id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.07098v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.07098v1
|
A Novel Multi-Stage Prompting Approach for Language Agnostic MCQ Generation using GPT
| 2024-01-13T15:18:44 | 2024-01-13T15:18:44 |
Subhankar Maity, Aniket Deroy, Sudeshna Sarkar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce a multi-stage prompting approach (MSP) for the generation of
multiple choice questions (MCQs), harnessing the capabilities of GPT models
such as text-davinci-003 and GPT-4, renowned for their excellence across
various NLP tasks. Our approach incorporates the innovative concept of
chain-of-thought prompting, a progressive technique in which the GPT model is
provided with a series of interconnected cues to guide the MCQ generation
process. Automated evaluations consistently demonstrate the superiority of our
proposed MSP method over the traditional single-stage prompting (SSP) baseline,
resulting in the production of high-quality distractors. Furthermore, the
one-shot MSP technique enhances automatic evaluation results, contributing to
improved distractor generation in multiple languages, including English,
German, Bengali, and Hindi. In human evaluations, questions generated using our
approach exhibit superior levels of grammaticality, answerability, and
difficulty, highlighting its efficacy in various languages.
|
[
-0.6809259057,
-1.0984277725,
0.6573563814,
0.2509898245,
-0.0553002842,
0.1780547798,
0.0890405849,
-0.0109210676,
-0.0148605341,
0.1213338077,
-0.9913448691,
-0.0991773307,
-0.1497177035,
0.3229242265,
-0.0765721798,
1.051705122,
-0.0658978075,
-0.0109177753,
0.025454266,
0.1398319453,
-0.5101261735,
-0.4842070043,
-1.0595560074,
-0.1178134009,
0.7509893179,
0.4456462264,
0.4512166083,
0.0935619846,
0.1373631805,
0.1820953488,
0.0532199107,
0.2988586426,
0.1952491105,
0.3513562083,
-0.2762231827,
0.0933588892,
-0.158937037,
0.0228948724,
0.6117122173,
0.4849441648,
-0.3593432307,
0.4036546052,
0.1920066625,
0.8709346652,
-0.8073067665,
-0.2609297335,
-0.7388426065,
0.2183019072,
0.0100663453,
-0.3222281635,
-0.3567982614,
-0.4382367134,
-0.1466553658,
-0.2169519812,
0.2227697968,
-0.3213705719,
0.5425512791,
0.2080836892,
-0.5396875739,
-0.5152033567,
-0.6390855312,
0.3499567509,
-0.3528749645,
0.2466564327,
0.2036930621,
0.4080854356,
-0.0183165967,
-0.4837854207,
-0.656085968,
-0.476020366,
0.40940997,
0.5134696364,
0.166384086,
-0.1033719108,
0.2703972161,
0.2143226266,
-0.7590409517,
-0.3837402165,
-0.2034230083,
0.0415538289,
0.2005410492,
-0.0860096738,
0.3006780148,
-0.3780899942,
-0.4867673218,
0.2299489081,
-0.7194553018,
0.0107479841,
0.4101424515,
0.3584811985,
0.5231556892,
0.5052140951,
-0.3846406639,
0.7423073649,
0.2979727685,
0.0099909985,
-0.1039725244,
-0.6505711079,
0.041205164,
-0.1784820259,
0.9030014873,
0.1726424843,
0.2208104581,
0.3541117609,
0.0299793482,
0.2612829208,
0.3395338058,
-0.4898388684,
-0.1441656798,
0.4338906407,
0.1149996743,
-0.1949259192,
-0.2458408475,
-0.8137603402,
-0.0079388935,
0.0176474545,
0.4284489751,
-0.3852454722,
-0.3632439673,
-0.0447189771,
-0.1497680396,
0.1015109867,
0.0553827062,
-1.1728429794,
0.0653393269,
0.1775685251,
0.6691897511,
-0.1904925853,
-0.4067022204,
-0.5685697794,
0.3648252785,
-0.2731243372,
0.9003016353,
-0.6166766882,
-0.446154356,
-0.0096702427,
-0.4608693421,
-0.2966500521,
-0.4170703888,
0.5813319683,
-0.2914497852,
0.6110540032,
-0.4538525343,
-0.1415918469,
-0.0046030497,
0.7817016244,
-0.4147295952,
1.4941594601,
0.1225152537,
-0.8773235679,
0.4582637548,
-0.9398223758,
-0.2054744512,
0.3628531098,
-0.4612091184,
-0.0188933276,
-0.042963814,
0.8034155369,
0.3923379779,
-0.0107603045,
0.4246105552,
0.0260222517,
0.0883100852,
0.0203675944,
-0.7602669597,
0.5252215266,
0.3017455637,
-0.3181757927,
0.1187039018,
-0.6904491782,
0.5451992154,
0.1192195117,
-0.4376382232,
0.023753684,
-0.0603368953,
-0.3115940392,
0.9888225794,
-0.0578573197,
-0.3050229251,
0.3356763124,
0.0960582793,
0.3608952761,
0.7444239855,
0.5204511285,
-0.0496051945,
-0.2246441394,
1.0622999668,
-0.0126014287,
0.21398215,
-0.4068015218,
-0.867921412,
-0.6258758903,
-0.0099895382,
0.0175465327,
0.9210127592,
-1.3327610493,
0.1538808495,
0.2158512622,
-0.2633102238,
-0.383883059,
-0.0449385941,
0.4418860376,
0.7095139027,
0.4125546813,
-0.182036832,
-0.3287145793,
-0.6178517342,
-0.3004462421,
-0.3484642506,
-0.0282577258,
0.0454865023,
0.5319269896,
-0.0057946946,
0.8101763725,
-0.4053838849,
0.2144755423,
-0.2866463363,
0.2538604736,
0.0898194239,
0.5122611523,
0.0492949858,
-0.7143651247,
-0.775446713,
-0.151387006,
-0.4517512918,
-0.165052712,
-0.3367316425,
-0.2409007847,
0.031854894,
0.3214829266,
-0.5670404434,
0.0045103841,
0.3491282761,
-0.2241902798,
1.1015067101,
-0.114504315,
0.577319026,
-1.1941998005,
0.0577249266,
-0.1968082041,
-0.0150063038,
-0.6750228405,
0.1938363612,
0.0670912564,
-0.2657698691,
-0.5908417106,
0.444894582,
-0.4657712281,
0.3939849734,
0.0344400369,
0.3496845067,
-0.060572546,
0.4128349125,
0.0591024943,
1.0317867994,
0.46312958,
-0.8952461481,
0.1242912263,
0.2376097292,
0.0069690896,
0.8216250539,
-0.486540705,
0.3968767524,
-0.0121481689,
0.273040086,
-1.1040827036,
-0.1190876365,
0.2840334773,
-0.3798210323,
0.168485567,
-0.1678210497,
-0.4495297372,
-0.9185400009,
-0.2093801051,
0.2723650336,
0.3227771819,
-0.3415933251,
0.0788475648,
-0.0075238105,
-0.7024314404,
-0.7584857941,
-0.5905408263,
0.107457608,
-0.1043733954,
-0.4332876503,
-0.1361590475,
-0.4870220423,
0.2023522854,
-0.4336664975,
-0.2450570911,
-0.0769548044,
-0.145707041,
-0.172890991,
0.3084346056,
-0.04409099,
0.0036402482,
0.359621495,
-0.2230714858,
-0.0272463448,
-0.6203404665,
0.6587396264,
-0.1889097989,
-0.6203296781,
-0.1811421961,
0.8041709065,
0.0981952101,
-0.2448851615,
0.1991783082,
0.7863771319,
-0.2053585798,
-0.1067124829,
-0.5945344567,
-0.0046771071,
-0.4626769125,
0.1040482074,
-0.7445453405,
-0.9751527309,
0.4743399322,
-0.1216701567,
-0.1371109635,
0.5035212636,
0.8830661178,
0.2547139525,
1.4837690592,
0.3469949067,
0.2191011906,
0.4957561791,
0.0907506272,
0.0340415873,
-0.8202639222,
0.0162060279,
-0.3638909161,
0.2067243159,
-0.3632774651,
-0.5312803984,
0.3827915788,
0.295555979,
-0.2245252728,
0.0276033636,
-0.7809783816,
0.7491285205,
0.5950189233,
-0.0970202163,
0.3476638496,
-0.1883471757,
-0.8464576602,
0.0682830364,
-0.9178600907,
-0.752063036,
0.9597768188,
-0.0660046935,
0.1570744514,
0.0032579747,
0.8531594276,
0.0500597209,
0.2680305243,
-0.5372585058,
0.5546319485,
0.4344920814,
-1.0990496874,
-0.3694259822,
-0.3980799615,
-0.8912451267,
0.4546209872,
0.0794711113,
-0.9434801936,
-0.1116523519,
0.2692550421,
-0.7194052935,
0.0361670591,
-0.7645336986,
0.8290304542,
-0.1032334045,
-0.3381640315,
0.2129573971,
-0.6656759381,
0.5657755136,
-0.0597663037,
0.1234684587,
-0.0210258123,
-0.0994111151,
0.376232028,
-0.1263796985,
0.3782373071,
-0.2916603386,
-0.2757025361,
0.6364971995,
0.1922303587,
0.4633574188,
0.3619580567,
-0.116836749,
-0.4326267838,
-0.0633752868,
-0.3729364872,
-0.5274604559,
0.585490942,
-0.2028681785,
-0.5630888939,
-0.3798571825,
-0.573448658,
-0.5102090836,
0.3420366943,
0.4283798039,
0.171646297,
-0.2374494076,
-0.5914773345,
0.3950236142,
-0.1558812708,
0.5652009845,
0.3976176083,
-0.3954674304,
-0.6373362541,
0.8159819245,
0.1128775924,
0.7863198519,
0.1010963842,
0.2451037616,
-0.5277029872,
-0.4505905211,
-0.8411166072,
0.0375475697,
-0.7953242064,
-0.0431190021,
-0.7076681256,
-0.0784618929,
-0.4025296271,
-0.2563918233,
-0.2097391188,
-0.4885164797,
0.1964817345,
-0.2371721268,
-0.1326342225,
0.8552687168,
-0.0280081518,
0.0566044636,
-0.91084975,
0.5713281631,
0.7526358366,
0.2243727595,
-0.133382678,
-0.0910253897,
-0.0687022731,
0.0730098709,
-0.8075665236,
-1.0713495016,
0.2011779845,
0.1604123414,
0.5499982834,
0.3543399572,
-0.0470914058,
0.7377025485,
-1.0230002403,
1.2781625986,
0.3424957395,
-1.1241321564,
0.9880619049,
-0.6489689946,
0.7657527328,
0.8594520092,
0.5921261907,
-0.7688220143,
-0.7670604587,
-0.7685750723,
-0.8283034563,
0.3716326952,
0.2780906856,
-0.0390606001,
-0.697551012,
0.2799783945,
0.2907114625,
0.470954448,
-0.8048698902,
-0.2009777278,
-0.2245298773,
0.084911935,
0.0450500399,
-0.1463026553,
-0.0841721073,
-0.213891834,
0.6254551411,
-0.3770799041,
0.3634334803,
0.4520899355,
0.0693408474,
-0.1632342488,
0.7902482152,
0.7074518204,
0.9295994043,
0.0483425185,
0.1096154451,
0.2893200219,
-0.5141955614,
0.4665134549,
-0.0249634981,
-0.3360700309,
-0.0013035747,
-0.2537596822,
0.4828741252,
-0.3119698465,
-0.2073996812,
0.1304002106,
0.0077323979,
-0.4205387533,
-0.1192160398,
0.0854688957,
0.0116108684,
0.1395928264,
0.5042738914,
0.0479400195,
0.2821516097,
-0.5171781778,
0.4578307867,
0.4285753965,
-0.5206459165,
-0.0883420855,
0.7826015949,
0.0750515983,
-0.2435890287,
0.385554105,
-0.648132205,
-0.6884380579,
0.2207956165,
0.7751873732,
0.958597362,
-0.6155207753,
0.7182986736,
0.5210784674,
0.472029537,
-0.3013447821,
0.7671381235,
-0.1924093962,
-0.5865079165,
-0.8319660425,
-0.4019373655,
-0.5729849339,
0.0514199957,
-0.6433224678,
0.0152805047,
-0.4190849662,
-0.1675133705,
-0.2255617678,
-0.0747728497,
-0.4313849211,
0.2874628901,
0.3510579169,
0.7803883553,
-0.8092803955,
0.7927590013,
0.677469492,
-0.6799131632,
-0.9137639403,
0.3029594719,
0.0651603118,
-0.6154453158,
0.2928557694,
0.2785826027,
-0.2073533982,
0.4355455637,
-0.4520640671,
-0.6384698749,
0.8794795275,
0.1708443016,
-0.2352281809,
-0.0776919201,
0.0905590206,
0.3378329873,
-0.3266323805,
0.5430630445,
0.4812297821,
0.5750234127,
0.276114583,
-0.8039873838,
0.2191958129,
-0.4378508031,
0.0493784212,
0.3174790144,
-0.4073828459,
0.8099561334,
-0.3994074464,
-0.3329335153,
-0.0851023719,
0.3877947628,
0.6697906852,
0.134000957,
0.5265321732,
0.334268868,
0.9516180158,
0.0079813804,
1.0082321167,
-0.2248899341,
0.2953672111,
1.0120056868,
-0.3030711412,
0.9377171397,
0.6701751351,
-0.3194629848,
0.5671969056,
0.7510971427,
0.1922212839,
0.3039528131,
0.3951634169,
-0.401452899,
-0.1766393036,
0.1291782558,
-0.5556200147,
0.0945261195,
0.3199990094,
0.0750982612,
-0.1794220656,
0.1860536635,
0.0600901209,
-0.1622659266,
-0.2544401288,
0.6482605934,
-0.0780839846,
-1.1393376589,
0.7265612483,
-0.4626323581,
0.544726789,
-0.8755381107,
0.0595494099,
-0.0051230974,
-0.1335253268,
0.0416765586,
-0.7850166559,
0.1486823708,
0.092537567,
-0.2061737925,
-0.4711420536,
0.5754039884,
-0.7556583881,
-0.5563564897,
-0.0662700683,
0.9088243246,
0.1603365988,
-0.472382158,
-1.1368763447,
-0.4579592943,
0.0236278921,
-0.4032311738,
0.1833171248,
0.631274879,
-0.0015212275,
0.7310186028,
0.7335229516,
-0.0344248004,
0.2017325312,
0.4510730505,
0.7144964337,
-0.7307886481,
-0.6176823974,
-0.7588902116,
0.9821654558,
0.0355857462,
-0.4728657305,
0.9342519045,
0.4187270701,
0.6105464101,
-0.2191073745,
1.0589321852,
-0.1737096608,
0.5490287542,
-0.5623602271,
0.4031018615,
-0.3485075533,
0.0926000699,
-0.8102621436,
-0.9607257843,
-0.2855170965,
0.3560179174,
-0.0819471627,
0.3513913453,
1.327299118,
0.5738452673,
0.2953467667,
0.0488764644,
0.3898934722,
-0.3662739694,
0.2990670502,
0.7330386043,
1.2300702333,
-0.2667111456,
0.706720531,
0.0823520496,
-0.2862351239,
0.2337622643,
-0.9464433193,
-0.790125668,
-0.7184410095,
-0.3374289274,
-0.2705632448,
-0.0822545886,
0.8306624293,
0.4259361029,
-0.7631819248,
-0.0372038595,
-0.3635374606,
0.1205476969,
-0.558627069,
-0.2396161854,
0.108373411,
-0.7268542647,
-0.6464281082,
0.4621496201,
0.367367208,
0.1182637662,
-0.4359412789,
0.1385465711,
-0.7234426737,
0.1519403607,
0.7262403965,
0.1139928028,
-0.6434147954,
-0.3163847327,
-0.0670253411,
0.1033514217,
0.0584335513,
0.9017803073,
-0.7185593843,
0.4697518051,
0.3512869477,
0.2938240767,
0.3678721488,
0.0154961385,
0.7207410932,
-0.945792377,
-0.0534874238,
0.3840839267,
0.0487946868,
0.2053502798,
-0.405104965,
0.5054072142,
0.1344958246,
-0.769541204,
-0.6056948304,
0.6731972098,
-0.7921033502,
-0.1284371316,
1.2070910931,
0.0157598387,
0.1719389409,
-0.3568910062,
-0.52947855,
0.1921194792,
-0.3757044673,
0.6058679819,
1.0213837624,
-0.3288984299,
-0.3297381997,
-0.9388402104,
0.6253759861,
0.5058928728,
-0.9714090228,
-0.0535839982,
0.3735672832,
-0.0582906269,
0.3207837045,
1.0108430386,
-0.0763826594,
0.256116271,
0.2486619204,
0.1043094024,
0.1646983624,
-0.4141956568,
-0.2705380917,
0.3487164378,
-0.0206857491,
-0.0935785621
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.07078v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.07078v1
|
PUB: A Pragmatics Understanding Benchmark for Assessing LLMs' Pragmatics Capabilities
| 2024-01-13T13:46:14 | 2024-01-13T13:46:14 |
Settaluri Lakshmi Sravanthi, Meet Doshi, Tankala Pavan Kalyan, Rudra Murthy, Pushpak Bhattacharyya, Raj Dabre
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
LLMs have demonstrated remarkable capability for understanding semantics, but
they often struggle with understanding pragmatics. To demonstrate this fact, we
release a Pragmatics Understanding Benchmark (PUB) dataset consisting of
fourteen tasks in four pragmatics phenomena, namely, Implicature,
Presupposition, Reference, and Deixis. We curated high-quality test sets for
each task, consisting of Multiple Choice Question Answers (MCQA). PUB includes
a total of 28k data points, 6.1k of which have been created by us, and the rest
are adapted from existing datasets. We evaluated nine models varying in the
number of parameters and type of training. Our study indicates that fine-tuning
for instruction-following and chat significantly enhances the pragmatics
capabilities of smaller language models. However, for larger models, the base
versions perform comparably with their chat-adapted counterparts. Additionally,
there is a noticeable performance gap between human capabilities and model
capabilities. Furthermore, unlike the consistent performance of humans across
various tasks, the models demonstrate variability in their proficiency, with
performance levels fluctuating due to different hints and the complexities of
tasks within the same dataset. Overall, the benchmark aims to provide a
comprehensive evaluation of LLM's ability to handle real-world language tasks
that require pragmatic reasoning.
|
[
-0.351167202,
-0.7791324258,
0.3983641267,
0.3460369408,
-0.2760905325,
0.0371139273,
-0.4333402216,
-0.2460754812,
-0.4217257202,
0.3469797671,
-0.7318102717,
-0.589337647,
-0.608728826,
0.1632862985,
-0.1566048115,
0.6945493817,
-0.1570525914,
0.0952676609,
-0.4407266974,
-0.0064466721,
-0.7487166524,
-0.3077905476,
-0.1938494295,
-0.3258137107,
0.4139749408,
0.675706923,
0.5367729068,
0.74231112,
0.7749507427,
0.2408757508,
-0.1904126108,
0.4216584265,
-0.6951074004,
0.0699411705,
-0.3660757542,
-0.5144757628,
-0.4569903612,
0.0394559912,
0.766677916,
0.905744493,
-0.2812686265,
0.3491587639,
0.3280319273,
0.4748390615,
-0.5436640382,
0.4524946511,
-0.7076109052,
-0.1396159232,
-0.1011142954,
0.111953035,
-0.3948088288,
-0.1511945724,
0.1851996332,
-0.7935118675,
0.1463922113,
-0.020181397,
1.0161274672,
0.2877627909,
-0.429536283,
-0.2270667553,
-0.3831844926,
0.6380627751,
-0.669670701,
0.5648471713,
0.3641716838,
0.4267371893,
-0.1604650468,
-0.8284502029,
-0.3592054546,
-0.30890432,
-0.0961192623,
0.1735024005,
-0.1018283963,
0.2163481712,
0.3112407029,
0.1556395143,
-0.6159186959,
0.1948608905,
-0.174460426,
-0.2449583262,
0.5891266465,
0.306799829,
-0.0533985868,
0.0252858698,
-0.3443398178,
-0.0944366083,
-0.6713886857,
0.1266933233,
0.2016956508,
0.1773385853,
-0.0657145306,
0.4132301509,
-0.3941553533,
1.1340150833,
-0.4498583972,
-0.2756868303,
0.1350013018,
-0.8331665993,
-0.190810591,
-0.4096778333,
0.4117497504,
0.4855240583,
0.5710371733,
-0.0961981416,
0.0205889884,
0.0419690311,
0.2049455494,
-0.6532953978,
-0.3810003996,
-0.1069997698,
-0.3004738092,
0.225722149,
-0.1388103366,
-0.4698425233,
-0.510504961,
-0.4989459813,
0.0971946567,
-0.5782367587,
-0.3378818929,
0.3245432079,
-0.0892510712,
0.482686013,
0.3935186863,
-0.4863239825,
0.3752419353,
0.927821517,
0.6492462158,
-0.3085537553,
-0.5674848557,
-0.28576985,
0.0130448192,
-0.1499492675,
0.9399513006,
-0.5349960327,
-0.48199597,
-0.1259469986,
-0.037955761,
-0.5161818862,
-0.8729472756,
0.664285183,
-0.0891329646,
-0.270707041,
-0.3143609464,
-0.8495690823,
-0.267288506,
0.3541098535,
-0.2586585283,
0.6730869412,
-0.0470478535,
-0.4169386625,
0.3047983944,
-0.3338809013,
-0.2811575234,
0.1907740235,
-0.1378499717,
-0.0656738654,
0.25628528,
0.0252397787,
0.4963462651,
-0.3068810999,
0.2706102133,
-0.2408747077,
-0.5736208558,
0.4843012094,
-0.4145362973,
0.283113718,
0.0117625473,
0.0252743755,
0.0653393716,
-0.6852678061,
0.1813886911,
0.1122450903,
-0.1754225791,
-0.0121838879,
0.1760268211,
-0.3431321979,
0.3062886298,
0.4215389192,
-0.0706701204,
-0.0002448471,
-0.2447569519,
0.3885110319,
0.6501650214,
0.2697848976,
0.1554349661,
-0.5170954466,
0.552077055,
0.1599198431,
0.0664069653,
-0.1924873739,
-0.4287169576,
-0.6112905145,
-0.433901161,
0.1803825051,
0.58385849,
-0.4302929938,
0.2210950255,
-0.349639684,
-0.6690410376,
-0.6339418292,
0.4468100965,
0.744487524,
0.6335065961,
0.1438995898,
-0.3405355215,
-0.2105248272,
-1.0334663391,
-0.6272788048,
-0.3871583343,
-0.1337697655,
0.5678051114,
0.5662152767,
0.0424641259,
0.7732322216,
-0.3102807403,
-0.0541619137,
-0.1018028855,
0.3505212367,
0.2768416107,
0.1751212478,
0.0004495705,
-0.7131609917,
-0.2782690227,
-0.1170238629,
-0.5526357293,
-0.3692288995,
-0.0890325084,
-0.1140663996,
-0.2247195095,
0.2470200956,
-0.4375468493,
0.25260517,
0.3072511256,
-0.472271353,
0.8423572183,
-0.165200904,
-0.013174193,
-0.5993562341,
-0.1132686436,
0.0431452803,
-0.0788945407,
-0.6566224098,
-0.0091414144,
0.3202263713,
0.166754961,
-0.7114090323,
0.4347509742,
-0.6035565734,
-0.3483423293,
-0.0266580731,
0.5130008459,
0.1368998885,
0.3769865036,
0.1064704135,
1.0621654987,
0.4056012332,
-0.6527435184,
0.193409577,
0.2627389431,
-0.5825847983,
0.679666996,
-0.7126395702,
0.1185091808,
-0.0527607538,
0.0808189437,
-1.1527581215,
-0.1290352792,
0.0177289508,
-0.3956437409,
0.1906120479,
-0.1419206411,
-0.648873806,
-0.0161390658,
-0.022098463,
-0.0724120364,
0.3654968441,
-0.1137705371,
0.2970182598,
0.143524915,
-0.1203895733,
-0.5071477294,
-0.4875057936,
0.0126951113,
-0.2275444716,
-0.6172244549,
0.3417266011,
-0.0262247641,
-0.5694516301,
-0.2533196807,
-0.3770458102,
-0.0725021139,
0.4166072309,
0.2489332855,
0.0956402496,
-0.2203531414,
0.1807358265,
-0.3328386545,
-0.0686386749,
0.1398929507,
-0.0049447897,
0.3450604677,
-0.3526532352,
-0.4974991977,
-0.5577395558,
-0.1351479143,
0.4446655214,
-0.4023711085,
0.6894847751,
0.4495053887,
-0.0935147256,
-0.2142030299,
-0.3700343072,
-0.2673021555,
-0.4119472504,
0.5345904231,
-0.5682676435,
-0.790084064,
0.5753214955,
-0.1655264944,
0.2998499572,
0.0677166805,
0.5237686038,
-0.322714895,
0.851478219,
0.3062063754,
0.306974411,
0.4748829007,
-0.0719557554,
0.0390916839,
-0.7439200878,
-0.2267939895,
-0.4754146338,
-0.3055915833,
-0.480043143,
-0.7532265782,
0.0133993821,
0.3428662717,
-0.2484245151,
0.2657881081,
-0.4136874974,
0.3910713196,
0.2934631407,
0.0608902872,
0.3128235936,
-0.2518121898,
-0.0723202229,
-0.2854798734,
-0.6087239385,
-0.7744286656,
0.8550816774,
0.5164036751,
0.8726677895,
0.1637546122,
0.5981414914,
-0.0596298724,
0.2824272215,
-0.7112260461,
0.8083987236,
-0.0427000783,
-0.4642161131,
-0.0569351204,
-0.4193164706,
-0.7714090943,
0.4896289706,
0.1248981357,
-0.7204467654,
0.0156454779,
-0.0892717093,
-0.0976992995,
-0.2764405906,
-1.1859946251,
1.1451135874,
-0.3126603961,
-0.4525620043,
-0.2703237236,
-0.516767621,
0.2981694043,
0.1175592765,
0.1838418394,
-0.6545927525,
-0.5806409121,
0.73956424,
0.0093843313,
0.9082782269,
-0.2351300269,
-0.053800039,
0.1965114176,
-0.0232168734,
0.3745332956,
0.098800458,
-0.0815984383,
0.1488217711,
0.0761813447,
-0.5264565945,
-0.6308543682,
0.3784142733,
-0.6256437302,
-0.7575323582,
-0.2211668044,
-0.7493644953,
-0.5265571475,
-0.0151883764,
-0.0826283321,
0.3027458787,
-0.1821530908,
0.2007107437,
0.7311498523,
0.0445112959,
0.1277218312,
1.0110633373,
0.1719592363,
0.0660176128,
0.8081110716,
0.1683097482,
0.3854939044,
0.2671521604,
-0.0917159021,
-0.5305576921,
-0.979834497,
-0.1594353318,
0.4286392927,
-0.8387625217,
-0.1258121878,
-0.3318664134,
-0.0148935067,
-0.1886829585,
0.0446687788,
0.0028618027,
-0.2137224078,
-0.4827259779,
-0.0187206101,
0.2624742985,
0.5753422976,
0.3330037296,
0.5502590537,
-0.7587185502,
0.2240023911,
0.3082658648,
0.3367108405,
-0.2996629179,
-1.0357738733,
-0.1165493354,
0.032906875,
-0.2597382069,
-1.000151515,
0.2722280622,
0.4730839133,
0.9400279522,
0.2033893615,
-0.1132850647,
1.0218472481,
-0.549089849,
0.6870473623,
-0.2357489616,
-0.7934110761,
0.5542392135,
-0.3397829533,
0.3939685524,
0.7971306443,
0.3034839034,
-0.2791097164,
-0.4163331389,
-0.644574821,
-0.551864326,
0.6580545306,
0.2002221942,
-0.0712148249,
0.0899030641,
0.4606094658,
-0.0686483458,
0.2569328249,
-0.2447690368,
-0.1117396057,
0.1428125501,
-0.293938756,
-0.2155998051,
-0.2381400913,
-0.2187153995,
-0.2384906411,
0.368296802,
-0.2464737445,
0.2822663784,
-0.0591852628,
-0.4657177329,
0.3251181841,
0.3369561732,
0.5763853192,
1.4095542431,
-0.2046780735,
0.1413044333,
0.4355663657,
-0.5045604706,
-0.0604731701,
0.3883444369,
0.3950024545,
-0.066744335,
0.6247897744,
0.7122346759,
0.5316553712,
-1.0992670059,
0.3100598156,
-0.3504811227,
-0.0785259157,
0.0972084254,
0.3674773574,
0.4201983809,
0.1907833219,
0.259645462,
-0.5004659295,
-0.0439610258,
-0.3960105777,
0.4274763465,
0.2833606601,
-0.2366417199,
-0.2058873773,
0.1471500397,
0.0807254612,
-0.4337520599,
0.438185662,
-0.2559655607,
-0.2821393311,
0.7413560152,
0.5641696453,
0.4004403353,
0.0201095827,
0.130684033,
0.1290377676,
0.3915459514,
0.0338948667,
0.462061137,
-0.289822489,
-0.7261645198,
-0.5080454946,
-0.5235181451,
-0.858700633,
-0.2078661472,
-0.853230834,
0.193730846,
-0.344581008,
-0.0410624109,
0.0805479512,
0.3804454505,
-0.7372950912,
0.1029158905,
0.0122440094,
1.2267785072,
-0.738158226,
0.9185987711,
1.0971693993,
-0.238886416,
-0.7807881832,
-0.0690389797,
0.1577888131,
-1.1687988043,
0.556969285,
0.220128119,
0.0663287267,
0.2112987936,
-0.2716040611,
-0.3950960934,
1.2487312555,
0.4021809697,
-0.8688898683,
0.0685885027,
-0.0153088504,
0.5409023762,
-0.404946357,
0.4138595462,
1.0811345577,
0.3526247442,
-0.073146224,
-0.9097543359,
-0.2179170698,
-0.0250633359,
-0.0393242836,
0.0437154435,
-0.5091703534,
0.5406765342,
0.1382906288,
-0.2311616689,
-0.1736395657,
0.629041791,
0.6742001772,
0.3770122826,
0.4826958179,
0.4915189743,
0.937725842,
-0.2762468159,
0.7315360308,
-0.3918293417,
0.167660743,
1.2595239878,
-0.4529828727,
0.93893677,
0.4228416085,
-0.3449782133,
0.3727115095,
0.712410152,
0.2594740987,
0.2430372238,
0.3691648543,
-0.2471170276,
-0.2663520575,
-0.360771805,
-0.1307242662,
0.540235281,
0.8750124574,
-0.1174635515,
-0.3378019631,
-0.131828934,
-0.0297370329,
0.2999784648,
-0.2855191827,
0.9780042768,
0.0803460181,
-0.791223526,
0.879303813,
-0.2513824403,
0.5800885558,
-0.7657969594,
-0.0534694232,
-0.2807133794,
0.2284387201,
0.0764416754,
-1.2299879789,
0.3020367026,
0.2019002587,
0.1004111394,
-0.4969539642,
0.8607044816,
-0.2767036557,
-0.1760807335,
0.2111413926,
0.7404843569,
0.4367637634,
0.0536703914,
-1.0172723532,
0.2921446264,
-0.1303209066,
-0.0855315477,
0.4625613689,
0.5204060078,
0.1715810597,
0.6899149418,
0.3532111049,
0.1387156546,
0.0039675222,
0.0930701792,
0.7314472198,
-0.6082214713,
-0.2412206382,
-0.801063776,
0.3656730354,
-0.1280010343,
-0.5813419223,
0.9575718045,
0.2489408702,
0.8164138198,
0.2660279572,
0.3168133795,
0.1640421897,
0.5504921675,
-0.2993774414,
0.3869386613,
-0.2598342597,
0.2326194495,
0.1244801581,
-0.5935302377,
-0.0481524505,
0.6708878279,
-0.7051768899,
-0.1349209249,
0.522089839,
0.9047751427,
0.1711547077,
0.1366892606,
0.388861835,
0.1481457949,
0.0717289522,
0.7733474374,
1.0966404676,
0.0350099355,
0.6560005546,
-0.2967070937,
-0.2191831172,
-0.1540749371,
-0.8669778705,
-0.8358322978,
-0.4334052205,
-0.3347477913,
-0.1364569217,
0.3072131574,
0.5624951124,
0.7206004858,
-0.5830551982,
-0.3492205441,
-0.2528297007,
0.4170551002,
-0.4318087399,
-0.2103880197,
-0.0026956771,
-0.5447106957,
-0.5240471363,
0.4508571029,
0.1746137291,
-0.1348322183,
-0.1507907659,
-0.0911624208,
-0.4604983032,
-0.0614926964,
0.3242236376,
0.219120875,
-0.7202701569,
-0.1411329955,
0.1614661664,
-0.124098368,
-0.0311976243,
0.7201320529,
-0.648604095,
0.4695609212,
0.4802113473,
0.7583072186,
0.314460367,
0.1809020042,
0.4622306228,
-0.8614767194,
0.1167067066,
0.4277641773,
0.2770710289,
0.3111227155,
-0.1199284196,
0.507171452,
0.2124397606,
-0.6001416445,
-1.0398706198,
0.1958556324,
-0.7087454796,
-0.2857794762,
1.056232214,
-0.5829142928,
-0.1515813917,
-0.3355169892,
-0.1129563749,
0.1677499712,
-0.1093707234,
0.229197219,
0.8992541432,
-0.3710704744,
-0.3912966549,
-0.8952034712,
0.2163697034,
0.7518242598,
-0.7974956036,
0.3806562424,
0.4510806799,
0.2278065532,
-0.1421928108,
0.4377669096,
0.1070592776,
0.4451826215,
-0.1073503494,
-0.262598455,
-0.1306796819,
-0.2444921434,
-0.5541165471,
-0.0780371428,
0.3370543122,
-0.3852442205
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.07037v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.07037v1
|
xCoT: Cross-lingual Instruction Tuning for Cross-lingual Chain-of-Thought Reasoning
| 2024-01-13T10:53:53 | 2024-01-13T10:53:53 |
Linzheng Chai, Jian Yang, Tao Sun, Hongcheng Guo, Jiaheng Liu, Bing Wang, Xiannian Liang, Jiaqi Bai, Tongliang Li, Qiyao Peng, Zhoujun Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Chain-of-thought (CoT) has emerged as a powerful technique to elicit
reasoning in large language models and improve a variety of downstream tasks.
CoT mainly demonstrates excellent performance in English, but its usage in
low-resource languages is constrained due to poor language generalization. To
bridge the gap among different languages, we propose a cross-lingual
instruction fine-tuning framework (xCOT) to transfer knowledge from
high-resource languages to low-resource languages. Specifically, the
multilingual instruction training data (xCOT-INSTRUCT) is created to encourage
the semantic alignment of multiple languages. We introduce cross-lingual
in-context few-shot learning (xICL)) to accelerate multilingual agreement in
instruction tuning, where some fragments of source languages in examples are
randomly substituted by their counterpart translations of target languages.
During multilingual instruction tuning, we adopt the randomly online CoT
strategy to enhance the multilingual reasoning ability of the large language
model by first translating the query to another language and then answering in
English. To further facilitate the language transfer, we leverage the
high-resource CoT to supervise the training of low-resource languages with
cross-lingual distillation. Experimental results on previous benchmarks
demonstrate the superior performance of xCoT in reducing the gap among
different languages, highlighting its potential to reduce the cross-lingual
gap.
|
[
-0.57835114,
-0.6650471687,
0.4296215773,
0.0056120646,
-0.3521194458,
0.5094419122,
-0.4790471196,
-0.4546866119,
0.0118351188,
0.517883122,
-0.7002977133,
-0.5645641088,
-0.4784018993,
0.0551887602,
0.0073662344,
0.8761523366,
-0.2629479468,
0.1648124903,
0.1751131415,
-0.1546147615,
-0.3592454493,
-0.4047105014,
-0.8189948797,
-0.0882407874,
0.4650025666,
0.7356956601,
0.6502466202,
0.6181274652,
0.3199738264,
0.2337693423,
0.1069868356,
0.6685994864,
-0.7414804697,
-0.1905927956,
-0.723380208,
-0.6817088723,
-0.432230711,
-0.3357756436,
0.6489153504,
0.5738592148,
0.0602430776,
-0.0541426316,
-0.0315491408,
0.4988902211,
-0.7379923463,
0.1227873117,
-0.9277506471,
0.2458050251,
-0.2106201351,
-0.3726930916,
-0.5472057462,
0.0658577234,
0.0510800593,
-0.7063946128,
0.1309733391,
0.6718041897,
0.5623609424,
0.0050103115,
-0.4523696899,
-0.1300181895,
-0.2827868462,
0.9652627707,
-0.4086260796,
0.6816241145,
0.4574085474,
0.2393056005,
0.0845103934,
-0.493752718,
-0.5657430887,
0.0392082334,
-0.2189283073,
-0.0517950654,
0.1479934007,
0.1127145886,
0.08864896,
0.2495321333,
-0.5497890115,
0.0240129773,
-0.0419757999,
-0.092166476,
0.4310478568,
0.0904185027,
0.401043117,
0.1042062491,
-0.6811632514,
-0.2530682087,
-0.7769964933,
-0.0797604769,
0.1684164256,
0.5963472128,
-0.2633203566,
0.0960299894,
-0.0306688007,
0.6837380528,
0.1362760365,
-0.0898505226,
0.032311473,
-0.7209758162,
-0.2192915827,
0.6198408008,
0.6393855214,
0.2487989962,
0.1260250658,
-0.1192791909,
-0.0970607549,
-0.1586360484,
-0.1617677808,
-0.5648060441,
-0.082839638,
-0.1997430176,
-0.0867340341,
0.00370833,
-0.0505042337,
-0.6771333218,
0.1676958799,
-0.1803688407,
0.0307904314,
-0.5328723788,
-0.295622319,
0.2560014427,
0.0465696976,
0.1840473264,
0.1350438595,
-1.126159668,
0.4942573309,
0.628410995,
0.78141886,
-0.3182393014,
-0.6327151656,
-0.7105866671,
0.469483465,
-0.5418565869,
0.7610797286,
-0.5486775041,
-0.3705807626,
-0.2360361516,
0.2032616138,
-0.2718450427,
-0.2366228849,
0.160691157,
-0.4209819138,
0.2775461674,
-0.4668233693,
-0.4402527809,
0.0288152285,
0.6252331138,
-0.4586007297,
0.8041882515,
0.3064168692,
-0.6630721092,
0.4133262038,
-0.5048319697,
-0.5328854918,
-0.0322996862,
-0.2748439908,
-0.0884911269,
-0.1971971691,
0.3366954923,
-0.0801599994,
-0.6688276529,
-0.080398649,
-0.0930570588,
-0.3316339552,
-0.0860851258,
-0.528894186,
0.9273941517,
0.1569631994,
-0.6559490561,
-0.0267121047,
-0.618627429,
0.6515461802,
-0.272657901,
0.0615634285,
-0.5093940496,
-0.4490104914,
-0.0324272029,
0.6303673983,
-0.0481404178,
-0.5225090981,
0.2768399119,
-0.4775715768,
0.2357727736,
0.5820106268,
-0.0717578158,
0.5091069937,
-0.2562890351,
0.5973115563,
0.3667956591,
0.1880140007,
-0.109058857,
-0.4027396142,
-0.6506293416,
-0.164532274,
0.2190158367,
0.4622287154,
-1.2588045597,
-0.0318329707,
-0.1562319994,
-0.1087978333,
-0.6876685619,
0.4699018896,
0.9719778299,
0.444088906,
0.5236333609,
-0.2073813528,
-0.5319054723,
-0.565540731,
-0.0828882307,
-0.1098985672,
0.4123339653,
0.2208528072,
0.247904852,
-0.0989618748,
0.5643419027,
-0.3922432661,
-0.4284830689,
-0.4111768305,
0.2340647727,
-0.139728561,
0.4304398596,
0.5752620697,
-0.6451207995,
-0.908554256,
0.7583120465,
-0.3815870881,
0.0134193636,
-0.088516593,
-0.7609327435,
0.570985198,
0.4975999296,
-0.2283640653,
0.1522200555,
0.6166245341,
-0.3621598184,
0.3143870234,
-0.2633519173,
0.5348896384,
-0.8821576238,
-0.2583427727,
-0.4756220877,
-0.4316265583,
-0.1508374661,
0.1145503819,
0.1902610362,
0.0498820655,
-0.9519296885,
0.776098609,
-0.673265934,
0.1835278571,
-0.2144116312,
0.5063608289,
0.2689428926,
0.7174661756,
0.243159011,
0.7966115475,
0.6233083606,
-0.4140611291,
0.1653363258,
0.2636427283,
-0.3833788931,
0.6605966687,
-0.0984024778,
0.2168059498,
0.2408408672,
0.0478438959,
-0.6462682486,
0.2372295856,
0.1819354147,
0.0216825195,
0.3848342896,
0.0162065551,
-0.2708783448,
-0.0619638301,
-0.2179769874,
0.7934300303,
0.0850608349,
-0.6991923451,
0.2766471505,
0.1951108873,
0.1620922834,
-0.7276735902,
-0.8762109876,
-0.0357013531,
0.1425057948,
-0.5186350942,
0.5782087445,
0.065948613,
-0.1684905887,
0.1791327447,
-0.1590332538,
-0.1177223697,
-0.4545412958,
-0.3462280631,
0.2945005596,
-0.4052329063,
0.1854556501,
0.4537350833,
-0.1721056402,
-0.0011613151,
-0.7331497073,
0.4275020957,
-0.0825412199,
-0.5417214036,
0.0144294016,
0.6118080616,
0.4402959645,
-0.2655109763,
0.7092654109,
0.543817997,
-0.0445524491,
-0.6763364077,
-0.1907601207,
-0.0291365646,
-0.4184730351,
0.2963733077,
-0.676014483,
-0.7916241288,
0.2250057459,
-0.0539152808,
-0.0221747048,
0.0736158267,
0.5617505908,
0.2470698208,
1.2388718128,
0.7718859315,
-0.0868078247,
0.4121922553,
-0.4742800593,
0.4533754885,
-0.7325170636,
0.0379785933,
-0.2047015876,
-0.2495268434,
-0.7017104626,
-0.7427154779,
0.2523661852,
-0.1075680777,
-0.2564944625,
0.3724720478,
-0.2990899682,
0.7639769316,
0.5331872702,
0.0395016298,
0.4259581268,
-0.152141422,
-0.5244161487,
0.2125456482,
-1.1293598413,
-0.1368066072,
0.6009477973,
-0.2176410854,
0.9177274108,
0.0815668106,
0.6336916089,
0.06287577,
-0.0640247166,
-0.5666117072,
0.4515334368,
-0.4570398629,
-0.6423633695,
-0.3070729375,
-0.5486038923,
-0.753233552,
0.2898925543,
-0.0646602735,
-0.7142454386,
0.2445848286,
0.1894804686,
-0.2385567278,
0.737388134,
-0.7805715799,
0.9283477068,
-0.8698661327,
-0.8024572134,
-0.5265747309,
-0.7621483207,
0.4443639815,
-0.0962766111,
0.181913808,
-0.0222856551,
0.0108593702,
0.3257928491,
-0.5306204557,
0.7536141872,
0.1184602976,
-0.3386743963,
0.4332530499,
0.054354772,
0.4262073934,
0.1200425699,
-0.042645108,
0.2779437602,
0.2771066129,
-0.4687547386,
-0.838144362,
0.8785951138,
-0.8681765199,
-0.7772265077,
-0.2415363193,
-0.7776072621,
-0.4378918707,
0.3651854396,
0.4416201711,
0.2561070919,
-0.1312372237,
-0.0488413163,
0.6909726858,
-0.1690635681,
0.1382657439,
0.320787102,
-0.4007993937,
-0.4852366149,
1.0263979435,
0.08671958,
0.862680614,
1.0018935204,
0.1024122462,
-0.3034277856,
0.0313041322,
-0.7361854315,
0.1087560803,
-0.8526954055,
-0.3102462292,
-0.3511075377,
-0.2391474992,
-0.3117240667,
-0.4925645888,
-0.399998188,
-0.3794626296,
0.1360665113,
0.0511098281,
0.2390684634,
0.2294856161,
0.1445591748,
0.2240745425,
-0.8754844666,
0.3079890311,
0.1618342996,
0.4646577537,
0.0174320787,
-0.2953230441,
-0.5522104502,
0.464089781,
-0.2669147253,
-0.3916604221,
0.2710766196,
0.2924900055,
0.5265249014,
0.3816361427,
0.1892673373,
1.050650239,
-0.4543557167,
0.4369870722,
0.4415705502,
-1.2073494196,
0.479839623,
0.0709332079,
0.4922409058,
0.6508816481,
0.4873598516,
-0.6371588707,
-0.455206573,
-0.4815046489,
-0.6987147927,
0.9280619025,
-0.1276680827,
-0.2538045347,
-0.3766253293,
-0.2156522572,
0.2664597929,
0.0571836643,
-0.3582407236,
-0.0043351497,
-0.1154417992,
0.0002959822,
0.1562380344,
0.2253632993,
-0.1437424421,
-0.4067060053,
0.8555892706,
-0.49322474,
-0.0497149266,
0.1075410843,
-0.3425401747,
-0.4636636078,
0.2685367465,
0.4473207891,
0.6366176605,
0.0644541457,
0.3947424591,
0.5802108049,
-0.3092752695,
0.4370237887,
-0.3788209856,
0.1413015872,
-0.1641446501,
0.4132173657,
1.1230312586,
0.755603075,
-0.6611717939,
0.2472905815,
-0.1338472962,
-0.128606841,
0.2269361913,
0.2962531745,
-0.0921349823,
0.0916884765,
-0.2051400244,
-0.0083926963,
-0.1939661503,
-0.8155696988,
0.2102584392,
0.3291435838,
-0.4813091755,
-0.1582137942,
0.5117632747,
0.2545155585,
-0.183307156,
0.667775929,
-0.3053027391,
-0.5427939296,
0.4084435403,
0.8513959646,
0.8159268498,
-0.0242482312,
0.172185719,
0.235072732,
0.2547279596,
0.0365081392,
0.4167752564,
-0.4955512285,
-0.8408102989,
-0.5031253695,
-0.3282311559,
-0.6291738749,
-0.4511595964,
-0.5514153838,
0.6339532733,
-0.3387067616,
0.0342700593,
-0.3037676811,
0.058132764,
-0.6926263571,
0.1027355939,
0.325352788,
1.1119828224,
-0.651462853,
1.2666394711,
0.5209596157,
-0.2949177027,
-0.8833622336,
-0.0408342853,
0.0109780459,
-0.8902217746,
0.6649283767,
-0.2023069263,
-0.7505115271,
0.1076834798,
-0.1349708438,
-0.8820374012,
0.9252753258,
0.5398070216,
-0.9788148403,
-0.0557718277,
0.3818657994,
0.4752426744,
-0.560203433,
0.3087225854,
0.5963983536,
0.4522612691,
0.1964448839,
-0.9109517932,
-0.0389846675,
-0.1283204108,
-0.044825349,
0.586352706,
-0.8981034756,
0.7508914471,
-0.3481961191,
-0.1969511211,
-0.2502451241,
0.4112269282,
0.284914583,
0.2590626776,
0.5798965693,
0.4702435434,
0.8480575085,
0.0321612246,
0.9523177147,
-0.7315688729,
0.258987695,
1.2880206108,
-0.6042012572,
0.68825984,
0.635530293,
0.0582130551,
0.6420347691,
0.3445722163,
0.4388850033,
0.6663924456,
-0.0003568498,
-0.2946954668,
-0.228573665,
-0.2051225603,
-0.2914522588,
0.4372357428,
0.3934956193,
-0.275672406,
-0.2998323143,
0.2331014276,
-0.0517289191,
-0.0408089012,
-0.4476841986,
0.6711532474,
0.1766386032,
-0.9736331105,
1.0965067148,
-0.3259470761,
0.4370603859,
-0.7691396475,
-0.1833517253,
-0.1052002683,
0.3201680183,
-0.179207027,
-0.8323768377,
0.250136286,
-0.0537334457,
-0.2068851292,
-0.4915629327,
0.394123137,
-0.8412413001,
-0.5510703325,
0.6976749301,
0.6588212252,
0.0467701331,
0.4207572341,
-0.7006275654,
0.01402409,
0.1245239079,
0.0530298688,
0.4431075156,
1.0638644695,
-0.5654803514,
0.5353951454,
0.4684202969,
0.3542998731,
0.0775873959,
0.3975716531,
0.8208885789,
-0.6466827393,
-0.6724267006,
-0.729906261,
0.1921470463,
-0.1027013585,
-0.5849294662,
0.5977503657,
0.4826543629,
1.4919475317,
0.0542416237,
0.6824759245,
-0.1946361661,
-0.0148686087,
-0.6834719777,
0.6225956678,
-0.5621691346,
0.2004704624,
-0.2342139333,
-0.6498390436,
-0.1241061613,
0.4235574007,
-0.3959091008,
-0.1010173187,
1.2838442326,
0.9353329539,
-0.3248892128,
0.0469404422,
0.7355628014,
0.0416134298,
0.1564706713,
0.8704560995,
0.580350399,
-0.2549090981,
0.6397513151,
-0.5176938772,
-0.2235465199,
0.0507207103,
-0.8388323188,
-0.8568572998,
-0.5107218027,
-0.260112673,
0.0226072017,
0.3149103522,
1.2619214058,
0.8876211047,
-0.944640398,
-0.4879250824,
-0.2283872068,
0.5341014266,
-0.7316702008,
-0.187833637,
0.2896925509,
-0.8121163845,
-0.7983824015,
0.2115252465,
0.5867545605,
-0.3564967513,
-0.3073704839,
-0.1953665018,
-0.5736971498,
-0.0048348601,
0.7439645529,
0.204722479,
-0.633072257,
-0.3207319081,
0.2574339807,
-0.2526629269,
0.2230462581,
1.0247619152,
-0.6694225669,
0.6804422736,
0.5250389576,
0.6238838434,
0.4783976376,
-0.2909683287,
0.7176971436,
-0.897390008,
0.3513964713,
0.1009116322,
0.5060587525,
0.1558345854,
-0.4894792736,
0.3910183609,
0.0279631671,
-0.357541889,
-0.6504887938,
0.156281054,
-0.7177596092,
-0.3244355619,
0.9283249378,
-0.2435753793,
-0.6021704078,
-0.1251955479,
-0.5511862636,
0.3191745281,
-0.1390542239,
0.7741388083,
0.7231728435,
-0.2462653369,
-0.3652167022,
-0.0994574577,
0.413658917,
0.4513565302,
-0.957467556,
0.2025901675,
-0.0750776231,
-0.0728161559,
0.1172694936,
0.505122602,
-0.0894962102,
0.5543221235,
0.1274671555,
-0.0141761098,
0.2214187086,
-0.4454356432,
0.2713621259,
-0.140314728,
0.0722774267,
-0.1915414184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.07022v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.07022v1
|
Edge-Enabled Anomaly Detection and Information Completion for Social Network Knowledge Graphs
| 2024-01-13T09:27:37 | 2024-01-13T09:27:37 |
Fan Lu, Quan Qi, Huaibin Qin
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In the rapidly advancing information era, various human behaviors are being
precisely recorded in the form of data, including identity information,
criminal records, and communication data. Law enforcement agencies can
effectively maintain social security and precisely combat criminal activities
by analyzing the aforementioned data. In comparison to traditional data
analysis methods, deep learning models, relying on the robust computational
power in cloud centers, exhibit higher accuracy in extracting data features and
inferring data. However, within the architecture of cloud centers, the
transmission of data from end devices introduces significant latency, hindering
real-time inference of data. Furthermore, low-latency edge computing
architectures face limitations in direct deployment due to relatively weak
computing and storage capacities of nodes. To address these challenges, a
lightweight distributed knowledge graph completion architecture is proposed.
Firstly, we introduce a lightweight distributed knowledge graph completion
architecture that utilizes knowledge graph embedding for data analysis.
Subsequently, to filter out substandard data, a personnel data quality
assessment method named PDQA is proposed. Lastly, we present a model pruning
algorithm that significantly reduces the model size while maximizing
performance, enabling lightweight deployment. In experiments, we compare the
effects of 11 advanced models on completing the knowledge graph of public
security personnel information. The results indicate that the RotatE model
outperforms other models significantly in knowledge graph completion, with the
pruned model size reduced by 70\%, and hits@10 reaching 86.97\%.}
|
[
-0.398150593,
-0.8919876814,
0.5293595195,
-0.2750678658,
-0.1635978222,
0.493760854,
0.1598694623,
-0.4867449403,
0.3690043986,
0.474521488,
-0.5533062816,
-0.7354588509,
-0.5551813841,
-0.1888711601,
-0.4730553627,
0.6692455411,
0.2253603339,
-0.2164011449,
-0.4321399033,
-0.0086610671,
-0.0946935341,
-0.2743169963,
-0.7402651906,
-0.4579286873,
0.023369411,
0.4279164374,
0.8696464896,
0.6976612806,
0.3967165649,
0.3175761998,
-0.0733901262,
0.4452310801,
-0.5979515314,
-0.2351364046,
-0.0281069353,
-0.1192464903,
-0.9858126044,
-0.2536199093,
0.4787269533,
1.0284851789,
-0.0511678159,
-0.0645549297,
0.0244477242,
0.8638311625,
-0.4433265626,
-0.0885813087,
-0.5322206616,
0.0046064449,
-0.3994663358,
0.1867319047,
0.1171566322,
-0.3467158079,
0.1114795208,
-0.5484482646,
0.3506613076,
-0.0177597385,
0.5783780813,
0.0630613118,
-0.4801087081,
0.023587428,
-0.4953600466,
0.2722530365,
-0.5955206156,
0.4903710186,
0.3628306389,
0.2985921502,
-0.258672446,
-0.8066780567,
-0.5814366341,
0.1299407631,
0.1124901921,
0.035545703,
-0.217080608,
0.2814568877,
0.0401594378,
0.2512622178,
-0.4620538652,
0.2354084402,
-0.4759353399,
-0.2385697216,
0.7595120668,
0.2710910738,
0.1477252841,
-0.1586864144,
-0.1219098493,
0.1193075776,
-0.7557015419,
0.3152970672,
0.6886174679,
0.1619484574,
-0.1851609498,
0.3047293127,
-0.795729816,
0.6224184632,
-0.0400124975,
-0.0292619523,
0.3090272546,
-0.4155924618,
-0.1047343612,
-0.2390209734,
0.6485985518,
0.5645820498,
0.0202133693,
-0.256303072,
-0.2135878801,
-0.2868455052,
0.2373791933,
-0.6358357072,
-0.4778178334,
0.3243584037,
-0.6265850067,
-0.1939648241,
0.1845546812,
-0.7637378573,
-0.8442829251,
-0.2785328329,
-0.1495393515,
-0.4082916379,
-0.5693978071,
-0.0966296494,
-0.3776380122,
-0.1384065449,
0.5952359438,
-0.2134711593,
0.5175428391,
0.7207541466,
0.9778875709,
-0.2186620235,
-0.1065343544,
-0.3880957067,
0.063422583,
-0.3345101476,
0.3688335121,
-0.3080407083,
-0.0644529909,
-0.1688575149,
-0.087510854,
-0.0290826242,
-0.3417791128,
0.4771977067,
-0.7206149101,
-0.6563037038,
-0.4779957235,
-0.6350910068,
-0.2828532159,
0.316359967,
-0.5216061473,
0.955216527,
0.2657560706,
-0.9105730653,
0.3963600695,
-0.3224939108,
-0.4281919301,
0.3779981732,
-0.1712869704,
-0.5491440296,
-0.2493267804,
0.2479163557,
0.7474348545,
-0.3893461823,
0.236132443,
-0.8030181527,
-0.4329522848,
-0.0151469344,
0.2499207705,
0.634820044,
0.2305268794,
-0.2474092096,
-0.1185501069,
-0.6225786805,
0.0540957637,
0.3027434647,
-0.0205856729,
-0.2712746263,
-0.0064335428,
-0.1614582539,
-0.165077284,
0.3888250589,
-0.8109961152,
0.0194924921,
0.1649780869,
0.3229937255,
0.7386133075,
0.2465123236,
0.4271718264,
-0.2925087512,
0.2737751007,
0.1539757699,
0.4973527193,
0.4120461643,
-0.4551402032,
-0.2031397223,
-0.4346098304,
0.1186504066,
0.6678162217,
-0.8209702969,
0.5775235891,
-0.4932433963,
-0.682723105,
-0.1376973689,
0.4981653094,
0.124391526,
0.6032232642,
0.2404080331,
-0.1092056856,
-0.4558139145,
-0.7322276831,
-0.12537238,
-0.0333153456,
0.0090158582,
0.5117912292,
0.4055579007,
-0.5076013803,
1.0806474686,
-0.5702751279,
-0.2524914443,
-0.4378548861,
-0.2729705274,
0.1618198752,
0.3769322932,
0.602021575,
-1.0081512928,
-0.266923517,
0.1706475616,
-0.8649384379,
0.1189515814,
0.4440751076,
0.308829695,
-0.5063316226,
0.4760372341,
-0.3843525052,
0.6700578332,
0.2416838557,
-0.2606166005,
0.2421412319,
-0.1231091022,
0.1828807145,
-0.7202327251,
-0.1066849157,
-0.070454061,
-0.4293545485,
-0.9365694523,
-0.1489894986,
0.1803949028,
-0.4662736952,
-0.185953781,
0.2129758894,
-0.4022423923,
-0.2151844203,
-0.0757261515,
0.3124496341,
-0.1020321548,
0.2783237994,
-0.312780261,
0.3174788952,
0.7250753641,
-0.9418709874,
0.5673972964,
-0.1309062392,
-0.1499164999,
0.6041144729,
-0.6817990541,
0.1161646768,
-0.4715687633,
0.2521001101,
-0.7035240531,
-0.6051912308,
0.1638222486,
-0.3775083721,
0.1133208349,
-0.4956432283,
-0.2997002602,
-0.4757167697,
-0.3272653222,
0.4474942982,
0.4449414313,
-0.2948316038,
0.6534311175,
0.7280756831,
0.002439274,
-0.5895795822,
-0.5105777979,
-0.0214124434,
-0.0907065421,
-0.7374545932,
0.4014048576,
0.3628067374,
-0.1650798619,
0.2441268265,
-0.0050549656,
-0.1911432594,
0.3917163908,
0.3733414114,
0.1196700111,
0.0976092294,
-0.0069560087,
0.1268384308,
0.2817126513,
-0.2430345863,
-0.1463055462,
0.4866118729,
-0.041428782,
-0.8366447687,
-0.5576819777,
0.3175033629,
0.6015686989,
-0.0819979012,
0.6493412256,
0.736263454,
-0.6746746898,
-0.0002911363,
-0.603176713,
-0.145957008,
-0.4806089699,
0.3383770287,
-0.1468283385,
-0.6609880328,
0.8252538443,
-0.2958549261,
-0.1006720141,
0.3079392016,
-0.2532623112,
-0.0231100526,
0.8329423666,
0.5133378506,
-0.1957710832,
0.7630162835,
-0.5129640698,
0.2797804177,
-0.7663847804,
-0.2294250429,
-0.1376376748,
-0.2070780098,
-0.3163659871,
0.0445763916,
0.6788685918,
0.5156027079,
-0.152731657,
0.2307725847,
-0.5756704211,
0.1209757552,
0.246375218,
0.6657734513,
0.1460326761,
0.002520747,
0.1277098358,
0.1774792224,
-0.6205574274,
-0.1463258415,
1.2344884872,
0.483096391,
0.5885690451,
0.0676585063,
0.8157470226,
0.6584967971,
-0.0908201709,
-0.3217636049,
0.5200486779,
-0.1389121413,
-0.1789753139,
-0.5079252124,
-0.7212203145,
-0.7766913176,
-0.1670446694,
-0.1202868223,
-0.8597207069,
0.5347934961,
-0.0567447655,
-0.2827891707,
0.3846312165,
-0.5746033788,
0.6638767719,
0.0081009399,
-0.1340370774,
-0.4000163972,
-0.3013994992,
0.3363731503,
0.0436481945,
0.2489724457,
-0.3570708036,
0.0532935336,
0.8604348898,
-0.7779403925,
0.9059859514,
-0.7772021294,
0.5114724636,
0.5267736316,
-0.2066200972,
0.9343316555,
0.3173522353,
-0.091272451,
0.1549315602,
-0.2850590646,
-0.4878691137,
-0.610876739,
0.4024188817,
-0.8845649958,
-0.476106137,
0.1923224032,
-0.3762390018,
0.0177429374,
0.4364594221,
0.2074679285,
0.5294783711,
-0.0323597044,
0.4252378047,
0.8363964558,
0.2072852254,
0.2470436245,
0.3811870813,
0.1742714792,
-0.4910124242,
0.8618192077,
0.7286091447,
0.1107246578,
0.0782228187,
-0.1520211101,
-0.1358335316,
-0.9477406144,
-0.3561854064,
-0.0228429381,
-0.7468389273,
-0.4558633864,
-1.1182967424,
-0.3719728887,
-0.8513382673,
-0.128330335,
-0.5060574412,
-0.2198826075,
-0.0586904772,
-0.1304772347,
0.7254186273,
0.7669948339,
-0.0638116226,
0.5843738914,
-0.4656380415,
0.2957031131,
0.3407020867,
0.1673583835,
0.2802166343,
0.0486540981,
-0.2575987875,
0.3369431794,
-0.1870256662,
-0.9504092336,
-0.0939696655,
0.1639187336,
0.7156116366,
0.5066407323,
0.5042906404,
0.5755982399,
0.2202080786,
0.5221340656,
0.0107095502,
-0.8731626868,
0.5213130713,
-0.4624663591,
-0.0640650243,
0.5230438709,
0.1820533425,
-0.4909029901,
-0.3225137293,
-0.7268118262,
-0.8125625253,
0.4576428831,
0.0896057263,
-0.282766521,
0.1837658882,
0.5356345177,
-0.3939127922,
0.2109320015,
-0.270103395,
-0.2006246895,
-0.4824616015,
-0.2170408666,
0.3353827298,
0.102923803,
-0.1808181405,
-0.1652365625,
0.5490736961,
-0.2948044837,
0.1138822585,
0.3959653676,
-0.0900649652,
0.0986447334,
-0.0108340597,
0.0921002477,
0.7944013476,
-0.071828723,
-0.0043720067,
0.4972623587,
-0.6560975313,
-0.0459141955,
0.2065500021,
-0.428894639,
-0.1129263565,
0.4139935374,
0.4238853753,
-0.2660330534,
-0.3311829269,
0.9906892776,
0.1160717681,
0.0731647313,
-0.418209523,
0.3136896193,
-0.0076529956,
0.324758172,
0.9468020797,
0.1476041675,
0.2739688158,
-0.5052013993,
0.3011332154,
0.5798091292,
-0.5806475878,
-0.166882202,
0.34468624,
0.0326079875,
-0.1591331065,
0.7571599483,
-0.6048288941,
-0.7319154739,
0.8793851733,
0.0961541906,
0.4877975285,
-0.1876064986,
0.2874040008,
-0.0204903092,
0.3320611119,
-0.0918234512,
0.4679971933,
-0.2337643504,
-0.7250296474,
-0.0621670783,
-0.2093551606,
-0.1927045137,
0.0155363195,
-0.4717233181,
0.0887317508,
-0.7949158549,
-0.4342361689,
-0.3729230762,
0.1625398695,
-0.9755696058,
0.2385549694,
-0.3916992545,
0.8095927835,
-1.109551549,
0.7720549703,
0.5439146757,
0.0040038847,
-0.6843762994,
-0.2774277031,
0.0209932365,
-0.5975832939,
0.3580745459,
0.0115497373,
0.0263231453,
-0.0282685868,
-0.3504685462,
-0.7670631409,
1.3983608484,
0.3431186676,
-0.2447489351,
0.1172888204,
0.1573957503,
0.3185486794,
-0.3553446531,
0.1721638739,
0.5096979141,
0.4841095507,
0.0370715335,
-0.691177547,
0.2341691554,
-0.2545174658,
-0.1952620447,
0.0815813169,
-0.6195244193,
1.0236102343,
-0.0842474997,
-0.2748416662,
-0.5204024315,
0.7757229209,
0.0809482262,
0.7863098383,
0.59719491,
0.6890844107,
1.3534468412,
0.0356229916,
0.7509877682,
-0.0772472396,
0.1446533501,
0.6696928144,
-0.2663439214,
0.2975255549,
-0.0893700942,
-0.2189822793,
0.2471373081,
0.7921729088,
0.1053816453,
0.4164220095,
-0.2961259186,
-0.0630558431,
-0.2385692298,
-0.4542420208,
-0.4173696339,
0.1410737932,
0.5055008531,
-0.0765770897,
-0.1595291942,
0.0809013546,
-0.1182483584,
-0.166385591,
-0.7551409006,
0.795686841,
-0.1247431636,
-0.264996022,
0.2430861294,
0.0931415781,
0.3859248757,
-0.3917180896,
0.1375257671,
-0.1963148266,
0.118394509,
-0.7575344443,
-0.7594884038,
0.3142530918,
-0.3267270625,
-0.1098266765,
0.1550303102,
1.1341981888,
-0.0967365727,
-0.1145852059,
0.3774214387,
0.5274022818,
0.1339354068,
-0.2275360823,
-0.5684259534,
-0.0978481397,
-0.1561886221,
-0.0312550254,
0.2513473928,
0.4532234967,
-0.1987636983,
0.9514167905,
0.7020545006,
0.2003709525,
0.0911719799,
-0.0482259169,
1.0832899809,
-0.1511212885,
-0.7523983717,
-0.7003868818,
0.3596616387,
-0.8123139143,
-0.0640350208,
0.6645566821,
0.5028666258,
0.529774487,
0.3257083893,
0.7342370749,
-0.3336069584,
0.5315777659,
-0.2867341042,
0.7135576606,
-0.3117278516,
0.296267271,
-0.3693317771,
-0.6417595148,
0.3320052922,
0.0057682409,
-0.3471751213,
-0.0233556312,
0.2497433871,
0.8242993951,
-0.4357523322,
-0.0209009703,
0.2266057432,
-0.3348018825,
0.3429846764,
0.274020344,
0.4806530476,
-0.5265346766,
0.4076279998,
-0.2068091035,
-0.3920342028,
-0.3644709587,
-0.4857032597,
-0.9415885806,
-0.3680720627,
-0.3836768568,
-0.2718272209,
0.028717028,
0.6565238833,
0.9399571419,
-0.5419952869,
0.2255689651,
-0.3095158339,
0.7239069939,
-0.4597324431,
-0.2946506143,
0.5062701106,
0.0036171093,
-0.1228501871,
0.5606765151,
0.1028218716,
0.1726634651,
-0.1184216514,
-0.2267720401,
0.0460223183,
-0.2550292909,
-0.0731088817,
0.2534527183,
-0.3647432029,
-0.2487791032,
-0.1346640289,
-0.071911037,
-0.2875362635,
0.8025837541,
-0.5937081575,
0.3071847856,
0.746596694,
0.9665312767,
0.4636974037,
0.2132392973,
0.3993103206,
-0.8305571675,
0.1471155286,
0.136655882,
0.4127571285,
0.4445118904,
-0.9988347888,
0.3943606019,
0.4996485114,
-0.3579452932,
-0.9085415006,
0.3711954951,
-0.5397530198,
-0.2479255944,
0.6766822934,
-0.404687196,
-0.3569070995,
-0.6057921052,
0.4087178707,
0.5068544745,
-0.5269806981,
0.4999520779,
0.3637904227,
-0.1511271447,
-0.1911498755,
-0.4502714574,
0.5844351649,
-0.0877414569,
-0.7046909928,
0.0371109173,
0.1115237027,
0.2523694932,
0.1922726184,
0.7325995564,
0.1899526119,
0.5110403299,
0.1249672472,
-0.0887320638,
-0.5030136704,
-0.3270077407,
0.0811123773,
0.4476177096,
-0.2543162107,
-0.1165674776
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.07013v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.07013v1
|
Knowledge Distillation for Closed-Source Language Models
| 2024-01-13T08:43:32 | 2024-01-13T08:43:32 |
Hongzhan Chen, Xiaojun Quan, Hehong Chen, Ming Yan, Ji Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Closed-source language models such as GPT-4 have achieved remarkable
performance. Many recent studies focus on enhancing the capabilities of smaller
models through knowledge distillation from closed-source language models.
However, due to the incapability to directly access the weights, hidden states,
and output distributions of these closed-source models, the distillation can
only be performed by fine-tuning smaller models with data samples generated by
closed-source language models, which constrains the effectiveness of knowledge
distillation. In this paper, we propose to estimate the output distributions of
closed-source language models within a Bayesian estimation framework, involving
both prior and posterior estimation. The prior estimation aims to derive a
prior distribution by utilizing the corpus generated by closed-source language
models, while the posterior estimation employs a proxy model to update the
prior distribution and derive a posterior distribution. By leveraging the
estimated output distribution of closed-source language models, traditional
knowledge distillation can be executed. Experimental results demonstrate that
our method surpasses the performance of current models directly fine-tuned on
data generated by closed-source language models.
|
[
-0.1114086136,
-0.5033812523,
1.133701086,
-0.3209046125,
-0.4315137267,
-0.1100437567,
-0.5943956375,
0.0184690207,
-0.2964327633,
0.6308478713,
-0.3682343364,
-0.6664472222,
-0.7628543377,
-0.0402109399,
-0.1130918562,
1.000352025,
0.1612538546,
-0.0756257474,
0.1145466045,
0.4205933809,
-0.3864647448,
-0.4203934371,
-0.2324708104,
-0.3666219711,
0.2458385676,
0.1414622962,
0.5419571996,
0.4578818679,
0.2311436683,
0.3593503833,
0.0120084109,
-0.1421235353,
-0.5073425174,
0.0937618464,
-0.5474356413,
-0.6612035632,
-0.2484433502,
0.2217343748,
0.6925130486,
0.7258827686,
-0.2599382401,
-0.0225123949,
0.1019875184,
0.6417817473,
-1.0199557543,
0.4349817336,
-0.8888710141,
-0.1457859278,
-0.2561549842,
0.1464090049,
-0.2603856921,
-0.7621120214,
0.1559939235,
-0.4360463023,
0.3367043436,
-0.4297582507,
0.5604844093,
0.3954946101,
0.0086248796,
-0.1331961006,
-0.9655614495,
0.9216789603,
-1.2844748497,
0.3851022422,
0.5011715293,
0.5234996676,
-0.1327490658,
-0.7983107567,
-0.7384107709,
-0.1410707682,
-0.0515097007,
0.1624927074,
-0.3798678517,
0.017411029,
0.2410565764,
0.4165982902,
-0.3265911639,
-0.1177400574,
-0.5745468736,
-0.0455608033,
0.3455166817,
-0.2919023037,
-0.0639291257,
0.1421154737,
-0.0396063663,
-0.0219844375,
-0.4097062349,
-0.6116096973,
0.4100438058,
0.3369584382,
0.1373825818,
0.4717442989,
-0.585215807,
0.8568637371,
0.0179295577,
-0.4651645422,
0.2325114757,
-0.2901847661,
-0.4067049325,
-0.0958921164,
0.7966868877,
0.1437107176,
0.3335464895,
-0.2191117108,
-0.1557696164,
-0.0033370887,
-0.0097297598,
-0.6774388552,
-0.7628368735,
0.0201694872,
-0.0324552953,
-0.1810473949,
0.1468732655,
-0.8410992026,
-0.3018001318,
-0.1116954088,
0.2731318176,
-0.2930756211,
-0.7376625538,
0.0893104598,
-0.5597121119,
-0.5343263745,
0.0524780564,
-1.0378810167,
0.2932249308,
0.5750434399,
0.929993391,
0.0361975953,
0.0814404339,
-0.4169616699,
0.6092987061,
-0.2023946345,
0.4861336052,
-0.5802547932,
-0.0675387979,
-0.0798987672,
-0.1119241491,
0.0933905691,
-0.4859111011,
0.3424317837,
-0.5021375418,
0.0720742419,
-0.1216280833,
-0.6428720951,
-0.1654057652,
-0.1267206967,
-0.5253702998,
0.5020023584,
0.1245288998,
-0.9717082977,
0.3414485753,
-0.3202704489,
-0.1705156863,
-0.105948776,
-0.0904805884,
-0.2295791954,
0.3364161551,
0.5382590294,
0.529271543,
-0.286293298,
0.4715626836,
-0.3887236118,
-0.116972357,
-0.0725631416,
-0.5977488756,
0.6675587893,
0.3910143673,
-0.2621159256,
-0.1620794684,
-0.6235542893,
-0.3225613832,
-0.1179521531,
-0.1945486367,
-0.7882086039,
0.1747564822,
-0.6233583093,
-0.0072570457,
0.4607814848,
-0.6211966872,
0.2644147575,
-0.5404857993,
0.4723932743,
0.7219153047,
0.0983268023,
0.7888044715,
0.0908806995,
0.4252207875,
0.0995344445,
0.0830065012,
0.0707543567,
-0.6017049551,
-0.1907354742,
-0.4789856672,
0.2808745205,
0.2515229285,
-0.7958201766,
0.1671008915,
-0.2768345177,
-0.7692776322,
-0.3674378395,
0.1757318974,
0.3459710181,
0.8110447526,
0.3023140728,
0.0049176258,
-0.1003895774,
-0.7100785375,
-0.1364226192,
-0.4405136108,
-0.3355396688,
-0.1173861623,
0.2202908844,
0.0915057212,
0.9940280318,
-1.1128767729,
-0.0651651323,
-0.1193808839,
0.3271379769,
0.6089090109,
0.439805299,
0.5366722941,
-0.553910315,
-0.3108530343,
0.2508626878,
-0.4807344079,
-0.5098395348,
0.3460344672,
-0.2510199845,
0.0219017584,
0.2895270288,
-0.3483300507,
0.2144887,
0.6941657066,
-0.0226689745,
0.5695806742,
-0.393758446,
0.0779491141,
-1.1748538017,
-0.0339455381,
0.0211791974,
-0.0658086762,
-0.5259748101,
-0.0622420236,
0.141065076,
0.1613897383,
-0.1926167756,
0.3824715614,
-0.5575866103,
-0.0288800243,
-0.3848370612,
0.3589700758,
0.0251014568,
0.3938292563,
0.5521175861,
0.3579903543,
0.3573220968,
-0.4044046104,
0.4313848615,
0.0176619161,
-0.5548514128,
0.2428006828,
-0.5855606198,
-0.122716181,
0.011322855,
-0.0394338034,
-0.9705073833,
-0.0600262582,
0.257589072,
-0.248593092,
0.3538473845,
-0.7239814401,
-0.3232427537,
-0.2660929263,
0.0022093919,
0.0056881467,
0.7356997132,
-0.278290242,
0.2370704263,
0.3949397802,
-0.4851774871,
-0.6135298014,
-0.7889109254,
-0.387512356,
-0.2002500296,
-0.4528603852,
0.1078622937,
0.1067122966,
-0.2340411246,
0.1688079834,
-0.161159426,
-0.3533234894,
-0.1046905667,
0.2222794294,
0.1287816316,
-0.2728682756,
0.0700712055,
0.6588956714,
0.0575229004,
-0.0608109571,
-0.7038277984,
0.2536664307,
0.324726671,
-0.4741393626,
-0.1893234253,
0.0038690928,
0.2639392912,
-0.2228543311,
0.7979394197,
0.4765991867,
-0.2530660331,
-0.0593751222,
-0.7906010151,
-0.3467068672,
-0.4575372636,
0.2000019848,
-0.4374467731,
-0.7897056937,
0.3796155155,
-0.1812509298,
0.0482765101,
0.3217741847,
0.7321142554,
0.2138137817,
0.6831898689,
0.7299538851,
-0.0989314914,
0.5452333093,
-0.0149258021,
0.0757611245,
-0.4666143358,
0.1097200513,
-0.663485229,
0.065765731,
-0.5272855759,
-0.3394390345,
0.4039134085,
0.3722221851,
-0.1867414862,
0.3256293535,
-0.3002837896,
0.2379570603,
1.010183692,
0.0334224328,
0.7060343623,
0.120339863,
-0.4237616658,
0.1065516248,
-0.5678958297,
-0.5304524899,
1.065879941,
0.3437552452,
0.7719829679,
0.3010030985,
0.8604233861,
0.0455461293,
0.4605052471,
-0.2260223329,
0.1075668335,
-0.0281925816,
-0.6651859879,
-0.3298605084,
-0.7333964705,
-0.4399304092,
0.2747653425,
0.1103332415,
-0.8030727506,
0.2873089612,
0.2474583089,
-0.2990811169,
0.317930907,
-0.9948202968,
1.0171928406,
0.386809051,
-0.2343123406,
-0.120732829,
-0.3225140572,
0.8546193838,
-0.455878377,
0.4292989671,
-0.1625314951,
0.0668181032,
0.5896891356,
-0.7120466232,
0.6997244954,
-0.5582780838,
-0.2489048839,
0.2928545475,
0.0221292544,
0.5236589909,
0.1752603054,
-0.2480957955,
0.3860774934,
0.3298501074,
-0.256005317,
-0.7545952797,
0.7141489983,
-0.6839051843,
-0.8455238938,
-0.340701282,
-0.3907936215,
-0.2804508507,
0.3512844443,
0.2275492549,
-0.0194044057,
-0.0105201611,
-0.26097399,
0.1893182248,
-0.3339021802,
0.5560872555,
0.8175922036,
-0.1506604701,
-0.3359167278,
0.7226533294,
0.1127422154,
0.6659772396,
0.3753472269,
0.3189639151,
-0.4402803779,
-0.9690304399,
-0.3666701615,
0.416036129,
-0.3508986831,
-0.1140545309,
-0.4767612517,
0.0507021844,
-0.677773416,
0.2061237097,
-0.3912757039,
-0.46770522,
-0.139018774,
-0.1632521152,
0.3781396151,
0.83030653,
-0.3896088898,
0.4934678674,
-0.9586067796,
0.232286945,
0.4114528298,
0.2829314172,
-0.2079737633,
-0.6319528818,
-0.3134444356,
0.5448285341,
-0.2591528296,
-1.2612707615,
0.5513537526,
0.1028917283,
0.4689388871,
0.3565642536,
0.3827400506,
0.5033764243,
-0.7443819642,
0.7924239039,
0.2126238793,
-0.7552827597,
0.7350793481,
-0.4965977967,
0.3893633485,
0.3454446197,
0.3971512616,
-0.0248025618,
-0.9100571275,
-0.321845293,
-0.4394179881,
0.7208710909,
0.4015142024,
0.0046933931,
-0.2394415289,
0.213698864,
0.1437299252,
0.478314817,
-0.3995939493,
0.1280621886,
-0.2831992805,
-0.2581045032,
-0.2103201002,
-0.0603848062,
0.2185325772,
-0.2389882803,
0.8934521079,
0.0026334354,
-0.1309898794,
-0.1704926342,
-0.0229332186,
-0.0226610973,
0.161846891,
0.3568949699,
0.9444506764,
-0.5514789224,
0.2261560559,
-0.212749362,
-0.6322191358,
-0.0567769147,
0.3852310181,
-0.3280947208,
0.1964246631,
0.0912704915,
0.61371696,
-0.0247441139,
-0.4753747284,
0.5252447128,
0.0545104295,
0.0329709798,
-0.2069953382,
0.104553692,
0.4096600115,
0.6638498902,
0.3037448823,
-0.1838826537,
0.1448240131,
-0.4769560695,
0.2381282598,
0.2532493472,
-0.1103779003,
-0.4000370502,
0.7098566294,
-0.1599526405,
0.3947173059,
0.5785419941,
-0.0536578782,
-0.2443905175,
0.2027153075,
0.3985291123,
0.7433561683,
-0.4772967696,
0.2533690333,
0.4562997818,
0.2697550058,
-0.3439250886,
0.0800924078,
-0.1321473122,
-0.8294807673,
-0.5961073041,
-1.1186205149,
-0.2518931031,
0.0715231746,
-0.5647662878,
0.1006933153,
-0.0488611385,
-0.2894639671,
0.1935512871,
-0.1551654339,
-0.4354503155,
0.0336063243,
-0.0308248289,
0.5437162519,
-1.0088816881,
1.2924109697,
0.2340712696,
-0.7839316726,
-0.7286893129,
0.0917125195,
-0.2914536297,
-0.4098238945,
0.6209869981,
-0.5308647156,
0.1488595456,
0.1391796917,
-0.2717735171,
-0.7399705648,
0.9709743261,
1.0182884932,
-0.890063107,
0.0053266217,
0.0485058799,
0.4606060088,
-0.0508873649,
0.2663767338,
0.7586240172,
0.4302819073,
0.0754050314,
-0.9854284525,
-0.0605917685,
-0.0227973759,
0.1255974621,
0.2417376488,
0.0306916535,
0.8102627397,
-0.0678204298,
-0.2655682564,
-0.1956831366,
0.8280115724,
0.3555290699,
0.026840562,
0.2723926008,
0.41069296,
0.655931592,
-0.1279554218,
0.8326560855,
-0.1867597848,
0.4118108749,
1.4404454231,
0.0059290733,
1.0204386711,
0.4916241467,
-0.3995447159,
0.4595124722,
0.3547792733,
0.1388136595,
1.0878469944,
0.127922222,
-0.4093630612,
0.1720287055,
0.2950040102,
-0.352361083,
0.0276091155,
0.2812077701,
-0.6105193496,
-0.4235922694,
-0.0920360163,
0.0198238585,
0.2073249519,
-0.1135961711,
0.8613222837,
0.1353783011,
-0.8356518149,
0.6531119943,
0.1074661836,
0.4437572658,
-0.4091398716,
-0.1531120539,
-0.3131006658,
0.2446446419,
0.0538925827,
-0.5842422247,
0.5109766126,
0.2942971885,
-0.266566664,
0.0080183353,
0.5733501315,
-0.8504530787,
-0.634495914,
0.0868159235,
0.6514258981,
0.4897604287,
-0.5562796593,
-0.175023824,
-0.0325318389,
-0.1500473619,
-0.2192709297,
0.2698111832,
0.6183124781,
0.2074731141,
0.1925804019,
0.4591320157,
0.4489830136,
0.407892257,
0.0913500264,
0.882019937,
-0.1842110902,
-0.395857513,
-1.1472492218,
0.4433997571,
-0.0542224087,
0.1118911579,
0.5357208848,
0.2608255744,
0.9383478165,
-0.3743870258,
1.1731530428,
-0.0287662335,
0.6062680483,
-0.5075441003,
0.9248926044,
-0.3099147975,
0.2910279632,
-0.7034241557,
-1.1067407131,
0.0657702684,
0.4783786535,
-0.7640564442,
-0.0261351634,
0.4907239676,
0.7881560326,
-0.3675606847,
-0.0339347012,
0.6178933978,
0.4097065628,
0.2549489439,
0.6278897524,
0.4930073023,
-0.0453417934,
0.173397392,
-0.5703603625,
-0.5782491565,
0.1965959817,
-1.1112469435,
-0.875654757,
-0.7516412735,
-0.2613768876,
0.0594570301,
0.3198369443,
0.2053417414,
0.5391567349,
-0.8064198494,
-0.1261601299,
-0.3054249585,
0.2131311744,
-0.3431650996,
-0.1515266001,
0.428139329,
-0.344758749,
-1.0907626152,
0.343975991,
0.111321792,
-0.1987199485,
-0.3716910183,
0.1566846222,
-0.2399359047,
0.0026035039,
0.3875170648,
-0.0272356477,
-0.8346036673,
-0.2699277997,
-0.3887881935,
0.0824406147,
-0.3987239599,
0.4355336726,
-0.7220078707,
0.5790074468,
0.6587487459,
0.4080459774,
0.7786984444,
0.0340739377,
1.1903232336,
-1.0157525539,
0.1587426662,
0.0157784931,
0.4072444737,
0.1777927727,
-0.0206911843,
0.5624160171,
0.311555326,
-0.2897093296,
-0.6417661905,
0.1610690504,
-0.6247255802,
-0.4671557248,
1.1237915754,
-0.7456889153,
-0.1165343225,
-0.117418468,
0.0387543552,
0.7191625237,
-0.4834593534,
0.5168616176,
0.6313756108,
0.3224833012,
-0.2225217223,
-0.7368170619,
0.534591794,
-0.0892063305,
-0.4796552658,
0.1328096241,
0.8448249102,
0.5580801368,
0.0841166377,
0.6307251453,
-0.1232274026,
-0.1709841788,
-0.1061138809,
0.0080966232,
-0.1340350509,
-0.0720349327,
-0.0217518397,
0.3891609311,
0.0038494843,
-0.1320660114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.07009v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.07009v1
|
Joint Extraction of Uyghur Medicine Knowledge with Edge Computing
| 2024-01-13T08:27:24 | 2024-01-13T08:27:24 |
Fan Lu, Quan Qi, Huaibin Qin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Medical knowledge extraction methods based on edge computing deploy deep
learning models on edge devices to achieve localized entity and relation
extraction. This approach avoids transferring substantial sensitive data to
cloud data centers, effectively safeguarding the privacy of healthcare
services. However, existing relation extraction methods mainly employ a
sequential pipeline approach, which classifies relations between determined
entities after entity recognition. This mode faces challenges such as error
propagation between tasks, insufficient consideration of dependencies between
the two subtasks, and the neglect of interrelations between different relations
within a sentence. To address these challenges, a joint extraction model with
parameter sharing in edge computing is proposed, named CoEx-Bert. This model
leverages shared parameterization between two models to jointly extract
entities and relations. Specifically, CoEx-Bert employs two models, each
separately sharing hidden layer parameters, and combines these two loss
functions for joint backpropagation to optimize the model parameters.
Additionally, it effectively resolves the issue of entity overlapping when
extracting knowledge from unstructured Uyghur medical texts by considering
contextual relations. Finally, this model is deployed on edge devices for
real-time extraction and inference of Uyghur medical knowledge. Experimental
results demonstrate that CoEx-Bert outperforms existing state-of-the-art
methods, achieving accuracy, recall, and F1 scores of 90.65\%, 92.45\%, and
91.54\%, respectively, in the Uyghur traditional medical literature dataset.
These improvements represent a 6.45\% increase in accuracy, a 9.45\% increase
in recall, and a 7.95\% increase in F1 score compared to the baseline.
|
[
-0.3504057229,
-0.865165174,
0.7184050083,
-0.0790636092,
-0.3114287853,
-0.1177654564,
-0.1679908335,
-0.8999559283,
0.0378749967,
0.5816110373,
-0.530906558,
-0.553606689,
-0.7544792891,
-0.4539636374,
-0.2100307792,
1.1939535141,
-0.1462455243,
0.3098181784,
-0.425434798,
-0.3075051904,
-0.0687916577,
-0.5068121552,
-0.4072436988,
-0.5409600735,
0.4783646166,
0.0883079842,
0.9105228782,
0.7713970542,
0.5554516315,
0.216143772,
0.1033296362,
0.080664672,
0.0413304307,
0.2957282364,
-0.2143089622,
0.00755218,
-0.313572973,
-0.0908454061,
0.3924948573,
0.8857756853,
-0.043985568,
0.0886772871,
0.0669675171,
0.7195925713,
-0.5522003174,
-0.0728630424,
-0.4521458447,
-0.0019868561,
0.0709757283,
0.1621716768,
0.1667689085,
-0.2297154963,
0.5464874506,
-0.4975396693,
-0.0117067844,
-0.1436043382,
1.2491391897,
0.1065626368,
-0.417460382,
-0.298158586,
-0.503711462,
0.7282170653,
-0.6614022851,
0.7135184407,
0.2268610597,
0.1050353348,
-0.1364091933,
-1.2742317915,
-0.3199478686,
-0.0304545853,
-0.2481801659,
0.1798793525,
-0.2942564189,
0.1234887242,
0.001189427,
0.2887026072,
-0.2290795594,
0.2639222145,
-0.3729267716,
-0.2688876688,
0.6556999087,
0.0558708124,
0.6617655754,
-0.1821192354,
-0.7518138885,
0.1340156943,
-0.712644875,
0.3560535908,
-0.0057001361,
-0.0652383491,
-0.0106759323,
0.1548037082,
-0.2083258033,
0.5663021803,
-0.0529652163,
-0.2812247574,
0.0208845027,
-0.0793316513,
-0.312866509,
-0.1406047791,
1.0754158497,
0.2108491212,
-0.0677862316,
-0.3419361711,
0.0450157486,
-0.3033252656,
0.0796317756,
-0.5868167281,
-0.4655987024,
0.3555164635,
-0.9780463576,
0.1300343871,
-0.118737489,
-0.9484581947,
-0.1900644451,
-0.3426517248,
0.4291060269,
-0.5961805582,
-0.3342907429,
-0.2583366334,
0.0012107829,
0.0849483013,
0.3120634854,
-0.7834388614,
0.8423897624,
0.6156482697,
0.6834179759,
-0.6302730441,
-0.0668176264,
-0.5181369781,
0.0692945421,
0.2600578666,
0.5690718293,
-0.5105149746,
-0.402780354,
-0.0042562839,
-0.0448074341,
-0.2974214852,
-0.4662790298,
0.6704633236,
-0.4113148153,
0.0190463997,
-0.0946268141,
-0.7316421866,
-0.3299598396,
-0.1610414535,
-0.7528642416,
0.9439566731,
0.0330444537,
-0.7988844514,
0.1068751588,
-0.4001213014,
-0.5121546984,
0.2209137678,
-0.6729040742,
-0.5299817324,
-0.043672964,
0.7374907136,
0.6695043445,
-0.4348802269,
0.3817717135,
-0.234085992,
-0.0966442078,
0.1425738931,
-0.2434465438,
1.1083738804,
0.3314869106,
-0.2960148454,
-0.0722175762,
-0.6189460158,
0.2311583757,
-0.044190377,
-0.1730716079,
-0.6559442878,
-0.1540621966,
0.1065758467,
0.3034594059,
0.2648891211,
-0.8010071516,
0.3059386909,
-0.2188194096,
0.1468093842,
0.3832474053,
0.354614526,
0.3220684528,
-0.2232810408,
0.1090906933,
0.0314904675,
0.2413785309,
0.3679954112,
-0.7038366199,
-0.2639378905,
-0.4422916472,
0.5990552902,
0.6258324981,
-0.4156243205,
0.3495377302,
-0.0845869184,
-0.3844281137,
-0.7682498693,
0.3706121743,
0.3726545274,
0.9090921879,
0.3837765157,
-0.1000594869,
-0.4546139538,
-0.74645859,
-0.3774446845,
0.1464954913,
-0.02757168,
0.5722969174,
0.2707526386,
-0.501286149,
0.8084135652,
-0.5985735655,
-0.2453893721,
-0.2608753443,
0.4348500371,
0.266721487,
0.7011064291,
0.2499000281,
-1.0094954967,
-0.2974269688,
0.1383743733,
-0.8584326506,
-0.0821882784,
0.1019700617,
-0.0312845521,
0.364082098,
0.225181967,
-0.4508215785,
0.6917611957,
0.6687138677,
0.0385766774,
0.2950818837,
-0.5507959127,
0.1098926589,
-1.1076281071,
0.0701612756,
0.0844799653,
-0.2173318714,
-0.3339333236,
0.2129256129,
0.0613821857,
0.0377318673,
-0.3361615837,
0.5576394796,
-0.7059726715,
-0.0061628125,
-0.1410978734,
-0.0767747387,
-0.0653136745,
0.4376175106,
0.2741987109,
0.2098920792,
0.587452054,
-0.5977626443,
0.4286392331,
0.0494635515,
0.0050167073,
0.4432013631,
-0.7213152647,
0.1234306991,
0.2721550167,
0.0231306851,
-0.6101611853,
-0.0903035998,
0.0946365818,
-0.5152673125,
0.243294239,
-0.3257766366,
-0.2832859457,
-0.1493310481,
-0.1171564683,
0.1486819834,
0.8292016983,
-0.6090158224,
0.7475332618,
0.5463599563,
-0.5442264676,
-0.6592936516,
-0.4653254449,
-0.2015392184,
0.0972489044,
-0.6576007605,
0.6215079427,
0.1884097308,
-0.397662729,
0.4269612432,
-0.2820629776,
-0.6041309834,
-0.0914320797,
0.6816346645,
0.6018376946,
0.0133859338,
0.355252564,
0.6371948123,
0.001899965,
0.0880751684,
-0.2436858267,
0.2813361585,
0.1537825018,
-0.1644185483,
-0.6322820187,
0.9668557644,
0.2612281144,
-0.0789789483,
0.549998343,
1.0030486584,
-0.7413451076,
0.2237746716,
-0.5655255914,
-0.2712815106,
-0.4014104605,
0.1178146154,
-0.3456989229,
-0.7258918285,
0.6069469452,
-0.5547337532,
-0.0336736292,
0.8375642896,
0.5603172779,
-0.5561996102,
0.8965687752,
0.5513461232,
-0.2268277258,
0.1167577207,
-0.2778127193,
-0.1188129485,
-0.9252229929,
-0.4971309304,
-0.4154472351,
-0.0937595069,
-0.6688945293,
0.3592221439,
0.6338424683,
0.163088426,
0.052354537,
-0.0201358963,
-0.520609796,
-0.1625026911,
0.9193968177,
0.6933652163,
0.3448261917,
0.3383722305,
-0.5675745606,
-0.1506501734,
-0.4171369672,
0.018456025,
1.161665678,
0.1413631141,
0.8295635581,
-0.3189925551,
1.0816013813,
0.3258131742,
-0.1307321191,
-0.5054855943,
0.3078215122,
-0.2393725365,
-0.4349825978,
-0.1494771391,
-0.4332520366,
-1.0169779062,
-0.0101108206,
-0.5064583421,
-1.2657538652,
0.1267973334,
-0.2370382845,
-0.5754611492,
0.5437561274,
-0.5517845154,
0.4456191659,
-0.2812287211,
-0.6062703729,
-0.024130635,
-1.1927269697,
-0.0458993986,
0.2178866565,
0.1013086364,
0.074975796,
-0.0382949337,
0.9809618592,
-0.6113838553,
0.5601018071,
-0.2184885591,
0.1916369796,
0.1846126318,
-0.186850965,
0.3650715053,
0.3286888599,
0.1262112111,
0.4650370479,
0.3617966771,
-0.3571636081,
-0.5618645549,
1.0399699211,
-1.0964677334,
-0.4293641746,
-0.5674311519,
-0.8715798855,
-0.2749441862,
0.2879784107,
0.391641438,
0.5219383836,
0.1330144554,
-0.0091038942,
0.6528652906,
-0.0903316736,
0.6747043729,
0.1737810522,
0.0299783088,
-0.5364741683,
0.662532568,
0.2130331099,
0.0616621114,
0.2954872251,
0.3064220548,
-0.3296001256,
-0.4999264479,
-0.4397303164,
0.1627420932,
-0.4682101905,
-0.182882756,
-1.1872810125,
-0.6979957223,
-0.5983725786,
-0.0057659559,
-0.2505539954,
-0.3725001812,
-0.275934577,
0.2301089913,
0.6145544648,
0.6943823099,
-0.2813639343,
0.3314032257,
-1.2111207247,
0.4823647141,
0.3752248287,
0.1213377863,
-0.2694216967,
-0.0860134587,
-0.0342570655,
0.0184237733,
-0.1271219999,
-0.9484319687,
0.4537834823,
0.0271476805,
0.8365536332,
0.1927779317,
0.0278115924,
0.5806971788,
-0.0763311386,
0.5870404243,
0.3173769116,
-0.8584728837,
0.4631637037,
-0.0411176234,
0.0618630312,
0.6476419568,
0.828830421,
-0.2985490561,
0.1145298928,
-0.7432618737,
-0.8163495064,
0.2712010741,
-0.1245494336,
-0.3055589795,
0.6077821255,
0.5141272545,
0.5048492551,
-0.0208114199,
-0.4165430665,
-0.3175491393,
0.3440630734,
-0.4696394503,
0.6610481143,
-0.1787411571,
-0.2450094372,
-0.7022868991,
0.4513576329,
0.1077344343,
0.37896806,
0.6137728095,
-0.1832332164,
-0.0392493494,
0.2726276517,
-0.0151693448,
0.7838290334,
-0.3651264608,
0.1241120473,
0.0558528639,
-0.8198130727,
-0.2273931652,
0.7830384374,
-0.0642780289,
0.1400280446,
0.3722579181,
0.2200241238,
-0.0506524108,
-0.3557119071,
0.5042077303,
-0.0333199576,
-0.1729212403,
-0.0184544493,
-0.1785424203,
0.1844623834,
0.2527971268,
0.6146008372,
0.0730664656,
0.4968761206,
-0.3488094211,
0.5856997371,
0.2777282596,
-0.6647347212,
-0.0902515054,
0.3610185981,
0.0877689943,
-0.0003563814,
0.8384991884,
0.1594664305,
-0.3009096384,
0.3879210949,
0.7147071362,
0.449804157,
-0.2702259421,
0.0341485776,
0.0595915206,
-0.2407034636,
0.2225084603,
0.5732533932,
-0.2027686387,
-0.3496176302,
-0.1653784066,
-0.4435718954,
-0.3489662707,
0.0115631521,
-0.8845644593,
-0.0620968789,
-0.1972568333,
-0.0127335051,
0.1051081046,
0.5642482638,
-0.6988538504,
0.5748286843,
-0.1152984649,
0.5415881872,
-0.5757898092,
1.1893062592,
0.8210855722,
-0.4808095992,
-0.9439310431,
-0.0366758667,
-0.0455414243,
-1.032695055,
0.5494038463,
-0.1907114834,
0.047817003,
-0.2846741974,
-0.4879623652,
-0.5313260555,
1.1706637144,
0.1079293936,
-0.7631093264,
-0.2589619756,
-0.1268605441,
0.3569875658,
-0.4133820832,
0.2549993992,
0.4133009315,
0.1005088463,
0.2970151305,
-0.8945451975,
0.3235327601,
-0.1155950427,
-0.342261523,
0.3091652095,
-0.1116656438,
1.1302011013,
-0.3272217214,
-0.1279282421,
0.1433008313,
0.4618580937,
0.1420357227,
0.5249320269,
0.437305212,
0.6507428288,
0.730264008,
0.0953196809,
0.9428940415,
-0.323331207,
0.3308443725,
1.0407836437,
-0.2487798482,
0.7749112844,
0.6422027349,
-0.1420136392,
0.785435915,
0.5326612592,
0.3165260851,
0.4946466684,
-0.2324782908,
-0.4002839029,
-0.1502116472,
-0.3429186642,
-0.5964221358,
0.2606503665,
0.4737604558,
-0.7873268723,
-0.2227544487,
-0.0176603775,
0.5343443751,
0.0053789401,
-0.4014080167,
1.0317912102,
0.2654101253,
-0.6171337962,
0.3137638271,
-0.2816482186,
0.4926631451,
-0.6579473019,
-0.4175132215,
-0.0257668663,
0.2009914964,
-0.3823590875,
-0.6548990607,
0.0750385672,
-0.2854673862,
-0.0140494537,
0.1479763985,
1.3183025122,
-0.4049496949,
-0.6591315269,
0.5130668283,
0.8458339572,
0.1002226695,
-0.0839739442,
-0.7917475104,
0.1290953457,
-0.2001024932,
0.1185987443,
0.432872504,
0.1122728586,
-0.0183161404,
0.3772919476,
0.8333069682,
0.5831933022,
-0.1700754911,
-0.2542652786,
1.0918632746,
-0.524854362,
-0.34270823,
-0.9054397941,
0.1541956663,
-0.4316979647,
-0.2264671624,
0.3319500089,
0.2233346403,
0.3674817085,
0.263979286,
0.8688488603,
-0.1367266327,
0.551730454,
-0.5172334313,
0.998442471,
-0.5661689043,
-0.1393810511,
-0.2695631385,
-0.4820530117,
-0.2449294031,
0.1021971926,
-0.1963151246,
-0.1497740895,
0.7488382459,
0.2667009234,
-0.1000121012,
0.1455222517,
0.1760352403,
-0.1497154385,
0.0516809002,
0.8142834306,
0.4572869241,
-0.5468767285,
0.4060001075,
-0.4720216691,
-0.5251787305,
-0.0433818474,
-0.6539536715,
-0.7826917768,
-0.7046787739,
-0.1575548649,
-0.2732847035,
0.5897438526,
1.0957552195,
1.0173912048,
-0.5713233948,
0.0494908579,
0.0878808498,
0.2819284499,
-0.6259630919,
-0.2102574706,
0.8504719734,
-0.1325027943,
-0.4869273901,
0.0177538618,
0.1138452142,
-0.1736219376,
-0.0190516505,
0.0086183371,
-0.6465725899,
-0.2921405733,
0.1144153625,
0.4237790108,
-0.6818462014,
-0.0846291557,
-0.0533813424,
-0.2409613431,
0.1474207938,
0.8191120028,
-1.0066322088,
0.5029572248,
0.4228519499,
0.9759725928,
0.5160796642,
0.0630971417,
0.6334648728,
-0.4209807813,
-0.0712788478,
0.0932921469,
0.4233861268,
0.0756189302,
-0.7257735729,
0.2858792543,
0.4110305607,
-0.7156014442,
-0.3227212429,
0.1200180352,
-1.2276805639,
-0.3963742554,
1.0546230078,
-0.6250733733,
-0.4683825374,
-0.2179851085,
-0.1710981727,
0.632499516,
-0.503434062,
0.5370801091,
0.1919316947,
-0.6184173822,
-0.1601205915,
-0.3606429398,
0.4219228029,
0.3287783861,
-0.9183825254,
-0.5375498533,
0.1047086269,
0.5518962145,
0.0606679134,
0.474758178,
-0.3716690242,
0.284819901,
-0.0575654618,
0.12053141,
-0.1569476128,
-0.2125010788,
-0.0964020193,
0.2480442971,
-0.3551367521,
-0.53737396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.07004v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.07004v1
|
Extending LLMs' Context Window with 100 Samples
| 2024-01-13T07:57:01 | 2024-01-13T07:57:01 |
Yikai Zhang, Junlong Li, Pengfei Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are known to have limited extrapolation ability
beyond their pre-trained context window, constraining their application in
downstream tasks with lengthy inputs. Recent studies have sought to extend
LLMs' context window by modifying rotary position embedding (RoPE), a popular
position encoding method adopted by well-known LLMs such as LLaMA, PaLM, and
GPT-NeoX. However, prior works like Position Interpolation (PI) and YaRN are
resource-intensive and lack comparative experiments to assess their
applicability. In this work, we identify the inherent need for LLMs' attention
entropy (i.e. the information entropy of attention scores) to maintain
stability and introduce a novel extension to RoPE which combines adjusting
RoPE's base frequency and scaling the attention logits to help LLMs efficiently
adapt to a larger context window. We validate the superiority of our method in
both fine-tuning performance and robustness across different context window
sizes on various context-demanding tasks. Notably, our method extends the
context window of LLaMA-2-7B-Chat to 16,384 with only 100 samples and 6
training steps, showcasing extraordinary efficiency. Finally, we also explore
how data compositions and training curricula affect context window extension
for specific downstream tasks, suggesting fine-tuning LLMs with lengthy
conversations as a good starting point. We release our code and SFT data at
https://github.com/GAIR-NLP/Entropy-ABF.
|
[
-0.4521741271,
-0.7823408842,
0.3745701313,
0.4042894244,
-0.4614294171,
-0.0271100663,
-0.5988794565,
-0.538180232,
0.2558410466,
0.2893852592,
-0.419395268,
-0.6558246613,
-0.6353236437,
-0.074117139,
-0.3370124996,
1.0757879019,
0.0142817218,
-0.2367791682,
-0.2547141016,
-0.2110793889,
-0.4893019795,
-0.44165048,
-0.4778999388,
-0.0677171797,
0.4574325681,
0.5565605164,
0.2987778485,
0.5372738242,
0.3824885786,
0.2309152782,
-0.0802322999,
0.1025223881,
-0.6163426638,
0.2540733218,
0.0659351796,
-0.572070837,
-0.5715290308,
-0.0578092337,
0.6951961517,
0.5448719859,
-0.0707357824,
0.3983608484,
0.4298987389,
0.6735439897,
-0.7775092125,
0.2830630541,
-0.8244820833,
-0.1258974522,
-0.2566788793,
-0.4973049164,
-0.40650177,
0.0761173815,
0.3654970527,
-0.3208341002,
-0.0492345579,
-0.0094583202,
0.5702989697,
0.5469810367,
-0.4599314332,
-0.0748143271,
-0.4470342696,
0.8415185809,
-0.6577579379,
0.297362119,
0.5852943659,
0.0433876999,
-0.1752183884,
-0.5473245382,
-0.1396546364,
-0.1754558682,
0.2035763264,
-0.0731463581,
-0.0296262205,
-0.0609008893,
0.3822538555,
-0.0222084317,
-0.369415462,
0.0117191281,
-0.2564568222,
0.0483086631,
0.5651910901,
0.0923743695,
0.0289956331,
0.337726891,
-0.4394299388,
-0.2144676,
-0.5949799418,
0.261569351,
0.1145298705,
0.0310341865,
-0.2213910073,
0.5271825194,
-0.2899607718,
0.9661323428,
0.1197384968,
-0.1173532009,
0.2239962518,
0.1128101349,
-0.196381554,
0.2721853852,
0.5618818402,
0.6689500213,
0.212928921,
0.1060402021,
-0.002155795,
-0.3999324441,
0.2318995893,
-0.480434984,
0.0475341752,
0.2760974765,
0.0954328403,
-0.1022629142,
0.0581680723,
-0.4050701261,
-0.3548000455,
-0.3312605321,
-0.0012909295,
-0.3327910602,
-0.0498820804,
0.1618182659,
-0.0549344644,
0.4638072848,
0.4925324321,
-0.8080415726,
-0.0334556028,
0.8676742315,
0.915081203,
-0.4293659627,
-0.3655435145,
-0.5901889205,
0.3937162459,
-0.2902089953,
0.7055940628,
-0.6188581586,
0.0538915209,
-0.1411663741,
0.1427083313,
-0.0649004132,
-0.3288510442,
0.3164476752,
-0.7050413489,
0.0684686527,
0.0456504896,
-0.456176579,
-0.1766887456,
0.4389467239,
-0.5612756014,
1.0193879604,
0.0617216825,
-0.7999264002,
0.1191281676,
-0.4639808238,
-0.3861054778,
-0.1506064832,
0.0166516341,
-0.1277211607,
0.3711545169,
0.1886975765,
0.4807148576,
-0.3088791966,
0.2691372037,
-0.6119607687,
-0.5042614341,
0.3945744932,
-0.6230384111,
0.5884655714,
-0.0207754727,
-0.2751316726,
0.0356560349,
-0.5211999416,
0.1235348731,
-0.4102888107,
-0.5615071058,
-0.6114705801,
-0.2418050766,
0.0137822079,
0.0154986307,
0.2852658629,
-0.4400744438,
0.2530409694,
-0.3942887187,
0.3695334792,
0.7010048628,
-0.2515847087,
0.5117124915,
-0.2318670005,
0.596143961,
-0.1583571136,
-0.2579474449,
-0.2099200189,
-0.3333708048,
-0.7603906989,
-0.2443829775,
0.3137530684,
0.5213088989,
-0.6227834821,
0.5627323389,
-0.6811422706,
-0.307751596,
-0.2793618739,
0.1533155739,
0.0024989345,
0.2474857271,
0.1932756007,
-0.3954082131,
-0.6620961428,
-0.5016843081,
-0.2448963225,
0.0161790662,
-0.2614506185,
0.2674675584,
0.1899797916,
-0.0883206204,
1.1678800583,
-0.62601614,
-0.3867170811,
-0.0781614557,
-0.1863009781,
0.4710742533,
0.4775291383,
0.3051658571,
-0.4880366325,
-0.6263005137,
-0.1494802684,
-0.6910692453,
-0.0021227777,
-0.1780810654,
-0.3121544719,
0.251907289,
0.7812201381,
-0.5625545382,
0.3452969491,
0.8852992058,
-0.1822140068,
0.2639132738,
-0.1299419403,
-0.203427121,
-1.0425721407,
-0.0583789162,
0.0882423893,
-0.4438034892,
-0.521815598,
-0.0919809267,
0.1655064821,
0.0299995728,
-0.3907524049,
0.5664432645,
-0.5977848768,
0.0038804144,
-0.6109093428,
0.2459544241,
-0.1620365381,
0.6709455848,
0.1292495728,
0.5751062632,
0.5551280379,
-0.5165809393,
0.3224030733,
0.0155421402,
-0.5677785277,
0.3711306155,
-0.6004530191,
0.3221979141,
-0.1146107689,
0.660179913,
-1.0784288645,
-0.3170494437,
0.1441455483,
-0.4702066481,
0.4389652312,
-0.1607637852,
-0.0421444103,
-0.0825527906,
-0.7642769814,
0.4679388106,
0.3177699149,
-0.4870468676,
0.3888755441,
0.527343154,
-0.2319361866,
-0.9280225635,
-0.7200218439,
0.3297957778,
-0.625772953,
-0.5032653809,
0.4469135404,
-0.0337858573,
-0.0957056284,
-0.2040797472,
-0.3791303039,
0.0408299267,
0.0736747161,
0.073268041,
0.0096137319,
-0.1879787892,
0.2103033513,
0.1367317438,
-0.0759120733,
0.0354253054,
-0.4814220965,
0.713658452,
-0.0728696734,
-0.2602416575,
-0.3279765248,
0.1229146495,
0.6876727343,
0.0405990109,
0.7485585213,
0.6863102317,
-0.2334272414,
-0.1694041044,
-0.5599259734,
-0.2484876662,
-0.4844536781,
0.5476118922,
-0.292889744,
-1.252371192,
0.2851165533,
-0.0986207873,
-0.052061189,
0.0384901613,
0.4784985483,
-0.2444651872,
0.6204147935,
0.8329681158,
-0.4734449387,
0.7844847441,
-0.188578546,
0.0599726327,
-1.411698103,
0.1441490501,
-0.141566515,
-0.4838402867,
-0.4174023569,
-0.8496235013,
0.5247465372,
0.3372029066,
-0.1558961421,
0.3974571824,
-0.1498836875,
0.4967468381,
0.4580230713,
0.2447742522,
0.2106662989,
0.3104210794,
0.1529981345,
0.1566161215,
-0.7689471245,
-0.3199326992,
1.0227124691,
0.4404467642,
0.9345798492,
0.0659951791,
0.4108830392,
0.1640907824,
0.461786598,
-0.8809943199,
0.4182444513,
0.0817265585,
-0.4610887468,
-0.6575929523,
-0.062624827,
-0.8747099042,
0.1565148234,
0.3261439204,
-1.0097329617,
-0.0131886723,
0.1227851138,
-0.2156202048,
0.0794992894,
-0.485101223,
0.4551595151,
-0.1344875544,
-0.5056239367,
-0.2656967044,
-0.6993447542,
0.3464889824,
-0.2101298869,
0.0934245586,
-0.3670617938,
-0.3545235991,
0.6458113194,
-0.2996498346,
1.2044261694,
-0.0231929682,
-0.6547047496,
0.4690655768,
-0.1371957213,
0.8086484671,
0.2742297351,
-0.1577179581,
0.2550492883,
-0.2194257677,
-0.2205368578,
-0.6200070381,
0.8572881818,
-0.4178213179,
-0.9119979143,
-0.3307582438,
-0.830254674,
-0.4069595337,
-0.2199855596,
0.1318886727,
0.2520607412,
0.2720142603,
0.7792798281,
0.3938587308,
-0.2596488893,
0.634616971,
0.3963358998,
0.1705324501,
-0.3399258256,
0.7129661441,
0.0304344781,
0.1059458256,
0.5120450258,
0.0991054922,
-0.2907312512,
-0.3539227843,
-0.3624218404,
0.014130136,
-0.7090474367,
-0.3149295747,
-0.5549681187,
-0.0685001761,
-0.3917507231,
-0.1172049642,
-0.1952603757,
-0.5267823339,
-0.2116724998,
-0.0292867422,
0.6948056221,
0.1367295533,
-0.0722462088,
0.3707812428,
-0.871088028,
-0.097468935,
0.1900766045,
0.3152806759,
0.1302679926,
-0.8337858319,
-0.4650061131,
0.0776612312,
-0.179397732,
-0.6036912799,
0.413575232,
0.3986905217,
0.4886688292,
0.2413376272,
0.3176674247,
0.870272994,
-0.5305894017,
0.5869582295,
0.1637051851,
-0.9195219874,
0.3466145694,
-0.414663136,
0.6133949161,
0.3729038537,
0.4121817052,
-0.5400227308,
-0.4767972529,
-0.2607986331,
-1.0747950077,
0.7738213539,
-0.0275442787,
0.4428889155,
0.1178747639,
0.3804266155,
-0.1433757842,
0.0150419697,
-0.5586589575,
-0.0419393256,
0.1748848855,
-0.3927735686,
-0.2844356894,
-0.2416575402,
-0.1861865222,
-0.4447418153,
0.4002076983,
-0.526366055,
0.212871626,
0.103717044,
-0.2390341759,
0.0078737661,
0.1719373465,
0.7330486178,
0.6598311663,
-0.0651689172,
0.2791934907,
0.7485394478,
-0.5113368034,
0.246632725,
-0.1719330549,
0.0474520102,
-0.2224718034,
0.6102913022,
0.9377638102,
0.2300318927,
-0.6891253591,
0.2863671184,
0.0845958665,
0.2323602885,
-0.31697312,
0.271845758,
0.2185218334,
0.4186996818,
0.4284463823,
-0.196335867,
-0.0381027088,
-0.3971239626,
0.3483060598,
0.4832090437,
-0.7582885027,
-0.2392762154,
0.4572329521,
0.1082136035,
-0.2359319627,
0.3296963274,
0.2531394958,
-0.3172900081,
0.5606603622,
0.5045158863,
0.7891391516,
-0.1214906201,
-0.0788088515,
0.3805773854,
0.0828211457,
-0.1039859205,
0.0034875125,
-0.4359318316,
-0.6996105313,
-0.6582140326,
-0.6828051805,
-0.2713418901,
0.0490806736,
-0.6982873082,
0.3921514153,
-0.1192190647,
-0.3644007742,
-0.596876502,
-0.2219573259,
-0.3068772852,
0.016845271,
0.2949765325,
0.9513601065,
-0.3711741567,
1.2160437107,
0.8050969839,
0.3309113085,
-0.4622115195,
0.4057411253,
-0.05688392,
-0.8195205927,
0.443377912,
0.3865866661,
-0.3528085053,
0.1125029549,
-0.7507555485,
-1.2168630362,
1.2927515507,
0.4158841074,
-0.7868202925,
0.0986803025,
0.0810147077,
0.568335712,
-0.4881799817,
0.0637666285,
0.6181189418,
0.1147015318,
-0.0481048338,
-0.8118403554,
0.1644789279,
-0.1416441053,
0.1675922722,
-0.1735083163,
-0.7723152637,
0.3740085959,
-0.2609853745,
0.0965792164,
0.0069146752,
0.7083368301,
0.6063722372,
0.2115470469,
0.6263514161,
0.4142093062,
0.5920882225,
0.0588396192,
0.9889531136,
-0.7134257555,
0.5395538211,
1.4516203403,
-0.2218657434,
0.9830908775,
0.7549149394,
0.0164014734,
0.3586072326,
0.7252707481,
0.3376736343,
0.5665715933,
0.3960072398,
-0.2903766632,
-0.126429677,
-0.1655803174,
-0.3800800443,
0.5015891194,
0.6480573416,
-0.2748669684,
0.0025774806,
0.2863048613,
0.0169046726,
-0.4908974767,
-0.0499367937,
0.6255863905,
0.354316026,
-0.7764095068,
0.9157804251,
0.0532736108,
0.7719552517,
-0.5215148926,
0.1685780734,
-0.2586230338,
0.2894307971,
0.0293665472,
-0.8379263878,
0.1647078246,
0.1357041299,
0.1971624941,
-0.2522036433,
0.5171371698,
-0.5884563327,
-0.2382415235,
0.298455894,
0.2287050784,
0.1344739944,
-0.1920871586,
-0.3649913669,
0.3475252688,
0.0460244492,
-0.6612368822,
0.4083477855,
0.5704746246,
-0.2127790898,
0.7619007826,
0.4384217858,
-0.2025423348,
0.0872253776,
-0.1128105298,
0.953769803,
-0.7529104352,
-0.2078064978,
-1.0263720751,
0.4130353928,
0.0124563631,
-0.456315279,
0.8569054604,
0.3557450473,
0.9153774381,
-0.1642093956,
0.664894104,
-0.0055393325,
-0.0112463711,
-0.6768221855,
0.4996473789,
-0.5105039477,
0.4717193544,
-0.2800327837,
-1.0408403873,
-0.3437048197,
0.600409627,
-0.2833216488,
-0.1397285014,
0.6986689568,
0.6640902162,
-0.0573484488,
-0.1827966273,
0.3156218231,
0.1807948053,
0.196495831,
0.8209424019,
0.9484525919,
-0.3728252351,
0.5266590118,
-0.1783713251,
-0.2248660624,
-0.3426668644,
-0.9188770056,
-0.7316422462,
-0.4284757972,
-0.382800132,
-0.2650025785,
-0.1892088354,
1.0097255707,
0.9238605499,
-0.6699416637,
-0.4100804329,
0.0414399803,
-0.0132315308,
-0.1254148185,
-0.186296761,
0.3632334471,
-0.4281093478,
-0.8571025729,
0.4884181023,
0.4180456102,
-0.0276326723,
-0.1508764774,
-0.175265491,
-0.1583201885,
-0.1219086796,
0.8605159521,
-0.0206350144,
-0.5469465256,
-0.4237287045,
0.0723032504,
-0.0089382278,
0.1047319397,
0.730435431,
-0.6876564026,
0.1633870304,
0.6534559727,
0.6567417383,
0.6715866923,
0.1961402148,
0.8032205701,
-1.0090620518,
0.3156511188,
-0.0678945631,
0.2715486884,
0.2411622554,
-0.3771651089,
0.7261376977,
-0.0229749288,
-0.2300993204,
-0.8528953791,
0.1141741872,
-1.0591715574,
-0.2615478635,
1.4341971874,
-0.2815576196,
-0.3555548787,
-0.0468890369,
-0.3066119552,
0.1998224705,
-0.3394623399,
0.9037847519,
0.8302569389,
-0.2631928325,
-0.2260458469,
-0.5808566213,
0.415898025,
0.4755586684,
-0.7288376689,
0.2712282538,
0.1317842901,
0.3163536191,
0.0044671721,
0.587988019,
0.0576347336,
-0.0060701966,
-0.407330811,
-0.2317880839,
0.1496676505,
-0.4783677161,
-0.5867574811,
0.2684644759,
0.0699575245,
-0.1670704633
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.08688v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.08688v1
|
Automated Answer Validation using Text Similarity
| 2024-01-13T07:13:08 | 2024-01-13T07:13:08 |
Balaji Ganesan, Arjun Ravikumar, Lakshay Piplani, Rini Bhaumik, Dhivya Padmanaban, Shwetha Narasimhamurthy, Chetan Adhikary, Subhash Deshapogu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Automated answer validation can help improve learning outcomes by providing
appropriate feedback to learners, and by making question answering systems and
online learning solutions more widely available. There have been some works in
science question answering which show that information retrieval methods
outperform neural methods, especially in the multiple choice version of this
problem. We implement Siamese neural network models and produce a generalised
solution to this problem. We compare our supervised model with other text
similarity based solutions.
|
[
-0.3137188256,
-0.6024549603,
0.9860687852,
-0.1048730314,
0.0283594951,
0.0870203897,
0.0691217333,
-0.5186628699,
0.3510988951,
0.5400365591,
-0.5056705475,
-0.2187014222,
-0.3454792202,
0.6186929345,
-0.5031573772,
0.9238965511,
-0.296880424,
0.6629559994,
-0.8459346294,
-0.2450903803,
-0.2696353495,
-0.5055034161,
-0.8545588851,
-0.5641899109,
0.4633076787,
0.3238576055,
0.4183259308,
0.6229966879,
1.1867719889,
0.4169275761,
-0.113963224,
0.2467868924,
0.0529051013,
0.0174683556,
-0.2502287626,
-0.874301672,
-0.0216683373,
0.0510921963,
0.31345734,
0.6665313244,
-0.1053133011,
0.2954161763,
0.1390506774,
0.5281743407,
-0.4001510739,
-0.229477033,
-0.5936829448,
0.0968516916,
0.4961037934,
-0.2021844089,
-0.2475715578,
-1.0204080343,
0.1952038258,
-0.7043813467,
0.343357116,
0.0742364675,
0.9325695634,
0.554414928,
-0.3592965007,
-0.5363316536,
-0.6896374822,
0.6478093863,
-0.5203770399,
0.0936550424,
0.5205868483,
0.5037590861,
0.0212807897,
-0.6567565203,
-0.6486931443,
-0.4646000266,
-0.2964513302,
0.3355214,
0.3810371161,
0.2719532251,
0.3573399484,
0.1522265673,
-0.8926585317,
-0.1947965771,
-0.6627267599,
-0.2891295552,
0.5615771413,
0.1381726712,
0.3726962209,
-0.2597694099,
-0.1238081008,
-0.2836205959,
-0.3116743863,
0.302514106,
0.4588636756,
-0.0255359784,
0.5923762918,
0.7525939941,
-0.5155143738,
0.746414721,
-0.0765795112,
0.1441021264,
0.156535387,
-0.4350401163,
-0.097760357,
0.1133840531,
0.4687634706,
0.5141991973,
0.5030934215,
-0.0992177576,
-0.0128054945,
0.0362350792,
0.3233345747,
-0.6891215444,
-0.1390903741,
0.2998587489,
-0.5461128354,
-0.299161762,
0.2559711337,
-0.5454061627,
-0.2294530123,
-0.6360031962,
0.8433187008,
-0.2284962833,
0.0820183381,
0.0950157791,
-0.5435560346,
0.2996117473,
0.6102887392,
-0.5505188704,
0.5465559363,
0.5063376427,
0.9032206535,
-0.3119919896,
-0.2259373963,
-0.4798049033,
-0.2921992242,
-0.4577424228,
0.9261014462,
-0.455199182,
-0.2461897433,
-0.3188461661,
-0.0832283646,
-0.0944751203,
-0.8745758533,
0.1086153686,
-0.8667446971,
0.537440002,
-0.2874749899,
-0.7739130259,
-0.4902973473,
0.4893428385,
-0.785279274,
0.9949418902,
-0.0444535874,
-0.9655779004,
0.2594023645,
-0.8516919017,
0.0387725011,
-0.3788383007,
0.0380445533,
-0.4159202874,
-0.008385851,
0.346983999,
0.2075056881,
-0.1882503629,
0.2090404928,
-0.4376948178,
-0.4942676127,
0.4791292548,
-0.2621712089,
0.9022250772,
0.1556328982,
-0.1508478224,
0.1099116281,
-0.8618194461,
0.5112477541,
-0.1084007844,
-0.3453165591,
-0.5815230608,
-0.3171479702,
-0.2270984054,
0.2997122705,
0.1509711444,
-0.8906882405,
0.1653701216,
-0.3208824396,
0.2835396826,
0.5283047557,
0.4223463237,
0.1295959651,
-0.7351177931,
0.5141952634,
0.2709422708,
-0.0972502753,
-0.0639737844,
-0.605635345,
-0.6871862411,
0.2450581938,
0.8217566609,
0.980068624,
-0.8978719711,
0.100625895,
-0.3340800107,
-0.4311217368,
-0.9245178103,
0.2958696783,
0.277007252,
0.6612357497,
0.5043669939,
-0.3256061077,
-0.5772602558,
-1.1046674252,
-0.2959302068,
-0.3565722108,
-0.4097302854,
0.4058265388,
0.7378728986,
0.0658367723,
1.2451841831,
-0.5626875758,
-0.015852632,
0.2276008427,
0.1431732625,
0.0457421131,
0.3874981105,
0.3546381593,
-1.1193025112,
-0.5217621326,
-0.0036368333,
-0.9797838926,
-0.0152852824,
-0.0750784576,
0.3253888488,
-0.0076032002,
0.4822542369,
-0.2114820331,
0.4530674219,
0.2367137074,
-0.0438825935,
0.5341952443,
-0.4261714518,
0.7660077214,
-1.0979986191,
0.2888057232,
-0.0387441106,
-0.4765016139,
-0.3779191077,
-0.0285689812,
0.1849382371,
-0.0556600839,
-0.4511960149,
0.4751505256,
0.0674712136,
-0.1747568995,
-0.2876285613,
0.2294949442,
0.1662649214,
0.283864826,
0.2219534367,
0.9616199136,
0.2868024111,
-0.6642771363,
0.9625609517,
0.2162251025,
-0.272161752,
0.5942966938,
-0.9987268448,
0.1399102062,
-0.5362573862,
0.2999062836,
-1.2586257458,
-0.444794625,
-0.200547725,
-0.690613389,
-0.1957468539,
0.2424818128,
-0.4254281223,
-0.6145117283,
-0.3403786719,
0.3412384987,
0.3610399067,
-0.7240854502,
0.4126859307,
-0.1445141584,
-0.4076253474,
-0.5835543871,
-0.7489162087,
-0.1165085584,
-0.1946773678,
-0.3309101164,
0.0832883865,
-0.439714849,
-0.503890872,
0.1300538778,
0.173285678,
-0.5328004956,
0.340093255,
-0.0426670201,
0.1878911406,
-0.2683282495,
0.5774124861,
0.0567297116,
-0.1198382378,
0.1562179327,
-0.3216279745,
0.3377824128,
0.0383916497,
-0.5590879321,
-0.7029827833,
0.6476631761,
0.4107617736,
-0.1013565958,
0.6202384233,
0.1369724274,
-0.5153663158,
0.1863970906,
-0.546690464,
-0.605499506,
-0.4856905639,
0.3111362159,
-0.1915045828,
-0.7999836802,
0.5089630485,
0.0735653564,
-0.0342525281,
0.4425456822,
0.2154410183,
-0.340813458,
1.2805637121,
0.5306630135,
0.1357623488,
0.0756009966,
0.0462905988,
-0.108432807,
-0.4661662579,
-0.3677123189,
-0.8972216249,
-0.1566743702,
-0.5184619427,
-0.0028145947,
0.3383561373,
0.0505726337,
-0.2516836226,
0.3282721043,
-0.9043211937,
0.5590616465,
0.8119877577,
0.4079907537,
0.388135314,
0.0067420262,
-0.4577799439,
-0.0242245439,
-0.4486026466,
-0.5666386485,
1.1261523962,
0.236693874,
0.6347011924,
-0.2285523266,
0.8572562337,
0.2029127032,
0.6047126055,
-0.5386185646,
0.5150767565,
0.1464568526,
-0.6742334366,
-0.4502879083,
-0.5664106607,
-0.6179900765,
0.0141709968,
-0.0549440347,
-0.6254898906,
-0.2856595814,
-0.1009087265,
-0.4535942972,
0.2521347404,
-0.6659827828,
0.2529734373,
-0.0443341397,
0.0608343445,
0.1028323695,
-0.6518674493,
-0.1180269271,
-0.2705262899,
-0.0999228433,
0.4151830077,
-0.0154408645,
1.1892701387,
-0.2724973261,
0.5658047199,
-0.0212384593,
-0.0084097199,
0.532531023,
-0.2596224844,
0.0038760104,
-0.0825449377,
-0.4709381461,
-0.2271968275,
0.1953682452,
-0.3763409853,
-1.075338006,
0.7413604856,
-0.8977212906,
-0.6622935534,
-0.3173687458,
-0.3143191338,
-0.2007406354,
0.146998778,
0.4876580536,
0.2229138613,
0.1352586001,
0.3071830571,
0.7827291489,
0.0935534909,
0.4992453158,
0.2455387115,
-0.286090374,
-0.6237748861,
0.5410231948,
0.1433374137,
0.209704414,
0.4653301537,
0.1203062385,
-0.7034175396,
-0.2802969813,
-0.5538904667,
0.0375678875,
-1.1054086685,
-0.3299427032,
-0.7817230225,
-0.5383475423,
-0.4145482183,
-0.1520390809,
0.1318686903,
-0.7076413035,
-0.1846189946,
-0.3498651981,
0.3715646565,
1.1148471832,
0.0431682728,
0.1771846712,
-0.8256449699,
0.2313994914,
0.8268734813,
0.542801857,
-0.1125366837,
-0.3879101872,
0.1256268322,
0.2870595455,
-0.4515243173,
-1.0421984196,
-0.0912594497,
0.2365778834,
0.5168330669,
0.0369459465,
-0.056780953,
0.4594889283,
-0.4087229371,
0.9922699928,
0.0532624424,
-0.7493143082,
0.9502558708,
0.1330543011,
0.1915765107,
0.8880690932,
0.8165192008,
-0.4073600769,
-0.4140675664,
-0.712482512,
-0.3426969051,
0.2598371804,
0.2105101198,
0.0254836567,
0.2125698179,
0.8349073529,
0.0606550053,
0.2341658175,
-0.8109214902,
-0.2698601186,
-0.1879199296,
-0.4440310597,
-0.1461793929,
0.2625110149,
0.084606193,
-0.1435702443,
0.8268267512,
-0.3827861845,
0.1898160279,
0.6694806814,
0.0185084287,
-0.1317719668,
0.2034499049,
0.5574284792,
0.4600609839,
0.0323699489,
0.0458562039,
0.7072701454,
-0.4788563251,
0.6361421943,
-0.0100499755,
-0.3815726936,
0.2379191667,
0.2026388645,
0.2576419115,
-0.2961127758,
-0.6327120066,
0.5015711784,
-0.4277525246,
-0.5024257302,
-0.1522558331,
0.4646545053,
0.0681600198,
-0.1970010102,
0.5109888315,
0.3177898228,
0.4907369018,
-0.2620763481,
0.6472007036,
0.2901040018,
-0.7381523252,
0.1748072505,
0.5379908681,
-0.1913240403,
-0.833611846,
0.6980206966,
0.2240588963,
-0.7418655753,
1.2162903547,
0.5234432817,
0.4621838033,
-0.499974072,
0.3526675105,
0.6558237076,
-0.0090522263,
-0.0460469052,
0.4450519979,
-0.1125132516,
-0.24056454,
-0.3384840488,
-0.4919966757,
-0.7654317617,
0.0590889752,
-0.8787495494,
0.1951835752,
-0.4891735017,
0.0142263249,
0.2124873549,
0.2432572097,
-0.6551951766,
0.8567090631,
-0.2297485322,
1.0173255205,
-0.9597666264,
0.6010248661,
1.1741942167,
-0.5431141257,
-0.8480682969,
-0.0723157376,
-0.3029403389,
-0.4553599954,
0.8914464116,
0.5822585225,
-0.1346330941,
0.0705110207,
-0.8415035605,
-0.9008464217,
0.9567893147,
0.0042099613,
-0.173719272,
-0.0648665056,
0.4227777123,
0.8170964718,
-0.2943843007,
0.953756392,
0.188565135,
0.3717700541,
0.1553705782,
-1.1389400959,
-0.2314477265,
-0.5025339723,
-0.0251844469,
-0.1755720079,
-0.2507961094,
0.4966137111,
-0.2061999142,
0.1839340329,
0.2774560452,
0.6685270071,
0.2211832255,
0.4158683419,
0.5746030807,
0.4322772622,
0.9334445,
-0.0978243873,
0.8216319084,
-0.0405171588,
0.4714900553,
0.8191068172,
-0.3289253116,
0.9497392774,
0.5386898518,
-0.0350386165,
0.7262752056,
0.8609489202,
0.0992924348,
0.4438587129,
0.4742630422,
-0.030852763,
-0.3112633526,
-0.1613100469,
-0.2975432873,
0.5070291162,
0.1323409826,
-0.3099565208,
-0.3729599118,
0.4318938851,
-0.437894702,
0.4475597143,
-0.4478676021,
1.1451448202,
-0.1732337475,
-1.1643865108,
0.3936150968,
-0.1433862895,
0.4456835389,
-0.3865677714,
-0.2601824105,
0.0645234212,
0.209266603,
-0.1082175523,
-0.8739715815,
0.4016905725,
-0.15997006,
-0.2837100923,
0.0778090879,
0.6712674499,
-0.4972325265,
-0.4034824073,
0.2246656269,
0.3288815916,
-0.0262564756,
0.0444689095,
-0.7722224593,
-0.6676324606,
-0.0583009049,
0.0093718451,
0.0651972666,
0.0975668803,
-0.0061215386,
1.0278654099,
0.575845778,
0.0556375347,
0.1067366078,
-0.4285927713,
0.6652106643,
-0.5155751109,
-0.7288777232,
-0.5684126019,
0.1854651868,
-0.4883345068,
-0.1142022461,
0.6101031303,
0.6420735717,
0.9344741106,
-0.1633142531,
0.8840898871,
0.3781359196,
0.9152944088,
-0.5421871543,
0.7502360344,
-0.6768038869,
0.0282626096,
-0.152146399,
-0.9432609081,
-0.6318845749,
0.7079709768,
-0.3421128988,
0.1769643277,
0.796246767,
0.73884058,
-0.0692837611,
0.3969327509,
0.2910905182,
-0.2313668579,
0.1931988448,
0.6063833237,
0.9172444344,
-0.6775520444,
0.5430570245,
-0.3014253974,
-0.157983318,
-0.1751130819,
-0.8039649129,
-0.8939567208,
-0.7937573791,
-0.3927593529,
-0.5944936872,
0.2182136029,
1.0099205971,
0.6520518661,
-1.1747986078,
0.1159108803,
-0.1325745136,
0.0894164816,
-0.0986211076,
-0.2475465983,
0.464912653,
-0.452008158,
-0.5307779908,
-0.2183208019,
0.0254784338,
0.4127376974,
-0.1089270338,
0.2093543559,
-0.1860103607,
0.270998776,
0.0154996403,
0.0916623324,
-0.5173721313,
-0.496170342,
0.3706845641,
-0.4431802034,
0.310218662,
0.7196838856,
-1.0679427385,
0.3572948873,
0.6144435406,
1.0136030912,
-0.0274389684,
0.1484407634,
0.3517918885,
-0.4554003477,
-0.2570283711,
0.4718331993,
0.2470923066,
0.3851560354,
-0.5006693006,
0.1476799548,
-0.0300672669,
-0.7107061148,
-0.3525214195,
0.0506695583,
-0.5678189993,
-0.1897537112,
1.0393160582,
-0.3856026828,
-0.3473104239,
-0.4927955568,
-0.4828162789,
0.0848502517,
0.0552379489,
0.9660089612,
0.9359452128,
0.0261676461,
0.0618985631,
-0.3296020925,
0.4627859294,
0.5605405569,
-1.2029287815,
-0.5430129766,
0.0208702497,
0.5608949661,
0.6005192399,
0.429682374,
0.0861189887,
0.723906517,
-0.1931366175,
-0.2173461914,
0.1243816391,
-0.4901490211,
-0.583016634,
0.3819508553,
-0.0335369781,
-0.1711865515
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06980v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06980v1
|
Joint Unsupervised and Supervised Training for Automatic Speech Recognition via Bilevel Optimization
| 2024-01-13T05:01:47 | 2024-01-13T05:01:47 |
A F M Saif, Xiaodong Cui, Han Shen, Songtao Lu, Brian Kingsbury, Tianyi Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ML
|
In this paper, we present a novel bilevel optimization-based training
approach to training acoustic models for automatic speech recognition (ASR)
tasks that we term {bi-level joint unsupervised and supervised training
(BL-JUST)}. {BL-JUST employs a lower and upper level optimization with an
unsupervised loss and a supervised loss respectively, leveraging recent
advances in penalty-based bilevel optimization to solve this challenging ASR
problem with affordable complexity and rigorous convergence guarantees.} To
evaluate BL-JUST, extensive experiments on the LibriSpeech and TED-LIUM v2
datasets have been conducted. BL-JUST achieves superior performance over the
commonly used pre-training followed by fine-tuning strategy.
|
[
-0.200836271,
-0.4934566617,
0.0430598445,
0.2289426625,
-0.2315666974,
0.1542395204,
-0.3541297317,
-0.3371838629,
-0.2577416003,
0.5013709664,
-0.6938646436,
-0.2477357984,
-0.4275642931,
-0.01394137,
-0.5080991387,
0.9793795943,
0.2741498649,
0.5724586844,
-0.0131369233,
-0.060816016,
-0.0100221522,
-0.4591950774,
-0.7798589468,
-0.3951718509,
0.3162369728,
0.1504625529,
-0.1108201668,
0.5165119767,
0.3812305033,
0.2613127232,
-0.2338626832,
0.0356214531,
-0.3277111053,
-0.0647173002,
-0.1192399263,
-0.0819000229,
-0.1946175545,
-0.1557692438,
0.7779842615,
1.3088355064,
-0.4203367829,
0.189880386,
0.1902962774,
0.6752408147,
-0.7574018836,
0.1874777973,
-0.5575720072,
0.1128100678,
-0.3969744146,
-0.1957793087,
-0.2115291506,
-0.2038843185,
0.1273174584,
-0.7279317379,
0.3039903045,
0.2967698574,
0.5302841067,
0.6366828084,
-0.2847883403,
-0.1758811027,
-1.0281530619,
0.85985744,
-0.4707413912,
0.9605314732,
0.2537406385,
0.2868406177,
0.192584455,
-0.5365930796,
-0.3683283627,
0.0336825065,
0.2069060802,
0.3308743238,
-0.2463591695,
0.3177302182,
0.3166578114,
0.1515558809,
-0.8299812078,
0.2656440437,
-0.6141051054,
-0.4266294539,
0.6590536237,
-0.0604040734,
-0.1948989034,
0.277879864,
-0.4844313264,
-0.2874913216,
-0.4691597521,
0.4535612166,
0.1955799013,
0.7032014728,
-0.2151744366,
0.3695398867,
-0.1101969257,
0.807731688,
0.1831756234,
-0.1284802705,
0.2968017161,
-0.1446585208,
-0.242576465,
0.6080864668,
0.5898079872,
-0.1111884862,
0.3680287302,
-0.3113944232,
-0.5575641394,
0.3439362645,
0.1043189317,
-0.367400825,
-0.4148268104,
-0.0051043564,
-0.1618522108,
-0.2335815877,
0.107730262,
-0.4537395239,
-0.1890672743,
-0.5837116241,
0.4727759063,
0.074604854,
-0.1159767658,
0.1662074327,
-0.111644052,
0.0887191445,
0.2463268936,
-0.7936577201,
0.5476298332,
0.4524425864,
0.4452347755,
-0.0506122597,
-0.2203088552,
-1.0937520266,
0.4645562172,
-0.4544006288,
0.7279419899,
-0.1766550988,
-0.4498415887,
0.0856201351,
-0.1646228582,
-0.2231771201,
-0.4114986062,
0.606531322,
-0.5109882355,
-0.1880118996,
0.0557078123,
-0.3821758926,
-0.1411187053,
-0.0762125999,
-0.400911957,
0.9226539135,
-0.0618826747,
-0.905426383,
0.5510219336,
-0.60767138,
-0.8604955077,
0.1782114059,
-0.1028165668,
-0.7167026401,
0.0737321749,
0.2273361534,
0.2240271866,
-0.3546360135,
0.1241425946,
-0.1633000821,
-0.2941231132,
-0.1069175303,
-0.1934275925,
1.0227658749,
0.1150183156,
-0.4014765918,
0.2002588511,
-1.0673832893,
-0.0060008434,
-0.1504216641,
-0.6401464343,
-0.4252010286,
-0.1737222224,
0.3733891547,
-0.209443137,
0.2472500354,
-0.8545396924,
-0.1066229418,
-0.8518573046,
0.1958240569,
0.5656125546,
-0.1721466482,
0.5958140492,
-0.1213913411,
0.2304488719,
-0.011819982,
0.2133386433,
0.6462643147,
-0.136654377,
-0.6599733829,
-0.3596588075,
0.5020327568,
0.6682411432,
-0.4570654631,
0.5536773205,
0.0182922482,
-0.2658240795,
-0.9119515419,
0.4364833534,
0.8958359361,
0.8045389056,
0.3466553688,
-0.2698628008,
-0.8234378695,
-0.7487384081,
-0.0855509937,
-0.0453944616,
-0.0270319898,
-0.0261464436,
0.0636262894,
-0.2452067286,
0.8074080348,
-0.0178274401,
-0.7006608248,
-0.4454983771,
0.4478397369,
0.2315727025,
0.480889976,
0.162965551,
-0.767472446,
-0.6229080558,
0.0518430918,
-0.445584625,
-0.343382448,
0.1326980591,
0.360581249,
0.5998331904,
0.4123320878,
-0.2390789688,
0.6723275185,
0.3138999939,
0.4710662365,
0.1395106614,
-0.4038401842,
-0.2263243794,
-0.4903793633,
0.0670337006,
-0.0741547644,
-0.2312991023,
-0.7698109746,
-0.4441914558,
0.1610974967,
-0.2747493982,
-0.3250278831,
0.4408503771,
-0.8057888746,
-0.6141225696,
-0.216471374,
-0.0275896695,
-0.1396868825,
0.5708930492,
0.3048766553,
0.4973881245,
1.1999597549,
-0.4422665536,
0.3514246643,
0.3592144847,
-0.2175921798,
0.444039464,
-0.7971284389,
0.3488278091,
-0.1030270457,
0.0309763905,
-0.6916368604,
0.0188745614,
-0.0243788138,
-0.4159498811,
0.8257498145,
-0.2751480937,
-0.4275880456,
-0.4722849131,
-0.1980412155,
0.326220721,
0.4073037207,
-0.7668084502,
0.3374418318,
0.5328663588,
-0.0895403326,
-0.3745917082,
-0.6602383256,
-0.4168803692,
-0.2035787106,
-0.4593567848,
0.1478038728,
-0.1370471865,
-0.0146692107,
-0.4180137515,
-0.2988778353,
-0.0741253123,
-0.2320735455,
0.2354448885,
-0.0148511333,
-0.0388919488,
-0.0576569252,
0.3092059195,
-0.3048352301,
-0.0404641517,
-0.2801042497,
0.4897180796,
-0.1173327267,
-0.2902464867,
-0.696736455,
0.3876131475,
0.0297225378,
-0.4743538499,
0.1300695837,
0.6786008477,
-0.3269400895,
-0.2946377397,
-0.554669559,
-0.20984146,
-0.4931894839,
0.1931034178,
-0.1758838743,
-0.7098708749,
0.2919481695,
0.0390251949,
0.051812429,
-0.0737439841,
0.5876106024,
-0.4502705336,
1.1578766108,
0.512455225,
-0.2625344098,
0.1738625169,
-0.4051977098,
0.16198726,
-0.7853078842,
-0.3610110879,
-0.6575693488,
-0.0045224582,
-0.4852629006,
-0.090659298,
0.6955323219,
0.0793927163,
-0.5001755953,
0.0773285404,
-0.7609932423,
0.0733638257,
0.9618199468,
-0.0320683718,
0.1201839149,
-0.0040802415,
0.1408734769,
0.1483232379,
-0.7948768735,
-0.0394437127,
1.0307737589,
-0.0749739408,
1.0294229984,
-0.1240431592,
0.7762275338,
0.3169404864,
-0.364956826,
-0.5395133495,
0.3364752233,
-0.2267109305,
-0.575941503,
-0.6420019865,
-0.5574995875,
-1.1364715099,
-0.1250095963,
-0.1704126298,
-0.6385453939,
0.1986120045,
0.4554112256,
-0.4031762481,
0.0101125045,
-0.3516614735,
0.6119924188,
-0.4855980277,
-0.0617612526,
0.0892805457,
-1.3030751944,
-0.2323266119,
-0.2092784792,
0.32471174,
0.2999267876,
0.1547855139,
1.0440286398,
-0.2814848721,
0.6576864123,
-0.5390595794,
0.3426480591,
0.0307250489,
-0.3182654381,
0.3866306841,
0.0551654473,
0.1308340132,
0.0350963697,
0.0216294359,
-0.3766621649,
-0.4354064465,
0.40979141,
-0.9742213488,
-0.3056834042,
-0.5543532968,
-0.5849507451,
-0.4682124853,
0.3110762835,
0.460831672,
0.8372264504,
0.1768953949,
0.1130231842,
0.7680710554,
0.0937839672,
0.5139843822,
0.6507995129,
0.0789598674,
-0.346758008,
0.9371165633,
0.0065178871,
-0.0299600121,
0.586632967,
0.3953036666,
-0.6064069271,
-0.9136354923,
-0.4071386755,
0.1260299236,
-0.3733731806,
-0.2734260261,
-0.5130044222,
-0.4807365239,
-0.9219540358,
-0.1895730346,
-0.5382713675,
-0.3379687667,
-0.481842041,
-0.0619511344,
0.2215945721,
0.396863848,
-0.6264674067,
0.3027848899,
-0.5304253101,
0.3436230123,
0.4957276583,
-0.0988001451,
-0.3539838195,
-0.6605282426,
-0.158847332,
0.3387069106,
-0.0571638756,
-0.3984426856,
0.5273066759,
0.6201392412,
0.7448035479,
0.4993033409,
0.3730292022,
0.5380560756,
-0.4118323922,
0.2009729892,
0.4336014092,
-0.7072998881,
0.7570155263,
-0.2354022563,
0.1383005679,
0.82081002,
0.2676101625,
0.1809822172,
-0.1876269132,
-0.3614528775,
-0.6098792553,
0.800768137,
0.1244175285,
-0.2476770878,
0.6332119703,
-0.0903859586,
-0.1090902463,
0.4019950032,
-0.4633257985,
-0.1695490479,
-0.5223213434,
-0.0460128672,
-0.1841077805,
0.152846083,
-0.4010223448,
-0.6512964964,
0.7232194543,
0.1157292947,
-0.0082725929,
-0.0424687788,
-0.3366404474,
-0.3826141357,
0.1444191635,
0.4513889551,
0.2098481506,
-0.4284064472,
-0.0383360349,
0.0823740289,
-0.2646856904,
0.0453935601,
0.5738504529,
-0.1253989041,
-0.192913264,
0.3877449632,
1.015786767,
0.4555987716,
-0.5436756611,
0.7364022732,
0.1017558724,
-0.3390353024,
-0.6269262433,
-0.052240856,
-0.1640253663,
0.5157342553,
0.4856393337,
0.0094270501,
0.6102753878,
-0.4312383235,
0.1818662733,
0.4026372135,
-0.5026822686,
-0.2634227276,
0.7925097942,
0.0799932778,
-0.5523294806,
0.6544523239,
-0.2785800397,
-0.7088486552,
0.3262070715,
0.5153741241,
0.4822032452,
-0.5245338082,
-0.0277192984,
0.074157916,
0.1607076973,
0.1891306639,
0.3519500494,
-0.4593123198,
-0.5859131813,
-0.0708686113,
-0.8438423276,
-0.5085161328,
-0.0961742699,
-1.0833598375,
0.3276792169,
-0.5345986485,
0.2750611305,
0.2246379554,
0.3154525757,
-0.5467664003,
0.4248994291,
0.0959501565,
0.422023803,
-0.7269630432,
1.0032737255,
0.9603363872,
-0.2499184459,
-0.9184339046,
-0.455326736,
0.1609326303,
-0.8013874888,
0.6137098074,
-0.0350981727,
-0.2690570951,
0.2576937377,
-0.3036259711,
-0.5416141152,
0.8414239287,
0.2288442105,
-0.8978769779,
-0.2037962377,
0.099179998,
0.5364630818,
-0.1410275698,
-0.3048510253,
0.5464974046,
0.384434253,
0.4762480855,
-1.1472485065,
-0.6404788494,
-0.320735842,
0.0757635385,
0.216553539,
-0.4325662255,
0.4111022055,
-0.1485902667,
-0.0034822421,
-0.086662516,
0.5315701365,
0.4756576717,
0.8159853816,
0.8824723959,
0.641259253,
0.5939307213,
0.0542512871,
0.6611436009,
-0.033658728,
0.3946617246,
1.0911906958,
-0.5063947439,
0.5857447386,
0.3310174346,
-0.1693712026,
-0.1507383585,
0.6665809155,
0.0144810583,
1.1338356733,
0.2557105422,
-0.1805174798,
-0.3513204753,
0.0880354568,
-0.286121875,
0.6936210394,
0.1626231968,
0.1389884502,
-0.1982797682,
0.5429471135,
-0.1605830044,
0.1019601002,
-0.5433548689,
1.0782346725,
0.1014271006,
-0.1091484651,
0.7483779192,
-0.4568787515,
0.7161802053,
-0.5450896025,
0.3263282776,
-0.0472153686,
0.0631074011,
-0.2455092669,
-0.1779004484,
0.3323079646,
0.0251906291,
-0.2523850501,
-0.2688224316,
0.7258115411,
-0.5972197056,
-0.7410140634,
0.4881193638,
0.0447548442,
0.3416813314,
-0.018618023,
-0.6196258068,
0.0976972505,
-0.0990929008,
-0.1599098444,
0.3727524877,
0.3017477989,
0.0539781004,
0.5539053082,
0.6957165599,
0.4743095338,
0.2852841914,
0.4566734433,
1.0105447769,
-0.1468325108,
-0.6116086245,
-0.0412131958,
0.3837326765,
-0.0795937553,
-0.0860167518,
0.391959399,
0.8579868674,
1.0467196703,
0.0889393017,
0.7535648942,
0.2607771754,
1.346531868,
-0.3273858428,
0.8464007378,
-0.8019099832,
0.2499841452,
-0.5001301169,
-0.771055758,
-0.4347000122,
0.9876641631,
-0.2001050264,
0.1128543243,
0.1653849036,
0.9193804264,
-0.2259151638,
0.069676362,
0.6386794448,
0.1599307805,
-0.0175188296,
0.5002682209,
0.6728129387,
-0.107864961,
0.5161140561,
-0.6354122162,
-0.3406904042,
-0.1164242029,
-0.4084508717,
-1.103194356,
-0.8442226052,
-0.4421419501,
0.2129167467,
0.4712288976,
0.6447210908,
0.8887853026,
-0.8533281088,
-0.4279560149,
-0.196945861,
-0.3446215987,
-0.1163263246,
-0.1465254277,
0.5396206975,
-0.2271434963,
-0.5633810163,
0.6716897488,
0.3227035105,
-0.0854142308,
-0.1498194486,
-0.2175923139,
-0.2116784602,
-0.142147705,
0.3009981513,
0.5432590246,
-0.3920572102,
-0.2021853775,
-0.2303812951,
0.1542121917,
-0.0263840836,
0.6006883383,
-0.599393189,
0.4972991049,
0.2154904753,
0.5936390758,
0.9976729751,
-0.0296366364,
0.3680177629,
-0.8876078129,
0.4437939823,
0.5618249774,
0.2496216744,
0.5114526153,
-0.0807153061,
0.4247876108,
0.1831396669,
-0.6998351812,
-1.2022254467,
-0.0410765111,
-1.5477445126,
0.1597796679,
0.9635605216,
-0.1442062855,
0.0241059661,
-0.3440419137,
-0.0156860314,
0.7080504894,
-0.4099482596,
0.6541922092,
-0.1424885988,
-0.300704211,
-0.5312066078,
-0.0970334187,
0.5490669012,
0.2714363933,
-0.6068351269,
-0.0680879205,
0.2768779099,
0.1113045663,
-0.0630757362,
0.5096434951,
0.1082964316,
0.4470507205,
-0.2219580114,
0.193429783,
-0.3101215959,
-0.5669400692,
-0.3732968271,
-0.1403061002,
-0.0014201504,
-0.3764216006
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06961v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06961v2
|
CHAMP: A Competition-level Dataset for Fine-Grained Analyses of LLMs' Mathematical Reasoning Capabilities
| 2024-01-13T03:18:16 | 2024-06-09T01:47:26 |
Yujun Mao, Yoon Kim, Yilun Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Recent large language models (LLMs) have shown indications of mathematical
reasoning ability on challenging competition-level problems, especially with
self-generated verbalizations of intermediate reasoning steps (i.e.,
chain-of-thought prompting). However, current evaluations mainly focus on the
end-to-end final answer correctness, and it is unclear whether LLMs can make
use of helpful side information such as problem-specific hints. In this paper,
we propose a challenging benchmark dataset for enabling such analyses. The
Concept and Hint-Annotated Math Problems (CHAMP) consists of high school math
competition problems, annotated with concepts, or general math facts, and
hints, or problem-specific tricks. These annotations allow us to explore the
effects of additional information, such as relevant hints, misleading concepts,
or related problems. This benchmark is difficult, with the best model only
scoring 58.1% in standard settings. With concepts and hints, performance
sometimes improves, indicating that some models can make use of such side
information. Furthermore, we annotate model-generated solutions for their
correctness. Using this corpus, we find that models often arrive at the correct
final answer through wrong reasoning steps. In addition, we test whether models
are able to verify these solutions, and find that most models struggle.
|
[
-0.4718467891,
-0.8955892324,
0.5801455379,
0.0787044913,
-0.2485392392,
-0.0090672774,
-0.2576059401,
-0.1831315458,
-0.1760790646,
0.4423364103,
-0.7959284186,
-0.6315356493,
-0.6189914346,
0.2637700438,
-0.2524804473,
1.0197520256,
-0.0948165059,
0.0120998351,
-0.6396615505,
0.0785777047,
-0.6910213232,
-0.6347275972,
-0.5101769567,
-0.2087200433,
0.4927902818,
0.5348216891,
0.6505599618,
0.5733118057,
0.8635037541,
0.2392483801,
-0.2236125916,
0.3548275232,
-0.4536944926,
0.2408500314,
-0.5154619813,
-0.5915064216,
-0.6964258552,
0.05714757,
0.2870300114,
0.7932474017,
-0.1314210445,
0.4662263393,
-0.0494586751,
0.6467963457,
-0.57885921,
0.3499031067,
-0.9349280596,
0.0000026896,
-0.3958257735,
-0.3283640742,
-0.2681977749,
-0.3194237947,
-0.0097776493,
-0.7291773558,
0.2724042535,
0.0016612305,
0.9121536613,
0.5112292171,
0.0429660343,
-0.6368909478,
-0.430631876,
0.7250309587,
-0.5226277709,
0.0096984217,
0.393897742,
0.7136484385,
-0.2553553581,
-0.356425494,
-0.2763944268,
0.0033443661,
0.1789888144,
0.254568845,
-0.3293195665,
-0.1900229007,
0.5034524798,
-0.0318515971,
-0.3019403219,
0.1637085229,
-0.4585336149,
-0.1043296456,
0.9139661193,
0.4549631476,
0.0125146257,
-0.4007698596,
-0.136416316,
-0.1373047382,
-0.9117234945,
0.2134379745,
0.3880023062,
0.4905738831,
0.1388351023,
0.7559915781,
-0.2781004906,
0.8679550886,
-0.1429717243,
-0.1607933939,
-0.0745595619,
-0.1735436171,
-0.0172979105,
0.0511303209,
0.5296289921,
0.4394353628,
0.634667933,
0.0323773995,
-0.508512795,
0.0696407333,
-0.1241337359,
-0.683891058,
-0.3437387049,
0.1555382162,
0.0324545614,
-0.1775567234,
-0.3196335435,
-0.5873042941,
-0.3036249876,
-0.4575368166,
0.5916755199,
-0.2312495559,
0.1980871707,
0.4292794466,
-0.0353390276,
-0.0206723586,
0.5276250839,
-0.5345010757,
0.2814530432,
0.9065161943,
0.7128247023,
0.0089413794,
0.0330834016,
-0.8157705069,
-0.0112045351,
-0.339623332,
1.0405219793,
-0.7921234369,
-0.4980668426,
-0.1330330968,
-0.3588117957,
-0.1872196645,
-0.8876383305,
0.8869384527,
-0.4095728099,
-0.0770283639,
-0.5712743402,
-0.9459748864,
0.146875605,
0.4658997357,
-0.5493301749,
1.0272979736,
-0.196173653,
-0.877638936,
-0.0869867504,
-0.4189691544,
-0.1849878579,
0.0662165731,
-0.40260607,
-0.3299531937,
0.4041025341,
0.3931419253,
0.5644131303,
-0.5176041722,
0.3231568933,
-0.3610395789,
-0.1905804425,
0.4282171428,
-0.2638456225,
0.4677703679,
0.1221396849,
-0.103400372,
-0.1460126936,
-0.771004796,
-0.0176383797,
0.4061106741,
0.1740930825,
-0.4316916168,
-0.1275379062,
-0.736751616,
0.349689424,
0.3446065187,
-0.307723999,
0.238468647,
0.193644017,
0.1750217378,
0.8859680295,
-0.0341110565,
-0.3573431373,
-0.5738608837,
0.6818404794,
-0.0025405933,
0.1299313456,
0.0079687247,
-0.7728939056,
-0.7475070953,
-0.0035141984,
0.7225565314,
0.5328227878,
-0.7595172524,
0.18312186,
-0.3226912618,
-0.4527237713,
-0.5597839355,
0.0979249105,
0.6079846025,
0.7300760746,
0.2932089269,
0.0165094212,
-0.2031327039,
-1.0120253563,
-0.4001961946,
0.0693399683,
0.1095723063,
0.5952649117,
0.7505882978,
0.4163202941,
0.8926720619,
-0.7260861993,
-0.3934967816,
-0.1588052511,
0.2235496789,
0.1786930859,
0.2383232713,
0.0871378407,
-0.5162674189,
-0.1702252775,
-0.1606442928,
-0.6647552848,
-0.496433109,
0.1727402061,
-0.2126831412,
-0.3709750473,
0.4905939996,
-0.2712526321,
0.3056972027,
0.3725636303,
-0.2472239435,
0.8854643703,
-0.2156788707,
-0.1057481617,
-0.6684575081,
-0.0524912626,
0.3017581403,
0.046973858,
-0.2680290043,
-0.0663972944,
-0.1749522835,
0.1068506539,
-0.0103458129,
0.7051263452,
-0.202332288,
-0.1814856827,
-0.089726828,
0.702760756,
-0.0702806413,
0.4190687239,
0.2288438976,
0.7866455913,
0.2856897414,
-0.5137732029,
0.3865746856,
0.0619741715,
-0.3657693565,
0.8982692361,
-0.8038311005,
0.1273207515,
-0.0777531043,
0.0036357862,
-0.7734900713,
-0.2737027109,
-0.2524076402,
-0.5741919875,
0.0154503342,
-0.1539391577,
-0.6921156645,
-0.3841101825,
-0.1057996452,
0.5300515294,
0.4124213457,
-0.388638109,
0.107421957,
0.2791489661,
-0.3491786122,
-0.4605825841,
-0.2210614979,
-0.1107294783,
-0.2945462465,
-0.6125386357,
0.2364377379,
-0.2253694981,
-0.3881802559,
0.1313574165,
-0.1572973728,
-0.0649603978,
0.1249007359,
0.0218430012,
0.2882448435,
-0.0140731102,
0.3207125366,
-0.0747923106,
-0.2887404263,
0.3504227996,
0.030055996,
0.2841889262,
-0.0845880359,
-0.4590446651,
-0.2264710814,
0.0491323471,
0.1474664956,
-0.3403948843,
0.1855262369,
0.1905087829,
-0.5852690935,
-0.4454630017,
-0.4489555955,
-0.1418369412,
-0.4326510131,
0.2147886008,
-0.8726423979,
-0.7084143758,
0.7611416578,
-0.0818195045,
0.0049832822,
0.5916656852,
0.4048841596,
0.0547019541,
1.1228654385,
0.0516184792,
0.205499649,
-0.0431154259,
-0.4051885903,
-0.0646205172,
-1.048076272,
-0.4354766607,
-0.6230034828,
-0.3396094441,
-0.2280153483,
-0.6534819007,
0.5057296157,
0.3957192004,
-0.1350202113,
0.2917533517,
-0.5084257722,
0.6285424232,
0.5238825083,
0.1441556662,
0.6758083701,
-0.2532814145,
-0.5666319728,
-0.3720569611,
-0.6732832789,
-0.3809177577,
1.2060250044,
0.1855252087,
0.7560194731,
0.0759851038,
0.7046527863,
0.1293209344,
0.314846009,
-0.6619472504,
0.5772439837,
-0.0743070841,
-0.861752212,
-0.057631135,
-0.7022484541,
-0.6934898496,
-0.0748931393,
0.0152723771,
-0.9015594125,
-0.1701048017,
-0.0477033518,
-0.5925001502,
0.2708972692,
-0.3841708004,
0.8267071843,
-0.162273705,
-0.6426510811,
0.125926733,
-0.2992551625,
0.6052309275,
-0.1747415364,
0.4549431503,
-0.3456572294,
0.1142564267,
0.829374671,
-0.5676198602,
0.6121616364,
-0.0431264564,
-0.4092136323,
0.6148887277,
0.3444517553,
0.6094157696,
0.1167496294,
0.0634382591,
-0.3845202029,
0.0550028905,
-0.3364548385,
-0.9344835877,
0.5737131238,
-0.5085440278,
-0.8551798463,
-0.229681924,
-0.637350738,
-0.5569147468,
-0.1705632657,
0.2362897694,
0.741119504,
0.3447998166,
-0.0255101044,
0.7696516514,
0.1235091165,
0.0175760128,
0.3370504379,
-0.2975440919,
-0.3163615763,
1.0756616592,
0.3676195443,
0.2948715091,
0.1961917728,
0.3870715201,
-0.5571500063,
-0.6964524388,
-0.46661219,
0.3094025552,
-0.9038313627,
-0.4638037384,
-0.1720209271,
-0.4079265893,
0.1646990776,
-0.0327518396,
-0.4873615503,
-0.6469667554,
0.0081842523,
-0.0427939706,
0.3041433692,
0.8145089149,
-0.1044625938,
-0.0115834391,
-0.5549456477,
0.0639361516,
0.5353384614,
0.3078670204,
0.0757072493,
-0.6558036208,
-0.1310477406,
-0.0527867414,
-0.2785651088,
-0.6761119366,
-0.0050919475,
-0.1247092858,
0.3767689764,
0.2611049414,
0.2568598092,
0.7243497372,
-0.3255761564,
0.6230158806,
0.0334892385,
-0.8166145682,
0.6443674564,
-0.4140292108,
0.1315668374,
0.4156062305,
0.2590045035,
-0.1661544889,
-0.257312417,
-0.8084667921,
-0.1975349486,
0.3267402947,
0.4689113796,
-0.238991797,
-0.0165359881,
0.6099029779,
0.0010320503,
0.0506523401,
-0.335716933,
-0.1563993543,
0.3111966848,
-0.3259634376,
0.1802027225,
0.029605275,
-0.3379071057,
-0.3427162468,
0.5757037401,
-0.244571209,
-0.0677829385,
0.2143171877,
0.046012409,
0.0041532237,
0.265445888,
0.5389588475,
0.6687821746,
-0.3352216482,
0.2270921618,
0.2504015267,
-0.1563212574,
-0.0707783028,
0.4014460444,
-0.0361064225,
-0.0359220654,
0.4885333776,
0.4613966644,
0.2618967295,
-0.9815013409,
0.5303035975,
-0.000838799,
-0.2432198226,
0.019343039,
0.2104989886,
0.0997238606,
0.2719214857,
0.3298473656,
-0.2822729647,
0.1799519211,
-0.3138564527,
0.0937091932,
0.5895203948,
-0.3917866945,
-0.4999043643,
0.6078867316,
0.063514173,
-0.1619126052,
0.1244679838,
-0.6100354195,
-0.7685748935,
0.6983368993,
0.4974246025,
0.5732559562,
0.0435379967,
0.1419969797,
0.4994160831,
-0.0250878781,
0.0103073753,
0.3443627059,
-0.1135090739,
-0.5245475769,
-0.3905868828,
-0.5533364415,
-0.5826784968,
0.1559881121,
-0.7509613633,
0.3890127838,
-0.3977150619,
-0.3531545997,
0.2159897834,
0.4014953673,
-0.9089133143,
0.2868719101,
0.1204071939,
0.9436677098,
-0.4847189486,
0.5484402776,
0.5661103129,
-0.2277578115,
-0.8428935409,
-0.4087421,
0.1066467986,
-0.8669409752,
0.80064255,
-0.0195420347,
-0.2532324195,
-0.1188802049,
-0.5615664721,
-0.6641364098,
0.8958064914,
0.2088941187,
-0.7317108512,
-0.2652285993,
0.0719487444,
0.3549584448,
-0.4666334689,
0.3468874991,
0.7731447816,
0.3580868244,
0.6326557994,
-1.0251996517,
-0.045179829,
-0.3599754274,
-0.181173861,
-0.0553878359,
-0.6540721059,
0.9535534978,
-0.5035543442,
-0.0511130095,
0.1152266115,
0.4859085679,
0.7131070495,
0.555562377,
0.2923502028,
0.8769888878,
0.8810215592,
-0.2563444972,
0.8091960549,
-0.157072559,
0.5306955576,
1.4137667418,
-0.1536405832,
0.9112630486,
0.0254391637,
-0.2258480787,
0.5140585899,
0.6992125511,
0.1110690385,
0.2848660648,
0.7860066891,
-0.0309094395,
-0.7575045228,
-0.3578302264,
-0.5432555079,
0.4024637341,
0.6957921386,
0.022363428,
-0.4958294332,
-0.4517577589,
0.2402902395,
0.3286167085,
-0.4519595802,
0.4434165359,
0.171250999,
-0.6239206195,
0.5323714018,
-0.1866048127,
0.3508763909,
-0.283582747,
0.0160576683,
-0.364890635,
0.26464504,
-0.0677204728,
-0.9697129726,
-0.0589141324,
0.3971756101,
0.1183476374,
0.4790786207,
0.4131737947,
-0.3309184015,
-0.7422883511,
0.0083692884,
0.8399617672,
0.1541964859,
-0.0239367355,
-0.738718152,
0.2119680643,
-0.3177852035,
0.0519988053,
0.0690483078,
0.9321044683,
-0.1422123462,
0.8305814862,
0.3458868861,
0.1639525741,
0.1871288568,
0.1963246316,
0.9392985702,
-0.7269490957,
-0.2199994177,
-0.7876543999,
0.2100148648,
-0.2958295643,
-0.5512354374,
0.9199285507,
0.7042911649,
0.8684399724,
0.3204912543,
0.7211997509,
0.4100504518,
0.5305376649,
-0.7401800156,
0.0945812538,
-0.6193606257,
0.4527538717,
-0.4704467654,
-0.7252796888,
-0.3723154068,
0.4153490067,
-0.6895500422,
0.1741047949,
0.4883358479,
0.4522003233,
-0.0974920094,
0.2265739441,
0.2455757409,
0.0046094721,
0.3897690475,
1.1193497181,
1.0920109749,
-0.2802535295,
0.5387941003,
-0.2946392,
-0.130447045,
-0.2962225676,
-0.830326438,
-1.2648786306,
-0.4301311076,
-0.4825811088,
-0.3511393368,
0.1858078837,
0.8829120994,
0.4574627876,
-0.7060481906,
-0.17196922,
-0.0448864587,
0.2816693783,
-0.0486556217,
-0.1768101007,
0.7165557742,
-0.6475522518,
-0.7047314644,
0.0741578862,
0.0686251968,
0.1039395258,
-0.3232163787,
0.0997487158,
0.2316464186,
0.3290127516,
0.3471954167,
0.0424265563,
-0.6385945082,
-0.2968052626,
0.1958975345,
0.03124745,
-0.0779367238,
0.8036900163,
-0.7082976103,
0.6938042045,
0.149429068,
0.6124088168,
0.2797381282,
0.261783272,
0.3016705215,
-0.6449671984,
-0.2324518412,
0.2261126339,
0.389826566,
0.3821635842,
-0.0370251499,
0.5562487841,
0.4384960532,
-0.3464235067,
-0.9210022092,
0.1292978525,
-0.6375522017,
-0.2906704247,
1.1183041334,
-0.1304669082,
-0.3913799822,
0.2052392066,
-0.1010304689,
-0.055000592,
-0.2429243922,
0.8395476937,
1.1243602037,
-0.3321682513,
0.0265821628,
-0.8566966653,
0.7560325861,
0.4302563071,
-0.8400967717,
0.2903026938,
0.2926525176,
0.0812502801,
0.2590594292,
0.2365428954,
-0.1519298553,
0.2274183035,
0.0498997942,
-0.5911250114,
-0.2299227715,
-0.6742896438,
-0.0904618204,
0.1567022204,
0.1186168864,
-0.0651329085
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06954v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06954v2
|
Bridging the Preference Gap between Retrievers and LLMs
| 2024-01-13T02:20:17 | 2024-02-20T21:11:23 |
Zixuan Ke, Weize Kong, Cheng Li, Mingyang Zhang, Qiaozhu Mei, Michael Bendersky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated superior results across a wide
range of tasks, and Retrieval-augmented Generation (RAG) is an effective way to
enhance the performance by locating relevant information and placing it into
the context window of the LLM. However, the relationship between retrievers and
LLMs in a RAG is still under-investigated. Most existing work treats the
retriever and the LLM as independent components and leaves a gap between
retrieving human-"friendly" information and assembling a LLM-"friendly"
context. In this work, we examine a novel bridge mechanism. We validate the
ranking and selection assumptions of retrievers in the context of RAG and
propose a framework that chains together supervised and reinforcement learning
to train a bridge model that optimizes the connection between the retriever and
the LLM. Empirical results demonstrate the effectiveness of our method in both
question-answering and personalized generation tasks.
|
[
-0.6207051873,
-0.658480227,
0.594368875,
0.04768252,
-0.0162613243,
0.0531895123,
-0.0907743275,
-0.3918018043,
0.2048698664,
0.4891009629,
-0.4400030375,
0.0230668597,
-0.4047189057,
0.1140322909,
-0.0369584709,
1.0484187603,
0.0926883444,
-0.1571676731,
-0.5149392486,
0.0120464442,
-0.4907591343,
-0.4359377027,
-0.9284222126,
-0.7232541442,
0.8861795068,
0.1903616041,
0.6385240555,
0.5988314152,
0.3212886453,
0.3319876194,
-0.1687863916,
0.3328573406,
-0.5364487767,
0.6245158911,
-0.5270109773,
-0.7252281904,
-0.2892727256,
-0.0532648675,
0.4936959147,
0.6890752912,
-0.1632974893,
0.111999467,
0.116527535,
1.0458904505,
-0.6590049863,
-0.071017161,
-0.9393849969,
-0.0964764729,
-0.5602280498,
-0.5278173685,
-0.5499036908,
-0.3306161165,
0.2001055181,
-0.4706443548,
0.4203127623,
0.3380311131,
1.2590771914,
0.1523890048,
-0.6433557272,
-0.1437212229,
-0.4675749242,
0.6028431058,
-0.2276075184,
0.4241198599,
0.4299435616,
0.3503970802,
-0.29378286,
-0.2879420817,
-0.4516738057,
-0.3476801217,
-0.2153781503,
0.0979383513,
0.1478339434,
0.0668556243,
0.1746483743,
0.5037866235,
-0.5034015179,
0.1510362029,
-0.298320502,
0.1715048254,
0.5999245048,
0.1427581161,
0.205291599,
-0.5806359053,
-0.6388474107,
0.0415603966,
-0.8531351089,
0.3182363212,
0.4651344717,
0.4809483588,
0.0722165853,
0.626453042,
-0.205344215,
0.851991713,
0.5818802714,
0.1192793697,
0.3719064593,
0.1283441335,
0.0365038067,
-0.0645314381,
0.6030586958,
0.2970641255,
0.0771541595,
-0.4020813406,
-0.5192472935,
-0.0923754722,
0.4088922143,
-0.5337272286,
0.106026724,
-0.0496541299,
-0.2656891346,
-0.3353301585,
0.0678774491,
-0.3558060229,
-0.3949511051,
-0.2672898173,
0.4115958512,
0.0202252753,
-0.4112455249,
-0.0412016474,
-0.0612831302,
0.340380758,
0.0730878934,
-1.2044894695,
0.3754063249,
0.582115531,
0.5733150244,
-0.5585421324,
-0.0190359708,
-0.9672448039,
0.5059579015,
-0.2248227745,
1.0212444067,
-0.5842677951,
-0.5080667138,
0.0074392133,
0.0129567487,
-0.0692586899,
-0.8427687287,
0.3792121708,
-1.1453771591,
0.2856068611,
-0.3666043282,
-0.5480697155,
0.1406474411,
0.4817981124,
-0.9951689839,
1.0256806612,
0.2357087284,
-0.9388673902,
0.2598807812,
-0.5601052046,
-0.3853223324,
0.0402826369,
-0.3274942935,
-0.4856702685,
0.0358646885,
0.1628399789,
0.3638373613,
-0.2513873279,
0.3637139201,
-0.4497238398,
-0.3247862756,
0.478108108,
-0.0224327594,
0.5385907888,
0.2241405845,
-0.0662611872,
-0.0399202444,
-0.386525631,
-0.32863006,
0.2995802164,
-1.0861642361,
-0.5884542465,
-0.0666695461,
-0.2255100906,
0.2906579971,
0.3331551254,
-0.5930209756,
0.1509254426,
-0.7895453572,
-0.1474263817,
1.0718170404,
0.0305814017,
0.7857478857,
-0.6567246914,
0.4988213778,
0.1699831933,
-0.3012310565,
-0.0798078701,
0.1789709926,
-0.8326180577,
0.2641192675,
0.4963957071,
0.4509118199,
-0.878480792,
0.0524669513,
-0.1630226523,
0.0627826303,
-0.5229836106,
0.2273436785,
0.5343766809,
0.5822831988,
0.2088439316,
-0.3380760849,
-0.4795078635,
-0.8301542401,
-0.3543625772,
-0.1387894899,
-0.1087853462,
0.8491355777,
-0.000288799,
0.0044901087,
1.1438930035,
-0.4582106471,
-0.0980611965,
-0.4368029237,
-0.1030224562,
0.3341338933,
0.3534893095,
0.2823240757,
-1.1263141632,
-0.5409967899,
-0.057521347,
-0.5928828716,
-0.1376217753,
-0.0362142026,
-0.3712512553,
0.2546060681,
0.4805158079,
-0.4613540173,
0.2054115534,
0.4284873903,
-0.0912529007,
0.4063451886,
-0.0927489847,
0.1042118073,
-1.2309906483,
0.0339789167,
0.0909001976,
-0.2255937159,
-0.4943767488,
0.0028926642,
-0.0809139237,
0.1109341383,
-0.2922696471,
0.9910418987,
-0.6741293669,
-0.1928441226,
-0.3465625346,
0.3922803402,
-0.0403952487,
0.4481932819,
0.1374550164,
0.6733192801,
0.2690600157,
-0.7753044963,
0.1344354898,
0.4067870677,
0.0924426243,
0.7137563229,
-0.7044973969,
0.1821000129,
-0.3269425631,
0.1794862449,
-0.9156759381,
-0.341983974,
-0.0699492991,
-0.5836278796,
0.5580960512,
-0.1148919091,
-0.1713777333,
-0.1928357482,
-0.3749524057,
0.4182244539,
0.3156450391,
-0.7925277352,
0.5942230821,
0.57234025,
-0.3552266955,
-0.5708658099,
-0.4000680745,
-0.1318997741,
-0.3281515837,
-0.769636333,
0.5255302787,
-0.0245736465,
-0.2414471805,
-0.0602162555,
-0.2247152478,
0.1174827889,
0.1622258872,
0.331150353,
0.390321821,
-0.0541357584,
0.3533925116,
0.0883908793,
-0.2967498004,
0.0755522922,
0.2295492142,
0.4935400188,
-0.1016858369,
-0.3374023736,
0.3512265086,
0.3298006654,
-0.011628204,
-0.4843267202,
0.633435905,
0.3019702137,
0.111962311,
-0.3670533001,
-0.7561706901,
-0.420794338,
-0.5552968979,
0.0650905222,
-0.7155947685,
-1.3264263868,
0.0761413798,
-0.3719595671,
0.1178844348,
0.121923916,
0.2329424322,
-0.2022278309,
1.0795755386,
0.773573041,
-0.0892297029,
0.508625865,
0.0425894894,
0.1507744491,
-1.2614628077,
-0.2451433837,
-0.4863386154,
-0.3763620257,
-0.7603375912,
-0.1307406127,
0.5063686371,
0.3096445203,
-0.3142651916,
0.066662766,
-0.2915626466,
0.3931156695,
0.7888889313,
0.2841546535,
0.2911670208,
0.1112247705,
-0.5405220389,
-0.0760846958,
-0.7605951428,
-0.390996635,
0.9338986874,
0.0908241048,
0.7714371085,
0.3455739915,
1.0567883253,
0.2191578746,
0.2831737399,
-0.5051286221,
0.6501141787,
-0.0146497227,
-0.8086836934,
-0.2299284786,
-0.5078434944,
-1.5059518814,
0.2796201706,
-0.3642909825,
-0.6077389717,
-0.016339805,
0.3439572155,
-0.1440905184,
0.2161714137,
-0.370664984,
0.584238112,
-0.2086687386,
-0.7932800651,
-0.089655973,
-0.8924078345,
0.544418931,
0.1437706053,
0.0289751068,
-0.0482491702,
-0.0065587489,
0.3968087733,
-0.0252791401,
0.4186484516,
-0.1219275817,
0.1947684735,
-0.022097908,
0.3692037761,
0.6353628039,
-0.1114654914,
-0.1946582645,
-0.4950977862,
-0.6028295755,
-0.340356499,
-0.5839244127,
0.6929533482,
-0.5612617731,
-1.0815086365,
-0.5016102791,
-0.5433380008,
-0.5581929684,
-0.0757625476,
-0.0358952545,
0.1691336334,
-0.0564448759,
0.1312055439,
1.0376056433,
-0.3223206103,
0.3545189202,
0.6864823699,
-0.3474868238,
-0.0448319614,
0.9273564816,
-0.2992040813,
0.3269256651,
0.6784699559,
0.2176864147,
-0.4038410783,
-0.3000265956,
-0.3429228663,
0.4808573723,
-0.336514771,
-0.0265639983,
-0.648284018,
-0.3794361055,
-0.0662940592,
-0.2223180681,
-0.0438631736,
-0.0653874204,
-0.1360761821,
-0.2716043591,
0.1477797478,
0.504791081,
-0.2047369182,
0.0367498994,
-0.6828280091,
0.507338047,
0.7035679817,
0.2674268484,
0.0947631225,
-0.4247457981,
-0.1670089811,
-0.2515979707,
-0.5148906112,
-0.7655626535,
0.1354381144,
-0.2896887958,
0.7681254745,
0.2915011346,
0.0599017553,
0.4280322194,
-0.6103893518,
0.6731186509,
0.202945441,
-0.5422924161,
0.6242334247,
-0.482246846,
0.2547588944,
0.413833946,
0.4225548506,
-0.5207288265,
-0.3459245265,
-0.6620121002,
-1.0131776333,
0.6142182946,
-0.0409527496,
-0.0056389277,
-0.3554400504,
0.1079620868,
-0.0580773689,
0.3535944819,
-0.9314848781,
-0.0565478876,
0.3224028051,
0.0717262626,
0.1457821578,
-0.2937969267,
0.0547656491,
0.1795906574,
0.8213346601,
-0.0691826418,
0.0278683063,
0.0270629339,
-0.0255176872,
-0.1248995513,
0.5055106878,
0.2068244964,
0.5072481632,
-0.1798385233,
0.2272015512,
0.0227110591,
0.0071854661,
0.2761555016,
0.1408597678,
-0.4304197729,
0.0352729522,
-0.1981664002,
0.8784389496,
0.1768826842,
-0.5878753662,
0.5227367878,
-0.0325102098,
-0.0214664526,
-0.0123243378,
0.1649677902,
0.4163178504,
0.5117006898,
0.2621884346,
-0.0210512187,
0.1191464439,
-0.2909640372,
0.2793174386,
0.7957396507,
-0.2969721854,
-0.0269502793,
0.8461831808,
0.5008929372,
-0.4292428792,
0.3948114514,
-0.2620018721,
-0.2786795795,
0.231186524,
0.4337143898,
0.7559610605,
-0.3403229713,
0.2895830274,
0.4145416021,
-0.0236884821,
-0.0278094187,
0.1084935144,
-0.2701202929,
-0.7982783318,
-0.3436398208,
-0.9367411137,
-0.2780819833,
0.0259969048,
-0.8560538888,
0.0092269219,
0.0577806942,
-0.2461433411,
-0.3059747219,
-0.0343944728,
-0.5571147799,
0.0929079428,
0.1524436921,
0.7786761522,
-0.5894143581,
0.7259758711,
0.5850270987,
-0.4736579657,
-0.933529675,
-0.0015352634,
-0.1879725456,
-0.6759282947,
0.9517559409,
0.0676656216,
-0.3092724383,
-0.1033005491,
-0.3576617241,
-0.7552879453,
0.9671991467,
0.3127883375,
-0.5638459921,
-0.3724659979,
0.0531741008,
0.151207909,
-0.3225848079,
0.0642858297,
0.4083920419,
0.2465824336,
0.1032240838,
-0.8280159235,
0.0151463216,
-0.3041736782,
0.4158845544,
0.4782583416,
-0.7528558373,
0.7629354,
-0.1970363855,
-0.1120649278,
0.1015397459,
0.6564129591,
0.9559742212,
0.2797345519,
0.8035939336,
0.525515914,
0.5422038436,
0.0074649998,
0.9697931409,
-0.095968321,
0.0330847465,
1.264332056,
-0.4445033371,
0.975561142,
0.8237169981,
-0.1005367041,
0.6584529877,
0.6859483123,
0.3085520566,
0.6116525531,
0.5107892752,
-0.5410860181,
-0.3356544673,
-0.4127783477,
-0.3149364591,
0.1105133072,
0.181260556,
-0.4783174098,
-0.2796660364,
-0.1162101254,
0.1154818237,
0.4080139101,
-0.3584682345,
0.897438705,
0.0939034,
-0.9930694699,
0.4125548899,
-0.0090529155,
0.7749854326,
-0.5966860056,
0.0038801301,
-0.4790268838,
0.0623635426,
-0.1826450676,
-0.7941675186,
0.000804966,
0.0317735523,
-0.4468136132,
-0.3154676557,
0.8816475272,
-0.6500961781,
-0.0537448823,
0.385822475,
0.7690659165,
0.0477058478,
0.1966567785,
-0.6395164132,
-0.0406753644,
-0.0182420611,
-0.5231727362,
0.6090136766,
0.358876735,
-0.0210794546,
0.6105085611,
0.716255784,
0.2189244032,
0.100371331,
0.1697236598,
1.0161778927,
-0.6324033737,
-0.5477196574,
-0.6461563706,
0.5242049098,
-0.3241662979,
-0.0596095771,
0.7705358863,
0.7089921832,
1.0603859425,
0.0522398204,
0.7994712591,
0.0772885829,
0.9997470975,
-0.4785456657,
0.4018135965,
-0.6860108972,
0.3165316582,
-0.1355818659,
-0.8343139291,
0.1759712547,
0.4182375073,
-0.4394381642,
0.1742611378,
0.4405221343,
1.0606774092,
-0.1250701994,
-0.3955528438,
0.2027618438,
-0.0868349746,
0.2123918235,
0.8554037809,
0.8833845258,
0.0309040546,
0.5883117318,
0.1232050508,
-0.102800481,
-0.1441428512,
-0.7395483255,
-1.053699255,
-0.5228969455,
0.0636790618,
-0.4864161313,
0.2091477662,
0.7468213439,
0.5303930044,
-0.2628041804,
-0.6172910929,
-0.0872701108,
0.225538373,
0.13264516,
-0.2853847742,
0.0737050474,
-0.5441442132,
-0.5858832598,
0.3160516322,
0.282638073,
-0.0865244046,
-0.3768519759,
-0.4280312061,
-0.3828900158,
0.1823757291,
0.4328400493,
0.3506555855,
-0.7385607958,
0.0070735398,
0.157620132,
-0.2598534524,
0.2426650971,
0.7428942323,
-1.059402585,
0.4931795597,
0.4956241548,
1.0920472145,
0.9035307169,
0.2626157105,
0.6199067831,
-0.9190374613,
-0.2374377549,
0.1398560405,
0.0935378671,
0.5713421106,
-0.2648571432,
0.4794261754,
0.040825434,
-0.7868050933,
-0.7557403445,
0.5215374231,
-0.8105143905,
-0.2497864962,
1.204595685,
0.0820922107,
-0.3292683065,
0.0693864897,
-0.2004317045,
0.1554948092,
-0.4676380754,
0.9254675508,
0.4421626925,
-0.2457232177,
-0.1248866543,
-0.5438745618,
0.5547088981,
0.4925273955,
-0.8301813006,
-0.3070581257,
0.3364967108,
0.2945208848,
0.0539905578,
0.7862627506,
0.1164874807,
0.2951072156,
-0.3600975275,
-0.0940283239,
-0.0650618225,
-0.2631081641,
-0.1405825317,
0.2957936525,
0.2895004153,
-0.2159148157
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06951v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06951v3
|
E^2-LLM: Efficient and Extreme Length Extension of Large Language Models
| 2024-01-13T02:11:20 | 2024-02-22T12:49:10 |
Jiaheng Liu, Zhiqi Bai, Yuanxing Zhang, Chenchen Zhang, Yu Zhang, Ge Zhang, Jiakai Wang, Haoran Que, Yukang Chen, Wenbo Su, Tiezheng Ge, Jie Fu, Wenhu Chen, Bo Zheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Typically, training LLMs with long context sizes is computationally
expensive, requiring extensive training hours and GPU resources. Existing
long-context extension methods usually need additional training procedures to
support corresponding long-context windows, where the long-context training
data (e.g., 32k) is needed, and high GPU training costs are assumed. To address
the aforementioned issues, we propose an Efficient and Extreme length extension
method for Large Language Models, called E 2 -LLM, with only one training
procedure and dramatically reduced computation cost, which also removes the
need to collect long-context data. Concretely, first, the training data of our
E 2 -LLM only requires a short length (e.g., 4k), which reduces the tuning cost
greatly. Second, the training procedure on the short training context window is
performed only once time, and we can support different evaluation context
windows at inference. Third, in E 2 - LLM, based on RoPE position embeddings,
we introduce two different augmentation methods on the scale and position index
parameters for different samples in training. It aims to make the model more
robust to the different relative differences when directly interpolating the
arbitrary context length at inference. Comprehensive experimental results on
multiple benchmark datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of our E 2 -LLM on
challenging long-context tasks.
|
[
-0.3735319376,
-1.1392122507,
0.4049987197,
0.1244605482,
-0.5011968613,
-0.1616331488,
-0.6141908169,
-0.8909838796,
0.1385290623,
0.3105451763,
-0.4198700786,
-0.327380687,
-0.4434751272,
-0.1349893808,
-0.2610988319,
0.7813016176,
-0.0324238241,
-0.1931316108,
0.0448603816,
-0.1717455983,
0.1139435843,
-0.3604576886,
-0.622821629,
-0.1395255327,
0.5856168866,
0.5284398198,
0.3910327852,
0.8179291487,
0.1859562695,
0.1662347615,
-0.1188942865,
0.4832347929,
-0.6961699724,
-0.0271208044,
0.0099981129,
-0.4109985232,
-0.7183687091,
-0.0481810346,
0.7509977818,
0.5718508959,
0.0759186447,
0.1847504228,
0.0476268046,
0.7467713952,
-0.5199609995,
0.0485750362,
-0.4794812799,
-0.0798859447,
-0.2438864559,
-0.2266379446,
-0.4131485224,
-0.0190917607,
0.0703448877,
-0.5504639745,
-0.0087079536,
0.2094353437,
0.724470973,
0.0619387887,
-0.6880009174,
0.0477337837,
-0.7546584606,
0.8093405366,
-0.6994606256,
0.5460156798,
0.2544978261,
0.1893319786,
-0.0088820448,
-0.4972142577,
-0.5233817697,
-0.1520574838,
0.1657144874,
0.0739498287,
0.1609252095,
0.4230780602,
0.5796329379,
0.0488171466,
-0.5850992203,
0.6126462817,
-0.4307468235,
0.1967697293,
0.737724781,
0.0133624421,
0.1568653882,
0.2347818613,
-0.4825061858,
-0.1606991142,
-1.2180724144,
0.0408435836,
0.7047657371,
-0.0875663459,
-0.1704700291,
0.5068428516,
-0.0312110614,
0.7716958523,
-0.3571690023,
-0.2473171949,
0.0485723466,
0.0878608599,
-0.0524811484,
-0.1808224469,
0.3646682799,
0.5745441914,
-0.0421312228,
-0.067297101,
-0.2896091044,
-0.2476320416,
-0.2576010525,
-0.9614741206,
0.0947934613,
0.091986306,
-0.1245317981,
0.0928206593,
-0.1426824778,
-0.7456528544,
0.1475520134,
-0.389408052,
0.2740350068,
-0.3149306178,
-0.1677362025,
-0.0667215213,
-0.0086566312,
0.5835520029,
0.3873266578,
-0.9083483815,
0.2855168283,
0.9310817719,
0.726531148,
-0.2559052408,
-0.3360869288,
-0.8286600113,
0.3424440622,
-0.3150550723,
0.4937147796,
-0.6033604741,
-0.1664848924,
0.0725814551,
0.1642887443,
0.1934740543,
-0.1915241778,
0.6634063125,
-0.6630638242,
0.1121399701,
0.2077440023,
-0.906806469,
-0.4292927384,
0.0814705044,
-0.5151903033,
1.2489284277,
0.4329427183,
-0.3830682933,
0.0846979916,
-0.5136223435,
-0.5581201315,
0.1409515291,
-0.1120663881,
-0.3764837682,
0.3285603523,
0.3364196718,
0.3889923692,
-0.6573006511,
0.0788486674,
-0.423075527,
-0.5383455157,
-0.1702348292,
-0.496525228,
0.3458268344,
0.029519625,
-0.3357900679,
-0.0753813386,
-0.713778913,
0.1358433813,
-0.0294453148,
-0.6312066317,
-0.3892066181,
-0.062041685,
0.4069703519,
0.2332795709,
0.2883051932,
-0.6234707832,
0.3029221892,
-0.765501678,
0.4370923638,
0.7758912444,
-0.4135959744,
0.4759264886,
-0.140146032,
0.6094666719,
-0.443334341,
-0.0882086083,
-0.211295411,
-0.2481372952,
-0.8107898831,
-0.4734455645,
0.2423383594,
0.4340417385,
-0.4866001904,
0.7118860483,
-0.6062492728,
-0.2282751501,
-0.1502680331,
0.0493874811,
0.4378127754,
0.3468191028,
0.423039645,
0.074700892,
-0.6773734689,
-0.9600769877,
-0.2715698183,
-0.0981402844,
-0.3124950528,
0.338247478,
0.4233618379,
-0.0453865938,
0.9511511922,
-0.5681660175,
0.0149059715,
-0.2757091224,
-0.2280270904,
0.2626117766,
0.4490689635,
0.3225571513,
-0.5393640399,
-0.6416111588,
-0.0813629776,
-0.5550782681,
-0.0754276067,
-0.066074878,
0.1365965754,
0.3995320201,
0.4965035021,
-0.4657227695,
0.2744996548,
0.735419035,
-0.0882617384,
0.4855665267,
-0.4513734877,
-0.221198231,
-1.068334341,
-0.0911034197,
0.111086078,
-0.5106351376,
-0.6882022619,
0.3452452719,
0.3310320079,
0.0434879437,
-0.4249048829,
0.807359159,
-0.7258318663,
-0.1595657468,
-0.4913522005,
0.3590011299,
0.0166806988,
0.6423962116,
0.0381035954,
0.6441010833,
0.5907691121,
-0.3747447133,
0.496896714,
0.0448395051,
-0.4596607387,
0.2846232653,
-0.6444115043,
0.4112773836,
-0.147871688,
0.55097121,
-0.8717895746,
-0.1403269321,
-0.214013949,
-0.2052665055,
0.6712533832,
-0.2947996557,
-0.4766535461,
-0.4073188901,
-0.5821021199,
0.5216254592,
0.7765727639,
-1.0691697598,
0.4448443949,
0.2609061301,
-0.2235961705,
-0.586673975,
-0.7072920203,
0.2276877165,
-0.6849953532,
-0.7969198227,
0.5363760591,
-0.0764558539,
0.0069160201,
-0.3056084216,
-0.055711709,
0.0949252397,
0.0296129007,
0.1012831256,
0.2375160158,
-0.0635583103,
0.176569894,
0.322648257,
-0.0224921983,
-0.0691269338,
-0.3814071119,
0.4996160865,
-0.0536595695,
-0.3342678845,
-0.3113841414,
0.5447337627,
0.3661079705,
0.0360938199,
0.6374711394,
0.5031864047,
-0.4636006951,
-0.4352519512,
-0.6909165978,
-0.1900645941,
-0.4755047262,
1.0490239859,
-0.5577126741,
-1.1732900143,
0.2325216234,
-0.2523620725,
0.1541968882,
0.1397982389,
0.3715735376,
0.0483843908,
1.1012576818,
0.6771081686,
-0.0670216084,
0.3030047119,
-0.2116533667,
0.2797532082,
-1.3072242737,
-0.0706367195,
-0.1729391366,
-0.3521611392,
-0.3787786961,
-0.7752596736,
0.461519599,
0.5753433704,
-0.0916120261,
0.4612691104,
-0.1715946198,
0.5527435541,
0.1105141565,
0.2811585963,
0.0088298377,
0.350396663,
0.0764855668,
0.0299543031,
-0.6699230075,
-0.3711405098,
1.190728426,
0.7460488081,
0.7008730173,
0.3335927725,
0.3635372818,
-0.020290928,
0.251727134,
-1.0756738186,
0.5114072561,
-0.1125761271,
-0.2520543337,
-0.6509453058,
-0.2328407913,
-0.5960493684,
0.2552099228,
0.1441767216,
-0.7411258817,
-0.1608738005,
0.0794347078,
-0.175607264,
0.423671186,
-0.3460463285,
0.155612424,
-0.3242058158,
-0.7438091636,
-0.4714798629,
-0.6791166663,
0.2435233146,
-0.3464278877,
0.2827686965,
-0.1919979304,
-0.481569767,
0.9067512155,
-0.7048059702,
0.569737792,
-0.1151835546,
-0.351334542,
0.2201805711,
-0.1630588919,
1.1974842548,
0.2163358033,
-0.035209015,
0.0299331211,
-0.4556995034,
-0.4796159267,
-0.577319622,
0.9775801301,
-0.6889638901,
-0.7720959187,
0.008314467,
-0.7777050734,
-0.4086135626,
-0.2488171905,
0.1448710859,
0.6269102693,
0.0233870652,
0.3217357099,
0.4587388337,
-0.281384021,
0.7268763185,
0.6268687844,
-0.0691990256,
-0.3754823208,
0.713376224,
0.0565461516,
0.3214402795,
0.5386261344,
0.2195504904,
-0.648573935,
-0.5728022456,
-0.5516454577,
0.163656339,
-0.7081632018,
0.0052381502,
-0.7434607148,
-0.0068002134,
-0.2569064498,
-0.285261035,
-0.3454217315,
-0.8498839736,
-0.0699579939,
-0.4151426852,
0.5921413898,
0.3578068614,
-0.2838760912,
0.3402729034,
-0.8054438233,
-0.0145209217,
0.4703136384,
0.1859418154,
0.0859928429,
-0.9247763157,
-0.4249066114,
-0.0133440355,
-0.0170892626,
-0.5650829077,
0.471227318,
0.5690657496,
0.3501195312,
0.5360478759,
-0.1648102254,
0.7601038814,
-0.8120979667,
0.7548559308,
0.4423349798,
-0.7321400642,
0.1991723329,
-0.3398805261,
0.0778012127,
0.1819940209,
0.3718646467,
-0.3597562015,
0.0822461769,
-0.3098231554,
-1.1956651211,
0.6985734105,
0.0263978112,
0.2550831437,
-0.0609177016,
0.4696447849,
0.1253130287,
-0.3332079947,
-0.5055292845,
-0.3311598003,
0.281563133,
0.0660154298,
-0.2812896073,
-0.6234845519,
-0.1850365847,
-0.5315957665,
0.8893840313,
-0.4346469641,
0.1248827949,
0.0416050553,
-0.3506546319,
-0.0992635265,
0.2997426689,
0.6017310023,
0.7667856812,
-0.0738702416,
0.2830281258,
0.7703934908,
-0.0772804245,
0.3205674887,
0.1240314692,
0.2054196447,
-0.0875136182,
0.3976154625,
0.9649499059,
0.1901930273,
-0.7539747953,
0.6074571609,
0.3788249493,
-0.1579870433,
-0.4041649997,
-0.1743493527,
0.4132676125,
0.1970955431,
0.3835160434,
-0.5484699607,
0.0370188616,
-0.3486630619,
0.1879196316,
0.2843712866,
-0.4386571944,
-0.3942147493,
0.5246542096,
0.293887943,
-0.2969183326,
0.6377558708,
-0.0163181741,
-0.5400126576,
0.7615466714,
0.8092936873,
0.5991153717,
-0.1907847077,
-0.1566300988,
0.5017774105,
0.1076342538,
-0.1254830509,
0.1559099853,
0.0364623852,
-0.4114016294,
-0.8079343438,
-0.6408615112,
-0.1251404583,
0.3258534968,
-0.532330513,
0.5484964848,
-0.2613442242,
0.2871235609,
-0.4969902337,
-0.0929481015,
-0.4591193795,
0.1330334395,
0.2553895712,
1.1172690392,
-0.5681932569,
1.1813120842,
0.5793673992,
0.1829361022,
-0.7487536669,
-0.3217488527,
-0.1058085561,
-0.8121202588,
0.7031561136,
0.5398068428,
-0.1291846931,
0.0693440288,
-0.5412141085,
-0.718493104,
1.1420366764,
0.1926059425,
-1.1484597921,
-0.2686201632,
0.366903007,
0.4444164634,
-0.5000898838,
0.469641,
0.5866783261,
0.3057247698,
-0.0780652165,
-0.8252395988,
0.1750763655,
-0.0760452822,
0.3129918575,
0.3971617818,
-0.7939139009,
0.6117676497,
-0.1803939044,
-0.123278074,
0.244660154,
0.6634445786,
0.260630399,
-0.1127168015,
0.6519238353,
0.7969505191,
0.5047136545,
0.1209838763,
0.8633158803,
-0.6515539885,
0.7022594213,
1.1738003492,
-0.293648839,
0.8596076369,
0.4537262619,
-0.2311836332,
0.1615621448,
0.7399504781,
0.160972923,
0.2884794176,
0.461517632,
-0.5588064194,
-0.3979917467,
0.0448445566,
-0.5786889195,
0.2218753397,
0.6438970566,
-0.3303818107,
-0.1866031289,
0.0861415565,
0.1638842076,
-0.1615315676,
-0.0909791961,
0.4604276121,
0.3898617923,
-0.5736266375,
0.8003012538,
0.3291614056,
0.8263462186,
-0.6008384824,
0.0334141627,
-0.2693083286,
0.0551575609,
-0.1379187256,
-0.4650948346,
0.1116905883,
-0.0871099383,
0.0430431627,
-0.0950812772,
0.4937696457,
-0.634313345,
-0.2395249158,
0.4765523672,
0.249665916,
0.2518179417,
-0.1256211698,
-0.4050951898,
-0.145348236,
-0.1136630699,
-0.5558078289,
0.4419983029,
0.0409495793,
-0.1244637594,
0.4550160468,
0.6611922979,
-0.0961098224,
0.0190450512,
-0.0932083875,
1.0847964287,
-0.4971930981,
-0.4699980021,
-0.8672029376,
0.2663421929,
-0.0860304758,
-0.054505527,
0.599568069,
0.8636218905,
0.7083787322,
0.0398571342,
0.8193737268,
-0.0560783371,
0.3506985307,
-0.7436155081,
0.3123696148,
-0.6777888536,
0.4539760649,
0.1275143474,
-1.3993726969,
-0.066974394,
0.3126301467,
-0.2636108398,
-0.1288015097,
0.8190069795,
0.8757123351,
-0.0337508358,
-0.0818240568,
0.4396786392,
0.2394997776,
0.4345365763,
1.0513983965,
0.8714123964,
-0.3942016959,
0.343012929,
-0.1530113667,
-0.4284490943,
-0.3254484236,
-0.8920959234,
-0.8778101802,
-0.2841143608,
-0.269600451,
-0.2640840709,
0.1330838799,
1.1903580427,
0.9795239568,
-0.3666672707,
-0.2079056054,
-0.0404752232,
-0.2064106762,
-0.0463042632,
-0.2171885371,
0.6360806823,
-0.0713346153,
-1.0454285145,
0.8702717423,
0.4435875714,
-0.1300072819,
-0.1965496093,
-0.3726064265,
-0.2386075109,
0.0659383759,
0.9080684185,
0.2997138202,
-0.7332877517,
-0.4857714772,
-0.1237208247,
0.1788945645,
0.1429825872,
0.5968978405,
-0.4214028716,
0.3768875003,
0.6397361755,
0.6091623306,
0.8763344884,
-0.0353027694,
0.637165904,
-0.8413517475,
0.3660189211,
-0.0261029117,
0.4208322465,
0.1900155544,
-0.3885468245,
0.6365421414,
0.0635512397,
-0.4985624552,
-0.7093172669,
0.4597893059,
-0.8252124786,
-0.3385158181,
1.5527336597,
-0.4958786666,
-0.127204448,
0.039300587,
0.0029571049,
0.1426160634,
-0.190105468,
0.4418452382,
0.512968719,
-0.2214765102,
-0.1559944749,
-0.52307266,
0.384857744,
0.5303152204,
-0.8990973234,
-0.019563172,
0.4252142906,
0.3659626245,
-0.2514318824,
0.1301675588,
-0.1037774906,
0.0691466331,
-0.2646027207,
-0.1043149829,
-0.2579110861,
-0.4859223962,
-0.480663389,
0.205791831,
0.068238467,
0.1847665012
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06947v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06947v1
|
Parameter-Efficient Detoxification with Contrastive Decoding
| 2024-01-13T01:46:20 | 2024-01-13T01:46:20 |
Tong Niu, Caiming Xiong, Semih Yavuz, Yingbo Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The field of natural language generation has witnessed significant
advancements in recent years, including the development of controllable text
generation techniques. However, controlling the attributes of the generated
text remains a challenge, especially when aiming to avoid undesirable behavior
such as toxicity. In this work, we introduce Detoxification Generator
(DETOXIGEN), an inference-time algorithm that steers the generation away from
unwanted styles. DETOXIGEN is an ensemble of a pre-trained language model
(generator) and a detoxifier. The detoxifier is trained intentionally on the
toxic data representative of the undesirable attribute, encouraging it to
generate text in that style exclusively. During the actual generation, we use
the trained detoxifier to produce undesirable tokens for the generator to
contrast against at each decoding step. This approach directly informs the
generator to avoid generating tokens that the detoxifier considers highly
likely. We evaluate DETOXIGEN on the commonly used REALTOXICITYPROMPTS
benchmark (Gehman et al., 2020) with various language models as generators. We
find that it significantly outperforms previous approaches in detoxification
metrics while not compromising on the generation quality. Moreover, the
detoxifier is obtained by soft prompt-tuning using the same backbone language
model as the generator. Hence, DETOXIGEN requires only a tiny amount of extra
weights from the virtual tokens of the detoxifier to be loaded into GPU memory
while decoding, making it a promising lightweight, practical, and
parameter-efficient detoxification strategy.
|
[
-0.2719866037,
-0.576584518,
0.4898730814,
0.0378957875,
-0.5709748864,
0.0734119862,
-0.2858009934,
-0.3556729257,
-0.2121551037,
0.4717945755,
-0.5312858224,
-0.6206763387,
-0.2901463211,
0.2872108519,
-0.2929793894,
1.1962440014,
0.3257174194,
-0.2543165684,
0.2316101491,
-0.1247243434,
-0.1164788231,
-0.1499437988,
-1.0771819353,
-0.4574084878,
0.5472992063,
0.1263790578,
0.6259028912,
0.6445856094,
-0.0036797866,
0.318795681,
-0.2635942698,
0.0346016958,
-0.6624600887,
0.4078321755,
-0.3691640794,
-0.0656305999,
0.2876576781,
-0.0758422539,
0.330640614,
0.4204545319,
-0.102044493,
-0.1254816353,
0.1467152238,
0.5771925449,
-0.8783906102,
-0.1976094246,
-0.7995601892,
0.1540528387,
-0.129986003,
-0.3824544847,
-0.6598405242,
-0.652900517,
-0.325800091,
-0.4163320959,
0.0826032683,
-0.054900609,
0.9113230109,
0.5898877978,
-0.2991842926,
-0.1206638366,
-0.8721169829,
1.0532809496,
-0.8078540564,
0.3999817669,
0.0505540781,
0.2441476136,
-0.1090267599,
-0.7982541323,
-0.524333775,
-0.2274804711,
0.069939442,
0.3076477051,
-0.2791884243,
0.168141976,
0.155520469,
0.3127599657,
-0.5809877515,
0.1579428166,
-0.1897425354,
-0.2945481539,
0.4510874152,
0.254265219,
0.5805234909,
-0.3933479786,
-0.4268231392,
-0.0722043514,
-0.7012803555,
-0.3621754646,
0.7701494098,
0.3503919542,
0.0857758522,
0.1767084897,
-0.1714791358,
0.2454670519,
-0.028766945,
0.1439774483,
0.3894201815,
-0.374751538,
-0.1681192219,
0.2803395987,
0.9989996552,
0.2930761874,
0.1713547856,
-0.3868538439,
-0.0999252573,
-0.025275467,
0.6377981901,
-1.2906712294,
-0.549141705,
0.4550187886,
-0.643337369,
-0.5979661345,
-0.3875132203,
-1.0383796692,
-0.3406914771,
-0.0681611598,
0.263266772,
-0.8438525796,
-0.4387118518,
-0.0083018886,
-0.3788061738,
0.1073715463,
0.0476348996,
-0.7473043203,
0.2742783129,
0.2752045691,
0.6689007282,
-0.1045415848,
0.3273937702,
-0.8296822309,
0.1186505109,
-0.121043466,
0.6945413351,
-0.6748734117,
-0.357311517,
-0.032027863,
-0.2952380776,
0.0822295696,
-0.7287116051,
0.7936645746,
-0.3908931911,
0.2149514556,
-0.1771837771,
-0.2848341167,
-0.1319379061,
-0.0211823452,
-0.8293918967,
1.0598028898,
0.0442940481,
-1.1267813444,
0.4401359856,
-0.4834362566,
-0.3634653986,
0.2600263953,
0.0305592753,
-0.6860898137,
0.2043038607,
-0.1254586577,
0.0731324926,
-0.1733599752,
0.0049566734,
-0.2354775518,
-0.5182074904,
-0.1311947107,
-0.5391074419,
1.0055183172,
0.8751929402,
-0.4447727501,
0.3107127249,
-0.9592567682,
0.1517787427,
0.193921715,
-0.5402632356,
-0.5460117459,
0.1735727042,
0.4021353126,
0.4505434334,
-0.1425246447,
-0.5964960456,
-0.3382818997,
-0.434335202,
0.4105816782,
0.6780208945,
0.3896400928,
0.1732291579,
-0.1508590728,
0.4850892127,
0.1008722186,
-0.1080261022,
0.0248866044,
-0.0989493728,
-0.5296370983,
-0.5004252195,
0.0560036041,
0.5238105655,
-1.0382938385,
0.6861785054,
-0.2995488942,
-0.5149915814,
-0.345128119,
0.3454122543,
0.6893059015,
0.6968013048,
0.5179196596,
0.0997353047,
-0.4522325993,
-0.8279946446,
-0.4147996604,
-0.1406464726,
-0.3181951642,
0.0246875882,
0.3884286582,
-0.126815632,
0.5301275253,
-0.3897480071,
0.3090076447,
-0.5718224645,
0.256917119,
0.0979089439,
0.600231111,
0.615514636,
-0.4862596989,
-0.3737798929,
-0.1386702359,
-0.5578892231,
-0.4895698726,
-0.3817625344,
-0.3852339685,
-0.2011666894,
0.6842718124,
-0.3513045907,
0.1363519132,
0.244822368,
-0.1294559836,
0.786416769,
-0.3172050416,
-0.11828769,
-1.1577934027,
0.5481156707,
0.0763460323,
-0.1849430352,
-0.9544072151,
0.2798636258,
-0.1037400439,
-0.1341544837,
-0.7453948259,
0.7094285488,
-0.2720086873,
0.6040005088,
-0.0824048296,
0.0679197758,
0.1937364191,
0.4585980177,
0.2812571824,
0.6867369413,
0.2739330232,
-0.7072120905,
-0.0458417833,
0.048299443,
-0.1251294762,
0.6315532923,
-0.5781575441,
0.08891996,
-0.3759819269,
0.2243985236,
-1.0051404238,
0.0664769858,
0.5349552631,
0.0895890221,
0.3470656872,
-0.0041238214,
-0.5669058561,
-0.2040546536,
-0.515339613,
0.4279043674,
0.8224268556,
-0.7138991952,
0.4580655694,
-0.2014549077,
-0.2081225663,
-0.3929873705,
-0.520498693,
0.0827345997,
-0.8271935582,
-0.0838440731,
0.2292824835,
-0.2245833874,
-0.3334776461,
-0.1181757227,
-0.0856551453,
0.1303179413,
0.3834787309,
0.0739557594,
-0.0516270995,
0.154408589,
0.2163897157,
0.707459867,
-0.3680569828,
0.187709555,
-0.0907415599,
0.5787639618,
0.2999988794,
0.0118429428,
-0.4871837199,
0.4980568886,
0.2971149385,
-0.3467047513,
0.8886756897,
0.8054068089,
-0.2191525996,
-0.4079201818,
-0.2552251816,
-0.2088024467,
-0.5730011463,
0.2989692092,
-0.3491232395,
-0.2765395343,
0.682982862,
-0.2856532037,
0.2547696829,
0.2930266559,
0.4909374714,
0.2444390655,
1.1981079578,
0.1250178069,
0.1079404429,
0.7162457108,
-0.0354718976,
0.1805990636,
-0.8991221786,
0.0384755358,
-0.8329000473,
-0.2963563502,
-0.5701040626,
-0.0287296046,
0.1391684562,
0.0142861903,
-0.6400242448,
0.2065557688,
-0.6076014042,
0.5475881696,
0.3975629807,
0.2085055709,
0.1713061929,
0.1130593121,
-0.4435390234,
-0.0833167583,
-0.4522937238,
-0.6104565859,
0.7160857916,
0.2129725963,
0.7307875752,
0.1022270322,
1.3082199097,
0.1001990512,
0.4770267904,
-0.4264009893,
0.5036871433,
-0.2833097279,
-0.4851804376,
-0.0097030587,
-0.7716138363,
-0.7709538341,
0.3932071626,
-0.0543087348,
-0.8912748694,
0.127865836,
0.1625497341,
-0.316504091,
0.478638798,
-0.6641862392,
0.8812195063,
0.1120202169,
-0.7110058069,
-0.1385624558,
-0.7171940207,
0.5892085433,
-0.1166278422,
0.1037416682,
-0.1389631629,
0.1784246415,
0.4281290174,
-0.4315509796,
0.4980041087,
-0.3164143562,
-0.3632168472,
0.3271018267,
0.3633539677,
0.5621085167,
0.0074728196,
-0.5596075654,
-0.0867456943,
-0.2352773696,
-0.3530103862,
-0.2833263874,
0.697403729,
-0.4229208827,
-0.3238697648,
-0.0349694788,
-0.2946021557,
-0.1402681172,
0.5168061256,
0.6892560124,
0.4638997614,
-0.2735876143,
-0.1637948751,
0.8849930167,
-0.8753453493,
0.6345080733,
-0.0349680483,
0.1163427532,
-0.2564651668,
1.3878674507,
-0.4226743877,
0.4934186935,
0.3382409513,
0.3697996736,
-0.5878636837,
-0.7758099437,
-0.3860887587,
0.186272949,
-0.7503552437,
-0.2176645249,
-0.6731790304,
-0.1907259822,
0.0094008883,
-0.123839885,
-0.1591027528,
-0.0976560712,
-0.5080552101,
-0.3063449562,
0.229630366,
0.3806095719,
-0.0542966425,
0.2312289178,
-0.8957269192,
0.5163409114,
0.0977764428,
0.312392056,
-0.1527538598,
-0.3326612413,
0.1359307915,
-0.0500934646,
-0.1987010837,
-1.1584964991,
0.4532013834,
0.3025565147,
0.7437781692,
0.8214787245,
0.5543543696,
0.3750200272,
-0.5014425516,
0.8167076707,
0.1547707915,
-0.9197563529,
0.4388393462,
-0.3381882608,
0.3941151202,
1.0203261375,
0.0799615905,
-0.5337580442,
-1.0085644722,
-0.3040270507,
-0.8860306144,
0.4986986816,
0.4668534398,
0.4479068518,
-0.5379701257,
0.3127111495,
0.2600791454,
0.1626949012,
-0.4720167518,
-0.1025639325,
-0.5611668825,
-0.6617918611,
0.1402764916,
-0.3154450059,
-0.0338181667,
0.1434785873,
0.663090229,
0.0684119388,
0.1711089015,
-0.2162103653,
-0.3285575211,
0.0499833077,
0.5496716499,
0.3585219979,
0.1017070636,
-0.3239601254,
0.4700967669,
-0.021790741,
-0.5101118684,
0.1957298368,
0.1052381918,
-0.3049494624,
0.0079404432,
0.0149774142,
0.6653267741,
0.0769504607,
-0.8404794335,
0.1078426763,
-0.1848396808,
-0.2093012631,
0.2420300394,
0.4048611224,
-0.0526017249,
-0.2138211131,
0.1119827032,
-0.1706359684,
0.4836265445,
-0.1254049093,
0.1682627946,
0.5014349818,
-0.4412485957,
-0.1874679327,
1.1503143311,
0.5782145262,
0.1664501429,
0.9002367854,
-0.4090138078,
-0.2513625622,
0.3638732731,
0.6253386736,
1.2719539404,
-0.3582805693,
0.2984955907,
0.6890413761,
0.113177821,
0.3510814905,
0.2973488569,
-0.2418887019,
-0.6148522496,
-0.2709529698,
-0.8909341097,
0.0848718211,
0.4095613062,
-0.6816849709,
-0.1944677383,
-0.5960796475,
0.0072522433,
-0.135084644,
-0.002189832,
-0.5230804682,
0.2181805223,
0.0312634148,
0.9031282663,
-1.1439454556,
0.6508912444,
0.3354837894,
-0.5277559757,
-0.3459828496,
0.2019183934,
0.1325657368,
-0.3214686513,
0.4750397205,
0.4270121455,
-0.3377862871,
0.2356068194,
-0.3329692185,
-0.2395154387,
0.6285442114,
0.5297873616,
-0.3797011971,
0.041906856,
-0.2906683683,
0.618766129,
0.2672538161,
0.2386425883,
0.6908268929,
0.5730563402,
0.0748595074,
-0.2445819974,
0.6148235798,
-0.70710361,
0.2419265062,
0.2360803932,
-0.3843434751,
0.396853596,
-0.1497025043,
-0.6739036441,
0.2867598534,
0.5267689824,
0.2556256652,
-0.1112838164,
0.6477512121,
0.6114481688,
0.6731625795,
0.0618870743,
1.0073107481,
-0.4601811767,
0.0047477288,
1.0930907726,
-0.2803652287,
0.4082851112,
0.471575439,
0.0708794892,
0.7110062242,
0.5329163671,
0.1708756238,
0.8125548363,
0.4118711948,
-0.8368090987,
-0.4412758052,
-0.2348054498,
-0.3628603816,
0.0534334257,
0.3746593893,
-0.6036553979,
-0.6894926429,
-0.0234221667,
0.3893468678,
0.1454280317,
0.006767564,
0.7880989909,
-0.146953702,
-0.4466795921,
0.6582951546,
-0.0470265485,
0.4243194163,
-0.5560780168,
-0.0827291235,
-0.3982951939,
0.1925563961,
-0.0592010953,
-0.4089439213,
0.283369869,
-0.0254912563,
0.1831609607,
-0.3712541461,
0.7143431902,
-0.5651062727,
-0.2680771053,
0.15862149,
0.2897565365,
0.2468616962,
-0.0385331325,
-0.6484302878,
0.1032284424,
-0.0702043697,
-0.3179707825,
0.2846288979,
0.2606968582,
0.1039372608,
0.6083119512,
0.5490604639,
0.1412640065,
-0.0744453892,
0.3355461061,
0.9277897477,
-0.4892764091,
-0.5570793748,
-0.8325670958,
0.5654798746,
-0.0959456638,
-0.1321059763,
0.6784235239,
0.5534460545,
0.3016172349,
0.0920196697,
0.8977161646,
0.1267135888,
0.1864448488,
-0.5737895966,
0.8541401625,
-0.5083051324,
0.1632225215,
-0.4175192714,
-0.9532200098,
-0.2588918507,
0.5077397823,
-0.0687041357,
0.2974096835,
0.6432026029,
0.7431240678,
-0.0162716601,
-0.2415360659,
0.1168443039,
0.0154072521,
0.7352324128,
0.5707741976,
0.5831618905,
-0.02945094,
0.7171986103,
-0.2618255913,
-0.0778689086,
-0.2294575721,
-1.058665514,
-0.8427455425,
-0.199318707,
-0.4544374049,
-0.5327659845,
0.1040153876,
0.7325025201,
0.5191993117,
-0.6941571236,
0.3808415532,
-0.4755739272,
0.328039676,
-0.6009814143,
-0.2630428374,
0.2226953954,
-0.6971390843,
-1.0452771187,
0.3498484194,
0.1410080642,
-0.006161348,
-0.2310819328,
0.0184372198,
0.1560012102,
0.3918442428,
0.4244953096,
0.4393886626,
-0.4313513935,
-0.4900142848,
-0.4911443591,
-0.2876501381,
-0.0129289273,
0.6134853959,
-0.7612054944,
0.5591426492,
0.7543637156,
0.4671179056,
0.2627046108,
0.2578832507,
0.3968165219,
-0.9359127879,
0.0925999805,
0.1675588042,
0.1736947596,
0.2846274376,
-0.3615793586,
0.2529216707,
-0.0221410971,
-0.1515768319,
-0.8115323782,
0.4004021883,
-0.8286550045,
-0.4612178504,
1.2259180546,
-0.1236168668,
-0.2404234707,
-0.3749473095,
-0.3339671791,
0.380279094,
-0.4522432685,
0.750683248,
0.1976380348,
-0.0148096485,
-0.1997145861,
-0.285977304,
0.7151066661,
0.2196690738,
-1.1790416241,
0.3316141069,
0.603916347,
0.5201221704,
0.0182083845,
0.4501196444,
-0.1904285103,
0.0735018179,
0.2054153681,
0.1662959009,
-0.1442918926,
-0.1415624917,
-0.3555125296,
0.0979402661,
-0.2768975198,
-0.2276748419
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06945v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06945v1
|
Knowledge-Centric Templatic Views of Documents
| 2024-01-13T01:22:15 | 2024-01-13T01:22:15 |
Isabel Cachola, Silviu Cucerzan, Allen Herring, Vuksan Mijovic, Erik Oveson, Sujay Kumar Jauhar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Authors seeking to communicate with broader audiences often compose their
ideas about the same underlying knowledge in different documents and formats --
for example, as slide decks, newsletters, reports, brochures, etc. Prior work
in document generation has generally considered the creation of each separate
format to be different a task, developing independent methods for generation
and evaluation. This approach is suboptimal for the advancement of AI-supported
content authoring from both research and application perspectives because it
leads to fragmented learning processes, redundancy in models and methods, and
disjointed evaluation. Thus, in our work, we consider each of these documents
to be templatic views of the same underlying knowledge, and we aim to unify the
generation and evaluation of these templatic views of documents. We begin by
introducing an LLM-powered method to extract the most important information
from an input document and represent this information in a structured format.
