This opens up applications like text-to-video generation, image captioning, text-to-speech, and more and is achieved either by retro-fitting an LLM with multi-modal capabilities, or building a MM-LLM from scratch. This paper provides an extensive review of the current state of those LLMs with multi-modal capabilities as well as the very recent MM-LLMs. It covers the historical development of LLMs especially the advances enabled by transformer-based architectures like OpenAI's GPT series and Google's BERT, as well as the role of attention mechanisms in enhancing model performance. The paper includes coverage of the major and most important of the LLMs and MM-LLMs and also covers the techniques of model tuning, including fine-tuning and prompt engineering, which tailor pre-trained models to specific tasks or domains. Ethical considerations and challenges, such as data bias and model misuse, are also analysed to underscore the importance of responsible AI development and deployment. Finally, we discuss the implications of open-source versus proprietary models in AI research. Through this review, we provide insights into the transformative potential of MM-LLMs in various applications.
[ -0.4021816551685333, -0.6336151957511902, 0.6588097810745239, 0.003573761321604252, 0.0639113113284111, -0.07337352633476257, -0.4471457898616791, -0.7065144181251526, -0.17846013605594635, 0.6239014267921448, -0.35338181257247925, -0.07856704294681549, -0.6835626363754272, 0.11606935411691666, -0.4188552796840668, 0.5211981534957886, 0.060005445033311844, 0.36335358023643494, -0.1791241317987442, -0.12915904819965363, -0.3964335322380066, -0.6404473781585693, -0.4542745351791382, -0.26364442706108093, 0.5067360997200012, 0.048321932554244995, 0.8694144487380981, 0.5341121554374695, 0.6857644319534302, 0.3794223964214325, -0.0696997120976448, 0.3429489731788635, -0.28854840993881226, 0.0020145359449088573, 0.055592894554138184, -0.5049523711204529, -0.593260645866394, 0.13723373413085938, 0.8331376910209656, 0.6781212091445923, 0.0836578756570816, 0.08251111209392548, -0.027902374044060707, 0.3639601171016693, -0.572706401348114, 0.4109874367713928, -0.6267581582069397, -0.20365549623966217, -0.11344210803508759, -0.015883278101682663, -0.50009685754776, 0.10508794337511063, 0.10028701275587082, -0.3404638171195984, -0.08380965888500214, 0.1852065622806549, 0.5416679978370667, 0.4928554892539978, -0.6426090598106384, -0.2813711166381836, -0.9747442007064819, 1.0551267862319946, -0.8659427165985107, 0.7351475954055786, 0.12254364043474197, 0.33804959058761597, -0.08318808674812317, -0.5264633893966675, -0.5710870623588562, -0.5433163642883301, 0.19098129868507385, 0.019975561648607254, -0.007931257598102093, 0.1809266209602356, 0.16292083263397217, 0.5114003419876099, -0.28080978989601135, 0.4087566137313843, -0.29108256101608276, -0.04679230973124504, 0.49312296509742737, 0.32145869731903076, 0.2584681212902069, -0.17310652136802673, -0.318734347820282, 0.022421447560191154, -0.7596669793128967, -0.17008334398269653, 0.21468734741210938, 0.22757072746753693, -0.18075518310070038, 0.8797266483306885, 0.07673370093107224, 0.926019012928009, -0.2530321478843689, -0.5428825616836548, 0.06493078172206879, -0.6042447090148926, -0.45702847838401794, -0.433395653963089, 0.8708993196487427, 0.18125656247138977, 0.5465212464332581, -0.043133605271577835, -0.27240297198295593, 0.07696893066167831, 0.27129867672920227, -0.5194480419158936, 0.20100225508213043, 0.03185449540615082, -0.6743718385696411, -0.16522373259067535, -0.1319475769996643, -0.6354607939720154, -0.4447748064994812, -0.7790500521659851, 0.2872503697872162, -0.3114641606807709, -0.3075152635574341, 0.18023674190044403, 0.24217268824577332, 0.46651744842529297, 0.5902741551399231, -0.7842219471931458, -0.08996885269880295, 0.6759301424026489, 0.6621676087379456, -0.0995776578783989, -0.5176477432250977, -0.20084165036678314, 0.36611226201057434, -0.35486969351768494, 0.38284099102020264, -0.6607877016067505, -0.2713482677936554, 0.22635389864444733, -0.0030967656057327986, -0.08328041434288025, -0.3913555443286896, 0.22990092635154724, -0.5348713397979736, 0.2088233083486557, -0.10112807154655457, -0.20452584326267242, -0.3762985169887543, 0.4780876636505127, -0.8063821196556091, 0.5363335013389587, -0.17246557772159576, -0.5372040867805481, 0.17633779346942902, -0.8674334287643433, -0.43763238191604614, -0.13758313655853271, -0.2864242196083069, -0.14180636405944824, 0.31847620010375977, 0.2064700871706009, 0.6938742399215698, -0.7836318016052246, 0.37794920802116394, -0.12068041414022446, 0.10681378096342087, 0.3114040493965149, -0.814067006111145, 0.5769740343093872, 0.215961754322052, -0.16955415904521942, 0.4854705333709717, -0.7316870093345642, -0.2706639766693115, 0.06840092688798904, -0.5361708402633667, -0.018262038007378578, 0.4058767855167389, 0.3052223324775696, 0.3063758611679077, 0.2217947095632553, -0.2799762189388275, -0.03788140416145325, -0.1631687879562378, 0.8614205121994019, 0.7273252606391907, -0.46586501598358154, 0.43748733401298523, -0.29830092191696167, 0.37169399857521057, 0.11169992387294769, 0.4734584093093872, -0.7102968096733093, -0.4701327085494995, -0.836577832698822, -0.47556883096694946, 0.03630615398287773, 0.5378865003585815, -0.7571620941162109, 0.06999772787094116, -0.30850404500961304, -0.33697035908699036, -0.6031150817871094, 0.15106503665447235, 0.008023062720894814, 0.1446869969367981, 0.1984689086675644, -0.053664132952690125, -0.19865410029888153, -0.9748564958572388, 0.09162341058254242, -0.18847768008708954, 0.002887165639549494, 0.6003321409225464, 0.36994898319244385, -0.5679465532302856, 0.5362768173217773, -0.20602810382843018, -0.2830776572227478, -0.319682240486145, -0.0980994924902916, -0.04471293091773987, 0.21420085430145264, 0.5827866792678833, -1.1058366298675537, -0.12989217042922974, 0.1335536688566208, -0.7380366325378418, 0.2576897144317627, -0.20969106256961823, 0.48038092255592346, 0.304890900850296, 0.5401986837387085, -0.7582849860191345, 0.0832909569144249, 0.8443511724472046, -0.04659145697951317, 0.5180816650390625, -0.23010173439979553, 0.351616770029068, -1.2563745975494385, 0.14639383554458618, 0.12592913210391998, -0.34289681911468506, -0.5969051122665405, 0.3769885003566742, -0.027159612625837326, -0.2873428463935852, -0.5346073508262634, 0.3970887064933777, -0.7251168489456177, -0.24271251261234283, -0.46886736154556274, -0.03913270682096481, -0.2148025929927826, 0.26484453678131104, -0.08968497067689896, 0.8596630096435547, 0.6412253975868225, -0.4540369510650635, 0.6700154542922974, 0.012973234057426453, -0.4791891276836395, 0.4256916642189026, -0.5453629493713379, -0.02897079661488533, -0.2148144394159317, -0.046132419258356094, -0.8407009243965149, -0.32388409972190857, 0.04965831711888313, -0.17917637526988983, 0.388568639755249, 0.1270536482334137, -0.7379323840141296, -0.3043390214443207, -0.21054792404174805, 0.6103057861328125, 0.33418548107147217, -0.4295254945755005, 0.9730149507522583, 0.46257394552230835, -0.1544434279203415, -0.3902972936630249, -0.7002182006835938, 0.4495425522327423, -0.13097602128982544, -0.679757297039032, 0.20323814451694489, -0.21038879454135895, -0.4237881898880005, -0.1905641257762909, 0.3958068788051605, -0.033398110419511795, 0.030505791306495667, 0.29595890641212463, 0.38918009400367737, -0.36110326647758484, 0.07429426163434982, -0.4660451412200928, -0.05096936970949173, 0.00196987041272223, -0.1231645941734314, 0.5478886365890503, -0.23585577309131622, -0.5799167156219482, -0.351112425327301, 0.5069573521614075, 1.0990912914276123, -0.6257463097572327, 0.6490941047668457, 0.6044797897338867, -0.3055252134799957, 0.1259903460741043, -0.8783016204833984, -0.13797032833099365, -0.4145914316177368, 0.591890811920166, -0.30918920040130615, -1.0945770740509033, 0.23946155607700348, -0.22911210358142853, 0.09561923891305923, 0.36806637048721313, 0.9793896675109863, 0.05942622199654579, 1.0872737169265747, 1.1778454780578613, -0.3902994394302368, 0.7502198815345764, 0.06603705883026123, 0.358222633600235, -0.8991000056266785, -0.3442828953266144, -0.28503578901290894, -0.21860633790493011, -0.5440644025802612, -0.6554111242294312, 0.4977057874202728, -0.22864705324172974, -0.12542445957660675, -0.06197717785835266, -0.1973612904548645, 0.3255652189254761, 0.5444992184638977, -0.202005997300148, 0.4986526072025299, -0.15504303574562073, 0.1773751825094223, 0.07189352065324783, -0.6847455501556396, -0.6473968625068665, 1.0957176685333252, 0.6069132685661316, 1.147068738937378, 0.05324086174368858, -0.021248599514365196, 0.09913996607065201, 0.19545945525169373, -0.9182034730911255, 0.5453488230705261, -0.22775396704673767, -0.7453619837760925, -0.3609273135662079, -0.18774326145648956, -0.5938416719436646, 0.32808488607406616, -0.23318184912204742, -0.4752393960952759, -0.08940786868333817, -0.01779784820973873, -0.16119150817394257, 0.6018795371055603, -0.6015525460243225, 0.6589558124542236, -0.5560330152511597, -0.14284518361091614, -0.4243267774581909, -0.6881042718887329, 0.5871840715408325, -0.2667165994644165, 0.3081543445587158, 0.009555628523230553, -0.17379657924175262, 0.29140418767929077, 0.13570141792297363, 0.9852145910263062, 0.18543295562267303, -0.38921159505844116, 0.28851258754730225, -0.12786851823329926, 0.2594829201698303, -0.14703021943569183, 0.14259858429431915, 0.3666662275791168, -0.05993263050913811, -0.062212180346250534, -0.17644886672496796, 0.6988662481307983, -0.7695896029472351, -0.6779731512069702, -0.16337676346302032, -0.9165241718292236, -0.1047646775841713, 0.2797934412956238, -0.196076899766922, 0.5134211778640747, -0.11428893357515335, 0.36529600620269775, 0.7613742351531982, -0.4840504229068756, 0.7157453894615173, 0.39852869510650635, -0.2988489866256714, -0.34334421157836914, 0.6864954233169556, -0.005701102782040834, 0.3670967221260071, 0.5050802826881409, -0.001655990956351161, -0.1517213135957718, -0.6259306073188782, -0.5187493562698364, 0.3506278395652771, -0.6468511819839478, -0.12465685606002808, -0.45887479186058044, -0.2812868356704712, -0.5030734539031982, -0.026103414595127106, -0.5329191088676453, -0.008947720751166344, -0.4028719663619995, 0.20852284133434296, 0.16335590183734894, 0.9100323915481567, 0.02983321063220501, 0.27167442440986633, -0.7485908269882202, 0.5696931481361389, 0.31666725873947144, 0.37435972690582275, 0.06892645359039307, -0.2257811427116394, -0.16762109100818634, 0.0866900160908699, -0.2880813479423523, -0.644413948059082, 0.322121798992157, 0.10831568390130997, 0.6065981388092041, 0.4541560113430023, -0.40768423676490784, 0.3574225902557373, -0.79703289270401, 0.9771993160247803, 0.35376447439193726, -0.760090708732605, 0.1890413612127304, -0.49416282773017883, 0.3210009038448334, -0.06868453323841095, 0.3084430992603302, -0.5908607244491577, -0.17257428169250488, -0.07307583093643188, -0.629948079586029, 0.5434470176696777, -0.20372696220874786, 0.3492364287376404, 0.24633784592151642, 0.3536606431007385, 0.043156564235687256, 0.30685582756996155, -0.9960328936576843, -0.1136225089430809, -0.1192980483174324, -0.267446368932724, -0.35924404859542847, -0.3391401469707489, -0.11494465172290802, -0.049385327845811844, 0.2951265871524811, -0.3603755533695221, 0.19587677717208862, -0.08447644859552383, -0.23990081250667572, 0.005484502296894789, 0.44536536931991577, 0.863654375076294, 0.7599067091941833, 0.2741381824016571, 0.14972835779190063, 0.061870887875556946, -0.20002995431423187, 0.021165387704968452, -0.0018853776855394244, -0.08103927224874496, -0.3270081579685211, 0.34667104482650757, 0.8331425189971924, 0.23754680156707764, -0.8371999263763428, 0.5727989077568054, 0.26042917370796204, -0.10999133437871933, -0.31983423233032227, -0.17367088794708252, 0.10985012352466583, 0.7011752724647522, 