id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15561v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15561v3
|
README: Bridging Medical Jargon and Lay Understanding for Patient Education through Data-Centric NLP
| 2023-12-24T23:01:00 | 2024-06-17T02:12:24 |
Zonghai Yao, Nandyala Siddharth Kantu, Guanghao Wei, Hieu Tran, Zhangqi Duan, Sunjae Kwon, Zhichao Yang, README annotation team, Hong Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The advancement in healthcare has shifted focus toward patient-centric
approaches, particularly in self-care and patient education, facilitated by
access to Electronic Health Records (EHR). However, medical jargon in EHRs
poses significant challenges in patient comprehension. To address this, we
introduce a new task of automatically generating lay definitions, aiming to
simplify complex medical terms into patient-friendly lay language. We first
created the README dataset, an extensive collection of over 50,000 unique
(medical term, lay definition) pairs and 300,000 mentions, each offering
context-aware lay definitions manually annotated by domain experts. We have
also engineered a data-centric Human-AI pipeline that synergizes data
filtering, augmentation, and selection to improve data quality. We then used
README as the training data for models and leveraged a Retrieval-Augmented
Generation method to reduce hallucinations and improve the quality of model
outputs. Our extensive automatic and human evaluations demonstrate that
open-source mobile-friendly models, when fine-tuned with high-quality data, are
capable of matching or even surpassing the performance of state-of-the-art
closed-source large language models like ChatGPT. This research represents a
significant stride in closing the knowledge gap in patient education and
advancing patient-centric healthcare solutions.
|
[
-0.1388432831,
-0.6230630875,
0.4298091531,
-0.1882832199,
-0.3557984531,
-0.1330340058,
-0.1240457445,
-0.6005300879,
0.1160458252,
0.6839040518,
-0.5582394004,
-0.7143024206,
-0.5855169892,
0.0581912622,
-0.1808287352,
0.8438267112,
-0.1141654551,
0.1481073499,
-0.4308916032,
-0.1450430751,
-0.3121618629,
-0.465002656,
-0.5786741376,
-0.5966768265,
0.2317974865,
0.5297325253,
0.8230130076,
0.9121550322,
0.4415500164,
0.1874777526,
0.2863975167,
0.0690389127,
-0.3491610289,
0.2073076665,
0.142208755,
-0.2188503742,
-0.440354228,
-0.080401428,
0.0786532909,
1.2879966497,
-0.3743239045,
0.043424651,
-0.3442079723,
0.8588990569,
-0.3224839568,
0.0137030706,
-0.5783240795,
0.4713517725,
-0.1009784713,
-0.4259893,
-0.4251601994,
-0.1456607431,
0.3453670442,
-1.0072020292,
0.2791843414,
-0.057467103,
0.7935262918,
0.5662232041,
-0.4326261282,
-0.4884415567,
-0.5481838584,
0.4811793268,
-0.8273319006,
0.5384874344,
0.3324923515,
0.3773474991,
-0.1057299376,
-0.9070211649,
-0.5098336935,
-0.112045005,
-0.1627926528,
0.2400694937,
0.1646988988,
0.2731940448,
0.276378423,
0.567083776,
-0.828749299,
-0.116598092,
-0.3845236301,
-0.0185307655,
0.7020719051,
0.0857414305,
0.368300885,
-0.3854314983,
-0.5454592109,
0.1939827651,
-0.5932512283,
-0.2684490681,
-0.2451574355,
-0.0098458426,
-0.1073624715,
0.6969123483,
-0.264084518,
0.7300789356,
0.0042538536,
-0.3527729511,
0.3092025816,
0.0632007495,
-0.4972915649,
0.2851525545,
0.7182399035,
0.3163697124,
0.0531544127,
-0.2928218842,
0.0091560679,
0.0743627772,
0.5325449109,
-0.7469184995,
-0.6085144281,
0.6137413979,
-0.6739987731,
-0.2757287025,
-0.2012282163,
-0.6519342661,
-0.6437194943,
-0.7516602874,
0.3459176421,
-0.5445632339,
-0.089719452,
0.6413731575,
0.1412089467,
0.219990924,
0.4463265836,
-0.6984680295,
0.2914573848,
0.7566922903,
0.5522475243,
-0.057130482,
0.0082809683,
-0.2155151069,
0.2646740377,
-0.171176672,
0.5033150911,
-0.2414867431,
-0.4484848678,
0.1321721226,
-0.1768519133,
-0.1371733546,
-0.5880455971,
0.5894026756,
-0.0613660105,
0.743024528,
0.2093269974,
-0.8160839081,
-0.2958410382,
0.1175635755,
-0.456129849,
0.7549645305,
0.2959104776,
-0.6335846186,
0.5148414969,
-0.7942607403,
-0.8014345765,
0.6952079535,
-0.5448265672,
-0.3932572007,
0.1730595529,
0.0663251132,
0.6536984444,
-0.3817322254,
0.2854682207,
0.1814043969,
-0.0206327494,
0.0502481721,
0.0422314368,
0.4972186983,
0.2736776471,
-0.4230374694,
0.1093865708,
-0.7161776423,
0.1584659517,
-0.01203248,
-0.0555021055,
-0.4575645924,
0.1672424972,
-0.0398978107,
0.55207932,
-0.010552533,
-0.200010106,
-0.0342338346,
-0.3532949984,
0.2041811943,
0.3328811824,
-0.1155754924,
0.1968514174,
-0.235867247,
0.4746651053,
0.127244249,
0.5002849102,
-0.358635366,
-0.5225639939,
-0.7431061864,
-0.297568202,
0.084041439,
0.5351492167,
-0.7085483074,
0.5257931948,
-0.3845886886,
-0.4882825911,
-0.9381426573,
0.1229407638,
0.2662683427,
1.1295776367,
0.5255619884,
-0.3612008691,
-0.4902127981,
-0.7098153234,
-0.0898860916,
-0.2247288227,
-0.2452247739,
0.6112354398,
0.2318897396,
-0.5232259035,
0.7740520239,
-0.6134615541,
-0.3255224526,
-0.1773841828,
0.0158447344,
-0.0380867869,
0.3316802084,
0.0188078806,
-0.9751622081,
-0.5188446045,
0.2233215123,
-1.0507624149,
-0.2005301565,
-0.3312218189,
-0.157243371,
-0.0188563131,
0.389739573,
-0.5096874237,
0.4199845791,
0.3708813787,
-0.5889713764,
0.3919997513,
-0.0629310831,
0.0880217552,
-1.4214856625,
0.4097656608,
-0.0113335457,
-0.3721039593,
-0.9027620554,
0.0044868672,
-0.145449385,
-0.2725669742,
-0.3772339523,
0.4600377083,
-0.3373537362,
0.253575027,
-0.2325865775,
0.1598603427,
0.2427397221,
0.0467733853,
0.2671718597,
0.4302871227,
0.5141128302,
-0.6411632895,
0.1820363253,
0.7910570502,
-0.0461458787,
0.7427660227,
-0.908618331,
0.0173456874,
-0.0806877241,
0.2219776511,
-0.2916833758,
-0.6007701755,
0.4044909179,
-0.3975810409,
0.194115743,
-0.1938144267,
-0.1283997148,
-0.2491229326,
0.1247631088,
0.2377653122,
0.4697938263,
-0.5148115754,
0.6013861299,
0.5574960709,
-0.096204713,
-0.4463535249,
-0.4572266042,
0.1460033655,
-0.1397451609,
-0.790178895,
0.4021513462,
-0.0996336043,
-0.1822811365,
-0.2528758049,
-0.1734813154,
-0.1852983832,
0.0967096835,
0.5529336333,
0.2909018695,
-0.1870509088,
0.4515621662,
0.1080490947,
-0.0799563304,
0.2909587324,
-0.3660857081,
0.5670222044,
-0.0020767741,
-0.3652436137,
-0.4670139849,
0.6888793707,
0.5837005377,
0.0897077993,
0.6097514629,
0.4337420464,
-0.5254392028,
-0.1278998405,
-0.4597356915,
-0.2543276846,
-0.4359163046,
0.0800745711,
-0.3360396922,
-0.9087530375,
0.3228036463,
-0.2920243442,
0.3724603355,
0.5386868715,
0.3978417516,
-0.2443163544,
0.8120631576,
0.6193399429,
0.4503540099,
-0.1518158615,
0.07338617,
0.1869595498,
-0.5772724152,
-0.6864332557,
-0.2488852292,
-0.0442813747,
-0.5507386923,
-0.4852355123,
0.3154017627,
-0.1438340098,
0.0595420673,
0.0341525711,
-0.6135771871,
0.0509092174,
0.2057922781,
0.1991131306,
0.2958483696,
-0.098003462,
0.1102848947,
-0.089431189,
-0.5371888876,
-0.5929318666,
0.9756289124,
0.6021565795,
0.6426072121,
-0.1027913764,
0.7040609121,
0.3901586235,
0.0610796288,
-0.9290320873,
0.4989300072,
-0.3398284912,
-0.316221416,
0.0401191674,
-0.5988762379,
-0.8909859061,
0.0506428443,
-0.2090543956,
-0.1399255842,
0.010958733,
0.3305092752,
-0.2390905321,
0.1416493356,
-0.6033335328,
0.9415333867,
-0.2793239951,
-0.1042894945,
0.0277156737,
-0.9693946242,
0.4098025858,
-0.1161318645,
-0.0071490784,
-0.0614573993,
-0.141584143,
0.5914056301,
-0.5305755734,
0.6110133529,
-0.0320043117,
-0.2252946645,
0.0413038991,
-0.0301422458,
0.1306255609,
0.138795957,
0.0692386478,
0.2059713602,
-0.0837424695,
-0.5225786567,
-0.3855180144,
0.502088666,
-0.561881423,
-0.1468642056,
-0.3287474215,
-0.5514777899,
-0.2958228588,
0.1458246857,
0.3253487349,
0.2912829518,
-0.2284546345,
-0.0012898104,
1.0741846561,
-0.3272364736,
-0.1465356052,
0.516880393,
-0.1072005481,
-0.164529264,
0.6591717005,
-0.3779801726,
0.3230339289,
0.2470115125,
0.2372830957,
-0.2244791836,
-0.3894507587,
-0.4923460484,
0.3016157746,
-0.6259201169,
0.003849165,
-0.8230014443,
-0.3364275992,
-0.3836107254,
-0.3019734323,
-0.1281475276,
-0.4715282023,
-0.4009928405,
0.1243359819,
0.3095886707,
0.8462149501,
0.2727747262,
0.621217072,
-0.6684433222,
0.5666729808,
0.1331300586,
0.4701467454,
-0.5888557434,
-0.4041536152,
-0.2657822669,
-0.1064745188,
0.1258905083,
-0.8313768506,
0.434538275,
0.2174414843,
0.3537356257,
0.691418767,
-0.0034607288,
0.5748992562,
-0.5213356018,
0.8107747436,
0.5049631,
-0.7499012351,
0.6410424113,
-0.2724813819,
0.2251803875,
0.9830469489,
0.4862370789,
-0.9872146845,
0.1786431521,
-0.7387020588,
-1.1361196041,
0.3325748444,
-0.0969188735,
-0.0326251127,
0.0326864757,
0.5439766049,
0.6006491184,
0.4808013439,
-0.5593348145,
-0.3576771617,
-0.363248378,
-0.5169696808,
0.1928454489,
-0.06860625,
-0.3347326517,
-0.0176631548,
0.8777363896,
-0.2961393893,
0.238075152,
0.1437816918,
-0.2898381352,
-0.149341926,
0.2790171206,
0.4524556994,
0.6802622676,
-0.017762851,
0.2207266092,
-0.2871574163,
-0.9166018963,
-0.2175109833,
0.2588275075,
-0.3485527039,
0.5441502929,
0.0768468678,
0.8603460789,
-0.0588543043,
-0.8846120238,
0.4615796208,
-0.1794686317,
-0.2184338719,
-0.4679671228,
0.057712853,
-0.1871782094,
-0.3977150321,
0.2412995249,
-0.0424663015,
0.2611402571,
-0.145669356,
0.5141199231,
0.2722345591,
-0.4556275308,
-0.1126835644,
0.6518741846,
0.4423997402,
-0.2377218157,
0.5795115829,
-0.0004586581,
-0.3108178079,
0.1871522516,
0.279802531,
0.7720414996,
-0.4017672539,
0.3965001404,
0.2890253365,
0.2081243247,
-0.0530678704,
0.5055398941,
0.0900483727,
-0.1047896296,
-0.6915906668,
-0.3935954869,
-0.4316370785,
0.4454426765,
-0.6821628213,
0.3156135678,
-0.3858750463,
0.1803123802,
-0.0052266461,
-0.0783646032,
-0.6438162923,
0.6300057173,
0.2874833047,
0.9071401954,
-0.9917637706,
0.4323266149,
0.7222399116,
-0.2296988517,
-0.9241198301,
0.1190661862,
-0.1198843345,
-0.4848290682,
0.15826419,
0.2989683151,
0.2890760601,
-0.1376600713,
-0.3946192563,
-0.3075984418,
1.0815449953,
0.0152654322,
-0.5989143848,
-0.2726863921,
0.6078746915,
0.4378488362,
-0.4805835485,
0.1855510622,
0.4694099724,
0.2029829919,
-0.0012621579,
-0.7367799282,
0.0306618586,
-0.3391326666,
-0.4617019892,
0.2241979092,
-0.0658931062,
0.4226683676,
-0.1083631888,
-0.1302649826,
-0.3768225312,
0.5226302147,
0.0375550762,
0.6648778915,
0.4825404286,
0.7512072921,
0.9699094892,
-0.064599745,
0.9551296234,
-0.3629852533,
-0.0612661391,
1.1959533691,
-0.3232914209,
0.5181670189,
0.6492363811,
0.1283495128,
0.5467213988,
0.6625350714,
0.175637126,
0.147563234,
0.0913993716,
-0.64506042,
-0.3290215731,
-0.3242858946,
-0.5243727565,
0.4707226455,
0.5443823934,
-0.5629193783,
-0.0561790578,
0.0482035242,
0.1141871884,
0.162238881,
-0.2838224471,
1.0789783001,
0.3019068539,
-0.6523652077,
0.4929112494,
-0.2764118612,
0.362256974,
-0.7513428926,
-0.0725168362,
0.0406390876,
-0.0593703836,
-0.4953721166,
-0.5432539582,
0.2066491246,
-0.0683507174,
-0.2520096302,
-0.1907937378,
0.7924730182,
-0.6189821959,
-0.4068239629,
-0.0334005021,
0.6893875003,
0.4529897571,
0.1785842329,
-0.9689336419,
-0.186228171,
0.0822491422,
-0.1204832718,
0.1387677342,
0.3945858181,
0.1235782728,
0.625333488,
0.7110772133,
0.1571581364,
0.0274726152,
0.3023462296,
0.6682121754,
-0.4279636443,
-0.4529033899,
-0.3612292409,
0.6644666195,
-0.1899936199,
-0.3284442127,
0.3579470515,
0.6781325936,
0.577942729,
-0.1062803641,
1.0136002302,
-0.272729218,
0.7223460078,
-0.3692151904,
0.9539898634,
-0.3982079029,
0.1843339056,
0.0219884217,
-0.2718162835,
-0.2537276149,
0.7058480382,
-0.0440656617,
-0.0094317086,
0.5230960846,
0.3769569397,
-0.1312094778,
0.0320675857,
0.3356169164,
0.135957554,
0.3166558444,
0.5216206312,
0.3411655128,
-0.500095427,
0.2173392177,
-0.4521695673,
-0.1626421362,
-0.3804625571,
-0.8683292866,
-0.9004234076,
-0.5909942985,
-0.708368659,
-0.386610806,
0.0701778829,
1.0284708738,
0.8730441928,
-0.6460264325,
0.0178197976,
-0.2544153035,
-0.1732390225,
-0.2137739658,
-0.1878462285,
0.5199747682,
-0.1947302371,
-0.3530948162,
0.4699370861,
0.1455840915,
0.0028577233,
-0.2993957996,
-0.2423314005,
0.0146565419,
0.11157424,
0.5388014913,
0.3752178252,
-0.4603647292,
0.1902402341,
0.0790307,
-0.3608971238,
0.0599623695,
0.8541852236,
-0.8863736987,
0.7331726551,
0.1478235573,
0.6441671252,
0.0315688923,
0.2737172246,
0.5572417378,
-0.6554788351,
-0.0621630736,
0.6657916903,
0.1187871546,
0.6019266248,
-0.7607780695,
0.6285462379,
0.0512035005,
-0.5085197091,
-0.6960605979,
0.3208330572,
-1.2183076143,
-0.2888368368,
1.0660495758,
-0.0258725956,
-0.0664748326,
-0.4688790143,
-0.1415580213,
0.4348622262,
-0.0428489745,
1.0138998032,
0.0489057265,
-0.2977444828,
0.0645652041,
-0.9669315815,
0.9326543212,
0.5929519534,
-1.3496552706,
0.0723078847,
0.567350924,
0.1431980282,
0.0213776939,
0.409111619,
-0.0678509846,
0.559055686,
-0.4054964483,
0.4523844719,
-0.1606815606,
-0.1837039888,
-0.2823643982,
0.1107502654,
-0.2167272717,
-0.1410075724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15550v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15550v1
|
Multi-level biomedical NER through multi-granularity embeddings and enhanced labeling
| 2023-12-24T21:45:36 | 2023-12-24T21:45:36 |
Fahime Shahrokh, Nasser Ghadiri, Rasoul Samani, Milad Moradi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T50, 68T07, J.3; I.2.7; I.2.1
|
Biomedical Named Entity Recognition (NER) is a fundamental task of Biomedical
Natural Language Processing for extracting relevant information from biomedical
texts, such as clinical records, scientific publications, and electronic health
records. The conventional approaches for biomedical NER mainly use traditional
machine learning techniques, such as Conditional Random Fields and Support
Vector Machines or deep learning-based models like Recurrent Neural Networks
and Convolutional Neural Networks. Recently, Transformer-based models,
including BERT, have been used in the domain of biomedical NER and have
demonstrated remarkable results. However, these models are often based on
word-level embeddings, limiting their ability to capture character-level
information, which is effective in biomedical NER due to the high variability
and complexity of biomedical texts. To address these limitations, this paper
proposes a hybrid approach that integrates the strengths of multiple models. In
this paper, we proposed an approach that leverages fine-tuned BERT to provide
contextualized word embeddings, a pre-trained multi-channel CNN for
character-level information capture, and following by a BiLSTM + CRF for
sequence labelling and modelling dependencies between the words in the text. In
addition, also we propose an enhanced labelling method as part of
pre-processing to enhance the identification of the entity's beginning word and
thus improve the identification of multi-word entities, a common challenge in
biomedical NER. By integrating these models and the pre-processing method, our
proposed model effectively captures both contextual information and detailed
character-level information. We evaluated our model on the benchmark i2b2/2010
dataset, achieving an F1-score of 90.11. These results illustrate the
proficiency of our proposed model in performing biomedical Named Entity
Recognition.
|
[
-0.3633099496,
-1.0591255426,
0.4316839278,
0.0044312319,
-0.3377260864,
0.1885498911,
-0.0558848307,
-0.8112622499,
0.372405529,
0.3689386249,
-0.1602836102,
-0.5726953745,
-0.7368986011,
0.2530471683,
-0.1525445729,
1.314537406,
0.215002954,
0.3939343393,
-0.2625877857,
-0.1913812608,
-0.3220295906,
-0.6986172795,
-0.6391394138,
-0.5082978606,
0.8363750577,
-0.0539299957,
0.3284297287,
0.3595750928,
0.7097293735,
0.2491993606,
-0.4305507839,
0.3550132513,
-0.2328086793,
0.0944307446,
-0.1526649892,
0.0353951417,
-0.682728529,
-0.3605696261,
0.7254748344,
0.7529051304,
0.1014782116,
-0.2499150634,
0.005134406,
0.2390227169,
-0.2008922696,
0.1473850906,
-0.3749536574,
0.0156462435,
-0.1171026304,
-0.2160118371,
-0.3547437489,
-0.0932967812,
0.5146352649,
-0.5981110334,
0.1353819966,
-0.1449866891,
1.1054575443,
0.0180799942,
-0.5734164119,
-0.303945303,
-0.6104175448,
0.6130545735,
-0.7923435569,
0.5604762435,
0.1412430555,
-0.0131257465,
0.0398152731,
-0.8616319299,
-0.384322226,
-0.2528600395,
-0.2634859979,
0.1750187129,
-0.1541491747,
0.2595945001,
0.1060453728,
0.2002604604,
-0.2927867472,
0.0672312975,
-0.3477944136,
-0.398239702,
0.3007127941,
0.0610556416,
0.2948281169,
-0.2080925852,
-0.499861449,
-0.0167865194,
-0.3265278637,
-0.086590603,
-0.1246054322,
0.4744027257,
0.1065077707,
0.5311568975,
0.0017841399,
0.5250799656,
0.4005134106,
-0.3218529224,
0.6997225285,
-0.6005681753,
0.0196395274,
0.1273662448,
0.7023572326,
-0.0779959187,
-0.2837714851,
-0.3291532695,
-0.1552023143,
-0.3427018225,
0.2802119553,
-0.9369082451,
-0.0657830313,
0.3422475457,
-0.6188815236,
-0.0932739675,
-0.1309576035,
-0.7819159031,
-0.3586442769,
-0.2668372989,
0.7077593803,
-1.0487419367,
0.0294957887,
-0.0682447702,
-0.1485833377,
0.2439215183,
0.3216383457,
-0.4190764129,
0.0669528097,
0.3429968357,
0.861594975,
-0.0445355661,
0.0012397652,
-0.3545298874,
0.6139668226,
0.1580315381,
0.7190688252,
-0.7457855344,
-0.3536219895,
-0.2355825901,
0.0402694382,
-0.0254619848,
-0.2767344415,
0.3100537956,
-0.5741434097,
-0.0313585438,
-0.1173685044,
-0.7659992576,
-0.1535634845,
0.3437646031,
-0.7046483159,
0.8014201522,
-0.1910656989,
-0.9544164538,
0.4893912375,
-0.7043227553,
-0.7803168893,
0.3414179087,
-0.2655977011,
-0.6379323602,
0.0801885128,
0.4261137247,
0.5635147691,
0.0581490435,
0.5139498711,
-0.3606960475,
0.0701087415,
0.212592721,
-0.1047802046,
0.3062751889,
-0.0928794444,
-0.110273622,
0.189621672,
-0.8664792776,
0.0430615656,
-0.1736359745,
-0.4872024059,
-0.5902792215,
0.0641389266,
0.1783363968,
0.2597547174,
0.3894285858,
-0.7811504006,
0.2024971843,
-0.3405718803,
0.451702863,
0.2946958244,
0.1466484815,
0.4132376313,
-0.2192869782,
0.0555969328,
0.2459189147,
-0.1230098382,
-0.1345026195,
-0.5185246468,
-0.4628908634,
-0.7300158143,
0.7049475908,
0.6995025873,
-0.6185491085,
0.724245131,
-0.4057503641,
-0.3687972724,
-0.6778666973,
-0.3394908607,
0.4538191855,
0.7530328035,
0.917530179,
-0.2332746387,
-0.4582077563,
-1.0967478752,
0.0001999335,
0.1553321034,
-0.0544967242,
0.6371933222,
0.5801129341,
-0.7255198359,
0.790819943,
-0.3279079795,
-0.4931864738,
-0.4478143752,
0.4184892178,
0.1716942936,
0.6629456878,
0.0432518087,
-0.8243975639,
-0.128709197,
0.3480486274,
-0.5949184299,
0.0541536584,
-0.1432620585,
-0.1168895066,
-0.3029512763,
0.4328215718,
-0.3066903055,
0.4372501373,
0.2355565131,
-0.1340241432,
0.2019894123,
-0.6635098457,
0.0802962705,
-1.2710659504,
0.2709412277,
0.103071034,
-0.2402556241,
-0.8746045828,
-0.1657033861,
0.1292753816,
-0.0274759028,
-0.1642955244,
0.6484749317,
-0.6307122111,
0.2624178827,
-0.1794732064,
-0.2489655167,
0.3235799074,
0.1056998745,
0.4181308746,
0.3049322367,
0.4284475148,
-0.6639463305,
-0.1316739917,
0.51479882,
-0.0128500387,
0.5135877728,
-0.9951531887,
0.1145529971,
-0.4429913759,
0.5834225416,
-0.5751536489,
-0.2906761467,
-0.0055594193,
-0.3943454921,
0.7449245453,
0.058438234,
-0.5417481661,
-0.290487051,
0.0218400471,
0.5023462772,
0.12414556,
-0.2180153131,
0.8788479567,
0.6509309411,
-0.3062565029,
-0.4181808531,
-0.9567666054,
0.0087413639,
0.1138139367,
-0.6397798657,
1.0632343292,
0.0447576903,
0.4314911067,
0.0580062754,
0.0976469591,
-0.4023612738,
-0.403796494,
0.0586215816,
0.2295795381,
-0.1733289212,
0.4262610674,
0.3442251086,
-0.0868546143,
-0.4112953842,
-0.0880746916,
0.4693812728,
-0.2083503008,
-0.2346266508,
-0.4620841742,
0.7589307427,
0.3670201004,
-0.4091903567,
0.8963855505,
1.0021365881,
-0.8488288522,
0.2701839209,
-0.5833888054,
-0.2692202032,
-0.344938457,
0.7367162108,
-0.3969043195,
-0.9095652699,
0.5718300343,
-0.2204096913,
-0.2562120259,
0.3824635744,
0.5851024985,
-0.2875867486,
0.9364118576,
0.6799438596,
0.1397218108,
0.3589169979,
-0.1846748441,
0.4325742424,
-1.1151269674,
-0.7248972654,
-0.2647985518,
-0.4410251379,
-0.3659372926,
-0.608935535,
0.6126132607,
0.2598587573,
0.0564621128,
0.256242305,
-0.5156950951,
0.2100296021,
0.4999729097,
0.6199305058,
0.0815319195,
-0.042521093,
-0.3861956596,
0.017053511,
-0.6182219386,
-0.4811432064,
0.734429419,
0.5096842647,
0.6525344849,
-0.0232120287,
0.795176208,
0.0801435784,
0.2176760584,
-0.7232455015,
0.2914482653,
-0.3282572925,
-0.7726094127,
-0.2217488587,
-0.3424001336,
-1.0995453596,
0.2280290425,
-0.5679934621,
-0.7069275975,
0.5349558592,
0.0095374454,
-0.5966283679,
0.2284252048,
-0.3364034593,
0.6822695732,
-0.2282529771,
-0.1046059653,
-0.0310272872,
-0.8491540551,
0.0380339511,
-0.1383823007,
0.2443091124,
0.0755361915,
-0.1945377737,
0.5959700942,
-0.2236369103,
0.8297311068,
0.0866708532,
0.1501624733,
0.0103667239,
-0.3407650888,
0.4142587781,
0.2616880834,
-0.0024925659,
0.5251979232,
0.0921575576,
-0.3833178878,
-0.0389996618,
0.4772921801,
-0.5703412294,
0.0326454788,
-0.4237562716,
-0.5835359097,
-0.2888329625,
0.4063085616,
0.5598552227,
0.7141020298,
-0.1318886727,
0.3370494843,
0.8996701241,
-0.6663503647,
0.2982216775,
0.2691732347,
0.0881022215,
-0.8243141174,
0.9380144477,
0.1097955033,
0.0535248406,
0.8061864376,
0.1273276061,
-0.3221559525,
-0.7028580904,
-0.3271361887,
0.2609885335,
-0.380178988,
-0.3724170625,
-1.137165904,
-0.3877255619,
-0.4540553391,
-0.1110982671,
-0.1689183265,
0.0823504031,
-0.4758680165,
0.1223171577,
0.1437479258,
0.6201008558,
-0.1640069336,
0.224819243,
-1.1416745186,
0.4668814838,
-0.0177640934,
0.2652299106,
-0.1157609075,
-0.3782485127,
-0.2156247795,
-0.0622754581,
-0.0947865695,
-1.0932968855,
0.4180059135,
0.4875437319,
0.7974994183,
0.2595664859,
-0.3553984165,
0.8217149377,
-0.76552248,
0.454408437,
0.287707895,
-0.8111662865,
0.7037364841,
-0.1980339289,
0.1848545521,
0.590616703,
0.4714131951,
-0.2752198279,
-0.2097704262,
-0.4550126493,
-1.1561697721,
0.3923155665,
0.0625939816,
0.0951995626,
-0.3252445459,
0.1918533146,
0.3033584058,
0.1356406361,
-0.7856709957,
-0.2674232423,
0.1306345761,
-0.2176575363,
0.1778316945,
-0.1665668637,
-0.0228838045,
-0.392374754,
0.5410705209,
-0.151465565,
0.5472214222,
0.5746126771,
-0.3969372511,
0.4230058491,
0.3476154506,
0.3059317768,
0.1303980947,
-0.142981872,
-0.0643957257,
0.2531324327,
-0.4697932601,
-0.1085330024,
0.5325011611,
-0.2286224514,
0.1267451495,
0.4838194549,
0.6796088815,
0.3556767106,
-0.5006399155,
0.4665749073,
0.1780835539,
-0.0176454186,
0.1588364094,
-0.4339579344,
0.1858520061,
0.3463757634,
0.2050163448,
0.0948503688,
0.4513021708,
-0.2842243314,
0.4688743651,
0.5530443788,
-0.546626091,
-0.2563770711,
0.4703390598,
0.1820128113,
0.0093978066,
0.4268454015,
-0.0449437536,
-0.3208363354,
0.4834396541,
0.7706858516,
0.5171299577,
-0.1552159786,
0.2439505607,
0.4400462508,
0.0524857976,
0.1378404498,
0.3962755203,
0.1499177814,
-0.6632088423,
-0.565371871,
-0.7809661627,
-0.1901188344,
0.155150488,
-0.7146342993,
0.2111727148,
-0.3658109903,
-0.5304617882,
0.4222995937,
-0.2650104761,
-0.8057642579,
0.3359189332,
0.4577604532,
0.6082308888,
-0.502794683,
0.8720857501,
0.8540478349,
-0.6082405448,
-0.4644912779,
-0.1291042864,
-0.3304851949,
-0.4583120048,
0.643247962,
0.3445993364,
0.2092810124,
-0.0534480251,
-0.2542090118,
-1.0887254477,
1.0293643475,
0.0054575242,
-0.7577683926,
-0.3415487111,
-0.0283388607,
0.6427069902,
-0.4424943328,
0.4222658277,
0.3049786985,
0.4420089424,
0.0766073242,
-0.9233317971,
-0.039081201,
-0.2312703282,
0.0297143199,
0.2873544991,
-0.3206724524,
0.807634294,
-0.3747876585,
0.03604725,
0.1045595407,
0.6574556828,
0.3365285993,
0.3704492748,
0.2200660706,
0.6592390537,
1.0514278412,
-0.0052793068,
0.9705808163,
-0.2808291018,
0.3630530238,
0.937112689,
-0.1215295345,
0.8104880452,
0.3131161332,
-0.0745086446,
0.7307343483,
0.5478445292,
-0.0245077796,
0.5943282247,
0.2350460291,
-0.3451085985,
-0.2003935724,
-0.3734506965,
-0.6426706314,
0.2340144664,
0.7267342806,
-0.636993587,
-0.1236775294,
0.2696730494,
-0.1790094376,
-0.4579973221,
-0.3314504027,
1.0270286798,
0.0844424292,
0.1031185761,
0.0330210961,
-0.0669250414,
0.8612335324,
-0.6210510135,
-0.0863151923,
0.1768259853,
0.1764750332,
-0.0883897021,
-0.4758351743,
0.0799184963,
-0.1839966327,
-0.456890285,
-0.0198360346,
0.9466893673,
-0.6966016889,
-0.8903403282,
0.5228399634,
0.5477263331,
0.0448352471,
0.1323023736,
-0.7549943924,
-0.2290849984,
-0.3396318257,
-0.1155701205,
0.3157081604,
0.5863397121,
0.0612314008,
0.4022993445,
0.6131961346,
0.2786217034,
0.0371221229,
0.2312805802,
0.8523176908,
-0.7782557011,
-0.4036062658,
-0.7184634805,
0.513620317,
-0.3304983079,
-0.365906477,
0.1405793875,
0.5125743747,
0.5554426312,
-0.0333451293,
0.7565202117,
-0.1399024129,
0.5459443927,
-0.2751913667,
0.6324387193,
-0.5695015788,
-0.0680945441,
-0.4529545605,
-0.61090976,
-0.5937663317,
0.5778291821,
-0.1649801135,
0.1670096368,
0.7206794024,
0.4877244532,
-0.0864560977,
-0.1213363335,
0.2500196695,
0.2007553428,
0.2616122067,
0.5546806455,
0.4735820293,
-0.2127882689,
0.3587555289,
-0.2782371044,
-0.2777822912,
-0.2635073066,
-0.9384247065,
-0.8427636027,
-0.3648479879,
-0.408772856,
-0.4312238693,
0.0260703117,
0.7862302065,
0.9227386117,
-1.0317276716,
0.5448040962,
0.1169517189,
-0.3405432403,
-0.1491008401,
-0.1684993505,
0.4684564471,
-0.4129748344,
-0.5994082689,
0.4347768724,
0.4793592989,
0.2005218416,
0.0234893765,
0.131762445,
-0.4381124377,
0.1453865469,
0.7807651162,
0.1064996943,
-0.8043304682,
-0.1604861468,
-0.0170936454,
-0.3916055262,
0.0649505407,
0.6070491076,
-0.8280337453,
0.4572280049,
0.4793842435,
1.0957567692,
0.4319812357,
0.0248657465,
0.4306964278,
-0.5992276073,
-0.2141221464,
0.6281722784,
0.3760997355,
0.4484222233,
-0.4920681715,
0.1753892004,
0.066597946,
-0.509724915,
-0.5214350224,
0.0296568424,
-1.076715827,
-0.2388216108,
1.0211048126,
-0.0655290037,
0.1511820853,
-0.198315531,
-0.2000887841,
0.4664569795,
-0.4671833515,
0.5000582933,
0.6227760315,
-0.4496823549,
0.2447417378,
-0.3805651665,
0.0547122136,
0.3071911931,
-0.8669556379,
-0.5992307067,
0.3713929057,
0.2215014398,
0.3260725737,
0.519489646,
-0.2965450883,
-0.1283675134,
-0.1477063,
0.1995003372,
-0.0262982752,
-0.4111056328,
-0.2661528885,
0.2183775753,
-0.5137143731,
-0.0949488059
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15548v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15548v3
|
YAYI-UIE: A Chat-Enhanced Instruction Tuning Framework for Universal Information Extraction
| 2023-12-24T21:33:03 | 2024-04-02T09:36:35 |
Xinglin Xiao, Yijie Wang, Nan Xu, Yuqi Wang, Hanxuan Yang, Minzheng Wang, Yin Luo, Lei Wang, Wenji Mao, Daniel Zeng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The difficulty of the information extraction task lies in dealing with the
task-specific label schemas and heterogeneous data structures. Recent work has
proposed methods based on large language models to uniformly model different
information extraction tasks. However, these existing methods are deficient in
their information extraction capabilities for Chinese languages other than
English. In this paper, we propose an end-to-end chat-enhanced instruction
tuning framework for universal information extraction (YAYI-UIE), which
supports both Chinese and English. Specifically, we utilize dialogue data and
information extraction data to enhance the information extraction performance
jointly. Experimental results show that our proposed framework achieves
state-of-the-art performance on Chinese datasets while also achieving
comparable performance on English datasets under both supervised settings and
zero-shot settings.
|
[
-0.1042082831,
-0.8493315578,
-0.0718494207,
0.0330665782,
-0.3701298535,
-0.120512709,
-0.4833931923,
-0.5764378309,
0.0873489678,
0.4040576518,
-0.5155716538,
-0.5415880084,
-0.5029855371,
-0.2055468112,
-0.1314169914,
0.983635366,
0.6002549529,
0.0957439318,
0.2665154636,
0.0241472125,
-0.4994166493,
-0.1941322535,
-0.5526320934,
0.1800513268,
0.3620023727,
0.6928109527,
0.5447678566,
1.1247454882,
0.3135929406,
0.2958389521,
0.2384848744,
0.4392644763,
-0.477060765,
0.407102555,
-0.0414972156,
-0.5028756857,
-0.278321296,
-0.0400699005,
0.4691881537,
0.3733555675,
-0.1621384621,
0.35385409,
-0.0610675663,
0.4819067121,
-0.925447166,
0.4636971653,
-0.8086192608,
-0.0670946687,
-0.1407201141,
-0.537795186,
-0.5047534704,
-0.3555721641,
0.1420998573,
-0.8341041207,
-0.0043805707,
0.0917466059,
1.2314107418,
0.2285638601,
-0.2037042528,
-0.2573748231,
-0.4425466359,
0.7801803946,
-0.9161624908,
0.2741658092,
0.0598188974,
0.1712133437,
-0.3196718693,
-0.7006500363,
-0.3971728981,
0.0439230464,
-0.0891875699,
0.3385843635,
-0.0820931643,
0.3607578576,
0.3283366561,
0.2632381022,
-0.222899735,
0.3768248558,
-0.3954393864,
-0.1856988072,
0.5530646443,
-0.1069331095,
0.7878488302,
-0.2159044445,
-0.3140413761,
-0.0237077456,
-0.5584257245,
0.2885870934,
0.1789991558,
0.5616810322,
-0.0199334752,
0.2443269193,
-0.2508558333,
0.6915867329,
0.0034300836,
-0.2168039978,
-0.0176245272,
0.0035990975,
-0.3497396111,
0.0600368269,
1.048845768,
0.5459529161,
0.2275378108,
-0.5099321604,
0.0956649184,
-0.3276894093,
-0.0932660997,
-0.8963603973,
-0.1115433648,
0.0452674702,
-0.370550096,
-0.0360604599,
0.6492103934,
-0.9654200673,
-0.2110119015,
-0.2826895714,
0.4053446651,
-0.344098866,
-0.5074627995,
-0.0393711329,
-0.4410993159,
0.5419890881,
0.1589980721,
-0.9763179421,
0.024633389,
0.6911762953,
0.5709113479,
-0.3941981196,
-0.0017405159,
-0.9233475327,
0.2238077074,
-0.3750729263,
0.6718211174,
-0.7848038673,
-0.1534386873,
-0.0328560695,
0.2314008623,
-0.3676675558,
-0.5116294026,
0.4589386284,
-0.3875264227,
0.5416551232,
-0.1156782657,
-0.6653195024,
-0.2303554565,
-0.2188089341,
-0.6282147169,
1.2109377384,
0.159866035,
-0.6100934148,
0.0907779709,
-0.7664313912,
-0.6209074855,
0.3717187345,
-0.512365818,
-0.1792745888,
0.0759617016,
0.2867057621,
0.3461070955,
-0.6353542209,
0.3147880435,
0.0020440922,
-0.7786407471,
-0.1534752697,
-0.9323031306,
1.0821194649,
0.1679568589,
-0.4769563675,
-0.1885763258,
-0.9769800305,
0.580632627,
-0.1190579981,
-0.4188774824,
-0.3586220741,
-0.039044641,
-0.1139916331,
0.0917060748,
0.5243086219,
-0.7886676192,
0.429923594,
-0.414873004,
0.3505246937,
0.7508363724,
-0.0688797012,
0.2981432676,
0.0879051909,
0.3638311625,
0.0400697254,
0.1030073464,
-0.5673674941,
-0.3289119899,
-0.7792542577,
-0.4856007695,
0.3953161538,
1.0760221481,
-0.7004939318,
0.7285466194,
-0.2663069069,
-0.0390142277,
-0.85368222,
0.1470019817,
0.5343033671,
0.6500415802,
0.2998140454,
-0.252050221,
-0.4857975543,
-0.8373974562,
-0.0913811848,
-0.2324286699,
-0.2639551163,
0.3776302636,
-0.3335479498,
0.2389005274,
0.9563497305,
-0.3553693295,
-0.1394360214,
-0.2036428154,
0.3157584965,
0.3563399613,
0.2489683926,
0.1930790842,
-1.0014262199,
-0.7295342684,
0.6170662642,
-0.8607516289,
-0.2433286011,
-0.1537306607,
-0.3725409806,
0.2068819553,
0.4223698974,
-0.3999813199,
0.6312844753,
0.2241908461,
-0.0002823564,
0.5351247191,
-0.2580558956,
0.4514293075,
-1.3145703077,
-0.0911207497,
0.1570358276,
-0.0582243837,
-0.6118407249,
0.0751849562,
0.3223479688,
0.1772767007,
-0.2195288688,
0.348861903,
-0.5967121124,
0.0737848803,
-0.315115571,
0.3955979347,
0.1622935534,
0.6877545118,
0.1060084179,
0.8463451862,
0.848428309,
-0.6492466927,
0.5284593105,
-0.0975918919,
-0.2441741973,
0.5031812191,
-0.5564566255,
0.2254898101,
-0.1507599354,
-0.3839529753,
-0.9345362782,
-0.3155600727,
0.3465822339,
-0.5451391339,
0.686894536,
-0.2180192173,
-0.2009339631,
-0.0045742649,
-0.3653332293,
-0.4449279606,
0.3533409834,
-0.802028954,
0.407320708,
0.3726789057,
-0.3903592229,
-0.9173226953,
-0.263607204,
-0.0184196476,
-0.2896047235,
-0.5098721981,
0.2915316224,
-0.1360165179,
-0.0232735053,
-0.2406934798,
-0.2601882517,
-0.588539362,
0.0963565633,
0.099089317,
0.7319482565,
-0.5665732026,
0.3152021766,
0.2649484575,
-0.0206353404,
-0.2513777912,
-0.0775250569,
0.147775203,
0.186730206,
-0.1379814744,
-0.7568594217,
0.5245133042,
0.2370986342,
-0.31678316,
0.7332183719,
0.8425115347,
-0.1116188988,
-0.0087784855,
-0.5005427003,
-0.1171893328,
-0.4780376256,
0.882861793,
-0.2710207403,
-0.583900094,
0.0786035582,
-0.2391140312,
0.7611277103,
0.1898496896,
0.1073303223,
-0.2975112498,
1.1547361612,
0.8645454049,
-0.6069475412,
0.7353175879,
0.0795942321,
0.2098989785,
-0.6619511247,
-0.0370269939,
-0.7294095159,
0.035499081,
-0.5094056726,
0.0740249828,
0.3351451457,
0.4012631476,
0.0108279958,
0.4205358326,
-0.5917434096,
0.5954796672,
0.4787250161,
-0.0583452806,
0.1938638836,
0.2146126926,
0.4218086004,
-0.0749371499,
-0.7171570659,
-0.3011570573,
0.7200604677,
-0.1290955245,
0.5094738603,
-0.1076970771,
0.4619837403,
0.3302800655,
-0.0421162136,
-0.5766421556,
0.3454270363,
-0.3883476555,
-0.4132742286,
-0.6035118699,
-0.592820406,
-0.9496849775,
0.4412711859,
-0.1139399484,
-1.4660491943,
-0.0378356725,
-0.1757779419,
-0.1935496479,
0.1527768075,
-1.0601748228,
0.7134106159,
-0.1497173756,
-0.2741169631,
0.1064450741,
-0.7690505981,
0.2008764595,
0.2233604193,
0.3641926646,
-0.2115284055,
0.0825891569,
0.609836936,
0.0123430658,
0.6587209105,
-0.1675734371,
-0.2262306213,
0.2740395963,
-0.3166916668,
0.3450255692,
0.1323326677,
-0.2523493171,
0.1389778107,
0.3189320266,
-0.1984267384,
-0.8846192956,
0.35585168,
-0.8388789296,
-0.663575232,
0.140813604,
-0.5960355401,
-0.0767549574,
0.1853820086,
0.5165976286,
0.6913111806,
-0.031732019,
0.3538645506,
0.6904482841,
-0.2370810062,
0.5312544107,
0.8440895677,
0.1480164528,
-0.0461675972,
1.4156076908,
0.0787079707,
0.250864923,
0.5950465798,
0.1373703033,
-0.1368696541,
0.0509998649,
-0.7196807265,
-0.1180614755,
-0.5571064353,
-0.2535707057,
-0.3731228411,
-0.7751735449,
-0.525169909,
0.4179988503,
-0.4051791131,
-0.4353797138,
-0.435716182,
0.1439893991,
0.1619088352,
0.2924817801,
-0.1325233132,
0.4548209906,
-0.9499307275,
0.7193831801,
0.0152902352,
0.0474828742,
-0.3414438367,
-0.7090861797,
-0.507460773,
0.2826573849,
-0.3585504293,
-0.7495661974,
0.0655934438,
0.7776583433,
0.9072098136,
0.6819594502,
0.3184748292,
0.9180088043,
-0.1928763986,
0.6632120609,
0.147408247,
-0.6318157911,
0.5082424283,
0.0772895366,
0.2058017403,
0.3165106177,
0.3364850879,
-0.6744514108,
-0.2739652395,
-0.3785302341,
-0.8205081224,
1.026876688,
-0.0439762175,
0.1415853798,
0.001359075,
0.4990207553,
0.4646899998,
0.0211755875,
-0.7099910975,
-0.4825752676,
0.2008832842,
-0.3449178338,
0.5222304463,
-0.0515701547,
0.3670727313,
-0.1861444563,
0.7331437469,
-0.1680257022,
0.129869625,
-0.000271227,
-0.1398143917,
-0.1867485642,
0.5520069003,
-0.2837207019,
0.427069813,
-0.1160694063,
-0.497946173,
-0.1716123372,
-0.5708941221,
-0.2558581829,
0.2833484709,
-0.3048840761,
-0.139639318,
0.4258638322,
0.8491534591,
0.1758641899,
-0.6185591221,
0.3679225743,
-0.4648456872,
0.1234195232,
0.1804423034,
0.8217253089,
-0.2216056585,
0.1997840405,
0.542275548,
-0.4114251733,
0.2385566831,
-0.4903085232,
0.1826343387,
0.5455492735,
-0.4896791875,
-0.2238104045,
0.2019517869,
0.1754727662,
-0.4049834311,
0.8098104,
-0.0008729972,
-0.0637394339,
0.6915296316,
0.6331023574,
0.5408024788,
-0.3206013739,
0.4039975703,
0.5821915269,
0.1205517277,
0.194133535,
0.2725319862,
-0.5543357134,
-0.6549403667,
-0.4304010868,
-0.3552797437,
-0.251783967,
0.3159271777,
-1.2424167395,
0.3020764887,
0.0572724976,
0.1425070614,
-0.1007378772,
0.0256144721,
-0.3452940285,
0.2609125376,
0.0982616842,
0.5758351684,
-0.2690272033,
0.9521036744,
0.4339552224,
-0.0142639689,
-0.7785052657,
-0.1360935122,
-0.1624251306,
-0.6928441525,
0.1552246958,
0.3837922812,
-0.0919803157,
0.0797159672,
-0.8533229828,
-0.656031251,
1.106757164,
0.5801045299,
-0.7870044112,
-0.219898805,
0.079304792,
0.332590431,
-0.421050787,
0.710437417,
0.9182277918,
0.1593468934,
0.1336238086,
-0.7760627866,
-0.4625186324,
-0.5494524837,
-0.3202293515,
-0.0596319027,
-0.684294641,
0.501940906,
-0.1891743094,
-0.6736165285,
0.1078265458,
0.6911622882,
-0.1920011193,
-0.0378635861,
0.3882168233,
-0.0569387786,
0.9859306216,
0.0376524404,
0.4570661187,
-0.5194992423,
-0.1292938739,
1.3258486986,
-0.0938515216,
0.7251823545,
0.1246050075,
0.1041560993,
0.4167715311,
0.4569058716,
0.29260993,
0.4936374128,
-0.3200265765,
-0.0987153128,
-0.1721847504,
-0.3648397923,
-0.4229644835,
0.7354806662,
0.7251425982,
-0.0445115976,
-0.2120817006,
-0.4000340104,
-0.0182238258,
-0.1916929632,
-0.1603496224,
1.0860577822,
-0.131840229,
-0.740491569,
0.5335898995,
0.0146135995,
0.6133618355,
-0.7921330333,
-0.4050704539,
-0.2391669899,
-0.2475457639,
-0.0449216031,
-0.4274592698,
-0.1503190696,
0.0739306286,
-0.0557272024,
0.2144242972,
0.8741236925,
-0.650734663,
-0.2183566689,
0.259994626,
0.3509207368,
0.3015831113,
0.0622906797,
-0.7575619817,
-0.0644789711,
0.4781803191,
-0.3783934116,
0.437189132,
0.8300263286,
0.2070673853,
0.3947862983,
0.5789071321,
0.3051357269,
0.2973162532,
0.0875140056,
0.7332696319,
-0.7261433005,
-0.5767149329,
-0.8001329899,
0.5298582315,
-0.5361714363,
-0.381606102,
0.4675427079,
0.4634624124,
0.4756747782,
0.4593221247,
1.1092687845,
-0.3021914661,
0.500225842,
-0.3992893994,
0.4540730715,
-0.5660204291,
0.2841801643,
-0.285705179,
-0.9037106633,
0.2638723254,
0.5101801157,
0.2539224327,
-0.3880758584,
0.2557775378,
0.9024710059,
0.1002160683,
0.5005936623,
0.6366428733,
0.0864107385,
0.3431453705,
0.7570918798,
0.445017308,
-0.5387803316,
0.6209813952,
-0.1233340129,
-0.5940349102,
0.1860900521,
-0.7334737182,
-0.9488790035,
-0.6116541624,
-0.1339541376,
0.1819310188,
0.1442323476,
0.854562223,
0.8355637193,
-0.6055520773,
-0.1109301001,
0.3120567501,
0.060450051,
-0.142342478,
-0.3257504702,
0.5787454247,
-0.5710713267,
-0.8609374166,
0.5172908902,
0.6719525456,
-0.4175586104,
0.0763891414,
0.0566867888,
0.0709325746,
0.0069542141,
0.258608222,
0.6503333449,
-0.441968739,
-0.2046079487,
-0.035751678,
-0.1955838501,
0.4630110264,
0.4509783387,
-0.4523608983,
0.7072613835,
0.0650140569,
0.601583004,
0.1108818054,
0.1616998762,
0.6921057701,
-0.8290908337,
0.3541878462,
-0.3976383507,
0.0408971794,
0.1340028346,
-0.7206662297,
0.2747782469,
-0.0725070462,
-0.3419549763,
-0.4810614586,
-0.0110416124,
-0.584918201,
-0.184055537,
0.9659916759,
-0.6006847024,
-0.4398673773,
-0.2672274709,
-0.5842400193,
0.7164039016,
-0.5195094347,
0.988936305,
0.6481983066,
-0.0512166806,
-0.217491731,
-0.6301819086,
0.1503111273,
0.1286052316,
-1.0679469109,
0.2280215025,
0.3456813693,
0.0183721613,
-0.0189402029,
0.5985720158,
-0.018731812,
0.636618495,
-0.1919407845,
-0.0795021355,
-0.0898788795,
-0.4468439221,
0.1725587845,
-0.0304736849,
-0.2779438198,
-0.426816076
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15523v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15523v1
|
The Persuasive Power of Large Language Models
| 2023-12-24T16:21:11 | 2023-12-24T16:21:11 |
Simon Martin Breum, Daniel Vædele Egdal, Victor Gram Mortensen, Anders Giovanni Møller, Luca Maria Aiello
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.HC, physics.soc-ph
|
The increasing capability of Large Language Models to act as human-like
social agents raises two important questions in the area of opinion dynamics.