We show that this unified representation can be used to generate multiple
templatic views with no supervision and with very little guidance, improving
over strong baselines. We additionally introduce a unified evaluation method
that is template agnostic, and can be adapted to building document generators
for heterogeneous downstream applications. Finally, we conduct a human
evaluation, which shows that humans prefer 82% of the downstream documents
generated with our method. Furthermore, the newly proposed evaluation metric
correlates more highly with human judgement than prior metrics, while providing
a unified evaluation method.
|
[
-0.2420454919,
-0.2139394283,
0.7129324675,
0.060439121,
-0.411570251,
0.1475603729,
-0.3689483404,
-0.0986477733,
0.3297038078,
0.2546788752,
-0.3284198344,
-0.8457552791,
-0.4983059466,
0.0377946608,
-0.4301146567,
0.8595820665,
-0.0171153918,
-0.1388036311,
-0.6995812654,
0.0062334612,
-0.1765542924,
-0.336548388,
-0.160137102,
-0.5950300694,
0.5952367187,
0.5125316381,
0.4046515822,
0.6616098881,
0.3222579062,
0.3014574945,
0.1519508362,
0.0497135222,
-0.2907232344,
0.2245908082,
-0.2445639074,
-0.2465824187,
-0.2825089097,
0.2736659646,
0.6477252841,
0.6835861206,
-0.1695523262,
0.2587044537,
0.2058999091,
0.8639264703,
-0.7090452909,
0.2243818939,
-0.5607234836,
0.2213069648,
-0.3182854056,
-0.5660050511,
-0.3892586827,
-0.3247327209,
0.0775843635,
-0.7435814142,
0.4024554491,
-0.0793969482,
0.3681815863,
0.1110093296,
-0.4756892622,
-0.3359743059,
-0.8687505722,
0.6134023666,
-0.5786069036,
0.4063468277,
0.2384996563,
0.2264174521,
0.0142585812,
-0.8547434807,
-0.6256710291,
-0.0697252154,
0.0874444023,
0.4629350007,
0.0377257727,
-0.1039494649,
0.0461912192,
0.3551964462,
-0.5402160883,
0.2092081457,
-0.6297893524,
-0.1932916492,
0.7530603409,
0.1469647288,
0.1242754608,
-0.3280785382,
-0.2911469638,
-0.0436135195,
-0.4481421709,
-0.1115392223,
0.6841260791,
0.1040358096,
0.0173874889,
0.6812448502,
-0.2313576639,
0.6295806766,
0.1013532728,
-0.1128848121,
0.2652917206,
-0.2213903517,
-0.2742732167,
0.1590830237,
0.798558116,
0.7113028169,
-0.0793458149,
-0.4959003031,
-0.0321009606,
-0.0882215872,
0.8379089832,
-0.5915312171,
0.0360464342,
0.3996114731,
-0.4452384412,
-0.36299178,
0.4841847122,
-0.7730781436,
-0.8213436007,
-0.6168699861,
-0.0012456914,
-0.6780737638,
-0.1899811029,
-0.0780095309,
-0.3278755546,
0.3530753851,
0.6389016509,
-0.7692414522,
0.0543117896,
0.8721373081,
0.5893831849,
-0.2498993725,
-0.5982641578,
-0.2888595462,
0.3769362867,
-0.2418893278,
1.304271102,
-0.4056174457,
-0.4251623154,
0.0230548102,
-0.444665879,
-0.050463479,
-0.2867718339,
0.4692064226,
-0.4271600544,
0.7659409642,
-0.3294508755,
-0.5839784741,
-0.0250112992,
0.4311185479,
-0.6513290405,
0.7834976315,
0.4465514123,
-1.0767397881,
0.6856347322,
-0.7098087072,
-0.4283554554,
0.2034958452,
-0.395455718,
-0.1824601591,
0.2341526896,
-0.0780464038,
0.2669810951,
-0.5751008391,
0.2639814317,
0.0492571928,
-0.1282862127,
-0.0196428802,
-0.263042897,
0.361458391,
0.3030177653,
-0.2260911167,
0.2829203904,
-0.790843606,
0.0173277296,
0.0466320366,
-0.782766819,
-0.3960012197,
0.1266599298,
0.0742541775,
0.0211097989,
0.2183918506,
-0.567209065,
0.1981460005,
-0.2368466109,
0.1957430094,
0.8175951838,
0.0614737496,
0.6662105322,
-0.4463196397,
0.5476425886,
0.0526453741,
0.234541297,
-0.2924440503,
-0.1155803502,
-0.4047979116,
0.0610087179,
0.2136699408,
0.1101724133,
-0.6582324505,
0.3828093112,
-0.3743758798,
-0.8595092297,
-0.3970886469,
0.4279684722,
0.3542649448,
0.9265239239,
0.0774406865,
-0.5999175906,
-0.3107627332,
-0.8906040192,
-0.3889921308,
-0.3874310553,
-0.1226973608,
-0.0013839037,
-0.0092153316,
0.0560942665,
0.8911551833,
-0.2256075293,
-0.0887874886,
-0.4958328605,
0.2261985391,
0.0775998831,
0.3885151148,
0.5897381902,
-0.9579631686,
-0.5844548941,
0.0190906338,
-0.8437432647,
-0.2158376426,
-0.1977351159,
-0.1548428982,
0.3971150219,
0.5078948736,
-0.4287575483,
0.5068269372,
-0.0082333032,
-0.3627896905,
0.4180663526,
-0.2429209352,
0.1289769709,
-1.3622670174,
0.2163352519,
0.2192345858,
0.0345164984,
-0.5354597569,
0.0553652197,
0.0655273274,
0.1098673642,
-0.5397120714,
0.4634566605,
-0.6820860505,
-0.1964808404,
-0.0528673716,
0.2328174859,
0.6763482094,
0.3510499001,
0.1034959629,
0.3034602702,
0.1436838508,
-0.1188148558,
0.506125927,
0.0831777155,
-0.4840703011,
0.7583438158,
-0.5216818452,
0.3774893284,
-0.404027611,
0.096750021,
-0.6999323368,
-0.1819909215,
0.2116604149,
-0.3394673467,
0.5788756013,
0.0063364017,
-0.7542019486,
-0.2641382813,
-0.7368050814,
0.0383668318,
0.0777034536,
-0.204968363,
0.7361867428,
0.3391743302,
-0.1122389957,
-0.481109798,
-0.4369038343,
0.0302554835,
-0.3452861011,
-0.6969752312,
0.340557158,
-0.0889431834,
-0.5024322867,
0.111796774,
-0.3549183309,
0.1030964702,
0.0112279952,
0.5095669031,
0.2411524802,
-0.1635292917,
0.0823528096,
0.1606109738,
-0.0523136705,
-0.0669215098,
-0.539466083,
0.5619907379,
-0.060713768,
-0.6789381504,
-0.2507703304,
0.721801281,
0.5584974289,
-0.2595543265,
0.6434673667,
0.4954568446,
-0.2745294571,
0.0578889064,
-0.7086151838,
0.3202603161,
-0.3830378652,
0.1821163893,
-0.2156338096,
-0.4537825882,
0.3552457988,
0.1436174065,
0.4199391603,
0.7416089773,
0.8289675117,
-0.2065612525,
0.186732769,
0.8906696439,
-0.0088562835,
0.4646983445,
-0.2179617584,
-0.0599912703,
-0.8062623143,
-0.8005728722,
-0.7303952575,
-0.3240399957,
-0.1774956137,
-0.2256128639,
0.5312568545,
-0.032723058,
-0.1276909262,
0.1198174208,
-0.6818075776,
0.4110963941,
0.6994128823,
-0.0620507598,
0.5169066191,
0.2142426521,
-0.3375328183,
0.0487268828,
-0.7879495025,
-0.8356891274,
1.3238811493,
0.0221315268,
0.5374339819,
-0.1367269158,
0.8833691478,
0.517431438,
0.8075802922,
-0.7959541082,
0.2578130662,
0.091027908,
-0.408279717,
-0.2560625076,
-0.2401532233,
-0.8644868731,
0.1289868951,
-0.2024925649,
-0.8412377834,
-0.01084862,
-0.2112754583,
-0.3394408822,
0.3625245988,
-1.0377506018,
0.8093873858,
-0.1347079426,
-0.5170456171,
-0.1338964999,
-0.632383585,
0.1332582384,
-0.2560703456,
0.0727968663,
0.1266050637,
0.0018651953,
0.8105061054,
-0.4678028822,
0.5542867184,
-0.1414889395,
-0.1136189625,
0.5530472994,
-0.0052908687,
-0.2855844498,
0.1313066185,
-0.6947345138,
0.0064228079,
0.1193662211,
-0.2344910651,
-0.7774819732,
0.5885875225,
-0.8785607219,
-0.8475143909,
-0.4425060451,
-0.6881839037,
-0.1636537164,
0.4646390975,
0.4361340404,
0.4979798496,
-0.3947589397,
0.1222600788,
0.2164456397,
-0.1959376037,
0.3269495964,
0.6112427711,
0.0428830348,
-0.1988488138,
0.6195294261,
0.0839113593,
-0.0604364909,
0.5622773767,
0.2532873154,
-0.2722189128,
-0.6264874935,
-0.342654258,
0.0901492164,
-0.6986665726,
-0.1545391381,
-0.5531342626,
-0.2011153698,
-0.6186028719,
-0.2805335224,
-0.3617555499,
-0.5219903588,
-0.2673311234,
-0.0736155137,
-0.0585696362,
0.8652592897,
-0.2545055151,
0.1893580407,
-0.8565583825,
0.3883129954,
0.2119376063,
0.323954314,
0.0883109868,
-0.2244914323,
-0.3570401371,
-0.1743500829,
-0.6446962357,
-0.9037334323,
0.2057759464,
-0.1059704274,
0.7958891392,
0.4727628231,
0.1499298662,
0.1305022836,
-0.3792130649,
0.718103528,
0.2513977587,
-0.70432657,
0.7112352252,
-0.2530697286,
0.1824326366,
0.8250703216,
0.4268443882,
-0.5395757556,
-0.1704273522,
-0.8307021856,
-0.9157732129,
0.7618111372,
0.1470623165,
0.0286786277,
0.3372064531,
0.3815322518,
0.4238347411,
0.4421341419,
-0.2793390751,
0.1593715847,
-0.6294366121,
-0.118112132,
-0.0320680998,
-0.2054221034,
-0.3420111835,
-0.0282042865,
0.4159957767,
-0.1548527032,
0.1343240887,
0.3002441525,
0.0492725484,
-0.1136617437,
0.4651104808,
0.3635454178,
0.9814731479,
-0.4294459224,
0.2017963827,
-0.5393928289,
-0.5899897814,
-0.0979682133,
0.3508038521,
-0.3584089279,
-0.037887156,
0.5509251356,
0.4546991587,
-0.2965843081,
-0.2474272102,
0.3984790742,
-0.3056491911,
-0.1875094622,
-0.242474854,
0.0656602457,
0.1782678068,
0.3476466537,
0.4597927034,
-0.0401708223,
-0.0604156367,
-0.6746919751,
-0.0004580749,
0.2569941878,
-0.2039092332,
-0.4492652416,
0.5173890591,
0.254094094,
-0.4167621434,
0.5391188264,
-0.0746528357,
-0.3672106564,
0.7115219235,
0.16845119,
1.0320421457,
0.001842959,
0.3194500506,
-0.0425298661,
0.3160920739,
0.2791007459,
0.2598807514,
-0.4488745928,
-0.685251832,
0.0641592592,
-0.8051506877,
-0.542658627,
0.084522061,
-0.7901751399,
0.1686965823,
-0.514641881,
-0.0675093159,
0.3671339154,
0.3250690401,
-0.7049348354,
0.0763876215,
0.1314705461,
1.0902068615,
-0.5685939789,
0.8189641237,
1.0948864222,
-0.4749291837,
-0.7946941257,
0.3973623812,
0.1004218236,
-0.4241114259,
0.2024730444,
0.0692882165,
0.0782773867,
-0.3582780957,
-0.4668708444,
-0.3366444111,
1.4370472431,
0.5271353722,
-0.1888810396,
-0.2432909161,
0.2631199658,
0.7133840322,
-0.4862224758,
0.1699614674,
0.2424604148,
0.6230426431,
0.20492284,
-0.5351991057,
-0.1797032952,
-0.6518238187,
-0.0273653287,
-0.2432401627,
-0.8122414947,
0.4905200005,
-0.0775954947,
-0.2461211085,
-0.2634786665,
0.6887803674,
0.321288377,
0.7646381855,
0.4010477066,
0.2930423915,
0.723258853,
0.2902034223,
1.300311327,
-0.4737295806,
-0.0790439472,
1.3237155676,
-0.4039758742,
0.310980618,
0.7427078485,
-0.0303452127,
0.4012983441,
0.4389070868,
0.0897873268,
0.3619783223,
0.1386699677,
-0.0935749635,
-0.0639741123,
-0.3460282385,
-0.4061765671,
0.6054945588,
0.172353223,
-0.3221763372,
-0.4455381334,
-0.5654826164,
0.016020596,
0.4863978624,
-0.0938416347,
0.6459601521,
0.0816416889,
-0.7330096364,
0.0810340121,
0.3391574323,
0.294683218,
-0.5382034183,
0.2920789421,
-0.4379660189,
-0.299131453,
-0.4249281585,
-0.9426523447,
0.659434557,
0.3832550049,
-0.464596808,
-0.4835192561,
0.9050300717,
0.0393906161,
-0.5368236303,
0.0360686891,
0.8919523358,
0.0526213944,
-0.1043154523,
-0.2015106082,
-0.0494252779,
-0.0840746164,
-0.6593046784,
0.4336399734,
0.7931426167,
-0.1078192517,
0.3138634264,
0.5724689364,
0.0427243635,
-0.0911025777,
0.2748987675,
1.223195672,
-0.5162619948,
-0.4402382672,
-0.8081796765,
0.4894375801,
-0.1165310591,
-0.1930539161,
0.6869844794,
0.8866021037,
0.6662689447,
0.1209747195,
1.0686494112,
-0.2037234902,
0.2530597746,
-0.3903143704,
0.9388482571,
-0.6344951987,
0.3749145865,
-0.4652186036,
-1.1348427534,
-0.1733649522,
0.132091552,
-0.3798182011,
-0.1496628374,
0.5801929235,
0.3153562546,
-0.1951314956,
0.0715393946,
0.1249411032,
-0.1689306796,
0.4165243208,
0.6616672873,
0.8356449008,
-0.1273023337,
0.3668665886,
-0.3579932153,
-0.1475008428,
0.2196355164,
-1.0929034948,
-0.790446043,
-0.8708127141,
-0.2548750341,
-0.2786460817,
-0.2365335375,
0.8118927479,
0.5106422901,
-0.2612130344,
-0.1763897836,
0.1803149432,
0.4171784222,
0.2680716217,
-0.2601184249,
0.4370651841,
0.0347707942,
-0.6992087364,
0.2338126451,
0.5207477808,
-0.2053265125,
-0.5449205041,
0.022735713,
0.0044596894,
-0.0456083678,
0.4584680498,
0.2832245231,
-0.1630561501,
0.0514655896,
-0.158200711,
-0.2658649385,
0.3524415791,
0.9889850616,
-0.7933806181,
0.4166273177,
0.6264573932,
0.5129303932,
0.5181239843,
0.1615674049,
0.6225238442,
-0.5907480717,
0.2505951822,
0.1953985691,
0.2633928657,
0.5962638855,
-0.539899528,
0.5368942022,
0.336391449,
-0.1831629574,
-0.5728346705,
0.0726325288,
-1.2290475368,
-0.1085557118,
1.056106925,
-0.2553445697,
-0.3170031011,
0.1140609682,
0.0412252545,
0.5629175901,
-0.528275907,
1.0644817352,
0.5482208729,
-0.254557997,
0.0138578871,
-0.2667626143,
0.0452791676,
-0.0400359891,
-1.0679491758,
-0.2019468397,
0.649006784,
0.3223734498,
0.3646805584,
0.9664899707,
-0.3691278696,
0.0080020847,
-0.068445228,
0.1933618933,
-0.513431251,
-0.4059766829,
-0.1397334039,
0.505748868,
0.1056690663,
0.168770656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06935v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06935v1
|
MiTTenS: A Dataset for Evaluating Misgendering in Translation
| 2024-01-13T00:08:23 | 2024-01-13T00:08:23 |
Kevin Robinson, Sneha Kudugunta, Romina Stella, Sunipa Dev, Jasmijn Bastings
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Misgendering is the act of referring to someone in a way that does not
reflect their gender identity. Translation systems, including foundation models
capable of translation, can produce errors that result in misgendering harms.
To measure the extent of such potential harms when translating into and out of
English, we introduce a dataset, MiTTenS, covering 26 languages from a variety
of language families and scripts, including several traditionally
underpresented in digital resources. The dataset is constructed with
handcrafted passages that target known failure patterns, longer synthetically
generated passages, and natural passages sourced from multiple domains. We
demonstrate the usefulness of the dataset by evaluating both dedicated neural
machine translation systems and foundation models, and show that all systems
exhibit errors resulting in misgendering harms, even in high resource
languages.
|
[
0.0408658981,
-0.3921011984,
0.159874022,
0.3917874694,
0.207047537,
0.1115430743,
-0.0564359762,
-0.2615586221,
-0.1649114043,
0.5344024301,
-0.7586435676,
-0.2809371054,
-0.9735220671,
0.4327047467,
-0.785046339,
1.0925779343,
-0.1569702625,
0.2493630052,
-0.0322744437,
-0.1850348264,
-0.7850074172,
-0.3129720092,
-0.3003080487,
-0.1351877898,
0.4170854986,
0.6610125303,
0.8494457603,
0.5579330921,
0.8021638989,
0.3104533255,
0.1800254434,
0.122195527,
-0.3830756545,
0.446474582,
-0.2288289517,
-0.720004499,
-0.1150506139,
0.162053138,
0.4097372591,
0.8331167698,
0.0933440179,
0.2172505558,
0.0817487314,
0.5588032007,
-0.5490031242,
-0.2190006077,
-0.4414454401,
0.1413847655,
-0.5745103359,
-0.238977477,
-0.4228589833,
-0.6467731595,
0.2446755618,
-0.195250541,
0.461479485,
0.190524742,
0.5352642536,
0.2395225912,
-0.3503302932,
-0.5139052272,
-0.7499005198,
1.00933218,
-0.5814026594,
0.2349557877,
0.6327200532,
0.6303145289,
-0.1393364519,
-0.2507849634,
-0.2107524723,
0.0334898569,
-0.4697649181,
-0.0143340277,
-0.5509290099,
-0.3710901141,
0.243704915,
0.1400529444,
-0.8398292661,
-0.3576284945,
-0.6074358821,
-0.2362809032,
0.6277518272,
0.1159306914,
1.0292969942,
-0.2258749008,
-0.2704386115,
-0.3459775448,
-0.7334305644,
-0.4881904423,
0.8189883232,
0.3886956871,
-0.306486547,
0.551615119,
0.4493320584,
0.4019474387,
-0.2223549485,
0.0995099545,
0.4284648001,
0.0849368572,
-0.1214088872,
0.037938755,
0.4484083354,
0.412014693,
0.4592524469,
-0.574395597,
-0.2174422443,
0.1201367825,
0.2400124073,
-0.412507236,
0.2187039703,
0.0279133376,
-0.3296604156,
-0.201949805,
0.1862352043,
-0.8648292422,
-0.3594664335,
0.1025891751,
0.2083972394,
-0.8175355792,
-0.2030109614,
-0.0327492654,
-0.7204470038,
0.0476040766,
-0.1284963489,
-0.7055486441,
0.3812442124,
0.2945346534,
0.6621186137,
-0.1710940599,
-0.5624462962,
-0.1884978861,
0.2035445273,
-0.4710056186,
0.5286864638,
-0.6511372924,
-0.7498140335,
-0.0790664777,
0.1421196908,
-0.1755045056,
-0.7746553421,
0.7802327275,
-0.0699338168,
-0.0055351881,
-0.1836331934,
-0.0812292472,
-0.316966027,
0.0139350947,
-0.4338809848,
0.7705598474,
0.2656336129,
-0.7032980919,
0.1644219756,
-0.5087434053,
-0.6891129017,
-0.0081509966,
-0.1576998681,
-0.1628119051,
0.4186000228,
-0.085631758,
0.4127443135,
-0.5505322218,
0.3682668805,
-0.0390439332,
-0.1523417532,
0.4063799083,
-0.7019937038,
0.7682403326,
0.1052340344,
-0.4368316233,
-0.0674966797,
-0.4373377264,
-0.1148375198,
0.3078663945,
0.0347519331,
-0.7033635378,
0.2526111603,
0.1839301139,
0.4073968232,
-0.1678570211,
-0.605883956,
-0.0135296397,
-0.4570657611,
0.4475461245,
0.5865616798,
-0.206862554,
0.396974504,
-0.5225905776,
0.363853991,
0.3662095964,
0.2736595273,
0.0078823008,
-0.5143050551,
-0.849435091,
0.2551527917,
0.3988093734,
0.6126183867,
-1.0185877085,
0.2381022573,
-0.6172071099,
-0.4731962979,
-0.6427890658,
-0.0890494063,
0.5759328008,
0.2700032592,
0.4079785049,
-0.0319052376,
-0.4835629463,
-1.6419937611,
-0.3377844393,
0.1460503191,
-0.0296867602,
0.1035038233,
0.780829668,
-0.5090104938,
0.6820802689,
-0.3100209534,
-0.3825878799,
-0.1285403371,
0.5381193161,
-0.1239609867,
0.6710460782,
0.536195457,
-0.768019557,
-0.3124569654,
0.1028930172,
-0.69630301,
-0.2367349565,
-0.0505660884,
-0.3213111758,
0.0805976838,
0.3172032237,
-0.2503881156,
0.6120433211,
0.7863348722,
-0.3411118686,
0.3067238927,
-0.1882273704,
0.2668679655,
-1.0865529776,
0.3208555579,
-0.0569656417,
-0.0206715912,
-0.5301386118,
-0.0891442224,
0.2861717641,
-0.0210014824,
-0.7051408291,
0.4735783935,
-0.5519568324,
-0.1055408567,
-0.096853368,
-0.145510748,
-0.2356559932,
0.035113465,
-0.3004269898,
1.0074214935,
0.2220523953,
-0.4237849414,
0.0230429713,
0.4489645958,
0.0028977909,
0.8243299127,
-0.3149954677,
-0.1251751035,
-0.3886731267,
0.0256460793,
-0.8093406558,
-0.4149975479,
0.3328304291,
-0.5127263069,
0.3525070548,
0.0775058344,
-0.5368485451,
-0.3891112506,
-0.2529551983,
0.6282644868,
0.2983529866,
-0.2653960288,
0.5559644699,
0.3014592528,
-0.14347817,
-0.6964228153,
-1.2551261187,
0.2378624082,
-0.2732107341,
-0.5993798375,
0.4037252665,
-0.1216997132,
-0.2543783188,
-0.060287945,
-0.0410121977,
-0.1377692968,
0.0747037232,
0.4797856808,
0.0292220451,
0.0108203748,
0.4628336728,
0.3157316148,
-0.3184058368,
-0.0689099208,
0.2603942454,
0.4914701581,
0.1943535954,
-0.289272964,
-0.1488684267,
1.0024365187,
0.6963754296,
0.0102889938,
0.5325670838,
0.0848611891,
-0.6510413885,
-0.5800651312,
-0.4257825911,
-0.2475432754,
-0.3600283861,
0.287368238,
-0.3716695905,
-0.3852371871,
0.5468152165,
-0.0885662213,
0.1009321436,
0.9932107329,
0.2269526869,
-0.3214041591,
1.0224635601,
0.7436995506,
-0.1269471943,
-0.0690618306,
-0.1609673798,
-0.0194489323,
-0.6499153376,
-0.0133600049,
-0.9385844469,
-0.6467450857,
-0.6486181617,
-0.5264230371,
0.1925157607,
-0.1765680611,
-0.2188345641,
0.5919917226,
-0.336528033,
0.6331920624,
0.4892588258,
-0.1243531033,
0.1992374659,
0.037487302,
-0.1504045278,
-0.4322070479,
-0.6372593641,
-0.7633813024,
1.0979362726,
0.2671248913,
0.7353835702,
0.570723474,
0.3813845813,
0.6758982539,
0.8912654519,
-0.4498783052,
0.2538204193,
-0.5682268739,
-1.1735481024,
-0.0474234112,
-0.5586643815,
-0.9944109321,
0.042780444,
-0.0439089462,
-0.694979012,
0.3411332071,
-0.1691593528,
-0.0402544588,
0.3603749573,
-0.5979214311,
0.6776412129,
-0.5251429677,
0.0572947673,
0.0322996974,
-0.8828039765,
0.5911949277,
-0.347628653,
0.3847742975,
-0.2099769861,
0.0019274272,
0.831748426,
-0.1568938941,
1.1693556309,
0.2315117121,
-0.0938412175,
-0.0953855366,
0.4121802449,
0.0584079251,
-0.6162911654,
-0.2522015572,
0.457092464,
0.2172899097,
-0.3378963768,
-0.3130894303,
0.5371521711,
-0.948014915,
-0.1483584195,
-0.5717722774,
-0.5935471058,
-0.3277749121,
0.145852685,
0.6471652985,
0.1862974465,
-0.4168203473,
0.0603860915,
0.2722811997,
-0.4390833974,
0.502068758,
0.4564774632,
-0.0968043208,
-0.3604052663,
1.1257805824,
0.3000290096,
0.1610397846,
0.117500037,
0.2075149417,
-0.1910505444,
-0.3158853352,
-0.6956050396,
0.4214146435,
-0.7231185436,
-0.3917964101,
-0.2632336915,
-0.2393227518,
-0.1387479454,
-0.0718036518,
-0.1008474752,
-0.1078161001,
-0.1174741983,
0.1236821562,
-0.1639863402,
0.7325116992,
0.104352057,
0.7229337692,
-1.3248041868,
0.0488933139,
0.0330663361,
0.2414956391,
-0.2538913786,
-0.403098613,
0.0802409276,
0.1233480722,
-0.4807677567,
-1.4174227715,
0.4689924717,
0.3046481311,
0.7307139039,
0.1195442528,
0.0529152229,
0.4350158274,
-0.6392176747,
0.5116325617,
0.219610706,
-1.0838851929,
0.6649798751,
-0.4488565326,
0.0580797158,
0.6747855544,
0.5246375799,
-1.003739953,
-0.3345845044,
-0.7428790927,
-0.7580670714,
0.8002055883,
0.4470523298,
0.3350021839,
-0.3329404891,
0.1613789648,
0.4848887026,
0.1009096876,
-0.4276994467,
-0.4476638138,
0.3605008125,
-0.4740100205,
-0.3613919914,
-0.1042601094,
-0.3049091399,
-0.068030104,
0.9080912471,
-0.0593352094,
0.2110217512,
0.0680762753,
-0.6751101017,
-0.5265108347,
0.2048459947,
0.682525456,
0.3450095654,
0.0199642312,
0.2466484457,
0.1590983421,
-0.4268270731,
0.3612849712,
-0.0995851308,
-0.3374643922,
0.1932329684,
0.3385329247,
0.5172347426,
0.2554476857,
-0.7018000484,
0.569575727,
-0.0011770582,
-0.2141648978,
0.0682175383,
-0.2707293928,
-0.0830011293,
-0.0003797669,
0.2467338741,
0.4742600024,
0.2415543795,
-0.5498290062,
0.2678284943,
0.182628721,
-0.4874536991,
-0.3364160657,
0.2399920225,
0.5214672685,
-0.454988569,
0.5776562095,
0.1295246184,
-0.5161351562,
0.5184432864,
0.566873908,
1.1447395086,
-0.6800979972,
0.3207746744,
0.253082484,
0.8403468728,
0.0284107961,
0.0327802077,
0.2863658965,
-0.5606313944,
-0.1540327817,
-0.5365163088,
-0.1755447537,
-0.0706106499,
-0.4593117237,
0.2211160362,
0.0297977626,
-0.4107501209,
-0.2099593878,
-0.7339342237,
-0.6017815471,
0.2242653072,
0.2375936508,
0.8267626166,
-1.3276648521,
0.4626570642,
0.612526536,
-0.3110442162,
-0.2563649118,
0.3448728323,
0.21918571,
-0.5740074515,
0.8970784545,
0.2201008797,
-0.1765105426,
0.0788749978,
-0.1169945747,
-0.8337451816,
0.6231293082,
0.6606460214,
-0.4648441374,
0.0406949297,
0.729532063,
0.3371079266,
-0.0305937678,
0.2338535339,
0.8877385855,
0.6573542953,
-0.2395159602,
-0.7141014934,
-0.058434695,
-0.3479533494,
-0.0350790322,
0.5600913763,
-0.2884739637,
0.8199449778,
0.2768739462,
-0.6531432867,
0.0866245404,
0.0587200783,
-0.3662781417,
-0.0560242608,
0.3877590597,
0.3551724255,
0.4263831675,
-0.566639781,
0.9990179539,
-0.0782130286,
0.1957469136,
0.9268157482,
0.0939805806,
0.8798139691,
0.5972055793,
-0.0602057986,
0.0325122103,
0.4169144034,
0.3175735772,
0.3026812077,
0.4534496963,
0.0150971096,
-0.1184562519,
-0.024431916,
-0.3098549843,
0.4505076706,
0.5272347927,
-0.7259124517,
-0.7684559822,
0.2494005263,
-0.0440526232,
0.0839979127,
0.1668135375,
0.6504514813,
0.1086896807,
-0.4815452099,
0.3789353371,
0.2493303269,
0.7825865746,
-0.6662905216,
-0.0968372151,
-0.3588015437,
0.1180582494,
-0.2552762628,
-0.7569642663,
0.7963112593,
0.0824101865,
-0.2978498638,
-0.2629074752,
0.640252471,
-0.355789572,
-0.9053158164,
0.5382703543,
0.9631882906,
0.3518447578,
0.1255077273,
-0.6515445709,
-0.0006162606,
0.0024267989,
0.0400261655,
0.0404366143,
0.1467890292,
-0.4233859181,
0.6494836807,
0.4914626777,
0.1264472157,
0.1360987127,
-0.0760778412,
0.3057842851,
-0.6702214479,
-0.1779611707,
-1.0193343163,
0.4903331101,
-0.1360081285,
-0.5541198254,
0.8016127348,
0.4846944213,
0.6925672889,
-0.2208652049,
0.9438047409,
-0.004883613,
0.4910791814,
0.0016005574,
0.994192481,
-0.5539239645,
-0.007648502,
-0.286125958,
-1.0369764566,
-0.4850646853,
0.456351608,
-0.6013549566,
-0.0162764397,
0.6415031552,
0.6515120268,
-0.3169458807,
0.1748075783,
0.5572112203,
0.1405568868,
0.0545200966,
0.3709899485,
0.8698089123,
-0.7703587413,
0.4005835354,
-0.3034660816,
-0.2291156352,
-0.2849213183,
-0.7317676544,
-0.5639877915,
-0.7202033401,
-0.1932995021,
-0.1455496252,
0.2540378571,
0.6840796471,
0.6863047481,
-0.6700126529,
-0.30574736,
0.0233558975,
-0.0998549238,
-0.075193882,
-0.1335745901,
0.0985345468,
-0.2413895577,
-0.8894201517,
0.2599280775,
0.2230848372,
0.4047569633,
-0.3269032538,
-0.0809242949,
0.0474308394,
0.1996105164,
0.4009268582,
-0.0203702562,
-0.6701378822,
-0.3152509332,
-0.2564093173,
-0.3162549138,
0.0156776495,
0.782871604,
-0.2350738198,
0.3348960578,
0.4172627926,
0.7357034087,
-0.0811307877,
-0.2499374896,
0.7366274595,
-1.0538624525,
-0.0666565523,
0.4515376687,
0.3344259262,
0.5832895041,
-0.1705112606,
0.5596917272,
0.278773129,
-0.0274769906,
-0.7080671787,
0.2264088243,
-0.4705622196,
-0.5089049935,
0.9444331527,
-0.0156425368,
-0.3305182457,
-0.0987674966,
-0.4458754361,
0.3460530043,
-0.1022921577,
0.5343049169,
0.8763705492,
0.5236225128,
0.1994990408,
-0.9302159548,
0.3778546453,
0.5058352947,
-0.9096302986,
0.3106555939,
0.4406484663,
0.369168967,
0.3933863938,
0.0776118487,
-0.2849937975,
0.2231541574,
0.0218223445,
0.3286065757,
0.3853240311,
-0.3431843221,
-0.1877542734,
0.0365965441,
-0.286434114,
-0.1737686247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06930v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06930v1
|
PizzaCommonSense: Learning to Model Commonsense Reasoning about Intermediate Steps in Cooking Recipes
| 2024-01-12T23:33:01 | 2024-01-12T23:33:01 |
Aissatou Diallo, Antonis Bikakis, Luke Dickens, Anthony Hunter, Rob Miller
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Decoding the core of procedural texts, exemplified by cooking recipes, is
crucial for intelligent reasoning and instruction automation. Procedural texts
can be comprehensively defined as a sequential chain of steps to accomplish a
task employing resources. From a cooking perspective, these instructions can be
interpreted as a series of modifications to a food preparation, which initially
comprises a set of ingredients. These changes involve transformations of
comestible resources. For a model to effectively reason about cooking recipes,
it must accurately discern and understand the inputs and outputs of
intermediate steps within the recipe. Aiming to address this, we present a new
corpus of cooking recipes enriched with descriptions of intermediate steps of
the recipes that explicate the input and output for each step. We discuss the
data collection process, investigate and provide baseline models based on T5
and GPT-3.5. This work presents a challenging task and insight into commonsense
reasoning and procedural text generation.
|
[
-0.0934419483,
-0.8788996935,
0.709749043,
-0.4349095523,
-0.0572301373,
-0.2518426776,
0.0046343738,
0.1806896031,
-0.2372842431,
0.9302016497,
-0.854947567,
-0.732711792,
-0.6575336456,
0.1760614067,
-0.5111575723,
1.1353548765,
-0.0418026112,
0.1254053116,
-0.2492152601,
0.4180516601,
-0.2720272541,
-0.1674318314,
-0.6938371062,
-0.0960170701,
0.4832903445,
0.9175544977,
0.8401755095,
0.7012276649,
0.2204241455,
0.3593243062,
-0.0657913238,
0.3376740813,
-0.3920948803,
0.0918168128,
-0.5411578417,
-0.2207469791,
-0.1310375631,
0.0307431296,
0.1337617636,
0.6644520164,
-0.0666807294,
0.130144462,
-0.0139166797,
0.6955893636,
-0.4970301986,
0.344750762,
-0.6065908074,
-0.1018112078,
-0.0429674312,
-0.2905398309,
-0.4834688604,
-0.6439083219,
-0.3381578326,
-0.7471641302,
0.5092073083,
-0.2463300377,
0.5085251927,
0.2460273653,
-0.3772096038,
-1.2561545372,
-0.4749876857,
0.7170633674,
-0.766813159,
0.0565535501,
0.5873433948,
0.3730323911,
-0.4953416288,
-1.1585749388,
-0.9422034621,
-0.3716255426,
0.0115681905,
-0.0944463909,
0.0800736248,
-0.099763535,
0.1121979579,
0.393954277,
-0.3548688591,
-0.1507430077,
-0.3900704086,
0.0986951888,
0.5167953968,
0.4296187162,
0.771674037,
-0.2555615902,
-0.3428976834,
-0.0517765768,
-0.6504976153,
0.0758254752,
0.4570668936,
0.3512996733,
-0.0626727119,
0.706894815,
-0.1431505829,
0.795856595,
0.1718973666,
-0.252261132,
-0.0871036872,
-0.7107674479,
-0.1286274642,
-0.08441329,
0.6045484543,
0.5221505165,
0.027482437,
0.0542332567,
-0.0152479559,
-0.1032074243,
0.1977056563,
-0.4993418455,
-0.662409544,
0.2883442342,
-0.2375450879,
-0.4473463595,
-0.0369418487,
-0.4253104925,
-0.3297492862,
-0.3298437893,
-0.0644516051,
-0.5000674129,
-0.1596509665,
0.0737977251,
-0.3236369193,
0.2279442847,
0.3428233862,
-1.2397580147,
0.5927188396,
0.9295046926,
0.7510704994,
0.3446436524,
-0.2220745385,
-0.4008389115,
0.4205922782,
-0.3885507584,
0.972342968,
-0.9513520002,
-0.644223094,
-0.1283297688,
0.2789013386,
-0.1546008885,
-0.3920119703,
0.9292427301,
-0.1685076058,
0.1049728766,
-0.7669145465,
-0.9294356108,
-0.3136407137,
0.2413283885,
-0.7809875011,
0.8311303258,
0.0845718011,
-0.4869369864,
0.0809069276,
-0.8008563519,
-0.4243464768,
0.2642333806,
-0.3014493585,
0.0720135272,
0.2048763335,
0.2895056307,
0.5628032088,
-0.3248417377,
-0.0482645445,
-0.0655415282,
-0.2112104297,
0.4396324754,
-0.3435399234,
0.7129951715,
0.3522811532,
-0.1260142028,
0.0518734269,
-0.4232323468,
-0.0121608134,
-0.0176035445,
-0.1661593467,
-0.1822792888,
0.2687062323,
0.0129677635,
-0.0766026825,
0.1579062045,
-0.2676277757,
0.2207632214,
-0.0700121447,
0.6730430722,
0.6428692937,
0.2632165849,
0.5471907854,
-0.487221241,
0.2011514157,
0.1250726134,
0.1367553771,
-0.5279301405,
-0.5910108685,
-0.4725964069,
-0.0102843745,
0.1810385734,
0.5456936955,
-1.1580070257,
0.3537468016,
-0.2291740477,
-0.600792706,
-0.0535147749,
0.1248524487,
0.4567848444,
0.6797673106,
0.3552091718,
-0.04611893,
-0.1210584491,
-0.6236630082,
-0.3687443137,
0.3016108572,
-0.0607975721,
0.1806609035,
0.522469759,
0.1270035654,
0.5289168954,
-0.6148052216,
0.1211881042,
-0.754586637,
0.1722194701,
0.337236762,
0.766690433,
0.1068985537,
-1.014472127,
-0.794179678,
0.2007996142,
-0.6646921635,
0.1192747578,
-0.3560797274,
-0.1333770454,
-0.2585842013,
0.701128602,
-0.6044260263,
0.30177176,
0.4803980291,
-0.4939936101,
0.4733426273,
0.0259696413,
0.2891596854,
-1.2316213846,
-0.3315652907,
0.1515292972,
0.1350205541,
-0.7440270782,
0.2126588076,
0.0518978015,
-0.0064489837,
-0.5759954453,
0.5173592567,
-0.5643731952,
0.0205970444,
-0.2138974369,
-0.2916893363,
0.0423085056,
0.6132403016,
0.2209097743,
0.9986370802,
0.2600670457,
-0.5031134486,
0.5368369222,
-0.0531521402,
-0.3512949347,
0.4170731306,
-0.5505134463,
0.2473469079,
0.2318028212,
0.2935700119,
-1.1808172464,
-0.6341124773,
0.6202208996,
-0.51824826,
-0.0773009062,
-0.5192373991,
-0.8454594612,
-0.1742458194,
0.303756237,
0.325670898,
0.3539492488,
-0.2776387334,
0.6164214611,
0.287736088,
-0.3918299675,
-0.2224717885,
-0.344693929,
0.099254787,
-0.0010299518,
-0.2740077078,
0.1293678284,
-0.0832913145,
-0.3344064653,
0.1342775375,
0.1456971318,
-0.5489675999,
-0.196264863,
0.1737006754,
0.0778653026,
0.1226635203,
-0.060318172,
0.4121181071,
-0.0100856461,
0.1774915904,
-0.3736866117,
0.4689821899,
0.0815792754,
-0.1801553369,
-0.6536946297,
0.5855905414,
0.4740722775,
0.1853682101,
0.5756006837,
0.5574685335,
-0.4710393846,
-0.2075995058,
-0.3561856747,
-0.0267160144,
-0.5389006138,
0.1169451252,
-0.4939832389,
-0.1608932614,
0.4713251889,
-0.0988489985,
0.0761134997,
0.4098306298,
0.669875443,
-0.1790010035,
0.469397068,
-0.0605413839,
0.6785984635,
0.023037849,
-0.172119379,
-0.0919435024,
-0.6322085261,
-0.4544263482,
-0.5759143829,
0.0467667691,
-0.4519375265,
-0.8463016748,
0.2890248597,
-0.4609584808,
-0.1859667748,
0.341142714,
-0.5578867197,
1.2635025978,
0.5336492062,
0.5490697026,
0.3002123535,
-0.1059942096,
-0.2396508157,
-0.0257090777,
-0.6045347452,
-0.7314450145,
1.1073465347,
0.1108704582,
0.5143257976,
0.169023782,
0.6793425083,
0.5146890283,
0.0448345728,
-0.7672463655,
0.6748276949,
-0.4710045457,
-0.6546886563,
-0.4818178713,
-0.528400898,
-0.5222913027,
-0.0275011528,
0.0843954012,
-0.1132075563,
-0.1668480486,
0.1074861959,
-0.3393033445,
0.5112157464,
-1.0706802607,
0.887804687,
-0.0716081932,
-0.837202251,
0.1791080385,
-0.3937090039,
0.4748667777,
0.5216512084,
0.3567389548,
0.0495415106,
0.0303475522,
0.3616946042,
-0.6988700032,
1.2255589962,
-0.2455068827,
-0.1498037428,
0.4330663085,
0.4229743481,
0.5388473272,
0.0670882985,
-0.0343396366,
-0.1383405626,
0.0656984672,
-0.7368426323,
-0.6782848239,
0.8716451526,
-0.5168862343,
-0.543390274,
-0.3502579033,
-0.6007785201,
0.0349564441,
0.3115563095,
0.3812615275,
0.4442144632,
-0.1654902697,
-0.1080278829,
0.922418952,
-0.0194407832,
0.3197754323,
-0.0941715986,
0.4125606418,
-0.358797133,
0.810082376,
-0.0357898548,
0.237572059,
0.4775712192,
0.1014465168,
-0.4241351187,
-0.6910465956,
-0.5042375326,
-0.137022391,
-0.9303999543,
-0.0852732137,
-0.3862893581,
0.0320882499,
-0.399417609,
-0.4308496714,
-0.4184816182,
-0.4815581739,
-0.3143017888,
-0.095296286,
0.0563608557,
0.9356302619,
0.0664120018,
0.181163162,
-0.9123521447,
0.297950238,
0.3109468222,
-0.0387936495,
0.1115043089,
-0.2593283057,
-0.3310375512,
0.1207471788,
-0.2713250518,
-0.9973778725,
0.4672297537,
-0.1598605812,
0.411259383,
0.2933961749,
0.0889408439,
0.5108283162,
-0.6852758527,
1.0931421518,
0.3689107001,
-1.1008470058,
0.5259867907,
-0.7040209174,
0.4561675191,
0.4435507357,
0.6334813237,
-0.4093250632,
-0.1646051705,
-0.5929222703,
-0.664293468,
0.2265713662,
0.3916293085,
0.4346317351,
-0.4154853225,
0.4125516415,
0.6792497039,
-0.0834381282,
-0.7927075624,
0.1777501553,
-0.4412855804,
-0.2406454086,
0.1859940439,
-0.2058739662,
-0.4408927262,
-0.285867244,
0.4311075211,
0.0342403427,
0.0413164869,
0.0542454422,
-0.0253029168,
0.1537782997,
0.3441430032,
0.6914764643,
0.5947887301,
0.0721914172,
0.1733007729,
0.0532975495,
-0.529076159,
-0.0363505259,
-0.3446241021,
0.2108214498,
-0.0047653862,
0.6143480539,
0.4363426864,
0.4022571445,
-0.4490973651,
0.434307009,
-0.1146697551,
-0.3259998858,
-0.6746599674,
0.4560947418,
0.2070443779,
0.161676079,
0.2423675656,
0.2089856863,
0.5153033137,
-0.6527919173,
0.2526433766,
-0.1680656821,
0.0686907843,
-0.3667445183,
0.1205816418,
0.4959341586,
-0.025477089,
0.9754920006,
-0.4306575358,
-0.1955910623,
0.7600017786,
0.4032910466,
0.738196969,
-0.0880199298,
0.5158877969,
0.6852314472,
0.0788351521,
-0.0264054164,
0.1676844507,
-0.4516071677,
-0.6742237806,
-0.1808439791,
-0.2797219753,
-0.6133038402,
-0.0503045358,
-0.8089649081,
0.0986778736,
-0.581659019,
0.1841054112,
0.0085488567,
-0.18096219,
-0.6357272863,
0.2643806636,
0.0689974353,
0.882593751,
-0.9052575231,
0.7180790901,
0.5280752182,
-0.4232829511,
-0.7663960457,
0.2524842918,
0.1965679675,
-0.8629745245,
0.6244257092,
-0.1325608641,
-0.0844015107,
-0.1936015189,
-0.8526023626,
-0.3358642459,
0.8164724112,
-0.1391928345,
-0.5257341266,
-0.5481587052,
0.2296785265,
0.3175358176,
-0.4605540037,
0.3432500064,
0.3834123015,
0.4214026928,
0.840046227,
-0.4711584449,
0.2732259035,
-0.4852527082,
0.1238790229,
-0.1197518632,
-0.2944723666,
1.0608645678,
-0.4567830563,
-0.2819580138,
0.3595994711,
0.4670014083,
0.252194047,
0.644528687,
0.1624142081,
0.5714228749,
0.5029372573,
-0.1783563346,
1.1090310812,
-0.1045498997,
0.1681111157,
1.4841660261,
-0.0893150643,
0.8178409338,
0.4725224674,
-0.0130324438,
0.7974725962,
0.9426952004,
-0.0384141505,
0.7041497231,
0.1437298805,
-0.393007338,
-0.2485755235,
0.0039878464,
-0.4000551701,
0.3981991708,
0.9236560464,
-0.6926741004,
-0.220880881,
-0.2945329249,
0.3010070622,
0.4220505953,
-0.3879550099,
0.9302539825,
-0.1516117454,
-0.8515136242,
0.3589300215,
-0.0783289894,
-0.1372094303,
-0.3113600016,
-0.4429149926,
-0.4362799227,
-0.0552324392,
-0.3395655453,
-1.1709374189,
0.3396658301,
0.0017691836,
-0.2097899318,
-0.1993709505,
0.2399135679,
-0.329893589,
-0.7276703119,
-0.3991118968,
0.3285922408,
0.1898802519,
0.2707477808,
-0.7783936858,
0.2399920076,
0.0490414202,
0.0592168085,
-0.1815737635,
0.8950489759,
0.3296379745,
0.3698275685,
0.8192068934,
-0.1122332811,
0.0998973399,
-0.1918705851,
1.0578856468,
-0.7759863734,
-0.7084690928,
-0.7286160588,
0.7440828681,
-0.0543679856,
-0.206247285,
0.5096303225,
0.3793866336,
1.1184782982,
-0.4250375926,
0.8894469738,
-0.1304974705,
0.447078526,
-1.1855683327,
0.3453773856,
-0.2928505838,
0.6333272457,
-0.0757350698,
-0.6625926495,
0.0392902642,
0.3564800024,
-0.5308763981,
0.0619414933,
0.8125677705,
0.8742456436,
-0.3178075552,
0.3348196745,
0.3288179636,
0.0872699693,
0.1307643056,
0.6253515482,
0.7850361466,
-0.3181029856,
0.2748686075,
-0.1931230873,
-0.1630138308,
0.1955779493,
-0.6911709905,
-0.8681083918,
-0.825694263,
-0.0319734998,
-0.2228744179,
0.421600014,
0.8456761241,
0.5702403188,
-0.6485754848,
-0.3463875949,
-0.6644228697,
0.2056509107,
-0.4135464132,
-0.2731495202,
0.1607708335,
-0.5625705719,
-0.9455007911,
0.3175584078,
0.0133803375,
-0.1488182247,
-0.0313980468,
-0.1212930158,
-0.1583835036,
0.246333763,
0.3939112425,
0.2929407954,
-0.8764373064,
0.1897296309,
-0.2066037804,
0.0444578268,
-0.1477868408,
1.0665040016,
-0.2733015716,
0.4962027371,
0.3197828531,
0.3589782715,
0.3499132693,
-0.1573580056,
0.6313231587,
-0.606507659,
-0.1150712371,
0.138945967,
0.183105588,
0.4227465689,
-0.5870319009,
0.4880009592,
0.2134302855,
-0.5048187375,
-0.5574803352,
0.489919275,
-0.868288517,
-0.6660452485,
1.2340859175,
-0.3444695175,
-0.3773894906,
-0.0303427875,
-0.0501515046,
0.3334123492,
-0.5326676965,
0.8907536864,
0.802965641,
-0.2414442003,
-0.5141021013,
-0.4561655521,
0.6777983308,
0.057967063,
-0.9325313568,
0.0861974135,
0.6574797034,
0.3309936523,
0.0086615905,
0.6004319191,
-0.3259436786,
0.5487441421,
0.4775043428,
-0.3649275899,
-0.281503588,
-0.4208307564,
0.3631728888,
0.3610385358,
-0.14654845,
-0.1935672909
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06920v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06920v1
|
Comparing GPT-4 and Open-Source Language Models in Misinformation Mitigation
| 2024-01-12T22:27:25 | 2024-01-12T22:27:25 |
Tyler Vergho, Jean-Francois Godbout, Reihaneh Rabbany, Kellin Pelrine
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent large language models (LLMs) have been shown to be effective for
misinformation detection. However, the choice of LLMs for experiments varies
widely, leading to uncertain conclusions. In particular, GPT-4 is known to be
strong in this domain, but it is closed source, potentially expensive, and can
show instability between different versions. Meanwhile, alternative LLMs have
given mixed results. In this work, we show that Zephyr-7b presents a
consistently viable alternative, overcoming key limitations of commonly used
approaches like Llama-2 and GPT-3.5. This provides the research community with
a solid open-source option and shows open-source models are gradually catching
up on this task. We then highlight how GPT-3.5 exhibits unstable performance,
such that this very widely used model could provide misleading results in
misinformation detection. Finally, we validate new tools including approaches
to structured output and the latest version of GPT-4 (Turbo), showing they do
not compromise performance, thus unlocking them for future research and
potentially enabling more complex pipelines for misinformation mitigation.
|
[
-0.0707696825,
-0.7307876945,
0.5543720126,
0.2161151171,
-0.2625340819,
0.0244464744,
-0.4093630314,
-0.7167205215,
-0.1341279,
0.174382329,
-0.0916230455,
-0.476818651,
-0.7520660758,
0.1773926467,
-0.2262028158,
0.9377139807,
-0.0437634587,
0.0906860232,
0.1387615949,
0.0070226849,
-0.4425173402,
-0.5414889455,
-0.5662510395,
-0.1397193819,
0.5485608578,
0.3081984818,
0.8811714649,
0.3983916342,
0.5044845939,
0.1935019046,
-0.0255580414,
-0.1675417125,
-0.6408472657,
0.3262452483,
-0.12928617,
-0.4712501466,
-0.2068508714,
-0.0968140066,
0.6739395857,
0.2447439432,
-0.2767274082,
-0.0724974796,
-0.073851414,
0.4200824201,
-0.8213288188,
0.2894470394,
-0.9158771038,
-0.1827591807,
-0.6535221934,
-0.0022076031,
-0.2286295146,
-0.6265266538,
-0.0922271162,
-0.4510798156,
0.2984039485,
-0.0175366383,
0.8288118243,
0.2048266828,
-0.0067678154,
-0.362282306,
-0.968511045,
0.5446516871,
-1.1189017296,
0.6262474656,
0.1110007763,
0.539914608,
-0.0576848015,
-0.6461827755,
-0.6962398291,
-0.1456080675,
0.2199576348,
0.2557220459,
-0.6933326721,
-0.0583098419,
0.2932503521,
0.4158947468,
-0.6046119928,
0.3440491855,
-0.6378668547,
-0.6570486426,
-0.02075761,
-0.2407516539,
0.0961483866,
-0.1205559969,
-0.2230247259,
-0.0425493643,
-1.2186017036,
-0.3093780279,
0.7018614411,
0.2819333971,
0.2423920631,
0.5443518758,
-0.2682699263,
0.4691292048,
-0.0697493702,
-0.192803517,
0.3185682893,
-0.1050809696,
-0.2603889108,
0.3105065823,
0.8319478035,
0.5087253451,
0.077980265,
-0.326818049,
-0.35079512,
0.3932415545,
-0.1384903789,
-0.9617641568,
-0.2462233901,
0.0899495557,
-0.1790065467,
-0.1131540462,
0.0289178509,
-0.699303627,
-0.3243241012,
0.1753563434,
0.4459955096,
-0.4608573616,
-0.3980636299,
0.212702021,
-0.2641760707,
-0.1805184782,
0.5570848584,
-0.7049542665,
0.0165802706,
0.5992498398,
1.1237089634,
-0.0059010265,
-0.1190551892,
-0.5743002295,
0.3313606977,
-0.3919066191,
0.9657573104,
-0.6153849363,
-0.1355331689,
-0.0186440591,
-0.173063904,
0.0628494993,
-0.5539377928,
0.786864996,
-0.5910426974,
0.5511962771,
-0.3915776312,
-0.4153172374,
-0.2675636411,
0.1781372428,
-0.956210494,
0.926227808,
0.3970131576,
-1.1397451162,
0.4186688066,
-0.5682365894,
-0.0418279395,
0.2402679771,
-0.2360856384,
-0.5517809391,
0.0858872756,
0.2161355615,
0.125551343,
-0.4848048389,
0.0814694539,
-0.4116609991,
-0.4446325004,
-0.1518615484,
-0.6868466735,
0.4330122471,
0.3335229158,
-0.5063378215,
0.12830773,
-0.3116987646,
-0.1630056053,
0.0897560939,
-0.5660381317,
-0.2916822731,
-0.0384232998,
-0.3133678436,
0.284181118,
0.0782947689,
-0.6228206754,
-0.0112081943,
-0.3879597485,
0.3112605214,
0.553416729,
-0.1841006577,
0.1194390208,
-0.3374557197,
0.6577211618,
0.2325332016,
-0.0083078444,
-0.0407081172,
-0.7654720545,
-0.5957450271,
0.0469136089,
0.3211138844,
0.5607487559,
-0.8906142712,
0.0669046864,
-0.3732916713,
-0.651037693,
-0.6059558392,
0.126483798,
0.3279607594,
0.6694888473,
0.4171468914,
-0.0436354615,
-0.4418555498,
-0.9611608386,
-0.7613860369,
-0.3677434623,
-0.189654842,
-0.0617720522,
0.1176899523,
-0.051598385,
0.9124461412,
-0.2958159149,
-0.1169517785,
-0.4115003049,
0.0799414068,
0.1867869347,
0.1436340064,
0.8079214692,
-0.5547773838,
-0.4702787399,
0.1330335736,
-0.3428588212,
-0.2537530363,
0.2841033936,
0.3465921581,
0.4524103403,
0.1164992154,
-0.6947443485,
0.4096431434,
0.6660235524,
-0.1213777512,
0.6096661091,
-0.0697786734,
0.2827813923,
-0.7617656589,
0.0215671547,
0.1629780829,
-0.1814935654,
-0.8278700709,
-0.3298481107,
0.5040528774,
0.3185703456,
-0.6009748578,
0.2739622295,
-0.4942412972,
-0.0435588062,
-0.3566312492,
0.13182275,
-0.3036224246,
0.0292705279,
-0.0797934756,
1.076595068,
0.3643291891,
-0.3682893515,
0.2446089238,
-0.1408263892,
-0.486505568,
0.0547428578,
-0.6255013347,
0.0728518069,
-0.2270857096,
0.3402066231,
-0.6872506142,
-0.3103748858,
0.7986751795,
-0.5148125291,
0.0409061946,
-0.4516493976,
-0.7385087609,
-0.347959131,
-0.4765023291,
0.0497723073,
0.5293697119,
-0.3946221769,
0.3244712055,
0.1746385396,
-0.4272397757,
-0.5705872178,
-0.5882320404,
0.1264767796,
-0.4328557551,
-0.7688877583,
0.1871615797,
-0.1129974127,
-0.173782289,
-0.0221794154,
-0.4136025906,
0.1003806591,
-0.0001917044,
0.0335014574,
0.171378985,
-0.5949241519,
0.1585369259,
-0.0016342051,
0.0418221802,
-0.0330121368,
-0.2524019182,
0.3619232178,
-0.4751388133,
-0.4687325954,
0.1822377592,
0.0491197333,
0.492626816,
-0.0462361388,
0.760645926,
0.6079544425,
-0.4040097892,
-0.0266049653,
-0.8716781139,
0.0456565991,
-0.4255413711,
0.3852001727,
-0.0588127114,
-1.1161463261,
0.3955618441,
-0.0223831832,
0.0351522304,
0.7275821567,
0.5841007233,
0.4749596715,
0.7486719489,
0.5342826247,
-0.2436940223,
0.3526791334,
0.2122952044,
0.5283151865,
-0.4239951372,
-0.0691627935,
-0.7156317234,
-0.004146114,
-0.3568612635,
-0.4880411029,
0.4498996437,
0.4191444814,
-0.0395535007,
0.178515926,
-0.2075455934,
0.6109300852,
0.2989065349,
-0.2790726721,
0.5732317567,
0.095768407,
0.0581739172,
0.0229091085,
-0.9193766117,
-0.62045151,
0.9265317321,
0.5332092047,
0.7953379154,
0.6044982672,
0.2244247794,
0.0347821042,
0.681160152,
-0.3800565004,
0.1461220384,
-0.0080969045,
-0.6781287193,
-0.187531054,
-0.5587044954,
-0.6979880929,
0.6054093838,
-0.0084769232,
-0.6659387946,
-0.0555406623,
0.4059985876,
-0.2903618515,
0.6535543203,
-0.8756642342,
0.8643879294,
-0.1238330156,
-0.3396161199,
0.0894512907,
-0.4633712769,
0.5821620822,
-0.3602700233,
0.2675142884,
-0.2212931365,
-0.0827939212,
0.5629389882,
-0.1865853667,
0.779528141,
-0.3511475623,
-0.3313342631,
0.1593888253,
0.0083080288,
0.6142171025,
0.0104772653,
-0.1352596134,
0.4281547964,
-0.2927334607,
-0.054685235,
-0.3206299841,
0.9401660562,
-0.5653507113,
-0.7057198286,
-0.4514514804,
-0.4394690394,
-0.1847001016,
0.4612753987,
0.5389258265,
0.0699035451,
-0.0091662696,
0.2839981914,
0.4945754409,
-0.1393728554,
0.3947840035,
0.7347548604,
-0.2656004429,
-0.3399284482,
0.7310101986,
0.1607800424,
0.3579310477,
0.1404909045,
0.4554017186,
-0.3467710018,
-0.8943284154,
-0.507068336,
0.2817707956,
-1.0183757544,
-0.5074283481,
-0.6328642368,
-0.1585372388,
-0.5649314523,
0.3509606719,
-0.2565592527,
-0.487678498,
-0.0290752668,
-0.173693791,
0.42920807,
0.8592402339,
-0.039724607,
0.4499261677,
-0.9029061198,
0.1066362858,
-0.1428069621,
0.4815261066,
-0.1205189973,
-0.3873818815,
-0.2833514512,
0.1928340495,
-0.5156380534,
-1.1612882614,
0.3647423387,
-0.0043456499,
0.8512886763,
0.4539872408,
-0.1185656413,
0.4657233655,
-0.3270865977,
0.8607402444,
0.1914378405,
-0.8188136816,
0.394186914,
-0.4644108117,
0.2015428692,
0.2630252838,
0.6183279157,
-0.6146549582,
-0.6527826786,
-0.5488651991,
-0.7455809712,
0.5389002562,
0.426738292,
-0.3601174951,
-0.1460946947,
-0.0014170188,
0.3191346526,
0.3758130372,
-0.9518889785,
-0.0401892029,
-0.4599735737,
-0.0512842536,
-0.0899168998,
-0.236305967,
0.1618760973,
0.2084911168,
0.8362680674,
-0.0940381736,
-0.0918191597,
0.1212867796,
-0.3150891364,
-0.3131962419,
0.4646170735,
0.6729628444,
0.7138307095,
-0.2414966822,
0.1758262217,
-0.0954126492,
-0.6447013021,
-0.0972653702,
0.1674581319,
-0.3459609151,
0.2348415107,
0.3165275455,
0.7468046546,
0.1564097852,
-0.4320408702,
0.6624876261,
0.0122365719,
-0.2773213387,
-0.0306666698,
0.124235183,
0.321382761,
0.2093646973,
0.2265519947,
0.2596915066,
-0.0207710043,
-0.2992471457,
-0.3230755925,
0.2672656476,
-0.1446580142,
-0.5065709949,
0.6245015264,
0.1419980228,
0.0001562689,
0.4518912137,
-0.1130007803,
-0.5890265107,
0.2865069509,
0.5696974993,
0.7648118138,
-0.4756708443,
-0.1063370332,
0.2572574317,
0.7367149591,
-0.4561205506,
0.1382210851,
0.1043543816,
-0.7691918612,
-0.448925823,
-0.3085312843,
-0.3344016075,
0.5447944999,
-0.0588525049,
0.1353726536,
-0.2186927348,
-0.137599498,
-0.089234978,
-0.4052457511,
-0.5017338991,
-0.3164449632,
0.0549472496,
1.0153152943,
-0.8657999635,
0.9660962224,
0.4201941788,
-0.536172986,
-0.7690160275,
0.2959670424,
0.2346460819,
-0.4291464388,
0.5000457168,
0.2836982608,
-0.3465119004,
-0.2442327887,
-0.4178399742,
-0.8872749805,
1.2712268829,
0.6998019218,
-0.8672862053,
-0.0660833344,
0.103490822,
0.3383260965,
-0.075746201,
0.3050697446,
0.4893076122,
0.6606604457,
0.153039068,
-1.0918557644,
-0.0982293785,
-0.0408104099,
-0.0795428678,
0.332090199,
-0.4766237736,
1.055782795,
-0.0189397577,
-0.4689660072,
-0.136543721,
0.5490329862,
0.2231106758,
0.2992588282,
0.6584292054,
0.4684037268,
0.7657150626,
-0.1338814199,
0.8925673962,
-0.3138692975,
0.3489972353,
1.0457776785,
-0.3924925327,
0.7810074687,
0.3810727596,
-0.0906882137,
0.3231992126,
0.4955206811,
0.0604036339,
0.4264856875,
0.1386593133,
-0.3288736045,
-0.0729831606,
0.3515197635,
-0.6147824526,
0.0599672347,
0.4787127674,
-0.147273168,
-0.7000382543,
-0.3018517792,
0.1686782837,
-0.2537558079,
-0.221609652,
0.3759223819,
-0.1410960704,
-0.5974426866,
0.5545942783,
0.1494118273,
0.8678101897,
-0.8026830554,
0.0082658613,
-0.2419722676,
0.2373824716,
-0.1971187443,
-0.6578929424,
0.3065798283,
0.3302459717,
-0.1343086958,
0.1448730528,
1.138523221,
-0.4883955717,
-0.2882711887,
0.2592708766,
0.5415691137,
0.2567999661,
-0.4348157048,
-0.4193659127,
0.4578461051,
0.0999146402,
-0.0756915808,
0.1524858326,
0.4796022177,
-0.2158968598,
0.5737679005,
0.6885229349,
0.4405502677,
0.2481767982,
0.2177893966,
1.1010739803,
-0.5278916955,
-0.5300355554,
-0.7202165127,
0.1455368102,
-0.1157988682,
0.000177275,
1.1174464226,
0.6993940473,
1.0349795818,
-0.1125694513,
1.1995319128,
0.1149399579,
0.8242134452,
-0.6564230323,
0.6754860282,
-0.1151224226,
0.7069984078,
-0.3751159608,
-1.1580233574,
-0.3878900111,
0.322214216,
-0.39257285,
0.1753575653,
0.7243177891,
0.902705431,
-0.3016981483,
0.2214715183,
0.290807575,
0.4307917058,
0.7363296747,
0.4823554456,
0.9791094661,
-0.1841795743,
0.8839825392,
-0.1147707179,
-0.2111445367,
-0.3042757511,
-1.1460181475,
-0.6809660196,
-0.0915439203,
-0.1017060801,
-0.2844927907,
0.3861518502,
0.5061579347,
0.3258937597,
-0.5294081569,
0.1572003961,
0.0174044278,
-0.0561696701,
0.0779761076,
-0.1364307255,
0.1012445614,
-0.1275250912,
-0.430129528,
0.5794923902,
0.3675049245,
0.2199877352,
-0.2729335725,
-0.255951345,
0.1731196046,
0.0396386646,
0.3144282401,
0.3017180562,
-1.0221495628,
-0.418707341,
-0.2451319396,
0.0294602886,
0.2572178245,
0.7948494554,
-0.757627368,
0.2026334554,
0.4684124589,
0.54465729,
0.2213753313,
0.0074637937,
0.4843653738,
-0.414362222,
-0.0866044238,
0.3068239689,
0.3749494553,
0.5771266818,
-0.3801623881,
0.3423174322,
0.2422232479,
-0.5393280983,
-0.6383656263,
0.0790943429,
-0.7066262364,
-0.2903420627,
1.1994489431,
-0.0829218701,
-0.1015774012,
-0.1716285497,
-0.1969696283,
0.012427317,
-0.6697671413,
0.7259666324,
0.8946419954,
0.1109893322,
0.0016289075,
-0.7484055161,
0.4912748039,
0.2069341689,
-0.7790181637,
0.174003467,
0.7788173556,
0.6971476078,
0.1805870384,
0.6823842525,
-0.3263474405,
0.3502105772,
-0.0358992629,
-0.1127221808,
-0.2890428603,
-0.2612538636,
-0.4576461017,
0.1089335307,
0.2254279107,
0.1245383918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06915v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06915v2
|
DocFinQA: A Long-Context Financial Reasoning Dataset
| 2024-01-12T22:19:22 | 2024-02-29T19:55:14 |
Varshini Reddy, Rik Koncel-Kedziorski, Viet Dac Lai, Michael Krumdick, Charles Lovering, Chris Tanner
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
For large language models (LLMs) to be effective in the financial domain --
where each decision can have a significant impact -- it is necessary to
investigate realistic tasks and data. Financial professionals often interact
with documents that are hundreds of pages long, but most financial research
datasets only deal with short excerpts from these documents. To address this,
we introduce a long-document financial QA task. We augment 7,437 questions from
the existing FinQA dataset with the full-document context, extending the
average context length from under 700 words in FinQA to 123k words in DocFinQA.
We conduct extensive experiments over retrieval-based QA pipelines and
long-context language models. DocFinQA proves a significant challenge for even
state-of-the-art systems. We also provide a case-study on the longest documents
in DocFinQA and find that models particularly struggle on these documents.
Addressing these challenges may have a wide reaching impact across applications
where specificity and long-range contexts are critical, like gene sequences and
legal document contract analysis.
|
[
-0.2479976118,
-0.7133901119,
0.7951188087,
0.1828000098,
-0.311431706,
0.0777096823,
-0.0825118124,
-0.6383135319,
-0.1198882908,
0.8937786222,
-0.5094914436,
-0.4499766231,
-0.5714380741,
0.1011546701,
-0.7299240232,
0.9484162331,
-0.1958010495,
-0.1780608594,
-0.2659674585,
0.0971319601,
-0.1040028408,
-0.4496720433,
-0.9410148859,
-0.0826135352,
0.4596171677,
0.3639762402,
0.7191072702,
0.3171340227,
0.5210350156,
0.2741178274,
-0.0850460082,
0.0636792332,
-0.5414290428,
0.0752089992,
-0.2321870774,
-0.3578202128,
-0.5162568688,
0.2047009617,
0.6141514778,
0.6082767844,
-0.0786196962,
0.1592887938,
-0.3394847214,
0.7750547528,
-0.3887931705,
0.4205265939,
-0.0173521861,
-0.2492503524,
-0.3060079217,
0.010243291,
-0.1832233369,
-0.0776196197,
0.4818928838,
-0.8223675489,
-0.0633266494,
0.1982827485,
0.8548691273,
0.219696939,
-1.0694195032,
-0.4719159901,
-0.5968734026,
0.5811464787,
-0.6799979806,
0.5998476148,
0.6283448339,
0.2622996569,
-0.2701299489,
-1.0180311203,
-0.7014572024,
-0.0957041457,
0.0398713425,
0.1064526588,
-0.2390990108,
0.0619841702,
0.4776785374,
0.2687877417,
-0.2482925355,
0.0583044402,
-0.6672972441,
-0.1245928109,
0.7162284851,
0.0005645022,
-0.1838790774,
-0.2317243665,
-0.2843205035,
-0.3708391786,
-0.5555431843,
0.2072355598,
0.4352299273,
-0.0548171885,
0.0599786527,
0.5155377388,
-0.3500207663,
0.6736451387,
-0.0987478867,
-0.2817386985,
-0.0651152432,
-0.3362143934,
-0.3862609863,
-0.0753306225,
0.3796955645,
0.2784781158,
0.2304008752,
-0.0109355953,
-0.5829898119,
-0.572345078,
0.1840822548,
-0.4625465274,
0.2688552439,
0.7652205825,
-0.0785530359,
0.0737153068,
0.0680418536,
-0.6900091767,
-0.3531850576,
-0.605869472,
0.0864275172,
-0.3847572803,
0.1178800464,
0.4785048366,
-0.4722164273,
0.6512809992,
0.2857768536,
-0.577305913,
0.382268697,
1.2301620245,
0.3705402911,
0.1443015784,
-0.1127663478,
-0.6680648923,
0.2299716175,
-0.399621278,
0.8776418567,
-0.484995544,
-0.5640488267,
-0.0612227283,
0.0997467041,
-0.0942993611,
-0.3335646987,
0.7548829913,
-0.6439874768,
0.5269694924,
-0.301273644,
-0.8795307875,
-0.1252236366,
0.2312861383,
-0.736800611,
0.8392800093,
0.6625552773,
-0.693684876,
0.4252180457,
-0.8430421948,
-0.4226337969,
0.0766153783,
-0.1686680019,
-0.1449040323,
-0.2522271574,
0.0236201473,
0.472252667,
-0.7475710511,
0.484141171,
-0.1839469522,
-0.4267766774,
0.5092764497,
-0.4218394756,
0.4607261717,
0.1402805746,
-0.3841482997,
-0.0369040295,
-0.8034001589,
-0.3223012984,
0.0683995038,
-0.331030637,
-0.6186404824,
-0.2235307992,
0.2047084868,
0.2518400848,
0.4011145234,
-0.5254001021,
0.193385154,
-0.382692337,
0.7692935467,
0.7415662408,
-0.0661086366,
0.3120777011,
-0.5015103221,
0.6528334618,
-0.1116730124,
0.2950332165,
0.1006094366,
-0.1699441969,
-0.4537560642,
-0.3528670073,
0.5535361767,
0.5027921796,
-0.5113552213,
0.0511964522,
-0.4427942634,
-0.2268821597,
-0.2112555206,
0.2300735861,
0.2364795059,
0.6167807579,
0.1332342923,
-0.0485670306,
-0.1838545501,
-1.1943625212,
0.0837469399,
-0.1479127556,
-0.2054246664,
0.367292434,
0.7156425714,
-0.2471817285,
1.0404340029,
-0.6608040929,
-0.0652671382,
0.117191717,
-0.0140390163,
0.5358793736,
0.2261453122,
0.5294908881,
-1.2350295782,
0.0484754369,
-0.287876457,
-0.4116299152,
0.2095062286,
-0.5116767883,
-0.2834975123,
0.0124629745,
0.6556788683,
-0.7473450899,
0.1413054168,
0.2918069661,
-0.8688937426,
0.5421151519,
-0.2770788372,
0.0082377959,
-1.0686696768,
0.3803996444,
0.1944169998,
-0.2744283378,
-0.5042661428,
0.2579819858,
0.2504267097,
-0.0728278831,
-0.2735828161,
1.0779143572,
-0.15011397,
-0.2407875061,
-0.1413364857,
0.2579527795,
0.3986199796,
0.3128197789,
-0.0797052458,
1.0065612793,
0.21531187,
-0.3288729489,
0.5394871831,
0.5072986484,
-0.4614074826,
0.7807825208,
-0.6153882742,
-0.1324521005,
-0.0369987153,
0.6118110418,
-0.7498281002,
-0.2173007727,
0.1710360944,
0.0075259488,
0.3337002695,
0.1707497984,
-0.6123483777,
-0.498837173,
-0.2064355165,
0.4063286483,
0.1354608983,
-0.4248379469,
0.7941179872,
0.1677913368,
-0.5358239412,
-0.7921967506,
-0.2680654824,
0.4023241699,
-0.2868753076,
-0.8622211814,
0.2686563134,
-0.0266545638,
-0.5613399148,
-0.2854571044,
-0.2174528986,
-0.0747690946,
0.3393752575,
0.3826873899,
0.4196509421,
-0.2203564197,
0.3891930282,
0.1086405218,
-0.0420031697,
0.3104885221,
-0.4870471954,
0.1013191193,
-0.1304140091,
-0.1659232527,
0.068001315,
0.674756825,
0.7390746474,
-0.2373809963,
0.4895911515,
0.0663276836,
-0.3022496402,
-0.15928258,
-0.7098583579,
0.2699632347,
-0.4978933036,
0.0622479096,
-0.4647544324,
-1.115367651,
0.6416324973,
-0.1580937058,
0.2015993148,
0.861117661,
0.1662366837,
-0.2258287817,
0.2376828194,
0.6221267581,
-0.1599732488,
0.1974765062,
-0.380833745,
0.0903294533,
-0.637980938,
-0.2615450025,
-0.4906036258,
0.0543971509,
0.0227191783,
-0.6707620025,
0.2211521417,
0.0954333693,
-0.2654211223,
0.1418792456,
0.0472066402,
0.3602592945,
0.4791572094,
-0.0239749178,
0.2804549038,
-0.4395309985,
-0.27391994,
0.5588119626,
-0.3669714332,
-0.4510084987,
1.114330411,
0.6204078794,
0.433696717,
0.1364710629,
0.4478596449,
0.4218989313,
0.1959914267,
-0.7776103616,
0.2520845532,
-0.2609430552,
-0.5730908513,
-0.7293599248,
-0.5635746121,
-0.8685905337,
-0.2942043841,
0.0257144626,
-0.2376711071,
0.4332981408,
-0.4423111081,
-0.6728482842,
-0.1566462517,
-0.3609075844,
0.7479652762,
-0.2798379064,
-0.0706617683,
0.0503688417,
-0.5466595292,
0.5732859969,
-0.7842441201,
0.5534132123,
-0.0505498387,
-0.1690936536,
0.93938905,
-0.6565832496,
0.6022042036,
0.1659303159,
-0.9058670998,
0.2805624604,
-0.2973664701,
0.6926345229,
0.3562547565,
-0.1573396921,
-0.212535128,
0.6541489363,
-0.7942353487,
-0.5153818727,
0.3794344664,
-0.3736198545,
-0.7664397955,
-0.4696213305,
-0.3907026052,
-0.5598692298,
0.1622062027,
-0.1179823056,
0.463455528,
-0.2401973307,
0.1215273887,
0.6047105193,
-0.0998099744,
0.1920333952,
0.6206869483,
-0.0286357813,
-0.082810387,
0.5641623139,
0.0178035442,
0.0294478275,
0.2266044021,
-0.0012649072,
-0.6569704413,
-0.4752043486,
-0.2165910751,
0.4761454463,
-1.0122408867,
-0.0912335888,
-0.3375359476,
-0.1884557754,
-0.5469504595,
-0.1654362828,
-0.1443133056,
-0.4809958041,
-0.3625576496,
-0.2793881297,
0.5687821507,
0.6029421687,
0.0328659788,
-0.0029722247,
-1.1253927946,
0.5464520454,
0.625103116,
0.631133616,
-0.1571267545,
-0.4484346211,
-0.2747719884,
-0.0315895975,
0.3283428848,
-0.5556305051,
0.116780594,
0.112752296,
0.4825447202,
0.5688539147,
0.2173142284,
0.3367350698,
-0.0489428043,
0.512021184,
-0.0031787835,
-0.844540894,
0.0913906172,
-0.6203252673,
0.4099366069,
0.6535795927,
0.4619946778,
-0.8048666716,
-0.3569404483,
-0.577100575,
-0.9817513824,
0.1737882048,
0.1623006314,
0.1313382536,
-0.1603105217,
0.9306037426,
0.2137318701,
0.1271491349,
0.0232671387,
0.1156753525,
-0.1373419464,
-0.1971109658,
-0.2483117878,
-0.3866247237,
-0.4826387167,
-0.0421268456,
0.605106771,
-0.5216863751,
-0.154473573,
0.2961220443,
0.2242966741,
0.1526568532,
0.503788054,
0.7433008552,
1.1081764698,
-0.3197022676,
-0.2320242822,
-0.0197690651,
-0.4092983603,
0.0261151362,
0.5806191564,
0.1316529959,
-0.248937875,
0.3407573104,
0.5358145237,
0.5438379049,
-1.2628821135,
0.6133148074,
-0.3971614838,
-0.6637535095,
-0.7254083753,
-0.2365564406,
0.2799686491,
0.6560297608,
0.8570176959,
-0.5676414371,
0.1588027626,
-0.6419328451,
0.5372738242,
0.1296555102,
-0.2316299081,
0.2141922414,
0.4059993029,
0.220223248,
0.2952722907,
0.9374454021,
0.2057167888,
-0.487516582,
0.9639196992,
0.0622959696,
0.5505213141,
0.4590515792,
0.3148655295,
-0.1010585353,
-0.1092194691,
-0.5213662386,
0.5020776987,
0.0336382054,
-0.3510377407,
-0.5717143416,
-0.8757629991,
-0.6602786779,
0.0451587774,
-0.6791610718,
0.0047673583,
-0.5046132803,
-0.3439719379,
0.2366975546,
0.3029535413,
-0.633392334,
0.4613469839,
0.2239822149,
1.4191433191,
-0.3120269775,
0.7931729555,
0.1207161173,
-0.2276630104,
-0.662666738,
-0.3710533977,
-0.0262286048,
-0.5376042724,
0.7221287489,
-0.1437128633,
0.1194710433,
-0.2245472521,
-0.5866942406,
-0.8033427596,
1.2898402214,
0.1971609443,
-0.9053135514,
-0.5198072195,
0.259108454,
0.5409449935,
-0.3107970953,
-0.2814782262,
0.8640580773,
0.8468396664,
0.2668187618,
-0.8244889379,
0.1680860519,
-0.390109241,
-0.4229158759,
0.2348332554,
-0.7981497645,
0.7579658031,
-0.0336216055,
-0.1409134716,
0.0728991702,
0.7683129311,
0.265583992,
0.549551487,
0.4618225992,
0.3654708266,
1.0882138014,
-0.0243504662,
1.3489105701,
-0.4927381575,
0.1782426834,
1.1785187721,
-0.3552105427,
0.8823409677,
0.482229501,
-0.1186690554,
0.2565131783,
0.9315231442,
-0.2194383591,
-0.1319182217,
0.5494536757,
-0.2427479029,
-0.4965806603,
-0.0857016817,
-0.2487027496,
0.497092247,
0.4530406892,
-0.3169185519,
0.0111418189,
-0.0053816247,
-0.0352778137,
-0.047441747,
-0.1736902148,
0.5379844308,
0.5685107708,
-0.5968803167,
0.1412090212,
0.300570786,
0.4432687759,
-0.725546062,
0.0297666322,
-0.5217648149,
-0.2900224924,
0.1382560432,
-0.7186002135,
0.070761621,
-0.0414873809,
-0.2587996721,
-0.1690199077,
0.541619122,
-0.1349953115,
-0.5028452277,
0.2505461872,
0.4700312316,
-0.0806393102,
-0.3416418433,
-0.5236429572,
-0.6164433956,
-0.3494679332,
-0.4425868094,
0.5080103278,
0.452290833,
-0.237870872,
0.8373770714,
0.8256180882,
-0.1834733337,
-0.2267813832,
-0.1580092609,
0.9935984612,
-1.0109242201,
-0.6231267452,
-0.3155284226,
-0.0255514048,
-0.0667448342,
-0.512062788,
0.3670042157,
0.6362624764,
0.5373355746,
0.1754192263,
0.5807696581,
0.445738554,
0.4340910017,
-0.9177391529,
0.6629422307,
-0.6094130278,
0.342867583,
0.0087971026,
-0.6814379692,
-0.0088394713,
0.0992307663,
-0.3717164695,
-0.3323548436,
0.6634159088,
0.2205866724,
-0.0203750692,
0.2270919383,
0.1833241731,
0.0737029612,
0.2359849364,
0.6884683967,
0.6022208929,
-0.4173094928,
0.502497077,
-0.0371372849,
0.174434945,
-0.1157090366,
-0.7947362661,
-0.5704232454,
-0.732828021,
-0.2574952543,
-0.3575678766,
0.0207023993,
0.701390326,
0.1962283105,
-0.5390350819,
-0.2183659375,
0.599332273,
0.0976586267,
0.0110536683,
-0.1968072653,
0.551392138,
0.0396529213,
-0.5831086636,
0.5845523477,
0.3048340976,
0.3774592876,
-0.2906320691,
-0.0963322669,
-0.2122660279,
0.6048524976,
0.5158584714,
0.5189272165,
-0.3815601468,
-0.4498496652,
-0.0156269986,
-0.4502319694,
-0.2079836428,
0.9517252445,
-0.4363434613,
0.0788784027,
0.3901458681,
0.7143850923,
0.5571675301,
0.1495374739,
0.9791887403,
-0.3559868038,
-0.2102486491,
0.1534051299,
0.4565754831,
-0.0365225822,
-0.5420616269,
0.761099577,
-0.0266978554,
-0.3383575976,
-0.485034287,
-0.1826869398,
-1.2517569065,
-0.7564968467,
1.2513741255,
-0.3198033571,
-0.4665132761,
-0.3474082351,
-0.0615804456,
0.0123677179,
-0.5189271569,
0.72851789,
1.0976939201,
0.2858377993,
-0.1524120569,
-0.7019014955,
0.6618376374,
0.2203520238,
-0.8144981265,
0.1789136827,
0.6993892193,
0.3325850368,
0.0700654089,
0.8341135383,
0.0323712714,
0.5080465674,
0.0213820059,
-0.5373562574,
-0.2314262092,
-0.1214447096,
-0.2846245468,
0.3841083646,
-0.1172042117,
0.6806979775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06877v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06877v3
|
Promptly Predicting Structures: The Return of Inference
| 2024-01-12T20:08:39 | 2024-03-29T18:27:17 |
Maitrey Mehta, Valentina Pyatkin, Vivek Srikumar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Prompt-based methods have been used extensively across NLP to build zero- and
few-shot label predictors. Many NLP tasks are naturally structured: that is,
their outputs consist of multiple labels which constrain each other. Annotating
data for such tasks can be cumbersome. Can the promise of the prompt-based
paradigm be extended to such structured outputs? In this paper, we present a
framework for constructing zero- and few-shot linguistic structure predictors.
Our key insight is that we can use structural constraints -- and combinatorial
inference derived from them -- to filter out inconsistent structures predicted
by large language models. We instantiated this framework on two structured
prediction tasks, and five datasets. Across all cases, our results show that
enforcing consistency not only constructs structurally valid outputs, but also
improves performance over the unconstrained variants.
|
[
0.0754322633,
-0.6105285883,
0.6696532965,
0.4412840903,
0.2946773171,
-0.1198750362,
-0.0192862246,
-0.331571877,
0.2959267497,
0.4190062582,
-0.6413663626,
-0.5360094309,
-0.5408458114,
0.34484604,
-0.208480373,
1.0038530827,
0.0634074584,
-0.0868949667,
-0.1400869191,
0.1439261287,
-0.744622767,
-0.4280717373,
-0.2819852829,
-0.5190715194,
0.7000364065,
0.120179072,
0.8241579533,
1.1124140024,
-0.1009179577,
0.3389962018,
-0.2632047236,
0.0690035224,
-0.1880372912,
0.3691875339,
0.0039819633,
-0.4673298895,
-0.1095322818,
-0.0686960593,
0.7509551644,
1.2833091021,
-0.0983889773,
-0.2926365435,
0.2409429401,
0.295325011,
-0.4000441432,
0.4460650384,
-0.6604967117,
0.1149420366,
-0.2603785396,
-0.1374304742,
-0.8301610947,
-0.1039646417,
-0.1111668125,
-0.5992311239,
-0.0053282105,
0.2596875727,
0.7522722483,
0.4229932725,
-0.3021067977,
-0.2179414034,
-0.507538259,
0.6562914848,
-0.6128685474,
0.3835771382,
0.6337161064,
0.2344916314,
-0.7662548423,
-0.5450121164,
-0.1801266521,
-0.3257331848,
-0.4441386163,
-0.0060084816,
0.2418667823,
0.0888288766,
0.4230207801,
0.0295148659,
-0.5106866956,
0.3031985462,
-0.2257543951,
-0.2342273295,
0.3625222743,
0.1175993532,
0.3368569911,
-0.5283300281,
-0.1859630197,
0.1821928173,
-0.7192679644,
0.2079741955,
0.2770613432,
0.8053463101,
-0.191387102,
0.8763244152,
-0.4812293351,
0.6860259175,
0.2256433815,
-0.1259213686,
0.1412943602,
-0.3179287314,
-0.0947616845,
0.2978082299,
0.5675439835,
-0.0926916674,
0.1578129679,
-0.3112522662,
-0.1373964548,
0.2836420238,
0.0072262976,
-0.7020663023,
-0.4832457602,
0.5095146298,
-0.1701633781,
-0.1350241452,
-0.104574509,
-0.3729342222,
-0.3308440745,
-0.0121907918,
0.0573639162,
-0.4747710228,
0.2442624271,
0.2159626782,
-0.3282520771,
0.0474290103,
0.2888258696,
-0.9035929441,
0.1483629346,
0.7059544325,
0.9804065824,
-0.1248786002,
-0.3569783866,
-1.2705841064,
0.2642132044,
-0.4851614833,
0.8597576022,
-0.7061080933,
-0.1412170827,
0.0260572694,
0.0354404412,
0.0780410394,
-0.047290843,
0.5123031735,
-0.143513605,
0.4057191014,
-0.1934861541,
-0.7805188894,
0.1447061598,
0.3920895159,
-0.7251650095,
0.7695577145,
0.2190843374,
-0.6169157028,
0.3377079964,
-0.1075213924,
-0.3682054579,
0.3871922493,
-0.3298770785,
-0.3961859345,
0.0034943321,
0.2237957418,
0.2526845634,
0.1024612784,
0.6535869241,
-0.6394432783,
-0.2661853731,
0.0374406762,
-0.1522375643,
0.7913205028,
-0.0422382653,
-0.2326816469,
0.1530740261,
-1.0366667509,
0.0605133437,
-0.3175393045,
-0.4866294861,
-0.1578388214,
0.3251325488,
-0.3080140054,
0.1427796483,
-0.005086781,
-0.7392582893,
0.280975014,
-0.7539055943,
0.3328348696,
0.6803572178,
0.0619875379,
0.6152495146,
-0.3307714164,
0.621502161,
0.0735629871,
-0.255685091,
-0.614905715,
-0.579949379,
-0.1761829555,
-0.4004116356,
0.1846034676,
0.3512026072,
-0.8340826035,
0.4053107202,
-0.1339129955,
-0.4406734109,
-0.0238869898,
0.0118264984,
0.6402486563,
0.6587171555,
0.2589070797,
-0.1587434858,
-0.8467892408,
-0.7467447519,
-0.3139942884,
-0.3507284522,
-0.2825641334,
-0.0664404482,
0.3983906209,
0.0614653751,
0.9080828428,
-0.5166481733,
-0.1159673259,
-0.2851573527,
0.2187866867,
0.5856484771,
0.6955572963,
0.3409741223,
-0.5741705298,
-0.5403650403,
-0.1164072305,
-0.5808751583,
-0.2070174962,
-0.4145825505,
-0.0203415174,
0.0345569588,
0.3474587798,
-0.6863732934,
0.3115284145,
0.3726345301,
-0.4427298009,
0.76717484,
0.2778868079,
-0.2605343759,
-0.8908938169,
-0.2390119433,
-0.0039211111,
-0.2297398597,
-0.7036217451,
-0.4901541173,
-0.1890370548,
0.0140720569,
-0.2683960199,
0.8851115704,
-0.3190167546,
-0.1245370805,
-0.0409447402,
-0.1610360444,
0.2879176438,
0.5544207692,
0.3215803206,
0.483758837,
0.5137135386,
-0.5632191896,
-0.1750294119,
0.9055281281,
-0.2726706266,
0.5325032473,
-1.0440632105,
-0.2230776995,
-0.3419993818,
0.4760044217,
-1.1961129904,
-0.5836769342,
0.4009786844,
-0.6916822195,
0.1747775823,
-0.5128570199,
-0.2203773558,
-0.321611166,
-0.4808835089,
-0.0208204854,
0.1069722101,
-0.5479112864,
0.6195172071,
-0.0741701946,
-0.2894361913,
-0.6549271345,
-0.738460958,
-0.0218037181,
0.0749835372,
-0.4466644526,
0.4322912395,
-0.2270645052,
-0.1117031798,
0.0850743204,
-0.2819135487,
-0.2176648378,
0.2729937434,
0.7310828567,
0.3927135766,
-0.3671310842,
0.1135462373,
-0.0144318631,
0.0484859571,
-0.089194946,
-0.4704507887,
0.381721586,
-0.0521427132,
-0.2527129948,
-0.2468730211,
0.3986704051,
0.1903603077,
-0.1824391782,
0.700861156,
0.2523434162,
-0.4187930524,
-0.3578826487,
-0.2557488084,
-0.1859256327,
-0.4751676321,
0.3477678001,
-0.6829306483,
-0.8440871835,
0.4699220061,
0.1580439657,
0.2373445034,
0.4135023952,
0.4598530829,
-0.1893338114,
1.0888133049,
0.6161057353,
0.2912432551,
0.4515934885,
0.2389586866,
0.0902153999,
-0.5199009776,
-0.3351329267,
-0.7591899037,
-0.1814779341,
-0.560890615,
-0.0353946649,
0.1903504729,
0.4425953329,
-0.0977085605,
0.6961880922,
-0.5733021498,
0.3639838099,
0.7571626902,
-0.222743541,
0.1410429329,
-0.0956721827,
-0.1792677641,
0.0622285791,
-0.849145472,
-0.568307519,
0.7947600484,
0.1726095974,
0.4989159703,
-0.1638075709,
0.7503888011,
0.1470234543,
0.2569226325,
-0.8041285276,
0.2801346183,
0.0075396723,
-0.7024517655,
-0.3411444426,
-0.439139843,
-0.972825408,
0.1333842874,
-0.1097949892,
-0.9019027948,
0.4352306724,
0.2644727528,
-0.5483595729,
-0.0395277776,
-0.5991526842,
0.8412847519,
0.052612979,
-0.2867311239,
0.4754299521,
-0.7610900402,
0.3650999665,
0.1078440472,
-0.0761509389,
-0.2838824689,
0.2360706329,
0.4857114553,
-0.4949208498,
1.2444571257,
-0.0259493329,
0.1649880856,
0.3773252666,
0.0712583885,
0.5901832581,
-0.0421043932,
-0.3119191229,
-0.0959970504,
0.1979949176,
-0.4218879938,
-0.6625636816,
0.457570672,
-0.4028753042,
-0.4388788044,
-0.3312603533,
-0.7559446692,
-0.3886350989,
0.208081916,
0.2519738674,
0.7571014762,
-0.0318545289,
0.1896766126,
0.3156725168,
-0.0558991842,
0.6799212694,
0.314573288,
0.063954778,
-0.4789870679,
0.5000519156,
0.2213862836,
-0.0934165567,
0.534057796,
0.3802950382,
-0.4472483695,
-0.5261739492,
-0.4749060273,
0.0163686816,
-0.4527141452,
-0.3774826229,
-0.6376094222,
-0.1603271067,
-0.6151031852,
-0.4152855575,
-0.2827553451,
-0.7004687786,
-0.0287431888,
-0.2696443498,
0.0141796703,
0.7171502709,
-0.0401099697,
0.4626795053,
-0.781288445,
0.2115669996,
-0.0437731184,
0.3366777599,
-0.3101764023,
-0.3613421321,
-0.1165617257,
-0.0863102674,
-0.1514426023,
-0.8862918019,
0.2823861837,
0.4144977927,
0.4387255311,
0.2495329976,
0.2029369771,
0.3758878112,
-0.8395866156,
0.6439172029,
0.3088587821,
-0.8282688856,
0.6507211924,
-0.3403999507,
0.3636621535,
0.4301897287,
0.4031357467,
-0.462174058,
-0.4200514555,
-0.5498287082,
-0.5722586513,
0.6380719543,
0.1965685934,
-0.098035872,
-0.6145758033,
0.4673624337,
0.2275578976,
0.3878820837,
-0.8626285195,
-0.0282435976,
-0.2083887309,
-0.2138257772,
0.1283834875,
-0.4806055129,
0.0711503923,
0.0523880795,
0.5199549198,
-0.3278172612,
-0.3085123897,
0.2313790023,
0.0187342372,
-0.0036696861,
0.41444242,
0.401221633,
0.4666789472,
-0.1484429836,
0.2200915515,
-0.3186714053,
0.0436155386,
0.2447350323,
0.1325487047,
-0.7679253221,
0.3607498407,
0.5943135023,
0.8193271756,
0.2968669534,
-0.631967485,
0.2720808089,
0.5645778179,
-0.0291840415,
-0.1342367083,
-0.0563386157,
-0.0414149463,
0.2820245326,
0.0287374891,
0.0536324531,
0.1857645214,
-0.6612744927,
0.6313445568,
0.4555974007,
-0.3738928437,
-0.611403048,
0.9477286935,
0.0025295527,
-0.266022265,
0.4041449428,
-0.3011474907,
-0.5268337131,
0.5374893546,
0.6873705387,
0.7151423693,
-0.2562033832,
0.5058177114,
0.5810979605,
0.2154258192,
-0.3909642696,
0.3664251268,
-0.0578198545,
-0.7174193859,
-0.7855170965,
-0.9044539928,
-0.4127238691,
-0.288833946,
-0.4967340231,
0.2391939759,
-0.534661293,
-0.0518492423,
0.2555451691,
0.0219201632,
-0.2478657514,
0.1697700173,
0.3095372617,
0.7852479815,
-0.8739134073,
0.7745832205,
0.5763604045,
-0.4982100427,
-0.8403885365,
-0.4346772134,
0.2922936082,
-0.4973987043,
0.6440028548,
0.4813396335,
-0.0861023441,
-0.3166872263,
-0.5109335184,
-0.9986292124,
0.6235541701,
0.5124161839,
-0.6342280507,
-0.461458683,
0.0507686138,
0.4392596185,
-0.5169757009,
0.0151172495,
0.4413514137,
0.6482644677,
0.3988618255,
-0.5763401389,
-0.0220030211,
-0.2003722489,
0.0367273316,
0.1110066995,
0.0918309614,
0.7717713714,
-0.2822180688,
-0.3924542665,
0.4033284783,
0.9838894606,
0.4946212769,
0.3660280406,
0.3754069507,
0.4018639922,
0.9076706767,
-0.0979974791,
1.1902873516,
-0.139781177,
-0.0432341136,
1.8353437185,
-0.2496875674,
0.9336503744,
0.4025940299,
-0.0694044232,
0.6322853565,
0.6932774186,
-0.3387663364,
0.4004454017,
0.1004104093,
0.2728984654,
-0.235320881,
-0.6978732347,
-0.0564047433,
0.4934016168,
0.2280625254,
-0.0542443879,
-0.285320878,
-0.3927895427,
0.0488859452,
0.313016206,
-0.2204890996,
0.4492750466,
0.0375532955,
-0.7934628725,
0.4033302963,
-0.1249919459,
0.5402396321,
-0.6513777971,
-0.0262722839,
-0.1707454473,
-0.1735445112,
-0.254001081,
-0.6400449872,
0.5533381701,
-0.3823486567,
-0.3392169476,
-0.3535513282,
0.6257838607,
-0.8527447581,
-0.4039359391,
-0.0247329213,
0.5388290882,
0.0232902989,
-0.1654028594,
-0.2421351522,
-0.0566184558,
-0.0200411659,
-0.3382500112,
0.1120713502,
0.4122682214,
-0.1084983274,
0.4361488521,
0.4931825697,
0.1985285729,
0.2483126819,
-0.0621459037,
0.624766469,
-0.4401300848,
-0.47742185,
-0.8469924927,
0.5387570262,
-0.0772072822,
-0.3716812134,
0.7183926105,
0.5729527473,
0.6143944263,
0.0566933751,
0.4196923077,
0.0527246855,
0.3866229653,
-0.4611287713,
0.2769213021,
-0.3033988774,
0.1522325873,
0.0006648746,
-0.982934773,
-0.4621057808,
0.2583289146,
-0.1611886173,
-0.2553214431,
0.703506887,
0.5881309509,
0.2221362144,
-0.1609462053,
0.4127117693,
0.4286666214,
0.3370037079,
0.4150666296,
0.6104047298,
-0.1405905783,
0.4537526369,
-0.389490664,
0.1030996293,
0.0510080829,
-1.0158896446,
-0.8801998496,
-0.530104816,
-0.6267856956,
-0.4081826806,
-0.1218060032,
0.749058485,
0.7479057908,
-1.0513167381,
0.0615947098,
-0.2181777507,
0.3023279011,
-0.2566040456,
-0.1795035005,
0.289290607,
-0.6562011838,
-0.7340557575,
0.9078297615,
0.7332613468,
0.0755246058,
0.1074938178,
0.0109063741,
-0.1320624053,
0.1810724437,
0.60952878,
0.615688622,
-0.8467280865,
-0.5132610798,
-0.0461950861,
-0.151575163,
0.192342028,
0.5017984509,
-0.9422805309,
0.1891893595,
0.5952438712,
0.849367559,
0.0673220679,
0.1662856042,
0.9020960331,
-1.2391935587,
0.0488427952,
0.3136355877,
0.6476801038,
0.3923152387,
-0.3792690039,
0.6771430373,
0.0907266513,
-0.0705121607,
-0.9420588613,
0.5822309256,
-0.9033555388,
-0.3349629939,
0.9869667888,
-0.3855386376,
-0.4511038661,
-0.2042323947,
0.2842262387,
0.0119408676,
-0.2348976284,
0.5852079391,
0.6588975787,
0.033139579,
0.0196520593,
-0.247093603,
0.494864881,
0.5731160045,
-0.7796236277,
0.0293732863,
0.8598019481,
0.0611397959,
0.3714036047,
0.578635335,
0.1505085528,
0.0641513094,
0.127836898,
-0.1453309953,
-0.2249101698,
-0.8264451623,
-0.1671552956,
0.5421566367,
-0.0588589311,
-0.1523239315
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06866v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06866v2
|
Health-LLM: Large Language Models for Health Prediction via Wearable Sensor Data
| 2024-01-12T19:40:11 | 2024-04-27T06:20:26 |
Yubin Kim, Xuhai Xu, Daniel McDuff, Cynthia Breazeal, Hae Won Park
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) are capable of many natural language tasks, yet
they are far from perfect. In health applications, grounding and interpreting
domain-specific and non-linguistic data is crucial. This paper investigates the
capacity of LLMs to make inferences about health based on contextual
information (e.g. user demographics, health knowledge) and physiological data
(e.g. resting heart rate, sleep minutes). We present a comprehensive evaluation
of 12 state-of-the-art LLMs with prompting and fine-tuning techniques on four
public health datasets (PMData, LifeSnaps, GLOBEM and AW_FB). Our experiments
cover 10 consumer health prediction tasks in mental health, activity,
metabolic, and sleep assessment. Our fine-tuned model, HealthAlpaca exhibits
comparable performance to much larger models (GPT-3.5, GPT-4 and Gemini-Pro),
achieving the best performance in 8 out of 10 tasks. Ablation studies highlight
the effectiveness of context enhancement strategies. Notably, we observe that
our context enhancement can yield up to 23.8% improvement in performance. While
constructing contextually rich prompts (combining user context, health
knowledge and temporal information) exhibits synergistic improvement, the
inclusion of health knowledge context in prompts significantly enhances overall
performance.
|
[
0.0009741795,
-0.8380486965,
0.8176449537,
0.0729234219,
-0.2580138445,
-0.0645830184,
-0.4498977661,
-0.86083287,
0.3906815946,
0.4593892992,
-0.7080472112,
-0.700825274,
-0.3631123006,
-0.0375864767,
0.1119775251,
0.7987082601,
0.1321968138,
0.157022208,
-0.1975424737,
0.0627947524,
-0.7615444064,
-0.4118716121,
-0.2989646196,
-0.6091285348,
0.561176002,
0.4317990541,
0.4940106571,
0.3203463554,
0.1759358197,
0.1034276187,
-0.2317456752,
0.320106715,
-0.3596384227,
0.3064165413,
-0.1474410743,
-0.2662746012,
-0.5575459599,
-0.2049282491,
0.3190906346,
0.7028905749,
0.0051980172,
0.3578444123,
0.0989220217,
0.6568367481,
-0.5292566419,
0.1461724639,
-0.2447174788,
-0.0816331208,
-0.1041578948,
-0.3846453726,
-0.23128739,
0.1368479729,
0.3554562628,
-0.3257171512,
-0.1839125454,
0.1669436693,
0.3187963963,
0.6277105212,
-0.5229350924,
-0.1756308824,
-0.7179887295,
0.6815462708,
-0.8071655035,
0.7131828666,
0.653808713,
-0.0466527268,
-0.2137688994,
-0.4166955352,
-0.2009430379,
-0.1524005234,
-0.1630413979,
0.3075348437,
-0.1810968369,
-0.0153085496,
0.1708393246,
0.2234720737,
-0.5190523863,
0.2232250124,
-0.0618817508,
-0.085530363,
0.666097939,
0.1922139525,
0.2673143446,
-0.4910602272,
-0.2455577105,
0.2410651892,
-0.7641077042,
0.0836181343,
-0.3442493975,
0.3076789379,
-0.6856604218,
0.6187125444,
-0.5323505402,
0.8393653035,
0.0479306243,
-0.7544859648,
0.4318448901,
-0.2403437495,
-0.3552722037,
0.1136740744,
0.4061320722,
0.6073687077,
-0.2273994386,
-0.4259532392,
-0.0876145586,
-0.0321229883,
0.1085193157,
-0.7020705938,
-0.04175869,
0.5885449648,
-0.3823877573,
-0.0103501556,
-0.2426650226,
-0.7296019197,
-0.6907712221,
-0.591876328,
0.2084480971,
-0.3254495561,
-0.0214102734,
0.494376719,
0.1810034662,
-0.0864908174,
0.1844870895,
-0.763890624,
0.0642955974,
0.5667970181,
0.8040204048,
-0.4159803689,
0.0337926,
-0.1021787077,
0.3792168796,
0.0095414286,
0.7995665073,
-0.3342713118,
-0.4548643827,
-0.1535140723,
0.1200419664,
-0.235585615,
-0.663648665,
0.7288390994,
-0.3484086096,
0.0129328687,
-0.5009514689,
-0.4510932863,
-0.0152289672,
0.3116065264,
-0.511157155,
0.752369225,
0.0533567593,
-0.7351204753,
0.5285927653,
-0.6771205664,
-0.9731121063,
0.0750928223,
0.1586471796,
-0.397918582,
0.0365605801,
0.4820645452,
0.8394854069,
-0.417709291,
0.3706703782,
-0.3236303031,
-0.2582392097,
0.4741693735,
-0.2283362746,
0.2805278599,
0.2476388067,
-0.4968147874,
0.3270579278,
-0.6880403161,
-0.2066013962,
-0.0536376312,
-0.3970564306,
-0.161566779,
0.236826852,
0.0568990856,
0.0457829833,
0.268753171,
-0.4290225804,
-0.1746611595,
-0.4673002958,
0.7103379369,
0.4549053609,
0.2346385866,
0.2672178745,
-0.7842450738,
0.4225760698,
-0.2803709507,
0.2841660976,
-0.16397205,
-0.5049832463,
-0.0831705779,
-0.5742253661,
-0.081015341,
0.6114900112,
-0.3557499647,
0.5882986784,
-0.508752048,
-0.5466186404,
-0.0018129463,
0.0024656621,
0.1929879189,
0.9638826847,
0.440137893,
0.0295289345,
-0.5109013319,
-0.3221428096,
-0.2534545362,
-0.0422852337,
-0.1588703245,
0.7766728997,
0.0269949157,
-0.8476124406,
0.6852784753,
-0.4972507656,
-0.0154692568,
-0.2270105481,
-0.1933120787,
0.4040759504,
0.3263827562,
0.2558028996,
-0.5675276518,
-0.0349015668,
-0.1019431874,
-0.7282966971,
-0.2620231211,
0.2387693971,
0.0063610887,
-0.0650375411,
0.2161833048,
-0.4508109987,
0.2945360541,
0.7714417577,
-0.3836117685,
0.547480464,
-0.0635556132,
0.0930617377,
-1.0902420282,
0.1958153546,
0.0224755146,
-0.3371306062,
-0.8577280641,
-0.0698803365,
-0.1372764111,
-0.2049610317,
-0.4938768446,
1.0610892773,
-0.3324452639,
0.0015970232,
-0.5040008426,
-0.2945368886,
-0.0620313138,
0.0117166061,
0.1379436553,
0.5570434928,
0.3991579413,
-0.7182379365,
0.2403784692,
0.1144264266,
-0.5929960012,
0.4309032559,
-0.7208103538,
0.0174260363,
-0.1101656258,
0.466222018,
-0.7247982621,
-0.8110442758,
0.1412592679,
-0.282433629,
0.0174648482,
0.2255274057,
-0.5866153836,
-0.4598231912,
-0.0496935919,
0.4901197851,
0.5785575509,
-0.5321676135,
0.4988815188,
0.6859938502,
-0.0618776828,
-0.1635279655,
-0.7062141895,
-0.1240099296,
-0.4310759306,
-0.593703568,
0.3556250632,
-0.1656680107,
-0.1128330529,
-0.1647168547,
-0.209924221,
0.2647357583,
0.264484942,
0.6118869781,
0.3716739118,
0.0319932178,
0.4842221439,
-0.0296644699,
-0.1106451899,
0.0034906333,
-0.3916409612,
0.5374335051,
0.1815244853,
-0.3161163926,
-0.559871912,
0.0268463753,
0.530064106,
-0.051864773,
0.692510128,
0.4267402887,
-0.7396932244,
0.1145027652,
-0.5853149295,
-0.3444414735,
-0.4097507894,
0.0329460129,
-0.089893207,
-1.0810449123,
0.4383656085,
-0.2885962725,
-0.1767307967,
0.0631108209,
0.8295202255,
-0.130260855,
0.8624866009,
0.2543022335,
-0.3324424624,
0.436959058,
0.1012677029,
0.1380320638,
-0.9472048283,
-0.4648970962,
-0.2233004868,
-0.4162141979,
-0.4262817502,
-0.5682159662,
0.8979676366,
-0.1244667396,
-0.358987838,
-0.0222045481,
-0.4749830961,
0.0337578952,
0.2536109984,
0.9338414669,
0.2083136737,
-0.1030577198,
-0.0278325863,
0.0616943687,
-0.5840516686,
-0.3586152792,
0.9769228697,
0.3418735266,
1.0877577066,
0.0487869009,
0.3056782782,
0.1055334508,
0.3279442191,
-0.8989213705,
0.1135911793,
-0.1144290566,
-0.5798155665,
-0.2946757972,
-0.2304386497,
-1.0627127886,
-0.1125799716,
-0.5084958076,
-0.9473484159,
0.1386901736,
0.3531655967,
-0.6805898547,
-0.0068244152,
-0.6177665591,
0.541051209,
-0.5151469111,
-0.5075794458,
-0.0959732905,
-0.6252655983,
0.1838443726,
-0.1289218515,
0.5100280643,
-0.5978364348,
-0.0530898422,
0.603218317,
-0.0715698227,
1.0386278629,
0.041048944,
-0.1034125909,
-0.049437765,
-0.4097117186,
0.3518976569,
0.2697164416,
-0.4342164993,
0.1764180958,
0.0621488392,
-0.3691900969,
-0.4369881153,
0.7332485914,
-0.5530395508,
-0.3657722473,
-0.1893625557,
-0.4676394463,
-0.8166675568,
0.3488501012,
0.2965121269,
0.5861249566,
-0.2326387167,
0.1202225089,
0.6269426346,
-0.3958514631,
-0.0237504356,
0.4684940577,
0.0921871215,
-0.3546271622,
0.5390925407,
-0.1566225141,
0.0266872719,
0.6210973859,
0.7293362617,
-0.4386081398,
-0.3577739894,
-0.186438337,
0.3383336663,
-0.5157305002,
-0.3040322959,
-0.6531396508,
0.0723501891,
-0.5659675598,
-0.2503378391,
-0.0623613335,
0.1469900161,
-0.5036914945,
-0.2580879033,
0.4454459548,
0.7476633191,
-0.1786198616,
0.3518773317,
-0.8105950356,
0.4650066197,
0.3339881003,
0.3276359439,
0.0055063879,
-0.2022419274,
-0.3153351247,
0.113527298,
0.0717438906,
-0.9114354849,
0.2749232054,
-0.0672959685,
0.533588469,
0.3744092286,
0.1331792325,
0.6051707268,
-0.5006799698,
0.7211409807,
0.2234396935,
-0.7887601256,
0.6363866329,
-0.427418977,
0.5461163521,
0.4698488414,
0.1371866763,
-0.7291610241,
0.1711926162,
-0.3184521198,
-0.7699190974,
0.2596071959,
-0.2366182506,
0.0514694229,
-0.0613218211,
0.4868533611,
-0.0112622986,
0.1628898531,
-0.3373486102,
-0.1025750935,
-0.0867607147,
-0.3282589912,
-0.2573930025,
-0.3127653003,
-0.2398599833,
-0.3431514502,
0.4420314431,
-0.3563767076,
0.339559257,
0.4092308879,
-0.0303286389,
-0.2301222384,
0.3144199252,
0.754548192,
0.8646945357,
-0.187970534,
0.2764308751,
0.2685823441,
-0.2769474983,
-0.006606597,
0.0007350347,
-0.1156778708,
-0.1937964261,
0.6533285975,
0.8845436573,
0.6341013908,
-1.0512952805,
0.2354784906,
0.0646140501,
0.3270302415,
-0.083502315,
0.0684595257,
0.2679915726,
0.2388320565,
0.0617530383,
-0.2120096982,
0.2626537681,
-0.6464698911,
0.212016046,
0.4577705562,
-0.3648857772,
-0.5060063004,
0.8734534383,
0.2533833086,
0.1243005618,
0.0501986519,
0.2266087234,
-0.3655390143,
0.3010953069,
0.598518312,
0.3642316461,
-0.4275291562,
0.068420738,
0.4255549908,
0.0885417461,
-0.1412256509,
0.3705551326,
-0.0311254188,
-0.798661828,
-0.6107785702,
-0.60808599,
-0.4935193658,
0.2736976743,
-0.6664233208,
0.1623965204,
-0.2366448045,
-0.3434616029,
0.0349724106,
0.1432138532,
-0.8649668694,
0.5766358376,
0.3458460867,
0.7832707763,
-0.7491345406,
0.6767777205,
0.7134903073,
0.2616991699,
-0.7710488439,
0.319388181,
0.1864157617,
-1.0337166786,
0.3524573743,
0.2330006063,
-0.0405185372,
-0.3800554872,
-0.4582017958,
-0.9157654047,
1.0630807877,
0.6121079922,
-0.5842910409,
0.057478413,
0.1643445194,
0.4664649367,
-0.2261137813,
-0.0517199486,
0.7164596319,
0.6364400983,
0.0818521604,
-1.0054700375,
0.2941659391,
0.1407342404,
-0.1030662879,
-0.2371453643,
-0.6033118367,
0.4450264573,
-0.319106847,
-0.2711383998,
0.0815157667,
0.4209749997,
0.5201758742,
0.6326377988,
0.4362499416,
0.5294341445,
1.1146500111,
0.1510020494,
1.2470097542,
-0.6121182442,
0.2257037163,
1.1246129274,
-0.4759426415,
0.6938506365,
0.1481147707,
-0.0308363643,
0.3748893738,
0.9189139605,
0.4779803157,
0.6074844003,
0.0724537745,
-0.4934172034,
-0.1413158327,
-0.3907625079,
-0.3424934745,
0.3596540391,
0.6707713008,
-0.3254500628,
0.0990687981,
0.2827810049,
0.1726332754,
-0.1748681515,
-0.2285894305,
0.8560265303,
0.20868285,
-0.5634801388,
0.5158085227,
-0.0383123159,
0.648144424,
-0.3538793325,
0.1499581933,
0.0875059292,
-0.1642545611,
-0.3658417761,
-0.5196823478,
0.3211193085,
-0.1799766421,
-0.4611467421,
-0.1613743156,
1.1365069151,
-0.1512272954,
-0.4278410971,
0.4324879348,
0.5905596614,
0.0710797012,
-0.1676718891,
-0.448321104,
0.1083616987,
-0.3110919595,
-0.2100224793,
0.1197011247,
0.066514045,
0.0499094203,
0.6003421545,
0.8354908824,
0.3706173301,
-0.1619043946,
-0.1029205173,
0.677359283,
-0.7257753015,
-0.472677201,
-0.6871058941,
0.2007479221,
0.1892771274,
-0.1265397668,
0.46818766,
0.2879531085,
0.3825998306,
0.061552126,
0.898029685,
0.171275124,
0.9197140932,
-0.7538106441,
0.687866509,
-0.5444610715,
0.117834352,
0.0929094255,
-0.486189425,
-0.3595663011,
0.3600675166,
-0.5701171756,
-0.0308381524,
0.5033665299,
0.3901455402,
0.0710530505,
-0.0512026958,
0.3755818009,
0.0874197856,
0.1830096841,
0.4385090768,
0.4577613771,
0.0682162195,
-0.433961004,
-0.2677437365,
-0.2908128798,
-0.4713085592,
-0.9740589857,
-0.7267091274,
-0.3145370483,
-0.0102971662,
-0.2460451573,
0.0789902732,
0.9525249004,
1.23609972,
-0.7282668948,
0.119873412,
0.1819603294,
0.1164772063,
-0.1315100342,
-0.1269821525,
0.312743187,
0.021822758,
-0.39374125,
0.8857270479,
0.3191550374,
-0.0529499874,
-0.0367581658,
-0.0814748257,
0.3767853379,
0.0729546845,
0.8058202267,
0.3201756179,
-0.7942278385,
-0.3160807192,
0.084247604,
0.0191181824,
0.014249593,
0.7752498388,
-0.7773096561,
0.3837813139,
0.3897014856,
0.6644383669,
0.2903392613,
0.2913645208,
0.3103104532,
-0.653654933,
0.1731548309,
0.2713268101,
0.5833953619,
0.5479764938,
-0.7008088827,
0.4872531593,
0.12807329,
-0.6572353244,
-0.501603663,
0.1414652914,
-1.1434760094,
-0.3837833107,
1.5157313347,
0.1350180209,
-0.3561809361,
-0.1018801257,
-0.0269726086,
0.257211715,
-0.3861805797,
0.6004751921,
0.3499160111,
-0.5175583959,
0.0534044281,
-0.7630501986,
0.4245061874,
0.370889008,
-1.1418020725,
-0.0446081124,
0.4772974253,
0.5450347066,
0.0077304724,
0.7892205119,
0.0641657412,
0.1755764782,
-0.7255565524,
-0.1566440165,
0.188588053,
-0.0417676605,
-0.2675796449,
-0.1684490889,
-0.0205452479,
0.063587971
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06855v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06855v3
|
Fine-grained Hallucination Detection and Editing for Language Models
| 2024-01-12T19:02:48 | 2024-02-21T22:20:12 |
Abhika Mishra, Akari Asai, Vidhisha Balachandran, Yizhong Wang, Graham Neubig, Yulia Tsvetkov, Hannaneh Hajishirzi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LMs) are prone to generate factual errors, which are
often called hallucinations. In this paper, we introduce a comprehensive
taxonomy of hallucinations and argue that hallucinations manifest in diverse
forms, each requiring varying degrees of careful assessments to verify
factuality. We propose a novel task of automatic fine-grained hallucination
detection and construct a new evaluation benchmark, FavaBench, that includes
about one thousand fine-grained human judgments on three LM outputs across
various domains. Our analysis reveals that ChatGPT and Llama2-Chat (70B, 7B)
exhibit diverse types of hallucinations in the majority of their outputs in
information-seeking scenarios. We train FAVA, a retrieval-augmented LM by
carefully creating synthetic data to detect and correct fine-grained
hallucinations. On our benchmark, our automatic and human evaluations show that
FAVA significantly outperforms ChatGPT and GPT-4 on fine-grained hallucination
detection, and edits suggested by FAVA improve the factuality of LM-generated
text.
|
[
-0.4110747278,
-1.1869786978,
0.7314290404,
0.1069333926,
0.0802823678,
-0.1902987659,
-0.4137688279,
-0.461877346,
0.2510542572,
0.6716965437,
-0.1950497478,
-0.6517385244,
-0.5571737289,
0.1616345197,
-0.7652103901,
0.8078488111,
-0.0762708262,
-0.0621358603,
-0.1088876724,
-0.043222405,
-0.4894975126,
-0.6391854286,
-0.4063369334,
-0.2076669037,
0.2935723364,
0.2775724232,
1.0711221695,
0.3899439871,
0.3294821084,
0.3118097484,
0.0834728181,
0.6645774841,
-0.4032377601,
0.0511187874,
-0.2866131663,
-0.3785883784,
-0.5515969992,
-0.1324098259,
0.2701159418,
0.5033932924,
-0.2315587252,
-0.1061410159,
0.0408828147,
0.6242024899,
-0.6287381649,
0.1314061433,
-0.9120494723,
0.1021668017,
-0.1502448171,
-0.2996230721,
-0.6175915599,
-0.4272759557,
-0.1793453246,
-0.2478543073,
0.524561882,
0.1197340339,
0.864297092,
0.6097118855,
0.0501866117,
-0.6819321513,
-0.7322270274,
0.3509818017,
-0.4811505675,
0.7296949029,
0.6030038595,
0.38528198,
-0.5082226396,
-0.522138238,
-0.735497117,
-0.5201513767,
-0.1721074283,
-0.4160232544,
-0.4316470623,
0.0770837441,
0.2789870799,
0.4953991175,
-0.6127644181,
0.0431872383,
-0.2193899304,
-0.5989733934,
0.4906449914,
0.3196143508,
0.1903111786,
-0.2693305612,
0.0893044993,
-0.05384757,
-0.2507949471,
-0.428034842,
0.3421123028,
0.2676777542,
0.2488351464,
0.6955193877,
-0.4801484346,
0.5460588932,
0.2194456905,
0.1261374801,
0.2902776301,
-0.0686888993,
-0.4045366347,
0.1340043694,
0.6626798511,
0.5379463434,
0.3272396922,
-0.4851389527,
-0.2997110784,
0.3417214751,
0.4238084257,
-0.7101150155,
-0.5227404237,
0.2946458459,
-0.348098129,
-0.4208934605,
-0.074051708,
-0.8791614175,
-0.9502058625,
-0.3260959685,
0.5846686959,
-0.7299952507,
0.0247309748,
0.5585412383,
0.1882269233,
0.0690929443,
0.5652117133,
-0.8500281572,
0.4782763124,
0.6235762239,
0.8380354643,
-0.2445501685,
-0.487298429,
-0.8270616531,
-0.203814894,
-0.3064310849,
1.1347242594,
-0.5241888165,
-0.1826197803,
-0.090418987,
0.080184646,
0.147352621,
-0.7444327474,
0.6836748123,
-0.1235431582,
-0.0294146575,
-0.1451880634,
-0.5500860214,
-0.1218979806,
0.2174685448,
-0.638029635,
1.0517224073,
-0.0597621053,
-0.6800024509,
0.1992584765,
-0.2470720708,
-0.2715953887,
-0.1345803887,
-0.2575517893,
-0.2075741738,
0.3544594944,
0.1635535955,
0.6334933043,
-0.0412155911,
0.422110498,
-0.1038158238,
-0.4362869263,
0.3474963009,
-0.5966066718,
0.1839184314,
-0.0040531773,
-0.5766109824,
0.3002534509,
-1.0696917772,
-0.290473938,
0.0144932661,
-0.1409902126,
-0.3592630625,
0.1051711291,
0.0426482223,
-0.005814861,
0.0804885551,
-0.3068348765,
0.223948583,
-0.3718011677,
-0.0338159837,
0.6817236543,
-0.0640497431,
0.0381993987,
-0.4105876088,
0.1144745424,
-0.062862061,
0.1071247011,
0.0955319628,
-0.3275608718,
-1.0950715542,
-0.0962843522,
0.10044799,
0.4764150381,
-0.5852754712,
0.6690864563,
-0.0753123015,
-0.5438358188,
-0.5368390083,
-0.019462578,
0.1266575158,
0.2940617502,
0.4747026861,
-0.2383214086,
-0.5309842229,
-0.9251876473,
-0.4230097234,
-0.068039082,
-0.011101637,
0.171178624,
0.5373299122,
-0.7846981883,
0.7133938074,
-0.4964967966,
-0.602494657,
0.2121802717,
0.4627337158,
-0.2490955591,
0.2643238306,
0.3710736632,
-0.366012454,
-0.1857487708,
0.1574145406,
-0.6408693194,
-0.3332964182,
-0.3314126134,
-0.0409096703,
0.5848867297,
0.5230044723,
-0.7087975144,
0.5160557032,
0.3651098013,
-0.4572873712,
0.8747030497,
-0.1316761225,
0.4837762117,
-0.6721143723,
-0.0421417579,
-0.2714110017,
-0.284334451,
-0.5519778132,
-0.0068726414,
-0.1104179323,
0.3600178063,
-0.1312865317,
0.5456137657,
-0.1691523343,
-0.1332789809,
-0.3446853161,
0.3622306585,
-0.0757370144,
0.4002705514,
-0.0447624698,
0.4845704734,
0.269778043,
-0.335052073,
0.4153446853,
0.1482387483,
-0.52458781,
0.2019747943,
-0.1971102953,
0.3156291544,
-0.1210135296,
0.1998718828,
-0.8906781077,
-0.5675299764,
0.2997413278,
-0.3763250411,
-0.0729732364,
0.260569483,
-0.7829642892,
-0.0394841619,
-0.2120604962,
-0.0253319237,
0.1688869596,
-0.5559455156,
0.5709979534,
0.2380383313,
0.1545246989,
-0.381002903,
-0.6441134214,
0.140958041,
0.0881104469,
-0.525486052,
0.1469114721,
-0.0364793129,
-0.3884640038,
-0.0363844074,
-0.3024220765,
-0.0676623359,
0.116260305,
0.3774188161,
0.006068232,
-0.1341168135,
0.1550372541,
-0.0161414258,
0.0918171704,
-0.013740954,
0.0852910802,
0.9596765637,
-0.4277458489,
-0.4186230004,
-0.4496661127,
0.0890428424,
0.6042989492,
0.1340105534,
0.471124351,
0.7454035878,
-0.7020078301,
-0.2566360533,
-0.9075985551,
-0.2482534349,
-0.398845762,
0.335251987,
-0.5367489457,
-0.8855199218,
0.6672782898,
0.1263137162,
-0.1310738325,
0.5422482491,
0.7511912584,
0.3327112794,
0.9378816485,
0.2103113532,
0.1693716198,
0.0162433367,
0.0120152673,
0.2658068836,
-0.4272465408,
-0.1981620491,
-0.5195146799,
0.0672015473,
-0.592862606,
-0.7670176625,
-0.2083742321,
0.0137652326,
0.1389350295,
0.107019484,
-0.6054333448,
0.7555379868,
0.0699126124,
0.0664301664,
0.607139945,
0.0435527824,
-0.0092948386,
-0.1287715435,
-0.1830750257,
-0.7825168967,
0.7323620915,
0.3694287241,
0.6989964843,
-0.1315645278,
0.6558629274,
0.6222126484,
0.240269646,
-1.0024675131,
0.5974170566,
-0.2938365638,
-0.4762037396,
-0.1862126887,
-0.2424417734,
-0.4857178926,
0.2152024209,
-0.2692738175,
-0.9972453117,
0.2894966304,
0.2063367218,
-0.4770799577,
0.3540226221,
-0.5302621722,
0.769523859,
-0.1262828857,
-0.2563081384,
-0.3952195942,
-0.2182485759,
0.5164577365,
-0.2813007832,
0.2512393892,
-0.1760072261,
0.3294025362,
0.5182492137,
-0.2691272497,
0.7549722791,
-0.114051789,
-0.3189615309,
0.114199169,
0.7156270742,
0.6100230217,
-0.0989041105,
-0.0512728766,
0.2604401112,
-0.0944817662,
0.0324046835,
-0.7040706873,
0.7612543702,
-0.5912476778,
-0.7092837095,
-0.4485418499,
-0.4770938456,
-0.2614609897,
0.0677520335,
0.212602213,
0.3119294345,
-0.5501363873,
0.1798016578,
0.5247721672,
-0.3520466983,
-0.212337628,
0.2651894987,
-0.6769169569,
-0.1861005723,
0.9873154163,
-0.0144428518,
0.1065107882,
0.0366061106,
0.148739174,
0.0261456724,
-0.7212119699,
-0.1343813092,
0.20758681,
-0.8904109597,
-0.1020742208,
-1.0534424782,
-0.3067017794,
-0.3497151732,
-0.1863344908,
-0.6246276498,
-0.2736301124,
-0.1872531772,
-0.0003411848,
0.375788033,
0.6703981161,
-0.1533651948,
0.2910757363,
-0.6643291712,
0.6274672747,
0.1818048507,
0.4090240002,
0.0176814292,
-0.4754351377,
-0.106514819,
0.0413018391,
-0.1783185601,
-0.5852559805,
0.3915628195,
-0.0003385329,
0.207120344,
0.3781358004,
-0.0601756833,
0.8626156449,
-0.6148245335,
0.7194592953,
-0.1280981451,
-1.082062006,
0.4527981281,
-0.1109294221,
-0.0061127781,
0.7606755495,
0.2995403707,
-0.6704881787,
-0.6282102466,
-0.4208280146,
-0.4425878823,
0.6249760985,
0.2852304578,
-0.0056881495,
-0.1715193689,
0.3007001281,
0.6315424442,
0.0331644379,
-0.521617651,
0.0168534648,
-0.2253310084,
-0.0639447048,
0.1676768512,
-0.3186026514,
0.1461164355,
-0.2840512395,
0.6656822562,
-0.1658174396,
0.1451056302,
0.3090012372,
-0.3671355844,
-0.1236980185,
0.2230923772,
0.6112779975,
0.3843204379,
-0.4905920327,
0.232253179,
0.2247608006,
-0.4503757358,
-0.0404631868,
-0.0844075382,
0.1297577769,
0.2898175418,
0.2866573334,
1.015843153,
0.2613980174,
-0.7405057549,
0.3075058162,
-0.3238769174,
-0.1668905169,
-0.2456347346,
0.3186236024,
-0.2082089335,
0.3604093492,
0.1483782828,
0.3102526367,
0.4782023132,
-0.6394504309,
0.4575938582,
0.2080053985,
-0.0739588439,
-0.3884500861,
0.6258965135,
-0.0668870732,
-0.4441154301,
0.4226278365,
-0.3719654083,
-0.4928027987,
0.1700569987,
0.3135456145,
1.1583590508,
-0.3461431563,
0.1944214553,
0.2693427205,
0.3681423962,
-0.2749461532,
0.1699653417,
0.0342640392,
-0.8446159959,
-0.1853955984,
-0.9363108277,
-0.3836855292,
0.4778220057,
-0.4367775321,
0.6463282704,
-0.4133908153,
-0.0372354537,
0.4289497137,
-0.1866546124,
-0.565759182,
0.0696844831,
0.3584994674,
0.6383984089,
-0.8166798353,
0.913140893,
0.1849919111,
-0.176645577,
-0.3944473267,
0.4313469529,
0.117259793,
-0.5966006517,
0.5056970716,
0.3617210388,
-0.4078263044,
-0.1714887023,
-0.4060970545,
-0.5814669132,
0.6896919012,
0.2682426274,
-0.6734679341,
-0.2905350924,
0.1713148355,
0.6275778413,
-0.3398978412,
0.0014056358,
1.0455474854,
0.5150099993,
0.0489991084,
-0.9348267317,
0.1187079102,
-0.0208938215,
-0.2754737139,
0.0335692279,
-0.5427293777,
0.7562969327,
-0.0223143864,
-0.3505335152,
0.1773245484,
0.538599968,
0.1536450982,
0.2385659814,
0.5756885409,
0.4158469737,
1.0417684317,
-0.0472776778,
0.9201189876,
-0.1537436098,
0.3700371385,
1.3861278296,
-0.4175399542,
0.7943948507,
0.2699768841,
0.0618909858,
0.3708185256,
0.6172132492,
-0.2389740795,
0.2868991494,
0.1798055321,
0.0728891045,
-0.3255240619,
-0.0087363385,
-0.1719614565,
0.6780391932,
0.5685887933,
-0.1066322327,
-0.2561686337,
0.1903799027,
0.131864354,
0.1013280973,
-0.0008870852,
0.6407361031,
-0.1293703765,
-0.6001615524,
0.8981405497,
0.0346165262,
0.6978480816,
-0.1210100353,
-0.0767415017,
-0.3704129159,
0.2275108844,
-0.4423761964,
-0.6206551194,
0.6332659125,
0.2678930461,
-0.0823694691,
0.2596957982,
0.7589541078,
-0.3414410055,
-0.2433722615,
0.4828272462,
0.2795774639,
0.518188715,
-0.418068856,
-0.3794121444,
0.5779461265,
0.0579374619,
-0.1821237803,
0.0171797499,
0.6666120887,
-0.206603229,
0.4363274276,
0.4574372768,
0.1070463583,
0.1432240009,
0.2277305424,
0.6696657538,
-0.7722483873,
-0.1407678723,
-1.0812700987,
0.1825821251,
-0.0666160882,
-0.1800659299,
0.6732272506,
0.5898871422,
0.8667542338,
-0.1855491251,
0.7502864599,
0.0031612017,
0.2209519893,
-0.5832853317,
0.8254407048,
-0.5369678736,
0.1116554663,
-0.3976455033,
-1.0194350481,
-0.3924203217,
0.863139689,
-0.2687718272,
-0.4343324304,
0.8600955606,
1.0749036074,
-0.1407064497,
0.1697942764,
0.5666390061,
0.7358279824,
0.2283827662,
0.2817505896,
0.911785543,
-0.4967535436,
0.2597849071,
-0.2502083182,
-0.1039485261,
-0.6142212749,
-0.5682439208,
-1.078066349,
-0.8252153397,
-0.4230856001,
-0.5147997141,
0.0223573893,
1.0622595549,
0.2062590718,
-1.0639603138,
-0.0807323232,
-0.0689913556,
-0.0030659984,
0.1493104696,
-0.2899448872,
0.4358152747,
-0.4424915314,
-0.7932436466,
0.3797352314,
0.3096122742,
0.0132747348,
-0.4156517386,
-0.0254155789,
-0.1043327749,
0.325283885,
0.7860145569,
-0.1529894024,
-1.1350002289,
-0.6931582093,
-0.0841568261,
-0.1861447692,
0.1643547416,
0.6409720778,
-0.6557978392,
0.5607312322,
0.4665610492,
0.7437694073,
0.3066996932,
-0.1883251816,
0.2268170863,
-0.4727020264,
0.239180997,
0.1116019711,
0.2922774255,
0.4031895697,
-0.4574303031,
0.507586956,
0.1983229071,
-0.5818009973,
-1.1967990398,
-0.1352732033,
-0.9584566951,
-0.3101662695,
1.1980905533,
0.2811030746,
-0.2919209003,
-0.0989687219,
-0.6096873283,
0.2762403786,
-0.2481309175,
1.3042262793,
1.1305323839,
-0.0510677025,
0.2339224368,
-0.7342540622,
0.811907649,
0.252361089,
-0.909740746,
0.6489170194,
0.8868036866,
0.031791918,
0.3033875525,
0.3709646165,
0.0328095593,
0.2895869911,
0.0567902699,
0.2737417519,
0.1255440563,
-0.5249150395,
-0.3014329374,
0.1153088361,
0.0238295514,
0.1187017485
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06853v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06853v5
|
Large Language Models Can Learn Temporal Reasoning
| 2024-01-12T19:00:26 | 2024-06-11T02:38:27 |
Siheng Xiong, Ali Payani, Ramana Kompella, Faramarz Fekri
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable reasoning
capabilities, they are not without their flaws and inaccuracies. Recent studies
have introduced various methods to mitigate these limitations. Temporal
reasoning (TR), in particular, presents a significant challenge for LLMs due to
its reliance on diverse temporal concepts and intricate temporal logic. In this
paper, we propose TG-LLM, a novel framework towards language-based TR. Instead
of reasoning over the original context, we adopt a latent representation,
temporal graph (TG) that enhances the learning of TR. A synthetic dataset
(TGQA), which is fully controllable and requires minimal supervision, is
constructed for fine-tuning LLMs on this text-to-TG translation task. We
confirmed in experiments that the capability of TG translation learned on our
dataset can be transferred to other TR tasks and benchmarks. On top of that, we
teach LLM to perform deliberate reasoning over the TGs via Chain-of-Thought
(CoT) bootstrapping and graph data augmentation. We observed that those
strategies, which maintain a balance between usefulness and diversity, bring
more reliable CoTs and final results than the vanilla CoT distillation.
|
[
0.0678424835,
-0.9880544543,
1.0378750563,
0.2345138341,
-0.3721396029,
0.6920555234,
-0.3709782064,
-0.3603555858,
-0.2145400941,
0.2130976766,
-0.5683116317,
-0.7305797338,
-0.4787218273,
-0.0286457073,
-0.1374464184,
0.6980506778,
-0.2092486322,
-0.0481999964,
0.3605501652,
-0.0849960223,
-0.2065639496,
-0.3471556306,
-0.8169083595,
-0.7914223671,
0.7133847475,
0.1240706965,
0.6611412168,
0.7492095828,
-0.2397912741,
0.1869275421,
-0.0608589612,
0.5155576468,
-0.4320396185,
-0.072631903,
-0.5494238138,
-0.5876296759,
-0.6044398546,
-0.0716392994,
0.7162640095,
0.9310991168,
-0.0337405801,
-0.0019902529,
-0.175861761,
0.3567849994,
-0.3923738003,
0.4494761825,
-0.7745341063,
0.2722635567,
-0.2255397588,
-0.4067109823,
-0.671937108,
-0.3572712541,
-0.0979487151,
-0.6033320427,
-0.1049870327,
0.2808658779,
0.6862519383,
0.3795613945,
-0.6719359159,
0.175466612,
-0.9334461093,
0.8288077712,
-0.7508119941,
0.4517834783,
0.2226250917,
0.5647485256,
-0.2447004765,
-0.8131422997,
-0.6286222935,
-0.0543326326,
-0.0119008822,
-0.134837091,
0.0432592593,
-0.0875897855,
0.3762512207,
0.135681197,
-0.5837556124,
0.2377398908,
0.0279755779,
0.0327003933,
0.3813529909,
0.223727107,
0.2933469713,
0.0368573144,
-0.1698450297,
0.1124208495,
-0.7179492116,
-0.2681078315,
0.0265396684,
0.246527046,
-0.2140381634,
0.4352893829,
-0.0539905913,
0.7707314491,
0.0163095146,
-0.1388594955,
0.1855920404,
-0.0974301174,
-0.277557373,
0.0150245363,
0.6362194419,
0.1364512891,
0.4652211368,
-0.5984938741,
-0.2486719042,
0.2225291878,
-0.0780977458,
-0.5530133247,
-0.1172292754,
0.3033027053,
-0.1729733795,
-0.2962042987,
-0.3639095128,
-0.5110396147,
0.0722921938,
-0.5016869307,
0.1915979534,
-0.4262818098,
-0.1419718266,
0.2445905507,
0.0125005394,
0.0753947124,
0.5266651511,
-0.6914837956,
0.1314821243,
0.6980752945,
0.8173424006,
-0.1354209781,
-0.1486664414,
-0.6670961976,
0.7560790777,
-0.6956248879,
0.676383853,
-0.7561132908,
-0.2457854301,
-0.3018890321,
0.0554478541,
-0.0983835608,
-0.2314535826,
0.1652370244,
-0.6623367071,
0.2150303721,
-0.0327691138,
-0.453227371,
-0.0334546007,
0.4043325186,
-0.4414691627,
0.8670287132,
0.2475948185,
-0.4721917808,
0.4591549039,
-0.2483053356,
-0.5444537997,
0.1400756538,
-0.34465608,
-0.172756508,
-0.113154538,
0.6074112654,
0.2928473055,
-0.2259921134,
0.6377637982,
-0.4699691236,
-0.2077795118,
0.1856109798,
-0.3463346362,
0.6053714752,
0.3150933981,
-0.2094944119,
0.0832415447,
-0.5434689522,
0.3520457745,
0.1187091172,
-0.3598546684,
0.0556375086,
0.0931775719,
-0.2088745981,
0.3468511403,
0.0766799003,
-0.416992873,
0.5220043659,
-0.3899462223,
0.9360185862,
0.7747939825,
0.0883410573,
0.5423774123,
-0.4729201198,
0.3121081591,
-0.010096685,
-0.0486505814,
0.0296753682,
-0.1474865079,
-0.6980352998,
0.1041093096,
0.0984220281,
0.5911477208,
-1.2794061899,
0.3027547896,
-0.5122819543,
-0.3752005696,
-0.0172046702,
0.0714687482,
0.2667474151,
0.5734246373,
0.3822600842,
0.2457854301,
-0.3869809508,
-0.4472440779,
-0.2376514822,
-0.4149445295,
-0.0726576075,
0.2511886954,
0.3764834702,
-0.29829216,
0.7051956654,
-0.4818708003,
0.004475486,
-0.3663264513,
0.2251701206,
0.2047857344,
0.3759776056,
0.5488709807,
-0.4607307613,
-0.1716136783,
0.0911898464,
-0.944799006,
-0.4304080904,
-0.3750565946,
-0.1699498892,
0.3856640756,
0.7951598763,
-0.4709351659,
0.1995253861,
0.3612914979,
-0.3507567644,
0.5410895944,
-0.2005379051,
0.0000986252,
-1.0229226351,
-0.0683583766,
-0.2376503646,
-0.6191365123,
-0.2310848236,
-0.0672718808,
-0.077574499,
-0.0833004117,
-0.3119268119,
0.9552920461,
-0.1982804835,
0.037982896,
-0.2232791334,
0.1635883451,
0.0920661464,
0.6517943144,
0.1131405607,
0.6530143023,
0.2007518262,
-0.6595478654,
0.2731881738,
0.1184489802,
-0.2741661966,
0.2678062618,
-0.6241506338,
0.3316441178,
-0.1217474937,
0.4966807365,
-0.5374509096,
-0.080432944,
0.166463539,
-0.3961780071,
0.4941270053,
-0.3819009066,
-0.8130937219,
-0.2151780874,
0.2696662247,
0.3685526252,
0.460781008,
-0.7285317779,
0.8572830558,
0.163168028,
-0.0284553636,
-0.4946077168,
-0.8411747813,
0.2181020826,
-0.1223982275,
-0.5333489776,
0.4998106658,
0.1324358881,
-0.4858253002,
0.1400621235,
-0.3584838808,
0.1589809805,
-0.1283717901,
-0.1335333586,
0.2117536366,
0.0032638393,
0.6915528774,
0.0572737046,
-0.2748555243,
-0.1095830575,
-0.9653272033,
0.6543965936,
-0.1777444333,
-0.2313546091,
0.0966478139,
0.0781653747,
0.394252032,
-0.1133300141,
0.7550442815,
0.6201838255,
-0.3095039725,
-0.7577877045,
-0.4809476435,
-0.0254866742,
-0.4563837349,
0.1364931315,
-0.3405019939,
-1.0965080261,
0.390642345,
-0.2928475738,
0.0954441503,
0.3299584985,
0.4631498754,
-0.1957089603,
0.8941916823,
0.2409075201,
-0.001250541,
0.5509634018,
-0.2562736869,
0.1673924178,
-0.5707104206,
-0.415625006,
-0.2509593368,
-0.3462036848,
-0.6018099785,
-0.7833370566,
0.3481726348,
0.0804156139,
-0.6876137853,
-0.0773581415,
-0.1264792085,
0.3840951622,
0.1242089868,
0.3452815413,
0.4236916006,
-0.0135549698,
-0.3734470308,
0.2104772925,
-0.7114768028,
-0.7637624741,
0.7891395092,
0.104233548,
0.9063004255,
-0.0445656702,
0.3480983973,
0.2625357211,
0.0476850905,
-0.5960120559,
0.7618103027,
-0.3326481879,
-0.338029772,
-0.2299748957,
-0.8807507157,
-0.7371762395,
0.0990324318,
-0.2275808156,
-0.9929195642,
-0.2425806671,
0.1262722164,
0.0297483094,
0.7526859045,
-0.5635409355,
0.6439219713,
-0.5858690143,
-0.6267214417,
-0.3385079801,
-0.5343920588,
0.0522980802,
-0.0775879249,
0.247230649,
-0.2680546939,
-0.132504195,
0.4767859578,
-0.5371118188,
0.8853201866,
0.0416352451,
-0.0373088457,
0.3712675869,
0.4383867085,
0.6473771334,
0.2045953125,
0.0042727967,
0.0966694504,
-0.0346972868,
-0.5539258122,
-0.9116967916,
0.5911716819,
-0.6981573701,
-0.8124627471,
-0.3587081134,
-0.8304450512,
-0.4513330162,
0.2367409915,
-0.1090484634,
0.3831111193,
-0.1162176505,
0.0036776776,
0.5120671391,
-0.330163449,
0.4573181272,
0.5368545055,
-0.5586634278,
-0.2652992606,
0.572733283,
0.0249378979,
0.5502775908,
0.8134346604,
0.3345907331,
-0.3845427334,
-0.4075567722,
-0.3390110731,
0.4303403199,
-0.7986949682,
0.1266341507,
-0.7467497587,
-0.2170467228,
-0.1473235786,
-0.1574094296,
-0.1032637879,
-0.7889787555,
-0.1112330854,
-0.2910117805,
0.3101353645,
0.4730960131,
0.0973365605,
0.3471777439,
-0.8715533614,
0.3253900707,
0.2917970121,
0.3252226412,
0.0135804713,
-0.384306103,
0.0449610874,
-0.0760603324,
-0.2200722694,
-0.5475695729,
0.3477596939,
0.0037810493,
0.5610367656,
0.1639867276,
-0.1632647365,
0.6726995707,
-0.5687151551,
0.647341311,
-0.0915924385,
-1.0020768642,
0.5786097646,
-0.6962308288,
0.5299753547,
-0.0284648966,
0.0035738545,
-0.5784963965,
-0.3714190722,
-0.6715046167,
-0.6641901135,
0.429515183,
0.2047989815,
-0.2774877846,
-0.0595971234,
0.4007323384,
0.0031006765,
0.1778608114,
-0.7323443294,
0.1032282487,
-0.0189101789,
-0.0590588599,
-0.1558672637,
0.0053713112,
0.0261523817,
-0.1716306806,
0.5421215296,
-0.3294058144,
0.0663207322,
-0.1179756746,
-0.1114900559,
-0.2215102613,
0.5820609927,
0.1269076467,
0.8701043725,
-0.0618983097,
0.3842262626,
0.4362002611,
0.0091528799,
0.1992174089,
-0.0752501339,
-0.1820704341,
-0.1946428418,
0.7289193273,
0.6512298584,
0.0959896222,
-0.4742601514,
-0.0341093503,
0.2057802081,
-0.01618612,
-0.2477816492,
0.0242886078,
0.2215594798,
0.5126668811,
0.3156028986,
-0.1193616465,
-0.5319945216,
-0.624622941,
0.0476184003,
0.0825019106,
-0.1491661966,
-0.3363477588,
0.8334512115,
-0.0582330339,
-0.1508626938,
0.6219806671,
-0.2789571583,
-0.6237977147,
0.5053024888,
0.6655876637,
0.756301403,
-0.02076713,
0.1737656444,
0.344376415,
0.3652187288,
-0.2712449431,
0.4293871522,
0.0142802326,
-0.77539891,
-0.8291682005,
-0.4958431423,
-0.2631643116,
0.1247261167,
-0.1113933623,
0.1761719435,
-0.6259306669,
-0.187104091,
-0.1529658884,
-0.0869066492,
-0.5952291489,
0.2929771543,
0.1846782565,
0.798448503,
-0.7854898572,
0.9579269886,
0.4943682253,
-0.3122074604,
-0.8998832703,
0.0591336451,
-0.0852946937,
-0.8169508576,
0.8950321674,
-0.0961140841,
-0.2634067833,
-0.1514176577,
-0.7296629548,
-0.6300154924,
1.1248252392,
0.5921444297,
-0.7453903556,
-0.3551664948,
0.0487867817,
0.6146346331,
-0.4561729431,
-0.0873150229,
0.5468893051,
0.3919228017,
0.4772025049,
-0.943541646,
0.1293141097,
-0.046418868,
-0.1210885718,
0.356672734,
-0.6682520509,
0.8393998742,
-0.4606787264,
-0.4443303943,
-0.2572761178,
0.4168968499,
0.4797427356,
0.4197376668,
0.4596145749,
0.7436562777,
0.8496374488,
-0.3667331636,
1.1608849764,
-0.058970429,
0.0545537136,
1.4881557226,
-0.2393499613,
0.4005575478,
0.4228831828,
-0.0697795004,
0.6331371069,
0.6089338064,
0.1776240617,
0.340379566,
0.1259757727,
-0.2328184098,
-0.7752026916,
-0.2584126592,
-0.1213512495,
0.1964076161,
0.7833732367,
-0.3242825866,
-0.4664877355,
-0.2206987292,
0.1450373232,
0.1973574311,
-0.3858914077,
0.5363491178,
0.5068190694,
-0.4955077469,
0.4277257621,
-0.1000838354,
0.0739750415,
-0.4981763363,
-0.1404729784,
0.0874817818,
0.3198145032,
-0.219260931,
-0.9112378955,
0.2969223559,
-0.0197291803,
0.0562140122,
-0.4509963095,
0.5041399002,
-0.464816004,
-0.5580378771,
0.3863170147,
0.862949729,
-0.0433062762,
0.2717025876,
-0.4357469976,
0.0317966416,
-0.1828463674,
-0.0934559628,
-0.0304487459,
0.9169272184,
-0.4455692768,
1.0808439255,
0.4585572481,
0.5180532336,
-0.2025726885,
0.4396545291,
0.9794636369,
-0.7479432225,
-0.7061302066,
-0.9865176082,
0.083865732,
-0.0182211231,
0.1671670973,
0.4353570342,
0.4336148798,
0.9531641603,
0.1927298009,
0.9004787803,
0.1039423272,
0.4203745425,
-0.9464953542,
0.4442685843,
-0.4591649473,
0.528239131,
-0.0378180929,
-0.7855921388,
-0.2659471333,
0.4286565483,
-0.8370064497,
0.2580394149,
0.9432269335,
0.5413737893,
-0.0072041797,
-0.0330502652,
0.2561690807,
0.304084599,
0.6762793064,
1.1102045774,
0.9360317588,
-0.0729941949,
0.6584641933,
0.1560763866,
-0.0783474743,
0.1749704629,
-1.1687943935,
-1.3272173405,
-0.3230918944,
-0.2875527442,
-0.4206494391,
0.1864071488,
1.1530971527,
0.5655545592,
-0.5065345168,
0.0344375707,
-0.1026393622,
0.222645849,
-0.1249737069,
-0.1571032703,
0.3916982412,
-0.4122266769,
-0.6075556874,
0.5091642737,
0.3633917272,
0.2319658995,
0.0465843938,
-0.0754466429,
-0.1277748793,
-0.1331799924,
0.6538641453,
0.1314335912,
-0.7100644708,
-0.5315972567,
-0.0833893195,
-0.0476289652,
0.0548507459,
1.003328681,
-0.8643978238,
0.5089892745,
0.518161118,
0.5262586474,
0.9783233404,
-0.1708913594,
0.8114353418,
-0.9388620853,
0.3181225359,
0.4112569392,
0.5174680948,
0.316685915,
-0.2236917168,
0.6978318095,
0.3245163262,
-0.4461633265,
-0.4913310409,
0.5665634871,
-0.9260127544,
-0.54909271,
1.3501706123,
-0.0596382953,
-0.2523738742,
-0.2004547119,
0.1129017547,
0.675739646,
-0.3472811878,
0.8112590909,
0.6276461482,
0.0915999711,
-0.3427232206,
-0.396925211,
0.2720702291,
0.0852821544,
-0.8905024529,
-0.0098161418,
0.4614852369,
0.3579394519,
-0.128605172,
0.5583154559,
-0.40383178,
-0.0110805687,
-0.1131710187,
-0.3927829862,
-0.4821326733,
-0.3392758369,
0.1115229949,
0.0143616674,
0.0657409132,
0.2378213555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06769v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06769v2
|
Machine Translation Models are Zero-Shot Detectors of Translation Direction
| 2024-01-12T18:59:02 | 2024-05-22T17:10:39 |
Michelle Wastl, Jannis Vamvas, Rico Sennrich
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Detecting the translation direction of parallel text has applications for
machine translation training and evaluation, but also has forensic applications
such as resolving plagiarism or forgery allegations. In this work, we explore
an unsupervised approach to translation direction detection based on the simple
hypothesis that
$p(\text{translation}|\text{original})>p(\text{original}|\text{translation})$,
motivated by the well-known simplification effect in translationese or
machine-translationese. In experiments with massively multilingual machine
translation models across 20 translation directions, we confirm the
effectiveness of the approach for high-resource language pairs, achieving
document-level accuracies of 82--96% for NMT-produced translations, and 60--81%
for human translations, depending on the model used. Code and demo are
available at https://github.com/ZurichNLP/translation-direction-detection
|
[
-0.2079575807,
-0.376965642,
0.8322779536,
-0.0546994843,
-0.6833097339,
-0.217787832,
-0.0761868805,
0.1786539704,
0.267970562,
0.7532736063,
-0.7127175927,
-0.928077817,
-0.7902252078,
0.2371525317,
-0.8116110563,
0.9271369576,
-0.2540136576,
0.4554231763,
0.0793207809,
-0.2454146594,
-0.1545650661,
-0.4019076824,
-0.4605407119,
-0.3431942165,
0.4810899198,
0.3391578496,
0.6346348524,
0.8105136156,
0.7064011693,
0.3531414866,
0.0948806107,
0.121464245,
0.0683620349,
0.3657202125,
-0.0167797673,
-0.4601213634,
-0.2209539115,
0.0289723016,
0.8256794214,
0.5700785518,
-0.0648603067,
-0.0559238456,
-0.2789430916,
0.8676133752,
-0.425937444,
-0.0967253,
-0.6414203048,
0.0789637268,
-0.2594999373,
-0.5891301036,
-0.5033550858,
0.2036956996,
-0.3060333729,
-0.3152118325,
0.4160355031,
0.1122237295,
0.7040991187,
0.1239735931,
-0.6255284548,
-0.2210106403,
-0.8519214988,
0.8295016289,
-0.6525592208,
0.4638608396,
0.200550586,
0.5806829333,
-0.4726575911,
-0.3307895362,
-0.6185158491,
0.2880503237,
-0.12552616,
0.2002367675,
-0.3840427995,
-0.154408738,
0.2304014117,
0.149559617,
-0.8388463855,
-0.0231759101,
-0.2392649949,
-0.0372364707,
0.6718758345,
-0.0176151656,
0.6378659606,
-0.1569152325,
-0.4915966094,
-0.3430179656,
-0.7401719093,
-0.1955532283,
0.4480285048,
0.3108735681,
-0.2253663242,
0.544005096,
-0.4929413795,
0.5703807473,
0.0261356067,
-0.0664290339,
0.3322923183,
-0.5188067555,
-0.2058374584,
0.1357452422,
1.1579592228,
0.4204295874,
0.0573830418,
-0.2193469256,
-0.4576515555,
-0.3230087459,
0.0781702399,
-0.9288915992,
-0.1546989977,
0.0344319493,
-0.4045285285,
-0.3849548399,
0.124150224,
-0.4450924695,
-0.5981047153,
-0.4034919143,
0.4470726848,
-0.4935989678,
-0.318359226,
0.3949536681,
-0.2180674523,
0.4739726186,
0.1454696059,
-0.5252475142,
-0.3190127909,
0.6827972531,
0.8319849968,
-0.2091463953,
-0.4642462134,
-0.5142700076,
0.0866156667,
-0.3006396294,
0.7754245996,
-0.1129465997,
-0.2461457103,
-0.1021201834,
0.1660906374,
0.1004310697,
-0.3505004346,
0.8879455924,
-0.4659077525,
0.1559321582,
-0.0606552176,
-0.2543285787,
-0.4491509497,
0.2081850469,
-0.4964088798,
0.2925624847,
-0.3772188723,
-0.9133726954,
0.3508992195,
-0.2851854265,
-0.6124601364,
-0.1185109243,
-0.2847029567,
-0.6178481579,
0.2362001538,
0.5746972561,
0.4641267359,
-0.3101688921,
0.3989511132,
-0.0976482779,
-0.4521102607,
0.3467374146,
-0.7734568715,
1.0692683458,
0.206188634,
-0.2477237582,
0.23176305,
-0.6639304757,
-0.4926144481,
0.4087308049,
-0.232478559,
-0.5961223841,
-0.0661509559,
-0.2580037713,
0.2787888646,
0.141010806,
-0.740259409,
0.2686934769,
-0.1964572519,
0.0631517768,
0.2514283657,
-0.0248065889,
0.5893386006,
0.0426591933,
0.5097944736,
0.5260929465,
0.0616180673,
-0.5160245895,
-0.7662448287,
-0.7183763981,
-0.4444614351,
0.3491748869,
0.5244672894,
-1.0320948362,
0.2789622843,
-0.2865896821,
-0.3293773234,
-0.7122805715,
0.2202391326,
0.4581927061,
0.3534918427,
0.3791722655,
-0.2297109962,
-0.6890490651,
-0.8709011674,
-0.863742888,
-0.0545111746,
-0.3459613025,
-0.3698946834,
0.4349763989,
-0.2028296888,
0.501054883,
-0.1917424649,
-0.2174079865,
-0.233367756,
0.614262104,
0.4890141487,
0.5490921736,
0.4374572039,
-1.0402019024,
-0.5776566267,
0.1633320749,
-1.2026562691,
-0.2739815116,
-0.1289090365,
-0.1826888323,
0.1825986952,
0.7829722762,
-0.5586377382,
0.5332996845,
0.4561726153,
-0.2006910145,
0.2540255785,
-0.5365402102,
0.2887318432,
-1.1083837748,
-0.0385397859,
-0.0698810071,
-0.4105272591,
-0.8568997383,
0.3377799988,
0.3989518285,
-0.1383009702,
-0.505120635,
0.0544737242,
-0.4501383007,
-0.2053124607,
-0.4560596049,
0.1173160747,
-0.0218804087,
0.4624683559,
0.2514194846,
0.5550760031,
0.3944008648,
-0.1169267744,
0.2019438595,
-0.0732453018,
-0.2724307477,
0.7649601102,
-0.3791159093,
0.1552481353,
-0.4123356342,
0.0360925607,
-1.0933756828,
-0.1075251922,
0.2779856324,
-0.7832684517,
0.4422402978,
-0.4748299122,
-0.6628530025,
-0.2584305406,
-0.2160446048,
0.62845999,
0.4927121401,
-0.5481334925,
0.6531494856,
0.1184551194,
0.0725214705,
-0.5348312259,
-0.7507458329,
0.148525238,
-0.1023354903,
-0.4566599429,
0.1893534958,
0.1655363739,
-0.2139695883,
-0.2101324052,
0.0738894641,
-0.2795490324,
0.0134604145,
0.3647670746,
0.2771435678,
-0.196492821,
-0.3669740856,
0.2951962352,
-0.2412650138,
0.1449689716,
-0.4801065922,
0.4581223726,
0.1715123504,
-0.7369537354,
-0.5238533616,
0.4583064318,
1.027048707,
-0.4240186512,
0.6760567427,
0.6333062649,
-0.2086580694,
0.0444548167,
-0.4804231822,
-0.2358815372,
-0.4491564929,
0.1323369741,
-0.5029931664,
-0.2466401011,
0.4562622607,
0.1044087783,
-0.2250778228,
0.4100981951,
0.5913715363,
-0.1130034626,
1.4999634027,
0.4184527993,
-0.1041941941,
0.3071922362,
-0.1901589483,
0.6421841979,
-0.5240639448,
-0.2022028118,
-0.4553725719,
-0.2229082733,
-0.9163992405,
-0.3625767827,
0.3686896861,
0.4771739542,
-0.0423621461,
0.819101572,
-0.3643379807,
0.5914548039,
0.6463110447,
0.0637283623,
0.9011577368,
0.1912093312,
-0.4331444204,
-0.0950069055,
-0.6114606857,
-0.2131433189,
1.222759366,
0.2023106366,
0.2081853449,
0.0415203422,
1.1803921461,
-0.1278753579,
0.0906003565,
-0.8781623244,
0.557086885,
-0.2824724317,
-0.3534337878,
-0.2300959527,
-0.512024343,
-0.7053094506,
0.5821765065,
-0.1798282117,
-0.0069546304,
0.0455656871,
-0.2006492615,
0.0259933732,
0.5553015471,
-0.4281000495,
0.9644334912,
-0.2997356355,
-0.0243748538,
-0.0131271752,
-0.4035474062,
0.1469059885,
-0.2512549758,
0.1536619961,
0.0373896547,
0.3141451478,
0.4037458301,
-0.2115094513,
0.48383829,
-0.2210518122,
-0.0075948155,
0.215414986,
0.4769744277,
0.6349620223,
-0.2585929036,
-0.0248634852,
0.4438383281,
-0.1420295835,
-0.3662770092,
-0.7025479078,
0.6615641117,
-0.3258052766,
-0.6870328188,
-0.2750062346,
-0.9845532179,
0.2452457845,
0.6210867167,
0.5499274731,
-0.0571750961,
-0.0849694312,
0.1222783178,
0.378133893,
-0.2765594125,
0.3662459254,
1.1523869038,
-0.5445622206,
-0.0645005777,
0.8770027757,
-0.0854737014,
0.0464378484,
0.4022784829,
0.3590967357,
-0.2558084428,
-0.7944452763,
-0.9108170271,
0.3586191833,
-0.4912528694,
-0.0881775916,
-0.3749047816,
-0.0190090593,
-0.3266534209,
-0.0723550841,
-0.5077680349,
-0.4058527648,
0.1754755527,
0.1546361893,
0.0193073936,
0.5258783102,
-0.0151629467,
0.259657532,
-0.6104367971,
0.2140119672,
0.1266784966,
-0.2733060122,
-0.3654386699,
-0.7103115916,
0.1077597737,
0.3159814477,
-0.323920697,
-0.9627892971,
0.6727276444,
-0.4872237146,
0.0917996466,
0.5357893705,
0.2267116755,
0.1466849893,
-0.483982116,
0.2794680297,
0.3753251135,
-0.8236364722,
0.3985657096,
-0.6854833961,
0.49855268,
0.3984725773,
0.4092790782,
-0.4307718575,
-0.5206167102,
-0.3289859593,
-0.5133300424,
0.5931538939,
0.322752744,
-0.1215067059,
0.2663541138,
0.1317416877,
-0.2272411436,
0.2642655671,
-0.6222717166,
-0.0628427789,
0.0175526086,
-0.2140047252,
0.001982074,
0.0272712968,
0.0703901127,
-0.1884456277,
0.4839344025,
0.0229071416,
0.3467359841,
0.0454862043,
0.0327522382,
-0.176745683,
0.3027826846,
0.7439807653,
0.2189825326,
-0.367844522,
0.3394296467,
-0.1740105897,
-0.0046555232,
0.178532511,
-0.0351264887,
-0.8937037587,
0.5446683168,
0.2822096944,
0.5248550177,
-0.1133925542,
-0.2161113322,
1.1413230896,
0.1207441911,
-0.1729110479,
-0.0877066404,
-0.3883691728,
0.0997167081,
0.2874344587,
0.0398006476,
0.085939765,
0.2127126902,
-0.4607313871,
0.1133445129,
0.6013718843,
-0.4828285277,
-0.4413044155,
0.5982239842,
-0.0098604234,
-0.5457938313,
0.3915405273,
-0.4480079412,
-0.8314502835,
0.4933451116,
0.6357184649,
1.2170523405,
-0.3847219348,
0.2279117554,
0.2927933037,
0.2479373664,
-0.2362211943,
0.1585900337,
-0.1929619461,
-0.6972478628,
-0.3660829067,
-0.6385269761,
-0.0116761634,
-0.0438712314,
-0.6319086552,
0.4670764208,
-0.1635744721,
0.1736586243,
0.1740418673,
-0.6744554043,
-0.4661691189,
-0.2997973561,
0.119568333,
0.6652626395,
-0.9512346387,
1.3408876657,
0.4723064899,
-0.5648521185,
-0.4450752735,
0.1731601506,
0.1602637023,
-0.9355282187,
0.8869069219,
0.3119705021,
-0.4634690881,
-0.2551271915,
-0.4542782903,
-0.3260357082,
0.8721749187,
0.4788625538,
-0.5898942351,
-0.0389159247,
0.755949676,
0.588491261,
-0.1646183729,
-0.1493507475,
0.5440558195,
0.3898021877,
0.0842865705,
-0.6877493858,
-0.0495136566,
0.0893917456,
-0.0562138185,
0.5766179562,
-0.0912680477,
0.9603969455,
-0.1255018264,
-0.2624084651,
0.2548134029,
0.2127359807,
-0.0212891623,
0.4643035829,
0.2280454785,
0.6027520299,
0.1272074729,
-0.0275954101,
1.0821185112,
-0.5404226184,
0.3631623685,
0.8648880124,
0.1177393869,
0.8497774601,
0.8103849292,
0.2222638577,
0.2253806293,
-0.0742689744,
0.189176023,
0.7235360742,
-0.033217635,
-0.2339620441,
-0.448631525,
-0.1628918052,
-0.0928994268,
0.4847422838,
0.0146683343,
-0.8111113906,
-0.3460165858,
0.0515950844,
0.4140476584,
0.2741732001,
-0.2452634722,
0.525829792,
0.1448646635,
-0.8821286559,
0.7644147277,
0.5401551723,
0.5337437987,
-0.2841779292,
0.0079767955,
-0.4291974306,
0.526065588,
-0.1455394924,
-0.8485305905,
0.3645560741,
-0.0766990557,
-0.1753866374,
-0.3078727126,
0.6619429588,
-0.90708673,
-0.6893250346,
0.5297187567,
0.5534786582,
0.1220509335,
-0.6134772897,
-0.5797432065,
-0.1575003713,
0.0644980296,
0.2029722929,
0.3928210437,
0.6865635514,
-0.1086922437,
0.4920707643,
0.8151813745,
0.008171563,
0.0194275584,
-0.0949076638,
0.433547169,
-0.4565510154,
-0.3402669728,
-1.0627362728,
0.1336179227,
0.0035375205,
0.0579071678,
1.1411346197,
0.4348555207,
1.0768473148,
-0.1603834778,
0.4655279815,
0.5391155481,
0.3728437126,
-0.503318727,
0.7466846704,
-0.6883490682,
0.2262074649,
-0.3273144066,
-0.604001224,
-0.6940362453,
0.4907288551,
-0.4592057467,
-0.5893950462,
0.6366804838,
0.9836207032,
-0.394867599,
-0.1201696321,
0.5468763709,
-0.1339989454,
0.0274031051,
0.5000600219,
0.6833514571,
-0.7926285267,
0.7044045925,
-0.5470654964,
-0.0603636466,
-0.0886670053,
-0.9748954773,
-1.1076127291,
-0.3866431117,
-0.2709154487,
-0.171578303,
0.0033199135,
0.4664745629,
0.4109631777,
-0.8911626339,
-0.4077121913,
-0.3568607271,
0.2024795413,
-0.2060881704,
-0.0532035008,
0.319047302,
0.001398767,
-0.5781541467,
0.5723773837,
0.4233589172,
0.2040599287,
-0.3566369116,
-0.2065261602,
-0.3182890117,
-0.0536539778,
0.448807925,
0.2268467695,
-0.703985393,
0.1615579426,
0.0321414247,
-0.224573493,
0.1645016074,
0.9917665124,
-0.2572205961,
0.7849502563,
0.8942325711,
0.4972279966,
0.6738317013,
-0.0146299759,
0.6612885594,
-0.7701144218,
0.5944719911,
-0.1550301462,
0.5773800015,
0.4394366145,
-0.2084106654,
0.3819236159,
0.537817955,
-0.4118745625,
-0.7077293992,
0.3706472814,
-0.632070303,
-0.2671509385,
0.9165911674,
-0.3297488391,
-0.3014234006,
0.165007934,
-0.0757888183,
0.3879125416,
-0.3321439028,
0.4163832664,
0.2928996086,
0.2793157697,
0.0433222577,
-0.6286649704,
0.3500529528,
0.588550806,
-0.2171051651,
-0.0383143835,
0.2077525109,
0.22840406,
0.4375640452,
0.3594866693,
-0.3190298676,
0.1155792251,
-0.2737980485,
0.170177117,
-0.2717745304,
-0.465180248,
-0.751830399,
-0.0510725453,
-0.0466348119,
-0.5408673286
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06766v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06766v3
|
Mind Your Format: Towards Consistent Evaluation of In-Context Learning Improvements
| 2024-01-12T18:58:26 | 2024-06-06T19:01:37 |
Anton Voronov, Lena Wolf, Max Ryabinin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models demonstrate a remarkable capability for learning to
solve new tasks from a few examples. The prompt template, or the way the input
examples are formatted to obtain the prompt, is an important yet often
overlooked aspect of in-context learning. In this work, we conduct a
comprehensive study of the template format's influence on the in-context
learning performance. We evaluate the impact of the prompt template across 21
models (from 770M to 70B parameters) and 4 standard classification datasets. We
show that a poor choice of the template can reduce the performance of the
strongest models and inference methods to a random guess level. More
importantly, the best templates do not transfer between different setups and
even between models of the same family. Our findings show that the currently
prevalent approach to evaluation, which ignores template selection, may give
misleading results due to different templates in different works. As a first
step towards mitigating this issue, we propose Template Ensembles that
aggregate model predictions across several templates. This simple test-time
augmentation boosts average performance while being robust to the choice of
random set of templates.
|
[
-0.5169647932,
-0.4146145582,
0.6053558588,
0.2400835752,
-0.2244088501,
-0.1898120791,
-0.4591641426,
0.008795917,
-0.1340247691,
-0.0433595888,
-0.2729532719,
-0.2381896526,
-0.4884844422,
0.2624843121,
-0.1380375475,
0.7829657197,
0.19568941,
0.306566,
-0.5060760379,
-0.2589209676,
-0.9295445681,
-0.3061161637,
-0.7269355655,
-0.2797232568,
0.2605277598,
0.407851547,
0.1971832365,
0.7263742685,
0.0839762539,
0.3013362586,
-0.1915644109,
0.1232193708,
-0.1880945861,
0.411978811,
-0.3026101291,
-0.5652472973,
-0.200350821,
0.2635385394,
0.8628363609,
0.6750702858,
-0.3171474934,
0.2182192355,
0.3344880342,
0.5208857059,
-1.0475381613,
0.1464455426,
-0.4691919386,
0.0514410324,
-0.1330649406,
-0.1039941832,
-0.7393183112,
-0.2924239933,
0.2033628821,
-0.5379719138,
0.2164414823,
0.1094955653,
0.1414784342,
0.2164065242,
-0.2910013497,
-0.1891970783,
-0.6565674543,
0.7127847075,
-0.3928854465,
0.6473073959,
0.1553563625,
0.6819912791,
-0.2041083723,
-0.8182661533,
-0.6321309209,
0.0992885306,
0.0437800847,
0.4883545637,
-0.0091539873,
-0.1653444618,
0.446234405,
0.2670134902,
-0.6416401863,
0.1354668885,
-0.3850257993,
-0.1513343453,
0.3589260578,
0.2206151336,
0.1140520871,
-0.0047545815,
-0.10552264,
-0.4533462524,
-0.6729764938,
0.2581806481,
0.326277256,
0.2741389275,
-0.2138554007,
0.382183373,
0.1552754343,
1.1007517576,
0.3372755945,
-0.2708269656,
0.1065178365,
-0.0701958239,
-0.4851620197,
0.0762391388,
0.5696994066,
0.3434994817,
-0.0434649624,
-0.248919189,
-0.3348610699,
-0.0093940711,
0.3337809443,
-0.4257541001,
-0.105151698,
0.1444611102,
-0.3899505734,
-0.1777268052,
-0.0507272892,
-0.6283128858,
-0.4179179966,
-0.4061830938,
0.296287328,
-0.757409215,
0.1076475084,
0.0425392166,
-0.4545707405,
0.2056888193,
0.7005602717,
-0.8227813244,
0.266928196,
0.6425263286,
0.7032318115,
-0.1912777424,
-0.2378291041,
-0.8262560964,
-0.0172782838,
-0.5400618315,
0.92596066,
-0.8158559203,
-0.5477711558,
-0.1774899513,
-0.3156663775,
-0.4333832562,
-0.4822016954,
0.2764208615,
-0.3427412808,
0.9516589046,
-0.4348888695,
-0.8755425811,
-0.1043364778,
0.0794268921,
-0.7036227584,
0.8777102828,
0.3895631731,
-0.7303717136,
0.7199739814,
-0.6193608046,
-0.1509266943,
0.1794122756,
-0.3750694692,
0.0033805175,
0.2693625987,
0.3059896827,
0.4441499412,
-0.2852335572,
0.2540521324,
-0.0897976607,
-0.8031468391,
0.1890565902,
-0.2869957685,
0.6900963783,
0.3316584826,
-0.2917893827,
0.2812942863,
-0.8159061074,
-0.0487227738,
-0.0739726424,
-0.4008294344,
-0.3787231147,
-0.1713855714,
0.1192772016,
0.4374989271,
-0.1657251716,
-0.485029012,
0.3451304436,
-0.2989054918,
0.1959797591,
0.9968027472,
0.0476069748,
0.6324597597,
-0.4666307867,
0.7459143996,
0.1295964569,
-0.2317107171,
-0.4578185678,
-0.547388792,
-0.314150095,
-0.3455636799,
0.4262156785,
0.0824741572,
-0.4814995527,
0.3994381428,
-0.1984227002,
-0.5061894655,
-0.6570143104,
0.0491181463,
0.3919612765,
1.0101743937,
0.3719523549,
-0.5646343827,
-0.5459421873,
-0.7974648476,
-0.3152534366,
-0.1406522393,
-0.314758122,
0.2146274894,
0.3956882358,
0.025714742,
1.1052948236,
-0.2746653557,
0.1485597193,
-0.5649493933,
-0.1979062706,
0.1626542807,
0.6822321415,
0.6645947695,
-0.5981253982,
-0.4635795951,
-0.4157709479,
-0.5190198421,
0.0499208644,
-0.1307992637,
0.1399755031,
0.1021611542,
0.4719147682,
-0.1364853233,
0.0895997509,
0.2827317417,
-0.3893794417,
0.6971096396,
-0.105723381,
-0.0951186866,
-1.2230169773,
0.0232643634,
0.4096344411,
-0.1063575,
-0.2805761397,
-0.0238438752,
0.4937206209,
-0.0662563443,
-0.5072796345,
0.9109814763,
0.1345722973,
0.0456775539,
0.2310585827,
-0.0602583624,
0.271858871,
0.2655525804,
-0.1288772374,
1.2641688585,
0.5999855995,
-0.7091854811,
-0.1018733382,
0.3135895133,
-0.6631103754,
0.8793106079,
-0.4902088642,
0.3964938819,
-0.5936332941,
0.5981536508,
-1.0186194181,
-0.3201975524,
0.165772438,
-0.2096566111,
0.5770564675,
-0.0230605844,
-0.394184798,
0.0026651688,
-0.3058911562,
0.2161606252,
0.5302032828,
-0.7320404053,
0.4871337712,
-0.0988066718,
0.2304628789,
-0.6541923285,
-0.2722547054,
-0.1511863321,
-0.61148417,
-0.2982408106,
0.4259229302,
-0.3721108139,
-0.3448452652,
-0.4441927969,
-0.254557699,
0.1768051684,
0.2425340861,
0.2274079472,
0.026637977,
-0.2510842681,
0.2960068882,
0.1095246151,
0.1267635375,
-0.0529244617,
-0.5502618551,
0.6215509176,
-0.1897923946,
-0.145220235,
-0.3411520422,
0.1951500028,
0.5887594819,
-0.3862679303,
0.739592731,
0.407815516,
-0.3562189937,
-0.3559965789,
-0.5140327215,
0.0153430682,
-0.4969881475,
0.1635090858,
-0.4723721445,
-0.5348932743,
0.3800749779,
0.1184519231,
0.108019188,
0.2747440636,
0.3311719,
-0.2179120034,
0.9646048546,
0.7472854257,
-0.0004876886,
0.7210938931,
-0.3052252233,
-0.183880955,
-1.3068622351,
-0.3075459599,
-0.4305846393,
-0.2870646417,
-0.3988533616,
-0.2662393451,
0.3821921349,
0.0315892622,
-0.5246466994,
0.1927479655,
-0.33267048,
0.3749681711,
0.3711183965,
0.1277016401,
0.1227740049,
-0.0536107793,
-0.5911543965,
-0.1957692057,
-0.9383666515,
-0.6142126322,
1.2963274717,
0.2248877585,
0.463696152,
-0.0078428667,
0.7814526558,
0.0722949579,
0.6420655251,
-0.7256594896,
0.2448542267,
0.1649418175,
-0.3943004906,
-0.1812513918,
-0.1984660625,
-0.7676646709,
0.3603516221,
0.0286432225,
-1.0344008207,
0.1429053247,
0.1632939875,
-0.4956879318,
0.0731632859,
-0.7346503735,
0.8097295761,
0.0684179962,
-0.3963282704,
0.0769025236,
-0.434227705,
0.1937770545,
-0.1470584869,
0.1044913083,
0.3610740304,
0.0565651841,
1.0300571918,
0.0652718991,
0.68303895,
-0.1020068377,
0.0694964603,
0.2459608763,
0.1096095294,
0.3095881045,
0.1070569605,
-0.3740871251,
-0.3426797688,
-0.3086210787,
-0.3567365408,
-0.9651731849,
0.4507284462,
-0.5786203742,
-0.6001507044,
-0.2961704135,
-0.563368082,
-0.4088502526,
0.0877042934,
0.5963004231,
0.9862467051,
-0.2916764021,
0.251621902,
0.6877676249,
-0.1574724168,
0.5578635335,
0.2586933076,
0.0947905853,
-0.266972363,
0.7407269478,
0.2744276226,
0.1281213313,
0.2490640581,
0.4512712955,
-0.490455389,
-0.4802673161,
-0.5913812518,
-0.0471123271,
-1.1532649994,
-0.1267426163,
-0.6529474258,
0.3092435598,
-0.585826695,
-0.4148449004,
-0.2277489454,
-0.3547158241,
-0.0984459296,
-0.2274565846,
-0.0542587601,
0.841509819,
0.2248900384,
0.5864669681,
-0.4183448553,
-0.31816113,
0.2975026369,
0.5445674062,
0.2043933868,
-0.5906108022,
-0.1412580162,
-0.2416499108,
-0.4635258019,
-0.7881532311,
0.2684618533,
0.1769551486,
0.76553756,
0.4908925891,
-0.2724031508,
0.7382287383,
-0.4745333791,
0.8108472228,
0.1433886737,
-0.9345026612,
0.5563723445,
-0.305899322,
0.4751260281,
0.5859220028,
0.3830679059,
-0.6801946759,
-0.2608485818,
-0.9374593496,
-0.6755065918,
0.3711094558,
-0.0192589462,
-0.1231208742,
-0.2713052034,
0.4393164814,
0.300388813,
0.2965154052,
-0.2795398831,
-0.2665562034,
-0.2816931605,
-0.2318661213,
-0.3389214873,
0.1053018123,
-0.1326254904,
-0.4350658059,
0.2706124783,
-0.4196078479,
0.3370323777,
0.1428940892,
-0.2003854811,
-0.1479190588,
0.259005934,
0.6694374681,
1.0321249962,
-0.2485645413,
-0.121366404,
0.2959455848,
-0.3332747221,
0.0886245146,
-0.3413881361,
0.0434619784,
0.0395239033,
0.5914469361,
0.5711506605,
0.5731812716,
-0.5052372813,
0.4754956365,
-0.4087476134,
0.2985548675,
-0.3276123405,
0.4634948969,
-0.1670929939,
0.0755167231,
0.3950829506,
0.3279066384,
0.1074900404,
-0.4646862745,
0.2588577867,
0.2532565892,
-0.4835490882,
-0.3266545832,
0.6572960615,
-0.106460847,
-0.3411633968,
0.6621178985,
-0.0608144738,
-0.4077097476,
0.819647491,
0.9347173572,
0.8710473776,
-0.3934921324,
0.0094716316,
0.416275084,
0.0455331765,
-0.1518002152,
0.2239415199,
-0.204681173,
-0.6986448169,
-0.2932022512,
-0.6247918606,
-0.4427728355,
0.4567090571,
-0.9421136379,
0.2712397277,
-0.4779087305,
0.0902836248,
-0.0796791315,
0.0549028479,
-1.231698513,
0.5388386846,
0.191279307,
1.5257000923,
-0.942285955,
0.7032217979,
1.0169955492,
-0.1139989123,
-0.8671148419,
0.084766157,
0.0942395926,
-0.4290615022,
0.3837804198,
0.5285707116,
0.1682935655,
0.0189902689,
-0.6253746152,
-0.8421804905,
1.0830032825,
0.2919530272,
-0.4531342685,
0.0037163848,
-0.5772953629,
0.427665323,
-0.9206545949,
0.4852333069,
0.6123598218,
0.3561325967,
-0.1088860333,
-0.7825387716,
0.084353663,
-0.1974161863,
0.2021170855,
-0.2301375568,
-0.481534481,
0.7432200909,
-0.1106586903,
-0.2312675267,
-0.2412429452,
0.7154459953,
0.4121362269,
0.2115270942,
0.4622264504,
0.4088150263,
1.1062961817,
0.1090393364,
1.5333846807,
-0.1265835464,
-0.0308681037,
1.2269349098,
-0.285502255,
0.5448082685,
0.5129773617,
-0.1069996431,
0.4537779987,
0.7762773633,
0.1692739725,
0.5267537236,
0.0534860194,
-0.0183365382,
-0.0956978872,
0.0765677616,
-0.4208818674,
0.658297658,
0.5891835093,
-0.3105327189,
-0.2952863872,
-0.0334054194,
-0.166004613,
0.2359638959,
-0.2750151753,
0.5677072406,
-0.1085138917,
-0.8306421041,
0.4012846649,
0.0495165065,
0.616769731,
-0.4498475492,
-0.0949195102,
-0.2978581488,
-0.0281783026,
-0.0285288636,
-0.4486863315,
-0.0402121507,
-0.3302346766,
-0.1863037646,
-0.194675222,
0.4177145362,
-0.19272995,
-0.3357546926,
-0.0779459104,
0.7640424967,
-0.1276809871,
0.0585301965,
-0.2928170264,
-0.0458566621,
-0.2641480863,
-0.4415347278,
0.6154547334,
0.3707782924,
-0.2662619352,
0.6582651734,
0.5678871274,
-0.0139907561,
-0.153769806,
-0.1779651642,
1.0063364506,
-0.4849947989,
-0.7535600662,
-0.7714751363,
0.5470748544,
-0.0361661129,
-0.7906400561,
0.7961831093,
0.6306942701,
1.1388293505,
-0.1096387655,
0.9031652808,
0.1172020286,
0.1357912421,
-0.420317471,
0.7465263009,
-0.4057322145,
0.2000648081,
-0.4540038109,
-1.041210413,
-0.0400767252,
0.6844193339,
-0.3541288972,
0.0669351816,
0.6662692428,
0.3436029255,
-0.1084250137,
0.1463654935,
0.3663319349,
-0.2818977535,
0.4664628506,
0.2690692246,
0.622189641,
-0.2188175321,
-0.1878318936,
-0.5243326426,
-0.2369372845,
-0.0169023499,
-1.0823277235,
-0.746671617,
-0.8278695941,
-0.3061766624,
-0.4846059382,
0.0849093273,
1.3523752689,
0.5818194747,
-0.580044806,
-0.2277148813,
0.2005760819,
0.1764359325,
-0.5660298467,
-0.2394806147,
0.4137030542,
-0.5838634372,
-0.811946094,
0.7625629902,
0.1492330134,
0.199415639,
-0.0829015002,
0.0481057651,
0.081867896,
-0.0330619439,
0.5583968759,
0.020343177,
-0.3835250437,
-0.3215816021,
0.0029694096,
-0.1059656888,
0.1873813868,
0.9835290909,
-1.1893731356,
0.8745801449,
0.3574944139,
0.4459576905,
0.1470562667,
0.0653095022,
1.1439074278,
-0.9452189803,
0.2704203129,
0.3423074484,
0.6060531735,
0.4249030054,
-0.4543800354,
0.4757634103,
0.1468130052,
-0.1330700219,
-0.8725967407,
0.084843263,
-0.6466972232,
-0.2609332204,
0.8527620435,
-0.1985382289,
-0.3504115939,
-0.14954032,
0.0376128368,
0.296602726,
-0.4642427564,
0.8944446445,
0.8272004724,
-0.1350684762,
0.0392697379,
-0.6141763926,
0.5779722929,
0.4166722298,
-0.2091655135,
-0.2549207807,
0.3470313251,
0.4971587956,
0.1017674655,
0.4714972377,
-0.0418850072,
0.4436687529,
-0.2479559928,
-0.2582635581,
-0.2212735415,
-0.5390731096,
-0.8799896836,
0.1567439139,
-0.1030403227,
-0.0241057891
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06761v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06761v1
|
APAR: LLMs Can Do Auto-Parallel Auto-Regressive Decoding
| 2024-01-12T18:50:36 | 2024-01-12T18:50:36 |
Mingdao Liu, Aohan Zeng, Bowen Wang, Peng Zhang, Jie Tang, Yuxiao Dong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The massive adoption of large language models (LLMs) demands efficient
deployment strategies. However, the auto-regressive decoding process, which is
fundamental to how most LLMs generate text, poses challenges to achieve
efficient serving. In this work, we introduce a parallel auto-regressive
generation method. By instruct-tuning on general domain data that contains
hierarchical structures, we enable LLMs to independently plan their generation
process and perform auto-parallel auto-regressive (APAR) generation,
significantly reducing the number of generation steps. APAR alone can achieve
up to 2x speed-up, and when combined with speculative decoding, the speed-up
can reach up to 4x. In addition, APAR reduces the key-value cache consumption
and attention computation during generation. This leads to a throughput
increase of 20-70% and a latency reduce of 20-35% in high-throughput scenarios,
compared to state-of-the-art serving frameworks.
|
[
-0.3671404123,
-0.681016624,
0.2305285484,
0.3324922323,
-0.2951881588,
0.1797415018,
0.0294838399,
-0.2488753498,
-0.045775637,
0.509146452,
-0.6152833104,
-0.3551349044,
-0.6032166481,
0.3398372233,
-0.2454111278,
0.8957215548,
-0.0080141518,
-0.2453579307,
-0.1302814186,
0.279976517,
-0.4831237197,
-0.4975217879,
-0.7801733613,
0.0550150573,
0.0211676303,
0.6271020174,
0.7914941311,
1.3951691389,
0.5674287081,
0.3501189649,
0.3285538256,
0.6908431053,
-0.4135565758,
0.4935033917,
0.0590573438,
-0.3304501772,
-0.589081347,
-0.4849992394,
0.8086448908,
0.3236060739,
-0.6001431346,
0.2821938396,
0.0614050776,
0.839525938,
-0.6127764583,
0.2871410549,
-0.9184272289,
-0.2250833958,
-0.3488052785,
-0.4360616207,
-0.4570311904,
-0.4267838597,
-0.190854609,
-0.5439338088,
0.425229609,
0.7242694497,
0.9687839746,
0.5347172022,
-0.1882180125,
-0.1412811279,
-0.6782027483,
0.7168646455,
-0.6969185472,
0.160806343,
0.3632652462,
0.3176128566,
-0.3613673151,
-0.5508570671,
-0.4857280254,
0.3143306375,
-0.0107105318,
-0.2008054852,
-0.3792478442,
-0.0261718389,
0.0379773341,
0.6097053289,
-0.6763031483,
0.0762119815,
0.1279610097,
-0.0701909512,
0.6744067073,
0.582047224,
0.1150872707,
-0.0794433728,
-0.2271664292,
-0.1794119775,
-0.9263260365,
-0.2463968843,
0.3688380122,
0.3563849628,
0.0981086716,
0.2930212617,
-0.1618236005,
0.5875895619,
0.4331268072,
-0.0402800329,
0.2706608772,
-0.4434969127,
-0.5781756043,
-0.2381630689,
1.0519577265,
0.2168311328,
0.1382507235,
-0.1374772638,
-0.3294197321,
0.0816861764,
0.36173895,
-0.9171927571,
-0.3255930841,
-0.0842869729,
-0.5584451556,
-0.3335037231,
-0.3665491641,
-0.7863230109,
0.1776490062,
0.0682547167,
0.1533713192,
-0.3438021541,
-0.020300841,
0.2853892446,
0.2674169242,
0.1058645919,
-0.1104488373,
-1.0858075619,
0.5208614469,
0.1888796985,
0.6863367558,
-0.2548951209,
-0.170790121,
-0.6156876087,
0.4580234587,
-0.3998121321,
1.0154197216,
-0.4157694876,
-0.4591494799,
-0.0008745628,
0.0245005898,
-0.1662803143,
-0.7808042169,
0.5204879642,
-0.7169888616,
-0.0069601815,
-0.1492393017,
-0.526234746,
0.15441221,
-0.0643481687,
-0.3715035319,
0.8573902845,
-0.0869761705,
-0.4851485491,
0.4224162698,
-0.3042099178,
-0.7374342084,
0.0694381073,
-0.3489530683,
-0.8161043525,
0.0661761761,
0.8329201341,
0.5025045872,
-0.693208456,
0.167886883,
-0.0231102575,
-0.0357747935,
-0.3738885224,
-0.3678729534,
0.1661926806,
0.4702002108,
-0.5298792124,
-0.1855536252,
-0.8299729228,
-0.0731282458,
0.3520788848,
-0.2830134928,
-0.1624888182,
0.3356243074,
-0.1530012637,
0.0999430716,
0.1478820145,
-0.4472906888,
0.2934467196,
-0.4928945303,
0.2017689943,
0.6455484629,
0.2370279431,
0.339179039,
-0.4672985673,
0.7031779289,
0.1070018485,
0.1313991845,
-0.4949322343,
-0.2732481658,
-0.6572713852,
-0.5979515314,
-0.0857585073,
0.2850902975,
-0.6892333627,
0.5472780466,
0.0264090113,
-0.2843814492,
-0.7800337672,
0.2134501338,
0.6284172535,
0.7246022224,
0.4832543731,
-0.0572787486,
-0.6232088804,
-0.9645749927,
-0.1772905141,
0.0826362371,
0.3014802933,
0.4486332238,
0.0166394562,
-0.2391658425,
0.6425974965,
-0.6421154737,
-0.408562839,
-0.0190808177,
0.3029595315,
0.2053290308,
0.5445808768,
0.4431986213,
-0.5473350286,
-0.841352284,
-0.1134457141,
-0.5419894457,
-0.3265934289,
-0.1012185961,
-0.1976026297,
0.6296601892,
0.6364868879,
-0.563419044,
0.0835022479,
0.5099230409,
-0.3055170774,
0.4200669825,
-0.491743058,
0.1091271937,
-0.9723810554,
-0.2014363408,
-0.2704338431,
-0.2126013041,
-0.2680537105,
-0.0360202417,
0.0387260504,
-0.0007190779,
0.0902176946,
0.0145428544,
-0.9702835679,
-0.0300228782,
-0.5783228278,
-0.2651954293,
0.1770189703,
0.2804652452,
-0.0971519873,
1.1774570942,
0.7693836093,
-0.7743862271,
-0.0074217664,
0.341350168,
-0.1660090238,
0.0849948898,
-0.6748492122,
-0.0008995329,
-0.3031050265,
0.3646098673,
-1.2003580332,
-0.1320003867,
0.0287326183,
-0.2716194093,
0.3227714598,
0.1401642263,
-0.6375079751,
-0.2865323722,
0.0263731536,
0.6220362186,
0.6999346614,
-0.7232275605,
0.5163520575,
0.5076472163,
-0.2626358271,
-0.4945489764,
-0.6699832082,
-0.0068629347,
-0.1221424639,
-0.5173099041,
0.536741972,
-0.0787891448,
0.1008620337,
0.0437102541,
0.0775094107,
0.2203209996,
-0.1624097675,
0.0804198384,
0.2220543176,
-0.3810518384,
-0.0588548519,
0.3178998828,
-0.1433979422,
0.0272671469,
-0.3935524225,
0.676864624,
-0.1032492667,
-0.1568468511,
-0.5667710304,
0.6097487807,
0.6826560497,
-0.3601996005,
0.7081879377,
0.2019055188,
-0.0358828641,
-0.6142826676,
-0.4843526483,
0.1839137226,
-0.590041399,
0.2763333917,
-0.471421659,
-0.6608757973,
0.4099965096,
-0.1386327744,
0.176488325,
0.6207671165,
0.8479663134,
0.0963151231,
1.2947998047,
0.6849848032,
-0.2572287619,
0.2304158658,
-0.1678722799,
0.0140499799,
-0.470626086,
-0.2126000077,
-0.4165324867,
0.0407657064,
-0.5474331379,
-0.4316863418,
0.2449135333,
0.046900589,
-0.4075081646,
0.2064808756,
-0.7681677938,
0.2812473774,
0.1633198708,
-0.2651078999,
0.4378653765,
0.1518370807,
-0.1736234128,
0.1555286497,
-0.8297564983,
-0.4206064641,
1.020924449,
0.3457578719,
0.8567565084,
0.0811186433,
0.7843519449,
0.3718060255,
0.2512963414,
-0.5349167585,
0.3683181703,
-0.4844299853,
-0.1342668682,
-0.2592509687,
-0.4121572077,
-0.7920557261,
0.2763752639,
0.1265842021,
-0.1485266089,
0.4939830303,
0.5258282423,
-0.4333289266,
0.188618809,
-0.7651162148,
0.3234342337,
0.0827852637,
-0.0045044678,
-0.1290530264,
-0.2987668514,
0.2520659268,
-0.1623539925,
0.1566918641,
-0.0193451028,
-0.1532375365,
0.2528858483,
-0.457074821,
0.6351038218,
-0.2669133246,
-0.2108596563,
0.1277566105,
0.1283307225,
1.0756680965,
0.1384692639,
-0.0798859745,
-0.2816112041,
-0.3400040269,
-0.3287888169,
-0.5723460913,
0.6504993439,
-0.8382824063,
-0.6289851665,
-0.2372974306,
-0.7873903513,
-0.5087154508,
-0.0127293868,
0.4564186931,
0.3126741946,
0.018758975,
-0.1576549113,
0.667537272,
-0.1088795736,
0.6652182937,
0.5963482261,
-0.0191967599,
-0.5390893221,
0.9292795062,
-0.0216511134,
0.34149611,
0.3794626892,
-0.0175504871,
-0.2738567293,
-0.8654408455,
-0.4523695111,
0.2875445187,
-0.1576540619,
-0.6338132024,
-0.6295691133,
-0.1558615863,
-0.516446352,
-0.2024907619,
-0.5721575618,
-0.1338932961,
-0.35832268,
0.1407082677,
0.3309601843,
0.7361873984,
-0.164509058,
0.512081027,
-0.7025415897,
0.5858983397,
0.1331291944,
0.1602524668,
0.1413719952,
-0.4522688985,
-0.3365032673,
-0.3998144567,
-0.1703280956,
-0.423209995,
0.911644876,
0.5056616664,
0.4745678008,
0.3054094315,
0.2576109767,
0.8262671232,
-1.0319663286,
0.4747424722,
-0.1154466346,
-0.7098798156,
0.4102864265,
-0.4774519503,
0.4558018148,
0.4497877955,
0.4389002919,
0.1118106171,
-0.6307737231,
-0.3465767205,
-1.1928933859,
0.7230166793,
0.0781254247,
-0.0474363938,
-0.3803371191,
0.4162790775,
0.2271684855,
0.2862049341,
-0.1876172125,
-0.4839708507,
-0.3036431074,
-0.1110403761,
-0.1183914915,
-0.4664899111,
-0.0319310427,
-0.0549575612,
0.7025921345,
-0.1017253622,
0.4865026772,
0.2806857228,
0.0901795998,
-0.5011132956,
0.0487822555,
0.3369545937,
0.224437058,
-0.3236143887,
-0.0507871956,
-0.1562099606,
-0.4539041519,
0.1904644221,
0.2493600547,
-0.144943729,
-0.0332854092,
-0.1073306724,
0.8425998092,
-0.1283051968,
-0.4776566029,
0.1886998266,
-0.2692041695,
-0.3547213674,
-0.1537845433,
-0.0230080821,
-0.307528615,
0.3501755297,
0.6835692525,
0.0744425133,
0.1479075998,
-0.1514365077,
0.532993257,
0.3310584426,
0.3698658943,
-0.1181579828,
0.7551549673,
0.195153445,
-0.1067617461,
0.4072574377,
-0.2100603282,
-0.174313128,
0.5606006384,
1.0254174471,
1.0955357552,
-0.3370574117,
0.0783632621,
0.1959843636,
0.2382797003,
-0.0927524716,
0.3232438266,
-0.1095196679,
-0.7313375473,
-0.5663771629,
-0.942985177,
-0.2440184802,
0.0453130715,
-0.7737224698,
-0.3078687787,
-0.4065654278,
-0.0005916937,
-0.1781642437,
-0.0858581439,
-0.4520949423,
0.3462828994,
-0.025468206,
0.7411464453,
-0.6359431744,
0.9778101444,
0.5667130947,
-0.0222836547,
-0.8058575988,
0.5238031149,
-0.2373355329,
-1.0551505089,
0.8129453659,
-0.2404745966,
-0.4699787498,
0.3524339497,
-0.1047330275,
-1.2095218897,
1.0617878437,
0.496766299,
-0.8627694845,
-0.273308754,
0.2273566425,
0.5664738417,
-0.8728896379,
0.0888588876,
0.5137419701,
0.2100345194,
-0.0316953324,
-0.7748242617,
0.3556078076,
-0.2355899364,
0.3389030695,
0.2101036608,
-0.9607662559,
0.7775266767,
-0.046786692,
-0.5202545524,
0.042185232,
1.0065482855,
0.3185659945,
-0.189960748,
0.5849311352,
0.4326710105,
0.6054934263,
0.3338092566,
1.1492519379,
-0.7503296733,
0.1950169653,
1.0608597994,
-0.1652886271,
0.9216136932,
0.4633232951,
0.095888868,
0.4897544682,
0.3899569809,
-0.0816316679,
0.9471511841,
0.0742189065,
-0.1280969828,
-0.3413328528,
-0.0177560803,
-0.3943952918,
0.3474015892,
0.4186446667,
-0.5592986345,
-0.3778823912,
0.1239185184,
-0.0143916411,
0.2336186618,
-0.2873088717,
0.5730279684,
-0.0259080529,
-0.6954282522,
1.0402516127,
0.0170141663,
0.8054457903,
-0.5136753917,
-0.0167030636,
-0.1959373951,
0.4183342457,
-0.0640362725,
-0.4087666273,
0.5760903358,
-0.1477431357,
-0.6785758138,
-0.5102797747,
0.540106535,
-0.5176882148,
-0.2550040781,
0.2564074993,
0.4719618261,
-0.124459669,
0.1520938724,
-0.5254508853,
0.1082856953,
-0.0511992089,
-0.5027311444,
0.4977788925,
0.4752711356,
0.2001732886,
0.6066682339,
0.6040157676,
0.1500292867,
0.221554935,
0.0386655219,
1.0119643211,
-0.4971829951,
-0.4102996588,
-0.7687984109,
0.1855828762,
0.2699856162,
-0.3317410648,
0.7672728896,
0.4714838266,
0.6839196682,
-0.0549257956,
0.7974348068,
0.0049388967,
0.5516393185,
-0.4324015081,
0.6904089451,
-0.5534339547,
0.4226190448,
-0.0330032259,
-0.494723171,
-0.2032717913,
0.268421948,
0.0450766869,
-0.2844745815,
0.5663808584,
0.8450737596,
0.2192061692,
-0.1370251924,
0.3816123605,
0.3809662461,
0.315612942,
0.4265936911,
0.4500674009,
-0.5959020257,
0.726349771,
-0.2106851041,
-0.3161483705,
0.1514694095,
-0.8056405783,
-0.7612083554,
-0.4512839913,
-0.0453400575,
-0.130636394,
0.4511452019,
0.7478415966,
0.6066917777,
-0.8551151752,
-0.402479142,
-0.6347026825,
-0.3540761471,
-0.2531076372,
-0.280870527,
0.5934827924,
-1.0644483566,
-0.8799955845,
0.7219100595,
0.2767936885,
-0.140538618,
-0.227290228,
-0.0234067217,
-0.2476071715,
0.2869960368,
0.4424831569,
0.3525700867,
-0.3937169611,
0.0174883306,
-0.0102201262,
-0.1617829949,
0.143221885,
0.686496675,
-0.8364396691,
0.2308374941,
0.2978588343,
0.9168168306,
0.5807777643,
0.2405106425,
1.0990815163,
-0.7703205347,
-0.0007083341,
0.1960768849,
0.3259834051,
-0.0256023258,
-0.828866899,
0.0527064018,
0.1899107844,
-0.9362843633,
-0.8809619546,
0.3162408471,
-0.57895118,
-0.1343031228,
1.053622365,
-0.0285597537,
-0.2175699472,
-0.1559322178,
0.0276993066,
0.1189036742,
-0.7211334109,
0.7782738209,
0.1705092043,
-0.5030391812,
-0.2363809943,
-0.085393101,
0.8738985062,
0.5898801684,
-0.8397576809,
0.4046314657,
0.3198194504,
0.054581631,
-0.1899552792,
0.7241694927,
-0.2491583973,
0.1201611012,
0.1217198074,
0.0181964766,
-0.4231787026,
-0.401822269,
-0.3008845448,
0.3947607577,
-0.0068657184,
-0.4568499327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06760v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06760v2
|
Navigating the Metrics Maze: Reconciling Score Magnitudes and Accuracies
| 2024-01-12T18:47:40 | 2024-06-10T12:57:48 |
Tom Kocmi, Vilém Zouhar, Christian Federmann, Matt Post
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Ten years ago a single metric, BLEU, governed progress in machine translation
research. For better or worse, there is no such consensus today, and
consequently it is difficult for researchers to develop and retain the kinds of
heuristic intuitions about metric deltas that drove earlier research and
deployment decisions. This paper investigates the "dynamic range" of a number
of modern metrics in an effort to provide a collective understanding of the
meaning of differences in scores both within and among metrics; in other words,
we ask what point difference X in metric Y is required between two systems for
humans to notice? We conduct our evaluation on a new large dataset, ToShip23,
using it to discover deltas at which metrics achieve system-level differences
that are meaningful to humans, which we measure by pairwise system accuracy. We
additionally show that this method of establishing delta-accuracy is more
stable than the standard use of statistical p-values in regards to testset
size. Where data size permits, we also explore the effect of metric deltas and
accuracy across finer-grained features such as translation direction, domain,
and system closeness.