0.2509506046772003, 0.07646908611059189, -0.06797191500663757, -0.8440678119659424, -0.28595784306526184, 0.8209916353225708, -0.2284453958272934, -0.42944300174713135, 0.8324645757675171, 0.18294069170951843, -0.32208147644996643, 0.47019273042678833, 0.3740399181842804, -0.3854714035987854, 0.3374365568161011, 0.44508829712867737, 0.7594766020774841, -0.22690153121948242, -0.07830317318439484, -0.08814045041799545, 0.6564904451370239, -0.07924345880746841, 0.11280137300491333, 0.07260452955961227, -0.7362445592880249, -0.7073123455047607, -0.5332335233688354, -0.4239855706691742, 0.47372445464134216, -0.2356240153312683, 0.1626138985157013, -0.31074395775794983, -0.25325456261634827, -0.043270766735076904, -0.3322846293449402, -0.7073715925216675, 0.1526525467634201, 0.5610219240188599, 0.7906009554862976, -0.5830856561660767, 0.7515347599983215, 0.8015711307525635, -0.3141227960586548, -0.44281378388404846, -0.21400707960128784, -0.0956902801990509, -0.822086751461029, 0.5894447565078735, 0.029671747237443924, -0.18327878415584564, -0.0762200653553009, -0.6029167771339417, -0.9011611938476562, 1.0755729675292969, 0.4153580963611603, -0.5476439595222473, -0.3949528932571411, 0.46873289346694946, 0.39816033840179443, -0.3670275807380676, 0.2063201665878296, 0.41109997034072876, 0.561360776424408, -0.13554759323596954, -1.2320013046264648, -0.22424453496932983, 0.12502215802669525, 0.1852819323539734, 0.16844864189624786, -0.9281719326972961, 0.9463638067245483, -0.39703989028930664, 0.04366854950785637, 0.10694016516208649, 0.5210851430892944, -0.10338927060365677, 0.056603267788887024, 0.2971881330013275, 0.3328864276409149, 0.2668711543083191, -0.043087802827358246, 1.13265860080719, -0.30742543935775757, 0.04354199394583702, 0.6831053495407104, -0.3623448610305786, 0.8493975400924683, 0.6593860387802124, 0.0002442675468046218, 0.011527877300977707, 0.35267823934555054, -0.2536539137363434, 0.31865325570106506, -0.0654521957039833, -0.039976686239242554, -0.38129156827926636, -0.23691615462303162, -0.2256067544221878, 0.68274986743927, 0.35846656560897827, -0.5194675922393799, -0.13654294610023499, 0.3140088617801666, -0.2586410641670227, -0.0815296620130539, -0.505023717880249, 0.730728805065155, 0.26078101992607117, -0.363942414522171, 0.13332006335258484, 0.26512813568115234, 0.8531002998352051, -0.5662800073623657, 0.15024805068969727, 0.16618385910987854, 0.25521382689476013, 0.08942625671625137, -0.61236172914505, 0.14330698549747467, -0.0264771468937397, -0.5663232207298279, -0.3251015841960907, 0.703291654586792, -0.38489043712615967, -0.5548491477966309, 0.28113406896591187, 0.8219300508499146, -0.09145975112915039, -0.08097048103809357, -0.6412599682807922, 0.3857842981815338, -0.24795806407928467, -0.3049863576889038, 0.24685953557491302, 0.3099021315574646, -0.052229490131139755, 0.9605560302734375, 0.5265180468559265, 0.06334491819143295, 0.34085404872894287, 0.122159443795681, 0.8166883587837219, -0.7667688727378845, -0.1323472261428833, -0.9101067185401917, 0.3871794641017914, 0.3042450547218323, -0.07598196715116501, 0.5979293584823608, 0.4739292860031128, 0.7256556749343872, -0.15098406374454498, 0.7635735869407654, 0.21448282897472382, 0.27331194281578064, -0.6166335344314575, 0.7563934326171875, -0.7377431392669678, -0.10282083600759506, -0.18566451966762543, -1.0562341213226318, -0.46098122000694275, 0.38405662775039673, -0.3218599557876587, 0.227096825838089, 0.4124855101108551, 0.6893470883369446, -0.11843980103731155, -0.05607328563928604, 0.7262508869171143, 0.20170800387859344, 0.5530340671539307, 0.4412379860877991, 1.089560866355896, -0.28538164496421814, 0.4647710919380188, 0.2539994716644287, -0.14153920114040375, -0.26820045709609985, -0.8885655999183655, -0.8954440951347351, -0.6706620454788208, -0.10263024270534515, 0.22813698649406433, -0.3543332517147064, 0.7669305205345154, 0.9210307598114014, -0.5556102991104126, -0.38846004009246826, 0.2438308298587799, -0.10313264280557632, 0.14275607466697693, -0.15707175433635712, 0.03910192474722862, -0.3136635422706604, -0.9474554657936096, 0.5514091849327087, 0.5247875452041626, 0.28619423508644104, -0.7702971696853638, -0.08220415562391281, -0.16561169922351837, 0.195924311876297, 1.0826971530914307, 0.061078350991010666, -1.1802302598953247, -0.22859293222427368, 0.0658823549747467, -0.18163034319877625, 0.1244673877954483, 0.8664288520812988, -0.5001305341720581, 0.33216071128845215, 0.3062903881072998, 0.8469489812850952, 0.2762121856212616, -0.33434194326400757, 0.601481556892395, -0.15276457369327545, 0.16966016590595245, 0.24826085567474365, 0.582726776599884, 0.5302184820175171, 0.07249947637319565, 0.2305489033460617, 0.07246389985084534, -0.6601175665855408, -0.7960819005966187, 0.44128450751304626, -1.0050065517425537, -0.30703234672546387, 1.2318408489227295, 0.20894397795200348, -0.15909676253795624, 0.1758173257112503, -0.3403984308242798, 0.11071192473173141, 0.034932538866996765, 0.7120168209075928, 0.7452871799468994, 0.024683183059096336, -0.5437924265861511, -0.8223191499710083, 0.22487510740756989, 0.21087197959423065, -0.8744025826454163, 0.11735536903142929, 0.7750737071037292, 0.12639406323432922, 0.24925941228866577, 0.19893775880336761, -0.25125962495803833, -0.02136114425957203, -0.20155850052833557, -0.01901395246386528, -0.267383337020874, -0.7122278809547424, -0.4644688367843628, 0.26483532786369324, 0.2574346661567688, -0.023728875443339348 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19511v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19511v1
Improving Clinical NLP Performance through Language Model-Generated Synthetic Clinical Data
2024-03-28T15:44:18
2024-03-28T15:44:18
Shan Chen, Jack Gallifant, Marco Guevara, Yanjun Gao, Majid Afshar, Timothy Miller, Dmitriy Dligach, Danielle S. Bitterman
cs.CL
cs.CL
Generative models have been showing potential for producing data in mass. This study explores the enhancement of clinical natural language processing performance by utilizing synthetic data generated from advanced language models. Promising results show feasible applications in such a high-stakes domain.
[ 0.03555101156234741, -0.9270303249359131, 0.7424036860466003, 0.17994599044322968, -0.05365075170993805, 0.11593293398618698, -0.12336917221546173, -0.6577269434928894, 0.27205196022987366, 0.9037954807281494, -0.32479169964790344, -0.6383612751960754, -0.5403146743774414, 0.23569567501544952, -0.6251981258392334, 0.8064913153648376, 0.32455673813819885, 0.6740167737007141, -0.2715383768081665, -0.06311220675706863, -0.3215974271297455, -0.9138815999031067, -1.128580927848816, -0.5170766711235046, 0.2294609546661377, 0.018112927675247192, 1.049017071723938, 0.7784428596496582, 0.8037447333335876, 0.30170702934265137, 0.11074198782444, 0.2575899064540863, -0.2708163857460022, 0.4472137689590454, 0.02460469864308834, -0.6169208288192749, -0.8745223879814148, -0.31020423769950867, 0.5787714123725891, 0.978499174118042, -0.5936292409896851, -0.4459071755409241, -0.5184308290481567, 0.6663476228713989, -0.23747333884239197, 0.13836078345775604, -0.6835610866546631, 0.15298312902450562, -0.28311648964881897, -0.4910643994808197, -0.575568675994873, -0.454673171043396, 0.35931211709976196, -0.6988185048103333, 0.9056835770606995, -0.08694669604301453, 0.688071608543396, -0.1231805682182312, -0.15788495540618896, -0.5634413957595825, -1.020598292350769, 0.5159245729446411, -1.131422758102417, 0.4366825222969055, 0.53267902135849, 0.4556155800819397, -0.32359713315963745, -1.2067798376083374, -0.43307849764823914, -0.501317024230957, -0.051229968667030334, 0.24679526686668396, -0.19508731365203857, 0.43050506711006165, 0.33510926365852356, 0.766303539276123, -0.7573135495185852, 0.06662361323833466, -0.5879572033882141, 0.04189889505505562, 0.8681787252426147, 0.6639768481254578, 0.6914143562316895, -0.06274077296257019, 0.18661317229270935, -0.035847850143909454, -0.7764087319374084, -0.37353387475013733, -0.008994863368570805, 0.4923228919506073, 0.12964250147342682, 0.8872182369232178, -0.31186991930007935, 0.8137344121932983, -0.4207145869731903, -0.26223477721214294, 0.1461203545331955, -0.30974024534225464, -0.335030198097229, 0.29890283942222595, 0.5847115516662598, 0.43742066621780396, 0.1145561933517456, -0.3022139370441437, -0.1904529333114624, 0.49310827255249023, 0.615643322467804, -0.6938260197639465, -0.448911190032959, 0.37450218200683594, -0.4877932667732239, -0.3988516926765442, -0.2315281480550766, -0.6365513801574707, -0.5409389734268188, -0.6334112286567688, -0.04698009043931961, -0.7783294916152954, -0.15741190314292908, 0.5091872215270996, -0.14933961629867554, -0.24858754873275757, 0.23640963435173035, -1.0663762092590332, 0.6741906404495239, 0.4174836277961731, 0.8312140107154846, -0.23776130378246307, 0.33606040477752686, -0.35576847195625305, 0.2930753231048584, -0.5212240815162659, 0.7512728571891785, -0.5619373917579651, -0.5818857550621033, 0.2800881564617157, -0.21904030442237854, -0.13220827281475067, -1.0461276769638062, 0.569034993648529, -0.321042001247406, 0.20508192479610443, 0.10706408321857452, -0.7738896012306213, 0.24153059720993042, -0.027739325538277626, -0.8289884924888611, 0.9024512767791748, 0.36692148447036743, -0.39782044291496277, 0.36828354001045227, -0.8233101963996887, -0.6588374376296997, 0.517620861530304, -0.24395842850208282, -0.4049452245235443, 0.26766467094421387, 0.27882200479507446, 0.2785750925540924, -0.4027880132198334, 0.5755278468132019, -0.05820498988032341, 0.06776232272386551, 0.4321318566799164, -0.3489360809326172, 0.38778451085090637, 0.416586697101593, 0.09179351478815079, 0.07047339528799057, -1.2810635566711426, 0.11203700304031372, 0.08555561304092407, -0.29027748107910156, -0.40419304370880127, 0.12366710603237152, 0.32926011085510254, 0.06516791880130768, -0.2790850102901459, -0.5183790922164917, 0.14361152052879333, -0.7753514647483826, 0.4014039933681488, 0.08268193900585175, 0.15213502943515778, 0.14090996980667114, -0.47729170322418213, 0.9223334789276123, -0.11264742165803909, -0.02957523800432682, 0.03071920946240425, -0.6484306454658508, -0.6693781614303589, -0.2555069327354431, 0.39041128754615784, 0.4673709273338318, -0.8742657899856567, 0.06258577853441238, -0.2254285365343094, -0.45260632038116455, -0.9459991455078125, -0.1665087789297104, 0.25912007689476013, 0.6332352161407471, 0.6476064324378967, -0.3071572780609131, -0.8519924879074097, -1.0529733896255493, -0.19242846965789795, -0.037585243582725525, -0.3147898018360138, 0.19886454939842224, 0.08395489305257797, -0.38964927196502686, 0.7776891589164734, -0.8491011261940002, -0.2850130796432495, -0.5806919932365417, 0.30661800503730774, 0.15598496794700623, 0.5960006713867188, 0.4741324186325073, -0.6073537468910217, -0.39563262462615967, 0.03273649141192436, -0.8592268824577332, -0.27528613805770874, -0.2251909375190735, -0.15059395134449005, 0.0751391351222992, 0.4721589982509613, -0.7520796060562134, 0.6436526775360107, 0.5092670321464539, -0.13430912792682648, 0.6274110078811646, -0.6178551912307739, 0.08075454831123352, -1.0778242349624634, 0.06676171720027924, -0.14566130936145782, -0.3810936510562897, -1.1596511602401733, -0.02712869644165039, -0.13335855305194855, -0.3231269121170044, -0.4118804633617401, 0.41322609782218933, -0.22055135667324066, 0.2508874833583832, -0.3321826159954071, -0.08899189531803131, 0.014682777225971222, -0.2613254487514496, 0.5464907884597778, 0.7136865258216858, 0.47924214601516724, -0.6356667280197144, 0.4025340676307678, 0.5078542828559875, -0.3360351622104645, 0.3033443093299866, -0.9754489660263062, -0.0986548364162445, -0.06487700343132019, 0.09511472284793854, -0.7261042594909668, -0.6944155097007751, -0.38185447454452515, -0.3676810562610626, 0.20159949362277985, 0.014930223114788532, -0.5397284626960754, -0.4153568744659424, 