First, whether these agents can generate effective arguments that could be
injected into the online discourse to steer the public opinion. Second, whether
artificial agents can interact with each other to reproduce dynamics of
persuasion typical of human social systems, opening up opportunities for
studying synthetic social systems as faithful proxies for opinion dynamics in
human populations. To address these questions, we designed a synthetic
persuasion dialogue scenario on the topic of climate change, where a
'convincer' agent generates a persuasive argument for a 'skeptic' agent, who
subsequently assesses whether the argument changed its internal opinion state.
Different types of arguments were generated to incorporate different linguistic
dimensions underpinning psycho-linguistic theories of opinion change. We then
asked human judges to evaluate the persuasiveness of machine-generated
arguments. Arguments that included factual knowledge, markers of trust,
expressions of support, and conveyed status were deemed most effective
according to both humans and agents, with humans reporting a marked preference
for knowledge-based arguments. Our experimental framework lays the groundwork
for future in-silico studies of opinion dynamics, and our findings suggest that
artificial agents have the potential of playing an important role in collective
processes of opinion formation in online social media.
|
[
-0.4779650867,
-0.8341610432,
0.7679710984,
0.0070778802,
-0.2012514472,
0.3501341641,
-0.4219015837,
-0.3626847565,
0.3116398752,
0.2504594922,
-0.3144804835,
-0.2112002671,
-0.40280056,
0.3838810325,
-0.5268955231,
0.8046256304,
0.2965782881,
0.2065190524,
-0.1341884136,
0.0868914947,
-0.0582272112,
-0.8719413877,
-0.5790522099,
-0.6175029874,
0.8510501981,
0.164623782,
1.1383894682,
0.1000783294,
-0.153662771,
0.4506342709,
-0.1836934835,
0.0976970047,
-0.5391154885,
0.2439183444,
-0.63070786,
-0.4770551324,
-0.1017643139,
0.3647038937,
0.5792931318,
0.3639765978,
-0.0276186019,
-0.1141044423,
0.015034508,
0.2757636011,
-0.0783053935,
0.1746117175,
-0.9533085227,
-0.1933877021,
0.0861461982,
-0.3693110049,
-0.1836784035,
-0.5019244552,
0.296209991,
-0.5086665154,
0.2138687521,
-0.1189704686,
0.8466952443,
0.0998410508,
-0.4616055489,
-0.1917806119,
-1.0140289068,
0.5012316704,
-0.7669733763,
0.2120562792,
0.1103327051,
0.117177479,
-0.3253578842,
-0.4660566747,
-1.120434761,
-0.387781173,
0.0477646664,
0.071764864,
-0.1066215038,
0.0236666966,
0.1617766768,
-0.2755222619,
-0.2233865112,
0.0059242737,
-0.2632830441,
-0.1300733089,
0.7823534012,
0.0420506448,
0.3565821052,
-0.1262454689,
0.0510483012,
-0.4090568423,
-0.6206034422,
0.0302186478,
0.7178664804,
0.3781833649,
-0.1410667002,
0.2980499268,
-0.1321950406,
0.3078928888,
0.4715106189,
-0.0150931524,
0.0151306372,
-0.0656799003,
-0.016093554,
0.2744217813,
0.8086731434,
0.5080181956,
0.1896974891,
0.0870369673,
-0.1097491458,
0.3983232081,
0.2627993226,
-0.6931937337,
-0.1962909997,
0.1970776021,
-0.3019812703,
-0.6698006988,
0.4290013909,
-0.9928756356,
-0.8380266428,
-0.455291003,
0.2930912077,
-0.0276538711,
-0.5285782218,
0.1472355276,
-0.2906627357,
0.1279635578,
0.6104926467,
-0.5926029086,
0.2167574763,
0.7853554487,
0.4982309937,
-0.0441628657,
-0.3059667051,
-0.0109815886,
-0.02993799,
-0.5902493,
0.9492958784,
-0.8517407179,
-0.4138141572,
0.0916164443,
0.2155255973,
0.117010802,
-0.4408236742,
0.0419614501,
-0.4822172225,
0.1893526763,
-0.3936155736,
-0.2814241052,
-0.0343060903,
0.3328304291,
-0.3379308283,
0.546009481,
-0.3131840229,
-0.3572131693,
0.3823011816,
-0.8536072969,
-0.3663015366,
0.0572059788,
-0.138614133,
-0.1063976511,
0.0118858721,
-0.1227404624,
0.1670412272,
-0.4408209026,
0.2832562327,
-0.3223388195,
0.1387469321,
0.8611370325,
-0.4256086349,
0.4837275147,
0.1152587682,
-0.5798560381,
0.2006809413,
-0.2573495507,
-0.246299684,
0.1621682793,
-0.2891867757,
-0.2284277231,
0.4242938161,
-0.2345597744,
0.0971864238,
0.0628119409,
-0.7201502919,
0.2427397668,
-0.4034488201,
0.7877506614,
0.9069067836,
0.3406668305,
0.403508991,
-0.3466742337,
0.5822985768,
-0.1277464628,
0.132825315,
0.1441663504,
-0.7538419962,
-0.5110405684,
0.2391754538,
0.0934957042,
0.2618855536,
-0.5748260021,
-0.1455711126,
-0.0588846467,
-0.6085581183,
-0.3962531388,
-0.0569199249,
0.0468636714,
0.0499373674,
0.0377613045,
0.2501876056,
-0.3292577267,
-0.6218262315,
-0.4717968702,
-0.6043780446,
0.0473148376,
0.1962958574,
0.4424085319,
-0.3130333722,
1.1065114737,
-0.1606592685,
0.486474216,
-0.2968343198,
0.3232895732,
0.0720864758,
0.2661028802,
0.4719522893,
-1.1191455126,
-0.3551622629,
0.1669448465,
-0.5526843071,
-0.1992225945,
-0.355658561,
0.0081270915,
0.3132174313,
0.1992712617,
-0.8286408186,
0.1855997145,
0.4877250493,
-0.3578001559,
0.6400390267,
-0.2801291943,
0.4608865678,
-0.9709064364,
-0.364836216,
0.1804978698,
-0.1038684472,
-0.8006203771,
-0.1255236268,
-0.5279961228,
-0.2408731729,
-0.6686914563,
0.7079534531,
-0.2551311553,
0.3853246868,
-0.3336962759,
0.0617653877,
-0.0594759472,
0.1556721032,
0.019613605,
0.47761482,
0.3424192369,
-0.578242898,
0.6393324733,
0.0988754854,
-0.1172792912,
0.5016103387,
-0.6643335223,
0.3903130889,
-0.3830522895,
0.5059592724,
-1.0107084513,
-0.5425982475,
0.1764924675,
-0.5371689796,
-0.1251590401,
-0.0879059806,
-0.5375614166,
-0.2570461333,
-0.1002001688,
-0.1261416227,
0.4083215296,
-0.3940776587,
0.8466162682,
0.6116058826,
-0.1881525069,
0.025579039,
-0.3894070387,
0.377741307,
-0.3673536181,
-0.5710263252,
0.1750097871,
-0.0492436849,
-0.9467667937,
-0.036436405,
0.1275442839,
0.2806633413,
0.0197192803,
0.4761405289,
0.0772634968,
-0.0400125347,
0.3786281645,
0.1338184029,
-0.030759979,
0.2085770071,
-0.2532979846,
0.6622638106,
-0.2109010965,
-0.0880704522,
-0.4948397279,
0.3285276294,
0.9957235456,
0.1875783056,
0.8081604838,
-0.040308997,
-0.2850803435,
-0.0799591318,
-0.6099783778,
-0.4345367253,
-0.5350025296,
0.1722209752,
-0.2402556986,
-0.794698298,
0.2475562841,
-0.2875322402,
0.1605903953,
0.423971653,
0.7963171005,
-0.2271746248,
1.3868956566,
0.0505886078,
-0.0104541574,
0.4530251622,
-0.1330178678,
0.2599594891,
-0.2018087655,
-0.0850511417,
-0.5629976988,
-0.2576721907,
-0.5767477155,
-0.3213450909,
0.3666240871,
-0.1920931935,
-0.3835734427,
0.2075454593,
-0.4613633454,
0.4156914949,
0.2712212205,
-0.0023837727,
-0.011108147,
0.0588674396,
-0.0773072317,
0.2511217892,
-0.5200616121,
-1.0007042885,
0.532961905,
0.238197431,
0.5379950404,
0.1212724522,
0.202056542,
0.7028938532,
0.5061153173,
-0.4976964593,
0.9346696138,
0.1193315238,
-0.5602117777,
-0.420860976,
-0.2809094787,
-1.0935592651,
0.3016023636,
-0.8127126694,
-0.6717378497,
0.2083596736,
0.2380934209,
-0.150011301,
0.5777835846,
-0.5517619848,
0.8280214071,
-0.3540810049,
-0.3932238817,
-0.7512801886,
-0.4607417285,
-0.2169973403,
-0.0930664614,
0.2351789922,
-0.1733628958,
0.2253780067,
0.5439477563,
-0.5621813536,
1.0363955498,
-0.2498035729,
-0.1670426577,
0.4038850069,
0.1325474381,
0.4729614258,
-0.0313982703,
-0.3922844231,
0.2655861676,
0.0478049405,
-0.1681419015,
-0.7284465432,
0.6867471337,
-1.1131994724,
-1.1266462803,
-0.2967171073,
-0.1831049621,
-0.1346768588,
-0.2123708874,
-0.0170026682,
0.3986438215,
-0.4109342992,
0.1386315227,
0.2749904096,
-0.4518251121,
0.2382417619,
0.4958565533,
-0.1708906293,
-0.4470736682,
1.0869057178,
0.105155535,
0.5739623308,
0.3029822111,
1.0339640379,
-0.2153799981,
-0.2405967116,
-0.3232274652,
0.2858057618,
-0.4792042077,
0.1653906256,
-0.619849205,
0.082216762,
-0.490996927,
-0.3010737896,
-0.1063545495,
-0.2726182044,
-0.1368420869,
-0.1711325645,
0.4072750807,
1.0201017857,
0.0105218654,
0.1699545681,
-0.6826525927,
-0.0175418314,
0.5279716253,
-0.2001161426,
-0.0053619933,
-0.1716971397,
-0.0716930479,
0.5164948702,
-0.3307563066,
-1.1026970148,
0.6588333845,
-0.0394462347,
0.4650299251,
0.7042391896,
0.262134403,
0.4800184965,
-0.1777651012,
1.1333473921,
0.0715788975,
-0.874363482,
0.397518754,
-0.7207704186,
0.2364056557,
0.0941386595,
0.3598155677,
-0.5296058655,
-0.6432518959,
-0.7659346461,
-0.5582075715,
0.3955720961,
0.0355293788,
0.3481152356,
-0.0529478155,
0.3266347349,
0.159989208,
0.4489829242,
-0.4441002309,
0.060615547,
-0.467285037,
0.1794756502,
-0.0803292096,
-0.0766123906,
-0.2088367641,
-0.1968582571,
0.5633234382,
-0.1457392573,
0.0866721272,
0.3048146665,
0.2989613414,
-0.3675238788,
0.4066874683,
0.6950984597,
0.5280876756,
0.1182576194,
0.2359001338,
0.1368817538,
-0.1764782965,
0.3402542174,
-0.1706336886,
-0.459736824,
-0.2208750546,
0.0783776119,
0.8386802673,
-0.0472791083,
-0.5720731616,
0.2024140656,
-0.0690112039,
-0.2958036065,
-0.3388177156,
-0.045517806,
0.2148569077,
0.3767066598,
0.4621998966,
0.2282816619,
-0.3569538891,
-1.1789228916,
-0.3246832788,
0.5690603256,
-0.2451691628,
-0.9059919119,
0.7012454867,
0.4549081326,
-0.8693593144,
0.1535476297,
-0.1542500108,
-0.9483438134,
0.5820141435,
0.4628663957,
0.7050928473,
-0.2485637367,
0.498596251,
0.1205653623,
0.0891833082,
-0.1613086164,
-0.1556981951,
0.0560929067,
-1.1235339642,
0.0393549018,
-0.4091068208,
-0.7061742544,
0.0030763736,
0.0690173507,
0.1180370525,
-0.5424563885,
-0.5260956287,
0.18239218,
-0.213067621,
-0.3143243492,
0.011618224,
0.2282094508,
0.3086096048,
-0.7698938251,
0.7124016285,
0.9603824615,
-0.3071543872,
-0.7601950169,
0.3265775144,
0.3617245853,
-0.0762742832,
0.5702950954,
0.0465963073,
-0.5547485352,
-0.3309599459,
-0.9590541124,
-0.7027059793,
0.7247726917,
0.5757536292,
-0.3600867391,
0.140956521,
0.1935093552,
0.8932541609,
-0.5734634995,
0.1453120261,
0.3845725954,
0.7370007634,
0.0758713186,
-0.8664910793,
0.0965219811,
-0.3262560368,
-0.1586975604,
-0.0720737651,
-0.8243052363,
0.662782073,
-0.25446257,
-0.4772646129,
0.0518962108,
0.6660288572,
-0.0007766183,
0.1947487742,
0.9441683292,
-0.1644781381,
0.6904923916,
0.1371322125,
1.2574130297,
-0.6291128993,
0.0785397366,
0.5837276578,
-0.6654206514,
0.8195459247,
0.2623088062,
-0.0669488534,
0.8171129823,
0.40377599,
0.2496291399,
0.0280692112,
0.4769302011,
-0.4401216507,
-0.6558176875,
-0.2524633706,
0.0337710977,
0.3229141533,
0.3433568776,
0.0887814239,
0.2887393534,
0.0877046734,
0.0597430952,
0.3070347309,
-0.1280750334,
0.7378099561,
-0.0056185359,
-0.9634031653,
0.2392783314,
-0.1239902601,
0.406008631,
-0.5606959462,
-0.2829871476,
0.2254445851,
0.1616261154,
-0.1591854542,
-0.7635394931,
-0.0874946415,
-0.0042576445,
0.0223207548,
-0.4066410363,
0.6006124616,
-0.2935126126,
-0.2936209142,
0.328709811,
0.291711688,
0.3321661651,
0.0676526204,
-0.5778964162,
-0.054016754,
-0.103962861,
-0.3012681305,
0.4806165099,
0.3077388704,
-0.1985236555,
0.6871370673,
1.0421973467,
0.3338191509,
-0.135462001,
0.2717619538,
0.923435688,
-0.4386349022,
-0.2837059796,
-0.8226174712,
0.3283726871,
-0.3492399156,
-0.1295931488,
0.7076260448,
0.280325532,
0.6048669815,
-0.0445211791,
0.9381043315,
0.0983300954,
0.421494633,
-0.0890422389,
0.8584946394,
-0.3913255632,
0.1809830517,
-0.5455068946,
-0.8534396291,
0.0689218044,
0.5623048544,
-0.3366420567,
-0.2402758747,
0.5793494582,
1.0851336718,
0.5557425618,
0.2000893205,
0.3531165719,
0.7684803009,
0.587166667,
-0.0210783258,
1.147108674,
0.2584387958,
0.2820726931,
0.1647329032,
-0.1147128344,
0.0609090962,
-0.8490041494,
-0.912198782,
-0.6444048882,
-0.4485686123,
-0.6627839804,
0.2414118201,
1.6768362522,
0.5167055726,
-0.6787135005,
-0.414195627,
0.0900954455,
0.017076781,
-0.128160879,
-0.2748137414,
0.0482392237,
0.2288103253,
-0.8079991937,
0.6092087626,
0.2409592271,
-0.0265674423,
-0.7433195114,
-0.2248145938,
-0.1371923685,
0.7649440765,
0.6539635658,
0.5249020457,
-0.9845713377,
-0.5751676559,
-0.253385663,
0.0355885066,
-0.1268780679,
0.956335783,
-0.8847041726,
0.4302703738,
0.5269969106,
0.283713907,
0.2709794939,
0.3157458901,
0.8951465487,
0.0595431924,
0.0595600381,
0.0617975928,
0.2406615466,
0.3310619891,
-0.1576512903,
0.0914098322,
0.5001872182,
-0.5726858974,
-0.6411355138,
0.0718468577,
-0.7325690389,
-0.3058282435,
1.5376677513,
0.1276315004,
-0.2470944971,
-0.2256789953,
-0.487660259,
-0.0357274562,
-1.0024442673,
1.0111509562,
0.6657754779,
-0.1603685021,
0.0121158073,
-0.0822924599,
0.4261776805,
0.0280167926,
-0.8109869957,
0.0833947882,
0.5282351971,
0.1384773552,
0.4362852871,
0.4772980511,
0.1808844358,
-0.078348197,
-0.0070322854,
-0.2372899055,
0.1435941011,
-0.2579670548,
-0.2065533847,
0.3677821457,
0.0133062918,
0.3369973004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15503v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15503v1
|
Making Large Language Models A Better Foundation For Dense Retrieval
| 2023-12-24T15:10:35 | 2023-12-24T15:10:35 |
Chaofan Li, Zheng Liu, Shitao Xiao, Yingxia Shao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Dense retrieval needs to learn discriminative text embeddings to represent
the semantic relationship between query and document. It may benefit from the
using of large language models (LLMs), given LLMs' strong capability on
semantic understanding. However, the LLMs are pre-trained by text generation
tasks, whose working pattern is completely different from representing texts as
embeddings. As a result, it is imperative to study how to adapt LLMs properly
so that they can be effectively initialized as the backbone encoder for dense
retrieval.
In this paper, we propose a novel approach, called LLaRA (LLM adapted for
dense RetrievAl), which works as a post-hoc adaptation of LLM for the dense
retrieval application. LLaRA consists of two pretext tasks: EBAE
(Embedding-Based Auto-Encoding) and EBAR (Embedding-Based Auto-Regression),
where the text embeddings from LLM are used to reconstruct the tokens for the
input sentence and predict the tokens for the next sentence, respectively.
LLaRA turns out to be simple, lightweight, and highly effective. It is applied
to adapt LLaMA-2-7B (base) on the Wikipedia corpus, where it substantially
improves the model's fine-tuned performances on a variety of dense retrieval
benchmarks, like MSMARCO and BEIR. Our model and code will be made publicly
available at BGE repository.
|
[
-0.1961586028,
-0.8734540939,
0.6470709443,
0.1960684061,
-0.5104900599,
-0.1235917285,
-0.4632834196,
-0.3764251769,
0.3480655253,
0.6823948026,
-0.0460393615,
-0.4457441568,
-0.5234766603,
0.139047727,
-0.6560901403,
0.7597885728,
-0.0451621301,
-0.0544371046,
-0.0637287125,
-0.0533235446,
-0.4469466507,
-0.2777952552,
-0.5219157338,
-0.1939659715,
0.5451152325,
0.307837218,
0.4990009665,
0.4807712734,
0.2044625431,
0.2999792099,
-0.1047932878,
0.1388998181,
-0.9980277419,
0.1990720183,
-0.1927098632,
-0.4613598287,
-0.2275643796,
-0.5214143395,
0.8362115622,
0.6594778299,
-0.3159961402,
-0.0319732539,
0.1086678058,
0.3740738034,
-0.6175559759,
0.0468461774,
-0.9393527508,
-0.242639333,
-0.1551810503,
-0.204462558,
-0.5839860439,
-0.0251773819,
-0.0159176234,
-0.6050586104,
-0.0214436762,
0.1751800776,
0.6650632024,
0.3141645789,
-0.3831784725,
-0.3189833164,
-0.5633063912,
0.6474987268,
-0.6987589002,
0.4567053318,
0.2948814332,
0.3359108269,
-0.4536340237,
-0.7373082638,
-0.6133588552,
-0.3872199953,
0.0580189526,
-0.0798457861,
0.0065660616,
-0.0581686497,
0.0976528078,
0.3185670972,
-0.4844564497,
0.450024575,
-0.0792596415,
-0.0623046421,
0.52044034,
0.0566721782,
0.1739473343,
-0.0921278596,
-0.1673287898,
-0.1152286604,
-0.6941607594,
-0.4899171293,
0.0582384318,
0.1216590852,
-0.0005595331,
0.7470514774,
-0.3309011161,
0.7067813277,
0.1891957968,
-0.0802543759,
0.2927887142,
-0.2101263255,
-0.1388011128,
0.1602226794,
0.5001413822,
0.1359247714,
0.3106488883,
-0.1954167783,
-0.4008076787,
-0.1378831863,
0.2342652231,
-1.0432641506,
0.0637366399,
-0.0257016663,
-0.5707221627,
-0.1528917104,
-0.1200538427,
-0.5311814547,
-0.3829767108,
-0.2292697281,
0.5463295579,
-0.3653553724,
-0.1367547363,
0.3895820975,
0.2929252088,
0.4990320802,
0.4725099504,
-0.8638291955,
0.3704668283,
0.5516293645,
0.719810009,
-0.0692343786,
-0.1489481032,
-0.6923166513,
0.4944139123,
-0.269249469,
0.848750174,
-0.518688798,
-0.3740475774,
0.0401948541,
-0.0643197447,
0.2549046278,
-0.4874856472,
0.534753859,
-0.7434213758,
-0.0744857714,
-0.1689653099,
-0.5936012268,
-0.059002094,
0.1331829131,
-0.8550545573,
1.0564690828,
-0.0216323603,
-0.6968468428,
0.1460827887,
-0.2461998314,
-0.5128474832,
-0.0591149032,
-0.0863287076,
-0.2529982924,
0.3447694778,
0.3025226295,
0.5872462392,
-0.5005816221,
0.4484065473,
-0.5271360874,
-0.5860624313,
-0.0357631072,
-0.1755504757,
0.5939369202,
0.2005104721,
-0.0715295598,
-0.0242583938,
-0.7503604889,
-0.2617509663,
0.1573319882,
-0.4671253562,
-0.5512232184,
0.1527965367,
0.0993213803,
-0.0917040557,
0.4231154621,
-0.3976092935,
0.0668700114,
-0.4603184164,
0.3637240529,
0.6835396886,
-0.2146944553,
0.6440541148,
0.0009466896,
0.1393958032,
-0.1894765049,
-0.1268647164,
-0.1052772775,
-0.1203645319,
-0.7609525323,
-0.2758448422,
0.3181847632,
0.4319953918,
-0.7562591434,
0.4611847401,
-0.5212612152,
-0.5067393184,
-0.4161995053,
0.4481311142,
0.1455193609,
0.363142848,
0.3165246248,
-0.3135854602,
-0.726631999,
-0.6986349225,
-0.0077158893,
-0.2490719557,
-0.0202672556,
0.4510528445,
0.5520831943,
-0.5214203596,
0.6466550231,
-0.5626450777,
-0.1835409403,
-0.312056452,
-0.144198373,
0.2860711515,
0.2981017232,
0.5358892679,
-0.7229857445,
-0.4752741754,
0.0279814973,
-0.8037990332,
-0.2429143786,
0.0993201733,
-0.4787889719,
-0.0206769221,
0.6618769169,
-0.7032117248,
0.0853196383,
0.4661153257,
-0.1056270525,
0.3362573087,
-0.1716638356,
-0.1247894466,
-1.3589615822,
0.1348861754,
-0.2376866043,
-0.2978523076,
-0.3533194065,
-0.022975605,
0.1352392584,
-0.0619515777,
-0.2456362993,
0.6967071295,
-0.5527974963,
-0.464275986,
-0.3382491469,
0.1064829677,
0.1113808677,
0.0823423713,
-0.01295349,
0.6792936325,
0.4533746243,
-0.5698365569,
0.2549294531,
0.2540643811,
-0.5918486118,
0.271241188,
-0.8320766687,
0.1688784212,
-0.4086824656,
0.6324350834,
-0.6968784928,
-0.1935885996,
-0.1206178069,
-0.1449769139,
0.3924884498,
-0.0363610424,
-0.71472013,
-0.1626923382,
-0.1514770091,
0.4680164456,
0.4434415102,
-0.7111457586,
0.8663253784,
0.5028727055,
-0.2401705384,
-0.7271383405,
-0.4881786108,
0.2081755847,
-0.0602524132,
-0.5009246469,
0.6751374006,
-0.151713714,
-0.1623333544,
0.0136981932,
0.1431052983,
-0.2195376158,
0.2159784138,
-0.193656683,
0.0685125887,
-0.354042232,
0.2374369651,
0.2072214186,
0.0383507833,
-0.2745513618,
-0.2886879444,
0.6551569104,
0.1315121949,
-0.0268623997,
-0.0393122658,
0.3604107499,
0.283534199,
-0.2944034338,
0.8166860342,
0.7374377251,
-0.4245829284,
-0.4354772568,
-0.8462316394,
-0.2966937721,
-0.4491666555,
0.683480978,
-0.3948650956,
-1.1159937382,
0.3484168947,
0.0124904383,
-0.0895122886,
0.2487415671,
0.774576962,
-0.0774758384,
0.7624601722,
0.8104957938,
-0.2274116725,
0.6743258238,
-0.0755331665,
-0.0673466772,
-0.7919436097,
-0.1413859576,
-0.5361495018,
-0.1103150472,
-0.2661119699,
-0.5092790127,
-0.0391541123,
0.3096192777,
-0.112277098,
0.413684994,
-0.081810914,
0.4160402417,
-0.0218954347,
0.1462360471,
0.1753906906,
0.2971234024,
-0.032046929,
0.2444846034,
-0.5958284736,
-0.4014255106,
1.1022547483,
0.1856285483,
0.9326065779,
0.2178206295,
0.7818248868,
0.1188078523,
0.412926048,
-0.6931594014,
0.5693492889,
-0.4719012976,
-0.3984808326,
-0.2146872878,
-0.603323698,
-1.0412029028,
0.4702011049,
-0.2829951644,
-0.3630954921,
0.167458728,
-0.1133247167,
-0.1059079766,
0.0626634061,
-0.5373561382,
0.6423876286,
-0.4036073983,
-0.4667334259,
-0.5118263364,
-0.2250457406,
0.2524699867,
-0.2637045085,
0.2295444906,
-0.1337302774,
-0.2973629832,
0.619309485,
-0.1843667775,
0.8737505674,
-0.0895278007,
-0.3075662851,
0.2953720391,
0.0870870873,
0.62856704,
0.1627086103,
-0.4414511323,
-0.0082405815,
-0.3618907034,
-0.3670322299,
-0.6283231378,
0.9197092056,
-0.7938599586,
-0.6218035221,
-0.0415946357,
-0.5093459487,
-0.0438343212,
0.4330303967,
-0.0897789598,
0.4039356112,
-0.3852987289,
0.5112560391,
0.8077213764,
-0.3244291246,
0.2550674081,
0.6642500758,
-0.283306241,
-0.2556029558,
0.6358872056,
0.1205138415,
-0.0786365718,
0.7313548326,
0.1924112737,
-0.3280072808,
-0.7929262519,
-0.3564011753,
0.4929182529,
-0.7233428359,
-0.2614070177,
-0.8283264637,
0.0830032453,
-0.3902008533,
-0.1814036816,
-0.2278026342,
-0.2406511158,
-0.593159616,
-0.0985760018,
0.3667342663,
0.6112412214,
0.1407873631,
0.2686548829,
-0.5926243663,
0.3661976755,
0.159807831,
0.22715801,
0.0632942095,
-0.830126524,
-0.3403668106,
-0.247976467,
0.2732016444,
-0.6365196705,
0.3358259201,
0.3485018611,
0.6185002327,
0.0629226863,
-0.0771322623,
0.7368920445,
-0.6110963225,
0.259146452,
-0.0793227777,
-0.7201598883,
0.4041697681,
-0.184973225,
0.1572380066,
0.6281220913,
0.3317938447,
-0.0637957305,
0.089146398,
-0.1116004065,
-0.8272873163,
0.2872691453,
0.0046401904,
0.449593544,
-0.1583226919,
0.6834564805,
0.1905908734,
0.1457156688,
-0.6358688474,
0.2568514347,
-0.1587543041,
-0.481169194,
-0.3184602559,
-0.627908349,
0.3111444414,
0.0292485785,
0.564019382,
-0.2138911337,
0.136182189,
0.0669399127,
-0.7731854916,
0.1018757001,
0.1046878323,
0.1772041917,
0.4084895849,
-0.1314626038,
0.0801204145,
0.432071209,
-0.383436501,
0.0137256272,
0.1472633034,
-0.2312353402,
-0.0870424658,
0.4042538106,
0.804471612,
0.7027341127,
-0.8157330751,
0.4721241593,
0.051799424,
0.1424282044,
-0.3278126717,
-0.1105202213,
0.1176366135,
0.2548660636,
0.3221940994,
-0.6013427377,
0.2981006205,
-0.6242164373,
0.2889059484,
0.3759124279,
-0.0554495826,
-0.2190524787,
0.483173728,
0.2549557686,
0.0242321044,
0.6044963598,
0.0797958374,
-0.3398963213,
0.3182801306,
0.8277675509,
0.6429656744,
-0.1981678009,
0.0508361943,
0.3974144757,
0.2042521089,
-0.3059165478,
0.235674426,
-0.0461646505,
-0.7487827539,
-0.7552535534,
-0.9501971006,
0.0244950317,
-0.1820445359,
-0.408048749,
0.4020474553,
-0.5345407724,
0.0700875223,
-0.2890467048,
0.0671187639,
-0.6884311438,
0.1156999394,
0.2631101012,
0.9364582896,
-0.6066803336,
1.068693161,
0.5468451977,
-0.4795113802,
-0.6123886704,
-0.1570215374,
-0.4656489789,
-0.961073041,
0.6446472406,
0.1724697948,
-0.078723602,
0.3154676557,
-0.476242125,
-1.1580651999,
1.2183374166,
0.6326984167,
-0.8310522437,
-0.1880034804,
-0.2360111177,
0.4950199425,
-0.5061050653,
0.4193580747,
0.264585793,
0.3405317068,
-0.0116845425,
-0.70950526,
0.3514149487,
-0.02739002,
0.2450373322,
-0.050819844,
-0.6777094603,
0.8037478328,
-0.1776447296,
-0.1133589894,
0.3366357386,
0.8749013543,
0.2032368183,
-0.147451669,
0.5060739517,
0.7008013725,
0.7087662816,
0.2720741332,
1.1956199408,
-0.1220339686,
0.1049193144,
0.9976088405,
-0.6239904761,
1.2569124699,
0.3386206329,
0.0677590445,
0.7184258103,
0.4195600748,
-0.0205374956,
0.4548764825,
0.2294673622,
-0.1440123618,
-0.268948108,
-0.1703338772,
-0.3574986458,
0.5155717731,
0.5362417102,
-0.3574134707,
-0.2135426849,
-0.0640352592,
0.0071095745,
0.0469216593,
-0.4473448992,
0.8348225951,
0.2395691276,
-0.3453612924,
0.6513412595,
0.1605080813,
0.6608211994,
-0.4831330478,
0.0376390517,
-0.2789903283,
0.1488831937,
-0.2363236845,
-0.5682401061,
0.0277951602,
-0.0079398779,
-0.1815071404,
0.0921058133,
1.0081410408,
-0.4154512882,
-0.5679187775,
0.6728510857,
0.3569274247,
0.1136935577,
0.0351044871,
-0.7143604755,
0.4806667566,
-0.1910198927,
-0.3583782315,
0.4309973121,
0.551843524,
-0.1025220379,
0.5762444735,
0.8484738469,
-0.1173824817,
0.0961143374,
0.4490790665,
0.9334399104,
-0.6735218763,
-0.4005176127,
-0.6175288558,
0.1862236857,
-0.0057351612,
0.0451679304,
0.6019485593,
0.4872840345,
0.6943090558,
0.0620902926,
0.5662366748,
0.0549357869,
0.1818695068,
-0.7944085002,
0.6903996468,
-0.69416219,
0.2460587472,
-0.2370633185,
-1.4450073242,
-0.3224228919,
0.7423654199,
-0.2123631984,
0.1507458687,
0.5500011444,
0.937430799,
-0.1239724383,
-0.4189362228,
0.3472617865,
0.6845760942,
0.1580495387,
0.5732204318,
0.7100998163,
-0.3195058703,
0.7300434113,
0.0945372358,
-0.1402783096,
-0.6457195878,
-0.829909265,
-0.8672190905,
-0.2487393618,
0.0541096963,
-0.3581959903,
0.260528177,
0.6910341382,
0.5626130104,
-0.5544285774,
-0.3448220789,
0.0284017511,
-0.1103128046,
0.3023638427,
-0.0784302354,
0.3375325501,
-0.2231803536,
-0.6214535832,
0.5976289511,
0.1496703923,
-0.0160589386,
-0.2533674836,
-0.2740746439,
-0.268122673,
0.0573493987,
0.8423835039,
0.0840446278,
-0.5475533605,
-0.3645737767,
-0.125732407,
-0.2568590343,
-0.1495781392,
0.630123198,
-0.8428654671,
0.2647176087,
0.5362234116,
1.1066616774,
0.9120665789,
-0.2526009977,
0.6706421375,
-0.2552038431,
0.262153089,
0.1598312408,
0.6670513153,
0.5200372338,
-0.3023477197,
0.4239994586,
-0.06650424,
-0.3241204619,
-0.8602080941,
0.2108495831,
-1.0077968836,
-0.3164335191,
1.2406396866,
0.0731978491,
-0.5141296387,
0.0008126164,
-0.189022854,
0.3168678284,
-0.3443686068,
0.7684108615,
0.4972059727,
0.5351127982,
-0.217052862,
-0.3856775165,
-0.024186926,
0.618676424,
-0.6412423253,
-0.1049588099,
0.5150154829,
0.3398110867,
-0.1883160472,
0.756995976,
-0.1740404367,
0.1008943543,
-0.0653929189,
-0.000332735,
-0.0089457585,
-0.2955682874,
-0.2391329259,
0.1163836792,
0.3181415796,
0.4422000945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15478v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15478v1
|
A Group Fairness Lens for Large Language Models
| 2023-12-24T13:25:15 | 2023-12-24T13:25:15 |
Guanqun Bi, Lei Shen, Yuqiang Xie, Yanan Cao, Tiangang Zhu, Xiaodong He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The rapid advancement of large language models has revolutionized various
applications but also raised crucial concerns about their potential to
perpetuate biases and unfairness when deployed in social media contexts.
Evaluating LLMs' potential biases and fairness has become crucial, as existing
methods rely on limited prompts focusing on just a few groups, lacking a
comprehensive categorical perspective. In this paper, we propose evaluating LLM
biases from a group fairness lens using a novel hierarchical schema
characterizing diverse social groups. Specifically, we construct a dataset,
GFair, encapsulating target-attribute combinations across multiple dimensions.
In addition, we introduce statement organization, a new open-ended text
generation task, to uncover complex biases in LLMs. Extensive evaluations of
popular LLMs reveal inherent safety concerns. To mitigate the biases of LLM
from a group fairness perspective, we pioneer a novel chain-of-thought method
GF-Think to mitigate biases of LLMs from a group fairness perspective.
Experimental results demonstrate its efficacy in mitigating bias in LLMs to
achieve fairness.
|
[
-0.2427782118,
-0.8278765678,
0.6195273995,
0.2607004344,
-0.0695325583,
0.1650034785,
-0.2569383681,
-0.3815185428,
-0.005173082,
0.4262666404,
-0.5870056152,
-0.5627133846,
-0.7077609301,
-0.1076387018,
-0.220932439,
1.2222523689,
0.3081252575,
0.3786513805,
-0.0826394483,
-0.2494662106,
-0.1797185838,
-0.5094825625,
-0.7565610409,
-0.4042060375,
0.5156971216,
0.2345727086,
0.9477848411,
0.4425427616,
0.6559119225,
0.3431628048,
-0.1966239065,
0.0445473231,
-0.7619410753,
-0.0529071428,
-0.4840683043,
-0.4593411684,
-0.6946353316,
0.1336930245,
0.8218935728,
0.9923534989,
-0.2185378969,
0.3061645031,
0.1102572829,
0.6552096605,
-0.6339626908,
-0.1420642436,
-0.9809430838,
0.3669592142,
-0.0758618265,
-0.0527777374,
-0.3676134348,
-0.6037871838,
-0.0241339821,
-0.5601375103,
0.3122871518,
0.3158713281,
0.5087042451,
0.0580630004,
-0.3456683457,
-0.179224655,
-0.5014702678,
0.840579927,
-0.4813744128,
0.2420810014,
0.2617119849,
0.6114954352,
-0.2332113236,
-0.3591171205,
-0.5569812059,
0.2272745073,
0.1673863679,
0.0057447646,
-0.1462835073,
0.0986604616,
0.1413146406,
0.491912514,
-0.398963213,
0.2919378281,
-0.1761467606,
-0.0946560726,
0.689044714,
0.0972995609,
0.2733228505,
-0.1514605135,
-0.2918149233,
0.3163054287,
-0.6159102321,
-0.1417144835,
0.6269394159,
0.3309160471,
-0.1829029918,
0.4234527051,
-0.4049719572,
0.2314665616,
0.1795427501,
-0.2827122808,
0.483412236,
-0.2177828103,
-0.405348599,
0.0019348228,
0.7895569205,
0.9635905027,
0.6555251479,
-0.4476750195,
-0.2553034127,
0.1801353693,
0.0861575678,
-0.6331471205,
0.3595561087,
0.0258945934,
-0.8401056528,
-0.5422529578,
-0.0679453015,
-0.9202792645,
-0.6486911178,
-0.0547836907,
0.2032847852,
0.1998835206,
-0.2024036795,
0.1551968902,
0.004490444,
0.0841371417,
0.4176309109,
-0.8296829462,
0.392689079,
0.6590116024,
0.5752398968,
-0.1856914908,
-0.1638146043,
-0.8037579656,
0.4591709077,
-0.2117729783,
0.6007951498,
-0.6860160828,
-0.3582017422,
0.1428902745,
-0.1979873627,
0.2459261715,
-0.6614874601,
0.4110815227,
-0.3906193078,
0.2819001079,
-0.4186050892,
-0.3293351829,
0.1365237087,
0.1445678473,
-0.6411222219,
0.5815230608,
0.0766051635,
-0.9469754696,
0.7711160779,
-0.4447923303,
-0.47993806,
0.110347189,
-0.6989630461,
-0.2148816735,
0.2780283093,
0.3360166252,
0.4265829921,
-0.3651746809,
0.6737492681,
-0.7229856849,
-0.4485867023,
0.2630724907,
-0.5041162968,
0.6565475464,
0.1846530139,
-0.3954617679,
0.2344482094,
-0.3886147738,
-0.0252534319,
0.0445837714,
-0.3784205914,
-0.4050550759,
0.1020080298,
-0.0596325025,
0.4383463562,
-0.0165133122,
-0.2694871426,
-0.0237351432,
-0.1642634571,
0.3479655981,
1.4143058062,
-0.3316241205,
0.7877362967,
-0.3617276847,
0.3336302638,
-0.1071163639,
0.6115123034,
0.3619713485,
-0.3056710362,
-0.6626384258,
-0.1400871873,
-0.1930547655,
0.2965408862,
-0.7776242495,
0.2574261725,
-0.3445005119,
-0.0141665069,
-0.6191019416,
0.2527412772,
0.3754184842,
0.3202690184,
-0.0003474273,
-0.2349179387,
-0.1502470076,
-1.2830771208,
-0.4552020729,
-0.1462951303,
-0.0520342253,
0.3934882581,
0.3220380545,
-0.2799282074,
0.8773971796,
-0.2776606083,
-0.2730767131,
-0.2369782329,
-0.2565741241,
0.1678718328,
0.0231890157,
0.3762818575,
-0.8605644107,
-0.1621425003,
-0.0889488384,
-0.8140106797,
-0.4203710854,
0.2059681565,
-0.3606072664,
0.3160169423,
0.5123820901,
-0.3935420811,
0.2265778631,
0.5451647639,
-0.4964465201,
0.2265593112,
0.2600352466,
0.2795680165,
-0.9086989164,
-0.2010241747,
0.1462848634,
-0.1500011384,
-0.3564945161,
0.0109400144,
-0.3127987385,
0.4221653044,
-0.6095311642,
0.6256738901,
-0.1903905421,
-0.2513659596,
-0.0818893611,
0.2217804492,
-0.1663035005,
0.3706410825,
-0.3639576435,
0.411233604,
0.4447712004,
-0.4545453787,
-0.0167283807,
-0.0209293142,
-0.3941299617,
0.8520541787,
-0.3858812153,
0.1760809273,
-0.5887151361,
0.4717207849,
-0.7016117573,
-0.2136503607,
0.3102550507,
-0.2500788867,
-0.1156206876,
-0.0061435779,
-0.6431863308,
-0.3085019886,
-0.427103579,
0.6880939007,
0.2140462846,
-0.4855078459,
0.6647204757,
0.7786013484,
-0.198574394,
-0.7559016943,
-0.7685114145,
-0.0205122512,
-0.5934452415,
-0.8552430272,
0.2773011923,
-0.1418543458,
-0.7923738956,
-0.0480591096,
-0.1858669221,
0.1092778742,
0.0719139799,
0.2101895213,
0.1447010636,
0.2123844475,
0.2643842697,
0.0007638808,
0.2050966322,
-0.1008000374,
-0.0862997249,
0.6002646089,
-0.3189361691,
-0.2084577233,
0.0784400105,
0.4791841805,
0.289879173,
-0.1274027973,
0.5471245646,
0.4017113745,
-0.5494043231,
-0.3990011513,
-0.921471417,
0.0504284278,
-0.5599662662,
0.5101014972,
0.0787391514,
-1.4146931171,
0.6512684226,
0.2192403972,
0.0394801274,
0.1634124368,
0.6401597857,
0.1472777873,
0.9142352343,
0.6399575472,
-0.3650688231,
0.3133575916,
0.0764199644,
0.3415067196,
-0.4080479145,
-0.309427321,
-0.3266637027,
-0.2509427369,
-0.6258921027,
-0.6012049913,
0.3305340409,
0.0697515309,
-0.4262812436,
-0.5796764493,
-0.1730160862,
0.6756824255,
0.3202163577,
0.1174020618,
0.6181796789,
0.2624328434,
-0.0542764105,
0.0233593602,
-0.4583334327,
-0.7242270708,
1.0522027016,
0.5231636763,
0.9175969362,
0.1722325683,
0.4850407839,
0.5286319852,
0.6238110065,
-0.6118544936,
0.8629339933,
-0.3707344532,
-0.6935406923,
-0.3064826429,
-0.7874768972,
-0.619987905,
0.5931142569,
-0.2088499665,
-0.8225409985,
-0.0424090587,
0.0986836851,
-0.2356981337,
0.3940887451,
-0.5186629295,
0.577681601,
-0.2269736677,
-0.4669759572,
-0.2429494262,
-0.5004071593,
0.5808073282,
-0.3447324932,
0.7663103938,
-0.3466549516,
0.05134755,
0.5443075895,
-0.2351273447,
0.6678918004,
-0.1790090501,
-0.3037936687,
0.1800264865,
-0.1655173302,
0.1797379553,
-0.0887834579,
-0.3076165915,
0.5053400993,
-0.7385694385,
-0.1074880883,
-0.489263624,
0.6870055795,
-0.4066188931,
-0.6150926948,
-0.228538394,
-0.6639334559,
-0.2873331606,
0.2525492907,
0.1037559211,
-0.0447789803,
-0.3406048715,
0.1034796983,
0.3739077151,
-0.5234960318,
0.4509738386,
0.4857775569,
-0.523765564,
-0.4093051851,
0.529348731,
0.1246555671,
0.6497164369,
0.0521508232,
0.0252725966,
-0.190296337,
-0.35799402,
-0.1604481786,
0.0805617943,
-0.7585106492,
-0.0787542984,
-0.6545364261,
-0.0173342358,
-0.311717391,
-0.2049188167,
-0.0365666673,
-0.3690833747,
0.3189399838,
-0.2934817672,
-0.009254558,
0.6436926723,
-0.1103791893,
0.4195884168,
-0.1887890846,
0.4366132021,
0.2430711985,
0.5919405222,
0.2151847035,
-0.096665144,
-0.0504057482,
-0.0032992742,
-0.311755687,
-0.4358576834,
0.0129141212,
-0.0989054963,
0.8270529509,
0.3825444877,
-0.252918452,
0.1812009513,
-0.8994343281,
0.4517838657,
0.5128648281,
-0.9461588264,
0.447278887,
-0.4537011385,
-0.1003532559,
0.4977260232,
0.0908098817,
-0.5422528982,
-0.8186995387,
-0.3366830051,
-0.9008324742,
0.5433478355,
0.2056192756,
0.1059744507,
-0.4034126997,
0.101640895,
-0.0046473895,
0.4597217441,
-1.0841841698,
-0.2249415666,
0.0588482283,
-0.1643735766,
0.0990440324,
-0.0062815617,
-0.081717357,
0.0172069427,
0.2603526413,
-0.2072660774,
0.008419564,
0.0091997841,
0.0482666977,
-0.4715389907,
0.5510678887,
0.1038035229,
0.734464705,
-0.0829598606,
0.1482846886,
0.0870115235,
-0.3437542617,
0.1913369149,
-0.0296001546,
-0.3814217746,
-0.3008435965,
0.0909156129,
0.5086522698,
-0.0887638628,
-0.5805908442,
0.7045618296,
-0.0914025307,
-0.1783150285,
0.0951751396,
0.1334815621,
0.1318280399,
0.5006563067,
0.5609695315,
-0.1878770292,
0.3860779703,
-0.8302639723,
0.1432537436,
0.6895740032,
-0.1539903283,
0.1545069069,
0.7517989874,
0.2422779202,
-0.1933774352,
0.2182260007,
-0.2013078332,
-0.4478152692,
0.5631418824,
0.2839514911,
0.8787070513,
-0.3718166351,
0.329457283,
-0.1776363254,
0.6138629913,
-0.1432180852,
0.0680289343,
0.3805212379,
-0.9777798653,
-0.4046101868,
-0.795701623,
-0.1823723018,
0.2278619409,
-0.433726877,
-0.0119668813,
-0.5471259952,
-0.4490863085,
-0.086485453,
-0.2987210155,
-0.7136464715,
0.3369049728,
0.1988363862,
0.5789424181,
-0.833176434,
0.3976776898,
0.3604961932,
-0.2763400972,
-0.5397071242,
0.3046917617,
0.0262696221,
-0.9086923003,
0.6538850665,
0.4081431627,
-0.2356176674,
-0.587503016,
-0.6608245969,
-0.4217590094,
0.9745672941,
0.6063161492,
-0.6626991034,
-0.2916513085,
0.4941944182,
0.4058107734,
-0.5384587049,
-0.0090522384,
0.3379265368,
0.293646872,
0.0261448827,
-1.0266928673,
0.2414419949,
-0.2095489353,
0.1273905039,
-0.157066077,
-0.974901557,
0.8901212215,
-0.2051799595,
-0.1142156199,
-0.4356870949,
0.4679707885,
0.6021110415,
0.4338903725,
0.7959414721,
0.4563811719,
1.0575922728,
0.0835300833,
0.9698757529,
0.1809261292,
0.1131165251,
1.2042837143,
-0.5344467759,
0.2308886647,
0.3926050961,
-0.0163321458,
0.0728306919,
0.3459535837,
0.0855620056,
0.5595511794,
0.7300583124,
-0.3732038736,
-0.3617298603,
-0.4604412913,
-0.3829301596,
0.3149608076,
0.2319971323,
-0.5155062675,
-0.2466361225,
-0.1430714577,
0.2958207428,
0.2464126647,
-0.8148623705,
0.3659619987,
0.2975369692,
-0.488484621,
-0.0871671513,
0.1622513682,
1.0852758884,
-0.2156081498,
0.0812970698,
-0.276044637,
0.3189187944,
-0.2585099041,
-0.7294524908,
0.0560084432,
0.0851988047,
-0.3304926157,
-0.1026707813,
0.7805626988,
-0.4370355606,
-0.7270507812,
0.6647749543,
0.5349094272,
0.0412465855,
-0.0311980974,
-0.4516311288,
0.2673560679,
-0.0219731051,
-0.0444087535,
0.2308964729,
0.682620585,
-0.3115589023,
0.7441862822,
0.3176324666,
-0.0391720235,
0.0982795283,
0.607373476,
0.875613153,
-0.5203262568,
-0.4425268471,
-1.0802010298,
0.4375865459,
-0.2818018198,
-0.0889728814,
0.710185349,
0.5358210802,
0.9391551018,
0.3569675386,
0.9763462543,
0.3446561992,
0.3798772991,
-0.5435686707,
0.9602800608,
-0.6085039377,
0.3899428844,
-0.8652555346,
-0.8921794295,
-0.2780619562,
0.7917574048,
-0.358115375,
0.5502568483,
0.4846113026,
0.76422894,
0.0456192456,
0.2269337326,
0.1171517447,
0.2896113694,
0.4372605085,
0.619872272,
0.9453110695,
-0.0919481888,
0.533718884,
0.3671711087,
-0.4735521078,
0.044914607,
-1.0152817965,
-1.0620230436,
0.0086127948,
-0.0514781214,
-0.405269891,
0.3588241637,
0.8337472677,
0.4061543941,
-0.3055967689,
-0.2613456547,
0.1483003646,
0.3473386765,
0.4211606681,
-0.2582433522,
0.0767903104,
-0.2063059211,
-0.5399111509,
-0.0640436485,
0.3044178486,
-0.1631934196,
-0.3230283558,
-0.2834574282,
0.0591103584,
0.0751225203,
0.7942972779,
-0.5709486604,
-0.6578418612,
-0.4997080863,
-0.151099667,
-0.252524823,
-0.0943888128,
0.5630898476,
-0.4416775405,
0.0754742175,
0.0879102573,
0.5251481533,
0.0091600688,
-0.1462123096,
0.5592200756,
-0.5108482838,
-0.0679089427,
0.1526403129,
0.4183132052,
0.5058899522,
-0.4036896825,
0.6331946254,
0.1732847989,
-0.5199761391,
-0.7723853588,
0.2650107741,
-0.8163461089,
-0.3149882555,
1.4753433466,
0.2656236291,
-0.0162389409,
0.0409693792,
-0.0909942985,
0.1466230452,
-0.590841651,
0.8611292839,
0.9459002018,
0.3241609335,
0.2129413188,
-0.5957374573,
0.2882350385,
0.2996110618,
-0.9495012164,
0.0930462405,
0.8627390265,
0.2454254925,
-0.1394251138,
1.3255534172,
-0.355858624,
-0.0467739478,
-0.4459838271,
-0.04972969,
0.4294174016,
-0.3090966344,
-0.1068822294,
0.1699739397,
-0.247619167,
0.1860463321
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15472v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15472v1
|
Towards Consistent Language Models Using Declarative Constraints
| 2023-12-24T12:53:07 | 2023-12-24T12:53:07 |
Jasmin Mousavi, Arash Termehchy
|
cs.DB
|
cs.DB, cs.CL
|
Large language models have shown unprecedented abilities in generating
linguistically coherent and syntactically correct natural language output.
