id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| text
stringlengths 190
2.08k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08355v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08355v1
|
Seal-Tools: Self-Instruct Tool Learning Dataset for Agent Tuning and Detailed Benchmark
| 2024-05-14T06:50:19 | 2024-05-14T06:50:19 |
Mengsong Wu, Tong Zhu, Han Han, Chuanyuan Tan, Xiang Zhang, Wenliang Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents a new tool learning dataset Seal-Tools, which contains
self-instruct API-like tools. Seal-Tools not only offers a large number of
tools, but also includes instances which demonstrate the practical application
of tools. Seeking to generate data on a large scale while ensuring reliability,
we propose a self-instruct method to generate tools and instances, allowing
precise control over the process. Moreover, our Seal-Tools contains hard
instances that call multiple tools to complete the job, among which some are
nested tool callings. For precise and comprehensive evaluation, we use strict
format control and design three metrics from different dimensions. Therefore,
Seal-Tools can serve as a new benchmark to evaluate the tool-calling ability of
LLMs. Finally, we evaluate several prevalent LLMs and our finetuned model on
Seal-Tools. The results show that current systems are far from perfect. The
code, data and experiment results are available at
https://github.com/fairyshine/Seal-Tools .
|
Seal-Tools: Self-Instruct Tool Learning Dataset for Agent Tuning and Detailed Benchmark: This paper presents a new tool learning dataset Seal-Tools, which contains
self-instruct API-like tools. Seal-Tools not only offers a large number of
tools, but also includes instances which demonstrate the practical application
of tools. Seeking to generate data on a large scale while ensuring reliability,
we propose a self-instruct method to generate tools and instances, allowing
precise control over the process. Moreover, our Seal-Tools contains hard
instances that call multiple tools to complete the job, among which some are
nested tool callings. For precise and comprehensive evaluation, we use strict
format control and design three metrics from different dimensions. Therefore,
Seal-Tools can serve as a new benchmark to evaluate the tool-calling ability of
LLMs. Finally, we evaluate several prevalent LLMs and our finetuned model on
Seal-Tools. The results show that current systems are far from perfect. The
code, data and experiment results are available at
https://github.com/fairyshine/Seal-Tools .
|
[
-0.0357562713,
-0.0108960243,
-0.0135097047,
-0.0006529365,
-0.0241868347,
-0.0114794904,
0.0085555483,
-0.0101523967,
0.0249576122,
0.0054517174,
-0.0434426218,
0.0895690024,
-0.0669350773,
0.0275292117,
0.0038732341,
-0.0069100535,
0.0625155494,
0.0071965121,
-0.0645209178,
-0.0108425878,
-0.0506434068,
-0.0238601845,
-0.0314837657,
0.0300138425,
0.0024483795,
-0.0255305525,
-0.0342304036,
0.033141192,
0.0205738638,
-0.0232153106,
0.0376101322,
-0.0031189639,
0.0237084776,
0.0632606149,
0.0000019541,
-0.0554435998,
-0.0238473527,
0.0100891395,
-0.0498552583,
-0.0260262936,
0.0119392341,
-0.0025235252,
-0.0070015797,
0.0350754447,
-0.0198913626,
0.02562101,
0.0290565304,
-0.0145778265,
0.0948986486,
0.0892155692,
0.037282899,
0.0419073291,
-0.0151519077,
0.0067647761,
-0.0480368398,
-0.0405517593,
-0.0091318376,
-0.0048434911,
0.0044635111,
-0.0308444612,
0.0413732976,
-0.0212307572,
0.0404427797,
-0.0030060427,
0.018506173,
0.0143247237,
-0.0373128764,
-0.0385970883,
-0.0198773146,
0.0080743385,
-0.0183392297,
-0.0123187751,
0.0099824956,
-0.0207883995,
0.0112791993,
0.0083107082,
-0.0157413166,
0.0223335717,
0.0052430374,
0.0007132795,
-0.03066222,
0.0079089357,
-0.0079474635,
-0.0324164964,
0.0049547506,
0.0987813696,
-0.0070970324,
0.0256901979,
-0.0220801663,
-0.0182718337,
0.053464707,
-0.016137233,
-0.0284549426,
0.0632606745,
-0.0793194845,
-0.0371713601,
-0.0322772637,
0.0403846279,
0.0229254048,
-0.0252871737,
0.0495409183,
-0.0238554832,
-0.0150386412,
0.0013380414,
-0.0443965197,
0.0176416729,
0.0325335525,
0.0638531446,
-0.0028571035,
0.0179956648,
-0.0541520342,
0.0418002829,
-0.0010843665,
0.0381978452,
0.0192746706,
0.0267594252,
-0.028520219,
0.0398010351,
-0.0315392949,
0.0310176052,
-0.0217459872,
-0.0398655534,
-0.0416985601,
0.0063459552,
-0.0604335628,
-0.0487123094,
-0.0581228994,
0.0148910535,
0.022650931,
-0.0223419331,
-0.0176724754,
0.0066372831,
-0.0406702384,
-0.009511847,
0.0247078389,
0.1165428162,
0.014694226,
0.0114321811,
-0.0708464012,
-0.0370821804,
0.1004165411,
-0.059610039,
-0.0285809245,
-0.0545276999,
-0.0023781359,
-0.0352709033,
-0.0199650191,
-0.0358098,
-0.0058789738,
-0.0419076346,
0.0061688754,
0.0407460779,
-0.0151926922,
0.0345753767,
-0.0122385984,
0.0107292328,
-0.0484162495,
0.0661558136,
-0.0116658993,
0.0696359947,
0.0218737461,
-0.0195823144,
0.0420579053,
0.0242356118,
-0.0386793315,
0.0319286026,
0.0058762813,
0.0248512253,
0.0208490007,
0.0527150445,
0.0220612399,
-0.0412405916,
-0.0166184045,
-0.0226930026,
0.0501227528,
0.0101479804,
0.0457505807,
0.0171395522,
0.0230811704,
0.0410962515,
0.0179623142,
-0.0341027714,
-0.0701074749,
0.0299998634,
-0.0393732451,
0.0176097769,
-0.0587936491,
0.0614999719,
-0.0509192795,
-0.0336937048,
-0.0045615365,
-0.0100144809,
-0.0834096223,
0.0049431114,
0.0538185202,
0.0036013685,
-0.0583377853,
0.021849798,
0.0211051963,
-0.0607032068,
-0.0677207485,
-0.0854049176,
0.0246770922,
0.0195067637,
0.0555866659,
-0.0696427599,
-0.0884395689,
0.0006542664,
-0.0233417116,
0.0190418065,
-0.0051513892,
-0.0281033441,
0.025061598,
-0.0143838944,
-0.057841327,
-0.0060360134,
-0.0025942947,
0.0327313952,
0.0489815623,
-0.0415524356,
-0.0312133711,
-0.0611686222,
-0.0023063582,
0.0633341745,
0.0037352182,
-0.0301434379,
0.0038170272,
0.0044959672,
0.0485188812,
0.0051694023,
-0.0270351507,
-0.0288136266,
0.0629430562,
0.0280099101,
-0.0340644084,
-0.0171572566,
0.0074846009,
0.0221549068,
0.0125697888,
-0.0151749514,
0.0107137309,
0.0435934551,
-0.0436644219,
-0.0516612194,
-0.0318281576,
0.0128861703,
0.0229002219,
0.0136590451,
0.043149747,
-0.0611596555,
0.0154226599,
-0.0188174564,
0.0316652767,
-0.0013158129,
-0.0355980583,
-0.0193455853,
0.042521771,
0.0060835648,
-0.0180206299,
-0.0007443056,
0.0044044438,
-0.0003796872,
0.0346572548,
0.0365816727,
0.0210094545,
-0.0325342529,
-0.0254905466,
-0.0126143768,
0.0485758781,
-0.010375726,
0.0041741417,
-0.0001790755,
-0.0356742665,
-0.0065696151,
-0.0331790224,
0.0160446297,
0.0497404486,
-0.0223677978,
0.0230925586,
-0.0013009039,
0.0031812801,
-0.0568692312,
-0.0152168442,
0.0022914037,
0.0042328113,
0.0043452047,
0.0121264132,
0.0334705599,
-0.0724316239,
0.091270484,
-0.0034319628,
-0.0051400946,
-0.0220219102,
-0.0504897311,
0.0204384495,
0.0000173309,
-0.0669365451,
0.0840635076,
-0.0616144985,
0.0440750048,
0.0878491253,
0.0229331683,
-0.0763771832,
0.0073518343,
-0.0249937382,
-0.0535557903,
-0.035824772,
0.025045868,
-0.0167284366,
0.0078298394,
-0.0273860935,
0.0066799442,
0.0060953139,
0.0172499437,
0.0589146093,
-0.0658341795,
0.0159374494,
0.0310253296,
-0.0371918231,
0.0190885868,
-0.0124226818,
-0.1062453538,
0.0104415426,
0.0145520624,
-0.0078890091,
0.015888555,
-0.0713271499,
-0.039930515,
0.0576001778,
0.0396321416,
-0.0098723462,
-0.0033490933,
-0.0147906933,
-0.0401190668,
-0.002771535,
0.0387174487,
-0.0162404478,
-0.0285564531,
-0.0223182943,
-0.0046402719,
-0.0120818308,
-0.0448240601,
-0.0427116789,
0.0318407379,
0.0030643241,
0.0327116661,
-0.0479908809,
-0.0663116798,
-0.0342592075,
-0.0153779024,
0.0219854191,
0.0077156015,
-0.0097694583,
-0.0135897761,
-0.0483051948,
-0.0196279511,
-0.0110459486,
0.0078577157,
0.0190238096,
-0.0083148992,
0.0601694882,
0.0267704893,
0.0434755348,
-0.0585865341,
-0.065265432,
-0.010468265,
0.0033553394,
-0.0765829161,
0.0320824496,
0.0286371224,
0.0595573634,
-0.0613482744,
0.0127890939,
0.0312525071,
0.0050236029,
-0.0258335322,
0.014135858,
-0.0076442044,
0.0084748901,
0.06604857,
0.046740219,
-0.0067002415,
-0.0103590703,
0.0277702101,
0.0722282156,
-0.0194982607,
-0.0417186208,
0.0281210151,
-0.0912389234,
0.0656109899,
-0.0059178625,
-0.0207514018,
0.014004481,
-0.0737128928,
0.0236036703,
-0.0688383207,
-0.0241534803,
0.0519701727,
0.0074450648,
-0.017497357,
0.0231438503,
0.0235099718,
-0.0048254989,
-0.0040703095,
-0.0665745214,
0.0756834447,
0.0329924896,
-0.0127827954,
-0.0146281822,
0.0141883614,
0.0523940399,
0.052408278,
0.0203798432,
-0.0113844387,
0.0319295414,
0.0225472804,
-0.0075521814,
0.0166182853,
0.0345338099,
-0.0378797352,
-0.0001511602,
0.0368996412,
0.0616989955,
-0.0397988632,
-0.0083111888,
-0.026128348,
-0.0465515591,
0.0037942762,
0.0440058783,
-0.0029718394,
0.0028337161,
-0.0539132208,
-0.020297952,
-0.0291466489,
-0.0165864136,
-0.0302992202,
0.0310054179,
-0.0839374065,
-0.0135480575,
-0.0315036997,
-0.0439992212,
0.0389981121,
0.0467208363,
0.0268634222,
-0.016774714,
-0.0197811816,
0.0753850862,
-0.0285227895,
-0.0115304124,
-0.0095231766,
0.017174568,
-0.0351391286,
-0.0354411118,
0.0501211025,
0.0022719025,
0.0076918243,
0.007582427,
-0.0447635055,
-0.0582270212,
0.0252906885,
0.0783123001,
0.0325351991,
0.0465176702,
-0.0147651704,
-0.0254498757,
0.0591965877,
0.0658182129,
-0.0239856932,
-0.0053920704,
0.0291388594,
0.0201733485,
0.0036868523,
0.0319394022,
-0.0535045303,
0.0294965897,
0.0197317582,
0.0014316506,
-0.0438212939,
-0.0255987924,
0.003679608,
0.0233601499,
-0.0529782958,
0.0102604385,
0.0117090186,
-0.0174306463,
0.0390876345,
0.0219781641,
0.0111778136,
-0.0319066457,
0.0687686205,
-0.0344000794,
-0.029362293,
0.0531521887,
0.0208873507,
0.0585242696,
0.0048354501,
-0.0092401514,
0.0258647297,
-0.0106687872,
0.0282487497,
0.0176016241,
0.0210562665,
0.0125343278,
0.0224886797,
0.0146863302,
0.0305217449,
0.0472756326,
0.00243766,
0.0171477795,
0.0509314574,
-0.0581010468,
0.0070395307,
-0.0336252563,
-0.0940682516,
-0.0074466136,
0.0155390631,
0.0673339516,
0.0032595682,
0.0289340466,
-0.0251547601,
0.0013557427,
-0.0070657241,
0.0016589906,
-0.0146871582,
0.0437679999,
-0.0271636434,
0.0237833448,
-0.0105501954,
0.0099001545,
0.065302439,
-0.0096507752,
0.1129583493,
-0.0128495106,
-0.0056151277,
-0.0785555989,
-0.0419140272,
0.0236657578,
0.0108340746,
0.0248044003,
-0.0514960326,
-0.0167245213,
-0.0067990869,
-0.0080994889,
0.0604372807,
0.0202806462,
-0.0132413264,
0.0244118888,
0.0352439433,
0.0136898737,
0.0084945904,
-0.0210712925,
-0.055447571,
0.0086614136,
-0.006866191,
0.024116857,
-5.066069513e-33,
0.0003494812,
-0.0128676612,
0.0532067418,
0.0420686752,
0.0091721034,
-0.0242279656,
-0.0058421553,
-0.0052702958,
0.0325963385,
0.0041958787,
-0.0227333512,
-0.0148839541,
0.0314854681,
-0.0281746238,
0.0389981233,
0.0289049242,
0.0554907173,
-0.0412248373,
-0.0471963994,
0.0067468951,
0.013974404,
0.033536464,
0.0420512483,
-0.0438469723,
-0.0372048803,
0.0157247763,
-0.0186410304,
0.0419782959,
-0.0443146229,
0.0260026772,
0.0406742953,
0.0159363933,
-0.0234291125,
-0.008043576,
-0.0259097107,
-0.058187589,
-0.0259983335,
-0.0579784214,
-0.0440617055,
-0.0096856654,
-0.0313332155,
-0.0599376634,
0.0460925326,
-0.0057915896,
-0.0390977524,
0.012546855,
0.0357116759,
-0.0122677684,
0.0025541352,
-0.0457621217,
-0.0194549616,
0.0340373553,
-0.0271108318,
-0.0518763624,
0.0026682108,
-0.0527196527,
0.0066810795,
-0.012302055,
-0.0458009578,
0.0202101897,
0.0138985952,
0.0047748932,
0.0470024161,
0.0279832538,
0.0053889658,
0.0325572379,
0.043191012,
0.0308008231,
0.0565293133,
-0.0128637413,
0.0101303691,
0.1202072501,
0.01241914,
0.0254807249,
-0.0375918671,
0.0004972276,
0.0122297164,
0.0874005556,
0.0725462884,
0.0417978987,
0.0189858377,
0.0154981185,
-0.022095751,
0.03127468,
-0.0211998057,
-0.0662432089,
0.0097039631,
-0.0283728167,
0.0265565235,
0.0280441064,
-0.0119880484,
-0.0442647897,
0.0064643202,
-0.0078870393,
0.0772956163,
-0.0236243661,
-0.0121105993,
0.0227339249,
0.0130482698,
-0.019524347,
-0.0334716402,
-0.0581693053,
-0.0355128087,
-0.0295707248,
0.0547462292,
-0.0298510138,
-0.0050456137,
0.0388779603,
-0.0440897979,
0.0330741778,
-0.072651878,
0.0110361408,
0.019945018,
-0.0545783043,
-0.0065738186,
-0.0333534293,
0.00745326,
0.0043930751,
-0.0184331536,
-0.0403820723,
-0.0179804694,
0.0374117084,
0.009839613,
0.0120214066,
0.0045709815,
0.0134272426,
-0.0686730593,
0.0168976244,
-0.0004872875,
-0.0101639749,
-0.0144586787,
-0.0023139361,
2.659e-7,
-0.0365430787,
0.0093249446,
0.0227365028,
0.0549356453,
0.0085215932,
0.0644645467,
-0.0320457891,
0.0182881039,
-0.0527259447,
-0.0069328402,
0.0098260092,
0.0292825084,
0.031440936,
0.0132076936,
-0.0325953811,
0.0170682296,
0.0214905236,
0.0302641317,
-0.0669279248,
-0.062219765,
-0.0209890772,
0.0429360457,
0.0501868874,
-0.0397547595,
0.0167734176,
-0.0400756858,
-0.0227062944,
-0.0244623385,
-0.0033460616,
0.0592683293,
-0.0253947414,
0.0331292078,
-0.0060219397,
0.0069678756,
-0.0074328189,
0.0338320322,
-0.0246748365,
0.0558181293,
0.0204813778,
-0.0340735503,
0.0147856781,
-0.0334288888,
0.0163292214,
0.0033996045,
0.0372246467,
0.0145098111,
-0.0248622634,
-0.0393247865,
-0.0105282543,
-0.0132803563,
0.0019740639,
-0.0170608778,
0.0072605838,
0.0312362015,
-0.0221910384,
-0.0281547643,
-0.0291873887,
-0.0309470389,
0.0067685372,
0.0120892813,
-0.0345338583,
-0.0927453041,
0.012930193,
0.013035981,
-0.0184264649,
-0.01265682,
-0.0174007379,
2.391622694e-34,
-0.0108183017,
-0.0089721493,
0.0230528284,
0.1017513797,
0.0181275047,
0.0106018893,
-0.0304325763,
0.009143047,
0.0194640271,
0.0070720855,
-0.0047748135
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08317v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08317v1
|
SpeechGuard: Exploring the Adversarial Robustness of Multimodal Large Language Models
| 2024-05-14T04:51:23 | 2024-05-14T04:51:23 |
Raghuveer Peri, Sai Muralidhar Jayanthi, Srikanth Ronanki, Anshu Bhatia, Karel Mundnich, Saket Dingliwal, Nilaksh Das, Zejiang Hou, Goeric Huybrechts, Srikanth Vishnubhotla, Daniel Garcia-Romero, Sundararajan Srinivasan, Kyu J Han, Katrin Kirchhoff
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Integrated Speech and Large Language Models (SLMs) that can follow speech
instructions and generate relevant text responses have gained popularity
lately. However, the safety and robustness of these models remains largely
unclear. In this work, we investigate the potential vulnerabilities of such
instruction-following speech-language models to adversarial attacks and
jailbreaking. Specifically, we design algorithms that can generate adversarial
examples to jailbreak SLMs in both white-box and black-box attack settings
without human involvement. Additionally, we propose countermeasures to thwart
such jailbreaking attacks. Our models, trained on dialog data with speech
instructions, achieve state-of-the-art performance on spoken question-answering
task, scoring over 80% on both safety and helpfulness metrics. Despite safety
guardrails, experiments on jailbreaking demonstrate the vulnerability of SLMs
to adversarial perturbations and transfer attacks, with average attack success
rates of 90% and 10% respectively when evaluated on a dataset of carefully
designed harmful questions spanning 12 different toxic categories. However, we
demonstrate that our proposed countermeasures reduce the attack success
significantly.
|
SpeechGuard: Exploring the Adversarial Robustness of Multimodal Large Language Models: Integrated Speech and Large Language Models (SLMs) that can follow speech
instructions and generate relevant text responses have gained popularity
lately. However, the safety and robustness of these models remains largely
unclear. In this work, we investigate the potential vulnerabilities of such
instruction-following speech-language models to adversarial attacks and
jailbreaking. Specifically, we design algorithms that can generate adversarial
examples to jailbreak SLMs in both white-box and black-box attack settings
without human involvement. Additionally, we propose countermeasures to thwart
such jailbreaking attacks. Our models, trained on dialog data with speech
instructions, achieve state-of-the-art performance on spoken question-answering
task, scoring over 80% on both safety and helpfulness metrics. Despite safety
guardrails, experiments on jailbreaking demonstrate the vulnerability of SLMs
to adversarial perturbations and transfer attacks, with average attack success
rates of 90% and 10% respectively when evaluated on a dataset of carefully
designed harmful questions spanning 12 different toxic categories. However, we
demonstrate that our proposed countermeasures reduce the attack success
significantly.
|
[
0.0329166129,
0.0861186907,
-0.0119016729,
0.0487893037,
-0.0144004775,
-0.0018592728,
0.031080924,
-0.017248556,
0.0393133834,
-0.0636762381,
-0.0367705859,
-0.0279513393,
-0.0060529527,
0.0097703738,
0.0788727477,
-0.0284919199,
0.0505157039,
-0.0705595165,
-0.0359183364,
-0.0043288586,
0.0384043716,
-0.0096593341,
-0.0196921136,
0.0405438319,
0.0066588619,
-0.0341866426,
-0.0080040991,
0.0180863105,
0.0113495896,
-0.0265222285,
0.0260451399,
0.0357071906,
0.005433755,
0.0684962198,
0.0000018647,
-0.0182669498,
-0.0079719294,
0.0155435978,
-0.0042331037,
0.0367572792,
0.0067043267,
-0.0357281081,
-0.0089285886,
0.0387315042,
-0.0213146638,
-0.0002594943,
0.0211979244,
0.0535490103,
0.1081186011,
0.0812501386,
-0.0022873946,
-0.0161966048,
0.0755766258,
-0.0270905476,
-0.0007653738,
-0.0714191869,
0.0195512976,
-0.0227898639,
-0.0290054958,
0.0253455713,
-0.0207789075,
0.0316281319,
0.0110071199,
-0.0070019565,
-0.0479131527,
-0.0067341146,
-0.0292923227,
-0.0302597694,
-0.0078318091,
0.1094871089,
-0.0193618257,
-0.0056454851,
-0.000618815,
0.0282231532,
0.0212516245,
0.0068409094,
-0.0656131431,
0.0202942248,
0.0258969013,
-0.0340990946,
-0.0244223159,
-0.0382250175,
0.033102639,
0.0157097504,
0.0160264187,
0.0086310469,
0.0390309691,
-0.0102423374,
-0.0030770875,
-0.0367517956,
-0.0458023772,
-0.0539700985,
0.0085040526,
0.0153047862,
-0.0260078274,
0.0139283491,
-0.0956276953,
-0.0343470313,
0.0255551264,
-0.0404768512,
0.0207100045,
0.0015846726,
-0.0343698412,
0.0321967006,
-0.0057419208,
0.0328902192,
-0.0502029657,
0.0295607913,
-0.0004632128,
-0.0010030069,
-0.0141901653,
-0.0363661982,
0.0008826465,
0.0156024108,
-0.0389793813,
-0.0184839591,
0.0025692149,
0.0290317275,
-0.0222447887,
0.026941089,
-0.0432801545,
0.0374815278,
0.0068257004,
-0.0019205952,
0.016776586,
-0.0066211708,
-0.0153567502,
0.0114279008,
0.0085972594,
-0.0721816272,
-0.0281388387,
0.0290950723,
-0.0498081408,
-0.0314152539,
-0.0013297697,
0.1339305043,
0.0159441158,
-0.0143855419,
-0.0360796377,
-0.0823758468,
-0.0318554044,
-0.0490376689,
0.0522846915,
-0.0451223776,
0.0009081036,
-0.0293223262,
-0.0057529644,
-0.0565292686,
0.025162803,
0.0217930805,
-0.0300134234,
0.0533359945,
0.0463694222,
-0.0218667127,
0.0074000563,
0.0425427295,
0.0106150536,
0.0553850569,
0.0208257213,
0.0102455243,
0.0669394732,
-0.0379250087,
0.0311635844,
0.0544699691,
0.036813926,
0.0338224284,
-0.0265961159,
0.0040590535,
0.0143557861,
0.0032625149,
-0.0192286205,
0.0467049554,
-0.0092729516,
-0.0708514303,
0.1330412179,
0.0493426137,
-0.0691935569,
0.0330789424,
-0.0197614115,
-0.0386187956,
0.0167311411,
0.0052240686,
-0.0662656724,
0.0092185196,
-0.0751960352,
-0.0336765945,
-0.000774287,
0.0489159524,
-0.0125864679,
0.000177773,
0.0375952832,
-0.0142415948,
0.0204340946,
0.0199672505,
0.0056702676,
0.0321428254,
-0.022226654,
0.0383125991,
-0.0114097726,
-0.0082629928,
-0.0194398686,
-0.0449758954,
-0.0069829607,
0.0198889766,
0.0557645857,
-0.0190908723,
-0.0019389319,
-0.0597139932,
0.0409353338,
0.0300432909,
0.009450472,
0.0037948941,
0.0405936316,
-0.0321345963,
-0.0047142673,
-0.0266862884,
0.0000335418,
0.0218708161,
0.0203191172,
-0.0088598635,
-0.0076343785,
0.0099313529,
-0.0154738957,
0.0210413728,
0.0169650745,
-0.0565377772,
0.024762664,
-0.0017572766,
0.0291949026,
0.0162755847,
-0.0379226953,
0.0265283734,
0.0628642514,
-0.0175895635,
-0.0056712544,
-0.0090078749,
-0.0440307371,
-0.0430687107,
0.0165995304,
-0.0339783579,
-0.0137856444,
0.0895312801,
-0.0311185326,
0.0118750539,
0.047479596,
-0.0470820591,
0.0008708583,
-0.0058600702,
0.0193324853,
0.0119047258,
0.0260323677,
-0.0368679352,
0.0126429452,
-0.020484563,
-0.0130678574,
0.0036110871,
0.0262609385,
-0.0089874845,
-0.0247515049,
-0.0321406238,
0.0281138942,
-0.0271821655,
0.0245674904,
-0.0092552854,
-0.0279600359,
-0.0336457454,
0.0005216201,
-0.052897688,
-0.0035646334,
-0.0172574557,
0.003624574,
0.0291436147,
0.0060120136,
0.0109164538,
-0.0188587457,
-0.0255802199,
-0.0259743575,
0.0071727801,
0.0146704093,
-0.0092714215,
-0.025003029,
-0.0092998091,
-0.0314382985,
-0.0107040936,
-0.0086402474,
0.0671145543,
-0.0405306071,
0.0126700625,
-0.0185232442,
-0.0278323032,
-0.0222309195,
0.0724643692,
-0.0185802244,
-0.0442127809,
0.0242233165,
0.0236823205,
-0.0135751842,
0.1078793854,
0.0569144189,
0.0179664288,
0.0462391451,
0.0137587246,
-0.0301882681,
0.0112228878,
0.0245494787,
-0.0181366261,
-0.0327371173,
-0.0016887676,
0.0086514689,
0.0435828045,
0.0461812876,
0.0092907883,
-0.0051730261,
0.0468930006,
-0.0047142003,
-0.0551711582,
-0.0166061204,
-0.0053019691,
-0.0494211055,
-0.0142880995,
-0.0226935726,
-0.0461319722,
0.0636538193,
-0.0425255224,
0.0034736223,
0.0050756857,
-0.0658935457,
0.0087502124,
0.0509725325,
0.00562084,
0.0184343588,
0.0363764763,
-0.0067647058,
-0.0570825711,
-0.0388098434,
0.0222413521,
-0.020030532,
0.0331654176,
-0.029134566,
-0.0204927493,
-0.0012638697,
-0.0505898744,
-0.0566718169,
-0.0731020868,
-0.0241994821,
-0.0114218751,
0.0321974345,
-0.0308933128,
-0.0154010765,
-0.0297166742,
0.0410290696,
-0.0137748569,
-0.0312349703,
0.0140532861,
-0.0337707549,
0.0705140233,
0.1044659838,
-0.0026485021,
-0.0049891756,
-0.0144790979,
0.0718551055,
0.0774254352,
0.0264418107,
0.0200534742,
-0.0225415379,
-0.0029917865,
0.0046117129,
0.0416206047,
-0.0073695797,
0.0078009064,
0.0640627742,
-0.0495065041,
0.0029585606,
0.0547462888,
0.0006770536,
0.0189048015,
0.0064213066,
0.0181703642,
0.0402879976,
0.0110451337,
-0.000771069,
-0.05977723,
-0.0511586815,
0.0137489391,
0.0588834286,
-0.0028716722,
-0.0023311591,
-0.0165470745,
-0.1098155379,
-0.0100339726,
0.0146157285,
-0.0388043262,
-0.016730452,
-0.0174167585,
-0.0326911211,
0.0075394721,
0.0323066786,
0.0029989087,
0.0062502641,
-0.0330492072,
0.0217921101,
-0.0336142071,
-0.0060498854,
0.0353385732,
-0.0364621729,
0.0473192595,
0.0987155885,
0.0151788136,
-0.0300341193,
0.0025631294,
0.051094003,
-0.0051411372,
-0.0210118406,
0.0258563086,
0.068359971,
-0.0176716521,
-0.0252487827,
-0.006132246,
0.0830686241,
-0.0006793731,
-0.0118393367,
0.0563146695,
0.0442539677,
-0.0017111448,
-0.0239726044,
-0.0518318154,
0.0286327899,
-0.0012452397,
0.0629333407,
0.0205618199,
-0.0711055696,
-0.038054321,
-0.0663896725,
-0.0317491405,
-0.0553674102,
-0.0486552417,
0.019516496,
0.0301360562,
0.0032012707,
-0.067542173,
-0.0200253222,
-0.0061588204,
0.0404245332,
-0.0020081964,
0.0064877886,
-0.0297712889,
0.0208436102,
-0.0019782521,
0.0096801249,
-0.0090981023,
0.0517186858,
-0.0537520535,
0.023226019,
0.0297085717,
-0.0253060255,
-0.0274472293,
0.0212619603,
-0.0848817751,
-0.0900151208,
-0.0002945775,
0.0616820529,
0.0150743993,
0.0407415517,
-0.024528591,
-0.0757632479,
0.0443948507,
0.0608442239,
-0.0446049049,
0.0159443431,
0.0806778297,
-0.0129515352,
0.0080912597,
0.0302631464,
-0.0453714319,
-0.0100958319,
0.035577178,
0.0072954316,
-0.046668198,
0.0015914369,
-0.0080899419,
0.0235760156,
0.0226296298,
0.005898919,
0.0077918274,
0.0223201606,
0.0330681428,
0.0040870695,
-0.0235593766,
-0.0254377481,
0.0392048061,
0.0370506682,
-0.015960712,
0.0212321132,
-0.0056466805,
0.021064911,
0.0147616053,
-0.0202795863,
0.021187434,
0.0394242257,
0.0261803661,
0.014783795,
0.0122442059,
-0.029248571,
0.0593287796,
0.0025711486,
0.0353974216,
-0.0022954778,
0.0744737387,
0.0010457257,
-0.0226466674,
0.0059377891,
0.0196076483,
-0.0832978711,
-0.0560742058,
-0.0227193814,
0.0603651293,
0.0077271671,
0.0048024179,
-0.002344829,
0.0043716682,
-0.0151226828,
-0.0270254295,
0.0013956865,
-0.0039145276,
-0.02375664,
0.0534846894,
0.0235193018,
0.0045830505,
0.0314085707,
0.0777817369,
0.0691836327,
0.0670448691,
0.0200781096,
-0.0165768713,
-0.0346081741,
-0.0356745049,
0.0573431961,
0.0070559988,
-0.0201246012,
0.0000894652,
-0.0305997804,
-0.0964950696,
-0.0177591871,
-0.0045659528,
0.0308224056,
-0.0188017637,
-0.0143796718,
0.0087107792,
0.0112419892,
0.0181646943,
-0.0331135988,
0.019815851,
-0.0129661253,
-0.0552571155,
0.0314739607,
-6.04942968e-33,
-0.00128053,
-0.0335509628,
-0.029415505,
-0.03699762,
0.0104643134,
-0.0075566471,
-0.0051168571,
0.0116718467,
-0.0225819014,
-0.0262840092,
0.0044458094,
0.0075199124,
-0.0197236519,
0.0451904461,
-0.0341065377,
-0.0690977797,
0.0119177364,
-0.0325900204,
-0.0184129924,
0.0273821577,
0.0597512759,
0.0150529286,
-0.0026245273,
-0.0437029414,
0.0367256813,
-0.0174121,
-0.034537755,
0.0007840235,
-0.0439941101,
0.0731697753,
-0.0147795202,
0.0196494032,
-0.0036374552,
-0.0128163155,
-0.0029179421,
0.0793127716,
-0.0324687883,
-0.0037954699,
0.0037317462,
-0.0047777905,
-0.0498056673,
-0.0219967049,
0.03316845,
-0.0142367594,
0.0124758417,
-0.0248832516,
-0.0122779803,
-0.0032979934,
-0.0101567963,
-0.0042107725,
-0.013033703,
0.0028748517,
-0.0396392681,
-0.0469041131,
-0.0217890944,
0.0559628233,
0.0306983963,
0.0076413481,
-0.0185101386,
0.0106172543,
0.0244181957,
0.0137872919,
0.0442722514,
0.0119326552,
0.0049309735,
0.0696911886,
0.0148654031,
-0.0270911716,
-0.0012350616,
-0.0124756433,
-0.0064187483,
0.0472374707,
0.0811506435,
0.0899351239,
0.0338968523,
-0.0219353046,
-0.0730535686,
-0.0122542474,
-0.0117889009,
0.0243204031,
0.0279982444,
0.000634347,
-0.0105134659,
0.0057394812,
-0.0641892776,
-0.0238749571,
-0.0391306467,
-0.014639684,
0.0569748171,
0.0227311831,
-0.0389163084,
-0.011334707,
0.0240720008,
-0.0603251308,
-0.0074927225,
0.0342040807,
-0.0218632054,
-0.0136348354,
0.0064251688,
0.0300909877,
-0.0132129602,
0.0300214645,
0.0515331142,
-0.0549132563,
0.0334381051,
0.0040548504,
0.0329267234,
0.0249697752,
-0.0555039234,
-0.022951141,
-0.0244240128,
0.0559370928,
0.0007120385,
0.020684218,
0.0299704913,
-0.0076720007,
-0.0270155743,
0.0089727221,
0.0102699753,
0.005544045,
-0.0435017385,
-0.0296249166,
-0.0263308398,
0.0099988328,
-0.0278798789,
-0.0261290427,
-0.0012170348,
-0.0350749567,
0.0259259716,
-0.0921484604,
0.0072688037,
-0.0286091808,
2.642e-7,
-0.0346546434,
0.0272301324,
0.0139984116,
0.0127249015,
0.0551957935,
0.0762798488,
-0.0171082709,
0.0724091008,
0.0108754234,
-0.0478632003,
-0.0461655669,
-0.0045866803,
0.0746420547,
0.0308283847,
-0.0473016761,
-0.0315744281,
-0.0893069282,
-0.0054493849,
-0.0525039993,
-0.0248777345,
0.0319796242,
0.1166296005,
-0.0033410243,
-0.0300604273,
0.0167282112,
-0.0696429536,
0.0319322795,
-0.0177839585,
-0.0044216341,
-0.0479633436,
0.0267136525,
0.0234885812,
0.0062081893,
0.0158116799,
-0.0241842307,
-0.0296858046,
-0.0043613063,
0.0724889264,
0.0136368824,
-0.0644738302,
-0.0470776893,
-0.0130926277,
-0.0008305013,
-0.0206206385,
0.0770773962,
-0.0104408115,
-0.0198370311,
-0.048227746,
-0.011978412,
-0.0328713842,
0.0253024716,
-0.0520236231,
-0.0056697698,
-0.0235359669,
0.0127783082,
0.0115092248,
0.026507264,
-0.0598693639,
-0.0100451382,
0.0043749441,
-0.0257174075,
-0.0549592935,
-0.0298177153,
0.0102456836,
0.0156544149,
-0.0335220397,
-0.0105837183,
2.396031946e-34,
0.0098357322,
-0.0323160402,
0.0304728132,
0.0089333458,
0.0438248068,
-0.002222948,
0.0268747807,
-0.0211044829,
0.0328017958,
-0.0699040443,
-0.0385981202
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08311v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08311v1
|
A Decoupling and Aggregating Framework for Joint Extraction of Entities and Relations
| 2024-05-14T04:27:16 | 2024-05-14T04:27:16 |
Yao Wang, Xin Liu, Weikun Kong, Hai-Tao Yu, Teeradaj Racharak, Kyoung-Sook Kim, Minh Le Nguyen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Named Entity Recognition and Relation Extraction are two crucial and
challenging subtasks in the field of Information Extraction. Despite the
successes achieved by the traditional approaches, fundamental research
questions remain open. First, most recent studies use parameter sharing for a
single subtask or shared features for both two subtasks, ignoring their
semantic differences. Second, information interaction mainly focuses on the two
subtasks, leaving the fine-grained informtion interaction among the
subtask-specific features of encoding subjects, relations, and objects
unexplored. Motivated by the aforementioned limitations, we propose a novel
model to jointly extract entities and relations. The main novelties are as
follows: (1) We propose to decouple the feature encoding process into three
parts, namely encoding subjects, encoding objects, and encoding relations.
Thanks to this, we are able to use fine-grained subtask-specific features. (2)
We propose novel inter-aggregation and intra-aggregation strategies to enhance
the information interaction and construct individual fine-grained
subtask-specific features, respectively. The experimental results demonstrate
that our model outperforms several previous state-of-the-art models. Extensive
additional experiments further confirm the effectiveness of our model.
|
A Decoupling and Aggregating Framework for Joint Extraction of Entities and Relations: Named Entity Recognition and Relation Extraction are two crucial and
challenging subtasks in the field of Information Extraction. Despite the
successes achieved by the traditional approaches, fundamental research
questions remain open. First, most recent studies use parameter sharing for a
single subtask or shared features for both two subtasks, ignoring their
semantic differences. Second, information interaction mainly focuses on the two
subtasks, leaving the fine-grained informtion interaction among the
subtask-specific features of encoding subjects, relations, and objects
unexplored. Motivated by the aforementioned limitations, we propose a novel
model to jointly extract entities and relations. The main novelties are as
follows: (1) We propose to decouple the feature encoding process into three
parts, namely encoding subjects, encoding objects, and encoding relations.
Thanks to this, we are able to use fine-grained subtask-specific features. (2)
We propose novel inter-aggregation and intra-aggregation strategies to enhance
the information interaction and construct individual fine-grained
subtask-specific features, respectively. The experimental results demonstrate
that our model outperforms several previous state-of-the-art models. Extensive
additional experiments further confirm the effectiveness of our model.
|
[
0.04447506,
0.0144724697,
0.0254383869,
0.0610196888,
-0.0192277841,
0.0622639209,
-0.0161914676,
-0.0067533483,
-0.0043237186,
-0.0534807146,
-0.0213193055,
-0.0211039223,
0.0013029384,
0.0054724845,
-0.022069918,
-0.062473245,
0.0226764362,
0.0140205352,
0.0278759152,
0.037563432,
0.0059855906,
0.0206781998,
-0.0250526778,
-0.0235803109,
-0.0379760712,
0.0230507515,
-0.0007393894,
-0.0165150054,
0.0352515206,
-0.0125069711,
-0.0042009405,
0.0262958426,
-0.0028122254,
0.0122409286,
0.0000017779,
-0.0404290706,
-0.0385213941,
0.0311366729,
-0.0345164947,
-0.0583361909,
-0.0111648124,
-0.0442015715,
-0.0126057696,
-0.0333148874,
-0.0191367175,
-0.1010968164,
0.0357166305,
0.0995365754,
-0.009205956,
0.0365138203,
-0.0432090275,
-0.0311953984,
0.0682676286,
-0.0287739914,
-0.0121111069,
-0.0303265043,
0.0286699142,
-0.0197373442,
-0.0337416641,
0.0110159973,
0.0165556017,
0.0083935577,
0.0032267291,
0.0212372132,
0.0078004315,
0.0573924705,
-0.028431898,
-0.0249408744,
-0.0196733344,
0.0772772506,
-0.0197679289,
0.0544940047,
0.0466268249,
0.0145846084,
-0.00571679,
0.0097081698,
-0.0173337255,
-0.018975351,
-0.0515155718,
-0.0007245611,
0.0258517284,
0.0205355454,
0.0056358716,
0.0113994963,
-0.0094079394,
-0.0195018072,
-0.0054205898,
-0.0236976147,
0.0193746872,
0.0435733497,
0.0058814823,
-0.0375659168,
0.0381185934,
0.0321442559,
0.0429481231,
0.02816738,
-0.0270798225,
-0.0395364389,
-0.0254075956,
-0.0518038236,
-0.0196953993,
-0.0004187727,
-0.0279400703,
0.0808076486,
-0.0605411232,
0.0077109099,
-0.0078585343,
-0.0166024119,
0.0039281705,
-0.0215515755,
-0.051690504,
0.0104392059,
-0.0227651037,
0.0970094651,
-0.03889158,
-0.0180250015,
0.0055702324,
0.0025257803,
0.00313507,
0.0218089968,
-0.0090115378,
0.0079923598,
-0.0143714324,
-0.0025663346,
-0.0005177763,
0.0276064761,
-0.049176652,
0.0081178425,
0.0001415117,
-0.0214583296,
-0.0172899552,
-0.051783897,
0.0525233597,
-0.0487953238,
0.0051234681,
0.0922273546,
0.0008620512,
-0.0609972142,
-0.0323728211,
-0.0537792109,
0.0086449515,
-0.0290263165,
0.0438961536,
-0.0266447775,
0.1140362322,
0.0243727043,
-0.0012840969,
-0.0343726389,
0.0314595476,
-0.0280575994,
-0.0796741694,
0.077735886,
-0.0266775191,
-0.0106342817,
0.0030716066,
0.022101339,
0.0380783491,
0.0714203566,
0.0466522612,
0.0259974655,
0.0388960056,
0.0142770801,
-0.0255712382,
0.0024605903,
0.0191090368,
-0.0314666443,
0.0447790958,
-0.0097336946,
0.0061801141,
-0.0385713354,
0.0383819379,
0.0405231752,
-0.0201950241,
0.0019780495,
0.0197101142,
0.0279084947,
0.0177060496,
0.026586527,
0.0142232943,
-0.0018710979,
0.0260206591,
0.0511378832,
-0.0511276834,
0.0276957229,
-0.0179033186,
0.0223303456,
-0.0210373159,
0.0614825748,
-0.0143802203,
-0.0150630726,
0.0204335973,
-0.0354278758,
0.0012867117,
0.01040849,
0.0752018541,
0.0216213036,
-0.0292664766,
0.0435986966,
0.0624862053,
-0.0297791045,
-0.0040324605,
0.0064045116,
-0.0157480892,
0.0246343929,
0.0190342478,
-0.019373104,
-0.0442443714,
-0.0044902787,
-0.035191007,
-0.0012109304,
0.0369522311,
-0.041045066,
0.0529445298,
-0.0203948766,
-0.0667206645,
0.0418318063,
-0.0094815604,
0.0104051465,
0.0160964411,
-0.01089954,
0.0357006043,
0.0387211367,
0.0065583074,
0.0295487642,
-0.0138309589,
-0.0404644273,
-0.0096055986,
0.0512245856,
0.0166461077,
0.0563576333,
-0.0104388744,
-0.0198429693,
0.047579091,
-0.0287816375,
-0.0019050735,
0.0020121979,
-0.0173713695,
-0.0442534238,
-0.0234207977,
0.047915943,
-0.0239817686,
-0.0445859134,
-0.0172628984,
-0.0364545062,
-0.0477289967,
0.029713016,
0.0569137894,
-0.0015109102,
0.0063800891,
0.0603140183,
0.0084316954,
-0.0529377647,
0.0730230734,
-0.0099589834,
-0.0277188811,
-0.0104030911,
-0.0763184428,
-0.0322985686,
-0.0238638297,
-0.0096338168,
0.0358215757,
0.0023060869,
-0.0397556126,
-0.0053673196,
-0.0210687239,
-0.0579095557,
-0.0458666123,
-0.0631391108,
0.0121456189,
0.0114027867,
0.0645637214,
0.0041369032,
0.0253484994,
-0.0245970823,
-0.0152802756,
-0.0101343673,
-0.0093843089,
-0.0360805057,
0.0136298686,
0.0085980017,
0.0563454777,
0.0058893827,
-0.0207980108,
-0.0040810606,
-0.0420059152,
0.0304202959,
0.0112444833,
-0.0784157589,
-0.0060498961,
0.0419287272,
-0.0349549539,
0.0456123762,
0.0171752702,
0.0029336999,
-0.0401822068,
0.0089515634,
0.0251937602,
0.0378163122,
-0.032919053,
0.0771364793,
-0.0260781795,
-0.0551764295,
-0.0239218734,
0.0501515307,
-0.053604722,
0.0388956591,
0.0085046729,
0.0022534141,
-0.0005093346,
0.0630872995,
-0.0196830295,
0.02738983,
-0.0129386811,
0.0074484227,
0.0013322815,
-0.0192051418,
-0.0181050971,
0.0238009524,
0.0188282654,
-0.0005209597,
-0.0914413258,
0.0003576335,
0.0784174055,
-0.0219735764,
-0.0072527337,
-0.0039837109,
0.028136719,
-0.0433463939,
0.0883709341,
-0.0058501023,
0.0195591021,
0.0282960124,
-0.052547235,
-0.0186856743,
0.0382886194,
-0.0060241721,
-0.0326864645,
0.0417396016,
-0.0185446627,
0.0179474596,
-0.02929838,
-0.005410057,
-0.0196688641,
-0.0077303969,
-0.0165707842,
0.0081881424,
-0.0140148876,
-0.0104291756,
0.0169959348,
0.0400170349,
0.0142526142,
0.001071861,
0.0016098912,
-0.0106937876,
-0.0257738978,
0.0658340752,
0.0374103598,
0.026457388,
-0.0286430698,
0.0174660143,
0.024317788,
0.0496622287,
0.0269798711,
-0.0038875164,
0.0411030985,
0.016595399,
0.0179422554,
-0.0490117893,
-0.0118407616,
-0.0345519967,
0.0334057212,
-0.056152951,
0.0203909278,
0.1089771017,
0.0235464852,
-0.0270781443,
-0.0388364941,
0.0500568263,
0.0102203358,
0.0035084512,
0.0132666714,
-0.0230321772,
-0.0233059265,
0.0133758038,
-0.0299842432,
0.0182650853,
-0.0608183891,
-0.0077980999,
-0.084817946,
-0.0036752825,
0.0038430421,
-0.0483281873,
-0.0159273781,
-0.0524280481,
0.0461625792,
-0.0209619608,
-0.0129950168,
-0.0133736283,
-0.0365230776,
-0.0091950288,
-0.0013242387,
0.0303890575,
-0.0464478135,
-0.0019258755,
-0.037666183,
0.0099762408,
0.0550142601,
0.0227838997,
0.0035257852,
0.0330536142,
-0.0111335535,
-0.0608648136,
-0.0193025898,
-0.0356485248,
0.0920056179,
-0.071757555,
-0.0173490308,
-0.0305545125,
-0.0155676715,
-0.0468123704,
-0.0099834921,
-0.0182815343,
0.0385798141,
0.0186126195,
0.0074839676,
0.007949613,
-0.0558749177,
0.0082225436,
0.0855621099,
-0.0008960553,
-0.0022953067,
-0.000786857,
0.0263329037,
-0.0032065478,
-0.0060381889,
0.0067914748,
-0.0127269542,
-0.0649517626,
-0.0294087753,
-0.0539340265,
-0.0936883613,
0.0724655762,
0.0301053952,
0.0150865037,
0.0272605233,
0.0551922508,
0.0187161472,
-0.0736828521,
0.021846557,
-0.0005448754,
-0.0116574522,
-0.0005870568,
-0.0179005377,
0.0005181507,
-0.0116475001,
-0.0365236215,
0.0000452301,
-0.04589618,
-0.0461638831,
0.0131103722,
0.0124918045,
0.0134354606,
0.0386940278,
-0.0036946586,
-0.0243345406,
-0.0130671058,
0.0116601335,
-0.0623653345,
-0.0040354813,
0.0072719748,
-0.0115035744,
-0.017882131,
0.0244423784,
-0.0426418521,
0.0350229554,
-0.0041087046,
0.0208037011,
-0.0676013306,
-0.0240313616,
0.0030054508,
-0.0133923814,
0.0688581094,
0.0164724104,
0.0122833857,
-0.0551410653,
0.024092732,
-0.0170938354,
-0.0015803152,
-0.0423284285,
0.0040846108,
0.0034297532,
0.0084990179,
0.0067921137,
0.0463268533,
0.0442248322,
0.0120573398,
-0.0390337259,
-0.0303682666,
-0.0115401661,
0.0101588117,
0.0004319669,
-0.0101722768,
0.010124716,
0.0452529341,
0.0261723287,
-0.007966944,
-0.0383570939,
0.0163324922,
-0.0006518744,
-0.0283530001,
-0.0179178473,
0.0239134952,
-0.0298769437,
0.0440816879,
-0.0437833406,
0.0445614122,
0.0212985016,
-0.0392941944,
0.0506934375,
0.0106596099,
-0.009638194,
0.0186592303,
0.0136047285,
-0.0133636063,
0.0273678359,
0.0214599911,
0.0333231762,
-0.0198863167,
-0.0235490184,
0.0720616579,
-0.0190033261,
0.0336907059,
0.0130016571,
-0.0072553842,
-0.0258095898,
-0.0254140235,
0.0183164291,
0.0011542316,
-0.0152504351,
0.014361605,
-0.03002044,
-0.0233526435,
0.0167214293,
-0.0425685048,
-0.0022590817,
0.0134356935,
0.0242023934,
0.0194724817,
0.0150362384,
-0.0632188544,
-0.0290858578,
-0.0024244557,
-0.0310409162,
-0.0066493014,
0.0076924185,
-6.048562753e-33,
-0.0925748348,
-0.0157563705,
-0.000462556,
0.0474451445,
-0.0257423762,
0.0582604595,
-0.0118356384,
-0.0036671523,
-0.0202082936,
0.0047995774,
0.0047811614,
-0.001940903,
0.0425917991,
0.0015008451,
-0.0241185203,
-0.0237922203,
0.0300510302,
0.0223554242,
0.0170478839,
0.0211701449,
0.0339730158,
0.0645888522,
0.0485724211,
-0.1120604277,
0.0247305576,
0.0105919121,
0.0249538776,
0.023921743,
0.0685720667,
0.0706279874,
-0.0287182145,
-0.008025093,
0.0409973823,
-0.0089699505,
0.0059711942,
0.0498319305,
-0.2089165151,
-0.0029606766,
-0.0201736726,
0.0146769779,
-0.0278432518,
-0.0289606154,
0.0170592964,
0.0075830938,
0.0634646416,
-0.0513465255,
0.0080743264,
-0.0312049165,
-0.0022789941,
-0.0411828458,
-0.0478077009,
0.0291759279,
0.0610516258,
-0.0007024088,
0.0855944827,
-0.0248501319,
0.0560381226,
-0.0319503918,
-0.0493153073,
-0.0426239409,
-0.0066919001,
0.0138471629,
0.0252324883,
0.0459887683,
-0.0164418109,
0.0507431626,
-0.0026980888,
-0.0103560966,
-0.0403881669,
0.01898917,
-0.0240787864,
0.0687178299,
-0.0503873304,
-0.000184632,
0.0176222548,
0.0029111241,
-0.0565412715,
0.0292997248,
0.0152457422,
0.04801552,
-0.0610772558,
-0.0032013529,
-0.065824382,
0.0183873363,
-0.0056264889,
0.0093417121,
-0.0224557854,
-0.0340260267,
0.0059158891,
0.0301924851,
-0.0441242009,
0.0690646172,
-0.004308329,
0.0043598292,
-0.0180146415,
0.0045663086,
0.0355054624,
0.0359668024,
-0.0183517709,
-0.0429544449,
-0.0614526421,
-0.0529570617,
0.0030149557,
-0.0073485221,
0.0018560538,
0.0219888259,
0.0605247281,
-0.0400142781,
-0.0380203091,
-0.0151111456,
-0.0272799749,
0.0179665983,
-0.007927916,
0.0183945727,
0.0294511486,
0.0088249017,
-0.0177826528,
0.0081157777,
0.0698946267,
0.0198723059,
-0.0480877347,
0.042721156,
0.0029036128,
0.0227539353,
0.05044467,
-0.0127653973,
0.0009862462,
-0.0481904894,
0.0374088511,
-0.0249380264,
-0.0018356264,
0.0012682102,
2.567e-7,
0.0130062001,
-0.0016603549,
0.0705442131,
-0.0031773637,
-0.0034042744,
0.0266239438,
0.0400629304,
0.0549507327,
0.0024047347,
-0.032933753,
-0.0174390916,
0.0187040996,
-0.007008187,
0.0359500386,
-0.0548091307,
-0.0502236784,
0.0132973706,
-0.0471262857,
-0.0506853946,
0.013331905,
0.0661043748,
0.051324144,
0.0243480485,
0.0059411917,
-0.0494564846,
-0.0324197859,
0.0541277602,
-0.0084318528,
-0.0027756765,
0.052135285,
-0.0188629907,
0.0364559777,
-0.0238528121,
0.0659821332,
-0.021800058,
0.0303845163,
0.0267624632,
0.0479266234,
-0.033165548,
-0.0189991109,
-0.0086534331,
-0.0266319774,
0.014176311,
0.0333387777,
0.0897178873,
-0.0651743561,
-0.0022070115,
0.0000709501,
-0.0075010136,
0.0459720045,
-0.0620043054,
0.0409399495,
-0.0191231556,
0.039800331,
0.0303756688,
-0.0131020499,
-0.0582752712,
-0.0933154747,
-0.0089764474,
0.0644611418,
0.0237798654,
-0.0152415577,
-0.0138890557,
-0.0568618253,
0.0019912024,
-0.0587054938,
-0.0459391773,
2.329383483e-34,
-0.070331201,
0.0305490158,
-0.0111146187,
0.0662788972,
-0.0029174592,
-0.0506403632,
-0.0888937041,
0.0100242542,
-0.0343868248,
-0.046007596,
0.0230420846
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08304v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08304v2
|
Computational Thought Experiments for a More Rigorous Philosophy and Science of the Mind
| 2024-05-14T03:58:19 | 2024-05-15T02:32:00 |
Iris Oved, Nikhil Krishnaswamy, James Pustejovsky, Joshua Hartshorne
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, q-bio.NC
|
We offer philosophical motivations for a method we call Virtual World
Cognitive Science (VW CogSci), in which researchers use virtual embodied agents
that are embedded in virtual worlds to explore questions in the field of
Cognitive Science. We focus on questions about mental and linguistic
representation and the ways that such computational modeling can add rigor to
philosophical thought experiments, as well as the terminology used in the
scientific study of such representations. We find that this method forces
researchers to take a god's-eye view when describing dynamical relationships
between entities in minds and entities in an environment in a way that
eliminates the need for problematic talk of belief and concept types, such as
the belief that cats are silly, and the concept CAT, while preserving belief
and concept tokens in individual cognizers' minds. We conclude with some
further key advantages of VW CogSci for the scientific study of mental and
linguistic representation and for Cognitive Science more broadly.
|
Computational Thought Experiments for a More Rigorous Philosophy and Science of the Mind: We offer philosophical motivations for a method we call Virtual World
Cognitive Science (VW CogSci), in which researchers use virtual embodied agents
that are embedded in virtual worlds to explore questions in the field of
Cognitive Science. We focus on questions about mental and linguistic
representation and the ways that such computational modeling can add rigor to
philosophical thought experiments, as well as the terminology used in the
scientific study of such representations. We find that this method forces
researchers to take a god's-eye view when describing dynamical relationships
between entities in minds and entities in an environment in a way that
eliminates the need for problematic talk of belief and concept types, such as
the belief that cats are silly, and the concept CAT, while preserving belief
and concept tokens in individual cognizers' minds. We conclude with some
further key advantages of VW CogSci for the scientific study of mental and
linguistic representation and for Cognitive Science more broadly.
|
[
0.0375164673,
0.0273947548,
-0.0798340216,
0.0133822318,
-0.0402873531,
-0.0049834391,
-0.0020352006,
0.0003357872,
0.0259301942,
-0.0425140224,
-0.0298532993,
-0.028738508,
0.0350320078,
-0.0233492386,
0.0772214606,
-0.0552087501,
0.0452093631,
-0.0240807254,
-0.0051385914,
0.00069896,
-0.0445118882,
-0.0071107959,
-0.0362763442,
0.0185216982,
0.0095134163,
-0.0181292463,
-0.0557716973,
-0.022163406,
0.011736921,
-0.0587127246,
-0.0709965676,
-0.054151047,
0.0370267145,
0.0284271296,
0.0000021715,
-0.0173789952,
0.0284518078,
-0.0060101952,
-0.0176471118,
-0.0217732992,
-0.011280058,
0.0439213291,
-0.0008482178,
-0.0126361744,
-0.0211137719,
-0.0265007429,
0.0560968146,
0.0087756477,
-0.0322672948,
0.0083251325,
0.0061338344,
0.0045583025,
-0.0008300128,
0.0342431925,
0.0423493832,
0.0638149157,
0.0280383471,
0.0531876944,
0.0575531945,
-0.0066326391,
-0.0371587947,
0.0062174802,
0.0277798828,
0.0111262919,
-0.0086351028,
0.0242197048,
-0.0521849692,
-0.0059594368,
0.0289233271,
0.0309426114,
0.0810909793,
-0.0206200462,
0.0104639474,
0.0509683825,
-0.0013598778,
0.0443086103,
-0.0116655985,
0.0405058451,
0.0059470525,
-0.0182018913,
0.0447734743,
0.0471239053,
0.0048326901,
0.0321801864,
-0.029991094,
0.0519579314,
-0.0060648392,
-0.0177686475,
0.0110377073,
0.0102505647,
-0.0532916188,
-0.0385178402,
-0.0251817666,
0.0127546005,
-0.0091064908,
0.0030889495,
0.0099187624,
0.0181548204,
-0.0194021035,
-0.0694597736,
0.1008596867,
0.0450750366,
0.0279606413,
0.0158484597,
0.0210335944,
0.036302004,
-0.0211024415,
0.0356077887,
-0.0033603064,
0.0354556553,
-0.0757744387,
-0.0071816924,
-0.0316844471,
0.0666384846,
0.0332717001,
-0.0262824949,
0.0137225119,
0.0034995233,
-0.0543510951,
-0.0086788349,
-0.1057419553,
-0.0038757245,
0.0077875718,
0.0409235321,
-0.036729902,
-0.0005950624,
-0.0379653089,
0.0157991648,
-0.0242804568,
-0.0725729316,
-0.0082712499,
0.0070808115,
-0.0259427857,
0.00621035,
-0.0222319793,
0.0206974819,
0.0420450047,
-0.0175312869,
0.0679591447,
-0.0364171304,
0.0135346921,
-0.0187939536,
0.0185152814,
-0.0091305533,
0.0042080083,
-0.016590314,
0.018263828,
0.0072428603,
0.006720277,
-0.0205661673,
0.0078144912,
0.1065623462,
-0.0175333973,
-0.0244029034,
0.0341499224,
0.0299387127,
-0.0014719212,
0.0093477797,
0.0061122766,
-0.0400074795,
-0.039662376,
-0.0052677407,
0.0104266182,
-0.0231583193,
-0.000663256,
-0.0356209129,
-0.0336957015,
-0.0160178784,
0.027309889,
0.0629411638,
-0.0341730751,
0.0257598311,
-0.0538502857,
0.0379780605,
0.050324522,
0.0773452669,
-0.0336686596,
0.0133260163,
0.0620141849,
-0.0363025144,
0.0396745764,
0.020425966,
-0.0478917547,
0.0482687019,
0.0120558282,
-0.0039061205,
-0.0332739726,
-0.0041681444,
-0.0239257962,
-0.0162408073,
0.0049005761,
0.0090967771,
0.0326091312,
-0.0106197558,
0.0108329458,
-0.0132116266,
0.0463318415,
-0.0393498465,
0.0167535543,
-0.0175603162,
-0.0279309321,
-0.0586052798,
0.0332956128,
0.030867951,
0.0382721312,
-0.0211464111,
-0.0095455283,
-0.0094296224,
0.0107083367,
0.0799153447,
0.0520371497,
-0.004221736,
-0.0627327263,
0.0230518468,
0.0330563188,
-0.0466347784,
-0.010470869,
0.0270576831,
-0.0676425546,
0.0429020561,
-0.0260064751,
0.0667072758,
0.0264809318,
0.0347542875,
-0.0183099862,
0.0033509096,
-0.0758353025,
-0.0080970665,
0.0045325081,
-0.0034775108,
-0.0022361369,
0.0079294955,
0.0251556262,
-0.0033535918,
-0.009579869,
0.0652173311,
-0.0215941072,
0.0260265954,
0.0264961291,
-0.0917691812,
0.0246020854,
0.002892378,
0.0584986284,
0.0190887675,
0.065681994,
-0.0434204824,
0.0540006869,
-0.015109268,
0.0207703914,
-0.0306731332,
-0.0062171873,
0.016808996,
0.0176627599,
0.0157328825,
0.0320248529,
0.0310342889,
-0.0208529439,
0.0581955686,
-0.0309331659,
0.0059899362,
0.0310592968,
-0.0017814953,
0.0046571651,
-0.017302461,
-0.0573242232,
-0.0507004596,
-0.0044790315,
-0.0882390738,
-0.0474858731,
0.0288306009,
-0.0480016693,
-0.0118395435,
-0.0503978655,
-0.0149870403,
0.0056128372,
0.0043597221,
0.0356163383,
0.0006631748,
0.025888687,
0.0157768242,
-0.0250624903,
-0.0136829093,
-0.0157648586,
0.0428026654,
-0.0409247726,
0.0509820953,
0.0133526977,
-0.0301277135,
-0.0426689051,
0.0020573807,
-0.0962826759,
-0.0137716625,
0.0058156168,
-0.0386209078,
0.0656908453,
0.0197974537,
-0.0121433027,
0.0373838134,
-0.0211685766,
0.0182030275,
0.0815227106,
-0.0029308638,
-0.0253326297,
-0.0148358047,
0.0284666959,
0.0242516864,
-0.0041166148,
-0.040106304,
-0.019008385,
0.0528762192,
0.0232574008,
0.0144599536,
-0.0626991466,
0.1356325895,
-0.0385995917,
-0.0531997867,
0.0124818692,
-0.0375005603,
-0.0077738347,
0.0020591519,
-0.0336766541,
0.02045816,
0.0784842968,
0.0156156216,
-0.0095768897,
0.0065551223,
0.0246155225,
0.032926172,
0.02695271,
0.0148917232,
0.0114334151,
0.0613994002,
0.0331849754,
-0.0654256865,
0.0215139203,
-0.0133244917,
-0.0150730265,
-0.0378049314,
-0.0557606183,
0.0092727989,
0.0047265375,
-0.0057458985,
-0.0586593635,
0.0744768679,
-0.0587290153,
0.0172603279,
-0.0099083269,
0.028762294,
-0.0454842411,
-0.0215896796,
0.0592383742,
-0.0142713357,
0.0212094374,
-0.0453173332,
-0.038773112,
-0.0656805411,
0.0399149768,
0.0832062736,
0.0414284915,
0.007694127,
0.0366199836,
0.040737588,
-0.0268557649,
0.0167702809,
-0.0375992283,
-0.0025348221,
-0.0009974682,
-0.0264784358,
-0.0085168816,
0.0055157468,
0.0362892784,
-0.0040567191,
-0.0314055644,
0.0574237853,
0.0446893796,
0.0229245014,
0.0444256067,
-0.0430047512,
-0.0428988598,
0.0469900481,
0.0229306053,
-0.0551378615,
0.0370483249,
-0.0147926947,
-0.056520123,
-0.0432124026,
-0.058005359,
-0.0113876425,
-0.0627245307,
0.0048605264,
0.0109684523,
0.0146644805,
0.0036206651,
0.0150840217,
0.022146957,
0.0244371314,
-0.0377464928,
-0.0047684866,
0.0219105314,
0.0376940668,
-0.0140120341,
0.0288663357,
0.0482682288,
-0.0037950065,
0.0019280206,
0.065801993,
-0.0027964064,
0.0269675665,
-0.014184935,
-0.1102449968,
-0.0687461197,
-0.0296139289,
0.0335200429,
0.0042568692,
0.0048097973,
0.0003740443,
0.0105871642,
-0.0453935303,
-0.0186609738,
-0.0190375187,
-0.0392664485,
0.0242199823,
0.0650245845,
-0.0748300403,
-0.0397000313,
-0.0024458426,
0.0356119946,
0.0002414521,
0.0299149845,
0.0374855138,
-0.0527421981,
0.0223397557,
-0.0294458754,
0.0260928348,
0.0929559246,
-0.0983541831,
-0.043915648,
0.0461229123,
0.0365899317,
-0.0801439881,
-0.0320514515,
0.0080418522,
0.0343035795,
0.0081471084,
-0.0357089192,
0.0361255035,
-0.0132880257,
-0.0441333726,
0.0167557839,
-0.0222370829,
-0.0027100749,
0.0199111756,
-0.0314779952,
0.0461951904,
-0.0608120225,
0.0048332536,
0.0251520276,
0.0323229581,
-0.051415164,
0.0164832491,
0.0290433783,
0.0256004427,
-0.018702833,
0.0235627033,
-0.0013373784,
0.0168693028,
-0.0361183845,
-0.0406921767,
0.0585417263,
-0.0211349409,
0.057203345,
0.0040782485,
0.0017368598,
0.0479249135,
0.007365406,
-0.0344377272,
-0.03016329,
-0.0516201816,
-0.0391778238,
0.0280819852,
-0.008086089,
0.0290540718,
0.0164443124,
0.0335916355,
0.0279773269,
-0.016147878,
-0.0419106521,
-0.0095888022,
-0.0022387987,
-0.0629526824,
-0.0215809438,
0.0517624542,
0.0241962112,
-0.0305772163,
-0.0270572454,
0.0232918933,
0.0535614602,
-0.0326359347,
0.003978699,
0.0320276394,
-0.0449089818,
0.0456950516,
0.0091854986,
0.0466955155,
-0.060444057,
0.0491158515,
-0.0189061891,
0.0612296164,
0.02256223,
-0.0183478501,
-0.0466813371,
0.0055809473,
-0.0406019203,
-0.0945012346,
0.0744712055,
0.0493812114,
-0.0003833388,
0.0179471597,
-0.0107415533,
-0.0495959595,
0.0100551769,
0.0158810169,
0.0343066268,
0.0487916879,
-0.0364508815,
-0.0086935824,
0.0351172574,
-0.0255072657,
-0.0497620516,
-0.0191029105,
-0.0687902197,
0.02150172,
-0.0323295817,
-0.0065919245,
-0.0166337006,
0.0000560983,
-0.0280406103,
0.035541255,
0.0213503316,
0.0212449823,
-0.0846743733,
-0.0372442417,
0.0450750999,
0.0229264833,
-0.0112311207,
-0.043101117,
0.0248595495,
-0.0072913948,
0.0395573229,
-0.0180577394,
0.0260095764,
0.0359244235,
-0.0049646003,
-0.0076806783,
-0.0440314785,
-5.794585076e-33,
-0.0542307049,
-0.0173522327,
0.0278768111,
0.0088524381,
-0.0643635616,
0.0014381409,
-0.0471347421,
0.0291246194,
-0.0231662504,
0.0075261276,
0.0065649804,
-0.0151931196,
-0.0088572288,
-0.0266542342,
0.0408426449,
-0.0073605268,
-0.0024868804,
-0.0117146308,
-0.0389091708,
-0.0436513796,
0.0117128333,
-0.0442784615,
0.0100232707,
-0.0825380012,
0.0343350992,
0.0122236675,
0.0334941149,
-0.0335672162,
-0.0312265716,
0.0011090242,
-0.0652602464,
0.039529141,
0.0170511696,
-0.0014878539,
0.0203698017,
0.0233350452,
0.0067792563,
-0.0683877245,
0.00963894,
-0.0002338313,
-0.040320348,
-0.016891174,
-0.0274363123,
-0.0054354738,
-0.0163921937,
0.0416687541,
0.0313057639,
-0.0309352856,
0.0062366854,
0.0282721333,
-0.066308558,
-0.0582607798,
-0.0022311739,
0.0003329685,
0.0390155762,
-0.008038573,
-0.0250849295,
-0.0229582768,
-0.0569518097,
0.0388157889,
-0.0447632559,
-0.0331460387,
0.0329457633,
-0.0156690869,
0.0459093414,
0.0585681088,
0.0425079763,
0.0486110151,
-0.0889712796,
0.0124192033,
0.0311235972,
0.0135387108,
0.0278325789,
0.067921631,
0.0033843303,
-0.0045035668,
-0.0277051497,
-0.0257100444,
0.0246383362,
-0.0068149632,
0.0312107652,
0.0032440077,
-0.0381693318,
0.0042747618,
0.0195459668,
-0.0146137243,
-0.0098516187,
-0.0349282324,
-0.0215624031,
-0.0484824739,
-0.0229730569,
-0.0282199867,
0.015274765,
-0.0474309251,
-0.0192744248,
-0.0394721813,
-0.0073316703,
0.0409630612,
0.0089790691,
-0.0345822684,
-0.0079054115,
-0.0304119661,
-0.0008025988,
0.0600585938,
0.0441254042,
0.0098784892,
-0.0082160346,
0.0154084759,
0.0088868141,
-0.012210751,
-0.0016630904,
-0.0176138747,
0.038968537,
-0.013790668,
0.0217762329,
0.0276072063,
0.0010693218,
-0.1010522619,
0.0384802222,
-0.0286600273,
-0.0084809884,
0.0552175865,
-0.0730334818,
0.0256908089,
-0.0078091491,
0.0083558038,
-0.0723407865,
0.0240566805,
0.0434842631,
-0.0756260082,
-0.0409661382,
-0.0188105963,
3.1e-7,
-0.0309261531,
0.0320312455,
0.0195117928,
0.0371684283,
0.0446734056,
0.0300304722,
0.016961677,
0.0197615698,
0.0325576887,
-0.0922938213,
-0.0246238224,
0.0328123942,
0.0158577897,
0.0062903385,
-0.0240294356,
-0.0197598245,
0.0384663641,
0.0205196291,
-0.0355404988,
0.0550526902,
0.0281783082,
0.0041178889,
0.0471517965,
0.0043673269,
-0.0076617962,
0.0465062149,
0.0143073061,
-0.0069705583,
0.040526215,
-0.0185299087,
-0.0400092378,
0.0061359694,
-0.0058722002,
0.0301935188,
0.033705119,
0.0065348339,
0.020019738,
-0.0474769026,
-0.0043055215,
0.0245654769,
-0.0090569323,
-0.0305421259,
-0.0082599018,
-0.0287854467,
0.054577969,
-0.1043259576,
-0.0140140979,
0.0197153892,
-0.0203179512,
-0.0173968356,
0.0119096814,
-0.0069338172,
-0.0195959415,
0.0128247319,
-0.0308700092,
-0.0068106069,
0.0176503751,
-0.025607232,
0.0138553996,
-0.0413207449,
-0.0249902066,
-0.0272824876,
0.0061571007,
-0.0346429907,
0.0388836786,
-0.0585576519,
0.0086793322,
2.245059441e-34,
-0.0250643026,
0.0485781617,
0.0379017815,
-0.0087129828,
0.021303026,
-0.0000234461,
0.01824921,
-0.0063972347,
0.073704645,
-0.0076452633,
-0.0108986618
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08295v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08295v2
|
SpeechVerse: A Large-scale Generalizable Audio Language Model
| 2024-05-14T03:33:31 | 2024-05-31T17:47:40 |
Nilaksh Das, Saket Dingliwal, Srikanth Ronanki, Rohit Paturi, Zhaocheng Huang, Prashant Mathur, Jie Yuan, Dhanush Bekal, Xing Niu, Sai Muralidhar Jayanthi, Xilai Li, Karel Mundnich, Monica Sunkara, Sundararajan Srinivasan, Kyu J Han, Katrin Kirchhoff
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown incredible proficiency in performing
tasks that require semantic understanding of natural language instructions.
Recently, many works have further expanded this capability to perceive
multimodal audio and text inputs, but their capabilities are often limited to
specific fine-tuned tasks such as automatic speech recognition and translation.
We therefore develop SpeechVerse, a robust multi-task training and curriculum
learning framework that combines pre-trained speech and text foundation models
via a small set of learnable parameters, while keeping the pre-trained models
frozen during training. The models are instruction finetuned using continuous
latent representations extracted from the speech foundation model to achieve
optimal zero-shot performance on a diverse range of speech processing tasks
using natural language instructions. We perform extensive benchmarking that
includes comparing our model performance against traditional baselines across
several datasets and tasks. Furthermore, we evaluate the model's capability for
generalized instruction following by testing on out-of-domain datasets, novel
prompts, and unseen tasks. Our empirical experiments reveal that our multi-task
SpeechVerse model is even superior to conventional task-specific baselines on 9
out of the 11 tasks.
|
SpeechVerse: A Large-scale Generalizable Audio Language Model: Large language models (LLMs) have shown incredible proficiency in performing
tasks that require semantic understanding of natural language instructions.
Recently, many works have further expanded this capability to perceive
multimodal audio and text inputs, but their capabilities are often limited to
specific fine-tuned tasks such as automatic speech recognition and translation.
We therefore develop SpeechVerse, a robust multi-task training and curriculum
learning framework that combines pre-trained speech and text foundation models
via a small set of learnable parameters, while keeping the pre-trained models
frozen during training. The models are instruction finetuned using continuous
latent representations extracted from the speech foundation model to achieve
optimal zero-shot performance on a diverse range of speech processing tasks
using natural language instructions. We perform extensive benchmarking that
includes comparing our model performance against traditional baselines across
several datasets and tasks. Furthermore, we evaluate the model's capability for
generalized instruction following by testing on out-of-domain datasets, novel
prompts, and unseen tasks. Our empirical experiments reveal that our multi-task
SpeechVerse model is even superior to conventional task-specific baselines on 9
out of the 11 tasks.
|
[
-0.004938378,
0.0089830635,
-0.0078047574,
0.0360475257,
-0.0009457521,
0.0095455134,
0.0498579703,
-0.0535734706,
-0.0506275333,
-0.0544834174,
-0.0720683262,
-0.0300689898,
-0.0105943661,
-0.0078420527,
0.034582518,
-0.0661473945,
0.0300452337,
-0.0813449472,
-0.0077695833,
0.0081538884,
0.0131019233,
0.0265593939,
-0.0486190654,
0.0753735378,
0.0013572013,
-0.0433627777,
0.0060040597,
0.0179924257,
0.0108294263,
-0.0269550234,
0.0053961999,
0.0309051387,
0.0783818141,
0.0176282842,
0.000001806,
-0.0224545654,
0.0230087377,
-0.0243698694,
-0.029334886,
0.0040570269,
0.0243783928,
0.015594082,
-0.0267196652,
0.037055552,
-0.0065979948,
-0.0116622848,
0.0224512797,
0.0190514866,
0.0674165785,
0.0550170429,
-0.0115607921,
-0.0422267802,
0.0065002721,
-0.0217657499,
0.0205106772,
-0.0482142083,
-0.0217868611,
-0.0006117685,
0.0303749125,
0.0095242187,
-0.0464035086,
0.0432352908,
0.017549878,
0.0109969219,
0.0127821192,
0.0219812896,
-0.0391770117,
-0.0314175971,
-0.0578037947,
0.1095095575,
-0.0116976015,
-0.0057868874,
-0.0039027135,
0.0083939759,
-0.0364026874,
-0.033810962,
-0.0656096935,
0.0437702388,
0.0315206572,
-0.0026248773,
-0.0244479291,
0.024566669,
0.0235971007,
-0.0158951674,
-0.0018030752,
0.0121724857,
0.01441711,
-0.0301524214,
0.0094577279,
-0.0159222297,
-0.0751691982,
-0.0334827714,
0.020982407,
0.0317156427,
-0.0646722093,
0.006122516,
-0.0498495549,
-0.0441819169,
-0.0160949882,
-0.0099228499,
0.0485073887,
0.0588513799,
-0.0798734725,
0.0755976737,
-0.0094693638,
0.0724534541,
-0.0100248484,
0.006923981,
-0.0060966983,
0.0178564806,
-0.0539901331,
0.0065944307,
-0.0225322116,
0.0113838315,
-0.0394115373,
-0.0450657606,
-0.0059018699,
0.0140906377,
-0.0289012287,
0.0334173441,
0.0435806289,
0.0169877149,
-0.0619804487,
-0.0054902309,
0.0241431147,
0.0539345518,
-0.0081135929,
0.0700321496,
-0.0170991756,
-0.0173434764,
-0.0024315775,
0.0181492604,
0.0251432043,
-0.0048055141,
0.0339673422,
0.0794282332,
-0.0280729737,
-0.0453260317,
-0.0336394347,
0.0009727839,
-0.0205023289,
-0.0720602423,
-0.0155246807,
-0.0434819609,
0.0165524986,
-0.0014371331,
0.0201938879,
-0.0017835356,
-0.0052832817,
0.0078688897,
0.0014014177,
0.0643883869,
0.0398971811,
0.031112209,
0.029042419,
0.0222290866,
-0.0027294601,
0.0747890696,
0.0394858494,
0.014485782,
0.0129173342,
-0.0088026701,
-0.0266964771,
0.0898489878,
-0.0213156175,
0.0095420321,
-0.0157481898,
-0.0079098018,
0.0205827635,
0.0302392934,
0.0283009969,
0.0230843574,
-0.0280917175,
0.0044542267,
0.0762462616,
0.0586985834,
-0.0115429508,
-0.0379471332,
0.0785776898,
0.0289733205,
-0.0153597901,
-0.0041576042,
-0.0514213406,
0.0042089266,
0.0160812344,
0.0027562289,
0.0161352754,
0.0196326338,
-0.0443180017,
0.014097631,
0.0215718653,
-0.0346439406,
-0.0077670128,
0.0230625253,
0.0481667146,
0.0098928148,
-0.078334935,
-0.0201713406,
0.0124347638,
-0.0420918986,
0.020460967,
0.0047858204,
0.015933672,
0.0772716999,
0.0186788943,
-0.0325244553,
-0.0342672169,
-0.0386767089,
0.0517594442,
0.0425842069,
-0.0016222204,
-0.0123863174,
0.0507512428,
-0.0727492943,
-0.0281536616,
0.0055349907,
0.0131965587,
0.0379521623,
-0.0245779399,
0.0199641846,
0.0044432511,
-0.0101771653,
0.0171661042,
0.0190762039,
-0.0515759848,
-0.03384424,
-0.0088975411,
0.020865012,
0.0288549904,
0.0336616747,
-0.0349955522,
-0.0233903136,
0.0461159758,
-0.0295325443,
0.0376057625,
0.0220303163,
-0.0734390542,
-0.0288697127,
0.0254722834,
-0.0254789535,
0.0047590821,
0.0328420252,
-0.0217855666,
-0.0423019044,
0.0143601466,
0.01532155,
0.0352607965,
-0.0329940468,
0.0377399586,
0.0089254165,
-0.0219694059,
0.001615981,
-0.0150361462,
0.0204574596,
-0.0109056383,
0.0432223603,
0.0030150798,
0.0059816465,
-0.0587285049,
-0.0372985788,
0.0031412379,
0.0001863706,
0.0198702291,
-0.0133633967,
0.0145604918,
-0.0340856761,
-0.0077875745,
-0.1017931178,
0.0378353223,
-0.0321480185,
-0.0067593358,
0.0204439647,
-0.0036406158,
-0.0001912245,
-0.0337861814,
-0.0062113409,
-0.0052068313,
-0.0002751733,
-0.000583309,
-0.0533576682,
0.00296443,
-0.013907712,
-0.0183594953,
0.0154520934,
0.0080148065,
-0.0015984109,
-0.0249460991,
0.0291507915,
-0.0328232683,
0.024304254,
0.0093602017,
0.0540891066,
-0.0255762581,
-0.0152303763,
0.0039530373,
-0.0124084568,
0.0396433808,
0.0661439672,
-0.0020848252,
0.0031802682,
0.0269442331,
-0.000068844,
-0.0506407693,
0.0149924504,
0.0027239467,
-0.0249538347,
-0.0502653494,
0.0329981856,
-0.0464774445,
0.0521251,
0.0417954363,
0.0389490426,
-0.085981518,
-0.0424122438,
-0.0270244237,
-0.0343323275,
-0.0519306548,
-0.0215187408,
-0.0368858911,
-0.0000872643,
-0.0229614116,
-0.0096584372,
0.0277388934,
-0.0740051419,
-0.0429761857,
-0.0339343101,
-0.0254876185,
0.0021015098,
0.0292885378,
-0.0223577786,
-0.0038545423,
0.0231624413,
-0.0263477284,
-0.0671667308,
0.0222667046,
0.0301020518,
-0.0283707883,
0.0348757356,
-0.0469708815,
-0.0260866769,
-0.0055105058,
-0.0248535667,
-0.048696816,
-0.0226895623,
-0.0278235544,
-0.0073975381,
-0.0319255926,
-0.0016767621,
-0.0470045395,
0.0078181364,
0.0361366682,
0.0750610903,
-0.0122721177,
0.013510094,
-0.0651187524,
-0.0042073228,
0.0514244623,
0.0031185281,
-0.0582867749,
-0.046546597,
0.0526571348,
0.0079468852,
0.0647921264,
-0.0259708948,
-0.0420830324,
0.0387287959,
0.0385145135,
0.0247107018,
-0.0389602184,
0.0671953931,
0.0771534517,
-0.0647062957,
0.0150424019,
0.114876844,
0.0101748407,
-0.0283198059,
-0.019935824,
0.0377443805,
0.0101073114,
0.0342252776,
-0.0150972307,
-0.0742872506,
-0.0602745712,
0.0266681202,
0.038565442,
0.0490532033,
0.0138483606,
-0.0032926751,
-0.0909268409,
0.0326775238,
0.0195984468,
-0.0311156306,
0.0022988536,
-0.0175919924,
0.0015855215,
-0.0174095035,
0.033901453,
-0.014119721,
-0.0337488838,
-0.0101692993,
0.0304577276,
0.0180040319,
-0.0637313575,
0.0635071844,
-0.0377465449,
0.0744916126,
0.070634447,
0.0171085484,
0.0066332188,
-0.0192423239,
0.0145918708,
0.0221999809,
-0.0005111355,
0.0081923474,
0.0386725031,
-0.0326360278,
-0.0184609629,
0.04311556,
0.0599879585,
-0.0175306778,
-0.0098436279,
0.0334510393,
0.0721454471,
-0.0154754575,
0.0235561933,
0.0050740833,
0.028342722,
0.0236639865,
0.0760330707,
0.0039149029,
-0.0642214864,
0.0010581395,
-0.0001478259,
-0.018266106,
-0.0604312345,
-0.0294028502,
0.0155258309,
-0.0223002099,
0.0046518086,
-0.0253942627,
-0.0069447779,
0.0575418733,
0.0543136597,
0.0336719044,
0.0064681377,
0.0298500825,
0.0308037214,
-0.0395865254,
0.0368812084,
-0.0098031368,
0.0605520159,
-0.093166329,
-0.0354096666,
0.0374418236,
-0.0545984395,
-0.0314951688,
0.0165304057,
-0.0840782002,
-0.062860705,
-0.015784312,
0.0222972687,
0.0173784029,
0.0615269765,
-0.0132553549,
-0.0422182009,
0.0248239376,
-0.0105012851,
-0.0819537342,
0.0501415282,
0.0505903363,
-0.0302303992,
-0.0123693524,
0.0072601689,
-0.0478275903,
0.0542396158,
-0.0052460171,
0.036722932,
0.0149709396,
-0.0007776393,
-0.0218467098,
-0.0105947712,
0.0624321401,
-0.0225298982,
0.0219254065,
-0.0432185344,
0.0345539935,
0.0027699061,
0.0227817576,
-0.0572950616,
-0.0025302109,
0.0278097317,
0.0067399568,
-0.0089168185,
0.0009475647,
-0.0018248542,
0.0203297734,
-0.0637258664,
0.034613084,
-0.0025413057,
0.007956218,
0.0349520035,
0.0187551677,
0.0069045308,
0.0289711952,
0.0183676593,
0.012951415,
-0.0014877465,
0.0846241042,
-0.0118257953,
0.0187144149,
-0.0169810001,
0.00969854,
-0.0566051826,
-0.0299266558,
-0.0247150306,
0.0415800214,
0.0616622083,
-0.0184517149,
0.0224191044,
-0.0076379552,
0.0145747783,
-0.0316507667,
0.0455379598,
-0.0260453541,
-0.0239792261,
0.0297295004,
0.0084049972,
0.0076065063,
0.0237198696,
0.0661465451,
0.0139804296,
0.0543275177,
-0.020236969,
0.0481423698,
-0.0439257771,
-0.0359228365,
0.0280781239,
0.0358146168,
-0.0060032802,
0.0408833064,
-0.0005270773,
-0.0632992983,
-0.003061499,
-0.0120569607,
-0.0146012278,
-0.0335745811,
0.0374773741,
0.0102308961,
-0.0432663858,
-0.0007626604,
-0.0072746868,
-0.0512246825,
0.0013765134,
-0.0212561525,
-0.0226095058,
-5.598632004e-33,
-0.0326489173,
0.0276368335,
0.0362792723,
0.0059607704,
-0.0157792382,
-0.0152889062,
-0.0283656027,
-0.0022331369,
0.004518698,
-0.0184871797,
0.000486922,
0.018878907,
0.0232318826,
0.0545580834,
-0.0145028252,
-0.0057208226,
0.0900657848,
-0.0569475032,
0.0116731683,
0.0372425318,
0.0508103073,
0.0331976637,
0.036589507,
-0.0729520619,
-0.0032045683,
-0.0008681304,
-0.01581016,
-0.0017707822,
0.024605453,
0.0661578774,
-0.0046624374,
0.0250436403,
-0.0125446562,
-0.0691398829,
-0.0309001561,
0.0296020228,
-0.0824681595,
0.0058814227,
0.0175549313,
0.0236333683,
-0.0164697412,
-0.0111224744,
0.0082850587,
-0.0174899641,
-0.0173933636,
-0.0206842031,
0.0504852794,
-0.025285216,
-0.0048623979,
-0.0129234781,
-0.0525274239,
-0.0154012544,
-0.0397222079,
-0.047769621,
0.0478499644,
0.0478023216,
-0.0116598373,
0.0174716413,
-0.0364369936,
0.0478341505,
-0.007709506,
0.013747924,
0.059475448,
0.0321474522,
-0.0056026289,
0.0413224883,
-0.0139218764,
-0.0514100045,
-0.0052219997,
-0.0184064861,
0.0438910313,
0.0496737957,
-0.002925578,
0.035518799,
-0.0047164755,
-0.0012157762,
-0.0542791039,
0.0019578715,
0.0116938744,
0.0137407519,
0.0245918743,
0.0138880573,
-0.0299840234,
0.0122190667,
-0.0576425195,
0.0109294029,
-0.0183258355,
-0.004788849,
0.0878514349,
0.0214540511,
0.0124643464,
-0.0112343477,
0.0782659724,
-0.049881313,
0.0212858953,
0.0371587574,
-0.0360475779,
0.0153098721,
-0.0043007801,
0.04083509,
-0.061737325,
-0.0323881395,
0.0907126367,
0.0031335491,
0.0340871513,
0.0001429701,
0.0275778901,
0.0472378992,
-0.0492623001,
-0.0077916896,
-0.007564446,
0.010726111,
0.0136066126,
0.0560187586,
0.0351062529,
-0.0045316019,
-0.0349403173,
0.0702729002,
-0.0296021886,
-0.0468506813,
-0.0241016317,
-0.0683923662,
-0.0124597475,
0.0356025249,
-0.0509887934,
0.0037452779,
-0.0242876709,
-0.0348753184,
0.0330470242,
-0.0434297472,
-0.0132246204,
0.008220857,
2.561e-7,
-0.017386727,
-0.000301475,
-0.0340848751,
0.0180255808,
0.0328340605,
0.0345508531,
-0.0624599606,
0.02069401,
0.0160934199,
-0.0143570947,
0.0158541705,
0.0426327735,
0.0486344658,
-0.0134405792,
-0.088245742,
-0.0034989929,
-0.044482328,
0.0338166803,
-0.0612251982,
0.0056549972,
0.031990096,
0.0965931416,
-0.0176731236,
0.007030596,
0.0315667875,
-0.007299589,
0.0411105677,
-0.0215187594,
0.0024976698,
-0.0578346588,
-0.0398285724,
0.0153878359,
-0.0473033339,
0.0110566225,
-0.0435551479,
0.029687047,
0.0231809337,
0.1059274226,
-0.0087895999,
-0.0326693952,
-0.027224917,
0.0318643562,
-0.0368310101,
-0.0160861537,
0.0654794276,
-0.0501786992,
-0.0158420037,
0.0094490722,
-0.0460632965,
-0.00864066,
-0.0290164575,
-0.0126473708,
0.020207135,
-0.0223696865,
0.0241565574,
-0.0140506066,
-0.0212942883,
-0.0834301189,
0.02030777,
0.0407035239,
-0.0602348149,
-0.0319262631,
-0.0434923209,
-0.0334140584,
0.0052864687,
-0.0562134124,
-0.0119799264,
2.188364798e-34,
0.0286534671,
-0.017133465,
0.0424898341,
-0.0210705586,
-0.0097976709,
-0.0130451387,
-0.011253505,
0.0060291351,
0.0246907994,
-0.0834499449,
-0.0378969945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08254v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08254v1
|
Detecting Fallacies in Climate Misinformation: A Technocognitive Approach to Identifying Misleading Argumentation
| 2024-05-14T01:01:44 | 2024-05-14T01:01:44 |
Francisco Zanartu, John Cook, Markus Wagner, Julian Garcia
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Misinformation about climate change is a complex societal issue requiring
holistic, interdisciplinary solutions at the intersection between technology
and psychology. One proposed solution is a "technocognitive" approach,
involving the synthesis of psychological and computer science research.
Psychological research has identified that interventions in response to
misinformation require both fact-based (e.g., factual explanations) and
technique-based (e.g., explanations of misleading techniques) content. However,
little progress has been made on documenting and detecting fallacies in climate
misinformation. In this study, we apply a previously developed critical
thinking methodology for deconstructing climate misinformation, in order to
develop a dataset mapping different types of climate misinformation to
reasoning fallacies. This dataset is used to train a model to detect fallacies
in climate misinformation. Our study shows F1 scores that are 2.5 to 3.5 better
than previous works. The fallacies that are easiest to detect include fake
experts and anecdotal arguments, while fallacies that require background
knowledge, such as oversimplification, misrepresentation, and slothful
induction, are relatively more difficult to detect. This research lays the
groundwork for development of solutions where automatically detected climate
misinformation can be countered with generative technique-based corrections.
|
Detecting Fallacies in Climate Misinformation: A Technocognitive Approach to Identifying Misleading Argumentation: Misinformation about climate change is a complex societal issue requiring
holistic, interdisciplinary solutions at the intersection between technology
and psychology. One proposed solution is a "technocognitive" approach,
involving the synthesis of psychological and computer science research.
Psychological research has identified that interventions in response to
misinformation require both fact-based (e.g., factual explanations) and
technique-based (e.g., explanations of misleading techniques) content. However,
little progress has been made on documenting and detecting fallacies in climate
misinformation. In this study, we apply a previously developed critical
thinking methodology for deconstructing climate misinformation, in order to
develop a dataset mapping different types of climate misinformation to
reasoning fallacies. This dataset is used to train a model to detect fallacies
in climate misinformation. Our study shows F1 scores that are 2.5 to 3.5 better
than previous works. The fallacies that are easiest to detect include fake
experts and anecdotal arguments, while fallacies that require background
knowledge, such as oversimplification, misrepresentation, and slothful
induction, are relatively more difficult to detect. This research lays the
groundwork for development of solutions where automatically detected climate
misinformation can be countered with generative technique-based corrections.
|
[
0.0173231792,
0.0298147462,
-0.0036845095,
0.0266121272,
-0.0311419945,
0.0322156623,
0.0367606357,
-0.0201339517,
0.0086161718,
-0.037968304,
0.0081507228,
0.0063598235,
0.0235620718,
0.0206220206,
0.0229683425,
-0.0753628463,
0.0292755887,
0.0088683795,
0.0578861348,
-0.0170724168,
0.0032919017,
-0.0028334213,
-0.0566056818,
0.0069856513,
0.0002024122,
-0.0459294282,
0.0258600991,
0.0038752684,
0.070986852,
-0.0661692172,
0.0429711863,
0.0284721609,
0.0172521695,
0.0465941839,
0.0000019588,
-0.0275564659,
-0.0281433836,
-0.0028861673,
-0.0115464209,
0.0226695444,
0.0728790835,
-0.0015102314,
0.01007016,
0.0508929528,
-0.021755565,
-0.009117567,
0.0577493384,
0.0776159838,
0.0597921796,
0.0318153314,
0.0109284064,
0.0076918234,
0.0034783867,
0.0384632349,
-0.0462868512,
0.0569099672,
0.0516472608,
0.0355216339,
-0.0736152604,
0.0288400818,
0.0209350325,
0.0081545208,
-0.0093730548,
-0.0141556449,
-0.0127808796,
0.0011116655,
-0.0281775557,
-0.0251419079,
-0.023919452,
0.0236890111,
0.0614548996,
-0.0207905658,
0.0033245864,
-0.0095559359,
0.0210966393,
0.0419605412,
-0.0427561626,
0.006073657,
-0.0226286668,
-0.0149953589,
0.0185265765,
-0.0014021947,
-0.005447444,
0.0435343795,
0.0509244427,
0.062759392,
-0.0393396616,
-0.0343371332,
0.0064079366,
-0.0025460941,
0.0685106516,
-0.0193440542,
-0.0083077401,
-0.0177069027,
-0.002801511,
0.0073124669,
-0.001575268,
-0.0112022609,
0.0257538334,
-0.0669240803,
0.0205777306,
-0.0098043345,
0.0148073537,
0.0121547729,
0.0693650618,
-0.0046997471,
-0.0095288446,
0.0337484851,
0.0087951506,
0.0127951251,
-0.0652338117,
-0.0269692261,
0.0062156022,
-0.0288404711,
0.0207559299,
0.0526591055,
-0.0081012333,
-0.0836778134,
-0.0465035737,
-0.0067567648,
-0.0467493571,
0.0164499395,
0.0181031041,
-0.0132094054,
-0.048952844,
0.0947250947,
-0.0183853451,
0.0402366482,
-0.0012608169,
-0.0384970754,
-0.0363487266,
0.0228760429,
0.0021885082,
0.0187687427,
-0.0108170379,
-0.0243256781,
0.0165407322,
0.0343012065,
-0.0443345308,
-0.0283651818,
0.0110100079,
-0.0391056128,
0.0426882841,
-0.0291431155,
-0.0519017689,
-0.0263984017,
0.0041673714,
-0.0495083779,
-0.0304237399,
-0.0162643027,
-0.0236882176,
0.0712444782,
-0.0483248755,
-0.0433278345,
0.1066786647,
0.0376501158,
-0.0255684461,
0.0541734919,
0.0105448812,
0.023690328,
0.0005076768,
0.0130462712,
0.0356868021,
-0.0426040553,
0.0162965786,
0.0135733718,
0.0164005868,
-0.0147211254,
-0.0727263242,
-0.0058816783,
0.025025703,
0.0005463983,
-0.0065815542,
0.0150544494,
0.0470520668,
-0.0098415865,
-0.0286459085,
0.0256451927,
0.0060648527,
0.0182015821,
0.0086581269,
0.0086242659,
-0.0159410611,
0.0341142677,
-0.0422160923,
-0.040043667,
-0.0059740725,
0.0233325399,
-0.017025819,
-0.0440402776,
-0.0372162424,
0.0154215358,
0.0159025323,
-0.0185399596,
-0.0112354346,
0.0040986389,
-0.0202099364,
-0.0089332871,
0.0186187308,
0.0165324099,
-0.0378251188,
-0.0105664153,
-0.0034265018,
0.0045854938,
-0.039532572,
0.0095497174,
-0.0197474752,
-0.0457223691,
0.0241451059,
0.0103057576,
0.0999593362,
-0.0196808372,
-0.0826697052,
-0.005136542,
-0.0384952351,
-0.023187967,
0.0249073412,
0.0234568231,
0.0113862222,
0.0246530678,
0.0077064889,
0.0306338016,
-0.0266986061,
0.0236402284,
0.0125668552,
-0.0006958724,
-0.0657224953,
0.0156673547,
0.0640013292,
-0.0104678236,
0.0213596653,
0.0040756445,
0.0357716829,
0.0192894023,
-0.0816191733,
0.0590447895,
0.0040971269,
0.038727697,
0.0110377986,
-0.0623047017,
-0.0380408913,
-0.002056771,
-0.0358826593,
0.0222818498,
0.0601815879,
0.0021478934,
-0.0225320589,
0.0022318566,
-0.0512913726,
-0.0168685894,
0.0089595756,
0.0394509621,
0.0593806803,
-0.0357220508,
-0.0043651084,
-0.0131002516,
-0.0014594089,
-0.0091516972,
-0.0303419083,
0.0454558879,
-0.0251182728,
-0.0037613667,
-0.0289587732,
-0.0015164583,
-0.0656269714,
-0.0646366552,
0.0577938184,
-0.022864366,
0.0021460403,
-0.0114263324,
0.0375653692,
0.0219509155,
-0.0636162534,
-0.0173221435,
0.0294622909,
0.0215732791,
-0.0326125398,
-0.0230047889,
0.0354611911,
0.0321118273,
-0.0288219936,
0.0291028246,
0.0039382735,
0.0538241342,
-0.0456300117,
0.0417662188,
0.0636921898,
-0.0477108322,
-0.0492858589,
0.0104058674,
-0.0233425237,
-0.0285209827,
-0.0098665385,
-0.0092204772,
-0.00711232,
0.0434760675,
-0.0370550342,
0.0165324155,
0.0547706783,
0.056816265,
0.0143160857,
0.0316517651,
-0.0022574982,
-0.0012203619,
0.0050812466,
0.00949228,
0.0347188227,
-0.0380423591,
-0.0163327549,
0.0264771897,
0.0067714313,
0.0251596179,
0.0464145504,
0.10614492,
-0.0558994487,
-0.0212363098,
0.0253234636,
-0.0406661965,
-0.0128766913,
0.0429765657,
-0.0392387472,
-0.0306292642,
0.0559234656,
-0.0119347461,
0.0540141836,
-0.0808475986,
-0.01735311,
0.0322334021,
0.0070409812,
-0.0210903883,
0.0252431687,
0.0904269069,
0.0198761784,
-0.0096962862,
-0.0852756649,
0.041864302,
0.0079771504,
-0.041031789,
-0.0915177241,
0.010069795,
0.0191089902,
-0.0077661355,
-0.0367020927,
-0.0072765453,
-0.0535846464,
-0.0227807593,
-0.0143688871,
-0.0450632162,
-0.0822744668,
-0.036182642,
0.061429549,
0.0170594975,
0.0381963477,
-0.0208623111,
0.0600102209,
0.0013432802,
-0.0110212583,
0.0551691353,
0.0696817636,
-0.0046297498,
-0.0105311582,
0.0536644012,
-0.0281229652,
-0.0150772734,
-0.0358586609,
-0.0248953719,
-0.0148608005,
0.0143998843,
0.0130517446,
-0.0138301393,
0.0303812325,
-0.0356761254,
0.023729356,
0.0596445017,
0.0305271205,
0.0274286587,
-0.0039350362,
-0.0115478523,
-0.0285796151,
0.0224183388,
-0.0297518615,
-0.0639067069,
-0.0040959129,
0.0094927326,
0.0006479274,
-0.055040665,
-0.020181058,
-0.0173889697,
-0.0426384099,
0.0698927268,
0.0173485111,
0.0305029415,
-0.0178341363,
-0.0877042636,
-0.0028200138,
0.0097857825,
-0.0441401824,
-0.0287776627,
0.0061124312,
0.0236640144,
0.030288808,
-0.0548222363,
-0.0205437467,
0.0107814427,
0.0272484254,
0.0406475291,
0.0365287475,
0.0589255393,
-0.0000245867,
-0.0279422272,
-0.0039164359,
-0.0176417474,
-0.0134598939,
-0.0311209932,
0.0132341618,
0.011810746,
0.0140775582,
-0.0062414594,
0.0753663629,
0.0041504693,
-0.0454687439,
0.0366601944,
0.0827530548,
-0.0057258056,
-0.0366894267,
0.0066116434,
0.0336910523,
0.0364052393,
0.0524332225,
0.0034007882,
0.0581479408,
-0.0169939492,
-0.0843714774,
0.0168620944,
-0.0097184097,
-0.0459546261,
0.048484236,
0.0392548442,
-0.0089664189,
-0.0149562694,
-0.0373927914,
0.0122823259,
-0.0043294383,
-0.0190074071,
-0.0364666507,
0.0883681327,
0.0283130575,
-0.0682955831,
0.0230740029,
-0.0220046565,
0.0251063704,
0.0356574692,
-0.0672453046,
-0.0039612493,
0.0144782569,
-0.0180209577,
0.0466902554,
-0.0189331025,
-0.0361969583,
0.009172474,
0.0216461606,
0.0196665581,
-0.0075959605,
0.0252385456,
-0.0045994269,
0.0313749686,
0.0433529727,
-0.0125611024,
-0.0010825308,
0.010533262,
-0.0062669828,
0.0228231791,
-0.0195622612,
0.0406354964,
0.0347495824,
-0.0080053322,
0.0164077803,
-0.0780115351,
0.0579376556,
0.0219125301,
-0.0236099437,
0.0729579106,
-0.0189634319,
-0.0092981169,
-0.0205002781,
-0.0306669697,
0.0158430375,
-0.0495296083,
0.034443751,
0.0167046618,
0.0020218387,
0.0045638639,
-0.0330652706,
0.0184998922,
-0.0674795508,
-0.0107461391,
-0.0008527353,
0.0637341514,
0.0217403844,
0.0567994304,
-0.0197973214,
-0.0060197855,
-0.0030464614,
-0.0542007312,
0.0052792109,
-0.0070514702,
0.0553590506,
0.0173666198,
0.012452215,
0.0231216904,
-0.0010542932,
-0.0368682183,
-0.0368267559,
-0.0390919745,
-0.0057531083,
0.0361633264,
-0.0179192722,
0.0326268822,
-0.0047465097,
-0.0213212613,
-0.0338594839,
-0.007216217,
0.0050837095,
0.0034143403,
-0.0271117743,
0.0549860001,
0.0019688136,
-0.0681042373,
-0.0071934341,
0.0153697794,
-0.0478177443,
0.0754491314,
0.0201603491,
-0.0851508379,
-0.0337889679,
-0.0555656478,
-0.0916086733,
-0.0385922194,
0.0380638018,
0.0184061304,
-0.0983143821,
-0.0275195744,
0.04788322,
0.0251068603,
0.0207110848,
0.0024683827,
-0.0260090642,
0.0328998528,
-0.0367085859,
-0.0403432027,
-0.0076627461,
0.0377603397,
-0.0414953716,
-0.0124155022,
-0.020381026,
-6.13635161e-33,
-0.0265019182,
-0.0970248058,
-0.0024514508,
0.0396328159,
0.0121269897,
0.033596877,
0.0032025247,
0.0149363466,
-0.0297544375,
0.0889348984,
0.0291338917,
0.0038568161,
0.0024494915,
-0.0222020764,
-0.0195976123,
0.0212971698,
0.0484156311,
-0.0243368559,
-0.018641334,
-0.0318372436,
0.0358959623,
-0.0032799048,
0.0386884995,
-0.0880676657,
0.0411426499,
-0.0217710212,
-0.0145590072,
0.0009435389,
-0.0188580602,
0.0165943578,
0.0142906522,
0.037140429,
0.0278908443,
-0.0358277634,
-0.0192839056,
0.050104104,
-0.0811014622,
-0.03437097,
0.0474382453,
-0.0208018404,
0.0187899675,
0.0158211924,
-0.0234434586,
0.0275968052,
-0.0236739833,
0.0130303977,
0.0194128267,
-0.0440730564,
0.0263395067,
-0.0187009461,
-0.0364515968,
0.0043414677,
-0.031277027,
0.0532205738,
-0.0759264827,
0.0706825927,
-0.0142937079,
0.0427464359,
-0.1414500475,
0.0453246832,
0.0378232785,
-0.0190170538,
0.0286933836,
-0.0199603792,
0.0054187509,
0.071264334,
-0.0108121186,
0.0035088444,
-0.0992766991,
-0.0285085011,
0.0015174681,
-0.03663164,
0.0473781601,
0.0897492021,
0.0406652987,
-0.0460182317,
-0.0683033019,
-0.0141193671,
0.0174280051,
0.0421651565,
0.0098107252,
-0.0213424657,
0.0004101514,
-0.015030304,
-0.0494036227,
-0.0269925147,
-0.0229042955,
0.0071890112,
0.0142959617,
0.0168879367,
-0.024291141,
0.0371625237,
-0.0252677891,
0.0017048533,
0.0129665248,
0.0081401905,
0.0240956713,
0.0094726169,
0.0233971067,
0.0262363777,
-0.0541432761,
0.0308131482,
-0.0194106419,
0.0543003045,
0.0455311053,
-0.0469888113,
0.05951548,
-0.0234397482,
-0.0228464715,
-0.0216013566,
-0.0266432129,
0.0295131411,
-0.0228386037,
-0.0522879139,
0.0002421244,
0.0275609829,
0.0015117632,
-0.0554012246,
-0.0066152229,
0.0259886608,
-0.0004148488,
0.0113406265,
-0.0486929864,
0.0360890478,
-0.030392142,
-0.0057761632,
-0.0151536427,
-0.021176897,
-0.0042969915,
-0.083881408,
0.0115314815,
-0.0005445907,
2.658e-7,
0.0176588688,
0.0605564751,
-0.0182001777,
-0.0478648916,
0.0330399983,
0.0600326844,
-0.0005142438,
0.0036249522,
0.0107385162,
-0.0429826491,
-0.0326455608,
0.0253903139,
0.0109207779,
0.0055795279,
-0.0370000452,
-0.0606731549,
-0.0025331031,
-0.0180442221,
-0.0323913284,
0.0090596415,
0.0407774709,
-0.00397398,
0.0181555245,
0.0054759085,
-0.0291320458,
0.0329163112,
0.0725677609,
-0.0124572702,
0.009627142,
-0.0283707231,
0.0230437312,
-0.0477507561,
0.0257931016,
0.045457501,
-0.0249040984,
-0.0711635798,
-0.0311718248,
0.0145609099,
0.0372548811,
-0.0503266267,
-0.020717442,
0.0299596172,
0.0080721797,
-0.0374065712,
0.0016474467,
-0.0797550827,
-0.048151549,
-0.0365627445,
-0.0552498624,
0.0490790009,
-0.0188065264,
0.0009560272,
-0.0051111709,
0.0206285343,
-0.0183544476,
0.009946662,
0.0227219276,
-0.0092579825,
0.0200785603,
0.0033061814,
-0.0290816687,
-0.0344253071,
-0.0139987478,
-0.0539214686,
0.0448915213,
0.0234545805,
0.0220616665,
1.844713616e-34,
0.0155269932,
-0.001147615,
-0.0166653637,
-0.0687140673,
0.0416614488,
0.0337035768,
0.0382501818,
-0.0100006163,
0.0183098968,
0.0033846546,
0.0171276014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08238v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08238v1
|
Silver-Tongued and Sundry: Exploring Intersectional Pronouns with ChatGPT
| 2024-05-13T23:38:50 | 2024-05-13T23:38:50 |
Takao Fujii, Katie Seaborn, Madeleine Steeds
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
ChatGPT is a conversational agent built on a large language model. Trained on
a significant portion of human output, ChatGPT can mimic people to a degree. As
such, we need to consider what social identities ChatGPT simulates (or can be
designed to simulate). In this study, we explored the case of identity
simulation through Japanese first-person pronouns, which are tightly connected
to social identities in intersectional ways, i.e., intersectional pronouns. We
conducted a controlled online experiment where people from two regions in Japan
(Kanto and Kinki) witnessed interactions with ChatGPT using ten sets of
first-person pronouns. We discovered that pronouns alone can evoke perceptions
of social identities in ChatGPT at the intersections of gender, age, region,
and formality, with caveats. This work highlights the importance of pronoun use
for social identity simulation, provides a language-based methodology for
culturally-sensitive persona development, and advances the potential of
intersectional identities in intelligent agents.
|
Silver-Tongued and Sundry: Exploring Intersectional Pronouns with ChatGPT: ChatGPT is a conversational agent built on a large language model. Trained on
a significant portion of human output, ChatGPT can mimic people to a degree. As
such, we need to consider what social identities ChatGPT simulates (or can be
designed to simulate). In this study, we explored the case of identity
simulation through Japanese first-person pronouns, which are tightly connected
to social identities in intersectional ways, i.e., intersectional pronouns. We
conducted a controlled online experiment where people from two regions in Japan
(Kanto and Kinki) witnessed interactions with ChatGPT using ten sets of
first-person pronouns. We discovered that pronouns alone can evoke perceptions
of social identities in ChatGPT at the intersections of gender, age, region,
and formality, with caveats. This work highlights the importance of pronoun use
for social identity simulation, provides a language-based methodology for
culturally-sensitive persona development, and advances the potential of
intersectional identities in intelligent agents.
|
[
0.0590262078,
0.0465698428,
-0.0397467278,
0.0165619515,
0.005999398,
-0.0082422001,
0.0569495447,
-0.0191127621,
0.0526009873,
-0.0382876992,
-0.0249337479,
-0.0349728875,
0.0246232916,
-0.0065053483,
0.0088603683,
-0.071831651,
0.021093728,
0.0335946418,
0.0461489595,
-0.0347288176,
0.0013268708,
0.0488596596,
0.0124433795,
0.0752525926,
-0.0533975512,
-0.0108495895,
0.0124207688,
-0.0076195695,
0.0191273317,
0.0282468274,
0.0705491602,
0.0184813142,
0.0083786752,
0.0472942814,
0.0000019139,
-0.0535946712,
0.0323944502,
-0.0297046695,
0.0112433285,
0.0104144216,
0.03325966,
0.0735774562,
-0.0352326408,
0.0104964962,
-0.0643028989,
-0.0054085245,
0.0412313566,
0.0472150967,
0.0453908741,
0.0111146513,
-0.0109485229,
-0.0154945832,
-0.065747641,
-0.0061348812,
-0.0103617152,
-0.0076476303,
0.0051207012,
-0.0436806157,
-0.0087542338,
-0.0371851847,
-0.017464431,
0.0061588991,
0.0301523302,
-0.0049495609,
-0.0114413826,
0.0355510674,
-0.0245549046,
-0.0201214161,
0.0090289246,
0.053725563,
0.0775489882,
-0.008008034,
-0.0138674891,
0.0673419088,
0.0036810352,
-0.0346625932,
-0.0018931957,
0.0127118491,
0.0009901054,
-0.0040580337,
-0.0357611999,
0.0135179739,
-0.0190747865,
0.0288483389,
-0.0216808859,
0.0610400327,
0.0107638277,
-0.0051887236,
-0.0125034656,
-0.0283659399,
0.0194364171,
-0.0670038834,
-0.0041938643,
0.0182197299,
-0.04891029,
0.0256392006,
-0.0326375291,
0.0139192482,
0.0006090073,
-0.0213089846,
0.0174517911,
0.0423058942,
-0.0283711497,
-0.0185786672,
0.0141154006,
0.028840363,
0.0290520079,
-0.0009141903,
-0.0291759595,
-0.0216264855,
-0.0242405534,
-0.0629328191,
-0.0491520688,
-0.0058788899,
-0.0058765528,
-0.0032750641,
-0.0235196948,
-0.0093055805,
-0.0637840331,
0.0227480456,
-0.0542458557,
-0.006195914,
-0.0184406117,
0.017821556,
-0.0260057468,
0.0434459262,
-0.077395834,
0.007982525,
-0.0121893855,
-0.0728784725,
0.0471810326,
-0.0113479747,
-0.0014406764,
-0.0179058742,
-0.0247704368,
0.0324161239,
-0.0222743582,
-0.0288103539,
0.0100627923,
-0.0364581496,
-0.0060127489,
-0.050774049,
0.0168547574,
-0.0251274798,
0.0219382551,
-0.0143882548,
0.0365551189,
-0.0658749565,
0.038972266,
0.0116752088,
0.0094493646,
0.0607446395,
0.0337564647,
0.0128973965,
0.0258898158,
0.0275571179,
0.0266818646,
0.0484390669,
0.0597040132,
-0.0230160132,
0.0411299542,
-0.02590275,
0.0231990349,
0.0013005934,
-0.0052044448,
0.0259091575,
0.0194703396,
-0.0298863351,
0.0390776508,
0.0344650149,
0.0676813796,
0.0139526809,
0.0142062064,
-0.0506909713,
0.0688686743,
0.0866412967,
-0.0515006669,
0.0347454995,
0.048289191,
0.053309653,
-0.0058723101,
0.036907468,
-0.0435372218,
0.011520735,
-0.0169498678,
-0.0277054925,
-0.0371399708,
0.0560330972,
-0.0324858762,
0.0167733654,
0.0021001636,
0.0307500288,
0.0397016592,
0.0019197051,
-0.0453897417,
0.0239217784,
0.0278356522,
0.0270367526,
0.0550682247,
-0.080852814,
-0.0206533559,
-0.0202597156,
-0.0259313602,
0.0495566204,
-0.0292653386,
0.0012541449,
0.0318650492,
-0.0167405736,
0.0385645516,
0.0507658087,
0.0574775524,
0.0121639594,
-0.0019072973,
0.0007736372,
0.0111784097,
0.0052202423,
-0.0099554285,
0.0731707662,
0.0273262635,
0.0524519943,
0.0083491784,
0.0314501934,
0.0135411844,
-0.0081078699,
-0.0457352474,
-0.0328146741,
0.011208728,
0.0118258176,
0.0266739056,
0.0143620549,
-0.0251741409,
-0.0109091494,
-0.0060377885,
0.0217914637,
-0.0509380028,
0.1229663268,
-0.0302578937,
0.0135738524,
0.019030733,
-0.0637321323,
-0.0352856778,
0.004211633,
0.0263938252,
-0.0069316253,
0.0573520921,
-0.0062240092,
0.033557348,
-0.0380259044,
-0.0235292856,
-0.0163324103,
0.0488688499,
-0.0069461348,
-0.0054889997,
0.0113128135,
-0.0408199392,
-0.0297661554,
0.0170169249,
0.0224511288,
-0.0511515364,
-0.0319657438,
0.035150215,
-0.0257650707,
0.0329436138,
-0.0157046709,
-0.0037916731,
-0.0252692401,
-0.0529728197,
-0.1266999096,
-0.055697348,
0.006187188,
-0.0534260087,
-0.0341488011,
0.0041302689,
-0.0491673611,
-0.0032603759,
-0.0284325387,
0.0040039374,
0.010063543,
0.0041125128,
-0.0020927282,
-0.0018630371,
0.0087521691,
0.0061417976,
0.0108218724,
-0.0527389646,
0.0446390584,
-0.0147943525,
0.0129812565,
0.0162299834,
-0.0836366192,
-0.0470194556,
-0.0061382214,
-0.0180724058,
-0.0641147941,
0.0582507923,
0.0228074994,
0.064635627,
0.0411810242,
0.0290011633,
0.0595171601,
0.0116368551,
-0.0768996179,
-0.0304791424,
0.0172635987,
0.0353704542,
-0.0054451567,
-0.0152762206,
-0.0968023241,
0.0007624538,
0.0349041633,
0.0280847233,
0.0001477202,
-0.0610430501,
0.0508278981,
-0.0310901683,
-0.0627150238,
0.0022210779,
-0.0145660937,
-0.0223454591,
0.0161549468,
-0.0103575317,
0.0337599404,
0.0581058711,
0.0057847542,
-0.0422254503,
-0.0014637504,
0.0267628077,
-0.0092690429,
0.0962499902,
-0.0267094132,
0.0284978934,
0.0491920076,
-0.0361595228,
-0.0205898955,
-0.0018576108,
-0.0079670288,
-0.0377814621,
0.009626911,
-0.0452945493,
-0.0004046864,
0.0212891903,
-0.0175700616,
-0.0341510884,
-0.0189963635,
-0.0329810753,
0.0050801844,
-0.0152367167,
-0.0003185384,
0.0178674236,
0.0133020747,
0.006856075,
-0.0107646333,
-0.0255207103,
0.0130927134,
-0.0242976844,
-0.0456791967,
-0.0017059201,
0.0305634607,
0.0058831265,
0.0247371159,
0.0410395227,
0.0065490128,
0.0290166009,
0.0125404829,
-0.0156813432,
0.00158769,
0.0291056726,
-0.0097797262,
0.0200754832,
-0.0163314492,
0.0683078021,
-0.0522881076,
0.0281413831,
0.0793883204,
-0.0006092428,
0.006081813,
0.0106934486,
-0.0166855063,
0.0300112944,
0.0188281033,
0.0394754186,
-0.0972131565,
0.0307408907,
0.0176590122,
-0.0146001242,
-0.0800460875,
-0.0367347673,
-0.0230876021,
-0.0991998464,
0.0354923345,
0.0176989175,
-0.0605360977,
-0.008620685,
0.0218463596,
0.0157133881,
0.0357323624,
0.0494871698,
-0.0092297848,
-0.0059736706,
-0.0281865429,
-0.0331392102,
-0.0534737818,
-0.0197070204,
0.0193753541,
-0.047518786,
0.0447726846,
0.002532898,
0.0788097084,
0.0063958322,
-0.0018075429,
0.00348778,
-0.013113345,
-0.0042997221,
-0.0261298418,
-0.001425894,
-0.0225953944,
-0.0269103944,
-0.0194485486,
0.0114932852,
0.0294450317,
0.0064596003,
0.023171844,
-0.0180405732,
-0.0108207185,
-0.0541420281,
0.0027048409,
0.0419454165,
0.0132294092,
0.0426384099,
0.0485078841,
-0.0423371121,
0.0131017985,
-0.0447564498,
0.0225371756,
0.0319282822,
-0.0728110522,
0.0146949003,
0.0024430205,
-0.0498230942,
-0.0470795333,
-0.0985322297,
0.0318134129,
0.0091937957,
0.0370626524,
-0.0655041933,
-0.0119412523,
0.005830856,
0.0068793716,
0.0100941677,
-0.0804923773,
0.079685472,
0.018101139,
-0.0371500477,
0.0080370419,
-0.0255252328,
0.0226745959,
0.0046112281,
0.0404252261,
-0.0330728367,
0.0442773066,
0.0497056171,
0.0233895481,
0.0313394107,
-0.0254379902,
-0.0420946926,
-0.0237780605,
0.0109430496,
0.0243972223,
0.0522276461,
0.0187911745,
0.0303857066,
-0.0148471724,
0.0194018129,
0.0087663541,
0.0191466957,
-0.0385640077,
-0.0268105846,
-0.0546861775,
-0.0718493685,
0.0044824248,
-0.0048702131,
-0.0184706319,
-0.0386254936,
0.0571208522,
-0.0094595011,
-0.0439179502,
-0.0588513426,
-0.0188138597,
-0.0159341916,
-0.0678509399,
0.0177586377,
0.0430574827,
0.0252350233,
-0.0287974719,
-0.0373687334,
0.0150337657,
-0.0155555671,
-0.0228982847,
0.0267570633,
0.0703740567,
-0.0415252112,
0.0313911922,
-0.0154851945,
0.0139877303,
0.0088807363,
0.0079809483,
0.0189321972,
0.0453125685,
0.0135309696,
-0.0630609691,
-0.0036455642,
0.0026786621,
-0.0302728508,
-0.0010541267,
0.0181475282,
0.0074916142,
0.0360819846,
-0.006630722,
0.0296364799,
-0.0487507991,
-0.0051693581,
0.011944958,
0.0021916674,
0.0341055356,
-0.0845116004,
0.015897261,
-0.0100177014,
-0.0066319476,
-0.0185525529,
0.0265995134,
0.0073317848,
0.0347454511,
0.0222014729,
-0.0192841049,
-0.0347487591,
-0.0209713876,
0.0230892152,
-0.0049195234,
-0.003660022,
-0.01596573,
-0.0952726081,
-0.0504056625,
0.0016189994,
-0.0134733384,
0.0439351313,
-0.0183141548,
0.0100828558,
0.0228518583,
0.0025402799,
-0.0201695841,
-0.0070357122,
-0.0027242734,
-0.0332122222,
0.0118163275,
0.0134415859,
-6.222422041e-33,
-0.0670986623,
-0.0263241567,
0.0131434472,
0.037013825,
-0.0763553753,
-0.0347775444,
-0.0624244288,
-0.001316149,
0.0232025627,
0.0181117319,
-0.0318076611,
0.0038335714,
0.0157112181,
-0.0180229023,
-0.0128022395,
0.0037874237,
0.0616141334,
0.0425144173,
-0.0123090073,
-0.013594362,
0.0033975842,
-0.0105320467,
0.0093276948,
-0.084944278,
0.0309629533,
0.0114976987,
-0.0519548804,
0.0098197497,
-0.0125673097,
-0.0146679562,
-0.0191831514,
0.0673905164,
-0.0016195694,
0.0322479717,
0.0206635334,
0.1111778319,
-0.0565386079,
-0.0516639091,
-0.016575221,
0.0162220038,
0.0326206312,
-0.0794021189,
-0.0082437573,
-0.035821259,
-0.0270229038,
0.0282103419,
0.05176837,
0.0200639628,
0.0460069813,
0.0277451631,
-0.087832354,
-0.0400774777,
-0.0209903531,
-0.0025451654,
-0.0302305892,
0.0003861017,
0.0177651737,
-0.092357479,
-0.0091569284,
0.0144904219,
-0.02901504,
-0.0559785776,
0.0102210185,
0.0551462583,
0.03446953,
0.0216637496,
0.0583047532,
0.0521988049,
-0.024643546,
-0.0105220294,
0.08719448,
-0.0259680897,
0.000403839,
0.0799386576,
-0.0989032164,
-0.071485281,
0.0414705127,
-0.0107668815,
0.0900840163,
-0.0319746397,
0.0146977566,
-0.0017418028,
-0.0263189375,
-0.0483842231,
-0.045704525,
-0.049858883,
-0.0023991149,
-0.0255846418,
0.0001629342,
-0.0289864521,
-0.0416528545,
0.0142935934,
0.0326536372,
-0.0422373004,
-0.0366111584,
-0.0417340845,
-0.0126193883,
-0.0099339504,
0.0182570219,
0.0075940471,
0.0168354027,
-0.0118118702,
0.0198110249,
0.0038665899,
0.0266006626,
0.0210349075,
-0.0168136302,
0.0170206428,
-0.0336145349,
-0.011371782,
-0.0056396537,
0.0288240425,
0.0155801177,
-0.0273398235,
0.0127697615,
0.0587764382,
-0.0109128468,
-0.0317127593,
0.0511143431,
0.038799122,
-0.0633193627,
-0.0211080797,
-0.0803391412,
0.0038529327,
-0.0266222078,
0.0316935256,
-0.0363611802,
0.0310767423,
0.0728757903,
-0.0120564513,
-0.0212029219,
-0.0509498939,
2.723e-7,
-0.0586892068,
0.0235842522,
0.012948513,
0.0065006916,
0.0327127203,
0.0363116525,
0.020128997,
0.0476889275,
0.0706836283,
-0.0130329039,
-0.0113475611,
0.0481048897,
0.0867538676,
0.0293182079,
-0.1005512998,
0.0009647573,
-0.00895165,
-0.0074698045,
-0.0648261458,
0.0465502106,
0.0081292745,
0.0272513293,
0.0660411194,
0.0099948505,
-0.0173398107,
0.0071237292,
0.0316036046,
-0.0167792365,
0.0046319668,
0.029824242,
0.0117284879,
-0.0307179093,
0.0529407635,
0.0212013945,
0.0445503369,
0.0031167984,
0.0173431579,
0.021816045,
-0.0234243162,
0.0165320393,
-0.0018383925,
0.023319127,
-0.0412310325,
-0.0335764661,
0.0340025797,
-0.0338929482,
-0.0068929475,
-0.0118918233,
0.0001475762,
-0.0232557748,
0.0397929363,
-0.0313947536,
-0.0666656792,
0.0584244803,
0.0036742382,
-0.0324403159,
0.031624645,
-0.0444962308,
-0.0020560315,
-0.0255629346,
-0.0094403895,
-0.0272703785,
0.0257115047,
0.013079375,
0.00179118,
-0.0179626085,
0.0391767994,
1.985564931e-34,
-0.0269061867,
0.0313974656,
-0.000044323,
0.0035936073,
0.0693080798,
0.0201515146,
0.0224235989,
0.0240674261,
0.0419083983,
0.0351031721,
0.0040250588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08237v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08237v1
|
A predictive learning model can simulate temporal dynamics and context effects found in neural representations of continuous speech
| 2024-05-13T23:36:19 | 2024-05-13T23:36:19 |
Oli Danyi Liu, Hao Tang, Naomi Feldman, Sharon Goldwater
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Speech perception involves storing and integrating sequentially presented
items. Recent work in cognitive neuroscience has identified temporal and
contextual characteristics in humans' neural encoding of speech that may
facilitate this temporal processing. In this study, we simulated similar
analyses with representations extracted from a computational model that was
trained on unlabelled speech with the learning objective of predicting upcoming
acoustics. Our simulations revealed temporal dynamics similar to those in brain
signals, implying that these properties can arise without linguistic knowledge.
Another property shared between brains and the model is that the encoding
patterns of phonemes support some degree of cross-context generalization.
However, we found evidence that the effectiveness of these generalizations
depends on the specific contexts, which suggests that this analysis alone is
insufficient to support the presence of context-invariant encoding.
|
A predictive learning model can simulate temporal dynamics and context effects found in neural representations of continuous speech: Speech perception involves storing and integrating sequentially presented
items. Recent work in cognitive neuroscience has identified temporal and
contextual characteristics in humans' neural encoding of speech that may
facilitate this temporal processing. In this study, we simulated similar
analyses with representations extracted from a computational model that was
trained on unlabelled speech with the learning objective of predicting upcoming
acoustics. Our simulations revealed temporal dynamics similar to those in brain
signals, implying that these properties can arise without linguistic knowledge.
Another property shared between brains and the model is that the encoding
patterns of phonemes support some degree of cross-context generalization.
However, we found evidence that the effectiveness of these generalizations
depends on the specific contexts, which suggests that this analysis alone is
insufficient to support the presence of context-invariant encoding.
|
[
-0.0360461362,
0.0547971539,
-0.0242620762,
-0.0260462407,
-0.0270138271,
-0.0106782261,
0.012039816,
0.0354135707,
-0.0314617753,
0.0262689851,
-0.0148201855,
-0.0637029111,
0.0723282546,
0.0415073708,
0.0073117232,
-0.0423494652,
0.0320432335,
-0.0514602028,
-0.0067347875,
-0.0038256855,
-0.0348066911,
-0.0548085719,
-0.056795679,
0.0155314291,
-0.0195949599,
-0.007654198,
-0.0398736075,
-0.0609155633,
-0.0218081046,
-0.0344347619,
-0.0286895167,
0.0290698018,
0.045914866,
0.0203971025,
0.0000017288,
-0.0320904441,
0.0032936772,
-0.0213223584,
-0.0381722227,
-0.0231473446,
-0.0265486818,
-0.0004697301,
-0.0278145336,
-0.0419812128,
-0.0045521026,
0.0185440276,
0.0304753948,
0.0170347821,
-0.0188361648,
0.0010356883,
-0.0163414255,
-0.0176278278,
0.0612198524,
0.017108636,
0.0529571623,
0.0125935785,
0.0207624529,
-0.0186745338,
0.0124040199,
-0.0249902569,
-0.0404305346,
-0.0024919168,
0.0415375046,
0.0726636648,
-0.0203250218,
0.1063268483,
0.0041343472,
-0.0081427107,
-0.0534014292,
-0.000918682,
0.0199897178,
-0.069521822,
-0.0187062621,
0.0282505304,
-0.0184983555,
-0.0382124223,
-0.0345555916,
0.0186612271,
0.0085696476,
0.0381664447,
0.0066960836,
0.0210090987,
-0.0035515148,
-0.029232651,
0.0278890915,
0.0629863217,
-0.0002984162,
-0.0478926226,
-0.0024462384,
-0.0174791999,
0.0010334759,
-0.0089349179,
0.0067895898,
0.0084303413,
-0.0165007114,
-0.0069764289,
0.0131094726,
0.0101909051,
-0.0028843412,
-0.0237139966,
-0.0128613431,
0.0406562351,
-0.0512027107,
-0.0286910981,
-0.0574519485,
0.0661925226,
-0.0144237326,
-0.0207573697,
-0.0149019901,
0.0417133346,
-0.0580663756,
-0.0251919907,
0.0134687917,
0.0087387701,
0.001751375,
-0.0030536407,
-0.0431794375,
0.0057064402,
-0.0154489484,
-0.0157743618,
-0.0288501605,
0.0178336333,
-0.0146664008,
0.0255775377,
-0.0554611869,
-0.0294051301,
-0.0132065555,
0.0739074573,
-0.0202790014,
-0.0186820906,
-0.0302178357,
0.0012948503,
0.0156365223,
-0.0067364494,
-0.0177689977,
0.0581897758,
-0.0247560441,
0.0172422864,
-0.019544581,
-0.0284247994,
-0.0210375451,
0.0106159607,
0.0275431126,
-0.0255639758,
-0.0002220275,
-0.0038838808,
-0.0244577266,
-0.0045435852,
-0.0240143146,
-0.0312548615,
0.0206747502,
0.0513730533,
0.0304148365,
0.0247425567,
0.0656238124,
0.0189260878,
0.017965477,
0.0059323702,
0.0087187029,
-0.0187993851,
-0.0298390668,
-0.0050433581,
-0.0443040989,
0.0156016424,
0.0118956286,
-0.0447053127,
-0.0767632872,
-0.0371210016,
0.0374237709,
0.0343910158,
0.0469515324,
-0.0128683345,
-0.0366273522,
-0.0814969018,
0.035254214,
0.0683507472,
0.0261985213,
0.0192386974,
0.0544610731,
-0.0448436812,
0.0021589454,
0.0367698185,
-0.0223269202,
0.0235801172,
0.002349173,
0.0191998705,
0.0018418924,
-0.0282100644,
-0.0081906999,
0.0089402357,
0.0102444841,
-0.0572200045,
-0.0164544489,
-0.0190368444,
0.0033734022,
-0.0217522923,
-0.0374536142,
0.0315627679,
-0.009128307,
0.0289503541,
0.001358141,
0.0197449401,
0.0319832861,
0.045180466,
-0.0307312235,
-0.0234679747,
-0.0286741257,
0.0044795778,
-0.0240826327,
0.0184382163,
0.0064176675,
0.0066737742,
0.0640813336,
0.0183517262,
-0.0361182652,
0.062374793,
-0.0321354084,
0.044391267,
0.0042261709,
0.0090001319,
-0.0231501069,
0.0341553688,
0.0274109226,
0.0060687349,
-0.0596515797,
-0.0567831323,
-0.0499872826,
-0.0367033519,
0.0453700162,
-0.035959281,
-0.0081009716,
0.0361143872,
0.0230436865,
-0.0051684701,
0.0075205341,
0.0369642153,
-0.1045642048,
-0.0247741826,
0.0278209075,
0.0275739785,
0.0068901614,
-0.0133216027,
0.0511365868,
-0.0477156155,
0.0408287384,
0.0129360929,
0.1007037759,
-0.0157605894,
-0.0179184731,
0.003111375,
0.0176503751,
0.035091199,
0.0347006097,
0.0034135946,
-0.0078041684,
0.0322527289,
0.0168950204,
0.0063204654,
-0.0488336571,
-0.0124606052,
0.029329719,
-0.0356542803,
-0.0475162938,
-0.036001388,
-0.0601435043,
-0.0820830017,
0.0240926724,
-0.1181562096,
-0.0352635011,
0.0694213286,
-0.0300896987,
-0.012966169,
-0.0458880998,
-0.0023257728,
0.0103623765,
-0.0291505177,
0.0008451564,
0.0116586313,
0.0400803648,
-0.0505583137,
0.0148102669,
-0.0431274176,
-0.0377639607,
0.0114730494,
-0.0380628407,
0.039877668,
-0.0397002213,
-0.0479915589,
-0.0255211145,
0.0233813375,
-0.0132353455,
0.0313776433,
0.0071000741,
0.0066666999,
0.0270276181,
-0.0086038951,
0.0391795486,
0.0246629082,
-0.0007259808,
-0.0099295853,
0.0314268991,
-0.0316212997,
-0.0135883037,
-0.0214318857,
-0.0612115264,
0.0336299352,
-0.0007342657,
0.0087495679,
-0.0452346839,
0.1000672281,
0.0760770217,
0.0236903038,
-0.0192581881,
-0.0275840778,
-0.0387072898,
-0.0577938221,
-0.0412106961,
-0.0497934297,
-0.0808017105,
0.0593975969,
-0.0216358043,
-0.0320573524,
0.0806482434,
0.0021718922,
0.000779444,
0.0067944978,
-0.0250667743,
0.0022960471,
0.0363512598,
0.0144076403,
-0.024066506,
0.0333167911,
-0.0114623196,
-0.0568619408,
-0.0047891978,
-0.0421795659,
-0.0057785334,
-0.0270169694,
-0.0132983904,
-0.014526831,
0.0243863966,
0.0271661729,
-0.0584210567,
-0.0041397419,
-0.0168190636,
0.0488073789,
-0.0310388226,
0.042136956,
0.0002466179,
0.0239043366,
0.0009124951,
0.0200708732,
-0.0163213201,
-0.042940639,
0.0300992448,
0.0596991666,
-0.0117173381,
0.0246480945,
-0.0110607222,
-0.0125004519,
0.045587264,
-0.0147231361,
0.063845247,
0.0619863719,
-0.0417315401,
0.0688620806,
-0.004349899,
0.0049267765,
-0.0564268306,
0.056936603,
-0.0351920389,
0.0022424536,
-0.0329597704,
0.0848351642,
0.0304394923,
-0.0197654963,
0.0306173898,
-0.0264930595,
0.013915264,
0.0044070617,
0.0136146042,
-0.0154951587,
0.0204385575,
0.0013965453,
-0.0312325284,
-0.0218120329,
-0.0094968649,
0.0118788397,
-0.0359147415,
-0.0141061209,
0.0516866967,
-0.0500920229,
0.0465668365,
0.0030687847,
-0.005158212,
0.0375102609,
0.014588071,
0.0126032634,
0.0008379144,
-0.006334973,
0.0589926504,
-0.0403573141,
-0.0018975879,
0.0230628066,
0.022792859,
0.0688267425,
0.0481801294,
0.0188062619,
-0.0126079023,
-0.0437436737,
0.0439294316,
0.0008404236,
0.0351765081,
-0.0060021947,
0.0117147714,
0.0536740124,
0.0115309656,
0.001027457,
0.0089349374,
-0.0171901062,
-0.0886944383,
-0.0054251901,
0.1415443867,
-0.0222134553,
-0.0056650955,
-0.0031887467,
0.0387641788,
-0.0116765909,
0.0567775145,
0.0282553099,
-0.0370309912,
0.0058741784,
0.0036080885,
0.0528717004,
0.0108537273,
-0.0450851656,
-0.0002454203,
0.0180944018,
-0.006575827,
-0.0265706182,
-0.0041743848,
-0.040811561,
0.0088940058,
0.0461802892,
0.0126793189,
-0.0049003703,
-0.0374831147,
-0.043159239,
-0.0226971861,
0.023275895,
0.0031285603,
-0.0169597045,
-0.0303090289,
0.0392110981,
-0.0561236702,
-0.0172193032,
0.0034648911,
-0.0149309784,
-0.0617978312,
0.0561666042,
-0.0347058102,
0.0224525593,
0.0459232368,
0.036049787,
-0.0022742774,
0.1029855162,
-0.0210515112,
-0.0336651467,
0.0570161864,
0.0047219913,
0.0352936015,
0.0173112024,
-0.007756473,
-0.0488349311,
0.0442405306,
-0.031314984,
-0.0409731455,
-0.0172289554,
0.02896256,
0.0557690486,
-0.0573015735,
0.0790414289,
-0.0081940545,
0.0054810294,
0.0092505021,
-0.0096011581,
0.0198739339,
0.0633562133,
0.0516292565,
-0.0259476397,
0.0492329299,
0.0786441043,
-0.0128992824,
-0.0245995466,
0.0030640881,
0.0006366765,
0.0110597378,
0.0026916538,
0.0262247417,
0.0026544235,
-0.0270240624,
0.0463923439,
0.0248413403,
0.0152503084,
-0.0665490925,
0.0112547697,
0.007185977,
0.0191579796,
0.0020897971,
0.019090727,
0.0077799498,
-0.0546158925,
-0.0754536688,
-0.002172047,
0.031022599,
-0.0094579374,
0.0012246225,
-0.0548530221,
-0.0420972034,
-0.0230970569,
0.066314593,
-0.0054513714,
-0.0332106575,
-0.0570477471,
0.0120328609,
0.0493353121,
0.0317711644,
-0.0029581934,
0.0004129627,
0.050918173,
-0.0098850047,
0.0390623286,
-0.0235649738,
0.0232185274,
-0.0257648993,
-0.026779091,
-0.0109554054,
0.0377651751,
-0.0481733978,
-0.0249010753,
0.0015594251,
-0.042114906,
0.0663101003,
-0.0041106464,
0.0752230734,
-0.0288989395,
-0.0015414321,
0.0150742251,
-0.017129764,
0.017757114,
0.0422266126,
-0.0094739795,
0.0244330782,
-0.0064551258,
-0.0305055324,
-5.772327825e-33,
-0.0154646765,
-0.0149537073,
0.0304240845,
0.0083989408,
-0.008760822,
0.0293272622,
-0.044737462,
0.012395665,
0.050799869,
-0.0171522088,
-0.0064704972,
0.0017681431,
0.0284174979,
-0.0163251236,
0.0723667592,
0.0054849149,
-0.0037983099,
-0.0521085672,
0.0558767095,
-0.0459489673,
0.0753910914,
0.040391393,
0.0383271165,
-0.0514281988,
0.0098829959,
0.0522029847,
0.0213961285,
0.002075389,
0.02484685,
0.0454887338,
-0.0648176149,
0.0438356735,
0.0359180681,
-0.0320825838,
-0.0261398461,
0.0308453683,
-0.0254381076,
-0.0499791838,
0.0372453704,
0.0012815767,
-0.0139561025,
-0.0112155918,
0.051997114,
-0.0353074633,
-0.0451082438,
0.0289521758,
0.0206693429,
-0.0446810126,
-0.0339911245,
-0.0328778066,
-0.0507367589,
-0.0235067941,
-0.013942224,
0.0214780923,
0.0762232691,
0.0512984917,
-0.0213333443,
-0.0182357635,
-0.0340172909,
0.0592912026,
-0.0474497452,
0.0354231223,
0.011981559,
0.0110191638,
0.0488403477,
0.0618521795,
0.1115397811,
-0.0321822502,
-0.0027213499,
-0.0167359058,
0.0337124839,
0.0188109949,
-0.0239869487,
-0.0317793339,
0.0462307185,
-0.0663123727,
0.0234974883,
-0.0014866608,
0.0142985946,
-0.0198279805,
0.0331403315,
0.0377244651,
0.007683849,
-0.0208902415,
0.0001783811,
-0.0003951342,
-0.02889896,
-0.0082298834,
0.0318993963,
-0.0331462771,
0.0758402869,
0.0112524619,
0.0615915842,
-0.0299567748,
0.041783303,
-0.0288411118,
-0.021103099,
-0.0116961636,
0.0619682968,
0.005961149,
-0.0508700497,
-0.0318936519,
0.040839117,
-0.0084757609,
0.0495823957,
-0.0179428514,
-0.0269312393,
0.041968409,
-0.0122155324,
-0.0238557979,
-0.0298849922,
-0.0398865715,
0.0882505924,
-0.0692587644,
0.0610214882,
0.0014247377,
-0.0204288587,
-0.0631490722,
0.0030762572,
-0.0052741016,
-0.0258364156,
0.0361806862,
-0.0509015806,
0.0671216846,
-0.0187991466,
-0.0400412194,
-0.0020361359,
0.0036771796,
0.0437631011,
-0.0138176186,
-0.0239248034,
0.0225084107,
2.715e-7,
-0.0425513014,
0.0056604245,
0.0165096726,
-0.0080080889,
0.0967567787,
-0.0239241645,
-0.0250353739,
-0.0103239622,
0.0037703174,
-0.0501097329,
0.0342846513,
0.0039518909,
0.0161221996,
0.0134549756,
-0.0141177513,
-0.0649256334,
-0.0494965687,
0.0612476841,
-0.0333002098,
0.0259725749,
0.0306772273,
0.0489423573,
-0.0149024446,
-0.0356081724,
0.0076406943,
0.0050225575,
0.0683959201,
-0.0435311645,
0.0245213211,
-0.0738388672,
-0.0666057989,
-0.0365349539,
-0.0064994721,
0.0333450437,
-0.0063691321,
0.0064006993,
-0.0136275021,
-0.0233490132,
0.0073117423,
-0.0704836175,
0.0443568677,
0.0211652145,
-0.0369668305,
0.0017647583,
0.0343323536,
-0.0477103665,
-0.0293907281,
-0.0036454417,
-0.0252193771,
0.0012733155,
0.0079390081,
0.0522048473,
-0.0001799247,
-0.028382279,
-0.0435774066,
0.0331904888,
-0.0158802886,
-0.0159787741,
-0.0330370851,
0.07959117,
-0.0879056603,
-0.0012474053,
-0.0493986122,
-0.0348309204,
0.0388894118,
-0.0398068689,
-0.0061386311,
1.942197684e-34,
-0.019916961,
-0.0013869549,
0.0607130341,
0.0252978671,
-0.0336405933,
-0.0553030707,
0.0478581414,
0.0276323482,
0.0636925921,
-0.0211151,
-0.0337481536
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13012v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13012v1
|
Divergent Creativity in Humans and Large Language Models
| 2024-05-13T22:37:52 | 2024-05-13T22:37:52 |
Antoine Bellemare-Pepin, François Lespinasse, Philipp Thölke, Yann Harel, Kory Mathewson, Jay A. Olson, Yoshua Bengio, Karim Jerbi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The recent surge in the capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) has led
to claims that they are approaching a level of creativity akin to human
capabilities. This idea has sparked a blend of excitement and apprehension.
However, a critical piece that has been missing in this discourse is a
systematic evaluation of LLM creativity, particularly in comparison to human
divergent thinking. To bridge this gap, we leverage recent advances in
creativity science to build a framework for in-depth analysis of divergent
creativity in both state-of-the-art LLMs and a substantial dataset of 100,000
humans. We found evidence suggesting that LLMs can indeed surpass human
capabilities in specific creative tasks such as divergent association and
creative writing. Our quantitative benchmarking framework opens up new paths
for the development of more creative LLMs, but it also encourages more granular
inquiries into the distinctive elements that constitute human inventive thought
processes, compared to those that can be artificially generated.
|
Divergent Creativity in Humans and Large Language Models: The recent surge in the capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) has led
to claims that they are approaching a level of creativity akin to human
capabilities. This idea has sparked a blend of excitement and apprehension.
However, a critical piece that has been missing in this discourse is a
systematic evaluation of LLM creativity, particularly in comparison to human
divergent thinking. To bridge this gap, we leverage recent advances in
creativity science to build a framework for in-depth analysis of divergent
creativity in both state-of-the-art LLMs and a substantial dataset of 100,000
humans. We found evidence suggesting that LLMs can indeed surpass human
capabilities in specific creative tasks such as divergent association and
creative writing. Our quantitative benchmarking framework opens up new paths
for the development of more creative LLMs, but it also encourages more granular
inquiries into the distinctive elements that constitute human inventive thought
processes, compared to those that can be artificially generated.
|
[
0.0346474871,
0.0349097662,
-0.0568336062,
0.0130756302,
-0.0451437086,
0.0221335012,
0.0159151461,
0.0020342469,
-0.0232080333,
0.0049515888,
-0.0420185328,
-0.0591626652,
0.0143442983,
0.0524414554,
0.0195775107,
-0.0145793064,
0.0007151671,
-0.0563602448,
0.0246048253,
0.0018892456,
-0.0531937182,
0.0312616564,
0.0042338627,
0.0544069558,
0.026679229,
-0.0139399227,
0.015813211,
-0.0024749157,
0.0217345692,
0.0165022053,
-0.0411519594,
0.0735652521,
-0.0156147303,
0.0845653191,
0.0000015669,
-0.0570217483,
0.0659691393,
-0.0482136048,
0.03294852,
-0.0113271028,
0.0305206589,
0.031576138,
-0.0319081731,
0.0030556812,
-0.0375939608,
0.0249685552,
0.0462100282,
0.0541506633,
0.010331152,
0.0353781581,
0.0144002708,
-0.0509791374,
0.0457998104,
-0.0478508249,
0.0177366752,
0.0353768244,
0.0241756272,
-0.0066700531,
0.0326522402,
-0.0475763977,
-0.0274981726,
0.0062920917,
0.0384010524,
-0.0087132771,
0.0109466752,
0.0462527722,
-0.0123753659,
-0.0318815447,
0.0434336141,
0.0319758579,
-0.0105364518,
-0.0186268296,
0.0008181006,
-0.0080883214,
-0.0005847309,
0.0173836555,
-0.0254498273,
0.0582445525,
0.0086548179,
0.0121291857,
0.0276530124,
-0.023343876,
-0.0056030937,
0.0322410874,
0.0171046853,
-0.0039814264,
0.0334565677,
0.0127201416,
-0.0141148549,
0.0270445198,
-0.0363964774,
-0.0679647923,
0.000058942,
-0.0371551327,
-0.0253200233,
-0.0145860724,
-0.0525774136,
-0.0319828689,
0.0102817323,
-0.0272382312,
0.1116961017,
0.0099833719,
0.0327390283,
0.0379400663,
0.0041332934,
0.0319541954,
-0.0422255844,
0.0290630851,
-0.0643163994,
0.0198798236,
-0.0512195155,
-0.0533474088,
0.0311706737,
-0.0296156313,
-0.0217153467,
-0.0384553969,
-0.0293647964,
0.0436290242,
-0.0101544186,
-0.0519204512,
-0.0328388959,
0.0387722813,
0.0011483738,
-0.021130519,
-0.0506218076,
-0.0139770797,
-0.0166988242,
0.0444620065,
0.0117976647,
0.0107869543,
-0.0145027088,
0.0155247562,
-0.0111505594,
-0.0590381175,
0.0165990498,
0.0109474724,
-0.0220025443,
-0.0259966645,
-0.0050926409,
-0.0148948235,
0.0108437305,
-0.0580587536,
0.0671315864,
-0.0614527725,
0.0364830792,
0.0314066708,
-0.0197886936,
-0.0632293448,
-0.0252471101,
0.0200049989,
-0.0419442765,
-0.003077155,
-0.026398655,
0.0514428355,
0.0209778324,
0.0041290564,
0.0162635464,
0.0040522092,
0.080355145,
0.0168735422,
-0.0244816728,
0.0244749915,
0.0108854594,
-0.0088741248,
-0.0338705145,
-0.0140320361,
-0.0459857807,
-0.0419254713,
-0.0147426296,
0.0680949762,
0.0517564379,
0.0623204634,
-0.0132438745,
0.0187536981,
0.1209565401,
0.0825569183,
0.0319594368,
0.0450773761,
0.0353130922,
-0.0220890753,
0.0284491815,
-0.0148033276,
-0.0207782611,
0.0630100071,
0.026563121,
0.0247458648,
0.0180895869,
0.0634791628,
-0.0305797905,
0.018853873,
-0.016528992,
0.0229483694,
0.0104766842,
-0.0407679342,
-0.017890498,
0.0213014521,
0.008251396,
-0.0128782419,
-0.00159356,
-0.0255086366,
-0.0029938654,
-0.0184319094,
0.0617259108,
0.0917681605,
0.0378379226,
0.0410308577,
0.0104677603,
-0.0181309301,
0.0027417243,
0.0849371478,
0.0036771407,
-0.0004980831,
-0.0041233436,
0.0130033782,
0.0260273628,
-0.0425956324,
0.0200021639,
-0.002389,
-0.0542445816,
0.0023872403,
-0.0195144918,
-0.0202239566,
-0.0010703591,
0.022559572,
-0.0819168463,
0.0156025225,
-0.0128291072,
0.0054421271,
-0.0044566216,
0.0258008484,
-0.0704543442,
0.0496364906,
0.0075587966,
-0.0469661839,
-0.073614426,
0.0552650914,
-0.0337161943,
-0.0015670195,
-0.0015901971,
-0.0887008011,
-0.0017899296,
0.003576545,
0.059162572,
-0.0265845358,
0.0381735489,
-0.0465866625,
0.0437402502,
-0.035385754,
0.0198251586,
-0.0137403049,
0.0222375095,
0.0086572831,
0.0802893639,
0.0013867609,
0.016328074,
-0.0043814769,
-0.0077840718,
0.0051307995,
0.0064408295,
-0.0134783788,
0.0019246881,
0.0311824027,
0.0091718528,
-0.0208962727,
-0.0079168528,
-0.0723307431,
-0.052531682,
-0.0510940365,
-0.0069974526,
0.0191326048,
-0.0032768773,
0.0153935421,
-0.0085705658,
-0.032436803,
0.0329710618,
-0.0284325276,
-0.0239771362,
0.0378792323,
0.0506211072,
0.021931354,
-0.0033301851,
-0.0190304797,
0.0199214201,
0.0022858505,
0.0054836343,
0.0319806673,
0.0384202935,
0.0132350139,
-0.0145523567,
0.0312546715,
-0.0687213242,
-0.0485610142,
-0.0257427115,
-0.0234428383,
0.0376782045,
-0.000923158,
0.0818960071,
0.024227405,
0.0129738413,
-0.0232383274,
0.0648376644,
-0.013842117,
0.0102947718,
-0.028660506,
-0.0090504894,
0.0419604704,
-0.0053752018,
-0.0160405375,
-0.0393835865,
0.0526139475,
0.0133309634,
0.0171682294,
-0.0054530576,
0.1017934605,
0.0326120369,
-0.0726035535,
0.0004684372,
-0.0329741426,
-0.0451344475,
0.0883576721,
-0.038897939,
-0.055636391,
0.049165789,
0.0230897702,
-0.0006991738,
0.0211787131,
0.0148124723,
-0.0080240956,
0.0883504078,
-0.0040800073,
0.0180347431,
0.0066573052,
0.0093926918,
-0.0877064094,
0.0286618415,
0.0203703437,
-0.0226439275,
0.04495975,
-0.0085014487,
-0.0174199827,
-0.0169935282,
-0.0403960235,
-0.0352887399,
0.0089588882,
-0.0113536445,
0.0210290067,
0.0445837453,
-0.0251346696,
-0.0269864704,
-0.0300723705,
0.0204645973,
0.0001197473,
0.0037402073,
0.012273415,
0.0055200323,
0.0090808878,
0.0649946034,
0.0018122512,
0.0069262534,
-0.0613328479,
0.0028798373,
0.0182252526,
-0.0598855093,
0.0447584279,
-0.0076787211,
0.0526181608,
-0.0022172295,
0.0247085672,
-0.0085402839,
0.0043525835,
0.0590711758,
-0.0069195218,
-0.0181234982,
0.0571440384,
0.0105620716,
0.0003754238,
0.0257760379,
-0.0052462276,
0.0090491213,
0.0214970466,
0.0335961618,
-0.0190629251,
0.0008176709,
-0.0044618514,
-0.0126342541,
-0.0091027804,
-0.0611981191,
-0.0255405214,
-0.0856557861,
0.0378206335,
0.0282441173,
-0.0220965575,
-0.0034196232,
-0.0008540633,
-0.0175588094,
0.0402175561,
-0.027573619,
0.0088744396,
0.0076172333,
-0.0047435653,
-0.0364931896,
0.0129006384,
-0.0370159112,
0.007622344,
-0.0588540435,
0.0484565347,
0.0543491878,
0.0329713896,
-0.0165787023,
-0.0558954403,
-0.0214415882,
-0.0181234274,
0.0288788825,
0.0066138888,
0.0201834328,
0.0614940971,
0.0086759776,
-0.0690460354,
0.034926042,
-0.0477213189,
-0.0492571853,
-0.0426707454,
0.0811390728,
-0.0299495421,
-0.0380377471,
-0.0386399254,
0.0018690007,
-0.0209772643,
0.0455954261,
0.0242299549,
-0.0702265799,
-0.0302337259,
-0.0014543327,
-0.0271749608,
-0.0657573268,
-0.043735221,
-0.0242381413,
0.028657712,
-0.022739552,
-0.0807128847,
-0.0135373771,
-0.014818863,
0.0301181525,
0.0149421263,
0.0324921645,
-0.0501655899,
-0.0395270437,
-0.0317245275,
0.0244763643,
0.0220931023,
0.033692155,
-0.0112742828,
-0.0357818082,
-0.0438395403,
-0.0724048018,
-0.0178255159,
0.0029644768,
-0.1474789381,
-0.0765564516,
0.0183590315,
-0.0232701134,
0.0221215524,
-0.0156332348,
0.0368263684,
-0.0851358399,
0.0343355201,
0.0535712056,
0.0284096207,
0.0783459842,
-0.0585025698,
0.0132572865,
0.011732013,
0.0236555282,
-0.0049393349,
0.0200006552,
0.0741069168,
0.0519908816,
0.022151703,
-0.0226492453,
-0.0035963797,
-0.0081407493,
-0.0004037054,
-0.0283538718,
0.0211204495,
-0.0835927874,
-0.033322759,
0.0035382533,
-0.0152595947,
-0.0316053107,
-0.0438753478,
0.0452640094,
0.0039149807,
-0.0104366876,
-0.0038389827,
0.0025517563,
0.0436795838,
-0.0570293032,
-0.0067924159,
0.0111492304,
0.0017754224,
0.0235224366,
0.0183297023,
0.0153583474,
0.0533979647,
-0.0637772381,
0.0527633876,
0.0097868508,
0.0450156182,
-0.0100426078,
-0.008980982,
-0.0087914253,
0.0260329731,
-0.0828046352,
-0.0803651884,
0.016571993,
0.0050111916,
0.0667308494,
-0.0066973781,
0.0311136637,
-0.0396374352,
0.022552941,
-0.0385157578,
0.0362050384,
-0.0405256003,
-0.0303889718,
-0.0355657749,
0.0183150731,
0.0054512592,
-0.0199063886,
0.0413461402,
-0.0570850112,
0.0111987358,
-0.016283812,
-0.0000109484,
0.0013946686,
-0.0222054925,
0.0191581938,
0.0185443312,
-0.0012859255,
0.034314353,
-0.0561835021,
-0.0564761683,
0.0649378896,
0.0062615909,
0.0301705804,
-0.0056025176,
-0.0004324073,
0.0454554223,
-0.0212656036,
-0.0068900301,
-0.0181471054,
-0.009119886,
-0.0311726257,
-0.0096643614,
-0.0521914288,
-5.186693234e-33,
-0.0074080536,
-0.0109384255,
0.0108703198,
-0.0428270996,
-0.0329772569,
-0.0475038514,
-0.0595310256,
0.0504664741,
-0.0047971131,
0.0263940021,
-0.0205300599,
0.0014913573,
-0.0078042741,
-0.0006685508,
0.046818316,
-0.0007787815,
0.0270516519,
0.001383152,
-0.0052030468,
-0.0151586821,
0.0560890026,
-0.0050865836,
-0.0022470264,
-0.0348438993,
-0.0136708152,
-0.046364639,
-0.0098981028,
-0.0198470168,
0.0112429056,
0.062504299,
-0.0192325339,
0.027341716,
0.0651066899,
0.0119647915,
-0.0237316769,
-0.0373305008,
0.0279948544,
-0.0495377332,
-0.0156871472,
-0.0411893539,
0.0295192413,
-0.0303479452,
0.0454317033,
0.001897611,
-0.0504879467,
-0.0201194938,
0.0395724997,
-0.0099777468,
-0.0018489189,
-0.0194494557,
-0.0919841975,
-0.0194367673,
0.0007773756,
-0.015961023,
-0.0252711233,
-0.0622197725,
-0.0146276392,
-0.0144373234,
-0.0681072846,
0.0813876018,
-0.0200514682,
0.0073973667,
0.053828761,
0.0231811907,
0.0038220407,
0.0645214617,
0.0581964292,
0.0676543117,
-0.0177061185,
0.030786369,
0.0129486574,
0.0847316235,
0.0178855583,
0.066459775,
0.0154852429,
-0.0092337318,
0.0366539657,
-0.0126877045,
0.0035071573,
-0.0274140872,
0.0369173437,
0.015204506,
-0.0011857722,
-0.0354271457,
0.0040317555,
-0.0370746069,
-0.0227042213,
0.0079957759,
0.0156519115,
-0.0205793753,
0.0284614414,
-0.0320594795,
0.0357247107,
-0.0262801908,
0.0248585343,
-0.0052747531,
-0.0656864643,
0.0494973175,
0.0026280452,
-0.0263482649,
-0.0415748172,
-0.0491466671,
0.0245195217,
0.0623564199,
0.0318927579,
0.0185627565,
-0.001508042,
-0.0147240553,
-0.0453802422,
0.0012899011,
-0.0372016653,
-0.0078676632,
0.048277583,
-0.0370397605,
0.0302806944,
-0.0272778124,
-0.0099126659,
-0.0540463328,
0.0262758341,
0.0052657444,
-0.0281870756,
-0.0099807233,
-0.033367835,
-0.0031808305,
-0.0023373028,
0.0157825314,
-0.0310363695,
-0.0191757362,
0.0664257109,
-0.0485748425,
-0.0186261516,
-0.0159027986,
2.379e-7,
0.0139646893,
0.0418475792,
-0.0221834276,
0.0427061841,
0.0503291525,
0.0256832484,
-0.0331235267,
0.0053321263,
0.0083567761,
0.0351776369,
-0.0052987589,
0.0226496682,
0.0420697927,
0.0258816164,
-0.0694624707,
0.0695806816,
-0.0807644799,
0.0525911339,
-0.0654706359,
-0.0344572142,
0.0592474975,
0.0113627529,
0.0142036853,
-0.0682293549,
0.010094313,
-0.0610045418,
0.0509119108,
-0.0131403189,
0.0309189092,
-0.0144498218,
-0.0066163102,
-0.0146232406,
0.0144807482,
0.0045219031,
-0.0224822834,
0.0098600471,
0.0020646506,
0.004933774,
0.0040454622,
0.0240357034,
0.0130208228,
-0.0054580271,
0.0077015311,
-0.0454084277,
0.0456566289,
0.0073947408,
-0.023165578,
-0.0004520963,
0.0255021639,
0.0117007717,
0.0317162611,
-0.030126011,
0.0307378732,
-0.0223507378,
0.0320937447,
0.0187750123,
0.0081531787,
-0.015269015,
-0.0158566386,
-0.0029626363,
-0.0780521706,
-0.0609858632,
-0.0558234863,
0.0344194509,
0.0518292971,
-0.0329923034,
-0.0075196577,
1.809830362e-34,
0.0191470217,
-0.0079367384,
0.0233805459,
0.0206637736,
0.0149974516,
-0.0033868416,
0.0334776305,
0.0093099624,
-0.0198340286,
-0.0765252486,
-0.0450211577
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08223v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08223v1
|
An information-theoretic model of shallow and deep language comprehension
| 2024-05-13T22:29:33 | 2024-05-13T22:29:33 |
Jiaxuan Li, Richard Futrell
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IT, math.IT
|
A large body of work in psycholinguistics has focused on the idea that online
language comprehension can be shallow or `good enough': given constraints on
time or available computation, comprehenders may form interpretations of their
input that are plausible but inaccurate. However, this idea has not yet been
linked with formal theories of computation under resource constraints. Here we
use information theory to formulate a model of language comprehension as an
optimal trade-off between accuracy and processing depth, formalized as bits of
information extracted from the input, which increases with processing time. The
model provides a measure of processing effort as the change in processing
depth, which we link to EEG signals and reading times. We validate our theory
against a large-scale dataset of garden path sentence reading times, and EEG
experiments featuring N400, P600 and biphasic ERP effects. By quantifying the
timecourse of language processing as it proceeds from shallow to deep, our
model provides a unified framework to explain behavioral and neural signatures
of language comprehension.
|
An information-theoretic model of shallow and deep language comprehension: A large body of work in psycholinguistics has focused on the idea that online
language comprehension can be shallow or `good enough': given constraints on
time or available computation, comprehenders may form interpretations of their
input that are plausible but inaccurate. However, this idea has not yet been
linked with formal theories of computation under resource constraints. Here we
use information theory to formulate a model of language comprehension as an
optimal trade-off between accuracy and processing depth, formalized as bits of
information extracted from the input, which increases with processing time. The
model provides a measure of processing effort as the change in processing
depth, which we link to EEG signals and reading times. We validate our theory
against a large-scale dataset of garden path sentence reading times, and EEG
experiments featuring N400, P600 and biphasic ERP effects. By quantifying the
timecourse of language processing as it proceeds from shallow to deep, our
model provides a unified framework to explain behavioral and neural signatures
of language comprehension.
|
[
0.0173669048,
0.0102356877,
-0.0408388488,
0.0419087894,
-0.0514735579,
0.0143200709,
-0.0218499973,
0.0418841764,
-0.0371194892,
-0.0135141928,
0.0119693419,
-0.0364598967,
0.0524341278,
0.022351671,
0.0249063671,
-0.060165897,
0.0393541753,
-0.0211505871,
0.0167186148,
-0.0223685652,
-0.0109435245,
-0.0500175543,
-0.030967664,
0.0331961252,
0.0178509448,
0.0269022081,
-0.0544409975,
-0.0101235639,
-0.0255819689,
-0.0256288555,
-0.0563790537,
0.0392520204,
-0.0078760628,
0.0469290018,
0.0000017573,
-0.0319757499,
0.0293405522,
-0.0061752079,
-0.0905820504,
0.0184248965,
-0.0433388688,
-0.0221972447,
0.0312174615,
-0.0402791612,
0.0308913216,
0.0134298876,
0.051514294,
0.0564117096,
-0.0124791991,
0.0354346707,
-0.003945916,
0.0078167897,
0.057123784,
-0.0286952984,
0.0726118982,
-0.0604516752,
0.0308624376,
-0.0418363214,
-0.0021907296,
0.018493643,
-0.0752680451,
0.0104274508,
0.0316183344,
0.0381041318,
0.0389387868,
0.0523603372,
0.0368803516,
-0.0212165639,
-0.0359699428,
0.0408150554,
0.0317630619,
0.0179416891,
-0.0062226253,
-0.004132682,
-0.0376218669,
0.0182565413,
-0.0123430323,
-0.0319043696,
-0.0261724256,
-0.0072466275,
0.0241294298,
-0.0293971207,
0.0182583351,
0.0020077899,
0.0003387091,
0.0837387145,
0.0021795197,
-0.0732824355,
0.0095433164,
0.015076519,
0.0026936226,
-0.0190986488,
0.0057005789,
0.0369487256,
0.0119830323,
-0.0030005241,
0.0171606783,
-0.0370715037,
-0.0061734784,
0.0108820088,
0.002314714,
0.0482976213,
0.0676600933,
0.0528982356,
0.0067752427,
0.0264489073,
-0.0037645467,
0.0022396839,
-0.0172838699,
0.0335181728,
-0.0036459388,
-0.0457424484,
-0.0213652253,
-0.0113111725,
-0.0277857129,
-0.05371508,
-0.0567562096,
-0.0322161019,
-0.0187526755,
-0.0532123111,
-0.0339683481,
-0.0147363218,
-0.030620655,
0.0074475268,
-0.0660139322,
0.0068259668,
-0.038360104,
0.0480156131,
-0.0073348884,
-0.0273103435,
-0.0115531012,
0.0049725603,
-0.0054315319,
-0.0057042241,
-0.0300687496,
0.0478187837,
0.0156890918,
-0.041018337,
-0.0310296696,
-0.0253944993,
-0.0166012216,
0.01264947,
0.0030118001,
-0.0481986366,
0.0378631987,
0.0101038674,
-0.0096132038,
-0.0165510941,
-0.0261964444,
-0.0105835916,
-0.0202173386,
0.0685714781,
-0.0350990593,
0.0288543887,
0.0450667255,
0.0308507718,
0.0067170067,
0.0308046676,
0.0510951057,
-0.0372043662,
0.0134856617,
-0.0288165901,
-0.0421795547,
0.0401546434,
-0.0055130557,
-0.0008345385,
-0.0226252191,
-0.0519804209,
-0.062040709,
0.0457513407,
0.0221379716,
0.0418627113,
-0.0483810157,
-0.0085989535,
0.0718762651,
0.076165542,
0.0033889005,
0.0208040662,
0.0274696853,
0.0214635059,
0.0185808334,
0.0405547246,
-0.0144682936,
0.0133971293,
0.0238289647,
-0.0022259848,
0.0544030592,
-0.0653433651,
0.0076134885,
-0.0253766533,
0.0364583917,
0.0254026968,
0.0495515838,
0.0277499668,
0.0210217535,
-0.0305969194,
-0.0352469794,
0.0158474185,
0.0000916517,
0.0240327101,
0.0371774994,
-0.0404820889,
0.0193912107,
0.0673134774,
0.0027990178,
-0.0108858831,
0.0675640181,
0.0390593931,
-0.0251991097,
0.063657105,
0.0105325319,
-0.001189757,
0.0272132698,
0.0025409819,
-0.0113024218,
-0.0130493324,
0.0068898848,
-0.0248014946,
-0.0254033171,
-0.0095370309,
-0.021902075,
-0.0067238463,
-0.0165773928,
0.023135161,
-0.0089775501,
-0.0193342473,
-0.0518879518,
0.0353728645,
0.021291187,
-0.0342299417,
-0.0130804321,
0.0148663959,
-0.0181059036,
0.0003267829,
0.0032542755,
-0.0259249881,
-0.0103588598,
0.0122884559,
0.0025444233,
-0.0333075784,
-0.0229964536,
0.0261400323,
0.0519964397,
-0.0332649536,
-0.0167124942,
-0.0949893296,
0.0387121551,
-0.0035051701,
0.0022847082,
-0.0227817781,
0.0183420796,
-0.0655428544,
0.0584907942,
-0.0033763757,
0.070249401,
-0.0026357169,
-0.0264134202,
0.0028305247,
-0.0420704,
-0.0204346199,
-0.0139781246,
0.006498042,
-0.0476412736,
0.0008279075,
-0.0300447494,
-0.0631331801,
0.0013721132,
-0.0720103681,
-0.0549254157,
0.0296367873,
0.0132981911,
0.023753142,
-0.0160106476,
-0.0014025564,
0.0267696436,
0.0147503782,
0.0641952753,
-0.0158947501,
0.0570224747,
0.0103407567,
0.0314975716,
-0.0381608494,
0.0107268021,
-0.0293208081,
-0.0403924994,
0.0498438217,
0.0296854693,
-0.0385483243,
-0.0571211018,
0.0362770483,
-0.021628147,
-0.0044080326,
0.0123139182,
0.0019232046,
0.0575071275,
0.0187141094,
0.0546396561,
0.0766096264,
0.0236577597,
0.0639202595,
0.0403427854,
-0.0261071287,
-0.0376862921,
0.0160812084,
-0.0445367396,
0.0461892001,
-0.0479005389,
-0.0467502773,
0.0085228896,
0.1120334342,
0.0598175265,
0.0023422318,
-0.0598279126,
-0.0099913608,
-0.0684968382,
-0.0788260177,
-0.0359953083,
-0.0250594281,
-0.0321140997,
0.0764322132,
-0.0536184385,
-0.0678319633,
0.0935163498,
0.0017693418,
0.0212799329,
0.0037539934,
0.032910943,
0.0360212214,
0.0552130155,
0.0145430733,
0.0344332419,
-0.0555699952,
-0.041480504,
-0.034586262,
0.0254502334,
0.0191990528,
-0.0107212104,
0.0628039613,
-0.0130341938,
-0.0046946565,
0.009448179,
-0.0112143764,
0.0108502535,
0.0070021274,
-0.0116657494,
-0.0314536653,
0.0346955471,
-0.0073654582,
-0.0130521553,
-0.0204320624,
0.0426023453,
0.0173643231,
-0.0026884542,
-0.0719632953,
-0.0002955268,
-0.0057540783,
0.0015470873,
0.0397172123,
0.0551046506,
-0.0747367293,
0.0403891616,
0.0353369899,
-0.0021414328,
0.0437195785,
0.0170643609,
0.0150609324,
0.0280091316,
-0.0220944639,
-0.0300822724,
0.0511611477,
0.0466518179,
-0.0489821248,
-0.038571395,
0.0913024768,
0.0024153756,
-0.0562938415,
0.0387149602,
-0.0646633804,
0.0232492555,
0.0112214405,
-0.0054362975,
0.0046430514,
-0.028022863,
0.0004551836,
0.0354458019,
-0.0263684932,
-0.0334739164,
-0.0246910993,
-0.0159219597,
-0.0086207297,
-0.0233163387,
-0.0310705043,
-0.0014379458,
-0.0375740081,
0.0183567926,
0.0638402477,
0.011692998,
0.0055702347,
0.0011335844,
0.0159005504,
0.0178409107,
-0.0019831841,
-0.0101385089,
0.0368416347,
0.0225908179,
0.0301275514,
-0.0147626409,
0.0245175548,
-0.0540672913,
-0.0045613963,
0.0044258586,
-0.0498694479,
-0.0032472482,
-0.0094397943,
0.0222807135,
0.0241532754,
-0.0079417927,
-0.0596057251,
-0.007848545,
0.0418062024,
-0.0445598252,
-0.0206627101,
0.0491554774,
-0.0155282589,
-0.0380840339,
0.0211387128,
0.0113378819,
0.0209467821,
0.0772038251,
0.0640366524,
-0.0724225044,
-0.0230072532,
-0.0009409965,
0.02768155,
-0.0524161011,
-0.0794100091,
0.0299202669,
0.0410103686,
-0.0038560082,
-0.0282288399,
-0.0301450752,
0.0138352094,
0.0337037966,
0.0596743114,
0.0464821346,
0.0675338507,
-0.0526073948,
-0.0156085566,
0.000408236,
0.0216959808,
0.0006637509,
-0.0601293743,
-0.0234731119,
-0.0499667935,
-0.0160520077,
-0.0109005515,
0.0279336404,
-0.0490635186,
-0.0408066027,
0.0792049021,
-0.0349837244,
0.0308449771,
-0.0186857432,
0.0321440212,
-0.0830743164,
0.0384903252,
-0.0107210847,
-0.0199396238,
0.0540728718,
-0.0162318051,
0.0244587585,
0.0125996973,
0.0317942463,
-0.0237812195,
-0.01608124,
0.0233065132,
0.0289668646,
-0.0121662859,
-0.0198192429,
0.0184989441,
0.0319733508,
0.0270627812,
-0.019826686,
-0.0001074971,
-0.0247620232,
-0.0252465624,
0.0300861783,
0.0464814045,
-0.0276037585,
-0.0998087227,
0.0347721949,
-0.0117504559,
-0.0152516011,
-0.0046629007,
0.0492015891,
-0.0674845204,
-0.0258131642,
-0.0076993946,
-0.029441556,
-0.0226012096,
0.0146785276,
0.0221681595,
0.0054929932,
0.0177534353,
-0.0803378597,
0.0124992207,
0.0365892611,
0.0441739596,
0.0537798963,
-0.0077663637,
-0.0324007049,
-0.0233261231,
-0.0307073761,
-0.060632199,
0.105137594,
-0.0084233778,
-0.0155022237,
-0.0215060059,
0.0189751368,
-0.0451253839,
0.0208166987,
-0.0364638604,
0.030662749,
-0.0183504261,
-0.0329142772,
0.0617488883,
0.027300315,
0.020710459,
-0.004198032,
0.078585647,
0.0114271613,
0.0472439341,
0.0069201686,
0.0122003015,
-0.0132122207,
-0.0315579437,
-0.032379359,
0.0465676859,
-0.0527762026,
0.02243701,
-0.054372903,
-0.0548683368,
-0.0265162047,
0.015015129,
0.0490970872,
-0.0254299343,
0.0038178577,
0.0605210215,
-0.006489302,
-0.0301570483,
0.0005284048,
0.0206354186,
-0.023241464,
-0.016229419,
-0.0111105181,
-5.677626327e-33,
0.0176962633,
-0.0399416536,
-0.0079272715,
0.0205221903,
-0.0270572379,
0.0710157529,
-0.0433238149,
0.0314948373,
0.0052842097,
0.0256507453,
0.000037507,
0.0131390467,
-0.0016575396,
-0.0024198168,
0.004791203,
-0.0009225991,
-0.0170947686,
-0.0137805864,
-0.0406887121,
-0.0181193016,
0.0436232276,
-0.003082542,
0.0561546758,
-0.0076838383,
0.0492342524,
0.0238329265,
0.0257790592,
0.0426362157,
-0.0158036575,
0.0443947576,
-0.0562720075,
0.0599351302,
0.0530184582,
-0.0492274165,
0.0022762248,
0.0363431685,
-0.0631150156,
0.0021646514,
0.0260111615,
0.006676652,
-0.0888431221,
-0.0009627898,
0.0760690942,
-0.006136809,
0.0095533868,
-0.013142243,
0.0190198012,
-0.0065833381,
-0.0245176759,
0.012121371,
-0.0641922876,
-0.0110480869,
-0.0468395352,
0.001487523,
0.0148722418,
0.0230676979,
-0.0356463157,
-0.0128186569,
-0.0855089054,
0.004411906,
-0.0502696708,
0.0493624136,
-0.0041748011,
0.0130907334,
0.0473047979,
0.0564626567,
0.0431074984,
0.0488699526,
-0.0386995822,
-0.0214201342,
0.0460108556,
-0.0095766559,
0.0059757298,
-0.0202445108,
0.0771773458,
-0.0283163302,
-0.0881330669,
0.0106637878,
0.0200805068,
0.0365559123,
0.0268674456,
-0.0224549454,
-0.0664316565,
-0.0253291801,
-0.0312778056,
0.033627566,
-0.0412682891,
-0.0050852648,
0.039828673,
-0.0270640384,
0.000341739,
-0.0347505175,
0.0372635052,
-0.0391411036,
0.0256518666,
-0.0230566338,
0.0025731788,
0.0271598622,
0.0203143749,
-0.0091614937,
-0.0085850125,
-0.0286129527,
-0.0269067362,
0.0100259464,
0.041810073,
0.0055294377,
-0.0345701165,
0.0153643033,
-0.016578842,
-0.0069739269,
-0.028500339,
-0.0375652425,
0.0327262096,
-0.0307049416,
0.0812492147,
-0.0149654122,
-0.0272701681,
-0.0567735136,
-0.0163404029,
-0.0039495691,
0.0049645263,
-0.0075810421,
-0.0251272507,
0.0523414798,
0.0017243706,
-0.0430268794,
-0.0507282801,
-0.0222476982,
-0.0013301231,
-0.049737677,
-0.0345064513,
0.0301418304,
2.758e-7,
0.0125493947,
0.0445285104,
-0.0029683518,
0.0496772826,
0.0354135185,
0.0040569068,
0.0248753708,
0.01044029,
-0.0214157514,
-0.0382941887,
-0.0020214377,
0.0398764685,
-0.0017094078,
-0.0300539024,
-0.0306999441,
-0.0864197016,
-0.0116629545,
0.0815887973,
-0.0325004235,
0.0333660319,
0.0617822707,
-0.0086925216,
-0.0077856979,
-0.0019034484,
0.0083910013,
-0.0157512892,
0.0646865815,
-0.0178872645,
0.048428487,
0.0142189572,
0.0571995229,
-0.0050509563,
0.0262476429,
0.0795897022,
0.0196643081,
-0.0147674242,
0.0224615391,
0.0031407981,
-0.0039600781,
0.0360625908,
-0.0011229162,
-0.0274066105,
-0.0151985576,
-0.0491783917,
0.0337863266,
-0.0388131142,
-0.0886713415,
0.0558219291,
-0.018461654,
-0.0309459791,
0.0083599919,
0.0200037993,
-0.0247130133,
-0.0486554466,
0.0011233147,
-0.0151218623,
0.0081689516,
-0.0345215499,
0.0176289752,
0.0574002899,
-0.0415102877,
-0.0104286401,
-0.0850779042,
-0.0182300285,
0.0518501177,
-0.0625065342,
-0.0191087425,
2.027962165e-34,
-0.0410389081,
-0.0159638189,
0.0583946668,
0.0136966854,
-0.0124322735,
-0.0291431211,
0.0622774474,
-0.0329226367,
0.0167268869,
-0.0714970306,
-0.0147136627
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08213v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08213v1
|
Interpreting Latent Student Knowledge Representations in Programming Assignments
| 2024-05-13T22:01:03 | 2024-05-13T22:01:03 |
Nigel Fernandez, Andrew Lan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Recent advances in artificial intelligence for education leverage generative
large language models, including using them to predict open-ended student
responses rather than their correctness only. However, the black-box nature of
these models limits the interpretability of the learned student knowledge
representations. In this paper, we conduct a first exploration into
interpreting latent student knowledge representations by presenting InfoOIRT,
an Information regularized Open-ended Item Response Theory model, which
encourages the latent student knowledge states to be interpretable while being
able to generate student-written code for open-ended programming questions.
InfoOIRT maximizes the mutual information between a fixed subset of latent
knowledge states enforced with simple prior distributions and generated student
code, which encourages the model to learn disentangled representations of
salient syntactic and semantic code features including syntactic styles,
mastery of programming skills, and code structures. Through experiments on a
real-world programming education dataset, we show that InfoOIRT can both
accurately generate student code and lead to interpretable student knowledge
representations.
|
Interpreting Latent Student Knowledge Representations in Programming Assignments: Recent advances in artificial intelligence for education leverage generative
large language models, including using them to predict open-ended student
responses rather than their correctness only. However, the black-box nature of
these models limits the interpretability of the learned student knowledge
representations. In this paper, we conduct a first exploration into
interpreting latent student knowledge representations by presenting InfoOIRT,
an Information regularized Open-ended Item Response Theory model, which
encourages the latent student knowledge states to be interpretable while being
able to generate student-written code for open-ended programming questions.
InfoOIRT maximizes the mutual information between a fixed subset of latent
knowledge states enforced with simple prior distributions and generated student
code, which encourages the model to learn disentangled representations of
salient syntactic and semantic code features including syntactic styles,
mastery of programming skills, and code structures. Through experiments on a
real-world programming education dataset, we show that InfoOIRT can both
accurately generate student code and lead to interpretable student knowledge
representations.
|
[
0.0079177292,
0.0218267757,
-0.0473466106,
0.0530731939,
-0.0192882288,
0.0141268903,
-0.0219581854,
-0.0243212078,
0.0015150944,
-0.0143308789,
0.0176587608,
0.0366918109,
-0.0239890385,
0.061760895,
0.0365774259,
-0.0336735733,
0.0114250062,
-0.0202801637,
-0.0335799493,
-0.0003202451,
0.0142407939,
-0.009531578,
-0.0270386226,
0.0753711835,
0.0490624346,
-0.0544556864,
-0.0299839061,
-0.0213395506,
-0.0264085624,
-0.027951289,
0.0018134562,
0.060067419,
0.0383002274,
-0.0581894517,
0.0000021269,
-0.0290036593,
-0.0026008822,
-0.0287111774,
-0.0221784487,
0.0152660934,
-0.028731497,
0.0207591671,
0.0389465727,
0.0077011818,
-0.0552952699,
-0.0616058148,
0.0508738533,
-0.0050940644,
0.0378311351,
0.0213578101,
0.0165982097,
0.0145610031,
0.0487557314,
0.0144355372,
0.1189574674,
-0.0139366705,
0.0363012925,
0.0311904065,
-0.0010834887,
0.0390372276,
-0.0506874658,
-0.0215885304,
0.0345889367,
-0.0072018183,
0.0506040677,
0.0119353207,
-0.0241239518,
0.0138371866,
0.039847929,
0.0699286237,
0.0042328504,
-0.0089836726,
-0.009636797,
-0.0249473285,
0.0125479307,
0.0284015201,
-0.0640726089,
-0.0012211622,
0.0005683597,
-0.0062808185,
0.0150454203,
-0.0208229478,
-0.0233944096,
-0.005865633,
-0.0293031242,
0.0631880686,
-0.0001296971,
-0.0375486426,
-0.0376595072,
0.0109831104,
-0.0294737052,
-0.0266703814,
-0.0165880341,
0.0667311251,
0.0146838203,
0.0010525384,
0.004300354,
-0.0332993455,
-0.0111686625,
0.0109436363,
0.00772786,
0.0265945327,
-0.0005584364,
0.0133052208,
-0.0062635704,
0.0710981861,
-0.0020927659,
0.0104580056,
-0.0423350409,
0.0001341799,
-0.0811793655,
-0.0158023909,
0.0010079878,
0.0768380985,
0.0483629256,
0.044224456,
0.0028865631,
0.0496502072,
-0.0385609195,
0.0374415591,
-0.059011396,
0.0361634307,
-0.0133738602,
0.0219936743,
-0.0530716702,
0.0393259637,
-0.0442190506,
-0.0267320368,
-0.0103201363,
0.0247067157,
-0.0105362087,
0.0449654274,
0.0097594876,
-0.0263659824,
-0.0137540391,
0.0266994704,
0.0096181529,
0.0278914645,
-0.0225757845,
-0.0561346114,
0.0309770331,
-0.0026742497,
0.0276519209,
-0.0682993904,
-0.0166725554,
0.0562910847,
-0.0157558955,
-0.077686362,
-0.0141112413,
0.0062035508,
0.0295542255,
0.043330498,
-0.0478230603,
-0.0357052721,
-0.0049448824,
0.0199582726,
0.01692014,
-0.0105896899,
0.0210662782,
0.0258253869,
-0.0080795987,
-0.0566189922,
0.0281433277,
-0.0210733674,
0.0104119619,
0.0044903783,
-0.0106781106,
0.0584114194,
0.04257828,
0.0068059885,
-0.0064566233,
0.0170336571,
-0.0000499853,
0.0201874115,
-0.0051925331,
0.0095931189,
0.017029589,
0.0375427455,
0.0247564428,
0.078999497,
0.0158870649,
0.0312562436,
-0.0261955988,
0.0679413527,
0.0266795736,
-0.0146238487,
0.0357956477,
-0.0142018087,
-0.005541252,
-0.0755287558,
0.0111358948,
-0.0161395241,
-0.0098878583,
0.0233857948,
0.0562408827,
-0.0099483142,
-0.0102335941,
-0.0047373842,
0.0351026244,
-0.0123073896,
0.0232099257,
-0.0641470328,
0.0672880709,
0.0471832566,
0.037840791,
-0.0739253536,
-0.0107599283,
-0.0252514947,
-0.0197212622,
-0.0233797692,
0.0335364304,
-0.0384988226,
-0.0117166732,
-0.0364418402,
-0.0479134433,
-0.0083075631,
-0.0100445691,
0.0289571527,
-0.019410966,
-0.0388442911,
0.0110780606,
-0.0098290723,
-0.0032328884,
0.0084683578,
-0.0098031266,
-0.0658031181,
0.0099090794,
-0.0034731061,
0.0209043156,
-0.014810374,
0.0015357838,
0.0099718086,
0.0227454249,
-0.0219214372,
-0.0188977327,
-0.089362286,
-0.0531784147,
-0.0341668539,
0.0163879879,
-0.0536327325,
0.0102444561,
0.0443879366,
-0.0246329941,
-0.0459878631,
0.0872113705,
-0.0216857921,
0.0359467231,
0.0108251479,
-0.0395015031,
-0.0032160394,
-0.0045995237,
-0.0271705929,
0.0412724242,
0.0090485374,
0.0545864441,
0.0252126455,
0.0027239069,
0.0471975505,
0.0174541641,
0.0005536543,
-0.000320238,
-0.025564339,
0.0359023735,
0.0290529132,
0.0046852063,
-0.0241066497,
0.0046694931,
-0.0313740112,
-0.0079876762,
-0.013215608,
0.0020725024,
0.0091944765,
-0.0127392216,
0.02678895,
-0.0016063692,
-0.0631249622,
0.0078980755,
-0.0524651781,
0.0027493804,
0.034960933,
0.019027302,
-0.0162758734,
-0.0359441824,
-0.016733963,
-0.0483156294,
0.055640813,
0.0378302559,
0.028047787,
-0.0404703543,
0.0580295026,
-0.0246990677,
-0.0035694276,
-0.0261913165,
-0.011245979,
0.0261962079,
-0.0444563739,
0.0683012903,
0.0442547053,
-0.0211779866,
0.0270685162,
0.0592454672,
0.0090260915,
-0.0804060102,
0.0292519722,
-0.0167507939,
-0.0090440549,
-0.0386501215,
-0.052997116,
0.0064507243,
0.0439028554,
0.0454385653,
-0.0397752188,
-0.0363465957,
0.0369805768,
-0.008663848,
-0.0033411263,
-0.0586501248,
0.0054016369,
0.0175808351,
0.0459007435,
0.004090718,
-0.0594875924,
0.0942371935,
0.0098662814,
0.0046300045,
-0.0089759743,
-0.0164613687,
-0.048659157,
0.0612468086,
0.0276045389,
-0.0113845346,
-0.0250075813,
-0.0127647165,
-0.0772312358,
0.0389780253,
0.0054220264,
-0.0326987989,
0.0171380434,
-0.0291153342,
-0.0605197214,
0.0085454285,
0.0012463604,
-0.0368004851,
-0.0112565868,
0.0509912148,
-0.0034680455,
0.0548473671,
-0.0288309734,
0.037565168,
-0.029272683,
0.0509408452,
-0.0350840949,
-0.0067983773,
-0.0377871729,
-0.026283592,
0.0062920963,
0.0482867733,
-0.043507129,
-0.0260360371,
-0.0353097282,
0.0006765698,
0.0409668759,
0.0452594385,
0.0379230045,
-0.0210603941,
0.0330694728,
0.0276970323,
-0.0199192185,
-0.0143027455,
0.049332466,
0.0313772485,
-0.0553329401,
-0.0110556874,
0.0690824538,
0.0148510924,
-0.0604561605,
0.0112302769,
-0.0169768967,
0.021492539,
0.0547792129,
0.0520162545,
-0.057645835,
-0.0153818242,
-0.0589883439,
0.0425049029,
0.0029888446,
-0.0581592321,
0.0072184103,
-0.0447897948,
-0.0053677936,
0.0030853152,
-0.0180010479,
-0.0710520893,
-0.0286782403,
-0.0258783866,
-0.0166531727,
-0.0260469392,
-0.0045289048,
0.0102057895,
0.0617903434,
0.0404722728,
-0.0063865404,
-0.0032539067,
0.0391004942,
0.0192438364,
0.053144034,
0.0498412214,
-0.0147665357,
-0.0321262181,
-0.0272524841,
-0.0362268761,
-0.0170465354,
-0.0153383426,
0.009838609,
0.0351242051,
-0.0059201685,
-0.0109053636,
-0.0034833215,
0.0172879007,
-0.065733321,
-0.0045182938,
0.0745643154,
0.0730968639,
-0.0369687378,
-0.0063633588,
-0.0548525155,
-0.0428830534,
0.0119697368,
0.0528569259,
0.0657450482,
-0.0612532757,
-0.0028814797,
-0.0950054154,
0.0070719155,
-0.0213000327,
0.0164269507,
-0.0159861259,
0.0283002481,
0.0123599246,
-0.0294262115,
-0.043544054,
0.0646904632,
-0.0020029454,
0.0167672746,
-0.0114425635,
0.0217887163,
-0.0215835627,
-0.0571514703,
0.0067999498,
-0.0047441018,
-0.0200444441,
-0.0085425973,
-0.0484478138,
-0.0153290816,
-0.0729975775,
-0.051873859,
-0.0330528878,
-0.0972630978,
-0.0131873013,
-0.0053810994,
0.0485213883,
0.0165218171,
0.0239488631,
0.0103759924,
-0.054194048,
-0.0233892836,
0.0068592015,
-0.0173396375,
-0.007890394,
-0.0037721901,
0.0017579,
0.0114069581,
-0.0065451064,
-0.0621208362,
0.0200154111,
0.0291263312,
0.000351612,
-0.0259060953,
-0.0350615233,
0.0291757639,
0.0352763757,
0.0280557107,
0.0766432211,
-0.0366693474,
-0.0243970063,
0.0132492054,
0.0293085054,
-0.0111333802,
-0.0387622491,
-0.0343043953,
0.0258799307,
-0.0034964404,
0.018561041,
-0.0044410983,
0.0110021271,
0.0480769128,
-0.0554538444,
0.0235005058,
-0.0044631483,
0.0428656638,
0.0526287816,
-0.0001775099,
-0.030848885,
0.039936237,
0.013476247,
0.0555602871,
0.0036244169,
0.082490325,
0.0021118019,
0.0404388607,
0.0372793078,
-0.0136921173,
-0.0519077145,
-0.0616383068,
-0.0014216346,
0.0216312613,
-0.02175151,
0.0659061372,
-0.0187294707,
-0.0282204151,
0.0413709432,
-0.0176975299,
0.0833645165,
-0.0099591147,
-0.0628966391,
0.0078790998,
0.042213928,
0.008419442,
-0.0215991288,
0.0831166655,
0.0241046455,
-0.003203463,
-0.0298937913,
-0.0052353819,
-0.0537723042,
0.0319852233,
0.0604783297,
0.0693008676,
0.0248647816,
0.0481972583,
-0.0364383459,
-0.0581348948,
-0.0248485003,
0.0512006246,
0.0222440511,
-0.0218784865,
0.0238690358,
0.0666445419,
-0.0413326956,
-0.0332761109,
-0.0198427793,
0.0108059673,
-0.0295212287,
-0.0449585468,
-0.0365884341,
-6.186742114e-33,
-0.0339198783,
-0.0315552913,
-0.0054731192,
0.0468953252,
0.0362502895,
-0.003487072,
-0.044279851,
0.0156159066,
-0.0271041486,
-0.029861331,
0.0257689878,
0.0350723304,
-0.0260751341,
0.0494510867,
0.0359862074,
-0.0108120283,
0.0220308676,
0.0194793288,
0.0175382514,
0.0778411105,
0.0213410594,
-0.000011874,
0.0557590276,
-0.060501352,
0.0423279926,
-0.0638510659,
0.0489969216,
-0.0223282576,
-0.0168538988,
0.0374883004,
-0.0290544536,
0.0658614114,
0.0192163512,
-0.0382005274,
-0.0235556141,
-0.0448146537,
-0.047846213,
-0.0911639556,
-0.0085945064,
-0.0237748083,
-0.0235444512,
-0.0507728495,
0.0599546246,
0.0146537274,
-0.0050465176,
-0.0230916589,
0.097708486,
0.0329033583,
0.0110879093,
-0.0289375149,
-0.031996768,
-0.015997719,
-0.0715705156,
-0.012070599,
-0.032385353,
0.0490976125,
0.0090762833,
0.0052244556,
-0.0079876464,
0.0120760379,
0.0377364717,
0.0487272963,
0.0532124937,
0.0059908172,
0.0016635021,
0.0450071618,
0.0592114702,
0.0052175024,
-0.0403470285,
0.0117156338,
0.0376251489,
0.0109686255,
0.0460732318,
0.0413502939,
0.0421291962,
0.0094180387,
-0.0836107731,
0.025905421,
0.0059994454,
-0.0055328044,
-0.0031857614,
-0.0064039985,
-0.0644373745,
-0.0368472375,
-0.0403320342,
-0.0126834391,
-0.0202376638,
-0.0557472445,
0.0433448292,
-0.0517830029,
-0.0195791386,
0.0097534154,
0.0262187384,
-0.0473215394,
-0.0046625151,
0.0027583721,
-0.0156235546,
0.0396179967,
0.0005045927,
0.0112749739,
-0.0487789735,
-0.0009799567,
0.0337700471,
-0.0683786646,
0.0589646623,
0.0602050014,
0.0107848495,
0.0212547164,
-0.0386292003,
-0.0443559103,
-0.0696462914,
-0.030378392,
0.0167332739,
0.0116857914,
0.0076080849,
0.0366668552,
-0.0054314644,
0.0369308293,
-0.0076537956,
-0.059226349,
-0.0403910242,
-0.0662663057,
0.0002168249,
-0.0221637283,
-0.0200859252,
-0.0389689431,
-0.0449191444,
0.0055400622,
-0.0011425667,
-0.0290479064,
-0.0156167913,
0.0391928777,
2.672e-7,
0.0338170081,
0.0212767702,
-0.0178641099,
0.0387295857,
-0.0125103435,
0.0319994763,
-0.0119959181,
0.0342413448,
0.0449922308,
-0.0235292818,
-0.0112310313,
0.0469461642,
-0.0068634027,
0.0260700248,
-0.0505729206,
0.0143102156,
0.0420309715,
-0.003796804,
-0.0444142744,
0.0602572933,
0.1450278759,
0.035772115,
0.025185626,
0.0238116626,
0.0393785574,
-0.0332858562,
0.0127811199,
-0.0244268999,
0.0136150122,
0.0125856046,
-0.042289637,
-0.0012052088,
0.0299411193,
0.0430698991,
0.0180805139,
-0.0526566394,
0.0150541328,
0.0393846519,
0.0028723311,
0.0164762661,
-0.0047797821,
-0.0099341273,
0.0181156285,
-0.0716714635,
0.0492839776,
-0.0555193424,
-0.008559972,
0.070173718,
-0.0301673934,
-0.0288766269,
-0.0176897179,
0.0099143358,
0.0322382376,
-0.0364764482,
-0.0131396353,
-0.0501642413,
-0.0058527305,
-0.0142653296,
-0.0141821085,
-0.0078869723,
-0.034000162,
-0.0378388055,
-0.049281422,
-0.0537991151,
0.0419088267,
-0.0037776362,
0.0091590378,
2.654158797e-34,
-0.0073198802,
-0.0146299647,
0.0213115886,
-0.0092137875,
0.0364851244,
-0.0204356015,
-0.0164414961,
0.0278927628,
0.0284022279,
-0.0539551005,
-0.044094678
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08209v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08209v1
|
Who's in and who's out? A case study of multimodal CLIP-filtering in DataComp
| 2024-05-13T21:53:06 | 2024-05-13T21:53:06 |
Rachel Hong, William Agnew, Tadayoshi Kohno, Jamie Morgenstern
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
As training datasets become increasingly drawn from unstructured,
uncontrolled environments such as the web, researchers and industry
practitioners have increasingly relied upon data filtering techniques to
"filter out the noise" of web-scraped data. While datasets have been widely
shown to reflect the biases and values of their creators, in this paper we
contribute to an emerging body of research that assesses the filters used to
create these datasets. We show that image-text data filtering also has biases
and is value-laden, encoding specific notions of what is counted as
"high-quality" data. In our work, we audit a standard approach of image-text
CLIP-filtering on the academic benchmark DataComp's CommonPool by analyzing
discrepancies of filtering through various annotation techniques across
multiple modalities of image, text, and website source. We find that data
relating to several imputed demographic groups -- such as LGBTQ+ people, older
women, and younger men -- are associated with higher rates of exclusion.
Moreover, we demonstrate cases of exclusion amplification: not only are certain
marginalized groups already underrepresented in the unfiltered data, but
CLIP-filtering excludes data from these groups at higher rates. The
data-filtering step in the machine learning pipeline can therefore exacerbate
representation disparities already present in the data-gathering step,
especially when existing filters are designed to optimize a specifically-chosen
downstream performance metric like zero-shot image classification accuracy.
Finally, we show that the NSFW filter fails to remove sexually-explicit content
from CommonPool, and that CLIP-filtering includes several categories of
copyrighted content at high rates. Our conclusions point to a need for
fundamental changes in dataset creation and filtering practices.
|
Who's in and who's out? A case study of multimodal CLIP-filtering in DataComp: As training datasets become increasingly drawn from unstructured,
uncontrolled environments such as the web, researchers and industry
practitioners have increasingly relied upon data filtering techniques to
"filter out the noise" of web-scraped data. While datasets have been widely
shown to reflect the biases and values of their creators, in this paper we
contribute to an emerging body of research that assesses the filters used to
create these datasets. We show that image-text data filtering also has biases
and is value-laden, encoding specific notions of what is counted as
"high-quality" data. In our work, we audit a standard approach of image-text
CLIP-filtering on the academic benchmark DataComp's CommonPool by analyzing
discrepancies of filtering through various annotation techniques across
multiple modalities of image, text, and website source. We find that data
relating to several imputed demographic groups -- such as LGBTQ+ people, older
women, and younger men -- are associated with higher rates of exclusion.
Moreover, we demonstrate cases of exclusion amplification: not only are certain
marginalized groups already underrepresented in the unfiltered data, but
CLIP-filtering excludes data from these groups at higher rates. The
data-filtering step in the machine learning pipeline can therefore exacerbate
representation disparities already present in the data-gathering step,
especially when existing filters are designed to optimize a specifically-chosen
downstream performance metric like zero-shot image classification accuracy.
Finally, we show that the NSFW filter fails to remove sexually-explicit content
from CommonPool, and that CLIP-filtering includes several categories of
copyrighted content at high rates. Our conclusions point to a need for
fundamental changes in dataset creation and filtering practices.
|
[
0.0367025323,
0.0934539214,
-0.0261805933,
-0.0074704071,
-0.0170072559,
0.0144878998,
0.0609709583,
0.0176516138,
-0.0042207208,
-0.0715518147,
-0.0006111523,
-0.0157973785,
0.0023347579,
0.0370280296,
-0.0083614057,
-0.0281930082,
0.0007231424,
0.0642865896,
0.0146730654,
-0.0084691318,
0.0018626667,
0.0077668466,
0.0295508672,
0.0544999391,
0.0028493921,
-0.0065877154,
0.0729586631,
0.0194898713,
-0.0106733041,
-0.0008893482,
0.0428359583,
0.0179369245,
-0.0122958161,
0.0238622688,
0.0000019145,
-0.0541736893,
-0.0025182154,
0.0381462984,
0.0291606206,
-0.0257758871,
0.0353388861,
0.0009926145,
-0.0030895961,
0.0206384379,
-0.0151526099,
0.050153777,
0.0464666039,
0.0011295695,
0.0753287375,
-0.0028012733,
-0.04744545,
0.0186124109,
-0.0678994209,
0.0015429389,
0.0316015705,
0.0322019905,
0.0403882638,
-0.0109444829,
0.0070472579,
-0.0288305487,
-0.0208629984,
0.0458842777,
-0.0071694935,
0.0379735902,
0.026374789,
0.0214870535,
-0.0407812297,
-0.097506538,
0.0442179032,
0.0497053713,
0.0042625847,
0.0280794092,
0.0145537294,
0.0006031105,
0.0180026013,
0.0268671736,
-0.0456855521,
0.0799651816,
-0.0254752766,
0.0372840762,
-0.0967667252,
0.0011410596,
0.0435882919,
0.0319541544,
0.0117920218,
0.0047419346,
0.0084343245,
-0.0128106372,
0.0071119005,
-0.0023469911,
0.0281428341,
-0.0101467967,
0.0681122988,
-0.0182798654,
0.0457331762,
-0.0096633397,
-0.0512351058,
-0.0191026349,
0.0404455513,
-0.0299487319,
0.0165187288,
0.0352010615,
-0.0221150536,
0.0539269522,
0.0075864368,
-0.0146465478,
0.0305141378,
0.0462500043,
0.0429532826,
0.0015447196,
0.013716761,
0.014986176,
0.0607650951,
0.0244201124,
-0.0100581991,
0.0288075153,
-0.0486431681,
0.0121883461,
-0.0696908608,
0.0206196737,
-0.0366909578,
0.0254148524,
-0.0216684397,
0.046339348,
-0.0346981883,
-0.0493059009,
-0.0092701726,
0.0371992178,
-0.0093114767,
-0.0571422689,
0.0230869576,
-0.0087966518,
0.0279823709,
-0.0375226103,
0.0544514321,
0.0647207722,
0.0171374734,
-0.0317389034,
-0.0307314415,
-0.0317609385,
-0.0139531726,
-0.0038347396,
0.0541084334,
-0.0205757469,
0.0295264423,
0.0026639216,
0.0054111886,
-0.0663775951,
-0.0266852025,
0.0429745018,
-0.0631095767,
0.0763015449,
0.0286951698,
-0.0152166309,
0.0372241326,
0.0400015339,
-0.0507348813,
0.0908664912,
0.0189585537,
0.0211536456,
0.0509221256,
-0.0163537059,
-0.0135227097,
0.0197919104,
0.0467995144,
0.0364772454,
-0.0835016519,
0.0126272971,
-0.010219085,
-0.0274635479,
0.0301056895,
0.0020649638,
-0.0305766482,
-0.0590890646,
0.0484328195,
0.0654905289,
-0.0124631822,
0.0554190949,
-0.020539457,
0.0144954147,
-0.0037629311,
-0.0130496994,
-0.0831894353,
-0.0051832655,
0.0267815888,
-0.0647755936,
0.0075365286,
0.0306812841,
-0.0249511488,
-0.0100894375,
0.0044039623,
0.0089286407,
0.0677403882,
0.0001780827,
0.0148870889,
0.0120734423,
0.0073360964,
-0.0286455452,
0.0242214091,
-0.0210389923,
0.0135399187,
-0.0510237366,
0.006586561,
0.0125554437,
0.0197358653,
-0.0432798788,
0.0305675622,
-0.0433783643,
0.0150320018,
-0.0254085083,
-0.0111763375,
0.0241353102,
-0.0006165964,
-0.039497219,
-0.067584455,
-0.0094911782,
-0.0071740793,
-0.0140361646,
0.028076537,
0.0125371441,
0.0143358205,
0.0187081825,
-0.0506110303,
0.0275220592,
0.0510095395,
0.017355239,
-0.0118350815,
0.0338216834,
0.0465929881,
0.00464478,
-0.0299929269,
-0.0209998917,
-0.0038390013,
0.0188595187,
-0.0105747627,
-0.0256591961,
0.0183131434,
0.0377605259,
0.0500945002,
-0.125513941,
-0.030847298,
0.0601847805,
-0.0121241705,
0.0448130779,
0.0223124046,
-0.0120824426,
-0.00894346,
-0.0188476406,
-0.0333281085,
-0.0083153779,
0.0356848761,
-0.0147052659,
0.0345390514,
-0.0156286526,
0.0179924741,
0.020906223,
-0.0384405144,
0.0205061659,
0.0085805636,
-0.0255921651,
0.0057186368,
-0.058421392,
0.0276481975,
0.0260496195,
-0.0192734562,
-0.0247943699,
0.0190457404,
-0.0044331332,
-0.0028977648,
0.0153646385,
-0.0180353858,
-0.0149216149,
-0.0240149386,
-0.0230677668,
-0.0402715802,
-0.0333733968,
-0.0661975145,
-0.0232897066,
0.0633146986,
0.0086879488,
-0.0185450055,
0.0320171751,
0.0136036137,
-0.0646226481,
-0.012897674,
0.0790502056,
0.0217801835,
-0.0245965309,
0.0637176409,
0.0120052146,
-0.0568227693,
-0.0078269383,
-0.0106854877,
0.0027194612,
0.0361605659,
0.0123400316,
-0.0574242957,
0.02779698,
0.0320045836,
0.0449472554,
0.0173181817,
0.0421431437,
-0.0058576451,
0.0000457243,
-0.0111559583,
0.0606796816,
0.0485575236,
-0.0407369919,
-0.0027237327,
-0.0298642088,
-0.012504586,
-0.0173093416,
-0.0571373254,
0.0962531045,
-0.0613363236,
-0.0417783372,
-0.0822156742,
-0.0002936845,
-0.0096635129,
0.0259516612,
-0.0549908951,
-0.0346810892,
0.0289050862,
0.0340030268,
0.0139849726,
0.0192816369,
-0.0110538183,
0.0097608576,
0.0063289753,
-0.0066563915,
0.0487354137,
-0.02011103,
-0.0202045236,
-0.0463843681,
0.007068966,
0.0616904497,
-0.0751436055,
0.0328781828,
0.0171978548,
-0.0179178994,
-0.0214438401,
-0.0576445647,
-0.0327133909,
-0.0632196069,
0.0222434904,
-0.0112538524,
0.0096422592,
0.003460591,
0.0020412854,
0.0102933012,
-0.0067301174,
0.0317141451,
-0.012484326,
-0.023718223,
0.0127183879,
-0.0012741029,
-0.0044499412,
-0.0177504215,
0.0014995077,
0.0092867259,
-0.0636582226,
0.0690961555,
0.0129960552,
-0.0194420926,
0.0239879098,
0.0553455837,
0.0188594107,
0.0087071182,
-0.0039342223,
-0.015224182,
0.0320935696,
-0.0171293262,
0.0338316523,
0.0201608557,
0.0066736862,
-0.0545759611,
-0.015894331,
0.0263587404,
-0.0232342463,
0.0427659899,
-0.0301709417,
-0.1103999913,
0.009683392,
0.0108783869,
0.0451966599,
-0.0739216954,
-0.0587749593,
-0.0201084297,
-0.0517204143,
0.0554984994,
0.0074248305,
-0.0437607579,
-0.0283662565,
-0.0557901636,
0.0422710963,
-0.0278385691,
-0.004890278,
-0.0493997,
-0.007758541,
0.0061709289,
0.0184427314,
-0.0277440846,
-0.0739957467,
-0.0078215394,
-0.0378868803,
-0.0040530763,
0.025565939,
0.0760876238,
-0.0478451401,
-0.0143916113,
0.0447545461,
-0.021623617,
-0.0221481882,
-0.0182934534,
0.0752295554,
-0.0467863418,
-0.027683951,
-0.0291671269,
0.0615862347,
0.0201519374,
-0.0116958311,
-0.0291102659,
0.0087891845,
-0.0195602644,
-0.014285245,
-0.0865470544,
0.0043759369,
-0.0085858805,
0.0716932192,
0.0418703295,
-0.0510159843,
0.0115129733,
-0.0644035786,
0.0169219151,
0.0108021796,
-0.0173011981,
0.0354272462,
-0.018413078,
-0.0489853062,
-0.0048537427,
-0.0355112627,
0.0153446803,
0.0128062591,
0.0181683991,
-0.0703494027,
-0.0164343081,
-0.0118650515,
-0.0478351302,
0.0151672736,
-0.0164298695,
0.0046412582,
0.02828403,
-0.0075940858,
-0.0567071773,
-0.0311035663,
-0.041523207,
0.0288331546,
-0.0320264921,
-0.0143090039,
0.0244725607,
0.05658672,
0.0294565577,
-0.0037589436,
0.0045351665,
-0.0320250504,
0.0522657447,
0.0935804099,
-0.0028469071,
-0.0289139152,
0.0501535311,
-0.0576212257,
-0.0104163308,
0.0032355839,
-0.0248160064,
0.021998113,
0.0088340119,
-0.0549107306,
-0.0118841855,
0.0281964336,
-0.0005048156,
0.0062342072,
0.0040917364,
-0.0297143683,
0.0040442739,
-0.0074817603,
-0.031865418,
0.0294896495,
-0.0175944101,
-0.0109073892,
-0.0090269754,
0.00291195,
0.0046476442,
-0.0663892329,
0.0485193245,
-0.0118634049,
0.0490307361,
-0.0858748183,
-0.0020539155,
0.0141002834,
-0.0216937661,
-0.0035106235,
0.0062041776,
0.0110733397,
0.0209855065,
-0.0009380847,
0.0158582628,
-0.00546129,
0.0352182835,
0.0379599556,
0.0431167558,
0.0065446687,
0.0135814138,
-0.0482385345,
-0.0023283451,
-0.007830821,
-0.0277844854,
0.003957808,
-0.0136299049,
-0.0201724004,
-0.0087187551,
-0.0415611044,
0.0034666746,
0.0055865091,
0.0120215733,
-0.0154187828,
0.0129792774,
-0.0148940301,
-0.0117208855,
-0.0077408124,
0.0426508784,
-0.0079766111,
0.0276319068,
-0.0202795826,
-0.0608365536,
-0.0143834203,
-0.015592414,
0.0260718893,
0.0466216579,
0.0029674179,
-0.0248816628,
-0.0646328852,
-0.0548344925,
-0.0344462208,
-0.0521074086,
0.0575248078,
0.0034135606,
-0.0165702365,
0.0378222726,
-0.0104338992,
-0.0245134849,
-0.0152308382,
-0.0286862459,
0.0000405319,
0.0133672832,
0.0309730042,
-6.297072544e-33,
0.0189439487,
-0.0021784792,
-0.0482718572,
0.0113605214,
-0.0147119537,
0.0070238132,
0.0156692695,
-0.0636652038,
0.0099164369,
-0.0221507996,
-0.0175844748,
0.0237737447,
-0.000498189,
0.0067607299,
0.0002836162,
-0.0336382538,
0.0593738891,
-0.0014960032,
-0.0509393215,
0.0076062772,
-0.0109682409,
0.0419379696,
-0.0149825597,
-0.0739651322,
0.0354940817,
0.0247202069,
-0.0447757207,
-0.0405826755,
0.0471376255,
0.0526328124,
-0.0223550461,
0.0478573889,
0.0358661003,
-0.053636916,
0.0083492016,
0.0365550444,
-0.0949535742,
0.0010052541,
-0.0074286866,
0.0377591178,
0.0234520826,
-0.0221776348,
0.0596407652,
-0.0013046619,
0.0063979905,
-0.0650435463,
0.0589252301,
-0.0460495763,
-0.0090062628,
-0.0331522562,
0.0260970555,
0.0149501143,
-0.0395571068,
0.0330973268,
0.0359278545,
0.0798489675,
0.0163189545,
0.054230921,
-0.060286738,
0.0248754323,
0.0153004201,
-0.0563915037,
0.0394359715,
0.0119365808,
0.0492393002,
0.0677885488,
0.0236143041,
0.0247533694,
-0.0149009945,
-0.0807916671,
0.0603644773,
0.0189368725,
-0.0430595912,
0.0413508192,
0.0791788325,
-0.0660396591,
-0.0433106832,
0.0034855702,
-0.0324305259,
-0.0141273858,
0.0211251862,
-0.0083432011,
-0.0221051611,
-0.0105495974,
-0.0197343808,
-0.0726936683,
-0.0311029386,
-0.0254070647,
0.0207175277,
-0.0190031473,
-0.0736933947,
0.0963347107,
-0.0128105097,
-0.0531690046,
-0.0650983602,
-0.0100842435,
-0.0329779834,
-0.0193364322,
0.0261990204,
-0.0390686207,
-0.0393044353,
0.0064064628,
0.0334942639,
-0.0199062899,
0.0540518984,
-0.0096024144,
0.0462282151,
0.0517069213,
-0.0480116308,
-0.0231300686,
-0.0337581784,
0.0486742593,
0.0280865096,
0.0460909195,
0.0339963026,
0.0382935964,
-0.0001202659,
-0.0022066692,
0.0575964786,
0.0763739049,
-0.02683191,
-0.0327197947,
-0.0175852664,
0.0082576275,
-0.0047707115,
-0.0587062985,
-0.0026720958,
0.0265532676,
0.0675439313,
-0.0860313028,
-0.0196405649,
-0.0427809134,
2.652e-7,
0.0269042049,
0.0002853745,
0.0009646064,
-0.0107298391,
0.0177010838,
0.0282122213,
0.0099865543,
0.0426204652,
0.035829667,
-0.0185335055,
-0.0160479918,
0.0349852033,
0.0209618639,
0.0477545038,
0.0008759514,
-0.0537695959,
-0.0414017662,
-0.0151254404,
-0.0268640537,
0.039698761,
0.0069792815,
0.069874458,
0.0480618551,
-0.0599131994,
0.0135436263,
-0.0275554489,
0.0236419402,
-0.038859617,
0.0203692615,
-0.0348004773,
0.0375479721,
0.0446579494,
0.0115586426,
0.0211162437,
-0.0421342775,
-0.0013528162,
0.0489748642,
0.0235451311,
-0.0033998045,
0.0509967692,
-0.0048542744,
0.0050090291,
-0.0000340677,
-0.0359767787,
0.0956103653,
0.0077007422,
-0.0219964366,
-0.0584618375,
-0.0632041544,
-0.0491753742,
0.074268654,
-0.0158703495,
-0.0090145115,
-0.0079538124,
-0.0082456125,
0.0048321243,
-0.0123803932,
-0.090171814,
0.0004398068,
-0.0248629805,
-0.012719878,
-0.0295646209,
-0.0028027107,
0.0235036425,
0.0396023244,
-0.0150812045,
-0.0014586234,
2.409668829e-34,
0.0130826002,
-0.0059960452,
0.0296615995,
-0.0472738184,
-0.0161036607,
0.0047782375,
0.0355100073,
-0.0226003192,
-0.0178088844,
0.055682689,
0.0141896643
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08172v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08172v1
|
CANTONMT: Investigating Back-Translation and Model-Switch Mechanisms for Cantonese-English Neural Machine Translation
| 2024-05-13T20:37:04 | 2024-05-13T20:37:04 |
Kung Yin Hong, Lifeng Han, Riza Batista-Navarro, Goran Nenadic
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper investigates the development and evaluation of machine translation
models from Cantonese to English, where we propose a novel approach to tackle
low-resource language translations. The main objectives of the study are to
develop a model that can effectively translate Cantonese to English and
evaluate it against state-of-the-art commercial models. To achieve this, a new
parallel corpus has been created by combining different available corpora
online with preprocessing and cleaning. In addition, a monolingual Cantonese
dataset has been created through web scraping to aid the synthetic parallel
corpus generation. Following the data collection process, several approaches,
including fine-tuning models, back-translation, and model switch, have been
used. The translation quality of models has been evaluated with multiple
quality metrics, including lexicon-based metrics (SacreBLEU and hLEPOR) and
embedding-space metrics (COMET and BERTscore). Based on the automatic metrics,
the best model is selected and compared against the 2 best commercial
translators using the human evaluation framework HOPES. The best model proposed
in this investigation (NLLB-mBART) with model switch mechanisms has reached
comparable and even better automatic evaluation scores against State-of-the-art
commercial models (Bing and Baidu Translators), with a SacreBLEU score of 16.8
on our test set. Furthermore, an open-source web application has been developed
to allow users to translate between Cantonese and English, with the different
trained models available for effective comparisons between models from this
investigation and users. CANTONMT is available at
https://github.com/kenrickkung/CantoneseTranslation
|
CANTONMT: Investigating Back-Translation and Model-Switch Mechanisms for Cantonese-English Neural Machine Translation: This paper investigates the development and evaluation of machine translation
models from Cantonese to English, where we propose a novel approach to tackle
low-resource language translations. The main objectives of the study are to
develop a model that can effectively translate Cantonese to English and
evaluate it against state-of-the-art commercial models. To achieve this, a new
parallel corpus has been created by combining different available corpora
online with preprocessing and cleaning. In addition, a monolingual Cantonese
dataset has been created through web scraping to aid the synthetic parallel
corpus generation. Following the data collection process, several approaches,
including fine-tuning models, back-translation, and model switch, have been
used. The translation quality of models has been evaluated with multiple
quality metrics, including lexicon-based metrics (SacreBLEU and hLEPOR) and
embedding-space metrics (COMET and BERTscore). Based on the automatic metrics,
the best model is selected and compared against the 2 best commercial
translators using the human evaluation framework HOPES. The best model proposed
in this investigation (NLLB-mBART) with model switch mechanisms has reached
comparable and even better automatic evaluation scores against State-of-the-art
commercial models (Bing and Baidu Translators), with a SacreBLEU score of 16.8
on our test set. Furthermore, an open-source web application has been developed
to allow users to translate between Cantonese and English, with the different
trained models available for effective comparisons between models from this
investigation and users. CANTONMT is available at
https://github.com/kenrickkung/CantoneseTranslation
|
[
0.0358783267,
0.024312567,
-0.0179865416,
0.0560797602,
-0.0529225729,
0.0087538296,
0.0265095532,
-0.0111504206,
-0.0200940948,
0.0041093621,
-0.0564400069,
-0.0557432324,
0.0395184644,
-0.0258637052,
0.024171764,
-0.0326788649,
0.029220039,
0.0339515097,
-0.0122230547,
0.0073201666,
-0.0137656042,
-0.0030854873,
0.0235909987,
0.0511061884,
0.0166478585,
-0.0222327132,
0.0351670086,
0.078163676,
0.0547793694,
-0.0285655633,
-0.002638309,
0.0235139839,
-0.0247871056,
0.0564654134,
0.0000022763,
-0.0270510316,
-0.0274423305,
0.0346052386,
0.0259670299,
0.0456243157,
0.0418432988,
-0.0360367522,
-0.0061868196,
0.0503883846,
-0.0027526629,
-0.0045402404,
0.0719599128,
0.0399998017,
0.0545329861,
0.0901457742,
-0.0240857005,
-0.057243593,
-0.0014009665,
-0.0613565706,
-0.0528872423,
-0.0471008494,
-0.0140808793,
0.0068418342,
-0.0384557359,
-0.0237570759,
-0.0323876143,
0.0456889272,
-0.0035831106,
0.0041809366,
-0.0140095055,
0.0036752457,
-0.0298842862,
-0.0317275748,
-0.0056286724,
0.0943809003,
-0.0817982554,
-0.0062971623,
-0.0297709312,
-0.0177945625,
0.004414585,
-0.0009311248,
-0.0224683974,
0.0238023158,
0.0217336752,
0.0219314955,
-0.0130818635,
0.0073432652,
0.0491166376,
-0.0028896718,
-0.0247520115,
-0.0525705144,
0.0283396319,
-0.0377523266,
-0.0146932071,
-0.0097280927,
0.008929587,
0.0072553074,
0.0511051081,
-0.012102819,
0.0174055863,
0.0280597117,
0.0110134725,
-0.0300522335,
-0.0049369722,
-0.0962000638,
0.0357374996,
0.0748948604,
-0.0336107537,
0.021498682,
-0.0172064491,
0.0564753488,
-0.0316710696,
0.0082807625,
-0.0833421052,
-0.006691989,
-0.0349931978,
0.0291897058,
-0.067280516,
-0.0046081403,
-0.0488168113,
-0.0420651324,
-0.0104028443,
-0.0149019808,
0.0213651955,
-0.0292000063,
0.0482096784,
-0.0406943001,
-0.0512645394,
0.0173748843,
0.002442518,
0.0418091193,
0.0002751451,
-0.0154388351,
-0.0180566926,
-0.0561060235,
-0.014771143,
0.0086470759,
-0.0364421234,
-0.0339754932,
-0.01341243,
0.0826437175,
-0.0277654286,
-0.0165408999,
-0.0371307544,
0.0408914872,
-0.0248961262,
-0.052518975,
-0.00681881,
-0.0475498103,
0.0402549468,
-0.0092717269,
0.0521474667,
-0.0234085005,
0.0018096952,
-0.0130308419,
-0.0075693601,
0.0322681889,
-0.0139397308,
0.0058283014,
0.0294108801,
-0.0071514649,
-0.0213491414,
0.0877445266,
0.0587864518,
0.0295993518,
0.0268020704,
-0.0304511059,
-0.0381898172,
0.017875012,
-0.0136212409,
0.0201621465,
-0.0800366551,
-0.0049881293,
-0.0136157367,
0.0497058257,
-0.0209790356,
0.0650888234,
-0.0348372795,
0.021260161,
0.043454919,
0.0134437233,
0.0414786674,
0.0681712553,
0.0469073914,
-0.0061305342,
0.0100809587,
-0.0143765137,
-0.0158751458,
0.0368894003,
0.0010199709,
0.0032328032,
0.0060450071,
0.0431929678,
-0.0224320032,
-0.0498699769,
-0.0298179854,
-0.0129842218,
0.0173398163,
-0.0337069631,
0.0139898853,
-0.0092049753,
-0.046572037,
0.0461182036,
-0.0259068161,
-0.0241268612,
0.0261249002,
-0.0311759617,
-0.0518752113,
0.1090172976,
0.0229788851,
0.0423386507,
-0.0408869423,
-0.0303808916,
-0.0586413518,
0.0564151891,
0.06734211,
0.0209317878,
0.0133804278,
-0.0671145841,
0.0047670705,
0.0312761739,
0.00232814,
0.0215903725,
-0.0004386609,
0.0515785776,
0.0399618037,
-0.0344090685,
-0.0831644014,
0.0296430998,
-0.0291749891,
-0.0024322583,
0.0376464799,
0.0164357498,
0.0490852222,
0.0119164484,
-0.0205571689,
0.015299648,
0.0202702489,
-0.0250999592,
-0.0346673653,
0.053241387,
-0.0054261899,
-0.041890081,
0.0308165196,
-0.0492231138,
0.0111591844,
0.0494590066,
-0.0587051325,
-0.0594240427,
-0.0428312868,
-0.0110487714,
0.0329355337,
-0.079771623,
0.0417319313,
-0.0272461902,
-0.0102670994,
-0.0175678413,
0.0486821234,
-0.0084028514,
0.0087166978,
0.0036057765,
0.0066789552,
0.0425322689,
-0.0577415712,
-0.0586699359,
0.0384435393,
0.0186885577,
0.0608353913,
0.0116795991,
0.0196314435,
-0.0104604652,
-0.0220167413,
-0.0645275712,
0.0136821289,
-0.029109126,
-0.0037140006,
0.0400865786,
0.0150702018,
-0.0003344225,
-0.0062549296,
-0.0094085196,
0.0303928349,
-0.0574401692,
0.0199862011,
-0.0029047325,
-0.0151767693,
0.031906914,
-0.0311428588,
-0.0152281607,
0.0380041637,
0.0256649777,
-0.0056465394,
-0.009784448,
-0.0709588379,
0.0010354789,
-0.0028304583,
-0.0259029437,
0.0054766815,
-0.0922880098,
-0.0013153021,
-0.0207848977,
0.0163478963,
0.0291138887,
0.019671252,
-0.0019055847,
0.0176948514,
0.0313857868,
-0.0376091264,
0.0078231618,
-0.0125011886,
-0.0344862752,
-0.0376529098,
-0.0428384654,
-0.0156472083,
0.0540171191,
0.0364495888,
-0.0003963751,
-0.1026071683,
-0.0730569735,
-0.0337973125,
-0.0115765659,
0.0010215415,
0.0446419269,
-0.0146019915,
0.0064287307,
-0.0265269037,
-0.0338547528,
0.0510037504,
-0.0281761866,
0.0123142479,
-0.0795589611,
0.017118115,
-0.0218254048,
0.0193502549,
-0.0532453954,
0.0292282272,
-0.0297330935,
-0.0209002942,
-0.014334416,
0.0166597851,
-0.0023501525,
-0.0332454592,
0.0063317735,
-0.0233469326,
-0.0151703581,
-0.027131388,
0.0014800302,
-0.0146255186,
-0.0461309142,
-0.0043517342,
0.0072671603,
0.0341326334,
-0.0186559204,
-0.0226183869,
0.0638084561,
-0.0351439975,
0.0430165716,
-0.0183525849,
0.0480913967,
-0.0012025636,
-0.0039577894,
-0.0179981831,
-0.0008856782,
0.0248717293,
-0.0304508824,
0.0553539284,
-0.0084840646,
-0.007887111,
0.0211615004,
-0.0282428339,
-0.0159316473,
0.0289022271,
-0.0167921707,
-0.0520372242,
-0.0122994194,
0.0529484525,
-0.0366675779,
-0.0058776638,
0.1104998738,
0.0141810579,
-0.0480549596,
-0.0030200602,
0.0130803939,
0.0003866042,
0.0073546176,
-0.0062197456,
-0.03704172,
0.0009444148,
0.0027138514,
0.0336135104,
0.0585325398,
0.0394941159,
-0.0063292114,
-0.1173404381,
0.0415426977,
0.0540413447,
-0.0703919679,
-0.0316784531,
-0.0130317006,
-0.0303159896,
-0.0524721742,
0.0531063601,
-0.0067968466,
0.0173441339,
-0.0140226958,
0.0083066532,
0.0576638505,
-0.0683550313,
-0.0037138741,
-0.0560376719,
0.0284217,
0.0542780645,
0.0585697852,
-0.020294087,
-0.0112996241,
0.0196783133,
-0.0402436219,
0.0006793071,
-0.0004303881,
0.0209845435,
0.0035719858,
-0.022499904,
0.0271930154,
-0.0122385425,
0.0040595043,
0.0367932282,
0.0003583058,
0.0256949794,
0.0037303055,
0.0034144337,
0.0192372017,
-0.0026269043,
-0.0100316787,
0.0760031864,
0.0284195393,
-0.0489630923,
0.0040459875,
0.0236632936,
-0.0344341137,
-0.0560545176,
0.0135359261,
0.0557088368,
-0.0685706139,
-0.0559760369,
-0.0985176489,
-0.0372921079,
-0.0226311721,
0.0194269959,
0.0430968963,
0.0078300145,
0.0209248383,
0.0229551997,
-0.019747382,
0.0270317756,
0.0240873042,
0.0219139922,
-0.0581025593,
0.0065534227,
0.0565868281,
-0.0252385251,
0.0259066429,
0.0015894091,
-0.0408687107,
-0.0530916415,
-0.0174032953,
0.0391195565,
0.0109085869,
0.0162916537,
-0.056280572,
-0.0088440357,
-0.0044570756,
-0.0092717241,
-0.0188107118,
-0.029455319,
0.0277946591,
-0.0106964894,
-0.0283711478,
0.0253566206,
-0.0201828964,
0.0046341857,
-0.0041080783,
0.0708427206,
-0.0039437017,
-0.0396568701,
0.0206465237,
0.0145030143,
0.0307365768,
-0.0601750389,
-0.0364571996,
-0.0314306021,
0.0465973169,
-0.0044718185,
-0.0204272904,
-0.0465058088,
-0.035353452,
0.1101852953,
0.0015255312,
-0.0072461511,
-0.0083913729,
0.0009708314,
-0.0434207767,
0.016859347,
0.0105581982,
-0.0399874114,
0.068439953,
0.020046534,
0.0377431065,
-0.0431741439,
-0.0193736963,
-0.0142522696,
-0.0095512783,
-0.0184603445,
0.0458022244,
0.032423038,
0.0528103635,
0.0146295959,
0.0505057424,
-0.0181727186,
-0.035181459,
-0.0331900753,
-0.0055467435,
0.0746577457,
-0.0001965429,
0.1078328341,
-0.0022299085,
-0.0104115643,
-0.0312800333,
0.0197993722,
0.0086884666,
0.0234404672,
-0.0090159904,
-0.0176714454,
-0.0172963496,
-0.0021871035,
0.0580977388,
-0.0023658159,
0.0080621438,
0.0059210621,
0.001129205,
-0.0132952277,
0.0006459565,
0.0047426517,
0.005194461,
-0.0229634307,
-0.0283541661,
-0.0356423259,
-0.0542416275,
-0.0079731196,
0.0075770435,
0.019632576,
0.0210220739,
-0.0112535786,
0.0743884817,
-0.0038556133,
0.0184301604,
-0.0680711046,
-0.0081335828,
0.004918227,
0.0082999635,
-0.039642401,
-6.431412447e-33,
-0.0318809971,
0.0133552412,
0.0046212585,
-0.0331663974,
-0.0453585982,
-0.0370135568,
-0.0408624075,
-0.033131361,
-0.0248131324,
-0.0100307856,
0.0092761926,
0.0177130271,
0.0312870294,
0.0150075322,
0.0208798759,
0.0232912749,
0.0532916039,
0.0001880292,
-0.0312959515,
-0.001938485,
0.0373787172,
0.0519145727,
0.0535785146,
-0.0383911803,
0.001276831,
-0.0205664448,
-0.0164118931,
0.0254683625,
-0.0227239933,
0.031374611,
0.0100149121,
0.0117483241,
0.0200123265,
-0.0151864635,
-0.0256258529,
-0.038071014,
-0.109174639,
0.0025602602,
0.0374168083,
0.0402001441,
0.0124146799,
-0.0205171574,
0.047125008,
-0.0293402318,
0.0113093928,
-0.0205374658,
0.0087917252,
-0.0641373396,
-0.0214933902,
0.0222857613,
-0.0495777801,
0.0285485517,
-0.0121658212,
-0.0219676644,
0.0188019834,
0.0526575446,
-0.052064795,
-0.0008815382,
-0.0813595578,
-0.0146251721,
-0.0025492383,
0.0325821713,
0.0495849773,
0.0386279039,
0.0130243478,
-0.0209275279,
0.0501490645,
-0.0112710288,
0.0645473525,
0.0101356423,
0.0581024066,
0.0529401116,
0.068727538,
0.0232417472,
0.0559613109,
-0.0509325825,
-0.0547511205,
0.0175129287,
-0.0151983658,
-0.002954667,
0.0314162821,
0.0397156663,
-0.0256264247,
-0.0103947623,
-0.0212088581,
-0.0687351599,
-0.0083593642,
-0.0544524826,
0.0288028102,
0.027209308,
-0.0331693664,
-0.0138276126,
0.0671770424,
-0.0325680934,
0.0512277745,
-0.0130428867,
-0.0095534641,
0.0106095271,
-0.0265764501,
0.0602628514,
-0.0532191619,
-0.0437809154,
0.0056593767,
0.0223826617,
-0.0126001537,
-0.0146994833,
0.032222975,
0.0267515648,
-0.0225776248,
0.023827957,
-0.0349531136,
-0.0485626757,
0.0018157372,
0.0381858796,
-0.0164022185,
-0.0159562398,
0.0028810173,
0.0417058542,
0.0192485284,
0.0263332725,
-0.0320711434,
-0.0135343745,
0.0374227539,
0.0162129141,
-0.0432400145,
0.0221185815,
-0.0115764765,
0.0401199833,
0.0605647378,
-0.0481454246,
-0.0273534395,
0.0445814133,
2.973e-7,
0.0638445616,
-0.0037717042,
0.0323557928,
0.0029725451,
-0.0044541755,
-0.0075719464,
-0.0586053021,
0.026479926,
0.0189721789,
0.0829700902,
0.0583876893,
0.0250918157,
0.1092391089,
0.0249859933,
-0.0799690187,
-0.0149941994,
-0.0433524214,
0.0154883126,
-0.0176902618,
0.0182023235,
0.0268410929,
0.086620912,
-0.0069834315,
0.0205776487,
-0.0023714895,
-0.0182637889,
0.0596194826,
-0.0158115756,
-0.0049744253,
0.018367881,
0.0239774585,
0.0502607152,
-0.043916963,
-0.0276442524,
-0.0399105214,
0.0347412899,
0.0471475683,
0.0813934952,
-0.0182419047,
-0.0507947579,
0.0132630514,
-0.0033626729,
-0.001078354,
-0.0402496867,
0.0399332829,
-0.0077246963,
-0.0066088503,
0.0378791913,
-0.0024521872,
0.0199800897,
0.0443363041,
-0.0611182377,
-0.0343926623,
0.023231009,
0.0441432483,
-0.0044609727,
-0.0231760852,
-0.0337650329,
-0.0363076963,
0.0110661983,
-0.0250681341,
-0.0517600551,
0.0014733477,
-0.0228656698,
0.0046431269,
-0.012592827,
0.0009088835,
2.072063407e-34,
0.0357099846,
-0.0296832155,
0.0075606508,
0.0314689502,
0.0175431315,
-0.0417691208,
-0.0292749088,
-0.0070941062,
-0.0417966768,
-0.0440605581,
-0.036980778
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08151v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08151v2
|
Benchmarking Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models in Biomedical NLP: Application, Robustness, and Self-Awareness
| 2024-05-13T19:51:20 | 2024-05-16T13:53:26 |
Mingchen Li, Zaifu Zhan, Han Yang, Yongkang Xiao, Jiatan Huang, Rui Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLM) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities in
various biomedical natural language processing (NLP) tasks, leveraging the
demonstration within the input context to adapt to new tasks. However, LLM is
sensitive to the selection of demonstrations. To address the hallucination
issue inherent in LLM, retrieval-augmented LLM (RAL) offers a solution by
retrieving pertinent information from an established database. Nonetheless,
existing research work lacks rigorous evaluation of the impact of
retrieval-augmented large language models on different biomedical NLP tasks.