0.18358077108860016, 0.2932318150997162, 0.6212820410728455, -0.1953279972076416, 0.2410499006509781, 0.38207197189331055, -0.48822999000549316, 0.11969758570194244, -0.8411948680877686, 0.273975133895874, 0.023022636771202087, -0.5671489834785461, 0.7976682186126709, 0.1208876520395279, -0.3061014413833618, -0.15795999765396118, 0.4668033719062805, -0.15077374875545502, -0.25005993247032166, 0.09568117558956146, 0.2991827726364136, -0.37109899520874023, 0.5005661249160767, 0.14667202532291412, -0.06202465668320656, 0.1566370725631714, 0.23161867260932922, 0.8287023305892944, 0.24491073191165924, -0.2426164150238037, -0.5238345861434937, 0.6579237580299377, 0.527886152267456, 0.09257061034440994, 1.1039364337921143, 0.2943927049636841, -0.6893846988677979, -0.1795819252729416, -0.3868066072463989, -0.23933802545070648, -0.44132667779922485, 0.31631019711494446, -0.1631176471710205, -0.5105841755867004, 0.3868289589881897, 0.07522144913673401, -0.2802543044090271, 0.3591277003288269, 0.850091278553009, 0.14064958691596985, 1.5529754161834717, 0.4332982003688812, 0.4599686861038208, 0.21537505090236664, -0.2087317258119583, 0.3601023256778717, -0.602023184299469, -0.19326251745224, -0.34566977620124817, 0.25360414385795593, -0.6830117702484131, -0.3973398506641388, 0.6371665596961975, 0.061837777495384216, 0.30685946345329285, 0.20346714556217194, -0.6235484480857849, 0.01480186078697443, 0.4813787043094635, 0.28053897619247437, 0.40151894092559814, -0.018535252660512924, -0.23778121173381805, -0.3795276880264282, -0.8531705737113953, -0.7432803511619568, 1.3181238174438477, 0.3703041076660156, 0.6113134622573853, 0.016733672469854355, 0.2960684895515442, 0.2666358947753906, 0.5960105657577515, -0.44329336285591125, 0.3384817838668823, -0.3665614426136017, -0.6451712846755981, 0.052694398909807205, -0.23526212573051453, -1.0719588994979858, 0.1584690362215042, -0.5756537318229675, -0.29345211386680603, -0.21613824367523193, 0.16621284186840057, -0.45828887820243835, -0.0006994898431003094, -0.6097664833068848, 0.44436803460121155, 0.05595075339078903, -0.14611570537090302, -0.29508596658706665, -0.3208470344543457, 0.39853185415267944, -0.07520876079797745, -0.11536742001771927, -0.051842547953128815, 0.3664233684539795, 0.6189413070678711, -0.7537906169891357, 0.6420450210571289, 0.07650180906057358, 0.03252655640244484, 0.2526343762874603, 0.044525399804115295, 0.38866958022117615, 0.29591619968414307, -0.2300039678812027, -0.08005926758050919, 0.011872229166328907, -0.4254221022129059, -0.5798375606536865, 0.48328202962875366, -0.37700703740119934, -0.4671444296836853, -0.33199000358581543, -0.7986699938774109, -0.5575757622718811, -0.04616387560963631, 0.35712912678718567, 0.7649943232536316, -0.389653742313385, 0.11033137142658234, 0.22803957760334015, -0.5207842588424683, 0.19791512191295624, 0.45334577560424805, -0.1889333575963974, -0.5020282864570618, 0.5257981419563293, -0.0201883502304554, 0.6237974166870117, 0.33016884326934814, 0.15810701251029968, -0.4940558969974518, -0.9607688188552856, -0.3359423875808716, 0.32953113317489624, -0.5030546188354492, -0.045703206211328506, -0.8952423334121704, -0.5706570148468018, -0.8106866478919983, -0.2833654582500458, -0.4747961759567261, -0.7305000424385071, -0.2572336494922638, -0.23296505212783813, 0.5002036094665527, 0.7635542154312134, 0.16195286810398102, 0.5907569527626038, -1.045246958732605, 0.5334158539772034, -0.017393218353390694, 0.17411917448043823, -0.18639147281646729, -0.100931316614151, -0.05590759217739105, 0.17382055521011353, -0.3658631443977356, -0.740253210067749, 1.192547082901001, 0.29493722319602966, 0.5146862268447876, 0.30744504928588867, -0.1938704401254654, 0.7544631361961365, -0.592460572719574, 0.895561158657074, 0.2813390791416168, -0.6639963984489441, 0.8693042397499084, -0.6473381519317627, 0.31675654649734497, 0.34138911962509155, 0.33048126101493835, -0.5249783992767334, -0.6366246938705444, -0.8384670615196228, -0.7330396175384521, 0.46306946873664856, 0.5279965996742249, 0.013330207206308842, -0.22446586191654205, 0.4939245879650116, 0.2281264066696167, 0.29155072569847107, -0.4455554783344269, -0.0970899760723114, 0.17365552484989166, -0.45082733035087585, -0.03829663246870041, -0.17316016554832458, -0.22230054438114166, -0.46782186627388, 0.4345749318599701, -0.216557577252388, 0.4280000925064087, 0.4555956721305847, 0.21383069455623627, -0.1211307942867279, 0.06416624039411545, 0.7333897352218628, 0.8794363737106323, -0.14027898013591766, -0.024183643981814384, 0.09467877447605133, -0.684904158115387, -0.1531294733285904, 0.04517073556780815, -0.17973683774471283, 0.27356889843940735, 0.7519901990890503, 0.6708394885063171, -0.1620991826057434, -1.0434778928756714, 0.0982498973608017, -0.17313480377197266, -0.1822117120027542, -0.404011070728302, 0.29531827569007874, 0.13350291550159454, -0.17980699241161346, 0.02017057314515114, 0.0678100511431694, 0.3878282308578491, -0.6254549622535706, 0.38793450593948364, 0.2643842399120331, -0.16224433481693268, -0.42421194911003113, 0.9278353452682495, -0.056633852422237396, -0.457773894071579, 0.9680860042572021, 0.36900538206100464, -0.28921449184417725, 0.592578113079071, 1.1049365997314453, 0.5909537076950073, -0.42332974076271057, 0.3836635649204254, 0.4187418222427368, -0.2611207067966461, -0.062295228242874146, 0.45534539222717285, 0.33630046248435974, -0.6826437711715698, -0.4949544370174408, -0.6497136950492859, -0.38304150104522705, 0.4953623116016388, -0.8365412354469299, 0.3322589099407196, -0.3624994158744812, -0.490033358335495, 0.3544752597808838, -0.2941698431968689, -0.6106863617897034, 0.6284370422363281, 0.04100314527750015, 0.6855811476707458, -0.6630325317382812, 0.9420427680015564, 0.5255550742149353, -0.324290931224823, -0.4490867853164673, -0.45833176374435425, -0.2970702648162842, -0.8094375133514404, 0.6433454155921936, -0.19917051494121552, 0.21693678200244904, -0.19646351039409637, -0.2869749367237091, -0.5907782912254333, 0.7161058783531189, 0.19245083630084991, -0.5282751321792603, -0.17853964865207672, 0.926358163356781, 1.2867560386657715, -0.6083864569664001, 0.22998324036598206, 0.7633344531059265, 0.07549633085727692, 0.1520853042602539, -0.8896198868751526, -0.02356388047337532, -0.43211629986763, 0.2554427683353424, 0.06670495122671127, 0.08659812808036804, 0.7691547274589539, -0.16859544813632965, -0.1605217158794403, 0.30692607164382935, 0.35477232933044434, 0.417072057723999, 0.42790326476097107, 0.052407387644052505, 0.5652329325675964, 0.7476369142532349, -0.08530009537935257, 1.503224492073059, -0.21661688387393951, 0.01862557977437973, 0.8882929682731628, -0.4143989682197571, 0.7041240930557251, 0.22993488609790802, -0.3383508622646332, 0.3922313451766968, 0.30422860383987427, 0.23265433311462402, 0.41802045702934265, 0.22141492366790771, -0.591579258441925, -0.15505802631378174, -0.3193453252315521, -0.43878820538520813, 0.43786078691482544, 0.7478301525115967, -0.9039700031280518, 0.1171170175075531, 0.08340800553560257, -0.06720135360956192, 0.3147813677787781, -0.10663476586341858, 0.7536728382110596, 0.19287672638893127, -0.7419052124023438, 0.7378067374229431, 0.05934397503733635, 0.04685381427407265, -0.6502906680107117, -0.3694837987422943, 0.05267516151070595, 0.34952032566070557, -0.09861218184232712, -0.3998107314109802, 0.737072229385376, -0.14706462621688843, -0.1476997584104538, -0.23452788591384888, 0.7668872475624084, -0.5872493386268616, -0.738423764705658, 0.07299855351448059, 0.43672654032707214, 0.038470618426799774, 0.10357971489429474, -0.5171077847480774, -0.17356158792972565, -0.27298298478126526, 0.04020698741078377, 0.19362872838974, 0.09187374264001846, -0.12299365550279617, 0.8531685471534729, 0.983325183391571, 0.8020856380462646, 0.24569755792617798, 0.5008745193481445, 0.6717243790626526, -0.7510033845901489, -0.49481526017189026, -0.6205013394355774, 0.2638838291168213, -0.261945515871048, -0.44101983308792114, 0.4566466808319092, 0.7192314267158508, 0.4451545178890228, -0.3074415922164917, 0.8172172904014587, 0.11360879987478256, 0.8330729007720947, -0.8160576820373535, 0.6430362462997437, -0.21340209245681763, 0.04816478118300438, -0.17568670213222504, -0.4470999538898468, -0.7812972068786621, 0.3781893849372864, -0.1868528127670288, -0.2208988219499588, 0.7085158824920654, 0.888720691204071, 0.04197387769818306, 0.38323092460632324, 0.4822506308555603, 0.2045179009437561, 0.7526022791862488, 0.5302339792251587, 0.7289900779724121, -0.5399536490440369, -0.23715797066688538, -0.425895631313324, 0.0440063551068306, -0.04566306993365288, -0.6434964537620544, -0.8122941851615906, -0.6154281497001648, -0.3980836272239685, -0.5196818113327026, 0.09012679755687714, 0.7819473743438721, 0.8688815832138062, -1.0244693756103516, -0.009275288321077824, -0.6972602009773254, -0.5557500720024109, -0.2336708903312683, -0.3093467652797699, 0.5400567054748535, -0.4554141163825989, -0.7739694714546204, 0.6570048332214355, 0.11308982223272324, 0.44889548420906067, -0.12560689449310303, -0.06697873771190643, 0.048785846680402756, 0.2860424518585205, 0.7731956243515015, -0.003046932630240917, -0.5528265237808228, 0.15879939496517181, -0.06890843063592911, -0.16614659130573273, 0.09787346422672272, 1.157806396484375, -0.7413168549537659, 0.72198486328125, 0.41294601559638977, 0.49502071738243103, 0.4731559455394745, 0.1722222864627838, 1.159766674041748, -0.5605389475822449, 0.09501133114099503, 0.724289059638977, 0.27364546060562134, 0.46023625135421753, -0.5637842416763306, 0.6237627267837524, 0.3032033443450928, -0.36173155903816223, -0.8878602981567383, 0.03693835437297821, -0.8051349520683289, -0.0599672868847847, 1.1590291261672974, 0.152244433760643, 0.16062308847904205, -0.33584481477737427, -0.31463423371315, 0.27217668294906616, -0.008113956078886986, 0.9212315082550049, 0.5317894816398621, -0.7192912101745605, 0.1623838245868683, -1.0530829429626465, 0.9943678975105286, 0.4794226288795471, -1.0491222143173218, -0.09922398626804352, 0.4538058638572693, -0.013014364056289196, 0.018214769661426544, 0.7908362150192261, -0.5557555556297302, 0.2711300551891327, 0.10328151285648346, 0.014198565855622292, 0.2543277442455292, -0.1332399547100067, -0.13525094091892242, 0.2659619450569153, -0.07407388836145401, 0.1488213688135147 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19509v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19509v1
Phonetic Segmentation of the UCLA Phonetics Lab Archive
2024-03-28T15:42:07
2024-03-28T15:42:07
Eleanor Chodroff, Blaž Pažon, Annie Baker, Steven Moran
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
Research in speech technologies and comparative linguistics depends on access to diverse and accessible speech data. The UCLA Phonetics Lab Archive is one of the earliest multilingual speech corpora, with long-form audio recordings and phonetic transcriptions for 314 languages (Ladefoged et al., 2009). Recently, 95 of these languages were time-aligned with word-level phonetic transcriptions (Li et al., 2021). Here we present VoxAngeles, a corpus of audited phonetic transcriptions and phone-level alignments of the UCLA Phonetics Lab Archive, which uses the 95-language CMU re-release as our starting point. VoxAngeles also includes word- and phone-level segmentations from the original UCLA corpus, as well as phonetic measurements of word and phone durations, vowel formants, and vowel f0. This corpus enhances the usability of the original data, particularly for quantitative phonetic typology, as demonstrated through a case study of vowel intrinsic f0. We also discuss the utility of the VoxAngeles corpus for general research and pedagogy in crosslinguistic phonetics, as well as for low-resource and multilingual speech technologies. VoxAngeles is free to download and use under a CC-BY-NC 4.0 license.