However, they often return incorrect and inconsistent answers to input
questions. Due to the complexity and uninterpretability of the internally
learned representations, it is challenging to modify language models such that
they provide correct and consistent results. The data management community has
developed various methods and tools for providing consistent answers over
inconsistent datasets. In these methods, users specify the desired properties
of data in a domain in the form of high-level declarative constraints. This
approach has provided usable and scalable methods to delivering consistent
information from inconsistent datasets. We aim to build upon this success and
leverage these methods to modify language models such that they deliver
consistent and accurate results. We investigate the challenges of using these
ideas to obtain consistent and relevant answers from language models and report
some preliminary empirical studies.
|
[
-0.0304099638,
-0.709672153,
0.6693912148,
0.1067929864,
0.0982685164,
0.2746478915,
-0.4558440149,
-0.5953870416,
-0.1021528468,
0.6499039531,
-0.463360846,
-0.3846924007,
-0.5491917133,
0.2254726887,
-0.3154116869,
0.6832357049,
-0.3971540928,
-0.0301007703,
-0.3591086566,
-0.306984812,
-0.7531490326,
-1.0660057068,
-0.1724069268,
-0.1644594818,
0.1133131012,
0.4538850188,
0.9057310224,
0.76311028,
0.6781793833,
0.2888325155,
0.0419384651,
0.4033400714,
-0.4237875342,
0.3316493034,
-0.3999700844,
-0.3983332515,
0.180946365,
-0.0906076357,
0.8943062425,
1.332898736,
-0.3433446586,
0.004462075,
0.1046105698,
0.5075838566,
-0.5831329226,
0.649040103,
-0.9452828765,
-0.053972628,
-0.1982670724,
0.0122303087,
-0.4948627949,
-0.5138263702,
-0.032097768,
-0.6399344206,
0.0281984601,
-0.1520358622,
1.0281875134,
0.3890805542,
-0.3983103335,
-0.636439085,
-1.372823596,
0.7652888298,
-0.9372095466,
0.5190623999,
0.6210979223,
0.1508307904,
-0.1838748455,
-0.5052509904,
-0.3773632944,
-0.2079919428,
-0.2101524472,
-0.2340739816,
-0.0355509929,
0.0277868696,
0.2613891065,
0.1332499385,
-0.3544687033,
0.2991526425,
-0.0493294373,
-0.2343305647,
0.602532506,
0.492975831,
0.0903127044,
0.0726462677,
0.0442062095,
0.147428602,
-0.6983475089,
-0.1376327127,
0.3768281937,
0.7158997059,
0.2230706066,
0.8018532395,
-0.3143425882,
0.9277615547,
0.1847609729,
0.0307460744,
0.1208424717,
-0.6273639202,
0.1867055595,
-0.29082039,
0.4126602709,
0.0103962133,
0.211549595,
-0.2192973346,
-0.5057651997,
0.09093339,
0.0220778473,
-0.5901882052,
-0.2234781832,
0.2778123021,
-0.0254679359,
-0.2632170022,
0.0476222821,
-0.5828303695,
-0.3837433755,
-0.547583878,
0.3772058189,
-0.3649031818,
-0.2692544162,
0.2449536175,
0.1686416715,
0.0536731966,
0.402423799,
-1.0522576571,
0.3824617863,
0.6214376092,
0.5425788164,
-0.1287094802,
0.0372977071,
-0.2757769227,
0.3202250302,
-0.5740089417,
0.3103966117,
-0.9405122399,
-0.2141544372,
0.3543238938,
-0.1396515816,
-0.218915686,
-0.7969196439,
0.3169277012,
-0.5508752465,
0.184174329,
-0.6062235236,
-0.9674342871,
0.0784294009,
0.356942296,
-0.6058712602,
0.8193539381,
0.0965924859,
-0.7103756666,
0.1330005825,
-0.2582730651,
-0.0884065703,
0.0632511005,
-0.2192500234,
-0.3184711933,
0.146206826,
0.008895115,
0.0892555043,
-0.2296355218,
0.6550834775,
-0.2066011429,
0.001435701,
0.398773104,
-0.434055835,
0.6263698936,
0.1490136832,
-0.1562857628,
-0.0334926769,
-1.0333684683,
0.0284775943,
0.2846271396,
-0.3897672594,
-0.2134921849,
0.2734322548,
-0.0960272327,
0.0612968877,
0.6074029803,
-0.5681263208,
0.3088326454,
-0.0340070538,
0.477560252,
0.7051510215,
0.1024968475,
0.3835501075,
-0.3249482214,
0.4724732637,
0.1468956321,
0.0770498961,
-0.0563872941,
-0.2758973539,
-0.476655364,
-0.0332615525,
0.5140347481,
0.4034807682,
-0.7318615913,
0.3891780972,
-0.2745492458,
-0.3435853124,
-0.4820026457,
0.2224783301,
0.2823130786,
0.4988671243,
0.2275638133,
-0.2196982652,
-0.6913781762,
-0.9294675589,
-0.1413741261,
-0.4761073589,
0.1460490227,
0.318526566,
0.3911102712,
-0.2051646113,
1.121006608,
-0.5451297164,
-0.1064266041,
-0.2070081681,
0.1712132245,
0.2011668086,
0.6023694873,
0.106225431,
-0.7635292411,
-0.5413695574,
0.1469002813,
-0.7926750183,
-0.340785116,
-0.2641243041,
0.263710767,
0.2201110721,
0.3250986934,
-0.5504885912,
0.0851355717,
0.5742217302,
-0.046294149,
0.7879896164,
-0.2194351852,
-0.0233434625,
-0.7968049645,
0.1123392954,
-0.1050035283,
-0.2908141315,
-1.0510101318,
0.1461343169,
0.0254837442,
0.012777999,
-0.1423276365,
0.3757033944,
-0.3249847293,
0.3089794219,
-0.0198835693,
-0.0920432508,
0.0428444892,
0.3628475666,
0.1298169643,
0.7382831573,
0.4742503464,
-0.5022753477,
0.3158404529,
0.5724306107,
-0.2757287621,
0.446901232,
-0.8249070644,
0.2096557766,
-0.3735772073,
0.0440200418,
-0.7780492306,
-0.4554163516,
0.2568053901,
-0.0534612313,
0.3902520835,
-0.3216224611,
-0.7140243649,
-0.1466504633,
0.1027420983,
0.4836347401,
0.3975074291,
-0.5680798888,
0.4821062684,
0.4547888935,
-0.1141581088,
-0.4799516797,
-0.5303109884,
0.1419313401,
-0.1393607259,
-0.4325963259,
0.3830813169,
-0.2380090803,
-0.5179905295,
-0.0114246765,
-0.2443959564,
-0.4388000369,
-0.0528279915,
0.0737510771,
0.2484515458,
-0.0723120645,
0.0923114121,
-0.2602318823,
0.252976656,
0.0455271825,
-0.2006258667,
0.447301954,
-0.0507653877,
-0.6147689223,
-0.3536083996,
0.3282635808,
0.5271220803,
-0.3373033702,
0.7278744578,
0.0336372629,
-0.5068749785,
-0.2244561911,
-0.6713460684,
-0.1778040826,
-0.4817287028,
0.3179012537,
-0.59535712,
-0.9737278223,
0.8981794715,
0.1027227789,
0.2369602621,
0.1315575838,
0.3537837267,
0.1633457392,
1.2403612137,
0.6561122537,
0.3386604786,
0.2611047328,
0.129362613,
-0.0372030884,
-0.5173757076,
-0.3887408078,
-0.7203148007,
0.0982901827,
-0.5525764227,
-0.2005487531,
0.057485681,
0.1381450146,
0.0070623136,
0.5239989758,
-0.3227172494,
0.2471823394,
0.3984172642,
-0.1444492042,
0.2395481318,
-0.3003785908,
-0.0166393891,
-0.2177665532,
-0.7597827911,
-0.6029512882,
0.8609990478,
0.2932169139,
0.9743859768,
0.1579919159,
0.5823317766,
-0.0243900418,
-0.0094225742,
-0.4556635618,
0.4502787292,
-0.0868905485,
-0.7619699836,
-0.3189770281,
-0.6470723152,
-0.9841223359,
0.1659804434,
-0.0118702557,
-0.7462727427,
0.4891863763,
0.1187849194,
-0.0000100661,
0.224183321,
-0.4909493923,
0.8262556791,
-0.0898572206,
-0.4981902242,
0.3263438642,
-0.7194495201,
0.0650103837,
-0.4038024247,
0.1831035763,
-0.2960233688,
0.1872952133,
0.4774020612,
-0.6151512265,
1.1587767601,
-0.0963953212,
-0.4950982928,
0.3756095469,
0.1906258315,
0.7542179227,
-0.1444525719,
-0.2142430246,
0.1994182765,
0.2617320418,
-0.4656641781,
-0.6201625466,
0.4851278961,
-0.6123775244,
-0.9599863887,
-0.2736725807,
-0.9354005456,
-0.543193996,
0.2132924497,
-0.0905987322,
0.6255457997,
-0.289244771,
0.0621731356,
0.6156683564,
0.0341764204,
0.3909616172,
0.5994560719,
-0.2868261337,
-0.2725671828,
0.8513703942,
0.3438230455,
0.4827147126,
0.3809576035,
0.1408350617,
-0.4372121692,
-0.6745717525,
-0.3210476935,
0.2771045566,
-0.7896798253,
-0.1704356521,
-0.2821584046,
-0.3539015353,
-0.298666358,
0.0574541986,
-0.4611641765,
-0.6445810795,
-0.2691133022,
0.044800587,
-0.068954125,
1.0532256365,
-0.2008806467,
-0.0332279615,
-0.8862484097,
0.1010460928,
0.2540482879,
0.3257479966,
-0.4319727719,
-0.556517005,
-0.3466480672,
0.3850648403,
-0.0674711913,
-0.9996597767,
0.2647803128,
0.2056138068,
0.5762556791,
0.1080844104,
0.1445542872,
0.5161599517,
-0.5968899131,
0.7264544368,
-0.1124560311,
-0.9889168739,
0.5412647724,
-0.3087615967,
0.3726171255,
0.7569029927,
0.3232812881,
-0.4767816961,
-0.6611776948,
-0.4928457737,
-0.5556041598,
0.4302003384,
0.5119495392,
0.1595290154,
-0.0410318561,
0.4427728951,
0.2944419384,
0.3833978772,
-0.4939796031,
0.0368774235,
0.0275214519,
-0.3863945901,
0.2421627939,
-0.3190039694,
-0.1355190426,
-0.0316945128,
0.7171286941,
-0.1820429862,
-0.2691938579,
-0.0840863958,
-0.1046092585,
-0.1423671842,
0.3624895215,
0.5556878448,
1.2908327579,
-0.1735528708,
0.3524270654,
-0.0657944456,
-0.2013967186,
0.2721499503,
0.1909468323,
-0.5214208961,
0.3680898249,
0.2046814412,
0.5748959184,
-0.0225746799,
-0.736355722,
0.2781459391,
0.1270127296,
-0.1940820366,
-0.28303653,
-0.141732946,
-0.0441202894,
-0.0059510712,
0.1490556896,
-0.0498746857,
-0.1811135262,
-0.5309196115,
0.1873600036,
0.6018238664,
-0.4250623882,
-0.4115004539,
0.8219046593,
-0.007577843,
-0.1716312915,
0.7507303953,
0.0315593891,
-0.4328123629,
0.535507381,
0.6427449584,
0.6298040152,
-0.3511226475,
0.3723554909,
0.2533788979,
0.3238397241,
-0.3969486654,
0.3332310915,
0.2136351764,
-1.0994927883,
-0.5212367773,
-0.3901877999,
-0.7755051255,
-0.0097946059,
-0.8129950166,
0.2556651533,
-0.3587259352,
-0.0696418956,
0.140874058,
-0.1554483026,
-0.496455282,
0.0260617752,
-0.0945142806,
0.6779070497,
-0.7876336575,
0.8862226605,
0.630639255,
-0.7925952673,
-0.8390623331,
-0.1597265601,
-0.1876888722,
-0.7158159018,
0.5177673101,
-0.1196857914,
0.0945449397,
-0.1700146198,
-0.7058534026,
-0.9495985508,
0.5728124976,
0.5741080642,
-0.6647288799,
-0.0344578549,
0.8654693365,
0.6676115394,
-0.3618347049,
-0.1871838421,
0.5396699905,
0.7097739577,
0.3492860794,
-1.0021246672,
0.1576973349,
0.0629750639,
0.1950907409,
0.2048190236,
-0.2881185114,
0.5315067768,
-0.1540700048,
-0.2795266211,
0.109280549,
0.6904885769,
0.2005057037,
0.0084750997,
0.317382127,
0.6510921717,
0.9700734615,
-0.1875536442,
0.768219173,
-0.417086184,
0.5151274204,
1.275911212,
-0.6928655505,
0.8216612935,
0.5697493553,
-0.1902169138,
0.374117434,
0.4700347483,
-0.0797572434,
0.4157485962,
0.2796112299,
-0.3384777606,
-0.2378130555,
-0.5002767444,
-0.2163731456,
0.4966641068,
0.3443484902,
-0.0705047697,
-0.1184376627,
-0.2175525576,
0.0092001716,
0.4704691172,
0.0369399823,
0.8211762309,
-0.244948715,
-0.518997848,
0.7769877911,
0.1040036082,
0.2362233251,
-0.5232526064,
-0.2258116007,
-0.3304206431,
0.0518986657,
-0.1159580573,
-0.7004747391,
0.5818718672,
-0.1426563114,
-0.2690596282,
-0.3217762113,
0.52507025,
-0.9677196741,
-0.4916042686,
-0.3029965758,
0.6145670414,
-0.1716992706,
0.2265187204,
-0.5132269859,
0.4473283291,
0.0420830399,
0.2202956825,
0.0951872915,
0.4462726712,
0.1637563109,
0.6859791875,
0.392940253,
0.1324871033,
0.1468416899,
0.0588719845,
0.6650264263,
-0.3761976957,
-0.2202506065,
-0.6577296853,
0.3641305268,
-0.0571261942,
-0.0785464421,
0.8108150363,
0.6060980558,
0.9018372893,
0.0104814256,
0.8004142642,
-0.0998721123,
0.4273093045,
-0.4237385094,
0.1908395737,
-0.2362927496,
0.5849416852,
0.0223222002,
-0.969278276,
-0.4465058148,
0.3423253596,
-0.138955161,
-0.0010879281,
0.6466588378,
0.7735314965,
0.0565882474,
-0.1790799499,
0.376218766,
0.3319295645,
0.4504702985,
0.4044921696,
0.8864198923,
-0.1886239946,
0.4601087868,
-0.4520311058,
-0.0383793637,
0.1674699187,
-0.7229713202,
-0.6761734486,
-0.8026096821,
-0.7470690608,
-0.4243716002,
0.2877398133,
0.9286587834,
0.6564686894,
-1.1890844107,
-0.4353812039,
-0.4065414071,
0.1337367892,
-0.1699312776,
-0.2621162832,
0.0957436413,
-0.5283820629,
-0.8218374252,
0.363322258,
0.1521813124,
0.1199320853,
-0.3757870495,
0.0220957845,
-0.0796152353,
0.4095156193,
0.2391664982,
0.6126696467,
-0.6562691927,
-0.62980479,
-0.1037102267,
-0.2960999906,
0.1176794469,
0.7694970369,
-0.438628763,
0.4587501884,
0.4382117987,
0.8635082245,
0.2220848352,
0.1772282273,
0.8206268549,
-0.9516001344,
-0.1857947856,
0.375318855,
0.3647664785,
0.6077470779,
-0.2083948553,
0.5979578495,
0.1537875235,
-0.5625334978,
-0.9064179063,
0.6375451088,
-0.7352836728,
-0.3588816524,
1.3506596088,
-0.2456701249,
0.1220402792,
-0.2659656405,
-0.0342057683,
-0.0294318181,
-0.0176875237,
0.8009318113,
0.8306069374,
-0.1010925248,
-0.1935506016,
-0.3024823964,
0.4245887995,
0.3022061586,
-0.8765527606,
0.5339146852,
0.7381678224,
0.2947275937,
0.1754632443,
0.28523615,
-0.2433485985,
-0.284404248,
0.0440178923,
-0.0594170764,
0.0320712775,
-0.3597137034,
-0.3722294569,
0.3078689575,
0.3997307718,
0.009873908
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.17262v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.17262v1
|
Multimodal Classification of Teaching Activities from University Lecture Recordings
| 2023-12-24T08:33:30 | 2023-12-24T08:33:30 |
Oscar Sapena, Eva Onaindia
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, 68T05 (Primary), 97P80 (Secondary), I.2.6; I.2.7; I.5.4
|
The way of understanding online higher education has greatly changed due to
the worldwide pandemic situation. Teaching is undertaken remotely, and the
faculty incorporate lecture audio recordings as part of the teaching material.
This new online teaching-learning setting has largely impacted university
classes. While online teaching technology that enriches virtual classrooms has
been abundant over the past two years, the same has not occurred in supporting
students during online learning. {To overcome this limitation, our aim is to
work toward enabling students to easily access the piece of the lesson
recording in which the teacher explains a theoretical concept, solves an
exercise, or comments on organizational issues of the course. To that end, we
present a multimodal classification algorithm that identifies the type of
activity that is being carried out at any time of the lesson by using a
transformer-based language model that exploits features from the audio file and
from the automated lecture transcription. The experimental results will show
that some academic activities are more easily identifiable with the audio
signal while resorting to the text transcription is needed to identify others.
All in all, our contribution aims to recognize the academic activities of a
teacher during a lesson.
|
[
-0.2809106708,
-0.7960543633,
0.373251766,
-0.0200371221,
0.110644713,
0.3702582717,
-0.2542515993,
-0.4709786177,
0.1892116219,
0.2997962236,
-0.3049387932,
-0.3448733091,
-0.543176949,
0.1950524598,
-0.5208305717,
1.1420488358,
-0.0225444324,
0.4995895624,
-0.5600529313,
-0.1953007281,
-0.3756108582,
-0.5091212988,
-0.3451429009,
-0.4766356945,
0.2324730158,
0.4344934225,
0.0244188737,
0.321573168,
0.4602668881,
0.4895260632,
0.1680671424,
-0.0048165163,
-0.062461447,
-0.1224666908,
0.1120747253,
-0.5805745721,
-0.2540141046,
-0.1761831641,
0.6996021271,
0.4336986244,
-0.2022114396,
0.4257343411,
0.0632653683,
-0.1156881526,
-0.3320753872,
0.3456167281,
-0.0552840494,
0.2609438002,
-0.3025433719,
-0.4400355518,
-0.6633325219,
-0.3836994469,
0.332277894,
-0.4746499956,
0.3044786155,
-0.5667154193,
0.3976534605,
-0.1135810837,
-0.6189175248,
-0.3699854612,
-1.0372868776,
0.7961081862,
-0.1980101615,
0.6415079832,
0.5118786693,
0.5754901767,
0.2476320714,
-0.6307958364,
-0.4576966763,
0.2318187654,
0.0037987928,
0.1636123657,
0.0934692994,
0.1875267178,
0.1088116914,
0.492636472,
-0.245002076,
-0.094614163,
-0.6082394719,
-0.3354904652,
0.1918411553,
0.1405908018,
0.5505114794,
-0.3561550081,
-0.317748636,
-0.2909745574,
0.0152951684,
0.4025855958,
0.1434973329,
0.0575218722,
-0.0752368197,
0.4119093418,
0.2828924358,
0.2141168118,
-0.2556086183,
-0.7463379502,
0.2692451179,
-0.1948169023,
-0.0983247533,
0.4045586288,
0.3934724331,
0.2149293423,
-0.2868385017,
0.0190164354,
0.096714884,
0.243107751,
0.3309093118,
-0.6939304471,
-0.3302251995,
-0.0661600381,
-0.2652899325,
-0.0368479751,
0.2508039474,
-1.1147077084,
-0.317276448,
-0.4280518591,
0.6763452888,
-0.3227213025,
-0.3242239058,
-0.3536656201,
-0.1705386043,
-0.0735828653,
0.5507534146,
-0.6274320483,
0.4043841064,
0.4246459901,
1.0266327858,
-0.1852219552,
-0.1394541711,
-0.6049573421,
0.1829395443,
0.4494081736,
0.7580223083,
-0.6744354963,
-0.683015883,
0.4019679427,
0.2610322833,
-0.2034768611,
-0.1568543613,
0.3442487121,
-0.5348184109,
0.7210426927,
0.1347151399,
-0.7368474007,
-0.6097595692,
0.2655754983,
-0.5722810626,
0.9651182294,
0.0692321286,
-0.457090497,
0.1141522378,
-1.0195577145,
-0.375734061,
0.2320417762,
-0.3206563592,
-0.7462582588,
-0.4260474443,
-0.2530654669,
0.5284868479,
0.1315838099,
0.0790246129,
0.0733472854,
-0.2032472938,
0.4807177186,
-0.3339448869,
0.6761576533,
0.0190258697,
-0.4652325213,
0.2328846604,
-0.8598983884,
-0.0612913556,
-0.1377580613,
-0.6304745674,
-0.6058217287,
0.0782122314,
0.4473939538,
0.0662447587,
-0.1622274667,
-0.6328405738,
0.4365371466,
0.0807014406,
0.3832487464,
0.6705659628,
-0.0442115739,
0.3655025065,
-0.2779300511,
0.6744024158,
-0.0935519785,
0.2457033098,
-0.3775224388,
-0.7153070569,
-0.6066530347,
-0.7137782574,
0.1860763282,
0.6963784695,
-0.483112365,
-0.0755018443,
-0.4496479928,
-0.6150468588,
-0.5340865254,
0.0833335072,
0.1715929657,
0.2777153552,
0.7546718717,
-0.1610792875,
-0.6428403258,
-0.071629703,
0.2185373753,
0.0949477553,
-0.0684168264,
0.3668268919,
0.2038579136,
-0.4940343797,
0.7699998021,
-0.6021220088,
-0.7508281469,
-0.2913277745,
0.5327641964,
-0.0350572243,
0.2724228203,
0.4677429795,
-0.7693760395,
-0.473033607,
0.1907449663,
-0.6294141412,
-0.0506356321,
-0.3572933376,
0.2038941532,
-0.0526933074,
0.4025763273,
-0.3550178409,
0.3692926466,
0.1981695145,
-0.2051337808,
0.0367271528,
-0.1909040064,
0.4026004076,
-0.6822652221,
-0.3524772525,
-0.0596122071,
-0.2007467598,
-0.7865993381,
-0.2814384103,
0.0540977605,
-0.1266835481,
-0.406273663,
0.1122858301,
-0.3066187203,
-0.0422283113,
-0.4173363745,
0.0858907625,
-0.111976184,
0.406894207,
0.1849001646,
0.3953031003,
0.7276877761,
-0.7533640265,
0.4794643819,
0.4301075339,
-0.4688653946,
0.4794636071,
0.0736565739,
0.0517360009,
-0.0276048165,
0.3918239176,
-0.7432805896,
-0.3794327676,
0.0469098426,
-0.3596186042,
0.3307175636,
-0.1711006016,
-0.0441096686,
-0.0402755477,
-0.3294115067,
0.4754503667,
0.249563843,
-0.6273659468,
1.1180933714,
0.3202689886,
-0.20292826,
-0.4127995968,
-0.499150157,
-0.3665458262,
-0.3825623989,
-0.2019750923,
0.4573016465,
-0.0860298723,
-0.1446808726,
-0.163682878,
0.0677812174,
-0.4274919629,
0.1162630543,
0.6962607503,
0.6514274478,
-0.2222367674,
0.1050867513,
0.0473752208,
0.0597054362,
0.1949059069,
0.2172034234,
0.5269256234,
0.1199534386,
-0.5836181641,
-0.7378281951,
0.5094237924,
0.8747451305,
-0.1007117704,
0.3551086783,
1.0546010733,
-0.3433298171,
-0.050355386,
-0.5131186843,
-0.3902662098,
-0.4619168937,
0.4021654725,
0.1811892837,
-0.4891453385,
0.3664606214,
-0.2656412721,
0.1910481304,
0.1279293001,
0.1979813725,
-0.0610453673,
0.7193793654,
0.7458361983,
0.1264794767,
0.8872870207,
-0.5167188644,
0.0930550992,
-0.5940779448,
-0.7939597964,
-0.5920271277,
-0.1590849906,
-0.5079191327,
-0.3406816125,
0.5327866077,
-0.0832992792,
0.1335564405,
0.3252384067,
-0.608697772,
0.3369253576,
0.553661108,
0.1452678144,
0.2585184574,
0.2065088153,
0.1242104694,
-0.0962931812,
-0.4374807179,
-0.4092679024,
0.9267042875,
0.4741876721,
0.368486017,
0.5527939796,
0.6095466018,
0.5661793947,
0.6894264817,
-0.8102300763,
0.5635309219,
0.203441456,
-0.6046575308,
-0.4835903943,
-0.2903136015,
-0.9753293395,
0.2306660414,
-0.2784883976,
-0.7092430592,
-0.1156001389,
-0.1029450446,
-0.4434370995,
0.5286507607,
-0.6696648598,
0.9672190547,
-0.3036750257,
-0.2163613588,
-0.5519901514,
-0.376123935,
-0.0936321244,
-0.0362142362,
0.8126060367,
0.1237528324,
0.3687151968,
0.9787769914,
0.0145578571,
1.0175998211,
-0.2185475379,
0.0640042052,
0.4131967723,
0.0730350763,
0.0300789773,
-0.0956838354,
0.2436760515,
0.0611968003,
0.2828321159,
-0.1609346122,
-0.3577110469,
0.4933398068,
-1.1167514324,
-0.3958490491,
-0.6607290506,
-0.0467599481,
0.0454901569,
0.0170239378,
0.1948656291,
0.7930477262,
-0.0432633497,
0.1858227551,
0.5139417648,
-0.0007210887,
0.910430491,
0.5383846164,
-0.3074356019,
-0.3792268038,
1.493406415,
0.3395113647,
-0.0554564707,
0.6716757417,
0.1996294409,
-0.3721832633,
-0.3787366152,
-0.3666419387,
0.0201911572,
-1.0801200867,
-0.1621669233,
-0.5834476352,
-0.0438808016,
-0.5295105577,
-0.300839901,
0.0746679232,
-0.2375191003,
-0.6428996921,
-0.1852489263,
0.3643600941,
0.6949467659,
-0.0586626492,
0.4166478813,
-1.1125181913,
0.0456896499,
0.7225071788,
0.2141664177,
-0.0956601724,
-0.6143835187,
-0.1800741851,
-0.2388632596,
-0.9499149323,
-1.0319514275,
0.3367450535,
0.8180675507,
0.6440314651,
0.8443241715,
-0.0515301488,
0.5212744474,
-0.349031806,
0.8793992996,
0.4143155217,
-1.0388602018,
0.5740466714,
0.0104569588,
-0.1758966744,
0.145419538,
0.8536686897,
-0.5393829942,
-0.2924581468,
-0.5534170866,
-0.8980870247,
0.7588423491,
-0.0630182922,
0.2257706374,
0.1113390997,
-0.2328619808,
0.3935522437,
0.1654508263,
-1.0865558386,
-0.4364273548,
-0.7636976242,
-0.0824052021,
0.1289761662,
0.0311159212,
-0.2771360874,
-0.4304942489,
0.6214583516,
-0.0142574338,
0.2989725471,
0.0220981129,
-0.301484257,
-0.156606704,
0.6499474645,
0.6900068521,
0.5666950345,
-0.0990432277,
0.4255530536,
0.426482141,
-0.9152472615,
0.1945302039,
-0.0373800322,
0.2396703809,
0.4206373692,
0.5898808837,
0.5562469959,
0.541161716,
-0.7491530776,
0.7142828107,
0.0368496366,
0.0451608896,
-0.805944562,
0.3315020204,
-0.5433828235,
0.265335083,
0.5298071504,
0.1394855827,
0.3145983517,
-0.7474055886,
0.1685426831,
0.0017465036,
-0.3836589456,
-0.4966775179,
0.4350233674,
0.3555701375,
-0.6983882785,
0.5973355174,
0.0668230653,
-0.5462219715,
0.305429101,
0.4152372479,
0.7381298542,
-0.929710865,
0.426320523,
0.3850343227,
-0.2728585899,
0.1636862308,
0.3493167758,
-0.2959335148,
-0.5713418126,
-0.3357988,
-0.4217793643,
-0.473138541,
0.1775743514,
-0.9594598413,
0.3723269701,
-0.4094980955,
-0.3084227145,
0.4286137819,
-0.5154517889,
-0.4520873427,
0.1556147337,
0.2309316844,
0.1629517078,
-0.9630990624,
0.9551202059,
1.1502941847,
-0.0926216021,
-0.2142263204,
-0.4789117575,
0.1593288779,
-0.1864649951,
0.6133160591,
0.3804304898,
-0.035867665,
-0.1476535499,
-0.00167372,
-0.4019548893,
1.0973526239,
-0.1120958701,
-0.4917760193,
-0.0013699478,
0.3880055249,
0.3297001719,
-0.0579238385,
0.6015099287,
0.0035327072,
0.4905408621,
-0.2129867971,
-1.0831108093,
-0.5526030064,
-0.0957375243,
-0.655672133,
0.3288725019,
-0.3246073723,
0.5578734875,
0.0271606836,
-0.2549196184,
-0.5864669085,
0.6478289962,
-0.2524009645,
0.8570688963,
0.5588806272,
0.0951673761,
0.8260756731,
-0.3106343448,
0.5913158059,
0.0573694818,
0.4421442151,
0.7444663048,
0.1790844947,
0.9127588868,
0.3994715214,
-0.4636084139,
0.6954507828,
0.3734188676,
-0.2708987892,
0.464419812,
-0.177979663,
-0.8158173561,
-0.4866320491,
-0.1867371947,
-0.4777030647,
0.6633709669,
0.4967996776,
-0.1077789739,
0.01673159,
0.9000383615,
-0.1868257523,
0.1125798672,
-0.5576809645,
0.8751950264,
-0.1817647815,
-0.5247313976,
0.0994188786,
0.1294341236,
0.5391897559,
-0.4388391674,
-0.1873750538,
0.3058460653,
0.2313511521,
-0.5088863373,
-0.5417907834,
0.2026054859,
-0.1288919896,
-0.0828431398,
-0.3270846307,
0.2400598377,
-0.4821189642,
-0.2592637837,
0.2390202284,
0.1661449969,
0.1842153519,
0.3456493318,
-0.120904319,
-0.0032050365,
-0.1146862805,
0.0926344618,
0.4916972518,
0.3902476728,
0.0635828078,
0.5992330909,
0.4135091007,
-0.3493317068,
0.340659976,
0.0701802969,
0.555293262,
-0.3982521892,
-0.607780695,
-0.5652476549,
0.3652422726,
0.0098130628,
-0.4024429023,
0.8055428863,
0.6727190614,
1.0382633209,
-0.2423018813,
0.6767144799,
0.004215267,
0.4360105395,
-0.3177142739,
0.3212735951,
-0.3336238265,
0.1624122858,
-0.4631785452,
-0.4803825915,
-0.0270679425,
0.7852828503,
-0.1155880913,
-0.4146127403,
0.7139157653,
0.254345566,
-0.3528471291,
0.6754092574,
0.1221111789,
-0.0901170075,
0.3032326102,
0.0002256912,
0.8479313254,
-0.3829333186,
0.721472621,
-0.5047703981,
-0.3335495293,
-0.5224534869,
-0.5323684812,
-1.0759189129,
-0.846732676,
-0.8726981878,
-0.1165101826,
-0.5235337019,
1.2576879263,
0.5844835639,
-0.9432209134,
-0.3525050282,
0.0941240937,
0.1493895799,
-0.5619597435,
-0.2585208416,
0.4405606687,
0.054376021,
-0.7358084917,
0.5101490021,
-0.0379068702,
0.3100364208,
-0.2164545208,
0.1257261932,
-0.3171382248,
-0.0684466735,
0.7622247934,
0.3968017995,
-0.6627715826,
-0.2249246389,
0.1424916685,
0.2145087123,
0.1895999312,
0.9820069075,
-0.3296934068,
0.5090599656,
0.3823583126,
0.7319407463,
0.5517029166,
-0.4118260443,
-0.1432787925,
-0.7637668252,
-0.0945470259,
0.3110191822,
0.3946958184,
0.2463738471,
-0.2312116027,
0.1102992743,
0.525397718,
-0.6182718277,
-0.9367066622,
-0.3276931643,
-1.2376307249,
-0.2658609748,
0.8570975661,
-0.4588692188,
-0.0356900916,
-0.542622745,
-0.3435918987,
0.5721745491,
-0.1659219712,
1.1812207699,
0.7150424123,
-0.3727466464,
-0.2425301671,
-0.6011636853,
0.3939033151,
0.0390481763,
-0.8169910908,
-0.3237928748,
0.2902246416,
0.2112995386,
0.7355495691,
0.1860863715,
0.0511120334,
0.4771844149,
-0.4104184508,
0.0608872287,
-0.0152767869,
-0.6098842621,
-0.0206891727,
0.7835896611,
-0.4901200831,
-0.5368028283
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15407v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15407v2
|
A Comprehensive Analysis of the Effectiveness of Large Language Models as Automatic Dialogue Evaluators
| 2023-12-24T04:50:57 | 2024-01-20T06:26:33 |
Chen Zhang, Luis Fernando D'Haro, Yiming Chen, Malu Zhang, Haizhou Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automatic evaluation is an integral aspect of dialogue system research. The
traditional reference-based NLG metrics are generally found to be unsuitable
for dialogue assessment. Consequently, recent studies have suggested various
unique, reference-free neural metrics that better align with human evaluations.
Notably among them, large language models (LLMs), particularly the
instruction-tuned variants like ChatGPT, are shown to be promising substitutes
for human judges. Yet, existing works on utilizing LLMs for automatic dialogue
evaluation are limited in their scope in terms of the number of meta-evaluation
datasets, mode of evaluation, coverage of LLMs, etc. Hence, it remains
inconclusive how effective these LLMs are. To this end, we conduct a
comprehensive study on the application of LLMs for automatic dialogue
evaluation. Specifically, we analyze the multi-dimensional evaluation
capability of 30 recently emerged LLMs at both turn and dialogue levels, using
a comprehensive set of 12 meta-evaluation datasets. Additionally, we probe the
robustness of the LLMs in handling various adversarial perturbations at both
turn and dialogue levels. Finally, we explore how model-level and
dimension-level ensembles impact the evaluation performance. All resources are
available at https://github.com/e0397123/comp-analysis.
|
[
-0.4868219793,
-0.7682121396,
0.4910909832,
0.2593093812,
-0.0670999289,
0.2744066417,
-0.4352255762,
-0.3120003343,
-0.1393150091,
0.432505995,
-0.3315514624,
-0.432235837,
-0.693847537,
0.2453596741,
-0.65062958,
0.8464711308,
0.2015140206,
0.3196226954,
-0.0681256801,
-0.1098987535,
-0.319090575,
-0.5228641629,
-0.8029398322,
-0.3766092658,
0.4072878659,
-0.0402615853,
0.7781105042,
0.2713208199,
0.6214077473,
0.4438004196,
-0.1296144128,
0.0604906231,
-0.4007033706,
0.0196000803,
0.1043045819,
-0.2164061368,
-0.5861012936,
0.2578888237,
1.0021722317,
0.7155900598,
-0.3055177331,
0.0233401619,
0.1860007644,
0.3811238408,
-0.5798026323,
0.3113220334,
-0.6946136355,
0.2234053016,
0.1516765356,
-0.1181474328,
-0.5033961535,
-0.5715225935,
0.6847034097,
-0.3781422079,
-0.1862877905,
0.0167223644,
0.3680120409,
0.3711926639,
-0.4492036998,
-0.5179795623,
-0.7837183475,
0.8174680471,
-0.8790159822,
0.2193402201,
0.0065612071,
0.4007828832,
-0.2808061242,
-0.5272887945,
-0.3867183328,
-0.609962225,
-0.0663445666,
0.1525897384,
-0.4731147587,
0.3794092834,
0.2157214731,
0.553519249,
-0.4843230546,
0.2411854118,
-0.0744078904,
-0.2189012766,
0.5920309424,
0.5144491792,
0.3991803527,
-0.3620654345,
-0.1866850704,
-0.0717276484,
-0.3985137343,
-0.1358186901,
0.4150517881,
0.0737449676,
-0.0421647169,
0.3339766562,
-0.0336010978,
0.8967902064,
0.0190152153,
-0.0860997364,
-0.0051589604,
-0.4241577685,
-0.3473009765,
-0.3766233921,
1.384167552,
0.3240642548,
0.2733332217,
-0.2352728993,
-0.1799480617,
-0.2641172707,
0.2920034528,
-0.6873543859,
-0.1377570778,
-0.0766654015,
-0.5161449313,
-0.5153023005,
-0.2212830186,
-0.8938766718,
-0.5241808891,
-0.4353025854,
0.5153402686,
-0.2667128444,
-0.0472929925,
0.0968376696,
0.0190624278,
0.1310927868,
0.3834332824,
-0.6400072575,
0.4862263203,
0.6269242764,
0.7522791028,
-0.3400854766,
-0.1675207764,
-0.5343170166,
-0.4206907153,
-0.3663113713,
0.5937179923,
-0.7677858472,
-0.3845930994,
0.1053385139,
-0.0012774196,
-0.4373520315,
-0.6876006126,
0.6072848439,
-0.4989336729,
0.2021136284,
0.1278242171,
-0.4551535249,
-0.1406978965,
0.3754602671,
-0.6796506643,
0.5243137479,
0.0283746198,
-0.367203176,
0.0291292984,
-0.6912413239,
-0.1387383491,
-0.1602578759,
-0.0095856506,
-0.2476502806,
0.1953942329,
0.2460266948,
0.2769601345,
-0.6878502965,
0.3514193296,
-0.3149452209,
-0.4250209928,
0.5032455921,
-0.9758024216,
0.8263942003,
0.1270376146,
-0.2391844392,
0.2415077537,
-0.7309450507,
0.1627245098,
-0.1084161699,
-0.2831428349,
-0.0375396684,
-0.0279414374,
-0.2861317992,
0.0257169809,
-0.0042967945,
-0.2573584318,
0.2068323046,
-0.4105869234,
0.4564773142,
0.6258764863,
-0.058463458,
0.3556051254,
-0.0803864747,
0.7926573753,
-0.3762944341,
0.2326504886,
-0.2405307442,
-0.2235740721,
-0.8718870282,
-0.330568254,
0.5752786398,
0.5690741539,
-0.5663471222,
0.6588618755,
-0.1165683344,
-0.597001195,
-0.4186494052,
0.1009199098,
0.4920933545,
0.0135412943,
0.0145352827,
-0.5688840747,
-0.3758545518,
-0.9210752249,
-0.2442132086,
-0.1458120346,
-0.2019817531,
0.3714478612,
0.3402391672,
-0.2715418041,
0.7739164829,
-0.1703484207,
0.0944200829,
-0.2118881494,
0.2685642242,
0.0685892329,
0.0792941153,
0.3561675251,
-0.1619379818,
-0.4558010697,
-0.2590644956,
-0.6732276082,
-0.2863330841,
-0.0408471785,
0.0557301231,
0.0203210022,
0.2459615767,
-0.7625706792,
0.2774841189,
0.741015017,
-0.0983117595,
0.7644852996,
-0.1058655903,
0.15422903,
-0.5449569225,
-0.0310940091,
0.1399732977,
-0.2633176148,
-0.5789679289,
-0.1127993912,
-0.1262237281,
-0.1728580147,
-0.1681828201,
0.5573000908,
-0.2836951315,
-0.3953914642,
-0.2624575794,
0.4647104144,
-0.1168929636,
0.5318683386,
-0.1566889286,
0.6279166341,
0.3128583729,
-0.4860518873,
0.7327542901,
0.1525859088,
-0.892126441,
0.4399956465,
-0.7524983883,
0.3775478005,
0.2750739157,
0.6444827318,
-1.0397713184,
-0.0703428984,
0.29692325,
-0.1570419073,
0.3362460732,
-0.1037530676,
-0.5001146793,
-0.2436803132,
-0.1917354912,
0.3530258238,
0.4077682495,
-0.5694031715,
0.5682553053,
0.4239566922,
-0.3001713753,
-0.4395820498,
-0.1373190731,
0.4682795107,
-0.3341277242,
-0.6502894163,
-0.1534053385,
-0.1113932356,
-0.4520520568,
-0.3643845022,
0.0722991675,
0.1549929976,
0.1672773957,
0.042256806,
0.2834934592,
-0.0825334862,
0.0409402698,
-0.3336130679,
-0.1748884022,
0.2540122867,
-0.1649643481,
0.6510918736,
-0.4608308971,
-0.6479398012,
-0.5989761353,
0.0011463125,
0.7061591744,
-0.1824196279,
0.380063802,
0.7171166539,
0.0012611899,
0.0210283175,
-0.6537498236,
-0.0479373671,
-0.4118204117,
0.5312905312,
-0.0739552379,
-0.6822143793,
0.4046768546,
-0.10877534,
0.1981188655,
0.513633728,
0.722366631,
0.0934726968,
1.2216541767,
0.1899382472,
-0.2293140739,
0.3787950277,
-0.2387548536,
0.3970620632,
-1.1722362041,
-0.0341566615,
-0.5012564063,
-0.1464137435,
-0.5221649408,
-0.4343964756,
0.518658042,
-0.1844926476,
-0.0551063083,
0.1285002381,
-0.3459614217,
0.2932188511,
0.1473717541,
-0.2444165945,
0.3671735525,
-0.1535481066,
-0.1162632257,
0.1036219224,
-0.7695832849,
-0.8081277609,
1.0958602428,
0.7625055909,
0.8974407315,
-0.1305304021,
0.2270054221,
0.2851226926,
0.3018826842,
-1.1057729721,
0.5947762728,
-0.2134523094,
-0.4614424109,
-0.5256868601,
-0.4860222042,
-0.8072444797,
0.5948329568,
-0.0057976972,
-0.849406898,
0.0256976578,
-0.1261714548,
-0.6390401721,
0.142647922,
-0.8001024127,
0.7702476978,
-0.4944198728,
-0.0503234975,
-0.3874128759,
-0.4280567169,
0.4507534802,
-0.2158944905,
0.1179648861,
-0.0334949866,
0.2758128345,
0.8375216126,
-0.1737946719,
0.8716378212,
-0.116313234,
-0.3272270262,
0.3797958195,
0.1212431416,
0.4341804087,
-0.0113264853,
-0.109949559,
0.3262660205,
0.1410565674,
0.0577841774,
-0.8746025562,
0.6076973677,
-0.786929965,
-0.75927037,
-0.3371605277,
-0.6713209748,
-0.463684082,
-0.2158368826,
-0.1262371391,
0.6018218994,
-0.495922327,
0.4874551296,
0.5462210178,
-0.5283616781,
0.3748732209,
0.5963886976,
-0.2829086483,
-0.5612527132,
0.7112425566,
-0.0904614255,
0.4781002104,
-0.0243540499,
0.3159928322,
-0.2491116822,
-0.4791293442,
-0.5856549144,
-0.0444431305,
-0.6512870789,
0.0221017879,
-0.5372093916,
-0.4056923091,
-0.1686001718,
0.2988987267,
-0.2381287664,
-0.4672931433,
0.0645524487,
0.0996173397,
-0.1747710705,
0.8979063034,
0.1049486324,
0.4254997075,
-0.8009309173,
0.1713776886,
0.5179598927,
0.2911930382,
0.2399138361,
-0.6769303679,
-0.1964584291,
0.1702684015,
-0.4351549149,
-0.5017624497,
0.3064928353,
0.158971563,
0.6933335662,
0.390232265,
-0.2365318835,
0.5049238801,
-0.4933731556,
0.7664942741,
0.0779504701,
-0.9590323567,
-0.0011491399,
-0.361431241,
0.5486590266,
0.323218286,
0.0896214023,
-0.5794650912,
-0.4593844712,
-0.4267959893,
-0.5159519315,
0.9101382494,
0.2324851453,
0.2135704756,
0.0776590779,
0.1752673239,
-0.0133250402,
0.1744223833,
-0.5136423707,
-0.0650483742,
0.029672347,
-0.1512326449,
-0.1134800911,
-0.3875517845,
-0.4280921221,
-0.1358022988,
0.5565048456,
-0.1113242581,
0.3219565749,
-0.0777179748,
-0.0941318348,
-0.0740331858,
0.3994796276,
0.4454301,
0.6657350659,
-0.048161801,
-0.2396450192,
0.4925024509,
-0.0915926471,
0.1185557693,
0.0370617099,
0.094676055,
0.0480457321,
0.5506844521,
1.0734528303,
0.3668743372,
-0.6033859849,
0.4721978605,
-0.3952783048,
-0.0414693356,
-0.4370104373,
0.1123567745,
-0.0223883428,
0.2987199724,
0.1849324405,
-0.0471898429,
0.2272455692,
-0.6904685497,
-0.0207780953,
0.8376384377,
-0.4460340738,
-0.1831241846,
0.0052362839,
0.4804371893,
-0.416293323,
0.7071475387,
0.0921130776,
-0.7242885828,
0.6646223664,
0.2937428057,
1.1208262444,
-0.3028331399,
0.0928234458,
0.2700024843,
0.3337693214,
0.1127171591,
-0.4616125226,
-0.125735268,
-0.6065687537,
-0.5556619167,
-0.8303250074,
-0.6176921129,
0.4448126554,
-0.415925473,
0.1681421995,
-0.4227390587,
-0.2902095914,
-0.0012166838,
0.0245953444,
-0.6932920814,
0.1273288131,
0.3157332242,
0.7372058034,
-0.4444124401,
0.4847567976,
0.2609812319,
0.1322042495,
-0.5329749584,
0.1496113539,
0.2462205887,
-0.7805874348,
0.6072857976,
0.0243895892,
-0.3180141151,
-0.312094599,
-0.2820933759,
-0.902739346,
0.7872688174,
0.3362239003,
-0.8310022354,
-0.2158599645,
0.2194526345,
0.8489357233,
-0.5259231329,
1.0685355663,
0.9827977419,
0.6132592559,
0.1707189381,
-1.4516067505,
-0.2644186914,
-0.091938518,
0.0132317459,
0.1219188422,
-0.8008549213,
0.3072505593,
0.1602467597,
-0.0152901057,
0.3299013376,
0.1893921643,
0.0042256019,
0.0215801857,
0.7518487573,
0.4354277551,
0.4936988652,
-0.1853493154,
1.1021939516,
-0.4318319559,
0.3109843135,
1.0270190239,
-0.1985867918,
0.5249199271,
0.0049680341,
-0.2567631304,
0.3484433293,
0.462005198,
-0.1436718702,
0.1986636221,
0.5622350574,
-0.1909560412,
-0.3627996147,
0.0445581786,
0.0789873973,
0.7696638703,
0.5453650355,
-0.4312570393,
-0.232561782,
-0.1202554107,
-0.2249904722,
-0.359798491,
-0.0969302878,
0.9949801564,
0.2503193617,
-0.7708596587,
0.6471766233,
-0.1164617613,
0.3523840904,
-0.5732074976,
0.0689249337,
0.0603766479,
0.1369901448,
-0.2032430619,
-0.5335426331,
0.2053513378,
0.1828102618,
0.3337730765,
-0.0363923609,
0.6307778955,
-0.3472715318,
-0.3791876435,
0.4030266106,
0.3991465867,
0.2669553161,
0.0971785411,
-0.7849643826,
0.2003348321,
0.0264845528,
-0.4031808674,
0.3311959207,
0.3338859677,
0.0185271688,
0.7620429397,
0.4210487008,
-0.0080388207,
-0.0590930805,
0.4063290358,
0.6501244903,
-0.5197156072,
0.0869621411,
-0.9217181802,
0.4147008359,
-0.0950516835,
-0.1435962617,
0.7323839664,
0.3941239417,
0.5176087618,
0.2404351085,
0.9685422778,
0.1396888942,
0.3855606019,
-0.5524746776,
0.6034817696,
-0.2866927981,
0.4150277376,
-0.4405241907,
-1.2780314684,
-0.0937497318,
0.5717113614,
-0.6206588149,
0.1777010262,
0.6420198679,
0.5885931849,
0.0575140119,
0.2002509534,
0.5172036886,
0.2820046842,
0.5435394049,
0.3421288729,
1.3495334387,
-0.3591078222,
0.6912189126,
0.0331808291,
-0.3199062347,
-0.2476916611,
-0.7164075375,
-1.1224564314,
-0.3417894542,
-0.2591640651,
-0.0906427354,
0.0649676174,
1.0132000446,
0.6187544465,
-0.7131807804,
-0.5389056206,
0.2832319736,
-0.0699509084,
0.3145580888,
-0.1895801872,
0.2125896513,
-0.4793563187,
-1.0539908409,
0.670486927,
0.3996256292,
-0.2593410611,
-0.7176582813,
-0.0400520414,
0.0885688663,
0.2314958721,
0.7178553939,
-0.1144595742,
-0.8646402359,
-0.2950746119,
-0.1978495419,
-0.1551876515,
-0.078760013,
0.9184477925,
-0.6030343771,
0.6513080597,
0.4248034656,
0.57682693,
0.1944171935,
0.0083573749,
1.0783863068,
-0.1687558293,
-0.1879225373,
0.3007059395,
0.4585204422,
0.3885582983,
0.0295816362,
0.4808939993,
-0.1076291874,
-0.8923378587,
-0.681618154,
0.0296588503,
-0.6003465056,
0.0922454447,
1.2977278233,
-0.2803971767,
0.0294093955,
0.0590068027,
-0.3415928185,
0.1958871484,
-0.3558630049,
0.9936021566,
1.1564012766,
-0.1501848102,
-0.1358539909,
-0.5555651188,
0.4804341793,
0.527448535,
-0.7301496863,
0.1178168058,
0.5519579649,
0.0927828103,
0.3384079933,
0.2536308467,
-0.2439939827,
0.0361447744,
-0.3814990819,
-0.192461744,
0.2250622511,
-0.3347670436,
-0.8004344106,
-0.0740437806,
0.1712477803,
0.1063013375
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15398v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15398v1
|
Fairness-Aware Structured Pruning in Transformers
| 2023-12-24T03:57:52 | 2023-12-24T03:57:52 |
Abdelrahman Zayed, Goncalo Mordido, Samira Shabanian, Ioana Baldini, Sarath Chandar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
The increasing size of large language models (LLMs) has introduced challenges
in their training and inference. Removing model components is perceived as a
solution to tackle the large model sizes, however, existing pruning methods
solely focus on performance, without considering an essential aspect for the
responsible use of LLMs: model fairness. It is crucial to address the fairness
of LLMs towards diverse groups, such as women, Black people, LGBTQ+, Jewish
communities, among others, as they are being deployed and available to a wide
audience. In this work, first, we investigate how attention heads impact
fairness and performance in pre-trained transformer-based language models. We
then propose a novel method to prune the attention heads that negatively impact
fairness while retaining the heads critical for performance, i.e. language
modeling capabilities. Our approach is practical in terms of time and
resources, as it does not require fine-tuning the final pruned, and fairer,
model. Our findings demonstrate a reduction in gender bias by 19%, 19.5%,
39.5%, 34.7%, 23%, and 8% for DistilGPT-2, GPT-2, GPT-Neo of two different
sizes, GPT-J, and Llama 2 models, respectively, in comparison to the biased
model, with only a slight decrease in performance.