|
[
-0.4442324042,
-0.4235056341,
0.5907315612,
0.3988851011,
-0.0041571269,
0.3046278059,
-0.2665591836,
-0.4751887321,
-0.0121854162,
-0.0310007036,
-0.5849837661,
-0.53125,
-0.8624132872,
0.0847649649,
-0.4620291889,
0.8187593818,
-0.1591721922,
-0.0333230384,
0.1499451101,
-0.4426996708,
-0.7167065144,
-0.1258526742,
-0.4174916744,
-0.12103194,
0.8831855059,
0.5148128271,
0.8223574162,
0.8507633805,
1.0485411882,
0.1692531705,
-0.2516919374,
0.1240051761,
-0.4792591035,
0.4726199806,
-0.1184222996,
-0.6241503954,
-0.4188985527,
-0.0814237371,
0.9220454097,
1.1474820375,
0.3083082736,
0.3937363923,
0.0126217399,
1.1230067015,
-0.5374993086,
0.0112641482,
-0.0877173841,
0.1245749369,
-0.3497676253,
0.0153841134,
-0.1624782979,
-0.4021479785,
0.1828925908,
-0.7106989622,
0.023818817,
-0.1072515324,
0.9826940894,
0.3839855492,
-0.7514121532,
-0.2954753041,
-0.7873751521,
1.0646891594,
-0.2276382595,
0.7668798566,
0.2453876883,
0.5562580228,
-0.4038592875,
-0.6019070745,
-0.0798474029,
-0.0608855076,
0.1147659644,
-0.0010995618,
-0.240679577,
-0.4387123287,
0.1646675915,
0.3659286201,
-0.2862366438,
0.1484130919,
-0.5847938657,
-0.1260891855,
0.8543320894,
0.4671835005,
-0.0369824655,
-0.0371588096,
-0.1619814932,
-0.3863215744,
-0.5375968218,
0.2983091474,
0.0799907073,
0.3523851335,
-0.2377754599,
0.3508796394,
-0.4426206648,
0.3708464801,
0.1360599399,
0.0837417543,
0.3100357056,
-0.5115986466,
-0.0119999135,
-0.2240638286,
0.6733068824,
0.7272152901,
0.1622924954,
-0.3876724839,
-0.3239840865,
0.0133173093,
0.4423270524,
-0.577471137,
-0.279140681,
0.0349242799,
-0.4897858799,
-0.1258756816,
0.1906319261,
-0.7436479926,
-0.4693590105,
-0.3321330249,
0.2953486741,
-0.4116372764,
-0.237362504,
-0.0474638082,
-0.3313522339,
0.2756564915,
0.5555745363,
-0.5713605285,
0.2991678119,
0.63386482,
1.1357592344,
-0.3133398592,
-0.2575100064,
-0.3025887311,
-0.2810727954,
-0.8219763041,
0.3554795086,
-0.2654012442,
-0.7315713763,
-0.3056439757,
-0.0283557698,
0.1820971668,
-0.5421692133,
0.4082368612,
-0.4538121819,
0.0212264825,
-0.5931881666,
-0.4291312993,
-0.4978992045,
0.2800784111,
-0.4801521599,
1.05245924,
0.1655024439,
-0.2009959817,
0.68124789,
-0.8068529367,
-0.3330783248,
-0.0794618428,
0.0427567028,
-0.2145877928,
0.3743296564,
-0.1594747007,
0.1859578341,
-0.1806890517,
-0.0064927572,
-0.0543812476,
-0.4019597173,
0.1995772421,
-0.4536422193,
0.7815632224,
0.2432466149,
-0.2482971698,
-0.1746659875,
-0.5754304528,
-0.0667280704,
-0.1953639835,
-0.570258677,
-0.3264748156,
0.0204411242,
-0.3119218647,
0.1363348812,
0.3686906695,
-0.2839187682,
0.0024584485,
0.0320863985,
0.1769177914,
0.6674977541,
-0.0329033248,
0.6807103753,
-0.4110562205,
0.4608443975,
0.0762770176,
0.1136511043,
-0.321251601,
-0.6595891714,
-0.5976823568,
-0.1568926275,
0.4272787869,
0.547160089,
-0.0681846067,
0.6240296364,
-0.5762823224,
-0.8004992008,
-0.5578771234,
-0.0053300858,
0.0763135254,
0.3472081423,
0.5005204082,
-0.6861467361,
-0.2286587656,
-0.6339837909,
-0.3581756353,
-0.1136346161,
-0.3365523219,
0.0115878265,
0.5488847494,
-0.0910522193,
0.5771328807,
-0.429818809,
-0.0596630275,
0.36272946,
0.0870200619,
-0.0360147543,
0.6381317973,
0.2902039289,
-0.7221922874,
-0.3390407562,
0.0712786689,
-0.7671509981,
0.0287366044,
-0.1834509522,
-0.3634106219,
-0.0212520882,
0.6170565486,
-0.3719627857,
0.4520155489,
0.5185507536,
-0.4175051153,
0.7112717628,
-0.3374821842,
0.4063129723,
-0.8015944958,
0.3225771189,
0.2494177073,
-0.0248824507,
-0.5836794376,
0.2055954039,
0.1412997544,
0.4577749074,
-0.0441438556,
0.6177926064,
-0.4473422766,
-0.2187896371,
0.1122651622,
0.4171003401,
0.0637273565,
-0.0280658677,
-0.4273111224,
0.641243875,
0.5247622728,
-0.8101571798,
0.423691839,
0.2934940457,
-0.4454086423,
0.9775077701,
-0.1317446083,
-0.0658656284,
0.0400088206,
0.278087914,
-1.1679040194,
-0.0238189343,
0.1179999858,
-0.9137724638,
-0.0066080634,
0.0298333261,
-0.3226265609,
-0.2243003398,
-0.0728414878,
0.6041772366,
0.5155227184,
-0.079366602,
0.0618504137,
0.3017906547,
-0.0947626159,
-0.4874191582,
-0.8419274688,
0.3501859009,
-0.4003808498,
-0.4999598861,
0.1029617935,
-0.0250799861,
-0.6243078113,
-0.3395727277,
-0.3767297864,
-0.0557433069,
0.4706762433,
0.4844915867,
0.1393423975,
-0.474722743,
0.481441319,
-0.0229587127,
-0.1748483628,
0.3059182167,
-0.3752651215,
0.2349188775,
-0.1961911619,
-0.1277247816,
-0.3939291537,
0.2116311044,
0.687202096,
-0.1738350242,
0.5505253077,
0.540722847,
-0.3926910162,
0.1498916596,
-0.0765297711,
-0.2323891222,
-0.4263020456,
0.4163873792,
-0.5343942046,
-0.5275507569,
0.7184063792,
-0.3388240337,
0.4030578136,
0.5188564658,
0.4405281842,
-0.3187672794,
0.8694565296,
0.5368033648,
0.1732521206,
0.4524943829,
-0.1370340735,
0.246449858,
-0.8902276158,
-0.4034126699,
-0.700981915,
-0.8731296659,
-1.0110161304,
-0.5575889945,
0.4798125029,
0.2065375,
-0.5028349161,
0.0939847305,
-0.2981987596,
0.3523882627,
0.4782477021,
-0.0809637308,
0.3196747005,
-0.2719107568,
-0.1794017553,
-0.0806177482,
-0.553435266,
-0.4590828419,
1.0596126318,
0.3982657194,
0.3589310944,
0.3494266272,
0.4175716341,
0.4546207786,
0.3088935614,
-0.922744453,
0.4432507753,
-0.2725219131,
-0.5910924077,
-0.5795358419,
-0.5929630399,
-1.1525166035,
0.1581981778,
-0.1057101786,
-0.7404547334,
0.0896828622,
-0.0913261622,
-0.4056341648,
0.1757787615,
-0.5175341964,
0.8822905421,
-0.3248288631,
-0.1758242548,
-0.1824385822,
-1.0496520996,
0.1573135853,
-0.1623075753,
0.3265558481,
-0.1962704062,
-0.2449745983,
0.6752031446,
-0.0247884504,
0.4160478413,
-0.0072453185,
-0.3266076744,
-0.1798402369,
0.7090620399,
0.1136032045,
-0.1518728286,
-0.3047071993,
0.5066049695,
0.0867345259,
-0.6798582673,
-0.4149362147,
0.5601009727,
-0.6029275656,
-0.4183426201,
-0.1511279941,
-0.8816128373,
-0.0811375454,
0.2924462557,
0.024897024,
0.140326336,
-0.1861758679,
0.282291919,
0.5436091423,
-0.161439985,
0.2634495497,
0.4111073613,
-0.1625147015,
-0.0120873889,
0.7096079588,
0.2225331515,
0.380294174,
0.5163145065,
0.0451720729,
-0.391813457,
-0.4345388114,
-0.7449346185,
0.1486683935,
-0.6289304495,
0.0962577611,
-0.080636017,
0.1104269922,
-0.1230661124,
-0.3502669632,
-0.4795838892,
-0.5632615089,
-0.0735247061,
-0.0079791229,
0.1735228449,
0.9578470588,
-0.2457501888,
0.172649011,
-0.9589787126,
-0.1671952009,
-0.3681788445,
0.2535670996,
0.0330092497,
-0.8630490303,
-0.6782309413,
0.298471868,
-0.3166553676,
-0.7504709959,
0.1614975035,
-0.2309440225,
0.4394573867,
0.3857542872,
-0.0876183584,
0.7236588597,
-0.3246749938,
0.9470021725,
0.1891044229,
-0.8950118423,
0.278889358,
-0.281394124,
0.6599187255,
0.5367825627,
0.5885930061,
-1.0735592842,
-0.4696370661,
-0.3943593204,
-0.7033150196,
0.2735590339,
0.1944399327,
-0.0574382767,
0.5070074201,
0.423653841,
0.23639521,
0.2040249705,
0.006479152,
-0.350715369,
0.1433981806,
-0.2335676849,
-0.471813947,
0.5600473881,
-0.1417833865,
-0.2147715837,
0.2632632852,
0.0213218257,
0.1988997459,
-0.0876987055,
-0.0420859046,
-0.3692370951,
-0.0259365849,
0.5971907377,
0.7629884481,
-0.1331409067,
0.2185869962,
0.1679378748,
-0.5808531046,
0.1878712177,
-0.0930540338,
-0.0264177639,
0.063661173,
0.2377914339,
0.6100698113,
-0.1854752451,
-0.4519056082,
0.1729269773,
0.0410188958,
-0.1031614244,
-0.0441723466,
-0.0604358539,
0.0081250677,
0.2574650645,
0.3061256707,
0.3079316318,
-0.0943475217,
-0.4994164109,
0.3965604007,
0.1177258566,
-0.7139840126,
-0.4383441508,
0.4905287921,
0.2978231311,
-0.6935006976,
0.743301332,
-0.1970978975,
-0.3958083093,
0.6369557977,
-0.1299667954,
0.701071918,
-0.2884257436,
0.2233135402,
0.3557185531,
0.3707375824,
-0.2842798233,
-0.1114241183,
-0.211644724,
-0.6787642837,
-0.1853585392,
-0.5648491383,
-0.4190825522,
-0.1520109028,
-0.7361162901,
0.2051556706,
-0.3053906262,
-0.3564014137,
0.2054208964,
0.1583184153,
-0.6245719194,
0.4176484942,
0.0294660889,
0.9302911758,
-0.656960547,
0.4062406421,
0.8072023392,
-0.347777158,
-0.6074607968,
0.2726074159,
0.2769818008,
-0.4375716746,
0.7220966816,
0.0501634367,
-0.1297413856,
-0.0378232449,
-0.1063996926,
-0.9245593548,
1.2700798512,
-0.0803856105,
-0.609089613,
-0.1476669163,
0.1926945299,
0.721614778,
-0.0867818221,
0.0962905288,
0.8935285807,
0.7542731762,
-0.2265872061,
-1.0578612089,
0.1215422079,
0.0560511872,
-0.348031044,
0.6955540776,
-0.7161102295,
0.7793844938,
-0.2773077488,
-0.1411197484,
0.1755752563,
0.3118816614,
0.1530309916,
0.5452913046,
0.3701531291,
0.2559995353,
0.9651926756,
-0.3764310479,
0.8186013699,
-0.1940953732,
0.2513002753,
0.7080689073,
-0.0046919193,
0.688385129,
0.6069510579,
-0.3201174736,
0.582828939,
0.9003103375,
0.0040650396,
0.1626519561,
0.4609885812,
-0.1896521151,
-0.1755558401,
0.2426478267,
-0.1500063241,
0.3778987527,
0.6155081391,
-0.3864992559,
-0.3151360154,
-0.1685729325,
0.1570041478,
0.031273488,
-0.1296737194,
0.4828745425,
0.3420548439,
-0.8229861259,
0.7301896214,
0.1069674119,
0.3165254593,
-0.5018200874,
0.2076642811,
-0.5632818937,
0.3194895089,
-0.0220314041,
-1.069190383,
0.2350351363,
-0.0290324297,
-0.1929462701,
-0.2205536813,
0.0187085159,
-0.0745201185,
-0.2760872543,
0.2841981649,
0.8717692494,
0.5231477618,
-0.0030239264,
-0.6374025941,
0.0374343321,
-0.0585527308,
-0.0947002396,
0.2014659196,
0.9572920203,
-0.4060231447,
0.8434396982,
0.5045141578,
0.1900887191,
0.2632951736,
-0.3010366559,
0.3487794399,
-0.8362894654,
-0.6181018949,
-0.6596651673,
0.446610719,
0.0773439258,
-0.6927866936,
0.7736784816,
0.4914900959,
0.8657680154,
0.1718548685,
0.6317655444,
-0.0811584294,
0.2568684816,
-0.1559908688,
0.5602501035,
-0.7107834816,
0.3627461493,
0.0811925381,
-0.7753359675,
-0.5947019458,
0.4745102823,
-0.3283472657,
0.0312465355,
0.7916258574,
0.8117545843,
0.0616338626,
-0.1469609886,
0.4183223844,
0.2516846061,
0.4074762464,
0.5290760994,
0.8488445878,
-0.5021712184,
0.6026642323,
0.2246237695,
-0.2206609249,
-0.3310956657,
-0.5862995982,
-0.2324504256,
-0.6325637102,
-0.1764513552,
-0.4536934793,
0.3211475313,
0.5451653004,
0.6317058206,
-0.631724596,
-0.6189947128,
-0.0930211321,
0.1194102541,
-0.566213429,
-0.2067184746,
0.1928025484,
-0.3214094043,
-0.7078322768,
0.2758812904,
0.2590510249,
0.0788524225,
-0.4944918156,
-0.3961111009,
-0.1100637764,
0.1685303748,
0.3021908402,
0.227068305,
-0.4968461692,
-0.4199371338,
0.1511860341,
-0.2872031033,
0.2796936035,
0.5935794115,
-0.5998088717,
0.3818565905,
0.4801001847,
0.5500566363,
0.1795306802,
0.0745589286,
0.7430410385,
-0.6816956997,
-0.1608404517,
-0.0336210206,
-0.1340657622,
0.528707087,
-0.0191308428,
0.5500297546,
0.3961079717,
-0.7255685329,
-0.844853878,
0.2683338225,
-0.8884738088,
-0.2030212283,
0.9774411917,
-0.3011903763,
-0.1139828339,
-0.1717745662,
0.0011641621,
0.2617418468,
-0.5489647388,
1.1989411116,
1.0091360807,
-0.1877917051,
0.2219339013,
-0.5769917369,
0.5390718579,
0.5393314362,
-0.5412116051,
-0.0250152238,
0.4454918504,
0.2235020995,
0.5733790398,
0.1537148207,
-0.0703157783,
0.420563966,
0.2868703902,
-0.2676236928,
0.4861609042,
-0.3946980536,
-0.3861130178,
-0.0693213642,
0.0078987777,
-0.540294826
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06752v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06752v1
|
Stylometry Analysis of Multi-authored Documents for Authorship and Author Style Change Detection
| 2024-01-12T18:36:41 | 2024-01-12T18:36:41 |
Muhammad Tayyab Zamir, Muhammad Asif Ayub, Asma Gul, Nasir Ahmad, Kashif Ahmad
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In recent years, the increasing use of Artificial Intelligence based text
generation tools has posed new challenges in document provenance,
authentication, and authorship detection. However, advancements in stylometry
have provided opportunities for automatic authorship and author change
detection in multi-authored documents using style analysis techniques. Style
analysis can serve as a primary step toward document provenance and
authentication through authorship detection. This paper investigates three key
tasks of style analysis: (i) classification of single and multi-authored
documents, (ii) single change detection, which involves identifying the point
where the author switches, and (iii) multiple author-switching detection in
multi-authored documents. We formulate all three tasks as classification
problems and propose a merit-based fusion framework that integrates several
state-of-the-art natural language processing (NLP) algorithms and weight
optimization techniques. We also explore the potential of special characters,
which are typically removed during pre-processing in NLP applications, on the
performance of the proposed methods for these tasks by conducting extensive
experiments on both cleaned and raw datasets. Experimental results demonstrate
significant improvements over existing solutions for all three tasks on a
benchmark dataset.
|
[
-0.1936020255,
-0.4935232699,
0.4815413952,
0.0814184919,
0.0171674471,
0.0811508372,
-0.0923545435,
-0.8385689259,
0.4557096064,
0.654209733,
-0.8529147506,
-0.4527762532,
-0.6888500452,
0.601295352,
-0.2557123601,
1.0554722548,
-0.4568798244,
0.1122670919,
-0.282035917,
-0.4468107522,
-0.3808425665,
-0.4016546607,
-0.5862250328,
-0.0324555226,
0.571598649,
0.2805124819,
0.454408139,
0.5650247931,
0.8601850271,
0.3463563919,
0.2021287382,
0.1038990244,
-0.1586143672,
0.4039405882,
0.091939196,
-0.2717172801,
-0.3544315696,
0.0149046872,
0.8712876439,
0.4629913867,
0.2144212872,
0.2913939357,
-0.006188035,
0.7248117328,
-0.5893012285,
0.0026208228,
-0.2413906902,
-0.0630153939,
-0.8886769414,
-0.3896887004,
-0.4178903699,
-0.3339876831,
-0.164830938,
-0.3748836219,
0.4051620662,
0.1478731334,
0.7458182573,
0.2706696093,
-0.4357637167,
-0.245799914,
-0.5200707316,
0.9452244043,
-0.6520678997,
0.5220865011,
0.0447004698,
0.1198977754,
0.011675708,
-0.4887842536,
-0.6385599971,
-0.0464132875,
-0.461891681,
0.0158333126,
-0.1061899439,
-0.0745996982,
0.1566137224,
0.2809796035,
-0.5255061388,
0.1775208712,
-0.326123327,
-0.3559063375,
1.0271911621,
-0.1149105728,
0.7727579474,
-0.2146130204,
-0.4241927266,
-0.4040507674,
-0.337167263,
0.0936250389,
0.7606765628,
0.4219228625,
-0.1059261337,
0.144829452,
-0.0446971171,
0.6011067033,
-0.21715343,
-0.1791626662,
0.2808307111,
-0.7833873034,
-0.0053761452,
0.1282721758,
0.8414657712,
-0.0698551387,
-0.0991563872,
-0.0747165754,
0.0243793596,
-0.1978233755,
0.1024331748,
-0.3401019573,
-0.2872641683,
0.2459677905,
-0.6912134886,
-0.2803945243,
0.2006374598,
-0.8478601575,
-0.8103065491,
-0.6516085267,
0.4585257173,
-0.5301097631,
-0.5281633735,
-0.1156778485,
-0.5331145525,
0.2430348247,
0.460706532,
-0.8979021907,
0.0291911084,
0.5807676315,
0.6198176146,
-0.5643182993,
-0.6443784237,
-0.2914233208,
-0.1195988655,
-0.1470396519,
0.9074370265,
-0.4732094407,
0.030687958,
-0.1785341501,
-0.1412099004,
-0.3813687265,
-0.0153973307,
0.4615318775,
-0.2685657442,
0.1107788384,
-0.5187302828,
-0.3653672636,
-0.0195005126,
0.0098934397,
-1.03995049,
1.0631649494,
0.073062852,
-0.856193006,
0.5925691724,
-0.7132906914,
-0.6031323075,
0.2201272696,
-0.019273879,
-0.6263816953,
0.0126782544,
0.0701734126,
0.2464058846,
-0.1459383518,
-0.0062378361,
-0.2089134157,
-0.2125683576,
0.1018392369,
0.1629388481,
1.1357861757,
0.0378268659,
-0.2794074118,
0.4689338505,
-0.7034223676,
-0.0668623671,
-0.0210959669,
-0.1677003205,
-0.3852557838,
-0.047853902,
0.5025154352,
0.0251278095,
0.2991632521,
-0.466765523,
0.4392658174,
-0.0799067989,
-0.0714970902,
0.7453123331,
-0.0192321315,
0.2558252513,
-0.5547311902,
0.4475974441,
-0.4116116762,
0.0850885436,
-0.1397702992,
-0.6194490194,
-0.6790885925,
-0.4137255251,
0.2358664572,
0.4861635864,
-0.7612774968,
0.3545528352,
-0.0461830795,
-0.6681780219,
-0.5606637001,
0.3394632041,
0.3558391929,
0.1029476747,
0.5864014626,
-0.2358802706,
-0.5182963014,
-0.9092838764,
-1.0901736021,
-0.0043116701,
0.0019102747,
-0.1903781593,
0.6013785601,
-0.0532056019,
0.9246451855,
-0.5062653422,
-0.3167413473,
-0.2690784037,
0.6162078381,
-0.0577246509,
0.6566346884,
0.7968466282,
-1.0807846785,
-0.4903692305,
-0.0334884934,
-0.7409054041,
-0.3882013261,
-0.3629066646,
-0.1376404464,
0.2890486717,
0.6359127164,
-0.2732765973,
0.2981608212,
0.3055708408,
-0.3271687925,
0.8378902674,
0.1586432904,
0.6627019048,
-0.9288973212,
0.3417835236,
0.2207426131,
0.1356897205,
-1.0571488142,
0.3673415184,
0.119909279,
-0.0280727539,
-0.2919301093,
0.6419845223,
-0.5468630195,
-0.0141464248,
0.0757823288,
-0.3414326608,
0.0146886082,
0.5159122944,
-0.0224299058,
0.2969687879,
0.282691747,
-0.3323590159,
0.4236623049,
-0.0314429514,
-0.1043302789,
0.7584360242,
-0.2599084079,
0.3562177122,
-0.3315576911,
-0.0276490189,
-1.4541424513,
-0.1235930547,
0.349283725,
-0.1882370859,
0.4682937264,
-0.2129102051,
-0.7586735487,
-0.1001688614,
-0.6690576673,
0.1921070218,
-0.2077457756,
-0.3444110453,
0.8868201375,
0.1638089716,
-0.5607923865,
-0.2318207622,
-0.2614728808,
0.0368446782,
-0.2295975685,
-0.8112465739,
0.5958253741,
-0.0432212353,
-0.3106164634,
-0.0372814499,
-0.0844167545,
-0.2881861627,
0.1958426535,
-0.0212505646,
0.487653017,
0.0992028415,
0.2167752087,
0.2894090414,
-0.2116983533,
-0.2810521722,
-0.0886902064,
0.3436706066,
-0.0880575478,
-0.2734103203,
-0.7364349961,
0.5325428843,
0.5804207325,
-0.5094987154,
0.593477726,
1.0381036997,
-0.2742314935,
-0.1430272758,
-0.5952910781,
-0.1516744345,
-0.4392438233,
0.136503309,
-0.2597400248,
-0.6079781651,
0.6392673254,
0.1910262704,
0.3868498206,
0.8540970087,
0.2715331912,
-0.0447168835,
0.4414907694,
0.72908777,
0.0440353826,
0.6750231981,
0.201117903,
0.0874144211,
-0.4501761496,
-0.0317901559,
-0.8441032171,
-0.7698107362,
-0.5685307384,
-0.1405741423,
0.411036998,
-0.2387415767,
0.1369529814,
0.7626437545,
-0.8490279913,
0.3667879701,
0.7292041183,
-0.1215689555,
0.4878924191,
-0.0830466822,
0.3213895261,
-0.2502855361,
-0.0565444268,
-0.1617905498,
1.0525019169,
-0.0482150055,
0.5816159844,
0.3838277161,
0.8316506743,
0.5624476671,
0.2203003466,
-0.6994765997,
0.479510963,
-0.2125604153,
-0.3953969181,
-0.6213389039,
-0.556265533,
-0.70295614,
0.5168241858,
-0.5388390422,
-0.7745781541,
0.2561781406,
0.1054200679,
0.0153230336,
0.3957546353,
-0.6070318222,
0.9024458528,
-0.4018551409,
-0.2919115126,
0.0375648886,
-0.6958653927,
0.326197505,
-0.170286566,
0.0043523274,
-0.0214575976,
0.2979353368,
1.249245286,
-0.0081824614,
0.5027197599,
-0.0820367709,
-0.08437033,
-0.0508273058,
0.0826852918,
0.3886103034,
-0.1958901286,
-0.3803161979,
0.3956735432,
0.3616858721,
-0.2010962963,
-0.2752814889,
0.5214585662,
-0.3501675725,
-0.3462697566,
-0.6298055053,
-0.4533285797,
-0.2301913351,
0.5507538915,
0.3853911757,
0.2222602963,
-0.0397229157,
0.2157645673,
0.2072734386,
0.0312896445,
0.5119423866,
0.3109626174,
0.1753652543,
-0.0879332721,
0.7588050365,
0.336327225,
-0.0407491587,
0.4967396855,
0.4128980637,
-0.1725945622,
-0.6373723149,
-0.7004394531,
0.2148994505,
-0.4544867277,
-0.0009440432,
-0.5693232417,
0.151776582,
-0.8019248843,
-0.402186811,
0.01264288,
-0.2394267023,
-0.2466129959,
0.3089258075,
0.4192423522,
0.5808253884,
0.3249269128,
0.0998803005,
-0.8221610188,
0.2788167,
0.2750347257,
0.1871715486,
-0.231155619,
-0.0917541087,
-0.0498359464,
-0.3226756454,
-0.3222519755,
-1.1034045219,
0.2187179029,
0.1956498474,
0.6631775498,
0.2529807985,
0.1217090413,
0.3295560479,
-0.0788347051,
0.5592036247,
0.2001493275,
-1.0595272779,
0.5022806525,
-0.4133089781,
0.1367522627,
0.9993304014,
0.3035646975,
-0.8256629109,
-0.3689420819,
-0.4492230117,
-0.7719691992,
1.0282046795,
0.2665064931,
-0.3632197678,
0.8236266971,
0.2583987415,
0.2863664925,
0.2978851795,
-0.5476517677,
-0.1286001056,
-0.0127775948,
-0.4240211546,
0.0361219756,
0.1957483739,
-0.2807871401,
-0.0889949873,
0.4359496236,
-0.3377656937,
-0.1035546213,
0.086756818,
-0.1663050354,
0.1040767282,
0.6022595167,
0.5312848091,
0.7618634105,
-0.1985849738,
-0.0879028961,
0.0902147666,
-0.4142375588,
-0.1632937789,
0.4287564158,
-0.146677956,
0.1044940129,
0.9245300889,
0.5952321291,
0.2773135304,
-0.1873434037,
0.4965695143,
0.1781182885,
-0.1156056672,
-0.0695831254,
0.224382624,
-0.2190109044,
-0.2035001367,
0.6701732874,
0.4858343899,
0.4009256959,
-0.5560849905,
0.2432628274,
0.3496233225,
-0.2775675654,
-0.3888030648,
0.3665560782,
0.3524081409,
-0.1946631968,
0.2115017772,
-0.2955134809,
-0.411622256,
0.7403345704,
0.330863893,
0.9299001098,
-0.5122619271,
0.2860333323,
0.1301229149,
0.3064675033,
-0.1808727235,
0.0650895238,
-0.1819840968,
-0.8160858154,
0.0324018411,
-0.7971912026,
-0.5099153519,
-0.2769976258,
-0.7053976655,
0.3375567794,
-0.4177705348,
-0.0287008546,
0.5932843089,
0.0283721406,
-0.5636610985,
-0.1438327581,
-0.1135343537,
0.1561959684,
-1.1177408695,
0.3705741763,
0.6988506317,
-0.2536549568,
-0.43435359,
-0.0360396728,
0.8274458647,
-0.4635187984,
0.6675513387,
0.241874963,
-0.4255459607,
-0.0666126385,
-0.351144582,
-0.749853611,
0.8968236446,
0.4459100068,
-0.2563963532,
-0.0692915991,
-0.2217935324,
0.4063303471,
0.0361555107,
-0.0317206345,
0.5496014357,
0.8231747746,
-0.0168381296,
-1.0279055834,
0.0152821355,
-0.4277845323,
-0.1941627115,
0.6658234,
-0.5402550697,
1.2233290672,
0.2480318844,
-0.5669939518,
-0.1933388561,
0.359361887,
0.2016930729,
0.388171494,
0.6224601269,
0.5140852332,
0.9307151437,
-0.2086078376,
0.938488543,
-0.1283103824,
0.4516502321,
0.7516024709,
-0.4571148455,
0.6543108821,
0.3829366565,
-0.368185401,
0.5972275734,
0.2703863382,
-0.3953117728,
-0.0823103487,
0.0891273469,
-0.0651720464,
-0.1876299828,
0.0480942056,
-0.5541889668,
0.6738744378,
-0.1177104637,
-0.2656228244,
-0.0525391065,
0.1170490906,
0.3326995671,
-0.0344683789,
-0.1615103483,
0.7487456799,
-0.2485499531,
-0.5869979262,
-0.0081769722,
0.1032278836,
0.8573121428,
-0.8523240089,
0.0058621517,
0.1589576602,
0.0858118832,
-0.4968093932,
-0.6509805322,
0.1679987013,
-0.2115149498,
-0.2254658937,
-0.6843226552,
1.0452325344,
-0.4858154356,
-0.8215187192,
0.2263048589,
0.2776044607,
-0.1372341663,
0.020990653,
-0.5043276548,
0.1901366562,
-0.0277363174,
-0.0596232489,
0.3297185004,
-0.131548509,
0.0278026722,
0.3848680556,
0.920358479,
0.0954490155,
-0.2495506853,
0.0325394012,
0.4945068359,
-0.6368634701,
-0.7540843487,
-0.9024661183,
0.3230122328,
-0.3557994664,
-0.5904605389,
1.0384578705,
0.3340781927,
0.5408822894,
-0.0871605352,
0.6389033794,
-0.0741200671,
0.3144187033,
-0.8188839555,
1.2438331842,
-0.7277228236,
-0.0338347666,
-0.9141619205,
-0.849296689,
-0.6505960822,
0.1645826101,
-0.1316165328,
0.1095234752,
0.8514262438,
0.621502161,
0.2291713953,
0.2936942279,
-0.2015997618,
-0.3877356946,
0.3692974746,
0.3366869688,
0.2217982262,
-0.412204802,
0.2810209095,
-0.0237303842,
-0.3760577142,
-0.630384326,
-0.7288811207,
-0.5456504822,
-0.9380379319,
-0.4998123348,
-0.0593363121,
-0.1534763426,
0.6898516417,
0.7064836025,
-0.893558979,
-0.1802244186,
0.2989120781,
0.3756560683,
-0.8093774915,
-0.230648905,
0.6698054075,
-0.2616394162,
-0.6867467761,
0.503936708,
0.5090864897,
-0.1883627325,
-0.1331504732,
0.3216863275,
-0.3863668442,
-0.1558203846,
0.4305205345,
0.4525945783,
-0.5445153117,
-0.3266902864,
-0.1644099504,
-0.0783278048,
-0.0457845367,
1.1410021782,
-0.1644792259,
0.7001215816,
1.0058898926,
0.703438282,
0.2934745848,
0.2753988802,
0.2854609191,
-0.8412145376,
-0.2034938186,
0.1619054824,
0.431333065,
0.2909090519,
-0.5020383,
0.376465708,
0.5817865133,
-0.403878361,
-0.7523689866,
0.2030979693,
-1.0876120329,
-0.2713873684,
0.7295173407,
0.2667287588,
-0.0149193052,
-0.3658474982,
-0.1406256258,
0.1830444932,
-0.3459779024,
0.548342824,
0.9246766567,
-0.5530967116,
-0.2526094317,
-0.0587997548,
0.8107326031,
0.3633095026,
-1.2001826763,
0.0736405775,
0.3736743629,
-0.0448811948,
0.7609562874,
0.7507684827,
-0.0071646725,
0.2363271713,
0.0001240459,
0.158730939,
-0.1920687258,
-0.5665932298,
-0.1782806516,
0.4789185524,
-0.4297882915,
-0.1078005582
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06751v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06751v2
|
The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Easy Training Data for Hard Tasks
| 2024-01-12T18:36:29 | 2024-06-05T14:10:11 |
Peter Hase, Mohit Bansal, Peter Clark, Sarah Wiegreffe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
How can we train models to perform well on hard test data when hard training
data is by definition difficult to label correctly? This question has been
termed the scalable oversight problem and has drawn increasing attention as
language models have continually improved. In this paper, we present the
surprising conclusion that current pretrained language models often generalize
relatively well from easy to hard data, even performing as well as oracle
models finetuned on hard data. We demonstrate this kind of easy-to-hard
generalization using simple finetuning methods like in-context learning, linear
classifier heads, and QLoRA for seven different measures of datapoint hardness,
including six empirically diverse human hardness measures (like grade level)
and one model-based measure (loss-based). Furthermore, we show that even if one
cares most about model performance on hard data, it can be better to collect
easy data rather than hard data for finetuning, since hard data is generally
noisier and costlier to collect. Our experiments use open models up to 70b in
size and four publicly available question-answering datasets with questions
ranging in difficulty from 3rd grade science questions to college level STEM
questions and general-knowledge trivia. We conclude that easy-to-hard
generalization in LMs is surprisingly strong for the tasks studied. Our code is
available at: https://github.com/allenai/easy-to-hard-generalization
|
[
-0.1469060779,
-0.7820389867,
0.757242918,
0.0607874617,
0.063011311,
-0.4570854604,
-0.4295070469,
-0.3007432818,
-0.3874965906,
0.4965305626,
-0.4948746562,
-0.3876086473,
-0.6344528794,
0.0695791095,
-0.5265556574,
1.3050837517,
0.014847964,
-0.017615879,
-0.1793136299,
-0.3883089423,
-0.2674640417,
-0.7620801926,
-0.390610218,
-0.4177448153,
0.5221728683,
0.5028264523,
0.7349672914,
0.9721199274,
0.6829842925,
0.1918785423,
-0.2953392863,
0.2421250939,
-0.7365857959,
-0.1826367974,
-0.1649007797,
-0.8492177129,
-0.5442771912,
0.0966662392,
0.4548248649,
1.2332248688,
-0.446478188,
0.1695753783,
0.2202813178,
0.9127033949,
-0.4723168612,
0.3368016183,
-0.6792725325,
-0.1975042224,
-0.2745856345,
0.2175890058,
-0.2851723135,
-0.2866374552,
0.0304004941,
-0.6712287068,
0.4131899178,
0.1537160426,
0.9743276238,
0.4219664931,
-0.5284097791,
-0.625782311,
-0.9053416252,
0.9742075801,
-0.3657640815,
0.3846202195,
0.6228953004,
0.2417125255,
0.196780473,
-0.6871811748,
-0.2138571441,
-0.3355245292,
-0.0650530457,
-0.4189568758,
-0.2403866202,
0.3235975206,
0.6299177408,
0.4708594382,
-0.2466879487,
0.2403779328,
-0.5474502444,
-0.0841339827,
0.4070765376,
0.3195972443,
0.1932733506,
-0.2342991233,
0.011060196,
-0.2750106156,
-0.8570604324,
0.4373775423,
0.2282611132,
0.6552941203,
0.0060960772,
0.6107293367,
-0.5555187464,
0.8085371256,
0.0528393164,
0.2698965669,
0.2778486013,
-0.4207179248,
-0.1404998153,
-0.461317271,
0.4422565401,
0.1385309845,
0.4384013712,
-0.2637014389,
-0.3721013069,
-0.2171869278,
0.251431942,
-0.6322990656,
-0.2847770452,
0.4580661654,
-0.1982965618,
-0.0546083152,
0.0000626651,
-0.2542556226,
-0.3213835657,
-0.5986556411,
0.447657913,
-0.2315808237,
-0.0022557047,
0.1929108053,
0.3374871016,
0.2104378045,
0.294023633,
-1.0617032051,
0.3203094006,
0.9101333022,
0.610593915,
-0.135909304,
-0.3509249985,
-0.7134172916,
-0.1111498922,
-0.447278291,
0.4588306844,
-0.215136528,
0.0986207724,
-0.2247083783,
0.1378620118,
-0.1574641019,
-0.6751847863,
0.5535402894,
-0.3539640009,
-0.0944411457,
-0.3173015714,
-0.5982896686,
0.1023194268,
0.2356474102,
-0.6939188838,
0.7105147243,
0.0766768456,
-0.5013221502,
0.5466589928,
-0.334456414,
-0.1697356254,
-0.2391820103,
-0.0461300053,
-0.6120218635,
0.2612431049,
0.2569523156,
0.6959425211,
-0.2040881664,
0.5152873397,
-0.3284033537,
-0.5166358948,
0.021399999,
-0.1927197129,
0.7033100724,
0.29224208,
-0.379835099,
-0.1434004605,
-0.7045471668,
0.421192944,
-0.0173659176,
-0.5780625939,
-0.6962826848,
0.0248785838,
-0.2309226543,
-0.0478889607,
0.0870205536,
-0.2276686579,
0.4294416606,
-0.5894062519,
0.2559710443,
0.7528218031,
-0.4381318986,
0.5974080563,
-0.1989170462,
0.1558950543,
-0.128390193,
0.022253165,
0.1118398458,
-0.194577381,
-0.8959826231,
0.001915299,
0.5721527338,
0.658418417,
-0.7089424133,
0.1505777389,
-0.3995122313,
-0.5278768539,
-0.712104857,
0.7510015965,
0.6023381948,
0.2379435152,
0.2146578282,
-0.2158456445,
-0.1922059208,
-1.1121324301,
-0.4593288302,
0.020714134,
-0.3464691937,
0.5309833884,
0.4707205892,
-0.2177986652,
0.8166490197,
-0.5501778722,
-0.2689905763,
-0.3228381872,
0.2466333359,
0.3829220235,
0.5812679529,
0.2283006012,
-0.7937365174,
-0.0969774351,
-0.0391586199,
-0.8337593675,
0.083551541,
0.2418505102,
0.1597343385,
-0.02337851,
0.6142524481,
-0.6105064154,
0.1305506527,
0.2039442807,
-0.149914816,
0.144118458,
-0.3228635192,
-0.1327002496,
-0.5197256207,
0.1398459524,
-0.0558824614,
-0.3345641792,
-1.0208662748,
0.4496234655,
0.3066870272,
-0.1589201242,
-0.6774046421,
0.2014591247,
-0.4201711118,
0.3433966637,
0.0204106756,
-0.4264609218,
-0.3353767097,
0.7260796428,
-0.1150568798,
0.4309288561,
0.5185789466,
-0.8783496618,
0.2722754776,
-0.0200039148,
-0.5018340349,
0.4213404357,
-0.7727565169,
0.4673053622,
-0.4525759816,
-0.0373378247,
-0.7360422015,
-0.5144020915,
-0.029404182,
0.0254516378,
0.2719771564,
-0.1146769822,
-0.2883425355,
-0.285820514,
-0.1340342164,
0.5445187688,
0.3365798891,
-0.6125301719,
0.2589600682,
0.2283064872,
-0.1691476852,
-0.4072524309,
-0.719385922,
-0.220937863,
-0.3210062385,
-0.3532611728,
-0.1455247104,
-0.069154419,
-0.2674081922,
-0.1893791109,
-0.0783511475,
-0.581802845,
0.1849121451,
0.2718523145,
-0.1368710697,
-0.197474733,
0.4599691629,
-0.2861282229,
-0.0054392945,
-0.0147118382,
0.0576319993,
0.2984568179,
-0.5422407389,
-0.4719583988,
-0.2942364514,
0.2136151493,
0.4886587262,
0.1381125003,
0.5202507973,
0.1974805295,
-0.5230643153,
-0.3773867488,
-0.538882792,
-0.3544128537,
-0.4582420886,
0.5685293078,
-0.4227694869,
-0.7573596835,
0.1769745052,
0.1077768505,
0.1243101731,
0.340470612,
0.1602287292,
-0.4043997824,
1.2820558548,
0.7728558779,
-0.2131342739,
-0.0511588119,
-0.2936218381,
0.0817973092,
-0.2898137271,
-0.0229520444,
-0.5777665973,
-0.2028264999,
-0.7127165794,
-0.2530347705,
0.1411740333,
0.0841275975,
-0.2442367673,
0.0487134457,
-0.5258439779,
0.5387120247,
0.705429256,
0.3915575445,
0.3741326034,
0.1731496751,
0.5385588408,
-0.3323438466,
-0.8035621643,
-0.4585553408,
1.4868695736,
0.5929891467,
0.9481573105,
-0.072550647,
0.6682975888,
0.1839541495,
0.3039498627,
-0.7355512977,
0.2713899314,
-0.4333414733,
-0.818956852,
-0.6779463887,
-0.5622697473,
-0.9442461729,
0.015687976,
-0.0072330041,
-0.3035851419,
0.3196980059,
0.5435224771,
-0.414680779,
0.3171280622,
-0.9754500985,
0.7978942394,
-0.2332509905,
-0.3290551305,
0.0281841028,
-0.4711616933,
0.4751660824,
-0.2341921926,
0.4673740268,
0.0048534768,
0.059213534,
0.871162951,
-0.6572014093,
0.8837285042,
-0.318341434,
0.0321622677,
0.3122832775,
-0.0525260121,
0.6765262485,
-0.2300133258,
0.1502862871,
0.1581763327,
-0.0739115924,
-0.6752825975,
-0.7406852841,
0.3791686893,
-0.6995466352,
-0.7115626931,
-0.2682125866,
-0.4348332882,
-0.3484552801,
-0.0254514385,
0.1976663619,
0.3274282217,
0.073129423,
0.5101316571,
0.9305479527,
0.1449146718,
0.0342076346,
0.5012242198,
0.0436895266,
0.2177128941,
1.3469464779,
0.3666264117,
0.292080313,
0.0694655478,
0.1328555793,
-0.0064069321,
-0.6492845416,
-0.2866121531,
0.1650449485,
-0.5475426912,
0.0774626359,
-0.5665411949,
-0.1901754439,
-0.0160627887,
0.1092525572,
-0.5464234948,
-0.5064632893,
-0.1993986964,
-0.1390872598,
-0.0228301119,
0.9824968576,
-0.0680245012,
0.3167170584,
-0.3618895113,
0.4513555765,
0.8869481087,
0.538156569,
-0.0570177697,
-0.4637004435,
-0.211095795,
0.1897664219,
-0.252127707,
-0.5209780335,
0.021449659,
0.3520157933,
0.3149822056,
0.2874657214,
-0.0946059898,
0.4235197604,
-0.3870446384,
0.3367569745,
-0.0777006373,
-0.7219665051,
0.5378564596,
-0.383739382,
0.2775737345,
0.9229579568,
0.4772613049,
-0.3046903908,
-0.4887538254,
-0.4708173275,
-0.8979130983,
0.9338651896,
0.2069910467,
0.2930301428,
0.3262531161,
0.6127650738,
0.2662107646,
0.2675842643,
-1.0834205151,
-0.3484630287,
-0.1092691198,
-0.1907401234,
-0.3580119014,
-0.3132638335,
-0.0563399196,
-0.4127803445,
0.3688502312,
-0.1195183024,
-0.1406519562,
0.0287751537,
-0.269774586,
0.1150477007,
0.7007128,
0.2796301842,
0.6492767334,
-0.437338531,
0.1604937613,
0.3834764957,
-0.3792271316,
0.2365161628,
0.0755208433,
-0.3114826381,
-0.3290617466,
0.4207853973,
0.7918012738,
0.1583171636,
-0.650614202,
0.6049297452,
0.0938846096,
-0.3092250824,
0.1245718449,
0.3328555822,
0.1116439849,
-0.0592749715,
0.4252400994,
-0.2314836085,
0.1195061877,
-0.6435825229,
0.1356104463,
0.2912071645,
-0.5606434941,
-0.3171804547,
0.5755628943,
0.2027338743,
-0.2482713908,
0.8194425702,
-0.3933418989,
-0.2083344609,
0.6694703698,
0.1590006649,
0.3589338958,
-0.2201649994,
0.04492395,
0.3084229231,
0.6464399099,
-0.4563311934,
0.1728859991,
-0.0828155875,
-0.4143116474,
-0.3714323044,
-0.4388428628,
-0.6683488488,
0.5309726596,
-0.7205020189,
0.1382821053,
-0.465952307,
-0.0515861139,
-0.0879748389,
-0.120014742,
-1.1536349058,
0.5560882688,
-0.1326367706,
0.5964697003,
-1.0288794041,
0.534188509,
0.5855135322,
-0.2156766057,
-1.0745816231,
-0.2972482443,
-0.1184347942,
-0.8819977045,
0.718883574,
0.1823429465,
0.4916732907,
-0.1441676617,
-0.8177091479,
-0.7022535801,
0.7061609626,
0.2975596488,
-0.9789693952,
-0.410942018,
0.4673664868,
0.603561759,
-0.1822495461,
0.0675637573,
0.7984662056,
0.4430292249,
-0.4084261656,
-1.0061305761,
0.0467744544,
-0.1640784293,
-0.3621037602,
-0.0328446664,
-0.5900989771,
1.1422538757,
-0.3846936822,
-0.0709571093,
-0.1992431581,
0.571230948,
0.1326779425,
0.6885524392,
0.7983064055,
0.5109672546,
1.0093628168,
-0.3242435455,
1.1391444206,
0.2285691351,
0.4108426273,
1.0763134956,
0.0444681495,
0.6984469295,
0.3776686788,
-0.3029900789,
0.1636803746,
0.468188107,
0.0355706923,
0.4841379523,
0.4344853461,
0.2856731117,
-0.5474722981,
0.0902948603,
-0.2277490497,
0.5258366466,
0.1731060743,
-0.0578950234,
-0.1881691664,
0.1071854755,
-0.1336250752,
0.0452776104,
-0.5607508421,
0.5776430964,
0.1992206872,
-0.6096199155,
0.8536332846,
-0.1419017464,
0.7267061472,
-0.5521970987,
0.1045949087,
-0.187115252,
0.026016416,
-0.2291897088,
-0.5869538784,
0.1935831904,
0.1032543853,
-0.3132227063,
-0.2267216742,
0.4714646637,
-0.3262895942,
-0.4733572602,
-0.067988798,
0.8884908557,
0.4351677895,
-0.3684942722,
-0.3210612833,
-0.2152052671,
0.1034959927,
-0.488209039,
0.2325858325,
0.1755730659,
-0.2594511807,
0.842019856,
0.4651048481,
0.1686652601,
-0.0223878492,
-0.0108599374,
0.7044640779,
-0.8117380738,
-0.3971210718,
-0.7145678401,
0.2573498487,
0.0458861329,
-0.2857254744,
0.437068373,
0.488758564,
0.7017912269,
0.0824249312,
0.6144376993,
0.2212120742,
0.7824049592,
-0.6143763065,
0.8777589202,
-0.6940562129,
0.2736664712,
-0.1155186445,
-0.8905689716,
-0.1394842118,
0.1510015279,
-0.4207014143,
0.2217932791,
0.6116588116,
0.695892036,
-0.4422074854,
-0.2607553005,
0.2939470708,
0.4466708899,
0.2065334469,
0.9087844491,
0.6657441854,
-0.2154916525,
0.8908467889,
-0.5141043067,
-0.2860821486,
-0.1784210652,
-0.6889592409,
-0.9228897691,
-0.5605663061,
-0.1409031451,
-0.1481963545,
0.2302636057,
0.5457573533,
0.7931543589,
-0.9129506946,
-0.1260418147,
-0.1478031576,
0.2900113463,
-0.1057129651,
-0.2008705437,
0.5845018625,
-0.370356679,
-0.8823621869,
0.2551333308,
-0.2817547917,
0.1481369287,
-0.0641065836,
0.076116547,
0.2638811469,
-0.06890288,
0.2424689829,
0.578307271,
-0.5232893825,
-0.3035746217,
-0.054798536,
-0.489552319,
-0.0855076984,
0.6878728867,
-0.5689383149,
0.3564643264,
0.1732755154,
0.6704518199,
0.4761063457,
0.1550626755,
0.4994929731,
-0.7432672977,
0.0497771911,
0.0433776714,
0.1558138728,
0.3872130513,
-0.2720074058,
0.5468699932,
0.0213897992,
-0.5329663157,
-1.1968477964,
0.0120082088,
-0.6445098519,
-0.1795363426,
1.0590760708,
0.0587602369,
-0.357306838,
-0.1717112064,
0.005661577,
-0.0934718251,
-0.1493491679,
0.9777805805,
0.9955970645,
-0.1011027545,
0.3117180765,
-0.7433717847,
0.7237264514,
0.9427113533,
-0.6828978062,
0.3557887971,
0.2905871272,
0.5405186415,
0.0942011029,
0.7085015774,
0.3376355171,
0.5446377397,
-0.3185280263,
-0.0574469082,
-0.2943980396,
-0.3343060017,
-0.7031444311,
0.4269319475,
0.3084236979,
0.1442433
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06742v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06742v1
|
Using Natural Language Inference to Improve Persona Extraction from Dialogue in a New Domain
| 2024-01-12T18:25:03 | 2024-01-12T18:25:03 |
Alexandra DeLucia, Mengjie Zhao, Yoshinori Maeda, Makoto Yoda, Keiichi Yamada, Hiromi Wakaki
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
While valuable datasets such as PersonaChat provide a foundation for training
persona-grounded dialogue agents, they lack diversity in conversational and
narrative settings, primarily existing in the "real" world. To develop dialogue
agents with unique personas, models are trained to converse given a specific
persona, but hand-crafting these persona can be time-consuming, thus methods
exist to automatically extract persona information from existing
character-specific dialogue. However, these persona-extraction models are also
trained on datasets derived from PersonaChat and struggle to provide
high-quality persona information from conversational settings that do not take
place in the real world, such as the fantasy-focused dataset, LIGHT. Creating
new data to train models on a specific setting is human-intensive, thus
prohibitively expensive. To address both these issues, we introduce a natural
language inference method for post-hoc adapting a trained persona extraction
model to a new setting. We draw inspiration from the literature of dialog
natural language inference (NLI), and devise NLI-reranking methods to extract
structured persona information from dialogue. Compared to existing persona
extraction models, our method returns higher-quality extracted persona and
requires less human annotation.
|
[
-0.2537355125,
-0.7237978578,
0.4280911386,
0.1481621712,
-0.2250982225,
0.2898760736,
-0.0388002098,
-0.6546779871,
0.4342534244,
0.8481904268,
-0.9902747273,
-0.3773043156,
-0.1810276359,
0.091348134,
0.1341754049,
0.8614789844,
0.4117046893,
-0.0215716772,
-0.476934582,
0.0237059966,
-0.5941387415,
-0.425103128,
-0.7581721544,
-0.3745166361,
0.445669651,
0.3011422753,
0.5974517465,
0.3369462192,
0.1274671704,
0.2671729028,
0.2673508227,
0.3645723462,
-0.4338218272,
0.2036003172,
-0.0973458514,
-0.4065803587,
-0.3677640259,
0.4498733282,
0.4094603062,
1.0209604502,
0.0604235604,
-0.090998143,
-0.0054162345,
0.2121496499,
-0.7704382539,
0.469820559,
-0.4226894975,
0.1923952252,
0.0163803231,
-0.346044302,
-0.699549377,
-0.6712655425,
0.8452833295,
-0.9781090617,
0.2854347825,
0.1372058839,
0.9704818726,
0.1299854219,
-0.3536245227,
-0.0136466119,
-0.7216345072,
0.9962937832,
-0.9299981594,
0.3075562716,
0.5351826549,
0.560926795,
-0.0606568344,
-0.6855751276,
-0.4126062989,
-0.3314918578,
-0.3216734231,
0.0782774985,
0.019954659,
-0.0350826383,
0.2625365853,
0.2561447322,
-0.1884516329,
-0.1097528115,
0.1378225684,
-0.1648293883,
0.6558499932,
0.0133216167,
0.2278079689,
-0.4580126405,
-0.136423856,
-0.0686120167,
-0.3680127561,
-0.0433304682,
0.5050335526,
0.2809384465,
0.2168515474,
0.2598083615,
-0.3013065755,
0.5706768036,
0.302256763,
-0.4500367343,
0.4309358299,
-0.140958041,
-0.2175547183,
-0.0520808138,
0.6485644579,
0.5734699965,
0.4450221956,
-0.4635475576,
0.0048314258,
-0.0380067006,
0.3949746192,
-0.7810639739,
-0.4817954004,
-0.0058544925,
-0.5111485124,
-0.3492593169,
0.1433533281,
-1.1235773563,
-0.6572398543,
-0.5194883347,
0.1841283888,
-0.4034439623,
-0.304245472,
-0.0675696284,
-0.3077597022,
0.577609539,
0.4969925582,
-0.8560594916,
0.3194491863,
0.586322844,
0.5477653742,
-0.1658941358,
-0.102138415,
-0.8224234581,
0.0533985049,
-0.1991145462,
1.0060381889,
-0.8323695064,
-0.1983952969,
-0.06022387,
0.1093062833,
-0.2573476732,
-0.6614926457,
0.6569820046,
-0.3654089272,
0.6786645055,
-0.2368124574,
-0.6665756702,
0.0984701291,
0.2040091753,
-0.6172529459,
0.6593879461,
0.3988814354,
-0.7187919021,
0.4105363786,
-0.5225328207,
-0.451205045,
0.1820482016,
-0.0278725941,
-0.1700834781,
0.1295484006,
0.5057592392,
0.2879393399,
-0.5610109568,
0.4117739499,
-0.3891993165,
-0.2376363128,
0.2563264072,
-0.3363266289,
0.8895740509,
0.1195084229,
-0.1592914909,
-0.168260321,
-0.5760509372,
0.0190626439,
-0.0129585713,
-0.1411596537,
-0.3593188822,
0.1238630861,
-0.0946715176,
0.0175040942,
0.0127666686,
-0.6708417535,
0.231645152,
-0.7884451747,
0.0202532597,
0.4959119856,
0.3602504432,
0.7924963236,
-0.359949261,
0.6186960936,
-0.3507879674,
-0.0175342914,
-0.0970420837,
-0.5720326304,
-0.7755985856,
-0.4687463045,
0.2834416926,
0.6401641965,
-1.0705784559,
0.566118598,
-0.3925245702,
-0.4180186391,
-0.6790547371,
-0.242768079,
0.3668337166,
0.7060261369,
0.0747277886,
-0.4358017147,
-0.7112233639,
-0.9510596395,
-0.5066871643,
-0.1386234611,
-0.4320040047,
0.5094218254,
0.1479105651,
-0.2754768431,
1.4698015451,
-0.7121545076,
0.1141276062,
-0.5574345589,
0.3966629803,
0.024471635,
0.478518039,
0.4389539361,
-0.7816725969,
-0.550462842,
-0.1947404891,
-0.8459287882,
-0.407497555,
-0.5101737976,
-0.5155938864,
-0.1788745224,
0.3022272885,
-0.5927774906,
0.5814519525,
0.1094264388,
-0.2195268869,
0.6307055354,
0.1577665955,
0.3208769858,
-1.0821063519,
0.0835849196,
0.1257314086,
-0.3001506031,
-0.8584566116,
-0.1787631512,
-0.4702496529,
-0.2776522338,
-0.1891102642,
0.9014689326,
-0.5139988065,
-0.2099056244,
-0.2942436934,
0.183131367,
0.4575310051,
0.8749046326,
0.5394353867,
0.5999602675,
0.3919516504,
-0.478491962,
0.2284215242,
0.6466953158,
-0.4285143018,
0.9179363847,
-0.5345506072,
0.2778531611,
-0.1196715236,
0.5074592233,
-0.779299736,
-0.518923223,
0.5426188111,
-0.4329582751,
0.1122914851,
-0.6037308574,
-0.282984525,
-0.1003241912,
-0.1023059711,
0.1124462262,
0.5109107494,
-0.6032353044,
0.7512516379,
0.5924030542,
-0.289788425,
-0.2344235331,
-0.4179061353,
0.2182793319,
-0.2865462005,
-0.557872951,
0.2773093581,
-0.1247024387,
-0.4006887674,
-0.3725035787,
-0.0719775483,
-0.6354653835,
0.1859840304,
0.0966136307,
0.2675201595,
-0.2748993337,
-0.0912716538,
0.1441393048,
-0.3082849085,
0.1407447904,
-0.2125872523,
0.3164088726,
0.1447178721,
-0.2936320603,
-0.9163627028,
0.534043014,
0.4366593659,
-0.3083438575,
0.7389010191,
0.4299072623,
-0.3327510357,
-0.0337663479,
-0.6498779655,
-0.3709178567,
-0.4200862646,
0.0175621808,
-0.2004111409,
-0.5679257512,
0.3531897366,
-0.2280897945,
0.3595240116,
0.0952953026,
0.0074105561,
-0.0831688046,
0.8932653666,
0.3893852532,
0.0542735718,
0.6794813275,
0.0161803868,
0.4601050615,
-0.7499855161,
-0.0770232975,
-0.3973041177,
-0.2490396202,
-0.3185574412,
-0.5466364026,
-0.1167416796,
-0.4498130679,
0.1786312163,
0.4469667077,
-0.1761026531,
0.5214952826,
0.72344625,
0.1309393495,
0.2705086768,
0.1626779884,
0.2588372529,
-0.4259951413,
-0.2788211703,
-0.5865753293,
0.8107021451,
0.18965289,
0.6331034303,
0.2383582443,
0.6381531954,
0.1857012361,
0.4804318547,
-0.7637568116,
0.434861958,
0.1129206941,
-0.5500724912,
-0.1431451142,
-0.6706117988,
-0.9658626914,
0.3931201398,
-0.2625617683,
-1.0593471527,
0.3988929987,
0.1356718838,
-0.5545309782,
0.0552199781,
-0.898355782,
0.9500303864,
0.1511869282,
-0.3748844266,
0.2054796964,
-0.9076781273,
0.4828895628,
-0.0112240305,
-0.087703906,
-0.3067456484,
0.41941607,
0.7580131888,
-0.4157333672,
1.0758976936,
-0.4233462811,
-0.1410813034,
0.4245960116,
0.0672084242,
0.4755607843,
0.2634577155,
-0.3885926902,
-0.2153542489,
-0.0671795011,
-0.4154154956,
-0.9938308001,
0.2881149948,
-0.6032356024,
-0.4900703132,
-0.157251358,
-0.4338538349,
-0.627473712,
-0.028248284,
0.3488840461,
0.6586176753,
-0.5351668596,
0.0348175094,
0.6553289294,
-0.425013423,
0.1314569414,
0.3433383107,
0.0768666789,
-0.4348748624,
0.8892989755,
-0.36176911,
0.3567177653,
0.5226429701,
0.2674235106,
-0.4062911868,
-0.174195677,
-0.15115951,
0.1737810522,
-0.4637802243,
-0.0288966466,
-0.7951306105,
-0.1324426085,
-0.7306285501,
-0.2261931896,
-0.2904119492,
-0.2791629136,
-0.2866102457,
0.0917600691,
-0.0097188167,
0.3311266005,
0.3664148152,
0.7332946062,
-0.7302572131,
0.4271021485,
0.5830813646,
0.0309280213,
-0.1319048554,
-0.7833960652,
0.0153603805,
0.2048956901,
-0.1147856191,
-0.9249933362,
0.6947950721,
0.4735288322,
0.7678126097,
0.5058397651,
0.1874801069,
0.8620132208,
-0.4098218977,
0.5391828418,
-0.0139823668,
-0.6744083166,
0.6339467168,
-0.467538774,
0.2740811408,
0.9936038256,
0.0110674715,
-0.8101482987,
-0.3622022271,
-0.7678714395,
-0.5192013979,
0.8554275036,
0.3991760612,
0.1999859959,
-0.1103455275,
0.4907607138,
0.2816978991,
0.4844479263,
-0.8368872404,
-0.1044111326,
-0.2078920901,
-0.1708132327,
-0.021684885,
-0.2003966123,
0.1598916799,
-0.2814005017,
0.5350948572,
-0.4074318409,
0.4895710051,
0.0813762248,
-0.3566962481,
0.1694627851,
0.0518970229,
0.0437891781,
0.4807875454,
-0.3878990114,
-0.0378162675,
-0.018671684,
-0.2198787779,
-0.0546249971,
0.1644966155,
-0.1094927192,
0.1037873551,
0.5176774859,
0.9124259353,
0.6973911524,
-0.7462154627,
0.6567502618,
-0.3720515072,
-0.0695822835,
-0.2352943122,
0.2056522667,
-0.032406833,
0.2754642963,
0.1869950444,
0.0779953599,
0.3138857186,
-0.4909656942,
0.4581424296,
0.3390971422,
-0.261081636,
-0.2815557122,
0.3195427656,
0.6494467854,
-0.6412604451,
0.8070744872,
-0.425688535,
-0.2167422771,
0.433321476,
0.3974928856,
1.1719433069,
-0.1591373384,
0.6763717532,
0.452517271,
-0.0939971209,
0.0452442393,
-0.2128349841,
-0.0760808811,
-0.7901742458,
-0.6482461691,
-0.6544523835,
-0.5371054411,
0.0683942586,
-0.7729242444,
0.0985620618,
-0.5308394432,
0.0026132851,
-0.0893051401,
0.1249758676,
-0.4954346716,
-0.0667735413,
0.200549081,
0.6873960495,
-0.9826972485,
0.6170578599,
0.3622866273,
-0.0433555208,
-0.442689091,
0.3562692702,
0.1363529861,
-0.3802312613,
0.3072345555,
0.5032430887,
-0.0713803992,
0.1588308215,
-0.5690742135,
-0.710101366,
0.8285152912,
0.7103569508,
-0.184169054,
-0.252881676,
-0.0921233818,
0.5944390297,
-0.6346792579,
0.195028618,
0.7529081702,
0.2344611585,
0.3704212308,
-0.5124449134,
-0.2600576282,
-0.3142337203,
-0.1707803756,
-0.0400380753,
-0.199730739,
0.4123086035,
0.0512846746,
-0.341948837,
0.3015571237,
0.9712285399,
0.3567802012,
0.2640462518,
0.760024488,
0.2748982012,
1.0198017359,
0.0732215568,
0.9823861122,
0.1668932885,
0.1550290138,
1.6495774984,
-0.6178225279,
0.430264622,
0.3145769536,
0.1343865097,
0.8064272404,
0.8513690233,
-0.0537036806,
0.6053319573,
-0.1269985586,
-0.573328495,
-0.6018881798,
-0.2583954632,
0.1248565242,
0.5027940869,
0.2231640369,
-0.1782072484,
-0.2488681227,
-0.0838327184,
0.001983298,
-0.0397819765,
0.3916947544,
0.8988230824,
-0.1204330027,
-1.0593723059,
0.1411680132,
-0.2108468711,
0.3007142842,
-0.3914316893,
-0.156525299,
-0.4219457805,
-0.1043198183,
0.1597439945,
-0.2011419386,
0.1910490245,
0.0285539236,
0.030935755,
-0.3756459057,
0.6438402534,
-0.3644560277,
-0.5567803383,
0.0093538621,
0.7116054296,
0.334828645,
-0.281039983,
-0.7087641954,
-0.4466097951,
0.2586883008,
-0.2526549697,
0.1627316773,
0.433339119,
0.1550179869,
0.6606673002,
0.6376079917,
-0.317476511,
-0.2173717171,
0.3503348827,
0.6815699935,
-0.5034906268,
-0.606353879,
-0.6553584933,
0.5190649629,
-0.5454700589,
-0.3864278495,
0.6749321818,
0.3850179911,
0.2529572845,
-0.0347993076,
0.7625304461,
-0.058090847,
0.6971042156,
-0.3067345321,
0.4141954482,
-0.3086004555,
0.3043507636,
-0.5875109434,
-0.8655868769,
-0.1447897553,
1.0251094103,
-0.4230569601,
0.0487897843,
0.5562556386,
0.7373077869,
-0.1226769537,
0.2200748473,
0.1464416385,
-0.1195317581,
0.5421825647,
0.4225803018,
0.8935270905,
-0.1921019107,
0.3003539741,
-0.2410268188,
-0.3161002696,
-0.2400710583,
-0.8751481175,
-1.1026405096,
-0.3142690361,
-0.5775663853,
-0.1881385744,
-0.1846750975,
0.9383040667,
0.9325517416,
-0.6239525676,
0.0185544137,
-0.0425817482,
0.2076200694,
-0.1977090836,
-0.321914047,
0.0227646716,
-0.262081176,
-0.9772087932,
0.6500277519,
0.0949071571,
-0.0780621171,
-0.1128335819,
-0.0514697768,
-0.3791272342,
0.2299290597,
0.4554459751,
0.327365607,
-0.6710453629,
-0.4417577386,
-0.0249076169,
-0.0037034627,
0.3670074046,
0.9484414458,
-0.9329599142,
0.3562113345,
0.2186561078,
0.8630669117,
0.3099449575,
0.2823861241,
0.9780688882,
-1.1117806435,
0.0613062605,
0.3374271095,
0.1833290607,
0.5435285568,
-0.3372224867,
0.4618419707,
0.4817665517,
-0.3290157616,
-0.5982778668,
0.4636311233,
-0.8842772841,
-0.1806070358,
1.0677968264,
-0.2513468266,
-0.3310118616,
-0.5449776649,
-0.4072372913,
0.2101247758,
-0.420178771,
0.5673727393,
0.516515851,
-0.2173034847,
-0.2920920849,
-0.5863293409,
0.5856230259,
0.2817618549,
-1.3292140961,
0.4750700593,
0.6560718417,
0.0586291701,
0.1720720977,
0.7002851367,
0.2363930792,
0.1663884223,
-0.0250153765,
0.1133652329,
0.4450085461,
-0.2877161205,
0.0383864231,
0.0483509526,
-0.1029277667,
-0.0420546643
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06838v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06838v3
|
MAPO: Advancing Multilingual Reasoning through Multilingual Alignment-as-Preference Optimization
| 2024-01-12T18:03:54 | 2024-04-13T18:27:04 |
Shuaijie She, Wei Zou, Shujian Huang, Wenhao Zhu, Xiang Liu, Xiang Geng, Jiajun Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Though reasoning abilities are considered language-agnostic, existing LLMs
exhibit inconsistent reasoning abilities across different languages, e.g.,
reasoning in the dominant language like English is superior to other languages
due to the imbalance of multilingual training data. To enhance reasoning
abilities in non-dominant languages, we propose a
Multilingual-Alignment-as-Preference Optimization framework (MAPO), aiming to
align the reasoning processes in other languages with the dominant language.
Specifically, we harness an off-the-shelf translation model for the consistency
between answers in non-dominant and dominant languages, which we adopt as the
preference for optimization, e.g., Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) or
Proximal Policy Optimization (PPO). Experiments show that MAPO stably achieves
significant improvements in the multilingual reasoning of various models on all
three benchmarks (MSVAMP +16.2%, MGSM +6.1%, and MNumGLUESub +13.3%), with
improved reasoning consistency across languages.
|
[
-0.3087507188,
-0.4271771312,
0.671995163,
0.255644083,
-0.1917193681,
-0.0125663169,
-0.7475056648,
-0.3445569575,
0.1999520957,
0.3436677158,
-0.5579087734,
-0.2889253795,
-0.6487748623,
0.3430466652,
0.5616002679,
0.6616163254,
-0.3095044494,
0.3401741683,
-0.4165374041,
-0.3060887754,
-0.3689335585,
-0.4031785131,
-0.5634560585,
-0.5957753658,
0.3381915092,
0.8504093885,
0.9999926686,
0.6358495355,
0.382363528,
0.2465624511,
0.0833398476,
0.8549429178,
-0.2909646928,
0.1503689438,
-0.2662395537,
-0.5616817474,
-0.5739812851,
-0.3003638089,
0.5177268982,
0.3605529666,
-0.305115521,
-0.3020866513,
-0.2261380255,
0.8143287301,
-0.7501842976,
0.1019852012,
-0.818107903,
-0.1343209594,
0.1270913482,
-0.0988146067,
-0.4330083728,
-0.4360814989,
0.0872131363,
-0.9884779453,
-0.4147707522,
0.0321145244,
0.8979961276,
0.3733633757,
-0.44311589,
-0.1573603749,
-0.349389106,
1.0810285807,
-0.6790514588,
0.6147607565,
0.5278460979,
0.2367560863,
-0.0104853213,
0.2194423527,
-0.519306004,
-0.0967238769,
-0.0116640078,
0.3222498298,
0.1575445831,
-0.0121683786,
-0.0325562209,
0.1906116158,
-0.6546768546,
0.1031404808,
0.2002702355,
-0.2039879709,
0.8779320121,
-0.2783594728,
0.208069846,
0.073894538,
-0.3379980922,
-0.0262114946,
-0.7730659246,
0.0486959629,
0.5356720686,
0.3685711324,
0.0615340918,
0.5738275051,
-0.0923790559,
0.9006875753,
-0.1141068414,
-0.564738214,
0.2907710969,
-0.3412932754,
-0.0253120195,
0.1128859371,
0.7031224966,
0.6593796015,
0.4761255383,
-0.1527782828,
-0.1014046967,
0.1542553008,
0.0510385223,
-0.3823759258,
0.2724988759,
0.3041555882,
-0.144711569,
0.0682182014,
-0.2288694084,
-0.6252362132,
-0.0855526552,
-0.6431600451,
0.0093482994,
-0.3338514566,
-0.5045387745,
0.5099486113,
0.015506017,
0.1429695785,
0.3997859657,
-1.141010046,
-0.1312220693,
0.6947048306,
0.5606735945,
-0.4702521563,
-0.5714505315,
-0.256220758,
0.4794018865,
-0.3934874237,
0.8260908723,
-0.7921767235,
-0.5690372586,
0.0824387148,
-0.0899835601,
-0.3863507211,
-0.6232263446,
0.8913978338,
-0.3625685871,
0.1030348912,
-0.3830581307,
-0.3511304259,
-0.2140705138,
0.6315705776,
-0.2410873324,
1.2234464884,
-0.284350723,
-0.3733008504,
0.451045841,
-0.6567887068,
-0.5648306608,
-0.4193289876,
-0.2249483913,
-0.3818345368,
-0.2071423382,
0.4313684404,
-0.0236514714,
-0.5631971955,
0.6311379075,
-0.4203321338,
-0.1528517902,
-0.0405714698,
-0.016203396,
0.707657516,
0.3379159272,
-0.4020332396,
0.4388947189,
-0.5351264477,
0.0708010718,
0.220388338,
-0.3005085588,
-0.2985992432,
0.2384278476,
-0.3748091459,
0.2098739892,
0.4885768592,
-0.5272645354,
0.5093646646,
-0.3696607947,
0.3356382549,
0.699154675,
-0.4653860331,
0.7923958302,
-0.2338989079,
0.6106926203,
0.036295943,
0.3836884201,
0.2526761591,
-0.7271687984,
-0.7507035732,
-0.2604408562,
-0.1122610494,
0.9315890074,
-0.6674237847,
0.3805744052,
-0.4413390756,
-0.2567850053,
-0.5309436321,
0.3436793089,
0.5489432216,
0.6412965059,
0.4379096031,
0.3658855855,
-0.4506800175,
-1.1893268824,
-0.2497542799,
-0.2188754976,
0.3500027657,
0.3668785989,
0.2403813899,
-0.4629152417,
0.6277023554,
-0.5170701742,
-0.0829144642,
-0.3666456044,
-0.3480699956,
0.3263470232,
0.4007986784,
0.5852808356,
-0.9578741193,
-0.7245648503,
0.5714518428,
-0.6916955709,
-0.2280309647,
0.179687649,
-0.6685323715,
0.3863249123,
0.1726230085,
-0.4195154905,
-0.1996940523,
0.5544141531,
0.0129745547,
0.4684584737,
-0.4410009682,
0.2993313968,
-1.0341725349,
-0.2011031508,
-0.1183381006,
0.0171906296,
-0.3224443495,
0.2289637774,
0.0924464613,
-0.2190945297,
-0.1379135847,
0.7336957455,
-0.5858259797,
0.136152789,
-0.2676120698,
0.3443040252,
0.2669892013,
0.366537571,
0.4801728427,
0.9839596152,
0.8574656844,
-0.5037669539,
0.2199666798,
0.3052023351,
0.038876649,
0.5892862082,
-0.3256343305,
0.1353310049,
0.027149355,
-0.228393361,
-0.7741174102,
0.0012229987,
0.0639816597,
-0.3863252997,
0.5001827478,
-0.1707094908,
-0.4786591232,
-0.1329001039,
-0.2414497435,
0.4325122535,
0.094356522,
-0.6103403568,
0.6993670464,
0.5605277419,
0.0789228603,
-1.0324779749,
-0.4302968681,
-0.1808003634,
-0.2968388796,
-0.8857589364,
0.1389605403,
-0.1208765134,
-0.393206805,
-0.3903683424,
-0.0977004915,
0.0524136536,
0.0720645413,
-0.3033173978,
0.3904830217,
-0.2119060755,
0.1106877476,
0.4102496803,
-0.2512350678,
-0.2645544112,
-0.6424551606,
0.2205878794,
-0.3463125825,
-0.329113394,
0.0332135856,
0.5236291289,
0.4757416844,
-0.4694038033,
0.5749259591,
0.1136282757,
-0.0882462412,
-0.025480276,
-0.4520826936,
0.0915445834,
-0.3962314427,
0.0027529695,
-0.793381393,
-0.7356020808,
0.5585247874,
-0.1234856322,
0.0507245176,
0.3403185308,
0.5619951487,
0.1744909436,
1.3060154915,
0.3447005451,
-0.0702504367,
0.3154208064,
-0.0188570935,
0.2536361814,
-0.6605328918,
-0.1919081658,
-0.4251389205,
-0.1856883466,
-0.6298975348,
-0.5157151818,
0.3598164022,
0.2776735425,
-0.1878844649,
0.246192947,
-0.4965636134,
0.4833744466,
0.7266082764,
-0.0212105121,
0.39911744,
-0.0064300289,
-0.4147272408,
-0.1461491734,
-0.8379746079,
-0.6256961823,
1.1593761444,
-0.128985092,
0.5389122367,
0.4040124714,
0.639847219,
-0.0199529212,
0.181467101,
-0.8750748634,
0.3415544927,
-0.1592601836,
-0.6388812065,
-0.2786702812,
-0.3792349994,
-0.8473796248,
0.5821982622,
-0.2658521533,
-0.7228038907,
0.2047894448,
0.334554702,
0.2638226449,
0.1911948472,
-0.8632838726,
1.0361357927,
-0.7287930846,
-0.5352525711,
-0.2554291487,
-0.5780941844,
0.1137395054,
0.0680110902,
0.5229126215,
-0.3554195166,
-0.1250517815,
0.2021591663,
-0.2947355807,
0.252217263,
-0.0784929246,
-0.3205233812,
0.2597421706,
-0.1224911362,
0.3470266163,
0.1239374876,
-0.4678184986,
0.3710025847,
-0.1589213312,
-0.5267415643,
-0.6676481366,
0.8027364612,
-0.9899442792,
-0.9221856594,
-0.2652629316,
-0.7989791036,
-0.5591296554,
0.4000265598,
0.3039246798,
-0.0619784407,
-0.0092622414,
-0.2480837554,
0.5453888774,
0.0206073914,
0.0659824237,
0.6218878031,
-0.4167659581,
-0.6186105013,
0.990213871,
-0.017652519,
0.4898040891,
0.8570821285,
0.4976215065,
-0.5661279559,
-0.5009827614,
-0.9493634105,
0.4083429277,
-0.7487136722,
-0.1632246077,
-0.4075354636,
0.5406828523,
-0.4862583578,
-0.4270269275,
-0.4628222287,
-0.4916101396,
0.1574001461,
-0.1409916878,
0.0630587935,
0.1291470677,
-0.1742538363,
0.1521674842,
-0.604809463,
0.1864652336,
0.0330510214,
0.1828427166,
-0.3049538732,
-0.3759679496,
-0.1860402972,
0.2818876803,
-0.3304426372,
-0.8637197614,
0.0779743865,
0.2813305557,
0.9057485461,
0.7481111884,
-0.1213898808,
0.7055546641,
-0.5464371443,
0.362162143,
0.1660780311,
-0.8589023948,
0.9099123478,
-0.4955609441,
0.3260268569,
0.6780457497,
0.4816705883,
-0.3216914833,
-0.3231330812,
-0.3084826767,
-0.4593134224,
0.6539385915,
0.0516968742,
-0.13866359,
-0.2472988963,
0.2103165537,
0.1232439354,
0.2364190519,
-0.6029894352,
-0.3291272819,
-0.2747398317,
-0.0527228899,
-0.2205448896,
-0.2020328939,
-0.4986989796,
-0.3243285716,
1.045992732,
-0.5746679306,
0.0715971068,
0.0501683354,
-0.1675568223,
-0.070115149,
0.3786710501,
0.9672009349,
0.8410589099,
-0.142196238,
0.0095483735,
0.025019953,
-0.0949398875,
0.3275493383,
0.2392769009,
-0.3938753307,
-0.1344082803,
0.0526524968,
0.8554112315,
0.1220848486,
-0.8250508308,
0.3309370279,
0.0431072935,
-0.1861080229,
-0.0484617241,
-0.0151655125,
0.1321323514,
0.0564955361,
0.0544913895,
-0.031852372,
0.1439542025,
-0.382258743,
-0.1370856166,
0.6413385868,
-0.1333880126,
-0.0962976366,
0.7310287356,
0.2439247519,
0.0082233297,
0.4323705137,
-0.174616009,
-0.7414389849,
0.552865684,
0.7688679099,
0.5724188685,
-0.3450514078,
0.114880614,
0.6116929054,
0.5056402683,
-0.1697948724,
0.5356038809,
-0.1553960145,
-1.3107805252,
-0.3608921766,
-0.4414469302,
-0.6508539319,
-0.5003262162,
-0.6600105762,
0.3603865206,
-0.1704067439,
-0.2247471958,
-0.2744481564,
-0.0898499563,
-0.1821060777,
0.1911407858,
0.2089082599,
0.7571191788,
-0.7378833294,
0.9142116904,
1.1590641737,
-0.2679115832,
-0.5064985752,
-0.3450734019,
0.1271095425,
-1.2305214405,
0.4190939367,
0.1661056429,
-0.4758059382,
-0.2051785588,
-0.0107005117,
-0.900703907,
0.7747352719,
0.959890306,
-0.5026535988,
0.2887689769,
0.2226423025,
0.3997680545,
-0.4900920987,
0.2134184539,
0.4321288466,
0.8200842738,
0.0519220568,
-1.1340501308,
-0.3194468021,
-0.2417127192,
-0.1420741677,
0.5895775557,
-0.8609319329,
0.3007952571,
-0.4425662458,
0.1145906076,
-0.2526629865,
0.4128476083,
0.4277184606,
0.1672266424,
0.3664197922,
0.961655736,
0.9563686252,
-0.389621377,
1.2962669134,
-0.551867485,
0.2720710337,
1.1421324015,
-0.4623928666,
0.7255939841,
0.6631206274,
-0.1238570586,
0.3746252358,
0.775211215,
0.2904687226,
0.549857676,
-0.2240281701,
-0.2150878757,
-0.5711458921,
-0.2417037338,
-0.4238558412,
0.5640670657,
0.1415717602,
-0.044246342,
0.0008560327,
-0.0277717616,
0.424069792,
0.4353388846,
-0.2613226771,
0.7924824357,
-0.1683026105,
-1.2103310823,
0.8078888655,
-0.0330602042,
0.4946526885,
-0.7445816994,
0.196867615,
-0.3723976016,
0.3389927447,
-0.1404734552,
-0.6889163852,
0.4127141237,
-0.2980059683,
-0.5094172359,
-0.4367462695,
0.4577450156,
-0.6593332291,
-0.5169613957,
0.8220264912,
0.5212088227,
0.0450091064,
-0.0320958383,
-0.9220291972,
0.0285355132,
0.1739918143,
0.0552593656,
0.2676183879,
0.3023677766,
-0.152975589,
0.6732732058,
0.6747263074,
0.1154983118,
0.0056198509,
0.3039110601,
0.4789311886,
-0.1583479196,
-0.5075850487,
-0.8567498326,
0.2733443677,
-0.191274628,
-0.4235712588,
0.8563454151,
0.923643887,
1.0824267864,
-0.1051193923,
0.6085343361,
0.2385605127,
0.2361292392,
-0.6152982712,
0.2367486209,
-0.9659712315,
-0.0879931375,
-0.0884918496,
-1.1186728477,
-0.2907932103,
0.7481725216,
-0.6572248936,
-0.2389447093,
0.7220517397,
0.7293738127,
-0.1076558679,
-0.0659010112,
0.3989925981,
-0.2380938381,
0.1875470132,
0.681471467,
0.584440589,
-0.1522078514,
0.4706876576,
-0.1272732317,
-0.337616086,
-0.0259694364,
-0.8919748068,
-0.7013530135,
-0.2719839811,
-0.2760649323,
-0.1344433278,
0.0134583088,
0.8596029878,
0.6443153024,
-0.9605719447,
-0.6661366224,
0.0130077107,
0.6460496783,
-0.4019727707,
-0.1501004845,
0.0758384168,
-0.5876580477,
-1.062762022,
0.5467850566,
0.661123395,
-0.3076812029,
0.1679557413,
-0.5415005088,
-0.6163811088,
-0.002257504,
0.628010273,
0.2865516543,
-1.0041177273,
-0.0954490528,
0.2812170088,
-0.0198698286,
0.5244813561,
0.8033948541,
0.0819672793,
1.0322363377,
0.4141293466,
0.7335324883,
0.3021393418,
0.0029919203,
0.8804068565,
-0.393148303,
0.4392096698,
0.041456867,
0.7539625168,
0.4220598042,
-0.3658190072,
0.625294745,
0.2425603569,
-0.4979845583,
-0.4682382345,
0.5067437887,
-0.9226561785,
-0.2629332244,
1.3117785454,
-0.205098629,
0.0607341044,
0.1479058862,
-0.3931336999,
0.0524145514,
-0.5899220705,
0.4796510637,
0.9600663781,
-0.4566597641,
-0.2055927217,
-0.2654203475,
0.4652595818,
0.7917689085,
-0.8597265482,
-0.1353996545,
0.5335392356,
-0.1039421931,
0.3571771085,
0.6306449771,
-0.0957565233,
0.2697553337,
-0.2947233021,
0.0244424473,
0.1598859131,
-0.3281402588,
-0.0649443418,
-0.3028235137,
0.3254754841,
-0.0925778151
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06730v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06730v1
|
Relying on the Unreliable: The Impact of Language Models' Reluctance to Express Uncertainty
| 2024-01-12T18:03:30 | 2024-01-12T18:03:30 |
Kaitlyn Zhou, Jena D. Hwang, Xiang Ren, Maarten Sap
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
As natural language becomes the default interface for human-AI interaction,
there is a critical need for LMs to appropriately communicate uncertainties in
downstream applications. In this work, we investigate how LMs incorporate
confidence about their responses via natural language and how downstream users
behave in response to LM-articulated uncertainties. We examine publicly
deployed models and find that LMs are unable to express uncertainties when
answering questions even when they produce incorrect responses. LMs can be
explicitly prompted to express confidences, but tend to be overconfident,
resulting in high error rates (on average 47%) among confident responses. We
test the risks of LM overconfidence by running human experiments and show that
users rely heavily on LM generations, whether or not they are marked by
certainty. Lastly, we investigate the preference-annotated datasets used in
RLHF alignment and find that humans have a bias against texts with uncertainty.
Our work highlights a new set of safety harms facing human-LM interactions and
proposes design recommendations and mitigating strategies moving forward.
|
[
-0.4052996933,
-0.7713944316,
0.8185527325,
0.0264055487,
0.2130599171,
0.1913229078,
-0.0159995556,
-0.9086650014,
-0.293055594,
0.3733433187,
-0.5892557502,
-0.2037410736,
-0.5730429292,
0.0968881771,
-0.2506045997,
0.7007908225,
-0.2086700946,
-0.118274428,
-0.4253316522,
-0.074522607,
-0.4592596591,
-0.8126480579,
-0.6747399569,
-0.2668562531,
0.8546158075,
0.3856903911,
1.4345742464,
0.3813788891,
0.5041603446,
0.2949290276,
0.0656453371,
-0.0866194963,
-0.3427530527,
0.3013831973,
-0.3553757966,
-0.4797570705,
-0.2566214502,
0.0365211181,
0.4410727322,
0.7271514535,
-0.114468582,
0.1961879432,
0.2589502633,
0.8720236421,
-0.8852342963,
0.201902315,
-0.5085533857,
-0.2163630277,
-0.0718239769,
0.0644811019,
-0.4560572207,
-0.3891879022,
0.3662058115,
-0.4048050642,
-0.2616286278,
0.2768397033,
1.0895104408,
0.5863953233,
-0.3068695366,
-0.4603253901,
-0.9703552127,
0.7784280777,
-0.7176594734,
0.3359368742,
0.794321239,
0.1606065631,
-0.3059458435,
-0.5732887983,
-0.4986819327,
-0.3814557493,
-0.3552301824,
-0.0742925704,
-0.1343065798,
0.3542936742,
-0.0943606645,
0.0047363448,
-0.5100694299,
0.333763659,
-0.1425020546,
-0.2959167957,
0.7984223366,
0.2222622633,
0.1902629435,
-0.0732993782,
-0.3491862118,
-0.1568414569,
-0.6001730561,
0.2368945032,
0.5885133743,
0.4899015725,
-0.0980754942,
0.6517449021,
-0.0439412668,
0.9182617664,
-0.1438583434,
0.1290906668,
-0.1683370769,
-0.102726467,
-0.3872802854,
0.02283228,
1.0374307632,
0.3353393674,
0.4577549398,
-0.0184927993,
-0.3547270298,
0.0550027564,
0.7171279192,
-0.2647127509,
0.1034890786,
0.6654672027,
-0.2011952102,
-0.2354133427,
0.1843252331,
-0.6905962825,
-0.7095063925,
-0.1160298139,
0.7109001279,
-0.2966147661,
-0.0580057763,
-0.0405094884,
0.0955979899,
0.0900290385,
0.2251793742,
-0.6881095767,
0.4628533721,
0.4483466148,
0.5677509904,
-0.0200869292,
-0.3583522439,
-0.3149555624,
0.0517988577,
-0.4454503357,
0.52515769,
-0.0892381594,
-0.5016598701,
0.1422396153,
-0.09969569,
-0.2560633123,
-0.3400575817,
1.1621427536,
-0.3730166256,
0.3476461768,
-0.2191508114,
-0.6484349966,
-0.1060177535,
0.0146346679,
-0.6759768724,
0.8183010817,
0.0248043463,
-0.9312636256,
0.0512452312,
-0.6443154216,
-0.3654260933,
-0.1657779366,
-0.1487052739,
-0.297184974,
0.0112023344,
-0.0444685481,
0.5190130472,
-0.0452335179,
0.1941774637,
-0.458198458,
-0.2446739078,
0.7322571278,
-0.8154829741,
0.4533453584,
0.3045085669,
-0.1030666083,
0.0888576582,
-0.5915064812,
0.1036050767,
-0.0398094691,
-0.3364987373,
-0.3758634031,
0.4862956703,
0.038949877,
0.3893559277,
0.308350265,
-0.3317764103,
-0.1411266625,
-0.3653044403,
0.4461625218,
0.8671777844,
-0.0516929068,
0.5701663494,
-0.5838850737,
0.4108456373,
-0.1495480239,
0.3132694066,
0.160214439,
-0.6989990473,
-0.6855268478,
0.4621043503,
-0.0421564765,
0.5520736575,
-0.5709718466,
0.2573449612,
-0.3634435236,
-0.4205319285,
-0.7307878137,
0.2503426969,
0.2812145948,
0.6662569046,
0.2880200148,
0.1063926145,
-0.5131056309,
-1.1410354376,
-0.4231209755,
-0.8680905104,
-0.1094063371,
0.2597893775,
0.1576664746,
-0.316008538,
1.4455407858,
-0.3794958591,
0.1425415277,
-0.229707554,
0.4111756384,
-0.1832539886,
0.3705155551,
0.2688677609,
-0.9095335007,
-0.3282202482,
-0.2337589413,
-0.5067412853,
0.0619673394,
-0.2940590978,
-0.077734679,
0.7594755888,
0.1163466126,
-0.9966781139,
0.3585163653,
0.6533161998,
-0.2487909645,
0.359727025,
-0.1831890345,
-0.0617629327,
-0.9767815471,
0.1135502532,
0.1186411679,
-0.1987688094,
-0.6806380749,
-0.0981921554,
0.0122348694,
0.2589941621,
-0.4548586309,
0.5163666606,
-0.4261862636,
0.1082123965,
-0.2051509917,
0.0160512626,
0.0563665442,
0.1135311276,
0.2487969995,
0.6395050287,
0.3200075924,
-0.5168745518,
-0.1065844893,
-0.0299039204,
-0.1220102161,
0.4138374031,
-0.7097681165,
0.1504914612,
-0.3023741841,
-0.0179592036,
-0.881651938,
-0.6671153307,
0.5338849425,
-0.7030410767,
0.5216992497,
-0.1445544958,
-0.2223438174,
-0.3901148736,
-0.2127579898,
-0.2206359506,
0.4407218695,
0.0505218171,
0.6904838681,
0.3732907772,
-0.2650967836,
-0.7197296619,
-1.102935791,
0.4525654614,
-0.272100687,
-0.6706247926,
-0.111683473,
-0.0438192971,
-0.5881335735,
-0.0562889054,
-0.0336837098,
-0.40220806,
0.4449941218,
0.6004469395,
0.3842515349,
-0.0024171341,
0.306271255,
-0.324316442,
-0.0345371552,
0.3019200265,
-0.0375158712,
0.1835056245,
-0.0830418244,
-0.4828979969,
-0.677271843,
0.4307730496,
0.6585129499,
0.2874023914,
1.0065015554,
0.4120673835,
-0.4535031021,
0.2598131597,
-0.3584690392,
-0.1302616298,
-0.5035307407,
0.2661184072,
0.1050538421,
-0.831754148,
0.2384870201,
0.3779578209,
0.1346753538,
0.4312545061,
0.3233173192,
-0.5863192081,
1.0349382162,
0.6292777061,
-0.3770467341,
0.0023291758,
0.4564475119,
0.150503993,
-0.2495733351,
0.1131785288,
-0.8099213839,
-0.2012125254,
-0.6517295837,
-0.2789717615,
-0.0232414529,
0.1321757585,
-0.34060812,
0.1214779317,
-0.2455123961,
-0.0063633625,
0.5220380425,
-0.0391806699,
0.1979834735,
-0.3927043974,
0.3614603579,
-0.1703384221,
-0.6358504295,
-0.9663521647,
0.7442067266,
0.6989359856,
1.273342371,
0.2863340676,
0.384609431,
0.3578797579,
0.4845702648,
-0.8987900019,
0.1570587605,
0.4445205927,
-0.9022055268,
-0.4731220603,
-0.4794023037,
-0.9201871157,
-0.2924821675,
-0.2734191418,
-0.9706959724,
0.1752792895,
0.3880178034,
-0.6907921433,
0.1830377728,
-0.9875988364,
0.5805419683,
-0.5107185245,
-0.4542804062,
0.3054900467,
-1.1971621513,
0.3067879677,
-0.0838260055,
0.44560799,
-0.0566251352,
-0.1493543833,
0.3599330187,
-0.4596146345,
1.1577070951,
0.0470194779,
-0.3860163391,
0.486086905,
0.1162774265,
0.7753113508,
0.0162161794,
-0.2775745988,
0.0781056359,
-0.2063337415,
-0.318234086,
-0.4285489023,
0.5343134999,
-0.8534095287,
-0.6052933931,
-0.6040099859,
-0.3979377151,
-0.4696471393,
0.057395,
0.4933352768,
0.1139521971,
-0.1637813002,
-0.1960472167,
0.4680082798,
-0.1476299912,
0.5687960386,
0.1240384951,
-0.2130211294,
-0.131743744,
0.6097159982,
0.1944185197,
0.888884604,
0.2806774974,
0.1216073781,
-0.5979425907,
-0.3838064671,
-0.569545567,
-0.3184768856,
-0.6914384365,
0.0028345266,
-0.4431473017,
-0.4260867238,
-0.2267064899,
-0.0937281176,
-0.6177889109,
-0.227953583,
-0.4668043554,
-0.2765744627,
0.318474412,
1.0635300875,
0.0724321231,
0.1957227886,
-1.0611250401,
-0.0223852862,
0.3460998237,
0.4208784699,
-0.1371180415,
-0.237337634,
-0.2570443451,
0.4220575988,
-0.0637741014,
-0.8399760127,
0.2338969857,
0.1896277219,
0.6472165585,
0.4160105288,
0.4804548621,
0.2750008106,
-0.1162149459,
0.8816014528,
-0.1015527546,
-0.8629648089,
0.3710972965,
-0.3378829062,
0.171301797,
0.7364195585,
0.7984598279,
-0.523411572,
-0.4035774469,
-0.3376616836,
-0.9029282331,
0.4833312035,
0.4738302827,
0.2347460538,
0.1629590839,
0.2676457763,
0.0289419629,
0.1619624794,
-0.7084725499,
-0.5716662407,
-0.0853463113,
-0.3257905245,
-0.1025331095,
-0.5052224994,
-0.1762440205,
0.1467403769,
0.4150313139,
-0.1356161386,
0.12955603,
0.4827584624,
-0.012189338,
-0.3256602287,
0.5428526402,
0.8006334305,
0.5053630471,
-0.4601228237,
0.3717811406,
-0.2131991535,
-0.4878996611,
0.189944014,
0.0421640351,
-0.310927242,
0.0049630129,
0.3780580163,
0.7450525761,
0.257469207,
-0.7328222394,
0.0270785075,
-0.2895924151,
-0.0086532282,
-0.38365978,
-0.0335269272,
0.4862706363,
-0.3137301207,
0.5166140795,
0.4186214805,
-0.0484879203,
-0.5200772882,
-0.0021112168,
0.2780645192,
-0.9010653496,
-0.2104856521,
0.5743963718,
0.1536806375,
-0.5878046751,
0.2303983569,
-0.1154758632,
-0.371534884,
0.1653635353,
0.0171636976,
0.9070260525,
-0.0812200606,
0.1371878088,
0.0509621352,
0.5526161194,
-0.1752508134,
0.2433731109,
0.387054503,
-0.8911741972,
-0.4223369956,
-0.4303680062,
-0.7140235305,
-0.0295227338,
-0.6768991351,
0.0733491033,
-0.4506802857,
-0.6543274522,
-0.4126372337,
-0.3511939049,
-0.3823493123,
0.1276376694,
0.3349211216,
0.7526465654,
-0.5949414968,
0.5623711348,
0.9065390825,
-0.4985744655,
-0.9215956926,
0.3961107433,
0.2031389773,
-0.4253804386,
0.3686701953,
0.1864442527,
-0.26949054,
-0.1177625954,
-0.7630804181,
-0.8125703335,
0.8047976494,
0.4083642066,
-0.4412704706,
0.2246227562,
0.5336952209,
0.5094744563,
-0.0662016124,
0.2127307653,
0.3225424588,
0.6670343876,
-0.0809753761,
-1.0713169575,
-0.0101100244,
0.0649986267,
-0.1098359972,
0.0661282763,
-0.6372537613,
0.8473465443,
-0.2640638053,
-0.6146005988,
0.1932228506,
0.47938627,
0.0864277184,
0.3189613223,
0.3656459749,
0.3056996167,
0.8678827882,
-0.0315659679,
1.2967787981,
-0.2558817565,
0.2727839947,
1.3971765041,
-0.5275216103,
1.2556664944,
0.8229128718,
-0.2355929613,
0.6091855764,
0.7080587745,
0.7208278179,
0.1215087548,
0.1835370213,
-0.3287177086,
-0.2940450907,
-0.2042794973,
-0.1188664958,
0.2447543889,
0.5091920495,
-0.1673004925,
-0.0354075991,
-0.3936452568,
0.0448312759,
0.2334884107,
-0.1546178609,
0.4838416576,
0.3530701697,
-0.6721416116,
0.4871299863,
-0.1452776641,
0.823935926,
-0.5805216432,
0.2861041129,
0.0482698865,
0.0247140154,
-0.175525859,
-1.1058963537,
0.3596543372,
-0.1536873281,
-0.1992146075,
-0.1165925041,
0.9517624974,
-0.0896536857,
-0.4200360179,
0.3463656604,
0.6451307535,
-0.0931651741,
-0.2282547355,
-0.680772841,
0.0940176174,
-0.1852033585,
-0.5015124083,
0.310261786,
0.2012753338,
-0.0266073514,
1.3080441952,
0.5171509981,
-0.004834251,
0.011371064,
-0.142342791,
0.4644279182,
-0.3974143565,
-0.0084669869,
-1.0013216734,
0.7270380855,
-0.1298911572,
-0.2541352808,
0.6559899449,
0.0306479447,
0.6363158226,
0.0625516102,
1.091604352,
0.0082397629,
0.4998924732,
-0.4594421387,
1.0050474405,
-0.2829675078,
0.3468600214,
-0.2270935178,
-0.4293937087,
-0.0499635972,
0.374496609,
-0.0681844503,
0.2809676528,
0.4497492611,
0.5011621714,
0.3617947698,
-0.0324852504,
0.2047562003,
0.3465748429,
0.1694657952,
0.5173895955,
1.1152231693,
-0.2395624965,
0.4668948352,
-0.4467864037,
0.2135135531,
-0.1701752394,
-1.0333964825,
-0.5134271383,
-0.3612677157,
-0.1587165892,
-0.3456976414,
0.0758816525,
1.0435342789,
0.5979202986,
-0.8938166499,
-0.1822899729,
-0.2760994732,
0.3413944542,
0.3082252443,
-0.3025163412,
0.0385678001,
-0.367482245,
-0.6640287638,
0.252946645,
0.2267124802,
0.5401958823,
-0.6373103261,
-0.5319495201,
-0.2633123696,
0.1123736426,
0.1394470781,
0.5246888399,
-0.6070765853,
-0.6834025979,
0.1649131775,
-0.5908774734,
-0.0397226997,
0.3516810536,
-0.6573073864,
0.1961189359,
0.3487609625,
0.7047201991,
-0.4197602868,
0.3565219641,
1.1446020603,
-0.6606092453,
-0.1111229211,
0.4092718661,
0.25518924,
0.6547209024,
-0.6443623304,
0.3609265685,
0.0804023519,
-0.7467445731,
-0.7119473815,
0.2135457546,
-0.7348618507,
-0.2279244661,
1.1267004013,
-0.0920943916,
-0.0426717214,
-0.7723633051,
-0.233487457,
-0.023069568,
-0.5971938372,
0.7231830955,
1.0997333527,
-0.2282109857,
-0.1268837452,
-0.8603004813,
0.7186995745,
0.4132884145,
-0.6117231846,
0.1937244534,
0.3006973565,
0.0837054029,
0.2532217205,
0.4915283322,
0.3670458496,
-0.0517940782,
-0.1063557342,
0.1448782235,
0.2658751309,
0.121689193,
-0.3358494043,
0.016372459,
0.6907011271,
-0.0050511886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10908v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10908v1
|
LLM-Assisted Crisis Management: Building Advanced LLM Platforms for Effective Emergency Response and Public Collaboration
| 2024-01-12T17:50:35 | 2024-01-12T17:50:35 |
Hakan T. Otal, M. Abdullah Canbaz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG, 68T50 68T50 68T50, I.2.7
|
Emergencies and critical incidents often unfold rapidly, necessitating a
swift and effective response. In this research, we introduce a novel approach
to identify and classify emergency situations from social media posts and
direct emergency messages using an open source Large Language Model, LLAMA2.
The goal is to harness the power of natural language processing and machine
learning to assist public safety telecommunicators and huge crowds during
countrywide emergencies. Our research focuses on developing a language model
that can understand users describe their situation in the 911 call, enabling
LLAMA2 to analyze the content and offer relevant instructions to the
telecommunicator, while also creating workflows to notify government agencies
with the caller's information when necessary. Another benefit this language
model provides is its ability to assist people during a significant emergency
incident when the 911 system is overwhelmed, by assisting the users with simple
instructions and informing authorities with their location and emergency
information.
|
[
-0.1038447693,
-1.0197892189,
0.6669157743,
0.7956054807,
-0.1430612206,
0.5426486731,
-0.1311715543,
-0.6635171771,
0.2943808138,
0.4771315455,
-0.3925511837,
-0.4153646827,
-0.5764400959,
0.3386788368,
-0.6269046068,
0.6454077959,
-0.0891099349,
0.1059187055,
0.271019429,
0.23171857,
-0.2119698822,
-0.653239131,
-0.9287145138,
-0.2137170136,
0.4475497305,
0.788079977,
0.6951667666,
0.3270320892,
0.7704694867,
0.4149180055,
-0.0507389829,
0.2167930752,
-0.8044039011,
-0.1954484284,
0.0995584875,
-0.2085591257,
-0.4559095502,
-0.2916005552,
0.4650578797,
0.1127107367,
-0.7032296658,
0.1009580642,
0.0769285038,
0.3848777115,
-0.4137572646,
0.2636258304,
-0.7918323278,
-0.1275003254,
-0.0303571634,
-0.3201819956,
-0.1719133258,
-0.5092078447,
0.2123596966,
-0.5588706136,
0.0081291134,
0.1411386579,
0.3715055883,
0.3201642334,
-0.4736308753,
-0.4948649108,
-0.9248417616,
0.4424326718,
-0.4534474313,
0.0878935084,
0.4023486376,
0.4022487104,
-0.3870229125,
-0.628895998,
-0.6918718815,
0.3007676303,
0.177735731,
0.0777862296,
-0.3339324296,
0.320306927,
-0.1018179804,
-0.0371864662,
-0.3588978946,
0.4978270233,
-0.507027328,
-0.1198327765,
0.8374189138,
0.4907607436,
0.3926776052,
-0.4531714022,
-0.5200234056,
0.3659581244,
-0.6292968988,
-0.0831523314,
0.1734127849,
0.3309465647,
-0.4964149892,
0.4160244465,
-0.1355668455,
0.2823470235,
-0.1388167292,
-0.3718449175,
0.0084803049,
0.0605564117,
-0.6970977783,
0.4702109694,
0.8569027781,
0.6791611314,
0.2215218842,
0.0285268687,
-0.3007481098,
-0.2268563658,
0.3569039404,
-0.7306436896,
-0.1040175483,
0.2059054375,
-0.418413043,
-0.5323697925,
-0.0443336591,
-0.8067876101,
-0.9763720036,
-0.3143879175,
0.3009751439,
0.0166026223,
-0.5868580937,
0.1960894167,
0.3860387206,
0.005935783,
0.6513061523,
-0.5367810726,
0.3611033261,
0.821116209,
1.0131690502,
0.1445348114,
0.1503662914,
-0.40377599,
0.1800945401,
-0.1971090138,
0.8906675577,
-0.5143306255,
-0.5400649905,
0.4941658676,
0.1834349781,
0.0807008594,
-0.7392417192,
0.8456178308,
-0.6546041965,
-0.2803589106,
-0.2035057992,
-0.0691973865,
-0.5738096833,
0.0921803191,
-0.5034641027,
0.9837545753,
-0.182498157,
-0.6897220016,
-0.0758653134,
-0.6260995269,
-0.2555401921,
0.0996637866,
-0.1219293326,
-0.3041767776,
0.1688697934,
0.2784342468,
0.7904882431,
-0.5484412313,
0.4711623788,
-0.4421926439,
-0.2254123539,
0.1425691098,
-0.1362126023,
0.5295131207,
0.1659753919,
0.0506830066,
0.3506014049,
-0.8648016453,
-0.2775520384,
0.3988917172,
-0.7189394236,
-0.2425456047,
0.3198312521,
0.4639643729,
0.0783615559,
0.2650786042,
-0.2913863063,
0.0011166956,
-0.1735134423,
0.4252220392,
0.7566950917,
0.14295277,
0.4530872703,
-0.2872968614,
0.1267238259,
-0.014772933,
0.0974876136,
-0.1246372312,
-0.6377590895,
-0.6731478572,
-0.1356840879,
-0.2361176461,
1.3168264627,
-0.5322551727,
0.3852093816,
-0.1262068748,
-0.2331348658,
-0.5517067313,
0.1810227185,
-0.072905235,
0.6855348349,
0.504314959,
0.1302487254,
-1.1115509272,
-0.9329969287,
0.3365576267,
-0.5162719488,
-0.0969673321,
0.195687145,
-0.1295432001,
-0.36119169,
0.7424317598,
-0.2013155669,
-0.0503305718,
-0.6064665914,
0.2206789106,
0.0658373311,
0.0048646904,
0.1574944705,
-0.78334409,
-0.27664572,
0.1092521474,
-0.9852186441,
-0.5218775272,
-0.2454770207,
-0.0009291625,
-0.0888652503,
0.3870716989,
-0.3227974474,
0.3556440473,
0.2881408632,
0.0894330814,
0.2275847793,
-0.0994011685,
0.1840627193,
-1.3262168169,
-0.2096251696,
0.0192311127,
-0.1634151936,
-1.1959495544,
-0.3639396429,
0.1490860283,
-0.3211798966,
-0.6360166073,
0.1793628633,
-0.3582528234,
-0.1729116291,
-0.44971627,
0.2219507396,
-0.6911658049,
-0.1091231257,
0.1763122678,
0.5686535239,
0.5005782247,
-0.4721390903,
0.4227157235,
0.2141380608,
-0.5147336721,
0.2076079249,
-0.5938323736,
0.2814294696,
-0.2447842509,
0.2272479981,
-1.1594346762,
-0.7302940488,
0.347785145,
-0.0961044878,
0.0507219546,
-0.2104218602,
-0.7685880065,
-0.5403606892,
0.0577081814,
0.0121497018,
0.3011124432,
-0.4104973674,
0.5735923052,
0.7636325955,
-0.4769456089,
-0.3408213556,
-0.5945369005,
0.4573015273,
-0.4577394426,
-0.6939334273,
0.0168021806,
0.0497098975,
-0.6477668285,
-0.2385060191,
0.1601039171,
-0.4614191055,
0.5365265012,
0.7245452404,
0.3890083134,
-0.0624286011,
0.1753362864,
-0.0203957669,
-0.0318238176,
0.2224386781,
0.4455198348,
0.7385948896,
0.0247189831,
-0.1712225527,
-0.8504918814,
0.7688087821,
0.5483829975,
0.1337185502,
0.7043784261,
0.4014068544,
-0.5843145847,
0.2369559556,
-0.766844511,
-0.0446041822,
-0.5608876944,
0.3521868885,
0.2313007861,
-0.9569013119,
0.6035912037,
-0.327875942,
0.2486070991,
-0.0527649112,
0.8619493246,
0.0014212632,
0.7298598886,
0.779404521,
-0.6475087404,
0.3902240396,
0.0943619981,
0.3312534988,
-0.2673846781,
-0.3797914684,
-0.3107520938,
-0.3286141455,
-0.2605409324,
-0.4946325123,
0.5427395105,
0.2642454505,
-0.1301372051,
0.3123305142,
-0.3137715161,
0.4000762105,
-0.1001905277,
0.1466763765,
0.3428190649,
0.1147164702,
0.4462079406,
0.2075027823,
-0.4986963868,
-0.8794968724,
0.6753965616,
0.6031147242,
0.8394987583,
0.2494059503,
1.0416581631,
0.2614025474,
0.785918951,
-0.888612628,
0.8109324574,
0.5178343654,
-0.4952462614,
-0.1760700941,
-0.2862532735,
-0.8888568878,
-0.0216872301,
-0.4832024276,
-0.8782929778,
-0.0715365186,
-0.1321942359,
-0.6430660486,
0.2484661192,
-0.8260198832,
0.0098875752,
-0.191900149,
0.348829776,
-0.6293357015,
-0.5206707716,
0.4009703994,
-0.2928280234,
0.7060924768,
-0.4346660972,
-0.4306835234,
0.5831800103,
-0.1585659534,
1.1770247221,
0.0736263692,
-0.2865576744,
0.6191715598,
0.1175449267,
0.6547178626,
0.3421397209,
-0.1340114474,
0.2053894252,
-0.5176340938,
-0.0932951197,
-0.2413108796,
0.7500177026,
-0.9621793628,
-0.6774166226,
0.0292596314,
-0.5982088447,
-0.0316514447,
0.0352857821,
-0.0642105117,
0.4211402833,
-0.1888912618,
-0.1870931983,
0.3602111936,
-0.1727681458,
0.9393966794,
0.9072337151,
-0.1601477265,
-0.5760546327,
0.5409703255,
0.2973075807,
-0.1911931038,
0.5261887908,
0.0184133649,
-0.1213180348,
-0.665553391,
-0.2506560683,
0.1976741701,
-0.7653210163,
-0.460523814,
-0.9085074067,
-0.3043152094,
-0.1719183624,
-0.3107734621,
-0.0672788322,
-0.2678556442,
-0.5498796701,
-0.4863487184,
0.5092927217,
1.1622112989,
-0.3194090724,
0.3932745159,
-0.9366663694,
0.3609012067,
0.1892430782,
-0.0722005591,
0.056852784,
-0.1556605995,
-0.0220237337,
-0.3609276414,
-0.3451992869,
-1.2841669321,
0.2892330289,
0.1677232683,
0.3606019616,
0.5425818563,
0.3210110664,
0.7148625255,
-0.7833512425,
0.6752057076,
0.4469282925,
-0.6171366572,
0.5575555563,
-0.4418551624,
-0.2369647026,
0.3416346908,
0.603760004,
-0.5838382244,
-0.2334004045,
-0.3554806709,
-0.9376448393,
0.5069223046,
0.2580464184,
0.2335327119,
-0.2558199763,
-0.0225258879,
-0.3573721945,
-0.0063121561,
-0.5062705874,
-0.2779493332,
0.1179284602,
-0.2866462171,
0.2033641487,
-0.667034924,
-0.3669677079,
-0.0543584004,
0.1839782,
0.1521431655,
0.414678216,
0.1416196525,
0.0848210007,
-0.4603879154,
0.4567546844,
0.7674740553,
0.4126251638,
0.0704988539,
0.1513733119,
0.741181314,
-0.5176514387,
0.2572986782,
0.2183783203,
0.2339728922,
-0.1155076176,
0.3669575155,
0.2844842076,
0.5122737288,
-0.7740887403,
0.3359463811,
-0.0915670991,
-0.0249461867,
-0.4817178845,
0.0114699947,
0.2014960647,
0.6082491279,
0.9093443155,
-0.2786405981,
0.347864002,
-0.4538147449,
0.138137728,
0.1001373753,
0.0649986118,
-0.4249872863,
0.3270155787,
0.6381950378,
-0.8710049987,
0.2328256816,
-0.0802817568,
-0.5050477386,
0.6348065734,
0.6660242677,
0.9502429962,
-0.6949876547,
0.254119426,
0.445853889,
0.3674427569,
-0.317373842,
0.5610652566,
0.0626902729,
-0.7052845955,
-0.2889858484,
-0.415921241,
-0.3859874308,
0.5910999775,
-0.4991915524,
0.3800387383,
-1.1287902594,
-0.1782853454,
-0.2029686719,
-0.4039101303,
-0.5839958191,
-0.0369658172,
0.5471847653,
0.9179514647,
-0.8452282548,
0.6108888388,
0.6842504144,
0.1488297284,
-1.0058976412,
0.1634765267,
0.4674709439,
-1.0242027044,
0.6081385612,
0.5467498302,
0.1781821698,
-0.0574385859,
-0.6118544936,
-0.9507377744,
1.14458251,
0.2552994192,
-0.8964828849,
0.0402162597,
0.3893986344,
0.5021194816,
-0.3757998347,
0.2912542224,
0.38284868,
0.3705486655,
-0.1006499901,
-1.2631053925,
0.0917138234,
-0.0361879133,
-0.1578710675,
0.391248107,
-0.7725365758,
0.2669951618,
-0.3456182778,
-0.6273171306,
0.0320308767,
0.8292446136,
-0.0676258206,
0.696625948,
0.4477759302,
0.4757357836,
1.0336215496,
0.0344527066,
0.7940551639,
-0.1602766067,
0.2358116657,
0.9816768169,
-0.1847997308,
1.018599987,
0.1101801768,
-0.0671826676,
0.4067085683,
0.7619622946,
0.4234170914,
0.5088496804,
-0.0036913883,
-0.7735443711,
-0.3449361026,
-0.2826020122,
-0.2050055414,
0.3673122227,
0.7118183374,
-0.4430736303,
-0.543055892,
0.0049351039,
0.08725252,
-0.0023457371,
-0.4468034208,
0.9332675338,
0.2437754571,
0.0421945862,
0.6146173477,
0.0908832103,
0.3839977682,
-0.058405742,
0.1553770453,
0.0747922584,
-0.1743439436,
-0.5317174196,
-0.9475096464,
0.5981898308,
0.3174138367,
-0.1101742834,
0.0351490565,
0.831047833,
-0.1776939631,
-0.5272688866,
0.4787631929,
0.3382889926,
0.1217039153,
0.0454010479,
-0.8046824336,
0.3482969105,
-0.3745003343,
-0.0761139095,
0.0978236869,
0.5222404599,
0.0189309698,
1.0498026609,
0.5090408921,
-0.11039754,
-0.1112399995,
0.1112665683,
0.9754539728,
-0.4413294494,
-0.5084022284,
-0.9487628937,
0.52765131,
-0.3048766255,
-0.0586208515,
0.385096252,
0.3788047731,
0.2887753844,
0.1095412448,
0.8783122897,
-0.1016741022,
0.5997934341,
-0.2425021529,
0.3459920883,
-0.1725704968,
0.4147745371,
-0.0802860558,
-0.5269466043,
-0.2998823225,
0.4695598185,
-0.5101265311,
-0.730194509,
0.0892688259,
1.0411223173,
-0.0347791538,
0.0839511976,
0.23842825,
0.0999892876,
0.420691967,
0.4455568492,
1.1056485176,
-0.0052376585,
0.7117515802,
0.0225811359,
-0.3406937122,
-0.5138180852,
-0.8165234327,
-1.1860940456,
-0.4240301251,
-0.0501011647,
-0.1640400141,
-0.1218739748,
1.4279713631,
0.6143265963,
-0.7424007058,
-0.2184682488,
-0.1233915463,
0.2040161192,
0.4567062259,
-0.2334214598,
-0.221008271,
-0.0375408046,
-0.3708219528,
0.7385437489,
0.6046261191,
0.2129687369,
-0.2147153914,
0.0851449817,
0.0703680515,
0.2586642504,
0.6718346477,
0.2051160634,
-0.8821589947,
-0.2146408111,
-0.2092979252,
-0.1793182045,
0.0682304204,
0.7791084647,
-0.4533519447,
0.1623846292,
0.4737277925,
0.9413810968,
-0.1765933186,
0.1732429266,
0.4765340984,
-0.5501540899,
0.2522891164,
0.1050909311,
0.1992239207,
0.7560920715,
-0.8225049973,
0.6044288278,
0.0907759145,
-0.6518065929,
-0.8752801418,
0.106347695,
-0.9566110969,
0.1086273268,
1.5322599411,
0.0495509095,
-0.0244720895,
-0.5272845626,
-0.5441727042,
0.2677275538,
-0.9211730361,
1.1500530243,
0.4528697729,
0.0956742018,
-0.4641956687,
-0.7556009293,
0.2634032071,
-0.2016541958,
-0.9900640845,
-0.0888278931,
0.1591208428,
0.3346349895,
0.2488622963,
0.6493393183,
0.2564706504,
0.1310138553,
-0.6161571145,
-0.360925138,
0.0868148729,
-0.3553648889,
-0.3170244396,
0.3224568665,
-0.3378060758,
0.0566400848
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06837v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06837v2
|
Structsum Generation for Faster Text Comprehension
| 2024-01-12T17:43:51 | 2024-06-19T09:59:51 |
Parag Jain, Andreea Marzoca, Francesco Piccinno
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We consider the task of generating structured representations of text using
large language models (LLMs). We focus on tables and mind maps as
representative modalities. Tables are more organized way of representing data,
while mind maps provide a visually dynamic and flexible approach, particularly
suitable for sparse content. Despite the effectiveness of LLMs on different
tasks, we show that current models struggle with generating structured outputs.
In response, we present effective prompting strategies for both of these tasks.
We introduce a taxonomy of problems around factuality, global and local
structure, common to both modalities and propose a set of critiques to tackle
these issues resulting in an absolute improvement in accuracy of +37pp (79%)
for mind maps and +15pp (78%) for tables. To evaluate semantic coverage of
generated structured representations we propose Auto-QA, and we verify the
adequacy of Auto-QA using SQuAD dataset. We further evaluate the usefulness of
structured representations via a text comprehension user study. The results
show a significant reduction in comprehension time compared to text when using
table (42.9%) and mind map (31.9%), without loss in accuracy.
|
[
-0.1728066057,
-1.1300992966,
1.0525826216,
0.2873267531,
-0.3486807048,
0.031691689,
-0.211457938,
-0.3325221837,
0.1635487676,
0.3168229461,
-0.4030708671,
-0.6544694304,
-0.248236239,
0.2700351477,
-0.40767923,
0.9682686329,
-0.4363569915,
-0.1737249196,
-0.6150405407,
0.1347795129,
-0.4439440668,
-0.4931905568,
-0.6307002306,
-0.5216661692,
0.6241574883,
0.4376032948,
0.7022331953,
0.9200640321,
0.2815628648,
0.3543759882,
-0.0762159452,
0.3423812687,
-0.4914432168,
0.3562554121,
0.0167192128,
-0.3638623655,
-0.5261462927,
-0.1621415019,
0.7130043507,
0.661578238,
-0.2906597853,
0.1320316494,
0.0164191965,
0.8724370003,
-0.0520269759,
0.4693035781,
-0.5601062775,
0.2031048238,
-0.0245620683,
-0.5248735547,
-0.5917028189,
-0.211525619,
0.0933980718,
-0.7382366657,
0.1975715756,
0.3489678204,
0.8012316227,
0.4477823675,
-0.590241909,
-0.44622612,
-0.5963775516,
0.4001362622,
-0.4762979746,
0.4694898129,
0.4281320274,
0.1291901171,
-0.5745465755,
-0.8975198269,
-0.7328589559,
-0.5031084418,
-0.0943721235,
0.1898805499,
0.272737056,
0.0470223464,
0.4846554101,
0.5077297091,
-0.7488524914,
-0.2048353851,
-0.2195025831,
-0.1474339068,
0.670404315,
0.3272768855,
0.516055584,
-0.3392519653,
-0.2280073166,
-0.2465668023,
-0.8240746856,
-0.0953068659,
0.3745358586,
0.111963369,
-0.099512659,
0.7333546877,
-0.335841924,
0.8857939839,
-0.037814144,
-0.1787762344,
0.0272567719,
-0.4954037666,
-0.2564049065,
-0.1744479239,
0.7168067694,
0.3529855907,
0.6389535666,
-0.2358459532,
-0.1294037402,
0.2436042428,
0.3006888032,
-0.7546446919,
-0.6008445621,
0.3117592633,
-0.3101297021,
-0.0415765569,
-0.0464951806,
-0.5686163902,
-0.1546907723,
-0.4749541283,
0.1617491394,
-0.5678713322,
-0.0217826124,
0.0504175127,
-0.1582117528,
0.1877126396,
0.3875433207,
-0.9072796106,
0.1134092808,
0.2836785316,
0.8361544013,
-0.2532886863,
-0.0651550889,
-0.2498867661,
0.4408896565,
-0.5944365859,
1.2314022779,
-0.2942154706,
-0.3306030929,
-0.0032391511,
-0.2826329768,
-0.0394153856,
-0.4675153196,
0.2065588683,
-0.3880909383,
0.3791311085,
-0.4084832072,
-0.620742023,
-0.0331360437,
0.3557295799,
-0.714232564,
1.264665246,
0.1795228422,
-0.6976293325,
0.385170877,
-0.5430147052,
-0.590333879,
0.1338430196,
-0.5034912825,
-0.1372424364,
0.074586682,
0.3186991215,
0.5859017968,
0.1177490726,
0.3280721307,
0.0641586855,
-0.3034624159,
0.2907251716,
0.0195891205,
0.3543551564,
0.0943301618,
-0.1824530959,
0.5143949986,
-0.5284583569,
0.2618817985,
0.1611067057,
-0.6824026108,
-0.2214041799,
0.6525403261,
-0.0098117013,
0.2037666887,
-0.0477011278,
-0.2093292475,
0.2070552409,
-0.5785375237,
0.6457731128,
0.593514502,
0.1383819282,
0.5465911031,
-0.5330955386,
0.317997396,
0.2205878794,
-0.3377303183,
-0.2895843387,
-0.4584005177,
-0.7737312317,
-0.3395215273,
0.2289034724,
0.4607888162,
-1.1511356831,
0.25244838,
-0.4021489024,
-0.541052103,
-0.2034794241,
0.1204385608,
0.2803027034,
0.5510329008,
0.3809001744,
-0.20664379,
-0.446521163,
-0.8441427946,
-0.1606298238,
-0.603243649,
-0.2330657095,
0.0732473433,
0.6599869132,
-0.1401288509,
0.944673717,
-0.6183237433,
-0.0239464249,
-0.5295675993,
0.0642707795,
-0.1739936918,
0.4130953848,
0.4539716244,
-0.7092028856,
-0.3791193962,
-0.4894647002,
-0.6500980258,
-0.0228592437,
-0.1328564286,
-0.2478423864,
0.4950233698,
0.5578063726,
-0.6815646291,
0.3126442134,
0.1673105508,
-0.5111715794,
0.5259445906,
-0.1277464926,
0.2327693254,
-1.2099485397,
0.0306967515,
-0.0604013652,
-0.3962903321,
-0.6199067235,
0.3218853772,
0.1374220103,
-0.1403654516,
-0.3362578452,
0.4829872549,
-0.4982999563,
0.0424082279,
0.0842618495,
0.491492033,
0.0918860286,
0.5985406637,
0.0390130989,
0.9682875276,
0.0069705229,
-0.770314157,
0.1003778502,
0.4389112294,
-0.4716963768,
0.3540896773,
-0.779586494,
0.1543865651,
-0.3006473482,
0.5654579401,
-1.1987450123,
-0.4326406121,
0.2632570565,
-0.2856160104,
0.2897374034,
0.2745135725,
-0.7909802198,
-0.4234960675,
-0.3437842727,
0.2333822399,
0.4491833746,
-0.230788976,
0.3454594612,
0.4608604908,
-0.1570558101,
-0.171380505,
-0.8651304245,
-0.0051194853,
0.0152376648,
-0.8549665809,
0.4558162987,
-0.4778080583,
-0.4551517963,
-0.0676029399,
-0.2637073696,
-0.0668075979,
0.1417389065,
0.2353768945,
0.2167683691,
-0.2019498944,
0.3378873467,
-0.0607306957,
0.0835597366,
0.1531752646,
-0.1077541634,
0.5674701333,
-0.1590812057,
-0.0685727969,
-0.2750677764,
0.6209513545,
0.2572531104,
-0.1295801848,
0.5245193839,
0.2243358791,
-0.4108684659,
-0.4340924323,
-0.4291355312,
-0.2817323208,
-0.4554626346,
0.3056631982,
-0.4428421557,
-0.9969823956,
0.7834422588,
0.4332585931,
0.0970893949,
0.5275809765,
0.722305119,
-0.2874180377,
0.9430630207,
0.68513906,
0.2702842057,
0.4119743705,
-0.1224855259,
0.2306708843,
-0.4843891561,
-0.3745682538,
-0.581520915,
-0.1717115641,
-0.3880310357,
-0.440164119,
0.2255674452,
-0.2057544291,
0.1476416439,
0.105606474,
-0.5771371126,
0.4733458757,
0.4337274134,
0.1658619642,
0.4517990351,
0.3092458546,
-0.2299227566,
-0.1120867953,
-0.9889601469,
-0.680832088,
0.7398698926,
0.1625663787,
0.6357076764,
-0.2396430671,
0.6185564399,
0.1819313914,
0.5349795818,
-1.1414872408,
0.7893288732,
0.2089971751,
-0.5959283113,
-0.3277444243,
-0.7531715035,
-0.7448964119,
0.1634658873,
-0.2210872471,
-0.3767904937,
-0.1912073344,
0.2608852983,
-0.50801301,
0.1229626238,
-0.7853201628,
0.8492131233,
0.1952263564,
-0.199399814,
-0.053868141,
-0.3901655376,
0.3453942537,
0.1360418051,
0.0794285089,
-0.1391516626,
0.0368174091,
0.9300720096,
-0.3889609277,
0.4985718131,
0.0214332398,
-0.3127068877,
0.5711739063,
0.1524206698,
0.4107299447,
0.0238467082,
-0.1379830688,
-0.2364414483,
0.1417347491,
-0.3885548115,
-0.6094248295,
0.3821440339,
-0.4518975019,
-0.6997616291,
-0.3877182007,
-1.0011013746,
-0.2875065207,
0.019528402,
0.2053630501,
0.7497148514,
-0.1652012318,
0.1136119366,
0.9050681591,
-0.0821288973,
0.4179151654,
0.4065980315,
-0.0305668321,
-0.2126360834,
0.6272087097,
0.5214291811,
0.037042398,
0.3424206674,
-0.0590475202,
-0.4046837091,
-0.7586117983,
-0.7044064999,
0.2391806692,
-0.6390941143,
-0.3377020955,
-0.5816909075,
-0.2005537152,
-0.4407866597,
-0.1811341345,
0.1752762794,
-0.5162463188,
-0.3216085136,
-0.3364352286,
0.3605131209,
0.9060450792,
0.3533403873,
0.3911633193,
-0.5726745725,
0.4978697002,
0.2612335682,
0.1753554195,
-0.0852507651,
-0.3780927062,
-0.2683729827,
-0.1623886824,
-0.1760227978,
-1.3046405315,
0.3025358319,
0.1190600917,
0.5113549829,
0.2057140023,
0.1033417955,
0.9003360271,
-0.8247463107,
0.6973289847,
-0.2017327696,
-0.9186508656,
0.5048579574,
-0.4711454213,
0.4925382137,
0.6938350797,
0.2322137505,
-0.5358749032,
-0.8491987586,
-0.5784998536,
-0.9385734797,
0.4268167317,
0.1643034816,
0.0237621795,
-0.2989267111,
0.7825054526,
-0.1739575863,
0.2255804986,
-0.6860166788,
-0.0631096214,
-0.2911377847,
-0.7023451924,
0.0131054362,
-0.5948771834,
-0.059479963,
-0.0849888474,
0.5488818884,
-0.2858278453,
0.3428002,
0.768750906,
-0.3649073243,
-0.1651717573,
0.3585123122,
0.8215204477,
1.0727599859,
0.0139643848,
0.5419532061,
0.2388750315,
-0.4474268556,
0.1814476997,
-0.089073427,
-0.4714278281,
-0.0572317392,
0.4664087296,
0.4853685498,
0.2667522728,
-0.629427433,
0.1677389294,
-0.0095448792,
-0.3831800818,
-0.1718592793,
0.1920769364,
0.143367663,
0.0659352392,
0.464856267,
-0.5927149057,
0.0415154994,
-0.6753520966,
0.3387175798,
0.3488431275,
-0.1162456274,
-0.2464191914,
0.5716845989,
0.1335805506,
-0.2658686638,
0.6077538133,
-0.2962915897,
-0.4990763664,
0.6250709295,
0.6577324867,
0.473879844,
-0.1534044147,
0.3278008997,
0.335506767,
0.6282321811,
-0.1453807205,
0.6011791229,
-0.1890068203,
-0.5246875286,
-0.6932823062,
-0.5767725706,
-0.4564903975,
0.0494097397,
-0.3783401549,
-0.3108151555,
-0.4583384097,
-0.1100620255,
-0.3122175336,
0.4206496477,
-0.4168034196,
0.2392489016,
0.0647338107,
1.2481333017,
-0.8302681446,
0.7902789712,
0.9303933978,
-0.4187810421,
-1.093577981,
-0.0740443617,
-0.361053288,
-0.4597515464,
0.3427480459,
0.1776707768,
0.0444031619,
0.2119705081,
-0.6451728344,
-0.6443317533,
0.9714587927,
0.3092488945,
-0.3922252059,
-0.2249385715,
0.084057644,
0.6442085505,
-0.2749679685,
0.1625586003,
0.4120206833,
0.6754927039,
-0.1602065563,
-0.3540708125,
0.474535197,
-0.1686322093,
0.1277579218,
-0.0047806771,
-0.3853036165,
0.5562527776,
-0.0759732649,
-0.7237141132,
-0.0557202436,
1.1668457985,
0.4382587373,
0.2771604359,
0.5872766376,
0.6143024564,
0.8593253493,
-0.3053747118,
1.1387034655,
-0.1593726128,
-0.1738115847,
1.0803318024,
-0.1719396263,
0.9065486193,
0.7286144495,
0.0609875955,
0.9321687222,
0.8957140446,
0.1034050584,
0.1219289899,
0.3728283942,
0.117334038,
-0.3620835841,
0.0810627565,
-0.3755144179,
0.043959301,
0.3981752396,
-0.0625502393,
-0.2760931253,
-0.2121817172,
0.1362439394,
0.3409441411,
-0.2120564878,
0.8423039913,
0.1307554841,
-0.9284009337,
0.3392666578,
-0.0013335217,
0.1789702326,
-0.6587641239,
0.064775072,
-0.4770079851,
-0.213275671,
-0.2130980492,
-0.7606076002,
0.5361302495,
-0.0702741519,
-0.3728426099,
-0.595898211,
0.7577656507,
-0.8682552576,
-0.2005650997,
-0.0205486156,
0.6928036809,
0.173032254,
-0.1649828702,
-0.4073468149,
0.0584459193,
-0.2106325924,
-0.5807814002,
0.0129321981,
0.4998072088,
-0.1309247315,
0.6690235138,
0.5468389988,
-0.0239042044,
0.0882593617,
-0.146146521,
0.8201383948,
-0.8196541071,
-0.6660166979,
-0.8688440919,
0.4498310387,
-0.0822514221,
-0.0611082874,
0.9513810277,
0.4914536476,
0.7481905818,
-0.1359402835,
0.3747501373,
0.0114366496,
0.1125966385,
-0.8607770801,
0.9961158633,
-0.480160594,
-0.2387256771,
-0.1004212946,
-0.9348980188,
-0.3511431515,
0.7484012246,
-0.2146594226,
-0.2495314777,
1.0384238958,
0.8247951269,
0.1575741619,
-0.1379983276,
0.0989899337,
0.2508457005,
0.2459956408,
0.5412607789,
1.0346032381,
-0.3318963647,
0.5777750015,
0.1442729235,
-0.0732626021,
-0.1224227995,
-0.777413547,
-1.1537094116,
-0.8489251137,
-0.3267557919,
-0.4121769667,
-0.0570369363,
0.6519631147,
0.7823543549,
-0.5810970068,
-0.2469702065,
-0.0939212069,
0.5207422972,
-0.0036242616,
-0.2487297505,
0.3613859415,
-0.5810527205,
-0.518093884,
0.6855082512,
0.2738539279,
0.3105291426,
-0.3284156322,
0.1012380049,
-0.1682267338,
0.4163227677,
0.7929207087,
0.0695323646,
-0.4270379543,
-0.4678106606,
-0.0542318113,
-0.5015677214,
0.1648109555,
1.0543744564,
-0.8758638501,
0.0282565486,
0.977752924,
0.4165815413,
0.4556035697,
0.0170936193,
0.5671319962,
-0.7005957365,
0.1397619843,
0.1461731941,
0.3319949508,
0.559099555,
-0.265411377,
0.5171527863,
0.2054173052,
-0.4586239159,
-0.9266484976,
0.4726621807,
-1.0814729929,
-0.2615924776,
1.0570428371,
0.0520192422,
-0.752372086,
-0.2429076582,
-0.2016972005,
0.437548995,
-0.3682938218,
0.9636628032,
0.771242559,
0.0265500285,
0.0847557932,
-0.5359191895,
0.8379626274,
0.6097134948,
-1.2187724113,
0.0110043986,
0.7566127181,
0.1733422577,
0.1323326081,
1.0228383541,
-0.0578802526,
-0.0005145785,
-0.1417465955,
-0.052672267,
-0.2631462812,
-0.6256625056,
0.0506986268,
0.4533803761,
-0.1336795688,
0.3170159757
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06715v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06715v1
|
Reframing Tax Law Entailment as Analogical Reasoning
| 2024-01-12T17:37:07 | 2024-01-12T17:37:07 |
Xinrui Zou, Ming Zhang, Nathaniel Weir, Benjamin Van Durme, Nils Holzenberger
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Statutory reasoning refers to the application of legislative provisions to a
series of case facts described in natural language. We re-frame statutory
reasoning as an analogy task, where each instance of the analogy task involves
a combination of two instances of statutory reasoning. This increases the
dataset size by two orders of magnitude, and introduces an element of
interpretability. We show that this task is roughly as difficult to Natural
Language Processing models as the original task. Finally, we come back to
statutory reasoning, solving it with a combination of a retrieval mechanism and
analogy models, and showing some progress on prior comparable work.
|
[
-0.024142528,
-0.7664849162,
0.9041954279,
-0.0710947141,
-0.6735947728,
-0.1405922025,
-0.2973643243,
-0.264347434,
0.2455711067,
0.99058038,
-0.3289369941,
0.1233096421,
-0.2954859138,
0.1004700288,
-0.4505340159,
0.662609458,
-0.18482925,
0.084724091,
-0.4472436905,
-0.0776086077,
-0.5432664752,
-0.5327714086,
-0.6625739336,
-0.4290527701,
-0.001063916,
0.0872815847,
0.6654368639,
0.6871818304,
0.2970422208,
0.3306711912,
0.1449312568,
-0.3843876421,
-0.2866679132,
0.0184535515,
-0.4476103187,
-1.0314388275,
0.0449714363,
-0.1186859235,
0.445143044,
0.5846016407,
-0.6740164161,
0.2325871736,
-0.0023575725,
0.6110365391,
-0.6718950868,
0.5074882507,
-1.0384353399,
-0.5957099199,
-0.0836193711,
-0.4993336499,
-0.3713493347,
-0.9525532126,
0.3526780903,
-0.9400091767,
0.4561068416,
0.1428700984,
0.748464942,
0.3947807252,
-0.5733556151,
-0.688113153,
-0.501476109,
0.6766765714,
-0.8719326854,
0.4030358195,
0.3179425597,
0.40663293,
-0.1439473182,
-1.2365529537,
-0.9655001163,
-0.3527469039,
-0.1752645224,
-0.0979973301,
-0.4754169583,
-0.19711487,
0.3109366596,
0.1569805145,
-0.3148780763,
-0.3390202522,
-0.5616233945,
-0.1031740457,
0.4352558255,
0.2075829506,
0.2572268546,
-0.1090505421,
-0.4190041721,
-0.04877064,
-0.6336160302,
0.1842325032,
0.5221264958,
0.3528140485,
0.1768659502,
0.3147715926,
0.0929920673,
0.7660077214,
0.0438048355,
0.3155364394,
0.0914431438,
-0.3808491528,
-0.339525193,
0.5426953435,
0.042264279,
0.3256816566,
0.5710899234,
0.0004425264,
-0.1285383999,
0.1807079911,
0.6405092478,
-0.7381151319,
0.0778149068,
0.2294720262,
-0.2656475902,
0.0143078985,
0.1169489995,
-0.3249669373,
-0.0189578291,
-1.1438109875,
0.3787525296,
-0.6699253917,
-0.2593153119,
0.6066670418,
-0.5820670724,
0.324486047,
0.493903935,
-0.8365117311,
0.6203110814,
1.2106516361,
0.1628890336,
0.4824868143,
-0.0892637894,
-0.0770596787,
0.3460810781,
-0.3229203522,
0.9469386339,
-1.0093854666,
-0.2265492529,
-0.0875778049,
0.4287477732,
-0.1849960238,
-0.7527834177,
0.4679577947,
-0.5696205497,
-0.038297195,
-0.3032514453,
-0.6437521577,
-0.7542586923,
0.0500577204,
-0.428276062,
0.4470062852,
0.3499142528,
-0.2581366003,
0.8969376683,
-0.4743378162,
-0.5815030932,
0.176291734,
-0.1851834506,
-0.0044427682,
0.2482562512,
-0.1802089363,
-0.1418782622,
-0.6580120325,
0.2809649706,
-0.2430415899,
-0.2098453492,
0.0478444956,
-0.0905335844,
1.0514161587,
0.3907705247,
-0.0713754296,
0.0954704434,
-0.5049681664,
0.2173335999,
-0.1181223541,
-0.3184085488,
-0.7195242047,
-0.0225549322,
-0.1809723973,
-0.3271562457,
0.3008003533,
-0.6327339411,
-0.0205076877,
-0.514387548,
0.9700523019,
0.4024973214,
0.2674783766,
0.542366147,
-0.4257303774,
0.4699656665,
-0.0073780268,
-0.2654236257,
-0.0020344437,
-0.5023073554,
-0.1790173948,
-0.1610960364,
0.4771476388,
0.6551241875,
-0.8314161897,
0.0446781814,
-0.3652775586,
-0.2284744382,
-0.6133699417,
-0.1653401256,
0.1117096916,
0.2993714213,
0.0198394321,
-0.1639034599,
-0.4967652559,
-1.1735457182,
-0.8103629947,
-0.2399288416,
-0.0146102747,
-0.0017767866,
0.8870741129,
0.3353015482,
0.9090980291,
-0.6449082494,
-0.0675757527,
0.1288976967,
0.4500977397,
0.3570557237,
0.4868336022,
0.5576568842,
-0.6818597317,
-0.1948221475,
-0.1686000079,
-0.5829489231,
0.0045740567,
-0.461699754,
0.0666858107,
0.0762430578,
0.4751190841,
-0.4455905259,
0.7642613649,
-0.8262056112,
-0.2982802391,
0.4205969274,
-0.6894883513,
0.3361805081,
-0.6612412333,
-0.5289558172,
0.1163228676,
-0.0103467982,
-0.5007027388,
0.702904582,
0.1717136651,
-0.1126859635,
-0.4867149889,
0.2047917545,
-0.3514877558,
0.2154656351,
-0.5674717426,
-0.1433356851,
0.2085916847,
0.1762897223,
-0.0540121309,
0.9846962094,
0.3619634509,
-0.533100307,
0.7888072133,
-0.025363883,
-0.2618278563,
1.0507537127,
-0.4380926788,
-0.0709551498,
-0.3575572968,
0.4054942131,
-0.7902311683,
-0.1781342924,
0.0821614936,
-0.1726191044,
0.3286879659,
-0.1634434164,
-0.823289156,
-0.2667648196,
-0.2711313665,
0.4886817634,
0.5637173057,
-0.2123949081,
0.6222345829,
0.2008903623,
0.0650542229,
0.0758156478,
-0.9058133364,
0.0741491988,
-0.5187833309,
-0.5316596627,
0.5173608065,
0.5981132388,
-0.5986673236,
0.7244210839,
-0.0922603011,
-0.3471069634,
-0.2408159226,
-0.0642414242,
-0.0596453696,
-0.5673748851,
0.2590996921,
-0.053604994,
0.0327797383,
0.5252654552,
-0.0685020983,
0.2275369614,
-0.1938079,
-0.3197516501,
-0.3041118979,
0.3551308215,
0.3090068102,
0.0455258936,
0.6554467678,
-0.1679752767,
-0.7870018482,
-0.0725169778,
-0.5154755116,
-0.2966330647,
-0.4042735994,
-0.1242871359,
-0.845841229,
-0.3480853438,
0.313497901,
0.1273081303,
0.0451434627,
0.430501163,
0.4868292511,
0.2376570404,
0.16840069,
0.0182389636,
0.5897588134,
0.0804135874,
0.0601216182,
0.5070282221,
-0.6770747304,
-0.2285540104,
-0.5325015783,
-0.0048189256,
-0.547860086,
-0.3281077147,
0.1607401818,
0.0810179636,
-0.5371337533,
0.951921165,
-0.6711043119,
0.513461411,
0.6943199635,
0.4648759663,
0.2137731463,
-0.0356286354,
0.4117316008,
-0.1143961921,
-0.2668504417,
-0.6681480408,
1.1166305542,
-0.1915649772,
0.6718286276,
0.4095439017,
0.7840914726,
0.0752995461,
0.2198783457,
-0.7620785832,
0.6779705286,
-0.2730886042,
-0.6594692469,
-0.2943061292,
-0.3653372228,
-1.1919019222,
0.3540863395,
-0.0844895244,
-0.7788156867,
0.3268949986,
-0.1980968416,
-0.4943531454,
0.3925721943,
-1.1437921524,
0.2590829432,
0.2441533655,
-0.4101841152,
-0.8735616803,
-0.3432643712,
0.5494399071,
-0.2337842435,
0.2856573462,
-0.1734604985,
-0.0576975904,
0.738009572,
-0.7379329801,
0.73967731,
-0.1508571059,
-0.1085216552,
1.009418726,
0.3148611188,
0.3260040879,
-0.2940586209,
-0.172951147,
-0.5330606699,
1.1872214079,
-0.3607916534,
-1.2155199051,
0.5426870584,
0.0813418105,
-1.1562422514,
-0.5072628856,
-0.5484428406,
0.0983760357,
0.0382615626,
-0.2801508009,
0.7267101407,
0.2194440812,
0.0231558569,
-0.0523347892,
0.0839570537,
0.0755989477,
0.6244255304,
0.12826249,
-0.0860032663,
1.113937974,
0.3545430601,
0.2302540392,
0.1930911392,
0.2585295439,
-0.8471841812,
-0.073752299,
-0.3498110771,
0.2476083785,
-0.9810535312,
0.0211693682,
-0.1607882977,
-0.1670049429,
-0.6268433332,
-0.0921120793,
0.1155574694,
-0.6414363384,
-0.1513419449,
0.2735412121,
0.6720656753,
0.6724533439,
0.045813743,
0.0792594999,
-0.545491457,
0.5514839292,
0.4651348591,
0.2574000657,
0.2008759975,
-0.740177989,
0.3849511743,
0.1987973005,
-0.2932393849,
-0.7276749015,
-0.1707432121,
0.0242625028,
0.6007301211,
0.2208437175,
0.3761987984,
0.904202044,
-0.6859026551,
0.566126883,
0.2345892787,
-0.853515625,
0.4091061354,
-0.0802921802,
-0.1383677721,
0.5437175632,
0.1460291147,
-0.0009566554,
-0.3045749068,
-0.881031096,
-0.6526477337,
0.4498968124,
0.4226772189,
0.5156280994,
-0.0184437856,
0.6966989636,
0.1061809361,
0.3492115438,
-0.2800140381,
0.1244784221,
-0.0810481459,
-0.1347746402,
0.5267771482,
-0.1027338952,
-0.2118491381,
-0.6245185733,
0.3555088341,
0.1519151628,
0.2326583564,
0.0623243675,
0.1391075402,
0.111358121,
0.7440583706,
0.7301021814,
1.2172085047,
-0.4133849144,
0.312261939,
0.220882073,
-0.3897391856,
0.23989214,
0.1122710332,
0.1090355441,
-0.2389876544,
0.4690486789,
0.5274833441,
0.4826787412,
-0.437312007,
0.1286694854,
0.5350754857,
-0.395011127,
-0.6048498154,
-0.1688978672,
0.2190914303,
0.2244826704,
0.3801082373,
-0.1108992919,
0.2871206701,
-1.4339182377,
0.5116125345,
0.3883420825,
-0.1101710871,
-0.0089795552,
1.1103624105,
0.1182045192,
-0.4566075504,
0.3841823637,
-0.0323698111,
-0.5784082413,
1.1576910019,
0.8585913777,
0.8136885762,
0.2164126337,
-0.1486626267,
0.3458057046,
0.4440842271,
-0.2210344821,
0.3845784664,
-0.0637850314,
-0.5498214364,
-0.3879253864,
-0.3195967376,
-0.4037329853,
-0.2714576721,
-1.1405121088,
0.2516777813,
-0.3390649557,
-0.1190796196,
0.3612556756,
-0.4784381986,
-0.5161949396,
0.2886066437,
-0.2571747303,
1.039840579,
-0.5578352809,
0.7215279341,
0.7003334761,
-0.6741234064,
-0.7312349677,
0.1526292413,
0.1757999659,
-1.1461514235,
0.7540126443,
-0.1199163571,
-0.1315120906,
-0.1851714849,
-0.4967769682,
-0.2220806032,
0.7690987587,
0.4070706367,
-0.3425630927,
0.1013492644,
0.303165853,
0.6034610271,
-0.454836905,
0.104826808,
1.1325706244,
0.6278618574,
0.3145451844,
-0.8055916429,
0.707126081,
0.1983181983,
-0.0881418288,
0.3835534751,
-0.1462408602,
0.6110185385,
-0.2457888573,
-0.4421329498,
-0.1813015491,
0.5024980903,
0.2008959949,
0.4750164151,
0.7739595771,
0.8618904352,
0.4767405689,
-0.2144433111,
1.2233396769,
-0.2118126601,
0.2466425151,
1.2034345865,
-0.5390831232,
0.8583834767,
0.6778322458,
-0.6273982525,
0.5961682796,
0.3987407684,
-0.0676879585,
0.5375647545,
0.6946949363,
-0.3181740046,
-0.4018890858,
-0.1245379895,
-0.3827728033,
0.2126668841,
0.3528003991,
0.0655011386,
-0.7825492024,
-0.1182989404,
-0.2762434483,
0.437300384,
-0.201788649,
0.5740417838,
0.3494471014,
-0.7258826494,
0.4342003465,
-0.0475348458,
0.0794009268,
-0.3801428974,
-0.4964290857,
0.3634029627,
-0.0293261763,
-0.09392225,
-1.5586278439,
0.8840689659,
-0.1096302867,
-0.1602872759,
-0.2642079294,
0.4381312728,
-0.1148148999,
-0.4147819877,
-0.1158347875,
0.1232284158,
0.4836626649,
-0.2456623167,
-0.5230817795,
-0.4946309626,
-0.0287323333,
-0.0299915802,
-0.0094156861,
0.8115922809,
-0.3771913052,
0.7512514591,
0.5606432557,
0.1284681559,
0.0004741975,
0.0593902953,
0.74669379,
-0.7818568945,
-0.6299934983,
-0.7839353085,
0.0918641686,
0.0810446963,
-0.1466521919,
0.3663026094,
0.7626393437,
0.7385267019,
-0.046938207,
0.3101840615,
-0.0661585629,
0.4795675278,
-0.7246873379,
0.3856677115,
-0.5296173096,
0.3785924613,
0.2558484972,
-0.6924243569,
0.0686720088,
0.2587179542,
-0.7239388824,
-0.2130161077,
0.9687449336,
0.6409423351,
-0.4938139319,
0.5623563528,
0.0468373075,
-0.204373166,
-0.2509605587,
0.5135804415,
0.768384099,
-0.2454408854,
0.6464069486,
-0.1069127843,
0.2645890713,
0.1027225628,
-0.5847994089,
-0.3607866168,
-0.8937434554,
-0.5385629535,
-0.6560585499,
-0.2036027908,
0.7496433258,
0.4598179758,
-0.8645446301,
-0.200745523,
-0.3762291074,
0.0306810755,
-0.1564608365,
-0.3438753188,
0.2974605262,
-0.3956140876,
-0.5534139276,
0.0424871817,
-0.0486711338,
-0.1068262085,
0.1967545152,
0.4475032687,
-0.1866397709,
0.5401598215,
0.2773216069,
0.2809279561,
-1.3701101542,
-0.6041329503,
-0.8330760002,
0.0071729198,
0.0391002633,
1.2891898155,
-0.7586200833,
0.6278576255,
0.6341665387,
0.6202253103,
0.756203711,
0.2481988966,
0.7065618038,
-0.2418428063,
0.3370606303,
0.1087364256,
0.3997480869,
-0.2653993964,
-0.3615835011,
0.7160976529,
0.2015439123,
-0.1420035362,
-0.9023596048,
0.471853435,
-0.9726127386,
-0.6867024302,
0.7034657598,
-0.1342176348,
-0.494020164,
-0.352378279,
-0.1318661571,
-0.012311493,
-0.3083406687,
0.5273989439,
0.8682433367,
-0.134199217,
-0.320512861,
-0.8188939095,
0.2914943695,
0.27250579,
-0.7797086239,
-0.1618684977,
0.2416586578,
0.6413605809,
0.1632800251,
0.4148563147,
-0.1165964082,
0.119946003,
0.5672336221,
-0.1514881253,
-0.0792815089,
0.4573857784,
-0.2897132337,
0.0534191243,
-0.3488942087,
-0.3739528656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06712v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06712v3
|
Few-Shot Detection of Machine-Generated Text using Style Representations
| 2024-01-12T17:26:51 | 2024-05-08T15:50:40 |
Rafael Rivera Soto, Kailin Koch, Aleem Khan, Barry Chen, Marcus Bishop, Nicholas Andrews
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The advent of instruction-tuned language models that convincingly mimic human
writing poses a significant risk of abuse. However, such abuse may be
counteracted with the ability to detect whether a piece of text was composed by
a language model rather than a human author. Some previous approaches to this
problem have relied on supervised methods by training on corpora of confirmed
human- and machine- written documents. Unfortunately, model under-specification
poses an unavoidable challenge for neural network-based detectors, making them
brittle in the face of data shifts, such as the release of newer language
models producing still more fluent text than the models used to train the
detectors. Other approaches require access to the models that may have
generated a document in question, which is often impractical. In light of these
challenges, we pursue a fundamentally different approach not relying on samples
from language models of concern at training time. Instead, we propose to
leverage representations of writing style estimated from human-authored text.
Indeed, we find that features effective at distinguishing among human authors
are also effective at distinguishing human from machine authors, including
state-of-the-art large language models like Llama-2, ChatGPT, and GPT-4.
Furthermore, given a handful of examples composed by each of several specific
language models of interest, our approach affords the ability to predict which
model generated a given document. The code and data to reproduce our
experiments are available at
https://github.com/LLNL/LUAR/tree/main/fewshot_iclr2024.
|
[
-0.1198157817,
-0.4865420759,
0.6550908089,
-0.2799892724,
-0.0728922486,
-0.0142705077,
-0.1697172076,
-0.6124642491,
0.1002848297,
0.716663301,
-0.5640221834,
-0.5610136986,
-0.6790794134,
0.4500971138,
-0.6290735006,
0.9065745473,
-0.0227289554,
-0.1981119514,
-0.1428277791,
0.073744379,
0.1213849336,
-0.5516591072,
-0.3043347001,
-0.5250296593,
0.5451514721,
0.1524810195,
0.2553691566,
0.5465709567,
0.5298589468,
0.3076711595,
0.0810749978,
0.3396610022,
-0.3400792181,
0.1131174117,
0.280177176,
-0.4708765149,
-0.3775183856,
0.1710859984,
0.7724469304,
0.1207043156,
0.2875133157,
0.0555423163,
0.2161997557,
0.373123318,
-0.7928955555,
-0.0710052475,
-1.0250042677,
-0.0111846812,
-0.6162909865,
-0.3590147197,
-0.8337872624,
-0.0254944339,
-0.1659223437,
-0.370396167,
0.337747395,
-0.0083162542,
0.8800656199,
-0.0597582683,
-0.1456113607,
-0.3563680649,
-0.6483838558,
0.74075073,
-0.80473876,
0.0082970159,
0.6876580119,
0.2489075661,
-0.2082515359,
-0.6502999663,
-0.8387200236,
-0.2309173346,
-0.383407861,
-0.0459362604,
-0.5376463532,
-0.0881086439,
0.3770974278,
-0.200819999,
-0.6758530736,
0.3290456533,
-0.2312088758,
-0.5035856366,
0.6577208042,
0.1507737935,
0.3951136172,
-0.4057070017,
-0.2223002315,
-0.0525504984,
-0.7585727572,
-0.2416815162,
0.7190455198,
0.4731388688,
0.017294798,
0.4656226337,
-0.0775929019,
0.4224280417,
-0.1415111572,
-0.2657969892,
0.046020709,
-0.2482480556,
-0.1105608866,
0.1620048732,
1.2237607241,
0.103318885,
0.4755862057,
-0.0608349703,
-0.4819561243,
0.0640289709,
0.3084252477,
-1.0058118105,
-0.2460348159,
-0.1985817105,
-0.513199389,
-0.645742774,
0.137771681,
-0.4779579639,
-0.7590168715,
0.0211359952,
0.2905801237,
-0.4098924696,
-0.2466965914,
-0.2943621874,
-0.1457856894,
0.1424104422,
0.0924208462,
-1.0188624859,
0.1537739635,
0.7600136399,
0.898506999,
-0.1551917046,
-0.3360029757,
-0.4870118797,
-0.0504841246,
-0.4803906679,
1.1020480394,
-0.545397222,
-0.2787535489,
0.0178814437,
-0.1555772871,
0.1318656057,
-0.4181638062,
0.3792923093,
-0.5032656789,
0.1842264831,
-0.0755209774,
-0.6200438142,
0.2085280418,
0.4413478374,
-0.7198522091,
0.8813529015,
0.0850482807,
-0.980194211,
0.4319790006,
-0.4816190004,
-0.2810711861,
0.0268242769,
-0.3963762224,
-0.9202568531,
-0.0537594929,
0.2065971643,
0.6488605738,
-0.0196684673,
-0.0475000441,
-0.3363992274,
-0.5921636224,
0.3536306918,
-0.5372968316,
0.8304885626,
0.0693400279,
-0.0982997939,
0.1031565368,
-0.9175855517,
-0.1159054413,
0.3051733971,
-0.2539082766,
-0.4189057648,
-0.2276361287,
0.3171095252,
0.0588761717,
0.0908629075,
-0.6651802063,
0.3439338505,
-0.3220704794,
0.1246270612,
0.7055473924,
0.0185093861,
0.5667624474,
-0.4946671724,
0.7498295903,
-0.1189183146,
-0.2892639041,
-0.5540503263,
-0.4172032773,
-0.4978190958,
-0.4694851339,
0.1200603023,
0.5094147325,
-0.6611298919,
0.2328240871,
-0.1565251201,
-0.4188757837,
-0.5643091798,
0.5479472876,
0.7038955688,
0.4376069009,
0.2330211103,
-0.1305002421,
-0.7619547248,
-0.8123072386,
-0.5361801386,
-0.3705856204,
-0.2516117692,
0.1203945428,
0.6836941242,
-0.1753717065,
1.0214095116,
-0.5569515228,
-0.3554550111,
-0.4655214846,
0.5286874175,
0.0080835223,
0.5372924209,
0.8546352983,
-0.4882639647,
-0.5606202483,
-0.0045938874,
-0.9564240575,
-0.2445544302,
-0.384287715,
-0.1074413881,
0.4513676167,
0.8085237741,
-0.2993176877,
0.6207672954,
0.2885297239,
-0.049227953,
0.668865025,
-0.0035245649,
-0.1029751003,
-1.0542343855,
0.228832379,
0.1811021715,
-0.3906899095,
-0.6421203613,
-0.0993936062,
0.2052541822,
0.0193774272,
-0.3955702782,
0.6904546022,
-0.4413349032,
-0.033363495,
-0.6455474496,
-0.004003712,
0.1989432424,
0.4509241283,
0.1532696933,
0.712680459,
0.1267008781,
-0.116574496,
-0.074116461,
0.0435248502,
-0.4931492209,
0.5482946634,
-0.581730485,
0.669573009,
-0.3599006534,
0.3028284311,
-0.9553971291,
-0.2721768618,
0.3321390152,
-0.5002790093,
0.4864092469,
-0.6133798361,
-0.7524363995,
-0.1505579948,
-0.4011139572,
-0.0334032997,
0.3889090121,
-0.2819933593,
0.5372025371,
-0.0045811418,
-0.0304071363,
-0.4432066083,
-0.9309093356,
0.2049363405,
-0.1177487001,
-0.5933196545,
0.435184896,
0.1019543186,
-0.2786532938,
-0.1150891632,
0.1197466403,
-0.3527301848,
0.3322774768,
0.2796546221,
0.4924943447,
-0.4322006404,
-0.0079325866,
0.0838319957,
-0.2774857283,
-0.1271015555,
-0.1724590957,
0.492146939,
0.0566155128,
-0.4018740952,
-0.8249764442,
0.423494041,
0.4367164969,
-0.308850795,
0.6241434216,
0.888573885,
-0.5111746192,
-0.3601746261,
-0.2897485793,
-0.4116428196,
-0.486050874,
0.2527442873,
-0.4110560119,
-0.5415563583,
0.4405579269,
0.2033499181,
-0.0308562964,
0.2570712268,
0.4511335194,
-0.4039641321,
0.8321005106,
0.7781139612,
-0.3190481961,
0.7609854341,
-0.2969841957,
-0.0186487865,
-0.648668468,
0.1009692997,
-0.6257498264,
-0.4776127338,
-0.6377182007,
0.1077879593,
0.2544927001,
-0.0565261133,
-0.0375028327,
0.622349143,
-0.5193303227,
0.8196853399,
0.6848097444,
0.1842477173,
0.3865306973,
-0.0160881374,
-0.1164637879,
0.0880896375,
-0.3936689198,
-0.9784198999,
1.2828956842,
0.124933131,
0.6721304059,
-0.0950871855,
1.2029685974,
0.2219301015,
0.369966805,
-0.8194262981,
0.423968643,
-0.2491666228,
-0.7098013163,
-0.0079023335,
-0.1301056743,
-0.9045317769,
0.1389992684,
-0.4098514915,
-0.9453840256,
0.0423844904,
0.2674762011,
-0.4883573651,
0.411539495,
-0.6745629311,
0.9123623371,
0.0483678505,
-0.2722628415,
0.0920192301,
-0.4232723415,
0.3255524933,
-0.1775711775,
-0.1167711988,
-0.0629760101,
0.1964006424,
0.6954674125,
-0.2631496191,
1.2992812395,
0.078828238,
-0.0182560161,
0.527356863,
0.4032197595,
0.6499387622,
-0.302557379,
-0.2888180614,
-0.0299744792,
-0.0263859332,
-0.3246510625,
-0.5365569592,
0.5419569016,
-0.6235698462,
-0.2265637964,
-0.3723247647,
-0.3549755216,
0.1966037154,
0.4845571816,
0.7394099236,
0.5041492581,
-0.2749864161,
-0.0765671059,
0.247895807,
0.0479115732,
0.7654770017,
0.2068697363,
-0.1610952914,
-0.0509161949,
0.7444131374,
-0.0517455041,
0.1605018824,
0.3573491275,
0.318684876,
0.0347461253,
-0.7900632024,
-0.4738896787,
0.0427099392,
-0.7702739239,
-0.2818801701,
-0.5755343437,
-0.2132282257,
-0.3632521629,
-0.3257929087,
-0.2532782555,
-0.1841456145,
-0.756723702,
0.1659852862,
0.2558493614,
0.8172824979,
0.3210714161,
0.6411217451,
-0.749615252,
0.2890319228,
0.162574932,
0.0610330068,
-0.0831373632,
-0.6640740037,
0.0498739555,
-0.1797972769,
-0.3906158209,
-0.7930631638,
0.5145501494,
0.2282052338,
0.3381744623,
0.6239649653,
0.0623319708,
0.3194526136,
-0.48588866,
0.5249790549,
-0.0001370161,
-0.8295256495,
0.5772693753,
-0.3382184207,
0.2338913232,
0.6655620337,
0.3606799841,
-0.5523292422,
-0.2921124995,
-0.4472135901,
-0.2488990426,
0.8142598867,
0.1759025902,
0.3401118219,
0.0347305052,
0.3146559,
0.0318026282,
0.0389032885,
-0.8690457344,
0.1663295627,
-0.1616912335,
-0.3636720181,
0.2158685774,
-0.2722124159,
0.1507387459,
0.2786404788,
0.4407021701,
-0.4758934081,
0.2209273279,
0.0469128825,
-0.3795503676,
-0.0502190962,
0.3083364367,
0.7216056585,
0.282089889,
-0.1888242811,
0.3412257135,
-0.1770791709,
-0.4662477374,
-0.0949396789,
-0.0791711286,
-0.5674219728,
0.1276017278,
1.0233744383,
0.6538780928,
0.0814860538,
-0.4851945639,
0.6701849103,
0.2285666168,
-0.0430393182,
-0.2522339523,
0.1370856762,
-0.1552421153,
0.2655529678,
0.2651045024,
0.304305017,
0.0393729843,
-0.6164333224,
0.3510549068,
0.5127230883,
-0.4244902134,
-0.621122539,
0.4167703986,
0.0361546241,
-0.5049613118,
0.5768741369,
-0.6556053758,
-0.7948652506,
0.6125556231,
0.803799808,
1.1178617477,
0.1281114072,
0.1373218745,
0.427982986,
0.342602402,
-0.0537845567,
0.0981950313,
0.0641366988,
-1.0920594931,
-0.144907698,
-0.4747730792,
-0.1490501612,
0.0837735981,
-0.266320616,
0.5486049652,
-0.7948621511,
-0.2263674587,
0.3338525891,
-0.134570539,
-0.4967734218,
-0.3995362222,
0.5138149858,
0.474706471,
-1.0193558931,
1.0457243919,
0.4819688499,
-0.5956290364,
-0.360345751,
0.2070686072,
0.6779343486,
-0.825115025,
0.8355132937,
0.3113000989,
-0.3689675331,
-0.1240305975,
-0.8187823892,
-0.3141561747,
1.0317499638,
0.4733909369,
-0.5972399712,
-0.0608092435,
-0.0618410371,
0.4956749976,
-0.3295848072,
0.2342589647,
0.5100063086,
0.3110199869,
-0.0272323582,
-0.8023908734,
-0.0764616057,
-0.1557298303,
-0.140344888,
0.1169790626,
-0.2397033125,
0.7518288493,
-0.1842165738,
-0.3052054346,
0.3580382764,
0.651599884,
0.3120249808,
0.4241041243,
0.3513047993,
0.2225553393,
0.8683106303,
0.199042514,
1.2491593361,
0.0921311751,
0.1765735,
1.2007495165,
-0.239822343,
0.9827936292,
0.3615931571,
-0.1922606379,
0.554002583,
0.20888789,
-0.1747155786,
0.3614304662,
0.1736543775,
-0.3691078126,
-0.3576082885,
-0.0842625424,
0.1546665132,
0.8599008918,
0.055881571,
-0.6083608866,
-0.1869515181,
-0.09492331,
0.3742934167,
0.4624818265,
-0.0892424658,
0.8078047037,
0.1284666955,
-0.4662286639,
0.5280780792,
0.1065667942,
1.0907188654,
-0.5106828809,
0.0031020786,
-0.1414562613,
0.1431171894,
-0.3288995028,
-0.6853379607,
0.2361465394,
0.4318913221,
-0.1711712927,
-0.3395192921,
1.1823066473,
-0.465105325,
-0.8020429611,
-0.0326062664,
0.3365515471,
0.1576805711,
-0.2370238751,
-0.3339781463,
0.1662966013,
-0.1991116107,
-0.0472711846,
0.3842661977,
0.2648569643,
-0.1529886574,
0.4054222405,
0.5818077326,
-0.0715487301,
0.0728518069,
0.2327476293,
0.6734160185,
-0.4618069232,
-0.2799005806,
-1.2652224302,
0.2862637341,
-0.0517678671,
-0.3314924538,
0.43309322,
0.4466323256,
0.6558263898,
-0.074814491,
0.8477545977,
0.2384818792,
0.1873485148,
-0.5849831104,
1.2158674002,
-0.3899176121,
0.1606207639,
-0.7454355955,
-0.5587921739,
-0.6408922672,
0.6309084892,
-0.1953879595,
-0.0486096255,
0.5698959827,
0.982260704,
-0.257025063,
-0.1925571412,
0.2944352329,
-0.1745155156,
0.4531912506,
0.3080505431,
0.7821550369,
-0.414509058,
0.688439548,
-0.3399766684,
0.0401614197,
-0.3480931222,
-1.2726678848,
-1.1542464495,
-0.5945567489,
-0.4216611087,
-0.190613851,
-0.1998248994,
0.9541233182,
0.8738882542,
-0.8181555271,
0.0562624931,
0.0241087805,
0.2204055041,
-0.0431391671,
-0.0996595323,
0.3394271433,
-0.2193240672,
-0.7407332659,
0.555310607,
0.2464344501,
0.4012854993,
-0.3204493821,
0.1045020074,
-0.1155851632,
0.0178509392,
0.4972161651,
0.2460431755,
-0.6837015152,
-0.2394061536,
0.0899968222,
-0.3808468878,
0.1606706083,
0.9407839179,
-0.6910369992,
0.4984122515,
0.7697209716,
0.7550411224,
0.5361520052,
-0.1528764516,
0.2398152947,
-1.191606164,
0.2034276426,
0.2944107354,
0.4695582092,
0.4544800222,
-0.3902051151,
0.1154622808,
0.2819898427,
-0.1748137474,
-0.859690845,
0.2356373072,
-0.8372944593,
-0.2401759475,
1.0146735907,
-0.3092571199,
-0.2708285749,
0.1203588471,
-0.1962754428,
0.1315404475,
-0.4521964192,
0.5944171548,
0.7145138383,
-0.0641635284,
-0.3370568454,
-0.3639216721,
0.4253145456,
-0.0338797458,
-0.8205618262,
0.0294394474,
0.495880723,
0.146205619,
0.2874143124,
0.8885844946,
-0.0523207635,
0.2254300565,
0.0817751214,
0.1439246684,
-0.2129113674,
-0.4705556035,
-0.340182066,
0.0507103279,
0.2232609838,
-0.1753436774
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06709v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06709v1
|
Reliability Analysis of Psychological Concept Extraction and Classification in User-penned Text
| 2024-01-12T17:19:14 | 2024-01-12T17:19:14 |
Muskan Garg, MSVPJ Sathvik, Amrit Chadha, Shaina Raza, Sunghwan Sohn
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The social NLP research community witness a recent surge in the computational
advancements of mental health analysis to build responsible AI models for a
complex interplay between language use and self-perception. Such responsible AI
models aid in quantifying the psychological concepts from user-penned texts on
social media. On thinking beyond the low-level (classification) task, we
advance the existing binary classification dataset, towards a higher-level task
of reliability analysis through the lens of explanations, posing it as one of
the safety measures. We annotate the LoST dataset to capture nuanced textual
cues that suggest the presence of low self-esteem in the posts of Reddit users.
We further state that the NLP models developed for determining the presence of
low self-esteem, focus more on three types of textual cues: (i) Trigger: words
that triggers mental disturbance, (ii) LoST indicators: text indicators
emphasizing low self-esteem, and (iii) Consequences: words describing the
consequences of mental disturbance. We implement existing classifiers to
examine the attention mechanism in pre-trained language models (PLMs) for a
domain-specific psychology-grounded task. Our findings suggest the need of
shifting the focus of PLMs from Trigger and Consequences to a more
comprehensive explanation, emphasizing LoST indicators while determining low
self-esteem in Reddit posts.
|
[
-0.3266197145,
-0.830422163,
0.706207931,
0.5529681444,
0.0004199177,
-0.2610788047,
-0.1886401176,
-0.5318168402,
0.1060859039,
0.2983041704,
-0.6455084085,
-0.2899129093,
-0.8451548815,
0.2381868511,
-0.4837923646,
1.0546234846,
0.0837002173,
-0.2605497539,
-0.5399133563,
0.1928897351,
-0.6082212329,
-0.6660712957,
-0.6189938188,
-0.2833529711,
0.6816346049,
0.2611636221,
0.5160360336,
0.1965018362,
0.907143414,
0.2414480597,
0.0616685823,
-0.1964991391,
-0.661221385,
0.0218685549,
-0.4709036946,
-0.3351506591,
-0.4739536643,
0.205134213,
0.2920729816,
0.6858772635,
-0.1392403692,
0.485456109,
0.2423806041,
0.5242151618,
-0.7293775082,
0.1564131826,
-0.5636222959,
0.0209465642,
-0.2517158687,
-0.3465984464,
-0.3924624622,
-0.2434457093,
0.0533576272,
-0.1797103137,
0.2377127558,
-0.295491755,
0.7203320861,
0.5849881172,
-0.2836869359,
-0.1471762061,
-0.9151815772,
0.8331663609,
-0.5171980262,
0.0989281535,
0.6979605556,
-0.1125177294,
0.1020361409,
-0.4867998064,
-0.419190526,
0.0986384973,
-0.2914476395,
0.0462816879,
-0.2385499924,
-0.0928943455,
0.1789586991,
0.194467783,
-0.300537616,
-0.0887648687,
-0.4433679581,
-0.1460545361,
0.8764809966,
0.0999755114,
0.3490641415,
-0.3945104778,
-0.1175688654,
0.2404520065,
-0.3508334756,
-0.0166624095,
0.0419905111,
0.0074515468,
-0.1795683801,
0.6305744052,
0.0929343775,
0.383612901,
0.2059149146,
-0.2528749406,
0.2844672501,
-0.3845292628,
-0.0380001217,
-0.0656319708,
0.8310203552,
0.5866919756,
0.4775795639,
0.0104533918,
-0.0451455936,
0.4136580229,
0.7320324779,
-0.3789583445,
-0.1869313121,
0.2774046361,
-0.7688190341,
-0.3570739627,
-0.1038332283,
-0.6317402124,
-0.412227273,
-0.0885320827,
0.2274082601,
-0.5139246583,
-0.416513592,
0.0527181812,
-0.0347116962,
-0.1195352972,
0.0952568874,
-0.8587452769,
0.2934943438,
0.5801418424,
0.8287192583,
-0.2885528207,
-0.2343730628,
-0.1682672352,
-0.0349181667,
-0.2511611581,
0.815477252,
-0.3900892735,
-0.2333832085,
0.005763174,
0.0854580104,
-0.1252386868,
-0.1966752857,
0.749525249,
-0.2559333444,
0.1804728508,
-0.2374037653,
-0.5643862486,
-0.1770895869,
0.2238295972,
-0.4383493364,
1.0475809574,
0.1488326639,
-1.0211068392,
0.1303998381,
-0.5345396399,
-0.5410484076,
0.2233258486,
-0.0410540886,
-0.2469343245,
0.3039345741,
0.0335994363,
0.693390131,
-0.0917938277,
0.1540587991,
-0.7673099637,
-0.3916421235,
0.4653871655,
-0.4153414667,
0.7048650384,
0.0317147747,
-0.2359608114,
-0.2281897664,
-0.7526267767,
0.139820233,
0.0236919075,
-0.0499487072,
-0.72331357,
0.2140610069,
0.0281051099,
0.3699237704,
0.4369826913,
-0.4549925327,
-0.341557771,
-0.4684016407,
0.3938811421,
0.6646495461,
0.3272637427,
0.1901680827,
-0.0794784948,
0.508669138,
-0.2315900326,
0.2771985829,
0.2146968693,
-0.5048491955,
-0.435141772,
-0.1258079708,
-0.1052045077,
0.5178676248,
-0.4927499294,
0.6292559505,
-0.1420517713,
-0.3997593224,
-0.5634719133,
0.1191946194,
0.3980943263,
0.4742021561,
0.401137352,
-0.1741607487,
-0.6154901385,
-0.7728572488,
-0.3502729237,
-0.4052664042,
0.0401578695,
-0.0593128614,
0.540533483,
-0.5329645872,
0.9129017591,
-0.4727107286,
-0.3572280109,
-0.3472545743,
0.2994570732,
-0.2562940121,
0.2559528649,
0.4885821342,
-0.6169460416,
-0.3056639731,
-0.3343998492,
-1.1226978302,
-0.2497611195,
-0.0769286454,
0.0293663554,
0.2008907348,
0.3723187149,
-0.7264155149,
0.5871735215,
0.3943799734,
-0.4052306116,
0.5739338994,
0.1672046632,
0.0972682834,
-0.7434729934,
0.0555685088,
0.3860975504,
0.0965553224,
-0.5233269334,
-0.1956129223,
-0.2277504355,
0.0079572741,
-0.1234339848,
0.3695486188,
-0.1287710965,
-0.061931517,
-0.3345721066,
0.1999317706,
-0.0291314535,
0.2252783775,
-0.0972038209,
0.532617569,
0.3119908869,
-0.4219593406,
0.0944386572,
0.1339578182,
-0.0672416389,
0.7293350697,
-0.7120822668,
0.1256220192,
-0.2808558643,
-0.0643368736,
-1.1331574917,
-0.2569086254,
0.3388549089,
-0.7166312933,
-0.0453016236,
0.1637617052,
-0.4451008141,
-0.5093874931,
-0.2540085614,
0.2307285815,
0.2305602729,
-0.0232048035,
0.2960749269,
0.6729657054,
-0.3599533141,
-0.5264576077,
-0.6406121254,
0.0313592553,
-0.3094391525,
-0.4373078048,
0.2580339611,
-0.0206579715,
-0.5500785112,
0.2678919435,
0.0140789561,
-0.2305248976,
0.5103866458,
0.4657398164,
0.1009771228,
0.0110495295,
0.6758816242,
0.0069036162,
-0.2143075764,
0.6201425195,
0.1108359247,
0.4116979837,
-0.3391358256,
-0.0619864129,
-0.7246349454,
0.3797748089,
0.2578548789,
-0.0884991661,
0.9620816112,
0.5998635888,
-0.6227003932,
-0.1127382368,
-0.4739300311,
-0.3598589599,
-0.3967008591,
0.3230722845,
-0.1593661159,
-0.830840826,
0.2612617612,
0.3770268857,
-0.2899438441,
0.6733597517,
0.445209682,
-0.7346773744,
0.9674685597,
1.0015854836,
-0.067236267,
0.3380335271,
0.109015733,
0.4071804285,
-0.3454256356,
0.0951624215,
-0.459848702,
-0.1677380502,
-0.4892308414,
-0.0052273902,
0.272698313,
0.0000917844,
-0.1164582372,
0.0229307078,
-0.5907219052,
0.2576352656,
0.4071581364,
0.1613355577,
0.1910700202,
0.0177041572,
0.4505074322,
-0.4631634653,
-0.3786619902,
-0.7030670643,
0.9371419549,
0.5641112924,
0.8215394616,
-0.1160208508,
0.6756434441,
0.7261382341,
0.6237316728,
-0.7316706777,
0.557510078,
0.0424332097,
-0.7775397301,
-0.4227939248,
-0.4662800729,
-0.5716036558,
-0.1101625711,
-0.2883576751,
-0.8715301156,
0.0406049825,
0.3081893623,
-0.4258368611,
-0.0515355952,
-0.7168734074,
0.9429969192,
-0.2124787122,
-0.0427702107,
-0.3763647377,
-0.794852972,
0.647239387,
-0.2469750494,
0.1195255369,
-0.1950834095,
0.2727430761,
0.9045082331,
-0.2437389493,
1.1249606609,
-0.0915791541,
-0.16721645,
0.3609275818,
-0.0878540128,
0.0965139791,
-0.0352149755,
-0.0396655574,
0.2965355515,
0.1995812058,
-0.2286281586,
-0.6527559757,
0.4261236191,
-0.7957568169,
-0.3814004362,
-0.3599041402,
-0.0604973696,
-0.1412959695,
0.145292446,
0.2843987942,
0.1646790504,
-0.0751289129,
0.2605522275,
0.5575757027,
-0.1774625033,
0.2565842271,
0.2664690614,
0.0429008603,
-0.3159993589,
0.7619658709,
0.2056424618,
0.042938944,
0.1642118841,
0.1177724674,
-0.1474987566,
-0.2949211895,
0.1593708247,
0.4658527672,
-0.7588309646,
-0.1289883256,
-0.5700512528,
-0.3064997196,
-0.4612952173,
-0.0468699224,
-0.4801309109,
-0.2906400561,
-0.5313055515,
-0.3953753412,
0.2795516551,
0.6929222345,
-0.1115384996,
0.4189337492,
-0.845223248,
0.2952064276,
0.0428106636,
0.3323145509,
0.2044544816,
-0.3774492741,
-0.4152190089,
-0.129434064,
-0.3037678301,
-0.9282793999,
0.3207317293,
-0.0039567873,
0.3890384734,
0.5127815008,
0.2545359135,
0.4687997401,
-0.1704790294,
0.6092902422,
0.2811532319,
-0.910609901,
0.7603878379,
-0.2185294777,
-0.0253041517,
0.7055606842,
0.6774308085,
-0.7251185179,
-0.537825346,
-0.6347411275,
-0.5378912091,
0.4919902682,
0.2331879884,
0.0249816161,
-0.5407446027,
0.774332881,
-0.0953240693,
0.0763378963,
-0.9638963342,
-0.408221513,
-0.2113749236,
-0.5429581404,
-0.251287818,
-0.6692012548,
-0.0854966715,
-0.1610749215,
0.7107525468,
-0.0945933089,
0.4227931201,
0.2988726795,
-0.1245497018,
-0.294318378,
0.1625605375,
0.3036539257,
0.6876247525,
-0.3827553391,
0.2338768095,
-0.2174277455,
-0.4789843559,
0.1727528423,
0.1076813564,
-0.3063185811,
-0.2084255368,
0.6189534068,
0.2809621692,
0.2014732361,
-0.4488626719,
0.5518497825,
-0.1106382087,
0.0938293934,
-0.5198263526,
-0.0188808646,
0.0763374418,
-0.0022238053,
0.2895956039,
0.2308010012,
0.2234420925,
-0.5990867615,
0.4537689388,
0.32108441,
-0.6771760583,
-0.6420642734,
0.5109698772,
0.2661018968,
-0.4392503202,
0.4583615661,
-0.1392898262,
-0.2840338051,
0.3341206312,
0.3338352144,
0.9004733562,
-0.1249212325,
0.5538452864,
0.2466654778,
0.5923061371,
-0.0654178932,
0.2887024581,
0.2868013382,
-0.963157773,
-0.5493862629,
-0.5266780853,
-0.1360893995,
0.242598787,
-0.7196648717,
0.030124573,
-0.429112792,
-0.6049764156,
0.0144853462,
-0.0555342734,
-0.4383670688,
0.3959819674,
0.2856836319,
0.4447211921,
-1.0541210175,
0.4074384868,
0.5814186335,
-0.439129889,
-0.4862936437,
0.2901253104,
0.084986493,
-0.449637413,
0.6141419411,
0.2345427871,
-0.3371768892,
-0.15992634,
-0.661372304,
-0.861060679,
0.5666715503,
0.2292771339,
-0.1841101646,
-0.1195593402,
0.0667270049,
0.9965091944,
-0.2844697535,
0.0749304593,
0.4891555607,
0.2968298197,
-0.3443403244,
-0.6731984615,
0.1370133758,
-0.1312514246,
0.0225294568,
-0.1191485897,
-0.4430786967,
0.6863726974,
-0.3040598333,
-0.4435979426,
-0.1025537923,
0.6360169649,
0.0419120006,
0.4018905759,
0.4186386764,
0.6248431206,
0.6210805774,
0.1495900154,
1.010434866,
-0.1606193483,
0.5705434084,
1.2162979841,
-0.208990708,
0.89071244,
0.3369503319,
-0.0692001656,
0.5414316654,
0.608926177,
0.0623098016,
0.4620247483,
-0.1849719584,
0.0040266938,
-0.2338463217,
-0.1315803528,
-0.211030215,
0.5787026882,
0.5977902412,
-0.6137089729,
-0.0326405764,
0.1267831028,
-0.0699693486,
0.2036197335,
-0.3040496409,
0.6918019056,
0.3069109917,
-0.5995223522,
0.4813495576,
-0.0008388766,
0.4798729122,
-0.2867296636,
0.0115671456,
-0.1250867844,
0.4133344591,
-0.2490549833,
-0.8470426798,
0.618082583,
-0.0946247727,
-0.4137070775,
-0.3223993778,
1.3129291534,
-0.185426414,
-0.6414251924,
0.5174522996,
0.7110112309,
0.2194800526,
-0.2245713323,
-0.7762910128,
-0.0245524123,
-0.1417151541,
-0.1923448294,
0.1333322972,
0.567414403,
0.032240063,
0.800372839,
0.2599011064,
0.0130364634,
-0.0985349864,
0.113337487,
0.4451049566,
-0.8214247227,
-0.2294373512,
-0.9834661484,
0.3171681166,
-0.1505310982,
-0.3152147532,
0.878457427,
-0.0001922678,
0.672588706,
-0.1545331776,
0.9263671041,
-0.1536385268,
0.7543641925,
-0.1567240208,
0.7778615355,
-0.535685122,
0.1197685823,
-0.548763454,
-0.621463716,
-0.3583470881,
0.7726188898,
-0.4778221548,
-0.0165644623,
0.8301210999,
0.3572047651,
0.2794144452,
-0.0717563257,
0.2000452876,
0.3014970124,
0.0571394898,
0.24125956,
0.9059252739,
-0.2242767513,
0.4369196892,
-0.4060615301,
-0.2046802193,
-0.2333641648,
-0.5725195408,
-0.9398501515,
-0.4834811389,
-0.5013657808,
-0.4324760735,
-0.0806374699,
0.6009112,
0.3993877769,
-0.5234686732,
-0.0551909469,
-0.0457572415,
0.4486711025,
-0.4118730724,
-0.3911837041,
0.1874760687,
-0.5626962185,
-0.2360470444,
-0.0999700427,
0.4158878326,
-0.0799650922,
-0.4817059934,
0.2284144312,
-0.1841140091,
0.0539717749,
0.7724668384,
0.0974036381,
-0.6825342178,
-0.6957520247,
-0.0384878255,
-0.1618506759,
-0.0265268907,
0.5050193667,
-0.3915393651,
0.1479963362,
0.3107656538,
0.5274041295,
-0.0193487667,
0.2750610709,
0.5399340987,
-0.7136380076,
-0.3796348572,
0.2170791477,
0.3041548133,
0.4443641901,
-0.620941937,
0.6726373434,
0.6788413525,
-0.4381625354,
-0.8598393202,
0.0782819167,
-0.8277820349,
-0.2771559656,
1.0046916008,
-0.3119025826,
-0.2841108739,
-0.1783658862,
-0.0804344267,
0.0795948431,
-0.2693863511,
1.431325078,
1.0399544239,
-0.1940721273,
-0.4268353879,
-0.3868712485,
0.6375761628,
0.246364221,
-1.0167568922,
0.1389889717,
0.4227007329,
0.2177993059,
0.4987995028,
0.9248926044,
0.0000158023,
0.2148187608,
-0.1001257151,
0.259249568,
0.5815489888,
-0.4336841106,
-0.1540972143,
0.388466835,
-0.1469164789,
-0.0116569344
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06706v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06706v1
|
Multi-Candidate Speculative Decoding
| 2024-01-12T17:15:23 | 2024-01-12T17:15:23 |
Sen Yang, Shujian Huang, Xinyu Dai, Jiajun Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models have shown impressive capabilities across a variety of
NLP tasks, yet their generating text autoregressively is time-consuming. One
way to speed them up is speculative decoding, which generates candidate
segments (a sequence of tokens) from a fast draft model that is then verified
in parallel by the target model. However, the acceptance rate of candidate
tokens receives limitations from several factors, such as the model, the
dataset, and the decoding setup. This paper proposes sampling multiple
candidates from a draft model and then organising them in batches for
verification. We design algorithms for efficient multi-candidate verification
while maintaining the distribution of the target model. Our approach shows
significant improvements in acceptance rates on multiple datasets and models,
consistently outperforming standard speculative decoding.
|
[
-0.379760474,
-0.3065439165,
0.7357637286,
0.6786550879,
-0.3111931384,
0.2996363044,
-0.1723772436,
-0.4431418777,
0.3873590529,
0.7267916203,
-0.4390907884,
-0.2839288116,
-0.7095758915,
0.3433740139,
-0.8894382715,
0.7289363742,
0.0068314834,
-0.3436137736,
0.1543814987,
-0.0839106962,
-0.234732911,
-0.7894362211,
-0.8388307691,
-0.0660967529,
0.375395298,
0.2770696282,
0.332829982,
0.8774005175,
0.3684755862,
0.2931915522,
0.0013527466,
0.5141902566,
-0.2280493379,
0.3736993074,
0.0163938794,
-0.6034590006,
-0.3134472966,
-0.0266104098,
0.9488268495,
0.3094324172,
-0.2992212474,
0.071955584,
-0.2957780361,
0.3588378429,
-0.8604212403,
-0.090344727,
-1.1211528778,
-0.2176174521,
-0.5378302932,
-0.3807997704,
-0.970380187,
-0.2943900526,
-0.1949524879,
-0.3917230964,
0.6545206904,
0.2162150741,
0.6183073521,
-0.2063773125,
-0.5355163217,
-0.3213596642,
-0.7983337641,
0.7602242827,
-0.5985456109,
0.4705529511,
0.3524965346,
0.3237312734,
-0.1061049104,
-0.8221660256,
-0.7456482053,
0.1035817266,
-0.005627377,
-0.2219902128,
0.2148246914,
-0.1001538411,
0.2977453172,
0.4319010973,
-0.6621385813,
0.1430731565,
-0.4350609481,
-0.4687678516,
0.4771006703,
0.2288291454,
-0.0256647486,
-0.1405005902,
-0.3373659253,
-0.4233749211,
-0.4440085292,
0.0054744682,
0.6868695021,
0.517216444,
0.1383410394,
0.6020414233,
-0.5518072248,
0.9182161093,
0.0700571164,
0.0741309598,
0.2489319295,
-0.9026396275,
0.0841283724,
0.0112428544,
0.7077579498,
0.0711731687,
-0.258058548,
-0.1404645145,
-0.327457279,
0.4697506428,
0.3687765896,
-0.7599537969,
-0.0943586454,
0.755028069,
-0.5681893826,
-0.2425761968,
0.0583541766,
-0.7925291657,
-0.122451514,
0.07146997,
-0.1200756729,
-0.510204494,
-0.337592423,
0.687306881,
-0.4838689566,
0.1498195231,
0.11457818,
-1.2157315016,
0.0644790679,
0.7105610371,
0.6447402835,
-0.0146273114,
-0.636719346,
-0.7943759561,
0.0942033231,
-0.5345777869,
1.0605117083,
-0.6888602376,
-0.0716382489,
-0.0807345659,
-0.3254863024,
-0.2560763359,
-0.178604126,
0.843745172,
-0.82910496,
-0.1080631241,
-0.3534348011,
-0.5928246379,
0.2007199079,
0.5481210351,
-0.7820238471,
0.8368346691,
-0.0673743188,
-0.8375781178,
0.8422225118,
-0.5885113478,
-0.2227354944,
-0.0107593769,
-0.1053143516,
-0.1688622385,
0.2626986504,
0.8561589718,
0.5799233317,
-0.2208144367,
0.2401004434,
-0.2642301321,
-0.4104565084,
0.0534718484,
-0.4080232382,
0.6294600964,
0.4679613709,
0.0742837638,
0.1367040426,
-0.8445953727,
0.2085385174,
0.0341886617,
-0.6073247194,
-0.2096876651,
0.0636209622,
0.352638334,
0.2911072671,
-0.0892697349,
-0.5883981586,
0.4990108013,
-0.3622241616,
0.422514677,
0.6540840268,
0.0542928912,
0.1659573168,
-0.2698737681,
0.5278931856,
0.1801553965,
0.0903426632,
-0.5929720402,
-0.4517618418,
-0.8170374036,
-0.2574260533,
0.4564391077,
0.18209517,
-1.1549538374,
0.4036823809,
-0.0157021992,
-0.5080800056,
-0.5697684288,
-0.1318497211,
0.1239398047,
-0.1631388664,
0.2457469702,
-0.0910177156,
-0.6995774508,
-0.7808375955,
-0.5696417093,
-0.470592469,
0.0678560436,
0.0830269828,
0.3275691569,
-0.2760061622,
0.6240648031,
-0.4339039326,
0.1011435539,
-0.1912104785,
0.333517313,
0.4852686226,
0.6098034382,
0.7072467804,
-0.7188988924,
-0.2872138619,
-0.0967819244,
-0.3610117733,
0.3922941089,
-0.4962377846,
-0.151143387,
-0.038869366,
0.5568804145,
-0.5203056931,
0.0301766805,
0.7753682137,
-0.4627540112,
0.5142247677,
-0.2388017029,
0.4672957361,
-1.0405892134,
0.0307226367,
-0.1448012292,
-0.2403854877,
-0.5136829615,
0.4725172222,
0.160535574,
0.0301747099,
-0.3362774849,
0.4084759951,
-0.5020653605,
0.2633013725,
-0.2188374996,
-0.0480763279,
0.0742240921,
0.0816142857,
0.0819632411,
0.6828438044,
0.6544928551,
-0.6586850882,
0.3528130651,
0.0582162514,
-0.4794869721,
0.1857527196,
-0.5153899789,
0.4602238536,
-0.394834429,
0.5540610552,
-0.990154326,
-0.2823276222,
0.0108768214,
-0.1413173378,
-0.0429164767,
-0.275680691,
-0.6777415276,
-0.7068098187,
-0.008031874,
0.8411434889,
0.1455710828,
-0.6854788661,
0.6759698987,
0.1451285779,
0.1668955982,
-0.9580700994,
-0.3882262409,
0.1068321392,
-0.0379543677,
-0.4229600132,
0.4976761937,
0.1817483455,
0.1095179319,
-0.1225023419,
0.1174665987,
-0.1942219585,
-0.2165884227,
-0.2055705339,
0.140004769,
-0.0546759441,
-0.2047142386,
0.0971852019,
-0.2797817588,
-0.2091386765,
-0.7621613145,
0.6345874071,
0.1789356321,
-0.5121790767,
-0.1927082241,
0.6976642013,
0.8903244734,
-0.3768224418,
0.6075030565,
0.952867806,
-0.4337183237,
-0.4895454049,
-0.8807843328,
-0.3355503082,
-0.4483712316,
0.338914156,
-0.7007977962,
-0.864120841,
0.76085639,
0.1231297478,
0.4237218797,
0.6266455054,
0.7634654045,
0.5187698007,
0.9764041305,
0.7400423288,
-0.0140517829,
0.2458516657,
-0.0998535603,
0.2479029447,
-0.4543073475,
-0.3069594502,
-1.002171874,
-0.0089759827,
-0.3701016903,
-0.8123969436,
-0.0173142031,
-0.0366270952,
0.4324451983,
0.4613561928,
-0.5819407701,
0.6554138064,
0.7237452269,
-0.0054035583,
0.2966641486,
0.1152273342,
-0.4093975127,
0.1828895509,
-0.8106400967,
-0.3089531064,
1.234241128,
0.2805612087,
0.5096068978,
0.0475860685,
0.8900060654,
0.0354979709,
0.0233825445,
-0.4083851278,
0.3406892419,
-0.4480115175,
-1.0187036991,
-0.0787923634,
-0.5018954873,
-0.6462640762,
0.3464193344,
-0.4952940345,
-0.6421663165,
0.5418282151,
0.3859006763,
-0.5946466327,
0.4316354096,
-0.5088598132,
0.6510068178,
0.1363609433,
0.0031538268,
-0.5124300122,
-0.2392538935,
0.8354557157,
-0.2943720818,
-0.0931683183,
-0.1661814004,
0.2899104059,
0.7005973458,
-0.3240631521,
0.3766906857,
-0.2373933345,
0.0996910334,
0.2309989929,
-0.0371017829,
0.8241361976,
0.3001618981,
-0.5862588286,
0.0389521047,
0.2544395924,
-0.5908675194,
-0.3437947929,
0.3998155296,
-0.5510228872,
-0.1823082119,
-0.3864047527,
-0.5090495944,
-0.2343591005,
0.2051331848,
0.4958232939,
0.3741466999,
-0.1255400777,
0.0834474713,
0.2079208791,
-0.0568163246,
0.4885072708,
0.0855391622,
-0.2896177471,
-0.2071897686,
0.8942471147,
-0.2929400802,
0.0992207229,
0.2051187307,
-0.0594314002,
-0.5640045404,
-0.9985755086,
-0.5752477646,
0.0693523958,
-0.6518167257,
0.0513539687,
-1.0026475191,
-0.0730479956,
-0.4351153374,
-0.0715041831,
-0.7125033736,
-0.3320885897,
0.0725671202,
0.2778273225,
0.1840695143,
0.7601474524,
0.0556938387,
0.460113138,
-0.9378789663,
0.6629505754,
0.1923727244,
0.4535425603,
0.0298918393,
-0.2820954919,
-0.1485889256,
-0.1605773866,
0.1664440036,
-0.6372308731,
0.2533420026,
-0.0383943915,
0.7130257487,
0.5325736403,
0.0259796325,
0.691921711,
-0.6217166185,
0.6861726642,
0.1405438036,
-0.9473462701,
0.3486916721,
-0.3589499593,
0.2247531265,
0.7718784213,
0.2484457642,
-0.7388068438,
-0.6616779566,
-0.4520863295,
-0.9544288516,
0.8479532003,
0.2064798772,
0.0878357291,
-0.1425052732,
0.5216281414,
0.2667525709,
0.0349016041,
-0.4196864665,
-0.2000841796,
-0.0607967041,
0.1427965909,
-0.1057334393,
-0.6119799018,
0.0046140784,
0.1204952896,
0.5631927848,
-0.3793751597,
0.3225932121,
-0.0011695742,
0.3424027264,
0.2799184322,
0.4121286571,
0.4732553661,
0.5381067395,
-0.2896216512,
0.132463783,
-0.2060195506,
-0.4615142643,
0.3811694086,
0.0114546157,
-0.1020790264,
0.3649198413,
0.3018890023,
0.6415892243,
-0.3681338727,
-0.26387766,
0.2700613737,
-0.5796912313,
-0.3173309565,
0.1019145474,
-0.0928775817,
-0.0658290312,
0.0506080724,
0.5488992929,
0.7080742121,
0.2428806126,
-0.3396180272,
0.3904426992,
0.2234703153,
0.1771280318,
-0.1514720321,
0.6852375865,
0.1130213812,
-0.0650787279,
1.0105353594,
-0.5135583878,
-0.4074451327,
0.6103363633,
0.6824323535,
0.8989796042,
-0.0293359142,
0.1630967855,
0.5740790367,
0.4183617234,
-0.6281923056,
0.5539003015,
0.2187361717,
-0.9548463821,
-0.8033294678,
-0.8043370843,
-0.530777216,
0.0322694555,
-0.602745235,
0.3068352938,
-0.3440983295,
-0.5015448332,
0.2098530531,
-0.4371299148,
-0.8391979933,
-0.0630847886,
0.0293574166,
0.9858916998,
-1.0267606974,
0.9146981835,
0.3471299112,
0.1919824183,
-0.9428024888,
0.1379189044,
-0.0978443176,
-0.673283875,
0.4662382007,
0.1567949057,
0.1358983964,
-0.0949679464,
-0.0309651643,
-0.8776997328,
0.4133918285,
0.370875299,
-0.6648707986,
-0.3387237191,
-0.1570275277,
0.1857753843,
-0.385804832,
0.2970134318,
0.5118460655,
0.4142058492,
0.139468208,
-0.7633797526,
0.0852406397,
-0.2574252188,
-0.0035751404,
0.0673682019,
-0.3654272556,
1.2064079046,
-0.2038265318,
-0.164960131,
-0.0076135402,
0.7098309398,
0.7119845748,
-0.0841038153,
0.8560814261,
0.2314249426,
0.9134673476,
-0.1101087183,
1.0938825607,
-0.4685307145,
0.2311637849,
0.8595349193,
-0.2863749564,
0.9170957208,
0.5196132064,
-0.2095229775,
0.371219784,
0.7044352293,
0.0041683502,
0.2539690137,
0.1110055298,
-0.190640986,
-0.5783093572,
-0.1767444015,
-0.3501183689,
0.789593637,
0.372135967,
-0.3038898408,
-0.2570399344,
-0.1506436169,
-0.5767729282,
-0.0573425256,
-0.0132696917,
0.2634842992,
-0.1695607901,
-0.8967099786,
0.440602988,
0.6826536655,
0.9301989079,
-0.7171812057,
-0.0186035037,
0.1702367067,
0.3092173636,
-0.077149123,
-0.4681115746,
0.359690994,
-0.221351251,
-0.4251779914,
-0.4313542843,
0.5358482599,
-0.4565645158,
-0.8179727197,
0.1380157173,
0.6316589713,
0.1848428696,
-0.1891390234,
-0.5265882611,
0.4173795581,
-0.0795795992,
-0.137454465,
-0.1081214622,
0.2951020002,
-0.0646782666,
0.4335460067,
1.0357077122,
0.4355045855,
0.2597180605,
0.2235550284,
0.8469521999,
-0.5314151049,
-0.8753129244,
-1.0041257143,
0.2940068841,
-0.0480207317,
-0.4375511408,
0.7554141283,
0.5533645153,
0.7611333728,
-0.1175547689,
0.6319037676,
0.0192651544,
0.2767095268,
-0.7260200381,
0.5509467721,
-0.2540565133,
0.2486393303,
-0.2044199258,
-0.7549580336,
-0.3023382723,
0.3514353335,
0.2517595291,
0.0568436757,
0.7716315985,
0.706584096,
-0.1324913055,
0.1301095933,
0.0988131389,
-0.2608533204,
0.4605330229,
0.7911861539,
1.0188058615,
-0.5778522491,
0.4488902986,
-0.2809931934,
0.1113197729,
-0.2312670648,
-0.9990887642,
-0.9257900119,
-0.6468735337,
-0.2254375666,
-0.5857821703,
-0.1113643721,
0.9180380106,
1.2261283398,
-0.8541866541,
-0.1485716105,
0.0609050654,
0.0834501311,
-0.6616851687,
-0.1763986945,
0.3778060973,
-0.4707557857,
-0.8253974319,
0.6692604423,
0.2209960818,
-0.1227181628,
-0.3026721179,
0.2240037769,
-0.2689532936,
0.1213823706,
0.4890432954,
0.0838411301,
-0.6826461554,
-0.0768321007,
0.0874701887,
-0.1512318701,
-0.2155785114,
1.3888605833,
-0.771075666,
0.5215005279,
0.6883334517,
0.7212023139,
0.6445571184,
-0.0121593764,
0.6905286312,
-0.8861997128,
0.4200191498,
0.2510718703,
0.4071512818,
0.0431889333,
-0.5505629182,
0.2597410679,
0.2041182667,
-0.2475730926,
-1.0831222534,
0.2090324759,
-0.878026247,
-0.274333626,
0.9333099723,
-0.0932666957,
0.0692087263,
-0.3576807082,
0.1148729175,
-0.0843040869,
-0.4332649708,
0.600826323,
0.8367415667,
0.0259614009,
0.0577687882,
-0.3260816932,
0.430509299,
0.2902625501,
-0.6266227961,
0.4184384346,
0.2996858656,
0.0065075583,
0.348672241,
1.1605116129,
-0.1043291911,
0.2640779018,
0.6585981846,
-0.0948937535,
-0.0343583114,
-0.5487272739,
-0.2417629957,
0.6460132003,
0.2645927966,
-0.138332054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06692v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06692v2
|
An Experimental Design Framework for Label-Efficient Supervised Finetuning of Large Language Models
| 2024-01-12T16:56:54 | 2024-05-06T21:58:04 |
Gantavya Bhatt, Yifang Chen, Arnav M. Das, Jifan Zhang, Sang T. Truong, Stephen Mussmann, Yinglun Zhu, Jeffrey Bilmes, Simon S. Du, Kevin Jamieson, Jordan T. Ash, Robert D. Nowak
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Supervised finetuning (SFT) on instruction datasets has played a crucial role
in achieving the remarkable zero-shot generalization capabilities observed in
modern large language models (LLMs). However, the annotation efforts required
to produce high quality responses for instructions are becoming prohibitively
expensive, especially as the number of tasks spanned by instruction datasets
continues to increase. Active learning is effective in identifying useful
subsets of samples to annotate from an unlabeled pool, but its high
computational cost remains a barrier to its widespread applicability in the
context of LLMs. To mitigate the annotation cost of SFT and circumvent the
computational bottlenecks of active learning, we propose using experimental
design. Experimental design techniques select the most informative samples to
label, and typically maximize some notion of uncertainty and/or diversity. In
our work, we implement a framework that evaluates several existing and novel
experimental design techniques and find that these methods consistently yield
significant gains in label efficiency with little computational overhead. On
generative tasks, our methods achieve the same generalization performance with
only $50\%$ of annotation cost required by random sampling.
|
[
-0.2671591341,
-1.1456404924,
0.3714309335,
0.1328989863,
-0.2097807229,
-0.33267501,
-0.6800318956,
-0.295376271,
-0.1878570765,
0.452195555,
-0.4025371671,
-0.5411350131,
-0.2265417725,
-0.0663734227,
-0.3906080425,
0.988658309,
-0.3435944617,
-0.1421012878,
0.1550120413,
-0.0898892432,
0.0493025109,
-0.2158400267,
-0.8128720522,
-0.124749966,
0.6339123845,
0.6287100911,
0.5747848153,
0.8529653549,
0.4921491444,
0.2188096195,
-0.0495077968,
0.2359170169,
-0.6981668472,
0.0237755571,
0.0011317297,
-0.6386138797,
-0.2004873157,
0.1095598042,
0.6030608416,
0.8951925039,
0.0234426074,
0.1298030764,
0.0863312259,
0.3704681993,
-0.7465339303,
0.3130010962,
-0.3804466128,
0.1927755773,
-0.3217873871,
0.0580348596,
-0.6330329776,
-0.254789561,
-0.071058996,
-0.9231585264,
0.5008683801,
-0.0973588154,
0.7832925916,
0.3765739799,
-0.0358991027,
-0.0762457848,
-0.904276371,
0.8500447273,
-0.6538586617,
0.4962511659,
0.4678738415,
0.1883962303,
-0.1953795701,
-0.5674801469,
-0.2553306818,
-0.3829213083,
0.0261622071,
0.0800277665,
-0.1175621673,
0.4006772041,
0.2954894006,
0.5543362498,
-0.4714772403,
0.4923901558,
-0.4383416474,
-0.1210850179,
0.6063004732,
-0.1269166023,
0.0737472326,
0.3316920698,
-0.1936489046,
-0.2513616979,
-0.6315996647,
0.0303077307,
0.2810386121,
0.6184108853,
-0.1032181606,
0.6520996094,
-0.5458945632,
0.7452581525,
0.1431357265,
0.0337890498,
0.414050281,
-0.2000948191,
-0.430603981,
0.0483637936,
0.8228024244,
0.0059187245,
0.3456498384,
-0.4316626787,
-0.4188260138,
0.0773582608,
0.1719703674,
-1.092905879,
-0.5489600897,
0.1145717427,
0.0032263969,
-0.5279088616,
-0.2206106633,
-0.4425235689,
-0.1579562724,
-0.4406060278,
0.5449854732,
-0.3724144399,
-0.0631631091,
0.0847473294,
0.0914707854,
-0.0983254388,
0.2762428522,
-1.0083349943,
0.147334978,
0.4893047214,
0.6419471502,
-0.3056636751,
-0.0283913948,
-0.64502424,
0.1220178157,
-0.6936546564,
0.5434752703,
-0.4855425358,
-0.1730476618,
-0.1775213927,
-0.0174044874,
0.2382021844,
-0.2401503175,
0.6201461554,
-0.4625368118,
-0.171886161,
0.080570139,
-0.5643672943,
-0.0995780453,
0.0373713896,
-0.7580041289,
0.9091344476,
0.2037646025,
-0.5165929794,
0.4373647273,
-0.6299889088,
-0.6118736863,
0.1547473073,
-0.4057600796,
-0.5674536228,
0.241827473,
0.1414128542,
0.653876245,
-0.1166119799,
0.3723963499,
-0.3265458643,
-0.8093372583,
0.3117933869,
-0.6872367859,
0.4924824834,
0.4863652289,
-0.7172123194,
0.2193041891,
-1.001894474,
0.0268923119,
0.0079669477,
-0.6919747591,
-0.6063981056,
-0.1991135776,
-0.0455774516,
-0.2358251661,
-0.1813873947,
-0.6015565395,
0.3015987873,
-0.3975811005,
0.2271393389,
0.7678320408,
-0.0704354793,
0.705845654,
0.0427663587,
0.3385975957,
-0.2837045193,
0.1523165703,
0.0398320891,
-0.1388905197,
-1.00659132,
-0.6275137067,
0.651032567,
0.3192357421,
-0.7413619161,
0.1646829844,
0.1319400221,
-0.4288820028,
-0.6818801165,
0.2783761621,
0.6391666532,
0.1157439798,
0.4046161175,
-0.1403052956,
-0.1637767851,
-1.2046830654,
0.1800348759,
0.2482761145,
-0.3675920069,
0.2210023254,
0.1454664618,
-0.1293009669,
0.8033599854,
-0.6826966405,
-0.078386195,
-0.0101086097,
0.5041453242,
0.0754405856,
0.570949018,
0.5956690907,
-0.6185846925,
-0.2579632401,
0.0820394084,
-0.4974319339,
-0.3984964788,
-0.3044460118,
-0.3052007556,
0.1494299173,
0.4531364441,
-0.2986745834,
0.2857321501,
0.484265238,
0.1085725129,
0.356990397,
-0.1179492474,
0.0379805267,
-0.5426897407,
-0.0787874907,
0.1779936254,
0.166700229,
-0.6362389326,
0.2478221804,
0.3007909656,
-0.0354531482,
-0.4488080144,
0.4160619378,
-0.5782960653,
0.4375068843,
-0.324429214,
-0.0767617226,
-0.122001484,
0.7723156214,
0.0392194986,
0.9068588018,
0.4507097602,
-0.644166708,
0.1053000465,
-0.2445717454,
-0.3463154137,
0.3066196442,
-0.5805370808,
-0.083755441,
-0.2593365014,
0.1192890853,
-1.0842318535,
-0.3011741936,
0.3017484844,
-0.1223817021,
0.5712461472,
-0.1492501646,
-0.425336659,
-0.1123590767,
-0.1998457164,
0.3196803033,
0.4324272573,
-0.5441058874,
0.2180101126,
0.1581283212,
0.0331151225,
-0.3080071509,
-0.9090228677,
-0.3475953639,
-0.1602946669,
-0.1962800622,
0.0394935347,
-0.0371192768,
-0.1766012013,
-0.0545361713,
-0.2772370577,
-0.1800227761,
0.3472526968,
0.172410652,
0.0133919604,
-0.3242686987,
0.4198643267,
0.182800144,
-0.0949982479,
-0.1077172011,
-0.3304689527,
0.1448495984,
0.0911052972,
-0.5151868463,
-0.4822794497,
0.2719738483,
0.2613811791,
-0.3499864936,
0.583681345,
0.5888205171,
-0.3722305596,
-0.7836749554,
-0.4924066067,
-0.1506786197,
-0.4782269597,
0.4760782123,
-0.3901354373,
-1.1116608381,
0.1797175109,
-0.1157080382,
0.5839677453,
0.1808213592,
0.3568175137,
-0.0187044479,
0.9036854506,
0.5034472942,
0.2521908283,
0.7066002488,
-0.4734330475,
0.1819984168,
-0.5524746776,
0.252299428,
-0.4217641354,
-0.4287078679,
-0.4006385505,
-0.6964739561,
0.1263836175,
0.3218804896,
-0.2947410643,
0.1948505789,
-0.7518411875,
0.5175493956,
0.8296117187,
0.2348495871,
0.1751142591,
0.1322371215,
-0.1442262381,
0.1526814848,
-0.6335526109,
-0.3681658208,
1.2154709101,
0.2756304145,
1.0807749033,
0.0734357685,
0.7969606519,
-0.0072447076,
0.5980619788,
-0.8369970322,
0.401555419,
-0.311776787,
-0.6460897326,
-0.5998016,
-0.5425364375,
-0.8969906569,
0.3579707146,
-0.1701807529,
-0.4906543791,
0.1692710817,
0.4764057398,
-0.4169742763,
0.169095099,
-1.0636366606,
0.7956045866,
-0.3119970858,
-0.8078954816,
0.1676760912,
-0.3458830118,
0.5643905401,
-0.4110404849,
0.2729978263,
-0.0002177227,
0.3214430511,
0.8649070263,
-0.2623698115,
1.158249259,
-0.1593179852,
-0.2644625306,
0.4617035091,
0.1187761351,
0.6286124587,
-0.1007105187,
-0.1502683461,
-0.3391224444,
-0.3278339505,
-0.378330797,
-0.4325812459,
0.7668938637,
-0.6851314306,
-0.3730987608,
0.0185426846,
-0.6517567039,
-0.1559506208,
0.150173068,
-0.1302357316,
0.4258010387,
-0.0520094037,
0.3884755671,
1.084000349,
-0.1480157971,
0.0730864629,
0.5851450562,
0.0757552981,
-0.2516906261,
1.1337332726,
0.3579439819,
0.6651483774,
0.3979443908,
0.2960229814,
0.1129036993,
-0.8215137124,
-0.5589793921,
0.0311787911,
-0.5129155517,
-0.2064178884,
-0.4603535533,
-0.0757768974,
-0.2058925778,
-0.3499847353,
-0.5879294276,
-0.65068084,
-0.3303771913,
-0.461777389,
0.5520002842,
0.3422817588,
-0.133782208,
0.5173915625,
-0.2989345193,
0.4053455591,
0.5188427567,
0.6251180768,
0.1006870493,
-0.2867254615,
-0.2564314008,
0.3496343493,
-0.407862246,
-0.5444241762,
-0.0401152894,
0.2199752778,
0.758617878,
0.5944239497,
0.4443750083,
0.5927895904,
-0.5354119539,
0.4992956221,
-0.0223885905,
-0.5694901943,
0.4747986794,
-0.3851638436,
0.2036848217,
0.6759772897,
0.3555612564,
-0.2114581168,
-0.6645405889,
-0.6274383664,
-1.2556689978,
0.6881082058,
0.2858954072,
0.0434299223,
-0.0994584337,
0.3599146605,
0.2330989838,
0.0179610047,
-0.5673019886,
-0.3287006617,
0.080270417,
-0.3383848965,
-0.1773480624,
-0.1132386103,
-0.3648364544,
-0.1116983965,
0.8201970458,
-0.2876728773,
-0.0308710169,
-0.0432688445,
-0.0857890099,
-0.1224596798,
0.4892358482,
0.5434551239,
0.3318728507,
-0.2826503813,
0.439404428,
0.1766972542,
-0.255869627,
0.2179890275,
0.2950173318,
-0.619620502,
-0.1253203452,
0.2796276212,
1.1146814823,
0.513528645,
-0.5724515319,
0.3882131279,
0.1179947108,
-0.4823898375,
0.1140411347,
0.5134925246,
0.1395417452,
0.2373224795,
0.2176340073,
-0.3265433609,
0.269085288,
-0.305603385,
0.3602048457,
0.3208293617,
-0.4484079778,
-0.108099103,
0.7621384263,
0.3608891368,
-0.2178278416,
0.5758514404,
-0.3237626553,
-0.1251860261,
0.4652636647,
0.5147255063,
0.6693620682,
-0.1274527162,
0.174500376,
0.2952097952,
0.1907025874,
-0.2550719976,
0.0035955161,
-0.2281476259,
-0.3868755102,
-0.6064834595,
-0.8113148808,
-0.5333375335,
0.195151493,
-0.5221920013,
0.2921724916,
-0.3663668334,
0.1191922501,
0.051494766,
-0.1275635958,
-0.453843534,
0.3806349337,
0.2110532522,
0.6550616026,
-1.022467494,
0.7407816648,
0.5831613541,
-0.4334926605,
-0.975779295,
-0.3594956398,
-0.0574067868,
-0.6255116463,
0.5485303998,
0.1241481751,
0.0630164295,
0.0835883245,
-0.7137655616,
-0.7195668817,
0.7966391444,
0.2200166732,
-0.8172204494,
0.1877452582,
0.0317797363,
0.5657832026,
0.0430932343,
0.1215096638,
0.5745843649,
0.3857565522,
0.3950486481,
-0.7741119862,
-0.0497839786,
-0.2422882617,
-0.1580881178,
0.3943746984,
-0.5372484326,
0.7075989246,
-0.19442451,
-0.2640602291,
-0.1220663339,
0.7606693506,
0.3932640254,
0.0753050074,
0.3817523122,
0.5239384174,
0.6867106557,
-0.1651553065,
0.7177516222,
0.0688693747,
0.4502034783,
1.1284403801,
0.0513300225,
0.5459510088,
0.5360527039,
-0.1206485406,
-0.3383795023,
0.6830769181,
-0.1097085252,
0.7325942516,
0.9797280431,
-0.2577215433,
-0.33000049,
-0.1106851101,
-0.2060907334,
-0.0433301143,
0.2682636976,
-0.3573864698,
-0.1810023934,
0.1092185229,
0.276284039,
-0.0780577064,
-0.177890867,
0.5784379244,
-0.090822272,
-0.419829309,
0.8215726614,
0.0368398316,
0.9434117079,
-0.7535327077,
-0.0872034803,
-0.2989742756,
0.4384462833,
-0.0668236166,
-0.6104172468,
-0.0533962697,
0.061290063,
0.0839664117,
-0.354478687,
0.1739492267,
-0.7011595964,
-0.7127872705,
-0.1078957841,
0.0118775787,
0.2358943075,
0.1957398653,
-0.2378921807,
0.316699475,
0.048774153,
-0.556393683,
0.3295204937,
0.6707202792,
-0.4166828692,
0.4215689898,
0.6383157969,
0.1724081784,
0.1790570617,
0.1536993533,
1.0008960962,
-0.2719691396,
-0.2405811995,
-0.5673802495,
0.5375761986,
0.0393027291,
-0.2959238887,
0.5521693826,
0.6940948963,
1.158749938,
-0.1296807528,
0.924788177,
0.0198977143,
0.2783687711,
-0.6024062634,
0.6560755968,
-0.538105011,
0.1045933291,
-0.3928355873,
-0.7459118366,
-0.5975627303,
1.016451478,
-0.1968327016,
-0.1543498188,
0.4929531515,
0.7813549042,
-0.3945122659,
0.0538879596,
0.1409078687,
0.179180637,
0.5962325335,
0.6243914366,
0.6001093388,
-0.2559509873,
0.5747717619,
-0.8512629867,
-0.5605953932,
-0.1269045919,
-0.6922044754,
-0.980168879,
-0.3089906573,
-0.5529327989,
0.2076836973,
0.2489530593,
0.8665794134,
0.7099334002,
-0.9087147117,
-0.1149638966,
-0.209704712,
-0.307549566,
-0.4817311168,
-0.2385881692,
0.6725538373,
-0.5311916471,
-0.8941892982,
0.3204594553,
-0.1261751801,
0.2971843183,
-0.1812493503,
0.1840141267,
-0.1531829387,
-0.1867281497,
0.5151393414,
0.2716961205,
-0.6385967135,
-0.4482373893,
-0.1481951326,
-0.2091389596,
-0.1760914922,
0.5983755589,
-0.4419175088,
0.3557676673,
0.3756944835,
0.9194641113,
0.6428959966,
0.0589930862,
0.5495404005,
-0.8643556237,
0.2275199145,
0.0949029997,
-0.0420108326,
0.1062062532,
-0.2875070572,
0.7928346992,
-0.0469643921,
-0.4291549921,
-1.0002058744,
-0.0535983145,
-0.9460766315,
-0.3317114115,
1.4051626921,
-0.2667370439,
-0.2539140582,
0.0667275712,
-0.4364586473,
0.3227407634,
-0.3783518672,
0.7172085643,
0.6103241444,
-0.2470237166,
-0.1052173227,
-0.8700759411,
0.3553341627,
0.2784813344,
-0.5671896935,
0.4671785831,
0.7222523093,
0.2316684723,
0.065853186,
0.3374152482,
0.2295629084,
0.1406886727,
-0.1447226256,
0.4057948291,
-0.4585748911,
-0.3748964667,
-0.1106080338,
0.2882005274,
0.2622692883,
-0.411210984
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06688v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06688v2
|
Don't Rank, Combine! Combining Machine Translation Hypotheses Using Quality Estimation
| 2024-01-12T16:52:41 | 2024-06-06T17:45:39 |
Giorgos Vernikos, Andrei Popescu-Belis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Neural machine translation systems estimate probabilities of target sentences
given source sentences, yet these estimates may not align with human
preferences. This work introduces QE-fusion, a method that synthesizes
translations using a quality estimation metric (QE), which correlates better
with human judgments. QE-fusion leverages a pool of candidates sampled from a
model, combining spans from different candidates using a QE metric such as
CometKiwi. We compare QE-fusion against beam search and recent reranking
techniques, such as Minimum Bayes Risk decoding or QE-reranking. Our method
consistently improves translation quality in terms of COMET and BLEURT scores
when applied to large language models (LLMs) used for translation (PolyLM,
XGLM, Llama2, Mistral, ALMA, and Tower) and to multilingual translation models
(NLLB), over five language pairs. Notably, QE-fusion exhibits larger
improvements for LLMs due to their ability to generate diverse outputs. We
demonstrate that our approach generates novel translations in over half of the
cases and consistently outperforms other methods across varying numbers of
candidates (5-200). Furthermore, we empirically establish that QE-fusion scales
linearly with the number of candidates in the pool.
|
[
-0.3158409595,
0.0772206038,
0.597019136,
0.0398240983,
-0.2745366991,
0.4743197858,
-0.0902431756,
-0.3020450771,
0.4432363212,
0.3005053997,
-0.3001573384,
-0.5039325356,
-0.8218640089,
0.0347827263,
-0.5325809121,
0.9087181687,
0.1786078662,
0.256152451,
-0.1680173874,
-0.0731192827,
-0.3628335595,
-0.16706644,
-0.3079346418,
-0.2506482005,
0.7082270384,
0.3693155944,
1.1727756262,
0.5834956765,
0.639087677,
0.3144637048,
0.0727636665,
0.4461378753,
-0.5504053235,
0.217909649,
-0.1991774142,
-0.4178263545,
-0.3694321513,
0.3747950792,
0.6918538213,
0.7997885942,
0.0407938063,
0.0532626584,
-0.0239293892,
0.5437005162,
-0.7862913609,
-0.3566422164,
-0.7586061358,
-0.0074192155,
-0.0187311377,
0.0193194281,
-0.4399774671,
-0.638273716,
0.0706318393,
-0.3102541864,
0.0433820374,
0.2757812142,
0.9368881583,
0.4138522744,
-0.5039986372,
0.3221134543,
-0.5448772311,
1.0924943686,
-0.7742266655,
0.4562700391,
0.3156719506,
0.5288158655,
-0.2250228375,
-0.4514757693,
-0.519220829,
-0.2073484212,
-0.0860865936,
0.3508434892,
-0.2102916092,
-0.0632380843,
-0.3192928135,
0.4605871439,
-0.8015246987,
0.3928931952,
-0.0842305422,
-0.1443156302,
0.8377989531,
-0.0694755763,
0.4911279976,
-0.1744898856,
-0.4585159421,
-0.6034348011,
-0.5566811562,
-0.0143376309,
0.1661440879,
-0.0492073707,
0.2923690677,
0.7453766465,
-0.2077527195,
0.6708421111,
0.0611536615,
-0.0023818177,
0.2291684151,
-0.6254267097,
-0.2020304948,
-0.1022515744,
1.2084554434,
0.6758812666,
-0.2787711322,
-0.709692955,
-0.2683190405,
0.0475049801,
0.2273772806,
-0.3934848011,
-0.1652432829,
0.2955312431,
-0.4796215892,
-0.4501902163,
0.1270628572,
-0.6381882429,
-0.1327731311,
0.0198364537,
0.8562881947,
-0.327306062,
-0.0963457674,
-0.1911031157,
-0.4631997943,
0.0409004949,
-0.1373754442,
-0.7709331512,
0.1447078884,
0.5008766055,
0.6498163342,
-0.4084871113,
-0.5269664526,
-0.6561941504,
-0.2212960571,
-0.6073909402,
0.5987846851,
-0.2068421841,
-0.4236972332,
-0.182291761,
-0.3844035566,
-0.2304377407,
-0.7399407625,
0.6645917296,
-0.4426959753,
0.4974263906,
-0.1451230794,
-0.7241361737,
-0.0883215368,
0.0225347169,
-0.580743134,
0.9360442162,
0.2402431071,
-0.3786877692,
0.4862198532,
-0.2051004469,
-0.2233238667,
0.0380797721,
0.0021658209,
-0.4449901879,
0.3556478024,
0.3214198053,
0.2937949896,
-0.3343038857,
0.3638177812,
-0.0775415972,
-0.35542503,
0.4706352949,
-0.1948779821,
0.4087603092,
0.2421423644,
-0.2121787667,
0.3659442067,
-0.1455745697,
0.3079336584,
0.0026282603,
-0.2707029879,
-0.2612992823,
0.0405333415,
-0.0017528669,
0.4215622246,
0.4003607631,
-0.5070391893,
0.1507842541,
-0.714517653,
0.2612356544,
0.1901185811,
-0.1920922548,
0.8363170028,
-0.5362936258,
0.3190038502,
0.1083728969,
0.1555521339,
0.2037784606,
-0.5574524999,
-0.6067929268,
0.0640647113,
0.6043260694,
0.6245317459,
-1.1069254875,
0.746350646,
-0.5536265373,
-0.783703506,
-1.1520235538,
0.186763376,
0.5658387542,
0.1507751793,
0.5466707349,
-0.1769867241,
-0.3711408675,
-1.0752540827,
-0.6354948282,
-0.2850977182,
-0.2698724568,
-0.1625210196,
0.2199487388,
0.156686604,
0.7796336412,
-0.3301438093,
-0.115691036,
-0.2113691419,
0.0791786611,
0.178782776,
0.5674280524,
0.4896999002,
-1.0045508146,
-0.3319036365,
0.0190294683,
-0.7409377098,
0.1521475613,
0.0002998918,
-0.3396897912,
0.0858155414,
0.1703695208,
-0.387388587,
-0.0102340449,
0.9263314009,
-0.258969605,
0.2057290822,
-0.1771732569,
0.6721689701,
-1.4953095913,
-0.1560354382,
0.1904549003,
-0.1416040212,
-0.5947526693,
0.3196159005,
0.2518684566,
-0.1218815744,
-0.543189168,
0.4696122706,
-0.0911549032,
-0.1541465223,
-0.3562075496,
0.4380830526,
0.0653607696,
0.1901067197,
-0.1213624626,
0.7894917727,
0.1521665305,
-0.311296314,
0.0646483153,
0.3685014844,
-0.3934476972,
0.4029487669,
-0.4781604707,
-0.2085331082,
-0.004344536,
0.0811645836,
-1.2061282396,
-0.0881408751,
0.090374805,
-0.8762260675,
0.1619196683,
0.1387813091,
-0.4964203835,
-0.2711711228,
-0.3091813326,
0.4176301956,
0.8224163651,
-0.4914622903,
0.2265293151,
0.4326553047,
-0.0249326695,
-0.5662611127,
-0.727507174,
0.5019074678,
-0.1815637648,
-0.7893356085,
0.8266585469,
-0.005771575,
-0.1146636158,
0.2027628273,
-0.1589590609,
-0.2676016092,
0.2229708284,
0.0270328876,
0.3804805875,
-0.1462274492,
-0.0836676732,
0.4438556135,
-0.2555943131,
-0.4775387347,
-0.5984157324,
0.2378742248,
0.2741203308,
-0.2116858512,
-0.5068823099,
0.4073274434,
0.7227897048,
-0.2601560354,
0.894505918,
0.7172955275,
-0.3529384732,
0.1390615404,
-0.7406923771,
-0.3367339373,
-0.4049898386,
0.2637894452,
-0.1859277189,
-0.8542199135,
0.2987045348,
0.1302946657,
0.4216612279,
0.5766358972,
0.3877747059,
-0.4052281678,
1.2489395142,
0.2490389645,
-0.2842794359,
0.4215395749,
-0.1244374365,
0.3909283876,
-0.7570114136,
-0.1601926386,
-0.6156552434,
-0.8149561882,
-0.9813481569,
-0.44293046,
0.5849261284,
0.263132751,
0.1224142015,
0.6812444925,
-0.3289257884,
0.3933548629,
0.8290095925,
-0.072799623,
0.3093908131,
0.1179613024,
0.1202697232,
-0.2535704076,
-0.8950182796,
-0.2794058919,
1.0697818995,
-0.0251026526,
0.2267876416,
0.3169274628,
1.2829037905,
0.1911475211,
0.0808008313,
-0.7091559768,
0.5038299561,
-0.4553368092,
-0.3074090779,
-0.3941632509,
-0.9075830579,
-1.232262969,
0.775852561,
-0.5724784136,
-0.4202804863,
0.1507713199,
-0.098855637,
-0.2357333004,
0.1092270613,
-0.6578751206,
0.8412715197,
-0.3131149411,
-0.057908114,
-0.3691975176,
-0.4186181426,
0.4586560726,
-0.0368854217,
0.185573563,
-0.1431935132,
-0.0191359073,
0.74921453,
-0.3121286035,
0.2303800881,
0.2105716616,
0.0893431306,
0.026366191,
0.1565472037,
0.2601041198,
-0.0565883666,
-0.214454174,
0.3082357943,
-0.0158578418,
-0.7293285728,
-0.7883840799,
1.0017566681,
-1.0248930454,
-0.4358891547,
-0.1825920939,
-0.6300318241,
-0.1630740017,
0.3121835887,
0.52523911,
-0.0289025735,
-0.2214711607,
0.0773390755,
0.1438925117,
-0.1616372019,
0.4886810482,
0.2464687526,
-0.0109665794,
-0.9342300892,
1.2452235222,
0.2530864477,
0.5307137966,
0.438695848,
0.0730430931,
-0.4805661142,
-0.7387233973,
-0.5376870632,
0.1690029502,
-0.4177701473,
-0.2660061121,
-0.5061868429,
-0.209621653,
-0.4608356059,
-0.1594437212,
-0.382663995,
-0.6087011099,
0.1534787267,
0.1820950955,
-0.2183717042,
0.3799422085,
0.1000291705,
0.4499421716,
-1.1942921877,
0.3040872216,
0.2029686719,
-0.1165180579,
-0.2779299915,
-0.5234281421,
-0.3739494979,
0.2219025195,
-0.4591163695,
-1.0000350475,
0.6671207547,
-0.013010527,
0.9539774656,
-0.2343749702,
0.1056890562,
0.3309682608,
-0.2254373133,
0.8987674713,
0.4627844095,
-0.9313422441,
0.440544039,
-0.2871738672,
0.2509874403,
0.7235905528,
0.3725225329,
-0.5283681154,
-0.7168886662,
-0.6744709015,
-0.9862537384,
0.3159401417,
0.7511150241,
-0.1827712655,
-0.127329722,
0.145565629,
-0.2629170716,
0.2619356215,
-0.5090543628,
-0.2626408041,
-0.0030309304,
-0.4076399207,
-0.4650925398,
-0.008341806,
0.0366987847,
-0.098031953,
0.766920507,
0.1018763557,
-0.0499300621,
-0.0048199734,
-0.302239567,
-0.1366292238,
0.1874036938,
0.4736354053,
0.4058841765,
-0.1696009487,
0.0455897637,
0.0149898361,
0.0813872367,
0.233554855,
-0.0485307276,
-0.277816236,
0.2853569686,
0.2717822194,
0.6227698922,
0.5868448615,
-0.3097505271,
0.322083056,
-0.016197281,
-0.3684922755,
0.1789848953,
0.054003045,
0.2363981605,
0.2172118425,
0.3095783591,
0.3044733107,
0.1151008457,
-0.2236525267,
0.3170033395,
0.2449962497,
-0.2520691454,
-0.0895619541,
0.6934964061,
0.4184815586,
-0.2902525365,
0.7832825184,
-0.2272414416,
-0.3328533471,
0.4954927862,
0.3016584814,
0.873262465,
-0.3961342275,
0.3875654936,
0.4849736392,
0.290271461,
-0.5081028342,
-0.0375120193,
0.3005529642,
-0.8239026666,
-0.7366839647,
-0.539663136,
-0.5212260485,
-0.416721195,
-0.5981287956,
0.0622560903,
0.0925885513,
-0.397249192,
0.0857603922,
0.1065193638,
-0.4717904329,
-0.0358488634,
0.0541233383,
0.6070702076,
-1.0489099026,
0.7758789659,
0.5516400337,
-0.6695915461,
-0.5621919036,
0.1200090572,
-0.02942097,
-0.5212184787,
0.4373929501,
-0.1887847632,
0.1142280623,
0.4127580523,
-0.1501698494,
-1.006289959,
1.1459941864,
0.4302321672,
-0.4654295146,
-0.0222509224,
-0.0247288663,
0.2097988129,
-0.295093447,
0.0828551427,
0.556694746,
0.5798078775,
0.0503005534,
-1.1642510891,
-0.2312994599,
-0.0033627583,
0.0193696115,
0.4997710586,
-0.5007787943,
0.605463028,
-0.0623313449,
-0.1632542163,
0.3068163395,
0.6363533735,
0.233608827,
0.1435447186,
0.394102186,
0.6689582467,
0.770870924,
-0.2172891945,
1.1181054115,
-0.3594239056,
0.3466312289,
0.9369048476,
-0.0965492353,
1.0982660055,
0.5770220757,
-0.1972764283,
0.2935475111,
0.6375636458,
-0.0163522661,
0.4136649668,
-0.0772045553,
-0.0977611914,
-0.6405511498,
-0.1857542545,
-0.2419899404,
0.4280132055,
0.0913279653,
-0.4426292777,
-0.3187626004,
-0.121974878,
-0.2086894214,
0.4893696308,
-0.0031348248,
0.750035584,
0.3239048719,
-1.0585308075,
0.7291914225,
0.1027496606,
0.6589329839,
-0.1466094851,
0.1584450603,
-0.2759105861,
0.0173772629,
-0.2152854651,
-0.8703213334,
0.2319301963,
-0.362827152,
-0.3614711761,
-0.2803472579,
0.253174901,
-0.8435825109,
-0.6216162443,
0.2122273594,
0.94080019,
0.3054822981,
-0.1428042352,
-0.5447207093,
-0.0666272938,
-0.0355716571,
0.1698232889,
0.8529177904,
-0.0910475478,
-0.0127202803,
0.5579595566,
0.7207605839,
-0.0025356908,
0.0144329034,
-0.1974743605,
0.4914435446,
-0.5290165544,
-0.2633615434,
-0.8963314891,
0.6224609017,
-0.2201253325,
-0.2106069624,
0.8104061484,
0.4372196496,
0.8231458068,
0.0486555956,
0.7296164632,
0.2611992955,
0.2043146342,
-0.4008287489,
0.8208331466,
-0.7339823842,
-0.0067424616,
0.0016312987,
-1.2176146507,
-0.3714324534,
0.3916527033,
-0.2243054658,
-0.2026617527,
0.6538597941,
0.6125554442,
0.138130933,
-0.4583968818,
0.7677019238,
-0.1892764568,
0.3052735627,
0.8130162358,
0.5541568398,
-0.8664693236,
0.6733651757,
0.0050992519,
-0.0841781124,
-0.4283688962,
-0.5443803072,
-0.458184123,
-0.4454214275,
-0.4520926178,
-0.4969466329,
-0.0757811666,
0.9444245696,
0.7966678739,
-0.6469815373,
-0.3201021254,
0.313288331,
0.4769433737,
-0.5637059808,
-0.1115864366,
0.2395281047,
-0.5490965247,
-1.0556092262,
0.9897112846,
0.1790847331,
0.0042821602,
-0.1281067282,
-0.2444383651,
-0.2136589289,
-0.1489813477,
0.4064641595,
0.0510288849,
-0.849704802,
-0.0933738574,
0.2053459585,
-0.3572413027,
-0.0414772294,
0.4612477422,
-0.6863688827,
0.4497162104,
0.8841069937,
0.8656757474,
0.1109308749,
0.1112428606,
0.9242620468,
-0.6750728488,
-0.0859025866,
0.2332679331,
0.3167732656,
0.2563884854,
-0.0790903047,
0.4006046653,
0.1485641599,
-0.6398358345,
-0.7151607871,
0.3345748782,
-0.9530647993,
-0.3108611405,
0.8697882891,
-0.1429409385,
-0.1509707719,
0.3107213676,
0.1671218872,
0.299592495,
-0.4064442217,
0.8286209106,
0.4491542578,
0.0265699122,
-0.0729434043,
-0.4450022578,
0.1929849684,
0.8158712387,
-0.5453565717,
-0.5117573142,
0.3723342717,
0.1841043681,
0.3199486136,
0.1567196995,
-0.0325395092,
0.3475449681,
-0.0609745793,
0.1898713857,
0.0367712267,
-0.1179424226,
-0.3029583991,
0.2169121653,
0.3834696412,
-0.5027465224
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06687v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06687v2
|
Proximal Causal Inference With Text Data
| 2024-01-12T16:51:02 | 2024-05-21T21:08:54 |
Jacob M. Chen, Rohit Bhattacharya, Katherine A. Keith
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ME
|
Recent text-based causal methods attempt to mitigate confounding bias by
estimating proxies of confounding variables that are partially or imperfectly
measured from unstructured text data. These approaches, however, assume
analysts have supervised labels of the confounders given text for a subset of
instances, a constraint that is sometimes infeasible due to data privacy or
annotation costs. In this work, we address settings in which an important
confounding variable is completely unobserved. We propose a new causal
inference method that uses multiple instances of pre-treatment text data,
infers two proxies from two zero-shot models on the separate instances, and
applies these proxies in the proximal g-formula. We prove that our text-based
proxy method satisfies identification conditions required by the proximal
g-formula while other seemingly reasonable proposals do not. We evaluate our
method in synthetic and semi-synthetic settings and find that it produces
estimates with low bias. To address untestable assumptions associated with the
proximal g-formula, we further propose an odds ratio falsification heuristic.