[ -0.2571107745170593, -0.6178776621818542, 0.26473501324653625, 0.2185637503862381, -0.1948673576116562, 0.44668862223625183, -0.1037205383181572, -0.3472136855125427, 0.46980753540992737, 0.4377670884132385, -0.3157399594783783, -0.6328839659690857, 0.049983128905296326, 0.2495638132095337, -0.45756757259368896, 0.47892147302627563, 0.37794429063796997, 0.3439768850803375, 0.048787157982587814, -0.3272930979728699, -0.15427418053150177, -0.7225104570388794, -0.676873505115509, 0.031831562519073486, 0.9616565108299255, 0.3005391061306, 0.49030181765556335, 0.6687324047088623, 0.09644607454538345, 0.2676665186882019, -0.21706326305866241, -0.22557076811790466, -0.3764162063598633, 0.002729482715949416, -0.001918281544931233, -0.3444213271141052, -0.44109195470809937, -0.03328012675046921, 0.9211301803588867, 1.0598156452178955, -0.3063579201698303, 0.1010354533791542, -0.12354981154203415, 0.4594923257827759, -0.3423798084259033, -0.22225728631019592, -0.5544971227645874, 0.15217432379722595, -0.6940096020698547, -0.24401536583900452, -0.3458719849586487, -0.4328047037124634, 0.24478018283843994, -0.7128978967666626, 0.4139833152294159, 0.05647009611129761, 0.46845048666000366, 0.027227576822042465, -0.23334477841854095, -0.03823689743876457, -0.6592846512794495, 0.8651034235954285, -0.2527633607387543, 1.1395561695098877, 0.24533772468566895, 0.3376813232898712, -0.17076554894447327, -0.6366350650787354, -0.37222805619239807, 0.04368233308196068, 0.24823695421218872, -0.0058729457668960094, -0.4952523112297058, -0.037072956562042236, 0.06583140790462494, 0.39998823404312134, -0.8802483081817627, 0.41473475098609924, -0.9697446823120117, -0.6701062321662903, 0.4312131702899933, -0.12596382200717926, 0.46294912695884705, -0.2797437608242035, -0.10907915234565735, -0.40091338753700256, -0.7355053424835205, 0.0069634513929486275, 0.6488264203071594, 0.3778883218765259, -0.17594856023788452, 0.7505932450294495, -0.02420097216963768, 0.5218527317047119, -0.22510112822055817, -0.26218342781066895, 0.6562637090682983, -0.2913934290409088, -0.20203757286071777, 0.5051552653312683, 0.6771472692489624, -0.15996535122394562, 0.06297571212053299, -0.2846306264400482, 0.2553587853908539, -0.16242404282093048, 0.2482641190290451, -0.5874052047729492, -0.2577608823776245, 0.42371171712875366, -0.3372572660446167, -0.12101668864488602, -0.151570662856102, -0.5705242156982422, -0.01181632000952959, -0.4704870879650116, -0.029392536729574203, -0.7721680402755737, -0.2860567271709442, -0.03877408057451248, -0.32685235142707825, 0.107200987637043, 0.2486080527305603, -0.6502159237861633, 0.20901601016521454, 0.6041412949562073, 0.8735272884368896, -0.16468186676502228, -0.41721805930137634, -0.6448742151260376, 0.05396014824509621, -0.3235008120536804, 0.6911600828170776, -0.49502575397491455, -0.8976401090621948, 0.13779518008232117, 0.24532628059387207, -0.1400505006313324, -0.7116963267326355, 0.7034808993339539, -0.24784041941165924, 0.45355144143104553, -0.2511078119277954, -0.5687713623046875, -0.16551564633846283, -0.11450181901454926, -0.6523961424827576, 0.9599518179893494, 0.142155259847641, -0.3706092834472656, 0.3018404245376587, -0.40314963459968567, -0.344914048910141, 0.08921323716640472, -0.25471392273902893, -0.22763508558273315, 0.13115452229976654, 0.1438818871974945, 0.08554130792617798, 0.1676333099603653, -0.0712997168302536, -0.20441128313541412, -0.06048676744103432, 0.37725114822387695, -0.4625508785247803, 1.2954552173614502, 0.352373868227005, 0.09317362308502197, 0.3570612668991089, -1.0467629432678223, 0.06470577418804169, -0.09961513429880142, -0.5004060864448547, -0.21030735969543457, -0.010693932883441448, -0.026197005063295364, -0.24789170920848846, -0.003639351576566696, -0.9361026883125305, 0.06945635378360748, -0.08553493767976761, 0.34240058064460754, 0.29564276337623596, -0.20633776485919952, 0.4501364529132843, -0.3409186601638794, 0.636417806148529, 0.009112517349421978, 0.10128207504749298, 0.04453792795538902, -0.5719208121299744, -0.3377297818660736, -0.5353602170944214, 0.4462461471557617, 0.5192434191703796, -0.37011849880218506, 0.17384670674800873, -0.32673561573028564, -0.5423028469085693, -0.7419255971908569, 0.006869669537991285, 0.19748397171497345, 0.5268200039863586, 0.5792871117591858, -0.24202528595924377, -0.5078366994857788, -0.7327884435653687, 0.14321739971637726, -0.24224667251110077, -0.22766345739364624, 0.09260634332895279, -0.23938845098018646, -0.016759512946009636, 0.66240394115448, -0.08958958089351654, -0.1672385185956955, -0.15333423018455505, 0.1330115646123886, -0.020550521090626717, 0.3557824492454529, 0.6334280371665955, -0.5584141612052917, -0.016957571730017662, -0.13153941929340363, -0.36029887199401855, -0.21855880320072174, 0.3624778985977173, -0.10735277086496353, 0.14698366820812225, 0.6215957999229431, -0.3170807659626007, 0.1860169768333435, 0.603262722492218, -0.10645721107721329, 0.5652065277099609, -0.05155571550130844, -0.007754886522889137, -0.8790243268013, 0.118181012570858, -0.13297992944717407, -0.17368550598621368, -0.5972351431846619, -0.5199577212333679, 0.08075736463069916, -0.27775779366493225, -0.8700726628303528, 0.4578225612640381, -0.628633975982666, -0.32239973545074463, 0.08879068493843079, 0.262952983379364, 0.0693790540099144, 0.12579040229320526, 0.18384531140327454, 0.735443115234375, 0.40419939160346985, -0.3771495819091797, 0.13004747033119202, 0.138530895113945, -0.2924484312534332, 0.5966599583625793, -0.54678875207901, 0.09288237988948822, 0.054117146879434586, 0.3191014528274536, -0.6701991558074951, -0.07242415100336075, 0.1167471632361412, -0.4817756712436676, 0.28878504037857056, -0.40004274249076843, -0.07020317763090134, -0.23401471972465515, -0.38717103004455566, 0.8024938106536865, 0.39748573303222656, -0.41538766026496887, 0.10583516955375671, 0.8689162731170654, -0.3273163437843323, -0.4549875855445862, -0.4768461585044861, 0.06636614352464676, -0.2801247835159302, -0.49703535437583923, 0.2971155643463135, -0.032460443675518036, -0.3736402988433838, -0.016883788630366325, 0.10859069228172302, -0.23299606144428253, -0.1409401148557663, 0.17569133639335632, 0.22651611268520355, -0.5410471558570862, -0.025664713233709335, 0.09068579971790314, 0.2092580795288086, 0.03219930827617645, -0.4053628146648407, 0.6084386110305786, 0.1233869194984436, -0.2885914146900177, -0.44415873289108276, 0.345577210187912, 0.5480910539627075, -0.11960773169994354, 0.261515349149704, 0.7586031556129456, -0.4348343312740326, 0.05311272293329239, -0.7241485118865967, 0.015082179568707943, -0.37461480498313904, 0.13206321001052856, -0.35273489356040955, -0.9191396832466125, 0.3401847183704376, 0.38531312346458435, 0.07080920040607452, 0.42709800601005554, 0.27597150206565857, -0.13881047070026398, 0.6320430636405945, 0.1807253658771515, -0.33007463812828064, 0.5978772044181824, -0.2102372795343399, -0.049218300729990005, -1.0592790842056274, -0.3579340875148773, -0.7990779280662537, -0.18837247788906097, -0.4749722480773926, -0.5643796920776367, 0.15936793386936188, -0.11921133100986481, 0.35441598296165466, 0.18302632868289948, -0.5673366785049438, 0.35318613052368164, 0.5790339112281799, -0.16492615640163422, 0.17933428287506104, 0.32656949758529663, -0.1964646726846695, -0.07767615467309952, -0.5961998105049133, -0.37603577971458435, 0.9860827922821045, 0.3622611165046692, 0.4332493841648102, 0.27558958530426025, 0.9964633584022522, 0.24663205444812775, -0.14299464225769043, -0.8903259038925171, 0.4495949149131775, -0.2907293438911438, -0.5062824487686157, -0.5255651473999023, -0.42518943548202515, -1.4279354810714722, 0.3757023513317108, 0.09524907916784286, -0.9679412841796875, 0.5346994996070862, 0.013952226378023624, -0.41204893589019775, 0.13751159608364105, -0.6480116248130798, 0.779245913028717, -0.2785014808177948, -0.06501524150371552, -0.24426576495170593, -0.47419387102127075, 0.15743610262870789, 0.0975908637046814, 0.3183336555957794, -0.24730923771858215, 0.1674627661705017, 1.0985310077667236, -0.4967527985572815, 0.6719182729721069, -0.05073115974664688, -0.18081791698932648, 0.49264800548553467, 0.14562751352787018, -0.35787877440452576, -0.07104871422052383, 0.021398546174168587, 0.4498935341835022, 0.4338955283164978, -0.2785085141658783, -0.037402812391519547, 0.7762651443481445, -0.7199639081954956, -0.37854069471359253, -0.2988108694553375, -0.41355183720588684, -0.14693878591060638, 0.4169621765613556, 0.2996278405189514, 0.8453851342201233, -0.6993982791900635, 0.4107588529586792, 0.5436201095581055, -0.18741431832313538, 0.39244934916496277, 0.25269898772239685, -0.4609122574329376, -0.4887000322341919, 1.1405534744262695, 0.2603517472743988, -0.061156485229730606, 0.4687764644622803, 0.43668970465660095, -0.6792353391647339, -0.8263270258903503, -0.6013126969337463, 0.3579675257205963, -0.2506161034107208, 0.09831805527210236, -0.6558926701545715, -0.23013101518154144, -0.799184262752533, -0.027921337634325027, -0.4443049728870392, -0.9065205454826355, -0.3891925811767578, -0.12701407074928284, 0.07589330524206161, 0.6244192719459534, -0.510132908821106, 0.0137032400816679, -0.9658269286155701, 0.42559710144996643, 0.22200536727905273, -0.26626503467559814, -0.3177020251750946, -0.4073907732963562, 0.00033453298965469003, 0.22834378480911255, -0.2532084882259369, -0.7208535075187683, 0.3249020576477051, 0.19267836213111877, 0.6341153979301453, 0.29644298553466797, -0.24980466067790985, 0.49418580532073975, -0.4697437286376953, 0.8566023111343384, 0.19920635223388672, -0.7423537373542786, 0.35806331038475037, -0.5230532884597778, 0.3923235237598419, 0.4917512536048889, 0.2240222990512848, -0.681650698184967, -0.5025894641876221, -0.6446585059165955, -0.8005332350730896, 0.5492708683013916, 0.17742250859737396, -0.15861016511917114, -0.17810292541980743, -0.10386694222688675, 0.2516002357006073, 0.05746334046125412, -0.09357946366071701, -0.04760359600186348, -0.37756243348121643, -0.2980920076370239, 0.04457133635878563, -0.19520486891269684, -0.39844849705696106, -0.21254505217075348, 0.6154369115829468, 0.05306205525994301, 0.06092628091573715, 0.3007458746433258, -0.35920199751853943, 0.05512763932347298, 0.4975188970565796, 0.850728452205658, 0.912662148475647, -0.33165377378463745, 0.24011197686195374, 0.062103595584630966, -0.9141731262207031, 0.0819498673081398, 0.2081146091222763, -0.011648948304355145, 0.3499792218208313, 0.3146217167377472, 0.47886690497398376, 0.3183162808418274, -0.42235520482063293, 0.16337591409683228, -0.20352913439273834, -0.22528192400932312, -0.37190741300582886, -0.03522583842277527, 0.29851052165031433, 0.07769323885440826, 0.2949881851673126, -0.4682084918022156, 0.1818418800830841, -0.7095050811767578, 0.13707496225833893, 0.23454323410987854, -0.2789616286754608, -0.5607731342315674, 0.5921993851661682, 0.2682248651981354, -0.5254695415496826, 0.708003044128418, 0.013132362626492977, -0.3449859321117401, 0.35263752937316895, 0.27197718620300293, 0.8915432095527649, -0.4906204640865326, 0.38504457473754883, 0.43291205167770386, 0.017335861921310425, 0.19895592331886292, 0.4188556671142578, -0.13517795503139496, -0.6377917528152466, -0.07537186145782471, -0.7432264685630798, -0.5795015096664429, 0.1161990538239479, -0.6431850790977478, 0.13607020676136017, -0.38718336820602417, -0.21179485321044922, 0.2959311008453369, -0.3014072775840759, -0.6822258830070496, 0.22348365187644958, 0.4804515242576599, 0.8621176481246948, -0.3577441871166229, 1.0466135740280151, 0.45955926179885864, 0.0004943188978359103, -0.7014912962913513, -0.4302275478839874, 0.4363536238670349, -0.8236600756645203, 0.5403363108634949, -0.0671115517616272, -0.30687814950942993, -0.020196858793497086, 0.008193870075047016, -0.7989628314971924, 0.831912100315094, 0.2712305188179016, -0.7573340535163879, 0.013655395247042179, 0.4590141177177429, 0.4716745913028717, -0.17061187326908112, 0.023020487278699875, 0.5652040243148804, 0.25425803661346436, -0.05149492248892784, -1.0569945573806763, -0.2927030026912689, -0.011344801634550095, -0.44291627407073975, 0.23634080588817596, -0.33792394399642944, 0.6009684801101685, -0.04426494613289833, -0.4171801805496216, 0.08782584220170975, 0.791164755821228, 0.32745012640953064, 0.296963632106781, 0.5450319051742554, 0.690538227558136, 1.1653954982757568, -0.15365613996982574, 0.6971096992492676, -0.06473971903324127, -0.1167517751455307, 1.0516093969345093, -0.14463135600090027, 0.9347259998321533, 0.5867851972579956, -0.38380318880081177, 0.3150506615638733, 0.6262415051460266, 0.16309770941734314, 0.13716423511505127, 0.2350950986146927, -0.25166475772857666, 0.1752721667289734, -0.3909788131713867, -0.5797041654586792, 0.5616337656974792, 0.47995302081108093, 0.01519461814314127, -0.03025829792022705, -0.24921447038650513, 0.12043431401252747, -0.40120619535446167, -0.024188701063394547, 0.5352702736854553, 0.11090909689664841, -0.4308791756629944, 0.5269551277160645, -0.5049252510070801, 0.14411258697509766, -0.5246323943138123, 0.2273797243833542, -0.08438760787248611, -0.07776842266321182, -0.19140994548797607, -0.8390657901763916, 0.2363530695438385, -0.13373111188411713, 0.05620240420103073, -0.05375591292977333, 0.3458581268787384, -0.5550450086593628, -0.6056755185127258, 0.28349897265434265, 0.668003261089325, 0.425841361284256, 0.1711963415145874, -0.4371107816696167, 0.31954142451286316, -0.03514920920133591, 0.030868323519825935, 0.19042474031448364, 0.39262399077415466, -0.1270608752965927, 0.30527862906455994, 0.7950379252433777, 0.383479505777359, 0.6024099588394165, 0.6428791880607605, 0.40882188081741333, -0.6352423429489136, -0.47687333822250366, -0.42330750823020935, 0.3110237419605255, -0.17557086050510406, -0.5081081986427307, 0.7414056062698364, 1.0924105644226074, 1.0496907234191895, 0.13210028409957886, 0.7638489007949829, 0.13786126673221588, 0.7541937232017517, -0.8220800757408142, 0.5261711478233337, -0.4597199261188507, 0.06787274777889252, -0.13383303582668304, -1.197576880455017, -0.24469350278377533, 0.3745148777961731, -0.07820770889520645, -0.429728239774704, 0.7608340978622437, 0.5538141131401062, -0.2780008912086487, 0.17074038088321686, 0.38354435563087463, -0.01839500293135643, 0.3396914601325989, -0.0013506292598322034, 0.8525784611701965, 0.05445706099271774, 0.5953975319862366, -0.7603749632835388, -0.03141622617840767, -0.1473960131406784, -0.5212546586990356, -0.5604711174964905, -0.7280519008636475, -0.38724371790885925, -0.1480349600315094, -0.03788096085190773, 0.6856505870819092, 0.6218904256820679, -0.7842393517494202, -0.6958847045898438, 0.3260165750980377, 0.1911361962556839, 0.17705138027668, -0.2452472746372223, 0.373492032289505, -0.13355839252471924, -0.8437587022781372, 1.1710410118103027, 0.26722872257232666, 0.33248063921928406, -0.16247110068798065, 0.11698593944311142, -0.020404404029250145, -0.11572254449129105, 0.4570467472076416, 0.857730507850647, -0.6488876342773438, -0.3497447371482849, 0.26677030324935913, 0.11479122936725616, 0.3631908595561981, 1.110459327697754, -0.5187436938285828, 0.443364679813385, 0.5859544277191162, 0.2990410327911377, 0.32172587513923645, -0.06432202458381653, 0.6093668937683105, -0.5894002318382263, 0.3546234667301178, 0.35428616404533386, 0.7752345204353333, 0.5882654786109924, -0.024923287332057953, 0.41810306906700134, 0.29220908880233765, -0.5110119581222534, -0.9114809036254883, -0.1099470779299736, -1.5042409896850586, -0.1565958708524704, 1.0922402143478394, 0.1283484846353531, -0.49705034494400024, -0.3085867166519165, -0.34778377413749695, 0.34311625361442566, -0.5922073125839233, 0.5510647892951965, 0.5621635317802429, -0.2430814802646637, -0.10182566940784454, -0.2506205141544342, 0.4598807096481323, 0.3321927785873413, -0.6002670526504517, -0.14887890219688416, 0.7888374924659729, 0.3127453327178955, 0.4929335415363312, 0.7124311923980713, -0.2546837627887726, 0.12855330109596252, 0.020470326766371727, -0.006622439716011286, 0.12205632776021957, -0.5126957893371582, -0.2525319457054138, 0.21843479573726654, -0.035760749131441116, -0.5395637154579163 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19454v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19454v1
JDocQA: Japanese Document Question Answering Dataset for Generative Language Models
2024-03-28T14:22:54
2024-03-28T14:22:54
Eri Onami, Shuhei Kurita, Taiki Miyanishi, Taro Watanabe
cs.CL
cs.CL
Document question answering is a task of question answering on given documents such as reports, slides, pamphlets, and websites, and it is a truly demanding task as paper and electronic forms of documents are so common in our society. This is known as a quite challenging task because it requires not only text understanding but also understanding of figures and tables, and hence visual question answering (VQA) methods are often examined in addition to textual approaches. We introduce Japanese Document Question Answering (JDocQA), a large-scale document-based QA dataset, essentially requiring both visual and textual information to answer questions, which comprises 5,504 documents in PDF format and annotated 11,600 question-and-answer instances in Japanese. Each QA instance includes references to the document pages and bounding boxes for the answer clues. We incorporate multiple categories of questions and unanswerable questions from the document for realistic question-answering applications. We empirically evaluate the effectiveness of our dataset with text-based large language models (LLMs) and multimodal models. Incorporating unanswerable questions in finetuning may contribute to harnessing the so-called hallucination generation.