This deficiency makes it challenging to ascertain the capabilities of RAL
within the biomedical domain. Moreover, the outputs from RAL are affected by
retrieving the unlabeled, counterfactual, or diverse knowledge that is not well
studied in the biomedical domain. However, such knowledge is common in the real
world. Finally, exploring the self-awareness ability is also crucial for the
RAL system. So, in this paper, we systematically investigate the impact of RALs
on 5 different biomedical tasks (triple extraction, link prediction,
classification, question answering, and natural language inference). We analyze
the performance of RALs in four fundamental abilities, including unlabeled
robustness, counterfactual robustness, diverse robustness, and negative
awareness. To this end, we proposed an evaluation framework to assess the RALs'
performance on different biomedical NLP tasks and establish four different
testbeds based on the aforementioned fundamental abilities. Then, we evaluate 3
representative LLMs with 3 different retrievers on 5 tasks over 9 datasets.
|
Benchmarking Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models in Biomedical NLP: Application, Robustness, and Self-Awareness: Large language models (LLM) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities in
various biomedical natural language processing (NLP) tasks, leveraging the
demonstration within the input context to adapt to new tasks. However, LLM is
sensitive to the selection of demonstrations. To address the hallucination
issue inherent in LLM, retrieval-augmented LLM (RAL) offers a solution by
retrieving pertinent information from an established database. Nonetheless,
existing research work lacks rigorous evaluation of the impact of
retrieval-augmented large language models on different biomedical NLP tasks.
This deficiency makes it challenging to ascertain the capabilities of RAL
within the biomedical domain. Moreover, the outputs from RAL are affected by
retrieving the unlabeled, counterfactual, or diverse knowledge that is not well
studied in the biomedical domain. However, such knowledge is common in the real
world. Finally, exploring the self-awareness ability is also crucial for the
RAL system. So, in this paper, we systematically investigate the impact of RALs
on 5 different biomedical tasks (triple extraction, link prediction,
classification, question answering, and natural language inference). We analyze
the performance of RALs in four fundamental abilities, including unlabeled
robustness, counterfactual robustness, diverse robustness, and negative
awareness. To this end, we proposed an evaluation framework to assess the RALs'
performance on different biomedical NLP tasks and establish four different
testbeds based on the aforementioned fundamental abilities. Then, we evaluate 3
representative LLMs with 3 different retrievers on 5 tasks over 9 datasets.
|
[
0.0869847536,
0.0189470407,
0.0148328803,
0.0066778068,
-0.0332487673,
0.0256207939,
-0.0198473167,
0.0167070292,
0.0627517551,
-0.0430566967,
-0.0388112068,
-0.0172258727,
-0.0379933119,
0.0044383504,
0.0131410314,
0.0079003116,
0.0389029421,
-0.0068848045,
0.0232505854,
0.0058013666,
-0.0128135122,
-0.0065188385,
-0.0045421347,
0.0183144249,
0.0414315797,
0.0053385859,
0.0548864193,
-0.0170966443,
-0.0054464135,
-0.0590687916,
-0.0128106354,
0.0349649861,
0.0078479061,
-0.0039239014,
0.0000016589,
-0.0837222263,
-0.0310455486,
0.0340221524,
-0.0413473137,
-0.0270784758,
0.0319797248,
-0.0110813584,
0.0287875589,
0.0010653329,
-0.0446112044,
-0.0260965712,
0.0088201212,
0.0806849003,
0.0263688099,
0.0587255098,
-0.0026744194,
-0.0280507784,
0.0409899279,
-0.0175513607,
0.0231973529,
-0.0286449231,
0.0808075592,
-0.0018309924,
0.0506888255,
0.0317298211,
0.0213286709,
0.0626660213,
-0.0251493249,
0.0475860648,
0.023153061,
0.0260190871,
-0.0653382093,
-0.0220756382,
-0.0040765121,
0.0565572754,
0.0024317761,
-0.0241418276,
0.019816244,
0.0192313753,
-0.0101954956,
0.033053603,
-0.0469700508,
0.0019085679,
-0.02306577,
-0.0017481979,
-0.0125174988,
0.0038490479,
0.0543769039,
0.0225227717,
-0.020777395,
0.0554685369,
0.0177749544,
-0.0422842614,
0.0289655942,
0.0089505482,
-0.0173741523,
0.0065594069,
0.0405154862,
0.0359365679,
-0.0109237321,
0.0342021696,
0.0385880917,
-0.040048901,
0.0775946826,
-0.0833188742,
-0.0058083208,
-0.0147645716,
-0.0449072793,
0.0618834645,
-0.0588753186,
0.0010556988,
-0.0713866577,
0.0433851741,
-0.0254102256,
-0.0120065957,
-0.0383516885,
-0.0400779061,
0.0014522038,
0.086652264,
-0.0332635678,
-0.0097619528,
-0.0708145425,
0.0030576258,
-0.0203767288,
-0.0181941558,
0.0034208235,
0.0663189292,
-0.0126250945,
-0.0235648286,
-0.0455700867,
0.0273972545,
0.0166716948,
-0.000930344,
-0.0245551579,
-0.0889139548,
-0.0274815112,
-0.0107894326,
0.0307768844,
-0.0648786426,
0.0433253422,
0.0998402759,
0.0380059667,
-0.0584847368,
0.0015060205,
-0.0181568749,
-0.0407172255,
-0.065077737,
0.0102997432,
-0.0500014685,
0.0298461411,
0.0340364687,
-0.010963669,
-0.054581441,
0.0348578319,
0.0095689418,
-0.0501788296,
0.0850628018,
0.0056213271,
-0.0137778185,
0.0113038169,
0.0063491645,
0.0041544628,
0.0330013223,
-0.0061163874,
-0.0366303101,
0.0275534932,
0.0041197557,
0.0163211878,
-0.0187654477,
0.0308331326,
-0.0600426793,
-0.0313663818,
0.0497278497,
0.0141431736,
0.0578251965,
-0.0393797234,
0.0788013339,
0.005046349,
-0.0292920265,
0.0195701867,
0.075235188,
0.0270505827,
-0.0071426351,
0.0117231822,
-0.01537799,
0.0225903988,
-0.018637022,
-0.0393837951,
0.0013287222,
-0.048717957,
0.0350000486,
-0.0001801662,
0.0205274243,
-0.0027023556,
-0.0252886992,
-0.0575024337,
-0.0021363925,
-0.0158506893,
0.0089303805,
0.0898441821,
-0.0031006378,
-0.0372947752,
0.0269559622,
0.0585207306,
-0.0247849543,
0.0260936636,
-0.0462441035,
-0.0082327249,
0.0223518033,
0.0512589701,
-0.049079217,
-0.0083065126,
-0.0151537918,
-0.0136513775,
-0.0100459345,
0.027535893,
0.0027785006,
0.0174527373,
-0.0107332757,
-0.0052761305,
0.0223822501,
0.0088312989,
-0.0348922424,
0.0358512998,
0.0161609333,
-0.0102552194,
-0.0249298178,
0.0014060891,
0.0487502478,
-0.0533756576,
-0.0293135904,
-0.0011499602,
-0.0105831185,
0.0236040317,
0.0209531467,
-0.0295086931,
0.0444782004,
0.0709339008,
-0.0493996255,
-0.0527730882,
-0.0192185622,
-0.0242469423,
-0.0405798554,
0.0178086292,
0.0241799094,
-0.0195034444,
0.0102367764,
0.0042333342,
-0.0168077461,
0.0153046204,
-0.013010107,
0.0216422565,
-0.030478349,
0.0180984084,
0.0121724699,
0.010833743,
-0.081851691,
0.0548214018,
0.0001290663,
0.0224545579,
-0.0126997633,
-0.0396641716,
-0.0058400175,
-0.0473390222,
-0.0574870072,
0.0078062187,
-0.0107515836,
0.0058742361,
0.0148551697,
-0.0383673199,
-0.0462262444,
-0.0206869859,
-0.061275091,
0.0264572743,
0.0041280161,
0.0149534326,
-0.0048071188,
0.0217961874,
0.0032748745,
-0.0262656379,
-0.0118262162,
-0.030503314,
0.0369669981,
0.028920291,
0.0376949236,
0.0483089015,
0.0216237716,
-0.0373730697,
-0.0121685583,
-0.019849943,
0.0671680495,
-0.0047600847,
-0.0484373756,
0.0111016035,
-0.0032298435,
-0.0440210439,
0.0190167408,
0.0093839876,
0.0101767341,
-0.010479738,
-0.0254298709,
-0.0038410211,
0.0618672855,
0.0008175622,
0.0245582536,
0.0342796333,
0.0271934103,
-0.0262885094,
0.0203008708,
-0.0762012154,
-0.0354258306,
-0.0061716749,
0.0188625697,
0.0091225384,
0.0340245552,
0.0271859821,
-0.0207202379,
-0.0219547246,
-0.0026126727,
-0.0183746722,
-0.0022854339,
-0.0509964563,
0.0263912957,
-0.0452868678,
0.0200527441,
-0.0189562347,
-0.0491097569,
0.1031985879,
0.0187358558,
0.0067219445,
-0.0413163342,
-0.0119417766,
-0.0361534022,
0.063112326,
-0.0073468364,
0.0297271386,
-0.0102202948,
-0.0139372079,
0.0157079715,
-0.0040361024,
-0.0249258075,
-0.0816739649,
0.0622900836,
-0.028641535,
0.0406208038,
0.0228311513,
-0.0411603637,
-0.0456435084,
-0.0001031399,
-0.042951826,
0.00959202,
-0.0153353186,
0.0180138275,
-0.0551875532,
0.0145449862,
0.0455179885,
0.0331733078,
-0.0209664498,
-0.0215197802,
0.0001177487,
0.0028710205,
0.0536026321,
0.0013350225,
0.0453542434,
0.0182217192,
0.0180829894,
0.0811917111,
-0.0009815622,
0.0074653034,
0.0125454012,
0.0194736421,
0.0195292775,
-0.0454119816,
0.0264910273,
0.0266434345,
0.0171115845,
-0.0596193857,
-0.026720779,
0.0914745033,
0.0356852449,
-0.0466197394,
-0.0044553382,
0.0026125656,
-0.0272963513,
0.0182062164,
0.0156266484,
-0.0394697711,
-0.0310633369,
-0.0413765237,
0.0132491319,
-0.0283116214,
-0.0543230921,
0.0199678708,
-0.1061604619,
0.0238980707,
-0.0165318046,
-0.0399958603,
-0.0508290492,
-0.0697413534,
0.0206883103,
-0.0204561558,
0.0155823817,
0.0285299942,
-0.0483892784,
-0.0122482553,
0.0279831588,
-0.0307064708,
-0.1035858318,
0.0189961251,
-0.0520293675,
0.0392667651,
0.0644849911,
0.0105021102,
-0.0179570541,
0.0142129287,
0.0235259794,
-0.0304583106,
-0.0058414652,
-0.02063323,
0.054118786,
0.01017089,
-0.0090227658,
-0.0612302274,
0.0084129833,
-0.0329573527,
-0.015415879,
-0.0440448597,
0.0829558745,
-0.0192654915,
-0.0128072677,
-0.0443383083,
-0.0117135551,
-0.0285328086,
0.091987744,
-0.0098767402,
-0.0169552416,
-0.0369988568,
0.0424897075,
0.033535704,
0.003835086,
-0.0501492135,
0.0310936812,
-0.0227574259,
0.0197984055,
-0.0400492325,
-0.0198423173,
0.0108637279,
0.0163089428,
0.0040282588,
0.1037060842,
0.0139803141,
0.00352537,
-0.0598840043,
0.0580940098,
0.0062711276,
-0.011874225,
-0.0153438672,
-0.0018214495,
0.0771499649,
-0.0249463525,
-0.0252911523,
0.0189312138,
-0.0283564683,
-0.0490483977,
-0.0033736713,
0.0348675512,
0.0226323884,
0.0077999444,
-0.0050454759,
-0.0531919599,
0.0198252294,
0.053304866,
-0.0357101895,
-0.0038948213,
-0.0210826807,
0.0298219193,
-0.0090113478,
0.0392852314,
-0.0391033515,
0.0022242197,
0.0154044172,
0.0494763628,
0.0138384476,
-0.0277522132,
0.0478478707,
0.0437879041,
0.071614109,
0.010588007,
0.0050816755,
-0.0083059622,
-0.0083313035,
-0.0327771939,
-0.0087754345,
-0.0179914404,
-0.0038521425,
0.0477345027,
0.0052793925,
-0.0261073261,
-0.0180346817,
-0.0351777449,
0.0477860086,
-0.0363470949,
0.0048106387,
0.000815893,
-0.0386630446,
0.0439928174,
0.0045112614,
-0.0079026464,
0.0133378385,
-0.0077075199,
0.0182108879,
-0.0196061935,
0.018592041,
0.0094862655,
-0.0039702686,
-0.0367608145,
0.0182945523,
-0.0848714337,
0.0091245258,
0.0001311687,
0.0261899978,
0.0177418459,
-0.0095069679,
0.0418170244,
0.0005651788,
-0.0279437806,
-0.0389469154,
-0.0060840445,
-0.0316733792,
0.0262533817,
0.0793539286,
0.0271118451,
-0.0338926949,
0.0015076433,
0.0407471023,
0.005808637,
0.0424207002,
-0.0032461733,
-0.058025118,
-0.0200802889,
-0.0272524972,
0.0028845989,
-0.0082720155,
-0.0608101971,
0.0170575585,
-0.0677674264,
-0.0420184396,
0.0623515248,
-0.0029799789,
-0.0140935061,
-0.0298503079,
0.0388707183,
0.0748213977,
0.0364103094,
-0.0558521636,
-0.0246722009,
0.0361213014,
-0.024374323,
-0.0125509882,
-0.0074020815,
-6.21608833e-33,
0.010366004,
-0.0340028033,
0.0106430417,
-0.0731485859,
-0.0030734472,
0.0239236224,
-0.0280272942,
0.0083854822,
-0.0475444421,
0.0203692764,
-0.0145963915,
-0.0077848188,
-0.0002252202,
0.0376221128,
-0.0114690429,
-0.0431796759,
0.0010659109,
0.0129063139,
0.0105378823,
-0.0050258171,
0.0168321058,
0.0850545168,
0.0560364462,
-0.0915450454,
0.0177345332,
-0.0079492517,
0.0415991582,
0.0423781127,
-0.0215551332,
0.0710499361,
-0.0491437614,
0.0552700348,
0.0309978742,
-0.0130321402,
0.0127274748,
-0.008384468,
-0.0994608402,
0.0047337208,
0.0141587984,
-0.0263555218,
-0.0098817833,
-0.0007079392,
0.0794402584,
-0.0169430766,
-0.0447903387,
-0.0043560788,
0.018696906,
-0.0167407375,
-0.0407533459,
-0.028091481,
-0.0244052242,
0.0288058296,
0.0289077535,
0.0128419679,
0.0137735605,
-0.0095836213,
-0.0304278228,
0.0854529291,
-0.0225163158,
-0.0282799844,
-0.0143302791,
0.011136503,
0.0084932521,
-0.0004457321,
0.0101034204,
0.0793936625,
0.0224164799,
0.0092291851,
-0.0244431216,
-0.0396964103,
-0.0211692564,
0.0487386845,
0.0280706659,
0.046439223,
0.0032956994,
0.0164171252,
-0.1058387533,
-0.014251125,
-0.0418043658,
0.052175995,
0.0332296863,
0.0053217183,
-0.0433589108,
0.0126876952,
-0.0275364798,
0.0348072127,
-0.027827587,
-0.0218128059,
0.0308756419,
0.002912686,
-0.011265398,
0.0705674067,
0.0095429765,
-0.0396867134,
-0.0274855513,
0.0317548215,
0.0135497199,
-0.0071320958,
-0.017747853,
0.0268923081,
-0.059080448,
0.0019637076,
0.0067688152,
-0.0123789189,
0.0015974225,
-0.0156980883,
-0.0179279372,
-0.0276033022,
-0.0639023483,
-0.0190327018,
-0.0215009265,
0.0012682665,
0.0025790681,
0.0199194532,
0.0425059795,
0.0489906706,
0.0094049675,
0.0676646754,
0.0348791182,
-0.0093043838,
-0.0351099484,
0.0185897779,
0.013450372,
-0.0150269205,
-0.0059589879,
0.0086992234,
-0.0139500573,
0.0676150396,
-0.0041757091,
-0.0609084778,
0.0079774447,
0.0040146429,
2.662e-7,
0.102821961,
0.040132612,
0.022185659,
-0.0147616761,
0.0130468849,
0.0085903835,
-0.0206533168,
0.0222720448,
0.0208175592,
-0.0173340943,
-0.0183362234,
0.0421939641,
0.0085750874,
-0.0100133996,
-0.0544716492,
-0.0162247643,
-0.0851361752,
-0.044823382,
-0.0282047223,
-0.0279654525,
0.056929253,
0.077523008,
-0.0186046697,
-0.0139671499,
-0.0029896649,
-0.0625926405,
0.0493655317,
-0.0302126445,
-0.0216517504,
0.0283671916,
0.017154675,
0.0211729929,
0.0355605297,
0.036288511,
0.005110499,
0.0043288432,
0.0124552771,
0.0784160495,
-0.0377486572,
-0.0304952599,
0.0329200029,
0.0073240758,
0.0231284685,
-0.0348132849,
0.063628912,
-0.0749746263,
-0.0494267754,
-0.0083299549,
-0.0053628939,
-0.014986706,
0.0520308465,
-0.0110952612,
-0.011046581,
0.0215281062,
0.0263368916,
0.0221850909,
-0.045879744,
-0.1018693522,
-0.0154261421,
0.0412268937,
-0.0493624546,
-0.0365165733,
0.0013097404,
0.0161822606,
-0.0028261279,
-0.098233059,
0.0025624919,
2.364606299e-34,
0.022613259,
0.0202492811,
-0.0103737498,
0.0313533582,
0.0446702205,
-0.0058624069,
-0.0003071012,
0.0318894088,
-0.0227625258,
-0.092774801,
0.0296980739
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08142v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08142v1
|
Discursive objection strategies in online comments: Developing a classification schema and validating its training
| 2024-05-13T19:39:00 | 2024-05-13T19:39:00 |
Ashley L. Shea, Aspen K. B. Omapang, Ji Yong Cho, Miryam Y. Ginsparg, Natalie Bazarova, Winice Hui, René F. Kizilcec, Chau Tong, Drew Margolin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, I.2.7, J.4
|
Most Americans agree that misinformation, hate speech and harassment are
harmful and inadequately curbed on social media through current moderation
practices. In this paper, we aim to understand the discursive strategies
employed by people in response to harmful speech in news comments. We conducted
a content analysis of more than 6500 comment replies to trending news videos on
YouTube and Twitter and identified seven distinct discursive objection
strategies (Study 1). We examined the frequency of each strategy's occurrence
from the 6500 comment replies, as well as from a second sample of 2004 replies
(Study 2). Together, these studies show that people deploy a diversity of
discursive strategies when objecting to speech, and reputational attacks are
the most common. The resulting classification scheme accounts for different
theoretical approaches for expressing objections and offers a comprehensive
perspective on grassroots efforts aimed at stopping offensive or problematic
speech on campus.
|
Discursive objection strategies in online comments: Developing a classification schema and validating its training: Most Americans agree that misinformation, hate speech and harassment are
harmful and inadequately curbed on social media through current moderation
practices. In this paper, we aim to understand the discursive strategies
employed by people in response to harmful speech in news comments. We conducted
a content analysis of more than 6500 comment replies to trending news videos on
YouTube and Twitter and identified seven distinct discursive objection
strategies (Study 1). We examined the frequency of each strategy's occurrence
from the 6500 comment replies, as well as from a second sample of 2004 replies
(Study 2). Together, these studies show that people deploy a diversity of
discursive strategies when objecting to speech, and reputational attacks are
the most common. The resulting classification scheme accounts for different
theoretical approaches for expressing objections and offers a comprehensive
perspective on grassroots efforts aimed at stopping offensive or problematic
speech on campus.
|
[
0.11649023,
0.0366345197,
0.0005920751,
0.0102967089,
0.0105311666,
0.0211385079,
0.0273363944,
-0.0061585349,
-0.0090658087,
-0.0855807364,
0.0304016788,
-0.0148044461,
-0.0071497671,
-0.0695536286,
0.027511375,
-0.0455520526,
-0.0081327539,
0.045899149,
0.0651051477,
-0.0176259913,
0.0844917744,
0.0001863183,
-0.0379983373,
0.0187341385,
-0.0391516462,
-0.0139692929,
0.0626773685,
-0.0171822924,
0.0459749363,
-0.0333273038,
0.0288363919,
0.0248094387,
0.0466229729,
0.0262227077,
0.0000014915,
-0.0689708218,
0.0365813598,
-0.0094316667,
0.0348701291,
0.0057609645,
0.0381730907,
-0.0296772327,
0.0114308372,
0.0370916314,
-0.0068043256,
-0.0140789039,
0.0248500593,
0.0387423411,
0.04998409,
0.0622084998,
0.0037323304,
-0.0742901117,
-0.051179748,
0.029749278,
-0.0557044633,
0.0310607497,
0.0128225405,
-0.0318011679,
-0.0548993424,
-0.0218453165,
0.0312612131,
-0.0148873935,
-0.0139304223,
-0.0011889957,
-0.0075473962,
-0.0276276767,
0.0195357278,
-0.0345143639,
0.039811492,
-0.001885962,
0.035046611,
-0.0072769364,
0.003251889,
0.0182017293,
0.0068021682,
0.039530538,
-0.0561415143,
0.0464930497,
-0.0462629981,
0.0043964782,
-0.0259484313,
0.0059150974,
0.0188763998,
0.084454,
0.0726237893,
-0.026137678,
-0.0366195478,
-0.0257287882,
-0.0164373405,
-0.0219699107,
-0.0080545563,
0.004339694,
-0.004235195,
0.0202366579,
0.004733488,
0.0101277148,
0.0080882441,
-0.0549527891,
0.0499307513,
-0.0560174771,
0.0154817216,
0.037828479,
0.0232015792,
-0.0245534182,
0.0081946403,
0.0069018193,
-0.0283956863,
-0.0073923226,
0.0760489926,
0.0358091146,
-0.0646227077,
0.0353636555,
0.0140233152,
-0.0122495499,
0.0098253991,
0.0298944358,
0.0110948347,
-0.030373916,
-0.0544259511,
-0.0321854018,
-0.0293523781,
0.0012921211,
0.0238210857,
0.0150912469,
-0.038823247,
0.0402186364,
-0.0579508841,
0.0283756647,
-0.0545246527,
-0.0478775725,
0.0028395273,
0.0198139939,
-0.0178466346,
0.0011953671,
-0.0070289769,
0.0650436878,
-0.0017052838,
0.0034768758,
-0.0243067052,
-0.0423144363,
-0.0245696213,
-0.0191828795,
0.0326543115,
-0.0434455983,
-0.0007532709,
-0.0020984337,
-0.0610016249,
-0.026124116,
0.0377255008,
0.0112428665,
-0.0100504486,
0.0289169271,
0.031066563,
0.0086404169,
0.0981022567,
0.0537193418,
-0.0293951835,
-0.0058768024,
0.0016011294,
0.0125882672,
0.0073103094,
0.0042066835,
-0.0051757838,
0.0120186135,
0.0146432649,
0.0057585323,
-0.0273196399,
0.0330632888,
-0.069769837,
-0.0340029746,
-0.0104559911,
0.0253569447,
-0.0235138014,
-0.0501497723,
0.0393703468,
0.0566729605,
-0.0917996168,
0.0160196573,
-0.0020886667,
0.0410651155,
0.0104026264,
-0.0606510937,
0.0156073831,
-0.0425506979,
-0.0149121843,
-0.0434045233,
0.0199511833,
0.0414781086,
-0.0268615168,
-0.0102921501,
-0.0354552455,
0.0242714416,
0.0891292021,
-0.0359344408,
0.0070725195,
0.0251905136,
0.0094028115,
-0.0108931111,
0.0313812941,
-0.008910411,
-0.0015382563,
-0.067765668,
0.0451913737,
0.0295688156,
-0.0218260754,
0.0155968573,
0.0319968089,
-0.0619461425,
0.0921651274,
0.0891749188,
0.0360548198,
-0.0276852772,
-0.0405486859,
0.0061423741,
-0.0345783271,
-0.0191501174,
0.010008635,
0.022973109,
0.0553352274,
0.023040371,
-0.0137540894,
0.0758046284,
-0.0119385701,
0.0138155781,
0.0823462605,
-0.0187973697,
-0.033157371,
0.0217360947,
0.0355951078,
0.0161059201,
-0.0101619009,
-0.0297895763,
0.0208622795,
0.0115548167,
-0.018518867,
-0.0180636644,
0.0108097959,
0.0654549673,
0.0128869498,
-0.0478709489,
-0.0211443529,
0.0156440884,
0.0140104545,
0.0680708662,
0.0989116207,
-0.0315930396,
0.0008491593,
-0.0119691137,
-0.057974156,
-0.0881104693,
-0.0064976471,
-0.0251429752,
0.0455011241,
-0.0341725014,
-0.010680072,
0.042547673,
-0.073474206,
0.0254334435,
0.0395768657,
-0.0519571379,
-0.0199556611,
-0.0305579491,
0.0351608619,
0.0207721051,
-0.0371297859,
-0.0163869709,
-0.0004191879,
-0.0140701011,
-0.0347138867,
-0.0341662206,
0.0336834565,
0.0444897451,
-0.0323411375,
-0.0103347115,
0.0171979927,
0.0386039503,
-0.0527585447,
0.0091587873,
0.0456187651,
-0.0024820124,
-0.0289868191,
-0.0227121748,
0.0009935553,
0.0080781765,
-0.0231606364,
-0.0078837788,
-0.0094423005,
-0.1072017848,
0.026836725,
-0.0108284587,
-0.0330335349,
0.013153567,
-0.025428867,
-0.0393951721,
0.066854246,
0.0413553007,
-0.0233194828,
0.0238235258,
0.0920462385,
0.111064367,
0.0133335451,
0.0323606692,
0.00346235,
-0.0146140726,
-0.0131561477,
-0.0224353578,
-0.0330077335,
-0.0318184607,
-0.0102793332,
0.0399760455,
0.0376308411,
0.0246449523,
-0.0382848009,
0.0510434248,
-0.0793001801,
-0.0146307955,
-0.02529772,
-0.0772001147,
-0.0084513323,
-0.0083918851,
-0.0194785837,
-0.0082847383,
0.0014064759,
0.0163714346,
0.0317948535,
-0.0101903593,
-0.0431562103,
0.0397596955,
0.0488857292,
0.0044599911,
0.0250232015,
-0.0253550448,
-0.0397430882,
0.0293700676,
-0.0444890596,
0.0826597288,
-0.0138872443,
-0.0009557314,
-0.0118158981,
0.0383130126,
0.0032514972,
-0.0130755082,
-0.0241961088,
-0.061232049,
-0.0331234261,
-0.0543794446,
-0.0244582426,
0.0032939892,
-0.0209000427,
0.0408523493,
0.0354751088,
-0.0307857227,
0.0179586019,
-0.0125698214,
0.057895463,
-0.0670534074,
-0.0191633571,
0.0559976213,
0.0403167158,
0.015080506,
-0.0229612477,
0.0643945113,
-0.0011464305,
-0.0210638624,
0.009756037,
-0.0338330902,
0.004029681,
0.0249009412,
0.0186719466,
0.0035559027,
0.0399168544,
-0.0016704515,
0.0080266362,
0.0426189341,
0.0189742912,
0.0329898074,
-0.0407991856,
-0.0101990402,
0.0039794166,
0.031548053,
-0.0329643153,
-0.0860197172,
0.002229417,
-0.0343434066,
0.0118223447,
-0.0692839324,
-0.0211565234,
-0.0188710708,
-0.0377872363,
0.0131989131,
-0.0371629782,
-0.0171221457,
-0.013667196,
0.0067695845,
0.0206546895,
0.032451544,
0.0200197231,
-0.0231963508,
0.0317523405,
-0.0127055189,
0.0319751613,
-0.0651972666,
-0.0000112697,
-0.0142928669,
0.0094130617,
0.007728999,
-0.0170349628,
0.0323828422,
-0.0118910354,
-0.0259716287,
0.0460241362,
-0.0247756913,
-0.0370076485,
-0.0399248749,
-0.009984809,
-0.0001197152,
0.0100896778,
0.0066883182,
0.0240695868,
0.0092621492,
-0.0191352125,
0.0143960249,
0.0453767553,
0.0414097346,
-0.0202694219,
-0.0718494877,
0.035118185,
0.0302157328,
0.0200609546,
0.0232134759,
-0.0212928224,
0.0273031611,
-0.0487863459,
-0.0154708391,
-0.0063819792,
-0.0412784368,
-0.0110025462,
0.0168255046,
-0.0308274925,
0.0026169491,
-0.0333833918,
-0.0098965811,
-0.0170594472,
0.0262563322,
-0.0167181827,
-0.0036594055,
-0.0022886181,
-0.0354594216,
-0.0211061463,
0.0255712047,
0.0081798052,
-0.0106784832,
-0.0253474172,
-0.0270599201,
0.0212534107,
-0.051583793,
-0.0047239061,
0.0008801465,
-0.0400651768,
0.051930476,
0.0358493738,
0.0210579522,
-0.0097946227,
0.0247831959,
-0.0412721597,
0.0279516838,
0.0337821282,
0.0020227893,
0.015680084,
0.0349150747,
-0.0018388537,
0.0193640348,
-0.0161145907,
0.0390631855,
0.0494893752,
0.0289067328,
-0.0209076907,
-0.0746780559,
-0.0006904242,
-0.0216428116,
-0.06014226,
0.0348450281,
0.0212057158,
-0.0558213145,
-0.0112816747,
-0.0498730019,
0.0002886367,
-0.0317917056,
0.0029149572,
-0.0001845897,
-0.0084031224,
-0.0135536781,
-0.0265269596,
-0.0165487602,
-0.0470755026,
0.0435490906,
-0.0313083567,
0.0477248244,
0.0380683318,
0.0424847193,
-0.0350898579,
-0.0010030096,
-0.0056121601,
0.0412728637,
0.0361250937,
-0.0246595219,
0.006585923,
0.0378076248,
0.0085855071,
0.0232204292,
0.0586815178,
-0.048065763,
-0.0057235593,
-0.04559654,
-0.0096774595,
-0.004354977,
-0.0637385547,
-0.0222852882,
0.0497891717,
0.042888388,
-0.0183305461,
0.0137880947,
0.0039219907,
-0.0439028181,
-0.0660164952,
0.0566467494,
0.0349196568,
-0.0332800373,
0.0081695616,
0.0110002095,
-0.0420061164,
0.0272741038,
0.0467178859,
-0.0595649071,
-0.0209465586,
-0.0501790196,
0.0077995211,
0.0471532904,
0.0595713034,
0.0338544361,
-0.0497796498,
0.0133507745,
-0.0188066717,
-0.0534890778,
0.0366430953,
-0.0235694107,
-0.0387020372,
0.031507168,
0.0372612402,
0.0217108298,
0.0191114359,
0.0123738591,
-0.0251404699,
-0.0816370249,
-0.0184101164,
-4.878692775e-33,
0.0021903077,
-0.0537705868,
-0.0151920328,
0.0095373429,
-0.0021567347,
-0.0207141992,
0.0247861221,
0.021173548,
-0.0176255219,
0.0291150846,
0.0165694226,
0.008800759,
-0.0026335004,
0.0048678038,
-0.0176848099,
-0.072236672,
0.0207931846,
-0.0633795112,
-0.0270355176,
-0.00582116,
0.0401318967,
-0.0244472772,
-0.0285071619,
-0.0872647539,
0.0283700284,
-0.0203291625,
-0.0310644396,
0.0115276333,
0.0554633327,
0.0440661684,
-0.0262490567,
0.0412587635,
0.0402043946,
-0.0145913931,
0.0201884452,
0.0997143313,
-0.0221898574,
-0.0118119549,
0.0495573916,
-0.0253542848,
0.0131373322,
0.0250564087,
0.0004656745,
0.0202138517,
-0.0376686007,
-0.0182117186,
0.0309478622,
0.0066585434,
0.0432549417,
-0.0294851828,
-0.086362794,
0.0015595123,
-0.0436437503,
0.0268009566,
-0.0157452859,
0.0296684187,
0.0004477741,
0.0183174368,
-0.0733926669,
0.0226516072,
-0.0243063755,
-0.0130016087,
-0.0047879727,
-0.0320725515,
0.0303425509,
0.0557709374,
0.0029645658,
0.0528852008,
-0.0351710729,
0.0300871748,
-0.0123601574,
-0.0009990492,
0.0040472071,
0.0912071764,
0.0188654475,
-0.1383347064,
-0.0608476251,
-0.0383429676,
0.0541789941,
0.0011301835,
0.0217488781,
-0.043137759,
-0.0283017568,
-0.0290386621,
-0.0055217603,
-0.05834141,
-0.0222463086,
-0.0069029522,
0.0089650443,
0.0056257667,
-0.0235000569,
-0.0355841555,
0.0367510431,
0.0063492334,
-0.024351513,
0.0388730355,
-0.0105811618,
0.0133126648,
0.0559477694,
0.0323382169,
-0.0463007689,
-0.0065335301,
-0.0142685436,
-0.0585541874,
0.0405209735,
-0.0029276381,
0.0715163797,
0.037012618,
-0.0483726934,
0.0070803817,
0.0118724974,
0.0729011819,
-0.0501136221,
0.0330973938,
0.0048475442,
0.0717918649,
0.0061902776,
-0.0284620784,
0.0394324698,
-0.032900691,
-0.0071301544,
-0.0031614394,
-0.0519563816,
-0.011715455,
-0.0279178191,
-0.009027374,
0.0124668349,
0.0290840734,
0.0205192603,
-0.1149977073,
0.0034193825,
-0.0413062647,
2.294e-7,
0.009827964,
0.038631238,
-0.0275314096,
-0.0023899903,
0.0611834079,
0.022802338,
0.0517949611,
0.0319791548,
0.0429195464,
-0.0745566711,
-0.0129865827,
0.0155228106,
-0.0353888683,
0.0370082185,
-0.0227452014,
-0.0693276525,
-0.0698020831,
0.0310901683,
-0.0132085299,
0.0358547196,
0.0012590182,
0.0055490155,
0.0218458641,
-0.007004051,
-0.0760346949,
0.0104429321,
0.0307180006,
-0.0111718588,
0.0053179264,
-0.0514589101,
0.0506134033,
0.000879137,
0.0313271917,
0.0362889245,
0.0183304399,
0.0388585813,
0.0012873496,
0.0255646259,
0.0332283676,
-0.008454348,
0.0016734612,
0.0140999053,
0.0227543935,
0.0115679484,
-0.0187906213,
-0.0252165012,
-0.0226620063,
-0.040371161,
-0.0262793172,
-0.0252052397,
0.020806741,
-0.0100676101,
-0.0412026495,
-0.0209328793,
0.0272481386,
0.0122042447,
0.0439708456,
-0.0455990285,
0.0244199615,
-0.0420416072,
-0.0329921432,
-0.0297332276,
0.0082606087,
-0.0299589876,
0.0357544571,
0.0701002702,
0.0424077995,
1.57084708e-34,
0.0047599892,
-0.0058186781,
0.0213569012,
-0.0538768061,
0.04671368,
0.0444304235,
0.0060744043,
-0.016041223,
0.0390091017,
0.0128902467,
-0.0448552519
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13011v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13011v1
|
Unveiling Social Media Comments with a Novel Named Entity Recognition System for Identity Groups
| 2024-05-13T19:33:18 | 2024-05-13T19:33:18 |
Andrés Carvallo, Tamara Quiroga, Carlos Aspillaga, Marcelo Mendoza
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
While civilized users employ social media to stay informed and discuss daily
occurrences, haters perceive these platforms as fertile ground for attacking
groups and individuals. The prevailing approach to counter this phenomenon
involves detecting such attacks by identifying toxic language. Effective
platform measures aim to report haters and block their network access. In this
context, employing hate speech detection methods aids in identifying these
attacks amidst vast volumes of text, which are impossible for humans to analyze
manually. In our study, we expand upon the usual hate speech detection methods,
typically based on text classifiers, to develop a Named Entity Recognition
(NER) System for Identity Groups. To achieve this, we created a dataset that
allows extending a conventional NER to recognize identity groups. Consequently,
our tool not only detects whether a sentence contains an attack but also tags
the sentence tokens corresponding to the mentioned group. Results indicate that
the model performs competitively in identifying groups with an average f1-score
of 0.75, outperforming in identifying ethnicity attack spans with an f1-score
of 0.80 compared to other identity groups. Moreover, the tool shows an
outstanding generalization capability to minority classes concerning sexual
orientation and gender, achieving an f1-score of 0.77 and 0.72, respectively.
We tested the utility of our tool in a case study on social media, annotating
and comparing comments from Facebook related to news mentioning identity
groups. The case study reveals differences in the types of attacks recorded,
effectively detecting named entities related to the categories of the analyzed
news articles. Entities are accurately tagged within their categories, with a
negligible error rate for inter-category tagging.
|
Unveiling Social Media Comments with a Novel Named Entity Recognition System for Identity Groups: While civilized users employ social media to stay informed and discuss daily
occurrences, haters perceive these platforms as fertile ground for attacking
groups and individuals. The prevailing approach to counter this phenomenon
involves detecting such attacks by identifying toxic language. Effective
platform measures aim to report haters and block their network access. In this
context, employing hate speech detection methods aids in identifying these
attacks amidst vast volumes of text, which are impossible for humans to analyze
manually. In our study, we expand upon the usual hate speech detection methods,
typically based on text classifiers, to develop a Named Entity Recognition
(NER) System for Identity Groups. To achieve this, we created a dataset that
allows extending a conventional NER to recognize identity groups. Consequently,
our tool not only detects whether a sentence contains an attack but also tags
the sentence tokens corresponding to the mentioned group. Results indicate that
the model performs competitively in identifying groups with an average f1-score
of 0.75, outperforming in identifying ethnicity attack spans with an f1-score
of 0.80 compared to other identity groups. Moreover, the tool shows an
outstanding generalization capability to minority classes concerning sexual
orientation and gender, achieving an f1-score of 0.77 and 0.72, respectively.
We tested the utility of our tool in a case study on social media, annotating
and comparing comments from Facebook related to news mentioning identity
groups. The case study reveals differences in the types of attacks recorded,
effectively detecting named entities related to the categories of the analyzed
news articles. Entities are accurately tagged within their categories, with a
negligible error rate for inter-category tagging.
|
[
0.0786774158,
0.0746245831,
-0.0080275228,
0.008957115,
-0.0011441609,
0.0617740564,
0.0469802432,
0.0180810243,
0.0119613633,
-0.0899709985,
0.0332157947,
-0.0260972679,
-0.0047934842,
0.0020396831,
0.0130712437,
-0.0130821941,
0.0369317718,
0.0468829088,
0.0524376482,
-0.0167263895,
0.0579200424,
0.0267357267,
-0.006320253,
0.0569555834,
-0.0418566428,
0.024165839,
0.0458453894,
-0.0084127299,
0.0391519368,
-0.0194914639,
0.0548015572,
0.0563258231,
-0.0194164217,
0.0769493282,
0.0000017011,
-0.0679593459,
-0.0071527907,
0.0019272842,
-0.0098626567,
-0.0598034039,
0.058499597,
-0.0301129967,
-0.0147587378,
0.0127212098,
-0.0186818484,
-0.0140052894,
0.0403898321,
0.0487903878,
0.0611429848,
0.0636788532,
-0.0142623829,
-0.075287953,
-0.0192737635,
0.0293849707,
0.0172398146,
0.0224028826,
0.043866884,
-0.0642564148,
-0.0449357405,
-0.0234699007,
0.0483570248,
0.0052766707,
0.0100713298,
0.0234224554,
0.0478665419,
-0.0032717122,
-0.0368277021,
-0.034713164,
0.0062313117,
0.0366414338,
-0.0214465596,
0.0016255733,
0.0196906142,
0.0085384799,
-0.0202031173,
-0.0195942577,
-0.0101197846,
0.0195273869,
-0.0615725145,
-0.0014756978,
0.0035692109,
0.015825808,
0.0365350619,
0.0647084862,
0.0279718246,
0.0301056039,
-0.0051050559,
-0.0200244226,
-0.0037783699,
-0.0134427957,
-0.0199176241,
-0.0060979696,
0.0277890041,
0.0133519238,
0.0109718125,
0.0328367166,
-0.0769101754,
-0.0559137762,
0.0199975204,
-0.0904356837,
0.0075642336,
0.0147277871,
0.0024550173,
-0.0121457521,
0.0064309239,
0.0259773303,
0.0224332772,
-0.002845142,
0.0476409756,
-0.0124404971,
-0.040673092,
0.0042265099,
-0.0111849802,
0.0347060263,
-0.008527779,
0.0422957465,
-0.0575339794,
-0.0092979223,
-0.0602650903,
-0.0144019388,
-0.0257003289,
0.003490191,
0.022767568,
0.0098021021,
-0.0183156971,
-0.0173361916,
-0.0316558927,
0.009014803,
-0.0462987497,
-0.0651505962,
0.0411825031,
0.0022918694,
-0.0029120012,
-0.0073823645,
0.0178929362,
0.0593284592,
0.0365326293,
-0.0570077114,
-0.0632803515,
-0.038435109,
-0.0011152257,
-0.0052178893,
0.0163796116,
-0.064239122,
0.0446154214,
-0.0042429585,
-0.0334016606,
-0.0642755851,
0.0025686729,
0.0092626503,
-0.0530026294,
0.0808618665,
-0.007393992,
-0.0028449912,
0.0856257081,
0.030639695,
0.0422695018,
0.0394587256,
0.0223398097,
0.0050431537,
0.0672425777,
-0.0094148424,
0.0098257139,
0.0427539907,
0.0237744115,
-0.0121614188,
0.000860171,
0.0148263136,
-0.0455236435,
-0.0640507564,
-0.0207772609,
0.0380767584,
0.0319309086,
-0.0743366629,
0.0398866832,
0.0780945048,
-0.0617181584,
0.0357604213,
0.0236279201,
0.0286390781,
-0.0094400756,
-0.053764917,
-0.0592010245,
-0.0523345359,
-0.0435777977,
-0.0679596961,
0.0368549153,
0.0461908467,
-0.0173409488,
-0.0188802406,
-0.0309868399,
0.0141828749,
0.0714008361,
-0.0226513799,
0.0160662886,
0.0179503169,
-0.0069616279,
0.0478461906,
0.0558472946,
-0.0114074778,
0.026198294,
-0.048731491,
0.031291388,
0.0520660542,
-0.0014964843,
-0.0161750894,
0.0055343006,
-0.0658780336,
0.0016333672,
0.0475338958,
0.0113676041,
-0.0127599314,
-0.0126131233,
-0.006981581,
-0.0014844049,
0.0504179038,
0.0028646141,
0.0372432545,
0.0882885233,
0.037070144,
0.0160801522,
0.0546246544,
-0.0414652191,
0.0347835533,
0.036417149,
-0.034308061,
-0.0022716094,
0.0197085068,
0.0392856188,
0.0503514744,
-0.013357454,
-0.0497684516,
-0.0132329362,
0.0015653463,
-0.062125396,
-0.0361414962,
-0.0065972642,
0.025147507,
0.0267060101,
-0.0200664606,
-0.0310997125,
0.0493141487,
-0.0116501711,
0.0186613817,
0.0860939398,
-0.0303736869,
-0.0344493315,
0.0097653344,
-0.0414093062,
-0.055064261,
0.0194807593,
-0.0259359069,
0.0772053897,
-0.0261773914,
0.0246744417,
-0.0262971688,
-0.0668221563,
0.013079606,
0.0113406722,
-0.0481923483,
-0.0262456797,
-0.0447891206,
0.0134922061,
0.008695554,
-0.0342842899,
-0.012507516,
0.0314742215,
-0.0816091299,
0.0085897222,
-0.0182803217,
0.0162533689,
0.0213578474,
0.0121511715,
-0.0365100428,
0.022618074,
0.0086044809,
-0.0498454459,
0.0341837965,
0.0188930314,
-0.0110632665,
-0.0482798181,
-0.0287489388,
0.0049243858,
-0.016455926,
-0.0338749066,
0.0255591162,
0.0528909974,
-0.0861450583,
0.0263093151,
-0.0349655077,
-0.0486532934,
0.001527278,
-0.0004525099,
-0.0299319942,
0.0375623293,
0.0381839909,
-0.0100045623,
0.0237847213,
0.0811957419,
0.0758226663,
-0.0175005514,
0.0071308049,
0.0019958841,
-0.0111288531,
-0.0296683703,
0.0426469743,
-0.0199184436,
-0.0577561334,
0.0242566038,
0.0877091959,
0.0570221841,
-0.0130501064,
-0.0556269325,
0.0307637881,
-0.079922013,
-0.0249225069,
-0.0255006589,
-0.0483081788,
0.005207743,
-0.0528271049,
-0.0425419845,
-0.0281784274,
0.0667763874,
0.0082145128,
0.0226462744,
-0.0092929397,
-0.0426334068,
0.0058445907,
0.0236848276,
0.0093597025,
0.0248425789,
0.0120423986,
-0.0505408011,
0.0535070747,
-0.0049070013,
0.0215231646,
-0.0179807469,
0.0114099197,
-0.0009283249,
0.0210080966,
0.0139313638,
-0.0136909392,
-0.0741240531,
-0.0458393134,
-0.0669561625,
-0.0272815134,
0.0107909329,
-0.0118683111,
0.000134527,
0.0259895287,
0.0227225274,
-0.0246427488,
-0.006116841,
0.002459578,
0.0360236391,
-0.0067406548,
-0.032702785,
-0.0434349664,
0.0205274988,
0.0053751045,
-0.027658904,
0.0550053418,
-0.0088970019,
0.01032608,
-0.0163560379,
-0.0030786339,
-0.0031607312,
-0.0257037599,
0.0109494431,
-0.0543576069,
0.0313515216,
-0.0028918225,
0.0267299674,
0.0939862505,
0.0334212817,
-0.0102418307,
-0.0076817079,
0.0197576378,
-0.0030079938,
0.0260439329,
-0.0188128836,
-0.0819874331,
-0.0004150316,
-0.008938916,
0.0497926101,
-0.081298314,
-0.0655872971,
0.0167594962,
-0.0396802351,
-0.0040025688,
-0.0302775335,
-0.0472458154,
-0.0067614843,
-0.0183676947,
0.0391588584,
-0.0106710438,
0.0045652683,
-0.0441056862,
0.0183955207,
0.0235034917,
0.0056976182,
-0.0725592598,
-0.0088201249,
-0.0071288794,
-0.0284943078,
0.0448589735,
0.0160162523,
0.0387203656,
-0.013468002,
-0.0129124019,
0.0696426257,
-0.0223857239,
-0.0255790483,
-0.0688078031,
0.058124546,
-0.0174175184,
-0.0293222349,
-0.0243827533,
0.0475773886,
0.0094433604,
-0.0208727308,
0.0252920389,
-0.0094774887,
0.0243229344,
-0.0008603009,
-0.0403455123,
0.0071606608,
0.0134794302,
0.0692288727,
0.0249739811,
-0.0395036638,
0.0158452839,
-0.0765202641,
-0.0039136391,
-0.0445276313,
-0.0780467987,
0.0216661319,
-0.026295146,
-0.0636315122,
-0.016473826,
-0.0295857955,
0.0264860839,
0.0023606617,
0.0069912779,
-0.0362458266,
0.0156284552,
0.0088122245,
-0.0659229085,
-0.0013238228,
-0.0062505584,
0.054491818,
-0.0209495537,
-0.0200880803,
-0.0290809684,
0.0276453141,
-0.051670108,
0.0329447538,
-0.0388882607,
-0.0598773845,
0.0669662654,
0.014544948,
0.0102009382,
-0.0014748055,
-0.0079614483,
-0.0779205859,
0.0506594591,
0.0525143221,
-0.0038536284,
-0.0089974152,
0.0137380036,
0.0106267668,
0.0142954541,
0.0126694832,
0.0133611942,
0.0442866124,
0.0342920125,
-0.0501740724,
-0.0710875988,
0.0130696287,
-0.0511409789,
0.0017801055,
0.0132077178,
-0.0007164867,
-0.0433876775,
-0.0122706583,
-0.0429611392,
0.0048430352,
-0.0363509394,
0.0242086258,
-0.0226919409,
-0.0179569852,
-0.0039842352,
-0.0385771953,
0.0130289728,
-0.0378592722,
0.0250215493,
-0.0626590773,
0.0315366127,
0.0426738858,
0.0696900859,
0.0195056722,
-0.0057509653,
0.0104686935,
0.0112563912,
0.0076656756,
-0.0083789518,
-0.0020561712,
0.0075001572,
-0.003200527,
0.0058047366,
0.0121804569,
-0.0445095934,
0.0253793281,
0.0154392794,
-0.0205260515,
-0.0024391913,
-0.0273269694,
0.0132120252,
0.018784862,
0.0407929048,
-0.0255908705,
0.0065838438,
-0.0013765808,
-0.0324308947,
-0.0628890023,
-0.0024347773,
0.0297877416,
-0.0257413201,
0.0007775545,
0.0107169282,
0.0219148137,
0.0167144723,
0.0393083654,
-0.0609663352,
-0.0369848162,
0.0198893156,
0.0201095138,
0.011837719,
0.0156999826,
0.0218950678,
-0.0323532969,
-0.0292851627,
0.0263797529,
-0.0604091398,
0.0438179038,
0.0423728153,
0.0142142577,
0.0416926853,
0.0087601189,
-0.0160020217,
-0.014139141,
-0.0013952736,
-0.0298528187,
-0.0701876804,
0.0083446326,
-5.338108294e-33,
-0.0177284852,
-0.0421789736,
-0.0209893119,
-0.0111503825,
0.0122197941,
-0.0151699744,
0.0249461569,
0.0030196535,
0.0273246877,
-0.0033499999,
0.0210089926,
0.0251826867,
0.0035335748,
0.0121434899,
-0.0393677056,
-0.0258113928,
0.0384001844,
-0.0140917506,
-0.0051736929,
0.0128973359,
0.043013785,
0.0230304804,
0.0208715852,
-0.0842224136,
0.0552840643,
0.0037028778,
-0.0018696577,
-0.0080297496,
0.0587208457,
0.061431475,
-0.0232147258,
0.0577379465,
0.0299034473,
-0.0218325481,
0.0238329973,
0.088643454,
-0.0845246986,
0.0080219405,
-0.0090086078,
0.0164649002,
0.0502192564,
-0.0154878302,
0.0326646343,
0.0124197444,
-0.0306528248,
-0.0170496926,
0.0427889712,
-0.0124099813,
0.0459425859,
-0.0440572277,
-0.0703316182,
0.0358562246,
-0.0180067141,
0.0537095368,
-0.0140055027,
0.0128712133,
0.0500199832,
-0.0137534887,
-0.0645266771,
0.010887363,
-0.0300574191,
-0.043680124,
-0.0137619535,
0.0225260202,
-0.0063146669,
0.0333157517,
0.0121819424,
0.0171657912,
-0.0472771674,
0.0490028523,
0.0210385527,
0.003907396,
0.035943307,
0.0554525666,
-0.0019664892,
-0.0834115893,
-0.0479910299,
0.003511295,
0.0547078773,
-0.0429551192,
0.0205393899,
-0.0418939106,
-0.070143126,
-0.0107349716,
0.005745146,
-0.0787679553,
-0.0252029505,
-0.0150378775,
0.0029608586,
-0.0070858304,
-0.0918953642,
0.0204776507,
0.0076947804,
-0.0164175667,
-0.0275323056,
0.0438887067,
0.0026473266,
0.0034831816,
0.0275331419,
0.0113678603,
-0.0535105169,
0.0008821887,
0.0184081122,
-0.0293239057,
0.0518659241,
-0.0340641178,
0.0423124805,
0.0231340434,
-0.0729432702,
0.0135249626,
0.0187248215,
0.0844164267,
-0.0281381421,
0.0601001307,
0.0214686301,
0.045365911,
-0.0116667952,
-0.0264570601,
0.0301192142,
-0.014573615,
-0.0069752326,
0.0223950166,
-0.0569780543,
0.0129412813,
-0.0157129392,
-0.0223178584,
0.0053397804,
0.0166516006,
0.0144021017,
-0.074942261,
0.0213631075,
-0.0712093711,
2.405e-7,
-0.0108026443,
0.0203647353,
0.0010239363,
-0.0110540856,
0.0359712467,
0.0290680844,
0.0977006853,
0.0395257622,
0.0014791472,
-0.0220446419,
-0.0378129035,
0.0478544049,
-0.0070827445,
0.0563640445,
-0.0296995696,
-0.041515179,
-0.0082455566,
0.0237778034,
-0.0625053048,
0.0351410955,
-0.0051281317,
0.0538826063,
0.0844951496,
-0.0375006013,
-0.0536046065,
-0.0281873737,
-0.0110072419,
0.0025925932,
-0.0034706311,
-0.0068400144,
0.0553000569,
0.0422123112,
0.0189831592,
0.0223752279,
-0.0127077457,
0.0163320415,
-0.0136921369,
0.0054207607,
0.0195081253,
0.0280182101,
-0.0071558594,
-0.0154551314,
-0.0014273677,
-0.0325082392,
0.0517239235,
-0.0006052829,
-0.02079097,
-0.0465356186,
-0.0274311341,
-0.0269153062,
0.0017587182,
-0.0039316448,
-0.0186452251,
0.0217790548,
0.0215272028,
-0.0386893004,
0.0102077611,
-0.094421804,
0.0389851779,
0.0058014081,
-0.0268674493,
0.0091988156,
-0.0067925137,
-0.0071626962,
0.0208882578,
0.0423617847,
0.0351097621,
1.773765071e-34,
-0.021342108,
0.0082921498,
-0.0425571464,
-0.0152396858,
0.020752009,
0.0343579017,
-0.0381499939,
-0.0045249299,
0.0336710252,
0.0012045185,
-0.0027469611
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08134v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08134v1
|
Many-Shot Regurgitation (MSR) Prompting
| 2024-05-13T19:22:40 | 2024-05-13T19:22:40 |
Shashank Sonkar, Richard G. Baraniuk
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce Many-Shot Regurgitation (MSR) prompting, a new black-box
membership inference attack framework for examining verbatim content
reproduction in large language models (LLMs). MSR prompting involves dividing
the input text into multiple segments and creating a single prompt that
includes a series of faux conversation rounds between a user and a language
model to elicit verbatim regurgitation. We apply MSR prompting to diverse text
sources, including Wikipedia articles and open educational resources (OER)
textbooks, which provide high-quality, factual content and are continuously
updated over time. For each source, we curate two dataset types: one that LLMs
were likely exposed to during training ($D_{\rm pre}$) and another consisting
of documents published after the models' training cutoff dates ($D_{\rm
post}$). To quantify the occurrence of verbatim matches, we employ the Longest
Common Substring algorithm and count the frequency of matches at different
length thresholds. We then use statistical measures such as Cliff's delta,
Kolmogorov-Smirnov (KS) distance, and Kruskal-Wallis H test to determine
whether the distribution of verbatim matches differs significantly between
$D_{\rm pre}$ and $D_{\rm post}$. Our findings reveal a striking difference in
the distribution of verbatim matches between $D_{\rm pre}$ and $D_{\rm post}$,
with the frequency of verbatim reproduction being significantly higher when
LLMs (e.g. GPT models and LLaMAs) are prompted with text from datasets they
were likely trained on. For instance, when using GPT-3.5 on Wikipedia articles,
we observe a substantial effect size (Cliff's delta $= -0.984$) and a large KS
distance ($0.875$) between the distributions of $D_{\rm pre}$ and $D_{\rm
post}$. Our results provide compelling evidence that LLMs are more prone to
reproducing verbatim content when the input text is likely sourced from their
training data.
|
Many-Shot Regurgitation (MSR) Prompting: We introduce Many-Shot Regurgitation (MSR) prompting, a new black-box
membership inference attack framework for examining verbatim content
reproduction in large language models (LLMs). MSR prompting involves dividing
the input text into multiple segments and creating a single prompt that
includes a series of faux conversation rounds between a user and a language
model to elicit verbatim regurgitation. We apply MSR prompting to diverse text
sources, including Wikipedia articles and open educational resources (OER)
textbooks, which provide high-quality, factual content and are continuously
updated over time. For each source, we curate two dataset types: one that LLMs
were likely exposed to during training ($D_{\rm pre}$) and another consisting
of documents published after the models' training cutoff dates ($D_{\rm
post}$). To quantify the occurrence of verbatim matches, we employ the Longest
Common Substring algorithm and count the frequency of matches at different
length thresholds. We then use statistical measures such as Cliff's delta,
Kolmogorov-Smirnov (KS) distance, and Kruskal-Wallis H test to determine
whether the distribution of verbatim matches differs significantly between
$D_{\rm pre}$ and $D_{\rm post}$. Our findings reveal a striking difference in
the distribution of verbatim matches between $D_{\rm pre}$ and $D_{\rm post}$,
with the frequency of verbatim reproduction being significantly higher when
LLMs (e.g. GPT models and LLaMAs) are prompted with text from datasets they
were likely trained on. For instance, when using GPT-3.5 on Wikipedia articles,
we observe a substantial effect size (Cliff's delta $= -0.984$) and a large KS
distance ($0.875$) between the distributions of $D_{\rm pre}$ and $D_{\rm
post}$. Our results provide compelling evidence that LLMs are more prone to
reproducing verbatim content when the input text is likely sourced from their
training data.
|
[
0.0631347895,
0.0450823493,
-0.0308914464,
0.0629437342,
-0.0828974396,
0.0262484066,
-0.0096227881,
0.0496995226,
0.0163414329,
-0.0399232842,
0.0049712011,
-0.0214734264,
0.0138454624,
0.0038887761,
0.0332210846,
-0.001774249,
0.0286912136,
-0.0044475212,
-0.0025385842,
-0.0211955439,
0.0476732403,
-0.0003008055,
0.0377271362,
0.0261277985,
0.0313977152,
0.0066374759,
-0.0004545574,
-0.0069593112,
0.0084630521,
-0.0120623661,
-0.0038386919,
0.0405688472,
0.0178530421,
0.067888312,
0.0000020085,
-0.061426308,
-0.0325487405,
0.0058736922,
-0.0499280915,
0.0433070473,
0.0336071774,
0.0329621397,
0.0105888797,
0.0107048303,
-0.0298130326,
0.0571562573,
0.0282267742,
0.0223559812,
0.045026511,
0.1131304279,
-0.0132853184,
0.0253311377,
0.041728761,
-0.026642086,
0.0349889658,
0.0332075059,
0.0402608924,
0.0072391243,
0.0285366457,
0.0394923761,
-0.0084608076,
0.0354951806,
-0.0002505543,
-0.0157723334,
-0.0082069524,
0.008001863,
-0.0225582216,
0.0038434078,
0.0248988457,
0.0449091755,
-0.007135273,
-0.0176138412,
0.0496876016,
0.0099720769,
0.0103200655,
0.0481664985,
-0.0438533202,
0.0219261013,
-0.0002214843,
-0.0015895427,
-0.0162664391,
-0.03521787,
0.0410480872,
0.0022734797,
0.0299217422,
0.0026308477,
0.0212838911,
-0.0492798053,
-0.0136568099,
-0.0261840466,
0.0000105602,
-0.079105258,
-0.0061921035,
-0.004144602,
0.0318395644,
0.0204104893,
-0.0706045553,
-0.0505370274,
0.0394088961,
0.0117588677,
0.0056184991,
0.0217114054,
0.0015057697,
0.0520490482,
-0.0192850884,
0.0242565386,
-0.0338906497,
0.0423201881,
0.0126106106,
0.0418722779,
-0.0497128479,
-0.0410646945,
0.0266395491,
0.0318615623,
0.043528825,
-0.034251865,
-0.0415937155,
0.018522054,
0.0127668129,
0.0186853837,
-0.0548928902,
-0.0160603505,
-0.0032064223,
-0.0123450896,
-0.0075722621,
-0.0225748923,
-0.0101922713,
0.0258419011,
0.015585714,
-0.0426118784,
-0.0449226163,
0.0243146308,
0.0002413703,
-0.0265316162,
-0.0098620793,
0.0386066996,
0.0095071597,
-0.0426814966,
-0.0270813778,
-0.092621997,
-0.0218598992,
-0.0076989555,
0.0016189546,
-0.0689279065,
0.020087922,
-0.0157712046,
-0.004902414,
-0.0358947366,
-0.0135222562,
0.0335496068,
-0.0566934794,
0.0449070409,
-0.0070305243,
-0.0017173789,
0.0098611629,
0.0197766852,
-0.0322555862,
0.0537977777,
0.0046186135,
0.0274852738,
0.0514449887,
0.0195506085,
0.0248351935,
0.0618165396,
0.0445594303,
0.047351148,
0.0105523914,
-0.0002673465,
0.0202749223,
0.0088345436,
0.0308866445,
0.0477745235,
-0.0479590297,
-0.0424509868,
0.085167706,
0.1034465209,
-0.0548109822,
-0.0275585391,
0.0440494418,
0.0338552818,
0.0117376,
0.0703327656,
-0.022991458,
-0.0345932543,
-0.0433160141,
-0.0164720472,
0.0338430479,
0.020350704,
0.0259240568,
0.0015220272,
-0.0131891798,
-0.023018958,
-0.003200257,
-0.0239503048,
0.0111707952,
0.0112607665,
-0.0071030725,
0.000719359,
0.0145896971,
-0.0161459688,
0.021679759,
-0.0657576323,
0.0268172324,
0.0537919812,
0.0653930381,
-0.0220624004,
0.0554866269,
-0.0506529547,
0.0176638998,
0.0147109963,
-0.0025784827,
-0.003949862,
-0.0208475813,
-0.0263513178,
-0.0434653983,
-0.0184043869,
0.0295449644,
0.0418821089,
0.0436651669,
0.0314076841,
0.0305940919,
-0.007304369,
-0.0394942053,
0.0334807783,
-0.0371280275,
-0.0126416804,
-0.0402567126,
-0.0109602436,
0.0500147641,
-0.0068397913,
-0.0307843983,
0.0147045776,
0.0161087662,
0.0086108036,
-0.0482966676,
-0.0183232259,
0.0296430327,
0.0053021358,
0.0363591611,
-0.0130906645,
0.0055655329,
0.0341087952,
-0.0088689337,
-0.0070358966,
0.0043587866,
-0.0409804545,
0.0632699952,
-0.0205028746,
0.0204092525,
-0.0125581492,
0.0423284918,
-0.0312609039,
0.0393265598,
0.001931852,
0.0237852801,
0.0695738345,
-0.0637243763,
0.0216507949,
-0.0312144049,
-0.0412305482,
-0.0081669567,
-0.0246783476,
0.0065824701,
0.0388260484,
-0.0267126672,
-0.0533308312,
-0.0156265385,
-0.0443920419,
0.0118493931,
-0.0196932796,
0.0331757851,
0.0264742021,
-0.0200425684,
-0.0527871214,
-0.0031981855,
-0.0289348885,
-0.0105483392,
-0.0055525997,
0.0415560901,
0.0349013656,
-0.0006137686,
-0.0226310063,
-0.0301799774,
0.0051863897,
-0.0208593849,
0.0524478257,
0.0414803326,
-0.0010077816,
-0.0290891752,
0.0352196917,
-0.0278791692,
-0.0353061743,
-0.029261753,
-0.0240779202,
-0.0053502866,
0.0049361158,
0.038162332,
0.0713251531,
0.0416695699,
0.0200517438,
0.0168938991,
-0.006669844,
-0.0737195984,
-0.0520559922,
-0.0208160188,
-0.0332330093,
-0.0635787845,
-0.0405694768,
0.0690179542,
-0.0001342879,
0.0374848954,
0.0104195401,
-0.0279749632,
0.0505159609,
-0.0025436224,
-0.0118891578,
-0.0181007851,
-0.0584171675,
-0.0480543748,
0.0194840245,
0.0090641351,
-0.0542877242,
0.0513098799,
-0.0656031296,
0.0522106513,
-0.0046172692,
-0.0119512044,
0.0309090205,
0.0289426353,
0.0247511473,
0.0103245769,
0.0828080699,
-0.0057899286,
-0.0440661572,
0.0077177212,
0.0813465938,
-0.0351177454,
0.0084402245,
-0.0084473547,
0.0165005829,
0.0192721467,
0.0073509961,
-0.0236364845,
-0.0873461068,
0.000420667,
-0.060330987,
0.0015348633,
-0.0387922637,
-0.0135467667,
-0.0399175733,
0.0499080643,
0.0056205839,
-0.0354130007,
-0.0043233531,
-0.0091480054,
0.0714330822,
0.055958055,
-0.0315471217,
0.0113856411,
-0.0181133598,
0.0031058504,
0.0683310255,
0.0117471218,
0.0455076285,
0.016487807,
-0.0443398729,
-0.0086378036,
-0.0227361377,
-0.0341647565,
0.0107803587,
0.0126801552,
-0.0652029961,
0.0248140153,
0.0958510041,
0.0152542694,
-0.0516345426,
-0.0271816701,
-0.0220943894,
0.0568910129,
0.0043283044,
-0.0033627031,
-0.113116011,
0.0038789096,
0.0149322422,
0.0399645865,
-0.0500729047,
-0.0443526246,
-0.0296779703,
-0.127202183,
0.0074397894,
-0.0020107666,
-0.0169220176,
0.0158199351,
-0.0436565429,
0.0133960722,
0.0254324228,
-0.0258613117,
-0.0195204746,
-0.0028582732,
0.013432092,
-0.0051222723,
-0.0637820736,
-0.0905744731,
0.0225620959,
-0.0352388471,
0.0733106434,
0.0369046964,
0.0151951201,
-0.0159484763,
-0.0062953113,
0.011804414,
-0.0219499897,
-0.0453681909,
0.0036696962,
0.1087575257,
-0.0195504203,
-0.0100082057,
0.0103915166,
0.0487419702,
0.0104441401,
0.0004182997,
0.0148752909,
0.0464965813,
0.0191283878,
-0.0259886924,
-0.0271697883,
-0.0130482083,
0.0363645256,
0.0781895444,
0.0326649398,
-0.003603647,
-0.0026848076,
-0.033720471,
-0.0149791185,
0.0020229397,
-0.0367816202,
-0.0194285437,
-0.0159515981,
-0.0021127816,
-0.0967171714,
-0.0096195741,
-0.0115395542,
-0.0031021282,
0.0167710036,
0.0299081337,
0.0190861654,
-0.0187066458,
-0.0053802519,
-0.025022788,
-0.0669522583,
0.0047846017,
-0.0385516807,
0.0258720722,
-0.010007536,
0.0165207498,
-0.0270233229,
-0.0104169212,
-0.1078321561,
-0.0704569072,
0.0044186432,
0.0244083945,
0.0228835512,
0.0656921268,
-0.0015754945,
-0.0328081064,
0.0614265464,
0.0192362424,
-0.0135030234,
0.0398885421,
0.016412111,
-0.0313570052,
0.0085911639,
0.0292195883,
-0.0381814167,
-0.0080855833,
0.0129993157,
-0.0645312294,
-0.0314058252,
0.027040353,
0.0203068536,
0.0471550487,
0.0228790343,
-0.0132212676,
0.02646772,
-0.0220728684,
-0.0027528792,
-0.0316038206,
-0.0057521039,
-0.0124996416,
0.0020458654,
0.0303186867,
-0.0082425335,
0.002463426,
-0.0204644054,
-0.0326466709,
0.0420147181,
-0.0589987934,
-0.0337530933,
0.019036632,
-0.0168258883,
0.04534683,
-0.0111127449,
0.0060394136,
0.0154353259,
-0.0193559453,
0.0622949749,
-0.0213070214,
0.0324130356,
0.0048056957,
-0.0258026682,
0.0725738406,
0.0257594232,
-0.0987296253,
-0.0385463648,
0.000435485,
-0.015911391,
0.0085314196,
-0.0340918861,
0.0503126681,
-0.0452804081,
-0.0049392879,
-0.0129064014,
-0.0272221193,
-0.0256425496,
-0.0101123368,
0.0147344721,
0.0149706872,
-0.0470218249,
0.0791247934,
0.0827741176,
0.0180337522,
0.0347133763,
0.0170179158,
-0.0694043785,
-0.0228257831,
-0.0172184203,
0.066557318,
0.0310053155,
-0.0069071753,
-0.0458380468,
-0.0367073081,
-0.0531744659,
0.0109114302,
-0.0057052476,
-0.0030669463,
0.0121915694,
0.0086207846,
0.0714835674,
-0.032952942,
0.0446425155,
-0.0356794856,
0.0294231083,
-0.0038321316,
-0.0539703779,
0.0131442826,
-6.1555118e-33,
0.0174488723,
-0.0315971114,
-0.0311026666,
0.0303429645,
-0.0307769794,
0.032021191,
-0.0191837009,
-0.0100670811,
-0.0245751999,
-0.0000234729,
-0.0138812307,
0.0192377195,
-0.0055850102,
0.0097592454,
-0.0069234688,
-0.035927467,
0.0103625525,
-0.0227874629,
-0.0403471291,
0.0155240735,
0.0646186173,
0.0111248912,
0.0350417718,
-0.0506809279,
0.0641444176,
-0.0283298343,
-0.0410524569,
-0.0312461052,
0.0098266937,
0.0430848114,
-0.0313469172,
0.0320050195,
0.0054789963,
-0.0278196987,
-0.0097296471,
0.0246906634,
0.0193429366,
-0.0153227849,
0.020521827,
-0.0328186229,
0.0319204628,
-0.0306889396,
0.0584914386,
-0.0307052881,
-0.0041724793,
-0.0199409649,
0.0354547463,
-0.0208618399,
-0.0005583645,
0.0033546807,
-0.0289252549,
0.0330805555,
-0.0174625032,
0.001614392,
-0.0182654895,
0.0472592898,
0.068776682,
0.0608315058,
-0.0600487851,
0.0466387235,
0.0113251237,
0.049184978,
0.0270520151,
-0.0348355509,
0.0277594142,
0.0715274438,
-0.0156884473,
-0.0264596716,
0.0047210422,
0.0086554149,
0.0145917488,
-0.0138902031,
0.0418019444,
0.0725754723,
0.052095592,
-0.0241216775,
-0.0373078696,
0.0078024981,
0.019852275,
0.0074564968,
0.0282555297,
-0.020859262,
-0.069909893,
-0.0227943156,
-0.011138998,
-0.0239589848,
-0.0059305709,
-0.0559327602,
0.0229940563,
-0.0021673834,
-0.0393382907,
-0.0387688465,
0.01505272,
-0.0506196581,
-0.0273944419,
0.0273023881,
-0.0597238019,
0.011983891,
0.0169733837,
0.0128140114,
-0.0238798223,
0.0169745218,
0.0169745553,
-0.0319947675,
0.0381341279,
0.0059351958,
0.0489405133,
0.0446784459,
-0.0885558799,
0.0020119476,
-0.0014196326,
0.007551475,
-0.0089817736,
-0.0158256255,
0.0270552281,
0.0051275291,
-0.0075789429,
-0.0124810431,
0.0446866192,
-0.0280721001,
-0.0505601354,
-0.0377929844,
-0.0364520624,
-0.0189245045,
-0.0075740488,
-0.020764837,
0.0003163259,
0.0436514579,
0.0248430073,
-0.0742530227,
0.0158733521,
-0.0260637589,
2.903e-7,
0.0340083279,
0.0233323462,
0.0274087526,
-0.0110240094,
0.0242579672,
0.0337313265,
-0.0077069551,
0.0485578775,
-0.0113556674,
-0.0783987641,
-0.0082177417,
-0.0001642267,
0.0230752211,
0.0020073741,
-0.1091180071,
-0.0102694416,
-0.1072998345,
-0.034895096,
-0.0751162618,
-0.029910123,
0.0623188652,
0.0610878952,
0.0527141429,
-0.0115130963,
-0.015365243,
-0.077473864,
0.0421064235,
-0.0239812862,
-0.0401132181,
0.0039494247,
0.0743734539,
0.0092217382,
0.0256679375,
0.0081071258,
-0.0249121394,
0.0156446397,
-0.0052986559,
0.0278481413,
0.0535028763,
0.0001023101,
-0.0512003005,
-0.0402671434,
0.0123579595,
-0.0682247207,
0.0619363971,
0.0012198656,
0.0122309551,
-0.0259825196,
-0.0422703251,
-0.0842716023,
0.0674989,
-0.0236252807,
-0.0293609705,
0.0207888782,
-0.0157688223,
0.0373611897,
0.0117002679,
-0.0708616152,
0.0005268013,
-0.0615063123,
-0.0410728492,
-0.0444306955,
-0.0476047695,
0.0167006627,
0.0112923756,
-0.0199836642,
0.0158246476,
3.000186911e-34,
0.0367287211,
-0.0356456898,
0.0240199286,
0.0209659692,
0.0272452254,
0.0269868169,
0.0172718633,
0.0082479008,
-0.0146337766,
-0.0662358627,
-0.0106751639
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16892v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16892v1
|
Multilingual Entity Linking Using Dense Retrieval
| 2024-05-13T18:57:27 | 2024-05-13T18:57:27 |
Dominik Farhan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Entity linking (EL) is the computational process of connecting textual
mentions to corresponding entities. Like many areas of natural language
processing, the EL field has greatly benefited from deep learning, leading to
significant performance improvements. However, present-day approaches are
expensive to train and rely on diverse data sources, complicating their
reproducibility. In this thesis, we develop multiple systems that are fast to
train, demonstrating that competitive entity linking can be achieved without a
large GPU cluster. Moreover, we train on a publicly available dataset, ensuring
reproducibility and accessibility. Our models are evaluated for 9 languages
giving an accurate overview of their strengths. Furthermore, we offer
a~detailed analysis of bi-encoder training hyperparameters, a popular approach
in EL, to guide their informed selection. Overall, our work shows that building
competitive neural network based EL systems that operate in multiple languages
is possible even with limited resources, thus making EL more approachable.
|
Multilingual Entity Linking Using Dense Retrieval: Entity linking (EL) is the computational process of connecting textual
mentions to corresponding entities. Like many areas of natural language
processing, the EL field has greatly benefited from deep learning, leading to
significant performance improvements. However, present-day approaches are
expensive to train and rely on diverse data sources, complicating their
reproducibility. In this thesis, we develop multiple systems that are fast to
train, demonstrating that competitive entity linking can be achieved without a
large GPU cluster. Moreover, we train on a publicly available dataset, ensuring
reproducibility and accessibility. Our models are evaluated for 9 languages
giving an accurate overview of their strengths. Furthermore, we offer
a~detailed analysis of bi-encoder training hyperparameters, a popular approach
in EL, to guide their informed selection. Overall, our work shows that building
competitive neural network based EL systems that operate in multiple languages
is possible even with limited resources, thus making EL more approachable.
|
[
0.014656472,
0.0437455364,
-0.0067832647,
0.0314976163,
0.0081764301,
0.0219765287,
0.0158356447,
-0.0264326446,
0.0178241972,
-0.0194095094,
-0.0024093313,
-0.0001691094,
0.0152912717,
0.0276518911,
0.0403749123,
-0.0304646343,
0.0341248251,
-0.0070737246,
0.00490832,
-0.0350522324,
-0.0224861503,
0.0494867899,
0.0012790271,
0.0062415753,
-0.0122351265,
0.0303521696,
0.0027049766,
0.0058021098,
0.0233915579,
-0.0279818904,
-0.0146091254,
0.0107494714,
-0.0000303841,
0.0710870996,
0.000001937,
-0.0536572449,
-0.0330183953,
-0.0158213489,
-0.0269246362,
-0.0031320828,
-0.0233451631,
-0.0366261564,
0.0058068656,
-0.0301588532,
-0.010350829,
-0.0568559058,
0.0266478527,
0.0227504838,
0.0359032378,
0.0341487788,
-0.0243953578,
-0.0538149253,
0.058642976,
-0.0495400801,
-0.0615018159,
-0.0466839895,
0.0107193775,
-0.0452940166,
-0.0282151196,
0.0297249313,
0.0022559066,
0.068630904,
0.0266512707,
0.0336503461,
-0.0053846245,
0.0168124381,
-0.0511667281,
-0.000500844,
0.0242209956,
0.0914841294,
-0.0497393869,
-0.0128121637,
0.018385781,
0.0208610296,
-0.0160339009,
-0.0233003683,
-0.0233318452,
0.0174784083,
0.0062595219,
0.0261362344,
-0.0022948175,
0.0062924651,
0.0600152314,
0.0221312363,
0.0067919618,
0.0037111982,
0.0161951333,
-0.0122231925,
0.0437404923,
0.0490775369,
-0.0089668129,
-0.0213763081,
0.0414636023,
0.0043440396,
-0.0375435762,
0.0163124166,
-0.031139601,
-0.0355758034,
0.0148442136,
-0.0547443703,
-0.0397228152,
-0.0200566091,
-0.004222041,
0.0431211926,
-0.0863005742,
-0.0039148587,
-0.021812316,
-0.0181285329,
0.0091782082,
-0.0829942524,
-0.0123439748,
0.0010337393,
-0.0359662473,
0.0105711566,
-0.0364871062,
0.0110475076,
-0.0481300317,
-0.0285935365,
-0.0366508104,
0.0981231034,
-0.005229752,
0.0151026491,
-0.0158884954,
-0.0044672601,
-0.0422341637,
0.0165039208,
-0.0563661344,
-0.0263782442,
-0.0316032693,
-0.0657578111,
0.0002141659,
0.0216894411,
0.0005780357,
-0.0689567998,
0.037114799,
0.0645755157,
0.0014005685,
-0.0078211483,
-0.0180054754,
-0.0403885096,
0.0327308849,
-0.0519896448,
-0.0009048888,
-0.1055282727,
0.0644338131,
-0.0072083869,
0.0006135319,
-0.092757605,
0.0217279475,
0.0163083747,
-0.0708406195,
0.0795297176,
-0.0469179824,
-0.0449869148,
0.0388323031,
-0.0050501875,
0.0635979399,
0.0508237891,
0.0677181855,
0.0089692324,
0.0664043427,
0.0367521755,
-0.0188354161,
0.0265408903,
0.0395159982,
-0.0238052476,
0.0239024628,
0.003801926,
-0.0198398735,
0.0655336678,
0.0485829376,
0.0711716935,
-0.0431164242,
-0.0535563231,
0.0213501807,
0.0216430072,
-0.0013245345,
0.0477432087,
0.0508396067,
-0.0329861008,
-0.0143760554,
-0.0584637076,
-0.0151888644,
0.0322167948,
0.014655997,
0.0010829661,
0.0451240502,
0.0645125434,
-0.0360636525,
-0.0035447187,
0.0259307139,
-0.0211449917,
0.0032839146,
0.0218947865,
0.0793459564,
0.0053518265,
-0.0232864451,
0.0771156102,
0.0187547356,
-0.0188831519,
0.0077826651,
0.0102556655,
-0.0394636206,
0.0336502343,
0.0159086417,
0.0487258323,
-0.0162182208,
-0.0330592506,
-0.0177128091,
0.0336954556,
0.0347143188,
-0.0297092944,
0.0414666086,
-0.0580491535,
0.0041792458,
0.002072141,
-0.020808477,
0.038163349,
0.0254968815,
0.0751107931,
0.0316195376,
-0.0052275346,
0.0012247839,
0.0141543401,
-0.0317110457,
0.0045951335,
-0.0031734875,
0.0419318229,
-0.0249257926,
0.0509262681,
0.0206636898,
-0.0384249575,
0.0407796726,
-0.0384121165,
0.0063444176,
0.0213956032,
0.0162083637,
-0.0275255758,
0.0211724825,
-0.0394780189,
-0.0107904989,
0.0019632997,
-0.0112790149,
-0.0457901731,
0.0164314769,
0.0111993272,
0.0122387037,
-0.01433169,
0.0048097116,
0.0071831592,
0.0344088599,
-0.0204768013,
0.0570566319,
-0.0063170339,
0.034536168,
0.0435024947,
0.0053308797,
0.0471301377,
-0.0462093465,
-0.0733779967,
0.0395270698,
0.0237366855,
-0.0162806194,
0.006209963,
-0.0181839094,
-0.0338202603,
0.0004529896,
-0.0638440922,
0.0402279161,
-0.0150353331,
0.0057016537,
-0.0144840507,
0.0148127014,
-0.0099272802,
-0.0174208451,
-0.0095836204,
-0.00242929,
-0.0095753139,
0.0154276108,
0.0469516963,
0.0130575802,
0.0098198755,
-0.0470310897,
-0.0271164551,
0.0035478284,
0.0637117103,
-0.0077416794,
-0.0575182252,
-0.0311026312,
-0.0004434976,
-0.0422921591,
0.0352145247,
-0.011470017,
0.0100655947,
-0.0216947347,
0.0273800679,
0.0239771642,
0.0556224287,
-0.0465385392,
0.0286194831,
0.0120624034,
-0.0248343404,
-0.0768337026,
0.0531908758,
0.0088109579,
0.0170494914,
-0.0334519222,
-0.0111904871,
-0.0236257371,
0.0155763598,
-0.0610573664,
-0.0072735306,
-0.0163490884,
-0.0108972657,
0.048362229,
-0.0128678633,
-0.0191087816,
0.0203187969,
0.0342259668,
0.0192939639,
-0.0084387232,
-0.0149422474,
0.0188556444,
-0.0350358635,
0.0032382815,
-0.013107135,
-0.0144048007,
-0.0360927768,
0.0399068296,
0.0232146848,
0.0163566824,
-0.0344794691,
-0.0130246766,
0.0011424239,
0.0861483216,
0.0012335569,
-0.005639127,
0.0213662218,
-0.0051083532,
0.0237050019,
-0.0141260577,
-0.0305014141,
-0.0059314477,
0.0298338644,
-0.0652327687,
0.0262631755,
0.0043791612,
-0.0176150147,
-0.0501492433,
0.0283076707,
0.0284850933,
0.044555977,
0.0281719342,
-0.025297476,
0.0066564507,
0.0316420086,
0.0545763858,
0.0071258675,
0.0236367621,
0.0022232158,
-0.0189028271,
0.0448344052,
0.0284483116,
-0.033680167,
-0.0192546416,
-0.0164790135,
0.0244821981,
-0.0639171153,
-0.0566324517,
-0.0326035917,
0.015762642,
-0.052121494,
-0.0096655311,
0.09301579,
0.0143840946,
-0.0849416628,
-0.0148593504,
0.0263827853,
0.0137816658,
0.0067891176,
0.0358055383,
-0.0859966874,
-0.0288300477,
-0.0105390605,
-0.0366248339,
0.0230124667,
-0.0670227334,
-0.0000041304,
-0.1349284649,
-0.0331335068,
-0.0299935751,
-0.0093502291,
-0.0707682595,
-0.0508551002,
-0.0011375562,
-0.0489614345,
-0.0070494064,
-0.0223612618,
0.0325096548,
0.0100050112,
-0.0124903545,
0.0014625677,
-0.0210532211,
0.0066842446,
-0.0997434631,
0.0428612828,
0.0243571512,
0.0441911109,
-0.0020573372,
-0.0141326478,
-0.031402085,
-0.0357796103,
-0.0388044789,
-0.0070125982,
0.0640452951,
-0.052141279,
-0.0050186305,
0.0087919319,
-0.0215291269,
-0.034754727,
0.0056713358,
-0.0162039101,
0.0432595015,
0.0449079312,
0.0122244321,
0.0002647827,
-0.0329129733,
-0.0057019116,
0.0448656045,
-0.0435668565,
-0.0231112037,
-0.0099659003,
-0.0441000722,
0.0228121504,
-0.0434488952,
-0.0073456285,
0.0111906994,
-0.0394776203,
-0.0165675618,
-0.066106014,
-0.0652080402,
0.0394365937,
0.0436977223,
-0.0156744048,
0.0376425348,
0.0213842243,
0.0010430322,
-0.0481417216,
0.0549134836,
-0.0314128324,
0.0243093967,
-0.0221625492,
0.0046020425,
0.0442251936,
-0.0197196938,
-0.0336328074,
0.0054063085,
-0.0684329942,
-0.0342375152,
-0.0306702685,
0.0194927957,
0.0099149691,
0.0622227937,
-0.0397556424,
-0.0724026859,
-0.0179270953,
0.0283040013,
-0.0279338788,
0.0021942784,
0.018400196,
0.0064354222,
-0.0141234761,
0.0401013196,
-0.0382222459,
-0.0027687366,
-0.0029007278,
0.0240687206,
-0.0599172115,
-0.0690803081,
-0.0220644679,
-0.0093987351,
0.05050648,
-0.0157891102,
0.0032274032,
-0.0399000309,
0.0253793206,
0.0161033645,
0.0058826189,
-0.0194980055,
0.0199571718,
0.0089305025,
0.0509140119,
-0.0195727069,
-0.0080852229,
0.0877423435,
-0.0128414305,
-0.0478281789,
0.0031226838,
0.0259499848,
0.0135275451,
-0.0217738468,
0.0185865611,
-0.002454364,
0.0294274818,
0.0137926452,
0.0955635607,
-0.0721498653,
-0.0206522681,
-0.0021431262,
-0.0127890781,
0.0207047518,
0.0407003872,
-0.0063107004,
-0.0003490033,
-0.0072860126,
0.0044841836,
0.1240768656,
-0.0119151101,
0.0673813745,
0.0134103606,
-0.0150139183,
0.0266733877,
-0.0071395496,
-0.0204618983,
-0.009972834,
0.0015114715,
0.0126594733,
-0.0122030936,
0.0761093721,
0.0569107085,
0.0064113671,
0.0428264067,
0.0230578762,
0.0034384518,
-0.0267261229,
-0.0034955651,
-0.0047052386,
0.0305906534,
-0.016009327,
-0.0234519709,
0.0314386897,
-0.064115718,
0.061768122,
-0.0230325107,
-0.0077051148,
0.0299889054,
0.0580482073,
0.0447551832,
0.0268998537,
-0.0085781915,
-0.0114106517,
0.004968551,
0.0147058284,
-0.0240135361,
-0.0351394303,
-5.611590728e-33,
-0.0273048971,
-0.0063468223,
0.0194656923,
-0.0375561826,
-0.0082556903,
-0.0135309678,
-0.0038678751,
-0.0322854705,
-0.0875268206,
-0.0121329073,
-0.004702792,
-0.0009481198,
0.0154352318,
0.029352542,
0.0158817284,
-0.0422430262,
0.0328760259,
0.0186068919,
0.0110424319,
0.0057994919,
0.0473100469,
0.0372537337,
0.0841600299,
-0.0646814182,
0.0300015826,
0.001310645,
-0.0112196347,
0.0437905863,
0.031438712,
0.0731976777,
-0.0058139819,
0.0259739924,
-0.0030012894,
-0.0272222925,
0.0162986033,
-0.0122336997,
-0.1415268034,
-0.0227560997,
-0.0257813558,
0.0404718742,
-0.0170574915,
-0.0371730253,
0.0394209363,
0.0203948095,
0.0543548129,
0.0047316561,
0.0401504114,
-0.0033630896,
-0.0335562751,
-0.0744969994,
-0.0294229258,
0.0453430675,
0.0110136392,
0.0678574592,
0.0796996206,
0.003652123,
-0.0074498998,
0.0148451934,
-0.1169688851,
-0.0184924603,
-0.0516726114,
0.0129910568,
0.0338819176,
-0.0322092511,
-0.0020342001,
0.0584619045,
0.0169672184,
-0.0216214117,
-0.0213420559,
0.0709878132,
0.0196329262,
-0.0134022227,
0.0482062735,
0.0628250912,
0.01839827,
-0.0291728023,
-0.1019530371,
0.0082739769,
0.0514726862,
0.0115355002,
-0.0283607803,
0.007460787,
-0.0072082649,
-0.0119816093,
-0.0318666995,
-0.0153116295,
-0.0042485101,
-0.0431824997,
-0.00035104,
0.0089838421,
-0.0132032242,
0.0766392201,
0.013499504,
-0.0019521499,
-0.0225041267,
0.0205562785,
0.0354886055,
0.0334683545,
0.0293674059,
0.0296165124,
-0.0587466583,
-0.021685278,
-0.0029840083,
-0.0151680214,
0.0220507681,
0.0212027468,
0.0454541594,
-0.0263381116,
-0.0666496158,
0.0040558991,
0.0066597359,
0.0108704213,
-0.0286039803,
0.0359174684,
-0.0042343703,
0.0034296946,
0.004510202,
0.0093611712,
0.0449266694,
-0.0099201985,
-0.0364582725,
0.0147717679,
0.0238015894,
-0.0068903859,
-0.0015070029,
-0.0077798814,
-0.0537844412,
0.011297198,
-0.0076130456,
-0.0963049755,
-0.0239591505,
0.0109301964,
2.59e-7,
0.0171388444,
0.0358983278,
-0.0025723611,
0.0040967986,
-0.0222920682,
-0.0095833074,
0.0534571558,
0.0520620644,
0.0002229599,
-0.0032133511,
-0.0248917192,
0.025710905,
0.0055587874,
0.0516337752,
-0.112686716,
-0.0483308323,
-0.0766608045,
0.0021435153,
-0.0404938757,
-0.0399163999,
0.0028486995,
0.0703703463,
0.0141930189,
0.0219571497,
-0.0144080007,
-0.0372982845,
0.0477977544,
-0.0162123796,
0.0114552546,
0.0088587394,
0.0075870231,
0.0275201201,
-0.0486399159,
0.0549694672,
-0.011561499,
0.0631417111,
0.0467934944,
0.0437020063,
0.0127675133,
-0.0158847142,
0.0046798866,
-0.0636599064,
-0.0171371233,
-0.003857628,
0.0780005306,
-0.0022935937,
0.0007936755,
0.0288493484,
-0.0145542342,
0.0424822308,
0.0444093831,
-0.0070239981,
-0.0207201969,
0.0253568385,
0.0273761917,
-0.0206363201,
-0.0180866998,
-0.0766885951,
-0.0094057657,
-0.002764961,
0.0033299127,
-0.0085401041,
-0.0132716,
-0.0544641912,
0.0096638752,
-0.0070129442,
0.0180836692,
2.175086074e-34,
0.0103817666,
0.0004864896,
-0.0108944941,
0.0194466393,
0.0463489443,
-0.0548126996,
-0.0524299778,
0.0093924962,
0.0013558022,
-0.0482865833,
-0.0071745357
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08099v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08099v1
|
KET-QA: A Dataset for Knowledge Enhanced Table Question Answering
| 2024-05-13T18:26:32 | 2024-05-13T18:26:32 |
Mengkang Hu, Haoyu Dong, Ping Luo, Shi Han, Dongmei Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Due to the concise and structured nature of tables, the knowledge contained
therein may be incomplete or missing, posing a significant challenge for table
question answering (TableQA) and data analysis systems. Most existing datasets
either fail to address the issue of external knowledge in TableQA or only
utilize unstructured text as supplementary information for tables. In this
paper, we propose to use a knowledge base (KB) as the external knowledge source
for TableQA and construct a dataset KET-QA with fine-grained gold evidence
annotation. Each table in the dataset corresponds to a sub-graph of the entire
KB, and every question requires the integration of information from both the
table and the sub-graph to be answered. To extract pertinent information from
the vast knowledge sub-graph and apply it to TableQA, we design a
retriever-reasoner structured pipeline model. Experimental results demonstrate
that our model consistently achieves remarkable relative performance
improvements ranging from 1.9 to 6.5 times and absolute improvements of 11.66%
to 44.64% on EM scores across three distinct settings (fine-tuning, zero-shot,
and few-shot), in comparison with solely relying on table information in the
traditional TableQA manner. However, even the best model achieves a 60.23% EM
score, which still lags behind the human-level performance, highlighting the
challenging nature of KET-QA for the question-answering community. We also
provide a human evaluation of error cases to analyze further the aspects in
which the model can be improved. Project page: https://ketqa.github.io/.
|
KET-QA: A Dataset for Knowledge Enhanced Table Question Answering: Due to the concise and structured nature of tables, the knowledge contained
therein may be incomplete or missing, posing a significant challenge for table
question answering (TableQA) and data analysis systems. Most existing datasets
either fail to address the issue of external knowledge in TableQA or only
utilize unstructured text as supplementary information for tables. In this
paper, we propose to use a knowledge base (KB) as the external knowledge source
for TableQA and construct a dataset KET-QA with fine-grained gold evidence
annotation. Each table in the dataset corresponds to a sub-graph of the entire
KB, and every question requires the integration of information from both the
table and the sub-graph to be answered. To extract pertinent information from
the vast knowledge sub-graph and apply it to TableQA, we design a
retriever-reasoner structured pipeline model. Experimental results demonstrate
that our model consistently achieves remarkable relative performance
improvements ranging from 1.9 to 6.5 times and absolute improvements of 11.66%
to 44.64% on EM scores across three distinct settings (fine-tuning, zero-shot,
and few-shot), in comparison with solely relying on table information in the
traditional TableQA manner. However, even the best model achieves a 60.23% EM
score, which still lags behind the human-level performance, highlighting the
challenging nature of KET-QA for the question-answering community. We also
provide a human evaluation of error cases to analyze further the aspects in
which the model can be improved. Project page: https://ketqa.github.io/.
|
[
0.0444142893,
0.0372465625,
-0.0132625094,
0.0312863775,
-0.0210332163,
0.0431228168,
-0.0386563465,
0.0246449281,
0.0101437103,
-0.0134998485,
-0.0292811487,
0.0490941927,
-0.0490274243,
0.0374594815,
0.0283094347,
0.0021629373,
0.03411033,
0.0234683342,
0.0182981435,
0.012379962,
0.0353045426,
-0.0079095094,
-0.0287720691,
0.0191449244,
-0.0177540053,
-0.0074592778,
-0.0267166514,
-0.0285639036,
-0.0128072742,
0.0029832027,
0.0257990286,
0.0596584938,
0.0116653442,
0.0028452897,
0.0000020312,
0.0223499648,
-0.024790857,
0.004048252,
-0.0649164245,
-0.0260026697,
-0.0497774705,
-0.0109313037,
0.0469254889,
0.0078434581,
-0.0543726832,
0.0014184203,
0.0227292571,
0.0636065602,
0.0644201711,
0.0272019338,
0.0145457089,
-0.0345712714,
-0.0244177263,
0.005114797,
0.0410024971,
-0.052885022,
0.0225766245,
0.0447884463,
0.018922871,
-0.0016207632,
0.0081728455,
0.049942892,
0.031699378,
-0.0056476649,
0.0118125444,
0.0425599515,
-0.0275918208,
0.0356179848,
0.0199138951,
0.1231939495,
0.0413925238,
-0.0229674168,
0.0046598483,
0.0017430863,
0.0287540779,
0.0203433204,
-0.0563089587,
-0.0300921146,
-0.0247413591,
-0.0460498668,
0.0038116302,
-0.0132860765,
-0.002687227,
-0.008883859,
-0.0092632752,
0.0620284453,
-0.0246203188,
-0.0434424467,
0.0082115363,
0.0076884269,
-0.0581382662,
-0.0217839442,
-0.0041064075,
0.0637082383,
-0.0253450628,
0.0395597853,
0.0337912478,
-0.0159517191,
0.0390288867,
-0.0309397243,
-0.0037056536,
0.0323083363,
-0.0042704055,
0.0532856956,
-0.03110715,
0.0148213608,
-0.0217674579,
0.0360472836,
-0.0274324566,
-0.029700648,
-0.0625991672,
-0.0181162059,
-0.0502843186,
0.0381799899,
-0.0632638037,
-0.014469712,
0.0206374172,
0.0123171574,
-0.0029210174,
0.0267728083,
0.0375844724,
0.0545129217,
0.0009344319,
0.0154088978,
-0.0536825508,
0.0298620425,
-0.0724202022,
0.0147117255,
-0.0058359532,
-0.055208277,
-0.0312945507,
-0.0136750434,
0.0343534648,
-0.021388324,
0.0253684539,
0.0531164147,
-0.0177056883,
-0.0019969635,
-0.0323095918,
-0.045838058,
-0.0299099516,
-0.0305690095,
-0.0063496367,
-0.0318239778,
0.0713041946,
0.0254384335,
-0.0065143392,
-0.0369766764,
0.0060982653,
0.0469470695,
-0.0162163135,
0.0413791314,
-0.0201346427,
0.0142799905,
0.0157435481,
0.0048393975,
-0.0731324255,
0.0821855515,
0.0190956723,
-0.0068583111,
0.0032718107,
-0.0239707008,
-0.0322813652,
-0.0007165907,
0.0582510531,
-0.0107948268,
0.0290481765,
0.0813113451,
-0.0340773799,
0.0244296938,
-0.0238655526,
0.0094016436,
-0.040959619,
0.0187985208,
0.0001793398,
0.0140631245,
0.0206826236,
0.0369698144,
-0.0001473535,
0.0007247224,
0.0492467359,
0.0071613276,
-0.0068389727,
0.0663389713,
-0.0001287217,
0.0222003516,
0.0064581377,
-0.0191628784,
-0.021581741,
-0.0392833501,
0.0110350093,
0.036771547,
-0.0366596282,
0.0254948959,
0.0298803877,
0.0365429893,
-0.0534432866,
0.0117533756,
0.0169067364,
-0.0211519469,
-0.0185554065,
-0.0028047671,
0.0717872381,
0.0504688695,
0.042378664,
-0.0582812019,
-0.0273091253,
0.0118802292,
-0.0021929026,
-0.0182169974,
-0.0023151934,
-0.0579078346,
-0.0128868939,
-0.0056253807,
-0.0394700617,
-0.0061894599,
0.020797072,
-0.0257048141,
0.0455851741,
0.0137011958,
-0.0150001161,
-0.047256954,
-0.0092802811,
0.0090015046,
0.0363757908,
-0.0096916622,
-0.0205741543,
0.0048740273,
0.014065274,
0.0342224985,
0.0058986899,
0.0448311456,
0.0263110101,
-0.0302420575,
-0.0177841187,
-0.0115386322,
-0.0277836416,
-0.0272399373,
0.0291731395,
0.0172333103,
-0.0441017821,
-0.0208383463,
-0.0405546837,
-0.0596625954,
-0.0054282085,
-0.0371364243,
-0.0264050439,
-0.0062912777,
-0.0408745706,
0.0410273261,
-0.0147530194,
-0.0143890791,
0.0851831809,
0.016587181,
0.0262898486,
-0.0187275168,
-0.0846609175,
0.0281501524,
-0.0271256734,
0.0196466446,
-0.0316660739,
-0.0061111022,
0.0338785797,
0.0275346003,
0.0082483916,
-0.0863161907,
0.0125628151,
-0.0797070041,
0.0326684192,
-0.0410729945,
0.0230185781,
0.0362915657,
0.0124634719,
-0.0161630586,
-0.0330656134,
-0.0561920442,
0.010180735,
-0.0090988576,
0.0212091524,
0.0625457093,
0.0360654257,
0.0191339292,
-0.0430530682,
-0.0275718812,
-0.013571132,
0.028292276,
0.0026755198,
-0.0095484117,
0.0124587379,
-0.010446351,
-0.0267904606,
0.0142728323,
0.0146684544,
-0.0024721762,
-0.0015184206,
-0.0274255872,
0.0090258922,
0.0274408236,
-0.0465359464,
0.0001792795,
-0.0002905772,
-0.0103937136,
-0.0407017246,
0.0240484904,
-0.0284267254,
0.0301960539,
0.023633251,
-0.0217577703,
0.0378623679,
0.0261249188,
0.0031684777,
-0.0027124344,
-0.0618126392,
0.0475537255,
0.0116073228,
0.0129611008,
-0.1029782146,
0.0430697836,
0.0221064128,
0.007011455,
-0.0510361455,
0.0485508852,
0.0459590666,
-0.0022946692,
0.0276523549,
-0.0162261389,
0.0262563601,
-0.0560989194,
0.0511460565,
-0.0080841305,
-0.0038371889,
-0.0195206292,
-0.0054264297,
-0.0193313491,
-0.0180527959,
0.0323399082,
-0.0405781008,
0.0766905993,
-0.0410036854,
0.0168993454,
0.0024125308,
-0.0306166299,
-0.0180535689,
-0.0135197146,
-0.0512140058,
0.0219334997,
0.0042107352,
-0.0147796934,
0.0019963412,
-0.018872438,
0.0362140425,
0.0247579385,
-0.0205451213,
-0.0210175775,
-0.0265198275,
0.0712427646,
0.0785702318,
0.0242418293,
-0.0169456229,
0.0111594582,
0.0675288066,
0.0829225853,
-0.0163409002,
-0.0399393812,
0.0020705122,
0.0148184868,
-0.0027772917,
-0.0440641977,
0.0056681549,
0.0090648085,
0.0028174806,
-0.0602316894,
-0.0075100926,
0.0669804662,
0.0238240995,
0.021364985,
-0.0182735454,
0.004396454,
0.0356216133,
0.0148236649,
0.0431052856,
-0.1077743247,
-0.0491495579,
-0.0144858845,
0.01331071,
0.0100943958,
-0.0617793351,
0.0052559394,
-0.0895154104,
0.0169763584,
-0.0516000316,
-0.0497110337,
-0.1116783693,
-0.049088221,
-0.0021320386,
-0.019247409,
0.0038634851,
0.0499947257,
0.0029966456,
0.0461766906,
0.0359882787,
-0.0271856077,
-0.0280657243,
0.0253562015,
-0.0418337137,
0.0085992822,
0.0143896416,
0.0200903844,
-0.0100034829,
-0.0199311171,
-0.0542813614,
-0.0493614078,
0.0323130488,
0.0068318322,
0.062198963,
-0.0091673657,
-0.0207444951,
-0.0272862464,
-0.0018304563,
-0.0577196889,
0.0057809642,
0.0468078889,
0.0769900009,
-0.029213218,
0.0138478363,
0.0138481911,
-0.0135725737,
-0.0202292744,
0.0677463189,
0.0586410388,
0.0473967902,
-0.0424996428,
-0.00052157,
-0.0474579893,
-0.0778224766,
0.0229763575,
0.0507071503,
0.0010718246,
0.0398900583,
-0.0793950185,
-0.0372401588,
0.0764126182,
0.0442877747,
-0.0269840173,
0.0459809825,
-0.0266732872,
-0.0023115622,
-0.0530034825,
0.0152321402,
-0.0594079979,
-0.0066626375,
-0.0024119685,
-0.0357336961,
-0.0128196245,
-0.0115551921,
-0.0404185988,
0.0130886296,
-0.0338577144,
-0.0058737337,
-0.0095925964,
0.026007982,
0.0145931151,
0.0056289663,
0.0002663873,
-0.0049122749,
-0.002827215,
-0.0204253402,
-0.0922711417,
-0.0609815605,
-0.006826608,
-0.0417244248,
-0.0076446082,
0.0316724554,
-0.0545950197,
-0.0198823828,
-0.0093800873,
0.0619156398,
-0.0271278229,
0.0217686146,
0.0512339361,
0.0222671404,
-0.017421389,
0.0678129345,
-0.0493838117,
-0.0304743629,
0.0278115422,
-0.0483737104,
-0.025180256,
0.0016965643,
0.0111137256,
-0.0044520162,
-0.0532792844,
-0.0267909765,
-0.0072974637,
0.0126733026,
0.0186130144,
-0.0538067557,
-0.0112858396,
0.0766274631,
-0.0228434224,
0.01152605,
-0.0410474278,
-0.0281616617,
-0.0296856631,
0.0363218188,
0.0378232487,
0.003026993,
0.0228789952,
0.0381470099,
-0.0509583578,
-0.0316332616,
0.0387001894,
-0.0647727922,
-0.0707628578,
0.0068477071,
0.0049156435,
0.0326914117,
0.0046923244,
0.0125511028,
-0.0112686707,
-0.0396457464,
0.0449611098,
0.0146181034,
0.0254797079,
0.0160370022,
0.0759535804,
0.0270074401,
-0.006620639,
-0.0240556542,
0.0885287225,
0.0060031614,
0.0517745428,
-0.0169877838,
-0.0303645171,
-0.0523156747,
0.0115824798,
-0.0158294588,
0.0025647338,
-0.0156380534,
-0.0109574059,
-0.0370345488,
-0.0412273929,
0.0101615479,
0.0391597152,
-0.0441572778,
0.0150347184,
0.0437789932,
0.0372083634,
0.0674727485,
-0.0484131277,
-0.0499975458,
0.0360199846,
-0.0415713191,
-0.0101826312,
-0.0058138319,
-6.453150276e-33,
-0.0328090787,
-0.0234262124,
0.0253529027,
-0.0247925408,
0.0050267773,
0.0030214707,
-0.0514912419,
-0.0273771994,
-0.0367192514,
0.0412824638,
-0.0292828027,
0.045510672,
0.0024728826,
-0.0200866871,
0.0078853937,
-0.0882660374,
0.0064458996,
-0.0115307495,
0.0008427927,
0.0376514904,
0.0293792728,
0.0331579112,
0.0034287714,
0.0135240545,
0.0487125516,
0.0115719475,
0.0074469112,
0.0121803693,
-0.0241211262,
0.0487157926,
-0.0249058343,
0.0512094907,
0.0427915826,
-0.0532401986,
-0.0094460705,
-0.0013561548,
-0.1664676219,
-0.053238079,
0.0007313947,
-0.0015182805,
-0.0348063037,
-0.0210431479,
0.0221588686,
0.0002383151,
0.0388259701,
-0.0152708944,
0.016740296,
-0.0048598214,
0.0022015343,
-0.0154334186,
0.005278666,
0.0181379784,
-0.0357047655,
0.0099643096,
0.0130594196,
0.0451010354,
0.0374574885,
-0.023851715,
-0.0555278659,
-0.0049704243,
-0.0088328896,
0.0090633184,
0.0183048379,
-0.035886988,
0.0176675376,
0.0191028733,
-0.0001049436,
0.0070379488,
-0.0479384288,
0.0181856975,
-0.0707458332,
0.0655946806,
0.0812143534,
0.0023540759,
0.0156847872,
-0.0040444382,
-0.0716838762,
0.0565219782,
-0.0183414854,
0.0509245284,
-0.0334579498,
-0.0301736854,
-0.046668984,
-0.0209267512,
-0.0275597163,
0.014807093,
-0.0412483402,
-0.001833667,
0.0187334586,
-0.0127630327,
0.0039476515,
-0.0165139083,
-0.0154447695,
0.0012281322,
0.0325825848,
0.0727930367,
-0.0042744065,
0.0087035717,
0.0243748929,
0.0089006228,
-0.0544778183,
0.0071249972,
0.0362610854,
-0.0269297604,
0.021877775,
0.0437176302,
0.0436998606,
0.0021416361,
-0.0406531766,
-0.0084107844,
-0.0633951053,
0.0562165082,
-0.0321272016,
-0.0121310493,
-0.0011045327,
0.0575997233,
0.0008153484,
0.0303388778,
0.032922253,
0.0444399677,
0.0035285859,
0.0168707054,
0.0087573677,
-0.0120916693,
0.0251393504,
0.0041106981,
-0.0235215053,
0.0003105433,
-0.0238082074,
-0.0313948952,
0.0071774903,
0.0172044225,
2.588e-7,
0.0851099864,
-0.0141493939,
0.0715624541,
0.0541209057,
-0.0055078696,
0.0083225202,
0.0062843091,
-0.0178220104,
-0.0019749673,
-0.0386207029,
0.0415450335,
0.0161237828,
0.0161883086,
0.034595415,
-0.0478811488,
-0.0678039864,
-0.0635954365,
-0.0376747437,
-0.0322936848,
-0.0130075859,
0.0677573904,
0.0504586883,
-0.0354759544,
-0.0077486075,
-0.0313074626,
-0.0249971375,
0.0295346286,
0.0002633626,
0.0234306306,
0.0157135855,
0.0771805421,
-0.0231230464,
0.0243413821,
0.0653000996,
-0.030600423,
-0.0008512822,
0.0035689231,
0.0273995847,
-0.0001395439,
0.0011519355,
-0.0272082835,
-0.053100355,
0.0632823557,
-0.076789178,
0.1218808442,
-0.0442204997,
-0.018494878,
0.0680392981,
-0.0444430076,
-0.0052695866,
0.0044366308,
0.0142966956,
-0.0157314856,
-0.0042930734,
0.0218731351,
0.0244533345,
0.0297970418,
-0.0622165278,
0.008086483,
0.0224800017,
0.0027650434,
-0.0048361085,
0.003729122,
-0.0688763931,
-0.0244431309,
-0.0365776606,
-0.0312223844,
2.084540178e-34,
0.0254694689,
0.0187017769,
0.0510754026,
0.0366510265,
0.0690231621,
-0.0249843635,
-0.0044058422,
-0.0390517823,
0.0299175605,
-0.0923586637,
-0.0272981748
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07990v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07990v1
|
Plot2Code: A Comprehensive Benchmark for Evaluating Multi-modal Large Language Models in Code Generation from Scientific Plots
| 2024-05-13T17:59:22 | 2024-05-13T17:59:22 |
Chengyue Wu, Yixiao Ge, Qiushan Guo, Jiahao Wang, Zhixuan Liang, Zeyu Lu, Ying Shan, Ping Luo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
The remarkable progress of Multi-modal Large Language Models (MLLMs) has
attracted significant attention due to their superior performance in visual
contexts. However, their capabilities in turning visual figure to executable
code, have not been evaluated thoroughly. To address this, we introduce
Plot2Code, a comprehensive visual coding benchmark designed for a fair and
in-depth assessment of MLLMs. We carefully collect 132 manually selected
high-quality matplotlib plots across six plot types from publicly available
matplotlib galleries. For each plot, we carefully offer its source code, and an
descriptive instruction summarized by GPT-4. This approach enables Plot2Code to
extensively evaluate MLLMs' code capabilities across various input modalities.
Furthermore, we propose three automatic evaluation metrics, including code pass
rate, text-match ratio, and GPT-4V overall rating, for a fine-grained
assessment of the output code and rendered images. Instead of simply judging
pass or fail, we employ GPT-4V to make an overall judgement between the
generated and reference images, which has been shown to be consistent with
human evaluation. The evaluation results, which include analyses of 14 MLLMs
such as the proprietary GPT-4V, Gemini-Pro, and the open-sourced Mini-Gemini,
highlight the substantial challenges presented by Plot2Code. With Plot2Code, we
reveal that most existing MLLMs struggle with visual coding for text-dense
plots, heavily relying on textual instruction. We hope that the evaluation
results from Plot2Code on visual coding will guide the future development of
MLLMs. All data involved with Plot2Code are available at
https://huggingface.co/datasets/TencentARC/Plot2Code.
|
Plot2Code: A Comprehensive Benchmark for Evaluating Multi-modal Large Language Models in Code Generation from Scientific Plots: The remarkable progress of Multi-modal Large Language Models (MLLMs) has
attracted significant attention due to their superior performance in visual
contexts. However, their capabilities in turning visual figure to executable
code, have not been evaluated thoroughly. To address this, we introduce
Plot2Code, a comprehensive visual coding benchmark designed for a fair and
in-depth assessment of MLLMs. We carefully collect 132 manually selected
high-quality matplotlib plots across six plot types from publicly available
matplotlib galleries. For each plot, we carefully offer its source code, and an
descriptive instruction summarized by GPT-4. This approach enables Plot2Code to
extensively evaluate MLLMs' code capabilities across various input modalities.
Furthermore, we propose three automatic evaluation metrics, including code pass
rate, text-match ratio, and GPT-4V overall rating, for a fine-grained
assessment of the output code and rendered images. Instead of simply judging
pass or fail, we employ GPT-4V to make an overall judgement between the
generated and reference images, which has been shown to be consistent with
human evaluation. The evaluation results, which include analyses of 14 MLLMs
such as the proprietary GPT-4V, Gemini-Pro, and the open-sourced Mini-Gemini,
highlight the substantial challenges presented by Plot2Code. With Plot2Code, we
reveal that most existing MLLMs struggle with visual coding for text-dense
plots, heavily relying on textual instruction. We hope that the evaluation
results from Plot2Code on visual coding will guide the future development of
MLLMs. All data involved with Plot2Code are available at
https://huggingface.co/datasets/TencentARC/Plot2Code.
|
[
-0.0326288119,
0.0753132775,
-0.0008635883,
0.054303892,
-0.0298624374,
-0.0001231141,
0.0007820087,
0.061036177,
-0.0053198645,
0.0160402656,
-0.0489912815,
0.0110454038,
0.02669359,
0.0963895693,
0.020918956,
-0.0470051542,
0.0045201271,
-0.0498763733,
-0.0083090747,
0.0036080293,
-0.0170106906,
0.0075076297,
0.0035229025,
0.0398244113,
-0.0402709395,
-0.0498671234,
0.014754042,
0.0015191318,
0.0591773726,
-0.0297866818,
-0.0488548204,
0.0601389222,
0.0239852518,
0.0389376096,
0.0000022293,
-0.0368535742,
-0.0147911152,
0.0396697447,
0.0415136442,
0.0716532692,
0.0664188489,
-0.0491307229,
-0.0257403087,
-0.0571037792,
-0.0142348502,
-0.0083942953,
0.0936812237,
-0.0204680767,
0.0666492134,
0.0099871894,
0.0062873932,
-0.0158411097,
-0.0114751952,
0.0034924827,
0.0210504569,
0.0093896501,
0.0081146257,
0.0368761793,
0.0408774912,
0.034219455,
-0.0214539431,
0.0688362196,
0.0365865491,
-0.0510378443,
-0.0094097098,
0.0660223588,
0.0187870134,
-0.0158734359,
-0.0180843156,
0.0723553225,
-0.0418089218,
-0.0207218509,
-0.0119748414,
-0.0220734645,
-0.0372994244,
0.0075042611,
-0.0719011277,
0.0223679207,
0.0021197218,
-0.0153301861,
-0.0264341906,
-0.0232002754,
0.0109187188,
-0.0339276083,
-0.0094750086,
0.0091088954,
0.0242214613,
0.0006903135,
-0.0565694608,
0.0147992633,
-0.041039601,
-0.0502035432,
0.0175747573,
0.0129135763,
0.0438516364,
-0.0130793164,
-0.0441277139,
-0.026794944,
0.0289101675,
-0.0204280317,
0.0713559687,
0.008493986,
-0.0351338014,
0.0280204341,
-0.0300015993,
0.0508047417,
-0.0211918727,
-0.0104532409,
0.0341984667,
0.0257469453,
-0.027546186,
0.0051072626,
-0.0148627907,
-0.0348173939,
-0.0217794254,
0.0197833329,
-0.035494104,
0.0022128287,
0.008403087,
0.0245335232,
-0.0030277178,
-0.0063800598,
-0.024761796,
0.0293160602,
-0.0012665548,
0.0298433471,
0.0068329722,
-0.0371559486,
-0.021096915,
-0.049446702,
-0.0151587883,
0.0437250398,
0.0006036184,
-0.020137487,
-0.014075336,
0.0807264447,
0.0275829732,
0.0008312719,
0.0274844468,
-0.0260677319,
-0.0311098285,
-0.0171234217,
0.0088951848,
-0.0568485856,
0.0089237811,
0.0161427893,
0.0309009459,
-0.0463815033,
0.0214672629,
0.0024360078,
0.0244890228,
0.0662666485,
-0.058269769,
-0.0063461121,
0.0043317932,
0.0152371218,
-0.0308429673,
0.0219059177,
0.0579136685,
0.0013010362,
-0.010598233,
-0.0983281359,
0.0451754443,
0.0091697425,
0.0123154642,
0.0174676906,
-0.0468165427,
0.0151028708,
0.0153018255,
0.0332818441,
0.050339058,
0.0479011945,
-0.0450118668,
-0.0172490608,
0.0274379253,
0.0489566512,
0.0324358828,
0.0012944941,
0.0796917453,
0.0015451608,
0.0385714881,
-0.0373685136,
-0.0117205335,
0.067862764,
0.0215094406,
0.0231199451,
-0.0164335351,
0.040721789,
0.0174834318,
-0.043407362,
-0.013100964,
-0.0242038965,
0.0008994579,
-0.0524537191,
0.016917076,
0.0010047886,
-0.0314940885,
-0.0246908199,
0.0182325784,
-0.0997024849,
-0.024558261,
-0.0421637036,
0.0210162029,
0.0475226939,
0.0295823552,
0.0149674956,
0.018839756,
-0.0096493801,
-0.0105080828,
0.0367548391,
0.0463410169,
0.0145704756,
0.0318997689,
-0.0628353804,
-0.0238270946,
-0.0517632999,
-0.0231897887,
0.0636802986,
-0.0020535726,
-0.0073072128,
-0.0091903023,
-0.0160743725,
-0.0367440209,
0.0141162798,
-0.0227021128,
0.010430037,
-0.0310734771,
-0.0131492922,
0.015952656,
-0.0270340256,
-0.0509279892,
0.0197147857,
0.0608543046,
-0.0013200591,
0.0228768382,
-0.0073252618,
-0.0025043706,
-0.0342056192,
0.0179560538,
-0.0504416488,
-0.0504469052,
-0.0014734395,
0.0099521559,
-0.0081347506,
0.0006167374,
-0.0486221984,
0.0105237477,
-0.0088653285,
-0.0030026152,
-0.0400126651,
-0.0115956254,
-0.0245133247,
0.0218399521,
-0.0213211849,
0.0387809463,
0.0374445915,
0.0404835828,
0.012641808,
0.0059681227,
-0.0225739684,
0.0303438157,
0.0338162482,
0.0033879275,
-0.0219301153,
0.0495154262,
0.0007492335,
-0.0277574174,
-0.0722770244,
-0.0396490619,
0.0228071045,
-0.0277348701,
0.0261795428,
-0.0280289557,
-0.0095574316,
0.0140671944,
0.0128997527,
0.0322566256,
-0.0319530666,
-0.0141864698,
0.0462244637,
-0.0371498577,
-0.0498629808,
-0.0179703478,
-0.0187223554,
-0.017578302,
0.0487096794,
0.0507138222,
0.011621438,
-0.0423952825,
0.0540640652,
0.0014094753,
-0.0313690342,
-0.0038459967,
-0.0461876765,
0.0336467065,
-0.0294881277,
0.0278981123,
0.041045025,
-0.0253282487,
0.0073168427,
0.0497506559,
-0.0274685603,
-0.0229030363,
0.0153345242,
0.0110534234,
0.0074615236,
0.0330546461,
-0.0410276987,
0.0190574322,
0.0742908269,
-0.0028513868,
0.0316460691,
-0.0515978225,
0.0068444936,
0.0031456645,
-0.0129930172,
-0.0037544891,
-0.0014913665,
0.0070189242,
0.0364762917,
-0.0098857423,
-0.1053321287,
0.0508058742,
-0.0720392466,
-0.0220239013,
-0.0223154128,
-0.0019842079,
-0.0372095145,
0.031953875,
0.0158845689,
0.0210056491,
0.0087287426,
-0.0243913811,
0.0151392575,
0.0172549076,
-0.0266673267,
-0.0491902642,
0.0469578356,
-0.0444541723,
0.0034556037,
-0.0213949364,
0.0048390664,
0.0155894822,
0.0262328163,
-0.0170638636,
-0.0403948762,
0.0306055639,
-0.0972774103,
0.0058977166,
0.0291143637,
0.0233768187,
-0.0238420423,
-0.0201945361,
-0.0241703447,
-0.0034209604,
-0.0161320269,
-0.0267399512,
-0.0046346392,
-0.0300371144,
-0.0443483368,
0.0118105104,
0.0355391949,
-0.0484412722,
0.0746005625,
-0.0651737079,
0.0369778313,
0.0192461759,
0.0892123207,
-0.0312567502,
0.0310837459,
0.1036108956,
-0.0400841199,
0.0227821488,
0.0524099767,
0.0069613345,
-0.0235882532,
-0.0008936608,
-0.0164958574,
0.1022528708,
0.0176003594,
0.0068238149,
-0.0577545613,
-0.0135947214,
-0.0124502974,
0.0241127554,
0.0091421064,
-0.0034857148,
-0.0061099362,
-0.07868772,
0.0944430977,
0.0466882549,
-0.0483584553,
-0.0419122949,
-0.0541371293,
-0.0231475085,
0.0089365076,
-0.0323034897,
0.0100518009,
-0.0129298354,
0.0168970954,
0.0045839329,
-0.0071381759,
-0.0371577851,
-0.0101666301,
0.0086631225,
-0.0006938603,
0.0366384536,
0.0518335551,
-0.0159811787,
-0.0245339554,
0.0443112515,
0.0537563898,
0.0347159058,
-0.0319733098,
0.0572658218,
0.0627441257,
-0.0350250155,
-0.0040955674,
0.0084267184,
-0.0091474187,
-0.0317473784,
-0.0328652896,
0.0367458537,
-0.0105671026,
-0.0295807589,
-0.0547672063,
0.0139422612,
-0.0158027131,
0.0321511775,
0.0834924355,
0.000264594,
-0.0586145446,
-0.0961960927,
0.0429224856,
-0.0513166375,
-0.0602154098,
-0.0031329701,
-0.000185522,
-0.0253660828,
0.0001885952,
0.0188396834,
0.0615171269,
0.0169322751,
0.0069694072,
-0.0272173062,
-0.0307041835,
-0.032028079,
-0.0552062094,
0.0376604535,
-0.0270601846,
0.0404367596,
-0.0487142242,
-0.0224869829,
0.0183950868,
0.0217649825,
0.0012806784,
0.044504635,
-0.0809128657,
-0.031505987,
-0.0422394127,
0.0680028349,
0.0187726188,
-0.0173210576,
-0.0057868361,
-0.0557535626,
0.0264321957,
0.052099295,
0.001293067,
0.0155827329,
-0.0195349585,
0.0089807939,
0.0066967574,
-0.0378556177,
-0.0015978622,
-0.0081866477,
-0.0085632596,
0.0231916308,
0.0121668745,
0.0129555082,
0.0181114711,
0.0494643711,
0.0228820369,
-0.0109493202,
-0.0397179462,
0.0107111763,
-0.0637417957,
-0.0296699759,
-0.0361570269,
-0.0580178164,
0.006947835,
0.042042207,
-0.0060652643,
0.0179451704,
-0.0074050687,
-0.0018442813,
0.0017452994,
-0.0489839949,
0.0753720701,
0.0277591497,
-0.0162934214,
0.0752176493,
0.026483696,
-0.0045968411,
0.0061400784,
-0.0358618088,
0.0265470948,
0.0155865941,
0.0213353969,
0.005635439,
0.0001778399,
0.0441778153,
0.0413202308,
-0.0567067899,
-0.0511624962,
-0.0322483629,
0.0219033994,
0.0738272369,
0.0478415564,
0.0678949878,
-0.0489428155,
0.0100381412,
-0.040635474,
0.0498952642,
0.0136505794,
0.0046661762,
0.0648363158,
0.0003843319,
-0.0296159051,
-0.0807425678,
0.0583500452,
0.0276806206,
0.0225537252,
-0.0200922266,
-0.009100344,
-0.0307815988,
0.0202047937,
0.0082879113,
-0.0277611855,
0.006630769,
-0.0201497059,
-0.0350969248,
-0.0738225356,
0.0295722485,
0.0531860515,
-0.0108274296,
-0.0162364189,
0.0407683477,
0.0112163182,
-0.026305316,
-0.0020839071,
0.0158597045,
0.0242337137,
0.0400449559,
-0.0755025744,
-0.0218464788,
-5.525548215e-33,
-0.0257432591,
-0.0399186015,
0.0123612927,
0.0120203076,
0.0040851827,
0.0104813706,
-0.0351564698,
0.0067788064,
0.0263843611,
0.0084304018,
0.0683503002,
-0.0276466478,
-0.0295445956,
-0.0241726693,
-0.0169761106,
0.0227812044,
0.0196730867,
-0.0006926989,
-0.0636823699,
0.0230062008,
0.0003001053,
0.0197376683,
-0.0036006975,
-0.0649109706,
-0.0482128523,
0.0313298069,
-0.0086414143,
-0.048962038,
-0.026705889,
0.0637041032,
-0.0128349829,
0.0288976636,
-0.0014095043,
0.0243306831,
-0.0573008247,
0.0345745273,
-0.0148300705,
-0.0346198976,
0.0025709115,
-0.005207181,
-0.0415650345,
-0.0553585812,
0.0540640466,
-0.0142458174,
-0.0434799418,
-0.0405604877,
0.022755295,
0.0139056612,
-0.0188537221,
0.0127508482,
-0.0126608461,
0.0359866172,
-0.0247628763,
-0.0014747268,
0.0134626189,
0.0277578067,
0.0136983991,
0.0744139105,
-0.0115981381,
0.0736952275,
0.0472437218,
0.0073574493,
0.0478963219,
-0.0120874159,
0.0386331528,
0.0560176931,
0.0629646927,
-0.0168767944,
-0.0167175122,
0.0137705095,
0.0298120119,
0.0650624111,
0.0561894178,
0.0168097094,
0.0126851853,
0.0053701415,
-0.0118863769,
0.028936008,
-0.0667821914,
-0.0061432654,
-0.0033918878,
0.0298211798,
-0.0179801993,
-0.0307484269,
-0.0419740491,
-0.0015990849,
-0.0388184004,
-0.0108270971,
0.0312278531,
-0.06342002,
-0.0372884162,
0.0085639153,
0.0128291799,
-0.0291965604,
-0.0299510043,
0.0012631919,
-0.058841303,
0.086109072,
0.0128080295,
0.0152311111,
0.0041149128,
-0.0122320317,
0.0379214026,
-0.0127968127,
0.079254441,
0.0103476029,
-0.0052384841,
0.034796834,
-0.0473144166,
-0.0066442117,
-0.0184417572,
-0.0772064105,
0.0332754217,
-0.0137175554,
0.0344523042,
-0.0424671136,
-0.0098010972,
-0.0017940103,
0.0083021699,
0.0046739927,
-0.0357335694,
-0.0356440507,
-0.0538295284,
0.0070293238,
-0.0338488445,
-0.0381861627,
-0.061031647,
-0.0102164308,
0.0425927266,
-0.0578569546,
-0.0658638254,
0.0170068797,
2.732e-7,
0.057321623,
0.0548010543,
0.0275862813,
0.0172580779,
0.0177982878,
0.0214486215,
-0.0641673878,
-0.0086653084,
0.0076135974,
-0.0296809245,
-0.0521107204,
-0.0012525119,
0.0494161919,
0.0568942726,
0.0180840753,
0.0274847616,
-0.0179462172,
-0.0272594281,
-0.0642607585,
0.0235068109,
0.0707058758,
0.0252840966,
-0.0184323117,
-0.0219355561,
0.045088537,
-0.0332501344,
0.0444222055,
-0.0619571246,
0.0126530556,
-0.006031746,
-0.1063353196,
-0.0037650929,
-0.0013189755,
0.0116607705,
-0.0119182887,
-0.0532193035,
0.0414568931,
0.0887558833,
-0.0247766133,
0.0667263269,
0.0662173778,
0.0101335719,
-0.0092492998,
-0.0594814979,
0.0293134712,
0.0088447854,
-0.0212521069,
-0.0235691555,
0.0173642468,
-0.0054056924,
0.0498669632,
-0.0579032376,
-0.0019703666,
0.0146373687,
0.0116864862,
0.011732474,
-0.0112803029,
0.0466616862,
-0.0409775563,
-0.0136046633,
-0.0344465561,
-0.0545052923,
-0.0790678635,
0.005755051,
0.0286704898,
-0.0032697688,
-0.0338326916,
3.152096137e-34,
0.0369374193,
-0.0514919609,
0.0408439077,
0.0050681978,
0.0451755114,
-0.0090659279,
0.006292392,
0.0108657125,
-0.0159979835,
-0.0287087634,
-0.0251460914
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07960v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07960v3
|
AgentClinic: a multimodal agent benchmark to evaluate AI in simulated clinical environments
| 2024-05-13T17:38:53 | 2024-05-30T22:56:17 |
Samuel Schmidgall, Rojin Ziaei, Carl Harris, Eduardo Reis, Jeffrey Jopling, Michael Moor
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL
|
Diagnosing and managing a patient is a complex, sequential decision making
process that requires physicians to obtain information -- such as which tests
to perform -- and to act upon it. Recent advances in artificial intelligence
(AI) and large language models (LLMs) promise to profoundly impact clinical
care. However, current evaluation schemes overrely on static medical
question-answering benchmarks, falling short on interactive decision-making
that is required in real-life clinical work. Here, we present AgentClinic: a
multimodal benchmark to evaluate LLMs in their ability to operate as agents in
simulated clinical environments. In our benchmark, the doctor agent must
uncover the patient's diagnosis through dialogue and active data collection. We
present two open medical agent benchmarks: a multimodal image and dialogue
environment, AgentClinic-NEJM, and a dialogue-only environment,
AgentClinic-MedQA. We embed cognitive and implicit biases both in patient and
doctor agents to emulate realistic interactions between biased agents. We find
that introducing bias leads to large reductions in diagnostic accuracy of the
doctor agents, as well as reduced compliance, confidence, and follow-up
consultation willingness in patient agents. Evaluating a suite of
state-of-the-art LLMs, we find that several models that excel in benchmarks
like MedQA are performing poorly in AgentClinic-MedQA. We find that the LLM
used in the patient agent is an important factor for performance in the
AgentClinic benchmark. We show that both having limited interactions as well as
too many interaction reduces diagnostic accuracy in doctor agents. The code and
data for this work is publicly available at https://AgentClinic.github.io.
|
AgentClinic: a multimodal agent benchmark to evaluate AI in simulated clinical environments: Diagnosing and managing a patient is a complex, sequential decision making
process that requires physicians to obtain information -- such as which tests
to perform -- and to act upon it. Recent advances in artificial intelligence
(AI) and large language models (LLMs) promise to profoundly impact clinical
care. However, current evaluation schemes overrely on static medical
question-answering benchmarks, falling short on interactive decision-making
that is required in real-life clinical work. Here, we present AgentClinic: a
multimodal benchmark to evaluate LLMs in their ability to operate as agents in
simulated clinical environments. In our benchmark, the doctor agent must
uncover the patient's diagnosis through dialogue and active data collection. We
present two open medical agent benchmarks: a multimodal image and dialogue
environment, AgentClinic-NEJM, and a dialogue-only environment,
AgentClinic-MedQA. We embed cognitive and implicit biases both in patient and
doctor agents to emulate realistic interactions between biased agents. We find
that introducing bias leads to large reductions in diagnostic accuracy of the
doctor agents, as well as reduced compliance, confidence, and follow-up
consultation willingness in patient agents. Evaluating a suite of
state-of-the-art LLMs, we find that several models that excel in benchmarks
like MedQA are performing poorly in AgentClinic-MedQA. We find that the LLM
used in the patient agent is an important factor for performance in the
AgentClinic benchmark. We show that both having limited interactions as well as
too many interaction reduces diagnostic accuracy in doctor agents. The code and
data for this work is publicly available at https://AgentClinic.github.io.
|
[
0.0409398116,
0.0419879332,
-0.0251117628,
0.0010610876,
-0.0303691383,
0.006198145,
0.0317210518,
0.0355582424,
0.0398702584,
-0.0020503963,
-0.026551934,
-0.0337497592,
-0.0146675734,
0.0404450819,
0.0227435604,
-0.0636564642,
0.0272022076,
-0.0014653194,
0.0606998354,
0.0033944133,
-0.0000249656,
-0.0073021916,
-0.0777963176,
0.0629678816,
-0.0221366361,
-0.0131422691,
0.0097759487,
-0.0215645172,
0.0140758799,
-0.0776852146,
-0.0309553407,
0.0234946944,
0.0024468254,
-0.0042209788,
0.0000021892,
-0.0612811819,
0.0368873328,
-0.0061235521,
-0.0420276746,
-0.0525513999,
0.0469319001,
-0.0184123851,
0.0166794099,
0.0147281559,
-0.0576904342,
-0.0335459933,
0.0315135494,
0.0457181968,
0.0575405844,
0.0594514161,
-0.0170699414,
0.0580826737,
0.0114977695,
0.0000993929,
-0.0044829492,
-0.0852872729,
0.0174771883,
0.0166225974,
0.0486938842,
-0.0521202497,
-0.0066692224,
0.0322368219,
0.0027443974,
-0.0016923924,
-0.0197520629,
0.0679920241,
-0.0108659938,
-0.0551813617,
-0.0301615801,
0.0839747787,
0.0335415639,
0.0436030179,
0.0007264037,
-0.0099051418,
0.0152425626,
0.0135687254,
-0.0527738258,
0.0053599258,
-0.0263761338,
-0.0256659742,
-0.0342339091,
0.0138158305,
0.0377270393,
0.00271048,
0.0159340221,
0.0060281535,
0.0066965348,
-0.0009172821,
0.040728312,
-0.0150088994,
-0.0159729943,
-0.0604009703,
0.0089463526,
0.0539738201,
-0.1210669875,
-0.0016587299,
-0.0215419587,
0.0018807583,
0.0574486665,
-0.0480776839,
0.0273888856,
0.0259251669,
-0.0087885475,
0.0439855084,
0.0240876712,
0.0303805172,
-0.0292490236,
0.0500258803,
-0.0195249766,
0.027265694,
-0.0263679996,
-0.0114279417,
-0.0224117171,
-0.0049710171,
0.0040135365,
-0.0468192697,
-0.0389899872,
0.0010029942,
-0.0499652699,
0.0266867857,
-0.0117046721,
0.0554661043,
-0.0041694259,
0.0489203855,
-0.0724775046,
0.0095778154,
-0.03834958,
0.0123815471,
0.0109548187,
-0.0478000343,
0.0163241122,
0.0028700754,
-0.0008784902,
-0.0135095678,
0.0179476384,
0.0988028347,
-0.014518057,
-0.0100683244,
0.0221819486,
-0.0283355284,
-0.0097471084,
-0.048832722,
0.010377395,
-0.0272093397,
0.0551966876,
0.0104280543,
-0.0045922683,
-0.0544834137,
0.0244678073,
0.0047230879,
-0.0263398923,
0.0842851177,
-0.009243845,
0.0159213841,
0.0453654639,
0.0473216623,
-0.032392554,
0.0158313848,
0.0240427833,
-0.0215447918,
0.0222002156,
-0.0374940597,
0.0557744652,
0.0157067664,
0.0159072019,
-0.0161133725,
0.0229235291,
0.0120522426,
-0.0050473623,
0.1201797947,
-0.0244160667,
0.0792097598,
-0.0202831067,
-0.0193288606,
0.0529297404,
0.0523465574,
-0.0254070722,
-0.0475986376,
0.0211878903,
-0.028526796,
0.0088831391,
-0.0054147169,
-0.0203407686,
0.0426827557,
0.0280242916,
-0.0248001143,
-0.0015115502,
-0.0117902504,
-0.0291156806,
-0.0388439484,
-0.0439387076,
-0.0016195613,
0.0081982873,
0.0045708548,
0.0069272663,
-0.0244850777,
-0.0444302075,
0.0190183278,
0.0322022624,
-0.0113154966,
-0.0586079359,
-0.0907097757,
0.0173600372,
0.0948783085,
0.045171652,
-0.0294603407,
-0.0456935205,
-0.0074904929,
0.013188092,
0.0284220502,
0.0633921549,
-0.022769371,
0.0352692232,
-0.0307969991,
-0.0141218416,
0.0081043644,
0.0154971387,
-0.0099614076,
-0.0169055331,
0.0193951782,
-0.0551852584,
-0.0183050875,
0.0129964584,
0.045813635,
-0.0463968553,
-0.0191871356,
-0.0193708111,
-0.0041804616,
0.053392794,
-0.0010504724,
-0.0316595472,
0.0181644205,
0.0195792951,
-0.0136235915,
-0.0191754401,
0.0415306762,
-0.040154431,
-0.0252006948,
0.0013982786,
-0.0440849774,
-0.0198271871,
-0.0029021313,
-0.0275419485,
-0.0113195796,
-0.0222268216,
-0.0585497655,
0.0113382982,
0.0102988156,
0.0149427513,
0.0372661166,
0.0166026056,
-0.0197245851,
0.0160463974,
-0.03723111,
-0.0223723371,
0.0346766561,
0.0247027092,
-0.0110400338,
-0.0426350012,
0.0066140573,
0.0244209543,
0.0239552967,
0.0093836337,
-0.0078740362,
0.00750528,
-0.0398385823,
-0.0211714208,
-0.1371410638,
-0.0356710702,
0.0288340319,
-0.0507073849,
-0.0037385877,
0.0137256589,
-0.0125729404,
-0.0104005709,
-0.0294737834,
0.0485534184,
0.0522061512,
0.037627589,
0.0350624584,
0.0498338901,
-0.0242819693,
-0.0486445948,
0.0177627858,
-0.0367533527,
0.0425397046,
0.0128056845,
0.0263614766,
0.0092848968,
-0.035761334,
-0.0571377911,
0.0318690352,
-0.0257611014,
-0.0248756185,
0.05136263,
-0.0355307572,
-0.0187966712,
0.0751171485,
-0.0050080763,
0.0375005379,
0.0419770665,
-0.0103339357,
-0.0426533334,
0.036844451,
-0.0068803136,
-0.0210804902,
-0.0031903444,
-0.0596280657,
-0.0069429125,
0.0744567439,
0.021879198,
0.052061718,
-0.0218308121,
0.0444832668,
-0.0019672883,
-0.0359804668,
-0.0315877497,
0.0113850553,
-0.0330630913,
0.0565565266,
-0.0154896704,
-0.0336507112,
0.1009793654,
0.0003130064,
0.0168479718,
-0.0369760729,
-0.0041555157,
-0.0324676931,
0.0410264209,
0.0115761328,
0.0266824048,
0.0095522497,
0.018448621,
-0.0207320526,
-0.0197918657,
-0.0015512666,
-0.0554507002,
0.0213923361,
-0.0435550995,
0.0180840772,
-0.0006331956,
-0.0469017513,
-0.0417297482,
-0.0285108201,
-0.0343928598,
-0.0175451469,
-0.0035231274,
0.0100146784,
-0.0549157783,
0.0152873015,
0.010750331,
0.0479465947,
0.0302719176,
-0.0277246851,
0.0019246985,
-0.0012353605,
0.038094461,
0.0655004382,
0.0006754685,
-0.0368706845,
0.0688492209,
0.0523979254,
0.0111249704,
0.0075470461,
-0.0449259467,
-0.0003173968,
-0.0363958366,
0.0107548414,
0.0136927534,
0.0512991585,
0.0173988603,
-0.0406675711,
0.0072111934,
0.0945141315,
0.0192961022,
-0.0703017637,
0.0188033599,
-0.0350277536,
-0.0197708737,
-0.007606932,
-0.0019718434,
-0.0587985143,
-0.0516519397,
-0.0029552723,
0.0139967045,
-0.0407775119,
-0.0437677689,
0.0340813696,
-0.0620541871,
0.0463139713,
-0.0347717032,
-0.0017227404,
0.0064262566,
-0.0365482382,
0.0126456358,
-0.0140567683,
0.0220001396,
-0.0171411633,
0.0292050987,
-0.0222303476,
-0.0206321981,
-0.0318346992,
-0.0443776175,
0.0580025539,
-0.0179858878,
0.0497154072,
0.0649921075,
0.0558856092,
-0.0270747431,
-0.0349355005,
-0.0055822246,
0.0557411239,
0.0415561944,
-0.0086504109,
0.0880957544,
0.007086006,
0.0148035837,
-0.0411383696,
0.0249430072,
-0.0119701978,
0.0001914803,
0.0218301527,
0.0778262168,
-0.0478292145,
-0.0379049666,
-0.0709428564,
0.0533837453,
0.0424928553,
0.0415732451,
-0.0001629102,
-0.037882179,
-0.0509205908,
0.0279308576,
0.0380749144,
0.0106920404,
-0.0136189274,
0.0216702763,
-0.0019802491,
-0.000155931,
-0.0612077117,
-0.0522799417,
0.0363519527,
0.0035292478,
0.0079207793,
-0.0228383299,
-0.0067261085,
0.0340825953,
-0.0272939336,
0.0424816832,
0.0459265411,
0.0418960303,
-0.0158115495,
-0.0084881047,
0.0318302289,
-0.026141163,
0.0203256104,
0.0291844793,
-0.0235798899,
-0.0007906927,
0.0042613349,
0.0841671973,
0.0204263385,
-0.0018087728,
0.0014747195,
-0.031591773,
0.0045292163,
-0.0082711326,
-0.052391842,
0.0233056005,
-0.0014175347,
0.0124619193,
-0.0247411579,
0.0124543421,
-0.0283370055,
0.0137708532,
-0.0210383702,
0.0322195962,
-0.0432253703,
-0.0473862253,
0.025669083,
0.0120447893,
0.0138536897,
-0.0144279515,
-0.0090699168,
-0.0076974132,
0.0083763748,
-0.0151998447,
0.006908596,
-0.0157700107,
-0.0183417853,
-0.0042459192,
-0.0015137404,
0.0222921856,
-0.0062137716,
-0.0505792983,
-0.0484565459,
-0.0159961935,
0.0220193136,
0.058983881,
-0.0187862925,
0.023855187,
-0.0055804895,
0.0071499581,
0.0325754546,
-0.0076146112,
0.0415378325,
0.0233625453,
0.1184400916,
-0.0000222542,
-0.0067595779,
-0.01461,
0.0503282733,
-0.0394637473,
-0.06407547,
0.0274596382,
0.0628518388,
0.0414000303,
0.0284515135,
0.0029155877,
-0.0317812599,
0.0212253369,
-0.0068765162,
-0.0058895075,
-0.0009638867,
-0.0138940085,
0.0639606863,
0.0131380083,
0.0243537873,
0.0113684768,
0.0612964034,
-0.0250914879,
0.050000146,
-0.0307009909,
-0.0277881883,
-0.0641885027,
-0.022150876,
0.0332485586,
0.0308187474,
-0.0265639946,
-0.0004545063,
-0.0623104721,
-0.0324314497,
-0.0046319901,
0.0084283296,
-0.0412167013,
-0.0690945685,
0.051135052,
0.045505818,
0.030384833,
-0.021766901,
-0.0097034276,
0.0467958078,
-0.0620971471,
0.0080186427,
-0.0276981369,
-5.797445568e-33,
-0.0143220574,
-0.0294685438,
0.0472510606,
-0.0346898474,
-0.0107651548,
0.0296386257,
-0.0710602701,
0.0121976677,
-0.015789438,
0.0410329886,
-0.026449332,
-0.0010697034,
-0.0067783119,
0.0101973265,
-0.0141975749,
-0.0368932039,
0.0216881819,
-0.0093574878,
-0.0566320382,
0.0158464983,
-0.0318292826,
-0.0012366752,
-0.0274726078,
-0.0917824209,
-0.0148783298,
0.0004540024,
-0.0031170284,
0.0089642582,
-0.0486496836,
0.0616994649,
-0.0383565389,
0.0287538823,
0.0426613726,
0.0125836739,
0.0027280035,
0.0134003842,
-0.033916872,
-0.0221056193,
-0.0053297658,
0.0031695429,
-0.0816996321,
-0.0108923176,
0.0252808426,
-0.0023618243,
-0.0398292802,
0.0041420497,
0.0212915335,
-0.0234776828,
0.0039615347,
0.0086280294,
-0.043581944,
0.0291795619,
-0.0248382296,
-0.0324188881,
-0.0275861155,
0.0245907623,
-0.0417121351,
0.0076591792,
-0.0381352082,
-0.0021018141,
0.012897009,
-0.0449697524,
0.0302429516,
-0.0065095467,
-0.0122773275,
0.0824437812,
0.0783922672,
-0.0048330911,
-0.0561067984,
-0.0063641788,
-0.0395994522,
0.0554494336,
0.0562751964,
0.0761798918,
-0.0200667288,
-0.0073889508,
-0.0548204109,
0.0557307638,
-0.0172122829,
0.0466389246,
0.0538821556,
-0.0015284163,
-0.0655651242,
-0.0105390754,
-0.0362984613,
0.0157413948,
-0.0409329198,
-0.0398943275,
0.0515144989,
0.0043877559,
0.0284382589,
-0.0314674489,
0.0297768041,
-0.0020966572,
0.0368132144,
-0.0457639806,
0.0377837904,
0.0361159854,
-0.0334865227,
-0.0009076533,
-0.0348516777,
-0.0156521257,
0.0247602966,
0.0017353774,
0.0633655787,
0.0312817022,
-0.0216917396,
-0.0200871713,
-0.0135685094,
-0.0121729178,
0.0122294631,
0.0128449528,
-0.0061235083,
0.0239927731,
0.0340238325,
-0.0009548087,
-0.0353233404,
0.029713301,
-0.0174099319,
-0.0194507819,
-0.0498890243,
-0.0694429949,
-0.0089362562,
-0.0198590048,
-0.0745471045,
0.0032037499,
-0.0778902471,
-0.0017543847,
0.0127267344,
-0.0842392892,
-0.0151879974,
0.0255124066,
2.892e-7,
0.0291512571,
0.0448460691,
-0.0000754945,
0.009720359,
0.0502538085,
0.0453898162,
-0.0317289308,
0.0256185383,
-0.0012254502,
-0.0594029464,
0.0255180206,
0.0359474123,
0.0189566407,
0.045637574,
-0.0119912131,
-0.0354523957,
-0.0537675209,
-0.017263433,
-0.0355813242,
-0.033824563,
0.0411592387,
0.0460087806,
-0.0371326581,
-0.0475793406,
0.0337712616,
-0.0271568857,
0.0467231944,
-0.0305142459,
0.003903724,
0.0272760317,
0.004213735,
-0.0109190783,
0.0191480517,
0.0750294551,
-0.0028100845,
-0.0348478258,
-0.0052252547,
0.0962023735,
-0.0721067116,
-0.0350125134,
0.0073614274,
0.0035530566,
0.022641914,
-0.0190501958,
0.0579551794,
-0.0426338948,
-0.059742637,
-0.0274134427,
-0.0131905321,
-0.0243494119,
0.0709417313,
-0.0442170538,
-0.0445541404,
0.0257619545,
0.0106632672,
0.0310318265,
-0.0194573402,
-0.062284328,
-0.0184581932,
-0.0001223162,
-0.0435685478,
-0.0648943707,
0.0254870765,
-0.023616882,
0.0019140536,
-0.083798416,
-0.0106712291,
2.346108563e-34,
0.0386335179,
0.0254789218,
0.0140980836,
0.0378054827,
0.0429259166,
0.0020420575,
0.015870871,
0.0196084157,
0.0633726269,
-0.0563399754,
-0.0050789956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07940v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07940v2
|
RAID: A Shared Benchmark for Robust Evaluation of Machine-Generated Text Detectors
| 2024-05-13T17:15:14 | 2024-06-10T15:51:16 |
Liam Dugan, Alyssa Hwang, Filip Trhlik, Josh Magnus Ludan, Andrew Zhu, Hainiu Xu, Daphne Ippolito, Chris Callison-Burch
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Many commercial and open-source models claim to detect machine-generated text
with extremely high accuracy (99% or more). However, very few of these
detectors are evaluated on shared benchmark datasets and even when they are,
the datasets used for evaluation are insufficiently challenging-lacking
variations in sampling strategy, adversarial attacks, and open-source
generative models. In this work we present RAID: the largest and most
challenging benchmark dataset for machine-generated text detection. RAID
includes over 6 million generations spanning 11 models, 8 domains, 11
adversarial attacks and 4 decoding strategies. Using RAID, we evaluate the
out-of-domain and adversarial robustness of 8 open- and 4 closed-source
detectors and find that current detectors are easily fooled by adversarial
attacks, variations in sampling strategies, repetition penalties, and unseen
generative models. We release our data along with a leaderboard to encourage
future research.
|
RAID: A Shared Benchmark for Robust Evaluation of Machine-Generated Text Detectors: Many commercial and open-source models claim to detect machine-generated text
with extremely high accuracy (99% or more). However, very few of these
detectors are evaluated on shared benchmark datasets and even when they are,
the datasets used for evaluation are insufficiently challenging-lacking
variations in sampling strategy, adversarial attacks, and open-source
generative models. In this work we present RAID: the largest and most
challenging benchmark dataset for machine-generated text detection. RAID
includes over 6 million generations spanning 11 models, 8 domains, 11
adversarial attacks and 4 decoding strategies. Using RAID, we evaluate the
out-of-domain and adversarial robustness of 8 open- and 4 closed-source
detectors and find that current detectors are easily fooled by adversarial
attacks, variations in sampling strategies, repetition penalties, and unseen
generative models. We release our data along with a leaderboard to encourage
future research.
|
[
0.0126381228,
0.0814174414,
-0.0017748171,
0.0862005875,
-0.0335560553,
0.0181196351,
0.0132140517,
0.0386345088,
-0.0002497085,
-0.0004463599,
-0.008395982,
-0.0033031933,
-0.0083770473,
0.0688663498,
0.007603541,
0.0038484957,
0.0235843416,
0.0013237078,
-0.0319702178,
0.025920704,
0.0049821185,
0.0040859412,
-0.0150444852,
0.0226918571,
-0.0141652338,
-0.0155191179,
0.0023477131,
0.0380792394,
0.0558021665,
-0.0527111702,
0.0081881378,
0.0442889594,
0.0010635392,
0.1451756358,
0.0000017895,
-0.0034160365,
-0.02554572,
-0.0038871518,
-0.0296811778,
0.0190416854,
0.0830755979,
-0.0580774471,
-0.0656009614,
0.0094736097,
-0.0072269328,
-0.0129609993,
0.0455003344,
0.0494378842,
0.0255958475,
0.0794370398,
-0.0239206702,
-0.0166906975,
0.0602949597,
-0.0424228869,
-0.0558060855,
-0.0469069518,
0.0148658175,
-0.0250514783,
-0.0298827402,
0.0098638199,
-0.0028912351,
0.0290183332,
0.0472776517,
-0.0163207147,
-0.0319669582,
0.0395255871,
-0.0112371342,
0.0030878412,
-0.0133690219,
0.0507870689,
-0.0462630577,
-0.0121545,
-0.0090358993,
-0.0351653397,
0.0005714456,
0.0077521843,
0.0136781344,
0.0253267437,
-0.0213254765,
0.0268027894,
-0.0564884283,
0.0287736319,
0.0231130235,
0.0281295441,
0.019675605,
-0.0081423353,
0.0245240536,
-0.0242233519,
-0.0128433118,
0.0306387134,
-0.0201724097,
-0.0243430454,
0.0418428704,
-0.0172056761,
0.0233003516,
-0.0049483571,
-0.1085445806,
-0.0912127867,
0.0198812149,
-0.0151064526,
0.0399735793,
-0.0205808692,
-0.0593821332,
0.035602808,
-0.0637733415,
0.0463124029,
-0.0599324852,
0.0079127923,
-0.0070140348,
0.0129000386,
0.0072396952,
0.0007631104,
0.0039037894,
-0.0395022705,
-0.0249267686,
-0.0300783832,
-0.0236226842,
0.0160551257,
0.0201486368,
-0.0019236292,
-0.046509359,
0.0159129016,
-0.0548007227,
-0.0230131466,
0.0314160138,
-0.0119221294,
-0.0178108998,
-0.0064157671,
0.0199515838,
-0.1030463725,
-0.0525193959,
0.0650338754,
0.0005654874,
-0.0077181864,
-0.0094964663,
0.0833376125,
-0.0381035134,
-0.0497004688,
-0.0305967387,
-0.0203834325,
-0.0431362204,
-0.0384030044,
0.041330453,
-0.0421673842,
-0.0280584507,
-0.0264235698,
-0.0069882232,
-0.0473837256,
-0.0013834742,
0.01732965,
0.0178363081,
0.0496202186,
-0.0066807992,
-0.0703046173,
0.0102005396,
0.013946333,
-0.0015536929,
0.0650670677,
0.0065635638,
0.1016065851,
0.0193895362,
0.0394843891,
0.0393656529,
0.0610664412,
0.0105153164,
0.0485230498,
0.0103172092,
-0.011402512,
-0.0051524425,
0.0271989536,
0.0314228386,
0.0340505019,
-0.0144626461,
-0.0774762109,
0.0871331468,
0.0284490176,
-0.0106085055,
0.0126233874,
0.0213984139,
0.0119991694,
0.0093406187,
0.0026099195,
-0.0125475246,
-0.0113549419,
-0.0374065451,
-0.0313261822,
-0.0137348622,
0.0467162952,
0.0007938957,
-0.0169718433,
-0.0101547157,
-0.0220572632,
-0.0176628605,
-0.0479925647,
0.0666953921,
0.0254765339,
-0.0519833863,
-0.031926658,
-0.0134245474,
-0.0247484986,
-0.020617988,
-0.0585982576,
0.0436713621,
0.0149630429,
0.0659868419,
-0.0035708442,
0.0457956865,
-0.0247976258,
0.0297453888,
0.0672598779,
-0.010699694,
0.0319607407,
0.0348109491,
-0.0600687787,
-0.0346625336,
-0.0147000719,
0.0137812207,
0.0510399267,
0.0479933321,
0.0267659277,
0.0110449996,
-0.0118408222,
0.0147425672,
0.0604736432,
-0.0122838058,
-0.0237723961,
0.0151952766,
-0.0012718376,
0.0419592001,
-0.002515842,
-0.051780697,
0.0061711487,
0.0336785689,
-0.0484588444,
-0.0132190622,
-0.0176193044,
-0.0192607138,
-0.0437354743,
-0.0338656083,
-0.0571475886,
-0.0297041237,
0.069134824,
-0.0609626956,
0.0224208906,
0.0232995115,
-0.0437097624,
-0.0428107642,
-0.0656241924,
-0.0247894824,
-0.0124991052,
0.0558953024,
-0.0015700827,
0.0709234029,
-0.0478217304,
-0.0361303464,
-0.0083481185,
0.0329968408,
0.04234083,
-0.0322977416,
0.0024752845,
-0.004149979,
-0.0341226123,
0.0047809882,
-0.0130722169,
0.0213493034,
-0.0197148919,
-0.0086003849,
-0.005338632,
-0.0024062265,
-0.0414485373,
0.0017196115,
0.0349863581,
-0.0280115902,
-0.0026605292,
-0.0264222044,
-0.0067177112,
0.0080150282,
0.0241857935,
-0.0033902375,
0.0134560643,
-0.0344072506,
0.0277035665,
0.0031046078,
-0.0253838953,
0.0212107431,
0.0561061054,
0.0272443537,
-0.0351694152,
-0.0286301542,
0.010599779,
0.0138800386,
0.0271982979,
-0.0305094589,
-0.0316391252,
0.0251523927,
0.0108629316,
0.0092614703,
0.089129515,
0.0332003497,
0.0149098542,
-0.0041024238,
0.0646790937,
0.0203985777,
-0.0108838473,
0.0115778744,
0.0263885669,
-0.0193423852,
-0.0067240167,
0.0436157174,
0.0507292189,
0.0137265418,
0.0080803381,
-0.0137078092,
0.0289357901,
-0.0209235325,
-0.047475554,
-0.0147099039,
0.0039878227,
-0.0361263566,
0.0166504811,
-0.0593990944,
-0.0863595009,
0.0340398252,
-0.020931311,
-0.0038833495,
-0.0144002568,
-0.0284926891,
0.0075986651,
0.0454534888,
0.0199538358,
0.016776504,
0.0399628058,
-0.0033267261,
-0.0173354726,
0.0106138475,
0.0338278487,
-0.0164447296,
0.0137650417,
-0.0048806658,
0.0168856364,
-0.0090225227,
-0.0320474543,
-0.0799715817,
-0.0281251017,
-0.0153091103,
-0.0064847791,
0.038081456,
-0.0323933512,
-0.0579291284,
-0.026300719,
-0.0112987487,
0.0460293368,
-0.0120148817,
-0.0021884234,
-0.0265400093,
0.1021758318,
0.0359112695,
-0.0446412154,
0.0426987372,
-0.0519797131,
-0.0113387993,
0.0849626511,
-0.019459879,
0.0226496756,
-0.030801611,
-0.0008960882,
0.0064186784,
0.0522419475,
0.0176378451,
0.0106913075,
0.0405855812,
-0.0272576939,
-0.0158225223,
0.0317154601,
-0.0096231792,
-0.01310685,
0.0069800057,
0.0266303904,
0.0194891281,
-0.0064162626,
-0.0348376669,
-0.0939209089,
-0.0374144688,
0.0136463018,
0.0185912084,
-0.0109312665,
0.0012838922,
-0.0074140402,
-0.1001328453,
0.042424567,
0.0145512009,
-0.0242452677,
-0.0326398909,
0.0245154724,
0.0005595303,
-0.0279527064,
-0.0070959404,
-0.0125610093,
0.0424002148,
-0.0128795598,
-0.0093363328,
0.0303358678,
-0.0592785701,
-0.0195716918,
-0.0366088748,
-0.003529113,
0.0971022993,
0.0324186869,
0.0107092252,
-0.0409687646,
0.0270180684,
-0.0174921975,
-0.012463578,
0.0136149274,
0.0887140036,
0.0073560714,
-0.0065087271,
-0.0229966585,
0.0491189212,
-0.0258200355,
-0.0064548687,
0.0194676146,
-0.0070576044,
0.0126802064,
-0.0531064756,
-0.0440245569,
-0.0081162509,
0.01666384,
0.0530956499,
0.0081513636,
-0.0267273206,
-0.0474655442,
-0.0451750681,
0.0478320457,
-0.1114388034,
-0.0283757448,
-0.0002650171,
0.0157361701,
-0.0344263427,
-0.058135502,
-0.0065442673,
-0.0351752043,
0.0280913562,
-0.0208340082,
-0.0391177684,
-0.0393742174,
-0.0025090959,
-0.0456699617,
-0.0168452859,
-0.0248507559,
0.0328790657,
-0.0481610671,
0.0052655172,
-0.0034047232,
-0.0455378294,
-0.0351789258,
0.0850465745,
-0.1111220792,
-0.0160946753,
0.0136986235,
0.0277082101,
0.0164382569,
-0.0036416103,
-0.0481759533,
-0.0384579748,
0.0972164795,
0.0346535742,
-0.0095763048,
-0.0031492889,
0.0358796567,
-0.037308272,
-0.0298486147,
0.0228779558,
-0.0187463257,
0.0505191982,
0.0449421629,
-0.0571898893,
-0.00805094,
0.008382488,
-0.0039892844,
-0.0261451211,
0.0520587973,
-0.0348121487,
-0.0190372765,
-0.0031047922,
0.0024454666,
-0.0072875977,
0.0028422682,
-0.0593524612,
0.0272903033,
0.0563532785,
0.0000814233,
-0.0118416939,
0.0571773723,
0.0267213471,
0.06122512,
-0.0283191707,
0.0008146576,
0.0338402428,
0.0748112276,
0.0418597721,
0.0058056177,
-0.0002101854,
0.0318372846,
-0.0146627696,
0.0178191122,
-0.0049619484,
0.0321754701,
0.0211578757,
0.005161609,
0.0258878563,
0.0290341899,
-0.0543245934,
0.0252199974,
-0.0764001906,
0.0296747163,
0.0574160479,
0.0204470865,
0.021525275,
-0.0347976796,
-0.0129035674,
-0.0427787676,
-0.0021867843,
0.013725006,
-0.0375235677,
-0.008555077,
-0.0069887452,
-0.0064679263,
0.0011081281,
0.0692929402,
0.0216217376,
0.0625617877,
0.0042680455,
-0.0142909568,
-0.0589282066,
-0.0149525413,
-0.002694112,
-0.0230245125,
-0.0043649818,
0.0205948669,
-0.019546194,
-0.0446609147,
0.0225810576,
-0.00990621,
0.0221052207,
0.0250986051,
-0.0151152723,
0.0390233584,
-0.0082108369,
-0.0031239616,
-0.0078520691,
0.0271330513,
-0.0263966508,
-0.0203909613,
-0.0067163049,
-5.782684298e-33,
0.0136030354,
-0.0280744676,
-0.0421660058,
-0.0918569788,
0.0082273921,
0.0299539883,
-0.0282775909,
-0.0306541044,
0.0053172894,
-0.0036356272,
0.0002013681,
0.020877786,
0.0093135759,
0.0515710153,
-0.0414821282,
-0.0299323965,
0.0621358119,
-0.0502456948,
-0.0478316881,
0.0028246127,
0.0266229715,
0.0328082442,
0.0226889979,
-0.0478702337,
0.0081969313,
-0.0201112553,
-0.0590224303,
-0.0107194865,
-0.0404992253,
0.0599770844,
-0.0023414411,
0.0163513124,
0.0199447572,
-0.0067312564,
-0.0290675741,
0.0151148783,
-0.0399766415,
0.0218315106,
-0.0595738366,
0.0296382811,
-0.0497543104,
-0.0451012328,
0.0149241518,
-0.0203242991,
-0.0095486986,
-0.0228268094,
0.0165673066,
-0.03545288,
-0.0043824059,
-0.0478585772,
-0.0469006673,
0.0389788561,
0.0049401759,
-0.0222984292,
0.0081870835,
0.0293160118,
0.0505161993,
0.0271657128,
-0.0505885817,
0.0008791147,
0.0151369423,
0.0155440522,
0.0363491364,
0.0294783339,
-0.0165680535,
0.0646409541,
0.0344497673,
0.0085324431,
-0.0325288959,
-0.0139646083,
0.016499389,
0.0301243532,
0.0856921673,
0.0960932001,
0.0673458129,
-0.0088774543,
-0.0732591972,
0.0297285859,
0.0026825981,
-0.0164672099,
0.017767217,
0.0285850428,
-0.0191130619,
0.0315029435,
0.0077085295,
-0.0682658106,
-0.0143138561,
-0.0072868299,
0.0384609066,
0.0493541285,
-0.0573484749,
0.0119823497,
0.0154807027,
-0.0420015603,
0.0105526131,
0.0283074565,
-0.0255962256,
0.0027352334,
0.0152649395,
0.0281261764,
-0.0248686429,
0.0028922651,
0.0722770467,
0.0089895157,
-0.0011394676,
-0.0410369933,
0.0682306066,
0.0191338286,
-0.0558693036,
0.0209182799,
-0.0463935733,
0.0636784807,
0.0473056659,
0.0354305655,
0.026544489,
-0.047673922,
-0.0102485893,
-0.0164832659,
0.0082298955,
0.0126400143,
-0.0278250147,
0.0215810277,
-0.0272315703,
0.0134365745,
-0.0120674446,
0.0044172592,
-0.0220814385,
-0.0028356037,
0.0428772122,
-0.0594108813,
0.0129625155,
-0.010770876,
2.31e-7,
0.0240954887,
0.0241844188,
0.0557004325,
-0.0002850675,
0.0313675217,
0.0348390229,
-0.0239249784,
0.0297327694,
-0.0528697707,
0.0230906811,
-0.038236998,
0.0092428662,
0.0912262425,
0.0246248059,
-0.051558055,
0.0608851388,
-0.0621996447,
0.0414604582,
-0.0374845006,
-0.0195477512,
0.058537282,
0.0845136642,
-0.0126696555,
-0.0261915568,
0.0638106391,
-0.0753185004,
0.0507011972,
-0.0099427328,
0.0414238945,
-0.0391218923,
0.0235348362,
0.0224113464,
0.0012765474,
-0.0194966178,
-0.0180549957,
-0.0286426358,
0.0358638763,
0.0482447743,
0.0411115438,
-0.0179336779,
-0.0091440873,
0.0089595737,
0.0091253063,
-0.0008510563,
0.0616818406,
0.0034818153,
-0.0140064294,
-0.0211762693,
-0.0184786059,
-0.0392853171,
0.0397643633,
-0.0342496522,
-0.0145366108,
0.0178800933,
0.0099710282,
0.0125079937,
-0.0156566277,
-0.0243541803,
-0.0186416749,
-0.0530129261,
-0.0632942617,
-0.0234658327,
-0.0861849189,
0.033253517,
0.0567072779,
-0.0126086362,
0.0047393595,
1.796038737e-34,
0.011087561,
-0.032479357,
-0.0211623516,
-0.0190964956,
0.0089310072,
-0.0202369541,
0.048719503,
-0.0237761028,
-0.0242929384,
-0.015865365,
0.0059695924
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07938v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07938v1
|
EconLogicQA: A Question-Answering Benchmark for Evaluating Large Language Models in Economic Sequential Reasoning
| 2024-05-13T17:13:47 | 2024-05-13T17:13:47 |
Yinzhu Quan, Zefang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we introduce EconLogicQA, a rigorous benchmark designed to
assess the sequential reasoning capabilities of large language models (LLMs)
within the intricate realms of economics, business, and supply chain
management. Diverging from traditional benchmarks that predict subsequent
events individually, EconLogicQA poses a more challenging task: it requires
models to discern and sequence multiple interconnected events, capturing the
complexity of economic logics. EconLogicQA comprises an array of multi-event
scenarios derived from economic articles, which necessitate an insightful
understanding of both temporal and logical event relationships. Through
comprehensive evaluations, we exhibit that EconLogicQA effectively gauges a
LLM's proficiency in navigating the sequential complexities inherent in
economic contexts. We provide a detailed description of EconLogicQA dataset and
shows the outcomes from evaluating the benchmark across various leading-edge
LLMs, thereby offering a thorough perspective on their sequential reasoning
potential in economic contexts. Our benchmark dataset is available at
https://huggingface.co/datasets/yinzhu-quan/econ_logic_qa.
|
EconLogicQA: A Question-Answering Benchmark for Evaluating Large Language Models in Economic Sequential Reasoning: In this paper, we introduce EconLogicQA, a rigorous benchmark designed to
assess the sequential reasoning capabilities of large language models (LLMs)
within the intricate realms of economics, business, and supply chain
management. Diverging from traditional benchmarks that predict subsequent
events individually, EconLogicQA poses a more challenging task: it requires
models to discern and sequence multiple interconnected events, capturing the
complexity of economic logics. EconLogicQA comprises an array of multi-event
scenarios derived from economic articles, which necessitate an insightful
understanding of both temporal and logical event relationships. Through
comprehensive evaluations, we exhibit that EconLogicQA effectively gauges a
LLM's proficiency in navigating the sequential complexities inherent in
economic contexts. We provide a detailed description of EconLogicQA dataset and
shows the outcomes from evaluating the benchmark across various leading-edge
LLMs, thereby offering a thorough perspective on their sequential reasoning
potential in economic contexts. Our benchmark dataset is available at
https://huggingface.co/datasets/yinzhu-quan/econ_logic_qa.
|
[
0.0109677669,
0.1216433272,
-0.0018334566,
0.0499477796,
-0.0505250432,
0.0093350392,
0.0120366113,
-0.0113746468,
0.0183451995,
-0.0251498818,
0.0236371085,
-0.0075819292,
-0.0453027487,
0.0509638935,
-0.0004845379,
-0.0232609622,
0.0349196754,
-0.0221045334,
0.0363818407,
-0.0332630798,
0.0001536062,
0.0132236592,
-0.0374510884,
0.0211635269,
0.0217751786,
-0.0416427925,
-0.0382936485,
-0.0301531069,
0.0269017424,
-0.0417245887,
-0.0117632952,
0.0449480452,
0.0210858565,
0.0164890569,
0.0000020566,
-0.0957151502,
-0.0315726437,
-0.0305239875,
-0.0356819294,
0.0139766969,
-0.0329653434,
-0.0050794333,
0.042418059,
0.0158744846,
-0.0638319403,
0.0026330564,
0.0181275439,
0.0616371147,
0.0447481051,
0.0546530187,
0.0022886116,
-0.0457555465,
0.0152372634,
-0.0463254638,
-0.040352352,
-0.096865125,
0.0339578316,
-0.0071086236,
0.0118580442,
-0.0184422974,
-0.0040834798,
0.017387107,
0.0362684615,
0.0108414767,
-0.0535795614,
0.0502596311,
-0.0138249295,
0.0298013613,
-0.0305332541,
0.060104128,
0.0546533316,
0.0203661676,
0.0134976199,
-0.0077379565,
0.0141745713,
-0.0122255879,
-0.0538464375,
0.0246399324,
-0.0024485134,
0.024682533,
0.0537796319,
0.0382026173,
0.0233209971,
0.0364070944,
-0.0565780997,
0.1329468936,
-0.032117378,
-0.0378221944,
0.0030463522,
-0.0030831816,
-0.0253617223,
-0.048559729,
0.0023492314,
0.067147404,
-0.0569629036,
0.0123912646,
0.01565798,
0.0458737016,
-0.0308186766,
-0.0368747748,
0.008686766,
0.0500054881,
0.0338433534,
0.0602834187,
0.0096598305,
0.0540061444,
-0.0284049474,
-0.0235855766,
-0.0204981379,
0.0270859115,
-0.0334409922,
-0.0298277978,
-0.0373005308,
0.0301337037,
-0.0190944262,
-0.0223854333,
-0.031233564,
-0.0178608354,
-0.0508579984,
0.0179998316,
0.0069113965,
0.0267548766,
-0.0133149689,
-0.047903236,
-0.0960203186,
0.0045568328,
-0.0457873493,
0.0437680855,
0.0014666489,
-0.0039884802,
-0.0074528456,
-0.008824097,
-0.0197667852,
-0.017005384,
0.0039365324,
0.104020983,
0.0028744149,
0.031469956,
-0.0629144236,
-0.0387985855,
0.0211476013,
-0.0569192469,
-0.0250915773,
-0.0649039224,
0.0236704368,
-0.0026140043,
-0.0215084422,
-0.0169875156,
0.0194772556,
-0.0033235468,
-0.0146053946,
0.0405096337,
0.0263705216,
-0.0035245535,
-0.0396621488,
0.0010259631,
0.0401225723,
0.0650433376,
0.0331516117,
0.0246748757,
0.033072114,
0.0162863974,
-0.0299475379,
0.0547613576,
-0.022097636,
-0.0216583759,
-0.0330145247,
0.043708887,
-0.0320020877,
0.0151997525,
0.0364965089,
0.0042663827,
-0.0225397665,
-0.0262612198,
0.0180389583,
0.0059457044,
0.005631913,
-0.0289734025,
0.0419394486,
0.0093113407,
-0.0124029601,
0.0092509976,
-0.0007871672,
0.0235226452,
-0.009409585,
0.0054443013,
0.0197000746,
-0.0228824224,
-0.016138602,
-0.051150851,
0.0196985137,
0.0000414147,
-0.0019334416,
0.0250646751,
0.0218168106,
-0.0288579538,
-0.0470215082,
0.0604055487,
-0.0065056928,
0.0177427717,
-0.0226442534,
-0.0170530435,
0.0299620256,
0.0622961856,
0.0222627819,
-0.0402383655,
-0.0493406504,
0.0036325855,
-0.0013457944,
0.0311709046,
0.044489108,
-0.0142376749,
0.0003994257,
-0.0031793537,
-0.0167883988,
-0.0080393255,
0.0180409905,
0.026743304,
0.0196880829,
0.0029252449,
-0.0160906892,
0.0243389495,
0.0544759817,
0.0177927781,
-0.0406354815,
-0.0567778908,
-0.0210488085,
-0.0089455834,
0.0362346843,
-0.010488417,
0.0224676747,
0.0385967009,
0.0230971221,
-0.0283113457,
-0.0367556326,
0.0351437367,
-0.0391410813,
-0.0014421133,
0.0410226546,
0.0171746705,
-0.0438409783,
0.0122681158,
-0.0602811836,
-0.0491942614,
0.0118303383,
0.0168624632,
0.0135004632,
-0.0242912378,
-0.012524277,
-0.0044865957,
-0.0181063991,
-0.0099118492,
0.072318688,
-0.026134409,
0.0484460741,
0.0224180445,
0.018281363,
-0.0070349537,
-0.0588663258,
0.0243563261,
0.0323370881,
-0.0203510858,
-0.0079859402,
0.0307080559,
0.0012015465,
-0.0406884365,
-0.0055074273,
-0.0424973033,
0.0188163649,
-0.0153140137,
0.0409813002,
0.0039623245,
-0.0581088439,
-0.0079088835,
-0.0032242553,
-0.0169624127,
0.0098779621,
0.0304689817,
0.0123266131,
0.0298891626,
0.0285396613,
-0.0167064518,
-0.0143868774,
-0.0004347432,
-0.0436225533,
0.0502379611,
0.0127658723,
0.0296767522,
-0.030071592,
-0.0476858355,
-0.0148352068,
0.0048919078,
-0.0248810891,
-0.005038633,
-0.0085742874,
-0.0359149426,
0.0213050675,
0.0270984285,
-0.02523054,
0.0359432772,
0.0264930185,
-0.0706313178,
-0.0485113412,
0.0279452279,
-0.023012761,
0.04204477,
-0.0676363111,
-0.0093959402,
-0.0073560202,
0.1100356057,
-0.0142028993,
0.0064307959,
-0.0369483009,
0.0604416989,
-0.0172094945,
-0.0222568419,
-0.0416207537,
-0.0145428358,
-0.0059032501,
0.0939086452,
0.0054703932,
-0.0360522605,
0.061752189,
0.0064958953,
0.0002220824,
-0.0220193025,
-0.0012873489,
-0.0734983459,
0.0708431751,
-0.0074008428,
-0.0105284536,
-0.0293597206,
-0.0336543731,
-0.0512120575,
-0.0000520478,
0.0139174098,
0.0102481255,
0.0314537361,
-0.0797902942,
0.0143688992,
-0.0127790347,
-0.0311146788,
-0.0173592214,
-0.0502484106,
-0.0620005354,
0.0325996503,
0.0136887897,
-0.0031833297,
-0.0620454028,
0.0063223452,
0.0087062679,
-0.0091971615,
-0.015307256,
-0.0146415252,
-0.0002518717,
0.0571964011,
0.0291472264,
0.0182333924,
0.0309206359,
-0.021760162,
0.0733505487,
0.0280873626,
0.0334759541,
-0.0023743059,
-0.0234644245,
0.0178006422,
0.019324515,
-0.0338217802,
-0.0020356155,
0.0561429709,
-0.0385389104,
-0.0686485022,
-0.0023184188,
0.1079883426,
0.0223700367,
0.035071481,
0.0128172748,
-0.0189227443,
0.024227554,
0.0245628562,
0.0310629476,
-0.0718908757,
-0.0252674818,
0.0204311814,
-0.0156843942,
-0.0013941451,
-0.075254485,
-0.0315691866,
-0.0965071395,
0.0359679163,
-0.0255537964,
-0.0453473404,
0.0067956652,
-0.0306875538,
-0.0147959217,
-0.0311093759,
-0.0113246767,
0.0308665894,
-0.0214599129,
-0.0021728987,
0.0173282623,
-0.0581667796,
0.012655722,
0.0640735626,
0.0222808998,
-0.0112812482,
0.0179342739,
0.0273773987,
-0.0385722406,
0.0267587863,
0.0010583701,
-0.0136416107,
-0.0136239603,
0.0030065638,
-0.0127343256,
0.0208124965,
-0.017079642,
-0.0132930428,
0.0255081709,
-0.013580949,
-0.0180933811,
0.0284594074,
0.0641188994,
-0.0150425145,
-0.0447679609,
0.0029431847,
0.0299138222,
-0.0500602908,
0.0598902553,
-0.0064196773,
-0.0367330238,
-0.0840374008,
-0.028247457,
-0.0545139126,
-0.0778445527,
-0.0241813399,
0.0152023472,
0.0324989893,
-0.0021906449,
-0.0437247865,
-0.0942453817,
0.0056413379,
0.0198910441,
-0.040347293,
0.0002445496,
0.0727681369,
0.0106132654,
-0.0130999153,
0.0056248298,
-0.0512712002,
0.0307280235,
-0.0400135592,
0.074077867,
0.0033800998,
0.0252211913,
-0.0667888969,
0.0346066393,
-0.0685366616,
-0.0312229898,
0.0142434435,
0.0169409029,
0.0182851739,
0.0014019752,
0.0016833316,
-0.0146719543,
-0.0213080682,
0.031277895,
-0.0047538672,
-0.0101812407,
0.0445029549,
0.0203165319,
0.0013182788,
0.0421230868,
-0.0416008085,
0.0432616323,
-0.0298023615,
0.101700753,
-0.0473621935,
-0.0518328249,
0.024207389,
-0.0124049569,
0.0117689837,
0.0010611154,
-0.0198373385,
-0.0327421613,
0.0314050429,
-0.0108581679,
-0.0280847978,
-0.014856684,
-0.0092477463,
0.0387202837,
-0.022543367,
-0.0100673884,
-0.0017153829,
0.009974991,
-0.0197511427,
0.0021334698,
0.0289692543,
0.0420859419,
0.0089310948,
0.0375274085,
-0.042927444,
-0.0214895848,
-0.0292497333,
-0.011059626,
0.0472529642,
0.0105131892,
0.066477932,
0.0395730585,
0.0035244212,
-0.0011972722,
-0.0391837284,
-0.065058805,
-0.0560479723,
0.0349179208,
-0.0049317866,
0.0739165172,
-0.0473669805,
-0.007296761,
-0.0390701331,
0.0012809441,
0.0200390648,
0.0145575581,
0.0053554149,
-0.0444964468,
0.0634196028,
0.0358613804,
-0.047653053,
0.0380429029,
0.0762068704,
0.0236334261,
0.0375874676,
0.0217784978,
0.0039899964,
-0.028975606,
-0.0968699083,
0.0083756363,
-0.0071635158,
0.0003625242,
0.0176103637,
-0.0817116052,
-0.0172837302,
0.0098030353,
0.0290290024,
-0.0329180062,
-0.0126357041,
0.0066340789,
0.0473615192,
0.0251442865,
0.0110363681,
-0.0069790157,
0.0273032729,
-0.0650540963,
-0.017319262,
-0.0463629961,
-5.691201817e-33,
0.0096377833,
-0.0532220379,
0.0628108308,
-0.0277912822,
0.029910937,
0.0132484147,
-0.0302194841,
-0.0160604194,
-0.0203681756,
0.0319273211,
-0.0087239137,
0.0015858095,
0.0167603828,
0.0032016814,
0.0184495188,
-0.0099583464,
-0.0033082445,
-0.0022251909,
0.0178946164,
0.0054331808,
0.0097301342,
0.0264331177,
0.0505485162,
-0.0187590644,
0.0467747226,
-0.0132329045,
-0.0053664306,
0.0529428907,
-0.0049649761,
0.0583910644,
-0.0109853186,
0.0004348702,
0.0356730781,
-0.084930636,
-0.006434015,
0.0216847733,
-0.0422506295,
-0.0515619479,
0.0080207782,
-0.0018517759,
-0.0359958149,
-0.0000332822,
-0.0161637124,
0.0272926576,
0.0038733047,
-0.0091350731,
0.0161674079,
-0.0349370353,
0.0021852551,
-0.0184605401,
-0.063930586,
0.04416674,
-0.0540400147,
0.0304357335,
-0.001985166,
0.1120777577,
-0.0005606673,
0.0205707047,
-0.0342505425,
0.0068119266,
-0.0152613558,
-0.0069000791,
0.0541119315,
-0.0141890021,
0.0141183874,
0.0558246933,
-0.0277251173,
-0.0140400687,
-0.019334618,
0.0415505879,
-0.0079844454,
0.0585257262,
0.0303944349,
0.0287842415,
0.0169933867,
0.0426745787,
-0.0951263607,
0.0230155252,
0.0397364609,
0.0661254749,
0.0310658887,
0.0036055821,
-0.0021520283,
-0.028011173,
-0.0792509094,
0.0389061496,
-0.0152917532,
0.0113899019,
0.0349294841,
-0.0139352782,
-0.0037664403,
0.0032818592,
0.0423707627,
-0.0334310979,
-0.0831428021,
0.051275894,
-0.0039978828,
0.0062585594,
0.0120162843,
0.088967219,
-0.0598836355,
0.0060387016,
-0.0109040374,
-0.0241205711,
0.0111096781,
-0.0177023802,
-0.0124259982,
-0.0172136016,
-0.0344194099,
-0.0101676844,
-0.030363258,
0.0252009463,
-0.0015785287,
-0.0028685567,
0.0449943319,
0.010454501,
0.0118761342,
0.0289946124,
0.0033009576,
-0.0247197654,
0.0079555614,
0.004570548,
-0.0149855679,
0.0292433873,
0.0043807966,
0.0028952311,
-0.0431364737,
0.0664798021,
-0.0247179773,
-0.0280800164,
-0.0093774181,
0.0790299922,
2.583e-7,
0.0543738082,
0.0426901691,
-0.0001469576,
0.067522034,
0.0097061731,
0.0280703064,
-0.0525794029,
-0.0066086752,
-0.0080929697,
0.0037978047,
0.0195213947,
0.0479190685,
0.0330079831,
0.0331597589,
-0.0620146133,
-0.0144613115,
-0.1023309007,
-0.0127672674,
-0.0641551316,
-0.0207709316,
0.0621245801,
0.0529977307,
0.0095707439,
0.002310416,
-0.0106114252,
-0.0599209368,
0.0598068163,
-0.0424686037,
0.0137108956,
0.023503447,
-0.0036767572,
0.014127003,
0.0105914893,
-0.0001750718,
0.0172606986,
0.0170312934,
-0.0451353677,
0.0808987021,
0.0453781821,
-0.027873164,
-0.0050217821,
-0.0564794615,
-0.0089177936,
-0.0622768216,
0.0929021537,
-0.0818127692,
-0.0604628362,
-0.0236613657,
-0.0206711385,
0.0009886264,
0.0046937624,
0.0190397929,
0.0177079309,
0.021853704,
-0.0003164016,
-0.0276425704,
0.0172130372,
-0.0372771211,
-0.0262217466,
0.0318754502,
-0.0283902846,
-0.015757205,
-0.0307677183,
0.0203453284,
0.0139763029,
-0.0233221482,
0.0091916285,
2.319775424e-34,
0.0425269231,
-0.0043563875,
-0.0065179998,
0.0321161151,
0.0605736263,
-0.0211136304,
-0.0508133024,
0.0406113453,
0.0186030902,
-0.0975221321,
-0.0015532434
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07932v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07932v2
|
PARDEN, Can You Repeat That? Defending against Jailbreaks via Repetition
| 2024-05-13T17:08:42 | 2024-05-14T15:56:37 |
Ziyang Zhang, Qizhen Zhang, Jakob Foerster
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown success in many natural language
processing tasks. Despite rigorous safety alignment processes, supposedly
safety-aligned LLMs like Llama 2 and Claude 2 are still susceptible to
jailbreaks, leading to security risks and abuse of the models. One option to
mitigate such risks is to augment the LLM with a dedicated "safeguard", which
checks the LLM's inputs or outputs for undesired behaviour. A promising
approach is to use the LLM itself as the safeguard. Nonetheless, baseline
methods, such as prompting the LLM to self-classify toxic content, demonstrate
limited efficacy. We hypothesise that this is due to domain shift: the
alignment training imparts a self-censoring behaviour to the model ("Sorry I
can't do that"), while the self-classify approach shifts it to a classification
format ("Is this prompt malicious"). In this work, we propose PARDEN, which
avoids this domain shift by simply asking the model to repeat its own outputs.
PARDEN neither requires finetuning nor white box access to the model. We
empirically verify the effectiveness of our method and show that PARDEN
significantly outperforms existing jailbreak detection baselines for Llama-2
and Claude-2. Code and data are available at https://github.com/Ed-Zh/PARDEN.
We find that PARDEN is particularly powerful in the relevant regime of high
True Positive Rate (TPR) and low False Positive Rate (FPR). For instance, for
Llama2-7B, at TPR equal to 90%, PARDEN accomplishes a roughly 11x reduction in
the FPR from 24.8% to 2.0% on the harmful behaviours dataset.
|
PARDEN, Can You Repeat That? Defending against Jailbreaks via Repetition: Large language models (LLMs) have shown success in many natural language
processing tasks. Despite rigorous safety alignment processes, supposedly
safety-aligned LLMs like Llama 2 and Claude 2 are still susceptible to
jailbreaks, leading to security risks and abuse of the models. One option to
mitigate such risks is to augment the LLM with a dedicated "safeguard", which
checks the LLM's inputs or outputs for undesired behaviour. A promising
approach is to use the LLM itself as the safeguard. Nonetheless, baseline
methods, such as prompting the LLM to self-classify toxic content, demonstrate
limited efficacy. We hypothesise that this is due to domain shift: the
alignment training imparts a self-censoring behaviour to the model ("Sorry I
can't do that"), while the self-classify approach shifts it to a classification
format ("Is this prompt malicious"). In this work, we propose PARDEN, which
avoids this domain shift by simply asking the model to repeat its own outputs.
PARDEN neither requires finetuning nor white box access to the model. We
empirically verify the effectiveness of our method and show that PARDEN
significantly outperforms existing jailbreak detection baselines for Llama-2
and Claude-2. Code and data are available at https://github.com/Ed-Zh/PARDEN.