This new combination of proximal causal inference and zero-shot classifiers
expands the set of text-specific causal methods available to practitioners.
|
[
0.0402696319,
-1.2266961336,
0.9332901239,
0.3265939355,
-0.2462353855,
-0.2932174206,
0.0886975154,
-0.34047544,
0.1815259308,
0.5332310796,
-0.5696562529,
-0.3858345151,
-0.5649944544,
0.0241181813,
-0.3591528535,
1.0964864492,
-0.0744617879,
0.0805447176,
-0.2588346601,
0.0560494028,
-0.3826780617,
-0.4230121076,
-0.408777386,
-0.468344748,
0.689561367,
0.3497079611,
0.7981936932,
0.4709092379,
0.322099179,
0.1726312637,
0.0695713982,
-0.0004978854,
-0.1340818703,
-0.019004995,
-0.2923481464,
-0.2724616528,
-0.1903654039,
0.2805742025,
0.5816674829,
0.6989059448,
0.1281064302,
0.0059485524,
-0.0186110195,
0.334508419,
-1.1163773537,
-0.0926450267,
-0.3889708519,
0.122674197,
-0.2232704461,
-0.2535100877,
-0.5809781551,
-0.4800724685,
0.2345241606,
-0.8788906336,
0.4389320016,
-0.040504504,
0.679692626,
0.2931478024,
-0.7602908611,
-0.1341851652,
-0.8528237343,
0.8312389851,
-0.6448710561,
-0.1279186904,
0.582498908,
0.1385046691,
-0.3625308573,
-0.6715302467,
-0.567561686,
-0.0173921306,
-0.346562624,
0.3102694154,
-0.3582561314,
-0.0209261701,
0.2272306979,
0.1016740426,
-0.3010644317,
0.0391194075,
-0.1520472914,
-0.4149582088,
0.6826347709,
0.0131217185,
0.0401390716,
0.1568608284,
-0.5248152018,
0.1517491341,
-0.9249537587,
-0.1408320665,
0.6140052676,
0.3192476034,
0.0580966249,
0.6683750153,
-0.0842466131,
0.5893269181,
-0.0506118499,
0.0456414856,
0.0883714035,
-0.410431236,
-0.357073009,
0.4111263454,
0.8497108817,
0.2997303307,
0.2687143385,
-0.2379000634,
0.3330301046,
0.0417384207,
0.1300729215,
-0.7383829355,
-0.0987029001,
0.3566212356,
-0.1986182183,
-0.1664866805,
-0.0229138732,
-0.949273169,
-0.5250115991,
-0.1475168765,
0.9359469414,
0.0475351587,
-0.0345065519,
0.1232012585,
-0.3597535491,
-0.1647369266,
0.0370508805,
-0.4648802876,
0.1672401577,
0.1816103309,
0.6495219469,
0.1367832422,
-0.0239936411,
-0.6168065071,
0.3936714232,
-0.3337710798,
0.9065098166,
-0.5765312314,
-0.4912551045,
0.1826786995,
0.1010212377,
-0.0628854036,
-0.0695337802,
0.9056372046,
-0.1025083438,
0.5726824403,
-0.0833317041,
-0.688010931,
-0.1343123168,
-0.2337135077,
-0.4518415332,
0.7551594377,
-0.1307319552,
-1.0692619085,
0.3491194844,
-0.3017002046,
-0.5409793854,
-0.2687430978,
-0.2017669976,
-0.8712806702,
0.1015023887,
0.0312015321,
0.2820326686,
-0.5396109819,
0.7107086182,
-0.4837529957,
-0.4385270178,
0.1132733971,
-0.6938237548,
0.6345419288,
-0.0903266668,
-0.5785062313,
0.1609587669,
-0.7088890672,
-0.0628655627,
0.1116445959,
0.2347715944,
-0.8932752013,
0.2902039886,
-0.0694080219,
-0.0851239339,
-0.0334586762,
-0.6559324265,
0.0717976466,
-0.1102932617,
-0.0358322859,
0.5110279918,
0.3675104678,
0.4146874547,
0.0953483656,
0.1673686504,
0.0493919179,
0.3454925418,
-0.0265717041,
-0.4677919149,
-0.3208165467,
-0.3262411952,
0.2172246128,
0.4523753822,
-0.7971196771,
-0.0052475049,
0.3332708478,
-0.4254032075,
-0.2888149917,
-0.373069495,
0.8622483015,
0.8847557306,
0.679915309,
0.1733769625,
-0.4293954968,
-1.0295616388,
-0.7722370028,
0.0179799274,
-0.2660073936,
0.0836921111,
0.5005090833,
0.0242972095,
1.0512962341,
-0.9625673294,
-0.5233815908,
0.2010974586,
0.7635399699,
0.2619668841,
0.664589107,
0.5893284678,
-0.8545607924,
-0.2846519947,
-0.4150779247,
-0.7241737247,
-0.4493836761,
-0.4090908468,
-0.216505751,
0.0936705023,
0.6403700113,
-0.3434091508,
0.7768867612,
0.3516882062,
-0.7004389763,
0.7150356174,
-0.5351373553,
0.0787302926,
-0.7209781408,
0.1147648618,
0.510166049,
0.0326844305,
-0.9526500702,
-0.3822275996,
0.0353494808,
0.4276051819,
-0.4855226278,
0.881077528,
-0.3568380177,
0.2829057574,
-0.3511438072,
0.0491818339,
-0.0140575143,
0.4444718361,
0.4012520313,
0.4353817403,
0.3544131815,
-0.5174670219,
-0.2667997777,
0.2284338027,
0.1167430058,
0.5991136432,
-0.8037027717,
-0.2862370312,
-0.4743169248,
0.463178128,
-0.9199348092,
-0.2794420123,
0.439722389,
-0.2909321785,
0.1282920837,
-0.1035515293,
-0.2172671854,
-0.2160427272,
-0.4763123393,
0.4242818654,
0.1639874429,
-0.239079982,
0.3717989028,
0.1222534478,
0.0839580148,
-0.7838618159,
-0.4480479062,
-0.1335756183,
-0.3535337448,
0.0259660669,
0.6662372947,
-0.065295659,
-0.281175971,
0.1270063221,
-0.4122179449,
-0.3825922012,
-0.0290630478,
0.368614465,
0.25088346,
0.0368134268,
0.0300262943,
0.4269931316,
-0.4727339149,
0.0996935144,
-0.2241724432,
-0.087658383,
0.5620192885,
-0.1977773458,
-0.4680675566,
0.6608886719,
0.1470708251,
0.1595315486,
0.8903179169,
0.4198327065,
-0.4947995245,
0.2254404873,
-0.4398162067,
-0.0836939365,
-0.3091143668,
0.0655140728,
-0.0875449926,
-0.6803250909,
0.3999127448,
0.0466855578,
-0.0434882902,
0.6196765304,
0.4714232087,
0.0641261339,
1.0969762802,
0.6534744501,
0.044460468,
0.441940397,
0.2082364112,
0.3211909831,
-0.5178166628,
-0.3347918391,
-0.9709575772,
0.1113866195,
-0.6916956306,
-0.0964813232,
0.5748915672,
0.2459454238,
-0.7850706577,
0.0890580863,
-0.166473195,
0.5701524019,
0.8025627732,
0.3767934144,
0.4553366899,
-0.1309842318,
-0.0419977754,
-0.0166134927,
-0.4203678668,
-0.30011639,
0.9727617502,
0.0529977009,
0.5422343612,
0.1213509068,
0.3287959695,
0.2984437943,
0.665999651,
-0.3807739615,
0.0976420715,
-0.1726089418,
-1.1217643023,
-0.2553885281,
-0.3818906844,
-0.8248808384,
0.3417839408,
-0.4403631985,
-1.0341303349,
0.3795137405,
0.3253403902,
-0.4269910455,
-0.0338874198,
-0.8749808669,
0.9511404634,
0.036066968,
-1.0253658295,
0.2416673452,
-0.7415809035,
0.3877425194,
-0.4724418521,
0.2799554765,
-0.0690662861,
0.1418310255,
0.7228927612,
-0.5931817889,
1.0198658705,
-0.579675734,
0.0238565374,
0.3574751616,
-0.0391287766,
0.4119452834,
0.0695650205,
0.0928422436,
0.2141987383,
-0.027722083,
-0.5218687654,
-0.4384620786,
0.3884913325,
-0.590829432,
-0.5356110334,
-0.4845739305,
-0.4086850584,
-0.3427734375,
0.4758969843,
0.4402837753,
0.3746220171,
0.041495081,
0.141450718,
0.3152255714,
-0.4174674153,
0.6122409105,
0.8598077893,
0.2770452499,
-0.482584089,
0.3925092816,
0.1296929419,
0.1636358947,
0.4046524167,
0.58612746,
-0.6617212892,
-0.3110361993,
-0.048501078,
0.2094436884,
-0.2672117651,
-0.4034457505,
-0.4689168632,
0.0438799746,
-0.1527010351,
-0.3371728063,
-0.1617762744,
-0.142375201,
-0.2093879879,
-0.0085290624,
0.2717050612,
0.1302140504,
-0.1994746923,
0.7345485091,
-0.5992621779,
0.4067700207,
0.0520685315,
0.2189914733,
-0.1275820285,
-0.3320539594,
-0.0967550427,
0.1829849482,
-0.2789365351,
-1.1759442091,
0.3482993841,
0.0635581985,
0.633949399,
0.3484991491,
0.3824774027,
0.759763062,
-0.6359561682,
0.5835224986,
0.4364193976,
-0.9674104452,
0.5801395178,
-0.5131571889,
-0.0813832283,
0.3598888516,
0.8147349954,
-0.1962901056,
-0.4799462557,
-0.629247129,
-1.0171821117,
0.6349540353,
0.4913511872,
-0.1514416337,
-0.1748126745,
0.5974704623,
0.0781285688,
0.2285417467,
-0.7875527143,
-0.450450331,
-0.0638390258,
-0.3021993637,
-0.3302457631,
-0.5272734165,
-0.2348702997,
-0.1430410743,
0.8001262546,
-0.3296830654,
0.286424011,
0.6027446985,
0.0742859393,
-0.1571487039,
0.2419551313,
0.7247352004,
0.4475589693,
-0.2744016945,
0.3185479641,
-0.1540924311,
-0.5460548997,
0.3531568348,
0.2038920522,
-0.4804548323,
0.1336053759,
0.4436542094,
0.6177849174,
0.3524943888,
-0.2344943285,
0.6225993037,
0.045285821,
-0.4533157945,
-0.3576181829,
-0.1001029089,
-0.1900298297,
0.350361824,
0.5548686981,
-0.2577883005,
0.2430721223,
-0.3642471433,
0.1353171915,
0.3284471631,
-0.5176590681,
-0.3014069796,
1.2854453325,
-0.1011613905,
-0.0585920289,
0.0957351327,
0.079785943,
-0.0400788784,
0.6676958799,
0.7744493484,
0.9230197072,
-0.2976400852,
0.6095829606,
0.3033528924,
0.0603133924,
-0.4143422842,
0.0946958736,
0.2423715442,
-0.6518650055,
-0.5594057441,
-0.4675382972,
-0.4582529962,
0.1705458313,
-0.5887411237,
0.1233969256,
0.0032634751,
-0.243412897,
0.4371909797,
0.0388663784,
-0.1895057112,
0.2610877156,
-0.2636021674,
0.7524186373,
-1.3199372292,
0.6027346849,
0.5103017688,
-0.6365127563,
-0.3612321615,
0.2183705717,
0.2968315482,
-0.3503685594,
0.3372171521,
-0.1263075918,
-0.0828570873,
-0.0174694918,
-0.6277327538,
-0.4437451661,
0.8184050322,
0.519593358,
-0.3609685302,
0.2423523664,
0.1893298626,
0.5352124572,
0.0312392395,
0.4749186933,
0.5147657394,
0.630933702,
0.2212599814,
-0.6329177618,
0.1486593038,
0.070541814,
-0.2818119228,
0.2049986571,
-0.4546252191,
0.6940022111,
-0.130019024,
0.115857318,
0.0156605449,
0.4522330761,
0.1729448289,
0.7992837429,
0.0980506167,
0.2301966846,
0.5769020915,
-0.1151842624,
0.904440701,
0.065231666,
0.5873724818,
1.1044127941,
-0.2881852388,
0.4811724722,
0.5715251565,
-0.0699156299,
0.2168266326,
0.5203956366,
0.2574372292,
0.7427253723,
0.0569512248,
-0.5104269385,
-0.2805979848,
-0.3445417881,
-0.1495055109,
0.2851590812,
0.0799868107,
-0.3075411022,
-0.4710419774,
-0.164355129,
0.7395889759,
0.0749572515,
-0.3189018369,
0.4845188558,
-0.1012804583,
-0.6482136846,
0.0171804596,
0.1098308861,
0.389937073,
-0.579662025,
0.0767261982,
-0.4916101992,
0.4766991735,
-0.2068555355,
-0.5311713219,
0.4769784212,
0.1432556212,
-0.1739246547,
-0.2236902267,
0.8666805029,
-0.430954814,
-0.5217636824,
-0.0385883786,
0.4619108737,
-0.0295221042,
-0.3965482414,
-0.1853275001,
-0.3391394019,
-0.1513467878,
-0.3079228699,
0.3022348583,
0.5159032345,
-0.5218294859,
0.0998842418,
0.539021492,
-0.0801164135,
-0.3975030184,
-0.0244820248,
0.5986869335,
-0.6913454533,
-0.2854574025,
-1.1962780952,
0.5516798496,
-0.1803030223,
-0.3523610234,
0.7982931733,
0.4603739679,
0.446701616,
-0.0052632787,
0.5770004392,
0.194719702,
0.38591519,
-0.5128030777,
0.5338637829,
-0.642247498,
-0.2038192302,
-0.7330617309,
-0.6919408441,
-0.8775689602,
0.4873261452,
-0.4418340027,
-0.1406208426,
0.8448489904,
0.38369596,
0.1688354462,
0.1614296138,
0.0556000657,
0.1595719755,
0.3216726482,
0.3397478163,
0.3747279942,
-0.4474439621,
0.2678372264,
0.0200142972,
-0.4926177263,
-0.1161733717,
-1.3574882746,
-0.6445453763,
-0.419947654,
-0.5983816981,
-0.1545958072,
0.2346065342,
0.3553791344,
0.2946297526,
-0.5701757073,
0.2288321853,
-0.2961948216,
0.4658744931,
-0.2218669355,
-0.2081702203,
0.5919601321,
-0.068631947,
-0.6342995763,
0.0009525582,
0.1509741396,
0.1343702227,
0.0271939803,
0.2466838658,
-0.3268419802,
0.3047100604,
0.5615204573,
0.3521925807,
-0.1950166672,
-0.5266091228,
-0.0550103672,
0.3061002791,
-0.3502684236,
1.0023024082,
-0.8239853382,
0.3303437531,
0.2637998164,
0.3394903541,
0.4203062952,
0.0970932245,
0.3967188299,
-1.0593345165,
0.3461465836,
-0.1970663518,
0.1811332405,
-0.2327695042,
-0.3632519841,
0.5222780704,
0.6260530949,
-0.3942678869,
-0.8798435926,
0.0191412326,
-0.5787041783,
-0.5730298758,
1.1341818571,
-0.175631389,
-0.1069411561,
-0.3293276727,
-0.0663404763,
0.4640686512,
-0.0955275819,
0.7728331089,
0.5488997102,
-0.3353198171,
0.1214203387,
-0.7142871022,
0.4722522199,
0.2403778136,
-0.8156625628,
0.0486779958,
0.8022313714,
0.0472113229,
0.078527078,
0.8338268399,
-0.1336090863,
0.0032585047,
0.1882539541,
-0.0566021279,
0.0872754827,
-0.5014528036,
0.1405908316,
0.1705851704,
-0.6065139771,
-0.2313515097
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06683v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06683v2
|
DQNC2S: DQN-based Cross-stream Crisis event Summarizer
| 2024-01-12T16:43:28 | 2024-02-02T09:54:18 |
Daniele Rege Cambrin, Luca Cagliero, Paolo Garza
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Summarizing multiple disaster-relevant data streams simultaneously is
particularly challenging as existing Retrieve&Re-ranking strategies suffer from
the inherent redundancy of multi-stream data and limited scalability in a
multi-query setting. This work proposes an online approach to crisis timeline
generation based on weak annotation with Deep Q-Networks. It selects on-the-fly
the relevant pieces of text without requiring neither human annotations nor
content re-ranking. This makes the inference time independent of the number of
input queries. The proposed approach also incorporates a redundancy filter into
the reward function to effectively handle cross-stream content overlaps. The
achieved ROUGE and BERTScore results are superior to those of best-performing
models on the CrisisFACTS 2022 benchmark.
|
[
-0.3906641006,
-0.3748026788,
0.4146127999,
0.6213106513,
-0.445446521,
0.1545240432,
0.2043023556,
-0.3471387923,
0.6697560549,
0.1113251969,
-0.9091200233,
-0.1531013101,
-0.2676087618,
0.2219907641,
-0.446349591,
1.4502036572,
0.2195244282,
-0.2932676077,
0.2368904203,
0.110293299,
-0.0775855482,
-0.2699371278,
-0.8536821008,
-0.0184837263,
0.7278085351,
0.4500850439,
0.8828579187,
0.5268080831,
0.5254844427,
0.3045205772,
0.0901282355,
0.320484072,
-1.0077396631,
0.2638189495,
-0.0234049615,
0.0343153886,
-0.646345377,
-0.332344234,
0.5148043036,
0.2064014822,
-0.040198043,
0.2107824832,
0.1115925536,
0.4649701416,
-0.8797159791,
-0.0037798809,
-0.3939889669,
0.2951993346,
0.0651913211,
-0.3057290018,
0.1004735753,
-0.4956986606,
0.1785985529,
-0.7024168372,
0.2949669659,
-0.4062340558,
0.7607241273,
0.3593858778,
-0.7702357769,
0.1063208058,
-0.9513178468,
0.5822860003,
-0.6212368011,
-0.1227190942,
0.2693412006,
0.4823459387,
0.0291898083,
-1.3965544701,
-0.3714501262,
0.6395816803,
0.0721426904,
0.6407491565,
0.1722422987,
-0.0606619604,
-0.1122385338,
0.1144881323,
-0.4584749937,
-0.0312080514,
-0.2783381939,
-0.202818498,
1.0306789875,
0.8645310998,
0.124878712,
-0.6235894561,
-0.3957642317,
-0.0049853432,
-0.5826960206,
-0.0969770476,
0.2625114024,
0.4355767071,
-0.4033452868,
0.4542506039,
-0.4500022233,
-0.1930339187,
-0.0476576723,
-0.3859971166,
-0.0601355284,
-0.9024183154,
-0.2783654332,
0.1444051415,
0.9521463513,
0.8422224522,
-0.2098124474,
-0.0067566917,
-0.0088218758,
-0.5727450848,
0.2582568824,
-1.2545400858,
-0.4802341759,
0.3871730566,
-0.4101254642,
-0.2268014848,
-0.0435246006,
-0.9309625626,
-0.583543539,
-0.095005624,
0.3539340794,
0.0650666133,
-0.2424335629,
-0.3621516526,
-0.3733777106,
-0.334982276,
0.6054461598,
-0.3048194945,
-0.2839969397,
0.3510554433,
1.0648211241,
0.2559123337,
-0.1127240658,
-0.6497454643,
0.2580674887,
-0.0249470416,
0.7649914026,
-0.0765576661,
-0.2960427999,
0.2364440858,
-0.1110631526,
0.3429026604,
-0.1129434332,
0.8356508613,
-0.495432198,
0.0376011692,
-0.4457616508,
-0.394161731,
0.0513778292,
0.0155378198,
-0.8076207638,
0.8962745667,
-0.0289355088,
-1.4078249931,
0.5247721076,
-0.0765832663,
-0.532797575,
0.0998692736,
-0.1561995596,
-0.939017117,
-0.3917258084,
0.637086153,
0.5759154558,
-0.1345924586,
0.4270025194,
-0.4794086516,
-0.5076966286,
0.0325050391,
-0.290504247,
0.7227551341,
-0.0864136443,
-0.4440180659,
0.329506278,
-0.6774030328,
0.0117527982,
0.1156676039,
-0.4821736515,
-0.078156732,
0.2887698412,
0.5019683838,
0.5863531232,
0.1296926737,
-0.10412357,
0.2177407146,
-0.1860409677,
0.3724768758,
0.3319350481,
0.6623194218,
0.1371020079,
-0.5218820572,
0.4039694965,
0.136869818,
0.3402328193,
-0.4004898965,
-0.3449959755,
-0.7113158703,
-0.4024599195,
0.0620339997,
0.9119979739,
-1.0518388748,
0.1239912733,
-0.460758388,
-0.4756782353,
-0.2016745061,
-0.1085941344,
0.2085325718,
0.2649146914,
0.5452530384,
-0.1749718338,
-1.189522624,
-0.8531778455,
0.043905925,
-0.3152568042,
-0.2851978242,
0.0755263492,
0.4113675356,
0.0453469716,
0.8441411853,
-0.3038415611,
-0.1350488812,
-0.5417141318,
0.509005785,
-0.0375249162,
0.1603810638,
0.4180622101,
-0.8916537762,
-0.0975406393,
-0.4762557745,
-0.5983196497,
0.1084346548,
-0.5902101994,
0.0072314902,
-0.0595758297,
0.3824748993,
-0.2333855182,
0.7011836767,
0.0826732218,
-0.4400438964,
0.4319373965,
0.0454680286,
0.5472652316,
-1.4250327349,
0.0147804162,
-0.2836811841,
-0.4289470613,
-0.6169089675,
-0.3704349399,
0.0275930762,
-0.1222049296,
-0.6512157917,
0.2790513337,
-0.2049270123,
-0.0694183037,
-0.127585575,
0.5801222324,
-0.0344657339,
0.2339905798,
-0.0150797367,
0.1151104197,
0.0653622448,
-0.6479068398,
0.4950166047,
0.3443684578,
-0.0526301116,
0.2951751351,
-0.5505260825,
-0.3829036951,
-0.2195450366,
0.6011686921,
-0.9983721375,
-0.3127477765,
0.1779454798,
-0.3458732367,
0.0500460006,
-0.3848058581,
-0.2298175693,
-0.3580220938,
-0.5707865357,
0.3369514346,
0.1609260887,
-0.318757385,
0.4808997214,
0.308029294,
-0.5552462339,
-0.4584748447,
-0.7941256166,
0.3486142159,
-0.5310795307,
-0.5822703838,
0.1872748882,
0.0304243639,
-0.0821827948,
-0.0375470668,
0.0069590556,
-0.3046682179,
0.1979391724,
0.7236455083,
0.2096947581,
-0.3114322424,
-0.0881491825,
0.1759934872,
0.1827859432,
-0.0378471427,
-0.041106943,
-0.0149247618,
0.234838143,
-0.0374375768,
-0.6608716249,
0.9249557257,
0.4613375962,
-0.0080633843,
0.844427824,
0.6951695085,
-0.4143527746,
-0.0562705062,
-0.1472800672,
-0.2630023658,
-0.3361096084,
0.323218435,
0.1555453241,
-0.9242137671,
0.6801277995,
-0.0837486312,
0.3533042073,
0.7196378112,
0.6738283038,
-0.0953917205,
0.8363694549,
0.3053590953,
-0.1676537991,
0.4131239057,
-0.1341682523,
0.2046698183,
-0.4488431215,
-0.1604123116,
-0.2882733047,
-0.408844918,
-0.3849633038,
-0.1901762635,
0.6286507249,
0.5065829754,
-0.4331640899,
0.0162607264,
0.031114785,
0.1159377992,
0.213197574,
-0.0129611799,
0.3770817816,
-0.1783705801,
0.1569760442,
-0.2488746196,
-0.8201020956,
-0.1518783718,
0.8317708969,
0.2467377037,
0.4018343687,
0.389385581,
0.8554050922,
0.3448650539,
0.3927238584,
-0.060534142,
0.2006391585,
0.2360840291,
-0.5894529223,
-0.8146816492,
-0.5320391059,
-0.7709726691,
0.3136216402,
-0.483612746,
-0.6792017221,
0.3223461807,
0.1246914864,
-0.9796839356,
0.2802179456,
-0.4644808769,
0.6277794242,
0.1722905487,
-0.322733134,
-0.1924112737,
-0.8559471369,
0.8218572736,
0.0265320484,
0.2681775391,
-0.1606230289,
-0.1624700427,
0.3234993219,
-0.7653354406,
1.0645796061,
0.1971514821,
0.2699105144,
0.5843163133,
0.0182889476,
0.6889910102,
0.8712192774,
0.2805488408,
-0.2560415268,
-0.1862522066,
-0.3449804187,
-0.5260798335,
0.3506036103,
-0.4744898975,
-0.1308512837,
-0.2031783611,
-0.4243893325,
0.1350748986,
-0.1109298915,
0.3393106163,
0.9130441546,
-0.3255841434,
-0.2402376533,
0.1098734885,
-0.0330157839,
1.1471056938,
0.3185686171,
-0.1449164003,
-0.9104272723,
0.8495140672,
0.131275475,
0.0703145564,
0.6031127572,
-0.0754544288,
-0.0962613299,
-0.293900907,
-0.7055322528,
0.0288807042,
-0.6388576031,
-0.5839246511,
-0.860312283,
-0.5093218684,
-0.3975423574,
-0.3103101552,
-0.5354978442,
-0.6807162762,
-0.4631612897,
-0.1682548374,
0.2672816515,
0.6256890893,
-0.4050494134,
0.0051888111,
-1.0015872717,
0.3788008392,
0.314234525,
-0.0351254009,
0.1092826873,
-0.3641406298,
-0.5947522521,
-0.1465276629,
-0.5731347203,
-0.8912849426,
0.5102127194,
0.4174895585,
0.027680343,
0.8138275146,
0.5843606591,
0.9888139963,
-0.3423729539,
1.0709089041,
0.3119546473,
-0.7836084962,
0.6993337274,
-0.4581966102,
0.3716954887,
0.3270087242,
0.6427276731,
-0.4839371741,
-0.8466911912,
-0.6864979267,
-1.3904210329,
0.562874794,
0.5514032841,
-0.2326759845,
-0.1626963466,
0.2270607501,
-0.210353598,
0.0782752633,
-0.2963198125,
-0.5977469087,
-0.7226352096,
0.1121963337,
0.0055093369,
-0.3798214793,
-0.1692566276,
-0.1093826517,
0.7105249763,
-0.2483640164,
0.0266482607,
0.6018341184,
0.1858429909,
-0.0657166243,
0.1883245111,
0.8865716457,
0.7809069157,
-0.0971887782,
0.0180961322,
0.2153517604,
-0.6275289655,
-0.0981421992,
0.4624181986,
-0.2619643807,
0.1276290268,
0.9054601789,
0.749145925,
0.6625903845,
-0.6833695769,
0.6578571796,
-0.6631698012,
-0.0899970233,
-0.3477231562,
-0.3149633408,
0.1936709285,
0.9856553674,
0.7313737869,
-0.5200639963,
0.4566646814,
-0.4538870752,
0.3894135356,
-0.2070152611,
-0.2170636207,
-0.2416633666,
0.8239411712,
0.3823764622,
0.1448117197,
0.7431291938,
-0.3996165395,
-0.4679758847,
0.6309498549,
0.3176907301,
0.8378267884,
-0.396721065,
0.5546257496,
0.6766524911,
0.2987971604,
-0.1183240488,
0.7133855224,
0.1969234943,
-0.2373272479,
-0.6429384351,
-0.2960018814,
-0.2307998538,
0.3134868443,
-0.7197098136,
0.1824745983,
-0.3168235719,
-0.4829783738,
-0.3602240384,
0.0195743572,
-0.5236763954,
0.4489477873,
0.0712155923,
0.6458812952,
-0.8484836221,
0.1876191646,
0.2704292536,
-0.5723125935,
-0.9504228234,
0.0619947165,
0.2823485434,
0.0510673411,
0.3964444995,
-0.2132805437,
0.5831338763,
-0.2646180689,
-0.0398848094,
-1.0878891945,
1.3594212532,
0.2826256752,
-0.6211227179,
-0.3479612172,
0.041257903,
0.4095588028,
-0.2597259581,
0.6634101272,
0.3608781993,
0.3682281673,
0.1351418495,
-0.9986523986,
0.0681775585,
-0.1699866205,
-0.2262875438,
0.6030192375,
-0.8103759289,
0.7896104455,
-0.590147078,
-0.6213396788,
-0.0725712478,
1.0912880898,
-0.2539943457,
0.6691426635,
0.1296241879,
0.5821051002,
0.643535316,
-0.1198030636,
1.1166367531,
0.1398611516,
0.3320913017,
1.6443172693,
0.2081287801,
0.754235208,
0.0227857009,
-0.0166027378,
0.2543617487,
0.8702543378,
0.1376008242,
0.6638277173,
-0.0889779329,
-0.1652102917,
-0.4794350863,
-0.1966106445,
-0.3390921354,
0.0589745529,
0.2362528443,
-0.3003296554,
-0.5638511181,
-0.3542186022,
-0.0210816152,
-0.4567371607,
-0.4810160697,
0.7429656982,
0.2770255506,
-0.2709030211,
0.2301763594,
0.0368539505,
0.0186582338,
-0.1676648557,
0.0400819071,
-0.5475100875,
-0.168017,
-0.2802327275,
-0.6246277094,
0.5062173009,
-0.2350401878,
-0.2287217528,
0.1353243291,
0.3445400596,
-0.5871338248,
-0.388946414,
-0.0175659955,
0.5569586158,
0.0275106542,
-0.1242661774,
-0.3612830043,
-0.0043887999,
-0.2666745186,
-0.2360812128,
0.2932004631,
0.6646687984,
-0.328654319,
0.5603054166,
0.184992075,
-0.1752054095,
0.1671487987,
0.3041884303,
0.9614040256,
-0.6762953401,
-0.9431102276,
-0.7464074492,
0.9009208679,
-0.2120260596,
-0.7006337047,
0.5598859191,
0.7608557343,
0.4893409014,
0.213190645,
0.8437675834,
0.0504081026,
0.4435193837,
-0.2354566902,
0.8284361362,
-0.5696544051,
-0.0930114985,
-0.5262793899,
-0.4006616473,
-0.111839205,
0.0355375074,
0.3478710353,
-0.1930757463,
0.6799573302,
0.2444622368,
0.2667735219,
0.1131132767,
0.078194432,
0.082812503,
0.1789844632,
0.8477008343,
0.7229962945,
-0.5291344523,
0.8713138103,
-0.2110618204,
0.0748409778,
-0.6604608297,
-1.1785255671,
-1.1739475727,
-0.957606256,
-0.42373541,
-0.3815162778,
0.0775604472,
0.5914669037,
0.6123163104,
-0.6569510698,
0.3651904166,
0.322534591,
0.2509461045,
-0.1738739461,
-0.2263042331,
0.5015118122,
0.134589538,
-0.3596352339,
0.4354989231,
0.5163927674,
0.1086263135,
-0.2135111243,
0.1071543023,
0.0134547921,
0.1394766718,
0.4552259147,
0.3792525232,
-0.4606395066,
-0.3031408489,
-0.593308866,
-0.2494603097,
-0.1903821081,
1.1181703806,
-0.797511518,
-0.0225569773,
0.5775388479,
0.8572895527,
0.51633811,
0.2770202458,
0.4639736414,
-0.7706772089,
-0.0631731823,
0.2995148301,
0.2030967772,
0.4156981409,
-0.6389877796,
0.2816914022,
0.2707697153,
-0.6542893052,
-0.7894926071,
0.1699859202,
-0.5838358402,
-0.1331486106,
0.793342948,
-0.1441089064,
0.1730262786,
-0.4779826105,
0.1485083699,
0.7078565955,
-0.5679059029,
1.029640913,
0.240316093,
-0.2702331543,
-0.2027297467,
-0.4709052742,
0.6074812412,
-0.018978605,
-0.9496181607,
-0.2067565918,
0.5551289916,
0.1385466605,
0.0732713267,
0.65136379,
0.2924365103,
0.4619460404,
0.1463532299,
-0.0084453011,
-0.0406007357,
-0.6791716218,
-0.0694134533,
0.4576816261,
-0.6636494398,
0.2098188847
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06836v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06836v2
|
Enhancing Emotional Generation Capability of Large Language Models via Emotional Chain-of-Thought
| 2024-01-12T16:42:10 | 2024-02-21T15:13:50 |
Zaijing Li, Gongwei Chen, Rui Shao, Dongmei Jiang, Liqiang Nie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable performance in various
emotion recognition tasks, thereby piquing the research community's curiosity
for exploring their potential in emotional intelligence. However, several
issues in the field of emotional generation tasks remain unresolved, including
human preference alignment and emotional generation assessment. In this paper,
we propose the Emotional Chain-of-Thought (ECoT), a plug-and-play prompting
method that enhances the performance of LLMs on various emotional generation
tasks by aligning with human emotional intelligence guidelines. To assess the
reliability of ECoT, we propose an automated model-based evaluation method
called Emotional Generation Score (EGS). EGS incorporates Goleman's Emotional
Intelligence Theory as a consensus of human experts, providing a new
perspective on the evaluation of emotional generation tasks. Extensive
experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of ECoT and EGS. Further, we
discuss the promise of LLMs in the field of emotional intelligence and present
key insights into the LLMs with the ECoT in emotional generation tasks.
|
[
-0.6717649102,
-0.8962595463,
0.6411862969,
0.0857906714,
-0.2923243642,
0.2041450143,
-0.4819993377,
-0.5116561651,
0.1949383765,
0.3156031072,
-0.8795414567,
-0.0618448369,
-0.1775141358,
0.2805471122,
-0.1198959351,
0.9903873801,
-0.1496304721,
-0.398888886,
-0.1567496359,
0.1915469021,
-0.3049824536,
-0.3950432539,
-0.7408906221,
-0.3733463287,
0.5459864736,
0.3501758873,
0.4260338247,
0.4088603258,
0.4312707782,
0.3047986031,
-0.0183626842,
0.5440443754,
-0.5118433237,
0.373737812,
-0.2284101546,
-0.2342040837,
-0.9478989244,
-0.1480603218,
0.3153014183,
0.1494681835,
-0.3918999434,
0.375849545,
0.0415879823,
0.9316436648,
-0.5078839064,
-0.0708757788,
-0.7910259366,
-0.0087439418,
0.1579346806,
-0.3762978911,
-0.6097300649,
-0.2567782402,
0.164478302,
-0.2313622981,
-0.2577041984,
0.5332482457,
0.6207959652,
0.0595303029,
-0.5335319638,
-0.3903529346,
-0.7530350089,
0.6706914306,
-0.6201330423,
0.2818787098,
0.1584841311,
0.03239711,
-0.2632329464,
-0.3543036282,
-0.7522207499,
-0.2194794267,
0.3650828302,
0.4058426619,
-0.4271455705,
0.1555564702,
0.4935406446,
0.2780808508,
-0.4929331243,
0.0724397004,
0.2007405013,
0.3189114034,
0.7140299082,
0.1591556966,
0.4161506891,
-0.1723313928,
-0.2699814737,
-0.0861425325,
-0.7377789617,
-0.0902896076,
0.6267815828,
0.1627104431,
0.0877739489,
0.4854747653,
-0.1613713503,
0.5052796602,
0.365416795,
0.3578636348,
0.2170006186,
-0.021454066,
-0.2023172975,
0.0025004018,
0.7429482937,
0.4039617777,
0.3125217557,
0.3289726973,
-0.3188105822,
-0.1195669472,
0.3998164833,
-0.6840181947,
0.0245519709,
0.2926848233,
-0.3507467806,
-0.3403165042,
0.0384039097,
-0.9312338233,
-0.1511132866,
-0.2570541799,
0.1496334374,
-0.3460027874,
-0.5178000331,
-0.1080442593,
0.2645855844,
0.0477645099,
0.1118423045,
-1.0498027802,
0.2089023441,
0.7140781283,
0.5099196434,
0.2190908194,
-0.1644092351,
-0.4165303111,
0.0508966818,
-0.3406201303,
0.7778567076,
-0.5691038966,
-0.0316633098,
0.2425328344,
-0.1633437872,
0.1098069996,
-0.3451264799,
0.4451715946,
-0.4230404794,
0.0785026178,
-0.3585118651,
-0.7404286861,
-0.2240815759,
0.3361056149,
-0.5131946802,
1.1380153894,
-0.0276884343,
-0.5673116446,
0.3086797893,
-0.6185774803,
-0.3091067076,
0.3147831261,
0.0069358349,
-0.2651025653,
0.3751669824,
0.3097105324,
0.4800269902,
-0.3937031627,
0.2484510243,
-0.3576778173,
0.0055942317,
0.3838728964,
-0.3889398873,
0.3617932796,
0.1320183724,
-0.6093651056,
0.0121844988,
-0.7246798873,
0.4652940631,
0.1441132277,
-0.2092553377,
-0.1949906498,
0.2057302296,
-0.1872177273,
0.5663309693,
0.158562243,
-0.3551091254,
0.1763752401,
-0.2482898086,
0.4446099699,
1.0350056887,
0.0976585373,
0.0559159666,
-0.340093255,
0.6769265532,
-0.2760525048,
-0.1237116605,
-0.2651768923,
-0.442584753,
-1.0025906563,
0.0188229512,
-0.1005946174,
0.460480541,
-0.5429273844,
1.0355159044,
-0.0916728899,
-0.5578464866,
-0.5195655227,
0.2392149866,
0.2743211091,
0.3222770393,
0.1820891947,
-0.007058444,
-0.6367444396,
-0.6377618313,
-0.3762257397,
-0.5215597749,
-0.0027108665,
0.4755918384,
0.5800007582,
-0.1069355905,
0.7097334862,
-0.3757663071,
0.5072928667,
-0.3483479619,
0.4226437211,
-0.0105195818,
0.2298388034,
0.0125199305,
-0.3958203197,
-0.3650791645,
0.116941072,
-0.4917626679,
-0.2777826488,
-0.0476210378,
-0.5141203403,
0.1418058723,
0.2606146634,
-0.5392238498,
0.0347389355,
0.5092712641,
-0.309997797,
0.5475447178,
-0.1999289542,
0.3316960931,
-0.942507863,
0.0146430722,
0.0860747769,
-0.1952492148,
-0.6266934276,
-0.0677218512,
0.0840528235,
0.085719645,
-0.466214478,
0.2833757401,
-0.4407210946,
-0.071711652,
-0.2395915538,
0.3128834665,
-0.043413002,
0.3865781128,
-0.0489302054,
0.3188739419,
0.419934243,
-0.5261104703,
0.6090203524,
0.0966935232,
-0.3298146129,
0.8699721098,
-0.2454794049,
0.7786664963,
-0.0292454921,
0.3776352704,
-0.826675117,
-0.2892127931,
-0.1120886728,
0.05465132,
0.209402144,
0.3201848567,
-0.6516489983,
-0.7691985369,
-0.169736743,
0.1792627573,
0.9345104694,
-0.6994224191,
0.5606998801,
0.125461027,
-0.4033550024,
-0.0214587897,
-0.2952026129,
0.0154428259,
-0.4049012661,
-0.7299437523,
0.1262125969,
-0.2938295603,
-0.2747531831,
-0.2864741385,
0.052910734,
0.4089604914,
0.0294151343,
-0.0011771114,
0.4864774942,
-0.0371285751,
0.3490081728,
0.1202484667,
0.1185277775,
0.3059544861,
-0.3009200692,
0.5217537284,
-0.3838056624,
-0.3614793122,
-0.0418331735,
0.2550576627,
0.4993559718,
-0.3588537872,
0.2659436762,
0.4737432301,
-0.4379130006,
-0.6438368559,
-0.7295499444,
0.0204759892,
-0.4937798381,
0.5965349078,
-0.1339724362,
-0.841982305,
0.3036275208,
-0.46329844,
0.0099530173,
0.3369781077,
0.8353239894,
-0.323546648,
1.4797679186,
0.4497999847,
0.1027829871,
0.4967191517,
-0.0146688903,
0.5741413236,
-1.2173292637,
-0.0934779122,
-0.1347346902,
-0.4178527892,
-0.4401632845,
-0.0529105216,
0.1164888069,
0.0738438815,
-0.4514665604,
-0.0933887213,
-0.4886006713,
0.4319887459,
0.0767451599,
0.2148598731,
0.0621911511,
0.0195775833,
-0.0472345911,
0.189476952,
-0.5695617795,
-0.730188489,
0.7624149323,
0.319580704,
0.527351737,
0.0242356956,
0.6917791367,
0.189460665,
0.3963975906,
-0.6767408252,
0.836673677,
0.1407618225,
-0.3297263086,
-0.2400060296,
-0.3476655483,
-0.6316577196,
-0.0105584562,
-0.1155162156,
-1.1375231743,
-0.130484432,
0.1612630039,
-0.4566972852,
0.3288899958,
-0.3711306453,
0.4100215137,
-0.6665401459,
-0.4051840901,
-0.3223555982,
-0.2616520822,
0.4379545152,
-0.2123156637,
0.156795457,
-0.0624618195,
0.0350342989,
0.9195251465,
-0.5429442525,
0.4395493269,
0.2163790017,
-0.3477932513,
0.634483695,
0.0788563639,
1.0232278109,
-0.4511829615,
-0.138497144,
-0.2163689733,
-0.7382482886,
0.0658470541,
-0.6986736655,
0.7622028589,
-0.4400917888,
-0.6304910779,
-0.1242303625,
-0.7072392106,
-0.4691891968,
0.0504741482,
0.2203301191,
-0.0306482855,
-0.2936578393,
-0.1312908083,
0.5520757437,
-0.2966626585,
0.4957503378,
0.2734804451,
-0.4104393423,
-0.414737463,
0.9711920619,
0.0515595563,
0.5047582388,
-0.028835386,
0.2196272314,
-0.3364676237,
0.0705458,
-0.4021482766,
0.0160887465,
-0.612742424,
-0.1223891899,
-0.6222397089,
-0.0452561826,
-0.0922286585,
-0.3568832576,
-0.214168027,
0.0193763804,
-0.0665992796,
-0.6243427396,
0.6172389388,
0.9657381177,
0.0798829868,
-0.145567432,
-0.6593163013,
-0.1448824704,
0.5505609512,
0.2377764881,
0.4931912124,
-0.3514770567,
-0.347781539,
0.0494666919,
-0.4753423929,
-0.8291730881,
0.3839387596,
0.078719236,
0.2161216289,
0.6487326622,
-0.161762625,
0.7066839933,
-0.5582030416,
0.7648319006,
0.4075742066,
-1.2147387266,
0.6588696837,
-0.5299890041,
0.1949197352,
0.1906321198,
0.1593620926,
-0.4723594189,
-0.4923422933,
-0.886975944,
-1.0567650795,
0.5019765496,
0.2849681377,
0.0661838353,
-0.4413073063,
0.0825579241,
-0.0370968655,
0.318649441,
-0.4957922101,
-0.0430282727,
0.0701584071,
-0.239722982,
0.1995546967,
-0.2140705287,
0.2082656324,
-0.1230734959,
0.7986540198,
-0.0108276969,
0.2440392971,
0.0285942778,
0.0355818756,
-0.7847049236,
0.5982394218,
0.3964180946,
0.3640010357,
-0.20688878,
0.2015526444,
0.3719870746,
-0.1996480823,
0.5021647215,
-0.3361918926,
-0.0427835025,
-0.3777044117,
0.0745032579,
0.9008054733,
0.0909586325,
-0.7169861197,
0.1775866747,
0.2116170526,
-0.101490356,
-0.1464635134,
0.0308911595,
0.2730201483,
0.2607517242,
0.1986436844,
-0.0818968415,
-0.0242323186,
-0.6572058201,
0.1471102685,
0.2887022793,
-0.4241745472,
-0.4275309741,
0.3153594434,
0.4263850152,
-0.5343030691,
0.7908402085,
-0.5189705491,
-0.8059430122,
0.7189733982,
0.9376219511,
1.2374106646,
-0.4486869574,
0.2099068761,
0.2775228918,
0.3300077319,
-0.3399614394,
0.6525225639,
0.2379290015,
-0.6484333873,
-0.504581809,
-0.462112695,
-0.4610692561,
0.1072900891,
-0.6856889725,
0.2572513521,
-0.3747376204,
-0.3605209589,
-0.5636255741,
-0.1884732693,
-0.8929475546,
0.2418961525,
0.6795496345,
0.6006854177,
-0.810087204,
0.3320825398,
0.7586962581,
-0.2205291092,
-1.2324101925,
-0.0987848788,
0.0170772579,
-0.454716146,
0.8135350347,
0.2571761906,
-0.1413079798,
0.373141259,
-0.3606981039,
-0.7050777078,
1.0783575773,
0.2066156715,
-1.0145055056,
0.0974825546,
-0.1240223199,
0.6024285555,
-0.831083715,
0.7925147414,
0.546500504,
0.5589578748,
-0.0983446091,
-0.6169301271,
0.3657140136,
-0.5272863507,
-0.0103116175,
0.3725015819,
-0.8326443434,
0.7159144878,
-0.3118623495,
-0.1188715696,
-0.053587608,
0.6661428809,
0.5647788644,
0.0369770378,
0.7419822216,
0.6655801535,
1.146073103,
0.1052818373,
1.0349224806,
-0.4622241557,
0.4836434424,
0.8190800548,
-0.8062703609,
1.0201981068,
0.3624934256,
-0.2555471659,
0.7557153702,
0.5741313696,
-0.1727544814,
0.1683454067,
0.6642208695,
-0.323112011,
-0.4590706825,
-0.2469071448,
-0.1759459227,
0.1923704594,
0.2048168927,
-0.3897442222,
0.164934665,
-0.0099884709,
0.136165455,
-0.3554231226,
-0.46100384,
0.6276088357,
0.2094729543,
-0.8123173118,
0.2504336238,
-0.449565053,
0.4521575868,
-0.3283193707,
-0.199658528,
0.0910087451,
-0.0244248044,
-0.2899620235,
-0.5207072496,
-0.3023795784,
0.5456961989,
0.0408359282,
-0.1791760623,
0.8124124408,
-0.4650758803,
-0.6409766674,
0.4038438499,
0.618784368,
0.0288960375,
0.0253777038,
-0.5426726341,
-0.0203143097,
0.0175320897,
-0.7129582763,
0.2829549611,
0.7585490942,
0.3127677441,
0.6137700677,
0.7117316723,
0.1433418393,
-0.1073187962,
0.1295356303,
0.6393299103,
-0.7241127491,
-0.572625339,
-1.1470968723,
0.6692596078,
-0.1437419653,
-0.3421803713,
0.6749376059,
0.1257760674,
0.589410007,
0.0995645151,
0.9760508537,
-0.0405404978,
0.0337192863,
-0.5404213667,
0.6161698699,
-0.3273169696,
0.2169597447,
-0.7411344647,
-1.2256959677,
0.1717216372,
0.579819262,
-0.4309449792,
0.3992238641,
1.0982606411,
0.535389781,
0.2178251296,
0.3692711592,
0.3503247797,
0.3614651859,
0.3396416903,
0.7658905387,
1.2480427027,
-0.0536748432,
0.2599511147,
-0.0404225923,
-0.4786971509,
-0.1760906428,
-1.2171256542,
-0.8304107189,
-0.2962164581,
-0.4181976914,
-0.3034957647,
-0.0104293004,
1.4380881786,
0.3857964575,
-0.3712764978,
-0.2195776403,
-0.3931902051,
-0.2312911749,
-0.3758434057,
-0.1761268973,
0.2431491613,
-0.2530176044,
-0.5480284095,
0.3053862453,
0.5524923205,
-0.1571165621,
-0.3249221444,
-0.2214832604,
-0.1862114072,
0.4610669017,
0.6826752424,
-0.0256139487,
-0.6496709585,
-0.5025693774,
0.0797109753,
0.1021896973,
-0.1074350849,
0.7935600281,
-0.4909317791,
0.466763407,
0.492341429,
0.3720358014,
-0.0082158102,
0.0698667169,
0.7584738731,
-0.345138222,
-0.4162229896,
0.204040125,
0.6698030233,
0.2163718492,
-0.5253669024,
0.3614404202,
-0.1678173542,
-0.8786298633,
-0.7793295383,
0.5137199759,
-0.8439899683,
0.3425267637,
1.1815882921,
-0.3302851319,
-0.2897494733,
0.1910645068,
-0.1477266848,
0.4056119323,
-0.6360624433,
0.8289938569,
0.8969654441,
-0.3099735975,
-0.1713428646,
-0.4180119634,
0.1561600119,
0.654196918,
-1.1620900631,
0.3790087998,
0.320623368,
-0.3109053671,
0.1133278385,
0.4341096282,
0.2084133774,
0.1073903516,
-0.2256649882,
0.4153622389,
0.0343188718,
-0.1094980091,
-0.2269914299,
-0.0976372957,
0.0525943637,
0.4212366939
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06373v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06373v2
|
How Johnny Can Persuade LLMs to Jailbreak Them: Rethinking Persuasion to Challenge AI Safety by Humanizing LLMs
| 2024-01-12T16:13:24 | 2024-01-23T22:46:12 |
Yi Zeng, Hongpeng Lin, Jingwen Zhang, Diyi Yang, Ruoxi Jia, Weiyan Shi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Most traditional AI safety research has approached AI models as machines and
centered on algorithm-focused attacks developed by security experts. As large
language models (LLMs) become increasingly common and competent, non-expert
users can also impose risks during daily interactions. This paper introduces a
new perspective to jailbreak LLMs as human-like communicators, to explore this
overlooked intersection between everyday language interaction and AI safety.
Specifically, we study how to persuade LLMs to jailbreak them. First, we
propose a persuasion taxonomy derived from decades of social science research.
Then, we apply the taxonomy to automatically generate interpretable persuasive
adversarial prompts (PAP) to jailbreak LLMs. Results show that persuasion
significantly increases the jailbreak performance across all risk categories:
PAP consistently achieves an attack success rate of over $92\%$ on Llama 2-7b
Chat, GPT-3.5, and GPT-4 in $10$ trials, surpassing recent algorithm-focused
attacks. On the defense side, we explore various mechanisms against PAP and,
found a significant gap in existing defenses, and advocate for more fundamental
mitigation for highly interactive LLMs
|
[
-0.4893104732,
-1.0054255724,
0.6494449973,
0.1112024263,
-0.1129304245,
0.1222327054,
-0.3425973356,
-0.3474718332,
0.4443452358,
0.763758719,
-0.40931499,
-0.478828609,
-0.7239155173,
0.0270105675,
-0.2566358149,
0.9603438973,
0.1856361926,
-0.2646290958,
-0.1468844712,
0.266405195,
-0.6106189489,
-0.7166995406,
-0.6042028069,
-0.03369141,
0.6053956151,
0.5102889538,
0.8275279403,
0.5135635734,
0.1739109904,
0.3523254693,
-0.1858585477,
0.0391824469,
-0.3416187763,
0.2868223488,
-0.0562694892,
-0.8595355153,
-0.1988521665,
0.2661195397,
-0.1415719986,
0.2811552286,
-0.10340745,
-0.4300016463,
0.0888439864,
0.7961005569,
-0.6530054808,
-0.145306766,
-1.0184156895,
-0.2538882494,
-0.3220865428,
-0.020686008,
-0.6462020278,
-0.2939473093,
-0.2391126305,
-0.5136880875,
-0.0518620238,
0.012764113,
0.6052662134,
0.3018704653,
-0.4614881277,
-0.4654778242,
-0.4649882913,
0.4592145085,
-0.4746847153,
-0.0217225198,
0.5628135204,
0.1777019054,
-0.5298479795,
-0.3097512424,
-0.5636792779,
-0.9578472972,
0.1898893267,
-0.2435105443,
-0.2872316241,
0.2106191218,
0.1914444566,
-0.3322157562,
-0.2611534894,
0.177577585,
-0.3072661161,
-0.0358924121,
0.8769389987,
0.1046104953,
0.5159468055,
-0.2367642671,
-0.4827200472,
-0.1538109332,
-1.1613152027,
0.0584004521,
0.6656166315,
0.126991868,
-0.1731692255,
0.455861181,
0.202553004,
0.680888772,
0.1135031208,
0.0476812758,
-0.2574145198,
0.1463005841,
-0.0837584212,
0.1194424778,
1.04142344,
0.3903466165,
0.567086339,
-0.1244172826,
0.0906699747,
-0.0242487062,
0.628267765,
-0.3459278047,
-0.4851143062,
0.1604802161,
-0.3086591959,
-0.7082133889,
0.1950130165,
-0.806207478,
-1.2818257809,
0.2638917565,
0.3425146639,
-0.403241545,
-0.1854260415,
0.125260815,
-0.1773281246,
0.1544941515,
0.2409463078,
-1.1399110556,
0.0704721287,
0.8937556744,
0.609295547,
0.2300099283,
-0.3277906179,
-0.4375633299,
0.4792896509,
-0.4187963307,
0.7636305094,
-0.3056204915,
-0.7290665507,
-0.1095522344,
-0.1761117727,
-0.1735053062,
-0.5113506317,
0.6459802985,
-0.3247210979,
-0.1758229136,
-0.1288165599,
-0.3528957069,
0.150614053,
0.5300760865,
-0.4868079424,
0.2352409065,
-0.6042519808,
-0.6551405191,
0.2294315994,
-0.6423883438,
-0.6320283413,
-0.0614894144,
-0.1868510246,
-0.1140186861,
0.095021829,
0.4894427359,
0.4588127732,
-0.1816193163,
0.397631377,
-0.5455849171,
-0.1286747456,
0.6380286217,
-0.6747763157,
0.8337106109,
0.3201307058,
-0.3535954058,
0.220289126,
-0.3199152946,
-0.3777899742,
0.3608570695,
-0.2123207897,
-0.6528369784,
0.3139608502,
-0.572627306,
-0.0356166363,
0.2989161611,
-0.5202134252,
0.3817707896,
-0.5650131106,
0.8056139946,
0.795470953,
0.0524967164,
0.3284120262,
-0.2873769701,
0.4652733803,
-0.401876837,
0.3931266963,
-0.098180227,
-0.5596657991,
-0.5949400663,
-0.228754282,
-0.100837782,
0.7141826749,
-0.5467238426,
0.3229617774,
-0.0774426311,
-0.6147092581,
-0.6322684288,
0.3622863293,
0.476858288,
0.2810111344,
0.2080316097,
-0.0251772143,
-0.5201530457,
-0.7879810333,
-0.7145511508,
-0.7036959529,
-0.1742678285,
0.3409494162,
0.096198082,
-0.0760339499,
0.6719815135,
-0.4137836099,
0.0341035277,
-0.6345635056,
-0.0416665412,
0.1928462833,
0.3101657629,
0.450709492,
-0.6613315344,
-0.3468252122,
-0.4926148653,
-0.7965986729,
-0.1665461957,
-0.2906286716,
0.2553789616,
0.0668809935,
0.8338282108,
-0.9116686583,
0.51118505,
0.2011076361,
-0.5376893878,
0.5639849901,
-0.04713016,
0.1480325758,
-0.8772904277,
-0.4748596251,
-0.0196692739,
-0.0009249391,
-0.7562083006,
0.2770700455,
-0.1548819393,
-0.2371276617,
-0.7060881257,
0.4657490849,
-0.3382033706,
0.41268453,
-0.3573356867,
0.2908034027,
-0.1257617474,
-0.0107868025,
-0.290266633,
0.768701911,
0.5061026216,
-0.4224053621,
0.4470379651,
0.3664031923,
-0.2162829041,
0.4880619049,
-0.9945842624,
0.2580657303,
0.0114694675,
0.2928781509,
-1.1287887096,
-0.2758730352,
0.335704118,
-0.5048283935,
0.2167669535,
-0.4757593274,
-0.2247781903,
-0.2952956557,
-0.4877253771,
-0.297154516,
0.4349540472,
-0.5673199892,
0.3921430111,
0.5928777456,
-0.261085242,
-0.4691657126,
-0.5820165873,
0.8970016837,
-0.6757804751,
-0.9372400045,
0.1690431237,
0.0585734025,
-0.7851889729,
-0.3938926458,
0.1818726063,
0.3356635869,
0.7438998222,
0.653930068,
0.3387564123,
0.2809527218,
-0.100365296,
-0.1743786335,
-0.2131646872,
0.5076906085,
-0.08559037,
0.6059246659,
-0.2020944059,
-0.4415020347,
-0.4200335741,
0.3111599088,
0.5309032798,
0.1712584347,
0.9744464159,
0.1043127999,
0.1802829355,
0.1569618136,
-0.5725952387,
-0.2824939191,
-0.5688542128,
0.0401119664,
-0.3963407874,
-0.7840185761,
0.0389566757,
-0.1938969642,
0.0703883246,
0.1695684791,
0.6359462142,
-0.3985503912,
0.9434995651,
0.3685097098,
-0.4784487188,
0.4859320819,
0.1166178137,
0.1674001366,
-0.5045183301,
-0.2854138613,
-0.5204658508,
-0.1232455224,
-0.6412129402,
-0.0349395275,
0.3345070183,
0.3112650514,
-0.3897699714,
0.4145916402,
-0.4252019823,
0.6072871685,
0.5631443262,
0.1113837361,
0.1214323714,
-0.1335347742,
0.01846461,
0.1077929661,
-0.3954856098,
-0.8531578779,
1.1544693708,
0.5705084801,
0.9866078496,
0.3498289883,
1.0143358707,
0.5083084702,
0.270738095,
-0.589856267,
0.9586581588,
-0.0375559404,
-0.5952804685,
-0.1283326298,
-0.0021214846,
-1.20834589,
-0.0192999728,
-0.3313384652,
-0.9622446895,
-0.0387040004,
0.2526860237,
-0.0275717452,
0.3122886121,
-0.8518869877,
0.6842215061,
-0.41387707,
-0.3109205961,
-0.4142452776,
-0.8552159071,
0.4783774912,
0.3747720718,
0.4594517946,
-0.2740230262,
-0.0832467303,
0.7092168927,
-0.6027308702,
1.2950547934,
-0.3605655134,
-0.1199021488,
0.2972309589,
0.2111607641,
0.8218804598,
0.2175686359,
-0.0783615336,
0.0100747999,
-0.3232192397,
-0.3238124549,
-0.5829983354,
0.7839542031,
-0.8685253859,
-1.3519053459,
-0.0952229425,
-0.3002645671,
-0.2236338556,
-0.2723176479,
0.2096895874,
-0.0692095086,
-0.1811207831,
-0.0385660678,
0.6636453271,
-0.2506654561,
0.3556646705,
0.2604186535,
0.1055435762,
-0.5143539906,
0.9109473825,
-0.4044886529,
0.2363692075,
0.2323378175,
0.2691238821,
-0.2752613723,
-0.6311987042,
-0.5171326399,
0.0951525792,
-0.6269860268,
0.0374931917,
-0.5885894895,
0.0291121509,
-0.4851536453,
-0.5676632524,
-0.1945331544,
-0.4861931205,
-0.2409781218,
-0.1726532876,
0.528170228,
0.83323282,
-0.0720430836,
0.3364548981,
-0.7579210997,
0.2886961699,
0.5008187294,
-0.1903344542,
-0.0986339301,
-0.3709081709,
0.1009261981,
-0.1955496669,
-0.5108650327,
-1.3662039042,
0.3775723577,
-0.1400898248,
0.632625103,
0.4360927343,
0.4202945232,
0.3981153071,
-0.2895597219,
0.9081149697,
0.3760539591,
-0.8537473083,
0.8385316133,
-0.3772997558,
-0.3839967549,
0.6614300609,
0.2615429461,
-0.4941545129,
-0.5532367826,
-0.6579599977,
-1.1280725002,
0.1683469415,
-0.1561746001,
0.3904670179,
-0.1612193882,
0.3087316155,
-0.1184430271,
0.1325119287,
-0.7617195845,
-0.3100615442,
-0.2555981576,
-0.1532920748,
-0.0681496188,
-0.3573754132,
-0.5981332064,
0.0246596932,
0.4617311358,
0.2363218218,
0.115964137,
-0.0320455357,
-0.0786313936,
0.442168951,
0.7724491954,
0.4581060112,
0.1134734154,
0.0121745011,
0.2644121051,
0.0498216152,
-0.490405947,
0.5776972175,
0.1367868632,
-0.1229994446,
-0.6087115407,
0.5868662596,
0.8301534057,
-0.145209223,
-0.7192651033,
0.5460512042,
-0.2026998401,
-0.2641789317,
-0.3231153786,
0.6275447011,
0.1415029317,
0.2182652652,
0.3099705577,
-0.1327874213,
-0.1909318417,
-0.5153630376,
0.1088646352,
0.6398599148,
-0.2928708494,
-0.0878928676,
0.8833498359,
0.6702164412,
-0.65739429,
0.5232854486,
-0.0599184968,
-0.4161095023,
0.6155388951,
0.5516373515,
1.0076247454,
0.0376083516,
0.0992816538,
-0.1099468172,
0.5637289286,
0.1400634497,
0.0537466183,
-0.0668695793,
-0.65804708,
-0.3088818789,
-0.0382509157,
-0.6425851583,
0.2046025693,
-0.3917668462,
0.1081859693,
-0.7408579588,
-0.0664792508,
-0.0255710948,
-0.1043465808,
-0.1049634367,
-0.1212092638,
0.2414163649,
1.0401556492,
-0.8179974556,
0.698528409,
0.8148499727,
-0.0676702112,
-0.7124661803,
0.3152792156,
0.3250528276,
-0.7992776632,
0.4800938368,
0.2683621347,
-0.0394051224,
-0.2159022391,
-0.9614158273,
-0.2898249626,
0.6834247708,
0.5446119905,
-0.6136402488,
0.1663886309,
-0.0765443966,
0.22923401,
-0.3050824106,
0.1730225235,
0.7328961492,
0.5873539448,
-0.1103048399,
-0.5553175211,
0.1613531709,
-0.3363822103,
-0.3060817122,
0.2883577645,
-0.5146213174,
0.3936697543,
-0.7505497932,
0.1474478245,
0.0557876453,
0.6122305393,
0.6948564053,
0.459472388,
0.7673609257,
0.2748488188,
0.6235684156,
0.027113324,
1.1528413296,
-0.361418277,
-0.3254762888,
0.7724716663,
-0.3144944906,
0.7169380188,
0.6149539351,
-0.1869034171,
0.584928751,
0.3463088274,
-0.0113233477,
0.4843574762,
0.4670540988,
-0.5032529235,
-0.4228617549,
-0.0541926138,
-0.1610486805,
0.4409250319,
0.5689869523,
-0.0679038614,
0.1227727532,
0.2732551694,
0.5496342778,
0.4310445487,
-0.2328350544,
0.8400207162,
0.0863100141,
-0.6761585474,
0.637825191,
0.1496492177,
0.7192730904,
-0.5728918314,
0.2853994966,
-0.0623706318,
0.0504154563,
0.0042106523,
-0.8976593614,
0.1901185662,
0.2288325578,
0.135740608,
-0.106508404,
0.9195867777,
0.0280175414,
-0.0047406708,
0.2296461612,
0.2069105059,
0.3060986698,
-0.0381280743,
-0.8356106877,
0.1753213704,
0.1158575863,
-0.2740726173,
0.6107046604,
0.0177813247,
-0.0440824293,
1.113719821,
0.77891922,
0.1709752977,
-0.1952925771,
-0.0100864731,
1.0186104774,
-0.8314061165,
-0.4864687324,
-1.3401068449,
0.3311066329,
-0.2044460475,
-0.051155325,
0.8852217197,
0.0235155132,
0.4694228768,
0.0683834925,
1.0229063034,
-0.2327077538,
0.1899418384,
-0.628349483,
0.7770610452,
-0.2492561638,
0.8140392303,
-0.2492505908,
-0.2291305214,
-0.0637269616,
0.407087028,
-0.6789437532,
-0.181557402,
0.1232552454,
0.7672961354,
0.5318018198,
0.0396986082,
0.3108811975,
0.377086997,
0.8114157319,
0.7705966234,
1.2386512756,
0.0460173711,
0.8427435756,
0.0385278128,
-0.2391769439,
-0.2085372955,
-0.983456552,
-1.1106445789,
-0.27039662,
-0.093347989,
-0.6185570359,
0.5194475055,
1.0282257795,
0.4683884978,
-0.5069935322,
-0.0903808177,
-0.2719890475,
0.3921374977,
0.0114083216,
-0.2277631909,
0.1527033299,
-0.1601593792,
-0.4307412803,
0.9502909184,
0.2281704247,
0.0306461584,
-0.3553802073,
-0.1537993848,
0.0722060576,
0.205792442,
0.2759509087,
0.5747611523,
-0.7576578856,
-0.1054712459,
-0.3363671899,
-0.2297992557,
-0.1360057294,
0.7726199031,
-0.9062978029,
0.1999628991,
0.218172431,
0.5255057216,
0.1730901897,
0.0627702102,
0.6138007045,
-0.5301687717,
0.3000719547,
0.0611466169,
0.2664988339,
0.3244770169,
-0.5651342869,
0.3474566936,
0.3105475605,
-0.5803533196,
-0.6389018297,
0.4971039891,
-0.5911615491,
-0.4972110987,
1.1763751507,
-0.2489163727,
-0.306471765,
-0.5424842834,
-0.3571841121,
-0.2167547941,
-0.6366767287,
1.07026124,
0.4540719986,
-0.1138856411,
-0.114600867,
-0.4531543851,
0.5294480324,
0.2688500285,
-0.8513093591,
0.3833968937,
0.1717117876,
0.3442061245,
0.0999754891,
0.5682681799,
0.0669588894,
0.1962278932,
0.0319229104,
0.0008212831,
-0.6139535308,
-0.4028911889,
-0.2385424823,
0.3610897362,
0.3930504918,
-0.0976860076
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06665v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06665v1
|
PolyTOPS: Reconfigurable and Flexible Polyhedral Scheduler
| 2024-01-12T16:11:27 | 2024-01-12T16:11:27 |
Gianpietro Consolaro, Zhen Zhang, Harenome Razanajato, Nelson Lossing, Nassim Tchoulak, Adilla Susungi, Artur Cesar Araujo Alves, Renwei Zhang, Denis Barthou, Corinne Ancourt, Cedric Bastoul
|
cs.DC
|
cs.DC, cs.CL, cs.PF
|
Polyhedral techniques have been widely used for automatic code optimization
in low-level compilers and higher-level processes. Loop optimization is central
to this technique, and several polyhedral schedulers like Feautrier, Pluto, isl
and Tensor Scheduler have been proposed, each of them targeting a different
architecture, parallelism model, or application scenario. The need for
scenario-specific optimization is growing due to the heterogeneity of
architectures. One of the most critical cases is represented by NPUs (Neural
Processing Units) used for AI, which may require loop optimization with
different objectives. Another factor to be considered is the framework or
compiler in which polyhedral optimization takes place. Different scenarios,
depending on the target architecture, compilation environment, and application
domain, may require different kinds of optimization to best exploit the
architecture feature set.
We introduce a new configurable polyhedral scheduler, PolyTOPS, that can be
adjusted to various scenarios with straightforward, high-level configurations.
This scheduler allows the creation of diverse scheduling strategies that can be
both scenario-specific (like state-of-the-art schedulers) and kernel-specific,
breaking the concept of a one-size-fits-all scheduler approach. PolyTOPS has
been used with isl and CLooG as code generators and has been integrated in
MindSpore AKG deep learning compiler. Experimental results in different
scenarios show good performance: a geomean speedup of 7.66x on MindSpore (for
the NPU Ascend architecture) hybrid custom operators over isl scheduling, a
geomean speedup up to 1.80x on PolyBench on different multicore architectures
over Pluto scheduling. Finally, some comparisons with different
state-of-the-art tools are presented in the PolyMage scenario.
|
[
-0.6877836585,
-0.5114710927,
0.4956338704,
0.4836506248,
-0.3042509556,
0.2300460041,
-0.2505593598,
-0.1860264838,
0.2499891967,
0.0760328919,
-0.5968469977,
0.1322850585,
-0.4712260962,
0.08507175,
-0.1599137336,
0.7722316384,
-0.0325727314,
-0.2184249908,
-0.7447109818,
0.0136993434,
-0.1672097892,
-0.653611958,
-0.6078906059,
-0.7162465453,
0.1352938116,
0.2540121973,
0.8933491111,
0.6702124476,
0.3797498345,
0.3990072012,
-0.2676143944,
0.1126580909,
-0.3674436808,
-0.0123313628,
-0.2506221533,
-0.1098117307,
-0.4541618526,
-0.4498802423,
0.6052348018,
0.6267870665,
-0.6438934803,
0.2510588467,
0.0754545107,
0.7144655585,
-0.8502178192,
0.0898824185,
-0.5127204657,
0.5178261399,
-0.3174913824,
-0.0512698255,
-0.0941155553,
-0.8260726929,
0.0327520333,
-0.8026179075,
-0.2906090617,
-0.1204588786,
0.5381844044,
0.6989265084,
0.0350296311,
0.10915903,
-0.9011670351,
0.9936876297,
-0.5249610543,
0.225491941,
-0.3030493855,
0.6868614554,
-0.1019111499,
-0.9624809027,
-0.3221940398,
0.1914551705,
-0.0299303588,
0.1409017742,
-0.0980432555,
0.0551720373,
0.5509662032,
0.6781156659,
-0.5157141089,
0.0009260856,
-0.2321415991,
0.036174193,
0.3492301106,
0.525808692,
0.268332392,
0.101743415,
-0.4501534402,
0.2842494547,
-0.5451975465,
0.1077875048,
0.363820523,
-0.1385057569,
-0.3433589637,
0.2646239102,
-0.4043940008,
0.8991367817,
0.0758780316,
-0.2626173496,
0.1668160707,
0.0984059051,
-0.3052054346,
-0.0499703176,
0.3308539987,
0.0535403825,
0.5155640244,
-0.1383880675,
-0.1341133118,
0.3478522599,
0.7718917131,
-0.7582786083,
-0.4106455147,
0.4416365623,
-0.3925209939,
-0.4060515165,
-0.31221053,
-0.9064842463,
-0.1048863456,
-0.7501464486,
0.158811003,
-0.4497025013,
-0.3330437243,
0.1520308405,
-0.237618342,
0.18790932,
0.3774125278,
-0.8039255142,
0.5577081442,
0.7924771309,
0.6855853796,
-0.6839393973,
-0.3771997094,
-0.3001257181,
0.1111656055,
-0.2898198366,
0.7126104832,
-0.4622078538,
-0.2916652858,
-0.3219913244,
-0.4057845771,
-0.5718319416,
-0.4367724359,
-0.0985500738,
-0.0469092615,
0.1133858114,
-0.0992873982,
-0.1966856718,
-0.1712860465,
0.3187473118,
-0.395262152,
1.0345464945,
0.3755836487,
-0.7107777596,
0.0591305159,
-0.7083901167,
-0.4852490127,
0.3381679952,
-0.7043047547,
-0.7653945088,
0.1083766744,
-0.1174284071,
-0.0030231327,
-0.5538946986,
0.3700826466,
0.0705792382,
-0.5345829725,
-0.0517848693,
0.3142378628,
0.969566226,
0.4251267612,
-0.7706975341,
0.4549258947,
-0.3350816965,
0.5059331059,
0.0918239951,
-0.4642677903,
0.4532418549,
0.3936332464,
0.040096622,
0.0836275667,
0.2082166523,
-0.5875974298,
0.3032670319,
-0.0186566021,
0.6461933255,
0.8993400931,
-0.2431161404,
0.1567120999,
-0.6337655783,
0.8545513153,
-0.2357384115,
0.7992472649,
0.6074726582,
-0.5332993269,
-0.6862000823,
-0.3755300045,
0.0387536399,
0.7701990008,
-0.6541878581,
0.0997409374,
-0.1550503522,
-0.4981644452,
0.1585840285,
-0.1071830541,
0.5627890825,
0.0949125439,
0.1831003129,
-0.2137273848,
-0.589987874,
-1.0577651262,
-0.060381379,
0.2565336525,
0.3701862991,
0.4157349169,
0.3637390435,
-0.0122765796,
0.7190958261,
-0.758453548,
0.173872903,
-0.5785939693,
-0.0971378908,
0.6517447233,
0.4030721188,
0.9319617152,
-0.9230342507,
-0.7496467233,
0.0686096326,
-0.5416049361,
0.234634161,
-0.0860512555,
-0.014621906,
0.0292414892,
0.5696985126,
-0.6453172565,
0.4357354343,
0.5041909218,
0.047941085,
0.9606543779,
0.0140817361,
-0.1050773636,
-0.7323302627,
0.0531245098,
-0.6957484484,
-0.1684668958,
-0.3179503679,
0.2670111954,
-0.2339382768,
-0.6007960439,
-0.5167589188,
0.063389115,
-0.1997139007,
-0.2684016526,
-0.2158015817,
-0.6618116498,
-0.1599288583,
0.7257736921,
0.2217711061,
0.9730167985,
0.9459360838,
-0.9112123251,
0.200436905,
0.1400094479,
-0.2479024082,
0.5715828538,
-0.7860100269,
0.3220606446,
-0.1059531495,
0.0683423355,
-0.3094392717,
0.0234481283,
0.1850192696,
0.0108444849,
-0.087716803,
-0.33039096,
-0.2290391773,
-0.2308810502,
-0.3644499183,
0.5376926661,
0.5326558948,
-0.6166036725,
0.8546866179,
0.3883828819,
0.0501902997,
-0.4714772999,
-0.3509231806,
-0.1231470257,
-0.2784465551,
-0.50785321,
0.7238798141,
-0.5405843854,
-0.2481714338,
-0.0241185911,
-0.246114254,
-0.1215222478,
0.222733885,
0.4469636679,
0.1315788925,
-0.3755226135,
-0.4244049788,
0.1023806185,
-0.3980687261,
-0.0367337801,
-0.4748064578,
0.7029280066,
-0.286378473,
-0.0538737401,
-0.1721561551,
0.6027797461,
0.8360751867,
-0.348469317,
0.7458515167,
0.4944501817,
-0.7710046768,
-0.2844167352,
-0.4405007362,
0.0161368418,
-0.5879247785,
-0.134536162,
-0.6318587065,
-0.4828970432,
0.139725253,
-0.2607320845,
0.2580740452,
0.127803579,
0.6948871613,
0.2190938145,
0.6492515802,
0.5289314389,
-0.0626938939,
0.4213220179,
-0.5128090978,
0.312179476,
-0.9146640897,
-0.0083196182,
-0.3519179523,
-0.5171330571,
-0.6315943599,
-0.2752389014,
0.7052510381,
-0.1636986881,
-0.3901080787,
0.5827040672,
-1.0609893799,
0.7406169772,
0.7366122007,
-0.1837356985,
-0.2047985643,
-0.1955484748,
-0.2506383657,
0.1731060445,
-0.9383050799,
-0.0769236609,
0.5680013895,
-0.2784832716,
0.5969778299,
0.0618849173,
0.5448459983,
0.0941986591,
-0.2921091616,
-0.3608729243,
0.6125844717,
-0.4982841909,
-0.4130589664,
-0.1393657178,
-0.3263581693,
-0.5905861259,
0.1481921971,
-0.1088390276,
-0.9664287567,
0.5938961506,
0.3342853189,
-0.705299139,
0.6453461647,
-0.5699235201,
0.800511539,
-0.3895938993,
-0.1430547535,
-0.40310812,
-0.0971906185,
-0.2459696829,
0.2042444348,
-0.2838976085,
-0.2709009051,
0.2172529995,
0.2360444218,
-0.3786929548,
0.4503666162,
-0.0298872963,
0.8323595524,
0.1845461726,
0.0883610994,
0.2169206142,
0.3173303306,
-0.3515806794,
0.3589837551,
-0.0049555316,
-0.3222146034,
-0.3309924901,
0.8098284602,
-0.9101313949,
-0.3967105448,
-0.8108927011,
-0.7917087078,
-0.0633282289,
0.3124912977,
0.5878475904,
0.6868942976,
-0.0175517723,
0.3453633785,
0.5825025439,
-0.2685721517,
0.5393515825,
-0.0662226453,
-0.030711256,
-0.2539071739,
0.8695393205,
-0.0771400258,
0.1863049865,
0.415792644,
0.3265320361,
0.3746703565,
-1.0106844902,
-0.3008834422,
-0.1927105933,
-0.0239512734,
-0.5118191242,
-0.3989090025,
-0.652140975,
-0.3576155007,
-0.6754788756,
-0.6732412577,
-0.7944028378,
0.0088259056,
0.2242920548,
0.4201722443,
0.4216686189,
-0.1088295504,
0.4593078494,
0.1202896237,
0.6452830434,
0.3741494417,
0.4864471555,
-0.3666738868,
0.2654746473,
-0.0584247485,
-0.4126880169,
-0.3196049929,
-0.4213022888,
0.0036565233,
0.3025034666,
0.6523054838,
0.1981987953,
-0.0802210346,
0.5493127704,
-0.4794405103,
0.3699097931,
-0.0343756266,
-0.8028359413,
0.5747891068,
-0.3745738566,
0.5710129738,
0.5702270865,
0.4279735088,
-0.403919071,
-0.0688176751,
-0.3461472094,
-0.7513830662,
0.7461361289,
0.4596723318,
-0.3170814216,
0.1422071904,
0.5459961891,
0.0987713188,
0.2553268671,
-0.4526554942,
-0.1784801036,
-0.4072429836,
0.285797596,
0.3378416896,
-0.2072487772,
-0.1808071285,
-0.4573199451,
0.5977123976,
-0.2117984891,
0.5362357497,
0.0770235285,
-0.1347900629,
-0.0013354475,
0.0440563969,
0.4912491441,
1.4617731571,
-0.4544138014,
-0.2868390977,
0.2902691662,
-0.5358468294,
-0.3303974569,
0.1597015858,
-0.480699867,
-0.2236326486,
-0.2553392351,
0.7065120339,
0.1330737174,
-0.3395946622,
0.0036347567,
-0.1204641163,
0.0234568901,
-0.9209529161,
0.5205630064,
0.2254390419,
0.2192546129,
-0.1507323682,
0.2571182847,
0.0955979452,
-0.3189136982,
0.0842030644,
0.1249328479,
-0.0879718587,
-0.0516032539,
0.7850843668,
0.1431956142,
-0.4857735932,
1.0569579601,
-0.3761069179,
-0.6483887434,
0.8338643909,
0.5496255159,
0.8652899861,
-0.3502947092,
0.0868520439,
0.4886190295,
0.4149940908,
0.3934956491,
0.6299191713,
0.0655568689,
-0.6926566958,
-0.2706350088,
-0.7245286703,
-0.675527215,
-0.077274017,
-0.6385148168,
0.3040339351,
-1.13245821,
-0.2193405926,
0.1586308628,
-0.1965558529,
-0.5697519779,
0.1612032056,
0.4612400532,
0.9332543015,
-0.3077321649,
0.8044954538,
1.0491220951,
0.18775177,
-0.3131899536,
-0.4825070202,
0.5236905217,
-0.4314858317,
-0.2753536105,
-0.1442947537,
-0.1611820608,
-0.1311813593,
0.1724853367,
-0.7120548487,
1.1069871187,
0.7182896137,
-0.4606134295,
-0.146927163,
0.4231007099,
0.1948893964,
-0.5111513734,
0.2202414125,
0.499635309,
0.3872128427,
-0.1207533777,
-0.9056096673,
-0.0141220214,
-0.4807520807,
0.2208027095,
0.6817974448,
-0.8219428658,
1.1383590698,
-0.0834661648,
0.1183754951,
0.0547494665,
0.2871999443,
0.2415851206,
0.0825543553,
0.8445399404,
0.7053076029,
0.4655032754,
-0.3818412721,
1.3279849291,
-0.543415308,
0.1578885615,
0.8708054423,
0.1405986995,
0.3628706932,
0.3441993296,
-0.2031682134,
0.7712851763,
0.5799409747,
0.1072013378,
0.2406881303,
0.4294433296,
-0.2586295903,
-0.4847430289,
0.0692269951,
-0.3774550259,
0.3565581143,
0.4447722733,
0.318292737,
-0.2757539749,
-0.2578982711,
0.128623724,
-0.1173282042,
-0.2719810903,
0.4347050488,
0.1991960257,
-0.6982017159,
0.3696978688,
-0.1269008964,
0.5423097014,
-0.9582178593,
-0.0910939127,
-0.1806511134,
0.4785407186,
-0.5220034122,
-0.4178929627,
0.6775869131,
-0.376437664,
-0.1751936078,
-0.4876310527,
0.6610184908,
0.2607179284,
-0.3580833673,
0.1534563452,
0.0344929285,
-0.0709542185,
-0.3834001124,
-1.0803010464,
0.3067209721,
0.0318425074,
0.1061280966,
0.3168289065,
-0.1305541843,
-0.0724607557,
0.7264371514,
0.6435023546,
0.0334509611,
0.1621612608,
-0.1377940625,
0.9898786545,
-0.5114012957,
-0.6234043837,
-0.4517185092,
0.37604478,
-0.2008982748,
-0.7251868844,
0.2603048086,
0.966855824,
0.6972472072,
-0.2162133902,
0.4001317918,
-0.434040606,
0.2987131178,
-0.2976732254,
0.6479563117,
-0.3137181699,
-0.0709513873,
-0.1130094975,
-1.3472733498,
0.1826473027,
0.575624764,
-0.2146925181,
-0.3523092568,
0.9260627031,
0.4581015706,
-0.5513928533,
0.1138997674,
-0.0833073482,
-0.107387051,
0.1546551138,
0.7603092194,
0.5986387134,
0.1499299556,
0.4665171206,
-0.8725863099,
-0.3510129154,
-0.0373428687,
-0.840452373,
-0.4943813086,
-0.5087827444,
-0.9160220623,
-0.0351810157,
0.5901216865,
0.5825601816,
0.9892916083,
-0.8277767897,
-0.6391196847,
-0.0401185937,
0.3375131786,
-0.7474261522,
-0.2323193699,
0.1832800061,
-0.3720143735,
-0.6788625717,
0.4393436313,
0.4701684713,
-0.5692237616,
0.1302413642,
0.1079569906,
-0.0556703359,
0.066106692,
0.5296564698,
0.6424479485,
-0.1805772483,
-0.2938770652,
0.0029644438,
0.1911877841,
0.3476481736,
1.1565459967,
-0.749430418,
0.2507609427,
0.666424334,
0.5898928642,
0.7412218451,
-0.2471604645,
0.8677451015,
-0.4386067688,
0.1606332362,
0.5336627364,
0.4494302273,
-0.0028067229,
-0.5032507777,
0.7536731958,
0.0806133151,
-0.6366468668,
-0.5680717826,
0.3548659682,
-1.2071908712,
-0.2624382377,
0.6839780211,
0.2223846465,
-0.226686269,
-0.0907960087,
0.3337751627,
-0.3408757746,
0.1340592802,
0.9254322648,
0.3404690921,
-0.8335284591,
0.1781701893,
-0.5499591231,
0.5697433949,
0.496399492,
-1.1699143648,
-0.3929205537,
0.1144788861,
0.4215344787,
0.2923936844,
0.6183845401,
-0.3921754658,
0.7838118672,
0.0029288242,
0.1971874982,
-0.1247602627,
-0.445011586,
0.2980897427,
-0.2639708519,
-0.1179881319,
-0.403845489
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06659v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06659v2
|
WisdoM: Improving Multimodal Sentiment Analysis by Fusing Contextual World Knowledge
| 2024-01-12T16:08:07 | 2024-02-20T09:28:50 |
Wenbin Wang, Liang Ding, Li Shen, Yong Luo, Han Hu, Dacheng Tao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Sentiment analysis is rapidly advancing by utilizing various data modalities
(e.g., text, image). However, most previous works relied on superficial
information, neglecting the incorporation of contextual world knowledge (e.g.,
background information derived from but beyond the given image and text pairs)
and thereby restricting their ability to achieve better multimodal sentiment
analysis (MSA). In this paper, we proposed a plug-in framework named WisdoM, to
leverage the contextual world knowledge induced from the large vision-language
models (LVLMs) for enhanced MSA. WisdoM utilizes LVLMs to comprehensively
analyze both images and corresponding texts, simultaneously generating
pertinent context. To reduce the noise in the context, we also introduce a
training-free contextual fusion mechanism. Experiments across diverse
granularities of MSA tasks consistently demonstrate that our approach has
substantial improvements (brings an average +1.96% F1 score among five advanced
methods) over several state-of-the-art methods.
|
[
-0.4021843076,
-0.4229509234,
0.6081350446,
0.1542064101,
-0.6905477047,
-0.0921966732,
-0.3588653505,
-0.4156680405,
0.3553084433,
0.1336959302,
-0.6917609572,
-0.5734145045,
-0.3196563721,
-0.2486144304,
0.1479708254,
0.8761867881,
0.4267775714,
0.1887003928,
-0.692081511,
-0.3413853645,
-0.6020722389,
-0.2885805964,
-0.1089075357,
0.0151646053,
0.7311121821,
0.2520744503,
0.4655731916,
-0.0570220351,
0.686720252,
0.2429739535,
-0.0448044576,
0.5422181487,
-0.2879090011,
0.2578247488,
-0.2229104042,
-0.1361698955,
-0.5109067559,
-0.046904467,
0.3562444448,
0.3868107796,
0.1917937845,
-0.0039725034,
-0.0121922065,
0.7487990856,
-0.8900988698,
0.2628891766,
-0.8162639737,
0.2809265554,
0.0630314574,
-0.393263191,
-0.2574401498,
-0.2491601259,
0.3072939515,
-0.5006290078,
-0.2570869625,
-0.2271909118,
0.6352849007,
0.3987036943,
-0.5798330307,
0.0942267329,
-0.392636925,
1.2480148077,
-0.5541811585,
0.4403111339,
-0.2498424947,
0.0997100845,
0.2554130256,
-0.4410966039,
-0.7820438743,
0.0916741639,
0.0018442394,
0.5333676338,
-0.2041872442,
-0.1488520503,
0.0513301753,
0.1994915456,
-0.1933643371,
-0.4178436697,
-0.2886244953,
-0.0695231631,
0.4827190936,
-0.0917476341,
0.2004702389,
-0.5372174382,
-0.7125574946,
-0.325887531,
-0.4356827736,
0.252582401,
-0.1143713146,
0.1841937155,
-0.088847369,
0.4029070437,
-0.196578607,
0.8873432875,
-0.3479019105,
-0.5694548488,
0.7230101228,
-0.5241586566,
-0.4084304273,
-0.0491650142,
0.8760583401,
1.1329342127,
0.0799427629,
0.0062349699,
-0.1088756174,
0.3271390498,
0.2788417339,
-0.6764279008,
0.0097476598,
0.1399924606,
-0.484087199,
-0.401271224,
0.1144052446,
-0.9615297914,
-0.505194068,
-0.3121896386,
0.3582929969,
-0.6758974195,
-0.4179667234,
-0.1782328933,
-0.4092657864,
0.4452302754,
0.3200629354,
-0.5136873126,
-0.4411810338,
0.5197182894,
0.9394174814,
-0.101588659,
-0.030635938,
-0.5637826324,
0.0621556379,
-0.2726379633,
0.9630777836,
-0.6391883492,
-0.427264601,
0.024585681,
-0.3403808475,
-0.0830516741,
-0.2631521523,
0.593213141,
-0.5442020893,
0.2531332374,
-0.4118721187,
-0.2168481797,
-0.456022799,
0.7257233262,
-0.5239194036,
0.831123054,
-0.0528262407,
-0.8121583462,
0.5365519524,
-0.7601658106,
-0.4507712722,
-0.1445181221,
-0.1084289476,
-0.0724999756,
0.232172519,
0.5751409531,
0.77260077,
-0.0175327752,
0.3933916688,
-0.4246206582,
-0.1510045081,
0.3461333811,
-0.4710896015,
0.5680434108,
0.3316483498,
-0.1427275538,
0.1874697804,
-0.6476535201,
0.218517527,
-0.2005829215,
-0.1186006814,
-0.8539241552,
-0.0377217531,
0.1337116808,
0.57224828,
0.2359321713,
-0.5726986527,
0.2435901314,
-0.4201258719,
0.1814346611,
0.6496107578,
0.0335968435,
0.5100394487,
-0.0375091173,
0.0568383187,
0.5593343973,
0.2885828018,
-0.4107272625,
-0.4632492363,
-0.5660914183,
-0.327113241,
-0.1606862694,
0.4685028195,
-1.1144503355,
0.4260310531,
-0.8302356005,
-0.4803902805,
-0.3393379748,
0.4270231426,
0.2552647591,
0.4450955391,
0.3824185729,
-0.7712330222,
-0.5886957645,
-0.9121825695,
-0.3867579401,
0.024494892,
0.1789441258,
0.2906888127,
0.1432652324,
-0.3795085847,
1.2694395781,
-0.5064442754,
-0.5201903582,
-0.1413810402,
-0.1574581563,
0.0604396835,
0.4075620472,
0.5023508072,
-1.0997196436,
-0.2514385879,
0.0728665739,
-1.2107511759,
0.345287919,
0.0215162057,
-0.1245187521,
0.1567088366,
0.4948718846,
-0.5585620999,
0.1795751452,
0.5541308522,
-0.1991027445,
0.0861016512,
0.2490533292,
0.268499583,
-1.4898979664,
-0.0644721016,
0.3774190247,
-0.0441037752,
-0.5958427191,
-0.032322105,
0.0933911502,
0.0457849987,
-0.740891397,
0.4239689112,
-0.2359603047,
0.0768685713,
-0.0573023334,
0.3324747682,
0.1098004356,
0.5717910528,
0.0594721995,
0.491099298,
0.6360859275,
-0.3315393031,
0.6187406182,
-0.0601886995,
-0.4294323921,
0.9772182703,
-0.1777569652,
0.0435035117,
-0.2044201344,
0.1949487478,
-1.0124830008,
-0.1953426003,
0.0835405067,
-0.3635645211,
-0.036126595,
0.0800782964,
-0.3430443406,
-0.0576922819,
-0.5918411016,
0.3652669191,
0.3995728493,
-0.5268222094,
0.9767551422,
0.3070504963,
-0.0616220459,
-0.8287431598,
-0.5906158686,
0.2613486946,
-0.2733536363,
-0.9513503909,
0.3806948662,
-0.1775348336,
-0.6316434741,
-0.0026510495,
0.1847791225,
0.1204538643,
-0.3154982626,
0.2442202419,
0.3720237315,
-0.1186397821,
0.5101752281,
0.0685904548,
-0.0517635979,
-0.0029497063,
-0.3824497461,
0.3565254807,
-0.4326540232,
-0.249458313,
-0.3686838746,
0.2502886653,
0.9450181127,
-0.4177569449,
0.6457879543,
0.9506507516,
-0.1140112504,
0.0019352405,
-0.7460564375,
-0.1355476379,
-0.4152438045,
0.386179924,
-0.2209422737,
-0.5481941104,
0.1148401871,
-0.1617681235,
0.1825164258,
0.1400977373,
0.4198595285,
-0.1551482528,
0.9104207158,
0.7225133777,
-0.2386585474,
0.7642229795,
-0.1991469264,
0.4281925559,
-0.8002462983,
-0.3765563965,
0.2610042393,
-0.2673819661,
-0.2964781225,
-0.6428922415,
0.8286223412,
-0.352162689,
0.2396269739,
-0.3736435175,
-0.3032967448,
0.4325456321,
0.6899542809,
0.2620962262,
0.3042230904,
0.4269747138,
-0.2085011154,
-0.2239184529,
-0.7826352119,
-0.1073353887,
0.9854168296,
0.0545895472,
0.5137814283,
0.061757993,
0.507869482,
0.1653703153,
0.1357487887,
-1.0674619675,
0.6501695514,
-0.202578932,
-0.0651315972,
0.1445700079,
-0.2763046324,
-0.3836491704,
0.5268613696,
-0.5670964718,
-0.2860191464,
0.0994393229,
0.0600159056,
-0.3091953993,
0.342808038,
-0.7169125676,
0.7080462575,
-0.153917253,
-0.6709535122,
-0.3733867109,
-0.7835593224,
0.5929962993,
0.2449872196,
0.5629184842,
0.0790488943,
0.102558203,
0.5974112153,
-0.0953669474,
1.1168253422,
-0.4016830027,
-0.3686024547,
0.1634151191,
-0.2101043314,
0.2283688635,
-0.0807252899,
0.2045638561,
0.1632761061,
-0.2434742898,
-0.2064828426,
-0.6914523244,
1.0089889765,
-0.568970561,
-0.261677295,
-0.339694947,
-0.9051273465,
-0.5412042141,
-0.0730916038,
0.0237899441,
0.6649013758,
-0.1153353304,
0.48416394,
0.8095569015,
-0.1153408363,
0.6503405571,
0.0308804531,
0.0733452812,
-0.5807830095,
0.9840013981,
0.0139520923,
0.1200330704,
0.3651899993,
0.1934212297,
-0.2560894191,
0.1058107987,
-0.5233938694,
-0.0713653043,
-1.0662419796,
-0.3701476753,
-0.7481408715,
0.1420268118,
-0.4117970765,
-0.2690611482,
-0.2304093391,
-0.2726006806,
-0.0113830697,
-0.0143681336,
0.5309462547,
0.331485033,
0.0243693274,
0.1340419352,
-1.002802968,
0.2779359221,
0.7344771028,
0.1961197853,
0.0114049045,
-0.0193312708,
-0.1426999718,
0.0546201915,
-0.2745560706,
-0.8558168411,
0.5356056094,
0.2427501082,
0.2243344188,
0.6446388364,
-0.0461916141,
0.918186605,
-0.1873285621,
1.1644687653,
0.6475811005,
-0.9114964604,
0.729703784,
-0.2148225605,
0.4323390722,
0.3122628331,
0.0061037573,
-0.5534967184,
-0.3154734969,
-0.3942428827,
-1.0396301746,
0.3174227178,
-0.2224768698,
0.359531045,
0.1625410318,
0.0597162805,
-0.0006613069,
0.2359157354,
-0.9894209504,
-0.0243483316,
-0.5689457059,
-0.5690911412,
-0.1317979544,
-0.1640305072,
-0.4451313615,
-0.488370806,
0.6803612709,
-0.5758981705,
0.0829486474,
0.2635270059,
-0.3207670748,
0.0601458885,
0.457764864,
0.5161334872,
0.5093523264,
-0.0110069606,
0.3132633567,
0.2445152551,
-0.3073016703,
-0.193541348,
-0.2345757782,
-0.1883687824,
-0.1119062155,
0.3665006459,
0.7025349736,
0.3080804348,
-0.8668394089,
0.7061905861,
-0.1265203953,
-0.0897629485,
-0.3633209467,
0.1727223694,
0.0501086079,
0.4239064455,
0.4236097932,
0.6908287406,
0.0785170421,
-0.5372578502,
0.019489551,
0.8906224966,
-0.9165055156,
-0.2479644716,
-0.0460305586,
0.3609547615,
0.3816545308,
0.3050583303,
-0.0864099935,
-0.4694763124,
0.1851784587,
0.3312388062,
0.6406909227,
0.1525935382,
0.119594425,
0.2580381334,
0.2435255051,
0.1964429766,
0.3912877142,
-0.1433021426,
-0.9022304416,
-0.5380631685,
-0.7354439497,
-0.1897879392,
-0.2122065127,
-0.5712178946,
-0.0129478583,
-0.1799042821,
-0.1330874115,
-0.4031965435,
-0.2566824853,
-0.7438089252,
0.5258375406,
0.1119493097,
0.6240603924,
-0.7458332181,
0.7068538666,
0.9692753553,
-0.2869983613,
-0.5310915709,
0.0562347919,
0.1312850565,
-0.6150606871,
0.6903297305,
0.5327607989,
-0.5447229147,
-0.194391042,
-0.7772349715,
-0.6039286256,
1.2710075378,
0.1385880858,
-0.3821708262,
0.4075211585,
-0.3364075422,
0.365215987,
-0.578016758,
0.0508125909,
0.3616608679,
0.5773671269,
0.2876089811,
-0.5953435898,
-0.1342990398,
-0.7354024649,
-0.0154801412,
-0.1093512252,
-0.6426355839,
0.6667940021,
-0.3093037605,
-0.0084630111,
-0.3420238197,
0.9398710132,
0.1131760776,
0.5042917728,
0.795306325,
0.6434206963,
0.7078557014,
-0.0942119882,
0.8601612449,
-0.3796676695,
0.1810363978,
0.5929859877,
-0.3567536771,
0.9720159173,
0.9519551396,
0.2592047751,
0.9542707205,
0.1342410147,
0.218389526,
0.7400169373,
-0.4514784813,
-0.5486912727,
-0.4929698706,
-0.3954268992,
-0.3712986708,
0.6966079473,
0.3928392231,
-0.4506687522,
0.0595359243,
0.4315600693,
0.0061057578,
-0.0229865946,
-0.5594707727,
1.0760215521,
0.136350736,
-0.7823502421,
0.3394758403,
-0.1798899621,
1.2620197535,
-0.6776498556,
0.0238932632,
-0.020421885,
0.3978526592,
-0.274356693,
-0.6989991665,
0.2317647934,
0.0278040804,
-0.3429823816,
-0.2535001338,
1.0149276257,
-0.4047108591,
-0.5912815928,
0.3875469565,
0.690974772,
-0.1425093859,
-0.2001476735,
-0.4352751374,
0.0204560161,
-0.0146928234,
-0.0763524324,
0.2979363203,
0.3421606123,
0.0949826762,
0.5553404689,
0.8868752718,
-0.1255684644,
-0.2275210172,
0.2260327786,
1.1523746252,
-0.7030436397,
-0.5493594408,
-0.9994493127,
0.6543733478,
-0.4111014903,
-0.2255695611,
0.7817438841,
0.1673339307,
0.5341411829,
-0.3292690814,
1.0324321985,
-0.2552239597,
0.1049547121,
-0.7597421408,
0.7075542808,
-1.0199463367,
0.0703312755,
-0.4885577261,
-0.9746542573,
-0.600774169,
0.6716526747,
-0.2309880257,
-0.0149429366,
0.6389594078,
0.8534905314,
-0.2520086765,
0.0240282677,
0.4282719493,
0.1296511441,
0.1762664467,
0.4982727766,
0.8081111908,
-0.2441710681,
0.5666047335,
-0.4090080857,
-0.265663892,
-0.1238044649,
-1.142999649,
-0.7958055735,
-0.5837647915,
0.0189983007,
-0.218835935,
-0.1207388192,
1.0954546928,
0.7582044601,
-0.4903186858,
0.1124924123,
0.3558728695,
0.0898774788,
-0.4822806716,
-0.2902414203,
0.2343311161,
-0.5837166309,
-0.5874384642,
0.5274737477,
0.5594779253,
-0.3677675724,
-0.4705311358,
0.0066080284,
-0.0175735131,
0.1450917274,
1.1721512079,
-0.3742182851,
-0.7434303164,
-0.4084496796,
0.0629191771,
0.0509956516,
0.1779408455,
0.7622513771,
-1.0823569298,
0.7256461978,
0.4937286973,
0.2208889425,
-0.1250090301,
-0.0696315095,
0.4665338099,
-1.1628789902,
0.2590095401,
-0.0037226856,
0.6390404105,
0.7541621923,
-0.1617535949,
0.1901737154,
0.5353053808,
0.0259481352,
-0.5390937924,
0.3339340091,
-1.3444448709,
-0.3043718934,
1.1852059364,
0.0745724812,
-0.444352746,
0.1133451536,
-0.3321067393,
-0.0146608036,
-0.4209696054,
0.7167052031,
0.4380449653,
0.2101851702,
-0.2151288539,
-0.2575439513,
0.3760727048,
0.5286572576,
-0.9679265022,
-0.1247040778,
0.8572847247,
0.1602566838,
0.6616601348,
0.5677503943,
-0.1053990647,
0.3620489836,
-0.1066999808,
0.2231559753,
-0.0584643297,
-0.4777494967,
-0.2135594636,
0.6423415542,
-0.319567591,
-0.0608364195
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06643v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06643v2
|
Effects of diversity incentives on sample diversity and downstream model performance in LLM-based text augmentation
| 2024-01-12T15:46:43 | 2024-02-15T11:14:10 |
Jan Cegin, Branislav Pecher, Jakub Simko, Ivan Srba, Maria Bielikova, Peter Brusilovsky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The latest generative large language models (LLMs) have found their
application in data augmentation tasks, where small numbers of text samples are
LLM-paraphrased and then used to fine-tune downstream models. However, more
research is needed to assess how different prompts, seed data selection
strategies, filtering methods, or model settings affect the quality of
paraphrased data (and downstream models). In this study, we investigate three
text diversity incentive methods well established in crowdsourcing: taboo
words, hints by previous outlier solutions, and chaining on previous outlier
solutions. Using these incentive methods as part of instructions to LLMs
augmenting text datasets, we measure their effects on generated texts lexical
diversity and downstream model performance. We compare the effects over 5
different LLMs, 6 datasets and 2 downstream models. We show that diversity is
most increased by taboo words, but downstream model performance is highest with
hints.
|
[
-0.2114053071,
-0.1198016256,
0.3423277736,
0.3110721111,
-0.6582046747,
0.0966673046,
-0.0223895963,
-0.6538855433,
0.1657071561,
0.741525054,
-0.5598839521,
-0.5182956457,
-0.8309169412,
0.5441012383,
-0.6527481675,
1.2628815174,
0.2581602037,
0.0071360506,
-0.3900471628,
-0.1821075976,
-0.3053203523,
-0.7467817664,
-0.1562619358,
-0.0481818169,
0.6239082217,
0.5382288694,
0.6865623593,
0.7603574991,
0.4116351902,
0.3455248475,
-0.5061514378,
0.1005765423,
-0.6835576296,
0.3360167742,
-0.2927094996,
-0.6265277267,
0.1587252766,
0.0691032186,
0.5997495055,
0.788713038,
0.0050047133,
-0.0644802079,
0.6626525521,
0.6575135589,
-0.7145807147,
-0.274515897,
-0.6091524363,
-0.3264282644,
-0.4018008113,
-0.3492545784,
-0.1659928709,
-0.7937617302,
0.0885052755,
-0.4016397595,
0.461594671,
-0.1869949698,
0.7327083349,
0.1579073519,
-0.2546360493,
-0.6919198632,
-0.3680538535,
1.0800578594,
-0.6899192929,
-0.0865019411,
0.1906525046,
-0.3612528145,
-0.1047464535,
-0.6418139338,
-0.3260968626,
-0.1707332432,
-0.1260702163,
0.0047867079,
-0.200791195,
0.094870232,
0.0474635996,
0.6025317907,
-0.1286743879,
0.5939567089,
-0.5836670995,
-0.119154036,
0.6232190132,
0.2191432565,
0.2338383645,
-0.2691586018,
-0.2397447973,
-0.3111893535,
-0.5906749368,
0.1298488528,
0.8882713914,
0.4054325223,
-0.1664340794,
0.6857923269,
-0.2803906798,
0.739800334,
-0.291993022,
0.0684733987,
0.3297865987,
-0.6780808568,
0.1011761278,
-0.1349796802,
0.5704791546,
0.294010371,
0.2370700091,
-0.2207154036,
-0.2220372707,
-0.3507551253,
-0.1807061434,
-0.703702569,
-0.0602522567,
0.0177254435,
-0.6272388697,
-0.5267751813,
0.1472350955,
-1.0157728195,
-0.6926904917,
-0.1429955214,
0.3093491197,
-0.2937590778,
0.0203672163,
0.0706596002,
-0.956207037,
0.2030610889,
0.3131250143,
-0.8972453475,
0.0390303768,
0.7281689644,
0.9782775044,
-0.544436872,
-0.2395289987,
-0.5498079062,
-0.1354303807,
-0.0382326208,
0.720597446,
-0.7585055828,
-0.8519511223,
-0.040749643,
-0.1592693627,
0.0282901116,
-0.7625066638,
0.8849604726,
-0.5260815024,
0.261726141,
-0.5266606808,
-0.7525511384,
-0.2582460344,
-0.3297682106,
-0.804754138,
0.7019803524,
0.1221117526,
-0.7228062749,
0.6310288906,
-0.3740316927,
-0.4520564377,
0.4472459555,
-0.2080261558,
-0.1288523227,
0.1021755785,
0.3702320457,
0.2743310034,
-0.1707958281,
0.1025810614,
-0.4260317385,
-0.5572890043,
0.4322562218,
-0.6480073333,
0.9412890673,
0.1571286023,
-0.2788229883,
0.0291847456,
-0.4421775639,
-0.3736526668,
-0.2122137547,
-0.4884725511,
-0.5790081024,
-0.1318136305,
0.0451798961,
0.1594692618,
-0.1104899049,
-0.4568983316,
-0.0743734017,
-0.3725622296,
0.2228682935,
0.8631117344,
0.2798036635,
0.4321259558,
-0.6336219907,
0.6925433874,
-0.0126194144,
-0.0974277854,
-0.2815489173,
-1.026321888,
-0.4128350914,
-0.5178466439,
0.438192457,
0.4456853569,
-0.6242762804,
0.252225101,
-0.3680284619,
-0.4007500112,
-0.4546557069,
0.3708414435,
0.1304367185,
0.2194252759,
0.0994759127,
-0.2622323632,
-0.2562783659,
-0.7492554188,
-0.6757888794,
0.1336908489,
-0.2905925214,
0.3539167941,
0.4416650832,
0.1564483643,
1.0806673765,
-0.2146656513,
-0.0719387531,
-0.2406195253,
0.4292967319,
0.3161636889,
0.4034962058,
0.6524409056,
-0.8356151581,
-0.0745675862,
-0.4601023197,
-0.2011066824,
-0.4178874195,
0.0122507773,
-0.038605269,
-0.0513509363,
0.2049463987,
-0.3385157883,
0.3233851492,
0.8426320553,
-0.2704712152,
0.3935315311,
0.0647508278,
0.4852097332,
-0.8380243182,
-0.3297886252,
-0.0666710064,
0.0458632037,
-0.3602518141,
0.1220253929,
-0.0598077327,
-0.0773251727,
-0.3350493312,
0.3223917782,
-0.530302465,
0.1564690173,
-0.5782920718,
0.1301891059,
0.0169625208,
0.0967524126,
-0.0431806147,
0.8676459789,
0.4020321965,
-1.0270552635,
0.2895690501,
-0.0218145233,
-0.6160820127,
0.1999130547,
-0.4947966933,
0.1041236147,
-0.303845048,
0.2197505534,
-1.0171256065,
-0.3354157507,
0.1409231871,
-0.3989672661,
-0.0470429435,
0.0247764625,
-0.3721188307,
-0.2680190206,
-0.6261819005,
0.4289101362,
0.6293727756,
-0.7786931992,
0.2262989432,
0.1472387016,
-0.4258538485,
-0.5903021693,
-0.9669228792,
0.2311704457,
-0.5356711745,
-0.6117143035,
0.5002677441,
0.022540791,
-0.3005999625,
0.0231595617,
0.1766698956,
0.1330548823,
0.1623896658,
0.0855201408,
0.1539750695,
0.1698648632,
0.2156860828,
0.4095579684,
0.3105402887,
0.0198177435,
-0.3934815526,
0.4312191904,
0.3391120136,
-0.333514154,
-0.155667454,
0.3857995868,
0.1552867591,
0.0573344789,
0.8085699677,
0.3582600653,
0.0039833919,
0.0570940822,
-0.4036458135,
-0.360711962,
-0.5319983363,
0.2345984578,
0.0711407289,
-1.3434194326,
0.3683518171,
0.2584685981,
0.3337869346,
0.5169305801,
0.56137532,
0.0914356485,
0.7181456685,
0.3921457827,
-0.1127318144,
0.495455265,
0.2301749885,
-0.2803327441,
-0.3736979067,
-0.2227165103,
-0.9328863621,
-0.5114120245,
-0.9431388378,
-0.5717449188,
0.2606944144,
0.3073828518,
0.3006206453,
-0.0856390595,
-0.424811393,
0.2647030056,
0.9523113966,
0.1442354769,
0.5461346507,
0.3256259859,
0.2610012293,
-0.1288373172,
-0.708412528,
-0.3291378617,
1.2029594183,
0.1066009253,
0.8193607926,
0.2015067935,
0.9388956428,
0.377802521,
0.4631950259,
-0.5673985481,
0.4308785498,
-0.4748654068,
-0.6641745567,
-0.2958103716,
-0.5954815745,
-0.9678826332,
0.1027978808,
-0.163447395,
-0.82509166,
0.8407948613,
-0.0410521887,
-0.2439438403,
0.2406692803,
-0.4984000623,
0.0235771015,
0.0052915048,
-0.3344852924,
-0.32415694,
-0.3132213652,
0.6374484301,
-0.2567714751,
0.2955463529,
-0.013169989,
-0.3677950501,
1.0032060146,
-0.4829905331,
0.8424296975,
-0.0989909545,
-0.1829780042,
0.3373182714,
-0.3664191067,
0.7495257854,
0.1052353904,
-0.4014108777,
0.2747113705,
-0.4451342523,
-0.4723828137,
-0.3256480694,
0.732473731,
-0.5123109221,
-0.8528088331,
-0.1796933562,
-0.7921437025,
-0.1772649884,
-0.2566148639,
0.8216479421,
0.372613132,
0.3809297085,
0.6881945729,
0.5317656398,
-0.3928202391,
0.5435884595,
0.2839869261,
-0.0833749175,
-0.5606015325,
0.7038342953,
0.0382593498,
0.497092545,
0.2362106591,
0.2189914137,
-0.4785341024,
-0.7118204236,
-0.4050276279,
-0.0383428186,
-0.6979379058,
-0.0897155255,
-0.8611037135,
-0.0280326419,
-0.5506820083,
-0.0359448493,
0.2191749066,
-0.4934675992,
-0.402718246,
-0.087089479,
0.9878696203,
0.5673390031,
-0.2624936998,
0.3751509786,
-1.0007890463,
0.03615354,
0.400516063,
0.1545597613,
-0.1592362374,
-0.8564577699,
-0.202190429,
0.0791350305,
-0.1289318651,
-1.1758078337,
0.2306024432,
0.0883996561,
0.6343431473,
0.3170672655,
0.0137078939,
0.3862790167,
0.1679577231,
0.9756385088,
0.1346211731,
-0.7928281426,
0.1308933347,
-0.3891653121,
0.25054726,
0.5508391857,
0.1820759922,
-0.3158366382,
-0.9841073155,
-0.3945120275,
-0.99027282,
0.6936231256,
0.6024596691,
0.6999213696,
0.0724315047,
0.4220363796,
0.5137637258,
0.3859345317,
-0.8660165668,
-0.3391892612,
0.0268194657,
-0.1804750264,
0.0014265798,
-0.3905035555,
-0.0369556174,
-0.0611166283,
0.3312340975,
0.2476080507,
-0.126046598,
0.1653548479,
-0.0098608239,
0.1054426953,
0.5097472072,
0.4218239188,
0.394159168,
-0.0273330193,
-0.1765651554,
0.1967453361,
-0.5552874207,
0.1023443937,
0.4020645916,
-0.5456146598,
0.3336630762,
0.3475030661,
0.7785534859,
0.0111238686,
-0.6642089486,
0.1722635031,
0.19213067,
-0.4131338894,
0.5603777766,
0.3359401226,
0.0513715222,
0.1123890802,
0.5670582056,
-0.0800926983,
0.6538845301,
-0.2315966636,
0.004207083,
0.5288444757,
-0.1965088099,
0.2849010825,
0.5419440866,
0.2881537974,
-0.2247243971,
0.6191834807,
-0.2252963334,
-0.2238754779,
0.741674602,
0.4234022796,
0.7898683548,
-0.1090871468,
0.2205585837,
0.1080332324,
0.4262010455,
-0.0186160542,
0.1898186654,
-0.1587511748,
-0.5395692587,
-0.6029809117,
-0.6378162503,
-0.4919457734,
0.2448913157,
-0.6333165169,
0.2963825762,
0.1462659836,
-0.037090186,
-0.2452026457,
-0.401334703,
-0.4578301609,
0.2548510432,
0.1418901682,
0.7657011747,
-0.6766049266,
0.4284362495,
0.706923306,
-0.2991254926,
-0.8568163514,
0.4031717181,
-0.1231713891,
-0.5232361555,
0.5598269701,
0.2822284102,
-0.2016383559,
0.2124219835,
-0.5541723371,
-1.004082799,
0.8566094041,
0.3103148341,
-0.5958732367,
0.1485311836,
0.3860841691,
0.1837011725,
-0.1351839155,
0.1941443086,
0.3882496059,
0.394783169,
0.0646601319,
-0.5024542212,
-0.0750136599,
-0.2754744589,
0.1174134612,
0.0584306009,
-0.2305731177,
0.8893963695,
-0.203838855,
-0.2617927194,
0.3404148221,
0.7032154799,
0.7464239597,
0.3215663731,
0.7869181633,
0.20770818,
0.7175642848,
0.0418376625,
1.273334384,
-0.1977387816,
0.1206118986,
0.6688012481,
-0.0468400195,
0.3336221278,
0.4881304204,
-0.1633372158,
0.7694794536,
0.76327914,
-0.166947946,
0.5069297552,
0.2582697868,
-0.2945968211,
0.0052137976,
-0.3781294525,
-0.508741796,
0.2626631558,
0.2527265549,
-0.6786136627,
-0.2780390084,
0.1074964702,
-0.0514867827,
0.022735443,
-0.5255873799,
0.5287398696,
0.1878744662,
-0.8291838765,
0.1942977607,
0.2846249342,
1.1612719297,
-0.4857574105,
0.2002484202,
-0.4689697623,
-0.1378350258,
-0.2402714044,
-0.9620308876,
0.1472226083,
0.1952380538,
-0.2644129992,
-0.0996443704,
0.826477766,
-0.3969330192,
-0.5440952182,
0.1692875475,
0.3298143148,
0.181435436,
-0.241651237,
-0.5784731507,
-0.3194846809,
0.0605622567,
-0.2013012916,
0.2947846055,
0.263407737,
-0.2168830186,
0.484700799,
0.8414524794,
0.0858048573,
0.1613518298,
0.4411050081,
0.9590218663,
-0.6066915989,
-0.7999813557,
-1.1989718676,
0.5177368522,
-0.4146997929,
-0.4243023992,
1.0019242764,
0.5575194955,
0.5621246099,
-0.0136479903,
0.8461114764,
0.1276363879,
0.4959713221,
-0.6750658154,
0.3745043278,
-0.5115859509,
0.4736779034,
-0.4421067238,
-0.6949294806,
0.1223297119,
-0.2702258229,
-0.3572250605,
0.4807936847,
0.3904236853,
0.8264502883,
0.2153929621,
0.3251870573,
-0.0200381242,
-0.2164519727,
-0.0257153641,
0.1471647024,
1.1678028107,
0.198939085,
0.9510160685,
-0.1932115406,
-0.3785135448,
-0.1640763581,
-0.8361313939,
-0.4398548007,
-0.3417921066,
-0.1326138526,
-0.3325770199,
0.1380760521,
0.5983508825,
0.3897764087,
-0.7422203422,
-0.3179376721,
-0.3048516512,
0.3523656428,
-0.240999043,
-0.3044956326,
0.041667562,
-0.3627147079,
-0.9597279429,
0.2452948838,
0.3753761947,
-0.0630651265,
-0.0130647058,
-0.0798916593,
0.0462795049,
0.1879125983,
0.3046165109,
-0.1371554732,
-0.4471680522,
0.2374991626,
0.1299346983,
-0.2104570717,
-0.1639888585,
0.985863924,
-0.7017347813,
0.1140871122,
0.6860646009,
0.5638103485,
0.107380718,
0.4466638565,
0.7560087442,
-0.740871191,
0.2231174409,
0.3536224067,
0.1516652107,
0.4064400494,
-0.5113750696,
0.1208215579,
0.5310691595,
-0.4738236964,
-0.7133616805,
0.2354405224,
-0.4100020528,
-0.5257135034,
1.5500632524,
-0.011393615,
0.1594427079,
-0.4002564549,
0.0960708559,
0.2105538994,
-0.4111649692,
0.6692246795,
0.9103763103,
0.0288444608,
-0.0849089846,
-0.2009294182,
0.6347894073,
0.7681112885,
-0.7267335653,
-0.0334807038,
0.5480752587,
0.115098834,
-0.1842104644,
0.3149848282,
-0.2435204685,
0.1878189594,
-0.1892861724,
-0.134632647,
0.08353398,
0.3414331079,
-0.5804025531,
0.1993357092,
0.1525759548,
-0.3091048896
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06640v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06640v1
|
Experimental Contexts Can Facilitate Robust Semantic Property Inference in Language Models, but Inconsistently
| 2024-01-12T15:40:31 | 2024-01-12T15:40:31 |
Kanishka Misra, Allyson Ettinger, Kyle Mahowald
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent zero-shot evaluations have highlighted important limitations in the
abilities of language models (LMs) to perform meaning extraction. However, it
is now well known that LMs can demonstrate radical improvements in the presence
of experimental contexts such as in-context examples and instructions. How well
does this translate to previously studied meaning-sensitive tasks? We present a
case-study on the extent to which experimental contexts can improve LMs'
robustness in performing property inheritance -- predicting semantic properties
of novel concepts, a task that they have been previously shown to fail on. Upon
carefully controlling the nature of the in-context examples and the
instructions, our work reveals that they can indeed lead to non-trivial
property inheritance behavior in LMs. However, this ability is inconsistent:
with a minimal reformulation of the task, some LMs were found to pick up on
shallow, non-semantic heuristics from their inputs, suggesting that the
computational principles of semantic property inference are yet to be mastered
by LMs.
|
[
-0.2043806612,
-0.9832568169,
0.6655861735,
0.0225607324,
-0.0990728736,
-0.1574599892,
-0.2959089577,
-0.6258043051,
-0.1782131642,
0.1794836074,
-0.4512778819,
-0.0960675031,
-0.9061093926,
-0.2052744925,
-0.4019923806,
1.2528179884,
-0.2046159953,
-0.1529929191,
-0.0754654631,
-0.2450798601,
-0.2534204423,
-0.1245530024,
0.090844363,
-0.3579707742,
0.4180400074,
0.2412812263,
0.7841394544,
0.7803476453,
0.1613715142,
0.1378936023,
-0.1846987456,
-0.1431329101,
-0.3698754311,
0.2260046899,
-0.344910264,
-0.4538514912,
-0.2589991689,
0.1693600118,
0.5530127883,
1.0714037418,
0.1639632881,
-0.1858581901,
0.120389387,
0.1226136982,
-1.191758275,
0.1861937493,
-1.0940390825,
-0.007618966,
0.0404108725,
-0.3415792584,
-0.4837670028,
0.4807551205,
0.4498488605,
-0.428834945,
0.4185929,
-0.2030032724,
1.3641945124,
-0.0113467723,
-0.4159700572,
-0.2912875116,
-0.8253166676,
1.1260761023,
-0.8844026327,
0.3417547345,
0.4158520699,
0.3080206215,
-0.2489522099,
-0.605191052,
-0.5244076252,
-0.5906351805,
-0.1189527363,
-0.1550117284,
0.0682462975,
-0.017096702,
0.354912281,
0.0655955076,
0.0727462396,
0.0537049063,
-0.2444657534,
-0.2762710452,
0.3566354215,
0.2074957043,
0.1944409758,
-0.3800473213,
-0.4388661683,
-0.2305803597,
-0.7678058147,
0.3305734098,
-0.0311227515,
0.6464529037,
-0.1646249145,
0.6011087298,
-0.2643121183,
0.5532582402,
-0.3172672689,
-0.2659473717,
0.2426240742,
-0.4400476515,
-0.205535993,
-0.1599502563,
0.4206495583,
0.1592882127,
0.1623259038,
-0.4889487922,
-0.3993588388,
0.3203537762,
0.0595225021,
-0.7701482773,
-0.0873124376,
0.1930504888,
-0.1415165663,
-0.2441424131,
0.0745999739,
-0.483479321,
-0.0883284509,
-0.083991468,
0.6824260354,
-0.4498923421,
-0.3388888836,
0.149627015,
-0.6071785688,
0.6205519438,
0.2747313678,
-0.9736694098,
0.4015470445,
0.7454915643,
0.577786088,
-0.3121307492,
-0.518268168,
-0.4443959892,
0.123633787,
-0.3347433507,
0.4993557334,
-0.6807886362,
-0.3200435042,
-0.3818040192,
0.0901711062,
-0.0854386389,
-0.3657514453,
0.2282063067,
-0.4849244654,
0.074618496,
-0.1552968174,
-0.6337331533,
0.3542694747,
0.0839891359,
-0.4295912385,
0.6469453573,
0.2408576906,
-0.7278948426,
0.6962766051,
-0.4408913553,
-0.4892109931,
-0.0905468836,
-0.4037178755,
-0.4090080261,
0.4413819611,
-0.1979968697,
0.451733321,
0.1201846227,
0.0211926289,
-0.7295721769,
-0.4106326401,
0.5937466025,
-0.4910330474,
0.7006890178,
0.1702778935,
-0.792316258,
-0.1156818941,
-0.6319769621,
0.0719394758,
0.1750755161,
0.1289195716,
-0.4808016717,
-0.0138755776,
-0.1573621631,
0.3548783064,
0.1654427201,
-0.6025754809,
0.0677268282,
-0.4446943402,
0.2868729234,
0.6969332099,
0.0149870068,
1.0174533129,
-0.2776961327,
0.4561646879,
0.0458945371,
-0.1891171187,
-0.0749255642,
-0.4376574457,
-0.6494168639,
-0.2856140733,
0.1844933629,
0.3840478957,
-0.5633389354,
0.1861709356,
-0.2314592004,
-0.166218847,
-0.3125889301,
0.2905333638,
0.6769666076,
0.6165896058,
0.1742988974,
-0.2206279039,
-0.1180050597,
-0.871937573,
-0.4170542955,
-0.0349523984,
0.0610813275,
0.5055740476,
0.6701251864,
0.0385151953,
1.1556632519,
-0.3756892085,
0.1493103057,
-0.4721852243,
0.2219164521,
-0.1597486138,
0.4634381831,
0.4151971638,
-0.6836448908,
-0.042333629,
-0.0123673165,
-0.7137804627,
-0.2036269158,
0.0844586045,
-0.1838511378,
0.1077973694,
0.373776406,
-0.572335422,
0.6683024168,
0.1840191633,
-0.4160257578,
0.6239005327,
-0.0919944569,
-0.2292230129,
-0.7938914895,
-0.2873942852,
-0.0886521414,
-0.2390926033,
-0.7022897005,
0.4164167941,
0.2003125995,
0.4013005197,
-0.7566972375,
0.9572964907,
-0.4050740898,
-0.2672725618,
-0.5932112336,
0.2110453099,
0.2140474617,
0.4116997421,
0.3011332452,
0.5235757232,
0.6150286794,
-0.6661757827,
-0.133528918,
-0.0416497141,
-0.2366676033,
0.4293520749,
-0.4040627778,
-0.0962354019,
-0.0419154502,
-0.1646754891,
-0.7338324785,
-0.3697638512,
0.1492508501,
-0.4791349471,
0.4763283134,
-0.0323211811,
-0.2747537792,
0.3141757548,
-0.3132150769,
0.1524580568,
0.5659994483,
-0.2540829182,
0.3275233209,
-0.0058866413,
0.1105796173,
-0.5808863044,
-0.8033180833,
0.0106270639,
-0.5166159272,
-0.260674119,
0.0921112075,
0.1557127237,
-0.5521047711,
0.3476454616,
-0.2148317844,
-0.2901799679,
0.6946959496,
0.1293111742,
0.1459760666,
-0.2106079459,
0.3055044711,
0.1885921061,
0.1487656981,
0.1769363731,
-0.0287693348,
-0.0207647178,
-0.2233715057,
-0.4309355319,
-0.1583907604,
0.2040636241,
0.4442799091,
-0.0547587909,
0.9748433828,
0.0821358562,
-0.4379052222,
-0.8183728456,
0.0082758535,
-0.6280460954,
-0.3792189062,
0.4303014576,
-0.655975461,
-1.0138654709,
0.5027190447,
-0.0417872034,
-0.0189004242,
0.2518531382,
0.3010149598,
-0.2944695652,
0.8889677525,
0.6859119534,
0.1994765252,
0.5292083621,
-0.3759843409,
0.1640632302,
-0.933072865,
0.1684419811,
-0.5021944642,
-0.2513344586,
-0.6889520884,
-0.1242312789,
0.2264296114,
0.3413580358,
0.0995771065,
0.5050221086,
-0.0471195802,
0.1974932253,
0.2119103819,
0.2579209208,
0.2802249789,
0.1037439406,
-0.1073111743,
-0.1256265342,
-0.6770063639,
-0.6712766886,
1.0815261602,
0.2058122009,
0.677225709,
-0.0675045922,
0.5425487757,
0.0232050419,
0.5197153687,
-0.7033337951,
0.3803247213,
0.2643640339,
-0.8560985327,
-0.5171486735,
-0.3488442302,
-1.0024123192,
0.406837672,
-0.0689895302,
-1.1641310453,
0.2095496505,
0.1458687633,
-0.0795874745,
0.191913709,
-0.7098301053,
1.0570892096,
-0.1074436009,
-0.8328976035,
0.1024783552,
-0.6992093325,
0.4310513437,
-0.230773896,
0.3546093702,
-0.2430512309,
-0.0560671315,
0.1954541057,
-0.7011362314,
0.8259795308,
-0.2338084877,
-0.234388873,
0.2971887887,
0.3710929155,
0.4282411039,
-0.0850775614,
-0.2362944335,
-0.3268047571,
0.1473907083,
-0.7494673729,
-1.090067625,
0.5149108171,
-0.5347533226,
-0.6709412336,
-0.0988684818,
-0.6580730081,
-0.3440358341,
-0.0210649222,
0.1839999408,
0.4086579084,
-0.074506484,
0.1980827302,
0.4327681363,
-0.0321027376,
0.5477672219,
0.6055909991,
0.1252383292,
0.3517171443,
0.9396273494,
-0.0822673887,
0.9434281588,
0.188986659,
0.3619270027,
-0.1412224621,
-0.5989262462,
-0.4650854766,
-0.1327787638,
-0.9318602681,
0.2675394714,
-0.5684409142,
-0.0719458982,
-0.1425571293,
-0.2210895866,
-0.3929463029,
-0.5942797661,
-0.135681957,
-0.4128759503,
0.311753571,
0.579683423,
0.2260989398,
0.2543144226,
-0.5270233154,
0.1169042364,
0.2521828115,
0.1062733904,
-0.1002240777,
-0.8171659112,
-0.0890255049,
0.2582960129,
-0.1373520941,
-0.9739205837,
0.264860779,
0.3620348275,
0.5117046237,
0.3853344917,
0.0495210476,
0.4994312227,
-0.2029178739,
0.6711837053,
-0.4859110415,
-0.9556171894,
0.6336165071,
-0.3380935192,
0.3461205661,
0.6934292316,
0.0461843051,
0.0796651244,
-0.9200238585,
-0.7796109319,
-0.6585407853,
0.620219171,
0.4033719003,
0.6600096226,
-0.076307714,
0.4829967618,
0.4046469629,
0.3018986881,
-0.9739513993,
-0.026943855,
-0.1010966673,
0.1181817576,
-0.0128813321,
-0.0203923639,
-0.0163275804,
-0.274582088,
0.4351190031,
-0.3030554652,
0.0401458479,
0.0492965691,
-0.4090112448,
-0.0098121138,
0.5880907774,
0.543413341,
0.8157949448,
-0.2653634548,
0.490855068,
0.4061418772,
-0.016132066,
0.1772895008,
-0.0373784639,
-0.3543710113,
-0.1348693669,
0.7126381397,
0.9357965589,
0.4309902489,
-0.7510097027,
0.8185836673,
0.2019132376,
-0.054408811,
0.1025085375,
0.2773869336,
0.0827765018,
-0.0992281586,
0.0239267908,
-0.1849805266,
0.2315650135,
-0.81559515,
0.4745059907,
0.7307941914,
-0.5979852676,
-0.4669121206,
0.4504144192,
-0.2852918506,
-0.0385470353,
0.3129107058,
-0.6698074937,
-0.3413816392,
0.7750169039,
0.4942354262,
0.8922124505,
0.0879960731,
-0.0200618785,
-0.2290201038,
0.1102092862,
-0.0063173231,
0.2449324578,
-0.5275182128,
-1.3013222218,
-0.3395383954,
-0.6463739276,
-0.3849604428,
0.0892955586,
-0.6197918057,
0.2243388593,
-0.3275388181,
0.1241552681,
-0.1275793463,
-0.3444880545,
-0.5806261301,
0.2973534465,
-0.0423114039,
0.7805129886,
-1.0005987883,
1.0289407969,
0.6008407474,
-0.2343959659,
-0.9151403308,
0.0724260882,
-0.0310535878,
-0.5112577677,
0.7575263381,
0.0906400681,
-0.2645576596,
-0.3274513483,
-0.6150549054,
-0.4870021939,
0.8200511336,
0.3646329939,
-0.0954246372,
0.1330887675,
0.2265980393,
0.7306395173,
-0.3906810284,
0.2608298957,
0.6655337214,
0.3110588491,
0.1359236687,
-0.9037861228,
0.1030987948,
-0.2182541788,
-0.1848978549,
0.0838257894,
-0.1022291258,
0.7279327512,
-0.3915394843,
-0.3267551661,
0.2637227774,
0.7147035003,
0.4620372355,
0.4703702331,
0.4460636377,
0.5564135909,
0.2241341621,
-0.0179080144,
1.351718545,
-0.4179356098,
0.3159785867,
1.2335941792,
-0.5232371092,
0.8217793107,
0.6349030733,
0.0412389785,
0.5968783498,
0.4208034873,
0.2197166383,
0.7801300287,
0.2607198954,
-0.3999018669,
-0.2366556674,
-0.3211323023,
-0.0694813579,
0.7348588705,
0.4252510667,
-0.444599092,
-0.352281183,
-0.0325116888,
0.096020855,
0.0202441085,
0.1312943697,
0.6347404718,
0.2647591531,
-0.6443923712,
0.3475803137,
0.0493918359,
0.5421678424,
-0.5723122358,
-0.1295541227,
-0.0707393438,
0.1921144277,
0.0852754489,
-0.5935438871,
0.3428091705,
-0.1654198766,
0.0336318836,
-0.3544358015,
0.8964385986,
-0.0523970611,
-0.1812649816,
0.591329813,
0.8970968723,
0.2284161896,
0.156470418,
-0.4607792199,
-0.013716314,
-0.463760525,
-0.4537291825,
0.4881049991,
0.6658363938,
-0.4482811987,
0.5019987226,
0.3106943071,
0.3196478486,
0.1544364095,
-0.0802773014,
0.7694634199,
-0.6365647912,
-0.1733211577,
-0.8810085058,
0.4490400851,
0.0805233493,
-0.4616681933,
0.8523367047,
0.2022851408,
1.1364303827,
0.0186199453,
0.8197908401,
0.0010036544,
-0.0139138093,
-0.3980183005,
0.4006353319,
-0.6200362444,
0.3923574984,
-0.4443200827,
-0.8793603778,
-0.0880721286,
0.4848937392,
-0.2931064367,
0.2941896319,
0.6868702173,
0.9161741734,
-0.1805879176,
-0.2060120255,
0.5176644325,
0.1517181695,
0.2109618038,
0.551594913,
1.1398761272,
-0.0861147121,
0.1694494933,
-0.5394591689,
-0.3533868194,
0.0487446971,
-1.1675040722,
-0.7574440837,
-0.3396627307,
-0.231177181,
-0.2662847638,
0.2186551988,
0.7177214026,
0.9152739644,
-0.9157898426,
-0.1906752735,
-0.4931891263,
0.2235875875,
-0.3028874397,
-0.3031910062,
0.101127848,
-0.4534125626,
-0.7061884999,
0.4861039221,
0.3191434741,
0.0727275833,
-0.3011534512,
-0.1534504741,
0.1185472161,
0.1009523422,
0.3305062652,
0.3808156848,
-0.9090703726,
-0.5317705274,
0.0616107695,
-0.4965740442,
-0.0668475553,
0.6244478822,
-0.7123557329,
0.5234971046,
0.6143098474,
0.6235851645,
0.4240473807,
-0.2902362943,
0.6993975043,
-0.7294315696,
0.2389839143,
0.0064840778,
0.5786867738,
0.2681306601,
-0.1484781206,
0.1746727675,
0.3966362476,
-0.0066566248,
-0.8525085449,
0.3967858851,
-0.798204124,
-0.8000865579,
1.2905021906,
-0.2733458579,
-0.4502391815,
-0.0500982031,
0.0976114869,
0.1130449101,
-0.1207743362,
0.9163605571,
0.8052749634,
-0.2842087448,
-0.3984245956,
-0.8204194307,
0.5126085877,
0.9217678308,
-0.751868844,
0.0140398936,
0.2476105094,
0.419475466,
0.0558912382,
0.2675810754,
-0.2383203954,
0.4476829767,
-0.0991367623,
-0.0294719692,
0.0584656447,
-0.3104250729,
-0.5071959496,
0.1604200751,
0.5090218782,
0.0303290579
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06628v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06628v2
|
OOP: Object-Oriented Programming Evaluation Benchmark for Large Language Models
| 2024-01-12T15:21:36 | 2024-02-21T06:18:16 |
Shuai Wang, Liang Ding, Li Shen, Yong Luo, Bo Du, Dacheng Tao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Advancing automated programming necessitates robust and comprehensive code
generation benchmarks, yet current evaluation frameworks largely neglect
object-oriented programming (OOP) in favor of functional programming (FP),
e.g., HumanEval and MBPP. To address this, our study introduces a pioneering
OOP-focused benchmark, featuring 431 Python programs that encompass essential
OOP concepts and features like classes and encapsulation methods. We propose a
novel evaluation metric, pass@o, tailored for OOP, enhancing traditional pass@k
measures. Our evaluation of 23 leading large language models (LLMs), including
both general and code-specialized models, reveals three key insights: 1) pass@o
offers a more relevant and comprehensive assessment for OOP code generation; 2)
Despite excelling in FP, code-specialized LLMs like WizardCoder lag in OOP
compared to models like ChatGPT; 3) The poor performance of all advanced LLMs
on our OOP benchmark highlights a critical need for improvements in this field.
Our benchmark and scripts are publicly released at:
https://github.com/alphadl/OOP-eval.
|
[
-0.2299546897,
-0.6474452019,
0.4321984649,
0.1641505212,
0.1942150742,
-0.0568794534,
-0.106663309,
-0.7612844706,
-0.43704772,
0.6041911244,
-0.1335250437,
-0.4741392136,
-0.1821835786,
0.1087022796,
-0.1063259691,
0.5177645087,
0.037557859,
0.0382479876,
-0.3292356431,
-0.1884273291,
-0.090357624,
-0.3377848566,
-0.3561313748,
-0.3973411918,
0.3019594848,
0.2854711711,
0.522069037,
0.5782396793,
0.5195948482,
0.2323267162,
0.2263057232,
-0.2014473528,
-0.3400803506,
-0.0089135701,
-0.0973470062,
-0.4755487442,
-0.7680320144,
-0.1664061397,
0.8110832572,
0.9762680531,
-0.1467509121,
0.3466732204,
-0.1894030273,
0.7176293135,
-1.1450132132,
0.252122432,
-0.3448046744,
0.2636509836,
0.0568865649,
0.1533968151,
-0.4795302749,
-0.3988915086,
0.0969602913,
-0.2763813138,
-0.2840394974,
-0.1010132879,
0.2218913883,
0.1431819052,
-0.0489879884,
-0.0921000987,
-0.4534989595,
0.9527984858,
-0.8695361614,
0.3736819327,
0.1458151937,
0.3005835116,
-0.0788660198,
-0.5471106768,
-0.4404018819,
-0.7256256342,
0.3553535938,
-0.0538601838,
0.0362087488,
0.1783856302,
0.3908277452,
0.5945003629,
-0.5205211639,
0.1642677933,
-0.3356681764,
0.1232389882,
0.8621953726,
0.2808544934,
0.1147438884,
0.2832816839,
-0.4445170164,
0.0747746378,
-0.3630378842,
-0.0457541384,
0.5581140518,
0.0145973666,
0.1291334331,
0.612121582,
-0.5390154719,
0.8963511586,
-0.6829708219,
0.0557324365,
0.3086816072,
-0.0907323956,
-0.1394958496,
-0.2746286392,
0.8257014155,
0.4561467767,
0.4703839719,
-0.212631762,
-0.2889857888,
0.088291049,
0.2493158728,
-0.8041583896,
-0.1658918262,
0.3231097758,
-0.5350126028,
-0.4102393389,
0.1802516431,
-0.660864234,
-0.4618201852,
-0.0405190401,
0.2370720357,
-0.4323095381,
-0.3487374187,
0.5189878941,
-0.097748518,
0.4411514401,
0.3839515746,
-0.6121153831,
0.5032989383,
1.0892066956,
0.8116730452,
-0.4119261503,
-0.6273001432,
-0.5548043847,
-0.2452368587,
-0.3407384455,
0.7185041904,
-0.8578854799,
-0.2800456583,
0.2076270729,
-0.6205654144,
-0.0226227045,
-0.6029732227,
0.1139461398,
-0.3305915594,
-0.0597171709,
0.3161447644,
-0.4780763388,
-0.0810196102,
0.1574339867,
-0.2863102853,
1.1416966915,
0.4284869134,
-0.3488694429,
0.3606425226,
-0.8066626191,
-0.286747992,
0.005771745,
-0.0791041106,
-0.2969534397,
0.3141430616,
-0.2607805133,
0.2071087807,
-0.3725427389,
-0.2668911219,
-0.9259649515,
-0.5467506647,
0.3733325303,
-0.1819255203,
0.6546894312,
0.2664565146,
-0.1947244257,
0.134995684,
-0.9447416663,
0.43617782,
0.0051439726,
-0.5442576408,
-0.1380632967,
0.247243613,
0.2069458663,
0.024073327,
0.2761723399,
-0.4616259038,
0.8192059994,
-0.2395839393,
0.4592460096,
0.660443604,
-0.3293985426,
0.4722824395,
-0.2088253051,
0.5427025557,
-0.4536336064,
0.4601727128,
-0.1371185631,
-0.6133800745,
-0.5757567286,
-0.011410363,
0.1370799541,
0.4611176848,
-0.2561867833,
0.5436793566,
0.199225083,
-0.6016315222,
-0.2825070918,
0.0191316418,
0.4536451399,
0.2669102848,
0.199025169,
-0.5628966689,
-0.1214037091,
-0.4989764392,
-0.3474431336,
-0.4681111276,
-0.1858213395,
0.216814518,
0.6372318268,
-0.4072670639,
0.7239611149,
-0.7959280014,
-0.2680563033,
-0.2970714271,
0.0318465419,
0.1882235259,
0.3314267099,
0.6416646242,
-0.3542866707,
-0.3689704835,
0.1136904061,
-0.3693525195,
-0.3020451367,
0.2627696693,
-0.0195696205,
0.4576914608,
0.3903363049,
-0.1584074199,
0.2365779281,
0.3326657712,
-0.3675510883,
0.9547854662,
-0.3103598654,
0.1078299433,
-0.2706095874,
0.3365227282,
-0.4442662299,
-0.1209714189,
-0.3383337259,
0.5057721138,
-0.0727392361,
-0.33036533,
-0.6038026214,
0.5157962441,
-0.3288632929,
-0.404858321,
-0.0940609425,
-0.1178932115,
-0.1255809218,
0.3104778826,
0.1098406985,
0.4035062492,
0.9238839746,
-0.5631063581,
0.3063074052,
-0.1716647744,
-0.290453881,
0.5383388996,
-0.668430388,
0.4161098301,
0.3009245992,
0.0888383836,
-0.5395078063,
-0.1951224655,
0.2778483331,
-0.2403661311,
0.1241855472,
-0.1787392199,
-0.5388414264,
-0.3133033812,
-0.5041171908,
0.2824791372,
0.5338983536,
-0.0834996998,
0.3554979861,
0.119177103,
0.2768552005,
-0.7012405992,
-0.6656596065,
-0.1669039726,
0.0713746175,
-0.4401943982,
0.0674035847,
-0.1235137358,
-0.2255691737,
-0.0198707543,
-0.3012956083,
-0.2923241854,
0.2931966484,
-0.139192909,
-0.1409537792,
-0.6140416861,
-0.0996325389,
-0.4751899838,
-0.1098402739,
0.1856928021,
-0.5553135872,
0.6955280304,
-0.4733947217,
-0.6582400203,
-0.3519081175,
0.2991145849,
0.5945051908,
-0.350238204,
0.5713538527,
0.299767375,
-0.1860386878,
-0.5526660681,
-0.4485557675,
0.0586949885,
-0.3882986903,
0.4321915507,
-0.3521509469,
-0.3046244085,
0.4733514786,
0.0140766837,
0.2236359864,
0.0387635268,
0.2807613611,
0.2807841599,
0.8229897022,
0.6454808116,
-0.1940968782,
0.7628241777,
-0.3053843677,
-0.0050133094,
-0.4358265102,
-0.0117445523,
-0.6975384355,
-0.0391222276,
-0.3226848841,
-0.6972984672,
0.0431076549,
0.4680390656,
-0.1730422676,
0.2231430858,
-0.3572490513,
0.7145021558,
0.4288098216,
-0.174298957,
0.5503278971,
-0.2502298951,
0.3129621744,
0.4887937009,
-0.601439178,
-0.6287915111,
1.2892894745,
0.403521508,
0.9733279943,
-0.0505551472,
0.9088577032,
0.4846901596,
0.2623573542,
-0.8141671419,
0.6735886335,
0.0708434209,
-0.3636629283,
-0.3783778548,
-0.6282851696,
-0.7014157772,
0.272859931,
0.2542145848,
-1.0705455542,
-0.1369556487,
0.2570958138,
-0.2390657216,
0.0794651881,
-0.8587486744,
1.1605389118,
-0.2462463081,
-0.3967691958,
-0.3213259876,
-0.196601361,
0.3019633591,
0.0865684077,
-0.0581701398,
-0.1920976788,
-0.3659137785,
0.3135921061,
-0.5865192413,
0.3704506457,
-0.2027204037,
-0.1947288215,
0.3116137087,
0.0259311274,
0.0180263594,
0.1051437706,
-0.4649016857,
0.380880475,
0.136217162,
-0.4062997997,
-0.5194631815,
0.6228030324,
-0.4658333659,
-0.1577838063,
-0.515653193,
-0.3284206092,
-0.1774523705,
0.3236068785,
0.0034674928,
0.4035286009,
-0.1321495473,
0.1192899719,
0.3206864595,
-0.3897223771,
0.3273477554,
0.5408110619,
-0.6065443754,
-0.2628555894,
0.8767175674,
-0.003020332,
0.7668343782,
0.382199049,
0.3363370895,
-0.2006769031,
-0.5600069761,
-0.4447825849,
0.1008722261,
-0.6939360499,
-0.0289493203,
-0.4044310749,
-0.0060072476,
-0.3797477782,
-0.1978854239,
-0.4862843156,
-0.3060536385,
0.0527879186,
0.4344551265,
0.0990239009,
0.8392884135,
0.1608190089,
-0.0311270021,
-0.6154136062,
0.3987188339,
0.0608517639,
0.7834472656,
0.0281322338,
-0.0871098712,
-0.0720584914,
-0.2558006346,
-0.4836719334,
-0.5736816525,
-0.1910890043,
0.4998551607,
0.7154325247,
0.5281965137,
0.3862042725,
0.3813634515,
-0.3926894665,
0.6958268881,
0.1191035211,
-1.0367922783,
0.6249571443,
-0.35520643,
0.3951144516,
0.4609103799,
-0.0081046689,
-0.4138391316,
-0.511798799,
-0.4052740335,
-0.7810922265,
0.9619163275,
0.0405071117,
-0.1685552746,
0.2954329848,
-0.0111312773,
0.2986420989,
0.3612514734,
-0.981864512,
-0.2485005856,
0.0931961238,
0.2150688916,
-0.0182785373,
0.0538902245,
0.2469076961,
0.1661509871,
0.2595627308,
-0.2829600275,
0.4412321746,
0.0711514279,
-0.3009803891,
0.0871821865,
0.1773391068,
0.6502825618,
0.8610270619,
-0.3984521627,
-0.0210058428,
0.0600430369,
-0.4737201333,
-0.1114906147,
0.0515670218,
-0.0217563268,
-0.2969475389,
0.6923196912,
0.3711865246,
0.0628185719,
-0.9462470412,
0.3436216414,
0.2070292532,
0.0990036577,
-0.1243393272,
0.6933040619,
-0.2549673915,
0.2036178559,
0.3827803433,
0.0161936395,
0.4426668286,
-0.9460223317,
0.027633125,
0.1808289737,
-0.3192304075,
-0.2003653049,
0.5136122704,
0.1898774356,
-0.3349389136,
0.3640080392,
-0.1081655473,
-0.4427652359,
0.7595248818,
0.2733015716,
0.9224153757,
-0.0261021182,
-0.0447353572,
0.0729779154,
0.2960922122,
-0.1713391393,
0.5251269937,
-0.4976285398,
-0.1915397048,
-0.4068730772,
-0.8034242392,
-0.6996794343,
0.0023696332,
-0.5905394554,
0.4012847543,
-0.4300837219,
0.0899975449,
-0.2713834345,
0.0604129434,
-0.4386262894,
-0.0996693075,
0.4176608026,
1.2216060162,
-0.6483895183,
0.7746814489,
0.8147651553,
-0.4097352028,
-0.1513141841,
0.2743322253,
-0.3192632198,
-0.314871043,
0.4589568377,
0.403432399,
-0.0923038349,
-0.2268404216,
-0.128600046,
-0.503408432,
0.5990294218,
0.372295022,
-0.4122270346,
0.0670532435,
0.6005281806,
0.593722403,
-0.3530518115,
0.6177293658,
0.668341279,
0.5329036713,
-0.3948370218,
-0.9936687946,
-0.310796231,
-0.0869529545,
0.1393355727,
0.1622162461,
-0.6070933938,
0.6717063189,
-0.3898504078,
0.1633799374,
0.3528943658,
0.4621573687,
0.3841373622,
0.5722061992,
0.3721374273,
0.4111875594,
0.3818385005,
-0.1741615236,
1.1953415871,
-0.1508670747,
0.4015368521,
0.7948579192,
-0.5101447105,
1.0449929237,
0.2555153668,
-0.6144044399,
0.0710600317,
0.2682482898,
0.0850106776,
0.3626873493,
0.5686600804,
0.0244119614,
-0.1278241724,
0.1628756374,
-0.7065891027,
0.4700229168,
0.1493127793,
-0.0962008536,
-0.1627309322,
0.0212868713,
-0.2858917117,
0.0058238222,
-0.4391616285,
0.5273801088,
0.1238534898,
-0.6486142874,
0.5726927519,
-0.1580852419,
0.5756824613,
-0.7276316881,
-0.1059735343,
-0.2496082038,
0.6242364049,
-0.2714772224,
-0.8174269199,
0.3263531029,
-0.0554019697,
-0.051608108,
-0.3927210867,
0.4281696379,
-0.0684341565,
-0.372671932,
0.4764784575,
0.0854901522,
0.2364121377,
-0.1586503834,
-0.6394914985,
0.2945193052,
-0.3313668072,
-0.4405453503,
0.2747141123,
0.3999055028,
-0.0617248826,
0.6948782802,
0.5183922052,
0.0618327223,
0.1295486391,
0.0982409418,
0.6699197888,
-0.5760121346,
-0.4078694284,
-0.8701227307,
0.4375855029,
-0.0958765745,
-0.6554072499,
0.6117968559,
0.8203427792,
1.0955899954,
-0.4638799131,
0.4881958067,
-0.3785378635,
0.1170417592,
-0.5021299124,
0.8784518242,
-0.6394620538,
0.1707401574,
-0.6269273162,
-1.3071233034,
-0.4022914469,
0.708473444,
-0.4681564271,
0.0611079931,
0.4865715504,
0.5621094108,
-0.0385875851,
-0.3782010078,
0.5620120764,
-0.1207068935,
0.3348979652,
0.6515672207,
1.1953821182,
-0.4261060357,
0.4823265374,
-0.2207915038,
-0.3704526424,
-0.6955193281,
-0.9835535288,
-0.8005126715,
-0.2776122093,
-0.7129148245,
-0.1323890984,
-0.0209604744,
0.6758067012,
0.7180618048,
-0.6514368057,
-0.5319401026,
-0.3622922897,
0.2704763412,
-0.7939599752,
-0.2372502685,
-0.0582957193,
-0.4739734232,
-0.8215000629,
0.3001132607,
0.4650988281,
-0.4532019794,
-0.4670164585,
-0.2722349167,
0.1462930143,
0.0099722734,
0.5667002797,
0.4363343418,
-0.6611005068,
-0.112947531,
-0.019155208,
-0.0926149935,
-0.0326899588,
0.9482665658,
-0.5625766516,
0.5087488294,
0.8915945888,
0.3769328594,
0.0373926014,
-0.1950524002,
0.702408731,
-0.3830782771,
0.1021163613,
0.4020711482,
0.3132683933,
-0.1218290851,
0.0070025409,
0.6217759252,
0.1885967255,
-0.5249273777,
-1.3055912256,
0.3818002641,
-0.8025892973,
-0.223545,
1.1340774298,
-0.3622867167,
-0.2907155454,
-0.0790557116,
-0.1923490614,
-0.2962005734,
-0.4788031876,
0.5757064819,
0.5205299854,
-0.3792314529,
-0.0026749419,
-0.6211497784,
0.154470861,
0.1592946202,
-1.004278183,
0.2224986404,
0.6329457164,
0.1100240424,
0.1721984893,
0.488534987,
0.0307265129,
0.6304641962,
0.3569211364,
0.3140766621,
-0.3608194888,
-0.3412511647,
-0.2597593367,
0.2446106076,
0.3314006627,
-0.3603348732
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06620v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06620v2
|
TransliCo: A Contrastive Learning Framework to Address the Script Barrier in Multilingual Pretrained Language Models
| 2024-01-12T15:12:48 | 2024-05-23T13:30:09 |
Yihong Liu, Chunlan Ma, Haotian Ye, Hinrich Schütze
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The world's more than 7000 languages are written in at least 293 scripts. Due
to various reasons, many closely related languages use different scripts, which
poses a difficulty for multilingual pretrained language models (mPLMs) in
learning crosslingual knowledge through lexical overlap. As a consequence,
mPLMs are faced with a script barrier: representations from different scripts
are located in different subspaces, which can result in crosslingual transfer
involving languages of different scripts performing suboptimally. To address
this problem, we propose TransliCo, a framework that optimizes the
Transliteration Contrastive Modeling (TCM) objective to fine-tune an mPLM by
contrasting sentences in its training data and their transliterations in a
unified script (in our case Latin), which enhances uniformity in the
representation space for different scripts. Using Glot500-m, an mPLM pretrained
on over 500 languages, as our source model, we fine-tune it on a small portion
(5%) of its training data, and refer to the resulting model as Furina. We show
that Furina not only better aligns representations from distinct scripts but
also outperforms the original Glot500-m on various zero-shot crosslingual
transfer tasks. Additionally, we achieve consistent improvement in a case study
on the Indic group where the languages exhibit areal features but use different
scripts. We make our code and models publicly available.
|
[
-0.2040451169,
0.1352478713,
0.3341657817,
0.1439507157,
-0.143566981,
0.450956434,
-0.2423922122,
-0.3599185646,
0.1466789693,
0.4555330276,
-0.8009482622,
-0.8014407754,
-0.5320580006,
0.3848991394,
-0.1538631469,
0.8978215456,
-0.218373701,
0.3246693015,
-0.0886034966,
-0.3204136491,
-0.0283258967,
-0.3920903504,
-0.0485920832,
-0.1689893156,
0.5280394554,
0.5326922536,
0.622013092,
0.6273878813,
0.6999549866,
0.3647627532,
0.2535939515,
0.0915087983,
-0.3334079385,
0.0573145747,
-0.4149726331,
-0.6832355857,
-0.0413657129,
-0.149782896,
0.6668274999,
1.0352009535,
-0.0614882968,
0.0122644259,
-0.0918793082,
0.4023398161,
-0.7062476873,
-0.1861652136,
-0.6148805618,
0.3279494643,
-0.4069108963,
0.0554540083,
-0.3191194534,
-0.1641888022,
0.1057904735,
-0.8434680104,
0.3962261081,
-0.1137359962,
0.845089972,
0.2321107984,
-0.1842962354,
0.1448603272,
-0.8190742731,
0.9666056037,
-0.669877708,
0.5006674528,
0.3065570891,
0.3353702724,
0.1789025962,
-0.6071657538,
-0.4311941862,
-0.1961299628,
-0.3532241285,
-0.0699983165,
-0.1985156685,
-0.1630462706,
0.1248083189,
0.0960049108,
-0.9431390166,
0.1259323508,
-0.5265543461,
-0.4782066047,
0.172969088,
0.0821163282,
0.429366082,
0.1206978858,
-0.3940575123,
-0.3898550272,
-0.6918460131,
-0.3557623327,
0.6021766663,
0.5885856748,
-0.2918447852,
0.1182244048,
-0.0349269882,
0.4653925896,
-0.032774061,
-0.0761437118,
0.6304427981,
-0.2539249361,
-0.0780789107,
-0.1027994677,
0.8124711514,
0.1660598367,
0.215671137,
-0.255107224,
-0.011735376,
0.0391559936,
0.2169692665,
-0.6470392942,
-0.0614087619,
0.0964437425,
-0.2501277924,
-0.0983393416,
0.0787861496,
-0.9533078074,
-0.367277801,
-0.3338790238,
0.3776809275,
-0.4529080093,
-0.446234256,
-0.1360194832,
0.0823422447,
0.1819576621,
0.1953318566,
-0.879427135,
0.3308247626,
0.4816987216,
1.0001331568,
-0.3691859543,
-0.7638643384,
-0.7069139481,
0.1730043143,
-0.2268036902,
0.7561824322,
-0.863104701,
-0.3269231021,
0.0943818912,
0.1621143818,
-0.3416085243,
-0.6434152722,
0.1784146875,
-0.1821652651,
0.4701357782,
0.0792725012,
-0.1644858122,
-0.1567486525,
0.0415105484,
-0.8384653926,
0.7580057383,
0.439936161,
-0.7086034417,
0.0679601803,
-0.4336519837,
-0.4603019655,
-0.1569033861,
-0.0724782571,
-0.3730977178,
-0.025533352,
0.0794141442,
-0.0069820597,
-0.3351159096,
0.1266284287,
-0.315277338,
-0.4851136506,
0.0628399327,
-0.0612887293,
0.5260124803,
0.4157836437,
-0.2897820473,
0.6058910489,
-0.7805428505,
-0.106534183,
-0.1870512962,
-0.0206911769,
-0.4684824944,
-0.4386419654,
0.1420364082,
0.5551061034,
-0.0372481719,
-0.3874417245,
-0.0513628051,
-0.4969521761,
0.2130925506,
0.6105358601,
-0.4941954911,
0.632288456,
-0.2877667248,
0.865886867,
0.3899267614,
0.268819809,
-0.2091354579,
0.1364609599,
-0.8167506456,
-0.1819023639,
0.5883858204,
0.4946412742,
-0.8581392169,
0.0723216608,
-0.2146460861,
-0.481716007,
-0.8259804249,
0.308206439,
0.5274386406,
0.5048798919,
0.4270789921,
-0.3273473382,
-0.5909780264,
-0.9919735789,
-0.1614902318,
0.0425734259,
-0.1868751347,
-0.0812300667,
0.446010381,
-0.2950757146,
0.4031087458,
-0.2378763556,
-0.3041435182,
-0.5218740702,
0.1844853312,
0.2177174985,
0.7155377865,
0.5224458575,
-0.7483561039,
-0.8591431975,
0.2389699966,
-0.372926265,
-0.390407145,
-0.0412734747,
-0.5338683724,
0.2134903222,
0.6719475389,
-0.3146559894,
0.1000245586,
0.77327317,
-0.0225631613,
0.3743755221,
-0.2055859715,
0.1917282343,
-1.2158937454,
0.5157526731,
-0.0739479437,
-0.2422098666,
-0.780382216,
0.1297712773,
0.0351769775,
-0.2879832387,
-0.7522230148,
0.4687346518,
-0.236913383,
0.0284516905,
-0.1088269353,
0.0552721657,
0.0264430158,
0.8485528827,
0.3913081288,
0.8112691045,
0.5776324272,
-0.4172652662,
0.0657394528,
0.0021789439,
-0.1008439586,
0.4729342759,
-0.5276560783,
0.2259276658,
0.060310211,
0.1569867879,
-0.8796237111,
-0.1346495748,
0.4294166267,
-0.1799748689,
0.2727194428,
-0.1767084152,
-0.149592787,
0.0547184497,
-0.3916601539,
0.6218033433,
0.3994266093,
-0.3823591769,
0.7178273797,
0.181120649,
-0.2053328007,
-0.8115916848,
-0.4989948869,
-0.1561003327,
-0.3953332305,
-0.3057971597,
0.5189245343,
-0.0715744495,
-0.179464668,
-0.1878067851,
-0.0210463144,
-0.1328616291,
-0.1829123497,
0.0657353401,
0.3390157521,
-0.1799662262,
0.3185426295,
0.0058281673,
-0.1618570387,
-0.2724470496,
-0.4472409189,
0.8072053194,
0.0844704583,
-0.3767286539,
-0.2501283586,
0.5221625566,
0.528180182,
-0.4428742826,
0.7169398069,
0.7586097121,
-0.1934438795,
-0.2007772326,
-0.3263631761,
0.0991673842,
-0.4146989286,
0.3232406378,
-0.3545819223,
-0.659940362,
0.8067420721,
-0.3569658399,
-0.151623711,
0.5792427063,
0.2858151793,
0.203759715,
0.7019390464,
0.9832363129,
-0.0767364278,
0.6265224814,
-0.1239604801,
-0.348100692,
-0.6525196433,
-0.323738575,
-0.7541784048,
-0.2085209042,
-0.7267683744,
-0.7083807588,
0.1916752011,
-0.1500284225,
-0.3159385026,
0.4703159332,
-0.1687799394,
0.6336417198,
0.6654578447,
-0.0214148369,
0.3918591142,
0.1555689573,
-0.5460563898,
-0.2062504292,
-0.6645589471,
-0.2429079413,
1.139008522,
0.0660709888,
0.9240728021,
0.2277662754,
0.6495282054,
0.2627469301,
0.3431075513,
-0.2510552406,
0.263222605,
-0.4487943947,
-0.4173211455,
-0.1123761386,
-0.5388258696,
-0.8076614738,
0.4265838861,
-0.1621941179,
-0.6685096025,
0.4076657295,
-0.0568633154,
-0.158247292,
0.1663433909,
-0.6332810521,
1.1174449921,
-0.0606091991,
-0.6714472771,
-0.231826365,
-1.171647191,
0.2552848458,
-0.3673896194,
0.0971555635,
0.0371010974,
-0.0045565958,
0.5221371055,
-0.5242493153,
0.7974196076,
0.2202458531,
-0.1718592495,
-0.0102442782,
0.2398402393,
0.2013610899,
-0.4152654111,
-0.0932190716,
0.2858328819,
-0.016579695,
-0.3173019886,
-0.4405730069,
0.5274781585,
-0.8048327565,
-0.5021942854,
-0.4719948769,
-0.5258668065,
-0.3370929062,
0.2906162143,
0.4211052358,
0.2832683623,
-0.2543010712,
-0.1386070698,
0.5319111347,
-0.6399818063,
0.2078107595,
0.7856318951,
-0.3143640757,
-0.4935969114,
1.0295577049,
-0.3152125478,
0.6189569831,
0.761086762,
0.0024122398,
-0.3917417526,
-0.3416377306,
-0.4640480876,
0.4443401992,
-0.8342362642,
-0.3519299924,
-0.4060738087,
-0.1692688316,
-0.4999330342,
-0.0477636606,
-0.3239727318,
-0.3495882154,
-0.0135051105,
0.1523902267,
-0.0218017101,
0.5661554337,
-0.3539321125,
0.3471836448,
-0.8988398314,
0.2836205661,
-0.0036756075,
0.4642046094,
-0.2073927373,
-0.6887944937,
-0.3705711067,
-0.0532848015,
-0.2499502152,
-0.7007259727,
0.5652297735,
0.2359103411,
0.5543041825,
0.1880280972,
0.0469039865,
0.7162591219,
-0.5533680916,
0.2932058573,
0.2990574837,
-1.1697505713,
0.5930022001,
-0.233974427,
0.5245718956,
0.7729392648,
0.6208420992,
-0.8070017099,
-0.5938062072,
-0.4805780947,
-0.6924158335,
0.9999678731,
0.1774870008,
0.0313680284,
0.3555269539,
-0.0395311154,
0.5804767013,
0.2745823264,
-0.9032036066,
0.075647071,
-0.267465502,
-0.5141484737,
-0.1640688032,
0.3320270479,
-0.169558242,
-0.1427697092,
0.5214053392,
-0.2549161911,
0.0073360521,
0.0800769106,
-0.4592197239,
-0.3350296021,
0.2607077062,
0.6920852065,
0.7287672758,
-0.1492698044,
0.2656392157,
0.1394990385,
-0.498703748,
0.169767946,
0.3121140897,
-0.0166739561,
0.1505879313,
0.6946742535,
0.7114846706,
0.1133142114,
-0.8591737151,
0.3177158833,
0.0496048965,
-0.1370720714,
0.1770427525,
0.004649499,
-0.0219028499,
0.2341688126,
0.1090370119,
0.0847451016,
0.139564395,
-0.6367221475,
0.1694992334,
0.2124037892,
-0.3162904978,
-0.3388122916,
0.6139181852,
0.3715294302,
-0.1663008481,
0.5770783424,
0.0777019188,
-0.7640665174,
0.6788833141,
0.4723626375,
0.8700121641,
-0.6282530427,
0.4846251905,
0.3785907626,
0.2605357766,
0.0387664884,
-0.0453149863,
-0.0392062292,
-0.5684252381,
-0.3877819479,
-0.6971797347,
-0.7445068955,
0.1631659269,
-0.4367583096,
0.3586318493,
-0.3479579687,
0.2288235128,
-0.003470663,
-0.1352336854,
-0.6751940846,
0.0307320263,
0.1963080764,
0.7525337934,
-0.9814963341,
1.0230876207,
0.4744295478,
-0.5917799473,
-0.6418604255,
0.2787175477,
-0.1505089402,
-0.6609660983,
0.6958856583,
0.2608833015,
-0.4280009866,
-0.2788051963,
-0.2860241234,
-0.7544383407,
0.8416751027,
0.8012028933,
-0.7901968956,
0.1081766784,
0.5915648937,
0.8103260398,
-0.5921092629,
0.1720853597,
0.3918049932,
0.3120772541,
0.2841735184,
-0.9789174795,
0.0844415799,
-0.3606743813,
-0.1430377364,
0.175107196,
-0.6873484254,
0.8424067497,
-0.2423829585,
-0.3066280484,
0.2185350657,
0.3412517309,
-0.0052973568,
0.1920105815,
0.4371770322,
0.2248913348,
0.5500341058,
-0.0232943911,
0.7460755706,
-0.3123971224,
0.1888015419,
1.1719104052,
-0.5352346301,
0.7103247643,
0.3849154115,
-0.2470071763,
0.7360387444,
0.618357718,
0.0405633859,
0.6416004896,
0.2852852643,
-0.1866289079,
-0.4933307469,
-0.3588124812,
-0.4543448091,
0.4778411388,
0.1270515621,
-0.4574451149,
-0.3433612287,
0.160444513,
-0.1443320811,
0.3719091713,
-0.1517180651,
0.59044981,
-0.0672476813,
-0.796387732,
0.5093051791,
-0.0425974838,
0.4679563046,
-1.072988987,
-0.1586858183,
-0.6966620088,
0.4054681957,
-0.0686036199,
-0.4044690728,
0.33277753,
0.101200372,
0.0447736233,
-0.0584979616,
0.5578365922,
-0.968965888,
-0.7053588629,
0.435557127,
0.630845964,
0.0824304223,
0.1632250994,
-0.6621438265,
0.2291183025,
-0.0533406027,
0.3480903506,
0.4585807621,
0.4074297547,
-0.1066307798,
0.6220946908,
0.4899374843,
-0.0638989508,
-0.3467911184,
0.4774277508,
0.9237828851,
-0.6604926586,
-0.563911438,
-0.8118975759,
0.2910059392,
-0.0258267727,
-0.2809564173,
0.6781292558,
0.6342484355,
0.974499166,
-0.2179386616,
0.5660263896,
0.2918638587,
0.5708265901,
-0.5309613943,
0.4568418264,
-0.6524312496,
0.293392092,
-0.5476770997,
-0.9371511936,
-0.5263376832,
0.5126831532,
-0.0637140423,
0.0635283068,
0.9090973139,
0.9009225368,
-0.235489592,
-0.3504905105,
0.3622460365,
-0.1282387227,
0.0240469035,
0.9618139267,
0.906883955,
-0.3122257292,
0.914657712,
-0.2532083094,
0.1644607782,
0.0311702285,
-0.7040265799,
-0.8277258277,
-0.6347811818,
-0.2666081488,
-0.2565765381,
0.1711543053,
1.0260562897,
0.6510410309,
-0.8811761737,
-0.5447767377,
0.0051078671,
0.2871015966,
-0.1466964781,
-0.1085873619,
0.3020315766,
-0.3554771245,
-1.0792722702,
0.1164940074,
0.2261128873,
0.1307282746,
-0.3979120553,
-0.1410049051,
-0.3904925287,
-0.0678038821,
0.1106217727,
0.2969394922,
-0.3576479554,
-0.0769357532,
0.0887436271,
-0.3115748763,
0.2346562147,
1.0380132198,
-0.7849101424,
0.356960237,
0.4050862193,
0.3660038114,
0.4093811512,
-0.2321323752,
0.8992210627,
-0.835370183,
0.3206700087,
0.0019818712,
0.2127767503,
0.6385094523,
-0.1021989956,
0.8172079325,
0.3738588691,
0.0149671873,
-0.7026235461,
0.1389910579,
-0.7461879253,
-0.5829154253,
1.096873045,
-0.2737147212,
-0.1101474389,
0.0053925952,
-0.1802190691,
0.377561003,
-0.0898822695,
0.6213203669,
0.6665728092,
0.1402178407,
-0.0897775665,
-0.1311914474,
0.6849489808,
0.4669809639,
-0.9237238169,
0.1427436024,
0.3306337595,
0.420799315,
0.3992955983,
0.397308737,
-0.1090681627,
0.2792718709,
0.1304831207,
0.1875692904,
0.0763154998,
-0.5866956115,
-0.5217811465,
0.0266772024,
-0.1723919809,
-0.1373403221
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06603v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06603v1
|
Mutual Enhancement of Large Language and Reinforcement Learning Models through Bi-Directional Feedback Mechanisms: A Case Study
| 2024-01-12T14:35:57 | 2024-01-12T14:35:57 |
Shangding Gu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities for
reinforcement learning (RL) models, such as planning and reasoning
capabilities. However, the problems of LLMs and RL model collaboration still
need to be solved. In this study, we employ a teacher-student learning
framework to tackle these problems, specifically by offering feedback for LLMs
using RL models and providing high-level information for RL models with LLMs in
a cooperative multi-agent setting. Within this framework, the LLM acts as a
teacher, while the RL model acts as a student. The two agents cooperatively
assist each other through a process of recursive help, such as "I help you help
I help." The LLM agent supplies abstract information to the RL agent, enabling
efficient exploration and policy improvement. In turn, the RL agent offers
feedback to the LLM agent, providing valuable, real-time information that helps
generate more useful tokens. This bi-directional feedback loop promotes
optimization, exploration, and mutual improvement for both agents, enabling
them to accomplish increasingly challenging tasks. Remarkably, we propose a
practical algorithm to address the problem and conduct empirical experiments to
evaluate the effectiveness of our method.