|
[
-0.4019066393,
-0.5106778145,
0.3928661644,
0.3782744408,
-0.101938501,
-0.1521954238,
-0.4427597225,
-0.2429713607,
-0.2477467656,
0.5072885156,
-0.8215059638,
-0.1846396029,
-0.7142698169,
0.0824217945,
-0.5747567415,
1.159286499,
0.3742903769,
-0.0478335097,
-0.124037303,
-0.1054319888,
-0.7209540009,
-0.3940593302,
-0.6082752943,
-0.4179940522,
0.4934658706,
0.3307540417,
0.8849461079,
0.864066124,
0.7010850906,
0.4097896814,
-0.5953166485,
-0.1923194379,
-0.6886848211,
0.0302521419,
-0.4618736804,
-0.743543148,
-0.6854491234,
0.181008637,
0.7243961096,
0.851939857,
-0.501393199,
0.4075343609,
0.2062141895,
0.6409981847,
-0.6653857231,
0.152768448,
-0.8607214689,
0.4579111338,
-0.3333880901,
0.0511720814,
-0.5580204129,
-0.2598743141,
-0.1051106453,
-0.4819898009,
0.6017462611,
-0.1157670841,
0.9070987105,
0.625018537,
-0.3456724584,
0.4212316573,
-0.8927120566,
1.127456665,
-0.5944809914,
0.5923144221,
0.1243298426,
0.4620755613,
0.0981544778,
-0.8545480967,
-0.551877737,
0.3047978282,
-0.3893054426,
0.1540852636,
-0.1568649858,
0.1955392957,
0.6463602185,
0.4161086082,
-0.256426543,
0.0472842604,
-0.4017315507,
-0.1942763776,
0.3907796144,
-0.0356685296,
-0.1875860691,
-0.1493699104,
0.0071541099,
-0.069196932,
-0.7902222872,
0.0166337695,
0.6010056138,
0.1926119179,
0.0837369263,
0.4910931587,
0.0435930416,
0.5770458579,
0.2727312446,
-0.4508813918,
0.3225410879,
-0.0600867122,
-0.3940614164,
-0.2799457312,
0.4881523252,
0.4515344203,
0.7578191161,
-0.3254662156,
-0.2740032077,
0.2224374413,
0.4003307819,
-0.8150467873,
0.0337824151,
0.025954416,
-0.5900475979,
-0.2997642159,
-0.0544671901,
-0.627738297,
-0.1369809061,
-0.4843118787,
0.1500898451,
-0.0381502286,
-0.475776583,
-0.0650966167,
-0.0166964121,
0.4607979059,
0.255910635,
-0.8512505293,
0.3333702087,
1.0062826872,
0.5102584958,
-0.0473541245,
0.0555431992,
-0.5552182198,
0.241799742,
0.0931599066,
0.228550151,
-0.5924381614,
-0.3041121662,
-0.3455296159,
0.1380975097,
-0.0263933819,
-0.8134303689,
0.7300972342,
-0.395077616,
0.2298181802,
-0.1736557335,
-0.0904604271,
-0.2814695537,
0.2592113316,
-0.6057255268,
0.6654198766,
0.2409006953,
-0.9730691314,
0.296710968,
-0.3452427089,
-0.7329833508,
-0.2269054353,
-0.528003335,
-0.8540931344,
0.2947050631,
0.3830055594,
0.2682169974,
-0.1473617405,
0.8715321422,
-0.152486667,
-0.5598278046,
-0.1137214378,
-0.5259588957,
0.7360278368,
0.1639758497,
-0.6203305125,
0.298955828,
-0.513685286,
-0.2431120425,
0.2093192339,
0.0801531225,
0.0888843015,
0.1312271953,
0.0484494865,
0.5717460513,
-0.2057388723,
-0.4926159084,
-0.1888150126,
-0.7310073972,
0.5496507287,
1.2274830341,
-0.4460229576,
0.6623678803,
-0.2880483568,
0.623048842,
0.1061578766,
0.5469176769,
0.1397223473,
-0.3645309508,
-0.95006001,
-0.4685626924,
0.4585769475,
0.4038222134,
-0.5034343004,
0.4703715146,
-0.3989938498,
-0.1696709245,
-0.7423725128,
-0.1107708514,
0.3857124448,
0.6666192412,
0.0286434665,
-0.468839556,
-0.3517999649,
-1.3653914928,
-0.5167505145,
0.0131872082,
-0.2907420695,
0.4047174156,
0.2330551744,
0.0687940568,
1.4920356274,
-0.3787108362,
-0.5436325669,
-0.261074692,
-0.4198397994,
0.3767124414,
0.4661312997,
0.4104307592,
-1.1505014896,
-0.2283120751,
-0.2255952209,
-0.5335615873,
-0.1922843158,
0.1806106865,
0.0478529669,
-0.1602763236,
0.3075887263,
-0.6815043688,
0.6601499915,
0.5315562487,
-0.2702455223,
0.3534636497,
0.2348558903,
-0.0973102823,
-0.5793745518,
0.1281543672,
0.0459506363,
-0.6326263547,
-0.437279284,
0.1266279072,
0.0555390231,
-0.1272431463,
-0.7745787501,
0.5157143474,
-0.2509430945,
-0.4215219915,
-0.2224742472,
-0.0272523947,
0.1190326884,
0.7956272364,
0.1383746117,
0.7322027087,
0.2794585228,
-0.6255605221,
-0.3520589471,
0.2921773791,
0.0350159444,
0.3923052549,
-0.7643456459,
0.1258689314,
-0.5276632905,
0.2302554697,
-0.586982429,
0.2241649032,
0.3414176404,
-0.2562891543,
0.3629777431,
-0.2690966129,
-0.3471997082,
-0.3030191064,
-0.1819234937,
0.6980075836,
0.631306529,
-0.338730216,
0.9238359928,
0.6850251555,
-0.3943799436,
-0.7333005667,
-0.6640487313,
-0.2654023468,
-0.400531888,
-0.7717506289,
0.6991092563,
0.0005383922,
-0.3985005319,
-0.0979484394,
-0.4466092288,
0.0920350999,
0.2680510581,
0.3241021037,
0.0231249705,
0.2838558853,
-0.035252206,
-0.0255558696,
-0.3653808832,
-0.0457380377,
0.1144497767,
0.6160005331,
-0.0971968472,
-0.4231343567,
-0.3575419486,
0.2050389796,
0.2819030285,
-0.708285749,
0.7998046875,
0.8648470044,
-0.3427993059,
-0.125367552,
-0.6732349396,
-0.6044568419,
-0.5893725753,
0.5680195093,
-0.2770112753,
-1.3124775887,
0.4676532447,
0.1167081222,
0.5024709702,
0.3791309893,
0.6157487631,
0.1906868517,
1.0867143869,
0.9200309515,
-0.0326346755,
0.545072794,
-0.0468601398,
0.613627851,
-0.8307728767,
-0.1427877843,
-0.6318472624,
-0.5732851624,
-0.5364910364,
-0.5430253148,
0.2437265366,
-0.078006655,
-0.2258888632,
-0.0392378457,
-0.7330343127,
0.4612451494,
0.4400912225,
0.1577067226,
0.3928749561,
-0.0107894866,
0.3679464161,
-0.3944403827,
-0.7386679053,
-0.3709972799,
1.0443886518,
0.6628171206,
0.3622609079,
0.0874244198,
0.3686910272,
0.0761402696,
0.6953066587,
-0.7162098289,
0.6659360528,
-0.2326388508,
-0.6857069135,
-0.2477781177,
-0.8968149424,
-0.8072788715,
0.6205154061,
0.1313713789,
-0.4470642805,
0.099153161,
0.1430547982,
-0.3055444062,
0.3342288435,
-0.6863028407,
0.7685172558,
0.1662966907,
-0.3006591201,
-0.5110703111,
-0.6110574603,
0.5771211386,
-0.0874205381,
0.5168989301,
-0.4207167625,
0.2316870689,
0.9487428665,
-0.4438848197,
0.6575163007,
-0.294564873,
-0.0794272125,
0.0950150639,
0.1205031276,
0.576459527,
0.0075843097,
0.0185777321,
0.4813961387,
-0.6139114499,
-0.2672324181,
-0.4471797347,
0.3539345264,
-0.5897493362,
-0.9566059709,
-0.2967374623,
-0.7087929249,
-0.2774240673,
0.0837261304,
-0.1170221344,
0.1697056592,
0.1426526159,
0.3133758307,
0.6129507422,
-0.4758234322,
0.5726904869,
0.4898501933,
-0.1999259293,
-0.0052934652,
0.65456599,
0.1216393858,
0.2064425945,
0.0970740095,
0.0926249698,
-0.1031672806,
-0.5803678036,
0.2704368532,
0.3241490126,
-0.5298039317,
-0.2332281768,
-0.849234581,
-0.391030252,
-0.4193556309,
0.1795934141,
-0.5732985139,
-0.6122306585,
0.0860167295,
-0.2671273351,
0.0580926538,
0.2513332069,
0.1716942489,
0.8180552721,
-0.5183047652,
0.5263203979,
0.4267835617,
0.6209582686,
0.1787259132,
-0.7818797231,
0.1149290651,
-0.1809363514,
-0.4959997833,
-0.457896173,
0.5358247757,
0.0419933572,
0.5488477349,
0.2985074222,
-0.0780168027,
0.6092963219,
-0.7122748494,
0.3265227675,
0.2960901856,
-0.9015133977,
0.3058719337,
-0.3751983643,
0.2303726375,
0.4093328118,
-0.2018868625,
-0.6448340416,
-0.7094509602,
-0.7438377142,
-1.078810811,
1.0355324745,
0.6003819108,
-0.0353637002,
0.0145309195,
0.2261366397,
0.0865822881,
0.5936123133,
-1.1100424528,
-0.4866271019,
0.0318579003,
-0.3349324465,
0.2177733928,
-0.1338323355,
-0.0503925271,
-0.4059972167,
0.6044566631,
0.1425789446,
0.153854236,
-0.0580703504,
-0.3652738333,
0.0608279034,
0.362419188,
0.2166146934,
0.8321197629,
-0.1030988023,
-0.1340577304,
0.0368103646,
-0.4876878858,
0.1437521279,
-0.0592887402,
-0.4394727647,
-0.0535562932,
0.0545819141,
0.5892502666,
0.137749657,
-0.5691667795,
0.6433973908,
-0.331725508,
-0.0237486605,
-0.0916141123,
0.1019169092,
0.0775715038,
0.1897717267,
0.2170755416,
0.2949180901,
0.1199864894,
-0.1777791232,
0.2696616054,
0.3446456194,
-0.4454333186,
-0.2042690814,
0.6122216582,
0.4499582648,
-0.4014924467,
0.7077141404,
-0.0267473236,
-0.5428950191,
0.6796693802,
0.2694924474,
0.7727412581,
-0.3084599376,
0.0210711006,
0.2286537439,
0.5706708431,
-0.0872500241,
-0.3048634827,
0.0776557699,
-0.7427609563,
-0.6938439608,
-0.7589324713,
-0.0577330515,
-0.0236485433,
-0.6416323185,
0.0721829459,
-0.4749569297,
-0.5703014731,
-0.292460084,
-0.1975655109,
-1.0645638704,
0.2309490293,
0.1202604175,
0.5990918279,
-0.7576915026,
0.5932977796,
0.1903690994,
-0.0611989796,
-0.8779873848,
-0.0679419637,
-0.1191793457,
-0.5378130674,
0.3978216946,
0.4975309074,
0.0400932208,
0.1170274764,
-0.1626206785,
-0.6825805902,
0.8963737488,
0.932982564,
-1.207515955,
-0.2816981077,
0.2221800089,
0.0290833563,
0.0955084339,
0.6174098253,
0.8435269594,
0.6130930781,
-0.1936527193,
-1.2288705111,
-0.170268625,
-0.079632692,
-0.0125449942,
0.2447195947,
-0.899305284,
0.9922456145,
0.0135466438,
-0.3314982951,
-0.439961344,
0.7330898643,
0.5410041809,
-0.0294698179,
0.9891804457,
0.6081516147,
0.7322481275,
-0.4028655887,
0.8829442263,
-0.016677754,
0.4190371633,
0.9623278975,
-0.4234455824,
0.1914289296,
0.7483440638,
-0.2770908475,
-0.0332150273,
0.4138553143,
0.2608584762,
0.4347075522,
0.220067814,
0.0196684878,
-0.3989183903,
-0.1876554936,
-0.4605351686,
0.4156291783,
-0.0061020539,
-0.1810056865,
-0.3531965017,
-0.0192709863,
0.1616466194,
0.2457732856,
-0.5066308379,
0.5822840929,
0.3621094227,
-0.6500600576,
0.0428987145,
0.497464776,
1.010731101,
-0.4494764209,
0.1018748209,
-0.2863960266,
0.5227126479,
-0.2567849755,
-0.6601954699,
0.5329988599,
0.0387772545,
-0.4376794994,
-0.4930291474,
0.6957090497,
-0.3767921329,
-0.6270135045,
0.4299895167,
0.4181630909,
-0.1846549362,
-0.2988532186,
-0.7499509454,
0.108785592,
0.2274833769,
-0.4363836348,
0.44272542,
0.2738247812,
-0.2415702343,
0.8511285186,
0.4451026618,
0.0396195054,
-0.0791589394,
0.4750985503,
0.8410960436,
-0.72166574,
-0.6468870044,
-0.9761214256,
0.6279271841,
-0.079575561,
0.0897413045,
0.6357711554,
0.4121923447,
0.8464574814,
0.1045473665,
0.4351748526,
0.1334891766,
0.5741157532,
-0.0565315373,
0.7729173899,
-0.3254545629,
0.3255292475,
-0.4164116085,
-1.2316588163,
-0.1791792363,
0.767463088,
-0.3553375006,
0.4884881079,
0.3384274244,
0.8374248743,
-0.1850935668,
-0.0528645329,
0.2094850242,
0.1681126505,
0.6865426898,
0.4617484808,
0.5746902227,
-0.2372707129,
0.7003336549,
-0.1949906796,
-0.1947895586,
0.0667738095,
-0.8820616007,
-0.7393064499,
0.07733991,
-0.3225277066,
-0.0113640539,
0.0691133291,
0.4709478021,
0.8711650372,
-0.5301603079,
-0.0841119885,
0.1642029285,
0.4205405712,
-0.2097675055,
-0.268409431,
0.3100912571,
-0.0920071453,
-0.7026613355,
-0.0195521954,
0.3142873645,
-0.461596936,
-0.0650862157,
-0.1678523123,
0.0658133999,
-0.157357201,
0.5861402154,
-0.2442237139,
-0.6176123619,
-0.3367233574,
-0.2606745958,
0.0329930484,
0.2357392758,
0.7174500227,
-1.0627579689,
-0.0986761525,
0.0588723086,
0.4235351384,
0.4675069451,
0.1189779714,
0.8195616007,
-1.2223792076,
0.827591598,
0.63976717,
0.389955312,
0.4950268269,
-0.2029104531,
0.5489699841,
0.3819705844,
-0.3595064878,
-1.0850412846,
0.3086261153,
-0.6933305264,
-0.1777402461,
0.951218009,
0.0839599669,
-0.3478970826,
0.0954063237,
-0.0634183735,
0.5247238278,
-0.2729757428,
0.6134301424,
0.4981439412,
0.5686683059,
-0.317748189,
-0.4750728011,
0.3138712347,
0.8072754145,
-0.5201239586,
0.2987106144,
0.2969278991,
0.2976359725,
-0.1765950322,
0.7316659689,
-0.3863202333,
0.2207911611,
-0.5663610101,
0.2745861113,
-0.1569499671,
-0.5238389373,
-0.2499886751,
0.4593110979,
-0.0473612361,
0.0872034281
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15395v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15395v1
|
Prompt Valuation Based on Shapley Values
| 2023-12-24T03:37:11 | 2023-12-24T03:37:11 |
Hanxi Liu, Xiaokai Mao, Haocheng Xia, Jian Lou, Jinfei Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.DB, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) excel on new tasks without additional training,
simply by providing natural language prompts that demonstrate how the task
should be performed. Prompt ensemble methods comprehensively harness the
knowledge of LLMs while mitigating individual biases and errors and further
enhancing performance. However, more prompts do not necessarily lead to better
results, and not all prompts are beneficial. A small number of high-quality
prompts often outperform many low-quality prompts. Currently, there is a lack
of a suitable method for evaluating the impact of prompts on the results. In
this paper, we utilize the Shapley value to fairly quantify the contributions
of prompts, helping to identify beneficial or detrimental prompts, and
potentially guiding prompt valuation in data markets. Through extensive
experiments employing various ensemble methods and utility functions on diverse
tasks, we validate the effectiveness of using the Shapley value method for
prompts as it effectively distinguishes and quantifies the contributions of
each prompt.
|
[
-0.106617026,
-0.6143680811,
0.7107357979,
0.4291011095,
-0.0262320228,
-0.0751046389,
-0.2389326692,
-0.3039574027,
0.4196941555,
0.3903798461,
-0.2446433008,
-0.114737615,
-0.5302941203,
-0.0297798384,
-0.0578558221,
0.9395390749,
0.3065320849,
0.0570112057,
-0.4675751925,
0.1963519156,
-0.5324345231,
-0.5795198679,
-0.6649298072,
-0.1353159547,
0.3894885182,
0.5299652219,
0.6501343846,
0.3778173029,
0.3104485571,
0.2903027236,
-0.3019320369,
0.0941510126,
-0.4273055792,
0.496887356,
0.1535834372,
-0.4102922976,
-0.0941645056,
0.3221499622,
0.5554709435,
0.9668890238,
0.0632205829,
0.2694505155,
0.3183256984,
0.5994809866,
-0.6758013964,
0.2930741608,
-0.3326943517,
-0.2213461548,
-0.3439362049,
-0.2842437327,
-0.3527375758,
-0.7437009811,
0.1093928143,
-0.3669758141,
-0.1804079413,
0.1750376225,
0.7869540453,
0.0655384064,
-0.1695257872,
-0.3938263953,
-0.3601559997,
1.2175244093,
-0.5779409409,
0.1172615811,
0.4827561677,
0.2376911044,
-0.3265583515,
-0.3159561157,
-0.3519963026,
-0.7838522196,
-0.0019641097,
0.0173594598,
-0.2669652402,
0.0611950494,
0.3164907396,
0.5617772937,
-0.095594503,
0.3356507421,
-0.2999038398,
-0.4561256468,
0.7010208964,
0.5296826363,
0.2380242646,
-0.5087198019,
-0.5295411348,
-0.1575067937,
-0.4380853772,
0.9415781498,
0.7681150436,
0.5002177954,
0.006004246,
0.5930740833,
-0.2159804255,
0.713566184,
0.3111897707,
-0.4874198437,
0.0788114443,
-0.5606990457,
0.0689702034,
0.0362480208,
0.6778903008,
0.4541142881,
0.1122401431,
-0.2308535725,
-0.4096209109,
-0.2318843305,
-0.1035994142,
-0.9366721511,
-0.2388047576,
0.5303851366,
-0.6070556641,
-0.4702895582,
-0.2586379051,
-0.5676060319,
-0.7938065529,
-0.461358279,
0.3991030455,
-0.6425766945,
0.0786688849,
-0.1950505823,
-0.4206043482,
0.0283953268,
0.5749784112,
-0.9776381254,
0.144309178,
0.5601371527,
0.8108860254,
-0.4229737818,
-0.3059745431,
-0.860665679,
-0.2372889668,
-0.4197947979,
1.337515831,
-0.7267352939,
-0.4604683518,
-0.089851886,
-0.308930099,
0.1108809412,
-0.6214010119,
0.918353796,
-0.4247373939,
0.2799732685,
-0.982334137,
-0.6803418994,
-0.0775729418,
0.1733158231,
-0.8760747313,
0.9058352709,
0.2141456902,
-0.5478495955,
0.5795353651,
-0.6633414626,
-0.4852860272,
0.3768086731,
0.1236435845,
0.0642369166,
0.094490841,
0.2532875836,
0.7052651048,
-0.3729447126,
0.3696349859,
-0.3485121727,
-0.2777663171,
0.6563008428,
-0.6957913041,
0.9327697754,
0.3578824699,
0.0346781537,
0.1284925491,
-0.5530426502,
0.1223180369,
-0.2592203617,
-0.2392519861,
-0.5424112082,
-0.2996573448,
0.067416586,
-0.0333056822,
0.3861946464,
-0.3452285528,
0.1112007573,
-0.4513694346,
0.1612423211,
0.952475071,
0.2919587195,
0.429980725,
-0.7453867197,
0.8089449406,
0.0077333231,
-0.0540602021,
-0.3165037036,
-0.5188837051,
-0.264557004,
-0.6283111572,
0.3447366357,
0.5138661861,
-0.5348172188,
0.2847034633,
-0.0353958011,
-0.4051780403,
-0.3313673437,
-0.0356508791,
-0.143450588,
0.4846509099,
0.0604982115,
0.1996292472,
-0.2951850593,
-0.9321593046,
-0.456636101,
-0.1169550568,
-0.088141337,
0.4318669438,
0.2577665448,
0.3433869183,
1.0526182652,
-0.2766255438,
0.0884868354,
-0.1362632364,
0.1709214449,
0.6307465434,
0.1985371411,
0.4164038897,
-0.3421890736,
-0.2652768791,
-0.3394837379,
-0.3413226902,
-0.5017873049,
-0.341574043,
-0.0268627387,
0.0403738953,
-0.0165114738,
-0.3115118742,
0.0598247312,
0.6711908579,
-0.3968193233,
0.8430786729,
-0.0564817451,
0.8734729886,
-0.92347157,
0.2512215078,
0.0413268916,
-0.1617486179,
-0.4285435081,
-0.290176034,
-0.0388444476,
-0.0911071897,
-0.3884452879,
0.8151590824,
-0.1627448946,
0.0432631113,
-0.3186066747,
0.1306304187,
0.0041664117,
0.1101356074,
-0.2766215801,
1.3516381979,
0.4846645892,
-0.9373764396,
0.6168826222,
0.3194618225,
-0.5941109657,
1.0771840811,
-0.814819932,
-0.2748081088,
-0.0076184934,
0.0362935886,
-1.1640970707,
-0.1015984789,
0.1722262055,
-0.4328123629,
-0.1146248952,
-0.3144327998,
-0.486980021,
-0.0267833378,
-0.7916782498,
0.4341172874,
0.5169622898,
-0.6120768189,
0.2357742041,
0.4700752795,
-0.4698249996,
-0.5330687761,
-0.5502786636,
0.2894212306,
-0.5372102261,
-0.9787707329,
0.2484346777,
-0.0539543256,
-0.6260578036,
-0.2114764154,
0.2458663732,
0.0681880116,
0.2439508736,
0.4017183185,
0.3314992785,
0.1511671692,
0.180237323,
0.012798233,
-0.4788372815,
0.1902554482,
-0.3895149231,
0.58966887,
0.0535314456,
-0.3593295515,
-0.2676704824,
0.1448028088,
0.2205234021,
-0.3445826173,
0.6352212429,
0.3929445744,
-0.2775537372,
-0.2412765026,
-0.6567137837,
-0.0185885374,
-0.5329968929,
0.0169169214,
0.0556582771,
-0.7837833762,
0.6403120756,
-0.0641295239,
-0.0646663159,
0.4861989319,
0.5645266771,
-0.22054407,
0.6995912194,
0.2139875591,
-0.0882720947,
0.6008421779,
-0.0369106233,
0.2234377563,
-0.7456868291,
-0.4007312357,
-0.7572549582,
-0.1008882374,
-0.3430502415,
-0.3702700734,
0.7730796337,
0.1040876135,
0.0500716344,
0.0156249562,
-0.3568371534,
0.3532744348,
0.8034157157,
0.1187212244,
0.3037038147,
-0.0389888808,
0.3437870741,
-0.0321631171,
-0.4533838928,
-0.8035881519,
0.9990483522,
0.2094762921,
0.9353388548,
0.0951508433,
0.6663344502,
0.7037789822,
-0.0524767302,
-1.1416897774,
0.3883942068,
0.1040634662,
-0.1298666298,
-0.5684829354,
-0.5846630335,
-1.2510896921,
-0.1441856176,
-0.1130268723,
-0.7668268681,
0.0504209921,
0.1978055835,
-0.8441429734,
0.0377767757,
-0.4579318464,
0.5948965549,
-0.421631664,
-0.4510959089,
-0.2195124179,
-0.0673998147,
0.4076927602,
0.1711359322,
0.1527011096,
-0.2960597277,
-0.2404033244,
1.1304036379,
-0.4967672825,
0.7232422829,
-0.205094263,
-0.2475412339,
0.4663922191,
0.1935210377,
0.6824244261,
0.0988927335,
-0.4203311503,
0.008792676,
0.2596694231,
-0.6007344127,
-0.4695786834,
0.8349165916,
-0.3917838633,
-0.3846747875,
-0.4778857827,
-0.771186471,
-0.3267041445,
0.0090962751,
0.1904952973,
0.6491497159,
-0.0850580558,
-0.1714661419,
0.7747833729,
-0.2339953184,
0.7214928865,
0.1578911096,
-0.0753764585,
-0.5915722251,
0.6974470615,
0.1538196802,
0.3361131847,
0.1978173405,
0.6116508842,
-0.6953018308,
-0.7364662886,
-0.496909529,
-0.1571690887,
-0.8346878886,
-0.3354479373,
-0.5740924478,
0.4979650974,
-0.3987931013,
-0.2233228534,
0.1192633957,
-0.5377731919,
-0.1145419702,
-0.0486983433,
0.7569981813,
0.5562691092,
-0.1462162435,
-0.0072043999,
-0.9917564392,
-0.0675941855,
0.6160274744,
0.4810956419,
0.0230774526,
-0.6945741773,
-0.1485027522,
0.2731897831,
-0.1192758605,
-0.896997571,
0.3318285644,
-0.1678685546,
1.0463081598,
0.2658651471,
0.3015838265,
0.5579339862,
-0.0196611974,
1.295539856,
0.0512312055,
-1.3293118477,
0.580186069,
-0.4379114211,
-0.0289834421,
0.7046786547,
0.2020987719,
-0.6738741994,
0.1113419831,
-0.6199908257,
-0.7387735844,
0.5145741105,
0.1330148578,
0.2966580689,
0.015826162,
0.2141295969,
0.2556613684,
0.2265894413,
-0.3433744311,
-0.2230577618,
0.067254588,
-0.2360903472,
0.1854552925,
-0.2903081179,
-0.0522889197,
0.0376199335,
0.6845101118,
-0.1153204739,
0.1131332666,
-0.1140800491,
-0.1699100286,
-0.0777711123,
0.4115344584,
0.3722519875,
0.5851069093,
0.0855182782,
0.0694939345,
0.4642042518,
-0.2001253366,
0.1920032352,
0.1714821011,
-0.0372481868,
-0.2531941831,
0.4525753856,
0.5990487337,
0.2010751963,
-0.9152938128,
0.8453372717,
0.2907068431,
0.1882817298,
0.0258699842,
0.1620868444,
-0.0729561448,
0.3092445433,
0.3680469692,
0.0480554588,
0.5328460336,
-0.4340665936,
0.0946199149,
0.6628001928,
-0.1883429587,
-0.1644432992,
0.3097715676,
0.2541956306,
-0.3967897594,
0.4862203896,
-0.3284408152,
-0.4725915492,
0.5736660361,
0.2961491346,
0.7855184078,
-0.1388897598,
0.4624482989,
0.285313338,
0.0683974922,
-0.2148041427,
0.3654354513,
-0.0682490915,
-0.6274695992,
-0.5493199229,
-0.5539706349,
-0.6508347392,
0.0060981871,
-0.5352316499,
0.3567194045,
-0.2881697118,
-0.0578697212,
0.1042012572,
0.143353954,
-0.6068819165,
0.0134429662,
0.0567947924,
0.6772959828,
-0.7898523808,
0.1862683147,
0.6366135478,
-0.6494299173,
-0.8696701527,
-0.032301899,
-0.2680065036,
-1.156858325,
0.4675586522,
0.1077859774,
-0.1637259573,
-0.3023178279,
-0.7664635181,
-0.9884423018,
0.929312706,
0.3772729039,
-0.2920629382,
0.4973829091,
0.1151320562,
0.3969489336,
0.0411297679,
0.5228652954,
0.2495930493,
0.7888842225,
0.1698615551,
-0.825245142,
0.1598087996,
-0.0807091519,
0.1058848202,
0.1390747577,
-0.4289080799,
0.8819409013,
-0.4677920043,
-0.2924520969,
0.1112126857,
0.491060406,
0.5740165114,
0.365163058,
0.5839856267,
0.0312296711,
1.3178902864,
-0.032805454,
1.1756521463,
-0.4363228083,
0.2881419957,
0.386000514,
-0.0437706746,
0.5580185056,
0.516272366,
-0.5783768892,
0.3467141688,
0.6790580153,
-0.0446444564,
0.2828680575,
0.4097980559,
-0.2768898606,
-0.6093121171,
-0.4927186668,
-0.2048914731,
0.0371092036,
0.1995136142,
-0.210194096,
-0.026294414,
-0.0249466915,
0.1987122446,
0.1889206469,
-0.4291717112,
0.618719697,
-0.0497760847,
-0.6845511198,
0.4847879112,
-0.1443752497,
0.7927741408,
-0.4498833716,
-0.1427405924,
-0.1797929853,
-0.2870444655,
-0.4263296425,
-1.1322313547,
0.0349035524,
-0.0403070189,
-0.2530720234,
-0.3575802147,
0.5781914592,
-0.2787362337,
-0.6012358069,
-0.4853106439,
0.5283856988,
0.074535355,
-0.3932365477,
-0.2785897851,
-0.1633450538,
-0.1214184314,
-0.0155862933,
0.1764350235,
0.4775170982,
-0.00704733,
0.7570953965,
0.8339434266,
0.1061702073,
-0.3937038481,
-0.0822631717,
0.6905190349,
-0.7611195445,
-0.7951595187,
-0.8280612826,
0.6436250806,
-0.2320059985,
-0.5132181644,
0.9240402579,
0.5715110898,
0.1831174493,
0.320497036,
0.9927452207,
0.1479954123,
0.3997071385,
-0.828650713,
0.4286831617,
-0.0013030447,
0.7759930491,
-0.3857882619,
-0.5399947166,
0.0397306345,
0.469640553,
-0.5341176987,
0.2263352424,
0.5277608633,
0.6460644007,
0.3479936719,
0.3796971738,
0.3585001528,
-0.1263895184,
0.421559453,
0.3803091347,
1.49208951,
-0.1108588427,
0.4056922197,
-0.304353714,
-0.4846729636,
-0.057303682,
-1.1950318813,
-0.8648952246,
-0.6119185686,
-0.1481754631,
-0.6441251636,
0.0259169415,
1.3881355524,
0.6131093502,
-0.9401331544,
-0.1517268419,
0.4167751074,
0.2043042779,
-0.4441475868,
-0.2486148328,
0.483882606,
-0.7085129619,
-0.5573658943,
0.4583067894,
0.1654306054,
0.0270487051,
-0.2638966143,
-0.044609528,
0.5337213278,
0.2746933997,
0.6366930604,
-0.1945387125,
-0.544505775,
-0.324012816,
0.1341438442,
-0.2032286078,
-0.0543576963,
0.852525115,
-0.9262349606,
0.000487449,
0.6902014017,
0.6143806577,
0.072730571,
0.1568733752,
0.4689690173,
-0.4482788146,
-0.2560501993,
0.5148818493,
0.3232381642,
0.3363633752,
-0.7718579769,
0.0330462642,
0.1276642233,
-0.6969296932,
-0.6483243704,
0.1156346127,
-1.1747224331,
-0.1164313108,
1.5552030802,
-0.0206276737,
-0.0381666571,
-0.2004808336,
-0.45978719,
-0.3817149699,
-0.9947432876,
0.9310521483,
0.5805178285,
-0.4342291355,
-0.093576178,
-0.2361361831,
0.5227167606,
0.3001097143,
-1.1298724413,
0.3529288769,
0.7222863436,
0.2888647914,
-0.0878157169,
0.4485640526,
0.0684182867,
0.2936056852,
-0.0681564733,
-0.2468785346,
-0.4973329008,
0.08967112,
-0.6537299752,
0.2823619545,
0.3683135211,
-0.2711240649
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15321v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15321v1
|
Greedy Grammar Induction with Indirect Negative Evidence
| 2023-12-23T18:43:56 | 2023-12-23T18:43:56 |
Joseph Potashnik
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper offers a fresh look at the pumping lemma constant as an upper
bound for the finite structural information of a Context Free Grammar. An
objective function based on indirect negative evidence considers the
occurrences, and non-occurrences, of a finite number of trees, encountered
after a sufficiently long non-adversial input presentation. This objective
function has optimal substructure in the hypotheses space, giving rise to a
greedy search learner. With this learner, a range of classes of Context Free
Languages is shown to be learnable (identifiable in the limit) on an otherwise
intractable hypotheses space.
|
[
-0.1195082366,
-0.9385254979,
0.7161126733,
0.0073444229,
-0.1071099117,
-0.4903877974,
0.0557066873,
-0.3331884742,
0.2211546451,
-0.0480309725,
-0.3870631754,
-0.2456484735,
-0.8785134554,
0.017961368,
-0.6834258437,
0.5652529597,
0.1731019616,
-0.1263505518,
-0.305770725,
0.0711709037,
-0.30950284,
-0.5107210279,
-0.4910951555,
-0.0694332346,
0.6343701482,
0.645014286,
0.4071588218,
0.85201478,
-0.2179751992,
0.3247953355,
0.1253941357,
-0.2502887845,
-0.6214089394,
0.2998933196,
-0.2439960837,
-0.4841658771,
0.0951278359,
0.0730288178,
0.7191674709,
0.6520773172,
-0.1057168841,
0.0844987556,
-0.1155937836,
0.3274244964,
-0.8592288494,
0.3037541807,
-0.8826968074,
0.0399733633,
-0.3956455588,
-0.5467796326,
-0.8770236373,
-0.1858623028,
0.1245217994,
-0.7736714482,
0.2145272791,
-0.3934524655,
1.0320450068,
0.2877942622,
-0.6328131557,
-0.4653730989,
-0.2149974853,
0.8482661843,
-0.2407334894,
0.416207701,
0.6411386132,
0.2496523857,
-0.2451264709,
-0.3571708202,
-0.2729849517,
-0.1811952144,
-0.2523518801,
-0.1699728668,
-0.2578366697,
0.1915994883,
0.2501578033,
0.4370841086,
-0.2678663135,
-0.0314194374,
-0.1888575852,
-0.2809281647,
0.2885937691,
-0.3010550737,
0.4479121268,
-0.1311262697,
0.1452585608,
0.1625105888,
-0.9112262726,
-0.0024391755,
0.3781397343,
0.5611488819,
-0.0215210281,
0.8236077428,
-0.2338825166,
0.8659397364,
0.1995185614,
-0.0972939357,
0.0881643146,
-0.070800364,
-0.2948490083,
0.3377115428,
0.149850145,
-0.040769849,
0.4520240426,
-0.2179150581,
0.0546600781,
0.609785378,
-0.198594138,
-0.9623556733,
0.3774650097,
-0.022410173,
-0.0392023884,
-0.2265239954,
0.1614990085,
-0.4773899019,
-0.123223193,
0.0189153813,
0.2562687397,
-0.1427687258,
-0.0686528012,
0.1300551742,
-0.3166195452,
0.2919257581,
0.0512313619,
-0.9960478544,
0.280875504,
0.6467377543,
0.6368390322,
0.4124054611,
-0.2641364336,
-1.1914527416,
0.2964872122,
-0.2187225074,
0.7655536532,
-0.7178063393,
-0.3805034757,
0.333575964,
0.2819486856,
-0.2566776872,
-0.6002086401,
0.7560241222,
-0.3766842186,
0.5102854371,
-0.4320406318,
-0.7761074305,
-0.0667236149,
0.157549262,
-0.3791616559,
0.8499686122,
0.5790869594,
-0.3884199858,
0.8360460401,
-0.5120138526,
-0.6949312687,
0.277765274,
-0.450414896,
-0.2176649123,
0.4035351276,
0.0032683671,
0.402002275,
0.0955958664,
0.4892450273,
-0.3253427446,
-0.4997780323,
0.0075959344,
-0.176338762,
1.0865756273,
0.1125983149,
-0.5270598531,
-0.0277167261,
-0.6110675931,
-0.1886506528,
0.2243575901,
-0.4530977309,
-0.6163375974,
0.2173383534,
-0.6012215614,
0.1892000735,
-0.1936483383,
-0.8239945769,
0.3841092288,
-0.4951914549,
0.4049602151,
0.9280290604,
0.1634479165,
0.3932832778,
-0.1865864694,
0.4192844331,
0.0359902084,
-0.1143072173,
-0.2299964875,
-0.2404233217,
-0.9733521938,
-0.2939042151,
0.1698856354,
0.2242037505,
-0.5135260224,
0.0924632102,
0.0517784506,
0.0521454476,
-0.300254792,
0.1267558783,
0.2599966824,
0.6207621694,
0.2632391751,
0.133256495,
-0.8519207239,
-0.8959856033,
-0.22473526,
-0.1141912639,
0.2521115541,
0.5460074544,
0.3608286679,
-0.3456264436,
0.5187075138,
-0.3399852514,
-0.2592971921,
-0.0928806737,
-0.0784029439,
0.5365872383,
0.4581542313,
0.7955326438,
-0.5932354927,
-0.6792993546,
-0.1356945038,
-0.7462581992,
-0.2893662751,
0.0515878834,
-0.4125592709,
0.2600145042,
0.666549027,
-0.8882300854,
0.3246131241,
0.4046836793,
-0.7131003737,
0.0761430264,
0.39698264,
-0.3105098605,
-0.7026261091,
-0.0722905248,
-0.0693411678,
-0.2577694654,
-0.4221436083,
0.2447674125,
-0.0421593711,
0.1581892371,
-0.4582903683,
0.7605531812,
-0.5971773267,
-0.0107408902,
-0.0679066032,
0.1100195423,
-0.4932582378,
0.3125406802,
-0.0318397693,
0.5769808292,
0.6624391675,
-0.7525043488,
0.0325787365,
-0.1083745435,
-0.313343823,
0.4223727584,
-0.48495242,
-0.3286983967,
-0.2910329401,
-0.006106901,
-0.7509451509,
-0.4669795632,
0.0687865764,
-0.4984862804,
0.1177612469,
-0.2489666343,
-0.0473194122,
-0.3024874628,
-0.1774628311,
0.4329806566,
0.5169913173,
-0.6684196591,
0.211900726,
0.312957257,
0.1533697397,
-0.8965239525,
-0.4890656769,
-0.3137255013,
-0.0322272442,
-0.3518640399,
0.1771337837,
-0.004461383,
-0.5081140399,
0.3338648975,
-0.0957609564,
0.09216775,
0.2363702506,
0.4058306217,
-0.1322142929,
-0.2586525381,
0.2088202089,
0.2546377778,
-0.1567372978,
0.0517533869,
-0.4632093906,
0.5204401016,
-0.2016326189,
-0.3082370162,
-0.3382947445,
0.3560773432,
0.5623211861,
0.4384013414,
0.5634019375,
0.1054692864,
-0.5720546842,
-0.3940734863,
-0.2436272055,
-0.0058911038,
-0.5167642832,
0.3753981292,
-0.4250394106,
-0.9413160682,
0.1502687484,
0.3258506358,
-0.4266472459,
0.7743099332,
0.6041057706,
0.3046205044,
1.0007089376,
0.6889513731,
0.089668043,
0.645640552,
-0.3093968332,
0.0313887186,
-0.2677988112,
-0.2479143143,
-0.5506942868,
0.0374013819,
-0.4350882471,
-0.1354596913,
0.145178318,
0.2313303202,
-0.3361880183,
0.1168130413,
-0.231857717,
0.8157749772,
0.7375379205,
-0.1773305386,
0.1155583262,
0.0305496454,
-0.4278031588,
0.0537204482,
-0.785708487,
-0.0119711636,
0.6958004236,
0.102906771,
0.3286576867,
0.292258203,
0.7052201033,
0.2853275836,
0.6918792129,
-1.127705574,
0.6388190985,
-0.038861312,
-0.8364833593,
-0.3180068433,
-0.2870620489,
-0.9224798679,
0.2058972716,
0.0044175265,
-0.7288603783,
0.4151504636,
0.5114751458,
-0.0247198734,
0.0628035441,
-0.854660213,
0.7847693563,
-0.1883322746,
-0.686750114,
-0.0388576128,
-0.3659690917,
0.3192306459,
0.2780469358,
0.1457415521,
0.0159474649,
0.167954728,
0.428802371,
-0.5908014774,
0.7860081792,
-0.7295092344,
-0.1533407271,
0.5957517028,
0.4688917696,
0.5986244082,
0.1436910331,
-0.1133770347,
-0.2207205147,
-0.2040629387,
-0.8132956028,
-0.3445885181,
0.6523829103,
-0.6409670711,
-0.7235506773,
-0.6480145454,
-0.2515030503,
-0.2885143161,
0.4898177385,
0.4589650333,
0.2976275086,
-0.1954248399,
0.5027992129,
0.2868769169,
-0.1450561583,
0.6207295656,
0.4379425943,
0.039110709,
-0.0661276802,
0.7560036778,
0.227472052,
0.1616854519,
0.7900577784,
0.4353118837,
-0.1578533798,
-0.392663449,
-0.4373973012,
0.1946670711,
-0.5174475312,
-0.1992538869,
-0.5598169565,
-0.1760244966,
-0.3656491339,
-0.4912267625,
-0.0468549654,
-0.5673162937,
-0.294160068,
-0.5966442227,
-0.1920388192,
0.6284387112,
-0.3521926701,
0.2836795151,
-0.3061230183,
0.0699035525,
0.5718529224,
0.3615633249,
-0.0140581029,
-0.2865832746,
-0.2931123674,
0.051798366,
-0.162580356,
-0.8939198852,
0.3695266545,
0.3431858122,
0.8012205362,
0.7430891395,
-0.1906217933,
0.6971377134,
-0.3044860363,
0.6217286587,
0.0605679527,
-1.1503280401,
0.4638692141,
-0.6257545352,
0.2989497185,
0.4258694947,
0.5829991102,
-0.4675206542,
-0.2177705318,
-0.6861726046,
-0.7051099539,
0.5550307035,
-0.2040724456,
0.0539703853,
-0.4606335163,
0.5396350622,
0.2726013064,
0.217475757,
-1.3340665102,
0.0577346012,
-0.260291487,
-0.1635045111,
-0.2291187644,
-0.7225406766,
-0.0186471306,
-0.5981368423,
0.9637331963,
-0.1823016107,
0.4212340117,
0.1544834375,
-0.4259131551,
-0.5714607239,
0.349650085,
0.8912380338,
0.5722017884,
-0.2877018452,
0.6278557777,
-0.0264780745,
-0.0866252854,
0.2938478291,
-0.2006545514,
-0.4480856657,
-0.017522227,
0.6666724086,
0.5550870299,
-0.0079948585,
-0.7939734459,
0.7652444839,
-0.0151872635,
-0.3998512924,
-0.3326362669,
0.0503654853,
-0.1838974655,
0.0009852464,
0.3971776366,
-0.309831053,
0.1442650557,
-0.7262554169,
0.2560228705,
0.7858554721,
-0.4850181043,
-0.4963525832,
0.2778027058,
0.1298511773,
-0.1595178396,
0.5058903098,
-0.4836744368,
-0.5003180504,
0.4210652411,
1.0080037117,
0.8602117896,
-0.299377948,
0.371016562,
0.5797283053,
0.3314201236,
0.3551062047,
0.2394889146,
-0.4025204778,
-0.7953000069,
-0.6613384485,
-0.5677320361,
-0.0753505901,
0.3561778665,
-0.3194721937,
0.2398407012,
-0.2945182025,
0.2767774463,
0.0271533392,
-0.1217220798,
-0.1770794243,
0.0890100524,
-0.0280091949,
0.7840818763,
-0.8495879769,
0.7296267152,
0.3671022356,
-0.0771001205,
-0.5080052614,
-0.2674846053,
-0.0167121887,
-1.1357500553,
0.9957450628,
0.2185841054,
-0.2069648504,
-0.2723515332,
-0.7865490913,
-0.9986190796,
0.6069788337,
0.7562150359,
-0.4240076244,
-0.1714507192,
-0.1439839602,
0.3642716408,
-0.246750772,
-0.1164389476,
0.0143914558,
0.4213978946,
0.1104239821,
-0.314960748,
0.2484620363,
-0.4805753231,
-0.4967045486,
0.5520281792,
-0.4511147738,
1.0441720486,
-0.3479347825,
-0.5678185821,
0.1748639345,
0.2822032571,
-0.1941904575,
0.2751747966,
0.5425812602,
0.6263347268,
0.6598405242,
-0.1458444744,
1.2737072706,
-0.262557596,
0.414370805,
0.9115178585,
0.0127665708,
0.5069304109,
0.760941565,
0.1059681252,
0.8071619272,
0.6899084449,
0.188467294,
0.6874028444,
0.4359041452,
-0.3215704858,
-0.2018185556,
-0.5439246893,
-0.5686821938,
0.2752248645,
0.3877246082,
-0.6159815192,
-0.3074572086,
-0.3936169446,
0.2511300445,
0.0348414481,
-0.3556536138,
0.557385385,
-0.1082458794,
-0.9205219746,
0.7352688313,
0.0420086235,
0.4830901325,
-0.5181706548,
-0.0874992013,
-0.1810771227,
0.3907197118,
-0.348969847,
-0.0544997901,
0.1859156489,
-0.2881251574,
-0.0900264904,
-0.1911498755,
0.7389000058,
-0.4040691555,
-0.333306998,
0.3363693357,
0.5224481225,
-0.2348486036,
0.3118629456,
-0.0784255862,
-0.1373080611,
-0.1211552918,
-0.2563677132,
0.1442083716,
0.3970364332,
0.0367829874,
0.2839463353,
0.4812125564,
0.1177473366,
0.1541912258,
-0.090433836,
0.6469549537,
-0.7286776304,
-0.5137674809,
-1.1650893688,
0.1082452387,
0.0114837307,
-0.2511908114,
0.9641088843,
0.5556103587,
1.1392228603,
-0.128447473,
0.823669076,
-0.2364179045,
0.2896972597,
-0.3212217987,
-0.0441821106,
-0.5412936211,
-0.2237558067,
-0.3857970238,
-0.7795697451,
-0.5036199093,
0.729192853,
-0.4477202892,
-0.0025980244,
0.7738320827,
0.4372497499,
-0.1483851671,
-0.0401504934,
0.3911607862,
0.5393383503,
0.174059242,
0.8365738988,
1.0780572891,
-0.1383624971,
0.098112002,
-0.2536163032,
-0.3678239882,
-0.3667863905,
-1.0889787674,
-0.7446058989,
-0.5648009181,
-0.0104690762,
-0.4918607175,
0.1877463013,
0.8802438378,
0.9803216457,
-0.7795292139,
-0.3965843022,
-0.6919357777,
0.5251938105,
-0.2104116678,
-0.3318432271,
0.2338403016,
-0.1783601493,
-0.6713683009,
0.5368772149,
0.2322282791,
0.2054890096,
0.0973791778,
-0.3331263065,
-0.6600648761,
0.3471876085,
0.905497551,
0.7416944504,
-0.3369686604,
-0.3758226335,
-0.0445247963,
0.1293010265,
-0.0757177547,
1.0441182852,
-0.7047572732,
0.344173193,
0.4251705706,
0.6256306171,
0.6959321499,
-0.0618903935,
0.294490695,
-1.0144760609,
0.6140043736,
0.1245545745,
0.6009502411,
0.0760699734,
-0.6442595124,
0.5767856836,
0.6126172543,
-0.2198492587,
-1.2046538591,
0.513014853,
-0.7955673337,
-0.4495235682,
1.2648030519,
0.2422286272,
-0.3052001894,
0.1487554908,
-0.0213880651,
0.1138063073,
-0.5255259275,
0.475812912,
0.8400346041,
-0.3552421927,
0.192841664,
-0.2047200054,
0.4308515489,
0.5813205838,
-0.6325107813,
-0.1548407376,
0.7198656797,
0.1260650009,
0.1917743534,
0.8473780751,
-0.166135475,
0.2629210949,
0.1968806833,
-0.411433965,
-0.19447276,
-0.6210159063,
-0.2342156023,
0.673263371,
0.2546001673,
-0.0935001373
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15316v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15316v2
|
Paralinguistics-Enhanced Large Language Modeling of Spoken Dialogue
| 2023-12-23T18:14:56 | 2024-01-17T17:07:37 |
Guan-Ting Lin, Prashanth Gurunath Shivakumar, Ankur Gandhe, Chao-Han Huck Yang, Yile Gu, Shalini Ghosh, Andreas Stolcke, Hung-yi Lee, Ivan Bulyko
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated superior abilities in tasks
such as chatting, reasoning, and question-answering. However, standard LLMs may
ignore crucial paralinguistic information, such as sentiment, emotion, and
speaking style, which are essential for achieving natural, human-like spoken
conversation, especially when such information is conveyed by acoustic cues. We
therefore propose Paralinguistics-enhanced Generative Pretrained Transformer
(ParalinGPT), an LLM that utilizes text and speech modalities to better model
the linguistic content and paralinguistic attributes of spoken dialogue. The
model takes the conversational context of text, speech embeddings, and
paralinguistic attributes as input prompts within a serialized multitasking
multimodal framework. Specifically, our framework serializes tasks in the order
of current paralinguistic attribute prediction, response paralinguistic
attribute prediction, and response text generation with autoregressive
conditioning. We utilize the Switchboard-1 corpus, including its sentiment
labels as the paralinguistic attribute, as our spoken dialogue dataset.