We find that PARDEN is particularly powerful in the relevant regime of high
True Positive Rate (TPR) and low False Positive Rate (FPR). For instance, for
Llama2-7B, at TPR equal to 90%, PARDEN accomplishes a roughly 11x reduction in
the FPR from 24.8% to 2.0% on the harmful behaviours dataset.
|
[
0.0459761769,
0.048072204,
-0.021167798,
0.0326747037,
-0.0420206264,
0.0131964507,
-0.004230449,
-0.018825585,
0.0605100393,
-0.0702164844,
-0.0285743326,
-0.0112651298,
-0.0084150638,
0.0440868326,
0.0209504925,
-0.0098304562,
0.0766275823,
-0.0083119292,
-0.0002213564,
0.0203743577,
0.033909712,
-0.0064671738,
0.0040042363,
0.033188168,
-0.0118383951,
-0.0258639846,
-0.000353617,
-0.0031791453,
0.0348262005,
-0.0580472499,
0.0249037016,
0.0323215313,
-0.0178051721,
0.0618945509,
0.0000020657,
-0.0462207459,
-0.0403798372,
0.0122104762,
-0.004950597,
0.0332629271,
0.0290973578,
-0.0517829508,
-0.0140958223,
0.0390284061,
-0.0554543249,
-0.009629068,
0.0448873825,
0.0499248579,
0.1055808216,
0.0799853131,
0.0031195392,
-0.0116104754,
0.0566559881,
-0.0218072962,
-0.0022591732,
-0.0442028753,
0.0387392007,
-0.0498576723,
-0.0235303324,
0.016037941,
0.0132023562,
0.0083270436,
0.0211390778,
-0.0225425307,
-0.0289227888,
0.0058526234,
-0.0267176945,
-0.0646357611,
-0.0221767109,
0.0550242849,
-0.0415931828,
-0.0423980318,
-0.00326825,
-0.0053462251,
0.029832691,
-0.0098575139,
-0.0053063463,
0.0258592218,
-0.0066476143,
0.0217691865,
0.0329549201,
-0.0003376478,
0.0647587329,
0.0031606294,
0.0066583953,
0.0593198426,
0.0011642671,
-0.036676161,
0.0182465408,
-0.0259201825,
0.0026252498,
-0.04195204,
0.004447829,
-0.0032051404,
0.0090561984,
0.0243997369,
-0.0809179544,
-0.0184890646,
0.0542727336,
-0.0554214194,
-0.0077493875,
0.0199135207,
-0.0581442565,
0.0122868493,
-0.0231123939,
0.0050655878,
-0.0109747695,
0.0533874147,
-0.0070714336,
0.0278178807,
-0.0116043668,
-0.0311387293,
-0.0192919746,
0.060832426,
0.0271033216,
0.0002372949,
-0.0442988798,
0.0309334509,
-0.0171075203,
0.0104694711,
-0.0143525731,
0.0037562479,
-0.0165080633,
0.0327730663,
0.0249432586,
-0.0100191999,
-0.0128639545,
0.0153715368,
0.005813695,
-0.0744054243,
-0.0277325977,
0.020054128,
-0.0736327842,
-0.0330422595,
-0.0138892382,
0.0832857564,
0.024426261,
-0.0360922441,
-0.0736933127,
-0.0628918186,
-0.0656768829,
-0.0050529083,
-0.0031087729,
-0.0476653315,
-0.0266874172,
-0.0319704488,
0.0238216519,
-0.0827335492,
0.0263246074,
-0.0072537926,
-0.0430021249,
0.064107798,
0.0071043973,
-0.0347777531,
-0.0160827339,
0.0508948006,
0.0153628578,
0.0848743916,
0.0109403506,
0.0272433162,
0.0610806048,
-0.0131745934,
0.0186505634,
0.0396946408,
0.0120557472,
0.0182230361,
-0.0186833907,
-0.0280929208,
0.0198396649,
-0.0174839478,
0.0079248734,
0.0310247224,
0.0134775918,
-0.02877656,
0.0613646097,
0.0312823914,
-0.0241087489,
0.0278875995,
0.0053237248,
-0.0268569123,
-0.0159620363,
0.0172421578,
-0.0784725621,
-0.0066222656,
-0.062468335,
-0.0233011767,
-0.0050309193,
0.032948751,
-0.0014202127,
-0.0208745152,
0.0061212792,
-0.0058282861,
0.0151950307,
-0.0169141684,
0.0156947579,
0.0301903859,
0.0007424671,
0.0507301614,
0.0236385874,
-0.0408082493,
-0.0172550678,
-0.0783682168,
0.0342592187,
0.0579614416,
0.0350080207,
-0.0149748866,
-0.0203799717,
-0.0331797898,
-0.0028916108,
-0.0056983512,
-0.0095647927,
0.0053142556,
0.0247607008,
-0.028835671,
-0.0328669623,
-0.0280513745,
0.0304762628,
0.0137900431,
0.0263542067,
0.0153087676,
0.0172482505,
-0.0066083167,
-0.0156673547,
0.0660070404,
0.0287256036,
-0.0254874676,
0.0063395333,
0.0175129343,
0.0421051271,
-0.0003527465,
-0.0249599963,
0.0097506996,
0.0704248175,
-0.0161480457,
0.0205051713,
-0.0157820005,
-0.0473888777,
-0.0364228413,
0.0530978069,
-0.0275525954,
0.0073732422,
0.0967349857,
-0.0426684879,
0.0022656969,
0.0181336794,
-0.0340845138,
0.0340366997,
-0.0072147273,
0.0311034285,
-0.0103425793,
0.0412001833,
-0.0128812334,
0.0246471986,
-0.0296759084,
-0.0143388612,
-0.0346382968,
0.0019700448,
0.0142113585,
-0.0002023916,
-0.0535777658,
-0.0151498728,
-0.047804635,
0.0242258795,
0.0125144711,
0.0302551612,
-0.0121043567,
-0.0351022705,
-0.0244448613,
0.0003127133,
-0.0396096259,
0.029954724,
0.0419520959,
0.0160234869,
-0.0210277867,
-0.0328799337,
-0.0095462007,
-0.0284709688,
0.0143683422,
0.0228827279,
-0.0003707088,
-0.0378093086,
-0.0500223823,
-0.0227413159,
-0.0115312673,
-0.0045062751,
0.0262762662,
-0.0178798623,
-0.0448000431,
-0.0270128567,
0.0130590592,
0.0068827597,
0.0199972615,
-0.019439308,
-0.0478941202,
0.0237336587,
0.0252022836,
-0.0432360433,
0.067674607,
0.0126959682,
0.0396813415,
0.0707805827,
0.0383439623,
-0.0408312716,
-0.014666344,
0.0195733402,
-0.0455265082,
-0.0405230895,
-0.054555513,
0.0342382491,
0.057164643,
0.0315885507,
-0.0026992701,
-0.0179032255,
-0.0062802555,
-0.0023493767,
-0.0443301015,
0.011813459,
-0.0634298101,
-0.0476259217,
-0.0107572488,
-0.0293067396,
-0.0943928137,
0.0683272257,
-0.0403675288,
0.0199626926,
-0.030159587,
-0.0427363105,
-0.0063149217,
0.0455833115,
-0.0025890991,
0.013944651,
0.0547218248,
-0.0466066524,
-0.0139928022,
-0.0218134932,
0.0176904574,
-0.007876981,
0.0467380434,
-0.0485854931,
0.0074792616,
-0.0031383738,
-0.0612101816,
-0.0924791321,
-0.0735974535,
-0.0075972457,
-0.035274066,
0.0108419573,
-0.0050338483,
-0.0245155822,
-0.0088532697,
-0.0069679213,
0.0010723224,
-0.0102775013,
0.0075957645,
-0.0152788088,
0.0429042913,
0.0369945765,
-0.0453255661,
0.0231841803,
0.0151029313,
0.0378106087,
0.0874012485,
0.0046056346,
0.026395794,
-0.0212033466,
0.0446733274,
0.0121230185,
-0.0146021796,
-0.0225152131,
0.0372479819,
0.0287123416,
-0.0380560383,
-0.0451463014,
0.0594746396,
0.0409654975,
0.0005846473,
0.0213101469,
0.0114099877,
0.0495902188,
0.0313059315,
-0.0151314884,
-0.0380947031,
-0.036686141,
0.0303008817,
0.062325865,
-0.0328946523,
0.0023585202,
-0.0182082318,
-0.1124846116,
-0.0046507171,
0.0425647274,
-0.0143871028,
-0.0023143471,
-0.0417362079,
-0.0316282548,
-0.0041153934,
0.0163187534,
-0.0150991827,
-0.0135934865,
-0.0138553483,
0.019691363,
-0.0510349125,
-0.0211665276,
0.0082551688,
-0.0267780814,
0.0588909797,
0.100196071,
-0.002795008,
-0.0380546898,
-0.0052621509,
0.0609942526,
-0.0310753025,
-0.0046298583,
0.0070551853,
0.0392392799,
-0.0180444904,
0.011005369,
0.002396343,
0.0631514117,
-0.012406636,
-0.0256228801,
0.0523506068,
0.0651715621,
0.0123787038,
-0.0102642719,
-0.0493216813,
0.0061838673,
0.0095887966,
0.064144887,
0.0329243504,
-0.031401515,
-0.0374204703,
-0.0472856686,
-0.0298477933,
-0.0349776037,
-0.01762628,
0.0463309512,
0.0028734303,
-0.0299421381,
-0.064669013,
-0.0127319796,
-0.0307689235,
0.0263493396,
0.0381934792,
-0.0042884755,
-0.0328463204,
0.0075471946,
-0.0406143181,
0.0027895323,
0.0042439685,
0.0351964831,
-0.0753244385,
0.0446460992,
0.0218990594,
0.0182175692,
-0.0229064729,
0.0194821227,
-0.0842870846,
-0.0883940905,
0.0335753374,
0.0701607093,
0.0234813746,
0.0179424565,
-0.0420297459,
-0.0477056764,
0.0603963062,
0.1079023927,
-0.0691639483,
0.0023850682,
0.0701269507,
-0.0543253906,
0.0169066563,
0.0219968818,
-0.025383871,
-0.0147896828,
0.0329952464,
-0.0012245278,
-0.0349917449,
-0.0126140341,
0.029571835,
0.0360842831,
0.0400312282,
-0.0260469746,
0.0130106332,
0.0023547967,
0.030999478,
0.017572524,
-0.0308620688,
0.0143415127,
0.0478549376,
0.0475342385,
-0.0541327968,
0.0006760726,
0.0221970417,
-0.0400386676,
0.0262772329,
-0.0161546003,
0.0051729833,
0.0298600122,
0.0294638667,
0.0349775217,
0.0164175741,
-0.0277432892,
0.040002767,
0.0159168281,
0.0233801398,
-0.0202627219,
0.0339847505,
-0.0189888049,
0.0054097534,
-0.024339607,
0.0626040921,
-0.0496731326,
0.0077542509,
-0.0321387537,
0.0520825945,
0.0013580553,
0.0089416159,
0.0413605236,
-0.0175897684,
-0.000498901,
-0.0310447756,
0.0046226145,
-0.0331910588,
-0.0540246889,
0.0220385548,
-0.0150148934,
-0.0325165205,
0.0074459757,
0.0635989532,
0.0056738239,
0.0598060749,
0.0306455549,
-0.0231986474,
-0.0511657819,
-0.0141726853,
0.0818442106,
0.0329597518,
-0.0541798435,
-0.0335625708,
-0.0599788725,
-0.0803148672,
-0.0017269551,
-0.0054969923,
0.0442259945,
0.0073895166,
-0.0273101237,
0.054461997,
-0.0059361672,
0.009093089,
-0.0403229892,
-0.0024385487,
0.0328976251,
-0.0438780896,
-0.0063406453,
-5.959107265e-33,
0.0048048506,
-0.0209776498,
-0.0473316386,
-0.0181823261,
0.0065715755,
-0.0157247949,
0.0096395789,
0.0149552077,
-0.0072913785,
-0.0257821716,
-0.0061769886,
-0.001558982,
-0.003855601,
0.0039069825,
-0.0103483722,
-0.0363395363,
0.0320701227,
-0.0045114537,
-0.0577562824,
0.0302400384,
0.0401832163,
0.0327958763,
-0.0040421179,
-0.0595356263,
0.0317094363,
-0.0051709348,
-0.0388633944,
0.0145297488,
-0.0515167788,
0.0829053149,
0.009867576,
0.0329033844,
0.0261148307,
-0.0025192169,
-0.0037169787,
0.0707441419,
-0.0436392054,
-0.0189990159,
0.0120995287,
-0.0033024063,
0.008363096,
-0.0452216081,
0.0837701336,
0.0059451815,
-0.010115698,
-0.0054811738,
0.0018187546,
-0.0292986296,
-0.0357398503,
-0.0129751191,
-0.0288703851,
-0.0128728431,
-0.0205484331,
-0.041127108,
-0.0128016705,
0.0263732392,
0.013666329,
0.0053151404,
-0.0534785204,
0.0160060637,
0.0259496961,
0.018266473,
0.0344336182,
-0.0051336279,
-0.0261593275,
0.0831988677,
-0.0011142553,
-0.0434018858,
0.0201297235,
-0.0103887869,
0.0137020601,
0.0260192752,
0.0381048769,
0.071059525,
0.0517881513,
-0.0435270965,
-0.1049041674,
0.0287555009,
0.0067299344,
0.0376154408,
0.0215817988,
-0.0131652467,
-0.0495583564,
-0.0043875366,
-0.021194214,
-0.0081694061,
-0.0100404955,
-0.0493781604,
0.0485819541,
0.0041401386,
-0.0379919931,
-0.0221435763,
-0.0029308482,
-0.0531817675,
-0.013232952,
0.0176506024,
-0.0072164433,
-0.0028109709,
-0.0124310153,
0.0376488753,
-0.0230894871,
-0.0053705652,
0.0212464891,
-0.0335959457,
0.0499362275,
-0.0175761003,
0.0954862237,
0.0357933678,
-0.0931301787,
0.0102355666,
-0.023816755,
0.0620318092,
0.0139190489,
0.0456987433,
0.0184618142,
-0.0062693162,
0.0021949348,
0.0141680464,
0.0197779816,
-0.0072937263,
-0.0564979464,
0.0250928365,
-0.0164757427,
0.0215092804,
-0.0103434492,
-0.002969766,
0.0014366823,
0.0182929337,
0.0422784835,
-0.0865708217,
0.0030963568,
0.0001691266,
2.836e-7,
-0.0055560339,
-0.0124126943,
0.026208926,
-0.0290323067,
0.0262438171,
0.0696431994,
-0.0383357145,
0.0910452232,
-0.0146573707,
-0.0502887368,
-0.0304221455,
-0.0191767607,
0.0552475005,
0.0598612279,
-0.0404203869,
0.0341037735,
-0.0832263678,
0.0218036361,
-0.0584497787,
-0.0148714976,
0.0484394245,
0.1280709356,
0.0309604462,
-0.0389983021,
0.0081161484,
-0.0734177828,
0.0118792458,
0.0228474978,
-0.0036103684,
-0.010885343,
0.0165930334,
0.0520647652,
0.0034658653,
-0.0071548503,
-0.0370445326,
-0.0214884747,
-0.0506295301,
0.0468148813,
-0.0036371544,
-0.0246061925,
-0.0424432755,
-0.0189043451,
0.0123128733,
-0.0450206064,
0.0790041387,
-0.0124120228,
-0.0038808477,
-0.030167127,
0.0290520377,
-0.0315146968,
0.0370357819,
-0.0342944711,
0.0088543762,
0.0167020913,
0.0235992558,
0.0154739441,
-0.0062781498,
-0.0773968995,
-0.0279881675,
-0.0159749053,
-0.0033875878,
-0.035659425,
-0.0149844792,
0.0501797572,
0.0285157952,
-0.086653702,
0.0282049291,
2.855282666e-34,
-0.0044852532,
-0.0634044334,
0.0195732117,
0.0143060759,
0.0119504305,
0.0125628002,
0.0245778523,
0.0158836599,
-0.0056996006,
-0.0031904876,
-0.0005302062
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07886v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07886v1
|
Russian-Language Multimodal Dataset for Automatic Summarization of Scientific Papers
| 2024-05-13T16:21:33 | 2024-05-13T16:21:33 |
Alena Tsanda, Elena Bruches
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The paper discusses the creation of a multimodal dataset of Russian-language
scientific papers and testing of existing language models for the task of
automatic text summarization. A feature of the dataset is its multimodal data,
which includes texts, tables and figures. The paper presents the results of
experiments with two language models: Gigachat from SBER and YandexGPT from
Yandex. The dataset consists of 420 papers and is publicly available on
https://github.com/iis-research-team/summarization-dataset.
|
Russian-Language Multimodal Dataset for Automatic Summarization of Scientific Papers: The paper discusses the creation of a multimodal dataset of Russian-language
scientific papers and testing of existing language models for the task of
automatic text summarization. A feature of the dataset is its multimodal data,
which includes texts, tables and figures. The paper presents the results of
experiments with two language models: Gigachat from SBER and YandexGPT from
Yandex. The dataset consists of 420 papers and is publicly available on
https://github.com/iis-research-team/summarization-dataset.
|
[
0.0367203578,
0.0400714539,
0.0276270248,
0.0087959552,
-0.0169624742,
0.013089519,
0.0210917704,
0.0085100355,
-0.0254658349,
-0.0435511395,
-0.0261960588,
-0.018572811,
0.0150011452,
0.0072093862,
0.0278379358,
-0.0973030254,
0.021049805,
-0.0220625866,
-0.0149357934,
0.0011275295,
0.0405814722,
-0.0014617103,
-0.0171303265,
-0.0077250698,
0.0198961049,
-0.0105274962,
0.0296086594,
-0.0040090438,
0.0124622695,
-0.0208950099,
-0.0090705259,
0.0219943188,
0.0298079643,
0.0144237867,
0.00000178,
-0.0545618795,
-0.0372181833,
-0.0069896993,
0.0862852708,
-0.0033465261,
0.1016941592,
-0.0993509367,
-0.0170537923,
-0.0409531072,
-0.0081042107,
0.0067625795,
0.0139485626,
0.0608425774,
0.0470698252,
0.0522434413,
-0.0208003204,
-0.0843815282,
0.0461584777,
0.025745526,
-0.0238772798,
-0.002756122,
-0.0099583361,
0.0509902015,
0.0111366995,
0.0272679497,
0.0125024579,
0.056236092,
-0.0054116235,
-0.0515656658,
-0.0527314506,
0.015107573,
-0.0550222248,
-0.0366755426,
-0.0014759233,
0.067105718,
0.0168153998,
-0.0066349902,
0.0403349213,
0.0227890257,
-0.0323832035,
0.0493243001,
-0.1156829745,
0.0507024378,
-0.034180373,
-0.0189183801,
-0.0254778042,
0.0016866318,
-0.0465537161,
0.0100031262,
0.0178352464,
0.0463238172,
0.0058040689,
-0.0051590363,
-0.0117743555,
-0.043968942,
-0.0046378677,
-0.003076796,
0.0343132466,
0.0250463039,
0.0415876508,
-0.0049440055,
-0.043572899,
-0.1156410649,
0.0441980548,
-0.0346343406,
-0.0092400452,
0.002553076,
0.0157033671,
0.0507238582,
-0.0375494882,
0.0022901241,
0.0065011266,
0.0221336186,
-0.0259073824,
-0.0185440052,
-0.0074962685,
0.0238510519,
-0.0381208882,
-0.0044098394,
-0.0146782948,
-0.0373707749,
-0.0266174618,
0.0293442123,
0.0329246931,
0.0339085087,
-0.0088454951,
-0.0247454476,
-0.0152454758,
-0.0235925727,
0.0278647486,
0.0598699972,
-0.0189501867,
-0.0490643568,
-0.0179866049,
-0.007065915,
0.0283759683,
0.0512545109,
0.0334294736,
-0.0156977829,
-0.005967645,
0.0314152949,
-0.0194728039,
-0.0490396395,
0.0260124318,
-0.0278406497,
0.0138453655,
-0.0523321256,
0.0240823217,
-0.0434163846,
0.0072780922,
0.0167127773,
-0.0039466755,
-0.0170813277,
-0.0049984884,
0.018516561,
-0.0481630675,
0.0414377153,
-0.0371912904,
-0.0023676574,
0.0546406955,
-0.0137840156,
0.0404136144,
0.0759673864,
0.0115701351,
0.0367265046,
0.0827516019,
-0.0327934809,
0.0057815886,
0.0464791283,
-0.0036833207,
0.0167618636,
-0.0006043967,
-0.0102096489,
0.0017933054,
-0.0123429652,
0.0303386692,
0.0157337245,
-0.0441551171,
0.0299298819,
0.0716578886,
0.0434627645,
0.0029181652,
0.0329940207,
-0.024397105,
-0.0009983819,
0.0646838769,
0.0462883711,
0.0158531331,
0.0488770306,
-0.0138109252,
0.0847373754,
0.0725906193,
0.0314218141,
-0.0009709818,
-0.0219972953,
0.0079872794,
0.0007226344,
0.0210077073,
-0.0478339605,
0.0947059318,
0.0050356132,
-0.0494041555,
-0.0316111408,
0.0134719945,
-0.0629695579,
0.0049381237,
0.0088440636,
0.0067252326,
0.0015380264,
0.079407461,
-0.0895608366,
0.0045202528,
0.0116454717,
0.0362133235,
0.0401584804,
0.0265840888,
-0.010472565,
-0.0357058607,
-0.0584704988,
-0.0335699096,
-0.0070775133,
-0.0236271843,
0.0030569909,
-0.0372836962,
0.0017567448,
0.0104742711,
0.0004547753,
-0.0331629999,
0.0210513696,
0.0076035098,
0.0369885452,
-0.0494737439,
-0.0319181867,
0.0052239029,
0.0195350498,
-0.032391049,
0.0331599899,
0.0323915184,
-0.0111542027,
0.04404971,
0.0410632119,
0.0364506207,
-0.0125323217,
0.0199591238,
-0.0752577931,
0.0060572783,
0.0160245858,
0.0017862577,
-0.0471216366,
0.0574086495,
-0.0342493169,
-0.0283969603,
-0.006984225,
0.0140410773,
0.0206025001,
0.045303043,
-0.0003483745,
0.0357338078,
-0.0035880972,
0.0399682745,
0.0385930948,
-0.0444678515,
0.0222379696,
-0.0437401347,
-0.0279599484,
0.0301134326,
0.0088471668,
-0.0008846567,
0.0554537065,
-0.0063818949,
-0.0094976332,
0.0009490636,
-0.0967204869,
-0.0057152994,
-0.0188275557,
0.0256206691,
0.0365418531,
0.0088759735,
0.0068055862,
-0.023898812,
0.0056828437,
0.0192055106,
0.0302111451,
-0.0126698352,
0.0528685041,
-0.0088335602,
0.0435374044,
-0.0594712608,
-0.0423035808,
-0.0102381287,
0.0250266902,
0.027022535,
-0.0344548114,
-0.0255985614,
-0.0012873216,
-0.0008321935,
0.0000296928,
-0.0091195703,
-0.0338763557,
0.001525504,
-0.034353327,
0.0322258621,
0.0927155465,
0.0280954204,
-0.0068238778,
0.0419682525,
-0.0137923378,
0.0019766691,
-0.015354122,
-0.0447305553,
0.0579983033,
0.0375108942,
-0.0286897682,
0.0340571031,
0.0251497496,
-0.0037531732,
0.0172232501,
0.0102007641,
0.0188028198,
-0.0204370599,
0.011492731,
-0.0389072597,
0.0462879874,
-0.0037764469,
0.0353194699,
0.0163789578,
0.0165307019,
0.0119358962,
-0.0472090393,
-0.0073346565,
-0.0812410489,
0.0049214656,
-0.0615476854,
0.0271230116,
0.045220878,
0.0251565743,
-0.026374869,
-0.0027396728,
-0.038085375,
-0.0133367516,
0.0467368029,
0.0009751493,
0.0286045913,
-0.0591720082,
0.0247181077,
-0.061408177,
0.0399042591,
0.0558221005,
-0.0492136516,
0.006767537,
0.0145535404,
0.0255322941,
-0.0125404429,
-0.0700489208,
0.0349575244,
0.0694068968,
0.0926448479,
-0.0383852571,
-0.0183854476,
-0.0138757387,
0.0753208771,
0.1012565345,
-0.0045716106,
-0.0397600085,
-0.0086169941,
-0.0056381556,
0.0503416024,
0.0182754043,
-0.0121984184,
-0.0037242142,
-0.0131307524,
0.0074993577,
-0.0425320677,
-0.0043775714,
-0.0462292023,
0.0099423314,
-0.0189296715,
0.024652198,
0.0690525249,
0.0218942873,
-0.0412884541,
-0.0494564399,
-0.0140973069,
-0.0050314986,
-0.0012305286,
-0.0183729809,
-0.0655363575,
0.0137200439,
-0.020625256,
-0.0090037808,
-0.0045869132,
0.00303314,
-0.0122160716,
-0.0441473462,
0.0045000562,
-0.0089676492,
-0.1045866534,
-0.0393219329,
-0.0285143051,
0.010270685,
-0.0127428807,
-0.0073450408,
0.0473107621,
-0.0459252559,
-0.0019234449,
0.0112003833,
-0.0725999847,
-0.041314017,
-0.0773309544,
0.00149167,
-0.019632427,
0.0349393971,
0.052805271,
-0.0482909642,
0.0229727477,
0.026905166,
-0.0079911184,
-0.0263916291,
-0.0188980531,
0.0678630471,
0.0089258309,
-0.0134921065,
-0.0210809205,
0.0483370274,
0.0213350262,
-0.002171542,
0.0297703873,
-0.0260625426,
-0.0093680611,
-0.0028186033,
-0.0713291392,
0.0485111438,
-0.0482200533,
0.0073940493,
-0.0022601441,
0.0212596245,
-0.0341679864,
-0.0146169262,
-0.009561006,
-0.0357331075,
-0.0213289931,
0.0057822359,
-0.0891097859,
-0.0474527627,
-0.079745084,
-0.0488626249,
0.0214211643,
0.0170950033,
0.0077882227,
0.0313090608,
-0.0405012853,
0.0268608965,
-0.0326593108,
0.0053106043,
0.0156855732,
-0.0171253718,
-0.0429421589,
-0.0303350296,
0.0683573931,
-0.0421692953,
-0.0175385792,
0.0048060333,
-0.0047651101,
-0.0334036052,
-0.0335112028,
0.0283163674,
0.0275982115,
0.0087637082,
0.0055455607,
-0.0537954979,
0.0301287808,
0.0027678753,
0.0185989328,
-0.0084017189,
-0.0103026619,
0.0110242013,
-0.0198495779,
-0.0194206685,
-0.0384419449,
0.0476665646,
-0.0208688546,
0.0053587267,
-0.0350196436,
-0.0176283475,
-0.0075986516,
0.0519801676,
0.0073056128,
-0.0175654776,
0.0017456298,
-0.0279247761,
-0.017687792,
-0.0436100625,
-0.0067718113,
-0.0200128127,
0.0733646154,
-0.0121381134,
-0.0060269861,
-0.0060892524,
0.0621826164,
0.0037600093,
-0.0277539287,
-0.0282804109,
0.0480756536,
0.0317219868,
-0.0108722681,
-0.0283322111,
-0.0199025068,
-0.0303235389,
-0.0155948251,
-0.0536932126,
0.005139858,
-0.0081500188,
0.0307723805,
0.0370859392,
-0.0532063693,
0.0188412964,
0.0822457001,
-0.0799624249,
0.0538759679,
-0.0487342887,
0.0368541144,
0.0697317794,
-0.0058647678,
0.1051824316,
-0.0429685861,
-0.01039676,
-0.0106510529,
0.0628063232,
0.0801700652,
0.0242554098,
-0.0081381816,
-0.0107599329,
0.0255478546,
-0.008372332,
0.0965394899,
-0.0106821591,
-0.0304402355,
0.0387072898,
-0.0085588945,
-0.0433428437,
0.0241129082,
-0.0038803688,
0.0005320502,
-0.0085765887,
-0.0442567021,
-0.0158799961,
-0.0034915074,
-0.0134606436,
0.0402277783,
-0.0346990153,
-0.0138027938,
0.031000318,
0.0416135602,
0.0286656246,
0.0126563711,
-0.0680611879,
0.02719054,
-0.0291017797,
-0.0306205377,
-0.0012828429,
-5.425141161e-33,
-0.0045382516,
-0.0011693524,
-0.0218033735,
0.0079430174,
-0.0148933493,
-0.0303679872,
-0.0613467321,
-0.0430458859,
0.0114267189,
-0.007013924,
-0.0253016669,
-0.0100662597,
0.0126472693,
0.0018325786,
0.0117972801,
0.049540475,
-0.0017958143,
0.0006837143,
-0.0179684348,
0.0241548903,
0.042784594,
0.0028002192,
0.0892351642,
-0.0561092384,
0.0431450196,
-0.011357815,
-0.0041751149,
-0.0550999157,
0.0708945543,
0.0283103511,
-0.0315761827,
0.0114683798,
0.0334402621,
-0.0448907316,
-0.0377408043,
0.0128636584,
-0.0638958067,
0.0074115274,
0.0362163596,
0.0510587655,
-0.0368091539,
-0.0106353005,
0.0476824678,
-0.0792800114,
0.0246144421,
0.0022915397,
0.0810469165,
-0.0545063019,
-0.0587113835,
-0.0637116805,
-0.0527333356,
0.0384929702,
-0.0369479172,
0.0135335447,
0.0714948922,
0.0435632505,
0.0139999352,
0.0046541053,
0.0001058604,
0.0518957824,
0.0025334903,
0.0415312275,
0.0489715375,
-0.0457567014,
0.0276812688,
0.0312308501,
0.002964142,
-0.0222908072,
0.0348224528,
0.0087426119,
0.0276420005,
0.0010828486,
0.0264727771,
0.0504060127,
0.0248612054,
0.0129388403,
-0.0210511405,
0.0717743263,
0.0048468523,
0.0353884734,
0.0266796388,
-0.0119347917,
0.033668723,
0.0212192591,
0.0207379274,
-0.0254256558,
-0.0215658341,
-0.037375737,
-0.016292261,
-0.0292993523,
-0.0485966839,
-0.0165349878,
0.0182902552,
-0.0185050685,
-0.0356358662,
0.0301673673,
-0.0068665612,
0.0689592883,
-0.0284736492,
-0.0424771905,
0.0079385424,
-0.0390216745,
0.0190833211,
0.0094025508,
0.0038335619,
-0.0053827702,
0.0170702022,
-0.0057286825,
-0.0170206409,
-0.0075052041,
0.0279758666,
-0.0167271234,
0.0011957985,
0.0545920618,
-0.0228241757,
-0.023210628,
-0.0044388706,
0.0192441661,
0.0429099835,
-0.0020837104,
-0.0217523202,
-0.0275868215,
0.0185828935,
0.0252905451,
-0.0061892602,
0.0179847367,
-0.0310293362,
-0.0157395918,
0.0203153025,
-0.0180401895,
0.0005661329,
-0.0011120066,
2.426e-7,
0.0507977568,
0.0545455292,
0.0288253631,
-0.01782047,
0.0323427171,
-0.0171798673,
-0.0470837541,
0.0333159789,
0.0037059064,
0.0094141988,
0.0364715904,
-0.0374400727,
0.0380245037,
0.0220668092,
-0.0703185573,
-0.0568517707,
-0.0670310184,
-0.0503803343,
-0.0458428301,
0.0437558033,
0.0413253121,
0.0582101159,
-0.0682608262,
-0.0044323285,
-0.037794549,
-0.0413062535,
0.0239496604,
-0.0257526152,
-0.0159287378,
0.0295163058,
0.0645459667,
-0.0114903394,
-0.0219981465,
0.0007323432,
-0.0013490175,
-0.0407644734,
0.0630076081,
-0.0047434573,
-0.0009592084,
0.017070055,
0.0451520607,
-0.0244490542,
0.0098904092,
-0.0336391702,
0.0655550212,
-0.0347887874,
-0.0270218607,
-0.0005172307,
-0.0452212207,
0.0004473033,
0.0079837032,
-0.0271162167,
-0.0590620115,
0.0679319873,
0.0054223766,
-0.0426919907,
0.0206857491,
-0.049876228,
-0.0175474398,
0.0310138017,
0.0095780073,
-0.037592534,
0.001338702,
-0.0531011112,
0.0019212957,
-0.0232638456,
-0.0314768925,
2.118852674e-34,
0.0992412195,
-0.0084764678,
-0.0323507451,
0.0125133405,
0.0039406791,
-0.0565173812,
-0.0292700995,
0.0139884017,
-0.014335339,
-0.0874533802,
-0.0067838179
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07883v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07883v1
|
Zero-Shot Tokenizer Transfer
| 2024-05-13T16:17:10 | 2024-05-13T16:17:10 |
Benjamin Minixhofer, Edoardo Maria Ponti, Ivan Vulić
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models (LMs) are bound to their tokenizer, which maps raw text to a
sequence of vocabulary items (tokens). This restricts their flexibility: for
example, LMs trained primarily on English may still perform well in other
natural and programming languages, but have vastly decreased efficiency due to
their English-centric tokenizer. To mitigate this, we should be able to swap
the original LM tokenizer with an arbitrary one, on the fly, without degrading
performance. Hence, in this work we define a new problem: Zero-Shot Tokenizer
Transfer (ZeTT). The challenge at the core of ZeTT is finding embeddings for
the tokens in the vocabulary of the new tokenizer. Since prior heuristics for
initializing embeddings often perform at chance level in a ZeTT setting, we
propose a new solution: we train a hypernetwork taking a tokenizer as input and
predicting the corresponding embeddings. We empirically demonstrate that the
hypernetwork generalizes to new tokenizers both with encoder (e.g., XLM-R) and
decoder LLMs (e.g., Mistral-7B). Our method comes close to the original models'
performance in cross-lingual and coding tasks while markedly reducing the
length of the tokenized sequence. We also find that the remaining gap can be
quickly closed by continued training on less than 1B tokens. Finally, we show
that a ZeTT hypernetwork trained for a base (L)LM can also be applied to
fine-tuned variants without extra training. Overall, our results make
substantial strides toward detaching LMs from their tokenizer.
|
Zero-Shot Tokenizer Transfer: Language models (LMs) are bound to their tokenizer, which maps raw text to a
sequence of vocabulary items (tokens). This restricts their flexibility: for
example, LMs trained primarily on English may still perform well in other
natural and programming languages, but have vastly decreased efficiency due to
their English-centric tokenizer. To mitigate this, we should be able to swap
the original LM tokenizer with an arbitrary one, on the fly, without degrading
performance. Hence, in this work we define a new problem: Zero-Shot Tokenizer
Transfer (ZeTT). The challenge at the core of ZeTT is finding embeddings for
the tokens in the vocabulary of the new tokenizer. Since prior heuristics for
initializing embeddings often perform at chance level in a ZeTT setting, we
propose a new solution: we train a hypernetwork taking a tokenizer as input and
predicting the corresponding embeddings. We empirically demonstrate that the
hypernetwork generalizes to new tokenizers both with encoder (e.g., XLM-R) and
decoder LLMs (e.g., Mistral-7B). Our method comes close to the original models'
performance in cross-lingual and coding tasks while markedly reducing the
length of the tokenized sequence. We also find that the remaining gap can be
quickly closed by continued training on less than 1B tokens. Finally, we show
that a ZeTT hypernetwork trained for a base (L)LM can also be applied to
fine-tuned variants without extra training. Overall, our results make
substantial strides toward detaching LMs from their tokenizer.
|
[
-0.0245731436,
0.0517261736,
0.0027081394,
0.041113209,
-0.0238571167,
0.0174124781,
0.0001546938,
0.0071065305,
-0.0437154733,
-0.0225461274,
-0.0234963167,
0.0037960312,
-0.0199422128,
0.0331857838,
0.0514540486,
-0.0215961039,
0.0454563461,
-0.0014345588,
-0.015242721,
0.0203939434,
-0.00617722,
0.0288898349,
0.0076454519,
0.0695510656,
-0.0000016529,
0.0076293102,
-0.0212908182,
0.0181592405,
0.0165354274,
-0.0165661275,
-0.0255124494,
0.0252866615,
0.0281991176,
0.0350698344,
0.0000016865,
-0.0068149674,
-0.0233605132,
-0.0132239256,
-0.0013099187,
0.0035044008,
0.0551994406,
-0.0562291741,
-0.0154699935,
0.027424952,
-0.0207776818,
-0.0625593737,
0.037432529,
0.0261636041,
0.0465607867,
0.0752323121,
-0.0125502618,
0.0007807548,
0.0545809418,
-0.0284187421,
0.0198340453,
-0.0320548303,
-0.0001480718,
-0.0114234444,
-0.0244340394,
0.0150064519,
-0.0464800298,
0.0441192053,
0.0110129341,
0.013310262,
0.0129150711,
0.0378506966,
-0.0731791258,
0.0028069415,
-0.0001851666,
0.0578657389,
-0.0921486691,
-0.0254568066,
0.0026072729,
0.0226226766,
0.0026111335,
-0.0116250673,
-0.0592201017,
0.0041305642,
0.0451690219,
0.0410178043,
0.0304485653,
-0.0390310697,
0.0383029133,
-0.0046350267,
-0.0465203039,
0.0461471751,
0.0366154164,
0.0101851905,
-0.0364724472,
-0.0097669186,
-0.0039480133,
-0.0887734368,
0.0030742974,
0.0209979564,
0.0065606367,
0.0043653026,
-0.0544433407,
-0.0484116897,
-0.0149834203,
0.0110768052,
0.0185283851,
0.0633285046,
-0.0169710927,
0.0153675843,
-0.0955006629,
0.042115286,
-0.0169081576,
0.0383075103,
-0.0714344382,
-0.0370302685,
-0.0645601079,
-0.0239485092,
-0.07631699,
0.0379650854,
-0.0197085943,
-0.0440644845,
-0.0285098553,
0.0120994756,
0.0261478331,
0.0091843987,
-0.0156273693,
-0.0124343308,
-0.0292507373,
0.0018968631,
0.0192264747,
0.0386680402,
-0.0153081603,
0.0169970933,
0.0289507937,
-0.0358709432,
-0.0490923971,
0.0423668474,
0.0262973644,
-0.0148971053,
-0.0112850145,
0.0844279304,
-0.0339463688,
-0.0348819308,
-0.0397622846,
-0.0119706644,
0.0109085096,
-0.0190024339,
-0.0001222958,
-0.0749741867,
0.0124032618,
-0.0046975976,
0.0131284334,
-0.0116871204,
-0.0023029621,
0.0176946931,
-0.024179453,
0.0741024241,
-0.0112906154,
-0.0365917087,
0.0133240018,
-0.0184768122,
-0.0239448976,
0.0626121387,
0.0304773618,
0.0287136268,
0.0313284509,
-0.0348506011,
0.0012973436,
0.051738143,
0.0289082043,
0.008380862,
-0.0536242984,
-0.0352837741,
0.0569823198,
0.0318080075,
0.0623165369,
0.0405359305,
-0.0782252103,
0.0194586366,
0.0156601369,
0.0947172567,
0.017720107,
0.0112102972,
0.1017383486,
-0.0356887877,
-0.0569877513,
0.0109144878,
-0.0241835974,
0.0120821493,
0.0271207523,
-0.0099035474,
0.0326784924,
0.003067581,
-0.0584750101,
-0.0323509239,
-0.0030831718,
-0.0349549577,
0.0018381504,
-0.0655260161,
0.0395189077,
0.0367428809,
-0.0524537116,
0.0818381011,
0.0184049141,
-0.0512532219,
0.0465619937,
-0.0269876011,
0.0123570897,
0.0773714483,
0.0284573827,
-0.0028469597,
-0.0184773374,
-0.0209970847,
0.0070448462,
0.0199669525,
0.0226597078,
-0.0317975394,
0.0206556562,
-0.0863773003,
0.0076525137,
-0.0048176567,
0.0278271008,
0.0581542328,
-0.0500362888,
0.0506473854,
0.036051169,
-0.0340206139,
0.0127873607,
0.0322960131,
-0.0445270911,
-0.030058492,
0.011031799,
-0.0002868503,
0.0188736822,
0.0208751746,
0.0078616459,
0.0102297794,
0.0199436266,
-0.0729592219,
-0.0327435359,
-0.0134345749,
-0.0593731962,
-0.0746894553,
0.0215220097,
-0.0430341996,
0.0431968644,
0.034989927,
-0.0558716543,
-0.0462028347,
0.0447741747,
0.0270358268,
0.0781274661,
-0.0338663943,
0.0139870914,
0.0309092142,
0.0398810208,
-0.0138840498,
0.0015283711,
0.0090237083,
0.022417536,
-0.0021128054,
-0.01717503,
0.0253928546,
-0.0342087969,
-0.0251400992,
0.0431417152,
-0.0133355595,
0.0095353201,
-0.0072017936,
0.0107928952,
-0.0078083961,
-0.0187649876,
-0.0938237906,
0.0174442008,
-0.0308435727,
0.0249823891,
0.0245029461,
-0.0010510652,
0.010650848,
-0.0063487086,
-0.0554240905,
0.027932059,
-0.0058447206,
0.0147901531,
0.04032024,
-0.000551879,
-0.0340224281,
-0.0253333058,
-0.0341821834,
-0.0018598716,
0.067165181,
-0.0660203025,
0.0025688172,
-0.0498404279,
-0.0168509912,
-0.034120705,
0.0094083687,
0.0117468182,
-0.0548591018,
0.0033912202,
-0.0275706481,
-0.0053039491,
0.0489768349,
-0.0123061351,
0.0103146369,
0.0302424729,
0.0206029564,
-0.0580355078,
-0.0271362811,
-0.0178098604,
-0.0065334532,
-0.0348555148,
0.0042293705,
-0.0026082676,
0.0644342378,
-0.0190668292,
-0.0159751102,
-0.0827448592,
-0.0013596315,
-0.0256876759,
-0.0111862477,
-0.0191752762,
-0.0068017561,
-0.007677611,
0.0272808168,
-0.0087594148,
-0.0178205539,
0.0301425625,
-0.0548536554,
0.0067361258,
-0.0160713438,
-0.0176375024,
-0.0422643907,
0.0011923977,
0.0219141915,
0.0292182975,
-0.0016001866,
-0.0564153753,
-0.0299803969,
-0.0178528503,
-0.0213788431,
-0.0118372841,
0.0261591189,
-0.0147721181,
-0.011314475,
-0.022208916,
-0.0256133415,
-0.0321353786,
-0.0083438568,
-0.0105077615,
0.0664373264,
0.0274789669,
-0.0009074677,
-0.0325249992,
0.0233146492,
-0.0183774773,
0.108119376,
-0.0069363196,
0.00524149,
-0.0408952758,
0.0650573,
0.0106903706,
-0.0237801615,
-0.0112500945,
0.0043868995,
0.0214531701,
0.0391639881,
0.0449582152,
0.0023039358,
-0.0375048704,
0.019541109,
0.0314804837,
-0.021553779,
-0.0128952479,
-0.0180293377,
0.0350710452,
-0.0205490422,
-0.0081995754,
0.1192694828,
0.0224497858,
-0.0511856265,
0.0111407768,
-0.0124720959,
0.0324642286,
0.0253499988,
0.0039929352,
-0.1037657037,
-0.027694026,
0.0221310593,
0.0116456756,
0.0332853645,
-0.0325942226,
-0.0174253285,
-0.1157529131,
-0.0054741325,
0.0423263088,
-0.0638492778,
-0.0110480636,
-0.023470616,
-0.029447265,
-0.0217983089,
0.0523057543,
-0.010455153,
0.0225764383,
-0.010521194,
0.023155624,
0.0087080272,
-0.0560427532,
-0.0035713017,
-0.0344809256,
0.0643244684,
0.0332405679,
0.0141888866,
-0.0102322157,
-0.0121033126,
0.0471293963,
0.0073852278,
-0.0138436556,
-0.0122656589,
0.0431280062,
-0.0530130379,
-0.0224938169,
0.082698524,
0.0320447385,
-0.0440591909,
-0.0225567091,
0.0055650724,
0.0902223215,
0.0431359001,
-0.0093203904,
-0.0136304414,
-0.0404309332,
-0.0042215604,
0.0589542687,
0.0333982222,
-0.0343166515,
0.0218146592,
-0.0310167372,
-0.0032707627,
-0.0514575914,
0.0061973492,
-0.0144536747,
0.0008035512,
-0.0475548431,
-0.0960058048,
-0.0091189444,
0.0367389247,
0.0676753223,
0.0143122654,
-0.0022776371,
-0.0149922147,
-0.0295337327,
-0.0187645387,
0.0169576518,
-0.0318399295,
-0.0075878273,
-0.0542664863,
0.0188180953,
0.040547628,
-0.0163850691,
-0.0262803957,
-0.030219866,
-0.0373420306,
-0.0487874299,
-0.0378346331,
0.0468513519,
0.015053302,
0.058216732,
-0.015683366,
-0.0524281375,
0.0538380146,
0.0346383788,
-0.0367957354,
0.0018458943,
0.0364978798,
0.0041093943,
-0.0027448782,
0.0463481657,
-0.0325484015,
0.0208094046,
0.0266864579,
0.0257620756,
-0.011545076,
0.0149663808,
0.0016320241,
-0.0032252213,
0.0497295968,
-0.006451421,
0.0457584001,
-0.0147616444,
0.0216154791,
-0.0367993899,
0.0241350438,
-0.0526892804,
-0.0027784014,
0.0558974408,
-0.0117958076,
-0.0082668271,
-0.0103986133,
-0.0199602488,
0.0428577475,
0.0069017238,
0.0077114301,
-0.0253659785,
0.020856604,
0.0293594822,
0.0166505035,
-0.0228799991,
-0.0331586376,
-0.0285462886,
0.0122370422,
-0.1001929343,
-0.0193119887,
0.0222561378,
0.0499947891,
-0.0369568169,
0.0413546562,
-0.0408766009,
-0.0103534656,
-0.0231225099,
0.0268908031,
0.0447343662,
-0.016425224,
0.0358354636,
-0.003676899,
-0.031703677,
-0.0143537689,
0.0213148016,
-0.0178486779,
-0.0256102867,
0.0409869701,
0.0363372974,
-0.0335414372,
-0.002218009,
0.0709862188,
0.0127912862,
0.0383609086,
-0.0189257655,
-0.0019350009,
-0.036082834,
0.0378085002,
0.0594002232,
0.0296128374,
-0.0061739841,
-0.0063198637,
-0.0057004979,
-0.1047491506,
0.030177081,
0.0116039719,
-0.0232511032,
0.0305356029,
0.0224854853,
0.0429627672,
-0.0131961741,
-0.006094628,
-0.0079944413,
0.0047197714,
0.0452518202,
-0.0474059284,
-0.0034181536,
-5.795717591e-33,
-0.0268936083,
0.0110835601,
0.0068817856,
-0.0251565687,
-0.0261165183,
0.0179467946,
-0.0255712494,
0.0044538411,
0.0022600808,
0.0068531814,
-0.0222355034,
-0.0056662923,
0.020320069,
0.0511701405,
0.0111107528,
0.018310681,
0.0467828326,
-0.0137878824,
-0.0254313517,
0.0140749076,
0.049408149,
0.0308492221,
0.0748171583,
0.0077459291,
-0.0441611335,
-0.0048778555,
0.0152233839,
0.0365771167,
0.0561869368,
0.0352012403,
-0.0017523447,
0.0449214689,
0.0140225599,
-0.0605231859,
-0.0235813074,
0.0346696787,
-0.0940368995,
-0.0514249839,
0.0138153648,
0.0082180379,
0.0062253773,
-0.1009748429,
0.0483131744,
-0.0235856101,
-0.0125857852,
0.0013447844,
0.0040401178,
0.0021690999,
-0.0466431193,
-0.0067298426,
-0.0623877123,
0.0048688776,
-0.031466227,
-0.0044045402,
0.0626066849,
0.0260394868,
-0.0029662116,
0.0126739722,
-0.0598496348,
0.0109561216,
-0.0485875346,
0.0677603781,
0.0711310357,
0.0195428524,
-0.0163992457,
0.0606606267,
0.0346169472,
-0.0251350328,
-0.0007815631,
0.0297137499,
0.0641832948,
0.0053423634,
0.0419340916,
0.0099338964,
0.0496537052,
-0.0506482646,
-0.062463291,
-0.0107653709,
-0.0221013818,
0.0130955633,
0.0226446707,
0.0636453107,
0.0009590114,
-0.0206981916,
-0.0533303358,
-0.048004318,
-0.0270266011,
-0.0565341115,
0.0386548229,
0.0088463556,
-0.0041039116,
-0.0158549324,
0.0658251047,
-0.0363583975,
-0.0232753996,
0.04097284,
-0.0134605719,
0.0072909137,
-0.0138041126,
0.03470378,
-0.0697706714,
-0.0527509786,
0.0278126299,
0.0013326994,
0.0302883629,
0.0062757898,
0.0707166269,
0.0208636615,
-0.0673031807,
-0.0182834454,
-0.038291581,
-0.0016688649,
-0.0070793368,
0.0737825632,
0.0386122726,
0.0211056899,
-0.0053950623,
0.0129798111,
0.0028392316,
-0.0492692962,
0.0272602458,
0.0186159555,
0.0087921498,
0.0196320172,
-0.0478569865,
0.0067578149,
-0.0313540772,
0.0407679714,
0.044435095,
-0.0337388851,
-0.0182414539,
0.0470575131,
2.482e-7,
0.024000844,
0.0102972435,
0.0299774371,
-0.0367541984,
0.021888243,
0.014637568,
-0.027123889,
0.0581131615,
0.0128902057,
-0.004946507,
0.007123339,
0.0296569187,
0.0261195023,
0.0252469834,
-0.1078224406,
0.0062588388,
-0.0350443125,
0.0283707939,
-0.0369621888,
-0.002381718,
0.0549334735,
0.1075017229,
0.0161702503,
0.0166618023,
-0.0025386326,
-0.0299201459,
0.026287267,
-0.0000185844,
-0.0259871762,
-0.0050661913,
-0.0412294567,
0.0390429273,
-0.0077007241,
0.0029317753,
-0.023403896,
0.0243346374,
0.0486137457,
0.0345421694,
-0.0248030778,
-0.029246334,
-0.0075139706,
-0.0077242847,
-0.027567191,
-0.0284369905,
0.0711396486,
-0.0638156757,
-0.028862115,
-0.0278090183,
-0.0429040007,
0.0245572291,
0.0081132203,
-0.0025438247,
-0.0295238178,
0.0615914091,
0.0632639602,
0.034547668,
-0.0240234453,
-0.084121637,
0.0304797944,
0.0087300185,
-0.0462559797,
-0.0403464437,
-0.0314818509,
0.0099718897,
0.020803865,
-0.0157296471,
0.0149723543,
2.153492105e-34,
0.0279564876,
-0.0243540872,
0.0312407985,
0.0364530385,
0.0086829932,
-0.0259218216,
-0.0197001621,
0.0119546065,
0.0233787317,
-0.0739894956,
-0.0233302061
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07875v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07875v1
|
Reproducing the Metric-Based Evaluation of a Set of Controllable Text Generation Techniques
| 2024-05-13T16:02:57 | 2024-05-13T16:02:57 |
Michela Lorandi, Anya Belz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Rerunning a metric-based evaluation should be more straightforward, and
results should be closer, than in a human-based evaluation, especially where
code and model checkpoints are made available by the original authors. As this
report of our efforts to rerun a metric-based evaluation of a set of
single-attribute and multiple-attribute controllable text generation (CTG)
techniques shows however, such reruns of evaluations do not always produce
results that are the same as the original results, and can reveal errors in the
reporting of the original work.
|
Reproducing the Metric-Based Evaluation of a Set of Controllable Text Generation Techniques: Rerunning a metric-based evaluation should be more straightforward, and
results should be closer, than in a human-based evaluation, especially where
code and model checkpoints are made available by the original authors. As this
report of our efforts to rerun a metric-based evaluation of a set of
single-attribute and multiple-attribute controllable text generation (CTG)
techniques shows however, such reruns of evaluations do not always produce
results that are the same as the original results, and can reveal errors in the
reporting of the original work.
|
[
-0.0329476185,
0.0159597304,
0.006805785,
-0.014249457,
-0.0378367268,
-0.0085271709,
0.0381937027,
0.0306235887,
-0.0254186615,
-0.0341717415,
-0.0283590443,
-0.0376037359,
0.0328462198,
0.0275376774,
0.0454794429,
-0.0465006642,
0.0050637568,
0.0009466456,
-0.0111429654,
0.018411452,
-0.0044854493,
-0.0080943787,
-0.0095655834,
0.0404489562,
-0.0155645637,
-0.028543314,
-0.0250115301,
0.0006399311,
0.0144192241,
-0.0538186915,
-0.0107702287,
0.0545334555,
-0.0269322172,
0.0311240498,
0.0000020383,
-0.0333748013,
-0.026585618,
0.0466397181,
0.035722129,
0.0327407122,
0.0904936343,
0.0347021855,
-0.00942975,
0.0160253104,
-0.0092614088,
0.0136865051,
0.0538234226,
0.0108714318,
0.0469258167,
0.0515450127,
-0.0124971624,
-0.0064562759,
-0.0235212911,
-0.0150123667,
-0.0051630614,
-0.0089431275,
-0.0152122881,
0.0462249406,
0.0461619869,
-0.0196175501,
0.0115295993,
0.0399018563,
0.0007929337,
-0.0220627151,
0.0300355908,
0.03813776,
0.0171951335,
-0.0288952757,
-0.0229249243,
0.0186625849,
-0.0090172859,
-0.0103879813,
0.0323013999,
-0.0310778208,
-0.0361652486,
-0.0346338972,
-0.0348822214,
0.0089424653,
-0.0241432581,
-0.0077264323,
-0.0659726933,
0.0172481537,
-0.0096642496,
-0.0207105819,
-0.0245148856,
0.0226811059,
0.0129584027,
-0.042468518,
-0.0332776643,
0.0494718477,
0.0296003055,
-0.0854533538,
0.019709792,
0.0200119633,
0.0184665676,
0.013874962,
-0.0478888974,
-0.0848511755,
0.0486906655,
-0.0424586236,
0.0634208322,
-0.0075148353,
0.0095293866,
-0.0406010151,
-0.0542215072,
0.1017957255,
-0.0061010388,
0.0194726866,
-0.007197578,
0.0669569969,
-0.0360670276,
-0.031382855,
-0.0228405669,
0.0362976156,
0.007532883,
-0.0190145075,
-0.0759626627,
0.0260941014,
-0.0111312903,
0.0271447841,
0.0318798982,
-0.0147049977,
-0.040477287,
0.0203964617,
-0.0012621704,
-0.0441577099,
-0.0096364506,
-0.0252244454,
0.0343249105,
-0.0360381342,
-0.0055458019,
0.033677984,
0.002403863,
0.0016944482,
-0.0352119356,
0.0625127852,
-0.053574454,
-0.0103849499,
0.0326777659,
-0.0481594801,
-0.0372982882,
-0.0247406494,
-0.032908503,
-0.0537894852,
-0.0043744892,
0.0078696972,
-0.0054374365,
-0.0491175242,
0.0250546988,
0.0064683175,
0.0215854645,
0.0280067977,
-0.0140187126,
-0.010485502,
-0.0071329144,
-0.0177685842,
0.0083960108,
0.0350889303,
0.0548301414,
0.080899857,
0.0174335148,
0.0176394749,
0.032606516,
0.0020135266,
0.0404871628,
0.0140220346,
-0.033885736,
-0.0360108614,
0.027625313,
0.0486521982,
0.0164871272,
0.0260951258,
-0.0374514684,
0.0569823273,
0.0348970704,
0.0018340447,
0.0569816492,
0.0066862209,
0.0797301531,
-0.0030757594,
0.0051829834,
0.0105843116,
0.0299266689,
0.0075469525,
0.0228945538,
0.0616024248,
0.0364813767,
0.0291390866,
0.0061237793,
-0.0495389402,
-0.0088775372,
-0.0041258717,
-0.0183457825,
-0.0499061793,
0.0567357689,
0.0481644273,
-0.0684783533,
-0.0284388717,
0.0062483121,
-0.0809387416,
0.0022169044,
-0.0445661768,
-0.0002592106,
0.0703725964,
0.0848764405,
-0.0040660226,
0.0093476325,
0.041285377,
-0.020107951,
0.0368469544,
0.0513918623,
0.0121570406,
-0.0386968777,
-0.0540349521,
-0.0251176096,
-0.0257276818,
-0.0088817738,
0.0550029427,
-0.0253711399,
0.0432999544,
0.0361279659,
0.0055509713,
-0.060849376,
0.0339965746,
0.0279786456,
0.0100893285,
0.0256147142,
-0.015354651,
-0.0020068153,
0.0247656014,
-0.0620407946,
0.0611994378,
-0.0042521986,
0.0042984667,
-0.0444765761,
0.0024812806,
-0.0017154432,
-0.0300143398,
0.0047967802,
-0.0290114861,
0.0222028103,
-0.0328766741,
0.0108293593,
-0.0513780229,
-0.0082387393,
-0.054129418,
0.0076236511,
-0.0175193176,
0.047596056,
0.0033897175,
-0.0324567966,
-0.0391990319,
0.0597575828,
0.0099451644,
0.0108655021,
-0.0175100174,
0.0485865958,
0.0289495755,
-0.028124718,
0.0029798825,
0.0392984897,
-0.0013257137,
0.0058914255,
0.0104219671,
0.0334238261,
0.0066295364,
-0.0685135424,
-0.035590224,
-0.0305110049,
0.0082940767,
0.0340633765,
0.020904718,
-0.0247492082,
0.0030914536,
0.0255649928,
-0.0475804545,
-0.0350878164,
0.0194426384,
-0.0267080236,
0.0505300164,
0.0079057068,
-0.0040078973,
-0.0234427918,
-0.027095221,
-0.0038327945,
0.0627584681,
0.0615280308,
-0.0150981043,
-0.0811376944,
0.070588544,
-0.0528273769,
-0.0263312571,
0.0291467942,
-0.0360055752,
0.0445721857,
-0.0009601071,
0.0462920293,
0.0328186154,
0.0365080126,
0.0449866503,
0.0228248518,
-0.0024241752,
-0.0516886711,
-0.0128209023,
-0.0246963426,
-0.0075731669,
0.047726512,
-0.063482739,
0.0626342893,
0.0295916032,
0.0405924208,
0.0325870402,
-0.0786601529,
0.0343948044,
-0.0360577032,
-0.0561328866,
-0.0204980467,
-0.0157858599,
-0.0182526018,
0.0479174592,
-0.0178447198,
-0.0538360551,
0.0336024091,
-0.0589960292,
-0.0066548302,
-0.0267184433,
0.0312863328,
0.0109247118,
0.0267822295,
-0.0031764309,
0.0200402122,
0.0412398651,
-0.0125585366,
-0.008715855,
0.0185239315,
0.0352055207,
-0.030791603,
-0.0242366716,
-0.0254527945,
0.0136236604,
-0.0154631585,
-0.021156108,
-0.0143717341,
0.0110899741,
0.0171765834,
-0.0324557386,
0.0473528169,
-0.0497795083,
-0.0113491556,
0.0427759774,
0.0694192499,
0.0049595153,
-0.0403143167,
-0.0172092542,
-0.0043248502,
0.0056463052,
-0.0037292328,
-0.0498014912,
-0.0162861906,
-0.0542805791,
-0.0176241957,
0.0374848396,
0.0160536226,
0.0356267951,
-0.0162482783,
-0.0022591813,
-0.0098935245,
0.0095658833,
-0.0309734307,
0.019130284,
0.0484647714,
-0.0246664174,
-0.0255049542,
0.0546680503,
0.0311049819,
0.0022739866,
0.0026482912,
0.028014211,
0.0614380166,
-0.0015321136,
0.0215410888,
-0.0575125031,
0.0360830501,
-0.0009213061,
0.1005916223,
-0.0686967373,
0.0033354759,
-0.0225741975,
-0.0786553919,
0.049658522,
0.0151228337,
-0.041092366,
-0.01796191,
-0.0025845459,
-0.0125288656,
0.0272931829,
-0.054735709,
0.0459280759,
0.0098947333,
0.0286248736,
0.0496651568,
-0.032712914,
-0.0386962406,
-0.042627003,
0.0310149193,
0.0293965526,
0.0737561136,
0.0304184798,
0.0292170029,
-0.0315427892,
-0.0224582329,
-0.0015739633,
0.0680223331,
-0.0382157415,
0.0305331573,
0.0307397451,
-0.0403529853,
-0.0174110904,
-0.0041737622,
0.0392712541,
-0.0001743004,
-0.0141411442,
-0.000271521,
-0.0341739357,
-0.0211401843,
-0.0032547342,
0.0004317795,
0.0255595651,
0.0014131649,
0.0437397808,
-0.0359247811,
-0.0917498395,
-0.0243530273,
0.0103201559,
-0.1216443777,
-0.0133295534,
-0.0341571793,
-0.0568148829,
-0.0647779033,
-0.093188934,
-0.0186629891,
0.0099258553,
0.0960906744,
-0.0187499318,
-0.0270806588,
-0.0055358186,
-0.0077571352,
-0.0793010071,
-0.0334720388,
-0.0000993006,
0.0341401435,
-0.053723786,
-0.0240833852,
-0.0129779344,
-0.0153303938,
-0.0147605073,
0.0728723407,
-0.0255327616,
-0.0562989488,
-0.021175582,
0.0622897893,
0.0268436372,
-0.0278653875,
-0.0293933414,
-0.029486334,
0.0537072569,
0.0228272732,
0.0135580469,
0.0347969793,
0.0246362668,
-0.0062381825,
-0.0136164231,
-0.0266429223,
-0.0244958103,
0.0029395598,
0.0186313577,
0.023982225,
0.0136604635,
-0.0120892059,
-0.016694624,
0.04739419,
-0.0322645903,
-0.0617844872,
0.0304946508,
0.0004674073,
-0.0284912772,
-0.0635306761,
-0.010340685,
-0.0709335133,
0.0263890121,
-0.0253104065,
0.008023574,
-0.0029045423,
0.0031931859,
-0.0538682267,
0.0313559063,
-0.0174136534,
0.037560638,
-0.0361402072,
0.0879205391,
0.0386815555,
-0.002400199,
-0.0191542655,
-0.0071966988,
-0.0070675239,
0.007806153,
0.0063670962,
0.0156937763,
0.0530721322,
0.0196691155,
-0.0100267977,
0.0698175356,
-0.018361479,
0.0258281752,
-0.0708389655,
0.000262712,
0.0132347569,
0.1021927446,
0.0905794725,
-0.0437162668,
0.020423064,
0.0015559701,
0.0513323173,
0.0249924157,
-0.0141808735,
-0.0499987118,
-0.0227979962,
-0.0067289113,
-0.0704548061,
0.0914402306,
-0.0378644466,
-0.0192078501,
-0.0740396902,
-0.0349924378,
-0.0536097065,
-0.0225034133,
0.003266718,
-0.0365049839,
0.0233134683,
-0.0658377185,
-0.0618723407,
-0.0330588296,
0.0530737452,
0.0509880856,
0.035986498,
-0.007968463,
0.0515456907,
0.0190153085,
-0.0019745396,
0.0252415594,
-0.0117151858,
-0.0129687423,
-0.0107129989,
-0.0121372016,
-0.0102813412,
-5.72726929e-33,
-0.0414626412,
-0.037131872,
-0.0255167615,
-0.0357707366,
-0.0689249113,
0.0010560633,
-0.0496912487,
0.0252985377,
0.0822214186,
-0.0076859253,
0.0142441187,
-0.0329836421,
0.0155078471,
-0.0303770322,
0.0086558163,
0.0301165432,
0.033700265,
-0.0312319677,
-0.0849213004,
0.0553991385,
0.0389146768,
0.0215341765,
0.0061868089,
-0.0670254827,
0.0513513088,
0.0218105782,
-0.0442317314,
-0.0439693518,
0.0097253136,
0.0201405529,
0.0101284934,
0.0009067394,
0.0088240849,
-0.0477700718,
-0.0566088334,
0.0175664648,
-0.0058041019,
-0.0405150056,
-0.019878583,
-0.0090557886,
-0.0192747042,
-0.0252609514,
0.0311181918,
-0.0103172911,
-0.0590588264,
0.0179587379,
0.0131227244,
-0.0042475872,
-0.0232330896,
-0.0678502917,
-0.0315955803,
0.0413969941,
-0.0011672842,
0.0006184076,
0.0075562717,
0.0389257558,
-0.0220566168,
-0.0063980431,
0.0108071947,
0.0329113789,
0.0719154179,
0.0044289827,
0.0558684245,
0.0454921834,
0.0478300154,
0.0209429599,
0.0378136598,
0.043643564,
-0.0704909042,
0.0072194077,
0.0213322025,
0.0390800536,
0.0695939511,
0.0452505089,
-0.036018014,
-0.0133130653,
-0.0263750385,
0.0542022176,
-0.0445625074,
-0.0168810319,
0.0381374583,
0.0030235823,
-0.0515021682,
-0.0078112748,
-0.0259965137,
-0.0100552216,
-0.0268325228,
-0.0474409498,
0.032794714,
0.0140872803,
-0.0484871306,
0.0006879838,
-0.0032587498,
0.0227115769,
0.0007939698,
-0.0489507094,
-0.0398649722,
0.0645158961,
-0.0250714868,
-0.0358652622,
0.0037891204,
-0.0222046003,
0.0428733528,
0.090066731,
0.035995923,
-0.0107022505,
-0.0173689798,
0.0161664486,
-0.0549988672,
0.0217845421,
-0.0097274883,
0.0212554447,
0.0384794809,
-0.0415898263,
-0.0207163729,
-0.0456848443,
-0.014579121,
0.0361845046,
0.010164015,
-0.0212261193,
-0.028066963,
-0.0100534325,
0.0224288069,
0.0343356244,
-0.0324907824,
0.0161596648,
-0.0288646631,
0.0245114528,
0.069460392,
-0.0239660945,
-0.033775568,
0.0099087851,
2.689e-7,
0.0401018858,
0.0309624542,
0.0658091381,
0.0134131843,
0.0038111054,
0.0071848365,
0.00420267,
0.0341141112,
-0.0090949694,
0.023293566,
0.0246477742,
-0.0147787016,
0.0641437694,
0.0000262702,
0.0141371014,
0.0186567511,
-0.0586995296,
0.0183075424,
-0.0559639297,
0.000358032,
0.0814492777,
-0.0395678394,
-0.0170094669,
0.0242120661,
0.025213493,
0.0083357552,
0.0320874862,
0.0294008777,
0.0281238519,
0.0077177049,
0.057208091,
-0.0406735018,
-0.0093793739,
0.0104984352,
-0.0262939855,
-0.0551104471,
0.0639905408,
0.0238593351,
0.0115198186,
0.0087058526,
0.0476404689,
-0.0285643991,
-0.0007246897,
-0.0591816902,
0.013411006,
-0.0201607551,
0.0006702625,
-0.008616874,
-0.0046867682,
0.0115940422,
0.0085128304,
-0.0150525803,
-0.0013471522,
0.0358440578,
0.0035485129,
0.035886474,
0.0293244924,
-0.007802363,
-0.0435679071,
-0.0172534566,
-0.0459327251,
-0.0582317337,
-0.0630234405,
0.0481741093,
-0.0021472727,
-0.0326239988,
-0.024274474,
2.471317997e-34,
0.0129384501,
-0.0551987402,
-0.0113984086,
-0.0333967321,
0.0102646518,
0.011215372,
0.0441482775,
0.0112804612,
0.0247891638,
-0.0242489669,
-0.0333100371
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07863v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07863v2
|
RLHF Workflow: From Reward Modeling to Online RLHF
| 2024-05-13T15:50:39 | 2024-06-12T04:40:53 |
Hanze Dong, Wei Xiong, Bo Pang, Haoxiang Wang, Han Zhao, Yingbo Zhou, Nan Jiang, Doyen Sahoo, Caiming Xiong, Tong Zhang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
We present the workflow of Online Iterative Reinforcement Learning from Human
Feedback (RLHF) in this technical report, which is widely reported to
outperform its offline counterpart by a large margin in the recent large
language model (LLM) literature. However, existing open-source RLHF projects
are still largely confined to the offline learning setting. In this technical
report, we aim to fill in this gap and provide a detailed recipe that is easy
to reproduce for online iterative RLHF. In particular, since online human
feedback is usually infeasible for open-source communities with limited
resources, we start by constructing preference models using a diverse set of
open-source datasets and use the constructed proxy preference model to
approximate human feedback. Then, we discuss the theoretical insights and
algorithmic principles behind online iterative RLHF, followed by a detailed
practical implementation. Our trained LLM, LLaMA-3-8B-SFR-Iterative-DPO-R,
achieves impressive performance on LLM chatbot benchmarks, including
AlpacaEval-2, Arena-Hard, and MT-Bench, as well as other academic benchmarks
such as HumanEval and TruthfulQA. We have shown that supervised fine-tuning
(SFT) and iterative RLHF can obtain state-of-the-art performance with fully
open-source datasets. Further, we have made our models, curated datasets, and
comprehensive step-by-step code guidebooks publicly available. Please refer to
https://github.com/RLHFlow/RLHF-Reward-Modeling and
https://github.com/RLHFlow/Online-RLHF for more detailed information.
|
RLHF Workflow: From Reward Modeling to Online RLHF: We present the workflow of Online Iterative Reinforcement Learning from Human
Feedback (RLHF) in this technical report, which is widely reported to
outperform its offline counterpart by a large margin in the recent large
language model (LLM) literature. However, existing open-source RLHF projects
are still largely confined to the offline learning setting. In this technical
report, we aim to fill in this gap and provide a detailed recipe that is easy
to reproduce for online iterative RLHF. In particular, since online human
feedback is usually infeasible for open-source communities with limited
resources, we start by constructing preference models using a diverse set of
open-source datasets and use the constructed proxy preference model to
approximate human feedback. Then, we discuss the theoretical insights and
algorithmic principles behind online iterative RLHF, followed by a detailed
practical implementation. Our trained LLM, LLaMA-3-8B-SFR-Iterative-DPO-R,
achieves impressive performance on LLM chatbot benchmarks, including
AlpacaEval-2, Arena-Hard, and MT-Bench, as well as other academic benchmarks
such as HumanEval and TruthfulQA. We have shown that supervised fine-tuning
(SFT) and iterative RLHF can obtain state-of-the-art performance with fully
open-source datasets. Further, we have made our models, curated datasets, and
comprehensive step-by-step code guidebooks publicly available. Please refer to
https://github.com/RLHFlow/RLHF-Reward-Modeling and
https://github.com/RLHFlow/Online-RLHF for more detailed information.
|
[
0.0844402835,
0.0650064051,
-0.000080462,
-0.00871119,
-0.0349726528,
0.0338312238,
-0.0102763046,
0.0180709977,
0.0147192013,
-0.0325959064,
-0.0744785666,
-0.0259001404,
-0.0087322351,
0.0223325677,
-0.0007495195,
-0.0603921041,
0.0197342094,
-0.0533927269,
0.0018833121,
-0.0143364333,
0.0276354533,
0.0206144806,
-0.0288727656,
0.0605530329,
0.0144853201,
-0.0080451751,
-0.0171572976,
0.0083311703,
0.0136235263,
-0.0205549411,
0.0180704463,
0.0588798821,
0.0326096565,
0.0419363044,
0.000002055,
-0.0395553857,
-0.0354821756,
-0.0174219199,
-0.0120320637,
-0.0338861309,
0.0582393222,
0.0239761323,
-0.0392389707,
0.0296083279,
-0.0095048686,
-0.0100639891,
0.0395040251,
0.0324806832,
0.0455492735,
0.0794581845,
0.0233588889,
0.0069149062,
0.0112133175,
-0.0354253091,
0.0141211208,
-0.0272944495,
0.024366118,
0.00426334,
0.0084831966,
0.0008106084,
-0.0287949294,
-0.0039454736,
0.0372513346,
-0.019235339,
0.0292645656,
0.0189675391,
-0.037306454,
-0.0471300334,
-0.0177371837,
0.1178719327,
-0.0114059271,
0.0000367631,
0.0293527208,
0.0109098954,
-0.0152447959,
-0.0123129757,
-0.0336582065,
0.0513170399,
0.0024304299,
0.017030308,
-0.018701965,
-0.0410326272,
-0.0037710126,
0.0375623628,
0.0050260513,
0.0496455133,
-0.0126971155,
-0.0276736002,
0.0143343182,
-0.0051711928,
-0.0342545137,
-0.053714972,
0.0098705515,
0.028794378,
-0.0898465663,
-0.0085626785,
-0.0239362679,
-0.0058411323,
0.0086914059,
-0.0299427677,
0.051938124,
0.0296051241,
0.014175023,
0.0501984879,
0.002691583,
0.055265218,
-0.0035454489,
0.0438271128,
-0.0179343186,
0.0229871031,
-0.0377737843,
0.0161994472,
-0.0206316151,
0.0511280335,
-0.0075924536,
-0.0292512663,
-0.0461918563,
0.0173167549,
-0.0225921068,
0.0475668199,
0.0119904028,
-0.0052752043,
-0.076209873,
0.0033258705,
-0.049424205,
0.0344550535,
-0.0309537314,
0.0019719449,
0.020192584,
-0.0560233779,
0.0168305151,
0.021527933,
-0.0031437648,
-0.0216236189,
0.0207096804,
0.0927252099,
0.0066640032,
-0.0233897213,
0.0361883752,
-0.0133956233,
0.0096956613,
-0.081100136,
-0.0017088354,
-0.0572837628,
0.0306743998,
-0.0469647124,
0.0075065866,
0.0101090893,
0.0018009706,
0.0243909918,
-0.015897179,
0.0550063401,
0.0017011861,
0.0171289369,
0.010697308,
-0.0183569081,
-0.0175037496,
0.0495775677,
0.0242100637,
0.0471246205,
0.0263129082,
-0.00026677,
0.0131511707,
0.0303293485,
0.0186581705,
0.0208033472,
-0.041999273,
0.0146248471,
0.0199285392,
0.071782805,
0.0417580903,
0.0389537923,
-0.0734614059,
0.0309312139,
0.0801496804,
0.0388719328,
0.0064630858,
-0.0101704253,
0.0110073285,
0.06548886,
0.0102051757,
-0.0161604173,
-0.051288154,
0.0428088941,
-0.0189623069,
-0.0120050311,
0.0206823871,
0.0065729031,
-0.0352715813,
-0.0460556224,
0.0241689719,
-0.0147272311,
0.0223994199,
0.027307,
0.0750398859,
0.0188336112,
-0.0445919894,
-0.035460934,
0.0685316697,
-0.014661395,
-0.003482677,
-0.0773452744,
0.0707757026,
0.0922782645,
0.0759676844,
-0.0276590046,
0.0041622589,
-0.0626750365,
-0.0081173657,
0.069901742,
0.0137515059,
-0.0336663127,
-0.0314474478,
-0.0419686399,
-0.0296543073,
0.0272915307,
-0.0154645704,
0.0228870027,
0.0505494401,
-0.0142764663,
-0.0331660807,
0.0348265022,
-0.0465570949,
0.0107649593,
0.0140692061,
0.004865855,
0.0142957121,
0.0104871653,
0.0596266165,
-0.0182438549,
0.0009431867,
-0.0101428255,
-0.0006250392,
0.0001383697,
-0.0432283208,
-0.0191639066,
-0.0303883161,
-0.0174870398,
0.0441642962,
-0.0079316637,
-0.001805546,
0.0678908825,
-0.0432910062,
0.0124054225,
-0.0010171869,
0.0058356188,
0.0343102179,
-0.0104993526,
0.0119361877,
-0.027698677,
-0.0141250687,
-0.0515836626,
0.0121321194,
0.0019738316,
0.0085646305,
-0.0173480771,
0.0063617923,
-0.0547552221,
-0.0593224429,
-0.0121284025,
0.0412502736,
-0.0190467313,
0.0289926771,
0.0237479303,
0.0531376526,
-0.0433072522,
-0.0372661725,
-0.042217683,
-0.0196284391,
-0.0240758061,
-0.0132708438,
0.0256651323,
-0.0201653168,
-0.0034511141,
-0.0460667163,
-0.0004701161,
-0.0004971656,
0.0177007355,
0.0391877331,
0.0231537391,
0.0077112643,
-0.0174903609,
-0.0538598672,
-0.0265752021,
0.0358220451,
-0.0076170634,
-0.0131248264,
0.0100656338,
-0.0370945334,
0.0054442897,
-0.0366860144,
0.0168713517,
-0.0256773867,
-0.0595303625,
0.0225244462,
-0.0464901812,
0.0179606751,
0.0975009575,
0.029675357,
0.0333672538,
0.0243997183,
0.0116202673,
-0.0889515504,
0.0119478256,
-0.0316643044,
-0.0726057813,
-0.0463838093,
0.0247280858,
-0.0089818239,
0.0616391152,
-0.0254468638,
0.0407600291,
-0.0668343082,
-0.0030896186,
-0.0125084082,
-0.041300904,
-0.0494978428,
0.0155604612,
-0.0276731588,
0.0065876972,
-0.0140599879,
-0.0802692771,
0.1050132439,
0.0151313897,
0.0016490276,
-0.059161678,
-0.0247353036,
-0.0190447606,
0.0140151819,
0.0059365183,
0.0327346176,
-0.0092023229,
-0.0224485062,
-0.0432382114,
-0.0422946848,
0.0304890908,
-0.0576311313,
0.0004116617,
-0.0130659435,
-0.0066272658,
0.0009835291,
-0.0598243847,
-0.0273366943,
-0.0324226171,
-0.0441195481,
-0.0264772605,
-0.0109208841,
-0.0389678143,
-0.0052513974,
0.0111063449,
0.0309449974,
0.0298459679,
-0.0180910602,
-0.0155521249,
-0.0245363005,
-0.0056057791,
0.0846682712,
0.0395575389,
0.0031417517,
-0.0242222436,
0.0216390733,
0.0423101299,
0.0670927987,
-0.0015111689,
0.0216338001,
0.0095972493,
0.0359079577,
-0.0338903815,
0.007927008,
0.0337441787,
0.0223148298,
-0.0466818325,
-0.0169513542,
0.1002376452,
0.0073130801,
-0.087572135,
0.0100510018,
-0.0207656268,
0.0773252696,
0.0076495297,
0.0452892594,
-0.0830748752,
-0.0264206454,
0.0281892586,
0.0482072346,
-0.0103585208,
-0.0307770967,
0.0215680562,
-0.1234016344,
0.0292746816,
-0.0046381643,
-0.0616555326,
-0.0271149073,
-0.0441285707,
-0.0014041193,
-0.0452338755,
0.0310667511,
0.0414625108,
-0.0064433175,
-0.0003658463,
0.0043889447,
0.0054351324,
-0.0251725465,
0.042056933,
-0.0427640937,
0.0701748058,
0.1149893403,
0.0263102576,
0.014135397,
-0.0022726853,
0.0246161949,
0.0341951624,
-0.0131731723,
-0.0382994451,
0.0325798877,
-0.0389904082,
-0.0228156261,
-0.0555988252,
0.063581422,
-0.0101373093,
0.00566637,
-0.0114119723,
0.0430582352,
-0.0000500692,
0.013879844,
0.0217729565,
0.0120674502,
0.0460859239,
0.0509285107,
-0.0063440329,
-0.0945490524,
-0.0334896073,
-0.0163063221,
-0.0239070747,
0.0021128142,
-0.0352523029,
-0.0301321261,
0.0032903221,
0.025228912,
-0.060365852,
-0.0299209245,
0.0032611557,
0.0380807482,
-0.0140278228,
-0.0239634346,
0.0276970547,
0.0317946523,
0.0118463971,
0.039334923,
-0.069090642,
0.023277482,
-0.0880646184,
-0.0262560397,
0.0368213616,
-0.0525483266,
-0.008452706,
0.008440963,
-0.0547258742,
-0.0370772518,
0.0008423375,
0.0562969223,
0.0195087362,
0.0689738989,
-0.0316123478,
-0.0584135391,
0.0237878077,
0.0013501768,
-0.0436172076,
0.0099817012,
0.0361496061,
0.0560351759,
0.0004917809,
0.0451016575,
-0.054735437,
0.0027556759,
0.0269106105,
0.0368372016,
0.0076592816,
-0.0211061575,
0.0176030342,
0.0108131431,
0.0231226217,
0.0138552831,
-0.0378323607,
-0.0300068352,
0.0375773497,
0.0099837715,
-0.0303805135,
-0.0458520092,
0.0137744071,
0.0310651138,
-0.0258243214,
-0.0063093756,
0.0022026324,
0.0184603725,
0.0263785459,
-0.0110319573,
0.00439084,
0.0087536993,
-0.0031266341,
0.0418466888,
0.0260728244,
0.007974308,
0.0314538889,
0.0087589249,
0.040612556,
0.0058182874,
0.0705374405,
0.031781964,
-0.0324584469,
0.006444219,
0.0109525723,
-0.0304673966,
-0.0648084581,
-0.0269572753,
0.0329493061,
0.0481943525,
0.0461114757,
0.0511087514,
-0.0042966921,
-0.0114798471,
-0.0216545723,
0.0184481274,
-0.0463034287,
-0.0268681366,
0.0068526389,
0.0318590589,
-0.0199688543,
0.0290224124,
0.0552011169,
0.0059069195,
0.0338291377,
-0.0043980177,
0.011090165,
-0.0203512963,
-0.0145359626,
-0.0084197968,
0.0151062477,
-0.0347518772,
-0.0158801042,
-0.0078245169,
-0.0380771831,
-0.0294108037,
0.0176696125,
-0.0385018177,
-0.0048244372,
0.0367679745,
0.0267232265,
-0.0270336065,
-0.0062972046,
-0.0818236172,
-0.0092269368,
0.0011578553,
-0.0234426502,
0.0016017677,
-6.381917522e-33,
-0.0361694284,
-0.0208155829,
0.0015504725,
-0.0137454784,
-0.0484311692,
-0.0198712181,
-0.0107450066,
-0.0151587958,
-0.0065418044,
-0.0116863959,
-0.0225000158,
0.0098072635,
0.0222117547,
0.0206680242,
0.0065192683,
-0.0307170171,
0.0494303666,
-0.0284597166,
-0.0554880053,
0.0465955399,
0.0113297682,
0.0177598223,
0.032528419,
-0.0174938049,
-0.0063545224,
-0.0003415688,
-0.0397991873,
0.0480780825,
-0.0525651425,
0.0786908194,
-0.0121075502,
0.0057800203,
-0.0101538571,
-0.0433716811,
-0.0193397626,
0.0212678909,
-0.0968512818,
0.0075571174,
-0.0378352068,
0.0241167825,
-0.0317088999,
-0.0010514092,
0.0472015329,
-0.0145857446,
-0.0061364677,
0.0095541291,
0.0022074785,
-0.0104864771,
-0.0377483554,
0.0112661757,
-0.0384016931,
0.0081459247,
-0.0020773821,
-0.0280884318,
0.0040272092,
0.049371507,
-0.0191557091,
0.0516550839,
-0.0680852458,
0.057232365,
-0.00990438,
0.0040378966,
0.0460248105,
0.021118924,
0.0602724701,
0.0444993787,
-0.0023105103,
0.0146921081,
0.0187406261,
-0.0154252481,
0.0258164853,
0.0269275326,
0.0090253912,
0.0350162722,
0.0151902596,
-0.0025636181,
-0.0454769209,
-0.0114178099,
0.0351858884,
0.0652793869,
0.0376341306,
0.0330626331,
-0.054479491,
-0.0004862675,
-0.0381539874,
-0.0222966205,
-0.0270400476,
-0.0715655684,
0.0362396911,
0.0571745373,
-0.0323419832,
-0.0542630292,
0.0295853,
-0.0338278525,
-0.0311669391,
0.0334741399,
-0.0314779356,
0.0362743028,
-0.0147651089,
-0.0090917954,
-0.0987321138,
-0.0452336073,
-0.0016612528,
-0.0459985919,
-0.0243329573,
0.0082590105,
0.0204563048,
0.045597095,
-0.0575240478,
0.0227817185,
-0.0070644501,
0.0299000256,
0.0121253319,
0.0486550219,
0.0410184674,
-0.0385666974,
-0.0077797631,
0.0841659158,
-0.0153002571,
-0.0264215488,
-0.0317652076,
-0.0005934694,
-0.0153102214,
-0.0148004815,
-0.0126041295,
0.003696671,
-0.0582350865,
0.0105391629,
0.0037525278,
-0.0362385325,
-0.0115241911,
-0.0226156581,
2.807e-7,
-0.0459945835,
0.0560049154,
0.0139075899,
0.0065825512,
0.0261226036,
0.0397001915,
-0.009768228,
0.0181420986,
0.0067604021,
0.0114802253,
0.0204500705,
0.0533744432,
0.0624975488,
-0.014583732,
-0.0736943334,
-0.0305617694,
-0.0977996513,
0.0014450029,
-0.0443892069,
-0.0468163639,
-0.0158862453,
0.1020100415,
0.0425949804,
-0.0178776719,
0.036843691,
0.0233103242,
0.0415111445,
-0.0289626587,
-0.047171738,
0.0319748037,
-0.0181888044,
0.0231160484,
-0.0166174565,
-0.0226589348,
0.0204332583,
-0.0030066452,
-0.0013665354,
0.0956775397,
0.0197779704,
-0.0461239256,
-0.0087188855,
0.0096539501,
0.0122728441,
-0.0485509373,
0.0626289397,
-0.0612313971,
-0.0285693165,
-0.0387670994,
0.0124946041,
-0.0611100793,
0.0364124812,
-0.0581181422,
-0.0175635181,
0.0195910893,
0.0142712602,
0.0214432813,
-0.0262767896,
-0.0576083288,
0.0151249738,
0.0097533055,
-0.038164895,
-0.0676831603,
-0.0490631647,
0.0142524512,
-0.0153799728,
-0.0323220082,
0.0133295013,
2.406703231e-34,
0.0287761874,
0.0073347199,
0.0083589787,
0.0265486464,
0.0209705513,
0.0304101463,
0.0211687479,
-0.0011086416,
0.0542279743,
-0.0796059296,
-0.0068305051
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07840v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07840v1
|
Open-vocabulary Auditory Neural Decoding Using fMRI-prompted LLM
| 2024-05-13T15:25:11 | 2024-05-13T15:25:11 |
Xiaoyu Chen, Changde Du, Che Liu, Yizhe Wang, Huiguang He
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL
|
Decoding language information from brain signals represents a vital research
area within brain-computer interfaces, particularly in the context of
deciphering the semantic information from the fMRI signal. However, many
existing efforts concentrate on decoding small vocabulary sets, leaving space
for the exploration of open vocabulary continuous text decoding. In this paper,
we introduce a novel method, the \textbf{Brain Prompt GPT (BP-GPT)}. By using
the brain representation that is extracted from the fMRI as a prompt, our
method can utilize GPT-2 to decode fMRI signals into stimulus text. Further, we
introduce a text-to-text baseline and align the fMRI prompt to the text prompt.
By introducing the text-to-text baseline, our BP-GPT can extract a more robust
brain prompt and promote the decoding of pre-trained LLM. We evaluate our
BP-GPT on the open-source auditory semantic decoding dataset and achieve a
significant improvement up to $4.61\%$ on METEOR and $2.43\%$ on BERTScore
across all the subjects compared to the state-of-the-art method. The
experimental results demonstrate that using brain representation as a prompt to
further drive LLM for auditory neural decoding is feasible and effective.
|
Open-vocabulary Auditory Neural Decoding Using fMRI-prompted LLM: Decoding language information from brain signals represents a vital research
area within brain-computer interfaces, particularly in the context of
deciphering the semantic information from the fMRI signal. However, many
existing efforts concentrate on decoding small vocabulary sets, leaving space
for the exploration of open vocabulary continuous text decoding. In this paper,
we introduce a novel method, the \textbf{Brain Prompt GPT (BP-GPT)}. By using
the brain representation that is extracted from the fMRI as a prompt, our
method can utilize GPT-2 to decode fMRI signals into stimulus text. Further, we
introduce a text-to-text baseline and align the fMRI prompt to the text prompt.
By introducing the text-to-text baseline, our BP-GPT can extract a more robust
brain prompt and promote the decoding of pre-trained LLM. We evaluate our
BP-GPT on the open-source auditory semantic decoding dataset and achieve a
significant improvement up to $4.61\%$ on METEOR and $2.43\%$ on BERTScore
across all the subjects compared to the state-of-the-art method. The
experimental results demonstrate that using brain representation as a prompt to
further drive LLM for auditory neural decoding is feasible and effective.
|
[
-0.045955386,
0.0488537475,
-0.0042806561,
0.036285039,
-0.0097495969,
0.0168184713,
0.0087556122,
0.0623817667,
0.0051626316,
0.0465182588,
-0.073479712,
-0.0077387635,
0.0734535828,
0.0676903799,
0.0038154037,
-0.003410565,
0.0047908528,
-0.0279531963,
0.0060049477,
-0.0040432345,
-0.0400247276,
0.0291778203,
-0.0725814179,
0.047248207,
0.0502070189,
-0.0065945652,
-0.002086072,
0.0043633226,
0.0306503568,
-0.0378917009,
-0.0527869985,
0.0293070972,
0.0222237315,
0.0123207923,
0.0000017263,
-0.0193407722,
0.0187450051,
0.0033094548,
-0.0360729098,
-0.0173073001,
0.0126659963,
0.0142090525,
-0.0096872635,
-0.0021649674,
-0.0056164488,
-0.0271791276,
0.0469970927,
0.0908870101,
0.0009775574,
0.0119661139,
-0.0174106546,
-0.0076250886,
0.0757050142,
-0.0165375713,
0.0292906389,
0.0107359635,
0.0043563708,
-0.0629715845,
-0.0184934326,
0.0270561632,
-0.0068429224,
0.0469539501,
0.0083010308,
0.0550201572,
-0.008684841,
0.0792711675,
0.0200216211,
-0.0241182987,
-0.0618150234,
0.057979051,
0.0759268776,
-0.001876205,
-0.0204790011,
-0.0028746051,
-0.0302286372,
-0.0134207625,
-0.017851796,
0.0661641136,
-0.0301745106,
0.0800798684,
0.0181185436,
-0.0244308934,
0.0286686048,
-0.0178943351,
-0.0139942868,
0.0716224313,
-0.0031928846,
-0.0440140404,
0.0910560861,
0.0054931995,
-0.0342671052,
-0.0053825611,
0.0595602579,
0.0064288704,
-0.0142424488,
-0.0090484545,
-0.0456046872,
-0.0555953719,
0.006418033,
0.0071775592,
-0.0000043916,
0.0540051162,
-0.0634364858,
0.0185605194,
-0.0218154807,
0.0003726541,
-0.0502542257,
0.0537456013,
-0.0079334509,
-0.0139541952,
-0.0186549667,
-0.0138373571,
0.00392173,
-0.0043080072,
-0.0343386047,
-0.0284203589,
-0.0017158698,
0.0111391125,
0.0171546414,
-0.0424341708,
0.0198674034,
0.0019350493,
-0.0310522374,
0.051777292,
-0.0128196524,
0.0147468848,
0.0366382003,
0.0230898652,
0.0231371485,
-0.0551411994,
-0.0519481115,
0.0400000326,
0.0102813356,
-0.0523430742,
-0.0182668027,
0.0399246365,
-0.0163975917,
-0.0217808876,
-0.0241216868,
0.0183660686,
-0.0003565557,
0.0457746014,
0.0106236581,
-0.0262239911,
0.0469878577,
0.0209608153,
-0.0062705851,
-0.0514076427,
-0.0092443889,
-0.0113231186,
-0.0384847559,
0.043310944,
-0.0941079929,
-0.027284991,
0.0825857669,
0.0471204259,
0.0015501975,
0.0136031182,
0.0256776419,
0.0174604561,
-0.0280381385,
0.0001620477,
-0.0471729301,
0.0525975525,
0.0230066478,
-0.0317206904,
-0.0184993763,
-0.0344827287,
0.0250199102,
0.0468300618,
0.0606264994,
0.0301729068,
-0.0250329897,
-0.007872832,
0.0340663865,
0.0709469318,
0.0046332274,
0.0024482147,
0.0011621414,
0.0038592608,
0.0034109445,
-0.0132941939,
-0.0106867095,
0.0270507764,
-0.018793216,
-0.0051369648,
0.0407804996,
-0.0361307301,
0.0063530523,
0.0227234364,
0.0236452315,
-0.0318013281,
-0.0115442509,
0.0319088623,
0.0550211854,
-0.027052734,
-0.0373213999,
0.0356766768,
0.0343435816,
-0.0065638712,
0.014647509,
-0.0393338501,
0.0540090688,
0.0268459767,
0.0250631776,
-0.0584647916,
0.0006925877,
0.0142075028,
-0.0170074981,
0.0661146343,
-0.0293169171,
0.0513799712,
0.0684806257,
-0.0484783724,
-0.0548261181,
0.0468642339,
-0.018116219,
0.018715281,
0.002700611,
0.0282266624,
-0.0337429643,
-0.008993567,
-0.0079990132,
0.0350993313,
-0.0119722765,
-0.0212210771,
0.0330562368,
-0.0135798203,
0.0430299714,
-0.016436452,
-0.0523815081,
-0.0056130691,
0.0323673636,
-0.0274615884,
0.0151093295,
-0.0367309749,
-0.0430963114,
-0.0137229413,
0.0057883607,
0.0143491812,
-0.0403665863,
0.0581697524,
-0.0007790831,
-0.0029621932,
-0.0203176141,
0.0033322845,
-0.0031306136,
-0.0570257492,
-0.0221559554,
0.007222069,
0.0222784132,
-0.0478403904,
-0.0182741918,
-0.0317781828,
-0.0090572452,
0.0237062126,
-0.0130900256,
0.0271211509,
-0.07649564,
-0.0165004749,
0.0908460468,
-0.0124248173,
-0.0267605372,
-0.0325395316,
0.0233839098,
-0.0460011885,
-0.0197596289,
-0.091311805,
-0.0112378718,
0.010743483,
0.0091239559,
0.0366326831,
-0.0044899555,
-0.0125429574,
0.0063256957,
-0.0177937075,
0.0362373665,
0.0169081688,
-0.0112107452,
-0.0246375781,
0.0086430209,
-0.0092240106,
0.0036902176,
-0.0011203224,
-0.0099406615,
0.0086311316,
-0.032998018,
-0.0337828323,
-0.0782032013,
0.0379647501,
-0.016819166,
-0.0097551178,
-0.0092760371,
0.0547631308,
0.0586867481,
-0.0566249266,
0.0451233983,
0.0292544011,
-0.0171273593,
0.0128549663,
0.0645307675,
-0.0071825166,
-0.0140663534,
-0.0311473235,
0.0245185141,
-0.0188452769,
-0.0178804398,
-0.0071888571,
0.0572990887,
0.0263995677,
0.0901841894,
0.0367720611,
-0.0263493117,
-0.0349342823,
-0.0394233689,
-0.0339996591,
-0.073621653,
0.0264005009,
-0.0330441333,
0.0685153231,
-0.0138916038,
-0.0450016595,
0.0677750409,
-0.058888644,
-0.0099990284,
0.0075335461,
-0.0403038561,
-0.0266629197,
0.0116197485,
-0.056398429,
-0.0017890283,
-0.036363408,
-0.0740165412,
0.0040941676,
0.0036949005,
-0.0506699234,
-0.0434079655,
0.0101105319,
-0.0261331126,
-0.0053469008,
-0.0245120712,
0.0082033649,
-0.030987272,
-0.0209718961,
0.01620185,
0.0107697761,
-0.0054323347,
0.029281009,
-0.0346176811,
-0.0373411812,
0.0218993984,
0.0496373028,
-0.0381023213,
-0.021707071,
-0.0235178061,
0.0741696507,
-0.0107640503,
0.0288598482,
-0.0066195405,
-0.043046359,
-0.0185672361,
0.0330496058,
-0.0060642883,
0.0210741684,
-0.0569333993,
0.0300678518,
0.0309697948,
0.0095477598,
0.0330046192,
0.0374970324,
-0.0091276634,
0.0063478611,
-0.0062417737,
0.1219223142,
0.0367116146,
-0.0890390128,
-0.050617896,
-0.0279306322,
0.0654937997,
-0.0265807193,
-0.0210066214,
-0.0625132918,
-0.007784205,
-0.0019875653,
0.0663947985,
0.0442914665,
0.004365237,
-0.0163497161,
-0.0135085164,
0.0495363958,
0.0111306785,
-0.0414225794,
-0.0168537535,
-0.026567217,
0.0137286736,
0.0230436921,
0.0411601588,
0.0101427669,
0.0156254899,
0.0210810043,
0.0100441072,
0.0367868282,
-0.0332156606,
-0.0132568795,
-0.0162680205,
0.0826219097,
0.0624425933,
-0.0033789603,
-0.0396442935,
-0.0313426107,
0.0013483227,
-0.0125966519,
-0.0189175904,
-0.0580078848,
0.0282928664,
0.0131325535,
0.0097054439,
-0.0081613651,
0.0185107458,
-0.032110922,
-0.0507658869,
0.0237210374,
0.0930588394,
-0.06542743,
0.0033122944,
0.0148724075,
0.0124166589,
0.0311108176,
0.0568263009,
0.0631191209,
-0.0403649919,
0.020114895,
-0.0038976073,
0.0163401533,
-0.021961296,
-0.0314430855,
0.0073585068,
-0.017734006,
-0.0196539722,
-0.0010284991,
0.0071026152,
0.0671929643,
-0.0179751907,
0.0405832045,
0.001309454,
0.0161294192,
-0.0288365837,
-0.0496849678,
0.0269366298,
-0.0166160781,
0.0013451782,
-0.0809321851,
-0.0188220795,
0.0086164167,
-0.0648885146,
0.0077724825,
0.0738272741,
-0.0572847985,
-0.0293301195,
0.0305269454,
-0.0031359179,
0.0130163506,
0.0047593489,
0.0134545891,
-0.0325807631,
0.0679519325,
0.0329842679,
-0.0207627937,
0.0619840436,
-0.013988575,
0.0558748096,
-0.0068398518,
0.0008649647,
-0.0486356318,
0.0053557903,
0.0101314597,
0.0335308984,
0.044332508,
-0.0025935657,
0.0493820533,
0.0507729463,
0.1071576402,
-0.0279529542,
0.0006968655,
-0.0433822498,
-0.0097450204,
0.0461891778,
0.0696883574,
-0.0146707492,
0.0128967594,
0.0510034487,
-0.0304793753,
-0.0430133045,
-0.0246897377,
-0.0181126297,
0.0069970577,
-0.0199334826,
-0.0109534282,
-0.0629984662,
-0.0126672992,
-0.0012893681,
0.0245449319,
-0.044072669,
0.0091235135,
-0.0422964171,
-0.0001763438,
0.0146163106,
0.0659690276,
0.0049878969,
0.0103106033,
0.0049335216,
0.050269302,
-0.0022273138,
-0.0412565321,
0.058936879,
0.0297746621,
-0.0062754462,
0.0567750372,
0.0339471772,
0.0142090777,
0.0345002078,
-0.0362311676,
0.0224150866,
-0.037632037,
0.0067024198,
0.0705418885,
-0.0136395777,
0.03342719,
-0.0638519302,
0.0210392457,
-0.0307124015,
-0.058625482,
-0.0151170874,
0.0528553948,
-0.035512127,
-0.0422411673,
-0.0178377554,
0.0208853465,
-0.0578039363,
-0.0112007679,
0.0460616723,
-0.004922003,
0.0135703152,
0.0146289514,
0.0038500119,
-0.0406170599,
-0.0220817346,
-0.0106130261,
-0.0189594775,
-0.0140240025,
0.0515716933,
0.0006721618,
-0.0247801412,
-0.073556304,
-0.0407713093,
-5.56939048e-33,
-0.0762562752,
-0.0277966242,
0.002652036,
0.0541912504,
-0.0562440008,
-0.0188848171,
-0.0648808777,
0.0120790945,
0.0417707711,
-0.0518857613,
-0.02360758,
-0.0236497503,
0.0334639736,
0.0133385379,
-0.0100354524,
-0.0101735136,
-0.0240498912,
-0.0511630103,
-0.0186590329,
0.0124153066,
0.0510242023,
0.0398044959,
0.073661916,
-0.0593175068,
0.0106901322,
0.0259834509,
0.0256681703,
-0.0172552895,
-0.0231771097,
0.0141197285,
-0.0626492575,
0.0568463393,
0.0346250273,
-0.0070683812,
0.0056626792,
0.0174237657,
-0.078692086,
0.0060940804,
0.020749623,
-0.0052337684,
-0.0706644058,
-0.009682483,
0.0328402817,
-0.0168737751,
-0.0038564389,
-0.0158221852,
0.0289112777,
-0.0304008015,
-0.0162461698,
0.0011846912,
-0.0116206584,
-0.0345594548,
0.0097359167,
0.0246988107,
0.053711988,
0.0396812931,
-0.0503336154,
0.0510948822,
-0.0659645125,
0.0110531934,
0.0046865777,
-0.0085860798,
0.0121961003,
0.0217079576,
0.0004275622,
0.0340176374,
0.0524941199,
-0.065007776,
-0.0483865067,
0.0154261738,
0.0361066796,
0.0379012898,
-0.0082972609,
-0.01441273,
0.040485695,
-0.0157299079,
-0.0252779834,
0.029321,
-0.0075413547,
-0.0433967002,
0.0032988703,
0.0081795966,
0.0230725128,
-0.0155661078,
-0.0275966153,
-0.0000749848,
-0.0497338139,
0.002729754,
0.0652005374,
-0.0238149446,
0.006103341,
-0.0449664667,
0.0582807437,
0.0268179551,
0.0660588294,
-0.0160436183,
0.0089305704,
0.0161133576,
0.0080602309,
-0.0161812901,
-0.0384611897,
-0.0258952528,
0.0708249882,
-0.0339581072,
0.0620218031,
-0.0235131215,
-0.0584376864,
0.0123519162,
-0.0269551054,
-0.0070015648,
-0.0097217411,
-0.0034107661,
0.0328043364,
0.0107418131,
-0.0027921372,
-0.0455375537,
0.011453921,
-0.038071651,
-0.0365836173,
0.0068767779,
-0.0594167337,
-0.0276018176,
0.0146591598,
0.0306169055,
0.0079886029,
0.0447528288,
0.03454642,
-0.0348604284,
0.0220118426,
-0.0380750187,
-0.0265575368,
0.0399264656,
2.471e-7,
0.0264637303,
0.0007170808,
0.0411971547,
0.0551083945,
0.0072815516,
-0.0185775254,
-0.0503869839,
0.0325749665,
0.0250134058,
-0.0348048098,
-0.0123167159,
0.0548388958,
0.0437009856,
-0.0005115485,
-0.058997713,
-0.0036779977,
-0.0154195158,
0.0204948522,
-0.0750125423,
0.0078580184,
0.090287596,
-0.0085237967,
-0.0394468978,
-0.0423725657,
0.0492198355,
0.0454106666,
0.0578367598,
-0.0546954721,
0.0352395363,
-0.04261823,
0.0235536769,
-0.0566510148,
0.0027131764,
0.0162748862,
0.0431355648,
-0.0098599726,
0.0083577354,
0.0098404828,
0.0077732531,
-0.0747437552,
0.017884383,
0.005866393,
-0.010042036,
-0.0133498413,
0.0046253763,
-0.0250390079,
-0.0663291365,
0.0162703153,
-0.0168718323,
-0.0391329527,
0.0505092777,
-0.042884618,
0.0142384758,
-0.0477815196,
-0.0076158303,
0.0046437355,
-0.0102533856,
-0.0069930018,
0.0167096779,
0.0293211248,
-0.0806322098,
-0.0105627161,
-0.0142662069,
0.0223915111,
-0.0019598778,
-0.0701813772,
-0.0064285346,
1.529263967e-34,
-0.0325681381,
0.0017701081,
0.0507578813,
0.03104081,
-0.0163678974,
-0.0056674629,
0.0609612912,
-0.0016606093,
-0.0496620461,
-0.0931048393,
-0.0398251377
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07803v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07803v2
|
Decoding Geometric Properties in Non-Random Data from First Information-Theoretic Principles
| 2024-05-13T14:45:08 | 2024-05-18T01:24:24 |
Hector Zenil, Felipe S. Abrahão
|
cs.IT
|
cs.IT, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.IR, math.IT, math.ST, stat.TH
|
Based on the principles of information theory, measure theory, and
theoretical computer science, we introduce a univariate signal deconvolution
method with a wide range of applications to coding theory, particularly in
zero-knowledge one-way communication channels, such as in deciphering messages
from unknown generating sources about which no prior knowledge is available and
to which no return message can be sent. Our multidimensional space
reconstruction method from an arbitrary received signal is proven to be
agnostic vis-a-vis the encoding-decoding scheme, computation model, programming
language, formal theory, the computable (or semi-computable) method of
approximation to algorithmic complexity, and any arbitrarily chosen
(computable) probability measure of the events. The method derives from the
principles of an approach to Artificial General Intelligence capable of
building a general-purpose model of models independent of any arbitrarily
assumed prior probability distribution. We argue that this optimal and
universal method of decoding non-random data has applications to signal
processing, causal deconvolution, topological and geometric properties
encoding, cryptography, and bio- and technosignature detection.
|
Decoding Geometric Properties in Non-Random Data from First Information-Theoretic Principles: Based on the principles of information theory, measure theory, and
theoretical computer science, we introduce a univariate signal deconvolution
method with a wide range of applications to coding theory, particularly in
zero-knowledge one-way communication channels, such as in deciphering messages
from unknown generating sources about which no prior knowledge is available and
to which no return message can be sent. Our multidimensional space
reconstruction method from an arbitrary received signal is proven to be
agnostic vis-a-vis the encoding-decoding scheme, computation model, programming
language, formal theory, the computable (or semi-computable) method of
approximation to algorithmic complexity, and any arbitrarily chosen
(computable) probability measure of the events. The method derives from the
principles of an approach to Artificial General Intelligence capable of
building a general-purpose model of models independent of any arbitrarily
assumed prior probability distribution. We argue that this optimal and
universal method of decoding non-random data has applications to signal
processing, causal deconvolution, topological and geometric properties
encoding, cryptography, and bio- and technosignature detection.
|
[
-0.0676815435,
0.1160778329,
0.0088580912,
0.0157963261,
-0.0646819025,
0.0265989639,
-0.0380301625,
0.0368503556,
-0.0230103396,
0.026119601,
0.0636448413,
0.003286219,
-0.0071360609,
0.0022177293,
0.0347813852,
-0.0031925291,
-0.0509174094,
-0.0049607363,
0.0280552395,
-0.0542264208,
-0.1073843762,
-0.0464294255,
0.0039580478,
-0.0161577165,
-0.0083872769,
-0.0248794854,
-0.0452462994,
-0.0041884664,
-0.04299872,
-0.0015353584,
-0.0560047217,
-0.0019904503,
-0.0034364369,
0.0198701471,
0.0000020336,
0.0335194357,
-0.0571530908,
0.0169353727,
-0.0386751294,
-0.0238053072,
-0.0445409492,
-0.0486642793,
-0.0163696874,
-0.0331891291,
-0.0449116156,
-0.0127610965,
0.0452810414,
0.0261116773,
-0.0517229773,
0.0673369542,
-0.0112043079,
-0.0599262938,
0.0583347902,
-0.0257974137,
0.0326833613,
0.0296547525,
0.007943104,
-0.0190622658,
-0.0124903349,
0.0331830308,
-0.0320242085,
0.0414777733,
0.0141528817,
0.0447061323,
0.0548253953,
0.0306855794,
0.0344903171,
0.0119866841,
-0.0347634442,
0.0064531309,
-0.0367774554,
-0.0279560983,
0.0143889999,
0.0202356037,
-0.0142680798,
0.0303752664,
-0.0254730843,
0.0180330668,
-0.0080327541,
0.0494893417,
-0.0691036209,
-0.0067984811,
0.0223538298,
-0.023454722,
-0.0236021467,
0.0801604986,
0.0343162827,
0.0142237823,
-0.0625438169,
0.0189825892,
0.030830007,
-0.010658701,
-0.04989345,
-0.0133325076,
0.0404355898,
-0.0091744848,
-0.0226655472,
-0.0215618759,
-0.0102235796,
-0.0356726572,
0.059482187,
-0.0220750682,
0.0316565856,
0.037849579,
0.0218858998,
-0.0166234728,
-0.0623361059,
0.0824479908,
-0.0344727859,
0.0178404581,
0.0004490194,
-0.0263492689,
0.0278830994,
0.0618727431,
0.0163592864,
0.0118695889,
0.0233686585,
0.0449394211,
0.022796886,
-0.0307956282,
-0.0545979477,
0.0077905743,
-0.0209341999,
-0.0179181956,
0.0204731673,
-0.0396936424,
0.0390574373,
0.0185749698,
-0.0434261598,
-0.044051107,
-0.0485058688,
0.0443907529,
0.0326524936,
0.0343810245,
-0.0003286194,
0.035218399,
0.0091264704,
-0.011744054,
0.0073201274,
-0.009004849,
-0.0025146003,
-0.0097006857,
0.0573528893,
-0.0168066062,
0.0015707371,
-0.0139461365,
0.0028323573,
-0.0319375768,
-0.0125775579,
-0.0241386537,
-0.0498552918,
0.0762660652,
-0.0133500462,
0.0127221756,
0.029135352,
-0.0120948041,
0.0222221669,
0.018726334,
-0.0204379633,
0.003620761,
0.0032688321,
0.0295836162,
0.0717706904,
0.0119320983,
0.0517639369,
0.001831102,
-0.0092338724,
-0.0417925157,
-0.0113957711,
-0.0191916469,
-0.015477391,
0.0441433825,
-0.0182079878,
-0.0460195057,
-0.0189666711,
0.0687024668,
-0.0035757897,
0.0108882207,
0.0301818345,
0.060837362,
-0.0141760465,
0.0445745699,
-0.012264763,
0.0070550758,
-0.0416981727,
0.0015029159,
0.0387231,
-0.0520286337,
-0.0310339294,
-0.0248770863,
0.0289042275,
-0.0905020386,
0.0181203447,
-0.0480483361,
0.1407885551,
-0.0115771703,
-0.0030926636,
-0.0508795865,
0.0203712098,
-0.0082157487,
-0.0228326339,
0.0223581754,
0.0327218249,
-0.0598428026,
0.0481026992,
-0.0678422824,
0.0717202127,
0.0110964766,
-0.0028787644,
-0.0549670346,
-0.037389487,
0.0086837057,
0.0442327522,
0.0313536897,
-0.0308631063,
0.0552814007,
0.0471463241,
0.002475861,
-0.0288854297,
-0.0160255302,
-0.0435121544,
-0.0014932315,
0.0256549418,
-0.0194498207,
0.0261794291,
-0.0297547895,
0.0542410053,
0.0097890301,
0.0657670647,
0.0428752191,
-0.0189559292,
0.0362355411,
0.0381760783,
-0.058106482,
-0.0312202647,
-0.0283593796,
0.0252215024,
-0.0127610983,
0.0107126096,
-0.0931197405,
0.0219440628,
0.0324917249,
0.0167525709,
-0.0338416249,
0.0588911921,
-0.0112814354,
0.0153905703,
-0.0185296368,
-0.0246649403,
-0.003125184,
0.0116963638,
-0.0013422263,
0.0071119727,
-0.0059699677,
0.0241410118,
-0.0186260249,
-0.035220623,
0.0552193224,
-0.0420551077,
-0.0135731837,
-0.0073276227,
-0.0468910001,
-0.0103621306,
0.0272705909,
0.0197263751,
0.0840841234,
-0.00654101,
-0.0110853761,
-0.0822852477,
-0.0138651486,
0.0088875722,
-0.0098750442,
0.0045130947,
0.0103713321,
-0.0427336469,
0.0072326767,
-0.0068405862,
0.0236237831,
-0.0480787307,
0.0088219019,
-0.0144920629,
-0.0003361618,
0.0505460128,
-0.0248686802,
-0.0190882683,
0.057975173,
0.0177753959,
-0.0440520495,
-0.0037363225,
0.0025180825,
0.0218628328,
0.0369871967,
-0.0266864393,
-0.0189773627,
0.0115989512,
-0.0757973194,
-0.0340168327,
0.0450727344,
-0.0116367945,
0.015446147,
-0.0464995056,
0.0466848798,
0.0258440748,
-0.0210285727,
-0.0586297773,
-0.0118993036,
0.0042571095,
-0.0309455283,
0.0423434526,
0.0012712521,
0.027556289,
-0.046145916,
-0.018304076,
0.0070224209,
0.0265928023,
-0.0172483232,
-0.0450696796,
-0.0066785254,
0.0019156188,
0.0340114236,
-0.0176280476,
-0.0059763147,
-0.0062447265,
-0.0130466698,
0.0238407608,
0.0046746051,
0.0014990194,
0.0018426595,
-0.0103086699,
0.0333107039,
0.0341650546,
0.0214196984,
0.0018183464,
0.0297237877,
0.0126128877,
0.0057688863,
-0.0141420672,
-0.0675834268,
-0.0672695488,
0.0112698106,
0.0331001543,
-0.0331155248,
-0.0052589574,
-0.0098219067,
0.0705476105,
-0.052682735,
-0.0361036174,
-0.0125452215,
0.0322506763,
0.020786304,
0.0005901004,
-0.0147650419,
-0.0048371484,
-0.008205859,
-0.0078917369,
0.0511957258,
-0.0376864821,
-0.0035717455,
-0.0504562631,
-0.0221418925,
-0.0653393418,
0.0248784889,
-0.027426634,
0.0882676542,
0.0308293886,
0.0464050621,
0.0169135332,
0.0560910814,
-0.0299738608,
0.0332224704,
0.0193407387,
0.0643257052,
-0.0278619397,
-0.0238034502,
-0.0100180339,
-0.0526855662,
-0.0061793597,
0.0216227006,
-0.06624908,
0.0024593384,
-0.0586137585,
-0.0687099397,
0.0204062667,
-0.0298469719,
-0.0208335724,
-0.0356763713,
-0.0084711416,
0.0259208232,
-0.0016949304,
-0.0051679872,
0.0306537133,
-0.0263775438,
-0.1202996373,
-0.04420821,
-0.0132380128,
-0.0063252281,
-0.0911197737,
-0.0521105379,
0.0381522365,
0.0319914483,
0.0086405678,
0.0063484591,
-0.035587091,
-0.0406465158,
0.0229349639,
0.0353540108,
0.0024153993,
0.0365198515,
-0.0206248183,
-0.0393573381,
-0.0981217101,
0.066578269,
-0.0033292142,
0.0137042673,
0.0136854732,
0.0830569342,
0.0124054663,
0.0425106771,
0.0457447954,
-0.0398286469,
-0.0008120572,
-0.0315390006,
0.0099390075,
-0.0016275778,
0.0043093855,
0.008484506,
-0.0738807544,
0.0696871206,
0.0401848406,
-0.0443909802,
0.0075251036,
-0.0540511049,
-0.0134414472,
0.1165007949,
0.0239506699,
-0.0307964906,
0.034741126,
0.0560251996,
-0.1244259253,
0.0169556979,
0.0472370833,
-0.0462157205,
0.055678986,
0.0027776274,
-0.011879093,
0.068479076,
-0.0500077568,
-0.0517445765,
-0.0722231269,
-0.024305718,
-0.0150662949,
0.0231903568,
0.002622358,
-0.0310041122,
-0.0446273498,
-0.0456258506,
0.0166357756,
-0.0106961541,
0.0035672223,
0.0257297866,
0.0114200739,
0.0184549112,
-0.0074214991,
-0.0234693363,
0.0300992131,
0.042578958,
-0.0431545787,
0.0047607301,
0.0377089158,
0.0405999571,
0.0211275946,
0.0190172791,
0.0338042416,
0.0016408493,
0.0403024666,
0.0108387899,
-0.0138809457,
-0.0399698354,
-0.0097616911,
-0.0212204568,
0.0152650392,
0.0333557092,
0.0427786857,
0.0255471542,
0.0297317952,
-0.0181742944,
0.0082586333,
0.0510939024,
-0.0373426452,
0.0059065535,
-0.0037034587,
0.0067210873,
-0.0301506184,
-0.0227353889,
0.0231789909,
-0.0181541685,
0.0060148844,
-0.0594867654,
0.0370498709,
-0.0164720975,
0.019489415,
-0.0056596715,
0.0380585417,
0.029185513,
0.044821959,
-0.031917844,
0.0080247838,
-0.0191538818,
0.0286075063,
0.0010162706,
-0.017325351,
-0.0138919093,
-0.0706450418,
-0.0259985756,
0.0212013293,
0.0570731349,
0.0721159726,
0.0856611207,
-0.0482109413,
-0.0348869823,
0.0141093777,
-0.0475181229,
0.0495016016,
0.0266151931,
-0.0117916744,
0.0074982024,
-0.0051284563,
-0.0455504544,
0.0234222021,
0.0470403805,
-0.0293656643,
0.0256061815,
-0.1095460728,
0.0276657473,
-0.0243015103,
0.0156220319,
-0.0156906601,
0.0545633547,
0.003753389,
0.0481108949,
-0.0064903423,
-0.0028980537,
-0.0030924706,
0.0122729866,
0.0411228091,
0.0155364089,
0.0187781416,
0.037894249,
-0.0650587082,
0.0316107236,
-0.0031215271,
-0.0262637213,
0.0171620492,
-0.0177747607,
-0.0151939103,
-6.18861115e-33,
0.0224588718,
-0.0183425788,
-0.0585247502,
0.0222683661,
0.0760903955,
-0.0195959117,
0.0284734461,
-0.0338373147,
0.0086319475,
-0.0303975809,
-0.017945515,
0.0379512757,
-0.0038671806,
0.048296947,
-0.0006025359,
0.0168015752,
0.0117050493,
-0.0185939148,
-0.0129540395,
0.0141490409,
0.0174766257,
-0.0093171429,
0.0061373534,
-0.0703629702,
0.0264133252,
0.0089011863,
-0.0001537033,
0.0251530875,
0.001507053,
-0.007739095,
-0.0203394741,
-0.0268685129,
0.0072593717,
-0.0298604518,
-0.0096704364,
0.0139926439,
-0.0100109307,
-0.0085722292,
-0.0175638553,
0.0088631893,
-0.0064733685,
-0.0719920248,
-0.0077807959,
-0.0073843547,
-0.0255296305,
0.0082237311,
0.0058680926,
0.0070052841,
0.0251848008,
-0.0279850308,
0.0395325087,
0.0324257761,
-0.052259516,
-0.00971442,
0.0728647783,
-0.056542702,
-0.0240574144,
-0.0123065971,
0.0254878122,
0.0519370884,
0.0309282038,
-0.0459556542,
-0.0094589423,
-0.0274305772,
0.0069508352,
0.0439899154,
0.0688028112,
-0.0849059522,
-0.0301316082,
-0.053719759,
-0.0378864519,
-0.0286698788,
-0.0440639667,
0.0538435541,
0.0393665731,
-0.0069703632,
-0.0754782632,
0.0445682928,
-0.0318009965,
-0.0615440309,
0.0007319714,
-0.0082139103,
-0.0428570248,
-0.0760979205,
0.0466244444,
-0.0735439807,
0.0239589233,
0.0369748026,
-0.0234695449,
0.0237762146,
-0.0099658743,
0.0023856044,
0.0019752041,
-0.0463634506,
-0.0036170282,
0.0380016305,
0.0600561388,
0.0280315932,
0.0073891245,
-0.0174626224,
0.0154922958,
0.0258123577,
-0.0081241624,
0.0086851809,
0.0236848071,
0.0091953659,
-0.0029172397,
0.0742928609,
0.0118835121,
-0.0465476699,
0.0194264222,
-0.0695822313,
0.055608619,
-0.0384612791,
0.0406246595,
0.0132620409,
0.0117566437,
0.040475525,
-0.0074029211,
0.0497820415,
0.0245867092,
0.005326699,
-0.0350241624,
0.0068302425,
-0.0175400358,
-0.0026127275,
-0.0119024366,
-0.0333056264,
0.0617817305,
-0.0161366556,
-0.0248854179,
-0.001371365,
3.071e-7,
0.0197372343,
0.0024072786,
0.0598883219,
-0.011187532,
0.0279509518,
0.012747624,
0.0018489527,
0.0413651764,
-0.060462907,
0.0120178303,
0.0054375124,
0.0137998471,
0.004377536,
-0.0507705621,
-0.0980307013,
-0.0157656614,
0.0286224764,
-0.0045513324,
0.0157205164,
0.0291891005,
0.0627209991,
-0.0242936201,
0.010958666,
0.0089069037,
0.0355845168,
0.0154021727,
-0.0196033567,
-0.004991787,
0.0540831611,
0.0071541178,
0.0193652324,
-0.0240664631,
0.0301359519,
0.0297305007,
0.0166242681,
-0.0406983718,
0.0136972629,
0.0381004885,
-0.0075236731,
-0.0040952279,
-0.0304664131,
-0.0141089363,
-0.0278638434,
0.0227284227,
0.0254938509,
-0.0191436764,
-0.0560623482,
0.0208303556,
-0.0109126931,
0.045439627,
-0.006982374,
0.0715634152,
0.00741089,
-0.0435863249,
-0.0314313024,
0.0291848741,
0.0733757839,
0.0092935646,
0.0388034768,
0.0393666364,
-0.0411391035,
0.0067404653,
0.015546266,
-0.0048814546,
0.0618166365,
-0.0278360788,
-0.0038957733,
2.511296055e-34,
-0.0509020835,
0.0120767923,
0.0199305974,
0.0042059566,
-0.0494116023,
-0.0170183033,
0.0086156726,
-0.0160585064,
0.0203311797,
-0.0217722151,
-0.0051186248
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07788v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07788v1
|
DEPTH: Discourse Education through Pre-Training Hierarchically
| 2024-05-13T14:35:30 | 2024-05-13T14:35:30 |
Zachary Bamberger, Ofek Glick, Chaim Baskin, Yonatan Belinkov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language Models (LMs) often struggle with linguistic understanding at the
discourse level, even though discourse patterns such as coherence, cohesion,
and narrative flow are prevalent in their pre-training data. Current methods
address these challenges only after the pre-training phase, relying on
expensive human annotated data to align the model. To improve the discourse
capabilities of LMs already at the pre-training stage, we introduce DEPTH, an
encoder-decoder model that learns to represent sentences using a
discourse-oriented pre-training objective. DEPTH combines hierarchical sentence
representations with two objectives: (1) Sentence Un-Shuffling, and (2)
Span-Corruption. This approach trains the model to represent both
sub-word-level and sentence-level dependencies over a massive amount of
unstructured text. When trained either from scratch or continuing from a
pre-trained T5 checkpoint, DEPTH learns semantic and discourse-level
representations faster than T5, outperforming it in span-corruption loss
despite the additional sentence-un-shuffling objective. Evaluations on the
GLUE, DiscoEval, and NI benchmarks demonstrate DEPTH's ability to quickly learn
diverse downstream tasks, which require syntactic, semantic, and discourse
capabilities. Overall, our approach extends the discourse capabilities of T5,
while minimally impacting other natural language understanding (NLU)
capabilities in the resulting LM.
|
DEPTH: Discourse Education through Pre-Training Hierarchically: Language Models (LMs) often struggle with linguistic understanding at the
discourse level, even though discourse patterns such as coherence, cohesion,
and narrative flow are prevalent in their pre-training data. Current methods
address these challenges only after the pre-training phase, relying on
expensive human annotated data to align the model. To improve the discourse
capabilities of LMs already at the pre-training stage, we introduce DEPTH, an
encoder-decoder model that learns to represent sentences using a
discourse-oriented pre-training objective. DEPTH combines hierarchical sentence
representations with two objectives: (1) Sentence Un-Shuffling, and (2)
Span-Corruption. This approach trains the model to represent both
sub-word-level and sentence-level dependencies over a massive amount of
unstructured text. When trained either from scratch or continuing from a
pre-trained T5 checkpoint, DEPTH learns semantic and discourse-level
representations faster than T5, outperforming it in span-corruption loss
despite the additional sentence-un-shuffling objective. Evaluations on the
GLUE, DiscoEval, and NI benchmarks demonstrate DEPTH's ability to quickly learn
diverse downstream tasks, which require syntactic, semantic, and discourse
capabilities. Overall, our approach extends the discourse capabilities of T5,
while minimally impacting other natural language understanding (NLU)
capabilities in the resulting LM.
|
[
0.0182925984,
0.0563997291,
-0.0064008231,
0.0623779744,
-0.0086425804,
0.0052510891,
-0.0159410499,
-0.0655948371,
-0.0266753323,
-0.0546660945,
-0.0080920206,
-0.0039446424,
0.0255625565,
0.0307694897,
-0.0186719578,
-0.1013157815,
0.0409110077,
-0.0241060294,
0.0116195772,
-0.0250601899,
0.005835901,
0.0157714952,
-0.0157397967,
-0.0036913378,
-0.0222476181,
-0.0362212434,
-0.0282627773,
0.0270923655,
0.0270920601,
-0.0321002603,
0.047423847,
0.0626512989,
0.0607456788,
0.0433306731,
0.0000021326,
-0.0133731309,
-0.000143666,
-0.037275672,
-0.0208579153,
0.0469137952,
0.0261323694,
-0.0231861956,
0.0154601345,
0.0057266108,
-0.0241183136,
0.0172748324,
-0.0174495336,
0.0774141178,
0.0959963948,
0.0529876091,
-0.0060132779,
-0.0454728343,
0.0057930634,
-0.0189353768,
-0.063958481,
-0.059516944,
-0.0112829162,
0.0345312916,
-0.0276742559,
0.0426377319,
-0.0450074449,
0.0280144997,
0.0445897169,
-0.0018771314,
0.0239879247,
0.0275335573,
-0.0174507461,
-0.00083074,
-0.0192090478,
0.081461139,
0.0121376486,
-0.0126673458,
-0.0215876251,
-0.0034771964,
0.0075654676,
-0.0156125231,
-0.0167838819,
0.0274725035,
0.0150664933,
0.0450687855,
0.0086784819,
0.0083741462,
0.0027757776,
0.0020245875,
0.0131885689,
0.0240839198,
-0.0095555978,
-0.0271531343,
0.0174269527,
0.0311025474,
0.008870298,
-0.0463143662,
0.0088721346,
0.0088566942,
-0.056673158,
0.0270897392,
-0.0478691757,
-0.0084129907,
0.0148033202,
-0.0950065851,
0.0069074673,
0.0194309354,
-0.0292736646,
0.0155060887,
-0.0079632178,
0.0442315303,
0.0188664421,
0.0098220175,
-0.0283896495,
-0.0074496176,
-0.024943918,
-0.0340414383,
-0.0602190532,
0.0472352691,
-0.0946421325,
-0.0253390055,
-0.0364959799,
0.0021985748,
-0.001133915,
-0.0200661197,
-0.0134966811,
0.0247647651,
-0.0338057764,
-0.0021130091,
-0.0280248504,
0.0722049549,
-0.0298106559,
0.0289058611,
0.002136372,
-0.0217430443,
-0.037389461,
0.0057834121,
0.0071337214,
-0.0018982204,
-0.0082710674,
0.0264364053,
-0.044173412,
-0.0239055082,
-0.0402600281,
-0.0109842261,
-0.0276709776,
-0.0427301191,
0.0006057927,
-0.0469114818,
-0.0143229375,
-0.0146546187,
0.0156218996,
-0.028688347,
0.0250976458,
0.0183190741,
-0.0233279057,
0.0485151261,
0.0003061054,
-0.0321539417,
0.0279875789,
0.0231816638,
0.0534806773,
0.0737386718,
0.0357271172,
0.0171559751,
0.0060488121,
-0.0048001702,
-0.0386993103,
-0.0159127563,
0.0032280802,
-0.018478971,
0.0120957205,
0.0131826513,
-0.0329266489,
0.0449389219,
0.0521498807,
0.0465175696,
-0.0425281301,
-0.0084061576,
0.0682579577,
0.0319509208,
-0.0375764109,
-0.010921834,
0.0396171547,
0.0382268131,
-0.0148459878,
0.0493242219,
-0.0256722458,
0.0044560949,
0.0206349213,
-0.007713051,
0.0285142902,
0.0044897762,
-0.0267910771,
-0.0432906337,
0.0002233268,
-0.0180352759,
0.0267737582,
-0.028824944,
-0.0053782291,
0.0492243282,
-0.0711909607,
0.066549398,
0.0522827394,
-0.0629968122,
0.0153972805,
0.0244130082,
-0.004622038,
0.0711553171,
0.0426819287,
0.0084956288,
-0.0484630466,
-0.0154067315,
0.0651595742,
0.0966851339,
-0.0003233858,
-0.0194518734,
0.0357147492,
-0.0527343154,
-0.0308338813,
-0.0679529086,
0.0182028245,
0.0431780182,
-0.0009600821,
-0.0270161368,
0.0046322267,
-0.0164264385,
-0.0568063781,
0.0314257666,
-0.0367876664,
0.0002065465,
0.0105737932,
0.0061620101,
0.0232507009,
0.0274615064,
-0.0112263095,
-0.0312393755,
0.0518454276,
-0.0415544808,
-0.0123568568,
0.0065033156,
-0.121229656,
-0.0662682801,
0.0039757937,
-0.0757389739,
-0.0368987359,
0.0473479554,
-0.046122212,
-0.036650043,
0.0503202565,
-0.0279827435,
0.0176669881,
-0.0487732291,
-0.0030617921,
-0.0001175677,
-0.0011717669,
-0.004789446,
0.0767873079,
-0.0086079314,
-0.0145330476,
-0.007581179,
-0.0100509115,
0.0170754995,
-0.0267039202,
0.0009233406,
0.0047612367,
0.0019429121,
0.0054993224,
0.0037786767,
0.0245087519,
-0.0410206057,
-0.0185739752,
-0.1084350199,
-0.0212628767,
-0.0359279439,
0.0020553409,
0.0385113731,
-0.0057039168,
0.0187351163,
-0.0497381985,
0.0037879299,
-0.0086081559,
-0.0124087501,
-0.0131850401,
0.0569933914,
-0.0022700743,
0.0324165002,
-0.0227276981,
0.0081596384,
0.0034514898,
0.0407395773,
-0.00994315,
-0.0164664052,
-0.0266595297,
-0.0129472381,
-0.0121764196,
0.0016222851,
-0.0101944329,
-0.0535733774,
0.0222350433,
0.0539989285,
0.0737606362,
0.0545490906,
0.0494647138,
0.0968677998,
0.0231975354,
-0.0092811622,
-0.018381957,
0.0434132889,
-0.0093406793,
0.0515709706,
-0.0759050697,
0.0327263065,
-0.0147126913,
0.0820114389,
0.0052250479,
0.0293431748,
-0.0562414713,
-0.0065162461,
-0.0108619807,
-0.0450331047,
-0.0043711299,
-0.0600617304,
-0.0263148788,
-0.0057177013,
-0.0741719678,
0.0222681928,
0.0462841056,
-0.0552611277,
-0.0095992815,
-0.0710031092,
0.0057396125,
-0.0361258201,
0.0431919023,
0.0136352628,
0.011093867,
-0.0073670801,
-0.0663280487,
-0.032459937,
0.0157007258,
0.0439697988,
-0.0075072637,
0.0481606424,
-0.0535429977,
-0.0031825469,
-0.0020953387,
-0.0564387366,
-0.0540615767,
-0.0434606485,
-0.0065592253,
0.0104518132,
-0.0295884628,
0.0124760251,
-0.0408586636,
-0.0353071988,
0.0141416816,
0.0539146587,
-0.0093107279,
0.0230878238,
-0.0463487878,
0.0369605906,
0.0366406031,
0.0365363397,
-0.0008041675,
-0.0615335517,
0.0528236553,
0.0452438258,
-0.0557738729,
-0.0212728977,
-0.0312132053,
0.0112977223,
-0.0207573064,
-0.0097008971,
-0.0099771274,
-0.0106575871,
0.0679102689,
-0.0589456484,
-0.0456612892,
0.1194268391,
0.0158024542,
-0.0074442867,
-0.003907389,
-0.0082435347,
0.066800043,
0.0214149598,
-0.0170213524,
-0.0795677006,
-0.0471701138,
0.0073270695,
0.0151521061,
0.0425426364,
-0.0202925075,
0.012762012,
-0.1017545611,
0.0139379688,
-0.0008084667,
-0.010777127,
0.0043112426,
-0.034248434,
-0.0087700728,
0.0215583872,
0.0689742491,
-0.0029885152,
-0.0200992376,
-0.01020029,
0.0216567013,
-0.010650252,
-0.0553639494,
0.0090790419,
-0.0201348923,
0.0383860804,
0.0321263447,
0.038897682,
-0.00896894,
0.0062838038,
0.0465938002,
-0.0037791543,
-0.0046798037,
0.0042793686,
0.0789281875,
-0.0344202742,
0.014560408,
-0.0065722554,
0.0407884531,
-0.0135048032,
-0.0122993253,
-0.0243009198,
0.0392189026,
-0.0117511377,
-0.0208563954,
0.0061711175,
0.0275940746,
-0.0025443777,
0.0830437765,
0.0552617908,
-0.0080147339,
-0.0377386175,
-0.0398023538,
0.0365487784,
-0.0555756949,
0.0094278092,
0.0166750047,
0.0152070476,
0.0124078263,
-0.069645822,
-0.0716565475,
0.0012654075,
-0.0079717375,
0.0065562492,
0.0083819982,
0.0341121964,
-0.0150170056,
-0.0389421135,
0.0084830206,
-0.0238397121,
-0.0136198616,
-0.0401831493,
-0.0237518623,
0.0057859225,
-0.0258860122,
-0.0275617409,
-0.0045051062,
-0.0390824787,
-0.0552036539,
0.0130204624,
0.0161436815,
0.0072130272,
0.0848372877,
-0.0125740068,
-0.0093210433,
0.074870795,
0.0152076771,
-0.0368951596,
0.0327742286,
0.0455756485,
0.0002802948,
-0.0080098342,
0.0423079208,
-0.0262718685,
0.0257675238,
-0.0182502288,
0.0403746031,
0.0008374837,
-0.0351032615,
0.0118932156,
-0.0403216816,
0.0514695421,
0.0024556762,
-0.0039299675,
-0.0578261875,
0.0449259691,
-0.0629576296,
-0.018140018,
-0.0235008467,
0.0208414923,
0.02080754,
0.0051983353,
0.0029293504,
0.0218423232,
-0.0010180356,
0.0634584352,
-0.0187024232,
-0.0003393519,
0.0277854875,
0.0075881146,
-0.0120319463,
0.0196527559,
-0.0131602623,
0.0164750144,
-0.0163472425,
0.0453367159,
-0.0130888596,
0.0388684534,
0.0224819481,
-0.0017465508,
0.0060423026,
0.0239488445,
-0.0688602477,
0.0404295325,
-0.0327632166,
-0.0008325281,
0.0661266819,
-0.0164739899,
0.0777121931,
-0.0045817751,
0.0150546767,
0.0121241817,
0.0494187102,
-0.0142606925,
-0.0587226115,
0.0035180235,
0.0070284186,
-0.025142068,
0.0209316406,
0.0679099187,
0.0094411923,
0.0360107012,
0.0369830579,
0.0296225827,
-0.0500134602,
-0.0716908425,
-0.0101509048,
0.0551616512,
-0.0157265421,
0.0347792134,
-0.0116237449,
-0.0154857552,
0.0358425342,
-0.0078880908,
-0.0035939291,
-0.0309092328,
0.0493428558,
0.0316991173,
-0.005004162,
-0.0160768516,
-0.0274183527,
-0.0082804207,
0.0124132,
-0.029549269,
-0.0299275741,
-6.676363429e-33,
-0.0460733548,
0.0048131244,
-0.0022053756,
0.0101720262,
-0.0384091921,
0.0279506762,
-0.079581514,
0.0035771572,
0.0108007034,
0.0583513714,
0.0273552109,
0.0284464285,
-0.000515526,
0.0668138042,
-0.002381515,
0.003599931,
0.0788765103,
-0.0125854323,
-0.0293492191,
0.0285782032,
0.0550904199,
0.0326099545,
0.0522213243,
0.0167304166,
-0.013103703,
-0.0152683277,
0.0136738047,
0.0294129755,
0.0243751891,
0.0155490274,
-0.0126886973,
0.0122475112,
0.0260198396,
-0.0015477688,
-0.0238635037,
0.028240582,
-0.1061155349,
-0.0220455695,
0.0258991923,
0.0161623005,
-0.0913254097,
-0.0300317612,
0.0234583504,
0.0172795355,
0.0322165452,
-0.0379917547,
0.0366438068,
0.0163657255,
0.0064674802,
-0.0190393813,
-0.0635454729,
-0.004863109,
-0.046787817,
-0.0257011708,
0.0081666019,
0.0337701589,
0.0225885604,
0.0001068234,
-0.0493714437,
0.0126565769,
-0.0159114655,
0.0226183031,
0.0129826479,
-0.0027373729,
-0.0385997146,
0.0999641493,
-0.0460558496,
-0.0037379933,
-0.0474492051,
0.0251374152,
0.0214105695,
0.0186177343,
0.0132190408,
0.013478783,
0.0211579148,
0.013391885,
-0.0734103769,
0.0080115804,
-0.0341234766,
0.0654492453,
0.010270834,
0.0119882785,
0.0151597233,
-0.011363158,
-0.0450961106,
-0.0126606449,
0.0175930373,
-0.0236295592,
0.0193875078,
0.006793472,
-0.014170358,
0.001304662,
0.0263223778,
-0.009549492,
-0.0144523177,
0.036191199,
-0.0177914947,
0.0016290534,
0.0164177548,
0.0587569773,
-0.039482832,
0.0137622617,
0.0586914048,
0.0155390929,
0.0096727787,
-0.0157901868,
0.0688506812,
-0.0189620182,
-0.0226412304,
0.0227823239,
-0.0190648939,
0.033192791,
-0.0573581941,
0.0677123144,
0.0125866225,
0.0318925679,
-0.026177343,
0.0412590913,
-0.0149509255,
0.0062927254,
-0.0480983034,
-0.0222334284,
-0.012721668,
0.0237898249,
-0.0271193385,
-0.0169297289,
-0.0642363504,
0.0176700428,
0.0106380265,
-0.0705738589,
0.0022506798,
0.0255455747,
2.685e-7,
0.0053891935,
0.0788699165,
0.0637517199,
-0.0172196627,
0.0444912463,
0.0035284299,
-0.013703214,
0.0473120101,
-0.0150545062,
-0.0492365509,
-0.0062113851,
0.0593456253,
0.0687733218,
0.0235158503,
-0.1209248975,
-0.0268643945,
-0.1004353613,
-0.0176979471,
-0.0520240702,
-0.0033458031,
0.0714184567,
0.0477711149,
-0.0235849116,
0.0012588307,
0.0086476048,
0.0242817104,
0.0553638414,
0.0168648567,
-0.0012724783,
0.0078617977,
-0.0498656891,
-0.0006942971,
-0.0286277588,
0.0113940937,
-0.0288323872,
0.0385543853,
-0.0324455425,
0.0576966181,
-0.005341853,
-0.0617763139,
-0.0231893118,
0.032175038,
-0.0073535996,
-0.0101700677,
0.036538247,
-0.056778688,
-0.0449933559,
0.0238443483,
-0.0794389918,
0.0054969685,
0.0094764326,
0.0180151444,
-0.0505619049,
0.0037628303,
0.0035287261,
-0.0254884306,
-0.0015654527,
-0.0732250661,
0.0021860639,
-0.0014700593,
-0.0337892659,
0.0211323723,
-0.0184670892,
-0.0238572769,
0.0210403427,
-0.0505804494,
0.0271252505,
2.343394824e-34,
0.0542865805,
-0.0367885381,
0.0128946891,
0.0050823288,
0.0307302605,
-0.0129680661,
-0.024300104,
-0.0156970285,
0.0011907105,
-0.0571937151,
0.0127033647
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07778v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07778v1
|
A Comprehensive Analysis of Static Word Embeddings for Turkish
| 2024-05-13T14:23:37 | 2024-05-13T14:23:37 |
Karahan Sarıtaş, Cahid Arda Öz, Tunga Güngör
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Word embeddings are fixed-length, dense and distributed word representations
that are used in natural language processing (NLP) applications. There are
basically two types of word embedding models which are non-contextual (static)
models and contextual models. The former method generates a single embedding
for a word regardless of its context, while the latter method produces distinct
embeddings for a word based on the specific contexts in which it appears. There
are plenty of works that compare contextual and non-contextual embedding models
within their respective groups in different languages. However, the number of
studies that compare the models in these two groups with each other is very few
and there is no such study in Turkish. This process necessitates converting
contextual embeddings into static embeddings. In this paper, we compare and
evaluate the performance of several contextual and non-contextual models in
both intrinsic and extrinsic evaluation settings for Turkish. We make a
fine-grained comparison by analyzing the syntactic and semantic capabilities of
the models separately. The results of the analyses provide insights about the
suitability of different embedding models in different types of NLP tasks. We
also build a Turkish word embedding repository comprising the embedding models
used in this work, which may serve as a valuable resource for researchers and
practitioners in the field of Turkish NLP. We make the word embeddings,
scripts, and evaluation datasets publicly available.
|
A Comprehensive Analysis of Static Word Embeddings for Turkish: Word embeddings are fixed-length, dense and distributed word representations
that are used in natural language processing (NLP) applications. There are
basically two types of word embedding models which are non-contextual (static)
models and contextual models. The former method generates a single embedding
for a word regardless of its context, while the latter method produces distinct
embeddings for a word based on the specific contexts in which it appears. There
are plenty of works that compare contextual and non-contextual embedding models
within their respective groups in different languages. However, the number of
studies that compare the models in these two groups with each other is very few
and there is no such study in Turkish. This process necessitates converting
contextual embeddings into static embeddings. In this paper, we compare and
evaluate the performance of several contextual and non-contextual models in
both intrinsic and extrinsic evaluation settings for Turkish. We make a
fine-grained comparison by analyzing the syntactic and semantic capabilities of
the models separately. The results of the analyses provide insights about the
suitability of different embedding models in different types of NLP tasks. We
also build a Turkish word embedding repository comprising the embedding models
used in this work, which may serve as a valuable resource for researchers and
practitioners in the field of Turkish NLP. We make the word embeddings,
scripts, and evaluation datasets publicly available.
|
[
0.0031768535,
0.005465325,
-0.0280490033,
0.0177143849,
-0.04530463,
0.0429389179,
0.0069108056,
-0.0048173717,
-0.0277003571,
-0.0357468762,
-0.0266433768,
-0.0598020032,
0.0477658696,
0.0061212829,
0.0630862936,
-0.0342595279,
0.046598535,
0.0133918934,
-0.0067537115,
0.0179459546,
0.0497144461,
0.0120547069,
-0.0240722727,
0.0420603566,
-0.0473553054,
-0.0018304811,
0.0195489489,
-0.058699213,
0.0156638138,
-0.0244930536,
-0.041252967,
0.0107364897,
0.0124880914,
0.0117204944,
0.000001706,
-0.0052484241,
0.0291977488,
-0.0117550921,
0.0069631469,
-0.0031123275,
0.0676525012,
-0.050644733,
-0.05663139,
-0.0012901034,
-0.0190535188,
-0.0411854796,
0.0541064665,
0.01595686,
0.0059890584,
0.03367294,
-0.0026940526,
-0.0821245834,
0.0161223989,
-0.0265742149,
-0.0382108837,
-0.0340208523,
-0.0040564816,
-0.031505134,
-0.0627390072,
0.0229804516,
-0.0401064083,
0.0496595763,
0.00813602,
0.0056820619,
-0.0021873685,
0.0394660607,
-0.0674565211,
-0.0476193242,
0.0427112579,
0.0524830744,
-0.0104274061,
-0.0208829045,
-0.0201043449,
0.0330351517,
-0.0149417501,
0.0017750128,
-0.0458599478,
0.0169376265,
0.0188757256,
0.0246129148,
0.0617281571,
0.0815292224,
0.0465458147,
0.0115902042,
-0.003774683,
0.0016115709,
0.0405691937,
-0.0474477373,
-0.0004495983,
0.0125126494,
0.0082159778,
-0.0096664103,
0.0289285649,
0.0152258324,
0.0148382075,
0.0383481123,
-0.0024846978,
-0.0376369059,
0.0400045142,
-0.0845907256,
0.0347607583,
0.0588075072,
0.0006390713,
0.0332458355,
-0.1084731743,
0.0041835555,
-0.0090505909,
0.014273162,
-0.0112521853,
-0.0118886372,
-0.0363542549,
-0.0148259541,
-0.0351606421,
0.0446291082,
-0.045926664,
-0.0259607509,
-0.0289707109,
0.0539486334,
-0.0053928965,
0.0085029304,
-0.0047139851,
0.004555054,
-0.022699561,
0.0445869379,
-0.0155548221,
-0.0432639383,
-0.066331327,
-0.0358785391,
-0.0623946525,
-0.0191859119,
0.034461204,
-0.0112810647,
0.0158842746,
0.0057653277,
-0.0174078364,
0.0442513153,
0.0118607841,
-0.0631851926,
-0.0218845811,
0.0401032902,
-0.0339440852,
-0.0392952524,
-0.0559679717,
-0.0495269597,
0.02723483,
0.0069882739,
0.001775926,
-0.0148031628,
-0.0029673423,
0.0535916314,
-0.0041867355,
0.0971250981,
0.0899575874,
-0.0066980277,
-0.0111525496,
-0.0060104909,
0.0580857024,
0.0636838675,
0.026971342,
0.0018406345,
0.0371925384,
-0.0153293423,
-0.0398517959,
0.0048866677,
0.0090364479,
-0.0062327469,
-0.0448690653,
0.0389139242,
0.0246364959,
0.0635557026,
-0.0380531438,
0.0486275256,
-0.0020434428,
-0.0128483651,
0.0319406316,
0.0960878208,
0.0154096,
0.0433198065,
0.0755814388,
-0.0127832945,
-0.0243802294,
-0.010795705,
-0.0061604851,
-0.0275722388,
0.0132279657,
0.0217428096,
0.0093728891,
0.0305418223,
-0.0114233587,
-0.040109124,
-0.0301428195,
-0.0179343969,
0.0556702912,
-0.0674404353,
0.0610358715,
-0.0037732127,
-0.0829438046,
0.0116879735,
0.0254597403,
-0.023121221,
-0.0102821728,
0.0091750426,
0.0217813458,
0.035877727,
0.0670469627,
-0.0023753215,
0.0050993199,
-0.0090676742,
-0.0143968314,
0.0386671722,
0.0433263034,
-0.052325163,
0.005699838,
-0.046073094,
0.0321824104,
0.0152684515,
0.0338762328,
0.0330228917,
-0.0179682579,
0.0659030601,
0.0303206574,
-0.0281776506,
0.0101062646,
0.0434183367,
-0.0226488039,
-0.0157752987,
-0.0334699266,
0.0173074733,
-0.0060226419,
0.0300481543,
-0.0150077948,
0.0210946966,
0.0429229885,
-0.0600045323,
0.022403108,
0.0088844569,
-0.0608821362,
-0.037996307,
0.0151747139,
-0.0352226198,
-0.0207078382,
0.022760842,
-0.0200960282,
-0.0182142481,
0.0478832163,
-0.0059079099,
0.0570081733,
-0.0438671187,
0.0190801807,
-0.0062455116,
0.0493142232,
-0.0081768902,
0.0578478388,
-0.0391059294,
0.0215459224,
-0.0142218675,
0.0377950817,
0.0174799655,
-0.0016345317,
-0.0351536833,
0.0395909473,
0.0224920865,
-0.0157198124,
-0.0234250128,
-0.0258386061,
0.0077122943,
0.0127020273,
-0.0872962773,
0.0082729142,
-0.0286237635,
0.039613165,
0.0053437413,
0.0158709213,
-0.0057912711,
-0.0066599818,
-0.0117849009,
-0.0141149899,
0.0145730246,
0.0211296827,
0.0465566441,
-0.0198976342,
-0.0262741409,
-0.049089551,
-0.0088875378,
0.0134637719,
0.0293932911,
-0.0219090488,
-0.020956289,
0.0170560516,
0.0242909323,
-0.0007919281,
-0.0076014316,
0.0028269917,
-0.0271988437,
0.013840599,
0.0176881906,
0.0509807691,
0.0316420496,
-0.0130687989,
0.0394923687,
0.0185224414,
-0.0030683193,
-0.014905341,
-0.0416430868,
-0.0191429202,
-0.0027782964,
-0.0322826169,
0.021467872,
-0.0068345307,
0.0482650176,
-0.0131631894,
-0.0117997928,
-0.0701984763,
-0.0142298359,
-0.0731130764,
-0.014196096,
-0.0412658826,
0.0069611124,
-0.0559458956,
0.0322598144,
-0.0105420928,
-0.0087842783,
0.0075310813,
-0.0425001793,
0.0175744109,
-0.0433597453,
-0.0112572229,
-0.0475669578,
0.0174062643,
-0.0165234171,
0.0051869457,
-0.0495225787,
-0.0206155982,
-0.030730959,
0.0010786419,
0.0189668778,
-0.0392051898,
0.0322017856,
0.0045010815,
-0.0061105234,
-0.0047319867,
0.0006090839,
-0.0243262965,
-0.0848769322,
-0.007457667,
0.0340402573,
0.0369803868,
0.036933057,
0.0000247396,
0.0423757918,
-0.024591269,
-0.0107846791,
0.020053165,
0.0043215686,
-0.0470059179,
0.0096312193,
0.0168330502,
-0.0259189084,
0.0170075428,
0.0458287038,
0.0294263028,
0.0279298313,
0.0165738985,
-0.0212387182,
-0.032138966,
-0.0147353131,
0.0198006388,
-0.052000355,
-0.0318790302,
-0.0573157594,
0.018845927,
-0.0159875229,
-0.0039733038,
0.0770680234,
0.0416133702,
0.002774267,
0.0581198782,
-0.0031181478,
-0.0021336121,
0.0295537021,
-0.0154456133,
-0.0344569236,
0.0004867362,
0.0380890705,
-0.0283185206,
0.0022244414,
-0.0023159704,
0.0546607263,
-0.1399338692,
-0.0494669192,
0.0007247506,
-0.043695122,
-0.0348319262,
-0.0439220034,
-0.015227681,
-0.0280893445,
-0.0076966034,
-0.0341344178,
-0.0084778927,
0.0296542514,
0.0230025481,
-0.0466789678,
-0.0893749669,
-0.0127533413,
-0.0122188358,
0.020020932,
0.0248563215,
0.0402208604,
-0.0313104205,
0.0127125196,
0.0403162166,
-0.0537081957,
-0.016327342,
-0.0035126542,
0.0138228359,
-0.0376596637,
-0.0239862353,
-0.0360513553,
-0.0513750091,
-0.0492627658,
-0.0000253125,
-0.0413557291,
0.0513599478,
0.0350249819,
0.0378460549,
-0.0129244206,
0.0044628978,
0.0126590682,
0.0555557907,
-0.0076440782,
-0.0080048153,
-0.0273321625,
0.0157074034,
-0.0184487086,
-0.0258509964,
-0.0414638482,
0.0162909571,
0.0111870039,
0.0199722387,
-0.0767923519,
-0.0798799172,
0.0356246978,
0.0206897408,
0.0055425009,
0.0350202397,
-0.0767445788,
-0.0236787498,
-0.0167485233,
-0.004951627,
0.0229068175,
0.0200945716,
-0.0072058523,
0.0222850423,
0.0397718288,
0.0172884818,
-0.0202675536,
0.0029850032,
-0.0543184616,
-0.027743984,
0.0028683073,
0.0019662252,
0.0042465054,
0.0075332192,
-0.0567188486,
-0.0130930655,
0.0735429451,
-0.0413919389,
-0.0607568324,
-0.0018173623,
0.0146061126,
0.0132420938,
0.0209475979,
0.0493720435,
0.0035053545,
0.017072659,
0.0093283253,
0.0066112112,
-0.0074412217,
0.0231909193,
-0.0064050448,
-0.0350529924,
-0.0161306504,
-0.0178353228,
0.0215224531,
-0.0329365954,
-0.0007958999,
-0.0038359629,
0.018751597,
0.0239206329,
0.0039516822,
0.0656441301,
0.01880317,
-0.0273572616,
-0.0208417978,
0.0013892018,
0.025668228,
-0.0395782106,
0.0209033787,
0.0532281548,
-0.0189108942,
-0.0121654831,
0.0786633566,
-0.0379636548,
0.0166620892,
-0.0801023692,
-0.0101108439,
-0.0544231981,
-0.0283777807,
-0.039538268,
-0.0054076896,
0.0003739797,
0.0506600887,
-0.0212090537,
0.038592387,
0.0104638441,
0.0813516825,
0.057117451,
-0.0600189827,
0.0254511423,
-0.0188043714,
-0.0099362386,
-0.0065469737,
0.0208049472,
-0.040665485,
-0.0340175852,
0.0246719141,
-0.0063599558,
-0.0341945514,
-0.0326732993,
0.0503697991,
0.0027198466,
0.0210360084,
-0.0267323684,
0.0127077047,
-0.0127329482,
0.0482846536,
0.0018723357,
0.0660479143,
-0.0205906946,
0.02406203,
-0.0821744204,
-0.1121359915,
-0.0291122682,
0.0198782235,
-0.0066437591,
-0.0206363332,
-0.006600088,
0.0576703474,
0.0737785399,
0.0665445626,
-0.0351696089,
0.0277309325,
-0.0106700985,
-0.0313650295,
-0.053416919,
-5.283941146e-33,
-0.0173763931,
0.0397562161,
-0.0327337049,
-0.0452893041,
-0.0097668804,
-0.000022242,
-0.0252991598,
0.002350423,
-0.0176698025,
0.017458234,
-0.0508769043,
0.0163288191,
0.0138599109,
-0.0128548024,
0.0046742526,
-0.0603446066,
0.0098998053,
-0.0058416766,
-0.0166277643,
0.0264133774,
0.0839904249,
0.039788574,
0.0729659647,
-0.034354154,
0.02627155,
-0.0261443797,
0.0394794866,
-0.0090961894,
0.0507685766,
0.100630179,
-0.0384405777,
0.0476719439,
0.0380820818,
-0.019903183,
-0.024611529,
0.0197692234,
-0.08691594,
-0.0212523043,
0.0437766835,
0.0356559828,
-0.0331223384,
-0.0193984825,
-0.0179867521,
-0.0325739048,
-0.0157279186,
0.0536426455,
0.012634282,
-0.0090578971,
-0.0595726818,
0.0232299045,
-0.0923025459,
0.0439888053,
-0.0146030309,
0.0264226831,
0.0652388185,
-0.0049280887,
0.0297807697,
-0.0017178174,
-0.0520241596,
-0.0186857246,
-0.0856943652,
0.0130191082,
0.053706266,
-0.0192868933,
-0.0008779161,
0.0487040691,
-0.0620189086,
-0.0230414122,
-0.0347639062,
-0.0187784825,
0.0061251749,
-0.0025296316,
0.0087682921,
0.053985592,
0.0466542244,
-0.0671179667,
-0.0543520488,
-0.0169982724,
0.0556605011,
0.0333428606,
0.0449686721,
0.0068115955,
-0.0663016662,
-0.0218999404,
-0.0118487654,
-0.0352161191,
0.0082236249,
-0.039540913,
0.0558278374,
-0.025028253,
-0.0149252294,
0.0165897924,
-0.0007020983,
-0.0490754358,
0.0215049312,
0.0037128001,
0.0409744568,
0.0129856607,
0.011344987,
0.0187259018,
-0.0363105349,
-0.037148241,
-0.0155916736,
0.0260873642,
0.0133193936,
-0.010041927,
0.0376796722,
-0.0148539506,
-0.0386339761,
0.008867858,
-0.0350181907,
-0.0286607463,
-0.015107817,
0.0412889905,
0.071670182,
0.0033255131,
-0.0139051974,
0.0005099788,
0.0572491512,
0.005584585,
0.0178057998,
-0.0282204729,
0.0130596226,
-0.007439163,
0.0045825802,
0.0090285102,
-0.0121548399,
0.0404445305,
0.0583876371,
-0.0260974951,
-0.0018708685,
0.0067375568,
2.482e-7,
0.0558454245,
-0.0165270213,
0.0331606008,
-0.0070393593,
0.0327830613,
-0.0150867328,
0.0027169921,
0.0325174704,
-0.0437199585,
-0.0138537223,
0.0076846373,
0.0051350784,
0.0571227483,
-0.0143164573,
-0.0533574708,
0.0072993292,
-0.0507274866,
0.0250684917,
-0.0133147091,
0.0181278102,
0.0301410574,
0.1187372953,
-0.001976884,
0.016890645,
-0.0758321211,
-0.0307565015,
0.0616247207,
-0.0371983834,
-0.0006447462,
-0.0347288325,
-0.0357840694,
0.0608650707,
0.0222384296,
0.0009039741,
-0.0395176895,
0.0925714001,
0.0773383155,
0.0439147428,
-0.013228409,
-0.0033678026,
0.0141480165,
-0.0495316014,
-0.0163163915,
-0.0595685951,
0.1161584109,
-0.0130185662,
-0.0560514852,
-0.0124484673,
0.0181624629,
0.0454592444,
0.0344228745,
0.0355508588,
-0.0673995838,
0.0206909049,
0.0454487838,
-0.0089233704,
-0.0015336578,
-0.0793969929,
0.0166904069,
0.0167564992,
-0.014802943,
0.0013980122,
-0.0147643518,
-0.0009157794,
0.0585371368,
0.0328394063,
-0.0506771244,
1.907104242e-34,
0.0058471174,
0.0465667695,
0.0403581262,
0.0132574681,
0.0129292822,
-0.0104595618,
0.0508164167,
-0.0255906917,
0.0532966927,
-0.0421164259,
-0.0091889473
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07766v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07766v1
|
Challenges and Opportunities of NLP for HR Applications: A Discussion Paper
| 2024-05-13T14:09:06 | 2024-05-13T14:09:06 |
Jochen L. Leidner, Mark Stevenson
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7; I.2.1
|
Over the course of the recent decade, tremendous progress has been made in
the areas of machine learning and natural language processing, which opened up
vast areas of potential application use cases, including hiring and human
resource management. We review the use cases for text analytics in the realm of
human resources/personnel management, including actually realized as well as
potential but not yet implemented ones, and we analyze the opportunities and
risks of these.
|
Challenges and Opportunities of NLP for HR Applications: A Discussion Paper: Over the course of the recent decade, tremendous progress has been made in
the areas of machine learning and natural language processing, which opened up
vast areas of potential application use cases, including hiring and human
resource management. We review the use cases for text analytics in the realm of
human resources/personnel management, including actually realized as well as
potential but not yet implemented ones, and we analyze the opportunities and
risks of these.
|
[
0.0711107329,
0.0502796732,
-0.0148118949,
-0.0563105531,
-0.038730029,
0.0132295443,
-0.0111392578,
0.0356584527,
0.0340210795,
-0.0793366954,
0.0591876581,
-0.0014962676,
0.0053959843,
-0.0140977949,
0.0074771084,
-0.0355770923,
0.017742509,
0.0793162957,
0.0145002902,
0.033988975,
0.006461578,
0.0712515041,
0.008483219,
0.0611453168,
-0.0254329816,
-0.01466941,
0.0282901581,
-0.0357399248,
0.0448518954,
0.0064693126,
-0.0108227655,
0.0336903185,
-0.0086761387,
-0.0462601855,
0.0000017882,
-0.02714522,
-0.0143875973,
0.0288252607,
-0.0156691521,
-0.0354389995,
0.0673359558,
-0.0018021479,
-0.007373665,
0.0470077321,
-0.0249912553,
0.0556863472,
0.0036015878,
-0.0053448966,
0.0425541364,
0.0289408844,
-0.0124834189,
-0.0075615277,
-0.0375791974,
-0.0105431182,
0.0027499404,
-0.034049999,
0.012701029,
-0.0414764248,
-0.0094047384,
-0.0105903391,
0.040873792,
0.0130533576,
-0.0533453487,
-0.0239321385,
0.0447442941,
0.0073251189,
0.016719602,
-0.0040849522,
0.0018545589,
0.0006522601,
0.0296348054,
0.0157551281,
-0.0051413658,
-0.0384590439,
0.0346613601,
0.0367791206,
0.0366690308,
-0.0003356309,
-0.0349033512,
-0.0200504418,
-0.0678825751,
0.0126677407,
-0.0445519015,
-0.013947702,
0.0238227695,
0.0163439047,
-0.0076695764,
-0.0319277942,
0.0750582665,
0.0533948019,
0.0820265487,
-0.0222686436,
0.0398195572,
0.0222873539,
0.0044707838,
0.0206683949,
-0.0119585274,
-0.0255900063,
0.0518740378,
-0.0776760429,
-0.0198541395,
0.0256758947,
0.018039085,
0.0287478063,
0.0529551245,
0.0012001637,
0.0298512764,
-0.0552588925,
0.0022032475,
-0.0394049324,
-0.0739997029,
-0.0114508606,
-0.0098413285,
-0.0054434566,
0.007087721,
0.03674303,
-0.0736911446,
-0.0012919148,
-0.0159650203,
-0.0113104824,
-0.0175566487,
0.0193908103,
0.0231389832,
0.0453309231,
-0.0948970765,
-0.038791243,
-0.0098028267,
-0.0118410252,
-0.0566743948,
-0.0030733431,
0.0620896555,
-0.0076338663,
0.0266175009,
0.023445081,
0.016494019,
0.0282383747,
0.002959958,
-0.021701863,
-0.0483014584,
-0.0456590243,
-0.0077402815,
-0.0049584401,
-0.0466460735,
-0.0401608348,
0.0623702034,
-0.0020728405,
-0.0386220738,
-0.0434776135,
0.0238175672,
0.0900565535,
-0.0448761284,
-0.017754253,
-0.0386417471,
0.0126320431,
0.0342555754,
-0.0121106058,
0.0224069394,
0.0277856197,
0.0188716277,
0.0218257885,
0.0313596427,
-0.0295974668,
0.0218770392,
0.0416619927,
0.0043137516,
-0.0453113914,
-0.0028149565,
0.0431431606,
-0.0252542235,
-0.0083764028,
-0.0130634718,
0.0295274761,
-0.0392973311,
0.0239141211,
-0.0228174664,
0.1137057245,
0.0020574122,
0.0318804495,
0.0418275669,
0.0398996323,
-0.0368054025,
-0.0475388691,
0.0083526755,
-0.0041975044,
-0.0018692164,
-0.0558521636,
0.0082338732,
0.0110097388,
-0.0344264656,
-0.0494398437,
-0.0223514959,
0.0054986789,
-0.0101389773,
-0.0298455544,
0.021128593,
-0.0165672339,
-0.0261024963,
0.0101592438,
0.0625400469,
-0.0437399857,
-0.0112474114,
0.0012937153,
-0.033595141,
0.1163469255,
0.0380809344,
-0.0309271198,
0.0599018522,
-0.0654288381,
-0.0324983671,
0.0463057309,
0.0517233647,
0.0040053311,
-0.0172413234,
-0.0201139934,
-0.0018733802,
0.0521170869,
-0.0252460819,
0.0074011483,
0.0149877304,
0.0416450612,
0.0155267734,
0.0509275682,
-0.0683698282,
0.0624890774,
0.0407480262,
-0.0083940802,
0.0051890486,
0.0395064801,
-0.0215620399,
0.0645393431,
0.00409918,
0.0098967375,
-0.0285842903,
0.0242843535,
-0.0468830355,
0.0045492556,
0.0313712545,
-0.0022665567,
0.0120257512,
-0.0210185852,
-0.0523788743,
-0.0068472363,
0.0323947482,
0.0437365249,
-0.0123690777,
-0.0481351577,
0.0182180628,
-0.0170217846,
0.0013287215,
-0.0584832244,
0.0158643704,
-0.0517832525,
0.0833970532,
0.0135265794,
0.0476282611,
-0.0215912517,
-0.0552296303,
0.0336587206,
-0.0764170364,
-0.0148739461,
-0.0262516588,
0.0223053638,
0.0221778676,
0.0607916005,
-0.0234155338,
-0.048061274,
0.0149292322,
-0.0540458187,
-0.0223946925,
0.0211755875,
0.0096042994,
0.0104259299,
-0.0314906873,
-0.0119373407,
-0.0241471753,
-0.0046616858,
-0.0291051362,
0.0426596366,
-0.0049896897,
0.0429094844,
-0.0227237605,
0.0254059415,
-0.0145475948,
-0.0356106497,
-0.0480001345,
0.010003712,
0.0808773413,
0.0064329631,
-0.0597634763,
0.0577797405,
-0.0187387317,
0.0100743026,
0.0105325626,
0.0175519884,
0.0295573901,
0.0133374678,
0.003536521,
0.0125143053,
0.0088587627,
0.0504982919,
0.006322707,
-0.0039171265,
0.0176207032,
-0.004356354,
-0.0235280041,
0.0440706201,
-0.0160479676,
-0.0576522723,
0.0287717581,
-0.0320070907,
0.0236155,
-0.0171969719,
-0.0460431054,
0.0036118149,
-0.079387784,
0.0146307852,
-0.0718527138,
-0.0292567126,
-0.0114695737,
0.0524793044,
0.0521702915,
0.0067118253,
0.0082284063,
0.0072723301,
0.0505747423,
-0.0829960853,
-0.0663539171,
-0.0357291102,
0.0513659902,
-0.0020376425,
0.0110359434,
-0.0042659589,
-0.0178886764,
0.0217527226,
-0.0429949388,
-0.0243105274,
-0.0176394265,
-0.0058399132,
-0.0001985497,
0.0079486053,
-0.0064454656,
0.0091666616,
-0.0481299981,
-0.0787930042,
-0.0122295674,
0.0035987822,
0.0321775079,
0.0062767318,
-0.0757684484,
-0.013274163,
0.0196804367,
-0.029476352,
0.0404249579,
-0.0465560108,
0.0226906668,
0.0014844632,
0.019009551,
0.0040645753,
0.0130528258,
-0.001150754,
-0.0216914807,
0.0539000891,
0.006908298,
-0.0230322909,
0.0203630831,
-0.024189692,
-0.0311234389,
-0.0643477812,
0.0339639932,
0.0023689233,
-0.0047533163,
-0.0185926259,
0.0445397608,
0.0423432849,
0.052694276,
-0.044543758,
0.0028782866,
0.0151538672,
-0.0393872708,
0.0237170719,
0.0545848906,
-0.0124899596,
0.0083355485,
-0.046518039,
0.0262939502,
-0.0556524098,
-0.0537455529,
0.0010581329,
-0.0836086646,
0.0254933964,
-0.0440690331,
0.0196808241,
-0.0236050077,
0.0059602493,
-0.0095435912,
-0.023214845,
-0.0405689068,
-0.0295617376,
-0.0351101123,
-0.0032890618,
0.0268097334,
-0.0649227276,
-0.0187320709,
0.042779956,
-0.0144901099,
-0.0633490309,
0.0372661576,
0.0878833756,
-0.0271961689,
-0.0181554053,
-0.0174887218,
0.0076781553,
0.0375370495,
0.0229676459,
0.081555821,
-0.0205764286,
-0.0215236079,
-0.0725829527,
-0.0179909077,
-0.0215404108,
0.0100616356,
0.045855321,
0.0644220412,
-0.0206067692,
0.0288888533,
-0.0270732474,
0.0310494341,
-0.0104615008,
0.0302508473,
-0.0507283099,
-0.0796262845,
0.0044862372,
-0.027440317,
0.0532796569,
-0.0095688971,
-0.0561291017,
0.0286799148,
-0.0387874693,
0.0162778627,
-0.0272837337,
-0.0956212282,
0.0505046435,
0.0071649421,
0.0186436884,
-0.0082894592,
0.0167349875,
-0.0086967107,
-0.0133973584,
-0.0200828556,
-0.0113511775,
0.0809697062,
0.0227590855,
-0.0443738103,
-0.0408659913,
0.0413762257,
-0.0360675678,
-0.0255382117,
-0.0418479107,
-0.021525301,
-0.0427991264,
-0.0284682661,
0.0114337914,
-0.0143504553,
0.0097331796,
-0.0346022919,
0.0250851456,
0.0260765515,
-0.0896341205,
0.0316921175,
-0.0635661036,
0.0720751584,
-0.0282162577,
-0.0219213571,
0.0018304402,
0.004609229,
-0.013629552,
-0.0499079749,
-0.0048790984,
-0.014461942,
-0.0254809801,
-0.0143424347,
-0.0638342872,
0.0100440364,
-0.004946772,
-0.0420807973,
-0.021180816,
-0.0236131903,
-0.0269637909,
0.0006870875,
-0.0413745157,
-0.0053480179,
0.0261945408,
-0.0133647891,
0.0003906755,
-0.0541598089,
0.0047263056,
-0.026597254,
0.0601807982,
0.0304843914,
0.0572306514,
-0.0124942167,
-0.0151044456,
0.0011567444,
-0.0471784808,
-0.038142167,
0.0474362001,
0.0180885736,
0.0449751057,
-0.0011213756,
-0.008200584,
0.0247279387,
0.0018282072,
-0.0203784686,
-0.0414277501,
0.0196972042,
-0.0362158418,
-0.0086736586,
-0.0161901787,
0.0298737716,
-0.0089793121,
-0.003684948,
0.0416800044,
-0.0280923396,
0.0281988885,
0.011653455,
0.0212697461,
-0.0153379841,
-0.0306544583,
-0.0112118935,
-0.0087035988,
0.0357931294,
0.0081839841,
-0.0469353087,
-0.0444400497,
-0.0295192525,
-0.0121613117,
0.0457765311,
0.0657619908,
-0.0110676065,
-0.0002910027,
-0.1092166305,
-0.0208752863,
0.007805292,
-0.0303855669,
0.0239409097,
-0.0194500294,
0.0219010841,
0.0143636502,
0.0149272447,
0.0095607787,
-0.0834776238,
0.0355590545,
-0.038614314,
0.0483808033,
-0.0245431662,
-5.419635439e-33,
-0.0159280431,
-0.0687669143,
0.0350357667,
-0.0012133799,
-0.0001939643,
-0.0042008455,
0.049607493,
-0.0238336138,
-0.0345977955,
-0.019011518,
-0.0068256259,
0.0288983528,
-0.0173275489,
0.0070007839,
0.0209682565,
0.0377015993,
0.0064171953,
-0.0337674879,
-0.00369206,
-0.0273064431,
0.0294272359,
0.0226509403,
0.0561811253,
-0.0512655079,
0.048609063,
0.0142442007,
-0.0248867106,
0.0249604397,
0.0624838844,
-0.0091861514,
-0.0360983759,
0.007543541,
0.031777136,
-0.0276060253,
0.0311022811,
0.0734124184,
0.0053113638,
-0.0505804494,
0.0121673513,
0.0215782318,
0.0210211277,
0.0176435057,
0.0033014903,
0.0098611917,
-0.0136591066,
-0.006229206,
0.0783318579,
0.0270973947,
0.0165202506,
0.0273244511,
-0.0364642143,
0.0535156503,
-0.0638318807,
0.0518074706,
0.0011137071,
0.0314510539,
-0.0093783187,
0.0258617271,
-0.1235760897,
-0.0120738456,
-0.0032221188,
-0.039344199,
-0.014596004,
-0.0362683609,
-0.0154945627,
0.0720832497,
0.0339266174,
0.0078608384,
-0.0114943329,
-0.0024578299,
-0.0049646152,
0.0426865816,
0.0195601787,
0.0101322373,
0.0086062364,
-0.0489168353,
-0.0417846702,
0.0099804346,
0.0165236965,
-0.0110036088,
0.0247861948,
-0.0037125943,
-0.0733878091,
-0.0283825137,
0.0272346567,
-0.0022874982,
-0.0039267722,
-0.0248940215,
0.0007408738,
-0.0032013995,
0.0180942807,
0.0407910533,
-0.0219758581,
-0.0022829289,
0.0052891443,
0.0250887126,
-0.0498777293,
-0.0132317776,
-0.0004942564,
-0.0398683548,
-0.1087417975,
0.0182894524,
-0.013001712,
0.0265933294,
0.0363305286,
0.0053831004,
-0.0032186683,
-0.0156612918,
-0.0770731717,
-0.0029873252,
0.0161540173,
0.0509327538,
-0.0171320103,
-0.0212521404,
0.0232536215,
0.0221953541,
0.0098737767,
0.0651317239,
0.0280651674,
0.0000429146,
0.0160588287,
-0.0078041181,
0.0603516363,
-0.0277101807,
0.0041363654,
-0.0339590497,
0.0313314013,
0.0412002355,
0.0623581298,
-0.0150441183,
0.0055655125,
-0.0357654244,
2.212e-7,
0.0745047703,
0.0389995538,
-0.0259657707,
-0.0322187543,
0.0195955001,
0.0348599292,
0.0324700996,
0.0146439904,
0.0234623086,
0.0489152707,
0.0352282487,
-0.022153642,
0.0284771603,
0.0537401736,
-0.0492136851,
-0.0367539227,
-0.0097165853,
-0.0983317345,
-0.0540257171,
0.0278343502,
0.0824911892,
0.05017028,
0.073848635,
-0.0164748821,
-0.0491578132,
-0.0230751913,
0.0376897901,
0.0245516021,
-0.0161065888,
0.0164310765,
0.0090260245,
0.0014763377,
-0.0309142638,
0.0641949549,
-0.0325438194,
0.0741558373,
0.0697546154,
0.0235910229,
-0.0710010976,
0.0293429084,
0.029897593,
-0.0470197089,
-0.0386988893,
-0.0068424661,
0.0378315784,
0.028009342,
-0.0360204056,
-0.021569144,
0.0064617242,
0.000234379,
0.0248448197,
0.0507865697,
-0.0215905923,
0.0133200837,
-0.0014907349,
-0.0238691047,
-0.0416495278,
-0.0391346924,
0.0401714705,
-0.0007164905,
-0.014229482,
-0.050823234,
0.0277911592,
0.0530445613,
0.0098860096,
-0.0086679636,
0.0474014953,
1.362461434e-34,
-0.0071808244,
0.0225726794,
-0.04163903,
-0.0005799743,
0.0608937666,
0.0571988486,
0.0150808003,
0.008778844,
0.0194310155,
-0.0285272412,
0.0149222966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07765v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07765v1
|
TANQ: An open domain dataset of table answered questions
| 2024-05-13T14:07:20 | 2024-05-13T14:07:20 |
Mubashara Akhtar, Chenxi Pang, Andreea Marzoca, Yasemin Altun, Julian Martin Eisenschlos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models, potentially augmented with tool usage such as retrieval are
becoming the go-to means of answering questions. Understanding and answering
questions in real-world settings often requires retrieving information from
different sources, processing and aggregating data to extract insights, and
presenting complex findings in form of structured artifacts such as novel
tables, charts, or infographics. In this paper, we introduce TANQ, the first
open domain question answering dataset where the answers require building
tables from information across multiple sources. We release the full source
attribution for every cell in the resulting table and benchmark
state-of-the-art language models in open, oracle, and closed book setups. Our
best-performing baseline, GPT4 reaches an overall F1 score of 29.1, lagging
behind human performance by 19.7 points. We analyse baselines' performance
across different dataset attributes such as different skills required for this
task, including multi-hop reasoning, math operations, and unit conversions. We
further discuss common failures in model-generated answers, suggesting that
TANQ is a complex task with many challenges ahead.
|
TANQ: An open domain dataset of table answered questions: Language models, potentially augmented with tool usage such as retrieval are
becoming the go-to means of answering questions. Understanding and answering
questions in real-world settings often requires retrieving information from
different sources, processing and aggregating data to extract insights, and
presenting complex findings in form of structured artifacts such as novel
tables, charts, or infographics. In this paper, we introduce TANQ, the first
open domain question answering dataset where the answers require building
tables from information across multiple sources. We release the full source
attribution for every cell in the resulting table and benchmark
state-of-the-art language models in open, oracle, and closed book setups. Our
best-performing baseline, GPT4 reaches an overall F1 score of 29.1, lagging
behind human performance by 19.7 points. We analyse baselines' performance
across different dataset attributes such as different skills required for this
task, including multi-hop reasoning, math operations, and unit conversions. We
further discuss common failures in model-generated answers, suggesting that
TANQ is a complex task with many challenges ahead.
|
[
0.0183078088,
0.0708309934,
-0.0101075117,
0.0272203386,
-0.0176165588,
0.0238131788,
-0.0121152457,
-0.0025509251,
-0.010356918,
-0.0094282078,
-0.0370088667,
0.0012980606,
-0.0311033316,
0.0438054428,
0.0367229767,
0.0038710544,
0.0239220597,
0.0002324844,
-0.0117501412,
0.0124223707,
-0.0096335076,
0.021143388,
-0.0233619902,
0.0212472603,
-0.0105865588,
-0.0399226435,
-0.0090795206,
-0.0263998751,
-0.0280412957,
0.0103351083,
0.0022507566,
0.0781145543,
0.0183917917,
0.0381218493,
0.0000017902,
-0.004761403,
-0.0173422135,
-0.0048955856,
-0.0403434224,
-0.0213614758,
0.0024975883,
-0.003161439,
0.044875551,
0.0270734113,
-0.0843219683,
-0.0336697362,
0.0090402532,
0.0459710881,
0.080009833,
0.0391770303,
0.0057933168,
-0.0266624056,
0.0072583798,
0.0013807146,
0.049996946,
-0.0480500571,
-0.0026376094,
0.0633107424,
0.0228355378,
-0.0089025684,
0.013355881,
0.0405409709,
0.0458406582,
-0.0120795239,
-0.0187902655,
0.0240608659,
-0.0423189998,
0.0477901883,
0.0217030998,
0.1137917042,
0.0300512686,
-0.0156579483,
-0.0140807889,
0.0122951902,
0.0316331722,
0.0099335751,
-0.078608714,
0.005619423,
-0.0140178166,
-0.0290680937,
-0.0140024358,
-0.0226818509,
-0.0041447286,
-0.01100122,
-0.0172295496,
0.0640317053,
-0.0062602689,
-0.0214645714,
-0.009871074,
-0.0042161057,
-0.0330084711,
-0.0354675129,
0.0040655518,
0.0484257936,
-0.0337692872,
0.0291095376,
-0.0144248949,
-0.0163275152,
0.0231174026,
-0.0403758399,
0.0292439628,
0.0391680747,
-0.007560668,
0.0583411269,
-0.0248539597,
0.0234351028,
-0.0268818736,
0.0259431545,
-0.0416164845,
-0.0378073677,
-0.0701149479,
-0.0247448776,
-0.038679719,
0.0294288732,
-0.0749676153,
-0.0008162242,
0.0174744632,
0.0169747472,
0.0012614283,
-0.0009601497,
0.0387915187,
0.0506575219,
-0.0113667119,
0.0075332089,
-0.0545884632,
0.0203430429,
-0.0549411513,
0.0150500191,
0.0048367525,
-0.0992566496,
-0.0273507293,
-0.0186327379,
0.0030261867,
-0.0367377475,
0.0322455727,
0.0844438449,
-0.015230244,
0.022707833,
-0.0224752817,
-0.0465862155,
-0.0019290687,
-0.058222197,
0.0035606225,
-0.0574631579,
0.0580182038,
0.0446485095,
-0.0275238696,
-0.060078375,
0.0045121689,
0.0771073401,
-0.0126129072,
0.0358531699,
0.0000669448,
0.004780692,
0.033008337,
-0.0050150868,
-0.0221562032,
0.088858895,
0.0396995917,
0.0050902236,
0.0153078921,
-0.007961642,
-0.0003700686,
0.0223990008,
0.0494321175,
0.0139291435,
-0.0053106453,
0.0915606767,
0.0061243428,
0.0332744829,
-0.0099957185,
0.0346010663,
-0.0136531927,
-0.011834451,
0.0328842737,
0.0379821882,
-0.0020584979,
0.0547338836,
0.001929293,
-0.0158180036,
0.048598446,
-0.018188348,
-0.0204171296,
0.061104726,
0.0090039996,
0.0133112362,
0.0223550312,
0.0137446122,
-0.0295718499,
-0.0374082848,
-0.0069282521,
0.0297934599,
-0.0386822969,
0.0365038924,
0.0312587097,
0.026776636,
-0.0447773486,
0.0425089449,
-0.0146114836,
-0.0664438978,
-0.0105244732,
-0.0205740146,
0.048821006,
0.0126937181,
0.0553761385,
-0.0541595295,
-0.0184511915,
-0.0267984308,
0.0361729935,
0.0157487784,
0.0338099077,
-0.040132124,
-0.0082498239,
0.0049436809,
-0.0101365084,
-0.0039146678,
0.0112207048,
-0.0140058799,
0.0270917397,
-0.0007073024,
-0.0115901306,
-0.0720287934,
-0.0263085887,
0.0249828324,
0.0008331132,
-0.0296660028,
-0.001373171,
-0.0146203246,
0.0025567552,
0.0445329137,
0.0072166822,
0.0555239469,
0.0370485485,
-0.0212344173,
-0.0205147099,
-0.0126918918,
-0.0112388562,
-0.0027292145,
0.0570452139,
-0.0101649947,
-0.0453201085,
0.028225936,
-0.0399040915,
-0.0699908733,
0.0270490441,
-0.0250249244,
-0.0195405874,
-0.0376211442,
-0.0328531601,
0.0237259082,
-0.0040756837,
-0.0207788255,
0.0890857279,
0.0062501109,
0.0549987741,
0.0046803677,
-0.051896777,
0.0552450344,
-0.0366200916,
0.0490733907,
-0.0233575143,
-0.0169906504,
0.0366005078,
-0.0004408979,
0.0165534057,
-0.0811566934,
0.0065807546,
-0.0688663498,
0.0328824483,
-0.0318694152,
0.0289254654,
0.0433641784,
0.0048778267,
-0.0116805155,
-0.0274044815,
-0.0864170417,
-0.0208783858,
0.0254556537,
0.0130864158,
0.060377609,
0.0129807107,
0.026980076,
-0.0349927172,
-0.0261397734,
-0.0351516381,
0.0431430787,
-0.0133809643,
0.0240275394,
0.0030174886,
-0.0229880232,
-0.0376812406,
0.0326627083,
0.0168831497,
0.0163906403,
0.0097186361,
-0.036554303,
0.0199962705,
0.0558337979,
-0.0210462753,
-0.0019074344,
-0.0012492146,
-0.0037950615,
-0.0474833474,
0.0289662443,
-0.0029056172,
0.0010816515,
0.0157008376,
-0.0432419963,
0.0089094732,
0.0377830863,
0.0069600525,
-0.0021385781,
-0.0388462245,
0.041726768,
0.0131279919,
-0.0047434741,
-0.0969601497,
0.0468461104,
0.0100022685,
0.0405493043,
-0.026841348,
0.0057571251,
0.0282143205,
-0.0270870514,
0.006613424,
-0.0321538858,
0.0193632618,
-0.0709480569,
0.0766837895,
-0.0193555504,
0.0028645296,
-0.0300612971,
-0.0153965903,
-0.0601827018,
-0.0019100356,
0.0012123224,
-0.0541683324,
0.0797541738,
-0.0409914888,
-0.0004624164,
-0.0193690266,
-0.0359195434,
-0.0216182433,
-0.0339277796,
-0.028008813,
0.0309972074,
0.0051739947,
-0.0273998864,
-0.0225354992,
-0.0330436304,
0.0451323502,
0.0032587987,
-0.0354729258,
-0.0200907793,
-0.0173276532,
0.0668394938,
0.0771373361,
0.0288766157,
0.0129035683,
-0.0224057995,
0.0112961503,
0.0581786036,
0.0533460937,
-0.0027602268,
0.0127522247,
0.0127272671,
0.0146409301,
-0.0268668626,
0.0000582949,
0.0168039296,
0.0011228403,
-0.0466938317,
-0.0213814527,
0.085232161,
0.0394543186,
0.0017546227,
-0.0263435245,
-0.0364285,
0.0220750049,
0.027342964,
0.0593342632,
-0.1348883808,
-0.0248107817,
-0.021478584,
-0.0004234431,
0.0318281539,
-0.0497716554,
-0.010155105,
-0.117079787,
0.0183628052,
-0.0407844111,
-0.0720367432,
-0.0638777688,
-0.0400717668,
-0.0117269326,
-0.0301735364,
-0.0032777709,
0.0505329259,
-0.0085745752,
0.0447427183,
0.023440443,
0.004890759,
0.0111448178,
0.0451373868,
-0.0327905118,
0.004991387,
0.0416240357,
0.0199741758,
-0.0167953987,
-0.0347906724,
-0.0153773222,
-0.0323051028,
-0.0173948463,
0.0087413788,
0.0612114109,
0.0031970523,
-0.0028717818,
-0.0176022388,
0.0216977894,
-0.0851104259,
0.0210775882,
0.0356937982,
0.0855232924,
-0.0070064147,
0.0268903375,
-0.0051985742,
-0.0198156219,
-0.0038705277,
0.0917550474,
0.0336487181,
0.0025296174,
-0.0669956282,
-0.0378519371,
-0.0399194174,
-0.0828201994,
-0.0083772903,
0.0408993475,
0.022010522,
-0.0036391011,
-0.0592787601,
-0.0396670662,
0.0694819838,
0.0511256568,
-0.0073113623,
0.0315408409,
-0.031393934,
0.0066587771,
-0.0381854139,
0.012489683,
-0.0564841554,
0.0154447649,
-0.0353093334,
-0.0088602491,
0.0042393734,
-0.0362616777,
-0.0355631933,
0.0213403162,
-0.0604246855,
-0.0123637123,
-0.0042651077,
0.0189443715,
0.0255450271,
-0.0279269423,
-0.0105705103,
-0.0007507593,
-0.0150918895,
-0.0046649626,
-0.0990175679,
-0.0310546067,
-0.0052028517,
-0.0287730079,
-0.0004286152,
0.049517747,
-0.0496381894,
-0.0031329764,
-0.0040067602,
0.0403630547,
-0.0101402337,
0.0012264063,
0.0522785708,
0.0028780252,
-0.0059758574,
0.0631418973,
-0.0404447615,
-0.0123615032,
0.0254589114,
-0.0460926406,
-0.0149664422,
-0.0170569681,
0.0078091458,
0.017254835,
-0.0358411968,
-0.005623823,
0.0003299427,
0.0047170571,
0.0520605855,
-0.0523047261,
-0.0230708718,
0.0547652952,
0.0005983823,
-0.0008372365,
-0.0379700325,
-0.0301739704,
-0.0313072167,
0.0015220891,
0.0479965322,
-0.0064230235,
0.0397069231,
0.0179082882,
-0.0249045417,
0.0011647361,
0.023120949,
-0.0930188447,
-0.0820365548,
0.0064211455,
-0.0005430916,
0.0280051455,
0.0171851646,
0.0205411222,
-0.0004050184,
-0.030198561,
0.0149151161,
-0.0026991817,
0.0335256495,
0.0152285937,
0.0468815193,
0.0310747232,
-0.0194251593,
-0.0369930975,
0.0932045728,
0.0204517581,
0.0242773201,
0.0012682631,
-0.0245991275,
-0.0273191724,
-0.0101774642,
-0.0262562931,
-0.009902793,
0.0030584252,
-0.001916995,
-0.0486942306,
-0.0610420033,
-0.0046130028,
0.0601913258,
-0.0237255637,
0.0071767056,
0.0331815071,
0.0797063783,
0.0524660908,
-0.0423529968,
-0.0649755821,
0.0470715649,
-0.0351329856,
-0.0341096893,
-0.0137956748,
-5.728946574e-33,
-0.0226003788,
-0.0015042406,
0.0442242101,
-0.0187241901,
0.0293222703,
-0.0248531774,
-0.031583257,
-0.0050853123,
-0.0534951091,
0.0013403047,
-0.0424746759,
0.0634974018,
0.0103383297,
0.0218953565,
0.0215050932,
-0.0671573952,
0.0016219565,
-0.0303991139,
-0.0050628553,
0.0273648016,
0.0514120981,
0.0094045149,
0.0179538112,
-0.0304606333,
0.0334215835,
-0.0218707733,
0.0115952855,
0.0251220781,
-0.0136196762,
0.0549434982,
-0.0203236993,
0.0286514163,
0.0327361301,
-0.0638652295,
-0.0281780008,
-0.0041337586,
-0.1277301162,
-0.0383940972,
0.0111228237,
-0.0031450512,
-0.0660010427,
-0.0149659133,
0.0216754079,
0.0025742238,
0.016036544,
-0.0407661013,
0.0271306857,
-0.0262747351,
-0.0006608492,
0.001454639,
-0.0015460073,
0.0048495596,
-0.0155673968,
0.011745912,
-0.0005613224,
0.0828212798,
0.0042026541,
-0.0143127758,
-0.03584316,
0.0195263214,
0.0082661007,
0.028027894,
0.0506360158,
-0.0182260536,
0.0309959371,
0.0094838068,
0.0302160736,
-0.0015083728,
-0.0307743307,
0.0018060233,
-0.0628767237,
0.0587837845,
0.0846675932,
0.0269635618,
0.0150767229,
0.0144081898,
-0.0875432566,
0.0646109879,
-0.0074778032,
0.0120022958,
-0.023440918,
-0.0250187498,
-0.0162442867,
0.001452181,
-0.0296691526,
0.0262083597,
-0.0387529433,
-0.031143792,
0.0326337479,
-0.0368024632,
0.0288156345,
-0.0162650701,
0.0347926505,
-0.0123569528,
-0.0072890474,
0.0619905442,
-0.0062810909,
0.011666486,
0.0303407609,
0.0428170413,
-0.0434121899,
0.0283493605,
0.0090307454,
-0.0023717554,
0.0187416337,
0.0404018871,
0.0369170234,
0.0048054974,
-0.0709966943,
-0.0109494254,
-0.0539164953,
0.0403141305,
-0.0129622472,
0.0036877759,
0.0021740112,
0.0218096748,
0.0194214024,
0.0358828492,
0.0011495434,
-0.0149379224,
-0.031328205,
-0.0120020853,
0.0067129373,
-0.0285958964,
0.0158937983,
0.0091409096,
-0.0404962823,
0.0333554968,
0.0078816321,
-0.0385592282,
0.0071056513,
0.0323985554,
2.354e-7,
0.0971984863,
-0.0144774001,
0.0485624559,
0.0771073848,
-0.0159055367,
-0.0019005068,
-0.0121847922,
0.0238984935,
0.0178012084,
-0.0181150511,
0.000158204,
0.0087269451,
0.0339791067,
0.0571124777,
-0.06567619,
-0.0414005592,
-0.072835587,
-0.0087318029,
-0.0411630049,
-0.0090671517,
0.0507534407,
0.0696335584,
-0.0428344943,
-0.0092386892,
-0.0221869536,
-0.0331918485,
0.0477279127,
-0.0287486706,
0.0144847948,
0.015793588,
0.044305604,
-0.0101497658,
0.0297997352,
0.0334747881,
-0.0221473053,
-0.0135845253,
0.0229411572,
0.0328555554,
0.0178359058,
-0.0251522381,
-0.022318963,
-0.0806755051,
0.0501952209,
-0.0685661435,
0.1028295904,
-0.0255433992,
-0.0160474312,
0.0568832308,
-0.0096117873,
0.0005495698,
-0.0013100334,
-0.0022667707,
-0.0003550331,
0.0005348122,
0.0141935823,
0.0067791562,
0.0351664759,
-0.0343997777,
-0.0298994668,
0.0400026441,
-0.0307049546,
-0.0201351084,
-0.0122842407,
-0.0301997233,
-0.0090452814,
-0.0190927405,
-0.0196660403,
2.179334384e-34,
0.0266337413,
0.0154461972,
0.0452650487,
0.0361894518,
0.0670212582,
-0.0564890727,
0.0099189989,
-0.0179838501,
0.0195869561,
-0.0995635539,
-0.0316425785
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07764v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07764v1
|
LGDE: Local Graph-based Dictionary Expansion
| 2024-05-13T14:07:15 | 2024-05-13T14:07:15 |
Dominik J. Schindler, Sneha Jha, Xixuan Zhang, Kilian Buehling, Annett Heft, Mauricio Barahona
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI, physics.soc-ph
|
Expanding a dictionary of pre-selected keywords is crucial for tasks in
information retrieval, such as database query and online data collection. Here
we propose Local Graph-based Dictionary Expansion (LGDE), a method that uses
tools from manifold learning and network science for the data-driven discovery
of keywords starting from a seed dictionary. At the heart of LGDE lies the
creation of a word similarity graph derived from word embeddings and the
application of local community detection based on graph diffusion to discover
semantic neighbourhoods of pre-defined seed keywords. The diffusion in the
local graph manifold allows the exploration of the complex nonlinear geometry
of word embeddings and can capture word similarities based on paths of semantic
association. We validate our method on a corpus of hate speech-related posts
from Reddit and Gab and show that LGDE enriches the list of keywords and
achieves significantly better performance than threshold methods based on
direct word similarities. We further demonstrate the potential of our method
through a real-world use case from communication science, where LGDE is
evaluated quantitatively on data collected and analysed by domain experts by
expanding a conspiracy-related dictionary.
|
LGDE: Local Graph-based Dictionary Expansion: Expanding a dictionary of pre-selected keywords is crucial for tasks in
information retrieval, such as database query and online data collection. Here
we propose Local Graph-based Dictionary Expansion (LGDE), a method that uses
tools from manifold learning and network science for the data-driven discovery
of keywords starting from a seed dictionary. At the heart of LGDE lies the
creation of a word similarity graph derived from word embeddings and the
application of local community detection based on graph diffusion to discover
semantic neighbourhoods of pre-defined seed keywords. The diffusion in the
local graph manifold allows the exploration of the complex nonlinear geometry
of word embeddings and can capture word similarities based on paths of semantic
association. We validate our method on a corpus of hate speech-related posts
from Reddit and Gab and show that LGDE enriches the list of keywords and
achieves significantly better performance than threshold methods based on
direct word similarities. We further demonstrate the potential of our method
through a real-world use case from communication science, where LGDE is
evaluated quantitatively on data collected and analysed by domain experts by
expanding a conspiracy-related dictionary.
|
[
0.0186174009,
0.0427577645,
-0.0121224849,
0.0428900346,
-0.0311109256,
-0.0058446382,
-0.0148798907,
0.0216038264,
0.0715759397,
-0.0148660261,
0.0134628238,
-0.0150370402,
-0.0271315984,
0.0337233506,
0.0389455855,
-0.0059072627,
0.0442767516,
0.0387994796,
-0.0315567888,
-0.0263221506,
0.0179541856,
0.0307215191,
0.0068982486,
0.0075723301,
-0.0256283227,
0.0329978913,
0.0308661014,
-0.0000474415,
0.0299349632,
0.0012123508,
-0.0059895981,
0.0295924861,
0.0366889909,
0.0582368672,
0.0000018236,
-0.0510185845,
-0.026157409,
-0.0091086244,
0.0303061847,
-0.047829058,
0.0531589352,
-0.0146416239,
0.054455746,
0.0139299454,
-0.033095289,
-0.0491274111,
0.0425158106,
-0.0163204949,
0.0210611783,
0.0581435896,
-0.0355575792,
-0.0690674037,
-0.0252677798,
0.0053312727,
-0.0177644938,
-0.0039913771,
0.0553678945,
0.0029805044,
0.018831471,
-0.0262308698,
-0.0384250619,
-0.0004388257,
-0.0573213957,
-0.0085408613,
0.1081114411,
0.0274887402,
0.0099013578,
-0.0348066725,
0.0239806343,
0.0854938477,
-0.0224002134,
-0.0251002945,
0.0487524569,
0.0078037642,
-0.0289127734,
0.1034202725,
-0.0256478265,
-0.0307274889,
-0.0460298285,
0.0238783918,
-0.0038727305,
-0.0510925539,
0.0699265376,
0.0167003833,
-0.0231480245,
0.0716511905,
0.006461971,
-0.0041762711,
0.0115196081,
-0.0352407359,
-0.0221862979,
0.0017218364,
0.0367549993,
-0.0060569998,
0.0121328784,
0.0254214071,
-0.0018706404,
-0.0213546772,
0.0077058407,
-0.0700628012,
0.0234575905,
-0.0285974387,
0.044571951,
0.0701461062,
0.0097514801,
-0.0227078423,
-0.0549953058,
0.0513599068,
-0.0589694194,
-0.0144100869,
-0.0465994067,
0.01288551,
0.0065085646,
0.0051896446,
0.0007079953,
-0.030958036,
-0.0025825158,
0.0357897431,
-0.0189782251,
-0.0183453467,
-0.0253657494,
0.0535132438,
0.0661042407,
-0.0110744871,
0.0008530134,
-0.0366666652,
-0.0492745675,
0.0354727097,
-0.0562827513,
0.0382294357,
-0.0049173706,
0.0029097782,
0.0695503056,
-0.0111120464,
-0.0110664135,
0.007789298,
0.0454081446,
-0.0225267876,
0.0110386573,
-0.017678868,
-0.0312827341,
0.0099006668,
0.0353568196,
-0.0862230361,
0.007443516,
0.0070393886,
-0.0184903294,
-0.0471587852,
-0.0124825332,
0.0116876811,
-0.0824507773,
0.0499484427,
-0.0332670324,
0.0163340662,
0.0643712431,
0.0015033312,
0.0253609344,
0.0023611418,
-0.0195631888,
0.0533044152,
0.0722852945,
0.0112139527,
-0.032140933,
0.0106421914,
0.036474131,
0.0044131596,
-0.0275431499,
-0.0131867724,
-0.0174539071,
0.0106222592,
-0.0121445619,
0.0441629589,
-0.0747255906,
-0.0721530616,
-0.0088783987,
0.0973729491,
-0.0155538619,
-0.0241799597,
-0.0140885832,
0.0346061178,
-0.0693393126,
-0.0206911173,
-0.0042219134,
-0.0205898844,
-0.0278796144,
-0.0387727283,
0.1108937785,
0.0148687353,
-0.0127023207,
0.030741429,
-0.0510059036,
-0.0027385184,
0.0784605965,
-0.0448004901,
0.0261250548,
0.0079968963,
-0.0118830167,
-0.0091938386,
0.0517060235,
-0.0162620526,
0.0081320303,
-0.0037917839,
0.0046533123,
0.0468599275,
0.0510731936,
-0.014340559,
-0.001680517,
0.0007301992,
0.0089000016,
0.0151653104,
-0.002476783,
-0.0254364219,
-0.062403284,
-0.0431847237,
-0.0315712318,
0.0176478997,
0.0159078874,
0.0192684345,
0.035727784,
0.0201612264,
-0.0063579534,
-0.0610207506,
-0.01488622,
0.0109642269,
0.0372689366,
0.0118978815,
0.0256837551,
-0.002057083,
0.0109006697,
0.0353195444,
-0.0303635001,
-0.0248221848,
0.0505563952,
-0.0348903239,
-0.0638213903,
-0.0190933868,
0.0341525748,
0.0205045063,
0.0446150973,
-0.0639255866,
0.0397297479,
0.0419672132,
0.0171578843,
-0.0041146833,
0.0887701884,
-0.0341920368,
0.0368396193,
-0.0255101975,
-0.0679855421,
-0.0521460697,
0.047453586,
-0.0364114828,
0.0390335098,
-0.019131301,
0.0202861186,
-0.0403743647,
0.006329881,
0.0248385463,
0.041737061,
-0.0604382679,
-0.0060580061,
0.0401616804,
0.0030020827,
0.0543767996,
-0.0514204726,
-0.0233056806,
-0.0042360476,
-0.0496816225,
-0.0158031825,
-0.0034762565,
-0.0164731033,
-0.0112874638,
-0.0058453688,
-0.0086653279,
0.0178269688,
0.0178803653,
0.0164863821,
0.0353143178,
0.0199608598,
0.0171703566,
-0.0463698059,
-0.0348912068,
-0.0282332413,
-0.0394848883,
-0.00403166,
0.0542104989,
-0.0060490975,
-0.06860248,
0.0609615035,
-0.0022388222,
-0.055612985,
-0.0015032325,
-0.0200151298,
-0.0040129302,
0.0059743193,
-0.0141069172,
0.027894048,
-0.0010239461,
0.0207510535,
0.0341765471,
0.0341731869,
0.0070476085,
-0.0184826124,
-0.0436471142,
-0.0682194829,
0.0125094885,
-0.0287200361,
-0.004744153,
-0.0275421366,
0.0070814034,
0.0707173347,
-0.0315214209,
-0.0394593626,
0.0207488239,
-0.0394307487,
-0.0041834842,
-0.0452639386,
-0.0373092853,
0.006857601,
0.0001304793,
-0.0150237055,
-0.0653524771,
0.0528856814,
0.0395379625,
0.0518052094,
0.0010593942,
-0.0406084359,
-0.0110651935,
0.0430334173,
0.0204035882,
0.0188789591,
-0.0261483304,
0.0057979622,
0.0319912247,
-0.0180050097,
0.0464309044,
-0.0318017043,
-0.0162079483,
-0.0180650055,
0.0296426266,
0.0498291925,
0.0178198181,
-0.0231878292,
-0.0625946,
-0.0030193306,
-0.0271347165,
0.0398613624,
-0.0599848032,
0.0507833362,
0.0049533476,
-0.0015905709,
-0.0104927346,
0.0224154573,
0.0029971043,
0.0234188456,
0.0168951508,
0.0146264601,
-0.0021826797,
0.0206062812,
0.0062080282,
-0.0185973197,
0.0258286744,
0.022179991,
-0.0279445145,
-0.0314368047,
-0.0173809081,
-0.021141842,
0.0071139797,
-0.0035396763,
-0.0317828991,
-0.012956406,
0.044001244,
-0.0078931833,
0.0738309771,
0.0450789891,
-0.0434813164,
-0.0109531032,
0.0380314365,
-0.0050663361,
0.0439815149,
-0.0248619672,
-0.0743967518,
0.0300897453,
-0.0288132951,
0.0233773701,
0.0142719671,
-0.0513698123,
0.0007663933,
-0.0362130888,
0.0170374494,
0.0093831271,
0.0032469004,
-0.0071671531,
-0.1163702831,
0.0170235001,
0.0078338096,
-0.055682309,
-0.0476430953,
0.0228752233,
-0.0024177337,
0.0243164822,
-0.0532271191,
-0.0436346345,
-0.0047578472,
-0.0309566148,
0.0161467995,
-0.0202242527,
0.0283419006,
-0.0139236497,
-0.0172903556,
-0.0137403971,
0.0310313441,
-0.0254579764,
-0.0542313196,
0.0401525013,
0.019129239,
0.0002237487,
0.0043013762,
0.0355547369,
-0.0403788835,
0.0014214823,
-0.0328406729,
0.0936234295,
0.0000678759,
-0.0357449166,
-0.0585331023,
-0.0024125718,
0.0022609169,
0.0008905596,
-0.0153684551,
0.0210506804,
0.0261364188,
0.0173487067,
0.0265199505,
0.0233831089,
-0.0562066063,
-0.029567983,
-0.0102555091,
-0.0160931759,
-0.0551348329,
0.0098565789,
0.0016864705,
0.045451358,
-0.0128774671,
0.0073542455,
0.0287674926,
-0.0496439822,
-0.0973552093,
-0.0099737989,
0.0127499616,
0.0023244917,
0.0562875755,
-0.0400926434,
0.0125820022,
0.0087816957,
-0.0526535437,
-0.0110914893,
-0.0656160414,
-0.0529311039,
0.0285460707,
-0.0285047386,
0.0025557256,
0.0388868302,
-0.0456605814,
-0.037613254,
0.0671800375,
0.0273102671,
0.0242318083,
0.0235653073,
-0.0001471061,
-0.0435993038,
0.0272668414,
0.0435764492,
-0.0188806374,
0.0171144996,
0.0238523483,
-0.0200292133,
-0.0614767373,
-0.0255305581,
-0.0136456657,
0.0299033653,
0.0543960184,
-0.0104771974,
-0.0292953681,
-0.0959339887,
-0.0536745936,
0.0014194751,
-0.0134452591,
0.0350444987,
-0.0328807198,
0.0385502689,
-0.0152070075,
-0.047539562,
0.005332991,
-0.0169742201,
0.0479169153,
-0.0318067931,
-0.0044206493,
0.0268908702,
0.0222027749,
0.0283176769,
0.0213115346,
-0.022219982,
0.0091998735,
-0.0320579,
-0.0219683871,
-0.0376749784,
-0.0124851875,
-0.0073727882,
-0.0326985903,
-0.0315242819,
0.0194990691,
-0.0483205579,
-0.0138778072,
-0.0134828705,
0.0263918228,
0.0252831075,
-0.0192083791,
0.0116881244,
-0.0070673856,
-0.0267329514,
-0.0208786298,
0.021601297,
-0.0384986363,
-0.0529236384,
0.0238906518,
0.0195739791,
-0.0289997347,
0.0694405884,
0.0261612982,
-0.0192334503,
0.0069816415,
0.0287297647,
-0.0534573235,
-0.0041554607,
-0.006925941,
0.0065617482,
0.0956033394,
0.0160499346,
0.0682073683,
-0.0531228855,
-0.0351972319,
0.0500728302,
-0.0079123471,
-0.033883322,
0.0304949153,
0.0502730496,
0.0755366683,
-0.0017509555,
0.0625267029,
-0.0403285064,
0.0434781387,
-0.0220409706,
-0.0616895743,
0.0405768156,
-6.49621892e-33,
0.0336075984,
-0.0638412908,
-0.0148985879,
0.0091584185,
-0.0192472003,
0.0168809835,
0.009761679,
-0.0082468837,
-0.0216758847,
0.0476991162,
0.000736664,
0.0375103056,
-0.015263618,
0.0014076707,
-0.0351520665,
-0.0098832743,
-0.0117984852,
0.015154426,
0.0334783047,
0.0204636585,
0.0560409427,
0.0327579863,
0.0462359637,
-0.0475798734,
0.0280199945,
-0.004003556,
0.0421028398,
0.0286671054,
0.0479693711,
0.0270767994,
-0.0257274583,
0.0764626339,
0.0079577416,
0.0080179758,
0.0080711842,
-0.0295282081,
-0.0120623177,
-0.0371883214,
-0.0035704575,
-0.0465369336,
0.0135116577,
0.0338509791,
0.0457531661,
0.0167750604,
-0.0214116219,
-0.0116918981,
0.0679296255,
0.0210399348,
-0.0588910319,
0.0160773676,
-0.0317096338,
0.0521036983,
-0.0327620767,
0.0106868073,
0.0068678623,
-0.0634660572,
0.0012858975,
0.0027953293,
-0.0329782255,
0.0576748848,
-0.0527618788,
-0.0146146482,
0.0021704738,
0.0033491643,
0.0339640155,
0.0992630422,
-0.0019380725,
0.015735805,
-0.0188062787,
0.0324883237,
0.0430159383,
0.0215879269,
-0.019953195,
0.0852417424,
-0.0078206686,
-0.062948674,
-0.0667801276,
-0.0069671851,
-0.0027949777,
-0.022481326,
0.029124124,
0.023132056,
-0.0402419195,
-0.0387240574,
-0.0096351393,
-0.0143918283,
-0.0260038301,
-0.0076561924,
-0.0418611318,
-0.008222972,
-0.0387062728,
-0.0151509102,
-0.0208773259,
-0.030481942,
-0.0127544506,
0.0607638322,
0.0075121536,
-0.0249821264,
0.0097145541,
0.0188202374,
-0.0452861413,
-0.0146453939,
-0.0428971536,
0.012301187,
0.0098859193,
-0.0044973777,
-0.0433178581,
0.008676054,
-0.0367268696,
0.0015517144,
-0.0046661976,
-0.0658980459,
-0.0543755926,
-0.0236050859,
0.0270151962,
0.0534603558,
-0.002363814,
0.0540618412,
0.0721689537,
0.0664420128,
0.0291642379,
0.0022772423,
-0.0232069492,
0.0070441961,
-0.0087521961,
-0.0134288939,
-0.0134157054,
0.0246981308,
0.0470040925,
-0.0825441107,
0.0186322127,
-0.0393837281,
2.747e-7,
0.0378093123,
0.0722683221,
0.0116312224,
-0.025582632,
0.0080287894,
-0.0103623606,
0.0405032486,
0.0398773216,
-0.0533298738,
-0.0465285368,
0.0136331432,
0.0725544393,
-0.0434984677,
0.0700833574,
-0.0364237688,
0.0568174645,
-0.0650341958,
0.0047367723,
-0.0357262976,
0.0096370568,
-0.0179282445,
0.0461818352,
0.0794683471,
-0.0018010986,
-0.0276688114,
-0.0420047902,
-0.0027616813,
-0.0167977195,
-0.0241029505,
-0.007068411,
-0.0115593616,
-0.0357695334,
0.0208110251,
-0.0187990814,
-0.0119797569,
0.0411534086,
0.0337793194,
-0.0295971073,
-0.0130035942,
0.0162472967,
-0.0197088644,
-0.039102979,
0.0129450206,
-0.0465133712,
0.057449121,
0.0041141491,
0.0069010644,
-0.0685522035,
-0.0053533907,
0.0340851992,
0.0845558718,
-0.0307349432,
-0.0302062668,
0.012496585,
0.0193169676,
0.0190496705,
0.0367569104,
-0.0999250636,
0.0533468761,
0.0420271717,
-0.0464313067,
-0.013504318,
0.0228980333,
-0.0142655596,
0.0297653116,
0.0894646496,
0.0268290602,
2.200771085e-34,
0.0196359362,
0.0154286064,
-0.0184403211,
-0.0407649875,
0.0346431918,
-0.0240835138,
-0.0445347577,
0.0006008633,
0.0460853837,
-0.0867650434,
0.0003973876
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07745v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07745v1
|
LlamaTurk: Adapting Open-Source Generative Large Language Models for Low-Resource Language
| 2024-05-13T13:41:59 | 2024-05-13T13:41:59 |
Cagri Toraman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite advancements in English-dominant generative large language models,
further development is needed for low-resource languages to enhance global
accessibility. The primary methods for representing these languages are
monolingual and multilingual pretraining. Monolingual pretraining is expensive
due to hardware requirements, and multilingual models often have uneven
performance across languages. This study explores an alternative solution by
adapting large language models, primarily trained on English, to low-resource
languages. We assess various strategies, including continual training,
instruction fine-tuning, task-specific fine-tuning, and vocabulary extension.
The results show that continual training improves language comprehension, as
reflected in perplexity scores, and task-specific tuning generally enhances
performance of downstream tasks. However, extending the vocabulary shows no
substantial benefits. Additionally, while larger models improve task
performance with few-shot tuning, multilingual models perform worse than their
monolingual counterparts when adapted.
|
LlamaTurk: Adapting Open-Source Generative Large Language Models for Low-Resource Language: Despite advancements in English-dominant generative large language models,
further development is needed for low-resource languages to enhance global
accessibility. The primary methods for representing these languages are
monolingual and multilingual pretraining. Monolingual pretraining is expensive
due to hardware requirements, and multilingual models often have uneven
performance across languages. This study explores an alternative solution by
adapting large language models, primarily trained on English, to low-resource
languages. We assess various strategies, including continual training,
instruction fine-tuning, task-specific fine-tuning, and vocabulary extension.
The results show that continual training improves language comprehension, as
reflected in perplexity scores, and task-specific tuning generally enhances
performance of downstream tasks. However, extending the vocabulary shows no
substantial benefits. Additionally, while larger models improve task
performance with few-shot tuning, multilingual models perform worse than their
monolingual counterparts when adapted.
|
[
0.002139437,
0.0616600625,
-0.013323456,
0.0279566217,
-0.0156869162,
0.0403884724,
0.053872399,
-0.0211619642,
-0.0208575241,
-0.0257808734,
-0.0542855263,
-0.0487155654,
0.0040281238,
-0.0044892719,
0.0387715809,
-0.0784400776,
0.0637636185,
-0.0767150298,
-0.0548987389,
-0.0326350667,
-0.0251533352,
0.0129391635,
-0.0293999631,
0.0278893132,
0.0272968188,
-0.0274649225,
-0.0035425737,
0.0035709178,
0.0172324218,
-0.020820925,
-0.0336748213,
0.0494758151,
0.0278584864,
0.0335294716,
0.0000020811,
-0.0555792674,
0.0267481916,
-0.0045035309,
-0.0048320796,
0.0539055802,
0.0771873817,
-0.0006354469,
-0.0358721726,
0.021428233,
0.0033068098,
-0.0565167442,
0.0813731328,
0.009977363,
0.016469596,
0.0408689827,
0.0021219582,
-0.0516148508,
0.0206465144,
-0.0404480621,
0.0217283554,
-0.0490160882,
-0.0053318711,
0.0427097864,
0.0182478148,
-0.0063827895,
-0.0348468795,
0.0487909503,
0.0482077673,
0.0069649783,
-0.0053284336,
0.0476421341,
-0.0054766713,
-0.0336964652,
-0.0036782559,
0.0461654402,
-0.0065726554,
-0.0225206763,
-0.0400460623,
0.0013509676,
-0.0112355538,
-0.0204700381,
-0.0425439775,
0.0300601199,
0.0282507613,
0.0097623225,
0.0280612353,
-0.0401540101,
0.0395925976,
0.0097077386,
-0.0246558152,
0.0144387102,
0.0557085983,
-0.0123036951,
-0.0039848303,
0.0114239389,
-0.0240196194,
-0.0336336046,
0.000753856,
0.0175408591,
-0.0263652485,
0.037132062,
-0.0354395844,
-0.0618300848,
0.0281473044,
-0.0386426598,
0.0548251569,
0.0584318377,
-0.0391205736,
0.0427936167,
-0.0301814098,
0.0324231535,
-0.009324464,
0.0116671016,
-0.0551529787,
0.009160609,
-0.0164361876,
-0.0096736131,
-0.050030008,
-0.0057987487,
-0.0652419627,
-0.0296602044,
-0.0299719181,
0.0177735835,
0.0573429093,
-0.0356844515,
0.0172305088,
-0.0092661418,
-0.0803298801,
-0.0116322124,
0.0146668833,
0.0578906313,
-0.0580103546,
0.0143024214,
0.0066935904,
-0.0802339837,
-0.0057366383,
0.0099875415,
-0.0005736057,
-0.0539642833,
0.0106484639,
0.045215372,
-0.0196871534,
-0.035920646,
-0.049263116,
0.0345198549,
-0.0097477846,
-0.0683537349,
0.0053694351,
-0.0549024493,
0.009738666,
0.0003110961,
0.0307802837,
-0.015906198,
-0.0039921789,
-0.0065519176,
0.0106062386,
0.0534608588,
-0.0162373465,
0.0191107821,
0.0229368228,
-0.0020998917,
0.047672987,
0.0927246585,
0.0156256706,
-0.0212838557,
0.0247255191,
-0.0408193879,
-0.0473092459,
0.0581629723,
-0.0136549259,
0.0245370679,
-0.0102127725,
-0.0133738555,
0.0198364165,
0.0361071639,
0.0634545013,
0.0171624422,
-0.029835619,
0.0344045572,
0.0651355013,
0.0479043387,
0.0303701404,
0.0220348015,
0.0366373882,
0.0072169579,
0.0110559855,
-0.0155705288,
-0.0366851054,
0.0087961378,
0.0138776619,
0.0328430273,
0.0218028259,
0.0771108419,
-0.0284519121,
-0.0407116525,
-0.0067918445,
-0.0104463175,
0.0139141958,
0.0341898315,
0.0979472846,
0.0246820115,
-0.0364888832,
0.0153696397,
0.0810959786,
-0.0580107309,
0.0230814852,
-0.0533054508,
0.0077760248,
0.0666929856,
0.0249398872,
0.0163886342,
-0.0287822951,
0.0143270381,
0.0286390707,
0.0610209666,
0.0384408012,
0.0196503457,
0.0490465574,
-0.0631682649,
0.0038021521,
-0.0021989541,
0.0232539903,
0.0543970838,
0.0136967478,
0.0248891655,
0.0129543561,
-0.0539051443,
-0.0514326096,
0.0169037525,
-0.0639937595,
-0.0221643429,
-0.0018253303,
0.0068395683,
-0.0031439539,
0.0162211079,
-0.0293887164,
-0.00944982,
0.01076198,
-0.0520850345,
0.0431849435,
0.0290871803,
-0.0695429817,
-0.0125096655,
0.0303563885,
0.0077125505,
-0.0057094004,
0.0227039233,
0.0033553757,
-0.0414725505,
0.03263418,
-0.0293315463,
0.0482668169,
-0.0684299991,
0.0152034685,
-0.0241506286,
0.0230583381,
-0.0374886468,
0.0319702774,
0.0192084014,
0.0015700897,
0.0094770407,
0.0142544033,
0.0104777822,
-0.0524273366,
-0.0243713073,
0.0396594778,
0.0065363138,
-0.0044263559,
-0.0237172954,
0.0227712803,
-0.0473693684,
-0.0093708578,
-0.0898275822,
-0.0122052189,
-0.033061631,
0.0317235626,
0.0192806479,
0.0275681317,
-0.0126259401,
-0.0125652887,
0.0071279807,
0.0240171459,
0.0074887457,
0.0219400655,
-0.0225238577,
0.0032575622,
-0.0304462332,
-0.0199263189,
-0.0250838455,
0.0419746339,
0.0141498633,
0.0252857935,
0.0039252569,
-0.0549492091,
0.0335093476,
-0.0108079286,
0.012567196,
0.0033616931,
-0.0742123127,
0.0099158455,
-0.0030678073,
0.0939232856,
0.0666001737,
-0.0171273481,
-0.0009890216,
0.0391534492,
-0.0085388385,
-0.0368190594,
0.0208965521,
0.026311079,
-0.0906502381,
-0.0620281585,
-0.0169298872,
-0.0380876511,
0.0697349757,
-0.0330570266,
-0.0187439434,
-0.0698100924,
-0.0148695325,
-0.0576111339,
-0.05350307,
-0.0238201953,
0.0320177861,
-0.025988562,
0.0123951538,
-0.0171648283,
-0.054148145,
0.0483380891,
-0.0348127037,
-0.0363473818,
-0.0592146441,
0.0074028657,
-0.0149812764,
0.0459289663,
0.0057179062,
0.0445007458,
-0.0109306043,
-0.0345530584,
-0.0399854258,
0.0258134548,
0.018428823,
-0.0044360152,
0.05226418,
-0.0350662284,
-0.0043633482,
-0.0245734062,
-0.0314580984,
-0.0121375276,
0.0081821373,
-0.0109715154,
-0.0105702896,
0.037007384,
-0.0149472533,
-0.054332152,
-0.0000539289,
0.060638763,
0.0402410813,
-0.004231757,
0.0066889632,
-0.0104104867,
-0.0143445963,
0.040006008,
0.0301499087,
0.0164210554,
-0.0527741984,
0.0090906536,
-0.0040624198,
0.0399753749,
-0.0373119004,
0.0023637651,
0.0164433587,
0.0353634395,
-0.006881108,
-0.0214151181,
0.0243130103,
0.0792548284,
-0.0609811582,
-0.0322279893,
0.0952853411,
-0.0018928301,
-0.0412202291,
0.0230240021,
-0.0581402332,
0.0586575121,
0.0177259967,
0.0253938548,
-0.0606157631,
-0.0177936517,
0.0156332068,
0.0188673679,
0.0275111403,
0.0106654651,
-0.013394095,
-0.1326063424,
0.0212052725,
0.025925627,
-0.0521737896,
-0.0111616999,
-0.033083111,
-0.026254762,
0.012215646,
0.0631860271,
0.0083033983,
-0.0233898517,
0.0021013417,
0.0202086493,
0.0026328049,
-0.0831708014,
0.0139769474,
-0.0153361876,
0.0550908372,
0.0664808303,
-0.0150150219,
-0.0243307296,
-0.0153398504,
0.0681547225,
-0.0054540881,
0.018350875,
-0.0165192522,
0.0110259652,
0.0382337421,
-0.0407998674,
-0.0094276918,
0.0084846858,
-0.0063064983,
-0.0246474817,
0.0028522701,
0.0380154848,
0.0216897186,
-0.0046892832,
0.030470822,
-0.0315172412,
0.0000260365,
0.0502321534,
0.0414602086,
-0.0568136759,
-0.0222556926,
-0.016931219,
-0.0193612333,
-0.0813490599,
-0.0158785135,
0.0277107097,
-0.0116291838,
-0.0650921538,
-0.0269420631,
-0.0525339283,
0.0122658331,
0.0324135982,
0.0194820277,
0.0226967633,
0.0053384798,
0.0086957999,
-0.0130324606,
0.0364866294,
-0.0308250356,
0.0166093521,
-0.0718317106,
-0.0464291088,
0.0203471035,
-0.0192204118,
-0.0077403588,
0.0059538954,
-0.0431918576,
-0.064043276,
0.0209191032,
0.0413183346,
0.0182195567,
0.023496775,
0.0092776744,
-0.084347114,
-0.0014572567,
-0.0012949531,
-0.0007454994,
0.0760902613,
0.0262221377,
0.0017560429,
0.0125152711,
0.0615043826,
-0.0183545817,
0.0373441391,
0.0150565132,
0.0508799516,
0.0132745188,
0.0105706397,
-0.0233497489,
0.0288524758,
0.0043142694,
-0.0472041741,
-0.0097919749,
-0.0654028356,
0.0346579216,
-0.0417632572,
0.0370603055,
-0.0382926464,
-0.0149750169,
0.0548460223,
0.0016696753,
0.0105008753,
0.0164649487,
0.018712569,
0.0168002974,
-0.041944664,
0.0437990911,
-0.009430374,
-0.0228017215,
0.0321543328,
0.0272785686,
-0.0322419889,
0.0017421219,
-0.0241592396,
0.0347267725,
-0.0199717656,
0.037530113,
-0.0091708535,
-0.0250578448,
-0.0290309582,
0.0281970035,
0.0050005438,
-0.0436783619,
0.0041810242,
0.029176753,
0.0747255087,
0.0154936444,
0.0834067166,
-0.007488498,
-0.0067155538,
-0.0314582177,
0.0048786295,
-0.0064869472,
-0.0400917493,
0.012905485,
-0.0007032295,
-0.0114654899,
-0.0273632482,
0.0774489492,
0.0332156718,
0.0395188071,
0.0106434291,
0.0642583892,
-0.0154925594,
-0.0439812355,
-0.0225988906,
0.0201814659,
-0.0413000174,
0.0198507365,
-0.0067194263,
-0.0883021578,
-0.0469537228,
0.0214412734,
-0.0306349378,
-0.0079221623,
0.0094285905,
0.032274086,
-0.0386429392,
-0.043221958,
-0.0286733899,
0.0057542995,
-0.0097867511,
-0.0111532435,
0.0394574367,
-6.547715123e-33,
-0.0424009822,
0.0221074503,
0.0280280802,
-0.0596114211,
-0.032702893,
-0.0224747378,
-0.0529133901,
0.0186097678,
-0.0344916768,
0.003425976,
-0.009138559,
0.0014343846,
0.0255762357,
0.0451936647,
0.0099648219,
0.0208727214,
0.0496319756,
0.0312996246,
0.0017604993,
0.0423068814,
0.0154831652,
0.0236439556,
0.0864541456,
-0.0105300834,
-0.0026941728,
0.0016090791,
0.0096265366,
0.0027497185,
0.0171433054,
0.0674316213,
-0.03247004,
0.0639590174,
0.003193052,
-0.0246713031,
-0.0508143939,
0.0067991209,
-0.0802465454,
-0.0112378383,
0.0431395322,
0.0369488001,
-0.0191312507,
-0.0481269918,
0.0211299248,
0.0051581631,
-0.0315596573,
-0.0116504068,
0.0029089809,
-0.0322244205,
-0.0265721045,
0.035618905,
-0.0754474401,
0.0072051943,
-0.0010995831,
0.0138837909,
0.0029859981,
0.0196018144,
-0.0339862108,
-0.0244731475,
-0.0125520816,
0.0041478854,
0.0419084281,
0.0577071644,
0.0931263492,
0.0513570122,
0.0329336412,
0.0253930483,
0.0395219401,
-0.0232355725,
0.0040611299,
-0.0228899308,
0.0660646334,
-0.0178101286,
0.0040546237,
0.0622039847,
0.0448416099,
-0.0295955986,
-0.0796034783,
-0.0238120053,
-0.0103885569,
0.0782393888,
0.0291816797,
0.0176609233,
-0.0125516672,
-0.0092336014,
-0.0565563738,
0.0215102304,
-0.0310166162,
-0.0383221768,
0.0676854402,
-0.0072190776,
-0.0072588329,
-0.0159014128,
0.0580393709,
-0.0303689875,
-0.0160290115,
0.0149059463,
-0.0008480118,
0.026802728,
-0.0314663425,
0.0451472141,
-0.0532793924,
-0.0392334983,
-0.0013162749,
0.0230296347,
0.0003445656,
-0.0156062562,
0.0149830729,
0.0049339193,
-0.0757794604,
0.0226317737,
-0.038334474,
-0.0000340914,
0.034201391,
0.0474513471,
0.0413493924,
-0.0141300783,
-0.0191397406,
0.0708239377,
0.0151963336,
-0.0497828797,
-0.0283629913,
-0.0265771281,
0.022008922,
0.0187275577,
-0.0206102338,
0.0082106758,
-0.0423565097,
0.0174561329,
0.0279964246,
-0.0496554933,
-0.0292752329,
0.0201782659,
2.829e-7,
0.0353290737,
0.0345455259,
-0.0070273881,
0.0219886098,
0.0083963871,
-0.0030915029,
-0.0037378513,
-0.0043142354,
0.0068176049,
0.0109042544,
-0.0281874407,
0.0691200867,
0.0419069417,
-0.0026946657,
-0.0578618608,
0.0113754794,
-0.0315070748,
0.0689284354,
-0.0589065216,
0.0188817699,
0.0111240121,
0.090222463,
-0.042629797,
-0.0075655249,
0.0345342569,
-0.0782854259,
0.0536475554,
-0.0405529626,
-0.0108720586,
0.012571875,
-0.0237837192,
0.0490252189,
0.0028564145,
-0.0113309547,
-0.0347869061,
0.0079711778,
-0.0237869266,
0.0678137839,
-0.0300983936,
-0.0113501018,
0.0141254133,
0.0107283629,
-0.0434406064,
-0.0636905655,
0.0566407777,
-0.0473477207,
-0.0200922359,
0.0133033786,
-0.0011741804,
-0.0102175307,
0.0186476856,
-0.0588311702,
-0.0252531506,
0.0080954432,
0.0337922238,
-0.0367852151,
-0.0247868784,
-0.034495689,
-0.0170091521,
0.0207515657,
-0.039879214,
-0.0639140308,
-0.0640882403,
-0.0112459548,
0.014260943,
-0.0103413342,
0.0065320688,
2.32928453e-34,
0.0413496569,
-0.010351426,
0.0344474763,
0.0306490418,
0.0124870287,
-0.0341721699,
0.0113013033,
0.0000186326,
-0.0137063283,
-0.1235353276,
-0.0277336501
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07730v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07730v1
|
Does Dependency Locality Predict Non-canonical Word Order in Hindi?
| 2024-05-13T13:24:17 | 2024-05-13T13:24:17 |
Sidharth Ranjan, Marten van Schijndel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Previous work has shown that isolated non-canonical sentences with
Object-before-Subject (OSV) order are initially harder to process than their
canonical counterparts with Subject-before-Object (SOV) order. Although this
difficulty diminishes with appropriate discourse context, the underlying
cognitive factors responsible for alleviating processing challenges in OSV
sentences remain a question. In this work, we test the hypothesis that
dependency length minimization is a significant predictor of non-canonical
(OSV) syntactic choices, especially when controlling for information status
such as givenness and surprisal measures. We extract sentences from the
Hindi-Urdu Treebank corpus (HUTB) that contain clearly-defined subjects and
objects, systematically permute the preverbal constituents of those sentences,
and deploy a classifier to distinguish between original corpus sentences and
artificially generated alternatives. The classifier leverages various
discourse-based and cognitive features, including dependency length, surprisal,
and information status, to inform its predictions. Our results suggest that,
although there exists a preference for minimizing dependency length in
non-canonical corpus sentences amidst the generated variants, this factor does
not significantly contribute in identifying corpus sentences above and beyond
surprisal and givenness measures. Notably, discourse predictability emerges as
the primary determinant of constituent-order preferences. These findings are
further supported by human evaluations involving 44 native Hindi speakers.
Overall, this work sheds light on the role of expectation adaptation in
word-ordering decisions. We conclude by situating our results within the
theories of discourse production and information locality.
|
Does Dependency Locality Predict Non-canonical Word Order in Hindi?: Previous work has shown that isolated non-canonical sentences with
Object-before-Subject (OSV) order are initially harder to process than their
canonical counterparts with Subject-before-Object (SOV) order. Although this
difficulty diminishes with appropriate discourse context, the underlying
cognitive factors responsible for alleviating processing challenges in OSV
sentences remain a question. In this work, we test the hypothesis that
dependency length minimization is a significant predictor of non-canonical
(OSV) syntactic choices, especially when controlling for information status
such as givenness and surprisal measures. We extract sentences from the
Hindi-Urdu Treebank corpus (HUTB) that contain clearly-defined subjects and
objects, systematically permute the preverbal constituents of those sentences,
and deploy a classifier to distinguish between original corpus sentences and
artificially generated alternatives. The classifier leverages various
discourse-based and cognitive features, including dependency length, surprisal,
and information status, to inform its predictions. Our results suggest that,
although there exists a preference for minimizing dependency length in
non-canonical corpus sentences amidst the generated variants, this factor does
not significantly contribute in identifying corpus sentences above and beyond
surprisal and givenness measures. Notably, discourse predictability emerges as
the primary determinant of constituent-order preferences. These findings are
further supported by human evaluations involving 44 native Hindi speakers.
Overall, this work sheds light on the role of expectation adaptation in
word-ordering decisions. We conclude by situating our results within the
theories of discourse production and information locality.
|
[
0.082536079,
0.0321908109,
-0.0297715832,
0.0312317833,
-0.0402483977,
0.0009486876,
-0.0139463507,
0.0014431641,
-0.0141015081,
-0.0407494493,
-0.0040968652,
-0.0298494771,
0.0618427061,
-0.0289614666,
0.0179151539,
-0.0644841641,
0.0229741558,
0.011727104,
0.0130481701,
-0.0096314121,
0.0271523353,
0.023532901,
-0.0322486497,
0.0068718353,
-0.0588340424,
-0.0065740999,
0.0050090207,
0.0137558533,
0.0053210896,
-0.025911063,
-0.0174037032,
0.0784691572,
-0.0311498288,
-0.0163306743,
0.0000017361,
-0.078464292,
-0.0063078292,
-0.0551225394,
-0.006891449,
0.0087736743,
0.0215174202,
0.0112466346,
0.0110628428,
0.0087267943,
-0.0262124278,
0.0118858032,
0.0661786497,
0.0424598157,
-0.0096427193,
0.0797472745,
-0.033518061,
-0.0442165136,
-0.0207363795,
-0.0035502845,
-0.022165997,
-0.0088776248,
0.0013511205,
-0.0081533175,
-0.0152129307,
0.0044924542,
-0.0444279984,
-0.0055581587,
-0.013671427,
-0.0086930636,
-0.0132099185,
0.01260396,
-0.0484581813,
-0.0206256621,
0.0310596488,
0.0321651772,
0.055949416,
-0.0599630214,
0.0062815007,
0.0019688534,
-0.001566875,
0.0208051819,
0.004710536,
0.0260523595,
-0.0079714414,
0.0395980775,
0.049811516,
0.0421433672,
-0.072604686,
-0.0141511122,
0.0329618342,
0.0831995234,
-0.0174707603,
-0.0251058415,
-0.0403884463,
-0.0029641737,
-0.0800964311,
-0.0538243391,
0.0112949461,
-0.0403781794,
-0.03054047,
0.0310054012,
-0.0056005549,
-0.0486512557,
-0.0054886467,
-0.0679343715,
-0.0074778427,
0.0143955899,
-0.020731125,
-0.0107443603,
0.0157025959,
0.0546763428,
-0.0158908367,
-0.0408369899,
-0.0459932201,
0.0432756022,
0.0125623271,
-0.0702394843,
0.0184198134,
0.0245496407,
-0.0576660559,
0.0031450498,
-0.0685692132,
-0.003322152,
0.037200667,
-0.0569580011,
0.0138730491,
0.0340393037,
-0.0354328603,
0.0016698495,
-0.0293505955,
0.0224448834,
-0.0529137924,
0.0357699431,
-0.0416205563,
-0.0564525276,
-0.0023314301,
0.046322301,
0.0099735698,
0.0041736625,
-0.0633192137,
0.0069459416,
-0.0238222331,
-0.0222961009,
0.022552982,
0.0096313367,
-0.0794339254,
-0.0141744101,
-0.021028474,
-0.0599806681,
0.0046941275,
0.0367759317,
0.0054032723,
-0.0342529826,
0.0034038499,
0.0152561953,
-0.0088035259,
0.0336093083,
0.0809093863,
0.0374296755,
0.014440191,
-0.0004540523,
0.0632101148,
0.0022167128,
0.0214296207,
-0.029522961,
0.0203124881,
-0.0075047519,
-0.0043046679,
0.0002187798,
-0.0411216915,
-0.0182627402,
-0.015962733,
0.0105328914,
-0.0525186956,
0.0079553816,
0.0308520757,
0.0326540507,
-0.0261728931,
0.0000478735,
0.0321205929,
0.0437041037,
-0.0141823739,
-0.0198374391,
0.000821306,
0.0615001507,
-0.0027813618,
0.1005433798,
0.0152535718,
0.0030140611,
0.0186887793,
-0.0151637569,
-0.0270562042,
-0.0260497816,
0.0087263165,
-0.0249492656,
-0.0385081954,
-0.0136058014,
-0.0121642919,
-0.0455237627,
-0.0091806697,
0.0321567841,
-0.0158177745,
0.0437481143,
0.0369397067,
-0.0752487779,
-0.0537195727,
0.0090251202,
0.0070371758,
-0.0032546779,
-0.0075433119,
-0.0101907114,
0.0113871759,
0.0549393445,
0.0140996035,
0.0804230869,
0.0082782712,
-0.0069774082,
0.0099471649,
0.0100901658,
0.0487188846,
0.027037181,
0.0021857419,
0.0282458793,
-0.0229488127,
-0.0208172482,
0.0159747321,
0.0371094421,
0.0112544363,
0.0298521854,
0.0045862719,
-0.0260195062,
-0.009872607,
0.011282092,
0.0645265058,
-0.0312768295,
-0.0120245852,
0.0343407169,
0.0166818909,
0.0061660814,
0.006579618,
0.0833683684,
-0.0901206732,
-0.051192347,
-0.0210805591,
-0.0557478443,
0.0311243962,
0.0126188165,
0.0092788078,
-0.0575081222,
0.0432691611,
-0.0183232706,
0.0612538941,
-0.0080408389,
0.0514139719,
-0.0142504619,
0.0050211186,
-0.0498310849,
0.0451761298,
0.0049060402,
0.0138974227,
-0.0006327718,
-0.0109286699,
0.0837754756,
-0.0039239004,
0.0198467188,
0.0228593033,
0.0249322485,
-0.0252524111,
0.0452109091,
0.0024118449,
-0.0612956211,
-0.0581802949,
-0.1318820864,
-0.0400588512,
0.0205091648,
0.0209994167,
0.0274739377,
0.0221795402,
-0.0247697439,
-0.0198772009,
-0.0030482216,
-0.0117778387,
0.0262164325,
0.0183455553,
0.0505929142,
-0.0214510746,
0.0043226746,
-0.0233506728,
-0.0189872533,
-0.0357726179,
0.0513236336,
-0.0286303982,
-0.0636318326,
-0.0375637785,
0.0605910495,
-0.0018220653,
0.0098009128,
-0.0053164721,
-0.0311124604,
0.023717219,
0.0478932783,
0.1000916511,
0.0400512218,
0.0047112033,
-0.0003734658,
0.0165353622,
-0.0091325883,
-0.0242467374,
-0.0247410964,
0.0181343518,
-0.0102034034,
-0.0091412254,
-0.0274591967,
-0.0408222787,
0.0667869598,
0.0326588899,
-0.0317881219,
-0.0072215335,
0.0015977565,
-0.0537667386,
-0.0300203618,
0.0119637633,
-0.0495450571,
-0.0627425015,
0.0662490502,
-0.0248110313,
-0.0113303503,
0.0124702714,
-0.0179234091,
0.0140740955,
-0.0572328418,
0.0613270625,
-0.0152291032,
0.0559182167,
0.0339494869,
0.0127436984,
0.0018434243,
-0.065565832,
-0.1116531789,
0.0259220991,
0.0091887349,
0.0277114715,
-0.0142680677,
-0.0731512606,
-0.0099209584,
-0.0246383548,
-0.0857961029,
-0.0011090916,
-0.0735017806,
0.0308673084,
-0.0164206922,
0.0191987325,
-0.0083270185,
0.0605037585,
0.0293337777,
-0.0049752984,
0.0026750765,
-0.0263599567,
0.0337028801,
-0.0031549055,
0.0483154953,
0.0357363522,
0.0237587206,
0.0258499924,
0.028815547,
0.0009321323,
0.0077597685,
0.0038329845,
0.0229401477,
0.0039357818,
-0.0027639165,
0.0150939682,
-0.0166399069,
-0.109972015,
0.0006677782,
0.0375343226,
0.0352405347,
-0.0007587535,
0.0806091875,
0.0386702232,
0.0149516454,
0.0382297114,
-0.070270814,
0.0464829914,
0.0158026759,
0.0123670176,
-0.0700033307,
0.0160468612,
0.0180067047,
-0.0539274178,
-0.0456947945,
-0.035364829,
-0.0188763421,
-0.075371787,
-0.0121863661,
-0.0131849218,
-0.0066291913,
0.0286192205,
0.0169111062,
-0.0195579752,
0.0406693928,
-0.0021423697,
0.061664179,
-0.0558084548,
0.0226053074,
0.0351549238,
-0.0217127092,
0.0092138723,
-0.0286183972,
0.0072479122,
-0.0289711021,
0.011305484,
0.0092265997,
-0.0031071256,
0.0141180661,
-0.0086656567,
-0.0336597227,
0.0052358559,
0.0170745682,
0.0184222739,
0.0159785319,
-0.0047631776,
-0.0532304011,
0.0022975616,
-0.0005819196,
0.009471165,
-0.0019102142,
0.0131985452,
-0.0117693627,
-0.0223929081,
0.0177606009,
0.0112236803,
-0.0302125104,
0.0290678497,
0.0511082225,
-0.0377556495,
-0.0142484512,
0.0040150085,
0.0157376081,
0.0396995321,
-0.0564703383,
0.0082734413,
-0.0126031311,
-0.0763674229,
-0.092378594,
-0.0719090998,
-0.0305705722,
0.0406653732,
0.033465229,
0.0220089238,
0.008373254,
-0.0176718496,
-0.013295576,
-0.0371524841,
0.0088116862,
-0.0308284983,
-0.0432356074,
0.0054869298,
0.055509761,
0.0057598529,
-0.0186231751,
-0.0203361195,
0.0156725831,
-0.0432808772,
0.0492627844,
-0.0051611909,
0.021757165,
-0.0089426916,
0.0181587804,
-0.0536833964,
0.02644982,
0.0112102721,
-0.0109037142,
0.0947413594,
0.0164409671,
-0.0281849429,
0.0120137511,
0.0228494816,
0.0020395003,
0.0313125402,
-0.01298384,
0.0000351125,
0.0003592889,
-0.0066778492,
0.0602955334,
0.0425515771,
0.0298882127,
-0.0650423542,
0.0407436229,
-0.0545984581,
0.0221791323,
-0.0191589203,
-0.0509306528,
0.0002855067,
-0.0106243882,
0.0375919007,
0.0847574696,
-0.0423017442,
-0.0303658899,
-0.0272308215,
0.032145258,
0.0271816049,
-0.0015036266,
0.0607402921,
0.031424243,
0.0150325345,
0.0298706777,
0.0006752054,
-0.0005630875,
-0.0249445252,
0.0318786353,
-0.0083174529,
0.0358834527,
-0.0123681594,
-0.0244256277,
-0.0197322126,
0.0515065566,
0.0205432344,
0.0688356012,
0.0185145922,
-0.0023070469,
0.0464976244,
-0.0902976766,
0.1047015488,
-0.0387353115,
0.0400536284,
-0.0038288555,
0.0135732861,
-0.0054210434,
-0.0108333901,
0.0122553436,
0.0002628867,
-0.036587622,
0.060268756,
0.1073419154,
-0.0002809628,
-0.0241094027,
0.0124836275,
-0.013936583,
-0.0253287945,
-0.0628525391,
-0.0175474845,
-0.0185546838,
0.0198176187,
0.0190861057,
-0.0675722212,
-0.0309510399,
0.0058069997,
-0.0483051725,
0.0606217645,
-0.042282287,
0.0356606692,
0.066276975,
0.0202203542,
-0.0403028987,
-0.0485876836,
-0.0160535406,
0.0151825789,
-0.0180767048,
-0.0258252434,
-5.690745946e-33,
-0.0628620908,
-0.0191290434,
-0.040776778,
0.0518990792,
0.0187850017,
0.0263119694,
-0.0176812056,
0.0419948325,
0.054716751,
0.0346242152,
-0.04934825,
0.0234734006,
0.0161290243,
-0.0145413168,
0.0746636912,
0.0190447811,
-0.0077870009,
0.0029374512,
-0.0135058155,
-0.0425989106,
0.0930249617,
-0.0182374865,
0.0966003984,
-0.0296438653,
0.0499314331,
-0.028544249,
0.0029029911,
0.0014781776,
-0.0234508011,
0.0289393533,
-0.0070951455,
0.0502180457,
0.0404487029,
0.0148720145,
-0.0084040025,
0.0522499159,
-0.0269023273,
-0.0494787917,
0.0716821998,
0.050400909,
-0.0332098268,
-0.0521500893,
0.0301950574,
-0.0265951641,
-0.0353415199,
0.0714601651,
0.015899213,
0.0190306939,
0.0159267075,
0.0171576403,
-0.0535508022,
-0.0093861613,
-0.0301816892,
0.0343754776,
0.0010743077,
0.0633610487,
-0.0203298982,
-0.0445172936,
0.0079998923,
0.034269277,
-0.0294982716,
0.0742542297,
-0.0147509463,
0.0072269342,
-0.0117530739,
0.02454325,
0.031546887,
-0.0215441771,
0.0466051884,
0.0030598727,
-0.0087274136,
0.0193979144,
-0.0098755835,
0.0281124953,
0.0280094948,
-0.0515584983,
-0.0480123647,
-0.0178266019,
0.0074628242,
0.0422965996,
-0.0229381528,
0.0086952047,
-0.053147573,
-0.081283778,
0.0295346174,
-0.0218581203,
-0.0028153805,
-0.037571799,
0.0354418829,
-0.0546376444,
-0.0102530839,
-0.0008872565,
0.0304192435,
0.0052794921,
-0.0206332542,
-0.0117872898,
-0.0820839554,
0.0451097004,
0.0207787193,
0.0487069674,
-0.0487515889,
-0.0118127288,
0.0043359841,
0.0428867824,
0.0259083733,
0.0408645086,
0.0370097049,
-0.0164669137,
-0.0576566719,
0.0015657463,
0.0059845047,
-0.0179970264,
-0.0439211577,
-0.0168978926,
0.0415558182,
0.0267458744,
-0.0061410912,
-0.0090948055,
0.0643160343,
-0.0064838198,
-0.0202074088,
-0.0062301625,
-0.0262964293,
0.007427278,
-0.0056756213,
-0.0050145974,
-0.0259790197,
0.0213531591,
0.0359839015,
-0.0300928783,
-0.0044052321,
0.0108792922,
2.68e-7,
0.0135047529,
0.0659134313,
0.030679632,
-0.0385490097,
0.0280137844,
-0.0145225087,
-0.008506204,
0.0210533943,
-0.0093585374,
0.0040323422,
0.0180583075,
-0.0194834583,
-0.0003724768,
-0.0232712086,
-0.1160202175,
-0.0246604569,
-0.0810339823,
0.008416798,
-0.0094190091,
0.0006069464,
0.0061036902,
0.0235036649,
-0.0224185977,
0.0167068392,
-0.0685499012,
0.0099005317,
0.0265563447,
0.0042070933,
0.000941179,
0.0114357835,
0.010272922,
-0.0467820168,
0.0186529625,
0.0256368034,
0.0215720311,
0.0167673305,
0.0320508033,
0.0337786004,
-0.0033557087,
-0.0038716057,
0.0228236578,
0.0277346447,
-0.0301847607,
-0.0000294425,
0.044991836,
0.0120080253,
-0.0511183143,
0.0268037077,
-0.042436298,
0.00400957,
0.0098218564,
0.0292266514,
-0.0146826217,
0.0132605126,
-0.0090364851,
-0.0591311343,
-0.0144763365,
-0.0052159587,
-0.0514724404,
0.0378530361,
0.0001231445,
-0.0520097204,
0.0176768731,
0.0224666782,
0.0235333666,
-0.0393394008,
-0.036589697,
2.379177837e-34,
0.0126006091,
0.0367605947,
0.0785363466,
-0.0102468152,
0.0328566618,
-0.0400567465,
-0.0244861711,
0.0551420189,
0.0292723421,
-0.0690470338,
-0.0235797893
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07726v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07726v1
|
Quantifying and Optimizing Global Faithfulness in Persona-driven Role-playing
| 2024-05-13T13:21:35 | 2024-05-13T13:21:35 |
Letian Peng, Jingbo Shang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Persona-driven role-playing (PRP) aims to build AI characters that can
respond to user queries by faithfully sticking with all persona statements.
Unfortunately, existing faithfulness criteria for PRP are limited to
coarse-grained LLM-based scoring without a clear definition or formulation.
This paper presents a pioneering exploration to quantify PRP faithfulness as a
fine-grained and explainable criterion, which also serves as a reliable
reference for optimization. Our criterion first discriminates persona
statements into active and passive constraints by identifying the
query-statement relevance. Then, we incorporate all constraints following the
principle that the AI character's response should be (a) entailed by active
(relevant) constraints and (b) not contradicted by passive (irrelevant)
constraints. We translate this principle mathematically into a novel
Active-Passive-Constraint (APC) score, a constraint-wise sum of natural
language inference (NLI) scores weighted by relevance scores. In practice, we
build the APC scoring system by symbolically distilling small discriminators
from GPT-4 for efficiency. We validate the quality of the APC score against
human evaluation based on example personas with tens of statements, and the
results show a high correlation. We further leverage it as a reward system in
direct preference optimization (DPO) for better AI characters. Our experiments
offer a fine-grained and explainable comparison between existing PRP
techniques, revealing their advantages and limitations. We further find
APC-based DPO to be one of the most competitive techniques for sticking with
all constraints and can be well incorporated with other techniques. We then
extend the scale of the experiments to real persons with hundreds of statements
and reach a consistent conclusion.
|
Quantifying and Optimizing Global Faithfulness in Persona-driven Role-playing: Persona-driven role-playing (PRP) aims to build AI characters that can
respond to user queries by faithfully sticking with all persona statements.
Unfortunately, existing faithfulness criteria for PRP are limited to
coarse-grained LLM-based scoring without a clear definition or formulation.