|
[
-0.3755606413,
-0.7993654609,
0.5899486542,
0.3147138953,
0.0099700997,
0.4549591243,
-0.7558042407,
-0.2653861642,
0.0279076193,
0.4590149522,
-0.6914259791,
-0.4044476748,
-0.3173619509,
0.0616848655,
0.0320268087,
1.1551921368,
-0.0103726145,
0.4955101013,
-0.3326348066,
-0.104092747,
-0.7675072551,
-0.4406660795,
-0.9800698161,
-0.6330195665,
0.9543583393,
0.8165005445,
0.6224209666,
0.0659720898,
0.1690774262,
0.4269605875,
0.1108172759,
0.3623292744,
-0.613547802,
0.3556054831,
-0.6466030478,
-0.3067538142,
-0.3454965949,
-0.0043162513,
0.8626077771,
0.7666170001,
-0.3475375175,
-0.1483128667,
0.3834814131,
0.5902364254,
-0.32212466,
0.2838664055,
-0.1238332912,
0.0237441622,
0.2451293319,
-0.109127827,
-0.6190401912,
-0.3851978183,
0.3938065171,
-0.6126840115,
-0.1088327542,
-0.1198680177,
0.6090574861,
0.0389490165,
-0.3661453128,
-0.2482757866,
-0.9681039453,
0.8876681328,
-0.4419037998,
0.4124792814,
0.2800423801,
0.3265247047,
-0.4042282999,
-0.4110416174,
-0.5274497867,
-0.2636547685,
0.0017256278,
0.1915138364,
0.1731212586,
0.1189704016,
0.0045652445,
-0.1576540172,
-0.1649785489,
0.2370197028,
-0.2737438381,
-0.337669909,
0.5871146321,
0.1033069491,
0.235195443,
0.2012390196,
-0.4608063996,
-0.4405218661,
-0.6126343012,
0.3389573097,
0.2994008958,
0.3933258653,
-0.1038459465,
0.4538331926,
-0.051797241,
0.4658391476,
-0.1217059121,
0.0183955692,
0.094341889,
-0.5440580845,
0.1845299453,
-0.1940017194,
0.6073829532,
0.3072853684,
0.1309612989,
-0.4356561601,
-0.518299222,
0.0408183336,
-0.0630790591,
-0.6575532556,
0.0938262045,
-0.132811144,
-0.2054140568,
-0.0865865201,
0.1815664023,
-0.9496619701,
-0.3134127557,
-0.6344125271,
0.7617117763,
-0.1127102375,
-0.6828520894,
0.0065750228,
-0.1793119758,
0.2119700909,
0.3944229484,
-0.7215446234,
0.3140927255,
0.8575841188,
0.7198257446,
-0.0300248619,
-0.8061870337,
-1.0264686346,
0.2519910634,
-0.1392014921,
0.5442954898,
-0.7113069296,
-0.4662499428,
0.1581889242,
0.0112155788,
-0.0246986542,
-0.4516217411,
0.0303925928,
-0.5837592483,
0.3295805156,
-0.4279353321,
-0.3257308006,
-0.1897136122,
0.375566572,
-0.4989163876,
0.8239448071,
-0.0081959506,
-0.5315362215,
-0.0085468953,
-0.6284040213,
-0.2670856416,
0.0471588001,
-0.4094773233,
-0.5018105507,
-0.2080632299,
0.123452805,
0.3630173504,
-0.2004435956,
0.3591271341,
-0.457436502,
-0.2758454084,
0.2882378995,
-0.2624106705,
0.4620252252,
-0.2139792293,
-0.3529998064,
0.6568627954,
-0.4873599708,
-0.0642063916,
0.2753468156,
-0.4843933582,
-0.288251251,
-0.1202752963,
-0.1943261623,
0.1882249117,
0.2786708474,
-0.3078371584,
0.435493499,
-0.2643367052,
0.2544580996,
0.973480463,
0.1459445059,
0.558570087,
-0.5509881973,
0.5893034339,
-0.0388524607,
0.1181668267,
0.0417374037,
-0.1202059463,
-0.6565337777,
-0.1167150661,
0.2334767431,
0.206258446,
-1.1965624094,
-0.0398064628,
-0.0048456118,
-0.2222430855,
-0.2666417062,
0.3644291162,
0.6321712732,
0.3020766377,
0.266787827,
-0.4718616009,
-0.4058824182,
-0.4292003512,
-0.1671660841,
-0.2264947295,
0.1364379823,
0.4244379997,
0.2723715603,
-0.1739303917,
0.827213943,
-0.1818515658,
-0.1255925298,
-0.4890315235,
0.200731501,
-0.0374653712,
0.3210532367,
0.288061589,
-0.5200974941,
-0.6174398661,
-0.067410782,
-0.5599282384,
-0.0390423797,
-0.0336015821,
-0.2604767382,
0.2383695841,
0.3595111668,
-0.2544205487,
0.2206355035,
0.595471859,
-0.5593878031,
0.8019120693,
-0.5476053357,
-0.1601381898,
-0.7278955579,
-0.3070629835,
-0.1412769556,
-0.2791820168,
-0.5057069063,
0.0399802886,
-0.2741979063,
0.1211464331,
-0.0978294685,
0.4631613791,
-0.503765285,
-0.3456738889,
-0.408741504,
0.5592167377,
-0.0683570728,
0.7844048738,
0.2498956621,
0.6803642511,
0.7078487277,
-0.5861474872,
0.5089485645,
-0.0525438413,
0.0926167145,
0.5910844803,
-0.5957564712,
0.2641021013,
-0.1030372009,
0.4080583751,
-0.6596092582,
0.0208442919,
0.4140777886,
-0.3302396834,
0.0917338729,
-0.053766001,
-0.4793075323,
-0.1443783492,
-0.4014233351,
0.2714872062,
-0.0062998277,
-0.8944342732,
0.6981554627,
0.2046325952,
-0.2868131995,
-0.7068334222,
-0.1058213413,
-0.0913050398,
0.1351845562,
-0.5426232219,
0.0120820962,
-0.1684578955,
-0.1965328008,
0.2312866002,
0.1211569458,
0.1132899076,
0.1186297014,
0.2838940918,
0.5508512855,
0.0126794726,
0.345790863,
-0.0212691613,
-0.2062362432,
0.2858432233,
-0.2992573977,
0.7678003907,
-0.3132714033,
-0.382286787,
-0.2709818184,
0.2186338305,
0.5030953884,
-0.4333081543,
0.8097333908,
0.6596069336,
0.0588071197,
-0.6761382222,
-0.2753593028,
-0.7308665514,
-0.5115486979,
0.4635303915,
-0.2434931397,
-0.8868309259,
0.2244294584,
-0.3033906221,
0.12583296,
-0.1764853895,
0.6945828199,
0.189228192,
0.9625508189,
0.7071120739,
-0.1540793926,
0.6620922089,
-0.4776964188,
0.0852283239,
-0.76666224,
-0.7675828338,
-0.5661135912,
-0.209029451,
-0.1871875972,
-0.4667181671,
0.3274233043,
0.0728890374,
-0.1881015152,
0.0859651864,
-0.2574104965,
0.6049832702,
0.7988368869,
0.2861725986,
0.3171544671,
-0.0277712662,
-0.6386991739,
0.2226684541,
-0.7906169295,
-0.1632997543,
0.9622175694,
0.3578180373,
0.6339899898,
0.4124343991,
0.8340632319,
-0.0013989287,
0.2504065037,
-0.6388463378,
0.7322072983,
0.3492386639,
-0.1256890297,
-0.5895429254,
-0.716148138,
-0.9275556207,
0.4822002351,
-0.310264498,
-0.3827345371,
-0.0766778365,
-0.10347794,
-0.072153151,
0.2708782256,
-0.6418075562,
0.7203212976,
-0.2332255393,
-1.0699615479,
-0.8368586898,
-0.499099791,
0.0019464529,
0.1477681398,
0.4477376044,
0.2810937166,
0.1038658842,
0.7830467224,
-0.6342279911,
1.040542841,
-0.5227460861,
-0.3012624085,
0.2101997733,
0.0955709144,
0.8164958358,
0.1784626395,
0.159309864,
-0.238263607,
-0.0405194759,
-0.471082896,
-0.8207501173,
0.758572042,
-1.1052029133,
-0.6337571144,
-0.3369009793,
-0.7037038207,
-0.4440032244,
0.1600428075,
-0.482919991,
0.4142362177,
0.1271428317,
-0.0294088442,
0.4621813595,
-0.194154501,
0.7005153298,
0.9955623746,
-0.7515608668,
-0.4374993145,
1.1306626797,
-0.0485332534,
0.4191465974,
0.0891270936,
0.4741295874,
-0.4106282294,
-0.2860731483,
-0.283393234,
0.6126759648,
-0.6130464673,
0.0727807358,
-0.2712133527,
-0.1497054994,
-0.2392987013,
-0.0895242691,
-0.2119178325,
-0.1272677034,
-0.0170698594,
-0.0580840111,
0.1502833664,
1.0415686369,
-0.4928064346,
0.0744017586,
-0.7255371213,
-0.2122197896,
0.563534379,
0.3544202447,
0.5887324214,
-0.2748054862,
-0.4639540017,
0.0800290778,
-0.297328949,
-0.7669283152,
0.1130437851,
-0.0846685469,
0.4182777405,
0.3871184289,
0.0985663682,
0.4134190977,
-0.1965973377,
0.5684449673,
0.2647924125,
-0.9009444118,
0.3121654093,
-0.1428966075,
0.0786091462,
0.247078523,
0.2491917461,
-0.7047947049,
-0.531948626,
-0.342535466,
-0.6128587127,
0.8910532594,
-0.214340359,
-0.1577161252,
0.3732000887,
0.230510205,
0.0536414236,
0.0837132037,
-0.9609225392,
-0.05866969,
-0.079987824,
-0.0358529203,
-0.1615993083,
-0.0796878487,
-0.1968806535,
-0.2245027721,
0.8711711168,
-0.0673460364,
-0.1664222181,
0.1822248101,
0.0123313321,
-0.3179182112,
0.4095614851,
0.5050264001,
0.5129623413,
0.2001980543,
0.2673148513,
0.1873411387,
-0.2074722797,
0.213616997,
-0.1205373332,
-0.0546926409,
-0.1683953404,
0.362623781,
0.7619481683,
0.3078472018,
-0.7269883156,
0.6425035,
-0.2735235691,
-0.2104626596,
-0.2037896812,
0.1221899614,
0.0569259636,
0.7725145817,
0.1662131697,
-0.1164415181,
-0.3289282322,
-0.6853976846,
0.2712338269,
0.6581703424,
-0.4501668215,
-0.4441698492,
0.0881096497,
0.3602531254,
-0.5777260661,
0.5160204768,
-0.1992218494,
-0.9524861574,
0.5487366915,
0.7124630213,
0.5701563954,
-0.2658336163,
0.6562634706,
0.2975029051,
0.1201696396,
-0.0709278807,
0.1225327998,
-0.401438117,
-0.6954123378,
-0.6203764677,
-0.2364264578,
-0.7960073948,
-0.1727140099,
-0.6371989846,
0.2600142658,
-0.5659069419,
0.1507246494,
-0.3142772913,
0.4443529844,
-0.3702384531,
-0.3557950556,
-0.1220003217,
0.3540983796,
-0.7073954344,
1.0962821245,
0.8332300782,
-0.6942702532,
-1.3329838514,
-0.0127223572,
-0.1684808731,
-0.6831639409,
0.9138660431,
0.0568512157,
-0.4191570282,
0.0452450961,
-0.4461952746,
-0.4382562637,
1.0583456755,
0.0566734672,
-0.9714263082,
-0.0828789026,
0.2675556242,
0.5575187802,
-0.2570718527,
0.4373494387,
0.1359233409,
0.4817880392,
0.1477615982,
-0.8486730456,
0.0829753652,
0.1423338205,
-0.134069249,
0.3004122972,
-0.969219625,
0.7101665139,
-0.4432164133,
-0.0572741963,
-0.1696609855,
0.7303407192,
0.3342091739,
0.6358086467,
0.8853920698,
0.4601304531,
0.8555096984,
0.3175488114,
0.617439568,
-0.2588262856,
0.5586002469,
1.2823706865,
-0.3456136882,
0.7986749411,
0.504139185,
-0.0360507816,
0.6763591766,
0.2209754288,
0.125345394,
0.5759628415,
0.3577511311,
-0.6386355162,
-0.2985119224,
-0.3679068685,
-0.2264182568,
-0.0052083903,
0.214078024,
0.0487568825,
-0.3469537795,
0.3536189497,
-0.0050685504,
0.3016051352,
-0.4490631223,
0.8338327408,
-0.0840110406,
-1.0321079493,
0.1894043535,
0.1243206933,
0.4738160968,
-0.4608438611,
-0.2847138643,
-0.4051849842,
0.3939735293,
-0.2257262468,
-0.5544266105,
0.0269715954,
-0.1314792186,
-0.1216233447,
-0.0970610306,
0.6113910675,
-0.9960170388,
-0.0792814866,
0.8749451637,
0.4366126955,
-0.1435256153,
0.3490112722,
-0.4999912381,
0.2535557747,
-0.0442826897,
0.154777348,
0.5224006772,
0.4701598883,
0.1002045721,
0.7639114261,
0.7840056419,
0.3574897647,
-0.0224317666,
0.2546797395,
1.0597361326,
-0.4317097962,
-0.3807920218,
-0.7468662262,
0.1047042087,
-0.0649215207,
0.1986816972,
0.8049550056,
0.3352251351,
1.2107983828,
0.1385454237,
0.6657307744,
0.2925662994,
0.5527236462,
-0.4487549365,
0.448990792,
-0.4397012293,
0.6315000057,
-0.0853443667,
-0.9610724449,
-0.0131054325,
0.579246521,
-0.4339851141,
-0.0014590138,
0.6427187324,
0.9636377692,
0.2295487672,
0.0917638242,
0.2201978266,
0.3062304258,
0.5253377557,
0.7101377249,
1.1277645826,
-0.0014325228,
0.6717418432,
-0.4186031818,
-0.3352787793,
-0.2276766896,
-0.4554276466,
-1.2238078117,
-0.5280926824,
-0.2990278006,
-0.6737106442,
0.3064334989,
1.3093022108,
0.5690039396,
-0.5137608051,
-0.5301527977,
-0.2500665486,
0.6312457919,
-0.2482097745,
-0.276545465,
0.2534229755,
-0.5279505253,
-0.7228778601,
0.4891402423,
0.1562731266,
-0.2007441968,
-0.8101901412,
-0.871663332,
-0.1689658463,
0.0493189096,
0.4584439695,
0.3452017009,
-0.4468848705,
-0.330509752,
-0.2392118275,
-0.0432633795,
-0.3110242486,
0.8965344429,
-0.7380300164,
0.40125072,
0.3215246797,
0.8490917087,
0.39438954,
-0.26814273,
0.561815083,
-0.6624728441,
0.0969232693,
0.0584737062,
0.0828394592,
0.127546519,
-0.077392213,
0.4426198006,
0.3436839283,
-0.8211237788,
-0.8982623219,
0.2481994629,
-0.7055177689,
-0.2846347392,
1.071095109,
-0.3630164862,
-0.2513711751,
-0.0883192718,
-0.3709685206,
0.300417155,
-0.5913163424,
0.6684961319,
0.7895784378,
0.1466252655,
-0.3481687903,
-0.0272597317,
0.165791288,
0.7449755669,
-0.6788533926,
-0.0516544059,
0.528531611,
0.2641378641,
-0.021430051,
0.3435292244,
0.1538824439,
0.2589910626,
-0.2222608179,
0.1051565111,
-0.3018250167,
-0.7923571467,
-0.5247659683,
0.1133000925,
0.3590948284,
-0.0970176831
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06591v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06591v1
|
Prometheus-Vision: Vision-Language Model as a Judge for Fine-Grained Evaluation
| 2024-01-12T14:19:23 | 2024-01-12T14:19:23 |
Seongyun Lee, Seungone Kim, Sue Hyun Park, Geewook Kim, Minjoon Seo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Assessing long-form responses generated by Vision-Language Models (VLMs) is
challenging. It not only requires checking whether the VLM follows the given
instruction but also verifying whether the text output is properly grounded on
the given image. Inspired by the recent approach of evaluating LMs with LMs, in
this work, we propose to evaluate VLMs with VLMs. For this purpose, we present
a new feedback dataset called the Perception Collection, encompassing 15K
customized score rubrics that users might care about during assessment. Using
the Perception Collection, we train Prometheus-Vision, the first open-source
VLM evaluator model that can understand the user-defined score criteria during
evaluation. Prometheus-Vision shows the highest Pearson correlation with human
evaluators and GPT-4V among open-source models, showing its effectiveness for
transparent and accessible evaluation of VLMs. We open-source our code,
dataset, and model at https://github.com/kaistAI/prometheus-vision
|
[
-0.4902555943,
-0.4544116557,
0.8058698773,
-0.0056813466,
-0.405000329,
-0.248832792,
-0.3354483843,
-0.6665582657,
-0.1000214666,
0.7558438182,
-0.3895545304,
-0.7058269978,
-0.3597011864,
-0.2256131321,
-0.5432855487,
0.999702692,
0.107849136,
0.1897339374,
-0.3476955593,
-0.4069060683,
-0.4553848505,
-0.2659357488,
-0.4537913799,
-0.425267756,
0.5738688707,
0.0767872259,
0.674544096,
0.2428041697,
0.8620503545,
0.2892117798,
-0.0787973553,
0.2152874321,
-0.5071721673,
-0.3148893118,
-0.5736726522,
-0.2316544354,
-0.3929468691,
0.043889828,
0.4547513127,
0.442019701,
-0.0931746736,
0.6896778941,
0.2691952288,
0.6843326688,
-0.7604353428,
0.1259609461,
-0.3865322471,
0.2677655816,
-0.2175725549,
-0.1179284751,
-0.6041095257,
-0.405608058,
0.4404196143,
-0.5421616435,
-0.0915812179,
0.1431769878,
0.8661538363,
0.0462457351,
-0.095557116,
0.0058256821,
-0.9259704947,
1.1030935049,
-0.4988220036,
0.6532154679,
0.3859792948,
0.6951447129,
0.2162782699,
-0.8425502181,
-0.5321674347,
-0.5611214638,
0.0202823542,
0.52488029,
-0.0862109289,
-0.0490303226,
-0.0919521898,
0.6536467075,
-0.653306663,
0.2408432066,
-0.5435820222,
-0.0312174596,
0.5090914965,
0.3496246338,
-0.1427150369,
-0.3485866189,
-0.6067103148,
-0.1893182844,
-0.1839357316,
0.1306630075,
0.0149222156,
0.2581375837,
-0.3461460173,
0.7501366138,
-0.4116543531,
1.0646696091,
-0.1194767803,
0.1988157034,
0.4845224917,
-0.3040704727,
-0.622151494,
-0.4491496086,
0.9271945953,
0.8859269023,
0.2458338439,
0.1114315838,
-0.5048091412,
0.3457868993,
0.6612600684,
-0.6216313243,
0.0097508989,
0.2983202636,
-0.6869237423,
-0.6543081403,
-0.0435464308,
-0.8445783854,
-0.8278341293,
-0.7084014416,
0.7261915803,
-0.3858654201,
0.0334736109,
0.4028030634,
0.0319823064,
0.4429445267,
0.744702816,
-0.3695796728,
0.4276645184,
0.5925424099,
0.6603555679,
-0.2994209528,
-0.3090049922,
-0.7365267873,
-0.3783147931,
-0.2777048647,
0.8601722717,
-0.5673984885,
-0.2631996274,
0.0027306997,
-0.2386142313,
0.1710453629,
-0.4706282318,
0.6932545304,
-0.2724320889,
0.4314186573,
-0.1008778438,
-0.6522099376,
-0.0566993281,
0.5585799813,
-0.5678533316,
0.874343574,
0.4863830209,
-0.6590750813,
0.4535827041,
-0.9107551575,
0.1414946914,
0.5388860703,
-0.5116977692,
-0.3714083433,
0.2918184698,
0.1307817847,
0.2695839405,
-0.3432429433,
-0.0271843784,
-0.3929446042,
-0.2567255199,
0.1971285045,
-0.4012368321,
0.4219753742,
0.436167866,
-0.2979740798,
0.432605952,
-1.0011280775,
0.3121465445,
0.0357562378,
-0.2243966609,
-0.385251224,
0.2258470058,
0.2329676598,
0.0133834137,
0.3726156354,
-0.5536336303,
-0.0739193037,
-0.354796052,
-0.0141070616,
0.8479032516,
-0.2713992,
0.1633710116,
-0.1449326426,
0.3002198637,
0.0091914628,
0.7923715711,
-0.0088983709,
-0.2799806595,
-0.8655272126,
0.028960472,
0.0745446309,
0.2386335135,
-0.71000278,
0.1783013791,
-0.3418852091,
-0.8555929661,
-0.4249343276,
0.0716882795,
0.6029756069,
0.4627194703,
0.3824732602,
-0.5453859568,
-0.4642089009,
-0.8815344572,
-0.2415027022,
-0.2665101588,
-0.1528699249,
0.5455957055,
0.4720183313,
-0.3450067639,
0.9757850766,
-0.4530759156,
-0.384899497,
-0.3819085062,
-0.1915114224,
0.1897855252,
0.2835118473,
0.5814214945,
-0.7867421508,
-0.0794091821,
0.3422222435,
-0.714096725,
-0.0466138311,
0.1431897432,
-0.0357435048,
-0.0680300668,
0.1265646666,
-0.4029553533,
0.4554746747,
0.8037244081,
-0.719224751,
0.7681370974,
-0.1007896662,
0.2760974765,
-0.9011331201,
0.1912377477,
0.355240941,
-0.4431143999,
-0.3525507152,
0.3782029748,
-0.0042189201,
0.0619302653,
-0.8453018069,
0.5965099335,
0.1814053059,
-0.3172973692,
-0.1438385099,
0.3365474343,
0.2098171562,
0.2864883542,
0.1019648239,
0.3461847603,
0.3379142284,
-0.5819562674,
0.6546865106,
0.2573785484,
-0.7602018118,
0.8519148827,
-0.6638609171,
0.1231941581,
-0.1705838442,
-0.1628724784,
-0.4810840487,
-0.0836036652,
0.1303706169,
-0.3044044077,
-0.2250839025,
-0.0129212895,
-0.102192685,
-0.6706463695,
-0.5007021427,
0.0571008101,
0.4326405823,
-0.5773632526,
0.5966098309,
0.2102534026,
0.4307365716,
-0.3491140008,
-0.5608843565,
-0.0696716979,
-0.1914605051,
-0.3237032294,
-0.0116309384,
-0.2558018565,
-0.5563352108,
-0.232138887,
0.0149141895,
0.0940828696,
0.1010989025,
0.3784856796,
0.3900009096,
-0.1848022342,
-0.051598981,
-0.6253252029,
-0.0588617548,
-0.0891117901,
-0.3321658969,
0.6279836297,
-0.6232019067,
-0.5708345175,
-0.2887902558,
-0.1391613334,
0.8021575809,
-0.5529049635,
0.3372147679,
0.6367580891,
-0.3102167249,
-0.1207397804,
-0.442167908,
0.0492253229,
-0.4388663173,
0.5112231374,
-0.2592361271,
-0.718469739,
0.2146477848,
0.0536202006,
0.2640400529,
0.483448863,
0.6887082458,
-0.225101769,
0.6517470479,
0.6510721445,
0.0647878423,
0.465634644,
-0.2635135949,
-0.1306338459,
-0.8617616296,
-0.401080966,
-0.4336285889,
-0.1419363916,
-0.2239697874,
-0.3304999769,
0.2177436203,
-0.2474530041,
-0.149228856,
0.1819662303,
-0.4420603812,
0.5314814448,
0.6212034822,
0.3374508619,
0.1495105624,
-0.0520098209,
-0.1081505567,
-0.0918847024,
0.0075481068,
-0.7140225768,
1.0290681124,
0.5706188679,
0.820817709,
-0.0416419394,
0.5413331985,
0.5943850875,
0.2270189822,
-0.9282053113,
0.7003148794,
-0.3378268182,
-0.1163599417,
-0.3283322752,
-0.2955979407,
-0.8434292674,
0.3856477439,
-0.2341053784,
-0.9891825318,
-0.1402333081,
0.176407367,
-0.6423859596,
0.0319512896,
-0.5558374524,
1.1482955217,
-0.2820171416,
-0.4417250156,
-0.2963607311,
-0.359936446,
0.2119174004,
-0.2900544703,
0.2702417374,
0.0303062331,
0.4034427702,
0.74269557,
-0.494915247,
0.7870118618,
-0.1886888742,
-0.1692065597,
0.3486259282,
0.009978055,
0.3062304556,
-0.1336036772,
-0.0209614467,
0.1103212461,
-0.0296069607,
-0.0320017301,
-0.6186699271,
0.5583170652,
-0.7986626625,
-0.24103643,
-0.2438489497,
-0.1828037798,
-0.2154814005,
0.2355119288,
0.1932427734,
0.6515984535,
-0.3672026992,
0.2722994685,
0.3834651113,
-0.3830156624,
0.1147196293,
0.7143255472,
-1.0808138847,
-0.3657363057,
0.8284633756,
-0.212812677,
0.2648460865,
0.1302767098,
0.4642119706,
-0.1818678826,
-0.7373843193,
-0.6010375023,
-0.1831177175,
-0.6954367161,
-0.1525452882,
-0.1597286463,
-0.2654004693,
0.0766704381,
0.0883363113,
-0.6539720297,
-0.0071090865,
-0.008201723,
-0.0604000613,
0.2494912595,
0.9233064055,
0.3719898164,
0.2853027582,
-0.8115817904,
0.4608310163,
0.3730083406,
0.6997694969,
-0.3839508891,
-0.5989815593,
-0.4334633946,
0.0120405406,
-0.3920435905,
-0.4101754129,
0.3756748438,
0.0355165116,
0.270831883,
0.4485029876,
-0.1630013734,
0.7540253997,
-0.5426036716,
1.1172212362,
0.2923874259,
-0.9716597795,
0.747215867,
-0.2127507478,
0.4666262269,
0.5637711883,
-0.1552083939,
-0.4378503859,
-0.6290040016,
-0.3960029483,
-0.4088969827,
0.5574407578,
0.3934264779,
0.0160405729,
0.1716631055,
0.0582414456,
0.1376174241,
0.1754469275,
-0.7868436575,
0.0171089992,
-0.3006809652,
-0.4417996705,
-0.2666510046,
-0.1631522328,
-0.0041941251,
-0.1364162117,
0.2233793139,
-0.113736406,
-0.0259044487,
0.2204972059,
-0.1940444708,
-0.1369045973,
0.2844608128,
0.5523042679,
0.709038794,
-0.3355050683,
0.2548876405,
0.1380434483,
-0.7312351465,
-0.3110263646,
-0.0581829026,
-0.2242631465,
0.1065976992,
0.2198864669,
1.0600446463,
0.0030477396,
-0.8090173006,
0.8037253618,
-0.2950918376,
-0.1376701593,
-0.5044276714,
0.0068984679,
-0.2974997163,
0.528681457,
0.069722183,
0.3528266847,
0.2779877186,
-0.217081666,
0.0193240233,
0.232439816,
-0.6191399693,
-0.320348382,
0.5846911073,
0.0619157963,
-0.1709218323,
0.4103493094,
0.0742616206,
-0.403816998,
0.3210619688,
0.2703205645,
0.7719056606,
-0.2463738918,
0.2593980432,
0.1948227286,
0.3653507233,
0.0265432745,
0.4802230597,
0.0238614902,
-0.6668369174,
-0.3464613259,
-1.2254419327,
-0.5831642151,
0.5390684009,
-0.7017698884,
0.5579849482,
-0.3412203193,
-0.3122382462,
0.0708396882,
-0.1389588416,
-0.8629152775,
0.5853664279,
0.6044159532,
0.82902354,
-0.5933283567,
0.615623951,
0.6864657402,
-0.3210712373,
-0.6016536951,
-0.4411489069,
-0.1861291379,
-0.7702871561,
0.7245706916,
0.3765041828,
-0.2436000556,
-0.2955738604,
-0.5306067467,
-0.6221787333,
0.8728727102,
0.4019140005,
-0.9499117136,
0.1676673144,
0.3956579864,
0.6759670973,
-0.0502111726,
0.2505218685,
0.4513209164,
0.5093775392,
-0.2728583813,
-1.2596708536,
-0.4441497028,
-0.2321518511,
0.0071212444,
0.1221994013,
-0.494400382,
0.7081144452,
-0.0807103291,
0.0510204881,
0.0982501283,
0.6563006639,
0.3118677437,
0.4803025126,
0.6222256422,
0.7275423408,
0.5669485331,
0.0519224368,
1.2679637671,
-0.1551359445,
0.7158408761,
1.1903493404,
-0.2429911047,
1.1113305092,
0.4519066513,
-0.3014648557,
0.4641996324,
0.2803901434,
-0.2798674405,
0.5227314234,
0.3238616586,
-0.1360014528,
-0.2080622464,
-0.115318425,
-0.048223678,
0.7146707177,
0.2835869193,
-0.5860213637,
-0.2292029411,
0.2457528263,
-0.5003039837,
0.1564297527,
-0.7266501784,
0.5554801226,
0.1796519607,
-0.4856506586,
0.5062018037,
-0.1334520429,
0.4282381833,
-0.6243478656,
0.0688887313,
-0.1080707461,
0.5777952075,
-0.2855986953,
-1.0779821873,
0.1820582449,
0.3707493246,
0.0131484391,
0.1368723661,
0.6650497913,
-0.0174715146,
-0.5393477678,
0.3047615588,
0.4428762794,
0.2921783328,
-0.0733513311,
-0.5010697842,
0.3583824039,
-0.0054112282,
-0.4572624266,
0.0912751555,
0.0045622066,
-0.2287523896,
0.7848897576,
0.503654778,
0.0060565569,
-0.0036932155,
0.5855363011,
0.6893574595,
-0.6303654313,
-0.353656143,
-1.0417146683,
0.5245617628,
-0.1353468597,
-0.4043584168,
0.7648326755,
0.7126082182,
0.9200059175,
-0.3260299563,
0.7379462123,
0.2074771076,
0.4208369553,
-0.4980970025,
0.715657115,
-0.605627358,
0.0161295552,
-0.4502696991,
-0.93470186,
-0.2804144621,
0.6075265408,
-0.2925702333,
-0.0877277926,
0.5533776283,
0.3094523251,
-0.1917198598,
-0.0354993083,
0.6709217429,
0.1547260135,
0.2873458266,
0.6249824166,
1.1052507162,
-0.3046613336,
0.3683685064,
-0.1730258167,
-0.1882380396,
-0.2141795456,
-0.7030743957,
-0.8299421072,
-0.4288189709,
-0.3324565291,
-0.395875901,
-0.0177676715,
0.8667541742,
0.4619497657,
-0.6305009723,
-0.2530995011,
-0.1550435275,
-0.3873386681,
-0.0032124254,
-0.2316101789,
0.3846176565,
-0.2582372427,
-0.6902894974,
0.3171709478,
0.4269045889,
0.1248799562,
-0.5644290447,
-0.3120470941,
0.6186199784,
0.0944469348,
1.0052536726,
-0.0442378782,
-0.7625170946,
-0.4523165524,
-0.111475572,
-0.2571882606,
0.0843435451,
0.1636196822,
-1.0983506441,
0.5762255788,
0.1079471856,
0.3203034401,
0.3109305799,
-0.2363879085,
0.4881088436,
-0.2767703533,
0.0168136302,
0.2663012445,
0.6644173265,
0.338740319,
0.0510373153,
0.5452887416,
0.0214326531,
-0.4270532727,
-0.8405379653,
0.2644968927,
-1.4053957462,
0.1315068454,
1.166691184,
-0.0878475159,
-0.4625505805,
0.3211197257,
-0.5285291672,
-0.1466995925,
-0.0643664375,
0.7970947623,
0.4087585807,
0.2820636928,
-0.0819221511,
-0.6857785583,
0.2362097949,
0.3623471558,
-0.9514289498,
-0.0170212295,
0.6257719398,
0.0938396826,
0.4061672986,
0.3698891699,
-0.304027617,
0.4362563789,
-0.2404721826,
0.1923287213,
0.0438298993,
-0.1467937231,
-0.3575036526,
0.2308457792,
0.3114641905,
-0.3712897003
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06583v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06583v1
|
Mapping Transformer Leveraged Embeddings for Cross-Lingual Document Representation
| 2024-01-12T14:01:15 | 2024-01-12T14:01:15 |
Tsegaye Misikir Tashu, Eduard-Raul Kontos, Matthia Sabatelli, Matias Valdenegro-Toro
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Recommendation systems, for documents, have become tools to find relevant
content on the Web. However, these systems have limitations when it comes to
recommending documents in languages different from the query language, which
means they might overlook resources in non-native languages. This research
focuses on representing documents across languages by using Transformer
Leveraged Document Representations (TLDRs) that are mapped to a cross-lingual
domain. Four multilingual pre-trained transformer models (mBERT, mT5 XLM
RoBERTa, ErnieM) were evaluated using three mapping methods across 20 language
pairs representing combinations of five selected languages of the European
Union. Metrics like Mate Retrieval Rate and Reciprocal Rank were used to
measure the effectiveness of mapped TLDRs compared to non-mapped ones. The
results highlight the power of cross-lingual representations achieved through
pre-trained transformers and mapping approaches suggesting a promising
direction for expanding beyond language connections, between two specific
languages.
|
[
-0.5699112415,
-0.0539213642,
0.3272106051,
0.2520847619,
-0.3281787336,
0.3653344512,
-0.4133965671,
-0.5554226637,
0.4844078124,
0.3411626518,
-0.2258534282,
-0.4974354208,
-0.8692601919,
0.2224426568,
-0.3336215615,
0.7348700762,
-0.3782020211,
0.4298888743,
-0.2428705692,
-0.2649975121,
-0.6182351708,
-0.5881810188,
-0.1131167933,
-0.6508595347,
0.5799072385,
0.2838811576,
0.7263128161,
0.0050394684,
0.5219194293,
0.3086842299,
0.3267688751,
0.0530250445,
-0.7774369121,
-0.0711067691,
-0.442848891,
-0.4497023523,
-0.1626267433,
-0.0875622481,
0.6078709364,
0.7275048494,
0.0819767267,
-0.1916190684,
0.125215292,
0.2815512717,
-0.3691392243,
0.2121216655,
-0.281807363,
0.3179015517,
-0.2131651342,
-0.4389137626,
-0.6246785522,
-0.2801297903,
0.2296452671,
-0.7988055944,
0.1355822533,
0.322622478,
0.8532658815,
-0.1596307606,
-0.6909661889,
-0.3469713032,
-0.9705839157,
0.8451469541,
-0.1609984487,
1.0434443951,
0.3107909858,
0.6468582749,
0.1129120514,
-0.5531827211,
-0.0066313236,
0.0008215558,
-0.5809091926,
0.094658643,
-0.2470901459,
-0.3844950497,
-0.0302164704,
0.3887738883,
-0.4227539003,
0.1787235737,
-0.3141036928,
-0.3258620799,
0.4469195306,
-0.2570517361,
0.5031080842,
0.3121036291,
-0.3243115544,
-0.4650611281,
-0.695371449,
-0.1901561916,
0.2826622427,
0.4586167037,
-0.0293143392,
0.642888546,
0.360991329,
0.5087276101,
0.2481242418,
0.0231829546,
0.2528975904,
-0.255782932,
0.1219135448,
0.0401441567,
0.6298370957,
0.4702567756,
0.5061107874,
-0.792321682,
-0.1779507399,
-0.1264945269,
0.3254303932,
-0.6415024996,
0.0611043535,
-0.3944346011,
-0.4177902937,
0.2847115993,
0.2519751489,
-0.5930083394,
-0.2613419592,
0.0297899619,
0.3308263123,
-0.4165258706,
-0.5002282858,
0.0100133875,
-0.3081322014,
0.3184417188,
0.0202064347,
-0.9372900724,
0.287191689,
0.3585543036,
0.44091627,
-0.1939463615,
-0.3595012724,
-0.1543760151,
0.4751077592,
-0.3146825135,
0.9194473624,
-0.8493583798,
-0.921792686,
0.6026544571,
0.4337816536,
-0.0811249837,
-0.4314418137,
0.7194051743,
-0.6690300703,
0.3931063712,
-0.3772149682,
-0.6184705496,
-0.4257209599,
0.3892104328,
-0.9694795012,
1.0347813368,
0.2740268111,
-0.5028575063,
0.5535666943,
-0.5735270381,
-0.6657280922,
-0.0962330699,
-0.1410538107,
-0.1083315164,
-0.1366374642,
0.4621574283,
0.4536853135,
-0.4856136441,
0.069967851,
-0.0285867788,
-0.2687770724,
-0.1479392201,
-0.1149588898,
0.4512418211,
-0.3064225912,
-0.1763814241,
0.0513927937,
-0.3010379076,
-0.2710795701,
0.1282508075,
-0.3066386282,
-0.7354826331,
-0.3389397562,
0.6100484133,
0.3110289276,
0.2645951807,
-0.6661834121,
0.0700724721,
-0.3642078042,
0.1485616416,
0.1259093881,
-0.341555655,
0.8628231883,
-0.399212569,
0.8203215003,
0.0978796482,
-0.3588630557,
-0.2382825911,
-0.4353802204,
-0.6588305831,
0.2276200205,
0.4385108352,
0.3958989382,
-0.8508899212,
0.3205991685,
-0.6652953029,
-0.5746649504,
-0.7435966134,
0.1317338049,
0.3864281774,
0.0559530593,
0.6623173356,
-0.1084122434,
-0.4162438512,
-0.8811201453,
-0.3146316707,
0.052935712,
-0.1401558965,
0.3477786183,
0.2170490474,
-0.3581256866,
0.7527985573,
-0.0986299291,
-0.7391818762,
-0.4352691174,
-0.038783554,
-0.0370053612,
0.2640475631,
0.7994471788,
-0.9851382971,
-0.7733063102,
0.2906401753,
-0.503249228,
-0.0103869857,
-0.0705000833,
-0.190079987,
0.3252283335,
0.3466931283,
-0.2501505613,
0.1938987374,
0.7225064635,
-0.505551815,
0.0860012472,
-0.4578541815,
0.2213734239,
-1.014891386,
-0.0704320446,
0.164687559,
-0.4249386191,
-0.3604636192,
-0.0950776041,
0.2899003029,
-0.3351460397,
-0.4565088451,
0.7546958923,
-0.7302969694,
-0.1053633243,
0.1094590947,
0.4234334528,
0.3183475435,
0.3376259506,
0.1975197494,
0.6460764408,
0.3860597908,
-0.2051955909,
0.3008902967,
0.408883065,
-0.0680420101,
0.7356203198,
-0.5418580174,
-0.111371085,
0.0968471766,
0.4710095823,
-0.675029099,
0.4327882528,
-0.0524946116,
0.0412583761,
0.5065412521,
-0.1656740755,
-0.5096001625,
-0.3172647357,
-0.1235352084,
0.4195099473,
0.1928915977,
-0.84589082,
1.1173378229,
0.5194764733,
0.0845800564,
-0.2661770284,
-0.881373167,
0.019854717,
-0.0968392864,
-0.7988925576,
0.8539203405,
0.231754303,
0.0938728526,
0.2849296331,
0.2291871607,
0.1166283414,
-0.3352748752,
0.348133117,
0.1619212776,
-0.2336987704,
0.1344347298,
0.0005910397,
-0.2575246394,
-0.1545099318,
-0.5058569908,
0.6425430179,
-0.0741613433,
-0.7010136247,
0.1147899553,
0.8057345152,
0.5296478868,
-0.4319413006,
0.6710811257,
0.8574812412,
-0.2115719616,
-0.1918495446,
-0.5510315299,
-0.0557858273,
-0.4181153774,
0.097909458,
-0.6696683168,
-0.9521297812,
0.5471794605,
-0.2308262289,
0.0147569748,
0.7382091284,
0.5459281802,
0.0372313522,
0.6105702519,
1.0391507149,
-0.2591529191,
0.3337033391,
-0.5193289518,
0.4887302518,
-0.6482980847,
-0.4866821766,
-0.4284734428,
-0.4254358411,
-0.9587865472,
-0.687479198,
0.2491419762,
-0.1586103141,
0.2282993495,
0.55893749,
-0.2754359543,
0.384275645,
0.598685205,
-0.2742155492,
0.2145256996,
-0.0076961275,
-0.6884453893,
-0.193951115,
-0.7636103034,
-0.3308044374,
0.8662248254,
0.1699624211,
0.8049958944,
0.0466999672,
0.4910226464,
0.1684226841,
0.138394624,
-0.9602037668,
0.2967762351,
-0.4359973073,
-0.5072948933,
-0.2509457767,
0.0798444524,
-1.1580411196,
0.3962720931,
-0.292039901,
-0.269254446,
0.3602684736,
-0.5157276392,
0.2178227156,
0.5358613729,
-0.5749415755,
0.7580416203,
-0.3199388385,
-0.0582087934,
-0.3762973249,
-0.2480068505,
-0.2934325635,
-0.2048814595,
0.1574437916,
0.1645383984,
0.1063578874,
0.8105288148,
-0.1069623083,
0.5732443333,
-0.1091215163,
-0.2826019228,
-0.1270303577,
0.1250576079,
0.4422778189,
-0.2425191253,
-0.3661793172,
0.4411102831,
-0.1007472575,
-0.4015987217,
-0.4478421509,
0.6964298487,
-0.6563797593,
-0.740255475,
-0.2084338814,
-0.5953159332,
-0.2908315361,
0.5342955589,
0.1527023911,
0.4345315993,
-0.5861318707,
0.326225847,
0.1168154255,
-0.3138713837,
0.3521703482,
0.6916826963,
-0.4449805319,
-0.0285709538,
0.82156986,
0.3236431181,
-0.1618163288,
0.8421481848,
0.0699794218,
-0.5507882833,
-0.0759098232,
-0.6176127195,
0.4249493778,
-0.768861711,
-0.0875203162,
-0.5208656788,
0.0095132813,
-0.5396409035,
-0.5090399981,
-0.1296133399,
-0.4461967647,
-0.1352375597,
-0.2450949401,
0.1729836911,
0.7451003194,
-0.0321258642,
0.1392166018,
-0.8227791786,
0.2718456388,
0.0219102595,
0.5769113898,
-0.1047692746,
-0.2552415133,
-0.6398538947,
-0.1253141314,
-0.2676129043,
-0.8068016171,
0.3794974089,
0.2646397352,
1.0036621094,
0.5456297994,
0.1052679643,
0.4110601246,
-0.7929589748,
0.6143980622,
0.007405987,
-0.6139338017,
0.3872066736,
-0.3722200692,
0.1905419976,
0.2339605838,
0.9435025454,
-0.5530589223,
-0.42740798,
-0.3273361921,
-0.6464226246,
0.4946443141,
-0.1050313339,
0.3172028363,
0.1671128869,
-0.2777270675,
0.2330835313,
-0.3306861818,
-0.4307750463,
-0.1905539334,
-0.3352707326,
0.2059242129,
-0.3958731294,
-0.1869646758,
-0.1565010846,
-0.0410347953,
0.7310436964,
0.0664755031,
0.2400280535,
0.0897565186,
-0.4780291021,
-0.23055996,
0.3521356285,
0.1174763963,
0.5451558828,
-0.108277753,
-0.0667931437,
-0.034167368,
-0.1446647495,
0.1976379603,
0.4504017532,
0.0515218526,
0.3711252511,
0.4925226271,
0.7650212646,
0.4672659636,
-0.3004759252,
0.4322756827,
-0.1822501421,
-0.0391196795,
-0.0769998133,
-0.4218676984,
0.345203042,
0.1286316812,
0.3851081431,
-0.2701831758,
0.0165141337,
-0.4913294613,
0.0722095594,
0.5071053505,
-0.5293018222,
-0.2779350579,
0.447037518,
0.5586552024,
-0.4488405883,
0.444341749,
0.2770389318,
-0.7800223827,
0.1922108531,
0.8168023229,
0.8379688859,
-0.2619106174,
0.2690225244,
0.1700097919,
0.3995241225,
0.0640187636,
0.0369296558,
-0.2328305095,
-0.7910345793,
-0.0121597694,
-0.5375541449,
-0.528660655,
-0.6093166471,
-0.6713619232,
0.4607869983,
0.0964613482,
-0.2005974948,
-0.0260983407,
0.0782727674,
-1.0950130224,
0.0595027544,
0.0922217742,
1.1013121605,
-1.0151872635,
0.995184958,
0.8537218571,
-0.4064095914,
-0.6789534688,
0.0388719253,
-0.239149496,
-0.780143559,
0.7262856364,
0.0658712834,
-0.3975461423,
-0.175476104,
0.4866220653,
-0.7976590991,
1.0808293819,
0.4428596795,
-0.4958701134,
-0.0938561037,
0.6063299179,
0.7216539383,
-0.5362734795,
0.4255083501,
0.238735497,
0.702578783,
-0.0095407655,
-1.1255843639,
0.0962825269,
-0.4639364481,
0.163240701,
0.2904509902,
-0.4649013281,
0.4085871875,
0.1033926532,
-0.4658030868,
-0.3256253898,
0.3491509557,
-0.1278136075,
0.0219752528,
0.4312296212,
0.5689551234,
0.5254448056,
-0.1690953374,
1.2835611105,
-0.5839428902,
0.0482051224,
0.9204970002,
-0.351396203,
0.8648189306,
0.659426868,
-0.0522212721,
0.8840399981,
0.5055223703,
-0.2622065544,
0.4871652126,
-0.0557894148,
0.1744618565,
-0.1479234993,
-0.6176288724,
-0.5490887761,
0.2264704257,
0.2990120649,
-0.4609898329,
-0.5448551774,
0.2797530591,
-0.3214881122,
0.2272571772,
0.0219308287,
0.7102146745,
0.1075453088,
-0.5423289537,
0.5552493334,
0.1496958286,
0.8271842599,
-0.4361397624,
-0.0146564934,
-0.290748179,
-0.1201146469,
-0.110701412,
-0.8471166492,
0.2425814271,
-0.2391018867,
-0.3543658853,
-0.8669711947,
0.9987685084,
-0.6465153098,
-0.8026049137,
1.2529075146,
0.7146850228,
0.0379570797,
0.2356300503,
-0.2537231743,
-0.0574206486,
-0.2922726274,
-0.1383443773,
0.2049204707,
0.6813946366,
-0.3317770958,
0.5686702132,
0.4753979445,
0.0823691711,
0.0686475188,
0.3810203671,
0.8784259558,
-0.3478199244,
-0.6434341073,
-0.4354700148,
0.1984593868,
0.2088674605,
0.0353705287,
0.902531445,
0.6679110527,
1.1685792208,
-0.1688045561,
0.7334010005,
0.2115501016,
0.3738688827,
-0.2221179903,
0.8971810341,
-0.7302324772,
0.1172941029,
0.0187362675,
-1.171967864,
-0.3511237502,
0.3360479176,
-0.4827578962,
0.0619445071,
0.6696834564,
0.739675343,
-0.4409640729,
-0.2360988408,
0.6010629535,
-0.0582056902,
0.242400527,
0.5464891195,
0.5135781169,
-0.5414264202,
0.7818771005,
-0.1822077185,
0.1935186088,
-0.3593700528,
-0.6336233616,
-1.0443356037,
-0.7870403528,
0.0251461696,
-0.1254518777,
-0.1037021503,
0.6062198877,
0.7948579192,
-0.8300970793,
-0.3239701986,
0.6031010747,
0.2296612859,
-0.0446910411,
-0.1264616996,
0.4410987198,
-0.0920701623,
-0.8406283855,
0.5102143288,
0.3337768316,
0.0313841216,
-0.7301176786,
-0.3392416239,
-0.3073494732,
-0.1249936819,
0.4180557728,
-0.0014278279,
-0.7118778825,
0.0767176747,
0.1241409481,
-0.3060024977,
0.1836934537,
1.0269706249,
-0.8703200221,
0.5991771221,
0.5976772308,
0.7076858282,
0.6887595057,
-0.390114814,
1.0049606562,
-0.6019598842,
0.1870718747,
0.1042710766,
0.6295500398,
0.7329748869,
-0.2562450767,
0.5381768346,
-0.2079969347,
-0.1456586868,
-0.3874152601,
-0.0816496313,
-0.8384330273,
-0.1024215221,
1.078902483,
-0.423855722,
0.1288649738,
-0.2162849903,
-0.0809391215,
0.3461850584,
-0.4882402718,
0.6467214227,
0.8394529223,
0.340626508,
-0.1409082711,
-0.2737465799,
0.1274273247,
0.3495441377,
-0.3868299425,
-0.3716489375,
0.0309346244,
-0.0298157111,
0.5080729723,
0.394328624,
-0.286605835,
0.0119460151,
-0.2030624747,
-0.137387678,
-0.0033544872,
-0.2668318748,
-0.1414413303,
0.1562430412,
-0.0589506626,
-0.0110872369
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06832v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06832v1
|
XLS-R Deep Learning Model for Multilingual ASR on Low- Resource Languages: Indonesian, Javanese, and Sundanese
| 2024-01-12T13:44:48 | 2024-01-12T13:44:48 |
Panji Arisaputra, Alif Tri Handoyo, Amalia Zahra
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
This research paper focuses on the development and evaluation of Automatic
Speech Recognition (ASR) technology using the XLS-R 300m model. The study aims
to improve ASR performance in converting spoken language into written text,
specifically for Indonesian, Javanese, and Sundanese languages. The paper
discusses the testing procedures, datasets used, and methodology employed in
training and evaluating the ASR systems. The results show that the XLS-R 300m
model achieves competitive Word Error Rate (WER) measurements, with a slight
compromise in performance for Javanese and Sundanese languages. The integration
of a 5-gram KenLM language model significantly reduces WER and enhances ASR
accuracy. The research contributes to the advancement of ASR technology by
addressing linguistic diversity and improving performance across various
languages. The findings provide insights into optimizing ASR accuracy and
applicability for diverse linguistic contexts.
|
[
-0.2915392518,
-0.5105979443,
0.100782223,
0.1594131589,
-0.1465641707,
0.3286102712,
-0.68220824,
-0.5074483752,
-0.176463455,
0.6433220506,
-0.1931071877,
-0.3686407804,
-0.7265034914,
0.703466773,
-0.4345782697,
0.5032725334,
-0.295209378,
0.3900010586,
0.1949104965,
-0.4721161127,
-0.2901791036,
-0.463757515,
-0.985676527,
-0.3667347133,
0.4863042831,
0.6398958564,
0.3749218881,
0.5891749859,
0.5742462873,
0.3370725811,
-0.2215443105,
0.0274435114,
0.0416978449,
0.0205479581,
0.1101973504,
-0.2491510212,
-0.2711287141,
-0.2361023128,
0.8759055734,
0.9052889347,
-0.3336203396,
0.2210436314,
0.2311894149,
0.8420277238,
-0.4898354411,
0.2180625349,
-0.1773789376,
0.2888649106,
-0.3376485705,
0.1727692336,
-0.3221575022,
-0.3095803559,
0.0973025784,
-0.5301996469,
0.0678798258,
-0.1085706875,
0.7263678312,
0.3217419088,
-0.2792557776,
-0.54719311,
-1.0511617661,
0.8846679926,
-0.7417090535,
0.7522668242,
0.3634420931,
0.5223175883,
0.5138838291,
-0.542244494,
-0.6998922229,
-0.3814965487,
0.0700544119,
0.1219490394,
-0.0920183063,
0.0007414507,
0.268168956,
0.2797296047,
-0.5999449492,
0.1877949983,
-0.6928733587,
0.0627755895,
0.804620564,
0.0868668705,
0.1837166548,
-0.2134678215,
0.159954235,
-0.1721013635,
-0.3172343075,
0.1873401999,
0.450781554,
0.9731816053,
-0.0424574316,
0.7840253115,
-0.1895858645,
0.7020542622,
-0.2664706111,
-0.1666165739,
0.3675426543,
-0.3536844552,
-0.188333407,
0.3249322474,
0.8890553117,
-0.1718372703,
0.2632550001,
0.0658333153,
-0.3752867281,
0.2929748893,
0.0173498057,
-0.6747862697,
-0.0047581624,
-0.1533817202,
-0.6168017387,
0.0193022918,
-0.0868008658,
-0.461144954,
-0.2992775142,
-0.6160366535,
0.3924924433,
-0.590731442,
-0.5092306137,
0.2584079802,
0.0771327019,
0.0591623373,
0.2574092746,
-0.529422462,
0.7057532072,
0.3296016455,
0.5933844447,
0.1068928763,
-0.2104196101,
-0.4192030728,
0.0393693559,
-0.4101352394,
0.7229038477,
-0.6217197776,
-0.5167158842,
0.0089478893,
-0.1835868657,
-0.2605194449,
-0.7235791087,
0.8264496922,
-0.29603827,
0.0432702191,
-0.1702373177,
-0.6429622173,
-0.407852143,
-0.1034400165,
-0.7546940446,
1.0006865263,
-0.2289495617,
-0.4851680696,
0.4697831273,
-1.1875772476,
-0.6619713306,
0.2959961295,
-0.2333544642,
-0.5948191881,
-0.1037824824,
0.1079871282,
0.4402543306,
-0.2558020651,
0.0301089678,
0.092482321,
-0.4074971378,
0.2224251926,
-0.4372926652,
0.7363194227,
0.7062655091,
-0.2743409872,
0.0868264139,
-0.9895341992,
-0.0394270346,
-0.0145500302,
-0.7726522684,
-0.286077559,
0.0553958677,
0.4860510826,
-0.0901704431,
-0.018214561,
-0.7950154543,
-0.1635912657,
-0.2422576696,
0.1740486175,
0.1769333631,
-0.5289319754,
0.338986069,
0.1455700248,
0.5574957728,
0.0027206007,
-0.0431675129,
-0.0627884567,
-0.3399530351,
-0.9136919379,
-0.1785287708,
0.5156099796,
0.824659586,
-0.7628003359,
0.4281943142,
-0.2195952684,
-0.4204401076,
-0.7830953598,
0.4784226716,
0.741569221,
0.395301193,
0.3023001254,
-0.3621311784,
-0.8373637199,
-0.7441518903,
-0.451050669,
0.1286300868,
-0.0716864392,
0.5906228423,
0.1404089481,
-0.5748036504,
0.7837224007,
-0.2153571248,
-0.5562877059,
-0.7555114031,
0.3629018664,
0.2734095454,
0.3941106498,
0.4316277802,
-0.6708778739,
-0.9721761942,
0.2124916762,
-0.6010419726,
0.0880439505,
0.5286332369,
0.7764004469,
0.6767873168,
0.6870962381,
-0.1000586599,
0.4118332565,
0.5849542618,
-0.1536054164,
0.2427435964,
-0.395811826,
0.1494680494,
-1.0479718447,
0.3140282631,
0.3190866709,
-0.0485443473,
-0.6883022189,
-0.2836037278,
0.2544060349,
-0.483098805,
-0.27504462,
0.3506725729,
-0.5299165845,
-0.2350703627,
-0.3617057502,
-0.0984894782,
-0.3640132248,
0.0335900337,
0.2311446965,
1.0238536596,
0.4481658936,
-0.7217265964,
0.3500088453,
0.3035263717,
-0.6141052842,
0.502209425,
-0.5619958639,
0.163250342,
-0.2070378959,
0.0363593884,
-0.8761229515,
-0.0802569166,
-0.0616449863,
-0.5397331715,
0.6345362663,
-0.0047739344,
-0.4690141082,
-0.6729715466,
0.2660441399,
0.3972328007,
0.392233789,
-0.2582301497,
0.6503725648,
0.545159936,
-0.5954291821,
-0.6654119492,
-0.8828792572,
0.3600730002,
-0.1383868456,
-0.3281649947,
-0.0806775987,
0.1064932495,
-0.2906584442,
-0.0177615639,
0.2452445179,
-0.3025048375,
-0.1451683342,
-0.0103312284,
-0.0780965239,
-0.5332187414,
-0.0191705618,
-0.0587759316,
-0.3196223974,
-0.2352774739,
-0.1860024035,
0.4372484684,
-0.3328332007,
-0.1646433771,
-0.8061068058,
0.3858933747,
0.1615633965,
-0.2986944616,
0.6480936408,
0.7184332609,
-0.4119543135,
0.084428817,
-0.7828420997,
0.0268141124,
-0.458135128,
0.5050643682,
-0.5778689981,
-0.7428286672,
0.5434230566,
-0.1243269145,
-0.3282226324,
0.4991908371,
0.1010905504,
0.025617728,
0.8865194321,
0.9244033098,
-0.2127373517,
0.479499191,
-0.4451685846,
0.2491147965,
-0.8384552598,
0.0579020232,
-0.9738493562,
0.0061216042,
-0.5690125227,
-0.2488931417,
0.2537024915,
-0.2427676171,
-0.2094561309,
0.5823184848,
-0.3909148872,
0.3977957666,
0.4727399349,
-0.032362882,
0.2368668765,
-0.0136546753,
-0.2936469316,
-0.2086192966,
-0.7851199508,
-0.7626820803,
1.2119402885,
0.2553323209,
0.906411171,
0.0613814816,
0.5276438594,
0.3105641603,
0.1851181537,
-0.650401473,
0.3974155188,
-0.8604120016,
-0.3566031158,
-0.6611831188,
-0.4818642437,
-1.061860919,
-0.0854211077,
0.0322693586,
-0.3616226614,
0.0869951993,
0.0225304011,
-0.6829802394,
0.2493599504,
-0.7470863461,
0.6666126847,
-0.1740262657,
0.1538324654,
-0.3546578586,
-0.5827175379,
0.0472953208,
-0.0664105043,
0.3196725845,
0.0654083118,
0.0710934475,
1.0909845829,
-0.0213927496,
0.6631693244,
-0.3377931416,
-0.0347773433,
0.254211396,
-0.384400636,
0.1557637006,
-0.1863350719,
-0.4865426123,
0.4254164994,
-0.2240775973,
-0.1477089673,
-0.1074784994,
0.3595373631,
-1.1786357164,
-0.0784416497,
-0.4635923207,
-0.5215515494,
-0.0497201867,
0.2972356975,
0.1151672676,
0.4036960304,
-0.2312586457,
0.3984047472,
0.7303082347,
-0.5616362095,
0.4685266912,
0.8540692925,
-0.1034248471,
-0.6762877107,
0.9066973329,
0.5689098239,
0.0488587953,
0.2684600651,
0.1321577728,
-0.4264899194,
-0.5671942234,
-0.5488141179,
0.139220044,
-0.6145538092,
-0.1598008871,
-0.7894099951,
-0.6506683826,
-0.5823310018,
-0.0800550207,
-0.7045986652,
-0.3651641309,
-0.3581780791,
0.0083954455,
0.353296876,
1.0107768774,
-0.2732224464,
0.2233130336,
-0.6709985137,
0.3634375334,
0.2439433038,
0.4928278625,
-0.1124536395,
-0.6510881782,
-0.2811035812,
-0.0436536334,
-0.0962126851,
-0.3874653578,
0.6486046314,
0.4514477551,
0.5518699288,
0.2087292969,
-0.0585984513,
0.7275455594,
-0.6712467074,
0.4561369121,
0.1760278791,
-1.0774995089,
0.5940752625,
-0.1925790459,
0.251422435,
0.5290510058,
0.0533481203,
-0.7686164379,
-0.2828047276,
-0.2833551764,
-0.8572880626,
0.9154400826,
0.0218358282,
0.1518102586,
0.4932488799,
0.5294639468,
0.3606295884,
0.1055802554,
-0.5801125765,
-0.3170641959,
-0.1755272001,
-0.3893046081,
-0.4467178881,
-0.394988358,
0.1450859755,
-0.3949853182,
0.675870657,
-0.1781585515,
0.1324795038,
0.0753049701,
-0.1768229306,
-0.4879424572,
0.4002265632,
0.7133117914,
0.3918252289,
-0.1464176476,
-0.0224943757,
0.3883473873,
-0.7440155149,
0.1777581275,
0.6427531242,
-0.1397213191,
0.0944133624,
0.0137067614,
0.9216160774,
0.1628846377,
-0.5881575942,
0.2487010509,
-0.4750310481,
-0.1154765636,
-0.748922646,
0.0704413652,
-0.0629592538,
0.196442917,
0.7456215024,
0.2523741722,
0.271043241,
-0.3000223339,
0.1904413998,
0.3395637274,
-0.485286653,
-0.0343173854,
0.693707943,
0.3594892621,
-0.5088116527,
0.5369852185,
-0.0819260329,
-0.5255046487,
0.547431767,
0.3506490588,
0.9183300138,
-0.791549623,
0.0632055551,
0.5635107756,
0.4234793484,
-0.0386273265,
0.536636889,
-0.1176395267,
-0.7493197322,
-0.4438368082,
-0.7364599109,
-0.7457692027,
0.1444979608,
-0.9284875989,
0.4354594946,
-0.2487995774,
-0.1183120757,
0.2049147189,
0.4364988208,
-0.6683316231,
0.323807478,
0.2272182256,
0.8307122588,
-0.852896452,
0.9693715572,
0.7666335106,
-0.3495706022,
-0.7826612592,
-0.1224755868,
-0.1747075617,
-0.5547606945,
0.9815504551,
0.2066441029,
-0.1555548608,
0.0676644072,
-0.2549850047,
-1.1395509243,
1.0165596008,
0.358022213,
-0.7373858094,
0.5752506256,
0.5289834738,
0.5817281604,
-0.2256657332,
0.1135736108,
0.439326793,
0.4097880125,
0.045277454,
-1.4890457392,
-0.359375149,
-0.3098063469,
0.2953906655,
-0.0094404807,
-0.5624979138,
0.7546621561,
-0.2136238664,
-0.1952986568,
0.2971697748,
0.8012521863,
0.206606105,
0.3398886621,
0.4330341518,
0.5683274269,
0.5706576705,
-0.0695476159,
0.8859472871,
-0.1463677436,
0.1024521887,
0.8203155398,
-0.7178577781,
1.0155572891,
0.2091979235,
-0.2310351282,
0.2672576308,
0.322137922,
0.118505612,
0.3748895824,
0.0460155532,
-0.4323881567,
0.0726097375,
-0.1862897128,
-0.3604785502,
0.6542465687,
0.5898897648,
-0.2302573621,
0.0442790054,
0.4823842645,
0.127323553,
0.2796613574,
-0.3242232203,
0.9843485355,
0.1051631644,
-0.3295220435,
0.4465866089,
0.1776877344,
0.8148648143,
-0.488204658,
0.2168440968,
-0.0250616707,
0.7644271255,
-0.0364680588,
-0.599919498,
0.5665974021,
0.4349134564,
-0.069139339,
-0.2233777195,
0.7241672277,
-0.583765924,
-0.9451073408,
0.3853452504,
0.2079918832,
0.0645115152,
0.2948679626,
-0.7937360406,
0.4031170309,
-0.2901186347,
-0.1388384253,
0.0902007595,
0.3936947286,
0.2463355064,
0.719509542,
0.5770525336,
0.2179793715,
0.0349677764,
0.3488215506,
0.6622053981,
-0.656707108,
-0.5403221846,
-0.4311522841,
0.3448567688,
-0.0922224969,
-0.04583757,
0.8306088448,
0.9332363605,
0.8920624852,
-0.0716804564,
1.0524574518,
0.1311976016,
1.0558907986,
-0.286805898,
1.0578429699,
-0.4154487252,
0.0983717293,
-0.5470611453,
-0.6083163023,
-0.5946279764,
0.9609503746,
-0.1850193292,
0.1101704463,
0.4922829568,
0.528840065,
0.0399978161,
0.107391268,
0.4247701168,
0.3047116399,
0.2314731181,
0.214293316,
0.5683355331,
-0.7896016836,
0.6671943665,
-0.3299285769,
-0.1963649541,
-0.0923677385,
-0.589787364,
-0.6256068945,
-0.6286250949,
-0.4844672382,
-0.1681650132,
0.1102123708,
0.7467220426,
0.4866162241,
-1.1373659372,
-0.9227032661,
-0.0813190416,
-0.3467303216,
-0.3375592828,
-0.1759631932,
0.3934607506,
-0.4133585095,
-0.7064868808,
0.4522021711,
0.3946338296,
0.0625139326,
-0.1787317693,
-0.5287123919,
-0.205788672,
0.086780712,
0.5561522245,
0.5390265584,
-0.7014510632,
0.0853128806,
0.0846126601,
-0.1689313054,
-0.0276255812,
0.5790365934,
-0.6593872309,
0.4363743067,
0.0991740078,
0.5771790743,
0.4497417212,
-0.3790783584,
0.5479674339,
-0.5938340425,
0.3573931754,
0.2783333361,
0.3865819275,
0.7123036981,
-0.196895957,
0.5718231797,
0.1200355813,
-0.4944398403,
-0.8557132483,
-0.0785364658,
-0.7479028106,
0.0312365945,
1.2045285702,
-0.0322097167,
-0.0128099667,
-0.351701647,
-0.427523762,
0.5860440135,
-0.4160081148,
0.8435448408,
0.4003280699,
-0.1648897529,
-0.3921127021,
-0.525646925,
0.5432790518,
0.3103003204,
-0.6632623672,
0.0798280463,
0.2624198794,
0.2268760651,
0.3427476287,
0.5648607612,
-0.0318241306,
0.2793426514,
-0.0496623181,
0.2782204449,
0.1157996282,
-0.1775366366,
-0.6127685308,
-0.1019865647,
0.1254329085,
-0.1148964614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06568v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06568v2
|
Lost in the Source Language: How Large Language Models Evaluate the Quality of Machine Translation
| 2024-01-12T13:23:21 | 2024-06-06T07:51:16 |
Xu Huang, Zhirui Zhang, Xiang Geng, Yichao Du, Jiajun Chen, Shujian Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This study investigates how Large Language Models (LLMs) leverage source and
reference data in machine translation evaluation task, aiming to better
understand the mechanisms behind their remarkable performance in this task. We
design the controlled experiments across various input modes and model types,
and employ both coarse-grained and fine-grained prompts to discern the utility
of source versus reference information. We find that reference information
significantly enhances the evaluation accuracy, while surprisingly, source
information sometimes is counterproductive, indicating LLMs' inability to fully
leverage the cross-lingual capability when evaluating translations. Further
analysis of the fine-grained evaluation and fine-tuning experiments show
similar results. These findings also suggest a potential research direction for
LLMs that fully exploits the cross-lingual capability of LLMs to achieve better
performance in machine translation evaluation tasks.
|
[
-0.2691728175,
-0.4818845093,
0.7508256435,
0.0856578723,
-0.3676266968,
-0.024790993,
-0.3938911259,
-0.3870923817,
-0.1674970537,
0.5930942893,
-0.477622956,
-0.1061475202,
-0.8788320422,
0.3287233114,
-0.6322304606,
0.9293137789,
-0.2777502239,
0.6584100127,
-0.2396914661,
-0.162007466,
-0.4344258904,
-0.660462141,
-0.4248560369,
-0.6310607791,
0.5961291194,
0.4944466949,
0.9499148726,
0.7145405412,
0.7651033998,
0.257340461,
-0.1423054487,
0.0600343347,
-0.8893520236,
0.0521669127,
-0.558953464,
-0.6778440475,
0.0599442981,
0.0922622606,
0.9959298372,
0.7597503066,
0.2013189197,
0.3581074476,
0.2933834195,
0.6339241862,
-0.555775106,
0.0471417606,
-0.7404666543,
-0.0848536417,
-0.1894854605,
-0.3669267297,
-0.4443024099,
-0.2862900496,
0.0203010514,
-0.1340359598,
0.2660359144,
0.0109959617,
0.8825539947,
0.3773825169,
-0.432955265,
-0.3722120225,
-0.9285352826,
0.8558613658,
-0.7454283834,
0.5554530621,
0.3416992724,
0.1881640851,
-0.1998542994,
-0.459431529,
-0.3954308629,
-0.5294049382,
-0.1269014776,
-0.1908483505,
-0.2838381529,
-0.2568665743,
0.1275096089,
0.4803890884,
-0.3571792245,
0.1399756372,
-0.3751756847,
-0.0949678347,
0.485706687,
0.171632722,
0.2293360978,
-0.1778647751,
-0.0681162551,
-0.2227480561,
-0.8158990145,
-0.2074493021,
0.1987490952,
0.422116667,
0.1100043505,
0.9174209237,
0.037493553,
0.7794221044,
-0.0574222468,
-0.042042844,
0.0677935332,
-0.581713438,
-0.3075207472,
-0.0958947241,
0.8736926317,
0.2655501068,
0.2543071508,
-0.3370257914,
-0.3836272359,
-0.4626951814,
0.1554246396,
-0.7538759112,
0.2601643503,
-0.2514139116,
-0.5805702806,
-0.1034933999,
0.0607385859,
-0.2112953961,
-0.2839590609,
-0.4486735463,
0.4438212514,
-0.2704600692,
0.0194947608,
-0.1369081587,
-0.2647244334,
0.1328023076,
0.2112074196,
-0.6548896432,
0.1657418311,
0.5492603183,
0.8385452628,
-0.288723737,
-0.4122196436,
-0.8245329857,
0.0518421382,
-0.5692413449,
0.4278153777,
-0.7415919304,
-0.4717631936,
0.0019379648,
0.3146462142,
-0.0510834083,
-0.8306695819,
0.7405620813,
-0.6529352665,
0.0337285288,
-0.5000916719,
-0.4555334449,
-0.2385698855,
-0.0572862476,
-0.8087319732,
0.9155001044,
0.1617510766,
-0.5470516682,
0.2303359509,
-0.2596427798,
-0.2993852794,
-0.1256276667,
-0.043243587,
-0.1394166946,
0.7143861651,
-0.1282681227,
0.5473188162,
-0.7462930083,
0.2157821208,
-0.4113063514,
-0.5464567542,
0.5789856911,
-0.5760634542,
0.5888664722,
0.3891599774,
-0.1238831356,
0.0955520347,
-0.617988646,
-0.1853831559,
0.3761161268,
-0.4435074329,
-0.820993185,
0.0216512941,
0.0540336706,
0.2546677887,
0.1699830592,
-0.3801882267,
0.0881091058,
-0.2480913699,
0.364023149,
0.2933038771,
-0.0994641706,
0.4869358838,
-0.0056709065,
0.4950053096,
-0.1692634225,
-0.0468234718,
0.0986755192,
-0.1368371844,
-0.7641552687,
0.3550623357,
0.5519514084,
0.2107236236,
-0.7352067232,
0.027297195,
-0.3505952656,
-0.4191349447,
-0.8552132249,
0.5420897007,
0.4240873456,
0.2754966617,
0.1343311369,
-0.1928865314,
-0.3377816379,
-1.0292664766,
-0.2745210528,
0.0333858058,
-0.2676711679,
0.1482624114,
0.5383481383,
-0.3710938692,
0.6462561488,
-0.1555430442,
0.0779755563,
-0.460080862,
0.081047684,
0.2201703489,
0.3593942523,
0.4838721752,
-0.546030879,
-0.2005968839,
0.1245282963,
-0.6066332459,
-0.4520741105,
-0.0251651555,
-0.0628517345,
0.0213241298,
0.7260853648,
-0.4441708922,
-0.0044220639,
0.9261313677,
-0.2462455779,
0.6237856746,
-0.2717168927,
0.2749662995,
-0.8647643924,
0.2631492317,
-0.1107903793,
-0.2203313857,
-0.3251631558,
0.3424748182,
0.3472857475,
-0.1083011702,
-0.3626337945,
0.4264766872,
-0.6273721457,
-0.3659488559,
-0.5789835453,
0.4097711444,
0.0870376602,
0.0845440701,
-0.0786363035,
0.9341097474,
-0.0275846198,
-0.4064214826,
0.2237507999,
-0.1727025062,
-0.4369446635,
0.3617322743,
-0.6654654741,
0.2007045895,
-0.1558620632,
-0.0221750103,
-0.7724899054,
-0.1245927364,
0.1188739389,
-0.3068312705,
0.509688735,
-0.2432252169,
-0.6979947686,
-0.1437651962,
-0.0019348351,
0.4486424923,
0.2385810167,
-0.2904356122,
0.2415439487,
0.3194780648,
-0.1093384996,
-0.3644097447,
-0.8015491366,
0.2068222314,
0.0186532587,
-0.2979609668,
0.1479622126,
-0.0230992287,
-0.3772831261,
0.168634057,
-0.1977077127,
-0.0192757081,
0.1283920258,
0.136668399,
0.0968173444,
-0.2896003127,
0.2387272567,
0.0220478531,
-0.0039663841,
0.2407229841,
-0.1174407303,
0.5227201581,
-0.0272334516,
-0.5680277348,
-0.1985743791,
0.1991181225,
0.7396903634,
-0.1896440238,
0.6905733347,
0.3562712371,
-0.1130660996,
-0.1986135989,
-0.4482718706,
0.0150516396,
-0.3777375519,
0.6515597701,
-0.4664713144,
-0.821591258,
0.4199917316,
0.0056480975,
-0.200330779,
0.727368474,
0.6970620751,
0.1377577633,
0.8430627584,
0.6775267124,
-0.2626440823,
0.509560585,
-0.1327965558,
0.0788445473,
-0.9489628077,
-0.1654210538,
-0.9395017624,
-0.2634726167,
-0.4750426412,
-0.8175289631,
0.2476340234,
0.3737806082,
-0.1100254133,
0.3660516143,
-0.0887015909,
0.4300483465,
0.5405666828,
-0.0494576544,
0.5879686475,
-0.1809806675,
-0.3527853489,
-0.0332102813,
-0.9037700891,
-0.6749919057,
1.0166591406,
0.5910589099,
1.004591465,
-0.2406064868,
0.3703541458,
0.1189956665,
0.3424682915,
-0.9902674556,
0.4234862328,
-0.1098943353,
-0.4712840319,
-0.2920614481,
-0.54299891,
-0.950402081,
0.3557354212,
0.006232935,
-0.2543669343,
0.0200846083,
-0.0918929055,
-0.0234633926,
0.0968104824,
-0.6696186662,
0.8169555664,
-0.3678730726,
-0.3157281876,
-0.4209655821,
-0.3761403263,
0.3660272658,
-0.3285561502,
0.2510397732,
0.1316828579,
0.0083464999,
0.6706904173,
-0.2934001088,
0.477299124,
0.2273395509,
-0.3199158013,
0.1616629511,
0.391689539,
0.5684690475,
-0.0619810782,
-0.3226636946,
0.5133479238,
-0.158925876,
-0.2596435845,
-0.696544528,
0.9882731438,
-0.6928873658,
-0.5365142226,
-0.1864242554,
-0.6160854697,
-0.2442226559,
0.253995955,
0.1594564468,
0.0634748638,
-0.2167928368,
0.5302727818,
0.4646225274,
-0.4104757011,
0.2652578354,
0.7464863658,
-0.3214535415,
-0.1829797924,
0.651224196,
0.129177317,
0.5267781615,
0.4733460248,
0.2724818885,
-0.1187487841,
-0.5934678912,
-0.6996694803,
0.4091137052,
-0.7894359827,
-0.1246107966,
-0.2752852142,
-0.2876513898,
-0.0469191819,
0.1847237051,
-0.5502128005,
-0.0996202826,
-0.2842305303,
-0.0792314038,
-0.1215273812,
0.8648221493,
0.2344714999,
0.3294236958,
-1.1416178942,
0.0804480836,
0.158367753,
0.3905332088,
0.0600660592,
-0.8408770561,
-0.6416895986,
0.2086914331,
-0.1779927462,
-0.9187389612,
0.2370251268,
-0.2331458777,
0.7245900631,
0.2318965197,
-0.2898575962,
0.560880363,
-0.666082859,
0.7031652331,
-0.0908211768,
-0.9974682927,
0.2568000853,
-0.1654448062,
0.5583840013,
0.4313408136,
0.3689052165,
-0.4460887909,
-0.5205801725,
-0.2054302692,
-0.6050242186,
0.7545995712,
0.2459646016,
0.1315618455,
0.2275574356,
0.308830142,
0.1558525562,
0.1778097153,
-0.7498485446,
-0.1669900119,
0.1798436195,
0.080739446,
-0.5128892064,
-0.5095182061,
-0.1542326808,
-0.1019003913,
0.481412828,
0.0370058678,
0.0094995536,
0.3148170412,
-0.3666704297,
-0.565877974,
0.1928846687,
0.5655339956,
0.756583035,
-0.0801843181,
0.2123536468,
0.208765924,
-0.1050030068,
-0.0645610392,
-0.107363306,
-0.3317719698,
0.4365155697,
0.7334106565,
1.0350483656,
0.4439395368,
-0.648427248,
0.1332698911,
0.1356741041,
0.0046587624,
-0.0436361842,
-0.0523472913,
0.1313238442,
0.2698076367,
0.4425987899,
-0.0262121093,
0.1499264538,
-0.7911530137,
-0.0327058025,
0.5744000673,
-0.3478987813,
-0.3062538505,
0.5281822681,
0.0398663022,
-0.4221725166,
0.5248985887,
0.1595544964,
-0.503692925,
0.3314058781,
0.5403240919,
0.9496773481,
-0.3212856948,
0.0154906688,
0.1338624358,
0.601329565,
-0.0646995455,
-0.1735103726,
0.1933696419,
-0.5092609525,
-0.7846236825,
-0.6987674236,
-0.3953394592,
0.3633634746,
-0.4435453713,
0.2295737863,
0.0738164857,
-0.0808753893,
-0.1836079806,
-0.149224326,
-0.8543239236,
0.0824755877,
0.1933048517,
1.0788117647,
-0.7439014912,
0.9706362486,
0.5324266553,
-0.3995650113,
-0.7846196294,
0.1816292405,
-0.2555260658,
-0.8306599259,
1.0441038609,
-0.2256218791,
-0.2837656736,
-0.2738339007,
-0.4617374837,
-1.2459554672,
0.6535047293,
0.765083611,
-0.7396579981,
0.0556968488,
0.2389246374,
0.6305378675,
-0.2619429231,
0.3016316891,
0.6806986332,
0.5283355117,
0.1262288094,
-1.3408210278,
0.1385796368,
-0.1110071018,
0.1862353086,
0.2156125903,
-0.5905500054,
0.6448396444,
-0.1082377061,
-0.0603312328,
-0.1678169221,
0.3873561621,
-0.0199429188,
0.1890888959,
0.1859026253,
0.243574366,
0.317237705,
0.0023311023,
1.3597812653,
-0.3135208488,
0.3790741861,
1.0763430595,
-0.2285507619,
1.030376792,
0.7529129982,
-0.0600122288,
0.2621545196,
0.5420930386,
0.0217926614,
0.3737552166,
0.3266803622,
0.1771420836,
-0.1215826795,
-0.1659376174,
-0.1540852487,
0.4262217879,
0.1953624636,
-0.7797163725,
-0.3023781478,
0.0053087687,
-0.0170411952,
-0.0032393932,
-0.3768666983,
0.624810636,
0.3028932512,
-0.7960840464,
0.9243651628,
0.2573274076,
0.1247082055,
-0.6559110284,
-0.0754392669,
-0.3016143143,
0.1625438184,
0.0198145509,
-0.6993099451,
0.4352915287,
0.0160957333,
-0.3141932786,
-0.2017302662,
0.470428884,
-0.4222902954,
-0.4928947389,
0.6016438603,
0.4471437633,
0.2595349252,
-0.1625826657,
-0.5594493747,
0.538431704,
-0.0466242768,
-0.4307319522,
0.492033124,
0.7123212814,
-0.1748851836,
0.7577161789,
0.4978884459,
0.3731009066,
-0.1292409897,
0.1373223364,
0.7699561119,
-0.8025039434,
0.1071579829,
-1.0263639688,
0.1656679958,
0.0468849093,
-0.220005095,
1.0611296892,
0.6083151102,
1.2102030516,
-0.4000312984,
0.7696387172,
0.2191428542,
0.4383131564,
-0.6054331064,
0.5805041194,
-0.6274805069,
0.2467388213,
-0.3713015318,
-1.0824090242,
-0.1087660417,
0.2929034531,
-0.362649411,
-0.0739557296,
0.8898485899,
0.5552132726,
-0.1098991632,
-0.5164697766,
0.5353911519,
0.340310365,
0.118713066,
0.4673325717,
0.8258093596,
-0.4297270179,
0.6571478844,
0.0167398714,
-0.0893471688,
-0.4309232831,
-0.7708570957,
-0.7059280276,
-0.5464122295,
0.1024762094,
-0.2559377253,
-0.0464441292,
0.8699489236,
0.5150584579,
-0.8862035275,
-0.592680335,
0.1581059843,
0.2925316989,
-0.0499940962,
-0.1925164908,
0.2181974053,
-0.4805630744,
-1.1250984669,
0.6474936604,
0.2274664789,
-0.0054267617,
-0.3934344351,
-0.2719795108,
0.0364453532,
-0.0153697552,
0.627119422,
-0.1174603254,
-0.8180924654,
-0.0505478419,
0.0349036977,
-0.4074470997,
-0.3239745796,
1.0565807819,
-0.4403595328,
0.4618727267,
0.6106328368,
0.8580808043,
0.3650090694,
0.0603667609,
1.0937544107,
-0.2888238132,
0.0260576662,
0.1419093758,
0.485394299,
0.2891066074,
-0.1731810868,
0.4823799729,
0.1846418679,
-0.656157434,
-0.832942307,
-0.0916046128,
-0.7254295349,
-0.4561092854,
1.4415751696,
-0.1539612859,
-0.0799501985,
0.2546980679,
-0.3886283636,
0.3743000031,
-0.1660150439,
0.6660401821,
1.1027108431,
0.1994416565,
-0.1080223992,
-0.9781876802,
0.3791484237,
0.484146893,
-0.3274826109,
0.0306141954,
0.6935946345,
0.358453244,
0.1147129387,
0.1315118074,
-0.1630628258,
-0.0021658407,
-0.2135377079,
-0.1473536789,
0.0624242127,
-0.2840488851,
-0.6491644979,
0.1898022592,
0.5526621938,
-0.0567901768
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06561v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06561v3
|
Intention Analysis Makes LLMs A Good Jailbreak Defender
| 2024-01-12T13:15:05 | 2024-04-29T16:40:57 |
Yuqi Zhang, Liang Ding, Lefei Zhang, Dacheng Tao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Aligning large language models (LLMs) with human values, particularly in the
face of complex and stealthy jailbreak attacks, presents a formidable
challenge. In this study, we present a simple yet highly effective defense
strategy, i.e., Intention Analysis ($\mathbb{IA}$). The principle behind this
is to trigger LLMs' inherent self-correct and improve ability through a
two-stage process: 1) essential intention analysis, and 2) policy-aligned
response. Notably, $\mathbb{IA}$ is an inference-only method, thus could
enhance the safety of LLMs without compromising their helpfulness. Extensive
experiments on varying jailbreak benchmarks across ChatGLM, LLaMA2, Vicuna,
MPT, DeepSeek, and GPT-3.5 show that $\mathbb{IA}$ could consistently and
significantly reduce the harmfulness in responses (averagely -53.1% attack
success rate) and maintain the general helpfulness. Encouragingly, with the
help of our $\mathbb{IA}$, Vicuna-7B even outperforms GPT-3.5 in terms of
attack success rate. Further analyses present some insights into how our method
works. To facilitate reproducibility, we release our code and scripts at:
https://github.com/alphadl/SafeLLM_with_IntentionAnalysis.
|
[
-0.176377818,
-0.8785835505,
0.8969966173,
0.2279563844,
-0.2999287844,
-0.0289378297,
-0.2434808016,
-0.3244038522,
0.2858706415,
0.5460883379,
-0.3334515691,
-0.6718366742,
-0.5698464513,
-0.2733218074,
-0.4141830206,
0.9077788591,
-0.0720821917,
-0.0629902855,
0.3346857727,
-0.0979810283,
-0.7685340643,
-0.2608865798,
-0.7335301042,
0.042382326,
0.5022305846,
0.494212389,
0.5097386241,
0.5719982386,
0.5378693938,
0.2007413805,
0.0994555876,
0.1459613889,
-0.4517417252,
0.2831536829,
-0.0982497185,
-0.415515691,
-0.4576233625,
0.064214766,
0.168860659,
0.0611321554,
-0.2852053642,
-0.0762775615,
-0.1263993382,
0.8291559815,
-0.8215165734,
-0.4980627298,
-0.7636417747,
-0.2098126858,
-0.2427473813,
0.0357993022,
-0.6252400279,
-0.2904764116,
-0.1804056168,
-0.1443060338,
-0.3386092782,
0.1348028481,
0.6712799072,
0.2887221277,
-0.3010526597,
-0.2467501014,
-0.446356684,
0.4557093084,
-0.9835028648,
0.0167865455,
0.3569905758,
0.2731050849,
-0.6278403401,
-0.2306638658,
-0.27534917,
-0.3000926673,
0.0452431664,
0.0235391222,
-0.2777636647,
0.3856063187,
0.1790031791,
0.0588457808,
-0.3389982283,
0.2583993375,
-0.3030780554,
-0.1863106191,
0.8350349665,
0.0261311196,
0.5021476746,
-0.231575191,
-0.4560343027,
0.0900441632,
-1.0611099005,
0.1811316907,
0.5699243546,
0.0359565318,
-0.1275449246,
0.657497108,
-0.1087398753,
0.4794433713,
0.1223587692,
-0.1336059719,
-0.0931910574,
-0.0576607585,
-0.1594985127,
0.3040938079,
1.1048177481,
0.4896416664,
0.2302052379,
-0.2500727475,
-0.2941420078,
0.0160446428,
0.6970646381,
-0.9328921437,
-0.0710245296,
0.6177617311,
-0.3052889407,
-0.5860486627,
0.1882881373,
-0.5092971921,
-0.6541355252,
0.0579992421,
0.5623562932,
-0.5691836476,
-0.163888827,
0.1986268461,
0.1024864167,
0.4023432136,
0.0609718151,
-0.9090095758,
0.2175085545,
0.9128604531,
0.8247264624,
-0.163573876,
-0.11851798,
-0.7001248002,
0.2451957315,
-0.5188343525,
0.6259439588,
0.0163318291,
-0.4344004691,
-0.3310790658,
-0.3967049718,
0.0548347719,
-0.3328832984,
0.7925597429,
-0.4737591147,
-0.3195283711,
-0.0184132103,
-0.5391503572,
-0.1544625312,
0.4737077653,
-0.5097699165,
0.6607335806,
-0.3067846,
-0.6412988901,
0.3170810342,
-0.6877251863,
-0.5427448153,
-0.2615110278,
-0.1360093355,
-0.4459929764,
0.4196454287,
0.2844387591,
0.4518032074,
-0.1079828814,
0.565158546,
-0.4593908787,
-0.2465817034,
0.3837606609,
-0.562414825,
0.6224421263,
0.3607892692,
-0.7065333724,
0.2994118929,
-0.5493795276,
0.0277796853,
0.2611340284,
-0.2495946437,
-0.4489701688,
0.3743932247,
-0.5759961605,
0.0496898182,
0.1947729737,
-0.7287541628,
0.2994285524,
-0.4547311068,
0.2837361991,
0.9647593498,
0.0595311001,
0.3520749807,
-0.0122556016,
0.411056906,
-0.2342260033,
0.5648008585,
-0.0621706396,
-0.3296044767,
-0.6944922805,
-0.3451279402,
0.1017896831,
0.5726422071,
-0.1639562696,
0.5162081718,
-0.0715992525,
-0.4608878195,
-0.6533042789,
0.3594363928,
0.6626808047,
0.1738098562,
0.2780850232,
-0.4169035256,
-0.6260775924,
-1.0114127398,
-0.6450281143,
-0.4714231193,
0.2544228137,
0.0355746374,
-0.0478511453,
-0.2835413218,
0.9469619393,
-0.4609211981,
-0.0116608907,
-0.471573174,
-0.1893642396,
0.3064033389,
0.3570289314,
0.6857933998,
-0.4963361919,
-0.4773758054,
-0.19556427,
-0.9582455754,
-0.4308309555,
-0.185284242,
-0.3885117471,
0.1057728529,
0.5056068301,
-0.6391798258,
0.6867716312,
0.4227991104,
-0.5832796693,
0.5313002467,
0.1062724516,
0.1540863663,
-0.9343841076,
-0.2778118551,
0.0347280651,
-0.2442256659,
-0.9709306955,
0.192648679,
0.2500209212,
0.2219608575,
-0.6191962957,
0.7292529345,
-0.3141076565,
0.1427777559,
-0.5699508786,
0.0292816311,
-0.1851035208,
0.0951954722,
-0.333853662,
0.8209037185,
0.4226180017,
-0.5051543713,
0.0204844773,
-0.0442895889,
-0.4122078717,
0.4133629799,
-0.6757202148,
0.2946918905,
-0.0211798605,
-0.1186465621,
-0.9897963405,
-0.1995100826,
0.5361917615,
-0.3993011713,
0.2203086168,
-0.4339147806,
-0.2303927988,
-0.2501698136,
-0.4699150622,
0.1302539408,
0.4125000238,
-0.6552708149,
0.8311857581,
0.4010355473,
-0.0306351297,
-0.7354341149,
-0.463351965,
0.3381848931,
-0.6394453645,
-0.7618278265,
0.0930516794,
-0.1724953949,
-0.7276795506,
-0.3307009935,
-0.2896004617,
0.2585637271,
0.4982657731,
0.3856060505,
0.4669290185,
0.0907436833,
-0.2227752507,
-0.0172068868,
-0.1350119561,
0.3809046447,
-0.1741842628,
0.5480265021,
-0.2834006548,
-0.5554003716,
-0.4389963448,
-0.0350583009,
0.5103138685,
-0.0054138643,
0.7462531924,
0.2562060952,
0.1012332737,
0.0226345882,
-0.8186506033,
-0.1385939568,
-0.5216833353,
0.0838418603,
-0.4570732415,
-0.6375346184,
0.3012453914,
0.1294356883,
0.2959024906,
0.0895148814,
0.3575373888,
-0.1398731023,
0.8496197462,
0.393557936,
-0.5032724142,
0.5114594102,
0.014195702,
0.5345826149,
-1.0417684317,
-0.1009758934,
-0.1253075004,
-0.2943970561,
-0.3961455524,
-0.0048944084,
0.1164979264,
0.3811698854,
-0.190860793,
0.6591529846,
-0.3212726712,
0.5525726676,
0.2802121043,
0.2784469128,
0.161605373,
-0.2426907122,
0.0681851804,
0.1155205742,
-0.2137214541,
-0.7055698633,
1.4124764204,
0.5650321245,
0.9913853407,
0.5550612807,
1.1746532917,
0.1848517954,
0.5385094881,
-0.8121017218,
0.7277216911,
0.0877627879,
-0.6676194668,
-0.1244188324,
-0.296695143,
-0.834438026,
0.469731003,
-0.0204766989,
-1.1709033251,
-0.0761226043,
0.3816947639,
-0.2672722042,
0.1949318796,
-1.044716239,
0.8491680622,
-0.9573400021,
-0.6469378471,
-0.2832827568,
-0.5969525576,
0.7170243859,
-0.256596446,
0.3982033432,
-0.5484239459,
0.0130610159,
0.6706900597,
-0.3179220557,
0.8232218623,
-0.4230303764,
-0.1242890432,
0.4926128387,
0.332616955,
0.6872102022,
0.3016297519,
-0.0551545881,
0.0053919461,
-0.3974838853,
-0.2244667858,
-0.5966957211,
0.635643959,
-0.4928472042,
-1.3126088381,
-0.2327408195,
-0.4051688313,
0.0034536454,
0.3878724575,
-0.0151493754,
0.0153829446,
-0.4495678544,
0.1490973979,
0.7783771753,
-0.1004616693,
0.546742022,
0.6378953457,
-0.3792635202,
-0.3719481826,
0.4590651095,
-0.3556983173,
0.4843070805,
0.123105377,
0.5189262629,
-0.2600251734,
-0.7987257242,
-0.2999292016,
0.0696222484,
-0.5290532112,
-0.3292020559,
-0.6850280762,
-0.124147743,
-0.3310601711,
-0.1448574513,
-0.4017955363,
-0.2108739913,
0.3053339422,
-0.3182184994,
0.3833053708,
0.5898527503,
-0.313508302,
0.4705961049,
-0.5717432499,
0.4630244672,
0.1329597235,
0.0215113126,
-0.1628184617,
-0.4858576059,
-0.0418369658,
-0.0486873724,
-0.4324066937,
-1.0273917913,
0.2852907479,
-0.0676082075,
0.6680501103,
0.6839273572,
0.1545467228,
0.5763069987,
-0.3574424088,
0.3639348447,
0.2252105474,
-0.9058606625,
0.9404377937,
-0.3419488072,
-0.0272728782,
0.9155985713,
-0.0406997241,
-0.4013474584,
-0.5275595188,
-0.6417847276,
-0.940346539,
0.5755052567,
0.3965488374,
0.1120337173,
-0.0905096233,
0.4947839975,
-0.2091112584,
0.0469466113,
-0.9636156559,
-0.2204761654,
0.0922504365,
-0.3235234916,
0.1849383116,
-0.3299007118,
-0.3674881756,
-0.063816607,
0.8406531811,
0.1006039977,
0.0250774827,
-0.0599109866,
-0.2216915488,
0.32951653,
0.5836396217,
0.4686713219,
0.4102929831,
-0.2359698713,
0.2296513617,
0.0878860876,
-0.6696306467,
0.671019733,
-0.0437574126,
-0.2817081809,
-0.5484388471,
0.1803542823,
0.677431345,
-0.0014295593,
-0.7039179802,
0.715737462,
-0.2401542366,
0.1550637633,
-0.1898953617,
0.591963172,
-0.0267016347,
0.297958672,
0.2469692081,
-0.1367083788,
0.1180561557,
-0.5278634429,
0.0778579861,
0.6802211404,
-0.2905974686,
-0.0865718052,
0.5624006391,
0.1095765084,
-0.4812817574,
0.4677045643,
-0.2617349923,
-0.5699269176,
0.6936275363,
0.6563190818,
1.1365237236,
-0.3349722624,
-0.0241797417,
0.2198962569,
0.6410443783,
-0.0994750112,
0.0946852863,
0.0623866804,
-0.8189275265,
-0.3450731933,
-0.4657974839,
-0.0136103537,
0.1131258979,
-0.4351827204,
0.2659370899,
-0.6300523281,
-0.1239642724,
-0.1570047289,
-0.3138825297,
-0.1425064802,
0.0505309179,
-0.0633604527,
0.9956108332,
-0.6528071761,
0.8395940065,
0.3919176161,
-0.1422828734,
-1.0097674131,
0.2087197453,
0.4177228212,
-0.8696930408,
0.4447352588,
0.5500816703,
-0.3430419564,
-0.2905264497,
-0.6081585288,
-0.819077611,
0.864739418,
0.2616762519,
-0.929620266,
0.3173797131,
-0.1478698254,
0.2160726339,
-0.2954876721,
0.0808195695,
1.0147335529,
0.5078914165,
-0.1561755538,
-0.4327716827,
0.1365733147,
-0.1522714347,
-0.1188527793,
0.6573548913,
-0.4937637448,
0.0979649648,
-0.5893477798,
-0.1076686606,
0.1327188462,
0.667134583,
0.6873924136,
0.1958649009,
0.5354288816,
0.7805970907,
0.4682174921,
-0.1213890538,
0.9570032358,
-0.3802892268,
-0.0662111491,
1.2029736042,
-0.1630993038,
0.8136363029,
0.742203474,
0.0340200625,
0.3571505249,
0.464361757,
0.1212525442,
0.7978079319,
0.2313374281,
-0.3429318964,
-0.1476852745,
0.3045246005,
-0.0367903113,
0.5204622149,
0.4178022444,
-0.230532676,
0.0992225334,
-0.0113747837,
0.6204943657,
-0.0191153232,
-0.2109962851,
0.9242413044,
0.1473827809,
-0.955489397,
0.2917940617,
0.1500695199,
0.6309821606,
-0.6863551736,
0.3319935501,
-0.371221602,
0.3194244504,
-0.3262349069,
-0.9074893594,
0.1483823806,
0.2490785867,
0.0852874443,
0.1917224377,
0.762767911,
-0.0494433492,
-0.1102010086,
0.5240393281,
-0.0766239688,
0.0582999922,
-0.0163599066,
-0.5170742273,
0.3295818269,
0.1337249577,
-0.3253935277,
0.3718761802,
0.0073359623,
-0.0746845827,
0.7681651115,
0.5606620908,
0.0925078914,
0.1118339822,
0.0167836584,
0.8341819644,
-0.5352838039,
-0.3237443268,
-1.3810048103,
0.6334789991,
-0.2947777808,
-0.0236239824,
0.8661745191,
0.6178700328,
0.4929386675,
0.3685147166,
0.7541919947,
-0.3228570223,
0.0106764361,
-0.8870042562,
0.5682398677,
-0.1669125408,
0.7928012013,
-0.3234374225,
-0.8960404992,
-0.1852720529,
0.6255088449,
-0.6393429637,
-0.1546102017,
0.5899351239,
0.9044482708,
0.1138596237,
-0.2159029841,
0.233063817,
0.1820051223,
0.7072586417,
0.5680494308,
0.9892601967,
-0.5147135854,
0.5090326071,
-0.1970067918,
-0.4778172076,
-0.114460513,
-0.9498233199,
-1.0540568829,
0.1084791943,
0.0087070633,
-0.512147367,
0.4526407123,
0.8447086215,
0.6596125364,
-0.6115589738,
-0.245170027,
-0.2364225984,
-0.0401674584,
0.0567168444,
-0.1475740969,
0.1511518508,
-0.4915620983,
-0.1353632808,
0.7542976737,
0.4539569616,
0.0680366755,
-0.1560288221,
-0.3938156962,
-0.196339041,
0.3184079826,
0.4789770842,
0.4465819299,
-0.8837089539,
-0.4149805307,
-0.2545104623,
-0.2517485917,
0.1330223829,
0.7934067249,
-0.4933965206,
0.4752644598,
0.1527234465,
0.7210713029,
0.356318891,
0.2232020199,
0.6363777518,
-0.5705147386,
0.1947960854,
-0.0281163696,
0.6175956726,
0.1552337706,
-0.6189751625,
0.7102600336,
-0.362604171,
-0.6116935015,
-0.5917597413,
0.4069812596,
-0.7187922001,
-0.3862431645,
1.3531633615,
-0.0895635784,
-0.384236753,
0.0613884889,
-0.395316124,
-0.1359453946,
-0.6004694104,
1.0077073574,
0.5599099994,
-0.1047365293,
-0.0896340087,
-0.4956813753,
0.3864870965,
0.3190237284,
-1.187199235,
0.121541366,
0.4081155062,
0.4034445882,
0.0080734547,
0.7293275595,
-0.2791237831,
0.3576303124,
-0.3953696787,
0.0031621347,
0.0491524599,
-0.6197242141,
-0.288908571,
-0.1177614033,
0.537153244,
-0.1879440248
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.10279v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.10279v1
|
A systematic review of geospatial location embedding approaches in large language models: A path to spatial AI systems
| 2024-01-12T12:43:33 | 2024-01-12T12:43:33 |
Sean Tucker
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Geospatial Location Embedding (GLE) helps a Large Language Model (LLM)
assimilate and analyze spatial data. GLE emergence in Geospatial Artificial
Intelligence (GeoAI) is precipitated by the need for deeper geospatial
awareness in our complex contemporary spaces and the success of LLMs in
extracting deep meaning in Generative AI. We searched Google Scholar, Science
Direct, and arXiv for papers on geospatial location embedding and LLM and
reviewed articles focused on gaining deeper spatial "knowing" through LLMs. We
screened 304 titles, 30 abstracts, and 18 full-text papers that reveal four GLE
themes - Entity Location Embedding (ELE), Document Location Embedding (DLE),
Sequence Location Embedding (SLE), and Token Location Embedding (TLE).
Synthesis is tabular and narrative, including a dialogic conversation between
"Space" and "LLM." Though GLEs aid spatial understanding by superimposing
spatial data, they emphasize the need to advance in the intricacies of spatial
modalities and generalized reasoning. GLEs signal the need for a Spatial
Foundation/Language Model (SLM) that embeds spatial knowing within the model
architecture. The SLM framework advances Spatial Artificial Intelligence
Systems (SPAIS), establishing a Spatial Vector Space (SVS) that maps to
physical space. The resulting spatially imbued Language Model is unique. It
simultaneously represents actual space and an AI-capable space, paving the way
for AI native geo storage, analysis, and multi-modality as the basis for
Spatial Artificial Intelligence Systems (SPAIS).
|
[
-0.4235637188,
-0.8801028728,
1.1634669304,
-0.0663373917,
0.2145622522,
-0.0610906407,
-0.277987659,
-0.52474612,
0.2986087501,
0.148197338,
-0.1745241135,
-0.8075777292,
-0.5157487988,
-0.2875640392,
-0.5807324052,
0.6225759387,
-0.1767933816,
-0.0471620485,
-0.2949311435,
-0.1263144314,
-0.3134656847,
-0.6626108289,
-0.2660722136,
-0.2687197626,
0.2571000457,
0.1770236641,
0.9038876891,
0.4201764762,
0.3243916631,
0.3177493513,
-0.2034083307,
0.1184430718,
-0.2495144457,
-0.001535153,
-0.3694216311,
-0.1566588432,
-0.153474912,
-0.0489719026,
0.9136116505,
0.7898472548,
-0.319750011,
-0.1477051824,
-0.1460934728,
0.3303477764,
-0.5678532124,
-0.246010825,
-0.3493974507,
0.07963074,
-0.0704542249,
-0.012513265,
-0.2050300688,
-0.2959565818,
0.4862676263,
-0.5056912303,
0.3034965396,
0.3988072574,
0.6644080281,
0.1655628532,
-0.5270033479,
-0.570551753,
-1.0179172754,
0.7094957829,
-0.4566106498,
0.5524377227,
0.3898390234,
0.3575602472,
-0.2724244297,
-0.4093521833,
-0.4736740589,
-0.3573961556,
-0.3515753448,
-0.0181511864,
0.0967016071,
-0.1573400348,
0.2709639072,
0.1092421263,
-0.7279934883,
0.0804672018,
-0.2903337479,
0.1706563085,
0.5530228615,
0.0446531177,
0.4775453806,
0.021297913,
-0.1773196459,
0.1678941697,
-0.9895167351,
-0.1229062527,
0.1309960186,
0.1616042852,
-0.268414855,
0.5956010818,
-0.0600334965,
0.4565126896,
-0.3109443486,
-0.0737969428,
0.2648453116,
-0.4695958793,
-0.1678105444,
-0.1599721462,
0.6349645853,
-0.0981195495,
0.085458599,
-0.3179210126,
-0.1587386131,
-0.2131369263,
0.2498072684,
-0.2826882005,
0.0043190941,
0.3445889354,
-0.1237259135,
0.2797933221,
0.2614314854,
-0.5189581513,
-0.5229474902,
-0.3011238873,
-0.1403446048,
-0.4924404323,
-0.1044577062,
-0.170976311,
0.0372353457,
0.4903055727,
0.365888387,
-1.0424562693,
0.1634966284,
0.8962888718,
0.9914933443,
0.0951179415,
-0.7821105123,
0.0573169366,
0.5329992175,
-0.5017511845,
0.8821196556,
-0.6193138957,
-0.4544475973,
0.3746529222,
-0.0726749375,
-0.0822685286,
-0.2987670004,
0.4667481184,
-0.4306394756,
0.2744252384,
-0.350048542,
-0.3372374773,
-0.4670756757,
0.1724316776,
-0.5157455206,
1.0709023476,
-0.2720580101,
-0.3695914745,
0.5470715165,
-0.7577300668,
-0.3700276017,
0.1818657666,
-0.3186926842,
-0.0099553568,
0.3393479884,
0.5695302486,
0.321036011,
-0.0612974912,
0.4751197398,
-0.2692952752,
-0.4436097741,
0.0379237272,
-0.0433381163,
0.4397737682,
0.1309990883,
-0.4084042609,
0.0652570277,
-0.1980249286,
0.0305897295,
0.1618565917,
-0.0550950691,
-0.5186410546,
0.6546926498,
-0.0961836129,
-0.0809352845,
0.3247482479,
-0.3085680604,
0.0645663142,
-0.6324651837,
0.5175641775,
0.3702843487,
-0.0119847581,
1.1290813684,
-0.0622293241,
0.1615941972,
-0.2745527029,
0.134269461,
-0.1180711761,
-0.4331438541,
-0.2626413703,
-0.1075938344,
-0.1066621467,
0.7282730937,
-0.2927631736,
0.602103591,
-0.3845349848,
-0.651131928,
-0.2963519692,
0.0622397661,
-0.0826439485,
0.105406411,
0.3513460159,
0.3370348811,
-0.264198482,
-0.7399792671,
0.18364577,
-0.0125770001,
0.1183635071,
0.6030741334,
0.6897572279,
-0.5017322302,
0.8843744397,
-0.3215584457,
-0.1586241424,
-0.1886263788,
-0.300128758,
0.1630899906,
0.1856879443,
0.7026768923,
-0.6893271208,
-0.3001086712,
0.1352557242,
-0.9985976815,
0.1390908659,
0.1241659224,
-0.2932997942,
0.097817339,
0.3100714386,
-0.7602317929,
0.4845964313,
0.5274470448,
-0.3899993598,
0.222847864,
-0.3601644635,
0.2950032353,
-0.7825626731,
0.1798206121,
0.0219815243,
0.0962404758,
-0.646803081,
0.3316889703,
-0.1146879271,
-0.3108468354,
-0.2072303891,
0.6934705973,
-0.7219670415,
-0.5001314878,
-0.198277384,
0.657972753,
-0.1167452559,
0.0924004689,
0.12936005,
0.7156407237,
0.4225524068,
-0.3426983953,
0.1636446714,
0.2667469084,
-0.3722089827,
0.1678511947,
-0.5892322659,
0.1075114235,
-0.1920012385,
0.4022304416,
-1.1581786871,
-0.0669017583,
0.1904741973,
-0.2088352889,
0.1076384485,
-0.2709672153,
-0.3924285471,
-0.3723252416,
-0.1451286674,
0.6136826277,
0.2668862045,
-0.5688055158,
0.6096500158,
0.6085430384,
-0.3312323689,
-0.40797925,
-0.7166614532,
0.2109817266,
-0.2156230062,
-0.4400640726,
0.1062966883,
0.212917313,
-0.4294026196,
0.2736823857,
0.2963948846,
-0.0555253252,
0.3319250345,
0.3447502553,
0.0186662301,
-0.0045183785,
0.22110264,
-0.3263216913,
-0.1018553227,
0.2018902004,
-0.5015072823,
0.4687782824,
-0.1214440092,
-0.673550725,
-0.2369264364,
0.6632778049,
0.4585035741,
-0.216668576,
0.7094319463,
0.4958554804,
-0.5837829709,
-0.2698296309,
-0.3946147859,
0.1370174289,
-0.3876066804,
0.4574641883,
-0.1318825483,
-1.0464749336,
0.5357243419,
-0.2204592675,
0.0057992777,
0.314807713,
0.4672470391,
-0.3799513876,
0.7608990669,
0.7934171557,
-0.5370689631,
0.5407965779,
-0.2309188396,
0.8621485829,
-0.7208720446,
-0.3517166376,
-0.7219390273,
-0.5131313205,
-0.5249788761,
-0.492123127,
0.2361660302,
0.0039312071,
-0.5123867393,
-0.2734305859,
-0.4943897724,
0.6077000499,
0.5079251528,
-0.158875227,
-0.2097524852,
0.5647247434,
-0.0247921441,
-0.1966941506,
-0.645263195,
-0.6025826931,
0.8678176999,
0.3685494065,
0.7208302617,
0.341765821,
0.5996604562,
0.3735739887,
0.2665131688,
-0.8170130849,
0.465710789,
-0.0946609899,
-0.308329314,
-0.5564103723,
-0.0325122774,
-0.7921205759,
0.1005298495,
-0.1153125018,
-0.9149854183,
0.0529603325,
-0.0851599723,
-0.381958425,
0.4107102156,
-0.7512702346,
0.3933694363,
-0.5666871071,
-0.2467916012,
-0.2946173549,
-0.3171506226,
0.0650848448,
0.298445344,
0.4921339154,
-0.0318047889,
-0.0281862114,
0.4359143972,
-0.1337210089,
0.7655497789,
-0.5795668364,
-0.2160351425,
0.3623632789,
0.044853095,
0.4205980301,
0.1134374589,
0.167121172,
0.5317252874,
-0.3731397688,
-0.2789216042,
-0.7116801143,
0.9957094193,
-0.9138985872,
-0.6766062379,
-0.4124881923,
-0.4291490614,
-0.1828017235,
0.0400261842,
0.0711483732,
0.4068474472,
-0.2195065767,
-0.1153773591,
0.6579669714,
-0.3668878675,
0.1890335679,
0.1195125729,
-0.3880730271,
-0.6237568259,
0.6227284074,
0.1508706957,
-0.3314391673,
0.4532567561,
0.0578999855,
-0.6131593585,
-0.714287281,
-0.0776269808,
0.555967927,
-0.6304081678,
0.1320036054,
-0.2822580636,
-0.2872997224,
-0.4438691735,
-0.8399960995,
-0.0489200801,
-0.0677292198,
0.1066220999,
-0.241842851,
0.1801120192,
1.314853549,
0.0196337234,
0.3386786282,
-0.543917954,
-0.1499776244,
-0.1774508208,
0.1557758003,
0.0878391936,
-0.2985534966,
-0.5138776898,
0.2305805534,
0.1777008921,
-0.8537374139,
0.3191336393,
-0.0487430841,
0.9411240816,
0.1246454567,
-0.5439095497,
0.7901268601,
-0.7549532056,
1.087010026,
-0.102396749,
-0.6959930658,
0.945396781,
-0.3310825825,
0.2186364979,
0.1050898358,
0.4847117364,
-0.4662916958,
-0.1167115867,
-0.2406491488,
-1.1638438702,
0.2070136666,
-0.3829283118,
0.0715770349,
-0.1349278092,
0.5747290254,
-0.2188670635,
0.1185690537,
-0.7478142977,
-0.0600148737,
0.1651739031,
-0.0890130103,
-0.4044566154,
-0.616701901,
-0.4696911275,
-0.0466512702,
0.4986227751,
-0.1001435146,
0.6629193425,
0.4917785227,
-0.4123292267,
0.11859373,
0.3473780453,
0.7029680014,
0.715498209,
0.062591657,
0.1728107035,
0.347787112,
-0.3330235481,
0.1858222485,
-0.0841822103,
-0.5973012447,
-0.1300611794,
0.5170168281,
0.5219154358,
0.2476000935,
-0.3321457505,
0.4339545071,
0.2461018115,
-0.1587656885,
-0.5900794268,
-0.235445112,
0.0576735437,
0.5080006719,
0.434024632,
-0.2038549781,
0.1535935849,
-0.295943737,
-0.0880933106,
0.6569313407,
-0.0611932278,
-0.3211369514,
0.4712524712,
0.0733816102,
-0.100772664,
0.786790669,
-0.1587098539,
-0.3239607215,
0.2681209445,
0.5086806417,
0.8752815127,
-0.1426583678,
0.1424482018,
0.5187972784,
0.6311928034,
-0.0264784042,
0.2584291399,
-0.0681709573,
-0.7389780283,
-0.419950366,
-0.4454601109,
-0.2744822204,
-0.1541758329,
-0.0671097338,
-0.0883318409,
-0.6901556253,
-0.1339530051,
-0.6171666384,
0.1357707083,
-0.6868308783,
-0.0824969411,
0.5434554219,
1.0566643476,
-0.9793893099,
0.4837888181,
1.1868231297,
0.163564235,
-0.565769136,
0.0931024179,
-0.0163350925,
-0.5498509407,
0.5073710084,
0.0327512547,
-0.2785852849,
-0.2681129277,
-0.8636098504,
-1.2138631344,
1.4383590221,
0.130347088,
-0.5639516711,
-0.2067318559,
0.2051921785,
0.6493325233,
-0.340256542,
0.334256798,
0.3310139477,
0.3610943258,
-0.1554047018,
-0.5998694301,
0.0233206581,
-0.02443696,
0.2573729753,
0.1751929969,
-0.5063068867,
0.5431813598,
-0.3693152666,
-0.3756082356,
0.2671599984,
0.5868176222,
0.387907356,
0.2720236182,
0.1428057253,
0.9417488575,
1.0285363197,
-0.3488479555,
1.0801941156,
-0.251061976,
0.2760351598,
0.9654077291,
-0.6896634102,
1.1372140646,
0.3982147276,
-0.042906981,
0.7738916278,
0.4792295694,
0.0786099285,
0.756088376,
0.0705755427,
-0.1459144354,
0.0121666947,
-0.0037589762,
-0.5125458837,
0.2775964141,
0.8161924481,
-0.2357931286,
-0.3943194151,
-0.0955615267,
-0.1173907593,
0.0888311937,
-0.1758234054,
0.6730617881,
-0.0559303723,
-0.4541216195,
0.035592597,
-0.0323022902,
0.2616316676,
-0.864530623,
0.0268241428,
-0.3655461371,
-0.0735596716,
-0.3144291043,
-0.9950481653,
0.3175927401,
-0.2355365753,
-0.2889343798,
-0.3088496923,
0.8172553182,
-0.3425573707,
-0.2019339055,
0.5408807993,
0.8228746057,
0.0298195947,
0.2219080478,
-0.5999345779,
-0.0051503517,
-0.2632084191,
-0.3699369431,
0.2359204143,
0.6982504129,
-0.1786782295,
0.688947618,
0.7487566471,
0.1256738752,
-0.0780638456,
0.1166138202,
0.5565261245,
-1.0142995119,
-0.7398577332,
-0.7224475741,
0.3979876339,
0.023230372,
-0.0267526172,
0.7802633643,
0.3891173601,
0.5597792268,
0.2174385935,
0.9034717083,
-0.1925256401,
0.2203822583,
-0.5169187188,
0.5558106899,
-0.4330999255,
0.2297537476,
-0.0630470216,
-0.9872252345,
-0.4930551648,
0.9444938898,
-0.9102205634,
0.2026206851,
0.7111132145,
0.7242392302,
0.0885303319,
-0.2130747885,
0.2925313413,
0.1482575685,
0.3607398272,
0.5734325647,
1.2210733891,
-0.3229533732,
0.0852802917,
0.0741510615,
-0.2499484271,
-0.0650120527,
-0.7576054931,
-0.5792454481,
-0.5835798383,
0.0133306403,
-0.0863485038,
0.0198559146,
0.6430125833,
0.6856430769,
-0.7794174552,
-0.2096020579,
0.1180104986,
0.2884649336,
0.019978201,
-0.2248567641,
0.2830166519,
-0.2542357147,
-0.6179975867,
0.6915102601,
0.5102575421,
0.1528509855,
-0.3748336732,
-0.2429053485,
-0.30864802,
-0.3638269305,
0.5611291528,
0.342700392,
-0.8415381908,
-0.4865738153,
-0.0893813595,
-0.3570216,
-0.2935138345,
0.8150900006,
-0.5587781072,
-0.0214605387,
0.4702618718,
0.6779904962,
0.0311190393,
0.0415111966,
0.3019022644,
-0.7387179136,
0.2779398859,
-0.0021184918,
0.8005794287,
0.3650255203,
-0.5261088014,
0.6913861632,
0.3288766146,
-0.8791114688,
-0.4353981018,
0.1752031296,
-0.644253552,
-0.2154489756,
1.3676093817,
0.0856175572,
-0.4063101411,
-0.0011311315,
-0.1542022973,
-0.3668149412,
-0.249354735,
0.6596241593,
0.757568121,
0.1283177584,
0.0217279252,
-0.5881017447,
0.1778084785,
0.1537868083,
-0.5884107947,
-0.033288639,
0.9014480114,
0.096139051,
0.537276268,
0.6374664903,
-0.0352552794,
0.0780296475,
-0.0899295062,
0.0937398896,
0.102453962,
-0.6390431523,
-0.4492292404,
0.3088921607,
0.2113936096,
0.2212147564
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06541v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06541v1
|
Medical Dialogue Generation via Intuitive-then-Analytical Differential Diagnosis
| 2024-01-12T12:35:19 | 2024-01-12T12:35:19 |
Kaishuai Xu, Wenjun Hou, Yi Cheng, Jian Wang, Wenjie Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Medical dialogue systems have attracted growing research attention as they
have the potential to provide rapid diagnoses, treatment plans, and health
consultations. In medical dialogues, a proper diagnosis is crucial as it
establishes the foundation for future consultations. Clinicians typically
employ both intuitive and analytic reasoning to formulate a differential
diagnosis. This reasoning process hypothesizes and verifies a variety of
possible diseases and strives to generate a comprehensive and rigorous
diagnosis. However, recent studies on medical dialogue generation have
overlooked the significance of modeling a differential diagnosis, which hinders
the practical application of these systems. To address the above issue, we
propose a medical dialogue generation framework with the
Intuitive-then-Analytic Differential Diagnosis (IADDx). Our method starts with
a differential diagnosis via retrieval-based intuitive association and
subsequently refines it through a graph-enhanced analytic procedure. The
resulting differential diagnosis is then used to retrieve medical knowledge and
guide response generation. Experimental results on two datasets validate the
efficacy of our method. Besides, we demonstrate how our framework assists both
clinicians and patients in understanding the diagnostic process, for instance,
by producing intermediate results and graph-based diagnosis paths.
|
[
-0.6302673817,
-0.8999091387,
1.136277914,
-0.1206644848,
-0.407019496,
0.0950488523,
0.1510938257,
-0.5604122877,
0.5413023233,
0.4914848804,
-0.8966451883,
-0.6190280914,
-0.4864958525,
0.1630449891,
-0.4530903697,
0.8053755164,
0.177101016,
0.3077671528,
-0.2071272135,
-0.1387037486,
-0.6362133026,
-0.128010422,
-1.2891147137,
-0.3327619433,
0.3855147064,
0.2522864938,
0.7935198545,
0.5998937488,
0.1772103757,
0.2992636263,
0.0501387939,
0.4455941319,
-0.2190595418,
0.479698509,
0.0173678119,
-0.351244241,
-0.3887758851,
-0.3544757664,
0.2623984218,
1.1735332012,
-0.1447063237,
-0.0672770441,
-0.2496162355,
0.6469540596,
-0.048166845,
0.1578260362,
-0.278870821,
0.1170030162,
-0.1199409515,
-0.4852242172,
-0.2244692296,
-0.4346125424,
0.2932343483,
-0.8475779295,
0.0503307283,
0.06763459,
0.4020006955,
0.2622982264,
-0.5257539153,
-0.6487230062,
-0.6750919819,
0.1373966485,
-0.7074842453,
0.0625466779,
0.1757896692,
0.6039652228,
-0.3334221542,
-0.8923876286,
-0.5666198134,
-0.2513850033,
-0.0683860928,
0.2406658828,
-0.4072200954,
0.1094049737,
0.3395520747,
0.0569743849,
-0.4701441824,
0.0400896445,
-0.0740164071,
-0.0907197148,
0.5521331429,
0.6374337077,
0.5700069666,
-0.0511883907,
-0.1320093721,
0.1721346974,
-0.6630145311,
-0.1547728181,
0.1337171048,
0.1019074321,
-0.093383275,
0.3916131556,
-0.2451764047,
0.6989254951,
0.3195486069,
-0.3903469443,
0.1003044397,
-0.2014915794,
0.1870379001,
0.2496282458,
0.8255399466,
0.7968885899,
0.0412378088,
0.030354647,
-0.205226481,
0.4263183773,
0.1333991289,
-0.9416744709,
-0.4241845012,
0.4987962842,
-0.6659505963,
-0.3849163353,
-0.5293713808,
-0.8324865699,
-0.5514306426,
-0.3880200982,
0.1954150051,
-0.5474549532,
-0.5168191195,
0.0305201691,
-0.0750429258,
-0.3403926194,
0.4413605928,
-0.72424227,
0.5278304219,
0.189994365,
0.3942057788,
0.265193224,
0.5420033336,
-0.8030398488,
0.06040534,
-0.3629707992,
1.0909720659,
-0.6704694629,
-0.8720102906,
-0.057398133,
-0.5063158274,
0.0970976502,
-0.8375708461,
0.3600249887,
-0.0683210269,
0.1670888811,
-0.1139287725,
-0.3885100484,
0.067993328,
0.0415953733,
-0.289793402,
0.7753546238,
0.1505866647,
-0.6787760854,
0.3484082818,
-0.6919745803,
-0.3150063753,
0.2990590632,
-0.6618165374,
-0.1838275194,
-0.0963055268,
0.1422412097,
0.1877859682,
-0.7381665111,
0.6447203755,
-0.4291761816,
0.2284171432,
0.1458461434,
-0.3115850091,
0.6465008259,
0.4096409082,
-0.2484426051,
-0.0674175844,
-1.0073087215,
0.2321400642,
0.1624673158,
0.2329808921,
-0.3251413703,
0.2130188197,
-0.5273409486,
0.2579449713,
-0.0344499163,
-0.4472218752,
0.2806185484,
-0.5943118334,
0.1245632395,
0.5536555052,
0.3281293809,
0.0172158163,
-0.3989854753,
0.6361761093,
0.3437508345,
-0.0646542683,
-0.3724760413,
-0.7403003573,
-0.6768947244,
-0.0337108597,
0.1129960418,
0.5659788251,
-0.9555590749,
0.4753799736,
-0.0441250578,
-0.4487575293,
-0.4869427979,
-0.423894912,
0.5333387852,
1.2191865444,
0.3461550474,
-0.248760581,
-0.3598318696,
-0.7891054153,
-0.07842841,
-0.3413890302,
-0.0327806138,
0.6962891817,
0.0022116296,
-0.3937953115,
0.8516460657,
-0.8917990923,
-0.1362410337,
-0.2084311098,
0.321900636,
0.1081348062,
0.3222940862,
0.7592757344,
-0.4339973629,
-0.5372490883,
0.1587112248,
-0.8083686829,
-0.5425520539,
-0.0246256534,
-0.2909765244,
-0.0443378761,
0.4378834069,
-0.6196255684,
0.8046893477,
0.0911257938,
-0.499111861,
0.6510354877,
-0.3334365785,
0.1383001059,
-1.2735782862,
0.1694535315,
0.001462556,
-0.323697865,
-0.5700442791,
-0.3577667475,
-0.4728704393,
-0.2193689495,
0.0560639128,
0.7367869616,
-0.1723406017,
0.2965196669,
-0.2081504762,
0.3728787899,
-0.0123425499,
0.0300006066,
-0.0183142461,
0.2558017075,
0.8236956596,
-0.7776767612,
0.3434020877,
0.47319749,
-0.0325855389,
0.8885124326,
-0.5875000358,
-0.0828719437,
-0.2591463029,
0.2778903246,
-1.0907341242,
-0.1945918649,
0.430072695,
-0.5916690826,
0.3263369203,
0.0353741758,
-0.5540596247,
-0.5579975843,
0.2004556507,
0.4774517119,
0.6371782422,
-0.5749152303,
0.6594730616,
0.3579594791,
-0.5956091285,
-0.150949508,
-0.131532222,
-0.10324426,
-0.1899544001,
-0.8907219768,
0.1313252598,
-0.2139647007,
-0.5888501406,
-0.1229086146,
-0.1283911616,
-0.02072623,
0.1169489324,
0.0640482083,
0.2700730264,
-0.2035842538,
0.2433538884,
0.6779461503,
-0.5060978532,
0.417752564,
-0.1031880826,
0.5874152184,
0.288906008,
-0.5605069995,
-0.496175915,
0.8421850801,
0.5196376443,
-0.0665575936,
0.3530529141,
-0.0519081987,
-0.4048191309,
-0.2194449455,
-0.1699353904,
-0.4988905787,
-0.4241329134,
0.0282722991,
-0.3601517677,
-0.0721093863,
0.7547377348,
-0.7116709948,
-0.0431417786,
0.3983992338,
0.5995081067,
-0.1935814619,
2.0296082497,
0.1632300466,
0.5747935772,
-0.0713671595,
-0.2160021663,
0.6790281534,
-0.6300904751,
-0.2398188412,
-0.493814528,
0.0059652193,
-0.4297063351,
0.2228358686,
1.0373083353,
-0.0452675261,
0.038534116,
-0.2812205553,
-0.490585357,
0.1329402775,
0.2359332144,
0.2768450379,
0.2607068121,
-0.2010246664,
-0.6172935367,
-0.1530484259,
-0.6407730579,
-0.5198350549,
1.0610507727,
-0.0712252334,
0.3852460086,
0.2183583826,
0.672093749,
0.2202398926,
0.4645548761,
-0.8550388217,
0.6246901155,
-0.1748940349,
-0.1207326651,
0.2659896314,
-0.4668943286,
-1.0546271801,
0.0933518261,
-0.2779296041,
-0.7899186015,
0.081934467,
0.4273841679,
-0.699939847,
-0.089529261,
-0.8294032216,
0.6464202404,
-0.1797388494,
-0.1393100619,
-0.1413591653,
-0.9961899519,
0.4201569557,
-0.2002168,
0.3151119947,
-0.0514118001,
0.3276719749,
0.4749861956,
-0.7988830805,
0.7284806967,
-0.4999200702,
-0.0926424712,
0.1236912981,
0.2484975904,
0.2071994096,
0.4653911889,
0.0006254546,
-0.4504041076,
0.1793156415,
0.0801901296,
-0.9350595474,
0.4105684161,
-0.4275678694,
-0.8090448976,
-0.1650941819,
-0.2697666883,
-0.5564541221,
0.5014211535,
0.2092086077,
1.0770176649,
-0.1627627313,
-0.442750752,
0.5952709913,
-0.1270928085,
-0.0584794022,
0.5631588101,
-0.3883962035,
-0.0773754269,
0.5626001358,
0.025120331,
0.2979255021,
0.0121209538,
0.4470431209,
-0.3401800394,
-0.4294679761,
-0.4679180086,
0.2861081362,
-0.7977566123,
-0.4267542064,
-0.8838258386,
-0.1623619944,
-0.2884179056,
-0.0552809834,
-0.1341104656,
-0.4406827688,
-0.3072535396,
0.1515389532,
0.4850236773,
0.697827816,
-0.131028071,
0.1306956261,
-0.7432159781,
0.6533011198,
-0.0481328703,
0.1468816251,
0.1728155166,
-0.0387779512,
0.116985999,
0.5274371505,
-0.4930481613,
-0.8824332952,
0.5579477549,
0.0304925907,
0.5571464896,
0.7338909507,
0.4120181799,
0.7661732435,
-0.7013124228,
0.5590332747,
0.5382356644,
-0.723151803,
0.9088771939,
-0.17994304,
0.0496539958,
0.3165908456,
0.3446161747,
-0.4507390261,
-0.6211802959,
-0.8893715739,
-0.7085123062,
0.5666265488,
0.0018537757,
-0.2376139611,
-0.5253016353,
0.3093847632,
0.3623299897,
-0.098207593,
0.0001733199,
-0.4712067842,
-0.0708053857,
-0.4663921893,
0.1332010627,
0.1268451959,
-0.7293085456,
-0.4439383447,
0.321696192,
-0.4384130836,
0.4828268588,
0.3730194867,
0.3699224591,
-0.0879373401,
0.0230854265,
0.4678268135,
0.6703504324,
0.1056019738,
-0.05685791,
-0.2332362384,
-0.2330595404,
-0.0312267952,
0.3590364754,
0.1495633125,
0.1880803555,
-0.0139929336,
0.6875584722,
-0.1223343611,
-0.9749776721,
0.5274115801,
-0.1689454764,
-0.2553349137,
-0.2599124312,
0.2145992368,
0.1270158887,
0.2379706651,
0.152380839,
0.553378582,
0.4519717097,
-0.5477653742,
0.2738203406,
0.5748568773,
-0.0402352847,
-0.2894420922,
0.7401112914,
0.4751861989,
-0.4973616898,
0.8172255158,
-0.1556535214,
-0.4106578529,
0.716031611,
0.7597099543,
0.75941962,
0.1613613516,
0.1627270579,
0.2736809254,
-0.4453009963,
0.2237450927,
0.3399759829,
-0.2610573769,
-0.6835178137,
-0.0796953663,
-0.2085881829,
-0.3545421064,
0.0000552115,
-0.7859540582,
0.4378620088,
-0.2755512893,
-0.4448278546,
0.4285559356,
-0.1805894673,
-0.3722546399,
0.3816135228,
-0.0652725995,
0.873284936,
-0.5049988031,
0.6024201512,
0.3370331526,
-0.2072687894,
-0.8738303185,
0.1737472713,
0.1370884329,
-1.0337226391,
0.6756176949,
0.1993950158,
-0.4071701467,
0.091556415,
-0.4671823978,
-0.5186201334,
0.8720322251,
0.387193352,
-0.3690138757,
-0.0005825844,
-0.0107195573,
0.7837067246,
-0.7334957123,
0.4632102251,
0.5849446654,
0.4421237707,
0.4488275051,
-0.9858294129,
0.2023870796,
-0.6662259698,
-0.1344887316,
0.4383127391,
-0.2471334636,
0.6133894324,
-0.6513640285,
-0.4492039084,
0.4921056032,
-0.0445013456,
0.3399572968,
0.422809422,
0.4219471514,
0.5184724331,
0.8130481839,
-0.1265319884,
1.3463875055,
-0.7737742066,
-0.2858386934,
0.6416202784,
-0.4250070751,
0.4415290356,
0.2212356329,
0.080486387,
0.3985635638,
0.6928048134,
0.5142271519,
0.4678903818,
0.1319664866,
-0.6293697357,
-0.2746928632,
-0.2482670099,
-0.7381602526,
0.2316184193,
0.8407361507,
-0.4527282119,
-0.4002069235,
-0.2395514101,
0.1516870707,
0.1585445702,
-0.2024163455,
1.0828428268,
-0.0257694162,
-0.88261199,
0.7947739363,
-0.3168672919,
-0.0790203884,
-0.6372013688,
-0.4423789084,
-0.2647475898,
0.0529826768,
-0.1562063098,
-0.7690858245,
0.2064319253,
-0.1540033966,
-0.1077877954,
-0.1450237185,
0.481357336,
-0.4371568859,
-0.3853001595,
0.216771245,
0.6396756768,
0.1819835901,
0.3587442935,
-0.4491544962,
-0.2841263115,
0.1106736362,
0.2249158174,
0.0933810845,
0.6792026162,
-0.1074721739,
1.0073342323,
0.5663491488,
0.1582240313,
-0.2012366205,
0.1547569036,
1.1007146835,
-0.2493122965,
-0.5253244042,
-0.4453417957,
0.5923426747,
-0.2137014419,
-0.3449237645,
0.0585018247,
0.2936109602,
0.2900605202,
0.0605038442,
1.0056451559,
0.0956344306,
0.7324000597,
-0.558777988,
0.6566937566,
-0.6839844584,
0.3796297908,
-0.1939438581,
-0.5293381214,
-0.3251612782,
0.3773086965,
-0.0036991241,
0.158620581,
0.8434919119,
0.5708007812,
0.1525442302,
0.2745708525,
0.13871409,
0.4585185349,
0.5524430871,
0.4850268662,
0.8563328981,
0.0066567776,
0.2652510405,
-0.0744625106,
-0.5611761808,
-0.1902647614,
-0.6279619336,
-0.6821837425,
-0.4180168509,
-0.1551607102,
-0.4342299402,
-0.0166671164,
0.8207537532,
0.5145314336,
-0.3725024164,
0.1069809869,
-0.264509052,
-0.1131490096,
-0.135646224,
-0.2233424336,
0.1317502856,
-0.1800173372,
-0.5803006887,
0.3557702899,
0.3133314848,
0.2172442228,
-0.1325525492,
0.0339548327,
0.3643656671,
0.0407004841,
0.5445326567,
0.3863776922,
-0.5323910117,
-0.1289418042,
-0.2447913438,
0.2105118185,
0.1984998286,
0.8853376508,
-1.1758266687,
0.7866002917,
0.1224933639,
0.4632930756,
0.2945141494,
-0.1412025094,
0.9382463098,
-0.2388851047,
0.0383758172,
0.4548033774,
0.2896440327,
0.0590971969,
-0.5627310872,
0.1735694855,
0.2497084141,
-0.307549715,
-0.7585092783,
0.6037724018,
-0.9516871572,
0.0559542254,
0.8201126456,
-0.0080849174,
0.1803089231,
-0.4102267623,
-0.6511927843,
0.1212230474,
-0.5155684352,
0.816747725,
0.262719959,
-0.9119082689,
0.2090391517,
-0.2075539678,
0.5592212081,
0.249856323,
-0.9423220158,
-0.1169701368,
0.3931728601,
0.1102716178,
0.1429634094,
0.8120096326,
-0.0628043562,
0.4775097072,
0.2139479667,
-0.4578427076,
0.275578171,
0.0212111603,
0.4493095875,
-0.2073362768,
-0.0791446939,
-0.0468429141
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06532v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06532v3
|
INTERS: Unlocking the Power of Large Language Models in Search with Instruction Tuning
| 2024-01-12T12:10:28 | 2024-05-28T13:58:32 |
Yutao Zhu, Peitian Zhang, Chenghao Zhang, Yifei Chen, Binyu Xie, Zheng Liu, Ji-Rong Wen, Zhicheng Dou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive capabilities in
various natural language processing tasks. Despite this, their application to
information retrieval (IR) tasks is still challenging due to the infrequent
occurrence of many IR-specific concepts in natural language. While prompt-based
methods can provide task descriptions to LLMs, they often fall short in
facilitating a comprehensive understanding and execution of IR tasks, thereby
limiting LLMs' applicability. To address this gap, in this work, we explore the
potential of instruction tuning to enhance LLMs' proficiency in IR tasks. We
introduce a novel instruction tuning dataset, INTERS, encompassing 20 tasks
across three fundamental IR categories: query understanding, document
understanding, and query-document relationship understanding. The data are
derived from 43 distinct datasets with manually written templates. Our
empirical results reveal that INTERS significantly boosts the performance of
various publicly available LLMs, such as LLaMA, Mistral, and Phi, in IR tasks.
Furthermore, we conduct extensive experiments to analyze the effects of
instruction design, template diversity, few-shot demonstrations, and the volume
of instructions on performance. We make our dataset and the fine-tuned models
publicly accessible at https://github.com/DaoD/INTERS.
|
[
-0.3307622969,
-0.5354576707,
0.4150064588,
0.1602986753,
-0.1854850203,
0.2042770386,
-0.402320981,
-0.1367393434,
-0.0436919257,
0.455236733,
-0.6130364537,
-0.6433634758,
-0.7418613434,
0.165965721,
-0.5060076714,
0.7679573298,
0.1753954589,
0.3488690257,
-0.2384264767,
0.0864499584,
-0.4104327261,
-0.1847200692,
-0.3757947087,
-0.0687516704,
0.5133879781,
0.9817624688,
0.3676635027,
0.9096983671,
0.7416998744,
0.2504239082,
-0.0007994029,
0.5091469884,
-0.7758781314,
0.3103682399,
-0.3129431009,
-0.6946870685,
-0.0050268052,
-0.0637332648,
0.8783688545,
0.4386480451,
-0.0108198766,
0.206274569,
0.2099601179,
0.8386930227,
-0.7146697044,
0.23490116,
-1.0045063496,
-0.302870065,
-0.4439395964,
-0.6699539423,
-0.5870717168,
-0.2892108858,
0.1703387499,
-0.5861817002,
0.3155070841,
0.3686863184,
0.6905652285,
0.3157051802,
-0.3980314732,
-0.5757115483,
-0.4575058222,
0.6492792964,
-0.7432422638,
0.3432940841,
0.4642916918,
0.078160651,
-0.3458208442,
-0.6428182125,
-0.3724995553,
-0.3415277004,
-0.1448727697,
-0.0746813715,
-0.0346901491,
0.3279388845,
0.3970970511,
0.5223418474,
-0.4201096594,
0.5409802794,
-0.3850399554,
0.1867423207,
0.3919908404,
0.3959177732,
0.3047682643,
-0.0256344806,
-0.09072382,
-0.2064691335,
-0.8196794391,
0.1039171442,
0.576397717,
0.5815749764,
0.0909468085,
0.7933931947,
-0.3811094761,
0.985491395,
0.018158704,
-0.0122005548,
-0.2500652075,
-0.2995095849,
0.1490667462,
-0.0174613334,
0.3640182316,
0.2209585607,
0.1552421451,
-0.232203126,
-0.3295596838,
-0.39033252,
0.3206076622,
-1.028347373,
-0.0475902483,
-0.3805880845,
-0.3647383153,
0.1152768061,
0.2713776529,
-0.5583670139,
-0.2278862447,
-0.7625037432,
0.5380914807,
-0.6782290936,
0.2322511375,
0.1289766431,
-0.0465460904,
0.4201681614,
0.1563491225,
-1.1125457287,
0.3598591685,
0.9003642201,
0.6493424177,
-0.0639307499,
-0.195856452,
-0.8429881334,
0.0359521918,
-0.3883321583,
0.6704146862,
-1.1756162643,
-0.3372890651,
-0.0637248456,
-0.0055690017,
-0.3422696888,
-0.8058127761,
0.4119049907,
-0.7953979373,
0.0992581993,
-0.2204039097,
-0.9099874496,
-0.115450047,
0.0314504281,
-0.5741376877,
1.0361369848,
0.0414230078,
-0.5022777915,
-0.0268405881,
-0.6056591868,
-0.6320120096,
0.0813448802,
-0.2346402705,
-0.0097601693,
0.4810687602,
0.1509533376,
0.4971088767,
-0.7618194222,
0.0238389634,
0.0261645429,
-0.9376850724,
-0.0927571356,
-0.3151850104,
0.1699818671,
0.2181010693,
-0.2780456543,
-0.1194321364,
-0.4678765535,
0.2289048135,
-0.1635651588,
-0.6443392038,
-0.4518342316,
0.0905005857,
-0.4947868288,
-0.2287003994,
0.3509492874,
-0.2620894611,
0.4600148499,
-0.312456578,
0.2457947433,
0.7174942493,
-0.1576306373,
0.4163741767,
-0.1534341127,
0.6542333961,
-0.1901294589,
0.034773089,
-0.5344294906,
-0.1917552203,
-0.7875252366,
-0.24468261,
0.3078105748,
0.5190765858,
-0.7852424979,
0.3125561178,
-0.4146844447,
-0.4935486615,
-0.7702295184,
0.2183668911,
0.7885919213,
0.5278342366,
0.3676868975,
0.1082433239,
-0.2918417454,
-0.9843497872,
-0.6508929133,
0.1196243763,
-0.0308961179,
0.5493363738,
0.189418003,
-0.056636788,
0.5222953558,
-0.5478332639,
-0.2353076041,
0.0172629301,
0.2453657836,
0.4137226343,
0.2661738098,
0.2126579434,
-0.6839343905,
-0.7226631045,
-0.1005566567,
-0.382563442,
-0.1125136167,
0.2747828364,
-0.1763540059,
-0.0120319147,
0.8426921368,
-0.2384037077,
0.4081255794,
0.2885607481,
-0.1946035624,
0.2653974295,
-0.4038184285,
0.3798992336,
-0.8233029842,
-0.0455180965,
0.2777411342,
0.1568852067,
-0.2514148951,
0.190516606,
0.5048210025,
-0.0437235944,
-0.126826793,
0.4990784824,
-0.6194431782,
-0.0669127405,
-0.2594495416,
0.0095101856,
0.0923475027,
0.2635587156,
-0.37183249,
1.2955694199,
0.4117393196,
-0.8206671476,
0.0061134035,
0.1357353032,
-0.7906525135,
0.2787773609,
-0.39494434,
0.1492970288,
-0.4221838713,
-0.0721793324,
-0.7162714005,
-0.39625898,
-0.2466040701,
-0.1826735735,
0.7114534378,
-0.2956615388,
-0.8536458015,
-0.094886601,
-0.2005137652,
0.1299956441,
0.1935188472,
-0.7319020033,
0.3995374739,
0.245957464,
-0.2268567681,
-0.7092625499,
-0.1266496032,
0.1311487854,
-0.0907397345,
-0.4960368872,
0.637891531,
-0.2262270004,
-0.3146716654,
-0.0678735971,
-0.1420505196,
0.0159881562,
0.1048491597,
-0.0817827061,
0.2671367526,
-0.3557994366,
0.5839547515,
0.2164445817,
0.0187979769,
-0.3090009987,
-0.2067104876,
0.5097059011,
-0.1935797483,
-0.4783077836,
-0.3155474067,
0.2872445583,
0.5593128204,
-0.4550165534,
0.743504703,
0.304538995,
-0.0813488066,
-0.2618604004,
-0.6568095684,
-0.4236572385,
-0.5202524066,
0.5149746537,
-0.2698127627,
-0.8402833343,
0.1390347034,
-0.2287892103,
0.113731496,
0.1209964007,
0.1870754957,
-0.2409451753,
1.1847897768,
0.5712481141,
-0.0885671079,
0.8071329594,
-0.3211336732,
0.2551290691,
-0.9762374759,
-0.3540032506,
-0.7138706446,
-0.5622363687,
-0.5799821019,
-0.457432121,
0.7078909278,
0.126498282,
-0.2237515152,
0.0364991687,
-0.5270100236,
0.8961651325,
0.866174221,
0.3567096591,
0.2543690205,
0.0951312408,
0.0900492743,
-0.2079771012,
-0.6799491644,
-0.4948008955,
0.993488729,
-0.2118546218,
1.1487107277,
0.0364465341,
0.3910209537,
0.217015326,
0.033315707,
-0.6921600103,
0.6407424808,
-0.85894382,
-0.3841679096,
-0.2064909488,
-0.392295748,
-0.933309257,
0.1216553673,
-0.0674823821,
-0.5621447563,
-0.1548582166,
0.1075327918,
-0.0830950961,
0.2307292372,
-0.8886272907,
0.5088060498,
-0.6109781861,
-0.4876933098,
-0.5052695274,
-0.5771775246,
0.0679115206,
0.2350308001,
-0.0205110498,
-0.1747611463,
-0.0806824192,
0.5088450313,
-0.1347025782,
0.5314183235,
0.0146844722,
0.1263900697,
0.0103206551,
0.0158900507,
0.7076061368,
-0.0531221591,
-0.5640586019,
-0.2238702327,
-0.140880987,
-0.2624924481,
-0.6867454052,
1.0964467525,
-0.5633668303,
-0.8978145719,
-0.0634192079,
-0.6333022118,
-0.219910875,
0.2419407219,
0.4278806746,
0.735480547,
0.1661704034,
0.6918945909,
1.1888502836,
-0.2255488336,
0.1004543751,
0.9387031794,
0.0497849584,
0.0668352172,
1.0573706627,
0.3064421117,
0.1684701145,
0.8711877465,
0.0626840666,
-0.2150641531,
-0.5268249512,
-0.2776311934,
0.2901226878,
-0.7554656863,
-0.4401857257,
-0.4719276726,
-0.1466735154,
-0.3352113962,
-0.0005794942,
-0.1585049331,
-0.0690384433,
-0.7294749618,
0.0155750299,
0.5545658469,
0.8280006051,
0.2287459075,
0.3196326792,
-0.7401728034,
0.282900691,
0.1292593777,
0.700858295,
0.004602687,
-0.7446510792,
-0.5694707036,
-0.0051066298,
-0.1350590438,
-0.5413668156,
0.3043981194,
0.416615665,
0.6200057864,
0.2313650846,
0.1619965732,
0.8481391072,
-0.378056109,
0.3154970109,
-0.3822425306,
-0.7762658,
0.5736852884,
-0.2361615747,
0.409142971,
0.7621147037,
0.5353693366,
-0.2363444865,
-0.2127658278,
-0.1448183805,
-0.9435552359,
1.1114784479,
-0.0925642475,
0.2605711222,
-0.0990528166,
0.6977315545,
0.2507226765,
0.1930416673,
-0.1598904878,
-0.2111784518,
0.3213286996,
-0.5060995817,
0.130926609,
-0.4248847961,
0.0257130694,
-0.3167689145,
0.9917542934,
-0.3393357098,
-0.0408269018,
-0.0882185772,
-0.1526028961,
-0.16029419,
0.1840870976,
0.2118266523,
0.5866764188,
-0.1546197087,
0.0658829212,
-0.0740134418,
-0.3512076437,
-0.1680766791,
0.2808987796,
-0.0615530722,
-0.2549155951,
0.2389819175,
0.9007747769,
0.5774540901,
-0.9229166508,
0.331507802,
-0.4724138081,
0.261621356,
-0.0099681886,
0.5340192318,
0.0347630717,
0.353646189,
0.5020010471,
-0.3134344816,
0.1981155723,
-0.4598006904,
-0.0598044954,
0.701130271,
-0.2835852504,
-0.0873682573,
0.3798737526,
0.0784052089,
-0.5280067325,
1.1077598333,
0.0262350701,
-0.1272044182,
0.591212213,
0.6208273768,
0.5682164431,
-0.0537625626,
-0.1003641188,
0.3651086986,
0.4486198723,
-0.0549401641,
0.3043531179,
-0.0606812835,
-0.1994817257,
-0.2279542387,
-0.5801720023,
-0.5242540836,
0.2034971863,
-0.8432348967,
0.4941335618,
-0.1907154173,
0.0916493833,
-0.1744503379,
0.0632708222,
-0.8142343163,
0.0334651805,
-0.0684653744,
1.1342918873,
-0.2087801993,
0.6944954395,
0.6572173238,
-0.0986971781,
-0.7385475039,
0.1826330572,
-0.3599996269,
-0.8813836575,
0.72653234,
0.2826837301,
-0.2464452833,
0.3423178792,
-0.7355635166,
-1.1093364954,
1.1960529089,
0.7763762474,
-0.891553998,
-0.2916261852,
-0.0601244345,
0.353798449,
-0.2834498882,
0.3450991213,
0.529794991,
0.385112226,
-0.0304608438,
-0.6973533034,
-0.2816799581,
-0.3446197212,
-0.0265219659,
0.2528401315,
-0.7372630835,
0.8793463707,
-0.2782814205,
-0.1547906995,
0.1813796163,
0.4140283465,
0.2087437063,
0.1705737412,
0.239914,
0.3612709343,
0.8376544714,
-0.05710968,
1.1168948412,
-0.7290127277,
-0.1147170067,
1.1434980631,
-0.162923187,
0.6595445871,
0.271819979,
0.1245346367,
0.3871706724,
0.5495205522,
0.3107767999,
0.4638560116,
0.200198859,
-0.4342062175,
-0.3312323093,
-0.2565991282,
-0.2474269867,
0.5960472822,
0.8335680366,
-0.5416605473,
-0.1506737322,
-0.0353158601,
-0.1493035853,
0.2474207133,
-0.3065199852,
0.8747866154,
-0.0821716338,
-0.9459037781,
0.4779494405,
0.0098982509,
0.6321578026,
-0.9279745221,
-0.4029710591,
-0.2933444381,
0.1650163084,
0.0360703543,
-0.8107320666,
-0.3071138561,
0.0508328974,
-0.3930316567,
-0.1305080056,
0.6437505484,
-0.3995985389,
-0.3424083292,
0.3328073621,
0.1707041115,
-0.0106859207,
0.0404133834,
-0.4153200686,
0.1571356505,
0.0574133396,
-0.2395919561,
0.6122738123,
0.6434856057,
0.0563288219,
0.7834383249,
0.4164186418,
-0.1139278114,
0.2932476699,
-0.1339754015,
1.0326018333,
-0.6588025689,
-0.2448838949,
-0.733694315,
0.2000624388,
0.0132821752,
-0.2563161552,
0.7748888731,
0.7920830846,
0.923506856,
-0.0334254391,
0.7414343953,
0.1956773847,
0.7439721227,
-0.8590044975,
0.3733076453,
-0.6138269305,
0.5371252894,
0.2450400144,
-0.7569428086,
-0.0643715486,
0.2585959435,
-0.3797326386,
-0.1595316231,
0.241941452,
1.1429201365,
-0.1927198917,
0.00557573,
0.1807370931,
0.1891341954,
0.2200222909,
0.0849613547,
0.7896815538,
-0.1871699989,
0.4574877918,
-0.1547740996,
-0.1166364476,
-0.6119246483,
-0.6877387166,
-0.6301626563,
-0.6043737531,
0.1420802772,
0.0001994479,
0.2452581525,
1.0267022848,
0.6564669013,
-0.4991449714,
-0.3479572535,
0.023195792,
0.2330724448,
0.2284163833,
-0.2482631356,
0.1961554736,
-0.6922181845,
-0.9508816004,
0.8009307981,
0.4474734366,
-0.1060956419,
-0.0391371474,
-0.0454466715,
-0.3609033823,
0.0955201387,
0.4590823054,
0.232487753,
-0.5649333,
0.0068591838,
0.3546353281,
-0.1505734324,
0.0100395484,
1.0265146494,
-0.8938667178,
0.7619146109,
0.5024185777,
0.6894734502,
0.4567376077,
-0.0153597202,
0.5349145532,
-0.8651152253,
-0.0783398449,
0.3764773607,
0.2730529904,
0.3448254466,
-0.6106796265,
0.5606560111,
-0.3258065879,
-0.670307219,
-0.7535495162,
0.0406619348,
-0.4086369276,
-0.2782721817,
0.9396723509,
0.0296302866,
-0.0187272374,
0.2316483259,
-0.2306262702,
0.2866517603,
-0.417934984,
0.886891067,
0.4614183307,
-0.2203940153,
0.0681552067,
-0.5673366785,
0.2453197986,
0.4684387743,
-0.653901279,
0.1293968409,
0.4419152439,
0.0946023241,
-0.330211699,
0.2807646394,
-0.0182267688,
0.0940592885,
-0.5190125704,
-0.2124159932,
-0.0688307881,
-0.476115644,
-0.1961847097,
-0.1655965447,
0.3018936813,
-0.0502248555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06526v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06526v1
|
MetaHate: A Dataset for Unifying Efforts on Hate Speech Detection
| 2024-01-12T11:54:53 | 2024-01-12T11:54:53 |
Paloma Piot, Patricia Martín-Rodilla, Javier Parapar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI
|
Hate speech represents a pervasive and detrimental form of online discourse,
often manifested through an array of slurs, from hateful tweets to defamatory
posts. As such speech proliferates, it connects people globally and poses
significant social, psychological, and occasionally physical threats to
targeted individuals and communities. Current computational linguistic
approaches for tackling this phenomenon rely on labelled social media datasets
for training. For unifying efforts, our study advances in the critical need for
a comprehensive meta-collection, advocating for an extensive dataset to help
counteract this problem effectively. We scrutinized over 60 datasets,
selectively integrating those pertinent into MetaHate. This paper offers a
detailed examination of existing collections, highlighting their strengths and
limitations. Our findings contribute to a deeper understanding of the existing
datasets, paving the way for training more robust and adaptable models. These
enhanced models are essential for effectively combating the dynamic and complex
nature of hate speech in the digital realm.
|
[
-0.5259213448,
-0.6663123965,
0.0931576937,
-0.1827234328,
-0.266153127,
0.3752296269,
-0.2895169854,
-0.4425299466,
0.3865112662,
0.4662494659,
-0.6757512689,
-0.6156283021,
-1.0525057316,
-0.1474373043,
-0.6972051263,
1.2257486582,
0.5592364669,
0.0127866222,
0.2749164402,
-0.4661215544,
-0.4514181614,
-0.3066070676,
-0.237780571,
0.0705230832,
0.6973170042,
0.4610473514,
0.7217339277,
0.3725005984,
0.4154084623,
0.1912957132,
0.2829791009,
-0.0154524716,
-0.7214478254,
0.4175240695,
-0.3704639375,
-0.0068591377,
-0.1191400364,
-0.0028295873,
0.5877792835,
0.6719530225,
-0.0507377088,
0.5459185243,
0.2112210989,
0.1743628681,
-0.9881434441,
-0.2618519068,
-0.748498857,
-0.0613618009,
-0.8498625755,
0.3108418882,
-0.0283406526,
-0.3238696158,
0.107473202,
-0.491163224,
0.3530391157,
-0.4190026522,
0.132579118,
0.2467842549,
-0.4229577482,
-0.3101586401,
-0.9462442398,
0.6774024963,
-0.5433608294,
0.3292742074,
0.3569993377,
0.6176662445,
0.1734490395,
-0.6450378299,
-0.4652599394,
0.2702499926,
0.0270125549,
-0.0514407866,
-0.5634478331,
0.0193322916,
0.2569954693,
0.1781436354,
-0.5291734338,
0.1993474513,
-0.5172744393,
-0.3991541862,
0.6290403605,
0.1865113527,
0.3970742226,
-0.141135186,
0.1308948398,
0.0099648628,
-0.2227217853,
-0.2415239811,
0.4385072291,
0.5680950284,
0.0788804814,
0.3373714089,
-0.0720749944,
0.6788368821,
-0.1914639771,
-0.0674086139,
0.2617913187,
0.1911256611,
-0.103733182,
-0.0948394164,
0.8652738929,
0.2863061726,
0.5329809189,
-0.2229828089,
0.0144811198,
0.6144070625,
0.4472190142,
-0.6261721253,
-0.2555041015,
0.0964770094,
-0.3417818248,
-0.4987025857,
0.0132000539,
-1.3265486956,
-0.9723009467,
-0.3607747257,
0.1748013049,
-0.2675786614,
-0.4874280393,
-0.340279907,
-0.3118121028,
0.039461825,
-0.0077531836,
-0.7515432239,
0.3182552457,
0.6198432446,
0.546205461,
-0.2980329096,
-0.1826202273,
-0.58047539,
0.1706989408,
-0.162898913,
0.645001471,
-1.0905429125,
-0.2552725375,
0.2604811788,
-0.1059910133,
0.1516143531,
-0.5812664032,
0.9803478122,
-0.3868569732,
0.0127555626,
-0.3511158526,
-0.3464296758,
-0.2657634914,
0.0426452085,
-0.6870418191,
0.9125886559,
0.1311569214,
-0.809785068,
0.3990299702,
-0.7268162966,
-0.5784267187,
0.2092355937,
-0.207976222,
-0.532807529,
0.3272484243,
0.1139657348,
0.4182958901,
-0.4096806645,
0.4343922138,
-0.6959784031,
-0.1470478177,
-0.0287273489,
-0.3241810203,
0.907687366,
0.455625087,
-0.7194545269,
0.1257357895,
-0.8334003687,
-0.2504091561,
0.2139818817,
0.268317163,
-0.5312024355,
0.0585997142,
0.3647750914,
0.0798058957,
-0.2030772567,
-0.8080364466,
-0.2942847013,
-0.0016371239,
0.4232102931,
0.8893145919,
-0.2463687807,
0.0443158783,
-0.1490370184,
0.4979116321,
-0.0645150319,
0.2953525186,
0.1901068985,
-0.3381433487,
-0.4312619865,
-0.192308113,
0.123142004,
0.527353704,
-0.3501929343,
0.1097437143,
-0.0694145635,
-0.574200511,
-0.4530734718,
-0.1768547446,
0.2227970958,
0.3351590037,
0.5713648796,
0.2779998481,
-0.9982028008,
-1.1060407162,
-0.473508954,
0.2683670819,
0.0309994724,
0.1147173643,
0.5609118938,
-0.3993984461,
1.0938080549,
-0.3196778595,
-0.1360583007,
-0.1056694388,
0.3688444793,
-0.1194270477,
0.1165837944,
0.6446717978,
-0.8730198145,
-0.6828261018,
-0.525372982,
-0.7686997056,
-0.5029593706,
0.334179163,
-0.0533929914,
-0.3405927122,
0.388091743,
0.1243233979,
0.3898310959,
0.6848614216,
-0.1639853418,
0.4302507639,
0.6921595931,
0.3443109095,
-1.0649065971,
0.026731072,
-0.0842666775,
-0.3007797897,
-0.999958992,
-0.0357911885,
-0.3712537885,
-0.4423881769,
-0.4951108992,
0.2189058363,
-0.1719489247,
0.0611779988,
-0.4273603559,
0.1314743757,
-0.6354320645,
0.410110414,
0.0178343263,
0.6239629984,
0.724470675,
-0.5424469709,
0.4808755219,
0.1347122043,
-0.0825046897,
1.1629879475,
-0.5086758733,
0.0453672931,
-0.2433005273,
0.1377875507,
-0.8917707801,
-0.3773813248,
0.5387806892,
-0.3753927946,
-0.1153082028,
-0.0126283262,
-0.3286592066,
-0.535407424,
-0.4616571069,
0.6941272616,
0.1124913394,
-0.4248329997,
0.7012722492,
1.1595139503,
0.1103160381,
-0.5877025723,
-0.6021805406,
0.256141305,
-0.5391177535,
-0.4240559936,
0.2523060143,
-0.1331236809,
-0.2356471121,
-0.1858543009,
0.1105567962,
-0.2406411469,
0.064550966,
0.4068392813,
-0.2229853719,
0.1180950478,
0.2951256633,
-0.1524300426,
0.0189752523,
0.0640202686,
-0.2528404891,
0.7037564516,
0.1377810985,
-0.2165484726,
-0.2756882608,
0.5627544522,
0.7452334762,
-0.0333640054,
0.6046921611,
0.9069836736,
-0.7166503668,
-0.1747502387,
-0.6484777927,
-0.1094842479,
-0.3945325315,
0.0882644579,
-0.0093841394,
-0.9777373672,
0.5242450237,
0.0629401505,
0.2664786577,
0.5206850767,
0.312384516,
-0.3202030957,
0.6470020413,
0.449449569,
-0.4162153006,
0.493737489,
0.1494391561,
0.0714381486,
-0.4939197302,
-0.1415422708,
-0.5443806648,
-0.3631299138,
-0.6358720064,
-0.3894781172,
0.3803202808,
-0.5650279522,
-0.3951010108,
0.4965938926,
-0.6120492816,
0.4933445156,
0.299972266,
-0.0042290268,
0.0751854479,
0.1318694651,
0.2942817211,
-0.4289753735,
-0.3248213828,
-0.3498258293,
1.2562807798,
0.1426181644,
0.4375557899,
0.2877825797,
0.2650624812,
0.886513412,
0.1969213337,
-0.4632002413,
0.5102046728,
-0.3145591021,
-1.05534482,
-0.3740875125,
-0.3930190206,
-1.0799403191,
0.2566805482,
-0.4392955303,
-0.6679034233,
0.1074441969,
0.2302696258,
-0.2841249108,
0.5748577118,
-0.0311082192,
0.8232979774,
-0.0337712541,
-0.3200803697,
-0.5147872567,
-0.6005477309,
0.5743708014,
-0.3757382631,
0.5908291936,
-0.2516339719,
0.1456366628,
1.2056088448,
-0.1703188419,
1.1684150696,
-0.1696353257,
-0.0963520408,
0.4512622654,
-0.0849844143,
0.3059725463,
-0.4477469325,
0.0788243115,
0.3079781532,
-0.2545205355,
-0.4497338831,
-0.1906190068,
0.1962883025,
-0.5261754394,
-0.0441479497,
-0.3342568874,
-0.3540868163,
-0.4225644767,
0.1811352372,
0.3785003126,
0.4956752062,
-0.7630912066,
0.1435002238,
0.9719304442,
-0.2947446406,
0.1934333146,
0.5069912672,
-0.2075598538,
-0.5940944552,
0.9044231176,
0.2700267434,
-0.0605062433,
0.0541245639,
0.2711145282,
-0.2062558532,
-0.3224781454,
-0.12186905,
0.1234967485,
-0.6012560725,
-0.3055265248,
-0.8217539191,
0.0241508521,
-0.7283989191,
0.0044025481,
-0.2305223942,
-0.3084034622,
0.0002155121,
0.0430043004,
0.4305883944,
0.9635585546,
-0.5325089097,
0.7855926156,
-0.5157697201,
0.7704327703,
0.5611571074,
0.4562038779,
-0.0547866113,
-0.7198578715,
-0.0463926345,
0.2754715681,
-0.2112386674,
-1.2924827337,
-0.0147713367,
0.1886435449,
0.619669497,
0.2459938973,
0.2010883689,
0.5445281267,
-0.4450409114,
0.5211758614,
0.1886489093,
-0.8954861164,
0.7894352078,
-0.7693288922,
-0.1338233799,
0.8004134297,
0.6873601675,
-1.027389884,
-0.4051356316,
-0.7854694128,
-0.4862284362,
0.5145871043,
0.1340776086,
0.0607824698,
-0.0389935412,
-0.0890650824,
0.0430943929,
0.3688589931,
-0.7609941959,
-0.4005182087,
-0.2372117341,
-0.1861592978,
0.0528941266,
-0.3104864061,
-0.2469799668,
-0.2841640115,
0.6668086648,
0.1676038206,
-0.1262187809,
-0.5671117306,
-0.418230772,
-0.0023788889,
0.1372810006,
0.4242720008,
0.4579809606,
0.0768313706,
0.0921384916,
0.2507623136,
-0.6581420302,
0.0481295101,
-0.1336615235,
-0.1166559458,
0.1116582081,
0.2733969092,
0.5355874896,
0.2932576537,
-0.6211153865,
0.7337821722,
0.2439049631,
-0.1096176207,
-0.3465903997,
-0.1489373744,
-0.0696967691,
0.0099403234,
0.2049435228,
-0.0423734076,
0.526268065,
-0.5285298824,
0.5052297711,
0.5866777897,
-0.2839054167,
-0.2532183826,
0.5775439143,
0.4008959234,
-0.272069633,
0.4480545521,
-0.0233268421,
-0.6409741044,
0.1808749288,
0.2290484905,
0.8347755671,
-0.5750904083,
0.5979073048,
0.5998708606,
0.4662820697,
0.2671864629,
-0.1988675594,
-0.1432593316,
-0.672760427,
-0.1044164971,
-0.6977629662,
-0.4045650661,
0.4277224541,
-0.570482254,
0.3590354323,
-0.5858703256,
-0.1631284058,
0.0732589141,
-0.2923281491,
-0.5257754922,
0.1308313459,
0.6722041368,
0.5603159666,
-1.4392601252,
0.3108891547,
0.1876838058,
-0.2970885932,
-0.2307957709,
-0.065639928,
0.5252352357,
-0.847358346,
0.1298547834,
0.1212545186,
-0.3554791808,
-0.1636872888,
-0.6152307391,
-0.7006393075,
0.4094408453,
0.2899179459,
-0.6044797301,
0.354822129,
0.6588566899,
0.5077892542,
-0.2967750728,
0.120780237,
0.9012258053,
0.6119602919,
0.0122933369,
-0.6185771823,
-0.0296486206,
0.0127085624,
-0.2173061967,
0.2863185108,
-0.471175313,
0.6291636229,
0.2004704922,
-0.4898716807,
-0.5730009675,
0.5644832253,
-0.1452528685,
0.2705198824,
0.6509463191,
0.722427845,
0.983720541,
0.0177052766,
0.4426559508,
0.1778440326,
0.0008205494,
1.2737723589,
-0.0254727826,
0.4889285862,
-0.1968468726,
-0.2033348233,
0.4531193078,
0.5524337292,
-0.1945189089,
0.2649956048,
0.3300333917,
-0.4940932393,
-0.4054170847,
-0.3951488435,
-0.3426448405,
0.5564541221,
0.5045577288,
-0.1694715917,
-0.6329324245,
0.5979554057,
0.0258032214,
0.3612631559,
-0.3397604823,
0.7519939542,
-0.3067599237,
-0.2610951364,
0.2976590693,
-0.2967878878,
0.960088253,
-0.4053800702,
0.1685412973,
0.0956822932,
-0.095448941,
-0.3990851045,
-0.8115814328,
0.7919964194,
0.3091998696,
-0.0842572451,
-0.0203891378,
0.7234429121,
-0.397792697,
-0.3402122855,
0.4643990993,
0.3185589015,
0.373243928,
-0.4167188108,
-0.7980220318,
0.4158507586,
0.0262519605,
0.2289189994,
0.1522074938,
0.3325206041,
-0.0445089005,
0.3467816114,
0.5682068467,
-0.1493591368,
0.2271267623,
0.2587115467,
0.8026602864,
-0.5215731859,
-0.2874366939,
-0.8986148238,
0.46031335,
-0.4141999781,
-0.3565654457,
0.630603075,
0.6111410856,
0.676684618,
0.2113055438,
1.0142587423,
-0.1577077955,
1.0835511684,
0.12840195,
0.3565233052,
-0.3430729508,
-0.0158710163,
-0.5950031281,
-0.9692112207,
-0.4332268834,
0.5701959729,
-0.262870878,
-0.1858486682,
0.3196640015,
0.6252954006,
-0.3139600754,
0.3580875397,
0.367477119,
0.1300516576,
0.443783164,
0.3017100394,
0.7086119652,
-0.456004411,
0.8208487034,
-0.0408356711,
-0.3745070696,
-0.1631337553,
-0.6655082703,
-0.820114553,
-0.6476479769,
-0.3810161054,
-0.2700184882,
0.0919267759,
0.8475403786,
0.6210929155,
-0.9933237433,
-0.2530622482,
0.0951496512,
0.0107289981,
0.00439526,
-0.1477587819,
-0.0982382521,
-0.185901165,
-0.6812800169,
0.2753688097,
0.0461435132,
-0.1288539022,
-0.1317907572,
0.3030661643,
-0.3070445657,
0.273401171,
0.7560391426,
0.4803469181,
-0.4032593369,
-0.0646508634,
-0.3294353187,
-0.045625709,
-0.0694543943,
1.0874562263,
-0.6247945428,
0.2676755786,
0.3321372271,
0.8063925505,
0.3952502012,
-0.2365450263,
0.296083957,
-0.6719228625,
0.0241232514,
0.4999863505,
0.1805157512,
0.2603165805,
-0.0080859372,
0.6407449841,
0.4717324972,
-0.3180485666,
-0.9569575191,
0.5129968524,
-0.7667984962,
-0.5435802341,
0.9161397815,
0.5215653181,
0.0303888991,
-0.5007608533,
-0.0166690983,
0.4067395926,
-0.3827224672,
0.6194421649,
0.7253297567,
0.3374458551,
-0.1054698601,
-0.4971152246,
0.4861416221,
0.1710189134,
-0.8314440846,
0.6342740059,
0.8436344266,
0.2926313579,
0.2487286478,
0.6681650281,
0.0697765872,
0.2863651812,
-0.0840369165,
0.0199140254,
0.2559951842,
-0.5789935589,
-0.4079959095,
0.4346260428,
-0.6264597178,
-0.2251317352
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06509v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06509v3
|
AntEval: Evaluation of Social Interaction Competencies in LLM-Driven Agents
| 2024-01-12T11:18:00 | 2024-03-05T12:07:04 |
Yuanzhi Liang, Linchao Zhu, Yi Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated their ability to replicate
human behaviors across a wide range of scenarios. However, their capability in
handling complex, multi-character social interactions has yet to be fully
explored, primarily due to the absence of robust, quantitative evaluation
methods. This gap has slowed the development of agents proficient in more
nuanced interactions beyond simple exchanges, for example, small talk. To
address this challenge, we introduce the Multi-Agent Interaction Evaluation
Framework (AntEval), encompassing a novel interaction framework and evaluation
methods. The interaction framework aims to foster an complex interaction
environment that bolsters information exchange and intention expression within
social interactions. Furthermore, we introduce evaluation methods, including
two metrics: Information Exchanging Precision (IEP) and Interaction
Expressiveness Gap (IEG), designed for the quantitative and objective
assessment of agents' interaction competencies. Our findings highlight the
utility of these evaluative methods and show significant potential for
improving LLMs' ability to construct agents that interact in a more natural
manner with human-like intricacy.
|
[
-0.458512187,
-0.8286017179,
0.5425554514,
0.3479240537,
0.0035942474,
0.6675928235,
-0.5383335948,
-0.7079657912,
0.2692075074,
-0.153175205,
-0.4926560521,
-0.4704685807,
-0.4746215343,
0.0784766525,
0.095378302,
0.6101436019,
0.1912787259,
-0.0194926895,
-0.5502073765,
-0.1871754527,
-0.218026191,
-0.5871587396,
-0.6836590171,
-0.514167428,
0.3286578655,
0.4194114208,
0.9809612632,
0.4309175313,
0.5531103015,
0.3987689316,
-0.1342039704,
0.6395577788,
-0.5535621047,
0.1594727635,
-0.2895595729,
0.0212838519,
-0.7604103684,
0.1852373928,
0.6952405572,
0.9901940823,
-0.1470396072,
0.1159475595,
0.2967734635,
0.5044562817,
-0.6172716618,
0.4814722538,
-0.4607255161,
-0.1084309742,
0.0232477672,
-0.3303175569,
-0.4247460067,
-0.4334622025,
0.0277558845,
-0.5482239127,
-0.2692724466,
0.0235980954,
0.4939647913,
-0.0443806611,
-0.5432950258,
-0.3588008285,
-0.619649291,
0.6798811555,
-0.614682734,
0.1519461274,
0.344458878,
0.3587357104,
-0.3579087853,
-0.538102448,
-0.585036993,
-0.4380893409,
0.1101700515,
-0.0446637124,
-0.0287508518,
0.2880220413,
-0.0404972322,
0.0706734434,
-0.181571275,
-0.1410965919,
-0.1300302297,
-0.051297307,
0.9269878864,
0.3860689998,
0.1362037361,
0.0799529403,
-0.3834491372,
0.0242799278,
-0.7178884149,
0.2881547213,
0.2637624443,
0.4054898918,
-0.1469282657,
0.5311079025,
-0.1556155384,
0.4579274952,
0.0231580157,
0.1351210326,
0.295953542,
-0.4141423106,
-0.0113281524,
-0.2187720984,
0.5039042234,
0.5554142594,
0.372582674,
-0.1975095421,
-0.0910173729,
0.096463725,
0.1246712953,
-0.7706138492,
0.3114980757,
0.3173176348,
-0.4293229878,
-0.6137787104,
0.0907444805,
-0.6859015822,
-0.7830629945,
-0.4102956951,
0.3747448623,
-0.3054355681,
-0.4337033927,
-0.0752243698,
-0.0468666032,
0.5611579418,
0.4525134563,
-0.5894789696,
0.7250830531,
0.8507755995,
0.6770546436,
-0.1931724548,
-0.8693450689,
-0.8472550511,
0.1145085171,
-0.532484889,
0.8252239227,
-0.9116930962,
-0.2110260129,
0.2275375277,
-0.0801100209,
-0.3121525347,
-0.4513774812,
0.3220097721,
-0.5823451877,
-0.3784363568,
-0.3239642084,
-0.5837621093,
0.042201452,
0.4773834348,
-0.4431056976,
0.7144630551,
0.2418721318,
-0.3284217715,
0.2035916597,
-0.7124205232,
-0.5535242558,
0.3445633948,
-0.3024480641,
-0.0774995014,
-0.0182923265,
-0.0978856012,
0.4417836368,
-0.4902924597,
0.1402867436,
-0.3576239944,
-0.6417136192,
0.437070936,
-0.2809755504,
0.4336534739,
0.0116061661,
-0.2969706953,
0.4359547198,
-0.781670928,
0.2000276297,
-0.0583809093,
-0.429300338,
-0.2145570666,
0.0613645203,
-0.1103705689,
0.2387586981,
0.3923545778,
-0.3713867664,
0.1835404336,
-0.3800908029,
0.343665421,
0.8918501139,
0.0935450718,
0.4294315875,
-0.5191142559,
0.7922637463,
-0.496584326,
0.2193670869,
0.209507823,
-0.1502267271,
-0.4716913998,
-0.181527108,
-0.0336753577,
0.3050318956,
-0.9341214895,
0.3016028702,
-0.2593191266,
-0.7433872819,
-0.5324888825,
0.2486345321,
0.6802495122,
0.009929982,
0.0757926106,
-0.1226736531,
-0.1874766499,
-0.4191336036,
-0.3828550279,
-0.3962587416,
0.0984103605,
0.5233322382,
0.2359270155,
-0.2795633674,
0.7919076681,
0.0995769799,
-0.0173944347,
-0.4319361448,
0.1152393594,
-0.2669080496,
0.2224768549,
0.4077374041,
-0.5412469506,
-0.5960900784,
0.2334144861,
-0.633344233,
-0.159763664,
0.1042054743,
-0.1614536345,
0.1566469222,
0.5015262365,
-0.6758058667,
0.5399749279,
0.4253254533,
-0.545499444,
0.5456347466,
-0.0246553756,
0.596580565,
-0.6064652205,
-0.2161911726,
-0.1922324449,
-0.297427088,
-0.8102468252,
0.0375100635,
-0.0913470834,
0.0802663788,
-0.6397901177,
0.915030539,
-0.7131506205,
-0.2980642617,
-0.0939403698,
0.5225889087,
0.1339981705,
0.3770200908,
-0.0150703872,
0.94084692,
0.3476107717,
-0.4953008592,
0.4133362472,
0.338703692,
-0.2255035639,
1.0025949478,
-0.7475054264,
0.3252049088,
0.089925617,
-0.1055935472,
-1.082878828,
-0.2772991955,
0.054311242,
-0.5681183934,
0.1765001267,
-0.065844588,
-0.3849971592,
0.0417401418,
-0.7702946663,
0.4917572141,
0.1061564013,
-0.372350812,
0.8064826727,
0.4426168203,
-0.4423646331,
-0.5663623214,
-0.3051517606,
0.2838471532,
-0.0302017648,
-1.0056549311,
0.0367184952,
-0.1024677753,
-0.6208655238,
-0.1201254725,
0.1693068743,
0.0624707825,
-0.0280265938,
0.1622583419,
0.3470770717,
-0.1146305203,
0.2573667169,
0.0011818155,
0.1076992974,
-0.0201665219,
0.4360746741,
0.7258035541,
-0.8590336442,
-0.5724428892,
-0.3216711581,
0.1396771818,
0.6493480802,
-0.4456629157,
0.9160657525,
0.2645161152,
-0.4187133908,
0.0811712444,
-0.5128415227,
-0.1506423652,
-0.4613066018,
0.4474231601,
-0.6070309877,
-0.6849700809,
0.6925161481,
-0.3723378778,
-0.0219945721,
0.2518931925,
0.4982863367,
0.0641140938,
0.9890486598,
0.5083670616,
0.3044222593,
0.1913748682,
-0.0543457493,
-0.0745602325,
-1.1748477221,
-0.3830391765,
-0.2596141398,
-0.0526196808,
-0.1787427217,
-0.5387691855,
0.2433718592,
-0.1741791368,
-0.2954377234,
0.0705855638,
-0.1036074907,
0.5325934291,
-0.0336868726,
-0.1887240261,
0.4123691022,
-0.1596944034,
0.0723745301,
0.0195488352,
-0.6745163202,
-0.8655882478,
0.8981884718,
0.4386875033,
0.8665724397,
0.4267781973,
0.3643709719,
0.6902071834,
0.6256978512,
-0.8634781241,
0.6925298572,
0.2480765432,
-0.2783339918,
-0.6511231065,
-0.3791854978,
-1.1107317209,
0.5309854746,
-0.5182079077,
-0.8104234934,
0.2848567367,
-0.1178205907,
-0.241391778,
-0.0420361385,
-0.648935318,
0.8671646714,
-0.158083722,
-0.7016875744,
-0.3547356427,
-0.8201880455,
0.0573647656,
0.1560810059,
0.3937389851,
-0.2498974949,
-0.1816097945,
0.3608741164,
-0.4703794122,
0.8131939173,
-0.1451949179,
0.1601614803,
0.3201897144,
0.2808274925,
0.5956473351,
-0.23076801,
-0.4414992929,
0.0582347326,
0.1454883814,
-0.3026920259,
-0.5728829503,
0.5374399424,
-0.9053100944,
-0.3683714569,
-0.5188882351,
-0.5242593884,
-0.5121054053,
-0.0777882189,
-0.2425215095,
0.3244273663,
-0.7498545051,
0.2694565952,
0.2465343475,
-0.027983509,
0.2105251551,
0.6359576583,
-0.0344787091,
-0.3816227615,
0.7375969887,
-0.0863008499,
0.6539950967,
-0.0262284689,
0.0807387605,
-0.2564933598,
-0.1604776382,
-0.2964486778,
0.2720784247,
-0.8051542044,
-0.1728706658,
-0.3537578583,
-0.3557130694,
-0.4490451515,
-0.3619791269,
-0.2356511801,
-0.4107695222,
0.0288040191,
-0.1010852754,
0.0454390086,
0.8222085238,
-0.0374132879,
0.4113493264,
-0.6603560448,
-0.062169034,
0.165442735,
0.259655863,
0.2840020359,
-0.3649105132,
-0.3114926517,
-0.0595105514,
-0.1185482293,
-0.9963285923,
0.1224627197,
0.4375327528,
0.730681479,
0.437178582,
0.1115508899,
0.4520338178,
-0.4043357372,
0.4906060696,
-0.1502633542,
-1.1655410528,
0.2865474522,
-0.2197069973,
-0.0355413072,
0.7018803358,
0.0211570244,
-0.5874989033,
-0.2966818213,
-0.5784617066,
-0.884555459,
0.6455749273,
0.3957008421,
-0.0087120207,
-0.0986412987,
0.2706336975,
-0.2628681064,
0.5199974775,
-0.5025843382,
-0.0068293079,
0.2460381389,
-0.0633373037,
0.1261598766,
-0.3268992305,
-0.4126913249,
-0.0032269852,
0.6242688298,
-0.0824534819,
-0.1021898314,
0.1213469207,
-0.2635469735,
-0.1429404169,
0.4434670508,
0.481914252,
0.9713342786,
-0.1972776353,
0.2853246331,
0.1056671962,
-0.3034442961,
0.3508877158,
0.2774647772,
0.3527967632,
-0.4503762424,
0.5409818888,
0.3234581351,
-0.1206703186,
-0.8583674431,
0.8552992344,
-0.2765130103,
0.1914227307,
-0.4052339792,
-0.0484381951,
0.0874934494,
0.5495191216,
0.2831308544,
-0.1404242367,
0.1968480498,
-0.826610148,
0.1423041224,
0.6881700754,
-0.4260983169,
-0.153437674,
0.3223045468,
0.6017638445,
-0.6183579564,
0.3277883828,
-0.5523381829,
-0.3139288723,
0.8838045597,
0.317247808,
0.889942646,
-0.480262816,
0.2973876894,
-0.0884224847,
0.5267021656,
0.3950485587,
0.2022839934,
-0.0842838287,
-0.8675646186,
-0.4003691077,
-0.3784027696,
-0.7706990242,
-0.2225559801,
-0.5847233534,
0.1966428459,
-0.2758151889,
-0.2654944956,
0.0528316647,
0.2683464587,
-0.7328066826,
-0.1377517879,
-0.1689366102,
0.6868605614,
-0.9226564765,
0.3465111852,
0.9673446417,
-0.4053134322,
-0.6367271543,
-0.0392651819,
0.0734708607,
-0.7943713665,
0.3037207425,
0.2474842668,
-0.7060160041,
-0.2292692959,
-0.3792081773,
-0.3612582684,
1.2054942846,
0.1877103299,
-0.143185094,
0.2675429583,
0.3169240654,
0.7126778364,
-0.861466229,
0.4199122787,
0.75235039,
0.5051348209,
0.3789055347,
-0.7687320113,
0.20573318,
-0.6283295751,
0.0330804177,
-0.2361769229,
-0.9825091362,
0.5214219093,
-0.2587123215,
-0.1778759807,
0.1683404893,
0.4593557715,
0.5207157731,
0.679817915,
0.4999223948,
-0.0774528235,
0.9418617487,
0.0360427834,
1.0062280893,
-0.5650376678,
0.1285748631,
1.1936933994,
-0.7732895017,
0.7685934305,
0.3707412183,
-0.1703733504,
0.3712897003,
0.601095736,
0.408842504,
0.1043786854,
0.2814175785,
-0.59518677,
-0.3097425401,
-0.3539457023,
-0.1857772917,
0.3748890162,
0.4797064066,
0.1201000735,
0.0157031342,
-0.1306531876,
0.1572785228,
0.3809431195,
-0.2949063778,
0.7345433831,
-0.0249714404,
-0.4171804786,
0.340937525,
-0.0193701312,
0.259398967,
-0.4805562794,
-0.3118962348,
-0.1260619462,
0.0817109942,
-0.316655606,
-0.7773073316,
0.1724255234,
-0.1525219381,
0.1050014496,
0.2543150485,
0.9569521546,
-0.5040897131,
-0.1598486006,
0.4124293923,
0.729972899,
0.3994458914,
-0.0608304255,
-0.4105263948,
0.2915885448,
-0.4301947355,
-0.3671864271,
0.1171608791,
0.6172594428,
-0.0259031504,
0.7092911005,
0.5006971955,
0.2814777195,
-0.3036354184,
0.3872764111,
0.9050962329,
-0.4419525862,
-0.1494735181,
-0.8436837196,
0.458666414,
-0.3492444158,
0.0652863383,
0.6562350988,
0.487860173,
0.2752765417,
0.3044669032,
0.812238574,
-0.0808744952,
0.4175285399,
-0.2650236487,
0.533206284,
-0.3565640152,
0.6770601869,
-0.3873564601,
-1.0207808018,
0.0866016001,
0.8001669645,
-0.4060293734,
0.2998822331,
0.5784803033,
0.6382548809,
0.1526972353,
-0.1884543598,
0.530174613,
0.2270775139,
0.4374925792,
0.570494473,
1.2763948441,
-0.0690694153,
0.5208873749,
0.2486124635,
-0.6986330152,
-0.141729936,
-0.8352129459,
-1.1106892824,
-0.3201443255,
-0.0996467471,
-0.533856988,
0.3381761312,
1.4614489079,
0.6201631427,
-0.163593784,
-0.580951035,
0.2506783605,
0.2452014387,
-0.2290959358,
-0.2756292522,
0.2621355355,
-0.3237579465,
-0.6323869228,
0.38129583,
0.60838449,
0.0750072598,
-0.3989371955,
-0.5050011873,
-0.1519554704,
0.6647428274,
0.8803145289,
0.3636236489,
-0.3888276219,
-0.3229911029,
0.0414272696,
-0.1225740835,
0.0860331655,
0.4816329181,
-0.5277088284,
0.4724461436,
0.1382121891,
0.7297219634,
0.2471948266,
0.4257900715,
0.4813290834,
-0.660125196,
0.192190811,
0.2060460448,
0.0479398742,
0.4933439493,
-0.3251028061,
0.6272163987,
-0.079142794,
-0.8216311932,
-0.7108054161,
0.3278929591,
-0.8001461029,
0.0141418176,
1.3668984175,
-0.2485612929,
0.0577960163,
-0.1584664732,
-0.2607061565,
-0.0120720966,
-0.3519712389,
0.7996103168,
0.9415739775,
-0.4810445011,
-0.0299508013,
-0.3087530434,
0.5352703929,
0.166713655,
-1.1510480642,
0.126274541,
0.606954813,
-0.0167483352,
0.1383405775,
1.0080037117,
-0.1016898751,
0.2719725966,
-0.0739567056,
0.2321363091,
-0.0224846974,
-0.5495008826,
-0.2988797426,
-0.1645952761,
0.5562776923,
0.0563090257
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06495v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06495v1
|
An investigation of structures responsible for gender bias in BERT and DistilBERT
| 2024-01-12T10:42:20 | 2024-01-12T10:42:20 |
Thibaud Leteno, Antoine Gourru, Charlotte Laclau, Christophe Gravier
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
In recent years, large Transformer-based Pre-trained Language Models (PLM)
have changed the Natural Language Processing (NLP) landscape, by pushing the
performance boundaries of the state-of-the-art on a wide variety of tasks.
However, this performance gain goes along with an increase in complexity, and
as a result, the size of such models (up to billions of parameters) represents
a constraint for their deployment on embedded devices or short-inference time
tasks. To cope with this situation, compressed models emerged (e.g.
DistilBERT), democratizing their usage in a growing number of applications that
impact our daily lives. A crucial issue is the fairness of the predictions made
by both PLMs and their distilled counterparts. In this paper, we propose an
empirical exploration of this problem by formalizing two questions: (1) Can we
identify the neural mechanism(s) responsible for gender bias in BERT (and by
extension DistilBERT)? (2) Does distillation tend to accentuate or mitigate
gender bias (e.g. is DistilBERT more prone to gender bias than its uncompressed
version, BERT)? Our findings are the following: (I) one cannot identify a
specific layer that produces bias; (II) every attention head uniformly encodes
bias; except in the context of underrepresented classes with a high imbalance
of the sensitive attribute; (III) this subset of heads is different as we
re-fine tune the network; (IV) bias is more homogeneously produced by the heads
in the distilled model.
|
[
-0.4096684158,
-0.679510653,
0.5157647133,
0.392013818,
0.171099171,
-0.0844936669,
-0.1584985107,
-0.2184934616,
-0.2916356921,
0.1465569586,
-0.9419780374,
0.0104610296,
-0.8868709803,
0.1765230596,
-0.5687517524,
1.1066004038,
0.3353138864,
0.3371371329,
-0.1569982916,
0.1235164627,
-0.5448979735,
-0.7390580773,
-0.1343834102,
-0.6632738709,
0.4672813714,
-0.1454760283,
0.619312942,
0.2343893647,
0.2935564518,
0.4448647201,
-0.5125450492,
-0.1157646179,
-0.4663822949,
0.2070847452,
-0.1547985226,
-0.6563764811,
-0.42627123,
0.2008708715,
0.5567041636,
1.1461439133,
-0.1201939061,
0.2845668495,
0.745670855,
1.0323300362,
-0.4450239539,
0.2161972821,
-0.8970538378,
-0.0244760271,
-0.1002077833,
0.0644458458,
-0.4063380659,
-0.2684696317,
0.6317201853,
-0.1010166407,
0.6306282878,
0.1242851987,
0.6433314085,
0.4837717414,
-0.3250002861,
-0.3124294877,
-0.7291972041,
1.0246824026,
-0.5412920117,
0.152280733,
0.2702466249,
0.1216193736,
-0.5219100118,
-0.496995002,
-0.5323275328,
-0.1523518413,
-0.195136562,
-0.2228792459,
-0.3233206272,
0.1270826608,
0.4254599214,
0.2901618183,
-0.2503409386,
0.0724959224,
-0.4413951933,
0.0153645119,
0.4138872325,
-0.1641755849,
0.1537254751,
-0.1065156385,
-0.2260721475,
-0.1047301292,
-0.3876058161,
-0.0534702875,
0.8851684332,
0.4098064005,
0.1496915817,
0.3071625531,
0.2851356268,
0.6509148479,
0.3045037687,
0.247404933,
0.1745770723,
-0.0063089137,
-0.2845353186,
0.6451585889,
0.6105225682,
0.1066603437,
0.3968275785,
0.1113070324,
-0.1371081769,
-0.0975963175,
0.4373881817,
-0.6709532142,
-0.2895596921,
0.1578936577,
-0.658985734,
-0.3940739334,
0.068290174,
-0.4854017496,
-0.3618917763,
-0.4669111967,
0.3204582036,
-0.1491394043,
-0.2795888484,
-0.0208795797,
-0.4837446213,
-0.0458356775,
0.1522255689,
-1.2066496611,
0.2310666144,
0.7563058734,
0.5536854267,
0.1516223401,
-0.2805190384,
0.0321950875,
-0.182611689,
-0.0586578362,
0.1810645163,
-0.2459745407,
-0.0355477855,
-0.104634501,
-0.1154917926,
0.1058337465,
-0.5935085416,
0.4900010824,
-0.2392884195,
0.2891393304,
-0.69577384,
-0.3760508001,
-0.0935285166,
-0.0007477469,
-0.8385969996,
0.8962589502,
-0.050355874,
-1.2524014711,
0.5342390537,
-0.6515387893,
-0.3926206827,
-0.3451907039,
-0.3222037554,
-0.438867569,
0.4141617119,
0.1652461439,
0.3419945836,
-0.4195176959,
0.6494387984,
-0.3557774425,
-0.3840226829,
0.5217750669,
-0.7835463285,
1.2070205212,
0.05387903,
-0.5749663711,
-0.1546078771,
-0.5790215731,
-0.3409172893,
0.1189097464,
-0.1303295046,
-0.569619,
0.3514603674,
-0.2767613828,
0.2418690324,
0.2579165995,
-0.6135920882,
-0.0297214389,
-0.0794631243,
0.7619788647,
1.1592189074,
-0.5838401914,
0.7021698356,
-0.2150100321,
-0.0201428812,
0.2335113585,
0.4185893536,
0.1857533753,
-0.4323760867,
-0.7095221877,
-0.3890315592,
0.5774775147,
0.136316359,
-0.4744354486,
0.5296980739,
-0.1110728979,
-0.1394643933,
-0.8368532062,
-0.0556872413,
0.2078470141,
0.7020308375,
0.2109211236,
0.0608193688,
-0.5093722939,
-1.3303951025,
-0.1285130531,
-0.2368365526,
-0.2267866135,
0.1987471133,
0.462002039,
-0.0065616239,
1.2655773163,
-0.4330380857,
-0.4667010307,
-0.2278454006,
0.3737713695,
0.6295359731,
0.4659717977,
0.8038215637,
-0.7794002891,
-0.1435871869,
-0.5894393325,
-0.6068163514,
-0.6653579473,
0.1123083606,
-0.206365481,
0.0206451062,
0.1918719262,
-0.3304659724,
0.3421301246,
0.5555130839,
-0.2051456273,
0.4593313932,
-0.3044911325,
-0.161753878,
-0.5347505808,
0.0106758168,
-0.0840669796,
-0.1231035814,
-0.6564134359,
-0.2717729211,
-0.1415035576,
0.1958357543,
-0.4766688645,
0.06213516,
-0.514942944,
-0.3093033731,
-0.3695688844,
-0.1345544159,
0.1204464883,
0.5873540044,
-0.0826200396,
0.5842254758,
0.4545936882,
-0.6314868331,
-0.0749532133,
0.2349710315,
-0.2429743111,
0.391511023,
-1.0080075264,
0.0077966941,
-0.7408331037,
0.3808943629,
-1.0702991486,
0.3684031963,
-0.0842311904,
-0.36935395,
0.3047319055,
-0.0270140488,
-0.589400351,
-0.4451273978,
-0.3048674464,
0.3194124103,
0.5964554548,
-0.5600107312,
0.6493635774,
0.3340563774,
-0.1508889049,
-0.8696652055,
-0.9981450438,
-0.4097326696,
-0.0510137565,
-0.598854661,
0.4032151103,
0.0422451384,
-0.4317030013,
-0.0624589026,
-0.306181848,
-0.1508570164,
0.2749041319,
0.527561903,
0.3451609612,
0.0861124322,
0.1208798587,
0.4301868379,
0.1822051555,
0.1687034965,
-0.1489569694,
0.632036984,
-0.1360924393,
-0.2269727886,
-0.3188903928,
0.4024811089,
0.6093729734,
0.0422208197,
0.8693369627,
0.430077672,
-0.2173608541,
-0.3651101291,
-0.5282599926,
-0.5889472961,
-0.5016260147,
0.2589777708,
-0.2182841003,
-0.9474381804,
0.5863378644,
0.1842290014,
0.2416795492,
0.4189032018,
0.7087250352,
-0.4117507637,
0.9715602994,
0.500243187,
-0.2157612443,
0.3786071539,
-0.0504394658,
0.1716466546,
-0.8178046942,
-0.0898386389,
-0.7181517482,
-0.9720263481,
-0.7440962195,
-0.0921010375,
0.2120866776,
-0.007167595,
-0.3151274025,
0.1755905002,
-0.8131169677,
0.305036664,
1.0025948286,
0.050997477,
0.1029925346,
-0.0555671901,
-0.1252121031,
-0.2249137908,
-0.8863095045,
-0.4928403795,
1.0305789709,
0.7189786434,
0.7295946479,
-0.012081638,
0.502371788,
0.5376531482,
0.1750116199,
-0.0925343186,
0.4968559444,
-0.5240556002,
-1.2631449699,
-0.1059946418,
-0.3744106293,
-0.8511470556,
0.3992682695,
-0.1581691653,
-0.5654368401,
0.6338812113,
0.2799373567,
-0.1769085974,
0.1390811801,
-0.6259948611,
0.5186482668,
-0.2758131921,
-0.5090355873,
-0.0085367206,
-0.8403078318,
0.4237861037,
-0.0209360421,
0.031535726,
-0.3586086333,
0.5403670669,
0.5986622572,
-0.3841759861,
0.9513094425,
-0.4478873909,
-0.2752167881,
0.1885975152,
-0.0567092113,
0.1292524785,
-0.1320324242,
-0.1617185622,
0.7465816736,
-0.1587803513,
-0.1375356913,
-0.3105408847,
0.5109680891,
-0.8833996654,
-0.5857497454,
-0.6480228305,
-0.6132852435,
0.2445703745,
-0.0597910397,
0.2493053526,
0.2258079499,
-0.1337236911,
0.2821604013,
0.7937791348,
-0.4283643067,
0.5766012073,
0.4706302285,
-0.1834530681,
0.3172051907,
0.3045394421,
0.2021617293,
0.1687839776,
0.3249990642,
0.1292026788,
-0.4174395204,
-0.3439064026,
-0.0844897553,
-0.0028161111,
-0.4271961749,
0.0104907546,
-0.6429280043,
-0.2890579104,
-0.2926894724,
0.1686821133,
-0.49518466,
-0.2516872585,
-0.4045541286,
-0.0811391622,
0.0416036956,
0.4237727225,
0.0860594288,
0.4372408986,
-0.3779511154,
0.2657909393,
0.619205296,
0.1021216512,
0.2092709392,
-0.4175686836,
0.3537954688,
0.3543458879,
-0.3291256726,
-0.8740221858,
0.2554286122,
0.180578351,
0.5749198794,
0.184951216,
0.189007923,
0.4368864894,
-0.8214207888,
0.6353589892,
0.1003446504,
-1.0450289249,
0.4772912562,
-0.2098601758,
0.0944212452,
0.6105342507,
0.2565830648,
0.0240872484,
-0.5310405493,
-0.4234668314,
-0.798640728,
1.0030045509,
0.6023331881,
0.2624498308,
-0.0341477022,
0.1910414845,
0.3963142037,
0.7055741549,
-0.7549114823,
-0.4729113281,
-0.1566777229,
-0.0538688563,
0.3341171145,
-0.5497515202,
-0.0366517045,
-0.3239018023,
0.4527668953,
0.1693347842,
0.4155566692,
0.3848161697,
-0.2473729402,
0.3498778641,
0.3522017896,
0.5659494996,
0.6059401035,
-0.6187298298,
0.2320979983,
-0.1221778616,
-0.4003351331,
0.2538971007,
0.1574344933,
-0.2611508369,
0.3840770125,
0.2602824569,
0.9841288924,
-0.0978514552,
-0.4670787752,
0.5361827016,
-0.3104560077,
-0.3449578881,
-0.3005231321,
-0.0433610491,
-0.1811880916,
0.526773572,
0.7396005392,
-0.0589531027,
0.3459070325,
-0.7046633363,
0.0351062901,
0.4780631363,
-0.3370260596,
-0.2521640658,
0.8643375039,
0.4604373574,
-0.0714786351,
0.8442125916,
0.0270994641,
-0.7058919072,
0.5443433523,
0.2689383328,
0.9033570886,
-0.1787448972,
0.0977227315,
0.0838474557,
0.615203619,
-0.1268099844,
0.1468714178,
-0.117895849,
-0.7424710393,
-0.3967598379,
-0.8278387189,
0.2035692036,
0.0752897859,
-0.6561413407,
-0.0218801666,
-0.3206293285,
-0.7146436572,
0.1741756499,
-0.3485798538,
-0.6802816987,
-0.0812981874,
0.4255678058,
0.5682948828,
-1.0095878839,
0.6614671946,
0.3974763751,
-0.0632137433,
-0.454200536,
-0.0154089006,
-0.0484719798,
-0.4908481538,
1.2820534706,
0.2061592638,
0.0773586109,
-0.3413344622,
-0.2991130352,
-0.4534494579,
0.8636429906,
0.8242928386,
-1.0961170197,
-0.2767267823,
0.421536088,
0.4857282043,
-0.0585542135,
0.3854100108,
0.6577014327,
0.4219104648,
-0.292844981,
-1.2128810883,
-0.1384613514,
-0.0105403652,
0.3686577082,
0.1577489525,
-0.3007659018,
1.3313735723,
0.1044446453,
0.1638921946,
-0.3436417282,
0.4850742221,
0.350810796,
0.0949693844,
0.6308428645,
0.3170727193,
0.5814003944,
-0.4391937256,
0.8519447446,
-0.0977447554,
0.2850495279,
1.1872181892,
-0.4286381304,
0.2783486247,
0.8169887662,
-0.4395528734,
0.4336479902,
0.3447326422,
0.0571390353,
0.7267550826,
0.5647407174,
-0.0456808284,
0.0311731771,
-0.0811472461,
-0.4109618068,
0.5207082629,
-0.0019052754,
-0.8501647711,
-0.2121718973,
-0.0387276448,
-0.0371855311,
-0.0067416206,
-0.3014487922,
0.6122276187,
0.1957465708,
-0.5149318576,
0.3297851682,
-0.0230672322,
0.9249415994,
-0.6091362834,
0.0783284754,
-0.1182756126,
0.347078979,
-0.0228691846,
-0.6489923,
0.2686195672,
-0.0633097962,
-0.6362361908,
-0.4262792468,
0.8704975843,
-0.5150822401,
-0.4737142026,
0.2958565056,
0.4139802754,
-0.1374033988,
-0.2166995257,
-0.7350253463,
0.1941468716,
0.0589623824,
-0.1601338983,
0.3477275372,
0.4092838168,
0.055586189,
0.4968726635,
0.546749115,
0.0250979364,
0.3585930169,
0.2149943709,
0.754519999,
-0.0918508694,
-0.5018728375,
-1.3164820671,
0.4880204797,
-0.2202502638,
0.0357665345,
0.6508982778,
0.2011341453,
0.5828838944,
-0.1998467743,
0.5632290244,
-0.1345585138,
0.2624531686,
-0.2056729943,
1.0760544538,
-0.3445404768,
0.3085722029,
-0.5238112807,
-1.3488076925,
0.1009971648,
0.6724979877,
-0.2575125396,
0.1835785955,
0.4312541485,
0.3741820157,
0.0839094222,
0.0922770724,
-0.1141990051,
0.2579568923,
0.2932317257,
0.4730404913,
0.8470035791,
-0.2591481507,
0.2411791682,
-0.1797191054,
-0.2003510743,
-0.1749988794,
-1.1504515409,
-0.9940241575,
-0.6223300099,
-0.2900661528,
0.0374735631,
0.1511281282,
0.7141162157,
0.8284290433,
-0.4267852902,
-0.1142193675,
-0.2021056265,
0.215019986,
-0.1802184731,
-0.1643113643,
0.2230342776,
-0.2317898124,
-0.9163749814,
-0.2261020541,
0.0873109996,
-0.0289416444,
-0.4298675656,
0.182766974,
-0.1985409856,
-0.0478436276,
0.6089614034,
-0.3716983497,
-0.5883381963,
-0.040329989,
-0.1239689589,
-0.0454294905,
-0.1654830277,
0.8461361527,
-0.7162985802,
0.3412163258,
0.6364717484,
0.3866234124,
0.1514836699,
-0.0772057697,
0.776943922,
-1.2513384819,
0.3813849688,
0.276691854,
0.4723245203,
0.2437040508,
-0.2439348549,
0.1915512532,
-0.0523246974,
-0.5794622302,
-1.0896770954,
0.0620282479,
-0.6863125563,
-0.6318261027,
0.8502249122,
0.0399381965,
-0.325124681,
0.0210742485,
-0.3211150765,
0.3620072901,
-0.4826729,
0.9734830856,
0.9511765242,
0.1435741186,
0.1133164093,
-0.5645688772,
0.3543245494,
0.5844248533,
-0.2508642375,
0.2230906785,
0.4567804933,
0.1611847878,
0.2078288049,
0.3321015835,
-0.1504141092,
-0.062167041,
-0.2611514628,
0.1249273196,
-0.1782360822,
-0.4026167989,
-0.2914756536,
0.1744375378,
-0.087444663,
-0.4618270993
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06831v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06831v1
|
A Survey on the Applications of Frontier AI, Foundation Models, and Large Language Models to Intelligent Transportation Systems
| 2024-01-12T10:29:48 | 2024-01-12T10:29:48 |
Mohamed R. Shoaib, Heba M. Emara, Jun Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This survey paper explores the transformative influence of frontier AI,
foundation models, and Large Language Models (LLMs) in the realm of Intelligent
Transportation Systems (ITS), emphasizing their integral role in advancing
transportation intelligence, optimizing traffic management, and contributing to
the realization of smart cities. Frontier AI refers to the forefront of AI
technology, encompassing the latest advancements, innovations, and experimental
techniques in the field, especially AI foundation models and LLMs. Foundation
models, like GPT-4, are large, general-purpose AI models that provide a base
for a wide range of applications. They are characterized by their versatility
and scalability. LLMs are obtained from finetuning foundation models with a
specific focus on processing and generating natural language. They excel in
tasks like language understanding, text generation, translation, and
summarization. By leveraging vast textual data, including traffic reports and
social media interactions, LLMs extract critical insights, fostering the
evolution of ITS. The survey navigates the dynamic synergy between LLMs and
ITS, delving into applications in traffic management, integration into
autonomous vehicles, and their role in shaping smart cities. It provides
insights into ongoing research, innovations, and emerging trends, aiming to
inspire collaboration at the intersection of language, intelligence, and
mobility for safer, more efficient, and sustainable transportation systems. The
paper further surveys interactions between LLMs and various aspects of ITS,
exploring roles in traffic management, facilitating autonomous vehicles, and
contributing to smart city development, while addressing challenges brought by
frontier AI and foundation models. This paper offers valuable inspiration for
future research and innovation in the transformative domain of intelligent
transportation.
|
[
-0.5358778238,
-0.8667463064,
0.8846287131,
0.251231879,
0.1010554284,
0.2423734069,
-0.0476510637,
-0.4498771727,
0.338029325,
0.6587605476,
-0.5934666991,
-0.1562692523,
-0.2552165985,
-0.051821515,
-0.9323602915,
0.6721373796,
-0.0107934326,
0.1077268869,
-0.2935457528,
-0.120106943,
-0.5402656794,
-0.3989943564,
-0.5777218938,
-0.32850793,
0.1397249997,
0.0709431246,
0.872431457,
0.5038359165,
0.8592679501,
0.5167816877,
0.1772444397,
-0.2165401429,
-0.171116069,
-0.3082044721,
-0.4052086174,
-0.2832456231,
-0.2951173186,
-0.0479102582,
1.0764958858,
0.7602053881,
-0.1959619075,
-0.267033577,
-0.2310159504,
0.5661351085,
-0.3812317848,
0.1441326737,
-0.6225193739,
-0.2323946804,
-0.5304625034,
-0.1707653999,
0.1681888551,
-0.6817580462,
0.1320393682,
-0.4657408297,
-0.069493264,
0.1630161107,
0.8981502652,
0.3387723565,
-0.7005075216,
-0.3671444356,
-0.963917613,
0.9941766858,
-0.5537979007,
0.4668327868,
0.0188067574,
0.6020416617,
-0.293366462,
-0.9158469439,
-0.9497974515,
-0.0165287927,
-0.0475090481,
0.1817845851,
-0.1353515238,
0.1983235627,
-0.1719181538,
0.4395257533,
-0.5146536827,
0.4739833474,
-0.6187108755,
-0.17549631,
0.6413871646,
0.7280949354,
0.2560392916,
0.2882152796,
-0.6356247067,
0.1708936095,
-0.9776995778,
0.2780491412,
0.0076076007,
0.206546247,
0.0055013392,
0.3605541885,
-0.5577881932,
0.7448145747,
-0.5664846301,
-0.2859424353,
0.2866612971,
-0.5394041538,
-0.3056432307,
-0.3841733336,
1.0286291838,
0.2943644822,
0.0754687861,
-0.6229576468,
-0.3258594871,
-0.057232663,
0.0792667419,
-0.5842457414,
0.2674074471,
0.049091313,
-0.2454130352,
-0.0322278254,
-0.018781174,
-0.7795641422,
-0.3371044099,
-0.5610806942,
0.121115312,
-0.1809133589,
-0.4015408456,
0.2723470926,
-0.0684980154,
0.7291458249,
0.437251389,
-0.9256276488,
0.3710795641,
0.8007824421,
0.7507852912,
-0.1599299759,
-0.4390994012,
-0.1625156254,
0.3038751781,
-0.2988830209,
1.1193647385,
-0.529404521,
-0.5467849374,
0.1890220493,
0.047657039,
-0.090846993,
-0.3225297332,
0.8740587831,
-0.5168510675,
-0.3068213463,
-0.3185561895,
-0.2847549617,
-0.3877997994,
0.4335925579,
-0.5249310732,
0.6935403943,
0.0465235412,
-0.3137671649,
0.121989049,
-1.0388734341,
-0.5395600796,
0.4267507493,
-0.3890275359,
-0.3402445018,
0.1477185637,
0.016568413,
0.3660775423,
-0.5806782842,
0.574644208,
-0.1235040054,
-0.3591285646,
0.1940649897,
-0.2470628917,
0.7005223036,
0.165226981,
-0.126875475,
0.3310496509,
-0.3754454255,
-0.1588765532,
0.0879012719,
-0.2002470344,
-0.2780374587,
0.0972969905,
0.2281378806,
0.1123588011,
0.2417733967,
-0.655677557,
0.0988250896,
-0.2593141198,
0.6134955287,
0.9343186021,
-0.1796093136,
0.5339563489,
-0.3663090765,
0.4334472716,
-0.2051696777,
0.1424971372,
-0.0655607879,
-0.6719962955,
-0.826990962,
-0.020078782,
0.3198256493,
0.6962396502,
-0.8101335764,
0.3886279166,
-0.7632992864,
-0.5448737741,
-0.232201308,
-0.3172401786,
-0.4558959007,
0.4516236782,
0.1032890379,
0.3061507344,
-0.1484705657,
-0.9795250893,
-0.0451049805,
-0.1152118966,
0.3137582541,
0.0762698054,
0.5296897888,
-0.5655276179,
1.2966980934,
-0.19964315,
-0.109013468,
-0.2957196832,
-0.213208437,
-0.0135113979,
0.6763091683,
0.8561176658,
-1.0957187414,
-0.2559922338,
-0.1410118192,
-0.5815920234,
0.1679627448,
-0.0117280157,
-0.2973451912,
-0.4544914067,
0.3074513376,
-0.8666485548,
0.2504087985,
0.3901759386,
-0.5019211173,
0.2300929725,
0.0019049281,
0.1596526355,
-0.7969827652,
0.0158414524,
-0.0955298916,
-0.0756380484,
-0.991345942,
0.2677192092,
-0.1585115939,
-0.0656311959,
-0.1276612133,
0.4603880942,
-0.1909517646,
-0.2310763001,
-0.2872246206,
0.1246142983,
-0.2258058488,
-0.0588402003,
0.1668168604,
0.9105874896,
0.6773148775,
-0.5492627621,
0.361576885,
0.3447386026,
-0.2130298018,
0.4395336509,
-0.3882267773,
-0.1189816445,
-0.1650848538,
0.282284677,
-0.9129897952,
-0.0962930545,
0.1583010852,
-0.0083422819,
-0.074179329,
0.4793200195,
-0.7108935118,
-0.4658611715,
-0.0993856639,
0.0442955717,
0.5122016668,
-0.2566421926,
1.0813579559,
0.8107813597,
-0.3570461869,
-0.1726517379,
-0.9945960641,
0.4956173301,
-0.3647578061,
-0.6999745965,
0.2142973691,
-0.1850323379,
-0.4339763522,
0.0365745872,
0.1949693859,
-0.2860448062,
0.5143382549,
0.2674785256,
0.2242608368,
-0.1073217466,
0.02544179,
0.0988674462,
-0.151563853,
0.3070739508,
-0.1024035886,
0.3838538826,
-0.4199334383,
-0.1097472981,
-0.3064748049,
0.5430793762,
0.8137801886,
-0.628692925,
0.8095861077,
0.6767936945,
-0.3563246131,
0.06775783,
-0.428050667,
-0.1497124285,
-0.5480471849,
0.3260440826,
-0.4844817221,
-1.2159172297,
0.5185189247,
-0.6012877822,
0.1348756701,
0.636567533,
0.6038228273,
-0.0633987337,
0.6223575473,
1.0499055386,
-0.2060555071,
0.5284888744,
-0.4151245058,
0.369186759,
-0.6858427525,
-0.2865555286,
-0.629945457,
-0.1937944442,
-0.8622602224,
-0.2232702225,
0.6054166555,
-0.2777407467,
-0.2224797606,
-0.0538274758,
-0.2283555418,
0.1282447726,
0.3654765785,
-0.2052481771,
0.531337142,
-0.0429016761,
0.3582747579,
0.1808465719,
-0.7262851596,
-0.5391306281,
0.9658805728,
0.4706629515,
0.4111398757,
0.1907233596,
0.2925404012,
0.3387611508,
0.6830577254,
-0.6331542134,
0.7687855363,
-0.0969990641,
-0.5862971544,
-0.2418104708,
-0.5076492429,
-0.7007034421,
-0.0985129476,
-0.1975734681,
-0.7731205821,
0.1393180639,
-0.3767357171,
-0.614315331,
0.4645608068,
-0.3317324519,
0.711835444,
-0.3778596818,
-0.064276062,
-0.3508202434,
-0.5268466473,
0.5581775308,
-0.2222183943,
0.4158949852,
-0.1636779755,
-0.1269793808,
0.6056666374,
-0.3009623587,
0.4989566207,
0.0557342023,
-0.1715862751,
0.4679124057,
-0.2450817078,
0.6429201961,
-0.1763372421,
-0.2047136873,
0.459876895,
-0.468015939,
-0.1711679697,
-0.2952601016,
1.0990332365,
-0.766923964,
-0.6144363284,
-0.2290839553,
-0.6745654345,
-0.4384960532,
0.3610106111,
-0.1424881518,
0.509299159,
0.0020778119,
0.0685438737,
0.5502833128,
0.19608742,
0.8965517879,
0.6475532055,
-0.1507391632,
-0.0866866335,
1.0452001095,
0.1889257878,
0.0835760981,
0.4243111908,
0.1591040641,
-0.5243747234,
-1.109492898,
-0.6966695189,
0.1706376374,
-0.6881687045,
-0.139498055,
-0.9614978433,
-0.1340967268,
-0.2695397735,
-0.2806141376,
-0.3860565126,
-0.3104580641,
0.1328656226,
-0.1489337534,
0.4610308707,
0.8958024979,
-0.028167557,
0.649265945,
-0.6459377408,
0.0088876989,
0.3179306984,
0.4617754519,
-0.1637092382,
0.1335084736,
-0.3968174756,
-0.0699707046,
-0.1011976898,
-0.5149505734,
0.0226632431,
-0.2217273563,
0.8087559342,
0.2259635329,
0.016731672,
0.3656488955,
-0.4619544148,
1.006492734,
0.0489357188,
-0.7641957402,
-0.0078202458,
-0.4581098855,
0.0162256397,
0.5547102094,
0.2375016063,
-0.3088610768,
-0.3653554916,
-0.2149907351,
-0.610855937,
0.3250546157,
0.2602907717,
0.1912550479,
0.3344566226,
0.1112568527,
-0.1059959009,
0.4376727641,
-0.7274054289,
-0.1795641631,
-0.1520453542,
-0.2402126491,
0.0336956307,
0.0484464467,
-0.0577427074,
-0.0856801793,
0.546387732,
-0.1833632141,
0.2579381764,
-0.0823572427,
0.4592420161,
-0.0673972741,
0.2503813803,
0.7596842647,
0.744148016,
0.0757676065,
-0.2416475415,
0.1228403226,
-0.5528821945,
0.0452834293,
0.2146836221,
-0.6371158361,
-0.1180217415,
0.0700434744,
0.6823669672,
-0.5048027039,
-0.7311956286,
0.3976801634,
-0.0540299006,
0.113269031,
-0.5849878192,
-0.0231080614,
-0.0449732617,
0.4027613103,
0.6453946233,
0.2729548216,
0.4805211723,
-0.4939111769,
-0.2947400808,
0.6782641411,
-0.4672939479,
-0.1656769961,
0.7798691392,
0.5684219003,
-0.0994114652,
0.4646821916,
-0.1892055422,
-0.7481122017,
0.5442331433,
0.1312803924,
1.0622731447,
-0.0221840721,
-0.1368945837,
-0.0750867277,
0.5103113055,
0.0342375264,
0.2083699554,
0.0591582619,
-0.8592280746,
-0.5274708867,
-0.6837428808,
-0.2674253285,
0.1714314222,
0.0156678781,
0.1513018608,
-0.3730571866,
-0.3387812376,
-0.446567893,
-0.085629724,
-0.6327331662,
0.2104695141,
0.2668055892,
0.9589170218,
-0.9152690768,
0.5892491937,
0.9537602663,
-0.2124237865,
-0.6900362372,
0.3344852626,
-0.2402369231,
-0.3661218286,
0.5869532228,
0.0287812576,
-0.2430234104,
0.3536942005,
-0.3995288014,
-0.8516161442,
1.202227354,
-0.0939960182,
-0.5743273497,
-0.1065609828,
0.7197751999,
0.3636391759,
-0.2716911435,
0.3152913749,
0.7627188563,
0.6446192861,
-0.2617222965,
-1.0533645153,
0.1364970654,
0.0548245795,
0.3520772159,
0.3320704699,
-1.17677176,
0.9147104621,
0.0820825547,
-0.2246302366,
0.4513170421,
0.7463011742,
0.1506088078,
0.3803986013,
0.612867713,
0.4853197634,
0.3012361825,
-0.4930116534,
0.9821625352,
-0.3565420508,
0.2148697227,
0.302273035,
-0.1893959641,
0.4526539147,
0.5977748036,
-0.2224363536,
0.5253284574,
0.3383642137,
0.1625823826,
0.7604911327,
0.2579726875,
-0.2323303372,
-0.206739828,
-0.3699661493,
-0.303481698,
0.5771226883,
0.6246424317,
0.2925275564,
-0.4850366414,
0.3952823281,
-0.0200718548,
0.0294690114,
-0.6749219298,
0.562995851,
-0.0716144517,
-0.2563438714,
0.1050574929,
0.276681453,
0.5883227587,
-0.8382296562,
-0.0984651297,
-0.1660627425,
0.1450290382,
-0.0050694882,
-0.9576918483,
0.3617987335,
-0.1178615391,
-0.0375127457,
-0.44191733,
0.5515129566,
-0.113586925,
-0.4035662711,
-0.0768403336,
0.5417540669,
-0.0610824749,
-0.0054956181,
-0.6675154567,
0.4212804139,
-0.12824817,
-0.1225378141,
0.1013809219,
0.6479349732,
-0.39058128,
1.0459522009,
0.6936123371,
0.0857466757,
0.0147339692,
-0.2484192103,
1.0949630737,
-0.8911042213,
-0.8339824677,
-0.7752550244,
0.698461771,
0.0135546187,
-0.2117733508,
0.6050308943,
0.5302439928,
0.4160640836,
0.021322282,
1.0277130604,
-0.2302709222,
0.4789811075,
-0.4786127508,
0.5296393037,
-0.3312029541,
0.4544067383,
-0.1314094961,
-0.6416119337,
0.0579293072,
0.1493019611,
-0.5701358318,
-0.1058014184,
0.2267803401,
0.5224952698,
-0.0341726802,
0.3541616797,
0.1337326616,
-0.1091564223,
0.6834295392,
0.5171483755,
1.2371861935,
-0.4603601098,
0.3669588864,
-0.1336726993,
-0.1031576693,
-0.2015313208,
-0.524817884,
-0.740019381,
-0.5371465087,
-0.1944221854,
0.210603416,
0.0805685669,
0.4692208171,
0.546485126,
-0.7536534667,
-0.2923600674,
-0.4976823032,
0.2085809708,
0.1112647429,
-0.2682566643,
0.1664055586,
0.0289600026,
-0.9268305898,
0.6106572151,
0.3612400293,
0.2756881416,
-0.7381039858,
0.0431712493,
0.062959969,
-0.0150096212,
0.3327706158,
0.0994434878,
-0.4185690284,
-0.130071193,
0.0606625602,
-0.1726694703,
-0.2134925276,
0.9581219554,
-0.8582261205,
-0.0920971334,
0.5216730237,
0.9080523252,
0.1545832157,
0.0676392913,
0.6827639937,
-0.0478452258,
0.2557603419,
0.2058524936,
0.3203091025,
0.4785892367,
-0.2496620864,
0.5638685226,
0.521225214,
-0.7023906112,
-0.8158231974,
0.1602243781,
-0.7125667334,
-0.0301973801,
0.8183219433,
0.1370016783,
-0.0852597803,
-0.1289260834,
0.1374785006,
-0.2265495211,
-0.3273248672,
0.44607988,
0.2613376677,
-0.2132249773,
-0.1009530872,
-0.9406477809,
0.383410871,
0.0377773121,
-0.86047405,
-0.2163214236,
0.2778532505,
0.0504782945,
0.2196941972,
0.6219540834,
0.2798941135,
-0.0424772948,
-0.1444084942,
-0.1704654843,
0.0484979711,
-0.3092485368,
-0.2326395214,
0.0805472285,
-0.1939261258,
-0.0666237101
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06477v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06477v2
|
Kun: Answer Polishment for Chinese Self-Alignment with Instruction Back-Translation
| 2024-01-12T09:56:57 | 2024-02-23T12:48:46 |
Tianyu Zheng, Shuyue Guo, Xingwei Qu, Jiawei Guo, Weixu Zhang, Xinrun Du, Qi Jia, Chenghua Lin, Wenhao Huang, Wenhu Chen, Jie Fu, Ge Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this paper, we introduce Kun, a novel approach for creating high-quality
instruction-tuning datasets for large language models (LLMs) without relying on
manual annotations. Adapting a self-training algorithm based on instruction
back-translation and answer polishment, Kun leverages unlabelled data from
diverse sources such as Wudao, Wanjuan, and SkyPile to generate a substantial
dataset of over a million Chinese instructional data points. This approach
significantly deviates from traditional methods by using a self-curation
process to refine and select the most effective instruction-output pairs. Our
experiments with the 6B-parameter Yi model across various benchmarks
demonstrate Kun's robustness and scalability. Our method's core contributions
lie in its algorithmic advancement, which enhances data retention and clarity,
and its innovative data generation approach that substantially reduces the
reliance on costly and time-consuming manual annotations. This methodology
presents a scalable and efficient solution for improving the
instruction-following capabilities of LLMs, with significant implications for
their application across diverse fields. The code and dataset can be found at
https://github.com/Zheng0428/COIG-Kun
|
[
-0.0917286724,
-0.4788071513,
0.3655094504,
0.4116194844,
0.0337129459,
-0.2019590139,
-0.6419116855,
-0.0285612829,
0.0805169567,
0.6312989593,
-0.7030392289,
-0.781236589,
-0.2953828573,
-0.0750152469,
-0.3808680475,
0.9297157526,
-0.0680536032,
0.4202582538,
-0.4105412364,
-0.09988866,
-0.5861573219,
-0.3941116035,
-0.27145347,
-0.1463164091,
0.4631333947,
0.8221353292,
0.5986008048,
1.3121060133,
0.4355303049,
0.2455246001,
0.4932208359,
0.3409351408,
-0.5549671054,
0.1187861264,
-0.0103790145,
-0.6729268432,
-0.6232555509,
0.0084179426,
0.7689059377,
0.577732563,
-0.0452599637,
0.5696204901,
0.1016527861,
0.7279189825,
-0.6559420228,
0.1180561557,
-0.506513834,
0.1337424219,
-0.4448823333,
0.0706087053,
-0.6747197509,
-0.3231034875,
-0.3390371501,
-0.9637614489,
0.272213459,
-0.1178363264,
0.8034458756,
0.4934146404,
-0.0555213019,
0.0850721449,
-0.5513808131,
1.0111602545,
-0.9621315598,
0.4420498908,
0.4716597795,
0.4600752592,
-0.2244601548,
-0.6293478012,
-0.4602814019,
0.2486319244,
-0.1142038181,
0.3090581298,
0.6890318394,
-0.1118066609,
0.2723142803,
0.5410531163,
-0.6669488549,
0.1435247213,
-0.1218182668,
-0.1222762465,
0.973762393,
0.3510841131,
0.5535877347,
0.0763631314,
-0.3783950806,
-0.3110378981,
-0.8776239753,
0.2737264931,
0.485740006,
0.4279485643,
-0.1825990826,
0.3365750313,
-0.2691562772,
0.9127284884,
0.2747148275,
-0.1255159378,
0.162738204,
-0.2128050625,
-0.0258247089,
-0.0544278212,
0.8904867172,
0.3243196309,
0.2192480564,
-0.3759602904,
-0.0875140503,
-0.3731014729,
0.1225903928,
-0.7362284064,
-0.5439415574,
0.2064807862,
-0.284894675,
-0.3427421749,
0.2810373604,
-0.7766645551,
-0.2088244408,
-0.4111134708,
0.2990367413,
-0.0565003008,
-0.1016818658,
-0.1811693907,
0.172112748,
0.6222215295,
0.2814653516,
-1.3239469528,
0.025845686,
0.7964085937,
0.544085443,
-0.4736720324,
-0.42177549,
-0.6053277254,
0.4269790351,
-0.6892931461,
0.4478193521,
-0.4755452871,
-0.166206792,
-0.0543266572,
0.2078256607,
0.0589507483,
-0.3483614326,
0.2243148983,
-0.4512409568,
0.3120550215,
-0.5804821253,
-0.6866561174,
-0.2636396289,
0.2866023183,
-0.6015044451,
1.1843614578,
0.1026949435,
-0.3543824255,
0.3261970282,
-0.4598995149,
-0.5862343907,
0.0595747083,
-0.2468110919,
-0.570417285,
-0.1908865124,
0.5883733034,
0.4505386651,
-0.1626410931,
0.3017118275,
-0.2412837446,
-0.3985488713,
-0.0870639458,
-0.4511765838,
0.8559120893,
-0.0435957573,
-0.4246944189,
0.2727198601,
-1.0015547276,
0.3355173767,
0.1776107252,
-0.3789738417,
-0.2968135178,
0.0796865895,
-0.4530020058,
0.3339025676,
0.7746344805,
-0.6892310381,
0.5128594041,
-0.7323830128,
-0.0626707226,
0.840670526,
-0.3056807518,
0.46790272,
-0.1403052807,
0.376704365,
0.0190263819,
0.3818195164,
-0.4654695988,
-0.3341930509,
-1.1182031631,
0.2006097734,
0.3937335014,
0.6379815936,
-0.6229151487,
0.3777162433,
-0.3669647276,
-0.4823199511,
-0.966463387,
0.7093461752,
0.6444035172,
0.5724334717,
0.6124164462,
0.0902818069,
-0.3838539124,
-0.7413991094,
-0.2165367305,
0.1103472114,
0.0924480408,
0.0969598815,
-0.115405485,
0.0859644562,
0.6499134302,
-0.4265516102,
-0.1765034646,
0.0878831446,
-0.0030149738,
0.2067712843,
0.5970567465,
0.2724310458,
-0.4915948808,
-0.9327602983,
0.1930483431,
-1.0342872143,
-0.1682653427,
-0.2683736682,
-0.764937222,
0.276176542,
0.6100010276,
-0.0025845743,
0.3890565336,
0.6436018944,
0.021546118,
0.2911099195,
-0.1425099224,
0.083075285,
-1.1393922567,
0.0560682826,
-0.4482163191,
-0.2983553708,
-0.5666877627,
0.3045762777,
0.4765480757,
0.0734493509,
-0.2873581052,
0.50277704,
-0.6928921938,
-0.0492344424,
-0.3791388571,
0.127035141,
0.1651030034,
0.8231396079,
-0.1472330242,
1.1100924015,
0.3656240702,
-0.6127722263,
0.6250066757,
0.5473932028,
-0.1308515072,
0.0980815738,
-0.3826305866,
0.4044255018,
0.17766729,
-0.1334444433,
-1.1135663986,
-0.2745094001,
0.4316627383,
-0.2892138064,
0.4487119615,
-0.3320691884,
-0.4160448313,
-0.3407336473,
-0.3012436628,
0.2329977006,
0.5463761091,
-1.0733337402,
0.4976880252,
0.1468524933,
-0.0671420619,
-0.8690420389,
-0.6869807243,
0.0150423031,
0.119827345,
-0.6485581994,
0.1748389304,
-0.1927551478,
0.127086401,
-0.3128222227,
-0.017004963,
0.0812701508,
0.0903010145,
0.1110228449,
0.2874472439,
-0.378770113,
0.3309931457,
0.3915184736,
-0.0888474807,
0.2057456672,
-0.2418360263,
0.4147410989,
0.09422452,
-0.4315210283,
-0.3343181014,
0.2005788535,
0.2889962196,
-0.5064386725,
0.6241383553,
0.7207420468,
-0.0035039254,
-0.3626245558,
-0.4117481112,
-0.0180848502,
-0.531429112,
0.1183454245,
-0.259398818,
-0.2437126338,
0.5583067536,
0.000533973,
0.6506601572,
0.3974208236,
0.6158627272,
-0.1231020913,
1.3902254105,
0.4479725957,
-0.1630184501,
0.4383968711,
-0.2134770751,
-0.0726661086,
-0.8673952222,
-0.0657207444,
0.0598511249,
-0.4718844295,
-0.4141319394,
-0.1845658422,
0.1890642345,
-0.0418668985,
-0.1617129892,
0.2368617654,
-0.7226526737,
0.5147328377,
0.6818333864,
0.0420877226,
0.1462440938,
-0.2955272496,
0.1166467741,
-0.0982669145,
-0.7974860668,
-0.3284010589,
1.3465298414,
0.0286120102,
0.9265779257,
0.1132278442,
0.8052325845,
-0.0709762499,
0.6102617979,
-0.702547133,
0.5405415893,
-0.4545988142,
-0.4804320633,
-0.68871665,
-0.2568253875,
-0.9058709145,
0.0960531309,
-0.1622068584,
-0.2321382016,
-0.1583336294,
0.3635390401,
-0.2951392829,
0.3095250428,
-0.7557518482,
1.0184170008,
-0.5175147653,
-0.4824584424,
0.2428590655,
-0.7865840197,
0.5807904005,
-0.1808645278,
-0.0207110792,
-0.1280233115,
-0.0644699708,
0.6343947053,
-0.7178251743,
0.8340660334,
-0.2803493142,
-0.5075827837,
0.2887940705,
-0.0518582053,
0.5205373764,
-0.1315670907,
-0.0954566449,
0.1562497467,
0.1451168656,
-0.4539263546,
-1.0082753897,
0.8241322637,
-0.9180731773,
-0.9588313103,
0.0244733021,
-0.7908289433,
-0.1885251105,
0.3805361092,
0.2477900386,
0.2801696062,
0.0363921039,
0.0258759521,
0.5166397691,
-0.246044293,
0.4583881795,
0.6635034084,
-0.4159711897,
-0.4766360223,
1.3237844706,
0.3638628721,
0.2924253047,
0.330950588,
0.3003627956,
-0.1311435699,
-0.2546889484,
-0.9742218852,
0.2529912293,
-0.7565866113,
-0.491446197,
-0.2983312607,
-0.3454304934,
-0.6450676918,
-0.0297726188,
-0.5411447287,
-0.2525758445,
-0.3414067626,
0.2067677081,
0.3993825912,
0.6680977941,
0.0929595232,
0.464594543,
-0.8150295019,
0.3632750809,
0.3515446484,
0.5945088267,
-0.0188727435,
-0.5198699832,
-0.7236071229,
0.3819219768,
-0.3292958438,
-0.6070343852,
0.3657695353,
0.3967071474,
0.4815089703,
0.2487277687,
0.3486118019,
0.919125855,
-0.7202654481,
0.8862950206,
-0.1614952683,
-0.8587873578,
0.6703318954,
-0.3479552567,
0.4084960818,
0.5778973103,
0.0997404531,
-0.4926726818,
-0.4560332596,
-0.3165498674,
-0.8748852015,
0.8065781593,
-0.3567936718,
0.285869509,
0.0357940532,
0.5942679644,
0.3786722422,
-0.1166033521,
-0.5121659636,
-0.4427331388,
-0.4122149944,
-0.7389838696,
0.0752284154,
-0.0063913194,
-0.1842230707,
-0.4055925608,
0.993861258,
-0.3500715792,
-0.0925671235,
-0.0327583998,
-0.2781483233,
-0.400611043,
-0.0212294012,
0.4203418195,
0.5165092945,
0.2260498255,
-0.2602434754,
0.3789688945,
-0.5727115273,
0.1459430456,
-0.1702325195,
-0.4411150813,
-0.0482921079,
0.0781133026,
0.5681687593,
0.1200043559,
-0.3558539748,
0.8881702423,
-0.0185761116,
-0.0022039989,
-0.6501076221,
0.4229554832,
-0.1713434458,
-0.0386936478,
-0.0402382575,
-0.418494463,
0.0049806098,
0.0238269623,
0.1642785668,
0.3437882662,
-0.2574344873,
-0.325771302,
0.7698547244,
0.2497792095,
-0.1984773129,
0.7629253864,
0.0374878682,
-0.1933439076,
0.3639206886,
0.703607142,
0.6729177833,
-0.4228083789,
0.057210125,
0.5771964192,
0.0196676832,
-0.2765789032,
0.3821437955,
-0.0882154033,
-0.622425139,
-0.7657535076,
-0.3569605649,
-0.4604135752,
0.2085985839,
-0.9977612495,
0.5142576098,
-0.6894199848,
0.1447421312,
-0.3308098018,
-0.1481470615,
-0.4582835138,
0.2305613905,
0.1912424713,
0.6698430181,
-0.7023021579,
0.9755839705,
0.5619137287,
-0.4434852004,
-1.0451641083,
0.0236416589,
-0.2901629806,
-1.105926156,
0.606321156,
0.182693392,
0.0626795068,
0.3086232543,
-0.9354794025,
-1.0209370852,
1.1033283472,
0.4018095136,
-0.7183175087,
-0.0578523092,
0.1342808008,
0.3820258081,
-0.0744575262,
-0.1354872733,
0.6099923253,
0.5192727447,
-0.2002856135,
-0.4600922167,
-0.0179903023,
-0.4261021018,
-0.1446091235,
0.3568640053,
-0.9889175296,
0.6879729629,
0.011581582,
-0.231385082,
0.3281806111,
1.0517954826,
-0.1375595033,
0.0040134592,
0.1892391294,
0.6060345769,
0.6367611885,
-0.1342930645,
0.896581769,
-0.7991335988,
0.1250130087,
1.3068518639,
0.0176914372,
0.79842484,
0.3103139102,
-0.0593130291,
0.638820231,
0.3947293758,
-0.3947089016,
0.1869454086,
0.1316429526,
-0.0230261665,
-0.5366925001,
0.2689820528,
-0.272218883,
0.5585320592,
0.2367344499,
-0.1767237931,
-0.087351054,
-0.066345945,
-0.0715710223,
0.4417061806,
-0.3053026795,
0.9833819866,
-0.1538524032,
-0.8863512874,
0.764869988,
-0.1186143607,
0.5483546853,
-0.5478900671,
-0.3253076077,
-0.2881494462,
0.0552270226,
-0.3692599237,
-0.7340937853,
0.1227123216,
0.0137744248,
-0.1904494613,
-0.2422716767,
0.4376916289,
-0.9502009749,
-0.6075876355,
-0.0648570284,
0.3527387083,
0.1960612983,
0.4000353515,
-0.5825490952,
-0.177744478,
-0.0490094088,
-0.179005459,
0.2622106969,
0.3853673339,
-0.0693482235,
0.4899251759,
0.6527983546,
0.0720047876,
0.2616615593,
0.2556025386,
0.596534729,
-0.6443524957,
-0.4055407941,
-0.8694532514,
0.5480017066,
-0.0419087447,
-0.3682665527,
1.1147093773,
0.5572256446,
1.0758053064,
-0.0895545781,
0.7443231344,
0.4189896584,
0.7336186767,
-0.5139915347,
0.8783867359,
-0.5206803083,
0.218644768,
-0.0565288849,
-0.6527044177,
-0.3538759053,
0.5241093636,
-0.5788660645,
-0.1281639189,
0.0730804875,
0.7613461018,
0.0237359926,
-0.1766207665,
0.5261715055,
-0.0678495094,
0.2971640825,
0.4398598969,
0.6869209409,
-0.7943717241,
0.6420815587,
-0.3832477927,
-0.0408936702,
-0.114163734,
-0.5376951694,
-0.9782604575,
-0.42678985,
-0.1796714216,
-0.165243119,
-0.0520392582,
0.9490869641,
0.6617269516,
-1.0591087341,
-0.266577065,
-0.0351489075,
0.0463623181,
-0.3481235802,
-0.2033918202,
0.4880209863,
-0.9362018108,
-0.8844544888,
0.473950088,
0.0627055168,
0.0105269933,
-0.3940114677,
-0.1346428543,
-0.1067639887,
-0.1075618938,
0.3176966608,
0.4433021247,
-0.8090571165,
-0.4066672325,
0.2920200229,
-0.322828114,
0.3875157237,
0.4521727264,
-0.4967559278,
0.8353946209,
0.4254313409,
1.0774794817,
0.2637571394,
0.279743731,
0.9357135296,
-1.101859808,
-0.0593691543,
-0.1286394894,
0.0826446265,
0.513640523,
-0.6768440008,
0.4259349406,
-0.0464987718,
-0.538721323,
-0.6124882698,
0.1119299978,
-0.6007882953,
-0.0354115702,
1.0228973627,
-0.4346738756,
-0.4411557615,
0.0650514439,
-0.2745291591,
0.5385261774,
-0.0015767332,
0.8789005876,
0.8335495591,
0.0389347672,
-0.2247125953,
-0.4031446278,
0.4809850752,
0.5588434935,
-0.7248164415,
0.4781015217,
0.2290465087,
0.3224020898,
0.0040873475,
0.1497561932,
-0.2276480943,
0.4905602932,
-0.0581939965,
0.4396544695,
-0.4337229729,
-0.3077000678,
-0.2699103355,
-0.3365330398,
0.1200742647,
-0.352555424
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06829v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06829v1
|
Cross-Attention Watermarking of Large Language Models
| 2024-01-12T09:39:50 | 2024-01-12T09:39:50 |
Folco Bertini Baldassini, Huy H. Nguyen, Ching-Chung Chang, Isao Echizen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
A new approach to linguistic watermarking of language models is presented in
which information is imperceptibly inserted into the output text while
preserving its readability and original meaning. A cross-attention mechanism is
used to embed watermarks in the text during inference. Two methods using
cross-attention are presented that minimize the effect of watermarking on the
performance of a pretrained model. Exploration of different training strategies
for optimizing the watermarking and of the challenges and implications of
applying this approach in real-world scenarios clarified the tradeoff between
watermark robustness and text quality. Watermark selection substantially
affects the generated output for high entropy sentences. This proactive
watermarking approach has potential application in future model development.