Experimental results indicate the proposed serialized multitasking method
outperforms typical sequence classification techniques on current and response
sentiment classification. Furthermore, leveraging conversational context and
speech embeddings significantly improves both response text generation and
sentiment prediction. Our proposed framework achieves relative improvements of
6.7%, 12.0%, and 3.5% in current sentiment accuracy, response sentiment
accuracy, and response text BLEU score, respectively.
|
[
-0.360283792,
-0.6690769792,
0.3523358703,
0.4322483242,
-0.5006263256,
0.1060077623,
-0.4503498077,
-0.0445523039,
0.32254228,
0.7630711198,
-0.3648726046,
-0.5304675698,
-0.4264236987,
0.0502071083,
-0.3117328882,
0.9521975517,
0.4352578819,
0.137713477,
-0.336755991,
-0.0721132085,
-0.36225757,
-0.6830961704,
-0.5726210475,
-0.1423695534,
0.4454975724,
0.2151710242,
0.7739565969,
-0.0435556844,
0.2679430246,
0.3665372431,
0.1014915779,
0.0626792312,
-0.3507873118,
0.2669879198,
0.1874768287,
-0.3443010747,
-0.6831423044,
-0.280185312,
0.5905042291,
0.5820345283,
-0.4135057926,
-0.0506730191,
0.3885017931,
0.1393601894,
-0.315582931,
0.5953902006,
-0.3631685376,
0.0453320108,
-0.2256129831,
-0.5483942628,
-0.5531672239,
-0.1421477199,
0.2206370682,
-0.5216360688,
0.0913408324,
-0.0054369108,
0.3947127759,
0.3247577846,
-0.4247739911,
-0.1741431653,
-0.7568525672,
0.8097923994,
-1.0635539293,
0.6237162352,
0.3788358867,
0.1559776515,
0.264623791,
-0.7740983963,
-0.6604519486,
-0.5401242375,
-0.1527887434,
0.2984861135,
0.0113335457,
0.6327574849,
0.2988237143,
0.2490598559,
-0.6183453202,
0.0453648791,
-0.0855725706,
-0.2752050161,
0.3352001309,
0.418628633,
0.3801207244,
-0.4203595519,
-0.2297632098,
-0.2298884094,
-0.4673994184,
0.1332014054,
0.2772114873,
0.3401704431,
-0.2811168432,
0.2846941054,
-0.1543074995,
0.8415283561,
-0.0325169377,
-0.5779904127,
0.4082877934,
-0.4063867629,
-0.1992361248,
-0.0450400375,
1.0413482189,
0.5839857459,
-0.162294656,
-0.1612188816,
0.0922876596,
-0.2985082269,
0.2556661367,
-0.7981154323,
-0.1966700703,
0.1489733756,
-0.4658192098,
-0.1452939957,
-0.0724031404,
-1.0094407797,
-0.3083182871,
-0.3870105743,
0.0835480541,
-0.4357928336,
-0.3819190264,
0.2356758863,
0.0553812124,
0.2061346173,
0.4216142893,
-0.8673747182,
0.1072297916,
0.4156229794,
0.7514891624,
-0.2419270724,
-0.210346356,
-0.5467672944,
0.1946111768,
-0.1060657948,
0.692158103,
-0.9033841491,
-0.5872350335,
0.0593134128,
0.0042163674,
-0.2214450836,
-0.5057895184,
0.7610642314,
-0.2891703844,
0.172610417,
-0.1050503179,
-0.3424483836,
-0.0708808228,
0.2056421489,
-0.8278375268,
0.8176593184,
-0.086534813,
-0.6149051785,
0.0447345041,
-0.590672791,
-0.539375186,
0.2311738133,
0.027626738,
-0.2895056903,
-0.0133661218,
0.3131548166,
0.6940518618,
-0.5478166938,
0.6766682267,
-0.1608375013,
-0.084855102,
0.3560627401,
-0.8606686592,
0.3482782841,
0.1541176289,
-0.2665332258,
0.1866522729,
-0.5731893182,
0.0799253732,
-0.3417862356,
-0.5027392507,
0.1366015226,
-0.0066669257,
0.2238930017,
0.3008818626,
0.2821388245,
-0.609333396,
-0.2078163326,
-0.4438017905,
0.409086287,
0.3821142316,
-0.0170175396,
0.4558537304,
-0.2767246962,
0.8102820516,
0.0674261823,
0.0270698592,
-0.4445082843,
-0.4563552141,
-0.8010182977,
-0.2060901374,
-0.0109318458,
0.6233074665,
-0.972917974,
0.5377416611,
-0.4525785744,
-0.47059533,
-0.3209666014,
-0.0536997207,
0.5118115544,
0.4706580937,
0.4622687399,
0.0425149091,
-0.5209870934,
-0.7926528454,
-0.2240343541,
-0.2573860884,
-0.1962546557,
0.2897248268,
-0.3172129393,
-0.1071849465,
0.7134078145,
-0.4312579036,
-0.0166554768,
-0.5863723159,
0.3645774424,
0.0195204392,
0.2645839155,
0.2471119463,
-0.6723275781,
-0.5839071274,
-0.0825970694,
-0.5757046342,
-0.1262559593,
-0.2879336774,
0.2165959328,
-0.015816709,
0.6045566797,
-0.7951146364,
0.0707809404,
0.6976349354,
0.1918482184,
0.5642107129,
0.092473112,
0.3138147593,
-1.3120005131,
-0.1044648066,
0.1522647738,
-0.2859945893,
-0.9180105925,
-0.2934324741,
-0.0585646182,
-0.6018075943,
-0.5254795551,
0.1765223294,
-0.2657346427,
0.1944863498,
-0.3038245142,
0.0610130057,
0.0640848055,
0.7006183863,
0.2825525403,
0.9343215227,
0.6858152747,
-0.5595543981,
0.6663521528,
0.3120628595,
-0.3502405882,
0.601962328,
-0.6143704653,
0.2254784256,
-0.1289794743,
0.6094732881,
-1.1121035814,
-0.1843553334,
0.025453398,
-0.1944249719,
0.3137476444,
0.1375392377,
-0.4732779562,
-0.2615716159,
-0.0671531931,
0.3134522438,
0.4098567069,
-0.3760445714,
0.8392273784,
0.2468540072,
-0.8066799045,
-0.1478200555,
-0.3929393589,
0.3308074176,
-0.3591240644,
-0.541485846,
0.3626580238,
-0.2104415148,
0.2190133482,
-0.6384602189,
0.0736293197,
-0.0911680013,
-0.4276371598,
0.0783949196,
0.1794131845,
-0.1640197188,
0.3282007873,
0.1789111048,
-0.248978585,
0.1322217584,
-0.0053513879,
0.8678228855,
-0.0935378596,
-0.383439362,
-0.6425972581,
0.3385335505,
0.6967611313,
-0.4059409499,
0.3983204663,
0.7570449114,
0.1170274317,
0.0462122373,
-0.5157652497,
-0.1847760826,
-0.5369012952,
0.6207403541,
-0.332016021,
-1.0295932293,
0.1471832693,
-0.2126529813,
-0.0198447909,
0.0490612239,
0.487179637,
-0.0985673368,
1.0189136267,
0.1882361025,
-0.1266490817,
0.6391003132,
-0.0148991728,
0.4891150296,
-0.8401072621,
-0.2585561275,
-0.2871486247,
-0.1631616503,
-0.4002411067,
-0.7382074594,
0.5437466502,
-0.176873073,
0.1287907511,
0.4876994491,
-0.2086556554,
0.1328601539,
0.4273779392,
0.3144547641,
0.0488154702,
-0.0605139099,
0.155271709,
-0.2458996624,
-0.6098167896,
-0.5239810348,
1.0571722984,
0.3198546767,
0.9534714222,
-0.1258086413,
0.6208050251,
0.0170060862,
0.0394234844,
-0.6360339522,
0.8153426051,
-0.0814034194,
-0.2520847917,
-0.3848493993,
-0.2936200798,
-0.5823494196,
0.2614607513,
-0.0518481433,
-0.6310459971,
-0.0712595135,
0.2161604911,
-0.6564977765,
0.1061801016,
-0.6824249625,
0.6862425804,
-0.2727071345,
-0.1573545337,
-0.4214553833,
-0.6620343924,
0.1267320514,
-0.0706928298,
0.0202756152,
0.0001601544,
0.0785389394,
0.8199187517,
-0.2514082491,
1.1949714422,
-0.2844696045,
-0.2291324735,
0.3353424072,
-0.0435766131,
0.4522664249,
0.1969831586,
-0.0919159204,
0.0315993801,
0.040144287,
-0.2105990648,
-0.8848467469,
0.6149978638,
-0.4774062037,
-0.8452700973,
-0.0558928289,
-0.6687064171,
-0.5957110524,
-0.1796436012,
0.2055701762,
0.7050747275,
-0.2919703722,
0.469519645,
0.702409029,
-0.4604579508,
0.5461767912,
0.50630337,
-0.0425186902,
-0.5230047107,
1.2378257513,
-0.1617741585,
0.4371459782,
0.5941115618,
0.2631735504,
-0.4908773005,
-0.3796526492,
-0.2533377111,
0.0562628433,
-0.5514644384,
-0.2431648076,
-0.9052454233,
-0.1273879707,
-0.5951937437,
0.0892400742,
-0.2474312484,
-0.2924219072,
-0.389516145,
-0.3388925791,
0.142389223,
0.35875687,
0.1963816434,
0.6245618463,
-0.9995135069,
0.5022205114,
0.4821572602,
0.0650224909,
-0.0038295744,
-0.6086550951,
-0.1921639144,
0.2438705266,
-0.484080255,
-0.6816015244,
0.5694285035,
0.443389833,
0.5484535694,
0.584163785,
0.1441689879,
0.7121299505,
-0.4684955776,
1.0261644125,
0.4548190832,
-0.8785775304,
0.333184123,
-0.4012013972,
0.4678367078,
0.3750923872,
0.265232712,
-0.6379128695,
-0.467287153,
-0.4691153765,
-0.6841311455,
0.7101558447,
0.1047480777,
0.5371469855,
-0.1373877674,
-0.1509739757,
0.1142078042,
0.4330207407,
-0.7866751552,
-0.0369173437,
-0.4893533587,
-0.2527221143,
-0.4408424199,
-0.2596253753,
0.0453801341,
-0.4931336939,
0.3646185398,
-0.2588023543,
0.5421202779,
-0.1078162789,
-0.1466483772,
0.2819114029,
0.4830549657,
0.7073361278,
0.3857727647,
0.0833887011,
0.1438226104,
0.2630937994,
-0.2057728171,
0.1672861278,
0.2307507992,
0.3353778422,
0.2019616514,
0.3977445662,
1.3120558262,
0.5720974207,
-0.7535783648,
0.4684464633,
0.14220047,
0.0393070839,
-0.1348988414,
-0.1208707988,
0.3178324103,
0.175003916,
0.041507639,
-0.0560457781,
0.3766884208,
-0.4353448749,
0.1302749366,
0.4005582929,
-0.3025420904,
-0.4785470366,
0.4741651118,
0.6562202573,
-0.4184272587,
0.3619821966,
0.0568526499,
-0.6257833242,
0.2529031634,
0.6890830994,
0.9219635725,
-0.6182300448,
0.5646698475,
0.2642500401,
-0.0309744254,
0.1954765022,
0.0622736365,
-0.5306718349,
-0.6530767083,
-0.2999466658,
-0.8689921498,
-0.4401452243,
0.1847430617,
-0.6445730329,
0.0723541453,
-0.3451363146,
-0.218909964,
-0.1650718898,
-0.6228325367,
-0.5165845752,
0.3104374707,
0.2608704567,
0.33033216,
-0.8488461375,
0.8352439404,
0.4632422328,
-0.3068884909,
-0.720628202,
0.2910827398,
-0.3599322736,
-0.6292383671,
0.6010418534,
0.2484540641,
-0.1446674466,
0.1870099455,
-0.2406779528,
-0.7114834785,
0.8627713919,
0.5359528065,
-0.7770582438,
-0.2731835842,
0.7087330818,
0.5130880475,
-0.1894638687,
0.3975248933,
0.5509793162,
0.2622100711,
0.145506829,
-1.1814213991,
-0.1301361173,
-0.2659980953,
0.1524872482,
0.1435718238,
-0.686973989,
0.5979830027,
0.2628540993,
-0.0708565935,
0.0023869378,
0.6550621986,
0.0752418637,
0.0448409393,
0.5744684935,
0.5419474244,
0.5056434274,
-0.0464968532,
0.8642816544,
-0.5096604824,
0.0680676401,
1.0568875074,
-0.4282580912,
0.9196777344,
0.4053845704,
-0.3019949794,
0.5341197848,
0.3538845479,
0.4613115191,
0.5370778441,
-0.0514695831,
-0.7745572925,
-0.4471431971,
-0.0713290796,
-0.1695087254,
0.4818048179,
0.4787088335,
-0.2812421918,
-0.2528481483,
0.6952766776,
-0.1630565077,
-0.0963616669,
-0.0047375732,
0.9784424901,
0.2168974131,
-0.7401921153,
0.6977450848,
-0.1826540828,
0.7785399556,
-0.5783436298,
0.0524536557,
-0.0602031462,
-0.1391085535,
-0.1754812747,
-0.6482954025,
0.1934147626,
-0.2079330981,
0.0500864983,
-0.6277384162,
0.5721946955,
-0.6751697659,
-0.413998872,
0.1742902994,
0.1705169678,
0.0848001912,
-0.1927959174,
-0.6676412225,
0.1288806498,
0.0577637926,
-0.216273129,
0.274395287,
0.3141520321,
0.1535164416,
0.5846004486,
0.4980180264,
-0.2013000399,
0.2023618072,
0.3844496906,
0.9622945786,
-0.5710047483,
-0.6855073571,
-0.607345283,
0.5705509782,
-0.1023597047,
-0.1981492639,
0.7085177898,
0.6166342497,
0.4467017055,
-0.268047899,
0.8922536969,
0.0843946859,
0.5149766207,
-0.6872808933,
0.437730372,
-0.1352556199,
-0.0523104444,
-0.4755480587,
-0.9301913977,
0.0325700492,
0.5294573903,
-0.3519443274,
0.0779212788,
0.8598208427,
0.9493059516,
-0.0586392954,
0.2155482769,
0.6598777771,
-0.0633761957,
0.3543305397,
0.4069564641,
0.8477776051,
-0.1688866764,
0.6346271038,
-0.0366391391,
-0.1086395308,
0.0601610318,
-0.5988716483,
-1.028062582,
-0.7153782248,
-0.2874869406,
-0.1079286486,
-0.0578214005,
0.7293017507,
0.722427547,
-0.7113284469,
-0.4466250241,
-0.3495382965,
-0.5516918302,
0.1329132468,
-0.2864429057,
-0.0209180731,
-0.5572478175,
-0.8689228296,
0.7025030851,
0.3920480609,
-0.0867372453,
-0.2619746923,
-0.2941897213,
0.0253503826,
0.0881444067,
0.7950268388,
0.0239327662,
-0.8668015599,
-0.1316577196,
0.0064425259,
0.1256609261,
0.161279276,
0.9559167027,
-0.5624060035,
0.5437937975,
0.3442141414,
0.6002694368,
0.5613803864,
0.1134856641,
0.8352234364,
-0.6723151803,
0.4258442521,
0.5035034418,
0.2629012764,
0.3920568228,
-0.1926791817,
-0.30794999,
0.0215031728,
-0.4967967272,
-0.5562705994,
0.4085900784,
-1.0489915609,
0.0926871747,
1.2262150049,
-0.2318547368,
0.0300677978,
-0.0566413812,
-0.5919319987,
0.2874366045,
-0.5033426285,
0.4179188013,
0.6747403741,
-0.1408085525,
-0.5802902579,
-0.4106805325,
0.5883286595,
0.6816502213,
-1.0822463036,
0.1845678687,
0.4795674682,
-0.0544854589,
0.2051304579,
0.6433564425,
0.0132157719,
0.1820306182,
-0.224325642,
0.0201005712,
0.1653679758,
-0.3624076247,
-0.191220209,
0.194144249,
0.0537190847,
-0.2101345956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15304v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15304v2
|
Exploring the Capabilities of ChatGPT in Ancient Chinese Translation and Person Name Recognition
| 2023-12-23T17:30:28 | 2024-02-23T05:24:26 |
Shijing Si, Siqing Zhou, Le Tang, Xiaoqing Cheng, Yugui Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
ChatGPT's proficiency in handling modern standard languages suggests
potential for its use in understanding ancient Chinese. This paper explores
ChatGPT's capabilities on ancient Chinese via two tasks: translating ancient
Chinese to modern Chinese and recognizing ancient Chinese names. A comparison
of ChatGPT's output with human translations serves to evaluate its
comprehension of ancient Chinese. The findings indicate that: (1.)the
proficiency of ancient Chinese by ChatGPT is yet to reach a satisfactory level;
(2.) ChatGPT performs the best on ancient-to-modern translation when feeding
with three context sentences. To help reproduce our work, we display the python
code snippets used in this study.
|
[
-0.3928002715,
-0.5061019659,
0.4033992589,
-0.039682541,
-0.3082747757,
-0.1326823235,
-0.580971241,
-0.7420858145,
-0.2525341809,
0.289756,
-0.1848044991,
-0.0239002164,
-0.4534663856,
0.1599565148,
-0.159563601,
1.1569390297,
-0.2252898663,
0.0996838734,
0.5299633145,
-0.0583900064,
-0.6073726416,
-0.5660168529,
-1.2366740704,
-0.4592685997,
0.2760169804,
0.5036329031,
0.8600224257,
0.3734610081,
0.6564928293,
0.2904228568,
-0.1416047513,
0.2486568689,
-0.4059824347,
-0.1101341993,
0.125975132,
-0.1968503445,
-0.5165773034,
0.1223056167,
0.7104785442,
0.3864849508,
0.1671279371,
0.0824891105,
0.2454513311,
0.5484413505,
-0.2135200948,
0.3811014295,
-0.4333364666,
0.2235386521,
-0.4981887341,
-0.5320622921,
-0.280164063,
-0.230919078,
0.6450644732,
-0.5847041011,
0.3258402348,
0.1009710133,
0.7672784328,
-0.0911055729,
-0.4547455609,
-0.3050216436,
-0.6676387787,
0.5029553175,
-0.566627562,
0.0718170851,
0.2616687119,
0.7193579078,
-0.2587203383,
-1.0367194414,
-0.5876795053,
-0.5888673067,
-0.2849278152,
0.1743382812,
0.2203060091,
0.0704091191,
0.3513992429,
0.9535192251,
-0.6878890395,
-0.1474554986,
-0.7268400788,
-0.3908392489,
0.4521400332,
-0.2468514293,
0.7346161604,
-0.291685164,
-0.5591288805,
-0.0947684273,
-0.5417456031,
0.1927337945,
-0.0022827187,
0.2083894759,
0.1951630563,
0.3988695145,
-0.2008497715,
0.7571237683,
-0.3390665054,
-0.0874105915,
-0.047471229,
-0.2336745858,
-0.2406499386,
0.3193997443,
0.470743686,
0.3004480302,
0.601426959,
-0.3420712948,
-0.0582606271,
-0.3766556382,
-0.032260336,
-0.7461932302,
-0.6427333951,
-0.2028608918,
-0.5626456141,
0.0587969534,
0.2272650301,
-0.2625001669,
-0.523052156,
0.0999588519,
0.396217823,
-0.7546573877,
-0.3529213965,
0.2962564826,
-0.4694668651,
0.6523504853,
0.7079200745,
-0.8951598406,
0.1517801434,
0.7259261012,
0.8255553246,
-0.0824982226,
-0.6103014946,
-0.3292733133,
-0.1277220845,
-0.0139171816,
0.791043818,
-0.1671251208,
-0.2046714276,
-0.3212470412,
0.0087284939,
-0.0855807215,
-0.3912818134,
0.7301186323,
-0.3458242714,
0.2603214085,
-0.2049607337,
-0.2188263237,
-0.5381109118,
0.2507554889,
-0.5010572076,
0.6180029511,
0.0863589793,
-0.7858035564,
0.1798978895,
-0.4382487535,
-0.5026587248,
0.6878553629,
-0.0520121045,
-0.1128106639,
-0.0934704468,
-0.0117513873,
0.3188194036,
-0.0010535641,
-0.3607498705,
0.1543795615,
-0.5871328712,
0.4086913168,
-0.4642044604,
0.6213086247,
0.4137136638,
-0.4735879898,
-0.3288547695,
-0.1914545447,
0.1025952473,
0.258998096,
-0.5729502439,
-0.1798294187,
0.3588548601,
0.2322471291,
-0.0810265765,
0.2755742073,
-0.36333251,
0.5985532999,
-0.2458672076,
0.9256595373,
0.4133834839,
-0.3056824505,
0.2908020616,
-0.3274798393,
0.2620477676,
-0.5186796784,
-0.2520281374,
-0.3714548945,
-0.9266167283,
-0.6372401714,
0.092623882,
0.4912705719,
0.6792115569,
-0.691696465,
-0.0666314587,
-0.4303514063,
-0.3740031719,
-0.3471069932,
-0.1623782814,
0.1883321106,
0.3258365095,
0.2660194933,
-0.5802179575,
-0.3471048474,
-0.7047120333,
-0.2853977382,
-0.5115420818,
-0.494059056,
0.371412456,
0.2648418248,
0.058869686,
0.5730478168,
-0.1594557464,
-0.2983985245,
-0.2885492146,
0.1870703846,
0.0016754881,
0.4811517596,
0.3575897515,
-1.0246462822,
-0.6184570193,
0.7307210565,
-0.2238948196,
0.2426330894,
-0.4826448262,
-0.1646013558,
-0.2655327618,
0.2138793766,
-0.2381311804,
0.4024392068,
0.4080995023,
-0.2983800471,
0.6072054505,
-0.3264974654,
0.3449940085,
-1.0737252235,
0.2028393149,
-0.4281802475,
-0.367636174,
-0.7735800147,
0.1266289651,
0.3041523695,
-0.2104184628,
-0.4925612509,
0.5580078363,
-0.7638688087,
-0.0913982838,
-0.2022304237,
0.7451484203,
-0.5495119095,
0.2010835409,
0.4129306972,
0.7676936388,
0.3960962296,
-0.4795958996,
0.6747549772,
0.141842097,
-0.3255438507,
0.4885549545,
-0.4036695361,
0.3947350085,
0.2271962911,
0.1339831948,
-1.1306563616,
-0.4243098795,
0.4990594089,
-0.8886681199,
0.1177620217,
-0.2728131413,
-0.4327416718,
-0.2004836798,
-0.0886609927,
0.4774076343,
0.4729970098,
-0.465454787,
0.3609078825,
-0.0481611341,
-0.0037004186,
-0.3133248091,
-0.7272953391,
0.3857294321,
-0.2546895444,
-0.812808156,
0.4525819123,
0.120861657,
0.0913504139,
-0.282828033,
-0.2704027295,
-0.1726129353,
0.1632340401,
-0.2674173117,
0.1613128334,
-0.4015787244,
-0.0915961266,
-0.5106344819,
-0.2659675479,
-0.3375375569,
-0.2629456818,
0.6974348426,
-0.4209807217,
-0.2080259174,
-0.4299907982,
0.0901030526,
0.3399864733,
-0.29992643,
0.3874298036,
0.6883739829,
-0.277989924,
0.1063456684,
-0.4521509111,
-0.0313786007,
-0.444059819,
0.481198281,
-0.4107525051,
-0.6635253429,
0.646366775,
-0.0158582889,
0.1371923834,
0.4301382601,
0.3919029832,
0.257497251,
0.5786396265,
0.1950438768,
-0.1439108849,
0.604578793,
0.1643516421,
0.3221749067,
-0.9350678921,
0.0169561841,
-0.3157038987,
-0.4734432399,
-0.7991837859,
-0.3584880233,
0.1226908416,
0.2556548119,
-0.0986513942,
0.6426384449,
-0.7488225102,
0.5615437031,
0.4951354265,
0.2787581384,
0.5266814232,
-0.1995294839,
0.3068908155,
0.1665676832,
-0.2275119722,
-0.7474737763,
0.5644031763,
0.2628383934,
0.6046418548,
0.2315466702,
0.5171042681,
0.1771944612,
0.2549025714,
-0.8457742333,
0.5214857459,
-0.2555954456,
-0.6174888015,
-0.2786423266,
-0.3955702484,
-1.0710080862,
0.3038113415,
0.113302879,
-0.9854125977,
-0.2525432706,
0.0212688539,
-0.3987933695,
0.2929606736,
-0.8529468179,
1.0203962326,
-0.423124671,
0.247285068,
-0.0754985362,
-0.6473645568,
0.2401142865,
0.3420373797,
-0.3719868362,
0.0256289765,
0.0518925451,
0.4989578724,
0.0681061223,
0.4956018925,
0.1940731704,
0.1237103418,
0.0872443244,
0.1466274709,
0.2684830725,
0.1709463298,
-0.0165953673,
-0.0011529938,
0.2255612165,
-0.618699193,
-0.3240492344,
0.409208566,
-0.677567184,
-0.5022273064,
-0.5125980377,
-0.266007036,
0.4318133891,
0.4493437111,
0.3457440138,
0.0922625139,
-0.4128507376,
0.2399887145,
0.3593709469,
-0.2118508369,
0.3667480052,
0.3332628608,
-0.0896580815,
-0.0282810424,
0.6503996849,
0.179657653,
0.4209033549,
0.261939466,
0.1859218627,
0.0887944251,
-0.5428097844,
-0.7932113409,
-0.1368072182,
-0.6357647181,
0.0933577046,
-0.0669266209,
-0.4742980599,
-0.10069561,
0.0170083269,
-0.1563719064,
-0.4214549363,
0.0410443321,
0.2857334912,
0.0645837486,
0.6783457994,
0.2979169786,
0.4173071682,
-0.6626967192,
0.1884776503,
0.684317112,
0.1485877037,
-0.0227186866,
-0.3099613786,
-0.0741003305,
0.0569710173,
-0.4258675873,
-1.2056106329,
0.0447368994,
0.2986892164,
0.6543242335,
0.633859098,
-0.0116540613,
0.7101069689,
-0.5531668067,
0.8814894557,
-0.3753339946,
-0.8831651807,
0.3522235155,
-0.2615706921,
0.2982167602,
0.346129477,
-0.1012633517,
-1.4563535452,
-0.0970297679,
-0.3496228456,
-0.5530520678,
0.8964476585,
0.6071636081,
0.1500284225,
0.2140131146,
0.7260407805,
-0.0642929748,
-0.0619842671,
-0.856417954,
-0.2076973766,
-0.1338408142,
0.4146482646,
-0.1198579967,
-0.0373893827,
0.3974362612,
-0.0347717851,
0.1991749555,
0.0673048347,
0.5578670502,
0.2662950456,
-0.1887759715,
0.2343433946,
0.3688007295,
0.5630946159,
0.5730194449,
-0.1134171337,
0.2533918917,
0.6201740503,
-0.69920367,
-0.4625445008,
0.2088387907,
0.0745444968,
-0.1066399366,
0.4382511079,
0.7225656509,
-0.0258431099,
-0.3800547719,
0.4159358442,
-0.277548939,
0.0212650113,
-0.6070696712,
0.2004638165,
0.1006704792,
0.3554147184,
0.7350693941,
0.1950410753,
0.2083785683,
-0.6548892856,
0.0309540238,
0.3350413442,
-0.2256422192,
-0.3062835038,
0.6095769405,
0.0716843307,
-0.6725869775,
1.0131069422,
-0.3712383509,
-0.9809808135,
0.5812056065,
0.4971129894,
0.8258909583,
-0.4969640672,
0.03138078,
0.3395549059,
0.2556613982,
-0.4262377918,
-0.1495683938,
-0.5070393085,
-0.5972096324,
-0.4635726213,
-0.1742364466,
-0.6937066913,
-0.0480237491,
-0.5135258436,
0.5095182061,
0.0455572903,
-0.063676998,
-0.0926995948,
0.098374851,
-0.5512399673,
-0.0435367897,
0.5870990753,
0.781644702,
-0.4046322107,
1.0319613218,
0.9716582298,
-0.2775483131,
-0.8897271752,
0.2680135667,
-0.1067658439,
-0.9083852768,
0.6702535152,
0.4795664549,
-0.0934385136,
0.2284944057,
-0.2950911522,
-0.5051601529,
1.1799687147,
0.13488397,
0.0465767905,
-0.2887555957,
0.0878242999,
0.5783081651,
0.0132854525,
0.5217376947,
0.5946359038,
0.6503599286,
-0.0199968163,
-1.3550416231,
-0.0042569428,
-0.39894858,
-0.0419773981,
0.0087168105,
-0.6357902884,
1.0514178276,
-0.1261086315,
-0.7711451054,
0.5167469978,
0.61557585,
0.0938472152,
0.1605513096,
0.4099262953,
0.070730485,
0.7059682608,
-0.2965964377,
0.8966017962,
-0.0292950589,
0.4727232754,
0.624802649,
0.2248322219,
0.8078690171,
0.1694130898,
-0.3314712942,
0.2511005104,
0.9460086823,
0.0072156521,
0.3353768885,
0.238972187,
-0.4889101088,
-0.0672569424,
0.3583943844,
-0.5540113449,
0.3591391742,
0.1430837214,
-0.1970539093,
-0.2314599007,
0.0225382373,
0.3670516908,
-0.5040583611,
-0.1808088124,
0.7329428196,
0.0807072967,
-0.8514251709,
0.5975837708,
0.0287091155,
0.6988317966,
-0.4990980327,
-0.1861265153,
-0.1942510307,
0.5104604959,
-0.1670193225,
-0.9122264385,
-0.0335291997,
-0.3835723996,
0.4648674726,
-0.1166746914,
0.713889122,
-0.2248547226,
-0.0139201498,
0.0567627735,
0.2671256661,
0.6913120151,
-0.3584182858,
-0.4049726427,
-0.5953141451,
0.3039928079,
-0.3356626332,
0.2573080063,
0.6722099185,
-0.1190143153,
0.5521775484,
0.2870627642,
0.222838819,
0.0673816875,
-0.4263631105,
0.600763917,
-0.740577817,
-0.4280266166,
-0.9996654391,
0.2352247834,
-0.0217937548,
-0.5452823639,
0.9101255536,
0.4084543288,
1.0721663237,
-0.0636077747,
0.7300813198,
-0.483617276,
0.1390877664,
-0.3149344623,
0.8349767923,
-0.3746905625,
0.0166981351,
-0.196926862,
-0.8129431009,
-0.2768781483,
0.9909700751,
-0.4530330598,
-0.0796798989,
0.7808948159,
0.3538201451,
-0.1922068596,
0.1586516351,
0.2102750242,
-0.2575362921,
0.3560209274,
0.7998841405,
0.9591551423,
-0.4496363401,
0.8982905149,
-0.226797834,
-0.3119974434,
-0.2282143086,
-0.7981936932,
-0.9365161061,
-0.577570498,
0.2029323578,
-0.2209917456,
0.08702714,
0.6514590383,
0.7091866136,
-0.78241992,
-0.2186420262,
0.1227014288,
-0.0873786584,
-0.5953269601,
-0.1502843201,
0.7209208608,
-0.413071543,
-0.9998233914,
0.1794383675,
-0.0287708696,
0.1849209219,
-0.1345959604,
-0.2724046707,
0.3195773363,
-0.4825124145,
0.4956571758,
0.6237903833,
-0.7974184155,
-0.5475032926,
0.0774955377,
-0.1946848929,
0.33522892,
1.0192265511,
-0.5269281864,
0.5891698599,
0.8923310637,
0.462331593,
0.682919085,
0.2734897137,
0.6257712245,
-0.3907822669,
0.0762001723,
0.1801955253,
0.4475572705,
0.4203040302,
-0.3342472911,
0.624373436,
0.0782951787,
-1.0585641861,
-0.2578573525,
0.1634772122,
-1.1682338715,
-0.2315666378,
0.967299521,
-0.3785193861,
0.094417952,
-0.4169732928,
-1.0189275742,
0.4828187823,
-0.2539455593,
0.8295937181,
0.8543634415,
-0.261045903,
-0.3611420691,
-1.2502667904,
0.5294983983,
0.2056592107,
-0.4575593174,
0.0369113982,
0.0406105481,
0.1894025803,
0.3252235949,
0.6835155487,
-0.133551985,
0.6528829336,
-0.2494709343,
0.0971922353,
-0.0151356626,
0.3604335189,
0.1584263742,
-0.2423022538,
0.3994535506,
-0.3608253002
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15291v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15291v2
|
Reverse Multi-Choice Dialogue Commonsense Inference with Graph-of-Thought
| 2023-12-23T16:18:47 | 2023-12-27T03:30:26 |
Li Zheng, Hao Fei, Fei Li, Bobo Li, Lizi Liao, Donghong Ji, Chong Teng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the proliferation of dialogic data across the Internet, the Dialogue
Commonsense Multi-choice Question Answering (DC-MCQ) task has emerged as a
response to the challenge of comprehending user queries and intentions.
Although prevailing methodologies exhibit effectiveness in addressing
single-choice questions, they encounter difficulties in handling multi-choice
queries due to the heightened intricacy and informational density. In this
paper, inspired by the human cognitive process of progressively excluding
options, we propose a three-step Reverse Exclusion Graph-of-Thought (ReX-GoT)
framework, including Option Exclusion, Error Analysis, and Combine Information.
Specifically, our ReX-GoT mimics human reasoning by gradually excluding
irrelevant options and learning the reasons for option errors to choose the
optimal path of the GoT and ultimately infer the correct answer. By
progressively integrating intricate clues, our method effectively reduces the
difficulty of multi-choice reasoning and provides a novel solution for DC-MCQ.
Extensive experiments on the CICERO and CICERO$_{v2}$ datasets validate the
significant improvement of our approach on DC-MCQ task. On zero-shot setting,
our model outperform the best baseline by 17.67% in terms of F1 score for the
multi-choice task. Most strikingly, our GPT3.5-based ReX-GoT framework achieves
a remarkable 39.44% increase in F1 score.
|
[
-0.6862467527,
-1.0596716404,
0.7173771262,
-0.3491171896,
-0.570258081,
0.2297682464,
-0.0406498909,
-0.2882665694,
0.3155848384,
0.5038891435,
-0.9663558602,
-0.4021341801,
-0.2943418026,
0.262574017,
0.2009980828,
0.6604703069,
0.0647466555,
-0.0078832014,
-0.1801674813,
-0.1342843175,
-0.3652654886,
-0.2089975178,
-0.9303312898,
-0.3756973147,
0.6814360023,
0.5416203141,
0.6859385967,
0.3896513879,
0.0932070687,
0.2105892152,
-0.1185911596,
0.3236613274,
-0.7050821781,
-0.0801237747,
-0.3576865196,
-0.195458293,
-0.3972716033,
0.2714871764,
0.3982340991,
0.530395627,
-0.0920416638,
-0.035214223,
-0.1217707247,
0.5106805563,
-0.5341263413,
-0.0463576801,
-0.7425211668,
0.0740543529,
0.2696942687,
-0.22426337,
-0.4369353652,
-0.4168732166,
-0.0409713462,
-0.8646814823,
0.0087094987,
0.0412158631,
0.7361035347,
0.2291572541,
-0.4588008523,
-0.0619342327,
-0.4215180576,
0.8486604095,
-0.3750085831,
0.3650346398,
0.451618284,
0.3692647219,
-0.2109076381,
-0.5357797742,
-0.8983708024,
0.0402012244,
-0.0164720006,
0.5500279665,
-0.3237205446,
0.2987234592,
0.1071697772,
0.0586471185,
-0.456341207,
0.0104145454,
-0.2125816196,
-0.1869819164,
0.3788747191,
0.1089672446,
0.2090790719,
-0.403514713,
-0.3797221184,
-0.0521897823,
-0.6951566935,
-0.2317145914,
0.4762931168,
0.3049088418,
0.218082875,
0.5937746167,
-0.5146234035,
0.9464838505,
-0.0555746444,
-0.1162757501,
-0.0000962593,
-0.4226356447,
-0.4519279301,
-0.290112257,
0.5723800659,
0.4401291609,
0.3023872077,
-0.1926316917,
0.2233054042,
-0.1992080808,
0.0964043438,
-0.6752693057,
0.1163225397,
0.5464703441,
-0.351207763,
-0.1648450792,
-0.3808455765,
-0.9721016884,
-0.2893136442,
-0.4095225632,
0.2557224631,
-0.4304196239,
-0.6524034739,
-0.0463620685,
-0.398947984,
0.0766010806,
0.6667272449,
-0.4031849504,
0.3280938268,
0.5540480614,
0.6795170307,
0.0309488475,
-0.3299351931,
-0.6790220141,
-0.0202755257,
-0.2127806246,
0.9018135071,
-0.7584984303,
-0.5099279284,
-0.4904059172,
-0.2772599459,
-0.4142295122,
-0.3647401631,
0.6375828385,
-0.650698781,
0.3629856706,
-0.5565603375,
-0.4680536091,
-0.4087511599,
0.6000191569,
-0.4836521149,
0.6627052426,
0.0853703767,
-0.935953021,
0.3281902671,
-0.735748589,
-0.1782580167,
-0.1258144379,
-0.2343306243,
-0.2312866151,
-0.3361736834,
0.4899762869,
0.1458504051,
-0.42635566,
0.0773722082,
-0.8411929011,
-0.3775649667,
0.343999207,
-0.6577705145,
1.2725052834,
0.2301446199,
-0.2529896796,
0.0720975846,
-0.5854939222,
0.2349196821,
-0.0032878271,
-0.1169537902,
-0.2879696786,
-0.3172736466,
-0.422186166,
0.4660929441,
-0.4526456296,
-0.6591286659,
0.1074773818,
-0.1229818091,
0.5166514516,
0.8018451929,
0.1234821975,
0.2165696919,
-0.4483542144,
0.583771348,
0.1605220586,
0.1664448529,
0.4919265211,
-0.8535834551,
-0.4064394534,
-0.6695154309,
0.1056632549,
0.6654133797,
-1.123116374,
0.1006350517,
-0.2415280193,
-0.4210295677,
-0.3811495602,
-0.2475028634,
0.4691727459,
0.8648036718,
0.4771946371,
-0.1557429433,
-0.1795999557,
-0.629463017,
-0.1699762493,
-0.3198240995,
0.1377851218,
0.6895438433,
0.5580485463,
-0.1209197342,
1.1323074102,
-0.8312909007,
0.2642159164,
-0.2789002061,
0.3226748705,
0.2458238602,
0.4151518047,
0.1078279167,
-0.9033167362,
-0.1011524275,
-0.2139282227,
-0.4734424055,
0.1579720229,
-0.0587385558,
-0.5234942436,
-0.0334006622,
0.1553142518,
-1.0564335585,
0.6074193716,
-0.0800410435,
-0.0890782103,
0.8652060628,
0.0647353753,
0.3920479715,
-1.1070146561,
0.1332921237,
-0.171197176,
-0.0733013228,
-0.4538515508,
-0.0345090628,
-0.2376803309,
-0.1390518546,
-0.3295223415,
0.6258152723,
-0.1700401753,
-0.3257617056,
0.1702875048,
0.4824168086,
0.1395076066,
0.7934733629,
0.2533710301,
0.7393393517,
0.3361350894,
-0.5484000444,
0.2587705255,
0.2274165601,
-0.0290492047,
0.705840528,
-0.2305690199,
0.5908500552,
-0.289347291,
0.5190824866,
-1.5298508406,
-0.2038227022,
0.7063674927,
-0.4617925882,
0.0422826298,
-0.4278761744,
-0.3436305821,
-0.578558445,
-0.1235548779,
0.3814367354,
0.0103269191,
-0.5992625952,
0.7884737253,
0.2044791579,
-0.1730348468,
-1.1694580317,
-0.5005546808,
0.0469962321,
-0.2934414744,
-0.4624528289,
0.261986196,
-0.2741134465,
-0.4391558468,
0.1202449352,
-0.1195188239,
-0.5042569637,
0.0044486239,
-0.0825269371,
0.3631325662,
0.0223525781,
0.2921101451,
0.3773216307,
-0.1723198891,
-0.1056258678,
-0.4378958642,
0.3535917699,
0.0061871945,
-0.4561719,
-0.4796808064,
0.410638839,
0.7082527876,
-0.0585790239,
0.3809682727,
0.4749494791,
-0.2253672183,
-0.0706159025,
-0.3506844342,
-0.2832947671,
-0.3761538863,
0.1079336554,
-0.5037179589,
-0.7027816772,
0.4820326865,
-0.1343143731,
0.0311733633,
0.1283666641,
0.3177067935,
-0.0707757697,
0.8031841516,
-0.1971373409,
0.234372288,
0.1535090357,
-0.2693898082,
0.110960573,
-0.755278945,
0.1877851486,
-0.2808221877,
-0.0917342901,
-0.2786353827,
-0.4655270576,
0.3121403158,
0.178176105,
-0.2017834932,
0.1539822519,
-0.4873686135,
0.5483372808,
0.6077987552,
0.4714685977,
0.4885886014,
-0.1751697212,
-0.5683313012,
0.3316985369,
-0.7252442837,
-0.0854526386,
1.2119537592,
-0.2627769709,
0.3265282512,
0.3194412589,
0.830011487,
0.0959035084,
0.493421495,
-0.687900722,
0.7707595825,
0.3139098883,
-0.9920933843,
-0.6490952969,
-0.7604669333,
-0.7864673734,
0.7509527802,
-0.1740861237,
-0.8301277161,
0.0372398682,
0.2155944258,
-0.6135525703,
0.4118795097,
-0.9372045398,
0.8333635926,
0.113112919,
-0.5437589884,
-0.5105422139,
-0.7226795554,
0.5598373413,
0.2222143561,
0.2414854467,
-0.034758728,
0.2599283457,
0.4891732037,
-0.1773077697,
0.8653318882,
-0.2452354878,
0.219198823,
0.665997684,
-0.0903905779,
0.553802371,
0.4753606617,
-0.0466225408,
-0.0422724001,
-0.2056100368,
-0.3341117501,
-0.6677991152,
0.5080538392,
-0.8061562777,
-0.7074427605,
-0.2654284537,
-0.4298863113,
-0.2788346112,
0.4453780949,
0.2504487038,
0.7328731418,
-0.3270970583,
-0.5632753372,
0.4821263254,
-0.1470680833,
0.5697628856,
0.2132707834,
-0.1879731417,
-0.9603992105,
0.6643747687,
0.1595549285,
0.5058912039,
0.5662034154,
0.2481399477,
-0.7500808835,
-0.5269129872,
-0.6852918267,
0.2698502243,
-0.9914179444,
-0.1133773625,
-0.7388553619,
0.1651772559,
-0.3841176033,
0.0541536324,
-0.0875712559,
-0.683324039,
-0.4983299375,
-0.3447766006,
0.1752100289,
0.3294861615,
-0.1886686832,
-0.0637675598,
-0.4243182242,
0.5503582954,
0.9867832661,
0.3848552108,
0.0652060807,
-0.0234351028,
0.3486946523,
0.2322899252,
-0.324267894,
-0.84694767,
0.0245538019,
-0.2243353724,
0.5765324831,
0.4453347921,
0.2545963526,
0.8611453176,
-0.1914892346,
0.5002567172,
0.3090291023,
-0.6255117059,
0.1286679208,
-0.4233838618,
0.1543720067,
0.6989378333,
0.2379805595,
-0.4372495711,
-0.1707604229,
-0.6879835129,
-0.3635950387,
0.6195365787,
0.4861225188,
-0.2798711956,
-0.350102216,
0.1909239739,
0.215796113,
0.0781989172,
-0.6315696239,
-0.2216117531,
-0.4936203957,
0.257353574,
0.1373619437,
0.1095142961,
-0.3577248156,
-0.4295474291,
0.575345993,
-0.220423162,
0.5486285686,
0.4928480387,
-0.0160326585,
-0.0352357849,
0.7003301382,
0.7613892555,
0.8754835129,
-0.541991055,
0.2494887859,
0.2158539444,
-0.312390238,
0.0839551762,
0.3336853981,
0.0921362191,
-0.1904155761,
-0.0117649417,
0.3988421261,
-0.0741231292,
-0.5148393512,
0.2428468019,
-0.2041969746,
-0.1216331571,
-0.1747467667,
0.0549904071,
0.247414723,
0.0821506456,
0.29472363,
0.5099200606,
0.1549135447,
-0.3544062078,
0.2365764529,
0.4694075882,
-0.4811973274,
-0.1541550606,
0.3636033535,
0.3645616174,
-0.1850268543,
0.7794811726,
-0.6363565326,
-0.3561250269,
0.6151880622,
0.3925240934,
0.9423155785,
0.1889399737,
0.6655019522,
0.4453020096,
0.1531692892,
0.2388876975,
0.3656666875,
-0.1674630046,
-1.0671082735,
-0.6648899317,
-0.0761835352,
-0.5939056277,
0.2575959265,
-0.4495226145,
-0.008716803,
-0.4103884399,
-0.4163014293,
0.0964496434,
-0.0905776396,
-0.5740395784,
0.2670948505,
-0.0925234705,
0.7830892801,
-0.4517133832,
0.749533534,
0.343042016,
-0.4409721196,
-0.5520959496,
0.0335458815,
0.2945235372,
-0.7594015598,
0.4833512008,
0.1493614465,
-0.7132122517,
0.4220408797,
-0.4256187379,
-0.6184949875,
0.960439682,
0.356615901,
-0.1051594019,
0.1576294005,
-0.197864145,
0.103057839,
-0.3534861207,
0.719019115,
0.5163872242,
0.5340391397,
0.451697886,
-0.4903268516,
0.1391173303,
-0.1286647469,
-0.4040464461,
0.2255197763,
-0.6040391326,
0.7402857542,
-0.5413084626,
-0.3977967799,
0.0506398343,
0.1901128143,
0.4967567325,
0.4890500307,
0.7942485809,
0.7905806899,
0.9876356125,
0.1015823111,
0.9284262657,
0.0882451013,
0.3941896856,
1.3119699955,
-0.2726106644,
0.6251588464,
0.4900638461,
-0.1728734225,
0.4570483863,
0.7398298979,
0.5759231448,
0.5152835846,
0.0550577715,
-0.340086937,
-0.5935223103,
0.0892655551,
-0.2794361711,
0.5155593753,
0.3488055468,
-0.031913422,
-0.3757394552,
-0.2351392508,
0.2154174447,
-0.2102755755,
-0.1111064032,
0.6467917562,
-0.1962686628,
-1.1855744123,
0.6877475381,
-0.4095785022,
0.0914172903,
-0.2740861773,
-0.2270287871,
-0.2921443582,
-0.0978664309,
0.2446543276,
-0.802629292,
-0.0528708547,
-0.2896235883,
-0.0067168763,
-0.1365173459,
0.6310061812,
-0.13341856,
-0.2938883603,
0.2693945467,
0.6397807598,
0.1765932292,
-0.0654275492,
-0.9682260156,
-0.4756904542,
0.0744173154,
0.0429590531,
0.0470092446,
0.372289896,
0.1551951319,
0.6525152922,
0.767847538,
-0.2185081393,
-0.3752969205,
0.0971762985,
1.0446414948,
-0.5461021066,
-0.6750354171,
-0.6947451234,
0.4335862398,
-0.6225276589,
-0.6431866288,
0.3089785874,
0.411049366,
0.692584455,
0.132077843,
0.8724706173,
-0.0032783197,
0.6187371016,
-0.5241813064,
0.4381782711,
-0.3172715902,
0.1911848634,
-0.5939238071,
-0.673237741,
-0.2893108726,
0.26448524,
-0.6145295501,
0.0825909451,
0.7960915565,
0.8460747004,
-0.1749539971,
0.4764577746,
0.1751885116,
-0.0447067916,
0.2086861283,
0.6031936407,
1.0936350822,
0.0458495952,
0.9252521992,
-0.1246912405,
-0.3420702517,
-0.1570933908,
-0.7538226843,
-0.9934324622,
-0.4047767818,
-0.2267112881,
-0.4804651141,
0.0168637093,
0.949673593,
0.623284936,
-0.5536350012,
0.0189457014,
-0.5042710304,
0.8532158136,
-0.9046078324,
-0.2301818728,
0.4337107539,
-0.1489638984,
-0.4675200582,
0.3175792098,
0.2836901248,
-0.0060655912,
0.2385237664,
-0.1000813097,
-0.5387120843,
0.1456753761,
0.3929807842,
0.3181250095,
-0.9107939601,
-0.6816383004,
-0.0306430012,
0.138350606,
0.3514203131,
0.8835644722,
-0.7495647669,
0.8597949743,
0.4045061767,
0.4810964465,
0.6227968931,
0.0856977254,
0.4033543169,
-0.5756667852,
-0.0035433564,
0.2870056629,
0.2901444137,
0.2299576104,
-0.2745415866,
0.5037732124,
0.5962316394,
-0.3231943548,
-0.4996162057,
0.728120327,
-0.9962044358,
-0.725933373,
1.1011356115,
-0.0623552017,
-0.0111356126,
-0.7572770119,
-0.316329211,
0.4553741813,
-0.4729619324,
0.7704876661,
0.7021378279,
-0.4492431283,
-0.3481422365,
-0.256991595,
0.4384565353,
0.1733151674,
-0.9291265011,
0.2878096998,
0.665763557,
0.1501523554,
0.3176735938,
1.0526144505,
0.214004308,
0.345651716,
0.3078307211,
-0.4155222476,
-0.1696657985,
-0.182787016,
0.1561186612,
0.3821849525,
-0.347899586,
-0.2940955162
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15272v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15272v1
|
Detecting anxiety from short clips of free-form speech
| 2023-12-23T14:44:17 | 2023-12-23T14:44:17 |
Prabhat Agarwal, Akshat Jindal, Shreya Singh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Barriers to accessing mental health assessments including cost and stigma
continues to be an impediment in mental health diagnosis and treatment. Machine
learning approaches based on speech samples could help in this direction. In
this work, we develop machine learning solutions to diagnose anxiety disorders
from audio journals of patients. We work on a novel anxiety dataset (provided
through collaboration with Kintsugi Mindful Wellness Inc.) and experiment with
several models of varying complexity utilizing audio, text and a combination of
multiple modalities. We show that the multi-modal and audio embeddings based
approaches achieve good performance in the task achieving an AUC ROC score of
0.68-0.69.