This paper presents a pioneering exploration to quantify PRP faithfulness as a
fine-grained and explainable criterion, which also serves as a reliable
reference for optimization. Our criterion first discriminates persona
statements into active and passive constraints by identifying the
query-statement relevance. Then, we incorporate all constraints following the
principle that the AI character's response should be (a) entailed by active
(relevant) constraints and (b) not contradicted by passive (irrelevant)
constraints. We translate this principle mathematically into a novel
Active-Passive-Constraint (APC) score, a constraint-wise sum of natural
language inference (NLI) scores weighted by relevance scores. In practice, we
build the APC scoring system by symbolically distilling small discriminators
from GPT-4 for efficiency. We validate the quality of the APC score against
human evaluation based on example personas with tens of statements, and the
results show a high correlation. We further leverage it as a reward system in
direct preference optimization (DPO) for better AI characters. Our experiments
offer a fine-grained and explainable comparison between existing PRP
techniques, revealing their advantages and limitations. We further find
APC-based DPO to be one of the most competitive techniques for sticking with
all constraints and can be well incorporated with other techniques. We then
extend the scale of the experiments to real persons with hundreds of statements
and reach a consistent conclusion.
|
[
0.0801367909,
0.0560122095,
-0.0231529698,
0.0343820378,
-0.0183105506,
-0.0147414552,
-0.0321637765,
-0.0185539816,
0.0201940369,
0.0095645627,
-0.0183684286,
-0.0320376381,
0.0089644371,
0.0130666932,
0.0224544071,
-0.0692922622,
0.0474224873,
-0.0078584822,
0.0334962383,
0.0125291375,
-0.0109845586,
0.02752221,
-0.0288382079,
0.04744808,
0.0004825972,
0.0182630084,
0.0258144215,
0.0004694902,
0.0848490894,
-0.0502714776,
0.0118013239,
-0.028049577,
0.0178090241,
-0.0460947454,
0.0000023439,
-0.090415962,
-0.0072529721,
-0.0168743357,
0.0011508968,
-0.0436366312,
-0.0147985779,
0.0607754737,
0.0361015499,
-0.0125667937,
-0.0397347361,
0.0060477308,
0.0576926358,
0.0532506332,
0.0731882229,
0.0616875179,
-0.0060599511,
-0.0373897254,
-0.0278261602,
-0.0162718538,
0.0281384792,
-0.0618737787,
-0.0128123555,
0.0012919729,
0.0549468249,
-0.0289790984,
0.0151917357,
-0.0140432063,
-0.0218547564,
0.0043515884,
0.0004184449,
0.0260358248,
-0.0255894847,
-0.0060547455,
0.0491006151,
0.0620849133,
0.0854404122,
0.0077451169,
0.0178263336,
-0.01314619,
0.0331468508,
0.0634244159,
0.0102270124,
-0.0039597889,
-0.0078960182,
-0.0107244318,
-0.0057573975,
0.0457604043,
0.0261742175,
0.0026074753,
-0.0239593051,
0.0509214811,
-0.0028248124,
-0.0406926014,
-0.0021259126,
-0.0102034761,
-0.0596256033,
-0.0470100604,
-0.0140360054,
0.0350975543,
-0.0817594007,
0.0257301275,
-0.0426375866,
0.0811653212,
-0.0037028713,
-0.017150363,
0.0289640706,
0.0597607419,
0.0369995907,
0.027940087,
0.0143899117,
0.0973701999,
-0.0152321504,
-0.0115185548,
-0.016191734,
-0.0019339654,
-0.0485267267,
-0.0314676277,
-0.0187337194,
0.0708293542,
0.0311111677,
-0.0036787835,
-0.0284102913,
0.0184192788,
-0.0628609136,
0.0528075695,
-0.0050700814,
0.0347019583,
-0.0508993715,
0.0017087291,
-0.1008468866,
0.0062574078,
-0.0687390119,
0.012333543,
-0.0445658974,
-0.0038939454,
0.006902494,
-0.0080859903,
0.0102217002,
-0.0286485814,
0.0242159218,
0.0864243284,
0.0243412647,
-0.033722695,
0.0187435281,
-0.0312488321,
-0.0088607026,
-0.0791120678,
-0.0643550307,
-0.0199909322,
0.0204060711,
-0.0399728715,
0.0230927505,
-0.0516683795,
0.0016018006,
0.0119362157,
0.0254120361,
0.0774175227,
0.0643064529,
0.017242685,
-0.0088969441,
0.0061466862,
-0.0327535644,
0.0289003551,
0.0474494509,
0.0105118351,
0.0117426217,
0.0088986401,
-0.011768912,
0.0110710002,
-0.0319396891,
-0.0283466056,
0.0096966773,
0.0375449657,
0.0078936378,
0.0509412922,
0.015948616,
0.0333503336,
-0.0485290587,
-0.0116198445,
0.0506377965,
0.0359831937,
0.0055057304,
-0.0188619271,
0.0692667961,
0.0357302129,
-0.0032907259,
0.0341846794,
-0.0469190627,
0.0242536291,
0.0372580849,
-0.0452170298,
-0.0257265493,
0.0148826344,
-0.0024152247,
-0.0457497053,
0.0428683683,
-0.0048204274,
-0.0177540667,
0.0269901939,
-0.0140525643,
-0.0139046321,
-0.0307160337,
0.0209221449,
0.0078253439,
-0.0701959208,
0.0401807465,
-0.0505314358,
0.0250196047,
0.0820969567,
0.0492578782,
-0.0638635829,
-0.0515873283,
0.0133239888,
-0.0473752804,
0.037334118,
0.0209544785,
-0.0408995412,
0.0294406936,
0.0024918213,
-0.0098932935,
-0.0206389837,
-0.0003592962,
0.0674315691,
0.0130429715,
-0.003993595,
-0.0198410563,
0.0087631429,
0.0060539134,
0.0450765267,
-0.0179898404,
-0.041580949,
0.002794157,
0.0455960855,
0.0438574217,
0.0192437563,
0.0153661016,
-0.0231113508,
0.0114061562,
-0.0260679051,
-0.0091346763,
0.0340244994,
-0.0248360056,
0.0375169627,
0.0347129889,
-0.0799127668,
-0.0401110537,
0.0456339195,
0.012643314,
-0.0097855926,
0.0057098875,
-0.0504433699,
-0.0118506392,
-0.0109088589,
0.0075337393,
-0.0202493481,
0.0062466413,
-0.0407441631,
0.0739490464,
0.0171896797,
-0.0120084751,
0.0497299619,
-0.021553224,
0.0189297274,
-0.0914732441,
0.0277023166,
-0.0246261861,
0.0087746745,
-0.0072191963,
0.0604919307,
-0.0159820504,
-0.0265484378,
-0.0401329137,
-0.0469093099,
0.001994597,
0.0134568857,
-0.0035461232,
0.0029071132,
0.0354886092,
-0.0365603715,
-0.0034948289,
-0.0435594656,
-0.0651342422,
0.0033154029,
-0.0289517306,
0.0648645088,
0.0385059789,
-0.0061175385,
-0.0277768504,
0.0367634892,
-0.0313070603,
-0.0080769192,
0.0157041103,
0.0274008885,
-0.0323971696,
-0.0034943458,
-0.0521415696,
0.0138411149,
-0.0191328023,
-0.0082644718,
0.0546831116,
0.0123470007,
0.0162633639,
0.058808554,
0.0272639971,
-0.0219272431,
0.0289872885,
-0.0057704868,
-0.0760120749,
0.0365237631,
-0.0013034999,
-0.0108094681,
-0.0328863561,
-0.0509368218,
0.0856771469,
0.0292391647,
0.0011893504,
-0.0015620172,
-0.1043129638,
0.0555565022,
0.00438511,
-0.0488925725,
0.0526048169,
-0.0106525421,
-0.0134547651,
0.0073858532,
-0.0033790318,
0.0185479075,
0.0981251895,
-0.0291939713,
0.0189103559,
0.0046356795,
0.001013474,
-0.0368916057,
0.0472929738,
0.0094857104,
0.0253431424,
0.010833187,
-0.0145527795,
-0.0713655129,
-0.0344917364,
0.0765361562,
-0.0130974781,
0.0507711396,
-0.0440846011,
0.0141741475,
0.0141080469,
-0.0346341394,
-0.0451180562,
-0.0328787006,
-0.0082766069,
-0.026907308,
0.0068002972,
-0.0409657992,
-0.0342958458,
-0.0079261903,
0.0135210436,
-0.0211843345,
-0.0143491784,
-0.0267054848,
-0.0373113267,
-0.0539294071,
0.0622067042,
0.0749241337,
0.0072684879,
-0.0050466368,
0.0088578844,
-0.0034207816,
-0.0590711646,
-0.0206632148,
0.0088751968,
0.0272115357,
0.0232143681,
-0.055256933,
-0.0151376184,
0.0145040555,
0.0384098999,
-0.0371126011,
-0.0050494932,
0.1049568057,
0.0259581208,
-0.0239913128,
0.0183128808,
-0.0044151628,
0.0262391884,
0.0215944033,
0.0287156943,
-0.0404040627,
-0.0253165141,
-0.0232996307,
0.0611288734,
-0.0242031608,
-0.0673433617,
-0.0348311886,
-0.0949773863,
0.0090743583,
-0.0325614698,
-0.0348672681,
-0.0150930705,
-0.0350516737,
0.0330293663,
-0.0515572615,
-0.0123053985,
-0.0054539717,
0.0078511601,
0.0052329199,
-0.0145520838,
-0.0314773321,
-0.0074517862,
0.0311671812,
-0.056648016,
0.0429487005,
0.0478973947,
0.0836126506,
0.0116580371,
-0.0461776108,
-0.0721286908,
0.026436355,
-0.0092266928,
0.004317923,
0.0264904164,
-0.0388483405,
-0.0115337465,
-0.0249020159,
-0.0053244936,
0.0209846981,
-0.011073241,
0.0057664816,
0.045949094,
-0.0136530474,
-0.0155834304,
-0.0044853599,
-0.0065669091,
0.0086366395,
0.0634424016,
-0.0358036831,
-0.0440748855,
-0.0090225749,
0.019006202,
0.010854559,
-0.0724991858,
-0.0663452819,
-0.0407512002,
-0.0308929998,
0.0189380217,
-0.0636924952,
-0.0334720649,
-0.0033167836,
0.0579467639,
0.0098329736,
-0.0187159628,
-0.0070856954,
0.029467009,
0.0037654226,
-0.0174404718,
-0.0695544854,
0.0133973248,
-0.017887041,
-0.0258747861,
0.0288242791,
-0.060696248,
0.0135894362,
-0.0120178331,
0.0142770363,
-0.0218014698,
-0.0133830905,
0.0626761764,
0.0219098106,
0.0388645157,
-0.0112783834,
-0.0452395007,
-0.0195089094,
0.0228263531,
-0.0255169738,
0.012270784,
0.003858669,
0.024870038,
-0.0084320027,
0.0142981037,
-0.065529637,
0.0022450453,
-0.0231030434,
0.0326713845,
-0.0073780464,
-0.0770161375,
0.0472280122,
0.0383653902,
-0.0229722448,
-0.0317011401,
0.0130667398,
-0.0099574421,
-0.006758051,
-0.0286425296,
-0.0235831309,
-0.0211616904,
-0.0066705844,
0.0471167229,
0.0480111502,
0.0019547432,
-0.0329085551,
-0.0383073241,
-0.001639989,
-0.0257431213,
-0.0413453244,
0.0755158961,
0.0132075883,
-0.0224953499,
-0.0095673129,
-0.0054905261,
0.0134127513,
-0.0047693211,
0.087742269,
0.009013013,
-0.0060309451,
0.036235597,
0.0061490536,
-0.0215762015,
0.0348487385,
-0.0430187024,
-0.0251521915,
0.0416975059,
-0.019236492,
0.0319048278,
0.0141426912,
0.0213162042,
-0.007812459,
0.0205715448,
0.0257466678,
-0.017073309,
0.0465090536,
-0.0035568825,
-0.011688997,
0.0506209098,
-0.0031508354,
0.0255826619,
0.0125318142,
-0.0027739638,
0.0544286296,
-0.0771313384,
-0.0152763426,
-0.0493058935,
-0.0659947097,
-0.0234860368,
0.0369184203,
-0.0356092602,
-0.0054499507,
-0.1020322442,
-0.035484083,
0.0073682982,
0.047034543,
-0.0084359385,
-0.0271616876,
-0.0024623603,
0.0022387821,
0.0244688075,
-0.0156819243,
-0.0302672107,
-0.031715136,
-0.0503246337,
0.0423061214,
-0.0089029716,
-6.017468723e-33,
-0.0496734455,
-0.019758366,
0.0294575077,
0.0097373351,
-0.0911010876,
-0.0202913266,
-0.0327386372,
-0.0268605109,
-0.003460401,
-0.0156555437,
0.0011724214,
-0.0123312287,
-0.0086542526,
-0.0448914245,
-0.0114446878,
-0.0341703929,
0.0184471495,
0.042619653,
-0.0873936787,
0.0164468549,
0.0582372025,
-0.0490124375,
-0.0165102426,
-0.0690568686,
0.0368076004,
0.0077169351,
-0.0344009064,
0.0377083384,
-0.0232495666,
0.0507022291,
0.0044160546,
0.0026764569,
0.0264853407,
0.0218380429,
0.025930712,
0.0134795234,
-0.0628690347,
-0.0553402416,
0.0414329059,
-0.0011388402,
-0.0167998429,
-0.0300152544,
0.006250686,
0.0071282825,
-0.0200042594,
0.0062415474,
0.057781931,
0.0001632148,
0.0521406643,
-0.009400744,
-0.0563793592,
-0.0163257346,
-0.0503809676,
-0.016203003,
-0.0132663101,
0.0722845122,
-0.0101732295,
0.0288673732,
-0.0367718525,
0.0423402004,
-0.044314824,
-0.0001307411,
0.009946201,
0.0490823537,
0.0235461853,
0.052538231,
0.0147563275,
0.0088048531,
-0.0473752171,
-0.0306431931,
0.0214445032,
0.0307553373,
0.0268950723,
0.096371226,
0.0230586994,
0.0109963771,
-0.0525749996,
0.0533389114,
0.0208323393,
0.0356605388,
0.0181046221,
0.0154608171,
-0.052432552,
-0.005680033,
-0.0166477729,
-0.0006574224,
-0.0089266663,
-0.0300632454,
0.0233382266,
-0.0221880395,
-0.0686032027,
-0.0038641111,
0.0106817745,
-0.0550724939,
0.0089551322,
-0.0066299392,
-0.016130928,
-0.0096014179,
0.0108143259,
-0.0013368481,
-0.015930526,
-0.006316626,
0.0400256813,
0.0007001941,
0.0583980083,
0.0245685522,
-0.032439813,
0.0528479144,
-0.0200676247,
-0.0191130508,
0.0068116677,
0.0138952713,
-0.051025629,
0.0157926977,
0.0183043908,
-0.0234035924,
-0.0097969547,
-0.0107068429,
0.0140173361,
-0.0294291005,
-0.0427409746,
0.0348862521,
-0.0056651896,
-0.006232365,
-0.011853206,
0.0166188795,
-0.0307567753,
0.046410393,
-0.0418539569,
-0.0537621565,
-0.0261557046,
-0.0134692229,
3.15e-7,
-0.0243253149,
0.0078926673,
0.0054753441,
0.0385374725,
-0.0165482387,
0.0573169254,
0.0092839729,
0.020339191,
0.0244112555,
-0.0387689583,
0.0687822029,
0.030152481,
-0.0152913174,
0.0233565923,
-0.0974100679,
0.0407887064,
0.0132476622,
-0.00853692,
-0.0135598257,
0.0111881895,
0.098182559,
0.0093016978,
0.0422433764,
-0.0175742432,
0.0181417987,
-0.0199313033,
0.0221078414,
-0.0086781681,
0.0114163505,
0.0419611894,
0.0256020688,
-0.0291004032,
-0.0080730347,
0.0337531827,
0.0116719892,
0.0672096685,
0.0132756708,
0.0515682027,
-0.0186066218,
-0.0157635212,
-0.0503437966,
-0.0142786941,
0.0228078142,
-0.0323882252,
0.0757601857,
-0.0295355655,
-0.0250421278,
0.0030691386,
-0.045937486,
-0.0135697452,
-0.0019017722,
0.0135234529,
-0.0693752542,
0.0099641541,
0.0102441031,
0.015202078,
-0.0342571363,
-0.0712931156,
0.007436398,
-0.040277265,
-0.0206097607,
-0.0277313665,
0.020452043,
0.0314200744,
-0.0030553527,
-0.0222990904,
0.0266850945,
2.616270915e-34,
-0.055703491,
0.0418903343,
0.0243089665,
-0.0257441793,
0.0911681503,
0.0503244437,
-0.0301115662,
0.0293888114,
0.0656346902,
-0.0407014675,
0.0012377639
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13010v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13010v1
|
UCCIX: Irish-eXcellence Large Language Model
| 2024-05-13T13:19:27 | 2024-05-13T13:19:27 |
Khanh-Tung Tran, Barry O'Sullivan, Hoang D. Nguyen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The development of Large Language Models (LLMs) has predominantly focused on
high-resource languages, leaving extremely low-resource languages like Irish
with limited representation. This work presents UCCIX, a pioneering effort on
the development of an open-source Irish-based LLM. We propose a novel framework
for continued pre-training of LLMs specifically adapted for extremely
low-resource languages, requiring only a fraction of the textual data typically
needed for training LLMs according to scaling laws. Our model, based on Llama
2-13B, outperforms much larger models on Irish language tasks with up to 12%
performance improvement, showcasing the effectiveness and efficiency of our
approach. We also contribute comprehensive Irish benchmarking datasets,
including IrishQA, a question-answering dataset, and Irish version of MT-bench.
These datasets enable rigorous evaluation and facilitate future research in
Irish LLM systems. Our work aims to preserve and promote the Irish language,
knowledge, and culture of Ireland in the digital era while providing a
framework for adapting LLMs to other indigenous languages.
|
UCCIX: Irish-eXcellence Large Language Model: The development of Large Language Models (LLMs) has predominantly focused on
high-resource languages, leaving extremely low-resource languages like Irish
with limited representation. This work presents UCCIX, a pioneering effort on
the development of an open-source Irish-based LLM. We propose a novel framework
for continued pre-training of LLMs specifically adapted for extremely
low-resource languages, requiring only a fraction of the textual data typically
needed for training LLMs according to scaling laws. Our model, based on Llama
2-13B, outperforms much larger models on Irish language tasks with up to 12%
performance improvement, showcasing the effectiveness and efficiency of our
approach. We also contribute comprehensive Irish benchmarking datasets,
including IrishQA, a question-answering dataset, and Irish version of MT-bench.
These datasets enable rigorous evaluation and facilitate future research in
Irish LLM systems. Our work aims to preserve and promote the Irish language,
knowledge, and culture of Ireland in the digital era while providing a
framework for adapting LLMs to other indigenous languages.
|
[
0.0141306417,
0.0721352994,
-0.0104971267,
0.0487035811,
-0.0397465639,
0.0183229316,
-0.0108401328,
-0.0199601147,
-0.0073648146,
-0.0223832112,
-0.0477238931,
-0.0462880693,
-0.0522929877,
0.0214539748,
0.0082562016,
0.0333023779,
0.0868054479,
-0.0322419256,
-0.0262035653,
-0.0511875488,
0.0183664653,
0.017335305,
0.0004735267,
0.0002311604,
-0.00184871,
0.0046590338,
0.0209259093,
0.0007878675,
-0.0069691129,
0.001567705,
0.004205252,
0.0069711255,
-0.0190617777,
0.008908364,
0.0000019016,
-0.0705969706,
0.0068300003,
-0.0264085215,
-0.0431439728,
0.0564376898,
0.0215592459,
0.0074970121,
0.0071202973,
0.0126178171,
-0.0336475447,
0.0060561788,
0.0295312759,
-0.0023480137,
0.0722130537,
0.0766562447,
0.0183905624,
-0.0392420217,
0.0260699224,
-0.0604675822,
-0.0147155076,
0.0140701337,
0.0361514911,
0.0571522936,
0.0098519288,
0.0010505972,
-0.0137907611,
0.0394850448,
0.0212672632,
0.0121663958,
-0.0507882088,
0.0294094328,
-0.0401402637,
0.0253200773,
-0.010672519,
0.0639202222,
0.0171120968,
-0.0109473746,
-0.0041936496,
0.0168703049,
-0.0281933844,
-0.0023659151,
-0.0745901167,
0.011880938,
0.005113598,
0.0255318265,
0.030957425,
-0.0413386635,
0.0209407657,
0.0190571658,
-0.0169009659,
0.056050241,
-0.001055829,
-0.0193169266,
-0.0042773257,
0.0014427826,
-0.0136596365,
-0.0104630413,
0.0017194507,
0.0750626922,
0.0019330545,
0.0080095613,
-0.0026219545,
0.0011239105,
0.0426313728,
-0.0454799607,
0.0409626067,
-0.005305036,
-0.0339719281,
0.0565224402,
-0.0336874053,
0.0475734472,
-0.0281585585,
-0.0107507585,
-0.0362264477,
-0.0510150492,
-0.0428256691,
-0.0078615118,
-0.0263912342,
0.0498574786,
-0.0362585485,
0.0060531748,
-0.0432504751,
-0.0048510619,
-0.0055859359,
-0.0140369097,
0.0655514821,
-0.0003029437,
-0.0347589217,
-0.0016573643,
-0.0305234827,
0.0683501288,
-0.0202477667,
0.0337087065,
-0.0509362258,
-0.0889151171,
0.0031360218,
0.0221402794,
-0.0172737371,
-0.0059000975,
0.0292966124,
0.0708237141,
-0.0109023424,
-0.0253788549,
-0.0532038733,
0.0027479483,
0.0245374218,
-0.0561158247,
-0.0250518508,
-0.0934695601,
0.0412353165,
-0.0391044393,
0.048795756,
-0.0477797836,
0.0279991943,
0.023139203,
-0.020859357,
0.00398573,
-0.0198250636,
0.0276645869,
0.011846845,
0.0056745331,
-0.0232686922,
0.0689038485,
0.0315781422,
-0.0172848329,
0.0572067983,
-0.0247833524,
-0.0245746411,
0.0490560755,
0.0248781089,
-0.0172075368,
-0.0087865302,
0.0833482072,
-0.0098111862,
0.0061139571,
0.0621253923,
0.0520751476,
-0.0012676388,
-0.0245726034,
0.0651073679,
0.0505501255,
0.0316676088,
0.0167822316,
0.0503293611,
-0.0342469141,
0.0167845078,
-0.0558833592,
-0.0313116945,
0.0151238805,
0.0429726504,
-0.0002057982,
0.0276896879,
0.038171269,
-0.0289238188,
-0.0529490039,
-0.0028917575,
0.0053678062,
-0.0555458181,
0.0415225774,
0.0235530026,
0.0018493589,
0.0205618516,
0.016224483,
0.0533343591,
-0.0337215066,
0.0387357734,
-0.0623858944,
0.0783207864,
0.0352735333,
0.0443484746,
-0.0268837269,
0.001592839,
-0.0313043706,
0.0466640703,
0.0227345303,
0.0248617046,
-0.059821602,
0.0185467117,
-0.0334879234,
0.0347430296,
0.0049657002,
-0.0209211633,
0.0006316166,
0.0596100762,
0.0565871522,
-0.0215193611,
-0.0246656854,
-0.0471227206,
0.0201064311,
-0.0330829211,
-0.0347721353,
-0.0003885028,
-0.0177411027,
0.020531334,
0.0344150588,
-0.0579530522,
-0.0347958095,
0.0335907787,
-0.0571306981,
0.024248248,
-0.0120901512,
-0.0177869238,
0.0052061952,
0.087067619,
-0.0174335036,
0.0136475796,
0.0558411963,
-0.0422078706,
-0.0344347954,
0.021293113,
-0.0133858025,
0.0461019427,
-0.0555867143,
0.000120087,
-0.0016810071,
-0.0042759348,
-0.0397264324,
0.0807672068,
-0.030342726,
0.007511653,
-0.028730195,
-0.0195654873,
0.0177715179,
-0.0537327006,
-0.0241048764,
0.034895245,
-0.0101943323,
0.0329211839,
0.0071306415,
0.0348236598,
-0.0075928019,
-0.0066010724,
-0.0846759379,
0.01619762,
-0.0426869988,
0.0289020278,
0.0434627533,
0.032912109,
-0.022694435,
-0.0262174737,
-0.0509821065,
-0.0227925479,
0.0057192375,
0.0276432484,
0.018300768,
0.0118023138,
0.0091717402,
-0.0401880182,
-0.0194518585,
0.0081455745,
0.0226305388,
-0.0274777785,
-0.0054077515,
-0.0163761657,
0.0069947098,
-0.0595987402,
-0.0099674193,
-0.024598293,
-0.0184112061,
-0.0322382227,
-0.0106294649,
0.0319382101,
0.0046521099,
-0.0312537886,
-0.0010962953,
0.0202784669,
-0.0017582916,
-0.0568749085,
0.0209572893,
0.0024252844,
-0.0396290794,
-0.0472029969,
-0.0504886359,
-0.004768406,
0.0680821911,
-0.0096002677,
-0.0179631393,
-0.0128619252,
-0.002611405,
-0.0434531309,
-0.0142467273,
-0.0603628419,
0.0393590517,
-0.0138436044,
0.0297855623,
-0.0671885014,
-0.0451660492,
0.03654892,
-0.0110910656,
0.0062615313,
-0.0406161323,
-0.040230006,
-0.0724707618,
0.0411239602,
-0.0107032955,
0.0379668772,
-0.0361346491,
0.0030573409,
-0.0284267534,
-0.0252695177,
-0.0064090942,
-0.0471235253,
0.0923360661,
-0.0344303995,
0.0286775567,
-0.0133946035,
-0.0217042249,
-0.0152686974,
-0.0139559088,
-0.0237907302,
0.0106325839,
-0.0252982806,
0.0000171429,
0.007595594,
-0.0215312093,
0.0134010911,
0.0137604764,
0.0095878197,
0.0072061988,
-0.0066346996,
0.0846022964,
0.0492825396,
0.0300543495,
0.0125910379,
0.0065745153,
0.0297582541,
0.0171392299,
0.030770028,
-0.0278365836,
0.0071960273,
0.0093011921,
0.0157210603,
-0.057317473,
0.0009117952,
0.0058446787,
0.0606887266,
-0.0183911547,
-0.0396086946,
0.0829333216,
0.0149411466,
-0.0121786138,
0.0026134825,
-0.0525490046,
0.0355267301,
0.0536825694,
0.0429586768,
-0.0973784775,
-0.0167270564,
-0.0346780755,
0.0229430757,
0.0408445671,
-0.013558683,
-0.0041833124,
-0.1016474888,
0.0314106047,
-0.0105241938,
-0.0484163649,
-0.0045976234,
-0.0328356139,
-0.0052582254,
-0.0618748665,
-0.0080737649,
0.0128826946,
-0.0384062044,
-0.0089443168,
0.0209537707,
0.0095742783,
-0.0247968473,
0.0069763106,
-0.050639499,
0.0757688135,
0.0232580043,
0.0010734134,
-0.0284308847,
0.0088649932,
0.0472464301,
-0.0279617924,
0.0045430227,
0.0021773123,
0.0079325484,
0.0067052897,
-0.029253995,
-0.0383442529,
0.0078411344,
-0.0216814317,
-0.0004900051,
0.0349638164,
0.0853886604,
0.0063632061,
0.0162502211,
-0.0063697565,
-0.0151555948,
0.0020710886,
0.0663193017,
0.0334425643,
-0.0277609415,
-0.0521953069,
-0.0130785229,
-0.0626474693,
-0.0169330239,
-0.0531278402,
0.0409070626,
0.0439677946,
0.0078654289,
-0.0774688199,
-0.0395231135,
0.0224880502,
0.002697278,
0.0091380877,
0.0253106747,
-0.0181229413,
-0.0118078934,
-0.0829501376,
0.0576524511,
-0.0917633101,
0.0143474042,
-0.0846417099,
-0.0191730857,
0.0816832557,
0.0030962394,
-0.0020677843,
-0.0009109874,
-0.0992958844,
-0.0473175533,
0.0072593661,
0.0809198767,
0.0254740808,
0.0224750489,
0.0044727251,
-0.0613179207,
0.0479238592,
-0.0054097846,
-0.0074535068,
0.0398722105,
0.0086940648,
0.0187466945,
-0.0057474901,
0.0453320071,
-0.065871045,
0.0460350066,
-0.0063263443,
0.0380558446,
-0.0581624545,
0.0082130451,
0.0131070446,
0.0251134802,
-0.0377329141,
0.000306577,
-0.0010639363,
-0.040036317,
0.0294735692,
-0.0211336445,
0.0024286348,
0.0131373061,
-0.0188913997,
0.0451154709,
-0.004049127,
-0.0038833956,
-0.0146623366,
0.019427998,
0.0301665645,
-0.054732237,
0.0268635005,
0.0294983387,
0.0011654862,
-0.0042195995,
0.0213148315,
-0.0198358558,
0.0445607901,
-0.0347697213,
0.0581447557,
-0.0147944409,
0.0353409499,
-0.0272114761,
0.0032911827,
0.0056634638,
0.0191324688,
-0.0411757082,
-0.0677087381,
0.0108834198,
-0.0126209138,
0.0895108879,
0.0096489089,
0.0261198524,
0.0138504896,
-0.009858747,
-0.0078445738,
-0.0124040656,
-0.0088213962,
-0.0161395259,
0.0527796783,
0.032640934,
0.002649178,
0.0222616997,
0.0938482806,
0.0006353577,
0.0604784638,
0.0121029085,
0.0488196947,
-0.0282300953,
-0.0565147586,
0.0257953089,
0.008894287,
-0.0188737027,
0.0066168411,
-0.0304644052,
-0.0664350688,
0.0206481367,
0.0265620667,
-0.0198134091,
-0.0039799684,
0.0293797851,
0.0284418929,
0.0417564437,
-0.017423721,
-0.0811176077,
0.0023062483,
-0.0255967807,
-0.0109703355,
-0.0030798863,
-6.176786411e-33,
-0.0274718441,
0.0366981737,
0.0195974633,
0.0076302411,
0.0061412486,
0.0203758236,
0.0030847352,
-0.0091396617,
-0.0737595484,
0.0061951326,
-0.015762439,
0.0253411252,
-0.0051217517,
0.0341883264,
-0.0145878615,
-0.0047166394,
-0.0061051226,
-0.0431626923,
0.0245320294,
0.0177320689,
0.0087820031,
0.0083485693,
0.0173820332,
-0.0595630519,
0.0038003519,
-0.0105066346,
0.0215710513,
0.0528520308,
-0.011452985,
0.0756737292,
-0.0451653413,
0.065398097,
0.0380953252,
-0.014411821,
-0.013591486,
0.0018892749,
-0.121716857,
-0.0533878133,
0.0410031714,
0.0009220358,
0.0088608842,
-0.0341285579,
0.0124305282,
-0.010848416,
-0.0015870926,
0.0129794972,
0.018488843,
-0.0164245721,
0.0066259368,
-0.0034949388,
0.0000788881,
-0.0044654412,
0.012948608,
0.0272329599,
-0.014292174,
0.0243557245,
-0.0048786495,
-0.0143277273,
-0.0593721271,
-0.0071999338,
-0.0396438502,
0.0404093489,
0.0650951341,
0.0018466311,
-0.0173066948,
0.0428236909,
0.0184149686,
-0.0099543305,
-0.0053419657,
0.0272187889,
0.0011547675,
0.0125331059,
0.0547828861,
0.0625979528,
0.020595843,
0.0041985963,
-0.1020021364,
0.011645373,
0.0761992484,
0.0526098311,
-0.0147803761,
-0.0061798198,
-0.0344899371,
-0.0017963345,
-0.0218654983,
-0.0053789415,
-0.0174352974,
-0.0241228174,
0.0615748242,
-0.0001546833,
0.0055611399,
0.0277425479,
0.0354897492,
-0.052024018,
-0.0212818608,
0.0554229282,
0.0499111712,
0.029544238,
0.0056500435,
0.0453815199,
-0.0742630363,
-0.0062736012,
-0.0128835747,
-0.0156286228,
0.0276322458,
-0.0072567342,
0.0442860834,
0.011259892,
-0.0809275806,
0.0192148201,
-0.0265281387,
0.0575464405,
-0.0080904765,
0.0252704453,
0.0247613247,
-0.0009594093,
0.0117128538,
0.0242685843,
0.0312440507,
-0.0693191662,
0.0083026392,
-0.0559349731,
-0.0021450166,
0.0102484869,
-0.0378431268,
0.0177443195,
-0.0519562587,
0.0456726775,
-0.0249837618,
-0.0367324948,
-0.0189367812,
0.0260280706,
2.477e-7,
0.0634298921,
-0.0069434331,
0.0543119311,
0.053787984,
0.0247346591,
-0.049979344,
-0.0136179067,
0.0275649615,
-0.0470534451,
-0.0028758773,
-0.0042126402,
0.0561485589,
0.0533822849,
0.026332356,
-0.0648891106,
-0.0100397039,
-0.0541929789,
-0.0144639965,
-0.0599792302,
-0.0395764522,
0.0186579842,
0.06933406,
0.0061519537,
-0.0309914965,
-0.063568294,
-0.0840671659,
0.0505303107,
-0.0553653277,
0.0194175318,
0.0339152105,
-0.0186146181,
0.0569416732,
-0.0283723529,
-0.0100501636,
0.0182455797,
0.0183787365,
0.02888727,
0.0707668066,
-0.0128223142,
-0.0117141604,
0.0149551574,
-0.0232284889,
-0.0034673156,
-0.0452200621,
0.0795354769,
0.0322676972,
-0.0093487334,
-0.0135858692,
-0.0180791076,
0.002768429,
-0.0022797678,
-0.043968346,
0.0051226928,
0.0133395782,
0.0478991941,
-0.0290202685,
-0.030172145,
-0.0829834044,
-0.0354957506,
0.0257784408,
-0.0032261431,
-0.017426027,
-0.0162318517,
-0.0032694524,
-0.0400545821,
-0.0768449306,
0.0031771737,
2.153365142e-34,
0.0257757753,
-0.0368825197,
0.0278531499,
0.0827485025,
0.0281263608,
-0.0305092521,
0.0240884069,
-0.0418611504,
0.0033861645,
-0.0567390025,
0.0176014863
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07703v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07703v5
|
OpenLLM-Ro -- Technical Report on Open-source Romanian LLMs
| 2024-05-13T12:46:11 | 2024-05-17T08:19:52 |
Mihai Masala, Denis C. Ilie-Ablachim, Dragos Corlatescu, Miruna Zavelca, Marius Leordeanu, Horia Velicu, Marius Popescu, Mihai Dascalu, Traian Rebedea
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved almost human-like
performance on various tasks. While some LLMs have been trained on multilingual
data, most of the training data is in English. Hence, their performance in
English greatly exceeds their performance in other languages. This document
presents our approach to training and evaluating the first foundational and
chat LLM specialized for Romanian.
|
OpenLLM-Ro -- Technical Report on Open-source Romanian LLMs: In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved almost human-like
performance on various tasks. While some LLMs have been trained on multilingual
data, most of the training data is in English. Hence, their performance in
English greatly exceeds their performance in other languages. This document
presents our approach to training and evaluating the first foundational and
chat LLM specialized for Romanian.
|
[
0.0068991533,
0.0265330318,
0.0080975983,
0.0738477409,
-0.0222735684,
0.0114037944,
0.0027710944,
0.0206966456,
0.0323840119,
-0.025831908,
-0.0749758258,
-0.063040033,
-0.011016354,
-0.0086203087,
0.0300362892,
-0.0235648509,
0.0534706414,
-0.0466195643,
-0.0503589883,
-0.0189837404,
-0.0015223959,
-0.0000050014,
-0.0248124097,
0.0219179727,
0.0284969546,
0.0055535338,
-0.0005434728,
0.0132942554,
-0.0012663782,
-0.0125367735,
-0.0029673968,
0.0127400057,
0.0265273247,
0.0370183624,
0.0000015966,
-0.0620123334,
-0.0024962362,
-0.0156971775,
0.0099516846,
0.0055227564,
0.0650855005,
-0.0471521653,
-0.0351634286,
0.0513730459,
-0.0290746875,
-0.0115186619,
0.0270266831,
0.0388262756,
0.0375181362,
0.1007286459,
-0.0068610557,
-0.0317560509,
0.0189240593,
-0.0388524458,
-0.0255857967,
-0.0087928455,
0.0340683647,
0.0026015008,
0.0119005293,
0.0070974329,
-0.0099998293,
0.03552863,
-0.0054605291,
-0.0045953249,
-0.0196097344,
0.0203387104,
-0.0468961895,
-0.0270176623,
-0.0340655632,
0.0518467873,
-0.0038860133,
0.0040044724,
0.0214060601,
0.0233506728,
-0.0397219546,
-0.0308106765,
-0.0528864078,
0.0653336719,
0.0288444348,
0.042123504,
0.0148573583,
-0.0143895783,
0.0126473829,
0.0048496434,
0.007776177,
0.0632901043,
0.042695839,
-0.0268457178,
0.0263216756,
-0.0091245035,
0.0219249055,
-0.0290867556,
0.0088392729,
0.073041454,
-0.0095463283,
0.0348517373,
-0.0217100754,
0.0120394025,
0.0643585101,
-0.0837166309,
0.0171342455,
0.026328044,
-0.0262409654,
0.0415278785,
-0.0399127007,
0.0523137636,
-0.016291365,
0.0196930412,
-0.0328828171,
-0.0207978766,
-0.0146186333,
0.0298572406,
-0.0450459793,
0.0117777176,
-0.0294104535,
-0.0068193129,
-0.0717583522,
0.0425306968,
0.0523793101,
0.0373705104,
0.0352653451,
-0.0332407877,
-0.0158571005,
0.0009384105,
-0.0374832973,
0.026255535,
0.0088451076,
0.0125960419,
-0.0602040067,
-0.0670952722,
0.0126491999,
0.0408729874,
-0.012384424,
-0.007098902,
0.0209716875,
0.0756196976,
-0.0014609714,
-0.0221000221,
-0.0307313148,
0.0263406355,
0.0101412451,
-0.0984350964,
-0.0284729172,
-0.0721983537,
0.010648719,
-0.0019053494,
0.0081391549,
-0.0556024611,
0.0161024965,
0.0350161865,
-0.0338858888,
0.0382324196,
-0.0491151288,
-0.0083133299,
0.0009375266,
-0.0015390522,
0.0278352071,
0.0816722214,
0.0021752645,
0.0411743969,
0.0496536568,
0.0132113239,
0.0005274505,
0.0802880377,
0.0094341999,
0.0231500641,
-0.0169508681,
0.0409806781,
0.0253478866,
0.0350677371,
0.0575740263,
0.0889027119,
-0.000090031,
-0.0009285018,
0.0610299297,
0.0436354876,
0.0627204254,
0.0354831293,
0.0249560792,
0.0044599273,
0.0205407478,
-0.0078782765,
-0.030058207,
-0.0251845904,
-0.0012085754,
0.014097264,
-0.0093778474,
0.033919692,
-0.0477522798,
-0.019064378,
-0.032735385,
-0.0485102162,
-0.0080080805,
-0.0356447101,
0.0831372291,
-0.0123335458,
-0.0331736133,
0.072446838,
0.0681144074,
-0.0280608423,
0.0003273603,
-0.0580740646,
0.0675719976,
0.0385644212,
0.0224201381,
-0.0371575877,
-0.0120683312,
-0.0192608368,
0.0210252181,
0.0551989861,
0.045938082,
-0.0134523502,
-0.0053868666,
-0.0607509352,
0.0234898198,
0.0073309843,
-0.0004545386,
0.0433048643,
-0.0308623612,
0.0276925601,
0.0181346871,
0.0180290025,
-0.0356766917,
0.0300495736,
-0.0277286489,
0.0151897147,
-0.0088745113,
-0.0143766683,
0.0086422618,
0.0250759125,
0.0064457566,
-0.0269086678,
0.0547583401,
-0.0494276546,
0.0112179546,
0.0002569404,
0.0164526086,
-0.0319281146,
0.0711963549,
0.0001922258,
-0.016715534,
0.0193575025,
-0.0359175093,
-0.0366314761,
0.0479972586,
-0.0035807458,
0.0286735669,
-0.0608293153,
0.0374872871,
0.0023486698,
0.0389997438,
-0.0264327731,
0.0482367501,
-0.0121447546,
0.0129711684,
0.0627539158,
-0.003462374,
0.02888689,
-0.0552243516,
-0.0446853153,
0.0310415588,
-0.0086728232,
0.0197864771,
-0.0245067794,
0.0486184731,
-0.01981874,
-0.0194522962,
-0.0763915107,
0.0376964658,
-0.0511676446,
0.0358714871,
0.0130764153,
-0.002470131,
-0.0210982412,
-0.0460495315,
-0.059276212,
-0.0059524495,
0.019733822,
-0.0257668477,
0.0290430654,
0.019347148,
-0.0473642685,
-0.0400304832,
0.0171083882,
0.0213558096,
0.0008514912,
-0.0224919859,
-0.0169863757,
-0.0879095569,
0.0790214911,
-0.0686380416,
0.052898515,
-0.0322008468,
-0.0473498814,
-0.0235758759,
-0.0076335962,
0.051402986,
0.0147915455,
-0.016810881,
0.0081545338,
0.0607353374,
0.0264153853,
-0.0361153148,
0.0013085941,
-0.0052236584,
-0.0304943211,
-0.0796697736,
-0.0150095262,
-0.0097039072,
0.0429502465,
-0.0427864641,
0.0129932286,
0.0102460347,
-0.0341344662,
-0.0363708399,
-0.0053342748,
-0.0341985673,
0.0138253812,
-0.0288073532,
0.0463564433,
0.0218985416,
-0.0370775983,
0.0239681713,
-0.0622489825,
-0.0060672155,
-0.0333739258,
-0.0676030144,
-0.0841706991,
0.0163520537,
-0.0216176119,
-0.0007986907,
-0.0485123843,
-0.0299801361,
-0.0261789355,
-0.0283823572,
-0.0049864994,
-0.0275829528,
0.0768232495,
-0.0263718776,
0.0136326542,
-0.0302488636,
-0.0260245558,
-0.0420875475,
-0.0223943889,
-0.0315549895,
0.0084669217,
-0.0008708746,
-0.0138804102,
-0.0274634473,
0.0320671052,
-0.0141469343,
0.0265149474,
-0.0207224954,
0.0351043604,
-0.0122221997,
0.0218563452,
0.0461486429,
0.0114984866,
0.0074412548,
-0.0465572178,
0.0105295945,
0.0428440832,
0.0429669097,
-0.035426084,
-0.0314872712,
-0.0255241264,
0.0446993113,
-0.0503951348,
-0.0237777326,
-0.0286916513,
0.0010151189,
-0.0327524357,
-0.0163586736,
0.1168564558,
0.0158900321,
-0.058724191,
-0.0141620217,
-0.0449369587,
0.0359437838,
0.0241532028,
0.0511571541,
-0.0763946474,
-0.004070112,
-0.0158324819,
-0.0044074962,
0.0107697807,
0.0127108293,
-0.03023885,
-0.0947489589,
0.0101756565,
-0.0017443377,
-0.0304563157,
-0.039997533,
-0.0344184712,
-0.0006741289,
-0.0406605899,
0.0354487412,
0.0267380588,
-0.054273542,
-0.0414437652,
0.0238056388,
-0.048369173,
-0.049946025,
-0.0173246861,
-0.0478379764,
0.0804774016,
0.0356056169,
0.0225560516,
-0.0249653496,
-0.0217500795,
0.0821373612,
0.0093412912,
0.0146790622,
-0.0448788404,
0.0189659111,
0.0025585897,
-0.0200572535,
-0.0014492798,
0.0002078194,
-0.0191916879,
0.0056493585,
0.0133317923,
0.0575798564,
-0.0184859224,
0.0028945955,
0.0240104683,
0.009137311,
0.0241854917,
0.039246127,
0.015518507,
-0.006335468,
-0.023934342,
-0.0184434932,
-0.0572644249,
0.0060032671,
-0.0466855802,
0.0149681764,
-0.0251603089,
-0.0534040555,
-0.0376481898,
-0.0302361418,
0.0427461751,
0.0114768706,
-0.0022840069,
0.0244764704,
0.0013079153,
0.008955488,
-0.0074987584,
0.0215246659,
-0.0350081325,
0.0156329609,
-0.0747708082,
0.0018852379,
0.0659222528,
-0.0288744327,
-0.0123925926,
-0.0003524794,
-0.0965388343,
-0.04945134,
-0.0069136028,
0.050160408,
0.0284158997,
0.0463689901,
-0.0284248199,
-0.0640207604,
0.0201183688,
-0.0148410872,
-0.0260811653,
0.0149916457,
0.0423805155,
0.0328998417,
0.0178244263,
0.0557064898,
-0.0283462796,
0.0306749362,
0.0039076484,
0.0053289891,
-0.0077831363,
-0.0333607309,
-0.0110469591,
0.0307626948,
0.0204499159,
-0.0279998966,
-0.0259397719,
-0.0419630595,
0.0686200261,
-0.0510688126,
0.0160483383,
-0.0159546472,
0.0242620874,
0.0265274812,
-0.0057371184,
-0.0273884423,
-0.0225165933,
-0.0481517464,
0.0138316248,
-0.0229390375,
0.0324059315,
0.0023010175,
0.0085865622,
0.0482103489,
0.0221168362,
-0.0172039792,
0.0500012413,
0.0084621683,
0.0253737736,
-0.029983364,
0.0206906293,
-0.0204974413,
-0.0063159093,
0.0076226667,
0.0278267991,
-0.0204583891,
-0.0101903388,
0.0106080305,
0.049470447,
0.0870901421,
0.0372854657,
0.0918416753,
-0.0348182209,
0.0071831606,
-0.0137094818,
0.0496049635,
-0.0365834273,
-0.0277740546,
0.0483063571,
-0.0147437528,
-0.0461710878,
0.030432567,
0.0674987659,
0.0037030987,
0.0010063685,
0.0130921248,
0.0126930661,
-0.0380870141,
-0.0055913385,
0.0099861138,
-0.0294723101,
-0.0460991971,
-0.0278992262,
-0.0364587009,
-0.0570052527,
0.0086897388,
0.021631822,
-0.0383164957,
-0.0157014355,
0.033799082,
0.0375205018,
0.0408260226,
0.0266386792,
-0.0578221008,
-0.0144471684,
0.0033466306,
-0.0200483762,
-0.0182723254,
-5.526772933e-33,
-0.0444171838,
0.0001282854,
0.0352996252,
0.0042806901,
-0.0345801413,
-0.0173529834,
0.0112186149,
-0.0033398592,
-0.0003347655,
-0.00788341,
-0.0154578499,
0.0061405567,
0.025691133,
0.0060142856,
-0.0146819949,
-0.0211557038,
0.0320814438,
-0.0077168881,
0.0120010441,
0.0148937013,
0.0104957931,
0.0545573719,
0.0812380165,
-0.0511009395,
0.0031220231,
-0.0414821766,
-0.0128861945,
0.0490747467,
0.0341627263,
0.0790958256,
-0.0365069434,
0.0403618626,
0.0188992471,
-0.0202469844,
-0.0037999512,
-0.0174290761,
-0.0417606384,
-0.0189044848,
0.0446958952,
0.0575052686,
-0.0060970061,
-0.0147394985,
0.0222295336,
-0.0110443011,
-0.0216819067,
0.0264721662,
0.0251781885,
-0.0307939537,
-0.0308233611,
-0.0034911665,
-0.0381177962,
0.0389379635,
0.0262424853,
0.0100328792,
0.0314548165,
0.0209312905,
-0.0118107507,
-0.0140379388,
-0.0415732786,
0.0287092831,
-0.0101808775,
0.0373886228,
0.0775492638,
-0.0206138678,
-0.0035589796,
0.0438813195,
0.0151038123,
-0.0204814207,
-0.0138286557,
-0.031288743,
0.0410030819,
0.0428242721,
0.0271435156,
0.0359427072,
-0.0256448034,
-0.0171498694,
-0.0978884175,
0.0025430934,
0.0736926273,
0.0301174354,
-0.0023218733,
-0.0134529229,
-0.006064916,
-0.0146667613,
-0.0066879755,
0.0116667189,
-0.0225340612,
-0.0589995272,
0.0210684668,
-0.0023063743,
0.0097223893,
-0.0314255245,
0.0098659899,
-0.0418449454,
-0.0371145345,
0.0006499572,
-0.0045585362,
0.0178841744,
-0.0308947302,
0.0456005447,
-0.0808623582,
-0.0533140562,
-0.0250379741,
-0.0056816991,
0.0025238395,
-0.0173619092,
0.0255270023,
0.0208497103,
-0.0663112849,
0.0140813645,
-0.0240550023,
0.0273522623,
0.0123109715,
0.0711789951,
0.0204535685,
-0.0213678926,
0.0011439807,
0.0753441527,
-0.0084728459,
-0.0148704201,
-0.0221436284,
-0.0633862317,
0.0262785107,
0.033545386,
-0.0481746867,
0.0355944857,
-0.0372906849,
0.0464200936,
0.0251238365,
-0.0286537707,
0.0094926301,
-0.008671537,
2.288e-7,
0.055298686,
0.0575786196,
-0.0107258195,
0.0543836243,
0.0035443325,
-0.0246586818,
-0.0761183873,
0.0302244648,
-0.0071097659,
0.0473920107,
0.0241794605,
0.031506896,
0.0573719218,
0.0099475356,
-0.1102486029,
-0.0162302535,
-0.0704550296,
-0.024302613,
-0.0390216075,
-0.0112037212,
-0.0047928477,
0.1170928627,
0.0028112843,
-0.0114225484,
-0.0460825525,
-0.0343607888,
0.0548063293,
-0.0366253667,
-0.0546920747,
0.0474718399,
0.0552408323,
0.0569846295,
-0.0328717008,
-0.0296137016,
0.0048887408,
0.0410246477,
-0.0099861305,
0.074559778,
0.0093292324,
-0.0312169362,
0.0624968186,
-0.0316748135,
-0.0370519087,
-0.0138815548,
0.055718828,
0.0038129496,
-0.0137895495,
-0.0555700883,
0.0205196962,
-0.0164344646,
0.0195376202,
-0.0366736613,
-0.0174387842,
0.0348100141,
0.0328199863,
-0.061088305,
-0.0394511819,
-0.0638407096,
-0.0259737652,
-0.0263022259,
-0.0295918975,
-0.0648575574,
-0.0057544853,
0.0014713772,
-0.0064747296,
-0.0421698019,
0.0051543764,
1.914777557e-34,
0.0621726699,
-0.0054070768,
-0.0328748599,
0.0629580393,
0.0110622449,
-0.0129673788,
0.0193683803,
0.0194043461,
-0.0053623347,
-0.0749733895,
0.0125599373
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07700v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07700v1
|
Age-Dependent Analysis and Stochastic Generation of Child-Directed Speech
| 2024-05-13T12:35:10 | 2024-05-13T12:35:10 |
Okko Räsänen, Daniil Kocharov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Child-directed speech (CDS) is a particular type of speech that adults use
when addressing young children. Its properties also change as a function of
extralinguistic factors, such as age of the child being addressed. Access to
large amounts of representative and varied CDS would be useful for child
language research, as this would enable controlled computational modeling
experiments of infant language acquisition with realistic input in terms of
quality and quantity. In this study, we describe an approach to model
age-dependent linguistic properties of CDS using a language model (LM) trained
on CDS transcripts and ages of the recipient children, as obtained from North
American English corpora of the CHILDES database. The created LM can then be
used to stochastically generate synthetic CDS transcripts in an age-appropriate
manner, thereby scaling beyond the original datasets in size. We compare
characteristics of the generated CDS against the real speech addressed at
children of different ages, showing that the LM manages to capture
age-dependent changes in CDS, except for a slight difference in the effective
vocabulary size. As a side product, we also provide a systematic
characterization of age-dependent linguistic properties of CDS in CHILDES,
illustrating how all measured aspects of the CDS change with children's age.
|
Age-Dependent Analysis and Stochastic Generation of Child-Directed Speech: Child-directed speech (CDS) is a particular type of speech that adults use
when addressing young children. Its properties also change as a function of
extralinguistic factors, such as age of the child being addressed. Access to
large amounts of representative and varied CDS would be useful for child
language research, as this would enable controlled computational modeling
experiments of infant language acquisition with realistic input in terms of
quality and quantity. In this study, we describe an approach to model
age-dependent linguistic properties of CDS using a language model (LM) trained
on CDS transcripts and ages of the recipient children, as obtained from North
American English corpora of the CHILDES database. The created LM can then be
used to stochastically generate synthetic CDS transcripts in an age-appropriate
manner, thereby scaling beyond the original datasets in size. We compare
characteristics of the generated CDS against the real speech addressed at
children of different ages, showing that the LM manages to capture
age-dependent changes in CDS, except for a slight difference in the effective
vocabulary size. As a side product, we also provide a systematic
characterization of age-dependent linguistic properties of CDS in CHILDES,
illustrating how all measured aspects of the CDS change with children's age.
|
[
0.0090734158,
0.0734831318,
-0.0259437263,
-0.0085779354,
-0.0402214415,
0.0265150648,
0.027057467,
-0.0003605475,
-0.0318102688,
-0.0103984931,
-0.000132331,
-0.0832193866,
0.0552371107,
0.0122289807,
-0.0127261411,
-0.0418375432,
0.0608951598,
-0.0491065122,
0.0192850493,
0.0069209808,
-0.0248332061,
0.0061391238,
-0.0096662734,
0.0144608021,
-0.054216221,
-0.0039776308,
-0.0018798966,
-0.0156697035,
-0.0444993153,
-0.0273992736,
-0.0004153196,
0.0499265455,
0.0467553288,
0.0552119128,
0.000002124,
-0.0553134494,
0.0455823801,
0.0033663739,
-0.0393636525,
0.0094239768,
0.0684192181,
0.0086383149,
-0.0371358395,
0.0013910007,
-0.0202063173,
0.0109288935,
0.0491094925,
-0.0439622924,
-0.0214984547,
0.0460283868,
0.0020481043,
-0.0175265577,
-0.0027050262,
-0.0072342623,
-0.0050843661,
0.0091815544,
0.0030655889,
0.0275471602,
0.0415632315,
-0.0642438978,
-0.0038983463,
0.0214896668,
-0.005651013,
-0.0305175632,
0.0337575488,
-0.0154972188,
0.0283297077,
-0.0528263487,
-0.0333803073,
0.0274929684,
0.0331156254,
-0.0206617191,
0.0100544123,
0.0100131528,
-0.0251194891,
0.009727315,
-0.0377758704,
0.0278779455,
0.0314523391,
0.024020616,
0.0038858494,
-0.035457626,
0.0118202334,
-0.0250748228,
-0.0006759309,
0.0644243062,
0.0138508296,
-0.0634819418,
0.0198644735,
0.0263522193,
0.0363343954,
-0.0068379692,
-0.009103029,
-0.0181573816,
-0.0333531126,
0.0244900379,
-0.0387190506,
-0.0132453227,
-0.0149699766,
-0.001504629,
0.038574215,
-0.0695156753,
-0.0408773907,
0.0033560961,
0.0279551875,
-0.0059622526,
0.0397187062,
-0.010943885,
-0.0612685755,
0.0211858507,
-0.0041683065,
-0.002944469,
-0.0170470774,
0.0074664191,
-0.0247009285,
0.0047130468,
-0.0724396035,
0.0092483703,
0.001440722,
-0.044311922,
0.0238006562,
0.0203097686,
-0.0328358002,
0.0049340641,
-0.0271355696,
0.0215979777,
-0.018325923,
0.0343098193,
0.0157712642,
-0.0520591103,
-0.013999776,
0.0394079909,
0.0401367545,
0.0138274925,
-0.0156352278,
0.0590481088,
0.0033144865,
0.0276150871,
-0.0174871981,
-0.0124447346,
-0.0468931645,
-0.0719381347,
0.0001978689,
-0.0692576095,
-0.0168791134,
-0.0107351625,
-0.026248252,
-0.0670429766,
-0.025840681,
-0.0160138234,
-0.0335751921,
-0.0379103199,
0.0000662857,
0.0617068671,
0.0027974392,
-0.0535108708,
0.061912246,
0.0565413944,
0.0743915811,
-0.1030122042,
0.0535212681,
-0.0321717001,
-0.0661498904,
0.069228597,
-0.0065435148,
0.0362692513,
-0.0136652347,
-0.0282050781,
-0.0185273979,
0.0125216972,
0.0606355071,
0.0134750819,
-0.0080426829,
0.0030070392,
0.0610726252,
0.0671716332,
-0.0179764125,
-0.0283744335,
0.0579874367,
0.0392807201,
0.0431452431,
-0.0253308713,
0.0123950401,
0.0183753185,
-0.0160267483,
-0.0686215237,
-0.0002452582,
0.0422089435,
-0.0257588327,
0.0140536213,
-0.0157989748,
-0.006767476,
0.0020301135,
-0.0128112296,
0.0229053777,
0.0501071103,
-0.0147801647,
-0.0134799154,
0.041647926,
-0.0502885394,
0.0141005125,
-0.0342349261,
-0.0232885517,
0.0255260654,
-0.0303311944,
0.0017167579,
0.0055164415,
0.0117954025,
-0.0154678077,
0.0375273116,
-0.0163227879,
0.0101493467,
0.0265045073,
-0.0050178263,
0.0033574912,
0.0778607875,
0.0274806283,
-0.0009748914,
0.0086352872,
-0.0216178298,
-0.0135836247,
-0.001266425,
-0.0016613019,
0.02595778,
-0.0511069298,
-0.0149683896,
0.0511968769,
-0.0100422408,
0.0478676856,
0.015460629,
-0.0000859339,
0.0306392275,
0.0227484126,
0.047055345,
0.0303846095,
0.0587597564,
-0.0484299026,
-0.0304362457,
-0.0075968266,
-0.0006707439,
-0.0309920758,
-0.0212172568,
0.0228165053,
-0.0173627175,
0.1099582985,
-0.0707884654,
0.0205658674,
0.0099297334,
0.0566867292,
-0.0238473658,
-0.0237580873,
-0.024229439,
0.0350685865,
-0.0053515634,
-0.0205780715,
0.0084938128,
-0.0125057772,
-0.0087790946,
-0.0768133625,
0.0060684611,
-0.043887049,
-0.0337290764,
0.0291790031,
0.0043643792,
0.002899166,
-0.0412362181,
-0.0285539199,
-0.0166901518,
-0.0265842825,
0.013563334,
0.0202353578,
0.005402985,
-0.0101903388,
0.0199141279,
0.023874281,
-0.0243878104,
0.0248013195,
0.0088244732,
0.0334379338,
0.0075636576,
-0.0521577336,
-0.0537166186,
-0.0395694077,
-0.0196786262,
-0.018041933,
0.022795856,
-0.0090014338,
-0.0395623557,
-0.000699461,
-0.0017674251,
-0.0233617891,
0.021328168,
-0.0045132209,
0.0312080104,
0.0361780114,
0.0189788267,
0.0845359936,
0.0318484381,
-0.026242394,
0.008121741,
0.0015313866,
-0.0854750425,
-0.0184480511,
-0.0107007464,
-0.0422986262,
0.0341648795,
-0.0397557467,
-0.0192108508,
-0.0008818195,
0.0518195145,
0.0469022542,
-0.0173136741,
-0.0383210517,
0.0354182459,
-0.0065860045,
-0.0166368224,
-0.0089741237,
-0.0509843715,
-0.0410368778,
0.0388159156,
-0.0168299507,
-0.0796131045,
0.01484848,
0.0065947566,
-0.0294437446,
-0.0469601974,
-0.0066145295,
0.0150376447,
0.0230092332,
0.011280084,
-0.0160074867,
0.010737123,
-0.0145203499,
-0.0770967454,
0.0510740727,
0.0632121265,
-0.0295017306,
0.0493880548,
-0.0830309466,
0.0101618497,
0.0669632256,
-0.021131048,
-0.0312283989,
-0.0332811326,
-0.0007974528,
0.0319009274,
-0.012503867,
-0.0466569699,
-0.0329877995,
-0.0387056582,
0.0230209548,
0.0513189249,
-0.0037131747,
0.0404596515,
-0.003161608,
-0.0025735442,
0.0335384533,
0.0063525066,
-0.0074999598,
-0.0367787778,
0.0099162906,
-0.0081708003,
-0.0150788072,
0.0135884723,
-0.0092712045,
0.0451498963,
0.016331831,
0.0616470911,
-0.0291233622,
0.0607775562,
0.0147967376,
-0.0172762536,
-0.0198257565,
0.0254923943,
0.0416793749,
-0.0057425858,
-0.0066246302,
-0.0129430443,
0.0662285239,
0.0136022791,
-0.0352552086,
-0.0415955707,
0.0195636973,
0.0306872018,
0.0367358625,
0.0004454971,
0.006351959,
-0.0464084782,
-0.0977046192,
0.058831282,
0.0127065573,
-0.0394827798,
0.0326840095,
-0.0120892217,
-0.0391429849,
0.0520173237,
0.0320566557,
0.0743706971,
-0.0572673902,
-0.034017548,
0.0375993326,
-0.0710112303,
-0.0797163397,
0.0439393148,
-0.0175722446,
0.0984087214,
0.063521564,
0.0098035736,
-0.0364223197,
-0.0030170351,
0.0041082194,
-0.0108608641,
-0.0428400636,
-0.0063725105,
-0.0296339653,
0.0331308097,
0.0105677098,
-0.0471383892,
0.0757704303,
-0.0000957574,
0.0096627474,
0.0391788892,
0.0491902865,
-0.0307459719,
-0.0410334058,
0.0148012638,
0.0602438673,
0.0202531368,
0.0268450659,
0.0151088182,
-0.0724090561,
0.0161847305,
0.0241744854,
-0.0041719377,
0.0178689696,
-0.0113970721,
0.0229871906,
-0.0128183002,
-0.0600809455,
-0.1152395979,
0.042828273,
0.0085136062,
0.0029779931,
0.0418025106,
-0.0136840548,
0.048453819,
-0.0555003397,
-0.0118604815,
0.0401109383,
-0.0000709308,
0.0093906997,
-0.0930491686,
-0.0657741427,
-0.0145181827,
-0.0510810018,
-0.0371615887,
-0.0128804538,
-0.0732524171,
-0.0672779679,
0.040506117,
-0.0176394805,
0.0233596172,
0.0424919464,
0.0021166757,
-0.0353352763,
0.0392276309,
0.0083422801,
0.0323235467,
0.0095784897,
0.016564928,
-0.0151062552,
0.0207855366,
0.0085385507,
-0.0227656234,
0.0473887436,
-0.0256938878,
0.0048953667,
-0.0311313849,
-0.0568403229,
-0.0070131188,
-0.019332476,
0.0291114412,
0.0021679359,
-0.011557349,
-0.0799137354,
0.0162889045,
-0.0375381708,
0.0316086635,
-0.0094434218,
-0.0244763419,
-0.0007465591,
0.0285969246,
-0.0065007228,
-0.00747569,
-0.0694384053,
0.0129510434,
0.0212579388,
0.0605899133,
0.0090600792,
0.0445419848,
0.009680626,
0.0399116687,
0.0156869013,
0.0413889699,
-0.0416385606,
0.064687781,
-0.0062668258,
0.0126899565,
-0.0307017863,
-0.0157680716,
-0.0072151055,
-0.0268594082,
-0.0124541912,
0.043945428,
-0.024079578,
-0.0394786336,
0.0393624529,
-0.0183622148,
0.0930643231,
-0.0363858454,
0.0392582342,
-0.0583182797,
-0.0060820752,
0.0021387937,
-0.0234967824,
0.0167155862,
-0.0228057206,
-0.0373295434,
0.0418667793,
0.0347042158,
0.0396316461,
-0.0126701752,
-0.0577292293,
0.0297938883,
-0.013487746,
-0.0300088394,
0.0223312862,
-0.0072537852,
-0.0681882501,
0.0266613308,
-0.0387656093,
-0.0233423766,
-0.0167997181,
-0.0150843915,
0.0209269077,
-0.0232370179,
0.0594635196,
0.0103834448,
-0.0823913291,
-0.0128024444,
-0.0372930057,
-0.0186151415,
0.0040790285,
-0.0303135775,
-0.0031120332,
-6.559772022e-33,
0.0042461674,
-0.0036515268,
0.0089754183,
0.0190628152,
0.0064521558,
-0.0062560118,
-0.0282055531,
0.0466829948,
-0.0139459157,
0.0069308933,
0.001263404,
-0.0348050334,
0.0180453099,
0.0371365994,
0.0459129065,
0.0211262926,
0.0124331526,
-0.0366103426,
0.0437172726,
-0.0266363434,
0.0244370308,
-0.0144333905,
0.0508459806,
0.0083484966,
0.0556971617,
-0.0040831254,
-0.0161533374,
0.0050171767,
-0.0011794837,
0.0456580594,
-0.0105404714,
0.0395252667,
-0.0107978014,
0.0132290572,
-0.004267693,
0.0155445915,
-0.0621151887,
0.0109086446,
0.0469575934,
0.0103731574,
-0.0457485691,
0.0394847393,
-0.0019170608,
0.0218290668,
-0.0219261218,
-0.0024861142,
0.0026106737,
-0.0079477066,
0.002008219,
-0.0224868283,
-0.089192979,
0.0169519261,
-0.0001874447,
-0.0052461554,
0.0188241415,
0.0321663283,
-0.0653047562,
-0.0211202148,
-0.0070458418,
0.0310808532,
0.0552213825,
0.0885374993,
0.0216356833,
0.0175004657,
0.0389627367,
0.030892482,
0.0383994281,
0.0122266142,
0.0201426968,
0.0331230536,
0.0814152956,
0.0251990911,
0.0126435291,
0.0087009603,
0.0181644969,
0.0046077371,
-0.0920305327,
-0.0310062189,
0.0320161134,
0.0479758456,
0.0185415689,
-0.0217374098,
-0.0156088816,
-0.0016864152,
-0.0525503047,
-0.0057053412,
-0.0017296788,
0.0027926669,
0.0039824704,
0.0034825073,
-0.0070769708,
-0.0432062671,
0.0234836936,
0.0159036685,
-0.0364870876,
-0.0513242893,
-0.011503282,
-0.0177253149,
-0.0100722238,
0.0304349922,
-0.0450607799,
-0.0684427097,
0.05290832,
0.0077685667,
0.0332980044,
0.0134658683,
0.0030380178,
0.0193112064,
-0.0855658203,
0.0077618142,
0.0026344785,
0.0506343506,
0.0115167983,
-0.0082826102,
-0.0015637736,
0.0037564035,
0.0015113073,
0.0544406585,
-0.0154901026,
0.0073336745,
-0.0041457238,
0.0023374511,
0.0128658982,
0.0199853573,
-0.0422994196,
0.012734835,
-0.0113335187,
0.0143286586,
0.0608309656,
-0.0076204161,
0.0094661228,
0.0227907673,
2.888e-7,
-0.0199887343,
0.1162140593,
0.0072627426,
0.0128661161,
0.0975572988,
-0.022886157,
-0.0298868045,
-0.0256507415,
0.0446257293,
0.0070219827,
-0.0128010362,
-0.0581837445,
0.1029171199,
0.0218474641,
-0.1149359792,
-0.0444006994,
-0.0837342441,
0.0215840843,
-0.0305704679,
-0.0155610302,
-0.0328237601,
0.0777511299,
-0.0139442738,
-0.0583165139,
-0.0159002263,
0.0437409244,
-0.0034089615,
-0.0236910842,
0.0083865477,
-0.0133131882,
-0.0329319239,
-0.0081253601,
0.0644033477,
0.0578137189,
-0.0786247402,
0.0748526305,
-0.0247615352,
0.0641203821,
-0.0434183739,
-0.0063735577,
0.0313867591,
0.0002220283,
-0.0647869408,
0.0040757176,
0.0237641949,
-0.0114932749,
-0.0065311957,
0.021531526,
-0.0415150933,
-0.0054951152,
0.0028476124,
-0.052323591,
-0.0025600414,
0.0180619899,
0.0308312196,
-0.0060601449,
0.0187440626,
0.0211081523,
0.017484352,
0.0257380214,
-0.0399144217,
-0.0983253121,
0.0303156879,
0.0315565839,
-0.0141943553,
0.0376684032,
0.0243931115,
2.397312822e-34,
0.0484551527,
-0.0200003143,
0.0477935337,
-0.0571686216,
0.0254619792,
-0.0301414654,
0.0463475361,
0.0291677397,
0.0436203517,
-0.0575858243,
-0.0220040809
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07682v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07682v1
|
FastSAG: Towards Fast Non-Autoregressive Singing Accompaniment Generation
| 2024-05-13T12:14:54 | 2024-05-13T12:14:54 |
Jianyi Chen, Wei Xue, Xu Tan, Zhen Ye, Qifeng Liu, Yike Guo
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM, eess.AS
|
Singing Accompaniment Generation (SAG), which generates instrumental music to
accompany input vocals, is crucial to developing human-AI symbiotic art
creation systems. The state-of-the-art method, SingSong, utilizes a multi-stage
autoregressive (AR) model for SAG, however, this method is extremely slow as it
generates semantic and acoustic tokens recursively, and this makes it
impossible for real-time applications. In this paper, we aim to develop a Fast
SAG method that can create high-quality and coherent accompaniments. A non-AR
diffusion-based framework is developed, which by carefully designing the
conditions inferred from the vocal signals, generates the Mel spectrogram of
the target accompaniment directly. With diffusion and Mel spectrogram modeling,
the proposed method significantly simplifies the AR token-based SingSong
framework, and largely accelerates the generation. We also design semantic
projection, prior projection blocks as well as a set of loss functions, to
ensure the generated accompaniment has semantic and rhythm coherence with the
vocal signal. By intensive experimental studies, we demonstrate that the
proposed method can generate better samples than SingSong, and accelerate the
generation by at least 30 times. Audio samples and code are available at
https://fastsag.github.io/.
|
FastSAG: Towards Fast Non-Autoregressive Singing Accompaniment Generation: Singing Accompaniment Generation (SAG), which generates instrumental music to
accompany input vocals, is crucial to developing human-AI symbiotic art
creation systems. The state-of-the-art method, SingSong, utilizes a multi-stage
autoregressive (AR) model for SAG, however, this method is extremely slow as it
generates semantic and acoustic tokens recursively, and this makes it
impossible for real-time applications. In this paper, we aim to develop a Fast
SAG method that can create high-quality and coherent accompaniments. A non-AR
diffusion-based framework is developed, which by carefully designing the
conditions inferred from the vocal signals, generates the Mel spectrogram of
the target accompaniment directly. With diffusion and Mel spectrogram modeling,
the proposed method significantly simplifies the AR token-based SingSong
framework, and largely accelerates the generation. We also design semantic
projection, prior projection blocks as well as a set of loss functions, to
ensure the generated accompaniment has semantic and rhythm coherence with the
vocal signal. By intensive experimental studies, we demonstrate that the
proposed method can generate better samples than SingSong, and accelerate the
generation by at least 30 times. Audio samples and code are available at
https://fastsag.github.io/.
|
[
-0.0004417052,
0.0115099167,
0.0078238547,
-0.0261828043,
-0.0189971421,
-0.0226669554,
0.0732539296,
-0.0242114719,
-0.0439256579,
0.027339654,
-0.0550071076,
-0.0183771439,
0.0059937267,
0.0307522137,
0.0229177773,
-0.0601645112,
0.0187502746,
-0.0293189455,
0.01691176,
-0.0241425242,
-0.0013204349,
-0.0113402987,
-0.0191513672,
0.0285026822,
-0.0835289881,
-0.0253518261,
-0.056746047,
0.0103001446,
-0.0133587932,
-0.0389229208,
-0.0796256736,
0.0020942928,
0.0066990554,
0.0105788885,
0.0000018394,
-0.0283406377,
-0.0189066399,
0.0619978085,
0.0400529429,
-0.0232920926,
0.0189785063,
0.0710037649,
-0.0621971376,
0.0159083884,
-0.0046321559,
0.0304131769,
0.0322777294,
-0.0055405889,
0.0835335478,
0.0594322048,
0.0082652271,
-0.0257990118,
-0.0131250471,
-0.0535438359,
0.0267713219,
0.0195313767,
-0.026032092,
-0.0271829795,
0.0604581311,
-0.0331600457,
-0.0098263724,
0.0689689741,
-0.0077627543,
-0.0027216992,
0.1050226837,
0.0396239795,
-0.027486952,
-0.0822091401,
0.0264444184,
0.0418883264,
0.0217870623,
0.0236746483,
0.0458115488,
0.0285931323,
0.0152932219,
0.0179814808,
-0.0087114368,
0.0196531881,
0.0045663281,
0.0008636841,
-0.0265610144,
-0.0081950473,
0.0204531569,
-0.0368006341,
0.043790821,
0.0208619591,
0.040678516,
-0.0284961034,
-0.0037576417,
0.0096541028,
-0.0108098518,
-0.0354716592,
0.0287701357,
0.0174943488,
-0.0345289744,
-0.0042134793,
-0.051435791,
-0.0393249057,
-0.0243855529,
0.0211999342,
0.0766669363,
0.0158254672,
-0.0051224609,
0.0255583879,
-0.03791463,
-0.0192052834,
-0.0259375218,
-0.0807110816,
-0.0261152219,
-0.0177376568,
0.0152922599,
-0.0114147551,
-0.073762767,
0.0082645603,
-0.0224945266,
-0.0268414915,
-0.0384169891,
-0.0027586629,
-0.0653668568,
0.0463030748,
0.0142221199,
0.0211649295,
-0.0589280687,
0.0034929381,
0.0244867653,
-0.0404273458,
-0.0124146556,
0.0453736708,
0.0370001644,
0.0217165668,
0.0073633338,
0.0220690649,
0.0136694256,
0.045959387,
0.0399074107,
0.0353495181,
0.0193360094,
0.0167711675,
0.0469906554,
-0.0607359633,
-0.0149271861,
-0.0487506725,
-0.0168521516,
-0.0706792995,
0.0270606596,
-0.0411997885,
-0.0536877736,
-0.0082962234,
0.0197868999,
0.008354784,
0.0012994676,
0.0091149909,
-0.0251859371,
0.0775643215,
-0.0072281361,
-0.0047184345,
-0.0665471181,
-0.0298551824,
0.0693915412,
0.0082421424,
-0.0156659503,
-0.031189125,
0.0069030202,
0.024836868,
0.0822406486,
-0.0017575829,
-0.0203735288,
-0.0373894125,
-0.0017252583,
0.0675965324,
0.0320711769,
0.0334948562,
0.0427059829,
-0.0246116053,
0.021367278,
0.0223599076,
0.0547182858,
0.0893027261,
0.0649203584,
0.0254060887,
0.000341676,
-0.0279881954,
0.0237267353,
0.0610791035,
-0.0014409558,
0.0200287439,
0.0489027612,
0.026002543,
-0.0418765992,
0.0150313126,
0.0211521257,
0.0012479989,
0.0088691395,
-0.0115388082,
0.0682633743,
0.0526988842,
-0.0286088698,
-0.0056720385,
-0.0160722584,
-0.0895920247,
0.0238154028,
-0.0255371667,
0.043950811,
0.0388551429,
0.0403355882,
-0.0169413965,
0.0537750758,
-0.0254043471,
-0.0031680602,
0.0520273186,
-0.015604713,
-0.0138305118,
0.0244351681,
-0.0000410423,
-0.0162253045,
0.0245975461,
-0.0336794667,
0.0239847824,
-0.03246684,
0.0216458607,
0.0127263311,
0.0518644527,
0.0585149936,
0.0143490471,
-0.0747065321,
0.016456984,
0.02931224,
-0.0126512134,
0.0551593006,
0.0608379878,
-0.020338824,
0.0374943838,
0.0287456792,
-0.0050676917,
-0.0023802484,
0.0280888453,
-0.0463164151,
0.0162794776,
0.0550793223,
-0.0365203768,
0.0188940782,
0.0099483868,
0.0373013802,
-0.0636002347,
0.0942969099,
-0.0329028554,
0.0084437914,
0.0043177172,
0.0151725439,
0.0353241116,
-0.0134616103,
0.0418165997,
-0.0133385435,
0.0458034463,
-0.0104370518,
0.0223795585,
0.036746297,
-0.011518864,
-0.0354857333,
-0.0067206779,
0.0183455609,
-0.0140784979,
0.0178785119,
-0.0305851139,
-0.0466244109,
-0.04606333,
-0.0305024553,
-0.1175478473,
0.0209046826,
0.0064157839,
-0.0615840368,
-0.016012229,
-0.0168412812,
-0.0091202483,
0.0014251135,
-0.0342530943,
0.0210843254,
-0.0045071258,
0.0066660289,
-0.0549410097,
-0.0054223114,
-0.0646139905,
-0.0180792976,
0.0017637931,
0.024628114,
-0.0374642275,
-0.0044572586,
-0.0044371532,
-0.0327485651,
-0.0267949104,
-0.0389799774,
0.0188840628,
-0.0126378443,
0.005062806,
-0.0007978164,
-0.0157511253,
0.0383568145,
0.021734925,
0.0128997266,
-0.0321105346,
0.0486475676,
-0.0063089137,
-0.0044796322,
0.011752896,
0.0121947108,
0.086275734,
0.0350556299,
0.0085873883,
-0.0153533462,
-0.0125168012,
0.0795363337,
-0.0089757517,
-0.0075692232,
-0.0038065684,
-0.010392582,
-0.0304628853,
0.0238478314,
-0.0174710136,
-0.0115169361,
-0.0129721723,
-0.0271225106,
-0.0395195335,
0.0255937036,
-0.0151103828,
-0.0485975817,
-0.0066232374,
-0.0527444705,
-0.0002893866,
-0.0103617972,
-0.0521681122,
0.0318235084,
-0.0827999413,
0.0179837365,
-0.0283801537,
0.017088782,
0.0021529533,
-0.087512441,
0.0012484893,
-0.0175242536,
-0.0167549066,
-0.0030264675,
0.018744152,
-0.0381492116,
-0.0193832684,
0.0033177049,
0.0151725439,
-0.0500658862,
-0.0212934129,
0.0456775613,
0.0278425589,
0.0319954455,
0.0142110307,
0.0064162109,
0.0282054003,
0.0080676591,
-0.0060016699,
0.038964361,
-0.0013659874,
-0.0381979719,
-0.0351617523,
0.0452337936,
0.0226899292,
0.0204741005,
0.0295521151,
-0.0367869847,
0.0141069582,
-0.0255319458,
0.033191558,
-0.0259796176,
0.0055698678,
0.0394708663,
-0.0281766485,
0.0490672253,
0.0584785528,
-0.0119424164,
0.0013972885,
0.0145937791,
0.0134209488,
0.0387262292,
0.0147824101,
-0.0250419546,
0.0222081337,
0.0125116007,
0.0666674972,
0.0510438085,
0.0378514677,
-0.0076936227,
-0.0192817599,
-0.0156580433,
0.0494673885,
0.0498898551,
-0.0537728034,
0.0207472425,
-0.031979844,
-0.0231397431,
0.0119926156,
-0.0421610996,
0.0414887741,
-0.0082577057,
0.0181355402,
0.0229049828,
-0.011124827,
0.0339274257,
-0.0674445108,
-0.0949719697,
0.0914423466,
0.073403053,
0.0507238843,
0.0140870279,
-0.0339309275,
-0.0164091159,
0.0519715175,
0.0350675546,
0.0094638141,
0.0186289232,
0.0356411971,
0.0021226215,
0.0053845961,
0.0556516498,
-0.0645150095,
0.0342888534,
0.0257288665,
0.0565766245,
-0.030379409,
0.0035757485,
-0.0459195301,
0.0453739427,
0.0363081992,
0.0703185424,
0.0069077201,
-0.0778166652,
0.0090389466,
0.0016891893,
0.0205950625,
-0.0268676281,
-0.009868836,
-0.0101548601,
-0.0101978052,
-0.0649210364,
-0.0590373613,
-0.0127047366,
0.0043293871,
0.0575555153,
-0.0115496796,
0.0341759585,
-0.0415196158,
-0.0525244921,
-0.0737056136,
-0.0170076061,
-0.0274398811,
0.0129010286,
0.0067837471,
-0.0814790428,
-0.0070657725,
-0.0317826755,
0.0008205088,
-0.0467309617,
-0.0578318834,
-0.0499582067,
0.0290522128,
0.0019379368,
0.0189875793,
0.0597966984,
-0.0051341993,
0.0118408343,
0.0281146038,
-0.0252843816,
0.0273852982,
0.0635574088,
0.0264066178,
-0.0363762528,
0.0216382258,
-0.0127962343,
-0.0526844561,
0.0403599441,
-0.0042607412,
0.0622855872,
0.067491591,
-0.0112258298,
0.0180340502,
0.0215959065,
-0.0009191581,
-0.0318206362,
0.0045643905,
-0.029470697,
-0.0376084074,
-0.0512984097,
0.0056545166,
-0.0876600742,
-0.007105038,
0.0079836519,
0.0175599474,
0.001092319,
-0.0280738436,
-0.0344178267,
-0.0214453358,
-0.021507455,
0.0121903596,
0.0114040114,
-0.0270463992,
0.0245775264,
0.0129291927,
0.0668662488,
-0.0055375434,
0.0361492857,
-0.0276374631,
0.0160694104,
-0.0196914431,
0.0118911248,
0.0060216789,
0.0014886993,
0.0233832151,
-0.0114561422,
-0.032377284,
-0.008309409,
0.0277913474,
0.0640767887,
-0.0051685967,
0.0330266096,
0.0054282858,
0.0110377837,
-0.024995707,
0.0685056522,
-0.0246096496,
-0.0388529859,
-0.0191004314,
-0.0205696151,
-0.0057800296,
0.0263244975,
0.0469328575,
-0.0426342823,
0.0066285282,
-0.044308763,
0.0089102518,
0.0112930639,
0.0133255031,
-0.0184579678,
-0.0144730313,
-0.0107788481,
0.0060597523,
-0.0104363291,
-0.0555663295,
-0.0131426798,
-0.0309649874,
-0.0103680016,
-0.0295832511,
0.0531246029,
0.000137882,
-0.0262202006,
0.0481196232,
-0.0195051264,
-0.0695589781,
-0.0353353769,
-0.0492967106,
0.0325177796,
-5.406487167e-33,
-0.0417030118,
-0.00120901,
0.013637702,
0.0029939127,
-0.0557682216,
-0.0251716673,
-0.047637742,
0.0125039769,
0.0150202606,
0.0019438262,
-0.0103659462,
0.0520479456,
-0.0222845245,
0.0056525976,
0.0166967064,
0.0310282074,
0.0628551915,
-0.0344486535,
-0.031155793,
0.0447901785,
0.0505317338,
0.0531123988,
-0.0685309619,
-0.0758114457,
-0.0437880903,
-0.0024501008,
-0.0074687302,
-0.0449313968,
0.0186925847,
-0.0118271392,
-0.0193972271,
0.0265531093,
-0.0256311968,
0.0324616469,
-0.0145621179,
0.0214352049,
-0.0235614777,
-0.064361088,
-0.0368662477,
-0.0060654287,
-0.0491883978,
-0.01763607,
0.0045951302,
0.0124514969,
-0.0569382273,
0.0076001296,
0.0397652276,
-0.0341194272,
-0.0341883376,
-0.0589283183,
-0.0083917715,
0.0173235647,
0.0098779583,
-0.0546845496,
0.0756076351,
0.0415451378,
-0.0082557509,
0.002175394,
-0.0154859032,
0.0354771465,
-0.0542479642,
0.0180176124,
0.0688340291,
0.0193779264,
0.0294726044,
0.0324659608,
0.0663122162,
-0.0480749123,
0.0185354892,
0.0558837205,
-0.0214736797,
0.0702184588,
0.0398898497,
-0.0899802446,
0.0421312451,
-0.045097176,
0.0165028945,
0.0231809076,
-0.0173469465,
-0.0493565798,
-0.0069834534,
0.0380111188,
-0.0492803156,
0.0192143079,
-0.0491680577,
-0.0424510576,
-0.0380504802,
-0.0734239146,
0.032714162,
0.0117110889,
0.0003339877,
0.0033969819,
-0.0204705689,
-0.0046553425,
0.050790675,
-0.024436187,
-0.0352439247,
-0.0091740573,
0.0422977768,
-0.0456222706,
-0.0029859825,
-0.0343685448,
0.0952021927,
0.0124403741,
0.0240641255,
0.0040779202,
-0.0194054618,
0.0772761628,
-0.0267956909,
-0.0247287434,
-0.000515728,
0.0391348526,
0.0391953066,
-0.0463407785,
0.0344321951,
0.0079049282,
-0.0186082926,
0.0404900238,
0.0106610944,
0.0425171331,
-0.0144258896,
0.0002222989,
-0.0332794078,
-0.0422020666,
-0.0218763407,
0.028881168,
-0.0158538036,
-0.0503029227,
0.0577650853,
-0.0438280813,
-0.0583266951,
0.0031909135,
2.879e-7,
-0.0526049212,
-0.0103006838,
0.0000381619,
0.0083881132,
0.0330501497,
0.0287512559,
-0.0813906714,
0.0181679931,
-0.026272418,
-0.0198233128,
0.0319609419,
-0.0271334723,
0.0836404935,
0.0214798339,
-0.0375427306,
-0.0265210159,
-0.0393368378,
0.0240121055,
-0.0285257623,
0.0259481594,
0.0008023289,
0.0389582589,
0.0408037305,
-0.0483478419,
0.0191039275,
-0.0039444128,
0.0499729924,
-0.003649381,
0.0240908563,
-0.0853718147,
-0.0029278798,
-0.0075414917,
-0.0013586452,
-0.0280341543,
-0.0444740579,
0.0291940067,
0.0537434332,
0.0290127415,
-0.0087267989,
-0.0216041747,
0.0316396505,
0.0647471398,
0.0149283875,
0.0469352752,
0.0057652374,
0.0295602269,
-0.0142902816,
-0.0250720773,
-0.0668033287,
0.0305515677,
-0.0346704237,
0.0021936977,
0.0032795516,
-0.0333015136,
0.0121610258,
0.0006314772,
0.0531167649,
-0.0200067628,
-0.0117107863,
-0.0206636768,
-0.0595109016,
-0.0334369913,
0.0086479634,
0.0303990562,
-0.0113121141,
-0.0204462279,
-0.0346051678,
2.231316948e-34,
0.0444009975,
-0.0860101953,
0.0022976866,
0.0033113915,
0.0048779999,
-0.0066410489,
-0.0217824318,
0.0197920091,
0.0143654486,
-0.0145265646,
-0.077834405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07673v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07673v1
|
An Empirical Study on the Robustness of Massively Multilingual Neural Machine Translation
| 2024-05-13T12:01:54 | 2024-05-13T12:01:54 |
Supryadi, Leiyu Pan, Deyi Xiong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Massively multilingual neural machine translation (MMNMT) has been proven to
enhance the translation quality of low-resource languages. In this paper, we
empirically investigate the translation robustness of Indonesian-Chinese
translation in the face of various naturally occurring noise. To assess this,
we create a robustness evaluation benchmark dataset for Indonesian-Chinese
translation. This dataset is automatically translated into Chinese using four
NLLB-200 models of different sizes. We conduct both automatic and human
evaluations. Our in-depth analysis reveal the correlations between translation
error types and the types of noise present, how these correlations change
across different model sizes, and the relationships between automatic
evaluation indicators and human evaluation indicators. The dataset is publicly
available at https://github.com/tjunlp-lab/ID-ZH-MTRobustEval.
|
An Empirical Study on the Robustness of Massively Multilingual Neural Machine Translation: Massively multilingual neural machine translation (MMNMT) has been proven to
enhance the translation quality of low-resource languages. In this paper, we
empirically investigate the translation robustness of Indonesian-Chinese
translation in the face of various naturally occurring noise. To assess this,
we create a robustness evaluation benchmark dataset for Indonesian-Chinese
translation. This dataset is automatically translated into Chinese using four
NLLB-200 models of different sizes. We conduct both automatic and human
evaluations. Our in-depth analysis reveal the correlations between translation
error types and the types of noise present, how these correlations change
across different model sizes, and the relationships between automatic
evaluation indicators and human evaluation indicators. The dataset is publicly
available at https://github.com/tjunlp-lab/ID-ZH-MTRobustEval.
|
[
0.0169536285,
0.054401435,
-0.0023761506,
0.0596065782,
-0.0144541739,
0.0134905642,
0.0263586286,
0.0049581332,
-0.0426874831,
-0.0029576414,
-0.0632551685,
-0.0719823614,
0.0504902489,
-0.0386915803,
0.0583018661,
-0.049205035,
0.0196817946,
-0.0295163207,
-0.0208633468,
0.0175154861,
-0.0131928911,
-0.0061349156,
0.03965782,
0.0337660573,
-0.0121773696,
-0.0121713514,
0.0253237188,
0.0635420755,
0.0434381254,
-0.0412458703,
-0.011629845,
0.0281536039,
-0.0206014086,
0.0918303356,
0.0000020407,
-0.0249314941,
0.0037064308,
0.0379879884,
0.0002184778,
0.05369756,
0.0607694648,
-0.0604685284,
-0.044328399,
-0.0026294389,
0.0188779309,
-0.0088763051,
0.0461410657,
0.0321082845,
0.0699221417,
0.0741145089,
-0.0052517788,
-0.0338842198,
0.0146216163,
-0.0449088886,
-0.0346456915,
-0.0445274971,
-0.0129563771,
0.0053353035,
-0.0475728884,
-0.0023311437,
-0.0059432196,
0.0451036915,
0.0161048528,
-0.0109777106,
-0.0428466238,
-0.022926975,
-0.0143135479,
-0.0466533639,
-0.0069090421,
0.0985242799,
-0.060692735,
0.0259640645,
-0.0474366397,
-0.0170000289,
0.0078981267,
-0.0362256877,
-0.0269050319,
0.0250640977,
0.006446267,
-0.0031807851,
-0.0182275046,
0.0385452174,
0.0656084269,
-0.0085080219,
-0.015202363,
-0.0131932907,
0.0211411063,
-0.0459828787,
-0.0118337637,
0.0049500396,
-0.0115302866,
0.0066236202,
0.0331402123,
-0.0023343763,
-0.0245706346,
0.0239740014,
-0.0451058708,
-0.0473879874,
0.0179729965,
-0.1098079979,
0.056146346,
0.0360526331,
-0.0242277011,
0.0419589579,
-0.0170159936,
0.0480520688,
-0.057265155,
0.0191528723,
-0.0406146497,
-0.016350152,
0.0084516564,
0.038893614,
-0.0120576285,
0.0162246153,
-0.021422198,
-0.0035158838,
-0.0481119752,
0.0014849704,
-0.00696823,
0.0053527867,
0.0180117637,
-0.0214780178,
-0.0589468777,
-0.0418072864,
0.0184337553,
0.0318096764,
0.0040373765,
-0.0188299939,
0.0062289466,
-0.0408647694,
0.0132541899,
0.0271096248,
-0.032168746,
-0.0413844399,
-0.0069937855,
0.1137611046,
-0.010737285,
-0.0088745439,
-0.0568661429,
-0.0013191056,
-0.0157967303,
-0.0275347158,
-0.0016718154,
-0.0303889308,
0.0427625887,
-0.0127916047,
0.0269695688,
-0.052899532,
0.00157441,
-0.0026414113,
-0.0178683084,
0.0538164973,
-0.0152366487,
-0.0121870125,
0.0189134628,
0.0033157556,
0.0063169128,
0.052683305,
0.0726541355,
0.0068900352,
0.0582505167,
-0.0016966742,
-0.0297997724,
0.0499546491,
-0.0073065441,
0.0333444402,
-0.0343092717,
0.0003930047,
0.0078642527,
0.0390285999,
0.0031717946,
0.0915115476,
-0.0310118459,
0.022122208,
0.0876026005,
0.0151364421,
0.0182345528,
0.0596760176,
0.039381139,
-0.0154773928,
-0.0004404395,
-0.003309055,
-0.0290843323,
0.025513377,
-0.0576727502,
0.0183669645,
0.0503821597,
0.0536665581,
-0.009109457,
-0.0704501197,
-0.0204590037,
-0.0124034639,
0.0093818503,
-0.033128541,
0.0245682131,
-0.023429852,
-0.048514761,
0.0190346707,
-0.01345162,
-0.0386227965,
0.0205752999,
-0.0450391397,
-0.0409117267,
0.0528548062,
0.034772031,
0.0225203596,
-0.0290072039,
-0.0224010777,
-0.0184972957,
0.0608811714,
0.0565950498,
0.0188660659,
0.0441124216,
-0.0432558358,
-0.0032448,
0.0383763276,
0.0132630849,
0.0502514131,
0.0065043396,
0.035653621,
0.0428630859,
-0.0232470836,
-0.1207315102,
0.0230910946,
-0.0236766282,
-0.0256631449,
0.0332733132,
0.0085440874,
0.0401813164,
0.0335379429,
-0.0453453138,
-0.0131323393,
-0.010950298,
-0.0178804807,
-0.0090285931,
0.0274940971,
-0.0345492885,
-0.0000607391,
0.036390163,
-0.010923285,
-0.0454611294,
0.0057222289,
-0.0373010524,
-0.0335972942,
0.000395066,
-0.0189776476,
-0.0443817712,
-0.0562105253,
0.0478635654,
-0.0312508196,
0.0202234797,
-0.0318557024,
0.0270196684,
0.0109480554,
-0.0017747697,
0.0030058126,
0.0105899032,
0.0393159799,
-0.0379307568,
-0.0773259699,
0.0337995514,
0.0124894716,
0.0595093705,
0.0105055803,
0.031606786,
0.0001997158,
-0.0388719998,
-0.0267936867,
-0.0114199091,
-0.0271222685,
0.0147673972,
0.0326809473,
0.0165353399,
0.0134517802,
0.0046695578,
0.0133399693,
0.0212123897,
-0.0037673526,
-0.0054409942,
0.0199278556,
-0.0116533572,
0.0110345725,
-0.0222649816,
-0.0107567161,
0.0343280584,
0.0430205576,
0.0411841311,
-0.0542983785,
-0.0889644101,
0.0162175689,
-0.0137433447,
-0.0218353122,
0.0072988225,
-0.0983780697,
-0.0021348852,
-0.0148557657,
-0.0026209378,
0.0503761731,
-0.0116790961,
0.0016584655,
0.0321775302,
0.0114960726,
-0.0199556965,
0.0118903546,
0.0245036576,
-0.0258762632,
-0.0242922343,
-0.040895246,
0.0118425563,
0.0397000499,
0.0024064609,
-0.0120095052,
-0.0300878529,
-0.013651466,
-0.0389268473,
-0.0297129396,
-0.0051052277,
0.0258009955,
-0.0100122951,
0.0449028723,
-0.0049668974,
-0.0429354347,
0.0677490532,
-0.02970149,
-0.0163930207,
-0.0165912118,
0.0084146559,
-0.0153750665,
0.0360190943,
-0.055918429,
0.0199064333,
-0.0083867665,
-0.0259416103,
-0.0303065106,
-0.0289286021,
0.0254765358,
-0.0114602204,
0.0325861722,
-0.0729793757,
0.0003134996,
-0.0303622857,
0.0127180023,
-0.0013263031,
-0.0074526304,
0.0068571307,
0.0005735952,
0.0371884741,
-0.0270182658,
-0.0170649365,
0.0347917192,
0.018521538,
0.0257229116,
-0.0109519269,
0.0056653661,
0.0107955812,
0.0117901806,
-0.0317610353,
-0.0082740812,
0.0615412444,
-0.0775667652,
0.0390543602,
0.0062120804,
-0.0449345261,
0.0100039812,
-0.0482326373,
-0.0305697713,
0.0238148551,
0.0140229147,
-0.0291871782,
0.0129255364,
0.0600379929,
-0.051090125,
0.0152049828,
0.0915137008,
0.0069081145,
-0.0318965502,
-0.0033615399,
-0.005159894,
0.0304048825,
-0.0195238683,
0.0203677732,
-0.0325637572,
-0.0140125426,
0.0098775672,
0.0449348502,
0.0337468348,
0.0145704746,
-0.0038497539,
-0.0935750455,
0.0251655821,
0.0582807399,
-0.0778493583,
-0.0788439959,
0.0029062515,
-0.031253811,
-0.0501326397,
0.0951271281,
-0.0133971293,
0.029364001,
-0.0303374995,
0.0178873986,
0.0195260067,
-0.0965697169,
-0.0171609186,
-0.0565891229,
0.0442901514,
0.0455594137,
0.0271091312,
-0.0287634954,
-0.0006870957,
0.051460959,
0.0257472545,
-0.003130195,
0.0231653154,
0.022611307,
0.0338444784,
-0.0398357287,
0.0037094525,
-0.0209967215,
-0.0179265011,
0.0599692278,
0.0262991618,
0.0315987431,
-0.0065266825,
-0.0021520909,
0.0171311796,
-0.0215342175,
-0.0012967008,
0.0395941064,
0.0234625693,
-0.0439688638,
-0.0101831108,
-0.0363481231,
-0.0354426093,
-0.0735328421,
-0.0133021399,
0.023556985,
-0.0699293539,
-0.0198711287,
-0.098345682,
-0.0778888762,
-0.036458414,
0.0393231064,
0.0208155699,
-0.016645845,
0.0346175209,
0.0250262804,
0.0115571041,
0.0068815388,
-0.0038470903,
0.0226213839,
-0.0776334628,
0.0413076021,
0.0310925208,
0.0071879225,
0.0271877255,
0.0427558534,
-0.0792955235,
-0.0711940974,
-0.0141576361,
0.0539500676,
0.0145119987,
0.028901672,
-0.0385538414,
-0.0623008832,
-0.0003212644,
0.0360834971,
-0.0030554018,
-0.0310908072,
0.052879706,
0.0035976225,
-0.0154949566,
0.0448817164,
-0.020843586,
-0.0064895712,
0.0074950592,
0.044736065,
-0.0155786844,
-0.0578744151,
0.0053730495,
0.051498089,
-0.0180057865,
-0.0475987084,
-0.0187132861,
-0.026601335,
0.0129474588,
-0.0213132761,
-0.0358552225,
-0.0592380725,
-0.0123762777,
0.0739984661,
-0.0001696201,
-0.0014569751,
0.0152758118,
0.02849105,
-0.0098463763,
0.0076379045,
-0.0051771249,
-0.0624661446,
0.0468620695,
0.0029103674,
0.023054434,
-0.0371466726,
0.0155122485,
-0.0206761751,
0.0079043405,
-0.00980986,
0.0415797196,
-0.0104510123,
0.0200877786,
0.0030580938,
0.0337329358,
-0.0331687443,
-0.0173312239,
-0.0311697982,
0.0156210382,
0.0842127204,
0.0316422321,
0.1035173982,
-0.0140147945,
-0.0210160837,
-0.0360688046,
0.0387369394,
0.0153752202,
0.0191296004,
-0.0010830447,
-0.0041502756,
0.0045303172,
0.0182593931,
0.0674371943,
-0.0107158115,
-0.0235364381,
-0.0048301131,
0.0049906522,
-0.0211175438,
0.0045060259,
0.0042453697,
-0.0205509048,
-0.0323591493,
-0.0059218667,
-0.0193974338,
-0.0678299814,
-0.0035736535,
0.0319019593,
0.0325437002,
0.0053060995,
-0.0403863154,
0.0722274855,
-0.0105426284,
0.0686876103,
-0.0358762667,
-0.0199310929,
0.0226463508,
0.0258099567,
-0.0398957245,
-6.206222994e-33,
-0.0255055819,
-0.0048691225,
-0.0130995866,
-0.0578604713,
-0.0144825196,
-0.023257684,
-0.020781016,
-0.0116273956,
-0.0269750711,
0.0070160632,
-0.005925498,
0.0088244043,
0.0231421832,
0.0124789216,
0.01915727,
-0.0019315945,
0.0426694006,
0.0026084166,
-0.0032317194,
-0.00230257,
0.007527526,
0.0246067252,
0.0791209415,
-0.0801290274,
0.0711264461,
-0.0002978678,
-0.0166641437,
0.0035906695,
-0.0118935863,
0.0453819111,
-0.0035619596,
0.0235237237,
0.0021019906,
-0.002653159,
-0.0313468389,
-0.0852300376,
-0.0667720512,
-0.0101464866,
-0.0023467939,
0.0583334155,
-0.008255682,
-0.0212649833,
0.0552240573,
-0.0420893766,
-0.0268852822,
-0.0276272222,
-0.0001865859,
-0.0540139936,
-0.0413222574,
-0.0092730736,
-0.0243357085,
0.0432814285,
-0.0005967725,
0.008608155,
0.0079428786,
0.027197564,
-0.0542068481,
0.0110893352,
-0.0946860462,
-0.0260051284,
-0.0078098229,
0.0341208167,
0.0582089238,
0.0373280644,
-0.0089296773,
-0.0201711878,
0.0200808737,
0.0313393064,
0.0562353395,
0.01631408,
0.0230630357,
-0.0194438826,
0.0949068144,
0.084405601,
0.042310711,
-0.0024614304,
-0.0701495633,
0.0307422038,
0.0041616405,
-0.0167876631,
0.0326167606,
0.0084697995,
-0.0196549986,
-0.0178952776,
-0.0204375833,
-0.0799073651,
-0.0342532471,
-0.0300424788,
-0.0042187003,
0.0041885832,
-0.0240819566,
-0.028510768,
0.0551232919,
-0.0374091752,
0.0045911367,
0.0026952242,
-0.0023429829,
0.0167507511,
-0.0114531247,
0.0445121154,
0.0233075097,
-0.0453611948,
-0.0296395216,
0.0513979569,
0.0051212041,
-0.0495009087,
0.054761488,
0.0309183337,
-0.0250378791,
0.0230613183,
-0.0201537907,
-0.0247997716,
0.023631053,
0.027166035,
0.0075141988,
-0.0508520976,
0.0006062763,
0.0449620709,
0.0294055101,
0.0294082146,
-0.0049806419,
0.0066618659,
0.0097521991,
0.0189300533,
-0.0408608727,
0.0157313403,
-0.0256040916,
0.0009802867,
0.0449829586,
-0.0495554544,
-0.0249894802,
0.0011811586,
2.741e-7,
0.0326586626,
0.0563005656,
0.0155387493,
0.0348352492,
-0.0030191347,
0.0240108613,
-0.0701149777,
0.0078329137,
-0.0241025221,
0.0657870322,
0.0299577117,
-0.0048082038,
0.0976416767,
0.052102685,
-0.0568107292,
-0.06600748,
-0.051573012,
0.0427115746,
-0.0291902907,
0.0006535412,
0.0460130796,
0.0936097652,
-0.0372624733,
0.0141768893,
0.0044423924,
-0.056870196,
0.0568650663,
-0.0042132931,
-0.0155444238,
0.00611206,
0.0674544871,
0.0227606148,
-0.0270329081,
-0.0296299513,
-0.0238591377,
-0.0041280445,
0.0514613837,
0.0821361765,
0.0176479816,
-0.0116608627,
0.0271859635,
-0.0196769647,
-0.0120326634,
-0.0385848582,
0.0346675031,
-0.0341303572,
-0.0321816243,
0.0379124321,
-0.0207464192,
-0.002602567,
0.0554581396,
-0.0635482669,
-0.0258361772,
0.0053334576,
0.0462139957,
-0.0260620117,
-0.0183537677,
-0.0219060797,
-0.0309918914,
-0.0048125023,
-0.0021135791,
-0.0529573523,
0.0057467893,
-0.0150865149,
0.0247404594,
-0.00694854,
0.0030268135,
1.907182417e-34,
0.0760588124,
-0.0217519253,
0.0440680683,
-0.0329630747,
0.0304016229,
-0.014585549,
-0.022596661,
-0.0357565545,
-0.0183915552,
-0.0333162136,
-0.02169214
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07671v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07671v1
|
Constructing a BPE Tokenization DFA
| 2024-05-13T11:59:24 | 2024-05-13T11:59:24 |
Martin Berglund, Willeke Martens, Brink van der Merwe
|
cs.FL
|
cs.FL, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Many natural language processing systems operate over tokenizations of text
to address the open-vocabulary problem. In this paper, we give and analyze an
algorithm for the efficient construction of deterministic finite automata
designed to operate directly on tokenizations produced by the popular byte pair
encoding technique. This makes it possible to apply many existing techniques
and algorithms to the tokenized case, such as pattern matching, equivalence
checking of tokenization dictionaries, and composing tokenized languages in
various ways.
|
Constructing a BPE Tokenization DFA: Many natural language processing systems operate over tokenizations of text
to address the open-vocabulary problem. In this paper, we give and analyze an
algorithm for the efficient construction of deterministic finite automata
designed to operate directly on tokenizations produced by the popular byte pair
encoding technique. This makes it possible to apply many existing techniques
and algorithms to the tokenized case, such as pattern matching, equivalence
checking of tokenization dictionaries, and composing tokenized languages in
various ways.
|
[
0.013607013,
0.0612255186,
-0.0282601286,
0.0342333578,
-0.0391391777,
-0.0007303527,
0.0022893182,
0.0499369055,
-0.0388238393,
-0.0678851753,
0.0420046411,
-0.0072255731,
-0.0148152076,
0.0862561092,
-0.0146941058,
-0.0301666185,
0.0455724485,
-0.012196904,
0.0126559939,
-0.0157589968,
0.0084621236,
0.038301792,
-0.0039810864,
0.0293498039,
-0.0322795771,
-0.0151539743,
-0.0241672285,
-0.0208875015,
-0.0413330719,
-0.0179900751,
-0.0593745522,
-0.000543434,
-0.0022983395,
-0.004940012,
0.0000018804,
-0.071041435,
-0.069397077,
0.0182482749,
-0.0020292704,
0.015045343,
0.0399983712,
0.0004421403,
0.0052635237,
0.0043269261,
0.0049320469,
-0.0730618909,
0.0842274949,
0.0256321207,
0.0874399096,
0.0277679767,
-0.013934385,
-0.0324453078,
0.0519551896,
0.053949181,
-0.0510333478,
0.0039338982,
0.0395755097,
-0.0079169953,
0.0502258949,
-0.0185176805,
-0.0225553568,
-0.0602862127,
-0.071161516,
0.0061559072,
0.0021512932,
0.0251836963,
-0.0081048459,
-0.0332893245,
-0.0288873501,
0.0286405981,
0.0050874734,
-0.012863826,
0.0120771453,
0.0277680308,
-0.048609104,
-0.0003332599,
-0.0002661045,
0.0724272728,
-0.0128175914,
0.0588878766,
0.0510429479,
-0.0086894697,
0.0086308345,
-0.0297654606,
-0.075137049,
0.0964377671,
0.0401896648,
-0.027962666,
-0.0416735522,
-0.0472024567,
-0.0124991369,
-0.1070947424,
0.0394816697,
0.0034470654,
0.0032732836,
0.0062796413,
-0.047592748,
-0.0472184382,
0.018108435,
0.0067222738,
-0.0130081167,
0.046902962,
-0.0425082669,
-0.0134392614,
-0.0303485338,
0.0245881993,
0.015626166,
0.016522916,
-0.0464130789,
-0.0202667974,
-0.0514683314,
0.015669411,
-0.0920755267,
0.0502910279,
-0.0110221598,
-0.0240356047,
0.042737402,
0.0466468669,
-0.0152702387,
0.0363009498,
-0.006918333,
-0.0290045012,
0.0197593663,
0.0291922372,
-0.0154183973,
-0.0282677691,
-0.040466819,
-0.0150581459,
-0.0166810527,
-0.0282095391,
0.0287727881,
-0.0123720728,
0.0497184247,
0.017232161,
-0.0315693878,
0.0819567516,
0.0230915099,
-0.018296415,
-0.0315567367,
-0.023904521,
0.0407678559,
0.0131992353,
-0.0372816175,
-0.054671824,
0.0122074811,
0.0119227711,
0.0052128495,
0.0111876903,
0.0272839982,
0.0294066425,
-0.0150365271,
0.0944453552,
-0.0898034126,
-0.0152279725,
0.0309248082,
-0.0174787473,
0.0268873125,
0.0254821032,
0.0181131866,
-0.0197488554,
0.0446677729,
0.0096668294,
-0.0033313867,
0.0270705298,
-0.0266519692,
-0.0223246459,
-0.0542806275,
0.0211068131,
0.0926621482,
0.000338697,
0.0302053411,
0.1106659994,
-0.0437022261,
0.0284423176,
-0.0501135401,
0.0905006677,
-0.0067287302,
0.0323652811,
0.0447294749,
0.0325145349,
-0.0020234764,
0.0226680785,
0.0371587798,
-0.0376990512,
0.0765160173,
-0.0206554234,
0.0570464171,
0.0022891122,
0.0017254667,
-0.0347314887,
-0.0368374959,
-0.0245869216,
0.0664059818,
-0.0855351239,
0.003880959,
0.0140547212,
-0.0435339883,
0.0658868328,
0.0291420948,
-0.0356397144,
0.0001131111,
-0.0712131262,
0.0319447368,
0.0666148439,
0.0453490652,
0.0040135873,
0.0417862646,
-0.0337920263,
-0.0079377284,
0.0092136739,
-0.0111586191,
-0.0302645713,
-0.033784721,
-0.0301750377,
-0.0098138927,
-0.0335364901,
0.0226194169,
0.0155730341,
-0.0240966137,
0.0315004289,
-0.0101090968,
-0.0256941523,
-0.0256820843,
0.0470279567,
0.0765134841,
-0.048979491,
0.0350488126,
0.0141959889,
0.0389148146,
0.0415305607,
-0.0324101001,
0.0540637039,
-0.0039097969,
-0.0266023502,
-0.0101751005,
0.0070733596,
0.0364861973,
0.0395436548,
0.044222109,
-0.0230718162,
0.0085620852,
0.0235308781,
-0.0162237491,
-0.0433036871,
0.0160897467,
-0.0485073887,
0.0427422412,
-0.0121681383,
0.0156135466,
0.0028919606,
0.0292660706,
-0.0083877267,
0.0140486406,
0.0219012722,
-0.0184056181,
-0.0565088391,
-0.0164967719,
0.0869325027,
-0.0147301806,
-0.0422613434,
0.0187105089,
-0.0308561586,
0.0099861789,
0.028540872,
0.0024194634,
0.0031501243,
-0.0051763486,
-0.0837951154,
0.0128863975,
-0.0191953927,
0.0269600805,
0.0293664057,
0.05524211,
-0.0163033046,
0.0143956542,
-0.0102585172,
-0.0069884113,
0.0224159565,
0.0016371139,
0.0575341918,
0.006720427,
-0.0887160972,
0.0267516002,
-0.0127449222,
-0.0287383553,
0.0351731889,
0.0070847403,
-0.044545047,
-0.0644451529,
0.0037762087,
-0.0138261588,
0.0558609776,
0.0468397625,
-0.017284777,
0.0629554614,
-0.0269625485,
0.0341270603,
0.0293022729,
0.0285424683,
-0.023220621,
0.0873812512,
0.0024726584,
0.0053860932,
-0.0036916418,
0.0170960166,
0.0048896633,
0.0295800567,
-0.0398706011,
0.0681551546,
-0.0248078294,
-0.0011225011,
-0.0080807311,
0.0164870117,
-0.0316941179,
-0.0150864394,
0.01571442,
-0.0343169793,
-0.0946535766,
-0.029492395,
0.0370102189,
0.0080567608,
-0.0154069848,
0.034903653,
-0.0607083961,
0.0497156456,
-0.0715086386,
0.0213770922,
-0.0069342311,
0.0580088198,
-0.0303533226,
0.0529565066,
-0.0259213597,
-0.0651698709,
0.0018974985,
-0.0231977049,
0.00244259,
-0.0090458393,
0.0146855824,
-0.0280622654,
0.0188076291,
0.0011724838,
-0.0022534516,
-0.0725741163,
0.0356865004,
-0.0479996316,
0.0229335427,
0.0385285914,
0.0061885025,
-0.0236189086,
0.0455642305,
-0.0215801168,
0.0198637489,
0.0371228568,
0.0193788521,
-0.0182827991,
0.0276395325,
-0.0231286623,
-0.0120881116,
-0.0667440742,
0.0338084623,
-0.0203502476,
0.0142065762,
0.0429704152,
0.0182908401,
-0.0100515615,
-0.0265580323,
0.0199645143,
-0.1008535847,
0.0136216069,
0.0165913161,
-0.0062153647,
0.0257974397,
-0.0339857601,
0.107810773,
0.0514937676,
-0.0158806518,
0.0242061224,
-0.0289838407,
-0.0827073976,
-0.0098511493,
0.0365286171,
-0.11428608,
-0.0079136714,
0.0055946382,
-0.0062259175,
0.0119724898,
0.0203242023,
-0.021632174,
-0.0901429802,
-0.0059057348,
-0.0085604535,
-0.0030370285,
-0.0084044393,
-0.0405983701,
-0.0083966898,
0.0025900707,
0.0013092377,
0.0198030863,
0.0665678307,
-0.0042622965,
0.0069792499,
0.0212178882,
0.0323036946,
0.0199944898,
-0.0482531898,
0.0492035225,
0.0708369538,
0.0623975545,
-0.0079306625,
-0.0165562294,
0.0252718572,
0.0083772596,
-0.0160143226,
0.0055747032,
-0.0194599759,
-0.022275744,
-0.0067167645,
0.0461436771,
0.0372917876,
0.0123648206,
-0.0186458826,
0.0051299045,
0.0141342804,
0.0301058982,
0.0135785975,
-0.0216414984,
-0.0312831849,
0.0313092619,
0.0074476879,
0.0095186057,
0.0088946167,
-0.0207426641,
-0.03251829,
-0.0071201613,
-0.0658776239,
0.0067224354,
-0.0715831369,
-0.0192566961,
-0.0536930747,
-0.0826030076,
0.0706741661,
-0.0058241137,
0.0157891214,
-0.0056473585,
-0.0070034028,
0.022279663,
0.0042570755,
-0.0578690171,
-0.0481725857,
-0.0098531842,
0.0249040071,
-0.0611003935,
-0.0521824732,
-0.0117971906,
0.0124668572,
-0.0502136797,
0.0176593214,
-0.00313451,
-0.0083328038,
0.0504566766,
0.0206928942,
0.0136946617,
-0.0016361433,
-0.0255684704,
0.0064041824,
0.0311499573,
0.0614846498,
-0.0314819366,
-0.0099907639,
-0.0101846969,
0.0453047641,
0.0130995037,
-0.0093223117,
-0.0085922303,
-0.0085014915,
-0.0445734411,
-0.0077895978,
0.0322060287,
-0.0331617408,
0.0541937426,
0.092348896,
0.0252788756,
-0.0129668489,
0.0351356454,
0.0044701993,
-0.0023126123,
-0.0339007899,
-0.0271089058,
-0.0186741464,
0.0387395471,
-0.0289628971,
-0.027456291,
0.0030091065,
-0.049077563,
-0.0652153045,
0.0181163959,
0.0831946209,
0.036257904,
0.0266709067,
0.0586239733,
0.008934401,
-0.0221416913,
-0.0057317619,
-0.0275525674,
-0.0071889451,
-0.0144405933,
-0.0617768541,
-0.0201698113,
0.0086233178,
0.0124549717,
-0.053039562,
0.0196816791,
-0.0011608138,
-0.0163778737,
0.0104291197,
0.0386386886,
-0.0157995988,
0.008348736,
-0.0177420136,
-0.0577227063,
-0.0042337589,
0.0218623858,
0.0047626398,
-0.0147677092,
-0.0175008141,
0.0142620569,
0.0099541834,
0.0040142126,
-0.0611714944,
0.0407126509,
-0.0522730537,
0.0228326563,
-0.0148290247,
-0.023942098,
-0.049657438,
0.0080487374,
-0.0007990932,
0.0635760352,
-0.032472223,
-0.0266239941,
-0.0034965242,
-0.0196779929,
0.024193624,
0.0450568423,
0.0466796719,
0.0487666093,
0.0448587947,
0.0184282269,
0.0527926572,
-0.0093022548,
-0.0143416934,
0.0050265105,
0.0159152374,
-0.0577616766,
-0.0123820044,
-5.444950812e-33,
-0.0008086576,
-0.0039462266,
-0.0406667553,
-0.0254159532,
0.0064248014,
0.0087753292,
-0.0152989067,
-0.0259239804,
0.0383416787,
-0.0164760109,
-0.0051300167,
0.0054335524,
0.0275239181,
-0.0013729411,
-0.0359051414,
0.0111614317,
0.0385155566,
-0.0373348743,
-0.0377797447,
-0.0056353034,
0.0815844908,
-0.0310555138,
-0.0205619372,
-0.0118863024,
0.0233988389,
-0.0450529382,
-0.0652424768,
0.0047587375,
0.0303248186,
0.032688681,
-0.0260050967,
0.0267782193,
-0.0125979744,
0.0596505478,
-0.0161939207,
0.0648669824,
-0.0543123446,
-0.0422990732,
0.035881158,
0.0085773906,
0.0228106715,
-0.0290641077,
0.0169014949,
-0.0205776431,
-0.0163676627,
0.068149209,
-0.0119415894,
0.0062161461,
0.0077562612,
0.0164184496,
-0.0681376234,
-0.0031815215,
0.0059839943,
0.0300371293,
0.0411437154,
-0.0695056617,
0.0192924477,
-0.0613333397,
-0.0026149659,
0.0523884408,
0.03053209,
0.0113196764,
0.0134508107,
-0.0486664213,
0.0041498067,
0.0319842808,
0.0215267036,
-0.0454043262,
-0.0136867994,
0.0598984212,
-0.0270415898,
-0.0012882893,
-0.0368136875,
0.042320352,
0.0636800081,
-0.0629115924,
-0.0422066338,
0.039323125,
-0.007013726,
0.009511509,
-0.0124963745,
0.0195822138,
-0.015715031,
-0.0217528734,
-0.0563492216,
0.0395207927,
-0.036335744,
-0.0031434044,
0.0034487816,
-0.0194645505,
-0.0927776545,
-0.0260968432,
-0.0149874408,
-0.050199192,
-0.0165261813,
0.0057974821,
-0.0052004894,
-0.0050854171,
-0.02537141,
-0.022538323,
0.0090540554,
-0.0692368001,
0.0164439268,
-0.0235769227,
0.007591513,
0.0106551843,
-0.0404910967,
0.0175606031,
-0.0760717914,
0.0241042115,
0.0065957857,
-0.0047082105,
-0.0126951206,
0.0173079837,
0.0224536173,
0.0118908891,
0.0232318975,
-0.0450802036,
0.0244155452,
-0.0399853103,
-0.0034867842,
0.0177231934,
-0.0016146277,
0.032847967,
-0.0351192206,
0.0145348525,
-0.0282792468,
0.0146446778,
0.0462205485,
-0.0092710722,
0.0028376428,
0.0204931498,
2.709e-7,
0.0197771136,
0.0265293196,
0.0877469629,
0.0142038809,
-0.0055703404,
-0.0135605782,
-0.000482069,
0.0391099676,
-0.0467426181,
0.0035349275,
-0.0130517501,
-0.0037949421,
-0.0605508611,
0.0257532746,
-0.0841379091,
0.0266746301,
0.0175036397,
-0.014441208,
-0.0662518367,
-0.0111003602,
0.0926605612,
0.0346094891,
0.0066190297,
0.013181258,
-0.0297066551,
-0.0674576759,
-0.0045280657,
0.0226119421,
0.0454244912,
0.018599432,
-0.0295120105,
-0.0028054735,
0.0331156179,
0.0064503285,
-0.007183223,
0.0252364017,
0.0082690204,
0.0052766334,
0.013256764,
0.0560328029,
-0.0001360163,
-0.0284037516,
-0.0073181232,
0.0091633629,
0.046389509,
0.0155856721,
-0.0283741746,
-0.0446462221,
-0.0379379764,
0.0306623485,
-0.0633084327,
-0.0060012275,
-0.0281361528,
0.0703289807,
0.0024784771,
0.0402184203,
0.0271605924,
-0.0430971198,
-0.0141708525,
-0.0667885393,
-0.0044052997,
-0.0221813694,
0.0055165729,
0.0323275663,
0.0551816002,
-0.037424624,
0.0151571818,
2.385802161e-34,
0.0120816296,
-0.0208814405,
-0.0343272686,
0.0176224913,
0.004467376,
-0.0082895141,
-0.0056545436,
0.0248128809,
0.0066042813,
-0.0063090697,
-0.0255631544
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07667v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07667v1
|
Backdoor Removal for Generative Large Language Models
| 2024-05-13T11:53:42 | 2024-05-13T11:53:42 |
Haoran Li, Yulin Chen, Zihao Zheng, Qi Hu, Chunkit Chan, Heshan Liu, Yangqiu Song
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL
|
With rapid advances, generative large language models (LLMs) dominate various
Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks from understanding to reasoning. Yet,
language models' inherent vulnerabilities may be exacerbated due to increased
accessibility and unrestricted model training on massive textual data from the
Internet. A malicious adversary may publish poisoned data online and conduct
backdoor attacks on the victim LLMs pre-trained on the poisoned data.
Backdoored LLMs behave innocuously for normal queries and generate harmful
responses when the backdoor trigger is activated. Despite significant efforts
paid to LLMs' safety issues, LLMs are still struggling against backdoor
attacks. As Anthropic recently revealed, existing safety training strategies,
including supervised fine-tuning (SFT) and Reinforcement Learning from Human
Feedback (RLHF), fail to revoke the backdoors once the LLM is backdoored during
the pre-training stage. In this paper, we present Simulate and Eliminate
(SANDE) to erase the undesired backdoored mappings for generative LLMs. We
initially propose Overwrite Supervised Fine-tuning (OSFT) for effective
backdoor removal when the trigger is known. Then, to handle the scenarios where
the trigger patterns are unknown, we integrate OSFT into our two-stage
framework, SANDE. Unlike previous works that center on the identification of
backdoors, our safety-enhanced LLMs are able to behave normally even when the
exact triggers are activated. We conduct comprehensive experiments to show that
our proposed SANDE is effective against backdoor attacks while bringing minimal
harm to LLMs' powerful capability without any additional access to unbackdoored
clean models. We will release the reproducible code.
|
Backdoor Removal for Generative Large Language Models: With rapid advances, generative large language models (LLMs) dominate various
Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks from understanding to reasoning. Yet,
language models' inherent vulnerabilities may be exacerbated due to increased
accessibility and unrestricted model training on massive textual data from the
Internet. A malicious adversary may publish poisoned data online and conduct
backdoor attacks on the victim LLMs pre-trained on the poisoned data.
Backdoored LLMs behave innocuously for normal queries and generate harmful
responses when the backdoor trigger is activated. Despite significant efforts
paid to LLMs' safety issues, LLMs are still struggling against backdoor
attacks. As Anthropic recently revealed, existing safety training strategies,
including supervised fine-tuning (SFT) and Reinforcement Learning from Human
Feedback (RLHF), fail to revoke the backdoors once the LLM is backdoored during
the pre-training stage. In this paper, we present Simulate and Eliminate
(SANDE) to erase the undesired backdoored mappings for generative LLMs. We
initially propose Overwrite Supervised Fine-tuning (OSFT) for effective
backdoor removal when the trigger is known. Then, to handle the scenarios where
the trigger patterns are unknown, we integrate OSFT into our two-stage
framework, SANDE. Unlike previous works that center on the identification of
backdoors, our safety-enhanced LLMs are able to behave normally even when the
exact triggers are activated. We conduct comprehensive experiments to show that
our proposed SANDE is effective against backdoor attacks while bringing minimal
harm to LLMs' powerful capability without any additional access to unbackdoored
clean models. We will release the reproducible code.
|
[
0.0567594022,
0.0771304145,
-0.0078462707,
0.029577136,
-0.0416210145,
-0.0040754848,
-0.0150262862,
-0.0090612015,
0.036994122,
-0.0491708033,
-0.0093609123,
0.000259416,
-0.0148990573,
0.0448684394,
0.0620083176,
0.0313806236,
0.0670694411,
-0.0541035943,
-0.035282772,
-0.0013411994,
-0.0370162949,
-0.0036450012,
0.0248284787,
0.0093849599,
0.0208757967,
-0.0174535587,
-0.0164641682,
-0.003013161,
0.0333172828,
-0.0191732254,
-0.0032587864,
0.0435665138,
0.0044324039,
0.0596747473,
0.0000020584,
-0.0419996269,
-0.0364415869,
0.021413995,
-0.0032301187,
0.0322688743,
0.0080333138,
-0.0157682486,
-0.0460338779,
0.0421628021,
-0.0452515371,
-0.0204027649,
0.0071512633,
0.0729588643,
0.0815687105,
0.1041733846,
0.0016517454,
-0.0505420826,
0.0804107338,
-0.039575059,
0.0084487107,
-0.0523404591,
0.051486589,
-0.0382831171,
-0.0262376219,
-0.0079913149,
-0.0182227623,
0.0154775605,
-0.0114616053,
-0.0066091963,
-0.0274669752,
0.0436641239,
-0.0140754823,
-0.0243604649,
-0.020807907,
0.0665541291,
-0.0354335979,
-0.0051795524,
0.0181381591,
-0.0090901032,
-0.0043276213,
0.022659149,
0.0157891829,
0.0339375399,
-0.0005703998,
0.0254792087,
0.0104309274,
-0.062063314,
0.0506122671,
0.0403117277,
0.0069096368,
0.0423251763,
0.0188092496,
-0.0263829324,
-0.0020094025,
-0.0517954454,
-0.0136962803,
-0.0501854792,
-0.0073690894,
0.0049396059,
-0.0086824326,
0.0294745862,
-0.0343303494,
-0.0174186807,
0.0363406427,
-0.0460243225,
-0.0045594182,
0.0134797264,
0.0046644495,
0.0384747796,
-0.041075699,
0.020371981,
-0.040110454,
0.045324374,
0.0329731554,
0.0193230584,
-0.0359116718,
-0.0150078395,
-0.0312055536,
0.0039006507,
-0.0372953825,
-0.0144706098,
-0.0340278372,
0.014862258,
-0.0169075727,
0.0208452102,
0.0026990294,
0.0253675841,
-0.0306464192,
0.0049052779,
0.0006231728,
-0.0222052857,
0.0022743153,
-0.0076489896,
-0.0101361237,
-0.0837547481,
-0.0177003872,
-0.0043560453,
-0.0230081845,
-0.017862631,
0.0015335635,
0.0832480341,
0.0242921617,
-0.0162240751,
-0.0923060551,
-0.0635973662,
-0.0169808399,
-0.0410848446,
0.0061487053,
-0.059379071,
-0.0260157175,
-0.0440058187,
0.0008559274,
-0.028495796,
0.0145549569,
0.0232384615,
-0.0471161343,
0.0846905261,
-0.0046492186,
-0.007165614,
0.0171707086,
0.0043435628,
0.0077724019,
0.0525272414,
0.0056478428,
0.0388688818,
0.0368268974,
-0.0255245455,
0.0311185047,
0.0383531228,
0.0155248251,
0.0263861697,
-0.0506119877,
0.0067207161,
0.0121067297,
-0.0068848357,
-0.0028681927,
0.0574761704,
-0.0318459421,
-0.0092357099,
0.0778603852,
0.0216683168,
-0.0107123647,
0.049397435,
0.0087436847,
0.0090315491,
-0.0488561541,
-0.0027438188,
-0.0773070902,
-0.0248077661,
-0.0831022859,
-0.0203051791,
0.0100872722,
0.0316734463,
0.0036739029,
-0.0168284252,
-0.0025765055,
0.0041323174,
0.0179830305,
-0.0038658557,
0.0459468402,
0.0679343045,
-0.0118912272,
-0.0118875774,
0.0169073269,
-0.0249668397,
-0.0078894766,
-0.0647402704,
-0.0360520668,
0.0786426589,
0.0915222019,
0.0175035279,
0.0098197544,
-0.0612955876,
-0.0341881476,
0.0178535469,
-0.010340645,
0.0239183921,
0.0018952464,
-0.0394559726,
-0.023425892,
0.0315691084,
0.0281444974,
-0.0037791927,
0.0348447561,
-0.0256542098,
0.0104356119,
0.014860739,
-0.0285840239,
0.0415928215,
-0.0107085332,
-0.0868242905,
0.0209439732,
0.0160751306,
0.030558832,
-0.0237949714,
-0.0152260792,
0.0269637369,
0.0359849185,
0.014835719,
-0.0379416645,
-0.0358153023,
-0.0041958392,
0.0172628369,
0.027265517,
-0.0117216827,
-0.0093741445,
0.0580734648,
-0.0395701863,
-0.0244525783,
0.0184701569,
-0.0365637355,
0.018707443,
-0.0402801074,
0.0047583478,
0.008864793,
0.0058853384,
-0.0297969151,
0.0584543087,
-0.0050412747,
-0.0115281986,
-0.0360218249,
-0.0029850067,
0.0107182842,
-0.0131519092,
-0.0451701656,
0.0172862001,
-0.0323132426,
0.0277066361,
-0.0095597869,
-0.000666785,
-0.0517975762,
-0.0149877295,
-0.0263827909,
0.0228342842,
-0.0199539419,
0.0374167375,
0.0209688544,
-0.0013521108,
-0.0385203809,
-0.0262972191,
0.0056949323,
-0.0053565651,
0.0002126467,
0.0318772122,
0.0054607056,
-0.0114439568,
0.0046822326,
-0.0022087195,
-0.011276735,
-0.0198949724,
0.0656698942,
-0.0114185633,
0.022060331,
-0.0537840351,
0.024620682,
0.0005586779,
0.0680430308,
-0.0170208104,
-0.0567804798,
-0.0040451293,
-0.0018846823,
-0.0090398714,
0.0608236194,
0.0301913451,
-0.0085242894,
0.07460168,
0.008766924,
-0.0596396327,
0.0171103459,
-0.0106414864,
-0.0698831305,
-0.0629097596,
0.0323841944,
-0.0053759622,
0.0499993525,
0.0253864229,
-0.0286841244,
-0.0292398985,
0.0212059263,
0.0114950491,
-0.0205359887,
-0.0276345089,
-0.0535254776,
-0.0509299934,
-0.0022685465,
-0.0218173489,
-0.0755032599,
0.0669277683,
-0.0197233129,
0.0440516844,
-0.0282200016,
-0.0117620863,
-0.0040743127,
0.0477419458,
-0.015802497,
0.0219227634,
0.0488558747,
-0.0398118719,
-0.0418920815,
-0.0218371861,
0.0409492105,
-0.026023753,
0.0052499943,
-0.0159339067,
-0.0000779506,
-0.0140411472,
-0.0428160354,
-0.0599706471,
-0.0710877553,
-0.019202305,
0.0159135796,
0.0222106203,
-0.0238954965,
0.0055285702,
-0.0249281432,
0.0058842702,
0.0051395572,
-0.0157374348,
-0.0167287234,
-0.0350189582,
0.006273963,
0.0640798286,
-0.0665361509,
0.0179864224,
0.0024614043,
0.0194056984,
0.0732097998,
0.045903936,
-0.0095989322,
-0.0414506048,
0.0142267458,
0.0134471189,
-0.0270471014,
-0.0013583581,
0.0218823683,
0.0015366073,
-0.0481727459,
-0.0189168844,
0.0669571534,
0.0086169764,
-0.0484420992,
0.0107486574,
0.0441602319,
0.0080412189,
0.0119733661,
0.0164723322,
-0.0680728778,
-0.0269064512,
0.0366226099,
0.0337468162,
-0.0276704133,
-0.0348061658,
0.0064649805,
-0.1723681688,
0.0259071477,
0.0099105481,
-0.0252226107,
-0.002065798,
-0.0611084737,
-0.0133693824,
-0.0071049347,
0.0071643498,
0.0038887591,
0.0007983473,
-0.0185578,
-0.0005866346,
0.0385426804,
-0.0486132801,
0.0072963154,
-0.0525534861,
0.0574616231,
0.0846613273,
0.0118221836,
0.0059774974,
0.009306388,
0.052737046,
-0.0011336871,
0.021014547,
0.0054161716,
0.0515078865,
-0.0155340666,
-0.0091742836,
0.0031425485,
0.0688322484,
-0.0125491945,
-0.0074654738,
-0.0001494396,
0.0645068958,
-0.0039677396,
-0.0033150432,
-0.0224196631,
-0.0258286241,
0.0272658169,
0.0563718863,
0.0051607057,
-0.0293897968,
-0.0507993065,
-0.0509562865,
-0.0075083445,
-0.0016515718,
-0.0587332882,
0.0108505562,
0.0177936368,
-0.0553293042,
-0.041769065,
0.0037805978,
-0.0060875751,
0.0104807541,
0.0373898633,
0.025806671,
0.0040203673,
0.0279328786,
-0.0309654698,
0.0136140138,
-0.051036492,
0.0399090126,
-0.0420137756,
0.0267636068,
0.0443045422,
-0.0090105655,
-0.0221640486,
0.0400129706,
-0.0664358735,
-0.0953933969,
-0.011907666,
0.0321419127,
0.0231423173,
0.0489340276,
-0.0520130061,
-0.0746305436,
0.0809485465,
0.0664874315,
-0.051923845,
0.0054738699,
0.0467004888,
-0.0144958142,
0.0160443615,
0.0534504391,
-0.020312123,
-0.0227077063,
0.0591339804,
0.0231930483,
0.0074380832,
0.0105978977,
0.0039944174,
0.0479032211,
0.1006161869,
-0.0206716321,
0.0120391035,
-0.0102294208,
0.0281172451,
-0.0192519687,
-0.0347312056,
0.0133269122,
0.0495957062,
0.042302385,
-0.0161771886,
-0.0021767139,
-0.0136905191,
0.0191276241,
0.0409577265,
-0.0437557027,
0.0195518974,
0.0293073151,
0.014427444,
0.0623817667,
0.0060154172,
-0.0012130098,
0.0439982526,
0.0376280583,
0.0081808427,
-0.0124055715,
0.0207606517,
0.0129041513,
0.0097258128,
-0.042580504,
0.0056370655,
-0.0606679991,
-0.0558580607,
-0.0258070976,
0.038965784,
0.0237256344,
0.0128413495,
0.0203451253,
-0.0051327045,
-0.0185513441,
-0.0204596091,
-0.0130260959,
-0.0168634709,
-0.0446122438,
0.0312565379,
0.0049794167,
-0.0119761797,
0.0198602453,
0.0816145539,
0.0203842223,
0.1098720282,
-0.0122534689,
-0.0292720348,
-0.0302053913,
-0.0455883443,
-0.0012695977,
0.0024273447,
-0.0300931707,
0.0051988168,
-0.0310647469,
-0.0992694348,
-0.0453403704,
0.0156473201,
0.0333165228,
0.0228882488,
0.0167683531,
0.0516280569,
0.0143858623,
0.0066217268,
-0.0783684775,
0.0222048946,
0.0125476439,
-0.0515376031,
-0.0218554586,
-6.459158521e-33,
0.0407159254,
-0.0251790434,
0.0033412573,
-0.0059826435,
0.0014448614,
-0.0203357115,
-0.0011593373,
-0.0079099592,
-0.0117067341,
-0.0053400253,
-0.0222336594,
0.0168630257,
-0.0063823732,
0.0251864623,
-0.0127632357,
-0.002512285,
0.0471983291,
-0.030630175,
-0.0236536879,
0.0363963395,
0.0579626672,
0.025943296,
0.0294655785,
-0.0515973978,
-0.0000348955,
-0.0089769531,
-0.0659364611,
0.0365018807,
-0.0706980452,
0.0703406259,
-0.0121340752,
0.017260557,
0.0031602993,
-0.0465110019,
-0.0036319536,
0.0529934093,
-0.0469808914,
0.0149406763,
-0.0208286922,
-0.0240677223,
0.0216242876,
-0.0545121469,
0.0892972201,
-0.0140908118,
-0.0184530783,
0.0107219536,
0.0060261688,
-0.028273169,
-0.0259953123,
-0.0509411283,
-0.0203248821,
0.0296853762,
0.0020001065,
-0.0123816356,
-0.0035309477,
0.0116574243,
-0.0085909143,
-0.0039462154,
-0.0230149571,
0.0268032756,
0.0782177299,
0.0098678693,
0.0421536081,
0.0152822826,
0.0252554063,
0.0641120449,
-0.003748419,
-0.0102713592,
-0.0156256054,
-0.017438231,
0.0215507895,
0.0779417455,
0.0156876631,
0.0639496371,
0.0735472888,
-0.0341995768,
-0.078907229,
0.0064058979,
-0.0356653035,
0.0581619292,
0.0452086627,
0.0278504156,
-0.0490157083,
0.0080316979,
-0.0792381912,
-0.0087436577,
-0.0390005931,
-0.0042583207,
0.0191118512,
0.0402281061,
-0.0465809703,
-0.0204525925,
-0.00865936,
-0.0613698401,
-0.0001009961,
0.04716295,
0.0126071535,
-0.0235285815,
0.0076079681,
-0.0061738254,
-0.0127405617,
-0.0298355985,
-0.0089080343,
-0.0536984988,
0.0204915889,
-0.0071260496,
0.0258283652,
0.0303325746,
-0.0940128192,
0.0025415511,
-0.0344070904,
0.0481510535,
0.034343563,
0.036652334,
0.0416269302,
-0.02668266,
0.0121693918,
0.0334682614,
0.0383268856,
0.0400033854,
-0.030565843,
0.0426958613,
0.0031745306,
0.0015466949,
0.0027805904,
0.002970851,
0.0121587561,
0.0244582295,
0.0574276336,
-0.0465705842,
0.0089058904,
0.0123177255,
3.023e-7,
-0.0004299007,
0.0289125871,
0.019819431,
0.0141959097,
0.0396932587,
0.0782752633,
-0.010902131,
0.0657396838,
-0.0047175745,
-0.0091067003,
-0.0112568066,
0.0068147858,
0.0393911041,
0.0225370396,
-0.0684861243,
0.0246497504,
-0.0685144216,
0.0146739036,
-0.0520122387,
-0.028760286,
0.0230041035,
0.0962437615,
0.0082648275,
-0.0213736575,
0.0100099584,
-0.0630800948,
0.0348015502,
-0.0093160151,
-0.0136587415,
0.0008555305,
0.0270565115,
0.0890317112,
0.0148913683,
-0.0050614532,
-0.0490257926,
0.0075416914,
-0.0807263851,
0.0565959886,
0.0008889494,
-0.0498415083,
-0.0183181018,
-0.0388249904,
0.0179434102,
-0.0342838615,
0.0682201833,
-0.0414554961,
-0.0277710203,
-0.0384603292,
-0.0021429597,
-0.0490234047,
0.0350056849,
-0.0599186234,
0.0022396315,
0.0048981314,
-0.0051950845,
0.0127522899,
-0.0081793657,
-0.0854758173,
-0.0142645389,
-0.03611058,
-0.0472445413,
-0.0453149602,
-0.0071765687,
0.0344431438,
-0.007441618,
-0.0220646746,
0.0141914226,
2.868342362e-34,
0.0241548512,
-0.0197696853,
-0.0078566037,
0.0053286026,
0.0566094145,
0.0141788311,
-0.0090612266,
0.0157251209,
0.0112741888,
-0.06883201,
-0.0373464786
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07663v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07663v1
|
Sign Stitching: A Novel Approach to Sign Language Production
| 2024-05-13T11:44:57 | 2024-05-13T11:44:57 |
Harry Walsh, Ben Saunders, Richard Bowden
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Sign Language Production (SLP) is a challenging task, given the limited
resources available and the inherent diversity within sign data. As a result,
previous works have suffered from the problem of regression to the mean,
leading to under-articulated and incomprehensible signing. In this paper, we
propose using dictionary examples and a learnt codebook of facial expressions
to create expressive sign language sequences. However, simply concatenating
signs and adding the face creates robotic and unnatural sequences. To address
this we present a 7-step approach to effectively stitch sequences together.
First, by normalizing each sign into a canonical pose, cropping, and stitching
we create a continuous sequence. Then, by applying filtering in the frequency
domain and resampling each sign, we create cohesive natural sequences that
mimic the prosody found in the original data. We leverage a SignGAN model to
map the output to a photo-realistic signer and present a complete Text-to-Sign
(T2S) SLP pipeline. Our evaluation demonstrates the effectiveness of the
approach, showcasing state-of-the-art performance across all datasets. Finally,
a user evaluation shows our approach outperforms the baseline model and is
capable of producing realistic sign language sequences.
|
Sign Stitching: A Novel Approach to Sign Language Production: Sign Language Production (SLP) is a challenging task, given the limited
resources available and the inherent diversity within sign data. As a result,
previous works have suffered from the problem of regression to the mean,
leading to under-articulated and incomprehensible signing. In this paper, we
propose using dictionary examples and a learnt codebook of facial expressions
to create expressive sign language sequences. However, simply concatenating
signs and adding the face creates robotic and unnatural sequences. To address
this we present a 7-step approach to effectively stitch sequences together.
First, by normalizing each sign into a canonical pose, cropping, and stitching
we create a continuous sequence. Then, by applying filtering in the frequency
domain and resampling each sign, we create cohesive natural sequences that
mimic the prosody found in the original data. We leverage a SignGAN model to
map the output to a photo-realistic signer and present a complete Text-to-Sign
(T2S) SLP pipeline. Our evaluation demonstrates the effectiveness of the
approach, showcasing state-of-the-art performance across all datasets. Finally,
a user evaluation shows our approach outperforms the baseline model and is
capable of producing realistic sign language sequences.
|
[
-0.0428601503,
0.0687117204,
0.0226181224,
-0.0216383263,
0.0082263313,
0.0097268354,
0.0106729316,
0.0045205578,
0.0355904177,
-0.0102393171,
-0.0008041331,
-0.0106645133,
0.0420030281,
0.0975440517,
0.0401681215,
-0.1256111264,
-0.0068783914,
-0.0114403395,
-0.0183921661,
-0.0226632953,
0.0435808972,
0.0480653681,
-0.0537736975,
0.0584210381,
-0.1170119196,
-0.0027338662,
-0.0374303497,
0.0224444345,
0.0445722453,
-0.0142519372,
-0.0863207877,
0.0205324348,
0.0579794422,
0.0004316862,
0.0000020969,
0.0047685448,
-0.0028388756,
0.0176677611,
0.0256635621,
0.0213254094,
0.0644610152,
-0.0496194586,
-0.048487436,
0.0227595251,
-0.0279674623,
-0.0727698132,
0.0516173951,
0.05329163,
0.0561888069,
0.0360293165,
-0.0209057163,
-0.0000302836,
0.0269402787,
-0.0423470587,
-0.0115282526,
0.0288137402,
0.015321414,
0.0072998805,
0.0448265411,
-0.0835571364,
-0.0436689593,
0.0619488358,
0.0482047647,
-0.0578064248,
-0.0286667459,
0.02709716,
-0.0254724417,
-0.0315432921,
-0.0106911622,
0.0617105253,
-0.0685765222,
0.0176180657,
0.0317493603,
-0.0276155435,
0.0387361869,
0.0097299814,
-0.0018523722,
0.0222823266,
0.0007446204,
0.0141042266,
-0.0713630989,
0.0075116116,
0.0199304484,
-0.0381482616,
-0.0345365405,
-0.0175990164,
0.0254637524,
0.0310846139,
-0.0246106479,
-0.0235091113,
0.0044268388,
-0.0605543219,
0.0341746323,
0.0057498696,
0.0117430007,
0.0015666068,
-0.0364516899,
-0.0032765972,
-0.0251692347,
0.0169150457,
-0.0607478432,
0.027646238,
-0.0000645363,
-0.0042256541,
-0.0095002959,
0.0195338093,
-0.0231023319,
0.0334989727,
-0.0404837094,
0.008997486,
-0.0126618017,
-0.0176752787,
-0.0197473913,
-0.0238374695,
-0.0174959768,
-0.0630789921,
-0.0263780262,
-0.0037169305,
0.0018219558,
-0.0173010454,
0.0142436437,
0.0515454486,
0.0063382788,
0.0023758819,
0.0090666329,
0.0161189307,
0.0132123297,
0.0475072674,
-0.0120165879,
-0.0526648648,
0.0036663024,
0.020483898,
0.0313972384,
0.0681544095,
0.0156955291,
0.0160028338,
-0.0258327033,
0.0158999525,
0.0405064374,
0.0102317389,
-0.0266536381,
-0.0201052688,
-0.0042632003,
-0.0251941867,
0.0136711104,
-0.058009129,
-0.0056494256,
-0.070656687,
0.000386571,
-0.0251446627,
0.047205545,
0.0174340494,
0.007721751,
0.0039175292,
0.0250459015,
-0.0022246053,
-0.0174598843,
0.0058885217,
0.0854598731,
0.0418730006,
-0.0171732828,
-0.0035226331,
-0.005841048,
0.0625455081,
0.0132424375,
-0.0164886583,
-0.0252966452,
-0.0693235025,
0.0161342341,
0.0310077574,
0.0098376842,
0.0371138155,
-0.0239273515,
0.0066451165,
0.0053572687,
0.0543436334,
0.0578613207,
-0.0325407237,
0.0304149725,
0.055032894,
0.0086559774,
-0.059950266,
-0.0110439612,
0.0592968874,
0.0364948921,
-0.0248418208,
-0.017532574,
0.0289523657,
-0.0687865838,
-0.0098608183,
0.0122658964,
-0.0236290842,
0.0395335816,
0.0157798827,
0.042281609,
0.0487113073,
-0.0589017272,
-0.0475181602,
-0.0197667759,
-0.049626831,
0.0276642125,
-0.0091329301,
-0.0158543531,
0.0234110057,
-0.0127221644,
0.0137089668,
0.0042583179,
-0.0077486495,
-0.02815965,
0.0273218993,
-0.0221110452,
-0.0179613307,
0.0452518538,
-0.0445080809,
-0.0255840104,
0.0584882721,
-0.0053303698,
0.0396314189,
-0.0493463241,
0.0592583045,
0.0114716021,
0.0288295578,
0.0353211462,
0.056191992,
-0.0579834133,
-0.01271924,
-0.0018776687,
0.0095362794,
0.0236236788,
0.0249143224,
-0.0191520918,
0.0011726414,
0.0307812262,
-0.0258995183,
-0.0381093062,
0.0476938896,
-0.0355872847,
-0.0283820406,
0.0411832891,
-0.0706014857,
-0.0095396237,
0.0226477552,
-0.0067653172,
-0.0852037519,
0.0430742875,
-0.0204793401,
0.0256484058,
-0.0134839145,
-0.0124084214,
0.0219018571,
-0.0080274725,
0.0069535272,
-0.0249038748,
-0.0036956235,
-0.0375643298,
-0.014204789,
0.0005221307,
-0.0330113135,
-0.0284327026,
0.018642338,
0.0655495301,
0.0007654851,
0.0068222652,
-0.0002057566,
0.0424045213,
-0.0308013149,
-0.0347842313,
-0.0487519838,
-0.0225831624,
0.0192218572,
-0.0186827108,
-0.0201594718,
-0.0337105691,
0.0012885921,
-0.0264273044,
-0.082743451,
0.0208201315,
0.0231267177,
-0.0751754344,
-0.0149846477,
0.0010692332,
-0.08808548,
-0.0366113968,
0.0054779798,
0.0111509133,
-0.0008131427,
0.0202282257,
-0.0613219142,
-0.0348590836,
-0.0270626452,
0.0129871098,
0.0152248461,
-0.0183396991,
-0.014270911,
0.0251209252,
0.0003223536,
-0.0110909194,
-0.0135842161,
-0.0108899595,
0.0128681595,
0.0073628346,
0.0032771665,
-0.0291918181,
-0.015507157,
0.0028049401,
0.0649520159,
-0.0270586163,
-0.0343637429,
-0.014908229,
0.0077038445,
0.034128949,
0.0640974194,
-0.0981313363,
-0.0243659485,
0.0196365602,
-0.0712601617,
0.0199781712,
0.011345055,
-0.0330979452,
-0.0403080471,
-0.025598174,
-0.057845775,
0.026495453,
-0.0299696717,
-0.0789479837,
0.0494431928,
0.0179457702,
-0.0092910947,
0.0705840364,
0.0205166042,
0.0260942113,
-0.014544528,
-0.0348519944,
-0.0342014618,
0.0331142135,
-0.0191566255,
-0.0547386408,
0.0070103318,
-0.0524462052,
-0.0054686116,
-0.0162347686,
0.0302980822,
0.0075600762,
-0.0127574056,
-0.0325551517,
-0.0054999073,
-0.0111790458,
-0.0599239096,
0.0027013505,
-0.0051731858,
0.0010251091,
0.0149092628,
0.0250815973,
0.0146789327,
-0.0147095416,
-0.0677350536,
0.0429671369,
0.0325613581,
-0.0167015661,
-0.0232616197,
0.0170318689,
0.0327459686,
-0.0090902485,
0.0372076221,
-0.0375002399,
0.0008099349,
0.013326766,
0.0605364554,
0.0052565318,
0.0250839666,
0.0222801678,
0.0150112445,
0.0695521757,
0.041665297,
-0.0134732211,
0.0028996819,
0.0344454236,
0.057843484,
0.031005485,
0.0110732028,
-0.0305236075,
-0.0318584777,
-0.0452836752,
0.0219701175,
0.029296767,
0.0592694581,
0.0148299793,
-0.0371636786,
-0.0312927291,
0.0282019526,
0.0408762731,
-0.077757448,
-0.0310969576,
0.0279425513,
0.0174541976,
0.0115070445,
-0.0117924251,
0.0269332007,
-0.0113418223,
0.0114468643,
0.0403592698,
0.0272679962,
-0.0412409082,
-0.0154412165,
-0.0075734211,
0.0528555885,
0.0342670195,
0.0158216804,
0.0344565623,
-0.0641594976,
-0.0170988869,
0.020072069,
0.0342348516,
-0.0062189642,
0.0270971712,
0.0204836652,
-0.0245163385,
-0.0127093,
0.0860794187,
-0.1213772222,
0.0189164225,
0.0029276023,
0.0003951373,
-0.0122439601,
-0.0011529726,
-0.0122640627,
0.0006736049,
0.0007273388,
0.0074529359,
-0.0096617118,
-0.051317323,
-0.0031307375,
-0.0100582931,
0.0193813257,
0.0495429784,
-0.0712023079,
0.0375912301,
-0.0199782625,
-0.0830884501,
-0.0544550605,
-0.0013948899,
0.0723839551,
0.0503763072,
-0.0079133967,
-0.0248777047,
0.0364561602,
0.004267592,
-0.0347384475,
0.0328667425,
0.0096125714,
0.0443856753,
-0.0313353576,
-0.0046657082,
-0.0131980637,
-0.0006922919,
0.0328087285,
-0.0184590593,
-0.0832048655,
-0.0542865321,
0.0240163188,
0.0345605761,
0.0144595755,
0.003843077,
0.0184888616,
0.0098850699,
-0.0182860699,
0.0487417728,
0.0307907313,
0.0483503714,
0.048967585,
-0.0473901778,
0.0002053241,
0.0057348744,
-0.026998248,
0.0170988943,
-0.0381810702,
-0.0012649712,
-0.0630143657,
-0.0307598002,
-0.0161429197,
0.0130024366,
-0.0370258056,
-0.0550941862,
-0.0136728846,
-0.0513515584,
0.0064588329,
-0.0380597375,
0.021669263,
-0.0931126624,
-0.0035222764,
0.0263861995,
0.0143817654,
0.0188058037,
0.0287517495,
-0.0161380786,
0.0222551692,
0.0256584883,
0.0387747958,
0.0141092194,
0.0339159258,
0.0276022889,
0.0280843079,
0.0203372613,
0.0440557189,
-0.0291753951,
-0.0078749545,
-0.0122823333,
-0.0116240187,
-0.0007303129,
-0.0029783137,
0.0305186193,
0.0256506577,
0.0333569348,
-0.0790967941,
-0.0211684164,
-0.003924387,
0.0268916786,
0.0517168939,
0.1062265635,
-0.0414280705,
0.0390000977,
-0.0252026338,
0.0234718267,
-0.0199801214,
-0.0406185277,
0.0366528705,
-0.0359291472,
-0.0309888311,
-0.0279318076,
0.0250438415,
-0.0760683566,
0.0061949235,
-0.0230945908,
0.0338610969,
-0.047614269,
-0.0225228574,
0.0087149516,
-0.0552749522,
-0.0208659824,
0.0251275878,
-0.0401051901,
-0.0330657549,
-0.0015868052,
0.0015034132,
-0.003640495,
-0.0008826752,
0.045316752,
-0.0666568279,
-0.0163199939,
0.0574417114,
-0.0055338298,
-0.0153478691,
-0.0262790807,
-0.0386599042,
0.0041807238,
-5.555418995e-33,
-0.0385057367,
-0.0321569555,
-0.0301038474,
-0.0130368927,
-0.029025929,
0.005719922,
-0.0382407196,
0.0280827694,
0.0107298708,
0.0255125016,
-0.0028284544,
0.0140926326,
-0.0047562993,
0.0173224285,
-0.0174847227,
0.0081054848,
0.0470123626,
-0.0367667899,
0.010174064,
0.0381347835,
0.0309895854,
-0.0040612598,
0.0307659134,
-0.0877813026,
-0.0365189053,
-0.0117869917,
-0.0703158006,
-0.0315719843,
0.0031918045,
0.0024146291,
0.013420199,
0.0123422043,
-0.027156949,
0.0024728084,
0.0056433366,
0.0249050688,
-0.0161544513,
-0.001825462,
-0.0704118907,
0.063782908,
-0.0636465475,
0.0327261202,
-0.0115991496,
-0.0196486842,
-0.0265998207,
0.0199408736,
0.0326035805,
-0.0224135127,
-0.0079042446,
-0.0481181405,
0.0161874276,
0.0202643648,
-0.0281497911,
-0.0850609243,
-0.0033842465,
0.0450309962,
-0.0027017153,
-0.0307323113,
-0.0135672083,
0.0366565995,
-0.0173698459,
0.0052165445,
0.0948616788,
-0.015277571,
0.0546430163,
0.0573849455,
0.0217521712,
-0.0745947063,
0.0170472432,
0.0025916127,
0.0488169789,
0.0419892296,
0.0076253,
0.0525283143,
0.0673060268,
-0.0430519544,
0.0042725089,
0.0277330242,
0.0509610549,
0.0291102361,
-0.0509780683,
0.0793377087,
0.0286642686,
0.0038258971,
-0.0447373912,
0.0064748125,
0.0258655492,
-0.0250520296,
0.0227141064,
0.0345701016,
-0.002640526,
-0.0073620602,
0.0547198281,
0.0138566075,
-0.0216573477,
0.0118766762,
-0.0413074456,
0.0355144739,
0.0141629698,
-0.0075719389,
-0.0263867099,
-0.0371939354,
0.1219269559,
0.0124751944,
0.0681540743,
0.0007917197,
-0.0260894857,
0.0772045925,
-0.0250688698,
-0.0034296056,
0.0048182895,
0.056592714,
0.0344945043,
-0.0353541635,
0.0545132235,
-0.0415496938,
-0.029825855,
0.0365151167,
-0.0233644228,
0.0052823978,
0.001682874,
0.0333164893,
-0.0044821138,
0.0002177309,
-0.0635634512,
0.0175047666,
0.0098145325,
-0.0707451031,
0.0867113471,
-0.0666434616,
-0.0120499888,
0.0347543694,
2.728e-7,
-0.0151803819,
-0.0039121751,
0.0525180474,
0.0427881293,
0.0372383669,
0.0500072129,
-0.0287404396,
0.0271374192,
0.0056411368,
-0.0147706829,
-0.0003999147,
-0.03695108,
0.0703974068,
0.0261569191,
-0.0403848067,
0.035610076,
0.0072039375,
0.0182569139,
-0.0043207323,
0.0448233224,
0.0645310134,
0.0775540993,
0.0006286752,
-0.0251729358,
0.0599674098,
-0.0427781716,
0.0333387405,
-0.0240377206,
0.0337481834,
-0.0392135829,
0.0119974827,
-0.0662382171,
0.0012979831,
-0.0141632436,
-0.0250637475,
-0.0157576557,
0.0352913812,
0.0279622804,
-0.0518975891,
-0.0091040432,
-0.0037742646,
0.0387730002,
-0.0425772518,
0.0469115078,
0.0356483348,
-0.0215856656,
-0.0101306057,
-0.0404531509,
-0.0255365055,
0.0160801616,
0.0216752794,
0.007894123,
0.0017403092,
0.0685640797,
0.0273554828,
-0.0512234345,
0.0092598666,
-0.0373215936,
-0.05675482,
-0.0431825593,
-0.0475793593,
0.0168382991,
-0.0111219669,
0.0121471127,
-0.0345305689,
0.0229402687,
-0.0550646819,
1.929952569e-34,
-0.0209829509,
0.0076238746,
0.0356002003,
0.0098424722,
-0.0175269861,
0.006393278,
0.013209857,
0.0434341133,
0.0237310547,
-0.0166120697,
-0.0595256798
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13009v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13009v1
|
METAREFLECTION: Learning Instructions for Language Agents using Past Reflections
| 2024-05-13T10:51:43 | 2024-05-13T10:51:43 |
Priyanshu Gupta, Shashank Kirtania, Ananya Singha, Sumit Gulwani, Arjun Radhakrishna, Sherry Shi, Gustavo Soares
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite the popularity of Large Language Models (LLMs), crafting specific
prompts for LLMs to perform particular tasks remains challenging. Users often
engage in multiple conversational turns with an LLM-based agent to accomplish
their intended task. Recent studies have demonstrated that linguistic feedback,
in the form of self-reflections generated by the model, can work as
reinforcement during these conversations, thus enabling quicker convergence to
the desired outcome. Motivated by these findings, we introduce METAREFLECTION,
a novel technique that learns general prompt instructions for a specific domain
from individual self-reflections gathered during a training phase. We evaluate
our technique in two domains: Infrastructure as Code (IAC) vulnerability
detection and question-answering (QA) using REACT and COT. Our results
demonstrate a notable improvement, with METARELECTION outperforming GPT-4 by
16.82% (IAC), 31.33% (COT), and 15.42% (REACT), underscoring the potential of
METAREFLECTION as a viable method for enhancing the efficiency of LLMs.
|
METAREFLECTION: Learning Instructions for Language Agents using Past Reflections: Despite the popularity of Large Language Models (LLMs), crafting specific
prompts for LLMs to perform particular tasks remains challenging. Users often
engage in multiple conversational turns with an LLM-based agent to accomplish
their intended task. Recent studies have demonstrated that linguistic feedback,
in the form of self-reflections generated by the model, can work as
reinforcement during these conversations, thus enabling quicker convergence to
the desired outcome. Motivated by these findings, we introduce METAREFLECTION,
a novel technique that learns general prompt instructions for a specific domain
from individual self-reflections gathered during a training phase. We evaluate
our technique in two domains: Infrastructure as Code (IAC) vulnerability
detection and question-answering (QA) using REACT and COT. Our results
demonstrate a notable improvement, with METARELECTION outperforming GPT-4 by
16.82% (IAC), 31.33% (COT), and 15.42% (REACT), underscoring the potential of
METAREFLECTION as a viable method for enhancing the efficiency of LLMs.
|
[
0.0373700261,
0.0411728173,
-0.0366588719,
0.0192728862,
-0.0445589833,
-0.0342832766,
-0.0023930687,
-0.026644662,
0.0079801641,
-0.0416288003,
-0.038984444,
0.0175862666,
-0.0293859541,
0.0246112831,
0.0074698837,
-0.0313201547,
0.0576905981,
-0.0592228621,
-0.031633608,
-0.0106598726,
0.0106540127,
-0.0016533441,
-0.0274319649,
0.0509206168,
0.0276524648,
-0.0335037895,
-0.0414556153,
-0.0057367235,
0.0101885311,
-0.0353362188,
0.0162271056,
0.0532862097,
0.008882165,
0.0412693061,
0.0000021301,
-0.0432368703,
-0.0302387588,
-0.0178563725,
-0.0190671626,
-0.0154164052,
0.0174445678,
0.0011171375,
-0.0309942029,
0.0572619513,
-0.067640841,
-0.0262984615,
0.0482309908,
0.0205718242,
0.0906305313,
0.0724969357,
0.013352111,
0.033203315,
-0.01682394,
0.0119815804,
0.0110674966,
-0.0464671925,
-0.0143524008,
-0.0272367187,
-0.0007529898,
0.0566323102,
-0.0129314419,
0.0200475864,
0.0420569479,
-0.0212105848,
-0.0296172127,
0.0521598049,
0.0131377978,
0.0216756016,
-0.0542476326,
0.059701141,
0.0288653281,
0.0112396488,
-0.0180252586,
0.001660459,
0.03847792,
0.0404695794,
-0.0240944531,
-0.0041711344,
0.0092661055,
-0.0054566339,
-0.0291392077,
-0.0015175544,
-0.0070219915,
0.0009029616,
0.0011704356,
0.0767879859,
-0.0093536321,
-0.0204560366,
-0.0120283151,
-0.0189728085,
0.0653135702,
-0.0504368916,
-0.0180752426,
0.0682942495,
-0.0318373926,
0.039748732,
-0.0210545268,
-0.0162751339,
0.0545384064,
-0.0106086023,
0.0200830586,
0.0324049741,
-0.0461795367,
0.0217530075,
-0.0222773738,
0.0579174832,
0.0031957035,
0.0281559303,
-0.0292858202,
-0.0090474905,
-0.0689751133,
-0.0252421647,
-0.0481792092,
0.0498382971,
0.002159975,
0.0038698094,
-0.0222677737,
0.0608767122,
-0.0068744328,
0.0161574706,
-0.0279196389,
-0.0129954219,
-0.0217893682,
-0.0138820261,
-0.0366425626,
0.0260774232,
-0.024922004,
-0.0022680857,
0.0197976995,
-0.0643587261,
-0.0123391477,
-0.0093651665,
-0.0173488092,
-0.0121432655,
-0.0221508071,
0.0701010302,
0.0047534192,
-0.0372796729,
-0.0081465291,
-0.0348336361,
-0.0195129998,
-0.0255298521,
-0.0029988002,
-0.0629516914,
-0.0174303856,
-0.0133895585,
-0.0205794144,
-0.0167305153,
0.0157303493,
0.0058526094,
0.0090517951,
0.0799653977,
-0.0315109193,
0.0084646204,
0.0221939553,
0.0223130267,
-0.0205920227,
0.0716743171,
0.0050318656,
0.0364018753,
0.0170248356,
-0.005003945,
0.0664105564,
0.0119115012,
0.0027437143,
0.0318216383,
0.0096118711,
0.0222230814,
0.0237902068,
-0.0021685278,
0.0243422128,
0.0361341201,
-0.0054307403,
0.0075977673,
0.0584599674,
0.0396296419,
-0.0196471866,
0.0237515233,
0.0146876164,
0.0379240066,
-0.0043578469,
0.0018181786,
-0.0539319851,
0.0518988892,
-0.0212011579,
-0.0050911638,
-0.0343887396,
0.0042492799,
-0.0291853137,
-0.0229658764,
0.0119500495,
-0.017905172,
-0.0032940619,
0.0347411595,
0.018866621,
0.0370606557,
-0.0378285386,
0.0074983491,
0.0099658789,
-0.0497814193,
-0.0078819254,
-0.1131750792,
0.0099699125,
0.0950219631,
0.0405682847,
-0.0379635766,
-0.0530978329,
-0.0153219365,
0.0158221554,
0.0500162244,
0.0306916609,
-0.0044218311,
-0.0136711719,
-0.0196647421,
-0.0199555028,
-0.0240019877,
-0.0059784483,
0.0306930281,
-0.0044466131,
-0.0022929655,
-0.0039927363,
0.0028834308,
-0.0119496798,
0.0384181179,
0.00748719,
-0.0391663462,
0.0231103376,
0.009572898,
0.0119410669,
0.0027242224,
0.0192969982,
0.0097225653,
0.0292544514,
0.0164756104,
-0.0542477407,
0.0332607888,
-0.0490595438,
-0.0367302522,
0.0303393286,
-0.0145304166,
0.0000052449,
0.0386324562,
-0.0285842717,
-0.0328057595,
0.0401894599,
-0.0521082804,
0.0638990626,
-0.0254879016,
0.0032120785,
-0.0118792215,
-0.0093962438,
-0.023662366,
0.0126529895,
0.0064277793,
-0.0255328082,
-0.0257797968,
0.0094648721,
-0.0062609124,
-0.0323450416,
0.0014641039,
0.0054386202,
-0.0013588303,
0.0399772488,
0.0289992783,
0.0495200194,
-0.045138251,
-0.0445808023,
-0.1219905242,
-0.031653598,
-0.0396853313,
0.0267066602,
0.0355441272,
0.0269072447,
-0.0181798581,
-0.0539750904,
-0.0444499105,
0.0046920967,
-0.002826232,
0.0316216573,
0.044698488,
0.0124208396,
-0.0264558829,
-0.0459831022,
0.0075153923,
-0.0306645501,
0.0197469853,
-0.0130765941,
0.0415598117,
-0.0616529882,
0.0239385702,
0.0207738448,
0.0358221978,
-0.024304077,
-0.0916021168,
0.0378834158,
-0.0200469699,
0.0411656797,
0.0111588547,
0.0378895625,
0.0140351681,
0.0574756414,
0.0019061662,
-0.0874637067,
0.0248898901,
-0.015672138,
-0.0585126132,
-0.0456257425,
-0.0133259129,
0.0400403626,
0.0504991151,
0.0105387783,
0.0047797244,
-0.0521754138,
0.0009425218,
-0.0118758669,
-0.0381169468,
-0.0111775445,
-0.0170005728,
-0.0244374629,
0.02860355,
0.0129883513,
-0.0591191165,
0.0999725908,
-0.0187045466,
-0.0117000276,
-0.0660385638,
-0.0214065574,
-0.0411127992,
0.0742016956,
-0.0427292213,
0.0283369161,
0.0398625359,
-0.0386095047,
-0.0405278727,
-0.0427585952,
0.0169990975,
-0.0149454111,
0.0396790318,
-0.0532192849,
0.0117852418,
0.0049692653,
-0.0786293894,
-0.0608406439,
-0.0502759479,
-0.018611338,
-0.0087549649,
-0.0486619696,
0.005274869,
0.004060063,
-0.0039741658,
0.0347861759,
0.0391596071,
-0.0220138207,
-0.0319834054,
-0.0157567933,
-0.0173345674,
0.0612682514,
0.0114446208,
-0.0078448653,
0.0183692705,
0.0875076875,
0.0435631238,
0.1107972041,
-0.0045757936,
-0.0457702689,
-0.0293586534,
0.0237158034,
-0.0483817309,
0.0049211229,
0.0350977816,
0.052118592,
-0.0581991002,
-0.0293303672,
0.1051671728,
0.0375193357,
-0.0709124953,
-0.0105282664,
-0.052548822,
0.0088345045,
0.0487560779,
0.0449314862,
-0.0591193549,
-0.0330953486,
0.0075506642,
0.0489072241,
-0.0033515927,
-0.0205653105,
-0.0101761166,
-0.128510654,
0.0122480979,
-0.0305560622,
-0.0202063359,
0.0073996782,
-0.0540120527,
0.0097549772,
0.0251522604,
0.0054039271,
0.0233472437,
-0.0313887708,
-0.0077306922,
0.007083036,
-0.0259153433,
-0.0052694981,
-0.002785149,
-0.0331307054,
0.0838049427,
0.0760247037,
0.0031532641,
0.0050880881,
0.021887105,
0.067868188,
-0.0337707363,
0.0319354236,
-0.0019125831,
0.0538411774,
-0.0149039011,
0.0100309998,
0.0059129503,
0.0293396283,
-0.061270833,
-0.0072016311,
0.0803911909,
0.0738039687,
-0.0486856252,
0.0178034324,
-0.031215122,
-0.0160100181,
0.0511459187,
0.0415785834,
0.0208686274,
-0.0534158088,
-0.0314407796,
-0.0334092751,
-0.0000689495,
-0.0296499617,
-0.0395758562,
0.0161234923,
0.0328491367,
0.021498071,
-0.0748623759,
-0.086768195,
0.028780004,
0.0316867083,
0.0096687526,
-0.0144028571,
-0.0231149588,
0.0432805642,
-0.0052515543,
-0.0059375521,
-0.0560309328,
0.0079859607,
-0.0535393842,
-0.0250708926,
0.0533394478,
-0.0676438734,
-0.0000699848,
-0.0358233191,
-0.0446223393,
-0.0678390265,
-0.0055617616,
0.0729213506,
0.0225826316,
0.0227146652,
-0.0426157303,
-0.016918486,
0.042716343,
0.0219753999,
-0.0944936574,
-0.0115330834,
0.0543901697,
-0.0006300306,
-0.0113074537,
0.0320694335,
-0.068314068,
0.0095506245,
-0.005656342,
0.0399079882,
-0.0450928621,
-0.0452985056,
0.0486799888,
-0.0017931013,
0.0492320322,
0.0001156864,
0.0091216061,
-0.0075728372,
0.0250786375,
-0.0118697453,
-0.0122547373,
-0.0030888517,
0.0301774424,
-0.0136384945,
-0.0368807577,
0.0575747341,
0.020229958,
-0.0519192144,
0.0242926665,
0.0183789544,
0.0311854966,
0.0295151826,
0.0462810695,
0.0195439309,
0.017424494,
-0.0198640153,
0.0252357461,
0.0440960787,
0.0086568296,
0.0091022486,
0.0620531179,
0.0241536498,
-0.0368077867,
-0.0256464947,
0.0465758219,
-0.0954041108,
-0.0643302202,
0.0528513528,
0.0385133885,
0.0399836153,
0.0749505013,
0.0247186534,
-0.0343427584,
0.020177858,
0.0080683297,
0.0169919375,
-0.0063069626,
-0.0355068259,
0.0333211012,
0.0215884242,
0.0044027609,
-0.0168897938,
0.0755816996,
-0.0164597631,
0.0503999293,
-0.003110036,
-0.001927085,
-0.0538020246,
-0.0299147312,
-0.0105816592,
-0.0113121709,
-0.0321046151,
-0.0023011426,
-0.0545060821,
-0.0426059701,
-0.0200400278,
0.0271019973,
-0.0030430281,
-0.0413610265,
0.0498878732,
0.0726659298,
0.0215221848,
-0.0300999191,
-0.0662227571,
0.0214372128,
-0.0131041724,
-0.0138845649,
-0.017879514,
-5.79300771e-33,
-0.0138162812,
-0.0414237902,
0.0501967929,
0.0363792852,
-0.0009092999,
-0.0015064301,
-0.0492962971,
0.018328581,
-0.0249256808,
-0.0270336103,
-0.0318132117,
0.0269357301,
0.017381357,
-0.0004623117,
0.030245563,
-0.0104076434,
0.0603664927,
-0.0158507302,
-0.0446685851,
0.0484557003,
0.0096908752,
0.0133061176,
0.0238159709,
-0.0424017981,
0.010035987,
0.0093635032,
-0.0078306012,
0.0287716556,
-0.0181995798,
0.0681510568,
0.0052133966,
0.0522078276,
0.0128810843,
-0.0197258629,
-0.0004092146,
0.0440673418,
-0.0461267382,
-0.0595513619,
0.0017003106,
-0.0082460921,
-0.056009084,
-0.0582977608,
0.0083310883,
-0.0238730647,
-0.0166730955,
0.0218292084,
0.0301294066,
0.0192280244,
0.0110462485,
0.0211757682,
-0.0493972898,
0.0007384587,
-0.0183775928,
-0.023235837,
-0.0011154675,
0.0615968257,
0.0152481096,
-0.0288525335,
-0.0179444961,
0.0445864759,
-0.0058724186,
0.0385228135,
0.0542337783,
0.0543735847,
-0.012794178,
0.041427128,
0.038395822,
0.0196558163,
0.0275278334,
-0.019664146,
0.0306665823,
-0.0173867289,
0.0232248772,
0.0702201948,
0.00837004,
-0.0140887005,
-0.0314497836,
0.0191904679,
0.0493899174,
0.050518766,
0.0534177274,
0.0053778007,
-0.0302231945,
0.0031313649,
-0.0600326397,
0.0142698428,
-0.0155202253,
-0.064431116,
0.0401355065,
0.0288630612,
-0.0174884666,
-0.0351922624,
0.0248666648,
-0.0109581612,
-0.0150712468,
0.0193472542,
-0.032238137,
0.0353804082,
-0.0136261657,
0.0384183899,
-0.0356416889,
0.0117238518,
0.0089318352,
0.0196506903,
0.0184913389,
0.0204844419,
0.0280162822,
0.0459999889,
-0.0742025673,
-0.0028684661,
-0.0574278161,
0.0464224331,
-0.024235798,
-0.0028445441,
-0.0026645344,
-0.002520714,
-0.010394373,
0.0357859135,
0.0029062489,
-0.0344769657,
-0.0717291012,
0.0097436858,
-0.0027317852,
0.0135089429,
-0.037156105,
-0.000264327,
-0.0467248037,
0.0677107647,
0.0140111381,
-0.0737325922,
-0.015270452,
0.0284585897,
2.874e-7,
-0.0169080198,
0.0248590391,
0.0198798776,
0.0280502662,
0.0213086531,
0.0584803335,
-0.0229430292,
0.0167169962,
0.0286490545,
0.0006979404,
-0.0088253794,
0.0518885776,
0.0303643793,
0.0548224151,
-0.1054727435,
-0.0190332327,
-0.0479763299,
-0.0063884356,
-0.0589921027,
-0.0024349948,
0.0498186871,
0.0496197529,
0.015711382,
-0.0091484189,
-0.0001948688,
-0.020732943,
0.0256376881,
-0.010617773,
0.0023027523,
0.0306011979,
-0.0402161218,
0.0249723829,
-0.0228100847,
-0.0031918338,
0.011211833,
-0.0125515843,
-0.0648933798,
0.0260861982,
-0.0028505337,
-0.0625160635,
0.0096800933,
-0.004540483,
0.0159049574,
-0.0410886295,
0.0522654913,
-0.0413392447,
-0.0021939639,
-0.0156066306,
0.0071498705,
-0.0467958115,
-0.0118603539,
-0.0468454175,
-0.0530008338,
0.0091910791,
-0.0177487005,
-0.0079036569,
0.0077086166,
-0.0604678057,
0.016657697,
-0.0190738458,
-0.0278499816,
-0.0410271436,
-0.0408805124,
0.0136719998,
-0.010831546,
-0.068965055,
0.0269064289,
2.394667041e-34,
-0.0076146503,
-0.008988061,
-0.0017178727,
0.0511287749,
0.0284334347,
0.0178249143,
-0.0138639854,
0.0206346363,
0.0560106151,
-0.0382571183,
-0.0481302775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07623v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07623v1
|
COBias and Debias: Minimizing Language Model Pairwise Accuracy Bias via Nonlinear Integer Programming
| 2024-05-13T10:30:33 | 2024-05-13T10:30:33 |
Ruixi Lin, Yang You
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
For language model classification, would you prefer having only one workable
class or having every class working? The latter makes more practical uses.
Especially for large language models (LLMs), the fact that they achieve a fair
overall accuracy by in-context learning (ICL) obscures a large difference in
individual class accuracies. In this work, we uncover and tackle language
models' imbalance in per-class prediction accuracy by reconceptualizing it as
the Contextual Oddity Bias (COBias), and we are the first to engage nonlinear
integer programming (NIP) to debias it. Briefly, COBias refers to the
difference in accuracy by a class A compared to its ''odd'' class, which holds
the majority wrong predictions of class A. With the COBias metric, we reveal
that LLMs of varied scales and families exhibit large per-class accuracy
differences. Then we propose Debiasing as Nonlinear Integer Programming (DNIP)
to correct ICL per-class probabilities for lower bias and higher overall
accuracy. Our optimization objective is directly based on the evaluation scores
by COBias and accuracy metrics, solved by simulated annealing. Evaluations on
three LLMs across seven NLP classification tasks show that DNIP simultaneously
achieves significant COBias reduction ($-27\%$) and accuracy improvement
($+12\%$) over the conventional ICL approach, suggesting that modeling pairwise
class accuracy differences is a direction in pushing forward more accurate,
more reliable LLM predictions.
|
COBias and Debias: Minimizing Language Model Pairwise Accuracy Bias via Nonlinear Integer Programming: For language model classification, would you prefer having only one workable
class or having every class working? The latter makes more practical uses.
Especially for large language models (LLMs), the fact that they achieve a fair
overall accuracy by in-context learning (ICL) obscures a large difference in
individual class accuracies. In this work, we uncover and tackle language
models' imbalance in per-class prediction accuracy by reconceptualizing it as
the Contextual Oddity Bias (COBias), and we are the first to engage nonlinear
integer programming (NIP) to debias it. Briefly, COBias refers to the
difference in accuracy by a class A compared to its ''odd'' class, which holds
the majority wrong predictions of class A. With the COBias metric, we reveal
that LLMs of varied scales and families exhibit large per-class accuracy
differences. Then we propose Debiasing as Nonlinear Integer Programming (DNIP)
to correct ICL per-class probabilities for lower bias and higher overall
accuracy. Our optimization objective is directly based on the evaluation scores
by COBias and accuracy metrics, solved by simulated annealing. Evaluations on
three LLMs across seven NLP classification tasks show that DNIP simultaneously
achieves significant COBias reduction ($-27\%$) and accuracy improvement
($+12\%$) over the conventional ICL approach, suggesting that modeling pairwise
class accuracy differences is a direction in pushing forward more accurate,
more reliable LLM predictions.
|
[
-0.0097137727,
0.061608851,
0.0055403668,
0.0600591376,
-0.0029222916,
0.0356722102,
-0.002627142,
0.0171872042,
-0.0175979715,
-0.0974467099,
-0.0349683985,
-0.0207754765,
0.0005043012,
0.0054719592,
0.0106950812,
-0.0067269919,
0.0392901562,
-0.0204586871,
0.0258326177,
-0.0305988528,
-0.0039641783,
-0.0123189166,
-0.0149302436,
0.0073024984,
0.0156194214,
0.0016051644,
0.0389734991,
0.0097128721,
0.0002201051,
-0.0074478076,
0.0801590905,
0.0679680333,
0.0226676725,
0.029017847,
0.0000021938,
-0.0806074888,
-0.0239896458,
-0.0018698425,
-0.0500110015,
-0.0016199697,
0.0677207485,
-0.0504027382,
0.0256469436,
0.0412067249,
-0.0443205461,
0.0064725908,
0.0342771821,
0.0636767,
0.0294959918,
0.047784213,
0.0015111183,
-0.0525509007,
0.0279543884,
-0.0167851895,
0.0308554154,
-0.0364341661,
0.0007142384,
-0.0166238286,
-0.0419553183,
0.0145161906,
0.0011511274,
0.0014403993,
-0.0118302153,
0.0542046279,
0.0245650765,
0.028172316,
-0.0199199524,
-0.0200478286,
-0.001574362,
0.0336856544,
-0.0129057271,
-0.0533356257,
-0.0295663308,
-0.0303054545,
-0.0058676838,
-0.0216339044,
-0.0192154776,
0.038507469,
-0.0086671337,
0.0483619384,
0.0539444461,
0.0273850169,
0.0599733479,
0.0403364301,
-0.005556704,
0.0399755687,
0.007423487,
-0.0190268271,
0.0221721902,
0.019205194,
-0.0549807847,
-0.0163683444,
-0.0015792281,
0.0233464967,
-0.0119006531,
0.0054931655,
-0.0036189766,
0.0125790257,
0.0560558885,
-0.0959922224,
-0.0168727022,
0.0346150063,
-0.009275767,
0.0188801475,
0.0135957245,
0.0185701549,
0.0263853148,
0.0006618857,
-0.0185329821,
0.0121108191,
-0.0058190692,
0.004532828,
-0.0237409193,
-0.0021405525,
-0.041595161,
0.0376615226,
-0.0544313937,
0.0122722415,
-0.0267217029,
0.0145946145,
0.0288711619,
0.0291150156,
-0.0139974141,
-0.0012057236,
-0.0108450083,
0.0028882415,
-0.016862696,
0.0225009173,
-0.0404338464,
-0.0387557037,
0.0044689868,
0.0115701333,
-0.0104022985,
-0.0250940751,
0.0360577218,
0.0829595178,
-0.0023347214,
-0.0385905392,
-0.0572884157,
0.0123830251,
-0.0149725033,
-0.0511030927,
-0.0466006063,
-0.0885526463,
0.0034849197,
0.0410655886,
0.003244241,
-0.0390039161,
0.0107928775,
-0.0075050658,
-0.0013717018,
0.0554189608,
0.0220672265,
-0.0147117088,
0.0784771815,
-0.0025418887,
-0.0110323075,
0.0846883133,
0.030861767,
-0.0409091078,
0.0523257256,
-0.0040281611,
0.0313480273,
0.0309611019,
0.0245008152,
0.0215327255,
-0.0133953076,
-0.0072629252,
0.039657589,
0.0077406028,
0.0649295226,
0.0040048552,
-0.0078952927,
-0.0343312137,
0.0593683235,
-0.005859023,
0.0042966451,
0.0270626638,
-0.0374453887,
-0.0443779901,
-0.0308841988,
-0.0191229079,
-0.0962657928,
0.0297375266,
-0.0771770254,
-0.0080219395,
0.0201896857,
-0.0205206368,
-0.0195320528,
-0.0534736924,
-0.0507194065,
-0.0214374997,
0.0270392764,
-0.0101783732,
0.0374071077,
-0.0356504582,
-0.0107426699,
0.0579529963,
0.0477400236,
-0.0146373119,
-0.0121864649,
-0.0428415835,
-0.0045205667,
0.0242311228,
0.0004192842,
-0.0523789637,
-0.0177511163,
-0.0085973945,
-0.0405391566,
0.0026931863,
0.0650934801,
0.0015995428,
0.0351721719,
-0.0440801121,
-0.0024935345,
-0.0216333885,
0.0639908314,
-0.0297256578,
0.0098906886,
0.0053371191,
-0.0043063797,
-0.0617134199,
-0.0650034398,
0.0379359797,
-0.0663071498,
-0.0698799118,
0.0159395207,
0.0218258426,
0.0173826125,
-0.0293256547,
0.0126495855,
-0.0030191385,
0.0117553044,
-0.0294344947,
-0.0084326575,
-0.0300402343,
-0.0305261929,
-0.0372597314,
0.0550841652,
-0.0113628479,
0.0002954045,
0.0188206397,
-0.048459176,
-0.0165891815,
0.047166571,
-0.000030209,
0.0268928781,
-0.0262349397,
0.0224785898,
-0.0189777743,
0.0266633686,
-0.0555277802,
0.0687748343,
0.000187606,
0.0333315171,
-0.0202301163,
-0.0666647628,
0.0211401861,
-0.0061089508,
-0.0157673787,
-0.0042741965,
0.0020938884,
0.019895982,
0.0328116938,
0.0096976999,
-0.0426382348,
-0.0345401689,
-0.0739018172,
0.0051898654,
-0.0206145346,
0.0234436858,
0.0331157185,
-0.0297266636,
0.0035800666,
-0.0120844217,
-0.0435304381,
-0.0624434985,
-0.0132964635,
0.0229871068,
0.027400393,
0.017004706,
-0.011756462,
-0.0377718434,
-0.0227683298,
-0.0197555758,
0.0367089063,
0.0028527777,
-0.0218102541,
-0.0626519769,
0.0887071937,
-0.0230999272,
0.0203382093,
-0.0192201827,
-0.0109594408,
-0.0358513892,
-0.006883984,
-0.0108749727,
0.0435426086,
0.0079100421,
-0.0120653976,
0.0797139704,
0.0283347666,
-0.0596133061,
0.0003173325,
-0.0050693769,
0.0068634311,
-0.0035702437,
-0.040631935,
-0.0265021361,
0.0799125284,
-0.0078295274,
-0.0164045542,
-0.0055382689,
-0.0196700953,
-0.0321695209,
-0.0051175593,
-0.0537758432,
0.0206427146,
0.0053249416,
0.071872972,
-0.0405802764,
-0.0694091618,
0.0521774627,
-0.0029865492,
-0.0197759978,
-0.0580460019,
-0.0121194739,
-0.0553231053,
0.0283517893,
-0.0005100785,
0.0190625042,
-0.0360427462,
0.004674105,
-0.0618249327,
-0.0225147996,
0.0432694703,
-0.046018023,
0.0723060369,
-0.0314428098,
0.0051325248,
-0.0322580263,
-0.0669003054,
-0.0405590199,
-0.0383908413,
-0.0194546916,
0.0131482333,
-0.0165720675,
-0.0049338024,
-0.0162256099,
-0.02281533,
-0.024093939,
0.0394073613,
-0.0179639012,
-0.024252763,
0.0128936348,
0.0198532119,
0.0067317681,
-0.0213192739,
0.0403367952,
-0.0190360788,
-0.0025029341,
0.0046403906,
0.0566178635,
0.0606948696,
-0.0073205475,
0.0211126469,
0.0542962477,
-0.0479681604,
-0.0520083122,
0.0127516482,
0.0184139367,
-0.0410062559,
-0.0393917523,
0.1209254488,
0.0287151989,
-0.0839508846,
0.0182638373,
-0.0094365971,
0.007941098,
0.0431529693,
0.0218018554,
-0.0139666693,
-0.0434361957,
0.0052704057,
0.0287056956,
-0.0120663745,
-0.0212502629,
0.0049249083,
-0.1050604731,
-0.0186445005,
0.0180239342,
-0.0396269932,
-0.0484042093,
-0.0608742982,
0.0084180394,
-0.0714144483,
0.0540578887,
-0.0192525201,
0.0064918529,
0.0117314579,
0.0546142608,
-0.0237891395,
-0.0403052382,
0.0361943692,
-0.0266920701,
0.0629552305,
0.0174342822,
0.0303935688,
-0.0423061885,
-0.0213426333,
0.098371841,
-0.0281725843,
-0.0269869994,
-0.028039502,
0.0429851301,
-0.0120025333,
0.022067057,
0.0236794576,
0.0147863664,
-0.0489088334,
-0.0109915538,
-0.0168107655,
0.0831927881,
0.0145643102,
-0.0119511466,
0.016536301,
-0.0175817143,
0.013877552,
0.0647484213,
-0.0146685354,
-0.0375650972,
-0.0052145692,
-0.0665380806,
0.0330355391,
-0.0000416717,
-0.0015735425,
0.0458249077,
0.0252139978,
-0.0204378758,
-0.0211038291,
0.0026070508,
0.0084865652,
0.0051832502,
0.0065694381,
0.0236520339,
-0.0523686074,
0.0063814083,
-0.0394719169,
-0.0191098005,
-0.0105094519,
0.0252159927,
-0.030960992,
-0.0335640423,
0.0429678485,
-0.0493156984,
-0.0257783197,
-0.0177679621,
-0.0980897248,
-0.0537133068,
0.0173656996,
0.0349424854,
0.0159280039,
0.0585143231,
0.0105692055,
-0.0573721603,
0.0394184552,
0.1078110561,
-0.0195953008,
0.0320661068,
0.0526394211,
0.055295717,
0.0045188833,
0.0370065197,
-0.0425131321,
-0.0155696468,
0.0556082837,
0.0207228325,
-0.0517788604,
-0.0426546969,
-0.0024845172,
-0.0013764406,
0.0391850136,
-0.0285435356,
-0.0664780363,
-0.0246006325,
0.0038085694,
0.0274008512,
-0.0301248506,
0.0075405589,
0.0151375113,
0.0354272425,
0.0208348501,
-0.0203778353,
0.0297026057,
0.0245583877,
-0.0090787271,
0.0033649562,
0.0229288358,
0.0407201834,
0.0268544499,
-0.0210757814,
0.0221045818,
-0.0370267667,
0.0264881831,
0.0107793752,
0.0408794582,
-0.0052003842,
0.0250045005,
0.0161838885,
0.0592136979,
-0.086122252,
-0.003890967,
-0.0248827823,
0.0322661847,
-0.0199294481,
0.0003801531,
0.0226960294,
-0.0241812039,
0.0182118099,
-0.0269681122,
-0.0089287413,
-0.0247707181,
-0.0022794679,
0.011636165,
-0.009304245,
0.0276041999,
0.0073196311,
0.0003653887,
-0.0048442758,
0.0738366097,
-0.0183199868,
0.0578666627,
0.0094935987,
0.0012734984,
-0.0121194441,
0.0130137149,
0.0437303707,
0.0398596972,
-0.001833391,
0.0246246476,
-0.0434700176,
-0.0519873127,
-0.0152281588,
-0.0084573971,
0.0317797773,
-0.0214747731,
0.0122771868,
0.0915068835,
-0.0239397958,
0.0015845139,
-0.0184430443,
-0.0461488552,
0.0151840057,
0.0149905439,
-0.0755675137,
-6.769805679e-33,
-0.0087845661,
-0.0110119777,
-0.0142344171,
0.023051301,
0.0514376797,
-0.0385181047,
0.0119946003,
0.0278012939,
-0.041684892,
-0.0022886284,
-0.016031364,
0.0094143199,
-0.0068699773,
0.0043361681,
0.035484843,
-0.0288851969,
0.0184967127,
0.0062584253,
-0.0318370461,
-0.0074162986,
0.0341747217,
0.0048276414,
0.1064900011,
-0.0583579876,
0.0374959819,
-0.0090964083,
-0.0052195955,
0.0554395653,
-0.0259597339,
0.029492246,
-0.021108117,
0.0694169328,
0.056837827,
-0.0350012146,
0.0143962326,
-0.0515768901,
-0.0201200526,
-0.0668693855,
0.0054345345,
0.034386199,
0.0496015027,
-0.0224403255,
0.0528552085,
0.0117411884,
-0.079379037,
-0.0457798578,
0.0433142632,
-0.0095500136,
-0.0096064406,
0.0090774726,
-0.0284535792,
0.0105940998,
-0.0081648482,
-0.0083605088,
-0.0064157443,
-0.0466645025,
-0.0120071666,
0.0160501376,
-0.0515314005,
-0.0013903258,
-0.0021131199,
0.0455742925,
0.006127534,
0.023197066,
-0.0283261761,
0.0523458235,
0.0711659044,
0.0148458602,
0.0170772877,
-0.0342471413,
0.0667368472,
0.0003479647,
0.0686692894,
0.1062953547,
0.1259304583,
-0.0092597548,
-0.0498060584,
0.0295785759,
0.0181588512,
-0.0194244143,
0.010258738,
0.0143525023,
-0.0451554544,
-0.0486234948,
-0.048789598,
-0.0398642011,
-0.0475779735,
0.0132615557,
-0.0133870915,
0.0221929029,
-0.0217287093,
-0.0042037629,
0.0122453133,
-0.0370705016,
-0.0618813671,
0.0432198718,
0.0105884848,
-0.0105588594,
0.019606594,
-0.0081624743,
-0.0448041484,
-0.0394248366,
-0.0144843319,
0.0182752982,
0.0328937545,
0.0092059728,
0.0714974254,
0.0056392006,
-0.0801771805,
0.009980483,
-0.0413005762,
0.0189719852,
0.0488302335,
0.05167735,
0.0245949812,
-0.0235857125,
0.007928147,
0.0288365241,
0.0382207111,
0.0337673426,
-0.0319894738,
0.0163867194,
-0.0548454784,
0.0123777157,
-0.0095902029,
-0.011571561,
0.0037362694,
-0.0378229432,
0.0080684349,
-0.0454032421,
-0.0044932612,
-0.0357808471,
2.831e-7,
0.042655848,
0.0551934354,
-0.0556114092,
-0.0232974719,
0.0323596932,
0.0747113228,
-0.0348158143,
0.008806115,
0.018084757,
-0.0142359799,
0.0189909544,
0.0270332471,
0.0140713565,
0.0511595495,
-0.0393461995,
0.0137526635,
-0.045527406,
0.0643163249,
0.0110840835,
0.0226194784,
0.0256622471,
0.0951104909,
0.0475969613,
-0.0325400345,
-0.0070672655,
-0.0588419661,
0.0451016799,
-0.0484696031,
0.0332268029,
0.0211653672,
-0.0340348966,
-0.011992041,
0.0479607172,
0.0280793756,
-0.0189168938,
0.0113129849,
-0.0223768111,
0.0109230317,
-0.0175095629,
-0.0247090217,
-0.0259568319,
0.0352489688,
-0.007245936,
-0.0873065218,
0.0579452217,
0.0174863506,
-0.0159851126,
-0.0521876141,
0.0229464378,
-0.0245374627,
0.0432647355,
0.0039810133,
-0.0203895383,
0.0088654114,
-0.0076363031,
-0.004816364,
-0.0408293344,
-0.075313136,
-0.037973389,
-0.0125050144,
-0.0168451294,
-0.0519010499,
0.0082442826,
0.0365097374,
0.0490672775,
-0.062198732,
0.0014463364,
2.832625701e-34,
0.0453958027,
0.0075321258,
0.003424752,
0.0222971216,
-0.0030110416,
0.0170661006,
-0.0142910052,
0.0108235851,
0.0285892542,
0.0040113935,
0.0215719212
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07615v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07615v1
|
ViWikiFC: Fact-Checking for Vietnamese Wikipedia-Based Textual Knowledge Source
| 2024-05-13T10:24:05 | 2024-05-13T10:24:05 |
Hung Tuan Le, Long Truong To, Manh Trong Nguyen, Kiet Van Nguyen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Fact-checking is essential due to the explosion of misinformation in the
media ecosystem. Although false information exists in every language and
country, most research to solve the problem mainly concentrated on huge
communities like English and Chinese. Low-resource languages like Vietnamese
are necessary to explore corpora and models for fact verification. To bridge
this gap, we construct ViWikiFC, the first manual annotated open-domain corpus
for Vietnamese Wikipedia Fact Checking more than 20K claims generated by
converting evidence sentences extracted from Wikipedia articles. We analyze our
corpus through many linguistic aspects, from the new dependency rate, the new
n-gram rate, and the new word rate. We conducted various experiments for
Vietnamese fact-checking, including evidence retrieval and verdict prediction.
BM25 and InfoXLM (Large) achieved the best results in two tasks, with BM25
achieving an accuracy of 88.30% for SUPPORTS, 86.93% for REFUTES, and only
56.67% for the NEI label in the evidence retrieval task, InfoXLM (Large)
achieved an F1 score of 86.51%. Furthermore, we also conducted a pipeline
approach, which only achieved a strict accuracy of 67.00% when using InfoXLM
(Large) and BM25. These results demonstrate that our dataset is challenging for
the Vietnamese language model in fact-checking tasks.
|
ViWikiFC: Fact-Checking for Vietnamese Wikipedia-Based Textual Knowledge Source: Fact-checking is essential due to the explosion of misinformation in the
media ecosystem. Although false information exists in every language and
country, most research to solve the problem mainly concentrated on huge
communities like English and Chinese. Low-resource languages like Vietnamese
are necessary to explore corpora and models for fact verification. To bridge
this gap, we construct ViWikiFC, the first manual annotated open-domain corpus
for Vietnamese Wikipedia Fact Checking more than 20K claims generated by
converting evidence sentences extracted from Wikipedia articles. We analyze our
corpus through many linguistic aspects, from the new dependency rate, the new
n-gram rate, and the new word rate. We conducted various experiments for
Vietnamese fact-checking, including evidence retrieval and verdict prediction.