|
[
-0.2659039795,
-0.8490387797,
0.4514485002,
0.2063499242,
-0.4967121482,
-0.1759187132,
-0.0490497574,
-0.6225436926,
0.2547916472,
0.8930128217,
-0.4528004229,
-0.1059749946,
-0.7790517211,
-0.2103930116,
-0.6606869102,
0.9568865895,
-0.1815363467,
0.007522318,
-0.3019769788,
-0.0934900269,
-0.1757347435,
-1.0019450188,
-0.637357235,
-0.3122812808,
0.4322354496,
-0.2173576802,
0.8193877339,
0.9545894861,
0.4928771555,
0.271399647,
-0.0539342202,
-0.3061742783,
-0.4819937944,
0.2970696092,
-0.40030393,
-0.4302480817,
-0.1675316691,
0.1566708684,
0.8146771193,
0.3572407961,
0.5013051033,
0.1901095659,
0.1100165546,
0.3566293418,
-1.1025134325,
0.1049633697,
-0.5550810695,
0.2664261758,
-0.2309411615,
-0.2973739207,
-0.5205872059,
-0.0723775253,
0.2197813094,
-0.564455986,
0.0391346924,
0.1612468511,
0.9746270776,
0.3488244414,
0.0195475202,
-0.0570309125,
-0.8752290606,
1.0387136936,
-0.889988482,
0.5061270595,
0.4820141196,
0.0906998217,
0.2697547078,
-0.856677413,
-0.5286971927,
0.0174642485,
0.1936330348,
0.1904103607,
-0.2364012152,
-0.2547343075,
0.1470894217,
0.2886006832,
-0.2076340169,
-0.1762000322,
0.3163386881,
-0.06559214,
0.7128642797,
0.0628432781,
0.2906468809,
0.5126772523,
-0.3542818129,
-0.2566409707,
-0.7831289768,
-0.1771387905,
0.4274571836,
0.2576499283,
0.0794403404,
0.6084393859,
-0.1326354295,
0.5710039139,
-0.166176334,
0.1560091376,
-0.0580157749,
-0.2340703458,
-0.335645169,
0.1324597895,
0.8318582177,
-0.0096023437,
0.6557084918,
-0.2733665407,
-0.1615783572,
-0.2526409626,
0.1190690398,
-0.6258782148,
-0.0944960043,
-0.0784395561,
-0.4957506061,
-0.2231687605,
-0.0363441259,
-0.8478429317,
-0.2598401904,
-0.3021737933,
0.7431189418,
-0.090251334,
-0.1764805168,
0.1376620382,
-0.0572790913,
-0.1758404672,
-0.0105349133,
-0.9172412157,
0.219214797,
0.4924188256,
0.6108002067,
-0.1633896977,
-0.2141865194,
-0.5794050097,
0.6929371357,
-0.125429526,
0.7601619959,
-0.9836639762,
0.1563713253,
0.0250545964,
0.0555499382,
-0.1513845474,
-0.3487062752,
0.1536671072,
-0.7781510353,
0.3090115786,
0.0150219351,
-0.8050793409,
-0.1717681587,
0.032697022,
-0.8895159364,
0.9207411408,
0.0388203152,
-1.2234216928,
0.0734028295,
-0.3948468566,
-0.4488631785,
-0.0459305197,
0.1992030442,
-0.5866989493,
-0.0887438431,
0.0982127264,
0.4374041557,
-0.4108188748,
0.1282075644,
-0.4175876081,
-0.1041575298,
0.3993700743,
-0.5201502442,
0.5808898211,
-0.1982650459,
-0.5124595165,
0.1385730654,
-0.6598288417,
0.2935605049,
0.3960371017,
-0.4169771075,
-0.7165577412,
-0.0264788792,
0.2901623547,
0.097454533,
0.3864596784,
-0.4271379113,
-0.1614883989,
-0.2997145057,
0.4433174133,
0.4432587922,
0.1137193739,
0.2848019898,
0.0306534618,
0.605977416,
-0.009293749,
0.2699016035,
-0.1161788628,
-0.4345473349,
-0.766964674,
-0.220864892,
0.8617482185,
0.7096188664,
-0.6868091226,
0.4018444121,
0.0322737135,
-0.4204154313,
-0.5299297571,
0.2625257671,
0.7159711123,
0.0541342683,
0.3283496201,
-0.3124743402,
-0.454426527,
-0.9425075054,
-0.7863858342,
0.1029871479,
0.1702612638,
0.1891216189,
0.5757197738,
-0.015206743,
0.7492644787,
-0.5441563725,
-0.0883694738,
-0.5162057877,
0.1960582435,
-0.2347324938,
0.6532364488,
0.454767853,
-0.8229953051,
-0.5669987798,
0.0468903296,
-0.4904286563,
-0.1009209231,
-0.0327037722,
-0.3793381453,
0.0805232897,
0.7525535822,
-0.5311101079,
0.5592432022,
0.6856843233,
-0.2902897596,
0.3826962113,
-0.0984261334,
0.0607167631,
-0.94480896,
0.1383742243,
0.0130622033,
-0.1914002895,
-0.5810765624,
0.0897588208,
-0.0508194268,
-0.104097344,
-0.4412429333,
0.8572382927,
-0.5642373562,
-0.0222931504,
-0.4305773973,
-0.1613596678,
0.1436029822,
0.42161116,
0.4100814164,
0.4436519146,
0.5888248682,
-0.3035389483,
0.4498747289,
0.0542151779,
-0.3859744668,
0.2898290753,
-0.7291091084,
0.1740065664,
-0.2268867493,
-0.0414714441,
-0.9056808352,
0.0602989309,
0.2906655967,
-0.2448383868,
0.4725133181,
-0.1765538901,
-0.4782304168,
0.0784146786,
-0.1113631055,
0.5377739668,
0.193790853,
-0.2107322365,
0.3760930002,
0.4565652013,
-0.4069156349,
-0.4110704958,
-0.9702839851,
0.1728919744,
-0.2532558739,
-0.2964579165,
0.4091845453,
0.1816167384,
-0.1875074953,
0.1722600907,
0.167195037,
-0.340457201,
0.1078263372,
-0.0140740285,
0.0097710304,
-0.2805864215,
-0.0100594535,
-0.0282750949,
-0.2523740232,
-0.1111815572,
-0.2488369942,
0.5817341805,
0.4593797922,
-0.3598214686,
-0.6518855095,
0.8976129889,
0.3382683396,
-0.6354305148,
0.8999612331,
0.3286672235,
-0.7041844726,
-0.1288070232,
-0.5178821683,
-0.2132783532,
-0.4010857046,
0.3181919158,
0.030166693,
-0.8032961488,
0.359731555,
0.148215279,
-0.039112974,
0.2617749274,
0.4267627001,
0.0052583558,
1.0594096184,
0.9048503637,
-0.1779495776,
1.0024983883,
0.0107643837,
0.5550616384,
-0.7741267085,
-0.0991106182,
-0.7362013459,
-0.1474837959,
-0.1552501917,
-0.4142619967,
-0.273132354,
0.1838392764,
-0.2409025878,
0.4847003818,
-0.3339783847,
0.4779923856,
0.7866700292,
-0.0080792196,
0.2154931724,
0.0377421156,
0.0706346855,
-0.3874328434,
-0.7482666969,
-0.5191224813,
0.8169201612,
0.2021588236,
0.8670612574,
-0.2625369728,
0.5400425792,
0.1399644017,
0.3876836002,
-0.4708611369,
0.3366802633,
0.0422818325,
-0.8500598073,
-0.5223554373,
-0.4103472531,
-0.9480351806,
0.1790429354,
-0.2687740326,
-0.79128021,
0.1069107875,
0.0714982823,
-0.308794409,
0.3886091709,
-0.767850399,
1.1948949099,
-0.2588674128,
-0.7341057062,
-0.1216621622,
-0.4978836477,
0.0130182728,
-0.2939071059,
0.2216076851,
-0.0050867652,
-0.0729276091,
0.9340642095,
-0.1274999678,
0.8973389864,
-0.1855469495,
-0.2791378498,
0.2435364425,
0.0161785707,
0.5797419548,
-0.1243812293,
0.0083774049,
-0.0212912187,
-0.0222047139,
-0.3584855199,
-0.3962771595,
0.4380053282,
-0.5124868155,
-0.654358387,
-0.3180894852,
-0.7348361611,
-0.315233618,
0.4351283014,
0.214803502,
0.3275457621,
-0.066158779,
0.2034150511,
0.6727994084,
-0.4157634676,
0.6405436397,
0.3560355306,
0.2315299958,
-0.4780430198,
0.8104834557,
0.2374456227,
0.306393832,
0.6459958553,
0.107209675,
-0.3178289533,
-0.5690901279,
-0.0909060463,
0.3338747025,
-0.7772707939,
-0.0791360512,
-0.8849359155,
-0.3262842298,
-0.3832853138,
-0.0203986559,
-0.5268850327,
-0.3315760791,
-0.2754927278,
0.3191688359,
0.2814507186,
0.6234115362,
0.1336308271,
0.4559523165,
-0.8563956022,
0.312582016,
0.368817687,
0.3862321675,
0.0522385761,
-0.4990845621,
-0.6032626033,
0.1194658652,
-0.3483896852,
-0.6780099869,
0.4553793371,
0.2543721497,
0.8061308861,
0.3795751333,
0.1555703878,
0.3399687409,
-0.4751775265,
0.5359521508,
0.204921037,
-1.2807971239,
0.655529201,
-0.1249925792,
0.4933808744,
0.3681084812,
0.4775454998,
-0.3346617818,
-0.6965232491,
-0.5482518673,
-0.9560416937,
0.5623725653,
0.1611989588,
0.2978468537,
0.048393026,
0.1924635321,
0.0745166168,
0.1410883516,
-0.9372370243,
0.1636381,
-0.1498632282,
-0.3276337385,
-0.0669932812,
-0.5415423512,
-0.1368153393,
-0.1383570731,
0.9472247362,
-0.075452283,
0.216535598,
0.1560297161,
-0.2808451951,
-0.019434588,
0.0538846105,
0.5017046332,
0.5298340321,
0.1624857783,
0.2128976434,
-0.1166537479,
-0.4298903346,
0.1535666883,
-0.0962029919,
-0.1986239851,
0.061972253,
0.6771401167,
0.883212626,
0.283300519,
-0.5848340392,
0.5307676792,
-0.0705956146,
-0.1702952087,
0.1866428107,
-0.1352967173,
0.4058165252,
0.4777878523,
0.1109116748,
-0.2372197807,
-0.0383362956,
-0.5558605194,
0.023506714,
0.4560640156,
-0.4147063792,
-0.2691872418,
0.9814091325,
0.0307899583,
-0.2197158188,
0.2574518323,
0.4200847149,
-0.7125767469,
0.6060919762,
0.670011282,
0.9538025856,
-0.4771708846,
-0.0768742412,
0.1919349283,
0.377181679,
-0.207049951,
0.3640509844,
-0.1068636924,
-0.7508529425,
-0.5440527797,
-0.416320473,
-0.5195454955,
0.2222141176,
-0.7898073792,
-0.033188466,
-0.4561806321,
-0.3217404783,
0.2633696198,
-0.294591397,
-0.4169661105,
0.5468745232,
0.3234045804,
0.5137926936,
-0.9881501198,
0.9629125595,
0.6285916567,
-0.1799901575,
-0.3225770295,
0.2508900464,
-0.5031692386,
-0.6851865053,
0.5915243626,
0.0897085145,
0.0113322362,
0.1359368712,
-0.6381825209,
-1.1996282339,
0.5036866665,
0.8169955015,
-0.5046511292,
0.3069229722,
0.3706225753,
0.475148052,
-0.3090750277,
-0.0728752092,
0.456961453,
0.5399034023,
-0.3923260868,
-0.6431543827,
0.2123148441,
-0.495403707,
0.1261407882,
0.1564115286,
-0.7056546807,
0.6796850562,
0.1482388377,
-0.2791192234,
-0.0694311038,
0.5800465345,
-0.0023001069,
-0.0087601105,
0.4092062414,
0.6212636828,
0.3649690449,
-0.1870880872,
1.118375659,
-0.3262608945,
0.396722734,
1.1110423803,
-0.4945696592,
0.9553924203,
0.8482457995,
-0.0968900695,
0.1534967571,
0.4988124073,
0.0040749898,
0.9347980618,
0.4002065659,
-0.2539110184,
-0.4862942696,
-0.3867310882,
-0.5022628903,
0.2216367424,
0.0198310018,
-0.6241717339,
0.0974409878,
0.1147914901,
-0.0832000151,
0.0115810223,
-0.0792057738,
0.7954874039,
0.1105022281,
-0.5171128511,
0.4431499541,
-0.0279157516,
0.5464884639,
-0.4867357314,
-0.0106335422,
-0.15076828,
0.4507012963,
0.0001428907,
-0.7087166309,
0.4106030464,
0.0565482788,
-0.3989509344,
-0.3877803683,
0.6178340912,
-0.6647785306,
-0.4672163129,
0.5828900337,
0.2392357737,
0.1959037483,
-0.3782970607,
-0.5967832804,
0.1899084151,
-0.0723160431,
-0.625615716,
0.384224087,
0.6274650693,
-0.220121026,
0.7730861306,
0.5718211532,
0.0996965468,
0.3267845809,
0.2202704847,
0.6078682542,
-0.6566744447,
-0.7332352996,
-0.9893467426,
0.187369898,
-0.0943895951,
-0.3011354804,
0.6651515961,
0.5136075616,
0.8315134048,
-0.21021384,
1.181209445,
0.2538259625,
0.2726071775,
-0.5319114923,
0.826783061,
-0.4910595715,
-0.203896299,
-0.4607148468,
-1.1419440508,
-0.4042289555,
0.5256148577,
-0.3195335269,
0.0914841145,
0.8459826708,
0.5631707311,
-0.0201488156,
-0.0150634004,
0.3680778444,
-0.1868734509,
0.0681989193,
0.63677001,
0.8724789023,
-0.5918576121,
0.5580528378,
-0.2254533619,
-0.1028873771,
-0.1378673315,
-0.9287266731,
-0.9638626575,
-0.5275437832,
-0.7885684967,
-0.1859444231,
0.183616221,
0.3469173312,
0.7942782044,
-1.0934280157,
0.0525456816,
0.0791352689,
-0.0519365445,
-0.3541331291,
-0.206422165,
0.4431730807,
0.0678861141,
-0.762717545,
0.0471494235,
0.305442363,
0.5342582464,
-0.2133973837,
0.1193184331,
-0.4754216671,
0.3345019817,
0.4026594758,
0.106139712,
-0.3156770766,
-0.2372193485,
-0.2788440287,
-0.1304615736,
-0.1221540272,
0.9081891775,
-0.3114513457,
0.1991571188,
0.7027315497,
0.9453355074,
0.7814173698,
-0.2233058363,
0.7076237798,
-0.5950481892,
0.4364557266,
0.2909325063,
0.3783595562,
0.4860373735,
-0.4524053037,
0.2695676684,
0.3120353222,
-0.2744601071,
-0.77611655,
0.0169642791,
-0.5612682104,
-0.2978544831,
1.1028242111,
-0.653748095,
-0.362170428,
-0.2832249403,
-0.1630635411,
0.4711263776,
-0.040518932,
0.6414444447,
1.1178770065,
0.3224667609,
-0.386279434,
-0.6503603458,
0.3216311336,
0.7836686969,
-1.0276199579,
0.3800858259,
-0.0431499779,
0.2242597193,
0.0659462288,
0.1778532118,
-0.3338279724,
0.0995631292,
0.121981889,
0.3584230244,
0.1266399622,
-0.2210282683,
-0.1569874436,
0.1712027937,
-0.2066858262,
-0.198924005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06469v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06469v3
|
Batch-ICL: Effective, Efficient, and Order-Agnostic In-Context Learning
| 2024-01-12T09:31:17 | 2024-06-05T09:13:17 |
Kaiyi Zhang, Ang Lv, Yuhan Chen, Hansen Ha, Tao Xu, Rui Yan
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
In this paper, by treating in-context learning (ICL) as a meta-optimization
process, we explain why LLMs are sensitive to the order of ICL examples. This
understanding leads us to the development of Batch-ICL, an effective,
efficient, and order-agnostic inference algorithm for ICL. Differing from the
standard N-shot learning approach, Batch-ICL employs $N$ separate 1-shot
forward computations and aggregates the resulting meta-gradients. These
aggregated meta-gradients are then applied to the forward computation of a
zero-shot query to generate the final prediction. This batch processing
approach renders the LLM agnostic to the order of ICL examples. Through
extensive experiments and analysis, we demonstrate that Batch-ICL consistently
outperforms most permutations of ICL examples. In some cases, it even exceeds
the performance of the best order for standard ICL, all while reducing the
computational resources required. Furthermore, we develop a novel variant of
Batch-ICL featuring multiple "epochs" of meta-optimization. This variant
implicitly explores permutations of ICL examples, further enhancing ICL
performance.
|
[
-0.4935261607,
-0.7555121779,
0.5666771531,
0.2450199127,
-0.2667911351,
0.3246501088,
0.0059240251,
-0.4306908846,
-0.2837283611,
0.1888817996,
-0.8340724707,
-0.6646980047,
-0.3989503384,
0.1377883404,
-0.3260694146,
1.086171031,
0.1981815994,
0.4017798901,
-0.0710955262,
-0.449716121,
-0.124478519,
-0.4484654963,
-0.9231669307,
-0.3460781276,
0.4601206481,
0.5773637295,
0.1344257742,
0.9265376329,
0.5107434988,
0.1875941008,
0.1874662042,
0.2515867352,
-0.4376101196,
0.1895164251,
-0.2430568337,
-0.3544881642,
-0.2328724265,
-0.0790146366,
0.6805550456,
0.6634929776,
-0.1979190558,
0.4853895009,
0.0808320865,
0.6221117377,
-1.1301562786,
-0.1342023462,
-1.0936483145,
0.2771852911,
-0.0757583156,
-0.344945848,
-0.7311909795,
-0.072062932,
0.0703789592,
-0.3185876608,
0.1642147601,
0.3112459183,
0.3886570334,
0.4338788688,
-0.3861276805,
-0.3401885331,
-0.8398036957,
1.1018742323,
-0.5997579694,
0.3562347889,
0.0216296166,
0.6856740713,
-0.0951977223,
-1.1626901627,
-0.5344918966,
0.0624608546,
0.1759237498,
0.2208200693,
0.2838857174,
0.3441917896,
0.1787996888,
0.3619420528,
-0.3012452722,
0.3249963522,
-0.0164645016,
0.2814777195,
0.4351244867,
0.3835620582,
0.0613231286,
0.49097085,
-0.6879639626,
-0.0313728787,
-0.843521893,
0.1989249587,
-0.0491568632,
0.3692622781,
0.3402677178,
0.2350226045,
-0.221631974,
0.7856123447,
0.4878821671,
-0.4064574242,
0.059696205,
-0.0168097615,
-0.710594058,
0.2929376662,
0.5484336615,
0.1982872635,
-0.1631240547,
-0.2057596594,
-0.4305876493,
-0.3026589751,
0.1855361909,
-0.9599573016,
0.2839905322,
0.3161179125,
-0.3151394725,
-0.2763678432,
0.0968613625,
-0.4423857927,
-0.0733844191,
-0.4849487841,
0.5471631289,
-0.2926962674,
0.4103008211,
-0.2904665768,
0.2289890647,
0.5039649606,
0.4567870796,
-0.9820408821,
0.5155122876,
0.6499587893,
0.7225478888,
-0.2019685954,
-0.4894087315,
-0.8192773461,
0.3655270636,
-0.5654506087,
0.5096062422,
-0.5790348649,
-0.378205061,
-0.3507582843,
-0.2937671542,
-0.002986664,
-0.764085412,
0.1040368751,
-0.7914253473,
0.1326481849,
-0.1406937093,
-0.6729453206,
-0.3096337616,
0.3132681251,
-0.2285374552,
1.0282484293,
-0.0845941454,
-0.3554982543,
0.8031176925,
-0.7976247072,
-0.4770791233,
0.1248494387,
-0.3595913947,
-0.3292806745,
0.1312343031,
0.1626520902,
0.5986793041,
-0.3415760398,
0.354024291,
-0.4837131798,
-0.6686143279,
-0.0194087103,
-0.5597811341,
0.8250743151,
0.5319872499,
-0.7054797411,
0.1231447086,
-0.4843398333,
0.157681182,
-0.2291870862,
-0.5795282125,
-0.0825875923,
0.190490514,
-0.1770617217,
0.1839707047,
-0.1403624564,
-0.260992974,
0.2686268091,
-0.2332914323,
0.1287059188,
0.8869130015,
0.1434768736,
0.5666107535,
0.0181526151,
0.2417041957,
0.0129845738,
0.5598245263,
-0.4005635083,
-0.0869275928,
-0.5069267154,
-0.5101790428,
-0.0010676329,
0.755559206,
-0.7417935729,
0.1027447209,
0.0147475544,
-0.2935905159,
-0.2589062154,
0.0604279228,
0.685814023,
0.8665580153,
0.681928277,
-0.1083479002,
-0.4405107796,
-0.8251755834,
-0.5554308295,
-0.0933949724,
0.0196309667,
0.4294480681,
0.2742094398,
-0.194223702,
0.9589682817,
-0.4396163225,
0.1003082395,
-0.0710405558,
0.167447716,
0.2360800952,
0.415612787,
0.5996524692,
-0.862051487,
-1.0381584167,
0.0497267991,
-0.877401948,
0.0544926934,
-0.1354738623,
-0.0727408156,
0.2538969219,
0.9519043565,
-0.1545733213,
0.5899708867,
-0.0733813196,
-0.0198437572,
0.4356841147,
-0.2070502043,
0.0865532458,
-0.9489837885,
-0.2022619545,
0.0141403172,
-0.2732047141,
-0.7917181849,
0.2706457376,
0.3041051924,
0.1417264491,
-0.7044849396,
0.7274660468,
-0.5522660613,
-0.2718840241,
-0.167604059,
-0.4423687458,
-0.2780167758,
0.5623281002,
-0.1851057261,
0.8242127895,
0.7488273382,
-0.8424509764,
-0.1418345571,
-0.2919857204,
-0.3900469542,
0.4912068844,
-0.3283329308,
0.0476485379,
-0.4575961232,
0.3937505186,
-1.0320104361,
-0.1202276275,
0.2709772587,
-0.0529070273,
0.6666789055,
-0.2523159981,
-0.3766937852,
-0.2038415372,
-0.1063767374,
0.5891400576,
0.5362864137,
-0.891110599,
0.4846073985,
0.0240452997,
0.4238968492,
-1.1003953218,
-0.7442039847,
-0.0134206936,
-0.4386670589,
0.0887717605,
0.4799629748,
-0.5464195013,
-0.6044336557,
-0.258292973,
-0.1905836314,
-0.2508025765,
0.2213405669,
-0.0306599289,
0.1293035895,
-0.226595968,
-0.050946027,
0.0466898493,
0.1052150056,
-0.2457081825,
-0.751193583,
0.2952729464,
-0.2689931393,
-0.5127305984,
-0.3569402695,
0.1178697199,
0.8206870556,
0.2279909402,
0.7158254385,
0.4039538503,
-0.3387097418,
-0.7236135602,
-0.6440445185,
-0.2937114537,
-0.5420732498,
0.1162639558,
-0.2754864991,
-0.361638248,
0.378023535,
-0.1173838899,
0.426150471,
0.2915243506,
0.4861949086,
-0.2842217386,
0.8775495887,
0.4304272532,
-0.1813825667,
0.6920847297,
-0.453168422,
0.0297889337,
-0.7191843987,
-0.1404503435,
0.020545831,
-0.4759496152,
-0.3028778732,
-0.2655754983,
0.5970440507,
0.1770564467,
-0.6976465583,
0.0072956122,
-0.3112711012,
1.0253652334,
0.6056540608,
0.3002260029,
0.1730602831,
0.1348240972,
-0.269708246,
0.3571321964,
-0.5252074599,
-0.2135236412,
1.0039571524,
-0.1813308895,
0.5893446803,
-0.1286453009,
0.7272136807,
0.3760863543,
0.5439893007,
-0.7478784323,
0.6080043912,
-0.2679260373,
-0.7844663262,
-0.4440594018,
-0.1473770291,
-0.6492916346,
0.4229445755,
0.1025636569,
-0.699192524,
0.0834947228,
0.2302027941,
-0.4817897379,
0.6639940739,
-0.695432663,
0.4504910409,
-0.4096984565,
-0.5455601811,
-0.2457020581,
-1.1344206333,
0.3868988156,
-0.1534342915,
0.0734701678,
0.0189554263,
-0.2666013837,
0.0786522254,
-0.6583285928,
0.6949687004,
-0.3005940318,
0.3483789861,
0.5004651546,
0.0502025783,
0.3773371279,
0.0335089937,
-0.3151991069,
-0.0894643813,
-0.3490297198,
-0.3932816684,
-0.7660499811,
0.5363088846,
-0.5849762559,
-0.6295956969,
-0.2407599837,
-0.4746533632,
-0.1601222754,
0.2694158554,
0.4957400858,
0.8410432339,
0.1570830196,
0.160922125,
0.6351821423,
-0.1894777268,
1.0726411343,
0.5173738599,
-0.0539948307,
-0.4454654455,
0.7095224261,
0.4150133431,
0.4865205586,
0.8205561042,
0.1542645693,
-0.27465868,
-0.7747280598,
-0.6437380314,
-0.2458585948,
-1.0242789984,
-0.2022847086,
-0.5735971332,
-0.1612849534,
-0.0864064693,
-0.607170105,
-0.2573234439,
-0.0932677165,
-0.357442677,
-0.0311990734,
-0.075379692,
0.5613248348,
0.0897760093,
0.2399377525,
-0.3437571526,
0.2408556491,
0.3978738189,
0.3905222416,
0.3066063523,
-0.3089115322,
-0.2836601734,
-0.002104718,
-0.393776387,
-0.4890959561,
0.1922282577,
0.4342807233,
0.7926539779,
0.6842148304,
0.100524202,
1.131821394,
-0.741016686,
0.6274702549,
0.0974113047,
-0.8589608073,
0.4297327697,
-0.216663599,
0.2499289811,
0.9432328343,
0.4734446406,
-0.2542107403,
-0.0994454473,
-0.6468378305,
-1.0451209545,
0.7534126639,
-0.1622460335,
-0.2058741599,
-0.1922232062,
0.7410573363,
0.328987211,
0.3782278299,
-0.6782326698,
-0.7334010005,
0.0859875306,
-0.1433304101,
-0.1453162879,
-0.1180703416,
0.0896357149,
-0.4366942644,
0.6659150124,
-0.3141337335,
0.0812439546,
0.1724565625,
-0.3133518398,
-0.0192313604,
-0.1529212147,
0.6083725095,
0.8033099771,
-0.3464731276,
0.2412927896,
0.6844111085,
-0.4004976153,
0.3269665837,
-0.4050054252,
-0.1673932523,
-0.3337941766,
0.3536540568,
0.7173217535,
0.1923071295,
-0.5277638435,
0.40761742,
0.0196356233,
0.0235252753,
-0.2760083079,
0.0832941979,
-0.5291593075,
0.4927949309,
0.860545516,
0.1692971438,
0.5617635846,
-0.749362886,
0.4797554612,
0.7557956576,
-0.3568931222,
-0.0746399388,
0.6876845956,
-0.2741182148,
-0.2975940406,
0.6976183653,
-0.2159695774,
-0.1975369453,
0.8806095719,
0.6324703693,
1.2279769182,
-0.2613909245,
0.0038116055,
0.2648847103,
0.0787127838,
-0.0213882048,
0.1358280182,
-0.3469133377,
-0.5022144318,
-0.3264993131,
-0.5638779998,
-0.5780901313,
-0.1288291961,
-0.6245173812,
0.4985913932,
-0.9050337076,
0.0785966441,
-0.2471120358,
-0.0377827361,
-0.7201761603,
0.508426249,
0.1120884418,
0.9525135159,
-0.4745585918,
0.9718331099,
0.5732955933,
-0.0014803485,
-0.5831842422,
0.3395684958,
0.1124923378,
-1.051199913,
0.8332912922,
0.3110777736,
-0.1907681972,
0.3098471463,
-0.7208766341,
-0.7169551849,
1.6405823231,
0.3826002777,
-0.3183794022,
0.1997582316,
-0.0520688444,
0.3424113989,
-0.6548017263,
0.5420856476,
0.2999181747,
0.1792033911,
0.4640262425,
-0.3544367552,
-0.1613920033,
0.0550905503,
0.0641796961,
0.2205335498,
-0.7728047967,
0.9069111943,
-0.3244107366,
-0.2727608383,
-0.3049545884,
0.5737373829,
0.4043677151,
0.8669730425,
0.520772934,
0.4007796645,
0.8022825718,
0.1834271103,
1.230686307,
-0.3984227777,
0.2977479398,
1.2648186684,
-0.3269385099,
0.6198422909,
0.584122777,
-0.1770674586,
0.4702306986,
1.0752207041,
0.0697205216,
0.8280568719,
0.1300683916,
-0.6532550454,
0.0210826881,
0.1575212032,
0.013934657,
0.1591985524,
0.3560008705,
-0.4479519725,
-0.4127014279,
0.0836571306,
-0.1146697998,
-0.5035402775,
-0.6194446087,
1.0226298571,
-0.0493360907,
-0.6390838623,
0.5650348663,
-0.2048909366,
0.5241423249,
-0.452994734,
0.0061426056,
-0.4150584936,
0.2235439867,
-0.0598357059,
-0.5162289143,
0.2167450488,
-0.2850154042,
-0.3168568313,
-0.2731976211,
0.5112329125,
-0.2355088294,
-0.5148060322,
0.253169328,
0.3160173595,
0.2415703982,
0.1355452389,
-0.76151371,
-0.3540400267,
-0.1206119806,
-0.301332593,
0.4863336384,
0.4357234538,
-0.2004360557,
0.8209529519,
0.5142877698,
-0.357475698,
0.204927966,
-0.2769174874,
0.5324047208,
-0.4333356321,
-0.3497951925,
-1.4322742224,
0.6426932812,
0.1723988205,
-0.2016455084,
0.5400949121,
0.6463474035,
1.01153934,
-0.1043610796,
0.913118422,
0.1126033291,
0.0195241738,
-0.6370494366,
0.3345008492,
-0.7479375601,
0.4106910825,
-0.2176937014,
-0.9409639835,
-0.694865644,
0.2442909032,
-0.2808412015,
0.1388114989,
0.6099386215,
0.6204831004,
-0.4010266364,
-0.1970125437,
0.5259148479,
-0.036268685,
0.2695301473,
0.2711864114,
0.6151250005,
-0.2477725446,
0.1991149336,
-0.4469081759,
-0.1711499989,
-0.367167145,
-1.1235668659,
-0.7475371361,
-0.4982242286,
-0.1395915002,
-0.0974827558,
0.0390484855,
1.335858345,
0.8579952121,
-0.8300024271,
-0.524538517,
-0.3598473072,
0.2221443504,
-0.514262259,
-0.2267356217,
0.2136177421,
-0.7703877091,
-0.8104941845,
0.6929063201,
0.6000531316,
0.1064880565,
-0.0089650033,
-0.1324561834,
-0.3208225667,
0.1349391788,
0.9396829605,
0.3701278269,
-0.8339576721,
-0.0137612838,
-0.0382848233,
-0.0067542996,
0.1556068659,
0.9053835869,
-0.7750605941,
0.4931454659,
0.2623769939,
0.7854446769,
0.6719864011,
0.0711260885,
0.4055600166,
-0.7887988091,
0.0293607228,
0.1475529373,
0.3076787591,
-0.0317904763,
-0.4994988739,
0.7602467537,
0.2516125739,
-0.6388047338,
-0.8527105451,
0.2730941176,
-0.5998982191,
-0.6564935446,
0.9111789465,
0.0237979479,
-0.1028524861,
0.0937679112,
0.0562316515,
0.2996468246,
-0.1919969767,
0.723256886,
0.4569083154,
-0.5706933737,
-0.0426557735,
-0.5910363197,
0.4607111514,
0.2512454093,
-0.6344394684,
-0.2687219977,
0.2489504814,
0.3096675575,
-0.3109603822,
0.6242433786,
0.0717211664,
0.0011901727,
-0.3185897171,
-0.1105209067,
0.0497184917,
-0.7596071959,
-0.3071990609,
0.1976124644,
0.015517259,
-0.2680043876
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06468v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06468v3
|
Adapting Large Language Models for Document-Level Machine Translation
| 2024-01-12T09:29:13 | 2024-06-09T13:13:03 |
Minghao Wu, Thuy-Trang Vu, Lizhen Qu, George Foster, Gholamreza Haffari
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have significantly advanced various natural
language processing (NLP) tasks. Recent research indicates that
moderately-sized LLMs often outperform larger ones after task-specific
fine-tuning. This study focuses on adapting LLMs for document-level machine
translation (DocMT) for specific language pairs. We first investigate the
impact of prompt strategies on translation performance and then conduct
extensive experiments using two fine-tuning methods, three LLM backbones, and
18 translation tasks across nine language pairs. Our results show that
specialized models can sometimes surpass GPT-4 in translation performance but
still face issues like off-target translation due to error propagation in
decoding. We provide an in-depth analysis of these LLMs tailored for DocMT,
examining translation errors, discourse phenomena, training strategies, the
scaling law of parallel documents, recent test set evaluations, and zero-shot
crosslingual transfer. Our findings highlight the strengths and limitations of
LLM-based DocMT models and provide a foundation for future research.
|
[
-0.0763820782,
-0.8348606825,
0.8676612377,
0.366880089,
-0.3334324956,
0.1418207884,
-0.4627579153,
-0.3756745756,
-0.3003661335,
0.6682172418,
-0.3693677485,
-0.5084263682,
-0.9626581073,
0.5938899517,
-0.466232121,
0.9045610428,
-0.296038568,
0.2392427623,
-0.0603807792,
0.0072861086,
-0.7916128635,
-0.617456913,
-0.8615080714,
-0.1960588992,
0.5084084868,
0.3771386445,
0.4930086136,
0.5819467306,
0.6455605626,
0.2753443718,
-0.1357527822,
0.3595454097,
-0.55894804,
0.1556808352,
-0.2388837934,
-0.6831416488,
-0.7188127637,
0.0241132248,
0.9799570441,
0.8185718656,
0.2118013501,
-0.2214839756,
0.1211726815,
0.411111027,
0.0247367024,
0.1268418133,
-0.798812747,
-0.1047021821,
-0.0617413856,
-0.4010605514,
-0.6344206333,
-0.1602740884,
-0.157836616,
-0.5840752125,
0.3367478848,
0.3640031219,
0.503446877,
0.2776344717,
-0.5031250119,
-0.3680776954,
-0.719248414,
0.5854717493,
-0.9645239115,
0.1471810937,
0.2365734428,
0.06674546,
-0.4366724491,
-0.6591022611,
-0.3118240535,
-0.245369643,
-0.0080828099,
-0.0455483198,
-0.17325899,
0.1007466763,
0.4649916291,
0.2797116041,
-0.5870851278,
0.653483808,
-0.1773988605,
0.1304400116,
0.3475301862,
0.4503880739,
0.3572666943,
-0.0077343462,
-0.1706168801,
-0.0882747173,
-0.4856802225,
0.0236825589,
0.1914165765,
0.4322498739,
-0.2084733844,
0.5420328379,
-0.0750604719,
0.84521842,
0.3792203963,
-0.0307053123,
-0.0802138075,
-0.6062636971,
-0.1700312048,
-0.1067698225,
0.7295919657,
0.378205806,
0.1904641539,
-0.3928065896,
-0.5248880386,
-0.3493556976,
0.1968266815,
-0.8098837137,
0.1588899493,
-0.0616147071,
-0.2431292981,
-0.2219509631,
-0.3422233164,
-0.3537564874,
-0.5157669783,
-0.4006398022,
0.4912196994,
-0.4788380563,
0.0819853321,
0.3077471852,
-0.0975284353,
0.3276831806,
0.5162923336,
-0.934037745,
0.5151654482,
0.8094365597,
1.040864706,
-0.4969193041,
-0.5158459544,
-0.7857531905,
0.0806306675,
-0.6007713675,
0.7960098982,
-0.4568009973,
-0.49657619,
-0.0040786969,
0.3054469228,
-0.4000739157,
-0.4535884261,
0.8969032168,
-0.5226365328,
0.0431917123,
-0.3365214169,
-0.6271309853,
0.0524931215,
0.3936832547,
-0.4589585662,
0.6236606836,
0.2640261352,
-0.6321852207,
0.0149457371,
-0.6512317061,
-0.7679699063,
-0.140364334,
0.2417046428,
-0.0561466776,
0.4427895844,
0.3374361992,
0.7054693103,
-0.6234679222,
0.0602349415,
-0.0695285574,
-0.3489390016,
0.2791621089,
-0.4188374281,
0.5058589578,
0.038633246,
-0.0365517102,
0.3088079691,
-0.7079076767,
-0.2878671288,
0.218498677,
-0.4640705884,
-0.2219115198,
-0.2937149405,
0.0035550173,
0.3604316413,
0.2821919024,
-0.2545603514,
0.44432199,
-0.3882080913,
0.7369619608,
0.6451016665,
-0.0518683828,
0.6902074814,
-0.2879548967,
0.6982774734,
-0.1433760077,
-0.0866016746,
-0.4097470045,
-0.3790041208,
-0.7064989209,
-0.1523399204,
0.3529550433,
0.5118905902,
-0.6465246081,
0.1269105524,
-0.4379906952,
-0.3506160975,
-0.5437435508,
0.2888018489,
0.3493551612,
0.6578939557,
0.2817184925,
-0.3864545822,
-0.2073378414,
-0.7554514408,
-0.3155407906,
0.1676383764,
-0.1260969937,
0.1125200614,
0.2453132421,
-0.1703034788,
0.4139709473,
-0.1705103815,
-0.2686332762,
-0.3657159507,
0.1853795797,
0.4732241333,
0.2943528891,
0.4236779213,
-0.5100089312,
-0.604575038,
0.1427562684,
-0.5562213659,
-0.3486103714,
-0.335282594,
0.1812405437,
0.2968155444,
0.6325730681,
-0.6054090858,
-0.107534945,
0.7557553053,
-0.2584051192,
0.4217971563,
-0.7992241383,
0.1465159357,
-1.158542037,
-0.1124037504,
0.0417129286,
-0.4541985691,
-0.7490056753,
0.1736515164,
0.3041951358,
-0.0800255314,
-0.4067375362,
0.5832294226,
-0.5625471473,
-0.3460240066,
-0.5880841613,
0.154419601,
0.2030747086,
0.2526308596,
-0.0964539275,
0.7292147875,
0.3931205571,
-0.4195481837,
0.2686750293,
0.1463799775,
-0.0971162394,
0.8040519953,
-0.763252914,
0.4338867068,
0.1007998139,
0.416260004,
-0.891669631,
-0.2689294815,
0.0596959144,
-0.2236206234,
0.7734446526,
-0.1994654089,
-0.8021908402,
-0.158387512,
-0.1828659475,
0.1745602936,
0.4769760668,
-0.3792783916,
0.4928466082,
-0.0817798227,
-0.4424304664,
-0.0582242049,
-0.5408216715,
0.569834888,
-0.141673401,
-0.7146145105,
0.4131362736,
-0.065964818,
-0.0756902322,
-0.2951571643,
0.0135302432,
0.0816986486,
0.1830729544,
0.155031085,
0.0165785868,
-0.2116470039,
-0.1138497293,
0.060629867,
-0.1457301378,
0.0460594483,
-0.5082539916,
0.604118228,
-0.0381316766,
-0.1575480402,
-0.2171775103,
0.4413761497,
0.7536916733,
-0.2404726744,
0.7909036279,
0.7668964267,
-0.2511376739,
-0.1509508491,
-0.4531978965,
-0.1166322455,
-0.4213452935,
0.5468257666,
-0.6961421371,
-0.7560681701,
0.4611010551,
-0.1414248794,
0.103822425,
0.5285004377,
0.7549486756,
-0.1225400791,
1.083692193,
0.7921845913,
-0.0686129853,
0.2990666628,
0.0045269085,
0.0907545835,
-0.9096849561,
0.0798378438,
-0.7530353665,
-0.2636552453,
-0.6194995642,
-0.6551626921,
0.1877742857,
0.1599638015,
0.0400763676,
0.3522524536,
-0.1216923222,
0.2813238204,
0.4852521122,
-0.1900337338,
0.6053174138,
-0.0041549928,
-0.0841775239,
0.072191447,
-0.7789878845,
-0.5802928805,
1.0713664293,
0.4319408238,
0.7653499246,
-0.0557323359,
0.3183479011,
0.2848568261,
0.061650116,
-0.66734761,
0.4462642372,
-0.6050707102,
-0.2993809283,
-0.2926071584,
-0.3850023746,
-0.8558811545,
0.1066723019,
-0.1137186959,
-0.2976843417,
-0.2113304883,
-0.2369402051,
0.0686969012,
0.2453254312,
-0.6174753904,
0.7313274741,
-0.4451265633,
-0.1925491095,
-0.2557869554,
-0.5396133661,
0.1646458209,
-0.6881523132,
0.3359386027,
-0.0292127319,
-0.2711186409,
0.5168902874,
-0.0249176007,
0.8071436286,
0.0808119103,
-0.5201615095,
-0.2581340075,
0.1241001263,
0.9080307484,
-0.1492701024,
-0.2760282755,
0.1676410139,
-0.0191823784,
-0.5296820998,
-0.5610161424,
0.9361303449,
-0.8730804324,
-0.9499145746,
-0.1125991493,
-1.0749976635,
-0.3227932751,
0.4172002971,
0.242839247,
0.1944236606,
-0.2483534664,
0.0366663784,
0.6799221039,
-0.2365917563,
0.3758512735,
0.8682360053,
-0.1385626197,
-0.0902275965,
0.6702241302,
0.1523777843,
0.5085151196,
0.5325324535,
0.1620033979,
-0.2976575494,
-1.1410131454,
-0.6463029385,
0.2360597551,
-0.7972007394,
0.1312070936,
-0.7577744126,
0.0144403167,
-0.5982333422,
-0.382846117,
-0.2326137871,
-0.441832453,
-0.3747076988,
0.042567797,
0.1789124906,
0.70281142,
0.151733771,
0.2553897798,
-0.8232322931,
0.3918577135,
0.082255058,
0.0891891867,
-0.4569884837,
-1.2443584204,
-0.2070655972,
-0.1945408285,
-0.0517294444,
-0.725197494,
0.3123458624,
0.1097564548,
0.4067912996,
0.0058367457,
-0.0199049097,
0.3357897699,
-0.7631965876,
0.5721564889,
0.0892287791,
-0.7330777049,
0.32301566,
-0.7573487759,
0.494625181,
0.1041050032,
0.3082095981,
-0.603267014,
-0.3891993463,
-0.1685668081,
-0.5848801732,
0.7347115278,
0.0279343836,
0.3774020374,
0.2637225389,
0.5933436155,
0.1870672107,
-0.1724919826,
-0.454507798,
0.1568764001,
0.1316286772,
-0.1893545985,
-0.4807244241,
-0.1859554201,
-0.0463726409,
0.1482197195,
0.4114409685,
-0.348554343,
-0.0384446941,
0.0782472342,
-0.2835763693,
-0.2281340212,
0.5672287345,
0.726710856,
0.5564418435,
-0.2243131399,
0.0459069833,
0.4836477637,
-0.1403609812,
0.3124158978,
0.3906297088,
-0.1489576846,
-0.0411808863,
0.4492627084,
0.8118440509,
0.3303311169,
-0.3601385653,
0.2284709811,
-0.1793323606,
-0.2279091626,
0.176717937,
0.0360928103,
0.3312010467,
0.2865919769,
0.2285812795,
-0.088518694,
-0.1580605358,
-0.5820049047,
-0.3211567402,
0.3067288399,
-0.307854712,
-0.4550863206,
0.6936035156,
0.3209663033,
-0.5354693532,
0.2770976126,
0.023011934,
-0.3024453521,
0.550906837,
0.8317840695,
0.7857138515,
-0.1734474152,
-0.035234794,
0.0715715066,
0.5930128694,
-0.3166677654,
-0.2820013165,
0.2644385397,
-0.402430594,
-0.5908559561,
-0.5751826763,
-0.493375212,
0.0424569696,
-0.3975496888,
0.3336522579,
-0.4390603602,
-0.0725668594,
-0.0182472467,
0.1186786816,
-0.875410378,
0.0286211986,
0.1577867121,
1.0723071098,
-0.6440176964,
1.0728760958,
0.8215305209,
-0.1941805929,
-0.5754116774,
-0.1168716326,
-0.1443284154,
-0.7915205359,
0.3882451057,
-0.0883385167,
-0.0297314078,
0.3163297772,
-0.0767972544,
-0.6579530239,
0.9187556505,
0.556268394,
-0.9098854661,
-0.4025415182,
0.4408396482,
0.63837713,
-0.4210123718,
0.080929786,
0.6262779832,
0.5126954317,
-0.1891987622,
-1.1270736456,
0.3107535541,
0.2240284681,
0.2533921897,
0.0394880548,
-0.6288228631,
0.7079510689,
-0.217295751,
0.0770749822,
0.2412846386,
0.2969135642,
-0.0265738461,
0.2541541755,
0.3828200996,
0.3189794719,
0.583596468,
0.0681920946,
1.2977721691,
-0.2634890079,
-0.1005314589,
1.141271472,
-0.3807143271,
0.7055134773,
0.4937742054,
-0.0321295634,
0.0147830509,
0.6384452581,
-0.0355456695,
0.2551964521,
0.1288657933,
0.0900475308,
-0.110831745,
-0.1786791086,
-0.3972808719,
0.3039794862,
0.4280242324,
-0.6231017709,
-0.0310204066,
0.0334482491,
0.0774691924,
0.1365054101,
-0.4840272367,
0.7169260979,
0.3304519355,
-0.7755306363,
0.6626296639,
0.576178968,
0.6346113682,
-0.449994415,
0.2224307209,
-0.5499361753,
0.2251229137,
0.0203144588,
-0.6125702262,
0.0674112439,
0.2007244527,
-0.4053930938,
-0.469348073,
0.8748253584,
-0.2386866063,
-0.633698225,
0.3396401405,
0.6105114818,
0.0860331431,
-0.1857519299,
-0.5262213945,
0.2182731181,
-0.1320599914,
-0.168235898,
0.7436873317,
0.7511416078,
-0.1413552165,
0.4492504895,
0.7147750258,
0.1184848249,
0.1865302026,
0.0957214758,
0.7281411886,
-0.7038712502,
-0.211955905,
-0.7569313645,
0.136496976,
0.1814381182,
-0.0445088707,
0.8760381341,
0.2268583477,
0.7144635916,
-0.1000681892,
0.6657733917,
0.4040926993,
0.2970098555,
-0.7202954888,
0.4686498046,
-0.4101549983,
0.3550308049,
-0.1845584512,
-1.0692067146,
-0.3022578657,
-0.016500175,
-0.412088573,
-0.1311454773,
0.6791003942,
0.6636835337,
-0.012058951,
-0.3190903962,
0.7361962795,
0.4642969966,
0.5321322083,
0.717510283,
0.6616271138,
-0.3482527435,
0.7465848327,
0.1655370742,
-0.1343290061,
-0.4174829125,
-0.9507884979,
-0.9639566541,
-0.3521853685,
-0.2339269668,
-0.2218584269,
0.212342903,
0.5502317548,
0.568007648,
-0.5042768717,
-0.0285672266,
-0.0920262039,
0.0289084613,
-0.0329466164,
-0.0927745253,
0.3107875288,
-0.6648412943,
-1.055254221,
0.695043087,
0.4137677252,
0.0444860347,
-0.2017172575,
-0.3363626301,
0.0437966324,
0.1371491551,
0.6615608335,
0.0689127818,
-0.7601620555,
0.0055638892,
0.1914584786,
-0.4355076849,
0.0583265647,
1.0078693628,
-0.3328250647,
0.4221183062,
0.4993349016,
0.8586406708,
0.545686543,
-0.1735311598,
0.8736603856,
-0.5897756815,
0.1008552238,
0.0255463198,
0.3899872601,
0.526507616,
-0.1999955028,
0.4287550449,
0.0922940597,
-0.5712320209,
-0.7865968347,
0.0283972304,
-0.8932030201,
-0.2638342083,
1.3164036274,
-0.3355999887,
-0.0212858599,
-0.0230682287,
-0.3513042629,
0.3601922095,
-0.1130088866,
0.602334857,
0.8671697974,
0.1310151368,
-0.362080127,
-0.7523317933,
0.1681478173,
0.5107041001,
-0.8052335978,
0.0019061911,
0.3806362152,
0.3810638189,
-0.1867342591,
0.487813741,
-0.042272713,
0.1226712391,
-0.0827483535,
-0.377232343,
-0.2522256374,
0.0088390987,
-0.7754203081,
0.0941557065,
0.6042110324,
0.132571876
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06466v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06466v1
|
PersianMind: A Cross-Lingual Persian-English Large Language Model
| 2024-01-12T09:24:10 | 2024-01-12T09:24:10 |
Pedram Rostami, Ali Salemi, Mohammad Javad Dousti
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models demonstrate remarkable proficiency in various
linguistic tasks and have extensive knowledge across various domains. Although
they perform best in English, their ability in other languages is notable too.
In contrast, open-source models, such as LLaMa, are primarily trained on
English datasets, resulting in poor performance in non-English languages. In
this paper, we introduce PersianMind, an open-source bilingual large language
model which demonstrates comparable performance to closed-source GPT-3.5-turbo
in the Persian language. By expanding LLaMa2's vocabulary with 10,000 Persian
tokens and training it on a dataset comprising nearly 2 billion Persian tokens,
we show that our approach preserves the model's English knowledge and employs
transfer learning to excel at transferring task knowledge from one language to
another.
|
[
0.0108742788,
-0.5021328926,
0.6757317781,
0.1819611639,
-0.2460695803,
0.3994462788,
-0.7743550539,
-0.3831571341,
0.1709095538,
0.2368545979,
-0.4612652659,
-0.404322952,
-0.6333318353,
-0.0507623591,
-0.3743928969,
0.9426641464,
-0.1251458973,
0.2265536189,
-0.0446446612,
0.0027683941,
-0.5389990211,
-0.4219406247,
-0.836838007,
-0.3846302032,
0.4531992376,
0.5768455863,
0.7526285052,
0.2579443455,
0.3236582279,
0.2418021113,
0.1175534204,
-0.0006121657,
-0.7517969012,
-0.0436833352,
-0.6983854175,
-0.8345583081,
-0.3677227497,
-0.1484884024,
0.7052320838,
0.5184661746,
-0.4013497233,
0.1668302715,
-0.1153580621,
0.5616729259,
-0.3893334866,
0.3694135845,
-0.8097515702,
0.0080028698,
-0.5302419662,
0.2055476457,
-0.2582188249,
-0.1410927922,
-0.1591504514,
-0.867315352,
-0.259891063,
0.1476060599,
0.6101534367,
0.1890153289,
-0.4402289689,
0.1046612561,
-0.801628828,
1.0369585752,
-0.6230315566,
0.5001574755,
0.4923677444,
0.5214440823,
0.0269959681,
-0.4409408271,
-0.8144304752,
-0.1242884547,
0.1894221455,
0.0181526653,
-0.3995755911,
-0.5857758522,
-0.0248732958,
0.4045747221,
-0.8167596459,
0.2960998416,
-0.470066607,
0.207334727,
0.7491518259,
0.0069822385,
0.5939751267,
0.2354469746,
-0.2083476037,
-0.173308447,
-0.8387572169,
-0.0112694465,
0.1249870211,
0.3547153473,
-0.2390594035,
0.6960383654,
-0.3445701897,
0.3285202682,
0.0242640581,
-0.4176585972,
0.239630565,
-0.0452426039,
-0.05686092,
0.0632808805,
0.6483861804,
0.0724021122,
0.5685706735,
-0.4270031452,
-0.0570837483,
-0.0697637945,
0.0638138577,
-0.469596386,
-0.2042944133,
0.1476666331,
-0.2534870505,
0.1497929096,
-0.1896092147,
-0.1842563152,
-0.3691361547,
-0.3089530766,
0.4233846962,
-0.6019422412,
-0.6380544305,
0.1548249274,
-0.0015359857,
0.2876472175,
0.4600608349,
-0.7627313137,
0.459061265,
0.9637007117,
0.7641690373,
-0.5398724675,
-0.4818745255,
-0.3860223889,
0.387876451,
-0.4474276602,
0.7928621769,
-0.5641316772,
-0.27298522,
-0.2995227873,
0.0281866007,
-0.1541266739,
-0.321701616,
0.2338611931,
-0.5418288708,
0.3462738097,
-0.0091623804,
-0.3184368312,
-0.6550158262,
0.2618133426,
-0.5278434157,
0.9707646966,
0.1811661571,
-0.6521735191,
-0.0158512406,
-0.4593810141,
-0.61253649,
0.2152923048,
-0.0355439819,
-0.0558559708,
0.1185813695,
0.3007124662,
0.4175423682,
-0.7361688614,
0.3516502976,
-0.0400747098,
-0.3176269233,
0.1089005098,
0.0198350381,
0.8585458994,
0.0557468347,
-0.3999550343,
-0.053189151,
-0.5416738987,
0.0888281316,
0.4548463523,
-0.1639906019,
-0.6015597582,
0.1578898877,
0.0461050496,
0.2004257739,
0.3285858333,
-0.6286978126,
0.0856589824,
-0.4495315254,
0.2844390273,
0.6562922597,
-0.3608932793,
0.40462327,
-0.3536572456,
0.6872432232,
0.058470007,
-0.1112103835,
0.147972852,
-0.6603494883,
-0.7399641275,
-0.3181142807,
0.3652074337,
0.9003733993,
-0.8220462799,
0.0548122674,
-0.6621833444,
-0.8158528209,
-0.2341640145,
0.2700202465,
0.3535385132,
0.1094192415,
0.237551704,
-0.6464942694,
-0.3058459461,
-1.1364173889,
-0.4726875424,
-0.1569021791,
0.0910375565,
0.4023147523,
0.4808486998,
-0.1209831983,
0.574960053,
-0.3337429762,
-0.3520912528,
-0.6227685809,
-0.1111907512,
0.4541347325,
0.5081723928,
0.3500935435,
-0.5299550295,
-0.8971117139,
0.675694406,
-0.5229555368,
0.2723510861,
0.0336667337,
-0.3876239657,
0.0675770789,
0.4557922482,
-0.7119070888,
0.2344289422,
0.8618682623,
-0.2560688555,
0.3983293176,
0.0969376266,
-0.0020918113,
-1.4778937101,
0.156461969,
-0.2033082992,
-0.3342930377,
-0.5805853009,
0.1160802692,
0.2374698967,
-0.0910862982,
-0.5727301836,
0.7953690886,
-0.4959091246,
-0.051386375,
-0.1472621709,
0.0331732817,
-0.4476126432,
0.7049441934,
0.3274158537,
1.1024554968,
0.7187678218,
-0.2707819939,
0.4689171612,
0.3630586863,
-0.503629446,
0.6752827168,
-0.5609406233,
0.1439062804,
0.0533190779,
0.1046844348,
-0.7017261982,
-0.1899440736,
0.0417586155,
-0.4128695726,
0.3740401566,
-0.0195513964,
-0.4599941075,
-0.2113239616,
-0.0733651295,
0.5669743419,
0.7359161973,
-0.4681854546,
0.5778396726,
0.6359813213,
-0.7168688178,
-0.4656092525,
-0.6591764688,
0.3297684193,
-0.0302249547,
-0.2864421904,
0.1583011001,
0.2935008109,
-0.3445341587,
0.1723306924,
0.1423519105,
-0.2570585907,
0.0640708059,
0.1978014112,
0.1201018542,
-0.4279421866,
0.193083778,
0.0126321474,
0.0378148519,
0.0416530967,
-0.5309551954,
0.4624805152,
0.1441648304,
-0.4821717739,
-0.1824454665,
0.4225706458,
0.4598777294,
-0.5483815074,
0.9626742601,
0.2686809003,
-0.380128175,
-0.6411471367,
-0.320610553,
0.2485262901,
-0.3950080276,
0.65146631,
-0.47837466,
-1.0367405415,
0.2383577973,
-0.133623004,
0.0644189492,
0.5385437012,
0.9245893359,
0.2244326174,
0.9063703418,
0.9437826872,
-0.4948623478,
0.2241778225,
0.0986093059,
0.3670973182,
-0.7434260249,
-0.1551031172,
-0.4197669327,
-0.1960027665,
-0.2863021195,
-0.925744772,
0.3490258455,
-0.15075019,
-0.39480564,
0.3939676881,
-0.0433220863,
0.5630818605,
0.6904015541,
0.0648290068,
0.4279910922,
0.2307651192,
-0.1955528259,
0.0753474385,
-0.7160618305,
-0.177167505,
1.3100168705,
0.2486932874,
0.8325749636,
0.5257858038,
0.3423386812,
0.0952249691,
0.1883779764,
-0.7752786875,
0.4016189277,
-0.2326152921,
-0.5685132146,
-0.333119452,
-0.3173425794,
-0.7691788673,
0.131213963,
-0.0956672356,
-0.6667130589,
-0.1563246548,
-0.1704226434,
-0.1116098613,
0.61910671,
-0.4035729766,
0.5984766483,
-0.5601072907,
-0.3500795066,
-0.7085744739,
-0.175917387,
0.7453320622,
-0.4405473173,
0.3485335112,
-0.1916725188,
-0.2247935832,
0.7059875727,
-0.2957663536,
0.6820007563,
0.1138517037,
-0.2660491765,
-0.0851001814,
0.3554094732,
0.6317135096,
-0.1005010307,
0.1492171586,
0.4597065747,
-0.387247622,
-0.5527423024,
-0.332424134,
0.7786576152,
-1.0061372519,
-0.9154698849,
-0.5177217126,
-0.6451473832,
-0.665004611,
0.258654207,
-0.2331589907,
0.0395970829,
-0.408631891,
0.0342798084,
0.6013417244,
-0.4832991362,
0.0970108658,
0.611833334,
-0.3439645171,
-0.255741775,
1.0309423208,
-0.194584474,
0.1636005342,
0.4097476304,
-0.023912115,
-0.1128759757,
-0.3899153471,
-0.6405998468,
0.6051586866,
-0.541359663,
-0.0953045189,
-0.5493525267,
-0.2787117958,
-0.2565541267,
0.0227672346,
-0.5300039053,
-0.838906765,
0.125573799,
0.1136543751,
0.5293207765,
1.1435080767,
-0.1078045294,
-0.0046743895,
-0.684304297,
0.2324061096,
0.663179338,
0.4479236305,
0.2425253242,
-0.6654052734,
-0.5808825493,
0.0010931059,
-0.079104729,
-0.8293591738,
0.45024544,
0.3944693506,
0.6094180346,
0.1938661486,
-0.3296505511,
0.5139860511,
-0.9803339839,
0.9105888009,
0.2579324841,
-0.9966335893,
0.3949617743,
-0.5394850373,
0.3650136888,
0.2261081487,
0.6262357235,
-0.8119873405,
-0.3819750547,
-0.3203520477,
-0.5479826331,
0.8589849472,
0.1199634522,
0.027547989,
0.1776636839,
-0.0452564694,
0.1864068657,
0.1054142043,
-0.6962843537,
-0.0094640115,
-0.0711809695,
-0.2386260182,
-0.600562036,
-0.0332797617,
-0.105096072,
-0.397706598,
0.949436307,
-0.1170760766,
0.2219439894,
-0.1358208209,
-0.4399893284,
-0.1962669045,
0.2747611701,
0.5295298696,
0.6883400083,
0.3485823572,
-0.0145039428,
0.4291138947,
-0.6537680626,
0.1407665461,
0.0159548465,
-0.0186390691,
-0.192419216,
0.2610268295,
0.631560266,
0.2712772489,
-0.9472434521,
0.6055006385,
-0.0519991927,
-0.3019477725,
-0.4738498032,
0.0080792001,
0.4985084236,
0.3849395812,
0.3035160601,
-0.2364749163,
0.0345246978,
-0.6375555396,
-0.1451028436,
0.6152871251,
-0.1672128588,
-0.4187771976,
0.80440557,
0.1300506592,
-0.0053232131,
0.424392432,
-0.0336164683,
-1.0267392397,
0.3941302896,
0.6723033786,
0.844443202,
-0.2745500505,
0.1595540643,
0.5845195651,
0.4038390219,
-0.296901077,
0.332200706,
-0.1780771911,
-0.5895797014,
-0.7714918852,
-0.5053932071,
-0.6823580861,
-0.1510564834,
-0.4204995632,
0.0127418349,
-0.4848034382,
0.1152220592,
-0.3186552525,
0.0008980582,
-0.8055813909,
0.0926613584,
0.5268986225,
0.9799612761,
-0.8701885939,
1.2271798849,
0.9438120127,
-0.0812367722,
-1.1911075115,
-0.2400463521,
0.0113349091,
-1.1418019533,
0.9759628773,
-0.1896574497,
-0.0710877627,
0.0756112412,
-0.4168535769,
-1.4215950966,
1.0491179228,
0.1544318646,
-0.6419910192,
0.1896303892,
0.303868264,
0.42659688,
-0.1682441682,
0.0916408896,
0.4033995867,
0.3205399513,
-0.2103034705,
-1.4554855824,
0.1010179371,
-0.4808309674,
0.0636370704,
0.1835606545,
-0.860586524,
1.2276896238,
-0.1332182288,
-0.4206708372,
0.182392776,
0.5809500813,
0.0088851042,
-0.2543662786,
0.3624002337,
0.9370935559,
0.7399542332,
0.0216132421,
1.0813566446,
-0.3488212526,
0.0699630827,
1.1224430799,
-0.5358621478,
1.312802434,
0.2089694142,
-0.3799953461,
0.840900898,
0.2922554314,
0.2985286713,
0.5016710162,
0.1476380825,
-0.1988283992,
-0.3890524209,
-0.1020537615,
-0.4099414647,
0.5804718733,
0.3485395908,
0.0006972032,
-0.1677774638,
-0.1282056123,
0.2321994305,
0.0770848691,
-0.5389739275,
0.8086887002,
0.1199766845,
-0.7853386998,
0.5797667503,
0.2045061141,
0.5869243145,
-0.4822168648,
-0.0167989302,
-0.3613913655,
0.2465960532,
-0.0006654176,
-0.6967055202,
0.0553671718,
0.2971404493,
-0.075919807,
-0.07436084,
0.5337993503,
-0.6222779751,
-0.6497055292,
0.2125838697,
0.8660567999,
0.249510482,
-0.159437865,
-0.6438089609,
-0.2611257136,
-0.0363307409,
-0.1217907667,
0.3472347856,
0.5719285011,
-0.4320107996,
0.6540493369,
0.8502954841,
0.5299099088,
-0.0411816165,
-0.3782412708,
0.886475265,
-0.775803566,
-0.5585271716,
-0.5078243613,
0.2330406606,
-0.0529093184,
-0.3215423524,
1.0545167923,
0.5885424614,
0.9622043967,
-0.1562824994,
0.9645588398,
-0.0024842224,
1.0648304224,
-0.37836954,
0.8723621964,
-0.7717929482,
-0.0820483267,
0.034357924,
-0.9889956117,
-0.1177401841,
0.6382486224,
-0.437828958,
-0.2685763538,
0.828579843,
0.6909479499,
-0.2336356342,
-0.1417265087,
0.3611046672,
0.4836851954,
-0.0986728147,
1.1990866661,
0.9325459003,
-0.1542117745,
0.2781493962,
-0.1096375883,
-0.291787982,
0.0815641657,
-0.6465612054,
-1.21609056,
-0.5049805641,
0.0305142794,
0.0298408847,
0.1868827045,
0.7554993033,
0.7270097136,
-0.9085764885,
-0.5017642975,
0.2584988177,
0.0521011613,
-0.1875090301,
-0.0954894498,
0.1932457238,
-0.2332778126,
-0.671528995,
0.5113997459,
0.3068553209,
-0.2412224263,
-0.3931057155,
-0.1523412019,
-0.1612048149,
0.1574620754,
0.5929902792,
0.5456985831,
-0.6383972168,
-0.0052948855,
0.0590543374,
-0.2072025537,
-0.1189758927,
0.6010714173,
-0.9592112899,
0.0365287736,
0.175372839,
0.8110008836,
0.5258706212,
-0.2198295146,
0.9473948479,
-0.3785006702,
0.3563741744,
0.028015893,
0.3199701011,
0.4756110907,
-0.263315469,
0.6167734861,
0.0964694619,
-0.3588314056,
-0.4248393476,
0.0441577248,
-0.7141418457,
-0.485355407,
1.2603328228,
-0.1528282315,
-0.4430815279,
-0.0188482385,
-0.1547009945,
0.0013990649,
-0.1836810857,
0.5154265165,
0.5764247179,
0.371366024,
-0.1656195074,
-0.6586905122,
0.4513998628,
0.6066613793,
-0.7906371355,
-0.1890559345,
0.3496201932,
0.3837271035,
-0.0747496039,
0.5791924596,
-0.017778514,
0.5809925795,
0.0056938366,
0.2300302982,
0.049196776,
-0.2487057894,
-0.3354556561,
-0.135126546,
0.373444885,
0.1853028685
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06461v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06461v3
|
Between Lines of Code: Unraveling the Distinct Patterns of Machine and Human Programmers
| 2024-01-12T09:15:20 | 2024-03-24T01:20:49 |
Yuling Shi, Hongyu Zhang, Chengcheng Wan, Xiaodong Gu
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models have catalyzed an unprecedented wave in code
generation. While achieving significant advances, they blur the distinctions
between machine- and human-authored source code, causing integrity and
authenticity issues of software artifacts. Previous methods such as DetectGPT
have proven effective in discerning machine-generated texts, but they do not
identify and harness the unique patterns of machine-generated code. Thus, its
applicability falters when applied to code. In this paper, we carefully study
the specific patterns that characterize machine- and human-authored code.
Through a rigorous analysis of code attributes such as lexical diversity,
conciseness, and naturalness, we expose unique patterns inherent to each
source. We particularly notice that the syntactic segmentation of code is a
critical factor in identifying its provenance. Based on our findings, we
propose DetectCodeGPT, a novel method for detecting machine-generated code,
which improves DetectGPT by capturing the distinct stylized patterns of code.
Diverging from conventional techniques that depend on external LLMs for
perturbations, DetectCodeGPT perturbs the code corpus by strategically
inserting spaces and newlines, ensuring both efficacy and efficiency.
Experiment results show that our approach significantly outperforms
state-of-the-art techniques in detecting machine-generated code.
|
[
-0.4401584268,
-0.7711501122,
0.4944655001,
0.2766415179,
-0.195930928,
0.5668272972,
0.0208330862,
-0.4961367548,
0.0896663517,
0.7312378883,
-0.4023730457,
-0.6838208437,
-0.4923935533,
0.1159758121,
-0.51597929,
0.8347748518,
-0.0713872313,
-0.2036623061,
-0.0987318903,
-0.048719909,
-0.4523811638,
-0.7423638105,
-0.072905384,
-0.1034570336,
0.0924500301,
0.2073238641,
0.468966186,
0.9136742949,
0.4737144411,
0.2052221298,
0.0788375512,
0.4671792388,
-0.135071829,
0.0050928653,
0.3505850732,
-0.4669738412,
0.0204454623,
-0.1038300544,
0.4465279579,
0.1599281728,
0.1755524427,
0.206137374,
0.087001428,
0.6107448339,
-0.4734738767,
0.0594707504,
-0.5683000684,
0.0433396287,
-0.6105532646,
-0.583039403,
-0.4907167852,
-0.4463313222,
-0.5249471664,
-0.0847570375,
0.3296028674,
-0.1848973036,
0.7379924059,
0.2464801818,
-0.173188135,
-0.6117210388,
-0.4643579125,
0.5372715592,
-0.6746867299,
0.1134499907,
0.0144762658,
0.0416943394,
-0.3705337048,
-0.6724157333,
-0.4787540138,
-0.3736478388,
-0.1486956924,
-0.2861407399,
-0.3913984001,
-0.4312588274,
0.4256666005,
0.2293738574,
-0.7846506834,
0.0361256972,
-0.1170315221,
-0.4882990122,
0.4762341678,
-0.0578836948,
1.0480507612,
-0.0943671167,
-0.4725403786,
0.1029156372,
-0.7945119143,
0.0441314317,
0.7412426472,
-0.0130619984,
0.0368634388,
0.3728558421,
-0.0948174223,
0.5092359185,
-0.128752768,
-0.1203722283,
0.1788428575,
-0.2605851293,
0.0460190661,
0.0836582109,
0.7432593107,
0.1463596076,
0.3920760155,
-0.2459371537,
-0.3417132497,
0.3111853302,
0.3127333224,
-0.6735591292,
-0.5869911313,
-0.1507196575,
-0.6209372878,
-0.5147491693,
0.5417174101,
-0.4237874746,
-0.6031939387,
-0.1435239017,
0.086615622,
-0.3608159125,
-0.3088951707,
-0.0753890723,
-0.3342216313,
0.6352203488,
-0.0903201029,
-0.5708019733,
0.0204915013,
0.8847414851,
0.7460443377,
0.0072858599,
-0.2452087998,
-0.496589452,
-0.2371428758,
-0.5052865744,
0.8511106968,
-0.6243249774,
-0.1554363817,
-0.2598751485,
-0.0230826903,
0.3906353712,
-0.8522706032,
0.4174066186,
-0.7755633593,
-0.0918954015,
-0.1584260464,
-0.4411953092,
0.0944961309,
0.0499215834,
-0.664394021,
0.9855111837,
0.2934390604,
-0.8936709166,
0.6505426764,
-0.6392292976,
-0.4324798584,
0.2503084242,
-0.4769428074,
-0.6771322489,
0.1055779755,
0.320332706,
0.17431207,
0.0854486153,
0.1813302785,
-0.2660277188,
-0.5845296383,
0.5225641727,
-0.3285989165,
0.9964318871,
0.3555157483,
-0.4109253883,
0.0981919616,
-0.8340227008,
0.2834073603,
0.2447329164,
-0.4299282432,
-0.2843458354,
0.0903504714,
-0.0060275099,
0.16527839,
0.036226172,
-0.3770083487,
0.4274056256,
0.1015435308,
0.5901271105,
0.7645221949,
0.2332627028,
0.2166723311,
-0.3536052108,
0.722227335,
-0.0517534204,
0.0059618298,
-0.5590631962,
-0.4955386817,
-0.3468120694,
-0.433509618,
-0.0429141112,
0.6885409355,
-0.6059058309,
0.6454529762,
0.1287892014,
-0.456038028,
-0.3198082745,
0.3595748544,
0.546642065,
0.1281458884,
0.4189532399,
-0.4800246358,
-0.8587532043,
-0.6330795288,
-0.7202734947,
0.1227420494,
-0.3081459999,
0.1178919673,
0.4498667121,
-0.5530189872,
1.0717579126,
-0.5604954958,
0.3213311136,
-0.0207603201,
0.224436298,
0.1535466909,
0.7294315696,
0.5236613154,
-0.7307643294,
-0.5838362575,
-0.0946278498,
-0.7006910443,
-0.6078765988,
-0.2762859464,
-0.2433102429,
0.0832403675,
0.7561835647,
0.0359953158,
0.3388312161,
0.6234211922,
-0.6005613208,
0.4405846,
-0.0689133108,
0.146905303,
-0.6844906211,
0.2106315345,
-0.2393070012,
-0.106954895,
-0.3488887846,
0.3956323266,
0.238293767,
-0.1169506162,
0.0332161039,
0.0875713676,
-0.7335301042,
-0.2542200685,
-0.3044360578,
-0.2804092169,
0.0229102038,
0.1886799783,
-0.1688262373,
0.9659879208,
0.2237859666,
-0.2060881108,
0.2313242555,
0.0134705128,
-0.5959486365,
0.2898139358,
-0.5661011934,
0.7691064477,
-0.0036104869,
0.1678198129,
-0.9709182382,
-0.0049351878,
0.2412359864,
-0.5670143366,
0.2908141315,
-0.5796201229,
-0.6503425241,
-0.0108527942,
-0.2147171646,
0.3384950161,
0.8665967584,
-0.4063052833,
0.0351169221,
0.2583169043,
0.0855361149,
-0.5418200493,
-0.6428384781,
0.1937599927,
-0.2134032398,
-0.837654829,
0.1824971735,
0.0137790479,
-0.4583303928,
-0.2701938748,
-0.3968208134,
-0.3545243144,
0.4235039651,
0.2834329009,
0.3200033903,
-0.5650947094,
-0.1450394541,
-0.0885147899,
-0.2877547145,
-0.0136878956,
-0.760050714,
0.7791933417,
0.0253954474,
-0.4121900201,
-0.241086036,
0.3704288304,
0.7535200715,
-0.6653602719,
0.2369279712,
0.8513461947,
-0.0115933409,
-0.5033635497,
-0.4896144867,
-0.0509634875,
-0.4244251549,
0.0956297219,
-0.2789035439,
-0.7458697557,
0.4006034136,
-0.1050076559,
-0.3256648779,
0.1530859172,
0.272349596,
0.2671110332,
0.7744166851,
0.7787063718,
-0.1965946257,
0.4655277133,
0.0749114379,
0.4357745945,
-0.6243960261,
-0.1083952114,
-0.740223527,
-0.0149028171,
-0.7139129043,
-0.531332612,
0.1079888418,
0.513988018,
-0.0355322175,
0.6277098656,
-0.9473537803,
0.9237673879,
0.5442224145,
0.11612124,
0.3770852983,
-0.2102942169,
-0.0953180641,
0.1068898216,
-0.2959315181,
-0.7408745885,
0.8579913378,
0.1286906302,
0.5527449846,
0.0849995092,
0.9910395741,
0.7476193309,
0.1703719795,
-0.3725530505,
0.288369596,
-0.0599050783,
-0.4434839785,
-0.0658074841,
-0.4366367459,
-0.8382442594,
0.0221641734,
0.0861406252,
-0.7026506662,
-0.158232376,
0.0909425393,
-0.1955717653,
0.2883254886,
-0.8457995057,
1.0170365572,
-0.1855455935,
-0.2650661767,
0.208887279,
-0.5598182082,
0.2378282845,
-0.14725326,
0.1755601913,
-0.0699738041,
0.0066899504,
0.4513583481,
-0.463652432,
0.6669327617,
-0.1531633288,
-0.3657334745,
0.6053417921,
0.5149850845,
0.670576632,
0.0816045627,
0.3489729166,
0.1547087729,
-0.1652893722,
-0.5607785583,
-0.3539191782,
0.5646948218,
-0.4632893801,
-0.1871685982,
0.0199980587,
-0.2621535659,
0.1171929836,
0.4024636745,
0.5318056941,
0.4593994617,
-0.0134588424,
-0.1543008238,
0.5609374642,
-0.5661660433,
0.4388844371,
0.2962673306,
-0.0324848033,
-0.1485594958,
0.8671019077,
-0.3165545762,
0.1287726164,
0.5646035075,
0.0631921664,
-0.065170832,
-0.612863183,
-0.3750732541,
-0.0418880731,
-0.6458148956,
-0.0601267964,
-0.4992796481,
-0.0180367548,
-0.326649189,
-0.4374378324,
0.1012013927,
0.0944626406,
0.0361797176,
0.1954149306,
0.2204136848,
0.7887040973,
0.2999881804,
-0.0142402779,
-1.0460145473,
0.2567386329,
0.059374135,
0.2322283685,
-0.3317274153,
-0.0287851952,
0.1260786951,
-0.1143310145,
-0.1219883636,
-0.7967679501,
0.5570421815,
-0.3940445483,
0.4559748173,
0.3234755099,
-0.0319462605,
0.4865115583,
-0.3993798196,
0.690862596,
0.0789846107,
-1.2707036734,
0.5701695085,
-0.2997912467,
0.2577526271,
0.0719977021,
0.0264921784,
-0.6544218063,
-0.5597179532,
-0.5706596375,
-0.7133007646,
0.3667643666,
0.1125774682,
0.0810825825,
0.0543745272,
0.1205076501,
0.1296874136,
0.1664866805,
-0.6084893942,
0.0921113193,
-0.211555928,
0.0795252621,
0.1997362673,
-0.1438333541,
0.0747404471,
0.2551182508,
-0.0588985048,
-0.1146453097,
0.4186055362,
0.09066616,
-0.3894734383,
0.1139135808,
0.3345363736,
0.775801599,
0.6896418333,
0.1189880073,
0.346632421,
-0.359790504,
-0.5020827055,
0.0384489037,
-0.1748899519,
-0.2581905425,
0.1012509391,
0.7592047453,
0.2503040433,
-0.1642602831,
-0.6989892721,
0.5062426329,
0.3230548799,
0.0471102595,
-0.458337307,
0.2741724253,
-0.3085035384,
0.507358253,
0.2984153926,
0.5350317955,
0.0312004164,
-0.6332721114,
0.5788464546,
0.367955178,
-0.2294997871,
-0.2115055621,
0.4903848171,
0.1220222414,
-0.442147553,
0.7915699482,
-0.3916535676,
-0.7164240479,
0.8754770756,
0.5371373892,
1.0081452131,
0.2244260013,
-0.0335593261,
0.0390994884,
0.3008651137,
0.1336148381,
0.1459153444,
-0.4610658586,
-0.7879589796,
-0.4674137235,
-0.477661252,
0.1492890418,
-0.121945098,
-0.4339912236,
0.3483909965,
-0.5876780152,
0.1589053273,
0.0600436479,
-0.1671413332,
-0.1924852729,
-0.4349697232,
0.3717662692,
0.6760331988,
-0.8783145547,
0.8621382117,
0.4694514275,
-0.6580076814,
-0.8249454498,
0.4730423093,
0.2446195185,
-1.019323349,
0.6613267064,
0.3304366469,
-0.2130121887,
0.0183185041,
-0.7626594305,
-0.621248126,
0.9263260961,
0.275051564,
-0.1684075892,
0.010097675,
-0.2927209735,
0.2292594165,
-0.05687619,
0.1403416246,
0.463888526,
0.5242135525,
-0.22755301,
-0.6854757071,
0.2637225389,
-0.3366536498,
0.0789339021,
0.75412184,
-0.3471955359,
0.8692828417,
-0.3717551827,
-0.5646852851,
0.1475616693,
0.0312207621,
0.2969523966,
0.3612553775,
0.138949424,
0.3071395755,
0.7909872532,
-0.1245829687,
0.8345665932,
-0.4249156713,
0.3224783838,
0.6040038466,
-0.2982420027,
0.2980386615,
0.3627450168,
-0.435284853,
0.8530749083,
0.1168687716,
-0.5494235158,
0.1832819432,
0.6776258349,
-0.1284579039,
-0.1625584215,
0.3056798577,
-0.3982186317,
0.5652987361,
0.0748562887,
-0.5048276186,
0.021638345,
-0.31987831,
0.3692958951,
0.2987101972,
-0.0023707873,
0.5890417099,
-0.1871013045,
-0.7782127261,
0.6786334515,
0.1114864051,
0.8288635015,
-0.4578222036,
-0.2987968028,
-0.3129748404,
0.3905805647,
-0.6157914996,
-0.5491084456,
0.3042854667,
0.1982145756,
-0.2516227067,
-0.2772363722,
0.7765594721,
-0.105245471,
0.0359233096,
0.0848398954,
0.3494629264,
0.0307032354,
-0.2256559879,
-0.240541473,
0.2476897091,
0.3249055147,
0.1740286797,
0.2022443116,
0.6793368459,
-0.1468778849,
0.3082737029,
1.085652113,
-0.09564244,
0.1807136685,
-0.1154166535,
0.732591331,
-0.6340327859,
-0.5918678045,
-1.1635597944,
0.4821793437,
-0.1597278714,
-0.3916478753,
0.8415198922,
0.6250962019,
0.8994582295,
-0.2746740282,
0.8680845499,
-0.2308886647,
0.1311144531,
-0.7980619073,
0.5776530504,
0.0318292342,
0.6355027556,
-0.6529175639,
-0.6517385244,
-0.5852065086,
0.4311499,
0.0149426814,
-0.0285603311,
0.6986771226,
1.0189648867,
-0.0712614134,
-0.1274028271,
0.1049545258,
-0.2538384199,
0.4799313843,
0.6091349125,
1.2968466282,
-0.1112628281,
0.6369860172,
0.0030723056,
-0.4198360443,
-0.2185854018,
-0.916809082,
-0.6673161387,
-0.4006417096,
-0.2723823488,
-0.4633847773,
-0.1087799892,
0.7164009213,
0.7676823139,
-0.624494493,
-0.1722281128,
-0.5903996825,
0.134448871,
-0.4719025791,
-0.2645977139,
0.1418821663,
-0.4921642244,
-0.2420831621,
0.3354536891,
0.2892249525,
0.1464510262,
-0.1578001231,
-0.152062878,
0.2933639288,
-0.1828989536,
0.4821525514,
0.4393149316,
-0.6181602478,
-0.1064555123,
0.2719030678,
-0.3250283897,
0.1853571832,
1.6517323256,
-0.7454016805,
0.2482244372,
0.7665855289,
0.5937870741,
0.1365203261,
0.0890025795,
0.4588902593,
-0.9366825223,
0.1203095466,
0.3920722306,
0.2628313005,
0.0346361287,
-0.4666591287,
0.5223560333,
0.5220963955,
-0.636531055,
-0.7590591908,
0.5856381059,
-0.6671612859,
-0.5467858911,
0.9357461929,
-0.1670207828,
0.1760725081,
-0.3576603234,
-0.2967714369,
0.1151652336,
-0.2859578431,
0.6344357729,
0.4870574474,
-0.320022732,
-0.1120248288,
-0.3294698,
0.4768830538,
-0.0748191401,
-0.6323401332,
0.0696612149,
0.62262851,
0.3736436665,
0.3538051546,
0.4734611213,
-0.4529722929,
0.2726546824,
0.3665800691,
0.1805642694,
-0.2333557308,
-0.1383297294,
-0.3449232876,
0.3530313075,
0.3084246516,
-0.3464400172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06443v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06443v2
|
BOK-VQA: Bilingual outside Knowledge-Based Visual Question Answering via Graph Representation Pretraining
| 2024-01-12T08:31:42 | 2024-03-15T07:17:10 |
Minjun Kim, Seungwoo Song, Youhan Lee, Haneol Jang, Kyungtae Lim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The current research direction in generative models, such as the recently
developed GPT4, aims to find relevant knowledge information for multimodal and
multilingual inputs to provide answers. Under these research circumstances, the
demand for multilingual evaluation of visual question answering (VQA) tasks, a
representative task of multimodal systems, has increased. Accordingly, we
propose a bilingual outside-knowledge VQA (BOK-VQA) dataset in this study that
can be extended to multilingualism. The proposed data include 17K images, 17K
question-answer pairs for both Korean and English and 280K instances of
knowledge information related to question-answer content. We also present a
framework that can effectively inject knowledge information into a VQA system
by pretraining the knowledge information of BOK-VQA data in the form of graph
embeddings. Finally, through in-depth analysis, we demonstrated the actual
effect of the knowledge information contained in the constructed training data
on VQA.
|
[
-0.5900120735,
-0.8116427064,
0.551718235,
0.1297971606,
-0.3599840701,
0.2407059819,
0.1011459231,
-0.3502299786,
0.1917091012,
0.5045135021,
-0.6245832443,
-0.4672659636,
-0.470543921,
0.0888996795,
-0.0229711495,
0.6226107478,
-0.4810959399,
0.4925983548,
-0.7023543715,
-0.1514013261,
-0.6014702916,
-0.415661186,
-0.3345346749,
-0.0778639615,
0.5570493937,
0.2083764672,
0.4585783482,
0.1180924103,
0.0743028075,
0.3615550101,
0.2849422991,
0.2944354713,
-0.6024580598,
-0.2982339263,
-0.108006835,
-0.6251849532,
-0.2614192665,
-0.2506409585,
0.6979349256,
0.5053408146,
0.1518859267,
0.3599865437,
-0.1406985521,
0.4784712493,
-0.5248060822,
0.6629677415,
-0.5158488154,
0.1826671809,
0.0218398627,
-0.2234648466,
-0.1558600664,
-0.5219554901,
0.171273455,
-0.9385225773,
-0.1789305806,
-0.294161886,
1.1537892818,
0.0390512794,
-0.8807309866,
-0.0399540812,
-0.2228380144,
0.2316396385,
-0.2816731632,
0.8779707551,
0.5814478397,
0.4926348925,
0.2025838792,
-0.8974642158,
-0.8252801895,
0.2551091909,
0.01926402,
0.8045227528,
-0.0884985253,
0.0771591589,
0.2493715435,
0.2644059956,
-0.7918901443,
-0.2313371599,
-0.5217453241,
-0.4293849468,
0.3800710142,
0.0554867461,
0.4671349823,
-0.1637929231,
-0.408552736,
0.0356207192,
-0.6898089051,
0.5335338712,
0.4820422828,
-0.0874677822,
-0.1283302605,
0.8607279062,
-0.5089580417,
0.7129768729,
-0.2623647749,
0.0929422826,
0.4858027697,
-0.7960053682,
-0.141378805,
-0.4993050098,
0.7615657449,
0.4809603393,
0.4528498352,
-0.0983400494,
0.1336013824,
-0.2306023091,
0.1479756534,
-0.8841638565,
-0.2975760102,
-0.139919728,
-0.1327192336,
0.2221368104,
0.1873406321,
-0.7133197188,
-0.0908433422,
-0.3363836408,
0.6827532053,
-0.3987897336,
-0.3209511936,
-0.1042145863,
-0.2964030504,
0.381521821,
0.272378087,
-0.3985359371,
-0.112807937,
0.1700603813,
0.4782986939,
0.3759987056,
-0.3901190758,
-0.4454354942,
0.1245704815,
-0.4539764822,
0.6337660551,
-0.2389026135,
-0.3184936941,
0.1913391352,
0.4759874046,
-0.1350949705,
-0.3376677036,
-0.0082255313,
-1.1620041132,
0.3277209997,
-0.8694554567,
-0.3358242214,
-0.5221304893,
0.4713309705,
-0.5598736405,
0.831420958,
0.3669035733,
-0.9500553012,
0.4787110984,
-0.2671073079,
-0.1815857738,
0.3370716572,
-0.2708110809,
-0.0761026666,
-0.3927212358,
0.6689699292,
0.2119992971,
-0.0889828727,
-0.1388872862,
-0.3964598477,
-0.006049566,
0.1391592473,
-0.0425922312,
0.8524669409,
-0.1816461533,
-0.0209758673,
0.176937595,
-0.4104497135,
0.4835619032,
0.182506755,
-0.2726176977,
-0.4616097212,
-0.6208081245,
-0.5202059746,
0.4656219482,
0.4786716402,
-0.6780503988,
0.0770605132,
-0.3309565187,
0.102033399,
0.6622650623,
0.0245438162,
0.2969971895,
-0.0472636148,
1.0554136038,
0.1275909841,
0.1288257688,
-0.2008540481,
-0.9986987114,
-0.3693856299,
-0.3387684524,
0.3730112612,
0.84540236,
-1.809694767,
-0.1974605769,
-0.378945291,
-0.371124804,
-0.5909789205,
0.3988728225,
0.6574675441,
0.7760041952,
0.4033896327,
-0.3663943112,
-0.5079203844,
-0.9795939326,
0.1322510839,
-0.108432211,
0.1212906241,
0.3234597445,
0.6497488618,
-0.2116524726,
0.8240360618,
-0.6244853735,
-0.0566071197,
-0.1600289643,
-0.013155858,
-0.1226627007,
-0.1496999264,
0.6546923518,
-0.890722394,
-0.6402226686,
0.2111676931,
-1.0044745207,
0.1473846138,
0.4410816133,
-0.4949603081,
-0.04382395,
0.4979934394,
-0.4828086197,
0.5153368115,
0.6248919368,
-0.2316102535,
0.6567236781,
-0.2976571023,
0.3298571408,
-1.0658420324,
-0.2009984553,
-0.2708319426,
-0.3169647455,
-0.4285773635,
0.0731818452,
0.322674334,
-0.1520428509,
-0.472712338,
0.7327726483,
-0.2867343426,
-0.1341693997,
0.1011763811,
0.0895961374,
0.1115563065,
0.6518287063,
0.2357129008,
0.6823673844,
0.6752984524,
-0.2598830163,
0.7311034203,
0.5684511065,
-0.4111995995,
0.6218237877,
-0.4733459651,
0.2610755265,
-0.5550034642,
0.2568820715,
-1.225381732,
-0.234074533,
0.3444668353,
-0.4243646264,
-0.0359727107,
-0.5793512464,
-0.5665566921,
-0.7675694227,
-0.0959696844,
0.8279180527,
0.300732851,
-0.6087038517,
0.5182750225,
0.3917591572,
-0.4118186235,
-0.834209919,
-0.6735011339,
-0.251090616,
-0.0298503749,
-0.8614441156,
-0.022213608,
0.0484386981,
0.2596630156,
0.2668670714,
0.1289450228,
-0.369247824,
-0.4887901545,
0.0844605044,
0.1318077743,
-0.4437378943,
0.1493026614,
0.175452739,
-0.0059033437,
0.0706919283,
-0.4512669742,
0.4583715796,
-0.2517238557,
-0.3585468829,
-0.2594403923,
0.5040145516,
0.2115365416,
-0.6766415238,
0.6261307001,
0.7737503648,
-0.2907156646,
0.0696249306,
-0.2306524217,
0.1505854577,
-0.4564432502,
0.661074996,
-0.6678056121,
-0.6729412675,
0.6923987269,
0.0929854959,
-0.3713574409,
0.1110316813,
0.7326610088,
-0.4236291647,
0.9092463255,
0.4904279113,
0.3912439942,
0.3811525702,
-0.6012628675,
-0.0253620725,
-0.514111042,
-0.4843778312,
0.1500877887,
-0.03527309,
-0.2247787565,
-0.5864336491,
0.4367781579,
0.0642745271,
-0.2954657078,
0.0710749552,
0.0861257091,
0.3731983304,
0.7295134664,
0.2951855659,
0.1980928928,
-0.1271944493,
-0.4156350791,
-0.1257309318,
-0.9832425117,
-0.0195856616,
1.226947546,
0.0112776337,
0.4083918929,
0.0988073274,
0.3563303053,
-0.3456568718,
0.2931216061,
-0.5468422174,
0.5088685751,
0.0399599336,
-0.5792652369,
-0.4229698777,
-0.5956814289,
-0.9576283693,
0.3772684038,
-0.149873361,
-0.4676115513,
0.111384511,
0.3105744123,
-0.0714080036,
0.1969857812,
-0.9282869101,
1.3264194727,
-0.4688062072,
-0.027212631,
0.0727315694,
-0.601452291,
0.5009821653,
-0.0768368319,
0.3609295785,
0.3259391785,
0.0436326414,
0.6468244791,
-0.4391323626,
0.7354906201,
-0.5268552899,
-0.1560588181,
0.4412471056,
-0.2192033678,
0.3206986487,
0.267662555,
0.5159021616,
0.2307820618,
0.3722932637,
-0.5755259991,
-0.8957033753,
0.2930553555,
-0.7620000839,
-0.4610241354,
0.07597965,
-0.58311373,
-0.6171162724,
0.4062665403,
0.5551841855,
0.464961201,
0.0461189449,
0.0992047265,
0.4127651155,
-0.4902345836,
-0.0802339613,
0.1895145923,
-0.6528072953,
-0.7095216513,
1.2302871943,
0.4958934486,
0.3520976603,
0.3841155767,
0.0486971661,
-0.7847713232,
-0.3530869782,
-0.7999729514,
0.4222782254,
-1.0454368591,
-0.096559979,
-0.5363647938,
-0.2964977324,
-0.3242266774,
0.1909727454,
-0.1679852754,
-0.1114158332,
0.1148214862,
-0.3818827868,
0.2211730331,
0.5507534146,
0.1825644225,
0.3439845145,
-0.6808707118,
0.8387913704,
0.9443666339,
0.4530484974,
-0.1510130912,
-0.3507179022,
-0.5329039097,
0.4039854109,
-0.264960736,
-1.1860996485,
0.0858253688,
0.0651088953,
0.6533447504,
0.2034352273,
-0.1685726196,
0.8834030628,
-0.3592193127,
0.6131588221,
0.1165043265,
-0.600520432,
0.1839068234,
-0.4521593451,
0.5197649598,
0.3503023088,
0.7308044434,
-0.3888165951,
-0.2203538865,
-0.394410491,
-0.7325021625,
0.3950888216,
0.0671337247,
0.2469091117,
0.2580269873,
0.0837728903,
0.2148171961,
0.4902325571,
-0.8314660192,
-0.0279377382,
-0.9190914035,
-0.2396252602,
-0.0316066891,
-0.0787408054,
-0.2630866766,
-0.6062299609,
0.438572973,
-0.4169679582,
0.2958739698,
0.0686327219,
-0.3927532136,
0.2354374528,
-0.1975297928,
0.2776194513,
0.8505318761,
0.1790065467,
0.0076515432,
0.3841514289,
-0.3351230323,
-0.000650317,
0.1774417311,
-0.1821347326,
-0.1609852463,
0.4635234773,
0.8144390583,
-0.1090034992,
-0.7336932421,
0.8047853708,
-0.1549870968,
-0.3366010487,
-0.31376037,
-0.4206625521,
0.2833039165,
0.4256470799,
0.1679974645,
-0.4406841099,
-0.110931322,
-0.5302088261,
0.1857618541,
0.5911376476,
-0.4109532535,
-0.4682029784,
0.5612257123,
-0.0698490366,
0.2878318727,
0.5136550665,
-0.2146059126,
-0.7207850814,
0.6204727292,
0.3218629062,
0.241599381,
-0.1605361849,
0.6520982981,
0.4324135482,
0.3385930061,
0.4347230792,
0.9635226727,
-0.1261671782,
-0.9049753547,
-0.5290068388,
-0.2465768754,
-0.0555274412,
0.1865188479,
-0.4844411314,
0.1398712397,
-0.2100890577,
-0.2013467848,
-0.388202548,
-0.3371124268,
-1.1443749666,
0.3814966381,
0.1317893714,
0.4488601983,
-0.7746205926,
0.7904440761,
0.9280620217,
-0.6847655773,
-0.7397419214,
-0.2383072823,
-0.2991302311,
-1.0389531851,
0.985665679,
-0.1512659788,
-0.0033743109,
0.0582337156,
-0.3531801403,
-0.7637696266,
1.0072965622,
0.7800096273,
0.0644332469,
-0.1098478585,
0.4772134423,
0.5782189369,
-0.0813288018,
0.2878308892,
-0.0270400271,
0.6231426001,
0.1291870624,
-0.8697819114,
-0.0679957122,
-0.5014919043,
-0.2054517865,
-0.028882863,
-0.6164104939,
0.6742753386,
-0.1942566782,
-0.1608781964,
-0.044396475,
0.6999887824,
0.0346746147,
0.2300470769,
0.3386808038,
0.5253344178,
0.7475675344,
-0.1029389203,
1.0258655548,
-0.0785707161,
0.0405583754,
1.0879406929,
0.1985272169,
0.5013397336,
0.4572933912,
-0.2053139508,
0.5525432825,
0.7307264805,
0.2300894856,
0.6278474331,
0.1569620669,
0.0190606657,
-0.3673472703,
0.1013459861,
-0.6821158528,
0.4270355105,
0.1270625442,
-0.0427252091,
-0.3057442307,
0.2416803837,
-0.2894760966,
-0.1128825471,
-0.4037102759,
0.7355499268,
0.0726575628,
-0.495403409,
0.6939510107,
-0.3196665347,
0.1439488232,
-0.786531806,
-0.070171617,
-0.1967528015,
-0.2431064248,
-0.1389534622,
-1.1098568439,
0.0278737172,
-0.2062463462,
-0.0329769403,
-0.1578743756,
0.3492625952,
-0.6983894706,
-0.5541956425,
0.401156038,
0.8369645476,
-0.1256666481,
-0.16220963,
-0.4591695666,
-0.6703407764,
-0.1122799218,
-0.0443641879,
0.1460513026,
0.8735909462,
-0.3287799358,
0.6199458838,
0.5742003918,
-0.0627467707,
0.6536948681,
0.0470351614,
0.9244605899,
-0.360984236,
-0.8322345614,
-0.3715157807,
0.7516597509,
0.0310263634,
-0.365778476,
0.9188749194,
0.5024303198,
1.1505199671,
-0.4372279644,
0.9943315983,
0.1831258088,
0.081409134,
-0.7511947155,
0.6503760219,
-0.8203336,
-0.4300343394,
-0.4870711267,
-0.7099888921,
0.0455989689,
0.168907702,
-0.6147200465,
0.0371325724,
0.6085550189,
0.7568272352,
-0.1711108834,
-0.0999675095,
0.4124324918,
0.203070417,
0.15187186,
0.6300640702,
1.2321414948,
-0.2739762366,
0.8027867079,
-0.3562566638,
-0.1178307235,
0.2254062742,
-0.4107538462,
-0.9727578163,
-1.0966697931,
-0.0990646109,
-0.1853053421,
-0.0862757638,
0.2031132579,
0.6156153083,
-0.5164349079,
0.0291820541,
0.3652248085,
0.113880977,
-0.0925620869,
-0.1404254138,
0.568102479,
-0.1139143258,
-0.4119444788,
0.1681534946,
0.0158541426,
0.1595094204,
-0.1306939274,
-0.1339743882,
-0.0947995633,
-0.1436490864,
0.7928221822,
0.4537437856,
-0.4245814085,
-0.3579747081,
0.1790035665,
0.2697107792,
0.2097716928,
0.6526930928,
-0.8581935167,
1.0098791122,
0.7208650112,
0.8352523446,
0.9006765485,
0.1518678516,
0.7260562181,
-0.830088675,
0.2594377697,
0.0629392415,
0.4507870376,
0.2637726367,
-0.0270554405,
0.1169935688,
0.47095263,
-0.0641304702,
-0.5633829832,
0.4725284278,
-0.8110355735,
-0.0900043845,
1.0131731033,
-0.4723899364,
-0.2323851287,
-0.4251753688,
-0.4632545412,
0.2936230302,
0.1202044934,
0.3429923356,
0.9270659089,
0.0367880948,
-0.4646664262,
-0.7074180245,
0.3351425827,
0.0476615056,
-0.9799929261,
-0.3352905512,
0.3892009556,
0.3233841956,
-0.1416711956,
0.867772758,
-0.1244852692,
0.4962623417,
-0.0537830852,
0.048494257,
-0.3116132915,
-0.2389521897,
0.0847102702,
0.2504826486,
-0.316498965,
-0.3145568669
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06437v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06437v1
|
3D-PreMise: Can Large Language Models Generate 3D Shapes with Sharp Features and Parametric Control?
| 2024-01-12T08:07:52 | 2024-01-12T08:07:52 |
Zeqing Yuan, Haoxuan Lan, Qiang Zou, Junbo Zhao
|
cs.GR
|
cs.GR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in implicit 3D representations and generative models have
markedly propelled the field of 3D object generation forward. However, it
remains a significant challenge to accurately model geometries with defined
sharp features under parametric controls, which is crucial in fields like
industrial design and manufacturing. To bridge this gap, we introduce a
framework that employs Large Language Models (LLMs) to generate text-driven 3D
shapes, manipulating 3D software via program synthesis. We present 3D-PreMise,
a dataset specifically tailored for 3D parametric modeling of industrial
shapes, designed to explore state-of-the-art LLMs within our proposed pipeline.
Our work reveals effective generation strategies and delves into the
self-correction capabilities of LLMs using a visual interface. Our work
highlights both the potential and limitations of LLMs in 3D parametric modeling
for industrial applications.
|
[
-0.0469274372,
-0.5214288235,
0.9945426583,
0.1391926557,
0.1739391983,
-0.3653585613,
0.248541221,
-0.4269037247,
-0.1182600707,
1.1522090435,
-0.5474869013,
-0.8271337152,
-0.2785912454,
0.2636024654,
-0.5736661553,
0.6339527369,
-0.1717874557,
-0.108869493,
-0.2028723508,
0.136012733,
-0.058015883,
-0.5683089495,
-0.4716579616,
0.0241757035,
0.5406680107,
0.3404866755,
0.8123178482,
0.9915995002,
0.4193071127,
0.3502098918,
0.3897865713,
-0.0094355391,
-0.467384994,
-0.0589615367,
0.14927423,
-0.404914856,
-0.3287419677,
-0.2254106253,
0.6272258759,
0.8758116364,
-0.0238102004,
0.001199694,
0.2231918126,
0.672127068,
-0.3324162066,
0.3050445616,
-0.7213497162,
0.0512994677,
-0.1362438053,
0.1401744336,
-0.2313288897,
-0.3564168513,
0.1087268665,
-0.4722265601,
0.6076794267,
0.1663952321,
0.8089067936,
0.232627511,
-0.1273147017,
-0.1679518521,
-0.8105159402,
0.6213020086,
-1.033385396,
0.5545479059,
0.1141708046,
0.4929584265,
-0.3689976633,
-0.8693863153,
-0.3360008895,
-0.1596764177,
-0.0056053828,
-0.1657253057,
0.29719612,
0.3066009581,
0.2811844051,
0.396515429,
-0.4045712054,
0.1769267023,
-0.7390164137,
-0.0423245579,
0.6700541973,
0.335665077,
0.5797104836,
-0.1907709241,
-0.4777724743,
-0.1136359349,
-0.964379549,
-0.1753817499,
0.3299931288,
0.5374400616,
-0.2511333525,
1.0616078377,
-0.3517566025,
0.894661665,
-0.4050520658,
-0.1288897693,
-0.1123788208,
0.1870180219,
-0.3673563898,
0.0039229821,
1.0061260462,
0.399776727,
0.1361659616,
0.0493742339,
-0.4007533789,
-0.3512845635,
0.1630417258,
-0.7226786017,
-0.3142943084,
0.3096911907,
-0.3966940939,
-0.0775995925,
0.1308733225,
-0.4008283913,
-0.7484313846,
-0.5099838972,
0.1732630432,
-0.2043343782,
-0.2885063291,
0.6666042805,
-0.1873448789,
0.3075711727,
0.2321772128,
-0.9073762298,
-0.1279051304,
0.6104614139,
0.8969773054,
0.0545294695,
-0.331769973,
-0.0424130484,
0.8674207926,
-0.7043080926,
0.6427209377,
-0.430868417,
-0.4468830228,
0.3341904581,
-0.2970978916,
0.4523936212,
-0.5439267159,
0.0373788998,
-0.0134469159,
0.1265695244,
-0.0866646096,
-0.2767643034,
-0.0960578844,
0.2028765231,
-0.9508560896,
0.7878890038,
0.2184334248,
-0.6595176458,
0.3560369313,
-0.2206803113,
-0.3895918131,
0.0148596233,
-0.904992342,
-0.4534407854,
0.2524175644,
0.1024663597,
0.6442024708,
-0.3248684108,
0.2142837197,
-0.7350583673,
0.06395524,
-0.0348130763,
-0.3119416833,
0.5366786718,
0.0953297243,
-0.2817778289,
0.1511280537,
-1.0338047743,
-0.1043937951,
0.1154985651,
-0.2561520338,
-0.0403195657,
0.2160041034,
0.0584632084,
0.4671306312,
0.3210197985,
-0.4474203885,
0.071147345,
-0.3855949938,
0.4541774094,
0.2700799406,
0.0339220501,
0.1644629985,
-0.1513748765,
0.4483458698,
-0.2777352035,
0.2096736282,
0.0558798052,
-0.2124962658,
-0.7333915234,
-0.3754815757,
-0.4572415352,
0.1401012242,
-0.7807334661,
0.2292321473,
-0.0766991526,
-0.3909631968,
-0.0936339349,
0.2374213785,
0.2651154101,
0.3926047385,
0.0691190138,
0.32472229,
-0.5348616242,
-1.2769271135,
-0.1780214608,
-0.1636751741,
-0.7469463944,
-0.1529589146,
0.0271726474,
0.0122602237,
1.0824244022,
-0.728004396,
-0.3679367006,
-0.423260808,
-0.0259115323,
0.2108927518,
0.4026384056,
0.6112056375,
-0.6404936314,
-0.1867533624,
-0.0983188003,
-0.7266951799,
-0.1153700575,
-0.24040021,
-0.3822821677,
0.1526801735,
1.1787908077,
-0.5944051147,
0.2185177058,
0.5685158968,
-0.0246604942,
0.3902831674,
-0.1212153807,
-0.1952894181,
-1.1592538357,
0.0765724927,
0.3020708859,
-0.0541580841,
-0.4227907658,
-0.1681929231,
-0.0204159189,
-0.5918864012,
-0.9090206027,
0.5150437355,
-0.7828879356,
-0.2484675944,
-0.280636996,
0.1168453619,
0.447568506,
0.4172518253,
0.4491322637,
0.4172680378,
0.465911299,
-0.8114032745,
0.1270884573,
0.4411160946,
-0.5727404356,
0.4021635056,
-0.8757358193,
-0.2687841058,
-0.1462054849,
0.0583385453,
-0.8496079445,
-0.6039660573,
0.0699887201,
0.0377896838,
0.0277490485,
-0.1495694965,
-0.5536745787,
-0.5789271593,
-0.0814909562,
0.0833863169,
0.3375529349,
-0.4264156818,
0.6335794926,
0.2881326079,
-0.4251997173,
0.1111579016,
-0.6984021664,
0.0786176547,
-0.2573301196,
-0.5595915318,
0.2187732905,
0.0461018905,
-0.2840991318,
-0.3329177797,
0.005266502,
-0.0223974157,
-0.3756639957,
0.0763792917,
0.1206545085,
-0.2352614999,
-0.370785892,
-0.0397841893,
0.1847667694,
0.3387804031,
-0.1455406994,
0.49584952,
0.1409338266,
-0.4590755999,
-0.3351642191,
0.1934427321,
1.0090624094,
-0.1315882355,
0.2940864861,
0.1532350034,
-0.5924866199,
-0.4413512349,
-0.2258063406,
-0.01966024,
-0.6090920568,
0.7309706807,
-0.659527719,
-0.4247031808,
0.25737679,
0.0175675191,
0.3894754946,
0.4926821291,
0.4601579309,
-0.0110909082,
1.473608613,
0.9042559862,
0.4128218889,
0.2487597167,
-0.2405263782,
0.3192307651,
-0.9746602178,
-0.4554285109,
-0.6719955206,
-0.2022698224,
-0.3220745325,
-0.3049847186,
0.5417066216,
0.2218279392,
-0.4344763458,
0.1500045806,
-0.3740519881,
0.3086389303,
0.3374508619,
0.0659363642,
-0.1648107469,
0.105373621,
-0.0882035643,
0.2005406618,
-0.6228716969,
-0.6935709715,
0.4979413748,
0.4475263953,
1.0501468182,
-0.1198198795,
0.4186838269,
-0.0976338014,
-0.0925176889,
-0.5280584693,
0.5477582216,
-0.2208984792,
-0.4760318995,
-0.4319081008,
-0.1983808577,
-0.5925933719,
-0.070113346,
-0.2317310572,
-0.3992479444,
0.124689959,
0.2640951574,
-0.4976212084,
0.573056221,
-0.7058601975,
0.8939542174,
-0.7435786128,
-0.3310158849,
0.3734992146,
-0.229836151,
0.3482691348,
-0.1880685836,
-0.0179513488,
-0.5174216032,
0.0130429892,
0.3397150934,
-0.5667049289,
1.1120095253,
-0.1508374065,
-0.7548749447,
0.3405381739,
0.438069582,
0.3698885739,
0.2467834651,
-0.2471278161,
0.2908194959,
-0.0687738284,
-0.2319774777,
-0.6322854161,
0.5027803779,
-0.5631844401,
-0.9710568786,
-0.0253082067,
-0.6886085272,
-0.4967961311,
0.6151233912,
0.3294875324,
0.7053200006,
-0.2789264023,
0.4482749999,
0.3109781444,
-0.5302541852,
0.3503961563,
0.2286046445,
-0.5503444672,
-0.4006178081,
0.7095099092,
-0.2887297571,
0.4401158392,
0.6614323854,
0.2210239768,
-0.7581015229,
-0.7574273944,
-0.7509575486,
0.2734159827,
-0.5601667762,
-0.1009091437,
-0.4775742292,
-0.4664391875,
-0.5637651682,
-0.5622659922,
-0.4061935544,
-0.2464487553,
-0.255389601,
-0.0933678076,
0.3938860893,
1.1712794304,
0.119390972,
0.2186143845,
-0.8106030822,
0.6913225651,
0.3253570795,
0.723477304,
-0.3214136362,
0.0646418557,
-0.1226639599,
0.3265726268,
-0.1201748773,
-0.329470098,
0.3781177998,
0.177459076,
0.4232015014,
0.5619470477,
0.0173452459,
0.4967342317,
-0.8007650375,
0.7752953768,
0.3727107346,
-0.7338314652,
0.4513283074,
-0.8478581309,
0.4452944398,
0.1873651594,
0.41763708,
-0.4535699487,
-0.6629874706,
-0.2955082059,
-0.8974354267,
0.5734379292,
0.144792363,
0.1515005231,
-0.0772922337,
0.4436385334,
0.1180770546,
0.2401346713,
-0.5732761025,
0.0988855436,
-0.3083594739,
-0.684427619,
0.0895183682,
-0.3308847845,
0.0503270887,
0.1641076356,
0.3963797688,
-0.0406136177,
-0.0792240575,
0.1658783704,
0.2728815079,
0.2005536109,
-0.287214756,
0.5517143011,
0.9557862878,
-0.113253586,
0.0698844269,
-0.2612215877,
-0.2735817432,
-0.1231095791,
-0.095275335,
-0.1058329567,
-0.0771649182,
0.1369720846,
0.8747453094,
0.099243857,
-0.6238663793,
0.1048607305,
0.1729967147,
-0.4435605109,
-0.2667858601,
0.1452376992,
0.0807980224,
0.2473646402,
0.2552010417,
-0.4581633806,
0.2815199494,
-0.1908996999,
0.1770532578,
0.3828569055,
-0.2103570104,
-0.1550406665,
1.1326925755,
0.4041248262,
-0.1557918191,
0.643345058,
0.5621601343,
-0.2260756791,
0.8062908053,
0.7698056102,
0.9289476871,
0.0575312078,
0.1883930266,
0.3326346874,
0.153942436,
-0.1767992526,
0.175042972,
0.3814576864,
-0.5374686718,
-0.0963769779,
-0.8484714031,
-0.3510746062,
0.60286659,
-0.3077317774,
0.8632633686,
-0.8185526133,
0.1603860557,
-0.1259084642,
-0.4969509244,
-0.4318963587,
0.5314536691,
0.4369297326,
0.6198303699,
-0.5771918297,
0.4499294162,
0.4962378144,
-0.4357346296,
-0.6105920672,
-0.047792837,
-0.1431047469,
-0.7349984646,
0.3554031253,
0.2664706111,
-0.4301422834,
0.1179829165,
-0.5145238638,
-1.200453043,
0.637798667,
0.4733037055,
-0.8425218463,
-0.2608282268,
1.0252811909,
0.2638896406,
-0.2845226526,
-0.4570676982,
0.3968281746,
0.2844683826,
0.2364153415,
-0.3338857591,
-0.0808836818,
-0.2095799148,
0.5804176927,
0.2295488715,
-0.441216588,
0.5998884439,
-0.008491517,
-0.2444194406,
0.0853666216,
0.9854214191,
0.6286126971,
-0.2748804986,
0.3753350377,
0.3605594039,
0.2168614268,
0.1995093971,
0.9597267509,
-0.4004239142,
-0.2488429397,
1.0703532696,
-0.5767980218,
0.6729741693,
0.1302983165,
0.0566248633,
0.3290308416,
0.6429075003,
-0.2069441527,
0.2134223878,
0.2783995867,
0.1075541973,
-0.0220137779,
0.2615135014,
-0.1492622644,
0.4034303427,
0.6257768869,
-0.1361973435,
-0.1949230731,
0.0501809716,
0.0178479329,
0.1617085487,
-0.3560034037,
0.5411637425,
0.1347684115,
-0.2838503718,
0.7452604771,
0.091813989,
0.2073343396,
-0.5601536036,
-0.2181227654,
-0.2917660773,
0.1925755739,
-0.0316663794,
-0.9283046722,
0.3645898402,
-0.0188089814,
-0.2295119911,
-0.3461137116,
0.2864690721,
-0.5595280528,
-0.9600480199,
-0.1104835421,
0.0758100897,
0.0194652081,
-0.1579816192,
-0.6111456752,
0.3107267022,
0.1220565587,
0.049436599,
-0.2242454886,
0.8389376998,
-0.270057708,
0.4957753718,
0.4413160682,
0.1160544157,
0.3588276207,
0.2830602527,
0.364295572,
-0.6881381273,
-0.395663619,
-0.6645269394,
0.4411574602,
0.0617873743,
-0.237150833,
0.594547689,
0.9258489609,
0.8980178833,
-0.3991942704,
1.0549616814,
-0.0001938569,
0.4205434024,
-0.9467063546,
0.844440341,
-0.6904925704,
0.0784054697,
-0.2897484899,
-1.104601264,
-0.6345564127,
0.2790749073,
-0.2241269201,
0.1142388582,
0.4955821931,
0.7320431471,
-0.1314652562,
-0.4456625581,
0.5262941122,
0.3074799776,
0.6972883344,
0.3099070191,
0.8449196219,
-0.0721604377,
0.635417819,
-0.2020353824,
0.0726548359,
-0.0843270123,
-0.9385801554,
-1.0137524605,
-0.6586635709,
-0.3411397338,
-0.1113982722,
-0.537751615,
0.4716594815,
0.6140786409,
-0.5943807364,
-0.4330805838,
-0.5648837686,
-0.3026338816,
0.1448892802,
-0.1459381133,
0.4153888524,
-0.3071749508,
-1.0868080854,
0.4347196519,
0.403855741,
0.4481699467,
-0.5711843371,
0.1299425811,
0.1588904113,
0.3256483376,
0.691485703,
0.4233873785,
-0.6712204814,
-0.2073218971,
-0.0546506792,
-0.401843667,
0.1006828696,
0.8919451237,
-0.4052424431,
0.2692278326,
0.5740999579,
0.41370821,
0.209127292,
-0.0429060198,
1.2019141912,
-0.7366337776,
0.341237843,
0.0029290533,
0.5156716704,
0.6665146947,
-0.364996016,
0.2156613767,
-0.2385696024,
-0.159929201,
-0.5355891585,
0.6007454991,
-0.4771786034,
-0.423358202,
1.135812521,
0.4715389907,
-0.6407757998,
-0.0496343598,
-0.4050911367,
0.1298042536,
0.2332757413,
0.8528501987,
0.2693593502,
-0.1705140322,
-0.0551183484,
-0.5469161272,
0.7741068006,
-0.1377543658,
-0.8664773107,
0.3922082484,
1.0299698114,
0.1966521144,
-0.0769337118,
0.2657751441,
-0.5037378669,
-0.1826383024,
-0.1167541519,
0.5922206044,
0.0014776469,
-0.8301489353,
0.0474353135,
0.1504630893,
0.2874738276,
-0.1567814648
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06431v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06431v2
|
Human-AI Collaborative Essay Scoring: A Dual-Process Framework with LLMs
| 2024-01-12T07:50:10 | 2024-06-15T03:44:08 |
Changrong Xiao, Wenxing Ma, Qingping Song, Sean Xin Xu, Kunpeng Zhang, Yufang Wang, Qi Fu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Receiving timely and personalized feedback is essential for second-language
learners, especially when human instructors are unavailable. This study
explores the effectiveness of Large Language Models (LLMs), including both
proprietary and open-source models, for Automated Essay Scoring (AES). Through
extensive experiments with public and private datasets, we find that while LLMs
do not surpass conventional state-of-the-art (SOTA) grading models in
performance, they exhibit notable consistency, generalizability, and
explainability. We propose an open-source LLM-based AES system, inspired by the
dual-process theory. Our system offers accurate grading and high-quality
feedback, at least comparable to that of fine-tuned proprietary LLMs, in
addition to its ability to alleviate misgrading. Furthermore, we conduct
human-AI co-grading experiments with both novice and expert graders. We find
that our system not only automates the grading process but also enhances the
performance and efficiency of human graders, particularly for essays where the
model has lower confidence. These results highlight the potential of LLMs to
facilitate effective human-AI collaboration in the educational context,
potentially transforming learning experiences through AI-generated feedback.
|
[
-0.2451380342,
-0.7719401717,
0.7227615118,
0.1248271838,
0.1671608239,
0.4367436171,
-0.5621412992,
-0.6297676563,
0.0326284319,
0.4023058712,
-0.1198397428,
-0.7311555743,
-0.4773500562,
0.3043648899,
-0.1725404859,
0.8628450036,
-0.3280957639,
0.3790788949,
-0.4980977476,
-0.2527708411,
-0.0951396599,
-0.4575080574,
-1.1233924627,
-0.5759642124,
0.7059785724,
0.7240296602,
0.4382273853,
0.4362621009,
0.7992802858,
0.3873401582,
0.4837749898,
0.1408914477,
0.0188337378,
0.1010433361,
-0.2262508124,
-0.5770380497,
-0.5594152212,
0.4399497509,
0.5975583792,
0.7181466818,
-0.0997141749,
0.2840098739,
0.4522743821,
0.5633144975,
-0.3401877284,
0.0882520527,
-0.1906817555,
-0.02048821,
0.0114391418,
0.2440088689,
-0.596394062,
-0.4688724875,
0.1504484117,
-0.5218546391,
0.0545445867,
0.0605128482,
0.4361155629,
0.335400939,
-0.2823097408,
-0.3145804405,
-0.7473483086,
0.9246176481,
-0.3439202905,
-0.0934409872,
0.3626645207,
0.3732504547,
0.0034128479,
-0.5571218729,
-0.5390629172,
-0.4972977936,
-0.0926277936,
0.1902307123,
0.1352527887,
0.4072172344,
-0.0601458214,
0.5310351849,
-0.5180156827,
0.5105438232,
-0.2703458071,
-0.2830367088,
0.9281951785,
0.3244419992,
0.4086655378,
0.1690530181,
-0.2897954881,
-0.0154856974,
-0.4383475482,
0.32034266,
0.6632119417,
0.2968797684,
-0.1427970976,
0.5326276422,
0.1507344991,
0.3283187449,
-0.0814886093,
0.0953971148,
-0.1291977763,
-0.0349552408,
-0.0829423442,
-0.3438968062,
1.0337234735,
0.474080652,
0.1767809838,
-0.1792812198,
-0.3068340719,
0.5563086867,
0.2245178223,
-0.5216979384,
-0.2021308988,
0.0147611219,
-0.3986709118,
-0.4434580505,
0.0764134303,
-0.9077444077,
-0.3346185684,
-0.6592007279,
0.7057127953,
0.0549931303,
0.0724876449,
-0.1880901009,
-0.017410418,
-0.0321115367,
0.6705220938,
-0.6493303776,
0.8611920476,
0.6316514015,
0.8736037612,
-0.6144329906,
-0.5485610962,
-0.5811457634,
-0.1361956894,
-0.3716414571,
0.8467479944,
-0.5978244543,
-0.283528775,
0.0470131114,
-0.4063103199,
-0.0083523383,
-0.6585975885,
0.7668828368,
-0.4177898467,
0.5857948065,
-0.1288562715,
-0.7819652557,
-0.0808567628,
0.1441963017,
-0.4991957843,
1.1773730516,
-0.0594746731,
-0.4304602742,
-0.0121661685,
-0.8897242546,
-0.3761678636,
0.1277474314,
-0.4375982285,
-0.2623369396,
-0.0124568203,
-0.1125825495,
0.4480966628,
-0.4638175666,
0.1471077055,
-0.2886271775,
-0.7149919868,
-0.0563607626,
-0.4942774773,
0.5068215728,
0.018428266,
-0.3492133021,
0.1058963537,
-0.7416465878,
-0.0061536641,
0.0280938148,
-0.7923872471,
-0.301138252,
-0.2033521384,
0.0842359439,
0.0623291954,
0.4716640115,
-0.5040580034,
0.2428131998,
-0.2733262777,
0.1967029572,
1.0204101801,
-0.2560198009,
0.5153842568,
-0.713001132,
0.549179852,
-0.4358972907,
-0.234388724,
-0.1292271912,
-0.4935871065,
-0.7711013556,
-0.3270848393,
0.0445016064,
0.7507308125,
-0.2489518225,
0.6662204862,
0.0922949165,
-0.3925090134,
-0.769975245,
0.3699565828,
0.532055378,
0.5062462687,
0.3999999464,
-0.5633050203,
-0.3560602069,
-0.7198582888,
-0.3934081793,
-0.3962991536,
-0.2064454854,
0.2533789277,
0.4241079092,
-0.0274327211,
0.82937783,
-0.3877396286,
-0.570017755,
-0.1624590456,
0.6157475114,
-0.1834670603,
0.3325226009,
0.3276664019,
-0.318942368,
-0.781666398,
-0.3996044099,
-0.7407625318,
-0.479668498,
0.2327547371,
-0.0282961652,
0.5082699656,
0.3276732564,
-0.3318882585,
0.4534281194,
0.5434383154,
-0.3322187364,
0.7798392773,
-0.4964831173,
0.2627801597,
-1.0922727585,
0.0291153584,
0.1834363341,
-0.2715267539,
-0.2590153813,
0.0604684949,
-0.3067587912,
0.0403384119,
-0.0780325904,
0.6821204424,
-0.1002009436,
-0.0597853214,
-0.4716126323,
0.0099457176,
0.1571727991,
0.6663478613,
-0.0103521841,
0.9526901841,
0.2368117571,
-0.257666111,
0.3185526431,
-0.1572565287,
-0.3579408526,
0.9186790586,
-0.6364160776,
0.4418875277,
0.0072531714,
0.3560649455,
-1.1671965122,
-0.382471323,
0.0460558236,
-0.402415216,
0.3125008047,
0.0705036893,
-0.4021300077,
-0.2350098491,
-0.6151070595,
0.1925847381,
0.4398301542,
-0.5032387376,
0.5966351628,
0.3498479426,
-0.3916755319,
-0.3672693968,
-0.6038485169,
0.3515505195,
-0.0313101821,
-0.68468678,
0.4166762531,
-0.4789679945,
-0.6673974991,
0.1021743715,
0.3368171751,
-0.1079787686,
0.1570822597,
0.3793201745,
0.4235894084,
-0.2094210237,
0.131198436,
0.1568167508,
-0.1581144929,
0.0972170606,
-0.353939414,
0.1916836798,
-0.1517262012,
-0.4883856773,
-0.9579269886,
0.7230892777,
0.9060422182,
0.0291810744,
0.710503459,
0.4264290631,
-0.564917326,
-0.3220800161,
-0.6720285416,
-0.3281544745,
-0.4300598502,
0.1647655815,
-0.0510390773,
-1.0424461365,
0.2535993755,
-0.0510380529,
0.3024787903,
0.3178539872,
0.617931366,
-0.5229737759,
1.0004249811,
0.6246204376,
-0.3384372592,
0.2493468821,
-0.2338602543,
0.0961321443,
-0.6053444743,
-0.1324153543,
-0.783364594,
-0.3906967938,
-0.371936202,
-0.3944877088,
0.4206992686,
0.0388049744,
-0.3248960674,
-0.1701140106,
-0.3020078838,
0.6233836412,
0.7607139945,
-0.1406270564,
0.509536922,
0.1653030813,
-0.4482615888,
-0.1653492898,
-0.1076345518,
-1.1406466961,
1.1270192862,
0.3787091076,
0.4840290248,
0.0309125707,
0.7751636505,
0.8063836694,
0.6751384139,
-0.5879967213,
0.6207770705,
-0.4345909655,
-0.5191559196,
-0.4186221957,
-0.3069410026,
-0.4396334589,
0.133982569,
-0.2090434581,
-0.7827550173,
-0.544178009,
0.1433813125,
-0.4725268185,
0.2837694883,
-0.8607269526,
0.6667813659,
-0.2739368677,
-0.9800384641,
-0.5040650368,
-0.4605399668,
0.0873444155,
-0.122655265,
0.4149211347,
-0.0933497474,
-0.1336391866,
1.0285357237,
-0.5906104445,
0.9796403646,
-0.2382456958,
-0.0680205896,
0.5411237478,
-0.0082201632,
0.3954079449,
-0.0161727928,
-0.3552316129,
0.2773824632,
-0.3454072475,
-0.1765812188,
-0.5498947501,
0.8356950283,
-1.289162159,
-0.6005640626,
-0.3929899335,
-0.2497462779,
-0.0317344517,
0.1236495376,
0.109416537,
0.1323106885,
-0.2319664359,
-0.1745551378,
0.2377645522,
-0.1364331543,
0.3050817549,
0.727584064,
-0.1830802858,
-0.5640915632,
0.8366466165,
0.143073082,
-0.0710429996,
0.3362585604,
0.3680315316,
-0.3450321555,
-0.45833534,
-0.4972649217,
0.2323268503,
-0.6644239426,
0.0393682197,
-0.5854319334,
-0.0396417677,
-0.4988670945,
-0.4779102504,
-0.3116744459,
-0.4460457861,
-0.3210038245,
-0.2174104005,
-0.0146523286,
1.0578484535,
-0.2682411373,
0.0941916257,
-0.7937512994,
0.1035092846,
0.4678266048,
0.5097765923,
0.02595447,
-0.7087071538,
-0.1557392329,
-0.2136534452,
-0.4118653834,
-0.3706898391,
-0.0648612678,
0.0673654899,
0.3412767351,
0.2172220796,
-0.1219448894,
0.2763534188,
-0.3509042263,
0.976505518,
0.0166952573,
-0.9333286285,
0.115677923,
-0.2138685733,
-0.0367399119,
0.9033833742,
0.2942480445,
-0.5450959206,
-0.4792858362,
0.0806252137,
-0.7416680455,
0.978369832,
-0.1038057208,
0.0773300603,
0.4099660218,
0.4926450849,
0.3636579216,
0.1381029338,
-0.6881129146,
-0.1729641408,
0.364110738,
-0.8305284977,
-0.3208967149,
-0.196873337,
0.0883416533,
-0.2858282626,
0.815502286,
-0.030359054,
0.0143854283,
0.0845861211,
0.0321426243,
-0.5503758192,
0.2580567002,
0.501850605,
0.1233792827,
-0.0410561338,
0.0266623944,
0.2102244943,
-0.4871844649,
0.4890195727,
0.0637812912,
-0.2230578959,
-0.4295867682,
0.5880110264,
0.3030291498,
-0.0017703091,
-0.7714158297,
0.6241877079,
-0.501760304,
-0.1683205515,
-0.620682478,
0.2779724896,
-0.0301586874,
0.296308279,
0.3436566889,
0.321128428,
0.0024853854,
-0.4027068913,
0.0558467247,
0.2814327478,
-0.2294627875,
-0.534658134,
0.5776204467,
0.6575955749,
-0.8247673512,
0.5182647109,
-0.1142053828,
-0.3878522515,
0.5821528435,
0.2427614331,
1.0424649715,
-0.4031460285,
0.2715446353,
0.2656490207,
0.146230191,
-0.2174445838,
0.0892870873,
-0.3542327285,
-0.5486652851,
-0.2568291724,
-0.886947453,
-0.7776378989,
0.2304998785,
-0.4700863957,
0.4991943836,
-0.593748033,
-0.0344156213,
-0.2270167619,
0.3667168617,
-0.5435752273,
0.2538440526,
0.3340892196,
0.6642000675,
-0.9139449596,
0.6189303994,
1.2372677326,
-0.2989249527,
-0.8982334137,
0.1092600897,
0.1924274266,
-0.4817562699,
0.3312370479,
0.4906351268,
-0.4827888012,
-0.100635834,
-0.2346020043,
-0.5844295025,
0.9661543965,
0.4009449184,
-0.5892409086,
-0.2955530882,
0.4400245547,
1.069175005,
-0.3450671732,
0.6465538144,
0.4368854761,
0.4252237082,
-0.1035902053,
-0.8077830076,
-0.4184542894,
-0.2511731386,
-0.3675865829,
-0.02723906,
-0.8805810809,
0.5683355331,
-0.2089864761,
-0.0123128537,
0.1354949474,
0.5478695631,
-0.095487006,
0.803814888,
0.4296688437,
0.8953551054,
0.8985209465,
0.2328758091,
0.8030238748,
-0.3851598501,
0.098482199,
1.0732959509,
-0.6087235808,
0.9409281611,
0.2620392144,
-0.3725867271,
0.7914840579,
0.2233000398,
0.2649109066,
0.0638834015,
0.3104697168,
-0.4864784181,
-0.2744058073,
-0.2413504273,
0.1221264675,
0.6668931246,
0.2323749363,
-0.423125267,
0.0164532121,
-0.1008660048,
0.0015502857,
0.7110544443,
-0.3203298748,
0.8351715207,
0.2654974163,
-1.3063477278,
-0.1124452725,
0.4470697343,
0.7742211819,
-0.3088490665,
-0.1520449221,
-0.2681156695,
0.3609626293,
-0.2563863397,
-0.6236855388,
0.3144152462,
0.5369691253,
-0.2775475979,
-0.3672604561,
0.571638763,
-0.5788506866,
-0.6513679028,
0.6120352745,
0.3484861553,
-0.019791523,
0.2802988589,
-0.4193371534,
0.0878931507,
-0.3864191771,
-0.226362288,
0.3255012035,
-0.0569728985,
0.0483934246,
0.2992233634,
0.4824384749,
-0.0128491502,
-0.2310267836,
0.1887233108,
0.3228202462,
-0.3507744074,
-0.4745841622,
-0.8189174533,
0.2442755252,
-0.0024770165,
-0.0329669379,
0.5714880228,
0.5896440148,
0.99955827,
0.309135735,
1.2283838987,
0.4904958308,
0.8648657203,
-0.2396790087,
0.7412777543,
-0.6032006145,
0.3368336856,
-0.3215218782,
-0.8258586526,
-0.3448777199,
0.4933736622,
-0.3186500967,
0.1475422084,
0.6529310942,
0.7058957815,
0.3673549294,
0.1468828917,
0.2920515239,
-0.127370432,
0.4366985857,
0.6231299639,
1.1201925278,
-0.1707607955,
0.3989081383,
-0.3760863543,
-0.4848302007,
-0.2206800878,
-0.4847411513,
-1.1236931086,
-0.5375692248,
-0.398732245,
-0.0507974513,
0.1060232371,
1.4819793701,
0.3777768314,
-0.6769413948,
-0.4382677376,
-0.1099772379,
0.0179881919,
0.2028656602,
-0.2709400952,
0.3291751742,
-0.2008289397,
-0.9636261463,
0.3660458028,
0.6405128837,
-0.0204193126,
-0.5167340636,
-0.3584625125,
0.0525493994,
0.4015468657,
0.2783769965,
-0.0367846303,
-0.6157845855,
-0.3902187943,
-0.1058032662,
-0.5267754793,
0.0388033502,
0.9656797647,
-0.5059148073,
0.2512078583,
0.4784282744,
0.6307189465,
-0.118778035,
0.0593176,
0.5171009302,
-0.411321789,
-0.240065828,
0.376833111,
0.2812522352,
0.5211382508,
-0.3558962941,
0.2002293169,
0.4870987535,
-0.8587219715,
-0.6496614814,
-0.0324446633,
-0.4479320347,
-0.0827449709,
0.7418385744,
-0.5395236611,
-0.0299078114,
-0.2231839597,
-0.297092855,
0.3021765947,
-0.5298416018,
1.1913337708,
0.9498913288,
-0.2318279445,
0.2069398016,
0.055893302,
0.3651657999,
0.5885953307,
-0.9531848431,
-0.1183247641,
0.5682361126,
0.1565726697,
0.2435912192,
0.8056747317,
0.1306211054,
0.2970547676,
-0.2519363463,
0.0636007115,
-0.0752166584,
-0.615087986,
-0.7099385858,
0.4875048995,
0.4427421689,
0.0275422409
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06416v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06416v1
|
Mission: Impossible Language Models
| 2024-01-12T07:24:26 | 2024-01-12T07:24:26 |
Julie Kallini, Isabel Papadimitriou, Richard Futrell, Kyle Mahowald, Christopher Potts
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Chomsky and others have very directly claimed that large language models
(LLMs) are equally capable of learning languages that are possible and
impossible for humans to learn. However, there is very little published
experimental evidence to support such a claim. Here, we develop a set of
synthetic impossible languages of differing complexity, each designed by
systematically altering English data with unnatural word orders and grammar
rules. These languages lie on an impossibility continuum: at one end are
languages that are inherently impossible, such as random and irreversible
shuffles of English words, and on the other, languages that may not be
intuitively impossible but are often considered so in linguistics, particularly
those with rules based on counting word positions. We report on a wide range of
evaluations to assess the capacity of GPT-2 small models to learn these
uncontroversially impossible languages, and crucially, we perform these
assessments at various stages throughout training to compare the learning
process for each language. Our core finding is that GPT-2 struggles to learn
impossible languages when compared to English as a control, challenging the
core claim. More importantly, we hope our approach opens up a productive line
of inquiry in which different LLM architectures are tested on a variety of
impossible languages in an effort to learn more about how LLMs can be used as
tools for these cognitive and typological investigations.
|
[
-0.1296426803,
-0.9064786434,
0.7358211875,
0.0002279491,
-0.1125806496,
0.5703812242,
-0.2935728133,
-0.4472191632,
-0.0494089648,
0.4021940231,
-0.6073032618,
-0.1443634629,
-0.6638990641,
0.2523416877,
-0.4137065411,
1.0597149134,
-0.1879655272,
0.3334629536,
0.1029545739,
-0.1661294699,
-0.2658645511,
-0.2135877907,
-0.3307118416,
-0.3763512075,
0.2189445794,
0.4763165414,
0.9700942636,
0.8098863363,
0.4093247354,
0.3123199642,
0.088255845,
0.2442747355,
-0.6897720695,
-0.3080429435,
-0.4283163548,
-0.6919529438,
-0.3062801063,
0.1232327223,
0.5364682674,
0.9593730569,
-0.0798619539,
0.0803699642,
0.0440876298,
0.7139692903,
0.0152607784,
0.215522483,
-0.9068038464,
0.0787779465,
-0.1110423282,
-0.0215435959,
-0.2921654284,
-0.1907067448,
0.0985308886,
-0.6356416941,
0.1915988028,
0.160715878,
0.6737831831,
-0.1055486649,
-0.1842497736,
-0.7764777541,
-1.1408807039,
0.7126755118,
-0.3723828495,
0.3218753934,
0.6641267538,
0.1869801283,
-0.2443875521,
-0.592034936,
-0.66693151,
-0.5007109046,
0.1951889098,
0.1386606395,
-0.1494403929,
0.0935948193,
0.1075994074,
0.4324216545,
-1.0551229715,
0.1878715903,
-0.5445011854,
0.0384509861,
0.3839134872,
0.3084928095,
0.5203091502,
-0.0176143087,
0.1289304495,
-0.0246188361,
-0.8011944294,
-0.198077634,
0.4643738866,
0.3529428244,
-0.0940248296,
0.76774019,
-0.0845482498,
0.4418203235,
-0.135089308,
0.1143788099,
0.1019935533,
0.1087507755,
-0.232225284,
-0.3687567413,
0.6014983654,
-0.0455650426,
0.0398391746,
-0.4274364114,
-0.2564061582,
0.1548649371,
0.2484756857,
-0.3088377416,
-0.3950553238,
0.241279766,
-0.1147493944,
-0.338978231,
-0.0387096293,
-0.4813464582,
-0.3367586434,
-0.1412605792,
0.6903755069,
-0.5653300881,
-0.2903189957,
0.064179942,
-0.023254022,
0.2399486005,
0.1489937305,
-0.8439432383,
0.3988283575,
0.740198791,
0.567451179,
-0.0108879814,
-0.6528952122,
-0.1206336766,
-0.0634033158,
-0.7209357619,
0.552128911,
-0.6837787032,
-0.6040599942,
-0.018805204,
0.393671751,
0.0893091112,
-0.5250501037,
0.320957005,
-0.5576725006,
0.3282791972,
-0.3430955708,
-0.6414799094,
-0.3972496986,
0.2407689393,
-0.3133629262,
0.7667335868,
0.3574618697,
-0.1697145402,
-0.0464741178,
-0.4752188623,
-0.305011481,
0.3976385593,
-0.3579658568,
-0.1182986349,
0.3883883655,
-0.446033299,
0.1271669567,
-0.4970299006,
0.332005918,
-0.2974562943,
-0.3925250471,
0.1724149883,
-0.5071129799,
0.8332486153,
0.2025717348,
-0.6956962943,
-0.1975890845,
-0.807395637,
0.1438877285,
0.6105464697,
-0.5003703237,
-0.3825482726,
0.2330857366,
-0.0496387146,
0.245224908,
0.1207488403,
-0.4683842063,
0.3593854308,
-0.6610152125,
0.6212162375,
0.7590928078,
-0.3840721846,
0.5564077497,
-0.5424214602,
0.717574954,
-0.3199866116,
0.0297279656,
0.1738982797,
-0.427818954,
-1.1064891815,
0.1118742749,
-0.0156537388,
0.8278566003,
-0.8617011309,
0.0765544623,
-0.2874092758,
-0.6554519534,
-0.4741504192,
0.4868374169,
0.6746405959,
0.1434500664,
0.1612408012,
-0.1619451046,
-0.5556580424,
-0.8594030738,
-0.4934215248,
-0.482406944,
-0.0164874718,
0.1535773873,
0.6448717713,
-0.1562808305,
0.5560692549,
-0.2031747252,
0.1236634031,
-0.2705511451,
0.0940314531,
0.0529250465,
0.3013522327,
0.3636597395,
-0.5633021593,
-0.344924897,
-0.0108721517,
-0.7377525568,
0.204893738,
0.0246491805,
0.3300077319,
0.3168769181,
0.5898125768,
-0.5902479887,
0.1164879054,
0.5367074013,
-0.0331950411,
0.4890653193,
-0.5260942578,
-0.202355966,
-0.5889629126,
-0.1361084431,
-0.3667623401,
-0.1222659647,
-0.8066625595,
0.3160747886,
0.2052202672,
-0.091668494,
-0.5034272075,
0.5931690931,
-0.6265557408,
0.1309711188,
-0.3361484408,
0.0366751514,
-0.379116416,
0.6176590323,
-0.2185397893,
0.403747946,
0.4703983665,
-0.4119506478,
0.2269055545,
0.1538731009,
-0.571349144,
0.3000536263,
-0.5230835676,
0.4451892078,
-0.1937457025,
-0.0120942425,
-1.1384094954,
-0.3395130336,
0.2657532394,
-0.2811539173,
0.4044840932,
0.0954947546,
-0.4264673591,
-0.3876037598,
-0.1624628454,
0.2831319273,
0.7402558923,
-0.29469347,
0.2629487514,
0.5257653594,
-0.1744933277,
-0.3255812228,
-0.812684536,
0.2035686672,
-0.145271644,
-0.0178711414,
-0.1122812182,
-0.3322131634,
-0.5977439284,
0.1104573086,
-0.017603226,
-0.0652881041,
0.0116603728,
0.5682702661,
0.177157864,
-0.1041394174,
-0.0688846111,
-0.0190471094,
0.1411776245,
0.0895851254,
-0.5591466427,
0.4216519892,
-0.4029716253,
-0.4588565528,
0.2000756711,
0.2673180401,
0.7508209944,
0.0352230594,
0.2352619916,
0.3126842976,
-0.5280503631,
-0.3807028234,
-0.3884741962,
0.2523881197,
-0.5330469012,
0.8515295386,
-0.5021787286,
-1.0066010952,
0.2978118062,
0.0966325179,
0.115830861,
0.2890513837,
0.6902732849,
0.0208022334,
0.9660772681,
0.6517702341,
0.0655144304,
0.0494830497,
-0.2249190211,
0.096950002,
-0.446197629,
-0.1683758795,
-0.3099279404,
0.0234459098,
-0.8767324686,
-0.4743828475,
0.3428301215,
0.0916329324,
-0.2226418108,
0.4800876677,
-0.1355667412,
0.6872811317,
0.3505503237,
0.1919841468,
0.2619614303,
0.0721095279,
-0.3353782296,
0.0273765251,
-0.7449034452,
-0.5426699519,
1.202033639,
0.3085666299,
0.4181057513,
0.153928563,
0.3400982022,
0.1294297576,
0.2862549126,
-0.8431105018,
0.749917388,
-0.2710673809,
-0.8124295473,
-0.4286396801,
-0.148282811,
-0.8870326877,
0.1468152851,
-0.0190317892,
-0.5145073533,
-0.1399478018,
-0.0627201647,
-0.2164818496,
0.427357167,
-0.539327383,
0.5511646271,
-0.4273323715,
-0.2374851108,
-0.3807606697,
-0.7070076466,
0.4885887802,
-0.4428505599,
0.6560750604,
0.005410301,
-0.1376769841,
0.4528579712,
-0.440618515,
0.8372351527,
0.1387258917,
-0.2832776606,
0.3515863419,
0.7399596572,
0.5774101019,
-0.1338272244,
0.1302094012,
0.1858815998,
-0.2255425751,
-0.5654845834,
-0.3582048416,
0.7915741801,
-0.8578953743,
-0.6377378702,
-0.5306964517,
-0.7868559957,
-0.4506104589,
0.4178624749,
0.1955508888,
0.2008015066,
-0.6467941999,
-0.2964782715,
0.3080796599,
-0.30511114,
0.4430247545,
1.078527689,
-0.3679478765,
-0.388124764,
1.3402707577,
0.4046937525,
0.505099237,
0.4429484606,
0.064153105,
-0.2239529192,
-0.7635383606,
-0.4236435294,
0.2907687724,
-0.5680087805,
0.3800241649,
-0.5742413402,
-0.0730150267,
-0.0898969322,
-0.0335485786,
-0.3326027989,
-0.7737466097,
-0.1323669404,
-0.1776739359,
-0.1240982935,
1.2175174952,
-0.30041942,
0.147591427,
-0.5851010084,
0.2519892156,
0.5138861537,
0.1138802245,
-0.3234723508,
-0.7817794085,
-0.0735623389,
0.2353430241,
-0.3456273675,
-0.6669243574,
0.3455581367,
0.1642515212,
0.1663610637,
0.2495258451,
-0.2299301773,
0.5949415565,
-0.9815254807,
0.5730314851,
0.0291176587,
-0.8724496961,
0.2722989023,
-0.720698595,
0.0934062302,
0.3436724246,
0.4127348959,
-0.3472488225,
-0.8691046238,
-0.8157071471,
-0.7413627505,
0.8421285748,
0.102442205,
0.224078998,
-0.2166382372,
0.3428968489,
0.310382694,
0.1775019169,
-0.4848509729,
-0.28162691,
-0.0420279838,
-0.0576534942,
-0.3111768961,
-0.2758905292,
-0.194651261,
-0.1788265407,
0.5975213647,
0.0746944249,
-0.0777877867,
0.0096566677,
-0.1751101911,
-0.4685105979,
0.2938155234,
0.8562309146,
0.943823576,
-0.0934305564,
0.2954548299,
0.3461037874,
-0.521506846,
0.356302917,
-0.1039922759,
-0.2472803593,
-0.0258179978,
0.2653606236,
0.6483821869,
0.1072265804,
-1.0066760778,
0.2162933052,
0.0162343867,
-0.3904840052,
-0.5765214562,
0.0268560238,
0.2076232284,
0.1993291825,
0.1188638061,
0.1397942752,
-0.1634005755,
-0.7582204938,
0.2250291556,
0.5053141713,
-0.5994292498,
-0.6809991002,
0.6606549025,
0.103616111,
-0.7293480039,
0.587896347,
-0.6485921144,
-0.4246215522,
0.6367765069,
0.6163135767,
0.854334414,
-0.4348819554,
0.4573776424,
0.0530919172,
0.877079308,
-0.4293999672,
0.3493909836,
0.2980940342,
-0.7064353824,
-0.1584222168,
-0.4923409522,
-0.5765140653,
0.7454140782,
-0.3876248896,
0.2904284298,
-0.7650725245,
0.3779086769,
-0.0350366086,
-0.0762042627,
-0.6315916777,
0.0922603086,
-0.0458404161,
0.5781912804,
-0.9529471397,
0.8518732786,
0.8090407848,
-0.1796321869,
-0.7916623354,
-0.1904238611,
0.4260937274,
-1.339771986,
0.3855327964,
-0.1260562986,
0.1690887362,
0.1475601494,
-0.6008627415,
-0.5491960645,
0.672949791,
0.5005534291,
-0.7128078938,
-0.1354023069,
0.5212712884,
0.5896211863,
-0.1139746085,
0.3301469386,
0.6423970461,
0.4010872841,
-0.2730293274,
-1.0786036253,
0.1945945024,
-0.2452943772,
-0.0963496119,
0.1302260756,
-0.7900064588,
0.8691338301,
-0.4121698737,
-0.2362252921,
0.4482608736,
0.3014989495,
0.0396426469,
0.0870297924,
0.4789392054,
0.5536224246,
0.6629010439,
0.0733609572,
0.9517644048,
-0.2171886414,
0.4462117553,
1.1696432829,
-0.2506884933,
0.616707623,
0.3739521801,
-0.4299372137,
0.141538769,
0.5522792339,
-0.089733921,
0.335490644,
0.3273330927,
-0.1516477913,
-0.2141189724,
0.089623481,
-0.0887744129,
0.5674854517,
0.4874847829,
-0.149300158,
-0.299102515,
0.0958368778,
0.173948288,
0.032729134,
-0.1142951399,
0.4238373041,
0.2107262462,
-0.6353612542,
0.7896861434,
0.0823542401,
0.3352792263,
-0.6237251163,
-0.0488384962,
-0.2360913455,
0.2025492787,
0.0508434586,
-0.5088864565,
0.2710412145,
0.0092969518,
-0.0776668489,
-0.1295495629,
0.2260427624,
-0.5948872566,
-0.6141430736,
0.2112060338,
0.7803161144,
0.4776579738,
0.1551327407,
-0.7684138417,
-0.147291109,
0.168903023,
-0.3051691651,
0.4501394033,
0.5074107647,
-0.0089927884,
0.7409915328,
0.4164331555,
0.4244464338,
0.0842536539,
-0.4019126892,
0.5675064921,
-0.5598020554,
-0.2570306361,
-0.9318233132,
0.1555105597,
0.5279055238,
-0.3150956333,
0.7477403283,
0.6683823466,
1.2352297306,
-0.2799044847,
1.1011580229,
-0.253944546,
0.4825061262,
-0.3659180701,
0.6611042023,
-0.6253490448,
0.3981088996,
-0.2755306959,
-0.7903844714,
-0.1217459589,
0.2300538123,
-0.1411398649,
-0.1442780048,
1.0064359903,
0.9669930935,
-0.0906272531,
0.1386627406,
0.5495202541,
0.6927966475,
0.3222292364,
0.8368809819,
1.0786319971,
-0.4072440863,
0.8285784721,
-0.3141674399,
-0.3001231253,
0.1707374901,
-0.5559167862,
-0.8321320415,
-0.6047868133,
-0.1526283175,
-0.4686765969,
0.2400070727,
0.9137760401,
0.2734042108,
-0.6898337603,
-0.4491562545,
-0.5052104592,
-0.0241330713,
-0.0315917619,
-0.1994758546,
0.2761646807,
-0.0804914385,
-1.0215649605,
0.8129466772,
0.3445806801,
0.222578764,
-0.2744273245,
-0.1482252479,
0.1531677246,
0.1415391564,
0.4932465851,
0.840035975,
-0.8025996089,
-0.4530410171,
0.1478524357,
-0.0985031798,
-0.2992427051,
0.7647738457,
-0.3998845518,
0.4497132599,
0.4338238537,
0.5228903294,
0.0287342779,
-0.3799715042,
0.4306771457,
-0.3417449892,
0.2354015857,
0.2574990392,
0.2052144855,
0.1701899022,
0.0912926868,
0.5315680504,
0.4440625608,
-0.5367091894,
-1.1363140345,
0.3208757341,
-0.7788298726,
-0.4338666499,
1.3034658432,
-0.0458316319,
-0.0917855427,
-0.3649390042,
-0.0946317464,
0.1182661727,
0.1141868904,
0.9286952615,
0.8624290824,
-0.1330767125,
0.3635285199,
-0.9449939728,
0.4864738286,
0.7371324301,
-0.3874340355,
0.0203272495,
0.3373306692,
0.6493793726,
0.0674767345,
0.7269492149,
-0.2375511378,
0.0595029965,
-0.027116403,
-0.3656086922,
-0.106780991,
-0.3694410622,
-0.7373476624,
0.0748811662,
0.207325384,
-0.0323744714
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06408v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06408v3
|
AboutMe: Using Self-Descriptions in Webpages to Document the Effects of English Pretraining Data Filters
| 2024-01-12T07:10:10 | 2024-06-20T18:21:49 |
Li Lucy, Suchin Gururangan, Luca Soldaini, Emma Strubell, David Bamman, Lauren F. Klein, Jesse Dodge
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models' (LLMs) abilities are drawn from their pretraining
data, and model development begins with data curation. However, decisions
around what data is retained or removed during this initial stage are
under-scrutinized. In our work, we ground web text, which is a popular
pretraining data source, to its social and geographic contexts. We create a new
dataset of 10.3 million self-descriptions of website creators, and extract
information about who they are and where they are from: their topical
interests, social roles, and geographic affiliations. Then, we conduct the
first study investigating how ten "quality" and English language identification
(langID) filters affect webpages that vary along these social dimensions. Our
experiments illuminate a range of implicit preferences in data curation: we
show that some quality classifiers act like topical domain filters, and langID
can overlook English content from some regions of the world. Overall, we hope
that our work will encourage a new line of research on pretraining data
curation practices and its social implications.
|
[
-0.6596167684,
-0.4539249241,
0.5491110086,
0.1729664654,
-0.2771389484,
-0.0205396339,
-0.3381035924,
-0.611030519,
0.2357868999,
0.52714926,
-0.5224962234,
-0.5329833031,
-0.6366242766,
0.3508305252,
-0.7726939917,
1.081541419,
-0.1178335622,
-0.0285829548,
-0.5575951338,
0.0094793458,
0.0344309062,
-0.7378827333,
-0.7443172336,
-0.2774151266,
0.9355235696,
0.3369028866,
0.6272580028,
0.6685079932,
0.3374162316,
0.2620403171,
0.2645362616,
-0.1052367017,
-0.8295001388,
0.0949338377,
-0.4572741389,
-0.5135549903,
-0.2318134159,
0.55155164,
0.6995229125,
0.6976292729,
0.1275466233,
0.2992690206,
0.3667639792,
0.505494833,
-0.699365139,
-0.0805324912,
-0.487305671,
0.094861351,
-0.4237016439,
-0.3048566282,
-0.3063640893,
-0.2421192527,
0.0434683897,
-0.5732380152,
0.5555049181,
0.22786659,
1.0831936598,
0.0883929655,
-0.4711131155,
-0.1938337833,
-0.8103324175,
0.661909461,
-0.5725072026,
0.4143232703,
1.0545229912,
0.0938149244,
-0.0340000018,
-0.6354655623,
-0.5436356664,
0.1839917004,
-0.4857204258,
0.1400475949,
-0.025454985,
-0.1775816679,
0.2466689497,
0.4373726845,
-0.6562752724,
0.5286031365,
-0.5832030177,
-0.1990795732,
0.912624836,
-0.0953242853,
0.2121496797,
-0.2264294028,
0.0317415446,
0.2215295285,
-1.0530883074,
0.0693940371,
0.6506662369,
0.2885684371,
-0.0865897983,
0.5380856991,
-0.4605314732,
0.4028648734,
-0.010533873,
-0.0226937458,
0.0691102147,
-0.2321970761,
-0.0492502004,
-0.0822144821,
0.8512185812,
0.4328263402,
0.6306952238,
-0.1194773912,
-0.365460366,
-0.2223603129,
0.2910876572,
-0.9147673249,
-0.2798169255,
0.0603495687,
-0.7010862231,
-0.1863875538,
0.1440465897,
-0.5033677816,
-0.3573159277,
-0.4446869195,
0.1853735447,
0.1328231394,
-0.1843430847,
-0.0224469863,
0.120321624,
0.1359931976,
0.0681305379,
-0.7235689759,
0.2941398919,
0.4042210877,
0.4804359376,
-0.3673089445,
-0.3288353682,
-0.144165054,
0.1276030391,
-0.1172587723,
0.8432062864,
-0.6138532758,
-0.4297592342,
0.2478029281,
0.2911157608,
0.3410379887,
-0.3310789168,
0.224825114,
-0.755104661,
0.3748206794,
-0.299641937,
-0.6189792156,
0.1634427905,
0.002722481,
-0.8132098913,
0.8737418056,
-0.3731674254,
-0.5794942379,
0.5435633659,
-0.2780932784,
-0.7531187534,
0.0998945087,
-0.1400306225,
-0.2194271386,
0.1721752286,
0.209694162,
0.756374836,
-0.1318031996,
0.1070737466,
-0.3154037893,
-0.1489795744,
0.4248715043,
-0.4396161437,
0.5693792701,
0.396396935,
-0.214948386,
-0.19713521,
-0.850658536,
-0.1082224324,
0.2051780969,
-0.3317176104,
-0.5513675809,
0.2624850571,
-0.0725135207,
0.252148062,
0.3224149048,
-0.322581768,
-0.1091818511,
-0.1162876263,
0.2261372507,
0.8627074957,
0.027196452,
0.3501879275,
-0.2525289357,
0.7187077999,
-0.1768551618,
0.2979781032,
-0.2095395774,
-0.2319642305,
-0.7400984168,
0.1919917464,
0.3169050515,
0.0459058322,
-0.4331420064,
0.2852312326,
-0.2393427938,
-0.5430089235,
-0.3391977549,
0.4112640321,
0.4951052666,
0.1580460072,
0.2670484185,
-0.2628997862,
-0.5275925994,
-1.0341922045,
-0.2048131526,
0.0218294486,
-0.0074354284,
0.2711344957,
0.2751205862,
-0.1049669981,
1.0370150805,
-0.624565959,
-0.2886278629,
-0.144710511,
0.0569187626,
-0.0380859226,
0.2935505807,
0.4842809737,
-0.8096467257,
-0.5493704081,
-0.5071903467,
-0.6076261401,
-0.4320951402,
-0.0734721273,
-0.5045832992,
0.032929223,
0.4019242227,
-0.449745059,
0.5223946571,
0.6094901562,
-0.2277058661,
0.5330768228,
-0.1288501918,
0.19697842,
-0.9708329439,
-0.1545243859,
0.3888368905,
-0.3079684079,
-0.3020383418,
-0.061567191,
-0.0423821695,
0.0332152434,
-0.4141869247,
0.7859361172,
-0.6768604517,
-0.0424219631,
-0.2816798687,
0.3870544434,
0.3740342855,
0.1051419154,
0.163645044,
0.7368226051,
0.4006181955,
-0.9458868504,
-0.1813602,
0.1652904898,
-0.2090996504,
0.6923636198,
-0.4793488085,
0.242383495,
-0.2574318349,
0.2727202773,
-1.1186773777,
-0.1620119363,
-0.1107568666,
-0.4975691438,
0.1921122372,
-0.2630657852,
-0.5285713673,
-0.5874525309,
-0.2470050603,
0.1831685156,
0.3254394233,
-0.4905262887,
0.3016385436,
0.8163015842,
-0.1305837929,
-0.2212792933,
-0.5596411824,
0.0709422827,
-0.2294909656,
-0.2474141717,
0.4153613746,
-0.2246589065,
-0.1638453603,
0.013817912,
-0.0503268428,
-0.5656445026,
0.2806324363,
0.4342731535,
0.175335288,
0.0023223462,
0.3072681427,
0.0049535953,
0.1284486055,
0.5392735004,
-0.1502576619,
0.5644212365,
0.3511470258,
-0.2886229753,
-0.3604077399,
0.1474232674,
0.1074780747,
-0.415169239,
0.7002190948,
0.5262532234,
-0.2633997202,
-0.2522684336,
-0.7115061283,
-0.2570916414,
-0.5349370241,
0.1448000222,
-0.4883051515,
-0.8223206997,
0.3863546848,
0.226532653,
0.0569950789,
0.5201200247,
0.03931164,
-0.714620769,
0.9383655787,
0.6708849072,
-0.043905057,
0.4702127874,
-0.2183766514,
0.2534113228,
-0.5871582031,
-0.0695845485,
-0.6480528712,
-0.5028532743,
-0.6935935616,
0.0266306549,
0.0399844199,
0.0239569955,
-0.0822604746,
0.0390739627,
-0.3802042305,
0.6414775848,
0.5202581286,
0.1774614304,
0.0981152579,
0.1679919511,
0.1477596313,
-0.1589138061,
-0.3804973364,
-0.6921828985,
1.4945778847,
0.077245906,
0.9613615274,
-0.0292541403,
0.6717770696,
0.4730049074,
0.4186991453,
-0.3357285857,
0.6042117476,
-0.4143831432,
-0.7772817016,
-0.3591011763,
-0.2035445571,
-1.4194723368,
-0.0865367576,
-0.3471437693,
-0.3140496612,
-0.1035576835,
0.4881336987,
-0.2951150835,
0.1696975976,
-0.5587474704,
0.5700951219,
-0.6886327863,
-0.6979656219,
-0.3800005317,
-0.361233145,
0.0867122933,
-0.2683398724,
0.4460088313,
-0.2667561173,
0.3033460677,
0.9161455631,
-0.2519578338,
1.0803940296,
-0.2256768942,
0.0213647038,
0.181971401,
-0.0052912328,
0.296837002,
-0.1628050655,
0.0127741154,
0.3381435275,
-0.018291017,
-0.3526195884,
-0.4070703387,
0.628706038,
-0.9158830047,
-0.8886680603,
-0.1214679331,
0.1138098761,
-0.1210586503,
0.424895972,
0.161190629,
0.4266706705,
-0.2090560347,
0.4334404171,
0.5947024226,
-0.3639781177,
0.2435887605,
0.8445646167,
-0.5056555867,
-0.0124066118,
0.8212577701,
0.4098851085,
0.1390083134,
0.209222436,
0.3444465995,
-0.4327556491,
-0.5975118876,
-0.0679498911,
0.493316412,
-0.721144557,
-0.0757034123,
-0.5529816151,
-0.4102830589,
-0.6103460789,
-0.0932865366,
-0.2558329403,
-0.2132999599,
-0.4176758528,
-0.2587979138,
0.2470512986,
1.0694131851,
0.0272144303,
0.523789525,
-0.462036401,
0.2990062237,
0.2716981173,
0.4155597687,
-0.0469668731,
-0.5217345953,
-0.5507158041,
0.0613923669,
-0.1054709479,
-0.6112408042,
0.3299045265,
0.1524524242,
0.9146667719,
0.5205833912,
-0.0049186097,
0.7495781183,
-0.4720449448,
0.7508341074,
-0.1335619539,
-0.6349888444,
0.7562777996,
-0.1592798978,
0.1784635633,
0.7157256007,
0.8529433608,
-0.4863593876,
-0.4380623102,
-0.3569380343,
-0.8920820355,
0.4899975359,
0.0040460438,
0.542389214,
-0.250983268,
0.6914256215,
0.2149229348,
0.4443275928,
-1.1100678444,
-0.6615565419,
-0.2181043029,
-0.0418953113,
-0.2118941694,
-0.6759089231,
0.137727946,
-0.2952896655,
0.7373127937,
0.0825675204,
-0.1178298146,
0.0348315202,
-0.5026264191,
-0.0499831848,
0.0843520984,
-0.0199003574,
0.795306623,
0.2197590768,
0.2936917841,
-0.1191676781,
-0.416375339,
0.0993282571,
-0.078361012,
-0.3484410644,
-0.0884017497,
0.1757337302,
0.6831437349,
0.3972243667,
-0.3025144637,
0.5469452739,
-0.0858221948,
0.1561471969,
-0.4851111174,
0.0741915032,
-0.0063106315,
-0.273732692,
0.335640192,
-0.5128947496,
0.2217288315,
-0.4789430499,
0.2336984426,
0.4677531719,
-0.1411667168,
-0.5383244753,
0.7066888213,
0.3358389437,
-0.2788206339,
0.588026762,
-0.2015044391,
-0.3456045389,
0.3448391557,
0.4239663184,
0.6890695095,
-0.3809002042,
0.3502348065,
0.4353618324,
0.2312614918,
0.0803924277,
-0.0102563631,
-0.1138735265,
-0.959084332,
-0.3115749657,
-0.9067499042,
-0.1140875667,
0.3017506599,
-0.64657408,
0.4346116781,
-0.4540641904,
-0.3861520588,
0.0988234058,
-0.0305571817,
-1.2955101728,
0.6272054315,
0.4362766743,
0.5333655477,
-1.0679988861,
0.7629659772,
0.6023259163,
-0.4519442618,
-0.8646197915,
0.0248914827,
0.0281391293,
-0.7766586542,
0.8861832023,
0.342869103,
-0.1602097452,
0.1983385086,
-0.5721864104,
-1.1601227522,
0.8562029004,
-0.0042742067,
-0.5454102755,
-0.1357301623,
0.3205499649,
0.5588707924,
-0.3046504557,
0.2358489633,
0.4565473199,
0.5310208201,
-0.1457670182,
-0.7037769556,
-0.2084733248,
-0.3121783733,
-0.202412039,
-0.259888351,
-0.6463548541,
0.7804340124,
0.1257752031,
-0.4603985548,
-0.2509064972,
0.3558427393,
-0.0405021347,
-0.0263270438,
0.4985581338,
0.3476777375,
0.7750926614,
0.0209142547,
1.2237401009,
-0.4159194529,
0.0477352142,
1.4095654488,
-0.36912781,
0.8064889312,
0.3182278574,
-0.363979727,
0.6371257901,
0.9385406971,
-0.0663897991,
0.4390876591,
0.2774435282,
-0.0150486482,
-0.1268280745,
-0.2671667039,
-0.0674595982,
0.5272886157,
0.2114408165,
-0.4643549919,
-0.0757487565,
0.0297994465,
0.1152600795,
0.2130669057,
-0.3455794454,
0.7016449571,
0.0107203405,
-0.6827675104,
0.1075004339,
-0.1837760657,
0.5734782219,
-0.6002574563,
0.1942206919,
-0.4774316847,
-0.3156688511,
-0.4074606299,
-1.0549197197,
0.1757508516,
-0.0328745544,
-0.38398543,
-0.7028909326,
0.8563182354,
-0.4681062102,
-0.4182715714,
0.468870461,
0.6755969524,
0.5861720443,
-0.276724577,
-0.5069510341,
-0.0161807444,
0.0279416442,
-0.5996177197,
0.3426373005,
0.4753499627,
-0.1279427707,
0.5586308837,
0.8233895898,
0.3728658557,
0.1957998723,
0.4517329037,
0.6960496306,
-0.5872571468,
-0.4801469743,
-0.8536029458,
0.3891632557,
-0.1768973768,
-0.1843855083,
1.0645436049,
0.7858510613,
1.1582970619,
0.1293351799,
0.8509981036,
0.2019836456,
0.3945817947,
-0.5185239911,
1.0801508427,
-0.6205915213,
0.1232688129,
0.0160225164,
-1.0750410557,
-0.0050491318,
0.6318416595,
-0.436845839,
0.1649484783,
0.6597635746,
0.7361257076,
0.0018790556,
-0.3294836283,
0.4045791328,
0.4248217642,
0.3389958143,
-0.0787730217,
0.699395299,
-0.1116561145,
0.4113616943,
-0.4640283883,
0.0729508251,
0.0283697043,
-0.789337635,
-1.0491213799,
-0.683216095,
-0.3781843185,
-0.2559254169,
-0.0326301567,
0.7296319604,
0.9626467228,
-0.7151646018,
-0.2798828781,
0.3074379563,
0.1356634051,
0.5167921185,
-0.2401870489,
0.111903429,
-0.375734061,
-0.6476038098,
0.1097470373,
0.0870782956,
0.1733077019,
-0.7181113362,
-0.0829707384,
-0.1995827556,
0.0687022954,
0.6154803634,
0.087740615,
-0.5752303004,
-0.2421002686,
-0.1335807443,
-0.1776851416,
0.0570418388,
0.7131451368,
-0.7600353956,
0.4359145164,
-0.0844099969,
0.4085265696,
0.651168406,
0.0506491177,
0.573143363,
-0.8749676347,
-0.0024549328,
-0.1882259399,
0.4721841514,
0.5766921639,
-0.5340813994,
0.4561961293,
0.1983025074,
-0.4734131396,
-0.6190570593,
-0.0922457203,
-0.3204937279,
-0.2707279325,
1.3094395399,
-0.1935739964,
-0.150915429,
-0.1008890346,
0.0352832265,
0.1757042706,
-0.1528241634,
0.8584896326,
0.9930986762,
0.1936095506,
-0.1095629781,
-0.6964771748,
0.5538513064,
0.0718011782,
-0.8320296407,
-0.0951518193,
0.7770214081,
0.5085341334,
-0.0587989017,
0.9418739676,
0.0671820194,
-0.1642357707,
-0.554020226,
0.2481419295,
0.1935420036,
-0.4705792964,
-0.1853161305,
-0.0563247353,
0.2217339277,
0.0733800903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06401v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06401v4
|
DevEval: Evaluating Code Generation in Practical Software Projects
| 2024-01-12T06:51:30 | 2024-03-06T02:16:51 |
Jia Li, Ge Li, Yunfei Zhao, Yongmin Li, Zhi Jin, Hao Zhu, Huanyu Liu, Kaibo Liu, Lecheng Wang, Zheng Fang, Lanshen Wang, Jiazheng Ding, Xuanming Zhang, Yihong Dong, Yuqi Zhu, Bin Gu, Mengfei Yang
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
How to evaluate Large Language Models (LLMs) in code generation is an open
question. Many benchmarks have been proposed but are inconsistent with
practical software projects, e.g., unreal program distributions, insufficient
dependencies, and small-scale project contexts. Thus, the capabilities of LLMs
in practical projects are still unclear. In this paper, we propose a new
benchmark named DevEval, aligned with Developers' experiences in practical
projects. DevEval is collected through a rigorous pipeline, containing 2,690
samples from 119 practical projects and covering 10 domains. Compared to
previous benchmarks, DevEval aligns to practical projects in multiple
dimensions, e.g., real program distributions, sufficient dependencies, and
enough-scale project contexts. We assess five popular LLMs on DevEval (e.g.,
gpt-4, gpt-3.5-turbo, CodeLLaMa, and StarCoder) and reveal their actual
abilities in code generation. For instance, the highest Pass@1 of gpt-3.5-turbo
only is 42 in our experiments. We also discuss the challenges and future
directions of code generation in practical projects. We open-source DevEval and
hope it can facilitate the development of code generation in practical
projects.
|
[
-0.3678900599,
-0.4249375165,
0.2769407332,
0.3349597752,
-0.1681774557,
0.2851282954,
-0.3839951158,
-0.1987476945,
-0.1340981573,
0.2794326842,
-0.3444968462,
-0.872440815,
-0.3394113481,
0.1224621609,
-0.4353577793,
0.9172639847,
-0.1483471096,
-0.0500942841,
-0.0866674855,
-0.0358141288,
-0.5275321007,
-0.3947775066,
-0.0353953056,
0.3076970279,
0.1757664382,
0.6637930274,
0.5150088668,
0.5366443396,
0.869422853,
0.2909727693,
0.0932993069,
-0.0681719631,
-0.410268873,
0.3575816453,
0.110417828,
-0.2339271456,
-0.5072125793,
-0.208232373,
0.3488742411,
0.3791565299,
-0.3369307518,
0.6957345009,
-0.0772568285,
0.819417417,
-0.6606709957,
-0.0093959458,
-0.6816096306,
-0.0209506135,
-0.3344300985,
0.1340773404,
-0.2696827054,
-0.8425644636,
-0.2340638638,
-0.0792912617,
0.2415806949,
-0.3644051254,
0.3693885505,
0.1686876863,
-0.1422059983,
-0.4424958527,
-0.6804018617,
0.8279162645,
-0.8291686177,
0.2912477851,
-0.0407912806,
0.6125292778,
-0.0964344665,
-1.0973953009,
-0.3279374242,
-0.508572638,
0.5795586109,
-0.1163711026,
0.159882009,
-0.3067518771,
0.3134071231,
0.5251400471,
-0.5373517275,
-0.1525571197,
-0.6376091838,
-0.0163060185,
0.6898977757,
0.1488794833,
0.0557861179,
-0.1014974266,
-0.2199157178,
0.0025756285,
-1.1760864258,
-0.2194729298,
0.2266296595,
0.2714111209,
-0.053387247,
0.43232584,
0.1905614138,
0.627520442,
-0.3150049448,
-0.1634705365,
0.4641773105,
-0.3981869817,
-0.1681610346,
-0.2670755982,
0.4569748938,
0.2210596502,
0.3485876024,
0.0773465782,
-0.4216139615,
0.2532909214,
0.5925173759,
-1.000541091,
-0.2968915403,
0.2941471636,
-0.3238222301,
-0.6894840598,
-0.1198639199,
-0.6164381504,
-0.476332128,
-0.078928411,
-0.0394559354,
-0.0763740912,
-0.6066195369,
-0.3136496246,
0.023052413,
0.446433872,
0.1264204234,
-0.3795023561,
0.0611324087,
0.7992904186,
0.8051489592,
-0.0534551144,
-0.3255214095,
-0.6383010149,
-0.1367116272,
-0.6150193214,
0.6731258035,
-0.3363733888,
-0.4065513313,
0.3344668746,
-0.4786230326,
0.3922653496,
-0.7795007229,
0.6236717701,
-0.4450220466,
-0.2932330668,
-0.1534093916,
-0.4436107874,
0.2520908713,
0.3466438949,
-0.2534777224,
0.833992362,
0.2963364422,
-0.5453811288,
0.7731798291,
-0.548897028,
-0.3273865581,
0.3838617802,
-0.5759068727,
-0.3786192238,
0.3691860139,
-0.1967900246,
0.1771483868,
-0.5098109245,
0.6291080117,
-0.3644168079,
-0.2366384119,
0.1056865454,
-0.4006869197,
0.4139337242,
0.5590543151,
-0.4643842578,
0.1985957325,
-0.9279869795,
0.3557052612,
-0.0654959008,
-0.4817752242,
0.0356947891,
0.0571584031,
0.1203675121,
0.2847606242,
0.0850874633,
-0.4324604273,
0.2709780931,
-0.2554765344,
0.6164960265,
0.6233016849,
-0.0869336873,
-0.0438578874,
-0.124972783,
0.8262823224,
-0.2072084993,
0.0633334816,
0.0048233336,
-0.504961729,
-0.5925577879,
-0.3025574684,
0.488037765,
0.2581467927,
-0.4708915651,
0.1321962327,
-0.1420188248,
-0.7988197207,
-0.5895175934,
0.3408597708,
0.5365251303,
0.3499284387,
0.0874063596,
-0.1380238533,
-0.4429766834,
-0.7936897278,
-0.342664808,
-0.2392015457,
-0.0885122716,
0.2577333748,
0.555935204,
-0.0979280025,
0.8306254745,
-0.5342636108,
-0.098149702,
-0.2928602099,
0.1062122956,
0.261633426,
0.2956834137,
0.3651630282,
-0.8203400373,
-0.4755700231,
-0.213743791,
-0.4941422343,
-0.133343339,
0.1320145726,
0.3184417784,
0.095563218,
0.5217700005,
-0.2831880748,
0.1471018344,
0.6653102636,
-0.2155622244,
0.5209282041,
-0.4186212122,
-0.0374497436,
-0.9372984767,
0.1172249541,
-0.1851406991,
-0.1597013772,
-0.5465461016,
0.5114606023,
0.3523458838,
-0.3658213615,
-0.7795544267,
0.2543453276,
-0.5139967203,
-0.4164238274,
-0.118253313,
0.4412530661,
-0.0588338114,
0.0086878603,
0.0417331606,
1.12974751,
0.5075611472,
-0.5054895878,
0.2427315116,
-0.0109656053,
-0.6472232342,
0.2723478079,
-0.7395923138,
0.3049969971,
0.3061450422,
0.0029362275,
-0.8167479634,
-0.1800443828,
-0.5031777024,
-0.3474373519,
0.1028372422,
-0.134455651,
-0.3913003504,
-0.6015594006,
-0.5481856465,
0.3010033369,
0.9504868388,
-0.5041571856,
-0.0440471247,
0.3922036886,
-0.0112054618,
-0.3503986597,
-0.8583413363,
0.120206438,
-0.3009288013,
-0.8550626636,
0.1181963161,
-0.2378515005,
-0.5619863272,
-0.2470566928,
-0.0966996551,
-0.0499768965,
0.113096796,
0.234970808,
-0.0173862353,
-0.4945835173,
0.0392805338,
-0.2323861718,
0.034550339,
-0.0241491422,
-0.1482329518,
0.3004380167,
-0.5972278118,
-0.409424752,
0.2471648902,
0.009647321,
0.6075724363,
-0.2244865894,
0.4054513574,
0.2799214721,
-0.1781209558,
-0.3727807701,
-0.547501266,
0.189385429,
-0.5117330551,
0.2537866235,
-0.6819528341,
-0.5532013774,
0.4023323655,
-0.4304519594,
0.3826075196,
0.3337892592,
0.8576486111,
0.4213241339,
0.82647717,
0.5835785866,
0.3554553092,
0.0182391778,
-0.381372571,
0.1389846951,
-0.7489895821,
-0.0578192994,
-0.5580714941,
-0.1601414084,
-0.7768934369,
-0.5509076715,
0.1655258387,
0.4239978492,
-0.3907067776,
0.5219510198,
-0.680582881,
0.4947823286,
0.3006336689,
-0.5022835135,
0.3210531175,
-0.3061254919,
-0.1541714221,
-0.0125064068,
-0.5399469733,
-0.7076717019,
1.2050573826,
0.3458593488,
0.5934733748,
0.2840000093,
0.9973917007,
0.4378261566,
0.7604999542,
-0.3374040425,
0.5571864247,
-0.1313204914,
-0.5762642026,
0.0134178987,
-0.3567093909,
-0.7367867827,
0.0941811875,
0.2258119583,
-0.2046540231,
0.1274882853,
0.0819705725,
-0.2321846038,
0.0360133164,
-0.8486869931,
0.9432961345,
-0.2055128664,
-0.3270140588,
-0.1983374208,
-0.2962420285,
0.4813699722,
-0.2938005924,
0.5404999852,
-0.1642647833,
-0.3633238077,
0.4078764617,
-0.5780258775,
0.5457992554,
-0.4121369421,
-0.2680883706,
0.5551817417,
0.2789264619,
0.3908028305,
0.3428017795,
-0.459035635,
0.1121166348,
-0.2138593942,
-0.3182713687,
-0.066685155,
1.088394165,
-0.6753593087,
-0.5739549398,
-0.2722306252,
-0.3041781485,
-0.2927723825,
0.2174877077,
0.3307343423,
0.591257453,
-0.456684947,
0.142146498,
0.1597432047,
-0.3414043486,
0.4724453986,
0.464332819,
-0.2980614007,
-0.5901110172,
0.8984984159,
-0.1059750617,
0.3860316575,
-0.051837761,
0.2385477573,
-0.0296951532,
-0.9918843508,
-0.7495214939,
-0.1472815275,
-0.5981934071,
-0.5070340037,
-0.1990664899,
-0.2355196029,
-0.269105494,
-0.403547734,
-0.5981644988,
-0.4567451179,
0.1101877913,
0.0250134543,
0.2486358583,
1.0391885042,
0.0140619501,
-0.349716872,
-0.8753046989,
0.2473817617,
0.1004598364,
0.4481096864,
-0.2619407475,
-0.3980937004,
-0.0871734768,
-0.175934419,
-0.4811628759,
-0.5787039399,
0.3555633724,
0.1175941303,
0.3867693543,
0.1895658523,
0.2990730405,
0.4599798024,
-0.50234586,
1.0730855465,
0.2168388218,
-0.8472744226,
0.7732763886,
-0.3903454244,
0.3656736016,
0.7743168473,
-0.0105508659,
-0.1053065211,
-0.6875890493,
-0.599701345,
-0.7445650697,
0.2068681866,
0.3741540313,
0.1803901047,
-0.2355955988,
0.2573654056,
0.186055541,
0.4845094383,
-0.6191558242,
0.0247678198,
-0.1462557912,
0.0047243666,
0.1610904932,
-0.1545252502,
0.001195739,
0.0254882649,
0.1885430217,
-0.0093263015,
0.0335194655,
0.0374619402,
-0.1681098938,
0.1024160236,
0.4485216141,
0.9172248244,
1.2116876841,
-0.1992310435,
0.1060162336,
0.1502281725,
-0.5867985487,
0.1604142338,
-0.2439028025,
0.0342703126,
-0.1959533244,
0.4596170485,
0.4017529786,
-0.1587945074,
-0.7881208658,
0.7076979876,
-0.058811564,
-0.3800070882,
-0.361766845,
0.2058935016,
0.1517983675,
0.2715905309,
0.1092097163,
0.1570747793,
0.0640241429,
-0.5187868476,
0.1692257673,
0.3340108097,
-0.2830681801,
-0.3425430655,
0.4873039126,
0.6970127225,
-0.5241084695,
0.6727836728,
-0.483412087,
-0.1989278942,
0.7525961399,
0.5186781883,
1.2050732374,
-0.0623226911,
0.0687465668,
0.3955653608,
0.2051889896,
0.090384312,
0.6334813237,
-0.0183562525,
-0.2742758989,
-0.627607882,
-0.689214766,
-0.4259737432,
0.0673079342,
-0.3801131845,
0.5041912198,
-0.3259569705,
-0.1543913335,
-0.2281834632,
0.0083101271,
-0.5428068042,
-0.1214983463,
0.0613884255,
1.2898122072,
-0.5634909868,
0.9665942192,
0.6224380732,
-0.3024004996,
-0.7367070913,
0.1804804057,
-0.0377107412,
-0.7591014504,
0.8320934772,
0.0374293029,
-0.096054785,
-0.1634109914,
-0.1737965047,
-0.4401107132,
1.0723627806,
0.3313912153,
-0.6769938469,
0.1877863705,
0.1605288833,
0.6528126001,
-0.5165200233,
0.2484693527,
0.5026859045,
0.4550928771,
0.1149343029,
-0.7123499513,
-0.0284811947,
-0.3346570134,
0.2228327096,
0.4641542733,
-0.5784235001,
0.7203347683,
-0.7253463864,
-0.0821382552,
0.2471628338,
0.4693856537,
0.5393456817,
0.2166021019,
0.2249006331,
0.192067042,
0.6009270549,
0.0343845449,
1.0938376188,
-0.7830899954,
0.2237569839,
0.827172637,
-0.5341025591,
1.1005805731,
0.3300293982,
-0.3471610546,
0.4886284769,
0.38033548,
-0.2286901474,
0.5462574363,
0.7747171521,
-0.1389793158,
-0.0184960291,
0.1652781218,
-0.8490270376,
0.1898227781,
0.0540516526,
-0.1410209537,
-0.1039379388,
-0.0103600379,
-0.2269008607,
0.1475559622,
-0.1105883047,
0.6618245244,
0.269156456,
-0.7062045932,
0.8839822412,
0.0467423312,
0.3997305036,
-0.4854038358,
-0.1656977981,
-0.5347263217,
0.7111113667,
-0.2240224928,
-0.8252965212,
0.4120541513,
0.5452612042,
0.1479199529,
-0.1672651768,
0.6686044931,
0.0310787577,
-0.6227119565,
0.1103805229,
0.483507067,
0.2640228868,
0.0618046299,
-0.4946804941,
0.2425261885,
0.0880988464,
-0.431124866,
0.4430101514,
0.5631096363,
0.1354865432,
0.5780918002,
0.3977327645,
0.3493338227,
-0.0076185088,
0.1679572463,
0.7951644659,
-0.8014786243,
-0.2188864499,
-0.685524106,
0.4213989675,
0.0269261841,
-0.7082032561,
0.8512690663,
0.7033258677,
0.5843032002,
-0.1921022981,
0.6308735609,
-0.2855501175,
0.3298600614,
-0.1908603162,
0.383486867,
-0.3175657392,
0.7860686779,
-0.3617660105,
-1.2627000809,
-0.3203830123,
0.3130316734,
-0.1859558821,
0.2073436081,
0.5333219171,
0.7173995376,
0.0708367527,
0.0054888283,
0.4553007483,
0.0489648245,
0.5370002985,
0.5650624037,
1.0921349525,
-0.2082764655,
0.9516353011,
-0.0829727054,
-0.3447321653,
0.0331278332,
-1.2257752419,
-0.6494037509,
-0.2020012587,
-0.5377835631,
-0.3571523726,
0.0228007436,
0.6814597249,
0.6734179854,
-0.7625849247,
-0.3769074082,
-0.760371685,
-0.06592834,
-0.2452779561,
-0.1887645721,
0.2664534152,
-0.5896655321,
-0.3132849038,
0.5500218272,
0.2623574138,
-0.36330989,
-0.7279956341,
-0.3191341758,
0.2547599673,
0.0166417584,
0.5359698534,
0.1244712695,
-0.4989851415,
-0.1067235172,
0.0974533185,
-0.1941741109,
0.1059028879,
1.0967066288,
-0.7029184699,
0.1653651893,
0.5549938679,
0.4455655813,
0.4619077742,
-0.1582544297,
0.690997541,
-0.8802044392,
-0.0444231555,
0.3703984618,
-0.0070029465,
0.3325975239,
0.1784292459,
0.6868595481,
-0.1922803521,
-0.98365587,
-1.0222790241,
0.245265469,
-0.360789299,
-0.2216882259,
1.2745600939,
-0.1776998341,
0.292049557,
-0.0686497465,
0.0724549368,
-0.3192242384,
-0.2045826167,
0.5426959991,
0.4445824623,
-0.0541809537,
0.1465006024,
-0.8145718575,
0.6859682798,
0.0258737803,
-0.9285712838,
0.4503856897,
0.4990050793,
0.1717690378,
0.2610677779,
0.7238811851,
-0.2168237418,
0.2847708464,
0.419290185,
0.0400106683,
-0.0541846044,
-0.2885297835,
-0.1705455333,
0.3753136098,
0.8467406034,
-0.0385991782
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06400v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06400v2
|
Generalizing Visual Question Answering from Synthetic to Human-Written Questions via a Chain of QA with a Large Language Model
| 2024-01-12T06:49:49 | 2024-01-16T06:01:48 |
Taehee Kim, Yeongjae Cho, Heejun Shin, Yohan Jo, Dongmyung Shin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Visual question answering (VQA) is a task where an image is given, and a
series of questions are asked about the image. To build an efficient VQA
algorithm, a large amount of QA data is required which is very expensive.