|
[
-0.4950048029,
-0.8769221902,
0.8657322526,
-0.0326702334,
-0.100901328,
0.0956524983,
-0.194031015,
-0.5591773987,
0.5262985826,
0.222974062,
-0.5802058578,
-0.8143596649,
-1.0610823631,
0.1012769118,
-0.3608562052,
0.7952830791,
-0.1550852656,
0.2141296268,
-0.1193788052,
-0.3261744082,
-0.3570318222,
-0.4897055626,
-0.885533154,
-0.0786374733,
0.4069806337,
0.48856318,
0.6055625081,
0.4513900876,
0.2030894905,
0.2040667385,
0.0731290132,
0.2821846306,
0.0817747936,
0.0801764205,
0.302726984,
-0.3202348948,
-0.4500700533,
0.160432294,
0.4986812472,
0.3744171858,
-0.1560546458,
0.207447201,
0.0926091224,
0.2067463249,
-0.5463917255,
0.1073305234,
-0.2648570538,
0.4830704331,
-0.2187599987,
-0.1335238367,
-0.268849194,
-0.0184866339,
-0.1343561411,
-0.5176292658,
0.2192226797,
0.1043080688,
0.5830802917,
0.6605368853,
-0.3504432142,
-0.5005940199,
-0.7340114713,
0.6988531351,
-0.3753943741,
0.7055683732,
0.7909038067,
0.2097733468,
-0.0290503595,
-0.4372692108,
-0.477471143,
-0.1651008278,
0.1764119118,
-0.1257893741,
-0.753760159,
0.1427592635,
0.2984381914,
0.1902534664,
-0.7754341364,
0.2023854405,
-0.3726421297,
-0.3515230119,
0.574776113,
0.0843487382,
0.4066745639,
-0.2277436107,
0.1485385597,
-0.2060183436,
0.250410229,
0.1466326118,
0.128444016,
0.2609343231,
-0.1780392379,
0.3439287245,
0.1156697348,
0.2466407716,
0.1507363766,
-0.597982049,
0.3281952143,
0.4574964345,
-0.2998687923,
0.4910141826,
0.8634154797,
0.1711082906,
-0.0842603967,
0.0151061043,
0.0124549307,
0.1352755427,
0.2258017361,
-0.3309977353,
-0.2026613206,
0.4437720478,
-0.5905287862,
-0.049200438,
-0.2463323027,
-0.6538290381,
-0.5157253742,
-0.3439496756,
0.5877211094,
-0.6496976018,
-0.1390858889,
0.0459009595,
-0.1554783583,
-0.3334881365,
0.0581203103,
-0.5724403262,
0.3579420447,
0.491006583,
1.1750375032,
-0.1750962734,
0.2465468049,
-0.6540011764,
-0.0282143448,
-0.4727292657,
0.6964363456,
-0.3513815105,
-0.6521226764,
-0.2360779047,
0.0739446431,
-0.2989790142,
-0.7603211999,
1.0129734278,
-0.0113361878,
0.1514184028,
0.2480708659,
-0.5749881864,
-0.3446527123,
-0.0002220565,
-0.9025662541,
0.9349403381,
0.4961200655,
-0.6712455153,
0.3435607255,
-0.8191917539,
-0.2949503362,
-0.2393881083,
-0.2883891761,
-0.6042742729,
0.0487393588,
0.524109602,
0.5024493933,
-0.0357270017,
0.0786629915,
-0.5901360512,
-0.2387949675,
0.4922018647,
-0.3635408282,
0.5056357384,
0.5186457634,
-0.232886076,
0.2967215776,
-0.840924859,
0.1819260567,
-0.2631558776,
-0.0303776748,
-0.4530884027,
-0.0427281298,
-0.0278534833,
0.2474369407,
-0.4032253623,
-0.346023351,
-0.2083426118,
-0.0330525115,
0.0757517591,
0.4847398996,
0.4125630558,
-0.156276837,
-0.450224489,
0.8574701548,
0.3903852105,
0.2520424724,
0.3834846914,
-0.6665787101,
-0.5611789823,
-0.8862322569,
0.2066768259,
0.7655226588,
-0.437569648,
0.5615506768,
-0.0458360575,
-0.4324463606,
-1.1291139126,
0.1945394427,
0.1029574797,
0.4896732271,
0.5463395715,
-0.3222283721,
-0.6913959384,
-0.8375577331,
-0.1729139984,
0.1587485075,
-0.4509707689,
0.2971604168,
0.4301557243,
-0.6038010716,
0.7174412608,
-0.5771030784,
-0.516389966,
-0.072931692,
0.585559845,
-0.0964998454,
0.3856494427,
0.4753671288,
-0.6674854159,
-0.4087278247,
-0.1757681966,
-0.6996080279,
0.0668194592,
0.3198470175,
0.1682398468,
-0.0446449742,
0.4590062201,
-0.3755081594,
0.5039166808,
0.351911962,
-0.0785518065,
0.1717824191,
0.0456515588,
0.1918789595,
-1.0210038424,
-0.1524870694,
0.2751086056,
-0.375597924,
-0.5618436337,
-0.6875824928,
-0.4905100167,
-0.351885885,
-0.1929313838,
0.0441977121,
0.0663397908,
0.3217432201,
-0.4444442391,
-0.1056035608,
-0.1025870293,
0.377723217,
-0.0630970448,
0.4176951051,
0.5773026347,
-0.483768791,
0.1208884418,
-0.0822990313,
-0.393112421,
0.4823197424,
-0.2361633629,
0.3396501839,
-0.349817425,
0.1374078691,
-0.6865766644,
-0.5922026038,
0.6452903748,
-0.7057597637,
0.2090802789,
-0.0325246342,
-0.1052641645,
-0.3273941875,
-0.1067045107,
0.3716721535,
0.4432113767,
-0.0955533534,
0.4184094071,
0.7118156552,
-0.1555155814,
-0.3734136224,
-0.5163130164,
-0.3677804768,
-0.5813509822,
-0.2380184829,
0.1083446965,
0.1222163439,
-0.3431515098,
0.1740234494,
0.0878251046,
-0.3400419652,
0.1685075313,
0.7051260471,
-0.1489942521,
-0.1891375035,
0.5121560693,
0.2637730539,
-0.0385625362,
0.1250208616,
-0.2954722941,
0.3743365407,
-0.125334084,
-0.3559234142,
-0.7674250007,
0.9248178601,
0.6675261259,
-0.0622753128,
0.475428462,
0.9303692579,
-0.8331138492,
-0.3305667937,
-0.1398901641,
-0.0646321401,
-0.4196198881,
0.2923314571,
-0.2369065881,
-0.9054912329,
0.2188705951,
-0.0318789631,
-0.7703322768,
0.4182285964,
0.4200680852,
-0.2290200591,
1.3660348654,
0.9258482456,
-0.4049975574,
0.2561569214,
-0.2173884511,
0.5275813341,
-0.4374927282,
-0.0861051753,
-0.5732474923,
-0.2785988748,
-0.6389764547,
-0.6288974881,
0.837500155,
0.1582119614,
0.0004476488,
-0.2095782161,
-0.6370539665,
0.0182185452,
0.4442982376,
0.2960604131,
0.0989782363,
0.1101550683,
-0.2419425547,
-0.2274198085,
-0.4567942917,
-0.447769165,
1.0781058073,
0.6642059684,
0.4914153814,
0.0253708065,
0.5682319403,
0.9960485697,
0.5208261609,
-1.2238191366,
0.0704246461,
-0.0642927736,
-0.5580454469,
-0.3592216074,
-0.305965662,
-0.8640571833,
0.0669391081,
-0.1947631389,
-1.1736792326,
0.3010413945,
-0.0378369316,
-0.7033238411,
0.3135113418,
-0.5075120926,
0.6825147867,
-0.2804800868,
0.1684218794,
-0.284922719,
-0.5104560852,
0.3784691691,
-0.0714601427,
0.5042695403,
-0.3220630586,
0.4173149168,
1.3396003246,
-0.0274000484,
0.4877945781,
-0.324436307,
0.1147146001,
0.551713109,
-0.2655874491,
-0.3145670295,
0.0788234025,
0.1191219762,
-0.1520072669,
0.168938905,
-0.0668021962,
-0.8185757399,
0.2962427139,
-0.9665364623,
-0.3171750605,
-0.562851727,
-0.5067767501,
-0.7875047326,
0.0048468574,
0.3858338296,
0.2313345671,
-0.0924509093,
0.1773059815,
0.8212173581,
-0.0670022145,
0.1885505021,
0.3660340011,
-0.0492727384,
-0.7012937665,
0.8757423162,
0.1543387622,
-0.5027058125,
0.2169851214,
0.2275749892,
-0.3218111694,
-0.2333407402,
-0.0849367678,
0.1222225279,
-0.5452311635,
-0.2100037187,
-0.6885561347,
-0.1284723878,
-0.8967762589,
0.3113720417,
-0.2494082004,
-0.2355872691,
-0.6145381331,
-0.4974045157,
0.4790294468,
0.5931184292,
-0.5287231207,
0.3834832311,
-0.7184596062,
0.5738852024,
0.1858524531,
0.2751742005,
0.1373073906,
-0.274083972,
-0.4004226923,
-0.0499243885,
-0.8003301024,
-1.2624354362,
0.6177504063,
0.3248726428,
0.3981616795,
0.9949785471,
0.2674051523,
0.6274979711,
-0.1548641175,
0.5637837648,
0.1859547496,
-1.0331969261,
0.7788618207,
-0.0437160954,
-0.4056526124,
0.4768140316,
1.324349761,
-0.7574645281,
-0.2788063884,
-0.7281140685,
-0.5977948904,
0.4742927253,
-0.0013447556,
-0.6074570417,
-0.1107564718,
0.1979970634,
-0.0806280822,
0.0514350832,
-0.3620738685,
-0.1517255604,
-0.300774157,
-0.6525192857,
-0.3926307559,
-0.1122512296,
-0.5134700537,
-0.5275997519,
0.6211648583,
-0.2602069974,
0.7408037186,
0.4568465352,
-0.0396661088,
-0.1554775387,
0.5936772823,
0.5829408169,
0.0728035867,
-0.4159193039,
0.116137363,
0.1298648864,
-0.3865047693,
0.4018995762,
0.1746937037,
0.1451709718,
0.4881022871,
0.2603222728,
1.0153963566,
-0.2142559886,
-0.7742944956,
0.5608752966,
-0.0813766047,
-0.4387309849,
-0.4743690193,
0.1586330235,
-0.1376693398,
0.2477090657,
0.2994252145,
-0.0615915023,
0.5499659181,
-0.4454417527,
0.4428862035,
0.2956357002,
-0.9693953395,
-0.198005259,
0.5359436274,
-0.2893404961,
-0.5426619053,
0.7609310746,
-0.2211084515,
-0.4209625721,
0.3013560474,
0.420088619,
1.073079586,
-0.2634692788,
0.3020834327,
0.0512776859,
0.0407920331,
0.2454119921,
0.4903913438,
-0.2703292072,
-0.5066446066,
0.0059495606,
-0.4590372443,
-0.5956163406,
0.5572550893,
-0.9967506528,
0.0776975304,
-0.4184813797,
-0.6325511932,
-0.0083682518,
0.2129830718,
-0.5511450768,
0.5320513844,
0.5959802866,
0.724147141,
-1.2680931091,
0.8112827539,
0.4693107903,
-0.2491695732,
-0.972443819,
-0.0157808233,
0.3696736395,
-0.3066391349,
0.1108535305,
0.3745218515,
-0.4392738044,
-0.5246789455,
-0.4431430697,
-0.690554738,
0.7563932538,
0.3305336833,
-0.1756022274,
0.0277190115,
0.233086288,
0.5973722935,
-0.417529434,
0.1393811405,
0.6517482996,
0.4697446227,
-0.4019626677,
-0.9560059905,
-0.3245297074,
-0.2977183163,
-0.3317561448,
-0.0284027494,
-0.362402916,
0.8304416537,
0.1135881469,
-0.3320834637,
-0.024452148,
0.8400483727,
0.1566968858,
0.9075443149,
0.6809137464,
0.8246135712,
1.5121401548,
0.0030572924,
0.6600241661,
-0.2893699408,
0.0622002333,
0.9884818792,
-0.0463093072,
0.8761155009,
0.3219348192,
-0.0187474471,
0.6905394793,
0.7260651588,
0.0504298918,
0.2590358853,
0.2996314466,
-0.6733986735,
-0.1904079169,
-0.5169886947,
-0.3842562735,
0.6997760534,
0.9554966688,
-0.433329016,
0.1238977388,
0.6803654432,
0.1551682651,
-0.0552805997,
-0.2854815423,
0.6907076836,
0.3526381552,
-0.4574848115,
0.3299459517,
0.2229561955,
0.5044488907,
-0.5247746706,
0.0540423281,
0.1410858482,
0.2495393902,
-0.2275354415,
-0.2508390248,
0.4326828718,
0.1297315657,
-0.3205761909,
-0.1508139372,
0.5935403705,
-0.3428564668,
-0.4775629938,
0.4437940121,
0.5140743256,
0.372505039,
-0.2221892625,
-0.4034925997,
-0.0269620307,
-0.2654503286,
0.1028029397,
0.2316426039,
0.4375976324,
-0.2963513732,
0.6040019989,
0.3051277101,
0.0130183343,
-0.0888065621,
-0.2098961174,
0.3472346067,
-0.6222060323,
-0.7475750446,
-0.5250201225,
0.0280466769,
0.0490762666,
-0.2838465571,
0.4687350988,
0.5209892392,
0.5056163073,
-0.1161227524,
0.9132840037,
0.1272254586,
1.0361666679,
-0.4139756858,
0.8569071889,
-0.7371139526,
-0.3848274648,
-0.2073271126,
0.0675655082,
-0.3986182511,
0.6389061809,
-0.2053703815,
-0.2970184684,
0.749512732,
0.7689351439,
0.0138162803,
0.1815174073,
0.2242930084,
-0.0777942166,
0.3880083263,
0.7106326222,
0.8002434969,
-0.1734244227,
0.3648619354,
-0.5030283928,
-0.270906657,
-0.0701449811,
-0.5096648932,
-0.5860059261,
-0.7436070442,
-0.3628357351,
-0.362166822,
0.0882013813,
1.2165005207,
0.9827862978,
-0.8827095032,
-0.1422138065,
0.5135674477,
0.3337332904,
-0.6132731438,
-0.261442095,
0.5064923763,
0.0153019633,
-0.5281239748,
0.6454926729,
0.0402028374,
0.2404781133,
0.037491139,
-0.0031534012,
0.0689356178,
-0.0367745124,
0.3839809895,
0.4868241251,
-0.6490656137,
-0.2615482509,
-0.1480726153,
0.0424766652,
0.267399013,
0.8619885445,
-0.7169416547,
0.2337401658,
0.031888213,
0.5662600398,
0.1008132473,
0.0148365516,
0.1395025253,
-0.6404490471,
0.1705249101,
0.6324786544,
0.269662708,
0.2683035135,
-0.4629111588,
-0.0038662814,
0.2714448273,
-0.3263646662,
-0.8360142708,
-0.1601671278,
-1.1596128941,
-0.2219463438,
0.5941765308,
-0.1381871104,
-0.3875770271,
-0.2874858081,
-0.1528355777,
0.6433839202,
-0.3610488772,
0.8501942158,
0.6519981027,
-0.8545914292,
-0.1453398764,
-0.3514038324,
0.8302404881,
0.3219712377,
-0.4871341586,
-0.5657920241,
0.2366451621,
0.284689188,
0.2399516404,
0.7244257927,
-0.0239826646,
0.3020587564,
0.0316638276,
-0.2237659991,
0.0859121159,
-0.5439839363,
-0.5486279726,
0.6882163882,
0.0622586273,
-0.5870019794
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15228v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15228v2
|
Adversarial Data Poisoning for Fake News Detection: How to Make a Model Misclassify a Target News without Modifying It
| 2023-12-23T11:37:09 | 2024-01-04T16:20:42 |
Federico Siciliano, Luca Maiano, Lorenzo Papa, Federica Baccini, Irene Amerini, Fabrizio Silvestri
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Fake news detection models are critical to countering disinformation but can
be manipulated through adversarial attacks. In this position paper, we analyze
how an attacker can compromise the performance of an online learning detector
on specific news content without being able to manipulate the original target
news. In some contexts, such as social networks, where the attacker cannot
exert complete control over all the information, this scenario can indeed be
quite plausible. Therefore, we show how an attacker could potentially introduce
poisoning data into the training data to manipulate the behavior of an online
learning method. Our initial findings reveal varying susceptibility of logistic
regression models based on complexity and attack type.
|
[
-0.0528842323,
-1.2558646202,
0.4330432415,
-0.1558675319,
-0.1279552579,
0.1056785136,
0.2475976795,
-0.6348409057,
0.150483042,
0.4576065242,
-0.3404117227,
-0.1255189031,
-0.7795655727,
-0.2450306714,
-0.7026382089,
1.222512722,
0.2135259658,
0.2256297171,
-0.071671471,
-0.0635950044,
-0.2512461841,
-1.0267214775,
-0.6825950742,
0.0539044738,
0.5563327074,
-0.1738272756,
0.7934182286,
0.2678114474,
0.4538049102,
0.1564137936,
0.0008984716,
-0.058258757,
-0.6554070711,
-0.1439994574,
-0.2845885456,
-1.1598082781,
-0.3578572571,
0.0268093459,
0.2176203579,
0.502241075,
0.124422729,
-0.1759927273,
-0.0365354382,
0.7558358312,
-0.7006680965,
-0.2662672698,
-1.0110592842,
0.0023454807,
-0.0493352488,
-0.2219989151,
-0.7498711348,
-0.4233496487,
-0.0467093624,
-0.3785863221,
0.5508255959,
-0.1947986335,
0.744022727,
0.2552964091,
-0.6347147822,
-0.2684897482,
-1.0900886059,
0.3900590837,
-0.5862460732,
0.1550090015,
0.4504249394,
0.4250381291,
-0.1664573699,
-0.5595235825,
-0.3302567005,
-0.2806915343,
-0.2193400115,
-0.0536451451,
-0.545013845,
0.1480172724,
0.4837500453,
0.1394687742,
-0.7961155176,
-0.2229329348,
-0.4863813519,
-0.1579692811,
0.6811823249,
0.0159796719,
0.3618901372,
-0.1642710418,
-0.4847267568,
0.0917838886,
-0.6962885857,
-0.1808708608,
0.91307199,
0.4407638311,
0.2293033302,
0.4422966242,
0.1359864175,
0.8534787297,
0.2026421279,
0.068323575,
0.04522302,
-0.115429312,
-0.3986538947,
0.4268089235,
0.548766315,
0.2061461061,
-0.1458213031,
-0.0971875936,
-0.2585841417,
0.4458419085,
0.846073091,
-0.5411916375,
-0.4211938083,
0.3651613891,
-0.3840234876,
-0.8522860408,
0.3129599392,
-0.6806498766,
-0.3556485474,
0.0951997861,
0.9298785329,
-0.2485525608,
-0.2806896269,
0.0508275144,
-0.3600254357,
-0.1298824698,
0.263980031,
-0.5031037331,
0.2909252942,
0.3428026736,
0.7412883639,
0.0694688261,
-0.1310704052,
-0.6860793829,
-0.1355345696,
-0.4472610652,
0.6284214854,
-0.3419287205,
-0.2094350457,
0.0139851598,
-0.0419841148,
-0.1340482384,
-0.4439161718,
0.171631515,
-1.0131293535,
0.1480938196,
-0.1333945692,
-0.620205462,
-0.2743149698,
0.2770376503,
-1.0354388952,
0.6059079766,
0.037018232,
-1.1034528017,
0.3719083369,
-0.3322522938,
-0.7582752109,
-0.2685791254,
0.260318011,
-0.616548717,
0.0571488217,
-0.0419430397,
0.2812390327,
0.5309452415,
0.2115062177,
-0.5816555619,
-0.239288196,
0.4710971117,
-0.6039530635,
0.9451723695,
0.3422983885,
-0.1982095093,
0.0416453183,
-0.7896572948,
-0.2856293023,
0.3675731421,
-0.3382589221,
-0.7261347771,
0.0341918208,
0.0656969994,
-0.0927704424,
0.0164829865,
-0.4175012708,
0.3097403347,
-0.1831103861,
0.1658181846,
0.6463256478,
0.3292346001,
0.3246484399,
-0.6910939813,
0.3627696335,
0.1458460242,
0.4321151674,
0.0049993582,
-0.3975512087,
-0.4345087111,
-0.0978021696,
0.5435694456,
0.5822242498,
-0.9847283959,
-0.0261525437,
0.1059876904,
-0.5750198364,
-0.3959830105,
0.041206006,
0.3692499697,
0.2143317759,
0.451446116,
0.0483803898,
-0.7017998099,
-0.5174996853,
-0.953107655,
-0.1770663112,
0.0790056884,
-0.1027837694,
0.5683034062,
-0.0662987828,
0.75271523,
-0.5803928375,
-0.2349084467,
-0.2773682475,
0.2902137041,
0.1069761664,
0.4551680684,
0.8235806823,
-1.2318439484,
-0.3011029363,
-0.3273364902,
-0.808688879,
0.1571472585,
-0.3828968406,
0.2184778452,
0.2943178713,
0.6163185835,
-0.5663248301,
0.9590443969,
0.2860902846,
-0.320173502,
0.8472517133,
-0.0575920977,
0.3419942856,
-0.8234394193,
-0.0843101814,
0.2353947312,
-0.4959269464,
-1.423631072,
0.162670061,
0.2042358369,
-0.1140976921,
-0.808036685,
0.2262563109,
-0.0368838087,
0.0236053709,
-0.4102768004,
-0.2576746941,
0.0699432492,
0.2667884231,
-0.1267903596,
0.1914683729,
0.492302984,
-0.7620062828,
0.5374526978,
-0.0284516755,
-0.5455169678,
0.5989503264,
-0.6513457298,
-0.1201308221,
-0.4084843695,
0.6085451841,
-0.7277741432,
-0.6214863658,
0.4151428044,
-0.8099652529,
0.4074254334,
-0.4642837346,
-0.5388857722,
0.0005771359,
-0.1397942603,
0.2591223121,
0.1350077391,
-0.7773151398,
0.4183031321,
0.0289522372,
0.3918970227,
-0.4619614482,
-0.984184742,
-0.0193572175,
-0.3987986147,
-0.3925508559,
0.4241920412,
-0.1436003298,
-0.4761191607,
0.421099633,
-0.1907637864,
-0.0833211765,
0.3616233468,
0.0856481642,
0.4509552419,
0.0064600413,
0.1647693813,
-0.1059486866,
0.1657520831,
0.143875733,
0.1088576168,
0.3728354275,
0.3477441072,
-0.6619293094,
-0.7275140285,
0.4113333821,
0.5645679235,
-0.0087667936,
1.0683882236,
0.3756441474,
-0.8226938844,
-0.1939542741,
-0.2588533163,
-0.286390841,
-0.3768261075,
0.3615429699,
-0.1833752543,
-0.2843387425,
0.3511668146,
0.2210430056,
-0.2193052471,
0.3607665896,
0.1072385013,
0.1065820977,
1.3561109304,
0.5430688262,
-0.3734944165,
0.548204422,
-0.1370394379,
0.1238802001,
-0.2771718204,
-0.1069528311,
-0.3076637685,
-0.1955199093,
-0.544673562,
0.1440467089,
0.1727282852,
0.2268915027,
-0.1258479208,
0.3061383665,
-0.2840240002,
0.5577321053,
0.5098133087,
0.4798218012,
0.2829421759,
0.1357788295,
0.3446932137,
0.2921041846,
-0.7770959139,
-0.162047565,
1.3537465334,
0.2815089822,
1.0346041918,
0.2134829909,
0.2986098528,
0.6561998725,
0.2249758691,
-0.4436496794,
0.0926264226,
-0.0832590908,
-1.1374791861,
-0.0173129123,
-0.4679557979,
-0.7997527122,
0.2133082449,
-0.2340571135,
-0.7912253737,
0.2345491648,
0.1466561109,
-0.2095564902,
0.8285982013,
-0.819691956,
0.6293690205,
-0.3746404648,
-0.121194087,
-0.1601240635,
-0.4165845215,
0.4941635728,
-0.43895787,
0.38100788,
0.3313079178,
0.5202544928,
0.5812727809,
-0.3199343681,
1.2202388048,
-0.3572637439,
0.3831739128,
0.1666179001,
0.3851865232,
0.6341154575,
-0.0422415957,
0.1019977555,
0.1231092513,
-0.1069000289,
-0.7453234792,
-0.6153085232,
0.6195222139,
-0.5778326988,
-0.7730827928,
-0.6947137117,
-0.3566182554,
-0.164870128,
0.0706676319,
0.6390431523,
0.2577472925,
-0.1668374836,
0.1125371158,
0.6137982607,
-0.036394652,
0.2649956644,
0.4312941134,
-0.2107128501,
-0.077411972,
1.0735375881,
0.3873237967,
0.6436267495,
0.3356656432,
0.064476952,
-0.1580645442,
-0.4202119708,
-0.3535339534,
-0.1713308394,
-0.6970788836,
-0.1082833409,
-0.4250497818,
-0.447437793,
-0.4364409149,
-0.1701780111,
-0.2511477172,
-0.3067090213,
-0.7676605582,
-0.2989708781,
0.3846171796,
0.9922654629,
-0.1843407899,
0.5448327661,
-0.5898221135,
0.2489436865,
0.403932184,
0.0352208614,
0.0194258448,
-0.5534681678,
-0.1570900381,
0.3303450346,
-0.3348367512,
-1.2493662834,
0.4996278584,
-0.1231734157,
0.5702905059,
0.5308221579,
0.2684658766,
0.4311145842,
-0.0877805948,
0.7541500926,
0.2017131597,
-0.8582726121,
0.8260490298,
-0.3031160831,
-0.0757475719,
0.1136437133,
0.9199252725,
-0.2353444993,
-0.4692129493,
-0.796274662,
-0.4946028292,
0.6989062428,
0.1743704677,
0.0592888035,
0.256665647,
0.343266964,
0.1030814424,
0.2148530334,
-0.9818698168,
-0.4906400442,
-0.6166262031,
0.0568015724,
-0.1305835396,
-0.2635747492,
-0.2556573451,
0.0536479652,
0.6913526654,
0.1799512506,
0.1555797905,
0.1912319809,
-0.3393007815,
-0.1605007201,
-0.099164255,
0.3016485274,
0.629083395,
-0.2122389674,
0.2871487439,
0.0360194519,
-0.389373064,
0.2474671304,
0.0841359794,
-0.310094595,
-0.0354919247,
0.612654388,
0.8856397271,
0.0453513749,
-0.2566564679,
0.6687761545,
-0.2198553681,
-0.3109669983,
-0.1852614433,
0.3194510937,
-0.2668963969,
0.3026709259,
0.7976669669,
0.4156254828,
0.0313736014,
-0.7807732821,
0.2733001709,
0.5749514103,
-0.4794979692,
-0.385168463,
0.9241725802,
-0.3727398217,
-0.3721846938,
0.1947304606,
-0.0571843386,
-0.8322427273,
0.7288045287,
0.8724088073,
0.4664355516,
-0.7221907377,
0.3631565869,
0.182458654,
0.5674364567,
-0.1117520183,
0.0064107818,
0.5230696201,
-0.7295353413,
-0.0287052467,
-0.329759419,
-0.2008029968,
0.6832573414,
-0.8871541619,
0.1071916521,
-0.6081795096,
-0.2277647257,
0.3999069035,
-0.2507777214,
-0.4620037377,
0.5755629539,
0.0209880639,
0.6981408596,
-1.1572550535,
0.632807076,
0.6026540399,
-0.2892196774,
-0.2686673105,
0.3561208844,
0.3085193336,
-0.3363265395,
0.3466894329,
0.114399448,
0.3522008657,
-0.264534086,
-0.8041613698,
-0.6182659268,
0.53950423,
0.3496422768,
-0.3374465704,
0.0115613714,
0.0557628088,
0.4532338977,
-0.1692471504,
-0.0781835616,
0.3894843459,
0.2892214358,
-0.1007525027,
-0.4347530305,
0.0320334919,
-0.0513614081,
-0.2474402487,
0.1088736057,
-0.4963369966,
0.9707971215,
-0.2098993361,
-0.2535965145,
-0.490962714,
0.3721521497,
-0.2321584225,
0.4436321855,
0.645483613,
0.6379143,
0.693318665,
0.0214616284,
1.0990692377,
-0.0001826073,
0.3789951205,
0.9120602012,
-0.0083403895,
0.62413764,
0.0713059083,
-0.250706315,
0.3495936096,
0.7579694986,
-0.2130143493,
0.6826953888,
-0.0429869816,
-0.443908453,
-0.3447642028,
0.1766184866,
-0.3902877867,
0.3776759505,
0.5394402742,
-0.3260433376,
-0.1243272498,
0.3668750226,
0.1467476636,
-0.0356813706,
-0.6293967962,
0.5160543323,
-0.1513366699,
-0.2976461947,
0.510268569,
0.103704147,
0.3910210729,
-0.5818533301,
0.1718825549,
0.0071506426,
0.1864113063,
-0.629058063,
-0.4065987766,
0.5352303982,
0.0737562701,
-0.2345249951,
0.3095859587,
1.1183240414,
-0.1483658552,
-0.5275868773,
0.3946109414,
0.2652808428,
-0.0805188492,
-0.4013507962,
-0.5473545194,
0.0163181033,
0.20901452,
-0.4995384812,
0.7848958373,
-0.1027073786,
0.0610881038,
0.8063357472,
1.1217497587,
0.2328056097,
0.1427833587,
-0.2037386894,
0.954079926,
-0.4516536593,
-0.5063585639,
-1.0064079762,
0.2692018449,
-0.033545807,
0.2226831615,
0.8546621203,
0.5929851532,
1.1260823011,
-0.0373786055,
1.185059309,
0.023457624,
0.4358840287,
-0.5585465431,
1.0046821833,
-0.6728653908,
0.2282558531,
-0.1682803929,
-0.5544732213,
-0.4453496635,
0.2992758453,
-0.4462571442,
-0.0888487697,
0.7050052285,
0.6630471349,
-0.1225510091,
0.1958579272,
0.3520533144,
0.3559930027,
0.3957995176,
0.2096013129,
0.6037304997,
-0.4458490014,
0.6899527907,
-0.3500584364,
-0.1740881205,
-0.5796152949,
-0.7171563506,
-1.2568824291,
-0.3959553242,
-0.3856032193,
-0.7300533652,
0.3251391947,
0.3551276326,
0.5788598657,
-0.857367456,
0.3542540669,
-0.0963239968,
0.4861547351,
-0.1956846863,
-0.2600504458,
0.446444571,
-0.1441122741,
-0.6016767621,
0.4736297131,
-0.2281995714,
0.3763821125,
-0.4046797156,
0.3056232333,
-0.282879591,
0.3284628689,
0.3603160977,
0.3265049756,
-0.4417085052,
-0.2909475267,
-0.2926922441,
-0.0918533504,
-0.074846983,
0.6490676403,
-0.8585849404,
0.6253169775,
0.3656718731,
0.5656515956,
0.4348526895,
0.1839327216,
0.1697222888,
-0.8367872834,
0.0671293139,
0.0214000251,
0.2210608423,
0.3223381639,
-0.9605545402,
0.0878223255,
0.6586167216,
-0.3987178206,
-1.1721873283,
0.2800218463,
-0.5724231005,
-0.8178347349,
1.0873912573,
-0.1396159679,
-0.4677046835,
-0.2195397764,
0.0303316638,
0.197465241,
-0.2145460695,
0.8623077869,
0.5466914177,
0.0399003848,
0.3846413493,
-0.911747694,
0.5406252742,
-0.0406852141,
-0.7509775758,
-0.1441042423,
0.241930604,
0.6280199885,
0.0604031347,
0.2958185673,
0.1484247446,
0.4494981766,
0.293782562,
-0.2682497799,
0.0088022249,
-0.5385286808,
-0.4079505205,
0.2239945978,
-0.3475420475,
-0.2890025079
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15197v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15197v1
|
TransFace: Unit-Based Audio-Visual Speech Synthesizer for Talking Head Translation
| 2023-12-23T08:45:57 | 2023-12-23T08:45:57 |
Xize Cheng, Rongjie Huang, Linjun Li, Tao Jin, Zehan Wang, Aoxiong Yin, Minglei Li, Xinyu Duan, changpeng yang, Zhou Zhao
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.CV, eess.AS
|
Direct speech-to-speech translation achieves high-quality results through the
introduction of discrete units obtained from self-supervised learning. This
approach circumvents delays and cascading errors associated with model
cascading. However, talking head translation, converting audio-visual speech
(i.e., talking head video) from one language into another, still confronts
several challenges compared to audio speech: (1) Existing methods invariably
rely on cascading, synthesizing via both audio and text, resulting in delays
and cascading errors. (2) Talking head translation has a limited set of
reference frames. If the generated translation exceeds the length of the
original speech, the video sequence needs to be supplemented by repeating
frames, leading to jarring video transitions. In this work, we propose a model
for talking head translation, \textbf{TransFace}, which can directly translate
audio-visual speech into audio-visual speech in other languages. It consists of
a speech-to-unit translation model to convert audio speech into discrete units
and a unit-based audio-visual speech synthesizer, Unit2Lip, to re-synthesize
synchronized audio-visual speech from discrete units in parallel. Furthermore,
we introduce a Bounded Duration Predictor, ensuring isometric talking head
translation and preventing duplicate reference frames. Experiments demonstrate
that our proposed Unit2Lip model significantly improves synchronization (1.601
and 0.982 on LSE-C for the original and generated audio speech, respectively)
and boosts inference speed by a factor of 4.35 on LRS2. Additionally, TransFace
achieves impressive BLEU scores of 61.93 and 47.55 for Es-En and Fr-En on
LRS3-T and 100% isochronous translations.
|
[
-0.283469677,
-0.7899065018,
0.3646395504,
0.5457679033,
-0.4713916481,
0.2222048193,
-0.2955903411,
-0.4209810793,
0.0694251582,
0.5403027534,
-0.57623595,
-0.4248900115,
-0.5272209644,
0.0511389151,
-0.4898665845,
0.6380209923,
-0.0073162611,
0.1201180369,
-0.0529530421,
-0.1342912316,
-0.9143000841,
-0.1198422089,
-0.3758494258,
-0.2716130912,
0.2031557113,
0.2867025435,
0.69887954,
0.6259253025,
0.3024381995,
0.2946920693,
0.0339046344,
0.0625384375,
-0.1093220934,
0.2624896467,
-0.1875930727,
-0.3112237453,
-0.6286753416,
-0.0839691535,
0.874820888,
0.7511823177,
-0.0521816984,
0.220966205,
0.0925124064,
0.4372564256,
-0.3989821672,
0.2505402565,
-0.419441998,
0.1794467866,
-0.3715076447,
-0.0646859035,
-0.4712782502,
-0.0317359529,
0.2840208113,
-0.4461400211,
0.125638172,
-0.1107529849,
0.5154310465,
0.543178618,
-0.0862830728,
0.3182832003,
-0.9712530971,
0.6984093785,
-0.4234885275,
0.9598911405,
0.0189029127,
0.5537585616,
0.2055381387,
-0.9780931473,
-0.6993678212,
0.0334687904,
0.2307701856,
0.3079524934,
-0.3043169379,
0.1020188779,
0.1217707321,
0.0203552879,
-0.6799436212,
-0.2332608104,
-0.351575166,
-0.1500088722,
0.5647087693,
-0.0690766647,
0.377921164,
-0.3832122684,
-0.2674583197,
-0.4135642648,
-0.4822317064,
-0.0308061708,
0.0647156388,
0.3901678324,
-0.3448675871,
0.4147829711,
0.0735107958,
0.6503360271,
0.0248988885,
-0.627450645,
0.3348715007,
-0.1306603998,
-0.5202997923,
0.3704588711,
0.8119372725,
0.4342874587,
0.2138340473,
-0.1531128138,
0.039464511,
-0.0178986434,
0.1557713598,
-0.8914985061,
-0.1969641149,
0.0989014134,
-0.2174435258,
0.0538743138,
-0.1109706685,
-0.5679405928,
0.3238682449,
-0.4168887734,
0.4047040343,
-0.3449479938,
-0.32055071,
-0.2467908114,
0.1140171587,
-0.1344065517,
0.5589082241,
-0.6767556071,
0.1404578239,
0.3878687024,
1.1264084578,
-0.5692940354,
-0.3879284561,
-0.6853052974,
0.4475139976,
-0.4966472983,
0.5386608839,
-0.3975900114,
-0.7135937214,
-0.1150162816,
0.0469940826,
0.0396506526,
-0.5538827181,
0.0541481227,
-0.0514287241,
0.0524683408,
-0.1748442948,
-0.1358365566,
0.0471929833,
-0.3537662327,
-0.5347994566,
0.6531966329,
0.2330556512,
-0.3468592167,
0.0259685516,
-0.3956694007,
-0.5308983326,
0.4079205096,
-0.3364365399,
-0.4736434817,
-0.005563511,
0.0839017928,
0.1509719938,
-0.3268277645,
0.3831070662,
0.0306193307,
-0.0471073091,
0.2664805055,
-0.4026920795,
0.6873250008,
0.237057656,
-0.456261307,
0.0232888013,
-0.3759454191,
-0.1842907071,
-0.3634715378,
0.0415012911,
-0.0949068218,
-0.1988270283,
0.4468922019,
0.2643664777,
-0.194539994,
-0.6620003581,
-0.1933281422,
-0.3178472519,
0.4927496016,
0.4814864397,
-0.0833578184,
0.4170486331,
-0.0812385306,
0.4960462749,
0.1369158328,
-0.0120220799,
-0.1918392777,
-0.8686887622,
-0.5632482171,
-0.1704169065,
0.2281258255,
0.7867031693,
-0.9888101816,
-0.0162007269,
-0.4046682119,
-0.3105210662,
-0.5609464049,
0.0994410813,
0.5752239823,
1.0189760923,
0.5863645673,
-0.5254628062,
-0.468693018,
-0.8897936344,
-0.0361796208,
-0.5462781787,
-0.2306034565,
0.2225861698,
0.2183904052,
-0.2489133179,
0.9578565955,
-0.0388904251,
-0.4242157042,
-0.1382994801,
0.2112734914,
-0.097744599,
0.725047946,
0.438185662,
-0.7782457471,
-0.5360800028,
0.2496009171,
-0.7580037117,
-0.4756653011,
-0.1806729138,
-0.114616774,
0.1623792797,
0.4890760183,
-0.601867497,
0.5533699989,
0.6151154637,
0.0624998659,
0.3192763627,
0.2644691467,
0.1675337702,
-0.9725677967,
0.0692259967,
-0.1215466708,
-0.7013596296,
-0.7076704502,
-0.0914717987,
-0.1085778698,
-0.4557995498,
-1.0088281631,
0.4673347175,
-0.1062111035,
-0.2956959009,
-0.3099546432,
0.2327799648,
-0.1167033911,
0.5539796948,
0.2865974307,
1.0868136883,
0.4568800628,
-0.566249907,
0.4397293627,
0.7143498659,
-0.2546026707,
0.9125557542,
-0.6781536341,
-0.0236487277,
-0.0176417306,
0.2350786328,
-0.7202269435,
-0.183662042,
0.2278777063,
-0.4984543622,
0.3500000834,
-0.1436701119,
0.0933602527,
-0.1281271875,
0.2409901619,
0.6321564913,
0.4238503277,
-0.263356179,
0.6549659371,
0.4958673418,
-0.6583454609,
-0.443503052,
-1.1666171551,
0.3613222241,
0.0809933543,
-0.6990092993,
0.8145464063,
-0.0961024836,
-0.0991457924,
0.0891310796,
-0.0728846639,
0.2070921212,
-0.5457995534,
0.2886422873,
0.1730778217,
-0.0283088982,
-0.0603658967,
0.2049634606,
-0.1014778614,
0.0326463841,
-0.4134413004,
0.3185732961,
0.0153863262,
-0.1015395895,
-0.7291228175,
0.6634922028,
0.6445627809,
-0.1229300052,
0.1154566854,
0.6786940694,
-0.2906136513,
-0.1025215536,
-0.4537069499,
0.0564465448,
-0.4125361145,
0.5130228996,
-0.7047675252,
-0.7639241219,
0.3485998511,
0.0418105163,
-0.07195694,
0.2936552763,
0.7848356366,
-0.1875714362,
0.9011821151,
0.3657731414,
0.2709760666,
0.7224279642,
-0.3531964123,
-0.0565329865,
-0.8981874585,
-0.3981623352,
0.0593065098,
-0.3064917922,
-0.7108152509,
-0.6200973988,
0.6891643405,
-0.2056190819,
-0.1428758949,
0.6802843213,
-0.4166600704,
0.0865144879,
0.6080622077,
0.1289567202,
0.2304581255,
0.244166106,
0.016174024,
-0.4223538041,
-0.4011022151,
-0.1810831577,
0.7455708981,
0.3995117247,
0.6041482091,
0.3046331108,
0.3927469552,
0.3652314246,
0.1701946259,
-0.566131711,
0.5359555483,
-0.264824599,
-0.3067812622,
-0.2968592048,
-0.5280876756,
-0.4815190136,
0.2142665237,
-0.0793045908,
-0.789388895,
0.4235821664,
0.1834802032,
-0.2884049118,
0.2272549421,
-0.3457876146,
0.9020562768,
-0.1380851418,
-0.5472124219,
-0.0573396645,
-0.7902325988,
0.3167796731,
0.0088954754,
0.0987373963,
-0.067076847,
0.1542826891,
0.6670030355,
-0.3409233391,
0.485116303,
-0.1893151551,
-0.0108086644,
0.5209465623,
0.2368006557,
0.1061561331,
0.3473979235,
0.4365811944,
0.4700374007,
-0.0601761639,
-0.1627307236,
-0.5544776917,
0.5207847357,
-0.683694005,
-0.7095862627,
-0.1643978804,
-0.5052394867,
-0.2176330537,
0.0227684956,
0.4358541369,
0.3175423741,
-0.3112943172,
0.2701720595,
0.6285741925,
-0.2208361477,
0.6382225752,
0.3207188845,
-0.5638217926,
-0.8662106395,
0.9176624417,
0.0411883928,
0.6370016336,
0.4709159136,
-0.0973487049,
-0.1059706435,
-0.1709157526,
-0.9486843944,
0.1696678996,
-0.3655712903,
-0.3316999078,
-0.7085677385,
-0.2111686915,
-0.6280168295,
0.1771330237,
-0.7534834743,
-0.4654002786,
-0.1282454431,
0.0313506275,
0.0564715192,
0.1580282152,
-0.3210347295,
0.6536456943,
-0.5364857316,
0.7098920941,
0.8042628169,
0.0996935964,
-0.3690466881,
-0.806512177,
-0.1030948833,
0.084455505,
-0.3658244014,
-1.0981509686,
0.7589938641,
0.2209706157,
0.1396054178,
-0.0058500026,
-0.3675780892,
1.0366925001,
-0.8412793279,
0.6783724427,
0.4190796018,
-1.1976428032,
0.5800888538,
-0.1398355067,
0.4165695906,
0.3964858055,
-0.0949875489,
-0.9018634558,
-0.3813010752,
-0.3394803405,
-0.6910043955,
0.6146085262,
0.6388862133,
-0.0699822381,
0.0978691652,
0.0805251002,
-0.0528639592,
0.4046407044,
-0.491425544,
-0.385173738,
-0.6901267171,
0.0882471651,
0.059836939,
0.1382837296,
0.0967820361,
-0.3168719113,
0.8574516773,
-0.1040541232,
0.4806931019,
0.5122944713,
-0.2898004949,
-0.4601834714,
0.0193495285,
0.6082825661,
0.5540599823,
-0.3199755549,
-0.0598614998,
0.1191564649,
-0.6546916366,
0.2319907248,
0.1712625027,
-0.4146906137,
0.6854856014,
0.2365551591,
1.1637912989,
0.1280012429,
-0.5050478578,
0.6768339276,
0.1637650579,
-0.0042918194,
-0.4395981431,
-0.3594790697,
0.0142970942,
0.164923206,
0.5652171969,
0.1382533908,
0.1762222052,
-0.6568651199,
0.4058154225,
0.242846176,
-0.4093056917,
-0.4121613204,
1.1551576853,
0.4386329353,
-0.5932427645,
0.3292200565,
0.1573733091,
-0.2056794316,
0.2031665593,
0.5444477201,
1.1760720015,
-0.8442162275,
0.3918834627,
0.195640102,
0.2006956041,
0.0242779739,
0.1950523406,
-0.2110129446,
-0.3932645619,
-0.6991010904,
-0.6856678128,
-0.7135314345,
0.1311567575,
-0.6011373401,
0.1940125972,
-0.2200726122,
-0.3013182878,
0.0074149044,
-0.4800071716,
-0.607496798,
0.3783921599,
0.499435991,
0.654353857,
-0.9158895016,
0.89297539,
0.4191929698,
-0.3982081115,
-0.4333412349,
-0.3614456058,
-0.1417322159,
-0.3760750592,
0.568641901,
0.0379552804,
-0.2989260256,
-0.032154426,
-0.3097355366,
-0.7843532562,
1.0553327799,
0.7371948957,
-1.0437159538,
-0.2084967047,
0.6275362372,
0.2607373595,
-0.4461832941,
0.0268825218,
0.677760601,
0.3461001813,
0.2613289058,
-1.2509897947,
-0.2741014063,
-0.0314429253,
0.4824458659,
-0.1518988013,
-0.65962255,
0.9287334085,
0.1634456962,
-0.3577848077,
0.0184469409,
1.1709293127,
0.0539711453,
0.3383317292,
0.3312009573,
0.4931662977,
0.3176292181,
-0.001086514,
0.5995409489,
-0.2997366488,
0.0767432526,
1.2128933668,
-0.0543513782,
0.7549516559,
0.6034746766,
-0.1553139985,
0.7279618979,
0.1427658945,
0.2949624062,
0.5855798721,
-0.3702146411,
-0.5129513741,
-0.4062579274,
-0.0897749439,
-0.4310106039,
0.7056716084,
0.3503065705,
-0.4750549793,
0.0487036854,
0.5509582162,
-0.2696722746,
0.1475003809,
-0.2150578946,
0.5655145049,
0.3173292577,
-0.7322170734,
0.399004072,
-0.0193468276,
0.2567089796,
-0.3085010946,
-0.1342186481,
-0.2972167134,
0.0152071873,
-0.0072476785,
-0.5721407533,
0.378020376,
0.057161402,
0.0426695459,
-0.4588485956,
0.2120828032,
-0.8634072542,
-0.577659905,
0.1172625422,
0.6331967711,
0.2570191622,
-0.045791246,
-0.6543282866,
0.3558986187,
0.0283643603,
-0.1558902264,
0.0126421778,
0.2153342217,
-0.1936453432,
0.5127059817,
0.4853399396,
0.1360000223,
-0.1218976378,
0.1965770721,
0.4309647083,
-0.5782344341,
-0.6111902595,
-0.7699135542,
0.4214299023,
0.0909087509,
-0.1836881936,
0.5589672923,
0.5785612464,
0.9493209124,
-0.1961198598,
0.8761627078,
0.035836231,
0.3863736987,
-0.5302903056,
0.5117958784,
-0.2633258104,
-0.1018983722,
-0.6507050395,
-1.1604263783,
-0.267193675,
0.6793999076,
0.0593866706,
-0.1588228941,
0.6803665161,
0.6099307537,
-0.0774566531,
-0.243601948,
0.681527555,
0.1734827161,
0.2437496334,
0.5843048692,
0.2085093856,
-0.7626796961,
0.76334548,
-0.3796933293,
-0.10305617,
-0.0687823668,
-0.6434836388,
-0.6598352194,
-0.8070470095,
-0.7068024278,
-0.4065468013,
0.2660702467,
0.6665922999,
0.9454101324,
-0.7991710901,
-0.52148211,
-0.1823405325,
-0.1390225142,
-0.2457917184,
-0.1902421415,
0.0765323564,
0.0648672506,
-1.1288193464,
0.6324680448,
0.5371177197,
0.2655379772,
-0.4942471683,
-0.2468780428,
0.0451414436,
0.0207816418,
0.7353749871,
0.4924713075,
-0.9937417507,
-0.3810743392,
-0.2164931744,
-0.0520335175,
0.2376497388,
0.6880511642,
-0.9711050391,
0.7312985659,
0.280007869,
0.4891400039,
1.0936564207,
0.152170226,
0.7474860549,
-0.9636598825,
0.3262850344,
0.0918462351,
0.1996664107,
0.7184538841,
-0.0194074214,
0.4060248137,
0.5241950154,
-0.2730647922,
-0.7852316499,
0.4908108711,
-1.3417087793,
-0.0866305605,
0.9984639287,
0.0295709409,
-0.5241018534,
0.2001986057,
-0.1540412158,
0.6482281089,
-0.3524068594,
0.4446513951,
0.2146375179,
0.0014661012,
-0.4903605878,
-0.6318554878,
0.5328643322,
0.3929355741,
-0.4987535477,
0.1057683006,
0.4447965026,
0.1664235145,
0.3621067703,
0.4139535427,
-0.1568744183,
0.6974642873,
-0.0423718654,
0.2291772366,
-0.142784968,
-0.5572564602,
-0.0326814838,
0.0237871166,
-0.5036792159,
-0.4422471225
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15194v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15194v2
|
PokeMQA: Programmable knowledge editing for Multi-hop Question Answering
| 2023-12-23T08:32:13 | 2024-02-15T03:10:29 |
Hengrui Gu, Kaixiong Zhou, Xiaotian Han, Ninghao Liu, Ruobing Wang, Xin Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multi-hop question answering (MQA) is one of the challenging tasks to
evaluate machine's comprehension and reasoning abilities, where large language
models (LLMs) have widely achieved the human-comparable performance. Due to the
dynamics of knowledge facts in real world, knowledge editing has been explored
to update model with the up-to-date facts while avoiding expensive re-training
or fine-tuning. Starting from the edited fact, the updated model needs to
provide cascading changes in the chain of MQA. The previous art simply adopts a
mix-up prompt to instruct LLMs conducting multiple reasoning tasks
sequentially, including question decomposition, answer generation, and conflict
checking via comparing with edited facts. However, the coupling of these
functionally-diverse reasoning tasks inhibits LLMs' advantages in comprehending
and answering questions while disturbing them with the unskilled task of
conflict checking. We thus propose a framework, Programmable knowledge editing
for Multi-hop Question Answering (PokeMQA), to decouple the jobs. Specifically,
we prompt LLMs to decompose knowledge-augmented multi-hop question, while
interacting with a detached trainable scope detector to modulate LLMs behavior
depending on external conflict signal. The experiments on three LLM backbones
and two benchmark datasets validate our superiority in knowledge editing of
MQA, outperforming all competitors by a large margin in almost all settings and
consistently producing reliable reasoning process.