BM25 and InfoXLM (Large) achieved the best results in two tasks, with BM25
achieving an accuracy of 88.30% for SUPPORTS, 86.93% for REFUTES, and only
56.67% for the NEI label in the evidence retrieval task, InfoXLM (Large)
achieved an F1 score of 86.51%. Furthermore, we also conducted a pipeline
approach, which only achieved a strict accuracy of 67.00% when using InfoXLM
(Large) and BM25. These results demonstrate that our dataset is challenging for
the Vietnamese language model in fact-checking tasks.
|
[
0.0624356046,
0.0046090391,
0.0118447216,
0.0412308574,
-0.0685773268,
0.0117963981,
-0.0177762322,
0.0205220487,
0.0303433966,
-0.0584164448,
0.0150817558,
-0.0201588664,
0.0268779211,
0.0187951606,
-0.0167326145,
0.0060350099,
0.0470797867,
0.022001192,
0.0807035342,
-0.0161205512,
0.0096895257,
0.0183423068,
-0.053263668,
0.0150553081,
-0.0338898003,
0.0043948563,
0.0346748717,
0.0031707566,
0.0204902049,
-0.045698151,
0.0346976072,
0.0571381189,
-0.0089232195,
0.0596002154,
0.0000017762,
-0.0302569326,
0.028382102,
0.0061153946,
-0.031001091,
0.0331767835,
0.0346420556,
-0.0190906562,
-0.0145751033,
0.0104535026,
-0.0070366552,
-0.0463342145,
0.0303178001,
0.0633681715,
0.0823457986,
0.0940864161,
-0.0082827201,
-0.0266301651,
0.0109961731,
-0.0031172168,
0.0158741679,
0.030467093,
0.061969988,
0.0265969038,
-0.0251854602,
-0.0113856914,
0.0138368597,
0.0247462206,
0.0169615205,
-0.0264713075,
-0.0058055855,
0.0167784058,
-0.0365573876,
-0.0393889695,
0.0430332348,
0.0412447751,
0.0354497433,
-0.0597087704,
-0.0058948882,
0.0137353903,
0.0056544011,
0.0329313986,
-0.0069858502,
0.0370171964,
-0.041352354,
0.0023770533,
0.0518849082,
-0.0099941799,
0.0202007871,
0.0304464381,
0.0277430881,
0.0350522436,
-0.0141818803,
-0.0447071232,
0.0059701726,
0.0006369879,
-0.0381664187,
-0.0365289934,
0.0075235623,
-0.0111629684,
0.0132946018,
0.0096834926,
-0.0015782689,
-0.0014995633,
0.0856777504,
-0.1156013012,
-0.0760530308,
0.0056878794,
-0.0642039254,
0.0436930545,
-0.013642868,
-0.0150762191,
-0.0273034982,
-0.0032177621,
0.0208981764,
-0.0241560657,
-0.036161907,
0.0432390086,
0.0032121469,
0.0079916725,
-0.0079324692,
0.0026488234,
-0.0299976021,
-0.024290204,
-0.0174662583,
0.0234153438,
0.0464923121,
-0.0221857149,
-0.0278062094,
-0.0056962837,
-0.0721612722,
0.0679953694,
-0.0037079654,
0.0748451054,
0.0099693164,
-0.0140181873,
0.0147582144,
0.0252227429,
-0.0006951903,
-0.0098624099,
0.0127088176,
-0.0261182301,
0.0058749844,
0.0425298885,
-0.03070632,
-0.0054544378,
-0.0203369614,
-0.052021388,
-0.008901733,
-0.1096044928,
-0.0187939629,
0.0099763479,
0.0124601703,
-0.0238094777,
0.0094267158,
0.0482047014,
-0.0395344086,
0.0574481934,
-0.0165284518,
-0.0220094994,
0.0461958013,
0.0057737953,
-0.0076408735,
0.0501902029,
0.0052393922,
0.0214816853,
0.0675759614,
0.0507716425,
-0.0131573323,
-0.0259089861,
0.0269779693,
0.0195150841,
0.0783001706,
0.0177036636,
-0.0084760971,
0.0016522624,
-0.0084217293,
0.0421267599,
-0.0142857898,
-0.026391428,
0.0406129807,
-0.0388241783,
-0.0194307957,
-0.0591501333,
0.0375822671,
0.0083981976,
0.0594288707,
-0.0068292972,
-0.0664088354,
0.0199436694,
-0.0333156027,
0.0034549979,
0.0013709229,
0.0472908989,
-0.0042614518,
-0.0434490815,
-0.0259118676,
-0.0083317924,
-0.0288441163,
-0.0279613696,
0.0123658804,
0.0135647953,
-0.0191249941,
0.0590081029,
0.0784375668,
-0.031187946,
-0.0193018373,
-0.0445010252,
0.0311570745,
-0.0142021514,
0.0385099985,
-0.0073042293,
0.0312179588,
-0.0160053447,
-0.0006035654,
0.0527178049,
0.0557646304,
-0.0417218581,
-0.0258207843,
0.0216096956,
0.0064269644,
-0.0048536938,
0.0536056459,
-0.0104649458,
0.0403534621,
0.0451338105,
0.0095878318,
-0.0605561137,
-0.0456781201,
0.0344272517,
0.0247267783,
0.0136234118,
-0.001815472,
0.009982747,
0.0192676801,
0.0198209882,
-0.0408819579,
-0.0023021358,
0.0458164811,
0.003052711,
-0.0169321597,
-0.0139735788,
0.0456437096,
-0.0644593015,
0.051262781,
-0.0453115292,
-0.0133135496,
0.055067949,
-0.0069052544,
-0.0089795766,
-0.0415286683,
0.0124123227,
-0.0113977632,
-0.060099408,
0.0032794811,
-0.0243668836,
0.0322578922,
0.0015196812,
0.0753824785,
-0.0278620776,
0.004235893,
0.0089889569,
-0.0301149357,
0.019235624,
-0.0116512766,
-0.040366061,
0.0292316712,
0.0337896906,
0.0184997879,
0.0268254168,
-0.0198459644,
-0.0141671142,
0.0132787786,
-0.1079116985,
0.0282178484,
-0.027283052,
0.0038379091,
0.0197195783,
-0.053665746,
-0.0223295446,
0.000459378,
0.0048857429,
0.0127846068,
0.0123437718,
0.0082011363,
0.0055258456,
0.0098762196,
0.0222161673,
-0.0304737035,
-0.0014997516,
-0.0084388452,
0.0218142495,
0.0171616692,
-0.0862950683,
-0.0085670156,
0.0221382491,
-0.0608947724,
-0.021022249,
-0.01544418,
-0.0029054736,
0.0162990391,
0.0019934103,
-0.0283233635,
0.0087627536,
0.0327158123,
-0.0036537605,
0.0321946219,
-0.0009616498,
-0.0135435611,
-0.0081095276,
-0.0107834116,
0.0276063308,
-0.0273292661,
-0.0292841811,
0.0102813449,
0.0205497947,
0.0245485511,
-0.0139713231,
-0.0091177095,
-0.0161210708,
-0.0131420717,
0.0003256268,
0.029232515,
0.0044296435,
0.0032359031,
0.0276132673,
-0.0244073905,
-0.0117675308,
0.0821638107,
-0.0115414355,
0.0507539138,
-0.0429296382,
0.0051512606,
0.01782538,
0.0001622903,
-0.0064444328,
-0.0016284242,
0.0359350964,
0.0165755767,
0.0207126345,
0.0375231057,
0.0578234233,
-0.0457461923,
0.0255325083,
-0.0124835279,
0.033296898,
0.0042508338,
-0.0252599679,
-0.0473125167,
-0.0526254028,
-0.0041161105,
-0.0247072242,
-0.0354843475,
0.0190286562,
-0.0542505831,
-0.0061364728,
0.0265242103,
0.0189185236,
0.0074982075,
0.0154843666,
0.0059482451,
0.0388830788,
0.0134475194,
-0.022354763,
0.0474706367,
0.0214280356,
0.0199855678,
0.0634801835,
-0.0339532308,
0.0194592085,
0.0169742219,
-0.0517368168,
-0.0265024398,
-0.0372846462,
-0.0080621913,
-0.0276953671,
0.0150990328,
-0.0319811441,
0.0077315695,
0.0697923973,
0.026355261,
-0.0390642621,
-0.0392742045,
0.0104077524,
-0.0086421147,
0.0331047811,
-0.0023465506,
-0.0868563429,
0.0041400874,
0.0109034926,
-0.0192940291,
-0.0259309281,
-0.0113153625,
-0.0037378245,
-0.1002335325,
0.0313034914,
-0.0156556666,
0.0435741097,
-0.060919717,
-0.0822725743,
0.0088462681,
-0.0026918137,
0.0156970378,
0.0221312996,
0.059104044,
-0.0087081976,
-0.0000452153,
-0.0042955927,
-0.065760009,
0.0754278675,
-0.0251639411,
0.0493173711,
-0.0202585347,
0.0414426029,
-0.0304240119,
-0.0429512374,
-0.0008870348,
-0.0007954269,
-0.0557454117,
-0.0070589054,
0.0805646628,
-0.0310080312,
0.000553579,
-0.0332332142,
0.0115207955,
-0.0030800935,
-0.0231853239,
0.0245408081,
0.075207606,
0.00742146,
-0.0153393922,
-0.0200437419,
-0.0116639147,
0.0323270038,
0.0549599528,
-0.0197792798,
0.0180830471,
0.0244622529,
-0.0245514382,
-0.0802549198,
-0.00090859,
-0.0656274185,
0.050665047,
-0.0025954358,
-0.0521367937,
-0.0938526168,
-0.0208695475,
-0.0191230867,
0.0410813987,
-0.0242637992,
-0.0129148057,
0.0437034965,
0.016114099,
-0.0342124775,
0.005166396,
-0.0377425142,
0.017834859,
-0.0074649239,
0.0029003785,
0.0192743763,
-0.0084535982,
0.0106345788,
0.0151532507,
-0.0414081067,
-0.0529410392,
0.0100733433,
0.0224275608,
0.0161208604,
0.0303743593,
-0.0328435227,
0.0120091429,
0.0330457762,
0.0613400489,
-0.0597730465,
-0.0045561199,
-0.0013144056,
-0.0461241454,
0.0077225897,
0.0260418169,
-0.0225880928,
0.009579326,
-0.0200990438,
0.0334131345,
-0.0090707289,
0.0005424767,
0.0439260565,
0.0566093475,
0.065078564,
-0.0288283359,
-0.0041726297,
-0.0792749599,
-0.0195153132,
-0.0416698791,
-0.0477777049,
0.0435036793,
0.0378378779,
0.0060965004,
-0.0152508626,
-0.0192454606,
0.0235307161,
-0.0141352275,
0.0000517122,
-0.0135514215,
-0.0278362278,
0.0307621881,
0.0641236752,
-0.0070280489,
-0.0312933922,
-0.0343416296,
-0.0489805713,
-0.0117942188,
0.0209982656,
-0.0218516346,
0.0290641505,
0.017611729,
-0.0316419676,
0.0237546898,
-0.0446817465,
-0.0485386141,
0.0399230681,
-0.0300848167,
0.0163959749,
0.0611301139,
-0.0024254357,
0.0552717671,
-0.0504197329,
-0.0368289314,
-0.016380854,
-0.0104587777,
-0.0026504549,
-0.0030600743,
0.0201151725,
-0.006467931,
-0.0368831828,
0.0383257195,
0.0417683497,
-0.0265071113,
0.0504030213,
0.0228649285,
-0.0650556535,
-0.0163905919,
-0.0494180322,
-0.0401443988,
0.0401582643,
-0.0346388631,
-0.0416132547,
-0.0554434471,
-0.0493757501,
0.0027526934,
0.0267614163,
0.0112234987,
0.0279636774,
-0.0463306196,
0.0765271261,
0.0599075854,
-0.0100976145,
-0.0679038316,
0.005544031,
-0.0551965125,
0.0330196656,
0.0340535566,
-6.148552139e-33,
-0.0382196456,
-0.0127677461,
-0.0196137428,
0.0345363393,
0.033262372,
0.0084409108,
-0.00979455,
0.0026158476,
-0.0711326525,
0.0813662037,
0.025320882,
0.0422034971,
0.0251630023,
-0.0323120318,
-0.0063383244,
0.019245103,
0.0117739551,
0.0282821245,
-0.0455587804,
-0.0109663913,
0.045058012,
-0.0241765771,
0.0576031543,
-0.0860042721,
0.1000032499,
-0.0068301931,
-0.0032615431,
0.0094385017,
-0.0220082384,
0.0436445512,
-0.0138830198,
0.0939268097,
0.0335889235,
-0.0272822212,
0.0081534218,
-0.0356975347,
-0.106698513,
0.0000527736,
0.0517028086,
0.0081750229,
-0.0146660907,
0.010307679,
0.0112433592,
0.009103585,
0.0019427041,
-0.0005045298,
0.0351841897,
-0.038567856,
0.0270817168,
0.0137514723,
-0.0642150864,
0.0276912954,
0.0406137593,
0.0122206155,
-0.0530467145,
0.0446196944,
0.0103123356,
-0.0108842961,
-0.1336409003,
0.020161774,
-0.0648710355,
0.0115928231,
-0.0031894855,
-0.0630430654,
-0.0295868814,
0.0561847202,
-0.0144043798,
0.0087589622,
-0.053030286,
0.0358837806,
0.0136921983,
0.0350604616,
0.0252883565,
0.1053873077,
0.0388742946,
-0.0749313235,
-0.1046699733,
0.0143409083,
0.0412982926,
0.0357931852,
0.0117567321,
-0.0263477173,
-0.0455805957,
-0.0119198272,
-0.0254161265,
-0.0275183823,
-0.0373213775,
-0.0068427059,
-0.0078058708,
0.0418848582,
-0.0191607531,
0.010081212,
0.0182287898,
-0.0346361175,
0.0298291985,
0.0477992371,
-0.072174564,
0.0132648144,
-0.0197917968,
0.0251027588,
-0.0682630613,
0.0355232544,
0.0046458179,
0.0181406327,
-0.0264161229,
0.0017635436,
0.0584498458,
-0.0007044526,
-0.0604189746,
0.0163797922,
-0.0281063952,
-0.0083404286,
-0.0060934299,
-0.0019382051,
0.0038566829,
0.0235932805,
0.0065945769,
-0.023379866,
0.004264934,
0.0093129175,
-0.0328920409,
-0.0503956303,
0.0051891203,
-0.0087191034,
-0.0144133875,
0.0112387389,
-0.0378267877,
0.0476153977,
-0.0238069538,
-0.0494164117,
0.0253343526,
0.0300192721,
2.527e-7,
0.0286891256,
0.0284840632,
0.0182477683,
0.0134006683,
0.0091900751,
0.016569661,
-0.007536924,
-0.0045790607,
0.0184611566,
-0.1304775327,
-0.026251819,
0.0474265441,
0.0207383949,
0.0497655384,
-0.0522214361,
-0.0532412007,
-0.0074505801,
-0.0451879017,
-0.0406396538,
-0.0350366123,
0.0023341235,
0.054348439,
0.017139608,
-0.0075578303,
-0.0143996701,
-0.0247234851,
0.0564174652,
0.0498291329,
-0.0524369366,
0.0087151537,
0.0878795907,
-0.0140241608,
0.0226231199,
0.0270431805,
-0.0105269412,
0.0151493568,
-0.0029718992,
0.0471440218,
0.0174666774,
0.0125876488,
-0.0399778672,
-0.0292943511,
0.0227638874,
-0.0459571071,
0.0498844981,
0.0297102463,
-0.0140115945,
-0.0373823717,
-0.0179653559,
0.0268087592,
0.03546606,
-0.0051710587,
-0.0510257632,
0.0082518924,
-0.0043557053,
0.0391549803,
-0.0328224413,
-0.0106870728,
-0.0613560267,
0.007149626,
-0.0443278141,
-0.0594555289,
0.0600253344,
-0.0376666859,
0.032237567,
-0.0563184656,
0.0536255017,
1.843423557e-34,
0.0338071138,
-0.0073632891,
-0.0175881628,
-0.0495823994,
0.0652584359,
-0.004454569,
-0.0596080571,
-0.0347265787,
-0.0149603188,
-0.0253438409,
0.0099148154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07609v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07609v1
|
NoiseBench: Benchmarking the Impact of Real Label Noise on Named Entity Recognition
| 2024-05-13T10:20:31 | 2024-05-13T10:20:31 |
Elena Merdjanovska, Ansar Aynetdinov, Alan Akbik
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Available training data for named entity recognition (NER) often contains a
significant percentage of incorrect labels for entity types and entity
boundaries. Such label noise poses challenges for supervised learning and may
significantly deteriorate model quality. To address this, prior work proposed
various noise-robust learning approaches capable of learning from data with
partially incorrect labels. These approaches are typically evaluated using
simulated noise where the labels in a clean dataset are automatically
corrupted. However, as we show in this paper, this leads to unrealistic noise
that is far easier to handle than real noise caused by human error or
semi-automatic annotation. To enable the study of the impact of various types
of real noise, we introduce NoiseBench, an NER benchmark consisting of clean
training data corrupted with 6 types of real noise, including expert errors,
crowdsourcing errors, automatic annotation errors and LLM errors. We present an
analysis that shows that real noise is significantly more challenging than
simulated noise, and show that current state-of-the-art models for noise-robust
learning fall far short of their theoretically achievable upper bound. We
release NoiseBench to the research community.
|
NoiseBench: Benchmarking the Impact of Real Label Noise on Named Entity Recognition: Available training data for named entity recognition (NER) often contains a
significant percentage of incorrect labels for entity types and entity
boundaries. Such label noise poses challenges for supervised learning and may
significantly deteriorate model quality. To address this, prior work proposed
various noise-robust learning approaches capable of learning from data with
partially incorrect labels. These approaches are typically evaluated using
simulated noise where the labels in a clean dataset are automatically
corrupted. However, as we show in this paper, this leads to unrealistic noise
that is far easier to handle than real noise caused by human error or
semi-automatic annotation. To enable the study of the impact of various types
of real noise, we introduce NoiseBench, an NER benchmark consisting of clean
training data corrupted with 6 types of real noise, including expert errors,
crowdsourcing errors, automatic annotation errors and LLM errors. We present an
analysis that shows that real noise is significantly more challenging than
simulated noise, and show that current state-of-the-art models for noise-robust
learning fall far short of their theoretically achievable upper bound. We
release NoiseBench to the research community.
|
[
0.0393261649,
0.0626457706,
0.0055876691,
0.033324603,
0.0407976769,
0.0463916659,
-0.0032936968,
0.0277822427,
0.013547047,
-0.0240580887,
-0.0162333865,
-0.0184690095,
0.010048762,
-0.0185926743,
0.054465916,
-0.0373813845,
0.026724726,
-0.0193056278,
0.0424673297,
0.0210833456,
-0.0174976625,
-0.0383450836,
0.0081675611,
-0.0033380808,
-0.036205586,
0.0199679956,
-0.0074849259,
0.0345569067,
0.0247031767,
-0.0593787506,
0.0306478925,
0.0536011904,
-0.0210667755,
0.079959929,
0.0000019101,
-0.0449073799,
-0.0356948823,
0.0309736244,
-0.044707302,
0.0045545059,
0.0110979164,
0.0001377846,
-0.0203912407,
-0.010210216,
0.0170662012,
-0.0571336672,
0.0463352501,
0.0753537789,
0.0411977172,
0.0720183477,
-0.0049824906,
0.0022750159,
0.0317838714,
-0.0292286798,
0.0242002662,
-0.0637046397,
0.0457284525,
-0.0176034998,
-0.0401916429,
0.0110845966,
0.0109612793,
0.0021120175,
-0.0245561078,
0.0022865087,
0.0212872196,
0.0319006704,
-0.0357018225,
-0.0058112806,
-0.0052538244,
0.0842981115,
-0.0134719694,
0.0252311006,
0.0452301465,
-0.016195558,
0.0168294776,
-0.0418392643,
0.0129531519,
-0.0072866557,
-0.0451506488,
0.0053449725,
-0.0359228961,
0.0134706758,
0.0474663787,
-0.0197874643,
0.029421594,
-0.004528862,
-0.0000691955,
-0.0571098961,
0.0311688632,
0.0252779853,
-0.0008060324,
-0.0340680405,
0.0049457662,
-0.0019195803,
-0.0097590992,
0.0175460093,
-0.0719716102,
-0.0345036425,
0.012204743,
-0.0594852977,
-0.0160828214,
-0.025706578,
-0.0262402054,
0.0473318063,
-0.0338308178,
-0.0195983909,
0.0168252885,
0.0343198404,
0.0337085128,
-0.0020335,
-0.0085251583,
0.0314021669,
-0.0139175989,
0.058048442,
-0.0271289181,
0.0312576927,
-0.0524502918,
-0.0091912206,
-0.0426396057,
0.057729274,
-0.0094518643,
-0.0014393196,
-0.0038421014,
-0.0182395298,
-0.0312648565,
-0.0383935235,
-0.0050049564,
0.0034290396,
-0.0056899325,
-0.0580824874,
0.0174617358,
-0.0162645411,
0.0009265221,
-0.0199950282,
0.035109058,
0.0939420983,
0.040366441,
-0.0837734714,
-0.1071410626,
-0.0109964097,
0.0078907833,
-0.011396843,
-0.0104015535,
0.0019387209,
-0.0035081543,
-0.0283024218,
-0.0017645954,
-0.0676363483,
0.0288239121,
-0.0333241671,
-0.0631857291,
0.0901069269,
-0.0941193253,
-0.0249577221,
0.0405668691,
-0.0007905004,
0.0194341075,
0.0318855345,
0.0518718585,
-0.0326115936,
0.0492112823,
-0.0029995006,
0.0163223855,
0.0187363904,
0.0381769948,
-0.0277077574,
0.0176919922,
0.004775166,
0.0086660469,
0.0176467504,
0.0146863749,
0.0562783182,
-0.0072907219,
-0.0401643887,
0.0524547026,
-0.0123118227,
-0.0409958959,
-0.0161124971,
-0.0380625427,
-0.0235398021,
0.0370730869,
-0.0182757806,
-0.0435253978,
-0.0228640679,
-0.0505767651,
0.0118837934,
0.0426851138,
0.0223195236,
-0.0265748873,
-0.0452788994,
-0.0457728282,
-0.0186848398,
-0.0236711241,
-0.0047839135,
0.0536397845,
0.0106819272,
-0.064675577,
0.0395215116,
0.02552603,
-0.007971257,
-0.0117244944,
-0.0129435323,
0.0295405313,
0.0416326299,
0.0429793783,
-0.0764151365,
-0.0219514053,
-0.0715021342,
-0.0213315953,
0.0558270775,
0.0234933347,
-0.006268831,
0.0288570002,
-0.0409314446,
-0.0214135014,
0.0716294795,
0.0298442449,
0.0138344737,
0.0345532857,
0.0003567494,
0.0071140639,
-0.0630365163,
-0.0816205069,
0.0409868211,
-0.014398247,
-0.0581359714,
0.0049974448,
0.0221056212,
0.0141666969,
0.0481865667,
-0.0371238366,
-0.0321817175,
0.0169440918,
0.0122048445,
0.017098939,
-0.018600842,
0.0127163045,
0.0094381543,
0.0262709614,
-0.0260366686,
-0.0867616162,
0.0002309476,
-0.0371952206,
-0.029424198,
-0.0349636003,
-0.0073744808,
-0.0150484648,
-0.0272517297,
0.0306307469,
0.0248408988,
0.0189690962,
-0.0263891313,
0.0654260963,
-0.0278930962,
0.0422271229,
-0.005654762,
0.0181950759,
-0.0037619309,
-0.0277330875,
-0.0558540188,
-0.0215151031,
-0.0254791975,
-0.0005901695,
0.0016431556,
-0.0383447073,
-0.0645834133,
-0.0067699081,
-0.029793093,
-0.0434112512,
-0.0125948461,
0.0309438668,
-0.0246800985,
-0.0041063968,
-0.0260930266,
-0.0402070768,
-0.0038720642,
-0.0066746492,
-0.037350975,
0.0059884689,
0.046191413,
-0.0127299791,
-0.0107293911,
-0.0165100452,
0.0031776736,
-0.0148927756,
0.0182940196,
0.0355259702,
-0.0756245106,
-0.0849020556,
0.0528968535,
-0.0097014559,
0.040539071,
0.0078010908,
0.0230907854,
0.0009402065,
0.0378593393,
0.0054145716,
0.0277815778,
-0.0098471921,
0.0244803187,
-0.0084740836,
0.0003646951,
-0.0053955042,
0.0373445041,
-0.0021533989,
0.0316652805,
-0.027513817,
-0.0498898998,
0.0098174298,
0.0552010536,
-0.0469551161,
0.0114666335,
-0.0390739627,
0.001586173,
-0.01355098,
-0.0168267954,
-0.0365408882,
0.0250571407,
-0.0252586417,
0.050152231,
-0.0264206175,
-0.0051829135,
0.0446047448,
-0.0218489114,
0.0098214103,
0.032589715,
0.0100118574,
0.0110858399,
0.0136412056,
0.0178432241,
-0.0076769483,
0.0751323774,
-0.0679029152,
-0.0051339543,
-0.0011423238,
0.0583496802,
-0.046951782,
0.0203327741,
-0.0089077018,
0.0359152816,
-0.005674744,
-0.0214115381,
-0.0497012548,
0.0059393034,
-0.0216695871,
-0.0095772129,
0.0026882929,
-0.0280567817,
-0.0115944259,
0.0139402291,
-0.0190913957,
0.0463693067,
0.0275666714,
-0.028419558,
-0.0115159545,
0.057795357,
0.0104954429,
0.0168713443,
0.0631202608,
-0.0432922393,
-0.0254486259,
0.0113997161,
0.0100803887,
0.0091337319,
0.0138485907,
-0.0108481999,
0.0192902666,
-0.0326906107,
0.0091946665,
0.0201658439,
0.0417887457,
-0.0182944406,
-0.0379790403,
0.0829745233,
-0.0086003924,
-0.0031952173,
-0.0188249983,
0.0265367422,
0.0278653409,
0.0211913139,
0.0092725856,
-0.0471267737,
-0.0256888773,
0.0316885002,
0.0496035777,
-0.0062124371,
-0.0834547058,
0.0225867592,
-0.1126952022,
0.0401870236,
-0.0121216755,
-0.0706413612,
-0.0202445723,
-0.0589559115,
0.0224206243,
-0.0493343025,
0.0259163678,
-0.0265713297,
0.0166152734,
-0.0241989698,
0.0414161533,
-0.0190470219,
-0.0746850446,
-0.0329072587,
-0.0599561967,
0.1160911843,
0.0396757089,
0.0020592662,
-0.0382690392,
-0.03891249,
0.0487933345,
0.0391793177,
-0.0318368413,
0.0174627006,
0.101814121,
-0.0132033452,
-0.0322491974,
-0.0168818347,
-0.0260008574,
-0.0243525505,
0.0178324096,
-0.0092038512,
0.0303323846,
0.016152462,
0.0114535931,
0.0078823846,
-0.0271105208,
0.026126815,
0.0677803755,
0.0196232311,
-0.017955618,
-0.0310997088,
-0.0339398794,
0.0325706601,
-0.0341638736,
0.0033463128,
0.0510142073,
-0.0670093,
-0.0895433053,
-0.0365441181,
-0.0797019452,
0.0103436578,
0.0391078293,
0.0205274075,
-0.0066370093,
0.0408230647,
0.0142738987,
-0.0438545309,
-0.0130929491,
-0.0047722971,
0.007352239,
-0.0731951147,
0.0045519718,
-0.0009321444,
0.0214824248,
-0.0355364569,
0.0337001495,
-0.0961255878,
-0.074855864,
0.0432538688,
0.0215533115,
0.0187997054,
0.0458849035,
-0.011803735,
-0.0419611409,
0.0141313998,
0.1000671536,
-0.0051613669,
-0.022348756,
0.0437334925,
-0.0108785946,
-0.024466211,
0.0026137717,
-0.0475547314,
0.0151948547,
0.0409986675,
0.0074355733,
-0.0546005554,
-0.0121800499,
-0.0078883162,
0.0312343631,
0.0562399998,
-0.0124747828,
-0.0494593605,
-0.0354651585,
0.0137132797,
0.029526731,
0.0085352557,
-0.0029952121,
-0.0315906368,
0.0131992865,
0.0006029463,
-0.0244041048,
0.0642595738,
-0.0048955227,
0.0498502068,
-0.0208972581,
-0.0410173796,
-0.0019689263,
0.0747090578,
0.0062325075,
-0.0381721444,
0.0192168895,
0.0739447996,
0.0740522295,
0.071395658,
0.020587828,
-0.0403027572,
0.0152396299,
0.0311596431,
0.0134237017,
-0.0300107319,
-0.0269783847,
0.004505449,
-0.0450402424,
0.0717007294,
0.0379849076,
0.009590013,
0.017165482,
-0.0343496464,
-0.0149687547,
0.0056681801,
-0.0205758549,
0.0104907015,
0.0036793388,
0.0012627125,
0.0179188903,
-0.0033762567,
-0.0102685988,
0.0589097217,
0.0336184464,
0.0555379726,
-0.038772542,
-0.0104711661,
-0.0585820526,
0.009756119,
-0.0066923709,
-0.0116596194,
-0.0184564162,
0.0088699106,
-0.0434310585,
-0.063442409,
0.0341486,
-0.0057403562,
0.0346147195,
0.0099800834,
-0.0129150115,
-0.0041694045,
0.0159747414,
0.0234426521,
-0.0180252139,
-0.0100034038,
0.0462005287,
-0.0359225869,
0.0004625005,
-6.116257636e-33,
-0.0282261223,
-0.0488587655,
-0.0121591818,
-0.0590692647,
0.0036804748,
0.0203537364,
-0.0087843314,
0.0085131582,
0.0132901408,
-0.0037902531,
-0.0204761848,
0.0081143221,
0.02555071,
0.0018082996,
-0.0008506958,
-0.043544028,
0.0570680238,
-0.0092178602,
-0.0090022925,
-0.0267903022,
0.0165579803,
0.0578602441,
0.0506635308,
-0.1253183484,
0.0766739547,
0.0212366804,
-0.0389548019,
0.0030475075,
0.055950515,
0.0353610814,
0.0024159772,
0.0098971603,
-0.0092396634,
-0.0200142115,
-0.0072379038,
-0.0434163511,
-0.1550284326,
0.0137120029,
-0.0579493009,
0.0607960895,
-0.0165234003,
-0.0114341136,
0.080737032,
-0.0085202921,
-0.0135842524,
0.0065532615,
0.0289801192,
-0.0354031958,
-0.0186688397,
-0.028683966,
-0.0261327345,
0.0577958152,
-0.0013128736,
0.0524137244,
0.0563909933,
-0.0276463963,
0.0192488134,
0.0172128621,
-0.1161620542,
-0.0102684023,
0.0566640608,
-0.020471666,
-0.0056515462,
0.036706537,
-0.0291006695,
0.0420213901,
0.0638715774,
0.057562165,
-0.0019499389,
-0.0231012721,
0.0226306636,
0.0187969208,
0.0267087948,
0.0753069669,
0.0602062084,
-0.0370140187,
-0.0476680622,
0.0466520675,
-0.0078268182,
-0.0486391336,
-0.0151760904,
-0.0238847714,
-0.0741779134,
0.0058857631,
0.0080027543,
-0.0348916352,
-0.0420052595,
0.0337903872,
0.0112132253,
0.0195710417,
-0.0270106178,
0.0133399395,
-0.0211108699,
-0.0100670122,
-0.0531786159,
-0.0237404499,
0.0561273396,
0.0091706505,
-0.0038817474,
-0.0220629815,
-0.0221759919,
-0.0503036566,
-0.0007432908,
0.0146049475,
0.0291372258,
-0.0250670705,
0.0692007914,
-0.0138559621,
-0.0819298849,
0.0148382867,
0.0159032717,
0.0685355067,
0.033648517,
-0.0069188927,
0.0274612252,
-0.0484803915,
0.0100766011,
0.0049327328,
0.0566675998,
0.0301994476,
0.0264791399,
0.0484720692,
-0.0106643504,
0.0170574896,
0.0152486982,
-0.0229243282,
0.0083130831,
-0.0205166414,
0.0223350972,
-0.0401496105,
0.0198163595,
-0.0108229443,
2.636e-7,
-0.0190201439,
0.0502234437,
0.0354235061,
0.0038409401,
-0.0027510168,
0.0425456315,
0.0107944999,
0.0264988914,
-0.0330385044,
-0.0376388393,
0.0046706158,
-0.047781609,
0.0565059669,
0.0466152132,
-0.0753388703,
-0.0799749047,
-0.0049626543,
0.0347016789,
-0.01685673,
0.0264511891,
0.0175059848,
0.0588903464,
0.0158785172,
-0.0405856781,
0.0031236873,
-0.019956626,
0.0393732749,
-0.0265100505,
0.0394870937,
0.0207293499,
0.0442205518,
0.0388748311,
-0.0063633355,
0.0303747654,
-0.0243943594,
-0.0273651797,
0.0213251505,
0.0192562081,
0.001821185,
0.0203300044,
-0.031571921,
-0.0020601794,
0.0406673774,
0.0026755561,
0.0309012905,
0.0040893676,
-0.0116858929,
-0.0120892944,
-0.0526432395,
-0.0238197893,
0.0548559092,
0.0014859793,
-0.0143197607,
-0.0106661441,
0.0001001754,
0.0012022795,
-0.0002080426,
-0.0337542892,
0.0268933717,
-0.0095766066,
0.018946616,
-0.0128179332,
0.0106810303,
-0.0012094036,
0.0265725404,
-0.0485650748,
-0.0061520184,
2.011238233e-34,
0.0362541452,
-0.0172981732,
0.0093773073,
0.0351921022,
-0.0016363029,
-0.0002897568,
-0.017732745,
-0.0269409958,
-0.010126329,
-0.0015787617,
0.0209431481
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07597v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07597v1
|
Using Model-Theoretic Approaches to Uncover Linguistic Organization
| 2024-05-13T09:58:59 | 2024-05-13T09:58:59 |
Olivia Griffin, Jerry Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we consider pluractional markers in Kaqchikel, Karuk, and
Yurok. Like Balinese, each of these languages marks one type of pluractionality
via reduplication, and a different type of pluractionality via
non-reduplicative affixation. This paper serves as a proof-of-concept for
applying model-theoretic approaches to language as a lens that can help us to
recognize linguistic organization that is not apparent on the surface.
|
Using Model-Theoretic Approaches to Uncover Linguistic Organization: In this paper, we consider pluractional markers in Kaqchikel, Karuk, and
Yurok. Like Balinese, each of these languages marks one type of pluractionality
via reduplication, and a different type of pluractionality via
non-reduplicative affixation. This paper serves as a proof-of-concept for
applying model-theoretic approaches to language as a lens that can help us to
recognize linguistic organization that is not apparent on the surface.
|
[
0.0123734493,
0.022382224,
-0.062071763,
0.0147736873,
-0.0232876763,
0.0092963809,
-0.0250601806,
0.021518534,
-0.040872436,
-0.0188441277,
-0.0205271691,
-0.0331186056,
0.061368607,
-0.0250136051,
0.0514123552,
-0.0539915711,
0.0367222913,
-0.0210535973,
0.0454753935,
0.0538484827,
0.0184993874,
-0.0075941938,
-0.0194343086,
0.0067866966,
-0.0229591858,
-0.0202054605,
-0.0358491018,
-0.0249888711,
0.0161378179,
0.0195052773,
-0.0515079349,
-0.0020088619,
-0.0456509143,
0.0472982638,
0.0000017243,
-0.0423553735,
-0.0102990717,
-0.0300463866,
-0.0112332264,
0.0471578017,
0.0315110907,
-0.0030284503,
-0.0380986817,
-0.014132617,
0.0021220159,
-0.0148291811,
0.0750829801,
-0.0014006004,
-0.0258322079,
0.0307225436,
-0.0091723474,
-0.0470617972,
0.006223077,
-0.0034200391,
-0.0837822333,
0.0472433418,
0.0041496009,
0.0420108326,
0.0256566014,
-0.0374298654,
-0.0215297677,
0.0534612574,
0.0092454851,
-0.0302889496,
-0.0402441919,
-0.0145584214,
0.016173806,
-0.04779502,
0.0440334529,
0.0022233345,
-0.0006237542,
-0.0364633128,
-0.0076802056,
0.0111271571,
0.0028714419,
0.0670551062,
-0.0186606087,
0.0386716053,
-0.0043684486,
0.0358059779,
0.0761509389,
-0.0046110884,
0.023662569,
-0.0165229347,
-0.0440273136,
0.1021566465,
0.0387675464,
0.0020647766,
-0.0256900303,
-0.0229948815,
0.0166786648,
-0.0310673099,
-0.0182239991,
0.030044999,
0.0056297109,
0.0141375884,
0.0495676957,
0.0169552937,
0.0035878948,
-0.0297205094,
0.0768186003,
0.0112361731,
-0.0426105149,
0.0190010965,
-0.0123367598,
0.0065014972,
-0.0138052981,
-0.0161989462,
-0.0607338101,
0.034247864,
-0.0149725368,
-0.0492005199,
-0.0528313518,
-0.0022181333,
-0.0024061042,
0.0169019345,
-0.0282207169,
0.0427131653,
0.0437123254,
-0.0239425395,
-0.0755809471,
-0.0929606929,
0.0101575563,
0.0067389919,
0.0164176151,
0.0218625981,
-0.0265315212,
0.0146243237,
-0.0506532453,
-0.0503015853,
0.0317011364,
0.0547834486,
-0.0448909327,
0.0095510753,
-0.0735006481,
0.0022909883,
0.0054888213,
0.0222443007,
-0.013043209,
-0.0145493681,
-0.0276899822,
-0.0441627912,
-0.0059743021,
-0.0099390345,
-0.0045352005,
0.0030312676,
-0.0247862265,
-0.0513646342,
-0.0310364887,
-0.0482534021,
0.0116662029,
0.0153978132,
-0.0014742994,
0.046723295,
0.0166583732,
0.0031633358,
0.0059319995,
0.0221087206,
0.0276544355,
-0.0246033706,
0.0657028183,
-0.0614050627,
0.0537125915,
0.0433225445,
-0.02334884,
-0.0126358662,
-0.0384668224,
-0.0345810913,
0.0248288251,
-0.0459484719,
-0.014047713,
0.0538617224,
-0.0101161459,
0.0140716601,
-0.0037015672,
0.0593141727,
0.0360896476,
-0.015477296,
0.0015371414,
-0.0256177671,
0.0051509207,
0.0640255958,
0.0321045145,
-0.0246303268,
-0.059121687,
0.0350762643,
-0.0385149755,
-0.0006760715,
0.0012315087,
-0.0385981128,
-0.0559432395,
0.0070578502,
0.019242892,
-0.04188402,
0.0428108759,
0.0397661403,
0.0098523339,
0.0054452908,
0.0323396996,
-0.0301151965,
0.0108041419,
-0.0557845756,
0.0412414782,
-0.0396035984,
-0.0255680773,
-0.0482650883,
0.049619209,
0.0360874459,
-0.0060916585,
0.0475411899,
-0.0273938533,
-0.0267960746,
-0.0093533257,
-0.0249753762,
0.0281572416,
0.0526326336,
0.0472293533,
-0.0109157413,
-0.086658366,
0.0430792272,
-0.0100787077,
-0.0155094778,
0.0016168758,
0.0216917805,
-0.0374021865,
0.0295010637,
-0.0420156233,
0.0236392543,
-0.0013771304,
0.0281850286,
-0.0059722448,
0.0678589493,
0.0557507947,
-0.0299327355,
0.0431769043,
0.05745757,
0.0161443129,
0.0258367453,
0.0540269092,
-0.0037934624,
0.0307594929,
-0.0455297418,
0.0587965548,
-0.0315297619,
0.1070855036,
-0.0317691155,
0.0754826888,
-0.0265933722,
0.0760394484,
-0.0205753352,
0.0108768437,
-0.0176237002,
0.0563696921,
-0.0091930712,
0.0103053972,
-0.0022039996,
-0.0294621736,
0.0278833117,
-0.0278724004,
0.0459727272,
0.0447843447,
-0.0054707187,
-0.0197178852,
0.0134993792,
-0.0503492691,
-0.0104274731,
-0.0420467071,
-0.0418833382,
-0.0527185947,
-0.0202344302,
0.0546608679,
0.0075044353,
0.0332449824,
0.006673181,
-0.0008597535,
0.0542603359,
-0.0110931527,
0.0373440124,
0.0180439372,
0.0260579884,
-0.0280241147,
-0.0982965827,
-0.0189865846,
-0.0155041898,
0.0001592916,
0.0325119607,
-0.0295442119,
-0.1035434455,
-0.0701365471,
-0.0266265348,
-0.0458731912,
-0.0262402035,
-0.0274336021,
-0.0615538061,
0.0104161045,
0.0099078687,
0.0177161247,
0.010260216,
-0.0482831821,
0.0503701493,
0.0053790547,
-0.0282760635,
0.0138885183,
-0.0396339223,
0.0004759103,
0.0243078582,
-0.0217200723,
-0.018341653,
-0.0173676275,
0.0850709379,
0.0110767819,
-0.0024523856,
0.0242606234,
0.0121179493,
-0.0840355605,
0.01962981,
0.03793405,
-0.0446239822,
-0.0272557195,
0.0728655607,
-0.0224435553,
-0.0297808759,
-0.0088512646,
-0.0063511864,
-0.0370923281,
0.0032246776,
-0.0150198899,
-0.0388346687,
0.0652374625,
-0.0063112178,
0.0060005933,
0.074782528,
-0.0546275713,
-0.019981144,
-0.0240951404,
-0.0091653904,
0.0161742326,
0.0529407151,
-0.0695822909,
0.013003746,
0.004757612,
-0.0161169488,
-0.0107399756,
0.0065128114,
0.0066027399,
0.0371157788,
-0.0299748592,
0.0187866092,
0.0105205216,
0.0549913757,
-0.0231296383,
-0.0291959681,
0.0243950523,
0.047004316,
0.0025899692,
0.064274624,
0.0078597562,
0.0175566524,
0.0224708952,
-0.0095495153,
-0.0079136435,
0.0115432395,
-0.0539005548,
0.0158844069,
0.009773423,
-0.01017169,
0.0309678763,
-0.0221830234,
-0.0671020225,
-0.0590252243,
-0.0001306309,
-0.0053594951,
0.0264385827,
0.0492039695,
0.0345347412,
0.0373096466,
0.0702194124,
-0.0207309145,
0.0204068385,
0.0228450876,
-0.0274015851,
-0.034144979,
0.0490258001,
0.000479443,
-0.0567875281,
-0.0019767052,
0.012362672,
0.0138567202,
-0.0536890812,
-0.0203108303,
0.0219892431,
-0.0579895079,
-0.0161464848,
-0.0049873129,
0.008479435,
0.0068542096,
-0.012878105,
0.0549692176,
-0.013072947,
-0.0039020535,
0.0335058123,
-0.0451161489,
-0.0608593412,
-0.0709493235,
-0.0375853367,
0.0043313848,
0.0202645417,
0.0327697396,
-0.0620267726,
-0.0128291789,
0.056430053,
0.0222217534,
-0.0099599017,
0.0086415168,
-0.0531311594,
0.0713043883,
-0.0138570825,
-0.0437923186,
0.016211208,
-0.0203294065,
-0.0091440361,
0.0191201735,
0.0467328653,
-0.0057518785,
-0.0192829352,
0.0276888404,
-0.004870018,
-0.0058603454,
0.0060332255,
0.0394718945,
-0.0050248005,
0.0193896834,
-0.0254420768,
0.0092302142,
0.0995753706,
-0.04484424,
0.0362658277,
0.0145591982,
-0.05371508,
-0.0844404325,
-0.0431002453,
0.0084173186,
0.0280545969,
0.0308721829,
0.0127148898,
0.0057040295,
-0.0376496762,
-0.0388550311,
-0.0145002855,
-0.0057996633,
-0.0130911088,
-0.0620753318,
-0.0315469056,
-0.0008177128,
-0.0317802876,
0.0102848159,
-0.0332805291,
0.0058568832,
-0.0693702474,
0.0491088703,
-0.0187792722,
0.0317710675,
-0.0463661961,
-0.0139841828,
-0.0536298491,
-0.0268073957,
-0.0441468582,
-0.0170461778,
0.083725132,
0.0131461378,
-0.0609557666,
0.007556078,
0.0659273416,
0.0165994167,
0.0484273434,
-0.0061387699,
-0.0188475586,
-0.0828764588,
-0.0157478396,
0.0015289781,
0.0199328419,
0.025571283,
-0.0346397907,
-0.0246274564,
-0.0225089155,
-0.0380067267,
-0.0443408303,
-0.0006677773,
-0.0294399578,
0.0085156308,
0.0431282967,
0.0233329963,
-0.0333086923,
-0.0379707813,
-0.0168500859,
-0.0030517075,
0.0433183648,
0.0395882986,
0.0510622896,
0.0054450384,
0.0065777963,
0.0490253605,
0.0370207541,
0.0841213986,
-0.0866031647,
0.028992936,
-0.0360458866,
-0.0071796258,
0.0163284224,
-0.0035193088,
0.0023783622,
0.0426701009,
0.0510337912,
-0.0094273565,
0.0516794883,
-0.0433377549,
0.0452501141,
-0.0386365689,
0.0714432448,
-0.0213802233,
-0.0067058071,
-0.0354909748,
0.062523745,
0.0180217866,
-0.0179900862,
-0.03402628,
0.0375392325,
-0.0307134539,
0.0355041176,
0.0277587175,
0.0009317063,
-0.0233830214,
0.0128208846,
0.0066607553,
-0.0193588119,
-0.0043250439,
0.0225877035,
-0.0235550161,
0.0048587411,
0.0259812903,
-0.1132407784,
-0.0377515741,
-0.0124955652,
-0.0044934708,
0.009596833,
0.0032365867,
-0.0147248935,
0.0421891287,
0.0341714099,
0.0105987201,
-0.056851346,
-0.0206308849,
-0.0164155681,
0.0232280102,
0.0562496781,
-5.492976001e-33,
-0.0461567231,
-0.0377514549,
-0.0116373627,
-0.0326443203,
0.000859574,
0.0200318601,
0.0059025353,
0.0180337895,
-0.0496809408,
0.0264586676,
-0.0041299611,
0.0055879019,
0.0103043653,
-0.0174268056,
0.0508012138,
0.0416311361,
0.0005082504,
-0.0073094754,
-0.0166755393,
-0.0498350002,
0.0452009328,
-0.0448995829,
0.1013335958,
-0.0233048163,
0.0078836987,
-0.0210941155,
-0.027440289,
0.0404749215,
-0.0347215571,
0.0579506494,
-0.03239296,
0.0063286377,
0.0133341644,
0.0135171497,
-0.01088457,
-0.0536143221,
-0.0175716318,
-0.0483112447,
0.0618547387,
0.0322721787,
-0.0312599838,
-0.0215236638,
0.0039517176,
-0.0367095731,
-0.0110292528,
0.0021356747,
-0.0152879925,
-0.0113420747,
0.0006499251,
0.1229317263,
-0.0777099431,
0.0180484932,
-0.0147452522,
-0.004153348,
0.1077827588,
-0.0541010574,
-0.0148606189,
-0.0630664453,
-0.0307358485,
0.0319148414,
0.0126219131,
0.0722143799,
0.0490956269,
0.0580496453,
-0.0268970411,
0.000548567,
0.0401189327,
-0.0065357359,
0.0497261547,
0.0268929657,
0.0205704216,
0.0787157863,
0.0056053707,
-0.0019045321,
-0.0265817661,
-0.0090251332,
-0.0057395529,
-0.0561622381,
0.0473267287,
-0.0365250185,
-0.0301298834,
0.0301537793,
-0.0649881735,
-0.0503400117,
0.0119042499,
-0.0896193385,
-0.0030846582,
0.0013885901,
-0.0152371861,
-0.0160766765,
0.0046249358,
0.0252131149,
0.014622543,
-0.0174262319,
-0.0457955077,
-0.0108248536,
-0.0312544741,
0.0530529656,
0.0040622596,
-0.0028209523,
-0.0019742297,
0.0095131183,
-0.0181376226,
0.033638142,
0.0249547213,
0.0130143249,
-0.0211355258,
0.0335542448,
-0.0299028829,
-0.0022931453,
0.0120064551,
-0.0507667139,
0.0167126134,
-0.0128736924,
0.0492620841,
0.0147562344,
0.0225079544,
0.0410969891,
0.0614364967,
-0.0049220864,
0.0065480168,
0.0312906168,
-0.0169292055,
-0.0196780507,
-0.0161303487,
-0.0103463549,
0.0282657053,
0.0681935325,
0.0904578418,
0.0111289918,
-0.0165457968,
-0.0128201358,
2.677e-7,
0.0564219654,
0.0439245664,
0.0663175881,
0.0068283915,
0.0277443081,
-0.0014443243,
-0.0376650281,
-0.0149916476,
-0.0371121615,
-0.0300079789,
0.0066248663,
-0.0062730326,
0.0171803702,
0.0057308283,
-0.0362513326,
0.0244193543,
-0.0272164438,
0.0011695309,
-0.0267533716,
-0.0387196578,
-0.0302298591,
0.0480330735,
0.0171493292,
-0.0231530331,
-0.0580664501,
0.0004265937,
0.0120343566,
0.0073638544,
-0.0172887146,
0.0406495929,
0.0080047166,
-0.0741980448,
0.0147052919,
-0.000529659,
0.0044679344,
0.0378318615,
0.0563365147,
0.0151412962,
-0.0204689018,
0.0472414158,
0.017516898,
-0.0394105874,
-0.0205002427,
-0.0254211109,
0.0274234451,
0.0529090092,
-0.0264388304,
-0.0074213608,
0.0018005368,
0.0429509096,
0.0289241318,
-0.0069647101,
-0.0030497913,
0.0510030203,
0.0031738961,
-0.0307817236,
-0.0202964637,
-0.0119862286,
-0.0640231222,
-0.032476224,
0.013584706,
-0.0272254236,
0.0342406556,
-0.0133419139,
0.0020045096,
-0.0567902327,
-0.0442799851,
2.317701549e-34,
0.0099029634,
-0.0059376019,
0.0325493366,
0.0389007442,
0.0047899475,
-0.0397722796,
-0.021327788,
0.0599303469,
0.0304392111,
-0.0313592292,
0.0065368293
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07586v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07586v1
|
Thai Universal Dependency Treebank
| 2024-05-13T09:48:13 | 2024-05-13T09:48:13 |
Panyut Sriwirote, Wei Qi Leong, Charin Polpanumas, Santhawat Thanyawong, William Chandra Tjhi, Wirote Aroonmanakun, Attapol T. Rutherford
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automatic dependency parsing of Thai sentences has been underexplored, as
evidenced by the lack of large Thai dependency treebanks with complete
dependency structures and the lack of a published systematic evaluation of
state-of-the-art models, especially transformer-based parsers. In this work, we
address these problems by introducing Thai Universal Dependency Treebank (TUD),
a new largest Thai treebank consisting of 3,627 trees annotated in accordance
with the Universal Dependencies (UD) framework. We then benchmark dependency
parsing models that incorporate pretrained transformers as encoders and train
them on Thai-PUD and our TUD. The evaluation results show that most of our
models can outperform other models reported in previous papers and provide
insight into the optimal choices of components to include in Thai dependency
parsers. The new treebank and every model's full prediction generated in our
experiment are made available on a GitHub repository for further study.
|
Thai Universal Dependency Treebank: Automatic dependency parsing of Thai sentences has been underexplored, as
evidenced by the lack of large Thai dependency treebanks with complete
dependency structures and the lack of a published systematic evaluation of
state-of-the-art models, especially transformer-based parsers. In this work, we
address these problems by introducing Thai Universal Dependency Treebank (TUD),
a new largest Thai treebank consisting of 3,627 trees annotated in accordance
with the Universal Dependencies (UD) framework. We then benchmark dependency
parsing models that incorporate pretrained transformers as encoders and train
them on Thai-PUD and our TUD. The evaluation results show that most of our
models can outperform other models reported in previous papers and provide
insight into the optimal choices of components to include in Thai dependency
parsers. The new treebank and every model's full prediction generated in our
experiment are made available on a GitHub repository for further study.
|
[
0.0578478724,
0.0572162792,
0.0084201004,
0.0597659014,
-0.0105118332,
0.0205374733,
-0.0401870646,
-0.0283333324,
-0.048167903,
0.0012218582,
-0.0078801075,
-0.0179975107,
-0.0090194484,
0.0132152373,
-0.043540325,
-0.1024421677,
-0.0052725202,
0.0244457722,
-0.0252817702,
0.0177756269,
0.0303032547,
-0.0105208587,
0.0134398108,
0.0233556386,
-0.0669825003,
-0.0348658897,
0.0201610792,
0.0281766746,
0.0058195977,
-0.0624457188,
0.0360308811,
0.0411506519,
-0.0237715114,
-0.0381045975,
0.0000019531,
-0.0228875075,
-0.0182985347,
-0.040882688,
-0.025884483,
0.0112204067,
-0.0111674797,
-0.0838057995,
0.0049628392,
0.034164533,
-0.0065178704,
-0.0344611891,
0.055348821,
0.0630869642,
0.0536071658,
0.0735099912,
-0.0401456095,
-0.0802460685,
0.0224498622,
-0.0400401615,
-0.0527024716,
-0.0137454318,
-0.0077855717,
0.0080241729,
-0.0395325907,
-0.0347334146,
-0.0349852853,
0.0067683887,
0.0433186963,
0.0191833954,
0.0367350876,
0.0047325967,
-0.025266353,
-0.0101072621,
0.0067306124,
0.0426617339,
-0.0267634355,
-0.007894705,
-0.0308196805,
-0.0079404172,
-0.0335946344,
0.0117778368,
-0.0149525404,
0.0354552455,
-0.0059501426,
0.0466486588,
0.03184627,
0.0516282544,
-0.009362408,
-0.0266811736,
-0.0188912824,
0.0584542342,
-0.0053482596,
-0.0494094603,
-0.0261522532,
0.0200649854,
0.0012522283,
-0.0293593705,
0.0334400199,
-0.0403283685,
0.0219922028,
0.0140123274,
0.0014275112,
0.0010490664,
0.0116469702,
-0.033610519,
-0.0475612432,
0.055841554,
-0.0907611623,
0.0035604036,
0.0070393402,
0.0458610281,
-0.0314735994,
-0.0039879959,
-0.0324273594,
0.0160325728,
-0.0081994794,
0.0063838176,
-0.0585250407,
0.038768176,
-0.022859253,
-0.0115724606,
-0.0412476957,
-0.0166778881,
0.0325067006,
-0.0331790037,
0.0592897721,
0.0266043842,
-0.0599335134,
0.0212830491,
0.0072303964,
0.0676315501,
0.0156562887,
-0.0088723311,
-0.0372178406,
-0.0445881747,
0.0080804955,
0.0264847111,
0.0311765969,
-0.0475455597,
0.0010213589,
0.0011030339,
0.0028377317,
-0.024535764,
0.0014317242,
0.0421367288,
0.0017112948,
0.0007393199,
-0.006131717,
-0.0510427244,
0.0270366538,
0.0231280942,
0.0629670396,
-0.0078696553,
0.031990502,
0.0187023096,
0.0234986115,
0.0634655505,
0.0067963628,
-0.0136155877,
-0.0343856104,
-0.0074799187,
-0.0057907822,
0.025234133,
-0.0029026526,
0.011897916,
-0.0014753743,
-0.0012211207,
-0.003445674,
0.0185659528,
-0.035548225,
-0.0128449826,
0.029480638,
0.0005694811,
-0.0320530534,
0.00379976,
0.0033271569,
0.0392240919,
-0.0227262359,
0.0139881503,
0.0055157365,
-0.0086381687,
-0.0191802718,
0.0085103977,
0.0440079868,
0.0159311332,
-0.0045553106,
0.0531821474,
-0.0341999009,
-0.0198415816,
0.0155763403,
0.0124686947,
-0.0755430013,
0.0008708821,
0.002326119,
-0.0464140363,
-0.0105201621,
-0.0703076869,
-0.0410790071,
-0.047617767,
0.0567065775,
0.0371746942,
-0.0389155447,
0.0909840763,
0.0351730511,
-0.0553288013,
-0.032812845,
0.0402420759,
-0.0312830396,
0.0529708341,
0.0444217958,
-0.0056382255,
-0.0256100688,
0.0074446732,
-0.0251872092,
0.0596756935,
-0.0244326051,
-0.0121737262,
0.0089768237,
-0.0428076759,
0.0382012203,
0.0416210257,
0.0103879096,
0.027380567,
-0.0168923289,
-0.0266454108,
0.0142108705,
0.0710875764,
-0.0160212107,
0.0352800228,
0.0182469059,
0.0353827253,
0.0316918492,
0.0200840198,
0.0601116195,
0.015067352,
-0.030845128,
0.0093646748,
0.0324494131,
-0.0788812563,
-0.018572893,
0.0498416014,
-0.0890944526,
-0.045444265,
0.0103248153,
-0.0695012882,
0.0049432144,
0.0683556199,
-0.0065784375,
-0.028341366,
-0.0110446513,
0.0020804275,
0.0286673531,
-0.024475202,
0.0354125053,
-0.0024159322,
0.067516923,
-0.0086702323,
0.0801100284,
-0.0186978262,
-0.0054515097,
-0.0173375458,
0.0110736471,
0.0371865034,
-0.0025766722,
-0.0380943753,
0.0189377554,
0.0028432584,
-0.0353786387,
0.0092518618,
0.0180932954,
-0.0080547426,
-0.017925486,
-0.0641494766,
0.0011710689,
-0.0417760536,
0.0632120073,
0.0169593059,
0.0088591436,
-0.0163317081,
-0.0471640266,
0.0186829027,
-0.0310763661,
0.0179096125,
-0.0225160345,
-0.0153205991,
0.016700346,
0.0176460613,
-0.0407463275,
-0.0102269333,
0.0055118483,
0.0203122199,
0.0038694339,
-0.0811839923,
0.0110870581,
0.0259100813,
0.0287857652,
0.0027286708,
0.0113954805,
-0.0502677485,
0.015329848,
-0.0086956564,
0.0456631482,
-0.0387547426,
-0.0165597796,
-0.0072796904,
-0.0164332185,
-0.0084783314,
-0.0088508762,
0.0039575463,
-0.008589833,
0.0381642357,
-0.0697175786,
-0.0203085989,
-0.0297545195,
0.0802356601,
0.0061656577,
0.0024144081,
-0.0359627344,
-0.0561993904,
-0.0409860387,
0.0064453869,
0.010715819,
-0.0398216136,
-0.0333035812,
0.0079998737,
-0.017977057,
-0.0252707396,
0.0303708762,
-0.0178927761,
-0.0318954177,
-0.0455966853,
0.0369638205,
-0.0575629137,
0.0801373422,
0.0663378835,
-0.0232564081,
0.0302583594,
-0.0739987269,
0.0382106975,
0.0558784269,
0.0024458903,
0.0014156692,
0.0342012011,
-0.0309818238,
0.0191262458,
-0.014743452,
-0.0647779107,
-0.0464124233,
-0.024710184,
-0.0348766409,
-0.005711162,
0.0140054245,
-0.0113018872,
0.0368383266,
0.0285043437,
-0.0295149572,
0.0059046103,
0.0183211174,
0.0262762327,
-0.0263080318,
0.0613496043,
-0.0064338376,
-0.0042813621,
-0.0057264804,
0.0297425538,
0.0364628881,
0.0149053466,
0.033297807,
0.0022512611,
-0.0341408364,
-0.0073844367,
0.0048487228,
-0.0067664371,
-0.0282944553,
-0.0302546993,
-0.0325418897,
-0.0233055875,
-0.0098952102,
0.0981175303,
0.0744203627,
-0.0437249392,
0.0284148771,
-0.0123434169,
0.030925272,
0.0142969424,
0.0023813988,
-0.0835700855,
-0.0301145278,
0.0212424286,
-0.0263757259,
0.0012633995,
-0.0155221894,
0.0191284996,
-0.1045904681,
-0.0064118979,
-0.0197283868,
0.0300881937,
-0.0241089724,
0.0233869273,
-0.0278968047,
-0.0532285869,
0.0156287942,
0.0220766049,
-0.0118295774,
-0.0197473578,
0.0607668459,
-0.0931466445,
-0.0821372941,
0.0276481323,
-0.0337429382,
-0.0169391725,
0.0447447784,
-0.0018893927,
-0.0379535593,
0.020208016,
0.0350919999,
-0.0550706573,
-0.0026345472,
0.0036531864,
0.044860363,
0.0066052284,
-0.0379309356,
0.0094916048,
-0.0056426283,
-0.0685040429,
0.0262154043,
0.0054083262,
0.0558557808,
0.0003447055,
0.0320164487,
0.0524416156,
-0.0547694005,
-0.0073442599,
0.0137011893,
-0.0027909612,
-0.0338584036,
-0.0228793174,
-0.052894216,
0.0037788874,
-0.0646209419,
-0.0289741047,
0.0294679068,
0.0151057588,
-0.0493758544,
-0.0925861597,
-0.0679678991,
0.0221005082,
-0.0170527566,
-0.0296825618,
-0.0184598975,
0.0438618995,
0.010089797,
0.0450939536,
0.0369784497,
0.0082272794,
0.0055901902,
-0.039107319,
-0.0138352914,
0.0400745235,
0.015766751,
-0.00648177,
-0.0019772199,
-0.0074730874,
-0.01108527,
0.0517831817,
0.0288460478,
0.0069719143,
0.0147777759,
-0.0503056645,
-0.0209174436,
-0.0900264457,
0.018827755,
-0.0481867865,
-0.0059871953,
0.0418267064,
-0.0469866544,
0.0164539479,
0.0283225905,
0.0197575446,
0.0181077104,
-0.0552733727,
0.0454200357,
-0.0213972908,
0.0032875757,
0.0874054655,
0.0044970009,
0.01803587,
-0.0320544168,
0.0313466862,
-0.0516712815,
0.0609003156,
-0.0658073649,
-0.0234087594,
-0.0322044939,
-0.0046330928,
0.0416864268,
0.0244998783,
-0.0303527378,
-0.0163791627,
-0.0128396722,
-0.0171803012,
0.0275133755,
0.0486420915,
0.0764624849,
0.0246688742,
0.0147857405,
-0.0097984029,
-0.0040114447,
-0.0715869814,
0.0153709548,
-0.0087009594,
-0.0062113577,
0.0207480583,
-0.0020077801,
-0.0227433704,
0.001340143,
-0.0275196489,
0.036057353,
0.0258287136,
-0.0060665193,
-0.0549920239,
0.0801027194,
-0.0427145213,
0.0681606233,
-0.0551341735,
0.0416242778,
0.0105048344,
0.0062529608,
-0.0159940291,
-0.0235674847,
0.0210841578,
-0.0304732863,
-0.016051352,
0.0376211591,
0.0811116621,
-0.0143184057,
0.0522630028,
-0.0013946448,
0.0147429314,
-0.0206681639,
-0.0275174081,
-0.0287418794,
0.0047534355,
-0.0244192295,
0.035213396,
-0.0396645144,
-0.0379674807,
-0.0086034723,
0.0103513757,
0.0248383284,
-0.0081146862,
0.0405495763,
0.0185793936,
0.0341386646,
0.0098303454,
-0.0071696728,
-0.0250954032,
-0.0520749316,
0.0305339564,
-0.0262202173,
-5.785905887e-33,
-0.0188062396,
0.0113584893,
-0.0361368768,
0.0258263331,
-0.0128556537,
0.0084047858,
-0.0232162829,
0.0261736996,
0.004293568,
-0.0066919029,
-0.0408659913,
0.0092807263,
0.0279155001,
0.0731013566,
0.0921977758,
-0.0152072199,
0.0150552643,
0.0061989152,
0.0235129204,
-0.0019838328,
0.031162655,
0.0476688966,
0.074906528,
-0.0570432767,
-0.0170207508,
-0.0264011919,
-0.0343567468,
0.0177420657,
-0.0083661592,
0.0541757606,
-0.0291042272,
0.0411335714,
0.0259528868,
-0.029633956,
-0.0272047631,
-0.0196648519,
-0.0856623426,
0.012197677,
-0.0059297755,
0.0596581884,
-0.045540113,
-0.0142219551,
0.0168741904,
0.0051184851,
0.0317952819,
0.0397250839,
0.0091753015,
-0.053316284,
0.0202623941,
0.0045739473,
-0.0499908552,
0.0357625112,
0.0013190716,
0.0189950895,
0.0259696133,
0.0774179101,
-0.0141428476,
0.0112429522,
-0.0376477353,
-0.016695058,
0.0011182554,
0.0290880669,
0.0298033841,
-0.0271556377,
-0.0110566914,
0.0161937289,
-0.0042296792,
-0.0857960656,
0.030199755,
0.0076798117,
-0.0295974109,
0.0438870043,
0.0447456129,
-0.0188834686,
0.0572941415,
-0.0040368023,
-0.0447106734,
-0.0240224395,
0.0344453603,
0.0700125173,
0.0033489119,
0.0089218095,
-0.0378690884,
-0.0176182427,
0.0233423803,
0.0000399719,
0.0111745913,
-0.0658002049,
0.0202002544,
0.0217248183,
-0.0158292241,
0.0377921797,
0.0483347028,
-0.0440934449,
0.0073872497,
0.0358467363,
-0.0185971633,
0.0728494972,
-0.0267556887,
-0.0017224458,
-0.053081397,
-0.0164555293,
-0.0125029366,
-0.0179499406,
-0.0003336165,
-0.0229745675,
0.0640673116,
0.0313650891,
-0.0509888753,
0.0337041877,
-0.038790971,
0.0187874306,
-0.0489550494,
0.101047717,
0.0055881888,
0.0197356269,
-0.047130838,
0.0170951094,
0.003666627,
0.0321459547,
-0.0663071647,
0.0121852849,
0.0148405982,
0.012431127,
-0.0141090108,
0.0056924117,
-0.0309446249,
0.0348124504,
0.0101775471,
-0.0042276541,
-0.0062493738,
0.0588585399,
2.592e-7,
0.0764077976,
0.0115783755,
0.0912672132,
-0.0468355343,
0.0565923825,
-0.0011882423,
-0.0146144368,
-0.0058359257,
-0.0200967658,
-0.0202011298,
0.016448183,
-0.0188256092,
0.0455212817,
0.0102441451,
-0.1253691167,
-0.0112934308,
-0.0638250783,
-0.0529638864,
-0.029620178,
-0.0354899354,
0.0504664108,
0.1253727525,
-0.0304876696,
-0.0035386765,
-0.0176883023,
0.0497925542,
0.0322594345,
0.0166488327,
-0.0096414229,
0.0231556073,
0.0093299691,
-0.0025038237,
-0.0022337595,
-0.0039967187,
-0.0132402806,
0.0466767251,
0.0234126635,
0.0329792425,
0.0068480093,
0.0137035083,
0.0248335451,
0.0631697327,
-0.0431036651,
-0.02475884,
0.0481259301,
-0.0373925306,
0.0105885575,
0.0416067094,
-0.0409794524,
0.0634858981,
-0.0160686709,
0.0245275348,
-0.0329473615,
0.0332374871,
0.032391414,
-0.0381905027,
-0.0759895071,
-0.0115992576,
-0.0503565148,
0.034199845,
-0.0321585089,
0.0263335407,
-0.011317661,
-0.0021451358,
-0.0375763737,
-0.0179249384,
-0.009260077,
2.01239536e-34,
0.011403867,
0.0121389553,
0.0282385647,
0.0393050238,
0.0253975559,
-0.0420434289,
-0.050871253,
0.0427443571,
-0.0513577238,
-0.0628338158,
0.0145334164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13008v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13008v1
|
Control Token with Dense Passage Retrieval
| 2024-05-13T09:17:19 | 2024-05-13T09:17:19 |
Juhwan Lee, Jisu Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This study addresses the hallucination problem in large language models
(LLMs). We adopted Retrieval-Augmented Generation(RAG) (Lewis et al., 2020), a
technique that involves embedding relevant information in the prompt to obtain
accurate answers. However, RAG also faced inherent issues in retrieving correct
information. To address this, we employed the Dense Passage Retrieval(DPR)
(Karpukhin et al., 2020) model for fetching domain-specific documents related
to user queries. Despite this, the DPR model still lacked accuracy in document
retrieval. We enhanced the DPR model by incorporating control tokens, achieving
significantly superior performance over the standard DPR model, with a 13%
improvement in Top-1 accuracy and a 4% improvement in Top-20 accuracy.
|
Control Token with Dense Passage Retrieval: This study addresses the hallucination problem in large language models
(LLMs). We adopted Retrieval-Augmented Generation(RAG) (Lewis et al., 2020), a
technique that involves embedding relevant information in the prompt to obtain
accurate answers. However, RAG also faced inherent issues in retrieving correct
information. To address this, we employed the Dense Passage Retrieval(DPR)
(Karpukhin et al., 2020) model for fetching domain-specific documents related
to user queries. Despite this, the DPR model still lacked accuracy in document
retrieval. We enhanced the DPR model by incorporating control tokens, achieving
significantly superior performance over the standard DPR model, with a 13%
improvement in Top-1 accuracy and a 4% improvement in Top-20 accuracy.
|
[
0.053710822,
0.0291223433,
-0.0152586102,
0.0052463477,
-0.037899904,
-0.0222870372,
0.0031425967,
0.0255506672,
0.0321870558,
-0.0467309281,
0.0026159708,
-0.0615701228,
-0.0406413265,
0.0322533138,
0.003160716,
-0.0489191897,
0.0560697913,
-0.0349249989,
0.0121697206,
-0.0126561755,
-0.0185018573,
0.0027470989,
0.0161021315,
0.0256781522,
-0.0045587807,
-0.0123329926,
-0.0050330739,
0.0149008408,
-0.0163467005,
-0.0190599654,
0.0263686776,
0.0470732339,
0.0208158754,
0.0577479079,
0.0000021421,
-0.0539277866,
-0.0615463369,
0.0191390887,
-0.0297567658,
-0.0174866784,
0.0579369254,
0.0734623969,
0.0274987016,
0.0225230288,
-0.0223437808,
0.0050801998,
0.0127143487,
0.0878258422,
0.0386365131,
0.0543681718,
0.0023937791,
-0.0398777612,
0.0249470863,
0.0005469901,
0.0697414204,
-0.0514215603,
0.0232172664,
0.0057310262,
0.0627439097,
0.0159077756,
0.0169904232,
0.0370142274,
0.0021567538,
-0.0142615428,
0.0337521993,
0.0200090483,
-0.0696415901,
-0.0096355146,
0.0132070938,
0.04823054,
0.0090617118,
-0.027869042,
0.0251297746,
0.0178893842,
-0.0052054012,
0.0284658652,
-0.0633133724,
-0.0079958849,
-0.0157836303,
-0.0076697012,
-0.02110295,
-0.0216795895,
0.0314139277,
0.023294799,
-0.0476318412,
0.0612545013,
0.0320728905,
-0.0332554132,
-0.0011706169,
-0.0070494595,
-0.0070499023,
-0.0138998926,
0.0407395326,
0.034793999,
-0.0655841529,
0.003696925,
-0.0195169281,
-0.0315343142,
0.0631037354,
-0.0475783907,
-0.0015215763,
0.013618621,
-0.0291702338,
0.0539529696,
-0.035167072,
0.0483822301,
-0.0108051673,
0.0201151073,
-0.0426552519,
-0.0134610459,
-0.0284769237,
-0.0368059538,
-0.0612028614,
0.0743026882,
-0.0403164737,
-0.0353900678,
-0.0213918779,
0.0145201217,
0.023266349,
0.0057449299,
-0.0244720969,
0.0245552715,
-0.0270798262,
-0.0237844046,
-0.0139882825,
0.006001947,
-0.0284389239,
-0.0340271071,
0.0356731191,
-0.065584816,
-0.0066728406,
-0.0082422532,
0.0205895659,
-0.0157852657,
0.0074078017,
0.0197431333,
0.0007006385,
-0.037486922,
-0.0301806331,
-0.0735819414,
-0.0022745563,
-0.0394610092,
-0.0298998859,
-0.0853132308,
0.0266265869,
0.0303643588,
-0.0099067902,
-0.02250522,
0.0122567387,
0.0648590326,
-0.0422530733,
0.0098767774,
-0.0049257735,
0.0132761234,
0.0582768135,
0.0275161769,
0.0085876593,
0.0453532226,
-0.0256803557,
0.0695584342,
0.0540746562,
0.0174756292,
0.0459025539,
0.0157532785,
0.0021632202,
-0.0041427054,
-0.0249288864,
0.0009613219,
0.0207023639,
0.0155611066,
0.0036234963,
0.0556714721,
-0.0496658459,
0.0267951377,
0.013172023,
0.0534125753,
0.0300240759,
-0.0107522178,
0.0126826121,
0.0087884814,
0.0018604267,
0.0122025497,
-0.0358647965,
0.0029814448,
-0.0208450649,
0.0072769034,
0.1169548407,
0.0035418584,
-0.0103352834,
-0.0248783287,
-0.0012709212,
0.022210706,
-0.0337773487,
0.0340148285,
0.033601556,
-0.0048910612,
-0.0503575057,
0.0611340068,
0.0171609893,
-0.0462361798,
0.0182714388,
-0.0488214158,
0.0100697083,
0.0961612016,
0.1005559936,
-0.0384055227,
0.0156537481,
0.0041122697,
0.0297364444,
0.0367208607,
0.0471280478,
0.0051882742,
-0.0390457548,
-0.0582694225,
-0.0462712534,
0.0158125032,
0.0196795333,
0.0048451256,
0.0209903438,
0.0282740053,
0.0393609479,
-0.0566875674,
-0.0490258411,
0.0185506083,
-0.0149314571,
-0.0229705852,
-0.0198626984,
-0.0206377842,
-0.0134935044,
0.0246360563,
-0.0066616079,
0.0318289511,
0.0236180574,
-0.0229149815,
-0.0544375181,
-0.0331621282,
-0.0574503578,
0.033223521,
0.030030204,
0.0100678504,
0.0120216981,
-0.0046991752,
0.0012036667,
-0.0430025756,
-0.0216399003,
-0.0516596101,
0.059698727,
-0.0573040247,
0.0468347706,
-0.004332759,
-0.0100464094,
-0.0649406835,
0.0844330117,
0.0092934407,
0.0497607812,
0.0401828997,
0.0250390079,
0.0055060145,
-0.0317742154,
-0.0268187821,
0.0140651129,
-0.0324225798,
0.0171305053,
0.0544389933,
-0.0407637917,
-0.0588282757,
-0.005488887,
-0.0780409053,
-0.0158145707,
-0.0196344946,
0.0027171534,
-0.0020518538,
0.0406383052,
-0.0163137298,
-0.009236455,
-0.0257887952,
-0.0353521034,
0.0368266515,
0.0451786891,
-0.0036107162,
0.0180881899,
-0.0181651991,
-0.033049278,
-0.0111642126,
0.0057172999,
0.0165395159,
-0.0250551701,
-0.0340680666,
-0.0503962412,
0.0516548716,
-0.0164165813,
0.0200244244,
-0.0027925011,
-0.0057959175,
0.0004119836,
-0.0596071444,
0.065458931,
0.0198001359,
0.0215804446,
-0.0141438274,
0.0242933445,
-0.0149465464,
-0.0997363254,
0.0181411635,
-0.0342197567,
-0.0142661603,
0.0133648794,
-0.0240617972,
0.0455370396,
0.0003903475,
0.0102860657,
0.0106498739,
-0.032348536,
-0.0099254828,
-0.0340516642,
-0.0175352022,
-0.0436640382,
-0.0147999264,
-0.0288546216,
0.0378538258,
-0.0226034429,
-0.0441873819,
0.0632866994,
-0.0196097959,
0.0112506878,
-0.0505370535,
0.0273342263,
-0.0143648973,
0.0429875217,
0.0019498819,
0.0320464373,
-0.0502466932,
-0.0590232462,
-0.0124353012,
0.0118196616,
-0.0019177718,
-0.0762670711,
0.0191170182,
-0.0049479851,
0.0107871257,
0.0018521537,
-0.0134351337,
-0.0638052672,
-0.0502724908,
0.0048011239,
-0.0248023923,
-0.0025542518,
-0.0119612748,
-0.0580219179,
0.0033504991,
0.0317967087,
0.0336395316,
-0.0448617935,
-0.0232115146,
0.0025406769,
0.0186958313,
0.0862235874,
-0.0090633044,
0.0101842787,
-0.0196270477,
0.0258146618,
0.0804402828,
0.0834705904,
-0.0163041633,
0.0455285162,
-0.0269416757,
0.0670728534,
-0.0582190491,
-0.040478617,
0.0236011539,
0.0273854788,
-0.0517656356,
-0.0413657129,
0.1041689143,
0.0558316372,
-0.0663817674,
-0.0384045132,
-0.0882881433,
0.0362368412,
0.0042850855,
0.0508293472,
-0.0527829826,
-0.0039792946,
0.0340042524,
0.0520712733,
0.0007440432,
-0.0104680872,
0.0060043111,
-0.1231280714,
0.0362856686,
-0.0015203098,
0.013553462,
-0.0403617062,
-0.0554055013,
-0.0066656545,
0.05962855,
0.0130932303,
0.048572164,
-0.0056576179,
-0.009121296,
0.0189909302,
0.0113659082,
-0.0024829498,
0.0065427045,
-0.0299252868,
-0.0016576927,
0.093889676,
0.0165187214,
0.0209767725,
-0.0507038683,
0.0330530293,
-0.0196540225,
0.0148169063,
-0.005550358,
0.0379609391,
-0.0006002258,
0.0280443486,
-0.020802442,
0.0116413031,
0.0083281714,
-0.0246540476,
-0.018657973,
0.0628770068,
-0.0293894745,
-0.0065315231,
-0.0516793393,
0.0076693716,
-0.0061116125,
0.0742329583,
0.0076700337,
-0.0086296871,
-0.0569929965,
-0.0201675016,
0.0491738617,
-0.0175454058,
-0.0151688857,
0.0167202037,
0.0058540492,
0.0118513722,
-0.0593608208,
-0.0050626774,
0.0089679481,
0.0524146184,
-0.0067462982,
0.0731790662,
-0.0590022281,
-0.0052857795,
-0.0146780573,
0.021760704,
-0.0734548643,
-0.0006595537,
-0.083304882,
-0.0061921924,
0.0202506036,
-0.0288181491,
-0.0126605835,
0.0269859638,
-0.0355208181,
-0.0698934719,
0.0302570444,
0.0118340198,
0.0236662477,
0.0161664393,
-0.0213689581,
-0.0583625734,
0.0771928355,
0.0494521447,
-0.0550055765,
-0.0216451474,
-0.0206031315,
0.00408031,
-0.0326049738,
0.010323734,
-0.0896307155,
-0.0073067215,
-0.0217179693,
0.0537297539,
0.0369385257,
-0.0351602994,
0.0201670527,
0.040407788,
0.0161607135,
0.0038238848,
0.0227723252,
-0.023798706,
0.0341327973,
-0.0230212398,
-0.0257150456,
0.0027358432,
0.0282995459,
0.012446288,
-0.0465381257,
0.0101640895,
-0.0107727749,
-0.003364685,
0.0385392904,
-0.0578721911,
-0.0298253838,
-0.0065572276,
-0.0032555347,
0.0418562032,
-0.0272008255,
-0.0212847982,
-0.0044056904,
0.0117235659,
0.068622157,
-0.0430732369,
0.0452133641,
-0.0031445764,
-0.0211158376,
-0.0192985628,
0.0220501218,
-0.0742698982,
-0.0812979713,
-0.0241025314,
0.0079829162,
0.0384159721,
-0.0084132692,
0.0191196837,
-0.0206051655,
-0.0050855414,
-0.0090726763,
-0.0390335545,
0.0586979836,
-0.0285009127,
-0.0200078823,
0.0419487692,
-0.0166841149,
0.0192519594,
0.0698161721,
-0.0120331803,
0.018613141,
-0.0202406254,
-0.0463763289,
-0.0080107627,
-0.0256101824,
-0.0007252409,
0.0446907356,
-0.0288553108,
-0.0439803042,
-0.0312296171,
-0.0269488338,
0.0495003499,
-0.0105304355,
-0.0073980698,
0.0001995781,
0.0426478088,
0.1049196273,
0.000576035,
-0.0428296439,
-0.0446788482,
0.0349945091,
0.0136238011,
-0.0134323267,
-0.000931336,
-6.485308128e-33,
-0.0181677956,
-0.026813399,
0.0170946829,
-0.0410652123,
-0.0364613794,
-0.0374872573,
-0.0196937881,
-0.0148805892,
0.0169511512,
-0.0160915367,
-0.0390435793,
0.0150355604,
0.0355027802,
0.0300854165,
-0.0033192111,
-0.0212909915,
0.0548998378,
0.0195257924,
-0.0267867669,
0.0583245568,
0.0686506331,
0.0561362244,
-0.019866908,
-0.0247681011,
0.0195812676,
-0.0498212092,
0.0288376566,
0.0016329824,
0.0266189016,
0.0282469485,
-0.0189032592,
0.0372358225,
0.0204374567,
-0.0461851545,
-0.020825848,
0.0147232013,
-0.0579285659,
-0.0150193879,
0.0034688648,
0.0008371651,
0.0080089848,
-0.0361911356,
0.0332254618,
-0.0355378389,
0.0121401679,
0.0405875668,
0.0294293333,
0.0033532258,
-0.0416077226,
-0.0298879799,
-0.0463822559,
0.0172084849,
0.0324353129,
0.0241961796,
0.0066655963,
0.0615632944,
0.0188986883,
0.0148580084,
-0.0655854046,
0.0253453981,
-0.0160138104,
0.0765055716,
0.0233266242,
0.0085001122,
-0.006601688,
0.070871003,
0.026575109,
-0.0099543352,
-0.0051962021,
-0.0116574876,
0.0169380587,
0.0077798981,
0.0002432372,
0.0113965329,
0.0336441211,
-0.0288678929,
-0.0078048194,
0.0584948175,
-0.0332415178,
0.0371251442,
0.0801091865,
0.0054268138,
-0.0520683601,
-0.0194319487,
-0.0090826694,
0.0551233515,
-0.0450051464,
-0.0430550836,
0.0551870652,
0.0224533547,
-0.044422444,
-0.0621435307,
0.0493500046,
-0.015917128,
-0.0260758381,
0.0360567272,
0.0049669482,
-0.0030036182,
-0.0391212218,
0.020713456,
0.0012881831,
-0.0255666524,
0.014006109,
-0.0250338465,
-0.0300880596,
0.0039101178,
-0.0212976933,
-0.0090695452,
-0.0776856467,
0.012892074,
-0.0193457194,
0.0123185934,
0.0048858337,
-0.0003817738,
0.0432370268,
0.0076046442,
0.0025471428,
0.0357875712,
0.0214473046,
0.0145856235,
-0.0279377401,
-0.0236579143,
-0.0037454504,
-0.0091363955,
0.0038917544,
0.0312379524,
-0.0537286326,
0.0579396375,
0.0032638742,
-0.0391499922,
-0.0097129438,
0.0120605975,
2.906e-7,
-0.0015906396,
0.0253473762,
0.023775693,
0.0290248264,
-0.0208949801,
-0.0176913049,
0.0447856337,
-0.0060172854,
0.0498097651,
-0.0075890617,
-0.0158619303,
0.0109037682,
0.0350729674,
0.0233651586,
-0.1405882686,
-0.0178786721,
-0.0357357077,
-0.0156626832,
-0.0613638237,
-0.0418684669,
0.0332917795,
0.0587611683,
-0.0146675603,
-0.0162651911,
-0.006176257,
-0.0603523329,
0.0226208139,
0.0185544919,
-0.0332316309,
0.0449665524,
0.0556971058,
0.0380789638,
0.031043781,
-0.0112181315,
-0.0206779148,
0.0213626102,
0.0322825573,
0.0154094519,
0.0177474413,
-0.0560331605,
-0.0220785122,
-0.0229669139,
0.0139657659,
-0.0530862249,
0.0755553916,
0.0303280167,
0.0225932486,
0.0090248715,
-0.0392709933,
-0.0361586846,
-0.0002360024,
-0.0117938919,
-0.0212596208,
0.048669558,
-0.0040808255,
0.0092494264,
0.0038752949,
-0.072954163,
-0.0135770626,
-0.0270305965,
-0.0470893234,
-0.0356454588,
-0.0480156541,
0.0132263303,
-0.0382712372,
-0.0618766099,
-0.0044690971,
2.907437192e-34,
0.041622974,
0.0167176072,
0.0187164247,
0.0231483504,
0.0418539345,
0.0074721766,
0.0459250361,
0.0447203927,
0.0226461068,
-0.0900185108,
-0.031414628
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13007v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13007v1
|
News Recommendation with Category Description by a Large Language Model
| 2024-05-13T08:53:43 | 2024-05-13T08:53:43 |
Yuki Yada, Hayato Yamana
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Personalized news recommendations are essential for online news platforms to
assist users in discovering news articles that match their interests from a
vast amount of online content. Appropriately encoded content features, such as
text, categories, and images, are essential for recommendations. Among these
features, news categories, such as tv-golden-globe, finance-real-estate, and
news-politics, play an important role in understanding news content, inspiring
us to enhance the categories' descriptions. In this paper, we propose a novel
method that automatically generates informative category descriptions using a
large language model (LLM) without manual effort or domain-specific knowledge
and incorporates them into recommendation models as additional information. In
our comprehensive experimental evaluations using the MIND dataset, our method
successfully achieved 5.8% improvement at most in AUC compared with baseline
approaches without the LLM's generated category descriptions for the
state-of-the-art content-based recommendation models including NAML, NRMS, and
NPA. These results validate the effectiveness of our approach. The code is
available at https://github.com/yamanalab/gpt-augmented-news-recommendation.
|
News Recommendation with Category Description by a Large Language Model: Personalized news recommendations are essential for online news platforms to
assist users in discovering news articles that match their interests from a
vast amount of online content. Appropriately encoded content features, such as
text, categories, and images, are essential for recommendations. Among these
features, news categories, such as tv-golden-globe, finance-real-estate, and
news-politics, play an important role in understanding news content, inspiring
us to enhance the categories' descriptions. In this paper, we propose a novel
method that automatically generates informative category descriptions using a
large language model (LLM) without manual effort or domain-specific knowledge
and incorporates them into recommendation models as additional information. In
our comprehensive experimental evaluations using the MIND dataset, our method
successfully achieved 5.8% improvement at most in AUC compared with baseline
approaches without the LLM's generated category descriptions for the
state-of-the-art content-based recommendation models including NAML, NRMS, and
NPA. These results validate the effectiveness of our approach. The code is
available at https://github.com/yamanalab/gpt-augmented-news-recommendation.
|
[
0.0583325326,
0.0433664061,
0.008113537,
-0.0006913339,
0.0172882862,
0.0278548524,
-0.0082438653,
0.0019069085,
0.0363648273,
-0.0550904348,
-0.0314090885,
-0.0116236676,
-0.0137458928,
0.0306558255,
-0.0007418016,
-0.025928257,
0.02176084,
-0.0418062881,
0.0277059339,
0.0016104286,
0.0116430232,
0.0501704738,
0.0481429584,
0.0010490378,
0.0212014709,
-0.0152394027,
-0.0230590105,
-0.0003887932,
-0.013933951,
-0.0346376412,
0.0102434009,
0.0216308255,
0.0136453211,
-0.0190443099,
0.0000018401,
-0.0386671424,
-0.0001299281,
-0.0160127785,
0.0588536486,
-0.0184420664,
0.0646624938,
-0.0058733728,
0.0149543155,
0.0121977869,
-0.0104656797,
-0.0064886999,
0.0304129049,
0.0568967722,
0.0103616435,
0.077447094,
-0.0288335811,
-0.0203519184,
0.0071505536,
-0.0332914256,
0.0595269427,
-0.0447026566,
0.0251285471,
0.0202011168,
0.0197631903,
0.0397620052,
-0.0008161836,
-0.0263343398,
0.0123100961,
-0.0422130004,
0.0207829345,
0.0397790596,
-0.013392223,
-0.0096281255,
0.0001265306,
0.0733450875,
-0.0280506443,
-0.0102223447,
-0.0020354588,
0.0251078699,
0.0118769864,
0.0280110557,
-0.0541826747,
0.0340970606,
-0.0039815698,
0.0214201622,
0.0339706168,
-0.0128317429,
0.0329078957,
0.0387241617,
0.0319284387,
0.0828300342,
0.0445615761,
-0.0125201941,
0.0059885858,
0.0102050398,
-0.0015895368,
-0.0712388754,
0.0040083099,
0.0180253703,
-0.0232753977,
0.0007678673,
-0.0216657147,
0.049227871,
0.0153148025,
-0.0704197288,
0.0085315062,
0.011205174,
-0.0111170392,
0.0720491335,
-0.0441794284,
0.0158409998,
-0.0215973277,
-0.0147894435,
-0.0477654152,
-0.0291999187,
-0.0499698892,
-0.0003033971,
0.0118888645,
0.0620636642,
-0.0055792788,
-0.0382060483,
-0.0506225787,
0.0703881755,
0.0249201059,
0.0408693366,
0.0215831455,
0.0128423786,
-0.0188987255,
-0.0280857589,
-0.0432941504,
-0.0035951766,
-0.0448694415,
0.0068273293,
0.0042265668,
0.0343892798,
0.0242700502,
0.0333794877,
-0.0049059545,
-0.0354351215,
-0.0020051412,
0.0459855236,
0.0138287041,
-0.034412846,
-0.0538371652,
-0.0226100534,
0.0010333912,
-0.0543366671,
-0.0101745166,
-0.085806191,
0.0053826817,
0.0099061895,
0.034549702,
-0.0277836416,
0.009448451,
0.0051597133,
-0.0286044106,
0.0440487228,
-0.0464681238,
-0.0086064124,
0.0312323272,
0.0233345963,
0.0476263724,
0.0728151873,
-0.0253146533,
0.0906523168,
0.0624947585,
-0.0085868984,
0.0270950384,
-0.0031706528,
-0.0246148519,
0.0194716118,
-0.0290511455,
0.0049816477,
-0.0247441754,
0.0204766709,
0.052133929,
0.0233782846,
-0.035484653,
0.005686264,
0.0908815935,
-0.0047539114,
0.0452433825,
0.0945212245,
0.034987729,
0.025179131,
0.0004562721,
-0.0308705289,
0.0133786239,
0.0745861828,
-0.0736839101,
0.0135723362,
0.0460787266,
0.0603328347,
-0.072837308,
0.0043445509,
0.0173518714,
-0.067426458,
0.0311668534,
0.0255888924,
0.0301967412,
-0.0096657006,
0.0020950062,
0.0216208026,
0.0732313991,
-0.0106762201,
0.0391945727,
-0.0410915501,
0.0862134546,
0.0701860934,
0.0459724329,
0.0045391982,
-0.0043612053,
-0.0246547926,
0.0086417766,
0.013315591,
0.051221177,
-0.0302826781,
-0.0276009366,
-0.0315449499,
-0.0320381485,
-0.0117785716,
0.0120691676,
0.0156208565,
0.0340137556,
0.0624280907,
0.0434094146,
-0.0269443337,
-0.029232163,
-0.0092451684,
-0.0236632656,
-0.0284768231,
0.0551742949,
-0.0227231402,
-0.0029481403,
0.027225785,
0.0314404443,
-0.0189561006,
0.0121229831,
0.0005863688,
-0.0521184281,
-0.0240804236,
-0.0179828834,
0.0025676605,
0.0451471694,
-0.0233718976,
0.0246170815,
0.0535257123,
-0.0045606759,
-0.0296968948,
-0.0017252573,
-0.0010569873,
0.0140762283,
-0.0441141278,
0.0311978497,
-0.0061115408,
0.0019868666,
-0.0104102856,
0.0841033012,
0.033330515,
0.0191854201,
-0.002071267,
-0.0286694728,
-0.0208683033,
-0.0042667515,
-0.0411901288,
0.046946872,
0.0361353047,
0.012065677,
0.0406856351,
0.0059583071,
-0.0305895619,
-0.0148750236,
-0.0778001472,
0.0075627384,
0.0198811553,
-0.0156732704,
0.0221717209,
0.0253560822,
-0.0130048217,
0.0204280056,
-0.0767886192,
-0.0166395698,
-0.0307657178,
0.0133725004,
-0.0101717934,
0.00421718,
-0.0297458824,
0.0103724208,
-0.0050482494,
-0.0127708167,
0.0569556095,
0.0070582214,
-0.0020842636,
-0.0719652399,
-0.012260356,
-0.0172543358,
-0.040983934,
0.0078461431,
0.0113344165,
-0.0559481978,
-0.0114143966,
-0.0247732345,
0.0252747592,
0.0234684274,
0.0131125543,
0.0606011488,
0.014452762,
-0.0206224285,
-0.0056675705,
-0.0465660058,
-0.0014338621,
-0.029778216,
-0.023028655,
0.0021408303,
0.0362934731,
-0.0320384502,
0.0112771522,
-0.048117131,
0.0123718698,
-0.005143716,
0.0541064404,
-0.0673425049,
-0.0246088766,
0.0077898824,
0.0428421088,
0.0009592106,
-0.0078180032,
0.0758686066,
-0.009448898,
0.0122920144,
-0.0484617986,
-0.0409420468,
-0.0875843465,
0.0050829877,
-0.0218575075,
0.0500024706,
-0.038697686,
-0.0384595469,
0.0011159251,
-0.0064823255,
0.0061021061,
-0.0229671299,
0.0486087166,
-0.0038338723,
-0.013620723,
0.012304402,
-0.0295345634,
-0.0033731507,
-0.0574025325,
-0.0002887851,
0.0224366281,
-0.0058346055,
-0.0308795422,
-0.0327553302,
0.0074839271,
0.0102423923,
0.0227243211,
-0.0595208555,
-0.0406013019,
0.0162321534,
0.0425879806,
0.1022970304,
-0.0666073337,
-0.0256259739,
0.0104633495,
0.0281137563,
0.0248460919,
-0.0350728706,
0.0379998796,
-0.0452233627,
0.0135549707,
0.0569005236,
-0.0452544317,
-0.0140888803,
0.0254971627,
-0.0053322911,
0.0355879143,
0.0106573971,
0.122235857,
0.0391638502,
-0.1383606642,
-0.0193865467,
0.0075810147,
0.0120449327,
0.0396117195,
0.0489063859,
-0.0727313682,
0.0086385347,
0.0004467592,
0.0296726003,
0.0431865938,
0.0029762108,
-0.0182024427,
-0.0863064304,
0.0264340919,
0.0318259411,
0.001677315,
-0.0271905512,
-0.069282636,
-0.0075264587,
-0.0247030742,
-0.0119644441,
0.0012948873,
-0.013073951,
-0.0199843012,
-0.0008187246,
-0.0172254872,
-0.0596314557,
0.0168898031,
-0.0055324826,
0.041601792,
0.0474989451,
0.035749685,
-0.0165136438,
0.0055859112,
0.018741712,
0.0092801107,
-0.0453355163,
0.0018803028,
0.0078091347,
-0.0480675176,
0.0199875534,
-0.0199273862,
0.0105784591,
-0.01157883,
-0.0212017372,
0.0213247463,
0.0594543628,
-0.0039232019,
-0.0162034649,
-0.021888623,
-0.0256416965,
0.0281626061,
0.0723429099,
0.0051702838,
-0.0594212227,
0.0467949882,
-0.051619269,
-0.055122301,
0.0300458875,
-0.0347330011,
0.0113273868,
-0.0229729824,
-0.0518960878,
-0.0560180061,
-0.0372280777,
0.0312025119,
-0.0214980301,
0.0292678401,
0.0322542712,
-0.0168014895,
-0.0367349312,
-0.0206230618,
0.0321419761,
-0.0285356101,
-0.0101250848,
-0.047967542,
-0.0232746322,
0.0411440693,
-0.0954823345,
-0.0050376272,
-0.0094361715,
-0.0414019637,
-0.0252800286,
-0.0489239469,
0.0025492425,
0.0180089176,
0.0480285883,
-0.0470933616,
-0.0738418102,
0.0523518324,
0.020861499,
-0.0383085608,
-0.0234329421,
-0.0655315518,
0.0413582213,
0.0142294727,
0.029174624,
-0.0625490695,
0.0134919984,
-0.0430842154,
0.0084519181,
0.0082311844,
-0.0295969378,
0.0406643078,
0.0064664735,
-0.0078663202,
-0.0222544894,
0.0475801304,
-0.0311892554,
-0.0079343915,
-0.0225956328,
-0.049500078,
-0.0135121373,
-0.0055183563,
0.0861580819,
-0.0296064373,
-0.0127090495,
0.0142827062,
-0.0198003314,
0.0278795362,
-0.0213440191,
-0.0189027563,
-0.0355909504,
-0.0008598317,
0.0163668003,
0.0149011053,
-0.0249030311,
-0.0202079304,
0.0071514375,
0.0136117563,
-0.0505036041,
0.0416540988,
-0.0038693238,
-0.0227968283,
-0.0158138052,
0.0435472727,
-0.0066572037,
-0.0453489125,
-0.0419703014,
0.040708039,
0.0397027805,
-0.0649590641,
0.0191331785,
-0.0522178151,
-0.0297193676,
-0.0267400909,
0.0049575833,
-0.0193139557,
-0.0494813845,
0.0337146521,
0.0404943749,
-0.0182213131,
0.0018481826,
0.0954395086,
0.019039413,
-0.01713177,
0.012502416,
-0.0599193908,
-0.025238879,
0.0214901883,
0.0304519068,
0.0335409157,
-0.0725560337,
0.0111338366,
0.0025852742,
-0.0295418818,
-0.0002899867,
-0.0731519908,
0.0259351172,
0.0070239385,
0.0442809239,
0.0809850693,
-0.0034151874,
0.0124393804,
-0.0914360806,
-0.0412500575,
-0.0479611158,
-0.0373578481,
-0.0272192843,
-6.490495731e-33,
-0.0109047564,
-0.0233694743,
0.0095631778,
-0.0071873367,
0.0051227254,
-0.000633559,
-0.0022807796,
0.012361832,
0.0418801233,
-0.005495884,
0.0203286652,
0.0112841884,
0.0012042928,
0.0225344244,
0.0084419223,
-0.0149783678,
0.0214600526,
0.0406844355,
-0.0220780056,
0.067456089,
-0.0251947679,
0.0307741594,
0.0193643309,
-0.0728784204,
0.0280508045,
0.0087750806,
-0.0234675724,
-0.0450685509,
0.0615789704,
0.0952433199,
-0.0086168433,
0.0467876606,
0.0273014233,
-0.0152770197,
0.0228732545,
0.0162884127,
-0.0591310002,
0.0097763734,
0.0509909801,
-0.0050626597,
-0.0139600709,
-0.0469992347,
-0.028250603,
-0.0049391501,
0.0119178034,
-0.0123951212,
0.0327752158,
-0.0396135487,
-0.0381867141,
-0.0489549823,
-0.0318583734,
0.0162211526,
-0.0092928363,
0.0069631594,
0.0185378529,
-0.0046194382,
-0.0177130066,
0.0768560469,
-0.0169613212,
0.0579976737,
-0.0033681656,
0.0687685907,
0.0098828385,
-0.0326037034,
-0.037019603,
0.0377481468,
-0.0150979673,
-0.0109404856,
-0.0051067248,
0.0448596738,
-0.0224952698,
0.0070701772,
-0.0009149861,
0.0280297846,
-0.0006664769,
-0.0320197009,
-0.0279443618,
0.0595406927,
-0.0066558449,
-0.0010755125,
0.0412743464,
0.0055891774,
-0.0132377567,
-0.0229952708,
-0.0023405633,
0.0097721657,
-0.0795897767,
-0.0633414686,
0.0139304828,
0.0416068584,
-0.0144530274,
0.0037917723,
-0.0122109847,
-0.0482844152,
-0.0262488481,
0.032014776,
-0.0529630147,
0.0252786856,
0.0086116362,
0.0144129312,
-0.0340562314,
-0.0400626585,
-0.0120431473,
-0.0598842576,
-0.0397137105,
0.0085308366,
0.0471007638,
0.0431323126,
-0.0511533618,
0.0184937194,
0.0147886826,
-0.0403404869,
0.0023282103,
0.0049625356,
-0.0057289475,
0.0165992342,
-0.0184214469,
0.0656309649,
0.0417108983,
0.0283772107,
0.0088602332,
-0.0669246987,
0.0121640731,
0.0507255606,
-0.018750241,
-0.007156773,
-0.0217837337,
-0.0278324336,
0.0489552543,
-0.0530741476,
-0.0339557901,
-0.0210698079,
2.674e-7,
0.0001502874,
0.0530216508,
-0.0561984405,
0.0203572791,
0.0264339894,
-0.0077686147,
0.0136610148,
0.0430215709,
0.0335298479,
0.0127420928,
0.0151247513,
0.0093075661,
0.0243251491,
0.019315457,
-0.1135644317,
0.0472402833,
-0.0371951237,
-0.001653865,
-0.1037725732,
0.006799832,
0.0291397367,
0.0878140032,
0.0256246459,
-0.0070705893,
0.0022088422,
-0.0459186174,
0.0595151335,
-0.0265779141,
-0.0608865768,
0.0068364688,
0.059247952,
0.0545532033,
-0.0350676365,
-0.0197881628,
-0.0002599759,
-0.0056304303,
0.0133309374,
0.0392153673,
-0.0045904433,
-0.0096519785,
0.0225084573,
0.0007523554,
0.0195256826,
-0.0602699891,
0.0937984064,
0.0014354753,
-0.0091186967,
-0.0554790981,
-0.0463001318,
0.0017314943,
0.0301790964,
-0.0777319148,
-0.0142972935,
-0.0003828332,
0.0231863428,
0.0152098536,
0.003271421,
-0.0421086513,
-0.0016091577,
0.0159915462,
-0.0197325964,
-0.0186732393,
-0.0460762568,
0.021149464,
0.0128444741,
-0.0831228197,
0.0530052111,
2.303843343e-34,
0.0306758434,
0.0665534511,
-0.0269640908,
0.0080993325,
0.0288277417,
-0.0214084722,
-0.0489556454,
0.0334384441,
0.0050088577,
-0.0611660369,
-0.0082062371
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07551v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07551v1
|
MuMath-Code: Combining Tool-Use Large Language Models with Multi-perspective Data Augmentation for Mathematical Reasoning
| 2024-05-13T08:32:19 | 2024-05-13T08:32:19 |
Shuo Yin, Weihao You, Zhilong Ji, Guoqiang Zhong, Jinfeng Bai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The tool-use Large Language Models (LLMs) that integrate with external Python
interpreters have significantly enhanced mathematical reasoning capabilities
for open-source LLMs, while tool-free methods chose another track: augmenting
math reasoning data. However, a great method to integrate the above two
research paths and combine their advantages remains to be explored. In this
work, we firstly include new math questions via multi-perspective data
augmenting methods and then synthesize code-nested solutions to them. The open
LLMs (i.e., Llama-2) are finetuned on the augmented dataset to get the
resulting models, MuMath-Code ($\mu$-Math-Code). During the inference phase,
our MuMath-Code generates code and interacts with the external python
interpreter to get the execution results. Therefore, MuMath-Code leverages the
advantages of both the external tool and data augmentation. To fully leverage
the advantages of our augmented data, we propose a two-stage training strategy:
In Stage-1, we finetune Llama-2 on pure CoT data to get an intermediate model,
which then is trained on the code-nested data in Stage-2 to get the resulting
MuMath-Code. Our MuMath-Code-7B achieves 83.8 on GSM8K and 52.4 on MATH, while
MuMath-Code-70B model achieves new state-of-the-art performance among open
methods -- achieving 90.7% on GSM8K and 55.1% on MATH. Extensive experiments
validate the combination of tool use and data augmentation, as well as our
two-stage training strategy. We release the proposed dataset along with the
associated code for public use.
|
MuMath-Code: Combining Tool-Use Large Language Models with Multi-perspective Data Augmentation for Mathematical Reasoning: The tool-use Large Language Models (LLMs) that integrate with external Python
interpreters have significantly enhanced mathematical reasoning capabilities
for open-source LLMs, while tool-free methods chose another track: augmenting
math reasoning data. However, a great method to integrate the above two
research paths and combine their advantages remains to be explored. In this
work, we firstly include new math questions via multi-perspective data
augmenting methods and then synthesize code-nested solutions to them. The open
LLMs (i.e., Llama-2) are finetuned on the augmented dataset to get the
resulting models, MuMath-Code ($\mu$-Math-Code). During the inference phase,
our MuMath-Code generates code and interacts with the external python
interpreter to get the execution results. Therefore, MuMath-Code leverages the
advantages of both the external tool and data augmentation. To fully leverage
the advantages of our augmented data, we propose a two-stage training strategy:
In Stage-1, we finetune Llama-2 on pure CoT data to get an intermediate model,
which then is trained on the code-nested data in Stage-2 to get the resulting
MuMath-Code. Our MuMath-Code-7B achieves 83.8 on GSM8K and 52.4 on MATH, while
MuMath-Code-70B model achieves new state-of-the-art performance among open
methods -- achieving 90.7% on GSM8K and 55.1% on MATH. Extensive experiments
validate the combination of tool use and data augmentation, as well as our
two-stage training strategy. We release the proposed dataset along with the
associated code for public use.
|
[
-0.0304730013,
0.1226753592,
-0.0042564119,
0.0866260082,
-0.0124363611,
0.0486895964,
0.0058233091,
-0.0002408606,
-0.0234727301,
-0.0406037197,
-0.0331036672,
0.0254390743,
-0.0159449391,
0.0190485008,
0.049329143,
-0.0284719355,
-0.005593793,
-0.0718105733,
-0.0210837591,
-0.0096942019,
-0.039488174,
0.0108757205,
-0.0200725384,
-0.0058191614,
-0.0127712283,
-0.0602419041,
0.0052709044,
-0.0255394671,
0.019010976,
-0.035930071,
-0.0223697908,
0.0347485878,
0.051193025,
0.0590656251,
0.0000023338,
-0.0558062345,
-0.0085398387,
0.0103996368,
-0.0498760231,
0.0038346935,
0.0044221357,
-0.0369131453,
0.0408789441,
-0.0164283514,
-0.0771671012,
-0.0010836917,
0.0165457688,
0.0037428546,
0.0975548998,
0.0531233884,
0.0083667338,
-0.0714101642,
0.0509617738,
-0.0076572131,
0.042858839,
-0.0512210466,
0.0231270213,
0.0457217917,
0.0133106746,
0.0315245464,
-0.0208349209,
0.0370238237,
0.0688474551,
-0.0129589485,
-0.0071206265,
0.0369193405,
-0.0192061365,
0.0342380889,
-0.0005340914,
0.0605517589,
-0.0044156569,
-0.0556196906,
-0.029277388,
-0.0233861823,
-0.01205453,
-0.0180701856,
-0.0831903219,
0.0449719988,
0.0059497436,
0.0194138531,
0.0153212985,
-0.0096346512,
0.0309993643,
0.0214353558,
-0.0683095455,
0.0811763182,
0.0148489987,
-0.03143619,
-0.0053612688,
0.0033068073,
-0.0578801706,
-0.0393400602,
0.00030519,
0.0739970282,
0.0393411964,
0.0143141756,
-0.0011964163,
-0.0722704008,
-0.0265465938,
-0.0209981501,
0.0392346457,
0.0884086788,
-0.0159711484,
0.0303464904,
-0.0398472287,
0.0227684211,
-0.0253856741,
0.0068753194,
-0.0454868227,
0.0093317637,
-0.033876393,
-0.0077946978,
-0.0069780494,
0.0314865038,
0.0088447826,
0.034739323,
-0.0205419175,
0.0440487899,
-0.0295163095,
0.028099725,
0.0097270887,
-0.0081943013,
0.0052298382,
-0.0273226481,
-0.0176737756,
0.0050525758,
-0.049403239,
0.0151619595,
0.0069090012,
-0.0553279743,
-0.0373397022,
0.0389860608,
-0.018579945,
-0.0437692516,
0.0206096396,
0.0591621809,
0.0233639292,
-0.0152155226,
-0.0204022974,
-0.0267032422,
0.0400352105,
-0.0654538795,
0.0117841652,
-0.1132808551,
0.0437043607,
0.0154591259,
-0.0205471497,
-0.0473348238,
0.0134069482,
0.0168359652,
0.0064731319,
0.0742026195,
-0.0055924654,
-0.0188781098,
0.0094649941,
0.007419283,
-0.0217975862,
0.0647037104,
0.0229120087,
-0.0339148752,
0.0149581861,
-0.0173654258,
-0.0124293054,
0.0246381629,
0.0269210916,
0.0120388521,
-0.0176225752,
0.0603018925,
0.0266567469,
0.0444092005,
-0.0126791894,
-0.0082748458,
-0.0434013307,
-0.0166360531,
-0.0012605352,
0.0221990813,
-0.0078477571,
-0.0025857266,
0.0467840396,
-0.0368984193,
0.0411360115,
-0.0174558926,
-0.0532011949,
0.0271528009,
-0.0351341255,
0.0067746318,
0.0172190163,
0.0246684588,
-0.0233851224,
-0.0828569606,
-0.001809636,
-0.0110785654,
-0.0320286639,
0.0328903869,
0.0803449899,
-0.0122385845,
0.0253001973,
0.058562018,
0.021300979,
-0.0405502059,
-0.0197049659,
-0.0472766347,
0.0313434973,
-0.0298351888,
0.0418813378,
-0.0653792769,
-0.0779158771,
-0.0191023108,
-0.0052889516,
0.0144698843,
0.0046946607,
-0.0137731507,
-0.0276570842,
-0.0659513697,
-0.0080075813,
-0.0517915562,
0.0075749722,
-0.0124162463,
0.0417516306,
-0.0136633087,
0.0407174639,
-0.0245723799,
0.0325541012,
0.0308368877,
-0.0700506046,
-0.0323935077,
-0.0156843979,
-0.025402572,
0.0110225752,
-0.008111042,
0.0264341626,
0.0380193442,
0.0411027074,
-0.0308018792,
0.0093845399,
-0.0311691854,
-0.0466916673,
-0.0627464503,
0.0732571483,
-0.0128282374,
-0.0345494188,
0.0161533095,
-0.0525928028,
-0.0122908056,
0.029353328,
0.0096851792,
0.0235038549,
-0.0345691629,
0.0119268838,
0.0056858142,
0.0016070033,
-0.0058684228,
0.0807071701,
-0.0092733176,
0.0084770694,
0.0268229209,
-0.0139231486,
0.0341401435,
0.0243055448,
0.0200478397,
0.0051214336,
-0.0154290413,
0.0181583073,
-0.0570399314,
0.0127282813,
-0.0492330678,
-0.0203382932,
-0.0615048073,
0.0243981779,
-0.0016582101,
0.0358989947,
0.0175524838,
-0.0178109203,
-0.0044013578,
-0.0022351979,
-0.0315260515,
-0.0130068641,
-0.0043712743,
-0.0011205904,
0.0228968672,
-0.001630491,
0.0114476755,
0.0085757207,
-0.0205333363,
-0.055846367,
0.0668615699,
-0.0012999533,
0.0337833278,
-0.026765408,
0.0020479471,
-0.0614688359,
-0.0006382471,
-0.0260059889,
0.0418328531,
0.0272558909,
-0.0487302728,
0.0129924081,
0.0581989214,
-0.0408203863,
0.0026947164,
0.0249495283,
-0.00399706,
-0.0360246301,
0.0198711734,
0.0024853307,
-0.0103486087,
-0.012934953,
0.014860576,
-0.0291138552,
0.0505792499,
-0.0535499491,
-0.0419247113,
-0.0147129288,
0.0530285239,
-0.0073660421,
-0.0116945021,
-0.0160073042,
0.0155420415,
-0.0114926212,
0.0707799941,
0.0139743378,
-0.049834244,
0.0579748861,
-0.0178606771,
-0.029382525,
-0.0525531508,
0.0088608228,
-0.1010365784,
0.031205371,
0.0039773472,
-0.0182572994,
-0.0196164604,
0.0011859341,
-0.0291991383,
-0.0138283717,
0.0142451264,
-0.0246971492,
0.0715927407,
-0.028354615,
-0.0034684176,
-0.0206393395,
-0.0367422625,
-0.0359315574,
0.0267923418,
-0.0429706126,
0.0338044241,
-0.0363536477,
-0.0356276706,
0.0193842072,
-0.0380834974,
0.0110937906,
0.0059617464,
-0.0237049647,
-0.0203562006,
-0.0270294398,
-0.0067601614,
0.0166011173,
0.0353893004,
0.0486661419,
-0.0527547486,
0.0027253064,
0.0271223579,
0.0241920818,
-0.0064216219,
-0.0287387874,
0.0292901527,
0.0107020903,
0.0023525797,
-0.0108006829,
0.0090760216,
0.0127336346,
-0.0773731247,
0.0051793088,
0.0893679559,
0.040583849,
-0.0262986887,
-0.0028149995,
-0.0780341625,
0.0177972671,
0.0477015413,
0.0235471055,
-0.0852836818,
-0.0253760479,
0.0034589546,
0.0093969749,
0.028106885,
-0.0302101374,
-0.0073691476,
-0.1258937418,
0.0303912181,
0.0135371657,
-0.0156068178,
-0.0115213627,
-0.0153192291,
0.0168571584,
0.020645868,
-0.0337332264,
0.0376594029,
0.0031146202,
0.0266520102,
-0.0002685339,
0.0178106166,
-0.023014335,
0.0201077759,
-0.0003839268,
-0.0227266699,
-0.0167537387,
0.0089521715,
-0.019755004,
-0.0681147799,
0.059336137,
0.015932899,
-0.0317896008,
-0.0227350034,
0.0117825046,
0.0059525114,
-0.0128062544,
0.0040982631,
0.0856346413,
-0.0649703369,
-0.0188123994,
0.0198701341,
0.1303078383,
-0.0055115446,
0.0035073848,
-0.0102484506,
-0.0060799699,
-0.0502455831,
0.0366073549,
0.0192082897,
-0.0128077473,
-0.0067491299,
-0.0419913903,
-0.0567988753,
-0.0143262483,
-0.0022856314,
0.0050066542,
0.0465828516,
-0.0110819992,
-0.0334544964,
-0.015516635,
0.0534102656,
0.0420772098,
0.0078831902,
0.0061591286,
0.0007910372,
-0.0321288146,
-0.0437203273,
0.0383329801,
-0.05563372,
0.0364431776,
-0.0117902039,
0.0253153741,
-0.0085786218,
-0.0412554257,
-0.0340867676,
0.0215198603,
-0.1273899227,
-0.0474608392,
-0.0458636992,
0.0276634637,
0.0230124537,
0.0389405563,
-0.0159324948,
0.0041129049,
0.0126015283,
0.022259688,
-0.0427429453,
0.0266117081,
0.047182072,
0.0126447724,
0.0135500357,
0.0196750313,
-0.0016609037,
-0.020079378,
0.015873082,
0.0301800035,
-0.008576422,
-0.0039716377,
0.0273669418,
0.0381948948,
0.0029827952,
0.0360354297,
-0.0123802479,
-0.0195611399,
0.0550672449,
-0.023389928,
-0.0300975796,
-0.0331788622,
0.0229563192,
0.0114173321,
-0.0341617204,
0.0207153596,
-0.0358303227,
0.030741496,
0.0433557816,
0.0117003415,
0.0721259043,
0.0101755327,
0.0336240977,
0.0510155261,
-0.0222956929,
-0.0028970491,
-0.0184486099,
-0.0209745206,
0.0515628271,
-0.0368667394,
0.0568385795,
0.0206609517,
0.0126594566,
-0.0298989527,
-0.0060287588,
-0.049430076,
-0.075695172,
-0.0099706482,
0.021844266,
0.0291480068,
0.0157140661,
-0.0157624651,
-0.0292423256,
-0.0057625184,
0.0084190443,
0.0427232236,
0.0230384804,
-0.0187160764,
0.0433143526,
0.0198332965,
0.0126437908,
-0.0407613479,
0.0452219024,
-0.0461457968,
0.0333809033,
0.0185000952,
0.0379256941,
-0.0324565917,
-0.0290275943,
0.0310076382,
0.0303509273,
-0.0015057608,
0.021334365,
-0.0363780484,
-0.100649856,
-0.0174957514,
0.016271254,
-0.0467141308,
0.0141527168,
0.034782771,
0.065921694,
-0.0018734384,
-0.0156107983,
0.0074384706,
0.0652403384,
-0.0148842959,
-0.0544577353,
-0.0016041106,
-6.165481094e-33,
-0.0049647796,
-0.0000126304,
0.0463889353,
0.0320079625,
-0.0151512139,
-0.0191876739,
-0.0298333168,
0.009139345,
-0.0326968469,
-0.0174971484,
0.0174380019,
0.0321570598,
-0.0085400771,
0.0149598373,
0.0001525408,
-0.0162816904,
-0.0272098742,
-0.0028407958,
-0.0186598487,
0.0021179172,
0.0166258626,
0.0024617794,
0.0791531354,
-0.0576494411,
0.0288045518,
-0.0244910195,
0.0170809235,
0.037411049,
-0.0768535659,
0.0713908449,
-0.0305653345,
0.0227144621,
0.0263909791,
-0.0175736118,
-0.0106528038,
-0.0205028523,
-0.0448469818,
-0.0457506068,
0.0096657239,
0.0133073721,
-0.0739137083,
-0.0481894389,
0.0337260701,
0.013274353,
0.0106793744,
-0.0472430103,
0.0184579287,
-0.0417034142,
0.002418757,
0.0232538953,
-0.0416093767,
0.0430855229,
-0.0241675172,
-0.0034084299,
0.0250768587,
0.0264342222,
0.0131697049,
0.0408346467,
-0.0067388536,
-0.0009539788,
0.0461960249,
0.0124231102,
0.0554121472,
-0.0177754164,
0.010925211,
-0.0023500065,
-0.0129256109,
-0.0537088849,
-0.040355105,
0.0075154426,
0.0236406494,
0.0717194602,
0.0670175999,
-0.0124645792,
0.0325223431,
0.0293408316,
-0.0558520593,
0.0002017458,
0.0235174093,
0.0490821712,
0.0191305634,
0.0060532894,
-0.017195357,
-0.0008473028,
-0.0531660765,
0.0014269096,
-0.0551285818,
-0.0148160774,
0.0123693151,
-0.0090567749,
-0.0266091991,
0.0494270846,
0.0232846774,
-0.0477976948,
-0.0189494006,
0.0292472709,
0.0046399632,
0.0266683269,
0.0154404044,
0.0539259091,
-0.0133393174,
0.0019078791,
0.0154044181,
-0.0237682555,
0.0593257584,
0.0063300002,
0.0473744012,
0.0110654896,
-0.0453092791,
-0.0228665117,
-0.0694451928,
-0.0269028265,
0.0271918103,
0.0554653741,
0.0279252753,
0.0467481725,
-0.0024596013,
0.0414837599,
0.0080874115,
-0.0066138566,
-0.0605326667,
0.0300384592,
-0.0052865688,
0.0114500783,
-0.0255099647,
-0.0119536184,
-0.0256286655,
-0.0104792165,
0.047216367,
-0.0577461906,
-0.0123687061,
0.0457201749,
2.889e-7,
0.0872667283,
0.0400014967,
-0.0021685997,
0.044009652,
0.0285884738,
0.0323319957,
-0.0644507408,
-0.0124579072,
0.0149857234,
-0.0332546756,
-0.0120859221,
0.0515438244,
0.0301912352,
0.058628384,
-0.044482585,
0.0247283503,
-0.01043294,
-0.0122145973,
-0.0637353659,
0.0062054978,
0.1036685333,
0.113016963,
0.025985444,
-0.0176717062,
0.0193808228,
-0.030222265,
0.0543531068,
-0.0045116628,
0.0045872265,
0.0146337086,
-0.0438433588,
0.0174937379,
0.0178809687,
0.0114565259,
0.0099515393,
0.0311093405,
0.0004752292,
0.0583358333,
0.0168962423,
0.0430811048,
-0.000673285,
-0.0351283364,
0.0136714391,
-0.0964279324,
0.0848463178,
-0.025170669,
-0.0506892949,
-0.019678317,
-0.0097510116,
-0.0104266154,
0.0097499089,
-0.0055408617,
0.0255988762,
-0.0033242085,
0.0164176542,
-0.0119083729,
-0.0184532534,
-0.0667267591,
-0.0526251383,
-0.0042732363,
-0.0543775335,
-0.0403630845,
-0.0385035127,
-0.010374208,
0.0403227434,
-0.04041861,
0.0012697374,
3.281616789e-34,
0.0512925982,
-0.0314633623,
0.0151177272,
0.048389595,
0.0462083519,
-0.0285210591,
-0.0210173838,
0.0169120617,
0.0208708551,
-0.0977700353,
-0.0096880235
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07542v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07542v1
|
EMS-SD: Efficient Multi-sample Speculative Decoding for Accelerating Large Language Models
| 2024-05-13T08:24:21 | 2024-05-13T08:24:21 |
Yunsheng Ni, Chuanjian Liu, Yehui Tang, Kai Han, Yunhe Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Speculative decoding emerges as a pivotal technique for enhancing the
inference speed of Large Language Models (LLMs). Despite recent research aiming
to improve prediction efficiency, multi-sample speculative decoding has been
overlooked due to varying numbers of accepted tokens within a batch in the
verification phase. Vanilla method adds padding tokens in order to ensure that
the number of new tokens remains consistent across samples. However, this
increases the computational and memory access overhead, thereby reducing the
speedup ratio. We propose a novel method that can resolve the issue of
inconsistent tokens accepted by different samples without necessitating an
increase in memory or computing overhead. Furthermore, our proposed method can
handle the situation where the prediction tokens of different samples are
inconsistent without the need to add padding tokens. Sufficient experiments
demonstrate the efficacy of our method. Our code is available at
https://github.com/niyunsheng/EMS-SD.
|
EMS-SD: Efficient Multi-sample Speculative Decoding for Accelerating Large Language Models: Speculative decoding emerges as a pivotal technique for enhancing the
inference speed of Large Language Models (LLMs). Despite recent research aiming
to improve prediction efficiency, multi-sample speculative decoding has been
overlooked due to varying numbers of accepted tokens within a batch in the
verification phase. Vanilla method adds padding tokens in order to ensure that
the number of new tokens remains consistent across samples. However, this
increases the computational and memory access overhead, thereby reducing the
speedup ratio. We propose a novel method that can resolve the issue of
inconsistent tokens accepted by different samples without necessitating an
increase in memory or computing overhead. Furthermore, our proposed method can
handle the situation where the prediction tokens of different samples are
inconsistent without the need to add padding tokens. Sufficient experiments
demonstrate the efficacy of our method. Our code is available at
https://github.com/niyunsheng/EMS-SD.
|
[
0.0216590874,
0.0843594149,
0.011944538,
0.0226963535,
-0.0054619168,
0.0030748842,
-0.0197203811,
0.0199769102,
-0.0577408671,
0.0073460555,
0.0147344535,
-0.0965046212,
0.0199847929,
0.004422978,
-0.0015392582,
0.0115838721,
0.0374660939,
-0.0389808156,
0.0436724089,
-0.0232716613,
-0.0295613073,
0.0296406522,
0.0118049318,
0.0378237329,
0.012461476,
-0.0099465121,
-0.028165685,
0.0037570591,
-0.0172104705,
-0.042610161,
0.012117886,
0.0559105054,
0.0121781472,
0.0589661077,
0.0000019969,
-0.0016530372,
-0.0236823764,
0.0071085263,
-0.0403047316,
0.0749415383,
0.0451298654,
-0.0402026027,
-0.0321252309,
0.0191253927,
0.0171506535,
-0.0518329889,
0.061437279,
-0.017163761,
-0.0072469953,
0.0485355891,
0.0011074647,
0.0058042184,
0.0010334817,
0.013713181,
-0.0299967173,
-0.0498352051,
0.0390128717,
-0.0418993682,
-0.029734211,
-0.0080086095,
-0.0336809754,
0.016466137,
0.0014549391,
0.0161410011,
-0.0427958481,
0.0065931086,
-0.0179484002,
-0.0221923366,
-0.021788884,
0.009363384,
-0.0181274172,
-0.068879433,
-0.0200471673,
0.0086954031,
-0.0507440493,
-0.0206734668,
-0.0350007936,
0.0264323112,
-0.049644243,
0.0416630544,
0.0684742928,
0.0294234324,
0.0462236889,
-0.004472502,
-0.0592734031,
0.092566669,
0.0503566116,
-0.0129886568,
-0.0315816477,
0.0114605157,
-0.0058038891,
-0.0397012569,
0.0189175345,
-0.020116318,
-0.0791857243,
0.0091821123,
-0.0399981178,
-0.0918457136,
0.0143378703,
-0.0121864248,
0.0295239743,
0.0797635093,
0.022883743,
-0.0119705666,
-0.0176224317,
-0.0090126712,
-0.0257667974,
0.0068496964,
-0.0363801345,
-0.0133601557,
0.0352910347,
0.0060773217,
-0.0617662445,
0.0079071419,
-0.0235539041,
-0.0068338728,
-0.0161010996,
0.0173939802,
0.017044168,
0.012173797,
0.0404847786,
-0.0334843695,
-0.0402518697,
0.0133004943,
0.0295862854,
0.0337734371,
-0.0170103684,
-0.0098075829,
-0.0289768148,
-0.0534700379,
-0.0346670374,
0.0017289749,
0.0132021205,
-0.0231774002,
-0.0159777347,
0.045858454,
0.0066855112,
-0.0258563235,
-0.0110737327,
-0.010198731,
0.0155391619,
-0.0409383029,
0.0156138465,
-0.0508504808,
0.0271783825,
0.0253583863,
0.0104999132,
-0.0035955047,
-0.023905091,
0.0108825993,
-0.0041981782,
0.0472989567,
-0.0274988841,
0.010908423,
-0.0018101117,
0.0012061842,
-0.0027391906,
0.1178540885,
-0.0118398247,
0.0307692792,
0.0384741984,
-0.005566203,
-0.0245261099,
0.0817029998,
0.0334274694,
0.0186935272,
-0.0358073004,
-0.0131044723,
0.0320069827,
-0.0075907852,
0.0502618402,
0.0622875802,
-0.043492116,
-0.030484831,
0.0030689111,
0.0650247782,
-0.0397618227,
-0.0055477712,
0.0161067173,
0.0266683605,
0.0263449699,
0.0090799686,
0.0049340501,
-0.0086501027,
0.0111136129,
0.030003855,
0.0692317858,
0.0654282048,
-0.0086711291,
0.026832588,
-0.0350944251,
-0.0186456032,
0.0015289905,
0.0135089522,
0.0734723285,
-0.0375022925,
-0.0606092885,
0.0648422837,
0.0323259979,
-0.0400650054,
-0.0214989465,
-0.025185924,
0.0531311296,
0.0769386813,
0.0458588563,
0.0401660129,
-0.0121568711,
0.0289426278,
-0.0420324579,
0.0143085402,
0.0055744802,
-0.0082207443,
0.0529478677,
-0.0436236039,
-0.0179296117,
0.0693581477,
0.0173074994,
0.0578596666,
0.0647653192,
0.0136683602,
-0.0085360799,
-0.0392617211,
-0.0233607944,
0.0122635858,
0.0097829187,
0.0097936923,
0.009108088,
-0.0003746401,
0.0390730985,
0.006286779,
0.000409872,
0.0035412407,
0.0393982865,
-0.0258784462,
0.0026623823,
-0.0074160066,
-0.0616061278,
-0.0571252853,
0.0360471159,
0.0040441342,
-0.032537479,
0.0187967829,
-0.0231457818,
-0.0398244299,
0.0282922834,
-0.0167001989,
0.0591571704,
-0.0431256928,
0.0433569662,
-0.0336938053,
0.0391457081,
0.0052850749,
0.0071467105,
-0.0331609547,
0.0339318477,
0.0066724923,
0.0054237559,
-0.0049673114,
-0.0199768264,
-0.0098433821,
0.0137583148,
0.000247604,
0.0081136255,
-0.0126271471,
-0.0208238009,
-0.0064750258,
0.005250663,
-0.0933072791,
-0.0083362097,
-0.0325813927,
0.0298278145,
-0.0025421982,
0.0210519619,
-0.0113614779,
-0.0089586014,
-0.0045761047,
-0.0398931056,
-0.0101892119,
0.0021068573,
-0.0456169061,
-0.0126323858,
-0.0547230728,
0.0173739064,
-0.0208356008,
0.0048303036,
0.0555987395,
-0.0484179743,
-0.0525582246,
-0.1033905596,
-0.0083816452,
0.0302356891,
0.0176956132,
0.0157614946,
-0.0328125693,
-0.0041649123,
-0.0502864085,
0.0218030885,
-0.012862158,
-0.0093444968,
-0.0103376498,
0.0187307913,
-0.0006567604,
-0.0458021276,
-0.0190945137,
0.0109919962,
-0.0049789073,
-0.0393700227,
-0.0591506995,
-0.0142530408,
0.0702146143,
0.016675381,
-0.0277073178,
-0.064658992,
-0.0297194831,
0.0032247787,
-0.0288615432,
0.0069446107,
-0.0196256973,
-0.0177742522,
0.043883834,
-0.0099882679,
-0.0537124425,
0.0736849606,
-0.083687827,
-0.0281583834,
-0.0283320844,
0.0039340504,
-0.0202062,
0.0036758273,
-0.0225067269,
0.0292394105,
-0.0079637142,
-0.0406166166,
0.0249256454,
0.0339384861,
-0.0192538016,
-0.0417868569,
0.0270301905,
-0.0071836077,
0.0259205326,
-0.0261713918,
-0.0145725813,
-0.0188940074,
-0.0268423073,
-0.0575000644,
-0.0084718047,
0.056524273,
-0.0596287288,
0.0117998971,
0.0289570466,
-0.0644830689,
0.0403256193,
-0.0007147185,
0.0247057937,
-0.002283402,
-0.0109863514,
0.0240474138,
-0.0327501148,
-0.0050200932,
-0.0530268513,
0.0001805684,
0.0550096035,
0.0626432151,
0.0437309705,
-0.0604743734,
-0.0048422115,
0.072871998,
0.0117680514,
0.0235034171,
0.0473264605,
0.0619991049,
-0.0455097966,
-0.0100545473,
0.1234336197,
0.0290851481,
-0.0398340523,
0.016484268,
0.0076011983,
0.0771209523,
0.0030253786,
0.0202932805,
-0.0762659982,
-0.0299945176,
0.0504589342,
0.0263557807,
-0.0166127458,
0.0006882406,
-0.0319326185,
-0.1095132381,
0.0452994853,
0.0368620642,
-0.0614207834,
-0.0035227782,
-0.0415743999,
-0.03530287,
0.0372941345,
0.0744409934,
0.0437534191,
0.0398996063,
-0.0058169994,
0.039685864,
0.0143934125,
-0.0394074284,
0.0292509235,
-0.0227765143,
0.0762958154,
0.0064928923,
-0.0414644442,
0.0162331611,
-0.01500104,
-0.0226333868,
0.0053346814,
-0.0471486673,
-0.0268424656,
-0.003169263,
-0.0240520984,
0.003914936,
0.0303800274,
0.0061051836,
-0.0309373643,
-0.012771925,
-0.0181054808,
0.0792447776,
0.0065378211,
-0.0247607343,
-0.008441804,
-0.0224240422,
0.006272526,
0.0622135364,
0.028093284,
-0.0381209664,
0.0079039941,
-0.0613132641,
-0.0458638668,
-0.065394327,
0.0307678375,
0.0306894071,
-0.0129310638,
-0.0421753936,
-0.0115531953,
0.0369986929,
0.0485754833,
0.0411492847,
-0.0106558157,
0.0601851009,
0.0078366352,
-0.0315153003,
-0.0770487487,
-0.0107102077,
-0.0178383887,
0.0315893553,
-0.0590744726,
0.0093940133,
0.0048980755,
0.0176965576,
-0.0073464233,
0.0249335431,
-0.0931996107,
-0.0682943091,
0.0074137445,
-0.0011227971,
0.0195080917,
0.0288976412,
-0.025429124,
-0.0433465987,
0.0502115339,
0.033886902,
-0.0485078432,
0.011910134,
0.0236310791,
-0.0263864789,
0.0229765624,
0.0150884157,
-0.0063026482,
-0.0119825434,
-0.0062798727,
0.0232089721,
0.0198654421,
-0.0069922041,
0.0029215403,
0.0490860492,
0.0333865397,
-0.0486853644,
-0.0036709711,
0.0212866776,
0.0598977208,
-0.0041848496,
-0.0034377142,
-0.006555981,
0.0176902115,
-0.0051341392,
-0.0493482985,
-0.0363675579,
-0.0146694565,
0.0347096361,
0.0245187804,
0.038673304,
-0.0297292378,
-0.0451696217,
0.032010667,
0.0843513608,
-0.0367712155,
-0.0118377022,
-0.0032284323,
0.0153475748,
0.0179158337,
-0.0288973786,
-0.0062715034,
0.0182607267,
0.0124724125,
-0.0303938556,
-0.0088050617,
-0.03479537,
-0.022104919,
-0.0606520995,
0.0288320426,
0.0285433233,
-0.0016196191,
0.0224186629,
-0.0148993861,
0.0030301483,
-0.0336200483,
0.0076596616,
-0.0262032915,
-0.0045066713,
0.0622832552,
0.0078307223,
-0.0397631191,
0.0244037695,
0.045191627,
0.042184744,
0.0266297068,
-0.0161726847,
-0.0276003275,
-0.015270954,
-0.0264018662,
-0.02614161,
0.0294444188,
-0.0645094588,
-0.0162199922,
-0.0170410499,
-0.069943279,
0.0245158002,
0.0264319032,
0.0083674053,
0.0178071391,
-0.0072761602,
0.0535595603,
0.0053908499,
0.0018923895,
-0.0062587243,
-0.0174444467,
0.0620904639,
-0.0351254307,
0.0155941928,
-6.540856848e-33,
0.012553297,
-0.0118906805,
-0.0197301321,
-0.067925781,
-0.0039536292,
-0.0290260371,
-0.0320461802,
-0.0281153582,
0.0521744527,
-0.0089802826,
-0.0353785604,
0.0230818205,
0.0450263247,
0.0379539877,
0.004162156,
0.0106666172,
0.0653263479,
-0.0108044138,
-0.0231164917,
-0.0050562271,
0.0435445234,
0.0429563522,
0.0508215912,
0.0125125861,
0.0005860481,
-0.0182267446,
0.0084506581,
-0.009633854,
-0.0133213559,
0.0456852689,
0.0012291069,
0.0315340906,
0.0135224741,
-0.0264907628,
-0.0420306548,
0.0044297366,
-0.0812675133,
0.0197484549,
0.0336296447,
0.0521846488,
-0.0137082404,
-0.0232762042,
-0.0309856031,
0.010832102,
-0.0075935312,
0.0105158808,
-0.0453242585,
-0.0260536391,
-0.0307579599,
-0.0574273355,
0.0144060589,
0.0335755497,
0.0020733341,
0.0729677007,
0.0764975771,
-0.0219237376,
0.0031477597,
0.0430780165,
-0.0210161805,
0.0090097431,
-0.0174998492,
0.0716856048,
0.0680790469,
0.0149686914,
-0.0219826121,
0.0279454421,
0.0370442197,
-0.0649731234,
-0.0077733742,
0.0104552712,
0.0494653992,
-0.0267532524,
-0.0212823767,
0.0478416421,
0.0913779363,
-0.0452414528,
-0.048845537,
0.0276350174,
0.0374047831,
-0.0019174626,
0.0544150211,
0.0243640728,
-0.0193321612,
-0.0576841384,
-0.0674332827,
-0.0260371827,
-0.0564349554,
-0.0035273186,
0.0090086097,
0.0134545835,
-0.0488818698,
-0.0090008099,
0.0593784451,
-0.0553501658,
-0.0368199088,
-0.0023373356,
-0.0157360379,
0.0060268096,
-0.0283358041,
0.043623466,
0.0052121133,
-0.0498141348,
0.0433370769,
-0.0178904552,
0.0004846301,
-0.0139305117,
0.0101903081,
0.0179062653,
-0.0857113451,
0.0081582759,
-0.0253205579,
0.0263868812,
-0.0000571837,
-0.001851926,
0.0630993545,
-0.0095730107,
0.0178872459,
0.0029873548,
0.0087781036,
0.0386364795,
-0.0232711751,
-0.0019155449,
0.0288782977,
0.0595784187,
-0.0110812234,
0.0195306335,
-0.0455506854,
-0.0366394669,
0.0533371419,
-0.0431328677,
-0.0122317588,
0.0481274761,
2.641e-7,
0.0219369326,
0.0524479672,
0.0542859435,
0.0006018752,
0.0216573738,
0.000939308,
-0.028013939,
0.0102886623,
-0.0008835437,
0.0045206798,
-0.0087281894,
0.0137867965,
0.0560318902,
0.0177635495,
-0.1035506353,
-0.0143394247,
-0.0311465785,
0.0204953235,
-0.0580639429,
-0.0132732885,
-0.0221124236,
0.1315698326,
-0.002226531,
-0.0441760868,
0.0508933924,
-0.0009384567,
-0.007195354,
0.0077788825,
-0.01785223,
0.0155026987,
-0.0157468468,
-0.0081194276,
0.025639236,
0.018385021,
-0.0073601925,
-0.001232618,
-0.0337277651,
0.0658390224,
-0.0004049133,
-0.0049158675,
0.0331795141,
-0.0286987796,
-0.0285156034,
-0.0058944519,
0.0234435275,
0.0052620559,
-0.00993919,
-0.0471569784,
-0.0005469228,
-0.0161638986,
-0.0551283583,
0.0037681328,
0.0196316577,
0.0658727959,
0.0327361412,
-0.0042686923,
0.0078740427,
-0.0566964708,
-0.0420553684,
-0.0327885486,
-0.0502049923,
-0.0819655657,
-0.0056212782,
-0.0046135872,
0.0206874441,
-0.0869074315,
0.0202154275,
3.063227387e-34,
0.0871018693,
0.0058603566,
-0.0041538901,
0.0751177073,
0.0226431377,
-0.0702134967,
0.0197742153,
0.0471311249,
-0.0134513881,
-0.0597673357,
-0.0510517098
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07513v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07513v1
|
Fine-tuning the SwissBERT Encoder Model for Embedding Sentences and Documents
| 2024-05-13T07:20:21 | 2024-05-13T07:20:21 |
Juri Grosjean, Jannis Vamvas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Encoder models trained for the embedding of sentences or short documents have
proven useful for tasks such as semantic search and topic modeling. In this
paper, we present a version of the SwissBERT encoder model that we specifically
fine-tuned for this purpose. SwissBERT contains language adapters for the four
national languages of Switzerland -- German, French, Italian, and Romansh --
and has been pre-trained on a large number of news articles in those languages.
Using contrastive learning based on a subset of these articles, we trained a
fine-tuned version, which we call SentenceSwissBERT. Multilingual experiments
on document retrieval and text classification in a Switzerland-specific setting
show that SentenceSwissBERT surpasses the accuracy of the original SwissBERT
model and of a comparable baseline. The model is openly available for research
use.
|
Fine-tuning the SwissBERT Encoder Model for Embedding Sentences and Documents: Encoder models trained for the embedding of sentences or short documents have
proven useful for tasks such as semantic search and topic modeling. In this
paper, we present a version of the SwissBERT encoder model that we specifically
fine-tuned for this purpose. SwissBERT contains language adapters for the four
national languages of Switzerland -- German, French, Italian, and Romansh --
and has been pre-trained on a large number of news articles in those languages.
Using contrastive learning based on a subset of these articles, we trained a
fine-tuned version, which we call SentenceSwissBERT. Multilingual experiments
on document retrieval and text classification in a Switzerland-specific setting
show that SentenceSwissBERT surpasses the accuracy of the original SwissBERT
model and of a comparable baseline. The model is openly available for research
use.
|
[
0.0102822911,
0.0472738892,
0.0043216799,
0.0738873929,
-0.0622495264,
0.0172934793,
-0.0042838426,
-0.0342203528,
-0.0030175243,
-0.0349017754,
0.0218182113,
-0.0051603117,
-0.0335098766,
0.0256841015,
0.0008172649,
-0.04529595,
0.0296894107,
-0.0227693599,
0.0016875025,
-0.0045701694,
0.0215755608,
-0.002420641,
0.0461045392,
0.0090653561,
0.0438983068,
0.0327135473,
-0.0107418392,
0.0210526995,
0.0285782926,
-0.0113351932,
0.0222113281,
-0.0017107514,
0.0626563504,
0.0018570781,
0.0000016815,
-0.0230879113,
-0.0278846417,
-0.025659943,
0.0550314151,
-0.032243941,
0.0368645638,
-0.1103628203,
0.0138320131,
0.0451510958,
-0.0049764067,
0.0010123021,
-0.0101997126,
0.058566168,
0.0210906137,
0.0968748704,
-0.0440763086,
-0.0534511209,
0.0325378925,
-0.0211486332,
-0.0240530558,
0.0120665738,
0.0075840103,
-0.0180464461,
-0.0079868482,
0.0717500001,
-0.0408072397,
0.046535179,
0.0511915237,
0.0051071001,
0.0164293274,
-0.0101889856,
-0.0085132373,
0.0033791936,
0.0192000512,
0.0422760323,
0.0042769476,
-0.0174265578,
-0.0297891907,
0.0033682473,
-0.0207840353,
0.0467199758,
-0.0387708358,
-0.0134791899,
0.0041690459,
0.0261402093,
0.0831293687,
0.0258354712,
-0.0232165083,
-0.0064354585,
-0.0012981946,
-0.0106726103,
0.0309936684,
-0.0625597388,
0.0230658278,
0.0321694575,
0.0127790533,
-0.0031063145,
0.0198165905,
0.0146248015,
0.0214526504,
-0.0198235363,
-0.0106947739,
-0.0386388116,
0.0248386804,
-0.0833576173,
-0.0373157635,
0.0444810987,
-0.045396436,
0.0853806287,
-0.0285063069,
0.0610880479,
-0.0256444123,
-0.0135305794,
-0.0743437037,
-0.0469986498,
-0.0315526426,
0.027804438,
-0.0388843678,
0.0304087028,
-0.0690248236,
-0.0599965081,
-0.0121306498,
0.0274187978,
0.0504562706,
0.0148699377,
-0.0225417167,
-0.0146083953,
-0.0136773465,
0.0135252019,
-0.0220203903,
0.0763183907,
-0.0464366041,
0.0117040519,
-0.0449310169,
-0.0084753819,
-0.0102907317,
0.0204975512,
0.01269955,
-0.0365585573,
0.0118561015,
-0.0015291206,
-0.0359359384,
-0.0549074821,
-0.0019339009,
0.0208830796,
0.0121551817,
-0.0203310065,
0.0013901363,
-0.0734762177,
0.0246160794,
0.0177099518,
0.0162015911,
-0.0497180931,
-0.0140188858,
-0.0002362436,
-0.0438508913,
0.0620209165,
-0.0081048468,
-0.042617172,
0.0112582389,
0.0012311279,
0.0122070266,
0.0739947259,
-0.0203481466,
0.0172266457,
0.0292578079,
0.0000851906,
0.0020352751,
0.0028302216,
0.0015642541,
0.0062750331,
-0.0407292098,
0.0294021741,
-0.0049601467,
0.0060241516,
0.048770126,
0.0578710027,
-0.0269966424,
-0.0337028056,
0.0421158373,
0.0426413864,
0.0344845653,
-0.0038223579,
0.0180759449,
-0.0000208731,
-0.026283022,
0.0228607748,
0.032878533,
0.021655133,
-0.0364583209,
0.0185412467,
0.0131714996,
0.01922388,
-0.0720623434,
-0.0202935524,
0.0252931695,
-0.0343678072,
0.0607734211,
-0.0172118824,
0.0850279257,
0.0157559495,
-0.0513256378,
-0.0003749754,
0.0283812545,
-0.0268478841,
0.0217142627,
-0.0026123743,
0.0142475106,
0.0951728895,
0.0438811556,
-0.0015596173,
0.0263165664,
-0.0356822163,
0.0037653612,
0.0349466428,
0.0399827734,
-0.0014407318,
0.0211683754,
-0.0543540791,
-0.04456589,
-0.0564284474,
0.0043072538,
0.0395848528,
-0.0375027396,
0.0607395768,
0.0194574427,
-0.017943887,
0.0161830708,
0.0076775695,
-0.0625262484,
-0.0109192058,
-0.0030726588,
0.0076270043,
-0.0148070818,
0.0049836859,
-0.0034652904,
-0.0147528257,
0.0270136725,
-0.0812946782,
-0.0032031017,
0.0132991364,
0.0128441453,
-0.0918019116,
-0.0229631737,
-0.0872363448,
0.0550809689,
0.0535587072,
-0.0353686623,
-0.0509029366,
0.0108447038,
-0.019245591,
0.0440653898,
-0.0397267789,
-0.0190691911,
-0.0233442299,
-0.0016734354,
-0.0041041067,
0.0588645786,
-0.0333686471,
0.0595128722,
-0.005113346,
-0.0267194584,
0.009843356,
-0.0299630091,
-0.0381498858,
0.0051147793,
0.0165373441,
0.0047940994,
0.0588458143,
0.0131913098,
0.0152174234,
-0.0306045506,
-0.0765674487,
0.0111918813,
-0.0637818426,
0.0101622585,
0.0129439114,
0.0252491627,
0.0187965091,
-0.0290238243,
-0.0324677117,
-0.0112310676,
0.0066443058,
0.0247114561,
0.0214449558,
0.0015974481,
-0.0125165191,
-0.0203426927,
-0.0168333668,
0.0193562098,
0.0693992972,
-0.0286588557,
-0.0125718629,
-0.0486321561,
0.0493992977,
-0.0157556497,
-0.010636989,
-0.04478205,
-0.0461756475,
-0.03156019,
-0.0007209972,
0.0001111622,
0.0752008036,
0.0118227806,
0.0609564222,
-0.0010320346,
0.0337279439,
-0.0558142886,
-0.0139873317,
-0.0397074558,
0.0281778574,
-0.0598106682,
-0.0283504389,
0.0348636433,
0.0471669585,
-0.0156508237,
0.0394396447,
-0.0373615623,
0.001550407,
0.0019253151,
0.0159342866,
-0.0334737971,
-0.0187430643,
0.0267344806,
0.0252154227,
-0.0138189001,
0.0030711186,
0.0615275018,
0.0034492388,
0.019036863,
-0.0444798917,
-0.0684167445,
-0.0461557731,
0.0117321433,
0.023550408,
0.030308418,
-0.0190579742,
-0.0004892166,
-0.0252907071,
-0.0396812409,
0.0162089467,
-0.0197340567,
0.0112487972,
0.0396327749,
0.0087033091,
0.0004509315,
-0.0894395933,
-0.0011243559,
-0.0650414005,
-0.0149518112,
0.0446124673,
0.026693549,
0.003946098,
-0.0745109469,
0.0212039147,
0.0264813546,
0.0615101121,
-0.025654085,
-0.0160206612,
-0.0234973505,
0.0788377151,
0.0513621196,
-0.0545129254,
-0.0094821462,
-0.0491669774,
0.0367221236,
0.0342662819,
-0.0213989168,
0.0268225409,
-0.029723797,
-0.0114109106,
0.0212766919,
-0.0222591832,
-0.0358410813,
-0.0413756557,
0.0385121144,
-0.018027341,
-0.0432684124,
0.1108761281,
0.0301690418,
-0.0553468019,
-0.0351394005,
-0.0162782762,
0.023007473,
0.0236321446,
0.0267302115,
-0.0470227897,
-0.0110934526,
-0.0000980796,
0.0080074146,
0.0057133031,
0.0434282348,
0.0271512456,
-0.0818572789,
0.0234108437,
0.0181921516,
-0.0576167628,
-0.0456751175,
-0.0837576985,
-0.0362652987,
-0.0525969826,
0.0062288251,
-0.0062545151,
-0.0038160472,
-0.017548833,
0.0113815209,
-0.0101712029,
-0.114596948,
-0.0292283092,
-0.0230224896,
0.0065816999,
-0.0104084173,
0.0005160146,
-0.0319796503,
-0.0482952334,
0.0075227381,
-0.0463485941,
-0.0046528741,
-0.0278023742,
0.0520469099,
-0.030025851,
0.0157047026,
-0.0161260776,
-0.002881215,
-0.026204804,
-0.0131937256,
-0.000510466,
0.0405182987,
-0.0141194044,
0.0271083266,
-0.025413502,
-0.0116693079,
0.0166566651,
0.0751695335,
0.0280058924,
-0.0363095552,
0.0044611986,
-0.053830374,
0.0315595567,
-0.047609292,
0.0009454837,
-0.0237228274,
0.0152252158,
0.0235051196,
-0.0452694669,
-0.0596988425,
-0.013015925,
0.0170063209,
-0.0103249662,
-0.0143858083,
-0.0094864266,
-0.0431205705,
-0.0668296367,
0.0258354247,
0.0128711425,
-0.0210024081,
-0.0154130151,
0.0077702668,
0.0882464647,
-0.0302901696,
-0.0353208743,
-0.056148693,
-0.0158786289,
-0.0357395038,
-0.0617285073,
0.0409109741,
0.0123608178,
0.0629624724,
-0.0093943551,
-0.0275477935,
0.0591385812,
0.0022071179,
-0.0453518033,
-0.0328863673,
0.0326320976,
-0.027987482,
-0.0095379483,
0.0024145741,
-0.0307375938,
0.0430926643,
-0.0008027616,
0.017189363,
-0.0326750018,
-0.0205472969,
0.0067907842,
-0.031831041,
0.0354036242,
0.0073772501,
-0.0162634663,
-0.0447480939,
0.0230380725,
-0.0216416176,
0.0205301438,
-0.0436478481,
0.0019878722,
0.0474890359,
0.0250293463,
-0.024856003,
0.018537147,
-0.0132007319,
0.0023959118,
-0.0304299165,
0.0329176858,
0.0691709891,
0.0070974682,
-0.0206937585,
0.0478671044,
-0.0190469306,
0.0440511629,
0.008804407,
0.0513209105,
-0.0500162728,
0.052044671,
0.0219413079,
0.0423002616,
0.0011596297,
0.0010881867,
-0.1004935876,
0.0038061631,
-0.0591985881,
0.0075253174,
0.0643679649,
-0.0284133311,
0.0451714993,
0.0016638181,
-0.0175517071,
-0.0119563891,
0.0261111949,
-0.0055250926,
-0.0309637263,
0.0114119984,
0.0291145053,
-0.0287236646,
0.028384041,
0.0277220011,
-0.0035716016,
0.0063931886,
0.0198522992,
-0.0246339105,
-0.0331723727,
0.0308409389,
0.0872107148,
0.0373454988,
-0.0278046932,
0.0016425828,
-0.0076188259,
-0.0200317092,
0.0313046649,
0.0119810291,
-0.0286616534,
0.0182046145,
0.0350090601,
0.0578521639,
0.0034375826,
0.012550259,
-0.0400123373,
-0.006078843,
-0.063711457,
-0.0660564229,
-0.0054632807,
-5.83492694e-33,
-0.0126059446,
0.0330758803,
-0.0248661414,
-0.0063840291,
0.0313214213,
0.0143074989,
-0.0278417803,
-0.0497669652,
-0.0359600484,
0.0200664848,
0.0258295983,
0.009408595,
0.0014092545,
0.0505382493,
0.0014029611,
-0.0167100597,
0.0522883199,
0.0410657339,
-0.0180324819,
0.0047261133,
0.0289902184,
0.0386558771,
0.045905225,
-0.0450971611,
-0.0132921357,
-0.0182315819,
0.0087305531,
0.011354208,
0.104749091,
0.0836890861,
-0.0122138793,
0.035593342,
0.0119666979,
-0.0480467156,
0.0074583804,
0.035204865,
-0.0705767497,
-0.0332360715,
-0.0215991978,
0.0277895834,
-0.0303328428,
-0.0354255885,
0.0305052157,
-0.007541941,
-0.0063789487,
0.0025855629,
0.05945177,
-0.0106836893,
-0.0320584774,
-0.0230970234,
-0.0442211293,
0.0068944637,
-0.0061598336,
0.0259193927,
0.0395241603,
0.0723010078,
0.0222440846,
0.0368790887,
-0.0528710261,
0.0079066018,
-0.012955498,
0.0153542822,
-0.0044570686,
-0.0351235345,
-0.0258258376,
0.0500865467,
0.0035692821,
-0.0049837693,
0.0472413711,
-0.0159223061,
0.0568797626,
-0.0172299109,
0.048303768,
0.0690393299,
0.0273995679,
-0.0182049461,
-0.060190279,
0.0567376167,
0.0116166156,
0.0116369277,
0.0272845775,
0.0230060034,
-0.0282310899,
-0.0089723617,
-0.0158764645,
-0.0301755723,
-0.015841797,
-0.0522191934,
0.0345222466,
0.0281218737,
0.0294686928,
-0.0339578353,
0.0767936036,
-0.0365297645,
0.0138882473,
0.0665005744,
-0.0362050571,
0.0276688095,
-0.0011596131,
0.0397909358,
-0.0459829308,
-0.0490551591,
-0.0005384139,
0.0219388139,
-0.0136116007,
-0.0032059588,
0.0725203604,
-0.0082370341,
-0.071837768,
0.0012909794,
-0.0068508633,
-0.0183521155,
-0.0441677198,
0.0301325526,
-0.0056712986,
0.0180850048,
-0.0017235363,
0.0401147716,
0.008571486,
-0.0120232953,
-0.0199865401,
-0.0871852562,
0.0191026852,
0.0544527173,
-0.0062301103,
0.0205209088,
-0.0174396969,
0.0619491935,
0.001943742,
-0.0401210487,
0.0026351488,
0.0081728343,
2.489e-7,
0.0455547124,
0.024728084,
-0.0475675352,
-0.0031695059,
0.0086169755,
0.01532178,
-0.0083147343,
0.0650675967,
0.0176300313,
-0.0000869248,
0.0364451148,
0.0285687484,
0.0364500098,
0.022726275,
-0.1048063263,
0.032476116,
-0.0509865955,
-0.0226854198,
-0.0280148238,
0.0200702678,
0.074189201,
0.1047712788,
0.0087369485,
0.0197939202,
-0.0223652422,
-0.0420057513,
0.0998851657,
-0.0172438249,
-0.0585365891,
-0.0487036742,
-0.0194744263,
0.0738752484,
-0.0152965141,
-0.0070227669,
-0.0024603559,
0.0488853119,
0.00749597,
0.0332221314,
-0.0031048236,
-0.0361142196,
0.0030383887,
0.0019432621,
-0.0479042307,
-0.0387608707,
0.0423835628,
-0.0384403057,
-0.0120202787,
-0.0029244074,
-0.0624998398,
0.0002910076,
0.088208355,
-0.0114852767,
-0.0204639472,
0.0077562584,
0.0252204593,
0.0094843889,
0.0125515284,
-0.0429298207,
0.020406777,
0.0560280643,
0.0136377746,
-0.0000567919,
-0.0009386666,
0.0251568332,
0.0041954094,
-0.0193195306,
0.026603261,
1.8897238e-34,
0.0685316771,
-0.0025773207,
-0.0275383443,
0.020341374,
0.0189568717,
-0.0274407398,
-0.0463425852,
-0.0329346545,
0.0155446278,
-0.049861595,
-0.0026775065
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07500v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07500v1
|
PromptLink: Leveraging Large Language Models for Cross-Source Biomedical Concept Linking
| 2024-05-13T06:36:30 | 2024-05-13T06:36:30 |
Yuzhang Xie, Jiaying Lu, Joyce Ho, Fadi Nahab, Xiao Hu, Carl Yang
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Linking (aligning) biomedical concepts across diverse data sources enables
various integrative analyses, but it is challenging due to the discrepancies in
concept naming conventions. Various strategies have been developed to overcome
this challenge, such as those based on string-matching rules, manually crafted
thesauri, and machine learning models. However, these methods are constrained
by limited prior biomedical knowledge and can hardly generalize beyond the
limited amounts of rules, thesauri, or training samples. Recently, large
language models (LLMs) have exhibited impressive results in diverse biomedical
NLP tasks due to their unprecedentedly rich prior knowledge and strong
zero-shot prediction abilities. However, LLMs suffer from issues including high
costs, limited context length, and unreliable predictions. In this research, we
propose PromptLink, a novel biomedical concept linking framework that leverages
LLMs. It first employs a biomedical-specialized pre-trained language model to
generate candidate concepts that can fit in the LLM context windows. Then it
utilizes an LLM to link concepts through two-stage prompts, where the
first-stage prompt aims to elicit the biomedical prior knowledge from the LLM
for the concept linking task and the second-stage prompt enforces the LLM to
reflect on its own predictions to further enhance their reliability. Empirical
results on the concept linking task between two EHR datasets and an external
biomedical KG demonstrate the effectiveness of PromptLink. Furthermore,
PromptLink is a generic framework without reliance on additional prior
knowledge, context, or training data, making it well-suited for concept linking
across various types of data sources. The source code is available at
https://github.com/constantjxyz/PromptLink.
|
PromptLink: Leveraging Large Language Models for Cross-Source Biomedical Concept Linking: Linking (aligning) biomedical concepts across diverse data sources enables
various integrative analyses, but it is challenging due to the discrepancies in
concept naming conventions. Various strategies have been developed to overcome
this challenge, such as those based on string-matching rules, manually crafted
thesauri, and machine learning models. However, these methods are constrained
by limited prior biomedical knowledge and can hardly generalize beyond the
limited amounts of rules, thesauri, or training samples. Recently, large
language models (LLMs) have exhibited impressive results in diverse biomedical
NLP tasks due to their unprecedentedly rich prior knowledge and strong
zero-shot prediction abilities. However, LLMs suffer from issues including high
costs, limited context length, and unreliable predictions. In this research, we
propose PromptLink, a novel biomedical concept linking framework that leverages
LLMs. It first employs a biomedical-specialized pre-trained language model to
generate candidate concepts that can fit in the LLM context windows. Then it
utilizes an LLM to link concepts through two-stage prompts, where the
first-stage prompt aims to elicit the biomedical prior knowledge from the LLM
for the concept linking task and the second-stage prompt enforces the LLM to
reflect on its own predictions to further enhance their reliability. Empirical
results on the concept linking task between two EHR datasets and an external
biomedical KG demonstrate the effectiveness of PromptLink. Furthermore,
PromptLink is a generic framework without reliance on additional prior
knowledge, context, or training data, making it well-suited for concept linking
across various types of data sources. The source code is available at
https://github.com/constantjxyz/PromptLink.
|
[
0.0235115252,
0.0601309687,
-0.0040875226,
-0.0505911894,
-0.0194353573,
0.0326578058,
0.0007955483,
0.012190992,
-0.0137067633,
-0.0138017153,
-0.0293262042,
-0.0129711572,
0.0406186059,
0.0446547978,
0.0373223908,
-0.0210634544,
0.0455147438,
0.0321331061,
0.0050795195,
0.0050726868,
-0.0184154063,
0.0236730129,
0.0054438827,
0.0331575051,
0.0139847696,
-0.0096489387,
0.0303397477,
-0.0142668197,
0.0254761614,
-0.0632923394,
-0.0195235163,
0.0545534715,
-0.0018091765,
0.0594165474,
0.0000019198,
-0.0663675889,
-0.04597551,
0.0444638766,
-0.0443100557,
-0.0336848088,
0.0244203862,
-0.0503308699,
0.0191291478,
-0.0333383754,
0.0031149751,
-0.038576968,
0.0733301342,
0.0490667634,
0.033381477,
0.0372371338,
-0.0023499131,
-0.0248216987,
0.0572123341,
-0.0457988717,
0.0346461833,
-0.0298732053,
0.0741332546,
-0.0236018654,
0.0119484626,
0.0112495711,
-0.0063906526,
0.0516155772,
-0.008653271,
0.0382390544,
0.0291746389,
0.0450393595,
-0.0230453014,
-0.0318354182,
0.0087213572,
0.1030215397,
-0.0196549464,
-0.0431197211,
0.0153571535,
0.0082702804,
-0.0370483436,
0.0375572145,
-0.0497656316,
-0.0044964231,
-0.0102231856,
-0.0026946189,
0.0189021975,
-0.0176455434,
0.0588110834,
0.0098387785,
-0.0203761309,
0.0367638022,
0.0216776337,
-0.008994502,
0.0351829864,
-0.0046396898,
-0.0088692065,
-0.050102029,
-0.0002766726,
0.0225433055,
-0.0316907726,
0.0435993336,
-0.0291626584,
-0.0087982435,
0.0975282937,
-0.0215617009,
-0.0118419267,
0.0177706461,
-0.0082319453,
0.0371779092,
-0.053706225,
-0.0099149514,
-0.0302420016,
0.0158223901,
-0.0163341146,
-0.04229353,
-0.0701061487,
-0.0107210819,
-0.0080585685,
0.0007025101,
-0.0188978612,
-0.0233244617,
-0.0770712867,
-0.0005768593,
-0.0155862551,
0.0336697064,
0.014718459,
-0.0069668042,
-0.0231041647,
0.0082521262,
-0.0416786671,
-0.0010480845,
0.0148998303,
0.0073809768,
-0.0274134036,
-0.0682725757,
-0.0167548805,
-0.0287771579,
-0.0303644165,
-0.0461510047,
0.0115145212,
0.0612386465,
0.0417692102,
0.0014414354,
-0.0154297799,
-0.0569206141,
0.0051845736,
-0.0418790877,
-0.0298112556,
-0.0741129741,
0.0556412339,
0.0139733935,
0.004184545,
-0.0649666116,
0.0105518298,
0.0174864549,
-0.0795601457,
0.123396188,
-0.0666470677,
-0.0295622833,
0.0242002513,
0.0178480111,
-0.0085777817,
0.0252156835,
-0.0240400564,
-0.0567648634,
0.0086543309,
0.0041431943,
-0.033512257,
-0.0137489149,
0.0496974289,
-0.0517205968,
-0.0046090907,
0.0186058842,
0.0612665564,
0.0802989751,
0.0081968373,
0.0458857119,
-0.0061700172,
-0.0356265418,
0.007666084,
0.0667442232,
0.0466956683,
-0.0056377575,
0.0581564941,
-0.0311316438,
-0.0164487436,
-0.0530118942,
-0.0300093163,
-0.0124989683,
-0.0270951167,
0.0099154534,
0.0132087441,
0.0424868427,
-0.014586783,
0.0111909769,
-0.0168942362,
-0.0013717273,
-0.052991353,
0.0041191392,
0.0437009893,
-0.0233808793,
0.0028169698,
0.0659659952,
0.0786729604,
0.0260115005,
0.0082444055,
-0.0258218311,
-0.0061816932,
0.0465114079,
0.0395818762,
-0.0063317865,
-0.0507950447,
-0.020664582,
0.001417404,
0.0021235675,
0.0149919847,
-0.0351361409,
-0.0141275134,
-0.0256581753,
-0.0076833549,
0.0297031738,
-0.0034406511,
-0.0126297679,
-0.0002721548,
0.0579825453,
-0.0031502943,
-0.0371590033,
0.0104081929,
0.0568108261,
-0.0634587705,
-0.0011213809,
-0.013769472,
-0.008691228,
0.0224386603,
0.0043484126,
-0.0150417862,
0.0373009183,
0.0476898737,
-0.027375238,
-0.0319235399,
-0.0168180726,
-0.0179279167,
-0.044589173,
0.0405108444,
-0.0146892881,
-0.0014279964,
-0.0516168252,
-0.0537939183,
-0.0469099022,
-0.011332796,
0.0263535939,
0.0138031049,
-0.0089815082,
0.0273211766,
0.0211263821,
0.0085348859,
-0.0547813214,
0.0224247687,
-0.0025276111,
0.0300228149,
0.0307908952,
-0.0067721517,
0.0238815658,
-0.0263937805,
-0.0302006435,
0.0164663475,
0.0044789165,
-0.0155948652,
-0.0071942569,
-0.0347840153,
-0.0596422739,
0.0087808939,
-0.0536359511,
0.0428592488,
0.0499050058,
0.0047845254,
0.0155888936,
-0.0007659057,
-0.0059806644,
-0.0215789881,
-0.0297879595,
-0.0043214154,
0.0131417969,
0.0244296342,
0.0193495676,
0.0384460874,
-0.0216208529,
-0.0470125154,
-0.0136714708,
-0.0479291715,
0.0777405351,
0.0061458591,
-0.043360278,
-0.018376682,
-0.0008116126,
-0.044223506,
0.002391909,
-0.004009943,
0.0313168764,
-0.0201759003,
0.0259369481,
0.0211240984,
-0.0025486043,
-0.0293314476,
-0.0122629441,
0.0764398724,
-0.0010318824,
-0.0458544642,
-0.004890576,
-0.0262331069,
-0.0191209055,
0.0081906328,
-0.0093041686,
0.0223753229,
0.0599150658,
-0.0023134756,
-0.0149717005,
-0.0366810672,
0.0325533114,
0.0001704203,
0.0164294727,
-0.0758494437,
0.0070310738,
-0.0072542983,
0.0323738866,
-0.0158656035,
-0.0452163815,
0.0982915163,
-0.009833253,
0.0546021797,
-0.019519249,
0.001597184,
-0.0292414408,
0.0194370821,
0.0144632151,
0.0253636185,
0.0496910289,
0.0098647531,
0.0007720171,
0.0376743376,
-0.0245461389,
-0.0179400723,
0.0611293465,
-0.035283383,
0.0503226072,
0.0361190811,
-0.005460036,
-0.0408910885,
0.0396476313,
-0.0469404161,
0.0335895829,
0.002529291,
0.0045097424,
-0.050165236,
0.0368381813,
0.0163587425,
0.0232016724,
0.0342912525,
-0.0312974639,
0.0047417735,
-0.0048760758,
0.0628428385,
-0.0609479994,
0.0173350349,
0.001676987,
0.0445282608,
0.0415757857,
0.0093649095,
0.0094359657,
0.0232097358,
0.0045492868,
0.0072911428,
-0.0654668733,
-0.0264639836,
0.0120962132,
-0.0104222484,
-0.0410798267,
0.0119855283,
0.1208518296,
0.0552963503,
-0.0940812454,
0.001256572,
-0.027504636,
-0.0054867971,
-0.0091909831,
0.0311963446,
-0.0866830572,
-0.0508098304,
-0.0154563021,
-0.0317316391,
-0.0135762645,
-0.0612217188,
-0.0099499142,
-0.0720638484,
-0.002270065,
-0.0076638255,
-0.0876222774,
-0.0517259724,
-0.0866369307,
0.0323273018,
-0.0410718583,
-0.0006657575,
-0.005135945,
0.0058622612,
0.0032694924,
-0.0058588898,
-0.0360496044,
-0.0805626512,
0.0463322327,
-0.0699380711,
0.0913537294,
0.0436156802,
0.0158257298,
0.015667025,
-0.0132108154,
-0.014204327,
-0.0804105252,
-0.0207674913,
-0.0194229688,
0.0691980571,
-0.004300449,
0.0098526711,
-0.0238026697,
0.0168721955,
-0.037578322,
-0.0439682566,
-0.0286689531,
0.1172101721,
-0.0002161794,
-0.0086285789,
-0.0423028879,
0.0033621909,
-0.0002002649,
0.0837786496,
-0.010244891,
-0.0020749511,
0.0004657324,
0.0193511806,
0.0197718255,
0.0153653761,
-0.0202170461,
0.0338716581,
-0.0752656385,
-0.0198670402,
-0.0521077663,
-0.0073738033,
0.0703521445,
-0.0006861205,
0.0331590697,
0.0748420432,
-0.0131773502,
-0.0201707315,
-0.0599163175,
0.0736023784,
-0.0016737739,
0.0419549793,
-0.051959306,
-0.039402876,
0.0668876767,
0.0028179691,
-0.0257931072,
0.0341035798,
-0.003619551,
-0.035870634,
-0.0290060434,
0.0204317551,
0.0172059257,
0.0164448842,
-0.0122992778,
-0.0277856849,
0.0595502891,
0.0454547182,
-0.0469439961,
-0.0331685543,
-0.0360368192,
0.0221922733,
-0.0035288285,
0.0299330559,
-0.0415254645,
0.013580313,
0.0105527742,
0.0371816643,
-0.006428564,
-0.041114796,
0.0427550264,
0.0372731499,
0.0659393445,
-0.0361211933,
0.0051430366,
-0.0120964237,
-0.0125748953,
0.0160416923,
0.0040296395,
-0.001633203,
0.0068641617,
0.06325569,
0.0142915901,
-0.0023123133,
-0.0030956927,
-0.0266285054,
-0.0128814578,
-0.0344725251,
-0.0004949911,
0.0244625527,
0.0275583155,
0.0631205961,
-0.0012867161,
0.0230640359,
-0.0085056778,
-0.0383514911,
0.0083871307,
-0.0668910667,
0.0198145825,
0.0261960961,
0.0440470204,
-0.0239141025,
0.0453494936,
-0.0286424998,
-0.0291838404,
0.0085851941,
-0.0025394657,
0.0488128588,
0.0198675208,
0.0267668758,
0.005783428,
-0.0312011205,
-0.0264248494,
-0.0019133113,
-0.0141544705,
0.0093440656,
0.0806263983,
0.0159119163,
-0.0256336182,
-0.0211026222,
0.0793892443,
-0.0096732909,
0.0990202054,
-0.004219579,
-0.0538716391,
-0.0053641535,
0.0175319016,
0.0249355379,
-0.0202387013,
-0.0654474273,
0.0024574248,
-0.0451591015,
-0.0723938793,
0.062931098,
-0.0097726053,
-0.0292000677,
0.0386652611,
0.0597893819,
0.0348385163,
0.0506175756,
-0.0119193848,
0.0054531074,
-0.0014466629,
-0.0244323984,
-0.0708584785,
-0.0057931263,
-5.783577306e-33,
-0.0292542521,
-0.0076327026,
0.0135032544,
-0.0122431191,
-0.0078214537,
0.0158440098,
-0.0308753792,
-0.0320137665,
-0.0208323821,
0.0464330055,
0.0020340362,
-0.0128644379,
-0.0091489572,
-0.0064433855,
0.0028347999,
-0.0319832899,
0.0205229297,
0.0223847069,
0.0112747643,
0.0047714291,
0.0291946568,
0.0562231466,
0.038658563,
-0.0280468836,
0.0312605388,
0.0478742756,
0.028499376,
0.0209553503,
0.0224597733,
0.0653976724,
-0.0375985466,
0.0491474941,
0.0233153012,
-0.0312420242,
-0.0159051511,
-0.0049117804,
-0.0879803151,
-0.0153482351,
0.0264127403,
-0.0421240553,
-0.0054681166,
-0.038818907,
0.0451031066,
-0.0138047654,
0.0052364217,
-0.0198404584,
0.0236834679,
-0.0294887777,
-0.0657968447,
-0.0436412543,
-0.0610055551,
0.0455959998,
0.0051613017,
0.0170260649,
0.0260133184,
-0.0177284367,
-0.0145799052,
0.0530008934,
-0.0346908458,
-0.0010701619,
0.023593314,
0.0245190039,
0.0269806702,
-0.0037905609,
0.0340759307,
0.0750827789,
0.0011667816,
-0.0571719706,
-0.0364574604,
0.054046575,
-0.0201724749,
0.0182979926,
0.02449557,
0.033010561,
0.0285263602,
-0.0000865719,
-0.1090109423,
0.0322564766,
-0.0270501189,
0.0254209861,
-0.0241278689,
-0.0114191473,
0.0112807825,
-0.0097213546,
-0.0729087889,
0.004134194,
-0.0405808464,
-0.0363995023,
0.0138895698,
-0.0309823677,
0.02773121,
0.0228382852,
-0.0040286263,
-0.0206933767,
0.0006070801,
0.0142655391,
0.0384520926,
-0.02103246,
0.0073231179,
0.0310236663,
-0.0792198181,
-0.0066526569,
0.0476324596,
-0.0289420839,
0.0440058522,
-0.0012928147,
0.0177220739,
-0.0297449455,
-0.0569944307,
-0.005201601,
-0.0159700438,
-0.0219918098,
-0.0153769432,
-0.0173545368,
0.0263614897,
0.0508318432,
0.0051648724,
0.0372235738,
0.0356300548,
-0.01239827,
-0.0055697286,
0.0122370273,
-0.0113687757,
0.0182244983,
-0.0319433734,
-0.0128563261,
-0.0260099508,
0.0174130835,
0.0248349421,
-0.0535430834,
-0.0167892631,
0.0043671257,
2.762e-7,
0.0839518979,
0.0282560177,
-0.0241816938,
0.0044234097,
0.0052531338,
-0.0212558769,
-0.0072690449,
0.0100814924,
-0.0198618956,
-0.0191216562,
0.0146529572,
0.0110053299,
0.0041175429,
0.008530465,
-0.067892164,
-0.0159991309,
-0.0533217937,
-0.023510484,
-0.0346975662,
-0.0217323899,
0.0268306751,
0.0908918008,
-0.0108060949,
-0.0136585357,
0.0180441048,
0.0012290494,
0.0288109109,
-0.0521714203,
-0.0105821379,
0.0513816103,
0.0010483939,
-0.0252481326,
0.0132729551,
0.0785715729,
-0.0065804585,
0.0013544997,
-0.0065235733,
0.0452888384,
-0.0313836522,
0.005042938,
0.0160124209,
-0.0147798546,
0.0212135613,
-0.038533546,
0.0539415032,
-0.0680844635,
-0.0471008793,
0.0179971289,
-0.0277700499,
0.0212282501,
0.0584668368,
-0.0045488458,
-0.0180108678,
0.0265703928,
0.029050475,
0.0389008746,
-0.0285092443,
-0.08374127,
-0.0085784877,
0.0601451285,
-0.0242727436,
-0.026522629,
0.0130052641,
-0.0451387689,
0.0153997708,
-0.0877346545,
0.02067996,
2.482633508e-34,
0.0212713908,
-0.0156604946,
-0.0270887464,
0.0138067128,
0.0521001965,
-0.048188258,
0.0038948427,
0.0208701603,
-0.0092313485,
-0.0943944678,
0.011572388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07495v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07495v1
|
MacBehaviour: An R package for behavioural experimentation on large language models
| 2024-05-13T06:31:48 | 2024-05-13T06:31:48 |
Xufeng Duan, Shixuan Li, Zhenguang G. Cai1
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
There has been increasing interest in investigating the behaviours of large
language models (LLMs) and LLM-powered chatbots by treating an LLM as a
participant in a psychological experiment. We therefore developed an R package
called "MacBehaviour" that aims to interact with more than 60 language models
in one package (e.g., OpenAI's GPT family, the Claude family, Gemini, Llama
family, and open-source models) and streamline the experimental process of LLMs
behaviour experiments. The package offers a comprehensive set of functions
designed for LLM experiments, covering experiment design, stimuli presentation,
model behaviour manipulation, logging response and token probability. To
demonstrate the utility and effectiveness of "MacBehaviour," we conducted three
validation experiments on three LLMs (GPT-3.5, Llama-2 7B, and Vicuna-1.5 13B)
to replicate sound-gender association in LLMs. The results consistently showed
that they exhibit human-like tendencies to infer gender from novel personal
names based on their phonology, as previously demonstrated (Cai et al., 2023).
In summary, "MacBehaviour" is an R package for machine behaviour studies which
offers a user-friendly interface and comprehensive features to simplify and
standardize the experimental process.
|
MacBehaviour: An R package for behavioural experimentation on large language models: There has been increasing interest in investigating the behaviours of large
language models (LLMs) and LLM-powered chatbots by treating an LLM as a
participant in a psychological experiment. We therefore developed an R package
called "MacBehaviour" that aims to interact with more than 60 language models
in one package (e.g., OpenAI's GPT family, the Claude family, Gemini, Llama
family, and open-source models) and streamline the experimental process of LLMs
behaviour experiments. The package offers a comprehensive set of functions
designed for LLM experiments, covering experiment design, stimuli presentation,
model behaviour manipulation, logging response and token probability. To
demonstrate the utility and effectiveness of "MacBehaviour," we conducted three
validation experiments on three LLMs (GPT-3.5, Llama-2 7B, and Vicuna-1.5 13B)
to replicate sound-gender association in LLMs. The results consistently showed
that they exhibit human-like tendencies to infer gender from novel personal
names based on their phonology, as previously demonstrated (Cai et al., 2023).
In summary, "MacBehaviour" is an R package for machine behaviour studies which
offers a user-friendly interface and comprehensive features to simplify and
standardize the experimental process.
|
[
0.0192014575,
0.0583128929,
-0.0525396802,
0.0106481789,
-0.062844269,
0.0195200667,
0.026535688,
-0.0007800638,
-0.0018128253,
0.0057006911,
-0.0361892506,
-0.0062627741,
0.0344440639,
0.0577941798,
0.0369395502,
-0.0215700511,
0.0496858619,
-0.0347661786,
0.0073488178,
-0.0088351462,
0.0013076281,
0.0223239101,
-0.0150394561,
0.0700218827,
0.0199665651,
-0.0199417565,
-0.021655336,
-0.0016733425,
0.0084251966,
-0.0102516245,
-0.017935887,
0.0556918904,
0.0086349137,
0.0715068132,
0.0000022291,
-0.0848999172,
0.0062310789,
0.0235056393,
-0.0270094164,
-0.0050027072,
0.0460098609,
0.0495396554,
-0.0221092161,
0.0208281577,
-0.0050480175,
-0.0171202719,
0.0700851902,
0.0032131053,
0.0000279746,
0.0449051894,
-0.0072551752,
-0.0069577931,
0.0063316133,
-0.009461089,
0.0308200084,
0.0184213724,
0.0539922416,
-0.0284982696,
0.0283021238,
-0.0226274896,
0.0081268856,
-0.0035810978,
-0.0057349368,
-0.0062885028,
-0.0227197167,
0.0466353074,
-0.0345284864,
-0.0673174411,
0.0157647654,
0.0413409621,
0.0303588472,
-0.01914238,
0.0319580287,
0.0339320861,
0.0037654538,
0.0150007773,
-0.0192367807,
0.0044811359,
-0.0125841312,
-0.0127751585,
-0.0030179492,
-0.0223766956,
0.0158909671,
0.0140566956,
-0.0116581405,
0.073019512,
0.0115485527,
-0.0251143817,
0.0181547422,
-0.0197040904,
0.0147858197,
-0.0877447575,
0.0129722487,
0.0096869981,
-0.023829611,
0.0074348059,
-0.0040852856,
-0.0053037587,
0.0487462431,
-0.0613458045,
0.0162763745,
0.0509540699,
-0.0131541267,
-0.0016830728,
-0.0572083034,
0.0530016758,
-0.0176528208,
0.0150852297,
0.0087427096,
-0.0183433034,
-0.0388116613,
-0.0356148705,
-0.0029425244,
0.0002357766,
-0.0054874867,
-0.0082809851,
-0.0571149066,
0.0272770617,
-0.0152105521,
-0.0182429254,
-0.002522863,
-0.0258787405,
-0.0273490231,
0.0142161017,
-0.0394857936,
0.0061305854,
-0.044478178,
0.0385323614,
-0.0198200904,
-0.077373907,
-0.004997768,
-0.0023400697,
-0.0036706771,
-0.0199987944,
0.0257940311,
0.0817176923,
0.0099101188,
-0.0183525011,
-0.0096592391,
-0.0042995913,
0.0021192546,
-0.0513617396,
-0.0100614876,
-0.0619332306,
0.0025640996,
0.0266580842,
-0.0106153544,
-0.0062278574,
-0.0016405415,
0.0151699651,
-0.0113231745,
0.0727753639,
0.0184078999,
0.0301107876,
0.0464700535,
0.0028541086,
-0.0174067896,
0.0796056911,
0.0431340151,
0.0000493807,
0.0017472267,
-0.043176353,
0.0254244879,
0.0520665944,
-0.010047839,
-0.0246515498,
-0.0226910599,
-0.0105163334,
0.0030031069,
0.0378402397,
0.0659304932,
0.0311088245,
0.0030779757,
-0.0475903861,
0.0411812998,
0.0809363276,
0.0013921604,
0.0366223343,
0.0329312012,
-0.0088446075,
0.0114250612,
0.0205371883,
-0.032700412,
0.0197670199,
-0.0609404147,
0.0182115398,
0.001107808,
0.035263814,
-0.0039985678,
-0.017858034,
-0.0171291735,
-0.0249512661,
0.0270463992,
0.0047118594,
0.0441439748,
0.0149330581,
-0.0018202845,
-0.0044235941,
0.0564533137,
-0.050574448,
-0.0437468439,
-0.0898824334,
0.0605745539,
0.0415439233,
0.0303255226,
-0.0255267918,
0.0167749487,
-0.0083617941,
-0.035698235,
0.0581893027,
0.0269218758,
0.001755319,
0.0003261428,
-0.025048947,
0.0307032801,
0.0625669584,
0.0055025285,
0.0774562806,
0.0246517491,
0.0406723768,
-0.0335745849,
0.009113526,
-0.0007607931,
0.023487946,
-0.0559218563,
-0.0343679935,
-0.00679356,
-0.0240439102,
0.0514412262,
-0.0206152461,
-0.0352781676,
0.0045778216,
0.0172161572,
0.0113373436,
0.0229547154,
0.0566316433,
0.0003192594,
0.01394914,
0.0299498942,
0.002856232,
-0.0422108397,
0.0512857959,
0.0172460191,
-0.0088778604,
0.0214076843,
-0.0399549082,
0.0561178625,
-0.0385135263,
0.0239070747,
-0.0409157611,
0.0350646116,
-0.0070878761,
0.0211323705,
0.015516948,
0.0069611603,
0.0265530217,
0.0092982808,
-0.0259944797,
-0.0861169323,
-0.055316519,
0.0338132083,
-0.006270091,
-0.0038604834,
0.0036449272,
-0.0123561649,
-0.0505109318,
-0.0406395458,
-0.1027629822,
-0.0067756958,
0.0246341303,
0.0055579669,
-0.0253798813,
-0.0108523006,
-0.0615003295,
-0.0114393281,
-0.0084735435,
-0.0072581032,
0.0067166453,
0.0603669956,
0.0168390237,
-0.0347189792,
-0.0717071071,
-0.060677167,
0.0054029375,
-0.0277228057,
0.0315928645,
0.0288917664,
0.0063457303,
-0.0404513143,
0.0173445195,
-0.0623746961,
0.0010174767,
-0.0200967062,
-0.0376315862,
0.0521306954,
0.0037215289,
0.110666357,
0.0696005225,
-0.0000251825,
0.0468042381,
0.0485587046,
-0.002745138,
-0.0552935526,
-0.0109480349,
0.0166724734,
-0.0137114665,
-0.0236489549,
-0.114403598,
-0.0288324356,
0.0732967854,
-0.0200222861,
0.0138944332,
-0.020426061,
0.0373558067,
0.0075855334,
-0.0630757064,
0.0014381021,
-0.0243744012,
-0.0656455904,
0.042947568,
0.0076782969,
-0.0782438815,
0.0794523731,
-0.0527627468,
-0.0386914685,
-0.0307766721,
-0.0320383422,
-0.0157097969,
0.0935852453,
-0.0081078745,
-0.0168872755,
0.056349691,
-0.0248686876,
-0.0244304687,
-0.0123292711,
0.0029403879,
-0.0426235795,
0.0029414746,
-0.0293978378,
0.0175551232,
0.0120101618,
0.0039478675,
-0.0492687449,
0.0033806288,
-0.048267182,
-0.0138896946,
0.0165513139,
-0.0381370634,
-0.0250369273,
0.0345205404,
0.0401326045,
-0.0236622244,
-0.0180175044,
0.0123564415,
-0.0130201159,
-0.0060931225,
0.0814459175,
0.0465142839,
0.0016791499,
-0.000391812,
0.0320312977,
0.0061620735,
-0.0230600815,
0.0157044735,
-0.0392031223,
0.0006922374,
0.0072215344,
-0.0023093019,
0.0164429825,
0.0250340942,
0.039339859,
-0.0396098904,
-0.0050342479,
0.0955901965,
0.0260343477,
-0.0490103401,
-0.0109005012,
-0.0468972661,
0.0885897204,
0.0053025815,
0.0420708694,
-0.0549653806,
0.0016853132,
0.0460938066,
-0.0142952176,
-0.0315779783,
-0.0163626485,
-0.0045983749,
-0.1256843507,
0.0181343686,
-0.0147024645,
-0.0867978707,
-0.0303175561,
-0.0542327315,
0.0327938795,
-0.0319549441,
0.0348436423,
0.0158024523,
-0.0157069881,
-0.0251129102,
0.0036119868,
-0.0531184152,
-0.0417271592,
0.0301415622,
-0.0592945032,
0.1172763631,
0.062926054,
0.0266051721,
-0.0466749109,
-0.0414757356,
0.0111877341,
0.0318574086,
0.0171785876,
-0.0145965526,
0.0277262051,
0.0416728705,
-0.003263359,
-0.071833916,
0.0080619799,
0.0409194753,
0.0015059237,
0.0099435085,
0.0375037789,
-0.0048324587,
-0.046851825,
-0.0254811272,
0.0184329227,
-0.0227078609,
0.0712496564,
0.0477251522,
-0.0555557907,
-0.0301810931,
-0.0426650904,
-0.0257787127,
0.0307290945,
-0.0719712526,
-0.0346417092,
0.0185545608,
-0.0476669557,
-0.059347339,
-0.0419941545,
0.0486632437,
-0.0255833529,
0.003800035,
-0.0173083842,
-0.0025144862,
0.0471462645,
-0.0314812176,
0.0570554286,
-0.0047614649,
0.032202296,
-0.0464759506,
-0.0131324874,
0.0517820343,
-0.0447981171,
-0.0135713089,
0.0340609848,
-0.0643186495,
-0.0927112773,
0.0345741324,
0.0350554623,
0.0317723826,
0.0463249125,
0.0042453995,
-0.0488204472,
0.0076494114,
0.0347557515,
-0.010842951,
0.0424991623,
0.0329382047,
0.0298044868,
-0.0025754713,
0.0140804481,
-0.0059000249,
0.0420891382,
-0.0307092592,
-0.0000048216,
-0.0268461145,
-0.0416170768,
0.0195446815,
0.0322008319,
0.0100190174,
-0.0087921927,
-0.0146007435,
-0.0272711925,
-0.0017576435,
-0.0438033268,
0.0439489074,
-0.0027489292,
-0.05414626,
-0.0062384834,
0.0334116593,
0.0045317719,
-0.0713953376,
-0.0537830368,
0.008127057,
0.0141065987,
0.0224568471,
-0.006864524,
0.0730550364,
0.0239125974,
0.0259557255,
-0.0075878007,
0.0139397187,
-0.0211729072,
0.0483120047,
0.019125687,
0.0263923071,
-0.0197598506,
-0.014821155,
0.0208780784,
0.0210977085,
-0.0247258451,
-0.0264847204,
0.0151143922,
0.0426717326,
0.016488146,
0.0113175837,
0.0582629964,
-0.0314644277,
0.0144440988,
-0.0283604208,
0.0078833038,
-0.0400430635,
0.0203086175,
0.0058125365,
0.0211266056,
-0.0374552272,
-0.0450888053,
0.0427116342,
0.0111386767,
0.0172437374,
-0.0180302951,
0.0079765199,
-0.0188843049,
-0.0159274731,
0.0313276052,
-0.0180959199,
-0.0453945585,
-0.04470101,
-0.0431217924,
-0.0764887854,
0.0196415689,
-0.0106537733,
0.0217568856,
-0.0275295619,
0.028080279,
0.0259343591,
-0.0004295501,
-0.0315165073,
-0.0091749048,
0.0087081175,
-0.0083386395,
-0.0453092977,
-0.0049264529,
-6.460402341e-33,
-0.0498428121,
-0.0486161187,
0.0075256908,
0.0225180574,
-0.0135766705,
-0.0184057672,
-0.0635351911,
0.0283774417,
-0.0098510785,
-0.0016243425,
-0.0069542956,
-0.0111577995,
0.0268526729,
-0.0412465818,
0.0223084521,
-0.0021618363,
0.0458809733,
-0.0021294493,
0.0200025942,
-0.03609078,
0.0108397873,
0.0210490171,
0.0176926311,
-0.0752363577,
0.040730454,
-0.014842445,
-0.0365393274,
-0.0182576142,
-0.0761938542,
0.0656511039,
-0.0333122537,
0.0180203393,
0.0011743507,
0.0133260386,
-0.0165563729,
0.0707969293,
-0.0528659821,
-0.0368785746,
0.0226156618,
0.0309231244,
-0.0040199826,
-0.0054652798,
0.0418292731,
-0.0184385572,
-0.0507923029,
0.0125983898,
0.0357486345,
-0.0281656347,
0.0239327103,
0.0381737165,
-0.0450553857,
0.0076681501,
0.0174472351,
-0.0339540914,
0.0451109,
0.0281967893,
-0.0183990318,
0.0014388582,
-0.0436144955,
0.0536118075,
-0.0000360534,
-0.0157496873,
0.0582399331,
0.0306188278,
0.0605377406,
0.0307104625,
0.0904583186,
-0.0195487347,
-0.0373637751,
-0.0130909011,
0.0472673848,
0.0097192554,
0.0626202896,
0.024475934,
0.0153593449,
-0.0121715069,
-0.0149200363,
0.0187449139,
0.089486219,
-0.0240424015,
0.0277090985,
0.0299017448,
-0.067160517,
-0.0144714881,
-0.004181901,
-0.0157001819,
-0.0421373919,
-0.0477627255,
0.0218950473,
-0.0240990911,
0.0230915993,
-0.0402167886,
0.0383046716,
-0.0336123295,
-0.0340063088,
-0.0347514674,
-0.0185169429,
0.0098390523,
0.0168719646,
0.0009424835,
-0.0331245698,
0.0070539685,
0.0427311584,
-0.0049471837,
0.0593442731,
0.0043084426,
-0.0298853721,
0.0085757431,
-0.0922934264,
0.0103967357,
-0.0051461421,
0.0011335863,
0.0378668867,
0.006120923,
0.0212463569,
-0.0090923905,
-0.0113820266,
-0.0245227683,
0.0389377251,
0.0365909562,
-0.108297646,
-0.0003083461,
-0.0648947507,
0.030421501,
-0.0160087552,
0.0036921902,
-0.053662613,
0.0392718203,
0.0409399495,
-0.0283251423,
-0.0113326646,
-0.0267804675,
2.987e-7,
-0.025151303,
0.0578099787,
0.023122102,
0.0669398457,
0.0230085459,
0.0107506895,
-0.0350950472,
0.0220780354,
0.0751467496,
-0.0091048907,
-0.0184558798,
0.0092016486,
0.0717264339,
0.0518297143,
-0.0810697749,
-0.0033273883,
-0.0984559357,
0.0035494394,
-0.0479371808,
0.0174763557,
-0.0150162596,
0.0816642269,
0.0190518498,
-0.0009542543,
-0.0131544378,
-0.014846677,
0.0228513293,
-0.0489491336,
0.0019044344,
0.0026333381,
-0.0068880888,
-0.0266158246,
-0.0027409722,
0.0126404287,
0.0205976646,
-0.0172654167,
-0.0119850989,
0.0192654897,
-0.013838145,
-0.0230897721,
0.0244674161,
0.0367362946,
-0.0179560445,
-0.0558946282,
0.036817804,
-0.007399973,
-0.0267866179,
-0.0256899577,
0.0392786637,
-0.0333692282,
0.0639087781,
-0.0238787625,
0.0064352397,
0.0249860715,
0.0003603993,
0.0008693181,
-0.0123346327,
-0.0254847035,
-0.0128450813,
-0.0190450158,
-0.0923919678,
-0.0641276762,
-0.023815399,
-0.0140036251,
-0.0014777466,
-0.0401206054,
-0.0006046616,
2.715597891e-34,
0.0064492454,
0.0184846632,
0.0014582108,
0.060528893,
0.036841616,
0.0033095195,
0.0232076254,
0.0491730981,
0.0432899185,
-0.0553417914,
-0.029435046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07490v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07490v1
|
Strategic Data Ordering: Enhancing Large Language Model Performance through Curriculum Learning
| 2024-05-13T06:09:10 | 2024-05-13T06:09:10 |
Jisu Kim, Juhwan Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The rapid advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs) has improved text
understanding and generation but poses challenges in computational resources.
This study proposes a curriculum learning-inspired, data-centric training
strategy that begins with simpler tasks and progresses to more complex ones,
using criteria such as prompt length, attention scores, and loss values to
structure the training data. Experiments with Mistral-7B (Jiang et al., 2023)
and Gemma-7B (Team et al., 2024) models demonstrate that curriculum learning
slightly improves performance compared to traditional random data shuffling.
Notably, we observed that sorting data based on our proposed attention criteria
generally led to better performance. This approach offers a sustainable method
to enhance LLM performance without increasing model size or dataset volume,
addressing scalability challenges in LLM training.
|
Strategic Data Ordering: Enhancing Large Language Model Performance through Curriculum Learning: The rapid advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs) has improved text
understanding and generation but poses challenges in computational resources.
This study proposes a curriculum learning-inspired, data-centric training
strategy that begins with simpler tasks and progresses to more complex ones,
using criteria such as prompt length, attention scores, and loss values to
structure the training data. Experiments with Mistral-7B (Jiang et al., 2023)
and Gemma-7B (Team et al., 2024) models demonstrate that curriculum learning
slightly improves performance compared to traditional random data shuffling.
Notably, we observed that sorting data based on our proposed attention criteria
generally led to better performance. This approach offers a sustainable method
to enhance LLM performance without increasing model size or dataset volume,
addressing scalability challenges in LLM training.
|
[
0.0465987697,
0.0375061817,
-0.004230055,
0.0537980534,
-0.0268773045,
0.019932555,
0.0316986255,
-0.0357507505,
-0.0188721493,
-0.0546532199,
-0.0266670026,
-0.0803908184,
0.0132853994,
0.0079051806,
0.0490713529,
-0.053348925,
0.0362178497,
-0.0864811167,
-0.0036592949,
0.0060916105,
-0.0188966859,
-0.0141822565,
-0.0036778459,
0.0147990547,
0.0254038982,
-0.015788639,
-0.0113006588,
0.0372246429,
0.0214727167,
-0.0404040031,
-0.0026373011,
0.0737008154,
0.036534857,
0.0658810884,
0.0000022304,
-0.0555027574,
-0.0139036123,
0.0064951917,
-0.0267411824,
0.036605496,
0.072513476,
0.0192390364,
-0.0053013372,
0.0433119908,
-0.0096699623,
0.0354961343,
0.0379264168,
0.004601107,
0.0758528784,
0.0606056973,
0.0081944605,
-0.0412927568,
0.0143094677,
-0.0519082621,
0.0233484358,
-0.0004166036,
0.0300053451,
0.0407643318,
0.0102601638,
0.0398233421,
-0.0217728391,
0.0359170362,
0.0312106013,
0.002495792,
0.0192907527,
0.0452342592,
-0.0395630747,
-0.019637458,
-0.0266371891,
0.0693319142,
-0.0040466483,
-0.0057855714,
-0.0076491223,
-0.0229927693,
0.0017225199,
-0.0327713154,
-0.0584950447,
0.059584938,
0.0132306153,
0.0089011453,
0.0576486886,
-0.0010129537,
0.0143668447,
-0.0144777279,
-0.0547450148,
0.0142189534,
0.0166567899,
-0.0555595569,
-0.0006582887,
-0.0091307312,
-0.0251030624,
-0.0373472162,
-0.0074196798,
0.0489052013,
-0.0033789936,
0.0271962434,
-0.0553087555,
-0.0313530564,
0.0222930536,
-0.030149851,
0.0750529021,
0.0321894214,
-0.0229423959,
0.0288204756,
0.011404342,
0.0784774423,
0.015096616,
0.0458192751,
-0.0646880269,
0.033733692,
-0.0150681818,
-0.0203009937,
-0.028421374,
-0.0013108624,
-0.0606314242,
-0.0074359984,
-0.0455601588,
0.0319154337,
0.0231092721,
-0.0205130503,
0.0791607946,
-0.0007117703,
-0.0396848321,
0.0142822191,
-0.0055297874,
0.0141191417,
0.0032350353,
0.007640752,
0.0236846935,
-0.0438026749,
-0.0166656971,
0.0155017301,
-0.0097072162,
-0.0256202053,
0.0058550136,
0.0379280932,
-0.0192951169,
-0.0395454541,
-0.057438273,
0.0084241778,
-0.0311220661,
-0.0725364685,
0.0220680535,
-0.0721774176,
0.0134715531,
0.0164466985,
-0.0055390019,
0.0025971835,
0.0051394468,
0.0121543668,
-0.04201084,
0.0035127359,
0.0227403622,
0.0315394551,
0.0308098644,
-0.0073074456,
0.02577704,
0.074244611,
0.0344944522,
0.0190161746,
-0.0093267644,
-0.0076665389,
-0.0178882014,
0.0370718688,
0.0093141021,
0.0109147215,
-0.0271892641,
0.0129940445,
0.0208348203,
0.0419903621,
0.0494231991,
0.0517733544,
-0.0389208905,
0.0189873502,
0.0859445855,
0.0218875818,
0.002019532,
-0.0227775741,
0.0373890586,
0.0121853603,
0.010639105,
0.0085703656,
-0.0474035144,
0.0137721561,
0.0402920358,
0.0178686753,
0.0334277228,
0.03407453,
-0.0113919685,
-0.0469843037,
-0.0167983416,
0.0042705517,
-0.0064924085,
0.0246318299,
0.0239685439,
-0.0110233491,
-0.0456871241,
0.0032163037,
0.0515785106,
-0.0424808525,
-0.0137657877,
-0.0347434245,
0.0018774081,
0.0955916941,
0.007811198,
-0.0306258313,
-0.0818918273,
0.0158237983,
0.0668484569,
0.029284928,
0.0272830371,
-0.0036495395,
-0.0045142947,
-0.0599932596,
-0.0091080265,
-0.0191173479,
-0.0026932389,
0.0291573424,
0.0142356846,
0.0051150918,
0.0134834936,
0.0064802771,
-0.0910036638,
0.0428810455,
-0.0671710446,
-0.054664325,
-0.0082666809,
0.0083919559,
0.0237547308,
-0.010115522,
0.0025236795,
0.0166840982,
0.0385902375,
-0.0419692956,
0.0622681901,
-0.0078129731,
-0.0803590715,
-0.0609944612,
0.0335172713,
0.0308634639,
-0.0102793686,
0.0269939825,
-0.0412787981,
-0.0355701782,
0.0093050683,
-0.0220712889,
0.0119506251,
-0.0374950096,
0.0425917171,
0.0013563521,
0.0058020144,
-0.0716993511,
0.0553236529,
-0.0274638366,
0.0078498861,
0.0542263873,
0.0328574255,
-0.0177893713,
-0.0586550571,
0.0033342817,
0.0202851463,
-0.0007100556,
0.0118179219,
-0.0232372098,
0.0285066515,
-0.0550660938,
-0.0354528725,
-0.0828483328,
0.0010359753,
-0.0289636161,
0.0064791762,
0.0170007236,
-0.000775142,
-0.0085567366,
0.009544679,
-0.0408039428,
-0.0164586771,
0.0292419121,
0.0183686577,
0.0140215391,
-0.0092888223,
-0.0412351191,
-0.0302794371,
-0.0298771523,
-0.0005195455,
0.0593066774,
-0.005283718,
0.0217001475,
-0.0786436126,
0.030196486,
-0.016059313,
-0.0045606042,
-0.016350463,
-0.0143145649,
-0.0036601494,
-0.0112725142,
0.0735727102,
0.078385964,
0.0051762778,
0.0319367051,
0.0627750084,
-0.0143829929,
-0.0339576229,
-0.0015003775,
-0.0060806125,
-0.0280771237,
-0.0293467194,
-0.0579807684,
-0.0175431613,
0.0519018658,
0.0073677702,
-0.0044982736,
-0.0439516753,
0.0000216433,
-0.0437292829,
-0.0444837175,
-0.0542833209,
-0.0174201615,
-0.0505447499,
-0.0008300196,
-0.04014064,
-0.0287938081,
0.0440958776,
-0.0387837477,
0.0053307544,
-0.0887474045,
-0.0008978378,
-0.0432429761,
0.027643837,
0.0241526663,
0.0299769808,
-0.0262068715,
-0.0135665433,
-0.0883025527,
0.0019286064,
0.0123686511,
-0.0243154187,
0.034849368,
-0.041356463,
-0.0087288003,
-0.0194803923,
-0.0298496969,
-0.0664454848,
-0.018262947,
0.0152389584,
0.0270814281,
0.0656436086,
0.0134667261,
-0.026842406,
0.0154753244,
0.0404175222,
0.0402619652,
-0.0428665057,
0.0002551647,
-0.0163286962,
0.0505354293,
0.0321986638,
0.0162547175,
0.0208724141,
-0.062141709,
0.0072604702,
0.0256256685,
0.0543438643,
-0.0259860046,
-0.0209830347,
0.0151321888,
0.0355257839,
-0.0232052114,
0.0012104876,
0.0370091647,
0.0401870422,
-0.0620597638,
-0.0344757289,
0.1239540204,
0.0170005448,
-0.0413440578,
-0.0013506626,
-0.0096016275,
0.0530638173,
0.0264729727,
0.0318759866,
-0.0353872068,
-0.0122690769,
0.010552139,
0.0560662821,
0.0023218461,
-0.0051199668,
-0.0421475843,
-0.1057098582,
0.033945892,
0.0290272459,
-0.0496803708,
-0.0100799007,
-0.0665562451,
-0.0278249234,
0.0028551209,
0.0430266038,
0.0470311306,
-0.0440417491,
0.012244273,
0.0618130378,
0.0091774818,
-0.0625659302,
-0.0159611646,
-0.0265684165,
0.0508532003,
0.0515791029,
0.005193457,
-0.0049675279,
0.0016594982,
0.02678065,
0.0251909234,
0.0074125174,
0.0091388561,
0.0335174948,
-0.0084510613,
0.0154640889,
-0.0107152015,
0.0290684458,
-0.0287660565,
-0.0132815465,
0.0213666931,
0.0800800398,
0.008001822,
-0.0131672937,
-0.0081036892,
0.0044546449,
0.0236764215,
0.0773347914,
0.0588269792,
-0.0424979106,
0.0008621426,
-0.0126356063,
-0.0026792078,
-0.0185597986,
-0.0108632371,
0.0443284921,
-0.0000681901,
-0.0441256016,
-0.0721255466,
-0.0507478155,
0.0205648746,
0.0609763674,
0.030257972,
0.0361575969,
0.008162356,
-0.0087984474,
-0.0570184924,
0.0269237049,
-0.029067941,
-0.0060567255,
-0.1123776808,
-0.0366386883,
-0.0098048272,
-0.0399404764,
-0.0255693458,
0.0256695133,
-0.1400953829,
-0.0821484253,
0.0251999497,
0.0518418998,
0.0220916588,
0.0572033562,
0.0457411148,
-0.052207496,
0.0389331207,
0.0121686459,
-0.0235162284,
0.0294485502,
-0.0037166891,
-0.0252224598,
-0.0023526649,
0.0027743331,
-0.0275645219,
0.0311575178,
0.0249305721,
0.0459596142,
0.0111759314,
0.0274849758,
0.0111429282,
0.0408659764,
0.0263807755,
-0.0237464532,
-0.0392389372,
-0.0646298304,
0.0601863451,
-0.0208022781,
-0.0020354786,
-0.0210285336,
0.0123761985,
0.016291786,
0.0168636423,
-0.0140239084,
-0.0295711253,
0.0347401761,
-0.0135502936,
-0.0514766611,
0.0216016062,
-0.0428493917,
0.0263260622,
0.0519130528,
0.0093052071,
-0.0371279828,
0.0226321165,
-0.0183268599,
0.0319332443,
-0.0096902819,
0.0475005955,
0.0001567605,
-0.0091137355,
-0.0227606148,
0.0575490966,
-0.0651045293,
-0.0519441441,
-0.0290881414,
-0.0073832832,
0.0426722653,
-0.0117004383,
0.0630410686,
-0.0238094628,
0.0046758503,
-0.0138001265,
0.0031916881,
-0.0010685835,
-0.0256287698,
0.0028883547,
0.0157362223,
-0.0060852906,
-0.0053230221,
0.0875475034,
0.0488419458,
-0.0042355321,
0.001845774,
0.010103737,
-0.029039029,
-0.0246930495,
0.0134356944,
0.004087172,
-0.0335304327,
0.0075815828,
-0.0238915682,
-0.0469638892,
0.0016855064,
0.001330196,
-0.0057841376,
-0.0355421267,
0.0415034592,
0.0512118414,
-0.0306218602,
0.0005025284,
-0.0259145424,
0.0027344136,
-0.0102942791,
-0.0630258843,
-0.0155293327,
-6.97671399e-33,
-0.0213135779,
0.015006802,
0.0560848787,
-0.014936408,
-0.0238976814,
0.0185503326,
-0.0393012613,
-0.0062160366,
0.0151815927,
-0.0220357887,
-0.02404093,
0.0107524516,
0.0199158322,
0.0368542485,
0.0043071262,
-0.0008451423,
0.0439634398,
-0.0113464911,
-0.0286982171,
0.0491250753,
0.0242518764,
0.0386513695,
0.0584403686,
-0.016326895,
0.0101613523,
0.0070102541,
0.043014925,
0.000594363,
-0.0173477642,
0.0429414026,
-0.02296835,
0.0344798416,
0.028311938,
-0.0630735531,
-0.0295113977,
0.0154226376,
-0.0462267064,
-0.0197029281,
0.0164288152,
0.0150547717,
-0.0131112477,
-0.0541158803,
0.0270094909,
-0.0052470616,
-0.0194351505,
-0.0145190712,
0.0093759401,
-0.0240436904,
-0.0625085086,
0.0019974879,
-0.0680340379,
0.0135610448,
-0.0027748961,
-0.0060410057,
0.0186469927,
0.0494022667,
-0.0203993563,
0.0258807875,
-0.0437583774,
0.0493835881,
0.0526562482,
0.0619414113,
0.0557850562,
0.082729727,
0.000075504,
0.0576765276,
0.0308585819,
0.0199998822,
0.0023672627,
-0.0118029471,
0.0329185501,
0.0396635197,
0.0082781939,
0.0219769105,
0.0110366102,
-0.008156375,
-0.0970856696,
0.0161445457,
0.0119871097,
-0.0055982219,
0.0639636889,
-0.031836357,
-0.0353279337,
-0.0485011786,
-0.0203798022,
0.0055011213,
-0.0305655356,
0.0137579236,
0.0552298762,
0.0069076936,
-0.0370103344,
-0.0220976342,
0.0630361363,
-0.03209332,
-0.0334798098,
0.0571791418,
-0.0033891532,
0.0234175455,
-0.0177281164,
0.055292882,
-0.1120172366,
-0.0257232841,
0.0361037813,
-0.0098044686,
-0.0010322328,
0.0075782686,
0.0345772393,
0.0044111041,
-0.0367608368,
-0.013685124,
-0.0418143533,
0.0444347598,
0.0069112228,
0.0197901018,
0.030771669,
-0.0126294279,
0.0074775354,
0.0560079217,
0.0385341085,
-0.0561724342,
-0.0309683736,
-0.0131156649,
-0.0053756093,
0.0162667446,
-0.0192394648,
0.0175775569,
-0.0225907322,
0.0155661795,
0.0313103683,
-0.0518828258,
-0.0194244012,
0.0051170262,
2.864e-7,
0.0335201025,
0.0737499073,
-0.0247410685,
0.0122474618,
0.0130031453,
-0.0142032849,
-0.0290477891,
0.0094250133,
0.0420025662,
0.0236645807,
0.0203081593,
0.04844651,
0.0360339396,
-0.0021311131,
-0.0694364533,
-0.0341163017,
-0.0708360747,
0.0111383321,
-0.0543544479,
-0.0254818499,
0.0164928734,
0.1048019528,
-0.0259224251,
-0.0297393911,
-0.0050059119,
0.0066353474,
0.0447771326,
-0.0301588215,
0.0124800652,
0.0111205,
0.0144050037,
-0.0194556415,
-0.0040918374,
0.0015485424,
-0.0070661465,
-0.0016482539,
-0.0362708978,
0.0439411774,
-0.000854398,
-0.0149010541,
0.0230983961,
0.0261618085,
-0.0252939742,
-0.091475524,
0.0585915782,
-0.0745304525,
-0.0100083807,
0.0144045418,
-0.0106027434,
-0.0087686079,
-0.0181587804,
-0.0323453844,
-0.0150111094,
0.015550172,
0.0077006714,
-0.0395425148,
0.0155448625,
-0.0451944582,
-0.0033087921,
0.0117713558,
-0.0440145321,
-0.0676802173,
-0.0572424158,
-0.0167921633,
-0.0045230347,
-0.0407232121,
-0.0045540403,
3.109311587e-34,
0.035531763,
-0.0171165988,
0.0381623022,
-0.0058228984,
0.0106492927,
-0.0314061865,
0.0300320853,
0.0219701305,
-0.0042335391,
-0.1031726524,
-0.0445841178
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07468v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07468v1
|
Evaluating large language models in medical applications: a survey
| 2024-05-13T05:08:33 | 2024-05-13T05:08:33 |
Xiaolan Chen, Jiayang Xiang, Shanfu Lu, Yexin Liu, Mingguang He, Danli Shi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have emerged as powerful tools with
transformative potential across numerous domains, including healthcare and
medicine. In the medical domain, LLMs hold promise for tasks ranging from
clinical decision support to patient education. However, evaluating the
performance of LLMs in medical contexts presents unique challenges due to the
complex and critical nature of medical information. This paper provides a
comprehensive overview of the landscape of medical LLM evaluation, synthesizing
insights from existing studies and highlighting evaluation data sources, task
scenarios, and evaluation methods. Additionally, it identifies key challenges
and opportunities in medical LLM evaluation, emphasizing the need for continued
research and innovation to ensure the responsible integration of LLMs into
clinical practice.
|
Evaluating large language models in medical applications: a survey: Large language models (LLMs) have emerged as powerful tools with
transformative potential across numerous domains, including healthcare and
medicine. In the medical domain, LLMs hold promise for tasks ranging from
clinical decision support to patient education. However, evaluating the
performance of LLMs in medical contexts presents unique challenges due to the
complex and critical nature of medical information. This paper provides a
comprehensive overview of the landscape of medical LLM evaluation, synthesizing
insights from existing studies and highlighting evaluation data sources, task
scenarios, and evaluation methods. Additionally, it identifies key challenges
and opportunities in medical LLM evaluation, emphasizing the need for continued
research and innovation to ensure the responsible integration of LLMs into
clinical practice.
|
[
0.0321960188,
0.0434156284,
-0.0010816314,
-0.0194734391,
-0.0309378803,
0.0399446636,
0.0068472638,
0.0361173451,
0.013638448,
-0.0038095822,
-0.01043473,
-0.0848374143,
0.0243852586,
0.0178230591,
-0.0008752643,
-0.0075543728,
0.0102644563,
-0.0087231314,
0.0244813804,
-0.0006301189,
-0.0200203955,
0.0016062014,
-0.0146103697,
0.0599940494,
0.0254281498,
0.0006279557,
0.0437372774,
-0.0186635535,
-0.0084230034,
-0.0846921206,
-0.0511101335,
0.0269682705,
-0.0152561674,
0.0055506295,
0.0000019061,
-0.0742445588,
-0.0191364344,
0.0399531946,
-0.0560297556,
-0.0117627634,
0.075947538,
-0.0378152169,
-0.0273728166,
0.0044114599,
-0.0146953054,
-0.0203090347,
0.0384594537,
-0.0079541849,
0.0251710638,
0.0327004418,
-0.0115971398,
0.0034113096,
0.0145216566,
-0.034801051,
-0.0045688446,
-0.024828149,
0.0506454445,
0.0296171028,
0.0555631779,
-0.0205935128,
0.0140560018,
0.049377393,
-0.0182605311,
0.0046336236,
-0.0159376096,
0.0209315941,
-0.0041501815,
-0.0177056957,
0.0054407241,
0.0281172842,
0.0066843829,
0.0166873373,
0.0168513935,
0.0021209165,
-0.0201073121,
0.0072200089,
-0.0469066836,
0.006980279,
0.0035377243,
-0.000872815,
0.0152206263,
-0.0115400059,
0.047282476,
0.0024074165,
-0.0446632653,
0.0299063157,
0.0225714967,
-0.0145522011,
0.0183085483,
-0.0158769116,
-0.0054598181,
-0.0318135247,
0.0303877443,
0.0369393788,
-0.068236351,
0.0207258314,
0.0089974385,
-0.0241231583,
0.1012288332,
-0.0928667709,
0.056841217,
-0.018376397,
0.0176049378,
0.056322325,
-0.0070789014,
0.0122554665,
-0.0235900693,
0.0233650245,
-0.0465856567,
0.0047906106,
-0.0365671888,
0.0088052433,
0.0156667829,
0.0098904576,
-0.0038883849,
0.0058412547,
-0.1030359864,
-0.0017449436,
-0.0192380603,
0.0453567542,
0.0178303216,
0.0102934819,
0.0040670568,
-0.018776089,
-0.0301388837,
0.0022732851,
0.0279959906,
0.0238599684,
-0.0344961658,
-0.0335634761,
0.0648736432,
0.0180948749,
-0.0221719649,
-0.0007715096,
0.0160799846,
0.0913496837,
0.0384228975,
0.0076432768,
-0.0078004682,
-0.0283296499,
-0.0482721254,
-0.0466793105,
-0.0202920046,
-0.0818216726,
0.0076183337,
0.0312160347,
0.0152677689,
-0.0613027811,
0.0066764154,
-0.0036308193,
-0.0412915461,
0.0667284504,
-0.0453908592,
0.0215297509,
0.0226187538,
0.0334461927,
0.0298017673,
0.048631575,
0.0395420231,
-0.0356472954,
-0.0049830964,
-0.0310050845,
-0.0060280343,
0.0327949375,
-0.0104471361,
-0.0042662215,
-0.0428937376,
0.0321404822,
0.0258080289,
0.0760697424,
-0.0640674233,
0.0741060898,
0.02249307,
-0.0034552494,
0.0355627872,
0.0695214793,
0.0547042377,
-0.0098240878,
0.0175283533,
-0.0338246338,
-0.0015061119,
-0.0405499116,
0.0049171704,
-0.0206430182,
0.0005173474,
-0.0161848608,
-0.0118763614,
0.0198910236,
-0.0229172651,
-0.0346102454,
-0.0662477911,
-0.0425408557,
-0.0068625323,
0.0105786361,
0.0578675419,
-0.0505982637,
-0.0079225274,
0.0781949461,
0.0374609232,
-0.0280582625,
-0.0017235785,
-0.0586153939,
-0.0258397795,
0.0914300755,
0.0606661178,
-0.0471261293,
-0.0237055812,
-0.0109358663,
0.0001282563,
0.006719938,
0.0095519405,
-0.0063202474,
-0.0029613187,
-0.0238922313,
-0.0063565625,
0.0683601424,
0.0098350598,
-0.0342949778,
-0.0035530534,
0.0336552635,
-0.0226300675,
-0.0410218909,
-0.0679905713,
0.0296570025,
-0.0748713985,
0.0022444893,
0.0016019556,
-0.0053488668,
0.0303839687,
0.0353899002,
-0.0085951118,
0.0494144075,
0.0405632593,
-0.0454911962,
-0.0055822134,
-0.0093192812,
0.0084121879,
0.0241203308,
0.0298790056,
-0.0134029873,
0.012661742,
-0.041919902,
-0.0108052166,
-0.0184649788,
-0.0156640839,
-0.0529461019,
0.0383142047,
0.0116073526,
0.0404300913,
0.0008757803,
0.0002060805,
-0.066208452,
0.0013768129,
-0.0275464375,
0.0400320552,
0.0249434151,
-0.0410460308,
0.0114542088,
-0.0064671002,
-0.0325666852,
0.0385880694,
-0.0066390811,
0.0230198372,
-0.0158832334,
0.0106572257,
-0.0248383675,
-0.0548736453,
-0.0889556631,
-0.0215551108,
0.0247963425,
0.0430283546,
0.021528177,
0.0087752435,
0.0015988706,
0.0142957764,
-0.0524633303,
-0.0229737777,
0.0319799557,
0.0139752356,
0.0043801204,
0.0344423987,
-0.0345179327,
-0.0246606562,
-0.0160310641,
-0.028346464,
0.041678153,
-0.0078937281,
-0.0128450636,
-0.0155722974,
0.0025118808,
-0.0427191183,
-0.0371176526,
0.0158605054,
-0.0104018105,
0.0242797732,
-0.012013766,
0.0148925725,
0.0083459886,
-0.0160891991,
0.0222460888,
0.0525386035,
-0.0120949177,
-0.0116689783,
-0.0358265042,
-0.0113884145,
-0.0374038443,
-0.0298580527,
-0.0710177124,
-0.0129072126,
0.0528841726,
-0.0027891949,
0.0262421276,
-0.0132997967,
-0.0229454357,
-0.0901085362,
0.0228710845,
-0.0564987287,
0.0274404678,
-0.0341672599,
0.0613455251,
0.0161238983,
-0.0401847474,
0.0825224891,
-0.0402038507,
0.0497003645,
-0.0639166087,
-0.0454695001,
-0.0470901541,
0.0036164464,
-0.0410588235,
0.0236379281,
-0.0060933069,
-0.0113253361,
0.0186950732,
-0.0037843853,
-0.0156621337,
-0.0811169371,
0.1096255407,
-0.0278659798,
0.0268864427,
0.0101333419,
-0.0101274289,
-0.0237277299,
0.0049531558,
-0.0311641749,
0.0107077267,
0.0372720808,
0.0277383141,
-0.0422827937,
0.059812367,
0.01163923,
0.0449696705,
0.0335222892,
-0.0145818954,
0.0204808768,
-0.0226944443,
-0.010522888,
0.0159537606,
0.0341359153,
-0.0178028829,
0.0517522171,
0.0437718742,
0.0016287375,
0.0257442798,
-0.0120906057,
0.005557674,
0.0282073449,
-0.041527424,
0.0065502715,
0.0390734076,
0.0202839393,
-0.0421585813,
0.0177860986,
0.1098688394,
0.0415185541,
-0.0621593036,
0.0234599262,
-0.021361826,
-0.035372477,
-0.0159202069,
-0.0031784594,
-0.0676414147,
-0.0061639487,
-0.0202456601,
0.0302297212,
-0.0167051591,
-0.0179450363,
0.0336848684,
-0.0343008898,
0.0385594293,
0.0186578352,
-0.0269742198,
-0.0220707487,
-0.0435717404,
0.0210754238,
-0.0150237698,
0.0114969341,
-0.0125090349,
-0.0277192052,
-0.0391392596,
-0.0009088895,
-0.0956739113,
-0.1228767335,
0.04486968,
-0.0233168975,
0.0659375712,
0.0542099848,
0.0121489856,
-0.0330300555,
-0.0074523976,
0.000058102,
0.011237666,
-0.010557238,
-0.0015496255,
0.0436896086,
0.0478222594,
-0.0095273387,
-0.0426651388,
-0.0219292976,
-0.0466818027,
-0.002382311,
-0.0159039367,
0.0999246389,
-0.0531374477,
-0.0054667126,
-0.0163761396,
0.0224727113,
0.0283263363,
0.0571189895,
0.0196290631,
-0.0278822482,
-0.0074284957,
0.0005759848,
0.0247357227,
0.0230876207,
-0.035772521,
0.0457865372,
-0.0244823322,
-0.0065396004,
-0.0277090818,
0.0077226367,
0.0495082289,
-0.0328274593,
0.0162886549,
0.0643786415,
0.0338215232,
-0.0224090219,
-0.0459459014,
0.0317316242,
0.0308339838,
0.0733102635,
-0.072584793,
-0.0267772768,
0.0402383059,
0.0104744965,
0.0023068534,
0.0188181344,
-0.02149955,
-0.0074251401,
0.0136987399,
0.0213034023,
0.0208637994,
-0.0414890274,
-0.0240447633,
-0.0394435152,
0.027707858,
0.0251896791,
-0.0349623561,
-0.0204042103,
-0.0169003457,
0.0194763485,
-0.0044691176,
0.012170976,
-0.0123185795,
0.0213931985,
0.0069752084,
0.014630584,
-0.0052328976,
-0.029161863,
0.0082100416,
0.0574866123,
0.0188633054,
-0.032720916,
-0.0345228426,
0.0038863539,
0.0057960986,
-0.0508564673,
0.0223797504,
-0.0181616861,
-0.0262494683,
0.0355888121,
-0.0105094137,
-0.0034733382,
0.0127103403,
-0.0590518862,
-0.0560556352,
-0.0573230721,
0.0963028669,
-0.0079188794,
0.0004543862,
0.0759687349,
-0.0088703353,
0.005109211,
0.0150408503,
-0.0361722112,
0.0043034363,
-0.0069187325,
0.0582192317,
-0.0213901047,
0.0335137062,
0.0002056823,
0.073016502,
-0.0025403393,
-0.0568735972,
-0.0148578929,
0.028701609,
0.0589550734,
0.0296533722,
0.0576872826,
-0.034077771,
0.0090188915,
-0.0618356839,
0.0014243656,
-0.0315378979,
0.0258346926,
0.0367837809,
0.0202696864,
-0.0090037128,
-0.0151326703,
0.0903895125,
0.0132134929,
0.0161525309,
-0.0238078274,
-0.044635348,
-0.0243818928,
-0.0311094746,
0.0071566417,
-0.0153806014,
-0.1030414402,
0.0067499401,
-0.0955101028,
-0.0605412535,
0.0124613028,
-0.0040866141,
-0.0218967218,
-0.0381516032,
0.0321342945,
0.0452615432,
0.0161072947,
0.002728533,
-0.0469704494,
0.0370777659,
-0.0168751422,
-0.0142074069,
0.0394572951,
-5.513035077e-33,
0.0248555988,
-0.0397550724,
0.0270179864,
-0.0335836709,
0.0017281569,
0.0325066,
-0.0223572683,
0.024284618,
0.0045330082,
0.0355005674,
-0.0023575411,
-0.014062006,
0.0016035197,
0.0277109183,
0.0234116148,
-0.0251997784,
-0.0064653503,
0.0124856941,
-0.0053883097,
0.0142672528,
-0.0188838094,
0.0131517388,
0.0409839414,
-0.089358896,
0.028637765,
0.0102860816,
0.0246600024,
-0.0008550558,
-0.018478943,
0.0957264379,
-0.0301782694,
0.0397184379,
0.0379754901,
-0.045509886,
-0.0058864369,
-0.0194676407,
-0.0257324129,
0.0127249714,
0.0222913101,
-0.0246534981,
-0.0149807055,
-0.0211231001,
0.0431076512,
-0.0016352192,
-0.0595421828,
0.0079945335,
-0.0161593799,
-0.0581322052,
-0.0319821946,
-0.0086995196,
-0.028352499,
0.0633260459,
0.0138807474,
0.0118533401,
0.002972635,
-0.018113954,
-0.0557085425,
0.0357148685,
-0.0198810603,
0.0052940487,
0.0546814911,
0.0260886513,
0.0399028733,
-0.0131261796,
-0.0323509015,
0.0451887511,
-0.0099427765,
0.00318736,
-0.0329302326,
0.0007882872,
-0.0306071434,
0.0463433675,
0.0593705103,
0.0216360372,
-0.0302245393,
-0.0233013406,
-0.0960141197,
0.0433531068,
-0.0619533211,
0.0483934134,
0.0349745303,
-0.0234222393,
-0.0444982462,
-0.0303156544,
-0.0471092053,
0.0279072747,
-0.0216898937,
-0.0341691673,
0.0302972514,
-0.0240764618,
0.0071567292,
0.0458113253,
0.0182384867,
-0.0385048278,
-0.0363205224,
-0.0337134488,
0.0409033112,
0.031877812,
-0.0246780273,
0.0142719829,
-0.0604046583,
0.0017010318,
-0.0031994155,
-0.0127711985,
0.0302757695,
-0.0055834651,
-0.0102396794,
-0.0355567932,
-0.0488145091,
0.0105160167,
0.0280133728,
-0.0239812862,
-0.0062395507,
0.0180915315,
0.0350741856,
0.0097893039,
0.0213670824,
0.0498623028,
-0.0010952837,
-0.0224573817,
-0.020284446,
-0.0401946791,
-0.00123285,
0.0114430273,
-0.0415155739,
0.0087546278,
-0.0651461929,
0.0451760143,
0.0604199022,
-0.0033353209,
-0.002401053,
-0.0227240622,
2.61e-7,
0.1140352339,
0.0696244314,
-0.0330862105,
-0.0061712419,
0.031498909,
-0.0113668106,
-0.0289474782,
-0.0125560407,
-0.0037939912,
-0.0153065454,
0.0306373034,
-0.0144441975,
0.0660665631,
0.0459938049,
-0.0333161578,
-0.021106109,
-0.0779748112,
-0.0093405629,
-0.0439094566,
-0.0160283316,
0.0431614444,
0.0648416504,
-0.0463466048,
-0.032957267,
-0.0006672326,
-0.0189104676,
0.020768851,
-0.0780191869,
-0.0182372537,
0.0471195839,
0.0307576768,
-0.0149330907,
0.0383780226,
0.0499477051,
-0.0179417562,
-0.0201469772,
-0.0098178368,
0.1056442782,
-0.0524706915,
0.0464968942,
0.0353190675,
-0.028851755,
0.0263522044,
-0.0506903976,
0.0353507474,
-0.0454433374,
-0.0447867997,
-0.0304971952,
0.0077341278,
-0.0271502323,
0.0964602232,
-0.0216946956,
-0.0368521549,
0.033517722,
0.0334830806,
0.0171193779,
-0.0382630192,
-0.0294822119,
-0.0107944366,
0.0331608169,
-0.0208309982,
-0.0526397601,
0.0366745181,
-0.0286441389,
-0.0221947897,
-0.0790213123,
0.0404949076,
2.382448788e-34,
0.0376725756,
0.0147673888,
0.0043684496,
0.0186891612,
0.0378444828,
0.0053114779,
-0.0084188469,
0.0204748921,
-0.0197966285,
-0.081324771,
0.0439443551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07467v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07467v1
|
MCS-SQL: Leveraging Multiple Prompts and Multiple-Choice Selection For Text-to-SQL Generation
| 2024-05-13T04:59:32 | 2024-05-13T04:59:32 |
Dongjun Lee, Choongwon Park, Jaehyuk Kim, Heesoo Park
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have enabled in-context
learning (ICL)-based methods that significantly outperform fine-tuning
approaches for text-to-SQL tasks. However, their performance is still
considerably lower than that of human experts on benchmarks that include
complex schemas and queries, such as BIRD. This study considers the sensitivity
of LLMs to the prompts and introduces a novel approach that leverages multiple
prompts to explore a broader search space for possible answers and effectively
aggregate them. Specifically, we robustly refine the database schema through
schema linking using multiple prompts. Thereafter, we generate various
candidate SQL queries based on the refined schema and diverse prompts. Finally,
the candidate queries are filtered based on their confidence scores, and the
optimal query is obtained through a multiple-choice selection that is presented
to the LLM. When evaluated on the BIRD and Spider benchmarks, the proposed
method achieved execution accuracies of 65.5\% and 89.6\%, respectively,
significantly outperforming previous ICL-based methods. Moreover, we
established a new SOTA performance on the BIRD in terms of both the accuracy
and efficiency of the generated queries.
|
MCS-SQL: Leveraging Multiple Prompts and Multiple-Choice Selection For Text-to-SQL Generation: Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have enabled in-context
learning (ICL)-based methods that significantly outperform fine-tuning
approaches for text-to-SQL tasks. However, their performance is still
considerably lower than that of human experts on benchmarks that include
complex schemas and queries, such as BIRD. This study considers the sensitivity
of LLMs to the prompts and introduces a novel approach that leverages multiple
prompts to explore a broader search space for possible answers and effectively
aggregate them. Specifically, we robustly refine the database schema through
schema linking using multiple prompts. Thereafter, we generate various
candidate SQL queries based on the refined schema and diverse prompts. Finally,
the candidate queries are filtered based on their confidence scores, and the
optimal query is obtained through a multiple-choice selection that is presented
to the LLM. When evaluated on the BIRD and Spider benchmarks, the proposed
method achieved execution accuracies of 65.5\% and 89.6\%, respectively,
significantly outperforming previous ICL-based methods. Moreover, we
established a new SOTA performance on the BIRD in terms of both the accuracy
and efficiency of the generated queries.
|
[
0.0199573822,
0.050075531,
-0.016605949,
0.0030557006,
-0.0321391039,
0.0127393873,
-0.0161803123,
0.0001683752,
0.0226281639,
-0.0552400462,
-0.0028197474,
-0.0300743785,
-0.0304764528,
0.0033377844,
0.038424246,
-0.0210376792,
0.0296112988,
-0.0337675922,
-0.0334754065,
0.0076909903,
-0.0506309457,
0.0320523158,
0.0280402098,
-0.0121446969,
-0.0111594163,
0.0008344671,
-0.0339059681,
0.0304912869,
-0.0286351461,
-0.0461035706,
-0.0220633578,
0.0636639073,
0.0215793476,
0.0232591238,
0.0000022903,
-0.0793043897,
-0.0704955161,
0.0159358941,
-0.0609074235,
0.0120574525,
0.033808019,
0.0094495295,
0.0299767796,
0.0537897535,
-0.0335299969,
0.0159065146,
0.0264035389,
-0.0057770647,
0.0463984385,
0.0626445487,
-0.0004976532,
-0.0539056696,
-0.0100735454,
0.0013615642,
0.0396063477,
-0.0716780275,
0.0094848685,
0.0370806307,
0.060035333,
0.011198964,
0.0050565479,
0.0270502344,
0.0028627939,
-0.0345498174,
-0.0028402279,
0.0018000253,
-0.0157614965,
0.0121758822,
0.0015975239,
0.0557187684,
-0.0142426789,
-0.0177907646,
-0.0094204834,
0.0013545383,
-0.0016924805,
0.0091176508,
0.0016496729,
0.028488677,
-0.0126879867,
0.0094379224,
-0.0216607004,
-0.0221016724,
0.0100987311,
0.0088139353,
-0.0738479495,
0.0248067416,
0.0048684976,
-0.0274004526,
0.0573916957,
-0.0370131731,
-0.0165801831,
-0.0315066911,
0.0282371808,
0.054068692,
-0.1258479804,
0.029894365,
-0.0424772128,
-0.0149354525,
0.0281014647,
-0.0366339348,
0.0421386845,
0.0358547382,
0.0228935964,
0.0540041402,
-0.0050189146,
0.0134288529,
0.0153835546,
-0.0010358779,
-0.0659030676,
-0.037590012,
-0.0703841075,
0.0088571217,
-0.0439684838,
0.0531205311,
-0.1127951294,
-0.0250090323,
-0.0404571109,
0.048331961,
0.0299965441,
0.0425815433,
0.0118636731,
0.0274460185,
-0.0171241891,
-0.001815456,
-0.0602611452,
-0.0205091406,
0.0151787773,
-0.0068369564,
0.0060084197,
-0.0616378672,
-0.0035590858,
0.0047069085,
0.0120006688,
-0.0332094729,
0.020373363,
0.0658671185,
-0.0397050641,
-0.0056274766,
-0.0755096301,
-0.0696322098,
-0.029126253,
-0.0228064265,
-0.0364983343,
-0.0230071303,
0.0594126508,
0.0091479514,
-0.0328571498,
-0.0147897592,
0.0135271708,
0.0602692924,
0.0176568758,
0.0750716627,
-0.0205328073,
0.023388505,
0.0515825748,
-0.0276839845,
0.0091648605,
0.0880680382,
-0.0175613463,
0.0502902009,
0.0045683314,
-0.0043894746,
-0.0049925293,
0.0110383518,
0.0157503523,
0.0346292146,
-0.0497926958,
0.0865253434,
0.0376726091,
0.0543213561,
-0.0241515264,
0.0721491799,
0.0098311277,
0.0137365218,
0.0630138367,
0.0018884847,
0.0341511369,
-0.0099321203,
0.0480746031,
0.0268545412,
0.0110753085,
-0.043336682,
-0.0395516157,
0.0035191628,
-0.0528553799,
0.0383197702,
0.0169282667,
0.0104217483,
0.001372482,
-0.0413758941,
0.0057374844,
-0.0078164842,
-0.0468497761,
0.0601385348,
0.0136541994,
-0.0185161866,
-0.0509978756,
0.0230008699,
-0.0085410718,
-0.0265108179,
0.0074810153,
-0.0009846133,
0.0056818696,
0.0858126357,
0.0113290101,
-0.0480319671,
-0.0088681672,
-0.0198399164,
0.0057507097,
0.0314409286,
0.0251697376,
-0.0370435268,
-0.0193296652,
-0.0229975674,
-0.0297470093,
0.0435926728,
0.0258375518,
-0.0180495977,
0.0334748812,
0.0043650926,
0.028126331,
-0.0307588838,
-0.041273579,
0.035177689,
-0.029388519,
-0.0455668196,
0.0319695324,
-0.003857363,
0.0159211531,
0.0334903039,
-0.0270932708,
0.0535300486,
0.0263992511,
0.0084675597,
-0.0476081856,
-0.0549816303,
-0.0092280162,
-0.0114259319,
0.0224419739,
0.0134792086,
-0.0149272839,
-0.0535209142,
-0.0385565534,
-0.0440226905,
-0.0495597012,
-0.0230825823,
0.0052509448,
-0.0441408157,
0.0266478937,
-0.0008688169,
-0.0403165221,
-0.0963715687,
0.0711778775,
0.0242114794,
0.0006440104,
0.0287038889,
-0.0164075624,
0.0284298267,
-0.0890280828,
0.0160566214,
0.0047665155,
0.0069360649,
0.0428454354,
-0.0182151124,
0.0250367578,
-0.0715458319,
-0.0212562811,
-0.0789550841,
0.0210653096,
-0.0078683654,
0.014901544,
0.0101473983,
0.0180881824,
-0.0179853812,
-0.0046578296,
-0.0370177552,
-0.0178823788,
-0.0044669001,
0.0128606474,
0.01189081,
0.0229626335,
-0.0020495974,
-0.0256214403,
-0.0199448522,
-0.0357325822,
0.066319488,
-0.0160569772,
-0.0073882174,
0.0037586873,
0.0330262631,
-0.016503334,
-0.0047831396,
0.0197450854,
0.0375587307,
-0.0026389705,
-0.0477640182,
-0.0153110791,
0.0502444617,
0.0400892608,
-0.038398575,
0.0073885471,
-0.0142835919,
-0.0413605459,
0.0116884569,
-0.0132826315,
-0.0300823692,
-0.0037202167,
-0.0327435769,
0.0503156185,
-0.0208324548,
0.0093709826,
-0.0221966989,
-0.0342624485,
0.0157125331,
0.035591878,
-0.0039449981,
-0.0860843062,
0.0154541554,
0.0422964357,
0.0420381241,
0.0074975626,
-0.0283681955,
0.05181548,
-0.02444892,
0.0232985225,
-0.0517447814,
0.0081218565,
-0.0551522337,
0.058705017,
-0.0115056662,
0.0337281898,
-0.0057233931,
-0.0302460957,
-0.0475442596,
-0.0554099828,
0.0224506669,
-0.0408707336,
0.0846072361,
-0.0505474322,
0.0306632575,
-0.0017169629,
-0.012899112,
-0.0374741815,
0.012259067,
-0.0348978788,
0.0348387808,
0.0690101087,
0.0081016067,
-0.0022679861,
-0.0070181559,
0.0196653921,
0.0032010896,
-0.0102509782,
-0.0292120259,
0.0031655307,
-0.0148188025,
0.0224710461,
0.0300776493,
0.0043497966,
-0.0107233534,
0.0570267141,
0.0192687996,
0.0390633605,
-0.0490105003,
0.0155720869,
0.0293913912,
-0.0159185678,
-0.0286451485,
-0.0051582754,
0.0561116301,
-0.0239347015,
-0.0416218527,
-0.0020036444,
0.0874674469,
0.0370693579,
0.0110564614,
-0.0069813333,
0.0339959748,
0.0109214745,
0.0331809223,
0.0703325048,
-0.0899480283,
-0.0434229076,
-0.0164741743,
0.0249580126,
0.0296015553,
-0.0581522398,
-0.0255613495,
-0.162465021,
0.0344872624,
-0.025147438,
-0.0746332705,
-0.0025913848,
-0.0292387269,
-0.0330749676,
-0.0268099234,
0.0140832746,
0.0722666159,
-0.0258947462,
0.0108543951,
0.0116823157,
0.0473023765,
-0.0652365386,
0.0060141734,
-0.0458660647,
-0.0010334512,
0.031795755,
0.0022246861,
0.0422958806,
-0.0052078045,
0.0268425308,
-0.0484555587,
0.0244270936,
-0.0441326648,
0.0636741892,
0.0057924278,
0.0161512252,
0.0167926047,
0.0071974061,
-0.0222087968,
0.0161211286,
0.0246450566,
0.10776411,
-0.0322762392,
0.0200074166,
-0.01513498,
-0.0457830913,
0.0244673938,
0.0503619798,
-0.013121211,
-0.0322874971,
-0.0492978431,
-0.0153820682,
-0.0304196142,
-0.046480421,
0.0273876432,
0.0586166829,
-0.0391693562,
-0.0356345959,
-0.0342628248,
-0.0123381056,
0.0686700568,
0.0606417656,
0.0095918141,
0.0483021699,
0.016504081,
0.0088637276,
-0.0281778257,
-0.0231353529,
-0.0480554998,
0.0169580169,
-0.0566654392,
0.0135370251,
0.0422699898,
-0.0509559326,
-0.0298332181,
-0.0237552859,
-0.0319353864,
-0.0376628749,
-0.0114726182,
0.0157864597,
0.0197695922,
0.0080740368,
0.0137510179,
-0.0397930592,
0.0487470962,
0.0556034148,
-0.0258286074,
-0.0273291692,
-0.0240540151,
0.0173659567,
-0.0326733552,
0.0366197824,
-0.0427941643,
0.0119659547,
-0.0026403426,
0.016244363,
-0.0070578102,
-0.0068611712,
0.0692572594,
0.0699106529,
-0.0305374172,
0.0078594266,
-0.046803955,
0.0123579567,
0.055915311,
-0.0322150774,
-0.059032537,
-0.0048009604,
-0.0032420049,
0.0013204274,
-0.0256887712,
0.0473621599,
-0.0480611697,
0.0181344151,
0.0331357643,
0.0145062217,
-0.0246658828,
0.0360710211,
-0.0134265572,
0.0492196754,
-0.017507147,
0.0029034594,
0.0292024706,
0.0213919133,
0.0618232824,
0.0009874019,
0.0218574964,
0.026158195,
0.0013179793,
-0.0416722186,
-0.0033020196,
-0.0235195961,
-0.0449362993,
-0.0169223435,
0.003375229,
0.0380576774,
-0.0126099158,
-0.0053772167,
-0.0028241428,
-0.0236397088,
-0.0406728983,
0.0142691359,
0.0573502705,
-0.014352004,
0.0454154462,
0.0133528803,
-0.0280026682,
-0.0160920043,
0.0630707666,
-0.0031598369,
0.0281718224,
-0.0119713834,
-0.0487903431,
-0.0462264456,
-0.0194434989,
0.0055622179,
0.0194125026,
-0.0139578031,
-0.0211806037,
-0.0500476435,
-0.0287070107,
0.0401962772,
0.0282035675,
-0.0305607822,
-0.0006912891,
0.0640570521,
0.0949963182,
0.0685577691,
-0.0232843813,
-0.0199327469,
0.0077031162,
-0.0619050153,
-0.0441397242,
-0.0223377869,
-6.340518815e-33,
-0.0309163872,
-0.0539319329,
0.0383601189,
-0.0295254476,
0.0242644139,
-0.0403534546,
-0.0206030756,
-0.0176589489,
-0.0355053656,
-0.0176628381,
-0.0362820625,
-0.0059766555,
0.023224758,
0.0600422882,
0.0343398601,
-0.0378082506,
0.003492194,
0.0045359875,
0.0115028638,
0.0034231306,
0.0493040159,
0.0250340123,
0.0016975299,
-0.0201256499,
-0.0253610667,
0.0241266377,
-0.0154153816,
0.0368813649,
-0.0303718392,
0.0396651886,
-0.0063614603,
0.0526023284,
0.0090676192,
-0.0218036491,
-0.0054675178,
-0.0200791843,
-0.0214139782,
-0.0261492208,
0.0059084785,
-0.0377318896,
0.0304032043,
-0.0342315771,
0.0503917821,
-0.0358005352,
-0.0143450405,
-0.0134839984,
0.014994543,
-0.0464772657,
-0.0460273251,
-0.0588607192,
-0.0403757952,
0.0118745379,
0.0298493803,
0.023582343,
-0.0184737369,
0.0474113151,
-0.0075835255,
0.0426090509,
-0.0126845511,
0.0558240451,
0.043869555,
0.050372459,
0.0325598083,
0.049112089,
0.0117900344,
-0.0046644597,
0.0186192449,
-0.0033379297,
0.0083670281,
0.0283421446,
-0.0160581153,
0.0634172633,
0.0338419266,
0.0728911236,
-0.0141978618,
-0.0013381196,
-0.084873639,
0.0392048135,
-0.0273037963,
-0.0085950503,
0.0225373674,
0.0078038541,
-0.0543183237,
-0.0661792159,
-0.0744217932,
0.0426236987,
-0.0459930934,
-0.0129827308,
0.0526840203,
-0.0053544044,
-0.0251700077,
-0.0072405436,
0.0281578265,
0.007852478,
-0.0671454147,
0.0012665929,
-0.0312275682,
-0.0299134851,
-0.0058031739,
0.0176237188,
-0.0615516752,
-0.0375794955,
0.0187214725,
-0.0019300961,
-0.0103669362,
0.0376727544,
-0.0047284127,
0.0273637045,
-0.0824499503,
0.0198464766,
-0.0154191172,
0.0285645425,
-0.0183020104,
-0.00813933,
0.0269811526,
-0.0059411926,
0.0268846564,
0.0246194899,
0.0051418729,
-0.0232864451,
-0.0154192131,
-0.0318737328,
0.0028582544,
0.0218479484,
0.0415838324,
0.0553201176,
0.0126283355,
-0.0219558645,
0.0262057129,
-0.0210459996,
0.0049907109,
0.0389205292,
2.958e-7,
0.0756548494,
0.0383685343,
-0.0028321343,
0.0437254645,
-0.0150602683,
0.0446764939,
0.0190081727,
-0.0036997132,
0.0326404385,
-0.0151801612,
0.0282032322,
-0.0091741271,
0.0263512861,
0.0534988157,
-0.0587206595,
-0.0139775053,
-0.0150461914,
0.0165195372,
-0.0747859851,
0.0224981159,
0.058572907,
0.093027696,
-0.0451550558,
-0.0046821944,
0.0135430954,
-0.0486211069,
0.0126229683,
-0.0442686453,
-0.0222137384,
0.0428459197,
-0.025016753,
-0.0162022542,
-0.0084337629,
0.0852029473,
-0.0269467514,
-0.0086683184,
-0.01166985,
0.0398725867,
0.0065690759,
0.01244184,
0.0125422468,
-0.0656437054,
0.0100582484,
-0.0497069098,
0.0866944343,
-0.0474069566,
0.0090818033,
0.0608169436,
0.0005729232,
-0.0531107523,
0.0110153798,
-0.0165514611,
0.0190551002,
-0.0279960185,
0.0006073187,
0.0524209663,
0.0242755841,
-0.031865824,
-0.0059735631,
0.0514436923,
-0.0285319574,
-0.0345465727,
-0.0218099505,
0.0177717544,
-0.0059729,
-0.033630915,
-0.002263838,
3.036500043e-34,
0.0192827899,
0.029382607,
0.0285789724,
-0.0026799508,
0.0418913588,
0.0174367875,
-0.0055627716,
0.0029555387,
0.009611221,
-0.093952015,
-0.0345270894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13006v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13006v1
|
Auto FAQ Generation
| 2024-05-13T03:30:27 | 2024-05-13T03:30:27 |
Anjaneya Teja Kalvakolanu, NagaSai Chandra, Michael Fekadu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
FAQ documents are commonly used with text documents and websites to provide
important information in the form of question answer pairs to either aid in
reading comprehension or provide a shortcut to the key ideas. We suppose that
salient sentences from a given document serve as a good proxy fro the answers
to an aggregated set of FAQs from readers. We propose a system for generating
FAQ documents that extract the salient questions and their corresponding
answers from sizeable text documents scraped from the Stanford Encyclopedia of
Philosophy. We use existing text summarization, sentence ranking via the Text
rank algorithm, and question-generation tools to create an initial set of
questions and answers. Finally, we apply some heuristics to filter out invalid
questions. We use human evaluation to rate the generated questions on grammar,
whether the question is meaningful, and whether the question's answerability is
present within a summarized context. On average, participants thought 71
percent of the questions were meaningful.
|
Auto FAQ Generation: FAQ documents are commonly used with text documents and websites to provide
important information in the form of question answer pairs to either aid in
reading comprehension or provide a shortcut to the key ideas. We suppose that
salient sentences from a given document serve as a good proxy fro the answers
to an aggregated set of FAQs from readers. We propose a system for generating
FAQ documents that extract the salient questions and their corresponding
answers from sizeable text documents scraped from the Stanford Encyclopedia of
Philosophy. We use existing text summarization, sentence ranking via the Text
rank algorithm, and question-generation tools to create an initial set of
questions and answers. Finally, we apply some heuristics to filter out invalid
questions. We use human evaluation to rate the generated questions on grammar,
whether the question is meaningful, and whether the question's answerability is
present within a summarized context. On average, participants thought 71
percent of the questions were meaningful.