Generating synthetic QA pairs based on templates is a practical way to obtain
data. However, VQA models trained on those data do not perform well on complex,
human-written questions. To address this issue, we propose a new method called
{\it chain of QA for human-written questions} (CoQAH). CoQAH utilizes a
sequence of QA interactions between a large language model and a VQA model
trained on synthetic data to reason and derive logical answers for
human-written questions. We tested the effectiveness of CoQAH on two types of
human-written VQA datasets for 3D-rendered and chest X-ray images and found
that it achieved state-of-the-art accuracy in both types of data. Notably,
CoQAH outperformed general vision-language models, VQA models, and medical
foundation models with no finetuning.
|
[
-0.5426098704,
-1.0478377342,
0.7578724027,
-0.143455267,
-0.4111814499,
0.2488138229,
0.261559844,
-0.5134391189,
0.2755384445,
0.7489386201,
-0.6523878574,
-0.6840806007,
0.0265953094,
0.2068110555,
-0.4518518746,
0.5038483143,
-0.2142879367,
0.1856713593,
-0.6195335388,
-0.2705100477,
-0.4826954305,
-0.6371614933,
-0.5554628968,
0.062575981,
0.5370111465,
0.262714982,
0.8335024118,
0.7435747385,
0.5218455791,
0.2658754885,
0.2947635651,
0.2956187129,
-0.4105755985,
0.0574136898,
-0.3430297971,
-0.5723514557,
-0.2991918027,
-0.3803903162,
0.4078772962,
0.718542099,
-0.0312331039,
0.3317917585,
-0.4271578193,
0.7491754293,
-0.5695526004,
-0.0417525247,
-0.3012247682,
-0.0323179774,
0.1257010102,
-0.4555784464,
-0.3165714145,
-0.4765947163,
0.5205096006,
-0.9437845945,
0.1183108687,
0.2784298062,
0.9679627419,
0.1403157413,
-0.6100093126,
-0.2176826298,
-0.6582709551,
0.455329597,
-0.1667059362,
0.3049101233,
0.126528427,
0.7144854665,
0.0197677985,
-1.0746319294,
-0.7627512813,
-0.0898550153,
0.1418862939,
0.4153840244,
-0.2848953009,
0.1437450498,
0.2656226158,
0.3415893614,
-0.8717374206,
-0.3320761919,
-0.6234571934,
-0.0829401016,
0.6363030672,
0.2404086888,
0.8210554123,
-0.2493349016,
-0.534283042,
-0.4731518328,
-0.7851161361,
0.2618755102,
-0.1360951215,
-0.1788082421,
-0.0720228851,
0.7962241769,
-0.5878075361,
0.8423918486,
0.043003805,
0.2971161902,
-0.0876921415,
-0.2649367452,
-0.2338021696,
-0.2848800719,
0.4798497558,
0.6442753077,
0.4263522029,
-0.1418152004,
0.1043389365,
0.3119911551,
0.3792597651,
-0.6459519267,
-0.3601130247,
0.2734359801,
-0.1962223798,
-0.0987303853,
0.0423339717,
-0.5755431056,
-0.3731903732,
-0.5375001431,
0.7550778389,
-0.0886642486,
0.0953423232,
0.1938342452,
-0.3618911505,
0.4565172791,
0.4184463322,
-0.4870768785,
0.4919445515,
0.3299932778,
0.4543112516,
0.0769186318,
-0.0438067541,
-0.8856229186,
0.1125686094,
-0.5498521328,
0.8366407752,
-0.3257350028,
0.0352032371,
-0.1384802163,
-0.1050711423,
0.0035854895,
-0.7744036913,
0.2819472253,
-0.8547943234,
0.3511640429,
-0.4725968838,
-0.4707670212,
-0.3661432266,
0.4968517721,
-0.7398232222,
0.4603791237,
0.245739907,
-0.6478581429,
0.2645333409,
-0.1625798792,
-0.1122012138,
-0.0134323779,
-0.6124284267,
-0.3555054367,
-0.0538684353,
0.7908845544,
0.3089192808,
-0.6097617149,
0.3495650887,
-0.2457204312,
-0.4716413319,
0.2878343761,
-0.0492239892,
0.5367193222,
-0.0237082057,
-0.2735263109,
0.269513011,
-0.7905267477,
0.4270079136,
0.1423760056,
-0.0812588036,
-0.3872628808,
-0.1291370243,
-0.1662968397,
0.4315417409,
-0.1269599199,
-0.5768792033,
0.3986842334,
-0.3309058845,
0.3024997711,
0.4807612896,
0.3442800045,
0.2771502137,
-0.4645930231,
0.8617020845,
-0.0465678722,
0.0534655899,
0.1326834857,
-0.7046015263,
-0.6672621369,
-0.3128009737,
0.0441905297,
0.5910315514,
-1.356621027,
-0.1730582118,
-0.1115913168,
-0.5229231119,
-0.4518895149,
-0.0454718992,
0.4841454923,
0.7723100185,
0.6013337374,
-0.3690873682,
-0.793839097,
-0.9956256747,
-0.2533521354,
-0.3995378911,
-0.0714194775,
0.2052608132,
0.4446036816,
-0.0699840933,
0.7798883915,
-0.8268815279,
0.1801033914,
-0.0282367133,
0.1606065929,
0.0324274562,
0.2644479275,
0.31862396,
-0.7931328416,
-0.3684636354,
-0.1014989242,
-1.0240923166,
0.008209032,
-0.2912143469,
-0.372954309,
0.00451741,
0.5275378227,
-0.384352088,
0.5272307396,
0.5652920008,
-0.2824404836,
0.5954406261,
-0.15477404,
0.1433106065,
-1.1011121273,
0.1624943018,
0.0516182333,
-0.2794666588,
-0.7412806153,
0.301438868,
0.0661175698,
-0.4146779776,
-0.3776174784,
0.882455349,
-0.3737179041,
0.0353000201,
0.1532159001,
-0.1042407602,
0.3379770219,
0.743232131,
0.3338600397,
0.5535941124,
0.4863424897,
-0.4088695049,
0.5059810281,
0.4183079004,
-0.206753999,
0.7074936628,
-1.042381525,
0.42794168,
-0.3514678478,
0.3161680698,
-1.079148531,
-0.3234618902,
0.2921692133,
-0.2592546642,
-0.1547111273,
-0.0162110403,
-0.3316707015,
-0.6108727455,
-0.2167303413,
0.646348238,
0.5333887339,
-0.7244104147,
0.592312336,
0.125157699,
-0.090990603,
-0.463247627,
-0.6024867296,
0.0525170714,
-0.0001322543,
-0.9923235178,
0.0864633694,
-0.0595240071,
-0.1659536362,
-0.0957570821,
-0.1564989984,
-0.5855289698,
-0.2037700862,
0.2453501821,
0.4506112635,
-0.2149379551,
0.0781564862,
0.0835749656,
0.0147819053,
0.1453240812,
-0.3019990623,
0.4572762847,
-0.2477226704,
-0.310352385,
-0.6059445143,
0.5740997791,
0.5680410862,
-0.2267504334,
0.3908347785,
0.4115867615,
-0.4260246754,
-0.0817690492,
-0.3344047964,
-0.0818657577,
-0.4548251629,
0.322494626,
-0.5001009107,
-0.7607742548,
0.4640426636,
0.1441353858,
-0.1914657652,
0.3463685811,
0.599360466,
-0.5784774423,
1.274522543,
0.357534349,
0.3882060647,
0.0496743098,
-0.5397987366,
0.07201837,
-0.4904610813,
-0.1465050727,
-0.1955958605,
-0.1679753214,
-0.5428539515,
-0.5434083939,
0.8265401721,
0.182801038,
-0.2049122453,
0.1255054921,
-0.3865919709,
0.2623388767,
0.7023470998,
0.4198468029,
0.4777169526,
0.1584333777,
0.0610647723,
0.1803455353,
-0.8420919776,
-0.2984597683,
0.9768505692,
0.0662388951,
0.7805877924,
-0.1083744168,
0.557653904,
0.0061532045,
0.0911063701,
-0.5071813464,
0.543417573,
-0.1077326536,
-0.5928542614,
-0.3321089149,
-0.2642626762,
-0.9044156075,
0.2416968346,
-0.3129537702,
-0.3762412369,
0.3337063193,
0.5618821383,
-0.3808644116,
0.1764542758,
-0.8472764492,
0.8337914348,
-0.0828004926,
-0.3631553054,
-0.0491894744,
-0.7813160419,
0.44351089,
0.1616416276,
-0.2031808197,
0.4300048947,
0.0827697366,
0.750559926,
-0.7166203856,
0.7198697925,
-0.0232693013,
-0.0872073621,
0.7171013951,
-0.0836104304,
0.428765595,
0.0962225571,
0.2345700562,
-0.0765714049,
0.4882890284,
-0.7138026357,
-0.9670922756,
0.2313673347,
-0.7278368473,
-0.5669445992,
-0.2871121168,
-0.5585474968,
-0.3926656842,
0.016973678,
0.334058851,
0.8719949722,
-0.0823923424,
0.090438813,
0.362452209,
-0.5238896608,
-0.1995505393,
0.003503737,
-0.2921437621,
-0.6481452584,
0.8783882856,
0.1300908774,
0.4815871418,
0.5995290279,
0.2556300163,
-0.476785779,
-0.3243484497,
-0.8280363083,
0.3443353176,
-0.7410000563,
0.0070718685,
-0.520796299,
-0.293307811,
-0.0355804563,
-0.3480878174,
0.0112976655,
-0.4077268243,
-0.0213292241,
0.2191387713,
0.2036034316,
0.4607621431,
0.257322818,
-0.0788255334,
-0.9020630121,
1.053856492,
0.849874258,
0.1411575675,
-0.1010004282,
-0.0590123199,
-0.0180682149,
0.2206720263,
-0.1429333687,
-0.8583977222,
0.1477255225,
0.0091626113,
0.1070941091,
-0.0006525549,
0.1851170361,
0.9593971372,
-0.2173421979,
0.5987261534,
0.3111160398,
-0.8556193113,
0.3815328479,
-0.5278405547,
0.5435289145,
0.4983069897,
0.3043705821,
-0.7190275788,
-0.2576681376,
-0.4315443635,
-0.6284014583,
0.1527470499,
0.1882698238,
-0.014946037,
0.0992007405,
0.4749394953,
0.0116392449,
0.3005492091,
-0.3526311517,
0.0617095791,
-0.1865606606,
-0.2971354127,
0.2381390929,
-0.0274317805,
-0.1524769068,
-0.508793354,
0.254534483,
-0.3970494866,
0.136105299,
0.6269016266,
-0.3145937324,
-0.1319835186,
0.1444112957,
0.3119482398,
0.8721008301,
-0.250410229,
0.1784999073,
0.0020420998,
-0.4529232383,
0.2678954601,
-0.349016875,
-0.4534255266,
-0.408994019,
0.5571699142,
0.650919199,
-0.3673268259,
-0.9933677912,
0.5418635607,
-0.3029365838,
-0.4558707774,
-0.157401979,
0.0598748997,
0.1495218873,
0.3056213856,
0.10478881,
0.0378385186,
0.1721123457,
-0.8604605794,
0.2934453189,
0.2134592235,
-0.3301850557,
-0.3455317914,
0.591843605,
0.1695138514,
0.0358700939,
0.8457268476,
0.2144165337,
-0.3835445642,
0.845136404,
0.4282047153,
0.6632527113,
0.1748870015,
0.5721875429,
0.4702936411,
0.1085027158,
0.1843053401,
1.0545544624,
0.0390847102,
-0.5107826591,
-0.5236187577,
-0.0995740965,
-0.6263040304,
0.013820447,
-0.8833190203,
0.127908349,
-0.6488084197,
0.1139048859,
-0.1302465498,
-0.1197716147,
-0.8822492361,
0.754601717,
0.0777651966,
0.7611998916,
-0.6713625193,
0.4317695498,
0.8178311586,
-0.5995043516,
-0.9470207691,
0.012302692,
-0.2689239085,
-0.7810467482,
0.5660604239,
0.0212443117,
0.0457802415,
0.1811305881,
-0.7373192906,
-0.7497603297,
1.0750981569,
0.4167249799,
-0.5617122054,
-0.1101445481,
0.2573989034,
0.9093062878,
-0.180224359,
0.0544372313,
0.2805408239,
0.2237112224,
0.2711614966,
-0.5224714279,
0.3260350823,
-0.4662943184,
-0.0305051245,
-0.0514794439,
-0.4199312329,
0.6068962812,
-0.4657785892,
-0.3379984796,
0.3949852884,
0.6641663909,
0.5339772701,
0.4331659973,
0.572871685,
0.4714390039,
0.8689922094,
-0.0408917516,
1.4448987246,
0.1692794412,
-0.0135913668,
1.0472948551,
-0.0966926217,
0.7731174231,
0.5547174215,
0.0098315086,
0.6236590147,
0.5400660634,
0.0197792351,
0.2287132293,
0.6029108763,
0.0294346884,
-0.4278244376,
-0.077308774,
-0.3130969107,
0.4231232405,
-0.0955226347,
-0.0692574829,
-0.0270838346,
0.0252480209,
-0.3058435619,
0.1340824068,
-0.2354931086,
0.7197679281,
0.053258907,
-0.8118322492,
1.0813059807,
-0.3671745062,
-0.0272084344,
-0.3443274498,
-0.283757925,
-0.0808681175,
-0.09613166,
-0.06555067,
-0.8034476638,
0.2295981944,
0.0332063623,
-0.2078293562,
0.1511040032,
0.4583134353,
-0.5273635387,
-0.5970981121,
-0.1276084483,
0.8218812943,
-0.1776373088,
-0.324301511,
-0.4311850071,
-0.2400749177,
-0.2986856103,
0.022387024,
-0.083190158,
0.0262011103,
-0.5516271591,
0.8206050396,
0.6229684353,
-0.12332616,
0.1497994661,
0.1525257081,
0.918048501,
-0.7487916946,
-0.7120703459,
-0.3678352237,
0.7108246684,
-0.1513980329,
-0.3152483106,
0.421693325,
0.3163968325,
0.7167365551,
-0.322799623,
0.7430150509,
0.1730052382,
0.2944602966,
-0.7427749038,
0.4280589819,
-0.827477634,
-0.0264129303,
-0.406442523,
-0.763561964,
-0.4427814782,
0.2517114282,
-0.2464488298,
-0.2173373997,
0.9348430634,
0.8262546659,
0.0294698682,
0.0168536883,
0.2838227153,
0.1370145679,
0.4917728603,
0.690428853,
1.0431036949,
-0.6270411015,
0.4360989332,
-0.3623734117,
-0.0164042376,
0.0260698851,
-0.4317963421,
-0.9364982247,
-0.8442707062,
-0.4336796403,
-0.4954830408,
0.1863857508,
0.6234008074,
0.6919939518,
-0.6294893026,
-0.1220553964,
-0.1320721656,
-0.0370910652,
-0.418776691,
-0.1673139483,
0.7957763672,
0.2606323957,
-0.5186944604,
0.0433892198,
0.3472991586,
0.059485741,
-0.2009930164,
0.0399536043,
-0.1530623734,
0.2642295361,
0.4990501404,
0.5127367973,
-0.5906941891,
-0.3322170377,
0.3718764186,
-0.0858386829,
0.1758876592,
0.7833738327,
-0.9098294377,
0.944970727,
0.9921274781,
0.8996036649,
0.618196547,
0.3231841326,
0.9138265848,
-0.619946003,
-0.249172911,
0.1202799231,
0.1364039779,
0.3122636676,
-0.3751385212,
0.3606779277,
0.1773896813,
-0.1299814433,
-0.5396455526,
0.3210632205,
-1.3926719427,
-0.1624041796,
0.8035539389,
0.1232311651,
-0.506291151,
-0.0850622579,
-0.5602197051,
0.297347188,
0.0832362249,
0.8074066639,
0.3151308596,
-0.1354443282,
-0.2190745622,
-0.2130833268,
0.2929591238,
0.4607081115,
-1.287026763,
-0.3939785957,
0.5446938872,
0.2008281797,
-0.0203394126,
0.7752075195,
0.0547712222,
0.8720026612,
-0.1346307397,
0.0142616294,
-0.0608369112,
-0.3014901578,
-0.1389803588,
0.3316437602,
-0.1167390049,
-0.3356626332
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06398v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06398v1
|
An approach for mistranslation removal from popular dataset for Indic MT Task
| 2024-01-12T06:37:19 | 2024-01-12T06:37:19 |
Sudhansu Bala Das, Leo Raphael Rodrigues, Tapas Kumar Mishra, Bidyut Kr. Patra
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The conversion of content from one language to another utilizing a computer
system is known as Machine Translation (MT). Various techniques have come up to
ensure effective translations that retain the contextual and lexical
interpretation of the source language. End-to-end Neural Machine Translation
(NMT) is a popular technique and it is now widely used in real-world MT
systems. Massive amounts of parallel datasets (sentences in one language
alongside translations in another) are required for MT systems. These datasets
are crucial for an MT system to learn linguistic structures and patterns of
both languages during the training phase. One such dataset is Samanantar, the
largest publicly accessible parallel dataset for Indian languages (ILs). Since
the corpus has been gathered from various sources, it contains many incorrect
translations. Hence, the MT systems built using this dataset cannot perform to
their usual potential. In this paper, we propose an algorithm to remove
mistranslations from the training corpus and evaluate its performance and
efficiency. Two Indic languages (ILs), namely, Hindi (HIN) and Odia (ODI) are
chosen for the experiment. A baseline NMT system is built for these two ILs,
and the effect of different dataset sizes is also investigated. The quality of
the translations in the experiment is evaluated using standard metrics such as
BLEU, METEOR, and RIBES. From the results, it is observed that removing the
incorrect translation from the dataset makes the translation quality better. It
is also noticed that, despite the fact that the ILs-English and English-ILs
systems are trained using the same corpus, ILs-English works more effectively
across all the evaluation metrics.
|
[
-0.4276783764,
-0.4340371192,
-0.1204262227,
0.2891763747,
-0.7696661353,
0.2475383878,
-0.4307623506,
-0.3118664026,
0.1872571409,
0.4656385481,
-0.4097262919,
-0.4278543591,
-0.8085283637,
0.4548041224,
-0.6019001007,
1.1201432943,
-0.523935914,
0.2366755903,
-0.1469736546,
-0.53050524,
-0.7116338611,
-0.1062809974,
-0.5203616023,
-0.386593014,
0.0773589015,
0.2658611238,
0.7533349991,
1.0491644144,
0.7667753696,
0.3456799388,
-0.1970875859,
0.4771666229,
-0.4207756221,
0.3034163713,
-0.2506938279,
-0.6427494884,
0.2151712477,
-0.2566067576,
0.714551568,
0.2971710563,
-0.2709581256,
0.5463534594,
0.3715173304,
0.7977471352,
-0.4298363924,
0.1392061263,
-0.5522175431,
0.2073956579,
-0.7466928959,
-0.4878906012,
-0.3519879282,
-0.5076289773,
-0.2826930583,
-0.6270749569,
-0.021423962,
0.0589880496,
0.9794513583,
0.668289125,
-0.1400967389,
-0.2637407482,
-0.840567708,
0.8982053399,
-0.6377695799,
0.2789098322,
0.3690260351,
0.2710674107,
-0.211642921,
-0.3190785646,
-0.5664690733,
0.1605689079,
-0.2373975515,
0.2739923,
-0.1621151119,
-0.1997488141,
0.2696106136,
0.3033836782,
-0.7378596663,
0.0126646003,
-0.5764189959,
0.1250812262,
0.295078218,
0.330752939,
0.5064807534,
-0.4261333346,
-0.5927083492,
-0.0148329539,
-0.7469312549,
-0.0457857326,
0.2202722579,
0.3957073092,
-0.1101971045,
0.7762724161,
-0.1934457719,
0.4953101575,
0.1276493371,
-0.3913135529,
0.3166075945,
-0.0404588357,
-0.3494755924,
0.0523115881,
0.6575123072,
0.2700512409,
0.233725071,
-0.2733347714,
-0.3970409632,
-0.0725714564,
-0.074971728,
-0.5946363807,
0.3811922371,
0.0383717939,
-0.4911190569,
-0.0501697324,
-0.3097320795,
-0.7662168741,
-0.4097699225,
-0.9616163969,
0.43876037,
-0.7760736346,
-0.4076551795,
-0.3255356252,
-0.0063620107,
0.3501769006,
0.3138428926,
-0.3251119554,
0.4148429036,
0.4841058254,
1.0262485743,
-0.3526330292,
-0.4229966998,
-0.31518507,
0.0790880173,
-0.5008336306,
0.5526661277,
-0.2909283042,
-0.0520176999,
-0.3380375206,
-0.3391544819,
-0.465025574,
-0.87873137,
0.5147356391,
-0.6093751788,
0.1150148883,
-0.1133029535,
-0.2696567178,
-0.53698349,
0.243926838,
-0.5346469879,
1.2649717331,
0.1958128959,
-0.9970157743,
0.1116470397,
-0.6144455075,
-0.4337915778,
0.2040166557,
-0.0777687654,
-0.3166576922,
0.0517779365,
0.3556219935,
0.4365105927,
-0.7457077503,
0.4491987824,
0.2581731677,
-0.6249233484,
0.2311154604,
-0.499645263,
0.9371108413,
0.6928997636,
-0.5217777491,
-0.2811100483,
-0.4992301464,
0.0642231554,
-0.2333606035,
-0.0735435411,
-0.6762737036,
-0.2709240913,
-0.0006865507,
0.4716835916,
-0.0134923663,
-0.6229453683,
-0.0596548766,
-0.4990701675,
0.0308119282,
0.6654555798,
0.0460438728,
0.1711184233,
-0.1451821178,
0.6105350852,
0.3133016825,
0.2092847675,
0.1751888245,
-0.2076694965,
-0.7136996984,
-0.5605655909,
0.4847337306,
0.8069897294,
-1.3019065857,
0.0370636098,
-0.4764076769,
-0.3675099015,
-1.1139246225,
0.240663901,
0.5373620987,
0.2865759432,
0.5046831369,
-0.2071607262,
-0.6962460876,
-0.8701876402,
-0.6409742236,
0.2018075436,
0.3350839615,
-0.5163965225,
0.3065496683,
-0.0375690386,
1.0213593245,
-0.1299333572,
-0.3571119606,
-0.0777153745,
0.3560019732,
0.1492495388,
0.6194414496,
0.3751660585,
-0.7760144472,
-0.8580036163,
0.5395063162,
-0.9217223525,
-0.0492133051,
-0.3147790134,
-0.1002733186,
0.3207729161,
0.4574671388,
-0.6788037419,
0.9780132771,
0.4125601649,
0.3617809117,
0.3488225639,
-0.0900522918,
0.4945338666,
-1.3630933762,
0.1794731766,
-0.0632915348,
-0.2414379865,
-0.6035524607,
0.2327184826,
0.000979378,
0.0427375622,
-0.3729759753,
0.5097973347,
-0.5537127256,
0.0700342432,
-0.2206384987,
0.002323925,
-0.4570999444,
0.4341798723,
-0.2788834274,
1.0400511026,
0.4445542991,
-0.4801960886,
0.1955389977,
0.2137090564,
-0.1678088307,
0.5944023728,
-0.256411463,
-0.1198167503,
-0.507271111,
-0.2038910985,
-0.9997905493,
0.0538182259,
0.5322277546,
-0.5763316154,
0.2872871161,
-0.2992145419,
-0.7482121587,
-0.0667328313,
-0.0388622023,
0.2257643491,
0.378590554,
-0.7709079385,
0.564537704,
0.0873203203,
-0.3787172735,
-0.9299351573,
-0.8653635979,
0.312731117,
-0.5125156045,
-0.1476759762,
-0.1132019386,
0.0197461378,
-0.2138907611,
0.0723839924,
-0.2324359268,
-0.366150558,
-0.2308207899,
0.4308656752,
0.3106665611,
-0.0377190299,
0.0936232507,
0.4514193535,
-0.3342358172,
-0.1323179007,
-0.0688561723,
0.5384462476,
0.0628850013,
-0.345440805,
-0.9203112125,
0.195535481,
0.8693526387,
-0.4908326566,
0.9331361651,
1.0014020205,
-0.3442013562,
-0.028902797,
-0.6086057425,
0.1680984646,
-0.3964281976,
0.2380492985,
-0.6938499212,
-0.3628862798,
0.5273006558,
-0.470354706,
-0.0045704595,
0.5686551332,
0.3928403854,
0.0394516885,
0.8499389291,
0.3176756799,
-0.302051723,
0.3443426192,
-0.2548693717,
0.4586538672,
-0.9150334001,
-0.230426535,
-0.7005158067,
-0.1444446892,
-0.5833206177,
-0.4261101186,
0.341735065,
0.1769097298,
0.0476801805,
0.5257669091,
-0.5979695916,
0.498629421,
0.238050729,
0.1550955027,
0.4494668841,
0.4342602193,
-0.276573509,
-0.3053596914,
-0.4935447276,
-0.4252928793,
1.1484121084,
0.055945456,
0.5507656336,
0.1019258201,
0.768905282,
0.1989361942,
0.6793143749,
-0.3671271205,
0.4328312576,
-0.2806838751,
-0.3543607295,
-0.3388132751,
-0.6226252913,
-0.6142750382,
0.6022654772,
-0.1173851788,
-0.3600829244,
0.0377887189,
-0.3405948281,
0.0421553105,
0.5594819784,
-0.6148793697,
0.3620685637,
0.0587806441,
-0.1218274012,
-0.272334516,
-0.6533837914,
0.5809122324,
-0.2642717063,
0.2332884222,
-0.0116390726,
0.0992864147,
0.6607491374,
-0.4164824486,
0.6794090867,
-0.2094497532,
0.2518969178,
0.294308424,
0.174759537,
0.589045167,
-0.071738407,
-0.2986555099,
0.1895917058,
0.1641791165,
-0.2662239373,
-0.6230071783,
0.5017420053,
-0.9883474112,
-0.1046460941,
-0.4781185687,
-0.5752620697,
0.1475337297,
0.1622645259,
0.5063644648,
0.4480741322,
-0.1026124135,
-0.0341904908,
0.5790225863,
0.1180433407,
0.4435823858,
0.3244463503,
-0.1780102253,
-0.5972338915,
0.9290136099,
0.3482200205,
0.1410879642,
0.3746337891,
-0.1659136713,
-0.2737513185,
-0.8234863281,
-0.8169128299,
0.2528852522,
-0.5763450265,
-0.5233493447,
-0.4704914689,
-0.391723454,
-0.167864114,
0.1855761111,
-0.4076139331,
-0.5337430239,
-0.127131328,
0.2400160283,
0.4842177629,
0.6040050387,
0.027005557,
0.6517643929,
-0.692278266,
0.300596565,
-0.201613903,
0.2582075298,
-0.0938029513,
-0.8407698274,
-0.3820935488,
0.0485963523,
-0.0354525894,
-0.5689530373,
0.7437628508,
-0.1504679918,
0.4978096485,
0.3202503622,
0.091187492,
1.3522043228,
-0.3114753366,
0.2284757048,
0.1861575991,
-0.9723706841,
0.22670874,
0.0116431573,
0.1592373997,
0.7479551435,
0.5253584385,
-0.9202616215,
-0.4897111654,
-0.3847647011,
-0.7140540481,
0.6545078158,
0.5282006264,
-0.304569751,
0.2503172159,
0.5913662314,
0.4291712344,
0.1989743114,
-0.4578873217,
-0.4893910289,
0.0869731009,
-0.5364390016,
-0.0073775672,
0.2756075859,
-0.1186416596,
-0.3507319689,
0.7871001363,
0.1824499071,
-0.0859242529,
0.1519263238,
-0.5386217237,
-0.3377850652,
0.3660181761,
0.2589681447,
0.5060958862,
-0.0333854444,
0.0175734982,
0.3775147796,
-0.8322518468,
0.1490123719,
0.0934519544,
-0.5211415291,
0.3424570262,
0.0086781802,
0.5726193786,
-0.3863307834,
-0.4455809295,
0.3079046011,
0.0229940284,
0.271591574,
-0.3337246776,
-0.3841602206,
-0.1800049841,
-0.0862135515,
0.2962667644,
0.8506715894,
0.0897328258,
0.0971774459,
0.0412173457,
0.0663543642,
-0.4020458162,
-0.2032333016,
0.2799872756,
-0.1401191056,
-0.1431898326,
0.6550835371,
-0.2045829892,
-0.397564888,
0.3501746655,
0.5598728657,
0.9343298078,
-0.7636955976,
0.2120026499,
0.5186084509,
0.6903924942,
-0.2788030207,
0.2052081227,
0.151693508,
-0.276578933,
-0.6255473495,
-0.5630170107,
-0.068856962,
0.0213358793,
-0.9419770837,
0.184110865,
-0.2671497464,
-0.0826500952,
-0.280533433,
-0.0929295942,
-0.7977206707,
0.1589960009,
-0.3648700714,
0.6071038842,
-1.1536835432,
0.8450382352,
0.6939213872,
-0.4753925502,
-0.6957094669,
-0.0476556197,
0.1700082272,
-0.4716545045,
0.6972634792,
-0.1955120564,
-0.266975373,
-0.0437596142,
-0.4023365974,
-1.1105331182,
0.9202699661,
0.4415457547,
-0.4263814986,
0.3534771204,
0.6314391494,
0.6069565415,
-0.1299227625,
0.2851656973,
0.5368588567,
0.5361388326,
-0.106515184,
-1.0208160877,
0.0286611691,
-0.2838829458,
0.3398142755,
0.4480603337,
-0.4761142135,
0.8300128579,
0.2375032455,
-0.4163132608,
0.3087377846,
0.6395971179,
0.0986791924,
0.2213897556,
0.4300017357,
0.6758683324,
0.6952427626,
0.0509300977,
0.6341037154,
-0.1274691969,
0.3098214269,
1.0606697798,
-0.0773558766,
0.8695940375,
0.8897706866,
-0.0737896562,
0.2596365213,
0.4995489717,
0.3472647071,
0.3853061199,
0.1891862601,
-0.2551290393,
0.0202072747,
-0.1197671592,
-0.4020756185,
0.4766952097,
0.4063317478,
-0.0985224023,
-0.4689666927,
0.4723962247,
0.3343784511,
0.313713789,
-0.1716580838,
0.6455626488,
-0.0946258008,
-0.6644864082,
0.866656065,
0.1803485304,
0.500582099,
-0.3966822028,
-0.1149461716,
-0.458858639,
0.2760959566,
-0.3487166464,
-0.5449540019,
0.4807487428,
0.2322877496,
-0.1625038534,
-0.2033361048,
0.4014194012,
-0.6603064537,
-0.3612101376,
0.0216484945,
0.7076022625,
0.5391603112,
0.0449798852,
-0.6510116458,
0.069880873,
0.2166450769,
0.0001447032,
0.40903759,
0.7124061584,
-0.408495158,
0.801155448,
0.6320108771,
0.3753477633,
0.219397217,
-0.1422779709,
0.8709420562,
-0.6579958797,
-0.3989834487,
-0.4984319508,
0.3010511398,
-0.0779233947,
-0.3879245818,
0.8744372725,
0.8942315578,
0.7470383644,
-0.0750392675,
0.7688853145,
-0.0075332308,
0.8860926032,
-0.429715842,
0.6799198985,
-0.2983693182,
0.4421182871,
-0.2653060257,
-0.8404077291,
-0.3762454093,
0.3291044831,
-0.1439968795,
-0.2989444435,
0.9476405382,
0.9799568653,
-0.1524339467,
0.15891321,
0.1752983481,
0.2845988274,
0.0466857627,
0.1645388305,
0.8637611866,
-0.7920385599,
0.6427189708,
-0.2645111978,
-0.3159180582,
0.119642511,
-0.4390245378,
-0.74426651,
-0.7759721279,
-0.218996942,
-0.1967255771,
0.3545576632,
1.0638462305,
0.3784425557,
-0.7016358972,
-0.472322315,
0.2670092583,
0.0854603723,
-0.7300819159,
-0.1894748658,
0.775123179,
-0.3823718727,
-0.7594584823,
0.2766775787,
0.3410829604,
-0.0784956515,
0.0740530491,
0.0178087093,
-0.2608680427,
-0.194151625,
0.5002677441,
0.2479326576,
-0.7857967019,
0.0803095624,
-0.2477111816,
-0.2919515669,
0.3587062657,
0.5792342424,
-0.717691958,
0.5367696285,
0.4327430129,
0.8230180144,
0.5807276368,
0.1376059204,
0.2190155685,
-0.7009887695,
0.2680904865,
0.0196315981,
-0.0602572113,
0.4086865783,
-0.4958001375,
0.6326041222,
0.2202216238,
-0.1892820001,
-0.8079842925,
-0.3050491512,
-0.7635253668,
-0.1200441867,
0.8820727468,
0.0082373563,
-0.484269321,
-0.4455998838,
-0.379671216,
0.5937390327,
-0.2400160879,
0.7905753851,
0.4963016212,
0.0636752471,
-0.0278359633,
-0.8446697593,
0.4568199515,
0.544605732,
-0.7834683657,
0.1333931237,
-0.0199934114,
0.4127327502,
0.1013938412,
0.4774796069,
-0.4770696163,
0.1193749309,
-0.1588436216,
0.4366073906,
-0.0952264443,
-0.2549854517,
-0.5303953886,
-0.0292909238,
-0.1606124938,
-0.4782581925
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06394v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06394v1
|
Adaptive Data Augmentation for Aspect Sentiment Quad Prediction
| 2024-01-12T06:20:56 | 2024-01-12T06:20:56 |
Wenyuan Zhang, Xinghua Zhang, Shiyao Cui, Kun Huang, Xuebin Wang, Tingwen Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Aspect sentiment quad prediction (ASQP) aims to predict the quad sentiment
elements for a given sentence, which is a critical task in the field of
aspect-based sentiment analysis. However, the data imbalance issue has not
received sufficient attention in ASQP task. In this paper, we divide the issue
into two-folds, quad-pattern imbalance and aspect-category imbalance, and
propose an Adaptive Data Augmentation (ADA) framework to tackle the imbalance
issue. Specifically, a data augmentation process with a condition function
adaptively enhances the tail quad patterns and aspect categories, alleviating
the data imbalance in ASQP. Following previous studies, we also further explore
the generative framework for extracting complete quads by introducing the
category prior knowledge and syntax-guided decoding target. Experimental
results demonstrate that data augmentation for imbalance in ASQP task can
improve the performance, and the proposed ADA method is superior to naive data
oversampling.
|
[
-0.4866260588,
-0.6487351656,
0.298325181,
0.6014873385,
-0.4394667745,
0.5881847739,
0.4193300009,
-0.33288908,
0.4426678419,
0.5338459611,
-0.6650515199,
-0.469050318,
-0.4157054722,
0.1549520344,
-0.2254763842,
0.9246473908,
0.1167167127,
0.173330009,
-0.6675646305,
-0.584425807,
-0.817502439,
-0.8342681527,
-0.7649629712,
-0.0950773209,
-0.2060226947,
0.6808545589,
0.5922665,
0.2774946094,
0.2803963423,
0.217441529,
-0.1395762563,
0.4160292447,
0.0351458639,
0.1551466137,
-0.0172250737,
-0.4867053032,
-0.7960349321,
-0.3371807635,
0.7550178766,
0.6918902993,
-0.0597139001,
-0.0428575389,
0.2578481734,
1.2088909149,
-0.5815919638,
0.1581206918,
-0.5034003854,
-0.0417724401,
0.0849685967,
-0.3305728734,
0.0362860374,
-0.1085445881,
-0.2760595381,
-0.5700981021,
0.1510558277,
0.6947529912,
0.4262384772,
0.1868186295,
-0.4412508011,
0.0830594152,
-0.4776253998,
0.6163697839,
-0.7391575575,
0.1425920576,
0.267800957,
-0.1463343054,
-0.0743290335,
-0.2533019185,
-0.8067448139,
0.169339329,
0.1317220181,
0.2099977881,
-0.4635133147,
0.1802824736,
0.3744158745,
0.869027257,
-0.3763146698,
-0.0746205822,
-0.2570248842,
-0.0887710303,
0.6030879021,
0.3713676929,
0.3494997025,
-0.33032161,
-0.4186793566,
0.1129830405,
-0.67323035,
0.4505239427,
0.4747158587,
0.0799162462,
-0.1729576737,
0.6675752997,
-0.6026400328,
0.5697512031,
0.4752531648,
0.5377990007,
0.8486726284,
-0.4665178657,
-0.2009747773,
0.1099965274,
0.5538362265,
0.7697284818,
-0.2007047236,
0.2152051777,
-0.2836775184,
-0.0287560485,
0.4452140331,
-0.5125841498,
-0.2523845732,
0.4891886711,
-0.2717594802,
-0.2462763786,
-0.272846967,
-0.9495909214,
-0.5929820538,
-0.2379132509,
0.4126091599,
-0.6577864885,
-0.3187912703,
0.1333442479,
-0.0000541611,
0.152142778,
0.2080267668,
-0.8229860067,
0.3556705415,
0.8442574143,
1.0685560703,
-0.2851726115,
-0.052522365,
-0.8927269578,
-0.3473209739,
-0.34721753,
0.9625612497,
-0.7926695347,
-0.4636306763,
-0.1182463095,
0.0623844229,
0.0302866679,
-0.3644728661,
0.8190464377,
-0.4164074957,
0.1177174076,
-0.3590930104,
-0.3669139743,
-0.6260771751,
0.4668067098,
-0.7865348458,
0.8659512401,
0.3992396593,
-0.9941385388,
0.4992642999,
-0.6089338064,
-0.5256729722,
0.008009091,
0.0452106856,
-0.8794689775,
0.2732998431,
0.9318768978,
0.045516327,
-0.100449957,
-0.4827124774,
-0.4576920271,
-0.2141135782,
0.3322035074,
-0.1785019785,
0.7395179272,
-0.0380295329,
0.0810600147,
0.3435808122,
-0.7239095569,
0.0843786523,
-0.3965352178,
-0.1985087544,
-0.4622608423,
0.2197890133,
-0.1186663881,
0.1026775315,
0.0568382032,
-0.7028382421,
0.446762681,
-0.8773991466,
0.2190822661,
0.662025094,
0.3803044558,
0.5722019076,
-0.3836686909,
0.8296651244,
0.5650866032,
0.0257598404,
-0.1297077537,
-0.2985707223,
-0.9020341635,
-0.0682943463,
0.4126169086,
0.4932461977,
-1.2298709154,
0.3899507523,
-0.3375643194,
0.044691354,
-0.9761396646,
0.1662816852,
0.248161599,
0.2596678436,
0.6189107299,
-0.726510942,
-0.5933001637,
-0.5327338576,
-0.1947610229,
-0.215197131,
0.124085106,
0.0514674038,
-0.0731474757,
-0.04553473,
0.7351539135,
-0.5137224197,
-0.4707867503,
-0.1991630495,
0.4141186774,
0.0169660468,
0.5978582501,
0.5842949152,
-0.8696855307,
-0.3712652326,
-0.1526002586,
-0.1552966088,
-0.1520888358,
0.0120942239,
-0.004013319,
0.5007692575,
0.3698778152,
-0.4220378101,
0.2618229091,
0.5262734294,
-0.7236294746,
0.3653542399,
-0.1041569486,
0.3808437884,
-1.1950577497,
-0.3285970986,
0.1744732857,
-0.3431430757,
-0.4408002198,
-0.0425337404,
0.1135395616,
0.0987726748,
-0.0058433567,
0.0726677626,
-0.3737260997,
-0.1978810728,
-0.6465196609,
-0.4764466286,
0.3213838637,
0.4828045666,
-0.0075891851,
0.607714653,
0.842582047,
-0.4226800203,
0.554966867,
0.2791976929,
-0.2619851828,
0.8897940516,
-0.3657570183,
0.0574978702,
-0.403226465,
0.1427878141,
-1.1102032661,
0.145410046,
0.4382581711,
-0.8195667863,
0.4274094403,
-0.1809106618,
-0.116311647,
-0.3023431599,
-0.6831250787,
0.5758655667,
0.2986235321,
-0.4319024086,
0.8274841309,
0.372733891,
-0.5127170682,
-0.6082997322,
-0.177785337,
0.0146793239,
-0.3614864647,
-0.3717542887,
0.3326574266,
-0.0260120388,
-0.1065095812,
0.1003641114,
-0.2783763409,
0.1535732895,
0.019675564,
0.5012976527,
0.2480301559,
-0.3005725443,
0.0547793023,
0.1730947345,
-0.1939723641,
0.2788424492,
-0.0675355271,
0.4726814926,
-0.0090833995,
-0.1904624104,
-0.1156618893,
0.5099565983,
0.5884746909,
-0.3040015399,
0.4160395861,
0.5894256234,
-0.2279219925,
-0.1418842971,
-0.2935381234,
0.1524145305,
-0.4236843884,
0.4518946707,
-0.4116167724,
-0.5136502981,
0.3304618001,
0.2430530041,
0.1285561323,
0.4269471169,
0.2911601961,
-0.1131618172,
1.6254315376,
0.8738293052,
-0.5705375075,
0.588794589,
-0.1524471343,
0.24136585,
-1.2322052717,
-0.098882556,
-0.2142169476,
-0.2652606368,
-0.4460325539,
-0.3846708536,
0.5235112309,
0.1294857711,
-0.0735764354,
-0.2351739854,
-0.5265690684,
-0.0716975406,
0.6752181053,
0.2345869094,
0.4183551967,
0.1806954294,
0.5358294249,
-0.0051967651,
-0.2847195864,
0.0898976177,
1.0731356144,
0.3472830951,
0.5884473324,
0.1305475533,
0.182783708,
0.7093417645,
0.022466898,
-1.0583122969,
0.1856558621,
-0.2988178134,
-0.0527246706,
-0.0984756947,
-0.2635695934,
-0.5136085749,
0.1596321911,
-0.6512844563,
-0.3577136099,
0.4429964721,
0.2987753749,
-0.6219441295,
-0.178790018,
-0.3852781355,
0.5253596306,
-0.1076060161,
-0.0587382577,
-0.4124060869,
-0.4004540741,
0.2021895051,
-0.1609822214,
0.2746383548,
-0.2469368577,
-0.0448898599,
0.7177683115,
-0.6204904318,
0.5136070848,
-0.409107089,
0.309676528,
0.3500241041,
-0.2130742967,
0.4372343719,
0.0691962391,
-0.2008064538,
-0.0428333282,
0.0825999454,
-0.5236419439,
-0.638653934,
0.5328957438,
-0.7571240067,
-0.5913628936,
-0.5735477209,
-0.5113372803,
-0.6164739132,
-0.163416639,
0.1810357273,
0.357503593,
0.15891321,
0.2225937992,
0.2470176071,
0.0631190091,
0.4629536569,
0.6509447694,
-0.1300554425,
-0.5358570218,
1.1678022146,
-0.0994748026,
0.1837750971,
0.2939673066,
-0.0390677527,
-0.3290776014,
-0.853502214,
-0.748503983,
-0.3028192818,
-0.4888535738,
-0.5525507927,
-0.7538138628,
-0.1510676295,
-0.4528857172,
0.0329316817,
-0.0910939351,
-0.6299308538,
-0.2164845616,
-0.2294236124,
0.8366482258,
0.2326399833,
0.0129423253,
0.4955902696,
-0.7107616663,
0.5255122185,
0.1259140968,
0.1327348948,
-0.2817661166,
-0.6835924387,
-0.1974823922,
0.3552615345,
-0.5911044478,
-0.5682598352,
0.6995033622,
0.3643758893,
0.1544779539,
0.1661820859,
0.2095399499,
0.7155284882,
-0.1289998889,
0.7853684425,
0.2423648238,
-1.058067441,
0.3231851459,
0.0189015735,
0.1950756013,
0.3913486302,
0.1789456904,
-0.3464787304,
-0.417406857,
-0.4603743255,
-1.1516355276,
0.9124897122,
0.0587524772,
0.2944792509,
0.4173838794,
0.4228490293,
-0.0065845908,
0.3110519946,
-0.7216427326,
-0.2051761299,
-0.524553299,
-0.510900259,
-0.0867787376,
-0.3534389734,
0.1671070904,
-0.36966905,
0.8190500736,
-0.4504420459,
0.1164464355,
-0.006907579,
0.0610156432,
-0.4602167606,
0.1898436099,
-0.1261447072,
0.3850977421,
-0.140701279,
-0.1020519137,
0.1758475304,
-0.630168438,
0.1300118715,
0.3043254912,
-0.1999815851,
-0.2957499027,
0.1310857832,
0.9978045225,
-0.2398334593,
-0.5168287754,
0.7332111001,
0.1258099675,
0.0826424658,
-0.3127389252,
0.2397708744,
-0.2356974483,
0.4431578815,
0.4720388353,
0.1724348366,
0.5401463509,
-0.7085139155,
0.1375546902,
0.668990612,
-0.5763663054,
-0.2943812311,
0.4925599992,
0.1582337469,
-0.0143049182,
0.5644613504,
-0.309348911,
-0.593791306,
0.6178047061,
0.4724777341,
0.83050102,
-0.3658607602,
0.1921242177,
0.2120628208,
0.1080002487,
0.0450206771,
0.6979682446,
-0.0246413238,
-0.8314786553,
-0.591673255,
-0.9393009543,
-0.4483386874,
0.0589464307,
-0.7933074832,
0.3892216086,
-0.4780115783,
0.0400321521,
0.1916206777,
0.2155327499,
-0.2360422313,
0.5415716171,
0.1260505915,
0.4195622206,
-1.0526969433,
0.6303070784,
1.0129015446,
-0.4796963334,
-0.4508719146,
0.2935310602,
-0.1551266015,
-0.8797604442,
-0.0453090593,
0.2063011974,
0.0923939496,
0.1319763362,
-0.366748929,
-0.8970995545,
0.7219877839,
-0.1346948147,
-0.2782338262,
0.1047554761,
-0.0110332118,
0.4698924124,
-0.6301879883,
-0.1334631443,
0.6644464731,
0.1664773077,
0.3724020422,
-0.5022665262,
0.2053037584,
-0.3762331009,
-0.0797583312,
0.3552898765,
-0.4347490966,
0.8506502509,
-0.1535360962,
-0.0192112159,
-0.0730968043,
1.0054460764,
-0.0096100122,
0.5452728271,
0.7848213911,
0.5029727817,
0.3541295826,
0.061811965,
0.6002846956,
-0.2515341938,
0.1359847635,
0.8305576444,
-0.0903511643,
0.8331424594,
0.2310397178,
-0.354447484,
0.6053658724,
0.7960398197,
0.0905168131,
0.6186017394,
-0.2042684853,
-0.4607539773,
-0.3112860024,
0.0040386426,
-0.2285941988,
0.6326887012,
0.7849938273,
-0.1930749416,
0.2138038725,
0.2678224742,
-0.2010406554,
-0.0908642188,
-1.0137532949,
1.0619083643,
-0.0217923131,
-0.6738705635,
0.4372614324,
0.1273387671,
0.567311883,
0.0822449178,
-0.1453726441,
-0.1685389578,
0.0584633239,
-0.5825791955,
-0.9700319767,
0.4578448236,
-0.3758045733,
-0.4978519082,
0.2026004642,
0.641841352,
-0.4790783525,
-0.827994287,
-0.2119591683,
0.2956351042,
-0.2592356205,
-0.5698075891,
-0.7255140543,
-0.0313275903,
0.2538567483,
-0.1146080196,
0.1472280174,
0.4758539498,
-0.2564336061,
0.5169618726,
0.4080516696,
0.1473218948,
-0.2748886943,
-0.1432686746,
1.0779496431,
-0.6944403052,
-0.7319939733,
-0.7874397635,
0.5232016444,
-0.2015213817,
-0.0576157607,
0.6797173619,
0.5686259866,
0.3026155233,
0.3699770272,
1.0200945139,
-0.1023929119,
0.8254306912,
-0.7282332778,
0.2224906683,
-0.7020121217,
0.4265362024,
-0.2186112106,
-0.8855662346,
-0.1719475985,
0.3156267405,
-0.314756006,
-0.0712265894,
0.5345435739,
0.6484586596,
-0.0747754201,
0.2031489462,
-0.0504987836,
0.3267535567,
0.1010440812,
0.4683010876,
0.6579771042,
-0.291703403,
0.2783221006,
-0.2946345508,
-0.2941341102,
-0.423885107,
-0.6359664798,
-0.6335653067,
-0.7776065469,
-0.5285190344,
-0.6109905839,
-0.0682002977,
0.845400393,
0.2440690696,
-0.8564896584,
0.3631442189,
-0.2280508727,
0.3363222778,
-0.4914468527,
-0.2773658633,
0.4667520821,
-0.3569800854,
-0.7763997912,
0.1577657014,
0.3924679756,
-0.034594588,
-0.1126820967,
0.219194591,
0.2029829621,
0.0449047387,
0.7351924777,
0.3360324502,
-0.2467593998,
-0.4276967049,
-0.2265761495,
0.3636271358,
0.5290508866,
0.7540565729,
-0.8900463581,
0.7220582962,
0.4663167,
0.4302011728,
0.2781220078,
0.8157826066,
0.8673341274,
-0.9377510548,
0.0646008477,
0.3806007504,
0.3878603876,
0.5992918015,
-0.605874598,
0.1011851653,
0.1958408207,
-0.4037193954,
-0.6740068793,
0.0128824702,
-1.0427788496,
-0.1624320447,
1.2225456238,
0.0608524382,
-0.2014369369,
-0.3977720737,
-0.4590008557,
0.0107181491,
-0.5116726756,
0.852232933,
0.3857153058,
-0.4640711248,
-0.2800726891,
-0.2418982536,
0.7031199932,
0.562096417,
-0.7750788927,
0.1057515368,
0.8856495023,
0.1588405371,
-0.0121774636,
0.7123572826,
0.1399523616,
0.4038994908,
-0.0159753654,
0.0982510224,
-0.0559516251,
-0.049913004,
-0.5675067902,
0.1304331124,
0.3746078312,
-0.7265194058
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06382v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06382v1
|
What should I say? -- Interacting with AI and Natural Language Interfaces
| 2024-01-12T05:10:23 | 2024-01-12T05:10:23 |
Mark Adkins
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.m; J.4; B.4.2
|
As Artificial Intelligence (AI) technology becomes more and more prevalent,
it becomes increasingly important to explore how we as humans interact with AI.
The Human-AI Interaction (HAI) sub-field has emerged from the Human-Computer
Interaction (HCI) field and aims to examine this very notion. Many interaction
patterns have been implemented without fully understanding the changes in
required cognition as well as the cognitive science implications of using these
alternative interfaces that aim to be more human-like in nature. Prior research
suggests that theory of mind representations are crucial to successful and
effortless communication, however very little is understood when it comes to
how theory of mind representations are established when interacting with AI.
|
[
-0.7211342454,
-0.9371240735,
0.6631644368,
0.1460892409,
0.0762899369,
-0.0382834598,
-0.307053864,
-1.0177474022,
0.2923493683,
-0.0295794308,
-0.702960968,
-0.1355523318,
-0.3198046982,
-0.0078720851,
-0.1850123852,
0.7167332172,
0.2184939384,
0.0996406674,
-0.4592135549,
-0.0958047584,
-0.9885419607,
-0.6873509884,
-0.9376400709,
-0.7101521492,
0.2830599248,
0.2608461678,
0.8011775613,
0.4932923019,
0.5900321007,
0.4494560063,
0.0599415265,
-0.1394671947,
0.1069452763,
0.0059738457,
-0.2009519637,
-0.7530122399,
-0.4382289946,
0.5261254907,
0.2783985436,
0.7706483006,
0.014978,
0.2279464304,
0.0661125705,
0.5294085145,
-0.4157201648,
0.2809453309,
-0.0690141171,
0.3143697083,
-0.2854982018,
-0.3401048779,
-0.1980356574,
-0.2063850313,
0.4024142921,
-0.7345907688,
-0.3354921639,
0.3110158145,
0.7003657818,
0.3404867351,
-0.4051341116,
-0.1395763606,
-1.1410758495,
0.8336269855,
-0.7681244016,
0.3083305657,
0.9046696424,
0.4303544462,
0.0141231492,
-0.5370814204,
-1.0676836967,
-0.4348259866,
-0.3721031845,
0.3195285797,
-0.3701772392,
0.5159752965,
0.3242417276,
0.2173748612,
-0.1686412245,
-0.0417012349,
-0.3366072476,
-0.1112778261,
0.9082712531,
0.1977759749,
0.6853086352,
0.0412743501,
0.1218491346,
0.1501371413,
-0.2676662803,
0.2084675729,
0.3316344917,
-0.0405196436,
-0.3145488501,
0.6256194711,
0.0014623849,
0.7963440418,
0.3185722232,
0.1659672409,
-0.0990816727,
-0.3041011095,
-0.2236992568,
-0.107183516,
0.7039966583,
0.7938363552,
0.347491622,
-0.1026447341,
0.2919464111,
0.2958159149,
0.374574542,
-0.1603287011,
-0.202274099,
0.3233539462,
-0.5642444491,
-0.2330140918,
0.0588771999,
-0.6925572157,
-0.6564645171,
-0.5883482099,
0.5076545477,
-0.1993038654,
-0.4862897396,
-0.2451487184,
-0.2311706543,
0.4384416044,
0.1889879405,
-1.0001788139,
0.4013638496,
0.6067987084,
0.2851132751,
0.0655888468,
-0.3919438124,
-0.1826906055,
0.1998522431,
-0.6504758596,
0.8497582078,
-0.6364526749,
-0.6778694987,
-0.0338857546,
-0.3017362952,
-0.1274233162,
-0.419930011,
0.3994043469,
-0.0236368645,
0.649118185,
-0.4355623722,
-0.6173641086,
-0.3423253894,
0.3457420468,
-0.6310293078,
0.5416585803,
0.0410216302,
-0.7997626662,
-0.0125787426,
-1.214720726,
-0.6630558968,
0.4310005605,
-0.6130350828,
0.283716023,
-0.1289325804,
-0.250215739,
0.1874917448,
-0.2152681649,
0.2195537686,
-0.1524305344,
-0.2774600983,
0.6334116459,
-0.2869258225,
0.4887207747,
0.1671775728,
-0.5805205107,
0.2262984961,
-0.3526116312,
0.1874191016,
-0.3752231598,
-0.3809942305,
-0.3612726331,
0.2909480333,
-0.0835006908,
0.0193520896,
0.456825465,
-0.7261961102,
0.0683949813,
-0.6530992389,
0.8531436324,
0.4356378317,
-0.0476546064,
0.7381895781,
-0.4682202935,
0.2197422832,
0.0318424627,
0.0695836544,
0.2398536354,
-0.592287302,
-0.808903873,
0.3234312236,
0.0139118256,
0.687802434,
-0.6594694257,
0.4188415408,
0.0104911802,
-0.1400093734,
-0.8403155804,
-0.0056498791,
0.3750165701,
0.7144406438,
0.3167457879,
0.0426660068,
-0.8471517563,
-1.2742000818,
-0.437689662,
-0.7392153144,
0.1008368209,
0.4836425781,
0.2288302034,
-0.4536506236,
1.2945184708,
-0.3447674811,
-0.3079761863,
-0.509898901,
0.3626720011,
-0.216693148,
0.5474491119,
0.3397070765,
-1.0157290697,
-0.4049497843,
0.2827861905,
-0.8951356411,
0.4055731595,
0.0200863238,
-0.1780061275,
0.2288961411,
0.6566537023,
-0.7291606665,
0.6546393037,
0.1898341775,
-0.1397260427,
0.0818018839,
-0.2172605246,
0.4430506527,
-0.9954514503,
0.2079414129,
0.2638686597,
-0.0472979434,
-1.0860331059,
-0.0745635331,
-0.3951924443,
-0.2500426769,
-0.5506865382,
0.6924297214,
-0.1705847234,
0.1602571309,
-0.3429920673,
-0.1114982218,
-0.0685036406,
0.4289698303,
0.1711404622,
1.2003499269,
0.6840495467,
-0.8316393495,
0.3074138165,
0.4999868572,
-0.2091496438,
0.8521667719,
-0.7497134209,
0.128903389,
-0.3120532632,
0.10127002,
-0.6216896772,
-0.5605234504,
0.4616702199,
-0.7678925991,
0.0249725934,
0.5317870975,
-0.1805775464,
-0.5843743086,
-0.3184847534,
0.3674440682,
0.4658658803,
-0.0229690745,
1.0015203953,
0.9879139066,
-0.0479397811,
-0.2744915485,
-1.1641179323,
0.2064123154,
-0.3748984039,
-0.4846651256,
0.3634221852,
-0.3746035099,
-0.847853303,
-0.1152274311,
0.307390213,
-0.4777539074,
0.2046888769,
0.4592386186,
0.2007135153,
-0.1900858879,
0.1908643991,
-0.1355799735,
-0.1976233721,
0.304892689,
0.2618994415,
0.4308469296,
-0.502645731,
-0.2499410659,
-1.1708244085,
0.6797104478,
0.5983715653,
0.0299129169,
0.4730376303,
0.4585064948,
-0.5997265577,
0.6799888611,
-0.4950104654,
-0.0375700556,
-0.4912793636,
0.3136121631,
-0.1235139966,
-0.7459719777,
0.2024818957,
-0.0635598153,
0.0523860939,
0.4093595445,
0.4008851647,
-1.0593857765,
1.3937087059,
1.1197149754,
-0.5483490229,
0.3857248127,
-0.0909046829,
0.5360606909,
-0.9883648157,
-0.2378802299,
-0.2113490701,
-0.5327216387,
-0.6523364782,
-0.1333666593,
0.3294861317,
-0.2428273857,
-0.3095959425,
0.3368622959,
-0.3223492801,
0.192421928,
0.7823013663,
-0.0256798901,
0.1906357408,
-0.4372998178,
0.6475686431,
-0.0454460308,
-0.4314316511,
-0.4231679142,
0.3839037418,
0.3930635154,
0.7208864093,
0.2008270621,
0.6319390535,
0.6718283296,
0.2622662783,
-0.799885273,
0.6462762952,
0.1737285852,
-0.6040010452,
-0.4096111357,
0.1138940305,
-1.0994250774,
-0.3103538752,
-0.4731837511,
-0.9862933755,
0.1133593991,
0.3681885302,
-0.5583688021,
0.1789645255,
-0.8577373624,
0.5397191048,
-0.0212201122,
0.1695444584,
-0.5775079131,
-0.6693643928,
0.4032421112,
0.537931025,
0.4551748335,
-0.004139802,
0.0662174225,
0.8975212574,
-0.1378082931,
0.9914330244,
0.159821853,
-0.0679383427,
0.6725242734,
-0.2196689695,
0.0434501171,
-0.0575190932,
-0.0527755469,
-0.0362224691,
0.1328558028,
-0.1332617253,
-0.729894042,
0.4155646265,
-1.0003525019,
-0.9737766981,
-0.3641497493,
-0.5502240062,
-0.3396944404,
0.0938247144,
0.3397077024,
0.3067074418,
-0.4027211368,
-0.339261502,
0.4989130795,
-0.0927152932,
0.5703426003,
0.1006311104,
0.0242451243,
0.0214710142,
1.2976472378,
-0.1612137705,
-0.0511945114,
0.3368737996,
0.1101888418,
-0.2874313891,
-0.0697539821,
-0.3183405399,
0.2293468565,
-0.6274262667,
0.1450568587,
-0.4607402384,
-0.5830562115,
-0.4047502875,
-0.0029893348,
0.2085144371,
-0.0843976289,
-0.2744598985,
-0.0679270998,
0.3645777404,
1.0386912823,
-0.1944224685,
0.5522205234,
-0.7137197256,
0.1520605236,
0.6693609357,
0.3950026929,
0.139426887,
0.0358528234,
-0.3293775916,
0.3274879754,
-0.2772627175,
-0.8847581744,
0.1133010685,
0.3407767117,
0.7590300441,
0.3225737214,
-0.0973770395,
0.6914483905,
-0.3730454743,
0.8816141486,
0.0662945285,
-1.0486427546,
0.7494206429,
-0.3126272559,
0.2023995668,
0.6819791198,
0.3890231848,
-0.8810659051,
-0.4063400626,
-0.7883096933,
-0.5225530863,
0.4176484048,
0.0127450554,
0.3284076452,
-0.0319340043,
0.2442905903,
-0.3086892962,
0.5355937481,
-0.7383341193,
-0.56765908,
0.1085290983,
-0.2896578312,
0.2003176808,
0.0119012669,
-0.4983522594,
-0.4208773375,
0.251910001,
0.0626496002,
0.7273319364,
0.0732072145,
0.160053879,
-0.1910218596,
0.3035007715,
0.502703011,
0.6898373961,
0.1962165385,
0.1714739203,
0.1224246249,
-0.5044049621,
-0.1269974113,
-0.1592515111,
0.0610093251,
-0.3171720505,
0.4581723809,
0.6784938574,
-0.218635276,
-0.774520874,
0.3960030079,
-0.1814103723,
-0.058989618,
-0.2674198747,
0.4372857213,
0.2001212686,
0.2472557724,
0.2484160215,
0.2611731589,
0.3790353239,
-1.0626077652,
0.146149233,
0.5565817952,
-0.767690897,
-0.2714140713,
0.3781016171,
0.6774638891,
-0.7936475277,
0.6670073271,
0.1882036328,
-0.47685197,
0.5747200251,
0.0588372201,
0.9163973927,
0.0079622753,
0.1323869526,
0.2670565546,
-0.0500503741,
0.3962718248,
0.3916464746,
-0.3937605321,
-0.5853399038,
-0.2545896471,
-0.0616554879,
-0.6067807078,
0.1310754269,
-0.6894567609,
-0.0287799463,
-0.4483400583,
-0.5027427077,
0.0368152522,
-0.0565291457,
-0.5831769705,
0.4193893969,
0.4510750771,
0.7262193561,
-0.727057457,
0.6184209585,
0.8659247756,
-0.5127581954,
-0.6678644419,
0.258055836,
-0.0325042047,
-0.6435510516,
0.4520634413,
0.0684099793,
-0.0966990441,
0.3043645918,
-0.646573782,
-0.8160583377,
0.8511922359,
-0.1179977208,
-0.249371618,
0.0275807846,
0.1726185828,
0.6327561736,
-0.3281217515,
0.4214870036,
0.9131540656,
0.811907351,
-0.4965105951,
-0.8181432486,
-0.2451089472,
-0.5565137267,
0.1470795423,
-0.093226172,
-0.7380617857,
0.5012993217,
-0.2082491517,
-0.5641211867,
0.2922647595,
1.1404526234,
-0.1080422848,
0.3135912716,
0.456710726,
0.2445752025,
0.8107677698,
-0.0289840102,
0.9825355411,
-0.5458738208,
-0.2746322155,
0.8451461792,
-0.0881707296,
0.8018221855,
0.4498621523,
-0.2848207355,
0.5888100863,
0.8216085434,
0.2985852361,
0.2652271986,
-0.018909594,
-0.4617831409,
-0.1004282311,
-0.4950662553,
-0.497938484,
0.258831352,
0.528983593,
0.2235041261,
0.0777961612,
0.4094395638,
-0.358433336,
0.3061430454,
-0.233008936,
1.0637421608,
0.0144047989,
-0.941889286,
0.0355580822,
-0.0007614719,
0.8510166407,
-0.3450187147,
-0.2948315144,
-0.01215652,
-0.3028373718,
-0.2322793454,
-1.2176221609,
0.537165761,
-0.1197377145,
-0.4106464982,
-0.0552814938,
0.7056370378,
-0.5221685767,
-0.1837483346,
0.1253910512,
0.501655817,
0.2993472219,
0.3353098631,
-0.737601459,
0.0866777673,
-0.1636676192,
0.0475929789,
0.4941292107,
-0.0448308326,
-0.1476479322,
0.9354740381,
0.4243651032,
-0.0184027366,
-0.0948191732,
0.028990224,
0.7518465519,
-0.7795584798,
-0.3065223396,
-0.7398245335,
0.5755432248,
-0.226581499,
-0.3798328936,
0.3876677454,
0.1380986124,
0.3425006866,
0.1063588783,
1.1654200554,
-0.5449991822,
0.3052454591,
-0.1322554052,
0.8823568821,
-0.313370347,
-0.0470976196,
-0.0365110375,
-0.6152783036,
0.3553497791,
0.7815227509,
-0.2754844427,
0.124819532,
0.6417300701,
0.3657313287,
0.3691108525,
0.3687345982,
0.3470205963,
0.2860574424,
0.1912950724,
0.3234961927,
0.8692946434,
-0.2617483735,
0.1436078101,
-0.2541804016,
-0.3122119904,
0.1034465879,
-0.5926604867,
-0.6139063835,
-0.9747344851,
-0.4138836861,
-0.1703919768,
0.0265743248,
0.8644710183,
0.6992088556,
-0.5751094222,
-0.520632863,
-0.1963014156,
0.1750546843,
-0.1834724247,
-0.2590762377,
-0.0185263269,
-0.3558351696,
-1.1174248457,
0.3207134306,
0.4055573046,
0.3808590174,
-0.5981611609,
-0.0290743746,
-0.3826100826,
0.0786962807,
0.5481871367,
0.8401607275,
-0.7665422559,
-0.3514584601,
-0.215909943,
-0.2722868621,
0.1278748959,
0.7340816259,
-0.9561208487,
0.3178390861,
0.2299584597,
0.7876829505,
-0.0460522063,
0.1914036274,
1.109369874,
-0.1911363006,
0.1582123041,
0.3734713793,
0.0478831455,
0.3626402915,
-0.7890588641,
0.2983289063,
0.0709587261,
-0.3698122501,
-0.5061626434,
0.4485057294,
-0.9072926641,
-0.1548717767,
0.6448817849,
0.1630320996,
-0.4696456194,
-0.3412984014,
-0.4694666564,
0.2462200969,
-0.1565109938,
0.7466548085,
0.8771867752,
-0.8153787851,
-0.2585250735,
-0.6785385013,
0.8529303074,
0.5446991324,
-0.9848777056,
-0.224758178,
-0.0628051236,
-0.135238871,
0.406552881,
0.9627552032,
0.2611715198,
0.2673235238,
-0.3499480784,
-0.1275780797,
0.3444802463,
-0.1739194542,
0.0885309651,
-0.4777947664,
0.3123263717,
-0.359479785
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06827v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06827v2
|
APLe: Token-Wise Adaptive for Multi-Modal Prompt Learning
| 2024-01-12T04:54:01 | 2024-01-23T08:54:15 |
Guiming Cao, Kaize Shi, Hong Fu, Huaiwen Zhang, Guandong Xu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Pre-trained Vision-Language (V-L) models set the benchmark for generalization
to downstream tasks among the noteworthy contenders. Many characteristics of
the V-L model have been explored in existing research including the challenge
of the sensitivity to text input and the tuning process across multi-modal
prompts. With the advanced utilization of the V-L model like CLIP, recent
approaches deploy learnable prompts instead of hand-craft prompts to boost the
generalization performance and address the aforementioned challenges. Inspired
by layer-wise training, which is wildly used in image fusion, we note that
using a sequential training process to adapt different modalities branches of
CLIP efficiently facilitates the improvement of generalization. In the context
of addressing the multi-modal prompting challenge, we propose Token-wise
Adaptive for Multi-modal Prompt Learning (APLe) for tuning both modalities
prompts, vision and language, as tokens in a sequential manner. APLe addresses
the challenges in V-L models to promote prompt learning across both modalities,
which indicates a competitive generalization performance in line with the
state-of-the-art. Preeminently, APLe shows robustness and favourable
performance in prompt-length experiments with an absolute advantage in adopting
the V-L models.
|
[
-0.1784592271,
-0.7742513418,
0.487133503,
0.201696828,
-0.3446564376,
-0.0534860641,
-0.1471984684,
-0.2079907507,
-0.0671419576,
-0.0388492458,
-0.7204938531,
-0.2275957316,
-0.4021779299,
0.3778227568,
-0.0358218849,
0.7053796649,
0.0910573304,
0.322434634,
-0.0532777496,
-0.2548827827,
-1.007342577,
-0.4523514807,
-0.8228504062,
0.3673993349,
0.601344049,
0.238768056,
0.3504226208,
0.4800999165,
0.2682562768,
0.3671064973,
0.0287016202,
0.3947783113,
-0.0576733388,
0.1172092333,
-0.3693677485,
-0.3393651843,
-0.5176149607,
-0.2521521449,
0.8797702193,
0.2516313195,
-0.0987301171,
-0.0913296044,
-0.0637529641,
0.643207252,
-0.7004246116,
-0.1214676872,
-0.8522042036,
-0.2174083591,
0.1314309835,
-0.1439963877,
-0.5628147125,
-0.0651986226,
0.2072948515,
-0.9908477068,
0.2536599934,
0.2386714816,
0.6746326685,
0.1975164115,
-0.2911053002,
-0.2498899996,
-0.46963346,
0.8286238313,
-0.3228363395,
0.5569161773,
0.0947742313,
0.5521121621,
0.11964982,
-0.8068675399,
-0.5182572007,
-0.2507041693,
0.2526074648,
0.1594091207,
0.0872321054,
0.170966357,
0.222063154,
0.245496437,
-0.3537927866,
0.0558919981,
-0.2893301845,
-0.4186432064,
0.3497854471,
0.2264181972,
0.3818423152,
-0.0829101279,
-0.788374722,
-0.2974804342,
-0.3549726605,
0.374004513,
0.1308209449,
0.3377081156,
-0.1073935628,
0.2225350291,
-0.1108151898,
1.1190246344,
0.1971003264,
-0.2916842699,
0.4403972626,
-0.9066447616,
-0.150214538,
-0.3535036147,
0.5981226563,
0.3467964828,
0.2557882369,
0.1754468977,
-0.2376463562,
-0.1880009919,
0.1908295453,
-0.5667463541,
-0.1245637536,
0.0157022215,
-0.420150578,
-0.0822264105,
0.0448023118,
-0.7210888863,
-0.4116984904,
-0.3342954814,
0.7617474198,
-0.599009335,
-0.2434191257,
0.0108721275,
-0.3275520205,
0.2658409774,
0.7135175467,
-0.7840518951,
-0.0928115696,
0.2872669101,
1.1370613575,
-0.2455908656,
-0.7292709947,
-0.8771603107,
0.0306544881,
-0.1458189487,
0.826613605,
-0.7407341003,
-0.5890068412,
-0.0295678824,
0.0489887893,
-0.5722524524,
-0.3707738817,
0.5675057173,
-0.4248534143,
0.3471341133,
-0.5044394732,
-0.3508311212,
-0.2806020677,
0.2263097465,
-0.5123718977,
0.7481282353,
0.0295528509,
-0.4989123344,
0.676881969,
-0.7121578455,
-0.1406204253,
0.0658301637,
-0.0990426466,
-0.2923097908,
0.1059207544,
0.5886431336,
0.358779043,
0.0456401296,
0.0847513378,
-0.1362120807,
-0.2815715373,
0.176135391,
-0.4805908799,
0.3596806824,
0.0575844198,
0.0192773975,
0.8536071777,
-0.8495758772,
-0.2429119051,
-0.1372031569,
-0.1409555078,
-0.2752589583,
0.0488075875,
0.1021717265,
0.129992187,
0.1143436804,
-0.2973106802,
0.3483909369,
-0.2969540358,
0.4436353445,
1.0737206936,
0.0052381419,
0.56337744,
-0.3167133331,
0.415885359,
0.2358206064,
0.5320032835,
-0.9078025222,
-0.4990144372,
-0.5345918536,
-0.7377955914,
0.3102822602,
0.6900248528,
-1.1753524542,
0.1120150983,
0.1035679355,
-0.2388027906,
-0.5176753998,
0.0693577304,
0.2706898749,
0.9073982835,
0.5527387857,
-0.4073775709,
-0.3885363042,
-0.5460098386,
-0.2506854236,
-0.17005153,
0.0102705862,
0.5047793984,
0.1460962445,
-0.0245853644,
0.8309095502,
-0.1777815968,
-0.3512809873,
-0.2180957645,
0.0965949818,
0.2357815504,
0.3170176446,
0.5363810062,
-1.2047348022,
-0.4800385535,
-0.1307637393,
-0.3766039908,
-0.1266439408,
-0.23781012,
0.1444134414,
0.1658791155,
0.561162293,
-0.3060693443,
0.2536510229,
0.2909168899,
-0.6368342042,
0.8616758585,
-0.2991554439,
0.3969785869,
-1.1242038012,
0.0226342566,
-0.0385557227,
-0.4770512283,
-0.5597422719,
-0.0079569733,
0.2818400562,
-0.0994985625,
-0.862409234,
0.6483066678,
-0.4112019241,
0.0027911873,
-0.4445991814,
-0.0446113572,
0.103472434,
0.4658321738,
0.223059535,
1.0734143257,
1.1532330513,
-0.9179786444,
0.4883233905,
0.0671218932,
-0.1498363912,
0.7732723951,
-0.7494910955,
-0.0531100184,
-0.243540585,
0.2728627026,
-1.0306662321,
-0.1416983902,
0.4012102783,
-0.2758453786,
0.1941015124,
-0.0133707887,
0.0299804844,
-0.1471186876,
-0.5422070622,
0.8392511606,
0.5319397449,
-0.5835273862,
0.9396483302,
-0.2026540935,
-0.0371433236,
-0.6658463478,
-0.1345233321,
-0.2028599977,
-0.2365974039,
-0.3152302206,
0.3516923785,
-0.4115837812,
0.2531422675,
-0.059833739,
0.0515040271,
-0.0449869372,
-0.0722060278,
0.1000496,
0.450760603,
-0.1666389555,
0.324113965,
-0.2629101872,
-0.1077990606,
-0.4186507463,
-0.2108321637,
0.3791319132,
-0.1517215818,
-0.3126136959,
-0.5788639188,
0.1599137634,
0.69064641,
-0.2527442276,
0.6252573133,
0.8092304468,
-0.1556808352,
-0.2059350908,
-0.4842514992,
-0.1698046029,
-0.5245869756,
0.62752527,
-0.5902427435,
-0.7155528665,
0.4992249906,
-0.236628741,
-0.0379043631,
0.2319995165,
0.7030411363,
0.0569844283,
0.8924328685,
0.9018868208,
0.0026551725,
1.0859291553,
0.0993423611,
-0.1294745505,
-0.8486942053,
-0.2772815526,
-0.1066484228,
-0.0592105389,
0.0446395874,
-0.4799820483,
0.5827714205,
0.3994033337,
-0.0245243609,
0.1121996194,
-0.5226972103,
0.6220837235,
0.5373939276,
0.2833733261,
0.1837518513,
-0.3177629709,
-0.0938114747,
0.1772317588,
-0.716580987,
0.0056467522,
0.8711817265,
0.2355258316,
0.6162725687,
-0.1565039903,
0.1912536621,
0.4418715239,
-0.2380069792,
-0.9073086977,
0.4869525135,
0.0210604742,
-0.1748987883,
-0.3886139095,
-0.1444566101,
-0.6485301852,
0.3694950342,
-0.2956992388,
-0.6051585674,
0.3267868459,
0.599160254,
-0.4813073874,
0.271707505,
-0.9228352904,
0.8883748055,
-0.2044655085,
-0.2381239384,
-0.1859454513,
-0.7078726292,
0.1815437526,
-0.0527435839,
0.3069150448,
0.0120014679,
-0.3493607938,
0.4887024164,
-0.2716457546,
0.9500373602,
-0.4233835936,
0.2343563139,
0.3532384038,
-0.2421368957,
0.3902051747,
0.135825634,
0.1443154961,
-0.2285933346,
-0.0506792516,
-0.5610158443,
-0.5219837427,
0.3372177482,
-0.7438203096,
-0.508189559,
-0.3017375469,
-0.5433923602,
-0.1186252162,
0.2150685638,
0.4395049512,
0.7944689393,
-0.0335688367,
-0.3616522551,
0.6057487726,
-0.2964541912,
0.9045989513,
0.4184516668,
-0.2771793008,
-0.5754189491,
1.087294817,
-0.174201116,
0.40726161,
0.3933624029,
0.2929082513,
-0.3769800067,
-0.5357102156,
-0.753513813,
-0.051654797,
-0.7501465678,
-0.2766737938,
-0.4162911475,
-0.0165767316,
-0.2423715442,
-0.3334952891,
-0.2733627856,
-0.2861195207,
-0.4200840592,
0.1411869079,
0.4635138214,
0.5389083028,
-0.0995310247,
0.2526401281,
-0.7735766172,
0.5990819335,
0.8710673451,
0.1332098246,
0.0376038775,
-0.6398743987,
0.0102542061,
-0.1859375685,
-0.3228109181,
-0.881347239,
-0.0867039263,
0.7951592207,
0.4989382923,
0.2181005478,
-0.197672233,
0.6711291671,
-0.7179760933,
1.0657883883,
0.5732844472,
-1.097728014,
0.6826945543,
-0.2065010369,
0.3806938529,
0.5412324071,
0.2517749667,
-0.5018133521,
0.1008979529,
-0.1663338542,
-0.9165706038,
0.7036671042,
-0.4800180197,
0.163753897,
0.1365111321,
0.3001414239,
0.4657923281,
0.1814763248,
-0.8092647791,
-0.0189303383,
-0.6625292897,
-0.2270274162,
0.1613931656,
-0.2710532546,
0.1401417702,
-0.3486072719,
0.5406293273,
-0.3907878697,
0.1420510709,
0.5325585008,
-0.3362182379,
0.024379367,
0.3045914769,
0.8854699731,
0.8475426435,
0.1044932678,
-0.0144131575,
0.3920755684,
-0.5286847949,
0.1644162387,
-0.1351384968,
0.0090022273,
-0.1162757874,
0.4030838609,
1.2060731649,
0.0444916822,
-0.7012144923,
0.9509468079,
-0.137364611,
-0.0655802339,
0.0935103819,
0.1054853499,
-0.4504380226,
0.2925302088,
0.5892908573,
0.4309245646,
0.1712879986,
-0.4925627112,
0.2550106943,
0.2583274245,
-0.4227401316,
-0.6146030426,
0.6375354528,
0.470019877,
-0.3514998257,
0.2247097343,
-0.1587043107,
-0.6446977854,
0.3313314915,
0.5192235112,
0.8431125879,
-0.4082438052,
0.2423733771,
0.4200604558,
0.0188318714,
0.0371217802,
0.3472842872,
-0.231692493,
-0.631504178,
-0.6428066492,
-0.5538356304,
-0.431447953,
-0.0780925229,
-0.3724893332,
0.5860186219,
-0.4728072882,
-0.0538562387,
-0.3104760945,
-0.6782810092,
-0.6386215687,
0.1963250786,
0.1352598369,
1.1537809372,
-0.9980039597,
0.7863426805,
1.0155556202,
-0.2520075738,
-0.6658968329,
-0.0520351864,
-0.1655479223,
-0.9960899949,
0.3577794731,
0.1994811445,
-0.0868480355,
0.052456703,
-0.27181077,
-0.5899966955,
0.9853734374,
0.1316685677,
-0.5802275538,
-0.1898272038,
-0.404445231,
0.1642451137,
-0.3509111702,
0.3942929208,
0.082502149,
0.3197460175,
0.2314425111,
-1.2311928272,
-0.085364446,
-0.1296299845,
0.1192923039,
0.0464949347,
-0.8421897888,
0.92192626,
-0.224746719,
-0.231619969,
0.080190219,
0.6922805905,
0.297609061,
0.4424417317,
0.8170750141,
0.2316871732,
0.6174665689,
0.150536716,
0.9155514836,
-0.1716898531,
0.1153076515,
0.7737509012,
-0.0901756287,
0.6703971028,
0.5899891257,
-0.0456859544,
0.4956361055,
0.5394631624,
0.0722502545,
1.0026721954,
-0.18054609,
-0.2656472027,
-0.3702720702,
-0.1857228726,
-0.4518169165,
0.2471909225,
0.2050279528,
-0.1952681839,
-0.146043852,
0.5486710072,
-0.611082077,
0.0932605863,
-0.853689611,
0.8925986886,
-0.0526134484,
-0.4927144349,
0.4807541668,
-0.2325776964,
0.9651748538,
-0.8180007339,
-0.1636312455,
0.2173652202,
-0.0393319093,
-0.0397892818,
-0.3493947387,
-0.0219682045,
-0.2925817668,
-0.4596906006,
-0.0224795993,
0.9606698751,
-0.4000160992,
-0.5512313247,
-0.0002291374,
0.4971401989,
-0.2768380642,
0.0377477072,
-0.8290816545,
0.1950669438,
-0.1259903759,
-0.1185523272,
0.1603114754,
0.4059628844,
-0.1061251909,
0.5768681765,
0.5375654101,
-0.0059326286,
0.342107147,
0.1611023247,
0.9395986795,
-0.5838642716,
-0.7696916461,
-0.9432954788,
0.8291555643,
0.0708393529,
-0.4940899014,
0.5525457859,
0.1683116108,
0.7932837009,
-0.3170546591,
0.7172392607,
-0.067674011,
0.4313558638,
-0.9445541501,
0.0858968049,
-0.5710067153,
0.0555231348,
-0.2761981189,
-1.0450640917,
-0.2299340069,
0.4820125103,
-0.1278321743,
0.1926166415,
0.7823354602,
0.5502521992,
-0.1943814456,
-0.1541211456,
0.4093256891,
-0.0372518189,
0.1382454038,
0.7063100934,
1.0997462273,
-0.3525408804,
0.4107675552,
0.0769079477,
-0.4597970843,
-0.2244825363,
-0.9787157178,
-0.9427589178,
-0.8914652467,
-0.2622112334,
0.0938096941,
0.0704908445,
0.893889606,
0.9203274846,
-0.8071410656,
0.1578272283,
-0.1999432296,
0.1986754686,
-0.3465940654,
-0.2109301984,
0.4180732965,
-0.6967764497,
-0.7305701375,
0.6684314013,
0.3665614426,
0.0760224536,
0.0524036251,
-0.1511936337,
-0.0925636962,
0.0140928132,
0.6202927828,
0.4502687454,
-0.7688393593,
-0.4684705138,
0.0481259376,
0.2267663032,
0.0928806439,
0.9998759627,
-1.0669651031,
0.7853252292,
0.4519276619,
0.5833797455,
0.0524847358,
0.2554876804,
0.6231826544,
-0.9624743462,
0.3516115844,
-0.0111477757,
0.3924283981,
0.3500700891,
-0.2468636036,
0.1380778551,
0.5186828971,
-0.6092310548,
-0.7736975551,
0.4902310669,
-1.1950383186,
-0.4671962261,
1.0276380777,
-0.0228631608,
-0.2005806565,
-0.1604030281,
-0.8406429291,
0.0710886121,
-0.478900671,
0.4933358133,
0.5189988613,
-0.1140997112,
-0.4257435203,
-0.0121737709,
0.6641513705,
0.5628042817,
-0.3982622921,
-0.1346740276,
0.5343744755,
0.1288962662,
0.1177684888,
0.7630029917,
0.1750829369,
0.8285191059,
-0.1327941418,
-0.2089521587,
-0.5607436895,
-0.7127422094,
-0.6861246228,
0.2200035602,
0.318125397,
-0.6795484424
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06327v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06327v1
|
Learning from Semi-Factuals: A Debiased and Semantic-Aware Framework for Generalized Relation Discovery
| 2024-01-12T02:38:55 | 2024-01-12T02:38:55 |
Jiaxin Wang, Lingling Zhang, Jun Liu, Tianlin Guo, Wenjun Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce a novel task, called Generalized Relation Discovery (GRD), for
open-world relation extraction. GRD aims to identify unlabeled instances in
existing pre-defined relations or discover novel relations by assigning
instances to clusters as well as providing specific meanings for these
clusters. The key challenges of GRD are how to mitigate the serious model
biases caused by labeled pre-defined relations to learn effective relational
representations and how to determine the specific semantics of novel relations
during classifying or clustering unlabeled instances. We then propose a novel
framework, SFGRD, for this task to solve the above issues by learning from
semi-factuals in two stages. The first stage is semi-factual generation
implemented by a tri-view debiased relation representation module, in which we
take each original sentence as the main view and design two debiased views to
generate semi-factual examples for this sentence. The second stage is
semi-factual thinking executed by a dual-space tri-view collaborative relation
learning module, where we design a cluster-semantic space and a class-index
space to learn relational semantics and relation label indices, respectively.
In addition, we devise alignment and selection strategies to integrate two
spaces and establish a self-supervised learning loop for unlabeled data by
doing semi-factual thinking across three views. Extensive experimental results
show that SFGRD surpasses state-of-the-art models in terms of accuracy by
2.36\% $\sim$5.78\% and cosine similarity by 32.19\%$\sim$ 84.45\% for relation
label index and relation semantic quality, respectively. To the best of our
knowledge, we are the first to exploit the efficacy of semi-factuals in
relation extraction.
|
[
-0.3658307195,
-1.0188035965,
0.850628674,
-0.1050403267,
-0.2701069415,
0.0197671745,
-0.0493063815,
-0.4873609245,
-0.1783839315,
0.4236060977,
-0.4912701249,
-0.8259132504,
-0.2829892337,
-0.138179943,
-0.0287357662,
1.3664739132,
0.0604502298,
-0.0588318557,
-0.5505056977,
-0.3034477532,
0.002422323,
-0.634141624,
-0.1290982068,
-0.1954118162,
0.2662804425,
0.431571871,
0.8752145171,
0.4870776832,
0.3173907697,
0.1614510864,
-0.2317561507,
0.2626245916,
-0.7263304591,
-0.1901911646,
-0.5962111354,
-0.2380257249,
-0.1974523067,
0.0970057473,
0.5852293968,
1.0244851112,
-0.4094683528,
0.3540920019,
-0.2660686374,
0.6589480639,
-0.6220622063,
0.7170077562,
-0.4524874985,
0.1479675621,
-0.1204281673,
0.0780342817,
-0.3055596352,
-0.3519513607,
0.3704719245,
-0.6617490053,
0.7022960186,
0.2122758627,
1.032692194,
0.0748616084,
-0.6778637767,
-0.3142272234,
-1.0312085152,
0.4311348796,
-0.2246874422,
0.48290205,
0.1136898249,
0.3878241777,
-0.3695814908,
-0.6719461679,
-0.5212363601,
-0.1644921601,
-0.3381583095,
-0.0029131912,
-0.1476173997,
0.1831094027,
0.5180565119,
0.7846341729,
-0.4571737051,
-0.4763693213,
-0.3747604191,
-0.0938925818,
0.6602111459,
-0.0800583065,
0.4118687809,
-0.2602327168,
-0.6805524826,
0.3156341612,
-0.729388833,
-0.1220391467,
0.1394773424,
0.3054789901,
-0.0822749212,
0.6726838946,
-0.1616948247,
0.5478277802,
0.1255516261,
-0.2022979259,
0.257850647,
-0.4709822237,
-0.2648346424,
0.0100542083,
0.968364656,
0.1698429435,
0.3469015658,
-0.6107774973,
0.0302369725,
0.4497022629,
0.0708224103,
-0.3734097779,
-0.4112956226,
-0.2270935476,
-0.3685747981,
-0.3243219554,
0.071239464,
-0.8737873435,
-0.1713936776,
-0.3718740642,
0.4726490974,
-0.3810508251,
-0.3915364444,
0.0804950073,
-0.1358881742,
-0.1036195457,
0.0895301998,
-0.962481916,
0.4399774969,
0.4167179763,
0.7514250278,
-0.0508145988,
0.0225655511,
-0.4775647521,
0.5049253106,
-0.3714024127,
0.6419174075,
-0.5674207807,
-0.5078332424,
-0.0229866281,
-0.1490689069,
0.0863146037,
-0.6349576116,
0.4918161631,
-0.6458182335,
0.4731598794,
-0.3768163323,
-0.5774310827,
-0.1746936738,
0.2156800926,
-0.6492595673,
1.1937954426,
0.5468924046,
-1.1342941523,
0.4950508773,
-0.2726841271,
-0.4510997832,
-0.1251384765,
-0.5303010345,
-0.3161884248,
0.0277832728,
0.0675693378,
0.5178972483,
-0.4521022141,
0.7042120099,
-0.6546911597,
0.0749866068,
-0.3550878167,
0.3174370527,
0.5943620801,
0.1181751117,
-0.0778850168,
-0.0680599734,
-1.0337401628,
-0.2918485403,
0.1317913681,
-0.0792539939,
-0.7026917934,
-0.0317432508,
-0.5494852066,
0.384439528,
-0.0221337564,
-0.7251557112,
0.1896247268,
-0.3598318994,
0.0014591174,
0.4873596728,
0.5200743675,
0.780760169,
0.1496689618,
0.2739785314,
0.2945353687,
0.0510680713,
0.1488205642,
-0.1073262244,
-0.5027652979,
-0.1178196371,
0.3464038074,
0.3557489812,
-0.9288938642,
0.5698521137,
-0.2698178291,
-0.3952799141,
-0.0750611201,
0.22443901,
0.6231862307,
0.8980996013,
0.5354906917,
-0.0636297762,
-0.3262502849,
-1.0599375963,
-0.1690547913,
-0.3019138277,
0.2115141898,
0.1005785018,
0.4356527328,
-0.2210702747,
1.2722543478,
-0.9721345901,
-0.5917325616,
-0.1254363954,
0.2614919841,
0.0949403122,
0.1214783043,
0.7163230777,
-1.1083550453,
-0.5046831965,
0.1121468395,
-1.2132195234,
0.2590229809,
0.0933687761,
-0.3023468554,
-0.0194032528,
0.3530466259,
-0.6400798559,
0.5165988803,
-0.0117576728,
-0.3401079476,
0.50563097,
-0.1693639904,
-0.3770391643,
-0.9874077439,
-0.0737714842,
0.2782925665,
-0.307340771,
-0.5725331903,
-0.0280549396,
-0.0464538448,
0.0607438721,
-0.1210279837,
0.2906321585,
-0.730599165,
-0.1867213696,
0.1390432417,
0.0406771675,
-0.2664612532,
0.5541571379,
0.1508951634,
0.5663951635,
0.5053324699,
-0.7716735601,
0.3247489929,
0.565215826,
-0.3611563444,
0.3967719972,
-0.2678013146,
-0.0852477849,
-0.2466129065,
0.2283408791,
-0.8133143187,
-0.0212097652,
0.3999218047,
-0.3336517513,
0.3964664936,
-0.30582726,
-0.407412231,
-0.3091354966,
0.0377856828,
0.185164243,
0.3019573689,
-0.7984606624,
0.6650985479,
0.746355772,
-0.2359924465,
-0.6691070795,
-0.2588808835,
-0.1892144084,
0.0740482956,
-0.6361041665,
0.357881099,
0.2528374195,
-0.3225997984,
0.4720599055,
-0.5226709247,
0.0347205475,
-0.143208921,
0.1173912436,
0.4143082201,
0.0623464137,
0.3653805554,
-0.0188722946,
-0.27755481,
0.4217597246,
-0.280177325,
0.1186434552,
-0.1184735671,
-0.0742809251,
0.1060877517,
0.2875724733,
0.2240990102,
-0.1794586629,
0.7479712367,
0.536287725,
-0.6296232343,
-0.3025322855,
-0.4009851217,
0.2127828896,
-0.3706352115,
0.2635339499,
-0.3289344311,
-1.0801683664,
0.4160860479,
-0.3659282625,
-0.0856309384,
0.5443275571,
0.3994694352,
0.1654828638,
0.8332893848,
1.1463997364,
-0.217948094,
0.0835214779,
-0.5028749704,
0.5919927359,
-0.6382470131,
-0.6076666713,
-0.3574019074,
0.0149821006,
-0.721796751,
-0.4274997413,
0.5293954015,
0.1416105479,
-0.1731225699,
-0.1062737703,
-0.2551001608,
0.372600466,
0.4070289731,
0.1127287447,
0.5353698134,
0.0245051794,
-0.5391531587,
-0.067290388,
-0.5317754149,
-0.4210819006,
0.9492544532,
-0.0082042553,
0.8640773296,
0.0910691544,
0.8562160134,
0.4292301238,
0.2980113328,
-0.6390142441,
0.514975965,
0.042663563,
-0.8389604092,
-0.0597106144,
-0.8355107903,
-0.5028428435,
0.2683753669,
-0.3634822965,
-0.8362298608,
0.308834374,
0.1733644754,
-0.2864661515,
0.3193905354,
-0.7263512611,
0.7893822193,
-0.1673511267,
-0.6418535113,
-0.0367094502,
-1.0298815966,
0.7866912484,
0.1234711111,
0.2997133732,
0.0344331749,
0.3334564865,
0.5844681859,
-0.160972476,
0.535245657,
-0.5488709807,
-0.0067173741,
0.3388440609,
0.0879235044,
0.302128315,
0.4286214411,
0.1896128654,
-0.2596099377,
0.1154241636,
-0.2157117277,
-0.8475058675,
0.5466154814,
-0.7574430704,
-0.5125531554,
-0.768886447,
-0.3936717212,
-0.5854126215,
0.4300769567,
0.034113504,
0.44292292,
-0.8889520168,
-0.0135013023,
0.8758090138,
-0.0636768118,
0.0410177708,
0.465733707,
-0.565928638,
-0.4533023238,
0.7980806231,
-0.0333864279,
0.2052940279,
0.5023835301,
0.0840138122,
-0.6812162399,
-0.2549095452,
-0.2433813065,
0.5085102916,
-0.6476735473,
-0.1989524662,
-0.8756524324,
-0.0720599294,
-0.3920896947,
0.4332484305,
-0.2929284275,
-0.4231235981,
-0.2248834372,
-0.5299113393,
-0.0159666371,
0.8083125353,
-0.1894677877,
-0.0990878046,
-0.8471490741,
0.9111067057,
0.2875397801,
0.2020058632,
-0.1607812792,
-0.0587302037,
-0.1370280832,
0.0416479297,
-0.3203808367,
-0.7659289241,
0.1937951148,
0.1262140721,
0.6208026409,
0.7528566122,
0.472587347,
0.5134481192,
-0.4453146756,
0.5901678801,
0.2346045524,
-0.5950849056,
0.4603672624,
-0.3872660995,
-0.3926666975,
0.5638158917,
0.7994101048,
-0.3319678903,
0.0613846816,
-1.2286608219,
-0.5936992764,
0.7356185317,
0.1330600232,
-0.2011152804,
-0.1347836703,
0.6022259593,
0.1476727128,
0.4983039796,
-0.5322216749,
-0.4411524236,
0.2552395761,
-0.1496964693,
-0.2468037754,
-0.5319887996,
-0.3965090811,
-0.3957041204,
0.7279936671,
-0.1602780074,
0.3516246378,
0.3729288876,
-0.1161523685,
-0.1652778536,
0.3101832867,
0.0831805095,
0.8140241504,
-0.4491519332,
0.3770650923,
-0.065375641,
-0.0861747563,
0.2304141819,
0.2845706046,
-0.3443447649,
0.1683236808,
0.1288687289,
0.7442550063,
0.2272313833,
-0.0801470578,
0.6865367889,
0.0231423173,
-0.3019156754,
-0.17970182,
0.0339761898,
0.1793881804,
0.1011891589,
0.3112104833,
0.0957175121,
0.1827954203,
-0.9135537148,
0.4411513805,
0.593971312,
-0.3219742775,
-0.6182438135,
0.5509462357,
0.0954118446,
0.2129149735,
0.5530516505,
-0.6108205914,
-0.7141198516,
0.1389338374,
0.6580668092,
0.6000318527,
0.0285576601,
0.5870088339,
0.3821534514,
-0.0024116964,
-0.2517050803,
0.1857644767,
-0.4215945601,
-1.0081988573,
-0.1298035234,
-0.67067945,
-0.4168591201,
0.0614284873,
-0.9994400144,
0.2977898121,
-0.4656256437,
0.0186377689,
-0.0139282513,
0.2663517892,
-0.4590212703,
0.4494222701,
0.0150160715,
0.7014778256,
-1.0246024132,
0.6099435091,
0.9212270379,
-0.3707329333,
-0.944026351,
-0.1245054379,
0.1538251638,
-0.4823679924,
0.306804359,
-0.0080236616,
-0.1773930639,
0.0175248012,
-0.5900277495,
-0.572008431,
0.9455620646,
0.4758771062,
-0.332262814,
-0.3940915763,
0.0673398376,
0.5916523933,
-0.4190941155,
0.1494299173,
0.7639590502,
0.2553731501,
0.436730206,
-0.4299914241,
0.1044198871,
-0.1758356988,
-0.0530841462,
0.5192041397,
-0.7589250803,
0.4246452451,
-0.4979635775,
-0.5066769719,
-0.3041806817,
1.0216521025,
0.0546046793,
0.612656951,
0.5318837166,
0.9024026394,
0.9940545559,
-0.1367966235,
0.8088827729,
0.1364882141,
0.6766665578,
1.2289429903,
-0.4297929704,
0.3617901504,
0.3678798079,
-0.2984633148,
0.6524220705,
0.580010891,
-0.0524295419,
0.8427246809,
-0.064243041,
-0.3653798103,
-0.3847665787,
-0.1513006985,
-0.4665730298,
0.2536975741,
0.3396224678,
-0.4682144523,
-0.6711778641,
-0.2494538724,
0.1267195791,
0.3581019938,
0.0434925221,
0.9053575993,
0.1275539845,
-0.5243382454,
0.2231280357,
-0.1850517243,
0.2329818755,
-0.5834798813,
-0.069691129,
-0.0231289268,
0.296374917,
-0.3357445598,
-0.596085906,
0.2498742491,
-0.0845611617,
-0.5663614273,
-0.0206263307,
0.8876204491,
-0.6218349934,
-0.4466154873,
0.5134575367,
0.6852656007,
-0.30554533,
-0.0292146299,
-0.3792073429,
-0.3795592189,
0.3203130662,
-0.0361755304,
0.4792118669,
0.8978512287,
-0.0689407736,
0.4552775025,
0.6345379949,
0.0651187226,
-0.1127893478,
-0.0528906807,
1.1645791531,
-0.7705581784,
-0.5082322955,
-0.6155243516,
0.2048919648,
-0.2728137076,
-0.1147619635,
0.5895481706,
0.8250865936,
1.096542716,
-0.1002168134,
0.9828215837,
-0.3396533728,
0.7725814581,
-0.5210284591,
0.3058655858,
-0.3198104799,
0.039803233,
-0.4454851449,
-0.9949846268,
-0.3760097623,
0.4528193474,
-0.4109014869,
-0.0843352973,
0.8988603354,
0.7077786326,
-0.3163694739,
0.3086676002,
0.040946994,
0.2300099432,
0.5124054551,
0.4690454304,
0.9308454394,
-0.2353065014,
0.6004109979,
-0.5452674627,
-0.3908419311,
0.3779838681,
-0.782939136,
-1.0123910904,
-0.5947980881,
-0.3564043343,
-0.1031188145,
0.062951453,
0.7505643368,
0.2862060666,
-0.4545281827,
0.0379476883,
-0.2684816122,
0.2227968425,
0.0439279117,
-0.2958345413,
0.3307001293,
-0.3220986426,
-0.3256644309,
0.1018021554,
0.2934629917,
-0.1697548926,
0.0410234071,
0.0552841127,
-0.665266037,
-0.5302524567,
0.4697034359,
0.3704442382,
-0.280834049,
-0.5010871291,
-0.3216173947,
0.0521219969,
0.0214031357,
0.7838289142,
-0.7681406736,
0.5263702869,
0.3767544925,
0.4493184388,
0.7082504034,
0.5664039254,
0.6083550453,
-0.8860173225,
0.0065823682,
0.1702101082,
0.0916729569,
0.3183680475,
-0.5194968581,
0.9136097431,
0.6697015166,
-0.4983220696,
-0.7652477622,
0.1929338425,
-0.9292103648,
0.1304950714,
1.1924965382,
-0.2121265382,
-0.2589994371,
-0.184837386,
-0.1171334684,
0.5460847616,
-0.3653055429,
0.6629512906,
0.6267900467,
-0.3480207026,
0.2501316071,
-0.3464782536,
0.6332728863,
-0.0003531925,
-0.5763826966,
0.1929172277,
0.8259292245,
0.4398631752,
0.4283106625,
0.657954514,
-0.330524534,
0.0752835944,
-0.2422930151,
-0.0836727321,
-0.1757441312,
-0.5709685683,
0.1260213554,
0.2045632601,
-0.1821752489,
-0.193241775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06321v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06321v1
|
Multi-Task Learning for Front-End Text Processing in TTS
| 2024-01-12T02:13:21 | 2024-01-12T02:13:21 |
Wonjune Kang, Yun Wang, Shun Zhang, Arthur Hinsvark, Qing He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We propose a multi-task learning (MTL) model for jointly performing three
tasks that are commonly solved in a text-to-speech (TTS) front-end: text
normalization (TN), part-of-speech (POS) tagging, and homograph disambiguation
(HD). Our framework utilizes a tree-like structure with a trunk that learns
shared representations, followed by separate task-specific heads. We further
incorporate a pre-trained language model to utilize its built-in lexical and
contextual knowledge, and study how to best use its embeddings so as to most
effectively benefit our multi-task model. Through task-wise ablations, we show
that our full model trained on all three tasks achieves the strongest overall
performance compared to models trained on individual or sub-combinations of
tasks, confirming the advantages of our MTL framework. Finally, we introduce a
new HD dataset containing a balanced number of sentences in diverse contexts
for a variety of homographs and their pronunciations. We demonstrate that
incorporating this dataset into training significantly improves HD performance
over only using a commonly used, but imbalanced, pre-existing dataset.
|
[
-0.2442018241,
-0.9403052926,
0.3244103491,
0.047860384,
-0.4947931468,
0.1480857879,
-0.3206347823,
-0.5096511841,
0.0204757266,
0.3177291155,
-0.5354121923,
-0.7254473567,
-0.7152173519,
0.3520472646,
-0.4341966212,
1.1015880108,
0.1428629011,
-0.1500178725,
-0.1894973367,
-0.0725211203,
-0.7234401107,
-0.6185084581,
-0.6553780437,
-0.23696661,
0.6940099001,
0.3801455796,
0.5143116713,
0.8415494561,
0.2882410288,
0.2938382626,
0.1115072891,
0.1177231371,
-0.2685348094,
0.3536077738,
-0.2897757292,
-0.3312355578,
-0.4055049717,
-0.2058938295,
0.6072500944,
0.7806373835,
-0.0634358898,
0.2141614705,
0.1310807168,
0.5171687007,
-0.5141554475,
0.111568965,
-0.7380977273,
-0.0721646175,
-0.5457774401,
-0.2245701998,
-0.5678646564,
0.1279824525,
0.3223605752,
-0.6997793317,
0.2079522014,
0.0904994085,
0.6828007698,
0.4403121471,
-0.6720048189,
-0.1277024895,
-0.5310185552,
0.8840662837,
-0.2768167257,
0.9886235595,
0.6316840649,
0.0283702184,
0.3579134643,
-0.6505016088,
-0.3502405882,
-0.0267748833,
-0.1853002608,
-0.0440203696,
-0.2365227193,
0.1476052552,
0.1628507525,
0.304387182,
-0.6015834808,
0.0967423171,
-0.1918564439,
-0.1957615912,
0.3650802076,
-0.0682167262,
-0.0318726897,
-0.1338192523,
-0.4693025351,
-0.1104212552,
-0.413092196,
0.0388857871,
0.0312806703,
0.8133845329,
0.012111757,
0.6141159534,
-0.063371852,
0.7602809072,
-0.1030041203,
-0.1627060026,
0.5163786411,
-0.3605797887,
-0.4357229173,
-0.2313644588,
0.6297801137,
0.0849368572,
0.0955532268,
-0.4885648191,
-0.3988279998,
0.1930686831,
0.4064708948,
-0.3718237877,
0.1804291755,
0.2978031933,
-0.3114754856,
0.0610667132,
-0.2132710963,
-0.5575028062,
-0.3753269315,
-0.7038849592,
0.5575917363,
-0.6169700027,
-0.1827767193,
-0.0260866508,
-0.1736675203,
-0.1964869946,
0.2256163061,
-0.7483381629,
0.4773463011,
0.5188933015,
0.8822564483,
-0.2210567892,
-0.6204701662,
-0.8766646981,
0.4393712282,
-0.0332429707,
0.7481707335,
-0.3151996732,
-0.2717217803,
-0.1029221788,
-0.1145225912,
-0.286272496,
-0.3721416593,
0.4003668129,
-0.2580215335,
0.166537717,
-0.0675552264,
-0.3079818189,
-0.1335038543,
0.2662794292,
-0.6123040915,
1.2849245071,
0.0709392428,
-1.029659152,
0.1979694963,
-0.611351192,
-1.1440529823,
-0.0156423766,
-0.1683949381,
-0.4539158344,
0.2476474643,
0.0730916634,
0.80742383,
-0.4404199719,
0.4154011607,
0.1705477238,
-0.2845586538,
-0.1872591525,
-0.139509201,
0.6300336123,
0.295252651,
-0.285328269,
0.5628685951,
-0.550259769,
-0.2953103483,
-0.0484840162,
-0.3343974948,
-0.4985067546,
0.1113194004,
0.3807395995,
0.1806919426,
0.249393627,
-0.7430205345,
-0.0214740392,
-0.3983016014,
0.4289103746,
0.5624200106,
-0.4008630812,
0.1465236098,
-0.5206404328,
0.2246217132,
0.2092469037,
0.0293337684,
-0.335013777,
-0.6649019718,
-0.3829484284,
-0.2504501045,
0.169651553,
0.6369063258,
-1.074855566,
0.4480566084,
-0.3020296991,
-0.3340678811,
-0.4107511938,
-0.1600417793,
0.5592489839,
0.6003169417,
0.6264794469,
-0.344825238,
-0.6224533916,
-0.7889991999,
-0.3382043242,
0.0313652195,
-0.0661101863,
-0.0019472446,
0.3638549149,
-0.3670246303,
1.1362546682,
-0.4297194779,
-0.6230310798,
-0.240142256,
0.3608527184,
-0.1462008655,
0.4586465657,
0.3592262268,
-1.0021257401,
-0.46702829,
0.157080397,
-0.4564363956,
0.1280007362,
0.1523332596,
0.1082761586,
0.3632645309,
0.3349728882,
-0.4859394431,
0.4935443699,
0.605463922,
-0.5011956692,
0.40139395,
-0.3246234059,
0.2106855214,
-1.3327856064,
0.177955538,
0.3338545561,
-0.479321003,
-0.876318872,
-0.0855400786,
-0.0930284187,
-0.1172270253,
-0.3624050915,
0.511139214,
-0.2669762671,
-0.4241043925,
-0.3375930488,
0.1925895363,
0.0139536383,
0.7448194623,
0.1721740663,
0.7571030259,
0.580797255,
-0.5822560787,
0.2418435961,
0.3646309078,
0.0737251118,
0.5637503862,
-0.3766354024,
0.0885335729,
-0.3345426321,
0.0990914628,
-1.16208148,
0.0363881662,
0.0738468394,
-0.4948063493,
0.2058844566,
0.0259937197,
-0.6552994847,
-0.3166000545,
-0.0908821672,
0.1972189993,
0.2703066468,
-0.2703700066,
0.8254898787,
0.7165970802,
-0.1383551508,
-0.6012903452,
-0.7750844359,
-0.1768621206,
-0.1880182028,
-0.3636859357,
0.8130760789,
-0.0387984477,
0.1034734994,
-0.1129758507,
-0.2536820769,
-0.4552542269,
0.2068240345,
0.3598376215,
0.0343786553,
-0.0174353682,
0.4778280556,
0.0142818782,
-0.1498023421,
-0.3413927555,
-0.4844865203,
0.6259424686,
0.0349145941,
-0.0834503621,
-0.6022554636,
0.552605629,
0.5049157739,
-0.515276134,
0.667424202,
0.7174549699,
-0.7525049448,
0.1739349812,
-0.4555750191,
-0.0978723019,
-0.395555675,
0.4346294105,
-0.7159782052,
-1.0928462744,
0.2555832565,
0.0834928825,
0.4789214134,
0.4561989903,
0.4256794453,
-0.1497719884,
0.9282721281,
0.9819672108,
-0.0750567764,
0.6695826054,
-0.0462062582,
-0.0665754229,
-0.6637847424,
-0.1322928965,
-0.6341899633,
-0.1877472103,
-0.4231932759,
-0.4801905155,
0.2136407197,
0.0206862595,
-0.354791522,
0.458637476,
-0.5520021915,
0.2357060015,
0.6591897011,
0.3713725209,
0.4661884606,
0.2059582174,
-0.1407541782,
0.1266438365,
-0.5835886598,
-0.3830681145,
1.1042551994,
0.4302226901,
0.3190944791,
-0.1701043397,
0.6095868945,
0.2094558626,
0.4112001956,
-0.7039290071,
0.2890226841,
-0.7454837561,
-0.4957165718,
-0.4986356497,
-0.4987211525,
-1.0501573086,
0.3444189131,
-0.2593221664,
-0.9424762726,
-0.296333164,
0.3077089787,
-0.3848797381,
0.358394444,
-0.7451776266,
1.0302619934,
-0.1095518917,
-0.3895734847,
-0.3423664272,
-0.9510106444,
0.0489331372,
-0.043235831,
0.5274280906,
-0.02614104,
-0.0060695396,
0.9821636081,
0.1378322393,
0.986389637,
-0.3643330038,
-0.2334667444,
0.1137100235,
-0.2442153543,
0.2758666873,
-0.1381947845,
-0.0845396742,
0.1444548219,
0.1109221727,
-0.2376545519,
-0.1378832459,
0.3276242912,
-0.77751863,
-0.4066132605,
-0.404232204,
-0.6933195591,
-0.4773519337,
0.2974959016,
0.2940724492,
0.5691706538,
-0.0223818365,
0.1528008431,
0.4826452732,
-0.0806582123,
0.3979665637,
0.1281540394,
-0.3278106153,
-0.5410199761,
0.8812870383,
-0.0303642508,
0.1112410575,
0.7407729626,
0.1660793871,
-0.4345384538,
-0.6248975992,
-0.2929968238,
0.1697319597,
-0.5292775631,
-0.2584964037,
-0.7755404115,
-0.0104589202,
-0.4631777406,
0.104636997,
-0.5097006559,
-0.1983340085,
-0.2092622519,
0.1410632581,
0.4667643011,
0.7909231186,
0.3001959026,
0.7769112587,
-0.966591239,
0.7220971584,
0.0789040998,
0.5713289976,
-0.1153735593,
-0.430914849,
-0.5500706434,
0.2012483776,
-0.3682573438,
-0.9324569702,
0.2762434781,
0.1691505164,
0.4464540482,
0.0101749469,
-0.0275723562,
0.6342827082,
-0.7687277198,
0.5525894165,
0.3111084998,
-1.14496696,
0.4738134444,
-0.344750315,
0.3347957134,
0.4841633141,
0.5451329947,
-0.7848953605,
-0.2060508281,
-0.3757065833,
-0.6397141218,
0.8412463069,
0.2204799056,
-0.2263912857,
0.0576713569,
0.2622383833,
0.2943865359,
0.5181549191,
-0.8447417021,
-0.3491039276,
-0.2187588513,
-0.5320439339,
-0.3356132507,
0.0359906778,
-0.1192053705,
-0.3641169667,
0.4648270011,
-0.3755813539,
0.4339451194,
0.0642191172,
-0.330642432,
-0.1288187653,
0.3480936885,
0.4514580071,
0.5637952685,
-0.0797106028,
0.2493102849,
0.0204178579,
-0.4470910132,
-0.1243442073,
0.4323398769,
0.3601211607,
-0.0297554079,
0.2183036357,
0.9561818838,
0.3007043004,
-0.6376305223,
0.5288314819,
-0.0370764732,
-0.1753169596,
0.2283922881,
-0.4791789353,
-0.0074005006,
0.2732551694,
0.5993179679,
0.1687885374,
-0.0776808783,
-0.4996644855,
0.5558934212,
0.3681131005,
-0.2900975049,
-0.5099240541,
0.6830089688,
0.2712917924,
-0.4155269265,
0.3217047453,
-0.0358280726,
-0.5971313119,
0.2993264198,
0.607547462,
0.8170143366,
-0.4300149977,
0.1744036227,
0.0704871193,
0.2965788841,
0.0676662624,
0.5589930415,
-0.3007096648,
-0.5486524701,
-0.6567062736,
-0.7039269209,
-0.2260166407,
-0.0670222715,
-0.439591974,
0.3410952687,
-0.2418679148,
-0.344741255,
-0.0018056589,
-0.0094920332,
-0.7558774352,
0.6037923098,
0.0918001756,
0.5484721661,
-0.8080649376,
1.199937582,
0.9012222886,
-0.224092871,
-0.4950379431,
0.0560771748,
-0.1937718838,
-0.4480706751,
0.7151523232,
0.4463768005,
-0.0231626611,
0.4545322955,
0.149130106,
-0.8523665667,
1.0495159626,
0.3052850962,
-0.6914314628,
-0.5138592124,
0.1659172028,
0.4225381911,
-0.3670482337,
0.1059255153,
0.4478542507,
0.1226372272,
-0.0093542561,
-1.3909519911,
-0.1185582355,
0.0814725012,
-0.0816782266,
0.4045600891,
-0.279294163,
1.042531848,
0.0522749759,
-0.435728848,
-0.1144594029,
0.574633956,
0.2888678014,
0.4433670342,
0.8027331233,
0.5494389534,
0.7427765131,
-0.1384431422,
0.8698703051,
-0.2996303737,
0.30025056,
1.1054079533,
-0.2589813173,
0.9507445097,
0.6681346297,
-0.0923459083,
0.2085651755,
0.6142843962,
0.4818459749,
0.4576051831,
0.0268449187,
-0.0586243421,
-0.043977581,
-0.2212311178,
-0.1785188168,
0.3900037408,
0.3853510618,
-0.0795451105,
-0.2960524261,
0.6413932443,
-0.3187282979,
0.1442272961,
-0.1807614118,
0.7873581648,
-0.162076965,
-0.5982966423,
0.4682207704,
0.1574750543,
0.9852986336,
-0.5653927922,
0.2352465242,
0.2737764418,
0.0635894313,
-0.1712380797,
-0.7416303754,
0.6916617751,
-0.019829087,
-0.2998147905,
-0.6672853231,
0.5542072654,
-0.5923483372,
0.0024624364,
0.3692474365,
0.6639332175,
-0.0644770786,
-0.3567120731,
-0.5420352221,
0.1367309988,
-0.0169616733,
-0.14030689,
0.2093272209,
0.3832536638,
-0.11024905,
0.5013896227,
0.5201604366,
-0.046903681,
0.2648606598,
0.0686133131,
0.833008647,
-0.6849300265,
-0.7361114621,
-0.694018364,
0.7655434608,
0.0938567817,
-0.3162989616,
0.5935433507,
0.7085428834,
1.0000579357,
0.0634277388,
0.8307771683,
-0.0433079265,
0.7916192412,
-0.3787511885,
0.3876113594,
-0.6970843077,
-0.0237396974,
-0.3439809382,
-0.8868937492,
-0.5003599524,
0.5946500897,
-0.1416568756,
-0.0982007161,
0.9536608458,
0.237032935,
0.0036035678,
0.305082351,
0.3898307681,
-0.1544395983,
0.1996132284,
0.5648962855,
0.637219131,
-0.5207536817,
0.4125880003,
-0.4351564944,
-0.3100190759,
0.2031214088,
-0.7121665478,
-0.8805228472,
-1.1578974724,
-0.2894923389,
0.0652126819,
0.1886457205,
0.9190073013,
0.8206803799,
-0.5724190474,
-0.5401559472,
-0.1804905087,
0.0287628546,
-0.3424648345,
-0.1495993882,
0.2697582543,
-0.5531135798,
-0.7967728376,
0.4464372396,
0.2452301085,
0.051700335,
0.1264392734,
0.1764275134,
-0.6531187296,
-0.4002530873,
0.8884955049,
0.003498262,
-0.7191032767,
-0.232689321,
0.0729487762,
-0.1123928428,
0.2209363878,
1.0107922554,
-0.9201029539,
0.2410359681,
0.40010342,
1.0119155645,
0.4482255578,
-0.0194323752,
0.5276660323,
-1.4718741179,
0.2791174352,
0.1607481688,
0.2891955972,
0.3708440959,
-0.3143669963,
0.3120817244,
0.3831605017,
-0.411265552,
-0.7787064314,
0.2667769492,
-0.8522744179,
-0.5155843496,
0.7961930037,
-0.0256046355,
0.0472561978,
-0.3543402553,
-0.2455835938,
0.8005487919,
-0.2182834744,
0.3643468022,
0.5549403429,
-0.1757966429,
-0.1980907172,
-0.4551029205,
0.5363202095,
0.3501644135,
-1.0018875599,
0.4429445565,
0.4524232447,
0.0732319653,
0.328257829,
0.6166718602,
0.2564515769,
-0.0035679643,
-0.3364450932,
0.087709628,
-0.1436542869,
-0.7372774482,
-0.2291349322,
0.3746494651,
-0.1224757582,
-0.413895458
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06320v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06320v2
|
Zero-shot Generative Large Language Models for Systematic Review Screening Automation
| 2024-01-12T01:54:08 | 2024-02-01T02:08:28 |
Shuai Wang, Harrisen Scells, Shengyao Zhuang, Martin Potthast, Bevan Koopman, Guido Zuccon
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Systematic reviews are crucial for evidence-based medicine as they
comprehensively analyse published research findings on specific questions.
Conducting such reviews is often resource- and time-intensive, especially in
the screening phase, where abstracts of publications are assessed for inclusion
in a review. This study investigates the effectiveness of using zero-shot large
language models~(LLMs) for automatic screening. We evaluate the effectiveness
of eight different LLMs and investigate a calibration technique that uses a
predefined recall threshold to determine whether a publication should be
included in a systematic review. Our comprehensive evaluation using five
standard test collections shows that instruction fine-tuning plays an important
role in screening, that calibration renders LLMs practical for achieving a
targeted recall, and that combining both with an ensemble of zero-shot models
saves significant screening time compared to state-of-the-art approaches.
|
[
-0.1681895405,
-0.3705845773,
0.8735619783,
0.0022556083,
-0.2747083008,
-0.1904983073,
-0.0675979704,
-0.3894708753,
0.0940181687,
0.7890773416,
-0.3075375259,
-0.7802226543,
-0.5870208144,
0.4011231959,
-0.73835361,
0.9764118195,
-0.4126328826,
0.3523063362,
0.2912503481,
-0.1189900115,
-0.3544669449,
-0.2000451237,
-0.2222250849,
-0.6554017663,
0.7183143497,
0.3673549891,
0.2545942962,
0.289095819,
0.6278327703,
0.1720157713,
0.01215587,
-0.0565566383,
-0.50725317,
0.3527198434,
-0.2959864438,
-0.6941779256,
-0.1825975329,
0.0732376352,
0.6221404672,
0.764064908,
-0.2115294635,
0.282720238,
-0.1069545075,
0.6338220835,
-0.9794466496,
-0.1002264395,
-0.4878463745,
0.3007045686,
0.1792553067,
-0.4200191796,
-0.4597185552,
-0.467661351,
-0.0746019557,
-0.2932566702,
0.2266074717,
-0.2195430249,
0.721675992,
0.0795359164,
-0.6228936911,
-0.321752131,
-1.0210394859,
0.7704968452,
-0.7999874949,
0.0385767743,
0.4249062538,
0.3540952206,
0.0232295599,
-0.2030746341,
-0.4428468347,
-0.4841967821,
0.0844304562,
0.1724305004,
0.0969807282,
0.422716707,
0.3657470942,
0.5506850481,
-0.4872050285,
0.2820763588,
-0.5119746327,
-0.2645244896,
0.6027457118,
0.3113307357,
0.169710815,
-0.1030212343,
0.0313098654,
-0.0512969196,
-0.9181816578,
-0.2572317421,
-0.0309303049,
0.1069661453,
0.1852214336,
0.7902215123,
-0.6398704648,
0.828050077,
0.0432085134,
0.0054614395,
0.0307477806,
-0.583239615,
-0.3418745995,
0.0484401435,
0.7080948949,
0.4081484377,
0.2826094925,
0.186050579,
-0.4763010144,
0.0910521075,
0.2992480099,
-0.9967362285,
0.0537921451,
0.4871417284,
-0.3816542029,
-0.4839155972,
-0.123369284,
-0.4239302278,
-0.3683333397,
-0.3075744808,
0.6293715835,
-0.2854069769,
0.0728100836,
0.4038106799,
-0.158836171,
0.2846118808,
0.472610116,
-0.670159936,
-0.0496808812,
0.45933038,
0.7692196965,
0.1126753911,
-0.0540782884,
-0.3142108917,
0.1929202825,
-0.8489178419,
0.9447425604,
-0.267098099,
-0.6791166663,
0.2472220212,
0.0036935175,
-0.184721902,
-0.3641565144,
0.3648318946,
-0.4900867343,
0.1381926686,
-0.1649967283,
-0.6232530475,
-0.1234417334,
0.7506744266,
-0.5819954872,
0.5452187657,
0.1829375476,
-0.3964065611,
0.5851129889,
-0.278188169,
-0.424321115,
0.0587381497,
-0.334255904,
-0.4596199691,
0.1658221036,
0.3195589781,
0.3562376797,
-0.3658824265,
0.2846865952,
-0.3367861211,
-0.6674690843,
0.0662683398,
-0.4148078561,
0.6519239545,
0.2701278329,
-0.4831606746,
0.2264950722,
-0.455750227,
0.0662603304,
0.0069045727,
-0.3037468195,
-0.2653522491,
-0.1544082612,
-0.2367489338,
0.1081798226,
-0.2114580721,
-0.6482981443,
0.2049247026,
-0.4493917525,
0.1030272245,
0.3177882433,
0.4601794779,
0.3527171314,
-0.5367831588,
0.6011427045,
-0.0935560688,
0.3700523078,
-0.6773740053,
-0.1795164347,
-0.8932783008,
0.029742239,
0.6328873038,
0.489544183,
-0.7245943546,
0.7087803483,
-0.0209603757,
-0.6206005812,
-0.3226464391,
0.2149618715,
0.4784918129,
0.3584545851,
-0.1228692308,
-0.7663302422,
-0.2118684798,
-0.734118402,
-0.0002660652,
-0.2219548672,
-0.2369175404,
0.3786936402,
0.6561512351,
-0.321466893,
0.6127840281,
-0.56687814,
-0.602157414,
-0.3953304887,
0.2160551399,
0.1946488172,
0.0160240903,
0.3083033562,
-0.2980109751,
-0.4633719027,
-0.1963472217,
-0.8966958523,
-0.3525674343,
-0.2885360718,
-0.0084625687,
0.3050979376,
0.4260553122,
-0.4866479337,
0.5684284568,
0.3027771413,
0.0620221794,
0.5060046315,
-0.3987404108,
0.5179452896,
-0.4693704247,
0.2542809546,
0.3259979486,
-0.1291432977,
-0.5178684592,
0.1917322576,
0.2710036933,
-0.1533958614,
-0.2404354215,
0.5571734309,
-0.5574685335,
0.3142374456,
-0.2951462567,
-0.0046458193,
0.176334545,
-0.0756898522,
0.1151845232,
0.3557804823,
0.364446789,
-0.6668252945,
0.0244866088,
-0.1180228814,
-0.6750891209,
0.5150173903,
-0.6056491137,
-0.2949533165,
-0.2545535862,
0.6398168206,
-0.8917979002,
-0.3270432353,
0.0881005228,
-0.2110089064,
0.483640492,
-0.0500320569,
-0.3882244527,
-0.5798608065,
-0.6770435572,
0.2245393693,
0.4338085651,
-0.0964287668,
0.2709639668,
0.5869861245,
-0.1899302602,
-0.4512297809,
-0.4969666302,
0.0096737184,
0.1886234432,
-0.0773762986,
-0.0291273203,
0.2165931165,
-0.0638395101,
-0.3193526268,
-0.0533991717,
-0.0344028734,
-0.2324849516,
0.1111674979,
0.4308137,
0.0071839513,
0.1649567634,
-0.0641051158,
0.0320525952,
-0.0588037483,
0.140632689,
0.5023359656,
0.3492556214,
-0.6909074187,
-0.4935325384,
0.2883667052,
0.7793198228,
0.0505772047,
0.1644575894,
0.3902062178,
-0.2762473524,
-0.3899349868,
-0.9336642027,
-0.5759794116,
-0.3497799337,
0.3277353048,
0.1628947407,
-0.7920606732,
0.2220311463,
0.1802234352,
0.1163820177,
0.4850405455,
0.8024392128,
-0.3162626028,
1.0026938915,
0.4996559918,
-0.2012821287,
0.4126050472,
-0.2338090539,
0.3771803975,
-0.8580340743,
-0.1367304921,
-0.4890676737,
-0.2954822481,
-0.3212308288,
-0.6880552173,
0.7067366242,
-0.2973331213,
-0.3010334373,
0.0531380177,
-0.5960096717,
0.4907442927,
0.5780839324,
0.1066517755,
0.3253949583,
0.0998127013,
-0.2901425958,
0.1861998886,
-0.6685730219,
-0.5513498187,
1.7501372099,
0.3431382179,
1.0029835701,
-0.4630814791,
0.8721945286,
0.1443291605,
0.5750454664,
-0.8891700506,
0.6760266423,
-0.038451191,
-1.0577487946,
-0.4601931274,
-0.2544470131,
-0.8539318442,
0.1977786124,
-0.2253629714,
-0.425083667,
0.1471281052,
0.1095824987,
-0.8401393294,
0.3280600607,
-0.5319163799,
0.3639651537,
-0.4269142747,
-0.1969010085,
-0.3190787733,
-0.373400569,
0.8598172069,
-0.304564625,
0.0645685866,
-0.3206443489,
0.1670487225,
0.5255937576,
-0.302215308,
1.0199992657,
-0.0351077057,
-0.0300617199,
0.4174679518,
0.2996512949,
0.151488632,
0.0333529301,
0.0801508799,
0.3831341863,
0.352376163,
-0.0635307655,
-0.2702197731,
0.6646577716,
-0.4898919761,
-0.6787849069,
-0.8879189491,
-0.5009964108,
-0.1368972808,
0.2761983275,
0.0208132733,
0.1503230035,
-0.2639503777,
0.1486843824,
0.6953278184,
-0.4958545268,
0.1163931638,
1.0881867409,
-0.4032918215,
-0.1825004369,
0.4454292953,
0.408852458,
0.3077690005,
0.3370254934,
0.1098203585,
-0.1156353652,
-0.6380636096,
-0.5953922868,
0.3052242398,
-0.3443188071,
-0.2234694362,
-0.725890696,
-0.4321516752,
-0.4877469242,
0.0896320045,
-0.148791492,
-0.2840273678,
0.0204122737,
0.1423630863,
0.1233105659,
0.713429451,
-0.0760684982,
0.2258137017,
-0.8232228756,
0.513800323,
0.1894447803,
0.5587720871,
-0.0195459481,
-0.517121017,
-0.114445433,
-0.1315109432,
-0.5594355464,
-0.9648272991,
0.3516395092,
0.0725959167,
0.5784423947,
0.5362684131,
0.1435770988,
0.4306789935,
-0.6461442113,
0.7048787475,
0.2110434324,
-0.5439447165,
0.6880660057,
-0.4787601531,
0.7574640512,
0.8744705915,
0.4999959767,
-0.7570655346,
-0.310248971,
-0.0566915534,
-1.0181003809,
0.758122623,
-0.028353814,
0.1143709123,
-0.0946840495,
0.1738123596,
-0.1472314596,
0.1430221796,
-0.5555945039,
0.0835686326,
0.3871937394,
-0.046965804,
-0.2435141802,
-0.6236997247,
-0.5852854252,
-0.1807528436,
0.7514922619,
-0.0214032978,
0.1119141132,
0.4778919816,
-0.2403685302,
-0.3811754286,
0.484066546,
0.4559491575,
0.4554639161,
-0.5784150362,
-0.1941302419,
0.0336262621,
-0.6277733445,
0.2806139886,
-0.0434844121,
-0.7583892345,
0.1462658048,
0.2566974461,
0.4203894734,
0.4100345671,
-0.7794592381,
0.518871665,
0.0956515744,
-0.4364075065,
-0.2903343737,
0.1478398591,
-0.2177936137,
-0.2010594755,
0.2131939828,
-0.2049140781,
0.3856296539,
-0.5822494626,
0.2517042458,
0.6201033592,
-0.5426405072,
0.0812301412,
0.3494880497,
0.2440882176,
0.0495860316,
0.7051089406,
-0.0561006851,
-0.2119862437,
0.6302270293,
0.3327734172,
0.8388470411,
-0.3501806259,
0.3744830787,
0.7141481638,
0.5405381918,
-0.3988112211,
0.1125247404,
0.0482034236,
-0.4537347555,
-0.5871171951,
-0.7387750149,
-0.7861471772,
0.1999135613,
-0.3788575828,
0.3817893565,
-0.5789001584,
-0.3060635626,
0.1146284044,
-0.1591788083,
-0.3890784979,
0.322848022,
0.2970457971,
1.0036951303,
-0.9783748388,
0.6125438213,
0.1308317184,
-0.6363390088,
-0.8337991238,
-0.1657627821,
0.3507089317,
-0.7571321726,
0.3137781322,
0.3322125077,
-0.0616217218,
-0.4329114854,
-0.254652679,
-0.8143684268,
1.2178113461,
0.2009504884,
-1.0247584581,
-0.2343750745,
0.0891150907,
0.6364238262,
-0.3397782445,
0.7215831876,
0.6579655409,
0.2353488654,
0.3830122948,
-1.0825775862,
-0.1989647001,
-0.1117476001,
0.0077756718,
0.2126738876,
-0.11981567,
0.6843479872,
-0.3299650848,
-0.2978184819,
0.0953460783,
-0.0568757318,
0.6095514894,
0.4425272048,
0.366114378,
0.5272840858,
0.3787030876,
-0.1277532578,
1.2987169027,
-0.6757409573,
0.2651177347,
0.9566845298,
-0.9366845489,
0.9282029867,
0.3756010532,
-0.1111041754,
0.3656393588,
0.5610111356,
-0.1634506881,
0.2812954187,
0.4168845713,
-0.4014639854,
-0.2622653842,
-0.1203961372,
-0.174154669,
0.2221322954,
0.4162116051,
-0.6994016171,
-0.4547090828,
-0.1302715391,
-0.1417269707,
-0.040730048,
-0.595736146,
0.8018669486,
0.2005698383,
-1.0233939886,
0.6339946389,
-0.0071787299,
0.6380019784,
-0.7626442909,
-0.0845116004,
-0.275406003,
0.3014508486,
-0.2739181221,
-0.7830975652,
0.0628605857,
0.1825440824,
-0.0909174085,
-0.091657646,
0.7329559922,
-0.3281267285,
-0.9076630473,
0.2149913907,
0.4083220065,
0.2433649451,
-0.0186476111,
-0.5149783492,
-0.0424436107,
-0.0634229034,
-0.379617095,
0.3530634642,
0.005459277,
-0.4446520507,
0.5455300808,
0.6755462885,
0.582434535,
-0.1313465089,
0.5326680541,
0.5611945391,
-0.8016639352,
-0.1603206992,
-0.7313147783,
0.2801347375,
-0.0842857584,
-0.006645326,
0.631545186,
0.4754719734,
0.78719908,
-0.174618572,
0.8408167958,
0.3432040513,
0.5777789354,
-0.3725149035,
0.9767528176,
-0.2655462623,
0.220078811,
-0.0636555105,
-0.8946965933,
-0.886310339,
0.6434381008,
-0.6143808365,
0.2029413581,
0.7859438658,
1.0674556494,
0.1946491003,
-0.3655868471,
0.535564065,
0.1134826392,
0.1911747307,
0.7362169027,
0.6173434854,
-0.4782865942,
0.335824728,
-0.1584229022,
-0.3384721279,
-0.4664832652,
-0.8458076119,
-0.7921412587,
-0.0299908295,
-0.3398081958,
-0.4015226662,
0.183280021,
0.8175858855,
0.7183520198,
-0.9375479221,
-0.3411368728,
0.1781603843,
0.003757261,
0.1341822594,
-0.1301475465,
0.1157490388,
-0.3734458387,
-0.6083117723,
0.1368751228,
0.7449864149,
-0.0525083393,
-0.5020892024,
0.1297658682,
-0.1583215147,
0.3728224635,
0.4651884437,
0.4789714217,
-0.633677423,
0.1162799448,
-0.000928332,
-0.4918046594,
-0.2321375757,
0.9436915517,
-0.75932163,
0.8970040679,
0.5239554048,
0.1681738794,
0.6084445119,
-0.2360352874,
0.7526801229,
-0.1252330989,
-0.0471390747,
0.5982154012,
0.4495849907,
0.1932423413,
-0.1303544194,
0.519821465,
-0.0752579272,
-0.7461198568,
-1.0275748968,
0.1875129789,
-0.7398694158,
-0.2034826875,
1.4501879215,
0.0930339545,
-0.2393827438,
-0.1815481186,
-0.2386187762,
0.1163895875,
-0.1934325099,
1.1484193802,
0.6378059387,
0.0161132514,
0.0245761778,
-0.7429351211,
0.2462677509,
0.5091647506,
-0.6203210354,
-0.2263343334,
0.6062330604,
0.5391889811,
0.0467871875,
1.0185428858,
-0.6182230115,
0.4388263226,
-0.2430018485,
0.4066027105,
0.1953301132,
-0.1244746521,
-0.8554794788,
-0.007518163,
0.2789555192,
0.1392402053
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06824v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06824v2
|
Open the Pandora's Box of LLMs: Jailbreaking LLMs through Representation Engineering
| 2024-01-12T00:50:04 | 2024-02-17T04:21:02 |
Tianlong Li, Shihan Dou, Wenhao Liu, Muling Wu, Changze Lv, Xiaoqing Zheng, Xuanjing Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Jailbreaking techniques aim to probe the boundaries of safety in large
language models (LLMs) by inducing them to generate toxic responses to
malicious queries, a significant concern within the LLM community. While
existing jailbreaking methods primarily rely on prompt engineering, altering
inputs to evade LLM safety mechanisms, they suffer from low attack success
rates and significant time overheads, rendering them inflexible. To overcome
these limitations, we propose a novel jailbreaking approach, named Jailbreaking
LLMs through Representation Engineering (JRE). Our method requires only a small
number of query pairs to extract ``safety patterns'' that can be used to
circumvent the target model's defenses, achieving unprecedented jailbreaking
performance. Building upon these findings, we also introduce a novel defense
framework inspired by JRE principles, which demonstrates notable effectiveness.
Extensive experimentation confirms the superior performance of the JRE attacks
and the robustness of the JRE defense framework. We hope this study contributes
to advancing the understanding of model safety issues through the lens of
representation engineering.
|
[
-0.2813134789,
-0.7104754448,
0.6799119711,
0.0386000238,
-0.2058713585,
0.4786708057,
0.199085176,
-0.4002868235,
0.1933814883,
0.9931342006,
-0.5074273348,
-0.6544494629,
-0.6766037345,
-0.1140329614,
-0.2844997048,
0.5846475363,
0.0131709417,
-0.1896082312,
-0.1145550683,
0.0481437668,
-0.7829037309,
-0.689447701,
-0.4054862559,
0.1263812333,
0.4898266196,
0.1621097624,
0.6320715547,
0.7336134315,
0.4179065228,
0.3308582306,
-0.0644050241,
-0.0596353225,
-0.6681604385,
0.4996258318,
-0.1451375335,
-0.8709857464,
-0.2915619016,
-0.0604812913,
0.0854162127,
0.2858971655,
-0.1528264582,
-0.2115546614,
-0.1564601958,
0.7719316483,
-0.9376995564,
0.0841493607,
-0.9888374209,
0.0491007641,
-0.4675197303,
-0.2127632797,
-0.9246766567,
-0.1712884754,
-0.3790543973,
-0.4653820992,
-0.2615589499,
0.2695626915,
0.5067088008,
0.1371978819,
-0.3252648115,
-0.0953270644,
-0.4732380211,
0.5360435843,
-0.6489142776,
0.2458965778,
0.2825205624,
0.5173609853,
-0.5362756252,
-0.3465311229,
-0.0713299885,
-0.5923537016,
-0.0111858062,
-0.1513618827,
-0.3223091364,
0.1822427213,
0.4553469718,
0.0735848546,
-0.5509217381,
0.1917250454,
-0.3119480014,
-0.0580404252,
0.6892924905,
0.0727682784,
0.8127327561,
-0.3595626652,
-0.4497419894,
-0.2237127572,
-1.0836902857,
-0.1112452224,
0.3142345846,
0.2820929885,
0.1127517149,
0.6628300548,
0.1883274466,
0.2564900517,
-0.2991966009,
0.0770241395,
-0.2214487642,
0.2616036534,
-0.2747964263,
0.2225797027,
1.0278716087,
0.3061238527,
0.199912861,
-0.5856583118,
-0.2739563584,
0.0618378259,
0.6884554029,
-0.7776660323,
-0.0373363905,
0.183085829,
-0.383510083,
-0.7712078691,
0.2308487594,
-0.8452140093,
-0.9418336153,
0.3585003018,
0.2442500293,
-0.4812374711,
-0.3130618632,
0.1362867653,
-0.0228860416,
0.1713665724,
-0.0475119799,
-0.9100448489,
0.3999941945,
0.8046330214,
0.7999122739,
0.099207297,
0.1823294759,
-0.5499649048,
0.4736124575,
-0.4808191955,
0.5937635303,
-0.5419945121,
-0.8169432878,
-0.3005629182,
-0.0299340226,
0.1781522483,
-0.7086560726,
0.3248475194,
-0.8605877757,
-0.3654449582,
-0.1909131259,
-0.4750837982,
-0.0232408326,
0.1998491883,
-0.8845475316,
0.4681355059,
-0.1080814302,
-0.6445750594,
0.0467187427,
-0.7368909121,
-0.1829002351,
0.0673378706,
-0.3385996222,
-0.4546155035,
0.3497263491,
0.367946893,
0.3060716093,
-0.1510080844,
0.2526662648,
-0.6617448926,
-0.4218620658,
0.1256303936,
-0.2721244097,
0.9792749286,
0.2945134342,
-0.3032081127,
0.1317078024,
-0.585932374,
-0.227691263,
0.6715524793,
0.0146928523,
-0.7800917625,
0.1661349088,
-0.394072324,
-0.06459108,
0.0462751463,
-0.6938899159,
0.3769263923,
-0.6785499454,
0.6113108993,
0.9572879076,
0.0677635446,
0.4894783497,
-0.1181446686,
0.7442435026,
-0.0708910897,
0.0702761337,
-0.1816845238,
-0.2326492667,
-0.2178624719,
-0.0539314225,
0.2587816715,
0.7714648247,
-0.6429802179,
0.1538683176,
-0.0900648534,
-0.4165736139,
-0.4906997979,
0.1750813127,
0.4208014309,
-0.0638892502,
0.2514538169,
-0.2976507545,
-0.7637090683,
-0.9225667715,
-0.633161366,
-0.3837572336,
0.0521226823,
0.0258089826,
0.3064438701,
-0.1177902818,
0.7114931345,
-0.3604391813,
0.1154318377,
-0.1627678126,
-0.2414535284,
0.1075532734,
0.6374358535,
0.7932556868,
-0.5019475222,
-0.244173795,
-0.0837728903,
-1.1180813313,
-0.1031089947,
0.0602768585,
-0.2449791133,
-0.0835968703,
1.0313764811,
-0.7331910729,
0.4591389,
0.1928154379,
-0.3420268893,
0.5392778516,
0.3463568091,
0.0549349599,
-1.0310302973,
-0.4737122059,
0.0814667046,
-0.3538184762,
-0.5247061849,
0.7174122334,
0.1676992327,
-0.323654592,
-0.5149975419,
0.3337968588,
-0.5889382362,
-0.0008742415,
-0.2708413899,
0.0377550572,
-0.0565314963,
0.0807107165,
-0.4418776035,
0.9108487964,
0.5666387081,
-0.0784502327,
0.2914149463,
0.0916961879,
-0.3460864127,
0.1149592474,
-0.656172514,
0.3161411583,
-0.1886753738,
-0.0190960821,
-0.8770666718,
-0.1997248083,
0.3546034694,
-0.1923253387,
0.6517782807,
-0.6483330131,
-0.5705310106,
-0.2847138047,
-0.4107441902,
0.2746239603,
0.5306279659,
-0.6508143544,
0.5637979507,
0.5353341103,
-0.2248529643,
-0.6776640415,
-0.6225453019,
0.5277450085,
-0.6239141822,
-0.8333314657,
0.335259527,
0.0740607306,
-0.5600103736,
-0.2029809356,
-0.3695828915,
0.2258998454,
0.5345771909,
0.2968657613,
0.3767531812,
-0.2256608158,
-0.2144537121,
0.1214248389,
-0.1789587885,
0.6045762897,
-0.0540001355,
0.4468024373,
0.0272851642,
-0.6268401742,
-0.0379563272,
0.5056910515,
0.7378894091,
-0.2229998261,
0.7473452687,
-0.2248571217,
-0.2989964783,
-0.313896209,
-0.4798001945,
-0.2489847392,
-0.5875228047,
0.4468618631,
-0.6362379193,
-1.0743625164,
0.4784306586,
-0.3377858698,
0.1053020656,
-0.0881859213,
0.1751606166,
-0.0173211358,
1.1754705906,
0.7643783092,
-0.1843899339,
0.4159581363,
0.1451949477,
0.4872491062,
-0.6173403263,
-0.1135759354,
-0.4369348288,
-0.0543901883,
-0.6936995387,
-0.3021351099,
0.4038784206,
0.5699359179,
-0.2446261197,
0.5346461535,
-0.5371420383,
0.866673708,
0.1515225619,
0.1363403201,
0.2977009714,
0.0259930305,
-0.254340291,
-0.1081308201,
-0.3722729981,
-0.9153906703,
1.1525794268,
0.613553822,
0.9832627773,
0.5222674608,
1.0885726213,
0.1566128433,
0.3846663833,
-0.6582448483,
0.8861940503,
-0.0967266411,
-0.5988371968,
-0.0223391093,
-0.4253560603,
-0.865583539,
0.5842146873,
-0.0349007286,
-1.2310390472,
-0.0051563657,
-0.0650056973,
-0.1280422807,
0.6471557617,
-0.7458134294,
0.8744133115,
-0.3593164086,
-0.4593529105,
-0.0122726625,
-0.5992461443,
1.0654481649,
0.0785669163,
0.3942761719,
-0.162484169,
0.2152950615,
0.6472836733,
-0.5748724341,
0.915263176,
-0.3142391145,
-0.239582181,
0.0880168304,
0.7038701177,
0.7575167418,
0.319963485,
-0.0028934367,
-0.2122291625,
0.0999654904,
-0.4824851751,
-0.7958570719,
0.7858787775,
-0.5928933024,
-1.1435899734,
-0.3700674772,
-0.5065124631,
-0.485930413,
0.1645642817,
-0.1053639427,
0.0443265811,
-0.2479646653,
-0.0060417149,
0.9573588967,
-0.4935774207,
0.3701394796,
0.4343498647,
-0.5775381923,
-0.1216583773,
0.8446182013,
-0.077386111,
0.228645727,
0.2863072455,
-0.0152410874,
-0.2012156844,
-0.9558954835,
-0.362672776,
0.0421753675,
-0.6556283832,
-0.2464145422,
-0.5370642543,
-0.3803800344,
-0.2290345579,
-0.1832393408,
-0.4779639244,
-0.2790569365,
0.0211003218,
-0.3301231265,
0.351983279,
0.8914926648,
-0.0056122439,
0.2857978642,
-0.8214149475,
0.3949880302,
0.2719612122,
0.332537204,
-0.1679586321,
-0.2370818257,
0.1114028022,
-0.2879535556,
-0.455470264,
-1.2375667095,
0.2660246491,
-0.546634376,
0.5579901338,
0.2101896852,
0.3043930233,
0.4839041531,
-0.628467083,
0.621557951,
0.3363717794,
-0.7615509033,
0.8958186507,
-0.4496371448,
-0.2875648737,
0.4182627797,
0.089361921,
-0.2434845269,
-0.7279144526,
-0.5179190636,
-0.9940345883,
0.4239199162,
0.1533132493,
0.3007885516,
-0.0947118402,
0.4672101438,
-0.0460425057,
0.0137175042,
-0.9607198834,
-0.2305957824,
-0.1493963748,
-0.0405197069,
0.2830343544,
-0.4072365761,
-0.3366233706,
0.0482875928,
0.5646269917,
0.170618549,
0.1588359475,
-0.197422877,
-0.3298788667,
-0.0083328094,
0.6491327882,
0.3433241248,
0.3302306533,
-0.4354230464,
0.0977295861,
-0.1314645559,
-0.397131443,
0.4803951383,
0.1382549405,
-0.3014189899,
-0.3720216155,
0.2714567482,
0.7667360306,
0.0145607451,
-0.762932837,
0.424824208,
-0.1533763111,
-0.0636234134,
-0.1093298942,
0.4259499311,
0.0496733934,
0.2156924754,
0.245475471,
0.0243411064,
0.0167662669,
-0.5854396224,
0.2874872386,
0.655041337,
-0.3308191597,
0.0486026146,
0.9642916918,
-0.0196090844,
-0.2235613614,
0.2751761377,
-0.1299576014,
-0.1001909599,
0.6487480998,
0.6930277944,
0.9783731103,
-0.1078437641,
0.0651423261,
0.1072570533,
0.8069429398,
-0.061605107,
0.0513883755,
0.3639267087,
-0.5961680412,
-0.5701153278,
-0.5050826073,
-0.3325026035,
0.3229304254,
-0.7201952934,
0.065271318,
-0.8027104139,
0.0015358981,
-0.349129945,
-0.3323364854,
-0.0122110415,
-0.1824019551,
0.3058170378,
1.0901973248,
-0.5970852375,
0.6600808501,
0.713832736,
-0.3169669211,
-0.6043342352,
-0.0977523103,
0.3497909307,
-0.7996889949,
0.4135867059,
0.3138150871,
-0.1013296992,
-0.1157417372,
-0.8840428591,
-0.7072284222,
0.8735705614,
0.7523498535,
-0.9844485521,
-0.0028343231,
0.0840571746,
0.0140361385,
-0.3160502613,
0.1126153246,
0.9307457805,
0.3167544305,
-0.3260990679,
-0.465246141,
0.3990154564,
-0.4788552523,
0.2532846034,
0.3006080091,
-0.4089164138,
0.3254786432,
-0.2839363813,
-0.3215764761,
0.2291025221,
0.5608074665,
0.877976954,
0.1306484491,
0.5121312737,
0.7964648604,
0.5511126518,
-0.2195124924,
1.2440999746,
-0.1137737036,
-0.0089345956,
1.0491474867,
-0.3387597799,
0.6947395205,
0.5845498443,
-0.2820143104,
0.4947221279,
0.3746931553,
0.0398524962,
0.7766799927,
0.6072881222,
-0.3226170838,
-0.189552173,
0.2756281495,
-0.2607731521,
0.3376637995,
0.4574979246,
-0.2640410364,
-0.3118841648,
0.3075433373,
0.2468662113,
0.3778292835,
-0.2550717592,
0.8179706931,
0.2878350019,
-0.1611236185,
0.580663383,
0.202435866,
0.4577648342,
-0.4793388546,
0.0255059451,
-0.122080043,
-0.2251657844,
0.0204352178,
-0.6370859742,
0.2277216464,
0.1205794439,
-0.0738592893,
-0.1558968872,
0.8957899809,
0.1108147502,
-0.2908507884,
0.6711619496,
0.4117722809,
-0.0569204167,
-0.1219811514,
-0.7279316783,
0.487536937,
-0.0906802416,
-0.3033570349,
0.7284296751,
0.3589505851,
-0.1108096018,
0.7660925984,
0.5910612941,
-0.0665322989,
0.3032607138,
0.0845486298,
1.0978592634,
-0.9239485264,
-0.3603366613,
-1.1413059235,
0.623437345,
-0.1617884189,
0.3991407752,
0.6442976594,
0.347933054,
0.6449750662,
0.0428240709,
1.1994372606,
-0.0055571818,
0.2961791456,
-0.7800847292,
0.8824185133,
-0.3667968214,
0.9576531053,
-0.4158021212,
-0.7587394118,
-0.3634981513,
0.509262085,
-0.4271837771,
-0.1617695093,
0.5609734654,
1.0831016302,
-0.0951173902,
0.1260379553,
0.4246780574,
0.6013876796,
0.6997628212,
0.6561231613,
1.1671905518,
-0.5713751316,
0.5895843506,
-0.2216203958,
-0.2506889105,
0.0770859644,
-0.7679385543,
-1.1119242907,
-0.0538262688,
-0.1120114401,
-0.6599776149,
0.4487740695,
0.8214967251,
0.638674438,
-0.8220751882,
-0.195964694,
-0.3240713477,
0.2913203537,
0.053703364,
-0.2295237333,
0.0667717531,
-0.4613636732,
-0.3757978976,
1.1208699942,
0.4701771736,
0.1035254225,
-0.3470003307,
0.0499105863,
0.1534887701,
0.0545062907,
0.6136842966,
0.3943052888,
-0.8272576928,
-0.1860332191,
-0.2895573974,
-0.2364157289,
0.0629336685,
0.8230170608,
-0.6520779133,
0.4282359183,
0.1680706441,
0.8812994361,
0.4034711123,
-0.0471117795,
0.7135321498,
-0.810863018,
0.1559393257,
0.1840017587,
0.4672787488,
0.0881203264,
-0.488779366,
0.4775448143,
0.1860830784,
-0.3334497213,
-1.1974730492,
0.6110265851,
-0.9123959541,
-0.6526123285,
0.7586468458,
-0.0831470191,
-0.4920936227,
-0.1983639449,
-0.1695377678,
-0.1726677418,
-0.376162827,
0.8592069745,
0.5157976747,
0.1714843214,
-0.6292156577,
-0.9564893842,
0.3655725718,
0.2595392764,
-0.8164112568,
0.2434552461,
0.2637849152,
0.3699300587,
0.1454075575,
0.3636870086,
-0.6139205694,
0.1089565381,
-0.0493037328,
-0.0379943475,
-0.192829296,
-0.1774571091,
-0.0679640993,
0.5582905412,
0.2403963655,
0.0279528722
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06310v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06310v2
|
ViSAGe: A Global-Scale Analysis of Visual Stereotypes in Text-to-Image Generation
| 2024-01-12T00:43:57 | 2024-02-22T20:35:02 |
Akshita Jha, Vinodkumar Prabhakaran, Remi Denton, Sarah Laszlo, Shachi Dave, Rida Qadri, Chandan K. Reddy, Sunipa Dev
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Recent studies have shown that Text-to-Image (T2I) model generations can
reflect social stereotypes present in the real world. However, existing
approaches for evaluating stereotypes have a noticeable lack of coverage of
global identity groups and their associated stereotypes. To address this gap,
we introduce the ViSAGe (Visual Stereotypes Around the Globe) dataset to enable
the evaluation of known nationality-based stereotypes in T2I models, across 135
nationalities. We enrich an existing textual stereotype resource by
distinguishing between stereotypical associations that are more likely to have
visual depictions, such as `sombrero', from those that are less visually
concrete, such as 'attractive'. We demonstrate ViSAGe's utility through a
multi-faceted evaluation of T2I generations. First, we show that stereotypical
attributes in ViSAGe are thrice as likely to be present in generated images of
corresponding identities as compared to other attributes, and that the
offensiveness of these depictions is especially higher for identities from
Africa, South America, and South East Asia. Second, we assess the stereotypical
pull of visual depictions of identity groups, which reveals how the 'default'
representations of all identity groups in ViSAGe have a pull towards
stereotypical depictions, and that this pull is even more prominent for
identity groups from the Global South. CONTENT WARNING: Some examples contain
offensive stereotypes.
|
[
-0.477296114,
-0.176394254,
0.2308491468,
0.4391492903,
-0.2716757655,
0.1504740268,
-0.1138897389,
-0.8079258204,
0.3700735569,
0.3998533785,
-0.5270912647,
-0.7435168624,
-0.812754631,
0.2765672803,
-0.1123383269,
0.6310645938,
0.268625319,
-0.0187594704,
-0.2808973789,
-0.2717869878,
-0.482804656,
-0.2063278407,
-0.4837172627,
0.0812025592,
0.3974104822,
0.5867791772,
0.689319849,
0.2849364281,
0.5884254575,
0.1504318416,
0.1655803025,
0.3297495544,
-0.8069764972,
0.0107273767,
-0.4007194042,
-0.3906590044,
-0.4027163088,
0.4573155046,
0.3632113039,
0.4933864474,
0.4144219458,
0.7226594687,
-0.1586225033,
0.5885692835,
-0.67412287,
0.4770050645,
-0.53324157,
0.0195785891,
-0.3958898783,
0.1984709203,
-0.4571703076,
-0.4403989613,
-0.0079035107,
-0.3746417165,
0.4057956338,
0.390319407,
0.826479435,
-0.2634362578,
-0.8217391968,
-0.3525750637,
-0.6427888274,
0.6229014993,
-0.1521099955,
0.0722320452,
0.0378720611,
0.4899962246,
0.0714106485,
-0.5750177503,
-0.3738193214,
-0.0226723365,
-0.2778804004,
0.5096095204,
-0.3333828747,
-0.1934568137,
0.2716233134,
0.2864583433,
-0.7253127098,
-0.1711165607,
-0.6186982989,
-0.121642001,
0.9220330119,
-0.0190992691,
0.8893108964,
-0.3863057196,
-0.3307137489,
0.184559375,
-0.8144267797,
0.0461004227,
0.4614087939,
0.1043019295,
-0.4011264741,
0.6230190396,
0.1085226834,
0.5873251557,
0.05275755,
-0.1754716337,
0.3744336665,
0.0278809555,
0.2289581299,
-0.0054522268,
0.7419016957,
1.255014658,
0.770716548,
-0.1672897637,
-0.0171108153,
0.345245868,
-0.0593821481,
-0.9840971231,
0.1396861225,
-0.3481850922,
-0.8768976927,
-0.5340436697,
0.3742688298,
-1.186207056,
-0.5888819695,
0.2220605612,
0.1153207496,
-0.0921849832,
-0.5739911199,
-0.2675588727,
-0.6919025779,
0.6282397509,
-0.0433769599,
-0.8106464744,
-0.1096391752,
0.4272843301,
0.8865214586,
-0.1474258602,
0.1592098475,
-0.3040071428,
0.1765338629,
-0.5940731764,
0.9680476785,
-0.7882819176,
-0.5605403185,
0.3003920615,
0.1509498358,
0.0521192588,
-0.6280014515,
0.2334727794,
-0.3393764198,
0.0214508828,
-0.6859607697,
0.0711849183,
-0.0310530197,
0.0391748399,
-0.8231350183,
0.8034702539,
0.2812637389,
-1.0193122625,
0.8611765504,
-0.3149596453,
-0.4856107533,
0.0592588596,
-0.5617996454,
-0.1887681484,
0.4215025306,
0.2987041175,
0.373665303,
-0.6929856539,
0.0869200379,
-0.5730465651,
-0.3785654306,
-0.1064112261,
-0.0185368136,
1.0538147688,
0.3060024381,
-0.3787650764,
-0.1128029674,
-0.7094823718,
-0.3579006195,
0.6117630601,
0.2236068249,
-0.7173683643,
-0.0503977314,
0.0349990726,
0.3600688875,
0.0935856476,
-0.6636857986,
0.2811677158,
-0.0564237945,
0.1361662894,
0.5695361495,
0.180434823,
0.4350824058,
-0.0468982197,
0.6127542257,
-0.0095784888,
0.2897557914,
-0.0008009367,
-0.6673818231,
-0.6312066317,
-0.4230199754,
-0.1510571837,
0.6280508041,
-0.8685039282,
0.0352680422,
-0.5531310439,
-0.4283021986,
-0.2272790074,
0.0492461883,
0.3515027761,
0.3780021667,
-0.1723187268,
-0.3226843178,
-0.4990388453,
-1.2643469572,
-0.5966756344,
-0.619002223,
-0.389901489,
0.4525972903,
0.3489150107,
-0.1042565107,
0.9575272202,
-0.5009511113,
-0.3055439293,
-0.4087767601,
0.1898752749,
-0.1721692681,
-0.0272049159,
1.1304352283,
-0.7084525824,
-0.5374351144,
-0.2600977421,
-1.211630702,
-0.34181723,
0.0074578668,
-0.2960127592,
0.1773808002,
0.6279244423,
-0.1747346371,
0.4868428707,
0.4479312897,
-0.6797804236,
0.3835566938,
-0.0329136886,
0.3991964161,
-0.8571607471,
0.034324728,
0.4661146104,
0.0764734074,
-0.3925274611,
0.1185241938,
0.2536618412,
-0.292209208,
-0.303355515,
0.8429831862,
-0.6362580061,
-0.1243489534,
0.3390307724,
0.0978951827,
0.1379241496,
-0.1416066289,
0.1510249674,
0.843842268,
0.6434019208,
-0.1237040162,
0.3216525912,
0.2847017944,
-0.4872258306,
1.0185387135,
-0.4608887434,
0.2287301272,
-0.7422733903,
0.1300379187,
-1.2975629568,
-0.3508243859,
0.2177456766,
-0.4207753539,
0.248743102,
-0.2754295468,
-0.4177723229,
-0.5049771667,
-0.2283965796,
0.5839804411,
0.7745035291,
-0.8942076564,
0.8796531558,
0.4449869692,
-0.091914691,
-0.4005130529,
-0.480969429,
0.4488843977,
-0.6674577594,
-1.0926532745,
0.1024451405,
0.3768915534,
-0.573230207,
-0.4789062142,
-0.0347969979,
0.2947022319,
-0.5623916984,
0.3797908425,
0.4232018292,
0.0536148734,
-0.1016278937,
-0.2243908048,
0.1699708551,
0.2765566409,
-0.2153967768,
0.2376892865,
-0.2142909318,
0.2539053559,
0.2287880629,
0.4311350882,
0.4147574306,
-0.5229817033,
0.7029145956,
0.6878206134,
-0.0665844232,
-0.1156643406,
-0.5469788313,
0.2894727588,
-0.4633281231,
0.3384157121,
-0.4622768462,
-0.3642322421,
0.7348508835,
-0.1528923959,
0.0334393866,
0.7433575988,
0.1508832276,
-0.2701948285,
1.1415219307,
0.9653888941,
0.1441447437,
0.3001627326,
-0.3699759841,
0.193008706,
-0.3871999681,
-0.6944963932,
-0.3551446795,
-0.2617103755,
-0.9246817827,
-0.4201725423,
0.485925138,
-0.1610378474,
-0.2336887419,
0.0135633647,
-0.2723123729,
0.5100046992,
0.1756313443,
0.0127431368,
0.0727532282,
0.5249205232,
-0.0358607955,
-0.3315040767,
-0.5385966897,
-0.6234180927,
1.0538141727,
-0.0211785212,
0.8843679428,
0.1802117676,
0.5075438619,
0.4938826263,
0.5954013467,
-0.6825068593,
0.8877553344,
-0.7173983455,
-0.5368295312,
0.2860027552,
-0.3681369722,
-0.7843720913,
-0.0680576116,
-0.3714796007,
-0.899969399,
0.3969543576,
0.3318580091,
0.1356753707,
0.2994621992,
-0.6447972059,
0.7867951393,
-0.1036014855,
-0.382394284,
-0.019799307,
-0.7942596674,
0.7678772211,
0.209448427,
0.5304680467,
-0.2043243498,
0.1221440285,
0.6060743332,
-0.0216998272,
0.7940564156,
-0.2947258055,
-0.1013432667,
0.4959654212,
0.2180850208,
0.1185093895,
-0.0673440769,
-0.1036519185,
0.6296112537,
-0.3217718899,
-0.4997446239,
-0.4500288069,
0.5029392838,
-0.6516211629,
-0.4291508496,
-0.2067587078,
-0.3100911975,
-0.0621669553,
-0.0432402194,
0.6497460008,
0.3348605037,
-0.4919857383,
-0.3246605694,
0.4966337383,
-0.6400493979,
0.0324629135,
-0.1466047317,
-0.7008590698,
-0.3519080281,
1.1315757036,
0.2617124915,
0.4674603045,
-0.1376257092,
0.1722388566,
-0.1140770242,
0.242662847,
-0.3671531379,
0.4149202704,
-0.7974875569,
0.168623805,
-0.3788497448,
-0.0770028904,
-0.5284627676,
-0.2637505233,
0.0018538127,
-0.3046344221,
0.0367541127,
0.104678981,
0.233123675,
0.6929921508,
-0.2257130891,
0.4695008099,
-0.2692176104,
0.7129311562,
0.4784701169,
0.4286188483,
-0.3386792541,
-0.4349623919,
0.3180442154,
-0.5747057796,
0.0281574726,
-1.2098903656,
0.2555192709,
0.3142218888,
0.3109813333,
0.8249633908,
-0.0054654437,
0.4056517184,
-0.4734366834,
0.6924446821,
0.506631732,
-0.348736614,
0.5171685815,
-0.3976640999,
0.1763115525,
0.3264977634,
0.3006388545,
-0.8078046441,
-0.4860660136,
-0.5591196418,
-0.769605577,
0.2591515183,
-0.0433516949,
0.2076095641,
-0.3066963553,
0.4294321537,
0.1420834661,
-0.0456481054,
-0.6730794311,
-0.4558211565,
-0.4324263334,
-0.3677569628,
-0.0818046629,
-0.3811450899,
0.0416424684,
-0.0628499687,
0.282405138,
-0.0861688852,
0.294100076,
-0.0489281826,
-0.2193587869,
0.0085350238,
0.0079515902,
-0.0837677643,
0.5136966705,
-0.3204119205,
0.2927348018,
-0.1855144352,
-0.5260395408,
0.192075789,
-0.2290864289,
-0.4976911247,
0.2716222703,
0.2239113003,
0.7090467811,
-0.5717331767,
-0.5385884643,
0.6900603771,
-0.2887164354,
-0.269251138,
-0.422224611,
0.0983896405,
-0.1103356779,
0.1234207153,
0.270116508,
0.2359257787,
0.176511988,
-0.7473365068,
-0.280998975,
0.6918126941,
-0.3560293019,
-0.2193786353,
0.7417141199,
0.3936177492,
-0.1821721047,
0.7355993986,
-0.3946758509,
-0.2840751708,
0.8709706664,
0.678827405,
0.6596937776,
0.0169494934,
0.5566235185,
0.8658146858,
0.7801038623,
0.2251167744,
0.3364789784,
0.4107407629,
-0.4993779361,
0.1309973747,
-0.4802738726,
0.1325035542,
0.0338526182,
-0.4934660494,
0.3621375561,
-0.5630818605,
-0.2580049932,
0.0371394344,
-0.4429449439,
-1.0897524357,
0.3388961256,
0.632527709,
0.8079522848,
-1.5070382357,
0.1362222284,
0.7763801813,
-0.4900516868,
-0.4039211273,
0.3074495494,
0.2975759208,
-0.9045357108,
0.8907510042,
0.7038539052,
-0.2606571615,
-0.1678877622,
-0.9274817109,
-0.690510273,
0.7176782489,
0.4515700638,
-0.3487196267,
-0.2187432349,
0.4222767353,
0.2451656461,
-0.7303955555,
0.194612816,
0.9561489224,
0.4812009037,
0.4486309886,
-0.2911037803,
0.0141649637,
-0.3741122484,
0.4699158072,
-0.1699877083,
-1.0006884336,
0.377047956,
-0.6453235745,
-0.4578291476,
-0.1241962463,
0.5807259679,
0.3577184081,
0.1946134567,
0.6989495754,
0.1544457376,
0.4631511271,
-0.2011024058,
0.8025127649,
-0.173543334,
-0.0376312807,
0.7537568212,
-0.1552872062,
0.2300918698,
0.3984817266,
-0.0004334027,
0.353461206,
0.6331120729,
-0.362760365,
0.3859502375,
0.2214205265,
-0.3589140177,
-0.3038854897,
-0.2446761429,
-0.2323941439,
0.6847862005,
0.3393071592,
-0.5038920641,
-0.3604998887,
0.1656185091,
-0.0737877041,
0.0709508583,
-0.6454995871,
0.6296237111,
0.0133262249,
-0.3449883163,
0.2682832778,
-0.2391442358,
0.5763963461,
-0.1988409758,
-0.106906794,
-0.7002558112,
-0.1126182228,
-0.3571905196,
-0.5215685368,
0.1045859307,
0.3770586848,
-0.186882481,
0.1236653477,
1.1008799076,
-0.2533977926,
-1.1457335949,
0.3762146235,
0.2759416103,
0.3952155113,
0.2445521951,
-0.3625173569,
-0.2049076259,
0.1182356402,
-0.0346513018,
0.0198186841,
0.4118439257,
-0.4707248807,
0.3566813469,
-0.0324433446,
0.1774639934,
0.1601505429,
0.2701229453,
0.2429133654,
-0.503454864,
-0.3153274655,
-0.7793489099,
0.5127796531,
-0.4740726054,
0.0208383072,
0.6361165643,
0.5405600667,
0.7018740773,
-0.1628862023,
1.1441483498,
-0.4097104669,
0.0620332845,
-0.1916355342,
0.8928918242,
-0.7758384347,
-0.081960246,
-0.4029929638,
-1.0143699646,
-0.2894620895,
0.6179901361,
-0.5821108818,
0.0892294496,
0.3252264559,
0.7910359502,
-0.1887553781,
-0.189184472,
0.2343145162,
0.218466118,
0.2267469019,
0.0278080031,
0.819656074,
-0.1659234464,
0.5737267733,
0.1387553364,
-0.6166311502,
0.0751499981,
-0.9507867098,
-1.0731163025,
-0.2510761917,
-0.2809841037,
-0.6204630136,
0.0321466886,
0.7340394855,
0.5789121985,
-0.3694359958,
-0.3108925521,
0.4450308681,
-0.2418670654,
0.0547701269,
-0.1646860391,
0.2631308138,
-0.1775487363,
-0.6131330132,
-0.2436991632,
0.4475590289,
0.0894882753,
-0.2766011655,
0.228890717,
0.4326836765,
0.3550698459,
0.8450224996,
0.0857542157,
-0.4748255014,
-0.2155972868,
-0.0581822433,
-0.0830081031,
0.3112381995,
0.6482992768,
-0.5181358457,
0.5973191261,
0.3235682845,
0.0022345532,
0.458135128,
-0.1006283835,
0.5352146029,
-0.8602377772,
0.3972715437,
-0.3398329318,
0.3685875535,
0.4868605137,
-0.2289903462,
0.5792700052,
0.4347327352,
-0.1827287972,
-0.3800206482,
0.392932713,
-0.8564267755,
-0.0496440977,
1.3200573921,
-0.127234742,
-0.2032660693,
0.2875401378,
-0.3647476435,
0.3654796183,
-0.1668820977,
1.0396845341,
0.4865426719,
0.1634196788,
-0.0227165706,
-0.8725504875,
0.381291002,
0.0344403945,
-0.9247598052,
0.0701449886,
0.8924233317,
0.5584082603,
-0.1189812124,
0.4597004056,
-0.2856648862,
-0.0314855091,
0.1840452999,
0.356333971,
0.3047834933,
-0.485712707,
0.1656731814,
0.1394859999,
-0.0660460293,
0.0126195764
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06301v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06301v1
|
Misconfidence-based Demonstration Selection for LLM In-Context Learning
| 2024-01-12T00:11:24 | 2024-01-12T00:11:24 |
Shangqing Xu, Chao Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In-context learning with large language models (LLMs) excels at adapting to
various tasks rapidly. However, its success hinges on carefully selecting
demonstrations, which remains an obstacle in practice. Current approaches to
this problem either rely on hard-to-acquire external supervision or require
frequent interactions with LLMs, resulting in high costs. We propose a new
method called In-Context Reflection (ICR) to overcome these challenges. ICR
strategically selects demonstrations to reduce the discrepancy between the
LLM's outputs and the actual input-output mappings. Specifically, ICR starts
with a random set of initial demonstrations, then iteratively refines it. In
each step, it analyzes a pool of candidate examples and identifies the ones
most likely to challenge the LLM's current understanding, measured by a new
metric called misconfidence. These most confusing examples are then selected to
replace the less informative demonstrations in the current set. Our
comprehensive evaluation across five diverse datasets encompassing 13 subtasks
shows the efficacy of ICR. Compared to existing methods, ICR achieves an
average performance boost of 4%, while demonstrating remarkable cross-task
generalization capabilities.
|
[
-0.3631280661,
-0.6218849421,
0.509355545,
0.5251818299,
-0.352743119,
0.0654078946,
-0.3123296499,
-0.1122539341,
-0.2968549728,
0.1452239901,
-0.3538787067,
-0.5068251491,
-0.5654171705,
0.089703083,
-0.3714106977,
0.8950713277,
-0.2036647946,
0.1698092222,
-0.6527855396,
0.0220471416,
-0.5705742836,
-0.1468973309,
-0.5460140705,
-0.5952712893,
0.155457139,
1.0024559498,
0.1595290154,
0.233637616,
0.1771231294,
0.2615359724,
0.0531480387,
0.516485095,
-0.57407552,
-0.0232890062,
-0.2442593127,
-0.3379696608,
0.1690920442,
0.0414165631,
0.5798946619,
0.589389205,
-0.1765249372,
0.130093798,
0.4916101396,
0.3776724041,
-0.9850184917,
0.1126874089,
-0.6964164376,
0.1360283047,
-0.0050920369,
-0.2173152417,
-0.5957400799,
-0.3955444992,
0.3187534809,
-0.4595525563,
0.1352709383,
0.0226027612,
0.4233779907,
0.2631363869,
-0.4709508717,
-0.3423265815,
-0.8926339149,
0.92143327,
-0.5887104869,
0.4173478782,
0.2209206522,
0.4943528473,
-0.243970111,
-0.7255423665,
-0.4090346098,
-0.4395272732,
-0.082698971,
0.3799001873,
-0.0543857589,
-0.1885714829,
0.2231052965,
0.0936676636,
-0.3346792459,
0.1165758595,
-0.0817359537,
-0.2368267924,
0.3484528363,
0.1318911761,
0.0034387379,
0.1366073936,
-0.5540738702,
-0.278840065,
-0.9495062828,
0.1497065276,
-0.0150967315,
0.1881649941,
0.019431524,
0.3689472079,
-0.2620273232,
0.4682818651,
0.3501746655,
-0.3339803517,
0.0166839231,
-0.046005182,
-0.2851078212,
0.2176124752,
0.5440858603,
0.2921976447,
-0.1631501168,
-0.1558216661,
-0.1631735414,
-0.1024258956,
0.0843555704,
-0.799682498,
-0.0812138095,
0.0024096675,
-0.2522991598,
-0.1062442511,
-0.028754862,
-0.9205325842,
-0.4059650004,
-0.084225677,
0.6955527663,
-0.3254854083,
0.0422540866,
-0.0060583525,
-0.0917924717,
0.0757321119,
0.5592356324,
-0.3509583473,
0.4286316633,
0.4641758502,
0.7489974499,
-0.3632237911,
-0.4586001039,
-0.829012692,
0.1902074367,
-0.3800539672,
0.6746442914,
-0.487193495,
-0.4747129381,
0.155759722,
-0.3205328882,
-0.1990377754,
-0.8676396608,
0.3715259433,
-0.2481408268,
0.3441433311,
-0.2818179727,
-0.6110141277,
-0.1141523793,
0.3681514561,
-0.2695437372,
1.0436711311,
0.1823769957,
-0.6489238739,
0.6421453953,
-0.563549757,
-0.3917045593,
-0.0357348509,
-0.5221329331,
-0.4567169547,
0.0020719073,
0.2935968339,
0.6130997539,
-0.1152036786,
0.1655591428,
-0.206090048,
-0.8119248748,
0.3146483898,
-0.4832186997,
0.2938877642,
0.0505390428,
-0.8955828547,
0.0163904913,
-0.5319178104,
-0.2127693594,
-0.1024177372,
-0.3982855082,
-0.4919356704,
0.169315055,
-0.223071605,
0.4514594376,
0.0213731062,
-0.5182704329,
-0.0485377684,
-0.4617302418,
0.0493063889,
0.6781095862,
0.1013362631,
0.2919440567,
-0.4418201745,
0.5788753033,
0.2141218036,
0.2366221398,
0.0452214889,
-0.2643693984,
-0.8527159095,
-0.1935105175,
-0.0856573731,
0.4281072021,
-0.9325259328,
-0.0046800678,
-0.1910238266,
-0.4841573238,
-0.2876000106,
0.2443252355,
0.8911651969,
0.8268213272,
0.5213096738,
-0.115393579,
-0.3329769969,
-0.9066622257,
-0.3096863627,
-0.2168954909,
0.0879368782,
0.4013565481,
0.4545867145,
-0.0506706685,
0.8002015352,
-0.3100007474,
-0.4956556261,
-0.4016643763,
0.1269708425,
0.0447696336,
0.3480373025,
0.317571938,
-0.7225487232,
-0.6755637527,
0.0214691218,
-0.3976508379,
0.0399098657,
-0.362395525,
0.025359422,
0.269836694,
0.7392340302,
-0.2044503093,
0.4591185153,
0.3719038963,
-0.0811461061,
0.6148739457,
-0.3499369025,
0.1229753867,
-0.9234884381,
-0.1973224878,
0.1377841383,
-0.1763139814,
-0.348596096,
-0.2216394097,
0.2370588779,
0.4339151084,
-0.6604834199,
0.5722173452,
-0.4508532584,
0.0587624833,
-0.1576859206,
0.1869566292,
-0.1774822474,
0.4683461189,
-0.0471384972,
0.9506791234,
0.3751887679,
-0.6709997058,
-0.0798465982,
0.4017618001,
-0.6776335239,
0.4798184633,
-0.2217631638,
0.1450293064,
0.0792850703,
0.3934885263,
-1.1080000401,
-0.2405111939,
0.2609829009,
-0.073140718,
0.2922673821,
-0.197148025,
-0.3938766718,
-0.0873584151,
-0.2351361066,
0.2433297336,
0.4138557315,
-0.8420051932,
0.5875233412,
0.040288046,
0.0131652132,
-0.9016937613,
-0.7072582245,
-0.0034229339,
-0.4401037097,
-0.1018959656,
0.3987158239,
-0.1456169635,
-0.2917920351,
-0.3375964165,
-0.3176485896,
0.2270605415,
0.1129720733,
0.4810909331,
0.1247747689,
-0.0338718556,
0.0291646849,
0.3045522571,
0.2003456801,
0.0479766466,
-0.021007495,
0.272161603,
-0.2636035979,
-0.758610487,
-0.3898452818,
0.3485393524,
0.432859838,
0.1220665872,
0.3935659528,
0.3231805861,
-0.2102436721,
-0.7205941677,
-0.6976441741,
-0.0692101866,
-0.5116611719,
0.6252135038,
-0.3022699654,
-0.8342256546,
0.2174204141,
-0.3712951541,
0.0916463062,
-0.0989822894,
0.3423496783,
-0.2068703324,
1.0200922489,
0.5330328345,
-0.1483674049,
0.5660917163,
-0.2739322782,
0.1686354727,
-0.8342908621,
-0.4347585738,
-0.2816956341,
-0.2551841438,
-0.2397104502,
-0.4943098426,
0.5925868154,
0.0563008375,
-0.2566507161,
0.1076213941,
-0.1839171499,
0.570910573,
0.5156417489,
0.2160678953,
0.3141655326,
-0.0585581101,
-0.4320014715,
-0.210811913,
-0.7297872901,
-0.5506975055,
0.9432080388,
0.0835387185,
0.7129976749,
0.2297564894,
0.6917373538,
0.0853246972,
0.7764570713,
-0.6392264962,
0.6496412754,
-0.1351516545,
-0.2751408219,
-0.2929843068,
-0.3669947982,
-0.6534790397,
0.4739773571,
-0.1176395044,
-0.7353119254,
0.1926112026,
0.4952068627,
-0.2309090197,
0.2461871058,
-0.7604497075,
0.8020598888,
-0.2065261006,
-0.3493288457,
-0.2281629443,
-0.5437468886,
0.4703771174,
-0.0543456823,
0.2299272418,
0.3583692908,
0.0851628333,
0.4133128822,
-0.1909923106,
1.0175091028,
-0.4127288461,
-0.1347314864,
0.113419123,
0.4455038309,
0.7685074806,
0.0514260978,
0.0192404985,
-0.368411988,
-0.3084836304,
0.016976269,
-0.7209489346,
0.7448391914,
-0.3915581405,
-0.6211559772,
-0.1331650168,
-0.3367790878,
-0.6583195329,
-0.1716094166,
0.4385479987,
0.4171393514,
-0.4586088061,
0.170233205,
0.7384580374,
-0.2689286768,
0.4742469788,
0.3731616437,
-0.1329340935,
-0.2813326418,
1.0905681849,
0.0579552725,
0.4846565127,
0.4506643116,
0.3246686161,
-0.2940628231,
-0.7651914358,
-0.252451092,
0.0590581596,
-0.9841583967,
-0.1957205236,
-0.6306425333,
0.0794388354,
-0.1305208951,
-0.2206328958,
-0.2667810619,
-0.1553200632,
-0.3399164081,
-0.0379775949,
-0.0891692713,
0.5392859578,
0.0804755911,
0.4027063847,
-0.3423632085,
-0.0149421655,
0.6651713252,
0.1480396539,
0.078636393,
-0.682852447,
-0.3114868999,
-0.144795686,
-0.6281884909,
-0.6667991877,
0.2568821907,
0.5202046633,
0.7155889273,
0.7251059413,
0.149533093,
1.0215293169,
-0.4237032831,
0.697059691,
0.0447849073,
-1.0118708611,
0.6138246059,
-0.015438715,
-0.0013159264,
0.6374421716,
0.3345487118,
-0.4486809373,
-0.7031168342,
-0.5726302862,
-0.8891767263,
0.6673761606,
-0.0366711318,
0.0398209579,
0.0103661707,
0.1481704414,
0.2331489176,
0.1400057971,
-0.5851771832,
-0.3234614432,
-0.2541668415,
-0.1731064022,
-0.2506532967,
-0.1308174878,
-0.3933637142,
-0.2002297938,
0.7703620791,
-0.5070211887,
0.1002915651,
0.3921565711,
-0.4954116642,
0.0166868921,
0.2792503536,
0.803019762,
0.7508479953,
-0.0777276307,
0.2739134133,
0.5790701509,
-0.3296264112,
0.122457549,
-0.0538972355,
-0.0395787694,
0.0796645433,
0.440061003,
0.6857549548,
0.583221674,
-0.8749422431,
0.9392154217,
0.0120063052,
-0.1829252094,
-0.4990108907,
0.2059898973,
-0.0263441596,
0.4602231681,
0.4124316275,
-0.0114714177,
0.2730912566,
-0.3683780432,
0.2546236813,
0.4454038739,
-0.5993760228,
-0.1082416326,
0.4186061621,
-0.0769340917,
-0.1405450851,
0.3740947843,
-0.2041803151,
-0.3534897268,
0.6349403262,
0.7738789916,
0.7850720286,
-0.1602577418,
0.4150053859,
0.2100010365,
0.1402157098,
-0.3252852559,
0.151296407,
-0.1952497512,
-0.7675932646,
-0.3896917105,
-0.1490471363,
-0.7335779667,
0.2000891715,
-0.6931856275,
0.2459947169,
-0.3448336124,
0.142079547,
-0.4518331587,
-0.1649039835,
-0.4929046631,
0.216988638,
0.1071551591,
1.0807782412,
-1.010845542,
0.7355514169,
0.6815893054,
-0.1356394887,
-0.6397131681,
0.4627713263,
0.0822806358,
-0.5450854897,
0.6996465921,
0.1302015036,
-0.3777182102,
-0.1567478627,
-0.7124038339,
-0.5419501066,
1.2256935835,
0.5310284495,
-0.4040547311,
0.178491652,
0.0287402086,
0.3590807617,
-0.7539257407,
0.3800941408,
0.2942165434,
0.2822340131,
0.1240716949,
-0.7714855671,
0.0402445607,
0.1159809306,
0.1244824603,
-0.2126335353,
-0.8500967622,
0.532813251,
-0.2714843154,
-0.2409176081,
-0.0718017519,
0.7560674548,
0.7199029922,
0.5148956776,
0.8424876928,
0.0812690556,
0.6000037193,
0.0072956653,
0.7993304133,
0.2789683938,
0.0849637687,
1.5423967838,
-0.5172991157,
0.947588563,
0.9570878148,
0.033468809,
0.6418613791,
0.5326299071,
0.2072580308,
0.7593287826,
0.2934529185,
-0.3684051633,
-0.4821866751,
-0.0951888338,
-0.0894966125,
0.4391613007,
0.4314985573,
-0.099411428,
-0.3605510592,
0.2372758538,
-0.0821792856,
0.3058125675,
-0.1192719787,
0.746196866,
0.0434134714,
-0.6786815524,
0.413413018,
-0.3099308312,
0.7800090909,
-0.547927618,
-0.3800216615,
-0.3883270621,
0.3023631871,
-0.0558070987,
-0.5017310977,
0.0614825189,
-0.080277212,
0.1305506229,
-0.3696871698,
0.454254806,
-0.5562843084,
-0.192211628,
0.4793625474,
0.4477533698,
0.0965155587,
-0.0887623131,
-0.3577214181,
-0.2788781524,
-0.0003568239,
-0.147866562,
0.5467429757,
0.5308849812,
-0.2676303387,
0.9293278456,
0.2739440799,
-0.0140256686,
-0.0169828329,
0.0222818311,
0.9016799927,
-0.3456201553,
-0.3166751862,
-0.7107225657,
0.5226792097,
-0.1734957099,
-0.5438818932,
0.7579895258,
0.7406978607,
1.3691476583,
-0.106122613,
0.9383257627,
0.2724228501,
0.59228158,
-0.5135453343,
0.5483746529,
-0.655248642,
0.3668859899,
-0.5229508877,
-0.6416449547,
-0.2048676014,
0.6227799654,
-0.2030682117,
-0.1291899532,
0.7970402241,
0.9009553194,
-0.3019345999,
-0.1207812577,
0.4753178358,
0.1888065487,
0.3792358041,
0.6055545211,
1.2080123425,
-0.2832663655,
0.755952239,
-0.4911701083,
-0.3041612208,
-0.3714193106,
-1.1027578115,
-0.8853427172,
-0.5463535786,
-0.4826332033,
-0.1660936326,
-0.0192034189,
1.2002942562,
0.6718204618,
-0.7968612909,
-0.4690285027,
0.0184703805,
0.1684225202,
-0.6333883405,
-0.180868119,
0.2654526532,
-0.4001308084,
-0.6745812297,
0.7910366058,
0.0615275539,
0.0716762394,
-0.1256268471,
-0.3226542473,
-0.0709054396,
-0.0102845924,
0.3965337873,
0.1738609672,
-0.7679252625,
-0.3944995403,
-0.2899302542,
0.0101225246,
0.08880876,
0.745977819,
-0.7725083232,
0.2979393899,
0.1603783369,
0.7500658631,
0.663077116,
-0.188202858,
0.4258257151,
-0.980119288,
-0.0224763118,
0.2102077305,
0.3427275717,
0.3210531473,
-0.3811081648,
0.2059353739,
0.0564524122,
-0.3992718756,
-0.9145414829,
0.1425406635,
-0.7853053808,
-0.2744042575,
1.1614015102,
-0.3042615652,
0.0214314535,
-0.2358630598,
-0.1912654489,
0.1394164413,
-0.3840113878,
1.1226944923,
0.6262520552,
-0.1970549524,
-0.0685325265,
-0.5312352777,
0.5678933263,
0.5832374692,
-0.6201500297,
0.125309661,
0.4428900182,
0.3790165484,
-0.0259098429,
0.4083390236,
-0.028606493,
0.2140098363,
-0.4374637008,
-0.0521021634,
-0.0644351467,
-0.5524605513,
-0.4616143405,
0.2118463069,
0.0621479675,
-0.2560282648
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05939v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05939v1
|
Uncertainty Awareness of Large Language Models Under Code Distribution Shifts: A Benchmark Study
| 2024-01-12T00:00:32 | 2024-01-12T00:00:32 |
Yufei Li, Simin Chen, Yanghong Guo, Wei Yang, Yue Dong, Cong Liu
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have been widely employed in programming
language analysis to enhance human productivity. Yet, their reliability can be
compromised by various code distribution shifts, leading to inconsistent
outputs. While probabilistic methods are known to mitigate such impact through
uncertainty calibration and estimation, their efficacy in the language domain
remains underexplored compared to their application in image-based tasks. In
this work, we first introduce a large-scale benchmark dataset, incorporating
three realistic patterns of code distribution shifts at varying intensities.
Then we thoroughly investigate state-of-the-art probabilistic methods applied
to CodeLlama using these shifted code snippets. We observe that these methods
generally improve the uncertainty awareness of CodeLlama, with increased
calibration quality and higher uncertainty estimation~(UE) precision. However,
our study further reveals varied performance dynamics across different criteria
(e.g., calibration error vs misclassification detection) and trade-off between
efficacy and efficiency, highlighting necessary methodological selection
tailored to specific contexts.
|
[
-0.0241801329,
-0.536123395,
0.5836423635,
0.1872403473,
-0.138986811,
0.0555834547,
-0.5600198507,
-0.4491501153,
-0.1668332517,
0.3147977889,
-0.2274318337,
-0.5951841474,
-0.7647061348,
-0.2695574164,
-0.3709048927,
0.538955152,
-0.1893434227,
-0.0323826745,
-0.0434286594,
0.0040164669,
-0.1551491469,
-0.294136107,
-0.1571240574,
-0.1465280354,
0.1695133448,
0.2467255741,
1.0429996252,
0.5862455964,
0.869355619,
0.1375637501,
0.1436445713,
-0.0636823326,
-0.2683224976,
0.0937341973,
0.0401688218,
-0.8736432195,
-0.1194865406,
-0.4979508817,
0.8078204989,
0.660623014,
-0.3907851279,
0.2852246761,
0.0033514765,
0.5870363712,
-1.1519303322,
0.3577104211,
-0.6734378338,
-0.1147660688,
-0.3896326423,
-0.0929950848,
-0.3827315569,
-0.5889581442,
-0.1174375936,
-0.5264456272,
-0.2210591882,
-0.2470698953,
0.5175912976,
0.5591191053,
-0.2219515443,
-0.3921929896,
-0.9017573595,
0.913182497,
-0.9557167292,
0.4190046191,
0.4241048992,
0.2712485492,
-0.265373677,
-0.53253901,
-0.3369101882,
-0.0234624352,
0.5125533342,
0.0632006079,
-0.2355992794,
-0.1665337831,
0.1922077239,
0.2621564269,
-0.3209721446,
0.3742925823,
0.0479122885,
-0.3268561959,
0.6295214891,
-0.0799601674,
0.029840054,
0.3363251686,
-0.1573669761,
-0.4025569558,
-0.8086645603,
0.1544792354,
0.4107078314,
0.0311757866,
-0.0540036224,
0.297549963,
0.0222646222,
0.6931343079,
-0.3204320967,
-0.3882170618,
0.401979208,
-0.1009479761,
-0.2525395453,
-0.3016533852,
0.6528224349,
0.3229544461,
0.4182266891,
0.1450286806,
-0.2440611273,
0.1714145094,
0.1819676012,
-0.5131453872,
-0.4313988388,
0.1113756746,
-0.3747057617,
-0.3410382867,
-0.0023502107,
-0.8186824322,
-0.5723777413,
-0.0006293157,
0.182529971,
-0.4139762223,
-0.5013220906,
0.3731411397,
0.2884028554,
0.182728529,
0.3883239031,
-0.6985484362,
-0.1002040803,
0.591871202,
0.4394676983,
-0.1014276445,
-0.0205458738,
-0.1690809429,
0.0450188406,
-0.7945525646,
0.5215941668,
-0.6590753794,
-0.1792196333,
0.3326896429,
-0.4410628676,
-0.1079410464,
-0.7313928604,
0.4357116222,
-0.6247745156,
-0.4075379074,
-0.0770086274,
-0.5968710184,
0.0338332579,
-0.0035792026,
-0.4421444535,
1.1187183857,
0.1848267168,
-0.6991964579,
0.3266239762,
-0.0600686036,
-0.2778839767,
-0.0671327785,
-0.4167792499,
-0.5093014836,
0.4733709395,
0.1391520649,
0.3764047623,
-0.1559598595,
0.3461467624,
-0.3751063049,
-0.5215501785,
0.738093257,
-0.727289319,
0.6097564697,
0.4068106413,
-0.4631374776,
-0.1679132879,
-0.6106002331,
0.2057918012,
-0.1411668807,
-0.2647455931,
-0.331467092,
0.1965651661,
0.047610499,
0.1123893857,
0.1993179023,
-0.0941489413,
0.2322110683,
-0.1245977357,
0.1429746002,
0.6397792101,
-0.0196970422,
0.3914088011,
-0.2119610757,
0.7603114843,
0.1090277508,
0.3078210652,
0.0667461753,
-0.4725016057,
-0.4346209168,
-0.2997990847,
0.3617249131,
0.6155288815,
-0.7281089425,
0.3034923375,
-0.2781298161,
-0.4759616256,
-0.4571912289,
0.2742988765,
0.4777900875,
0.1133190542,
0.1250885576,
-0.3312915564,
-0.3051459193,
-0.7748137116,
-0.320892334,
-0.4615020454,
-0.0704670846,
-0.0340326503,
0.1822016984,
-0.3090173006,
0.780210197,
-0.6965770125,
0.0114500513,
-0.1044738293,
0.1405635178,
0.2314601839,
0.4984595776,
0.5400538445,
-0.763089478,
-0.3022377789,
-0.2656280994,
-0.5013834834,
-0.253572911,
-0.394937247,
-0.0760193914,
0.5412493348,
0.6919941306,
-0.3207404613,
0.5527229905,
0.9034006,
0.2534998655,
0.8193200231,
-0.2544012666,
0.0654514804,
-1.0825583935,
-0.0525906123,
0.2574961782,
-0.0941762775,
-0.4448698163,
0.2572874129,
0.529930234,
0.441350311,
-0.2418967187,
0.0691285729,
-0.6308025718,
-0.4380204678,
-0.1362251192,
-0.099866569,
-0.42463395,
0.1436576694,
0.2036106139,
0.8584362864,
0.6820436716,
-0.4230445921,
-0.0950459316,
-0.1750974655,
-1.0119121075,
0.3702367544,
-0.3392359912,
-0.0671826154,
0.267718792,
0.1760210991,
-1.0828326941,
-0.0832386836,
0.0953886732,
-0.345415771,
0.4943309426,
-0.099113822,
-0.6901839972,
-0.1516511589,
-0.2131829858,
0.4499480128,
0.6745176315,
-0.170443669,
-0.0418589301,
0.4363873303,
-0.0711632743,
-0.7769411206,
-0.7154359221,
0.1161240339,
-0.1691943854,
-0.2946114838,
0.1492727399,
-0.2053329498,
-0.5866866708,
-0.3311328888,
-0.5730761886,
-0.0895202681,
0.4037077129,
0.3752569854,
0.0378805064,
-0.1487706006,
0.2840178907,
-0.1485443562,
0.0374761336,
0.1677442193,
-0.2165562212,
0.386154443,
-0.1856414676,
-0.6832920909,
-0.199745208,
-0.110076189,
0.2625619471,
-0.1001807451,
0.5465652943,
0.6305136085,
-0.4091501236,
-0.2697940171,
-0.6198426485,
0.0839592889,
-0.4561914504,
0.5853994489,
-0.3256860375,
-0.684186101,
0.6547458768,
-0.2132627368,
-0.098843798,
0.2671477497,
0.6019807458,
-0.2438971549,
0.7507172823,
0.7141453028,
-0.2388017476,
0.6864426136,
-0.167148158,
0.2227586508,
-0.6611068249,
0.1400611401,
-0.6376367807,
-0.1474268734,
-0.6085870862,
-0.8781442046,
0.3792649806,
0.3659596741,
0.0384618342,
0.2712063491,
-0.165420413,
0.3544059098,
0.4330137968,
0.1021599919,
0.2039484233,
0.0492591262,
0.1347834915,
-0.1300972253,
-0.5969387889,
-0.4980530441,
1.2824856043,
0.3325933814,
1.0972460508,
0.1602098644,
0.7605253458,
0.2687009275,
0.3509555459,
-0.3349089622,
0.4651014209,
0.1983601153,
-0.3432082832,
-0.4354993105,
-0.5605216622,
-0.8102865815,
-0.0057157362,
-0.1500791907,
-0.9669877291,
0.4036500752,
0.1894941628,
-0.15024288,
0.3710555434,
-0.6867454052,
0.6842666864,
-0.1273733526,
-0.2902273834,
-0.1847448498,
-0.6457075477,
0.1933884025,
-0.3442967534,
0.6539577842,
-0.1267541647,
-0.1318671703,
0.3060877025,
-0.0716955662,
0.9388310909,
-0.0698498487,
-0.6677776575,
0.2750427127,
0.5494418144,
0.8082800508,
0.1730243862,
-0.290572077,
0.3692514896,
-0.0063100355,
-0.2705255747,
-0.4390976727,
0.5292788744,
-0.6759096384,
-0.4851097465,
-0.23680453,
-0.8241937757,
-0.3851643801,
0.0400555842,
0.4442563653,
0.3651371002,
0.0384733714,
0.1591039151,
0.7504904866,
-0.3675110042,
0.431343466,
0.3312099278,
-0.115394555,
-0.1166907027,
0.7055405378,
0.1952685267,
0.5987567306,
0.5919861197,
0.0192048363,
-0.1725776345,
-0.9394008517,
-0.1115701124,
-0.0928341672,
-0.8502677083,
-0.2580017745,
-0.2766164541,
0.0147242742,
-0.5703585744,
-0.330555439,
-0.3978396058,
-0.4307246506,
-0.1116752774,
0.1018666327,
0.1533589959,
0.37096259,
0.0142571311,
0.2644434869,
-0.5364276767,
0.012054407,
-0.0222226437,
0.5465075374,
-0.3466270864,
-0.5947040915,
-0.4793812037,
0.3428469598,
-0.1027894467,
-0.7922322154,
0.3920755088,
0.1638809144,
0.7302520871,
0.3863452971,
0.3240181208,
0.5719901919,
-0.0216056854,
0.550812304,
0.0995428413,
-0.9666349888,
0.3589531481,
-0.4484189153,
0.5404165983,
0.5979769826,
0.0649419054,
-0.3715097904,
-0.6688523889,
-0.5419274569,
-0.8826243877,
0.4024580121,
0.2136539519,
-0.0661670566,
0.1764485836,
0.2916521132,
-0.0537161045,
0.3400015831,
-0.5167382956,
-0.2040498108,
0.1875011623,
-0.419572413,
-0.4041545987,
-0.2195236534,
-0.021603629,
0.1352859139,
0.4929685891,
-0.3843053281,
0.3114476502,
-0.1096185148,
-0.5408455729,
-0.1519197226,
0.2847648561,
0.7562188506,
0.9578259587,
-0.3425733149,
0.4512844682,
-0.0270804577,
-0.6211067438,
-0.0145000825,
-0.1482875049,
-0.0660499707,
-0.1139721796,
0.5516746044,
0.4402171671,
0.5248526335,
-0.8207824826,
0.5483896136,
0.1188748181,
-0.061420884,
-0.3572871983,
0.1229353473,
0.149072215,
0.3054703474,
0.4464629591,
0.3133978546,
0.1449395567,
-0.3311977088,
0.0964957327,
0.3390123844,
-0.116780512,
-0.1762663722,
0.516959846,
-0.1697898954,
-0.1810344309,
0.3928383589,
-0.002239851,
-0.3044382334,
0.9624282122,
0.5584965348,
0.7873907089,
-0.1992390007,
0.2947350442,
0.0657027215,
0.5569956303,
-0.4931130707,
0.2077996284,
-0.093590349,
-0.9969867468,
-0.3054894507,
-0.369299531,
-0.565497756,
-0.3619098067,
-0.778031528,
-0.0539389551,
-0.1682353914,
-0.3420832455,
-0.1358450204,
-0.1531576514,
-0.6619016528,
-0.0374605991,
0.2560353875,
0.8935608268,
-0.8341809511,
1.0485471487,
0.6661018729,
-0.0696468353,
-0.7598558664,
0.5240644813,
0.0435189195,
-0.9583921432,
0.4647796154,
0.045381844,
-0.1207530275,
-0.0820833147,
-0.5725826621,
-1.0776987076,
0.9399710298,
0.541523993,
-0.8088305593,
0.4819049835,
0.295784831,
0.6670026183,
-0.1687097996,
0.3652541935,
0.5824280381,
0.2732450068,
-0.163477093,
-0.8945957422,
-0.0297338758,
-0.0220999643,
0.5092327595,
0.3654879928,
-0.5201908946,
0.5066804886,
-0.4134964943,
-0.1939082891,
-0.1054931358,
0.3366213143,
0.305804342,
0.2239731103,
0.5051918626,
0.3023675978,
0.7412101626,
-0.115509674,
1.1070872545,
-0.5114358068,
0.4271069169,
1.1255502701,
-0.574102819,
1.148866415,
0.6426084638,
-0.5065493584,
0.4225095212,
0.5779459476,
0.2537857294,
0.4404742718,
0.4659233987,
-0.1394513994,
-0.4932679534,
0.2369485497,
-0.5466859937,
0.1878598183,
0.5284648538,
-0.2987247109,
-0.0161640756,
-0.2170999646,
0.0207172949,
0.1328084767,
-0.0816419572,
0.5519325733,
0.0185959656,
-0.6836917996,
0.7084262371,
-0.1745884269,
0.6688865423,
-0.470379293,
0.2494477183,
-0.3282810748,
0.5713715553,
-0.1352473497,
-0.9634392858,
0.1909928173,
-0.2714020908,
0.0736213699,
-0.2575724423,
0.5981490612,
-0.307163924,
-0.5900194049,
0.0961391106,
0.2550844848,
0.0862728283,
-0.0526415892,
-0.5888970494,
0.4398612678,
0.0726076663,
-0.2886607051,
0.5816366673,
0.4389704168,
-0.2424329966,
0.7590301633,
0.3535910845,
0.1164222285,
0.2344380021,
0.06650801,
0.5400146246,
-0.1979304701,
-0.2827402949,
-0.6727516651,
0.2906232774,
0.0513506122,
-0.2968981862,
0.9492272735,
0.4276163578,
0.9317904711,
-0.2693210244,
0.8034769893,
0.0947669819,
-0.0163134448,
-0.6380959153,
0.3448969126,
-0.2053776085,
0.7068639994,
-0.6204888821,
-0.9783442616,
-0.6822183728,
0.75851053,
-0.4108281136,
-0.0151833137,
0.5350368619,
1.0487085581,
0.2325595617,
-0.1145023406,
0.4120807648,
0.0761145651,
0.3146204054,
0.7216790318,
0.6624851823,
-0.444355458,
0.4645282328,
-0.3322681189,
-0.2748321593,
-0.4891678691,
-1.0417640209,
-0.3365258873,
-0.5021577477,
-0.7621463537,
-0.2294335365,
0.2411635667,
0.8073884845,
0.7797288895,
-0.7786121964,
-0.4169380367,
-0.1344927996,
0.0558477528,
-0.7212107778,
-0.1648417413,
0.406565994,
-0.3530109227,
-0.4179556072,
0.0900707394,
0.2290202826,
-0.0317696631,
-0.1416762173,
-0.0244743768,
-0.0431932099,
0.086383678,
0.2352307886,
0.2566763759,
-0.567542851,
-0.3186623156,
-0.0499082878,
-0.3837212622,
-0.0216174945,
0.7981082797,
-0.4194974005,
0.4438629746,
0.4870631397,
0.6656184196,
0.3583389521,
-0.1315571517,
0.5857156515,
-0.968362689,
0.1802968681,
0.0829642043,
0.3584331274,
0.0906880572,
-0.2661601305,
0.6707052588,
0.0397475548,
-0.7732311487,
-1.0317989588,
0.3181870282,
-0.8034885526,
-0.3870840669,
1.5540220737,
-0.2895257473,
-0.0647206977,
-0.0432056971,
0.0469714552,
0.1274006814,
-0.329497993,
0.9068712592,
0.7126100063,
0.0594059154,
-0.3436324298,
-0.6491175294,
0.433901161,
0.4307491481,
-0.8799125552,
0.2992174029,
0.6396043301,
0.3241758943,
0.1121135503,
0.5644798875,
-0.1302877516,
0.2363248318,
0.0086349584,
0.4026772678,
0.3215465248,
-0.1814200878,
-0.5862154961,
0.1137422323,
0.4265565574,
-0.1082860306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06233v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06233v2
|
LEGOBench: Scientific Leaderboard Generation Benchmark
| 2024-01-11T19:20:27 | 2024-02-21T06:40:33 |
Shruti Singh, Shoaib Alam, Husain Malwat, Mayank Singh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The ever-increasing volume of paper submissions makes it difficult to stay
informed about the latest state-of-the-art research. To address this challenge,
we introduce LEGOBench, a benchmark for evaluating systems that generate
scientific leaderboards. LEGOBench is curated from 22 years of preprint
submission data on arXiv and more than 11k machine learning leaderboards on the
PapersWithCode portal. We present four graph-based and two language model-based
leaderboard generation task configurations. We evaluate popular encoder-only
scientific language models as well as decoder-only large language models across
these task configurations. State-of-the-art models showcase significant
performance gaps in automatic leaderboard generation on LEGOBench. The code is
available on GitHub ( https://github.com/lingo-iitgn/LEGOBench ) and the
dataset is hosted on OSF (
https://osf.io/9v2py/?view_only=6f91b0b510df498ba01595f8f278f94c ).
|
[
-0.3960098028,
-0.7065373063,
0.3481889069,
0.4918538332,
-0.1880057007,
0.3506406844,
-0.3070338964,
-0.3012506962,
0.099242717,
0.0818990916,
-0.2744313478,
-0.725425303,
-0.5940294862,
0.2085834891,
-0.3452576399,
1.1976217031,
-0.0973264948,
-0.0282659885,
-0.8848862052,
0.2915509045,
-0.246939376,
-0.3272017837,
-0.3779889047,
-0.5193995833,
0.5072817802,
0.2522069514,
0.565957129,
0.9085689783,
0.717743516,
0.2893276811,
-0.2273612171,
0.036546737,
-0.5818454027,
0.4936364293,
-0.4394288361,
0.1612741351,
-0.8819485903,
-0.0583466105,
0.8048166037,
0.7900258899,
-0.2559669316,
0.7410578728,
-0.0155059956,
0.5440633297,
-0.6033613086,
0.6612561941,
-0.395393461,
0.0681580901,
-0.2151516676,
0.0748947188,
-0.462990731,
-0.6214392781,
-0.3796979785,
-0.2904975712,
0.1797076464,
0.1057048663,
0.6820107102,
0.0364805199,
-0.1919951886,
-0.13881284,
-0.2295270562,
0.5275696516,
-0.3236385584,
0.4120703638,
0.3277136385,
0.5708271265,
-0.3930855393,
-0.8970845342,
-0.2882052362,
-0.1507646739,
0.1611774266,
0.238376528,
-0.0993927643,
-0.3708198369,
0.2566557229,
0.0856365785,
-1.0304039717,
-0.0713962615,
-0.5268937945,
0.2220301032,
0.6849915981,
-0.005334876,
-0.0182423163,
-0.5535671711,
-0.0745749027,
-0.8460800648,
-0.6714075804,
-0.0994805694,
0.4168431759,
0.3651200831,
0.1682995856,
0.4901414514,
-0.1506469995,
0.6498582959,
0.0066285902,
0.2006619722,
0.3483079374,
-0.3522484004,
0.0749289319,
0.2975862622,
0.8745699525,
0.536800921,
-0.0125865284,
-0.3833875954,
-0.1163477674,
0.284532845,
0.3643220961,
-1.4250537157,
-0.7010447979,
0.0649257749,
-0.2207374871,
-0.4420831203,
0.175441727,
-1.0152564049,
-0.3390041292,
0.2009238452,
-0.0643234476,
0.0249090753,
-0.2780348063,
-0.5345003605,
-0.223329708,
-0.253038913,
0.061493095,
-0.8161361217,
0.456951201,
0.8226025105,
0.8554984331,
-0.5938500166,
-0.2789916098,
-0.7286513448,
-0.1940320581,
-0.7953107953,
1.0067437887,
-0.2847632468,
-0.6247397065,
-0.4606763422,
-0.0662737638,
0.0443461798,
-0.8248760104,
0.216415152,
-0.4829007387,
-0.1054565385,
-0.1111457124,
-0.4964906573,
0.2324218899,
0.3925515115,
-0.514282167,
1.2499482632,
0.0681369379,
-0.279211849,
0.3973062634,
-0.5303575993,
-0.4074552357,
0.3307910562,
-0.4228969216,
-0.5426455736,
-0.0623227097,
-0.0380906053,
0.4113584459,
-0.6395230293,
0.8387184143,
-0.2838355899,
-0.1118366122,
0.0305445511,
-0.0185851511,
0.4385711551,
0.2414792776,
-0.4615351558,
0.1796634048,
-0.7972266078,
0.6769523621,
0.1649167836,
-0.3785943687,
0.3239915967,
0.2483326346,
0.2230061889,
0.3566506207,
0.399248302,
-0.7067274451,
-0.0184351206,
0.1252634376,
0.4040786028,
0.8307438493,
-0.0557575785,
-0.2509686649,
-0.1636682004,
0.4423696399,
-0.3902152777,
-0.0337921418,
-0.2035171092,
-0.6247591972,
-0.0635545105,
0.0366502926,
0.6429522634,
0.282931,
-0.446955353,
0.5738014579,
-0.4925478399,
-0.9194844365,
-0.2321631163,
0.1284818649,
0.7358655334,
0.5917630196,
0.4400042593,
-0.6837385893,
-0.5324066877,
-0.8486270308,
-0.0008103636,
-0.4250351787,
-0.0312928744,
0.4479849637,
0.6678688526,
0.0956117287,
0.6198104024,
-0.3342868388,
0.4658154547,
0.1391335726,
0.2644137144,
0.4077320993,
0.5973089337,
0.4936954379,
-0.6216222644,
-0.7568014264,
0.2064305246,
-0.9875335693,
-0.1054886729,
0.1751458347,
-0.1783157438,
0.1196258366,
0.6787762046,
-0.5117381811,
0.3356137872,
0.9122771025,
-0.3097741604,
0.7697790861,
-0.0816519037,
0.3928136826,
-0.8720046282,
0.5442939401,
-0.5113389492,
-0.2139086276,
-0.1459586322,
0.1771690249,
0.1471809,
-0.4770307243,
-0.2166696936,
0.5322672725,
-0.3020406067,
-0.4155846834,
-0.2468881309,
0.405823946,
0.068430163,
0.2995452881,
-0.0718725696,
0.7163130045,
0.5675721765,
-0.2831477821,
0.4835841954,
0.3466601968,
-0.6152366996,
0.5518781543,
-0.8971616626,
0.2109780759,
0.1743314862,
0.2249285132,
-0.7600404024,
-0.3171790242,
-0.020053314,
-0.436185658,
0.1140986234,
0.0243021399,
-0.8878521919,
-0.7180241942,
-0.0706234351,
0.2284629494,
0.6652601957,
-0.7271578312,
0.1067823023,
0.2915504575,
-0.5792046785,
-0.3189629018,
-0.606113255,
0.2362910807,
0.4078080058,
-0.5120119452,
0.490254283,
-0.5825079679,
-0.0924532041,
0.3195791841,
-0.4417308271,
0.1696194708,
-0.0094350995,
0.600904882,
0.1944798529,
-0.3784186542,
-0.0086135063,
0.0604604185,
-0.1212540641,
0.2749391496,
-0.0748655051,
0.6484540105,
-0.5882820487,
-0.3742184937,
0.0110230222,
0.3239386082,
0.4388701618,
-0.1166821942,
0.6049118042,
0.1651235223,
-0.0545612983,
-0.4176962972,
-0.0318297446,
-0.1919476837,
-0.5300434828,
0.5984297395,
-0.3491063416,
-0.3671972752,
0.3551172316,
-0.260973841,
0.1412243396,
0.5025103092,
0.476901263,
0.1503487825,
1.1156328917,
0.3846217692,
0.4991016984,
0.2443033755,
0.0081020938,
0.2599709928,
-0.5972054601,
-0.3788299561,
-0.5572224259,
-0.2769576013,
-0.7594896555,
-0.4120229185,
0.3521897793,
0.4157349765,
-0.5346237421,
0.626883924,
-0.927667439,
0.7749174833,
0.582497716,
-0.1835445464,
0.1748352796,
-0.001340496,
-0.2527047694,
0.0745714679,
-1.0230122805,
-0.5305038095,
1.130312562,
-0.3247723877,
0.4434964657,
-0.0375605151,
0.7601028085,
0.3230735064,
0.4535423517,
-0.147481516,
0.8516303301,
-0.2304519266,
-0.5566323996,
-0.030248316,
-0.6396034956,
-0.8030098677,
0.2662934959,
-0.2004488707,
-0.5626522303,
0.2354249954,
0.1398462355,
-0.0833225101,
0.3707464337,
-0.5062335134,
1.1936836243,
-0.4927887321,
-0.645930171,
-0.1230171472,
-0.3965272009,
0.0668975338,
-0.2462936491,
0.0759069398,
-0.1009545773,
0.5501102209,
0.8684479594,
-0.260335356,
0.6019049883,
-0.1851910055,
0.5021541119,
0.204394266,
0.1872350276,
0.5321227908,
-0.0567519777,
-0.4230009019,
0.1934796721,
-0.0554343089,
-0.2821380198,
-0.3480220437,
1.0395220518,
-0.6883569956,
-0.2052894533,
-0.5994858146,
-0.4356120825,
-0.1407429129,
0.5353418589,
0.1776506305,
0.1184791699,
-0.6482688189,
0.6540577412,
0.1674798876,
-0.144393608,
0.3979424238,
0.3295623958,
-0.5152954459,
-0.4607725441,
1.1085820198,
0.1009404287,
0.1719322801,
-0.1889354289,
-0.1181271821,
0.0850756839,
-0.6774911284,
-0.6172330379,
-0.0513253398,
-0.7988159657,
-0.3745318651,
-0.4493775964,
-0.414778173,
-0.493339777,
-0.2774637938,
-0.6977416277,
-0.5963169336,
-0.0452960096,
-0.2948504388,
0.2676081061,
0.9625880122,
-0.2880314887,
0.0167845562,
-0.3568341732,
0.2324065864,
0.3286402524,
0.5780279636,
0.0808125213,
-0.0070243115,
-0.374905616,
-0.360488385,
-0.5161251426,
-0.4366150796,
0.2051207721,
0.2121068537,
0.7284764051,
0.005675165,
0.0062316954,
0.5180584192,
-0.8146214485,
0.7884786129,
0.236437127,
-0.7710647583,
0.5854095817,
-0.2434128225,
0.4320331514,
0.7122644186,
0.3967594504,
-0.4196141064,
-0.3137184978,
-0.9096390605,
-1.0211228132,
0.5695397258,
0.149586007,
-0.3977981806,
-0.2948852479,
0.1041442603,
0.0643783733,
0.5846935511,
-0.3631121218,
0.0163210779,
-0.6639350057,
-0.1359173208,
-0.1630663127,
0.1428793073,
-0.3533781171,
0.0827572048,
0.7625257373,
-0.1883690953,
0.1533110887,
-0.1130164564,
-0.0642325729,
-0.4417506158,
0.0800819397,
0.5080171824,
0.9774233699,
-0.4575639665,
0.1573964059,
-0.159718588,
-0.448936671,
-0.2501578629,
0.407823503,
-0.2247496247,
-0.0942486078,
0.381868571,
0.7958292961,
0.2001098245,
-0.9246560335,
0.2562479675,
0.0187914427,
-0.2539183199,
0.2372741699,
0.3182703853,
0.2405402958,
0.2892187238,
0.3354184628,
0.1831048876,
-0.2391780615,
-0.5273838639,
0.4879181683,
0.1905748546,
-0.1646553427,
-0.4292088151,
0.8700730801,
-0.0123708323,
-0.3935721219,
0.7290068865,
-0.456058681,
-0.3104463816,
0.9268092513,
0.7137229443,
0.6082897186,
-0.1784725189,
0.5980437398,
0.6942641735,
0.2233298272,
-0.0032364563,
0.1199399307,
-0.2337192148,
-0.2953000367,
-0.0711201131,
-0.8474341631,
-1.0369564295,
-0.3705881238,
-0.8948669434,
-0.1735792309,
-0.7940590978,
-0.4047288597,
0.3404254913,
0.0841265097,
-0.5604059696,
-0.0807938203,
0.045011986,
0.6025309563,
-0.6573252678,
0.5927540064,
0.7062407732,
-0.1494920105,
-0.2645152807,
-0.6033870578,
-0.058725778,
-0.5618047118,
0.7668591738,
-0.0081827389,
-0.057073053,
-0.1767135113,
-0.543179214,
-0.8616560698,
1.1967365742,
0.2385031134,
-0.5812721252,
0.1410780847,
-0.0235577747,
0.7297202945,
-0.4589323699,
0.2002355009,
0.2182614654,
0.7649863362,
-0.0549567714,
-0.7139982581,
0.1131789014,
-0.8821803331,
-0.0416831113,
0.0543335788,
-0.6872521043,
1.157820344,
-0.0278077237,
-0.2173792869,
0.1164669245,
0.5359420776,
0.853877008,
0.0189955737,
0.2041934878,
0.2915076315,
0.9002315998,
-0.3463962376,
1.184740901,
-0.4850507081,
0.2016260028,
1.5044789314,
-0.50261724,
1.0039646626,
0.1526294351,
-0.0490072817,
0.8634132743,
0.6506621838,
-0.7334940434,
0.5895009041,
0.3432062268,
0.2772938609,
-0.3210069537,
-0.1359513849,
-0.5632070899,
0.1532722563,
0.1992676556,
-0.263068825,
-0.5816476345,
-0.0701758787,
-0.0709395111,
0.1206886843,
-0.0749774128,
0.5798965693,
-0.1187244207,
-0.8087500334,
0.6589710712,
-0.1396206915,
0.061022386,
-0.6180413961,
-0.130826503,
-0.1658219993,
0.2328130901,
-0.0793722197,
-0.7996687889,
-0.0056450213,
0.33927086,
-0.3464815319,
-0.6386176944,
0.2425631732,
-0.346775353,
-0.5858815312,
0.3885467947,
0.4493283927,
0.3722967207,
0.1616090238,
-0.7266541719,
0.2593024969,
-0.3490637541,
-0.5257647634,
0.4191928208,
0.2945460379,
-0.2920835614,
0.3114099205,
0.7534508109,
0.159775883,
0.0787826627,
-0.1773401946,
0.9929691553,
-0.6529679894,
-0.4744456112,
-0.3161066771,
0.2722203135,
-0.3271464109,
-0.5275294185,
0.9081274271,
0.7718130946,
0.7704868913,
0.1086817533,
0.4237404466,
-0.363040477,
0.261472404,
-0.037851017,
1.1395721436,
-0.457474798,
-0.2261446863,
-0.2089843303,
-1.0743592978,
-0.3642560244,
0.518314898,
-0.1344929039,
0.1044880822,
0.8123127818,
0.751455009,
0.0446171127,
0.157637313,
0.0450170673,
0.4547929466,
0.4930178225,
0.29719612,
0.4745676517,
-0.3839829862,
0.6524395943,
-0.2262600213,
-0.2944025099,
-0.1748704761,
-1.1431796551,
-0.897962153,
-0.438151747,
-0.4506962001,
-0.2512895763,
0.4791855514,
0.5644815564,
0.9913726449,
-1.1622604132,
-0.442265898,
-0.2672795653,
0.2037926316,
-0.4614137113,
-0.2181629837,
0.7635597587,
-0.1661358178,
-0.5274044275,
0.9033454061,
0.0218156949,
-0.2639819086,
-0.0767038837,
-0.0892837867,
-0.1635507047,
-0.1007797867,
0.5085200071,
0.4886766374,
-0.2206557244,
-0.0987731293,
0.1102991253,
-0.1962457448,
0.2145127803,
0.4165886939,
-0.822363019,
0.6141986251,
0.6893103719,
0.5248320103,
1.0282377005,
0.0015148021,
0.4530599713,
-0.7709826827,
-0.2873744071,
0.3403933644,
0.0856750757,
0.5392100215,
0.0181145407,
0.7630811334,
0.1801632941,
-0.8293418884,
-1.3357312679,
-0.1345802546,
-0.7833887935,
-0.4443339109,
0.3839225769,
-0.0543749779,
-0.5556688905,
0.42339921,
0.4787372947,
-0.0038731559,
-0.3814937174,
0.7978743315,
0.710939467,
-0.2103437036,
0.1967607588,
-0.6362687945,
0.3080848455,
0.2670260966,
-0.9595221877,
0.2485203892,
0.4002138674,
0.0489927232,
0.6095799804,
0.2884569764,
-0.1953705549,
0.5890669227,
0.5381189585,
0.6535826325,
-0.4130457044,
-0.8145977259,
0.2890297771,
0.6025298238,
-0.2036744952,
0.2396950126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06210v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06210v1
|
Learning Unsupervised Semantic Document Representation for Fine-grained Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-01-11T18:59:52 | 2024-01-11T18:59:52 |
Hao-Ming Fu, Pu-Jen Cheng
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Document representation is the core of many NLP tasks on machine
understanding. A general representation learned in an unsupervised manner
reserves generality and can be used for various applications. In practice,
sentiment analysis (SA) has been a challenging task that is regarded to be
deeply semantic-related and is often used to assess general representations.
Existing methods on unsupervised document representation learning can be
separated into two families: sequential ones, which explicitly take the
ordering of words into consideration, and non-sequential ones, which do not
explicitly do so. However, both of them suffer from their own weaknesses. In
this paper, we propose a model that overcomes difficulties encountered by both
families of methods. Experiments show that our model outperforms
state-of-the-art methods on popular SA datasets and a fine-grained aspect-based
SA by a large margin.
|
[
-0.4174019396,
-0.4347322285,
0.7788050771,
0.1890223175,
-0.5802021027,
0.0061277193,
-0.2487847656,
-0.1539055258,
0.2257702202,
0.5416901708,
-0.5848000646,
-0.77908355,
-0.9755282402,
-0.0394981578,
-0.3784691989,
1.201685071,
-0.0588458367,
0.3738807142,
-0.495396167,
-0.3874772489,
-0.0205231067,
-0.5143555999,
-0.4089883864,
-0.6000608206,
0.2807244956,
0.2756777406,
0.6179901958,
0.0541740246,
0.4582400322,
0.3117573261,
-0.1778846085,
0.0835908353,
-0.0569422506,
0.2992325425,
-0.4844933152,
-0.4382591546,
-0.1688207686,
0.0675246865,
0.5024742484,
1.1543880701,
0.0962739363,
-0.1538994014,
0.4436431527,
0.9786026478,
-0.4313984513,
0.5223005414,
-0.6049585938,
0.2085639238,
-0.115011245,
-0.0989111885,
-0.4895449281,
0.0220035054,
0.226696372,
-0.402433753,
0.459702462,
-0.150414601,
0.7522689104,
0.0124101518,
-0.2330345809,
-0.5266131759,
-0.7302413583,
0.8423833847,
-0.5240684152,
0.1391144544,
0.1659177691,
-0.0475523472,
-0.2705123425,
-0.5698144436,
-0.5160118341,
0.0944607481,
-0.0316682085,
0.3233830929,
-0.0714473575,
0.0620052852,
-0.1282179952,
0.7016683817,
-0.378744632,
0.254658699,
0.0015281374,
0.0092287548,
0.4050324559,
0.1206896752,
-0.0472777151,
-0.8042078018,
-0.5267806053,
-0.2835122049,
-0.1535203904,
0.2941279709,
0.2238762677,
0.4395786226,
0.0693003088,
0.6181005239,
-0.4089926779,
0.3682249188,
0.2611648738,
0.0592449829,
0.3753949702,
0.175470382,
-0.2771784365,
-0.3157141507,
0.9885089993,
0.5277296901,
-0.106999062,
-0.1632948369,
-0.5697755814,
0.2921585441,
0.4888508022,
-0.4785783589,
0.0046642739,
0.4635851681,
-0.6752352118,
-0.4280771315,
0.4796869159,
-1.1033844948,
-0.7274089456,
-0.434453249,
0.2752104998,
-0.399325043,
-0.123584412,
0.022188073,
-0.1876366585,
0.3479404449,
0.3886989653,
-0.9271934628,
0.2200080603,
0.9037469625,
0.8749818802,
-0.0873442143,
-0.2732650936,
-0.4060473144,
-0.3086917996,
-0.2514017522,
1.1115983725,
-0.8883601427,
-0.7446017265,
0.1189692318,
0.078023158,
0.0508989133,
-0.3860476017,
0.6820958257,
-0.3811207414,
0.367972523,
-0.2500034571,
-0.6549266577,
-0.361035943,
0.2400667518,
-0.4460691512,
1.0096801519,
0.5577151179,
-0.9699911475,
0.296633482,
-0.5013383031,
-0.3185715675,
-0.2804442644,
-0.2940456271,
-0.4424500763,
0.7871742845,
0.3636841178,
0.899948597,
-0.1905992031,
0.0157194007,
-0.3497259021,
-0.0402779132,
0.0698253363,
-0.3557144701,
0.1317041367,
0.0491692573,
-0.103921175,
0.1678567529,
-0.7218926549,
-0.1638475657,
0.3155177236,
-0.1650552899,
-0.7249522805,
0.1731234193,
0.0296246968,
0.2941528261,
0.3149591088,
-0.8299973607,
0.3053469062,
-0.8153211474,
0.3112512231,
0.5214134455,
0.1502172798,
0.970487237,
0.0085942904,
0.2458874881,
0.5438731909,
0.197141692,
-0.1870454252,
-0.1906353384,
-0.9182800055,
0.235846445,
0.3909168243,
0.2659665346,
-0.7181332707,
0.6320981383,
-0.3029598594,
-0.3571351469,
-0.4961284399,
0.1743485332,
0.3098452985,
0.3211148083,
0.409293294,
-0.8562048078,
-0.151619643,
-0.662881434,
0.0013816078,
-0.0945074335,
-0.1406658292,
-0.0760243461,
0.3452894688,
-0.379119277,
0.9895288348,
-0.624494195,
-0.5877643228,
-0.3596486747,
0.9473103285,
0.0536053739,
0.2415993363,
0.2886930704,
-0.8088686466,
-0.1246303245,
0.0052027013,
-0.7401467562,
0.0973452181,
-0.2097524554,
0.0405017473,
0.6010681987,
0.3504939973,
-0.5721369982,
0.4094523787,
0.3010965884,
-0.2055374235,
0.2657820284,
-0.3425236046,
-0.0960310549,
-1.2590888739,
-0.411398679,
0.2941132486,
-0.1056347266,
-0.3620876372,
0.1844991446,
-0.0223636683,
-0.2594411671,
-0.3138283789,
0.271648109,
-0.3170855939,
-0.3179957867,
-0.5545659065,
0.1294286698,
0.385558635,
0.6748491526,
0.383267194,
0.2373202145,
0.4692843556,
-0.1986418366,
0.0749757811,
-0.0365217775,
-0.1447296441,
0.7937678099,
-0.4106291234,
0.1291042566,
-0.5779281259,
0.3288039863,
-0.9370935559,
-0.1205869094,
0.1843385845,
-0.4663431346,
0.5817143321,
-0.2844372988,
-0.5013520718,
-0.3053327501,
-0.5985063314,
-0.1636641175,
0.2224578857,
-0.5594349504,
0.9920526743,
0.2788539827,
-0.1299418956,
-0.4891284406,
-0.3740808964,
-0.1975906938,
-0.1076579392,
-0.5217514634,
0.3927023113,
0.5147550106,
-0.164218545,
0.0312999748,
-0.3118670583,
-0.0280592814,
-0.1564997286,
0.5174401999,
0.1523716152,
-0.051160723,
0.1594259888,
0.2340125889,
-0.4102065861,
0.075914003,
-0.4179239571,
0.715036571,
-0.2305324376,
-0.3404449224,
-0.1249852329,
0.8696144223,
0.6891152859,
-0.3084904253,
0.6839821935,
0.6567669511,
-0.2823219001,
-0.3795214593,
-0.3127778172,
0.2170172036,
-0.4088035822,
0.3692998886,
-0.1713878214,
-0.6776203513,
0.5672118664,
-0.319090724,
0.1733209342,
0.722235322,
0.3225275576,
-0.5545299053,
0.8983889818,
0.647023797,
-0.3530670404,
0.3206312656,
-0.4578700364,
0.0219001062,
-0.9800595641,
-0.3159074485,
-0.5885863304,
-0.1199675575,
-0.5162472129,
-0.5554386973,
0.1057385132,
0.4160821736,
-0.0380144008,
-0.1638944894,
-0.5656733513,
0.2928642631,
0.3776930273,
0.0687165931,
0.2251952589,
0.2369852215,
-0.1674557626,
0.0156184547,
-0.2162854224,
-0.754229784,
0.8208366036,
0.4476454258,
0.6720176935,
-0.1675654501,
1.0936666727,
0.3597911596,
0.0514620803,
-1.1924153566,
0.4696330428,
-0.9228889942,
0.2077841908,
-0.2431268692,
-0.1261701882,
-0.9122389555,
0.4623661339,
-0.2204676718,
-0.705198586,
0.4354771078,
-0.3175777793,
-0.2265387028,
0.2311046422,
-0.7167297602,
0.6785858274,
0.1343798786,
0.0514241681,
-0.0959986672,
-0.5931571126,
-0.0580245778,
-0.0250533652,
0.3066376746,
0.0185784027,
0.1812877953,
0.8396289349,
-0.6571977139,
1.0982681513,
-0.5330901146,
0.0676961467,
0.3499838114,
0.01381444,
0.5925143361,
0.0509050936,
-0.0338507369,
0.2003554851,
0.0797227249,
-0.2987169921,
-0.9270390272,
0.7943350077,
-0.9342428446,
-0.5260335207,
-0.6656411886,
-0.2803400457,
-0.4650399089,
0.1025501639,
0.4431123435,
0.5827397108,
-0.343508482,
0.0673414916,
0.5892461538,
-0.0035957424,
0.5494437218,
0.5127308965,
-0.2356712073,
-0.189967677,
0.9637539387,
0.2029776126,
-0.1009032056,
0.4809266627,
0.4351663291,
-0.3849612474,
-0.6333605647,
-0.2309647799,
-0.0255478863,
-1.0437008142,
-0.0753234699,
-0.741116941,
-0.1807701886,
-0.3175825477,
-0.208493337,
-0.4730984569,
-0.412289381,
-0.4837554693,
-0.0079724062,
0.2616249621,
0.9154410958,
0.3049552441,
0.482137382,
-0.8302464485,
0.3453886807,
0.2785217762,
0.4142795801,
0.2069828212,
-0.3948739767,
0.1451913416,
-0.2258969396,
-0.5153688192,
-0.7268987894,
0.261662066,
-0.0041823634,
0.1959468573,
0.553242445,
0.2866731286,
0.346427232,
-0.3713040948,
0.8993521929,
0.2550097406,
-0.7741308808,
0.6441952586,
-0.2941790223,
0.197426632,
0.7975788713,
0.3517894745,
-0.5463879108,
-0.503194809,
-0.7215925455,
-1.1182143688,
0.6109292507,
-0.0227390192,
0.3596220911,
-0.0979400501,
0.4001935124,
0.3700162172,
0.0005634715,
-0.5135484934,
0.0858434513,
-0.6844635606,
-0.4593767822,
-0.0130664837,
-0.3190838993,
0.2580090761,
-0.0674375147,
0.560482204,
-0.2453496307,
0.2898203731,
0.290974468,
-0.1825687587,
0.1628362983,
0.6364975572,
0.0351063646,
0.0861153081,
-0.2053059042,
0.2243372947,
-0.2419438362,
-0.4284409881,
-0.0187916905,
0.172918722,
-0.2239881903,
0.1055160537,
0.438829422,
0.7748637795,
0.337344259,
-0.0938149467,
0.7699525952,
-0.0732104331,
-0.0926580131,
-0.2659855485,
-0.1604677588,
0.061497435,
0.2082736194,
0.226976335,
0.2234538049,
0.1643600464,
-0.5853143334,
0.0508178212,
0.3931037486,
-0.6832771301,
-0.1657102555,
0.1011488587,
0.2878749669,
-0.0523431599,
0.4572104812,
-0.5590757132,
-0.5072572827,
0.2641740739,
0.1387100816,
1.0712081194,
0.0518312231,
0.6383462548,
-0.0486644804,
0.0090085017,
-0.3381153345,
0.2166360468,
-0.0543922223,
-0.6515629888,
-0.0493762679,
-1.1146851778,
-0.4497268498,
-0.0430676378,
-0.9970517755,
-0.0347822458,
-0.6588464379,
-0.1075161994,
0.2077066749,
0.0867156312,
-0.6510433555,
0.2600021064,
0.1260130703,
0.7143365741,
-0.9903982878,
0.7856292725,
0.8762567043,
-0.6040378213,
-0.5638226271,
0.5159057975,
-0.0556067005,
-0.5357496738,
0.2776341438,
0.3104940057,
-0.1540455073,
-0.4127370119,
-0.2084182203,
-0.4939367473,
0.8138804436,
-0.2228006721,
-0.5130864978,
0.1178516373,
0.249822095,
0.8275634646,
-0.5369490981,
-0.0080744056,
0.4433981776,
0.1791083664,
0.1682566553,
-0.2396480888,
-0.1789126098,
-0.078977555,
0.2845970094,
0.281383723,
-0.6171500683,
0.6336067319,
0.2963310778,
-0.1277881116,
-0.0963390395,
1.0719636679,
-0.2121508569,
0.4065535367,
0.653120935,
0.5343498588,
0.799397707,
-0.3029637635,
1.146030426,
0.0279735252,
0.5453407764,
1.2502353191,
-0.3258202374,
1.1353011131,
0.474363029,
-0.185191527,
0.7067568302,
0.5843770504,
0.0684418529,
0.5798466802,
-0.1281117648,
-0.1556447595,
-0.2688469291,
-0.1416231096,
-0.018248098,
0.7171567082,
0.4723886847,
-0.5473382473,
-0.5127193332,
0.1928557903,
0.0478415526,
0.3212152123,
-0.6068278551,
1.045773983,
0.3146852255,
-0.591414094,
0.0835085511,
0.2818716168,
0.8845905662,
-0.6013583541,
0.244323194,
-0.255391717,
0.1896035522,
-0.3432539999,
-1.2311279774,
0.5144960284,
0.0143212844,
-0.6896740198,
-0.0407198183,
0.793397367,
-0.2359876931,
-0.7947117686,
0.5558922291,
0.259419173,
-0.1015116125,
-0.2812644541,
-0.6801747084,
-0.0901585296,
-0.252605021,
-0.389449656,
0.6305353045,
0.6426383257,
-0.2907764912,
0.1830216646,
0.2585195899,
-0.135903731,
-0.3210702538,
0.4331948161,
0.9360024929,
-0.6084185839,
-0.6599504948,
-0.7092206478,
0.3828533888,
-0.143348366,
-0.1635069549,
0.5246848464,
0.2634211183,
0.6928662062,
-0.0313312858,
0.8132045865,
0.1202748045,
0.4717955291,
-0.7185799479,
0.4634274244,
-0.5129846334,
0.1436339468,
-0.4326224327,
-0.9986022115,
-0.3320150673,
0.511297524,
-0.3879695833,
-0.2282708436,
0.7787614465,
0.44554919,
-0.0268197674,
0.4451895952,
0.0524696149,
0.0934199616,
0.130588606,
0.3765440285,
0.7619134188,
-0.2352152914,
0.160322234,
-0.5609695911,
-0.2657043934,
0.0473193452,
-0.7589851022,
-0.9354773164,
-0.8292569518,
-0.2447053641,
-0.3231840432,
-0.3313071728,
0.9963165522,
0.2693095505,
-0.7077219486,
0.3083147407,
0.0929874554,
0.0466465168,
-0.0601233393,
-0.2030712217,
0.6900331378,
-0.6995717287,
-0.6104225516,
0.209909007,
0.4626502693,
-0.0036517819,
-0.5023345351,
0.1828122139,
0.2306413352,
0.2699873745,
0.9013649225,
0.0703311637,
-0.8335440755,
-0.4392601848,
-0.4167530537,
-0.0726363659,
0.3346739709,
0.8436923027,
-0.585945487,
0.4616551101,
0.6900290251,
0.4994821548,
0.3173635602,
0.2029897273,
0.1997525394,
-1.0965923071,
0.1301679313,
0.1146513745,
0.6737695336,
0.4795045555,
-0.4094260335,
0.1026683822,
0.1318904161,
-0.2526440918,
-0.2787318528,
0.1521059871,
-1.3348914385,
-0.6824404597,
1.1615695953,
-0.2360523343,
-0.3033089638,
-0.2030154616,
-0.2006316334,
0.1596602052,
-0.7010791302,
0.6959272027,
0.790330708,
-0.1082690507,
0.1173684299,
-0.115415059,
0.142798841,
0.3256092072,
-0.5318212509,
0.2446286082,
0.3416318297,
0.1284325421,
0.4380143881,
0.5961965322,
-0.4759361744,
-0.0898571461,
-0.1916166246,
0.0339281112,
0.0561105385,
-0.3844347596,
-0.7742328048,
0.6259371042,
0.1960377544,
-0.2504221797
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06121v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06121v1
|
TOFU: A Task of Fictitious Unlearning for LLMs
| 2024-01-11T18:57:12 | 2024-01-11T18:57:12 |
Pratyush Maini, Zhili Feng, Avi Schwarzschild, Zachary C. Lipton, J. Zico Kolter
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Large language models trained on massive corpora of data from the web can
memorize and reproduce sensitive or private data raising both legal and ethical
concerns. Unlearning, or tuning models to forget information present in their
training data, provides us with a way to protect private data after training.