[ -0.5495344996452332, -1.3288897275924683, 0.8344100713729858, -0.16064025461673737, -0.4372950494289398, -0.03525612875819206, 0.007691146340221167, -0.2776286005973816, -0.0699489563703537, 1.0110161304473877, -0.8240477442741394, -0.7817177772521973, -0.25185635685920715, 0.2788475751876831, -0.3521656095981598, 0.6491817831993103, -0.3331148326396942, 0.17170970141887665, -0.7426235675811768, -0.134010449051857, -0.6193211674690247, -0.19596590101718903, -0.538152813911438, -0.005396633874624968, 0.24106042087078094, 0.5331618189811707, 0.6511877179145813, 0.29203325510025024, 0.49433159828186035, 0.3148123025894165, 0.20224164426326752, 0.19531220197677612, -0.19144023954868317, 0.2815723419189453, 0.1152099221944809, -0.8821040987968445, -0.04478158801794052, -0.21066302061080933, 0.6655684113502502, 0.90382981300354, -0.01313832774758339, 0.30562153458595276, -0.1616363823413849, 0.46496516466140747, -0.5803410410881042, 0.19364820420742035, -0.6217115521430969, 0.2574753165245056, -0.14699526131153107, -0.2811454236507416, -0.3278258144855499, -0.37588220834732056, -0.1471778303384781, -1.1719145774841309, 0.3001050651073456, -0.055972665548324585, 0.8019947409629822, 0.30371618270874023, -0.3761315643787384, -0.6433611512184143, -0.5267404913902283, 0.47379162907600403, -0.5503495335578918, 0.23319309949874878, 0.7037231922149658, 0.309972882270813, -0.1986323893070221, -0.5880016684532166, -0.8766574263572693, -0.1543532758951187, 0.0583893246948719, 0.5194492340087891, 0.260295569896698, 0.14297011494636536, 0.5493924617767334, 0.5338165760040283, -0.9280973076820374, -0.14875589311122894, -0.19380784034729004, -0.17839449644088745, 0.3869408071041107, 0.3574953079223633, 0.7694129347801208, -0.4321248531341553, -0.16471098363399506, -0.28856930136680603, -0.26685699820518494, 0.07090043276548386, 0.1359957605600357, 0.19621489942073822, 0.0891164243221283, 0.8791393041610718, -0.3924041986465454, 0.7157204151153564, -0.1278972625732422, -0.29723867774009705, -0.031127136200666428, -0.34765318036079407, -0.11982966214418411, -0.07410218566656113, 0.8133004903793335, 0.3615647852420807, 0.09583720564842224, 0.02061513252556324, 0.04518115893006325, -0.06037530303001404, 0.3226204514503479, -0.667861819267273, -0.02208685874938965, 0.3419436812400818, -0.3363840579986572, -0.12386049330234528, -0.046844374388456345, -1.187131404876709, -0.4215940237045288, -0.2125457376241684, 0.5290017127990723, -0.41674137115478516, -0.02653253823518753, -0.08331187814474106, -0.24457314610481262, 0.5768901109695435, 0.5752832889556885, -0.7838450074195862, 0.21139489114284515, 0.4459019601345062, 0.6718668937683105, 0.06515980511903763, -0.22585828602313995, -0.43096381425857544, -0.04317723587155342, -0.5993779301643372, 0.6181293725967407, -0.5734975337982178, -0.7005173563957214, 0.10071483999490738, 0.2697999179363251, -0.09254414588212967, -0.4844535291194916, 0.5288645625114441, -0.6826791763305664, 0.5546268820762634, -0.457314133644104, -0.5815849304199219, -0.22490637004375458, 0.4733392894268036, -0.7892739772796631, 0.9997317790985107, 0.13699032366275787, -0.6776984930038452, 0.16159610450267792, -0.4918633997440338, -0.2636466920375824, 0.3053276538848877, -0.35315045714378357, -0.39247485995292664, 0.06757776439189911, 0.6396908760070801, 0.34607598185539246, -0.5642264485359192, 0.20701798796653748, -0.2693836987018585, -0.3816849887371063, 0.493115097284317, -0.7237794995307922, 0.7045407891273499, 0.2648783028125763, -0.2273772954940796, -0.3034065067768097, -0.8975914716720581, 0.1523468941450119, 0.4951264262199402, -0.22609227895736694, -0.6751217842102051, -0.40281087160110474, 0.0469047948718071, 0.18203553557395935, 0.2815387547016144, -0.542465329170227, 0.29770538210868835, -0.11013708263635635, -0.01130902860313654, 0.43653160333633423, 0.34520241618156433, 0.09344594925642014, -0.24477960169315338, 0.9966769218444824, -0.02307755872607231, 0.18089553713798523, -0.3911669850349426, -0.6387194395065308, -0.7610936164855957, 0.1116035059094429, 0.07875046879053116, 0.4976249635219574, -1.4962059259414673, 0.0312521867454052, -0.019099675118923187, -0.6064624190330505, -0.824260950088501, -0.013742593117058277, 0.4413629174232483, 0.8395638465881348, 0.33448970317840576, -0.38164812326431274, -0.17927761375904083, -0.6739107966423035, 0.23904742300510406, -0.4803234934806824, -0.09213600307703018, 0.3863133192062378, 0.5043857097625732, 0.05210357531905174, 0.6358967423439026, -0.5927895903587341, -0.08640419691801071, -0.03145560994744301, 0.3045506477355957, 0.0002706881205085665, -0.03401021286845207, 0.1820083111524582, -1.0488379001617432, -0.19987493753433228, 0.028658827766776085, -1.1608331203460693, -0.06549980491399765, -0.49571266770362854, -0.1232205480337143, 0.10843432694673538, 0.5502213835716248, -0.6271668672561646, 0.12144522368907928, 0.4516275227069855, -0.05250566452741623, 0.5748956203460693, -0.14306868612766266, 0.4657593071460724, -1.421793818473816, 0.33797988295555115, -0.20526838302612305, 0.00928499549627304, -0.664021372795105, 0.49858182668685913, 0.12164772301912308, -0.5680943727493286, -0.4445347189903259, 0.5259416103363037, -0.4601391851902008, -0.27665460109710693, -0.19312889873981476, 0.44168293476104736, 0.30278781056404114, 0.6107138991355896, 0.19795064628124237, 1.1206525564193726, 0.37593939900398254, -0.38961705565452576, 0.39767590165138245, 0.6475036144256592, -0.4461290240287781, 0.593745231628418, -0.5411956906318665, 0.20699886977672577, -0.41974401473999023, 0.04368676245212555, -1.1923143863677979, -0.3947766125202179, 0.30588582158088684, -0.5088810920715332, 0.15689997375011444, -0.06674382090568542, -0.4434739649295807, -0.5583284497261047, -0.2012380212545395, 0.35819709300994873, 0.2131490409374237, -0.4920884668827057, 0.6413801312446594, 0.3446026146411896, -0.3152271509170532, -0.8086490631103516, -0.5300643444061279, 0.029833978042006493, -0.09557144343852997, -0.24233496189117432, -0.16408461332321167, -0.2591177523136139, 0.04063815250992775, 0.07886654883623123, 0.008844288066029549, -0.26612144708633423, 0.16577230393886566, 0.4218013286590576, 0.5710170865058899, -0.3401302099227905, 0.11372850090265274, 0.21852724254131317, 0.06340791285037994, 0.11339198797941208, 0.009510285221040249, 0.6935803294181824, 0.06254469603300095, -0.40467578172683716, -0.43072694540023804, 0.5964287519454956, 0.7683414220809937, -0.25582754611968994, 0.5814068913459778, 0.5346112251281738, -0.4297182261943817, 0.0677829459309578, -0.3995437026023865, 0.1505148559808731, -0.44077861309051514, 0.5203146934509277, -0.7487391829490662, -0.8706201314926147, 0.6801760792732239, 0.056466903537511826, -0.010895203799009323, 0.5269163250923157, 0.6499987244606018, -0.2699180543422699, 0.9832863807678223, 0.3332454264163971, 0.03992173820734024, 0.1014096662402153, -0.04786080867052078, -0.14282554388046265, -0.7750815153121948, -0.3390819728374481, -0.6292749047279358, 0.3408869206905365, -0.666610836982727, -0.4838864803314209, 0.35521626472473145, 0.1457291543483734, 0.1533147096633911, 0.24015328288078308, -0.37719273567199707, 0.5792796015739441, 0.35885417461395264, -0.06883715093135834, 0.5003690123558044, -0.191913440823555, -0.0898858979344368, 0.21072885394096375, -0.6624451279640198, -0.4706496298313141, 1.189693570137024, 0.23524054884910583, 0.7300386428833008, -0.06732805073261261, 0.5202996730804443, -0.04337781295180321, 0.13573716580867767, -0.8212711811065674, 0.6729987263679504, -0.08096892386674881, -0.8160024881362915, -0.6625928282737732, -0.5721772909164429, -0.9049388766288757, 0.23049971461296082, -0.2275274693965912, -0.46923568844795227, 0.19567272067070007, -0.058725032955408096, -0.09639275819063187, 0.14420190453529358, -0.4516420364379883, 0.8793781399726868, -0.11249226331710815, -0.05100841820240021, 0.2692543566226959, -0.5902410745620728, 0.4939444363117218, -0.25332993268966675, 0.12718965113162994, -0.010446458123624325, 0.07917005568742752, 0.8195289969444275, -0.36311405897140503, 0.6734864711761475, -0.07501988857984543, -0.25134459137916565, 0.4976567327976227, -0.018997596576809883, 0.42342010140419006, 0.1866980493068695, 0.04339687526226044, 0.05746791139245033, 0.3950408101081848, -0.35826295614242554, -0.7599736452102661, 0.6391869187355042, -0.8958176374435425, -0.5543370842933655, -0.3384709656238556, -0.5566109418869019, -0.38715285062789917, 0.37276995182037354, 0.48108330368995667, 0.43299490213394165, -0.3599039912223816, 0.11488446593284607, 0.8892846703529358, -0.4333885610103607, 0.07513114809989929, 0.3971198797225952, -0.2867739498615265, -0.3136122226715088, 0.8663964867591858, 0.12869670987129211, 0.4066583812236786, 0.6026361584663391, -0.17684097588062286, -0.5070474743843079, -0.45269739627838135, -0.8419636487960815, 0.36463984847068787, -0.9869554042816162, -0.006727429106831551, -0.6360272169113159, -0.3011702001094818, -0.19229906797409058, -0.10060359537601471, -0.22869059443473816, -0.2585514485836029, -0.2647972106933594, 0.04339725896716118, -0.06679236143827438, 0.35323721170425415, 0.5635987520217896, 0.007678155787289143, -0.724644660949707, 0.855384349822998, 0.6168414950370789, 0.22121813893318176, -0.07353144139051437, -0.3129222095012665, -0.019090043380856514, 0.12758216261863708, -0.12690331041812897, -1.0453468561172485, 0.20849406719207764, -0.062152199447155, 0.4716912508010864, 0.2155219316482544, 0.19687724113464355, 0.6485137939453125, -0.2815123200416565, 0.8389295935630798, 0.1433584988117218, -0.6748114824295044, 0.572009265422821, -0.41888388991355896, 0.6076037883758545, 0.9680853486061096, 0.761411726474762, -0.8917744755744934, -0.5630109906196594, -0.4568544030189514, -0.6874590516090393, 0.5210030674934387, 0.20823149383068085, 0.21964091062545776, -0.013152179308235645, 0.5572487711906433, 0.28355109691619873, 0.2994438409805298, -0.5952626466751099, -0.1947498470544815, -0.41355612874031067, -0.4329466223716736, -0.14588242769241333, -0.02453182078897953, -0.062213264405727386, 0.0691317468881607, 0.576228141784668, -0.41178226470947266, 0.329772412776947, 0.25348517298698425, -0.25982794165611267, -0.2242412269115448, 0.3931095004081726, 0.3011183738708496, 0.4577557444572449, -0.279744952917099, -0.002565204631537199, 0.21473988890647888, -0.6889175772666931, 0.20661932229995728, 0.13581016659736633, -0.5834121108055115, 0.04791015759110451, 0.2933245897293091, 0.9040243029594421, -0.38769981265068054, -0.9441353678703308, 0.4801832139492035, -0.5009255409240723, -0.4378621280193329, -0.5408426523208618, 0.15280629694461823, -0.13182136416435242, -0.11819683760404587, 0.25666525959968567, -0.5719389319419861, 0.3018432557582855, -0.8872386813163757, 0.06844466924667358, 0.3876372277736664, -0.5611168742179871, 0.13565683364868164, 0.7260435223579407, -0.05302414670586586, 0.053103916347026825, 0.8302663564682007, 0.04872451722621918, -0.24351142346858978, 0.8775810599327087, 0.5675663948059082, 0.5776241421699524, -0.0501483790576458, 0.629090428352356, 0.4581504166126251, 0.32872533798217773, 0.16332459449768066, 0.309280663728714, -0.19289690256118774, -0.735848069190979, -0.3002532124519348, -0.72754967212677, -0.7701231837272644, 0.4791494607925415, -0.9086039662361145, 0.027904443442821503, -0.4940529763698578, 0.055213458836078644, 0.17922551929950714, 0.09991750866174698, -0.5771743059158325, 0.5646748542785645, 0.24925273656845093, 0.5695663094520569, -0.9688891172409058, 0.6287879943847656, 0.6659000515937805, -0.7673839926719666, -0.6539325714111328, 0.28002822399139404, -0.11946842819452286, -0.8689780235290527, 0.0926358699798584, 0.1015329360961914, 0.16524788737297058, 0.04578930512070656, -0.5553024411201477, -0.7771501541137695, 1.178475022315979, 0.12131229788064957, -0.5398703813552856, -0.01833510585129261, 