|
[
-0.365236342,
-0.8396825194,
0.7420400977,
-0.0169666968,
0.0340937115,
0.6502703428,
0.0455707312,
-0.3653123975,
0.2493754625,
0.5075528026,
-0.7447802424,
-0.203914389,
-0.6561570764,
0.2627668083,
-0.0490518995,
0.5743351579,
-0.2066005766,
-0.2261628211,
-0.1551275402,
-0.2341910154,
-0.709345758,
-0.4271196127,
-0.5649820566,
-0.1809190214,
0.387444824,
0.5057906508,
0.8367529511,
0.4088180959,
0.3011523783,
0.3988541067,
-0.4149737954,
0.663559556,
-0.2127302289,
0.3488370776,
-0.2488472015,
-0.5152795911,
-0.55302912,
0.0513524972,
0.6222752333,
0.4202497303,
0.2320983559,
0.0990868583,
-0.0640930459,
0.4578303099,
-0.6023218036,
-0.1852467954,
-0.9718073606,
-0.1755526066,
-0.0289270151,
-0.2062197924,
-0.1472214758,
-0.2971554995,
-0.1400322318,
-0.4871203005,
-0.1782937944,
-0.0111261988,
0.6892134547,
0.5331463218,
-0.4249533415,
-0.1408454478,
-0.4314158261,
0.4851331413,
-0.5279731154,
0.4988133907,
0.1628675759,
0.2129621357,
-0.5155262947,
-0.3508560359,
-0.6885855794,
0.0651303232,
0.1961393952,
0.2713760734,
-0.0617275983,
0.1413516998,
0.4067540169,
0.1037565768,
-0.3069728315,
-0.253951937,
-0.3914351463,
-0.2299583852,
0.2908035219,
0.2215577215,
0.3707625568,
-0.2066298127,
-0.1818121523,
0.1159848422,
-0.6530873775,
0.3730687201,
0.2173366249,
-0.1529168338,
0.4023039639,
0.9376991987,
-0.6030482054,
0.610658288,
0.1577223539,
-0.3286028504,
0.0115605993,
-0.1037804857,
-0.3559663594,
-0.2098553777,
0.6789995432,
0.4887128174,
-0.0215730704,
-0.1544194221,
-0.0063197394,
-0.2311984003,
0.2527264655,
-0.4801202118,
-0.1968590319,
0.6379355192,
-0.2516609132,
-0.2350546718,
-0.3127800226,
-0.6026669145,
-0.4306107163,
-0.0883354619,
0.699986577,
-0.7609778643,
-0.0112031894,
0.2987285852,
-0.3029548228,
0.0967658833,
0.5428444147,
-0.2727814913,
-0.2437036633,
0.7212252617,
0.8443576097,
0.2365793586,
-0.749029398,
-0.8193007112,
0.2164398432,
-0.3072678149,
0.6638413668,
-0.5781131387,
-0.2240609378,
-0.3654591739,
-0.1320967823,
-0.3738441467,
-0.4291494787,
0.5102876425,
-0.9657074809,
0.0621306263,
-0.2473502755,
-0.7316482067,
-0.1729735285,
0.7121224999,
-0.4687294066,
0.909145534,
0.0737710819,
-1.0055838823,
0.3412065804,
-0.9067006111,
-0.1589996219,
-0.1308977008,
0.1850353181,
-0.3185402155,
-0.2231791168,
0.425501287,
0.175421387,
0.2075214982,
0.2811956108,
-0.2993651628,
-0.4026352763,
0.4986058176,
-0.0853312016,
0.8116558194,
0.2361056656,
-0.1187582463,
0.3028076887,
-0.6696200967,
0.0341077298,
-0.1410296708,
-0.8606702685,
-0.3275640905,
-0.0037787459,
-0.8321046233,
0.4631426036,
0.0488164946,
-0.7344691753,
0.5516200662,
-0.1855600923,
0.2479863763,
0.5601981282,
0.3700187802,
0.1527549773,
-0.6838510633,
0.5588859916,
0.1384283155,
0.2305818647,
-0.1977910548,
-0.8233683705,
-0.7527418733,
-0.477013886,
0.2772485018,
0.8677756786,
-1.0720639229,
0.2520420253,
-0.0823481306,
-0.4429841936,
-0.8483313918,
0.239906311,
0.1290975362,
0.5626341701,
0.6019106507,
0.2195295542,
-0.5365518928,
-0.3185990453,
-0.7483267784,
-0.0291711185,
-0.0658907369,
0.0635070056,
0.4073844254,
-0.4312248528,
0.911419034,
-0.3058501482,
0.0625648499,
-0.2222028226,
0.161064744,
0.1158922091,
0.4462913275,
0.0692124665,
-0.3690438271,
-0.1464265734,
-0.2753583789,
-0.5842010975,
-0.2465026975,
-0.4577587545,
-0.6521068811,
-0.2245958298,
0.6273034811,
-0.9827688336,
0.3439040482,
0.4595507085,
-0.5296343565,
1.0573139191,
-0.1167391315,
0.7555033565,
-0.9542242289,
-0.1949690729,
-0.5903837681,
-0.1467038542,
-0.6121922135,
0.3699813783,
0.3284208477,
0.1421076953,
-0.4163017571,
0.35933429,
-0.2773604691,
0.1798346937,
-0.1543528587,
0.2057181299,
0.2628572583,
0.4027511179,
0.0142920911,
0.6975127459,
0.4799576104,
-0.722458005,
0.4076324105,
0.6740261912,
-0.3528652191,
0.2839360237,
-0.4397528172,
0.128104046,
-0.0485884733,
0.046678707,
-0.8316307068,
-0.0998214036,
0.3255187869,
-0.4826545417,
0.0101810191,
-0.6149970889,
-0.3359474838,
-0.1360711157,
-0.5549314022,
0.2865129709,
0.0943732113,
-0.6851577759,
0.7220862508,
0.0757860243,
-0.1372081786,
-0.6442440152,
-0.5015525818,
0.2160057276,
-0.4025448859,
-0.8774600625,
0.2664450109,
-0.3022502959,
-0.2714349926,
-0.0734202489,
-0.0768594593,
0.0168241914,
0.1218576729,
0.0043094298,
0.3429056406,
-0.0357570983,
0.255392611,
0.4137480557,
-0.045980189,
0.0294679012,
-0.0943965763,
0.0917477161,
0.2294873744,
-0.4421778321,
-0.0855874419,
0.2979249656,
0.8292807341,
-0.6021440625,
0.6765464544,
0.4824604392,
-0.2245159596,
0.1063162759,
-0.6112527251,
0.1400211453,
-0.4734028876,
0.2440925688,
-0.8931201696,
-1.1912961006,
0.4019218981,
-0.619489193,
0.3729706407,
0.2026470304,
0.4759749174,
-0.2009958774,
0.749696672,
0.1627200693,
0.1383472383,
0.2142317295,
0.0622602701,
0.1782392859,
-1.2170091867,
-0.1563329399,
-0.4186119139,
-0.3067768812,
-0.4648188651,
-0.7346765995,
0.4968969226,
0.3777359426,
-0.323017925,
0.0093922541,
-0.2042604536,
0.6354581714,
0.6806412339,
0.1328413188,
0.52697438,
-0.6131595969,
-0.3401630819,
0.0731188133,
-0.7315362692,
-0.3759058118,
1.0486757755,
0.2035332322,
0.8294056654,
0.3886748552,
0.8455860615,
0.0419740826,
-0.0268377196,
-0.8202783465,
0.3344958723,
0.2959374487,
-0.4649063051,
-0.3042152226,
-0.5874923468,
-0.6290015578,
0.6103412509,
-0.4872740805,
-0.7992046475,
0.0059702643,
0.2305138409,
-0.4789626002,
0.7327145338,
-0.6193705201,
0.8141322732,
-0.1720470935,
-0.1754071712,
0.0074713407,
-0.4476293921,
0.9044424891,
-0.0063143191,
0.4010939598,
-0.0754717216,
0.0996233448,
0.5734218955,
-0.4409434795,
0.4124598801,
-0.1117625087,
0.1063190997,
0.2409308851,
0.7416416407,
0.425526619,
0.3719747365,
-0.0274434686,
-0.143771261,
0.4358890355,
-0.1696627885,
-0.5752004981,
0.4297544658,
-0.6784124374,
-0.7053909302,
-0.2291731238,
-0.7933365107,
-0.5876036882,
0.1302193999,
0.0466253087,
0.3860923946,
0.0606128946,
-0.1324318647,
0.8288009167,
-0.4592063427,
0.1264182627,
0.2107862085,
-0.3072954416,
-0.3062583804,
0.4475781024,
-0.1763253063,
0.2756675482,
0.4499277174,
0.3574859798,
-0.3582326174,
-0.3966273069,
-0.4927600622,
0.081183888,
-0.7946908474,
-0.2876798809,
-0.9873306751,
-0.1078748778,
-0.2317643464,
-0.1998990625,
-0.4109086692,
-0.50018996,
0.2381887883,
0.2475084811,
0.3643639386,
0.5708242059,
-0.164486587,
0.2767400742,
-1.097736001,
0.7614934444,
0.5833861232,
0.4608662724,
-0.3947145939,
-0.582484901,
-0.097128354,
0.0712565035,
-0.2501702607,
-1.1934967041,
-0.1084274575,
0.1827484071,
0.42114833,
0.0329074189,
0.1197994649,
0.84710145,
-0.3883652389,
0.5258620977,
-0.1466018856,
-1.152499795,
0.5941181779,
-0.156909883,
0.5054258108,
0.4153491557,
0.1182932928,
-0.780246079,
-0.7086779475,
-0.4169737399,
-0.3979430497,
0.618816793,
0.0011273082,
-0.3064897954,
0.207459718,
0.4317454696,
-0.0164334122,
0.1915665865,
-0.3196741641,
-0.0575281121,
-0.1813667715,
0.0154587999,
0.3105040789,
-0.3905107677,
-0.1959329396,
-0.3722735941,
0.7839315534,
-0.0700563788,
0.1774165481,
0.2547388077,
-0.3894569874,
0.0554211438,
0.6325765252,
0.349109441,
0.5618315339,
-0.3408300579,
0.2562457621,
0.2102653533,
-0.3905658424,
0.1147500947,
-0.154505074,
-0.2923268378,
-0.1154766977,
0.2426221073,
0.3000630438,
0.1054359153,
-0.6891922355,
0.2253093123,
-0.2888645828,
-0.5351757407,
0.4770819843,
0.3123144805,
0.221029833,
0.5750877261,
-0.0001551645,
0.4361200929,
0.1584676951,
-0.3292450607,
0.2683615983,
0.3789637983,
0.2467926592,
0.1480486244,
0.5605298877,
0.0847095847,
-0.1679014117,
0.5265906453,
-0.544410646,
-0.9684812427,
0.1222411171,
0.21143803,
0.5578657389,
-0.1594456583,
0.216310218,
0.4123465419,
0.7188047171,
0.3167545497,
0.4600436687,
0.0720151216,
-0.948336184,
-0.7290653586,
-0.2784925103,
-0.7558697462,
0.267546773,
-0.2800909281,
0.1277631223,
-0.3896181285,
0.1004691496,
-0.1839988977,
-0.0292054601,
-0.5381820798,
0.1885403246,
-0.1691430211,
0.9696008563,
-0.4095902443,
0.7322554588,
0.7673743367,
-0.1124200448,
-0.7908861041,
0.1493671983,
0.1904906183,
-0.4556953311,
0.1095695347,
-0.0771540701,
-0.3454043865,
-0.1879380345,
-0.4576648474,
-0.7454055548,
0.8607555628,
0.2980410159,
-0.1659588069,
0.1965955198,
0.0584985316,
0.0213651098,
-0.0347529873,
0.266551137,
0.8282980919,
0.4536466897,
0.3779428601,
-0.7419176698,
-0.0550133549,
-0.1016534641,
-0.3916751742,
0.0977030843,
-0.5281792283,
0.7957832813,
-0.4316382706,
0.0308588035,
-0.0485712662,
0.2498786598,
0.5456190705,
0.0909857303,
0.473362267,
0.479557097,
0.9122235179,
-0.1717969924,
0.4411718249,
-0.2900822759,
0.1737036854,
1.4368983507,
-0.0215206146,
0.7274182439,
0.5501981974,
-0.1620196104,
0.3347120285,
0.6334760189,
0.3124802411,
0.1385167539,
0.0450837687,
-0.236027509,
-0.5042333603,
0.5253324509,
-0.1752059311,
0.8618330956,
0.2880603969,
0.259785831,
-0.1635171026,
-0.1848459244,
0.1529010087,
-0.2964510024,
-0.2102887332,
0.647374332,
-0.4512799978,
-0.8129515648,
0.3869667649,
0.3162963986,
0.7247354388,
-0.5911142826,
-0.1488971561,
-0.2711927593,
-0.0752814263,
-0.2267132699,
-1.0950517654,
0.4540937245,
0.2284021825,
0.0013319319,
0.1067592204,
0.9049751163,
-0.570700109,
-0.2262065709,
0.1545329988,
0.955019176,
0.0052916938,
-0.4294043481,
-0.9686242938,
0.2527900636,
-0.0260872189,
-0.2212060541,
0.1278474033,
0.6641450524,
0.1636516154,
0.922542274,
0.703327179,
0.0980372503,
0.5388345718,
0.0104427664,
0.9159819484,
-0.6248604655,
-0.6616421938,
-0.531223774,
0.7640395761,
-0.0628119335,
-0.0898551419,
0.5895256996,
0.3403716385,
0.66568923,
-0.0211772826,
0.8948754668,
-0.2976576686,
0.6795192957,
-0.7353162766,
0.5493186116,
-0.4408475757,
0.2972230017,
-0.3701287806,
-0.5593568087,
-0.1573428214,
0.3681571782,
-0.0721611008,
-0.068527624,
0.6823744178,
0.7967085838,
-0.0793659315,
-0.1406244785,
0.5267554522,
0.094022423,
0.4024477601,
0.6868538857,
1.1707818508,
-0.4783100486,
0.6269443035,
-0.3045259416,
-0.3966976106,
-0.0383841321,
-0.8012912869,
-0.974398911,
-0.3514955342,
-0.5878482461,
-0.2428940237,
-0.0700518861,
0.8298514485,
0.4036643803,
-0.6044024825,
0.1303593367,
0.3792591691,
0.6139668226,
-0.4241360426,
-0.216819346,
0.2351887673,
-0.4435048997,
-0.4589782357,
0.7352973223,
0.4577171206,
-0.3173815608,
0.2409395725,
-0.227977246,
-0.6082645059,
0.2222982794,
0.7007178664,
0.2250937819,
-0.5398737788,
-0.4440612793,
-0.000836022,
0.2325379848,
0.1280836165,
0.7353388071,
-0.5668413639,
0.9278082848,
0.3303645253,
1.0417727232,
-0.0086083356,
0.1635879576,
0.1205251664,
-0.762735188,
-0.2490382046,
-0.1359484494,
0.5510955453,
0.1163340881,
-0.3495580554,
0.1254036576,
0.1600373238,
-0.7258321643,
-0.3030303121,
0.1720463336,
-0.838968873,
-0.2063726485,
0.9698261619,
-0.2670128047,
-0.0661785975,
-0.3761048019,
-0.5776354671,
0.3923951089,
-0.0587718338,
0.7965863347,
0.7939258218,
-0.4530867338,
-0.3452692032,
-0.509542942,
0.6180374026,
0.2676249444,
-1.0153967142,
0.1576182544,
0.5977171063,
0.5187862515,
-0.1341944337,
0.5022115707,
-0.0473969616,
0.5668578148,
0.0745256394,
0.0355235748,
-0.3118483722,
-0.3198733926,
-0.2314775437,
-0.0036743386,
0.3320058882,
-0.4826372266
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15185v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15185v1
|
emotion2vec: Self-Supervised Pre-Training for Speech Emotion Representation
| 2023-12-23T07:46:55 | 2023-12-23T07:46:55 |
Ziyang Ma, Zhisheng Zheng, Jiaxin Ye, Jinchao Li, Zhifu Gao, Shiliang Zhang, Xie Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.MM, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
We propose emotion2vec, a universal speech emotion representation model.
emotion2vec is pre-trained on open-source unlabeled emotion data through
self-supervised online distillation, combining utterance-level loss and
frame-level loss during pre-training. emotion2vec outperforms state-of-the-art
pre-trained universal models and emotion specialist models by only training
linear layers for the speech emotion recognition task on the mainstream IEMOCAP
dataset. In addition, emotion2vec shows consistent improvements among 10
different languages of speech emotion recognition datasets. emotion2vec also
shows excellent results on other emotion tasks, such as song emotion
recognition, emotion prediction in conversation, and sentiment analysis.
Comparison experiments, ablation experiments, and visualization comprehensively
demonstrate the universal capability of the proposed emotion2vec. To the best
of our knowledge, emotion2vec is the first universal representation model in
various emotion-related tasks, filling a gap in the field.
|
[
-0.3732791245,
-0.1210702732,
0.3191026449,
0.3091377616,
-0.0695987269,
-0.1798473597,
-0.07065548,
-0.4115216732,
0.3247075677,
0.2496936321,
-0.7133259177,
-0.4818139076,
-0.5699191689,
-0.1080205664,
-0.3953781426,
0.8680643439,
0.0561179854,
0.3669273555,
-0.422216922,
-0.173883006,
-0.2509349287,
-0.8798705935,
-0.4027770162,
-0.5277634859,
0.5398088694,
0.5028755069,
-0.0339547768,
-0.0095772333,
0.2728714049,
0.3243549466,
0.1705277413,
-0.1962738335,
-0.7634802461,
0.2885800898,
0.1428080946,
-0.3891414702,
-0.4035789967,
0.5079457164,
0.1644604504,
0.2794868648,
-0.5153725743,
-0.0044302107,
0.1148585305,
0.7391076684,
-0.6587511897,
0.219537437,
-0.4936365485,
0.1981636733,
-0.1362944841,
0.0586715862,
-0.3938037753,
-0.3145111203,
0.0967544615,
-0.2671464384,
-0.0564379953,
-0.1481672227,
0.428183794,
0.3923394382,
-0.5987010598,
-0.4448949099,
-1.0091934204,
0.4735988379,
-0.249420777,
0.5441938639,
0.5007750988,
0.2425594479,
0.2113434076,
-0.7820271254,
-0.5356442332,
-0.1392447799,
0.3506810367,
0.6663156152,
-0.5702565908,
0.2863268256,
-0.0172959585,
0.1988266408,
-0.6531514525,
0.2677427232,
-0.3267725706,
-0.2889253795,
0.4432100654,
-0.1230703518,
-0.00462955,
0.0283332709,
-0.3970582485,
0.0168218557,
-0.5957012177,
0.1117187813,
0.38040483,
0.0481856205,
-0.0782095119,
0.3610495627,
-0.1414488703,
0.1564746499,
-0.1942604035,
0.4722325504,
0.3347614706,
0.0907692537,
-0.159806937,
0.465199858,
0.8203698397,
0.0808693692,
0.5735988021,
0.1446296275,
0.1298087835,
0.218887493,
0.3660614491,
-0.7800464034,
-0.3745194376,
0.198556602,
-0.3021832705,
-0.179695338,
0.1486903876,
-0.7616478205,
-0.2400935739,
-0.5389291644,
0.4524730444,
0.0002923517,
-0.3908432424,
-0.2652443349,
0.1000043675,
-0.0143628772,
0.2076415271,
-0.8455449343,
0.3714642823,
0.5106204748,
0.7742212415,
0.0542723276,
0.0004976683,
-0.3665235043,
-0.282194227,
-0.4032853544,
0.835079968,
-0.5421666503,
-0.5098646283,
0.1386270076,
-0.105984956,
0.3837650716,
-0.4604721069,
0.5836163163,
-0.1971370131,
0.3786655962,
-0.1678699404,
-0.7043516636,
-0.0184063762,
-0.2897690535,
-0.6120147705,
0.9874840975,
0.0607222132,
-0.7264819145,
0.0906559974,
-0.6116190553,
-0.2152553946,
-0.1501245499,
-0.0658383667,
-0.2267211825,
0.1629119366,
0.0693481266,
0.6410260797,
-0.2538563907,
-0.1955282837,
-0.4712360501,
-0.0213921778,
0.100470759,
-0.1619247794,
0.3227078915,
0.6510046721,
-0.2501805425,
0.1047715917,
-0.5940353274,
-0.0074096126,
0.1296695918,
0.0294811893,
-0.4011826217,
-0.1449447125,
0.0739117935,
0.4144358933,
0.1663687378,
-0.7311227322,
0.0639385357,
-0.3441592455,
0.5098984838,
0.8890324235,
-0.348190695,
0.4409167767,
0.4617056251,
0.5699190497,
0.010444208,
-0.0320766009,
-0.1812194735,
-0.5243878961,
-0.6039031744,
-0.1473760009,
0.4195294678,
0.7411862612,
-0.233554855,
0.5316451788,
0.0718220621,
-0.5779108405,
-0.8077378869,
-0.0746206418,
0.4232192934,
0.7460180521,
0.3549253047,
-0.1529834718,
-0.8864507079,
-0.7526534796,
-0.01290634,
-0.3227229714,
-0.1740341336,
0.0916880369,
0.2467769682,
-0.3617387116,
0.9178831577,
-0.2599267066,
-0.5674908161,
-0.2952777147,
0.7082343102,
-0.0895783529,
0.4610363543,
0.2740344405,
-0.7049908042,
-0.4115508497,
-0.2338565439,
-0.6466183066,
-0.2621465921,
0.163899824,
-0.0444804914,
0.235071376,
0.5184970498,
-0.2146015614,
0.5559133887,
0.8861442804,
-0.1825257093,
0.1055546403,
-0.3866290152,
0.3861935437,
-1.0591316223,
-0.3278767467,
-0.0496150143,
-0.2665858567,
-0.8817320466,
-0.8517379165,
0.0921468362,
-0.2772423327,
-0.5590922236,
0.356901288,
-0.3370614946,
-0.1165493131,
-0.2123495042,
0.0171159934,
-0.1307753474,
0.3659436107,
0.1934038103,
0.5766487718,
0.8161050677,
-0.3817242384,
0.7945256829,
0.3050654531,
-0.2067452371,
0.6408949494,
-0.6775957346,
0.5783154368,
-0.3856010735,
0.4376447201,
-1.1732448339,
-0.2709054053,
-0.0312355254,
-0.7273621559,
0.4547836185,
-0.0285068844,
0.0065125874,
-0.6176633239,
-0.0033370818,
0.2375111282,
0.8977914453,
-0.7390397191,
0.7048706412,
0.4985700548,
-0.2601286769,
-0.3315917253,
-1.2393760681,
-0.1888489723,
0.028717408,
-0.5612796545,
0.0394416489,
-0.103674747,
0.0744131207,
-0.1335546523,
-0.1053470671,
-0.187048912,
-0.2646768689,
0.7436292171,
0.0092562558,
0.0841138214,
0.4633612037,
-0.0991898328,
-0.2850821018,
0.0892450139,
-0.1911851168,
0.5231550932,
-0.1810750216,
-0.3366129696,
-0.8003444672,
0.622890532,
0.0826410875,
-0.2827468514,
0.3267590404,
0.6499449015,
-0.4703166485,
-0.0330031365,
-0.6927491426,
-0.0751564577,
-0.4540905356,
0.5446329713,
-0.3905713558,
-1.0210728645,
0.4585513175,
-0.4598257542,
-0.4564606845,
0.5074919462,
0.7634735107,
-0.6101971865,
1.2259584665,
0.3336503208,
-0.3585800827,
0.5244532824,
-0.1754688919,
0.0181812961,
-0.6088836789,
-0.6354724765,
-0.6967704296,
-0.2369359732,
-0.4986635149,
-0.4667233825,
0.1917318553,
0.0702012554,
-0.2404993922,
0.0787065104,
-0.5799504519,
0.3375896811,
0.4661695659,
-0.327231288,
-0.3441281617,
0.0746356547,
0.079600364,
-0.1344930977,
-0.3047567606,
-0.2404281199,
1.145603776,
0.5247189403,
1.0713503361,
-0.2291181386,
0.9628813267,
0.5544282198,
0.0571979769,
-0.7196996212,
0.261831522,
-0.2647899985,
-0.6169672608,
-0.1559801251,
-0.4519196153,
-0.9376131296,
-0.0331067704,
-0.0746251792,
-0.9479970932,
0.221170634,
0.4916095138,
-0.2349462509,
0.1551867723,
-0.8838447332,
0.997404635,
-0.3113865554,
0.0104158213,
-0.4543186426,
-0.6342204213,
0.0524524041,
0.2521152794,
0.1378563046,
-0.3134860992,
0.2313230336,
0.8921021819,
-0.2406871766,
0.5425165892,
-0.5049023032,
0.0589840971,
0.6189233065,
0.1949974298,
0.5854530334,
-0.2706166208,
0.0161762871,
0.4961205125,
-0.1775963753,
-0.251121521,
-0.6617973447,
0.6900826097,
-0.869941473,
-0.1932304651,
-0.4819568992,
0.1613815576,
-0.4966141284,
-0.328222096,
0.4121934772,
0.440636456,
-0.7320689559,
0.1690802574,
0.7682676911,
0.0883850828,
0.1927188784,
0.3578817248,
-0.0747203454,
-0.4592917264,
0.9263057113,
-0.0576826446,
0.0653991252,
0.401042819,
0.1914831549,
-0.6433156133,
-0.1477110088,
0.1135686189,
-0.009754275,
-0.8147447109,
-0.0941671357,
-0.7182428241,
-0.1576365381,
-0.9512013197,
0.1748729199,
-0.7608121037,
-0.374363929,
-0.7659372091,
-0.4459600151,
0.3882829547,
1.1562663317,
-0.7398264408,
0.3244516551,
-0.653183341,
0.4868502021,
0.8791428804,
0.2771791518,
-0.4886006713,
-0.6801328063,
-0.0738229305,
-0.031591557,
-0.0480128489,
-0.9420337081,
0.4994166791,
0.5422506928,
0.3410114944,
0.7336319089,
-0.0911138132,
0.503962338,
-0.6157999635,
0.9305205345,
0.6369475722,
-1.1721317768,
0.8197733164,
0.1129588857,
0.0834884122,
0.3971895576,
0.7718946338,
-0.6899840832,
0.1784269363,
-0.5110559464,
-0.7784987092,
0.8480536342,
0.2995686531,
0.1924386472,
0.2617122531,
0.3124841154,
-0.0530881137,
0.138436839,
-0.4456596076,
-0.3315109313,
-0.8520035744,
-0.5597512126,
-0.1899079978,
-0.6908875704,
-0.0221843533,
-0.2762320936,
0.4692970216,
-0.0131937489,
0.7483963966,
0.3411241174,
0.1191986352,
-0.0829928368,
0.336488843,
0.3989576697,
-0.1411677003,
-0.3430912793,
0.2640041411,
0.1378382742,
-0.3492617905,
0.314827472,
0.0995274633,
0.5756029487,
-0.1904197037,
0.3453846872,
1.2741146088,
-0.0390672125,
-0.5209664702,
0.6764498353,
-0.2632205188,
-0.3468668163,
-0.5708755851,
-0.133314997,
0.2450719029,
0.2387454808,
0.1550985426,
-0.0384054184,
0.4773916006,
-0.647600472,
0.3013755977,
0.1864300221,
-0.9098973274,
-0.5126212835,
0.7769434452,
0.5021293163,
-0.0617795624,
0.6456357241,
-0.2096677572,
-0.6084015965,
0.4492338002,
0.2919152677,
1.0593744516,
-0.9697744846,
0.3193956316,
0.4130203128,
0.0630954877,
-0.0316986032,
0.4605039656,
-0.2089959383,
-0.4632799923,
-0.0964393765,
-0.4343231022,
-0.3462873101,
-0.1602067202,
-0.7708126903,
-0.084349215,
-0.2588825822,
-0.1692467928,
-0.2831198275,
-0.3224138916,
-0.8656144738,
0.3863220513,
0.9910836816,
0.5463019013,
-0.9074065685,
1.14925313,
0.4708226919,
-0.1664390713,
-0.9562808275,
-0.4129219353,
0.3071031868,
-0.730445087,
0.8151772618,
0.3098765612,
-0.3399368823,
0.0273345914,
-0.6819110513,
-0.7488372326,
1.0117970705,
0.4542379379,
-0.9848575592,
0.153670609,
0.2266310304,
0.7158925533,
-0.6850650311,
0.5689038038,
0.7287182808,
0.365775317,
0.5122929811,
-0.7565983534,
-0.5423330069,
-0.3671900332,
0.1105780676,
-0.3245057166,
-0.46312204,
0.785335362,
-0.2159990668,
-0.301066041,
-0.1098768488,
1.042827487,
-0.1656769365,
0.3283414841,
0.6397345066,
0.6374996901,
0.9318375587,
-0.4276750386,
0.9978832006,
0.0959546193,
0.3733750284,
1.3798424006,
-0.4166499972,
0.8973190188,
0.1493956,
-0.3532196581,
0.4187937081,
0.6809289455,
0.1530849636,
0.7649319768,
0.3606345356,
-0.2283654362,
-0.4646622241,
-0.17785348,
-0.4600351751,
0.655076623,
0.3363345265,
0.0973420441,
0.1509291977,
0.3955599666,
-0.1950156391,
-0.0335583501,
-0.4024594426,
1.0041037798,
0.2289323956,
-0.2490119636,
0.492050916,
-0.55242908,
0.6604341269,
-0.8877103925,
-0.0199134331,
-0.1284009814,
0.010321239,
-0.3194663227,
-0.8252319694,
0.0979771316,
0.1464537531,
-0.0001976445,
-0.2775708437,
0.7371551991,
-0.8190147281,
-0.2589835227,
0.7884216309,
-0.0103998287,
0.4462503195,
-0.6749919057,
-0.645506978,
0.0965470299,
0.0754595697,
-0.5248672366,
0.2049354315,
0.4821766317,
0.5629069209,
0.5730143785,
0.2224896848,
0.1172757819,
0.1363750994,
0.451553762,
0.7584644556,
-0.718403995,
-0.5751748085,
-0.3593399525,
0.756280899,
0.0326408818,
-0.0596656017,
0.1932060272,
0.2251293957,
0.6688206196,
-0.0846332535,
0.8546891809,
0.0239276737,
0.7690069079,
-0.4395943582,
0.543323338,
-0.8434340358,
-0.4606253505,
-0.1228910014,
-0.7552378178,
-0.0326115526,
0.6176000834,
0.0362171605,
0.0608113222,
0.5486022234,
0.6141079664,
0.2622474432,
0.3147654831,
0.5238693953,
0.4429022074,
0.3302626908,
0.5006469488,
0.9642899036,
-0.1905976385,
0.6007962823,
-0.3899435401,
-0.3118151426,
-0.2302138656,
-0.6682684422,
-0.8056838512,
-0.9663968682,
-0.276224345,
-0.2405415326,
-0.0217733085,
1.3453103304,
0.9286575913,
-1.1594884396,
-0.0927743092,
-0.0209918264,
-0.334813267,
0.2573607862,
-0.18055664,
-0.007996521,
-0.2294516861,
-0.7760294676,
0.7291589975,
0.2457281649,
0.2941849828,
-0.3153046072,
-0.3367085159,
0.1516971737,
0.1048777252,
0.5261358023,
0.4519222379,
-0.7246145606,
-0.1533524692,
-0.3851821721,
-0.0787852854,
0.3206776381,
1.0033718348,
-0.6972501874,
0.8371424675,
0.5101891756,
0.2609933913,
0.6512141824,
-0.0713253841,
0.3659979403,
-0.7098277807,
0.516475141,
0.4646306634,
0.411840409,
0.2625859082,
-0.2010626346,
0.3447132111,
0.0390150286,
-0.7526240349,
-0.5498408079,
0.3358928263,
-1.2729593515,
0.0155880004,
0.9214779139,
-0.3829609454,
-0.0942221805,
0.3229297698,
-0.2654040754,
0.5806768537,
-0.7924365401,
0.4157994688,
0.468091011,
-0.3297604024,
-0.1057302654,
-0.3081923723,
0.6180461049,
0.3162083626,
-0.9390133023,
0.2998437583,
0.4988877475,
0.0630408674,
0.0247677192,
0.7236840725,
0.0027015745,
-0.080162026,
-0.0522918738,
0.8633511662,
0.0285245273,
-0.6228743792,
-0.864373982,
0.1697425395,
-0.2118839175,
-0.1742282063
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15181v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15181v1
|
Multilingual Bias Detection and Mitigation for Indian Languages
| 2023-12-23T07:36:20 | 2023-12-23T07:36:20 |
Ankita Maity, Anubhav Sharma, Rudra Dhar, Tushar Abhishek, Manish Gupta, Vasudeva Varma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Lack of diverse perspectives causes neutrality bias in Wikipedia content
leading to millions of worldwide readers getting exposed by potentially
inaccurate information. Hence, neutrality bias detection and mitigation is a
critical problem. Although previous studies have proposed effective solutions
for English, no work exists for Indian languages. First, we contribute two
large datasets, mWikiBias and mWNC, covering 8 languages, for the bias
detection and mitigation tasks respectively. Next, we investigate the
effectiveness of popular multilingual Transformer-based models for the two
tasks by modeling detection as a binary classification problem and mitigation
as a style transfer problem. We make the code and data publicly available.
|
[
-0.7027356625,
-0.5767986178,
0.0602572151,
0.4862481952,
-0.0452221148,
-0.0382527635,
-0.4260916412,
-0.5945846438,
0.1732839346,
0.3107845783,
-0.7030470967,
-0.0837784037,
-0.5795817971,
0.2914857268,
-0.2697191834,
1.1455891132,
-0.0141632287,
0.3560397625,
-0.0845195726,
-0.4827719033,
-0.5274540782,
-0.3021147549,
-0.4957973361,
-0.2766396701,
0.4177346826,
0.8195697069,
0.5023843646,
0.1428015083,
0.3182136416,
0.2429986,
-0.0270555187,
0.1568726152,
-0.3341664672,
0.1662691087,
-0.3461793363,
-0.5058615208,
0.0883035585,
-0.1828176081,
0.7238468528,
0.7017393112,
-0.1156499758,
0.2074713409,
0.0486210287,
0.7641345263,
-0.8812137246,
0.1895581633,
-0.5362808704,
0.0651139244,
-0.5002115965,
0.0618967973,
-0.582074523,
-0.3227683008,
-0.1580628157,
-0.4005892873,
0.3418471515,
-0.0919525251,
0.5495976806,
0.1184119061,
-0.6720690727,
-0.4321082234,
-0.7818975449,
1.0295689106,
-0.4633909762,
0.4575961232,
0.3659297824,
0.0823400393,
0.3105785847,
-0.0842615664,
-0.8259295821,
0.1235443354,
-0.1210441217,
0.1210430861,
-0.1531852931,
-0.3654037714,
0.4401870966,
0.2928242087,
-0.2718291879,
0.1300977021,
-0.5317702889,
-0.5835101008,
0.4889396727,
-0.0083191143,
0.5547519922,
-0.4651671648,
-0.2265352011,
0.0273148641,
-0.5756086111,
-0.0855060816,
0.8396437168,
-0.0011387287,
-0.2914074957,
0.4619511366,
-0.1123613939,
0.6395981908,
0.0100236246,
-0.3929907084,
0.2972866893,
-0.4065103531,
0.2897133529,
0.1723921746,
0.5831887722,
0.5858998299,
0.5732216835,
-0.124168098,
0.0465652794,
0.3315296471,
-0.0741720423,
-0.5604377985,
0.0642597899,
-0.0140800476,
-0.4935301244,
-0.2905335724,
-0.3077113628,
-1.1702504158,
-0.6625537872,
-0.3086995482,
0.1116087213,
-0.2530699074,
-0.7099618912,
-0.313247472,
-0.342912674,
0.4154416323,
0.0123013277,
-1.092150569,
0.0282523334,
0.2670724392,
0.7637277842,
-0.4446333349,
-0.3772336841,
0.0569140539,
0.2813698053,
-0.3976036906,
0.9878979325,
-0.5290390253,
-0.5448447466,
0.1814250052,
-0.0555676855,
0.0536445193,
-0.2563294768,
0.8420248628,
-0.2491072565,
0.2655370831,
-0.580965817,
-0.125034377,
-0.0395460986,
0.3726221025,
-0.7701683044,
0.8060007691,
-0.012780929,
-1.343919158,
0.4851811528,
-0.5541784763,
-0.6951434612,
-0.3263314366,
-0.1974343956,
-0.425654918,
-0.0207725577,
0.4120826125,
0.0065737776,
-0.1644437611,
0.2861222327,
-0.1739750952,
-0.3532776833,
-0.0052300314,
-0.7957641482,
1.136447072,
0.3380061984,
-0.5577507615,
0.0765850693,
-0.7896569371,
-0.3142762184,
-0.0205093864,
-0.2828830183,
-0.5044283867,
0.0840604529,
0.4411397874,
0.4244861603,
-0.0857201889,
-0.7786849737,
0.0849026516,
-0.2699454725,
0.3227283955,
0.9109944701,
-0.0982797965,
0.5875785351,
-0.1225451007,
0.4039564133,
0.3109654486,
0.4136799574,
-0.0916888565,
-0.6186296344,
-1.0137345791,
-0.158503443,
0.2212603986,
0.6329854131,
-0.8793841004,
-0.0609746017,
-0.3966144919,
-0.3199231327,
-0.5410838127,
0.162913397,
0.3736724854,
0.7528558373,
0.306401819,
-0.0411973111,
-0.502836585,
-1.3253468275,
-0.5598304272,
0.2921158373,
0.0855505839,
-0.0347715355,
0.4781024456,
-0.3003823459,
0.838586688,
-0.3670306504,
-0.3835716546,
-0.1259933263,
0.0225566737,
-0.0324030258,
0.4556909204,
0.5818279982,
-1.2314682007,
-0.7935509682,
-0.1906699836,
-0.7511863112,
-0.1678846478,
0.0584239066,
-0.0502561703,
0.4267262816,
0.5672220588,
-0.385271728,
0.4003516138,
0.5346277356,
-0.074513644,
0.5959905982,
0.0909564346,
0.351773411,
-1.2583551407,
0.0361596048,
-0.0635021552,
-0.0218764916,
-0.7242794037,
-0.0135356532,
0.3487725854,
-0.1666833162,
-0.4436999261,
0.5759743452,
-0.5578492284,
0.1515660882,
-0.2166810036,
-0.0399192758,
-0.0539201424,
0.5220017433,
-0.0376995467,
0.8571599126,
0.5535727739,
-0.4959474206,
0.1062329039,
0.2500689328,
-0.2593937814,
0.906455636,
-0.3461668193,
-0.0557902977,
-0.5218666792,
0.1936460733,
-1.0574835539,
-0.0859024078,
0.3402124643,
-0.4933070242,
0.3958677948,
-0.3224140108,
-0.1722083837,
-0.2586571574,
-0.5906668901,
0.3803867102,
0.1360630989,
-0.6399177313,
0.6951907873,
0.5338344574,
-0.138147369,
-1.0608100891,
-1.0845607519,
-0.0682950467,
-0.1669398546,
-0.6167110801,
0.1809610426,
-0.3434271216,
-0.3166802824,
-0.1104534566,
-0.2543809414,
-0.1308441609,
-0.2217745632,
0.2009198219,
0.1772144437,
0.0790044665,
-0.1368001848,
0.1398154944,
-0.2197590321,
0.1315850317,
-0.0514918268,
0.5841565132,
0.1013477072,
-0.5405954719,
-0.2171676457,
0.6806086898,
0.6417525411,
-0.4279791713,
0.8901528716,
0.9863997102,
-0.329313457,
-0.0173555948,
-0.8949428201,
0.0139269447,
-0.4675606191,
0.1976779401,
-0.2799812257,
-0.6003850102,
0.7980433702,
0.1858340651,
-0.0200051554,
0.6717463732,
0.7105717063,
0.2670027316,
1.2647141218,
0.7887524366,
-0.5073702931,
0.5478026867,
-0.0154641364,
0.4370599389,
-0.665371418,
-0.417181462,
-0.8993698955,
-0.1122277007,
-0.9793454409,
-0.0076788799,
0.4323679209,
-0.08740969,
0.0884506032,
-0.0435429439,
-0.6685032248,
0.6774246693,
0.5833698511,
0.1889198571,
0.3792816699,
0.2301222086,
-0.2526901662,
-0.3365292549,
-0.4673960507,
-0.111971274,
1.1556657553,
-0.1129204184,
0.7485567927,
0.3804199398,
0.3739928305,
0.4013053775,
0.4566039145,
-0.6124274731,
-0.0178505071,
0.1053316966,
-1.1121065617,
-0.216746822,
-0.3129977286,
-0.5419173241,
0.2861103714,
-0.1638126075,
-0.4216667414,
0.5132236481,
0.0452163182,
0.3590203226,
0.4173465371,
-1.1301412582,
0.6852716804,
0.1366494894,
-0.5298850536,
-0.2923642993,
-0.6277095079,
0.6630374193,
-0.1960348636,
0.755489707,
-0.1008300632,
0.2275372148,
0.7273325324,
-0.1344977319,
0.7150713801,
-0.2158840597,
-0.0479967594,
0.0469211526,
-0.0696127564,
0.2504994869,
0.1952617466,
-0.178767994,
0.4145642221,
-0.2517348528,
-0.8000666499,
-0.0608357824,
0.9811741114,
-0.6218824983,
-0.3725784123,
-0.5331497788,
-0.6749506593,
-0.4917465448,
0.4955720901,
0.549484849,
0.3080760837,
0.0313402079,
0.0261948667,
0.704759717,
-0.1333101988,
0.8082426786,
0.6201109886,
-0.0330047421,
-0.1952803731,
0.7364501953,
0.1908794641,
0.1326368451,
0.0371585004,
0.1279530823,
-0.2606659532,
-0.4469513297,
-0.5870627165,
0.0524558723,
-0.9918006063,
-0.1455044448,
-0.4641131759,
-0.0221839584,
-0.4396369457,
0.0371117182,
-0.1674590856,
-0.3448573351,
0.2562381923,
-0.0134105748,
0.2378169298,
0.8196943998,
-0.2867789567,
0.1399074793,
-0.5146791935,
0.5215176344,
0.198714152,
0.5852444768,
0.0963222086,
-0.359877497,
-0.2049514204,
0.0642633513,
-0.2479806244,
-0.8199920654,
0.2018819153,
0.0128609836,
0.6507143378,
0.4227458239,
-0.0651215836,
0.3863191307,
-0.7315211892,
0.6783345938,
0.2963907123,
-1.0077958107,
0.5882105827,
-0.2794442773,
0.236209482,
0.5258259773,
0.794046104,
-0.6407456398,
-0.2686411738,
-0.2015553117,
-0.6611073613,
0.7462297678,
0.1137959883,
0.394864887,
-0.1150852144,
-0.0341637656,
0.1490410417,
0.0845172033,
-0.7459548116,
-0.5784137845,
-0.2951274216,
-0.0769291669,
-0.1572743803,
-0.467331022,
-0.0693350434,
-0.3812566102,
0.5818842053,
0.0268899929,
0.069752641,
0.312746942,
-0.538110435,
-0.0886138082,
0.3984158039,
0.8588539958,
0.8356770873,
0.2022644132,
-0.0410733968,
0.1323800832,
-0.8411684036,
0.0447415076,
0.0353867076,
-0.5249280334,
0.243200779,
0.3269633651,
0.546508193,
0.0624585003,
-0.3510812819,
0.5479531884,
-0.0982324779,
0.0888648629,
-0.3499868512,
-0.2173688561,
0.1254873425,
-0.1629796177,
0.478792727,
0.4609234631,
0.2713932395,
-0.435669452,
-0.0122237485,
0.5390952229,
-0.3500387669,
-0.1059739888,
0.6539395452,
0.2583864331,
-0.0977430418,
0.5786061883,
0.0474446565,
-0.7872573733,
0.5369536281,
0.5098606944,
0.2940350175,
-0.6075909138,
-0.0145748993,
0.3148726523,
0.5675449371,
0.0091265813,
0.2459740043,
-0.0084855976,
-0.8640062809,
-0.5089552999,
-0.4883065522,
-0.3657281101,
-0.1540744901,
-0.6928565502,
0.4247734547,
-0.1856533289,
-0.0023985389,
0.288241297,
-0.1899032593,
-0.7050543427,
-0.0239074621,
0.1799260825,
0.861397028,
-1.1378046274,
0.8317680359,
0.3063168228,
-0.8127563596,
-0.5574012995,
0.0042025745,
0.1596820801,
-0.6558753848,
0.4519515038,
0.2045300305,
-0.1544679552,
-0.1560455412,
-0.3936284184,
-0.6146324873,
0.608690083,
0.5386906862,
-0.4286101162,
0.1399501115,
0.1548621953,
0.2965296209,
0.1191837788,
0.3201227486,
0.4895017445,
0.8053215742,
-0.4655900002,
-0.93145895,
-0.3439998329,
-0.3227552772,
-0.2024187446,
0.3377486765,
-0.7532418966,
0.8297359943,
0.1801056415,
0.192346856,
-0.5321851969,
0.2241301537,
-0.2046292424,
0.2088341117,
0.4126000404,
0.5155561566,
0.6432124376,
-0.1214254647,
1.094615221,
-0.3544402719,
0.3576196134,
0.6947931647,
-0.2120703906,
0.480320245,
0.6670737267,
-0.1249185055,
0.574423492,
0.3826786876,
0.1721603423,
0.477676183,
-0.0363637805,
-0.3745009005,
0.0583991557,
-0.5067722201,
-0.5974367261,
0.5446211696,
0.3906539679,
-0.1040578261,
-0.2764732242,
0.4258439541,
0.3563420773,
0.1590592116,
-0.5278679132,
0.4907588065,
-0.3003977835,
-0.6792852283,
0.4591886699,
0.1150149629,
1.2791858912,
-0.5191916823,
-0.0141720455,
-0.6674116254,
0.3028627038,
-0.4959195554,
-0.6450100541,
0.5879279375,
0.0423516035,
-0.6043562889,
-0.1497308761,
1.0214352608,
-0.5270146132,
-0.6151404977,
0.3829159737,
0.3793946505,
-0.1152356714,
-0.0321754925,
-0.48427701,
0.2318325639,
0.1151858568,
0.0096206013,
0.3378048539,
0.1325913817,
-0.4139266312,
0.5979622006,
0.6520638466,
-0.061440412,
0.3874969482,
0.3028457463,
0.8134561777,
-0.2632038295,
-0.4687837958,
-0.8604624867,
0.350009203,
-0.4860838354,
-0.021515321,
1.1694864035,
0.6565769911,
1.0536249876,
-0.3479351997,
0.9012907147,
-0.0652476475,
0.5088586807,
-0.3251540065,
1.0446330309,
-0.4043268859,
-0.0196604468,
-0.3046368361,
-0.9276039004,
-0.3552097976,
0.436062485,
-0.0751713067,
0.1173862889,
0.6334786415,
0.7580607533,
-0.3256682456,
0.0959463567,
0.0589931458,
0.057183899,
0.1053061038,
0.2712550461,
0.7166662216,
-0.3572560847,
0.7812597156,
-0.5268033147,
-0.279624939,
-0.0026597541,
-0.8819602728,
-0.8759453297,
-0.539953649,
-0.0133315297,
-0.3586400747,
-0.0678308308,
0.4332356155,
0.7938921452,
-1.2600579262,
0.0306021422,
0.1318763047,
0.5944674611,
0.0931748152,
-0.2400670648,
0.3834824562,
-0.2052553296,
-0.8667827845,
0.0591355525,
0.08248128,
-0.4323034585,
-0.4727477133,
0.0481542684,
-0.4363107979,
-0.0503136814,
0.6093586087,
0.198013559,
-0.572576046,
-0.2385572195,
-0.0773872137,
-0.096695289,
0.1433321238,
0.9637254477,
-0.3237919211,
0.6126151085,
0.5385291576,
0.5609596968,
0.4216961563,
-0.3371026814,
0.2001676261,
-1.001989603,
0.6235516071,
-0.0412473194,
0.3857870698,
0.5921080112,
-0.3060956597,
0.4819050133,
0.4198787212,
-0.3487793207,
-0.702870667,
0.1668540984,
-0.5803892016,
-0.3169582784,
1.0101419687,
0.2653214335,
-0.1061491966,
-0.4006301165,
-0.3605200946,
0.3547484577,
-0.1561954468,
0.6778248549,
1.22910285,
0.0519818924,
-0.0377785675,
-0.7430856228,
0.5129696727,
0.4048051238,
-0.6223522425,
-0.1849533767,
0.5409843922,
0.6536170244,
0.4496892095,
0.6685167551,
-0.13173002,
0.2734986842,
0.0148386536,
0.1612690985,
0.1461737007,
-0.3241192997,
-0.4565376937,
-0.0538634546,
0.0019038124,
-0.0612702407
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15166v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15166v3
|
SOLAR 10.7B: Scaling Large Language Models with Simple yet Effective Depth Up-Scaling
| 2023-12-23T05:11:37 | 2024-04-04T01:53:38 |
Dahyun Kim, Chanjun Park, Sanghoon Kim, Wonsung Lee, Wonho Song, Yunsu Kim, Hyeonwoo Kim, Yungi Kim, Hyeonju Lee, Jihoo Kim, Changbae Ahn, Seonghoon Yang, Sukyung Lee, Hyunbyung Park, Gyoungjin Gim, Mikyoung Cha, Hwalsuk Lee, Sunghun Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We introduce SOLAR 10.7B, a large language model (LLM) with 10.7 billion
parameters, demonstrating superior performance in various natural language
processing (NLP) tasks. Inspired by recent efforts to efficiently up-scale
LLMs, we present a method for scaling LLMs called depth up-scaling (DUS), which
encompasses depthwise scaling and continued pretraining. In contrast to other
LLM up-scaling methods that use mixture-of-experts, DUS does not require
complex changes to train and inference efficiently. We show experimentally that
DUS is simple yet effective in scaling up high-performance LLMs from small
ones. Building on the DUS model, we additionally present SOLAR 10.7B-Instruct,
a variant fine-tuned for instruction-following capabilities, surpassing
Mixtral-8x7B-Instruct. SOLAR 10.7B is publicly available under the Apache 2.0
license, promoting broad access and application in the LLM field.