Although several methods exist for such unlearning, it is unclear to what
extent they result in models equivalent to those where the data to be forgotten
was never learned in the first place. To address this challenge, we present
TOFU, a Task of Fictitious Unlearning, as a benchmark aimed at helping deepen
our understanding of unlearning. We offer a dataset of 200 diverse synthetic
author profiles, each consisting of 20 question-answer pairs, and a subset of
these profiles called the forget set that serves as the target for unlearning.
We compile a suite of metrics that work together to provide a holistic picture
of unlearning efficacy. Finally, we provide a set of baseline results from
existing unlearning algorithms. Importantly, none of the baselines we consider
show effective unlearning motivating continued efforts to develop approaches
for unlearning that effectively tune models so that they truly behave as if
they were never trained on the forget data at all.
|
[
0.0943416283,
-0.5667066574,
0.4777954221,
-0.0217215661,
-0.018281702,
0.3320230544,
-0.4471033216,
-0.0517516136,
-0.4546541274,
0.628372848,
-0.7328667641,
-0.5289267302,
-0.4308642745,
0.0471465699,
-0.7730061412,
1.2939589024,
0.1200965047,
-0.0865545645,
-0.7509942651,
-0.1693673432,
-0.1392187327,
-0.3227010965,
-0.5022863746,
-0.4926420152,
0.6622921824,
0.690338552,
0.2914857268,
0.8465830684,
-0.0156982411,
0.2857285142,
0.1356642097,
0.2935877144,
-1.3903018236,
-0.1674650759,
-0.5808865428,
-0.7399013042,
-0.153823033,
0.1969350576,
0.6934027672,
1.0497866869,
-0.3218820393,
0.6000096202,
0.0697446391,
0.8673570752,
-0.8319469094,
0.1127428263,
-0.8192352057,
0.0861110315,
-0.1535057873,
-0.3508497477,
-0.6888142228,
-0.3755699992,
-0.2532872856,
-0.882953763,
0.470248729,
0.1131011546,
0.7388358712,
0.3960069716,
-0.4043456912,
-0.3204658926,
-0.7840362191,
1.0142145157,
-0.5353931189,
0.4604192376,
0.6920556426,
0.1812748909,
-0.3625792861,
-0.888414979,
-0.4761412144,
-0.0566370115,
0.0572563745,
0.2131410688,
-0.2361169308,
-0.2670072615,
0.3760313988,
0.5144184828,
-0.3302203119,
0.3221562207,
-0.4212895632,
-0.2243621647,
0.7204146385,
-0.1717552096,
0.119458206,
0.1973974109,
-0.3877595961,
-0.0288953315,
-1.0657951832,
0.1540411562,
0.7082157135,
0.0958907977,
-0.0040022107,
0.6397127509,
-0.1817456037,
0.1315144449,
-0.0309808236,
-0.3381840885,
0.2636161745,
0.1622301638,
-0.1613238454,
-0.2004952878,
0.6445477009,
0.0914581493,
0.8622406125,
-0.8512423038,
-0.4437904656,
-0.0862837136,
0.4845661819,
-0.5372659564,
-0.2361513972,
0.1711964905,
-0.4304188788,
-0.1921258271,
0.0474797562,
-0.7373870611,
-0.3589864373,
-0.3926283419,
0.4422627091,
-0.4675998986,
-0.2677133083,
-0.1823205948,
-0.1322760433,
-0.0395708531,
0.1745616496,
-0.6559864879,
0.5705993772,
0.7743486762,
0.329977721,
-0.1450189054,
-0.6050471067,
-0.5292330384,
0.2726852298,
-0.54306072,
0.5458701253,
-0.3641791344,
-0.5275700688,
0.1245884299,
0.0840008259,
0.0547786318,
-0.7253271341,
0.3143043518,
-0.4547990263,
0.2545816898,
-0.5587124228,
-1.0284696817,
-0.4204668403,
0.0307273082,
-0.5514794588,
0.9538649917,
0.2552741766,
-0.3563800156,
0.3303180337,
-0.4333738983,
-0.2741416693,
-0.1083233356,
-0.0266747847,
-0.6331336498,
0.238974601,
-0.1985580176,
0.470330745,
-0.348084569,
0.6406394243,
-0.5229049325,
-0.4994675517,
0.4392678142,
-0.6134437919,
0.9069882631,
0.0930018052,
-0.2598898113,
-0.1319662333,
-0.9570689201,
-0.0887217969,
0.4338220358,
-0.3445485532,
-0.2539215684,
0.0208593495,
-0.1709068269,
-0.0660344958,
0.2126199305,
-0.5828458071,
-0.0427917503,
-0.0913141668,
0.4168637395,
0.9073182344,
0.0276794136,
0.3503813744,
-0.713897109,
0.2938087881,
-0.0201319829,
-0.1166007668,
-0.2325820923,
-0.0216689073,
-1.1179732084,
-0.1504359394,
0.2670191526,
0.4506412148,
-0.4868157506,
0.2285173088,
-0.2742290199,
-0.5566585064,
-0.697694838,
0.7632966042,
0.8808797002,
0.6951078773,
0.296151638,
0.002571221,
-0.2456163168,
-0.8746734262,
-0.5086578131,
-0.1565541476,
-0.0197423492,
0.1309958994,
0.7328042388,
-0.0551443659,
0.6682028174,
-0.2196181566,
-0.4857786,
0.1351074129,
0.1330431998,
-0.2322721481,
0.3985771537,
0.3678129911,
-0.5971283317,
-0.2155526727,
-0.0758429617,
-1.3001276255,
0.1497712582,
-0.0888513029,
0.0344573148,
0.1907258034,
0.8533239365,
-0.3107846975,
0.3015063107,
0.1630562842,
-0.0610374101,
0.498958081,
-0.4265767038,
-0.191627562,
-0.8894370794,
0.5019129515,
-0.2555919588,
-0.270593673,
-0.6675296426,
-0.0901281983,
0.3075214326,
-0.075018838,
-0.5987926722,
0.6751807928,
-0.7106199265,
-0.0404675677,
-0.122594133,
-0.1006155759,
-0.1245064288,
0.8323751092,
-0.286572665,
1.0322787762,
0.2686306536,
-0.5972284675,
0.000298544,
0.2879054546,
-0.3995133638,
0.4461615682,
-0.3576464951,
0.474702239,
-0.3768584132,
-0.0383227319,
-0.9432816505,
-0.1676619649,
-0.0951458439,
-0.3374535739,
0.3627929688,
-0.0439577587,
-0.7307209373,
-0.0306179207,
-0.2891997397,
0.3572653234,
0.561001718,
-0.7948921323,
0.3527389467,
0.4727357328,
0.0946968347,
-0.8713825941,
-0.4864143729,
-0.1245015338,
-0.4009291828,
-0.0294642895,
0.3887994289,
-0.1130535305,
-0.0901371315,
0.0580022633,
-0.119321242,
-0.1995272785,
0.1254199594,
0.5298034549,
0.0434565544,
-0.0886847749,
0.2968120575,
-0.0058093332,
-0.1248149723,
0.2968049347,
-0.1875040382,
0.2686910331,
-0.0164204109,
-0.4144559801,
-0.3383562267,
0.0983933508,
0.4370554686,
-0.1026614308,
0.5048407316,
0.3584438264,
-0.5698786378,
-0.7381989956,
-0.6521930099,
0.1072222963,
-0.5438667536,
0.1974844933,
-0.1473343819,
-0.6675482392,
0.5598606467,
-0.4480904043,
0.51922822,
0.265199542,
0.2786846161,
-0.2915448546,
0.4299638867,
1.0809425116,
-0.1170825288,
0.1989889145,
-0.3875680268,
0.0092756795,
-0.496281296,
-0.6570767164,
-0.319354862,
-0.3796772063,
-0.4588630199,
-0.177191332,
0.0136500765,
0.251108855,
-0.4138843119,
0.1868652999,
-0.0879229233,
0.6343858242,
0.5301972628,
0.1184857264,
0.6156869531,
0.0987678319,
-0.0871162489,
0.010711683,
-0.64659971,
-0.5808113217,
1.5148814917,
0.1219663695,
0.5986061096,
-0.0967018753,
0.6472909451,
0.4019808769,
0.5015864372,
-0.5470891595,
0.5777992606,
-0.3906337619,
-0.6299726963,
-0.3283959329,
-0.4366297722,
-1.0374221802,
-0.2202715278,
-0.1030770317,
-0.7997719646,
0.0076345364,
0.3698624074,
-0.2557314336,
0.5808024406,
-0.5968592167,
0.7608330846,
-0.3714004457,
-0.5770683289,
-0.1929955184,
-0.3947222233,
0.5772098899,
-0.5818509459,
0.2327528,
-0.350646764,
-0.1027764529,
0.868293643,
-0.2447278947,
1.1913633347,
0.0417679325,
-0.1234039664,
0.0675780624,
0.1746689528,
0.367503047,
0.1391391903,
-0.233956784,
0.3456398249,
-0.0156085743,
-0.4269779921,
-0.4772687256,
0.7328866124,
-0.9219369292,
-0.5203959942,
-0.2668131888,
-0.5067059398,
-0.4234109819,
0.3932215273,
0.499555707,
-0.0291420389,
-0.6343050599,
0.1708243638,
0.8437154889,
-0.2594671547,
0.4815235436,
0.7916219831,
-0.1192044765,
-0.1402659565,
1.3651924133,
0.2419793159,
0.1225742027,
0.5731754303,
-0.024119826,
-0.4361958206,
-0.398853451,
-0.2112376392,
0.6386551857,
-0.7849670649,
-0.3642917275,
-0.5759400725,
-0.3780557215,
-0.2465060353,
-0.195319429,
-0.5956770778,
-0.2645226419,
-0.6686966419,
-0.1894215196,
0.3772106767,
0.8505483866,
-0.0238003582,
0.2915827036,
-0.3492201269,
0.4882143736,
0.0652991012,
0.5230933428,
0.1917351335,
-0.6512794495,
0.0158686545,
0.1312494576,
-0.4004112482,
-0.2858223915,
0.3131755888,
0.4733841717,
0.7943613529,
0.641671598,
0.3270196915,
0.755654633,
-0.5109764934,
0.2676342428,
0.102070339,
-0.8686984181,
0.2977513075,
-0.3559017479,
0.0761391371,
0.767090559,
0.5549049973,
-0.5724676847,
-0.2088957429,
-0.7876548767,
-0.6791477799,
0.5643244982,
-0.0450526997,
0.2044010013,
0.3833019733,
0.6081678271,
0.7752158642,
0.5906788707,
-0.6873432994,
-0.3853761852,
-0.1457443088,
-0.1145497859,
-0.5226587653,
-0.2376938909,
-0.1368737519,
-0.2192568779,
0.6448729634,
0.0073697092,
0.1682620198,
-0.4352614284,
-0.4461505115,
-0.3696494401,
0.0376832709,
0.1141526774,
0.8618298173,
0.0035832943,
-0.0044690152,
0.2647391856,
-0.3095998466,
0.1570080668,
-0.1731425077,
-0.4026424289,
-0.3090210259,
0.4938541651,
0.5350035429,
0.4978072941,
-0.9294323325,
0.3625013828,
0.2392837256,
-0.5108216405,
-0.77806288,
0.3272672892,
0.3283029795,
-0.1296519339,
0.1038829759,
-0.1777808815,
-0.0954419822,
-0.7837532163,
0.4418007433,
0.3672727644,
-0.3369961977,
-0.4055145681,
0.7446431518,
-0.0736582205,
-0.4050267935,
0.9819963574,
0.0607895963,
-0.0286253355,
0.408493638,
0.6165875196,
0.5441185236,
-0.186693415,
0.3336665332,
0.1619787365,
0.1774503887,
-0.3629152775,
0.0301236901,
0.0033321553,
-0.5892839432,
-0.0187059306,
-0.6276968718,
-0.2987461984,
0.8219866157,
-0.7422711253,
0.1596471518,
-0.7799375057,
0.2363270223,
0.2794240713,
0.0950451121,
-0.8086609244,
0.3029165566,
-0.3015860319,
0.7066643834,
-0.8899891973,
0.9143566489,
0.4178576767,
-0.4920132756,
-0.574999392,
-0.0103624305,
0.3719011247,
-0.9766547084,
0.1531550288,
0.2490817606,
-0.0502877571,
0.1866716892,
-0.5596259236,
-0.8514214754,
1.0544019938,
0.8284738064,
-0.5605313778,
-0.0919602811,
0.4907556176,
0.5356485248,
-0.1642082483,
-0.1876072288,
0.5597813129,
0.2465336919,
-0.1348951906,
-0.5524771214,
-0.0499274395,
-0.4809614122,
-0.3569944799,
-0.0297474321,
-0.8185737729,
0.865530014,
-0.4956384897,
-0.3112568259,
0.1706890315,
0.6134550571,
-0.0157429893,
0.4641230702,
0.3922676444,
0.4209995568,
1.2324545383,
0.0361376293,
0.7507480979,
0.0434152372,
0.1293128133,
1.1991376877,
-0.1700863391,
0.804161489,
0.3728283346,
0.0466792732,
0.0728169754,
0.5630990863,
-0.386387974,
0.4860699177,
0.3195569813,
-0.0926695466,
-0.2752177715,
-0.114321962,
-0.1422591805,
0.5510367751,
0.3050692677,
-0.2300565988,
-0.3603130579,
0.0790999904,
0.2545862496,
0.6850302219,
-0.0640946403,
0.8271400332,
0.3917672932,
-0.7670348287,
0.7782899737,
-0.0554868951,
0.4782716334,
-0.5357255936,
-0.0008017011,
-0.4876588881,
0.6026647091,
-0.1868364066,
-0.4541933239,
0.1499473155,
0.2352737486,
-0.2943281829,
-0.5003553033,
0.3804946244,
-0.5582215786,
-0.6625697017,
0.5722131133,
0.6876068711,
0.3417952061,
0.1394679844,
-0.6872843504,
-0.3044911325,
0.1123680249,
-0.218758896,
0.6675376892,
0.6199059486,
-0.1614873558,
1.1470527649,
0.8995478153,
-0.056547787,
-0.1563521326,
-0.1182384789,
0.7163463235,
-0.6125957966,
-0.2430292815,
-0.6229442954,
0.2220371366,
0.0444241017,
-0.6012379527,
0.7553570867,
0.7534952164,
1.3615053892,
0.0382236652,
0.7935249805,
0.5271804929,
0.8140277267,
-0.5310226083,
1.2809917927,
-1.036801815,
0.358549118,
0.0914729089,
-0.7849476933,
0.0995552391,
0.1515350938,
-0.006759082,
0.1911012679,
0.6001111865,
0.8075742126,
-0.338788718,
0.0043206569,
0.6982531548,
0.0618556552,
0.0597577132,
0.470670104,
0.6713290215,
-0.3199645579,
0.5706201196,
-0.6112644076,
0.0598696582,
0.003907227,
-0.8418460488,
-1.1348723173,
-0.6454664469,
-0.2442332655,
-0.1941522509,
0.4682500362,
0.6456024051,
0.4571894109,
-0.9809823632,
-0.5458712578,
-0.0012658902,
0.08431793,
-0.3427832723,
-0.0508539528,
0.3212678134,
-0.3219690919,
-0.6125758886,
0.5322106481,
0.0058241016,
0.1007734239,
-0.1839766651,
-0.0358144268,
-0.1873351336,
0.0762704685,
0.3208518028,
0.8036187887,
-0.6784864068,
0.0479070321,
-0.0446457937,
0.1251764745,
-0.0080141276,
0.8770755529,
-0.7256417871,
0.2114198506,
-0.1698611975,
0.6625397801,
0.5485654473,
0.0265773293,
0.7207347155,
-0.9718415737,
0.0866057053,
0.0333411582,
0.2356888205,
0.4605571032,
-0.4763624072,
0.4820652306,
0.221382305,
-0.290807277,
-1.1849335432,
-0.1350849718,
-0.6208139062,
-0.6327577233,
1.0526351929,
-0.434538275,
-0.2740822136,
-0.1703980565,
0.3797085285,
0.637254715,
-0.447555393,
1.1387207508,
0.5198425055,
0.3352861404,
-0.004077448,
-0.7269515991,
0.7187140584,
0.4017309844,
-0.9033980966,
0.5679731965,
0.3575692177,
0.7455140352,
-0.1070501953,
0.5753577948,
-0.1068549901,
0.1823515147,
0.0533698164,
-0.1555647105,
-0.4452735484,
-0.6119769216,
-0.170532316,
0.2121702135,
-0.1106872261,
0.0383005477
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06118v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06118v3
|
Extreme Compression of Large Language Models via Additive Quantization
| 2024-01-11T18:54:44 | 2024-06-08T10:55:52 |
Vage Egiazarian, Andrei Panferov, Denis Kuznedelev, Elias Frantar, Artem Babenko, Dan Alistarh
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
The emergence of accurate open large language models (LLMs) has led to a race
towards performant quantization techniques which can enable their execution on
end-user devices. In this paper, we revisit the problem of ``extreme'' LLM
compression -- defined as targeting extremely low bit counts, such as 2 to 3
bits per parameter -- from the point of view of classic methods in
Multi-Codebook Quantization (MCQ). Our algorithm, called AQLM, generalizes the
classic Additive Quantization (AQ) approach for information retrieval to
advance the state-of-the-art in LLM compression, via two innovations: 1)
learned additive quantization of weight matrices in input-adaptive fashion, and
2) joint optimization of codebook parameters across each transformer blocks.
Broadly, AQLM is the first scheme that is Pareto optimal in terms of
accuracy-vs-model-size when compressing to less than 3 bits per parameter, and
significantly improves upon all known schemes in the extreme compression (2bit)
regime. In addition, AQLM is practical: we provide fast GPU and CPU
implementations of AQLM for token generation, which enable us to match or
outperform optimized FP16 implementations for speed, while executing in a much
smaller memory footprint.
|
[
-0.3757821023,
-0.9850154519,
0.4664558768,
-0.0306525696,
-0.3562616408,
0.1678488255,
-0.0546847135,
-0.2463838309,
-0.0677765757,
0.2848632336,
-0.1843823642,
-0.4648793638,
-0.4038780034,
-0.1960960329,
-0.5787191391,
0.4737793505,
0.2748000324,
-0.0819138885,
-0.084144406,
-0.1682688594,
0.0640114769,
-1.0482983589,
-0.6196038723,
-0.0224604383,
0.2601150274,
0.2308093458,
1.2650974989,
0.9426478148,
0.3924685419,
0.1885880828,
-0.3427013159,
0.1242028102,
-0.4200464487,
0.1083547994,
0.290715009,
-0.4136437178,
-0.4744374454,
-0.4256713688,
0.8875070214,
0.4628740549,
-0.4417979717,
0.2737661898,
-0.1402484775,
0.8272463083,
-0.8550872803,
-0.452690661,
-0.5395044684,
0.1154087484,
-0.097672902,
-0.4311923981,
-0.5021091104,
-0.3483071327,
-0.5615544915,
-0.4444659948,
0.2597555518,
0.3738505244,
0.6026108265,
0.1849688441,
-0.6438373923,
-0.3284102082,
-0.8088033795,
0.7110281587,
-0.7382951379,
0.5159575343,
0.1477193534,
0.1338039041,
-0.0018493384,
-0.7056610584,
-0.7346403599,
0.2172845602,
0.2126714587,
-0.2465179563,
-0.6931160092,
0.2413466722,
0.5117841959,
0.5540282726,
-0.7099260092,
0.2057996839,
-0.3117280304,
-0.300327301,
0.3800908029,
0.324511975,
0.1686636209,
0.151833877,
-0.39111799,
-0.0830477551,
-0.9299456477,
0.0088221794,
0.4633962214,
0.1247306019,
0.2370291352,
0.5881316662,
-0.3324806392,
0.889441371,
-0.3965154588,
0.0729138628,
-0.0718215406,
-0.2078106701,
-0.2841280997,
-0.0184526797,
0.8059219718,
0.0811203942,
-0.1631344855,
0.0749031752,
-0.4941339493,
-0.0462355539,
0.2222469151,
-0.8169119358,
-0.3119368553,
0.3016496599,
-0.6190734506,
-0.1853214651,
-0.216468513,
-0.5217024088,
-0.4500126243,
-0.2941975594,
0.8420438766,
-0.1904501915,
-0.0667689815,
0.2244098932,
0.0557623841,
0.164598152,
0.2119613141,
-0.6720544696,
0.3999635577,
0.5447289944,
0.8492323756,
0.2092565894,
0.1130537614,
-0.8074674606,
0.139960736,
-0.2874710858,
0.7594783306,
-0.5320110321,
-0.3991400003,
0.1686869264,
-0.5287542343,
0.4422782958,
-0.5167326331,
0.7916172743,
-0.7964449525,
-0.3143984973,
0.0581730343,
-0.5008251667,
-0.1173023283,
0.0677695423,
-0.6889097691,
1.0523506403,
0.0996977091,
-0.4626128376,
-0.1545524597,
-0.4111424685,
-0.3423565924,
0.2258932889,
-0.0470582061,
-0.4306912422,
0.5990765691,
0.2977449596,
0.3181840181,
-0.7227803469,
0.1483731121,
-0.3067453504,
-0.7094191313,
0.267809242,
-0.6723630428,
0.760669291,
0.3148469925,
0.0367559902,
0.1304884255,
-0.7743199468,
0.281634599,
0.154137224,
-0.4780997634,
-0.3317718506,
-0.0903261527,
-0.0757788047,
0.2538999319,
0.3014055789,
-0.4290027618,
0.5074875951,
-0.1474239826,
0.5871943235,
0.7054037452,
-0.1703678966,
0.3490997851,
-0.2246323228,
0.5446791053,
-0.3084184229,
0.6109762788,
-0.2648724616,
-0.1820582747,
-0.8059299588,
-0.1746061742,
0.4918336868,
0.3426760435,
-0.7536790371,
0.3025212884,
-0.4352141023,
-0.3311651647,
-0.6090527773,
0.0217413809,
0.4290684462,
0.1219257638,
0.4010379016,
-0.07324031,
-0.4277559221,
-0.9074550271,
-0.2284130305,
-0.2296446115,
-0.2302395552,
0.3960306942,
0.1752351522,
0.0001647849,
0.6459869742,
-0.6865179539,
-0.1130034402,
0.0932534039,
0.0602345318,
0.3855060637,
0.497587949,
0.2962812185,
-0.9950889945,
-0.4202361703,
-0.1465492398,
-0.2393448651,
0.0041669179,
0.1966309249,
-0.1748229563,
0.2271169573,
0.3891236484,
-0.513414681,
0.3479776382,
0.6795665622,
-0.3102492988,
0.5305697918,
-0.3683385253,
-0.0702507719,
-0.5315191746,
0.0053662509,
-0.3810859919,
-0.3023661375,
-0.684104383,
0.4008219242,
0.5569694042,
-0.2340208143,
-0.4925640821,
0.6669005156,
-0.4339841008,
-0.13495785,
-0.3866785467,
-0.125921607,
0.0715657845,
0.5872939229,
-0.2571563721,
0.7738398314,
0.4966641068,
-0.7978060842,
0.5010169148,
-0.006887753,
-0.1059329808,
0.3625037968,
-0.4823944867,
0.4883736968,
-0.2067242265,
0.2661811411,
-0.8676427007,
0.1997858882,
-0.1003573313,
-0.458019048,
0.2816381156,
-0.1452430934,
-0.8917477131,
-0.3178758621,
-0.4580070674,
0.6657874584,
0.7955316305,
-0.7259520888,
0.7434710264,
0.2981232107,
0.1131063029,
-0.6137150526,
-0.5907737613,
0.199518919,
-0.1145522892,
-0.2561680377,
0.3649131656,
-0.3244078457,
-0.0833606571,
0.1788404584,
-0.2664324045,
-0.0279576574,
0.0338738337,
-0.1471195817,
0.1763183028,
-0.1211818308,
0.1353375316,
0.134882316,
0.1287972927,
-0.1623613685,
-0.5731304288,
0.5941465497,
0.0012386896,
-0.1515457779,
0.0219679102,
0.4343758225,
0.3271175325,
-0.0581676178,
0.7424500585,
0.6535551548,
-0.3575919867,
-0.1510612965,
-0.6119125485,
0.2478981614,
-0.4995352328,
0.1947725564,
-0.5426307321,
-0.9421653748,
0.5450849533,
0.0080873473,
0.1267973632,
0.483571887,
0.4297106564,
0.2735992074,
1.2804200649,
0.553481698,
0.2029295564,
0.3845961094,
-0.2301064879,
0.1524892449,
-1.0419057608,
-0.0062307096,
-0.655534327,
-0.26820454,
-0.3367511034,
-0.6932222843,
0.5451756716,
0.6209776998,
-0.367493093,
0.0667515397,
-0.4716895819,
0.5206460953,
0.7399698496,
0.320956111,
0.456050247,
-0.0093036229,
-0.0870390236,
0.3479092419,
-0.9544850588,
-0.2409378141,
1.2217042446,
0.2511875331,
0.6897819042,
0.5384675264,
0.5110253096,
0.4784239531,
0.2550946474,
-1.0144224167,
0.4439979792,
-0.3407810032,
-0.3047671914,
-0.2571448088,
-0.6382166743,
-0.7673822045,
0.3331452012,
-0.1596589833,
-0.3460799754,
0.2256268114,
0.2202162147,
-0.5049920082,
0.3667431474,
-0.4441318512,
0.4074653089,
-0.0593045503,
-0.3581261039,
-0.2187111974,
-0.5614735484,
0.3931883574,
-0.228185758,
0.5643544793,
-0.035090737,
-0.61480546,
0.6020457149,
-0.312715143,
0.3665342927,
-0.1474916488,
-0.1774690449,
0.257109642,
0.244074747,
0.7912506461,
-0.0666793659,
-0.2791119814,
0.0267949663,
-0.0648321956,
-0.9039622545,
-0.8867490292,
0.6391580105,
-0.5607592463,
-0.5816401243,
-0.1609225869,
-0.5071024299,
-0.1381639689,
0.0442257933,
0.1028840095,
1.0060911179,
0.1284257323,
0.3298779726,
0.8066692352,
-0.4096385539,
0.5965868831,
0.8232424855,
-0.0943267867,
-0.6230916977,
1.0089710951,
0.0326559246,
0.2149823755,
0.7320373058,
0.2969082296,
-0.3722618818,
-1.0151952505,
-0.4741893411,
0.0269910824,
-0.9607002735,
-0.7260361314,
-0.6499712467,
-0.176247254,
-0.4223799706,
0.0579765588,
-0.3031130135,
-0.5664994717,
-0.2560321987,
0.3644050956,
0.1567312628,
0.6422218084,
0.0282615945,
0.3602510095,
-1.2079819441,
0.3395546675,
0.2863266766,
0.3442713916,
0.25304389,
-0.7658973932,
-0.5343742371,
-0.0927847922,
-0.3504201174,
-0.5280344486,
0.3822084665,
0.4266924262,
0.3740267456,
0.2690512836,
0.6389997005,
0.670317173,
-0.5131109953,
0.787850678,
0.098191753,
-0.9249718785,
0.0403077416,
0.0646881908,
0.5216355324,
0.1302502304,
0.5738515854,
-0.3867082,
-0.1852730066,
-0.6774671078,
-1.0452622175,
0.4486416578,
0.0602689721,
0.4929286242,
-0.0133298077,
0.456289649,
-0.0691031218,
0.2254956812,
-0.5937855244,
-0.4292265773,
0.27254498,
-0.2595386505,
0.05002103,
-0.670612514,
-0.0454213247,
-0.0818441883,
0.6214843392,
-0.209363997,
0.4891699255,
0.246100843,
-0.1530603766,
-0.1805863976,
0.3253111541,
0.4911432266,
0.4828198254,
0.0024340141,
0.4661365747,
-0.0244115889,
-0.3882131577,
0.2182511538,
0.0231212471,
0.0291417036,
-0.1294985414,
0.2297858894,
0.979493022,
0.1218191236,
-0.7969896197,
0.5247592926,
-0.2447620779,
-0.1927769333,
-0.0745075271,
0.0578603335,
-0.3613066673,
0.3116572797,
0.9357717037,
-0.1726655066,
0.4698832929,
-0.5184704661,
0.0182335265,
0.5958411694,
-0.2381533831,
-0.1272467077,
0.6026909351,
0.0173083544,
-0.4771149457,
0.4887424111,
-0.3188253045,
-0.6504296064,
0.2415709496,
0.572887063,
0.7156504393,
-0.2253180146,
-0.248478204,
0.2545394897,
0.1799815148,
-0.1846178621,
0.2234900743,
-0.3681360185,
-0.5112965107,
-0.5992980003,
-0.9828671217,
-0.5071771145,
0.0034994606,
-0.6303185821,
0.4420987368,
-0.2224511802,
-0.0461162329,
-0.2060153782,
0.1053310782,
-0.4665085077,
0.1549822539,
0.03230685,
0.796584487,
-0.4849756956,
0.9256060123,
0.5979765058,
0.1226839647,
-0.6378170848,
-0.0884744823,
-0.2384942323,
-0.794559896,
0.2917022407,
-0.3074082136,
0.2398370057,
0.5809257627,
-0.4002706409,
-0.9311676025,
0.8083097935,
0.4367897213,
-0.7005431652,
-0.2721420527,
-0.158922568,
0.3019523025,
0.0547841899,
0.4129866958,
0.4056335986,
0.1220925525,
0.2939587831,
-0.8219559193,
0.230118677,
-0.3237138391,
0.1143029034,
0.6122315526,
-0.6518729329,
0.7756628394,
-0.039762754,
-0.1875841022,
0.1605948806,
0.4777235985,
0.0995349586,
-0.0537765026,
0.3902975023,
0.4750529826,
0.554265976,
0.2253969014,
1.296874404,
-0.393083185,
0.4714533985,
0.7501862645,
0.1989892125,
1.0316499472,
0.3494001925,
-0.605753243,
-0.007712265,
0.4834017158,
0.1658880115,
0.1715052426,
0.3893754482,
-0.5024241209,
-0.2069356441,
-0.2456789315,
-0.1732411981,
0.0530428477,
0.3401898146,
-0.1494904608,
0.0983239561,
0.0902095214,
-0.2001823038,
-0.0763178021,
-0.5618659258,
0.6900793314,
-0.0806973875,
-0.2660833001,
1.1457298994,
0.0931205079,
0.6959119439,
-0.4428726733,
-0.0123019563,
-0.241572693,
-0.1320294738,
-0.1757241935,
-0.7001276016,
0.1066811159,
-0.1086274981,
-0.1296356618,
-0.2086831629,
0.5174844265,
-0.3572281599,
-0.3871799409,
-0.0217397735,
0.3283576965,
0.1428678334,
-0.3639904857,
-0.492541641,
0.4661495388,
-0.0606660657,
-0.4347943664,
0.612711668,
0.4982629418,
0.1161685511,
0.5527616143,
0.7644641399,
0.1780677885,
0.2338814139,
-0.0728172362,
1.1330252886,
-0.7435117364,
-0.402667135,
-0.9247652888,
0.1977091581,
0.2766261995,
-0.0245100521,
0.5118985176,
0.8839771748,
0.6076586246,
0.300183028,
0.560990572,
-0.0235094354,
0.2480091453,
-0.8458430171,
0.2163894624,
-0.8463961482,
0.4487268627,
-0.0946604311,
-1.1471498013,
-0.6338946223,
0.1753353029,
0.3172785342,
-0.2360845357,
0.7047941685,
0.6242128015,
0.0749236718,
-0.2148722559,
0.5962536335,
0.1944858134,
0.3642651141,
0.7677136064,
0.7932913303,
-0.6414029002,
1.0472071171,
-0.3248049021,
-0.2336961627,
-0.2668963671,
-0.8343682885,
-0.4472154975,
-0.407928437,
-0.2200314701,
-0.3919574022,
0.0770123303,
0.9275891781,
0.4130043387,
-0.460496068,
-0.1451610774,
-0.0717736185,
0.1024744883,
-0.0484392196,
-0.1499139071,
0.5652077198,
-0.1845874339,
-0.8713674545,
0.2203199714,
0.2387337685,
0.1998632997,
-0.2755543888,
-0.0953034312,
0.1038252488,
0.0935067683,
0.6853260398,
0.1452273726,
-0.5155360699,
0.0030994629,
0.0535222851,
-0.0395628884,
0.1064100266,
1.0204161406,
-0.8814731836,
0.3976915777,
0.431381911,
0.5467873812,
0.5148223042,
0.189497292,
0.4981447756,
-0.6927565336,
0.1308866143,
0.4895603359,
0.0596077964,
0.1159185842,
-0.4060648382,
0.3950572014,
0.1021099687,
-0.586611867,
-1.3240907192,
0.1233277693,
-0.630440712,
-0.4830316901,
1.2637084723,
-0.0586342998,
-0.3068911135,
-0.0555649847,
-0.36980322,
0.2940227091,
-0.5124861598,
0.4892804921,
0.4693816006,
-0.3167763352,
-0.3937541246,
-0.5945791602,
0.4033166468,
0.3098163009,
-0.3120004237,
0.2798331678,
0.3996009827,
-0.3758209646,
-0.0606559925,
0.5877510309,
-0.0461773016,
0.2798901796,
0.046756465,
0.1476695389,
-0.2474460006,
-0.1254899651,
-0.7927849293,
0.416216433,
0.3984059691,
0.2222517133
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06112v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06112v2
|
Axis Tour: Word Tour Determines the Order of Axes in ICA-transformed Embeddings
| 2024-01-11T18:46:12 | 2024-06-13T13:44:03 |
Hiroaki Yamagiwa, Yusuke Takase, Hidetoshi Shimodaira
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Word embedding is one of the most important components in natural language
processing, but interpreting high-dimensional embeddings remains a challenging
problem. To address this problem, Independent Component Analysis (ICA) is
identified as an effective solution. ICA-transformed word embeddings reveal
interpretable semantic axes; however, the order of these axes are arbitrary. In
this study, we focus on this property and propose a novel method, Axis Tour,
which optimizes the order of the axes. Inspired by Word Tour, a one-dimensional
word embedding method, we aim to improve the clarity of the word embedding
space by maximizing the semantic continuity of the axes. Furthermore, we show
through experiments on downstream tasks that Axis Tour yields better or
comparable low-dimensional embeddings compared to both PCA and ICA.
|
[
-0.585401237,
-0.7979701161,
0.6286361814,
0.2137445658,
-0.6800455451,
0.0357730277,
0.0647320747,
-0.3187406957,
0.6887845993,
0.523958087,
-0.6773069501,
-0.9497812986,
-0.787740469,
-0.0291422177,
-0.1955633909,
0.5647355914,
-0.08140558,
0.0409396179,
-0.3841605783,
-0.7166344523,
-0.5113252401,
-0.1592307687,
-0.4398072362,
-0.4133855402,
0.3858295381,
0.2287486941,
1.1323261261,
0.9514792562,
0.5405569673,
0.2461256832,
0.1235958263,
0.3001922965,
-0.5874009132,
-0.0785816237,
-0.2310146838,
-0.1764894277,
-0.2637937963,
0.010579817,
0.3529195189,
1.0829356909,
0.2734580636,
-0.0706576109,
0.1638572216,
0.4524890184,
-0.4145310521,
0.5602542162,
-0.3061089516,
-0.0091031091,
-0.2508828342,
-0.3564815819,
-0.374430865,
-0.3173466623,
0.3097505569,
-0.9286196828,
-0.2297762781,
0.2081985921,
0.9337256551,
0.2679095268,
-0.4625343978,
-0.1933106035,
-0.7210603952,
0.8268253207,
-0.2362449914,
0.7261938453,
0.2919401526,
0.0676563978,
-0.2208887488,
-0.7498438954,
-0.6239752173,
0.1613063812,
-0.0645251423,
0.1624957472,
-0.5257304311,
0.2604539394,
-0.2640698552,
-0.1397375464,
-0.5053753257,
0.3403612077,
-0.3270203173,
-0.0911485329,
0.6576849818,
-0.0977832153,
0.7459751368,
-0.2887752056,
-0.6129996777,
-0.4934470654,
-0.7411907911,
0.0497074537,
0.3108999431,
0.5517394543,
0.2262050658,
0.5469091535,
-0.2938936055,
0.4312657714,
-0.2092996538,
-0.5308627486,
0.3382703364,
0.0730927363,
-0.1236004755,
0.4177644551,
0.5857917666,
0.609888196,
-0.2373804897,
-0.399821043,
0.0031980951,
0.2190655172,
0.2306844592,
-0.573248148,
-0.073479034,
0.1504824311,
-0.5306253433,
-0.0257210825,
0.0395388789,
-0.7956422567,
-0.1782965064,
-0.7422647476,
0.6483350396,
-0.8666181564,
-0.0653800815,
0.1944004744,
0.0355439857,
0.5164746046,
0.1783217192,
-0.4029572606,
0.086373657,
0.9555118084,
0.7223985195,
-0.4162155688,
-0.3297243118,
-0.6147694588,
-0.0089369696,
-0.4541605413,
1.1376878023,
-0.7054532766,
-0.3805804551,
0.2490641028,
-0.2288027853,
0.0511476882,
-0.1749855578,
0.8007566929,
-0.5855377913,
0.0705980062,
-0.3568340242,
-0.6449174881,
-0.6758946776,
0.0989686027,
-0.31046772,
0.7884989381,
-0.0890340582,
-0.5902092457,
0.5505788326,
-0.5291905403,
-0.302641958,
0.1995973438,
-0.4485858977,
-0.2710340619,
0.1284213811,
0.6355347633,
0.1006667912,
0.2599743307,
-0.3381215036,
-0.4351971149,
-0.0318178497,
-0.3615506291,
-0.1926193833,
0.8994922638,
-0.0017221868,
-0.1504219472,
-0.0068778396,
-0.8057498932,
0.2562979758,
-0.1010117084,
0.0325192772,
-0.8933924437,
0.2185997665,
-0.1918094605,
0.0247893799,
0.1681822687,
-0.581297636,
0.4105886817,
-0.5295937657,
0.0070066354,
0.8765317798,
0.241242364,
0.5596513748,
0.1771117896,
0.6472629905,
0.0912781954,
0.0430031754,
0.2426893264,
-0.6950710416,
-0.7257080078,
-0.400524348,
0.2143944055,
0.4223513603,
-0.9466895461,
0.6783707738,
-0.5880863667,
-0.4910423756,
-0.7486304045,
0.0139361089,
0.1188348234,
-0.0550906621,
0.4753963053,
-0.2911034524,
-0.3330584764,
-0.8611019254,
-0.1014470756,
-0.2115383297,
0.1583435982,
-0.1524865031,
0.1197330505,
-0.3185998499,
1.0344749689,
-0.9358485937,
-0.6885053515,
-0.4700598121,
0.4915634692,
0.0158533882,
0.1781693548,
0.7299696207,
-0.4883188605,
-0.4641861916,
0.0352162495,
-0.5392434597,
-0.0976171866,
-0.2210415453,
-0.663436234,
-0.2833753526,
0.6096478701,
-0.5021709204,
0.8138614893,
0.4278521538,
-0.4669598937,
-0.1112573892,
-0.530354917,
-0.4271309972,
-0.7122379541,
-0.4542719126,
-0.4256682396,
-0.1942402571,
-0.6190077662,
0.0469853021,
-0.2678385079,
-0.0703161508,
-0.1434537917,
0.3514389992,
-0.6127096415,
-0.0935162976,
-0.4956251681,
0.7919734716,
0.1531601101,
0.7542803288,
-0.3744568229,
0.3344762623,
0.5283131003,
-0.5532671213,
-0.0954119861,
0.7001338601,
-0.2963062525,
0.7893448472,
-0.1531876773,
0.4199287593,
-0.6250900626,
-0.0663914457,
-1.1374753714,
0.38730672,
0.0986430198,
-0.3385950327,
0.4064683914,
0.1491700411,
-0.3430255353,
0.0625228509,
-0.3368100822,
0.2683623135,
0.2342489809,
-0.8024709821,
0.8536102176,
0.5453480482,
0.021837363,
-0.1309465468,
-0.2864912748,
-0.0542626679,
-0.05260792,
-0.7185914516,
0.5914995074,
0.0044358834,
-0.4473028779,
0.0933313295,
-0.1238196269,
0.1347752959,
-0.1209786832,
0.2091170102,
-0.008360263,
-0.2523659468,
0.1103563011,
0.4929620326,
-0.4378842115,
-0.0923635811,
-0.4269123673,
0.6807461977,
0.272223264,
-0.4034374356,
-0.7097754478,
0.5888723731,
0.403396219,
-0.3748390079,
0.5969878435,
0.7310413718,
-0.2822580636,
-0.3085979521,
-0.0335619189,
0.0063755121,
-0.4549385905,
0.3294685185,
-0.4409985244,
-0.2521029413,
0.23264274,
0.0412651151,
0.0382879972,
0.5234806538,
0.0587334037,
0.1381400824,
1.3543134928,
1.0778465271,
-0.2924554646,
0.3073453307,
-0.4438132942,
0.7213023305,
-0.6999754906,
-0.0342724808,
-0.5919462442,
-0.6106303334,
-0.9587484002,
-0.390853107,
0.6858156919,
0.1414158195,
0.144503504,
0.1503457129,
-0.4073208272,
0.4190012813,
0.5366228819,
0.0925302431,
0.3146243989,
0.1927977651,
-0.4471436739,
-0.193377465,
-0.5313606858,
-0.4543089867,
0.7058935761,
0.1094693765,
0.4260662794,
-0.0349846222,
0.9412021637,
0.0463837311,
0.1874149293,
-1.0787847042,
0.6491431594,
-0.4992516637,
0.066712819,
-0.49595505,
0.2130353153,
-1.2966127396,
0.5924608707,
-0.1290697753,
-0.8197861314,
0.4508445859,
-0.5571773052,
-0.3400170207,
0.4243143499,
-0.5167945027,
0.5988750458,
-0.1429145336,
0.1021015123,
-0.1126563475,
-0.4802559912,
-0.2780443132,
0.3415591717,
0.3522988558,
-0.2270264924,
0.0346661992,
0.8486655354,
-0.5331887007,
0.524967134,
-0.2397896349,
0.0793554038,
0.3387024105,
0.3004181087,
0.5581570268,
-0.0662796944,
0.201981023,
0.1794708669,
-0.2989962995,
-0.3371601701,
-0.7450594306,
0.6411078572,
-1.1562342644,
-0.52309376,
-0.3418247998,
-0.5020698905,
-0.3076476157,
0.5411889553,
0.1975374967,
0.7858836651,
-0.0362223201,
0.1930661201,
0.4473088384,
-0.3188726604,
0.3242103457,
0.0864508897,
-0.4966997802,
-0.433098495,
0.9496605992,
0.4913907051,
-0.0063656876,
0.7734656334,
0.4234538078,
-0.1798232198,
-0.99317348,
-0.1154301241,
0.3314048648,
-0.8559185863,
-0.15291363,
-0.7804123163,
0.0462478809,
-0.5533255935,
-0.2878924906,
-0.4365686774,
-0.4578331709,
-0.3056336939,
-0.5828943253,
0.1760365665,
0.8177534342,
-0.1262535751,
0.3699799478,
-0.5479785204,
0.3016660511,
0.3308162987,
0.116031684,
-0.3964166641,
-0.1674748808,
0.0609930083,
-0.1395560354,
-0.4791076779,
-0.6900549531,
0.5897319317,
0.0570006333,
0.6715003848,
0.9283141494,
0.3031795621,
0.9543350339,
-0.5255323648,
0.6995772719,
0.0084872022,
-0.779216826,
0.3592938185,
-0.1354613006,
0.4781406522,
0.6273363829,
0.4078979492,
-0.3140952885,
-0.5708926916,
-0.5637350082,
-1.1763375998,
0.5512466431,
0.4507270455,
-0.0104089975,
-0.0134928674,
0.0768118128,
0.2957556546,
-0.2861506343,
-0.3339457512,
-0.4726541936,
-0.2130454481,
-0.2491601706,
-0.0389473476,
-0.1046594381,
-0.148208499,
-0.0511499532,
0.6208677292,
-0.2513072491,
0.5930808187,
0.2699022591,
-0.1210432351,
0.1016710028,
-0.1429600865,
0.2913990319,
1.0361016989,
-0.152450949,
0.3269662261,
0.0618728958,
-0.58105129,
-0.2476583272,
0.0516668707,
-0.3321579993,
0.3507430553,
0.5994551182,
0.9184476137,
0.1477807164,
-0.1793929636,
0.5632051826,
-0.0349381305,
0.1456453353,
-0.2168000191,
-0.3611240089,
-0.1690143049,
0.2046618164,
0.212065801,
-0.2127062231,
0.1147115454,
-0.3863287866,
0.2281077206,
0.2975556254,
-0.5661149025,
-0.4200454652,
0.3727113903,
-0.1460585892,
-0.3978947103,
0.7746272683,
-0.2926160395,
-0.6049928665,
0.156610474,
0.17030783,
1.3090685606,
-0.1073445976,
0.391525805,
0.2892260849,
0.4153014123,
0.4075827003,
0.308598727,
0.1609155685,
-0.8831170201,
0.0022458034,
-0.6201047897,
-0.2882944942,
-0.2953263819,
-0.784132719,
0.5066536069,
-0.0600281879,
0.0684215873,
0.0429137014,
-0.0386075675,
-0.8734763265,
0.0534121022,
0.120431833,
0.707636714,
-0.5828148127,
0.9033739567,
0.5501680374,
-0.3533078134,
-0.7985982895,
0.1685337722,
-0.1427424103,
-0.9142637253,
0.6329551935,
0.2946048677,
-0.2824642062,
-0.184149161,
-0.4039410949,
-1.1269717216,
1.2426482439,
0.0840420946,
0.0114414925,
-0.0919381008,
0.6619259715,
0.6020311713,
-0.5317049026,
0.0574257411,
0.471562922,
0.4674991667,
-0.0692700073,
-0.5157361627,
-0.169118166,
0.2961655557,
0.3765460849,
0.1569773108,
-0.6271727085,
0.353595525,
0.2131849527,
-0.4390712976,
-0.1696694791,
1.1723200083,
-0.0501385219,
0.3254947364,
0.7959268093,
0.7114867568,
0.6972530484,
-0.1266515702,
0.9694475532,
-0.3951048851,
0.3296706975,
0.9365366697,
-0.1263647079,
0.9486956,
0.5833761692,
-0.2141558528,
0.5683732033,
0.2729378045,
0.5974062681,
0.9392554164,
-0.0150551181,
0.0763277933,
-0.2619647682,
0.0214255415,
0.075630039,
1.0554391146,
0.3539811373,
0.1081744879,
-0.5759429336,
0.528002739,
0.5108296275,
-0.0261017941,
-0.2062532753,
0.6811280251,
0.1272189915,
-0.6204097271,
0.3231636584,
-0.0361358784,
0.2026111335,
-0.8090168834,
-0.0258912705,
-0.5177492499,
0.4485547245,
0.1086132824,
-0.5135535598,
0.3369824588,
-0.638899982,
0.3482544124,
-0.5406199694,
0.4654971659,
-0.3121818006,
-0.6673158407,
0.6957392097,
0.2723743916,
-0.0288419873,
0.1212928817,
-0.4237202108,
0.1484468132,
-0.0207869224,
-0.2501480579,
0.255353272,
0.8061664104,
0.0600831024,
0.4979273081,
0.330812633,
-0.1883317232,
0.2207395434,
-0.333262682,
0.7742980719,
-0.4210088253,
-0.7945863605,
-0.4649841487,
0.2774544954,
-0.0365912914,
-0.400829196,
0.7978737354,
0.5339375734,
0.8699979782,
0.2751757801,
0.500837326,
0.0607359819,
0.2804837823,
-0.613093555,
0.5366888642,
-0.5254938006,
0.051311478,
-0.2851119041,
-0.7342157364,
-0.4866674244,
0.7543885708,
-0.3401330411,
-0.4159934521,
0.9458835125,
0.7416658401,
-0.0454326756,
0.1587883681,
0.4177360237,
0.4857687354,
0.7032352686,
-0.0853796527,
0.2535034716,
-0.4750291407,
0.5259898901,
-0.616709888,
-0.2926630378,
0.0335743837,
-0.7546797991,
-0.5613361597,
-0.5558351874,
-0.5369272232,
-0.3826075196,
-0.214187324,
1.0502933264,
0.370858103,
-0.5891106129,
-0.2656898797,
0.1904276758,
0.2877872884,
-0.6437720656,
-0.2453114986,
1.0352429152,
-0.4936015606,
-0.9105085135,
0.5741232038,
0.6687652469,
-0.3028441668,
-0.5445684791,
0.2376346141,
-0.3920102119,
0.2267233431,
0.8740894794,
-0.1685237885,
-0.3660189509,
-0.8872604966,
-0.1771353483,
0.1501166821,
0.4072942138,
0.6097747684,
-0.5393124819,
0.8194653988,
1.0081566572,
0.6501814127,
0.4947713614,
-0.2008693218,
0.5947213173,
-0.5048072934,
0.1366183907,
0.0992139354,
0.4850184619,
-0.0386533961,
-0.1926945895,
0.4003936052,
0.1617080718,
-0.4142522514,
-0.6129592061,
0.2531226873,
-1.5422363281,
-0.1327825338,
1.1886076927,
-0.157932207,
-0.5325855613,
-0.1737752259,
-0.3058592975,
0.1909300983,
-0.0958240926,
0.6732650399,
0.6783912182,
-0.5158110261,
0.3811586797,
-0.3845269978,
0.2727849483,
0.0214302856,
-0.7119933963,
-0.4208189845,
0.0939453766,
0.0728205964,
0.5947924852,
0.3878983855,
-0.2023533285,
-0.35497123,
-0.0611926094,
-0.223871991,
0.3398194909,
-0.4651882946,
-0.0242556538,
0.4377094507,
-0.0146879759,
-0.6530991197
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06105v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06105v1
|
PALP: Prompt Aligned Personalization of Text-to-Image Models
| 2024-01-11T18:35:33 | 2024-01-11T18:35:33 |
Moab Arar, Andrey Voynov, Amir Hertz, Omri Avrahami, Shlomi Fruchter, Yael Pritch, Daniel Cohen-Or, Ariel Shamir
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.GR, cs.LG
|
Content creators often aim to create personalized images using personal
subjects that go beyond the capabilities of conventional text-to-image models.
Additionally, they may want the resulting image to encompass a specific
location, style, ambiance, and more. Existing personalization methods may
compromise personalization ability or the alignment to complex textual prompts.
This trade-off can impede the fulfillment of user prompts and subject fidelity.
We propose a new approach focusing on personalization methods for a
\emph{single} prompt to address this issue. We term our approach prompt-aligned
personalization. While this may seem restrictive, our method excels in
improving text alignment, enabling the creation of images with complex and
intricate prompts, which may pose a challenge for current techniques. In
particular, our method keeps the personalized model aligned with a target
prompt using an additional score distillation sampling term. We demonstrate the
versatility of our method in multi- and single-shot settings and further show
that it can compose multiple subjects or use inspiration from reference images,
such as artworks. We compare our approach quantitatively and qualitatively with
existing baselines and state-of-the-art techniques.
|
[
-0.5420837998,
-0.7577235699,
0.6039912105,
0.2002239823,
-0.4317125976,
0.0599218607,
-0.1994512081,
-0.0570768416,
0.3235227168,
0.4214868844,
-0.8142973185,
-0.5569514036,
-0.2991113365,
0.3001889586,
0.1799162626,
0.7590503097,
0.001741939,
-0.1381895244,
-0.3617638052,
-0.2435369492,
-1.1122354269,
-0.2258877605,
-0.6552054286,
0.0159153733,
0.7498307824,
0.5541873574,
0.6385810375,
0.6685475707,
0.7505910993,
0.2567863464,
0.0026270065,
0.2546220422,
-0.1589946598,
0.6890189052,
-0.2704266608,
0.0537603498,
-0.2885299921,
0.0598386936,
0.586801827,
0.479496628,
0.0271958672,
0.1300972402,
0.0593157746,
0.6692607999,
-0.5816518664,
-0.2135239244,
-0.3318396509,
0.1513253003,
-0.3518489599,
-0.3066462874,
-0.5098374486,
-0.3735467196,
0.3066224158,
-0.9162985682,
0.1039015278,
0.1591496468,
0.6278921962,
0.3626795709,
-0.4709223211,
-0.2452584356,
-0.6067261696,
0.6568915248,
-0.4055811167,
-0.2119692564,
-0.0233004205,
0.9010632038,
0.097038947,
-0.7390107512,
-0.461137265,
0.070111461,
-0.1898166686,
0.4038095474,
-0.0954888463,
-0.0686991811,
0.2544799745,
0.1787460297,
-0.5238046646,
0.0091401627,
0.1069006324,
-0.1098684147,
0.4738274217,
0.3271864355,
0.5069786906,
-0.1219562739,
-0.7415646911,
-0.022307815,
-0.4648153782,
0.4109600484,
0.6180000901,
0.5515283346,
0.0625836551,
0.6474764347,
-0.151671797,
0.882499814,
0.7228426337,
-0.1292659491,
-0.0197169688,
-0.4230065942,
0.2269345671,
0.3485038579,
0.8461156487,
0.7885357738,
0.1195040271,
0.1558582336,
-0.0268991515,
-0.2500290871,
0.1404887885,
-0.6988427043,
-0.0897127464,
0.2453998923,
-0.4959287047,
-0.3106657267,
0.1872009188,
-0.9758328199,
-0.6707445979,
-0.416480273,
0.2411657572,
-0.4458546042,
0.1392138004,
-0.1381224394,
-0.3952967525,
0.042344138,
0.5837845206,
-0.9536204338,
-0.0795343444,
0.4047712088,
0.7980636954,
-0.2631658316,
-0.2799499631,
-0.7143447995,
0.2668261826,
-0.1178585291,
1.1839852333,
-0.9024715424,
-0.4065927863,
0.14796938,
-0.2095136493,
0.4614635408,
-0.1611146331,
0.554184854,
-0.3019428253,
0.6861439347,
-0.7133177519,
-0.5606449842,
0.0449177437,
0.263835758,
-0.5163371563,
0.5903221369,
-0.0572687835,
-0.9890494347,
0.247746855,
-0.5185782909,
-0.1015772074,
0.2450255454,
-0.2245094031,
-0.3196721673,
0.1812838465,
0.4920612872,
0.3523731232,
-0.1227682903,
0.282676965,
-0.549026072,
-0.2889789641,
0.2399374694,
-0.452287972,
0.5123900175,
0.177895546,
0.1760956794,
0.0920430869,
-0.5720832348,
-0.1386107355,
0.1952134371,
-0.0257935394,
-0.4915193021,
-0.1744641662,
0.134170115,
0.164192915,
0.7061896324,
-0.6180648804,
0.6357958913,
-0.1207629368,
-0.0054089846,
0.9248350859,
0.240735516,
0.6948648095,
-0.5966042876,
0.6776621342,
0.0144285792,
0.0069588968,
-0.9680494666,
-0.4963395596,
-0.0167543087,
-0.5946359634,
0.3245854974,
0.4346778393,
-0.4979880452,
0.4826491475,
-0.1122982204,
-0.3102622926,
-0.3601057529,
-0.2037864178,
0.318135649,
1.131249547,
0.3485007584,
-0.5159665346,
-0.2641738653,
-0.9531171918,
-0.3828727007,
0.2018545121,
-0.1968901753,
0.4214767218,
-0.1693475842,
0.1377503127,
1.3805463314,
-0.8460319638,
-0.3356490135,
0.2794075906,
0.1165188923,
0.2952685654,
0.6870791316,
0.5900520086,
-0.7781977654,
-1.0140868425,
-0.1226200461,
-0.550729692,
-0.4044696391,
-0.3945627213,
-0.265843302,
-0.2064229846,
0.0778382868,
-0.5133500695,
0.2401514649,
0.1884965003,
-0.6489562988,
0.548425138,
-0.4153574705,
0.5372425318,
-1.4272978306,
0.165450424,
0.4703790247,
-0.3369252384,
-0.7937988043,
-0.0435885489,
-0.0457656607,
-0.4165150821,
-0.3470068872,
0.9544002414,
-0.4614715576,
0.2894831598,
-0.4162572324,
0.0965806544,
0.4028897583,
0.4157556891,
0.2647269368,
0.5175215602,
0.6829422712,
-0.20312877,
0.4806733131,
0.718816638,
-0.154159233,
1.5622013807,
-0.7581911087,
0.4030412734,
-0.4936232865,
0.4239259064,
-1.3743485212,
-0.4070391953,
0.5182973742,
-0.2593541741,
0.6183542013,
0.0082659302,
-0.2881609797,
0.0615325049,
-0.5310426354,
0.5328267217,
0.4575996995,
-0.7078311443,
0.7273821831,
0.0094105005,
-0.4235224128,
-0.5570757985,
-0.4459658861,
0.1012254059,
-0.6637451053,
-0.7978248596,
0.8870023489,
-0.3660588861,
0.0321472175,
-0.1465023458,
-0.1288359016,
-0.1298940182,
-0.2559912503,
0.3120158613,
0.4309620559,
-0.1937944591,
0.234315753,
0.2755087912,
-0.2434381694,
-0.5198605061,
0.055051621,
0.5426613092,
0.1895671189,
-0.4549121261,
-0.9214477539,
0.8063741326,
0.2764699757,
-0.4160183668,
0.4625251591,
0.5075665116,
-0.4154757559,
0.1759853214,
-0.6230374575,
-0.0520941131,
-0.5387102962,
-0.2041750997,
-0.633897841,
-0.4692108035,
0.6430213451,
-0.1634081006,
0.2484824657,
0.3011286855,
0.4105151594,
-0.6632284522,
1.1704264879,
0.4988470376,
0.2891840041,
0.7114410996,
0.3128530383,
0.0653163418,
-0.9794496894,
-0.2232564092,
-0.3896608353,
-0.6063743234,
-0.2122384459,
0.0125336247,
0.4270752966,
-0.0496195406,
-0.5281738043,
0.2965850234,
-0.8868246675,
0.5268830657,
0.6045159698,
0.4897140563,
0.3512271643,
0.0786747932,
0.0672211349,
-0.3492498696,
-0.3571977317,
-0.6788398027,
0.8711745143,
0.225542888,
0.8072369695,
0.0494074337,
0.809453249,
0.3043068051,
0.0973841473,
-0.5724225044,
0.3133336008,
-0.3554958403,
-0.506706953,
-0.2500928044,
0.0319940932,
-0.8099238276,
0.0018873846,
-0.2938628495,
-0.7735844254,
0.3688380718,
0.5171958804,
-0.746946156,
-0.1368097067,
-0.8406054974,
1.1212515831,
-0.306578666,
-0.2654303908,
0.3656480908,
-0.7838201523,
0.1215367615,
-0.197268635,
-0.1225919798,
-0.3599036634,
-0.489941895,
0.1018508449,
-0.3188774586,
0.9279267192,
-0.3687579036,
0.1078162044,
0.1247705072,
0.0004696429,
0.4768007994,
0.1118466854,
-0.0729188174,
-0.2142720371,
0.1644841731,
-0.4527412951,
-0.7198406458,
0.6168786287,
-0.3574820757,
-0.7139889002,
-0.3101573586,
-0.5690124631,
-0.1656747013,
0.1208259165,
0.5850093961,
0.6453948617,
-0.3894277513,
-0.0214366224,
0.619138062,
-0.3528649807,
0.5816059113,
0.1753003895,
-0.0282941852,
-0.6587988138,
0.7052460313,
-0.2646459937,
0.1165013388,
0.5794934034,
0.5147042274,
-0.5225041509,
-0.1954325289,
-0.4320571125,
0.0253591724,
-0.8034192324,
-0.3937580585,
-0.2921857536,
0.4348435402,
-0.5981446505,
-0.6229065061,
-0.2043444365,
-0.3637136519,
-0.6229656339,
0.5718864202,
0.232905373,
0.138645336,
0.3748799264,
0.5829811692,
-0.9032540917,
0.4582724869,
0.4942235947,
0.2268746495,
-0.462218821,
-0.7391045094,
0.573558569,
-0.0052183368,
-0.4372766912,
-1.2688215971,
0.2411949337,
0.38173154,
0.5979089141,
0.5410809517,
0.261680603,
0.8189257979,
-0.7547137737,
0.7982882261,
0.6316729188,
-0.9763031602,
0.9401631951,
-0.5067949295,
0.6866090298,
0.8226671815,
0.4162198305,
-0.8011187315,
0.0706861913,
-0.4993742108,
-0.4464296401,
0.4551623166,
-0.1512338966,
0.3906569183,
0.2214865535,
0.5672225952,
0.3415920734,
0.2514864802,
-0.5585075617,
-0.2279704064,
-0.2788719535,
-0.6949515343,
-0.0281347856,
-0.0796629041,
-0.3000558615,
-0.0273123123,
0.4314194024,
-0.5199261308,
-0.1013666838,
0.2703278959,
0.2359742969,
-0.0612302311,
0.0746099278,
0.453959167,
0.5099838376,
-0.0960034952,
-0.0021596863,
-0.2299127579,
-0.0331179909,
0.2759660184,
0.1877168417,
-0.2876277566,
0.0922949985,
0.0190428086,
0.6582878828,
-0.0903411433,
-0.5497007966,
0.7095121741,
-0.1650409549,
0.1939530075,
-0.123805277,
-0.1987264603,
-0.2339402735,
0.308008641,
0.137765348,
0.338141948,
0.1416423619,
-0.4385545254,
0.032686457,
0.5279529095,
-0.4181031287,
-0.3479014039,
0.5709137917,
0.3309914172,
-0.4992167056,
0.3931158781,
-0.059701927,
-0.1282538623,
0.5263784528,
0.6309975982,
0.9284040928,
-0.3293414414,
0.4889614284,
0.3184401989,
-0.1147292107,
-0.0691162124,
0.0619212054,
-0.0472073741,
-0.5741050839,
-0.0175870862,
-0.2915160358,
-0.5786822438,
-0.4601620436,
-0.4902127981,
0.6988540888,
-0.2980045378,
-0.3458425701,
0.2300039232,
-0.1963042617,
-0.4837811589,
0.0767066032,
0.4335039854,
0.8405591846,
-0.7883467078,
0.5197159052,
1.1064580679,
-0.4497234225,
-0.6146308184,
0.0946666002,
0.1726022214,
-0.4719603062,
0.1484181732,
0.4857473969,
0.286696434,
0.037365634,
-0.4037150145,
-0.6885449886,
1.2093763351,
0.4545280337,
-0.7018588781,
-0.0692516863,
-0.1615417749,
0.4630509615,
-0.7431099415,
0.1827834845,
0.2888351679,
0.4725188613,
0.4399698377,
-0.5409507155,
0.2011908591,
-0.1535036713,
0.3188103437,
0.1690822989,
-0.6454556584,
0.5069685578,
-0.0630281195,
-0.4311139882,
0.2665849924,
0.5814960003,
0.5202479959,
0.5942602754,
0.5376948118,
0.4528470635,
0.7817691565,
-0.1120229363,
0.9767661095,
-0.3837935627,
0.1979085058,
1.4172261953,
-0.388281554,
0.3728618026,
0.7534607053,
-0.0367505588,
0.2300379425,
0.9131065011,
-0.1335138977,
0.9700769782,
-0.1068450436,
-0.3297803104,
-0.2063898891,
-0.4197662175,
-0.2709252834,
0.279384315,
-0.0380439013,
-0.3052274287,
-0.2545774877,
0.1334641874,
-0.4891873598,
0.5096751451,
-0.1460939348,
0.7176676989,
-0.1862651706,
-0.8065598607,
0.0085117444,
-0.1879357845,
0.8143177629,
-0.5067954659,
-0.0368122458,
-0.2374696434,
-0.2782311738,
-0.1486784965,
-0.9509832859,
0.2485491484,
-0.061219085,
-0.1719470769,
-0.5974089503,
0.9522963166,
-0.4974013567,
-0.388279587,
-0.5305892229,
0.3572969139,
-0.1236479506,
-0.257679075,
-0.6406903863,
-0.1279550046,
-0.0303768553,
-0.19441998,
0.1410350502,
0.4556751847,
0.2578351796,
0.2686301172,
0.3179143965,
-0.1707835495,
-0.0901215076,
0.0407155827,
0.7037747502,
-0.4068424106,
-0.432710588,
-0.9416003823,
0.8848730922,
-0.1769450754,
-0.7307609916,
0.3993865848,
0.3626943231,
0.3279476464,
-0.3027962446,
0.5517314672,
-0.0334689468,
0.3188053966,
-0.3574958742,
0.2606397569,
-0.6028889418,
0.2197256386,
-0.4065385461,
-1.1189981699,
-0.3353267014,
0.273756206,
-0.0988329574,
-0.2891024351,
0.496165216,
0.6303347349,
-0.0767493621,
-0.1383500099,
0.1267731488,
-0.6833164096,
0.3935237527,
0.3089681864,
1.0660606623,
-0.1594672948,
0.188583672,
-0.6413904428,
-0.3248808682,
0.0639916807,
-1.3231797218,
-0.6922573447,
-0.8088817,
-0.713771224,
0.0196190886,
-0.2098883986,
0.9171355367,
0.5661857128,
-0.5817979574,
0.2837640345,
0.106434375,
-0.0703858882,
-0.1866150647,
-0.1731324792,
0.2716078162,
-0.3131541908,
-0.987113893,
0.1038550809,
0.5539803505,
0.3899181783,
-0.1026352197,
0.1159151122,
0.0824684724,
0.0736109167,
0.2872938514,
0.215137884,
-0.6717660427,
-0.2811240256,
0.1950684935,
-0.1626799703,
0.5216473937,
0.8565912247,
-0.5555097461,
0.824459374,
0.7796468139,
0.5707309842,
0.0877793133,
0.776486516,
0.6847717166,
-1.1680978537,
0.0436172113,
0.2897281051,
0.3757320344,
0.4500156939,
-0.7284561396,
0.0800292641,
0.0480947308,
-0.6328291297,
-0.6770121455,
0.4109229147,
-1.5808622837,
-0.2646052837,
0.7895041108,
-0.3330791295,
0.1588581502,
0.3665859401,
-0.6863493323,
0.1153821424,
-0.4978770614,
0.7901782393,
0.8114208579,
-0.1993940324,
-0.1982245594,
-0.0042181425,
0.101855278,
0.3988831043,
-0.8858162761,
-0.3920692801,
0.7411466837,
0.200185582,
0.3222248554,
0.6417385936,
0.1291456074,
0.385245204,
-0.3278491497,
0.0504051149,
-0.1419909745,
-0.2789029479,
-0.73013556,
0.3095987439,
-0.099808827,
-0.4908257425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06104v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06104v2
|
Transformers are Multi-State RNNs
| 2024-01-11T18:35:26 | 2024-06-18T09:16:14 |
Matanel Oren, Michael Hassid, Nir Yarden, Yossi Adi, Roy Schwartz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Transformers are considered conceptually different from the previous
generation of state-of-the-art NLP models - recurrent neural networks (RNNs).
In this work, we demonstrate that decoder-only transformers can in fact be
conceptualized as unbounded multi-state RNNs - an RNN variant with unlimited
hidden state size. We further show that transformers can be converted into
$\textit{bounded}$ multi-state RNNs by fixing the size of their hidden state,
effectively compressing their key-value cache. We introduce a novel,
training-free compression policy - $\textbf{T}$oken $\textbf{O}$mission
$\textbf{V}$ia $\textbf{A}$ttention (TOVA). Our experiments with four long
range tasks and several LLMs show that TOVA outperforms several baseline
compression policies. Particularly, our results are nearly on par with the full
model, using in some cases only $\frac{1}{8}$ of the original cache size, which
translates to 4.8X higher throughput. Our results shed light on the connection
between transformers and RNNs, and help mitigate one of LLMs' most painful
computational bottlenecks - the size of their key-value cache. We publicly
release our code at https://github.com/schwartz-lab-NLP/TOVA
|
[
-0.3246902227,
-0.0205494761,
0.3231033981,
0.3826256692,
-0.2548229396,
0.2165605128,
-0.4985256791,
-0.2287683487,
0.3377744853,
0.7392663956,
-0.8933607936,
-0.132576406,
-0.7603339553,
0.370526433,
-0.9279167056,
1.0340787172,
0.1521695703,
-0.445912838,
0.1998312026,
-0.0870160609,
-0.449688375,
-0.3046212792,
-0.1872301847,
-0.3082965612,
0.5351112485,
0.1706106812,
0.6965082884,
0.5631115437,
0.4849140048,
0.2743670642,
-0.1657771468,
0.062646158,
-0.5965246558,
0.3353389204,
0.1027634218,
-0.7469278574,
-0.090815343,
-0.1917112768,
0.6920817494,
0.1150868833,
-0.4251149595,
0.167190969,
-0.1682414114,
0.7175393701,
-0.6933628917,
0.2144719064,
-0.7229399085,
0.4488183856,
0.0696581155,
-0.4190298319,
-1.002194643,
-0.1139002889,
-0.1421277523,
-0.5458968282,
0.4447497129,
-0.0526393428,
1.0088412762,
0.9185031056,
-0.3669434786,
0.0823932365,
-1.1968265772,
0.9408095479,
-0.4925914109,
0.4990926385,
-0.092889376,
0.3850058615,
-0.1528235078,
-0.8807705045,
-0.673920691,
0.2758964598,
-0.1005580574,
0.3377676606,
-0.5469535589,
0.1126219779,
0.5220840573,
0.6977129579,
-0.2170597464,
0.1840915233,
-0.3377372026,
-0.1592701226,
0.2354648858,
0.0714282915,
0.0204217825,
-0.3229706585,
-0.6509167552,
-0.4322095811,
-0.6214476228,
0.0052881064,
0.0944938436,
0.3126712441,
-0.1940519959,
0.7303839326,
-0.0331457034,
0.4360933602,
0.0367973559,
0.1086715236,
0.0787034407,
-0.0951837748,
-0.3810609281,
0.0082016475,
0.8225998282,
0.0735473856,
0.2802084088,
-0.5831649303,
-0.2851078212,
0.2698121369,
0.6893236637,
-0.7904621363,
0.179476276,
0.0983801335,
-0.5409642458,
-0.3173026145,
0.0678743795,
-0.8579365015,
-0.2373923957,
0.000377932,
0.3844004869,
-0.0122791985,
-0.3188676536,
0.4118962288,
-0.3377964795,
0.348384589,
-0.0393157415,
-0.9711959958,
0.2874598205,
0.573358655,
0.9162158966,
-0.2312385142,
-0.2518719137,
-0.0771331191,
-0.0727995336,
-0.1813210845,
0.7675415874,
-0.3411571383,
-0.6310178041,
0.2014989853,
0.0222042743,
0.0680565163,
-0.3068752587,
0.3374491036,
-0.7847831845,
-0.2131066918,
0.0529357828,
-0.3741907179,
0.0031392425,
0.0911572799,
-1.0566985607,
0.9796330929,
0.3412254155,
-0.385320276,
0.384545058,
-0.5282123089,
-0.3103662729,
-0.3343533278,
-0.1856277138,
-0.4781356454,
0.4910202622,
0.1922686845,
0.3602393568,
-0.442345798,
0.1750650555,
0.0920353755,
-0.4103492498,
0.464438796,
-0.9783399105,
0.493521601,
0.0149526969,
-0.189832747,
0.2755613029,
-0.6839382052,
0.1705256701,
0.0157887135,
-0.5891038179,
0.345682174,
-0.1651802808,
-0.2825050652,
0.4331353903,
-0.0851233527,
-0.7082223296,
0.6274538636,
-0.5213191509,
0.8242561817,
0.7700362802,
-0.1312419325,
0.6618168354,
-0.358351171,
0.5900073051,
-0.1705805957,
0.3966239393,
-0.2930985689,
-0.4081544876,
-1.2262960672,
-0.2574120462,
0.2891579568,
0.4378092587,
-0.5923313498,
0.5719410181,
-0.7201150656,
-0.2245543003,
-0.7379924059,
-0.4211751819,
-0.0252119116,
0.1900703311,
0.754955411,
-0.1292025745,
-0.593411684,
-0.979285717,
-0.1830122769,
0.209397167,
-0.1756088138,
-0.0234168395,
0.6332697868,
-0.1812486947,
0.9298214316,
-0.2918838859,
-0.5726225376,
-0.3482975066,
-0.1144368276,
0.2941714227,
0.2699674666,
-0.099447675,
-0.6448743343,
-0.2208680063,
-0.4096902013,
-0.4908412993,
0.4861375391,
-0.4230181575,
0.2643907964,
0.0354737528,
0.3905597031,
-0.9501700997,
0.9416755438,
0.7811505795,
-0.0559211448,
0.2490253597,
-0.3383900821,
-0.161445424,
-1.1913889647,
-0.2408466935,
-0.4387002587,
-0.204513222,
-0.6147111058,
0.1420432925,
0.2928085029,
-0.3499313593,
-0.606821835,
0.184599489,
-0.4160501957,
-0.2424742579,
-0.281329155,
-0.4103790522,
-0.0296590216,
0.8561403155,
-0.0032774466,
0.8473675251,
0.4379808009,
-0.6558727026,
0.2287606597,
0.6394485831,
-0.396158129,
0.0001146419,
-0.5284577012,
0.1900837421,
-0.1730951965,
0.8638229966,
-0.5569704175,
0.2359345406,
-0.0428785868,
-0.4058547914,
0.5216652751,
-0.1210676804,
-0.7935798168,
-0.4262392223,
-0.0866960734,
0.5382973552,
0.7012642026,
-0.7853591442,
0.874998033,
-0.0458092019,
0.6683281064,
-1.0179668665,
-1.2013423443,
0.3041869402,
-0.0343449041,
-0.2899431288,
0.5251517892,
-0.0691395029,
0.3459989727,
0.0956872776,
-0.41528669,
-0.1359138936,
-0.1555753499,
0.466348052,
0.1263231784,
-0.1488563567,
0.2319427729,
-0.0042558429,
-0.6258956194,
-0.1015059873,
-0.4603514373,
0.7075750828,
-0.2966671288,
-0.2902324796,
-0.4530769289,
0.4471329749,
0.6838160753,
-0.3163716793,
0.8671417236,
0.3995093107,
-0.1638278812,
-0.4214984775,
-0.3035835326,
-0.3962184787,
-0.5330101252,
0.220845595,
-0.2486405969,
-1.0687819719,
0.3515146673,
-0.1970864385,
0.3140738606,
0.6684346199,
0.4043084979,
0.2389182597,
0.6316463351,
0.7503710985,
-0.0668835044,
0.1508985907,
-0.6659824848,
0.4593784511,
-0.8614350557,
-0.3537977636,
-0.5157514811,
-0.6593429446,
-0.8439041972,
-0.6524052024,
0.2663214803,
-0.0863476023,
-0.3236800432,
0.4333468676,
-0.8734246492,
0.6281995177,
0.3781416714,
0.0747484043,
0.2592033446,
0.0251761507,
0.1348463893,
-0.0053829663,
-0.9149208069,
0.0492387488,
1.2076123953,
0.1572043747,
0.783978045,
0.2662860751,
0.7320950627,
0.2149999291,
0.189005509,
-1.2147215605,
0.5886816978,
-0.3891766965,
-0.5889311433,
-0.3650316298,
-0.2724973857,
-1.2278181314,
0.2248296291,
-0.5815181136,
-0.6518797874,
0.1716615558,
-0.1190951765,
-0.3247544169,
0.9008254409,
-0.1752998233,
0.2258652598,
-0.0299656559,
0.2611721456,
-0.3247839212,
-0.7686980963,
0.0760123059,
0.1443523765,
-0.273991853,
0.0360563062,
-0.0676323697,
0.4080360234,
-0.3163531125,
0.7317760587,
0.2122616023,
0.1188115478,
0.1660431474,
0.0571197048,
0.5956032872,
-0.0440520868,
0.0687850192,
0.5507543087,
-0.3490478992,
-0.299402535,
-0.8905863166,
0.5770022273,
-0.6389329433,
-0.5582637787,
-0.57147789,
-0.8297601938,
0.0096203582,
0.3119376898,
0.590718627,
0.6085572839,
0.2310917675,
0.5203491449,
1.0747549534,
-0.4153497219,
0.6673949957,
0.4230207205,
0.0626410469,
-0.0377135985,
0.620287776,
-0.2326520234,
0.492942214,
0.9244983196,
0.2667560279,
-0.5746099353,
-0.1886801422,
-0.5277343392,
0.06614957,
-0.7619901299,
-0.4173240662,
-0.5792368054,
-0.6084582806,
-0.146689266,
-0.0226716083,
-0.8413183689,
-0.5921897888,
-0.2527534366,
-0.0946766436,
0.5007043481,
0.7688583732,
-0.1335855424,
0.2386812717,
-0.8662940264,
0.6702652574,
0.2547463179,
0.5629057288,
0.2019175589,
-0.534450233,
-0.0530790798,
-0.184721902,
-0.1597007364,
-0.7597349286,
0.260489583,
0.1928642839,
0.1633915454,
0.2755771577,
0.2198220044,
0.6392855644,
-0.8984490633,
0.8260512948,
0.4628507197,
-0.6744976044,
0.1097378731,
0.086673677,
0.5330754519,
0.3290003836,
-0.0607801154,
-0.5362209082,
-0.351480633,
-0.710739255,
-0.9105355144,
0.4920972884,
0.3921195865,
0.5247334242,
-0.0425718017,
0.3057998121,
0.0805894285,
0.3408097029,
-0.6870881915,
-0.7830845714,
-0.5257636309,
0.0497114882,
-0.0949275941,
-0.2674923241,
0.0084218914,
-0.0362547636,
0.3750187457,
0.1716751456,
0.9130729437,
0.1547461301,
-0.0985636637,
0.0680094063,
0.8432331681,
0.782810688,
0.1545494944,
-0.0111633204,
0.1563062519,
0.1691883653,
-0.2607488334,
0.251606673,
-0.0440854318,
-0.205743134,
0.0695736334,
0.0287278686,
1.0505802631,
0.4430197775,
-0.2666369975,
0.557818234,
-0.3749276102,
-0.2759766877,
-0.5672410727,
-0.0886594132,
-0.1193117127,
0.3071141839,
0.2975676656,
0.6989354491,
-0.1469804496,
-0.1355157495,
0.2362436354,
0.2361312509,
-0.5454956293,
-0.2262323946,
0.6382731795,
0.071977824,
-0.5106586814,
0.9265840054,
0.0493205264,
-0.4418047667,
0.3181523979,
0.6870775223,
0.9184494615,
-0.05229114,
0.1226708442,
0.2900730073,
0.6116749644,
-0.4937093258,
0.0687749758,
-0.1888065189,
-0.7731379867,
-0.8077551723,
-0.5200542808,
-0.0634773076,
0.3985862732,
-1.025930047,
-0.000179214,
-0.2614814341,
-0.3516730964,
-0.4322856963,
-0.4877204001,
-0.9051424861,
0.0478937477,
-0.2251058519,
1.0957164764,
-0.4342839718,
0.7104050517,
-0.0117351245,
-0.2505265176,
-0.9483165741,
-0.0647558793,
-0.1487908214,
-0.9159793258,
0.4186054766,
0.3424401879,
-0.2671442926,
0.202180773,
-0.2012828737,
-1.0170936584,
0.9216840863,
0.2960612774,
-0.5643398166,
-0.3835586309,
0.3478504419,
0.479522109,
0.0997570381,
0.0868796036,
0.5346088409,
0.49272874,
-0.1916384697,
-0.9215578437,
-0.0634990633,
-0.1017335877,
0.0202789158,
0.7724809051,
-0.6510710716,
0.691198349,
-0.3453903198,
-0.4733780622,
0.3715842962,
0.777200222,
-0.1066662371,
-0.2717437446,
0.5554522276,
0.8679059744,
0.410422653,
-0.203236118,
1.3633822203,
-0.3618299961,
0.4076335728,
0.985758245,
0.1622563303,
0.8230793476,
0.6874727607,
-0.0133283623,
0.565349102,
-0.0018620783,
-0.3290182948,
0.5185322762,
0.3484928906,
-0.2387025654,
-0.2089216262,
-0.1646448225,
-0.2742478549,
0.4660691917,
0.1706834733,
-0.2119842172,
-0.2951414287,
-0.0259140637,
-0.2207983434,
-0.0352508016,
-0.2999650538,
0.4506934583,
0.2441588789,
-0.5494590998,
0.6643798351,
-0.1247686595,
0.8974529505,
-0.8198402524,
-0.0187493861,
0.1844832599,
0.0948902816,
-0.3538191319,
-0.8186612725,
0.3033258915,
-0.0590462908,
-0.4364504218,
-0.7292859554,
0.554135263,
-0.2783178389,
-0.1594765037,
0.1322790682,
0.1967998594,
0.0580383986,
-0.0300886557,
-0.4861548841,
-0.142586112,
-0.0172045212,
-0.2609964609,
0.3270881474,
-0.0163403749,
0.2722561359,
0.9544077516,
0.5115527511,
0.3165928721,
0.3817017972,
0.2114952654,
0.7037656307,
-0.6167961359,
-0.4903346598,
-0.5931818485,
0.4941602647,
0.3597496748,
-0.3052846491,
0.4809357822,
0.3955682218,
0.842428565,
-0.1751152277,
0.600690484,
0.1904251277,
0.292201221,
-0.5720290542,
0.6339819431,
-0.5717003942,
0.1204275861,
0.360085845,
-0.8109341264,
-0.2647857666,
0.4273061454,
0.419038862,
-0.1393234283,
0.8438171148,
0.5858560801,
0.0194014516,
0.139305234,
0.3690975904,
-0.0463875085,
0.2884946764,
0.6218357682,
0.921720624,
-0.5764026642,
0.9480202794,
-0.3308638632,
0.1967947334,
0.1727415919,
-0.823998332,
-0.7109484673,
-0.5999982953,
0.174462989,
-0.5551390648,
-0.3138138354,
0.5923228264,
0.6774635315,
-0.5223031044,
-0.0493347645,
-0.293590486,
-0.0031072719,
-0.2886165082,
-0.1840453595,
0.2618585825,
-0.1503439695,
-0.4891062081,
0.7832283974,
0.3586136997,
0.0559341349,
-0.3993113339,
0.0057522478,
0.2328124195,
0.0856031105,
0.5768511295,
0.364475131,
-0.9451650977,
-0.2735241652,
0.292029947,
0.2292114943,
0.4145120978,
1.2932019234,
-0.9346995354,
0.5371088386,
0.0913487971,
0.7816991806,
0.7417542338,
-0.284825027,
0.3905634284,
-0.9731880426,
0.3600036204,
0.5060263276,
0.2269993275,
0.0091008926,
-0.2104779929,
0.1839924008,
-0.1461443156,
-0.5855440497,
-0.6893620491,
0.7770844698,
-1.0466724634,
-0.2294485122,
1.2454806566,
0.1489049941,
0.089920111,
0.1029961929,
0.3181622028,
0.6992957592,
-0.6668949723,
0.8593072891,
0.3439737856,
-0.0174823105,
-0.2075811327,
-0.5154314041,
0.5429210663,
0.385643363,
-0.4965012074,
-0.0134682637,
-0.0116647901,
-0.0104804197,
0.2977067828,
0.2945109308,
-0.0751246288,
0.0832918435,
-0.1775683761,
0.044723846,
-0.2249582857,
-0.6206454039,
-0.5538107753,
0.0279487502,
-0.2871494889,
-0.2643633485
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06102v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06102v4
|
Patchscopes: A Unifying Framework for Inspecting Hidden Representations of Language Models
| 2024-01-11T18:33:48 | 2024-06-06T22:59:58 |
Asma Ghandeharioun, Avi Caciularu, Adam Pearce, Lucas Dixon, Mor Geva
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Understanding the internal representations of large language models (LLMs)
can help explain models' behavior and verify their alignment with human values.
Given the capabilities of LLMs in generating human-understandable text, we
propose leveraging the model itself to explain its internal representations in
natural language. We introduce a framework called Patchscopes and show how it
can be used to answer a wide range of questions about an LLM's computation. We
show that many prior interpretability methods based on projecting
representations into the vocabulary space and intervening on the LLM
computation can be viewed as instances of this framework. Moreover, several of
their shortcomings such as failure in inspecting early layers or lack of
expressivity can be mitigated by Patchscopes. Beyond unifying prior inspection
techniques, Patchscopes also opens up new possibilities such as using a more
capable model to explain the representations of a smaller model, and multihop
reasoning error correction.
|
[
-0.5115762949,
-0.3926276267,
0.7780528069,
0.2839718163,
-0.0489577539,
0.3002059162,
-0.1818393618,
-0.4831293821,
0.0202924013,
0.9232430458,
-0.4666724503,
-0.2580216825,
-0.5373353958,
0.0626225546,
-0.661842525,
0.5210396051,
-0.2757026553,
-0.1479258388,
-0.2487188578,
0.1442305595,
-0.1641484797,
-0.4994057417,
-0.2951279879,
-0.6078970432,
0.1915243864,
0.2771483958,
0.5878521204,
0.5186222196,
0.5631837845,
0.4121210575,
-0.2917423844,
0.5463341475,
-0.169959709,
-0.1691510081,
-0.2660579979,
-0.7163114548,
-0.2419363856,
0.123529546,
0.8954928517,
0.9055106044,
0.1174149811,
0.002015718,
0.2502288222,
0.5223203897,
-0.6951538324,
0.2995839119,
-0.4725939333,
-0.0197471865,
-0.3866693079,
-0.3354793489,
-0.5029292107,
0.039813444,
-0.0179503616,
-0.5529197454,
0.2718833983,
-0.0498247854,
0.7465002537,
0.0420536883,
-0.7570548058,
-0.1120158583,
-0.741374433,
0.8013731837,
-0.6575097442,
0.292655021,
0.3249633312,
0.5962638259,
-0.5281702876,
-0.7835490108,
-0.5299146771,
-0.0458121859,
-0.4575059116,
0.0091138333,
-0.3836762607,
0.1824392378,
0.1910150796,
0.7602485418,
-0.3382875025,
0.0006466324,
-0.3171803057,
-0.5887473226,
0.4040810466,
0.0598543733,
0.3866084516,
-0.2960659564,
-0.3669267595,
-0.0934555009,
-0.7333706021,
-0.0545434952,
0.2058347613,
0.0453198105,
-0.0537201017,
0.4627793729,
-0.0847213045,
0.8384091258,
-0.1568344086,
0.0290972013,
0.0236212444,
-0.2092518359,
-0.4809253216,
-0.3773607612,
0.4122983217,
0.1741129756,
0.3478628695,
-0.232559815,
-0.3542369306,
0.3338540792,
0.3027414382,
-0.348582834,
-0.2074835896,
0.144171983,
-0.4162436426,
-0.5596897006,
0.0579060055,
-0.7423098087,
-0.5056245923,
-0.358156234,
0.270129472,
-0.0938986242,
-0.4221127927,
0.2498374134,
-0.0816349238,
-0.0892777741,
0.3282967508,
-0.8688651919,
0.4490793943,
0.7877098322,
0.6835983992,
0.228858605,
-0.430678606,
-0.5411883593,
0.2838978171,
-0.581317842,
1.0519634485,
-0.4758937359,
-0.1448339522,
0.0294040777,
0.2561353147,
0.0076931883,
-0.5878680944,
0.3369668424,
-0.4632934034,
0.1245762706,
0.068016775,
-0.680988133,
-0.3985544145,
0.3064282835,
-0.6639088392,
0.9588468671,
-0.0045078103,
-0.8059433699,
0.0879173726,
-0.8180084229,
0.0517519861,
-0.1572107375,
-0.1698903143,
-0.0173683632,
0.4413358569,
0.7522647381,
0.3797152042,
-0.0633477494,
0.0722735748,
-0.2515874505,
-0.4252422452,
0.5669481754,
-0.5042569637,
0.6833410859,
0.0791412964,
-0.1562375426,
0.3301058114,
-0.6004326344,
-0.0643354207,
-0.094433628,
-0.1744669229,
-0.4020046592,
0.0981725082,
-0.1408939362,
-0.1295554191,
-0.0424678847,
-0.5060483217,
0.3523232043,
-0.7820528746,
0.5505540371,
0.9795441031,
-0.1201173961,
0.6828533411,
-0.1070794091,
0.5505717993,
0.3045917749,
0.1642936319,
-0.7216048837,
-0.5307912827,
-0.8203037381,
-0.2410590351,
0.0049199965,
0.2342213988,
-0.6830731034,
-0.2549020052,
0.0344758928,
-0.2398398668,
-0.6124511957,
0.3826088607,
0.5497801304,
0.4403197467,
0.0769435167,
-0.2388468385,
-0.6486209035,
-0.9940827489,
-0.5740583539,
-0.0891763866,
-0.2542696297,
0.1100612506,
0.4771136343,
-0.5239533186,
0.8306943774,
-0.393335253,
-0.1263274699,
-0.1421547532,
0.3307157457,
0.4301576912,
0.1741568446,
0.3537692726,
-0.7005224824,
-0.0391758718,
0.066039905,
-0.7463487387,
-0.2380564511,
-0.0157323312,
-0.1751131564,
-0.0070316419,
0.6804757714,
-0.2529738247,
0.5401697755,
0.9089205861,
-0.4382537007,
0.5222153068,
-0.3613824546,
0.0927818492,
-0.7940815687,
-0.1081341207,
-0.0223264582,
-0.6980984211,
-0.6325320005,
0.5164176822,
0.3230509162,
0.0798403248,
-0.3552593887,
0.734371841,
-0.8117421269,
-0.3603395224,
-0.2927556634,
0.2568493783,
0.3740940094,
0.1067848951,
-0.1367916167,
0.7806797624,
0.4688382745,
-0.4404179752,
0.4800118208,
0.0016838546,
-0.5346754193,
0.3330735564,
-0.4804729521,
0.2149883658,
-0.2904754579,
0.1383419484,
-0.8812054396,
-0.4280251265,
0.0510283373,
-0.361338675,
0.3207094967,
-0.4752606452,
-0.631680131,
-0.4434653521,
-0.2762758136,
0.3813532889,
0.236387372,
-0.9548181295,
0.5340912938,
0.4865238667,
0.3223950267,
-0.4144987166,
-0.8196579218,
0.0057193576,
-0.1512648761,
-0.8019156456,
0.1163445637,
0.0129016349,
-0.632913053,
-0.1802863628,
-0.0290629696,
-0.3075844944,
0.2072740197,
0.3614263833,
0.3185477555,
-0.362114042,
0.283711344,
-0.1308860183,
-0.3828389049,
0.0458541438,
-0.3290089667,
0.4303806424,
-0.4861035049,
-0.6815194488,
-0.1461335421,
0.2638445795,
0.5424867272,
-0.1730499417,
0.3272365034,
0.3528269529,
-0.5210450292,
-0.0579454936,
-0.7609359026,
-0.2214571387,
-0.5337565541,
0.1468753666,
-0.2522147298,
-0.8920524716,
0.5539248586,
-0.3123740256,
-0.1411952972,
0.346398145,
0.5630542636,
-0.1444306523,
1.0458196402,
0.939673841,
-0.0246377811,
0.1996894926,
-0.0193854999,
0.0880856588,
-1.073327899,
-0.1671113819,
-0.288190335,
-0.1809445322,
-0.2670938969,
-0.8598148227,
0.3046668768,
0.5401536822,
-0.0374042504,
0.1095845103,
-0.5568437576,
0.8265304565,
0.5061123967,
-0.1305282265,
0.6670494676,
0.0225773379,
-0.3464295566,
-0.2923340797,
-0.3594932556,
-0.8088020682,
0.9027273059,
0.7331337333,
0.7903539538,
0.0653302372,
0.5690181255,
-0.0164993722,
0.6368898153,
-0.5604493618,
0.2577983737,
-0.2016094029,
-0.699991703,
-0.1121033207,
-0.3922275007,
-0.8249467015,
0.5561541915,
0.0793400928,
-1.1943507195,
0.2792105973,
0.6040591598,
0.1353778541,
0.5343434215,
-0.8343126178,
0.8270735145,
-0.2329865247,
0.0811086521,
-0.0833772421,
-0.2165298015,
0.8084513545,
0.0251595303,
0.6833226681,
0.0477273613,
0.1231498346,
0.4634079039,
-0.3756863475,
1.1143577099,
0.1112900525,
-0.0805766359,
0.0108136851,
0.3738076687,
0.3149292171,
0.2281879187,
0.0926717371,
0.1364070028,
0.2159640789,
-0.3614456654,
-0.776683569,
0.569526732,
-0.4525361061,
-0.6064993739,
-0.3619940281,
-0.6570341587,
-0.2033088505,
0.1697479337,
0.0323874801,
0.7020088434,
0.0421070196,
-0.1605942994,
0.4910033345,
-0.2351829857,
0.2805336714,
0.538570106,
-1.0505862236,
0.1620124131,
0.6806697249,
-0.3275978267,
0.3595802486,
0.4827096164,
0.3176715076,
-0.074574329,
-0.3989670277,
-0.3893527091,
0.2041025013,
-0.8138518929,
-0.1540632695,
-0.1421967447,
-0.100735344,
-0.269760251,
-0.0121256113,
-0.3652893603,
-0.3792115152,
-0.2474166453,
-0.0715256333,
0.3827281892,
1.2672355175,
-0.435102433,
0.2626650333,
-0.7423451543,
0.4191941619,
0.4120200574,
0.567414403,
-0.0885576755,
-0.3834885657,
-0.1186426207,
0.2698665559,
-0.2165200859,
-1.0379859209,
0.6241542101,
-0.0091728978,
0.5766149759,
0.5297400951,
-0.2228674442,
0.8742815852,
-0.3384189904,
0.6760168076,
0.1014719233,
-1.2896902561,
0.7237086296,
-0.2080737054,
0.3940427303,
0.0126096094,
-0.03699385,
-0.5712214708,
-0.6727997065,
-0.2685723901,
-0.6433355212,
0.5454909205,
0.1056233943,
0.0660333261,
0.0190498009,
0.3793154061,
-0.125737071,
-0.0251019243,
-0.6370264888,
-0.049004212,
-0.1372058839,
0.1245961115,
-0.2718586922,
-0.5473752618,
-0.4992753863,
-0.047700163,
0.2643025219,
-0.4004425406,
0.3862537444,
0.2685476542,
-0.3948789239,
-0.1942587495,
0.4171535671,
0.5977022052,
0.9216091633,
-0.1888616383,
0.581628859,
0.0214128755,
-0.3122843504,
-0.202331841,
-0.1378111839,
0.139145866,
0.0585152879,
0.7811916471,
0.5440954566,
0.6174165606,
-0.6372265816,
0.6343768835,
-0.0440743305,
0.1280988306,
-0.1517527401,
-0.3935559094,
0.3236142099,
0.4144036472,
0.2931835651,
-0.0248043463,
0.1575852036,
-0.8219755292,
0.1678367704,
0.4288800657,
-0.431910485,
-0.3098981082,
0.3197644651,
-0.0877166241,
-0.2718300521,
0.585934639,
0.0123038739,
-0.7307885885,
0.5626602769,
0.5166010857,
0.6266109943,
-0.1756265312,
0.3479092121,
-0.1217659414,
0.7035845518,
-0.0102076847,
0.0392678194,
0.0038449836,
-0.8886995316,
-0.7764009237,
-0.5280159116,
-0.6054692864,
0.0034560573,
-0.8440731764,
-0.1087960973,
-0.1171732917,
0.2243442982,
0.114870213,
-0.3273598254,
-0.6870304346,
0.0525254719,
0.0564964898,
1.2147461176,
-0.8325667977,
0.841160059,
0.7252777219,
-0.3785419464,
-0.8732610941,
-0.0643973276,
0.3097170889,
-1.1633050442,
0.7661244869,
0.18199265,
-0.1295798123,
-0.4751358032,
-0.5106659532,
-0.7787992954,
0.8184702396,
0.6515012383,
-0.6625888348,
-0.0805880874,
0.0536938496,
0.6312156916,
-0.3051431775,
0.4736388624,
0.4493360221,
0.554400444,
-0.1307716221,
-1.0945065022,
-0.0224061832,
-0.2042472363,
-0.0107780779,
0.3986467719,
-0.0641914234,
0.9150551558,
-0.1131690741,
-0.292108804,
0.025569167,
0.3256146908,
0.1020102575,
0.2942694724,
0.3988991976,
0.2775810361,
0.806080997,
-0.1662812382,
1.5167948008,
-0.0468477607,
0.4444732368,
1.0393077135,
0.1923932135,
0.8473172784,
0.7361805439,
-0.1950464398,
0.5238338113,
0.2905758023,
0.2185583711,
0.2753651142,
0.2698240578,
-0.1419220567,
-0.4816838503,
0.210091278,
-0.2650752664,
0.4353990853,
0.454770267,
-0.4018678963,
-0.3197765648,
0.0825485885,
-0.3497683108,
0.2572696209,
-0.4201547503,
0.6416038871,
0.3333548605,
-0.2452254593,
0.3375606537,
-0.0850015059,
0.5934086442,
-0.4127945304,
-0.2448320985,
-0.2068337053,
0.5510006547,
-0.2601487339,
-1.0261670351,
0.6628599167,
-0.1406329125,
-0.2447088808,
-0.396879226,
0.824796617,
-0.1890684217,
-0.7627455592,
0.5035207868,
0.3378841877,
0.3228958845,
-0.3273580968,
-0.2570482194,
0.1743294448,
-0.1110384166,
-0.187591821,
0.3073889911,
0.4447586834,
-0.2340120077,
0.9689715505,
0.7223604321,
0.2857326269,
0.100982286,
0.0882851109,
1.0702441931,
-0.6660887599,
-0.2903982103,
-0.6888310909,
0.6732134223,
-0.1821007431,
-0.0231105238,
0.8247349858,
0.1806277782,
0.7971837521,
0.0265586227,
0.4590944052,
0.7228830457,
0.8112824559,
-0.6382296681,
0.6386154294,
-0.5861228704,
0.6898936629,
-0.2855218947,
-0.6331554651,
-0.477312237,
0.8451523185,
-0.2504410744,
-0.3811625242,
0.538162291,
0.9196167588,
-0.3811152875,
-0.07646171,
0.4532917738,
0.5184977055,
0.321346283,
0.4808546007,
1.1235866547,
-0.1927724332,
0.5533844233,
-0.3862243295,
-0.4572116733,
0.0350482613,
-1.0745829344,
-1.1068785191,
-0.4052241445,
-0.0608148985,
-0.2676471174,
0.0119926259,
0.2633507252,
0.8007133603,
-0.8316372633,
-0.2828977704,
-0.1890487224,
0.4483751655,
-0.063935414,
-0.283582896,
0.2031075656,
-0.2099941522,
-0.6008988023,
0.7764793634,
0.6002792716,
-0.169803381,
-0.7942970991,
0.0382892489,
0.1102347821,
0.1311349273,
0.5445342064,
0.2838900387,
-1.0867079496,
-0.4080429077,
-0.1660938263,
0.1613484919,
-0.1046888754,
1.1691607237,
-1.0623534918,
0.9655957222,
0.3633445203,
0.4025502801,
0.6190843582,
-0.5460834503,
0.9632254243,
-0.7950870395,
0.3220634162,
0.0587212704,
0.7091278434,
0.415184021,
-0.2206154019,
0.4390389621,
-0.1104323044,
-0.5012438297,
-1.0915238857,
0.6918267608,
-0.8583573699,
-0.34054479,
0.781416595,
-0.3929795921,
-0.1664932072,
-0.2771018147,
-0.2854830623,
-0.0504352003,
0.0127480216,
0.7374331951,
0.6460767388,
-0.0035141993,
-0.6307560205,
-0.5601481795,
0.2797331214,
0.1951638162,
-0.8744260669,
0.0187260993,
0.2944312692,
0.3523933291,
0.3727053404,
0.5074736476,
-0.4002269804,
0.1489643455,
-0.1064335033,
-0.2449687868,
-0.2035743147,
0.0059635006,
-0.5435284376,
-0.1255281866,
0.0617457293,
-0.078933306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06088v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06088v1
|
Autocompletion of Chief Complaints in the Electronic Health Records using Large Language Models
| 2024-01-11T18:06:30 | 2024-01-11T18:06:30 |
K M Sajjadul Islam, Ayesha Siddika Nipu, Praveen Madiraju, Priya Deshpande
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The Chief Complaint (CC) is a crucial component of a patient's medical record
as it describes the main reason or concern for seeking medical care. It
provides critical information for healthcare providers to make informed
decisions about patient care. However, documenting CCs can be time-consuming
for healthcare providers, especially in busy emergency departments. To address
this issue, an autocompletion tool that suggests accurate and well-formatted
phrases or sentences for clinical notes can be a valuable resource for triage
nurses. In this study, we utilized text generation techniques to develop
machine learning models using CC data. In our proposed work, we train a Long
Short-Term Memory (LSTM) model and fine-tune three different variants of
Biomedical Generative Pretrained Transformers (BioGPT), namely
microsoft/biogpt, microsoft/BioGPT-Large, and microsoft/BioGPT-Large-PubMedQA.
Additionally, we tune a prompt by incorporating exemplar CC sentences,
utilizing the OpenAI API of GPT-4. We evaluate the models' performance based on
the perplexity score, modified BERTScore, and cosine similarity score. The
results show that BioGPT-Large exhibits superior performance compared to the
other models. It consistently achieves a remarkably low perplexity score of
1.65 when generating CC, whereas the baseline LSTM model achieves the best
perplexity score of 170. Further, we evaluate and assess the proposed models'
performance and the outcome of GPT-4.0. Our study demonstrates that utilizing
LLMs such as BioGPT, leads to the development of an effective autocompletion
tool for generating CC documentation in healthcare settings.
|
[
-0.1172869951,
-0.6098149419,
0.8662345409,
0.0389795192,
-0.3733409941,
0.069038704,
-0.2068692297,
-0.5986210704,
0.3364776075,
0.6951826811,
-0.4505832195,
-0.9301639795,
-0.5529472232,
0.3734999895,
-0.417956531,
1.1370408535,
-0.1631382257,
-0.0642478094,
-0.0521556847,
0.013299155,
-0.5901582241,
-0.8043438792,
-0.6860107183,
-0.1527807862,
0.675044477,
0.3941589594,
0.4755353034,
0.5552049875,
0.7544036508,
0.3889938891,
0.1746254265,
0.3771152794,
-0.4019194245,
0.1317642629,
0.0785906538,
-0.3248343766,
-0.6207917929,
-0.271504581,
0.2129102051,
0.395742923,
-0.0349701233,
0.0233511943,
0.0701587051,
0.5492681861,
-0.3449364007,
0.325702101,
-0.7068752646,
0.3106819391,
0.1112219691,
-0.3645536304,
-0.3189851642,
-0.455388546,
0.4433770776,
-0.5642891526,
0.5136163831,
0.0381470285,
0.9847146273,
0.4079731107,
-0.2848396897,
-0.7268407345,
-0.5327579379,
0.5544099808,
-0.6869822741,
0.1726680845,
0.4714303911,
0.2903642058,
0.0088141533,
-0.7084443569,
-0.4448461831,
-0.5763352513,
-0.3918863535,
0.3891384602,
-0.240492925,
0.4142352045,
0.3444024324,
0.5408412218,
-0.7848365903,
0.1564495862,
-0.2761823237,
-0.2274918705,
0.6915534735,
0.518414259,
0.2388191372,
-0.5746637583,
-0.0853994414,
0.0243802555,
-0.5035908222,
-0.2528123856,
-0.0916746408,
0.2407634407,
-0.1290434599,
0.5847216845,
-0.2270379364,
0.6591803432,
0.2755739689,
-0.0468353033,
0.296723783,
-0.2306407541,
-0.3553533256,
0.0783431008,
1.0994621515,
0.2734883428,
0.0223190002,
-0.1618366241,
-0.1633224934,
-0.00614641,
0.4662560523,
-0.6006456614,
-0.6296644211,
0.393861264,
-0.5857056379,
-0.2675210536,
-0.0707711428,
-0.7458506227,
-0.3841025233,
-0.6975767612,
0.1336648166,
-0.4721059799,
0.103781946,
-0.0982026532,
0.3766936958,
-0.2128485888,
0.3630773127,
-0.5666609406,
0.0081447642,
0.3135733902,
0.8690615296,
-0.3506423235,
0.0895518139,
-0.5326612592,
0.0917030945,
-0.1594986618,
0.7940166593,
-0.1220651343,
-0.6386891603,
0.1938751638,
0.2172238678,
-0.239538908,
-0.8038104773,
0.514226079,
-0.0792708769,
0.1612442583,
-0.2989298701,
-0.3582450151,
0.0693375096,
0.3509322703,
-0.6896374226,
0.5695356131,
0.1854958236,
-0.5810067654,
0.2125935107,
-0.4940147996,
-0.3379070759,
0.4135561883,
-0.464366734,
-0.8921051621,
-0.0369794294,
0.2108314782,
0.6010379791,
-0.4131018221,
0.3277455568,
0.038910877,
-0.1908984929,
0.0402107202,
-0.076307565,
0.4787115753,
0.2961506248,
-0.2824566364,
0.1469218433,
-0.7521695495,
0.1484608203,
-0.0308933258,
-0.5787896514,
-0.1097339168,
0.062174879,
-0.0769353956,
0.2835460007,
0.1817177981,
-0.3376375437,
0.1321198493,
-0.2250056714,
0.5094237924,
0.3990928829,
0.2207012773,
-0.1494174302,
-0.6279669404,
0.5135300159,
0.2871055603,
0.2261046916,
-0.3900705278,
-0.3442479372,
-0.8424540162,
-0.3429664671,
0.2034006566,
0.6102765799,
-0.6696081161,
0.769952774,
-0.3229873478,
-0.3927929401,
-0.4316671491,
0.0116311247,
0.521740973,
0.6135803461,
0.74794662,
-0.3262882829,
-0.6429677606,
-0.8284973502,
-0.0317455307,
-0.3466191888,
-0.038285587,
0.6096093059,
0.2960063815,
-0.5354365706,
0.9096391201,
-0.5797390342,
-0.492146492,
-0.3315684497,
0.5026602745,
0.0339331143,
0.3049688339,
0.3459587693,
-0.6549995542,
-0.4462021589,
0.0042403731,
-0.6415405869,
-0.3561366498,
-0.2195127308,
0.1650285721,
0.3302932084,
0.4388168156,
-0.6556150913,
0.6098875999,
0.2955120504,
-0.0118091507,
0.6806167364,
-0.3991284966,
0.2169393003,
-1.1729004383,
0.2055370063,
0.0828680694,
-0.1412994415,
-0.3896637857,
-0.1192085445,
0.0603815429,
-0.1019816622,
-0.0938405991,
0.0283799488,
-0.5089172721,
0.3120720088,
-0.0582718588,
-0.0246729739,
-0.155271858,
0.3490927517,
0.1913594753,
0.2066913098,
0.0475979112,
-0.6170491576,
0.4670077562,
0.3528023362,
-0.1453251839,
0.3242925704,
-0.7390163541,
0.0581435077,
-0.1651556194,
0.2583408058,
-0.9313025475,
-0.3149311841,
0.0236932673,
-0.4501788616,
0.394559741,
-0.0545057878,
-0.5390922427,
-0.8024237156,
0.1641810685,
0.2757902145,
0.3805833459,
-0.3118576705,
0.5013607144,
0.1727113724,
-0.3664180636,
-0.2236639559,
-0.6954532862,
0.2012718618,
-0.0703856722,
-0.2640301883,
0.3570895791,
-0.1620896906,
0.2191695571,
-0.2057978213,
0.1415555626,
-0.0672588274,
-0.3290123343,
0.4085853994,
0.4548410475,
-0.3192582726,
0.412683636,
-0.1188822016,
-0.0344519913,
0.1444516331,
-0.0758292899,
0.6523956656,
-0.1504055262,
-0.4681081474,
-0.3837852478,
0.6997748613,
0.6602101922,
-0.1423787624,
0.2008902878,
0.2908875346,
-0.4348318279,
-0.0012517014,
-0.8649847507,
-0.0258118641,
-0.4089965522,
0.5040031075,
-0.0371111743,
-0.7800204754,
0.6141354442,
-0.0684278235,
-0.0077668172,
0.563460052,
0.6058454514,
-0.0690251216,
0.9629287124,
0.2786153853,
-0.329110533,
-0.045633845,
-0.3054783344,
0.453471452,
-0.5378522277,
-0.2081476301,
-0.6404843926,
0.0511459373,
-0.7924757004,
-0.2889595926,
0.7071154118,
-0.1573376805,
-0.2386821806,
0.3586452305,
-0.702521801,
0.149852246,
0.1768228859,
0.4486467242,
0.3877916932,
-0.0178384595,
-0.3656275272,
-0.0216076653,
-0.7680434585,
-0.2719733715,
0.7230607867,
0.4087435305,
0.6741704941,
-0.0480491482,
0.8948351741,
0.1055718437,
0.1983834654,
-0.7342371345,
0.3547616005,
-0.552664876,
-0.0839266255,
-0.03543346,
-0.5581409335,
-0.9274498224,
-0.2715962827,
-0.3563085198,
-0.3973879814,
0.128966257,
0.51834023,
-0.7361844182,
0.0713050291,
-0.5109077692,
0.764844358,
-0.3476718366,
-0.204982087,
-0.154140532,
-0.6632101536,
0.2995001972,
-0.132179305,
-0.0281280242,
0.3352405131,
0.3542913795,
0.422157228,
-0.759013772,
0.9755243063,
0.2225271165,
-0.1379595697,
0.381405741,
-0.1988290101,
0.5801829696,
-0.0764861703,
0.3139720559,
0.1422620267,
-0.0768213719,
-0.0341386423,
-0.2519724965,
0.6371101737,
-0.7498615384,
-0.4583696127,
-0.3503711522,
-0.2605534196,
-0.2202047855,
0.072822243,
0.7592470646,
0.45700863,
-0.0026954324,
-0.0153382402,
0.842520237,
-0.7790826559,
0.311050117,
0.7289043665,
0.1810842007,
-0.2363051921,
0.819619,
0.3029885888,
0.1730921119,
0.3828913569,
0.170146063,
-0.210950017,
-0.424759984,
-0.4257196188,
0.2957826555,
-0.6355158687,
-0.5477989912,
-1.1423614025,
-0.6807143092,
-0.4218808115,
-0.116610162,
-0.0792711526,
0.0141109228,
-0.4868154824,
0.0692241788,
0.3299939632,
0.7395149469,
0.1556916237,
0.2757664919,
-1.0532370806,
0.4416602552,
0.3346032202,
0.2941330969,
0.0725359768,
-0.3839119375,
-0.3556248248,
-0.0961814448,
-0.5894014239,
-0.9562672377,
0.5840647817,
-0.0879595354,
0.4062626958,
0.3250418603,
0.096185036,
0.8657063842,
-0.5919376612,
0.9357805252,
0.4894869924,
-0.6960758567,
0.6076607108,
-0.5504002571,
0.3801938593,
0.6229478121,
0.4684360027,
-0.5192589164,
-0.5544237494,
-0.607606411,
-1.06204319,
0.3015204966,
-0.2407499701,
-0.1769947857,
-0.44919613,
0.4072604775,
-0.1082089096,
0.0675818697,
-0.5271322131,
-0.0422945246,
-0.1851096302,
-0.522583425,
0.0072283056,
-0.3513610661,
0.1918835938,
-0.0389353894,
0.5173825622,
-0.1030168235,
0.4438654482,
0.560880661,
-0.0250990912,
-0.3641070426,
0.3223375678,
0.529915154,
0.4016577303,
0.0073948298,
-0.1408375055,
0.1232338026,
-0.709522903,
-0.2659337521,
0.2212315351,
-0.0135879312,
0.4233894348,
0.2171907276,
0.6044251323,
0.0764740929,
-0.5705688596,
0.5442762375,
0.0249240957,
-0.3186931312,
-0.7028289437,
0.0041596722,
-0.038090881,
-0.1158009022,
0.1570479125,
-0.224985227,
0.3370384276,
-0.472324729,
0.1808865219,
0.3053551316,
-0.3930579126,
0.1102552935,
0.4639152586,
0.0649462789,
0.0052251671,
0.7586112022,
-0.0010506519,
-0.6008670926,
0.6911231279,
0.414156884,
0.8607620001,
-0.3855063617,
0.1147475392,
0.686999917,
0.1675427258,
-0.2391190678,
0.1829798073,
0.1702842861,
-0.1668943167,
-0.6143498421,
-0.5875152946,
-0.342208147,
0.54726547,
-0.7131501436,
0.543694973,
-0.468092829,
-0.256570071,
-0.0937710553,
0.0609038956,
-0.8265013099,
0.4246154726,
0.1226351187,
0.6918311119,
-0.5106689334,
0.5991703868,
0.4293260276,
-0.5687845349,
-1.1380361319,
-0.0219002906,
-0.0606717952,
-0.6935625076,
0.5681036711,
0.0822762325,
0.2049177885,
-0.3174373209,
-0.3602259457,
-0.5899361968,
1.1432347298,
-0.0912296921,
-1.1673038006,
-0.4342461824,
0.5725229383,
0.6169434786,
-0.5109215379,
0.4902088344,
0.5146237612,
0.2462499738,
0.0081909765,
-1.2406891584,
0.228904143,
-0.2606909275,
-0.0785094425,
0.1339262724,
-0.6998859048,
0.9179852009,
-0.3587017059,
-0.0803333893,
0.2980610728,
0.2906032503,
0.2835210562,
0.3525755703,
0.3724535704,
0.7200608253,
0.7680745721,
-0.1268867403,
1.0042827129,
-0.1950437874,
0.2835957706,
1.278555274,
-0.1616592258,
0.6373652816,
0.0076370221,
0.0649439096,
0.7160835862,
0.4966766238,
-0.1991252005,
0.17202124,
0.656945765,
-0.2984224856,
-0.1498274505,
0.1300635338,
-0.4157039523,
0.2712788582,
0.5549567342,
-0.9926191568,
-0.1293571293,
-0.0976350456,
-0.0603190847,
-0.0151515929,
-0.5197810531,
1.1015356779,
0.1635697782,
-0.8924642205,
0.7733383179,
-0.1405538619,
0.4358962774,
-0.5634372234,
-0.2537441552,
-0.1062796935,
0.0205832329,
-0.4247640371,
-0.1751723588,
0.1720643938,
0.2223445922,
-0.4174632132,
0.1522764117,
0.5264905095,
-0.6707054377,
-0.3899432123,
0.0973196328,
0.2331802845,
0.3092539907,
0.0002581086,
-0.7947489023,
-0.0879013389,
0.0051288675,
0.1376256943,
0.1838338971,
0.4383418858,
-0.0600242577,
0.363525629,
0.5044336319,
0.3564783633,
-0.046989575,
0.210734278,
0.8762381077,
-0.6325802207,
-0.6984314322,
-0.6818870902,
0.4537733197,
-0.1193640009,
-0.2902531922,
0.2577570379,
0.5417845249,
0.5286217928,
-0.2259622365,
1.2150782347,
0.1176362485,
1.0344161987,
-0.5812103748,
0.8724170923,
-0.2968398333,
0.2492484599,
-0.3829862773,
-0.5115349889,
-0.2987017632,
0.5334216356,
-0.4301703274,
0.0938897505,
0.9387857914,
0.5713503361,
0.0452362075,
0.0503413863,
0.2906675935,
0.5501612425,
0.2805308402,
1.0775711536,
0.5885031223,
-0.316103369,
0.5499538779,
-0.0681664124,
-0.0848308355,
-0.4235799909,
-0.9265366197,
-0.8341845274,
-0.4740885794,
-0.5084169507,
-0.4829438031,
0.1018954068,
1.0814746618,
0.6364194155,
-0.9295397997,
0.1626980454,
-0.186620459,
-0.4526392221,
0.2454361618,
-0.2119595855,
0.6104934812,
-0.5685304999,
-0.2608616948,
-0.0491734743,
0.0555328391,
0.2143574059,
-0.0011405613,
0.0703072846,
0.2529680133,
-0.1990687996,
0.5689426064,
0.3939005136,
-0.7476122975,
-0.2034361213,
-0.0004627637,
-0.3738873601,
0.0279185046,
1.0811579227,
-0.7617862821,
0.3700293899,
0.1302125454,
0.6306126714,
0.2076005489,
-0.0251204781,
0.4226635396,
-0.4459001422,
-0.4186486304,
0.436259836,
0.4244371355,
0.3741908669,
-0.855009675,
0.1834758818,
0.1213136315,
-0.8219385743,
-0.4041776359,
0.0095791379,
-1.1248476505,
-0.1191717237,
1.1051640511,
-0.2725468874,
0.1230072081,
-0.3498424292,
-0.2546091974,
0.4885442555,
-0.2706233859,
1.1601274014,
0.5330796242,
-0.2733092904,
-0.1770046949,
-0.7434853911,
0.6907144189,
0.4336837232,
-0.8154819012,
0.1592091322,
0.606770575,
0.2281722426,
0.3572136462,
0.6843954921,
-0.4488904476,
0.52125144,
-0.5440759659,
0.0198744982,
0.1069429293,
-0.1528551877,
-0.2377121001,
0.0774958581,
-0.2051924616,
0.055330988
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06081v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06081v2
|
Improving Large Language Models via Fine-grained Reinforcement Learning with Minimum Editing Constraint
| 2024-01-11T17:58:41 | 2024-06-17T05:52:06 |
Zhipeng Chen, Kun Zhou, Wayne Xin Zhao, Junchen Wan, Fuzheng Zhang, Di Zhang, Ji-Rong Wen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Reinforcement learning (RL) has been widely used in training large language
models (LLMs) for preventing unexpected outputs, eg reducing harmfulness and
errors. However, existing RL methods mostly adopt the instance-level reward,
which is unable to provide fine-grained supervision for complex reasoning
tasks, and can not focus on the few key tokens that lead to the incorrectness.
To address it, we propose a new RL method named RLMEC that incorporates a
generative model as the reward model, which is trained by the erroneous
solution rewriting task under the minimum editing constraint, and can produce
token-level rewards for RL training. Based on the generative reward model, we
design the token-level RL objective for training and an imitation-based
regularization for stabilizing RL process. And the both objectives focus on the
learning of the key tokens for the erroneous solution, reducing the effect of
other unimportant tokens. The experiment results on mathematical tasks and
question-answering tasks have demonstrated the effectiveness of our approach.
Our code and data are available at https://github.com/RUCAIBox/RLMEC.
|
[
-0.1528095454,
-1.1161601543,
0.5014458895,
-0.0063597765,
-0.1577544063,
0.06821464,
-0.5523451567,
-0.1663045883,
0.0387766138,
0.4771854579,
-0.6193822622,
-0.5116611123,
-0.6618391275,
0.0728844404,
-0.0296117608,
1.1349440813,
-0.2073392123,
-0.2002287358,
-0.1302617937,
-0.0936217234,
-0.3785102069,
-0.443957895,
-1.1439737082,
-0.376463443,
0.8494642377,
0.4926177561,
0.3537657559,
0.7229455709,
0.0066492739,
0.3087504506,
-0.4189652503,
0.6844865084,
-0.6285777688,
0.0456436723,
-0.3824416399,
-0.5252379179,
-0.266376406,
-0.1204736307,
0.3958563209,
0.3715735078,
-0.5044728518,
0.0119606657,
0.0153324073,
0.562744081,
-0.610370636,
0.4698139429,
-0.6770324707,
0.3129379153,
0.0606334321,
-0.1309369951,
-0.7837613821,
-0.2432388812,
-0.3559614718,
-0.7834052444,
-0.0019384919,
0.2466987073,
0.7168947458,
0.3377275467,
0.1094988137,
-0.1825893968,
-0.5830237865,
0.8715527058,
-0.9685742259,
0.1275285482,
0.2604024112,
0.1218171343,
-0.3092161715,
-0.4586964548,
-0.5427290797,
-0.3651157916,
-0.1105807126,
0.012405673,
0.1279449016,
0.2378106117,
0.4006595314,
0.0358109549,
-0.3654624522,
0.3838881552,
-0.1875691265,
-0.2641199231,
0.4831424654,
0.3992860019,
0.1558789164,
-0.0530381277,
-0.1386820227,
-0.2846542299,
-0.6940800548,
0.3706038892,
0.1605455726,
0.6524317265,
0.0318938345,
0.5211327672,
-0.2372703254,
0.6721510291,
0.103019312,
-0.1682374328,
0.049972035,
-0.0055524488,
-0.1801642627,
0.0849291906,
0.5693271756,
-0.0154415537,
0.2005041987,
-0.1298813522,
-0.6388585567,
-0.0906557441,
0.2696415782,
-0.6218156815,
-0.0173192918,
0.2185518146,
-0.287712127,
-0.4328548312,
-0.0449140854,
-0.5034130812,
-0.269369632,
-0.4045255184,
0.312880069,
-0.4641522169,
0.0862697139,
0.1770973206,
0.1475536823,
0.0051449388,
0.5310522914,
-1.1423559189,
0.1977258772,
1.029201746,
0.6027079821,
-0.0408650227,
-0.6632378101,
-1.1549241543,
0.0651494563,
-0.4291915298,
0.7391254306,
-0.5321288109,
-0.3198365271,
0.1201874018,
0.0247505866,
-0.015590624,
-0.6570568681,
0.6430123448,
-0.5609001517,
0.0085120639,
0.0899033174,
-0.6596765518,
0.0967699662,
0.4391177297,
-0.520839572,
0.9578962326,
-0.0565162934,
-0.4486435056,
0.2073303908,
-0.4915569723,
-0.4653044641,
-0.1154358685,
-0.2046529055,
-0.6101357341,
0.1903123707,
0.4287122488,
0.3084867001,
0.231682539,
0.3722112477,
-0.0115803825,
-0.3574794233,
0.1487355083,
-0.4905896783,
0.2428784221,
0.1061355993,
-0.1954304278,
0.5704575181,
-0.5681246519,
0.190739885,
0.1789990962,
-0.7285815477,
-0.3159365058,
0.002166352,
-0.1679388732,
0.2611767948,
0.2448842376,
-0.5801389217,
0.5091438293,
-0.550863266,
0.4546095729,
1.1101784706,
0.0468459465,
0.2531776428,
-0.2691536844,
0.4372919202,
0.0592403337,
0.2967045605,
0.090788871,
-0.1317044795,
-0.8802440166,
-0.1194095835,
0.520643115,
0.5475922227,
-0.8903428912,
0.3407126963,
-0.0773995817,
-0.2113686651,
-0.5976452827,
0.2230187207,
0.8133401275,
0.1890981048,
0.5213406682,
-0.0247805957,
-0.4020633399,
-0.8002500534,
-0.319116801,
-0.0354370698,
0.0843125358,
0.366330713,
0.5581896901,
-0.1217843145,
0.6976967454,
-0.5316537023,
-0.3845350742,
-0.4685718119,
0.4845871925,
0.0140428804,
0.6449414492,
-0.0675662607,
-0.4419425726,
-0.382106781,
0.1461029947,
-0.443962425,
-0.0053278692,
-0.4100475609,
0.0219256859,
0.3881636262,
0.7178983688,
-0.4620047808,
0.2104098797,
0.3127958477,
-0.3258392811,
0.5727313757,
-0.5898483396,
0.0247511342,
-0.7165173888,
-0.1052033603,
-0.1931117475,
-0.5141562223,
-0.4842026234,
0.1070953608,
0.1119297966,
-0.033488594,
-0.567319572,
0.6804834008,
0.0189803448,
0.0879864544,
-0.3200432658,
0.2425165474,
-0.0672964528,
1.0784926414,
0.1395654231,
0.8195359111,
0.1068535,
-0.4606525004,
0.3327078521,
0.2949265838,
-0.4793926477,
0.1787187606,
-0.5739276409,
0.130003497,
-0.3017539084,
0.2305555195,
-0.2708074152,
-0.1083136126,
0.17029652,
-0.4418717325,
0.3502093852,
-0.0326034389,
-0.3248342276,
-0.0908471793,
-0.232689172,
0.3615856171,
0.3241808116,
-0.6711910963,
0.540751338,
-0.0221635886,
-0.2675147951,
-0.6655086279,
-0.6696391702,
-0.0469575152,
-0.0318689533,
-0.1256486475,
0.2656502426,
0.0836331993,
0.000770616,
0.0831733793,
-0.0688603297,
0.0486781783,
0.093918778,
-0.0425060317,
0.1408772767,
0.1044023782,
0.1148416176,
0.0932980254,
-0.2992573082,
-0.0858383775,
-0.1301208586,
0.518573463,
-0.0882699788,
-0.3996818662,
-0.5655584335,
0.3134402931,
0.4583865702,
-0.3267105818,
0.8032378554,
0.2136084884,
-0.1804236025,
-0.708086729,
-0.2039972395,
-0.1998318434,
-0.4098795652,
0.6042940021,
-0.3668883443,
-1.0870103836,
0.4052890837,
-0.0314843059,
0.3023117781,
0.1634834111,
0.4631286561,
0.1848054379,
1.0938919783,
0.3733461797,
-0.2460265309,
0.7023604512,
-0.200801,
0.1744557023,
-0.9327247739,
-0.2943805158,
-0.3499590755,
-0.1094575152,
-0.1205087677,
-0.580322504,
0.1742116958,
0.3300265372,
-0.3317845464,
0.1349226534,
-0.3295140564,
0.6203628182,
0.5830417871,
0.2909192443,
0.3164883554,
-0.106851384,
-0.2987444699,
0.1179527119,
-0.8780301213,
-0.3468108177,
0.6518337131,
0.3715105653,
1.0733076334,
0.0053218398,
0.81251055,
0.3513511419,
0.3057787716,
-0.7158241868,
0.3667844534,
-0.1078936905,
-0.1526147574,
-0.7298821807,
-0.5867698789,
-0.7482813597,
0.3642842472,
-0.1982210577,
-0.5900933743,
-0.000728803,
0.3643964827,
-0.5543048382,
0.388733834,
-0.4911191463,
1.165976882,
-0.285074085,
-0.4411507547,
-0.3384752274,
-0.3544227481,
0.2897675335,
0.2767405212,
0.3777016401,
0.2028601468,
0.0978224128,
0.5630271435,
-0.7448030114,
0.9513839483,
-0.2262425721,
-0.1752765328,
0.2613705397,
0.2173816413,
1.2851959467,
0.1343155503,
0.1286646873,
-0.4576351941,
-0.1759430915,
-0.5124676228,
-0.9562340379,
0.6327819824,
-0.6663491726,
-0.5992913842,
-0.2345307767,
-0.5421572328,
-0.3210945129,
-0.042383831,
-0.0584277138,
0.4928153157,
-0.1345610172,
-0.0248053949,
0.8322244287,
-0.2882510126,
0.2521063685,
0.2975059748,
-0.3015727997,
-0.4081024528,
1.1011388302,
-0.3466986716,
0.5743275881,
0.449101001,
0.3473239839,
-0.1398711503,
-0.5994896889,
-0.5306323171,
0.0497332588,
-0.6605801582,
-0.2383072823,
-0.4335624278,
-0.231965676,
-0.1571896523,
-0.3411637247,
-0.5794441104,
-0.1473565847,
-0.2146047354,
-0.1373686343,
0.2723106444,
0.528817296,
-0.0471362583,
0.010132703,
-0.7364251614,
0.1511342376,
0.5994653702,
0.4354013205,
0.3040782809,
-0.6563504934,
-0.4598095119,
0.1006941423,
-0.0350278206,
-0.1883543283,
0.3474042118,
0.0853515863,
0.4640269578,
0.2263827026,
-0.0110559985,
0.6807430387,
-0.6635151505,
0.5724508762,
0.1344704628,
-1.0076893568,
0.4679722786,
-0.227409184,
0.1860735863,
0.7085025907,
-0.3178894222,
-0.9885932803,
-0.6068377495,
-0.6421143413,
-0.6562855244,
0.8131384254,
-0.019098416,
0.0676425472,
-0.1638344526,
0.4526679814,
-0.0361701883,
0.1326963603,
-1.0718457699,
-0.0429441854,
-0.1175827906,
-0.254164964,
0.0956395492,
-0.412383616,
-0.0553267524,
-0.1268645674,
1.0219429731,
-0.2450957447,
-0.023113599,
0.2981718183,
-0.1702572107,
-0.1646365374,
0.5512111783,
0.9323865175,
0.1547432691,
-0.0021286809,
0.1909351796,
0.3227636516,
-0.0063579301,
0.1715406477,
-0.2986896932,
-0.2130097747,
-0.288854152,
0.4900933206,
1.1775493622,
0.4569412768,
-1.0829107761,
0.4041231573,
0.0113869309,
-0.3325691223,
-0.0525255874,
0.163919434,
0.0405489281,
0.3655881882,
-0.0678362474,
-0.1620095074,
-0.3351837993,
-0.5484794378,
0.1439143419,
0.3775012791,
-0.3751547933,
0.0540908687,
0.5020576119,
0.1123450994,
-0.4409990311,
0.6124135852,
-0.537832737,
-0.7567533255,
0.6278584599,
0.6341090798,
0.603030622,
-0.0395377837,
0.3508707583,
0.420956701,
0.2301998138,
-0.2976620495,
0.02260576,
0.119766362,
-0.6778185964,
-0.7539909482,
-0.623554945,
-0.4406454563,
0.1267580092,
-0.4790863991,
0.1357480735,
-0.6409757137,
0.4548984766,
-0.1577854007,
-0.2839203775,
-0.1716385484,
0.0246345345,
-0.0059490129,
0.7981595397,
-0.7694302797,
0.9460502863,
0.5578944087,
-0.4861095846,
-1.0617977381,
-0.2148093581,
-0.328564167,
-0.7108531594,
0.7989987731,
-0.178696841,
-0.0731821135,
0.0411088727,
-0.4619101882,
-0.6158905625,
0.7700086236,
-0.0775157809,
-0.7217572927,
-0.1101186275,
0.0769309551,
0.5560358167,
-0.4273841679,
-0.1570960432,
0.4078158736,
0.5221977234,
0.025962688,
-0.6690987349,
-0.0589627102,
0.1140569523,
0.1524674743,
0.41613096,
-0.5938641429,
0.8571823835,
-0.2071248293,
-0.1591478586,
0.2578258216,
0.6244946718,
0.3785488605,
0.0419045985,
0.5742372274,
0.783706069,
0.7214418054,
0.0430869311,
1.0434247255,
0.0681551918,
0.8279518485,
1.3551684618,
-0.0226894543,
0.9763145447,
0.6055155993,
-0.1531030387,
0.5341057777,
0.515402317,
0.0707706958,
0.6220128536,
0.534832418,
-0.3182719648,
-0.5358464122,
-0.1340032369,
0.1754702628,
0.1210058481,
0.267228961,
-0.1847130358,
-0.4269938171,
0.3348974288,
0.0416819379,
0.5066610575,
-0.5850582719,
0.9031786919,
-0.0791430473,
-0.7299416065,
0.7540093064,
0.2715547085,
0.6629394889,
-0.5097736716,
-0.1433199793,
-0.3669330776,
0.2030778378,
-0.1143175811,
-0.4919753969,
0.2520101666,
0.111924991,
-0.2031162679,
-0.1486293972,
0.3341092169,
-0.6608146429,
-0.4229466617,
0.0160996728,
0.2509306073,
-0.0842735246,
0.1451836973,
-0.7406154275,
0.0643545687,
0.1256566644,
-0.2774241269,
0.4040335417,
0.4605924487,
-0.1578796953,
0.6938465238,
0.5017077327,
0.195178926,
-0.0295488592,
0.1433339864,
0.7584772706,
-0.8219186068,
-0.5195364952,
-0.7624945641,
0.3977914155,
-0.0488166586,
-0.2018450052,
0.3487758338,
0.5554584265,
0.9549273849,
-0.2275538594,
0.6726152897,
0.0551409237,
0.4336830378,
-0.9487819672,
0.2270236313,
-0.5374141932,
0.213182956,
0.026844658,
-0.6541543603,
-0.3480863273,
0.7698509097,
-0.2705721855,
-0.2085682601,
0.8283080459,
0.9031000137,
0.0126938038,
-0.2842389345,
0.4732104838,
0.2415507585,
0.3585235178,
0.9898637533,
0.9136772752,
-0.1376517415,
0.4317108989,
-0.2776978314,
-0.032413099,
-0.3514285982,
-0.6922172308,
-0.8602159023,
-0.2015988529,
-0.2786045372,
-0.3867189288,
0.2108167857,
1.290002346,
0.3842012882,
-0.8972872496,
0.0633787885,
-0.5454593301,
0.4484203756,
-0.5495614409,
-0.1961760968,
0.4341387153,
-0.7614073753,
-0.8677443266,
0.4341409802,
0.3276682794,
-0.0785762444,
-0.2865005136,
-0.3443340659,
-0.175529629,
0.1507194191,
0.6196036339,
0.6562954783,
-0.9872549176,
-0.7688930631,
-0.3399493992,
-0.2857104838,
-0.0080906488,
1.0202181339,
-0.6446941495,
0.255861938,
0.2760193646,
0.934158504,
0.4037715197,
0.1231617481,
0.3088302314,
-0.8905236125,
0.2498626113,
0.163649261,
0.3071107268,
0.06093527,
-0.3082269132,
0.1870522052,
-0.0429093204,
-0.6033730507,
-0.7412870526,
0.4216212332,
-0.7948078513,
-0.6050998569,
1.1384869814,
-0.2729203701,
-0.4267720878,
0.0604299605,
-0.4981960356,
0.1410292983,
-0.5296673775,
1.0039128065,
0.6312924027,
-0.0870236233,
-0.1539586931,
-0.4915474951,
0.6765981317,
0.6922097802,
-0.9272845387,
0.6533623338,
0.5984376669,
0.1550079584,
-0.0782146975,
0.227437824,
-0.0072260257,
0.3334411383,
-0.1497943699,
0.2570363581,
-0.5428466797,
-0.3776919544,
-0.4773270786,
0.061890658,
0.6404236555,
0.0243363902
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06072v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06072v2
|
Chain of History: Learning and Forecasting with LLMs for Temporal Knowledge Graph Completion
| 2024-01-11T17:42:47 | 2024-02-14T15:49:21 |
Ruilin Luo, Tianle Gu, Haoling Li, Junzhe Li, Zicheng Lin, Jiayi Li, Yujiu Yang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Temporal Knowledge Graph Completion (TKGC) is a complex task involving the
prediction of missing event links at future timestamps by leveraging
established temporal structural knowledge. This paper aims to provide a
comprehensive perspective on harnessing the advantages of Large Language Models
(LLMs) for reasoning in temporal knowledge graphs, presenting an easily
transferable pipeline. In terms of graph modality, we underscore the LLMs'
prowess in discerning the structural information of pivotal nodes within the
historical chain. As for the generation mode of the LLMs utilized for
inference, we conduct an exhaustive exploration into the variances induced by a
range of inherent factors in LLMs, with particular attention to the challenges
in comprehending reverse logic. We adopt a parameter-efficient fine-tuning
strategy to harmonize the LLMs with the task requirements, facilitating the
learning of the key knowledge highlighted earlier. Comprehensive experiments
are undertaken on several widely recognized datasets, revealing that our
framework exceeds or parallels existing methods across numerous popular
metrics. Additionally, we execute a substantial range of ablation experiments
and draw comparisons with several advanced commercial LLMs, to investigate the
crucial factors influencing LLMs' performance in structured temporal knowledge
inference tasks.
|
[
-0.0519696027,
-0.8328099251,
0.9075040221,
-0.4323289096,
-0.2896764576,
0.5985566378,
-0.0584604852,
-0.4311836958,
-0.1349022239,
0.5277436972,
-0.8976345062,
-0.76499331,
-0.4060778022,
-0.1864924133,
-0.3254916966,
0.9554381967,
-0.162496224,
-0.1187296361,
0.0759208947,
0.3180833757,
-0.130551815,
-0.4343347549,
-0.6983168125,
-0.9276550412,
0.6961374879,
0.2908085287,
0.5291400552,
0.9254947305,
-0.1699398607,
0.1506340504,
-0.198980093,
0.5004713535,
-0.7602481842,
0.2784375846,
-0.3692430854,
-0.3664441705,
-0.5953377485,
-0.2421443313,
0.6973975301,
1.0880131721,
0.0167809036,
0.2727490962,
0.0344861187,
0.6845400333,
-0.4849902093,
0.267826438,
-0.7416937947,
0.230654493,
-0.070860818,
-0.4554871917,
-0.328961581,
-0.4149404168,
0.1803458482,
-0.6040999889,
0.0263224561,
0.2710327804,
0.5371008515,
-0.0097848307,
-0.8380816579,
-0.0730562285,
-0.8934534192,
0.890781939,
-0.6116053462,
0.7303164005,
0.3592971563,
0.3139727712,
-0.4391122162,
-1.1374297142,
-0.3232667148,
-0.0115574105,
0.1456897259,
0.0231698211,
0.0578657016,
0.0641273409,
0.3235388398,
0.3339594901,
-0.4957372248,
0.2387566566,
-0.3374014795,
-0.0836350918,
0.3716795146,
0.5214169025,
0.0194594637,
-0.1299892962,
-0.2097393572,
0.1331585795,
-0.8912094831,
-0.1926852912,
0.4025925994,
0.269443363,
-0.0657097399,
0.5508692265,
-0.3102092743,
0.8370036483,
-0.1274019778,
-0.3665237725,
-0.0762018338,
-0.3242300749,
-0.4261187017,
-0.1001231149,
0.5823901296,
0.2858335674,
0.4905337393,
-0.6094756126,
0.176452741,
-0.2193860412,
0.1740001887,
-0.5495306253,
-0.1584009081,
-0.0677780285,
-0.3815201521,
-0.2957219183,
-0.2904463708,
-0.7374477386,
-0.2392876893,
-0.4368411005,
0.0667302459,
-0.287561059,
-0.0731087774,
-0.1400972754,
-0.319711417,
0.0650057122,
0.4960331917,
-0.6345824599,
0.1038001329,
0.7362909913,
0.8301751018,
-0.0540549643,
-0.2843210399,
-0.5516081452,
0.5829026103,
-0.5307196379,
0.3569392562,
-0.4421811104,
-0.4220152497,
-0.048871275,
0.0652571768,
0.0914773941,
-0.1784708649,
0.2040645033,
-1.0066049099,
-0.0651848018,
-0.2365153283,
-0.7446268201,
-0.3882119358,
0.459408164,
-0.4697405398,
0.7693812251,
0.1717635542,
-0.558321178,
0.4622592032,
0.0806230903,
-0.527723074,
0.0209508669,
-0.1345052719,
-0.2743012607,
-0.171492964,
0.1912077963,
0.450671792,
-0.2764753103,
0.4093159437,
-0.7268741131,
-0.0509259552,
-0.0593668707,
-0.3113048673,
0.6810193062,
0.3018752635,
-0.1859010011,
-0.0217079464,
-0.7214235067,
-0.0634601489,
-0.0120151751,
-0.2463199049,
-0.075617075,
0.4737384021,
-0.4701472521,
0.1253299713,
0.1923866272,
-0.1902306378,
0.6354178786,
-0.423927933,
0.6900077462,
0.9301401973,
0.3377062082,
0.3903697133,
-0.2020073831,
0.5272203684,
-0.0742668733,
0.1364281327,
-0.0684127212,
-0.2887965739,
-0.4586484432,
0.2513974905,
0.0323358104,
0.5055637956,
-0.875259161,
0.1301036477,
-0.4379904568,
-0.4892044663,
0.3053860068,
0.3000491858,
0.1122345328,
0.9310548306,
0.1205478087,
0.1222303882,
-0.9229316115,
-0.5425083041,
-0.0750715435,
-0.6815169454,
-0.0518316999,
0.4126881957,
0.3785273731,
-0.1363370717,
0.7784808874,
-0.6213371754,
0.0820936784,
-0.2579174042,
0.0644562244,
0.4881102443,
0.0894100666,
0.1500471681,
-0.4125717878,
-0.0343819112,
0.2758523822,
-0.7961309552,
0.1049787849,
0.019957006,
-0.140298456,
0.4269213974,
0.8874704242,
-0.0796049312,
0.2798666358,
0.5391916633,
-0.3851672113,
0.6067917943,
0.0499993116,
0.1693035513,
-1.0313037634,
0.137514323,
-0.2414583862,
-0.5165082216,
-0.5134691,
-0.2538862228,
-0.1176309437,
0.0611192845,
-0.3649809957,
0.6763985753,
-0.2642670274,
-0.0487318859,
0.0011221849,
0.1258977056,
-0.1897695065,
0.5821603537,
-0.0694313198,
0.3377681375,
0.1827923059,
-0.7031814456,
0.2776692212,
-0.1325097531,
-0.3588226438,
-0.0011428145,
-0.3029172719,
0.2036000192,
0.0825795755,
0.1828707159,
-0.9938156009,
-0.0208415221,
0.1860732585,
-0.3958975077,
0.4673395753,
-0.5805743337,
-0.5296192169,
-0.5918703675,
0.0482461117,
0.3263823688,
0.7117212415,
-0.5873169303,
0.9838539958,
0.1192329824,
0.0580831356,
-0.8549280167,
-0.5306822658,
-0.0586454868,
-0.271671623,
-0.5190599561,
0.1082754657,
0.1234056652,
-0.2547440231,
-0.0721335411,
-0.4344973266,
0.1063433513,
0.289750278,
0.2950853705,
0.2925970554,
-0.0606252998,
0.3211685121,
0.1681116223,
0.0569232516,
0.0199998915,
-0.9748834372,
0.6355890036,
0.0608033985,
-0.3320558965,
-0.082269907,
-0.1969512105,
0.536524415,
0.3654882908,
0.7232171893,
0.2950586379,
-0.3292047083,
-0.2361231297,
-0.7234576344,
-0.0851769224,
-0.4039273262,
0.2376704216,
-0.1266213953,
-1.0326700211,
0.7946808338,
-0.295443207,
0.0303853583,
0.5848303437,
0.5234864354,
-0.1461565793,
0.8945839405,
0.2594818473,
-0.3798708618,
0.6195728183,
-0.3150099218,
0.1080530286,
-0.5849416256,
-0.4385269582,
-0.3188875616,
-0.1190528944,
-0.6034044623,
-0.1092877313,
0.3327072263,
0.5756479502,
-0.8141503334,
-0.1225557253,
0.1522514075,
0.306676954,
0.3266001344,
0.3836642802,
0.7700867057,
0.1505872011,
-0.0914973393,
0.3029097915,
-0.7728976011,
-0.4866442084,
1.1878361702,
0.2888751626,
1.0388110876,
-0.1571332514,
0.4767780006,
0.2725687921,
-0.0106911808,
-0.7216700912,
0.4970347583,
-0.2899597287,
-0.3052122295,
-0.2975960076,
-0.5930283666,
-0.9167367816,
-0.3563656509,
-0.083457388,
-0.9047791958,
-0.0948640481,
0.3560978472,
-0.1753649563,
0.8526015282,
-0.3315135539,
0.6782287955,
-0.077611804,
-0.3357020915,
-0.2915489972,
-0.7367459536,
0.2450581193,
0.1443139166,
0.1754028946,
0.0102046579,
-0.0531418435,
0.6607185006,
-0.3754724562,
1.0569148064,
0.128079012,
0.0463115908,
0.2566309273,
0.3574581146,
0.7515457273,
-0.0456367657,
-0.0139731755,
0.2868407071,
-0.0356895551,
-0.1444299668,
-0.6173260212,
0.7373558879,
-0.7831583023,
-0.6983647346,
0.0623091199,
-0.6699849963,
-0.1870001554,
0.3211391866,
0.0228576493,
0.6001544595,
-0.1128164306,
-0.090438135,
0.5529044271,
-0.078426525,
0.4820507169,
0.3377838135,
-0.4783627391,
-0.3925848603,
0.5700817108,
0.2756741643,
0.4757341743,
0.6148365736,
0.3139744103,
-0.3136312664,
-0.7057119608,
-0.3568582535,
0.3431665301,
-0.9174596667,
-0.2341386229,
-0.8692929745,
-0.2990665734,
-0.5190699697,
-0.2186053693,
-0.1172635481,
-0.5956527591,
-0.5665979385,
-0.3189287782,
0.458363533,
0.8984968662,
0.0882168934,
0.267619282,
-0.7000356913,
0.0611039661,
0.2526831329,
0.4331335425,
0.4536207914,
-0.3163711429,
-0.2532633841,
-0.2367207706,
-0.4474768937,
-0.8722800612,
0.3061348498,
-0.0619410016,
0.6447857022,
0.4108650088,
-0.0542911291,
0.827916801,
-0.5617595315,
0.9804401398,
-0.0096906489,
-0.8944717646,
0.6602855325,
-0.5279652476,
0.1958409399,
0.0497012697,
0.576408565,
-0.6280979514,
-0.4838241041,
-0.7269770503,
-1.0069715977,
0.5118350983,
-0.2237410098,
-0.5432911515,
-0.1610381156,
0.6357985735,
0.122299917,
0.1859289706,
-0.56324476,
-0.3561375439,
-0.0042505958,
0.0139466589,
-0.2411469817,
-0.2532768548,
-0.0502418391,
-0.0838005617,
0.7665979266,
-0.0860214978,
-0.1828749478,
0.0987519175,
-0.1842522025,
-0.3206149638,
0.3415386677,
0.3170794547,
1.2895857096,
-0.2506759763,
0.1231934652,
0.538995564,
-0.1874524653,
-0.1047923341,
-0.0671610013,
-0.0397200957,
-0.295245409,
0.7798458338,
0.8802509308,
0.0460106991,
-0.4309023321,
-0.0054294523,
0.2928548157,
-0.1882677227,
-0.557035625,
-0.0357115641,
0.040081162,
0.7294183373,
0.6646792293,
-0.3828573823,
-0.0579235554,
-0.629765451,
0.0032937913,
0.432695061,
-0.2954173088,
-0.2383140028,
0.5679177046,
-0.1670673341,
-0.0512589179,
0.9666649103,
-0.0054892246,
-0.6836573482,
0.5954656005,
0.4149972796,
0.6279928684,
-0.0984617323,
-0.1059415266,
0.457501471,
0.2743733823,
-0.1463285834,
0.2139635831,
-0.0178696699,
-0.536842227,
-0.822620213,
-0.6284043789,
-0.2894947529,
0.0830902234,
-0.4866631925,
0.252509594,
-0.4021472931,
-0.1069879532,
-0.3705951869,
0.2074129879,
-0.7973164916,
-0.0091894027,
0.1718362719,
0.9627898335,
-0.9819502234,
0.8121917844,
0.2978644073,
-0.1566290706,
-0.8545091152,
-0.2776936889,
0.1342297494,
-0.9172712564,
1.1031370163,
-0.4533805847,
-0.0649395809,
0.1103686094,
-0.3567986786,
-0.8291493058,
1.5000821352,
0.2395380735,
-0.8261336684,
-0.5402675271,
-0.1945484728,
0.4343778491,
-0.2451649755,
0.138346985,
0.6679608822,
0.313575387,
0.4781600833,
-0.8956423998,
0.1100857258,
0.3855541945,
-0.1148269102,
0.6409009695,
-0.1041934267,
0.7599805593,
-0.2585689723,
-0.4379934967,
0.1171502769,
0.7094902992,
0.3835000992,
0.542189002,
0.388753593,
0.5230206847,
0.8222447038,
-0.1937028617,
1.2414642572,
-0.1301825941,
0.3054997921,
1.1620492935,
0.0438619703,
0.5023822784,
0.4809941351,
-0.3693290949,
0.769141674,
0.7946900129,
0.1326028705,
0.316273272,
0.1010039523,
-0.0355252214,
-0.5144539475,
-0.136027813,
-0.4632835984,
0.0110957585,
0.4721767008,
-0.5442515016,
-0.3721636534,
-0.2069066167,
0.1524477452,
-0.267734468,
-0.9088966846,
0.8273707628,
0.2081599236,
-0.6002804637,
0.272847563,
-0.4988972545,
0.140133515,
-0.8755244017,
-0.0318727903,
-0.1536040306,
0.1243895143,
-0.2019864917,
-0.8451064229,
0.2842444181,
-0.4485184848,
-0.4017425478,
-0.1532717943,
0.6125314832,
-0.4662517905,
-0.461866349,
0.486359477,
0.6505487561,
-0.0246277079,
0.299295634,
-0.2025031447,
-0.0047118636,
-0.0286866538,
-0.2648352683,
0.0786120668,
0.4772423506,
-0.2583800554,
0.8804191947,
0.3488654494,
0.3655901253,
-0.0465411842,
0.2664145231,
0.840153873,
-0.8717480302,
-0.4712847769,
-1.2643740177,
0.2458178997,
0.1877744943,
0.2233627439,
0.6940568089,
0.4575125575,
1.0198297501,
0.1100399792,
0.671018064,
0.2903516591,
0.4466338456,
-0.8934776187,
0.448456198,
-0.5776361227,
0.3059921861,
-0.2791032195,
-0.6310382485,
-0.1146034673,
-0.0400855169,
-0.4857382774,
0.1340084672,
0.7156570554,
0.4356020987,
0.1527255625,
0.157149747,
0.2004043013,
0.4023100138,
0.476003319,
0.7463404536,
1.0494070053,
-0.1311626434,
0.7763405442,
-0.1451708078,
-0.0136539862,
0.0519722179,
-1.2800792456,
-1.0859116316,
-0.6309332848,
-0.1633763909,
-0.5968543291,
0.4207851887,
0.9436008334,
0.5678490996,
-0.5687104464,
-0.4194334745,
-0.0315919481,
0.5272046328,
-0.2058781236,
-0.186723426,
0.4552184641,
-0.2700529099,
-0.4357402623,
0.3834762871,
0.1881618202,
0.1493417919,
-0.1489223689,
-0.0436686389,
-0.1226194873,
-0.4497928917,
0.7173262835,
0.3578957319,
-0.7695464492,
-0.4370512366,
-0.1410335898,
0.3896489739,
-0.1393775046,
1.1157633066,
-0.8947325349,
0.4225800037,
0.7928702831,
0.4478160739,
1.0210074186,
-0.1967204213,
0.7844733,
-0.8103006482,
-0.2125476003,
0.1307419091,
0.5122262836,
0.0597082712,
-0.404435128,
0.7306696773,
0.3471781015,
-0.6420858502,
-0.7692790627,
0.4244953394,
-0.9746326208,
-0.5570319891,
1.087851882,
0.0334214531,
-0.2758533061,
-0.3478296697,
0.374220252,
0.8033204079,
-0.2523895502,
0.5201021433,
0.7488458157,
-0.0864776224,
-0.1968766749,
-0.4943859875,
0.1959727705,
-0.1659994274,
-0.4139584899,
0.0829951018,
0.5961862206,
0.4057651758,
-0.1294325739,
0.5172168016,
-0.1348046064,
-0.0240276139,
-0.306115061,
-0.3092874289,
-0.4482294023,
-0.4079636335,
-0.0938689038,
0.2360940129,
0.1540574431,
0.4020836949
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06071v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06071v5
|
GroundingGPT:Language Enhanced Multi-modal Grounding Model
| 2024-01-11T17:41:57 | 2024-03-05T14:36:12 |
Zhaowei Li, Qi Xu, Dong Zhang, Hang Song, Yiqing Cai, Qi Qi, Ran Zhou, Junting Pan, Zefeng Li, Van Tu Vu, Zhida Huang, Tao Wang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Multi-modal large language models have demonstrated impressive performance
across various tasks in different modalities. However, existing multi-modal
models primarily emphasize capturing global information within each modality
while neglecting the importance of perceiving local information across
modalities. Consequently, these models lack the ability to effectively
understand the fine-grained details of input data, limiting their performance
in tasks that require a more nuanced understanding. To address this limitation,
there is a compelling need to develop models that enable fine-grained
understanding across multiple modalities, thereby enhancing their applicability
to a wide range of tasks. In this paper, we propose GroundingGPT, a language
enhanced multi-modal grounding model. Beyond capturing global information like
other multi-modal models, our proposed model excels at tasks demanding a
detailed understanding of local information within the input. It demonstrates
precise identification and localization of specific regions in images or
moments in videos. To achieve this objective, we design a diversified dataset
construction pipeline, resulting in a multi-modal, multi-granularity dataset
for model training. The code, dataset, and demo of our model can be found at
https: //github.com/lzw-lzw/GroundingGPT.
|
[
-0.4661554694,
-1.0890079737,
0.4318088591,
0.2513023317,
-0.3524482548,
-0.2368962914,
-0.3024438024,
-0.1576058418,
-0.234734118,
0.1435782015,
-0.4366367161,
-0.5059973598,
-0.7704173326,
-0.5167230368,
-0.2135976851,
0.9711550474,
0.0224149749,
0.1184136495,
-0.0140826646,
-0.0933548734,
-0.8082860112,
-0.4001141489,
-0.3734244704,
-0.4937270284,
0.078334257,
0.2476768345,
0.9416940808,
0.5843548775,
0.3498126864,
0.2333925664,
-0.0497476384,
0.0440041795,
-0.3062267601,
-0.1665235609,
-0.0328066684,
-0.1143874079,
-0.4071470201,
-0.0669849813,
0.6781886816,
0.7391435504,
0.0091004269,
0.0067380904,
-0.2196713984,
0.2950562537,
-0.5148137212,
0.4177950621,
-0.6105121374,
0.0899483114,
0.1373816133,
-0.20213148,
-0.0513692871,
0.0920364708,
0.0234798864,
-0.4499121904,
0.3528391123,
-0.3298879266,
0.9002249837,
0.3511634469,
-0.6092916131,
-0.0824376941,
-0.5498762727,
0.490591675,
-0.5009759665,
0.7959951162,
0.557921052,
0.3548340797,
0.3384138048,
-0.3941191137,
-0.356908977,
-0.4818912148,
0.1035319343,
0.1752349287,
0.293299228,
0.1640420407,
0.238765806,
0.635156095,
-0.3916638792,
-0.2994013131,
-0.0409949645,
-0.1418214887,
-0.0831100568,
-0.0913895369,
0.4535783529,
-0.3759534955,
-0.4544576406,
0.1618490219,
-0.3130873144,
0.2888244987,
0.1178881675,
0.4985704124,
-0.3930705786,
0.5888092518,
-0.4665970504,
0.8409901857,
0.2711067796,
-0.4342864752,
0.1813492775,
-0.3556415737,
-0.501283288,
-0.2176882625,
0.4838654697,
0.4065197706,
-0.1707428545,
-0.317201823,
-0.3680301905,
0.1340903044,
0.034445703,
-0.8735134006,
-0.2611199319,
0.0836739317,
-0.4472191334,
-0.3729434013,
0.1720408052,
-0.4130526483,
-0.3887077272,
-0.6399568319,
0.535734117,
-0.7130983472,
-0.5403546691,
0.3180556595,
-0.0816072896,
0.2308398336,
0.3841633201,
-0.8486804366,
0.0594710484,
0.5918896198,
0.987377286,
0.3083369434,
-0.5031307936,
-0.7046111822,
0.3100562692,
0.039386604,
0.7392711043,
-0.8567751646,
-0.0133182816,
-0.1981041878,
0.1848511696,
-0.1549400091,
-0.0240865834,
0.682636261,
-0.6114495397,
0.1764278412,
-0.3050255179,
-0.1281140596,
-0.4522026479,
0.7223575115,
-0.604791224,
1.0145741701,
-0.0623577572,
-0.9060108066,
0.4344665706,
-0.5406914353,
-0.4535097182,
-0.1708737314,
-0.3483869135,
-0.2433413416,
0.2833726406,
0.4885413647,
0.6804084778,
-0.3945058584,
0.8598815203,
-0.1413957328,
-0.2441496253,
-0.2837724388,
-0.817536056,
0.3792531192,
0.1192728058,
-0.3472010195,
0.1251083612,
-0.8012161255,
0.0329261944,
-0.1142058894,
-0.5968231559,
-0.2074695826,
0.0774839967,
0.4853610396,
0.6056615114,
0.0537948273,
-0.2464175224,
0.1735596061,
0.0031211604,
0.3907287419,
0.4915009737,
-0.1160584539,
0.5626193881,
-0.3745731413,
0.4271722138,
-0.039277032,
-0.1301175058,
-0.5849435329,
-0.3344220221,
-0.3316166103,
-0.4974910319,
0.28308025,
0.655264914,
-0.6048210263,
0.3406739235,
-0.6830283403,
-0.3458361924,
-0.1400513053,
-0.0797068626,
0.1754990518,
0.5429215431,
0.3010569513,
-0.2608415186,
-0.4389773011,
-0.6886940598,
-0.0328147188,
0.1318396032,
-0.0854497179,
0.5676944852,
0.3254496157,
-0.2967805862,
1.1450241804,
-0.2604577243,
-0.1380615532,
-0.2179712057,
0.2937719226,
0.0332257561,
0.5826335549,
0.3511633873,
-1.1726998091,
-0.3198768497,
0.3883794248,
-0.9094644785,
-0.2201074213,
-0.4412428737,
0.1244683564,
-0.5256209373,
0.3716382086,
-0.7627365589,
0.0931488276,
0.8217143416,
-0.3707227409,
0.4700875878,
-0.0992212296,
0.5576067567,
-1.1694172621,
0.1884712279,
0.020273041,
-0.4352335632,
-0.6276404858,
0.29361099,
0.1950955242,
-0.6935787201,
-0.3914447129,
0.2232486755,
-0.5931591988,
-0.1089159474,
-0.2924698293,
-0.0338766128,
0.0762171373,
0.4047698379,
0.3498061895,
0.9987851381,
1.1054821014,
-0.5106730461,
0.3098759055,
0.1171462238,
-0.0927649438,
0.5606212616,
-0.5872689486,
-0.0112862717,
-0.3876846433,
0.2006714344,
-0.7604345679,
-0.5829230547,
-0.0034457431,
-0.3789538145,
0.0850857124,
-0.8247743845,
-0.4019640088,
0.1297136247,
-0.0918499604,
0.6660360098,
0.2271628976,
-0.505223453,
0.8616505861,
0.4315198064,
-0.064991653,
-0.4067550898,
-0.4054791629,
0.306016475,
-0.4379693866,
-0.9193917513,
0.3117012382,
-0.0162692256,
0.0063815555,
-0.3267422318,
-0.1893908232,
-0.4487636983,
-0.0723860636,
0.375094533,
-0.2860646844,
-0.2892947793,
0.346331656,
-0.1830450296,
-0.3155848384,
-0.1201160252,
-0.3980850279,
0.8197281361,
-0.3757322729,
-0.6337642074,
-0.3861553669,
0.5682033896,
0.830071032,
-0.5820614696,
0.5103596449,
1.0010405779,
-0.6068515778,
0.2730969787,
-0.5693800449,
0.0194102228,
-0.4606933594,
0.5229347348,
-0.7232835889,
-0.6054391861,
0.6071560383,
-0.4368853271,
-0.3353663385,
0.0670483559,
0.5318734646,
0.2959250808,
1.0524740219,
0.7723820806,
-0.2958197594,
0.7818368673,
-0.1815201938,
0.1656422764,
-0.7005730867,
-0.1122324094,
-0.0342646837,
0.1524600238,
-0.0565808713,
-0.8238272071,
0.3354004323,
0.5237772465,
-0.0790599361,
0.0420376845,
-0.1826923937,
0.804454267,
0.3772616386,
0.4240160286,
0.2090033293,
0.1476139575,
-0.077725552,
-0.1268733144,
-0.5516433716,
-0.5470241904,
0.7139138579,
0.6113240719,
0.9050061107,
0.0652044341,
0.0096135717,
0.176479131,
-0.1763128787,
-0.7941630483,
0.239740327,
0.0197927654,
-0.3659508824,
-0.0648171902,
-0.2568880618,
-0.3875015974,
0.4562907815,
-0.0109632155,
-0.4186096787,
-0.10889671,
-0.0178937968,
-0.2893879414,
0.4610695541,
-0.6263437271,
1.0013184547,
-0.3127377927,
-0.4358962178,
-0.005344444,
-0.7438272834,
0.3724426627,
0.088155739,
0.4320567548,
-0.0650238991,
0.2239335775,
0.249063611,
-0.0262610652,
1.1033965349,
-0.4289104939,
-0.2927906215,
0.1306755394,
0.0743572265,
0.5845690966,
0.6682602167,
0.0930987075,
0.1871748716,
-0.4329590797,
-0.3286648691,
-0.3433556855,
0.6721792817,
-0.6137186885,
-0.2199204564,
-0.0706878453,
-0.8238697648,
-0.1141381413,
0.4071400762,
0.1330587715,
0.8873153925,
-0.1019411758,
0.3629007041,
0.7726470828,
-0.0769288838,
0.3235044479,
0.1667831689,
0.0724578276,
-0.5066646934,
0.9017329812,
-0.1755449474,
0.224374488,
0.354727149,
0.0359858721,
-0.1171715707,
-0.539678216,
-0.6852665544,
-0.160529688,
-0.95283705,
-0.1966361254,
-0.8428489566,
0.1034200266,
-0.4270334542,
-0.2774693966,
-0.4746821225,
-0.1405972838,
-0.1215695515,
-0.2227125466,
0.1063348502,
0.5187404156,
-0.1970184147,
0.6350032091,
-0.7654445171,
0.8093159199,
0.5034977198,
0.5986850262,
-0.2896466553,
-0.4506237209,
-0.290558666,
0.1842266172,
-0.1596627682,
-0.8408331871,
0.2427416146,
0.3073703051,
0.528967917,
0.3648369312,
-0.4232705832,
0.9608581066,
-0.6027985811,
0.8272442818,
0.1073859558,
-1.1216547489,
0.724423945,
-0.9266809225,
0.4878244698,
0.4427810013,
0.0558712967,
-0.8282665014,
0.0648990422,
-0.3665260077,
-0.9825273156,
0.5446746349,
0.1353946477,
0.2815005481,
0.0305455346,
0.2258166224,
0.1602041572,
0.2878531516,
-1.2256320715,
0.1150190532,
-0.4283017814,
-0.0368659496,
0.1096280813,
-0.1114334762,
-0.2632559538,
-0.1676438749,
0.3782939613,
-0.5357728004,
0.3727886081,
0.0725223273,
-0.7158216834,
-0.0072361436,
0.2878973186,
0.7002310157,
0.5242362618,
-0.1367233098,
0.3566255569,
0.2074514031,
-0.4116795659,
0.1566536427,
0.2191538513,
-0.1336355358,
-0.0561364256,
0.3141267002,
0.9668672085,
0.3440912068,
-0.5231174827,
0.6990845203,
0.0581028797,
0.1496035308,
-0.1596336216,
-0.3465318382,
-0.1455939859,
0.3121132553,
0.2672773302,
0.3995049,
0.10400787,
-0.4170832932,
0.4819058776,
0.4468789697,
-0.3953159451,
-0.5917198062,
0.6571296453,
0.0322489664,
-0.1261072755,
0.2358680367,
-0.1138692796,
-0.7176058888,
0.4479584098,
0.7575606704,
0.741048336,
-0.0003761537,
0.2210800201,
0.2493958175,
0.358097136,
-0.1843732148,
0.1728833467,
-0.1902170628,
-0.6879554987,
-0.5051349401,
-0.4795398414,
-0.074147217,
0.2860736251,
-0.4572155476,
0.4600720108,
-0.3635150492,
0.0212102719,
-0.5071380734,
-0.3094113767,
-0.7696892023,
0.5732448697,
0.4210582078,
0.6847195625,
-1.2910112143,
0.7544788122,
0.987653017,
-0.5388059616,
-0.670840621,
0.1781019121,
-0.25686571,
-0.6344209909,
0.5907607079,
0.5371938944,
-0.1661248654,
0.0694890618,
-0.298553884,
-0.9817665815,
1.156244874,
0.4956588447,
0.0679797009,
-0.1832360029,
0.2009709924,
0.1390757859,
-0.4936267436,
0.3978829086,
0.2770313621,
0.4929190576,
-0.0579714552,
-1.0996536016,
-0.0923109576,
-0.2510329485,
-0.0429426692,
0.0351643339,
-0.6225987673,
1.1642301083,
-0.0013314267,
-0.108456023,
-0.4868649244,
0.3243536651,
0.1296492219,
0.1541373432,
0.5366210938,
0.8080928922,
0.6005648971,
-0.0692843497,
0.8905290961,
-0.4943599105,
0.6481693387,
1.0197008848,
0.050050132,
0.3821109235,
0.2822417617,
0.3037243187,
0.1006315276,
0.6158473492,
0.1799760163,
0.8741853833,
-0.2136864811,
-0.5063364506,
-0.6577190757,
-0.1625407487,
-0.615160048,
0.5991818905,
0.3031329513,
-0.2560176849,
-0.7425980568,
0.3793373406,
-0.2479966283,
-0.1894234717,
-0.3400991559,
0.6493033171,
-0.4037833214,
-0.1783781499,
0.5719183087,
0.3181580901,
0.6750386953,
-0.6086338162,
-0.0756572261,
-0.0438289829,
-0.0621143095,
-0.2144742459,
-0.4813582897,
0.2021877617,
-0.066103749,
-0.5306198001,
-0.3449801207,
0.9053393006,
-0.5418676734,
-0.3678944707,
0.0682966784,
0.6600388288,
-0.0674601644,
-0.5124819875,
-0.7686123848,
0.2237951905,
-0.1791110784,
-0.2521884143,
0.1388676465,
0.836533308,
-0.2193215936,
0.7247411609,
0.7960891128,
-0.1765641123,
0.1888837069,
0.3446637094,
1.080858469,
-0.671507597,
-0.7795268893,
-0.81318295,
0.8604742289,
0.0733763129,
-0.1073342189,
0.6103535891,
0.6413357258,
0.6130737662,
-0.2689443529,
1.0540462732,
-0.3923966587,
-0.007285703,
-0.7850645185,
0.4570610225,
-0.3665869534,
0.1407491416,
-0.3025711179,
-0.7844837904,
-0.3933849931,
0.9988188744,
-0.2205982506,
0.120837532,
0.5925023556,
0.6071052551,
-0.817355454,
-0.1496459842,
0.4403628707,
0.0044826013,
0.5509521961,
0.3937496245,
0.8278515339,
-0.69620502,
0.2664386034,
-0.2640307844,
-0.3212094307,
0.1199075282,
-1.1406457424,
-0.9817183614,
-0.3847136497,
-0.1195204481,
0.0438317358,
-0.1351712793,
0.9677610397,
1.1374335289,
-0.6297187805,
0.0182738025,
-0.3778261244,
-0.2328961343,
-0.0502971746,
-0.1972467303,
0.1859056652,
-0.3422157466,
-0.6701363921,
0.7214499712,
0.1863944978,
0.0990285203,
-0.0612812229,
0.0543215275,
-0.2180526108,
-0.3167245388,
0.7530973554,
-0.0795325413,
-0.7525863647,
-0.5789468884,
-0.062831752,
0.0687008798,
0.3223365247,
1.0563061237,
-0.9275176525,
0.3635703027,
0.304828614,
0.8027570248,
0.217085585,
0.4148175716,
0.6195057631,
-1.202921629,
0.5947958231,
0.1145999506,
0.4305959046,
0.5601828098,
-0.4708070755,
0.424713552,
0.2997745872,
-0.4118457735,
-0.658814311,
0.3381887376,
-1.002961874,
-0.0078997137,
1.2707908154,
-0.0256219376,
0.3195741773,
-0.1196511462,
-0.6804948449,
0.3026637733,
-0.3078874648,
0.6977011561,
0.7545502186,
0.3393244445,
-0.4178706706,
-1.0199644566,
0.1915118545,
0.3226075768,
-0.7645323277,
0.3553901613,
0.8009824753,
0.4777750671,
0.0439182036,
0.661747992,
0.130197987,
0.2381017506,
-0.0140985334,
-0.0142759942,
-0.2468498349,
-0.5944339037,
-0.6140979528,
0.6574053764,
-0.0478795767,
-0.0723023713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06066v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06066v1
|
DeepSeekMoE: Towards Ultimate Expert Specialization in Mixture-of-Experts Language Models
| 2024-01-11T17:31:42 | 2024-01-11T17:31:42 |
Damai Dai, Chengqi Deng, Chenggang Zhao, R. X. Xu, Huazuo Gao, Deli Chen, Jiashi Li, Wangding Zeng, Xingkai Yu, Y. Wu, Zhenda Xie, Y. K. Li, Panpan Huang, Fuli Luo, Chong Ruan, Zhifang Sui, Wenfeng Liang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the era of large language models, Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) is a promising
architecture for managing computational costs when scaling up model parameters.
However, conventional MoE architectures like GShard, which activate the top-$K$
out of $N$ experts, face challenges in ensuring expert specialization, i.e.
each expert acquires non-overlapping and focused knowledge. In response, we
propose the DeepSeekMoE architecture towards ultimate expert specialization. It
involves two principal strategies: (1) finely segmenting the experts into $mN$
ones and activating $mK$ from them, allowing for a more flexible combination of
activated experts; (2) isolating $K_s$ experts as shared ones, aiming at
capturing common knowledge and mitigating redundancy in routed experts.
Starting from a modest scale with 2B parameters, we demonstrate that
DeepSeekMoE 2B achieves comparable performance with GShard 2.9B, which has 1.5
times the expert parameters and computation. In addition, DeepSeekMoE 2B nearly
approaches the performance of its dense counterpart with the same number of
total parameters, which set the upper bound of MoE models. Subsequently, we
scale up DeepSeekMoE to 16B parameters and show that it achieves comparable
performance with LLaMA2 7B, with only about 40% of computations. Further, our
preliminary efforts to scale up DeepSeekMoE to 145B parameters consistently
validate its substantial advantages over the GShard architecture, and show its
performance comparable with DeepSeek 67B, using only 28.5% (maybe even 18.2%)
of computations.
|
[
-0.8049229383,
-0.6352809668,
0.6755110621,
0.2260576636,
-0.3454369605,
0.193384096,
-0.4713617563,
-0.6709813476,
0.2973501682,
0.5201667547,
-0.4162545204,
-0.2976409197,
-0.8744907975,
-0.264256835,
-0.1655436009,
0.389939338,
0.2159783691,
-0.3121141493,
-0.2139751166,
0.1708303988,
-0.3309766352,
-0.2406470478,
-0.4330461621,
-0.2409016639,
0.4145176709,
0.8392558694,
0.6498658657,
0.6690095663,
0.2392924279,
0.307331413,
-0.0806632712,
0.1732033193,
-0.5674544573,
0.2783277333,
-0.1163873374,
-0.3643169999,
-0.6911392808,
-0.1193093732,
0.4161866307,
0.6666983962,
-0.3525554538,
-0.2603116632,
-0.0924519375,
0.6148570776,
-0.6866326332,
-0.1345955133,
-0.9723647237,
-0.0016243472,
-0.3338202834,
0.1565860957,
-0.1548384577,
0.2380196154,
0.1696319431,
-0.4907436967,
-0.0163740814,
-0.2615350485,
0.5655556321,
0.3636476398,
-0.4443124831,
0.0697177052,
-0.6900200248,
0.9741181731,
-0.968978703,
0.4713895917,
0.3031638265,
0.3599447608,
-0.0739617869,
-0.3348114491,
-0.4301020801,
-0.2733427286,
0.2805299163,
0.2478230298,
-0.0311769899,
-0.0905008242,
-0.233357504,
0.4992419779,
-0.2731388211,
0.7491132617,
-0.4573315978,
-0.0485996194,
0.9991499186,
0.161754936,
-0.0274415389,
0.2502138019,
-0.2773169279,
0.1790303141,
-0.4963868558,
-0.3004954457,
0.4501730204,
-0.1560913622,
0.1845547259,
0.3089171946,
-0.6799203753,
0.4951411486,
0.3408454359,
-0.1380225271,
0.2851123214,
0.1018248126,
-0.187635392,
0.0153139671,
0.7590681911,
0.2287829518,
0.3430494368,
-0.4183225334,
-0.1629158854,
-0.1433665603,
0.4288449585,
-0.9138492346,
-0.6009265184,
0.2285439819,
-0.1518244147,
-0.3742311895,
-0.301911056,
-0.91195333,
-0.2998618484,
-0.4246407747,
0.2671321332,
-0.4299010038,
-0.8116717339,
0.2592112124,
0.1887470037,
-0.0378045514,
0.4778096676,
-1.0614441633,
0.4858036935,
0.887054801,
0.3972426057,
-0.3280510306,
-0.4044654667,
0.005700116,
0.3976419866,
-0.4067311585,
0.7446658015,
-1.0041350126,
-0.409394443,
-0.3386125863,
-0.6777822375,
-0.0535783023,
-0.6614621878,
0.4556559622,
-0.7324312925,
-0.0055856211,
-0.1519635767,
-0.9011348486,
-0.4121485651,
0.1967982948,
-0.3736714125,
1.0577608347,
0.0531739257,
-0.3997611701,
0.503200829,
-0.4928925931,
-0.440097481,
0.2629137635,
-0.3593400717,
0.0282489117,
0.4171823263,
0.2463145554,
0.8306479454,
-0.3487621546,
0.2809022665,
-0.4265038371,
-0.048420582,
-0.0258038305,
-0.3892149925,
0.4772931933,
0.2289767116,
-0.3823778033,
-0.029262241,
-0.8314293623,
-0.0698521882,
0.0684143603,
-0.1559654176,
-0.5569919348,
0.0679324493,
-0.2755999565,
0.2991166711,
0.3419478536,
-0.4517872632,
0.2998723686,
-0.2855527997,
0.3411877453,
0.9364132881,
-0.0362437256,
0.7106408477,
0.25502491,
0.3569585681,
0.3131715357,
0.2426366806,
0.1689391434,
-0.7111683488,
-0.7979670167,
-0.5993071795,
0.2812902927,
0.4316489995,
-0.3905128539,
0.7460423708,
-0.19907704,
-0.8125378489,
-0.630675137,
0.5686553121,
0.3344023526,
0.6132624745,
0.3871095181,
-0.3792689145,
-0.1334575862,
-1.3742470741,
0.0886513442,
0.1927566379,
-0.0734440461,
0.4772884548,
0.1840780079,
-0.5253491998,
0.7689327002,
-0.5191271305,
-0.0943752751,
-0.0526895858,
-0.1156498641,
0.3070403636,
0.688026011,
0.6609678268,
-0.7868376374,
-0.7741066217,
0.401664257,
-0.4592832625,
0.0002603854,
0.2622588873,
-0.5265812278,
0.0437222011,
0.3349684775,
-0.7072569132,
-0.0642781258,
0.5613059998,
-0.0668444037,
0.5439212322,
-0.1518073529,
-0.0276490934,
-1.1266336441,
-0.1218609437,
-0.1168882921,
0.1097443476,
-0.7463513613,
0.4451375008,
-0.0845531598,
0.237972647,
-0.140871644,
0.5430848002,
-0.2608947456,
0.2086441815,
-0.2650547922,
-0.0257830806,
-0.234278664,
0.7270195484,
-0.0762017667,
0.5476229191,
0.9968200326,
-0.9187871814,
0.4010905921,
-0.1217444986,
-0.3596741557,
0.4593036771,
-0.6834356189,
0.3107171655,
0.16675964,
-0.2269161642,
-0.8724625707,
-0.4423068166,
0.2558021247,
-0.4389344156,
0.5791300535,
-0.1263173372,
-0.5037035942,
-0.1715854704,
-0.237779215,
0.5593251586,
0.7941123843,
-0.1704574227,
0.893106401,
0.6023474336,
-0.4199625254,
-0.5001695752,
-0.5499789715,
0.1470382214,
-0.1239076257,
-0.8203651905,
0.2796964347,
-0.1153547987,
-0.2602748573,
0.1917302907,
-0.2106562704,
-0.2793248594,
0.2692299485,
-0.0177464671,
-0.0321917608,
-0.4251301587,
-0.0650596991,
0.6981733441,
-0.3639854789,
-0.1611522883,
-0.6332202554,
0.629601717,
0.0892035887,
-0.3641326725,
-0.162973389,
0.6302567124,
0.5786501169,
-0.447183907,
0.6175048351,
0.6772398353,
-0.1436051875,
-0.011021887,
-1.0765590668,
0.0036394075,
-0.4986189902,
0.6563472152,
-0.5756359696,
-1.0711270571,
0.5336111784,
-0.0923908874,
0.324783355,
0.7560063004,
0.7819206715,
-0.0863450766,
1.0045763254,
0.7338132858,
-0.3733042777,
0.153878361,
-0.0721009225,
0.0534124039,
-0.8173176646,
-0.3087898195,
-0.2746576071,
-0.5452733636,
-0.2360533625,
-0.5478878617,
0.2944309413,
0.3671919703,
-0.1764414459,
0.0868432224,
-0.3462758064,
0.6041263938,
0.8572994471,
0.1856855005,
0.0531002842,
0.3014679849,
-0.0251755416,
0.0265303142,
-0.9971323609,
-0.2630972266,
1.1009471416,
0.3629167676,
0.5013943911,
0.1000570059,
0.9419588447,
0.1503921747,
0.0824086592,
-0.7302939892,
0.7618778944,
-0.3278256655,
-0.6291585565,
-0.4451815188,
-0.4900356531,
-0.5835743546,
0.4380491078,
-0.0432730578,
-0.6457572579,
0.5457609892,
0.3391900957,
-0.2306492329,
0.362787962,
-0.7580054402,
0.5869553685,
-0.1670984775,
-0.2217565477,
-0.842751801,
-0.5458025336,
0.389686197,
-0.1994944066,
0.0734755173,
-0.3924755454,
-0.3726663589,
0.6647553444,
-0.2109742463,
0.7704790235,
-0.1103556976,
-0.3976877928,
0.1586433649,
0.3845603168,
0.417773664,
0.0300929882,
-0.2469529808,
0.3731994629,
-0.6474497914,
-0.7956174612,
-0.5482402444,
0.8534277081,
-1.0946793556,
-0.7957541347,
0.2638349235,
-0.4938550293,
-0.5606851578,
0.3508907259,
0.1384589374,
0.3901461959,
0.1374643892,
0.25648579,
0.9544625878,
0.2382742614,
0.2411347777,
0.531126976,
0.1146756932,
-0.5786737204,
1.0370765924,
0.0827485695,
0.2540386617,
0.4863315821,
0.2700166702,
0.00167208,
-0.90334481,
-0.4661406279,
0.0666430593,
-0.5636569262,
-0.0990814045,
-0.8816506863,
0.1025816575,
-0.3853546381,
-0.2528838813,
-0.7073511481,
-0.4031358361,
-0.1194930226,
-0.1762695014,
0.2668166161,
0.5681254268,
-0.2063981891,
0.3604800999,
-0.8632499576,
0.1224776432,
0.8083984256,
0.5057016015,
0.5227146745,
-0.5253690481,
-0.4024650156,
-0.0442167968,
0.069661133,
-0.6775513887,
0.0105846524,
0.112587668,
0.9778318405,
0.9062120914,
-0.0780120045,
0.5873346925,
-0.6278102994,
0.558678031,
0.1340444386,
-0.7798472047,
0.2742361426,
-0.3900249004,
0.1274516433,
0.8576194644,
0.4344810843,
-0.2433196306,
-0.479411453,
-0.7503396869,
-1.0890043974,
0.5876609087,
0.1598278731,
0.3726790249,
0.2364955842,
0.338129878,
0.5253562927,
0.3194780648,
-0.0814813152,
-0.085954152,
0.1421359479,
-0.1465421319,
-0.0989505127,
-0.8639769554,
-0.2130440325,
-0.4267965555,
0.7269920111,
0.1811575145,
0.127902329,
-0.0835209042,
-0.1331955492,
-0.0188855231,
0.1687312424,
0.6030322909,
0.896050036,
-0.0686165243,
0.061958205,
0.1725078523,
-0.4785015583,
-0.1361784041,
0.1630565822,
-0.1989595294,
-0.2254763246,
0.5087391734,
0.8613575101,
0.3561930954,
-0.5132029653,
0.078755796,
0.503454864,
-0.398989588,
0.1519143432,
0.5126284957,
0.0366468728,
0.4455249906,
0.4905386865,
0.2397417128,
0.1859950721,
-0.279538095,
0.1001388207,
0.1457061172,
-0.1142599136,
-0.2917506397,
0.4666978121,
0.671238184,
-0.1037768796,
0.6248645782,
-0.1334171593,
-0.6905429363,
0.6692990065,
-0.0463763848,
1.025698185,
-0.564365685,
-0.0824283585,
-0.1020648628,
0.3437680602,
0.2498005629,
0.0812405497,
-0.3932553828,
-0.7617465854,
-0.6414069533,
-0.464723587,
-0.3235253692,
-0.1737272143,
-0.5625501871,
-0.1144284159,
-0.3843680024,
0.2034534514,
-0.2052408904,
0.0501009822,
-0.6008091569,
0.2334868163,
0.3941265047,
1.0848747492,
-0.6562699676,
0.8583413959,
0.8826895952,
0.0538708679,
-0.6061184406,
-0.0146262655,
-0.2807969749,
-0.8947142959,
0.4165941775,
-0.0091286888,
0.1029689834,
0.0673367754,
-0.5027909875,
-0.6997303367,
0.9493799806,
0.2294014543,
-0.8763782978,
0.2338259816,
0.0020821998,
0.399687916,
-0.2557114661,
0.1306465566,
0.5574088097,
0.5037971735,
0.1547615081,
-0.8815295696,
-0.1512765884,
-0.3731126189,
-0.148083955,
0.3008693159,
-0.7658362389,
0.8828635216,
-0.0426973552,
0.3640004694,
-0.2303483188,
0.9266188741,
0.0789532438,
0.0221995488,
0.6648600698,
0.8353523016,
0.7779399753,
0.3372274339,
0.9038149118,
-0.464300245,
0.1964665502,
0.9233276248,
-0.2952019274,
0.8100813627,
0.2353834361,
-0.2774577141,
0.3068636358,
0.5797470808,
0.085235171,
0.639723599,
-0.3425045013,
-0.2688563764,
-0.8094665408,
0.2928017378,
-0.6590784192,
0.2031303495,
0.3570997715,
-0.021026751,
-0.0939757451,
-0.2333516628,
0.0651787147,
-0.0674505979,
-0.5447440147,
0.8142818213,
0.0423291437,
-0.3799216449,
0.1032117456,
0.0548638292,
0.7132542729,
-0.7785188556,
0.1897886693,
-0.4132331908,
0.2658189535,
-0.0679820329,
-0.9190708399,
-0.1404016018,
-0.3119702637,
-0.3553844094,
0.139460057,
0.8371968269,
-0.6094765663,
-0.7017551661,
0.3200725615,
0.3155186176,
0.0553110614,
-0.4348450601,
-0.583031714,
-0.051962439,
-0.0851403028,
-0.3779745102,
0.3396171927,
0.7200213075,
0.2073381245,
0.6231321096,
0.4343588352,
-0.0215606261,
0.4318345785,
0.0205191076,
1.1741120815,
-0.2519273758,
-0.6667663455,
-0.8539097905,
0.5988614559,
-0.3554084599,
-0.3751688302,
0.8838673234,
0.4347642362,
0.8960364461,
-0.1723109484,
0.5324567556,
-0.0779958591,
0.260248512,
-0.4445343018,
0.5892207623,
-0.7817198038,
-0.033123605,
-0.4200095534,
-1.0046849251,
-0.0693174228,
0.267457664,
-0.3409104645,
0.1680863798,
0.034831062,
0.5164857507,
-0.4737906456,
-0.1251345724,
0.4653822184,
0.4833291769,
0.3033446968,
0.716283679,
0.648050189,
0.1186590791,
0.3178170323,
-0.5436854959,
-0.44286412,
-0.593755126,
-0.5684809685,
-0.9812161922,
-0.1934915334,
-0.3960159719,
0.2917380333,
-0.1274545193,
0.832241416,
1.0561197996,
-0.8315017819,
-0.1024022475,
-0.0327854678,
-0.0129646128,
-0.2970195711,
-0.1859248728,
0.1795701087,
-0.3200725317,
-0.8100665212,
0.477222383,
0.5671417713,
-0.3628867269,
-0.4455237985,
-0.3141100705,
0.0104548689,
0.0946595669,
0.835218966,
0.0712299868,
-0.5912308097,
0.1710999459,
-0.1280540377,
0.1062445864,
-0.1375160664,
0.7650584579,
-0.4934896827,
0.4584928155,
0.483535856,
1.0705565214,
0.292853862,
-0.2887750268,
0.6332555413,
-0.5670025945,
0.3382934034,
0.5198259354,
0.2325563878,
-0.1714282185,
-0.4487634003,
0.3490200341,
0.2579519153,
-0.4011652768,
-0.6540760994,
0.2845632732,
-1.0092080832,
-0.3949591815,
1.0455750227,
0.0697438866,
0.1338802427,
0.0555867217,
-0.1843942404,
-0.2633636296,
-0.5871588588,
0.7529200315,
0.7303587198,
-0.027274251,
-0.3494485021,
-0.5002812743,
-0.036526151,
0.6993777752,
-0.4591659307,
-0.1829836071,
0.3065879941,
0.2159816474,
0.0674548522,
0.5151959658,
0.1672479063,
0.1865364611,
0.1241686344,
0.0821343735,
-0.5788500905,
-0.5843193531,
0.0632309169,
0.2323939055,
-0.0748638511,
-0.0693202168
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06059v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06059v1
|
Investigating Data Contamination for Pre-training Language Models
| 2024-01-11T17:24:49 | 2024-01-11T17:24:49 |
Minhao Jiang, Ken Ziyu Liu, Ming Zhong, Rylan Schaeffer, Siru Ouyang, Jiawei Han, Sanmi Koyejo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Language models pre-trained on web-scale corpora demonstrate impressive
capabilities on diverse downstream tasks. However, there is increasing concern
whether such capabilities might arise from evaluation datasets being included
in the pre-training corpus -- a phenomenon known as \textit{data contamination}
-- in a manner that artificially increases performance. There has been little
understanding of how this potential contamination might influence LMs'
performance on downstream tasks. In this paper, we explore the impact of data
contamination at the pre-training stage by pre-training a series of GPT-2
models \textit{from scratch}. We highlight the effect of both text
contamination (\textit{i.e.}\ input text of the evaluation samples) and
ground-truth contamination (\textit{i.e.}\ the prompts asked on the input and
the desired outputs) from evaluation data. We also investigate the effects of
repeating contamination for various downstream tasks. Additionally, we examine
the prevailing n-gram-based definitions of contamination within current LLM
reports, pinpointing their limitations and inadequacy. Our findings offer new
insights into data contamination's effects on language model capabilities and
underscore the need for independent, comprehensive contamination assessments in
LLM studies.
|
[
-0.4224414229,
-0.7808461785,
0.7004553676,
-0.2130102962,
-0.2666405439,
0.0624930076,
0.0032770741,
-0.774286449,
-0.3882972896,
0.8709308505,
-0.3690651059,
-0.3241333961,
-1.0363764763,
-0.0901008174,
-0.6749119163,
1.2152379751,
-0.1131958961,
-0.1486215591,
-0.3977255225,
0.2741330862,
-0.4514494538,
-0.8466177583,
-0.4224224091,
-0.2621877491,
0.6061885357,
0.3880078793,
0.6777493358,
0.8946384192,
0.5146745443,
0.3064960539,
0.036263302,
-0.171093002,
-0.7023283839,
0.0802256837,
-0.3794242144,
-0.6284434199,
-0.3797290921,
0.3420371115,
0.6210353374,
0.7445475459,
0.0159528665,
0.0621213615,
0.5328807831,
0.5554677844,
-0.8746443987,
-0.0737554505,
-0.7809835076,
-0.246274814,
-0.4161692262,
-0.2757757902,
-0.3744193017,
-0.2160073817,
0.2178584337,
-0.7006399632,
0.2112040818,
-0.2906164527,
1.1845083237,
0.4262371063,
-0.2557223141,
-0.2940764129,
-0.9609915018,
0.7378525138,
-0.693305254,
0.1432862133,
0.8839994073,
-0.0356906764,
-0.0728711337,
-0.8651121855,
-0.3908471763,
-0.0877551436,
-0.2540061176,
-0.1052030176,
-0.2829772532,
0.0155454092,
0.1579844058,
0.2486984581,
-0.4317301214,
0.268061161,
-0.6111694574,
-0.1494215727,
0.3876438141,
0.0027128856,
0.4996480942,
-0.0951203331,
-0.4121684432,
-0.1212614253,
-1.1743267775,
-0.24219428,
0.6269916892,
0.3059921265,
0.017776778,
0.4035211802,
-0.0110586965,
0.6571872234,
-0.2125667632,
0.2491330802,
0.2020972669,
-0.7983971238,
-0.4506708682,
-0.1510843337,
0.7445530295,
-0.0411101505,
0.4935618043,
-0.2545452416,
-0.1897884905,
-0.0642591193,
0.6268447042,
-0.8537716269,
-0.4046096802,
0.2738593221,
0.0718140975,
-0.5742332339,
0.025208218,
-0.5227863193,
-0.4512045383,
-0.6526938081,
0.7256656289,
-0.1543569565,
-0.3979609609,
0.2136116773,
0.1311439723,
-0.3260496259,
0.2220634669,
-0.8443861008,
0.1802562624,
0.8030874133,
0.3999184668,
-0.0916733742,
-0.3153101504,
-0.7046518922,
-0.0681405216,
-0.138747558,
0.7382448316,
-0.5168713927,
-0.5424008965,
0.0165352542,
-0.1975211352,
-0.1095325276,
-0.9659005404,
0.5671018362,
-0.5186408162,
0.3266908526,
-0.0968573168,
-0.6871976256,
-0.0441347621,
-0.0926767737,
-0.7341781259,
1.0916838646,
0.0972739682,
-1.0380835533,
0.6977677941,
-0.1804605573,
-0.4993572235,
0.1831804365,
-0.3376327455,
-0.2154311091,
0.0305205882,
-0.109276168,
0.4205389023,
-0.0839516893,
0.2337080091,
-0.3253927827,
-0.5900817513,
0.188550204,
-0.5406783223,
0.5531176329,
0.1785525531,
-0.4366986454,
0.0437014326,
-0.9191610217,
0.2986835539,
-0.1973011345,
-0.3388302922,
-0.5311397314,
-0.1558211297,
-0.0201454014,
0.4092380702,
-0.0075616413,
-0.2115419507,
-0.1127295196,
-0.030980859,
0.2745698094,
0.9168832898,
0.0936480239,
0.2109172642,
-0.4216109216,
0.485378623,
0.2654121816,
0.2715975344,
-0.1063616946,
-0.317019999,
-0.7092100978,
-0.1544170231,
0.3796186745,
0.4408742189,
-0.6820418835,
0.497576803,
-0.4755908549,
-0.685280025,
-0.4871957898,
0.2182862461,
0.3143460453,
0.5190628767,
0.3769096136,
-0.2230177224,
-0.5237901211,
-0.9052683115,
-0.3444498181,
0.0469309278,
-0.2610250413,
0.3154045939,
0.6718336344,
-0.43366611,
1.261883378,
-0.346097827,
-0.2144516557,
-0.0906252265,
0.3310529292,
-0.0112165837,
0.6002585888,
0.0926459581,
-0.5030777454,
-0.3736482263,
-0.3949576616,
-0.6966437101,
-0.3241875172,
0.0175076984,
-0.1753950119,
-0.0930909067,
0.5597026348,
-0.3938889205,
0.4824020863,
0.6869544983,
-0.0095803598,
0.7417913079,
-0.3740093708,
0.1433629096,
-0.7354527712,
0.1357322335,
-0.1104526222,
-0.1758397222,
-0.8417600989,
-0.064430207,
-0.01570311,
0.2123105079,
-0.8260378242,
0.1857522726,
-0.2962560058,
-0.0159170367,
-0.3047580421,
0.4565705657,
0.3682887554,
-0.0396888964,
0.0270498712,
1.033831954,
0.4114115536,
-0.7208162546,
-0.2104632407,
0.0577613339,
-0.6775647402,
0.0947822183,
-0.7200247049,
0.462672472,
0.1481440663,
0.0017004609,
-0.9020125866,
0.004473574,
0.1523293406,
-0.2432409823,
0.4933551252,
-0.2787136436,
-0.8123633265,
0.2665564716,
-0.1229255572,
0.4826471508,
0.1654398888,
-0.5120174289,
0.0276847985,
0.2470591217,
-0.1724427938,
-0.5975307822,
-0.7481266856,
-0.0479101315,
-0.3771551549,
-0.6224510074,
0.0064471131,
0.1227860898,
-0.3395063579,
0.0698515698,
-0.1539311111,
-0.1692696214,
0.526429832,
0.3527990282,
0.2975084782,
0.0772492364,
0.0973151997,
-0.076699473,
0.1077677459,
0.1998782605,
0.1088541821,
0.7521042228,
0.1811018139,
-0.4076387882,
-0.4271604717,
0.0056145801,
0.250028789,
-0.2417443991,
0.7694951892,
0.2789650857,
-0.3567086756,
0.0671782866,
-0.4125335813,
-0.0926545858,
-0.5536001921,
0.5791396499,
-0.2307649702,
-0.6180437803,
0.2158324867,
0.0573835559,
-0.2492851019,
0.4329008758,
0.0924503058,
-0.3537735939,
0.5266882777,
0.647215426,
-0.016331384,
0.5843287706,
-0.2163942456,
-0.0067203795,
-0.6827158332,
0.0707137808,
-0.5554535389,
0.1211040616,
-0.6030783057,
-0.6106420159,
-0.038784191,
0.4618449509,
-0.2869757712,
0.1741927266,
0.0191715788,
0.6613913178,
0.4060839713,
0.042804677,
0.5488795042,
-0.0048328387,
-0.1373862922,
0.0218829084,
-0.5179833174,
-0.7934303284,
1.4285275936,
0.3586931527,
0.6850244999,
-0.3335160315,
0.9566437602,
0.3534278572,
0.5023999214,
-0.1098513678,
0.248287484,
-0.345357269,
-0.7622626424,
-0.184449628,
-0.6515958905,
-0.9984903932,
0.1721585095,
-0.0419629365,
-0.8277004957,
0.1084844172,
-0.081386663,
-0.2245867252,
0.2459188402,
-0.6914368868,
0.8407590389,
-0.4274260998,
-0.6285995841,
-0.1923720539,
-0.5411131382,
0.5201573372,
-0.54941535,
0.4898323417,
0.0611506142,
0.3062562943,
0.6981723309,
-0.4285852611,
0.7096152902,
-0.0581372268,
-0.4935666621,
0.2121818513,
0.0146444431,
0.5731275678,
-0.1409079731,
0.3310481906,
0.4169010222,
0.0735646412,
-0.293638289,
-0.3147450089,
0.2799349725,
-0.8392449021,
-0.5819065571,
-0.5344231725,
-0.292614311,
-0.4183953702,
0.2732526958,
0.691603601,
0.3080084026,
0.0040566311,
0.2660307586,
0.7093102336,
-0.4731594324,
0.2047544867,
0.4842534959,
-0.4172331691,
-0.1568064988,
0.8892303705,
0.1435049623,
0.914986968,
0.0814770907,
-0.0522214286,
-0.3185912073,
-0.6985458732,
-0.3023667336,
0.1653802395,
-0.6724274158,
0.0320886932,
-0.4683824182,
-0.156960845,
-0.1616919935,
0.4084845781,
-0.4201938212,
-0.1049496979,
-0.5883184075,
-0.3065949976,
-0.0619141348,
1.0129313469,
-0.1039921567,
0.5405914783,
-1.0265836716,
0.1044414341,
-0.1015755013,
0.5149356723,
-0.3344531059,
-0.4992982149,
-0.4690194726,
0.3921632767,
-0.1511049867,
-0.7158196568,
0.0646528751,
0.052714739,
0.5449379086,
0.6440756917,
-0.334741652,
0.5101124048,
-0.3571342826,
0.7353839874,
-0.1544703692,
-0.9636463523,
0.48447752,
-0.5580755472,
0.0872604772,
0.8521221876,
0.3832857609,
-0.5883902311,
-0.8163282275,
-0.6054397225,
-1.0151826143,
0.733543992,
0.2822527587,
-0.029086072,
0.0635815561,
0.4258256257,
0.1661981046,
0.3606376648,
-0.5540727377,
-0.1947804987,
-0.0171553344,
0.1664110571,
-0.2648122013,
-0.5652270317,
0.0009063315,
0.0514288954,
0.7303551435,
0.4682073891,
-0.2529236376,
-0.2540886998,
-0.6942026615,
0.106495373,
0.2774428129,
0.6747868061,
0.8600349426,
-0.1598170251,
0.1619810015,
-0.1536086947,
-0.8935931325,
0.198818922,
0.0220348537,
-0.1703578681,
-0.2805262208,
0.5603687167,
0.5285624266,
0.2304726541,
-0.7249085307,
0.3450013399,
-0.1352836341,
0.0368352048,
-0.2173635066,
0.173814103,
0.1134475619,
-0.2031567395,
0.4497223496,
0.0902417302,
0.0916274861,
-0.7127199173,
0.8012918234,
0.011590641,
-0.1973476559,
-0.1870180517,
0.5511497855,
-0.056224864,
0.2803124189,
0.8208149076,
-0.1049985215,
-0.5632036924,
0.4670137763,
0.1805996895,
0.6277710199,
-0.3132087886,
-0.0362043977,
-0.126971215,
0.4872625172,
0.1003392488,
0.1347154975,
0.309997946,
-0.8108394742,
-0.6706442833,
-0.6157551408,
-0.1743361652,
0.7506002784,
-0.9103571177,
0.2171532214,
-0.3284888566,
-0.1591375023,
-0.252582252,
-0.1144062281,
-0.8447555304,
0.4946715832,
0.3850846887,
0.5058994889,
-0.9828125834,
0.8670787811,
0.2107743174,
-0.5845057368,
-0.8721274137,
0.205022499,
-0.1514074951,
-0.6229519248,
0.9334390163,
0.3367630839,
-0.1314065307,
-0.2101859748,
-0.0061466075,
-1.0146276951,
0.6310558319,
0.4668824971,
-0.5166471601,
-0.0166824367,
0.8361038566,
0.5365071297,
0.0334534533,
0.4127435982,
1.0568085909,
0.5173637271,
-0.4392955005,
-0.9396893382,
-0.0180599578,
-0.2509992421,
-0.2310218066,
0.0949320495,
-0.1936302483,
0.8304714561,
0.0297303945,
-0.4847397506,
-0.0469341911,
0.1981580108,
0.1427104622,
0.0860603079,
0.5523262024,
0.7124715447,
0.8672564626,
-0.1970123649,
1.046756506,
-0.2722512782,
0.3988675773,
1.8082741499,
-0.4410351217,
0.9135305882,
0.4392959476,
-0.4126054049,
0.3195081949,
0.8113896251,
-0.0349990763,
0.5336972475,
0.6607215405,
-0.2178262174,
0.1988792419,
-0.1227147281,
-0.3996124566,
0.6827970147,
0.2779785097,
-0.3717563152,
-0.3886854351,
0.1506845057,
0.2274481952,
-0.151318416,
-0.0956823006,
0.7159036994,
-0.1843504161,
-0.6079909801,
0.5535907149,
-0.1475764811,
0.5646639466,
-0.4348564446,
0.0899913535,
-0.333240658,
0.1599178463,
-0.3674373329,
-0.6826565862,
0.3879132271,
0.1278557926,
0.0370089486,
-0.3778599799,
0.6263442039,
-0.4894913137,
-0.2477236092,
0.6257802844,
0.8134580851,
0.4390623271,
-0.6551741958,
-0.1396207213,
0.2485514879,
-0.1849902719,
-0.3958498836,
0.7058033943,
0.2771930397,
0.2157323509,
0.5498469472,
0.6069186926,
0.2482545376,
0.4354248047,
0.2651348412,
0.9113377333,
-0.2586356401,
-0.1957633644,
-0.9429555535,
0.5389508009,
0.278603971,
-0.0303894393,
0.6187665462,
0.9997152686,
0.9818224907,
0.098853156,
1.0914367437,
0.3793598413,
0.4249377847,
-0.5761725307,
0.8954716325,
-0.3336958885,
0.5129540563,
-0.2636069357,
-0.7667101622,
0.191765815,
0.1389466226,
-0.4223968387,
0.2212860733,
0.8879202008,
0.4232582748,
-0.1308594346,
0.089209348,
0.2335389107,
0.3252048194,
0.512647748,
0.3682549,
0.9686388969,
-0.2090213597,
0.6853984594,
-0.4510780275,
-0.070447512,
0.0437990539,
-0.8357313275,
-0.4099722803,
-0.431951791,
-0.2979546487,
-0.2034914345,
0.0542218201,
0.2672466636,
0.4247319698,
-0.6608325839,
-0.0978272781,
-0.340370506,
-0.1410443634,
0.1101074219,
-0.2263644338,
0.4112379849,
-0.6342133284,
-0.7750169635,
0.4903334975,
-0.3144776523,
0.1631702185,
-0.1082560867,
0.4829633832,
-0.1916916519,
-0.1144020706,
0.403862685,
-0.1479306519,
-0.2354374677,
-0.5313401222,
-0.2498452961,
-0.2484000623,
0.1943022013,
0.7452024221,
-0.7936036587,
0.373944819,
0.2312757969,
0.6326814294,
0.496855557,
0.269094944,
0.6862062216,
-1.061408639,
-0.1105297431,
0.1265906692,
0.3762970269,
0.4382186234,
-0.6879692078,
0.5337442756,
0.2245558053,
-0.3889897764,
-0.9769496322,
0.1397337466,
-0.4723742902,
-0.2732553482,
1.3598095179,
-0.4137663245,
0.2866156697,
-0.1607382596,
0.2238459289,
0.517836988,
0.0567229129,
0.6489118934,
1.2794374228,
-0.0113321608,
0.1522893161,
-1.1601151228,
0.6185331345,
0.3527337015,
-1.2583559752,
0.3313699365,
0.4715282023,
0.814356029,
0.0061259447,
0.5052886009,
-0.406850785,
0.0295457523,
0.0084631247,
-0.0329082385,
-0.1343903989,
-0.4614294469,
-0.4872845709,
-0.0774897933,
0.0390778445,
-0.2040996403
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.