|
[
0.076154381,
-0.0302270539,
-0.0090842107,
0.008324937,
-0.0208663847,
0.025844479,
-0.0054654414,
-0.0101649128,
0.0192314554,
-0.0634241998,
0.0199846048,
0.0056205606,
0.0116718328,
-0.0221375301,
0.0146017745,
-0.0431690551,
0.0062423227,
-0.0069622444,
-0.0049310718,
-0.0102564963,
0.0139259677,
0.0258188583,
-0.0059200828,
0.0100910496,
0.0287459288,
-0.0013992577,
-0.0158515014,
0.0054381695,
0.026894141,
-0.0165336486,
0.01327499,
0.0374376252,
-0.0130256386,
-0.0484335385,
0.0000018377,
-0.0982716605,
-0.0370666981,
-0.009458743,
0.0009147368,
0.0048559075,
0.0170562211,
0.0557962358,
0.0203487556,
0.0226440448,
-0.0323430039,
0.0395244658,
-0.032468725,
0.0228503384,
0.0554933771,
0.0425000787,
-0.0086409813,
-0.0749302357,
0.0214449838,
0.0432985276,
0.0398258828,
-0.0370179117,
-0.0048938105,
0.0426449031,
0.0011298305,
0.0480161421,
0.0226858091,
-0.0014863599,
-0.0005611875,
-0.039713461,
0.0920195878,
-0.0124603324,
-0.0560399815,
-0.0263401754,
0.0169125311,
0.0616172999,
0.0550331585,
-0.006136647,
0.060696613,
0.0162129346,
0.0410608537,
0.044465553,
-0.0425469801,
0.0210305545,
-0.0168185569,
-0.0393364578,
0.0443505719,
-0.0016902672,
-0.0326083936,
-0.0023592419,
-0.0090577714,
0.0144636584,
0.0235226639,
-0.0254670847,
-0.0117008835,
-0.0143621294,
-0.0397030823,
-0.083286643,
0.0191614982,
0.0809173658,
0.0006828306,
-0.0376750343,
-0.0221900046,
-0.0366485082,
0.0485152043,
-0.0498616807,
-0.0123756621,
0.0058886157,
0.0169383753,
0.01244736,
0.0085881017,
0.0123356115,
0.0248518549,
-0.0282367766,
-0.0519271754,
0.0217756163,
-0.0596712306,
-0.0100785121,
-0.0163467843,
0.084114328,
-0.0079522673,
-0.017747717,
-0.0228499267,
0.0178362913,
0.0663467795,
0.0221412759,
-0.0269643255,
0.0083577707,
-0.0215959325,
-0.0156570692,
-0.0110955248,
-0.0218174234,
-0.0669653565,
0.0090915486,
0.0052713957,
0.0029727994,
0.0392816961,
0.0160779972,
0.032136932,
0.0157149658,
0.0134985596,
0.0136393728,
-0.0153128039,
-0.0207337402,
-0.0394257307,
-0.0643998757,
0.008527589,
0.0065482999,
-0.0317439772,
-0.0503761731,
-0.0049115852,
0.0286121983,
-0.0154350232,
0.0356256664,
0.0373145342,
0.0576234385,
-0.0107383793,
0.0206558406,
-0.0159642324,
0.0044481154,
0.1317498237,
-0.0201890562,
0.0239441004,
-0.0198445488,
0.016397031,
0.0333354846,
0.0691208467,
0.0370791368,
0.0246368982,
-0.0225462951,
0.0054519665,
0.0066089835,
0.0484000295,
0.0591950417,
-0.0343354307,
-0.0133502949,
-0.0668082535,
0.0919422954,
0.0233750213,
0.0375303067,
0.0163828861,
0.0663671866,
-0.0218492448,
0.0493155755,
0.0094200782,
0.0279821176,
0.0336313732,
0.042766083,
0.003947604,
0.046324864,
-0.0466919132,
0.0263784528,
0.0481223576,
0.0201273784,
-0.0071079652,
-0.053570047,
-0.0183572117,
0.0296154525,
-0.0442422777,
0.03328906,
0.0238745995,
0.0273887627,
-0.0203462392,
-0.018542815,
-0.0052969707,
-0.0448366031,
0.0090784188,
0.0009205495,
0.0626070499,
0.0376211405,
0.0651063696,
-0.0255327709,
0.0092810635,
-0.0005574281,
0.0392328389,
0.0452552848,
0.0651000142,
-0.0241667423,
-0.044279702,
-0.0458841696,
-0.0035788435,
-0.0318271108,
-0.0080410074,
-0.0539421886,
-0.0122590791,
0.0035929317,
0.0714489073,
-0.0619422495,
-0.0698330924,
0.0440550558,
-0.0162213799,
-0.0367665663,
0.0063040322,
0.0043617152,
-0.0312107038,
0.0419809967,
-0.0150982765,
0.0374949202,
-0.0008867921,
-0.0288550183,
0.0089634508,
-0.0129013015,
0.0085500423,
0.0162742846,
0.0432002023,
-0.0838379487,
-0.0063811615,
0.0462007336,
-0.0194446184,
-0.0454448238,
-0.0315916464,
-0.0610574149,
-0.0139346141,
-0.0299718119,
0.0171918627,
0.0339792185,
-0.023947252,
-0.0445916466,
0.0816941261,
0.0248570014,
0.0229470041,
0.0319242962,
-0.034493316,
0.0445909537,
-0.0520454571,
0.0036445018,
-0.0468569957,
-0.0215967335,
-0.0124800615,
0.0563522726,
0.0232666358,
-0.0544953719,
-0.0076923622,
-0.0820384026,
-0.0050698291,
-0.0303955711,
0.0041978564,
0.0375995934,
-0.0120174028,
0.0022843007,
-0.0013414933,
-0.0730289072,
0.0041942629,
0.0039175702,
-0.0401523747,
0.0853193998,
0.0188490693,
0.0235640276,
-0.0487283692,
-0.002139007,
-0.016242886,
0.0099400701,
0.0972435027,
0.0144144036,
-0.0218809936,
0.020776486,
-0.0495160632,
-0.0393562093,
0.0334359817,
-0.0038180349,
-0.0151059087,
-0.0153904054,
0.0095509943,
0.038571272,
0.0859090686,
0.0161795951,
-0.0051120878,
0.0247951038,
-0.0005910336,
-0.0119575458,
-0.0231977869,
0.0121600395,
0.0345498472,
-0.0811678618,
0.0553149618,
-0.029883692,
0.0039118454,
-0.0035427453,
-0.0221371166,
0.0443025567,
-0.0300168432,
0.0238874722,
-0.0616895892,
-0.0195561629,
0.0010232099,
0.0538190193,
0.0169076677,
0.0078978185,
0.0545946397,
0.0017814218,
0.0118711842,
-0.0927800015,
0.0185599327,
-0.056722004,
0.0300887525,
-0.0108745927,
0.0363798253,
0.0033845019,
-0.0002308822,
-0.0525622331,
-0.0052251215,
0.0509412326,
-0.031184366,
0.0040764217,
-0.0324606635,
0.0110670524,
-0.0220091511,
-0.0224478152,
-0.0129416231,
-0.0168606788,
0.0025433523,
-0.032013908,
0.044806689,
0.009962854,
0.0035181572,
-0.0188414436,
0.0472647958,
-0.0033416899,
-0.030151844,
-0.0470669717,
0.0108650131,
0.0761002228,
0.0893236697,
-0.0173110217,
0.0123638976,
-0.0561855882,
0.0436144359,
0.0450560078,
0.0200869422,
0.0196680222,
0.047245793,
-0.0328896306,
-0.005530796,
-0.0591332652,
0.0045729438,
0.0040253624,
-0.0025987409,
-0.0126530956,
-0.0329028219,
0.0986828879,
0.1035025343,
-0.0138226179,
-0.0153398886,
-0.0388166085,
0.0028145248,
0.0007307582,
0.0334936157,
-0.0578123629,
0.0124476999,
0.0018514239,
0.0507785603,
-0.0268125273,
0.0026499734,
0.0094700605,
-0.0715422854,
0.0027861507,
-0.0102143586,
0.0006190428,
-0.0168858077,
0.011634456,
-0.0175852142,
0.0175344739,
-0.0606152415,
0.0532358922,
-0.0225796327,
0.0219587982,
0.0285272896,
-0.0191798154,
0.0304121654,
-0.0090785865,
0.0211752579,
-0.0202881787,
0.044678539,
0.0400593877,
-0.0016091575,
-0.0218572542,
0.058339037,
-0.0295848642,
-0.011941527,
0.0011619596,
0.0604601875,
-0.0117210895,
0.0020728826,
-0.0603009462,
0.0594869815,
-0.0070284205,
-0.0006783314,
0.089181155,
-0.0213351026,
-0.0293333475,
-0.0165475421,
-0.0569477156,
0.0293081123,
-0.0558201782,
0.0681666583,
0.0049924399,
-0.025496589,
0.0065756468,
-0.0476393029,
0.0402996652,
-0.0686282516,
-0.0422166511,
-0.0202372503,
-0.0085314298,
-0.0072055431,
-0.1115738675,
-0.0189297125,
-0.0054838047,
0.0102053545,
0.0297165867,
-0.0417687967,
-0.0154485535,
0.0410498679,
-0.030498594,
-0.0422245972,
0.0172877535,
-0.0306649003,
-0.0587983318,
-0.0297846459,
0.0655045807,
-0.0420863852,
-0.0359856486,
0.0100203091,
0.0143743493,
-0.0358692259,
-0.0031746677,
0.0261648279,
0.0163324643,
-0.0346871167,
-0.0020904143,
-0.0000040814,
0.0325840339,
0.0369272865,
-0.0372017212,
0.0042373203,
-0.02547382,
0.0226485711,
-0.0106570022,
0.0093199611,
-0.0836457312,
0.0355478227,
-0.070728302,
0.036267601,
-0.0446168333,
-0.0770796388,
0.0614729114,
0.0689002126,
-0.0607677028,
0.0074732564,
0.0033473624,
-0.0098010851,
0.0411860198,
-0.0230723433,
-0.0353735648,
-0.0175192952,
0.0687497929,
-0.0018917745,
-0.0162048712,
0.0325465463,
0.0108753759,
-0.0159352329,
0.0329233259,
0.0146483257,
-0.0359438397,
0.0099761542,
0.0302057713,
-0.0395731367,
-0.0361743234,
-0.0481462888,
-0.0102425478,
-0.0145934457,
0.0587561205,
0.0147188958,
0.0363902412,
0.0313641615,
-0.0134544484,
0.0060492498,
-0.0081009008,
-0.0791134164,
-0.0570548102,
-0.0427324735,
-0.0079568047,
-0.0201930739,
0.0156251285,
0.0096019246,
-0.0299926456,
-0.0339868404,
0.00067362,
0.0472429097,
0.0410670713,
-0.0149278035,
-0.0158342216,
0.0330387056,
-0.0056429086,
-0.0198412854,
0.0447767265,
-0.0047842171,
-0.0592332669,
0.0376958363,
-0.0523366593,
-0.0573200583,
-0.0054267533,
-0.0187855717,
0.0260179974,
0.0258967802,
0.0118798129,
-0.0716862231,
-0.0354143344,
-0.0111891506,
0.0347110666,
0.039480716,
0.0071355267,
0.0530593544,
0.036950279,
0.0199817922,
-0.0398573093,
-0.074093163,
0.0855643451,
-0.0982377678,
-0.0196509045,
0.0117606921,
-5.857848345e-33,
-0.0334844179,
-0.0561449155,
-0.0228973702,
0.036604546,
0.0271102451,
-0.0244619045,
-0.051567439,
0.0165391918,
-0.0197317488,
0.0273110345,
0.0066785892,
0.0118541457,
-0.0081564523,
0.0236277767,
-0.0333572291,
-0.0259217769,
0.0118178772,
-0.0104059651,
-0.0290280133,
0.0355712064,
0.053065829,
0.0071636778,
-0.0208784342,
-0.0074892449,
0.0215216,
-0.0912965462,
0.0088297939,
-0.0077919802,
0.0191990696,
0.0250829197,
0.0037698483,
0.0120280487,
0.0169773363,
0.0021854548,
0.0317985229,
0.0453993902,
-0.0303592384,
-0.0447152555,
0.0088939182,
-0.0608189516,
-0.0464279838,
-0.029449001,
0.0015559894,
-0.012539329,
0.0416298732,
-0.0109259682,
0.0917043835,
-0.0251191575,
0.0028549805,
-0.0891595781,
-0.0303528588,
0.0111122606,
-0.0511676259,
-0.0087248655,
-0.0335948579,
0.0955125615,
0.0142619535,
0.0030608445,
0.0268342476,
0.0244310368,
0.0176697318,
0.0278062876,
-0.0027848522,
-0.0248315074,
0.014674129,
0.0170136224,
-0.0492124707,
0.0155198919,
0.0096502174,
0.0084048389,
-0.0534501746,
0.0008779821,
0.0333084352,
0.0547229685,
0.0117313592,
0.0049264119,
-0.0378954858,
0.0818902701,
0.0047354726,
-0.0112322876,
0.0074531296,
-0.0567907393,
-0.0150852986,
0.0183799602,
-0.0237236973,
0.052278515,
-0.0234714039,
-0.0084989266,
0.0212251227,
-0.0234349407,
-0.0707730204,
-0.0662294775,
-0.028612759,
0.0162643641,
-0.0154939033,
0.0186075233,
-0.0305862091,
0.0257388875,
-0.0155807547,
-0.0181628224,
-0.0345079899,
0.0498877726,
-0.0092951972,
0.0159706231,
0.0116980197,
0.0120810745,
-0.0265556891,
-0.0345110521,
-0.0129790781,
-0.010479412,
0.0249722116,
0.0144308368,
-0.0163691659,
-0.007118803,
-0.0232801717,
0.0415273122,
-0.0108907605,
0.0141766025,
-0.0045018317,
0.0095237624,
-0.0479966216,
-0.0204426479,
0.0136681749,
0.0271998495,
-0.0055415877,
0.0114587573,
-0.012154039,
0.098551169,
0.0169111956,
-0.0383224338,
-0.0099695353,
-0.0118890246,
2.601e-7,
0.0600828156,
-0.0017763269,
0.036225751,
0.031012496,
-0.0306851845,
0.0319026485,
0.0456702635,
0.0299936477,
0.0526138023,
-0.0320025571,
0.0218957253,
0.0270595085,
0.0129149351,
0.019814726,
-0.085269846,
-0.0448403694,
-0.0254696812,
-0.0433203541,
-0.0337777846,
0.0116942702,
0.0513483658,
-0.0019572924,
-0.0089570479,
-0.0029158536,
-0.0185652114,
0.0059919953,
0.0150070647,
0.0132058095,
-0.0079895733,
0.0572217368,
0.0465766042,
-0.0171517991,
-0.0099918656,
0.0176570509,
-0.0203180872,
0.0012046484,
0.0370297767,
-0.0213652421,
0.0174268242,
-0.068922922,
-0.030866148,
0.002421621,
0.0518698953,
-0.074822031,
0.0384078734,
-0.027463479,
-0.0013491254,
0.0117432121,
-0.0701740161,
-0.007597785,
-0.0257716775,
-0.0018462678,
-0.0450306199,
0.0342594609,
-0.0185200498,
-0.0104669612,
0.0487370156,
-0.0333036222,
-0.0089456616,
0.0253463592,
-0.0043940973,
-0.0397947803,
-0.0302173663,
-0.0041956506,
-0.0389802605,
-0.0015077532,
-0.0185181852,
2.081259355e-34,
0.0429680534,
-0.0070964592,
-0.0134993708,
0.0243512746,
0.0043193968,
-0.0073814313,
-0.0314658992,
0.0134304985,
0.0220505949,
-0.0405209549,
0.0048548738
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17440v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17440v1
|
CataLM: Empowering Catalyst Design Through Large Language Models
| 2024-05-13T03:19:47 | 2024-05-13T03:19:47 |
Ludi Wang, Xueqing Chen, Yi Du, Yuanchun Zhou, Yang Gao, Wenjuan Cui
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The field of catalysis holds paramount importance in shaping the trajectory
of sustainable development, prompting intensive research efforts to leverage
artificial intelligence (AI) in catalyst design. Presently, the fine-tuning of
open-source large language models (LLMs) has yielded significant breakthroughs
across various domains such as biology and healthcare. Drawing inspiration from
these advancements, we introduce CataLM Cata}lytic Language Model), a large
language model tailored to the domain of electrocatalytic materials. Our
findings demonstrate that CataLM exhibits remarkable potential for facilitating
human-AI collaboration in catalyst knowledge exploration and design. To the
best of our knowledge, CataLM stands as the pioneering LLM dedicated to the
catalyst domain, offering novel avenues for catalyst discovery and development.
|
CataLM: Empowering Catalyst Design Through Large Language Models: The field of catalysis holds paramount importance in shaping the trajectory
of sustainable development, prompting intensive research efforts to leverage
artificial intelligence (AI) in catalyst design. Presently, the fine-tuning of
open-source large language models (LLMs) has yielded significant breakthroughs
across various domains such as biology and healthcare. Drawing inspiration from
these advancements, we introduce CataLM Cata}lytic Language Model), a large
language model tailored to the domain of electrocatalytic materials. Our
findings demonstrate that CataLM exhibits remarkable potential for facilitating
human-AI collaboration in catalyst knowledge exploration and design. To the
best of our knowledge, CataLM stands as the pioneering LLM dedicated to the
catalyst domain, offering novel avenues for catalyst discovery and development.
|
[
-0.0145312957,
0.0863894224,
-0.0251473915,
0.0434329696,
-0.0159041416,
0.0094141094,
0.0195959229,
0.0304212775,
0.0415143445,
0.0031809323,
-0.0405977294,
0.0264896452,
-0.0213235375,
0.0581735186,
0.0271195676,
-0.0038958306,
0.0541344397,
-0.0560477041,
0.0474374145,
-0.0301379841,
-0.0057691317,
-0.0050968435,
-0.0166212711,
0.0427647084,
0.0089271814,
0.0197901521,
-0.0323150009,
0.0004175903,
0.0240574516,
-0.03171755,
0.0141713349,
0.0576173179,
0.0048064124,
0.0421788059,
0.0000018084,
-0.0863080099,
0.0168034453,
0.0296994541,
0.0464718081,
-0.0360792801,
0.0335096605,
-0.040356718,
-0.0230740029,
-0.0090397839,
0.0102006104,
-0.005925213,
0.0315966271,
0.0175762586,
0.0194343589,
-0.0115948319,
-0.0163953025,
-0.0299256966,
0.0784136131,
-0.0107569965,
0.0405367352,
-0.0014118653,
0.0310294535,
-0.002923405,
0.0501232147,
-0.0315619968,
-0.0109283198,
0.0394084863,
0.0011111118,
-0.0355733708,
0.0556063429,
-0.0117969252,
-0.014132468,
-0.03826949,
-0.0014613341,
0.056296289,
-0.0035750752,
-0.0220458843,
-0.0736503303,
0.0023772004,
-0.056983687,
0.0237015542,
-0.0263819732,
0.0124985399,
-0.0036083895,
0.0261911601,
0.042080421,
-0.0285466053,
0.0470617563,
0.031317696,
-0.0102756778,
0.0560254306,
-0.0019209676,
-0.0245898478,
0.0317481123,
0.0144342976,
-0.0254782662,
0.0149637256,
-0.0092302058,
0.0075038937,
-0.0459417738,
-0.0120114535,
0.0382932313,
0.0446850285,
0.0045585469,
-0.0527920946,
0.0510717705,
0.0248822086,
0.0167181231,
0.0311506335,
-0.046396479,
-0.0018770396,
-0.0310177729,
-0.001529778,
-0.0614564233,
-0.0413629413,
-0.0354702771,
-0.0205546599,
-0.0518574603,
0.0026858097,
-0.0621323921,
0.0027395354,
-0.015824208,
0.0434022136,
-0.0262227394,
0.0144234682,
-0.0137537718,
-0.0013799228,
0.0172874574,
-0.0192708261,
-0.0069092512,
0.0272965468,
-0.0281458683,
0.0215610098,
-0.0121953934,
-0.0338006802,
-0.0140982559,
0.0037014531,
-0.0471592844,
-0.01587075,
-0.0145542147,
0.0965175778,
-0.0035243789,
0.0084752617,
-0.0316062532,
-0.0165697932,
0.0117042605,
0.015075014,
-0.0003194295,
-0.0400449783,
0.0413960107,
0.0463303626,
0.0072565493,
-0.0858026817,
-0.006918015,
-0.0271120891,
-0.0022817182,
0.0574616902,
-0.0519145913,
-0.010831573,
0.019541489,
0.0070124441,
-0.0157551616,
0.0245261043,
0.0315580592,
0.0199690517,
-0.0281031244,
0.0106263626,
0.0046111704,
0.0195971243,
0.0167971067,
-0.0415760428,
-0.0372313373,
-0.036093995,
-0.0040381597,
0.0529515184,
0.0128899496,
0.0028405872,
0.001393154,
0.0038612925,
0.0421929657,
0.0456614383,
0.0352873802,
0.0825206339,
0.007007068,
0.0284122955,
0.0110315029,
-0.0793409348,
-0.0046632965,
0.0254621748,
-0.0304303672,
-0.0597551912,
0.034264151,
0.0169622153,
0.0094467439,
-0.0248658322,
-0.0278084893,
-0.0185364857,
0.0302861873,
-0.0458264463,
0.0334811695,
-0.0460124984,
-0.0484429523,
0.0331679061,
0.0195951238,
-0.0162858069,
-0.0353498682,
-0.0694527254,
0.0298377741,
0.0922191292,
0.050017599,
-0.0616407953,
-0.0342558771,
0.0248809215,
-0.0232148208,
0.000717068,
0.0267089568,
-0.0207182653,
0.0127957333,
0.0264407415,
0.0053511104,
-0.0347640254,
0.0242537763,
-0.0140126422,
-0.0303496178,
0.0103834504,
-0.0160747785,
0.0040916391,
-0.0692497864,
0.0295488872,
0.0161870141,
-0.0140118934,
-0.0143763516,
-0.0094701238,
0.0336644687,
0.0333734341,
0.0078153042,
0.0195121169,
0.0798802823,
-0.0707049742,
-0.0347428545,
-0.0308942012,
-0.0095496941,
0.0224286281,
0.0605913624,
-0.0184312277,
0.0340904854,
0.0158008076,
0.0069221309,
0.0088023897,
0.05800635,
0.0400371514,
0.0222927481,
-0.0170609392,
-0.0019483611,
-0.0062447712,
0.0705391541,
-0.0252943877,
0.0605200827,
0.0264871735,
0.0018112913,
0.0200809669,
0.0152304973,
0.0187777616,
-0.0061360039,
0.0196905658,
0.0167312995,
0.042332001,
0.042232383,
0.0366440527,
-0.0217687711,
0.0094705373,
-0.0115162414,
-0.0220513009,
0.0025575981,
-0.0010653719,
0.0127828317,
0.0024066684,
-0.0277543385,
-0.008463433,
0.0291361939,
0.0340368785,
-0.0297997054,
-0.0182298608,
-0.0495864786,
0.0369816534,
0.0049531083,
-0.0965457857,
-0.0242328513,
-0.0262332,
-0.0615503974,
0.070073016,
0.0249726661,
-0.0311121959,
-0.0258753523,
0.02976905,
0.0572109856,
0.0450435728,
0.0035235905,
-0.0042847823,
0.0210703425,
-0.028926475,
-0.009444043,
-0.0149818296,
0.004423108,
0.0455599129,
0.0338680409,
0.0034835711,
-0.0028738447,
0.0072834892,
0.0306059998,
-0.0287971105,
0.0127357449,
-0.0257296134,
0.0078710327,
0.0590052828,
-0.0545974448,
0.0291776862,
-0.0069259955,
0.0184385404,
0.011018889,
-0.0706192702,
-0.0205268338,
-0.0195988044,
0.0457349159,
0.0202795137,
-0.0082909539,
-0.0404596478,
0.0656696856,
-0.0066593522,
-0.0088620512,
-0.0493262,
-0.0179640446,
-0.0080298735,
0.0490144752,
-0.0235494897,
0.0346352905,
-0.011665401,
0.0423561856,
-0.0173497871,
-0.0561874211,
-0.0173131805,
0.0321721323,
-0.0018564796,
-0.0302721579,
0.0348059647,
0.0001861256,
-0.0192713253,
-0.0088838357,
-0.0142925745,
-0.0114275124,
0.0612430722,
-0.0020374265,
-0.0191271063,
0.0057588974,
0.0557774715,
0.0664088875,
-0.0173319969,
-0.0165346991,
-0.019524524,
-0.0400899611,
0.0439133458,
-0.0440351702,
0.0007494733,
0.0130179049,
0.0063264053,
0.0694333687,
0.0540374592,
0.0047392095,
-0.0012333065,
-0.0849324316,
0.0283457804,
0.0281842798,
0.0247352328,
0.0118802004,
-0.0148743698,
-0.0228699725,
-0.0209829397,
0.0050693741,
0.0693005398,
0.0007801988,
-0.0606259368,
0.0333422199,
0.0065961643,
-0.0058268779,
-0.0133572146,
0.0658796281,
-0.1112958938,
-0.0183044691,
-0.0110143404,
0.0033860879,
0.0175578222,
0.0074396273,
-0.0100609157,
-0.0296310075,
0.0621630624,
-0.0037063349,
-0.0531767905,
-0.040600691,
-0.0561932214,
-0.0157324616,
-0.0085264733,
-0.007025396,
0.0456204452,
-0.0028523693,
-0.0204181299,
-0.0130985063,
-0.019115869,
-0.0862973854,
0.0126867993,
0.0029299527,
-0.0412584245,
0.0579750314,
0.0270096995,
-0.0149287004,
-0.0002903942,
0.058110036,
-0.0029649385,
0.0296830609,
-0.0913817585,
-0.0431232713,
0.0282770824,
-0.0355260856,
0.0021287396,
0.0719845966,
-0.036916703,
-0.0843280628,
-0.0151020875,
0.1112030968,
-0.0185317863,
0.0066611459,
-0.0412305929,
-0.0542681813,
0.0184254013,
0.0384635217,
-0.0052302876,
-0.044735115,
-0.0835786611,
-0.0314843357,
-0.0079368558,
-0.0411850549,
-0.0211038869,
-0.0416993722,
0.0446061902,
-0.059370406,
0.0032029552,
-0.0127121387,
-0.0052418448,
-0.0217187088,
-0.037535131,
-0.0280003548,
0.0279470775,
-0.0412542857,
-0.0513723604,
0.0122083882,
-0.002186629,
0.0144074922,
-0.0238432381,
-0.0977275968,
0.0067603351,
-0.0480725951,
-0.0108278561,
0.0501701273,
-0.0001716428,
-0.028335914,
0.0402256735,
0.0345597118,
0.0228216127,
0.0047074105,
-0.0257323887,
-0.0462925211,
0.0455944687,
0.0663542449,
-0.0346748829,
0.0117969243,
-0.0052997302,
0.0178465582,
-0.0271236058,
0.0061530625,
-0.0113724899,
0.0346614495,
-0.0251400769,
0.0164118279,
-0.0086853113,
-0.0221534017,
0.0132912518,
0.021374872,
0.0132983942,
0.0107560242,
0.0213823449,
-0.0202250183,
-0.0285391975,
0.0603158735,
0.0267643835,
-0.0547209643,
-0.0319012888,
0.0376137495,
-0.0550521612,
0.0271290522,
-0.0541799776,
0.018694846,
-0.0529864356,
-0.0444221981,
0.1092648432,
0.0238581765,
0.0382930525,
0.0422182009,
-0.0147115635,
0.000162988,
0.0143110398,
-0.0833679959,
0.0478287563,
-0.0319496803,
-0.007019972,
0.002685213,
0.0490976125,
0.0007151926,
0.0763602555,
0.007968992,
-0.0980444476,
-0.0426377393,
0.0628650114,
0.0704175979,
0.0488515273,
0.0178981666,
-0.0260509476,
-0.0503575541,
-0.006919683,
0.0265257601,
-0.0018619481,
-0.0379165597,
-0.0087237135,
0.0468993224,
-0.0226768143,
-0.064465411,
0.058458861,
0.0008476576,
-0.0091944374,
-0.0409832671,
-0.0383654311,
-0.0245692302,
-0.0447362326,
-0.0178566612,
-0.0522616804,
-0.0267772209,
-0.0232268367,
-0.0619018003,
-0.0237980802,
0.0229511019,
0.0639629439,
-0.0253188759,
0.0004771089,
0.0283486359,
0.0606958866,
0.0001283622,
-0.0620023459,
-0.0012016774,
-0.0339746624,
-0.0140487617,
-0.0475525036,
0.0141476514,
-5.338687224e-33,
0.001827447,
0.0249586683,
-0.0069000237,
0.0332315937,
-0.0132721355,
-0.0364343226,
-0.0786737651,
-0.0127948867,
0.0289319642,
0.0563991219,
-0.000412222,
-0.0302740913,
0.0052837855,
-0.0422679596,
0.0626927093,
0.0254457127,
-0.0012195297,
0.0296656024,
-0.0204384178,
0.0238527879,
-0.0130620254,
0.043321386,
-0.0007966749,
-0.0246690027,
0.0214327984,
0.0259582382,
-0.0029673257,
0.0060657379,
-0.0173114017,
0.0502104163,
-0.0299235731,
0.0516119339,
-0.0127005447,
-0.0440710336,
-0.0072859987,
0.0134037128,
-0.0331655629,
0.004286021,
-0.0027961025,
0.0038548149,
-0.0374136306,
-0.0120476875,
0.0225701742,
0.0320478976,
-0.0781499743,
0.035526488,
-0.0035312357,
-0.0740553215,
0.0838524923,
0.0185809061,
-0.081482023,
-0.0164783429,
0.0025985229,
0.0260189977,
0.0067616641,
-0.0328007042,
-0.0245695077,
0.0181770828,
0.0073073921,
0.0525654778,
0.0378983691,
-0.005175035,
0.059178669,
0.0336960889,
-0.0071768849,
0.0114741456,
0.0717860833,
0.0622379445,
0.0109009612,
0.0591687374,
0.0299793929,
0.079656519,
0.0605225973,
0.0044584004,
-0.0284466892,
0.0253600143,
-0.130466342,
0.0135203563,
-0.0156450719,
0.0540441312,
0.0295972228,
0.0377689973,
0.0267007593,
-0.0583370142,
-0.029886486,
0.043923825,
-0.0056247623,
-0.0060512773,
-0.0508918948,
-0.0275354013,
-0.0477537513,
0.0080373399,
0.0133459102,
-0.0496239439,
-0.0022439407,
0.0756865069,
-0.0106185395,
0.0416341797,
-0.0208287276,
0.0016588698,
-0.0732817054,
-0.0564849973,
-0.0680847466,
0.0285212435,
0.0328042582,
-0.0226497259,
-0.0407467298,
0.0449786931,
0.0142717334,
-0.0005746318,
-0.0779476687,
-0.0083555141,
0.0278530736,
0.0069926209,
0.0059009516,
-0.0193490777,
-0.0016536636,
0.001762101,
-0.0407748073,
0.0307807121,
0.0302033816,
0.0637554154,
-0.0025845021,
0.030834049,
-0.0265252031,
-0.0336352177,
-0.0559457131,
0.0480340347,
0.0061812932,
-0.0410587676,
-0.0207979772,
-0.0208025873,
2.532e-7,
0.0373305567,
0.0276564807,
0.0367729105,
0.0203449894,
-0.0104911551,
0.0192153566,
0.009376443,
0.0070226993,
-0.0392583497,
0.0015279191,
0.0280840732,
0.0643595606,
0.0330292657,
0.0056383763,
-0.0195932165,
0.0111206453,
-0.0267140679,
0.047287643,
-0.0518299192,
0.0156388599,
-0.0165816899,
0.0310240984,
-0.0065989457,
-0.0405978076,
0.0214673728,
-0.053513471,
0.0100471862,
-0.0450368188,
0.0129175419,
0.0725971684,
-0.0912462249,
-0.0151872942,
-0.0255281832,
0.0386990383,
0.0033815764,
-0.0041729482,
-0.0185245164,
0.0226707868,
-0.0237385295,
0.0428293608,
0.0461337231,
-0.0027415929,
-0.0008973739,
-0.0133996606,
0.0141737955,
0.0130554875,
-0.0105468938,
-0.0048198318,
0.0031840748,
-0.0410148725,
-0.0034406516,
-0.0187264215,
0.0282694679,
-0.0318940915,
-0.0248922035,
0.0114761377,
0.0098345047,
-0.0078184241,
-0.0384064242,
-0.00102269,
-0.0206318703,
-0.0190502722,
-0.0450126417,
0.0319444202,
0.0264899302,
0.022743497,
0.0552710667,
1.950704636e-34,
0.0546039566,
-0.0140363378,
-0.0180604421,
0.0111461347,
0.0609089583,
0.0041994965,
-0.0767754167,
0.0093377354,
0.0006867461,
-0.0542641766,
-0.0185101349
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07437v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07437v2
|
Evaluation of Retrieval-Augmented Generation: A Survey
| 2024-05-13T02:33:25 | 2024-07-03T04:59:32 |
Hao Yu, Aoran Gan, Kai Zhang, Shiwei Tong, Qi Liu, Zhaofeng Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) has recently gained traction in natural
language processing. Numerous studies and real-world applications are
leveraging its ability to enhance generative models through external
information retrieval. Evaluating these RAG systems, however, poses unique
challenges due to their hybrid structure and reliance on dynamic knowledge
sources. To better understand these challenges, we conduct A Unified Evaluation
Process of RAG (Auepora) and aim to provide a comprehensive overview of the
evaluation and benchmarks of RAG systems. Specifically, we examine and compare
several quantifiable metrics of the Retrieval and Generation components, such
as relevance, accuracy, and faithfulness, within the current RAG benchmarks,
encompassing the possible output and ground truth pairs. We then analyze the
various datasets and metrics, discuss the limitations of current benchmarks,
and suggest potential directions to advance the field of RAG benchmarks.
|
Evaluation of Retrieval-Augmented Generation: A Survey: Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) has recently gained traction in natural
language processing. Numerous studies and real-world applications are
leveraging its ability to enhance generative models through external
information retrieval. Evaluating these RAG systems, however, poses unique
challenges due to their hybrid structure and reliance on dynamic knowledge
sources. To better understand these challenges, we conduct A Unified Evaluation
Process of RAG (Auepora) and aim to provide a comprehensive overview of the
evaluation and benchmarks of RAG systems. Specifically, we examine and compare
several quantifiable metrics of the Retrieval and Generation components, such
as relevance, accuracy, and faithfulness, within the current RAG benchmarks,
encompassing the possible output and ground truth pairs. We then analyze the
various datasets and metrics, discuss the limitations of current benchmarks,
and suggest potential directions to advance the field of RAG benchmarks.
|
[
0.0614560023,
0.0542922653,
-0.0051031145,
-0.0056412001,
-0.0347069241,
-0.0343211964,
-0.0436356887,
0.0049271788,
-0.0326366536,
-0.0476985648,
0.003568823,
-0.0101292403,
-0.0170247164,
0.0170028415,
0.0337745175,
-0.0084084691,
0.0640291572,
0.0432291925,
-0.0309078395,
0.0265398193,
0.0051884293,
0.028071437,
-0.0236688461,
0.0532762446,
-0.0450502038,
0.0406367667,
0.013715825,
0.0277182292,
0.0498323962,
-0.0059166816,
-0.0112896934,
0.0018394134,
0.0032831719,
0.0425489619,
0.0000017052,
-0.0648128986,
-0.037506029,
0.0035119662,
-0.0017127403,
-0.0365969539,
0.0418248177,
0.0345850252,
-0.02377088,
0.028799912,
-0.0499124303,
-0.0246933233,
0.0515234768,
-0.0029193596,
0.0486954711,
0.08890187,
-0.0045932652,
-0.012478888,
0.0357747339,
-0.0362097919,
0.0264019687,
-0.0068215043,
-0.0087120989,
0.0037237236,
-0.0126707098,
0.0076361401,
-0.0062035955,
0.0244752057,
0.0147897163,
-0.0234427676,
0.0438002907,
0.0188964903,
-0.0769152269,
-0.0035860117,
-0.0185960177,
0.0617498383,
0.037935134,
-0.0149634248,
-0.006264491,
0.0083641866,
-0.0089211389,
0.0388431661,
-0.0247069523,
0.0267878007,
-0.002361821,
0.0303444881,
-0.0129411491,
0.0449582562,
0.0267190449,
0.0101348143,
-0.0051789768,
0.0475527719,
0.0499871224,
-0.0211616885,
-0.0191576909,
0.0010325521,
-0.0068150647,
-0.0257106218,
-0.0187283847,
0.0111610778,
-0.0002148576,
0.0335313156,
-0.0159871113,
-0.040202979,
0.0510154068,
0.0122038824,
0.0442912877,
0.0437540263,
-0.0314634442,
0.0229407866,
-0.0371955112,
0.0650742799,
-0.0064059971,
-0.0248343293,
-0.0415629707,
-0.0045204917,
-0.0528285094,
-0.0060393875,
-0.0329165347,
0.0277073048,
-0.0403593779,
-0.0393113717,
-0.0618624575,
0.0123960497,
-0.0135402987,
0.002202546,
0.0148827946,
0.0501047783,
-0.0527256615,
0.0269716233,
-0.0599577874,
0.0041101421,
-0.0334252641,
-0.002367716,
0.0536924005,
-0.0643864125,
-0.0083637303,
0.00889346,
0.0265939366,
-0.0220686831,
-0.0028376719,
0.0532157347,
0.0113710249,
-0.0419095643,
-0.0365841798,
-0.073858507,
-0.0321330652,
-0.0722076893,
-0.0068617347,
-0.0399101824,
0.0390932038,
-0.0242926106,
-0.0195798501,
-0.0279634632,
0.0223967955,
0.048068881,
0.0067067551,
0.0255695358,
-0.0061789961,
-0.0080980742,
0.0039305105,
-0.0006551887,
0.033547163,
0.0332886912,
0.0265904386,
0.0390213989,
0.0310765654,
0.0331817493,
-0.0038360362,
0.0106836455,
0.030852491,
-0.0104592228,
-0.0292855538,
0.0098619321,
-0.0360835157,
0.0136277843,
0.0093905907,
0.0740852654,
-0.0541532151,
0.0065916199,
0.0065141967,
-0.0137395458,
0.0483918861,
0.0180403497,
0.0955320746,
0.0141805438,
0.0036603373,
0.0036211736,
0.0020871188,
0.0134561304,
-0.0465248562,
0.0501185358,
0.0697716922,
0.052357655,
-0.0069723516,
-0.0511991568,
-0.0225335546,
-0.0058242972,
-0.0063319374,
-0.0253553707,
0.0515428446,
0.0640935451,
-0.05755971,
0.0163394529,
0.0174516495,
-0.0793883502,
0.0079530487,
-0.0266435239,
0.0200368389,
0.0843495876,
0.1197405979,
0.0131475944,
-0.013072676,
0.0290991161,
-0.0460657813,
0.0479569547,
0.0058007804,
-0.0068214643,
0.0090517206,
-0.0492924973,
-0.0301028825,
-0.0281108264,
0.0123080909,
0.0389770605,
0.0584218241,
0.0072920234,
0.0585412309,
-0.0406920947,
-0.0115167871,
0.0417500436,
-0.041144263,
-0.0227962397,
0.0203069188,
-0.00179592,
0.0151334116,
0.0437981784,
-0.0235520676,
0.0305777565,
0.0496702679,
-0.0273675714,
-0.0210063923,
0.0487394519,
-0.0465104915,
-0.0496491864,
-0.0054281405,
-0.0382206067,
0.0195432808,
0.017219251,
-0.0244922321,
-0.0547703952,
0.0315325297,
-0.049895972,
0.029277578,
-0.1054543927,
-0.0119858859,
0.0595371909,
0.0250921734,
-0.0391863808,
0.0824593455,
-0.0202303361,
0.0190478358,
0.0377664939,
0.0334975421,
0.0363666452,
-0.0659944788,
-0.0035721126,
-0.0090372274,
-0.0056438218,
0.00275633,
0.050654646,
-0.0095223915,
-0.0572714098,
-0.0066292575,
-0.0422913209,
0.0038700451,
-0.011387514,
-0.0074514607,
0.0413755812,
0.0226155203,
-0.007564323,
-0.0178160444,
-0.020723965,
-0.0051471419,
0.0545553751,
0.0056342608,
0.0322592705,
0.0323004648,
-0.0145606259,
-0.0464175865,
0.0016106756,
0.0160715673,
0.0436605737,
0.0205219127,
0.0324237309,
-0.0345173292,
0.0150872255,
-0.080144994,
0.0043253573,
0.0028150545,
-0.0075114458,
0.0197131056,
-0.0168477185,
0.0598376617,
-0.0343514197,
0.0178159066,
-0.0083954455,
0.0240136217,
-0.0296547599,
-0.0612105913,
0.0113358935,
-0.0614090003,
-0.0248497277,
0.0337746479,
-0.0190367214,
0.0144615313,
0.0300689805,
0.0313295387,
-0.0352345854,
-0.0365139879,
0.0291657299,
0.0010678194,
-0.0554032698,
-0.0202149693,
-0.0349131748,
-0.0134641696,
0.0366758481,
-0.0264801253,
-0.0678366572,
0.0644714907,
-0.0491936281,
0.0160875786,
-0.0432917029,
0.0260725562,
-0.0341821201,
0.0389582105,
-0.0027617333,
0.0316455141,
-0.0145033197,
-0.0003459535,
0.0013284571,
0.0014451646,
0.0248441864,
-0.0553142503,
0.0230204985,
-0.022294445,
0.0184401572,
0.0291635357,
0.0057397615,
-0.0731515065,
-0.0181420762,
0.05453109,
0.0097316978,
0.0037773543,
-0.0143371383,
-0.0337886661,
-0.014593822,
0.0349439308,
-0.0013516941,
0.0154418247,
-0.0325692333,
-0.0076603782,
0.0457538925,
0.046930857,
-0.0167458393,
-0.0039961031,
0.0337101221,
-0.0317863934,
0.0305763092,
0.0474855825,
-0.0114138108,
-0.021477988,
-0.0047687045,
0.0134225953,
-0.0120450808,
0.0112082018,
0.018816568,
0.0087980786,
-0.0316095576,
-0.05290718,
0.0573966391,
0.048645217,
0.0185722448,
0.0034388402,
0.0088897869,
0.0371509343,
0.0262661893,
0.030725522,
-0.0753714368,
-0.0112806559,
-0.0109761665,
0.0443897657,
-0.0295338817,
-0.0214700997,
-0.0339728631,
-0.1460329741,
0.0373321362,
0.0109631168,
0.0029865855,
-0.0061848327,
-0.0333521031,
0.0131315989,
0.0026322606,
-0.0203814935,
0.0241281018,
0.0160751566,
0.0368258208,
-0.0041440059,
-0.0029051877,
-0.0554658286,
-0.0079553109,
-0.0135239484,
-0.0058433679,
0.1174488142,
0.0131218722,
0.0354627818,
-0.0419198014,
-0.0207063109,
-0.0221929606,
0.0160958823,
0.0015193603,
0.0276843216,
-0.0092984447,
0.0124744065,
-0.0216160677,
-0.0045102155,
0.0002314831,
-0.0099835088,
-0.0288849827,
0.0369234793,
-0.0162139144,
0.0494450442,
-0.0759272575,
-0.0004466724,
0.0268514436,
0.0705798939,
0.0213050488,
0.0118793761,
-0.0055322624,
-0.0015549223,
0.0285892524,
-0.087727353,
-0.0181803461,
0.0145589299,
-0.0035345582,
-0.0323888958,
-0.1232888028,
-0.0624605455,
-0.0496964827,
0.0299767759,
-0.0201251488,
-0.0178041328,
-0.0477185883,
-0.0117150322,
-0.0625570491,
0.0175780337,
-0.0082486477,
-0.016862059,
0.0034105089,
-0.0452342257,
0.0374259055,
-0.0485036559,
-0.0088840174,
0.0582878515,
-0.0274665281,
-0.0461737551,
0.0043893983,
0.029880641,
0.0245005246,
0.0368793532,
-0.0350324139,
0.007527248,
0.036770191,
0.0430980064,
-0.0314913653,
0.0220767669,
-0.0182725117,
0.0092421854,
-0.0086780135,
0.0108572599,
-0.0620893277,
0.0244958885,
-0.019206604,
0.0982559323,
0.0361663178,
-0.0272158515,
0.0580394417,
0.0250881519,
0.0309210327,
-0.0579355434,
-0.0192202777,
-0.028454043,
-0.0188597478,
-0.0410065465,
-0.0238213409,
-0.0440227091,
0.0255368967,
0.038200818,
-0.0091546942,
-0.0024318236,
0.0232077688,
-0.0468821041,
0.0785999224,
-0.0167458504,
-0.057224378,
0.0129735358,
0.0002041764,
-0.0185917895,
0.0138074867,
-0.0160535742,
0.0195542388,
-0.0338388644,
0.0380256735,
-0.0424483083,
0.0250955112,
-0.0004630652,
-0.0101051303,
0.0098824268,
0.0347092897,
-0.0533288084,
0.0361709446,
-0.0672691688,
0.0249821655,
0.0324942395,
0.0139721856,
0.0749343634,
0.000228904,
-0.0010884957,
-0.0067413813,
0.0159037951,
0.0172025599,
-0.0659355968,
-0.0131113902,
0.0241559092,
-0.016959453,
0.0206591748,
0.0536824204,
-0.0346143581,
0.0528686643,
-0.0749832243,
-0.0223710872,
-0.059688244,
-0.0301199071,
-0.023235023,
0.0112162409,
-0.0062840069,
0.0038388893,
-0.0647763312,
-0.0515998639,
0.0126503427,
0.0199359972,
0.028962817,
0.0158283655,
0.0683870092,
0.0774207041,
0.0061759423,
0.0133258672,
-0.0374252535,
-0.0150691243,
-0.0698180273,
0.0104010031,
-0.0303025804,
-5.92838021e-33,
-0.0510767214,
-0.0111368205,
0.0326139554,
-0.0965703726,
-0.0409943201,
-0.0072339675,
-0.0413210951,
-0.02705222,
-0.0048968899,
-0.0244217347,
0.0117649334,
-0.008667442,
0.0124189286,
0.0278307553,
-0.0196354762,
0.0329696499,
0.0200963989,
0.0329928137,
-0.0521274731,
0.0299454089,
0.0827776939,
0.0294189267,
0.0416792408,
-0.0401813649,
0.015730096,
0.0003920087,
-0.0378201567,
-0.001246469,
0.0017963652,
0.0947985202,
-0.0272848811,
0.0570813268,
0.0013803071,
-0.0115881618,
-0.0090545993,
-0.0212541949,
-0.0663933456,
-0.0170514006,
-0.0107836798,
-0.0401060432,
-0.0734390765,
0.0025074629,
0.0286967102,
-0.0545695759,
-0.0200151093,
0.0213085525,
0.0273579732,
-0.0553202555,
-0.0106839444,
-0.056290824,
-0.0666396692,
0.018302165,
-0.0027744675,
-0.0137047032,
-0.0404966287,
0.062476296,
0.0243490171,
0.0171965305,
-0.0514677092,
0.0500379689,
-0.0039468561,
0.062794283,
0.054292839,
-0.0111398706,
0.0031267968,
0.0506784357,
0.0140113737,
-0.0453151725,
-0.021111384,
-0.013390338,
0.0048759859,
0.0583067201,
0.0102025606,
0.0905678272,
0.0509797335,
0.0056983242,
-0.0372639932,
0.0708161294,
0.0041247094,
0.0490013249,
-0.0043428689,
-0.0129333464,
-0.0424251929,
0.0121946428,
-0.0283418223,
0.0372210667,
-0.0203361474,
-0.0575732589,
0.0637494996,
0.0590776503,
-0.0324766077,
0.019990243,
0.0115389666,
-0.0203086901,
0.0453522354,
0.0349000208,
-0.0489989147,
-0.0249266233,
-0.0076640253,
-0.003459706,
-0.029827008,
-0.0069250823,
0.0730470195,
0.0199170224,
-0.0353037752,
-0.0265498348,
0.0207241401,
0.0480926186,
-0.0398825221,
0.0365750082,
-0.0419043712,
0.0551503822,
-0.0381980166,
-0.0555011444,
0.0180564765,
0.019060649,
-0.0409908891,
0.0280905478,
0.042575594,
0.0347221047,
-0.0015546988,
-0.0218252074,
0.0304803904,
0.0285313893,
-0.0330389366,
0.0548488572,
-0.0026543227,
0.0097274547,
0.0147424359,
-0.011626414,
-0.0078265686,
0.0299854595,
2.532e-7,
0.0309649482,
-0.0177556798,
0.0844778419,
0.0089807156,
-0.0190205257,
-0.0341882966,
-0.0133412834,
0.0224104952,
-0.0044430159,
-0.007029172,
-0.0206159391,
0.0108727245,
0.0242513455,
0.0156439971,
-0.0371207185,
0.0156321302,
-0.0518047065,
-0.0255765487,
-0.0317945145,
-0.0036594805,
0.0678055063,
0.0250764452,
-0.0081856195,
-0.0145485653,
-0.0075838761,
-0.0506956875,
0.0775729641,
0.0301107224,
-0.0263252128,
0.0075757904,
0.050997749,
0.0448774435,
0.0056384294,
-0.0494779572,
-0.0215913858,
0.0322103612,
0.0031426642,
-0.0134817902,
0.0071439869,
-0.0790961087,
0.0114499321,
-0.0002617777,
0.0049679377,
-0.0162135661,
0.0377617739,
-0.013189205,
0.0035417823,
-0.0007085847,
-0.0477777459,
0.0325640924,
0.0151873184,
-0.0224601869,
-0.0495939739,
-0.0006173576,
0.0177575853,
0.0422520861,
-0.0222066231,
-0.0780521929,
-0.0130345505,
-0.0200394653,
-0.048852697,
-0.0410545766,
-0.0208185147,
0.0062746275,
-0.0184002947,
-0.061159499,
-0.0287595633,
2.343605357e-34,
0.0337268338,
0.0270992815,
-0.0109085767,
-0.0159875304,
0.0318980627,
-0.0106628472,
-0.043468751,
0.0008547003,
-0.0157014336,
-0.0569978207,
-0.0411615185
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08032v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08032v1
|
Exploring the Potential of Conversational AI Support for Agent-Based Social Simulation Model Design
| 2024-05-12T22:11:54 | 2024-05-12T22:11:54 |
Peer-Olaf Siebers
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SE
|
ChatGPT, the AI-powered chatbot with a massive user base of hundreds of
millions, has become a global phenomenon. However, the use of Conversational AI
Systems (CAISs) like ChatGPT for research in the field of Social Simulation is
still limited. Specifically, there is no evidence of its usage in Agent-Based
Social Simulation (ABSS) model design. While scepticism towards anything new is
inherent to human nature, we firmly believe it is imperative to initiate the
use of this innovative technology to support ABSS model design. This paper
presents a proof-of-concept that demonstrates how CAISs can facilitate the
development of innovative conceptual ABSS models in a concise timeframe and
with minimal required upfront case-based knowledge. By employing advanced
prompt engineering techniques and adhering to the Engineering ABSS framework,
we have constructed a comprehensive prompt script that enables the design of
ABSS models with or by the CAIS. The effectiveness of the script is
demonstrated through an illustrative case study concerning the use of adaptive
architecture in museums. Despite occasional inaccuracies and divergences in
conversation, the CAIS proved to be a valuable companion for ABSS modellers.
|
Exploring the Potential of Conversational AI Support for Agent-Based Social Simulation Model Design: ChatGPT, the AI-powered chatbot with a massive user base of hundreds of
millions, has become a global phenomenon. However, the use of Conversational AI
Systems (CAISs) like ChatGPT for research in the field of Social Simulation is
still limited. Specifically, there is no evidence of its usage in Agent-Based
Social Simulation (ABSS) model design. While scepticism towards anything new is
inherent to human nature, we firmly believe it is imperative to initiate the
use of this innovative technology to support ABSS model design. This paper
presents a proof-of-concept that demonstrates how CAISs can facilitate the
development of innovative conceptual ABSS models in a concise timeframe and
with minimal required upfront case-based knowledge. By employing advanced
prompt engineering techniques and adhering to the Engineering ABSS framework,
we have constructed a comprehensive prompt script that enables the design of
ABSS models with or by the CAIS. The effectiveness of the script is
demonstrated through an illustrative case study concerning the use of adaptive
architecture in museums. Despite occasional inaccuracies and divergences in
conversation, the CAIS proved to be a valuable companion for ABSS modellers.
|
[
0.0372324474,
0.0108131971,
-0.0486416109,
0.0126069188,
-0.0283789858,
-0.0317355171,
0.0423506983,
-0.034754876,
0.0655312017,
0.0165209472,
-0.0095901722,
-0.033045318,
0.0030163997,
0.0543491766,
-0.0057310564,
-0.0005822153,
0.0198467448,
-0.0211280249,
-0.0045643849,
-0.0044890139,
0.0106974328,
0.002776138,
-0.0274746493,
0.0544511527,
-0.0276873205,
0.0000056941,
-0.0903541595,
0.0170808714,
0.020518044,
-0.0232892539,
-0.0048373439,
0.0451099575,
0.0614569336,
0.0403751396,
0.0000025497,
-0.049491547,
-0.0211042948,
-0.0004466902,
-0.0464386754,
-0.0121053662,
0.0867703035,
0.1055066064,
-0.0145447757,
-0.0137102893,
-0.0383752547,
0.0306158196,
0.065081805,
-0.009514208,
0.0172163863,
0.0103053227,
-0.0150930155,
-0.0098159276,
0.0112427445,
0.0118761472,
-0.0195044652,
-0.0543940812,
0.0169313364,
0.0348644219,
0.1065101027,
-0.0178452451,
0.0105521455,
0.0292045157,
0.0222149175,
-0.017171273,
0.0180210825,
0.0284826718,
-0.0128107145,
-0.0390895195,
-0.0312581733,
0.0616432205,
0.110200651,
0.0043930127,
0.0312697366,
0.0099113071,
0.0356559232,
0.0289772023,
-0.0485350899,
0.003028993,
-0.0068539996,
-0.0203166567,
-0.0281603392,
0.0301682651,
-0.0109975059,
0.0095926505,
0.0201638695,
-0.0078250961,
-0.0019488886,
0.0029648785,
-0.0536997989,
-0.0403434709,
0.0039579356,
-0.0535748824,
-0.0007257341,
0.0602500886,
-0.0898295641,
0.0044080671,
0.0396096371,
0.0383635387,
-0.0042822207,
-0.0194839537,
0.036419455,
0.0319143124,
0.0018755321,
0.010024529,
0.0787428692,
0.0385849103,
0.0054897633,
-0.01174236,
0.0207775403,
0.052412983,
-0.0706317276,
-0.0029312256,
-0.0466277674,
0.0068155266,
-0.0565728955,
-0.0370378681,
0.0234606769,
0.0511731766,
-0.041706752,
0.0136734722,
-0.0228796527,
0.0337917916,
-0.0154230557,
0.004677217,
-0.0265074018,
-0.0501118489,
-0.0399833545,
0.0021713278,
0.006326654,
-0.0826420709,
0.0324302763,
0.0076453337,
0.0192044619,
0.028873276,
-0.0395237803,
0.054401923,
-0.0035563419,
-0.015153815,
0.0091871694,
-0.0413316526,
0.038500458,
-0.0333371833,
0.019131558,
-0.0274566207,
0.0476756468,
-0.0112812445,
-0.0154809309,
-0.0196011476,
0.0075546009,
-0.0154215815,
0.0043363185,
0.0458970778,
-0.0327958055,
0.0318470597,
0.030519139,
0.0317918248,
-0.0202629715,
0.0273909178,
0.0234754458,
0.0089004701,
0.0273805764,
0.0340795219,
0.0699606091,
0.0395028479,
-0.0027402502,
0.0173338037,
0.0474130251,
0.013297474,
0.0013072059,
0.0177133214,
-0.055120755,
-0.0075434959,
-0.020138232,
0.00100427,
0.0577247068,
0.0017860723,
-0.0498526767,
0.0469521284,
0.0327788927,
0.0480696149,
0.0121591352,
-0.0183125865,
-0.0123995207,
0.0268773325,
-0.0137974164,
-0.0144130429,
-0.0438178331,
0.0274558701,
-0.0290983543,
-0.0216087531,
0.0611559525,
-0.0302423388,
0.0595330857,
-0.0042530992,
-0.0066841529,
-0.0018545025,
-0.0216017719,
-0.0618218333,
-0.0126817394,
-0.0232684817,
-0.0399935022,
-0.0946839079,
0.0277940072,
0.1156611368,
0.0725571662,
-0.0423194803,
0.0087174671,
0.0023911332,
0.0052361507,
0.0528899543,
0.0834990144,
-0.0277531184,
-0.0269858055,
-0.0114533324,
-0.0127967214,
-0.0313701406,
0.0018315446,
0.0417694189,
-0.0183859691,
-0.0149498153,
-0.020780988,
0.0599029586,
-0.0232089646,
0.0102700526,
-0.0826007351,
0.0052344454,
-0.0691384673,
-0.0092627704,
0.0177058522,
0.0628559887,
-0.0346878767,
0.0033116094,
0.0028125674,
0.0359870195,
-0.023210628,
0.0597152375,
-0.0185287651,
0.0208875313,
0.0130822891,
0.0139384307,
-0.0046248757,
0.0081235375,
0.0031959687,
-0.0043168925,
0.0308179799,
-0.0146564646,
0.0771840662,
0.0107700415,
0.038100224,
-0.03315657,
-0.0008544936,
-0.0130884564,
-0.0035550394,
0.0240605678,
-0.0403973646,
0.0327426828,
0.0110902917,
0.0303550269,
-0.0388605855,
-0.016800262,
-0.0159139484,
0.0073655588,
0.0170345567,
0.0267529562,
0.0011197289,
-0.0296038426,
0.0468332469,
-0.1156001836,
-0.0320378169,
0.0191874914,
-0.05055831,
-0.0003372696,
0.0002254894,
-0.0253886171,
0.0169703476,
0.0030382173,
0.0523055047,
-0.0203558654,
0.0181726217,
0.0316926613,
-0.0015019986,
-0.1012786403,
-0.0508116782,
0.0299229212,
-0.0119702667,
-0.0017844432,
0.0914124995,
-0.0076608057,
-0.0293224752,
0.0045193732,
-0.0235737879,
0.0034276529,
-0.0054220511,
-0.0568957366,
0.0398118049,
0.001312795,
0.018147666,
-0.0172050204,
-0.0226429403,
0.0684147626,
0.0131556774,
-0.064110294,
-0.0457339473,
0.010098068,
-0.0308536142,
0.0278900266,
-0.0168812163,
-0.0436560959,
0.0010804565,
-0.0146878129,
-0.0065074228,
0.036899779,
-0.019646354,
0.0376469158,
0.0280386601,
-0.0450806879,
0.0238991659,
-0.0316641107,
-0.0128494175,
0.0581842139,
-0.0054254509,
0.0142796133,
0.0158403479,
-0.0241208002,
-0.0031248555,
0.010368594,
-0.0151444832,
-0.0088706529,
0.0289013833,
-0.0031637836,
0.0082013151,
0.0328873247,
0.0376438163,
-0.0408276804,
-0.0378842056,
-0.0337742902,
-0.0218843743,
-0.0605585165,
-0.0319713391,
-0.0237390585,
0.0379889645,
-0.0340228975,
-0.0328346044,
-0.0142618148,
-0.040715985,
0.0362814926,
0.0060732416,
-0.0305519849,
-0.0363441333,
0.0157264899,
0.0309944898,
0.0069613401,
0.0042357864,
-0.0224515218,
-0.0464147665,
-0.0093372138,
0.0239870455,
0.0668684021,
0.0013157803,
-0.0015097363,
0.0117678633,
-0.0049763196,
-0.0210884996,
-0.0209637322,
-0.0614597872,
-0.0336663537,
-0.0022369681,
0.0289071444,
0.0014643132,
0.032497745,
0.0265854467,
-0.012415329,
-0.0127142342,
0.0569049753,
0.0182160493,
-0.0006717087,
0.0306681003,
-0.0455753468,
0.0217318274,
-0.0082903849,
0.0139577901,
-0.0473807268,
0.026759088,
0.032061033,
0.0153044416,
-0.0477165356,
-0.0524186417,
0.0270555038,
-0.0671218485,
0.0812774524,
-0.0159435868,
-0.0688250065,
-0.0030143014,
-0.0212279465,
0.0419244021,
-0.0021773584,
-0.0272269696,
0.0163892675,
0.0365612917,
-0.018039396,
-0.0006131888,
-0.0786734968,
-0.0029245268,
0.0184520632,
-0.0299093258,
0.1371789277,
0.0439100564,
0.0611359738,
0.0230180509,
-0.0191314481,
-0.0140413409,
0.0743947551,
0.054868225,
0.0051037576,
0.0183007028,
0.0235876553,
0.022627933,
-0.0225608796,
-0.0057559418,
-0.0421547182,
-0.0324178301,
0.0554192476,
0.0341684408,
-0.0388869643,
0.0006551576,
-0.0707529187,
0.0258056633,
0.071769014,
0.0291328039,
0.0259570666,
-0.0249195267,
-0.0350459367,
-0.0271511599,
-0.0172573198,
0.0038413943,
-0.0043592257,
-0.035420198,
-0.0491339266,
-0.0540851317,
-0.0310022458,
-0.0494989231,
-0.0083996672,
0.0092714252,
0.00988789,
-0.0774368569,
0.040315982,
0.0242465064,
0.0265439022,
-0.0485056601,
-0.0503690876,
0.0275093503,
0.0287766978,
-0.0177747849,
0.0108682485,
-0.0586725697,
0.0011045317,
-0.0194520056,
0.0503681563,
-0.0429776758,
0.0721389651,
0.054839503,
0.0343092047,
0.0135997208,
-0.0013074239,
-0.0062507018,
-0.0050495188,
0.0054332986,
-0.0298867114,
-0.0042099701,
0.0083071943,
0.0431733429,
-0.0083978865,
-0.0145941172,
0.0049669426,
0.0332963727,
-0.0297344774,
0.0380209051,
-0.0384733789,
-0.0329075195,
-0.0071533038,
0.0543162152,
-0.0351427905,
0.0114904772,
-0.0467628799,
0.0142458668,
0.0068364204,
-0.0531742387,
0.01183003,
-0.0076322765,
-0.0266886819,
-0.0590255931,
-0.0003803301,
0.0498837791,
-0.0204925165,
-0.043814186,
0.0313514844,
0.0179871581,
0.0093097836,
0.0387091339,
0.0212180614,
0.0101250522,
-0.0022748802,
0.0189341623,
0.0580227003,
-0.0152623113,
0.0394674614,
0.0254335608,
0.0351407453,
0.0280519091,
-0.0444563329,
0.0043287282,
0.0489476211,
-0.008567146,
-0.0909084678,
-0.0132487537,
0.1059927046,
-0.0212676879,
0.0533559546,
-0.013259178,
-0.051143609,
0.030225547,
-0.0184706748,
-0.0030854018,
0.0419069156,
-0.0534570888,
-0.0352561474,
0.0281851534,
-0.0295053646,
-0.0053492091,
-0.0023055449,
-0.0460001864,
0.0209068153,
-0.0538576953,
-0.0572428592,
-0.0313749984,
-0.0119035849,
0.0394382589,
0.0164264813,
0.0060227043,
-0.0180989299,
-0.0799047723,
-0.0284189731,
-0.0356732048,
0.0442452058,
-0.0122768898,
-0.04471834,
0.0508836247,
0.0320693254,
-0.0097023472,
-0.0116367182,
0.0020425988,
0.0090525029,
-0.0918546766,
0.0039831577,
-0.0367942713,
-6.490063737e-33,
-0.0190363415,
-0.0380987711,
0.0900851116,
0.0386677533,
-0.0265538394,
-0.0559888892,
-0.0501581095,
-0.0017962836,
-0.0115457112,
0.0040230909,
-0.0337578282,
-0.0173786618,
0.0071617537,
-0.0340660177,
0.0204641074,
-0.0099077374,
0.050381016,
-0.0110790152,
-0.0407875739,
0.0089019118,
-0.007315184,
-0.0305527169,
-0.0543421246,
-0.1052408367,
0.0075516631,
-0.0506382622,
-0.0103459768,
-0.0053708269,
0.0194254629,
-0.0078786779,
-0.0212692246,
0.0407931358,
0.0186255965,
-0.0002727761,
0.014701141,
0.0523062199,
-0.0247472916,
-0.0190830175,
0.0217896514,
-0.007335925,
0.0013310444,
-0.0051231021,
-0.0492938757,
-0.0003933154,
-0.0642334595,
0.0499033257,
0.0224096421,
-0.0145774614,
0.0366180725,
0.0536685064,
-0.10057991,
0.0066502001,
-0.0361907892,
-0.0423030779,
0.0062724417,
0.0433449708,
0.0085785529,
-0.0208065212,
-0.0248851161,
0.0330789536,
0.0091193337,
-0.0752594844,
0.029682599,
-0.0086983349,
0.0170798618,
-0.002517414,
0.0502966084,
0.0741175115,
-0.0317253545,
-0.0306123774,
-0.0121502504,
0.0825134367,
0.0054638861,
0.0436830632,
-0.0740542263,
-0.0103252009,
0.0041142125,
0.0228315257,
0.0782997683,
0.0062963855,
0.0239206385,
0.0410927273,
-0.0700491369,
0.0033437388,
0.0133793196,
0.0056296885,
-0.0132124973,
-0.045999065,
-0.0081010107,
0.0003254431,
-0.0082138227,
-0.0061019082,
0.0085565578,
-0.0376915261,
-0.0055565345,
-0.0379308872,
0.0020258939,
0.0034349149,
-0.0069934921,
-0.0132881617,
-0.0314992778,
-0.046521198,
0.0180238876,
0.0395329334,
0.0386740416,
0.0450202115,
-0.0500677153,
0.0526829995,
0.0373792723,
-0.0058151316,
0.0008138163,
0.0183140431,
0.0362121686,
-0.0870995447,
-0.0129810013,
0.0092496499,
-0.0227657557,
-0.0061748046,
0.016045073,
0.015958054,
0.0062067546,
0.0142095629,
-0.0437552184,
-0.0234971475,
-0.0210491698,
-0.0213222764,
-0.0426535234,
-0.0158619713,
0.0117430994,
-0.0394338705,
-0.0315911435,
-0.0527039543,
3.314e-7,
-0.0451476388,
0.0509774238,
0.0152520975,
0.0323681273,
0.0387106501,
0.041035112,
0.0113762235,
0.0391166732,
-0.0043537058,
-0.0325532258,
0.0350150242,
0.0392957777,
0.0131208906,
0.0044050235,
-0.0425780676,
-0.0366051123,
-0.0370237119,
-0.0070547089,
-0.0716194287,
0.0077752029,
0.0442813821,
-0.0331426449,
0.0345095918,
0.0039209062,
-0.0094678057,
-0.0096702753,
-0.0487471893,
-0.04289978,
-0.0011783665,
0.043920204,
-0.0064978465,
-0.0230260417,
0.0063883201,
-0.0010643144,
0.0203625597,
0.0118087558,
-0.0208908636,
0.0179403424,
-0.0019829299,
-0.0243102331,
0.054289408,
-0.0484980308,
0.001098864,
-0.0552649796,
0.0367901698,
-0.0506034717,
-0.0155098327,
-0.0144085968,
-0.0440357812,
-0.0065642921,
-0.0240567196,
-0.0019907595,
-0.0029532837,
-0.0151822614,
-0.0477536358,
-0.0058937804,
0.0286761969,
-0.0192243457,
0.0662409142,
-0.0375726111,
-0.049076438,
-0.0815196782,
-0.0094289919,
-0.0210377872,
-0.0086688716,
-0.0281991996,
0.0487379991,
2.681006674e-34,
0.0432753004,
0.0141951423,
-0.0072395578,
0.0576362126,
0.0697649121,
0.0199354757,
-0.0038539302,
0.0254639816,
0.0611682534,
-0.0303727333,
-0.0308907703
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13005v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13005v1
|
Understanding the Rare Inflammatory Disease Using Large Language Models and Social Media Data
| 2024-05-12T20:54:23 | 2024-05-12T20:54:23 |
Nan Miles Xi, Hong-Long Ji, Lin Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SI
|
Sarcoidosis is a rare inflammatory disease characterized by the formation of
granulomas in various organs. The disease presents diagnostic and treatment
challenges due to its diverse manifestations and unpredictable nature. In this
study, we employed a Large Language Model (LLM) to analyze sarcoidosis-related
discussions on the social media platform Reddit. Our findings underscore the
efficacy of LLMs in accurately identifying sarcoidosis-related content. We
discovered a wide array of symptoms reported by patients, with fatigue, swollen
lymph nodes, and shortness of breath as the most prevalent. Prednisone was the
most prescribed medication, while infliximab showed the highest effectiveness
in improving prognoses. Notably, our analysis revealed disparities in prognosis
based on age and gender, with women and younger patients experiencing good and
polarized outcomes, respectively. Furthermore, unsupervised clustering
identified three distinct patient subgroups (phenotypes) with unique symptom
profiles, prognostic outcomes, and demographic distributions. Finally,
sentiment analysis revealed a moderate negative impact on patients' mental
health post-diagnosis, particularly among women and younger individuals. Our
study represents the first application of LLMs to understand sarcoidosis
through social media data. It contributes to understanding the disease by
providing data-driven insights into its manifestations, treatments, prognoses,
and impact on patients' lives. Our findings have direct implications for
improving personalized treatment strategies and enhancing the quality of care
for individuals living with sarcoidosis.
|
Understanding the Rare Inflammatory Disease Using Large Language Models and Social Media Data: Sarcoidosis is a rare inflammatory disease characterized by the formation of
granulomas in various organs. The disease presents diagnostic and treatment
challenges due to its diverse manifestations and unpredictable nature. In this
study, we employed a Large Language Model (LLM) to analyze sarcoidosis-related
discussions on the social media platform Reddit. Our findings underscore the
efficacy of LLMs in accurately identifying sarcoidosis-related content. We
discovered a wide array of symptoms reported by patients, with fatigue, swollen
lymph nodes, and shortness of breath as the most prevalent. Prednisone was the
most prescribed medication, while infliximab showed the highest effectiveness
in improving prognoses. Notably, our analysis revealed disparities in prognosis
based on age and gender, with women and younger patients experiencing good and
polarized outcomes, respectively. Furthermore, unsupervised clustering
identified three distinct patient subgroups (phenotypes) with unique symptom
profiles, prognostic outcomes, and demographic distributions. Finally,
sentiment analysis revealed a moderate negative impact on patients' mental
health post-diagnosis, particularly among women and younger individuals. Our
study represents the first application of LLMs to understand sarcoidosis
through social media data. It contributes to understanding the disease by
providing data-driven insights into its manifestations, treatments, prognoses,
and impact on patients' lives. Our findings have direct implications for
improving personalized treatment strategies and enhancing the quality of care
for individuals living with sarcoidosis.
|
[
0.0426138267,
0.0848726407,
-0.0011354383,
-0.0036336516,
0.0256739464,
0.0136763835,
-0.0119098453,
0.0208655074,
0.0345554911,
-0.0322365612,
0.0144220404,
-0.0063016741,
0.0016466789,
0.0213303231,
-0.004208426,
-0.0271871891,
-0.0098087341,
0.0389978439,
0.0349769294,
-0.0003045662,
0.041541785,
0.0123344157,
0.0040516867,
0.0138078257,
0.0268966127,
-0.0196223408,
0.0778197721,
-0.0318969935,
0.0406941772,
-0.058635775,
0.0178172011,
0.0215627626,
-0.0132540502,
0.0200242866,
0.0000019531,
-0.0410399586,
-0.0053310548,
-0.0003666536,
0.0336040892,
-0.0097889416,
0.0744075552,
-0.0334685817,
0.0355191082,
0.0173635799,
-0.0456986167,
-0.0361625291,
0.0345308222,
0.0650508031,
0.0294878054,
0.0207681525,
-0.0302808043,
-0.0470889509,
-0.0203698128,
-0.0145664485,
0.0085614044,
0.0213699136,
0.0273414589,
-0.0152218714,
0.0424019396,
-0.0407696441,
0.0211447589,
0.0624098517,
-0.0615929924,
-0.0204844605,
-0.0041042729,
0.0305841994,
-0.030135449,
-0.0274971835,
0.026017677,
0.0552129447,
0.0262594949,
0.0008695814,
0.0373801924,
-0.0056303311,
-0.0072828848,
0.0515310019,
-0.0311503429,
-0.0185073223,
0.0177582894,
0.0402558371,
-0.0058326917,
0.0124116503,
0.0348862335,
-0.0066258381,
0.0333078317,
0.0203628391,
-0.033383783,
0.0111637888,
-0.0215532519,
0.0062170983,
-0.0292057805,
-0.0487765744,
0.039130602,
0.0123216454,
-0.0250546336,
0.0208661202,
0.0265123099,
-0.0375430435,
0.0677489862,
-0.1109205112,
-0.0300992355,
-0.0151584866,
0.052613318,
0.0333274491,
0.0433518477,
-0.0754668266,
-0.0163543392,
0.0049976986,
-0.0169957243,
0.0079551367,
-0.0591527037,
-0.003790041,
0.0129178539,
0.0164489392,
0.022545889,
0.0075034853,
-0.0732740238,
0.0030332217,
-0.0237130113,
-0.0286047645,
0.0223712288,
0.0179212987,
0.0445238501,
0.0115008233,
-0.0051535973,
0.0136887701,
-0.030089194,
0.0381434076,
-0.013191211,
-0.0150290299,
0.0622721501,
-0.0105149187,
0.031236073,
-0.000957472,
0.0213418864,
0.0275050234,
0.028401738,
-0.0078971414,
0.0101041002,
-0.0087547693,
-0.0457959287,
-0.0477630422,
-0.0218662955,
-0.0982490182,
0.0543208495,
0.0703560933,
0.0072353403,
-0.0255263411,
-0.0262283366,
-0.0142442212,
-0.0915589854,
0.0271432642,
-0.0699352846,
0.02744711,
0.0322770849,
0.0208279714,
0.039504867,
0.010836794,
0.0050182939,
-0.0275528561,
0.0360675529,
-0.014979546,
0.0215767194,
0.0222130623,
0.016050877,
0.0188893862,
-0.0110588772,
0.0456561744,
-0.0254077688,
0.0080783414,
-0.0521921553,
0.0516405441,
0.0020708456,
-0.0114126578,
0.0425341614,
0.1050246805,
-0.0092022493,
0.0124910818,
-0.0657144338,
0.0231306441,
-0.0092763286,
-0.0618053265,
0.0467554256,
-0.0121823773,
0.0026973109,
-0.0011100202,
0.0536823981,
-0.0056329537,
-0.0221122745,
-0.0389287658,
-0.0797502995,
-0.018779641,
0.0064781131,
-0.0007082958,
-0.0030631337,
-0.0479234271,
0.0352236889,
0.0186715368,
0.0604151972,
-0.0151358452,
-0.0084004104,
-0.0308122374,
-0.0173822287,
0.0744361952,
0.0106382379,
-0.0084185805,
-0.0372704715,
-0.0128147444,
0.0146339322,
-0.0107471608,
0.0086593721,
0.0008289205,
-0.050196968,
0.0043560262,
0.006074938,
0.0500695482,
0.0233495645,
-0.0530795194,
-0.0024006108,
0.0043472033,
-0.06815622,
-0.0172742158,
-0.001753428,
0.0148893446,
-0.0114679001,
-0.0313731693,
-0.0109150577,
-0.0259955078,
0.0603734851,
0.0175110083,
-0.0004737199,
0.0143457847,
0.0141447522,
-0.0259018987,
-0.0822984874,
0.036273174,
-0.0067150067,
-0.0246556979,
0.0042728554,
-0.0408556759,
-0.0533236898,
-0.0015171496,
-0.0307563059,
0.0076178536,
0.0823965967,
-0.0539778173,
0.0148551203,
0.0478130765,
-0.0309394486,
0.012863826,
-0.0005385589,
-0.0035712831,
0.0015160537,
-0.0340843759,
0.015800124,
-0.0188041516,
-0.0737117976,
-0.0122451186,
-0.038535051,
-0.030079741,
-0.0108459089,
0.0136584761,
0.0299936142,
0.0247556306,
-0.0544585213,
0.0110544777,
0.0095161656,
-0.1137168333,
-0.0005290481,
0.0094282655,
0.0108840484,
0.0288151465,
0.0209344625,
-0.0215165224,
-0.0422324724,
-0.0572930165,
-0.0107798809,
0.0440261811,
0.0314834826,
0.0337333158,
0.0132003948,
0.0086874785,
-0.0917018279,
-0.0242457949,
-0.0562029928,
0.0386935361,
0.0550903864,
-0.0401877686,
0.0525766015,
-0.0163568575,
-0.1083067209,
0.0036883822,
0.0063316845,
-0.0083467932,
-0.0164986718,
-0.0481593125,
-0.013133714,
0.0162770115,
0.0118664037,
0.0467040353,
0.0307053328,
0.0250577126,
-0.0149529483,
-0.0263756383,
-0.0766405463,
-0.0274228118,
-0.0170584768,
-0.0577518642,
0.0173759162,
0.1022315249,
0.0412946492,
0.0345498733,
-0.0194564797,
-0.0113788024,
-0.062772207,
0.0120415082,
-0.0552856661,
0.0014084242,
-0.0103885802,
0.0350415371,
-0.0130003914,
-0.0305905957,
0.0328197666,
0.0242478307,
0.0414990038,
-0.0607862957,
-0.0222288053,
-0.0099692065,
0.0187787004,
0.0263447165,
0.0271568336,
-0.0076806406,
0.0468330309,
0.0555908941,
-0.0480625816,
-0.0024242664,
-0.0564234555,
0.0354568772,
-0.0055328915,
0.0397407562,
0.011312332,
-0.0118158674,
0.0230128113,
-0.0233971905,
-0.0712850764,
-0.0356390551,
0.0257315263,
-0.0221443716,
-0.0352463573,
0.0140586672,
-0.0153861176,
0.0241898,
0.0196873676,
-0.0372836851,
0.0358749032,
0.0007699298,
0.0522132032,
-0.0393500291,
0.0137708327,
-0.0312672146,
0.0152475471,
0.0710479319,
-0.0274313726,
-0.0079677887,
0.0066741472,
-0.0019825432,
0.0039354679,
0.0011909901,
0.0104356436,
-0.0129810423,
0.0442818999,
-0.0187931713,
0.0039931634,
0.0809781924,
0.0292128045,
-0.0208401419,
0.0098985313,
-0.0256341137,
-0.0316642188,
-0.0161866639,
-0.0033915101,
-0.0176811647,
-0.0268210024,
-0.0466723517,
0.0101126293,
-0.014618244,
-0.0369920358,
0.0055800667,
0.0027905242,
0.0261455346,
-0.0064002601,
-0.0462514758,
0.0044708294,
-0.0469903462,
0.0030282096,
0.0030878696,
-0.0042691492,
-0.050346192,
0.027494261,
0.0142199751,
0.0130320843,
-0.0873956978,
-0.0330640897,
0.0434776917,
0.0028031366,
0.0371805765,
0.0090616168,
0.054433886,
-0.0035002925,
0.0011488148,
0.0098958714,
0.0659809932,
-0.0098175006,
0.0018031914,
0.0859190375,
-0.0044560386,
0.0137233464,
-0.1175304651,
0.0179065838,
-0.0854339972,
0.0042415364,
-0.0340328738,
0.0797629505,
0.0030887274,
-0.0526527539,
-0.0421787351,
0.0071905544,
0.0210132394,
0.0317654796,
0.02256082,
0.0178650673,
-0.0214099772,
-0.010373028,
0.043290399,
0.0133607592,
-0.0444904603,
-0.0123089049,
-0.0073711853,
-0.0517314784,
-0.0392772183,
-0.0181698166,
0.0352016166,
-0.0639012232,
0.0063385582,
0.0315640084,
0.0469842367,
-0.0532819517,
-0.094236888,
0.0372451469,
0.0452649742,
0.0323647335,
-0.0208452456,
-0.0501529761,
0.0676333457,
0.0534275658,
0.0207589418,
0.0159481931,
-0.0429871492,
-0.0303728208,
0.0255486593,
-0.0437291637,
0.0230374727,
-0.0202777814,
-0.0156898741,
-0.0377291404,
0.0512431078,
0.0641000122,
-0.0186626613,
-0.0067314529,
-0.0093838312,
0.0339566991,
0.0498733558,
0.0202175304,
-0.014655754,
0.0309786703,
0.0389246568,
-0.0262119547,
-0.0766002983,
-0.0097633777,
-0.0083176782,
-0.0066065877,
0.0255511198,
-0.0122598503,
-0.050730858,
-0.032721255,
-0.049837999,
-0.0033203424,
0.0274330638,
-0.0070332428,
-0.055034209,
0.0001653201,
0.019415129,
-0.0625049025,
0.0587604232,
-0.0629446357,
0.0132793142,
-0.073776938,
0.0639356077,
0.0242865887,
0.000978171,
0.0501646399,
-0.0202616937,
0.0312709771,
-0.0041875024,
-0.0213312563,
-0.0058727441,
0.0150233796,
0.009806335,
0.0077555538,
0.0072310269,
0.0432525501,
0.0296602175,
-0.0104481122,
-0.0411650576,
0.0142760044,
0.0105483113,
-0.0221341997,
-0.0219588298,
0.0749287531,
0.0005810278,
-0.0102475295,
-0.0222098362,
-0.0027205343,
-0.0494855307,
0.0058489228,
0.0408691019,
0.0120954402,
-0.0254412573,
0.0172367841,
0.0553141087,
-0.0376666635,
0.0022940238,
-0.0182174668,
-0.057276044,
-0.0100832526,
0.0078459112,
0.0144757386,
0.0076065883,
-0.0662782639,
0.0166710522,
-0.0550026484,
-0.060731452,
0.0002850737,
-0.0397620276,
-0.0158354361,
0.0007329724,
0.0006293697,
0.0412239693,
0.0276893508,
0.0317953341,
-0.068556346,
0.0659196675,
-0.0567601547,
-0.0397051536,
0.0156355333,
-6.195422405e-33,
0.0330769308,
-0.0593606345,
-0.0114260456,
-0.0060508647,
0.0338373072,
0.0416125171,
-0.0414111987,
0.0231056381,
0.0163818989,
0.0415878929,
0.0207127836,
0.017040778,
-0.0044468129,
0.0335496776,
0.01348201,
-0.0163357314,
0.0314894505,
-0.0004807543,
-0.0131927496,
0.0101492982,
0.0161170959,
0.0261279568,
-0.0030077102,
-0.0810359493,
0.0525127649,
-0.0148960249,
0.0528756455,
0.0107812658,
0.0594542213,
0.0566955358,
-0.0167387147,
0.0590472966,
0.0676882118,
0.0161051378,
-0.0044723931,
0.0458154082,
-0.031800162,
-0.0349047482,
-0.0164722484,
0.0281936768,
-0.0056063179,
0.0231220126,
0.0348907672,
-0.0032875503,
-0.0109972665,
-0.0106385732,
0.0459657051,
-0.0031582245,
0.0220764223,
-0.0366036482,
-0.0200091712,
0.0405822881,
-0.0115152076,
0.0150145646,
-0.0302433185,
0.0100928023,
-0.0285087582,
0.0770541653,
-0.0355134606,
0.042166654,
0.0035535439,
0.0051731174,
0.0241838135,
0.0046350518,
-0.0115966322,
0.0612909384,
-0.0004286176,
-0.0037951616,
-0.0556199662,
0.0356473774,
-0.0524299294,
0.0032332868,
0.0328200459,
0.0226459559,
-0.0090438537,
-0.0243502297,
-0.0598094761,
-0.0145034054,
-0.0451843329,
-0.0238772966,
0.060003493,
0.0317598209,
-0.0270924866,
-0.0097458577,
-0.0229388606,
0.0274760481,
-0.0102052232,
-0.0138272634,
-0.0418677069,
-0.0088278372,
-0.0214038286,
0.0089641996,
0.0026059877,
-0.0139412945,
-0.0623895079,
-0.035233587,
0.0368565582,
0.0208390076,
-0.0017710937,
0.0249985009,
-0.0311627369,
0.0267860964,
-0.0238842499,
-0.0227881372,
0.0195988026,
-0.0100780772,
0.0118313003,
-0.034680929,
-0.0459630974,
-0.0207278505,
0.0112131806,
0.0009132985,
-0.0203302838,
0.0311709158,
0.0133220181,
0.0381706506,
0.0026054443,
0.0911272764,
0.0411772318,
0.0334187597,
0.0126713747,
-0.0214900058,
-0.0535916314,
-0.0422880016,
-0.0322786123,
-0.0227279216,
-0.0465680435,
0.0323769711,
0.0480305292,
-0.0684155822,
0.0088111004,
-0.0329707377,
2.783e-7,
0.1206712946,
0.0814757422,
-0.0631907061,
-0.0359969176,
0.0583027154,
0.0233717859,
0.0078200549,
0.0004402527,
-0.0070182593,
-0.0156329945,
-0.0169184543,
0.0546965413,
-0.002902407,
0.0585699454,
-0.0052459412,
-0.0097806565,
-0.0874629989,
-0.0043985243,
-0.0172538534,
0.0231588557,
0.0324275121,
0.0959687233,
-0.0155444946,
-0.0264723729,
0.004250275,
-0.0056040711,
0.0358096249,
-0.0637545362,
-0.0337361731,
0.0241710916,
0.0272179302,
-0.0347953029,
0.0103311501,
0.0150298625,
-0.0224038269,
-0.0437852591,
-0.0257012043,
0.0147010693,
0.0039539742,
0.0032891843,
0.0233870987,
-0.0559176803,
0.0221931543,
-0.0284942277,
0.0287823919,
-0.0506435968,
-0.0681074187,
-0.0558162034,
0.0277660396,
-0.005321017,
0.0734887123,
-0.0229812302,
-0.0680950508,
0.011066461,
0.023577027,
0.0262895301,
-0.0279608518,
-0.0253114142,
0.0085100885,
-0.0132955844,
-0.0708203614,
-0.043510329,
0.0484659895,
-0.0109130107,
-0.0013013292,
0.0048243538,
0.0631160587,
1.665784205e-34,
0.0244402606,
0.049978666,
-0.0294249132,
-0.0436604656,
0.0207198262,
-0.0316018797,
-0.0200345069,
0.0246827155,
0.0231319629,
-0.0396612436,
-0.0082210843
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13004v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13004v1
|
MathDivide: Improved mathematical reasoning by large language models
| 2024-05-12T20:21:15 | 2024-05-12T20:21:15 |
Saksham Sahai Srivastava, Ashutosh Gandhi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models have been proven to be capable of handling complex
linguistic and cognitive tasks. Therefore their usage has been extended to
tasks requiring logical reasoning ability such as Mathematics. In this paper,
we propose a prompting technique called MathDivide that breaks down the
mathematical problem into simpler subproblems. Each of the subproblems is
formulated as an algebraic expression whose value is evaluated by the Python
code generated by the LLM for the corresponding algebraic expression. The
values fed to the Python code are the numerical values provided in the problem
statement. The solutions for the subproblems are composed together to obtain
the final answer for the problem statement. Finally, the final answer is
compared to the correct answer. If the final answer matches the correct answer,
it is produced as output else a refinement prompt is fed to the LLM. We
experiment with this prompting technique on both closed-source LLM models and
open-source LLM models using GSM8K dataset. The results obtained demonstrate
that MathDivide was able to significantly outperform the leading prompting
technique called Math-prompter.
|
MathDivide: Improved mathematical reasoning by large language models: Large language models have been proven to be capable of handling complex
linguistic and cognitive tasks. Therefore their usage has been extended to
tasks requiring logical reasoning ability such as Mathematics. In this paper,
we propose a prompting technique called MathDivide that breaks down the
mathematical problem into simpler subproblems. Each of the subproblems is
formulated as an algebraic expression whose value is evaluated by the Python
code generated by the LLM for the corresponding algebraic expression. The
values fed to the Python code are the numerical values provided in the problem
statement. The solutions for the subproblems are composed together to obtain
the final answer for the problem statement. Finally, the final answer is
compared to the correct answer. If the final answer matches the correct answer,
it is produced as output else a refinement prompt is fed to the LLM. We
experiment with this prompting technique on both closed-source LLM models and
open-source LLM models using GSM8K dataset. The results obtained demonstrate
that MathDivide was able to significantly outperform the leading prompting
technique called Math-prompter.
|
[
-0.0225405078,
0.0660692826,
-0.0043361536,
0.0602266081,
-0.0586169288,
0.0282791555,
0.0471735708,
0.0112581998,
-0.0051673222,
-0.0446114801,
0.0143836141,
-0.0109611191,
-0.0036797856,
0.0200327151,
0.004424206,
-0.0548864231,
0.0261717644,
-0.0676097646,
0.036064133,
-0.00079818,
-0.0286994632,
-0.0041085449,
-0.0172401648,
-0.015989121,
-0.0151445679,
-0.0650071278,
0.0057281703,
-0.0480393171,
0.0022047085,
-0.0253047459,
-0.0399786718,
0.0338285081,
0.0147917029,
0.0315405168,
0.0000024099,
-0.050834842,
-0.0112706833,
0.0174850505,
-0.0691975802,
0.0279123876,
0.0067720255,
0.013540823,
0.004656143,
0.0240547806,
-0.0822205991,
0.0331803486,
-0.0009174003,
0.0215194281,
0.1015700996,
0.0714930221,
0.0095330533,
-0.067658186,
0.0175522398,
0.026953524,
0.0312678777,
-0.0466433652,
0.037844833,
0.0438685417,
0.0287429746,
-0.0091732629,
-0.0014040634,
0.028772587,
0.0683852732,
-0.0216715187,
-0.021458827,
-0.0149433995,
-0.0424397066,
0.0050326921,
-0.0102084326,
0.0498508923,
-0.0015704507,
-0.0142306928,
-0.00628347,
-0.0045775026,
0.0032200939,
0.0117759816,
-0.0895855948,
0.0382450819,
-0.0164179783,
-0.0051229214,
0.0089126518,
-0.0249659605,
0.0146888951,
0.0164240506,
-0.06963294,
0.1137902886,
0.0088468427,
-0.0448681116,
-0.0201466773,
-0.0172617398,
-0.064363867,
-0.0594234318,
0.0390361585,
0.0979786441,
-0.0304672662,
0.0200913381,
-0.0282944087,
-0.0450891033,
-0.0206428617,
-0.0417219959,
0.0362862796,
0.0573937148,
0.0178683456,
0.0360647701,
-0.0453240871,
0.0495256037,
-0.0305297058,
0.007217641,
-0.0343118496,
0.0388024449,
-0.0241896026,
-0.0221497063,
-0.0156545267,
0.0498772115,
0.0058279079,
0.0269589946,
-0.0371746458,
0.0392998792,
-0.0325321928,
0.0247060582,
0.0162047818,
-0.0292847287,
0.0506696664,
-0.0282594152,
-0.0373451561,
-0.0150497248,
-0.0560370572,
0.0017480004,
-0.0107272193,
-0.0412264988,
0.0083930437,
0.017062366,
-0.0095865224,
-0.0164876208,
0.0239585005,
0.0644244701,
0.0116835972,
0.0104732383,
-0.0320905,
-0.0482410118,
0.0451461412,
-0.0835592896,
-0.0130490139,
-0.1069575548,
0.0308251809,
0.0277037341,
-0.0396600366,
-0.0462441184,
0.0024149586,
0.0042547733,
0.0446452424,
0.0430214368,
-0.0017657003,
0.012355281,
0.0688434169,
-0.0106535256,
-0.025058154,
0.0205497015,
0.030411398,
-0.033296492,
0.0128139881,
-0.0089839464,
0.0279913917,
0.0427482203,
0.0040602023,
-0.0098339813,
-0.0460773855,
0.0242603552,
-0.0057908529,
0.0220581796,
-0.0396128818,
0.0423098356,
-0.0364272371,
-0.0043037925,
-0.0082028359,
0.0480748117,
0.022638768,
-0.0083548343,
0.0335845873,
-0.0001347037,
0.0450123698,
0.0092242789,
-0.0569772869,
0.0184762701,
-0.0432865322,
0.0037839955,
0.0119218398,
0.0282616504,
-0.0110670887,
-0.0790834129,
0.0004124177,
0.0148017528,
-0.0103575941,
0.0447981134,
0.0593204945,
-0.0284026805,
0.0295813922,
0.080528833,
0.0189287476,
-0.0310754329,
-0.0346099697,
-0.0685708597,
0.0634960458,
0.0127985403,
0.0377566516,
-0.058745347,
-0.0071398648,
-0.0136523852,
0.0068583237,
0.0003014722,
0.0364832208,
-0.003931751,
-0.0645638406,
-0.0427422076,
0.0064049647,
-0.0118747493,
0.0088435095,
-0.016725488,
0.0567357652,
-0.0125240665,
0.0308724642,
-0.015501136,
0.0342799649,
0.0267980583,
-0.0234846827,
-0.0376520045,
-0.0137431407,
-0.0015393503,
-0.0113472668,
0.0289817844,
0.0135049652,
0.0540218987,
0.0257189088,
-0.007054036,
0.0038522624,
-0.0488410182,
-0.0495145172,
-0.0537820347,
0.070387423,
-0.0050955825,
-0.0444839969,
-0.020678252,
-0.0448966436,
-0.0051023741,
0.036387872,
-0.0289774891,
0.0234667845,
-0.0089604007,
0.0413564742,
-0.0133461244,
-0.0487894937,
-0.0152551234,
0.0784004852,
0.0225392766,
0.0125937359,
0.0411721654,
0.0066115619,
0.0144703537,
-0.0386144929,
0.0364356264,
-0.0019543942,
-0.0151657416,
0.0139544904,
-0.056850493,
0.021459816,
-0.0188628528,
-0.0136605706,
-0.0063513829,
-0.0095347809,
-0.0088458229,
0.0542008542,
0.0096953679,
-0.0185017176,
-0.0073353187,
-0.0031886497,
-0.0222374182,
-0.0054711397,
0.006662582,
-0.0028133367,
0.0117339566,
-0.009633095,
-0.019737307,
-0.012576906,
-0.0308637582,
-0.0349226557,
0.0721099377,
0.0214967933,
0.0349323303,
-0.0552235022,
0.0159886442,
-0.0413245447,
-0.0107506169,
0.0153896715,
0.0267114025,
0.0185910165,
-0.0400836691,
0.0511593558,
0.0763904676,
-0.0110402405,
0.0137551697,
0.0316553712,
-0.0211304687,
-0.0487187058,
-0.0038337542,
-0.0014234891,
0.0137713403,
0.0093899993,
-0.0261430331,
-0.0192317534,
0.0414091423,
-0.014952586,
-0.0109016094,
-0.0018343452,
0.0568551756,
-0.0130896512,
-0.0042107529,
-0.0338061266,
-0.0063500716,
-0.0273376144,
0.0741086006,
0.0219429564,
-0.0473508164,
0.0584156178,
-0.0014521304,
-0.0142286737,
-0.058053229,
-0.0274293665,
-0.0815439001,
0.0441007987,
-0.0164953154,
-0.0279843658,
-0.0112882396,
-0.0190097969,
-0.0232596211,
-0.0165269952,
0.0247550327,
-0.0274452399,
0.0918724611,
-0.0356027521,
0.008100491,
-0.0048513776,
-0.0138243353,
-0.0447839387,
0.0005376858,
-0.0385513343,
0.0342498012,
-0.008142625,
-0.0090851169,
-0.0007074557,
-0.0015549446,
0.048620183,
0.015233947,
-0.0276561752,
-0.0004396797,
-0.007957384,
0.0047029927,
0.0056256498,
0.025947284,
0.0363287032,
-0.045841042,
0.0731981099,
0.0070910715,
0.0323553607,
0.0098166019,
-0.0219499767,
0.0192453787,
-0.0104828663,
-0.0597091168,
-0.0315756202,
0.0446673185,
-0.0065008625,
-0.1036971956,
0.0244018156,
0.1039771661,
0.0531326719,
-0.0174864549,
-0.0159851592,
-0.1090857312,
-0.0107347202,
0.0326476805,
0.0398732536,
-0.0887639374,
-0.0198152438,
0.0077316756,
-0.022202231,
0.0280365385,
-0.0187691115,
-0.0058294958,
-0.1123078242,
0.0657826513,
0.0125775533,
-0.0026821084,
-0.0056714392,
-0.0448996648,
-0.0083142994,
0.0330470279,
-0.0265541077,
0.0751107261,
-0.0142892255,
0.0173623972,
-0.0050535519,
-0.0180121921,
0.0067399289,
0.0126280906,
-0.0082282433,
-0.0290929098,
0.0257002227,
0.0114189563,
-0.0204144847,
-0.0789417997,
0.036699947,
0.0381345823,
-0.0274490137,
-0.0335355997,
-0.0127651254,
0.0212697685,
0.0080203265,
-0.0268029086,
0.0362353064,
-0.0312918946,
-0.0172692873,
0.066962637,
0.131933555,
-0.0259513445,
-0.003671899,
-0.0044061076,
0.0135460468,
-0.0457615629,
0.0446448289,
0.028074285,
-0.0010536092,
-0.0505199507,
-0.0579153486,
-0.0775991455,
-0.0094802259,
-0.0176533759,
0.0035888925,
0.0227054395,
-0.0010061276,
-0.0198250916,
0.020341007,
0.0817452818,
0.0401500389,
0.0002130273,
-0.0148422122,
0.0276573449,
-0.0033654242,
-0.0383704044,
0.0038408055,
-0.0255917031,
0.0513041168,
-0.0700676963,
0.021206649,
0.0114797531,
-0.0278038066,
-0.0261747539,
0.0003362093,
-0.0656552911,
-0.0526953824,
-0.0258126706,
0.0260415599,
0.0249840505,
-0.0068280743,
0.0054911776,
-0.0203922447,
0.0114040338,
0.025717726,
-0.0489796586,
0.018533539,
-0.0123859495,
0.0209723618,
0.0082069049,
-0.0016765801,
-0.0070886579,
0.0166461021,
0.0056550931,
0.0289487727,
-0.0489251278,
-0.0255506579,
0.0054095853,
0.0761835352,
-0.0249579679,
0.0257660244,
-0.0123841139,
-0.0040742061,
0.0290805716,
-0.0376493968,
-0.0314715207,
-0.021336114,
0.0380197652,
-0.0104164435,
-0.027809076,
0.0334626511,
-0.0173125491,
-0.0060856687,
0.0012075832,
0.0123490877,
0.0967258736,
-0.0054041087,
0.0287102126,
0.0683095008,
-0.0456311628,
0.0207330473,
-0.0200322755,
-0.010424491,
0.0363600403,
-0.0028921838,
0.0715068281,
-0.0094632041,
0.0134533197,
-0.0526841655,
-0.016096808,
-0.0201432705,
-0.1311431527,
0.0327239074,
0.0581038147,
0.0110601615,
0.0486398935,
-0.0304308198,
-0.0329003073,
-0.021693008,
-0.0154866045,
0.0327459648,
0.0562674329,
-0.0232154652,
0.0490287393,
0.0281909555,
-0.0094669079,
-0.0654264838,
0.0175417233,
-0.0384096131,
0.0095479079,
0.0150365271,
0.0205466002,
-0.045866821,
-0.0362453237,
-0.0036943143,
-0.0074242824,
-0.0313498043,
0.0095465872,
-0.0555300899,
-0.0569565594,
-0.0081154965,
0.0131362779,
-0.015666116,
-0.0082075624,
0.0336969644,
0.0665463358,
-0.0092467954,
-0.023636898,
-0.000734413,
0.0709840655,
-0.048450619,
-0.0598730408,
-0.0095482087,
-6.08438778e-33,
-0.0214934759,
-0.0476176627,
0.0637295842,
0.0313300528,
0.0119329514,
-0.0236065611,
-0.0171986856,
0.0326068848,
-0.0038428262,
-0.0084870802,
-0.0225597527,
0.016559884,
0.0103836646,
-0.0172783509,
-0.0059408885,
-0.0281531401,
-0.0039158389,
-0.0190718733,
-0.0293194875,
-0.0165268965,
-0.0130646704,
0.0057027033,
0.0429163389,
-0.0355271958,
0.0184993092,
-0.0027228484,
0.0147969443,
0.0247756932,
-0.0661230832,
0.0672360212,
-0.018486103,
0.0257246941,
0.017961232,
-0.0335515365,
-0.0217819419,
0.0538282543,
-0.0084404461,
-0.019101996,
0.0197187252,
0.0019006063,
-0.0604348779,
-0.0325954296,
0.0330972485,
0.0294589922,
-0.0318064131,
-0.0169519931,
0.0205458626,
-0.042057313,
0.000906602,
0.015347885,
-0.053944625,
0.0561492629,
-0.0055680475,
-0.0262073763,
0.0372379534,
0.0224293713,
-0.0414572433,
0.0041549942,
-0.0017875932,
0.0268689953,
0.0849113464,
0.0204582736,
0.0422672108,
-0.0082076779,
-0.0202082507,
0.0057648495,
-0.0047631362,
-0.0588130131,
-0.0304685477,
-0.0132015655,
-0.0032441756,
0.0740927011,
0.0605430864,
-0.0081201112,
0.026564287,
0.007496668,
-0.0542253815,
0.0133689838,
0.0158430897,
0.0224277657,
0.0185900219,
-0.0040076575,
-0.003459794,
-0.0126371803,
-0.0288315825,
0.0548140593,
-0.0703730509,
-0.0251546055,
-0.0025604197,
-0.0410762802,
-0.0207181256,
-0.0103090154,
0.0220135115,
-0.0372861475,
-0.011740623,
0.0216819439,
0.014421449,
0.0295206066,
-0.0098626334,
0.0267020632,
-0.0222249757,
0.0084681744,
-0.0008610526,
-0.0210874025,
0.0319049358,
0.0099166958,
-0.016164029,
-0.0046917968,
-0.0510527007,
-0.0127987545,
-0.0338561013,
-0.0018164014,
0.0335943736,
0.0426313765,
0.027444873,
0.031339597,
0.0188118815,
0.0480029881,
-0.0321193449,
-0.0688060299,
-0.0404387824,
0.023424441,
0.0067585381,
0.047269769,
-0.0444426276,
-0.0017964049,
-0.0356131084,
0.0147126103,
0.0119185224,
-0.0292890444,
-0.0019104446,
0.0110513922,
3.038e-7,
0.0454131886,
0.0644171759,
0.0075771483,
0.0662378743,
0.0034296447,
0.0177037194,
-0.0194640923,
-0.044271417,
0.0209315866,
-0.0247404184,
-0.0022600077,
0.0504993685,
0.0299117584,
0.0379486457,
-0.0348765291,
0.0348569378,
-0.0287347306,
-0.0217739753,
-0.0755559579,
0.0236755647,
0.0940750092,
0.0452914946,
0.032998316,
-0.0015784607,
-0.0008638624,
-0.0239511412,
0.009089225,
-0.0003394682,
0.0030949337,
0.0155881308,
0.0013150693,
-0.0224389937,
0.045724269,
0.0196765922,
0.0156243872,
0.0000957652,
-0.009466107,
0.0908518806,
0.0250637718,
0.0556554385,
-0.0053716637,
-0.0483050868,
0.0084866509,
-0.050673347,
0.0616480671,
-0.0131672472,
-0.0418369509,
-0.0338359512,
0.0077510527,
-0.0657033697,
-0.0067044795,
-0.03494066,
0.0355837457,
0.0133157754,
0.015700357,
-0.0306040607,
-0.0030490612,
-0.0364200585,
-0.0426760316,
0.031986054,
-0.0579929985,
-0.0405795537,
-0.0360264927,
0.0270765014,
0.0374982245,
-0.0072074169,
0.0091848969,
3.010192158e-34,
0.0486621819,
0.0070210542,
0.0233890451,
0.088872008,
0.0533853807,
0.015738843,
-0.0670023412,
0.0323956981,
0.0278055929,
-0.0713443086,
-0.0030907234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07363v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07363v1
|
Multilingual Power and Ideology Identification in the Parliament: a Reference Dataset and Simple Baselines
| 2024-05-12T19:25:15 | 2024-05-12T19:25:15 |
Çağrı Çöltekin, Matyáš Kopp, Katja Meden, Vaidas Morkevicius, Nikola Ljubešić, Tomaž Erjavec
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce a dataset on political orientation and power position
identification. The dataset is derived from ParlaMint, a set of comparable
corpora of transcribed parliamentary speeches from 29 national and regional
parliaments. We introduce the dataset, provide the reasoning behind some of the
choices during its creation, present statistics on the dataset, and, using a
simple classifier, some baseline results on predicting political orientation on
the left-to-right axis, and on power position identification, i.e.,
distinguishing between the speeches delivered by governing coalition party
members from those of opposition party members.
|
Multilingual Power and Ideology Identification in the Parliament: a Reference Dataset and Simple Baselines: We introduce a dataset on political orientation and power position
identification. The dataset is derived from ParlaMint, a set of comparable
corpora of transcribed parliamentary speeches from 29 national and regional
parliaments. We introduce the dataset, provide the reasoning behind some of the
choices during its creation, present statistics on the dataset, and, using a
simple classifier, some baseline results on predicting political orientation on
the left-to-right axis, and on power position identification, i.e.,
distinguishing between the speeches delivered by governing coalition party
members from those of opposition party members.
|
[
-0.0353233665,
0.0701953843,
-0.0203549862,
0.0549250208,
-0.0493540615,
0.0289385859,
-0.0090077519,
-0.027239332,
-0.0167253762,
0.0125047499,
0.0157860219,
-0.0502938703,
0.0251258258,
-0.0375197306,
0.0435507521,
-0.0701279715,
0.076652959,
0.0319974609,
0.0550896451,
-0.03219942,
-0.0104453648,
0.0292752944,
0.0015909818,
0.0408425182,
-0.0153766023,
0.0101789376,
-0.0234643593,
-0.0073033539,
0.0572193898,
0.029802369,
-0.0077397577,
0.0027474381,
-0.024955608,
0.0005905135,
0.0000015476,
-0.0313287824,
-0.0104577206,
-0.0319578052,
0.0536833741,
-0.033097852,
0.0752191916,
0.00916408,
-0.0112645039,
0.03081006,
-0.0301092472,
-0.007447334,
0.0408696681,
-0.0092588468,
0.0122694038,
0.0127620185,
0.0083307521,
-0.0076825633,
-0.0759308338,
-0.0220983345,
-0.0253229607,
-0.0089885592,
0.0333662666,
-0.0445268191,
-0.0798183903,
-0.0242465399,
-0.0132038053,
-0.0027909281,
-0.0360031389,
0.0013069269,
-0.0616384298,
0.0007007995,
0.0170083474,
-0.0096847005,
0.0196390972,
-0.0055735367,
0.0426364429,
-0.0127978912,
0.0172320101,
-0.006395224,
-0.0173412524,
0.0577524528,
0.0026952834,
0.0143718785,
-0.0214064624,
-0.0003670486,
0.0664955601,
0.018284766,
-0.040311493,
0.0044173161,
-0.0583848655,
0.0709349588,
0.0058879829,
0.0040800264,
0.0299206655,
-0.0415546559,
0.0073084407,
-0.0340171792,
-0.015579368,
-0.0221781954,
0.0150237335,
0.0303573161,
0.0411248878,
0.0112376641,
-0.0008219192,
-0.0903951079,
-0.0299205072,
0.008492603,
-0.019485645,
0.0712266341,
0.0328461416,
0.0028990796,
0.0135156699,
-0.0065823873,
0.0022919842,
-0.0250775982,
0.018171791,
-0.0040913504,
0.0214049518,
-0.0174336713,
0.0191856436,
0.0173375886,
-0.055816479,
-0.0027784228,
-0.0130911237,
0.0170900356,
-0.0376842767,
-0.0116632357,
-0.0039975313,
0.0397465453,
-0.0393902995,
0.1054194421,
-0.0172357503,
0.0379333384,
-0.081579037,
-0.0058769337,
0.0345328599,
0.0628836378,
-0.0176631827,
-0.0204620287,
0.0176450089,
0.0235868134,
-0.0400573164,
0.0332965218,
0.0512574837,
-0.0364428572,
-0.0355290771,
-0.0513517335,
0.048343882,
-0.0369510017,
0.0614617541,
0.0096318228,
0.0096934047,
-0.0551550835,
-0.004460841,
-0.0215576123,
0.0002688248,
0.013384982,
0.039797049,
0.0553553253,
0.0101350248,
0.0044970857,
-0.0096832877,
0.0371310115,
-0.0018347757,
-0.0109717594,
0.0253359713,
-0.0521164052,
0.0033266016,
0.0526108034,
-0.02969799,
0.0261488035,
-0.0377207473,
0.0050393301,
-0.0064440849,
-0.0771939382,
0.0255615413,
0.0140544996,
0.030339187,
-0.001354093,
0.0383526385,
0.0232463647,
0.0151317557,
-0.0151968133,
-0.057546109,
0.0190115292,
0.011980826,
0.0152364429,
0.0279553644,
0.0074680131,
0.0570572168,
-0.0134867234,
0.031705115,
0.0110381255,
0.001894926,
0.0019829585,
0.000716105,
0.0075414134,
-0.0132822953,
0.0129821738,
0.0589825064,
-0.0484555326,
-0.00115407,
0.0065905671,
0.0478225611,
-0.0316959284,
0.010912423,
-0.0124926008,
0.0216759667,
-0.0185479484,
-0.0377503559,
-0.0506618172,
-0.0000601795,
-0.0520526767,
0.051116623,
0.0387781337,
0.0877383798,
-0.0618324503,
-0.0052902,
0.0022836458,
0.0262565203,
0.0602868795,
-0.0081218099,
0.0558822863,
-0.0318663456,
0.0275005605,
-0.024041865,
0.0103138126,
0.018408319,
0.0131391743,
-0.0185965486,
0.0060103131,
0.0210755356,
0.0168050677,
0.0479781516,
0.0132790813,
-0.0167037379,
-0.0242243037,
0.0444174521,
-0.0145518677,
0.0454002656,
0.0212304723,
-0.0250961147,
0.0605271049,
0.0648950562,
0.0020906522,
0.0073536416,
-0.0098091345,
-0.0352408849,
-0.011252881,
0.0934425294,
0.0167719517,
0.008370026,
-0.0381393358,
0.01818249,
-0.0343023092,
-0.0286242701,
-0.0171670262,
0.0126732681,
0.0036760999,
0.0238454286,
0.0223073214,
-0.0805019662,
0.0738298446,
0.0132672805,
-0.0067598065,
0.0029672734,
0.0101981126,
0.009532664,
-0.0077526541,
-0.0283791684,
0.0305649471,
-0.0423295461,
0.0102634141,
-0.0272797458,
-0.0388652608,
0.0520100109,
0.006444158,
-0.020225903,
0.0070916489,
0.0295285918,
-0.0286758989,
-0.0326746814,
-0.0466074236,
-0.0401562415,
0.02495851,
-0.0079702297,
-0.0370797627,
-0.0090128919,
0.0157773048,
-0.0382688567,
0.0000700847,
-0.0240693986,
-0.0726139471,
0.0153728174,
-0.0236341171,
-0.0456045419,
0.0032084656,
-0.0924032331,
-0.0392185822,
0.0016529956,
0.0093700308,
0.0503530167,
0.0321447104,
0.0639976263,
-0.0125870509,
0.0217379648,
0.0115451524,
-0.0618050657,
-0.0190112423,
-0.0663026273,
0.0760461465,
-0.0265279803,
-0.037458349,
0.0118135717,
0.0037627388,
-0.011733979,
0.0154631687,
0.0333821252,
0.0069907717,
0.0010353753,
-0.0163762625,
-0.0097381482,
0.0152613251,
-0.0109424191,
0.0327968337,
0.0546060316,
0.0046264911,
-0.0022128292,
-0.0149937272,
0.0456707664,
0.0007987353,
-0.0141954124,
-0.023526419,
0.0700533465,
0.0015256068,
0.0223814733,
-0.0656224787,
0.0078496458,
-0.0224289019,
-0.0741551146,
0.0261799786,
-0.0447812267,
0.0422840975,
-0.0608108826,
-0.0080772024,
-0.0605870076,
-0.0354083627,
-0.009841484,
-0.0245253425,
0.0117503488,
0.0215083696,
-0.0004455205,
-0.0545202345,
0.006694274,
0.0625513867,
0.0158164557,
-0.0464709885,
0.0282274503,
0.0531005003,
0.035899993,
-0.0183576047,
-0.0082908645,
0.0053858659,
0.016636502,
-0.0283187069,
-0.0625195131,
-0.0002638582,
-0.0254690312,
0.0396941602,
0.0069563589,
-0.0652071089,
0.0399735942,
-0.032612849,
-0.0083928341,
-0.00455005,
-0.0209212005,
-0.0158753991,
0.0179530289,
0.0411075167,
0.0107025262,
-0.0357048213,
0.0086269611,
-0.0039128284,
-0.0301823094,
0.0300773084,
-0.0102585806,
-0.0805240944,
0.0565095544,
0.0405891836,
0.0085176313,
-0.067651622,
-0.0081989635,
-0.0155533319,
-0.0448039435,
0.0143829789,
0.0138143636,
-0.0206718873,
-0.0581827834,
0.0091169467,
0.0443583727,
-0.0374217778,
-0.0643132702,
0.0326375365,
0.0376688018,
0.0145014664,
0.0432158634,
-0.1281770319,
-0.0598364025,
0.0028769451,
-0.0157130267,
0.0097714923,
-0.0163905621,
0.0686009824,
-0.0364613757,
-0.0200537294,
0.0606718138,
-0.0280892532,
-0.064737238,
0.0364150032,
-0.0082639307,
-0.0234985221,
-0.0022180949,
-0.011535448,
0.0535138324,
0.0829857513,
0.0107582882,
0.0669369027,
0.0032728461,
-0.0509439446,
-0.0042920681,
0.0554509759,
0.0315308534,
0.0760485828,
0.0231866241,
0.0237776302,
0.0393134765,
-0.0090277772,
-0.0343853086,
0.0272592772,
-0.0328382179,
-0.0309322979,
-0.0023715124,
0.0014329461,
-0.0172219742,
0.0060877837,
-0.016604865,
0.0238628779,
0.0447597653,
0.0367968641,
0.0247215796,
-0.0193706825,
-0.0144275231,
-0.0340952687,
-0.079226017,
0.0042072432,
0.0400381312,
-0.0106944554,
-0.105905436,
0.0146948174,
0.0359857827,
-0.0493530072,
-0.0474016964,
0.0291360468,
-0.0348855108,
0.0419712141,
-0.0263582505,
0.0218123961,
-0.012387991,
0.0242459401,
-0.0010294092,
0.0470647328,
0.045497492,
-0.0318575613,
0.0206673536,
0.0062456951,
0.0377112515,
-0.0197914802,
0.0183523986,
-0.0231339298,
0.0179931261,
0.0382091999,
-0.0832787976,
-0.0353951715,
0.0068473034,
0.0030696336,
0.0204685275,
0.0054864115,
-0.02488726,
-0.0596206002,
-0.0600278713,
-0.0125386259,
0.0076125655,
-0.0274939146,
0.026817875,
-0.0472830422,
0.0085827354,
-0.0201506373,
-0.0258537289,
0.0161475111,
-0.0243928134,
0.029281674,
-0.0170771405,
0.0848640576,
0.0463961996,
0.0289403778,
0.0212351643,
-0.0284873545,
0.0101058679,
0.0226795692,
-0.0184497442,
0.0492059402,
0.004921834,
0.0024311272,
0.0033671001,
0.0033923248,
0.049369067,
-0.0074570146,
0.0050153364,
-0.0289781373,
-0.0221325643,
-0.0198169369,
0.0163014084,
-0.0275455043,
0.0026884438,
-0.0054644891,
0.0048717293,
-0.0393502451,
0.0143094463,
-0.0595571734,
-0.0307180714,
0.0427626632,
-0.0266992599,
-0.0499277897,
0.0280949734,
0.0310448781,
0.0067003137,
0.0258362163,
0.0301007014,
-0.0074970312,
-0.0329606645,
-0.0503050238,
0.0446321517,
-0.025455039,
-0.0330925696,
-0.0629065186,
-0.0873241872,
-0.0036307871,
0.004053975,
0.0218976829,
0.0153446849,
0.0458651222,
-0.0139004337,
0.0367740542,
0.0035296581,
0.0790876672,
-0.0600294657,
0.0058553168,
-0.0760861486,
0.0206411947,
-0.0036451188,
-5.304943924e-33,
-0.0444614962,
0.0108346958,
0.0057347631,
0.0120064858,
0.0272925254,
-0.0254143756,
0.0089583797,
0.0027355095,
-0.0317082144,
-0.0009169033,
0.0023840636,
0.0049988846,
0.0230804756,
-0.031085778,
0.0083143683,
-0.0150939077,
0.011701039,
0.0143962745,
-0.0183852352,
-0.0083524063,
0.0903709531,
-0.0254307669,
0.0981961489,
-0.0621826984,
0.0302508492,
0.0581960492,
0.0130434055,
-0.0673600957,
0.0123115424,
-0.0025298526,
-0.0046677217,
-0.0236084592,
-0.0012883266,
-0.0175092705,
0.0163511056,
0.0663960874,
0.0122665754,
-0.0202703588,
-0.0204895213,
0.0395037904,
0.0435261801,
-0.0174391922,
0.0062673017,
0.0090903603,
-0.0795668066,
-0.0283959098,
0.0513618141,
0.0295750275,
0.0243636556,
-0.0008816438,
-0.0251621362,
0.0214502346,
-0.0185979027,
0.0165103339,
-0.0199473705,
0.0638816059,
0.0583602488,
-0.0070980331,
-0.080136247,
0.0358335562,
-0.0322777927,
0.0145151978,
0.0284030437,
0.0074224677,
0.013561327,
0.0356950089,
0.0596602,
0.0272613727,
-0.0111504365,
0.025508957,
0.0325241424,
0.0208051819,
0.0876904353,
0.0351905786,
0.0140374666,
-0.0755329207,
-0.0823035091,
0.0144309923,
0.1056338549,
-0.0069324109,
0.0192452371,
-0.0230598487,
0.0204940699,
-0.0351531208,
-0.0180838704,
-0.1026811898,
0.0152877001,
-0.0024755534,
-0.0068758233,
-0.0389480367,
0.007535785,
0.0306620412,
0.0953853279,
-0.0274653044,
0.0054455856,
0.0018947548,
-0.0538465455,
0.0167413708,
-0.026618436,
-0.0156281181,
-0.0424314439,
-0.0430305228,
0.0091568902,
0.0472169891,
0.0806299746,
-0.0119442139,
-0.0095472038,
-0.0096495766,
-0.0611201786,
-0.0261273682,
-0.0080460738,
-0.0114600202,
0.0008506133,
0.0819034949,
0.0348087251,
0.0077018412,
0.0122991791,
-0.0338237211,
-0.0154853091,
-0.0073412424,
0.012577083,
0.0029221263,
-0.0589907393,
-0.0167564359,
-0.062744379,
-0.0262390859,
-0.0016710404,
-0.0051383511,
0.014840357,
0.0419897214,
0.0020082276,
-0.0387845673,
2.291e-7,
0.0317278616,
0.0501313731,
0.0156850051,
-0.0207018163,
-0.0141152609,
0.0055830833,
-0.0187372938,
0.0548249185,
-0.0757603794,
-0.0393995531,
0.0092635565,
-0.0434650779,
0.0390354209,
0.0521729402,
-0.0896285623,
0.0125819547,
-0.0677767023,
0.0206202902,
-0.0541836843,
0.0373562127,
-0.0550884753,
0.0328926295,
0.0323732086,
0.0096121738,
-0.0109198019,
0.0126517657,
0.007594489,
-0.0361686759,
-0.052441895,
0.0341492407,
0.017751174,
-0.0405011624,
0.0302385408,
0.0302831475,
0.0244704019,
-0.0020680865,
-0.0513451435,
0.0634233877,
-0.0035877579,
0.0028845456,
-0.0304629821,
-0.0035549751,
0.0028246667,
0.0158547554,
0.0273864176,
0.0056578149,
-0.028765291,
-0.0425950363,
-0.0382662229,
0.0376981311,
0.0786508545,
0.0483147427,
0.0180839319,
0.0332991704,
0.0194086805,
-0.0540829711,
-0.007911237,
-0.0275437124,
-0.003793366,
-0.0380895883,
-0.0203488413,
-0.0602639541,
0.0420557298,
0.0406116657,
0.0090930425,
0.0227766149,
-0.0296523757,
1.796822553e-34,
-0.0114739798,
-0.00642495,
-0.0828770772,
-0.0019554053,
0.0513815172,
-0.019626148,
-0.005077634,
0.039663177,
-0.013012669,
-0.0328141637,
0.0271901526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07348v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07348v2
|
MedConceptsQA: Open Source Medical Concepts QA Benchmark
| 2024-05-12T17:54:50 | 2024-05-14T16:44:02 |
Ofir Ben Shoham, Nadav Rappoport
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We present MedConceptsQA, a dedicated open source benchmark for medical
concepts question answering. The benchmark comprises of questions of various
medical concepts across different vocabularies: diagnoses, procedures, and
drugs. The questions are categorized into three levels of difficulty: easy,
medium, and hard. We conducted evaluations of the benchmark using various Large
Language Models. Our findings show that pre-trained clinical Large Language
Models achieved accuracy levels close to random guessing on this benchmark,
despite being pre-trained on medical data. However, GPT-4 achieves an absolute
average improvement of nearly 27%-37% (27% for zero-shot learning and 37% for
few-shot learning) when compared to clinical Large Language Models. Our
benchmark serves as a valuable resource for evaluating the understanding and
reasoning of medical concepts by Large Language Models. Our benchmark is
available at https://huggingface.co/datasets/ofir408/MedConceptsQA
|
MedConceptsQA: Open Source Medical Concepts QA Benchmark: We present MedConceptsQA, a dedicated open source benchmark for medical
concepts question answering. The benchmark comprises of questions of various
medical concepts across different vocabularies: diagnoses, procedures, and
drugs. The questions are categorized into three levels of difficulty: easy,
medium, and hard. We conducted evaluations of the benchmark using various Large
Language Models. Our findings show that pre-trained clinical Large Language
Models achieved accuracy levels close to random guessing on this benchmark,
despite being pre-trained on medical data. However, GPT-4 achieves an absolute
average improvement of nearly 27%-37% (27% for zero-shot learning and 37% for
few-shot learning) when compared to clinical Large Language Models. Our
benchmark serves as a valuable resource for evaluating the understanding and
reasoning of medical concepts by Large Language Models. Our benchmark is
available at https://huggingface.co/datasets/ofir408/MedConceptsQA
|
[
0.0286674947,
0.04638936,
0.0159443934,
-0.0071998718,
-0.0256370753,
0.035589274,
-0.005453703,
0.0254070926,
-0.0055724448,
-0.0181894396,
-0.0175373834,
-0.0539043471,
-0.0318666622,
0.0111564146,
0.0080388654,
-0.0424510427,
0.025709942,
0.0047796266,
0.0106524946,
-0.0193618033,
-0.0204089507,
0.0131038986,
-0.0547734387,
0.0327008851,
0.0348849818,
-0.0375419371,
0.0299421586,
-0.017093759,
0.0115616368,
-0.0804712325,
0.0104107028,
0.0499586798,
-0.0043253233,
0.018808743,
0.0000018667,
-0.0694232732,
-0.0201454442,
0.0190498326,
-0.0324036889,
-0.0174661558,
-0.0076813134,
-0.0581439473,
0.0151281347,
0.0257223099,
-0.0369830914,
-0.060963165,
0.0273315869,
0.0359347202,
0.0411651172,
0.0456091948,
-0.0036051311,
-0.0368220285,
0.0072444649,
-0.0282530561,
0.0464899801,
-0.1010039821,
0.0340363942,
0.0400897637,
0.0299962293,
-0.0156108774,
0.0043195998,
0.0179314725,
0.0120843267,
0.0680890828,
-0.0106986612,
0.0586570278,
-0.0542219728,
-0.0030037516,
0.0206038337,
0.1087586507,
0.0016837934,
-0.0121835181,
-0.007168035,
-0.0009912011,
-0.0312099122,
0.0005395107,
-0.0509045646,
0.0148589164,
-0.023928022,
-0.0027853148,
0.0012221372,
-0.0004388526,
0.0428681858,
0.017484501,
-0.0020390239,
0.0194399133,
0.0246881396,
-0.0049273823,
0.0378253274,
-0.0179955699,
-0.0538625717,
-0.0129007474,
0.0210595001,
0.0679177865,
-0.0320076756,
0.0220117625,
0.0017398384,
0.0060634525,
0.081287019,
-0.0455874018,
0.0041882801,
0.0234768409,
-0.0182937048,
0.0761416331,
-0.0359240323,
0.0166462418,
-0.0453720167,
0.0376342349,
-0.0398099422,
-0.02333395,
-0.0460123383,
-0.0203610621,
-0.0557161309,
0.0243045911,
0.015494477,
-0.0146922944,
-0.0689841509,
-0.0258577988,
0.000775664,
0.0054054847,
0.0104882037,
0.0334130526,
-0.0180465747,
-0.0165740568,
-0.0212055314,
0.0287801493,
-0.0523572229,
0.0089476397,
-0.0314428881,
-0.0595717691,
-0.0181116294,
-0.0242845435,
0.0039774748,
-0.0301965531,
0.0519343801,
0.0432775132,
-0.0024750931,
-0.0252576489,
-0.0017887108,
-0.0489005558,
-0.0073626894,
-0.0371166095,
-0.0033215275,
-0.0732244104,
0.0178055149,
0.0294849258,
0.0051964247,
-0.0238075797,
0.0168183725,
0.0247670468,
-0.0443213843,
0.0892491862,
-0.0496050678,
-0.0141355982,
0.0210707374,
0.0572089478,
-0.0106282001,
0.0583255254,
-0.0150223728,
-0.0445387363,
0.0169190001,
-0.0321385562,
0.0062137637,
-0.0074987477,
0.0350360237,
-0.0442105308,
0.0221401341,
0.0425874814,
0.0337208286,
0.1002391279,
-0.0437233187,
0.072530441,
-0.009613446,
-0.0217974056,
-0.0159376506,
0.0713662431,
0.0034530098,
0.0022339954,
0.0124190506,
-0.0322330222,
0.0339848436,
-0.031009376,
-0.0000194972,
0.0190549549,
0.0086114733,
0.0161547177,
-0.0284150653,
-0.0115572978,
-0.0366115868,
-0.0094352001,
-0.0522972196,
0.0049017826,
-0.0497484058,
-0.0107864467,
0.0544909015,
-0.0055477661,
-0.0350837372,
0.0658623204,
0.0422079675,
0.006765482,
-0.021624092,
-0.0297091287,
0.0229818467,
0.0338392705,
0.0427615717,
-0.0451563299,
-0.0704143569,
-0.0056409612,
0.0354568362,
0.000157874,
0.0198522359,
-0.0315723009,
0.0255614538,
-0.0517357439,
0.0325059108,
0.0164467506,
0.0140396589,
-0.0351890177,
0.0397928916,
0.0501437783,
-0.0150941182,
-0.0536225922,
0.0230118111,
0.0272368398,
-0.03968326,
-0.0575379096,
-0.0108623765,
-0.0221658181,
0.0260763932,
-0.0048601138,
-0.0040442878,
0.024205856,
0.0251585823,
-0.0202600509,
-0.0132173635,
-0.0072172582,
-0.0486576967,
-0.0329221226,
0.0345673375,
-0.0259877741,
-0.0373076759,
0.0028322022,
-0.0656018704,
-0.0265687034,
-0.0053404188,
-0.0303680301,
0.0179767646,
-0.0045047612,
-0.0239253771,
0.0324264504,
0.0036678324,
-0.049109228,
0.032860633,
-0.0137773436,
0.0467884503,
0.0146487979,
-0.0020782894,
0.0170358494,
-0.014269392,
-0.0246984679,
0.0168974027,
-0.0028122095,
-0.003891258,
-0.0473344773,
-0.0115471706,
-0.0519188754,
-0.0175123978,
-0.0852052718,
0.0194930304,
0.016447993,
0.0098528592,
0.04801552,
0.0260911714,
-0.0054522925,
-0.0247578397,
-0.0504891463,
0.012465952,
0.0184842367,
0.0170243699,
0.0472741984,
0.0579382703,
0.0199491512,
-0.0380334668,
0.0000628707,
-0.0460449643,
0.0221716613,
-0.0027823402,
0.0280589238,
0.0241066832,
-0.0163377468,
-0.0566559955,
0.0119366106,
-0.0013512196,
-0.0253758822,
0.01916942,
-0.0315068327,
-0.0276697688,
0.0627427101,
-0.003519797,
-0.0116331289,
0.0349185839,
0.0086673247,
-0.0102122519,
0.0351553336,
-0.0249068066,
-0.0588776208,
0.0137159741,
-0.0331195071,
-0.0288274419,
0.0982510373,
0.0029499833,
-0.0161517523,
-0.0372511894,
0.0241970476,
-0.0259468239,
0.0392125063,
-0.0684910119,
0.0462565348,
-0.0337407291,
0.0344037265,
-0.0100302128,
-0.0081911264,
0.0907620266,
0.0071120779,
0.0210341252,
-0.0647090152,
0.0251997858,
-0.0408582129,
0.0312073678,
-0.0181230307,
0.0345850512,
-0.0041519972,
-0.0081219971,
-0.0255676415,
-0.0011375491,
0.0089269243,
-0.068151094,
0.043332994,
-0.0389193967,
0.039564725,
-0.0051838513,
-0.0477484353,
-0.0291873757,
0.0021525172,
-0.0589269772,
0.0101558985,
-0.0029184096,
0.0088298647,
-0.021109825,
0.0094804047,
-0.0109387543,
0.0599241778,
0.0310863163,
-0.0088262986,
-0.0058771516,
0.0364606045,
0.0610688999,
-0.0058927848,
0.0048546363,
-0.0083972057,
0.040934816,
0.0817292631,
0.0124042714,
0.0067424309,
0.0103002666,
-0.0032587568,
-0.0017053117,
-0.0242996737,
0.0059019262,
0.0158439204,
0.0293430854,
-0.0514105447,
-0.0226936806,
0.1221940592,
0.0511709452,
-0.0364458933,
0.0121465279,
-0.0229860041,
0.0052477424,
-0.006832744,
0.0284632128,
-0.0920379385,
-0.0647521615,
-0.013146136,
0.0508770309,
0.0091775255,
-0.0307006221,
0.0092619341,
-0.052619271,
0.0035944956,
-0.0240742993,
-0.0726154596,
-0.0170100424,
-0.0430616178,
-0.0105210403,
-0.0204859935,
-0.0112711061,
0.0023470582,
-0.0095806485,
0.0164247956,
-0.0029139055,
-0.058167126,
-0.0463952124,
0.0787096843,
-0.0102688493,
0.0550717935,
0.0342907868,
0.0138734672,
-0.0265882052,
-0.0178765561,
0.0186514799,
-0.0552024022,
-0.0047597503,
-0.0044800327,
0.0800246671,
0.0141455103,
-0.01852246,
-0.058368437,
0.051580485,
-0.0489495397,
-0.0340254232,
-0.0063863504,
0.078583613,
-0.000802941,
-0.0381186567,
-0.0222969111,
0.0243194848,
-0.0100661675,
0.0661765784,
-0.0131493257,
0.0227230638,
-0.052845519,
0.0255684648,
0.0616562441,
0.0067076059,
-0.0250058025,
0.038057711,
0.016509505,
0.0007669113,
-0.046768479,
-0.036598485,
0.0653826222,
0.0111695025,
-0.0171398185,
0.0333508588,
-0.010232646,
0.0343108736,
-0.0709684342,
0.0647919849,
0.013855123,
0.0117702922,
-0.0638908073,
-0.0375571251,
0.0840807185,
0.0071488768,
-0.0340477042,
0.0112984283,
-0.0386173725,
0.0170570202,
-0.0009595299,
0.0340104662,
0.015343939,
-0.0227921419,
-0.0302979778,
-0.0303644445,
0.0201747157,
-0.0041999277,
-0.0325118043,
-0.0150571931,
0.0101947021,
0.0020343221,
0.0046406868,
0.0305076092,
-0.0381480269,
0.0112674069,
-0.0058786836,
0.0459121764,
-0.0144501124,
-0.0088596726,
0.045847062,
0.0468877442,
0.011541808,
-0.0059428387,
0.0035209809,
0.0010473424,
0.0264430959,
0.0051003043,
0.0140122809,
-0.0010259018,
0.0038432213,
0.0672613829,
-0.0302518122,
-0.0243374128,
-0.0090297461,
-0.0498786718,
-0.0277936682,
-0.0096332971,
0.0271928832,
0.0455754735,
-0.0117374938,
0.0749877095,
-0.0413923189,
-0.0138036199,
0.0009719481,
-0.014866082,
0.0649732277,
-0.0159117561,
0.0669499114,
0.012909892,
0.021794511,
0.000761707,
0.0303033628,
-0.0450407229,
-0.0641016588,
0.0024972064,
0.0237476006,
0.0453256071,
0.0120291747,
0.0048268107,
-0.0082593318,
-0.0123906005,
-0.0070827315,
-0.0152738718,
-0.0405666754,
0.0051274584,
0.0960398391,
0.0318217017,
0.0154384803,
0.0091699343,
0.11770726,
-0.005078637,
0.0872729719,
0.0158433318,
-0.0168650541,
-0.0293351728,
-0.0043728282,
-0.0066841939,
0.0291386098,
-0.0470690988,
0.0363992713,
-0.0748248994,
-0.0502382331,
0.009247683,
-0.0087364437,
-0.0402630344,
0.0090389596,
0.0765138268,
0.0532288514,
0.0218006913,
-0.04032268,
-0.0218880065,
0.0664640814,
-0.0493797995,
-0.0059355209,
0.0325221345,
-6.082830617e-33,
0.0131713999,
-0.0106695946,
0.0239584725,
-0.0502416156,
0.0134539781,
0.0307932924,
-0.0392670818,
-0.012680456,
-0.0463718958,
0.0608318523,
-0.022949392,
0.0159955416,
-0.0035909477,
0.035065826,
-0.0115642883,
-0.0499573387,
-0.0087647559,
0.0071453373,
-0.0162710324,
0.0330059975,
-0.018312633,
0.058099959,
0.0366167016,
-0.0207793713,
-0.0254907403,
-0.0077541335,
0.0213903897,
0.0345023274,
-0.0228463355,
0.0644749552,
-0.047138501,
0.00735068,
0.0462561846,
-0.0148967979,
0.0213677436,
-0.0235410202,
-0.0788702071,
-0.0251776539,
0.0075701652,
-0.0010712626,
-0.0538966618,
-0.0301069189,
0.0194552653,
-0.0245087892,
-0.0020166228,
-0.0267219841,
-0.0025365131,
-0.0331675671,
-0.0021109839,
-0.0396811664,
-0.0132107809,
0.0427396744,
-0.0169395637,
-0.0008595801,
-0.0340973176,
0.0029148876,
-0.0286896396,
0.0684069917,
-0.0088751055,
-0.0175491367,
0.0142412717,
0.0283676665,
0.0173462853,
-0.0227290969,
-0.0046724989,
0.0561652742,
0.0329723731,
-0.036618486,
-0.0420127511,
0.0205089152,
-0.0545123704,
0.0191862248,
0.0618904643,
0.0499055907,
0.0567223132,
0.0138661619,
-0.1162094548,
0.0289717447,
-0.0615896955,
0.0806723908,
0.00438574,
-0.0390745737,
-0.0531958565,
0.0007533639,
-0.0546522476,
0.0269905813,
-0.0372534469,
-0.0224829819,
0.0490933843,
-0.0250625107,
-0.0007298089,
0.0086240135,
0.0021215838,
-0.0181651823,
0.0253656823,
-0.0012509387,
0.0266703703,
0.0100108068,
-0.0299588125,
0.0554979742,
-0.0548660569,
0.0058450685,
0.0246430729,
-0.0222955868,
0.0346459746,
0.0214628428,
0.0110889524,
-0.0279084574,
-0.0566286966,
-0.0062746508,
-0.016734289,
-0.0045455582,
-0.0271783806,
0.0214956943,
0.0224781763,
0.0337741859,
-0.0020520273,
0.0452233627,
0.0050774929,
0.0177423172,
-0.0296106897,
-0.0496536009,
-0.0208053347,
0.0052613062,
-0.0402392522,
0.0003632898,
-0.0248893742,
0.0595982745,
0.0112929037,
-0.0613235123,
-0.011026633,
0.0308565553,
2.669e-7,
0.1165832803,
0.0544666722,
-0.0051966705,
0.0092697134,
0.0261942707,
0.0004796125,
-0.0098934462,
-0.0122488029,
-0.0170927849,
-0.019294614,
0.0096989861,
0.0328365676,
0.0179052204,
0.0536131561,
-0.0717391372,
-0.0084228124,
-0.0768479854,
-0.019694142,
-0.0171255022,
-0.0558268204,
0.0296032075,
0.0964307263,
-0.0525592826,
-0.0368258581,
0.0281939115,
-0.0279808324,
0.0441608466,
-0.0060153697,
0.0073331124,
0.0494980663,
0.006158011,
0.0142619424,
0.0329265259,
0.0297092162,
-0.0099696787,
-0.037285991,
0.0001234587,
0.0683963969,
-0.0415671505,
-0.0208888315,
-0.0115385847,
-0.0309953336,
0.0393809117,
-0.0699734241,
0.084888719,
-0.0621836632,
-0.0671827793,
0.0034725158,
-0.0329818763,
-0.0341572575,
0.0625164062,
-0.0137480367,
-0.0192664377,
0.023844488,
0.0057013663,
0.0089862021,
-0.0177175943,
-0.0760156587,
-0.0127786733,
0.0304609705,
-0.0041413386,
-0.0357124247,
0.0297571197,
-0.0433224067,
0.005475306,
-0.0724724531,
0.0074817454,
1.964514399e-34,
0.0333025232,
-0.0041959416,
0.0269920826,
0.0428184755,
0.0099394703,
-0.0240482185,
0.0269738119,
-0.0167928021,
0.0297279134,
-0.0540907122,
0.0092553273
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07320v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07320v1
|
L(u)PIN: LLM-based Political Ideology Nowcasting
| 2024-05-12T16:14:07 | 2024-05-12T16:14:07 |
Ken Kato, Annabelle Purnomo, Christopher Cochrane, Raeid Saqur
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The quantitative analysis of political ideological positions is a difficult
task. In the past, various literature focused on parliamentary voting data of
politicians, party manifestos and parliamentary speech to estimate political
disagreement and polarization in various political systems. However previous
methods of quantitative political analysis suffered from a common challenge
which was the amount of data available for analysis. Also previous methods
frequently focused on a more general analysis of politics such as overall
polarization of the parliament or party-wide political ideological positions.
In this paper, we present a method to analyze ideological positions of
individual parliamentary representatives by leveraging the latent knowledge of
LLMs. The method allows us to evaluate the stance of politicians on an axis of
our choice allowing us to flexibly measure the stance of politicians in regards
to a topic/controversy of our choice. We achieve this by using a fine-tuned
BERT classifier to extract the opinion-based sentences from the speeches of
representatives and projecting the average BERT embeddings for each
representative on a pair of reference seeds. These reference seeds are either
manually chosen representatives known to have opposing views on a particular
topic or they are generated sentences which where created using the GPT-4 model
of OpenAI. We created the sentences by prompting the GPT-4 model to generate a
speech that would come from a politician defending a particular position.
|
L(u)PIN: LLM-based Political Ideology Nowcasting: The quantitative analysis of political ideological positions is a difficult
task. In the past, various literature focused on parliamentary voting data of
politicians, party manifestos and parliamentary speech to estimate political
disagreement and polarization in various political systems. However previous
methods of quantitative political analysis suffered from a common challenge
which was the amount of data available for analysis. Also previous methods
frequently focused on a more general analysis of politics such as overall
polarization of the parliament or party-wide political ideological positions.
In this paper, we present a method to analyze ideological positions of
individual parliamentary representatives by leveraging the latent knowledge of
LLMs. The method allows us to evaluate the stance of politicians on an axis of
our choice allowing us to flexibly measure the stance of politicians in regards
to a topic/controversy of our choice. We achieve this by using a fine-tuned
BERT classifier to extract the opinion-based sentences from the speeches of
representatives and projecting the average BERT embeddings for each
representative on a pair of reference seeds. These reference seeds are either
manually chosen representatives known to have opposing views on a particular
topic or they are generated sentences which where created using the GPT-4 model
of OpenAI. We created the sentences by prompting the GPT-4 model to generate a
speech that would come from a politician defending a particular position.
|
[
-0.0201069433,
0.0647586212,
0.0103194332,
0.0573344938,
-0.0465965904,
-0.0003249767,
-0.0108373873,
-0.0184204523,
-0.0077175265,
-0.0354771093,
0.0136881787,
-0.0206983946,
-0.0333871916,
-0.0155079095,
0.0055973586,
-0.0604538769,
0.0459159054,
0.0617289841,
0.0641545355,
-0.0422579162,
0.008802929,
-0.0029675195,
-0.0194856804,
0.0487489253,
-0.0106599145,
-0.0249082204,
-0.0549152493,
-0.0164408758,
0.1096586883,
0.009761462,
0.002666808,
-0.0142904129,
0.0006252142,
-0.0117713958,
0.0000016615,
-0.0072518215,
-0.0259023849,
-0.0317144729,
0.0668826699,
-0.0021464932,
0.0435675643,
0.06241142,
-0.0290635768,
0.0550837852,
-0.0572343767,
0.0507088825,
0.0494462326,
0.0442585126,
0.0700349063,
0.0511977784,
-0.0002457622,
-0.0372607224,
-0.0078568226,
-0.0064514694,
0.0089431992,
-0.0001082149,
0.034886986,
-0.0412483476,
-0.0803577453,
0.0159776211,
-0.0172081124,
-0.0188844539,
-0.0045182495,
-0.0060895248,
-0.0363373943,
0.0159780327,
0.0026250642,
-0.0312251486,
0.0044971756,
0.0446848981,
0.0373192988,
-0.0007027778,
0.0188920088,
-0.0294434559,
-0.0287306141,
0.041440051,
-0.0285578333,
0.0230148006,
-0.0075624795,
0.0637306497,
0.0673661754,
0.0021210508,
0.0000634964,
0.0283436012,
-0.055145666,
0.0755819306,
0.0059705456,
-0.034101665,
0.0334354118,
-0.0196899157,
-0.006759766,
-0.0178981666,
0.0003603781,
0.0141174654,
0.0473212749,
0.0356080942,
0.0094188461,
0.0016833843,
0.0252313465,
-0.0751056969,
0.007451789,
0.0309298076,
-0.0214441214,
0.0581431016,
0.0258364063,
-0.0064721247,
-0.0221561268,
0.0237765517,
0.0074318424,
-0.0040195831,
-0.0156188216,
-0.0083401222,
0.0038138342,
0.0363468081,
0.0054102456,
-0.0044776788,
-0.0384652875,
0.0180438068,
-0.0493753776,
0.0059863157,
0.0065045669,
0.0208573435,
0.030050071,
0.0349485427,
-0.058299277,
0.0685876533,
-0.0294997636,
0.0372550301,
-0.0405116081,
-0.0041657598,
0.0138159255,
0.0649391711,
-0.0010133403,
0.0082906866,
0.0144492732,
0.027755769,
0.0191071536,
0.0231661033,
0.016643418,
0.0028228497,
-0.0545229688,
-0.0470628776,
0.0327203088,
-0.0649144277,
0.0110014537,
-0.0202529896,
-0.0041346252,
-0.0393110849,
0.0140190534,
0.0080679795,
-0.0169762913,
0.0535648875,
0.0100181382,
0.0043925261,
0.0277910903,
0.0295547768,
0.0308326278,
0.0377548561,
0.0356255025,
0.0107023921,
0.0143463518,
0.0065609892,
0.0080975508,
0.03441469,
0.0129572181,
-0.0042264764,
-0.0421168767,
0.0195033886,
-0.0568341762,
-0.0152053926,
0.0129372375,
0.0610712618,
0.0193363298,
-0.0178041961,
0.0336103551,
0.0604696684,
-0.0044465745,
0.0322315134,
-0.0229755491,
0.0114221182,
0.0476131774,
0.0107581867,
0.0369677432,
0.0532163344,
0.0303088985,
-0.011849232,
0.0625847206,
0.0137019241,
-0.0012663633,
-0.0373797156,
0.0043838159,
-0.0003010687,
-0.0195014607,
-0.0320053101,
0.0309229698,
-0.0509101637,
-0.0203108992,
0.0266313404,
0.0332424678,
-0.0786055252,
-0.0081819426,
-0.0539466254,
0.0525525883,
0.0035910069,
-0.0083343638,
-0.0449883863,
-0.0577394776,
-0.0225077774,
-0.0142512154,
0.0669239834,
0.0709622502,
-0.0609224997,
-0.0282811094,
-0.013116261,
0.0108329402,
-0.006520099,
0.0175773986,
0.0403447039,
-0.0075503951,
0.0289977062,
-0.0202351008,
-0.0071287807,
0.0444047041,
0.0296952985,
0.0075212945,
0.012864192,
0.0041933088,
0.0286461618,
0.0839822963,
0.0450298749,
-0.0307417959,
-0.0085491361,
0.0743291304,
-0.0123929614,
-0.0035996758,
-0.0025093665,
0.0105065992,
0.0224261321,
0.0523494259,
-0.0637646616,
-0.0031189548,
0.0079319179,
-0.0418775864,
0.0035607084,
0.0504229069,
0.0126633737,
0.0055037737,
-0.077349633,
-0.0211901702,
-0.0346692055,
-0.0417226516,
-0.0634450167,
0.0680672079,
-0.0158655122,
0.0021135595,
0.0124241766,
-0.0609901249,
0.0733848736,
-0.0338969007,
-0.0161110144,
-0.0364421681,
0.0552607365,
0.0327548832,
0.0189607963,
-0.020032078,
0.0023742241,
-0.0778238699,
-0.04979809,
-0.0132788755,
-0.0212333761,
0.062222328,
0.0122853685,
-0.0428611487,
0.0077195596,
0.0425088778,
-0.0194579363,
-0.0051577855,
-0.0342093334,
-0.0279749408,
0.064658165,
-0.0036508357,
-0.0210655294,
-0.0315396227,
0.0462772138,
-0.0425845496,
-0.0146924816,
-0.0017015587,
-0.0224517509,
0.0126910591,
-0.0117139667,
-0.0787042528,
0.0047329557,
-0.0397536755,
-0.0650254562,
0.0419561453,
-0.006004395,
0.0473277792,
0.0222670734,
0.06355571,
0.0657437518,
0.0257394277,
0.0154988933,
-0.0594477914,
-0.0182101335,
-0.0651776865,
0.0614795871,
-0.0152260186,
-0.0330154374,
0.0224374346,
0.028118385,
0.0034525963,
-0.0074609793,
-0.0341985635,
0.0666235313,
0.0254937988,
-0.0094601018,
-0.0052576032,
0.0153530547,
-0.0345697403,
0.0092740962,
0.0407030657,
-0.0430211984,
0.0295794588,
-0.0153847169,
0.0682157725,
-0.0205224901,
-0.0187154822,
-0.0330562443,
0.040942017,
-0.0224314611,
0.000125097,
-0.0553016588,
0.033048369,
-0.0240564849,
-0.0276388898,
-0.0036178764,
-0.0430125408,
0.0482486263,
-0.0325806811,
0.014383981,
-0.0277390834,
-0.0146747027,
-0.0150828399,
-0.0632278249,
-0.0024571761,
-0.0023250226,
0.0045745643,
-0.0660647377,
0.014743018,
0.0184871219,
0.0036372128,
-0.0753231868,
0.0399578437,
0.0317207612,
0.0136689888,
0.0063706702,
0.0116404239,
-0.0157233309,
0.0092919832,
0.0130996732,
-0.0119856745,
0.0329918861,
-0.0001663628,
0.034643095,
-0.0653737932,
-0.0677284226,
-0.0006975583,
-0.0276254695,
-0.0208706222,
-0.0029657239,
-0.012288671,
-0.0021072403,
0.0162051208,
0.0675524026,
0.0414188839,
-0.0117430314,
-0.0101704989,
-0.0072732433,
-0.0221323576,
-0.0012667432,
-0.0103206104,
-0.098868005,
0.0344731584,
-0.0007131792,
-0.003143497,
-0.0602003746,
-0.0307066031,
-0.0100547299,
-0.0777205899,
0.0076047988,
-0.0110091716,
-0.0023998702,
-0.0502053387,
-0.0202056374,
0.0320008583,
-0.0042772172,
-0.0324887559,
0.0075078756,
0.0474703759,
0.0444954932,
0.0236059874,
-0.0987033546,
-0.0248728301,
0.0162487794,
-0.0111000184,
0.0396735817,
-0.0009280656,
0.1057446375,
-0.0233661197,
-0.0621045567,
0.0314569771,
-0.0377324931,
-0.0334366448,
0.0089382576,
0.0168537032,
-0.0505887158,
-0.0261018053,
-0.0362198576,
0.0506856553,
0.0541153215,
-0.0165227782,
-0.0078575583,
0.0487037748,
-0.0911979824,
0.005762422,
0.0054713953,
0.0465887487,
0.0440419614,
0.0593339056,
0.0177404545,
0.0026242256,
-0.0208558235,
-0.0396461189,
-0.011778417,
-0.0378992669,
-0.0142071489,
-0.0283355154,
-0.0318475589,
0.0249562357,
-0.0359179638,
-0.0151826777,
-0.0058066817,
0.0285608415,
0.0089440634,
0.0059107919,
0.00959206,
0.022705555,
-0.0232084859,
-0.0318564847,
0.0170568246,
0.0003565871,
0.0110096484,
-0.0689850375,
0.0474583879,
0.0202834681,
-0.0635799021,
-0.0277293026,
0.0028666588,
-0.0742188394,
0.0018263463,
0.0215755701,
0.0237090699,
-0.0134752123,
-0.0087684803,
0.0075245854,
0.0533622578,
0.0506758317,
0.035666164,
0.0196956918,
0.0264741108,
0.097540006,
0.0207030084,
0.0226983223,
-0.0083954306,
0.007851446,
0.0358280726,
-0.0676396042,
-0.0912453607,
-0.057057444,
-0.0093616927,
-0.0045679645,
0.0440611616,
0.0048100525,
-0.057906244,
-0.0572421849,
0.0039865086,
-0.0161046851,
-0.0247147977,
-0.0086670639,
-0.0329224691,
-0.0021023841,
-0.0467225872,
-0.0590070114,
0.0069512408,
-0.0282485206,
0.053928569,
-0.0065984214,
0.0871553123,
0.031148592,
0.0162184332,
-0.0109931501,
-0.0370759293,
-0.0011359084,
-0.0202294718,
-0.0344422907,
0.0121621406,
0.0105211101,
0.0175163113,
0.0120831365,
0.0243155193,
0.0614429004,
-0.0140080815,
-0.0319976769,
-0.042373281,
-0.0395165235,
0.054888621,
0.0030495599,
0.0442534983,
0.0052648908,
-0.0249951724,
-0.0167318042,
-0.0126928361,
0.0508682318,
-0.0282279719,
-0.0305590648,
0.0686340407,
-0.0284505654,
-0.0478137434,
-0.0286681317,
0.0109675759,
0.0020415594,
0.0379465297,
0.0280226786,
-0.0220925882,
-0.0296309646,
-0.0240392517,
0.0370823666,
-0.0368531086,
-0.0246778335,
-0.0200710874,
-0.0453263521,
0.0047463737,
0.0346968845,
0.0557064861,
0.006284974,
0.0282221679,
0.0093971444,
0.0478984043,
-0.0062890607,
0.0730608553,
-0.0332136862,
0.0191917587,
-0.0846322626,
-0.0066552954,
0.0162167512,
-5.806760626e-33,
-0.0405755304,
-0.0177812446,
0.001363723,
0.0289381091,
-0.0124110114,
-0.0137237441,
-0.0188964717,
0.0044180807,
-0.0318903774,
0.033544343,
0.0191709064,
0.0449746288,
0.022436155,
-0.0049303295,
-0.0100301541,
-0.0390882045,
0.0037557441,
0.0052472209,
-0.0154812513,
-0.025062792,
0.059511438,
-0.0189737268,
0.0616387166,
-0.0522003472,
0.0330892839,
0.0267055295,
-0.0042043077,
-0.040169213,
-0.0269062705,
0.0005895758,
-0.0195997395,
-0.0049335281,
0.0218378399,
0.0096767107,
0.0258798897,
0.0923677683,
-0.0016397829,
-0.0394954048,
-0.0174697004,
-0.0199566968,
-0.0075914892,
-0.0255204644,
0.0139932455,
0.0255070683,
-0.0742176622,
0.0172577351,
0.0471229479,
0.0073979921,
0.0520323291,
-0.0311028529,
-0.01484056,
0.0159382261,
-0.0221233666,
0.0104765017,
-0.0391306095,
-0.0053811073,
0.0452434123,
0.0300369058,
-0.0860022753,
0.0285159107,
-0.0162159819,
-0.0085461345,
0.0104344487,
-0.0495450422,
0.032662686,
0.0861739442,
0.0050895391,
-0.0212215167,
-0.0723086447,
-0.0233131535,
0.0105943251,
0.0207573734,
0.0644815043,
0.0154048558,
0.0227305479,
-0.0385512747,
-0.1150380373,
0.0293168612,
0.1074491441,
0.0166824237,
0.0118529042,
0.0080891484,
0.0484121516,
0.0074318009,
-0.0229783002,
-0.0908622742,
-0.0171746109,
-0.0097174486,
-0.0139063802,
-0.0272730868,
-0.0024382405,
0.01468335,
0.0396250896,
-0.0279811099,
0.0310480818,
0.0158074889,
-0.0446856655,
0.0190064553,
-0.0272767525,
-0.0163675044,
-0.0694250911,
-0.0244163126,
-0.0211405475,
0.019489916,
0.0504572354,
-0.0158930924,
-0.0014220527,
-0.0055873389,
-0.0855235755,
-0.0293661114,
-0.0135169746,
-0.035767097,
-0.0070447004,
0.0686595887,
0.0279141739,
0.0151283648,
0.0220472813,
-0.0115254363,
-0.0259146765,
0.0410107747,
0.002733689,
-0.0282708928,
-0.01475666,
-0.0146314539,
-0.0212038402,
-0.0184149761,
-0.0047576446,
0.0345492326,
-0.0388146564,
-0.0453124084,
-0.005513709,
-0.001544486,
2.546e-7,
0.0447997488,
0.048911348,
0.0153739965,
-0.0084658973,
0.0053965845,
0.0126610706,
-0.0094315745,
0.0245463066,
-0.0737336278,
-0.0729649812,
0.0074728914,
0.0012019156,
0.0320890062,
0.023424821,
-0.0668413043,
-0.0033383863,
-0.0567487478,
-0.0085296752,
-0.0376186892,
0.0406306833,
0.0080149937,
0.0529291146,
0.0556144156,
0.0205675606,
0.0030803785,
0.0229687989,
0.0519843549,
-0.0017075236,
-0.0380732343,
0.0224424023,
0.0272401627,
-0.0571554415,
0.0161391106,
0.0120509975,
0.0331149176,
0.0038472251,
-0.0301274639,
0.0684453174,
-0.0234224759,
-0.0348328426,
-0.0433991328,
-0.016522862,
0.010251116,
0.0046755662,
0.0509390086,
-0.0315622427,
-0.0178674329,
-0.0292607285,
-0.0292006824,
0.0237346645,
0.0742467046,
0.010797427,
0.021631429,
-0.0133073628,
-0.0010424339,
-0.0489959121,
0.0076350868,
-0.0855084583,
-0.0046231807,
-0.0422063954,
-0.049624823,
-0.0660984963,
0.0352494083,
0.0146118738,
0.0613709427,
-0.0409118831,
-0.0208782461,
1.899857388e-34,
0.0270581152,
-0.0141978087,
-0.0534646362,
0.0042756642,
0.0475645177,
0.0116300266,
0.0125465691,
0.0111307781,
0.0023276734,
-0.0486888364,
0.0221579913
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07282v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07282v1
|
Branching Narratives: Character Decision Points Detection
| 2024-05-12T13:36:07 | 2024-05-12T13:36:07 |
Alexey Tikhonov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7
|
This paper presents the Character Decision Points Detection (CHADPOD) task, a
task of identification of points within narratives where characters make
decisions that may significantly influence the story's direction. We propose a
novel dataset based on CYOA-like games graphs to be used as a benchmark for
such a task. We provide a comparative analysis of different models' performance
on this task, including a couple of LLMs and several MLMs as baselines,
achieving up to 89% accuracy. This underscores the complexity of narrative
analysis, showing the challenges associated with understanding character-driven
story dynamics. Additionally, we show how such a model can be applied to the
existing text to produce linear segments divided by potential branching points,
demonstrating the practical application of our findings in narrative analysis.
|
Branching Narratives: Character Decision Points Detection: This paper presents the Character Decision Points Detection (CHADPOD) task, a
task of identification of points within narratives where characters make
decisions that may significantly influence the story's direction. We propose a
novel dataset based on CYOA-like games graphs to be used as a benchmark for
such a task. We provide a comparative analysis of different models' performance
on this task, including a couple of LLMs and several MLMs as baselines,
achieving up to 89% accuracy. This underscores the complexity of narrative
analysis, showing the challenges associated with understanding character-driven
story dynamics. Additionally, we show how such a model can be applied to the
existing text to produce linear segments divided by potential branching points,
demonstrating the practical application of our findings in narrative analysis.
|
[
0.0018350623,
-0.0016840321,
-0.04866964,
0.0410960875,
-0.039247904,
0.0262786094,
-0.0170511547,
0.0098937238,
0.0181061886,
0.0156931877,
0.0261660405,
-0.0229394585,
0.0367437452,
0.0504692607,
-0.0278091915,
-0.0327844881,
0.0087459395,
-0.0140386894,
0.0593398251,
0.0281932522,
-0.0207890887,
0.0409794971,
-0.0044178925,
0.0383325368,
0.0000790323,
-0.0430841707,
-0.0198251717,
0.0286751445,
0.0494982824,
-0.0743196756,
0.0002826832,
-0.0191412307,
0.0065638153,
-0.0043406524,
0.000001896,
-0.0463636555,
-0.0103545468,
-0.0529496856,
-0.0337855667,
-0.0232494194,
-0.0039352323,
0.0388522185,
0.0365395918,
-0.0194813572,
0.0011834359,
0.0100085624,
0.0245565381,
0.0311248694,
0.0403832719,
0.0639456287,
-0.0155295944,
-0.0492705591,
-0.0428556353,
0.0141968103,
-0.0010317391,
0.0105015701,
-0.0133960601,
0.0460522808,
0.0512606874,
-0.0523515269,
-0.0347208641,
-0.0051357904,
-0.0149981705,
0.0215631817,
-0.0341651328,
0.0665240213,
0.0469252244,
0.0501086935,
-0.0081160795,
0.0770980269,
-0.0019360018,
-0.0110307885,
0.0090734037,
-0.0438480303,
0.0242862795,
-0.0130528007,
-0.0353980735,
0.0299186222,
-0.0447016135,
0.0108332103,
0.0029684983,
0.0224136189,
0.0176883228,
-0.0308704562,
0.0195457824,
0.0595704503,
-0.0066739433,
0.0150851393,
-0.0352229103,
-0.0045972536,
-0.0192367584,
-0.0462232344,
-0.0148055153,
0.0567100942,
0.0020527306,
0.0250560064,
-0.0529942103,
0.0751161277,
-0.016463453,
-0.0410440564,
0.0515932031,
-0.0092488863,
0.0357061662,
0.0266284253,
0.0379598811,
0.0089038573,
0.0286664888,
-0.0048532044,
0.0056524067,
0.0381238088,
-0.0069855643,
0.0039045487,
-0.0281071309,
0.02216327,
-0.0224223565,
-0.032914795,
-0.0205836203,
0.0177971944,
0.0207020678,
0.0233403295,
0.0013910903,
0.0175545271,
0.0244248305,
-0.0009412498,
-0.0409018211,
0.019547658,
-0.0591054671,
0.0033396119,
-0.0195643883,
0.0405762233,
0.0012846454,
-0.0483633243,
0.0617795885,
0.0028791546,
0.0404670201,
0.1020111665,
0.0379407629,
-0.030750962,
-0.0298801083,
-0.0527674332,
-0.0262636188,
-0.0710935742,
-0.056598071,
-0.0557608232,
0.0227960441,
-0.0130801853,
0.0453488268,
-0.0001957995,
0.0205824319,
0.0067874263,
0.0027284289,
0.0278883372,
0.0019610452,
0.0171912834,
0.0163420867,
0.0043625948,
-0.0049980106,
0.0096355369,
0.085576199,
0.0503754169,
0.0570298284,
0.0176554117,
0.0378468297,
0.0250288993,
-0.0543413721,
-0.0077048824,
-0.0132366186,
-0.0190739874,
-0.0126074273,
0.0718931034,
-0.0319359154,
0.0206504501,
-0.0579835847,
-0.0496577024,
0.0810325965,
0.0870880634,
0.034607552,
-0.0497879945,
0.0648900419,
-0.0019126486,
0.033441212,
0.0229756292,
0.0055309851,
0.0058608386,
0.042853754,
-0.0256428085,
-0.1044170111,
-0.0030636939,
0.0066187382,
-0.0214575287,
0.0055783275,
0.0024573435,
-0.0376697257,
-0.008613674,
-0.0024796021,
-0.0434065759,
-0.0434347615,
-0.0206234697,
0.024626717,
-0.0735086054,
0.0410586111,
-0.0023997899,
0.0449000224,
0.0794541389,
0.0735470578,
-0.0680752024,
-0.0880787224,
-0.056893792,
0.0096549308,
-0.021091504,
-0.0238334388,
-0.0610242635,
0.0755237862,
-0.0294322371,
0.012830128,
0.0057146801,
0.0234592389,
0.0445556603,
-0.0133778742,
-0.0001122506,
-0.0465308093,
-0.0615732409,
-0.010017259,
0.0444445126,
-0.0327489935,
0.0110929096,
-0.0094768023,
0.0077779731,
-0.0318344459,
0.0060476484,
-0.0104444558,
-0.0449069627,
0.0416732281,
-0.0220344346,
-0.0079887901,
0.0842752233,
-0.0088926079,
-0.0530570783,
0.042974934,
-0.0579579435,
-0.035339471,
-0.0280785952,
0.0074987495,
-0.0180798136,
0.0193569977,
-0.0573141463,
-0.0053193113,
0.0074102557,
0.018334819,
-0.0138135618,
-0.0005187123,
-0.0399473011,
0.084977679,
-0.007945885,
0.0143378172,
-0.047313448,
-0.0003466465,
0.0118603949,
-0.0279542077,
0.0687188506,
0.008394327,
0.0285677258,
-0.029954534,
0.0151494117,
-0.0556646921,
-0.0031649829,
-0.0485848114,
-0.065157257,
0.0193160176,
0.0078913011,
-0.0004209951,
0.018472774,
-0.0188073944,
-0.0704896972,
0.0245025102,
-0.0242488775,
0.0129264472,
0.0170530602,
-0.040655788,
0.0329460725,
0.0436955132,
-0.0011054887,
-0.0074550514,
0.0143850604,
-0.0284303203,
0.0774090365,
0.0437768847,
-0.0321950167,
-0.0507137105,
-0.0232679397,
-0.0042496291,
0.0009962857,
-0.0457972214,
0.0039906367,
0.0207475238,
-0.0151028335,
0.0664893091,
0.0346024111,
-0.0018904398,
0.0358335376,
0.0663229674,
-0.1086220816,
0.0009142006,
0.0194346383,
-0.0177319925,
0.045568008,
-0.0766757205,
-0.0758215934,
0.0389789976,
0.0555021241,
0.0101655656,
0.0239970796,
-0.036064133,
-0.0051513123,
0.0262400266,
0.0014866412,
0.0111778583,
-0.0389719009,
-0.0307880901,
0.0363967642,
-0.0111113079,
-0.002835721,
0.0508308858,
-0.0329595655,
0.0325362682,
0.0206373129,
-0.0055019003,
-0.0785003752,
0.1243487895,
0.0274353307,
0.036318846,
0.0386271998,
-0.0301885698,
-0.0076665366,
-0.0069679432,
0.0625369996,
-0.0150362346,
0.0437990613,
-0.0420281515,
-0.0348948725,
0.0276400913,
0.0090952376,
-0.0197676886,
-0.0054696728,
-0.0432800241,
-0.0428621396,
0.0602905862,
-0.0429256074,
-0.0088212593,
0.0020547451,
-0.0233309306,
0.0017176523,
-0.0132839028,
-0.0043885764,
-0.0006736293,
0.0669217929,
0.0551691838,
-0.0119041447,
0.0335900895,
-0.0686210021,
0.0542329662,
0.0301691759,
-0.0411155783,
-0.022109488,
0.0091931792,
0.0028090759,
0.0170634501,
-0.0558079854,
-0.0193699095,
-0.0026529771,
0.0396197736,
-0.0884188563,
-0.0027672823,
0.1059764326,
0.0432397686,
-0.0389190689,
0.0041706334,
0.0160634257,
-0.0127151795,
0.0311250109,
-0.0066209459,
-0.0406452194,
-0.0168292411,
-0.004126193,
0.0129060475,
-0.0116037922,
-0.0770835876,
-0.0469578058,
-0.0503517613,
0.0482032299,
-0.0128632346,
-0.0229322463,
-0.0177744534,
-0.0031883023,
0.0084392261,
-0.0153327938,
-0.0699804798,
-0.0172766689,
-0.0413877293,
-0.0185506921,
-0.026709687,
-0.0526723601,
0.0601135865,
0.0157623198,
-0.0491881855,
0.0397763848,
-0.012185541,
0.0954739228,
-0.0028772512,
0.0480001047,
0.0237538926,
-0.0017474993,
-0.0117183169,
0.0073075108,
0.0744218826,
-0.0324035212,
0.0030651342,
-0.0363082662,
0.0271453001,
0.0408628024,
-0.0428443998,
0.0226410348,
0.0453043357,
-0.0120382644,
-0.0554108582,
-0.0117551312,
0.0479696691,
-0.0105855213,
0.020552054,
0.0047987811,
-0.0375598073,
-0.0537236221,
-0.009346324,
0.0383885242,
-0.0516725853,
-0.0075372327,
-0.0221100152,
-0.0012988269,
0.0214900821,
-0.0504672751,
-0.0423960686,
0.0037468041,
0.055898048,
0.0231622122,
0.0309133697,
-0.0245296434,
0.0194397308,
-0.0388849117,
-0.0080243172,
-0.0320292972,
0.0088237301,
0.0012085906,
0.0467471294,
0.0139681334,
-0.0464633219,
0.0192022044,
0.0379460491,
-0.0581598915,
-0.0473991483,
-0.0289866347,
-0.0065427064,
0.0144312987,
0.0173241049,
0.0100743016,
-0.0312053934,
0.0002605998,
0.0122019416,
0.0127670718,
0.0460573174,
-0.023091495,
0.0622405373,
-0.0309303999,
0.0029651669,
-0.0036286176,
0.0186489224,
-0.0138942469,
0.0019792044,
-0.0844913945,
-0.0158494208,
0.0105279684,
-0.0276885722,
0.004127902,
-0.0453055389,
-0.0394087806,
-0.0820670649,
-0.0144781815,
-0.0299190506,
-0.0178037193,
-0.0067198658,
-0.0291509535,
0.0193533842,
-0.0081262905,
-0.0592668094,
-0.0013116902,
-0.0257971697,
0.0028406985,
-0.0388146415,
0.0130830072,
0.0875311047,
-0.0189631581,
-0.001659608,
0.0051309946,
-0.0093992632,
0.0085371975,
-0.0528803878,
0.0430823639,
0.0192285329,
0.0158198383,
-0.0005687248,
-0.0394556671,
-0.021296259,
0.0002411305,
-0.0331478938,
0.0037482474,
0.0210857484,
-0.0031760265,
0.06339214,
-0.0200169552,
0.0151340086,
-0.0195796099,
0.0024602588,
-0.0082440199,
0.0133441519,
-0.0066234241,
-0.030857794,
-0.0505820066,
0.0403613187,
-0.0447826646,
0.0477982163,
0.0313214697,
0.0298647713,
0.073543258,
0.0226919465,
-0.0530381165,
-0.0261746105,
-0.0441891514,
0.0104619758,
0.0354959406,
0.0057771513,
0.0008403698,
-0.0952517837,
-0.0085860416,
0.059248656,
0.0223196559,
0.0595826954,
-0.0084922211,
-0.0227240603,
-0.0146677056,
0.0290535055,
0.0165878925,
-0.0583188161,
0.0447003804,
-0.0270643625,
-0.0037452665,
0.0118858358,
-5.301162506e-33,
-0.0441950709,
-0.0423183329,
0.0044154758,
0.0547487475,
-0.0868021175,
0.0200832281,
-0.0124692144,
-0.0084850267,
0.0063528605,
0.0470325984,
0.0232446752,
0.0256683342,
-0.0045868014,
-0.034819074,
-0.0154268974,
-0.0144660166,
0.0268296804,
0.0137579506,
-0.0585800596,
0.0202437174,
0.0492602326,
0.0322571546,
0.0166985206,
-0.0342344418,
-0.0040643374,
-0.0524110012,
-0.0301861092,
0.0046676407,
0.0113809826,
0.010601352,
0.0034225706,
0.0032551491,
0.0259006787,
0.0124446824,
0.0068360837,
-0.006834168,
-0.0751270428,
0.0065497104,
-0.0226623137,
-0.0065861936,
0.024555929,
-0.0401661173,
0.0046963957,
0.0307639893,
0.0313784555,
-0.0560285747,
0.086935319,
-0.0234292112,
0.0036001019,
-0.0175365955,
-0.0632231906,
0.0379899256,
-0.0401307642,
-0.0137417447,
0.008261485,
0.0590724535,
0.0271724071,
-0.0034302289,
0.0086853458,
0.0491511412,
0.0171236452,
-0.0021551775,
-0.0426303409,
0.0313300826,
0.0034190221,
0.1033941507,
0.0179627687,
-0.0128028188,
-0.0443114415,
0.0415232182,
-0.0042585647,
0.0135272881,
0.0464862324,
0.0328519084,
-0.0486360863,
-0.0144394003,
-0.0991621912,
0.0245085508,
0.0567726903,
0.0058466122,
0.021497814,
-0.0000983481,
-0.0460931249,
-0.0141483974,
-0.0105571533,
-0.0776582733,
0.0063247597,
0.0076119639,
-0.0216848142,
-0.0410894975,
-0.0361431427,
0.014566578,
0.0152015733,
-0.0295151267,
0.0097815776,
0.0255399123,
-0.0018531162,
0.0662237629,
0.0058996081,
0.0312491041,
0.0164583791,
0.0024177493,
0.0089875394,
-0.0184770506,
0.0626227334,
-0.0180107672,
-0.0123831229,
0.0343446471,
-0.0382043906,
-0.00127945,
0.0049894527,
-0.0043882695,
-0.0442118831,
0.0236105826,
0.0314213783,
-0.0320509896,
-0.0093578398,
0.0067102029,
-0.004350611,
0.0423522554,
-0.0103435321,
-0.0406124108,
-0.0482704081,
0.007481188,
-0.0030814337,
0.008161989,
0.0011237729,
0.0626635104,
-0.0094195623,
-0.0427380055,
-0.0157389976,
-0.0028626984,
2.637e-7,
0.012482293,
0.0276968908,
0.0365580805,
-0.0231048875,
0.0128566148,
0.0308937076,
-0.0151629848,
-0.001457738,
-0.0057381615,
-0.0575870648,
0.0642341375,
0.0160837192,
0.0242460463,
0.0568116568,
-0.0796401575,
0.0087367715,
0.0142422803,
-0.0334103145,
-0.051041197,
-0.0285712965,
0.0493626259,
0.0197452903,
0.0682819486,
-0.0006202434,
0.0254095998,
-0.0007353487,
0.0243818909,
-0.0459175631,
-0.0113365958,
0.052203875,
-0.0140113719,
-0.0380895548,
-0.0615012273,
-0.0223924108,
0.0066396529,
0.0449537002,
-0.0000893702,
0.0264096111,
-0.0191845316,
0.0124308066,
0.0050779684,
-0.0117807621,
-0.0167857744,
-0.007764874,
0.0517277271,
-0.0040692217,
-0.035479527,
-0.0491189063,
0.0131497243,
0.0104189068,
0.0274211802,
0.0054270569,
-0.0117103867,
0.0351415202,
-0.0242826864,
-0.0206389688,
0.011743783,
-0.0997248366,
-0.0002493476,
0.0444978625,
-0.0235666092,
-0.0040115993,
0.012890269,
0.0427642986,
0.0054658507,
-0.0707652196,
0.0343017392,
2.248890818e-34,
-0.0132469302,
-0.0071546286,
-0.0421009324,
0.019273553,
0.0431543812,
-0.0053064674,
0.0173098128,
0.0104477648,
0.0553329736,
-0.0271709412,
0.0000733195
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07280v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07280v1
|
Humor Mechanics: Advancing Humor Generation with Multistep Reasoning
| 2024-05-12T13:00:14 | 2024-05-12T13:00:14 |
Alexey Tikhonov, Pavel Shtykovskiy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.HC, 68T05, 68T30, 68T50, 91-08, I.2.7; I.2.1; I.2.6; H.5.2
|
In this paper, we explore the generation of one-liner jokes through
multi-step reasoning. Our work involved reconstructing the process behind
creating humorous one-liners and developing a working prototype for humor
generation. We conducted comprehensive experiments with human participants to
evaluate our approach, comparing it with human-created jokes, zero-shot GPT-4
generated humor, and other baselines. The evaluation focused on the quality of
humor produced, using human labeling as a benchmark. Our findings demonstrate
that the multi-step reasoning approach consistently improves the quality of
generated humor. We present the results and share the datasets used in our
experiments, offering insights into enhancing humor generation with artificial
intelligence.
|
Humor Mechanics: Advancing Humor Generation with Multistep Reasoning: In this paper, we explore the generation of one-liner jokes through
multi-step reasoning. Our work involved reconstructing the process behind
creating humorous one-liners and developing a working prototype for humor
generation. We conducted comprehensive experiments with human participants to
evaluate our approach, comparing it with human-created jokes, zero-shot GPT-4
generated humor, and other baselines. The evaluation focused on the quality of
humor produced, using human labeling as a benchmark. Our findings demonstrate
that the multi-step reasoning approach consistently improves the quality of
generated humor. We present the results and share the datasets used in our
experiments, offering insights into enhancing humor generation with artificial
intelligence.
|
[
0.0565473437,
0.0511958152,
-0.0004843216,
0.0094269188,
-0.0236760546,
0.0124872997,
0.0337356403,
0.02100759,
0.0478524566,
-0.0331676491,
0.049230095,
-0.0100809699,
-0.0067629977,
0.0666810721,
0.0309812948,
-0.0848104209,
-0.0233882368,
-0.0020459727,
0.041315455,
-0.0195960756,
0.0001400123,
0.0125741465,
-0.0529542156,
0.0378678627,
-0.0351925865,
0.0142269582,
0.0042755716,
0.0625247732,
0.0159075111,
-0.0343063101,
-0.0178481173,
0.0140391886,
0.0062477775,
-0.0069840937,
0.0000017003,
-0.0661906898,
0.0137731684,
-0.0262212027,
0.007871653,
-0.0134314252,
-0.003172904,
-0.0130379163,
-0.046611052,
0.0206327997,
-0.0313626938,
0.0468772277,
0.0606596954,
0.0260238629,
0.0825807452,
0.0733972117,
-0.0109377261,
-0.0292830504,
-0.0202133227,
-0.0315487795,
0.0538385101,
-0.0455978774,
0.0078702001,
0.033830177,
0.0315555818,
-0.0360251628,
-0.0325401388,
-0.005819662,
0.0195758231,
-0.0000373281,
-0.0305567812,
0.075648509,
-0.0149023263,
-0.0077408212,
-0.0192622971,
0.0309897922,
0.0009617229,
0.0353824235,
0.0132421944,
0.015879577,
0.0098596234,
-0.0320603549,
-0.0571698062,
0.0380871557,
-0.0189997312,
-0.0215737224,
-0.0268641748,
0.0352708697,
-0.0251311176,
0.0313630737,
0.0122957807,
0.0455932692,
0.0271658096,
-0.0186788049,
-0.0378246531,
-0.0072965566,
-0.0290004946,
-0.059848506,
0.0490319394,
0.0837584436,
0.0285998676,
0.0285319444,
0.0004352373,
0.0007357468,
0.0514820889,
-0.0388658419,
0.0043061734,
0.0350476317,
0.0169032663,
0.0726317242,
-0.0402000137,
0.0300182942,
-0.018218942,
-0.0102785164,
-0.0248358361,
0.0195792243,
-0.0553526692,
-0.001625206,
-0.0338654034,
0.0353531763,
-0.0016661154,
-0.0228620302,
-0.0657989159,
0.0298908167,
0.0250782669,
-0.0213394798,
0.0093259672,
0.0505044051,
-0.0334151685,
-0.0431267023,
-0.0170161314,
0.0288727358,
-0.0855645239,
-0.0092822807,
0.0076330956,
-0.0304968823,
-0.0373889953,
0.0227361489,
0.0556022897,
-0.0324651264,
0.0184748489,
0.0629030988,
-0.0136010302,
-0.014746665,
-0.0286233034,
-0.0721483529,
-0.0646831542,
-0.0742347687,
0.0228218809,
-0.0529819056,
0.0278658103,
0.0077933394,
-0.0165025722,
-0.0143986521,
0.0103485491,
0.0283374954,
-0.0441938937,
0.0205964614,
-0.0504431985,
0.0104013719,
0.0391041711,
0.030509159,
-0.0372899473,
0.0314877778,
0.0301923305,
0.0287989676,
0.0087388651,
-0.0000324451,
0.0322291255,
-0.0277619641,
0.005905089,
-0.0153791467,
-0.0094110295,
-0.0336946771,
-0.0482892357,
0.0443221666,
0.0171856601,
0.0360701196,
-0.0395938009,
0.0679880679,
0.0173417535,
0.0307388827,
0.011118779,
0.0477603748,
0.078244321,
-0.0412205197,
-0.0270647109,
0.0204134732,
0.014678658,
0.0481785238,
-0.0440056175,
0.0137180462,
0.0295613017,
0.0296913963,
-0.0158401262,
-0.038945809,
-0.0161798969,
-0.0127926162,
0.0583366193,
-0.0605404712,
0.039436277,
0.0534864478,
-0.0353392884,
0.0256675761,
-0.0093836598,
-0.0773381367,
-0.0276820529,
-0.0046383576,
0.0084768273,
0.0809155628,
0.0414460935,
0.0176634062,
-0.0364920273,
0.0019640066,
0.0506937243,
0.0397998504,
-0.000396291,
0.0247093532,
0.0180990845,
-0.0390789509,
0.0332710147,
-0.040263813,
0.003707984,
0.0348566994,
0.0220144223,
0.0311239194,
0.0028848804,
0.024481874,
0.0892547667,
0.0338882431,
-0.066448167,
0.0022407032,
0.007239074,
0.0187343881,
0.0095165502,
-0.0071604117,
-0.0004930153,
-0.0004639631,
-0.0015653551,
-0.0445985906,
-0.0474724807,
0.056731496,
-0.0303253084,
-0.042291943,
0.0354779288,
-0.0747524351,
-0.0141189443,
-0.0051280833,
-0.0092165647,
-0.0314787738,
0.0418453254,
-0.0472878739,
-0.0121962791,
-0.0592139699,
-0.0332937576,
0.0022394522,
-0.0012922036,
0.0078277988,
0.0828627348,
-0.0177992601,
0.0129993185,
0.0032797479,
0.0056007323,
0.0379762575,
0.0001322098,
0.0164261796,
0.040227171,
-0.0237006638,
0.0232842937,
-0.0008677585,
0.0508187115,
-0.0273011345,
-0.0392052606,
-0.0701261759,
0.0097913407,
0.0109948153,
-0.0321444757,
0.0240733847,
-0.0003649816,
-0.0229243636,
-0.0251219552,
-0.0139600597,
-0.0073332926,
0.0031423438,
0.0013194301,
0.0456271172,
-0.0081777163,
-0.0273521431,
0.014478175,
-0.002441148,
-0.0497705676,
0.0098495958,
0.0644156411,
0.067112267,
-0.0530822873,
-0.0075920173,
-0.0949636027,
-0.0436103269,
0.0188524816,
-0.0556510352,
0.0434211791,
-0.0261369646,
0.0173090659,
0.0597242452,
0.0486848019,
0.0274608657,
0.0199850108,
-0.0229870994,
0.0149199469,
0.0066006263,
-0.008149758,
0.0612760223,
0.0405303761,
-0.0212497693,
-0.0224233642,
0.0195874739,
0.0287770443,
0.0535047092,
-0.0993468687,
0.1018261462,
0.0351848081,
0.0176571086,
0.0096306326,
-0.0272995867,
-0.0281502567,
0.0118019376,
-0.0171294156,
-0.0049920403,
0.1016107947,
-0.0119631635,
-0.028738495,
-0.0117713846,
0.0311641973,
-0.0012434811,
0.0842228457,
-0.0283482317,
0.0445997566,
-0.0140368557,
-0.0094435904,
-0.0034773771,
-0.0067995116,
0.0226144176,
-0.013938332,
0.0171318483,
-0.0552989207,
-0.021945795,
0.0064085955,
-0.0567229949,
-0.0153070092,
-0.0163770709,
-0.0340881534,
-0.002565776,
-0.0398296081,
-0.0240846779,
-0.0045071384,
-0.0029879017,
0.0096701449,
-0.0111735761,
-0.0422106944,
-0.0268449765,
-0.0131541928,
0.0070396075,
0.0451163277,
-0.0063167061,
-0.0180482008,
-0.0035231411,
-0.0016179172,
0.0310283229,
-0.0139364731,
0.0369383916,
0.0027864475,
0.0295044929,
-0.0200882945,
0.0011083672,
-0.001175106,
0.0211563408,
0.0336771421,
-0.0362391435,
-0.0403756164,
0.0571426675,
0.0168914553,
0.0301676914,
0.0212552994,
-0.0016424183,
-0.0079939412,
0.0023379817,
0.0158024449,
-0.037385352,
-0.0364634432,
0.0168879591,
0.0028116994,
-0.0207439438,
-0.0237519406,
-0.0488601252,
-0.1042001769,
0.0325858071,
0.0193613283,
-0.012718345,
-0.014098498,
0.0098079052,
-0.0083280411,
0.0163322315,
-0.0632425919,
0.0091967909,
0.0335672572,
0.0282371435,
-0.0019517376,
0.0387651809,
-0.034142185,
-0.0010396589,
0.0058665839,
0.0628400519,
0.0534733348,
0.066049099,
0.0087985462,
-0.0660018399,
-0.0168534052,
-0.0356399901,
0.0143501461,
-0.015381108,
0.0426940024,
0.0217755344,
0.0218419712,
-0.0225334968,
0.0460721366,
-0.0319941342,
-0.0307599548,
0.015066511,
0.0486531742,
-0.035288915,
-0.0412684046,
-0.0426068343,
0.0451316275,
-0.0189478751,
0.08660312,
0.0458052494,
-0.0475035124,
-0.0483194217,
-0.0607333295,
-0.0086405044,
-0.1043749973,
-0.0002424339,
-0.0322535522,
0.0113375857,
-0.0220546126,
-0.0923355445,
-0.0114811221,
0.0131983534,
0.0747185126,
-0.0227171034,
-0.0485981666,
-0.0771051794,
0.0297942795,
0.0042109573,
-0.0457843915,
0.002254586,
-0.0180552751,
-0.0115811685,
0.0223446302,
0.0083487201,
-0.0800176561,
-0.0303032082,
0.0317969434,
-0.0333418697,
-0.0461134538,
0.0086388877,
0.0628767461,
0.0363649614,
-0.0154087273,
-0.0397549607,
-0.0375165381,
-0.0034343484,
0.0706360862,
0.0038023377,
0.0203991458,
0.0132164694,
0.0492272563,
0.025836207,
0.0082306461,
-0.0213225503,
0.0432479344,
0.0198830701,
0.0396416783,
-0.0364939906,
-0.0284831002,
0.005634835,
0.0191112552,
0.0277598295,
-0.039540045,
-0.0629396141,
0.0316605754,
-0.0216359012,
-0.0305382572,
-0.0316045918,
-0.0160544422,
0.0209359024,
-0.0013335214,
-0.0115172258,
-0.0348100774,
-0.0452538058,
-0.0276647955,
0.0190837979,
0.0077539785,
-0.0446103401,
0.0380283333,
-0.0006237503,
0.0181683097,
-0.0082697775,
-0.0162447542,
-0.0040957383,
-0.0169560984,
0.0192717537,
-0.0187780242,
0.0589437447,
0.0275870785,
-0.0310269035,
0.0040562577,
0.0521089733,
-0.0257987473,
-0.0414339304,
0.016133178,
-0.0170905292,
0.063951619,
0.0291782785,
0.0579469539,
-0.0281911064,
0.0075507616,
0.0229476206,
0.0378091708,
0.0114598088,
-0.0729641765,
-0.0155104734,
0.0211915411,
0.0107264668,
-0.0631674528,
0.070130825,
-0.0864619911,
0.0157728903,
0.00442449,
-0.0131340688,
-0.0418415815,
-0.0338041596,
-0.0344875269,
0.0344021916,
0.049286332,
-0.0048581217,
-0.0452727266,
-0.0252970159,
-0.0027507029,
0.0113640362,
0.020069357,
0.0200898983,
0.0432653874,
0.0529111736,
-0.0131911654,
-0.0035193653,
-0.0365707278,
0.0276479796,
-0.0432314388,
0.0047956426,
-0.0223124884,
-6.033832339e-33,
-0.0192647446,
-0.0462406687,
-0.0076930509,
0.0179183055,
0.0068117962,
-0.033197917,
-0.0910812616,
0.0189141445,
0.0095225535,
0.0122617641,
0.0030880764,
-0.0082562706,
-0.0168971848,
-0.0093499031,
0.0366630666,
-0.0196762774,
0.0139390491,
0.0185683239,
-0.0552162342,
0.0265778229,
0.0480183549,
0.0216610637,
0.0035499821,
-0.0430314131,
-0.0116857039,
-0.0066290782,
-0.055315312,
0.0058046402,
0.0221165717,
0.0367915444,
0.0152908433,
0.0278112441,
0.048642952,
0.0082923258,
0.0104887718,
0.028082775,
0.0014525347,
-0.0389136635,
-0.0197237059,
-0.0541437902,
-0.0459147841,
-0.0472765304,
0.0495208651,
-0.0084183579,
-0.0121733788,
-0.0114786271,
0.0482406132,
-0.0157364886,
0.0442744568,
-0.0441723391,
-0.0473141968,
0.0000508756,
-0.0412381589,
-0.0661698282,
-0.0026018647,
0.0468411967,
0.019898789,
0.0005210719,
-0.0202068239,
0.0613303073,
-0.0751263872,
-0.0445095971,
-0.0131414663,
-0.0753748268,
-0.0014019735,
0.0444057845,
-0.0075964341,
0.0348275825,
-0.0267330855,
-0.0084121283,
-0.0093663009,
0.0569331795,
0.0893756226,
0.0339944921,
0.0427744985,
-0.0485822558,
-0.0398428217,
0.0413745269,
0.0043285307,
-0.0156550519,
0.0359023921,
0.0164826624,
-0.060088966,
0.0095090978,
0.0544455461,
-0.0091025801,
0.001148827,
-0.1050926298,
-0.0123249628,
0.0353636146,
-0.0259337053,
-0.0224739648,
0.0031948425,
-0.0096461158,
0.0148165924,
0.0021450035,
-0.0324709937,
0.0264157746,
-0.0031174356,
0.0013509163,
-0.0232678857,
-0.0050224625,
0.0423376076,
0.0715482682,
0.0345240086,
0.0309759062,
0.0532356091,
0.0054721809,
-0.0345274471,
0.0037051376,
-0.0607858822,
0.0299414191,
0.0051666223,
-0.0551354475,
-0.0079276934,
0.0565057173,
-0.0148922903,
-0.0314006247,
0.0482396558,
0.008808299,
-0.0478708893,
0.0220322162,
0.0078600775,
0.0239612181,
-0.0497106425,
-0.0168844629,
-0.0096418895,
-0.078804329,
-0.0098733809,
-0.0666677728,
-0.0213293508,
0.0078406874,
2.663e-7,
0.0161081254,
0.0657033324,
0.0454443246,
0.0358964205,
0.0467967242,
0.0431960896,
-0.0254924167,
0.0031977766,
0.0062944372,
0.008888348,
-0.0053312681,
0.0294856206,
0.0127974637,
0.0090667028,
-0.0739636347,
0.0344853103,
-0.0450481921,
0.0145790093,
-0.0339322463,
0.0043445732,
0.0805729777,
-0.051937405,
0.0368516631,
-0.008100098,
0.0275410246,
-0.0561051667,
0.0204208568,
0.0181614328,
0.0495005436,
-0.0044678343,
0.0001562057,
-0.0139452247,
-0.0103371507,
0.0180722866,
0.0058353618,
-0.0804869458,
-0.0004547828,
0.0597644374,
-0.0368147492,
-0.006232596,
0.023094967,
0.0087636625,
0.0196780041,
-0.0552757941,
0.0672957152,
0.0127088977,
-0.018036535,
-0.0032794334,
-0.0098857628,
-0.0169549175,
0.0246927738,
0.0118118785,
-0.0352019556,
-0.0055690329,
0.0299352128,
0.0187769718,
0.0239422042,
-0.0499111339,
-0.0558755547,
0.0287341215,
-0.0637334213,
-0.006461313,
-0.0071350923,
-0.0181447882,
0.0314600393,
-0.1110062599,
-0.0282231718,
2.110522047e-34,
0.0098148929,
-0.0126900338,
0.0353456363,
-0.0223122761,
0.0323105529,
0.0279815663,
-0.0072308779,
-0.013372804,
0.0377225727,
0.0135445977,
-0.0407258868
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07278v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07278v1
|
Human-interpretable clustering of short-text using large language models
| 2024-05-12T12:55:40 | 2024-05-12T12:55:40 |
Justin K. Miller, Tristram J. Alexander
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7
|
Large language models have seen extraordinary growth in popularity due to
their human-like content generation capabilities. We show that these models can
also be used to successfully cluster human-generated content, with success
defined through the measures of distinctiveness and interpretability. This
success is validated by both human reviewers and ChatGPT, providing an
automated means to close the 'validation gap' that has challenged short-text
clustering. Comparing the machine and human approaches we identify the biases
inherent in each, and question the reliance on human-coding as the 'gold
standard'. We apply our methodology to Twitter bios and find characteristic
ways humans describe themselves, agreeing well with prior specialist work, but
with interesting differences characteristic of the medium used to express
identity.
|
Human-interpretable clustering of short-text using large language models: Large language models have seen extraordinary growth in popularity due to
their human-like content generation capabilities. We show that these models can
also be used to successfully cluster human-generated content, with success
defined through the measures of distinctiveness and interpretability. This
success is validated by both human reviewers and ChatGPT, providing an
automated means to close the 'validation gap' that has challenged short-text
clustering. Comparing the machine and human approaches we identify the biases
inherent in each, and question the reliance on human-coding as the 'gold
standard'. We apply our methodology to Twitter bios and find characteristic
ways humans describe themselves, agreeing well with prior specialist work, but
with interesting differences characteristic of the medium used to express
identity.
|
[
0.0680223703,
0.020561954,
-0.0212717373,
0.0052113323,
-0.0048141908,
0.0186655018,
0.0228414517,
0.0149757983,
0.050793618,
-0.0089803105,
0.0090766465,
-0.0475116,
0.0196073875,
0.032796178,
0.0489033349,
-0.0667279065,
0.0058234804,
0.0011622125,
0.0242243297,
0.0144440504,
0.0282147527,
0.023161117,
0.042993959,
0.0545100793,
-0.0010309462,
-0.0081136078,
0.0147261294,
0.0025496343,
0.0183036234,
0.0302473269,
0.000562551,
0.0969298854,
-0.0186212715,
0.0716088638,
0.000001578,
-0.0358759761,
-0.048117362,
0.0077576498,
-0.0072732768,
-0.0021845067,
0.0880931318,
0.0047493242,
-0.0129520223,
0.0216999091,
-0.0279835537,
-0.01683525,
0.034289334,
0.0336803161,
0.0858927444,
0.0699171424,
-0.0267383587,
-0.0133855222,
0.0060690632,
-0.0091047287,
0.0149697009,
-0.0185830668,
0.0253114849,
0.0061425371,
0.0178759415,
0.0373865478,
0.0266742483,
0.0377502963,
-0.0165186692,
-0.0034971,
0.0301460288,
0.0305464752,
-0.0432560444,
-0.0212364029,
0.0448909774,
0.044476375,
0.0277065895,
-0.0290796179,
0.0635699108,
0.0383801274,
0.0195198879,
0.0149404993,
-0.036010284,
0.0414741114,
-0.0029650824,
-0.0056498167,
-0.0193698537,
0.0393829532,
0.0182557758,
0.0061123488,
-0.01821105,
0.0385403,
0.0053317552,
-0.0066522467,
-0.0221082661,
0.0154096214,
0.0069350144,
-0.0418088064,
0.0304660816,
0.0107758641,
0.0084875142,
0.0093734441,
-0.0618872158,
0.0001469806,
0.0181157067,
-0.0315671451,
-0.034382917,
-0.0248894356,
0.0251268242,
0.0406418554,
0.0081511261,
0.0110726133,
0.0093225399,
-0.0235527754,
-0.0053757168,
-0.0408233851,
-0.1077024937,
-0.0249482505,
-0.0230167639,
0.0093172528,
-0.0073026647,
0.0040528015,
-0.0725544393,
0.0474836566,
-0.0169950668,
-0.0291528963,
-0.0295076147,
-0.0172595885,
-0.0029260581,
-0.0197568722,
0.002194976,
-0.033154875,
-0.0227925349,
-0.0128095923,
-0.0112925479,
-0.0343600474,
0.0414709002,
0.0517381802,
0.04046252,
-0.0270780027,
-0.0463363864,
0.0252101459,
0.0110397059,
-0.0312817842,
-0.018957762,
-0.0853004381,
-0.027199151,
-0.0136210825,
-0.0389647596,
-0.0831239447,
0.0239403378,
0.0294742137,
-0.0052293031,
-0.0441476777,
-0.0294639952,
0.0252247136,
-0.0457018837,
0.0342728049,
-0.0745367408,
0.0550121069,
0.0330292843,
0.0200999212,
-0.0043410617,
0.0280818027,
0.0338648781,
0.0629243404,
0.086197488,
-0.0101066586,
0.0251844116,
0.053074915,
-0.0099703399,
0.0166743547,
0.0216659717,
-0.0188429616,
-0.0107395137,
-0.0003074517,
0.0131537793,
0.0718123913,
-0.0348700434,
0.010199408,
0.0404868983,
0.1021339372,
0.0229183994,
0.031065464,
0.03013804,
0.0749740824,
0.030255137,
-0.0106273312,
-0.0284333378,
-0.0361498632,
-0.0384138413,
-0.0181665551,
0.0570261143,
0.0326739252,
-0.0287276749,
0.0048113405,
0.0091374107,
-0.0122358538,
0.0392696895,
-0.0376663581,
0.0158104412,
-0.0183335841,
0.0325352922,
0.0522637144,
0.0189424716,
-0.0650977194,
0.0379920788,
-0.0544679426,
0.0220138617,
0.0623788238,
0.0075118509,
0.0003268506,
0.0316655152,
-0.0029954875,
0.0126888677,
0.0054538781,
-0.0126698576,
-0.0192361698,
-0.0256405845,
-0.0388321616,
0.0027493834,
0.0633374155,
0.00606809,
-0.0331412442,
0.0289774798,
-0.0089423899,
0.025193315,
-0.028796101,
-0.0614362806,
0.0169100296,
-0.0111370143,
-0.000709863,
0.0046838881,
0.0147041241,
-0.0077500576,
0.0554534718,
0.0260432325,
-0.0188516863,
-0.0018318603,
0.0079426514,
0.0047752275,
0.0221405365,
0.008107855,
0.001393068,
0.0012566193,
-0.0278701484,
-0.0660725832,
0.0077185682,
-0.017056115,
-0.0561355986,
0.0246382523,
-0.0490947142,
0.0332064517,
-0.0190356355,
0.0101510296,
-0.0127752284,
-0.0081742946,
-0.024783669,
0.0672317073,
-0.0000762429,
0.0066776783,
-0.0223600939,
-0.0461535119,
-0.010692752,
-0.0638821274,
-0.0199832786,
-0.0229670331,
-0.0052282102,
0.0360686779,
0.0361604057,
-0.026647523,
-0.0656175762,
-0.0415846072,
-0.1117258519,
-0.0227674395,
-0.0202713162,
0.0090932939,
0.0526698567,
0.0186280906,
-0.0085264761,
-0.0041495557,
-0.0559940264,
-0.0401901156,
0.0129362848,
0.007891451,
0.0649218261,
-0.0113488035,
-0.0072856396,
-0.0341232866,
-0.0307544228,
-0.0359950475,
0.0680106729,
0.0422111824,
-0.0352441408,
-0.0449642725,
0.0131515516,
-0.0095514208,
-0.046601411,
0.0149548519,
-0.0262628514,
-0.0047651622,
-0.0180632845,
0.0345938429,
0.000317965,
0.0357016511,
0.0595737882,
-0.0449768864,
0.0226070322,
0.0200632792,
-0.0489383787,
-0.0270469934,
0.0295517314,
-0.0141200563,
-0.0837645158,
0.0496096462,
0.0102590648,
0.0042340565,
-0.0102552129,
-0.0855298489,
0.0437242799,
-0.0446085706,
-0.0098163439,
-0.0497225747,
-0.0067954669,
0.0016375701,
0.0445130467,
-0.0269177221,
-0.0318422839,
0.0366392732,
-0.0396722481,
0.0358842872,
0.0188857745,
-0.0544653013,
-0.0426376723,
0.0521078892,
0.0172783528,
0.0372871011,
0.0137868579,
-0.036758922,
0.0031673496,
0.0124564357,
-0.0133964214,
-0.0138610555,
0.0389143154,
0.0046777483,
0.0026568573,
0.038341213,
0.0069284677,
-0.0070907664,
-0.0716293976,
-0.0274259429,
0.0114836982,
0.0727745742,
-0.0714782849,
-0.0399884917,
0.0402289815,
0.0349234641,
-0.0307579767,
-0.0465448685,
-0.0142023591,
-0.0152518572,
0.0725559071,
0.0238119941,
-0.0022773084,
0.0085972371,
-0.0622617789,
-0.0302083362,
0.0457567982,
0.0191061087,
-0.0084313303,
0.0009658375,
-0.0363611951,
-0.0137164071,
-0.0510360673,
-0.0264397506,
-0.0042628231,
0.0850346163,
-0.0002754527,
0.0007737947,
0.148607865,
0.022941893,
-0.0500252806,
0.0168676898,
0.0350328833,
0.0339731686,
-0.0189323444,
0.0142864613,
-0.0140387444,
-0.0109782061,
-0.006176651,
0.050959114,
-0.0153476596,
-0.0582492761,
0.0016117474,
-0.0431012586,
0.0325149037,
0.0154939331,
-0.0781110823,
-0.0228736158,
-0.0534501635,
-0.0131006911,
-0.044190608,
-0.0270260926,
0.0092991106,
-0.0413615815,
0.0258105062,
0.02225166,
-0.0677805319,
-0.0561450869,
0.0190378278,
-0.052723784,
0.0481961705,
0.0291440655,
0.0400258303,
0.0100781005,
-0.0023782409,
-0.0240032803,
-0.0080901561,
0.0018401977,
0.0204359554,
0.0755958483,
-0.0141037907,
0.0176529065,
-0.0976425111,
0.0424007252,
-0.0341435522,
-0.0165469982,
-0.0232506339,
0.0264808573,
0.0151370456,
-0.0199925043,
-0.0124123245,
-0.003975309,
0.0050108251,
0.0842010677,
0.0433988012,
-0.0407531671,
-0.0144933406,
-0.033453472,
0.0187794529,
-0.0041519464,
-0.0831196457,
-0.0079780724,
-0.035910733,
-0.041247569,
-0.0640836656,
-0.0688261911,
0.0141203543,
0.0314361155,
-0.0304922462,
-0.0120027578,
0.0509484783,
-0.0205143616,
-0.0562361628,
0.0520349406,
-0.0604252852,
0.0029185133,
-0.0709121153,
-0.0143997008,
0.0260753054,
-0.0336169675,
-0.0141917681,
0.0038805699,
-0.0512416251,
-0.0405122116,
-0.0002756665,
-0.0464827307,
0.0302638914,
0.0210485272,
-0.0528094098,
-0.0858526751,
0.0333495438,
0.0432546921,
-0.0478372574,
0.0012539343,
-0.0311824773,
0.0262386631,
-0.019736411,
0.0259241257,
-0.0337148011,
0.016808128,
-0.0151525829,
-0.0401259735,
-0.0742591023,
-0.031837374,
-0.009851655,
0.0536346398,
0.0128220255,
0.0059716711,
-0.0219969824,
-0.0315629095,
-0.089139469,
-0.0247272477,
0.0039097434,
0.0113951461,
-0.030040158,
0.027865801,
0.0040193424,
-0.0207374245,
0.0049313325,
-0.0258883368,
0.0093201464,
-0.061312072,
0.0018909776,
-0.021554606,
0.046138335,
-0.0104467468,
-0.0185115244,
0.0074747559,
0.008983843,
-0.0181594007,
0.0312402919,
-0.0178250689,
-0.0106666945,
-0.0014975182,
0.0023673105,
-0.0149665242,
0.0829326212,
-0.0772887543,
-0.0364737436,
-0.0139011946,
-0.0175287183,
-0.0031373927,
-0.0214015972,
0.0616153777,
-0.0055669625,
-0.0276982505,
-0.0132342987,
0.0386465639,
0.0036996792,
-0.0014717804,
-0.0273252688,
0.0121039199,
-0.0407560244,
0.0061384952,
0.0829912275,
0.0328483917,
-0.0074814903,
0.0005324314,
-0.0683483407,
-0.0254973173,
0.0064764018,
0.0137301832,
0.0245506186,
-0.0099833412,
-0.0078238025,
-0.0524542555,
-0.0571589358,
0.0605562516,
-0.0168062933,
0.0312062148,
0.0313351639,
0.0353518873,
0.0562327988,
-0.0028732487,
-0.0012758791,
-0.085791409,
-0.0221779924,
0.0178214069,
-0.0338020511,
0.0329369381,
-6.448121364e-33,
-0.0016569031,
-0.0838795528,
-0.017197378,
-0.0418723039,
-0.0166133735,
0.01369916,
-0.0219949856,
0.0150375012,
0.0234713536,
0.0144965639,
0.0016876615,
0.0209631603,
0.0121847419,
0.031220898,
0.005577968,
0.0534148887,
0.043591883,
0.0371468291,
0.0012218677,
0.0728227869,
0.0558598004,
0.0057365554,
-0.0252816267,
-0.0607652217,
0.0416957438,
-0.0276718568,
-0.0103627415,
0.0170757566,
0.0629302859,
0.0735037774,
-0.0320557617,
0.0241573118,
0.0503501073,
-0.0009553803,
-0.0009556471,
0.0399359018,
-0.0741403922,
-0.0067332727,
-0.0131375361,
-0.0138961384,
-0.0118950792,
-0.0606710315,
0.0625593513,
-0.0434603319,
-0.011393629,
0.0145268934,
0.074873127,
0.0296694096,
0.0176392365,
0.007740669,
-0.0231480859,
0.0746719465,
-0.0198148862,
0.0112007326,
0.0268455371,
0.0266686082,
-0.0243980233,
0.0426185392,
-0.0817788318,
0.0506384373,
-0.0010147606,
-0.0028188201,
0.0229762141,
0.0271770712,
-0.0116234692,
0.049752824,
0.0297447909,
0.0278645512,
-0.0557471737,
0.0013277708,
0.0036059134,
0.0370787568,
0.0095428899,
0.0585820191,
-0.0456214696,
-0.0405066609,
-0.0401033349,
0.0511247516,
0.0014452237,
-0.0151365763,
0.0315735713,
0.0000819443,
-0.0754612759,
-0.0238904692,
0.0127571411,
-0.0480663143,
-0.025323486,
0.0058854246,
-0.0246616695,
-0.0436322391,
-0.0758239552,
0.0059331167,
0.0221766438,
-0.0325558819,
0.0049391724,
-0.0162829179,
-0.0198704004,
0.054813426,
0.0037451733,
0.0061517823,
-0.0299009643,
-0.0338531397,
0.0193311926,
-0.0023703768,
0.0076522953,
0.0049527292,
0.0268209558,
-0.0202618744,
-0.0360915512,
-0.0096611781,
0.0402496606,
0.0187835488,
-0.0234682579,
-0.0218204446,
0.0199155472,
0.0062494995,
-0.008759669,
0.0426291302,
0.0554713495,
0.0377744772,
0.015158481,
0.0039220597,
-0.0018856436,
-0.0374377146,
-0.0054082968,
0.0081012538,
-0.026965728,
0.0427057184,
0.042655874,
-0.0162236579,
-0.0059364396,
-0.0247077402,
2.382e-7,
0.0386560448,
0.0829490125,
0.0299362633,
-0.0238162111,
0.0429847166,
0.0478638485,
0.0480136499,
0.0126280533,
-0.0241452325,
0.0067761727,
0.0202525742,
0.0483827218,
0.0523024313,
0.0163179673,
-0.0313263759,
0.0198966991,
-0.0403218679,
-0.0133523652,
-0.0443720818,
0.0455007851,
0.0590059496,
0.0705540478,
0.0157547668,
0.0062630847,
-0.0059863268,
-0.0442170836,
0.0269285068,
-0.0083836708,
-0.0310718566,
0.0646840855,
0.0363184325,
-0.0204303525,
0.0138142956,
0.0054331967,
-0.0001495854,
-0.0212952513,
0.0294245109,
0.0407677703,
-0.0234190375,
0.0347761288,
0.0173715018,
-0.0224734694,
0.0219760984,
-0.0437148213,
0.0430985987,
-0.028912086,
-0.0734911263,
-0.0268654991,
-0.0032074421,
-0.0306552183,
-0.0109523404,
0.0120505188,
-0.0359553285,
0.0483408831,
-0.0010627796,
-0.0202277023,
-0.012353166,
-0.0507899038,
0.021000782,
-0.0128080714,
-0.0417612158,
-0.0422245078,
-0.0046092714,
-0.0043303035,
0.0333022885,
-0.0431303754,
0.0691589043,
1.884693626e-34,
0.0194909554,
0.0420639664,
-0.0282667391,
-0.0256451741,
0.03662958,
0.020985974,
-0.0208957903,
0.0171621274,
0.0163829662,
-0.0734190047,
0.0043122089
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07263v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07263v1
|
Span-Aggregatable, Contextualized Word Embeddings for Effective Phrase Mining
| 2024-05-12T12:08:05 | 2024-05-12T12:08:05 |
Eyal Orbach, Lev Haikin, Nelly David, Avi Faizakof
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Dense vector representations for sentences made significant progress in
recent years as can be seen on sentence similarity tasks. Real-world phrase
retrieval applications, on the other hand, still encounter challenges for
effective use of dense representations. We show that when target phrases reside
inside noisy context, representing the full sentence with a single dense
vector, is not sufficient for effective phrase retrieval. We therefore look
into the notion of representing multiple, sub-sentence, consecutive word spans,
each with its own dense vector. We show that this technique is much more
effective for phrase mining, yet requires considerable compute to obtain useful
span representations. Accordingly, we make an argument for contextualized
word/token embeddings that can be aggregated for arbitrary word spans while
maintaining the span's semantic meaning. We introduce a modification to the
common contrastive loss used for sentence embeddings that encourages word
embeddings to have this property. To demonstrate the effect of this method we
present a dataset based on the STS-B dataset with additional generated text,
that requires finding the best matching paraphrase residing in a larger context
and report the degree of similarity to the origin phrase. We demonstrate on
this dataset, how our proposed method can achieve better results without
significant increase to compute.
|
Span-Aggregatable, Contextualized Word Embeddings for Effective Phrase Mining: Dense vector representations for sentences made significant progress in
recent years as can be seen on sentence similarity tasks. Real-world phrase
retrieval applications, on the other hand, still encounter challenges for
effective use of dense representations. We show that when target phrases reside
inside noisy context, representing the full sentence with a single dense
vector, is not sufficient for effective phrase retrieval. We therefore look
into the notion of representing multiple, sub-sentence, consecutive word spans,
each with its own dense vector. We show that this technique is much more
effective for phrase mining, yet requires considerable compute to obtain useful
span representations. Accordingly, we make an argument for contextualized
word/token embeddings that can be aggregated for arbitrary word spans while
maintaining the span's semantic meaning. We introduce a modification to the
common contrastive loss used for sentence embeddings that encourages word
embeddings to have this property. To demonstrate the effect of this method we
present a dataset based on the STS-B dataset with additional generated text,
that requires finding the best matching paraphrase residing in a larger context
and report the degree of similarity to the origin phrase. We demonstrate on
this dataset, how our proposed method can achieve better results without
significant increase to compute.
|
[
0.0256001316,
0.0507828221,
0.0100599462,
0.0631889254,
-0.0338238105,
-0.0133902831,
0.0290576592,
0.0052717114,
-0.0443436019,
-0.0254169144,
-0.0027854964,
-0.018267341,
-0.0254317056,
0.0096691987,
0.0379582569,
-0.0461154133,
0.0461896807,
0.0346071087,
0.0170011483,
0.0087385625,
0.0168880317,
0.0225907732,
0.0094098048,
0.0323380642,
-0.0218596514,
0.0008587596,
0.0484107472,
0.0075194701,
0.0469278432,
-0.0418022759,
0.0583348349,
-0.0046586134,
0.0847496688,
-0.00386993,
0.0000016842,
-0.0071839588,
-0.0434051156,
-0.0144121302,
0.0043640803,
0.0557567589,
0.0688120797,
-0.0221158341,
0.0352573842,
0.0089526214,
-0.0239569098,
-0.0362746827,
0.0008316882,
0.032723479,
0.0431242809,
0.0376143977,
-0.0318721943,
-0.0238685608,
0.0022697868,
-0.0128396703,
0.0058582867,
-0.0701247603,
0.0115946513,
-0.0465775728,
-0.0036800217,
0.0189350341,
-0.0173155051,
0.0293274131,
-0.0040644254,
0.0081967264,
0.0399365388,
0.0428632274,
-0.0742612407,
0.0338532925,
-0.006467558,
0.0751867369,
-0.0309554916,
0.0097453967,
0.0296084266,
0.0174584482,
-0.024252234,
-0.0115638636,
-0.0608850941,
0.0195402168,
0.0159461256,
0.0317391902,
-0.0200244263,
0.052536048,
0.0127919903,
0.044691097,
-0.0448452272,
-0.0221201461,
0.0254136547,
-0.0390441678,
-0.0199210923,
-0.0034115396,
-0.088822037,
0.0324607342,
0.0271177273,
-0.0249811672,
-0.0346730538,
0.040099185,
-0.0218513645,
-0.0444791876,
0.0353570096,
-0.0363148041,
0.0314963907,
0.008115245,
-0.0225493722,
0.0690238029,
-0.0529984646,
0.0323715061,
-0.0318730548,
0.0275127403,
-0.0502885617,
-0.0401744135,
-0.0344648845,
-0.0072088107,
-0.056268435,
0.0640043095,
-0.0462616161,
-0.024426626,
-0.0277383756,
0.0309544466,
-0.0081905304,
0.0144043053,
-0.0504547916,
0.0626998618,
0.0045848037,
0.0036068838,
0.0205679275,
-0.0128898192,
-0.0263968967,
0.0255414825,
0.005088829,
-0.0498077534,
-0.0508763827,
0.0254144296,
0.0459190644,
-0.0484393872,
-0.0111141214,
0.0301198084,
0.0082836403,
-0.0960604548,
-0.0182784181,
-0.014172879,
-0.0512993187,
-0.004605066,
0.0133509981,
-0.0592664257,
0.0590958782,
0.0049166447,
-0.0091360565,
-0.0117319915,
-0.0016328467,
0.0490083285,
-0.0410214439,
0.0304713417,
0.0136917075,
-0.0456224494,
-0.031095935,
0.0295333471,
0.0463872813,
0.0240221508,
0.0267498437,
0.0453235768,
0.0649690479,
0.0329935588,
-0.0266043283,
-0.0197157357,
0.0500141531,
0.0156497229,
-0.0567136146,
0.0400072709,
0.0083150687,
0.004992275,
0.0305508301,
0.0448800661,
-0.0669785589,
-0.0188318547,
0.0079047168,
0.0998077095,
-0.0078694802,
0.0396472029,
0.027350625,
0.0306138154,
-0.0268296469,
-0.0116875665,
-0.0185465775,
0.0028126347,
0.0053831968,
0.0100430269,
0.0725898817,
0.0211244673,
-0.0326705873,
-0.0155923283,
-0.020069506,
-0.0111093316,
-0.0159104466,
-0.0012583492,
0.0264728423,
-0.0058329045,
-0.0441905484,
0.0807383284,
0.0252145622,
-0.105551593,
-0.0373924449,
0.0182380769,
0.0030100308,
0.0564140603,
0.0811403021,
-0.0226033237,
0.0208516568,
0.0035513751,
0.0649724677,
0.0311695039,
0.0248622149,
-0.00660682,
0.0466070734,
-0.0457547493,
-0.0350109525,
-0.0127371773,
0.0054925913,
-0.0036948477,
0.0111272139,
-0.013360451,
0.0208175778,
-0.0355518498,
-0.0395558253,
0.01638023,
0.0229738057,
-0.0026994462,
0.0371014215,
0.0197477937,
0.0107819717,
0.0313419513,
-0.009172624,
0.0332050547,
0.0525305755,
-0.0896397531,
-0.0480164178,
0.0129639702,
-0.0839852989,
-0.0781815276,
0.0085102012,
-0.0565281697,
-0.0080781626,
-0.022979375,
-0.0543348119,
-0.0182256177,
0.0194031149,
-0.0864372402,
0.0501523018,
-0.0330834836,
-0.0104382234,
-0.0221928917,
0.0051226723,
-0.0472180471,
0.0908352584,
-0.0234160144,
0.0328106657,
-0.0076588844,
0.0422570929,
0.0545882136,
-0.0096156718,
-0.0381512754,
-0.0119783534,
0.0212147627,
0.0143082226,
0.0251510311,
-0.0077785891,
-0.0320475027,
-0.0019157978,
-0.0712671503,
0.0219556,
-0.0036191507,
-0.0215588082,
0.0116421906,
0.0146122156,
-0.0064486647,
-0.0358661003,
0.0019063365,
-0.0207748171,
-0.0012066144,
0.0076141851,
0.0576385818,
0.0135540888,
-0.0111153508,
-0.0635028034,
-0.0268543754,
-0.0150765078,
0.0597184449,
-0.0312417112,
0.025529664,
0.011572089,
0.0478023849,
-0.0265070163,
-0.0067559145,
-0.0111048454,
-0.0157240964,
-0.0193795841,
-0.0577987768,
0.0222093854,
0.0536474399,
0.0518789217,
0.0420204327,
0.0253214668,
0.0059650047,
-0.0386794992,
0.0194791723,
-0.0264780391,
0.0177527368,
0.0207235049,
-0.0178638976,
0.0274909995,
0.0093096262,
0.041825138,
0.0067954897,
-0.0403262936,
-0.0184550565,
0.0239547305,
0.0190073866,
-0.0376128219,
0.0158127937,
-0.0030167557,
0.0089002131,
-0.0599079579,
-0.0321592465,
0.0486886352,
-0.0111698406,
-0.00199636,
-0.0475339033,
-0.0321242772,
-0.0465774313,
0.0201029312,
-0.0363667794,
0.0273285899,
-0.0447070897,
-0.0040680268,
-0.0116295172,
-0.013555075,
0.0007636184,
-0.0287972242,
0.0597530343,
-0.0074437456,
0.0018163237,
-0.0217738375,
-0.0513587892,
-0.0407180153,
-0.0612128153,
0.0001097727,
0.0070719887,
-0.0227518156,
-0.0083538555,
-0.0353976898,
-0.0498141907,
0.0310259461,
0.0210250877,
-0.0078109549,
-0.0152315823,
-0.0211914983,
0.0560482666,
0.0727794096,
0.0099860206,
0.0084574511,
0.0102724917,
0.0129128741,
0.062889874,
0.0630353615,
0.0046509281,
-0.0371743925,
-0.0028063529,
0.0023250268,
-0.0037558842,
0.0028954311,
-0.0075097163,
0.018534733,
-0.0159361083,
-0.0454847738,
0.1056092978,
0.0370306075,
-0.0288492218,
-0.0166958012,
0.0040723723,
0.0266105365,
0.0198113509,
-0.0128127756,
-0.0613225847,
-0.0343869478,
-0.0486339107,
0.0103022251,
0.0417762101,
-0.024051901,
-0.0192461796,
-0.0758204088,
0.0187779274,
0.0027452342,
0.0201706346,
-0.050404124,
-0.0369437933,
-0.0179473702,
0.0115745412,
0.0241085403,
-0.0158814415,
-0.0340996869,
-0.0037166388,
0.0011735256,
-0.0047538569,
-0.0269284099,
0.0266568325,
-0.0638881698,
-0.02194307,
0.0473178327,
0.0528177768,
-0.0006562992,
-0.0443334393,
-0.023249926,
-0.0849154741,
-0.031369891,
0.0177386645,
0.0609019883,
-0.0207156129,
-0.0165874325,
-0.0032758606,
-0.0035811444,
-0.0574167892,
-0.0435005277,
0.0312246308,
0.0538008809,
0.0030217697,
0.0227182489,
-0.0480584502,
0.0037517836,
-0.0158740021,
0.0941073596,
0.0264576524,
-0.018903058,
-0.008740928,
0.0167375468,
0.0159642417,
-0.0674752444,
-0.0222381502,
-0.0062490823,
0.0036778525,
0.0543276519,
-0.0482305437,
-0.040587727,
0.0336080231,
0.0550619885,
-0.0421044901,
0.038191963,
-0.0192261711,
-0.0300249234,
-0.0641169772,
0.0233992543,
-0.0282677114,
0.0311145168,
0.0096707335,
0.0234068744,
0.0207389146,
-0.0053760651,
-0.0375267304,
-0.0165647808,
-0.0470601134,
-0.0303475019,
-0.0162425004,
-0.0050051245,
0.000291973,
0.0133071486,
-0.0157689378,
0.0029644347,
0.0832194537,
0.0358869024,
-0.0530954264,
0.0121104755,
0.0231984276,
0.0372466892,
-0.0024186159,
0.0357356668,
-0.058453612,
0.004905222,
0.0332755186,
0.0406460948,
0.0130016925,
-0.0017101812,
0.0087999748,
-0.0399209559,
0.0676712692,
0.0021267969,
-0.0066407281,
-0.0161535479,
-0.0012989166,
-0.0006041796,
-0.0006243556,
-0.0180668943,
0.0204530451,
-0.0216642953,
-0.0247266982,
-0.0197527744,
0.0498090759,
-0.0127855344,
0.049767714,
-0.0458597504,
0.0228921473,
-0.0262717586,
0.0263042618,
-0.0319144465,
0.0308565982,
-0.0289149191,
-0.0432638228,
-0.0597140305,
-0.0141237034,
-0.0322722159,
-0.0069308532,
0.0099457214,
-0.0552020632,
-0.0334069505,
0.0680285767,
-0.0889489129,
0.0296445359,
0.0015718306,
0.0043922039,
0.0523720086,
-0.0675553158,
0.018518962,
0.0120853074,
-0.0140805123,
-0.0082595479,
0.0174316429,
-0.0199019834,
-0.0097827464,
0.0180416536,
0.0460618287,
-0.0290874019,
-0.023797363,
0.0483502485,
0.0263344031,
0.039043311,
0.0058296332,
-0.0261823144,
-0.0270993523,
-0.0216009282,
0.0356853418,
0.0722043291,
-0.0097118793,
0.0116642956,
-0.0287958272,
-0.0346451774,
0.0722136423,
0.0022547485,
-0.0110045476,
0.00746141,
0.0540513471,
0.0365441255,
0.0120321354,
-0.0084382184,
-0.0193607267,
0.0413218327,
0.0068890685,
-0.0300822668,
-0.0305292532,
-5.731678863e-33,
0.0101528149,
-0.0288333204,
-0.0086510889,
-0.0150406267,
-0.0155106205,
0.0262991041,
-0.0471722074,
-0.0468514189,
-0.0429163724,
0.019014623,
-0.0036706242,
0.0251881201,
0.0080115292,
0.0508657843,
0.0014258067,
-0.0002481903,
0.048373796,
-0.011832064,
0.0052773571,
0.0239997432,
0.0554519929,
0.0446189195,
0.0476506576,
-0.0544053987,
-0.0156791769,
-0.0344742648,
0.0249657426,
0.0202627517,
0.0656578988,
0.0595512614,
-0.0167819597,
0.0476811491,
0.0301418733,
0.027019795,
-0.0196944494,
0.0165846273,
-0.0867700428,
-0.0162290167,
-0.0054850145,
-0.0393355526,
-0.0760916024,
-0.0311947688,
0.011682936,
-0.0365505703,
0.0200923011,
-0.0048000067,
0.0418065339,
-0.0333187059,
-0.0557534434,
0.0018519673,
-0.0219721999,
0.0111406976,
-0.0079867076,
0.0344730057,
0.0102557978,
0.028908981,
0.0366137326,
0.0759748891,
-0.0442444049,
0.018286543,
-0.0645356327,
0.0210682265,
-0.0301016718,
-0.0121847196,
0.0050239172,
0.0672372803,
0.0037587115,
-0.0808675364,
0.0062189419,
-0.0102834897,
-0.0125244986,
0.0274627153,
0.0330320708,
0.0568607859,
0.0396735929,
-0.0306173544,
-0.062697269,
0.0148484949,
0.0018616411,
0.0200496688,
0.065560028,
0.0276362766,
-0.0363436714,
-0.0101725804,
0.0065449271,
-0.0130645614,
-0.0395810641,
-0.0145877991,
0.0372806527,
0.0476160161,
-0.0039382237,
0.0004847216,
0.0206085723,
-0.0172591936,
-0.0156265311,
0.0374832749,
0.0101527069,
-0.020554496,
0.0415933281,
0.0169970132,
-0.0246961564,
-0.0229620673,
-0.0012637712,
0.0227612779,
-0.0071300301,
-0.0183758065,
0.0826131701,
-0.013689355,
-0.0540392585,
0.0154079115,
-0.0326003693,
-0.0538678691,
-0.0658635721,
-0.0298500359,
-0.0009285084,
0.0419010669,
0.0035824529,
0.0499691218,
0.0211261567,
-0.0217618179,
-0.0230567306,
-0.0237842556,
0.0075352234,
0.0204225145,
0.0078196051,
-0.0161343459,
-0.0284159854,
0.0448881239,
0.0363107584,
-0.059153799,
0.0109498445,
-0.0402083546,
2.399e-7,
0.0283186734,
0.0143574812,
0.0497898236,
-0.0167767387,
-0.0112300497,
0.0134082977,
-0.0016482653,
0.0514790528,
-0.0608789772,
0.0150166722,
0.0059026973,
0.0397290885,
0.0268672332,
0.0143692549,
-0.0706279278,
0.0559826232,
-0.0753058791,
-0.0339943133,
-0.0464810207,
-0.010488485,
0.0993773267,
0.1002443805,
0.0094227521,
-0.0050154845,
-0.0281774234,
-0.033907529,
0.0581121035,
-0.0194850564,
-0.006309988,
-0.0310171377,
-0.0361695364,
0.0557175986,
-0.0161153171,
-0.0315950476,
-0.02325207,
0.0894769207,
0.0622433834,
0.0616336353,
0.0270637721,
-0.0505563989,
-0.0181513987,
-0.0254350509,
0.0078117806,
0.0045030355,
0.0672917515,
-0.0389096364,
0.0213087276,
-0.0172541589,
-0.0095683923,
0.0543022379,
0.0379767418,
0.0264050644,
-0.0396800637,
-0.0102602588,
0.0145569928,
-0.0066527706,
-0.0066293366,
-0.1352436095,
-0.0008055544,
0.0210982282,
-0.0400979072,
0.0143558197,
-0.0371436924,
0.0362713113,
0.0613815635,
-0.0253173802,
0.0266035888,
2.307001795e-34,
0.0194390658,
0.0044896351,
0.0045970283,
-0.0008562272,
0.0247749686,
-0.0336296409,
-0.0368537009,
-0.0227226634,
0.0222069044,
-0.0663284436,
0.0093524111
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10974v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10974v2
|
Bottleneck-Minimal Indexing for Generative Document Retrieval
| 2024-05-12T11:41:26 | 2024-05-21T01:29:13 |
Xin Du, Lixin Xiu, Kumiko Tanaka-Ishii
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We apply an information-theoretic perspective to reconsider generative
document retrieval (GDR), in which a document $x \in X$ is indexed by $t \in
T$, and a neural autoregressive model is trained to map queries $Q$ to $T$. GDR
can be considered to involve information transmission from documents $X$ to
queries $Q$, with the requirement to transmit more bits via the indexes $T$. By
applying Shannon's rate-distortion theory, the optimality of indexing can be
analyzed in terms of the mutual information, and the design of the indexes $T$
can then be regarded as a {\em bottleneck} in GDR. After reformulating GDR from
this perspective, we empirically quantify the bottleneck underlying GDR.