0.6085540652275085, 0.6185156106948853, -0.1107463389635086, 0.36913663148880005, 0.4572831690311432, 0.400997132062912, 0.13977575302124023, -0.41862186789512634, 0.18291833996772766, -0.6250623464584351, 0.1764422208070755, 0.1902375966310501, -0.5973629355430603, 0.31364506483078003, -0.022970929741859436, -0.315159410238266, 0.4693778157234192, 0.5428164601325989, 0.3876365125179291, 0.543745756149292, 0.5060574412345886, 0.4331252872943878, 0.9146903157234192, -0.1688062995672226, 1.2160778045654297, 0.0971740186214447, 0.03481049835681915, 1.1423596143722534, -0.17689749598503113, 0.766917884349823, 0.42036786675453186, -0.11300110071897507, 0.3278576731681824, 0.6905124187469482, -0.08911113440990448, 0.3228561580181122, 0.005642849951982498, -0.17007549107074738, -0.3282926082611084, -0.35225367546081543, -0.4190610647201538, 0.5392615795135498, 0.4032755494117737, -0.05160483345389366, 0.05216888338327408, 0.39038538932800293, -0.08981836587190628, 0.09264881163835526, -0.18985037505626678, 0.9231128692626953, -0.03516721725463867, -0.8168593049049377, 0.47501346468925476, -0.05966798961162567, 0.03743400052189827, -0.5906022191047668, -0.045297667384147644, -0.5102742314338684, -0.46032100915908813, 0.22570756077766418, -1.0973061323165894, 0.0015855435049161315, 0.07760917395353317, -0.1598610132932663, 0.2735486328601837, 0.5404592752456665, -0.5845839977264404, -0.6454369425773621, -0.09560651332139969, 0.4860759973526001, 0.2055867463350296, 0.05317459627985954, -0.7694451808929443, -0.28887739777565, -0.11180968582630157, -0.21834801137447357, 0.28950372338294983, 0.5287073254585266, -0.22578386962413788, 0.7403836250305176, 0.6994724869728088, -0.22949157655239105, -0.04628756642341614, 0.3124755024909973, 0.865041971206665, -0.5167413949966431, -0.3935806155204773, -0.19743426144123077, 0.404938668012619, -0.021339714527130127, -0.4708373546600342, 0.691985011100769, 0.438473105430603, 0.8290656208992004, -0.19154562056064606, 0.8212155699729919, 0.067513607442379, 0.269449919462204, -0.9599167704582214, 0.6304745078086853, -0.8795390725135803, -0.054619207978248596, -0.5624829530715942, -1.0294195413589478, -0.35561248660087585, 0.1870681643486023, -0.19136042892932892, -0.09870253503322601, 0.6946438550949097, 0.8506145477294922, 0.1659858375787735, 0.15015345811843872, 0.583544135093689, 0.1236572414636612, 0.13563653826713562, 0.6548347473144531, 1.0033793449401855, -0.7161941528320312, 0.5727760791778564, -0.3808026611804962, 0.032951757311820984, -0.09441162645816803, -0.2103131264448166, -0.8975788354873657, -1.0293669700622559, -0.3194490373134613, -0.1592114120721817, 0.08592327684164047, 0.5917474627494812, 0.16900956630706787, -0.7875051498413086, 0.00731694558635354, -0.05554504320025444, -0.023266615346074104, -0.0168474018573761, -0.2294365018606186, 0.5682424902915955, -0.14833752810955048, -0.7842714786529541, 0.1597146987915039, 0.2125958502292633, 0.23838302493095398, -0.11865659058094025, 0.06649163365364075, -0.12221959978342056, 0.16125473380088806, 0.34870314598083496, 0.4996751844882965, -0.541572630405426, -0.03568410500884056, 0.21026451885700226, -0.14956918358802795, 0.07986706495285034, 0.6018562316894531, -0.325141042470932, 0.9295841455459595, 0.48497289419174194, 0.8545198440551758, 0.6219793558120728, 0.20962968468666077, 0.2862327992916107, -0.6408897638320923, 0.12044953554868698, 0.12176356464624405, 0.30070558190345764, 0.3406512439250946, -0.4273924231529236, 0.3256482481956482, 0.14868329465389252, -0.37699252367019653, -0.5091511607170105, 0.018298132345080376, -1.1868507862091064, -0.5944288969039917, 0.8523370623588562, -0.07293658703565598, -0.48329073190689087, -0.2892950177192688, -0.4377349615097046, 0.38400039076805115, -0.03677530586719513, 0.9080610275268555, 0.888648271560669, 0.32156309485435486, -0.6518381237983704, -0.7228386402130127, 0.22206296026706696, 0.481587290763855, -1.3951352834701538, 0.15498663485050201, 0.6352178454399109, -0.06205156818032265, 0.23442396521568298, 0.8643077611923218, -0.3095749616622925, 0.618108868598938, 0.13218830525875092, 0.14920800924301147, 0.01271045207977295, -0.3660092055797577, -0.33059263229370117, 0.446655809879303, 0.17769181728363037, -0.19674476981163025 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19443v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19443v1
Mixed Preference Optimization: Reinforcement Learning with Data Selection and Better Reference Model
2024-03-28T14:15:10
2024-03-28T14:15:10
Qi Gou, Cam-Tu Nguyen
cs.CL
cs.CL
Large Language Models (LLMs) have become increasingly popular due to their ability to process and generate natural language. However, as they are trained on massive datasets of text, LLMs can inherit harmful biases and produce outputs that are not aligned with human values. This paper studies two main approaches to LLM alignment: Reinforcement Learning with Human Feedback (RLHF) and contrastive learning-based methods like Direct Preference Optimization (DPO). By analyzing the stability and robustness of RLHF and DPO, we propose MPO (Mixed Preference Optimization), a novel method that mitigates the weaknesses of both approaches. Specifically, we propose a two-stage training procedure: first train DPO on an easy dataset, and then perform RLHF on a difficult set with DPO model being the reference model. Here, the easy and difficult sets are constructed by a well-trained reward model that splits response pairs into those with large gaps of reward (easy), and those with small gaps (difficult). The first stage allows us to obtain a relatively optimal policy (LLM) model quickly, whereas the second stage refines LLM with online RLHF, thus mitigating the distribution shift issue associated with DPO. Experiments are conducted on two public alignment datasets, namely HH-RLHF and TLDR, demonstrating the effectiveness of MPO, both in terms of GPT4 and human evaluation.
[ -0.32837748527526855, -0.40380966663360596, 0.5554576516151428, 0.010460732504725456, -0.34098270535469055, 0.14110499620437622, -0.35540106892585754, -0.15523315966129303, -0.1590256690979004, 0.5887576341629028, -0.7668014764785767, -0.17346124351024628, -0.44490012526512146, 0.17198224365711212, 0.36595678329467773, 1.1036423444747925, -0.21112991869449615, 0.19960236549377441, -0.26711517572402954, -0.11629920452833176, -0.3551374673843384, -0.5417968034744263, -0.6342032551765442, -0.8778314590454102, 0.6136931777000427, 0.5167855620384216, 0.8341454863548279, 0.947378933429718, 0.38464653491973877, 0.2239450365304947, -0.12532521784305573, 0.4081437289714813, -0.7115919589996338, 0.1576671004295349, -0.19171108305454254, -0.330010324716568, -0.05579809099435806, 0.009425793774425983, 0.4998021125793457, 0.38262084126472473, -0.46912625432014465, -0.3575650155544281, 0.06331666558980942, 0.9308643341064453, -0.7688837647438049, -0.03878345713019371, -0.6341599822044373, 0.1259126365184784, 0.1758514791727066, -0.15525923669338226, -0.34494081139564514, -0.5253350734710693, 0.303590327501297, -0.70296710729599, -0.30130696296691895, 0.14705263078212738, 0.8955020904541016, 0.512961745262146, -0.4624650180339813, -0.22030477225780487, -0.7399842739105225, 1.2284578084945679, -0.6030545234680176, 0.391508549451828, 0.2944478988647461, 0.23296429216861725, -0.3647952079772949, -0.1343071162700653, -0.6525808572769165, -0.3871013820171356, 0.0005717035965062678, 0.23023316264152527, 0.385911226272583, 0.13982589542865753, -0.07876312732696533, 0.3119901418685913, -0.2607809603214264, 0.48701217770576477, 0.038644954562187195, -0.13468554615974426, 0.6081907749176025, 0.027634091675281525, -0.010368830524384975, -0.07105011492967606, -0.6159247756004333, -0.4458323121070862, -0.6264002323150635, 0.10634099692106247, 0.6314696073532104, 0.3695644438266754, -0.023686900734901428, 0.3998355567455292, -0.13923917710781097, 0.5647917985916138, 0.24308866262435913, -0.6635822057723999, 0.21841590106487274, -0.05132057145237923, 0.028762249276041985, -0.008125163614749908, 0.8296079039573669, 0.3724614381790161, 0.3522082269191742, -0.13680429756641388, -0.3934888243675232, 0.12414828687906265, 0.1766110211610794, -0.531696617603302, 0.12457777559757233, 0.2854478657245636, -0.36967378854751587, -0.576977014541626, -0.11573275178670883, -0.7908300757408142, -0.4915134012699127, -0.6458871364593506, 0.13904595375061035, -0.14950741827487946, -0.1411944329738617, 0.054321009665727615, 0.271732896566391, 0.20113283395767212, 0.3183925449848175, -1.1947568655014038, 0.3669481575489044, 0.7981561422348022, 0.48660269379615784, -0.6575778722763062, -0.41194385290145874, -0.6478531360626221, 0.20402543246746063, -0.22268527746200562, 0.5201780796051025, -0.6022657155990601, -0.3448493182659149, 0.13942766189575195, -0.3545287549495697, -0.018366441130638123, -0.7705816626548767, 0.8822230100631714, -0.6873962879180908, 0.4906800091266632, -0.1579904854297638, -0.42809078097343445, 0.06837446242570877, 0.32455483078956604, -0.6248304843902588, 1.1402695178985596, -0.0005149765638634562, -0.8795667290687561, 0.4311383366584778, -0.41028064489364624, -0.22754234075546265, -0.5053890347480774, -0.275443971157074, -0.7303429841995239, -0.2076513022184372, 0.2935686707496643, 0.2383968085050583, -0.14934714138507843, 0.4757721424102783, -0.5077387690544128, -0.39481961727142334, 0.301798939704895, -0.12532460689544678, 0.38776132464408875, 0.30650538206100464, -0.20523059368133545, 0.44870129227638245, -0.724224328994751, -0.21151180565357208, 0.16694720089435577, -0.7209024429321289, -0.25007063150405884, 0.4216194748878479, -0.18704853951931, 0.4593757390975952, 0.1946316957473755, -0.40270569920539856, 0.32649028301239014, -0.4305948317050934, 0.4470161199569702, 1.0752923488616943, -0.1073930561542511, 0.6404185891151428, -0.42468446493148804, 0.42853015661239624, 0.1088641956448555, 0.2806903123855591, 0.47805115580558777, -0.11296296119689941, -0.7068347334861755, -0.0708022266626358, 0.31287238001823425, 0.7245891690254211, -0.8799664378166199, 0.5657505989074707, -0.1134771853685379, 0.11790604144334793, -0.4584692418575287, 0.21462807059288025, 0.4267869293689728, 0.6572348475456238, 0.24791082739830017, -0.11235704272985458, -0.31150051951408386, -0.9692074656486511, 0.08034822344779968, -0.1685878187417984, 0.14789347350597382, 0.516027569770813, 0.24801529943943024, -0.32825666666030884, 0.8340163230895996, -0.6667519807815552, 0.03380630165338516, -0.17817313969135284, -0.026532819494605064, 0.1678299903869629, 0.28620827198028564, 0.19164949655532837, -0.8317992091178894, -0.42657819390296936, 0.13341155648231506, -0.2478620857000351, -0.07844206690788269, 0.02217419072985649, -0.2669145464897156, 0.20826515555381775, 0.022546645253896713, -0.20434574782848358, -0.23008228838443756, 0.648707926273346, 0.12765204906463623, 0.33285343647003174, -0.27729806303977966, 0.08623829483985901, -0.9647397398948669, -0.14296117424964905, 0.0862782672047615, -0.2812528610229492, -0.4213723838329315, -0.2055642306804657, -0.007664427161216736, -0.1038740873336792, -0.3451741337776184, 0.5093685984611511, -0.2838156223297119, 0.0557326078414917, -0.4332902133464813, 0.06973960995674133, -0.2364085167646408, 0.7845584750175476, 0.3411127030849457, 0.7683892250061035, 0.18745096027851105, -0.6639689207077026, 0.3109889030456543, 0.217099130153656, -0.0420394092798233, 0.4049588143825531, -0.3843829929828644, 0.4329688251018524, -0.19435736536979675, 0.11774442344903946, -0.7809339165687561, -0.13452759385108948, 0.4795408546924591, -0.07085611671209335, 0.4083525836467743, -0.016741832718253136, -0.3177461326122284, -0.12619270384311676, -0.536878764629364, 0.2768515944480896, 0.3389158248901367, -0.7005664110183716, 0.12600786983966827, 0.4309309422969818, -0.11787107586860657, -0.9429274201393127, -0.20952723920345306, -0.3943430781364441, -0.40577659010887146, -0.3503071367740631, 0.41725534200668335, -0.10698851197957993, -0.25979316234588623, -0.24831417202949524, -0.16859565675258636, -0.0706767588853836, 0.008296930231153965, -0.061111003160476685, 0.4436149001121521, 0.281639039516449, 0.1349235475063324, -0.04325443506240845, -0.35699519515037537, -0.3247268795967102, -0.09206108003854752, 0.4659639298915863, 0.11749610304832458, -0.04092869907617569, -0.22784578800201416, 0.2417658120393753, 0.312899649143219, -0.10625316202640533, 0.5954875349998474, 0.2612617313861847, 0.024793729186058044, -0.3211369812488556, -0.38579118251800537, -0.23625381290912628, -0.463226854801178, 0.27069854736328125, -0.22883270680904388, -0.8599048256874084, 0.07986506074666977, -0.2158399373292923, 0.08641636371612549, 0.02904200553894043, 0.5245269536972046, 0.07016656547784805, 1.0418891906738281, 0.556047797203064, -0.3740747570991516, 0.7803693413734436, 0.20056340098381042, -0.026906708255410194, -0.6729333400726318, -0.1139414981007576, -0.42274779081344604, -0.33818319439888, -0.8531141877174377, -0.31266218423843384, 0.18113717436790466, 0.2071162909269333, -0.3610244691371918, 0.022711526602506638, -0.47823575139045715, 0.5359804630279541, 0.6245710253715515, 0.3795953691005707, 0.28969237208366394, 0.1389147788286209, -0.39394181966781616, -0.24650438129901886, -0.6878266930580139, -0.48908117413520813, 1.226926326751709, 0.3607535660266876, 0.843766987323761, -0.11644607037305832, 0.913029134273529, 0.12027662247419357, 0.27935731410980225, -0.8873534202575684, 0.29074254631996155, -0.13609914481639862, -0.25663620233535767, -0.411705881357193, -0.6703801155090332, -0.8122338652610779, 0.49552589654922485, -0.5287042856216431, -0.5024179220199585, 0.20554986596107483, 0.34159597754478455, -0.06845633685588837, 0.10768488049507141, -0.5550391674041748, 0.5995290279388428, -0.5336230993270874, -0.6758309006690979, -0.24102386832237244, -0.7345656752586365, 0.3762902319431305, 0.13271382451057434, 0.1903790831565857, -0.1128498762845993, -0.26051557064056396, 0.614998996257782, -0.239043727517128, 0.41885384917259216, -0.00384330446831882, -0.05216815695166588, -0.06947659701108932, -0.19736884534358978, 0.8767497539520264, -0.10779950767755508, -0.23964554071426392, -0.2849329113960266, -0.2638043165206909, -0.3776673376560211, -0.5820218920707703, 0.7830578684806824, -1.1683850288391113, -0.4281797707080841, -0.5610751509666443, -0.42412886023521423, -0.5704725980758667, 0.07225345820188522, 0.021325424313545227, -0.10283355414867401, -0.15086564421653748, -0.02609466016292572, 0.7550358772277832, -0.15477560460567474, 0.32626184821128845, 0.36268341541290283, -0.08933882415294647, -1.0149484872817993, 0.76521235704422, -0.3026612102985382, 0.41807565093040466, 0.6730685830116272, 0.6007452011108398, -0.3761281669139862, -0.7422744035720825, -0.26695409417152405, 0.4107569456100464, -0.547714352607727, 0.08411423861980438, -0.1206519827246666, 0.14229711890220642, -0.14518442749977112, -0.0681774914264679, -0.40597161650657654, -0.0950506404042244, -0.29035764932632446, -0.014569335617125034, 0.036527372896671295, 0.5758485198020935, 0.08561371266841888, 0.2481035590171814, -0.4008292555809021, 0.33765968680381775, 0.41566959023475647, 0.4483966529369354, -0.15882068872451782, -0.21965396404266357, -0.11874284595251083, 0.0009270574664697051, -0.5155784487724304, -0.7919398546218872, 0.31504371762275696, -0.20216496288776398, 0.5957232117652893, 0.5058051943778992, 0.12279392033815384, 0.47157180309295654, -0.5036611557006836, 0.2971171736717224, 0.3574656844139099, -0.5826385617256165, 0.4780808091163635, -0.41829121112823486, 0.021293863654136658, 0.8804709315299988, 0.5797936320304871, -0.46646976470947266, 0.21400456130504608, -0.3398299515247345, -0.7809932827949524, 0.8416967988014221, 0.14168591797351837, -0.19144049286842346, 0.17296451330184937, 0.44180828332901, 0.21821598708629608, 0.4310397803783417, -1.0075548887252808, -0.3405955135822296, -0.03702271357178688, -0.22789296507835388, -0.13136395812034607, -0.33462706208229065, -0.372041791677475, -0.02517007105052471, 0.861993134021759, -0.20392484962940216, -0.08992261439561844, 0.027202708646655083, 0.029974348843097687, -0.1964174062013626, 0.5180302858352661, 0.6216078400611877, 0.5958985686302185, -0.49498453736305237, -0.12243043631315231, -0.1273171603679657, -0.21745151281356812, 0.4284239113330841, 0.029302814975380898, -0.37478604912757874, -0.4513355791568756, -0.0016793510876595974, 1.0405303239822388, 0.2777915298938751, -0.5601746439933777, 0.3561071455478668, 0.13319037854671478, -0.22134582698345184, 0.1054585874080658, 0.09689533710479736, 0.05716707557439804, 0.04623475670814514, 0.028828173875808716, -0.3219923675060272, -0.09215279668569565, -0.5976532101631165, 0.10636613517999649, 0.33116570115089417, -0.36540767550468445, 0.06977178901433945, 0.33516547083854675, 0.49713560938835144, -0.3013256788253784, 0.5050367712974548, -0.04251132905483246, -0.522014856338501, 0.3380878269672394, 0.6007640957832336, 0.7205559611320496, -0.07134963572025299, 0.31192320585250854, 0.2184572070837021, 0.0748167484998703, -0.34303972125053406, 0.016963422298431396, -0.1531873345375061, -1.0867193937301636, -0.3572509288787842, -0.5735355019569397, -0.8545195460319519, 0.24422356486320496, -0.7157028317451477, 0.2369098663330078, -0.5749530792236328, -0.06366435438394547, -0.29530617594718933, 0.38513585925102234, -0.3223670423030853, 0.16534699499607086, 0.1609961837530136, 0.33728960156440735, -0.8346785306930542, 0.88142991065979, 0.7200987935066223, -0.22495605051517487, -0.5808616876602173, 0.27444371581077576, -0.0037818951532244682, -0.9186738133430481, 0.5028465986251831, -0.1065785363316536, -0.07739647477865219, -0.16473188996315002, -0.3267674148082733, -0.793631911277771, 1.0424121618270874, 0.4296356737613678, -0.809304416179657, 0.05240906402468681, -0.019828401505947113, 0.37451305985450745, -0.4578465223312378, 0.12615792453289032, 0.6200585961341858, 0.4562658965587616, 0.28295961022377014, -0.8017784357070923, -0.05474340543150902, 0.2875480353832245, 0.15234829485416412, 0.49233439564704895, -0.8969637751579285, 0.5348799824714661, -0.06881098449230194, -0.03495464101433754, -0.14904093742370605, 0.4783789813518524, 0.6767006516456604, 0.1338077038526535, 0.6813827753067017, 0.7993338108062744, 0.7475321292877197, 0.0010366636561229825, 1.06991446018219, -0.05727973207831383, 0.4037996530532837, 1.1903340816497803, -0.621608555316925, 1.0348151922225952, 0.8199328780174255, -0.4747685194015503, 0.38873913884162903, 0.8792847394943237, 0.16236098110675812, 0.9062769412994385, 0.3462199866771698, -0.2428482174873352, -0.2685095965862274, -0.05741233378648758, -0.10556649416685104, 0.03935500606894493, -0.1491212099790573, -0.1922825276851654, -0.1554131805896759, -0.19596043229103088, 0.05133616924285889, 0.4238143563270569, -0.20871973037719727, 0.9939950108528137, -0.05930386856198311, -0.920547366142273, 0.4757501184940338, 0.027821993455290794, 0.8454102277755737, -0.6794300079345703, 0.03621046617627144, -0.31755581498146057, 0.3168669641017914, -0.11214213073253632, -0.5851891040802002, -0.06562837213277817, -0.18816278874874115, -0.2882348895072937, -0.32182401418685913, 0.5891033411026001, -0.5696452856063843, -0.2559678256511688, 0.41984426975250244, 0.12589576840400696, -0.2589549720287323, 0.24006971716880798, -0.9576534628868103, 0.07030854374170303, 0.18564563989639282, -0.3051432967185974, 0.6122299432754517, 0.07753236591815948, -0.013467766344547272, 0.6654562950134277, 0.683822751045227, 0.28091347217559814, -0.28336817026138306, 0.09326576441526413, 0.7499920129776001, -0.6077774167060852, -0.6028875112533569, -0.7636051177978516, 0.2502060532569885, -0.19284556806087494, -0.31407085061073303, 0.31225401163101196, 0.45241957902908325, 0.8816182613372803, 0.054410096257925034, 0.6238904595375061, 0.49836277961730957, 0.522677481174469, -0.7431486248970032, 0.10392908751964569, -0.41133302450180054, 0.2863028943538666, -0.1011430025100708, -1.1719930171966553, -0.10200650244951248, 0.5136517286300659, -0.5198792815208435, -0.09067472815513611, 0.6735909581184387, 0.7162349820137024, -0.005522024817764759, -0.36062881350517273, 0.2013373076915741, -0.25180667638778687, 0.11195828765630722, 0.7059996128082275, 0.91813725233078, 0.001872086781077087, 0.5910587310791016, -0.43795135617256165, -0.30834582448005676, -0.2728259563446045, -1.0096920728683472, -0.7574741244316101, -0.1784665733575821, -0.22951555252075195, -0.3180892765522003, 0.2659807503223419, 1.1854723691940308, 0.7976117730140686, -0.8435031771659851, -0.5144925713539124, -0.15495125949382782, 0.4973268210887909, -0.12301310151815414, -0.23094753921031952, 0.2554224133491516, -0.2586268484592438, -0.8581517934799194, 0.3035047650337219, 0.2522050440311432, 0.14130088686943054, -0.1536584198474884, -0.5986847877502441, -0.352688193321228, 0.06039194017648697, 0.34205496311187744, 0.29508358240127563, -0.752135694026947, -0.28529274463653564, -0.2276451736688614, -0.26104283332824707, 0.38908982276916504, 0.9512528777122498, -0.4917408525943756, 0.48281845450401306, 0.6584740877151489, 0.8129019141197205, 0.5827766060829163, 0.28105422854423523, 0.7956632971763611, -0.5209606289863586, 0.1620277762413025, 0.3177434802055359, 0.24869228899478912, 0.33668240904808044, -0.42250004410743713, 0.4319237470626831, 0.19561639428138733, -0.7401983737945557, -0.6465016603469849, 0.4997612237930298, -1.059766411781311, -0.37695565819740295, 1.2924672365188599, 0.06579304486513138, -0.04593699425458908, 0.14759372174739838, -0.323011189699173, 0.2110067903995514, -0.7460643649101257, 0.9636431336402893, 0.9126555919647217, -0.38829296827316284, -0.21762403845787048, -0.3026733696460724, 0.680887758731842, 0.5409746170043945, -0.8364299535751343, -0.09356966614723206, 0.5765788555145264, 0.32279592752456665, -0.18793274462223053, 0.5401607751846313, 0.09271755814552307, -0.0026567948516458273, -0.33585554361343384, 0.009963098913431168, -0.13035263121128082, -0.2237636297941208, -0.5851814150810242, 0.061985909938812256, 0.3820476233959198, -0.3515235185623169 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19432v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19432v2
Uncovering Misattributed Suicide Causes through Annotation Inconsistency Detection in Death Investigation Notes
2024-03-28T14:03:12
2024-03-29T17:21:02
Song Wang, Yiliang Zhou, Ziqiang Han, Cui Tao, Yunyu Xiao, Ying Ding, Joydeep Ghosh, Yifan Peng
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI
Data accuracy is essential for scientific research and policy development. The National Violent Death Reporting System (NVDRS) data is widely used for discovering the patterns and causes of death. Recent studies suggested the annotation inconsistencies within the NVDRS and the potential impact on erroneous suicide-cause attributions. We present an empirical Natural Language Processing (NLP) approach to detect annotation inconsistencies and adopt a cross-validation-like paradigm to identify problematic instances. We analyzed 267,804 suicide death incidents between 2003 and 2020 from the NVDRS. Our results showed that incorporating the target state's data into training the suicide-crisis classifier brought an increase of 5.4% to the F-1 score on the target state's test set and a decrease of 1.1% on other states' test set. To conclude, we demonstrated the annotation inconsistencies in NVDRS's death investigation notes, identified problematic instances, evaluated the effectiveness of correcting problematic instances, and eventually proposed an NLP improvement solution.