Finally, using the NQ320K and MARCO datasets, we evaluate our proposed
bottleneck-minimal indexing method in comparison with various previous indexing
methods, and we show that it outperforms those methods.
|
Bottleneck-Minimal Indexing for Generative Document Retrieval: We apply an information-theoretic perspective to reconsider generative
document retrieval (GDR), in which a document $x \in X$ is indexed by $t \in
T$, and a neural autoregressive model is trained to map queries $Q$ to $T$. GDR
can be considered to involve information transmission from documents $X$ to
queries $Q$, with the requirement to transmit more bits via the indexes $T$. By
applying Shannon's rate-distortion theory, the optimality of indexing can be
analyzed in terms of the mutual information, and the design of the indexes $T$
can then be regarded as a {\em bottleneck} in GDR. After reformulating GDR from
this perspective, we empirically quantify the bottleneck underlying GDR.
Finally, using the NQ320K and MARCO datasets, we evaluate our proposed
bottleneck-minimal indexing method in comparison with various previous indexing
methods, and we show that it outperforms those methods.
|
[
0.012558897,
0.0533161052,
-0.022296695,
-0.0054119928,
-0.0493961349,
0.0219462048,
0.0024582518,
0.0646602362,
-0.0230747871,
-0.0073253829,
-0.0132854832,
-0.0251231194,
-0.0587734766,
-0.0220333003,
0.000537844,
-0.0183733758,
0.0358606279,
0.0234831534,
0.0093330452,
-0.0075532673,
-0.0227292757,
-0.0218143668,
0.0329862274,
-0.0090612518,
-0.0113514345,
0.0181496385,
-0.0322707482,
0.0219036248,
-0.0312248785,
-0.0039334632,
-0.0372797549,
0.0243249387,
0.0285651423,
0.0568306819,
0.0000020002,
-0.014170262,
-0.0189252552,
0.015520866,
-0.0192882828,
0.01221216,
0.0328994356,
-0.0242871977,
0.0078077558,
0.0031864292,
-0.0256789513,
-0.0913075656,
0.0372656174,
0.0641833618,
0.0014869208,
0.0772082284,
-0.0370398983,
-0.0429953635,
0.0370995589,
-0.0552472062,
0.0815266073,
-0.0577389076,
0.0161162242,
-0.0120610399,
0.0128967892,
0.0443961062,
-0.0227435026,
0.0317170136,
-0.0025379877,
-0.0127227567,
0.0850360841,
0.0048904577,
0.0182414576,
0.0249910429,
0.0111903418,
0.0153199872,
0.0082626101,
-0.0258029439,
0.0131194992,
0.0069221836,
-0.0299287885,
0.0370808877,
-0.050011389,
-0.010828835,
-0.023039965,
0.0095899887,
-0.0080863554,
0.0519388989,
0.0278076101,
-0.0138306487,
0.0155807436,
-0.0306947567,
0.0190050136,
-0.0245340019,
-0.0464558266,
-0.0344087221,
0.022309145,
0.0254728962,
-0.0237502959,
-0.0099121947,
0.0475900397,
-0.0179383773,
-0.0017805581,
-0.0707168654,
0.0331621319,
-0.0492384732,
0.0038071824,
0.0264122542,
0.0502480716,
0.0698192641,
-0.0088519007,
0.0514074713,
-0.0254068449,
-0.0211097188,
-0.0251942314,
-0.0260093212,
-0.0326227956,
-0.0455555543,
-0.0433716178,
0.0526711196,
0.003717663,
-0.0483162217,
-0.0042532417,
0.0306276195,
0.0305168368,
-0.0578666478,
-0.0356152095,
-0.0083527816,
-0.0501305237,
-0.0028237002,
-0.0421161689,
-0.0119645633,
-0.0427127033,
-0.0089324629,
-0.0248312689,
-0.0277828239,
-0.011973354,
0.0184375886,
0.0156656392,
-0.0212390926,
0.0004412814,
-0.0058002863,
-0.0161741897,
-0.021305006,
-0.0198907312,
-0.0445441008,
0.0464386679,
0.0025245477,
0.014573019,
-0.0365632325,
0.0426427834,
0.0106141688,
-0.0100535527,
-0.0397434086,
-0.0388418213,
0.0091394568,
-0.0103378631,
0.0087810755,
0.010190797,
0.0100027602,
0.0762542859,
0.0140798781,
0.0485030897,
0.0620899796,
0.003496418,
0.0338701494,
0.0243430436,
0.0062365672,
-0.0086758779,
-0.0019031174,
0.0317238458,
-0.0113381064,
0.0067812456,
-0.0313444287,
0.0057652406,
0.0321216844,
0.0093128383,
0.041173134,
-0.0815315917,
-0.042683173,
-0.0126844961,
0.0616574399,
0.0613281578,
0.0237756521,
-0.0237937719,
0.0022286461,
-0.042075865,
0.0150300926,
0.0628045946,
0.0586562902,
0.0276794434,
-0.0416382849,
0.0675741509,
-0.0098092202,
-0.0532509871,
-0.0186502654,
0.0145643353,
0.0551190861,
-0.039184805,
-0.028382767,
0.0462460965,
-0.0064930776,
0.0027874957,
-0.0217515975,
-0.0278444532,
-0.0172831304,
-0.0108439513,
-0.0149772046,
-0.0054592243,
0.0495476425,
0.0653442368,
-0.0118567366,
0.0416180864,
0.0222785752,
-0.0161214843,
-0.0155105451,
0.0227406397,
-0.0087767281,
-0.0008732809,
-0.0447602682,
-0.0377312861,
0.0224197563,
-0.0106435288,
0.0383389629,
-0.010768231,
0.0280796904,
0.0429688618,
-0.0210409611,
0.0243012402,
-0.0028166922,
-0.0020501504,
-0.0731012523,
0.0587681159,
0.0015456829,
0.018527342,
-0.0102637718,
-0.0285657663,
0.0032185081,
0.0463991128,
-0.0305764712,
-0.0235561915,
-0.0203283001,
-0.0140431868,
0.009835708,
-0.013725278,
-0.0571293011,
0.0525664091,
-0.0033782697,
0.0137597267,
-0.0766366124,
0.0320608355,
-0.0197753552,
0.0322835296,
-0.1171820015,
-0.031959556,
0.0038875353,
0.0102599058,
-0.037300203,
0.0300795417,
0.0209034234,
0.0495777577,
-0.0258053355,
-0.0016286874,
0.0735667869,
-0.0492308587,
0.0062993197,
0.0244940016,
-0.0076460177,
0.0162071027,
0.0454272591,
-0.0292233396,
0.0301958341,
-0.0185271632,
-0.0467947423,
-0.0121733192,
-0.0286079831,
-0.0207674541,
-0.0321097448,
0.0391764157,
0.0063448451,
-0.0399020091,
-0.0512650907,
-0.004374411,
0.0168755613,
-0.0009173037,
0.003799598,
0.0323284753,
-0.0058133444,
0.0120226275,
-0.0698992908,
0.0224425253,
0.0224549882,
0.0217439197,
-0.0473426841,
0.0137265911,
0.0089456066,
0.0053973473,
0.0159192886,
-0.043917302,
0.003106619,
0.0072934111,
-0.0705709979,
0.0190521572,
0.0182230007,
0.0120343817,
-0.0412102118,
0.0259164423,
0.0205187779,
-0.1013623253,
0.0414868854,
-0.0397963896,
0.0200052708,
0.0292970184,
-0.0335448757,
0.0386479534,
0.0285147224,
0.0006016049,
-0.0111537706,
-0.0514269322,
0.0159013849,
0.0018419251,
-0.0077268174,
-0.0975295231,
0.0120538538,
0.0371868312,
0.0357402749,
-0.0033228949,
-0.0638144016,
0.0058885664,
0.00452497,
0.0180053338,
-0.0106810592,
0.0095380628,
-0.025562346,
0.0614515841,
0.0138703845,
0.0335696563,
0.0137801524,
-0.0179474987,
0.0100635951,
0.0666358545,
0.0459021367,
-0.0250648614,
-0.0221017748,
0.0287973024,
0.0711706653,
-0.0134115964,
-0.072127901,
0.001373218,
-0.0358130671,
0.0862529278,
-0.0102889575,
0.0720842183,
-0.0342733115,
-0.0125771593,
0.0409619585,
0.0138132833,
0.0267521758,
-0.0308099873,
-0.041714754,
0.0241227821,
0.0390166938,
0.0383985154,
-0.0319290124,
-0.0208498258,
0.0204833914,
-0.0274710059,
0.0119587267,
0.0501723811,
0.050124079,
0.0012199602,
0.0098259775,
0.0349338986,
0.012506648,
-0.0393266752,
-0.0185071472,
-0.0656552389,
0.0257662423,
-0.0342017896,
0.0540441163,
0.0254325736,
-0.0987454504,
-0.049816478,
-0.0090663275,
0.0042264853,
0.0009925178,
0.057981234,
-0.0480386615,
0.0289354641,
-0.0028683003,
0.0466003269,
-0.0389159471,
0.0017911508,
-0.0035945792,
-0.0714594424,
0.053602349,
-0.0170330275,
0.0327978767,
-0.0333449803,
-0.0681295991,
-0.0405217148,
0.0260068048,
-0.0467078052,
0.01012732,
-0.0188157205,
-0.0400795974,
0.0341992117,
0.0256157275,
-0.0404952131,
-0.0585582592,
-0.0111956894,
0.0171394255,
0.0286939777,
0.0007989655,
0.0141468123,
-0.0259563625,
-0.0165170655,
-0.0061731851,
0.004418618,
-0.0259524267,
0.0340966359,
-0.0060374965,
-0.0038245504,
-0.0274955127,
-0.0414136946,
0.0301700886,
0.0490488932,
-0.0394994207,
0.0265445653,
-0.0392280817,
0.0284173209,
-0.0472845882,
-0.0407626964,
-0.0126081053,
0.0699756816,
-0.0123380255,
0.0365229324,
-0.0097101517,
-0.0004139272,
0.0748558864,
-0.0468068421,
0.0054174918,
0.0124226017,
0.0239831284,
-0.0348737799,
-0.0675241128,
-0.0034755017,
-0.0612627603,
0.0627837852,
-0.0159410536,
0.05028053,
-0.0438231602,
-0.0340735465,
-0.0294768848,
-0.0573378168,
0.0199980717,
-0.0526356585,
-0.071841009,
-0.0138971796,
0.0371224545,
-0.0467157029,
-0.0247846767,
-0.0155410813,
-0.0364959762,
-0.0326665528,
-0.0024712214,
0.0095773488,
0.0164500736,
0.0069028353,
-0.0061056525,
-0.0989970565,
0.0418443792,
0.0935905427,
-0.0210548975,
-0.0022397393,
-0.0245938357,
-0.0657460317,
-0.0483347811,
0.0162228066,
-0.0435642265,
0.042947948,
-0.0442909524,
0.0029302272,
-0.0524501391,
0.0130369542,
-0.0054899179,
0.0299297348,
0.0431911349,
0.0153725715,
0.0149549106,
-0.0484721549,
0.0217496715,
-0.0091151558,
0.0051838104,
-0.0109746521,
-0.0422478952,
0.072552003,
-0.0140493065,
-0.0449261069,
0.0705770329,
0.0393699296,
-0.0096729985,
-0.0275709629,
-0.0371107534,
-0.0299029704,
0.0076232529,
-0.0129445745,
0.0076909475,
-0.0277082678,
0.0056833699,
0.0287670754,
0.0324848332,
-0.0424392559,
0.0011645356,
0.0388672426,
0.0152999246,
-0.0166650284,
-0.0050805463,
-0.0671029165,
-0.0521723926,
0.0065281722,
-0.0210636351,
0.0451234393,
0.0014562372,
-0.0147387479,
-0.0287771504,
0.0109763965,
-0.0236665793,
-0.0302159917,
0.0530559123,
0.0030862128,
0.0002267162,
0.0401558764,
0.0029741209,
0.0094763422,
0.076391831,
0.0547378957,
0.0162232351,
-0.0418354496,
-0.021602327,
-0.0029405109,
0.0120647103,
0.0408424251,
0.0092079658,
0.0006184303,
-0.0104673104,
0.0050991741,
0.0260939058,
0.0271549169,
0.0036477656,
0.0134565784,
-0.0109901456,
0.0505012944,
0.0669692978,
-0.0022761463,
-0.0328305364,
-0.0262110606,
-0.0263643358,
-0.0662401989,
-0.0079225935,
0.000414624,
-6.688452654e-33,
0.0067355041,
0.0258702505,
0.0017021204,
-0.0008175772,
-0.0034570149,
0.0189140737,
-0.0002710915,
-0.0672424585,
-0.0075870897,
-0.010072072,
-0.0305373296,
0.0478294753,
0.0077641392,
0.0175994914,
0.0186533462,
0.0277633443,
0.0609225817,
-0.0184431616,
-0.0094872098,
0.050003618,
0.0552925356,
0.0372274667,
0.0004861593,
-0.0082048168,
-0.034271121,
-0.0095359078,
0.0332879499,
-0.0082167694,
0.0441213809,
0.0639913082,
-0.0370179117,
0.0121143283,
0.0122152036,
-0.0672273114,
0.0111202076,
-0.0028321815,
-0.0899004936,
-0.0761884078,
-0.0530360602,
0.0007745193,
0.0309655052,
-0.0255394913,
0.0091080479,
-0.003869917,
-0.0519838147,
0.0153288953,
0.0193020776,
0.0491563082,
-0.0789267644,
-0.1003555208,
-0.0072684656,
0.0243824907,
0.0361370146,
0.0374458432,
0.0444256365,
-0.0077688773,
-0.0099484753,
-0.0117429039,
-0.0499280505,
0.0235865414,
-0.0081215659,
0.0888774693,
-0.0567318089,
0.0237261876,
0.0614111163,
0.0462935492,
0.0599763617,
-0.0010125132,
0.0076970961,
0.015358015,
0.0429673716,
-0.0271667279,
0.0007595177,
0.041682452,
0.1154688224,
-0.024575606,
-0.0784135982,
0.0892143697,
0.0286652949,
0.0379452817,
0.0302888956,
0.0444346145,
-0.0853067935,
-0.0335251093,
-0.0176825449,
0.0079504028,
-0.0044899611,
-0.0129602859,
0.0248897728,
0.0605879389,
0.0180397015,
-0.0511722751,
0.0686798468,
0.0040463191,
-0.0274558216,
0.0462814048,
0.0109004565,
0.0217359308,
-0.0023683729,
-0.0123853609,
-0.0244727954,
-0.0165224504,
0.0560980923,
0.0249680374,
-0.0120059969,
-0.031367287,
0.0058070887,
0.0227457955,
-0.0685874969,
-0.037591897,
0.0096624792,
0.014600819,
0.0014709996,
-0.0526650138,
0.0021875415,
-0.004583972,
0.0271019489,
0.0288024042,
0.0212306026,
0.0470431931,
0.0173176937,
-0.0640550032,
0.0059102518,
-0.0196684785,
0.0264945049,
0.0632718951,
-0.0476208143,
0.0160250999,
0.0464367718,
-0.0604331084,
0.0079279793,
0.0878083631,
2.833e-7,
0.0033167596,
0.0119607951,
0.0258029066,
0.0427308343,
0.0276179928,
-0.0163764823,
0.0095242485,
0.0353401117,
-0.0091305654,
0.0198075771,
0.0375189446,
0.0134138539,
0.0163813327,
-0.0073583629,
-0.0943227485,
0.011686625,
-0.0237872005,
0.0157248732,
-0.032280419,
-0.0444259942,
0.0041559096,
0.056531664,
-0.0429998748,
0.009688898,
0.0410568565,
-0.0628333837,
0.0635292605,
-0.0262448005,
0.0251093246,
0.0153867947,
0.0894097015,
0.0245331675,
-0.0022108064,
-0.018672483,
-0.0000838526,
0.0223520864,
-0.0256952289,
-0.0006503364,
-0.0416505113,
-0.0452557094,
0.0206088331,
-0.0101632485,
-0.0287038423,
0.0091917571,
0.0713070333,
0.01474752,
-0.0031237993,
0.0552360751,
-0.0031234771,
0.0265732259,
0.0177313853,
0.0035236683,
-0.0474257506,
0.0066492227,
0.0017105133,
-0.0099778995,
0.0316131189,
-0.0360167809,
0.074415572,
0.0015266936,
-0.0304584447,
0.0364679694,
-0.0651522577,
0.0385115445,
0.0145918773,
0.0182834566,
0.0013156127,
2.250062639e-34,
0.0217451919,
0.0109080616,
0.0014932725,
-0.005692678,
-0.0076104118,
-0.0067595509,
-0.0458929837,
0.0406161435,
-0.0059823752,
-0.0948516428,
-0.0239895377
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07248v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07248v1
|
Limited Ability of LLMs to Simulate Human Psychological Behaviours: a Psychometric Analysis
| 2024-05-12T10:52:15 | 2024-05-12T10:52:15 |
Nikolay B Petrov, Gregory Serapio-García, Jason Rentfrow
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.HC, 68T50, I.2.7
|
The humanlike responses of large language models (LLMs) have prompted social
scientists to investigate whether LLMs can be used to simulate human
participants in experiments, opinion polls and surveys. Of central interest in
this line of research has been mapping out the psychological profiles of LLMs
by prompting them to respond to standardized questionnaires. The conflicting
findings of this research are unsurprising given that mapping out underlying,
or latent, traits from LLMs' text responses to questionnaires is no easy task.
To address this, we use psychometrics, the science of psychological
measurement. In this study, we prompt OpenAI's flagship models, GPT-3.5 and
GPT-4, to assume different personas and respond to a range of standardized
measures of personality constructs. We used two kinds of persona descriptions:
either generic (four or five random person descriptions) or specific (mostly
demographics of actual humans from a large-scale human dataset). We found that
the responses from GPT-4, but not GPT-3.5, using generic persona descriptions
show promising, albeit not perfect, psychometric properties, similar to human
norms, but the data from both LLMs when using specific demographic profiles,
show poor psychometrics properties. We conclude that, currently, when LLMs are
asked to simulate silicon personas, their responses are poor signals of
potentially underlying latent traits. Thus, our work casts doubt on LLMs'
ability to simulate individual-level human behaviour across multiple-choice
question answering tasks.
|
Limited Ability of LLMs to Simulate Human Psychological Behaviours: a Psychometric Analysis: The humanlike responses of large language models (LLMs) have prompted social
scientists to investigate whether LLMs can be used to simulate human
participants in experiments, opinion polls and surveys. Of central interest in
this line of research has been mapping out the psychological profiles of LLMs
by prompting them to respond to standardized questionnaires. The conflicting
findings of this research are unsurprising given that mapping out underlying,
or latent, traits from LLMs' text responses to questionnaires is no easy task.
To address this, we use psychometrics, the science of psychological
measurement. In this study, we prompt OpenAI's flagship models, GPT-3.5 and
GPT-4, to assume different personas and respond to a range of standardized
measures of personality constructs. We used two kinds of persona descriptions:
either generic (four or five random person descriptions) or specific (mostly
demographics of actual humans from a large-scale human dataset). We found that
the responses from GPT-4, but not GPT-3.5, using generic persona descriptions
show promising, albeit not perfect, psychometric properties, similar to human
norms, but the data from both LLMs when using specific demographic profiles,
show poor psychometrics properties. We conclude that, currently, when LLMs are
asked to simulate silicon personas, their responses are poor signals of
potentially underlying latent traits. Thus, our work casts doubt on LLMs'
ability to simulate individual-level human behaviour across multiple-choice
question answering tasks.
|
[
0.0502815656,
0.0512345843,
-0.0576413721,
0.0013470728,
-0.0349600688,
0.011218816,
0.0170674752,
-0.0092511,
0.0391126238,
-0.0124136405,
-0.0297395643,
-0.0385507792,
0.0130585618,
-0.0143613555,
0.0368261077,
-0.0536056086,
0.0154334353,
-0.0109298658,
0.018806912,
-0.0251486413,
-0.0215329174,
0.0250491221,
0.0255258158,
0.0349101909,
0.0233814772,
-0.0169827398,
0.0077951839,
-0.0421579294,
0.0383818746,
-0.0092060193,
0.0345110856,
0.0461259894,
0.0189431552,
-0.0229371581,
0.0000020227,
-0.0355939008,
0.048313871,
0.0100272112,
0.0241045225,
0.0514089912,
0.0588133186,
0.0640894175,
-0.0017510091,
0.038655322,
-0.061156705,
-0.0058551533,
0.0233107638,
0.0305503756,
0.0289435368,
0.0123083265,
-0.0028304579,
-0.036241211,
0.0215156954,
0.0168488361,
0.0076978044,
0.0029429812,
0.0291196685,
-0.0382810012,
0.0002342823,
0.0067129987,
0.0085915029,
-0.0299815461,
0.0139133874,
0.0537750088,
-0.0137443971,
0.0134589337,
-0.0242958572,
-0.0244137459,
0.0182486475,
0.0550900362,
0.0687908679,
-0.02609591,
-0.0314470902,
-0.0101239989,
0.0135532524,
0.0336644575,
-0.0018821108,
0.0213404465,
-0.0092396531,
-0.0155559368,
0.0085256966,
0.0309374463,
0.0030793594,
0.0080545461,
-0.0117652006,
0.0555786975,
0.0163694173,
-0.0328597501,
0.0063304654,
-0.0092880512,
-0.0214928016,
-0.0373484902,
-0.011273508,
0.0199836493,
-0.0221144222,
0.0286850426,
-0.0230011027,
0.0036762923,
0.0566349216,
-0.0481416136,
0.0245923288,
0.0458545536,
-0.0168752708,
-0.0031812571,
0.0415897407,
0.0732906908,
0.0059428965,
0.013100272,
-0.032019224,
-0.0138770109,
-0.0496760681,
-0.0277497005,
0.0229192786,
0.0202017445,
0.036762163,
-0.0163039416,
-0.0499532707,
0.0093799829,
-0.0233176406,
-0.0382813141,
-0.0190906748,
-0.0015606184,
-0.0122843543,
0.0267641339,
-0.0920332521,
0.0217220895,
-0.0710667968,
0.0261502359,
0.0045374311,
-0.0496523976,
0.0501174182,
0.0243121311,
-0.0122153824,
-0.0237982124,
0.0338357091,
0.0079410253,
0.0094249565,
-0.0262891464,
-0.032331232,
-0.0064681382,
-0.0075765485,
-0.0692718849,
0.0126467617,
-0.0572278015,
0.028062528,
0.0270085335,
-0.0223542135,
-0.0410502404,
0.0145814279,
0.0594297461,
-0.0372014083,
0.0469870493,
0.0274122786,
0.0406468101,
0.0147830788,
0.0242534708,
0.0275384095,
0.0272749793,
0.033579085,
-0.0247599576,
0.0401945412,
-0.0390346199,
0.028524749,
0.060671933,
-0.013399817,
0.016975008,
0.0227009542,
0.029023543,
0.001046009,
0.006499195,
0.0611420758,
0.061080914,
-0.0087503353,
-0.0141936112,
0.092288509,
0.0968239307,
-0.0225063749,
0.0371722057,
0.0324078947,
0.0171196572,
0.0489184856,
0.031539984,
-0.0243069027,
0.0028027932,
-0.0196194444,
0.0199331064,
0.007904904,
0.045021195,
-0.0270290878,
-0.0136655252,
-0.008317519,
-0.0057069268,
0.0236255322,
0.0261754896,
0.0034370925,
-0.0245958325,
0.0038883451,
0.0244308151,
0.0232115518,
-0.0664748996,
-0.0235464796,
-0.075873971,
0.0286273398,
0.0498488992,
0.0189745445,
0.0091182627,
0.0211546198,
0.0098895617,
-0.0191817228,
0.0399735756,
0.074035503,
-0.0147187337,
-0.038858816,
-0.021262452,
0.0321310461,
0.0060978113,
-0.0055610724,
0.0158953536,
0.0457685553,
0.0008874647,
0.0010500478,
-0.041092582,
0.0166347921,
0.0104907183,
-0.0972031504,
-0.0220772456,
-0.0296844058,
-0.000535024,
0.0522159562,
0.0149106057,
-0.0003351749,
0.0214888398,
0.010048544,
0.0172478314,
0.0135412682,
-0.0046390737,
0.0056547783,
0.0492999293,
0.005268693,
0.0000118749,
-0.011024625,
0.0633628368,
0.0257519446,
-0.0107055111,
-0.0073467088,
-0.0264915489,
0.0174684934,
-0.0213212073,
-0.0141579369,
-0.034641888,
0.0530330129,
-0.019143559,
0.0683501959,
0.0007609466,
0.0241892897,
0.0362349786,
0.0068396847,
0.0080979234,
-0.0647035688,
-0.0279320069,
-0.0291932914,
0.0241128188,
0.023454912,
0.0064205802,
-0.0216236711,
-0.0618583672,
-0.0402776524,
-0.10440588,
0.0037939583,
0.0202144664,
0.015758615,
0.0159736183,
0.0091976272,
-0.0501963459,
0.0307538658,
-0.0750708655,
-0.0063766064,
0.012663669,
0.0464449041,
0.0236300286,
-0.0319338404,
0.0062384228,
-0.0432808101,
0.0099162105,
-0.0509563796,
-0.0021976337,
-0.0331362039,
0.0672565475,
-0.0073769656,
0.0223452505,
-0.0629409775,
0.0052136332,
-0.0094576497,
-0.0482651107,
0.0603155494,
0.0150789423,
0.0845075548,
0.08514449,
0.0418923944,
0.0410006791,
-0.0041974057,
0.0132530676,
-0.0353611186,
-0.0092672221,
-0.0268432945,
-0.0247055292,
-0.0304685626,
-0.1127907336,
-0.0053004222,
0.0185265038,
0.0350840874,
0.0084980642,
-0.0600666292,
0.0490808822,
-0.017086288,
-0.0366833322,
0.035752032,
0.0234025866,
-0.042609375,
0.0478407703,
-0.0065660486,
-0.0237001311,
0.0487052985,
-0.0007180161,
0.017979091,
-0.0189660359,
-0.0075206677,
-0.0303086713,
0.0619688667,
0.0239467565,
-0.0259158239,
0.0297956597,
0.0354060493,
-0.0663330257,
-0.0228681043,
-0.0146745676,
-0.0514048599,
0.0099140434,
-0.0261739828,
-0.0382522903,
0.0190302357,
-0.0109807299,
-0.0231836271,
-0.0470774025,
-0.031883385,
0.0062138042,
0.0223492552,
-0.0310668517,
0.0006325269,
-0.0241053496,
0.034457162,
-0.0390076712,
-0.0328151286,
-0.0083735436,
-0.0015355673,
0.0210477412,
0.0763976872,
0.0326426961,
0.0547783077,
-0.0389741994,
0.0145173334,
0.0235647783,
0.0029563764,
0.004551291,
-0.0073426659,
-0.0057695173,
0.0118063251,
0.0046627419,
-0.0222442541,
0.0598645248,
0.0470610969,
0.0076395678,
-0.0093067838,
0.1038343459,
0.0322867446,
-0.0233945902,
0.0138010569,
0.0043810094,
0.0419980064,
0.018576568,
0.0377642438,
-0.0263382196,
0.0119775431,
-0.020149529,
0.0241349731,
-0.0634157509,
-0.0241389815,
-0.0076910509,
-0.1206580922,
0.0361158773,
-0.0139083276,
-0.0511134453,
0.0134511273,
-0.054133568,
0.0349413939,
0.0038242307,
0.022490738,
-0.0200951155,
0.0174491182,
0.0025470208,
-0.0162682459,
-0.0592507385,
-0.0352854989,
0.0933389217,
-0.0182368867,
0.0753352866,
0.0291040037,
0.0639837906,
-0.0251923222,
-0.0672279149,
-0.0325522907,
-0.0254245922,
0.0117773889,
0.022987403,
0.0329064801,
-0.0088920016,
0.0324023366,
-0.1038724259,
0.0202370025,
-0.0498772599,
-0.019559864,
0.0095032463,
0.0613207147,
0.014441357,
-0.0528451987,
-0.0414395556,
0.0048653511,
0.0032756089,
0.0567953065,
-0.0001756335,
-0.0862219259,
0.0002762107,
-0.0087387823,
-0.002029784,
0.0143140079,
-0.0886985287,
0.0004662178,
0.012568051,
-0.0143263098,
-0.0221544169,
-0.1095016748,
0.0071819527,
-0.0221278463,
-0.0008199373,
-0.0341860242,
0.0196097698,
0.0011876179,
-0.0145445075,
0.0062415241,
-0.0422371551,
0.0299966205,
-0.0093419002,
-0.0207817126,
0.0698962212,
-0.0388659723,
-0.0029553177,
-0.0092520779,
-0.0453526415,
-0.039557308,
0.0183006991,
0.0361569114,
0.0263414979,
-0.0282300524,
0.0225448087,
-0.0454993658,
-0.0051409262,
-0.0275992919,
-0.0246342625,
0.0615667142,
-0.0400428399,
0.0511254184,
0.0022542018,
0.0027279747,
0.0038143808,
0.0116034988,
0.0107396748,
-0.0256475285,
-0.0219322275,
-0.1097737923,
0.0285616554,
0.0245788638,
0.0082870545,
-0.0045779836,
-0.0025403977,
-0.0129156495,
-0.0462184921,
-0.0345958509,
0.0034444886,
0.0096590146,
-0.086841099,
0.0203654151,
0.022524735,
-0.0246963501,
-0.0393747017,
-0.0389263183,
0.0470003597,
-0.0357089192,
-0.0146612739,
0.0317650177,
0.0408099294,
-0.0198637806,
0.0037510071,
-0.0233884826,
-0.0248573758,
-0.0342931263,
0.0650673583,
0.0255055726,
0.0794136301,
-0.0229136348,
-0.0017138721,
0.0368053019,
0.0135306716,
-0.0700098947,
-0.0442250893,
0.0067745047,
0.0108376266,
-0.0307651032,
-0.0000224263,
0.006901802,
-0.0383714773,
0.0141038829,
-0.0332608297,
-0.0005277998,
0.0023210072,
-0.0168575365,
0.0421671495,
0.0027421212,
-0.0159587357,
-0.0155711928,
0.0530295633,
0.025274124,
-0.0030353672,
-0.0195018854,
-0.042755127,
-0.0259833913,
0.001346603,
0.0093552265,
0.0338306762,
-0.0234670155,
-0.0389870331,
-0.0917910561,
-0.0630953759,
0.0107994694,
0.0187742207,
-0.0008887795,
-0.0367140882,
0.0044910451,
0.0564437993,
-0.0364810191,
-0.039280232,
-0.0331882648,
0.0253777131,
-0.0863745064,
0.0117837358,
-0.0302106868,
-6.237356696e-33,
-0.0440615974,
-0.0258554369,
0.0210978631,
0.0012595461,
-0.0377553292,
-0.0572847016,
-0.0225169677,
0.0263337251,
-0.0556001067,
-0.011511148,
-0.0417656228,
-0.0042668995,
0.0154235633,
-0.0069009298,
0.0091455691,
-0.0079142274,
0.0206806865,
-0.0393038802,
-0.0252969544,
-0.0115582151,
-0.0179032329,
-0.0508111417,
0.0201799739,
-0.0600266233,
0.0469252132,
-0.058704108,
0.0066581643,
-0.025634272,
-0.0226364974,
0.0607895553,
-0.0347533897,
0.0669269189,
0.0473980121,
0.0037768115,
0.0224522725,
0.0808137953,
-0.0319663174,
-0.0442852639,
0.0402834117,
0.0159325004,
-0.0162046347,
-0.0608164929,
0.0081942827,
-0.0116893891,
-0.0509801693,
-0.0233508479,
0.0684931502,
-0.0244706497,
0.035634011,
0.0022102697,
-0.0440031812,
-0.0242915973,
0.0207426045,
0.0110672833,
-0.0698886588,
0.0564090908,
-0.0540453903,
0.0151020866,
-0.0775770769,
0.0575779974,
-0.0028915659,
-0.0351458527,
0.0332396328,
0.0192629807,
0.0358836427,
0.0289534591,
0.0774812624,
0.0320558436,
-0.0538181998,
-0.0422769226,
0.0546799637,
-0.0010560838,
0.0501642562,
0.0791918412,
-0.0128021836,
-0.0572841056,
-0.0044745151,
0.0158634633,
0.0664291829,
-0.0487864166,
0.0502098836,
0.0194552876,
-0.0447871685,
-0.0329133756,
-0.0268893111,
-0.0045358981,
-0.0256230347,
-0.0419204831,
0.0433531776,
-0.0452373959,
-0.0028615771,
-0.0509118773,
0.0389668234,
-0.0382308513,
-0.0084637767,
-0.0317122415,
-0.0231449101,
0.0564891212,
-0.0036808341,
0.0056657665,
-0.0738438219,
-0.0015062555,
-0.0095697679,
0.0285536479,
0.0523223579,
0.039974276,
-0.0271954853,
0.0095868669,
-0.0508576259,
-0.027214868,
0.0117804576,
-0.0140789784,
0.0359199159,
0.0029877303,
0.0170099847,
0.0046734652,
0.0206019506,
-0.0225387271,
0.0024658451,
-0.0144451102,
-0.0531982519,
-0.0059035155,
-0.0083200717,
-0.0148464469,
-0.0107587306,
0.0141323302,
-0.0492926091,
0.0253299344,
0.0159795079,
-0.0205190089,
-0.0039112251,
0.0204066467,
2.661e-7,
-0.0090225814,
0.0485489033,
-0.029582575,
0.0509836711,
0.0349624343,
0.0434766449,
0.0311816763,
0.0030914459,
0.0805167034,
-0.0590623356,
0.021959886,
0.0198810305,
0.0300905965,
0.0251626261,
-0.0635929108,
0.009757054,
0.0039332891,
0.0127907861,
-0.0253424272,
0.0182393696,
0.0828906521,
0.036024183,
0.0228145644,
0.0052794344,
-0.039544601,
0.0140076661,
0.055495169,
-0.0202481821,
-0.026947977,
0.0138269495,
-0.0118682869,
0.0049834684,
0.0122730276,
0.0947246701,
0.0107991863,
-0.0040121917,
0.0224991553,
0.0473884679,
-0.0099518737,
-0.0506925173,
-0.0057147113,
-0.028992692,
-0.0154222529,
-0.0726345778,
0.0566712879,
-0.0365993753,
-0.0586227253,
-0.0196549799,
-0.0154288057,
-0.0235845726,
0.0208774041,
-0.0185728148,
-0.0123829013,
-0.0040053055,
0.0244320333,
-0.0017007012,
0.0077966359,
-0.0130286738,
0.0066654528,
-0.0141672688,
-0.0477078743,
-0.1021682471,
-0.0242567696,
0.0238518994,
0.0233492926,
-0.0594053715,
0.0157923698,
2.252254753e-34,
-0.0095357737,
0.0409295671,
0.0158166196,
-0.0122959297,
0.0556265749,
0.0026072911,
0.0193037167,
0.0267947093,
0.0533093922,
-0.074972719,
-0.0134053249
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13003v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13003v1
|
A Survey on Recent Advances in Conversational Data Generation
| 2024-05-12T10:11:12 | 2024-05-12T10:11:12 |
Heydar Soudani, Roxana Petcu, Evangelos Kanoulas, Faegheh Hasibi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Recent advancements in conversational systems have significantly enhanced
human-machine interactions across various domains. However, training these
systems is challenging due to the scarcity of specialized dialogue data.
Traditionally, conversational datasets were created through crowdsourcing, but
this method has proven costly, limited in scale, and labor-intensive. As a
solution, the development of synthetic dialogue data has emerged, utilizing
techniques to augment existing datasets or convert textual resources into
conversational formats, providing a more efficient and scalable approach to
dataset creation. In this survey, we offer a systematic and comprehensive
review of multi-turn conversational data generation, focusing on three types of
dialogue systems: open domain, task-oriented, and information-seeking. We
categorize the existing research based on key components like seed data
creation, utterance generation, and quality filtering methods, and introduce a
general framework that outlines the main principles of conversation data
generation systems. Additionally, we examine the evaluation metrics and methods
for assessing synthetic conversational data, address current challenges in the
field, and explore potential directions for future research. Our goal is to
accelerate progress for researchers and practitioners by presenting an overview
of state-of-the-art methods and highlighting opportunities to further research
in this area.
|
A Survey on Recent Advances in Conversational Data Generation: Recent advancements in conversational systems have significantly enhanced
human-machine interactions across various domains. However, training these
systems is challenging due to the scarcity of specialized dialogue data.
Traditionally, conversational datasets were created through crowdsourcing, but
this method has proven costly, limited in scale, and labor-intensive. As a
solution, the development of synthetic dialogue data has emerged, utilizing
techniques to augment existing datasets or convert textual resources into
conversational formats, providing a more efficient and scalable approach to
dataset creation. In this survey, we offer a systematic and comprehensive
review of multi-turn conversational data generation, focusing on three types of
dialogue systems: open domain, task-oriented, and information-seeking. We
categorize the existing research based on key components like seed data
creation, utterance generation, and quality filtering methods, and introduce a
general framework that outlines the main principles of conversation data
generation systems. Additionally, we examine the evaluation metrics and methods
for assessing synthetic conversational data, address current challenges in the
field, and explore potential directions for future research. Our goal is to
accelerate progress for researchers and practitioners by presenting an overview
of state-of-the-art methods and highlighting opportunities to further research
in this area.
|
[
0.0718795732,
0.0595815293,
-0.0163385421,
0.0213668142,
-0.0085410485,
-0.0167069305,
-0.0015885694,
-0.0081891073,
-0.0020826291,
-0.0397532955,
-0.0271616541,
-0.0329783522,
-0.0009137443,
0.0582154989,
0.0156595372,
-0.0553259887,
0.0177447516,
-0.0051452108,
0.0068254406,
0.0300246496,
0.0243055765,
0.018530136,
-0.0411689654,
0.0538629852,
-0.0503475517,
0.0182928164,
-0.0374876745,
0.0220138673,
0.0355597138,
-0.0228758175,
0.0144596854,
0.0357916802,
0.0291977804,
0.0221004952,
0.0000018609,
-0.0258999411,
-0.0010721412,
-0.0317443758,
-0.045844283,
-0.0697531477,
0.012485709,
0.0165031068,
-0.000024342,
0.0346976705,
-0.0771339685,
-0.0072301966,
0.035855189,
0.028930774,
0.0657361969,
0.091827862,
-0.0189046916,
0.0038450407,
-0.0128426803,
0.01331212,
0.023408426,
-0.0027154852,
-0.0275892764,
0.0323029794,
0.0179562196,
0.0284225643,
0.0151236746,
-0.0021746019,
0.0153500037,
-0.0425901227,
0.0288831834,
0.0263908356,
-0.0426327996,
-0.0286055487,
-0.0258632712,
0.1091979444,
0.0365690179,
0.0008122273,
-0.0023846459,
-0.013986446,
0.0029926335,
-0.0423795618,
-0.0317920893,
0.0225556958,
-0.013792919,
0.0124872616,
-0.0414738357,
0.0468224622,
-0.0132515654,
0.0025470899,
0.0014912351,
-0.0026219846,
-0.018139679,
-0.0242724158,
-0.0099763731,
-0.008663821,
0.0177442636,
-0.0671089441,
-0.0170981865,
0.004830284,
-0.0701225773,
0.0296475831,
-0.07425116,
-0.0128244525,
0.0061377175,
-0.0086664734,
0.0245411843,
0.0217123684,
-0.0168663878,
0.0052286773,
0.0485915206,
0.0039795884,
-0.0093689878,
-0.0181031413,
-0.0143099455,
-0.0178598017,
-0.0223532766,
0.0155456215,
-0.0230578929,
-0.0004135901,
-0.0946909636,
-0.0220701136,
-0.0174093358,
0.0517141297,
0.0027215227,
0.0086700246,
0.028992027,
0.0398791246,
-0.0354310796,
0.0243424997,
-0.0294732768,
-0.0405006669,
-0.0407186262,
0.0296508148,
0.0419755615,
-0.0930828899,
-0.004735366,
0.0490408279,
0.0286523346,
0.0016497567,
-0.0058578281,
0.0644459128,
-0.0181042477,
-0.0396216772,
-0.013995897,
-0.0258192942,
-0.0246309824,
-0.0598930568,
-0.0033350347,
-0.0056271791,
0.0689575598,
-0.0131976539,
-0.02386228,
-0.0053121517,
0.0322146751,
0.0401065946,
-0.000188556,
0.0530875251,
-0.060152296,
0.0121816313,
0.0189953949,
-0.0013475157,
-0.0121427896,
0.0695690885,
0.076195702,
0.0182541292,
0.0588606074,
-0.0135281608,
0.0180860106,
0.0036848127,
0.0239355601,
-0.0235581715,
0.0383582972,
0.0450921766,
-0.0355251953,
0.0390225835,
-0.0026086017,
0.0470668562,
-0.0447178558,
0.0153480591,
0.0671990812,
0.0269480664,
0.0100837089,
0.0345479399,
0.0692658424,
0.056295041,
-0.0065979478,
-0.0209344868,
-0.0014219886,
0.0082269143,
0.002321258,
-0.0005496671,
0.0518204272,
0.0168550722,
-0.024664823,
-0.0469316952,
0.0105865002,
0.0192655195,
0.0178176276,
0.0004825787,
0.0004318125,
0.0222704336,
-0.0648714453,
0.0161021575,
0.0136235356,
-0.0826744214,
-0.0219565127,
-0.0106834369,
-0.0014112067,
0.0822801962,
0.0590360463,
-0.0151603911,
-0.0156534258,
-0.0140183028,
0.0129453931,
0.067821674,
0.0178103857,
-0.0296814982,
0.0427553952,
-0.0857366994,
0.0040198974,
0.0141545236,
-0.0256286189,
0.0026267397,
0.0180855002,
0.0029638233,
0.0302177984,
-0.0097406488,
-0.0138621023,
0.0221647806,
-0.0240608379,
-0.0051998934,
0.0560230725,
0.0017489946,
0.0236913338,
0.0520857275,
-0.0084721325,
-0.0123695619,
0.0371271782,
0.0199599769,
-0.0052531408,
0.0665790886,
-0.0522500202,
-0.0547779724,
-0.0154241947,
-0.0510458611,
-0.0072717723,
0.0042188931,
-0.0178009868,
-0.0540422089,
0.0007711898,
-0.0638049766,
0.005504522,
-0.0504950806,
-0.0029580165,
0.0746221244,
0.0474590287,
0.0004996849,
0.0357871801,
0.0162032824,
0.0003628815,
0.0426071435,
0.0207287669,
0.0107337274,
-0.073006779,
0.0343253948,
0.0009106075,
-0.0202566646,
-0.0004808877,
0.0185065363,
0.0220197197,
-0.0790817961,
-0.0311819669,
-0.1144062281,
0.0146234455,
-0.0031952721,
-0.0172985997,
0.0152282463,
0.0125354817,
-0.016712226,
-0.0251144711,
-0.0732845291,
0.0121018458,
0.0653716028,
-0.0353734605,
0.0505182855,
0.0222382266,
0.0015041979,
-0.0345989354,
0.0418153368,
0.024509158,
0.0300567914,
0.0116444826,
0.0018197022,
-0.0397677645,
0.0199374333,
-0.03977051,
0.0465745032,
-0.0254611429,
-0.0228125453,
0.0527961552,
0.022097161,
0.0397061259,
0.0149217462,
0.0692683458,
0.0442869775,
-0.0175790954,
-0.0562714152,
-0.0470738113,
0.0496488959,
-0.0333464146,
0.0368060805,
-0.0238859393,
-0.0372263007,
0.0370509773,
-0.0065350798,
0.0234510675,
0.0461156927,
-0.0566104501,
0.0264133085,
0.0557733588,
-0.0589671023,
-0.0129317297,
0.010543908,
-0.0507432371,
0.0360638723,
-0.0155249313,
-0.0231949612,
0.0426680259,
-0.0385709628,
-0.0317526832,
-0.0356884599,
-0.0136465374,
-0.0318292417,
0.0345291123,
-0.0252125133,
0.0040512937,
0.0119480984,
0.0076528913,
-0.0078656552,
0.0134101454,
0.0110735372,
-0.0361674279,
0.0148314107,
-0.0396082662,
-0.0072989953,
0.0263019651,
-0.0420774072,
-0.0685654879,
-0.0391806476,
0.014424216,
-0.0302519538,
0.0563302264,
-0.0406964757,
-0.0150712589,
-0.0215755664,
-0.0121202422,
0.0370888747,
0.0213343892,
-0.0147144692,
-0.0324338302,
0.04034587,
0.0470332801,
0.0467935354,
-0.0050342605,
0.0015833967,
0.0636929199,
0.0288074203,
0.0426685475,
-0.0214978866,
-0.0025134054,
-0.0286365785,
0.0162137095,
0.0182514805,
0.019458048,
0.0129592149,
0.0532992296,
0.0089277998,
-0.0332376175,
0.0808574706,
0.025450049,
-0.0034998029,
0.0077156988,
-0.0073362836,
0.0257174782,
-0.0161179546,
0.009149191,
-0.0881354213,
-0.0286232792,
-0.003413385,
0.0467048585,
-0.0554191545,
-0.0589857325,
-0.0367713533,
-0.103931576,
0.0571171604,
-0.0189202316,
-0.0633412078,
-0.0455876775,
-0.0023347905,
-0.0062078768,
0.0050467518,
-0.0012567986,
-0.0232155826,
0.0232116356,
0.0115755424,
-0.0008028955,
-0.0091933385,
-0.0499974862,
0.0093247723,
0.0037624368,
0.0577526055,
0.041677352,
0.0628808141,
0.0601689182,
-0.0190787371,
-0.0061538559,
-0.0028335929,
-0.0089407424,
0.0021984191,
0.0772034898,
-0.0372302905,
-0.0239632688,
-0.0297791734,
0.0573999807,
-0.0170187838,
-0.0099958694,
0.0270737875,
-0.0104032382,
-0.0754338726,
0.0243997071,
-0.0033619686,
0.0495135114,
0.087662898,
0.069735609,
0.042513568,
-0.0548492,
-0.0011443783,
-0.0163574964,
0.0195032824,
-0.0940753371,
0.0058641983,
-0.008281772,
0.0280353595,
0.0092975656,
-0.0979386419,
-0.0766665861,
0.0262532495,
0.025173964,
-0.0295227878,
-0.0306280088,
0.0079635177,
0.005793497,
-0.01864421,
0.0035579503,
-0.0130350459,
-0.0042630993,
-0.0439586192,
-0.0690099522,
0.0122084105,
-0.0600698926,
-0.0038704348,
0.0642763749,
-0.0700383484,
-0.0334250592,
-0.0181421228,
0.0467940383,
0.0191846192,
0.0601223372,
0.018456867,
0.0037229315,
-0.0124012288,
0.044106327,
-0.0391277783,
-0.0202242155,
0.0371523015,
0.0511168055,
0.000064191,
0.038692221,
-0.0142138898,
0.0189481042,
-0.0228288751,
0.0293836258,
-0.0276948884,
-0.0870624185,
0.0144029278,
-0.002895592,
0.0405886918,
-0.0040975679,
-0.0152305737,
-0.0248396844,
0.025574524,
-0.0672165975,
-0.038436532,
-0.0826913863,
0.0089740353,
-0.034632396,
-0.0113591123,
0.0137228528,
0.0055805235,
-0.0728862509,
0.0315411799,
-0.0323419236,
-0.0082051074,
0.021744933,
0.020487994,
0.014278545,
-0.014905978,
-0.0179611184,
0.0305311289,
-0.0013442413,
0.0378429368,
0.0333526134,
0.0790690258,
0.0174992196,
-0.0513577461,
0.0300981551,
0.0544201694,
-0.0815012157,
-0.011815683,
-0.0414267071,
0.0476026535,
0.005358893,
0.019652823,
0.0414732918,
-0.0408846587,
0.0337692201,
0.0047380668,
0.0607699528,
0.0013853409,
-0.0475642271,
0.0005749669,
-0.0055377758,
-0.0413650423,
-0.0054321354,
0.0756995678,
-0.0071115396,
0.0221481193,
-0.0363698639,
0.0048028538,
-0.084320128,
-0.0261799172,
-0.0014609118,
0.0123754423,
0.0151948221,
0.0032097888,
-0.0525198355,
-0.0275754537,
-0.0280890428,
0.0213585217,
0.0025397849,
0.0013266035,
0.0624415092,
0.0489657857,
-0.0125439921,
0.0202555209,
-0.0432834104,
0.0127898129,
-0.033462055,
-0.00642594,
-0.033754833,
-5.541105882e-33,
-0.0224596299,
-0.0394816026,
0.0243490152,
-0.0022095854,
-0.0299216732,
-0.0328923315,
-0.0336400419,
-0.0153513169,
-0.0133627011,
-0.0163287502,
-0.028069118,
0.0047453651,
0.0065558981,
0.0636156797,
-0.0264725219,
-0.0202527642,
0.0404580235,
-0.015915703,
-0.0198403411,
0.0496934876,
0.057091184,
-0.0008625857,
0.0064438703,
-0.0758230388,
0.0355055556,
-0.0315859951,
-0.0231243949,
0.0285169743,
0.0358528234,
0.0335548632,
-0.0198486838,
0.0398767591,
0.007696846,
-0.0366493426,
-0.0341382101,
0.0353463963,
-0.0243621916,
-0.0109138163,
0.0015062559,
-0.0137341963,
-0.0367192999,
-0.0021269135,
-0.0047093034,
-0.0244645141,
0.0054950747,
0.0287629701,
0.0010358618,
-0.0422380902,
0.0172918309,
-0.0266045555,
-0.0170347653,
0.0200030077,
-0.0301035345,
-0.0854950026,
-0.0212477464,
0.1088222414,
0.0406633168,
-0.0357037336,
-0.0364121795,
0.0803558677,
-0.0077190106,
-0.0365590453,
0.027226815,
0.0331686996,
0.0166116618,
0.0593577772,
0.0308017656,
0.0245750193,
-0.026047606,
-0.0243024938,
-0.0405379198,
0.066392161,
0.005992712,
0.0752514601,
-0.0173027012,
-0.0074681798,
-0.0143543975,
0.0481455028,
-0.011955779,
-0.0194134992,
-0.0297236927,
-0.0242239945,
-0.0364364274,
0.0056602503,
-0.0025082331,
-0.0124115339,
0.0104982089,
-0.0091591971,
0.0347490944,
0.0205385704,
-0.0032433753,
-0.012554232,
0.0100358175,
-0.0237043854,
0.0440097973,
0.0226672422,
-0.0471774079,
-0.0038216491,
-0.0180705264,
-0.0418392941,
-0.0521189719,
-0.0336369984,
0.1049472019,
0.0388702862,
-0.0009872993,
0.0222306829,
-0.0141268736,
0.0050415117,
-0.0203522015,
0.024111066,
-0.0134553118,
0.0950561017,
-0.0542891994,
-0.0089883702,
0.0092940237,
0.0061146175,
-0.0570936985,
0.0629071295,
-0.0104390252,
0.026940152,
-0.0221229699,
-0.0233236495,
0.0271748602,
0.0218209662,
-0.0232847612,
0.0209224634,
-0.013881525,
-0.0426670611,
0.0341792367,
-0.0170423593,
0.0069872881,
-0.0227528028,
2.522e-7,
-0.0283252615,
0.0100074457,
0.037390355,
0.0186953787,
0.0040629762,
0.0406975262,
0.0185214169,
0.0293212496,
0.0077065621,
-0.0303850733,
0.0259290729,
-0.0034621365,
0.0687493011,
0.0239160769,
-0.1013233811,
-0.061070513,
-0.0639694929,
-0.0516471937,
-0.0161385164,
-0.0038493318,
0.0840981305,
0.0351900049,
-0.0185628515,
-0.00038014,
0.0107894698,
0.0144818565,
0.0309766121,
-0.0502059907,
-0.0264176335,
-0.0008660193,
0.0389040522,
-0.0206904355,
-0.0232884195,
-0.010587533,
-0.0266866647,
0.0266767964,
0.0000049603,
0.0262404289,
0.0370614305,
-0.0776610002,
0.0011518098,
0.0160378516,
0.003322222,
-0.0259625353,
0.0248737745,
-0.0371383876,
-0.0189931411,
-0.0025206727,
-0.0101387855,
0.0084076794,
-0.0016383905,
-0.0413541943,
-0.0351680368,
0.0161838867,
0.0084048538,
0.007916498,
0.0400713645,
-0.0565387048,
-0.0014534066,
-0.0407428332,
-0.0749276429,
-0.0579612181,
-0.0163762607,
-0.0364549272,
0.020656975,
0.0084437747,
0.0037873113,
1.807198242e-34,
0.0225277394,
0.0176819023,
0.0174867883,
-0.0005600661,
0.0419416614,
-0.0086626057,
0.0236039404,
-0.0029991891,
0.0358759947,
-0.055568669,
-0.0209503509
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13002v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13002v1
|
DuetRAG: Collaborative Retrieval-Augmented Generation
| 2024-05-12T09:48:28 | 2024-05-12T09:48:28 |
Dian Jiao, Li Cai, Jingsheng Huang, Wenqiao Zhang, Siliang Tang, Yueting Zhuang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) methods augment the input of Large
Language Models (LLMs) with relevant retrieved passages, reducing factual
errors in knowledge-intensive tasks. However, contemporary RAG approaches
suffer from irrelevant knowledge retrieval issues in complex domain questions
(e.g., HotPot QA) due to the lack of corresponding domain knowledge, leading to
low-quality generations. To address this issue, we propose a novel
Collaborative Retrieval-Augmented Generation framework, DuetRAG. Our
bootstrapping philosophy is to simultaneously integrate the domain fintuning
and RAG models to improve the knowledge retrieval quality, thereby enhancing
generation quality. Finally, we demonstrate DuetRAG' s matches with expert
human researchers on HotPot QA.
|
DuetRAG: Collaborative Retrieval-Augmented Generation: Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) methods augment the input of Large
Language Models (LLMs) with relevant retrieved passages, reducing factual
errors in knowledge-intensive tasks. However, contemporary RAG approaches
suffer from irrelevant knowledge retrieval issues in complex domain questions
(e.g., HotPot QA) due to the lack of corresponding domain knowledge, leading to
low-quality generations. To address this issue, we propose a novel
Collaborative Retrieval-Augmented Generation framework, DuetRAG. Our
bootstrapping philosophy is to simultaneously integrate the domain fintuning
and RAG models to improve the knowledge retrieval quality, thereby enhancing
generation quality. Finally, we demonstrate DuetRAG' s matches with expert
human researchers on HotPot QA.
|
[
0.0402065404,
0.0158961844,
-0.0162291992,
0.0105408942,
-0.0414844342,
-0.0115773249,
-0.0052909856,
-0.0125157665,
0.0200039037,
-0.0495099276,
-0.023488028,
-0.04651412,
-0.0299040489,
0.018311765,
0.0453335233,
-0.0105213216,
0.0282895472,
-0.0019273574,
-0.0246496946,
-0.0238121394,
-0.0024730864,
0.0085709086,
-0.0090346579,
0.044221919,
0.00004538,
-0.0145938648,
-0.0039563011,
-0.0093636811,
0.0165429134,
-0.0304579549,
0.0463147387,
0.0340017155,
0.0161022041,
0.0449492671,
0.0000019315,
-0.0538658872,
-0.0303093027,
0.0131560313,
-0.0199373756,
0.000336066,
-0.0016534723,
0.0484164134,
0.0283626579,
0.0348124169,
-0.0668852702,
-0.0031426484,
0.0035426731,
0.044893682,
0.0555434637,
0.0498082638,
0.0179884452,
0.0012493279,
0.0126809468,
-0.0536677241,
0.0078211073,
-0.0562936179,
0.0114454208,
0.0547925532,
0.011259363,
0.0354916118,
0.0146035682,
0.0415811278,
0.0181524865,
-0.0266033057,
0.0276414156,
0.017605288,
-0.0627437755,
-0.0173788909,
0.0285159256,
0.0825852156,
0.0774278268,
-0.0114353392,
0.0131228324,
0.0292607341,
0.0235364623,
0.0990137309,
-0.0528988242,
0.0147805586,
-0.0196508393,
-0.0120755434,
-0.0175019838,
-0.0214604326,
0.0220227484,
0.0172478575,
0.0041442141,
0.0858935639,
0.0223383997,
-0.0209785216,
-0.0133441566,
0.015538333,
-0.0392782018,
-0.0230548251,
0.0074196071,
0.0464071818,
-0.0308436975,
0.0051638419,
0.0026955472,
-0.0332724713,
0.0371667892,
0.0297234897,
0.0317725688,
0.0117904395,
-0.0066534947,
0.0175002497,
-0.0259263236,
0.0048088101,
0.0075323544,
-0.0386847816,
-0.0694173127,
-0.0114270728,
-0.0425359644,
-0.0365883298,
-0.0477245674,
0.0376372896,
-0.0579743795,
-0.0003472921,
-0.03085435,
0.0128051443,
-0.0199513305,
0.0104324073,
-0.0149692055,
0.0484332442,
-0.056982398,
-0.0220542271,
-0.0479203016,
0.0470077284,
-0.0331430845,
0.0220819227,
0.0626552328,
-0.0472290888,
-0.0091862986,
0.0114174178,
-0.0164184123,
-0.0074469931,
-0.0115769068,
0.026227152,
-0.0197332464,
-0.0099948114,
-0.0148907993,
-0.086725004,
-0.0014063811,
-0.0542588159,
0.0061677946,
-0.065751344,
0.0240333807,
0.0213960111,
-0.0230636913,
-0.0553573631,
0.0157596413,
0.0442307405,
-0.0091279615,
0.0341183729,
-0.0163358953,
0.0098390076,
0.0595441386,
0.0384192094,
-0.0241834,
0.0518548153,
-0.0094607556,
0.034057606,
0.0313367248,
0.0316140652,
0.0063581751,
-0.0067647342,
0.0404162146,
0.0207347982,
-0.0151690813,
0.0465686321,
0.0283653196,
0.0294712409,
0.0172717813,
0.0523494668,
-0.0511267819,
0.0492326356,
0.0278482791,
0.0227473993,
0.0380807519,
0.042427849,
0.062895067,
0.0127060842,
0.0088105937,
0.0314859189,
-0.0134504978,
0.0197698697,
-0.0180926565,
0.0048396769,
0.0416997038,
0.0557892285,
-0.02965183,
-0.0337906368,
0.0053710951,
0.0284569506,
-0.0483838432,
0.031935446,
0.023376815,
0.0221471358,
-0.0166460816,
0.0599457845,
-0.0031804901,
-0.0615835413,
0.030452868,
-0.0238722395,
0.0425086133,
0.0319224037,
0.0889386684,
-0.031003423,
-0.0544662327,
0.0216761809,
-0.0198471975,
-0.0144462828,
0.0640129596,
-0.0327325054,
-0.0523097888,
-0.0572791956,
-0.0378638096,
-0.0092122089,
0.0167608466,
-0.0109466221,
0.0257820562,
-0.0083249724,
0.0873971283,
-0.0449134223,
-0.0117182005,
0.0191847533,
-0.1125454232,
-0.0073584951,
0.0000829935,
0.0027230021,
-0.0107843671,
0.0190944318,
-0.000059475,
0.0435176082,
0.0306700375,
-0.0318971351,
-0.0390684865,
0.0075133136,
-0.0173099265,
-0.0562808141,
0.0223959796,
-0.0224431157,
-0.006363411,
0.0199798141,
-0.0235041752,
-0.0414053202,
0.0105865933,
-0.0052137487,
-0.0204957742,
-0.0770913661,
-0.0045432858,
0.0301056411,
0.0065665641,
-0.0587090217,
0.0705379024,
0.017369261,
0.0241650678,
0.0278142616,
0.0264288206,
0.0207762159,
-0.0568800941,
0.0068351007,
-0.0048018694,
-0.0246157814,
0.0339796953,
0.0383955799,
-0.0074481089,
-0.0859892815,
-0.018529065,
-0.0632923543,
0.0206796415,
-0.0203471947,
0.0093475226,
0.0072500021,
0.011092646,
-0.0011503687,
-0.0029480103,
-0.0695383176,
-0.0072535048,
0.0186210237,
0.0098786093,
0.0186218042,
0.03706396,
0.0383217186,
-0.0276044831,
0.0199627411,
-0.0116153285,
0.0235956665,
0.0201391466,
0.0392393023,
-0.0652186573,
0.064996846,
-0.0570595972,
-0.0005719031,
-0.0041453945,
0.0093049174,
0.0137341702,
-0.0152704278,
0.0886866972,
0.0218390953,
0.0057707964,
-0.0107049271,
0.0441685095,
-0.0293799639,
-0.0699183568,
0.0263732187,
-0.0448863916,
-0.0272201542,
0.0298714191,
-0.0117279785,
0.0261937659,
0.0148714818,
-0.0020952115,
-0.0399227105,
-0.0306582339,
0.0441522188,
-0.0225956887,
-0.0134512251,
-0.0310609285,
-0.0122788465,
-0.009018302,
0.0472924151,
-0.0091759739,
-0.0242234413,
0.0793689042,
-0.0286217704,
0.0163955651,
-0.0713232532,
0.0225900337,
-0.0536617599,
0.0384117886,
-0.0311945844,
0.0155757461,
-0.0051092943,
-0.0037893758,
-0.0652779713,
0.0185963493,
0.0252243113,
-0.0700064003,
0.0389949568,
-0.0391834192,
0.0243664272,
-0.005704267,
-0.0361576527,
-0.0643511415,
-0.0362624973,
0.0056269495,
0.0137035102,
-0.002761221,
0.0028280118,
-0.0133532695,
-0.0057477155,
0.0393640324,
-0.007283316,
-0.0293562412,
-0.017854983,
-0.0116966525,
0.0741809383,
0.0810969993,
0.0200241506,
0.016209852,
-0.0297148935,
0.0145637384,
0.0433126651,
0.0613798127,
-0.0145396674,
0.0293513089,
-0.0385072902,
0.0435762145,
-0.0176819637,
-0.019743178,
0.0124307498,
0.0538402312,
-0.0512545481,
-0.0364157148,
0.0785312057,
0.0384570397,
-0.0096473992,
-0.0256099124,
-0.0504543856,
0.055551853,
0.0257226657,
0.0766230673,
-0.072937429,
-0.0100422027,
0.007484572,
0.0584179312,
0.0100075407,
-0.0440267995,
-0.0197077319,
-0.1561386883,
0.0468547978,
0.0168309528,
0.0107947187,
-0.0160850734,
-0.0192010552,
0.0105590755,
0.0289120469,
0.0126205701,
0.054912623,
-0.0100970967,
0.0405512378,
0.0482161753,
0.0317122452,
-0.0367356092,
0.0088098906,
-0.0464701243,
0.0392956696,
0.0749201626,
0.0108557446,
0.032150019,
-0.0155050335,
-0.027213905,
-0.0281621087,
0.0176569391,
0.0045725135,
0.0281914026,
0.021038793,
-0.0020104381,
-0.0216545742,
0.0329783708,
-0.0217936151,
-0.013188648,
0.0175859556,
0.0601970814,
-0.0360003673,
-0.0031358011,
-0.035315685,
0.0249454323,
-0.0072474568,
0.0605981499,
0.0494536571,
-0.0008774385,
-0.0008245646,
-0.0013549529,
0.0176223107,
-0.0605825298,
-0.0320153125,
0.0326087214,
-0.0093007274,
0.0220241752,
-0.0944610611,
-0.0515089221,
0.0444027185,
0.0599132888,
-0.0019554046,
0.0214231517,
-0.0210191365,
-0.0039632074,
-0.0305730887,
0.0409010313,
-0.0753253698,
-0.0049248911,
-0.0358346775,
0.0001698858,
0.0476762429,
-0.0550302565,
-0.0107610989,
0.017004488,
-0.0423517264,
-0.069875665,
-0.0113827577,
0.0338388346,
0.023544265,
0.0199938864,
-0.0203793887,
-0.052248694,
0.0223061312,
0.0780027062,
-0.063063696,
-0.0087989885,
-0.0209503807,
-0.0238321759,
-0.0445456021,
0.0405735523,
-0.0527204797,
0.0194325354,
-0.0229411051,
0.0877110958,
0.0091679618,
-0.075601384,
0.0448221415,
0.0309115257,
0.0391751938,
-0.0007475971,
0.0120962402,
-0.0278453622,
-0.0045409231,
-0.0029160585,
-0.0358535089,
-0.0307381023,
0.0310506504,
0.0069608884,
-0.0300056841,
0.028111726,
-0.0051827095,
-0.0019616603,
0.0902374759,
-0.0427339599,
-0.026006015,
-0.0229204725,
0.0175719298,
0.0345609225,
0.0004087677,
-0.0184778571,
-0.0036099153,
-0.0109478887,
0.0542574711,
-0.0149020534,
0.0535796061,
0.0167783108,
0.0220760647,
-0.0032518376,
0.0119722141,
-0.0653826818,
-0.0682845488,
-0.0378688797,
-0.0098474575,
0.0228637364,
0.0055653495,
0.030102456,
-0.0136449775,
-0.0207129307,
-0.0294862408,
0.0247376971,
-0.0013617896,
-0.0236300137,
0.0285538901,
0.0340014249,
-0.0238028187,
0.0096780611,
0.0925890878,
-0.0171227138,
0.0222809687,
-0.0361820869,
-0.0337123834,
-0.0227690153,
-0.0510851778,
0.0223057866,
-0.0135347908,
-0.0156769585,
0.0152559327,
-0.0885269567,
-0.0841556191,
-0.0171081778,
0.0024458494,
-0.0188994464,
-0.0081733419,
0.0334928669,
0.0866354555,
-0.0156023894,
0.0115540149,
-0.0611953847,
0.0712273121,
-0.0567891039,
-0.0166620947,
0.0045980285,
-6.602875195e-33,
-0.0417779833,
-0.064743951,
0.0576112755,
-0.0320604332,
-0.0431950092,
-0.0014524923,
-0.026865473,
-0.0106972838,
-0.0291930996,
-0.0054310993,
-0.006583638,
0.0004929379,
0.0026967858,
0.0112213669,
0.0100899097,
0.0042603277,
0.0483524911,
0.0221030731,
-0.0432623774,
0.0452930219,
0.0433422662,
0.0520244837,
-0.0041201436,
-0.0579906516,
0.0140137216,
-0.0495460257,
0.0149956895,
0.0263791401,
0.0022606454,
0.0225986186,
-0.0025659453,
0.0365863033,
0.0066908961,
-0.0680713281,
-0.0008125895,
-0.0160493031,
-0.0806329623,
-0.0209217221,
0.0078616804,
-0.0472186916,
-0.0424075648,
-0.0390670598,
0.0238378327,
-0.016223466,
0.0051762806,
-0.0015517231,
0.027682187,
-0.0379080623,
-0.0211970098,
-0.0438645072,
-0.0453017689,
0.0129926102,
0.0110692764,
-0.0335633829,
-0.0308270622,
0.0790581405,
0.0199849661,
0.0161020048,
-0.0247776639,
0.0292217135,
0.0147709176,
0.0836692676,
0.0611071177,
-0.004169798,
-0.006439887,
0.0331439562,
-0.0334011577,
-0.0005385553,
-0.0002584781,
-0.0302910134,
-0.0078262268,
0.0616387874,
0.0028838457,
0.1026553363,
0.0127964336,
-0.0262027755,
-0.0335883722,
0.0757086203,
0.0065915687,
0.0250511542,
-0.0061975191,
-0.0188674517,
-0.0162052996,
-0.0202957243,
-0.0487463027,
0.0515084676,
-0.0341773331,
-0.0457096621,
0.0493835397,
0.02674211,
-0.0433544815,
0.0037590826,
0.0088416068,
-0.030888686,
0.0328115076,
-0.0153617021,
-0.0454761423,
-0.0229727775,
-0.0278075859,
0.0445204377,
-0.0329767726,
-0.0212401431,
0.0106438529,
0.013407642,
-0.0132837892,
0.0107489023,
0.0153798424,
0.003714843,
-0.0315794684,
0.0006992526,
-0.0322536826,
0.0291020293,
-0.005105888,
-0.0182251576,
-0.0054952502,
0.040725328,
-0.0109616164,
0.0272791423,
0.0237326249,
0.0082358494,
-0.0305044744,
-0.0276260693,
0.0104857255,
-0.0167641398,
-0.0123160537,
0.0327296443,
-0.0203539077,
0.0349667631,
0.0296442937,
-0.0240313336,
-0.0313532166,
-0.0052776993,
2.83e-7,
0.0402589589,
0.0356593058,
0.0071421247,
-0.0164793804,
-0.0137454914,
0.046949394,
0.0017010241,
0.0149922585,
0.0550180711,
0.02314643,
0.0008037121,
0.0088185575,
0.0357177705,
0.0388111509,
-0.0815621912,
-0.0320769995,
-0.0678374097,
-0.0220628362,
-0.0149640534,
-0.0439153351,
0.047387287,
0.0393123031,
-0.0123509811,
-0.0327526219,
-0.0183086675,
-0.0579168387,
0.0903603137,
0.0291494988,
-0.0545301065,
0.0577412471,
0.060560327,
0.00594413,
0.0121759512,
-0.0032071734,
-0.0154642388,
0.018672144,
0.0211434849,
0.0010850347,
0.0512417555,
-0.0275597461,
-0.0004077321,
-0.0144848684,
0.0342386737,
-0.0572081059,
0.0436947234,
-0.0704728886,
-0.0142548624,
0.0083057471,
-0.0381514244,
-0.0145815909,
-0.0153235691,
-0.0082391854,
0.0032693825,
0.0225901511,
-0.0222207755,
0.0213173106,
0.0047876597,
-0.0437601656,
-0.0221486166,
-0.0080430051,
-0.0567769706,
-0.0666401386,
-0.0283671282,
-0.034584906,
-0.0383922122,
-0.0586768687,
0.0378755853,
2.555201917e-34,
0.0267760213,
0.0162994023,
-0.0024423369,
0.0031637142,
0.036451079,
-0.0060094264,
-0.0414069444,
0.0251279548,
0.0140179833,
-0.0611208528,
-0.0163997971
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07195v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07195v1
|
InsightNet: Structured Insight Mining from Customer Feedback
| 2024-05-12T07:40:12 | 2024-05-12T07:40:12 |
Sandeep Sricharan Mukku, Manan Soni, Jitenkumar Rana, Chetan Aggarwal, Promod Yenigalla, Rashmi Patange, Shyam Mohan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We propose InsightNet, a novel approach for the automated extraction of
structured insights from customer reviews. Our end-to-end machine learning
framework is designed to overcome the limitations of current solutions,
including the absence of structure for identified topics, non-standard aspect
names, and lack of abundant training data. The proposed solution builds a
semi-supervised multi-level taxonomy from raw reviews, a semantic similarity
heuristic approach to generate labelled data and employs a multi-task insight
extraction architecture by fine-tuning an LLM. InsightNet identifies granular
actionable topics with customer sentiments and verbatim for each topic.
Evaluations on real-world customer review data show that InsightNet performs
better than existing solutions in terms of structure, hierarchy and
completeness. We empirically demonstrate that InsightNet outperforms the
current state-of-the-art methods in multi-label topic classification, achieving
an F1 score of 0.85, which is an improvement of 11% F1-score over the previous
best results. Additionally, InsightNet generalises well for unseen aspects and
suggests new topics to be added to the taxonomy.
|
InsightNet: Structured Insight Mining from Customer Feedback: We propose InsightNet, a novel approach for the automated extraction of
structured insights from customer reviews. Our end-to-end machine learning
framework is designed to overcome the limitations of current solutions,
including the absence of structure for identified topics, non-standard aspect
names, and lack of abundant training data. The proposed solution builds a
semi-supervised multi-level taxonomy from raw reviews, a semantic similarity
heuristic approach to generate labelled data and employs a multi-task insight
extraction architecture by fine-tuning an LLM. InsightNet identifies granular
actionable topics with customer sentiments and verbatim for each topic.
Evaluations on real-world customer review data show that InsightNet performs
better than existing solutions in terms of structure, hierarchy and
completeness. We empirically demonstrate that InsightNet outperforms the
current state-of-the-art methods in multi-label topic classification, achieving
an F1 score of 0.85, which is an improvement of 11% F1-score over the previous
best results. Additionally, InsightNet generalises well for unseen aspects and
suggests new topics to be added to the taxonomy.
|
[
0.044878114,
0.003707814,
-0.0111007337,
0.065498203,
-0.0094357375,
0.0143399788,
-0.0158644952,
0.0143692829,
-0.0108013563,
-0.0766802505,
-0.070233129,
0.0195182227,
-0.033530727,
0.0728461742,
-0.0418177508,
-0.0289855879,
0.0084317215,
0.032264553,
0.0160551704,
0.0640664473,
0.0206535365,
0.0519961268,
-0.0275134929,
0.0286385212,
-0.0020628287,
-0.0299811903,
0.009754817,
-0.0037083591,
0.0168391783,
-0.0191124529,
0.0472706407,
-0.001157216,
-0.0134754786,
0.0138559211,
0.0000022001,
-0.0194913261,
-0.0356726609,
-0.0313636772,
0.007798776,
-0.0059749791,
0.0534903817,
-0.0013418461,
0.0429761782,
0.0070123323,
-0.0309134014,
0.0185486674,
-0.0275391527,
0.1414086968,
0.0643105507,
0.019404579,
-0.0347348899,
-0.0262200925,
-0.0431034602,
0.0115341162,
-0.0034023081,
-0.0359760448,
-0.0137699824,
0.020432923,
-0.0420783758,
0.0706582889,
0.0284704249,
0.0002455822,
-0.0090780165,
-0.0001829459,
0.040246021,
0.0183293819,
0.0025764811,
0.0131535269,
-0.0356704928,
0.037238922,
-0.0028571291,
0.0196993146,
-0.0005817516,
-0.0510367192,
-0.009258396,
-0.0371594355,
-0.0043987515,
-0.0220718514,
-0.0081885103,
0.0222093146,
-0.0185342412,
0.0208250806,
0.0036577992,
-0.0503100529,
0.0141375409,
0.0791821256,
-0.044034373,
-0.0178496595,
0.0308567733,
0.0302781053,
0.0130348364,
-0.0206884462,
-0.0264356211,
-0.0185965355,
-0.0147329979,
0.0014730748,
0.0213195458,
0.0010879213,
0.0152529152,
-0.0813031867,
0.0444178544,
-0.0532012098,
-0.0118712718,
0.0407406799,
-0.0271681622,
-0.0445288643,
0.0013223337,
-0.0060077561,
-0.0655884147,
-0.0010044334,
-0.0903307199,
-0.0122431433,
0.0126792006,
0.0742272958,
0.0027583286,
-0.0176524315,
-0.0440569445,
-0.0132617857,
-0.0191012882,
0.0179406963,
0.0276867915,
0.0227939524,
0.0107937576,
-0.0081628561,
-0.057476338,
-0.0160449091,
-0.061770279,
0.0706039146,
-0.0402234979,
0.0339347199,
0.0184718482,
0.0472793505,
0.0235683545,
0.0362734012,
-0.0028133283,
0.0173124075,
-0.0089845555,
-0.0463696681,
-0.0917087793,
-0.0639514178,
-0.0195776671,
-0.0172741618,
-0.0001208434,
-0.0483672991,
0.0190088935,
-0.0195104387,
-0.0410793014,
0.0295763034,
0.0089263814,
0.0110096624,
-0.0074699223,
0.0495161489,
-0.0659753829,
-0.0298540816,
0.0169856623,
0.0142160691,
0.0402518213,
0.0145081272,
-0.0049220622,
0.0628201216,
0.055193875,
0.0323032811,
-0.0012034433,
-0.0169876013,
0.0041486234,
-0.0357421972,
0.0283102021,
-0.0002160722,
-0.0662813932,
-0.0292698089,
-0.0045061912,
-0.0027514792,
0.0297765397,
0.0464262031,
0.022986725,
0.0170967095,
-0.0080045303,
0.0705219731,
-0.0021547177,
0.0377002805,
-0.0277046412,
-0.0036255969,
0.0531409867,
0.0271988008,
0.0026988348,
-0.0158857908,
0.0061705443,
-0.0495302677,
-0.0288129281,
-0.0708869398,
-0.0083438223,
-0.015602529,
-0.0274801478,
-0.0191051941,
0.0464856029,
0.040445555,
-0.0500002466,
0.0311134607,
0.040384803,
-0.0237749293,
-0.0482249372,
-0.015480645,
0.059525907,
0.0513773039,
0.0131616592,
-0.0372497402,
-0.0140838372,
-0.0111830235,
-0.0509691909,
0.0063954457,
0.0317323916,
-0.015849242,
-0.0433289967,
-0.0255851001,
-0.0098824212,
0.0033919404,
0.0173162706,
0.0202548224,
-0.0490076542,
0.0166750569,
0.0130131533,
0.0021994589,
-0.0049704495,
0.0218865313,
0.0333188251,
-0.0054700417,
0.0429043695,
-0.016204169,
0.0555857532,
0.0588335283,
-0.001084918,
-0.0020279037,
0.0565774925,
-0.0601495802,
-0.078098543,
0.0069789402,
-0.0039706295,
-0.0253471565,
-0.0160586257,
-0.013676622,
0.0076094088,
0.000567202,
-0.0271173101,
-0.0075085619,
-0.019128507,
0.0403738208,
0.0263371132,
-0.0147711234,
-0.0364453308,
0.0331843197,
0.0070684878,
-0.0051861918,
0.0597759634,
0.0109023564,
0.0090583982,
-0.0444722995,
-0.1228441298,
-0.0087042497,
0.0626050904,
0.000332716,
0.0058093718,
0.0050817751,
0.0051748706,
0.0052315048,
0.0437672548,
-0.0069567477,
0.0265529919,
-0.0888874084,
-0.0133402459,
0.0038837688,
0.0160459913,
0.032791961,
-0.0192643944,
0.0259412769,
0.0198659431,
-0.0369288363,
0.018013807,
-0.0177689884,
-0.0351905525,
0.0635108128,
0.0561075546,
0.0099710729,
-0.0403040648,
-0.0051999418,
-0.025893867,
0.0053132847,
0.0199918672,
-0.0483376943,
-0.0231599752,
0.0429731607,
-0.0239852984,
-0.0217690058,
-0.0380463824,
0.0174746327,
-0.0331880115,
-0.0376248285,
-0.0374662802,
-0.0274262186,
0.027604403,
0.0105604809,
-0.0357998125,
0.0031963701,
-0.0337974504,
0.023547763,
-0.0615400039,
0.0017319119,
0.0048771524,
-0.0185409486,
0.0824480057,
0.0512618423,
0.0340393968,
-0.0109824138,
-0.0416876897,
-0.0036933038,
-0.04336714,
-0.0037768071,
-0.0756783336,
0.0179987587,
0.0234908666,
0.0439005271,
0.0260054227,
0.0028688114,
0.0438100025,
0.0075128176,
0.0260403343,
-0.0600723401,
-0.0286048111,
-0.0600870736,
0.0751928389,
-0.0352846123,
0.0355818458,
0.0116055226,
0.0179219171,
0.0289974343,
-0.0587049462,
0.0015545946,
0.0293971319,
0.0719750524,
-0.0177311338,
-0.0008669775,
0.0006882705,
-0.0247294214,
-0.0124078533,
-0.0131010022,
-0.0209340453,
0.0023723815,
0.0866992325,
-0.0066666123,
-0.0076511321,
0.0061248564,
-0.0409608893,
0.0315541066,
0.0139391506,
-0.0417194813,
0.0167439673,
0.0254602078,
0.0516592525,
-0.0349177383,
0.0097369924,
-0.0244517978,
0.0369010568,
0.0772122964,
-0.0291501377,
-0.0202503745,
-0.0111032063,
-0.0320919082,
0.0044651092,
-0.0302359033,
0.0354762413,
-0.0296676233,
0.0092018656,
-0.0302636903,
0.0059111835,
0.0920975357,
0.0701259524,
-0.0480339751,
-0.0016581722,
0.0023713675,
-0.0107910438,
0.011909835,
0.007158373,
-0.0329386294,
-0.0237738397,
-0.0380329788,
0.0327125043,
0.0248625409,
-0.0112658013,
-0.007132587,
-0.0786891133,
0.0395026021,
-0.0265262518,
0.0121071171,
-0.1050829291,
-0.0092418175,
-0.0358514972,
0.026444627,
-0.0336245336,
-0.0139216054,
-0.0065698852,
-0.0235008709,
0.008391954,
-0.0756671205,
-0.0199224297,
0.0734202191,
0.019269729,
-0.0038393508,
0.0250678454,
0.0398454256,
-0.0122899553,
0.0133416774,
0.0241288077,
-0.0301105082,
-0.0092469826,
-0.0126553252,
0.0812269151,
-0.0435271077,
0.0049095228,
0.0317137353,
0.0213294942,
-0.0917911828,
0.0259245895,
0.0596813336,
0.0073827747,
-0.0319382437,
-0.0296056438,
-0.0171069857,
0.0303502493,
-0.0024349126,
0.0603420064,
-0.0230733491,
-0.0508118346,
0.0274862368,
-0.0135952057,
-0.0202472936,
-0.009091733,
-0.0440612659,
0.0154382251,
-0.0088779135,
-0.0114464406,
-0.0693877563,
-0.0096630622,
-0.0080921696,
0.0178053714,
0.0097439364,
-0.0090951379,
0.0148211895,
0.0204566512,
-0.009471152,
0.0042110523,
0.0392997228,
0.0000750933,
-0.014812937,
-0.0177377015,
0.0881356448,
-0.0216114465,
-0.049627319,
0.0078660892,
-0.0273397733,
0.007134954,
-0.0325720869,
0.0260126125,
0.0034168873,
0.0255809799,
0.0089080473,
0.010037153,
-0.0073677427,
0.0357350893,
-0.0397940241,
-0.0508027747,
0.0338333249,
0.0474946424,
0.0189192854,
0.0479265712,
-0.0449097417,
0.0341120996,
-0.0221267883,
-0.0109524801,
-0.0599894412,
-0.0333672985,
0.0137054222,
-0.0315653495,
0.0347756669,
0.0186328087,
0.0127783213,
-0.0678238198,
0.0263961628,
-0.0050053243,
-0.0241616387,
-0.0628354922,
0.0218668338,
-0.0247677825,
-0.0196406953,
-0.0720286593,
0.0452531762,
-0.004009672,
0.0338217653,
-0.0195135362,
0.0248627886,
0.020138653,
-0.0053388448,
-0.035934899,
-0.0117178103,
-0.0085688513,
-0.0225166008,
0.0038773553,
0.0038888745,
-0.00789095,
0.0615847819,
0.0287497286,
0.021762792,
-0.0600625612,
0.0433140248,
-0.0026637337,
-0.0227481388,
-0.0315612592,
0.0154219298,
-0.0004261847,
-0.0176705234,
0.0139379604,
-0.0832630023,
-0.0071936473,
0.0177660473,
0.0296740178,
-0.0086657889,
0.0184045732,
0.0251026191,
0.0011899649,
-0.0334062316,
-0.0170908254,
0.0788484886,
-0.0693908706,
0.0077554062,
-0.0182942208,
-0.0478898361,
-0.0803135261,
0.0254194345,
0.0535918884,
0.0210394282,
0.0116459383,
-0.0027156132,
-0.0409416929,
-0.0224897731,
0.0345521085,
0.0058268309,
0.0136716692,
0.0018995259,
0.0762395412,
0.0640153289,
0.0272734296,
-0.0278507881,
-0.0549863614,
-0.0147442613,
-0.0223892611,
0.0135278516,
-0.0184067301,
-6.667921175e-33,
-0.0359523259,
-0.0294133797,
-0.0434108861,
0.0596556254,
0.0266780816,
0.0147512164,
-0.0235757865,
0.0492292233,
0.0426538698,
0.0630840883,
0.0123082362,
0.0106407078,
-0.0076946891,
0.0115401726,
0.0334673561,
-0.0127500407,
0.0471945517,
-0.0354662873,
0.0374316499,
0.0604981221,
0.053348124,
0.0238208845,
0.0348305628,
-0.1076579541,
0.0498153195,
-0.0126977358,
-0.0474386401,
0.0053281751,
0.0239961985,
0.0355506055,
0.0026350243,
0.0704754665,
0.0394257195,
-0.0554476306,
0.0499646552,
0.0217107721,
-0.0516797416,
0.0068693422,
-0.0294542871,
-0.0256827809,
-0.0552150607,
0.0074605942,
-0.00405028,
0.0120442789,
-0.0019802465,
0.0206288695,
0.0703592375,
-0.0093432507,
0.0196801536,
-0.1329564154,
-0.0386692807,
0.0143898223,
-0.0230902359,
-0.0013398266,
0.0110000148,
0.0436324738,
0.0076273587,
0.05094276,
-0.0464005023,
0.0045104488,
-0.0079304036,
0.0497411378,
0.0136682447,
-0.0122147081,
-0.0390901603,
0.0703145638,
-0.0212445222,
0.0268246029,
0.0041350061,
0.0524364114,
-0.0037882107,
0.0584723279,
0.0051260726,
-0.0175459683,
-0.033630833,
-0.0363824964,
-0.0236984715,
0.0282498021,
0.0178703815,
-0.0191691276,
0.0313218571,
-0.0175289661,
-0.0363763906,
-0.0007536007,
0.0552364849,
-0.0285358857,
-0.0156703182,
-0.0092703402,
0.0021509319,
0.012101952,
-0.0209649839,
-0.0020824266,
-0.0202408209,
-0.0301514976,
-0.0085204393,
-0.0100328382,
-0.0298823733,
-0.0031127294,
0.0077469274,
-0.011128732,
-0.079729706,
-0.0034659321,
-0.0678979307,
-0.0021245391,
0.0114770019,
-0.0208240561,
0.0623872131,
-0.0016885062,
-0.0588812195,
0.01359984,
0.0312065408,
0.0012798879,
-0.0387811586,
0.0966049135,
-0.0046951054,
0.0044804565,
-0.0194598194,
0.0910391659,
-0.0407440402,
0.0597018935,
-0.0009189079,
0.0286945477,
-0.0131013393,
0.0031350541,
-0.0008400558,
-0.0396472029,
0.008114201,
-0.0356783196,
0.0433562472,
-0.0382495821,
-0.0100477766,
0.0346443392,
2.892e-7,
0.0347133204,
0.0531675257,
-0.0348046832,
-0.0271784998,
0.0605782308,
0.0814068913,
0.0525819398,
0.0027154118,
-0.0130677903,
-0.0418671817,
0.0495950356,
-0.0135036036,
-0.0054357983,
0.0647022203,
-0.083701916,
-0.0121592786,
-0.0172399543,
-0.0195040163,
-0.0526168942,
-0.0212631766,
0.0910731182,
0.0540237427,
0.0015601213,
-0.0126111088,
0.0058493717,
0.0134451361,
-0.0076265102,
-0.0391737521,
-0.0384861752,
0.0385255404,
0.016525913,
0.0134076774,
-0.0430085137,
-0.0130187403,
-0.054746028,
0.0043724594,
0.0328164436,
0.0292034764,
0.0314564183,
-0.0698611736,
0.0078765284,
0.0403332487,
0.0197515134,
-0.0013687006,
0.0177784171,
-0.07583417,
-0.0325190425,
-0.0655029714,
0.0442803949,
0.0181175172,
-0.0110578872,
0.0063592666,
-0.0160310213,
0.0390601158,
-0.0090559358,
-0.0324277952,
-0.0291478783,
-0.0831394047,
0.0589515381,
0.0687885731,
-0.030013036,
0.0046779113,
0.0077153766,
0.014503072,
-0.0004299344,
-0.0137272459,
0.005329079,
2.476532646e-34,
0.0492237546,
-0.0156090846,
-0.0081629809,
0.0224744063,
0.0051280893,
0.0202913992,
-0.0613097325,
-0.010392148,
-0.0065935641,
0.0115335761,
0.0207586791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13001v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13001v1
|
Large Language Models for Education: A Survey
| 2024-05-12T01:50:01 | 2024-05-12T01:50:01 |
Hanyi Xu, Wensheng Gan, Zhenlian Qi, Jiayang Wu, Philip S. Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
Artificial intelligence (AI) has a profound impact on traditional education.
In recent years, large language models (LLMs) have been increasingly used in
various applications such as natural language processing, computer vision,
speech recognition, and autonomous driving. LLMs have also been applied in many
fields, including recommendation, finance, government, education, legal
affairs, and finance. As powerful auxiliary tools, LLMs incorporate various
technologies such as deep learning, pre-training, fine-tuning, and
reinforcement learning. The use of LLMs for smart education (LLMEdu) has been a
significant strategic direction for countries worldwide. While LLMs have shown
great promise in improving teaching quality, changing education models, and
modifying teacher roles, the technologies are still facing several challenges.
In this paper, we conduct a systematic review of LLMEdu, focusing on current
technologies, challenges, and future developments. We first summarize the
current state of LLMEdu and then introduce the characteristics of LLMs and
education, as well as the benefits of integrating LLMs into education. We also
review the process of integrating LLMs into the education industry, as well as
the introduction of related technologies. Finally, we discuss the challenges
and problems faced by LLMEdu, as well as prospects for future optimization of
LLMEdu.
|
Large Language Models for Education: A Survey: Artificial intelligence (AI) has a profound impact on traditional education.
In recent years, large language models (LLMs) have been increasingly used in
various applications such as natural language processing, computer vision,
speech recognition, and autonomous driving. LLMs have also been applied in many
fields, including recommendation, finance, government, education, legal
affairs, and finance. As powerful auxiliary tools, LLMs incorporate various
technologies such as deep learning, pre-training, fine-tuning, and
reinforcement learning. The use of LLMs for smart education (LLMEdu) has been a
significant strategic direction for countries worldwide. While LLMs have shown
great promise in improving teaching quality, changing education models, and
modifying teacher roles, the technologies are still facing several challenges.
In this paper, we conduct a systematic review of LLMEdu, focusing on current
technologies, challenges, and future developments. We first summarize the
current state of LLMEdu and then introduce the characteristics of LLMs and
education, as well as the benefits of integrating LLMs into education. We also
review the process of integrating LLMs into the education industry, as well as
the introduction of related technologies. Finally, we discuss the challenges
and problems faced by LLMEdu, as well as prospects for future optimization of
LLMEdu.
|
[
0.0657809079,
0.0206141677,
-0.0453161597,
0.0242277682,
-0.0204408113,
0.0167430509,
0.0472067595,
-0.044574786,
0.0064719184,
-0.0693986788,
-0.0174634159,
-0.0051032077,
-0.0249894802,
0.0396908224,
0.0290227979,
-0.0710081235,
0.0165788513,
-0.054839924,
0.0245849472,
0.0013696946,
-0.0148615297,
0.0051552001,
-0.0342515297,
0.0579975173,
-0.0011984605,
-0.0049036979,
-0.0137101421,
-0.0338195227,
0.0029893031,
-0.0270588845,
0.0210322645,
0.0426724851,
0.0301158577,
0.0427331217,
0.0000024957,
-0.0733775869,
-0.0028292667,
-0.0214951728,
0.0038379675,
0.0254265685,
0.0204632748,
0.0307693873,
-0.0276639853,
0.0326260179,
-0.0730918199,
0.0165241156,
0.0404570363,
0.0016335583,
0.0307020117,
0.0289388243,
0.0143088065,
-0.0651835352,
0.0686053783,
0.0042231162,
-0.0383762233,
-0.0166721363,
0.0536244176,
0.0004453617,
0.0199291203,
-0.0068708197,
-0.0508473106,
0.0320247412,
0.0237586536,
-0.0475328453,
-0.0049003195,
0.0118326871,
-0.002116119,
-0.0364887938,
-0.0174156632,
0.053048756,
-0.0129684433,
0.0014858275,
0.029062869,
-0.0214281604,
-0.0016737259,
0.0086062998,
-0.0566594414,
0.0429029614,
0.0395886786,
0.0373294577,
0.0310293846,
-0.0225870591,
0.0200414229,
0.0604990646,
-0.0245897621,
0.0463034213,
0.0053062709,
-0.0219250303,
-0.0046211006,
0.046614334,
0.0159928184,
-0.0238033216,
0.030399261,
0.0650077984,
-0.0090108998,
0.0194990113,
-0.0187094714,
-0.0503489822,
0.017530011,
-0.0243866332,
0.0072549703,
0.0140354699,
0.0018755439,
0.0319532715,
-0.0019756239,
0.0657680482,
-0.0047270437,
0.0359697677,
-0.019406341,
0.0162779931,
-0.0265008118,
-0.00749812,
-0.0131057389,
0.0634292662,
-0.0164633598,
-0.0103989504,
-0.0536484644,
0.0157790761,
-0.0531010218,
0.0184371453,
-0.0247858595,
-0.0073072813,
-0.0051964615,
-0.0228139218,
-0.0432362817,
0.0626308173,
0.0047583668,
0.0337845348,
-0.009825415,
-0.0105244098,
0.0533235893,
0.0139780371,
-0.0142222298,
0.0057947366,
0.0225192066,
0.0651594475,
-0.0050877994,
-0.0369926877,
-0.0539031364,
-0.0393070467,
-0.0006015995,
-0.069382377,
0.0228777435,
-0.1087881848,
-0.0235698465,
-0.0277076103,
-0.0054606735,
-0.0351959318,
0.0135805169,
-0.0114719309,
0.0005940698,
0.0259213559,
-0.0201628879,
0.0105837304,
0.0612513982,
-0.0156506877,
0.0494735874,
0.062978439,
0.0416468158,
-0.0126489,
0.0030452358,
-0.0359944142,
-0.0116600534,
0.0419784822,
-0.002562897,
-0.0036224695,
-0.0125513291,
-0.0228087846,
-0.0162420813,
0.056258399,
-0.0201874617,
0.0433513969,
0.010284923,
0.0321699344,
0.0527136102,
0.0676855817,
0.0212952346,
0.0203126036,
0.0384408236,
0.0399964452,
0.0446730368,
-0.0247908421,
-0.0346187726,
0.0025187032,
-0.0393486582,
-0.0067552361,
0.003041368,
0.0584203936,
-0.00940686,
-0.0834067687,
0.0034785264,
-0.0500247516,
0.0139768533,
0.0430807061,
0.0947233215,
-0.0410569385,
-0.0062357737,
-0.0104162423,
0.0633077174,
0.0105796903,
0.037716344,
-0.0961284637,
0.0571809448,
0.1087289751,
0.0471772701,
-0.0516452678,
-0.050192479,
-0.0253545456,
0.0006698107,
0.0725543573,
0.0303216912,
0.0053185285,
-0.0464810543,
-0.0354702137,
-0.0188057274,
0.0090252301,
0.0074125868,
0.0049116365,
-0.0203173775,
0.0414405875,
-0.0031682584,
0.0179223027,
-0.0421154499,
0.0233322475,
-0.057076145,
-0.0371958166,
-0.0254455432,
0.0370390974,
0.0218267739,
0.0524361283,
-0.0034193294,
-0.0105793597,
0.0302779563,
-0.0049247225,
-0.0121624945,
-0.0709797144,
-0.071837835,
0.0427481346,
0.0677012429,
-0.0706495643,
0.0091475351,
0.0285687391,
-0.0298661385,
-0.0338779762,
0.0122192549,
-0.0218822937,
0.0200583749,
-0.0236140639,
0.0349171497,
-0.0535760373,
-0.0073272269,
-0.0400811248,
0.0153421257,
0.0218638889,
-0.025657542,
0.0370866321,
0.0382645428,
0.0095976638,
-0.0095607825,
-0.0464258641,
0.0104067111,
-0.0112017393,
0.0431759842,
0.0274311602,
0.0551177002,
-0.0306210369,
-0.0213012956,
-0.0383432955,
-0.0056927279,
0.0064891698,
-0.0016784066,
-0.0463343114,
-0.0162034724,
-0.014521529,
0.0059729731,
-0.0211475641,
0.0132182082,
0.0095830737,
-0.0181527026,
-0.0136477258,
0.0100770378,
-0.023144519,
-0.0489981286,
-0.0367057696,
-0.0275329612,
0.0287546702,
0.041593764,
0.0025345334,
-0.033734221,
0.034832973,
-0.029590033,
0.0539691187,
0.0301382411,
-0.0395773351,
0.0124038234,
-0.0241409577,
0.0241204556,
0.0720582381,
0.0222882256,
0.0322832465,
0.053732384,
-0.0126824332,
-0.0688077435,
0.0069417073,
-0.0176523607,
-0.0138464654,
-0.0564939342,
0.0040400587,
-0.0526459664,
0.0305577647,
-0.0123859448,
-0.0107987924,
-0.0236471444,
0.0562677719,
-0.0355307534,
-0.0316598043,
-0.0371304229,
-0.000901145,
-0.0207887758,
0.0207880456,
0.0214201268,
-0.0233548973,
0.07174173,
-0.0005695841,
0.0429952182,
-0.033834897,
-0.0296753012,
-0.0401901565,
0.0074707717,
-0.0095537724,
0.0028125802,
-0.0341498442,
-0.0129314316,
-0.0426923931,
-0.0090929018,
0.0031281677,
-0.0583024323,
0.0464040674,
-0.044560425,
-0.0076513002,
-0.0202376172,
-0.0205400251,
-0.0310596004,
-0.0064454162,
-0.0416603088,
0.0130769517,
-0.0018283627,
-0.0115605388,
-0.0255262852,
0.0055861366,
0.0174907893,
0.0181268081,
-0.0101761036,
0.0205350965,
-0.0289206654,
0.0032424978,
0.0507055521,
-0.0281040408,
0.0028804033,
-0.0127062779,
0.0720685273,
0.0126283458,
0.0130269546,
-0.002037528,
-0.0195699297,
0.0220294334,
0.0316761285,
-0.0076117977,
-0.0160131548,
0.0365887843,
0.0006034173,
-0.1020449325,
-0.0018904728,
0.1128853485,
0.0122835534,
-0.0491334945,
-0.0142088141,
-0.0173081961,
-0.024744153,
-0.003089549,
0.0151684107,
-0.0890406072,
-0.0230772011,
-0.0114524793,
0.0088434452,
-0.010145328,
-0.0094307829,
0.0208318848,
-0.1190781519,
0.0103702061,
0.0183395967,
-0.0213965178,
-0.0259671267,
-0.0185163673,
-0.0242811516,
0.0216507465,
0.0363999158,
-0.0234740376,
-0.0079042632,
-0.0039048572,
0.0490085222,
-0.0343007855,
-0.0395939611,
0.0140604032,
-0.0610991865,
0.0495454259,
0.0685448796,
0.0385542773,
-0.0412043743,
-0.0137024196,
-0.0410351977,
0.0240246281,
-0.0027246182,
-0.0104613649,
-0.0194103401,
-0.0090156449,
-0.0130086578,
-0.0340712853,
0.044613447,
0.001463744,
0.0187704004,
0.0444757827,
0.1181561351,
-0.0361098126,
-0.0077066338,
-0.0411893278,
0.0005457947,
-0.018652251,
0.0603411198,
-0.0038081461,
-0.0919117928,
0.0041094641,
-0.0152939288,
-0.0419235155,
-0.002457798,
-0.0426882058,
0.0102829961,
-0.0017364639,
0.0116727632,
-0.0223627891,
-0.0458098464,
0.0558619872,
-0.0174181703,
0.0244783796,
0.0103287362,
0.1017141044,
-0.0020239169,
-0.0493224598,
0.0173682366,
-0.0430082381,
0.0173849314,
-0.1117249876,
-0.0271549653,
0.0054914053,
-0.0541006401,
-0.0120784501,
0.0175210573,
-0.0582246706,
-0.0857614428,
0.0123828761,
0.0374642275,
0.0102108466,
0.0112765972,
0.0142391883,
-0.0574344136,
0.0767870992,
0.0271167774,
-0.0016183354,
0.0057520331,
-0.0002795643,
-0.0048915721,
0.0187118612,
0.0022667926,
-0.0542284399,
0.0224877577,
0.0199221596,
-0.0107990624,
-0.0256804805,
-0.038084548,
0.0045278301,
0.0265530944,
0.0511558242,
0.0011711428,
-0.0197288189,
-0.0610537119,
0.007193788,
-0.0285522174,
0.0099501349,
-0.0137266535,
-0.0137126688,
0.0345779061,
0.0211781822,
0.0153047582,
0.0018139201,
0.0417320505,
-0.0159700457,
-0.0186263435,
0.0764017552,
-0.0304107778,
0.0440446101,
0.0217193887,
0.0160216615,
-0.0052635544,
0.0549361743,
-0.0122839352,
0.0209094994,
0.0092498288,
0.053387858,
0.0083509665,
0.0019686634,
0.0187681224,
-0.0048269629,
0.0099069364,
-0.0987227485,
-0.0227030404,
0.0560856797,
0.0517383516,
0.0169821288,
0.0100341812,
-0.0450480133,
0.0076136268,
-0.0136102606,
-0.0116593326,
-0.0081007984,
-0.0212674569,
0.028006807,
-0.0022385928,
0.013147559,
0.0355808511,
0.0406717695,
0.0265032146,
0.0369928256,
-0.0024814429,
0.0127221001,
-0.0224581063,
-0.0212979149,
0.0420763791,
0.0306657106,
-0.0158583988,
0.0161160678,
-0.0181255732,
-0.0321942158,
-0.0237781759,
0.008400511,
-0.0284646582,
-0.0541862957,
0.0593869835,
0.0206682067,
-0.0320870876,
0.0135371247,
-0.0182445757,
-0.0061443252,
0.0037996063,
-0.0410521962,
0.0084850183,
-6.543929297e-33,
-0.0243985318,
-0.0355557688,
0.0606868975,
0.034771055,
-0.0090985354,
-0.011963333,
-0.0055854856,
-0.0002610169,
-0.0186016802,
0.0008219158,
0.0316079259,
0.0000046717,
0.0039170915,
0.0479940064,
0.0187441483,
0.0150714833,
0.0405445956,
-0.0121901082,
0.0551598333,
0.0298733674,
-0.0011726071,
0.0239328817,
0.0564939268,
-0.0389806256,
0.0007517093,
0.0149371,
0.0044851089,
-0.0037200612,
-0.0558580458,
0.054992862,
-0.0274973027,
0.0536771007,
0.0098137166,
-0.0376914553,
-0.0378220752,
0.0526176654,
-0.0602065548,
-0.0386799872,
-0.0107096359,
0.0429576449,
-0.0085608913,
-0.0605101138,
0.0922276899,
-0.0006022758,
-0.0599281937,
0.0049239579,
0.0713548586,
-0.0277633909,
-0.0038112451,
-0.025905503,
-0.0965272039,
0.0071141152,
-0.0468626581,
-0.0094182519,
0.0289527886,
-0.0010584295,
-0.0253739953,
0.0209596567,
-0.0483866893,
0.0662526414,
0.0498802066,
0.0062146154,
0.0721248314,
0.005107577,
-0.008935214,
0.0448101945,
0.0317790061,
-0.0214253049,
0.0015475074,
-0.0313570648,
0.0830667838,
0.0544312708,
0.0741839185,
0.0448622666,
-0.0149440765,
-0.0161358118,
-0.0742492378,
-0.0154734161,
0.0313209854,
0.0132795358,
0.0330844969,
-0.0204230938,
-0.0546750613,
-0.0160166174,
-0.0352648571,
0.0148577057,
0.0020347189,
-0.0119117042,
0.0391532667,
-0.0476041995,
-0.0009539407,
0.0121301962,
0.0316859335,
-0.0686296523,
-0.0013787271,
0.0073813088,
-0.0002541901,
0.0097219842,
-0.0268598087,
0.0183774512,
-0.0819318071,
-0.0713837743,
-0.0009414125,
-0.0234430209,
0.0041713263,
0.0329419933,
0.002949795,
0.0040706373,
-0.0306657013,
0.0092974063,
-0.0230795648,
-0.0220614448,
0.0674246475,
-0.0241174623,
0.0237716045,
-0.0143948812,
0.0154811796,
0.0573367625,
0.029789051,
-0.0475398973,
-0.0055960696,
-0.0557839349,
-0.0104243336,
0.0148561075,
-0.0369653143,
-0.0041901795,
-0.089873679,
-0.0000971765,
0.0161700267,
-0.0789810419,
0.0040038666,
0.0247436147,
3.119e-7,
-0.0007448425,
0.092858687,
-0.0085209766,
-0.0275246836,
-0.0062493677,
0.0535148494,
0.0129269212,
-0.0104761505,
0.0253118072,
0.0781459808,
0.0276526492,
0.0222083777,
0.0435791165,
-0.0036478729,
-0.0704448894,
-0.0002721509,
-0.0408109017,
0.0140358489,
-0.1111790091,
0.0249765608,
0.0093956357,
0.0767160431,
0.0479389429,
-0.0253688656,
-0.0103022829,
-0.0413939655,
0.0198439956,
-0.022217473,
-0.035080146,
0.0027732484,
0.0037864021,
0.0482602641,
0.0086067654,
0.0164452698,
0.0123844976,
0.0295481589,
-0.026221564,
0.0345992446,
-0.0006540908,
0.0280628279,
0.0131065389,
-0.0246531479,
-0.0318104438,
-0.0389083549,
0.0782602429,
-0.0442055836,
-0.0127745271,
-0.0172207262,
-0.0319258049,
-0.0485664718,
-0.0037859792,
-0.042742908,
0.0233393535,
-0.0241164658,
0.0033408215,
-0.0454309471,
0.0107096937,
-0.0273468364,
0.0331603959,
0.0094904285,
-0.0276016556,
-0.0293695573,
-0.0277324654,
0.0068928977,
0.0231310613,
-0.0459115244,
0.0223852638,
2.618051146e-34,
0.0177051984,
-0.0177588817,
0.0236268695,
-0.0191858523,
0.0175725948,
0.034034349,
-0.0590121597,
0.0118268337,
0.0051435721,
-0.0807948858,
-0.0173453335
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07111v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07111v1
|
Designing and Evaluating Dialogue LLMs for Co-Creative Improvised Theatre
| 2024-05-11T23:19:42 | 2024-05-11T23:19:42 |
Boyd Branch, Piotr Mirowski, Kory Mathewson, Sophia Ppali, Alexandra Covaci
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Social robotics researchers are increasingly interested in multi-party
trained conversational agents. With a growing demand for real-world
evaluations, our study presents Large Language Models (LLMs) deployed in a
month-long live show at the Edinburgh Festival Fringe. This case study
investigates human improvisers co-creating with conversational agents in a
professional theatre setting. We explore the technical capabilities and
constraints of on-the-spot multi-party dialogue, providing comprehensive
insights from both audience and performer experiences with AI on stage. Our
human-in-the-loop methodology underlines the challenges of these LLMs in
generating context-relevant responses, stressing the user interface's crucial
role. Audience feedback indicates an evolving interest for AI-driven live
entertainment, direct human-AI interaction, and a diverse range of expectations
about AI's conversational competence and utility as a creativity support tool.
Human performers express immense enthusiasm, varied satisfaction, and the
evolving public opinion highlights mixed emotions about AI's role in arts.
|
Designing and Evaluating Dialogue LLMs for Co-Creative Improvised Theatre: Social robotics researchers are increasingly interested in multi-party
trained conversational agents. With a growing demand for real-world
evaluations, our study presents Large Language Models (LLMs) deployed in a
month-long live show at the Edinburgh Festival Fringe. This case study
investigates human improvisers co-creating with conversational agents in a
professional theatre setting. We explore the technical capabilities and
constraints of on-the-spot multi-party dialogue, providing comprehensive
insights from both audience and performer experiences with AI on stage. Our
human-in-the-loop methodology underlines the challenges of these LLMs in
generating context-relevant responses, stressing the user interface's crucial
role. Audience feedback indicates an evolving interest for AI-driven live
entertainment, direct human-AI interaction, and a diverse range of expectations
about AI's conversational competence and utility as a creativity support tool.
Human performers express immense enthusiasm, varied satisfaction, and the
evolving public opinion highlights mixed emotions about AI's role in arts.
|
[
0.0423190743,
-0.0324409604,
-0.0420663431,
0.0065343319,
-0.0394990221,
-0.0054831654,
0.0180073585,
-0.0153324092,
0.0150087262,
-0.0228726044,
-0.045435302,
-0.0200045127,
-0.0052499054,
0.0901512951,
0.0035740256,
-0.0442208983,
-0.0204280149,
-0.0633201748,
0.0411474444,
0.0143457185,
-0.028623879,
0.0086180167,
-0.0517619886,
0.0593505614,
-0.0297363494,
0.0044328105,
-0.0527415909,
0.015899526,
0.0154313454,
0.0180709362,
-0.0404583924,
0.0245473739,
0.0509711355,
0.0532651991,
0.0000016154,
-0.0231124293,
0.0250684079,
-0.0221561156,
0.0425228477,
-0.0310099442,
0.0254201349,
0.06048375,
-0.0457163677,
0.0257125646,
-0.0339045711,
0.015742097,
0.0443563201,
0.018533485,
0.06472487,
0.0660973713,
0.0062341625,
-0.0109114135,
0.0221184716,
-0.0161631703,
-0.0201449953,
-0.0235214867,
-0.0040839049,
-0.0100618107,
0.097248435,
-0.0416516662,
-0.0192962196,
0.0187214017,
0.0356210731,
-0.0481926352,
0.0027291207,
0.0245095715,
-0.0759107247,
-0.0548041053,
0.0060976907,
0.0623005368,
0.0551262721,
0.0155524686,
0.0024315494,
0.0232576877,
0.0336357392,
0.0189418532,
-0.0363017693,
0.0375512764,
0.0109057045,
-0.0345644727,
-0.0970904827,
-0.0373658277,
0.0023042429,
0.0088642724,
0.0458579026,
0.0204162505,
-0.005937485,
0.0203555599,
-0.0388157964,
-0.0154097611,
-0.0281784125,
-0.0806575865,
0.0102480417,
0.0555351488,
-0.0555464439,
0.0161513742,
-0.0326299705,
0.0188645497,
-0.0280336235,
-0.0388042405,
0.0422583632,
0.0380568691,
0.025618786,
0.0477368049,
0.0355750397,
0.0397605971,
-0.0250884257,
0.0629418343,
0.0334594063,
0.0035118277,
-0.0362730846,
-0.0321337022,
-0.0584143884,
-0.0071662785,
-0.054127045,
-0.0481587462,
0.0226787161,
0.0459882468,
-0.0348574929,
0.0259761028,
-0.0151928831,
0.0011230875,
-0.0119976532,
-0.0285385214,
-0.0215042364,
0.0440504923,
-0.0046884967,
0.0393653475,
0.0454659462,
-0.0425051898,
0.0111368131,
0.0285078119,
0.0153600266,
-0.017266918,
-0.0001181715,
0.0452250391,
-0.0199758261,
-0.0660382584,
0.0218305551,
-0.0063517708,
-0.0179560464,
-0.0436090864,
-0.0050347261,
-0.0156171303,
0.0460224673,
-0.0321255364,
-0.0287628174,
-0.0291619413,
0.0086362464,
0.028742779,
0.0157450493,
0.0207791943,
-0.0108845858,
0.0503880717,
0.0246328488,
0.0184359867,
-0.0265456643,
-0.0056325155,
0.1112558395,
0.0558136217,
0.0238186847,
-0.0089474283,
0.0698359087,
0.024187617,
-0.0496545918,
-0.0050707222,
-0.0312465951,
-0.0122419707,
0.0018081,
0.0519266203,
-0.018471593,
0.0273343641,
-0.0009307105,
0.0446166582,
0.0629335269,
-0.0057598595,
-0.0177740455,
-0.0219443515,
0.0678972676,
0.0142680695,
0.0004723146,
-0.0019806148,
0.0165215507,
0.0466504321,
0.050561551,
-0.0108687505,
0.0451280214,
0.0041599795,
-0.0132716298,
-0.0107062524,
0.0145312902,
-0.0053503118,
0.049987223,
0.0246419534,
-0.0079626283,
0.0205737911,
-0.0472300388,
-0.0632258058,
0.0021463889,
-0.0810476691,
0.0160018224,
-0.0529650562,
0.0192148704,
0.115005441,
0.0384537317,
-0.0354907587,
0.013626785,
-0.0036042884,
0.0347355083,
0.0741088241,
0.0483812205,
-0.0367891677,
0.0000523695,
0.0226666443,
0.0361228138,
-0.0233447663,
-0.0060886317,
0.0149698202,
-0.0483434908,
0.0164087303,
-0.0203684084,
0.0295829307,
-0.0310081858,
-0.0026277003,
-0.0887046531,
-0.0046580969,
-0.0257647373,
-0.0055478006,
0.0400537327,
0.0635294542,
-0.0718075633,
0.0060348767,
0.0445306823,
0.012009494,
-0.0152914021,
0.0555843152,
-0.0145662418,
0.0113693587,
0.017183667,
-0.0398418047,
-0.0172886979,
0.0329335108,
0.0149027044,
-0.0274999179,
0.0642369986,
-0.0222521629,
0.0381247923,
-0.0122946911,
0.0049370686,
-0.0132720303,
-0.0317233354,
0.0173019674,
-0.0212116763,
0.0166976526,
-0.0079511572,
-0.0198933799,
0.0405800343,
0.0140038077,
-0.0441903248,
-0.0241996851,
0.0757469982,
0.0193402078,
0.0618010573,
0.0057635359,
0.0075300806,
-0.0357003473,
-0.0418253094,
-0.1311762631,
-0.0264003053,
-0.0248742625,
-0.063858591,
-0.0148824872,
-0.0111484453,
-0.0338281244,
-0.0005910851,
-0.0170539618,
-0.0398477428,
0.0137901446,
0.0017636728,
-0.0137765314,
0.0380506106,
-0.0590351671,
-0.0091137802,
0.0176543463,
-0.0080774855,
0.0010323433,
0.0642579421,
-0.0020376551,
0.0113252653,
-0.0391421914,
-0.0577318706,
0.0163022038,
-0.0430262424,
-0.0212764144,
0.0470119268,
-0.0300932415,
0.0036419637,
0.0362809598,
0.0001551071,
0.0262597073,
0.0773566514,
-0.0082926769,
-0.0056931097,
0.0300256591,
0.0205524098,
0.0300573688,
-0.0221538842,
0.0113049056,
0.0221629962,
0.0139305824,
0.0399456173,
0.0570554845,
-0.0517698415,
0.0558095016,
0.0124347927,
-0.0646572337,
0.0186074991,
-0.0339076705,
-0.0510678552,
0.0281516295,
-0.0077389153,
0.0276136938,
0.0377331115,
-0.0388190001,
-0.0300253332,
0.0027819034,
-0.0256033242,
-0.0398197696,
0.0665547401,
-0.05211493,
0.0488722213,
-0.0489891842,
-0.0135209002,
-0.0367217548,
0.0391395502,
0.0226642992,
-0.0465717055,
-0.0406530537,
-0.0490709245,
0.0160436574,
0.0037581765,
-0.0168646444,
0.0008213586,
-0.0294458847,
-0.0410794951,
0.0057679662,
-0.0100974906,
-0.0238897279,
-0.012024736,
0.0226756483,
0.0487917103,
0.0410566591,
0.0309799239,
0.0084841484,
-0.0418400057,
-0.0087029058,
0.0160586443,
0.0647754073,
-0.0619964376,
-0.001478512,
0.0282278508,
-0.0187505241,
0.0087871868,
-0.0070066806,
-0.0419883616,
-0.017730616,
0.0022814297,
0.0274144784,
0.0060132043,
0.0081670368,
0.064251557,
-0.0392199941,
0.0033671111,
0.0869224146,
0.0135321496,
-0.0308429915,
0.0034077032,
-0.0117076328,
-0.0047872444,
-0.0115763657,
-0.0012106337,
-0.0308937076,
0.0078602638,
0.0386703536,
0.0461863913,
0.0103182541,
-0.0259734746,
0.0059324997,
-0.1035317555,
0.0671770424,
-0.0078634387,
-0.0291928258,
-0.0638685524,
-0.0217324179,
0.037373554,
0.0431151725,
0.0333738066,
0.0454404801,
0.0125961713,
0.0278784446,
0.0219928604,
0.0069962628,
-0.0300908051,
0.0060776677,
-0.0440735035,
0.1242929995,
0.0299253166,
0.0612734891,
0.0081851091,
-0.0209931303,
0.0002806871,
0.0174968764,
0.0393709727,
0.0196491666,
0.0088562509,
0.0009651241,
0.007247576,
0.0233706795,
0.0109819351,
-0.0098133525,
-0.0281783342,
0.0175748691,
0.0244027674,
-0.056406077,
-0.013778328,
-0.0093518486,
0.0437430628,
0.0268138591,
0.0397063829,
0.0405455306,
-0.0663251355,
-0.0115416422,
-0.002814105,
-0.0212537739,
-0.0505710617,
-0.0563728251,
-0.0229509789,
0.0227304045,
-0.0334587023,
-0.0367442705,
-0.0229208786,
0.0184008051,
0.0569768846,
0.017787911,
-0.0172089543,
-0.0409791805,
0.0346831903,
-0.0308046378,
0.0127597488,
-0.0084492145,
0.0108339479,
-0.0488914289,
-0.0465152748,
-0.0208671354,
-0.0470621809,
-0.0025143081,
0.0059134052,
-0.0208076667,
-0.072338976,
0.0249731541,
0.0506400801,
0.029369168,
0.0132978028,
0.0147968121,
-0.0401499979,
-0.0361091681,
-0.0173884351,
-0.0276794005,
0.0679514185,
-0.0025917194,
0.0489648022,
-0.0267803594,
-0.0000475156,
-0.0369126648,
-0.0007160039,
0.0073036333,
0.0435583405,
-0.0129798735,
-0.0847084448,
0.0025960288,
0.0234311949,
-0.0062444126,
-0.024810547,
-0.0030416758,
-0.0295634046,
-0.0203484073,
-0.0421448387,
0.0142299952,
-0.0639904514,
-0.0337662399,
-0.0348742045,
-0.0189562384,
0.0082993237,
0.0183863863,
-0.0277361609,
0.0238285903,
-0.0120373871,
0.0097567076,
0.0521209799,
-0.027661426,
0.0098053757,
0.0037721826,
0.0200803187,
0.061717093,
-0.0199063625,
0.0074968096,
0.04321016,
0.0185346082,
0.0324250758,
-0.0746093988,
0.046014715,
0.0781184137,
-0.0404026471,
-0.0995017141,
0.0274152569,
0.0490681157,
0.0224695448,
0.0594431348,
0.0248508677,
-0.0096414397,
0.0239425469,
-0.0312174484,
0.0564308614,
0.0136537002,
-0.048863925,
-0.026441399,
0.0063216495,
-0.0100864405,
0.0083360802,
0.0674329773,
-0.030837005,
-0.0153507311,
-0.0113505218,
0.0029843936,
-0.0193010326,
-0.0360793881,
-0.0213332884,
-0.0182356145,
0.0049451604,
0.0461867936,
-0.0601623096,
-0.0508475602,
-0.0113253761,
0.0155845834,
-0.0062932442,
-0.0513022654,
0.0102311019,
0.0414228886,
0.025864739,
0.0394470654,
-0.0229407959,
-0.0229279138,
-0.0396203548,
0.0051616123,
-0.0206992701,
-4.984736325e-33,
-0.0587946847,
-0.0459153913,
0.0381529145,
0.019296309,
-0.0662500337,
-0.0399592146,
-0.0857884884,
0.0303395558,
0.0160996336,
-0.0175431259,
-0.0201033782,
0.0265796185,
-0.0233040135,
-0.0185029469,
0.0264277216,
-0.0647327304,
0.0488554128,
0.0043442561,
-0.029812403,
0.0398676954,
0.0625356138,
0.0120550003,
-0.0525665022,
-0.1050237268,
0.004188987,
-0.0304606874,
-0.0388349555,
-0.0110268611,
0.0158536546,
-0.018098522,
0.0147931194,
0.0261004064,
0.038050402,
0.004994656,
0.0214446913,
0.0495784618,
0.0295594595,
-0.0226952769,
-0.0055507571,
0.0276375823,
-0.0405958667,
-0.0179107953,
0.0139519265,
-0.0330743417,
-0.0320518725,
0.0521246009,
0.0212087967,
-0.0077280356,
-0.000609484,
0.0136872949,
-0.0635210276,
-0.0041552573,
-0.0319693573,
-0.0666543245,
-0.0074321642,
0.0441730209,
0.0196134802,
-0.0345725231,
-0.0432491601,
0.0589546598,
-0.0680733174,
-0.0351235755,
0.033676181,
0.0003319996,
0.0042654406,
0.0653726757,
0.0116493395,
0.0700881407,
-0.0246351641,
0.0084231086,
-0.0096331043,
0.0887735561,
0.0095818462,
0.0527502075,
-0.0579738244,
-0.0087449728,
0.0369533971,
0.0402033553,
-0.0004741953,
0.0010759503,
-0.0009813275,
0.0423927978,
-0.0144057348,
0.0044067027,
-0.025350729,
-0.0212642513,
0.0079285456,
-0.0581470132,
0.0360992663,
0.0105421245,
0.0069756974,
-0.0515990965,
0.0195087921,
-0.0203514304,
0.0052464926,
-0.0479980111,
-0.0373250544,
0.0608653761,
-0.0294119082,
-0.0154345809,
0.0161322709,
-0.0191644058,
0.048348166,
0.0257097017,
0.0463287346,
0.0061560762,
-0.0359886996,
0.0695722625,
0.0156393554,
-0.0171569921,
-0.0043389667,
0.0446997657,
0.0340254344,
-0.0011369543,
0.0107512958,
0.0316022374,
-0.0211177953,
-0.001976874,
0.009462798,
0.0341240764,
-0.0000888424,
-0.01835512,
-0.0517624728,
-0.0165147968,
-0.040519774,
-0.0134744747,
-0.0341477431,
-0.0141011477,
0.0157225206,
-0.0346547738,
-0.0198066384,
-0.047219988,
2.656e-7,
-0.0402520001,
0.0253114514,
0.0075956993,
0.0355057977,
0.0477609746,
0.0227696411,
-0.0318542086,
0.0395841487,
-0.0031545446,
-0.0174456835,
0.0360436141,
0.0232145395,
0.0481306352,
0.0218041521,
-0.0868688375,
-0.0349943303,
-0.1006860137,
0.023165999,
-0.0526660345,
0.0067166574,
0.0239114724,
0.0010081376,
0.0573045388,
-0.0120415026,
-0.023566829,
-0.0546967164,
-0.0017311444,
-0.0322375,
0.0007430337,
0.0004048462,
0.0158430599,
-0.0396376103,
-0.0169641078,
0.0116038108,
-0.0071209767,
0.0225226432,
0.0320196263,
0.0436051749,
-0.02262122,
-0.019941492,
0.0175215844,
0.0243253727,
0.0105843917,
-0.0126179839,
0.04714844,
-0.0034103692,
-0.0325713232,
0.0330082364,
-0.0070928084,
-0.0395554043,
-0.0059325113,
-0.0159112494,
-0.0206463411,
0.0024729709,
-0.0121160345,
-0.0055902223,
0.0555313602,
-0.0205470473,
0.0273764133,
-0.0515018813,
-0.0897617415,
-0.0446424596,
-0.0148447687,
-0.0409851074,
-0.0321382284,
-0.0738398135,
0.0050855004,
1.904075277e-34,
0.0365090296,
-0.0008146545,
-0.0115133245,
0.0207247902,
0.0482863635,
0.0408517942,
0.0067603611,
0.0101811681,
0.0199750066,
-0.0298313033,
-0.0266088955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07101v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07101v1
|
Advanced Natural-based interaction for the ITAlian language: LLaMAntino-3-ANITA
| 2024-05-11T22:02:55 | 2024-05-11T22:02:55 |
Marco Polignano, Pierpaolo Basile, Giovanni Semeraro
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In the pursuit of advancing natural language processing for the Italian
language, we introduce a state-of-the-art Large Language Model (LLM) based on
the novel Meta LLaMA-3 model: LLaMAntino-3-ANITA-8B-Inst-DPO-ITA. We fine-tuned
the original 8B parameters instruction tuned model using the Supervised
Fine-tuning (SFT) technique on the English and Italian language datasets in
order to improve the original performance. Consequently, a Dynamic Preference
Optimization (DPO) process has been used to align preferences, avoid dangerous
and inappropriate answers, and limit biases and prejudices. Our model leverages
the efficiency of QLoRA to fine-tune the model on a smaller portion of the
original model weights and then adapt the model specifically for the Italian
linguistic structure, achieving significant improvements in both performance
and computational efficiency. Concurrently, DPO is employed to refine the
model's output, ensuring that generated content aligns with quality answers.
The synergy between SFT, QLoRA's parameter efficiency and DPO's user-centric
optimization results in a robust LLM that excels in a variety of tasks,
including but not limited to text completion, zero-shot classification, and
contextual understanding. The model has been extensively evaluated over
standard benchmarks for the Italian and English languages, showing outstanding
results. The model is freely available over the HuggingFace hub and, examples
of use can be found in our GitHub repository.
https://huggingface.co/swap-uniba/LLaMAntino-3-ANITA-8B-Inst-DPO-ITA
|
Advanced Natural-based interaction for the ITAlian language: LLaMAntino-3-ANITA: In the pursuit of advancing natural language processing for the Italian
language, we introduce a state-of-the-art Large Language Model (LLM) based on
the novel Meta LLaMA-3 model: LLaMAntino-3-ANITA-8B-Inst-DPO-ITA. We fine-tuned
the original 8B parameters instruction tuned model using the Supervised
Fine-tuning (SFT) technique on the English and Italian language datasets in
order to improve the original performance. Consequently, a Dynamic Preference
Optimization (DPO) process has been used to align preferences, avoid dangerous
and inappropriate answers, and limit biases and prejudices. Our model leverages
the efficiency of QLoRA to fine-tune the model on a smaller portion of the
original model weights and then adapt the model specifically for the Italian
linguistic structure, achieving significant improvements in both performance
and computational efficiency. Concurrently, DPO is employed to refine the
model's output, ensuring that generated content aligns with quality answers.
The synergy between SFT, QLoRA's parameter efficiency and DPO's user-centric
optimization results in a robust LLM that excels in a variety of tasks,
including but not limited to text completion, zero-shot classification, and
contextual understanding. The model has been extensively evaluated over
standard benchmarks for the Italian and English languages, showing outstanding
results. The model is freely available over the HuggingFace hub and, examples
of use can be found in our GitHub repository.
https://huggingface.co/swap-uniba/LLaMAntino-3-ANITA-8B-Inst-DPO-ITA
|
[
0.0586557537,
0.0419411957,
-0.0180046298,
0.0529226363,
0.0077178315,
0.0045531644,
-0.0288893469,
0.0030670178,
0.0341536663,
-0.0235673171,
-0.0875342637,
-0.0178309772,
0.0118818376,
0.0358707197,
-0.0211475939,
-0.0523135923,
0.0481821485,
-0.0086402642,
0.0135055389,
-0.0199443251,
0.0346893035,
0.0062671932,
0.0243118145,
0.0166203175,
0.0205115881,
0.010048422,
0.0117833931,
-0.0271495264,
-0.005023683,
-0.0039868606,
0.0403482988,
0.0750574917,
-0.0032463244,
0.0059785433,
0.0000025191,
-0.0219489466,
0.0283891261,
-0.0432459638,
-0.0065810187,
-0.0048780753,
0.0532061942,
0.0445589721,
-0.0033706531,
0.0215768199,
-0.047442276,
0.0369602256,
0.0358240306,
0.0202389248,
0.019817451,
0.0524049066,
0.0094019659,
-0.0317119956,
0.0190257579,
-0.0393525995,
0.0095576746,
-0.0067549148,
0.0303877369,
-0.0337268747,
0.0183575992,
0.0359489918,
-0.0081505934,
0.0193355009,
-0.0025276674,
-0.024450846,
0.000215994,
0.024248546,
-0.0181097966,
-0.0291741211,
0.0015886589,
0.1073157191,
-0.0098560452,
-0.0114595033,
-0.0220919121,
0.0015276484,
0.011365083,
0.0013488925,
-0.049816303,
-0.0285274051,
0.0010433646,
0.0391091108,
0.0453826599,
0.0137260156,
0.0057808785,
0.0278176181,
0.0033996801,
0.0906413794,
0.008474974,
-0.0158215277,
0.0258423053,
-0.0235671084,
-0.0325965509,
-0.0709878355,
0.0176675767,
0.0402367227,
-0.0258296747,
-0.002364201,
-0.0275242534,
0.0094991764,
0.0516378954,
-0.0816406384,
0.0023314613,
0.0418652706,
0.0103248181,
0.0345143601,
0.0245842095,
0.0262559224,
-0.0281901769,
-0.0393762477,
-0.0511715338,
-0.0029018421,
-0.0238143429,
0.0041402988,
-0.0068669645,
0.0585591234,
-0.1010401696,
-0.006432944,
-0.0224176832,
0.0183957368,
-0.003922109,
-0.010303312,
0.0227147862,
0.0088656889,
-0.0259661265,
0.0262373257,
-0.0574212857,
0.069279857,
-0.0789175928,
0.0171507169,
-0.0273395702,
-0.048673477,
0.0100885034,
-0.0072043398,
-0.0073738066,
-0.0603024028,
0.0390952267,
0.0507137701,
0.0006800994,
-0.0344487727,
0.0023462705,
-0.0188806839,
-0.0416865572,
-0.1033032537,
-0.0388337784,
-0.0701971874,
0.0547938943,
-0.0314917751,
-0.0287000854,
-0.0494380891,
-0.0019964708,
0.0482839905,
-0.0457902551,
0.0658867955,
-0.0471225232,
-0.0235730894,
0.012468636,
0.0025556902,
0.027255645,
0.0528695993,
0.0172142386,
0.0230521504,
0.0391698368,
0.0061733196,
-0.0238933302,
0.048649244,
0.0309782289,
0.0174336582,
-0.0157760456,
0.042016454,
-0.0403401889,
0.0200457089,
0.0438509434,
0.0296547897,
-0.0153811667,
-0.0219323188,
0.0592255145,
0.0316570327,
0.0181197468,
0.0247488357,
-0.0156580824,
0.0378276221,
0.0073720389,
0.005619396,
-0.0343943648,
0.0666719824,
-0.0493245609,
-0.0165609512,
0.0120064951,
0.0522672348,
-0.0352242999,
-0.0616329685,
0.023330044,
-0.0354670249,
0.011873005,
0.0182094574,
0.0368419923,
-0.024930751,
-0.0229428336,
-0.0471266322,
0.0512035042,
-0.0166220367,
0.0226527583,
-0.0530988798,
0.089808099,
0.0992402434,
0.0375783667,
-0.0240665264,
-0.0395068787,
-0.0017556562,
-0.0131807262,
0.0515686311,
0.0332058072,
-0.0290162563,
-0.0234754141,
-0.0476779975,
-0.0557081252,
-0.0048912172,
-0.0080894567,
0.024957709,
0.0148833273,
0.0256581753,
-0.010959995,
0.0289231874,
0.0029519349,
0.0159061253,
0.0077237762,
-0.037224628,
0.0089755654,
-0.0004733041,
0.0250534303,
0.0208676662,
0.0023017821,
-0.0079551609,
0.0261951759,
-0.0290254485,
-0.0227535404,
-0.0229614321,
-0.0336074531,
-0.0449820161,
0.0324570872,
-0.0164036844,
-0.0023694986,
0.0024399208,
-0.0458430909,
-0.0542886369,
0.0116789797,
0.0083334874,
0.0127936201,
-0.0167118236,
-0.0057401573,
-0.0148424348,
0.0270425268,
-0.0658446476,
0.0936773866,
-0.0255136136,
0.0076559577,
0.0445014052,
-0.0010023457,
0.0295250639,
-0.0293685757,
-0.0292562824,
0.0389412045,
0.0104730474,
-0.0047572274,
0.0582168214,
0.0352069885,
-0.0379698239,
-0.0421008058,
-0.0766888559,
0.0335416831,
-0.010386331,
0.0408038832,
0.0298077781,
0.0286864638,
-0.0166381821,
-0.0140702967,
-0.0395148546,
-0.0207664203,
-0.0110064643,
0.0072470796,
0.0384096056,
0.0285147503,
0.0010896634,
-0.0863070488,
-0.0149009516,
0.0157195702,
0.0040009255,
0.0082767867,
-0.0188453365,
-0.0042779986,
-0.0107422145,
-0.0452535152,
0.0447576717,
-0.01126533,
-0.0630493388,
-0.0120919375,
0.0057330364,
0.0147731211,
0.0805145726,
-0.0065846969,
-0.0210048147,
0.0385383479,
0.015578812,
-0.0839820951,
0.0132598374,
-0.0277586374,
-0.0226443168,
-0.0609791502,
-0.0367002301,
0.0162297972,
0.1053649932,
-0.0077456897,
0.000841504,
-0.0546115413,
0.0221470352,
0.0044340254,
-0.0181743316,
0.0139579317,
0.007150162,
-0.0163913183,
0.0562921427,
-0.0331548043,
-0.0158464015,
0.0914289653,
-0.002447342,
0.0232164282,
-0.0668757558,
0.0066290018,
-0.0404408798,
0.005057307,
-0.0036063981,
0.0227339324,
-0.0106161004,
0.0111628706,
-0.0576797575,
-0.0674534142,
0.0176472496,
-0.0306595601,
0.0179434307,
-0.0370275825,
0.0111365747,
-0.0026570023,
-0.0550821647,
-0.000523991,
-0.0224408079,
-0.0323919281,
-0.0057941307,
0.019706741,
-0.0405580178,
0.0154277124,
-0.0176895,
0.0063402541,
0.0425473861,
-0.0438862219,
-0.0035560252,
-0.0220978651,
0.0379842892,
0.0790792927,
0.0081791962,
-0.0047863624,
0.0364644267,
0.0357177034,
0.05350082,
0.0451732948,
0.0127812,
-0.0020220091,
0.0134169161,
0.0518412739,
-0.0381344594,
-0.0744318143,
0.018176293,
0.0167901833,
-0.0299009793,
0.0047670333,
0.1210941598,
0.0304657929,
-0.0751216412,
0.0016876521,
-0.036759261,
0.0514450073,
0.036302343,
0.0677834004,
-0.0561489798,
-0.0382011943,
-0.0143116852,
0.0268282332,
-0.0118906554,
-0.0207608789,
0.0091854101,
-0.1079325303,
0.0217179842,
-0.0294760857,
0.0013573657,
-0.0199811328,
-0.0738387033,
0.025774179,
-0.0267122537,
0.0217476729,
-0.0070539629,
-0.0073776767,
0.0003843938,
0.008375085,
0.0216104519,
-0.0541733876,
0.0519148074,
0.0050031436,
0.0614932217,
0.0402069539,
0.0480582081,
-0.0241291467,
0.0009328889,
0.0425860733,
0.0000990213,
-0.0066306056,
-0.0606684722,
0.0380553044,
-0.0039655222,
0.0149325524,
-0.0712898597,
0.0492751822,
0.0074998438,
-0.0095640616,
0.0045071729,
0.0749696642,
0.0101890257,
0.0376354493,
-0.0397777744,
-0.0221445374,
0.0119911311,
0.0594067425,
0.0442803465,
-0.0853017345,
-0.0184967536,
-0.0052821031,
-0.0242854338,
-0.032851927,
-0.0413030013,
0.0160031039,
-0.0208900906,
-0.0080537135,
-0.0651530921,
-0.0474995859,
0.035393279,
0.0092819268,
0.0085152732,
0.02827923,
-0.002100012,
-0.0396221355,
-0.0008320958,
0.0583756007,
-0.0265800674,
0.0286484621,
-0.0542081147,
0.0283658039,
0.0236298442,
-0.0366560854,
-0.0279412009,
-0.0207260419,
-0.0317383856,
-0.0572276451,
-0.0343288742,
0.0897875577,
0.0215747971,
0.0539168641,
-0.0182414223,
-0.0928709805,
0.0233647674,
0.0106939068,
0.0078819478,
-0.0137960399,
0.0058923829,
0.0069907014,
0.0093006287,
0.0377291813,
-0.0207995381,
0.0117255654,
0.0027105988,
0.0300004706,
-0.0455292575,
-0.0412672982,
0.0251148753,
-0.0012954144,
0.0149521846,
-0.0054297401,
0.0009062736,
-0.043143589,
0.0270318091,
-0.015225485,
-0.012921581,
-0.0272417217,
-0.0030053155,
0.0427552871,
-0.023768926,
0.0103509761,
-0.0370522887,
-0.0688214079,
0.0271405093,
-0.0260475129,
0.0345728025,
0.0280116517,
0.0083456952,
0.0035088132,
0.0373811871,
-0.0223273467,
0.0465284921,
0.0136985714,
0.0685319826,
-0.044408232,
0.047794953,
0.0114379358,
-0.0342399888,
-0.0129083516,
0.0468040742,
-0.0086965719,
-0.0269547235,
-0.0443363972,
0.0083750552,
0.0385379232,
0.0059719607,
0.0470550694,
0.0176325236,
-0.0305038355,
-0.010836225,
0.013154407,
-0.0222792085,
-0.030344354,
0.05967132,
0.0210004896,
-0.0203214251,
-0.0027287095,
0.0681280717,
0.0006095273,
0.0187473223,
0.0052022678,
0.0114700692,
-0.0135708749,
-0.0219816808,
-0.0184517764,
0.0437717251,
-0.0555846691,
-0.0061251619,
-0.0414122678,
-0.060104344,
-0.0206097364,
-0.0096901273,
-0.0420370363,
-0.016303746,
0.0663094372,
0.0112481583,
0.0095511703,
-0.0137549425,
-0.0487997197,
-0.0000173362,
-0.0153710125,
-0.0192148127,
-0.0348374918,
-7.050260999e-33,
-0.0462011583,
-0.0324010216,
0.0320237204,
0.025635764,
-0.0275059324,
-0.023237586,
0.002193453,
-0.0142474668,
-0.069339104,
-0.0255512483,
-0.0146439914,
-0.0179641489,
0.0020681378,
0.0183412209,
-0.006118542,
-0.0081123691,
0.0159343891,
-0.0176121742,
-0.0243006162,
0.0119998977,
0.0005700587,
-0.002545228,
0.0470372066,
-0.0456086509,
0.0358951464,
0.0035293847,
-0.0091660162,
0.0369119905,
-0.020974448,
0.0905916989,
-0.031057708,
0.0623127408,
0.012043952,
-0.0091929333,
0.0014627422,
0.0558369607,
-0.0697834268,
-0.0782048553,
0.0485412963,
0.0232557915,
0.0183341186,
-0.0470478982,
0.0250201803,
0.0054580816,
-0.0227405392,
0.015435053,
0.0443930402,
-0.0166119076,
-0.0413222089,
0.0259134453,
-0.0542808175,
0.0153959254,
0.007483291,
-0.0244644582,
0.0012755921,
0.0690538436,
0.0205764305,
0.0425174944,
-0.0537627675,
0.0011047267,
-0.011447602,
0.0255801808,
0.0566536151,
0.0189779829,
0.029176658,
0.0372285768,
0.0202855133,
-0.0200858265,
0.0013389961,
-0.0155279711,
0.0159081239,
0.0538212061,
0.01767046,
0.0844744444,
0.0241796765,
-0.014006787,
-0.0801819116,
0.0304368995,
0.0620970614,
0.047523018,
-0.0144063728,
-0.0104859313,
-0.0497985892,
-0.0232603196,
-0.0650523007,
-0.0248608906,
-0.0440443829,
-0.0321350843,
0.0159038976,
-0.013621971,
-0.0062380033,
-0.0353736952,
0.0167149715,
-0.0366437361,
-0.0264136903,
0.0286628045,
-0.0300079584,
0.026812369,
0.0253256392,
0.0369807743,
-0.0678658038,
-0.0290902667,
-0.0295752548,
-0.0388552286,
-0.0162117574,
0.0287498888,
0.0197133441,
0.0032942258,
-0.0482271947,
0.0133063337,
-0.0314929336,
0.0001240283,
0.0150736021,
0.0479337908,
0.020511169,
0.0162906181,
-0.0137559697,
0.061081361,
0.049101226,
0.0417181067,
-0.0312512442,
-0.0666167438,
0.0119652981,
0.0320152119,
-0.0124133965,
0.0133171473,
-0.0068546864,
0.0252256822,
-0.014527496,
-0.0510661528,
-0.0387003459,
-0.0035898807,
3.097e-7,
0.0452227071,
0.0548341013,
-0.0091306204,
0.030091133,
-0.0077846912,
0.0523414351,
0.0085237855,
0.0249140579,
0.0033821356,
0.0402942896,
0.0176004674,
0.0166299976,
-0.0044367341,
0.0244212151,
-0.070282951,
0.0194526054,
-0.0486872196,
-0.0043846644,
-0.062690869,
-0.0471185483,
0.0220041089,
0.0951119512,
0.0352621339,
-0.0214953553,
-0.0339550339,
0.0006550244,
0.0689035803,
-0.0186315347,
-0.0380762704,
0.0520637073,
0.0121516176,
0.0390711427,
-0.0114059579,
0.0031536315,
-0.0089481724,
0.0467293784,
-0.0389247313,
0.0850756541,
-0.0196821634,
-0.0597384349,
0.0379167646,
-0.0576421693,
-0.0179281346,
-0.0538608879,
0.0804934353,
-0.0493899435,
-0.0111852912,
-0.0284585841,
-0.0470911115,
-0.0184726287,
0.0368155129,
-0.0542753525,
0.0066280821,
0.0035075948,
0.0062366915,
-0.0195647366,
-0.0320487022,
-0.0279298425,
-0.0198789965,
-0.0018402981,
-0.0349452421,
-0.0272528492,
-0.0574254245,
-0.0028438312,
0.0008430639,
-0.0090243667,
0.0213550851,
2.859670107e-34,
0.0248728544,
-0.0166706685,
0.0167556722,
0.0272675958,
0.0209167153,
0.0190754663,
-0.0420825295,
0.0223686136,
0.057551723,
-0.0860343724,
-0.0163157247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07099v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07099v1
|
Do Pretrained Contextual Language Models Distinguish between Hebrew Homograph Analyses?
| 2024-05-11T21:50:56 | 2024-05-11T21:50:56 |
Avi Shmidman, Cheyn Shmuel Shmidman, Dan Bareket, Moshe Koppel, Reut Tsarfaty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Semitic morphologically-rich languages (MRLs) are characterized by extreme
word ambiguity. Because most vowels are omitted in standard texts, many of the
words are homographs with multiple possible analyses, each with a different
pronunciation and different morphosyntactic properties. This ambiguity goes
beyond word-sense disambiguation (WSD), and may include token segmentation into
multiple word units. Previous research on MRLs claimed that standardly trained
pre-trained language models (PLMs) based on word-pieces may not sufficiently
capture the internal structure of such tokens in order to distinguish between
these analyses. Taking Hebrew as a case study, we investigate the extent to
which Hebrew homographs can be disambiguated and analyzed using PLMs. We
evaluate all existing models for contextualized Hebrew embeddings on a novel
Hebrew homograph challenge sets that we deliver. Our empirical results
demonstrate that contemporary Hebrew contextualized embeddings outperform
non-contextualized embeddings; and that they are most effective for
disambiguating segmentation and morphosyntactic features, less so regarding
pure word-sense disambiguation. We show that these embeddings are more
effective when the number of word-piece splits is limited, and they are more
effective for 2-way and 3-way ambiguities than for 4-way ambiguity. We show
that the embeddings are equally effective for homographs of both balanced and
skewed distributions, whether calculated as masked or unmasked tokens. Finally,
we show that these embeddings are as effective for homograph disambiguation
with extensive supervised training as with a few-shot setup.
|
Do Pretrained Contextual Language Models Distinguish between Hebrew Homograph Analyses?: Semitic morphologically-rich languages (MRLs) are characterized by extreme
word ambiguity. Because most vowels are omitted in standard texts, many of the
words are homographs with multiple possible analyses, each with a different
pronunciation and different morphosyntactic properties. This ambiguity goes
beyond word-sense disambiguation (WSD), and may include token segmentation into
multiple word units. Previous research on MRLs claimed that standardly trained
pre-trained language models (PLMs) based on word-pieces may not sufficiently
capture the internal structure of such tokens in order to distinguish between
these analyses. Taking Hebrew as a case study, we investigate the extent to
which Hebrew homographs can be disambiguated and analyzed using PLMs. We
evaluate all existing models for contextualized Hebrew embeddings on a novel
Hebrew homograph challenge sets that we deliver. Our empirical results
demonstrate that contemporary Hebrew contextualized embeddings outperform
non-contextualized embeddings; and that they are most effective for
disambiguating segmentation and morphosyntactic features, less so regarding
pure word-sense disambiguation. We show that these embeddings are more
effective when the number of word-piece splits is limited, and they are more
effective for 2-way and 3-way ambiguities than for 4-way ambiguity. We show
that the embeddings are equally effective for homographs of both balanced and
skewed distributions, whether calculated as masked or unmasked tokens. Finally,
we show that these embeddings are as effective for homograph disambiguation
with extensive supervised training as with a few-shot setup.
|
[
-0.0139147043,
0.0161613468,
-0.0146190077,
0.0518726222,
-0.0398595333,
0.038032338,
0.0396326296,
0.0248138644,
-0.0270575136,
-0.0431672484,
-0.0215933919,
-0.0769582018,
0.0309639554,
-0.0407935604,
0.0396005102,
-0.0096403873,
0.0310312267,
-0.0433398858,
-0.0321381427,
0.0147727327,
0.0113076996,
0.0544325709,
0.0150212068,
-0.0043545198,
-0.0284669437,
-0.0034830903,
0.0015667448,
0.0417770855,
0.0424985625,
0.0366161205,
-0.0735619068,
0.0291078296,
-0.0080644684,
0.077769503,
0.000001671,
-0.0529722907,
-0.0226739496,
0.0008245331,
-0.0459350608,
-0.0005715418,
0.0721214488,
-0.0940653086,
-0.024154691,
0.0100255888,
-0.0001445813,
-0.0204931051,
0.0434719026,
-0.0299903359,
0.0272914842,
0.0390544534,
-0.0043923748,
-0.0549990311,
0.0189918093,
-0.0166307483,
-0.025096992,
0.0316775069,
0.0037257867,
-0.0580327436,
-0.078338936,
-0.0052716364,
-0.0501686372,
0.0406211577,
0.0235512964,
0.0589832962,
-0.0329469666,
-0.0124882292,
-0.0473563485,
-0.0154830422,
0.0415681861,
0.0029628945,
-0.0789063051,
-0.0491713621,
0.0205615759,
-0.0323928259,
-0.0506530553,
0.0084386347,
0.0194102414,
0.0513081364,
-0.0272327326,
0.0125852004,
0.036729414,
-0.0084052244,
0.0443476848,
0.0068400903,
-0.0408012569,
-0.0129407113,
0.0588113144,
-0.0054422044,
0.0159478541,
0.016083071,
-0.0228171516,
-0.0108923782,
0.0093680592,
-0.0100052161,
0.0455540232,
0.0333809815,
-0.0142322229,
-0.0408683233,
0.0025738499,
-0.0429306142,
0.0078943055,
0.0447334722,
-0.0325067714,
-0.0018194735,
-0.0261638667,
0.0127018644,
0.0465898141,
0.0161110386,
-0.0349151157,
-0.0014454997,
0.0149445925,
0.004849087,
-0.0696831495,
0.0243779588,
-0.0489132479,
0.0397196226,
-0.0418237895,
0.0171423871,
0.0371157303,
0.0035536913,
-0.0281585064,
-0.0776043087,
-0.0413291976,
0.002664315,
0.0293133166,
-0.0238125287,
-0.0500471704,
-0.0281517729,
-0.0560689718,
-0.0730888247,
0.0036619473,
0.0440554395,
-0.0195476152,
-0.0266246852,
-0.002559738,
0.0521068014,
0.0070296321,
-0.0575433783,
-0.0107150227,
-0.0126751587,
-0.0527356677,
-0.0141159194,
0.0081822304,
-0.071295917,
0.0592836365,
-0.0075208498,
-0.032118585,
-0.0145766912,
-0.0540976934,
-0.009269434,
0.0086347209,
0.0897700042,
0.0310764536,
-0.0369657911,
0.0158521757,
0.008397053,
0.0137668597,
0.0571413711,
-0.0097258883,
-0.0100690918,
0.0405086763,
-0.0081725838,
-0.0275729615,
0.0345134139,
-0.0112241311,
0.0459777936,
-0.0249110833,
-0.0437621996,
-0.0127779832,
0.021939246,
-0.0151729276,
0.0691636205,
-0.0417376049,
-0.0549394861,
0.0182925481,
0.0723121613,
0.0198397841,
-0.0183021165,
0.0335998796,
0.0509344339,
0.0366696939,
0.0303450767,
-0.0193542503,
-0.0499977916,
0.0061238897,
0.0226472132,
-0.02215169,
0.0346013419,
-0.0123272166,
-0.049150914,
-0.0191714074,
-0.0335906297,
-0.0158632584,
0.0160395168,
0.084250398,
0.0074413,
-0.0358147658,
0.0354814082,
0.0290132761,
-0.0455295481,
0.0541943274,
-0.0001456179,
-0.0010163824,
0.0290258583,
0.0349620581,
-0.0019833781,
-0.0295661297,
0.0146123711,
0.0015097469,
0.0526088178,
-0.005353522,
0.0090123778,
0.04527409,
-0.0556002371,
0.0375517756,
0.0258653183,
0.0265415628,
-0.000611338,
-0.0144436229,
0.0116417101,
0.0487563089,
-0.0458175018,
0.0348300152,
0.0160811692,
-0.01878215,
0.036278747,
-0.048046317,
0.0301619377,
-0.0098331142,
0.0257972609,
-0.0179369655,
-0.0023736677,
0.0163375977,
-0.0413922183,
0.0325684398,
0.0099036777,
-0.0627085716,
-0.0534464084,
0.0275232382,
-0.0159854274,
-0.0223703962,
-0.0199720412,
0.001492348,
-0.0142215705,
0.0348722152,
-0.0160178468,
0.0717603788,
-0.0357336067,
0.0594828837,
0.017190855,
0.0199531987,
-0.0505811013,
0.0492589138,
0.0347969607,
0.035418801,
0.003046127,
0.0108274948,
0.0246562529,
0.0124468384,
-0.028832119,
0.0113987867,
-0.005389214,
-0.0143545456,
-0.0341958068,
-0.0587504804,
-0.0035297186,
-0.0349552929,
-0.1044813395,
-0.0177181549,
-0.0487576872,
0.0406668857,
-0.0047076149,
0.0141153689,
0.0274894889,
-0.0129603939,
0.0137470495,
0.0064285169,
-0.0018453265,
0.0099866129,
0.0160552133,
-0.0540979356,
-0.0335425474,
-0.0359859318,
-0.0330883823,
-0.0159116611,
0.0541492254,
0.026532298,
-0.004079924,
0.0071009924,
-0.0349547155,
-0.0454110764,
0.0026577497,
-0.0091050649,
-0.0175883509,
0.0141844088,
0.0023712586,
0.0642432123,
-0.0056553911,
-0.0133287022,
0.0292507056,
0.0068949987,
-0.0356508121,
-0.0374852866,
-0.0337737426,
0.018330466,
0.0100834323,
-0.063900955,
-0.0220489092,
-0.0258158166,
0.0439080708,
0.0217387211,
-0.0110839177,
-0.0212861151,
0.0371409878,
-0.0589661188,
0.0188938472,
0.0408907644,
0.0033092587,
-0.0260420591,
0.0462422855,
-0.0341027565,
-0.0513433814,
0.0386151597,
-0.0471046567,
-0.0040397076,
-0.0276483428,
-0.0214908998,
-0.0516458526,
0.0334858149,
0.00588209,
0.0253011379,
-0.0237388182,
-0.0373693593,
-0.0878171325,
0.0013850702,
0.0186571293,
-0.0369269177,
0.0772834122,
-0.0294326786,
-0.0116925659,
-0.0329608582,
-0.0040229829,
-0.0216075722,
-0.0201360863,
-0.0204111096,
0.0291446578,
0.0900640786,
0.019963488,
0.032709185,
0.0031228741,
-0.0669423789,
0.01736301,
0.0540584363,
0.003057336,
-0.0299816281,
0.0187750887,
-0.0047056102,
-0.0364357829,
0.0305747073,
-0.0279534496,
0.0149659049,
-0.0217945874,
-0.0257193428,
-0.0338222124,
-0.0420671515,
-0.0026107419,
0.0300352871,
-0.0539086945,
-0.0685104579,
-0.0369897746,
-0.0057720463,
-0.0144114336,
0.0301928688,
0.113972567,
0.0492145792,
-0.0382056646,
0.0125289066,
0.0031295288,
-0.0061005913,
-0.0232873317,
-0.0092168115,
-0.1251401156,
-0.0150489286,
0.0325592011,
-0.0088214297,
0.0425421521,
-0.0036242935,
0.0294452887,
-0.0762926042,
-0.0298452955,
0.0253946967,
-0.0653659925,
-0.0289042424,
0.030074941,
-0.0245178062,
-0.0166154075,
-0.0011728477,
-0.0102938293,
-0.0318469629,
-0.0018600982,
0.0288331434,
-0.0099538313,
0.0044907629,
-0.0225945041,
-0.0637851655,
0.0163999554,
-0.0099447221,
0.021271212,
-0.0429669879,
0.0057830242,
0.0430170335,
-0.0449750535,
-0.0358689874,
-0.0205828529,
-0.0041337563,
0.0129726464,
-0.0245820098,
-0.0044859303,
-0.0408184715,
-0.012679168,
-0.0212782528,
-0.0172421727,
0.0309336893,
-0.0027281279,
0.0104797985,
0.034301769,
0.0389350876,
-0.0529281162,
0.0677834675,
-0.0087909326,
0.0074974215,
-0.0664894283,
-0.020001933,
0.065135628,
0.0106865428,
0.0184769891,
-0.0180359036,
0.0112917302,
0.028104173,
-0.0836036429,
-0.0483804494,
0.0065355203,
0.0511839725,
0.0177537203,
0.0077876691,
-0.0116756326,
-0.0007679213,
-0.0505246148,
-0.0042621884,
0.0031748023,
0.0417736843,
-0.0529467165,
-0.0106077781,
0.0110061998,
-0.0481362529,
0.0201573614,
0.0242596604,
-0.0593072623,
-0.0422591791,
0.0389402136,
-0.0445099063,
0.0111323018,
0.052528251,
-0.0562897623,
-0.0261340495,
0.0047662663,
-0.0120933084,
-0.0307865124,
0.0481649302,
0.0727942511,
0.0455282219,
-0.0293196719,
0.0334870741,
0.0024719888,
0.0406105183,
0.0631983131,
-0.0309808608,
-0.0436958559,
-0.0196603518,
-0.0360668711,
-0.0149943111,
0.0250717141,
-0.0225474257,
0.0222180169,
-0.0333472379,
-0.0001092738,
-0.013012616,
0.0257074628,
-0.0271148439,
-0.0094019426,
0.027434865,
0.0033069253,
-0.0124360109,
0.06239447,
0.0085901227,
0.0155744525,
0.0216910057,
0.0460598096,
0.0189196598,
-0.0342899151,
-0.0405673012,
0.0452444106,
0.0149438884,
0.0136502823,
-0.0278610028,
0.0379226655,
-0.0383379199,
0.0027772265,
-0.0635696575,
-0.0211220849,
-0.0196762886,
0.0046658246,
0.0166055132,
0.0063651144,
-0.010679286,
0.0504968166,
0.0335816927,
-0.0249065142,
0.0577298366,
0.0057400898,
-0.0043606926,
-0.0247968361,
0.0411009043,
-0.003351457,
0.0160484165,
0.0331104435,
0.0159915946,
-0.0283516627,
-0.0155166108,
0.0237542465,
0.0551627688,
0.0024552988,
0.0119060138,
-0.0151753901,
0.006137935,
-0.017210694,
0.009343246,
0.0231865514,
-0.0320000798,
-0.019220572,
-0.1118200347,
-0.0874476805,
0.0095821396,
0.0074057858,
0.0021756697,
0.0204298552,
0.029206777,
0.0522741489,
-0.0001969782,
-0.0224653091,
-0.0220784657,
0.0355347656,
0.0340306796,
-0.0303179678,
0.007075218,
-5.057846563e-33,
-0.0218585115,
0.0078262659,
-0.0218201056,
-0.0648901537,
-0.0243058875,
0.0288586561,
-0.0033968452,
-0.0132457884,
-0.027180057,
-0.0213352088,
-0.0021814781,
0.0328477137,
0.0290747266,
0.0095415618,
0.0056225429,
-0.0284544192,
0.0763796344,
0.0326404385,
-0.0251902938,
-0.013248411,
0.0282909479,
0.0282271653,
0.0799854323,
0.0514074937,
-0.001947108,
-0.0303985644,
0.0225010645,
0.0296954103,
-0.0042724754,
0.0665795356,
0.0164217837,
0.0484208539,
0.0206207931,
0.0062319692,
-0.0180348139,
0.0031548303,
-0.0848905221,
-0.0189335309,
0.0578867309,
0.0584553741,
-0.0496885553,
-0.0152978953,
0.0104908179,
-0.030704733,
-0.0232391208,
-0.0034720418,
0.0254183039,
0.0057680653,
-0.0473570451,
-0.0196343306,
-0.0630784184,
0.0828392431,
0.0013470025,
0.0224899426,
0.085076794,
-0.0137954839,
0.0216030143,
0.0275447592,
-0.0708423108,
-0.034474615,
0.0041429475,
0.0194217879,
0.0120776705,
0.0453753136,
-0.0657853857,
0.0027187904,
0.0496421941,
-0.0451001376,
0.0510343611,
0.0208874922,
0.0634718314,
-0.032780163,
0.0310427267,
0.0212771725,
0.0236548744,
-0.0155458972,
-0.0170407705,
-0.0758688673,
0.0497646593,
-0.0150295375,
0.010381761,
-0.0090649417,
-0.0707121417,
-0.0288464166,
-0.0542324707,
-0.0484047011,
-0.0194327999,
-0.0083851749,
0.0280907322,
0.0205167104,
-0.0142734786,
0.0835241079,
0.0406477451,
-0.0213505141,
0.0470479019,
0.0226459298,
0.0078342706,
0.0290140975,
-0.0184976365,
0.0329758041,
-0.0054426691,
-0.0443111695,
0.0161232874,
0.0054544695,
-0.0123748081,
-0.0206087902,
0.0213103555,
-0.0324456505,
-0.0420418978,
0.0145072276,
-0.0306157097,
-0.0183011368,
-0.0136515675,
0.0160253476,
0.0305510499,
0.0340435244,
0.0292669591,
0.0247086436,
0.0465163663,
-0.0351744518,
-0.0074388743,
0.0960107893,
-0.0450921059,
0.022112852,
-0.0036623559,
0.0137649653,
0.0497957282,
0.0356532484,
0.0792019144,
-0.0406630076,
0.0053345566,
0.0262202639,
2.421e-7,
0.067304045,
0.0064182766,
0.0119718257,
-0.0217740741,
0.0190614145,
-0.0120107522,
0.0373162776,
-0.0341328494,
-0.0243061669,
0.0450481884,
-0.0228265617,
0.0119134858,
0.098077096,
0.0199497789,
-0.030804079,
-0.0157091822,
-0.0274193324,
0.0260795765,
-0.070252426,
0.0362476371,
0.0447536521,
0.155644685,
-0.013926466,
-0.0019956415,
-0.0695344135,
0.0043060035,
0.0293215085,
-0.0265863352,
-0.0156798568,
0.0094045512,
-0.0229031108,
-0.0040385234,
0.0312629789,
0.0078193862,
-0.0450120792,
0.0053165969,
0.0764904842,
0.0661422536,
0.0279056169,
-0.0032936153,
0.0023734639,
-0.0188540872,
-0.0269247536,
-0.0266352352,
0.0734611824,
-0.0214488171,
0.0318823792,
0.0190052856,
-0.0196209233,
0.0309717357,
0.0009471322,
0.0371372104,
-0.0606693216,
0.0367717557,
0.0701642707,
-0.0272401087,
-0.0083242413,
-0.0597984493,
0.0399248824,
0.0392202102,
-0.0003976749,
-0.0124595594,
0.005289854,
-0.0300405826,
0.0166305378,
-0.0005778338,
-0.0210663658,
2.298210153e-34,
0.0393858738,
-0.0105409538,
0.0316759497,
-0.0093132304,
0.0064472193,
-0.008760199,
0.0341960937,
0.0540634058,
0.0036881079,
-0.0115711065,
0.0156510342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16891v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16891v1
|
Survey on Reasoning Capabilities and Accessibility of Large Language Models Using Biology-related Questions
| 2024-05-11T20:25:40 | 2024-05-11T20:25:40 |
Michael Ackerman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This research paper discusses the advances made in the past decade in
biomedicine and Large Language Models. To understand how the advances have been
made hand-in-hand with one another, the paper also discusses the integration of
Natural Language Processing techniques and tools into biomedicine. Finally, the
goal of this paper is to expand on a survey conducted last year (2023) by
introducing a new list of questions and prompts for the top two language
models. Through this survey, this paper seeks to quantify the improvement made
in the reasoning abilities in LLMs and to what extent those improvements are
felt by the average user. Additionally, this paper seeks to extend research on
retrieval of biological literature by prompting the LLM to answer open-ended
questions in great depth.
|
Survey on Reasoning Capabilities and Accessibility of Large Language Models Using Biology-related Questions: This research paper discusses the advances made in the past decade in
biomedicine and Large Language Models. To understand how the advances have been
made hand-in-hand with one another, the paper also discusses the integration of
Natural Language Processing techniques and tools into biomedicine. Finally, the
goal of this paper is to expand on a survey conducted last year (2023) by
introducing a new list of questions and prompts for the top two language
models. Through this survey, this paper seeks to quantify the improvement made
in the reasoning abilities in LLMs and to what extent those improvements are
felt by the average user. Additionally, this paper seeks to extend research on
retrieval of biological literature by prompting the LLM to answer open-ended
questions in great depth.
|
[
0.0539969914,
0.0304636061,
0.0024522643,
0.0055857725,
-0.0439648814,
0.0222021341,
0.031763047,
0.0360686779,
0.044075042,
-0.0296350401,
0.0328612551,
-0.0327916592,
-0.0172774307,
0.0050421227,
0.0177030452,
-0.0144350762,
0.0074952012,
-0.0164934844,
0.0077449302,
-0.0037958259,
-0.0140924267,
0.0162627604,
0.0094900634,
0.0134762693,
0.0829144418,
-0.0205957778,
0.0242704619,
-0.0341903195,
0.0085273441,
-0.0557919033,
-0.0482536331,
0.0163491275,
0.0173674151,
-0.005001463,
0.0000020108,
-0.0949930474,
-0.0432034694,
0.0533574894,
-0.0581568517,
-0.0123158377,
0.0463448055,
0.0235590879,
-0.0006799517,
0.0113260327,
-0.0155149652,
0.0223655533,
0.0474622846,
0.0100141903,
0.0067959428,
0.0349559374,
0.0012837722,
-0.0447596163,
0.0796545818,
0.0022745891,
0.0591249056,
-0.0274078976,
0.0365317725,
0.0234407615,
0.1216670573,
0.0226362571,
0.0231473316,
0.0795368701,
0.0019379016,
-0.0196362715,
0.0167826302,
0.0194477104,
0.0237091128,
-0.0446800403,
0.0346274413,
0.0129830772,
0.0541373603,
-0.0109141199,
0.0059681786,
0.0180005673,
0.0000714937,
0.0527454242,
-0.0674732476,
0.0094929198,
-0.0238737557,
-0.0204242375,
0.036618311,
-0.0356017649,
0.0278250054,
0.0234649256,
-0.0479421653,
0.0712082535,
0.0086077731,
-0.0325655229,
0.0236357506,
-0.0221111383,
0.0207649693,
-0.0221359376,
0.0442478396,
0.057542,
-0.0089421561,
0.0133241732,
0.0466478541,
-0.0089217871,
0.0838361233,
-0.0679106116,
0.0087656248,
-0.0103586605,
-0.0179613419,
0.0394787826,
0.002803925,
-0.0073987665,
-0.06308534,
0.0253975596,
-0.0089703007,
0.0261950027,
-0.0787083507,
-0.0460018516,
-0.0067523504,
0.0254686121,
0.0034944427,
0.0350406505,
-0.0580260903,
-0.0199559387,
0.027176464,
-0.0161241759,
-0.0135916797,
-0.0179242212,
-0.0245427154,
0.0034841893,
-0.0652844235,
0.0109545449,
-0.005922555,
-0.0023724092,
-0.0300769228,
-0.0876951814,
0.009091205,
-0.0137971416,
0.0179648083,
-0.0271844119,
0.0226991232,
0.0731135383,
0.0081643723,
-0.0297050476,
-0.0012899296,
-0.04484291,
-0.047862649,
-0.0475071445,
-0.024685761,
-0.0713545904,
0.0046239793,
0.0582522228,
-0.0405649394,
-0.0391643941,
0.0184971429,
0.0191647932,
-0.0508966818,
0.0619626008,
-0.0832972676,
-0.0188205875,
0.0353667997,
0.0080941487,
0.0217176992,
-0.0049945074,
-0.0052053374,
-0.0565298647,
0.0148343183,
-0.0128538935,
0.0244970527,
-0.0273520686,
-0.0239268653,
-0.048664473,
-0.0160500258,
0.0525922142,
-0.0035370407,
0.060160663,
-0.0554970466,
0.0508952327,
0.0095813917,
0.0027263635,
0.027152041,
0.1106592044,
0.0376158245,
0.0200370792,
-0.0047386247,
0.0017836499,
0.0240075085,
-0.0069590658,
0.0103734983,
0.0110587059,
-0.0129748816,
0.0282294303,
0.0019771997,
0.0265198629,
0.0284181107,
-0.0533986688,
-0.0537401251,
0.0306396689,
0.0154813714,
-0.0040012985,
0.0467751212,
-0.0397187024,
0.0123843011,
0.0458385646,
0.0299761463,
-0.0504487194,
0.006109973,
-0.0440527685,
0.0080416678,
0.0592227429,
0.0386872292,
-0.0496012941,
-0.0200343244,
-0.0144878104,
-0.0156239793,
0.0601298288,
0.006363119,
0.0106314039,
-0.0427915379,
-0.0278261006,
0.0188803487,
0.0087468913,
-0.0017936035,
-0.0451462045,
-0.0322272778,
0.0571220443,
-0.0046828403,
-0.0410227478,
-0.0369109884,
0.0149412826,
-0.0734929964,
-0.0037300333,
-0.0681811348,
-0.0014228289,
-0.0084557328,
0.0210441463,
-0.0129300663,
0.0623141713,
0.0315486081,
-0.0509434752,
-0.0305595249,
-0.0129119847,
0.0215105359,
0.0097319763,
0.0379779041,
-0.0058228597,
-0.0259305295,
-0.0165057741,
0.0069366568,
0.0000977216,
-0.0049149957,
-0.0416356735,
0.0391507708,
-0.017032193,
0.0246188957,
-0.0249136481,
-0.0318901464,
-0.0527215451,
0.0320985205,
0.0200303625,
0.0342407934,
0.047077138,
-0.0666314662,
0.0195158496,
-0.0569992028,
0.0008113004,
0.0464347862,
0.0216797758,
0.0113515761,
0.0138975792,
-0.0090124961,
-0.0553823225,
-0.0036641916,
-0.0251590107,
-0.0141216861,
0.0290524941,
0.0610737875,
-0.0034174493,
-0.0073130499,
0.001661852,
0.0009731447,
-0.040176861,
-0.0087732347,
0.0097938506,
0.016559707,
0.0601972155,
0.0209054649,
-0.0288329087,
-0.0513430908,
-0.0067707561,
-0.0457414575,
0.0400264263,
0.057422746,
-0.0336249545,
0.0133462725,
0.030543346,
-0.0431895964,
-0.0052575306,
0.0123881251,
-0.0057954253,
0.0373439603,
-0.0374007896,
-0.0092405342,
0.0469091423,
-0.0182015244,
0.0306099895,
0.0633132532,
0.0218072142,
-0.0169358384,
0.0056511071,
-0.017966982,
-0.0238958634,
-0.0191827081,
-0.0287742037,
0.0131903831,
0.042042505,
-0.0201116577,
-0.0323971212,
-0.0059081172,
0.0389217287,
-0.0376511291,
0.0003453366,
-0.0309492406,
-0.0003527761,
-0.0207677037,
0.0702475905,
0.0217705611,
-0.0402656756,
0.0838258788,
-0.0213460028,
0.0227333978,
-0.0834747031,
-0.0183414519,
-0.0212248843,
0.063266404,
-0.0135843521,
0.0265220981,
0.0192544293,
-0.0220861975,
-0.0070675593,
-0.0101527432,
0.014717265,
-0.0546321496,
0.0624838471,
-0.0391138233,
0.0374321416,
0.0099541461,
-0.012823143,
-0.0042366041,
0.0237515271,
-0.0553701855,
0.0014643412,
0.0357968844,
-0.011698761,
-0.0594920292,
0.0421493985,
0.0498007461,
-0.0062886016,
0.0035762296,
-0.0146722868,
0.0064574159,
0.0105402106,
-0.0090028066,
0.0095704915,
0.0211797412,
-0.0182425268,
0.0617858618,
0.0625308454,
-0.0354033373,
0.006447203,
0.0326399207,
0.0215890184,
0.0404037572,
-0.0596521236,
-0.0426414497,
0.0316520445,
0.0263502728,
-0.0788816884,
0.0008989898,
0.0996268839,
0.057806164,
-0.0267299842,
0.0018621779,
-0.0825344399,
-0.0720730647,
0.0104304394,
0.0658363923,
-0.0772571191,
-0.0056419061,
0.0019394569,
-0.0026377684,
-0.0334157646,
-0.0578071699,
-0.0061747087,
-0.0356351472,
0.0507166348,
0.0027256126,
-0.0360521153,
-0.0194799695,
-0.0604207776,
-0.0060226009,
0.0091452217,
-0.0037279387,
0.0386877581,
-0.0047393478,
0.0235904269,
0.0067998371,
-0.0589247532,
-0.0411826521,
0.0207035523,
-0.0262169465,
0.0140678128,
0.0361272208,
0.0470604822,
-0.0158204027,
-0.034452375,
0.0353670716,
0.0106335478,
0.021565903,
-0.03230986,
0.043415077,
0.0526143089,
0.0098032914,
-0.0874107257,
0.0022921937,
-0.0153754354,
-0.0123283817,
-0.0012244307,
0.0954828188,
-0.0232633874,
-0.0312651917,
-0.0494058505,
0.0059819962,
-0.0442707017,
0.0477570631,
0.0405427776,
-0.0038792293,
-0.0259315502,
-0.0425557569,
0.0124550881,
0.0087953433,
-0.0811491385,
0.029279042,
-0.0348382406,
-0.0139936535,
-0.0372336619,
-0.0044733067,
0.0809382424,
0.0010357344,
0.0146506913,
0.0464380421,
0.0431314744,
-0.0262756795,
-0.0388101004,
0.047476314,
0.0344972834,
0.035170421,
-0.0662870407,
-0.0094702151,
0.0753285512,
0.0122394701,
-0.0243097227,
0.0145180924,
0.0157720167,
-0.0758279338,
-0.035066504,
0.0004731816,
0.0317500532,
-0.0577003881,
0.0039372952,
-0.0667686388,
-0.0000849843,
0.0339496806,
-0.0121071441,
-0.0245817229,
-0.0436215699,
0.0240778066,
-0.0083777197,
0.016940875,
-0.0270349141,
-0.0216546785,
-0.0245323163,
0.0507886335,
-0.0027966811,
-0.033134561,
0.0603325143,
0.0696504116,
0.0261194408,
0.0067390176,
-0.0328095965,
-0.0054697017,
0.0099514164,
-0.0336840488,
-0.021114815,
0.0020309249,
-0.0183812492,
0.0092913089,
0.013979814,
-0.0028810035,
-0.0091373241,
-0.0609830841,
0.0116013214,
-0.0338709094,
0.0902487636,
0.0101686437,
-0.0153303286,
0.0557282008,
-0.012089503,
-0.0114698326,
-0.0025939518,
-0.0407677852,
0.0460211672,
0.0023751303,
0.0243801698,
-0.0137010701,
0.0111751705,
-0.0329706185,
-0.0184662156,
-0.0407005064,
-0.0770756006,
0.031081086,
0.01601802,
0.0087814238,
-0.0063246898,
0.0094528496,
0.0006094443,
-0.022459846,
-0.0193124395,
0.0038958266,
0.0046429229,
0.0111974152,
0.0789915845,
0.0268180966,
-0.0389678292,
-0.083570987,
0.0402398445,
0.0323279239,
0.0283592194,
-0.0295616053,
-0.0605884604,
0.0050029745,
-0.0361285061,
-0.0037653754,
-0.0133181429,
-0.0284415707,
-0.0000086146,
-0.0702495277,
-0.0483464599,
0.029955877,
0.0043608351,
-0.0409455448,
-0.0024616676,
-0.0178581215,
0.0368533097,
0.0649605542,
-0.0674243793,
-0.0244566686,
0.0830411911,
-0.0588182993,
-0.019281501,
0.0150278583,
-6.060831608e-33,
0.0159975626,
-0.052707728,
0.0282934345,
-0.0192790981,
0.0024569486,
-0.0079131173,
-0.0426889807,
0.010763403,
-0.0208457559,
0.0393986814,
-0.0318895057,
-0.0016324095,
0.0027464633,
-0.0120431557,
0.0008848702,
-0.0303505901,
-0.0007499105,
0.0167200901,
0.0164703503,
-0.0327151418,
0.0003775934,
0.0430147946,
0.0343044624,
-0.0413231999,
0.0557979122,
-0.0029029108,
0.0610976107,
0.017312536,
-0.033573471,
0.0405015983,
0.0130426865,
0.0290970895,
0.0163743924,
-0.0447433181,
-0.014937561,
0.0018827945,
-0.0268561877,
0.0111908698,
0.0455174595,
-0.0321422666,
-0.0385416374,
-0.0424456634,
0.0697650537,
0.0092204027,
-0.0328170247,
0.003221947,
0.0457200594,
-0.0615527034,
-0.023230236,
-0.0266201533,
-0.0306912828,
0.0329601057,
-0.0181778651,
0.0541131347,
0.0102719087,
0.0093132602,
-0.0377112143,
0.0357988216,
0.0017565854,
0.0248250309,
0.0652868524,
0.0350892954,
0.0494205169,
-0.0256502647,
0.0080608604,
0.0310187265,
-0.0049134055,
-0.0150031475,
-0.0202150661,
-0.0024874383,
-0.0225547887,
0.0468382612,
0.0421624854,
0.017149331,
0.0111524863,
0.0049535828,
-0.0772439018,
0.0444682576,
-0.023432564,
0.0631906986,
0.0020184494,
0.0020086046,
-0.0116666211,
-0.0255626887,
-0.0494956449,
0.0318787172,
-0.0354457684,
-0.0349608138,
0.0060642241,
-0.0946291089,
0.0011635961,
-0.0059563909,
0.0134562366,
-0.0035396435,
-0.0569924563,
-0.0302128214,
0.0200602654,
0.0055756178,
-0.030404482,
0.0333647206,
-0.0450341329,
0.0239377525,
-0.0184395052,
-0.0145830205,
0.0240322575,
-0.010816195,
-0.047412239,
-0.0166302305,
-0.0557223856,
-0.0182083212,
-0.0108355684,
-0.0061983941,
0.0283506494,
0.0477971956,
0.0231525917,
0.0267735664,
0.0307418965,
0.0709930286,
0.0151839331,
-0.0159917772,
-0.0235080495,
0.0288287643,
-0.002338131,
-0.0084544048,
-0.0340922996,
-0.0015663253,
-0.027766943,
0.0939275026,
0.0202278029,
-0.0365257189,
-0.0084916279,
-0.0054920744,
2.846e-7,
0.1178585812,
0.0716719702,
0.0065294155,
0.0113018313,
-0.0009052479,
-0.0145974196,
-0.0298682209,
-0.0462018363,
0.0028060051,
-0.0020762812,
0.022204306,
0.0226678085,
0.0119024003,
0.0155531494,
-0.0426268801,
-0.0238934867,
-0.0619775802,
-0.0119221397,
-0.0442492962,
0.0164620504,
0.0633282438,
0.0395999998,
-0.059669368,
0.0021070549,
-0.0088359648,
-0.0527497567,
0.0096277008,
-0.0517553799,
0.0116274031,
0.0429523662,
0.0439300239,
0.0116917435,
0.0433823541,
0.0452286452,
-0.0082087833,
-0.0269495659,
-0.0116287619,
0.0429287814,
-0.0211105011,
0.0358796939,
0.0449517295,
-0.0216740742,
0.0337595604,
-0.0563740283,
0.0265824627,
-0.0379149169,
-0.0655250624,
-0.0068866215,
-0.0122771105,
-0.0414036885,
0.0239208341,
-0.0190244056,
-0.0091665611,
0.0312454067,
-0.0006569903,
-0.0151363099,
-0.0158651136,
-0.0369516611,
-0.0251604822,
0.0158008058,
-0.0239645876,
-0.0693948194,
-0.0277880579,
0.0099936547,
0.025729483,
-0.0447555892,
0.0003821311,
2.398100311e-34,
0.0354271829,
0.0244031716,
0.0185339618,
0.0354734398,
0.0428603068,
0.0088247377,
-0.0097349668,
0.0178903118,
-0.0122678531,
-0.1049494371,
-0.0019469542
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07081v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07081v1
|
T-curator: a trust based curation tool for LOD logs
| 2024-05-11T19:32:27 | 2024-05-11T19:32:27 |
Dihia Lanasri
|
cs.DB
|
cs.DB, cs.CL
|
Nowadays, companies are racing towards Linked Open Data (LOD) to improve
their added value, but they are ignoring their SPARQL query logs. If well
curated, these logs can present an asset for decision makers. A naive and
straightforward use of these logs is too risky because their provenance and
quality are highly questionable. Users of these logs in a trusted way have to
be assisted by providing them with in-depth knowledge of the whole LOD
environment and tools to curate these logs. In this paper, we propose an
interactive and intuitive trust based tool that can be used to curate these LOD
logs before exploiting them. This tool is proposed to support our approach
proposed in our previous work Lanasri et al. [2020].
|
T-curator: a trust based curation tool for LOD logs: Nowadays, companies are racing towards Linked Open Data (LOD) to improve
their added value, but they are ignoring their SPARQL query logs. If well
curated, these logs can present an asset for decision makers. A naive and
straightforward use of these logs is too risky because their provenance and
quality are highly questionable. Users of these logs in a trusted way have to
be assisted by providing them with in-depth knowledge of the whole LOD
environment and tools to curate these logs. In this paper, we propose an
interactive and intuitive trust based tool that can be used to curate these LOD
logs before exploiting them. This tool is proposed to support our approach
proposed in our previous work Lanasri et al. [2020].
|
[
0.0412191674,
0.0778388828,
0.0090945121,
0.0186922699,
-0.038387429,
-0.040184319,
0.0333243571,
0.0054453798,
0.0664996505,
-0.0063310685,
-0.0335706435,
0.0598519072,
-0.0277457703,
0.0722988695,
-0.043309629,
-0.0278336201,
0.0015617101,
-0.0154165039,
-0.0381866731,
-0.0113579743,
0.0011597278,
0.0335889719,
0.0158431381,
-0.018057093,
0.0001516323,
-0.0078363959,
0.0046560001,
-0.0068781297,
0.0011292594,
-0.0138431815,
-0.0288235135,
0.0347816795,
-0.0321383104,
0.0492452346,
0.0000021016,
-0.0456505418,
-0.0403647758,
0.0305958241,
-0.0630984083,
-0.0008985551,
-0.0097603099,
0.0161480773,
0.0257268436,
0.0231044106,
-0.0184651781,
-0.0305056553,
0.0166478325,
0.0068229339,
0.0269529503,
-0.0238521751,
-0.0009068492,
0.0418410525,
-0.0094911754,
0.0067071891,
0.0591847561,
0.0123485746,
-0.0145259444,
-0.0191658605,
0.0251293238,
0.0040438287,
0.0025430245,
0.0015872911,
-0.0202000774,
-0.0000164364,
0.0275835712,
0.0113499332,
0.0025027476,
-0.0118578188,
-0.016939491,
-0.0101206005,
0.0539421402,
0.0197481476,
0.0234323256,
0.0062891543,
-0.0118062319,
0.0445082225,
-0.0386101827,
0.0190842487,
-0.013061719,
0.0094194524,
-0.0441814475,
0.0089597004,
0.0038721173,
0.0095215943,
-0.0300935432,
0.0548599437,
0.0098069245,
-0.004210657,
-0.0223543439,
-0.0017904578,
0.0911607817,
-0.0351527669,
0.0204591099,
0.0059288652,
-0.006866788,
-0.0055331718,
0.0029435046,
0.0596043989,
0.0214887317,
0.0607324243,
-0.0636561289,
-0.0230752937,
-0.0187291354,
0.0482861102,
0.0622555017,
-0.0248758402,
0.0036751167,
0.0296624098,
0.0798563138,
-0.0339311175,
-0.0340943485,
-0.0020530063,
0.0204944089,
-0.0288861617,
-0.0200274792,
0.0319983102,
0.0137708914,
0.0373452529,
-0.0054700607,
0.0654805154,
0.0470103659,
0.0048296074,
0.0206138305,
-0.0103707258,
-0.0778757706,
-0.091728285,
0.0296725109,
0.0136497961,
-0.0144322477,
-0.0510610081,
-0.0067552375,
-0.0218931288,
0.0620110929,
-0.0169546567,
-0.0090303542,
-0.0068529877,
0.0578481779,
-0.0112456707,
-0.0580488928,
-0.0994182751,
0.0397978872,
0.0257484317,
-0.0597864501,
-0.0102926288,
0.0190120954,
-0.0166054107,
-0.0120623987,
-0.0417642891,
-0.0427672714,
0.0120245609,
-0.0509724356,
0.0005028069,
-0.12336649,
-0.0255560037,
-0.030703634,
0.0132502159,
0.0059327553,
-0.0158948209,
0.0096994508,
0.0618609041,
0.0530557372,
0.0264080819,
0.0117585016,
-0.0125004537,
0.0198105015,
-0.0203541648,
0.0544932373,
0.0472640172,
-0.0489683561,
-0.029612923,
0.0037187254,
0.0092377895,
-0.0142394342,
-0.0235655773,
0.0594709627,
0.0135161737,
0.0559276119,
-0.0209098589,
0.0028864336,
0.0339099132,
-0.018378824,
-0.0135556394,
-0.052648142,
0.0517942049,
0.0474632606,
-0.0407704972,
-0.0009556172,
0.0314507633,
-0.0104529699,
-0.0122273136,
0.0129647497,
-0.0161901973,
-0.0152659277,
0.0283200312,
-0.0029047448,
0.0435435995,
0.0413371474,
0.0280861966,
-0.0221643429,
0.0045702546,
0.0170588773,
-0.0113302451,
0.0547304638,
0.0401197188,
0.0574524216,
-0.0288534276,
-0.0025839838,
-0.04116375,
-0.004616783,
0.0071703107,
0.0201772675,
0.0047109211,
-0.0251067579,
-0.0180812869,
-0.0809521973,
0.0313902609,
0.0307317358,
-0.0347186215,
-0.0071153212,
0.047301434,
-0.0092164334,
-0.0758338347,
0.0106723644,
0.0008117872,
0.0862195417,
0.0075698514,
0.0078991437,
0.0205885023,
0.0201288201,
0.0603266507,
0.0504375137,
0.0136608919,
0.0263905134,
0.0543374643,
-0.0452869572,
0.0515128896,
0.0581588931,
0.0857720599,
-0.0265354682,
-0.0513154417,
0.0174007714,
-0.0012622881,
-0.0411097147,
-0.0173875075,
-0.0042978562,
-0.0151342303,
0.0206479989,
-0.0058313375,
-0.0401903279,
0.0058408049,
-0.0108719496,
-0.0205633938,
0.0089070722,
0.0029254116,
0.0052508344,
-0.0466247015,
-0.0102950744,
0.0202909801,
-0.0488275588,
0.0668202713,
-0.0025691697,
-0.019766802,
0.0147645213,
0.0073947757,
-0.0248572715,
-0.0584707893,
0.024127299,
-0.0052352869,
-0.018357778,
-0.0048926659,
0.018874554,
-0.0092563517,
0.0324454121,
-0.0150323436,
-0.0050820997,
-0.0432918593,
0.0223247726,
0.0289409123,
0.0012654146,
0.0379519202,
0.0318266898,
0.0102410233,
0.0141441096,
0.0153739778,
0.0045164111,
0.0131821949,
0.0052377237,
0.010366966,
-0.0340982527,
-0.0326742567,
-0.0749710873,
-0.0507225767,
0.0231674556,
0.0478853285,
-0.0026005236,
0.004429996,
-0.0413166732,
0.0335241742,
0.0035665107,
0.0389264226,
0.0100758718,
-0.024144724,
-0.036054153,
-0.0488287434,
0.0133943986,
0.0112776039,
0.0071378867,
0.0426595956,
0.0902994499,
-0.0598696731,
0.0267294794,
0.0040824073,
-0.0008579753,
0.0154996905,
0.0245385151,
0.0122258635,
0.0005542568,
-0.0216238853,
0.0071449038,
0.0639769807,
0.0284793135,
-0.0652580932,
0.0171186328,
0.0109138237,
0.042926386,
0.0031320185,
-0.0448404476,
-0.0679544881,
0.0526947528,
-0.0206313916,
0.0369366147,
-0.0202001184,
-0.0628828704,
0.0297080521,
-0.0180341545,
0.0408216976,
-0.0343761854,
-0.0559573136,
0.0006722633,
-0.0616214015,
0.007744703,
-0.0040984554,
-0.0003913502,
0.0022346505,
-0.0637068897,
-0.0405588523,
-0.0036787225,
-0.037845321,
-0.0308049358,
-0.0149812624,
0.0273853987,
0.0027234333,
0.0299821235,
-0.0316159464,
0.0195703842,
-0.0405107513,
-0.0173706189,
0.0003741356,
-0.0059176958,
0.0380078554,
-0.0324781202,
0.0684234351,
0.0322180986,
-0.0755033642,
0.0113618234,
0.0022945139,
0.0129184397,
-0.0191771146,
0.039794825,
-0.0248237755,
-0.0183479432,
-0.0037818768,
0.0187740903,
0.0132192289,
0.0531424321,
-0.0355055369,
0.0114355572,
0.0079131033,
0.0173167661,
-0.0104252994,
0.0080822501,
-0.1209874451,
0.0058260518,
-0.023602346,
0.0288896095,
-0.0158502441,
-0.1020469218,
-0.0065786974,
-0.0331121311,
0.0622729212,
-0.0245414618,
-0.003226547,
-0.0172977578,
-0.1286975294,
-0.0107869003,
-0.0694415346,
-0.0784422085,
-0.0169526916,
-0.0030631914,
0.0006301876,
0.0045449203,
-0.0109165097,
0.0112002138,
0.0019733324,
-0.0729069188,
0.0219266731,
-0.0237339418,
0.0121426415,
0.0255784914,
-0.0453801043,
-0.0441864878,
0.0547157526,
-0.0269168038,
-0.04781688,
0.073657237,
-0.0075172815,
0.0094111618,
-0.022529481,
0.0639642552,
0.0124983443,
0.0234379172,
-0.0140038617,
0.0796296597,
-0.0079655135,
0.0125617115,
0.0028808147,
-0.0440238304,
0.0373248756,
0.0446434245,
-0.0026011558,
-0.0136065353,
0.0271746833,
-0.0183898322,
-0.0093251718,
0.065079838,
-0.0178152509,
0.0985771194,
-0.0299691278,
-0.0174253099,
-0.030200839,
-0.0231735557,
0.0233861692,
0.0469490662,
-0.0062255696,
-0.0321882814,
0.0183109138,
-0.0065423185,
0.0022584917,
-0.0015056096,
-0.084823668,
0.0646522269,
-0.0446649119,
0.0704821572,
0.000732371,
0.0073934565,
0.0017753218,
0.019648267,
0.012026717,
-0.0048529669,
0.0175406747,
0.0255406294,
0.0311397519,
-0.0203980543,
-0.0094359983,
-0.0381063037,
0.003889428,
0.0298102964,
-0.0636795014,
-0.0883239433,
-0.0048916237,
0.0127225146,
-0.0183793511,
0.0204405524,
-0.0734998137,
-0.0479778983,
-0.0199603494,
-0.0821523368,
-0.002081498,
-0.0267477389,
0.0242361538,
0.0408123285,
0.0335670859,
0.0453497618,
0.0460240021,
-0.0160980038,
0.0381699204,
-0.0070204507,
0.0164600536,
0.0086661428,
0.0710915551,
0.0098259989,
-0.0253299177,
0.018346956,
0.0245669037,
-0.0207938291,
0.0065319701,
-0.0789062455,
-0.0004688028,
0.0168048199,
-0.0063142348,
0.0258942116,
-0.0128018297,
-0.0339834578,
0.0022468388,
-0.0157530848,
0.0510535166,
0.0047162315,
-0.0278962236,
-0.0109581817,
-0.0249744989,
0.0069819768,
-0.0107019292,
-0.099113293,
-0.0406896733,
0.0422643423,
-0.0574060865,
0.0067820656,
0.0127022834,
0.004793107,
-0.0370795578,
0.0028912725,
0.0114238728,
-0.0234710556,
0.0256600156,
-0.011088891,
0.0102804126,
0.0013443558,
-0.0316332206,
0.0226377044,
0.0388105363,
0.0072053238,
0.0227343924,
-0.0755022094,
-0.0601866022,
-0.0524925664,
-0.0263845567,
0.0505123585,
0.0630120337,
-0.0415106639,
-0.0797461867,
-0.026679961,
0.0112024127,
0.0528656766,
-0.0020116137,
0.0217339508,
0.0176050663,
0.0050375205,
0.024460325,
0.0154476501,
0.0229413491,
-0.0218225606,
-0.0512105301,
-0.009545478,
-0.0576887019,
-0.005389329,
-5.851082273e-33,
0.0368584357,
-0.0548735261,
0.0004738415,
0.0467813835,
0.0314509422,
-0.012790245,
0.0029113151,
-0.0235519372,
-0.0019040519,
0.0147559866,
0.0003128929,
-0.0028821812,
0.0404522941,
-0.0051779542,
-0.0090094944,
-0.0098962868,
0.0451539084,
0.0017896335,
0.0190043021,
0.0077927145,
0.083041437,
-0.0107127344,
-0.0336668044,
-0.1008622199,
0.0758683085,
-0.0152227283,
-0.0309110153,
0.0564982183,
0.0252722055,
0.0479350686,
0.0071719219,
-0.0056162411,
-0.0144330859,
-0.0027626981,
0.0079254191,
-0.0273171365,
-0.057454031,
-0.010019511,
0.008376251,
-0.0148154804,
0.023422854,
0.0240784213,
-0.0035680458,
0.0147428429,
0.0080999006,
0.0195160937,
-0.0141422292,
0.0199686401,
-0.0469403341,
-0.0605722815,
0.0226586051,
0.0215015411,
-0.0369564965,
0.0421560779,
0.037924502,
0.0143366018,
0.0389302,
0.0045874417,
-0.0797123015,
0.044301983,
-0.0796151757,
-0.0651968867,
-0.0029719023,
-0.0369531624,
-0.0108853122,
0.0097783795,
-0.0681865811,
-0.0360845253,
0.0338104144,
0.1083518341,
-0.0658039004,
0.095957756,
0.0029378426,
0.0574719161,
-0.0213595778,
-0.0487211645,
-0.0267653819,
0.0345199518,
0.0094922213,
0.0016132572,
-0.0127899321,
0.009006625,
-0.0175398644,
0.0218538288,
-0.004948969,
-0.0277336668,
-0.0517037027,
-0.007188526,
0.0008437869,
0.03746479,
-0.0538298488,
0.0020229944,
-0.0077322298,
-0.0049734851,
-0.0284215696,
0.0122766513,
0.0442801751,
-0.0196344107,
0.0128286229,
-0.0165228061,
-0.0064604906,
0.0084228013,
0.0224126372,
0.0019460774,
-0.0113722654,
0.0056172507,
0.0597613119,
-0.0199897271,
-0.0408665985,
0.0442085043,
-0.0087707117,
0.0213543586,
-0.0300382841,
-0.0718081817,
0.0458467864,
-0.0106601771,
0.0081387851,
0.0430245996,
0.0291066449,
0.0231064223,
-0.003477993,
0.0024382533,
-0.0090303086,
-0.0092570223,
0.0513935536,
-0.0405432135,
0.0292081814,
-0.0614680499,
0.0458843522,
-0.0005751854,
0.005208923,
-0.0550668165,
2.778e-7,
0.0063627749,
-0.0121588754,
-0.0041436208,
0.009662481,
0.0569493733,
-0.0139970006,
0.0313827433,
0.0769479647,
-0.0371246077,
-0.0424718969,
0.0060009323,
-0.0207689907,
0.0304872524,
0.07094156,
-0.0404144228,
-0.0546142347,
-0.0013277919,
-0.07475546,
-0.0770992264,
-0.0091562858,
0.028722154,
-0.0022891259,
0.0122196767,
0.0004034944,
0.0248906612,
-0.0204123855,
-0.0218993481,
-0.0155877238,
-0.0157872885,
-0.0295128375,
0.1165474877,
-0.0122715533,
-0.0078491885,
-0.0284656156,
-0.043398086,
-0.0013287889,
-0.0622924604,
0.0041840407,
0.023988137,
0.014651197,
0.0207581613,
-0.1171183959,
0.0177540872,
-0.0283857062,
0.0436365008,
0.0447572023,
-0.0244645402,
0.0498636626,
-0.0054417183,
-0.0422369391,
0.0351960696,
-0.0014158328,
-0.0251056664,
0.002986863,
-0.0053315051,
0.0215333067,
0.0104982732,
-0.0400084592,
-0.0195699502,
-0.060445033,
0.0068802228,
-0.0311502852,
0.0118770469,
0.0190874357,
0.0026559157,
0.0375967547,
0.0152126495,
2.142852504e-34,
0.0027219187,
0.0524358675,
-0.0095908279,
-0.0281031653,
0.0701506883,
0.0035249144,
0.0252107382,
0.0058843927,
0.0456835888,
-0.0350569971,
0.0092787808
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07076v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07076v2
|
Integrating Emotional and Linguistic Models for Ethical Compliance in Large Language Models
| 2024-05-11T19:26:00 | 2024-05-14T03:08:12 |
Edward Y. Chang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
This research develops advanced methodologies for Large Language Models
(LLMs) to better manage linguistic behaviors related to emotions and ethics. We
introduce DIKE, an adversarial framework that enhances the LLMs' ability to
internalize and reflect global human values, adapting to varied cultural
contexts to promote transparency and trust among users. The methodology
involves detailed modeling of emotions, classification of linguistic behaviors,
and implementation of ethical guardrails. Our innovative approaches include
mapping emotions and behaviors using self-supervised learning techniques,
refining these guardrails through adversarial reviews, and systematically
adjusting outputs to ensure ethical alignment. This framework establishes a
robust foundation for AI systems to operate with ethical integrity and cultural
sensitivity, paving the way for more responsible and context-aware AI
interactions.
|
Integrating Emotional and Linguistic Models for Ethical Compliance in Large Language Models: This research develops advanced methodologies for Large Language Models
(LLMs) to better manage linguistic behaviors related to emotions and ethics. We
introduce DIKE, an adversarial framework that enhances the LLMs' ability to
internalize and reflect global human values, adapting to varied cultural
contexts to promote transparency and trust among users. The methodology
involves detailed modeling of emotions, classification of linguistic behaviors,
and implementation of ethical guardrails. Our innovative approaches include
mapping emotions and behaviors using self-supervised learning techniques,
refining these guardrails through adversarial reviews, and systematically
adjusting outputs to ensure ethical alignment. This framework establishes a
robust foundation for AI systems to operate with ethical integrity and cultural
sensitivity, paving the way for more responsible and context-aware AI
interactions.
|
[
0.0688401237,
0.1202245802,
-0.0414645448,
0.0465956777,
-0.049625691,
-0.0011945062,
0.0374457203,
-0.0197338574,
0.0725843012,
-0.0262431484,
-0.0403834693,
-0.0097507164,
-0.0256346408,
0.037029352,
-0.0075224973,
-0.0291584358,
0.0431459881,
0.0384892002,
0.0653515533,
-0.0265227091,
0.0225388501,
0.0510762855,
0.0422481596,
0.016077308,
-0.0096340971,
-0.0003285817,
0.0033553748,
-0.0107563818,
0.0473508947,
0.0030965128,
0.0342239439,
0.0235720705,
0.0066180932,
0.0521836169,
0.0000018885,
-0.0590004399,
-0.0139350249,
0.0067623835,
0.0192848071,
-0.000224833,
0.1055988967,
-0.035734091,
-0.0377673283,
-0.0118831424,
-0.0651571229,
0.0240082629,
0.0495280549,
0.0554659069,
0.0859188214,
0.0591985099,
-0.021495657,
0.0203415249,
0.0172834806,
-0.0090567004,
-0.0666521043,
-0.0405107215,
0.0290923249,
0.0059145093,
-0.0582914427,
-0.0057464396,
-0.0180197507,
0.0180296283,
0.0299622398,
-0.0224750154,
-0.0401967801,
-0.03968326,
-0.0105268527,
-0.0436875224,
0.0012686145,
0.057091102,
-0.015079014,
-0.0069287075,
0.0287606623,
0.0060442965,
0.0069191614,
-0.0104098311,
0.0046126558,
0.046382986,
-0.006268186,
0.0056993193,
0.0137437247,
0.0235184561,
0.0183937438,
0.1112474352,
0.0325478911,
-0.0063361134,
-0.0283424258,
-0.0052937837,
-0.0069954628,
-0.021979278,
0.0006218749,
-0.0239696968,
0.060990233,
0.0256979037,
-0.0279583465,
0.020985825,
-0.0406438224,
-0.0025342049,
0.0466015749,
-0.0683038235,
0.0077294083,
0.0285606161,
-0.0085992785,
0.014625174,
0.0104626724,
0.0437896252,
-0.0076755788,
0.053152252,
-0.028117137,
0.0045832368,
0.016536925,
0.0036663758,
-0.0003793544,
0.0017068184,
-0.0347014032,
0.0327473544,
-0.0738331452,
-0.0029489244,
-0.0781685784,
0.0371173769,
-0.0283977427,
0.0147905769,
-0.0165680908,
-0.0140287951,
-0.0191371441,
0.0041804868,
-0.0376141742,
0.0221995991,
-0.0128046069,
-0.002967044,
0.0210633315,
-0.0120389182,
-0.0574956648,
0.0127075957,
0.0163851827,
0.0892170072,
0.0280033331,
0.0280511267,
-0.0341605283,
-0.0082600489,
-0.016159473,
-0.0569879562,
-0.0167362746,
-0.0305494331,
0.0307310242,
-0.0275994334,
-0.0276679564,
-0.0928732008,
0.0248419661,
0.0099777542,
0.0023282033,
0.0746704489,
0.027366735,
-0.0199598819,
0.0216188058,
0.0600024574,
0.0193143766,
0.0309013277,
0.0102770971,
0.0762791038,
0.0501082167,
-0.0211027116,
0.005355808,
0.0102844713,
0.0051842947,
0.0019234968,
-0.069259271,
-0.0124936951,
-0.007040902,
0.0128210066,
0.025550697,
0.0722657219,
-0.0116095785,
-0.057296101,
0.0483769663,
0.0682330728,
-0.0610393994,
0.0315015465,
-0.0067581241,
0.0117227724,
-0.0168269072,
-0.0051743779,
-0.0569316037,
0.0320352651,
0.010232321,
-0.0517644696,
-0.0716585666,
0.0675509721,
-0.0017619939,
-0.0565578192,
0.0131476019,
-0.0376463197,
0.0588602796,
0.02932081,
-0.010203586,
0.0170711279,
0.0146583179,
-0.0558880679,
0.0311319847,
-0.0817336589,
-0.0056656678,
-0.0486671999,
0.0384721793,
0.1047707349,
0.0370135494,
-0.0178860743,
0.0228209496,
-0.0551113151,
-0.0091845226,
0.0377372205,
0.0212976001,
-0.0170755219,
-0.0025932309,
-0.0438950807,
-0.0471164249,
0.0043944097,
-0.0167145319,
0.0191138946,
-0.0069071562,
0.0172476508,
0.0052424408,
-0.0170466863,
-0.0619055443,
0.0322769508,
-0.0392285287,
-0.0218687393,
-0.0265810564,
0.0319975577,
0.0288074818,
0.0106839379,
0.0164413992,
-0.021809753,
0.0083028395,
-0.0047302837,
-0.0209244397,
-0.0184367299,
-0.024513578,
0.0216165036,
0.0419359282,
-0.0405746028,
-0.0272371266,
0.043910455,
-0.039511323,
0.0321379825,
-0.0009301036,
0.0246339925,
-0.0056935782,
-0.0696509406,
-0.0219870657,
-0.0438317321,
0.0061536897,
-0.0331927389,
0.0250618365,
-0.0442825928,
-0.0297711194,
-0.028818015,
-0.0065779523,
0.0308022182,
0.0162285659,
-0.0565167777,
0.0331493989,
-0.0240504947,
0.0459703058,
0.043761313,
0.023736041,
-0.0236628447,
-0.0400634892,
-0.073643364,
-0.027349351,
0.0032468201,
-0.0046568592,
0.0030131147,
-0.0163881369,
-0.0010382998,
0.007173127,
-0.0504141711,
-0.0188328903,
0.0036697919,
0.0237435382,
0.0203978997,
-0.0354287028,
-0.0182685312,
-0.0289362762,
-0.0079636676,
-0.0291611608,
0.0042107566,
0.013809029,
-0.0128830727,
-0.023161348,
-0.0091534983,
-0.0618984923,
0.0201814771,
-0.0093816677,
-0.0956428871,
-0.0075899693,
0.0486007929,
-0.0111485394,
0.0775761604,
0.0388345942,
0.0638672858,
0.0626037195,
0.0471747406,
-0.0518171676,
-0.008769162,
0.0250713881,
0.0054049953,
-0.0091584399,
-0.0227723848,
-0.0189480372,
0.0285415165,
0.0059517352,
-0.0071982685,
-0.020292284,
0.0600476861,
-0.0520316996,
-0.080737859,
0.0046488643,
-0.0657686293,
-0.0150117381,
0.0243966728,
-0.0127222268,
-0.0562982187,
0.0924773216,
0.0460826829,
0.0237581749,
-0.0140201598,
-0.0117564155,
-0.0036173514,
0.0709434375,
-0.0276188087,
0.0773322508,
0.0169435628,
-0.0060477299,
-0.039469149,
-0.0199489202,
0.0454027988,
-0.0713262931,
0.0124043385,
-0.0110512339,
-0.014330646,
0.0243354384,
-0.0456206724,
-0.0693947226,
-0.0401848741,
-0.0118855797,
0.0050697541,
0.0020255276,
-0.0017985001,
-0.0189694185,
-0.0090311775,
0.0239013955,
-0.0289008338,
0.0077858916,
0.0065520615,
-0.0022216714,
-0.0393888839,
0.05512508,
-0.0334484279,
0.0413393527,
0.0093935411,
0.0671636686,
0.0574762896,
0.0080036558,
-0.0082372036,
0.034890227,
0.0160532333,
0.0255631991,
0.0183065217,
0.035330113,
0.0009876888,
-0.0016614901,
-0.0261085965,
0.0261571705,
0.0831431672,
0.0138736386,
-0.0558631644,
0.0116278408,
-0.0418467484,
-0.012145672,
0.0135520659,
0.024360057,
-0.0688904077,
0.01105134,
-0.0271985084,
0.0238488615,
-0.0470599979,
-0.0349760056,
0.011464824,
-0.0738129914,
0.0167236682,
0.0377784781,
-0.0168878883,
-0.0269124862,
0.009117906,
-0.0165370163,
-0.0289908927,
0.0566828847,
-0.0421974026,
0.0119533995,
-0.0683594793,
-0.0074815983,
0.0007833424,
-0.0131497737,
0.0392716825,
-0.0554183871,
0.0708752796,
0.0831161439,
0.0745624974,
-0.0373033434,
-0.0558932535,
-0.00396627,
0.0206628572,
-0.0191494096,
0.0205122065,
0.0251128115,
-0.032341186,
-0.0119387051,
-0.0404640809,
0.0239487123,
-0.0067476151,
-0.0355479196,
0.0051940945,
0.0643213466,
0.0020571521,
-0.0318980031,
-0.0208749417,
0.019271275,
0.0361786671,
0.0630165711,
-0.0176684167,
-0.0711643696,
0.0068723173,
-0.0431050919,
-0.0046189376,
0.0065416354,
-0.0352153555,
0.0095065534,
-0.0396614522,
-0.0300603863,
-0.0741084144,
-0.0662103146,
-0.026760783,
0.0044535557,
0.0415060073,
-0.0420294702,
0.0273539498,
-0.0079622744,
-0.0144247385,
0.0042886497,
-0.0153626632,
0.0436790623,
0.0186909419,
0.0154761095,
0.0128566511,
-0.0072431988,
0.0200147238,
0.0309629757,
0.0506709181,
-0.0540768579,
0.0673243552,
0.0629397407,
0.0081516188,
0.0220145565,
-0.0138084264,
-0.0193465278,
-0.0015632752,
0.0404696129,
-0.0522121899,
-0.0107259694,
0.0708070472,
0.0154659059,
-0.0262820777,
0.0218274202,
-0.0100687305,
0.0280400515,
0.0441919602,
0.0076782433,
-0.0745496899,
-0.0452502482,
0.036536552,
0.0270402953,
-0.0114387982,
-0.0385202244,
-0.0214956198,
-0.0380665138,
-0.0464827418,
-0.0105354385,
-0.0519372076,
-0.0282563791,
0.0119343465,
0.0342015997,
0.0101875756,
0.0062404713,
0.000617491,
-0.0226946659,
-0.0413346589,
-0.0015921379,
0.0193186775,
-0.0017448412,
0.088585414,
-0.0348021165,
0.0240041409,
-0.0271274,
0.0472492874,
0.0251107384,
0.030807022,
-0.0201587342,
0.0628732815,
0.0394537635,
0.0090964241,
0.0074898461,
0.0442214869,
-0.0127500826,
-0.002765913,
-0.007427345,
-0.0090379696,
0.0122545306,
0.0020092467,
0.022826409,
-0.0338095427,
0.003225215,
-0.0113579966,
-0.0009269755,
0.0041420599,
-0.0598257333,
0.0031519595,
0.0019114879,
-0.0422327779,
0.0037611849,
0.0028677692,
-0.0401920006,
0.0483478867,
-0.0145251658,
-0.0296589062,
-0.0142478971,
-0.0483835787,
0.094649978,
-0.0408634841,
-0.0217610933,
0.0078323865,
-0.0748527795,
-0.0640248433,
-0.0229884908,
-0.0019738185,
-0.0300579518,
-0.0548625737,
0.0078069065,
0.0637814403,
0.0003154435,
0.0353272818,
-0.0482762083,
0.0114793396,
-0.0323320553,
-0.0345221497,
-0.0134721054,
-5.370866015e-33,
-0.0024847491,
-0.0535740964,
-0.0288134757,
-0.0150076272,
-0.0010120834,
-0.0111262333,
0.0017188814,
0.0011680573,
-0.0396086611,
0.0508073978,
-0.009393095,
0.0053382097,
-0.0094581023,
-0.0102623776,
0.0033475826,
-0.0439297296,
0.0346626081,
0.0191284493,
-0.0106803766,
0.0212273803,
0.0104311556,
0.0073156906,
0.018234184,
-0.1183133572,
0.0602128617,
0.0394018143,
-0.0684523508,
0.0239343941,
-0.0103222942,
0.0486657545,
-0.0027873912,
0.0715730339,
0.0028481176,
0.0181440748,
0.0204766672,
0.0383889824,
-0.0211041812,
0.0037742467,
0.0255560279,
-0.0083238855,
-0.0185021367,
-0.047255639,
0.0130526172,
-0.0444267876,
-0.0378198065,
0.0155342882,
0.0298665911,
-0.0225076359,
-0.0021272199,
-0.0385105573,
-0.0630533993,
-0.0162639339,
-0.0310573615,
-0.0049555223,
-0.0081131076,
0.0284956712,
-0.0142753366,
-0.004483053,
-0.0400431752,
0.01160785,
-0.0174454488,
-0.0400517546,
0.0528652668,
-0.0267356336,
0.0024743145,
0.083996661,
0.0005812349,
0.0311044995,
-0.0245931596,
-0.0043956595,
0.031252943,
0.0455701388,
0.0584831201,
0.0880379155,
-0.0585786961,
-0.0623107627,
-0.0351166092,
0.0204106458,
0.0323037915,
0.0477152504,
0.0225357227,
0.0010423796,
-0.02812309,
-0.0187796839,
-0.0199289676,
-0.0347750336,
-0.0218869764,
-0.0316123925,
0.022038741,
-0.0334937647,
-0.0473448336,
-0.0361011885,
-0.0082022268,
-0.0718112141,
0.0111082057,
0.0490933694,
0.0390910804,
-0.0300280694,
0.0148411244,
0.0557949282,
-0.0139727518,
0.0093633942,
-0.0295597799,
-0.0458477028,
0.0384099148,
-0.0027229732,
0.0509830453,
0.0343441479,
-0.0278760958,
0.0105706183,
-0.0006385972,
0.0320135653,
0.0067455429,
-0.0116310008,
-0.0014573277,
-0.0050200331,
-0.0098962635,
-0.001877855,
0.0333665833,
0.0071695447,
-0.0327074118,
-0.0011022397,
-0.0157147218,
0.0383075215,
-0.050772097,
-0.0057585533,
-0.0423883758,
0.0189972501,
0.0421481021,
-0.047379449,
-0.0099948114,
-0.0035814997,
2.578e-7,
-0.0073385686,
0.0185055342,
-0.0009761366,
-0.0169880558,
-0.0234011728,
0.0642495155,
0.0286944695,
0.0672540888,
-0.0010007678,
-0.0356435589,
0.0312559754,
0.0219342988,
0.07330513,
0.0284122229,
-0.0433997959,
0.0083250329,
-0.036299523,
0.000630996,
-0.0338729061,
0.0542103909,
0.0064558149,
0.0583018698,
0.0292069204,
-0.022271093,
0.0048042443,
-0.0043406184,
0.0347472206,
-0.053996522,
-0.0060679768,
0.0013923987,
0.002067151,
-0.0374656841,
0.0257528648,
-0.0004305062,
0.0133872274,
-0.0006857355,
0.0465423316,
0.1090845391,
-0.0136847524,
-0.017498266,
-0.0153758908,
-0.0187875647,
0.0017308135,
-0.0525579154,
0.0313434638,
-0.0081639672,
-0.0327891894,
-0.0602942519,
0.033770252,
-0.0450755917,
0.045225393,
-0.0293453485,
-0.0476109087,
0.0047698249,
0.0260921828,
0.0047773696,
0.012601018,
-0.0296965409,
0.0032946302,
-0.0304471701,
0.0122389402,
-0.0431668647,
0.0279769022,
0.0382743403,
0.0022612975,
-0.0264039896,
0.0515163057,
1.9552909e-34,
0.0052646189,
-0.0351766646,
0.0005600424,
0.0163693987,
0.0502265058,
0.0682212338,
-0.0303789675,
0.0233533401,
0.0298492983,
-0.0008697106,
-0.0017252939
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13000v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13000v1
|
RAGE Against the Machine: Retrieval-Augmented LLM Explanations
| 2024-05-11T19:08:38 | 2024-05-11T19:08:38 |
Joel Rorseth, Parke Godfrey, Lukasz Golab, Divesh Srivastava, Jaroslaw Szlichta
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
This paper demonstrates RAGE, an interactive tool for explaining Large
Language Models (LLMs) augmented with retrieval capabilities; i.e., able to
query external sources and pull relevant information into their input context.
Our explanations are counterfactual in the sense that they identify parts of
the input context that, when removed, change the answer to the question posed
to the LLM. RAGE includes pruning methods to navigate the vast space of
possible explanations, allowing users to view the provenance of the produced
answers.
|
RAGE Against the Machine: Retrieval-Augmented LLM Explanations: This paper demonstrates RAGE, an interactive tool for explaining Large
Language Models (LLMs) augmented with retrieval capabilities; i.e., able to
query external sources and pull relevant information into their input context.