[ -0.16808156669139862, -0.8598902225494385, 0.5985968112945557, 0.349031537771225, 0.17052975296974182, 0.029733916744589806, 0.1126982793211937, -0.47370749711990356, 0.049611613154411316, 0.39045268297195435, -0.6306202411651611, -0.3697393238544464, -0.6277349591255188, 0.46600696444511414, -0.3073868155479431, 0.9078456163406372, -0.17105861008167267, 0.11223415285348892, -0.17579180002212524, -0.3833944797515869, -0.3822709321975708, -0.4813743829727173, -1.0919115543365479, -0.09271183609962463, 0.5768142342567444, 0.08009332418441772, 0.5532737970352173, 0.4005943536758423, 0.5570191144943237, 0.13082586228847504, -0.16452012956142426, 0.31282711029052734, -0.15024806559085846, -0.10157916694879532, 0.3453245759010315, -0.5608943700790405, -0.3734440505504608, -0.04830363392829895, 0.328186959028244, 0.2873067557811737, -0.15633322298526764, 0.13150493800640106, 0.00701862620189786, 0.6651244759559631, -0.6647602319717407, -0.25348880887031555, -0.2056404948234558, 0.5044424533843994, -0.22368866205215454, -0.376773864030838, -0.5285145044326782, -0.8728181719779968, 0.16090607643127441, -0.5753846168518066, 0.5493406057357788, -0.28075459599494934, 0.5615355372428894, 0.569516658782959, -0.16607870161533356, -0.4282854497432709, -0.806523859500885, 0.7200855612754822, -0.7593734264373779, 0.16780300438404083, 0.41553500294685364, 0.2486865520477295, -0.31770938634872437, -0.1180245652794838, -0.546516478061676, -0.06927478313446045, -0.1601879745721817, -0.1111660823225975, -0.2016548216342926, 0.0717499777674675, 0.5889572501182556, 0.4778051972389221, -0.6597145199775696, 0.17118601500988007, -0.1087385043501854, -0.46768680214881897, 0.8606360554695129, 0.31019845604896545, 0.4928555190563202, -0.4169347584247589, -0.22666122019290924, -0.020932834595441818, -0.49191778898239136, 0.036060791462659836, 0.6932894587516785, 0.30395030975341797, -0.17414094507694244, 0.5550233125686646, -0.16131193935871124, 0.8043596744537354, -0.02936624176800251, -0.32898807525634766, 0.5188922882080078, -0.2959262728691101, -0.1076393574476242, 0.5022919774055481, 0.7655988335609436, 0.6380496621131897, 0.30592480301856995, -0.0039674825966358185, 0.10424265265464783, -0.018416879698634148, 0.2161492556333542, -0.415935754776001, -0.2855628728866577, 0.39240339398384094, -0.46393826603889465, -0.3570117652416229, -0.3468492031097412, -0.6232073903083801, -0.6443209648132324, -0.3497328758239746, 0.4061899483203888, -0.6112461090087891, -0.24185630679130554, -0.1609732210636139, -0.5134349465370178, 0.06257995218038559, 0.49346381425857544, -0.24891184270381927, -0.03908858075737953, 0.44096702337265015, 1.0064506530761719, -0.14565914869308472, -0.07498981803655624, -0.5628172755241394, -0.21556861698627472, -0.08644688874483109, 1.0041539669036865, -0.3419419527053833, 0.16528604924678802, 0.20798924565315247, -0.023472793400287628, 0.09943292289972305, -0.5778545141220093, 0.9893006682395935, 0.07438672333955765, 0.1739012748003006, -0.3401724398136139, -0.5357857942581177, -0.11222304403781891, 0.3357020318508148, -0.6971902847290039, 1.1409378051757812, -0.11957239359617233, -0.9831012487411499, 0.7782565355300903, -0.4920649528503418, -0.3427313268184662, -0.011565441265702248, -0.18586674332618713, -0.7283526659011841, 0.035146892070770264, 0.25093981623649597, 0.6018604636192322, -0.13071668148040771, 0.27193015813827515, -0.2143920660018921, -0.21882125735282898, 0.19306889176368713, -0.5163602828979492, 0.959197998046875, -0.14780744910240173, 0.03961530700325966, -0.2170296162366867, -1.2076219320297241, -0.0549151711165905, 0.18909095227718353, -0.6165663599967957, -0.6659555435180664, 0.0676739439368248, 0.33028215169906616, 0.17515751719474792, -0.11150522530078888, -0.8012672066688538, -0.08552267402410507, -0.17541036009788513, -0.054399892687797546, 0.3837260901927948, 0.5550552606582642, 0.08665101230144501, -0.5459144711494446, 0.24427299201488495, 0.08956839889287949, 0.445283442735672, 0.07654500007629395, -0.6015442609786987, -0.3929223120212555, -0.07785939425230026, -0.04209147021174431, 0.8491505980491638, -0.5675802826881409, 0.3731936812400818, 0.33408594131469727, -0.4719848036766052, -0.4217737317085266, -0.20186913013458252, 0.16193227469921112, 0.9140172004699707, 0.8754705190658569, -0.028577495366334915, -1.0483633279800415, -0.9082764983177185, -0.6292914748191833, -0.17954383790493011, -0.031247664242982864, -0.41874760389328003, 0.3146921694278717, -0.03137664124369621, 1.0929285287857056, -0.3276042938232422, -0.6842638850212097, -0.118036188185215, 0.5762661099433899, -0.06322029232978821, 0.35873502492904663, 0.33167120814323425, -0.765108585357666, -0.3151315748691559, -0.3370058238506317, -0.964465856552124, -0.19968484342098236, -0.48181116580963135, 0.22596433758735657, 0.29338857531547546, 0.4376431703567505, -0.07489445060491562, 0.8490241169929504, 0.08944131433963776, 0.17372047901153564, 0.5903417468070984, -0.20634256303310394, -0.021933725103735924, -0.6013455390930176, -0.1508234441280365, 0.2644282281398773, 0.15062479674816132, -0.7629357576370239, -0.7376748323440552, 0.0547848716378212, 0.36788034439086914, -0.19648465514183044, -0.07564172893762589, -0.211380735039711, 0.2960352599620819, -0.14953699707984924, 0.14831285178661346, -0.04178224131464958, 0.08015639334917068, -0.02149263396859169, 0.2766568958759308, 0.1693984717130661, -0.4990489184856415, 0.3260350227355957, 0.5094064474105835, -0.07026714086532593, 0.8915683627128601, -0.4000895023345947, -0.35871389508247375, -0.6452485918998718, 0.20781071484088898, -0.8112012147903442, -0.21311016380786896, 0.34590861201286316, -0.32026776671409607, -0.03957301378250122, -0.2862941026687622, -0.38020825386047363, 0.008202099241316319, -0.2912966012954712, 0.09275011718273163, 0.03566506505012512, -0.04985126480460167, 0.6546952724456787, 0.3065033555030823, 0.03895334154367447, -0.53794926404953, -0.8650050163269043, 0.0848703533411026, -0.36814311146736145, -0.2785778343677521, -0.14297805726528168, 0.16458499431610107, -0.23755839467048645, -0.14779779314994812, -0.002333323936909437, -0.1601124405860901, 0.25419968366622925, 0.4769694209098816, -0.05954792723059654, -0.18519173562526703, 0.37292641401290894, 0.04006513953208923, -0.209832563996315, 0.3694441318511963, 0.399872750043869, 0.1712365597486496, 0.32979094982147217, -0.2930351197719574, -0.6587437987327576, 0.37207379937171936, 0.18906204402446747, -0.1279599368572235, 0.7362576723098755, 0.39046427607536316, -0.5536516308784485, -0.187227264046669, -0.7101887464523315, 0.25559377670288086, -0.2714090049266815, 0.009585111401975155, 0.24828709661960602, -0.6758504509925842, 0.6529704928398132, -0.02169894054532051, 0.20803917944431305, 0.64556485414505, 0.0570371150970459, -0.000807807024102658, 0.7513159513473511, 0.4497300088405609, 0.08238983899354935, 0.5130601525306702, -0.0843435749411583, 0.4170420467853546, -1.0254689455032349, -0.3719998300075531, -0.45816099643707275, -0.1056012287735939, -0.5420113801956177, -0.25883862376213074, 0.5137547850608826, 0.09733224660158157, -0.26972654461860657, 0.2596568167209625, -0.5980737209320068, 0.5726238489151001, 0.0952865332365036, -0.06183112785220146, 0.6619051098823547, 0.10425649583339691, 0.09369941800832748, -0.28537335991859436, -0.3395186960697174, -0.5209861993789673, 0.9807348847389221, 0.2699100375175476, 0.5689117312431335, 0.13157068192958832, 0.9279923439025879, 0.37289538979530334, 0.4855390787124634, -0.3189045488834381, 0.10028084367513657, -0.06559000164270401, -0.5782725214958191, -0.5000811815261841, -0.47645339369773865, -0.5603809952735901, -0.08979824930429459, -0.3167438805103302, -0.8289906978607178, 0.40499767661094666, 0.03410099446773529, -0.617677628993988, 0.03649287670850754, -0.4027734398841858, 0.9008395671844482, -0.3243485987186432, 0.223029226064682, 0.2203315645456314, -0.5350633263587952, 0.3320533037185669, -0.1230260506272316, 0.2711382806301117, -0.4201904237270355, 0.42203325033187866, 0.9442314505577087, -0.5491830110549927, 0.817254900932312, -0.4052346348762512, -0.14007365703582764, 0.27034178376197815, -0.016531040892004967, 0.47185879945755005, 0.06513684242963791, -0.24813970923423767, 0.07416560500860214, -0.26773399114608765, -0.012546246871352196, -0.44897380471229553, 0.1476210355758667, -0.44836243987083435, -0.007839544676244259, -0.5424953103065491, -0.383838951587677, -0.052653443068265915, -0.0038684275932610035, 0.622028648853302, 0.4940339922904968, -0.3286716639995575, -0.3357270658016205, 0.7196627259254456, -0.279197633266449, 0.535426914691925, 0.5306612253189087, -0.08813344687223434, -0.47723403573036194, 0.8167539238929749, 0.5636918544769287, 0.29846861958503723, 0.18619264662265778, 0.051156219094991684, -0.04406141862273216, -0.5217393636703491, -0.5466687083244324, 0.262137770652771, -0.8017110824584961, -0.4003986418247223, -0.8905202746391296, -0.2105172872543335, -0.1248878464102745, -0.045892540365457535, -0.33445945382118225, -0.18275566399097443, -0.4179150462150574, -0.235247403383255, 0.8458356857299805, 0.7898007035255432, -0.40636521577835083, 0.17325562238693237, -0.6359671354293823, 0.44113513827323914, -0.02379215694963932, 0.11515405774116516, 0.02682054415345192, -0.41387060284614563, -0.1491147130727768, 0.13673317432403564, -0.2919837534427643, -0.9964008331298828, 0.06458534300327301, 0.31004518270492554, 0.49269741773605347, 0.34761425852775574, 0.28404292464256287, 0.9762172102928162, -0.2854847013950348, 0.566763699054718, 0.06337869167327881, -0.7602004408836365, 0.8671318888664246, -0.190386101603508, -0.16781498491764069, 0.8731595873832703, 0.7243366241455078, -0.8700834512710571, -0.6933448910713196, -0.7234976887702942, -0.7909918427467346, 0.6173933744430542, 0.1754712164402008, -0.29479536414146423, -0.06263820081949234, 0.3989613950252533, 0.04053308814764023, -0.07295522093772888, -0.5595453977584839, -0.6534218192100525, 0.06737823039293289, -0.18769431114196777, 0.14917847514152527, -0.14098979532718658, -0.04058725759387016, -0.16770902276039124, 0.742882251739502, -0.18298783898353577, 0.05372251942753792, 0.6620929837226868, -0.056122589856386185, -0.591559648513794, -0.09466427564620972, 0.6190580725669861, 0.6684668660163879, -0.23803357779979706, -0.05581466108560562, 0.36460840702056885, -0.4929945170879364, 0.36843860149383545, 0.2358047515153885, -0.4054549038410187, 0.24324563145637512, 0.6436399817466736, 0.5366460084915161, -0.01193735096603632, -0.5225947499275208, 0.8359133005142212, -0.40589407086372375, 0.058503881096839905, -0.8419814705848694, 0.04454195499420166, -0.2074597179889679, 0.12080598622560501, 0.6758074164390564, 0.22386321425437927, 0.37171614170074463, -0.33275917172431946, 0.29632240533828735, 0.3668559491634369, -0.3169029653072357, -0.07567690312862396, 0.37944889068603516, -0.11551986634731293, -0.3065049350261688, 0.33566349744796753, -0.24317602813243866, -0.5084978342056274, 0.54277503490448, 0.14828331768512726, 0.8432629704475403, -0.48186251521110535, 0.6641319394111633, 0.433750182390213, 0.7071340084075928, -0.40532124042510986, 0.4362916648387909, 0.17295287549495697, -0.6367949843406677, -0.6898688077926636, -0.7328498959541321, -0.49516141414642334, 0.2832942008972168, -0.9831207990646362, 0.25712624192237854, -0.6528173089027405, -0.00015787231677677482, 0.21718895435333252, -0.4411686062812805, -0.46522700786590576, 0.2766706049442291, 0.4370288550853729, 0.6243783831596375, -1.5213556289672852, 0.10854584723711014, 0.4672323763370514, -0.6747982501983643, -0.6871027946472168, 0.3309270143508911, 0.12630191445350647, -0.3657107949256897, 0.7307397127151489, 0.36184197664260864, 0.31023624539375305, -0.37983277440071106, -0.5214870572090149, -0.9500163793563843, 0.5920680165290833, 0.21381978690624237, -0.3195391297340393, 0.21438279747962952, 0.5398812890052795, 0.6996601223945618, -0.17232979834079742, 0.2540622055530548, 0.7061808705329895, 0.4777592122554779, -0.2620775103569031, -0.8501087427139282, 0.2654748260974884, 0.14644281566143036, -0.13979671895503998, 0.6714501976966858, -0.41616126894950867, 0.8149125576019287, -0.051621198654174805, -0.2987685203552246, -0.35963067412376404, 0.514733612537384, 0.1849689781665802, 0.8575760126113892, 0.2709886133670807, 0.9637407064437866, 0.947291374206543, -0.056695014238357544, 0.8520724773406982, 0.6947355270385742, 0.4326993227005005, 1.019066333770752, -0.30022844672203064, 0.7227489352226257, 0.5975049734115601, -0.31821516156196594, 0.6543607115745544, 0.20208165049552917, -0.006793275009840727, 0.39534932374954224, 0.15940316021442413, -0.17762748897075653, -0.40242496132850647, -0.21013684570789337, -0.17071226239204407, 0.3431246876716614, 0.3282506465911865, -0.4274098873138428, -0.5919122099876404, 0.3940843939781189, 0.006911004893481731, -0.29337841272354126, 0.056773584336042404, 0.8710176944732666, -0.017363417893648148, -0.15983249247074127, 0.46123066544532776, -0.2001734972000122, 0.45291873812675476, -0.183247908949852, -0.45447441935539246, -0.04404016211628914, 0.09463926404714584, -0.6300265192985535, -0.7388548851013184, 0.8252068161964417, 0.1268029510974884, -0.3073079586029053, 0.05134323611855507, 0.542091429233551, -0.13626986742019653, -0.6033060550689697, 0.13375939428806305, 0.20524539053440094, 0.20465902984142303, -0.4720270037651062, -0.4585488438606262, 0.22755767405033112, 0.10110173374414444, 0.02081431820988655, 0.11765439063310623, 0.6425243020057678, -0.18092267215251923, 0.4428584575653076, 0.6721408367156982, 0.09653501212596893, 0.18526701629161835, -0.2608535587787628, 0.5142428874969482, -0.59537273645401, -0.31628841161727905, -0.7750487923622131, 0.7790153622627258, -0.32342737913131714, -0.7123541831970215, 0.8178905248641968, 0.5209684371948242, 0.8632552623748779, 0.1180507093667984, 0.9961560964584351, -0.21688412129878998, 0.9136514663696289, -0.5051157474517822, 0.5340102314949036, -0.4007553458213806, 0.09537050873041153, -0.3212009370326996, -0.7856667041778564, -0.7493680715560913, 0.8783953785896301, -0.6668915748596191, -0.2846236526966095, 0.5470441579818726, 0.4902872145175934, 0.30018484592437744, 0.2756608724594116, -0.028359312564134598, 0.23961013555526733, 0.18768104910850525, 0.36903947591781616, 0.9194533824920654, -1.0324739217758179, 0.3296518325805664, -0.38925671577453613, 0.04586593434214592, -0.44306230545043945, -0.9275233745574951, -0.8206683993339539, -0.5444550514221191, -0.8291375041007996, -0.18001537024974823, -0.08775384724140167, 0.7630357146263123, -0.15244843065738678, -0.7961527109146118, 0.2690691351890564, -0.283448189496994, 0.20954616367816925, -0.13389915227890015, -0.2401461899280548, 0.28749880194664, -0.08392918854951859, 0.005437909625470638, 0.3625858426094055, 0.3061138689517975, 0.08852341026067734, -0.018786080181598663, 0.1317436546087265, -0.30041027069091797, -0.3393673002719879, 0.30831223726272583, 0.3300876021385193, -0.7659106254577637, -0.4661628007888794, -0.6568261981010437, 0.04729064926505089, 0.10648065060377121, 0.8002713322639465, -0.7716707587242126, 0.1982957124710083, 0.3725362718105316, 0.5515123009681702, -0.18692731857299805, 0.015116793103516102, 0.16735200583934784, -0.9647712707519531, -0.23339861631393433, 0.18737122416496277, 0.09808140248060226, 0.6464083790779114, -0.8253950476646423, 0.4020712673664093, 0.2701028287410736, -0.6336469054222107, -1.1059544086456299, -0.031106028705835342, -0.6581540107727051, 0.18710678815841675, 0.6887790560722351, 0.07046876847743988, -0.32122597098350525, -0.7099027633666992, -0.16725151240825653, 0.3924161493778229, -0.3609963357448578, 0.5452325940132141, 0.5051731467247009, -0.6099398732185364, -0.10768813639879227, -0.7056567072868347, 0.8488927483558655, 0.2922092080116272, -0.8030744791030884, 0.3363068699836731, 0.5915384888648987, 0.2845727503299713, 0.5617817640304565, 0.34861698746681213, 0.21492412686347961, 0.41288578510284424, -0.19549687206745148, 0.17068661749362946, 0.024155963212251663, -0.2060389518737793, -0.5857173800468445, 0.22371764481067657, -0.23393183946609497, 0.05531911924481392 ]