Our explanations are counterfactual in the sense that they identify parts of
the input context that, when removed, change the answer to the question posed
to the LLM. RAGE includes pruning methods to navigate the vast space of
possible explanations, allowing users to view the provenance of the produced
answers.
|
[
0.0192568451,
0.0042433813,
-0.0353422388,
0.0855990872,
-0.0365149714,
-0.013212543,
-0.0163449347,
0.0135518527,
-0.0211426485,
-0.014355924,
0.0270858966,
0.0003260919,
0.0027741522,
-0.0049828081,
0.0244118311,
-0.0436843745,
0.0224480424,
-0.0502582565,
0.0136310877,
0.0078658462,
0.0036132839,
0.0240631197,
-0.0033809741,
0.0529417843,
0.0144175319,
-0.0238402486,
-0.040056888,
0.0005080672,
-0.035618294,
-0.0188935492,
-0.0184583515,
-0.0004949157,
0.0427459292,
0.038240023,
0.0000022378,
-0.0385420099,
-0.0044581839,
0.0123630529,
-0.0799196362,
0.0412355512,
-0.0375327803,
0.0364263803,
0.0248389319,
0.0193739608,
-0.0089804856,
0.0158858709,
0.044462882,
0.0264985114,
0.0518480651,
0.0519548096,
0.0241042282,
-0.02146722,
-0.0249776095,
-0.0142722009,
0.0807873309,
-0.0058759898,
0.0010154477,
0.0154765211,
0.060576763,
0.0141929351,
0.0034096034,
0.0365408584,
0.0281583965,
-0.0506398231,
-0.0296430979,
0.0048343414,
0.0275479257,
-0.0240262765,
0.0125441737,
0.0372646153,
0.0270335581,
-0.0369700603,
-0.006592392,
0.0091891242,
0.0069018635,
0.0444424972,
-0.103684701,
0.0236545168,
-0.0103580523,
-0.0019082924,
-0.0131311538,
-0.0305224974,
0.0658608228,
0.0129082594,
-0.024254676,
0.0778385922,
-0.0087648351,
-0.0042724996,
-0.0615148991,
-0.0104107698,
0.0117635326,
-0.0523505658,
0.0180859882,
0.1011092812,
-0.0381846987,
0.0261949729,
0.0385583825,
0.0034594601,
0.0283780545,
-0.0248593744,
0.0042621451,
0.0161417294,
-0.0389022604,
0.0443443879,
0.0102110943,
0.0505193993,
-0.0282365195,
-0.0203140397,
-0.0255565103,
-0.0040707574,
-0.0360830054,
-0.0514524169,
-0.0089473631,
-0.0034973437,
-0.0562917106,
0.0216653459,
0.0032043736,
0.0310032964,
-0.0167850256,
-0.0068318993,
0.002034948,
0.0069566029,
-0.0029914,
-0.0241645761,
-0.059395574,
0.0171270184,
-0.0518146083,
-0.0138240643,
0.0187328067,
-0.0847844109,
-0.0397430994,
0.0049734707,
-0.0031231761,
-0.0067166733,
-0.0079294555,
0.082595408,
0.0083106132,
0.0130763799,
-0.0340057984,
-0.0584628619,
-0.0198313352,
-0.0411850102,
-0.0243260246,
-0.05547956,
-0.0044791745,
0.0073367739,
-0.0327221937,
-0.0421523899,
0.0198108237,
0.0291492175,
-0.0328735001,
0.0414457098,
-0.0595569275,
0.024678506,
0.0415772945,
0.0082996702,
-0.0164695121,
0.0393557623,
0.0114975357,
0.0113020949,
0.0409692489,
-0.0236949287,
0.0629004985,
0.0181376506,
0.0396573916,
-0.0088383434,
-0.0496604927,
0.0199122634,
-0.037342567,
0.0367368273,
0.0079804575,
0.0235876627,
-0.035212744,
0.0138567099,
0.0282033626,
0.0595954843,
0.0125396084,
0.0090963971,
0.02731039,
0.0059299171,
0.0019551397,
0.0365248621,
-0.0381556116,
0.0327191986,
-0.0321270563,
0.0061587365,
0.0004509243,
0.0129217245,
0.0004353453,
-0.0724703297,
-0.0282552298,
0.0292672403,
-0.0193207711,
0.0315337181,
0.0508701988,
0.0042078728,
-0.0002357136,
0.0666005015,
0.0367466584,
-0.0438079312,
-0.0101950234,
-0.0694535226,
0.0835212246,
0.072465077,
0.0710026547,
-0.0570661686,
-0.0088176578,
0.0123754572,
0.0176351257,
0.0336204804,
0.0208827928,
-0.0029795878,
-0.0138088642,
-0.008608357,
-0.0182855781,
-0.0464777313,
0.0380730629,
0.0008888762,
0.0125124659,
-0.0514315218,
0.0141486824,
-0.0894913152,
-0.0332315415,
0.0152171589,
-0.0254889969,
-0.0518780872,
-0.0217923988,
0.0039144852,
-0.0329732448,
0.0345541053,
0.0164240599,
0.0493392311,
0.0387110449,
-0.0107974494,
-0.0104767298,
0.0158572029,
0.0120493528,
0.0045369188,
0.0618891604,
0.0003870015,
-0.0062083262,
0.0026571264,
-0.0137243401,
-0.025820652,
0.0166454725,
-0.056521412,
0.0679942593,
-0.0163531061,
0.0163571257,
-0.0188723542,
-0.0098120915,
-0.0348719619,
0.0536216088,
0.0105298078,
0.0177514423,
0.0558972806,
-0.0346999466,
0.0182189848,
-0.0297750197,
0.0300132949,
0.0323076621,
-0.0185775384,
-0.0039862008,
0.0103403032,
-0.0388703644,
-0.0344712548,
0.0036279163,
-0.0084425109,
-0.0156240892,
-0.0165407341,
0.0135643268,
0.0100857159,
0.0210282113,
-0.0153946998,
-0.0237210784,
-0.0090252226,
-0.0028032537,
0.0378530696,
0.0288771056,
0.0430940017,
0.0287943464,
-0.0467178561,
-0.051749561,
-0.0099148275,
-0.0078977793,
0.0652871951,
0.0183162335,
0.0052099028,
-0.0712484494,
-0.0229252949,
-0.0413710438,
-0.0008971237,
-0.0301321764,
-0.0030163727,
0.0398486815,
-0.0616995655,
-0.0131916264,
0.0167580713,
-0.0101426551,
0.0916853547,
0.0780297369,
-0.0240987614,
-0.0786126107,
-0.0057946593,
-0.0095524844,
-0.0480308346,
-0.0104842586,
-0.0559218638,
-0.0000966684,
0.0711500347,
-0.0181228295,
0.0132416682,
-0.0209236145,
0.0279575363,
0.0253180526,
-0.0009157324,
-0.0543948561,
-0.066475451,
-0.0298842136,
0.0759019107,
-0.0096591553,
-0.0774755478,
0.0602645464,
-0.0700572208,
0.0171852577,
0.0025579482,
-0.0434166305,
-0.0348871946,
0.0912788883,
-0.0410329923,
0.0157132596,
0.0122514619,
-0.0251925755,
0.0012520688,
-0.0361898728,
0.0487096049,
-0.0500112437,
0.0334300771,
-0.0642026439,
-0.0014752044,
0.0166012887,
0.01595526,
-0.0181109048,
-0.0377578177,
-0.0413552299,
-0.0157042388,
0.0179383196,
-0.0255008936,
-0.0370217413,
-0.0050811493,
0.0819002166,
-0.0012483775,
-0.0150533579,
0.0045965617,
-0.002973794,
-0.0057093482,
0.0256230198,
0.0623178333,
0.0188723058,
-0.0492985435,
0.026670428,
0.0354943424,
0.0143968593,
-0.0301565435,
-0.0186592247,
-0.0367783904,
0.0139240222,
-0.0231767278,
-0.0235124268,
0.0185041297,
0.0380912758,
-0.0786519423,
-0.006895782,
0.0949783847,
0.032605838,
-0.0515019782,
0.0138663249,
-0.0544936955,
0.0258926079,
0.0325855017,
0.0454785936,
-0.0676504299,
-0.0060823509,
0.0066856714,
0.0439889841,
0.033818122,
0.0028421446,
-0.0197664518,
-0.1082715839,
0.0527802482,
-0.0038262543,
-0.0305833928,
-0.0234191138,
-0.0589056946,
-0.013253157,
0.0129548227,
0.0008942802,
0.0472588278,
-0.0070547592,
0.0289063863,
0.0148610482,
0.0017001549,
-0.0013915983,
0.0014398083,
-0.006962053,
0.0181195121,
0.0329083055,
0.023524465,
0.0122166192,
-0.0325531662,
0.0507432744,
0.0048295963,
0.0521965027,
-0.0424978137,
0.0692155957,
0.0363345407,
-0.0088910926,
-0.0481302813,
-0.0140595138,
-0.0017018983,
-0.0352314785,
0.0153155755,
0.1010298207,
-0.0281283259,
0.0186419524,
-0.0188083556,
-0.0208817534,
0.0020804189,
0.0824347883,
0.0736355558,
0.0016088329,
-0.027426919,
-0.0639297664,
-0.0359380916,
-0.012987297,
-0.053283371,
-0.0108055258,
0.0246094931,
-0.0161817111,
-0.0207237061,
-0.00894788,
0.0203857068,
0.0439671762,
0.006533361,
0.0070927381,
-0.0377373472,
0.0086501697,
-0.0337335505,
0.0390277952,
-0.013275912,
0.010542877,
-0.014161692,
0.0090624932,
0.0063752439,
-0.0464164503,
0.0146010406,
0.0016983518,
-0.0009849669,
-0.059794303,
-0.029546598,
0.0250629615,
0.03716553,
0.0586006381,
0.0043726186,
-0.0791523382,
0.0174666513,
0.0245551523,
-0.0336835831,
0.005533413,
-0.0078015854,
0.0043998579,
-0.0130999368,
0.0305036064,
-0.0692172348,
-0.0384933762,
-0.0279256422,
0.0399145819,
-0.0565326065,
-0.0388866812,
0.0416238271,
0.0286977179,
0.044221025,
-0.0079437103,
-0.0458038934,
-0.0167620126,
0.0379588678,
-0.0487738699,
-0.0156227155,
-0.0166251119,
0.043028906,
-0.0122545827,
-0.0630330592,
0.0399078578,
-0.0145142963,
-0.014137594,
0.0290086549,
-0.0614652969,
0.0425604694,
0.011762307,
-0.0125535242,
0.0184975397,
0.0244035181,
-0.0028859719,
0.0187519826,
-0.0248778239,
0.0609092452,
-0.0025716589,
0.0422736593,
0.0090038572,
0.004783188,
-0.0125822686,
-0.0118207689,
-0.0819998458,
-0.1075255349,
0.0222935136,
0.0041629672,
0.0394366495,
-0.0136513151,
0.0670599937,
0.0096642282,
-0.0286106318,
-0.0011891472,
0.039939791,
0.0286281426,
-0.042532675,
0.0247739758,
0.0411021486,
-0.0298199896,
-0.0101217693,
0.051635772,
-0.0123395305,
0.0469306186,
0.0076796142,
-0.0224570837,
-0.0049507353,
-0.0382356569,
-0.0147380428,
0.0162154231,
0.0032956912,
-0.0242963322,
-0.0560659692,
-0.0737612396,
-0.0211645029,
0.0215068478,
-0.0495235547,
-0.0367560871,
0.0046034791,
0.0910668299,
0.0445558392,
-0.0415164381,
-0.0276120938,
0.0871966183,
-0.0822555125,
-0.0048084678,
-0.006295139,
-6.457646542e-33,
-0.0431582779,
-0.0766975135,
0.0342914201,
-0.0298934001,
0.00010432,
0.0000138577,
-0.0766257122,
0.0160774663,
-0.0383436047,
0.0157492757,
-0.0077943448,
0.0306285061,
-0.000859161,
-0.0111911567,
-0.0114080366,
-0.0437807962,
0.0361168049,
0.0311565213,
-0.0164917465,
0.0259976033,
0.0679559857,
0.0169262961,
0.0420462489,
-0.0924449861,
0.0700519085,
-0.0072494582,
-0.0171338003,
0.0585665703,
-0.0182767697,
0.0562403053,
-0.0072013568,
0.0468409956,
0.00304506,
-0.0226812046,
-0.001181115,
0.0121432953,
-0.0255273525,
-0.0081693223,
0.0573790967,
-0.001401764,
-0.0291627161,
-0.0583428182,
0.0379880667,
0.0227270052,
0.0085721267,
0.0064800181,
0.0326116979,
-0.0192193724,
-0.033440385,
0.0349810384,
-0.0178397503,
0.0203671269,
-0.040852949,
-0.0334200487,
0.0185995996,
0.028814001,
0.0276518855,
0.0183761027,
-0.0100362692,
0.0201913603,
0.0399455018,
0.0453159362,
0.0692640319,
0.0211389717,
0.0047061965,
0.0434929729,
-0.0013616816,
-0.0133648431,
-0.0704072863,
0.0133527182,
-0.0122387279,
0.0705556199,
0.0797142014,
0.0336510763,
0.0056002196,
0.025337385,
-0.0386819504,
0.0395853892,
0.0112836892,
0.0431346968,
0.0237138905,
0.0218698774,
-0.010358531,
-0.0154114896,
-0.0413933471,
-0.0158452485,
-0.0391972438,
-0.0360381752,
0.0223321095,
-0.0301168188,
-0.0289673042,
-0.0383192562,
-0.0030356145,
-0.0297869761,
-0.0226994436,
0.0639556423,
-0.0034240161,
-0.0039618802,
0.0043988288,
-0.0187465288,
0.0038463587,
0.0331969075,
-0.0176767372,
0.0003481093,
0.0239194501,
0.0483567007,
-0.0290958006,
0.0198369529,
-0.020916963,
-0.0031672148,
-0.065247938,
-0.0200210754,
-0.0338906869,
-0.0286849197,
0.0263783019,
0.0168073289,
-0.0179117415,
0.0403097011,
0.0103051933,
0.0099105313,
0.0004097087,
0.0019327754,
-0.0278192349,
0.0042047207,
-0.0116450191,
-0.0129593359,
-0.0148879066,
0.0474585928,
0.0573435761,
-0.0614406988,
-0.015141746,
0.020168731,
2.722e-7,
0.0528022945,
0.0246544722,
0.048104912,
0.0240864698,
0.0077261343,
0.0026631709,
-0.0236137584,
-0.055243481,
0.0331885554,
-0.0522670969,
-0.0150765032,
0.0518280976,
0.0565938391,
0.0404093936,
-0.0393193029,
-0.0350993089,
-0.063004382,
-0.0410992093,
-0.0485175848,
0.0131307421,
0.0472192951,
0.0366833769,
-0.0003102595,
0.0083386786,
-0.0264343936,
-0.0690312386,
0.0236125775,
-0.049888514,
0.0203539561,
0.0083144438,
0.0370460674,
-0.0038295593,
0.0226599574,
-0.0666743964,
-0.0279388092,
-0.0061448626,
-0.0491521582,
0.0364394225,
0.0021474543,
-0.0251336787,
-0.0427086689,
-0.0494656414,
0.0174946673,
-0.0522710457,
0.0490505546,
0.0445464365,
0.0001850669,
-0.0206026807,
0.0029463463,
-0.0661258325,
-0.0180560593,
-0.0218835678,
0.0041142236,
0.0235847998,
-0.0219604149,
-0.0187828671,
-0.0038204528,
-0.0621380545,
-0.0732034668,
0.0076319524,
-0.0460135154,
0.0095223011,
-0.039043799,
-0.0006267662,
0.0128520364,
-0.0180699136,
0.0069923154,
2.522336289e-34,
0.0195510872,
0.0140357139,
0.0117163043,
0.0651766881,
0.0586929545,
0.0317057297,
0.0013376611,
0.0320294425,
0.0433929712,
-0.0931022838,
-0.0201499462
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07052v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07052v1
|
Length-Aware Multi-Kernel Transformer for Long Document Classification
| 2024-05-11T16:48:06 | 2024-05-11T16:48:06 |
Guangzeng Han, Jack Tsao, Xiaolei Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Lengthy documents pose a unique challenge to neural language models due to
substantial memory consumption. While existing state-of-the-art (SOTA) models
segment long texts into equal-length snippets (e.g., 128 tokens per snippet) or
deploy sparse attention networks, these methods have new challenges of context
fragmentation and generalizability due to sentence boundaries and varying text
lengths. For example, our empirical analysis has shown that SOTA models
consistently overfit one set of lengthy documents (e.g., 2000 tokens) while
performing worse on texts with other lengths (e.g., 1000 or 4000). In this
study, we propose a Length-Aware Multi-Kernel Transformer (LAMKIT) to address
the new challenges for the long document classification. LAMKIT encodes lengthy
documents by diverse transformer-based kernels for bridging context boundaries
and vectorizes text length by the kernels to promote model robustness over
varying document lengths. Experiments on five standard benchmarks from health
and law domains show LAMKIT outperforms SOTA models up to an absolute 10.9%
improvement. We conduct extensive ablation analyses to examine model robustness
and effectiveness over varying document lengths.
|
Length-Aware Multi-Kernel Transformer for Long Document Classification: Lengthy documents pose a unique challenge to neural language models due to
substantial memory consumption. While existing state-of-the-art (SOTA) models
segment long texts into equal-length snippets (e.g., 128 tokens per snippet) or
deploy sparse attention networks, these methods have new challenges of context
fragmentation and generalizability due to sentence boundaries and varying text
lengths. For example, our empirical analysis has shown that SOTA models
consistently overfit one set of lengthy documents (e.g., 2000 tokens) while
performing worse on texts with other lengths (e.g., 1000 or 4000). In this
study, we propose a Length-Aware Multi-Kernel Transformer (LAMKIT) to address
the new challenges for the long document classification. LAMKIT encodes lengthy
documents by diverse transformer-based kernels for bridging context boundaries
and vectorizes text length by the kernels to promote model robustness over
varying document lengths. Experiments on five standard benchmarks from health
and law domains show LAMKIT outperforms SOTA models up to an absolute 10.9%
improvement. We conduct extensive ablation analyses to examine model robustness
and effectiveness over varying document lengths.
|
[
0.0329317003,
0.0410529114,
0.0182793811,
0.0305690393,
-0.0266402215,
-0.0319581032,
0.0244407132,
0.0221007857,
-0.0276471954,
-0.0565293133,
-0.019334428,
-0.0167033281,
0.0264327675,
0.0133691924,
0.02597888,
-0.04116055,
0.0075855083,
-0.0107763736,
-0.0014964755,
0.0308468007,
0.0092749773,
0.0072784522,
0.0353171974,
0.0313776731,
-0.0456099547,
-0.0057987622,
-0.0080275666,
0.0036533338,
0.0088998023,
-0.0218624659,
0.0601995289,
0.0313730724,
0.005429572,
0.0366875231,
0.0000017796,
-0.0273618791,
-0.0185996946,
0.0250796862,
-0.0056787762,
0.0304238051,
0.0751246437,
-0.0886433795,
0.0142924339,
-0.0024701336,
0.0122289164,
0.0129873864,
0.0283596832,
0.1021896079,
0.0219159499,
0.0877942517,
-0.0263543539,
-0.0549323596,
0.057559099,
-0.0569772944,
0.0269309543,
-0.0362010226,
0.0324446671,
-0.0351509638,
0.0306758825,
0.0134641593,
-0.0544534475,
0.051695507,
0.0518307351,
-0.0037519685,
0.0216295626,
0.0280614439,
-0.0676858723,
-0.004861278,
0.0228052754,
0.076331459,
-0.04856731,
-0.0009153059,
0.0238570422,
-0.0053674467,
0.0361413136,
-0.0323728025,
-0.0193855166,
-0.0056668608,
0.0050791726,
0.0092630051,
-0.0086252438,
0.0486637652,
0.0303963162,
-0.0003066196,
-0.0563878715,
-0.0009753112,
-0.022556603,
-0.0454465933,
-0.0011843655,
-0.0185208768,
-0.0304252561,
0.0120476037,
0.0104583241,
0.0287659261,
0.0362538919,
0.0135475257,
-0.0638979822,
-0.0503331646,
0.0526809841,
-0.0751440525,
-0.0290782023,
0.0031923729,
-0.0351193026,
0.0214884076,
-0.037498951,
-0.0107386848,
-0.030679578,
0.0321392342,
-0.0305332914,
-0.0135351894,
-0.0485863127,
0.0111741191,
-0.035466589,
0.0100920592,
-0.0119139291,
-0.0241681989,
-0.0507210717,
0.0280997474,
0.0177768543,
-0.0048854295,
-0.0071574803,
0.0127592459,
0.0067617055,
-0.0009663698,
0.0109491115,
0.041672647,
-0.0057893675,
0.0015074399,
-0.0052303872,
-0.0068645892,
-0.0252766609,
0.0631321296,
0.0039458671,
-0.048273284,
0.0183689464,
0.0222555734,
-0.0175474472,
-0.0780284926,
-0.0039668586,
-0.0079006534,
-0.0886746496,
-0.0521865077,
-0.0106441528,
-0.0876245275,
0.0233427584,
0.001082659,
-0.0043671858,
-0.0424277671,
0.0072051105,
0.013769364,
-0.0545103289,
0.0480432026,
0.0685262531,
-0.0179829895,
0.0599810332,
0.0305625238,
0.0451665781,
0.0458362401,
0.0224991366,
0.0080417469,
0.0304056071,
-0.012085123,
0.0006347481,
0.0183911957,
0.0367092974,
-0.0282754749,
0.0009963269,
0.0049048718,
0.0041123661,
0.0340248235,
0.0208906103,
0.0689537376,
0.0009040676,
-0.0750682801,
0.033778213,
0.0746546239,
0.0039022204,
0.0245674066,
0.0047486275,
0.0258672368,
-0.0260473546,
0.0024202701,
-0.0263053793,
-0.0023584906,
0.0241111834,
0.0099729188,
0.0261092652,
0.0155572193,
-0.0319982208,
-0.0423210748,
-0.0258874465,
-0.0335146636,
0.0105808247,
-0.0034192919,
0.0812317729,
-0.0085137794,
-0.0303935315,
0.1016076505,
-0.0134389428,
-0.0411819853,
-0.0114612188,
-0.0204950403,
-0.0141578829,
0.0307925269,
0.0269093644,
-0.0585603006,
-0.0108674048,
-0.0464092083,
0.0285164397,
0.0111634741,
0.0392212272,
0.009333076,
0.0175985023,
-0.0671842694,
0.0173389819,
-0.0164270177,
0.0186598822,
-0.0401402265,
0.0301384013,
0.0628888384,
0.0681581274,
-0.0259541869,
-0.0033921381,
0.0261409227,
0.0093112718,
-0.0154262539,
-0.0153101534,
0.0036791894,
0.0195614249,
-0.0065167062,
-0.0060551646,
0.0138244983,
0.0252012368,
-0.0582120456,
-0.0107797319,
-0.0330453105,
-0.0510811321,
-0.0217367001,
0.0087857246,
-0.0120073892,
-0.0093695587,
0.0164659172,
-0.0526286773,
-0.0263864268,
-0.0018470864,
-0.0428866297,
0.0021234988,
-0.0030562535,
0.0069751493,
0.0087797698,
0.062911205,
-0.0347112939,
0.00584062,
-0.0045472356,
0.0110285077,
-0.0415501036,
-0.0287945829,
0.0301869567,
-0.0325398482,
-0.0526276566,
0.0171139054,
-0.0350721367,
0.0279171821,
0.0078375181,
-0.0137687335,
-0.0108134402,
-0.058590766,
-0.0920273438,
-0.0117571289,
-0.0263066441,
0.0076243356,
-0.034026172,
0.0166251156,
0.0138982544,
-0.0173232183,
-0.0379779115,
-0.0187892169,
0.008502515,
-0.004428497,
0.0124065857,
-0.0116050262,
-0.0033125344,
-0.0279071983,
-0.0606199279,
-0.0024791448,
0.082130298,
-0.0325772464,
-0.0507988818,
-0.0305041056,
0.003056844,
0.0126901781,
0.001554366,
-0.0286596287,
-0.0242052041,
-0.0277551301,
-0.0101019461,
0.0597860105,
0.0766398087,
0.0515825003,
0.0435749851,
0.0208411608,
0.0359889716,
-0.0073385993,
0.0263231192,
-0.0209593866,
0.0109025231,
-0.0459032878,
-0.0120211896,
0.0111500174,
0.0730685219,
-0.0134057049,
-0.0065826303,
-0.0464418903,
-0.0458108559,
-0.0059554102,
0.019047657,
-0.0241184346,
0.0183582772,
-0.0103613995,
-0.0107044112,
-0.0055165566,
-0.0392812975,
0.0633810833,
-0.0168297812,
0.0042728456,
-0.0241608843,
-0.0250426456,
-0.0576463975,
0.0653988495,
0.0178430155,
-0.0113086039,
0.0211865995,
0.0122663109,
-0.0269715562,
-0.013806398,
-0.0491654314,
-0.0282847583,
0.0957366154,
0.0137168951,
0.0210327022,
-0.0447236933,
-0.0306456555,
-0.0148899835,
-0.066793777,
0.002598081,
0.0105425008,
-0.0063218079,
-0.0010041002,
-0.0685786158,
0.0327240452,
0.0175271295,
0.0922518894,
-0.0045044678,
0.0143042374,
0.0128397625,
0.0622053891,
0.0364288501,
-0.0063661933,
-0.0137404352,
-0.0345233679,
0.0249385219,
0.0517915934,
0.0023341428,
0.0132859135,
-0.0068459664,
-0.0491700396,
-0.0014016139,
-0.0211026892,
-0.0402291715,
-0.0027339631,
0.039664302,
-0.087372534,
-0.0064718616,
0.0985610113,
0.0144072426,
-0.0486529507,
0.0191506818,
0.0135029042,
0.0436347052,
-0.0063938019,
0.0192605127,
-0.0531804338,
-0.0281260498,
-0.0258835442,
0.018164169,
0.020560246,
0.0004354057,
0.0119504258,
-0.0304391999,
0.0134265628,
0.0186511651,
-0.0561383478,
-0.0189425442,
-0.0327127427,
-0.0248061698,
0.000254106,
-0.0175898783,
-0.0324256681,
-0.0071923044,
-0.036461696,
0.0141852396,
-0.0473755412,
-0.0383798704,
0.0073350267,
0.0062046521,
0.0276259296,
-0.0033414122,
0.0183247048,
-0.0248151682,
-0.0524631105,
0.0400211029,
-0.046791587,
-0.0095323138,
0.027949661,
0.069381915,
-0.0255526993,
0.0030663507,
0.0219898541,
0.0254568178,
-0.0414660536,
-0.0195876546,
-0.0055114762,
0.085010305,
-0.0060793064,
-0.0315680504,
-0.0468935855,
-0.025663184,
-0.0193705969,
0.0771590248,
0.0240867939,
-0.0456098616,
-0.0669914111,
0.009134274,
-0.0352273993,
-0.0419564173,
0.0031788405,
0.0150441993,
-0.0317811482,
-0.0233993847,
-0.0358577222,
-0.0406031832,
-0.0024306388,
-0.0019398431,
-0.0349647179,
-0.0004456149,
-0.0034648797,
0.0086986376,
-0.0868066102,
0.0602171496,
0.007394061,
0.0129648484,
-0.0670870692,
0.0280775763,
0.0399261154,
0.001861329,
-0.0111627914,
0.0309656616,
-0.0907997265,
-0.0463983677,
0.0012125965,
0.0033670976,
0.0076560876,
0.0311515685,
-0.0006269462,
-0.0224960223,
0.1024197936,
0.0417629778,
-0.027415758,
0.0167434458,
0.0402127691,
-0.021296395,
-0.0154450694,
0.0363145545,
-0.0264083724,
0.0472519137,
0.0067215171,
-0.0191057175,
-0.0014067496,
-0.0308607034,
-0.074696742,
-0.0272263605,
-0.0123208417,
0.0074999151,
0.0256346241,
-0.002031913,
0.0375396572,
0.023791004,
0.0128932036,
-0.0117616933,
0.00536924,
0.046972286,
0.0028500573,
-0.015206987,
0.0500398166,
0.0093135713,
0.0098248301,
-0.0216195341,
0.0307589248,
0.0000368027,
-0.0131881228,
0.0364932045,
0.0091472436,
-0.0237460211,
-0.0348924249,
-0.0106579345,
0.0093485434,
-0.0233866088,
0.0441016965,
-0.0025886991,
0.0335864797,
-0.0384252109,
0.03768095,
-0.0749470592,
0.0276664142,
-0.0294899791,
-0.0035410025,
0.0085997768,
-0.0372941084,
0.0358817205,
-0.0050204955,
-0.01826993,
-0.0318436772,
0.0509264469,
0.0000929925,
0.0133725414,
0.0110049229,
0.0268214829,
-0.0171908271,
0.0066341134,
0.0739634261,
0.0461324938,
0.0136165665,
0.0317501016,
-0.0192878041,
-0.0429883786,
-0.0154318232,
0.000720594,
0.0233666878,
-0.0160036273,
-0.0043680775,
-0.0151897417,
-0.0496793874,
0.0769222528,
-0.0500726923,
-0.0017233486,
0.0034306061,
0.0169979241,
0.0485364683,
0.0257805418,
-0.0072232713,
-0.0222979803,
0.0111193256,
0.0128289359,
-0.0486595705,
0.0010833507,
-5.677129681e-33,
0.0360309295,
-0.0163365845,
-0.0110648964,
0.0258784331,
-0.0405051634,
0.0348913483,
-0.0156165911,
-0.0161060989,
-0.0064793923,
-0.0005536156,
-0.0099904127,
0.0214537252,
-0.0012921412,
0.078478992,
0.0074703488,
-0.0164987147,
0.0677097887,
0.0043298346,
-0.0186814219,
0.0381444991,
0.0297051612,
0.0310504045,
0.0341451578,
-0.0284358468,
0.0341073014,
0.0217991043,
0.0363830961,
-0.0376503207,
0.0130792819,
0.0780992135,
-0.0317667946,
0.0683111325,
0.0601933934,
-0.0292957686,
-0.0024848892,
0.0737086385,
-0.1042641625,
0.0251095854,
-0.0307433177,
-0.0019612103,
-0.0012859646,
-0.0534694232,
0.0795863345,
-0.0122406865,
0.0234366264,
-0.0521103665,
0.0647692233,
-0.0206225477,
-0.0406747833,
-0.0411371216,
-0.047592137,
0.0520594642,
-0.0140323015,
-0.0070720203,
0.0354119726,
0.0282429047,
-0.0141180698,
0.0369881056,
-0.0561075956,
-0.0454264842,
-0.0416170731,
0.0308393426,
0.0229714531,
0.0138870198,
-0.032255929,
0.0190241095,
-0.0317164026,
0.032636378,
-0.0337613411,
-0.0439657792,
0.0302536003,
0.031472493,
0.0587073639,
0.0267355032,
0.0570535883,
-0.0634110868,
-0.07250496,
0.0006628219,
-0.0303410459,
0.0130580403,
0.0607987829,
0.0062697548,
-0.0205668136,
-0.0199428182,
-0.0029632181,
0.0020844685,
0.0007977476,
-0.0009628598,
0.0071070693,
0.0410116091,
0.0237129796,
0.0155201033,
0.044453878,
-0.0297431815,
0.0334531218,
0.0290377215,
0.0122941723,
0.0367682278,
0.00640751,
-0.0166863594,
-0.068564117,
0.000740647,
0.0239830539,
0.0036570178,
0.0086435592,
-0.0326145515,
0.1093672886,
0.0013093173,
-0.0683972165,
-0.0344391875,
-0.0066165687,
0.0168117676,
-0.0098580932,
0.0769928843,
0.0159092322,
0.0273484644,
-0.007880874,
0.0637660772,
0.0078044478,
-0.0061228732,
-0.0011551721,
-0.0205682665,
0.0177525636,
0.0123617752,
-0.0310508907,
0.0004673509,
-0.01237542,
0.0319898501,
0.0192587264,
-0.0793797821,
0.0211574305,
0.0069579128,
2.501e-7,
0.0643973053,
0.0208592229,
0.0248835571,
-0.0791400671,
0.0420536995,
0.0058954544,
0.0514028817,
0.0641256645,
-0.0751176625,
0.0008019384,
-0.0022586077,
0.0079497499,
0.0706026778,
-0.0005740377,
-0.0902432352,
-0.025380183,
-0.0808958933,
0.0083156461,
-0.0380552188,
0.008183633,
0.0718033835,
0.1076775268,
0.0001055169,
-0.0223045964,
0.0086051002,
-0.0318832211,
0.0588847846,
-0.0125736399,
0.0183066819,
0.0081410306,
0.0327816829,
-0.0033704438,
0.0097936084,
-0.012648914,
-0.010470516,
0.0327810608,
0.002441969,
0.0955128744,
0.0053186752,
-0.0435721613,
0.0175175145,
0.0089572361,
-0.0243311785,
-0.0555924997,
0.0617853217,
-0.0571735092,
-0.0298635736,
-0.0298330877,
0.0271760151,
-0.0090754107,
0.0499202646,
0.0082691554,
0.0154738678,
0.0318230726,
0.0290025044,
-0.0525388494,
0.0149021624,
-0.119800292,
-0.035445556,
0.0315235145,
-0.0464101173,
0.0005979458,
-0.0681896284,
-0.0297773201,
0.0443642139,
-0.0526508726,
-0.0178174097,
2.269133198e-34,
0.0425870493,
-0.0198167954,
-0.037212126,
0.0017874097,
0.006875155,
-0.0254294742,
-0.0010217548,
0.0151193505,
0.0114475517,
-0.0849036947,
-0.0123060541
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07035v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07035v2
|
A Turkish Educational Crossword Puzzle Generator
| 2024-05-11T15:18:56 | 2024-05-15T12:23:39 |
Kamyar Zeinalipour, Yusuf Gökberk Keptiğ, Marco Maggini, Leonardo Rigutini, Marco Gori
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper introduces the first Turkish crossword puzzle generator designed
to leverage the capabilities of large language models (LLMs) for educational
purposes. In this work, we introduced two specially created datasets: one with
over 180,000 unique answer-clue pairs for generating relevant clues from the
given answer, and another with over 35,000 samples containing text, answer,
category, and clue data, aimed at producing clues for specific texts and
keywords within certain categories. Beyond entertainment, this generator
emerges as an interactive educational tool that enhances memory, vocabulary,
and problem-solving skills. It's a notable step in AI-enhanced education,
merging game-like engagement with learning for Turkish and setting new
standards for interactive, intelligent learning tools in Turkish.
|
A Turkish Educational Crossword Puzzle Generator: This paper introduces the first Turkish crossword puzzle generator designed
to leverage the capabilities of large language models (LLMs) for educational
purposes. In this work, we introduced two specially created datasets: one with
over 180,000 unique answer-clue pairs for generating relevant clues from the
given answer, and another with over 35,000 samples containing text, answer,
category, and clue data, aimed at producing clues for specific texts and
keywords within certain categories. Beyond entertainment, this generator
emerges as an interactive educational tool that enhances memory, vocabulary,
and problem-solving skills. It's a notable step in AI-enhanced education,
merging game-like engagement with learning for Turkish and setting new
standards for interactive, intelligent learning tools in Turkish.
|
[
0.023240488,
-0.01291114,
-0.0521737821,
0.0232593715,
-0.0481315851,
0.0136347981,
0.0391661599,
-0.00392055,
0.0128015168,
0.0137760565,
-0.0085525308,
0.0158981625,
-0.005346972,
0.0076573961,
0.0053908275,
-0.0513014644,
0.0320768356,
-0.0653085858,
0.0044952873,
-0.0076619773,
-0.0399337001,
0.0325243808,
-0.0568440557,
0.024760155,
-0.019651195,
-0.0094186701,
-0.0434502773,
-0.0447132736,
-0.023927452,
-0.0522421598,
-0.0025273212,
0.01561548,
-0.0060154009,
0.0440045483,
0.0000019257,
-0.0384667888,
-0.0162079856,
-0.0427322648,
-0.0049819965,
-0.0153969238,
0.0197550319,
0.0280436799,
-0.029535355,
-0.0108409105,
-0.0553208031,
-0.0079595922,
0.0549360365,
0.0108229108,
0.0547142886,
0.0403897241,
0.0132811675,
-0.0297433343,
0.0548171438,
0.0166614652,
0.100396581,
-0.0633682534,
-0.006724101,
0.0119558983,
0.0228484925,
0.0378539041,
-0.0146495942,
0.0507766455,
-0.0109747257,
-0.0120496424,
-0.0401798449,
0.0119372196,
0.0127563104,
-0.0353048667,
0.0083742067,
0.040276859,
0.0036378505,
-0.016985666,
0.0213015825,
0.019605007,
0.0158909801,
0.0856948942,
-0.083439067,
0.042397052,
-0.0257745236,
-0.0127528077,
0.0828190595,
0.003607678,
-0.0086108213,
0.0398282371,
0.0031968399,
0.0614659078,
0.0379662812,
-0.0305118058,
-0.0430915281,
0.000678016,
0.0165326875,
-0.0474765673,
0.0083379028,
0.0627828762,
-0.0565528572,
0.0394072533,
-0.047289677,
-0.052272182,
0.0151702007,
-0.035559848,
0.0528391898,
0.0008107371,
0.0265673399,
0.0511010736,
-0.0002607877,
0.0309281871,
0.0306283347,
-0.0176009554,
-0.0451132953,
-0.0021133621,
-0.0170260407,
-0.0192450993,
-0.0425333567,
0.0496096127,
-0.0390967727,
0.0053157285,
-0.0434644371,
0.0175659526,
0.0199134238,
0.056304317,
0.028086327,
-0.0026296899,
-0.0248038769,
-0.0151318917,
-0.0269162823,
-0.0157525577,
-0.0531847253,
-0.0129791638,
-0.0141349025,
-0.0219087396,
0.0326612145,
-0.024539575,
0.0240972489,
-0.0270576291,
0.0540576912,
0.0359578915,
-0.0189619493,
-0.0375686176,
-0.0209624227,
-0.0124719329,
-0.0081919273,
-0.0526539758,
0.0096565429,
-0.0835235864,
0.0424868353,
-0.0167803373,
0.0081216944,
-0.0255603623,
0.0266307835,
0.0626513362,
0.0150193833,
0.0857117847,
-0.0042946963,
0.0239659864,
0.0614248663,
-0.0105180843,
0.0643144622,
0.0745572224,
0.0579215027,
0.0154120494,
0.0671925545,
-0.037329074,
0.0157334171,
0.0418930314,
0.0167427845,
-0.0307719093,
0.0096823871,
-0.0162538774,
0.0385765769,
0.0549479015,
-0.0713366866,
0.0239646751,
0.0249359179,
0.044736553,
0.0527565032,
0.0763283372,
0.0096092913,
0.0552625172,
0.0243878309,
-0.0105721783,
0.0157259684,
0.0061953943,
0.0101375878,
0.0348886698,
-0.0023804409,
0.0209065359,
-0.005357672,
0.0568562038,
-0.000979756,
-0.0656235814,
-0.0003211631,
0.0007404044,
0.0383810103,
0.0170139056,
0.1142828465,
-0.0244462118,
-0.0299789179,
0.0126879457,
0.0322384983,
-0.061709512,
0.0328802913,
-0.0681124181,
0.0709594786,
0.074390471,
0.0741858482,
-0.0552438088,
-0.0253541376,
0.0151548404,
0.0510405563,
0.0483378619,
0.014216979,
-0.0353479721,
-0.0361609869,
-0.0433376841,
-0.0061877845,
0.0063707149,
0.0062942039,
0.0025644626,
0.0493224598,
0.0518167913,
-0.0062583215,
-0.0179154854,
0.0246323273,
0.0222568754,
-0.0675503314,
-0.0501535721,
-0.0258586686,
0.0183467381,
-0.0277424138,
0.062491063,
0.0046725399,
0.007388649,
0.0587436855,
-0.0208404232,
0.0254258849,
-0.0384760611,
-0.0331604928,
0.0332666524,
0.070644021,
-0.0590413921,
0.0160451997,
0.0369389281,
0.0257827658,
-0.0266072359,
0.0563019216,
-0.013247909,
0.0659569651,
-0.005584124,
0.0425257161,
0.0009048151,
-0.0133890193,
-0.0394286104,
0.0539061725,
0.0191544406,
0.0338640809,
-0.0475133285,
-0.0263811164,
0.0036260884,
-0.0299235918,
0.0147692189,
0.0665249377,
-0.0246744324,
0.0010367536,
0.0017819074,
0.008909652,
-0.0576049909,
-0.0345482938,
-0.0709474608,
0.0086755631,
0.0199903529,
0.0100436183,
-0.0025768217,
0.0248007905,
-0.0370759405,
0.0214484762,
-0.0211367477,
-0.018671602,
0.0598887801,
-0.0169087071,
-0.0014287292,
-0.0020666739,
-0.000466636,
-0.0075628394,
-0.0288485009,
-0.0085509447,
0.0184111614,
0.0268801171,
-0.0258775707,
-0.0205303915,
0.0479791388,
-0.0119942715,
0.004275837,
-0.0020420332,
-0.0317878462,
0.032169167,
-0.0280520748,
0.0434860103,
0.0417730175,
0.0133742783,
-0.0001659511,
0.0444542319,
-0.1137967035,
-0.0534072518,
0.0156999435,
-0.0122250868,
-0.0439591259,
-0.0146733709,
-0.0569946803,
-0.0174348336,
0.0277928356,
0.0044988557,
-0.0044684382,
-0.0478365123,
0.02541079,
-0.0171304755,
-0.0158184003,
-0.0641759038,
-0.0084457705,
-0.0146165891,
0.0235593822,
-0.0048730648,
0.0123369852,
0.0330677219,
-0.0319848321,
0.0267013051,
-0.0561541542,
0.0085941963,
-0.0314422958,
0.0404560156,
-0.0555968732,
0.0037578116,
-0.0017668732,
0.0113996761,
-0.0524106249,
-0.0029964698,
0.0520105995,
-0.0728560984,
0.0157190599,
-0.0603296757,
-0.025793815,
-0.0017184333,
0.0088352859,
-0.0330108441,
0.0135414861,
-0.0143320672,
-0.0550499149,
0.0721648112,
-0.0001942583,
-0.0311306827,
-0.0068838359,
0.0454829857,
-0.0431817621,
-0.0121152028,
-0.0009934556,
0.0120671112,
0.0393396243,
0.0700008273,
0.0013378719,
-0.0274106953,
-0.0100649353,
0.0304073542,
0.0561012067,
0.0117828995,
-0.0369647592,
0.0175432377,
0.0284178201,
0.0494042262,
-0.0433501378,
-0.0102939578,
-0.0090521881,
-0.0118654929,
-0.045454625,
-0.0306085311,
0.0788360164,
0.0450463817,
-0.020905599,
-0.0231207609,
-0.0082087629,
-0.0149409929,
-0.0025205393,
0.0419308357,
-0.0429224484,
0.0125585897,
0.0171883199,
-0.0028990442,
-0.0102090156,
-0.0214975793,
0.0111490358,
-0.1295107454,
0.0009396743,
0.0243595261,
-0.04815083,
-0.0448735878,
-0.055485066,
-0.0339414887,
0.0011208353,
-0.0634850934,
-0.0097177876,
-0.0194362961,
0.0435396247,
0.0108439494,
0.0098011829,
-0.031143764,
-0.0196808651,
-0.0293115042,
0.0523320436,
0.0532800071,
0.0389039591,
-0.0305034313,
-0.0635265931,
0.0032837798,
0.0072687208,
-0.0302953403,
-0.0311042219,
0.0120255006,
-0.0206336398,
-0.0288141351,
-0.0492516793,
-0.0064605922,
-0.023754105,
-0.0255993493,
0.0591546781,
0.0656922087,
0.0204835162,
0.0360563584,
-0.0082384888,
-0.0062346742,
0.0318158045,
0.0306172092,
-0.0254406147,
-0.0340031125,
0.0265390426,
-0.0206453763,
-0.017049659,
-0.0558276586,
-0.0474476926,
0.0110394303,
-0.0142778968,
0.017709244,
-0.0559173301,
-0.0300794076,
0.0413704924,
0.0285501461,
-0.0083981864,
0.0433892459,
-0.058140818,
0.0428150967,
-0.0365072414,
-0.0378802828,
-0.0209551919,
0.0104826922,
-0.0512974374,
-0.0685401037,
0.0042473017,
-0.0751693174,
0.0151549336,
0.0481291153,
-0.0614147224,
-0.0092635183,
0.051863268,
0.0415691584,
0.0151885236,
0.003447253,
0.0636738986,
-0.0036806152,
0.0490947179,
-0.0051638046,
-0.0523330308,
0.0093773622,
-0.0613892153,
0.0082942601,
0.0159569941,
-0.0148372641,
-0.0206092149,
-0.0168094933,
0.0370623916,
0.0324320011,
-0.0322551467,
-0.0136013431,
0.0189614631,
0.0257807374,
0.0068653631,
-0.0475984737,
-0.0128017124,
-0.026775891,
0.0227504335,
-0.0403471589,
-0.0313393809,
0.0011965593,
-0.0176063422,
0.0223766491,
-0.0462307483,
0.0252559744,
0.0388059355,
0.0145937921,
-0.0327258185,
-0.0687562153,
0.0386493914,
0.0034914215,
0.02052355,
-0.0045151589,
0.0205485914,
0.0133043248,
0.0695574731,
-0.0221737307,
0.0509297661,
-0.0079581467,
0.0156622138,
-0.0189355947,
-0.0441014394,
0.0127346721,
0.0529414602,
-0.0078089135,
-0.0198094081,
-0.0198724288,
0.050134901,
0.0905735865,
-0.0014755351,
-0.0146070775,
-0.0215652566,
-0.003839612,
0.0079090083,
-0.0159552563,
0.0266017802,
-0.0310533959,
0.0007041173,
0.0040075672,
0.0292890407,
-0.0291224886,
0.0598377921,
0.0114515321,
0.0345280133,
0.0360547304,
-0.0240226109,
-0.0358702578,
-0.0027492049,
0.0255664047,
0.0464945287,
-0.0386556871,
-0.0116665633,
-0.0393616743,
-0.0580399632,
0.0126137724,
0.0719425306,
0.01143042,
0.0079182852,
0.0384154767,
0.0685185418,
0.0081918472,
0.0228086617,
-0.0379177444,
0.0713500977,
-0.0514350906,
-0.0599338003,
-0.0197998453,
-5.434178508e-33,
-0.0456996746,
-0.035216555,
0.0545536093,
0.0198480953,
0.0029378382,
-0.0343555212,
-0.0029721414,
0.0439305268,
0.0117444918,
-0.0150015233,
-0.0459134802,
0.0015713866,
0.0059536546,
0.0125898374,
0.014363369,
-0.027971141,
0.0054968558,
-0.0171529725,
-0.0042710165,
0.0097674383,
0.0467831679,
-0.0009591207,
0.060057126,
-0.0566825382,
0.0033212604,
-0.0143588167,
-0.0086150104,
-0.0180282556,
-0.0257013217,
0.0613160878,
-0.0185809713,
0.0425224304,
0.0023251504,
-0.0155954203,
0.007191591,
0.0197559576,
-0.0568550043,
-0.0283681862,
0.0077935881,
0.0240987372,
-0.0016786981,
-0.0706969127,
-0.0126232067,
-0.0212930888,
-0.0362924039,
0.0292561091,
0.0490169749,
-0.0465499088,
-0.0102152908,
0.0016553416,
-0.0375313126,
0.0049785916,
-0.0301593542,
-0.0429426394,
0.0409516506,
-0.0055479212,
0.0364396088,
-0.0453460366,
0.0025912216,
0.1122099385,
0.0487242527,
0.0233774986,
0.1002747491,
-0.0081781913,
-0.0114444075,
0.0335261077,
0.0260852147,
-0.0424323753,
-0.0200570263,
0.0129043302,
0.0365100279,
0.0156955924,
0.0604913719,
0.0781371295,
-0.0025918523,
-0.0421239287,
-0.0541770868,
0.0759908408,
0.0232399367,
0.0328993835,
0.0024812808,
-0.0142410276,
-0.0500954129,
-0.0112776933,
-0.0261664521,
0.0240857974,
-0.0218702853,
-0.032786414,
0.0234891307,
-0.0235949643,
-0.0320867635,
-0.0461590588,
-0.0110875145,
-0.0006096599,
0.0067884452,
0.0087248534,
0.0667902976,
0.0025588342,
-0.0424774662,
-0.0420728996,
0.0060632126,
-0.0406209268,
-0.0057536806,
-0.0251935534,
0.0055848607,
0.0133601362,
-0.0524118952,
0.0204467699,
-0.0494774543,
0.0182076525,
-0.0231828131,
0.0114638181,
0.057377845,
-0.0373939425,
0.0435498692,
-0.0527954921,
-0.0131472703,
-0.0257756468,
0.0568675511,
-0.0349419937,
-0.003877152,
-0.0379127227,
-0.0221274868,
-0.0233521182,
0.0045136563,
0.0297639687,
-0.0802563056,
-0.0006655882,
0.0084173698,
-0.0194453932,
0.0188941695,
-0.0128877824,
2.656e-7,
0.0052523506,
0.064247705,
-0.0025253687,
0.0487160012,
0.0043027187,
-0.0067280522,
-0.0093771694,
-0.0268846136,
-0.0064176912,
0.0240521561,
0.0195363723,
0.023542162,
0.0412159264,
0.0518240817,
-0.0831685513,
-0.0227568895,
0.0258667488,
0.0308680758,
-0.0708135962,
0.0445615351,
0.0497980379,
0.0277179256,
0.0221356302,
-0.0138863856,
-0.0410962813,
-0.0158517454,
-0.0017877949,
-0.0496678278,
-0.0382286981,
0.0084296716,
-0.0599958487,
0.0184914172,
-0.0128207933,
-0.0010216304,
-0.0340274051,
0.0197852608,
0.0485213138,
0.0195865035,
0.0099366466,
0.01214692,
0.0027356315,
-0.0202266015,
-0.0159993488,
-0.0659550056,
0.0897957161,
0.0393374078,
0.0169752557,
-0.0285440944,
-0.0128872152,
-0.0425626971,
-0.0112490095,
-0.0454660617,
-0.0332648233,
0.00773104,
0.0068711075,
0.0193262752,
0.0122892112,
-0.0270768926,
-0.0086740684,
-0.0197328813,
-0.0376843847,
-0.0411784314,
-0.0644671917,
-0.0166344084,
-0.0503883474,
0.0128193013,
-0.0036428021,
2.075172957e-34,
-0.0391882807,
0.0031966099,
0.0083739534,
-0.0074332226,
0.0142195085,
-0.0093238186,
0.0097841481,
0.0332973413,
0.0268702004,
-0.0758545101,
-0.0157348067
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08017v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08017v1
|
Translating Expert Intuition into Quantifiable Features: Encode Investigator Domain Knowledge via LLM for Enhanced Predictive Analytics
| 2024-05-11T13:23:43 | 2024-05-11T13:23:43 |
Phoebe Jing, Yijing Gao, Yuanhang Zhang, Xianlong Zeng
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In the realm of predictive analytics, the nuanced domain knowledge of
investigators often remains underutilized, confined largely to subjective
interpretations and ad hoc decision-making. This paper explores the potential
of Large Language Models (LLMs) to bridge this gap by systematically converting
investigator-derived insights into quantifiable, actionable features that
enhance model performance. We present a framework that leverages LLMs' natural
language understanding capabilities to encode these red flags into a structured
feature set that can be readily integrated into existing predictive models.
Through a series of case studies, we demonstrate how this approach not only
preserves the critical human expertise within the investigative process but
also scales the impact of this knowledge across various prediction tasks. The
results indicate significant improvements in risk assessment and
decision-making accuracy, highlighting the value of blending human experiential
knowledge with advanced machine learning techniques. This study paves the way
for more sophisticated, knowledge-driven analytics in fields where expert
insight is paramount.
|
Translating Expert Intuition into Quantifiable Features: Encode Investigator Domain Knowledge via LLM for Enhanced Predictive Analytics: In the realm of predictive analytics, the nuanced domain knowledge of
investigators often remains underutilized, confined largely to subjective
interpretations and ad hoc decision-making. This paper explores the potential
of Large Language Models (LLMs) to bridge this gap by systematically converting
investigator-derived insights into quantifiable, actionable features that
enhance model performance. We present a framework that leverages LLMs' natural
language understanding capabilities to encode these red flags into a structured
feature set that can be readily integrated into existing predictive models.
Through a series of case studies, we demonstrate how this approach not only
preserves the critical human expertise within the investigative process but
also scales the impact of this knowledge across various prediction tasks. The
results indicate significant improvements in risk assessment and
decision-making accuracy, highlighting the value of blending human experiential
knowledge with advanced machine learning techniques. This study paves the way
for more sophisticated, knowledge-driven analytics in fields where expert
insight is paramount.
|
[
0.0298326425,
0.070593074,
-0.005118039,
0.0198313165,
-0.0297270995,
-0.004044388,
-0.0163410176,
-0.0057939743,
0.0234514549,
-0.0163599532,
0.0437100157,
0.0056526079,
-0.0190011282,
0.1072304472,
0.0135632576,
-0.002705748,
0.0089875236,
-0.0378992893,
0.0513179563,
0.0422962308,
-0.0078525338,
0.0226386841,
0.0029481172,
0.0511703715,
-0.0037850656,
0.0199119207,
0.0112331416,
-0.0291022193,
0.0127161453,
-0.0524689183,
0.014846093,
0.0240594316,
0.0369685963,
0.0258406643,
0.0000020074,
-0.0734682605,
-0.0512444563,
0.0226841364,
-0.0213526618,
-0.0088191889,
0.0273872409,
-0.0442559198,
0.0404420346,
0.0326428711,
-0.0365513228,
0.0156082511,
0.0170804746,
0.0093808789,
0.0286906417,
0.0100719547,
-0.0275061894,
-0.0092179431,
0.0207752809,
0.0100067845,
-0.0045358222,
-0.0376731753,
0.0196768641,
0.0259940848,
-0.0064071361,
0.0046155523,
0.0117854541,
0.0352703221,
0.0200603269,
-0.0010956293,
0.0172394961,
0.019294139,
0.0052043279,
-0.0119565539,
-0.0115531655,
0.0313355327,
-0.0067437803,
0.010470707,
-0.0045246747,
-0.025409691,
0.0013461423,
0.029197244,
-0.0196656268,
-0.0033914433,
-0.0257984214,
0.0148807811,
-0.0079011424,
0.0631848723,
0.0245550033,
0.029252734,
-0.0274620913,
0.0811260343,
-0.0434273183,
-0.0094129806,
0.0359172709,
0.0079092355,
0.021167513,
0.0009196298,
-0.006740971,
-0.0008181167,
-0.0316710211,
0.0248351526,
0.0470118299,
0.0156877637,
0.069594495,
-0.052417554,
0.0262566023,
0.0025149719,
0.0006714021,
0.0389017314,
-0.0202420466,
-0.0117393453,
0.0054672915,
-0.0207051542,
0.002141986,
-0.0165520515,
-0.070256941,
-0.0481475517,
0.0341710486,
0.002607828,
0.0080528883,
0.0345637314,
-0.014835014,
0.0033725179,
-0.0148884635,
0.0138586918,
-0.0329420939,
0.0359900109,
-0.006490557,
-0.0065446552,
-0.0679719448,
0.0046328576,
-0.0237206407,
0.068738915,
-0.0207028184,
-0.0294629112,
0.0101584187,
0.0052928352,
-0.0111877732,
0.0115662739,
-0.0006226731,
0.0710288212,
0.0276351515,
0.0084359897,
-0.0362379774,
-0.0792527944,
-0.0085105132,
-0.0226411056,
-0.0244287346,
-0.0354596823,
0.0184114445,
0.0336482748,
-0.0087453909,
-0.076355271,
-0.0021239349,
-0.0277858842,
-0.0191176236,
0.0665627718,
-0.0620949976,
0.0048273834,
0.0004974879,
0.024796458,
0.0022304934,
0.0515397489,
0.0224229936,
0.0341515914,
0.0068416265,
-0.004559617,
0.0182159822,
-0.0028164436,
0.0145868417,
-0.0267886203,
-0.0245375726,
0.0092937648,
-0.0201353021,
0.0047968854,
0.0087334067,
-0.0128619578,
0.0114396224,
-0.0091891363,
0.0523918308,
0.0483748056,
-0.0242854003,
0.0280247238,
0.031281665,
0.0229188614,
-0.0204491802,
-0.0692930222,
0.0034685046,
0.0009430164,
-0.035163492,
-0.0099353632,
-0.006817495,
0.0279459041,
-0.0025431763,
-0.0522018373,
-0.0210969914,
0.0256397035,
0.0096700387,
0.0037936626,
0.0361598954,
-0.0482556522,
-0.0051519647,
0.0222842824,
0.0228006467,
-0.003806615,
-0.0198131371,
-0.0539902374,
0.0078663463,
0.0898927674,
0.0408858806,
-0.0581678525,
-0.0105407918,
-0.0314047299,
-0.0143028237,
-0.0573522374,
0.0124687077,
0.0138783772,
-0.0023768125,
0.009459855,
-0.0574410707,
-0.0065173199,
0.0066065295,
0.0004391713,
0.0014153157,
0.0014986959,
-0.0158133581,
-0.0175445806,
-0.0754267871,
0.0429253392,
-0.0331892371,
-0.0109454598,
0.0043009156,
-0.0086229378,
0.0446827002,
-0.0039629559,
0.0123075182,
0.0330865569,
0.0361990668,
-0.0218125973,
-0.0605882294,
-0.0026676385,
0.0619062707,
0.0297671836,
0.0000260614,
-0.0277305618,
0.0140510956,
-0.0349457413,
-0.0480007865,
0.0324278884,
-0.0288789626,
-0.0146962469,
0.0129913734,
-0.0325288139,
-0.0216130409,
-0.0138136446,
0.0039518503,
-0.0159903262,
0.0408153981,
-0.0269984417,
-0.0360079333,
-0.013086468,
-0.0928248689,
0.0209109727,
0.0120144906,
0.0111809019,
-0.0175341479,
0.0017782216,
0.0238102097,
0.0329202227,
-0.0239091162,
-0.0309579279,
0.0198768806,
-0.0605741479,
-0.0159130469,
0.0023300028,
-0.0058069779,
-0.0194505863,
-0.0287906099,
-0.0309134461,
0.0055632391,
0.0087868208,
-0.0432011373,
-0.0042971266,
0.0043599,
0.0497260094,
0.0213232096,
-0.0014089621,
0.0027331712,
-0.0088529224,
-0.0441355556,
0.0754977465,
0.0602884777,
-0.0274541304,
-0.0355808511,
0.0342078581,
-0.0421910249,
-0.0323689207,
-0.0226411577,
-0.012261508,
-0.0023767897,
0.0017664605,
-0.0473714434,
0.0286400411,
-0.0207425803,
0.064075388,
0.0479617827,
-0.0253437068,
-0.043371737,
-0.0018610185,
-0.0643189624,
-0.0130843744,
-0.0255087949,
-0.0217495523,
0.012921622,
0.0246739816,
0.0203139819,
-0.0078022708,
-0.008234866,
0.0414191559,
-0.0206843298,
-0.0426588245,
-0.0452037118,
-0.0267179664,
0.0239298977,
0.0999004617,
0.0192784742,
-0.069419384,
0.0824517086,
0.0157060754,
0.0436410904,
-0.0431397893,
-0.0463102981,
-0.054772988,
0.0696276203,
-0.0243209805,
0.0096925218,
0.0143947117,
0.0409893692,
0.0154911289,
-0.0205592569,
-0.0192078911,
-0.0152356075,
0.0082911961,
-0.0738956481,
0.0245222226,
0.0595579967,
-0.0119985072,
-0.0290877074,
-0.0556779914,
-0.0611618161,
0.0350480191,
0.0229611285,
-0.0274399817,
-0.0352615379,
0.0339985751,
0.0118778441,
-0.0245598704,
0.0141850943,
-0.0478519201,
-0.00163892,
-0.0502409823,
0.0161225516,
-0.0139450766,
0.0668088272,
-0.0026432457,
0.0360771641,
0.0425792709,
-0.0313247442,
-0.0140020801,
-0.0453200489,
0.0453512371,
-0.0257016774,
-0.0062371185,
0.0072352518,
0.038136933,
0.015660692,
-0.0564711019,
0.0157626756,
0.0942552984,
0.0242470223,
0.005152375,
0.0313967243,
-0.0281008948,
0.0266479608,
-0.020322701,
0.0220292658,
-0.0445661657,
-0.0331472009,
-0.0164689776,
0.0043132398,
-0.0269466005,
-0.0812178701,
-0.0025033881,
-0.0763830468,
0.0752868652,
0.0059642475,
-0.0090667838,
-0.0395800471,
-0.0660042167,
-0.0113618672,
-0.0780591443,
-0.0302634723,
-0.0253168587,
0.0112980604,
-0.0141868452,
0.0245776754,
-0.1025323942,
-0.0741315261,
0.0495461226,
-0.0184063874,
0.0057463637,
0.0439165868,
0.0214034189,
-0.0193508882,
0.0047273552,
-0.0599203594,
0.0300742816,
0.0671248287,
0.0120559307,
0.0783911869,
0.0124169979,
0.0018692206,
-0.0325879529,
0.0479310676,
-0.0523160547,
-0.0235293508,
0.0290083569,
0.1310513765,
-0.0590783171,
-0.0244004223,
-0.0497019887,
0.036554303,
0.0161517654,
0.0849118382,
-0.0048371023,
-0.0354362018,
-0.0092876107,
-0.0340663046,
0.009396866,
0.0180921871,
-0.0695052519,
0.0144526586,
-0.0059797717,
-0.0213619936,
-0.0073086843,
-0.019891303,
0.0482557416,
-0.0232525282,
0.0123539539,
0.023220133,
0.0059981016,
0.0062525985,
-0.0466574468,
0.0599080175,
0.018209165,
0.0637176856,
0.02244265,
0.0174664427,
0.0691867322,
0.0090862382,
-0.0526144765,
0.0352213271,
-0.0214681253,
-0.0515725017,
-0.0148127237,
0.0702862367,
0.0269926209,
-0.0017702965,
-0.0031080993,
-0.0682941228,
0.0654491335,
0.0294493362,
-0.0611423701,
-0.063440226,
0.0023446635,
0.0068049175,
0.0019735424,
0.000768263,
-0.0028354761,
-0.0023717589,
-0.0159056839,
-0.0247762334,
-0.0912340358,
-0.0691132247,
0.0179678425,
-0.0098291552,
0.0548057146,
-0.0189620685,
-0.0061528557,
0.0035608369,
-0.0250202008,
0.0262243468,
0.0110163093,
-0.0368593037,
0.0133028748,
0.0106892325,
-0.031308569,
-0.0238725469,
0.0067313849,
-0.0226541236,
-0.0538692027,
-0.013998162,
0.0447972529,
0.0328969881,
0.002560982,
0.0497501194,
0.0003907827,
0.0053060614,
-0.0281770639,
-0.0126119275,
0.0343338437,
0.0471919812,
0.0468320623,
-0.0022871785,
0.045975484,
-0.0289176647,
0.0127670914,
-0.0373248272,
-0.1034215093,
-0.0272794887,
0.0197951086,
-0.0117786517,
0.0152374916,
-0.0169304293,
-0.0605839416,
0.0028894714,
-0.0195998885,
0.031099854,
-0.0265039951,
0.0175094306,
0.0650494546,
0.0146558089,
-0.0746980309,
-0.04147055,
0.0767792985,
0.0496664643,
0.0333553366,
-0.0533913262,
-0.069061324,
-0.0162539165,
-0.0313897692,
0.070679538,
0.0002216132,
0.0015370006,
0.0057968525,
-0.1146878675,
-0.0456617326,
0.0414592102,
-0.0220345631,
-0.0112709394,
-0.0244801957,
-0.0280992202,
0.0494845062,
-0.0114018768,
-0.015186456,
-0.0204475466,
-0.0245633088,
-0.0310576949,
-0.0051122755,
-0.0456623957,
-6.181935811e-33,
0.0126645239,
-0.072523959,
-0.0048897765,
-0.0159604922,
0.0168716181,
0.0188554246,
-0.0202501584,
-0.0048130662,
0.0125846695,
0.029591823,
0.0135484878,
-0.0044908351,
-0.0086150011,
-0.0130145373,
0.0673108026,
-0.0226002559,
0.0181483254,
-0.0004651008,
0.0120349796,
-0.0028518059,
0.0412878245,
0.0162062217,
0.008148429,
-0.1122115627,
0.0479925312,
0.0351739563,
-0.0040463018,
0.0322297513,
-0.0126863578,
0.0323296413,
-0.0179037191,
0.0471324176,
0.0266708732,
-0.0782132298,
-0.0306523982,
-0.0127604231,
0.0081812087,
-0.0139196776,
0.0204826631,
-0.0555767417,
0.0136979287,
-0.0098117758,
0.0409479439,
0.0339454226,
-0.0126677137,
-0.0044191005,
0.0390145145,
-0.0433376692,
0.0103276996,
-0.0772955641,
-0.030473195,
0.0507430434,
-0.0703040808,
0.0261017065,
0.0208581891,
0.0419502929,
-0.0169239249,
0.0082665421,
-0.0281137452,
0.0195658263,
0.0412707627,
-0.0454869792,
0.0703208596,
-0.0030909029,
-0.0138203157,
0.0974657238,
-0.0026569834,
-0.0189626683,
-0.0410241038,
0.0003120028,
0.0082360953,
0.1006188616,
0.0399338268,
0.034118887,
-0.0241447166,
-0.0010972656,
-0.0891410187,
0.0576698706,
-0.0332672633,
0.0371414311,
0.0397388265,
-0.0023319027,
-0.0459361486,
-0.0542631932,
-0.0172346737,
0.0159346405,
0.0057973773,
-0.0165190455,
0.0179979056,
-0.0314594731,
-0.0447621495,
0.0510695353,
0.029741127,
-0.027501028,
0.012085069,
0.0296241958,
0.0200997237,
0.0008443872,
0.021184301,
0.0327232108,
-0.0637898892,
0.0246178322,
-0.0368807353,
-0.0314748771,
0.0343973674,
-0.0200746171,
0.0217813607,
0.0180778801,
-0.009948425,
0.0014421364,
-0.0040101274,
-0.0048763389,
0.0058893603,
0.004699959,
0.0248319488,
0.0183452666,
0.0077645206,
0.0178963151,
0.0180415045,
0.0089586806,
0.020232968,
0.0318835862,
-0.0011489696,
-0.0086018359,
-0.0129313981,
-0.0386554822,
0.009390329,
-0.0688366741,
0.0203406755,
-0.0125949113,
-0.0161836762,
-0.0120723387,
2.734e-7,
0.0855542272,
0.0414209105,
-0.0287004709,
-0.0051005688,
0.029724814,
0.0670762211,
0.013222496,
-0.0109698996,
-0.0021250697,
-0.036063116,
0.0905207917,
0.0217029974,
0.0335609168,
0.0533373132,
-0.0085077332,
-0.0312188603,
-0.0159836393,
-0.0380193591,
-0.0948046371,
-0.007960313,
0.0804176182,
0.0683850423,
0.0255249478,
-0.0082236212,
0.022011824,
-0.0412510708,
0.0135094989,
-0.0893146023,
0.0065759048,
0.0360659733,
0.0448035561,
0.0306446478,
0.0057187141,
0.06613902,
-0.020357877,
0.0071817134,
-0.0071469848,
0.066230908,
-0.0114181694,
0.0039479565,
0.0062601576,
-0.0421614572,
0.0263590403,
-0.0391879864,
0.0562826209,
-0.053468354,
-0.0438289046,
-0.0133813443,
0.0327495821,
-0.0324375369,
0.0347098038,
-0.0200096369,
0.0142494552,
0.0143131744,
-0.0390600748,
-0.0075779045,
-0.0044985097,
-0.0271396711,
0.0040370217,
0.0608214214,
-0.046324376,
-0.0375916623,
0.0070853923,
0.0224435814,
0.0491390638,
-0.0561401397,
0.0576096401,
2.683224042e-34,
0.0367170945,
0.013497998,
-0.0273653548,
0.0133900046,
0.0728056952,
0.0261987932,
-0.0347817577,
0.0151163554,
0.0271025728,
-0.063570492,
0.0212700702
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07010v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07010v1
|
Deciphering public attention to geoengineering and climate issues using machine learning and dynamic analysis
| 2024-05-11T13:10:57 | 2024-05-11T13:10:57 |
Ramit Debnath, Pengyu Zhang, Tianzhu Qin, R. Michael Alvarez, Shaun D. Fitzgerald
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, J.4; K.4
|
As the conversation around using geoengineering to combat climate change
intensifies, it is imperative to engage the public and deeply understand their
perspectives on geoengineering research, development, and potential deployment.
Through a comprehensive data-driven investigation, this paper explores the
types of news that captivate public interest in geoengineering. We delved into
30,773 English-language news articles from the BBC and the New York Times,
combined with Google Trends data spanning 2018 to 2022, to explore how public
interest in geoengineering fluctuates in response to news coverage of broader
climate issues. Using BERT-based topic modeling, sentiment analysis, and
time-series regression models, we found that positive sentiment in
energy-related news serves as a good predictor of heightened public interest in
geoengineering, a trend that persists over time. Our findings suggest that
public engagement with geoengineering and climate action is not uniform, with
some topics being more potent in shaping interest over time, such as climate
news related to energy, disasters, and politics. Understanding these patterns
is crucial for scientists, policymakers, and educators aiming to craft
effective strategies for engaging with the public and fostering dialogue around
emerging climate technologies.
|
Deciphering public attention to geoengineering and climate issues using machine learning and dynamic analysis: As the conversation around using geoengineering to combat climate change
intensifies, it is imperative to engage the public and deeply understand their
perspectives on geoengineering research, development, and potential deployment.
Through a comprehensive data-driven investigation, this paper explores the
types of news that captivate public interest in geoengineering. We delved into
30,773 English-language news articles from the BBC and the New York Times,
combined with Google Trends data spanning 2018 to 2022, to explore how public
interest in geoengineering fluctuates in response to news coverage of broader
climate issues. Using BERT-based topic modeling, sentiment analysis, and
time-series regression models, we found that positive sentiment in
energy-related news serves as a good predictor of heightened public interest in
geoengineering, a trend that persists over time. Our findings suggest that
public engagement with geoengineering and climate action is not uniform, with
some topics being more potent in shaping interest over time, such as climate
news related to energy, disasters, and politics. Understanding these patterns
is crucial for scientists, policymakers, and educators aiming to craft
effective strategies for engaging with the public and fostering dialogue around
emerging climate technologies.
|
[
0.0114996126,
0.0911621153,
-0.0022428981,
-0.0006498414,
-0.023184577,
-0.0165533423,
-0.0117068999,
-0.0197207555,
0.0200547967,
-0.0520415455,
0.0457402691,
0.0590185784,
-0.0191896241,
0.0568012111,
0.001740888,
-0.0795109197,
0.0311839487,
0.0089520896,
0.0657869354,
0.0146260886,
0.0038902049,
-0.0330466516,
-0.006541342,
0.0050010737,
0.0274023414,
0.0091449078,
-0.0046176938,
0.0296078008,
0.0675579235,
-0.0640796125,
0.0400568321,
0.0148999626,
0.0346337743,
0.0123507418,
0.0000017687,
-0.0161478799,
-0.0304033998,
-0.0169540532,
0.0616136305,
0.0008020021,
0.0486274175,
-0.030381199,
-0.0040856893,
0.0085778674,
-0.0386388414,
0.0026829846,
0.0522724204,
-0.0214797705,
0.036134135,
-0.0173536893,
-0.0106236218,
0.0217544641,
-0.0130563192,
-0.0122425463,
-0.0194138978,
0.0701418594,
0.0159863662,
-0.0183992162,
-0.0300477892,
0.0386159681,
-0.0008138734,
0.0516709648,
-0.0263743699,
0.0209273137,
0.0165229328,
0.0449652076,
-0.0468309,
0.0105852243,
-0.0257743839,
0.0291069224,
0.0684351176,
-0.0096853552,
0.0225935727,
-0.0081161959,
-0.0039967331,
0.0185648408,
-0.0296246521,
0.0176690128,
0.0015551092,
0.0174635518,
0.0086258575,
-0.0209798012,
-0.0181749128,
0.0585028492,
-0.0066515715,
0.0902809948,
-0.0444673002,
-0.0253198836,
-0.0148206977,
0.0362402685,
0.0612777248,
-0.031579826,
-0.0188335199,
-0.0281518605,
0.03930296,
0.0179639757,
0.0175750796,
0.0196654908,
0.0144046238,
-0.0679681823,
-0.0313761793,
0.02323322,
0.0466140434,
0.0474086888,
0.0711455047,
-0.0191934705,
0.0127299847,
0.014243206,
0.051626619,
0.0136056626,
-0.0631191656,
-0.0164426006,
0.0308453999,
-0.0236326922,
0.030528551,
0.0213464089,
0.0555277206,
-0.0297374539,
-0.0259253308,
0.0132072456,
-0.0827162862,
0.0076330244,
0.0172690842,
-0.0148515701,
0.0123576708,
0.0736536086,
-0.0326362699,
0.0630129874,
0.0230259914,
0.0284585319,
-0.0140561424,
-0.031619072,
0.0378445946,
0.0274158828,
-0.0233595986,
0.0378854237,
0.0410502739,
-0.0381026529,
-0.0611278526,
-0.03270749,
0.0347517096,
0.0262153037,
-0.0010341679,
-0.0030146495,
-0.0566290058,
0.0134071652,
0.0067415042,
0.0091057066,
-0.0047557391,
-0.0292161666,
-0.0096137132,
0.033732485,
-0.0150478454,
-0.0352510847,
0.0518622026,
0.0458463915,
0.0112986285,
0.067996949,
0.0338440835,
0.0639614984,
0.0221470371,
-0.0060158791,
-0.0148208663,
-0.0078388378,
0.0101103699,
0.0157628786,
-0.0442505702,
-0.0198190305,
-0.0606050864,
-0.0003231954,
0.0147883287,
-0.0190744009,
-0.0091598276,
0.0258812457,
0.0301757678,
0.0208120793,
-0.0261368807,
0.0366326757,
-0.0282021556,
0.0705818236,
-0.0257179234,
-0.062482737,
0.0116827833,
-0.0043224599,
-0.0490911752,
-0.0294698365,
0.0338917039,
0.0233751349,
-0.0275915898,
-0.0211586244,
-0.0222960636,
0.0041582733,
0.061518237,
-0.0224277154,
0.0110750226,
-0.0383193754,
-0.0015131907,
0.017485993,
0.019252168,
0.0100503415,
0.0108281244,
0.021190377,
-0.0004402192,
0.0196795836,
-0.0328688808,
0.0276306085,
-0.047916498,
-0.0506069921,
-0.0162805803,
-0.0174747817,
0.0199548621,
0.0143950721,
-0.0554337166,
0.0102663776,
-0.0475137495,
-0.0408262387,
0.0297463983,
0.0302147083,
-0.0013201934,
0.0596200861,
-0.029909512,
-0.0096824123,
-0.0071851476,
0.0257440787,
-0.0098522119,
-0.0120735932,
-0.0549466647,
0.0024230715,
0.0336100496,
0.0067124646,
-0.0048535946,
0.0049339947,
0.0622860156,
-0.0027066183,
-0.0637476593,
0.0350247994,
0.0711039677,
0.0660201237,
-0.0235142894,
-0.075394325,
-0.0097644143,
0.0004554238,
-0.0185396504,
-0.0032852846,
0.0438984297,
-0.0211325027,
0.0557077564,
0.0078381924,
-0.0416068546,
-0.0359515585,
-0.0181977823,
-0.0338450633,
0.0164031759,
-0.0223063044,
-0.0109924152,
-0.013538369,
-0.0561974458,
0.0065421746,
-0.0073984452,
0.0083840201,
-0.0277379621,
-0.021443408,
-0.0161477607,
0.0282356627,
-0.0505474247,
-0.0376100205,
0.0088660112,
-0.0347264037,
-0.0298781395,
-0.0244724005,
0.0329132676,
0.0456657931,
-0.0258961301,
-0.0298140086,
0.0258833505,
0.0583385192,
-0.0495731346,
-0.0344658978,
0.009750504,
0.0249934476,
-0.0070141368,
0.0552134514,
-0.0422452353,
-0.0100170607,
-0.0404008739,
0.0864207447,
0.0744611099,
-0.0382893905,
-0.0443816409,
0.0124587929,
-0.0133402515,
-0.0203413479,
-0.0330286883,
-0.0259115119,
-0.0280609373,
0.0084623126,
-0.0169125646,
-0.0086676953,
0.0663614944,
0.0568166301,
-0.0028718351,
0.0279134344,
-0.0426388793,
-0.003510087,
-0.0055528083,
0.0225574207,
0.0360506922,
-0.0130307088,
0.0552940741,
-0.0017976651,
-0.0202290807,
0.0235424042,
0.0522677079,
0.0643373653,
-0.005483618,
-0.0327237397,
-0.0062123672,
-0.0323697552,
0.0315228701,
0.0483845584,
-0.0000970465,
-0.0365894958,
0.0515552983,
0.0369525105,
0.036637947,
-0.0922016427,
-0.0175897107,
-0.0109209698,
0.017176494,
-0.0232172627,
0.0230569504,
0.0296408851,
0.0128430044,
0.0290345233,
-0.0904014036,
-0.0354164019,
0.0040920358,
0.0057197274,
-0.0344672054,
0.002945032,
0.0255870726,
0.007908267,
0.0096468749,
-0.0450385325,
-0.0502409674,
0.0045763045,
0.0476140641,
-0.0775890499,
-0.0137675274,
0.0239987355,
0.0592389852,
-0.0464117266,
0.0153657217,
-0.0266702734,
0.043166697,
0.0305799954,
0.014623425,
0.0226707626,
-0.0107873138,
0.0251740664,
-0.0373135507,
-0.0156922154,
0.0306886211,
0.010393763,
-0.0522319824,
0.0030976322,
0.0147612533,
-0.0098561207,
0.0026655672,
-0.0225357078,
0.0114654098,
-0.0189808551,
0.011626292,
0.0251316354,
-0.0083433911,
-0.0059780781,
0.0099681094,
0.0024673354,
0.0312465876,
0.0022115,
0.0033635551,
-0.0384516343,
0.0180988517,
-0.0202697329,
-0.0249771178,
-0.0233410187,
-0.0103606991,
-0.0330702849,
-0.0795956552,
0.0632776469,
-0.0140218763,
0.025756266,
0.003514986,
-0.1210481599,
0.0134001626,
-0.0329639986,
-0.0785092115,
-0.047007326,
-0.0105035426,
0.0186001267,
0.0348419473,
-0.0791192874,
-0.0455711931,
0.0033959721,
-0.0126273828,
-0.0029244144,
0.0834886879,
0.0553417504,
-0.04431656,
-0.0334027596,
0.0152510609,
0.0572417341,
0.0029407905,
-0.016788749,
0.0231460743,
0.0005801688,
0.0031405052,
-0.0051354012,
0.019620603,
0.003286917,
0.0147859398,
0.0097489227,
0.073091574,
-0.0483332053,
-0.0048785456,
-0.0265853666,
0.0172994342,
0.0784264579,
0.013189815,
-0.0278717093,
-0.0148387263,
-0.0509900115,
-0.0577143952,
0.0259744525,
-0.0099997437,
-0.0061487807,
-0.0395569056,
-0.0025496415,
-0.0308537204,
0.0025411348,
-0.01983428,
0.0170549843,
0.0081080124,
0.0082136802,
0.0199719593,
0.127032578,
0.0177769698,
-0.0616518855,
0.0619825311,
0.0410223007,
0.0098776072,
-0.0322997198,
-0.0921330079,
0.0543129519,
0.0458184779,
-0.0388111062,
0.0074175242,
-0.0394057035,
-0.0400868431,
0.0253067352,
0.0013629487,
0.027245285,
-0.0398993045,
0.0182204098,
0.0319404528,
0.0123049272,
0.0772258118,
-0.0267446861,
-0.0419408567,
0.0126172882,
0.0750744119,
-0.0060048765,
-0.0241538268,
0.0422270745,
-0.0062933243,
-0.0027920275,
-0.0491866022,
-0.0779177025,
-0.0215141084,
-0.0317444876,
-0.0325286239,
0.0955302268,
0.0288221575,
-0.0380858704,
-0.0191636719,
-0.0485221967,
0.0390988812,
0.0133280335,
-0.0423054881,
0.01313309,
-0.0082330955,
-0.0120980265,
-0.0725737363,
0.0444744378,
0.0115362881,
0.0016261621,
-0.0969491452,
0.0861757398,
-0.0047610183,
0.0220045764,
-0.01399564,
0.006228033,
-0.0011262521,
-0.0316360667,
0.0093478067,
-0.0066867457,
0.0461371541,
-0.0211850498,
0.0187225994,
0.0149550987,
0.0120612113,
0.0226359181,
-0.0481900685,
-0.0644284263,
-0.0250997376,
0.0502957404,
-0.0309112631,
0.0645933598,
0.0061896835,
-0.0027021307,
-0.0263690986,
-0.0074992231,
0.0254630055,
-0.0119200964,
-0.0206845161,
0.0650535896,
0.0004100358,
-0.0563793704,
-0.0155064408,
-0.0211733878,
0.0295229703,
0.0296949018,
0.010813944,
-0.0204341263,
-0.0191137325,
-0.0296035875,
0.0303705949,
-0.0319624245,
0.022259742,
0.0342406556,
-0.061754588,
0.0408618152,
0.0622509122,
-0.0079972725,
-0.003697956,
-0.0522002988,
0.0166657921,
0.0167564731,
-0.0343328528,
-0.0024746172,
0.0119231101,
-0.0012231013,
-0.0928034335,
-0.0410805717,
-0.0135494228,
-5.960138762e-33,
-0.0206555389,
-0.0297552776,
-0.0259996019,
0.003914691,
-0.0489537418,
0.0335928462,
-0.0218311846,
0.0400317907,
-0.0229028892,
0.0046876315,
0.002816037,
0.0098223463,
0.009132633,
-0.0193347875,
0.0760604739,
0.0030833506,
0.0408982337,
0.0009724667,
-0.0098385494,
0.023545336,
0.0544657595,
0.0348907113,
0.0235364866,
-0.0704566836,
0.0328576304,
0.0483806729,
-0.0292343199,
-0.0628505498,
0.0128084728,
-0.0142717902,
0.0013292428,
0.0218166243,
0.0388987735,
-0.0505619571,
-0.0302267186,
0.0661199391,
-0.0569112226,
-0.0208019819,
-0.0142162219,
-0.0585574247,
0.0154565936,
0.026133338,
0.0173400361,
0.0335169993,
-0.0376377888,
0.0232390985,
0.0457891002,
0.005390299,
0.0109850299,
-0.0307385605,
-0.0254107565,
0.0025737965,
-0.0380205363,
0.0611889698,
-0.0335975513,
0.0382079631,
-0.0048705549,
0.1246357262,
-0.0824436992,
0.0605461299,
0.0673758164,
-0.0097026806,
0.0060027912,
0.0014373192,
0.0020722665,
0.0946192741,
-0.0324520208,
0.0302584842,
-0.0662167445,
-0.0212409347,
0.0251113381,
0.0040765232,
-0.0031995601,
0.0692715794,
0.0324284323,
-0.0471399091,
-0.0714053214,
0.0363810137,
0.0311347824,
0.0261332523,
0.0438954122,
-0.015209158,
0.0230073333,
-0.0279457439,
-0.019130921,
-0.0031732353,
-0.0175237805,
0.0214316957,
-0.013593073,
0.0025908281,
-0.0351046808,
0.0309408512,
0.0183302164,
-0.027334528,
-0.0296812784,
0.0946808234,
-0.0333389603,
0.0144779291,
0.0087028239,
0.0052347709,
-0.0841170922,
-0.0194760822,
-0.0685676411,
0.0756242648,
0.0108987167,
-0.0301364046,
-0.0433582664,
0.0122910468,
-0.0385350026,
-0.0044976925,
-0.0125096031,
-0.0186529774,
-0.0135217141,
-0.0239895303,
0.0015603031,
-0.0235342868,
0.0338210054,
-0.026908204,
0.0022404557,
0.045974981,
0.0464730263,
0.007038828,
-0.1033707634,
0.0290583838,
0.0049721524,
-0.0535840541,
-0.0170968734,
-0.0317930542,
-0.0395121016,
-0.0310612619,
0.0120079964,
-0.0277794413,
2.551e-7,
0.0145818843,
0.0551827848,
-0.0117127486,
-0.0140257059,
-0.0031916162,
0.0558265746,
-0.0211671218,
0.0411034338,
0.0104579842,
0.0072543072,
-0.0045368932,
-0.0156907216,
-0.011932713,
-0.008356493,
-0.0445160381,
-0.0120646954,
-0.0243390147,
0.0123845199,
-0.06707488,
0.024918519,
0.0610261001,
-0.0224086475,
0.0168799609,
0.0359956846,
-0.0114158895,
-0.0024300925,
0.0532773063,
-0.0886988565,
0.006527605,
0.0036693856,
-0.0164805334,
0.0153913824,
-0.0072236322,
0.0008312102,
-0.0276797526,
-0.0463594906,
-0.0357484855,
0.0027714467,
0.0446213558,
-0.0544342957,
0.0047880472,
0.0045628236,
0.0063153827,
-0.0379895344,
-0.0257770624,
-0.0579791591,
-0.0281076897,
-0.0488488823,
-0.0151276179,
0.0233947244,
0.0079528801,
-0.0027491264,
-0.0123334294,
-0.0578626283,
-0.0248460323,
-0.0155777866,
-0.0187752564,
-0.0147800231,
0.0043046139,
0.013164646,
-0.0349995121,
0.0012424893,
-0.0267210007,
0.0269113835,
0.0429907739,
0.018638216,
0.0358180851,
1.765770676e-34,
0.0432541743,
-0.0236602481,
-0.0559134781,
-0.0235368386,
0.0022844316,
0.0345979594,
0.0095605301,
-0.0079289582,
0.0242256131,
-0.0407570787,
0.0343757011
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07006v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07006v1
|
Word-specific tonal realizations in Mandarin
| 2024-05-11T13:00:35 | 2024-05-11T13:00:35 |
Yu-Ying Chuang, Melanie J. Bell, Yu-Hsiang Tseng, R. Harald Baayen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The pitch contours of Mandarin two-character words are generally understood
as being shaped by the underlying tones of the constituent single-character
words, in interaction with articulatory constraints imposed by factors such as
speech rate, co-articulation with adjacent tones, segmental make-up, and
predictability. This study shows that tonal realization is also partially
determined by words' meanings. We first show, on the basis of a Taiwan corpus
of spontaneous conversations, using the generalized additive regression model,
and focusing on the rise-fall tone pattern, that after controlling for effects
of speaker and context, word type is a stronger predictor of pitch realization
than all the previously established word-form related predictors combined.
Importantly, the addition of information about meaning in context improves
prediction accuracy even further. We then proceed to show, using computational
modeling with context-specific word embeddings, that token-specific pitch
contours predict word type with 50% accuracy on held-out data, and that
context-sensitive, token-specific embeddings can predict the shape of pitch
contours with 30% accuracy. These accuracies, which are an order of magnitude
above chance level, suggest that the relation between words' pitch contours and
their meanings are sufficiently strong to be functional for language users. The
theoretical implications of these empirical findings are discussed.
|
Word-specific tonal realizations in Mandarin: The pitch contours of Mandarin two-character words are generally understood
as being shaped by the underlying tones of the constituent single-character
words, in interaction with articulatory constraints imposed by factors such as
speech rate, co-articulation with adjacent tones, segmental make-up, and
predictability. This study shows that tonal realization is also partially
determined by words' meanings. We first show, on the basis of a Taiwan corpus
of spontaneous conversations, using the generalized additive regression model,
and focusing on the rise-fall tone pattern, that after controlling for effects
of speaker and context, word type is a stronger predictor of pitch realization
than all the previously established word-form related predictors combined.
Importantly, the addition of information about meaning in context improves
prediction accuracy even further. We then proceed to show, using computational
modeling with context-specific word embeddings, that token-specific pitch
contours predict word type with 50% accuracy on held-out data, and that
context-sensitive, token-specific embeddings can predict the shape of pitch
contours with 30% accuracy. These accuracies, which are an order of magnitude
above chance level, suggest that the relation between words' pitch contours and
their meanings are sufficiently strong to be functional for language users. The
theoretical implications of these empirical findings are discussed.
|
[
-0.0233792569,
0.0758955926,
-0.0024050758,
0.0092592994,
-0.0125550227,
-0.0519234613,
-0.0046094814,
-0.0019158563,
-0.0279237479,
0.0294114761,
-0.1043138355,
-0.0785251632,
0.0869372264,
0.0643722937,
0.0299314931,
-0.0694691464,
0.0183729269,
-0.0184299629,
0.0474491864,
0.0032635387,
0.0463917255,
-0.0181112234,
-0.0088462448,
0.0566525981,
-0.0342977457,
-0.0096925655,
-0.0307086427,
-0.0000138292,
-0.0068959552,
-0.0099006118,
-0.0244411193,
0.0343628265,
0.0173379704,
0.0129832597,
0.0000017932,
-0.0680099279,
0.0089191124,
-0.0087983282,
-0.0215672553,
-0.0082823168,
0.0636454597,
0.0024825134,
-0.0339327604,
0.0179804713,
-0.0161011051,
0.0219601598,
0.0528609641,
0.0227835476,
-0.0102724144,
0.0031049205,
-0.0321629643,
-0.0107274577,
-0.0043511339,
0.0019298195,
-0.0218431372,
-0.0023223918,
0.0249007512,
0.0131099317,
-0.0435872674,
-0.0656939521,
-0.0506758131,
0.0097639104,
-0.0147858188,
0.052153822,
0.0166752785,
0.0379995927,
-0.06252902,
-0.0233192556,
0.0016585155,
0.02780913,
0.0090015642,
-0.0350978859,
-0.0432719626,
0.0143591799,
0.0002196173,
-0.0173232555,
0.014500658,
-0.0056518782,
0.009935407,
0.0020810156,
0.0306585357,
0.0352060385,
-0.0053619947,
-0.0030139072,
-0.010486302,
-0.0078063463,
0.0273304041,
-0.0728816837,
-0.0028211891,
-0.027189672,
-0.01369543,
-0.0241617374,
0.04137161,
0.0154192504,
0.0116412863,
0.0128728049,
0.0107083591,
-0.0180401355,
0.0023765126,
-0.0569205545,
0.0003916813,
0.0042097187,
-0.0423082188,
-0.0288499128,
0.0087124184,
0.0200399235,
0.0201223083,
-0.0753989592,
-0.0556826517,
0.0072885756,
0.014017337,
-0.0552086793,
-0.0430512466,
0.006087916,
0.0384872891,
-0.0238125939,
-0.0352331102,
0.000628508,
-0.0430750959,
-0.0210053734,
0.0016163251,
0.0293346625,
-0.0593589284,
-0.0019569052,
-0.0162000731,
0.0217425283,
-0.0410231501,
0.071509093,
-0.0533099473,
-0.0367507562,
0.0165138002,
0.0137061914,
0.0275464021,
0.0467654727,
0.0228221435,
0.0182311367,
0.0060416274,
0.0034365188,
0.0587853566,
-0.0603678897,
-0.0845143348,
-0.0213790685,
-0.0661027953,
-0.0579701588,
-0.0159607474,
-0.0195908844,
0.0169707071,
-0.0190194845,
-0.0342548117,
-0.0094008213,
0.0334882401,
0.0245649349,
0.0105129313,
0.0229013618,
0.001665324,
0.0094305659,
-0.0387219265,
0.0253848713,
0.0577684976,
-0.0186324157,
0.0070329388,
-0.0499583855,
0.0031434302,
0.0158114973,
-0.0137161361,
-0.0252130236,
-0.0178898051,
-0.0507503264,
0.000300675,
0.0592242703,
0.0354043767,
0.0171306543,
0.0051421141,
-0.0251246188,
0.0446978137,
0.0949324816,
0.0725681782,
0.0359739959,
0.0066427952,
-0.0048829741,
-0.0065442761,
0.0302686896,
-0.0041954867,
-0.0181413945,
-0.01748964,
0.045873519,
0.0223155301,
0.0207082108,
-0.0166471265,
-0.0337262303,
-0.0213778932,
-0.0346527249,
-0.0230787527,
-0.0474549867,
0.0365413614,
0.0154280094,
0.0064356243,
0.0108722942,
0.0151702529,
-0.047029309,
0.0091463616,
-0.0081922552,
-0.0223554112,
0.0505843535,
-0.0101114726,
-0.0233662743,
0.0271039661,
0.012642704,
-0.0409557223,
0.030725779,
0.0131404847,
0.0015826097,
-0.0013816376,
-0.0318355896,
0.0148565024,
0.0542388298,
0.0148893567,
0.0221976712,
-0.0459422581,
0.0372606628,
-0.0216355324,
-0.0313898586,
0.0116913402,
-0.0185556859,
-0.0200419053,
-0.0228277892,
-0.0166410748,
0.0159656648,
0.0299414992,
0.0349729881,
-0.034544114,
0.0541467257,
-0.0069958786,
-0.0016074384,
-0.0040218276,
0.0542778745,
-0.081475459,
0.0066709346,
0.0224043485,
-0.0188461505,
0.0360543951,
-0.0420055464,
0.0546355173,
-0.075979501,
0.0586074777,
0.0128522366,
0.0749783739,
-0.0803584531,
0.0244523417,
-0.0483748727,
0.081331104,
0.0343941562,
0.0057858219,
0.0332115367,
-0.0155517319,
-0.0193232633,
-0.0032198501,
0.0056776539,
-0.0276294686,
-0.0517931581,
0.0321987122,
-0.0011916098,
0.0312778465,
-0.0188836604,
-0.0583787113,
-0.0152405463,
0.0003988531,
-0.0800654516,
-0.0136170443,
0.0006903224,
-0.0281852223,
0.0075585297,
0.0109718097,
0.0239133909,
0.0154868644,
-0.0253632274,
-0.0264798962,
-0.0295791887,
0.0295303818,
-0.0286764242,
-0.0522537455,
-0.037837863,
-0.0258776434,
0.0030255241,
-0.022175001,
-0.0122513119,
-0.0157754365,
-0.0057216301,
-0.0054299827,
0.0325601399,
-0.0204953235,
-0.0104437331,
0.0203095898,
-0.0446991995,
0.0064668311,
-0.032319203,
0.074108921,
0.0299799386,
0.0059735775,
0.0205934905,
0.0784095377,
-0.020202145,
-0.0081125917,
-0.0325292796,
0.0171701722,
0.0378916413,
-0.0023548612,
-0.0067110211,
-0.0146217439,
0.0761811361,
0.0707618147,
0.0138304634,
-0.0677810982,
-0.0359219797,
-0.0403194577,
-0.0170044266,
-0.0034863311,
-0.012191833,
-0.0950396061,
-0.004008959,
-0.0263214651,
-0.0629942194,
0.08782579,
-0.0221320987,
-0.0455069691,
-0.0142739248,
-0.0245516058,
-0.0317253545,
0.0196664501,
-0.0154176038,
-0.0266803447,
0.0389695019,
-0.0465620384,
-0.024757294,
0.0470632501,
0.0186835416,
-0.0712025538,
0.0516506433,
0.0237669647,
-0.062691018,
-0.0048843874,
-0.0043799924,
-0.0176375024,
-0.0081995502,
-0.069600068,
0.0545564666,
0.0363932885,
-0.0153681962,
0.1060965881,
0.0461332202,
-0.0138443336,
-0.0068796366,
-0.0160280485,
0.0332607999,
-0.0013290353,
-0.0403021872,
0.0021429157,
0.0847877637,
-0.0037783752,
-0.0040901196,
0.063204661,
-0.0346779339,
0.014282288,
0.0387519412,
-0.007181068,
0.0102159474,
0.0168988947,
0.0274664126,
-0.0368070304,
0.0103911571,
0.0317061618,
-0.0040400098,
0.0232955813,
0.1088074073,
0.0103072776,
-0.0382203721,
0.0121435411,
-0.011025439,
0.0528499037,
0.0019028097,
-0.0115089109,
-0.0383204482,
-0.0034431932,
0.0508606397,
-0.0278846025,
0.0142674912,
0.0237703547,
-0.010331288,
-0.093576178,
0.0352063216,
0.0275678206,
0.0135687916,
0.0114760529,
-0.0360268131,
0.0276078396,
0.019906288,
0.0049970341,
0.0139248287,
-0.0309925657,
-0.0228952002,
0.0189652834,
-0.1192709878,
0.0002618152,
0.0457375199,
-0.0292590968,
-0.0131582255,
0.0223790146,
0.0338817649,
-0.0604359172,
-0.048293516,
-0.0124118635,
0.036487326,
0.0045835366,
-0.0063350834,
0.0583131239,
0.047825627,
0.013980289,
-0.0242657885,
0.0533044785,
-0.0331373736,
-0.0162299573,
-0.0201474577,
0.0500444844,
-0.0133075407,
-0.0247914046,
-0.0121761179,
0.0548028089,
-0.0267535057,
0.0782750845,
0.0376478843,
-0.1013548598,
0.0310031082,
0.0264240783,
0.0475913063,
0.0319031887,
-0.0158344507,
0.0214638468,
0.026077345,
-0.0121849393,
-0.0491152741,
-0.0038275514,
-0.0257200543,
0.0285413843,
0.0442103557,
0.0440177284,
-0.0282272156,
-0.0097720418,
-0.010821824,
-0.0181137603,
0.0586724095,
0.0709844902,
-0.0550926067,
-0.007622093,
0.0403157286,
-0.0912928432,
-0.0210266691,
-0.0560215563,
-0.0124565838,
-0.0299218204,
0.0823282748,
-0.0666712448,
0.0093417745,
0.0644333437,
-0.0215850808,
-0.0205235165,
0.0352338105,
-0.028144015,
0.0069531472,
0.0244516749,
0.0405540131,
0.0022957381,
0.0069843126,
0.029584052,
-0.0227703266,
0.0327429958,
-0.0512010679,
-0.0268480312,
-0.0009080265,
-0.0406814888,
0.0062405192,
-0.0087431325,
0.0543328971,
-0.0105012394,
0.0160048176,
-0.0424024463,
-0.0080417832,
0.0135865519,
0.0037075202,
-0.0090203658,
-0.0443308763,
0.0307206959,
0.0151741691,
-0.0247840192,
-0.0022358124,
-0.0297915172,
-0.0214003231,
0.0336321145,
0.0417972356,
0.0500558764,
0.0257941857,
0.0136289913,
0.0298037473,
-0.0098067382,
0.0323159806,
-0.0355040282,
-0.0004632957,
0.0042905789,
-0.0206362791,
-0.0321517475,
0.0087121725,
-0.0075354078,
0.000988799,
-0.0133200651,
0.0018387515,
-0.0096578561,
-0.0246160682,
0.0284055099,
-0.0228082892,
-0.0268777832,
-0.0302813463,
0.0357329994,
-0.0318165086,
-0.0107723093,
-0.0310913492,
-0.0239053629,
0.0401918851,
0.0130124418,
-0.0480487905,
-0.0321090072,
0.0311825909,
-0.0037757552,
0.0005784456,
-0.0420982502,
-0.0035156186,
0.0024469218,
0.0281520821,
-0.0096374545,
0.0084669953,
-0.0376560502,
0.0191855114,
-0.0953933522,
-0.0647913963,
0.0760702118,
-0.0050536324,
0.0236172732,
-0.0173254516,
0.0058605243,
0.025949996,
-0.0657249242,
0.0163696446,
0.0206679888,
-0.0359243751,
-0.0259313062,
0.0252544414,
0.0355858803,
-5.935041957e-33,
-0.0127134919,
-0.010573484,
-0.0033233834,
0.0611628257,
0.0026722713,
0.0504901335,
-0.0234989412,
0.0252131131,
-0.0221604332,
0.0143031003,
0.0038151571,
-0.000957554,
0.0163507815,
-0.0228014197,
0.0457620993,
0.0066670957,
0.0397954322,
-0.0124683706,
0.0129241133,
-0.0506938286,
0.068046622,
0.0128117558,
0.0612885132,
-0.0201353151,
0.0052686236,
0.0135938106,
-0.0027853174,
0.0009255728,
0.0143703213,
0.0442243256,
-0.0218783356,
0.0738340244,
0.0311414003,
0.0470852964,
-0.0447240397,
0.0191292837,
-0.0621013343,
-0.0601046495,
0.0049145673,
0.0472734459,
0.0067935335,
0.0168866497,
-0.0035322122,
-0.0026849881,
-0.0289329197,
-0.0499182977,
0.027800722,
-0.020028634,
0.0073707909,
-0.0098062539,
-0.032475058,
0.0106987134,
0.0338826068,
-0.0444487035,
0.0473937131,
0.0288470145,
-0.0408151299,
-0.0139541803,
-0.0169103052,
0.038711939,
-0.0016973482,
0.0336007588,
0.00782625,
0.0866990313,
0.0209453311,
0.0343713872,
0.0524816066,
-0.0338182189,
-0.007621903,
-0.0248423293,
0.0860238746,
0.0119651258,
-0.0202481188,
0.0172900707,
0.0685999095,
-0.046438437,
0.050582651,
-0.0337094329,
0.028377153,
-0.004504961,
-0.0061450722,
0.0576376468,
-0.0646336451,
-0.0370444097,
-0.0276256967,
-0.0345406197,
-0.0491417721,
-0.0041639325,
0.0144130066,
-0.013972098,
0.0473678373,
0.0009017094,
0.0543065257,
-0.0295178015,
0.0070169824,
-0.0165168103,
-0.029148329,
0.0083397971,
0.0340281352,
0.0262863655,
-0.0368031599,
-0.0115299383,
0.017649876,
0.0806025118,
0.0391447842,
-0.000324626,
-0.0032972035,
0.017379893,
-0.0285620019,
-0.0084889308,
0.0211869907,
-0.080345571,
0.0357844383,
-0.0247788168,
0.0463723131,
0.0263820682,
-0.0242553428,
0.0356634408,
0.0020080486,
0.0391406752,
-0.0536318421,
0.0058797686,
-0.0537554845,
0.053154964,
-0.0376178473,
0.0002094039,
0.0200610384,
-0.0484260544,
0.0702747628,
-0.0493405238,
-0.0276500657,
0.0107339788,
2.68e-7,
0.0253339931,
-0.0180145986,
0.0375973582,
0.0077429451,
0.0285924934,
0.0109709799,
-0.0454751365,
0.0089515178,
0.0293026641,
0.0355325677,
0.0323405713,
-0.0303578228,
0.091045551,
0.0416414551,
-0.0827010423,
0.0237688608,
-0.0774403065,
0.0424151309,
-0.0310115404,
0.0255047549,
0.0399776511,
0.0711748898,
-0.0580114312,
-0.0253314208,
0.0115473364,
-0.0206758399,
0.0207175855,
-0.029704731,
0.0276463795,
-0.0128936125,
-0.0516961515,
-0.0031090626,
0.0002377015,
0.0288051832,
-0.0716748685,
0.0729466453,
0.0504809618,
0.0168408845,
-0.0011805259,
-0.0194895919,
-0.0183241554,
0.0214547981,
-0.035227742,
0.0212359428,
0.0548506603,
0.0324820317,
-0.0464312397,
-0.0385251753,
0.026525747,
0.0083415713,
0.0410006121,
-0.0045131529,
-0.0129080666,
-0.0087401327,
-0.008775482,
-0.0051764599,
-0.01902855,
-0.0004889047,
-0.0580916442,
0.0387983732,
-0.0535949841,
-0.0228664111,
0.0151269576,
-0.0674584508,
0.0186638739,
0.0116960984,
0.0034738444,
1.994648609e-34,
0.0224859137,
-0.0330331959,
0.0515494496,
0.0045097372,
0.0036558313,
-0.0367039405,
0.1105500162,
0.0191833843,
0.0527856201,
-0.0274105594,
-0.0590506308
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07001v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07001v2
|
Evaluating Task-based Effectiveness of MLLMs on Charts
| 2024-05-11T12:33:46 | 2024-06-17T15:44:33 |
Yifan Wu, Lutao Yan, Yuyu Luo, Yunhai Wang, Nan Tang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
In this paper, we explore a forward-thinking question: Is GPT-4V effective at
low-level data analysis tasks on charts? To this end, we first curate a
large-scale dataset, named ChartInsights, consisting of 89,388 quartets (chart,
task, question, answer) and covering 10 widely-used low-level data analysis
tasks on 7 chart types. Firstly, we conduct systematic evaluations to
understand the capabilities and limitations of 18 advanced MLLMs, which include
12 open-source models and 6 closed-source models. Starting with a standard
textual prompt approach, the average accuracy rate across the 18 MLLMs is
36.17%. Among all the models, GPT-4V achieves the highest accuracy, reaching
56.13%. To understand the limitations of multimodal large models in low-level
data analysis tasks, we have designed various experiments to conduct an
in-depth test of capabilities of GPT-4V. We further investigate how visual
modifications to charts, such as altering visual elements (e.g. changing color
schemes) and introducing perturbations (e.g. adding image noise), affect
performance of GPT-4V. Secondly, we present 12 experimental findings. These
findings suggest potential of GPT-4V to revolutionize interaction with charts
and uncover the gap between human analytic needs and capabilities of GPT-4V.
Thirdly, we propose a novel textual prompt strategy, named Chain-of-Charts,
tailored for low-level analysis tasks, which boosts model performance by
24.36%, resulting in an accuracy of 80.49%. Furthermore, by incorporating a
visual prompt strategy that directs attention of GPT-4V to question-relevant
visual elements, we further improve accuracy to 83.83%. Our study not only
sheds light on the capabilities and limitations of GPT-4V in low-level data
analysis tasks but also offers valuable insights for future research.
|
Evaluating Task-based Effectiveness of MLLMs on Charts: In this paper, we explore a forward-thinking question: Is GPT-4V effective at
low-level data analysis tasks on charts? To this end, we first curate a
large-scale dataset, named ChartInsights, consisting of 89,388 quartets (chart,
task, question, answer) and covering 10 widely-used low-level data analysis
tasks on 7 chart types. Firstly, we conduct systematic evaluations to
understand the capabilities and limitations of 18 advanced MLLMs, which include
12 open-source models and 6 closed-source models. Starting with a standard
textual prompt approach, the average accuracy rate across the 18 MLLMs is
36.17%. Among all the models, GPT-4V achieves the highest accuracy, reaching
56.13%. To understand the limitations of multimodal large models in low-level
data analysis tasks, we have designed various experiments to conduct an
in-depth test of capabilities of GPT-4V. We further investigate how visual
modifications to charts, such as altering visual elements (e.g. changing color
schemes) and introducing perturbations (e.g. adding image noise), affect
performance of GPT-4V. Secondly, we present 12 experimental findings. These
findings suggest potential of GPT-4V to revolutionize interaction with charts
and uncover the gap between human analytic needs and capabilities of GPT-4V.
Thirdly, we propose a novel textual prompt strategy, named Chain-of-Charts,
tailored for low-level analysis tasks, which boosts model performance by
24.36%, resulting in an accuracy of 80.49%. Furthermore, by incorporating a
visual prompt strategy that directs attention of GPT-4V to question-relevant
visual elements, we further improve accuracy to 83.83%. Our study not only
sheds light on the capabilities and limitations of GPT-4V in low-level data
analysis tasks but also offers valuable insights for future research.
|
[
-0.016108457,
0.0432310626,
-0.0259086601,
0.0171790943,
-0.0256730933,
-0.001661612,
0.0544734113,
0.0103001418,
0.0464409329,
0.0330321528,
-0.0185524318,
-0.0043925876,
-0.008217331,
0.0447503291,
0.0335339606,
-0.1143143475,
-0.0051314528,
-0.0099054463,
0.0482553169,
0.0084627839,
0.0001111448,
-0.027877057,
-0.0263456665,
0.0429864489,
-0.0475244373,
-0.0487367697,
-0.0359247215,
0.0374268964,
0.0499404557,
-0.0717213154,
-0.0323208198,
0.0582872033,
0.0202636924,
0.0105507281,
0.0000025665,
-0.0313396528,
0.020665301,
-0.0145026417,
-0.0257961117,
-0.0050083366,
0.0326315798,
-0.0369777791,
0.0357650146,
-0.022596674,
-0.0297097769,
0.0073414939,
0.0591222607,
0.0146532096,
0.063047491,
-0.0197055396,
-0.0068159057,
0.0300509818,
-0.0124575123,
-0.0147644021,
0.0707669705,
-0.037666548,
-0.0136324102,
0.033116322,
0.0472362004,
0.0286054388,
-0.04550061,
0.0610479712,
0.0287759509,
0.0382539891,
0.0209022406,
0.0360779427,
0.0109901549,
-0.0424630679,
-0.0262437183,
0.0909956917,
-0.0099342186,
0.0094676865,
-0.0173041336,
-0.0346198492,
0.0379255116,
0.0630523488,
-0.0940411836,
-0.0381037407,
-0.0425729938,
-0.0404089764,
-0.068611972,
0.0078839967,
0.0123105459,
-0.0338870957,
-0.0032519866,
-0.0051310332,
-0.0106374575,
-0.028029589,
0.0346894599,
-0.0029673378,
-0.0289352965,
-0.0353103504,
-0.0075807571,
-0.0012780458,
-0.0303490162,
-0.0101191644,
0.0062591624,
-0.026276568,
0.0025219701,
-0.0023225069,
0.0841473863,
0.0103703626,
-0.0288004857,
0.0174657125,
0.0308151934,
0.0501879416,
-0.0056505543,
-0.0548625849,
0.008676948,
0.0183761735,
-0.0197824966,
-0.0122593464,
-0.0149373384,
-0.044505097,
-0.06366577,
-0.0189908687,
-0.0047225752,
0.022006955,
-0.0056571583,
0.042997025,
-0.0363473482,
0.0099175293,
-0.0119723259,
0.038256079,
-0.0485151596,
0.0257656053,
-0.0648710802,
-0.0139862495,
-0.0129517894,
-0.0380053781,
0.0024186587,
0.0126655037,
0.0287927259,
-0.0224683452,
0.0072610751,
0.0630283952,
0.0338069797,
0.0230650771,
-0.0243428368,
-0.0523562357,
-0.0048483615,
-0.0228654109,
0.0102717662,
-0.0050951871,
0.0207813308,
0.0124360202,
0.0186807718,
0.0005492496,
0.0119386027,
0.0453284159,
-0.0093141589,
0.0870115682,
-0.0088742981,
-0.010717798,
-0.0069263824,
-0.0084456699,
-0.0638086945,
0.0488005951,
0.0414910093,
0.0310566518,
0.0269602425,
-0.0933905989,
0.0530924276,
0.0389145911,
0.0023947333,
-0.0151024293,
-0.0274348296,
0.026762709,
-0.0710326061,
0.0229163449,
0.0135967815,
0.0226835143,
-0.0388790518,
-0.0094853826,
0.115287587,
0.0325502269,
0.059666831,
-0.0046773823,
-0.0044176825,
0.0041130991,
0.0136388168,
-0.0035480324,
-0.0473265164,
0.0704895332,
0.0128957601,
0.0224705823,
-0.0425237715,
0.0011085792,
-0.0069388524,
-0.0497299954,
-0.0278162006,
0.0319512635,
-0.0171968993,
0.0075426032,
0.0081736809,
-0.0259756073,
-0.0016218565,
-0.0150157027,
-0.0137521476,
-0.0409387946,
-0.0556250997,
-0.0031536804,
0.0389843434,
0.0563905127,
0.0250881687,
-0.0332540534,
-0.0427188426,
-0.0545326024,
0.0089399349,
0.0289911218,
0.0493504368,
0.0053975247,
-0.0266078413,
-0.0440681502,
-0.0489987172,
-0.0323200561,
0.0018791193,
0.0271853749,
-0.0132093811,
-0.005027038,
-0.0139709366,
-0.0600506999,
0.0051430152,
-0.0165751111,
0.0209296644,
-0.016327085,
0.0006605872,
0.0159876496,
0.0246778037,
0.0229006186,
0.0282510947,
0.0166095011,
0.0084190294,
0.027322175,
0.0324536003,
0.0289333519,
0.0002507282,
-0.00660002,
0.0165605098,
-0.0426155217,
-0.0185600463,
0.0134606725,
-0.0294481963,
-0.0207511522,
0.0061981352,
-0.0502701402,
-0.0268405806,
-0.0121306889,
-0.0542424247,
-0.0061980044,
-0.0006128926,
-0.0483031645,
0.0514996238,
-0.0092011848,
0.0199947245,
0.0126243746,
0.0641363636,
0.0197880305,
-0.0301483497,
0.0291710794,
0.0203336626,
0.0234145708,
0.0222374126,
-0.0086109806,
-0.019818075,
-0.0725124776,
0.0349741131,
-0.0875087827,
-0.0265522748,
-0.0064122579,
0.0104979156,
0.0249326043,
0.0058632656,
-0.0671002418,
-0.0317791551,
-0.0218997914,
0.0179435741,
-0.0345889702,
0.0214006826,
0.0301368497,
-0.0225119386,
0.0257493556,
-0.0157943442,
0.0126610743,
-0.0176488943,
0.0131783774,
0.0622396208,
-0.0160960369,
-0.0006524354,
-0.0276650842,
-0.0405659787,
-0.0166572053,
0.0099695316,
0.0402651951,
0.0426936895,
-0.0154953543,
0.1036285758,
0.0282355454,
-0.039136555,
0.0487214699,
0.0076974849,
-0.0563430227,
-0.05006098,
0.051931113,
-0.0050087636,
0.0251733288,
0.0151491668,
-0.0064800535,
-0.0021657569,
0.0255476702,
0.0145173799,
0.0143467262,
-0.0120696155,
0.0514152497,
-0.0082770586,
0.0095519582,
-0.0662092716,
0.0239596702,
-0.0237629674,
0.0382003672,
-0.0128968088,
-0.0774853677,
0.035331659,
-0.0036338877,
-0.0317597948,
-0.0124587314,
-0.0070631183,
-0.0152505701,
0.0791830271,
0.0025607503,
-0.0207472183,
-0.0143703427,
-0.024151491,
-0.0258518178,
0.0223139822,
0.0000857281,
-0.0385065079,
0.0338131711,
-0.0806653202,
-0.0391715206,
-0.0205415022,
-0.0044406531,
-0.0300776474,
-0.0303462427,
-0.0183357801,
-0.0289939549,
-0.0069201947,
-0.0289505739,
0.0016062077,
-0.0032255799,
0.04304149,
-0.0127057163,
-0.0137474928,
-0.0241357666,
0.0025003799,
0.0127800452,
0.0147629874,
0.0386452191,
0.0045615574,
-0.0553123653,
0.0398461074,
0.0420720018,
0.0074970345,
-0.0248503573,
-0.0373110548,
0.0303704794,
-0.026532514,
0.0400452763,
-0.0018116675,
0.0348207168,
0.0811761022,
-0.0384516269,
0.0397878438,
0.0817745328,
0.0113516618,
-0.0517244302,
-0.0155438371,
-0.0049874703,
0.0553390197,
0.0172922406,
0.0006190217,
-0.0839254335,
-0.0260879043,
0.0249489713,
0.0567087978,
0.0058031273,
-0.0438796133,
0.0028238948,
-0.0771345869,
0.0962219089,
0.0016546908,
-0.0257400908,
-0.0003169314,
-0.0285722837,
0.0309992135,
0.0073785186,
0.0050735143,
-0.0117752496,
-0.0090959975,
0.037184,
0.0076470631,
-0.0592875145,
-0.0263700914,
-0.0302187167,
0.0045030913,
-0.0419786125,
0.026025027,
0.0384525545,
-0.0336016268,
-0.0569556467,
0.0140447849,
0.0447281525,
0.0188182089,
-0.0369603373,
0.086945489,
0.0362887681,
-0.007389992,
-0.0490347408,
0.0609522462,
0.0183439478,
-0.0082355756,
0.037367329,
0.0650840625,
-0.0359952524,
-0.0316833034,
-0.0415670313,
0.0090888301,
0.0155714676,
0.0145909507,
0.0957247838,
-0.0403437428,
-0.0256933589,
-0.0645894632,
0.034159217,
-0.042309586,
-0.0050896504,
0.0015053005,
0.0379681289,
-0.0020773725,
-0.0225279834,
-0.0652292073,
0.0495366156,
0.0176630002,
-0.0018383462,
-0.0144130783,
-0.0256112255,
-0.0240055732,
-0.0290537979,
0.0747025982,
-0.0067844852,
0.0443350114,
0.0189787913,
-0.0175608508,
-0.006022207,
-0.0038717703,
-0.0073152245,
0.0407601222,
-0.0778363273,
-0.0010959418,
-0.0277365837,
0.0477013774,
0.0294794608,
-0.0094304327,
0.0119295353,
-0.0172453467,
0.0253206547,
0.0669798553,
-0.0154137472,
-0.030143097,
-0.0150171118,
0.0383918621,
-0.0058571864,
-0.0263735261,
0.021477256,
0.0283611435,
0.0086762849,
0.0249463581,
-0.0191819053,
-0.0020818526,
-0.0039101029,
0.0180690475,
0.0578530729,
0.0018415025,
-0.0542697087,
0.0037691339,
-0.030319972,
-0.0109752836,
-0.0186691787,
-0.0214631166,
-0.0223315805,
0.0109687569,
-0.0152716478,
-0.0258587524,
-0.0283209495,
-0.0059282207,
-0.03577682,
-0.1417755634,
0.0248538088,
0.0117309159,
-0.0205269977,
0.0265297946,
0.0252481699,
-0.0130565716,
-0.0049964353,
0.0050998568,
0.0338506065,
0.0703941584,
0.0630025044,
-0.0007622865,
-0.0133480178,
0.0024041082,
0.0414556675,
-0.072453998,
-0.0767123699,
0.0347163528,
0.0034046061,
0.0494464673,
-0.0058380966,
0.0012802602,
-0.0140763111,
-0.0036005981,
-0.0140956054,
0.0068695918,
0.0307839252,
0.032511197,
0.05392332,
0.0047928928,
-0.0248712953,
-0.0800586864,
0.0326080844,
-0.0303602759,
0.0226268712,
-0.0468444936,
-0.0300158896,
-0.0643424839,
0.0260991044,
0.0365955643,
0.0167662576,
0.0092806891,
0.0083840378,
-0.1053023115,
-0.0688280612,
0.0243809149,
-0.0075434772,
-0.0083222175,
-0.0233935304,
0.0451166965,
0.0322633646,
-0.0253455807,
-0.0194592346,
0.0111495992,
0.0430360101,
-0.025858894,
-0.0409413055,
-0.0380844325,
-6.284541774e-33,
-0.0021769013,
-0.0592999011,
0.0247791521,
0.0153843062,
-0.0120083867,
-0.0062165512,
-0.0294116531,
0.0243287254,
0.0180387888,
0.0126279127,
0.0144833373,
-0.0363803506,
-0.0036060256,
-0.0055672275,
0.0281776935,
-0.0425303169,
0.0260429066,
0.0165513046,
-0.0202457011,
0.0023173217,
0.0077090096,
0.0219720043,
-0.0113644907,
-0.0900596455,
0.0273123831,
0.0193638392,
0.0069073816,
-0.0354322419,
-0.0243939869,
0.0383681133,
-0.0060265646,
0.0489268191,
0.0294235814,
-0.0121649196,
-0.0697402433,
0.0693041608,
-0.0327968448,
-0.0581599586,
0.006862794,
-0.0005338071,
-0.0617767088,
0.0027269362,
0.0431896709,
0.0074244919,
-0.0215256065,
-0.0535510518,
0.0514246896,
-0.0090658236,
-0.0158475675,
0.0167257078,
0.0031321612,
0.0299999565,
-0.025304256,
-0.0059973467,
0.0296593923,
0.1200845391,
0.0160009693,
0.0465118997,
-0.0628094673,
0.0447410941,
0.0175070334,
-0.0906745419,
0.0456191786,
0.0502880551,
0.0339975096,
0.0309389438,
0.024032332,
-0.0056936927,
-0.0627898425,
0.0336963944,
0.0107431607,
0.0836423188,
0.071618326,
-0.0081088291,
0.0092040859,
0.006766032,
-0.0208464582,
0.0435489304,
-0.0475868024,
0.0000262494,
-0.0369227529,
0.0223048385,
-0.0516361184,
-0.0080544436,
-0.0114369681,
0.0038107403,
-0.0440487042,
-0.0086656734,
0.0503374077,
-0.0452141687,
0.0162633453,
0.0498377271,
0.0113324905,
0.0236155912,
-0.0176375881,
-0.0569667183,
0.0163615774,
0.0518896356,
0.0298863817,
-0.0368950367,
-0.0327776112,
0.0348925553,
-0.0114808753,
0.0025385127,
0.0463552922,
0.006450444,
0.0094293207,
0.0099129705,
-0.0644647479,
-0.0313527808,
-0.0192709193,
0.0060855686,
0.0073845857,
-0.0254910812,
0.0504747517,
-0.0217888094,
-0.0330990665,
0.0252901055,
0.0132374372,
0.0159367919,
-0.0399246514,
-0.0273241661,
-0.0705900118,
-0.020012429,
0.0344274342,
-0.0293608867,
-0.0061486978,
-0.0368390381,
0.0356220566,
-0.0454978682,
-0.0064167902,
-0.0370353386,
3.003e-7,
0.0357008316,
0.0522570647,
0.023507094,
0.0205536354,
0.0417663008,
0.0261391327,
-0.0548878238,
-0.0330369584,
0.0130783059,
-0.0348038115,
0.0115751205,
0.0253419783,
0.0646149591,
0.0885236338,
-0.0338098444,
-0.0580118261,
0.0236869138,
-0.0068812361,
-0.069849655,
0.0489767864,
0.0933904722,
-0.0165649783,
0.0320617594,
-0.0138168931,
0.0532925501,
-0.0181746073,
0.0515463836,
-0.0652424097,
0.0028089574,
-0.0407259203,
0.0083075818,
0.011525712,
0.0112556973,
0.037949089,
-0.0216069613,
-0.0389349461,
-0.0028930116,
0.0173882879,
0.0110106785,
0.0136742359,
0.0056687733,
0.0219326578,
0.0302422866,
-0.0619791299,
0.0469137803,
-0.0184784904,
-0.0365850963,
0.0418926179,
0.0038221793,
-0.0068608481,
0.0510738231,
-0.0179378074,
-0.0397673324,
-0.0257307962,
0.0067325677,
0.0131151685,
0.0161156338,
0.0081586381,
-0.0257610288,
0.0258877017,
-0.0570708252,
-0.0553858355,
-0.0500244163,
-0.0052086515,
-0.0161457583,
-0.0128120268,
-0.0477328598,
2.832742791e-34,
0.0321476273,
-0.0160284992,
0.0579947606,
-0.017086694,
0.051288873,
-0.0144018019,
0.0155518912,
0.0313161276,
0.0499439873,
-0.0606377833,
-0.0152926873
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06996v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06996v1
|
Quite Good, but Not Enough: Nationality Bias in Large Language Models -- A Case Study of ChatGPT
| 2024-05-11T12:11:52 | 2024-05-11T12:11:52 |
Shucheng Zhu, Weikang Wang, Ying Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While nationality is a pivotal demographic element that enhances the
performance of language models, it has received far less scrutiny regarding
inherent biases. This study investigates nationality bias in ChatGPT (GPT-3.5),
a large language model (LLM) designed for text generation. The research covers
195 countries, 4 temperature settings, and 3 distinct prompt types, generating
4,680 discourses about nationality descriptions in Chinese and English.
Automated metrics were used to analyze the nationality bias, and expert
annotators alongside ChatGPT itself evaluated the perceived bias. The results
show that ChatGPT's generated discourses are predominantly positive, especially
compared to its predecessor, GPT-2. However, when prompted with negative
inclinations, it occasionally produces negative content. Despite ChatGPT
considering its generated text as neutral, it shows consistent self-awareness
about nationality bias when subjected to the same pair-wise comparison
annotation framework used by human annotators. In conclusion, while ChatGPT's
generated texts seem friendly and positive, they reflect the inherent
nationality biases in the real world. This bias may vary across different
language versions of ChatGPT, indicating diverse cultural perspectives. The
study highlights the subtle and pervasive nature of biases within LLMs,
emphasizing the need for further scrutiny.
|
Quite Good, but Not Enough: Nationality Bias in Large Language Models -- A Case Study of ChatGPT: While nationality is a pivotal demographic element that enhances the
performance of language models, it has received far less scrutiny regarding
inherent biases. This study investigates nationality bias in ChatGPT (GPT-3.5),
a large language model (LLM) designed for text generation. The research covers
195 countries, 4 temperature settings, and 3 distinct prompt types, generating
4,680 discourses about nationality descriptions in Chinese and English.
Automated metrics were used to analyze the nationality bias, and expert
annotators alongside ChatGPT itself evaluated the perceived bias. The results
show that ChatGPT's generated discourses are predominantly positive, especially
compared to its predecessor, GPT-2. However, when prompted with negative
inclinations, it occasionally produces negative content. Despite ChatGPT
considering its generated text as neutral, it shows consistent self-awareness
about nationality bias when subjected to the same pair-wise comparison
annotation framework used by human annotators. In conclusion, while ChatGPT's
generated texts seem friendly and positive, they reflect the inherent
nationality biases in the real world. This bias may vary across different
language versions of ChatGPT, indicating diverse cultural perspectives. The
study highlights the subtle and pervasive nature of biases within LLMs,
emphasizing the need for further scrutiny.
|
[
0.0489297099,
0.0222264919,
-0.0246182792,
0.0106656551,
-0.0241955705,
0.0150294518,
0.0551746376,
-0.0380353965,
0.0212246664,
-0.0589835644,
-0.0228922255,
-0.0662518367,
0.0039971117,
-0.0116239665,
0.0129499333,
-0.0622607693,
0.025344044,
0.02835075,
0.0659672245,
-0.0285845269,
0.0397010446,
0.0410637148,
0.0239020102,
0.0625998005,
-0.0380511098,
-0.0006435807,
0.039928887,
0.0153669054,
0.0414170548,
-0.0200760923,
0.0367812254,
0.0706515759,
-0.0175799094,
0.047381103,
0.000002042,
-0.043548096,
0.0148586864,
-0.0073212683,
0.0399664529,
0.0382473506,
0.07557071,
0.0332026854,
-0.0167345088,
0.0231230445,
-0.0474128984,
-0.0155983074,
0.0491211712,
0.0391058363,
0.0710533187,
0.044952523,
-0.0086338893,
0.009354095,
-0.0541812852,
0.0003209777,
-0.0317730457,
0.0201889556,
0.018072553,
0.0357838683,
-0.0275727306,
0.0098809851,
0.013179251,
0.0045862338,
-0.0132869082,
-0.0172308218,
0.0019494342,
0.0288983136,
-0.0396989733,
-0.0423313864,
0.0240242034,
0.0391669236,
0.0708972216,
-0.0079303896,
-0.013968071,
-0.0098584928,
0.0018481321,
-0.0090586385,
-0.0097186249,
0.0621242411,
-0.0224768985,
0.0177631676,
0.0187997166,
-0.0050888504,
-0.0057012085,
0.0442436524,
0.018453626,
0.0511626974,
0.0107673081,
-0.0270958245,
-0.02580438,
0.0392809547,
0.012496626,
-0.0897589624,
0.0166393444,
0.0008897801,
-0.0305611808,
0.0112436712,
-0.0059328428,
0.0143236173,
0.0273705926,
-0.0769543275,
-0.0079516303,
0.040368557,
-0.0271008145,
-0.0101322308,
0.0171057973,
0.0194136593,
0.0068699992,
-0.0256344229,
-0.0371163934,
-0.0063234074,
-0.0099915341,
-0.0199790951,
0.0080289962,
-0.007699728,
0.0205438193,
0.0358510874,
-0.077473551,
-0.0195357315,
-0.0439587645,
-0.0058153132,
-0.0031147893,
-0.0069153788,
-0.0196424611,
0.0092327148,
-0.0393307135,
0.0566610359,
-0.0741208419,
-0.008098389,
-0.0218900535,
-0.0673795268,
0.0407717153,
0.0365494937,
-0.0264629293,
-0.0362755544,
-0.0316426568,
0.0122442162,
0.0065569496,
0.0206613578,
-0.0071745808,
-0.0385551639,
-0.0124423588,
-0.060311757,
-0.0238273386,
-0.0602206849,
0.0034414544,
0.0145861739,
-0.0062042102,
-0.0444291979,
0.0245870408,
0.0472352356,
-0.0213894509,
-0.0087193679,
-0.0297783352,
0.0277445875,
0.0829221979,
0.0116196023,
-0.0166895036,
0.0699340776,
0.0103112021,
0.0016888153,
0.0351973511,
-0.0151787894,
0.0120832482,
0.0231846496,
-0.0262067188,
0.0129370019,
-0.0267360639,
-0.0132872555,
-0.0223191753,
-0.0004230464,
0.0430956893,
0.0692169294,
-0.0193881914,
0.0079794489,
0.0483510233,
0.0283074323,
-0.0551903062,
0.0488631502,
0.0509651601,
0.034924075,
-0.0205039494,
0.0477283746,
-0.0187289231,
0.0176877696,
-0.0362686589,
-0.0133659849,
0.0277716648,
0.0623766147,
-0.0282751974,
-0.0379759744,
-0.0304825716,
0.0233869143,
0.048816517,
-0.014707353,
0.0014552857,
-0.0276666954,
0.0198729262,
0.0377118438,
0.0398723558,
-0.076497741,
0.0008599302,
-0.0218132529,
0.0114239333,
0.0599707924,
-0.0205264855,
0.0328237116,
-0.028329704,
-0.0237225331,
0.0113230487,
0.0706802979,
0.0843321458,
0.0003488675,
-0.0522224419,
-0.0449360013,
-0.0206984151,
-0.0067237159,
0.007488546,
0.0436112918,
0.0429664738,
0.0324227661,
0.0437232368,
0.0184960607,
-0.0576161407,
-0.002787347,
-0.0450401045,
0.015723655,
-0.0090006962,
-0.008788459,
0.0182530805,
0.0396854095,
-0.048747275,
0.0097604729,
-0.0307151359,
-0.0109687448,
-0.0181594901,
0.0861974359,
-0.0643705204,
-0.0088036042,
0.0214883052,
-0.061993286,
-0.0123350425,
-0.0463643894,
-0.00642002,
-0.0240469314,
0.0301190075,
0.0022873722,
-0.0264246557,
-0.0373933837,
-0.0118352445,
-0.0358370617,
0.0092601571,
-0.0180667862,
0.0416752435,
0.0015221606,
0.0050793719,
0.039220877,
-0.0018059782,
0.0440575741,
-0.0490644425,
-0.0433266871,
0.0260717701,
0.0259382315,
0.0038466584,
0.0791100711,
0.0227098558,
-0.0263148919,
-0.000785124,
-0.1320656538,
-0.0086127054,
-0.0212262925,
0.0029996259,
0.038273681,
-0.0057890541,
-0.0257371552,
0.0246468987,
-0.084305875,
-0.0352462269,
0.0012171092,
0.0407954194,
0.0273361132,
-0.0235844757,
0.0370383747,
-0.0125746252,
0.0063990392,
-0.0203419458,
0.0015506051,
0.0405395105,
-0.0157525819,
-0.04933374,
0.0174897872,
-0.0675491542,
-0.0341157839,
-0.0037505322,
-0.0607129447,
0.0199152976,
0.0442541093,
0.0496617407,
0.0130198244,
0.0453719385,
0.0022261955,
0.0502913222,
-0.0237033237,
-0.0053148805,
-0.0237846207,
0.010564357,
0.0438436307,
0.0128906062,
-0.113804467,
-0.0203449912,
0.0497064628,
0.027161872,
-0.0051234285,
-0.0676480532,
0.0564735234,
-0.0893608257,
-0.0239492431,
-0.0098013422,
-0.032880716,
-0.0084466655,
0.0433019549,
-0.0110524204,
-0.038023077,
0.0624587499,
-0.0060012089,
0.0154075697,
-0.0225798786,
-0.0052777948,
-0.0539104082,
0.0275923833,
-0.0024704731,
0.0457067564,
0.0269414391,
0.007172286,
-0.0373065248,
-0.0260274652,
0.0333021618,
-0.0157670993,
-0.0034115887,
-0.0395615399,
-0.0176240988,
-0.020804286,
-0.033394631,
-0.0251330659,
-0.0500444695,
-0.027187461,
0.0157346278,
0.0602155849,
-0.002844322,
0.0385747217,
0.0541099086,
0.03487207,
0.0052978857,
-0.0501003489,
0.0376398154,
0.0180838332,
0.0026276871,
0.0210298598,
-0.0048476891,
0.0440641046,
-0.0254805107,
0.0121705681,
0.0168276727,
-0.0177418292,
0.0116322599,
0.0234069452,
-0.0271527059,
0.0130683351,
-0.0192057788,
-0.0720969886,
-0.0155717833,
0.0816365331,
-0.0425837785,
0.0074962741,
0.1019691974,
0.0067651602,
-0.0466409326,
-0.0144480271,
-0.0219396465,
0.0430520959,
0.025487233,
0.0171784423,
-0.0892551988,
0.0422172286,
0.0029333641,
-0.0043316144,
-0.0767673403,
-0.0233834274,
-0.0369440243,
-0.1204082519,
0.0383229367,
0.0305168889,
-0.0317815468,
0.0311356168,
-0.0029687479,
-0.0280640051,
0.0164335091,
0.0356004871,
-0.0144268991,
0.0021846178,
0.0243723113,
0.0313548781,
-0.0985372812,
-0.0497505628,
0.0126528451,
-0.0343345925,
0.0740923807,
0.0177203733,
0.0606490374,
-0.0036030388,
-0.0131604634,
0.0308818202,
-0.0083219875,
0.0059152995,
-0.0336484797,
0.0241967179,
-0.0079043722,
-0.013725874,
-0.0413127132,
-0.0065790187,
0.0256307255,
0.0132464226,
0.035154175,
0.012008056,
0.004871455,
-0.0180884805,
-0.0160719063,
0.0429527238,
0.0114546623,
0.0825285688,
0.0191576742,
-0.0518356562,
-0.0120011792,
-0.0330331102,
0.0199896786,
-0.0275092404,
-0.0475350618,
0.0265030563,
-0.0327725373,
-0.0550801754,
-0.0612236597,
-0.0876533389,
-0.0045360187,
-0.0126100378,
0.0200285427,
-0.0187664181,
0.0004349168,
0.0096492479,
0.014216694,
0.0076928916,
-0.034796726,
0.0220612884,
-0.0039089904,
-0.0299506411,
0.0178801715,
-0.0458733402,
0.0090536205,
0.0043950747,
-0.017899435,
-0.048755154,
0.0120453089,
0.0328768194,
0.0181468893,
0.0357008092,
0.0174452327,
-0.0469516143,
0.0043489323,
0.0215159357,
0.0007102799,
0.0121044721,
-0.0144992778,
0.0446833372,
0.0079650646,
0.0192566272,
0.0002909157,
0.0459284149,
-0.0102885412,
0.0146965012,
-0.0176678095,
-0.0383274592,
0.0135318106,
0.0272004046,
0.0049453392,
-0.0413378291,
0.0158102419,
-0.0700766593,
-0.0311153103,
-0.0626993254,
-0.0382130705,
-0.0234437343,
-0.0329334624,
0.0057557742,
-0.0036055245,
-0.014289164,
-0.0115468903,
-0.0541651696,
0.0192910321,
-0.0145386681,
0.0430406742,
-0.0100156516,
0.0660097599,
-0.0004595576,
-0.0119259264,
-0.0406122729,
0.0098097706,
-0.0018311532,
0.0262111556,
-0.0155781172,
0.0727559701,
-0.0030604531,
-0.021870235,
0.0508481935,
0.0057346742,
-0.0171104968,
-0.0067280629,
-0.0106115844,
0.0173798352,
0.0711974874,
-0.0151840085,
0.0941523612,
-0.006076524,
-0.0011396789,
-0.0088774571,
0.0313951485,
0.032356821,
-0.0565051772,
0.0104207005,
-0.027693985,
-0.0572459027,
-0.0122470902,
0.0651442632,
0.0016308971,
0.0075416542,
0.0253068227,
-0.0635908768,
-0.0106784254,
-0.0189170409,
-0.0095237251,
-0.0342997387,
-0.011524044,
-0.0073958621,
-0.1047790498,
-0.0247388314,
-0.0275170151,
0.001107618,
0.0144074932,
-0.0224807076,
0.0026203543,
0.0617138669,
-0.0398640744,
-0.0139830904,
-0.0650890619,
0.0076272995,
-0.0646146983,
0.0123241395,
-0.0099906232,
-6.637211385e-33,
-0.0401145406,
-0.0358354375,
0.0116029279,
0.0013397755,
-0.0438600294,
-0.020119762,
-0.0334939472,
0.029754227,
-0.0040063057,
0.0358558632,
-0.0100589851,
-0.0218217093,
0.0147697031,
-0.0119563686,
0.0281492267,
-0.0078483243,
0.0570377596,
0.0190094113,
-0.0294198431,
0.0383438282,
0.0304247774,
-0.0083710551,
0.0639091954,
-0.0608779602,
0.0545193739,
-0.0398718864,
-0.0161326807,
0.0113015091,
0.0220272783,
0.0154359415,
-0.0223054197,
0.0573409535,
0.040770784,
-0.0050690724,
-0.0182693861,
0.0021881545,
0.008097548,
-0.0310146939,
0.0260345917,
0.0230392888,
0.0325512439,
-0.0642398372,
0.0113457264,
-0.0261972062,
-0.06177954,
0.0353162177,
0.0514220819,
-0.0110416953,
0.03575911,
-0.0055841422,
-0.0593729727,
0.047326345,
-0.0063951937,
0.0385832377,
-0.0209382009,
0.071305193,
-0.0106577864,
-0.0276022162,
-0.0353385769,
0.0225639939,
0.0362505354,
0.016761139,
0.0536756925,
0.01162076,
0.0144088743,
0.0468733311,
0.0593444556,
0.0811846554,
-0.0374451503,
-0.0416181162,
0.0199036356,
-0.0354269743,
0.0078741712,
0.1030788869,
-0.0174135249,
-0.0542856753,
-0.0386708155,
0.0024583112,
0.0676174164,
0.0053824801,
0.0448268242,
-0.0422115512,
-0.0306939799,
-0.0593325533,
-0.0217936616,
-0.0502809957,
-0.0244943518,
-0.0608418845,
0.0340503566,
-0.0163182262,
-0.0033190208,
-0.0291062556,
0.0401539691,
-0.0130765401,
-0.0185219944,
0.0284151658,
-0.0501371473,
-0.0273887943,
-0.0075446391,
0.0344401225,
-0.0514363758,
-0.0246363822,
-0.0209748689,
0.0312258229,
-0.0011479056,
0.0279108379,
0.0089495331,
0.005148056,
-0.0579661541,
-0.0062678563,
-0.0248700697,
0.0200311802,
-0.0189441107,
-0.0042037396,
-0.0013523964,
0.004161899,
-0.0179884769,
0.0067880838,
0.0602456741,
0.0267192349,
-0.0541132949,
-0.0380251482,
-0.0073621697,
0.0240631104,
-0.0272257142,
0.0360017791,
0.0068265116,
0.039693553,
0.0403249003,
-0.0258180276,
-0.0237947553,
-0.0504706725,
2.7e-7,
0.0134606343,
0.0805652216,
-0.0360948294,
0.001445168,
0.0365770124,
0.0295804963,
0.0001918958,
0.0083431248,
0.057762932,
0.0208849516,
0.0016863502,
-0.0124538271,
0.0439737476,
0.0941915065,
-0.0905106366,
0.0320178755,
-0.0655832291,
0.0165169463,
-0.0308956895,
0.0244171098,
0.029086953,
0.0144782439,
0.0050638025,
0.0037394557,
-0.0535139628,
-0.0133983782,
0.0720805526,
-0.064205423,
-0.0264738351,
0.0478113107,
0.0531873479,
-0.0039013622,
0.0287604481,
0.0188268591,
0.0148125887,
0.0128464699,
0.0200275965,
0.0432291441,
0.020862218,
0.0125530446,
0.0278555583,
0.0219464693,
0.0058951299,
-0.0969946906,
0.0392539836,
-0.0072287321,
-0.0306269117,
-0.0565893576,
-0.0162652917,
-0.0268223882,
0.0563773401,
-0.0333418958,
-0.0381396636,
0.0406474657,
0.0081901224,
-0.0015682877,
0.0007851339,
-0.0101621384,
-0.0468610451,
-0.0317104161,
-0.018776549,
-0.070526503,
-0.0131426603,
0.0316534303,
-0.0459045358,
0.0056659747,
0.0476816297,
2.229622813e-34,
0.0231692232,
-0.0054456308,
0.003619588,
-0.0059096362,
0.0543217734,
0.0394177921,
0.0177555326,
-0.0003401799,
0.0066636768,
0.0065128449,
-0.0191543158
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06981v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06981v1
|
AraSpell: A Deep Learning Approach for Arabic Spelling Correction
| 2024-05-11T10:36:28 | 2024-05-11T10:36:28 |
Mahmoud Salhab, Faisal Abu-Khzam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Spelling correction is the task of identifying spelling mistakes, typos, and
grammatical mistakes in a given text and correcting them according to their
context and grammatical structure. This work introduces "AraSpell," a framework
for Arabic spelling correction using different seq2seq model architectures such
as Recurrent Neural Network (RNN) and Transformer with artificial data
generation for error injection, trained on more than 6.9 Million Arabic
sentences. Thorough experimental studies provide empirical evidence of the
effectiveness of the proposed approach, which achieved 4.8% and 1.11% word
error rate (WER) and character error rate (CER), respectively, in comparison
with labeled data of 29.72% WER and 5.03% CER. Our approach achieved 2.9% CER
and 10.65% WER in comparison with labeled data of 10.02% CER and 50.94% WER.
Both of these results are obtained on a test set of 100K sentences.
|
AraSpell: A Deep Learning Approach for Arabic Spelling Correction: Spelling correction is the task of identifying spelling mistakes, typos, and
grammatical mistakes in a given text and correcting them according to their
context and grammatical structure. This work introduces "AraSpell," a framework
for Arabic spelling correction using different seq2seq model architectures such
as Recurrent Neural Network (RNN) and Transformer with artificial data
generation for error injection, trained on more than 6.9 Million Arabic
sentences. Thorough experimental studies provide empirical evidence of the
effectiveness of the proposed approach, which achieved 4.8% and 1.11% word
error rate (WER) and character error rate (CER), respectively, in comparison
with labeled data of 29.72% WER and 5.03% CER. Our approach achieved 2.9% CER
and 10.65% WER in comparison with labeled data of 10.02% CER and 50.94% WER.
Both of these results are obtained on a test set of 100K sentences.
|
[
0.0398552753,
0.0136240236,
0.0109366905,
0.0191196278,
-0.0305312462,
0.0194711387,
0.0273634605,
-0.0462866873,
-0.0197974127,
-0.0620990805,
0.0117896069,
-0.07081604,
0.0645113289,
0.0045589898,
0.0465475954,
-0.0277470332,
0.04983126,
-0.0296128821,
-0.0105035035,
0.0087095518,
0.0337803029,
0.0037611255,
-0.0356866233,
0.0212129019,
-0.0222224742,
-0.0215621404,
-0.01005942,
0.0152502079,
0.0134363435,
0.0218681861,
0.0354771838,
0.0356632844,
-0.0304451622,
0.0745334551,
0.0000020767,
-0.051530391,
-0.0313146003,
-0.034679804,
0.0136849191,
0.033400394,
0.0228583384,
-0.0352458581,
-0.0886814147,
0.0397275425,
0.0226393435,
0.0021197267,
0.0672728345,
0.0615504161,
0.0512538403,
0.0557198785,
-0.0091092531,
-0.0464764088,
0.0380127616,
-0.0105197765,
0.0150858462,
-0.0012316876,
0.0232433863,
-0.0449417345,
-0.0414001606,
-0.0081814267,
-0.0638012588,
0.0314743482,
-0.0118489647,
-0.0591257252,
-0.0167217776,
-0.0405919924,
0.0289779194,
-0.0270315316,
0.0006815738,
0.025989756,
-0.0275298003,
-0.0252461787,
-0.0240738839,
0.021842178,
0.0041433889,
-0.006608746,
0.0175944064,
0.0347311012,
-0.0282937028,
-0.0007567772,
0.0512037314,
-0.0538636856,
0.0359634496,
0.0225891732,
-0.0322834179,
0.0202969909,
0.0262541324,
-0.0637155771,
-0.0288572628,
0.0081494879,
0.0473889858,
-0.0203444082,
0.0508950353,
0.0085115014,
-0.0201351177,
-0.0285217538,
-0.0346415602,
-0.0946734101,
-0.0138688581,
-0.0410924293,
0.0306430329,
0.0120425671,
-0.0126904007,
0.0067836368,
-0.0406867899,
0.0455117486,
0.0501316004,
0.0235860292,
0.0144065432,
0.0009439801,
-0.0359295383,
0.0227926355,
-0.021423487,
0.0269232653,
-0.0395367295,
0.0135654574,
-0.0992358476,
-0.0162139088,
-0.0266003143,
0.0193209779,
0.0220058449,
0.00591711,
-0.0422518589,
-0.0284536667,
-0.0089613423,
0.0062335478,
0.0415588096,
0.0290308632,
-0.0241878089,
-0.0661582053,
0.0233103354,
0.0040073576,
0.0449522063,
0.0145666525,
0.0096507128,
0.0312079024,
-0.0135469558,
-0.044569321,
-0.0424422063,
0.023035707,
-0.0158207752,
0.0037480572,
-0.0690378621,
-0.0819182843,
-0.010238667,
-0.0515649132,
0.0004936116,
-0.0097746318,
0.0063693998,
0.035651803,
0.0007056856,
0.1029622555,
-0.0395530351,
0.0121564222,
0.0567498207,
-0.0072223195,
0.0555728972,
-0.0208694693,
0.0448192693,
-0.0159688219,
0.0144382557,
0.0070070215,
0.0652571768,
0.0253081825,
-0.0530386157,
-0.0286997575,
-0.0070974436,
-0.0883866772,
-0.023723511,
0.066183269,
0.0188049432,
0.0842864811,
-0.0081814658,
0.0236031581,
0.0634601265,
-0.010129842,
0.0333598591,
0.0603542291,
0.0039075427,
-0.031679634,
0.0214777645,
-0.0160694886,
-0.0212985612,
0.0050545023,
0.0064347964,
0.0039296281,
0.0159422755,
0.0299616046,
-0.0244319662,
-0.0572071746,
-0.0127399946,
-0.0187346376,
0.011114982,
-0.0348550342,
0.070023872,
0.0136158913,
-0.0775644481,
-0.0107240342,
-0.024952881,
-0.0315695107,
0.0156592876,
-0.0318819247,
-0.0007975812,
0.0996614471,
0.0502438322,
0.0035204815,
-0.034259975,
-0.0324216485,
-0.0467111394,
0.055600062,
0.0275474396,
-0.0215421971,
0.0033764946,
-0.0620065294,
-0.0216300488,
0.0346149281,
-0.0014980966,
-0.0145845227,
0.011363728,
0.0485982411,
0.0121949883,
-0.0111753345,
-0.0469263867,
0.0275010206,
-0.0163747147,
-0.0199105162,
-0.0021460741,
0.0364506319,
-0.0315096006,
0.0256845821,
-0.0212775003,
0.0024550408,
-0.0242156889,
-0.0315245427,
-0.0456804335,
-0.0231847707,
-0.0413119905,
-0.0225141458,
0.0509483889,
-0.0774210021,
-0.0075297765,
0.0640097708,
-0.0283920355,
-0.0536608472,
0.0178067256,
-0.0525692925,
0.0016907101,
-0.0824803561,
0.0520443209,
0.0121841524,
0.0059757507,
-0.018918369,
0.0097690606,
-0.0171710961,
-0.0050964775,
-0.009663444,
0.0096455328,
-0.0082721692,
0.0039100372,
-0.0538148284,
-0.0332480073,
-0.0065522511,
0.0318920761,
0.0299665611,
0.0174661204,
-0.0154561475,
-0.0369472541,
-0.0218578577,
-0.0119440267,
-0.0290265046,
0.0025160383,
0.0167193227,
0.0342789963,
0.010116403,
-0.023937365,
-0.0247251224,
-0.0002232038,
0.0255410317,
0.0070337011,
0.0993676782,
-0.0426184125,
-0.0151617154,
-0.0596318506,
-0.0220594797,
-0.0183448382,
-0.0183934793,
0.0319499411,
-0.0662769377,
-0.027404096,
0.0158821102,
0.0086060641,
0.0563910529,
0.0419588648,
-0.0595078431,
0.0031316476,
-0.020410331,
0.0400370993,
0.0334867388,
0.0218053777,
0.0211088322,
-0.0074236253,
0.0006429713,
0.0008867823,
0.002482218,
-0.003629473,
-0.0169926528,
-0.0054367539,
-0.0280234981,
-0.015879266,
0.043263685,
-0.0211176053,
-0.0043272339,
-0.0165597051,
-0.004979365,
-0.0061811735,
0.0250736289,
-0.0039756093,
-0.0148824602,
0.0065014316,
0.0364998803,
-0.0259404629,
-0.0254983176,
0.0080869813,
0.0043939934,
0.0340277478,
-0.0398709364,
0.0028130631,
-0.0123082353,
-0.070955947,
-0.0350396819,
0.0276315399,
-0.0592529662,
-0.0723769292,
-0.048406966,
-0.0281860251,
0.0307886768,
-0.0256782714,
0.0484701358,
-0.0547381416,
0.0133216195,
-0.0182383433,
-0.0233791247,
-0.0350852907,
0.0411671959,
-0.0327741466,
-0.0321259759,
0.035351716,
-0.030331919,
-0.0361167975,
-0.0007770626,
0.011830627,
0.0838487893,
0.0008933208,
-0.0257019941,
0.003062563,
-0.0141187301,
0.0264425613,
-0.0121177994,
0.0614285208,
-0.0052994122,
0.0559771396,
0.0495660305,
-0.0284047034,
0.0086203478,
-0.0537417755,
-0.0071638515,
0.0215659831,
-0.0461658165,
-0.0274165086,
-0.0254941843,
0.0071040662,
-0.0636117086,
-0.0383537896,
0.0985535607,
0.0064540012,
-0.0496636331,
-0.032988809,
0.0095812939,
-0.0526940525,
-0.0055415384,
-0.0072712484,
-0.0920057744,
-0.017411964,
0.066003561,
0.0075470549,
-0.0006577198,
-0.0210476704,
0.0566746742,
-0.114694804,
0.0279300846,
0.0139855044,
-0.0172371455,
-0.0930634439,
0.0211532172,
-0.0023554869,
0.0045770169,
0.0368869193,
0.0133406473,
-0.0270465557,
-0.0194418635,
0.0474813692,
-0.0476515293,
-0.0764971226,
-0.0196367092,
-0.0562257878,
0.0256000627,
0.0547758304,
0.0118043413,
-0.0205680318,
-0.0473241992,
0.0013009321,
0.0239316169,
-0.0439486429,
0.0086089922,
0.020754857,
-0.0005667771,
-0.0339098871,
-0.0447590128,
0.004338617,
-0.0598433837,
0.0226092413,
-0.0396569185,
0.0280137248,
-0.0183447804,
0.0306518897,
0.009980985,
-0.0032757248,
-0.0001565439,
0.0149501953,
-0.0116734868,
-0.0334248506,
-0.0721888393,
-0.0150101846,
-0.0033598137,
-0.0988045782,
-0.0023753287,
0.0358434543,
-0.0043302192,
-0.0293679759,
-0.0899822563,
-0.062738575,
0.0131142214,
0.007582318,
0.0447956882,
0.016137708,
0.0097938133,
0.021697782,
-0.0258511677,
-0.0799928755,
0.0110500036,
0.0297057629,
-0.0648838952,
0.0153737878,
-0.0338781774,
-0.0199873243,
0.0327856466,
-0.0114191053,
-0.0434325896,
-0.0090547623,
0.0712164491,
0.0066478071,
0.0053918478,
0.0017812727,
-0.0222256873,
-0.0537029169,
0.0472924933,
0.031459108,
0.0428446867,
0.0236570481,
0.0174406655,
-0.0255016387,
-0.015198851,
0.0248798169,
0.0131356642,
0.0045900913,
-0.0124869617,
0.007166802,
0.0064500896,
-0.0412262976,
0.0065584425,
-0.026610693,
0.0572247133,
-0.0148733128,
-0.0112429271,
-0.0687599853,
0.0202283412,
0.0202222504,
0.03130145,
-0.0159615446,
0.0361874364,
0.0300014224,
0.0332204066,
-0.00467559,
-0.0045203771,
0.0146944057,
-0.0397455171,
0.019864155,
0.0257052165,
0.0150388246,
0.0479558967,
-0.0000476195,
0.0142257977,
0.0087395152,
-0.0160587765,
0.0380285382,
0.0334291123,
-0.0057499814,
-0.0223352816,
0.0011634433,
0.0530410074,
0.0017933144,
0.043520093,
0.0133556249,
0.0171540454,
-0.0399514847,
0.030988073,
0.0922922939,
-0.015009311,
0.0431488827,
-0.0040817522,
0.0027073042,
-0.0327708051,
0.034079399,
-0.0087535381,
0.0304472055,
0.0047317068,
-0.0119436886,
0.0269529521,
0.001810739,
0.0202757437,
0.0061811628,
0.0286644157,
0.0107320268,
-0.0310475454,
-0.0045458558,
0.0048276712,
-0.0101934867,
-0.0521029644,
-0.0594148636,
-0.0380478837,
-0.010083409,
-0.0883299559,
0.040250618,
0.0474460162,
0.0244886689,
0.0326689146,
0.0039487639,
0.0417835526,
0.0369335897,
0.0208667107,
-0.0583048873,
0.000393746,
0.0455076434,
-0.0488498509,
0.0159910452,
-5.994180711e-33,
0.0202016514,
0.0019916573,
0.0090414071,
-0.0134462984,
0.0006915246,
0.0007834446,
-0.0176607892,
-0.0154459421,
-0.0054710479,
0.0691548437,
-0.020303946,
0.0307464432,
0.0232517906,
0.0153974276,
0.0638777837,
0.0085411565,
0.0738270506,
0.0134572405,
0.0171281919,
-0.0148561187,
0.0298678838,
0.0854597166,
0.1196028218,
-0.0283741411,
0.010928723,
0.0043133097,
-0.0299134608,
0.029928863,
0.0061853915,
0.0507484078,
0.0190281831,
0.0436385237,
-0.0042374427,
-0.00651243,
-0.0073175519,
0.0101988567,
-0.0956695229,
-0.0190549213,
-0.0375200436,
0.0710917711,
-0.0398743413,
-0.0264986195,
0.0423977114,
0.0038231579,
-0.0464472249,
0.0150835831,
0.0303608198,
-0.0195661001,
0.0188141353,
-0.0189788137,
-0.0641372129,
0.011929593,
0.0278366506,
0.0014869388,
-0.0054995595,
0.0307224263,
-0.0216266364,
-0.012158093,
-0.1168502569,
0.0035736344,
0.0290057715,
0.0508171394,
0.0225225314,
0.0172846131,
-0.0818831772,
0.0071262955,
0.0026702459,
-0.0015866258,
0.0216980018,
0.0284148119,
0.0340224802,
-0.0339831524,
0.0744251236,
0.0605243854,
0.0490080155,
-0.0602697134,
-0.0632164851,
0.0339414813,
-0.0311604869,
0.0710313842,
-0.0016963655,
-0.0266069379,
-0.0427729376,
-0.0004232915,
0.0163194016,
0.0283194613,
-0.0129624484,
0.0164516997,
0.0315137282,
0.0359647125,
0.0096103996,
0.0450615361,
-0.0473956056,
-0.0333299078,
0.0191831496,
-0.0404492654,
0.0131100239,
0.0035538138,
-0.0340030305,
-0.014817399,
0.0053846641,
-0.0287914257,
0.0008354125,
0.0760366693,
-0.0009288451,
0.027671475,
0.0455436632,
0.0684142634,
-0.0909703821,
0.0134744877,
-0.0060602389,
0.0488544665,
0.0417148322,
0.0346683487,
-0.0293432493,
-0.0467017926,
0.0128695322,
0.0126833804,
-0.0025996193,
0.0234167371,
0.0040499172,
-0.044596713,
-0.01476203,
-0.0217351634,
-0.0180563293,
-0.0076610949,
-0.0622260645,
-0.0008500042,
-0.0073618768,
-0.0658992007,
0.0119643724,
-0.0085633593,
2.773e-7,
0.0178467631,
0.0644186884,
0.0565752536,
-0.0321609788,
-0.0059959674,
0.0105893556,
0.0032460915,
0.049343247,
-0.0127516333,
0.055388663,
0.0440188162,
-0.0180172622,
0.048080191,
-0.0229097288,
-0.0767124295,
-0.034179531,
-0.0506707206,
0.058088243,
0.0044256449,
-0.0096100988,
0.0110164471,
0.0901337862,
-0.0099208998,
-0.0484457053,
-0.0181743223,
-0.0158527549,
0.0208322294,
0.0169504117,
0.001832256,
0.005828118,
0.0996162072,
0.0304134861,
0.0560128242,
-0.0107749356,
-0.0465385243,
-0.0196422711,
0.0057947789,
0.02235917,
-0.0314074717,
0.0338051841,
0.0116247898,
-0.003838842,
0.0002702891,
-0.0259640366,
0.0183956046,
0.0129147368,
0.0514954329,
0.0135339145,
-0.0131529309,
0.0302557796,
0.0514442921,
-0.0435628667,
-0.0057320301,
0.0043135658,
0.050653141,
0.029279368,
-0.0258666649,
-0.0348564237,
0.0340030827,
-0.0160993487,
0.0493639074,
0.0273386296,
0.0198876578,
-0.0311289728,
0.0018420619,
0.0121012572,
-0.0088686747,
2.193390955e-34,
0.0214531329,
-0.0030656531,
0.0288881361,
-0.0007659548,
0.0174221322,
-0.004456942,
-0.001893778,
0.0190979019,
-0.0021611571,
-0.0180552322,
-0.0320295915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06932v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06932v1
|
Piccolo2: General Text Embedding with Multi-task Hybrid Loss Training
| 2024-05-11T06:32:08 | 2024-05-11T06:32:08 |
Junqin Huang, Zhongjie Hu, Zihao Jing, Mengya Gao, Yichao Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this report, we introduce Piccolo2, an embedding model that surpasses
other models in the comprehensive evaluation over 6 tasks on CMTEB benchmark,
setting a new state-of-the-art. Piccolo2 primarily leverages an efficient
multi-task hybrid loss training approach, effectively harnessing textual data
and labels from diverse downstream tasks. In addition, Piccolo2 scales up the
embedding dimension and uses MRL training to support more flexible vector
dimensions. The latest information of piccolo models can be accessed via:
https://huggingface.co/sensenova/
|
Piccolo2: General Text Embedding with Multi-task Hybrid Loss Training: In this report, we introduce Piccolo2, an embedding model that surpasses
other models in the comprehensive evaluation over 6 tasks on CMTEB benchmark,
setting a new state-of-the-art. Piccolo2 primarily leverages an efficient
multi-task hybrid loss training approach, effectively harnessing textual data
and labels from diverse downstream tasks. In addition, Piccolo2 scales up the
embedding dimension and uses MRL training to support more flexible vector
dimensions. The latest information of piccolo models can be accessed via:
https://huggingface.co/sensenova/
|
[
-0.0193315148,
-0.0176921319,
0.0239756759,
0.0451560691,
0.012278093,
0.0192327481,
-0.0009194296,
-0.0132243885,
-0.0024986209,
0.0116882985,
-0.0523182005,
-0.0368880071,
-0.0170917213,
-0.0004661712,
0.0508464091,
-0.0154380156,
0.004393883,
0.0378806293,
-0.0013882886,
0.0265036542,
0.0436898991,
0.0124600306,
0.0220196862,
0.0434091613,
-0.0184937976,
-0.0355739817,
-0.0030799455,
0.0431906991,
0.041932676,
-0.0371633209,
0.0297122616,
0.0121430382,
0.0741289034,
0.0400164574,
0.0000018104,
0.020629961,
0.0041857227,
0.0183824748,
-0.0366298854,
0.0140221436,
0.0636456236,
-0.0026532274,
0.0120316576,
0.0094107073,
-0.0003959191,
-0.0070010102,
0.0397724174,
0.0745247006,
0.0525358506,
0.0828547254,
-0.0101921856,
0.0071133641,
0.0360601805,
-0.0776307061,
0.0354340039,
-0.0096141016,
0.0100588333,
0.0011853842,
-0.0217924733,
0.046230454,
-0.0040367646,
0.0394687019,
0.0454352424,
0.0129355239,
-0.000954932,
0.0485857837,
0.0267033819,
0.0080124056,
0.0183295086,
0.083932057,
-0.0193293393,
0.0011718177,
-0.0120978048,
-0.0123086693,
-0.0046121757,
-0.0554656237,
-0.0473803282,
-0.0119264126,
0.0025933338,
0.0216635726,
-0.0420145877,
0.0468032658,
0.0413232781,
-0.015793398,
0.0254991874,
-0.0232792925,
-0.0214756839,
-0.0519802272,
0.000354086,
-0.0194766186,
0.0077399141,
0.0347504579,
0.0163481664,
-0.0181118026,
-0.0058941236,
0.0050543086,
-0.0413745679,
-0.073367022,
0.0196763892,
-0.082399033,
0.0594855249,
0.0161576327,
-0.0305400398,
0.071165055,
-0.0305902343,
0.0302538108,
-0.0400213003,
0.0376867168,
-0.0183837544,
-0.0087098274,
-0.0576633364,
-0.0290331393,
-0.0246798638,
0.0178362634,
-0.0360896401,
-0.0432379805,
0.0043080822,
0.0200623237,
-0.0211490635,
0.0046695359,
0.0471131578,
0.0262304768,
-0.0550652929,
-0.0244130623,
0.017243864,
0.0325723179,
-0.0333272628,
0.0136706242,
0.0202039815,
0.0232727956,
-0.038466759,
0.0336005315,
0.0038305281,
-0.0412983745,
0.0132342838,
0.0435191281,
-0.0474508666,
-0.0383489244,
-0.0082278987,
-0.0067468318,
-0.0348389372,
-0.0672973767,
-0.0045919386,
-0.0342574269,
0.0586508028,
-0.0582064614,
-0.003885129,
-0.022904722,
0.0072687184,
0.0260458961,
-0.0189426765,
0.0756165311,
0.0464526229,
-0.0578216501,
-0.0051583517,
0.0529475138,
-0.0213701949,
0.0871125534,
-0.0198545717,
0.0513612218,
0.0127231814,
0.0447304025,
-0.0433063209,
-0.0031675596,
0.0228345804,
0.0067547797,
0.02493174,
0.0348333418,
0.0386245549,
0.0723646879,
0.0517041273,
0.0211950522,
-0.0471965149,
-0.0311253238,
0.0589267798,
0.0036631806,
0.0273745395,
-0.0200213119,
0.0468838513,
0.0385546833,
-0.0191668626,
-0.025514029,
-0.0265249629,
0.0283855945,
0.0412439331,
-0.0112049989,
0.0149003863,
0.0414395519,
-0.0495124124,
-0.0131036434,
0.004074377,
-0.0347949341,
-0.0180881489,
-0.0299550984,
0.0468031652,
-0.0171385817,
-0.057133425,
0.0200709552,
0.0345723256,
-0.0273995306,
-0.0184644386,
-0.0007527827,
0.0009630867,
0.0479302667,
0.0305240937,
-0.0747680739,
-0.0409332924,
-0.0320534296,
0.0806032643,
0.0302728694,
0.0058249119,
-0.014339109,
0.0748627782,
-0.0844705775,
-0.019836694,
-0.0206303746,
0.033262223,
0.0352034606,
-0.0075661265,
0.0307971332,
0.0247270502,
-0.0442416929,
0.0242860485,
0.0289487243,
-0.0232379064,
-0.0147207268,
0.0030530284,
0.0243514553,
-0.024369346,
-0.0017034924,
-0.0247442722,
0.0093973726,
0.0495770425,
-0.0507734977,
-0.0500015058,
-0.0186972171,
-0.0466873981,
-0.0806624889,
0.032080669,
-0.0448271036,
-0.0077576414,
0.0523574762,
-0.0409281552,
-0.0118996194,
-0.0257324371,
-0.0012111795,
-0.0028680589,
-0.0120747183,
-0.031942036,
0.0013890713,
0.000972894,
-0.0293826107,
0.0487012826,
-0.0287730042,
0.0037006817,
-0.0093481541,
-0.0149714947,
0.0096282009,
-0.0387486406,
-0.0309304986,
-0.0047083185,
0.0016731771,
0.0386776216,
-0.0283655468,
-0.0003046556,
-0.0091234725,
-0.0429250784,
-0.0568614304,
0.0263083931,
-0.0319837146,
-0.0124692619,
0.0050685839,
-0.0272881705,
0.0207007527,
-0.0220895596,
-0.032094907,
-0.0228538644,
-0.0460822545,
0.0242146924,
0.0107541084,
-0.0126695298,
0.0452810414,
-0.0042002336,
-0.0089113778,
-0.0034749229,
0.0538847856,
-0.043385487,
-0.0208668932,
-0.010574121,
-0.0309849828,
0.0246047471,
-0.0203648396,
-0.0520983748,
0.0108763445,
-0.0261432398,
-0.0044434061,
0.037592046,
0.0838121772,
-0.02804989,
0.0406360626,
-0.006239519,
0.0193816889,
-0.0142475078,
0.0307384972,
0.0065588765,
0.052829612,
-0.0454670228,
-0.010695409,
-0.0010011963,
0.0381853618,
-0.0295251589,
0.0257725362,
-0.057736598,
-0.0179142132,
-0.004291018,
-0.0172116682,
-0.0500146411,
0.0275865216,
-0.0444054529,
-0.0511468463,
-0.0451838486,
-0.0195135847,
0.0123527655,
-0.0279218443,
-0.0363800079,
-0.0416467115,
-0.0441849642,
-0.021034535,
0.0410152972,
0.0010544005,
0.0343811847,
0.0480780117,
-0.0026313527,
-0.0532366596,
0.0376807377,
0.0283205938,
-0.0004566062,
0.0225481596,
0.0346580856,
-0.0330942422,
-0.0432437584,
-0.051346954,
0.0019538605,
-0.0631297976,
0.0300016757,
0.0133136418,
0.0268128477,
-0.0116678867,
-0.075239487,
-0.0276435707,
0.0007743658,
0.0393935703,
-0.0376521274,
-0.0163868498,
-0.0214979686,
0.0737434179,
0.0306435823,
0.0003143525,
-0.0214068871,
-0.0304371566,
0.0168504361,
0.0719782636,
0.0180590861,
-0.0248646289,
-0.0100395912,
-0.0161701906,
-0.0123944404,
0.0344950594,
-0.0063717463,
-0.0027607048,
0.0612112843,
-0.046511177,
-0.0128784673,
0.0581266843,
0.0148397405,
-0.0514891334,
-0.0350776017,
0.0166206565,
0.038138777,
0.0092450343,
-0.0010412346,
-0.0500243716,
-0.0452561267,
0.0012092941,
0.0242199656,
0.0609400831,
0.0122749703,
-0.0063909562,
-0.0312375575,
0.0093673868,
0.0019046614,
-0.0328124948,
-0.035005454,
-0.0121278306,
-0.0233070701,
-0.0218895283,
0.0107554523,
-0.023590805,
-0.0046899989,
-0.0310099274,
0.0389903449,
-0.0098773278,
-0.0567524731,
-0.0007159123,
-0.0464309268,
0.0309232958,
0.0018966746,
0.0573970973,
0.0255737603,
0.0091092885,
0.010260704,
0.0208275579,
-0.0363477096,
0.0209828392,
0.0829368085,
-0.03014002,
0.0123959919,
-0.0272865091,
0.004916145,
-0.0094882706,
0.0034412397,
0.0136125525,
0.1132201776,
0.0283931494,
0.00670214,
-0.0319883227,
-0.021967696,
0.016019728,
0.073955223,
0.021686608,
-0.0260213856,
-0.039794568,
-0.0183421336,
0.016601963,
-0.0490005389,
-0.035308186,
0.0063229362,
-0.0108840941,
-0.0187113937,
-0.0393215567,
-0.0552822389,
0.0202168692,
0.059248101,
-0.0298327077,
-0.0131622348,
-0.0508413985,
-0.030608885,
-0.0892112255,
0.0157948192,
-0.0421852432,
0.0456869118,
-0.0245210603,
0.0341905057,
0.0236382075,
-0.0037445771,
-0.0301029794,
0.0042884406,
-0.1280212104,
-0.0466521718,
-0.062817052,
0.0190097317,
0.0056436886,
0.0339847319,
-0.0181093775,
-0.0136702824,
0.0767201409,
-0.001741084,
-0.0579224713,
0.0025782483,
0.0807161331,
-0.0301272292,
-0.0116432477,
0.0413724296,
-0.0096109081,
-0.0062975381,
-0.0065733604,
0.0057967482,
0.0178300925,
0.0461489521,
0.0080092717,
-0.0991313532,
0.0341839045,
0.0210876688,
-0.0115057277,
-0.053462293,
0.0230048317,
0.0022469636,
-0.0213122852,
-0.0380276851,
0.0206858236,
0.0537059121,
0.0060962439,
-0.0008597155,
0.0246711522,
0.0565430559,
0.044443585,
-0.0530723967,
0.0179384947,
0.0061887135,
0.0078608021,
0.032611981,
0.0460642911,
-0.0220625661,
-0.007179644,
-0.0279060695,
0.0044799275,
-0.0190139748,
0.0326503366,
0.0180673935,
-0.0026321183,
-0.0084267808,
0.067679882,
-0.0471500494,
-0.0040047821,
-0.0377201326,
-0.0078372955,
0.0464099161,
0.0058834003,
0.0359829813,
0.0029592982,
-0.0249288622,
-0.0264179856,
0.0067237499,
-0.0210968666,
0.0053613181,
0.0463666618,
0.0114693446,
-0.019353373,
-0.017978942,
0.0878295451,
0.0309088193,
0.0101599041,
0.020578023,
-0.0036552029,
-0.0446202084,
-0.0239810385,
0.0334049053,
0.0789030939,
0.0028381431,
-0.0300140791,
-0.02288769,
-0.0409018323,
0.0001341384,
-0.0360742435,
-0.0432371683,
0.0177965723,
0.0282941014,
0.010258534,
0.0169956274,
0.0110982889,
0.0107428413,
-0.0139752515,
0.0060339198,
-0.01072211,
-0.0005333324,
-5.717392199e-33,
-0.0170732997,
0.0188218243,
0.0105213989,
-0.0411409102,
-0.0338541344,
0.047080569,
-0.0299458578,
-0.0135981599,
0.0034936974,
0.0324178077,
0.0220729131,
-0.0024984074,
0.0098153884,
0.0475539602,
-0.0250039101,
-0.014588939,
0.0410382561,
0.0026430269,
0.0049757701,
0.0229146816,
0.0216842517,
0.0261818338,
0.030549027,
-0.0381359495,
0.0014441869,
0.0186819527,
-0.010980851,
0.0128719844,
0.0186667647,
0.0605692305,
-0.0320514776,
0.0308588129,
0.014093915,
-0.0676840395,
-0.0463851243,
0.0483645685,
-0.1056791618,
-0.0005775783,
-0.0593476854,
-0.0092015462,
-0.0498422086,
0.0102274772,
-0.0012501697,
0.0007042226,
0.0796009675,
-0.0484582596,
0.0493747853,
0.0032304262,
-0.0439851508,
-0.017757047,
-0.0367944874,
0.0366797671,
0.002207902,
-0.0217800383,
0.0354719274,
0.0380716808,
0.0687311962,
0.0358438268,
-0.0741177574,
-0.0232419204,
-0.0979798213,
0.0124811521,
-0.0254333485,
0.0195932202,
-0.010945172,
0.0535589606,
0.0345066004,
0.0198997445,
-0.0251259115,
-0.0236588456,
0.0330838785,
0.0494916961,
0.065953508,
0.0541472547,
0.0124669001,
0.0136537151,
-0.055264663,
0.0172737334,
0.0695493221,
0.0039206049,
0.0148316724,
0.0596151724,
-0.0468652137,
-0.0246956181,
-0.0012144281,
-0.0036898898,
-0.0204856675,
-0.0188963413,
0.0610663034,
0.0561907478,
0.0162914582,
0.0304239187,
0.0194860343,
-0.0269880444,
0.0050970279,
0.0376086757,
0.0083220303,
0.0172382519,
0.0072102263,
0.018747488,
-0.0420666002,
-0.007959676,
0.036847271,
0.0139998933,
-0.0116936062,
-0.0278185643,
0.081415318,
0.0046888138,
-0.0845449045,
-0.0135493958,
-0.0548618101,
-0.0259589925,
0.0386345647,
0.0736773983,
0.02774317,
-0.0241014045,
-0.0268691164,
0.0488732606,
0.0313344486,
0.0037489466,
-0.014980359,
-0.0298225936,
0.0010427099,
-0.0040468085,
0.0122924699,
0.005794181,
-0.0500296764,
-0.0171785969,
0.0434232689,
-0.0911426991,
-0.0088342177,
-0.0194278527,
2.334e-7,
0.0124018509,
0.0266868826,
-0.0088639427,
-0.021644108,
0.0169969182,
0.0609923601,
-0.0354701839,
0.0638921708,
-0.0619235262,
0.0209336579,
0.0118692601,
0.0097223781,
0.0556199998,
0.0140187331,
-0.0964613855,
-0.0060717962,
-0.0594001524,
0.0115781454,
-0.0289024469,
-0.0192167945,
0.0207489021,
0.1362897307,
0.0345133021,
0.0128280781,
0.0322638005,
-0.039236214,
0.0829649046,
-0.019171996,
0.0416301601,
-0.0175796356,
-0.0308590587,
0.0265542306,
-0.0288633443,
-0.0259131063,
-0.0405989625,
0.0182294399,
0.0550267883,
0.0753556043,
0.0022049812,
-0.0586891696,
0.0320563912,
0.0041544866,
-0.0385277271,
-0.0317080282,
0.0606348664,
-0.0428640991,
-0.0224892832,
-0.0103552779,
-0.018286597,
0.0156624522,
0.0336128101,
0.0199424084,
-0.033387959,
0.0034462288,
0.0084061055,
-0.0186566878,
-0.0073218429,
-0.1225690842,
-0.0253810603,
0.0010800678,
-0.0711538941,
-0.0156505462,
-0.0601204,
0.0425108783,
0.0537247621,
-0.0596323274,
0.0061233016,
2.37333664e-34,
0.0128585743,
-0.0082300901,
0.0141288759,
0.0038762663,
0.003516674,
-0.0217801575,
-0.004028575,
-0.0397771634,
0.0277715567,
-0.0497517586,
-0.021222882
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06922v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06922v1
|
EmoMix-3L: A Code-Mixed Dataset for Bangla-English-Hindi Emotion Detection
| 2024-05-11T05:58:55 | 2024-05-11T05:58:55 |
Nishat Raihan, Dhiman Goswami, Antara Mahmud, Antonios Anastasopoulos, Marcos Zampieri
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Code-mixing is a well-studied linguistic phenomenon that occurs when two or
more languages are mixed in text or speech. Several studies have been conducted
on building datasets and performing downstream NLP tasks on code-mixed data.
Although it is not uncommon to observe code-mixing of three or more languages,
most available datasets in this domain contain code-mixed data from only two
languages. In this paper, we introduce EmoMix-3L, a novel multi-label emotion
detection dataset containing code-mixed data from three different languages. We
experiment with several models on EmoMix-3L and we report that MuRIL
outperforms other models on this dataset.
|
EmoMix-3L: A Code-Mixed Dataset for Bangla-English-Hindi Emotion Detection: Code-mixing is a well-studied linguistic phenomenon that occurs when two or
more languages are mixed in text or speech. Several studies have been conducted
on building datasets and performing downstream NLP tasks on code-mixed data.
Although it is not uncommon to observe code-mixing of three or more languages,
most available datasets in this domain contain code-mixed data from only two
languages. In this paper, we introduce EmoMix-3L, a novel multi-label emotion
detection dataset containing code-mixed data from three different languages. We
experiment with several models on EmoMix-3L and we report that MuRIL
outperforms other models on this dataset.
|
[
-0.0029351427,
0.0824348927,
-0.0189550519,
0.0469982401,
0.0052790237,
0.0684162378,
-0.0134416241,
0.0035891789,
0.0305197425,
-0.0220662318,
-0.0725677237,
0.0039063203,
-0.0257725082,
0.0477177799,
-0.014558157,
-0.0191545878,
0.0121354917,
0.0674980283,
0.0483455658,
0.0092957001,
0.0671989396,
0.0519737974,
-0.0026249459,
0.0172747206,
-0.0766168535,
-0.0080853542,
-0.0109046213,
0.0365094393,
0.0416546091,
-0.0212570261,
0.0577813946,
0.0671418011,
0.0041406378,
0.0034436532,
0.0000018378,
-0.0117830923,
-0.0199711956,
-0.0356995426,
-0.0052925488,
-0.0325844027,
0.1103607267,
-0.0169772599,
-0.02123034,
0.0220563076,
-0.0279970095,
-0.0477921143,
0.0859361812,
0.0373711064,
0.0720379874,
0.0653310642,
-0.044494275,
-0.020554699,
-0.0042356327,
0.0012067781,
-0.0148576265,
-0.0028746212,
0.0417179689,
0.0064177769,
0.0166815203,
-0.0475924015,
-0.0343290716,
-0.0185147915,
0.0099673383,
0.0402196869,
-0.0510956198,
-0.0259589776,
-0.0420139879,
-0.0436017737,
0.0030419347,
0.0567682907,
-0.0728786737,
-0.0047386303,
0.0053828121,
-0.0285823047,
-0.0319064148,
-0.0959679559,
0.0290009268,
-0.0088632908,
-0.0424358286,
0.0528602004,
0.0286749899,
0.0186161976,
-0.004363128,
0.0002326334,
0.0163881648,
0.0403300822,
-0.0174877755,
-0.0077765565,
0.0184173211,
0.003097964,
0.0124184433,
-0.0006880584,
0.0095957676,
-0.0286195818,
0.0309235454,
0.0329455733,
-0.0558034666,
-0.0763187855,
-0.0180148575,
-0.0286763869,
-0.0686474815,
0.0327588096,
-0.0740767494,
0.0075374679,
-0.0056784414,
0.0054350067,
0.0142083187,
0.0025043364,
-0.0304904189,
-0.050517939,
-0.0145279272,
0.0235819537,
-0.0125945881,
0.0029025075,
-0.0269878861,
0.0195464641,
-0.0983193815,
-0.0118550388,
-0.0375634246,
0.003954614,
-0.0119666373,
-0.0435784794,
0.0208365154,
-0.0055265813,
0.0407137834,
-0.0005103929,
-0.05203541,
0.0193107724,
0.0052147307,
-0.0928895772,
0.036176946,
0.025806956,
-0.0097753266,
-0.0162175875,
0.0306640137,
0.0195830259,
0.0050964002,
-0.0350652337,
-0.0641437694,
0.0003306268,
-0.0311316643,
-0.0387571715,
-0.0021332698,
-0.0498760454,
0.0659552366,
0.0070068189,
0.0419020094,
-0.0704454482,
0.0066227606,
-0.0348498374,
-0.0169848949,
0.0898114592,
-0.0358826704,
-0.0524523556,
-0.0134088304,
0.0081059877,
0.021481473,
0.0926510915,
-0.0215357225,
0.0165272355,
0.0627481863,
-0.003662019,
0.0336297192,
0.0399691761,
-0.0093816034,
0.0026281045,
-0.0128151737,
-0.0310759507,
0.0314461403,
-0.0136515005,
0.0181410518,
-0.0108079482,
-0.0336279161,
-0.0081027662,
-0.0556749739,
0.0070178416,
0.013085423,
0.0014812937,
-0.0216019917,
-0.0113241803,
0.0212316364,
-0.0000600219,
0.0163239297,
0.0155638279,
-0.0352017134,
-0.0318867639,
0.0389875323,
0.0379057564,
-0.0393063203,
-0.0549518317,
-0.0659734979,
-0.0453590304,
0.0137536488,
0.0105397804,
0.0481167734,
-0.01361199,
-0.0173290353,
0.0071623023,
0.0685253739,
-0.051565744,
-0.0043095611,
-0.0197805725,
0.0012221055,
0.0254322905,
-0.025654925,
-0.047014337,
0.0151355304,
-0.0045795674,
-0.004119473,
-0.0047207894,
-0.0014664645,
-0.0155074093,
0.0429783165,
-0.0798153579,
0.0246898048,
0.0108428681,
0.0188979637,
0.0364017934,
-0.0138475522,
0.0552337803,
-0.0348625965,
0.0400514267,
0.0041467492,
0.0004135455,
-0.0245391596,
0.0162950736,
0.0015342508,
0.0031652839,
0.0364696383,
0.004080805,
-0.0295189042,
-0.0234305002,
0.0124356998,
-0.0130179785,
-0.0099828104,
0.0178559348,
0.0172961839,
-0.09490899,
0.0303348079,
-0.0144108981,
-0.0235489737,
0.011434908,
-0.0392138958,
-0.02451347,
0.0384879559,
0.0087194536,
0.0441341996,
-0.0283424426,
0.0166964885,
-0.0210259184,
0.0414914824,
-0.0038805113,
0.0383886807,
0.0098387413,
0.0223211106,
-0.0193457324,
0.005137729,
0.0462048016,
0.0353687666,
-0.040212933,
0.071066685,
-0.0032476615,
0.0044414238,
-0.0361832269,
0.0079897204,
-0.0594078787,
-0.0578022376,
-0.0684056655,
-0.0191946644,
-0.0259055775,
-0.0120793367,
-0.0067853578,
0.0273273475,
-0.0354036838,
0.0215837769,
-0.0388733335,
0.0162892006,
0.0328136496,
0.0092683239,
-0.0073395176,
-0.0154099949,
0.0183768347,
-0.0459131636,
-0.01051897,
-0.0341798961,
0.0313079804,
-0.0220950786,
-0.0281421486,
-0.0260523427,
0.0063175042,
-0.0408840589,
0.0235308576,
-0.0277426373,
-0.0503834039,
-0.0064211595,
-0.0343037993,
0.0324973539,
0.0077687353,
-0.0560136437,
0.0653904676,
0.015510208,
-0.0189474411,
-0.0025077318,
0.0415868871,
0.0096567404,
-0.0016950627,
-0.0119204232,
-0.054649584,
-0.018985305,
0.0647996664,
-0.0034192882,
-0.009192992,
-0.043423146,
-0.0134669263,
-0.0180875603,
-0.0453140847,
-0.002291095,
-0.0117683085,
-0.0107440734,
0.0618615821,
-0.0006919478,
-0.0496674813,
0.0422891937,
0.0228278991,
-0.0395514145,
-0.1063884795,
-0.0079451334,
-0.0596083403,
0.0312274732,
-0.0485603139,
0.0136592956,
0.0004738344,
-0.0019897199,
-0.014050669,
-0.0343002938,
-0.0476624891,
-0.0325265191,
0.0072151693,
-0.0019499789,
-0.0247099549,
0.012254741,
-0.0199273899,
-0.0037431533,
-0.036129564,
-0.0556522049,
0.002053035,
0.0437872037,
-0.0032324754,
0.0412723087,
-0.033190392,
-0.0144073954,
-0.0344823413,
0.0172397941,
-0.0048616971,
0.0345587023,
0.0198469758,
0.0246956926,
-0.0454670154,
0.0145078376,
-0.0078163743,
0.0033427367,
0.0135171413,
0.0270396303,
0.0405925475,
-0.0043927738,
0.0743332952,
0.0444340482,
0.0688351765,
0.0019919442,
-0.0332641751,
-0.0001281577,
0.0167449843,
0.051949285,
0.0703961253,
0.0563228317,
-0.0541954935,
0.0032107367,
-0.0825995058,
0.0305825491,
0.0302523635,
0.0279844403,
-0.0578087717,
-0.0379405767,
-0.0082016736,
-0.036135681,
0.0022544179,
-0.0157634243,
-0.0108755892,
-0.0804622024,
-0.0031789786,
0.0061227302,
-0.020296881,
-0.0583195835,
0.005281481,
-0.0007721093,
-0.0156330559,
-0.0262265522,
-0.0569595434,
0.0206382573,
-0.0396804996,
0.0423435792,
0.0178219881,
-0.0515344515,
0.0343018696,
-0.0270971768,
0.0438829102,
0.007371339,
0.069079563,
-0.0416715443,
-0.037160702,
0.0190406907,
0.0183133371,
-0.041508764,
-0.0250076558,
0.0346106701,
-0.0117834825,
-0.0650457069,
0.0033246719,
0.0103753675,
-0.0529168695,
0.0121113034,
-0.0152608659,
0.0448064245,
0.028154999,
-0.0054870574,
-0.023346277,
0.0080168722,
0.0265646223,
0.0157261044,
0.0180946123,
-0.0710958764,
0.0205316357,
-0.0227179285,
0.0366876535,
0.0110296011,
-0.0335522816,
0.0423332155,
-0.0346451029,
-0.0536791049,
-0.0309628509,
-0.0839797854,
0.0408346653,
0.0411686748,
-0.0262317453,
-0.0046118959,
-0.0285217129,
-0.003515207,
-0.026089808,
0.022394184,
0.0346110836,
0.0266610496,
-0.0374046676,
-0.0059230956,
-0.0019197462,
-0.0138481492,
-0.0021883252,
0.0119236754,
-0.0744087547,
-0.0515447259,
0.0277123433,
-0.010247116,
0.0133302351,
0.0023800349,
-0.0195695851,
-0.0342443213,
-0.0576037019,
-0.0090850526,
-0.0041736038,
-0.0089817746,
0.0793674067,
0.0027839111,
-0.008757811,
0.0021372233,
-0.0259185713,
0.0377431884,
0.0020892106,
-0.0439199619,
-0.0166239794,
-0.0047347872,
-0.0012150293,
0.0083199386,
0.0348365344,
-0.0169000309,
-0.0670228824,
-0.0487345345,
-0.0102241337,
0.0210728422,
-0.0322091728,
-0.0420180745,
-0.0348183252,
0.0199863333,
0.0068643824,
-0.0751669034,
-0.0592649356,
-0.0010796353,
-0.0294408835,
0.0379233137,
0.0835597366,
0.0565699562,
0.0506642871,
0.0311191846,
0.0375604816,
0.0032380417,
0.0499866679,
-0.0083419578,
0.0005628884,
-0.0202205274,
0.0238267388,
0.0087339962,
-0.0338813961,
0.0678754896,
0.037151631,
0.0621429086,
0.0352514014,
-0.0099949725,
-0.0617153682,
0.0608171523,
-0.0155240996,
0.0554584078,
-0.0176158492,
0.0228521843,
-0.0210792571,
0.0133051453,
-0.0384020135,
-0.0416958407,
0.0328872241,
-0.0080968887,
-0.0385124758,
-0.014440936,
0.052841723,
-0.0005687914,
0.0722936764,
-0.0015282799,
0.0213259272,
-0.0112576038,
0.0480477437,
0.1107970253,
-0.0090717962,
0.0195027646,
0.0317075439,
-0.0612359531,
-0.06345094,
0.0423392095,
-0.0607217588,
0.0021518562,
0.0242218226,
0.0240286402,
0.0552167334,
0.0033313693,
0.0458793417,
-0.0316727683,
-0.001795796,
0.0002360253,
-0.0436306894,
0.025812408,
-6.005523129e-33,
0.022980744,
0.0017773466,
-0.0633182079,
-0.0300724227,
0.0089618126,
0.025898302,
0.0061052209,
0.0144915935,
-0.0310339369,
0.0145454453,
0.0066949348,
0.0521843769,
0.0099766161,
-0.0260799676,
0.0380216651,
-0.0386571139,
0.0047636558,
0.0131883593,
0.0440831929,
0.0025261985,
0.0211570784,
0.034221869,
0.0722925439,
-0.0573501289,
0.0414187573,
0.0102562252,
-0.0458394513,
-0.0122676995,
0.0178385787,
0.0777725801,
-0.0219317395,
0.0864763409,
0.0049538063,
0.0075414679,
-0.006211218,
-0.0197187252,
-0.0075257747,
0.003307564,
-0.0007129611,
0.062255241,
-0.0210389979,
-0.0255467501,
-0.0144840367,
-0.0091116931,
-0.0035714328,
0.0254847724,
0.0239774659,
-0.0134669086,
0.0208603758,
-0.0352517702,
-0.0054663662,
0.0485503599,
-0.003944912,
0.0197067354,
0.0651569888,
0.0684216246,
0.0147432331,
0.0450324565,
-0.0441740416,
0.0152297011,
-0.0147645157,
0.0120276557,
0.0002640032,
-0.0167342424,
-0.0020835414,
0.0573283173,
0.0518651493,
-0.0143740177,
0.0318144262,
0.0655139461,
0.0281104781,
0.0407024845,
0.0238708761,
0.0571914949,
0.0064757317,
-0.0175696127,
-0.0049862438,
0.0130160768,
0.0470253676,
-0.0129095754,
0.0066040889,
0.0310940873,
-0.060176041,
-0.0330242701,
0.0391680002,
-0.0236707944,
-0.0384006649,
-0.0211634468,
0.0460966341,
-0.0223466605,
0.0193606168,
0.0141969491,
0.0100866053,
-0.024197014,
-0.0315280668,
0.0379908085,
-0.0328171775,
0.0609305426,
0.0107987756,
0.0674405769,
-0.0198206343,
-0.0239506923,
0.0412242971,
0.0175927114,
0.0720174462,
-0.0259239078,
0.0290438347,
0.0069419234,
-0.0839367285,
0.005074969,
-0.017410202,
0.0417270139,
-0.0037576265,
0.0288951844,
-0.0382245965,
0.0061011487,
-0.0160805359,
-0.0186157618,
0.0513045117,
0.0179783348,
-0.0328802355,
-0.0408985764,
-0.028406892,
0.0339891091,
-0.0350256637,
-0.0246973187,
-0.0186066106,
-0.0314520299,
0.0454897471,
-0.0069589689,
-0.0023893088,
-0.0074638659,
2.609e-7,
0.0001015294,
0.0193497781,
-0.0205103233,
-0.0358901508,
-0.0007123107,
0.0312050879,
-0.0644706562,
0.0398651473,
0.0146445921,
-0.0142830741,
-0.008546588,
-0.0303888172,
0.0685914457,
0.0522396751,
-0.088383697,
-0.0010075015,
0.0176270809,
0.011965082,
-0.0333213247,
0.0232822634,
0.0919280127,
0.1195199788,
0.0506937467,
0.0151144871,
0.0011789601,
0.0573462732,
0.0088460092,
-0.0151795577,
0.0191898849,
0.0183776412,
-0.0461266153,
0.0356649011,
0.0014840057,
0.0026060161,
-0.0052101165,
-0.0231374819,
0.0611330345,
0.0406599082,
-0.0072335899,
-0.0248086378,
0.0582239814,
0.0450982749,
-0.0686797798,
-0.027433712,
0.0495328493,
0.0292266384,
-0.0288498867,
-0.0092920437,
0.0151149919,
0.0174679477,
0.0558846109,
-0.0182629656,
-0.0466305651,
0.0352663957,
0.0050372882,
-0.0623018667,
-0.0257095769,
-0.073024027,
-0.0215347949,
0.041320134,
-0.0204804763,
-0.012244828,
-0.0074150735,
0.0553190336,
0.0527935326,
-0.0453763343,
0.0163612254,
2.026537108e-34,
0.012797392,
-0.0174863301,
0.0092697423,
0.0549733117,
0.037793804,
-0.0237092171,
-0.0464020111,
0.001310171,
0.0145095484,
-0.0206746608,
0.0207577851
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06919v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06919v1
|
Automating Thematic Analysis: How LLMs Analyse Controversial Topics
| 2024-05-11T05:28:25 | 2024-05-11T05:28:25 |
Awais Hameed Khan, Hiruni Kegalle, Rhea D'Silva, Ned Watt, Daniel Whelan-Shamy, Lida Ghahremanlou, Liam Magee
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, K.4.2
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are promising analytical tools. They can augment
human epistemic, cognitive and reasoning abilities, and support 'sensemaking',
making sense of a complex environment or subject by analysing large volumes of
data with a sensitivity to context and nuance absent in earlier text processing
systems. This paper presents a pilot experiment that explores how LLMs can
support thematic analysis of controversial topics. We compare how human
researchers and two LLMs GPT-4 and Llama 2 categorise excerpts from media
coverage of the controversial Australian Robodebt scandal. Our findings
highlight intriguing overlaps and variances in thematic categorisation between
human and machine agents, and suggest where LLMs can be effective in supporting
forms of discourse and thematic analysis. We argue LLMs should be used to
augment, and not replace human interpretation, and we add further
methodological insights and reflections to existing research on the application
of automation to qualitative research methods. We also introduce a novel
card-based design toolkit, for both researchers and practitioners to further
interrogate LLMs as analytical tools.
|
Automating Thematic Analysis: How LLMs Analyse Controversial Topics: Large Language Models (LLMs) are promising analytical tools. They can augment
human epistemic, cognitive and reasoning abilities, and support 'sensemaking',
making sense of a complex environment or subject by analysing large volumes of
data with a sensitivity to context and nuance absent in earlier text processing
systems. This paper presents a pilot experiment that explores how LLMs can
support thematic analysis of controversial topics. We compare how human
researchers and two LLMs GPT-4 and Llama 2 categorise excerpts from media
coverage of the controversial Australian Robodebt scandal. Our findings
highlight intriguing overlaps and variances in thematic categorisation between
human and machine agents, and suggest where LLMs can be effective in supporting
forms of discourse and thematic analysis. We argue LLMs should be used to
augment, and not replace human interpretation, and we add further
methodological insights and reflections to existing research on the application
of automation to qualitative research methods. We also introduce a novel
card-based design toolkit, for both researchers and practitioners to further
interrogate LLMs as analytical tools.
|
[
0.051196143,
0.0564634427,
-0.0414698049,
0.0074384878,
-0.0374472663,
0.0069939727,
0.0271478109,
-0.0112888431,
0.0007835569,
-0.0515362173,
0.0330636576,
0.0574613772,
-0.0381937809,
0.0597942397,
-0.0155561958,
-0.0413379036,
-0.0122431796,
-0.0237910114,
0.053102389,
0.0403922796,
0.0068512568,
0.035110198,
0.0129438071,
0.0452580005,
0.0171283409,
0.0043030893,
-0.0223116241,
-0.0085174218,
0.0256443955,
-0.0397319086,
-0.0263410304,
0.0503355004,
0.0603907034,
0.0611965805,
0.0000020583,
-0.017469395,
0.0123482272,
0.0118973348,
0.0013980286,
0.0061944998,
0.0631153658,
0.0017839634,
-0.0010930325,
0.006588513,
-0.0464728586,
0.0295338985,
0.0319125466,
-0.0157342758,
0.034251608,
0.0247038081,
-0.0236056503,
-0.0320864469,
-0.0031044567,
0.0111249425,
-0.0602941625,
0.0070195654,
0.0176728014,
-0.0007646458,
0.0573776327,
0.0694602057,
0.0198809244,
0.0604372993,
0.0185702015,
-0.02997851,
-0.0027270897,
-0.0152976764,
-0.044880975,
-0.0686072484,
0.0290429071,
0.0280896612,
0.0420159809,
-0.0080421334,
0.0072666593,
0.0013975562,
0.0008226634,
0.0263262484,
-0.0239202753,
0.0802862048,
-0.0312594846,
-0.0076458827,
0.0109738195,
0.0133955833,
-0.0172392242,
0.025053544,
-0.0247772802,
0.029669961,
-0.0308338143,
0.0046630916,
0.0054116151,
-0.0062531568,
0.0307786539,
-0.0352794826,
-0.0072862688,
0.0286659952,
-0.0111688618,
0.0301923547,
0.0370839611,
0.0023407305,
0.0620099865,
-0.0713157803,
0.0094522145,
0.0132392421,
-0.0228842441,
0.0075480663,
0.063526772,
-0.0050091636,
-0.0125793647,
0.0123993,
-0.0263874903,
0.0259248037,
-0.062837556,
-0.0206300728,
-0.0215664543,
-0.003253449,
-0.0611318462,
0.0054155625,
0.0151725337,
0.0284054652,
-0.0127800293,
-0.0071260938,
-0.0645322129,
0.0119436933,
-0.0117460154,
0.0036058119,
-0.0230379589,
0.0056305369,
-0.0560355894,
0.0647623762,
-0.0173293129,
-0.0160651561,
0.0566874668,
0.0242969468,
-0.0083450666,
0.0102212392,
-0.0180438068,
0.0714263022,
-0.0015996534,
-0.0103607792,
-0.069531858,
-0.0502308421,
0.0034320804,
-0.0353356227,
0.0301975887,
-0.0356428549,
-0.016086014,
0.0301416535,
-0.0310703944,
-0.0091340141,
0.0176693294,
0.0106783332,
-0.0280616973,
0.0744013488,
-0.020571053,
0.0026691565,
0.0527635142,
0.0496582575,
0.018144805,
0.0497425757,
0.020718975,
0.0577042848,
0.0212771427,
0.0125519587,
0.0355160534,
-0.0021256628,
-0.0646807924,
-0.0031025009,
-0.0608776808,
0.0123418989,
-0.0765768066,
0.0331340022,
0.0398789272,
0.0471486822,
-0.0271929484,
0.0398853868,
0.0510519519,
0.0837075338,
-0.0225630961,
0.0430771522,
0.0406755917,
0.0095356219,
-0.0041537285,
0.0053999289,
0.0171461049,
0.0029498683,
0.0076192394,
-0.0360124037,
-0.0065754992,
0.0153023629,
-0.0229535941,
-0.0389619954,
0.0090558426,
0.0044955164,
0.0667748526,
-0.0108677642,
0.0167117715,
-0.0280626323,
0.0171793047,
-0.0515328683,
0.0149754649,
-0.0196197629,
-0.0237978604,
-0.079784818,
0.0647313744,
0.066360347,
0.0281388368,
-0.026581075,
0.0236622263,
-0.044158604,
0.0001465395,
0.0523985997,
-0.0086084604,
-0.0178244971,
-0.0947343335,
-0.0024641408,
-0.0254408866,
-0.0276491512,
0.0103907827,
0.0365934968,
-0.0281661898,
-0.0076059187,
0.0125145111,
-0.0000236663,
-0.0318332948,
0.0169958994,
-0.0024653575,
-0.0394065864,
-0.0476050116,
0.0097735785,
0.0155398585,
0.0516155921,
-0.0224331282,
0.0183740221,
0.040500734,
-0.0323371552,
-0.0029519121,
0.0189475007,
0.0376379974,
0.0835691094,
-0.010271512,
-0.0829776451,
-0.019418668,
0.0325731263,
0.0076237246,
0.010650848,
0.0217473507,
-0.0017496696,
-0.0090417927,
-0.0494061522,
-0.0167082604,
-0.033545211,
-0.0169295073,
-0.0425174236,
0.0407982767,
0.0049926061,
-0.0225999318,
-0.0067996071,
-0.0183409918,
0.0389231183,
0.0218438525,
-0.0042482284,
0.0578045882,
0.0316408202,
0.053286694,
0.0503788516,
-0.0440645479,
-0.0302929096,
-0.0428102911,
-0.0824198797,
-0.0257867761,
-0.0037346955,
-0.0133785401,
0.0342312865,
-0.024145158,
-0.0308351964,
-0.0009020731,
0.0303320978,
-0.0596417598,
-0.0232692081,
0.0537045039,
0.0081202826,
0.019952599,
0.0042500752,
-0.0003716747,
-0.0038095904,
-0.0257157851,
0.0452354401,
0.0796360523,
0.0005416457,
-0.054424867,
-0.0067571746,
-0.0233675987,
-0.0294189285,
-0.0132401017,
-0.0391806439,
0.0498993844,
0.0263619144,
-0.0060384856,
0.0488078818,
0.0386632569,
0.0966816321,
0.0575529523,
0.002226396,
-0.000536127,
-0.0269880518,
0.0126181394,
-0.0146067645,
0.0041318415,
-0.0435949862,
0.0162187852,
0.0157713294,
-0.0167488772,
0.0377985053,
-0.006003587,
0.0683017746,
-0.0426277332,
-0.0218391456,
-0.0600393116,
-0.1011797637,
-0.0307426061,
0.1070763841,
0.0145985847,
-0.0222653374,
0.0205569845,
0.009045382,
0.0569056571,
-0.0628096908,
-0.0346665531,
-0.0238081757,
0.1211881414,
-0.0390242748,
0.0255649127,
0.0064643095,
-0.0065164855,
-0.0220479369,
-0.0819319263,
0.0139133837,
-0.0270833913,
0.0182530172,
-0.0893113613,
0.0041747815,
-0.0105803879,
-0.0067490279,
-0.0247863401,
-0.0359621122,
-0.0721339211,
0.0161540229,
0.0217883512,
-0.0042078635,
-0.0180419572,
0.0366822369,
0.0689985082,
0.0070990296,
0.0393030569,
0.0087405154,
0.005958599,
0.0304311235,
0.0054286998,
-0.0341133811,
0.0336092263,
0.0375362784,
0.0295839608,
0.0202473663,
-0.0345961899,
-0.0108355489,
-0.0358289406,
-0.009371574,
-0.0143429628,
-0.030197328,
-0.0101210568,
-0.0086574079,
0.02974605,
-0.057277035,
0.0105150891,
0.0812241584,
0.0299491715,
-0.0501411557,
0.0035259558,
-0.0261413809,
-0.0477801375,
-0.0051885704,
0.0375168845,
-0.0645340011,
0.0458800979,
-0.0075176689,
0.0168102551,
-0.0895020142,
-0.0566118471,
0.0120597156,
-0.0624266528,
0.0615865029,
-0.0114022531,
-0.0381376222,
-0.0037325763,
-0.0475374721,
0.0106287468,
0.009607261,
-0.0030568456,
0.0250631105,
-0.0000582158,
-0.0052995859,
0.0159931425,
-0.0667068586,
0.0118024703,
0.02421798,
-0.0052340254,
0.0561897382,
0.0401031189,
0.0488000959,
-0.0226985309,
-0.0368990302,
0.0230902564,
-0.0098439874,
-0.0131304748,
0.0095910765,
0.0022018668,
0.0031516487,
-0.0105290189,
-0.0326511748,
0.0396997631,
-0.0053950469,
-0.0214820206,
0.0321136191,
0.0695554391,
-0.023293592,
-0.0262162983,
-0.0578708649,
-0.0041685915,
0.010771459,
0.0088548092,
0.0407701507,
-0.0342056565,
-0.013991029,
-0.0374340117,
-0.0089102248,
0.0420774817,
-0.0673368797,
0.0029864521,
-0.009804708,
-0.0213832725,
-0.0129450066,
-0.0915437788,
0.0106213521,
-0.0025711118,
0.0084917927,
-0.0006900316,
0.0360801406,
0.0098482557,
-0.0668913126,
0.0394441262,
-0.0081031593,
0.0067964015,
0.0129941851,
-0.0010171552,
0.0087140277,
0.0108733913,
-0.0016580076,
0.0051555047,
0.0369067341,
-0.0322058871,
0.0579514429,
-0.0139303859,
0.0334625393,
-0.0164383668,
0.0071002846,
-0.04961849,
0.0143813519,
0.041590631,
-0.0759510472,
0.0049420083,
-0.0042770351,
0.0627173781,
-0.0152585115,
0.0032882241,
0.0202982333,
0.0526638739,
-0.0260059685,
-0.0095035499,
-0.0867211968,
-0.04811408,
0.0156824458,
-0.0234202053,
0.0105623193,
-0.0322780162,
-0.0140060997,
-0.0470305495,
-0.0441496223,
-0.0511724278,
-0.0345027819,
-0.0202326495,
0.0110751186,
-0.007005875,
-0.0072722612,
-0.0424461439,
-0.0440889038,
-0.0944832712,
0.0452658199,
0.0094281491,
0.0752798617,
0.0138555067,
0.0531717986,
-0.0133398296,
-0.0214473139,
-0.016062079,
0.0366319902,
-0.0378566086,
0.0427875333,
0.0095365485,
0.034391962,
0.0078125885,
-0.0076068449,
0.0190226901,
0.0337367058,
-0.0408296809,
-0.0636451021,
0.0172341391,
-0.0204622895,
-0.0063033821,
-0.0032084708,
-0.033699438,
-0.0125294803,
-0.0238239374,
0.0169276986,
0.0139809223,
0.0020102926,
-0.0071152467,
0.0120336143,
0.0265410487,
-0.0508426689,
-0.0163170975,
0.0099273184,
-0.0061050141,
0.0004755792,
0.0470717289,
-0.0405392572,
-0.0207117815,
-0.0550520681,
0.0445290469,
-0.023742117,
-0.0074527627,
-0.0258784369,
-0.1119183004,
-0.0295098815,
0.0128515,
-0.0023256808,
0.0106637385,
-0.0398307666,
0.0001406566,
0.0575798154,
0.0266899075,
0.0015600071,
-0.0543701015,
0.0268350951,
-0.0581807606,
0.0043025622,
0.0130473441,
-6.358837425e-33,
-0.0211113691,
-0.0693561062,
0.0283113904,
-0.0312778205,
-0.0105292788,
0.0241649207,
-0.0209998433,
0.0233149175,
-0.0231092349,
0.0298997015,
-0.0090750502,
-0.0099010477,
0.0064109811,
-0.0380366705,
0.0364600793,
0.0039278879,
0.0475176871,
0.0201502908,
-0.0050909603,
0.0211637858,
0.025851341,
-0.0102120247,
-0.0275286995,
-0.1162300184,
0.0633373335,
-0.0053129522,
-0.016938908,
0.0132491197,
0.0460355431,
0.0319618173,
-0.0238174722,
0.0282805935,
0.0302883685,
0.0023705109,
0.0239624586,
0.1010063514,
-0.0208602622,
-0.0144210868,
0.0309799239,
-0.0147861121,
0.0362506993,
-0.0536153689,
0.0267820507,
-0.023801133,
-0.0240205415,
0.0375720821,
0.0430976748,
-0.0470722355,
-0.0053172568,
-0.0567181706,
-0.0667539611,
0.0202290919,
-0.0282738283,
0.0202845056,
-0.0291490983,
-0.0277851894,
-0.0061992295,
0.013592964,
-0.046939943,
0.0182315949,
0.038191516,
-0.0284688845,
0.0343778804,
0.0136999376,
-0.0028683399,
0.0521761589,
-0.0257297382,
0.0378488936,
-0.0561797246,
0.0349514037,
0.0101247299,
0.0413866863,
0.0533940718,
0.0511225536,
-0.0229221303,
-0.0280577298,
-0.0602071472,
-0.0055164765,
-0.0107989265,
0.0506617129,
0.05087265,
0.007722049,
-0.0185549222,
-0.0053007668,
-0.0474831238,
-0.0453880914,
-0.0364641175,
-0.0370314345,
-0.0031896553,
-0.0141614508,
-0.0527821593,
0.0175532289,
0.0192816369,
-0.0253808238,
0.0453459844,
-0.0296593644,
-0.0017346154,
0.0079364935,
-0.0007460662,
0.0328743681,
-0.0313514173,
0.0019345054,
0.017676346,
0.036787793,
0.0430511162,
-0.0020598576,
-0.0249811318,
-0.0113138212,
-0.0318063535,
-0.006543091,
-0.0180880167,
0.0220840145,
0.0058346521,
-0.0227455609,
0.0063893488,
0.0266812313,
0.0061779213,
-0.0203228034,
0.0235244427,
0.0232006591,
-0.0051627839,
-0.0012100555,
-0.0715131462,
-0.0028726954,
-0.0153059019,
-0.0128534716,
-0.0211495552,
0.0800561458,
0.0902423412,
-0.0390279591,
-0.0008634652,
-0.010808019,
2.836e-7,
0.0627809912,
0.048670236,
-0.0191714372,
-0.0546057038,
0.014226892,
0.0281345826,
0.0500546694,
0.0206984971,
0.0101833334,
-0.0377525538,
0.0302220229,
0.0340367891,
0.0065419972,
0.0651501939,
-0.0501142181,
-0.0199294239,
-0.0188480858,
0.0036625045,
-0.1104565412,
0.0605217628,
0.0853493586,
0.0203868877,
-0.0086480528,
-0.0083129015,
-0.0549622811,
-0.0425663479,
0.0009539857,
-0.0374328941,
-0.0164561961,
-0.0044763419,
0.0399753898,
0.0375495143,
0.0048858547,
0.0104958303,
0.0337310322,
-0.0200224873,
-0.0103725567,
0.0438012108,
0.0098922113,
-0.0283783972,
0.0000034432,
-0.0496549569,
0.0263879783,
-0.0584748238,
0.044851698,
-0.0547336526,
-0.0345899016,
-0.0361529104,
-0.0374652036,
-0.0477564819,
0.0332079455,
-0.0352826938,
-0.0074925576,
0.0367531255,
-0.0162065793,
-0.0108220056,
0.0318373851,
-0.0621600412,
0.0157154445,
-0.0022877255,
-0.0446452983,
-0.0354737565,
-0.0110919038,
-0.0002131821,
0.0291937329,
-0.0558400899,
0.0716194957,
2.400485968e-34,
0.0495794415,
0.0177735072,
-0.0496195927,
0.0228575487,
0.0479737893,
0.06731309,
-0.0118016005,
0.0038458141,
0.0332120135,
-0.0697277859,
0.0268809795
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06907v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06907v2
|
AIOS Compiler: LLM as Interpreter for Natural Language Programming and Flow Programming of AI Agents
| 2024-05-11T04:29:03 | 2024-05-21T20:35:55 |
Shuyuan Xu, Zelong Li, Kai Mei, Yongfeng Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.PL
|
Since their inception, programming languages have trended towards greater
readability and lower barriers for programmers. Following this trend, natural
language can be a promising type of programming language that provides great
flexibility and usability and helps towards the democracy of programming.
However, the inherent vagueness, ambiguity, and verbosity of natural language
pose significant challenges in developing an interpreter that can accurately
understand the programming logic and execute instructions written in natural
language. Fortunately, recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have
demonstrated remarkable proficiency in interpreting complex natural language.
Inspired by this, we develop a novel system for Code Representation and
Execution (CoRE), which employs LLM as interpreter to interpret and execute
natural language instructions. The proposed system unifies natural language
programming, pseudo-code programming, and flow programming under the same
representation for constructing language agents, while LLM serves as the
interpreter to interpret and execute the agent programs. In this paper, we
begin with defining the programming syntax that structures natural language
instructions logically. During the execution, we incorporate external memory to
minimize redundancy. Furthermore, we equip the designed interpreter with the
capability to invoke external tools, compensating for the limitations of LLM in
specialized domains or when accessing real-time information. This work is
open-source at https://github.com/agiresearch/CoRE,
https://github.com/agiresearch/OpenAGI, and
https://github.com/agiresearch/AIOS.
|
AIOS Compiler: LLM as Interpreter for Natural Language Programming and Flow Programming of AI Agents: Since their inception, programming languages have trended towards greater
readability and lower barriers for programmers. Following this trend, natural
language can be a promising type of programming language that provides great
flexibility and usability and helps towards the democracy of programming.
However, the inherent vagueness, ambiguity, and verbosity of natural language
pose significant challenges in developing an interpreter that can accurately
understand the programming logic and execute instructions written in natural
language. Fortunately, recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have
demonstrated remarkable proficiency in interpreting complex natural language.
Inspired by this, we develop a novel system for Code Representation and
Execution (CoRE), which employs LLM as interpreter to interpret and execute
natural language instructions. The proposed system unifies natural language
programming, pseudo-code programming, and flow programming under the same
representation for constructing language agents, while LLM serves as the
interpreter to interpret and execute the agent programs. In this paper, we
begin with defining the programming syntax that structures natural language
instructions logically. During the execution, we incorporate external memory to
minimize redundancy. Furthermore, we equip the designed interpreter with the
capability to invoke external tools, compensating for the limitations of LLM in
specialized domains or when accessing real-time information. This work is
open-source at https://github.com/agiresearch/CoRE,
https://github.com/agiresearch/OpenAGI, and
https://github.com/agiresearch/AIOS.
|
[
0.0230245329,
0.0343427993,
-0.0467840433,
0.0508302078,
-0.0166760478,
0.0114972927,
-0.0308576152,
-0.0176697969,
0.051351551,
-0.0421647355,
-0.0190484747,
0.0502437428,
-0.0144547289,
0.0890166089,
0.0249932855,
-0.0368685834,
0.0607362278,
-0.0452362448,
0.022003442,
0.016360702,
0.0139899552,
0.026795879,
0.0195989031,
0.0332200155,
0.0552282855,
-0.0105855735,
-0.0397969373,
0.0035869803,
-0.0167585146,
-0.0059683039,
-0.0155737214,
-0.0184585694,
0.044114165,
-0.0024282716,
0.0000023775,
-0.0645234138,
0.0194022171,
0.0365016535,
-0.0388438962,
0.0081173684,
0.0106776692,
0.010183055,
-0.0093908608,
0.0117762713,
-0.0404643863,
-0.0077046449,
0.0666960925,
-0.0252592303,
0.1011136696,
0.0856158957,
0.0132051501,
-0.0428491943,
0.0260443483,
0.0352508761,
0.0222537294,
-0.0353862531,
-0.0008287966,
0.0082830926,
0.0448923633,
0.0183347072,
0.0042298441,
0.009682972,
0.0274422672,
-0.0083566969,
-0.0035690737,
0.0132143321,
-0.0223267693,
-0.0336102024,
-0.0390081368,
0.0251765195,
0.000367237,
0.0015175286,
0.0358141847,
0.0016298646,
0.0017834444,
-0.058844246,
-0.0321439914,
0.0736279786,
0.0025877068,
0.0077242111,
0.0506211407,
-0.0080409935,
0.0008938524,
0.0189809725,
-0.0504937284,
0.0690758005,
-0.0227993038,
0.0007886006,
-0.0143532287,
-0.035406284,
0.015273273,
-0.0700234622,
0.0327364095,
0.0757709444,
-0.0289989132,
0.0248234682,
-0.0307523143,
0.0181775242,
0.0155275865,
-0.0893876478,
0.0306066927,
0.0371199958,
0.0118070375,
0.0275700744,
0.0072460421,
0.091538623,
0.0019826847,
0.050397411,
-0.0235068649,
0.0193093494,
-0.0445054621,
-0.0175224431,
-0.053074941,
0.0521950833,
-0.0325638056,
0.0196251236,
0.0024241982,
0.0608903021,
-0.0279453099,
0.0356871411,
-0.024160143,
-0.0360247009,
-0.0271834917,
0.0105188778,
-0.0494491346,
-0.0041966205,
-0.0292123687,
-0.0335352048,
-0.0151537638,
-0.0575582311,
-0.0018536802,
0.0352632999,
-0.0317427143,
0.0011734569,
0.0078546302,
0.1076903641,
0.0374529436,
-0.003349148,
-0.047921285,
-0.0189010315,
0.0433410816,
-0.0619167648,
0.0012276289,
-0.0829713494,
0.0188385826,
0.0167959072,
-0.014677017,
-0.0597054698,
0.0151484469,
0.0265114661,
-0.0006180641,
0.0308656394,
-0.0334002338,
-0.0023036641,
-0.0134515371,
-0.0080068083,
0.0157938357,
0.0559115149,
0.0594356619,
-0.0026721614,
-0.0157962274,
-0.01519458,
0.011178812,
0.016481787,
-0.0676023662,
-0.017750334,
0.0145300385,
0.0404254161,
-0.0337044932,
0.0380470455,
-0.0140672028,
0.05718375,
0.0227329079,
-0.0124386987,
-0.019248426,
0.0428760648,
-0.0055931453,
0.0328129604,
0.0905848742,
0.0661785081,
0.0156969354,
-0.0279122908,
-0.0572815016,
0.0502877049,
-0.0186196379,
0.0008209614,
-0.0499629192,
0.0656649396,
0.0110177696,
-0.0971356109,
-0.003515691,
-0.0280051902,
0.0426849537,
0.0006956361,
0.0290276688,
0.0087329308,
-0.0296241064,
-0.0088285096,
-0.0078513101,
-0.0434557498,
-0.0238341112,
-0.0722499639,
0.0048460579,
0.0808366388,
0.0048730299,
-0.0390531607,
-0.0227623526,
-0.0145446388,
-0.0264291875,
0.0287891347,
0.0112852268,
0.0039787446,
-0.0223356821,
-0.0383066274,
-0.0111712627,
-0.0154235931,
0.0017310659,
0.0484309979,
-0.0108726509,
-0.0077913585,
-0.0021827358,
0.0358991027,
-0.0656551793,
0.0363433622,
-0.0368116833,
-0.0215201881,
-0.0062178401,
-0.0074931672,
0.0184359401,
-0.002713301,
-0.0187513661,
0.0202808548,
0.0536524951,
0.0024578648,
-0.0639505535,
-0.0144292805,
-0.0208704751,
0.0032171574,
0.0333927646,
-0.0149594946,
-0.0303019173,
-0.0095058745,
-0.0534342714,
-0.0012163809,
0.0638555288,
-0.0464026444,
0.0143536068,
0.0188781917,
0.018891098,
-0.0094431117,
-0.0223238524,
-0.0308744088,
0.0439328067,
0.0230449345,
-0.0269789547,
-0.0010988837,
0.0382358655,
-0.0006316639,
-0.0171103198,
0.016991511,
0.0134494491,
-0.0029174641,
0.0360003412,
0.0521742925,
0.055079896,
0.0043822695,
-0.0127370693,
-0.0447273366,
0.0603456572,
-0.0207605064,
-0.0059863371,
0.0179704502,
0.0202144105,
0.0020188279,
0.0146387918,
0.0038642052,
0.0212739594,
0.0061414083,
-0.0161997825,
0.0109829521,
-0.0071401852,
-0.0805710703,
-0.0046302266,
0.0006820827,
-0.051810123,
0.0083971228,
0.0256102253,
-0.0343690924,
-0.076645948,
0.0643155947,
-0.009425763,
0.0168813076,
-0.0014459438,
-0.0150556993,
0.0004420778,
-0.0414519832,
-0.0103987865,
0.0719590783,
-0.0510560647,
0.0477520972,
0.0640631765,
-0.0113451388,
-0.0465439409,
0.0284725782,
0.0350041762,
-0.019500751,
-0.0392084122,
-0.045609355,
0.0336548164,
0.0574913286,
0.0305574536,
0.0025055103,
-0.0213924479,
0.0085703591,
0.0142880715,
0.0121432599,
0.0377469361,
-0.0243019927,
-0.0332080871,
0.0261508022,
-0.007632798,
-0.059428826,
0.0843733698,
-0.0185160693,
-0.0246824529,
-0.0616197772,
-0.0592329912,
-0.0758573562,
0.074151434,
0.0156089813,
0.0106480718,
0.0222659484,
-0.0255041737,
0.0155341057,
0.0045102611,
-0.0250433926,
-0.0195276234,
0.0486577079,
-0.0719139352,
-0.0010756059,
0.0130004724,
-0.0100736339,
-0.0278209932,
0.0076581645,
-0.0332127884,
0.0051571764,
0.0045696893,
-0.017495973,
-0.0197448079,
-0.0325868987,
0.0175105017,
0.0196883157,
0.0027960651,
-0.0170412306,
-0.0441225991,
-0.0496464968,
-0.0137215657,
-0.0140550081,
-0.043541003,
0.0440411307,
0.0283905212,
0.0362151563,
0.0005183367,
0.0103457412,
-0.0811764225,
0.0012085657,
0.021404827,
-0.0363522395,
-0.0333345272,
0.0637346953,
0.0282917935,
-0.0822446123,
-0.0194770209,
0.1026924998,
0.0270717498,
-0.017137982,
0.0270035081,
-0.0330701619,
0.0087075429,
0.0820741579,
0.0585548803,
-0.0565086901,
-0.0395716392,
0.0006501803,
0.010131008,
0.0040991209,
0.0030616731,
-0.021432139,
-0.0786094815,
0.0369582996,
0.0343249701,
0.0184433106,
-0.0482314602,
-0.0586388335,
-0.0274259634,
-0.0051010307,
-0.0377690867,
0.0161510445,
0.00287859,
-0.000812482,
-0.0254419129,
-0.0100315837,
0.0082712723,
0.0341295078,
-0.0175548438,
0.0537488684,
0.1261149794,
0.0175957158,
-0.0242224336,
-0.0044587343,
0.0157577842,
0.0339029059,
0.0122127067,
-0.0358971655,
0.0036954179,
-0.0004197463,
-0.0145776914,
-0.0172934197,
0.0160849188,
-0.0570821576,
0.0002399966,
0.0388672836,
0.0766184106,
-0.0455906913,
-0.0223959871,
-0.034560822,
-0.0276720487,
0.0116682081,
0.0369012877,
-0.0030349817,
0.0080975192,
-0.0561937205,
-0.0978949368,
-0.0348889418,
-0.0330755636,
-0.0627658367,
0.024327442,
-0.0166061353,
-0.0227917694,
-0.0115288571,
-0.0189788975,
0.0179059077,
-0.0129043367,
0.0344578512,
-0.0565925688,
0.0663946867,
-0.0086844424,
-0.0240981448,
-0.0032487193,
-0.0506841205,
0.0578741729,
-0.0025059346,
-0.0459313951,
0.0235233717,
0.0072185565,
-0.0231033731,
0.0771903843,
-0.0334326513,
-0.0621863902,
-0.0030256035,
0.0696176738,
0.017655462,
-0.0069532059,
-0.0070698662,
-0.002785658,
-0.0459918305,
0.0143729188,
-0.0478638597,
-0.001484739,
0.0142661212,
0.0219589714,
0.0430140272,
0.0101754982,
-0.0546455048,
-0.0085262554,
-0.0352323242,
0.022783516,
-0.0409511663,
0.012990512,
0.0457080379,
0.0472977012,
-0.0357320197,
0.0278126467,
-0.0052669826,
0.0316542871,
-0.0247785188,
-0.0367634036,
-0.0212270357,
-0.0540679134,
0.0123309679,
-0.0111812707,
-0.023234684,
0.0687436461,
-0.0006193178,
-0.0240006782,
-0.0189369395,
0.0306664947,
0.0493784919,
0.020934429,
0.0258032922,
0.0199529808,
0.0222466048,
-0.0229820907,
0.0546970405,
-0.007246248,
0.0305118505,
-0.0452514254,
0.0329307877,
0.0110401046,
0.0175779387,
-0.0185176097,
-0.0035479732,
-0.0345201455,
-0.0727872774,
0.0423493534,
0.0373444557,
0.0236447938,
0.0347538292,
0.0226697307,
-0.0622564293,
0.0435254835,
-0.02871239,
0.0310385954,
-0.0091757607,
-0.0661107004,
0.0056782346,
0.0368693545,
-0.0004568916,
-0.0798418447,
0.0687251836,
0.0108411787,
0.0319358073,
-0.0102421399,
-0.0427780859,
-0.0580964759,
-0.0321502872,
0.011540792,
-0.0130079705,
-0.0059673367,
-0.0257321503,
-0.0292768497,
-0.0443110056,
-0.003555947,
0.0271784104,
0.0338419937,
-0.0458609648,
0.0419208668,
0.0407463573,
0.0156566761,
-0.0425213389,
-0.0110083902,
0.0361301228,
-0.0298771728,
-0.0403676033,
-0.039430473,
-5.942092719e-33,
-0.0551594608,
-0.0118202819,
0.0428340994,
0.0299738888,
-0.0054461542,
-0.0396996588,
-0.0602253899,
-0.0198054444,
0.0036978277,
-0.0270067677,
0.0394453593,
0.0027941775,
-0.0016219969,
-0.0156613924,
0.0242915917,
0.0100546032,
0.0213007443,
-0.0073678996,
-0.0008164034,
-0.0018301704,
0.0180714596,
-0.0241533834,
0.0268197898,
-0.047275655,
0.0207522493,
0.007836299,
0.0193220787,
0.0313442573,
-0.0316231288,
0.0289722271,
0.0101862121,
0.0172836557,
-0.0028011303,
-0.0066592325,
-0.042223651,
0.0228644107,
-0.0383335166,
-0.0325691104,
0.0313530713,
0.0363742448,
-0.0277676657,
-0.0737924278,
0.0805621818,
-0.0192722026,
-0.0408230722,
0.0176325329,
0.0276088733,
-0.0234227963,
0.030698061,
0.0145706953,
-0.0783991069,
0.0153329438,
-0.0526859611,
-0.0024641624,
0.0082720062,
-0.0062200353,
-0.0099224178,
0.006277428,
0.0082875695,
0.0148719829,
-0.0112762619,
0.0198388062,
0.0439011343,
-0.0221038088,
0.0300166346,
0.0007827026,
0.0301998667,
-0.0049374686,
-0.0535671376,
0.0625293702,
0.0143928928,
0.0261697639,
-0.0118946861,
0.0038414919,
0.005861036,
-0.008082523,
-0.0518424325,
0.0117896833,
0.0051428545,
0.0744455606,
0.0045752232,
0.0286905151,
-0.0527367219,
-0.0096388264,
-0.0202130862,
-0.0251123495,
-0.0076403012,
-0.0284593422,
0.0222232267,
-0.0204086322,
-0.0097696884,
-0.006639584,
-0.0017154287,
-0.0463611521,
0.0119854594,
0.0212954115,
-0.020539334,
0.0034261686,
0.0056435061,
0.0470130295,
0.0015491835,
-0.0271780249,
-0.0176471062,
-0.0283918176,
0.0845974609,
0.0280109234,
-0.0170799475,
0.0581606552,
-0.0205762871,
0.0155801717,
-0.0637105927,
-0.0309898779,
0.0077682957,
0.0111087663,
-0.003923954,
-0.007384852,
-0.0011068977,
0.0623357035,
-0.0160687417,
-0.049940899,
-0.0359264277,
0.0087149916,
-0.0012498403,
0.0177991632,
-0.0636671558,
-0.0213564876,
-0.0791500062,
0.0522363335,
0.0178375188,
-0.0267965142,
-0.0299458932,
0.0163855013,
3.13e-7,
-0.0078750122,
0.0431024283,
0.0263364762,
0.0999785066,
0.0031210838,
0.0459688082,
-0.0125751337,
0.0212965626,
-0.0068094153,
-0.0222895574,
-0.0570696481,
0.0546867475,
-0.0148243103,
-0.0047188271,
-0.0714152604,
0.0512393862,
0.0371074453,
-0.0041913697,
-0.0784775689,
0.0369802974,
0.0811359584,
0.0709797591,
0.0399102271,
0.0270651411,
-0.0119164716,
-0.0854739919,
-0.0106582157,
0.0127893575,
0.0162358973,
0.0237590838,
-0.0749706998,
0.0367845111,
-0.0203244779,
-0.0165789369,
0.0282792468,
0.0111279432,
-0.0296535399,
0.0918696597,
-0.022126101,
0.0425614789,
0.0361141972,
-0.0331652313,
-0.0107035711,
-0.0087530585,
0.0339386016,
-0.022564644,
-0.0264575556,
-0.0469731167,
-0.0110515989,
-0.0059274789,
-0.0411291979,
-0.0164426211,
-0.0075202263,
-0.0117493607,
-0.007870351,
-0.049035918,
-0.0062963259,
-0.0166941248,
-0.0093359808,
-0.0368072614,
-0.034341678,
-0.0093644792,
-0.0575129203,
0.0651009157,
0.0319610238,
-0.0223544519,
0.0094843777,
3.337686951e-34,
0.0184444934,
-0.0207461845,
0.0180421192,
0.04796708,
0.0826106369,
0.0106414752,
-0.0544515513,
0.0341569334,
0.0212491527,
-0.0346483029,
-0.0430782437
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.