|
[
-0.3596185148,
-0.4556725919,
0.5547195077,
0.6698660851,
-0.1458381265,
0.1798741221,
-0.5788611174,
-0.4060243964,
0.0417592861,
0.9069997668,
-0.293367058,
-0.484254092,
-0.7628682256,
-0.0474740975,
-0.5564982295,
0.5802397728,
0.2680533826,
0.1010091603,
-0.2854121923,
0.1599824578,
-0.3018523157,
0.0306875091,
-0.9146533608,
-0.2159428746,
0.6600242853,
0.738697648,
0.7719462514,
0.7485640049,
0.7441611886,
0.4095142782,
-0.4640414715,
0.04967314,
-0.4302540123,
0.1976356953,
-0.2639797926,
-0.2876748741,
-0.6133409739,
-0.2165436,
1.0006994009,
1.1195331812,
-0.2974573076,
0.4068223834,
-0.2808692455,
1.0459681749,
-0.5704379082,
0.1091307625,
-0.6036245823,
-0.3710962832,
-0.1477662623,
0.060766805,
-0.5439350605,
-0.1660158783,
0.0048602722,
-0.4564033151,
0.144540146,
0.3112160563,
0.188730225,
0.3088881373,
-0.3451524079,
0.070262216,
-0.8909156322,
0.7873552442,
-0.8722269535,
0.3547253907,
0.1112861782,
0.3187546134,
-0.1524928361,
-0.8694336414,
-0.4992547929,
-0.3221030235,
0.0871441662,
-0.2659706175,
0.1901281476,
0.2743993402,
0.3835483789,
0.7741184831,
-0.2295659781,
0.327924341,
-0.4620639682,
0.0642196536,
0.6546429396,
0.139284119,
0.3100237548,
-0.0956505984,
-0.164647758,
-0.2911406755,
-0.9770530462,
0.0327511951,
0.1572352201,
0.5154799223,
-0.0736170784,
0.6658539772,
-0.2147788554,
0.7937033772,
-0.0100329043,
0.0511964969,
-0.1068117544,
-0.5212360024,
-0.3197444975,
0.1738164425,
0.3824243546,
0.1950282902,
-0.0973349586,
0.0096307015,
-0.0528607853,
-0.2065705508,
0.3648567498,
-1.0309907198,
-0.30571872,
0.0101592522,
-0.1575633436,
-0.3421015441,
-0.0821556598,
-0.6481664777,
-0.7846958637,
-0.3573265374,
0.2892737985,
-0.1757972986,
-0.2627995014,
0.4241368771,
0.1047996581,
0.2302005887,
0.6013877392,
-1.1546632051,
0.721406877,
0.7417148948,
0.7443832755,
-0.027445687,
-0.318441093,
-0.5526708961,
0.0480310097,
-0.3266720176,
0.5976543427,
-0.6653118134,
-0.2515252233,
-0.4748230278,
-0.1585804522,
-0.1124474481,
-0.5010253787,
0.1409173459,
-0.6038407087,
0.4139915109,
-0.1860232353,
-0.604444623,
-0.0389280096,
0.0252400059,
-0.6835625172,
1.1593604088,
0.3428889811,
-0.6139505506,
0.1166123673,
-0.6106963158,
-0.3732312918,
0.0133005716,
0.1693209857,
-0.2374638021,
0.3367909193,
0.1640620083,
0.2778033316,
-0.5704007745,
-0.0187515616,
-0.3519391716,
-0.2437025011,
-0.2682981789,
-0.2150665075,
0.7309786677,
0.1067408547,
-0.1977112293,
0.4623936415,
-0.9106561542,
0.0740600377,
-0.1005015448,
-0.5148006082,
-0.4402011633,
-0.1998203397,
-0.2481927276,
-0.0602865219,
0.4248152673,
-0.7124783397,
0.2235902101,
-0.759740591,
0.2172733396,
0.6517067552,
-0.4467664063,
0.9550783038,
0.2295595258,
0.4649162591,
-0.2847115993,
0.0891800076,
-0.3611249626,
-0.2939594686,
-0.6520237327,
-0.4159412682,
0.4480891228,
0.3472270072,
-0.2661983967,
0.5148549676,
-0.2015780509,
-0.8145183325,
-0.4285603762,
0.5351854563,
0.4344647527,
0.5628035665,
0.4899940789,
-0.3511528373,
-0.4211756289,
-0.6041966081,
-0.2398921549,
0.049681019,
-0.0949904993,
0.4054010808,
0.1442549229,
-0.0378378332,
0.5276063681,
-0.5324506164,
-0.0868879259,
-0.5967177153,
-0.0481598228,
0.1503983736,
0.3197725415,
0.3282657564,
-0.6633730531,
-0.6266444921,
0.2146290094,
-0.4014849067,
-0.1734933108,
0.0657032579,
-0.1171407029,
0.1795975119,
0.7953930497,
-0.6487764716,
0.1280050576,
0.8047338724,
-0.641040504,
0.423925817,
-0.6877824664,
-0.1369328946,
-1.2135150433,
-0.1004072502,
-0.0215838682,
-0.2626608908,
-0.5379020572,
0.3407847881,
0.4841061831,
0.0282227378,
-0.6482459903,
0.6547044516,
-0.7161757946,
-0.5250583291,
-0.467338711,
0.0167755149,
0.1306503862,
0.070277229,
-0.2265966535,
0.6243651509,
0.9272677898,
-0.6869910955,
0.8537840247,
-0.075601697,
-0.5766792893,
0.2275537401,
-0.6262466311,
0.0038986157,
0.1038767323,
0.3063960075,
-0.7490723729,
-0.2813562155,
-0.1990721226,
0.0842357129,
0.5036463737,
0.0323979035,
-0.4865186512,
-0.5337975025,
-0.3802287579,
0.3739157319,
0.5083036423,
-0.7232817411,
0.896153748,
0.1990919709,
-0.5014609694,
-0.4651509821,
-0.3269669116,
0.2794406414,
-0.1660732776,
-0.8727117181,
0.4729226828,
0.0200037733,
-0.3851720989,
-0.1482724249,
-0.1730964184,
0.2787131965,
0.1780635267,
0.1270451397,
0.124514021,
-0.4969773591,
-0.1350070387,
0.1698708981,
0.0234714206,
0.0896836668,
-0.2337554395,
0.7256374955,
-0.3073222935,
-0.1877475977,
-0.2241970152,
0.0641507208,
0.5616652966,
-0.1715750545,
0.7173458338,
0.1941263378,
-0.1093760729,
-0.2883312106,
-0.4126744568,
-0.1271160692,
-0.5506052971,
0.4453773201,
-0.1244402528,
-0.7865724564,
0.571965158,
-0.4827158749,
0.1223592609,
0.4431864321,
0.5063441396,
-0.0460239388,
0.8311235309,
0.9310324788,
-0.0305895004,
0.6107878089,
-0.2433845401,
-0.1018528417,
-0.9979670048,
-0.2715860903,
-0.5331625938,
-0.4855566919,
-0.3167176843,
-0.6195687056,
0.012402189,
0.0744109005,
-0.3614681065,
0.4589938521,
-0.3692627549,
1.0301122665,
0.6659985185,
-0.0454464853,
0.4356142282,
-0.1311928034,
0.2618120909,
0.3430635929,
-0.5038623214,
-0.2509344518,
1.0560022593,
0.3119259775,
1.0873075724,
0.1812797636,
0.5628263354,
0.0621502027,
0.3312907815,
-0.4947660267,
0.7967690825,
-0.5300752521,
-0.5018442869,
-0.9421719313,
-0.5783430338,
-0.886344552,
0.3854483664,
0.0328364745,
-0.5085800886,
-0.0602763146,
0.1245735735,
-0.4763911366,
0.5494027138,
-0.9706202149,
0.9403600693,
-0.3424773216,
-0.0438227952,
-0.6347205639,
-0.6617763638,
0.27346313,
-0.1428197026,
0.197220549,
-0.0628028736,
-0.1576426327,
0.3851130009,
-0.3263987899,
0.8627772927,
-0.2116976529,
-0.365458101,
0.0532332212,
0.1607894897,
0.4829978049,
0.0346809253,
-0.0203676522,
-0.1320747882,
-0.2239185423,
-0.5273243189,
-0.7622910142,
1.1125389338,
-0.826181829,
-0.8605085611,
-0.1449348927,
-0.6504335403,
-0.0717961267,
0.2845076919,
-0.1042851284,
0.3664538264,
-0.1806346625,
0.5566859245,
0.8507390618,
-0.4123990834,
0.5200519562,
0.4921435714,
-0.6162261367,
-0.3090267777,
0.8632169366,
-0.0098313252,
0.5917916298,
0.4772732854,
0.4045337439,
-0.3652329445,
-0.7549801469,
-0.6896439195,
0.1668743938,
-0.4181568623,
-0.1359521449,
-0.5167459249,
-0.1999877393,
-0.64193964,
-0.1887203604,
-0.8761763573,
-0.722117722,
-0.1817766428,
-0.1865266711,
0.4057094157,
0.8432721496,
0.0099895792,
0.563814044,
-0.4981612861,
0.408490032,
0.2946122289,
0.6224190593,
-0.1344046593,
-0.9904590249,
-0.3607384562,
-0.2028152496,
-0.2398013622,
-0.3830120265,
0.3764514029,
0.4424366653,
0.18253313,
0.2452809513,
-0.1089292988,
0.4357553124,
-0.3755715191,
0.678354919,
0.3604629934,
-0.8856179118,
0.6156777143,
-0.2494250387,
0.4912729263,
0.4102121294,
0.0758210272,
-0.4587377906,
-0.5625377297,
-0.6974949241,
-1.1463534832,
0.9508518577,
-0.0564359054,
0.4976687729,
0.2790851295,
0.3818594515,
0.2731022537,
0.0664132833,
-0.4027971029,
-0.2722886801,
-0.1574260741,
-0.0655236021,
-0.4964433908,
-0.2886427343,
0.0394729935,
-0.4560566545,
0.5664050579,
0.0174145643,
-0.3061240315,
-0.1407412291,
-0.1683906019,
-0.090389125,
0.2830742896,
0.6449494362,
0.6509273052,
-0.4427530468,
0.359210521,
0.2784320116,
-0.5648135543,
0.0059561236,
0.2028912157,
-0.2043002695,
-0.4061872363,
0.1862537265,
0.8821393251,
0.6213420033,
-0.4422748983,
0.2431176305,
-0.0514584221,
-0.096829392,
-0.1659306884,
0.4744444191,
0.4765162766,
0.2723054588,
0.1183808148,
0.2006628364,
-0.1558130682,
-0.4984053969,
-0.0301659834,
0.2585805357,
-0.1584177166,
-0.3696901798,
0.6037403941,
0.5149005055,
-0.1895097494,
0.4905892313,
-0.0245970525,
0.0272365008,
0.6659852266,
0.4931879044,
0.6903889775,
-0.2253815979,
0.3739420176,
0.3277618885,
0.3121504188,
-0.533678472,
0.291585952,
-0.0716058686,
-0.7172502875,
-0.855548501,
-0.6694353819,
-0.8195248246,
-0.1076728776,
-0.499058038,
0.1540667564,
-0.8560107946,
0.1755861193,
0.1215310991,
0.3141305149,
-0.47648862,
0.2173398733,
0.3409779966,
1.1837558746,
-0.4928406775,
0.9685291052,
0.7605906129,
-0.0986250266,
-0.7573362589,
-0.5334373116,
-0.2015315592,
-0.7344526649,
0.6245384812,
0.1066856384,
-0.2656832039,
0.3861576915,
-0.5802034736,
-1.0877689123,
1.1903918982,
0.7092877626,
-0.6445666552,
-0.045770172,
0.1588224471,
0.5839198828,
-0.5904316306,
0.1834172755,
0.6230164766,
0.5510456562,
0.2124049515,
-0.8820150495,
0.1474609077,
-0.0257732999,
0.0534946769,
0.2602450848,
-0.5877385736,
0.6853489876,
-0.6766628623,
-0.0973526016,
0.1060099974,
0.9618520141,
0.2150266171,
0.4002150595,
0.6183212996,
0.6572476029,
1.0371009111,
0.0679022893,
1.3170129061,
-0.2644154727,
0.048700843,
1.2157833576,
-0.3667977154,
0.7894584537,
0.3798297048,
-0.174683556,
0.6449791193,
0.4880373478,
0.1367958486,
0.3174494505,
0.2812918127,
-0.3271422088,
-0.3969277442,
0.0734140277,
-0.4301392436,
0.2659806907,
0.1403547525,
-0.3623267412,
-0.223157838,
-0.1238286048,
-0.3067090809,
0.2439604253,
-0.7104213238,
0.7201201916,
0.1908200979,
-0.4786300063,
0.2322593927,
0.123840861,
0.7082591653,
-0.5485055447,
0.3928916752,
-0.4337939024,
0.3511545062,
-0.1594525278,
-0.8401215076,
0.1291434765,
0.0372153781,
-0.3336358666,
-0.4359956682,
0.8359171152,
-0.3900897801,
-0.8311643004,
0.3799074292,
0.3065066934,
0.1189853773,
-0.4417506754,
-0.3642526865,
-0.0845651031,
-0.0430084094,
-0.7065398097,
0.6251601577,
0.6109439731,
0.0380282626,
0.9206742048,
0.5985649824,
0.6429323554,
0.3888451755,
0.5124689341,
0.9077367187,
-1.0318582058,
-0.1437926739,
-0.7243366838,
0.334733218,
-0.2700357139,
-0.2305163145,
0.7763904333,
0.6358883381,
1.0828858614,
-0.0669427365,
0.2905370891,
0.0667690337,
0.5237141252,
-0.4327794611,
0.3685572147,
-0.4196898341,
0.5892965198,
0.0158842988,
-1.2819135189,
-0.4966860712,
0.113489002,
-0.4498063624,
0.011649007,
0.5607300401,
0.836389482,
-0.0462252758,
0.0780305341,
0.4665034413,
0.3264014125,
0.1935071051,
0.1360716522,
0.7227141261,
-0.0575441793,
0.5810726285,
-0.333735913,
-0.2771443129,
-0.0271658804,
-0.8666709065,
-0.7554466724,
-0.0941444933,
-0.2932698727,
-0.0683599561,
-0.31882146,
0.8558456898,
0.572422266,
-0.6745799184,
-0.295055002,
-0.3387753665,
0.2443396449,
-0.2530828118,
-0.1231615394,
0.2568461299,
-0.4692702889,
-0.7351077199,
0.6305708885,
0.4569671154,
-0.1131962985,
-0.5764589906,
-0.3564962149,
0.1597763896,
0.2083885372,
0.8279376626,
0.4266142249,
-0.5653399825,
-0.1221101955,
0.0206935946,
-0.2098608315,
-0.153219074,
0.780181706,
-0.6316019893,
0.3147723079,
0.5695599318,
0.6697567701,
0.5893612504,
-0.0341017954,
0.6465052962,
-0.7296475172,
-0.058713302,
-0.0096150478,
0.3267869651,
0.6776966453,
-0.2534715533,
0.3944736719,
-0.0053772596,
-0.5340789557,
-0.9181936383,
0.202731818,
-1.1432917118,
-0.3743612468,
1.3070551157,
0.1372627467,
-0.2923267484,
0.2791982889,
-0.3476996124,
-0.0529415794,
-0.2900771499,
0.8797578812,
0.5076195598,
0.0291305911,
-0.4482528865,
-0.1022466198,
0.4053754508,
0.5328771472,
-0.7631610036,
0.6563198566,
0.33086285,
0.0885982439,
0.099069111,
0.6041339636,
-0.1165380925,
0.0987589359,
0.011083289,
0.1818241477,
-0.3088752925,
-0.6060116291,
-0.2142169327,
0.1663518697,
0.1214826405,
0.2339122295
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15159v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15159v2
|
Understanding the Potential of FPGA-Based Spatial Acceleration for Large Language Model Inference
| 2023-12-23T04:27:06 | 2024-04-07T06:03:02 |
Hongzheng Chen, Jiahao Zhang, Yixiao Du, Shaojie Xiang, Zichao Yue, Niansong Zhang, Yaohui Cai, Zhiru Zhang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.AR, cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) boasting billions of
parameters have generated a significant demand for efficient deployment in
inference workloads. The majority of existing approaches rely on temporal
architectures that reuse hardware units for different network layers and
operators. However, these methods often encounter challenges in achieving low
latency due to considerable memory access overhead. This paper investigates the
feasibility and potential of model-specific spatial acceleration for LLM
inference on FPGAs. Our approach involves the specialization of distinct
hardware units for specific operators or layers, facilitating direct
communication between them through a dataflow architecture while minimizing
off-chip memory accesses. We introduce a comprehensive analytical model for
estimating the performance of a spatial LLM accelerator, taking into account
the on-chip compute and memory resources available on an FPGA. Through our
analysis, we can determine the scenarios in which FPGA-based spatial
acceleration can outperform its GPU-based counterpart. To enable more
productive implementations of an LLM model on FPGAs, we further provide a
library of high-level synthesis (HLS) kernels that are composable and reusable.
This library will be made available as open-source. To validate the
effectiveness of both our analytical model and HLS library, we have implemented
BERT and GPT2 on an AMD Alveo U280 FPGA device. Experimental results
demonstrate our approach can achieve up to 13.4x speedup when compared to
previous FPGA-based accelerators for the BERT model. For GPT generative
inference, we attain a 2.2x speedup compared to DFX, an FPGA overlay, in the
prefill stage, while achieving a 1.9x speedup and a 5.7x improvement in energy
efficiency compared to the NVIDIA A100 GPU in the decode stage.
|
[
-0.2235304266,
-1.3350746632,
1.0859174728,
0.5732486844,
-0.1519648135,
-0.1515374333,
-0.0699318126,
-0.6266118288,
-0.0880617127,
0.2395181507,
-0.2968712747,
-0.4090679884,
-0.5831902623,
-0.3830735087,
-0.3045990169,
0.2037280351,
-0.1334861517,
-0.1652258188,
-0.020298833,
0.0656302571,
-0.3794026971,
-0.4252074957,
-0.5234057307,
-0.4184689224,
0.3665764332,
-0.1135657057,
0.8619648218,
0.6176612377,
0.3527888656,
0.4212993979,
-0.1419525892,
-0.0938851535,
-0.2922876179,
-0.1445545703,
0.0724170282,
-0.2953579128,
-0.6226459146,
-0.2556684613,
0.7565561533,
0.5585223436,
-0.3469801247,
-0.2132914364,
-0.2852502763,
0.46498698,
-0.5431713462,
0.1922688782,
-0.6773509979,
0.2938055396,
-0.3062065244,
0.0023241178,
-0.3151891232,
-0.3918441534,
0.2543128431,
-0.8911236525,
0.1109399647,
0.0443414897,
0.6196478605,
0.2416145951,
-0.0176226236,
0.1018710583,
-0.9381536245,
0.81812644,
-0.8387355208,
0.6047067046,
-0.1342161447,
0.4520785809,
-0.2560326457,
-0.6417549849,
-0.448449254,
0.0170167554,
-0.0159131438,
-0.0423441976,
-0.5145921111,
0.1438603848,
0.5491685867,
0.2148953676,
-0.6688613892,
0.3299606442,
-0.1944090277,
0.1219885498,
0.3734911382,
0.1476631612,
0.1766152829,
-0.0039703688,
-0.4665203094,
0.0870052204,
-0.9632374048,
-0.1135848835,
0.1539153159,
0.3277275264,
-0.322684288,
0.3273667395,
-0.0339390822,
0.6155034304,
-0.2369033247,
0.0778669417,
0.36524266,
-0.1305041909,
-0.4526204169,
-0.1772470772,
0.6414487362,
-0.1283543855,
-0.0675090849,
-0.2661623061,
-0.3171361983,
-0.0337210633,
0.1385049373,
-1.0366809368,
-0.2995581627,
0.359584868,
-0.4020805359,
0.1781273037,
-0.2893165052,
-1.1793180704,
-0.1818738729,
-0.1445345879,
0.2877958417,
-0.1393809766,
-0.0838542953,
0.2708973289,
0.0320688263,
0.3677274585,
0.3443529904,
-1.0293774605,
0.1203644723,
0.8729716539,
0.8200791478,
-0.1377611458,
-0.2161620855,
-0.5423511863,
-0.0346996039,
-0.3314721286,
0.7339416742,
-0.79331249,
-0.331649065,
-0.0094203055,
-0.0037658338,
-0.0214101952,
-0.4313421845,
0.6097975373,
-0.7771451473,
-0.2694429159,
-0.134767428,
-0.3679069281,
-0.0627388433,
-0.2440736741,
-0.4826848507,
1.1930701733,
0.0697144493,
-0.2798871398,
0.2971663773,
-0.6635945439,
-0.5032947063,
0.027278332,
-0.267354846,
-0.4218331873,
0.4596847296,
0.4244798124,
0.2852385044,
-0.397706449,
0.4826618731,
-0.5081435442,
-0.6745406389,
-0.0126710208,
-0.4177451134,
0.4865571856,
0.3669157326,
-0.35378775,
0.1806128621,
-0.5707714558,
-0.0835945979,
0.1868258417,
-0.4701927602,
-0.23768951,
0.3853330314,
-0.3509477377,
-0.0302230157,
0.2753557861,
-0.8453143239,
0.1070864946,
-0.4399269819,
0.4904557467,
0.7495924234,
-0.2802875638,
0.4459817708,
0.2532267272,
0.5167636275,
-0.2544464171,
0.1860964149,
-0.0992850214,
-0.7940137982,
-0.1595854163,
-0.4253255129,
-0.0303124562,
0.6413863301,
-0.9299125075,
0.3345884681,
-0.3229583502,
-0.4488920271,
-0.4163504839,
-0.0172285996,
0.4010222256,
0.4528721869,
0.3543184996,
0.163478449,
-0.3576807082,
-0.7037599683,
-0.0758610368,
-0.0962918773,
-0.3516303897,
0.6194145679,
0.2064276785,
-0.0798763111,
0.4254585207,
-0.654718399,
0.2976687849,
-0.100747481,
0.1286508441,
0.455958873,
0.3838312626,
0.8590124249,
-0.3720855415,
-0.1145651862,
0.3100046813,
-0.7880058885,
-0.4614268839,
0.2191581875,
-0.3100724816,
0.1662410349,
0.4295250475,
-0.6276859045,
0.4773522019,
0.7572622895,
-0.2699837387,
0.3672838509,
-0.5966237783,
0.1817835271,
-0.4474850595,
0.0415669493,
0.0640000775,
0.1922032982,
-0.5844656825,
0.1278305501,
-0.1902648211,
-0.2692153454,
-0.3220528066,
0.6227322817,
-0.0797113106,
-0.6965969801,
-0.3262295127,
0.3346180618,
-0.010296586,
0.5504424572,
0.3344427645,
1.0399985313,
0.5989343524,
-0.4509831965,
0.0965017155,
0.0305416044,
-0.3708117902,
-0.0235900078,
-0.9174435735,
0.065977104,
-0.019119978,
0.0195472464,
-0.9969174862,
0.1772125661,
0.0199912004,
-0.1704686135,
-0.0738168806,
-0.1167209074,
-0.4835496545,
-0.3818021119,
-0.0042842664,
0.4642600119,
0.6630271673,
-0.8872748613,
0.8947446942,
0.344725728,
-0.1670647115,
-0.4031879306,
-0.7919400334,
-0.2000718117,
-0.0571876913,
-0.965641439,
0.4617278576,
-0.008740901,
-0.27662763,
-0.1110240966,
0.3098414838,
-0.1053583324,
0.2952027321,
0.2091497779,
0.3287492096,
-0.6429499984,
-0.0517628901,
0.3217442036,
-0.0610682778,
0.1678727567,
-0.5193604827,
0.4089185894,
-0.1332656741,
-0.4124834239,
-0.4569577873,
0.2236890495,
0.3910838068,
-0.0480393209,
0.6020420194,
0.6574727297,
-0.3678880036,
-0.1826464236,
-0.213412717,
-0.0952690393,
-0.4867779911,
0.4651863277,
-0.3115680218,
-0.750050962,
0.5366125703,
-0.0237483513,
0.3029944599,
0.2744807899,
0.6155862808,
0.0575020686,
0.903768301,
0.1265492588,
-0.1429401487,
0.6105180383,
0.0021258984,
0.4792915881,
-0.608277142,
0.0673657581,
-0.6269400716,
-0.53182441,
-0.5545107126,
-0.912476182,
0.2906025052,
-0.2616897821,
-0.2059300691,
-0.0464737229,
-0.2238852978,
0.4467009306,
0.3127026856,
-0.0873407871,
0.0852358714,
0.5153038502,
-0.0942896605,
-0.1761534959,
-0.7076248527,
-0.2360635996,
0.65846771,
0.551023066,
0.7784540057,
0.0889971852,
0.0611480586,
0.3322663009,
0.4280007184,
-0.4139793515,
0.5927441716,
-0.5771079063,
-0.3923961222,
-0.2523497939,
-0.3980932832,
-0.696818471,
0.5547397137,
-0.1451105028,
-0.8151962757,
0.0892197043,
0.2275647372,
-0.5275464654,
0.5291564465,
-0.776426971,
0.7416433096,
-0.2849790156,
-0.7443932891,
-0.2900542021,
-0.1235104054,
0.2221566588,
-0.1284636855,
-0.0148658268,
-0.1468351334,
0.2464697957,
0.2920823097,
-0.364915967,
0.5723287463,
-0.8306446075,
-0.3083905578,
0.3289884329,
-0.1527513266,
0.5204201937,
-0.0779757574,
-0.3477894068,
0.5257106423,
-0.3970927596,
-0.4130046964,
-0.7225161195,
0.9515910745,
-0.7505698204,
-0.4659105837,
0.1289666891,
-0.5985394716,
-0.224397555,
0.0080780787,
-0.3865507543,
0.4536192715,
-0.1127294824,
-0.0661307052,
0.6328963637,
-0.6170502305,
0.3144607842,
0.5279400945,
-0.4994932711,
-0.1060834453,
0.8088517785,
-0.2197075784,
0.1571731269,
0.5115813017,
0.2143868953,
-0.4264040291,
-1.0508800745,
-0.7242693901,
0.2799615264,
-0.2583120167,
0.1547507197,
-0.4307532907,
0.0939299986,
-0.1393687278,
-0.4393459857,
-0.315107137,
-0.18723239,
-0.1541723013,
-0.1158311442,
0.2045277506,
0.6393025517,
0.0415341146,
0.8373378515,
-0.6631346941,
0.3165515363,
0.1284376085,
0.2919377089,
0.1686484516,
-0.5383712053,
0.0033000517,
-0.0852114484,
-0.2118989527,
-0.3466642499,
0.3879082501,
-0.1250808388,
0.50776124,
0.4270188808,
-0.6163434982,
0.8785980344,
-0.4985991418,
0.7714545131,
-0.3492277861,
-0.8631248474,
0.449790746,
-0.536965847,
0.3182991743,
-0.031919688,
0.0992902666,
0.0141456164,
-0.1309507936,
-0.2140431702,
-0.762134552,
0.6711942554,
0.0255342051,
0.0027567174,
0.0733512342,
0.6730491519,
-0.096128948,
-0.0058046998,
-0.3515280783,
0.0048632245,
0.2323503345,
0.0575610213,
0.0706741214,
-0.3220352232,
0.1734137386,
-0.1124516502,
0.7581816316,
-0.0523185767,
0.6869738698,
0.1893299818,
0.0833494663,
0.0782280788,
0.1730615497,
0.6943589449,
0.710355401,
-0.2762035131,
-0.2077735811,
0.1247010231,
-0.2862679064,
-0.1784580946,
0.4938251972,
-0.2600831091,
-0.1360236704,
0.1618101001,
1.1244938374,
0.4888156056,
-0.6094507575,
0.3745657504,
-0.2838323414,
-0.1495487392,
-0.0042137154,
-0.0808962509,
0.1505891979,
0.6544358134,
0.2006044686,
-0.1841160208,
-0.1073007435,
0.0137211569,
0.0565985627,
0.6159856319,
-0.0204720274,
-0.6108281016,
0.9141770601,
0.3024688661,
0.0367564447,
0.9252646565,
-0.1731224954,
-0.247797519,
0.6535614133,
0.6021499634,
0.8631142974,
-0.2015479952,
-0.1488410681,
0.4343840182,
0.2934482694,
0.3597880006,
0.5074460506,
-0.1096929386,
-0.8357236385,
-0.678374052,
-1.0501958132,
-0.0770282075,
-0.0515064336,
-0.2088218778,
-0.2559409142,
-0.678136766,
-0.0861651003,
0.0768908784,
-0.146707356,
-0.4478668571,
-0.1498480886,
0.3891493082,
0.9864429832,
-0.8850069046,
1.0491940975,
0.4012717307,
0.3634441495,
-0.5295015574,
-0.3179368377,
-0.1834452897,
-0.9303298593,
0.6798192263,
-0.1871921122,
-0.2966623306,
-0.3049896657,
-0.1362589747,
-0.5952143669,
1.1594554186,
0.445436269,
-0.5818485618,
-0.1101983339,
0.1822632551,
0.6708690524,
-0.4796406031,
0.2048420906,
0.7321306467,
0.5623821616,
0.2072715312,
-0.5320035815,
-0.0286251605,
0.1540597975,
0.3634116054,
0.4038603604,
-0.2304916829,
0.9425429106,
-0.401469022,
-0.129313454,
0.3623147011,
1.0349903107,
0.4758760929,
0.2064472735,
0.4046929181,
0.5538828969,
0.8255413771,
-0.4617581666,
1.1650543213,
-0.4895358682,
0.2607289553,
0.861890614,
-0.4810956419,
1.0435199738,
0.4113079309,
-0.4137951434,
0.4043482542,
0.3279363811,
-0.0155441603,
0.3196439147,
0.2364810854,
-0.4160978198,
-0.1291010231,
0.0386346765,
-0.2011483908,
0.337230891,
0.6514205337,
-0.6082684994,
-0.2936829031,
-0.1697319448,
0.0137236901,
-0.1560320109,
-0.3990639746,
0.2232269049,
-0.2395092398,
-0.7694319487,
0.2528759837,
0.2418378294,
0.5470443368,
-0.7035903931,
-0.1662117988,
-0.2157631516,
0.5465247035,
-0.1131380275,
-0.7074474692,
0.3632593155,
-0.029212812,
-0.1460223198,
-0.2178882807,
0.7244949937,
-0.3239246607,
-0.4981391132,
0.5565735102,
0.3609866798,
0.2172428221,
0.0025001019,
-0.6482999325,
0.6336588264,
-0.0002056687,
-0.1093953252,
0.3588179946,
0.3723109365,
-0.0280180182,
0.5010647178,
0.7613266706,
0.1411422938,
0.3640850186,
0.0857837275,
0.6878883839,
-0.3996466994,
-0.2768612206,
-0.7313492894,
0.0443675108,
0.2015892118,
0.0318065397,
0.6410422325,
0.4278977811,
0.410472542,
-0.0552635156,
0.5773532987,
-0.071240969,
0.1669016927,
-0.7878928781,
0.4801410139,
-0.4450948834,
0.4211994708,
-0.1943392456,
-0.7481149435,
-0.1881508678,
0.5834892988,
-0.6226630807,
0.1633269191,
0.3199647367,
0.8820310831,
-0.1532154232,
0.3040767014,
0.4229665101,
0.5264012218,
0.667973876,
0.7434030771,
0.436730355,
-0.289922148,
0.0649486855,
-0.1620094925,
-0.3360605538,
0.0782683417,
-1.0404860973,
-0.4032092392,
-0.146594137,
-0.159798786,
-0.0183544438,
0.2612442076,
0.3768071532,
0.6555864215,
-0.5523868799,
-0.2565050721,
0.0018484103,
0.018896386,
-0.0917042047,
-0.2428030074,
0.3458450139,
-0.1064403802,
-0.9980086088,
0.729637742,
0.4868364632,
-0.1691946834,
-0.4386375844,
-0.0652190298,
-0.2111627609,
0.0956995338,
0.9147819877,
0.370651722,
-0.6458300352,
-0.2386751175,
-0.1543032825,
0.1273047775,
0.1263501048,
0.9801505208,
-0.9566556215,
0.3365709782,
0.7267330885,
0.9229806662,
0.5623247027,
0.2543668151,
0.5384353399,
-0.7122389674,
0.2717342675,
-0.1286759824,
0.575060308,
0.0990828425,
-0.2792162597,
0.1544125527,
0.2124965489,
-0.7546575069,
-0.4149518311,
0.0320751891,
-0.6805189848,
-0.1676504463,
1.0153410435,
-0.4586803317,
-0.6296640635,
0.1609881669,
0.1362276673,
-0.2691578865,
-0.5276479721,
0.5134467483,
0.398861289,
-0.4271255434,
0.1819188297,
-0.7905213237,
0.1579727232,
0.5154096484,
-0.9476017952,
0.5514797568,
0.7273076773,
0.0516323075,
0.060940776,
0.6575616002,
-0.2856425047,
0.1501782835,
0.0789265633,
-0.0584494807,
0.0871298164,
-0.4443333149,
-0.5041054487,
0.2325986177,
-0.0345662683,
-0.0167714693
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15156v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15156v2
|
Large Language Models as Zero-Shot Keyphrase Extractors: A Preliminary Empirical Study
| 2023-12-23T03:50:49 | 2024-01-10T10:46:49 |
Mingyang Song, Xuelian Geng, Songfang Yao, Shilong Lu, Yi Feng, Liping Jing
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Zero-shot keyphrase extraction aims to build a keyphrase extractor without
training by human-annotated data, which is challenging due to the limited human
intervention involved. Challenging but worthwhile, zero-shot setting
efficiently reduces the time and effort that data labeling takes. Recent
efforts on pre-trained large language models (e.g., ChatGPT and ChatGLM) show
promising performance on zero-shot settings, thus inspiring us to explore
prompt-based methods. In this paper, we ask whether strong keyphrase extraction
models can be constructed by directly prompting the large language model
ChatGPT. Through experimental results, it is found that ChatGPT still has a lot
of room for improvement in the keyphrase extraction task compared to existing
state-of-the-art unsupervised and supervised models.
|
[
0.0081270272,
-0.8890013099,
0.7869270444,
-0.0714618191,
-0.4356463253,
0.00643866,
-0.4069943726,
-0.3885439038,
-0.0992842987,
0.4163824022,
-0.4018448293,
-0.3584220111,
-0.7670288086,
0.1596405208,
-0.3665523827,
1.012557745,
0.1180907637,
0.0967055336,
0.3105403781,
0.3494100571,
-0.6401614547,
-0.5897712111,
-0.6078161597,
-0.2372964621,
0.6690670252,
0.5209110975,
0.6157141924,
0.4821389019,
0.4200075865,
0.1665184945,
-0.295399338,
-0.4505750239,
-0.1911927462,
0.507650733,
-0.0683430806,
-0.4290049672,
-0.1354534477,
0.2091223001,
0.3923635483,
0.7040897608,
0.0778143555,
-0.0000342761,
-0.1070989072,
0.3049280047,
-0.6016500592,
0.3512706757,
-0.7413347363,
0.0399735421,
-0.2647026777,
-0.1187477112,
-0.4693756104,
-0.2679234743,
0.387667954,
-0.1867132932,
0.2827084064,
0.0482223853,
0.7298491597,
-0.2634434104,
-0.3794867992,
-0.3766103089,
-0.6959869862,
0.6441457868,
-0.8806259632,
0.3472469747,
0.1561773866,
0.3870130181,
-0.148736909,
-0.6499091387,
-0.6015923023,
-0.674258709,
0.2478529811,
0.0686856881,
0.0672260299,
0.1870628446,
0.5313032866,
0.347787708,
-0.7173335552,
0.3623633385,
-0.4351626635,
0.0046518808,
0.3930383921,
-0.0695643723,
0.4500030875,
-0.3650442362,
-0.0489495546,
-0.0675621629,
-0.9460195303,
0.0290480107,
-0.0201924704,
0.6870217919,
0.1218246445,
0.8023355007,
-0.3298248649,
0.5198853612,
-0.1776140183,
0.0751921982,
0.0512771867,
-0.1441666931,
-0.1162562817,
0.2883932292,
0.9589347839,
0.0156566948,
0.5922546387,
-0.5937154889,
-0.1906692982,
0.0449462123,
0.0090688234,
-1.1723915339,
-0.4461297691,
0.4160220623,
-0.2879194617,
-0.5478364825,
0.0009352374,
-0.8801954389,
-0.359477967,
0.0436786823,
0.671012342,
-0.3939644396,
-0.185016945,
0.1699091792,
-0.4036104679,
0.6353845,
0.4366428256,
-0.8571019769,
-0.0683981553,
0.8212102652,
1.144195199,
-0.2453515381,
0.0023338594,
-0.684761405,
-0.0639952198,
-0.4656710029,
0.6842865348,
-0.8546943069,
-0.5327007174,
0.1383607537,
0.1468202472,
-0.1520356685,
-0.3205055892,
0.6532358527,
-0.670090735,
0.4677625,
-0.3542422056,
-0.8805969357,
0.0266863313,
0.2378066629,
-0.4462146759,
0.5853605866,
-0.1763970703,
-0.4583568573,
0.2746469676,
-1.0132681131,
-0.5861514211,
0.3525526822,
-0.069243148,
-0.2453015745,
0.2629199326,
0.5029866695,
0.7112273574,
-0.380775243,
0.2903421521,
-0.5210867524,
-0.4007944763,
0.430467546,
-0.7855624557,
1.0071235895,
0.2929340899,
-0.5286952853,
-0.2768680453,
-0.5553420186,
-0.0471354388,
0.4620645642,
-0.1237167642,
-0.1465197206,
-0.2072889358,
0.0279562678,
0.4131348431,
0.186440289,
-0.859292388,
0.7186103463,
-0.4603680372,
0.5677576661,
0.7877002358,
0.2313711196,
0.4116499424,
0.05746378,
0.8777012229,
-0.2700321078,
-0.1943823993,
-0.6332885623,
-0.5594944358,
-0.4433176816,
-0.5360540152,
0.6105447412,
0.5386714339,
-0.6949359179,
0.2578497827,
-0.3059294522,
-0.5324656367,
-0.2072346807,
0.0242622886,
0.3081079125,
0.4741579294,
0.0884421468,
-0.1722409278,
-0.116447866,
-0.4395772815,
-0.0748297423,
-0.1308268905,
-0.2552531958,
0.3007300496,
0.5488650203,
0.363864094,
0.8758528829,
-0.8287898898,
0.0325598232,
-0.6111389995,
0.3641968668,
0.5011547208,
0.2396855801,
0.2388995737,
-0.7967016697,
-0.6846231818,
-0.0932574719,
-0.8983900547,
-0.2457077503,
-0.0786328241,
0.1169401854,
-0.3090747893,
0.5890570283,
-1.2079226971,
0.17415227,
0.192784369,
-0.1245641634,
0.683300972,
-0.0544790104,
-0.0046535563,
-1.1333993673,
0.405916065,
-0.1555304676,
0.0307004731,
-1.0816050768,
0.091348581,
0.2467082888,
-0.7306783795,
-0.6466293931,
0.8421118855,
-0.5671512485,
0.1127195284,
-0.3846684396,
0.1089302376,
-0.1105333492,
0.4651747048,
0.5633115768,
0.7865567803,
0.7184720635,
-0.4298707545,
0.1117655188,
0.2166508585,
-0.2152655572,
0.2237847596,
-1.068494916,
0.104170613,
-0.2483282089,
0.2488431633,
-1.2280523777,
-0.5320762396,
0.3072540462,
-0.4969401658,
0.4759016335,
-0.388284564,
-0.4307236075,
-0.513445735,
-0.3155290782,
0.0825045034,
0.7851265073,
-0.4430860281,
-0.015875008,
0.0717728734,
-0.4815603495,
-0.219252944,
-0.1344910711,
0.2353256643,
-0.2494175285,
-0.2328422517,
-0.1120627746,
-0.0328714103,
0.0505011491,
-0.4742212892,
0.0871138424,
-0.2663305104,
0.2128862739,
0.4464862943,
0.5088644028,
-0.1395581812,
0.3727237284,
-0.2291662842,
-0.0991500318,
-0.20107162,
-0.2264389247,
0.6981697083,
0.2497325391,
-0.4170832336,
-0.5293483138,
0.3692615628,
0.7729179263,
-0.6170957088,
0.6194474101,
0.3472268581,
-0.1401667744,
0.2351367027,
-0.4194065034,
-0.4381914735,
-0.4504937232,
0.2991416752,
-0.1932490021,
-0.9870387912,
0.2266150713,
-0.0803381428,
0.2484598458,
0.2763362825,
0.6157858372,
0.0055602919,
1.2046568394,
0.4501821995,
-0.3487988114,
0.5632475615,
0.078652963,
0.3866092265,
-0.5370001793,
0.1918614358,
-0.8238060474,
0.0496709049,
-0.3562412858,
0.050735794,
0.2853812575,
0.2014560401,
-0.1291924268,
0.3363812864,
-0.4615750909,
0.38668859,
0.5582523346,
-0.019796377,
0.0661983043,
-0.1132097617,
0.0935522914,
0.037032865,
-0.6017180681,
-0.3053539991,
1.2963378429,
0.1533585042,
0.5664774179,
-0.1346703917,
0.7179535031,
0.0405809097,
0.1134172603,
-1.081697464,
0.4278071821,
0.2076099068,
-0.9012972116,
-0.4307688773,
-0.3822578788,
-1.2932481766,
0.3059796393,
-0.1289345771,
-1.0101811886,
0.0173025001,
-0.007667087,
-0.6078223586,
0.0237327013,
-0.8709744811,
1.0788071156,
-0.2022735626,
-0.0111552728,
0.4727970958,
-0.5462430716,
0.3679210544,
-0.3579045534,
0.0388103947,
-0.2315216064,
0.2062416673,
0.7042937875,
-0.4059940279,
0.6261578202,
-0.4159356654,
-0.1606291384,
0.3324571848,
0.1576196402,
0.8543661237,
-0.2335186899,
0.0036218597,
0.0319223218,
-0.1198733076,
-0.3135321736,
-0.5592908263,
0.3133389652,
-0.423712045,
-0.5334115624,
-0.3997642696,
-0.4103308916,
-0.3472231328,
0.4123224318,
0.3731663823,
0.4978123903,
-0.0803182796,
0.4610448778,
0.5889381766,
-0.3409681916,
0.856326282,
0.5755890608,
-0.1155290231,
-0.0518731624,
0.8548131585,
0.225138098,
0.3884539902,
0.4170737267,
0.3589117229,
-0.3557880521,
-0.564940393,
-0.2959575951,
0.1244451925,
-0.241326943,
-0.1499799043,
-0.832418561,
-0.3739543855,
-0.6261213422,
-0.2388123572,
-0.3911275268,
-0.5132226348,
-0.0402661078,
0.0592697337,
0.4037699699,
0.3505429029,
0.1138009876,
0.7234107256,
-1.0723669529,
0.2863091528,
0.4146915376,
-0.1522599459,
0.0127736647,
-0.6546877623,
-0.0561733805,
0.0595513694,
-0.0425986536,
-0.9459801912,
0.5463221073,
0.1844846308,
0.2777884603,
0.4823587239,
0.154682979,
0.4687388539,
-0.823733747,
1.1309956312,
0.2504273355,
-0.6113756299,
0.5543986559,
-0.5256360173,
0.6800228953,
0.4480715394,
0.5114800334,
-0.7393850088,
-0.2997268438,
-0.5332271457,
-0.677687943,
0.694855392,
0.2996499836,
0.3753227592,
-0.2222898006,
0.331237793,
0.0758990869,
0.2846771181,
-0.7078801394,
0.148478806,
0.0907070115,
-0.1097612008,
-0.2199475765,
-0.3702006042,
0.3729920983,
-0.0121287443,
0.4912210703,
-0.0639890879,
0.345518887,
-0.0078387847,
-0.2373663485,
0.1559421718,
0.5922604799,
0.2246439606,
0.2293768227,
-0.4142312109,
0.0540359654,
-0.1237959638,
-0.5029771924,
0.3960953057,
0.1367466748,
-0.5030508637,
-0.0748303086,
0.5834027529,
0.6431279182,
0.3513142169,
-0.8359052539,
0.9475800395,
-0.0744989142,
-0.1706182659,
0.0589837879,
0.1252115518,
-0.06754978,
0.2327035218,
0.4308603406,
-0.6075873375,
0.0410935283,
-0.5327838063,
0.202667594,
0.794077158,
-0.4100924134,
-0.3604787588,
0.6550879478,
-0.1531590372,
-0.2333670259,
0.7953670025,
0.0434617549,
-0.6447235942,
0.3685038388,
0.6248084903,
1.0551604033,
-0.2562568188,
0.4193884432,
0.224658832,
0.1116863489,
-0.3567746282,
0.0025566923,
-0.3509351611,
-0.5798306465,
-0.550337255,
-0.6812107563,
-0.4884133935,
0.2697027028,
-0.4510324001,
0.2322472036,
-0.3594153523,
0.1582060456,
0.4077250659,
0.045597177,
-0.4724603295,
0.0799288824,
0.1898756623,
0.6952701807,
-0.8295058608,
0.9005472064,
0.2435400188,
-0.6086508036,
-0.7513314486,
0.0209315717,
-0.1575541645,
-0.8414428234,
0.6419559717,
0.4265505672,
0.4841350019,
-0.0220108572,
-0.8289505839,
-0.7562834024,
0.7637876868,
0.360686332,
-0.5722870231,
-0.2617077529,
0.0787410662,
0.3912151456,
-0.0472849868,
0.347165972,
0.1235979721,
0.3018678129,
0.5260531306,
-0.8743460178,
-0.0425574519,
-0.07833682,
-0.1492133737,
0.2426426262,
-0.2673184872,
1.0825740099,
0.0174836759,
-0.2434729934,
0.1443560719,
0.4805654883,
0.0338517018,
-0.1784569323,
0.2086661756,
0.1691401154,
0.5422407985,
0.2262525707,
1.0516818762,
-0.299387753,
0.3327558935,
1.2249664068,
-0.6402087212,
1.0191937685,
0.3056436479,
0.0642599985,
-0.0996297449,
0.5291634798,
-0.0336686373,
0.5847124457,
-0.1321935207,
-0.3420692086,
-0.4422680438,
0.0472079404,
-0.4194809794,
0.7821899652,
0.1466318667,
-0.4745598137,
-0.6430764198,
0.0646662414,
0.2971332669,
-0.5972420573,
-0.2603259683,
0.747128129,
0.1774972379,
-0.7432073355,
0.4380360544,
-0.0940566659,
0.4415362775,
-0.6356635094,
-0.0329439156,
-0.0709353089,
-0.0550166927,
0.2745075524,
-0.6280590892,
-0.285561651,
0.3227606714,
0.1828584075,
-0.1797385514,
0.9806165695,
-0.306209892,
-0.4552060664,
-0.2450268269,
0.6382617354,
0.38256675,
-0.6632407904,
-0.5504511595,
-0.2624291182,
-0.0549435355,
-0.4688491523,
0.550688982,
0.4323435724,
0.08829467,
0.3723292649,
0.8888249397,
0.1902033389,
-0.0458958708,
-0.1695356667,
0.7130195498,
-0.7766085863,
-0.1785472035,
-1.2737243176,
0.2451589704,
-0.177047044,
-0.0726104677,
0.9912618995,
0.3757312894,
0.2863779366,
-0.1765953153,
0.9400601983,
-0.1121146753,
0.5905331373,
-0.4584882557,
0.7767087221,
-0.3255287409,
-0.2274628282,
-0.5161425471,
-1.1513205767,
-0.4745791852,
0.5856593251,
-0.4991582632,
-0.0130721945,
0.4642896354,
0.9258992672,
-0.014770505,
0.1209842786,
0.4937297702,
0.1059380844,
0.6524986625,
0.4300414026,
0.7452006936,
-0.2399237305,
0.4641284347,
0.0011167938,
-0.1782428622,
-0.266659677,
-0.887832582,
-0.9881884456,
-0.3295854032,
-0.1008597687,
-0.1491440386,
0.0475917794,
0.9688127637,
0.4479671419,
-0.7073856592,
0.0953448266,
-0.1669188887,
-0.0212709699,
0.1017478406,
-0.2406284511,
0.4301069081,
-0.5732346177,
-0.6693339944,
0.4439016879,
0.3026851714,
0.1755559295,
-0.0807062387,
0.1169830859,
-0.1056497395,
0.1003806442,
0.6820223331,
0.6446391344,
-0.3479601443,
-0.4626672566,
0.1777478307,
-0.1119317338,
0.0687220618,
0.7074899673,
-0.521304667,
0.4005310237,
0.4615124464,
0.6779077053,
0.5418091416,
-0.1005109996,
0.6176005006,
-0.4843033254,
0.136120528,
0.0338016041,
0.2353984416,
0.1546000987,
-0.2170096934,
0.3923144042,
0.2285316885,
-0.5773219466,
-0.9215433598,
0.0691160038,
-0.9390673637,
-0.268979311,
1.4331880808,
-0.2853742838,
-0.4111718237,
-0.0887233838,
-0.4438001215,
0.1695640385,
-0.4592539072,
0.6983055472,
0.7704944015,
0.1494243145,
-0.3206831515,
-0.7129605412,
0.3075597882,
0.2044507116,
-0.7288922071,
0.4098834395,
0.4736118913,
0.1646106839,
0.025185572,
0.7020881772,
-0.1677248925,
0.2799619436,
-0.0243080501,
0.0990201756,
0.0203615166,
-0.2354812473,
-0.5111418366,
0.5472067595,
0.344458133,
-0.1666036844
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15099v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15099v2
|
Moderating New Waves of Online Hate with Chain-of-Thought Reasoning in Large Language Models
| 2023-12-22T22:34:49 | 2024-05-10T17:01:55 |
Nishant Vishwamitra, Keyan Guo, Farhan Tajwar Romit, Isabelle Ondracek, Long Cheng, Ziming Zhao, Hongxin Hu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG, cs.SI
|
Online hate is an escalating problem that negatively impacts the lives of
Internet users, and is also subject to rapid changes due to evolving events,
resulting in new waves of online hate that pose a critical threat. Detecting
and mitigating these new waves present two key challenges: it demands
reasoning-based complex decision-making to determine the presence of hateful
content, and the limited availability of training samples hinders updating the
detection model. To address this critical issue, we present a novel framework
called HATEGUARD for effectively moderating new waves of online hate. HATEGUARD
employs a reasoning-based approach that leverages the recently introduced
chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting technique, harnessing the capabilities of
large language models (LLMs). HATEGUARD further achieves prompt-based zero-shot
detection by automatically generating and updating detection prompts with new
derogatory terms and targets in new wave samples to effectively address new
waves of online hate. To demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach, we
compile a new dataset consisting of tweets related to three recently witnessed
new waves: the 2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine, the 2021 insurrection of the
US Capitol, and the COVID-19 pandemic. Our studies reveal crucial longitudinal
patterns in these new waves concerning the evolution of events and the pressing
need for techniques to rapidly update existing moderation tools to counteract
them. Comparative evaluations against state-of-the-art tools illustrate the
superiority of our framework, showcasing a substantial 22.22% to 83.33%
improvement in detecting the three new waves of online hate. Our work
highlights the severe threat posed by the emergence of new waves of online hate
and represents a paradigm shift in addressing this threat practically.
|
[
-0.8428977132,
-1.1792042255,
0.5522261858,
0.0481809638,
-0.2964265943,
0.2739984989,
-0.123502709,
-0.4703516364,
0.4996066093,
0.6150771976,
-0.5997197032,
-0.4134448767,
-0.6090358496,
-0.0508558117,
-0.6744619012,
1.0413515568,
-0.0357488804,
-0.3459166586,
0.4208241701,
0.0400950611,
-0.4028097391,
-0.3938610554,
-0.7656593919,
-0.2406221777,
0.701131165,
0.0097481487,
0.5485251546,
0.207308054,
0.4226704538,
0.1444031149,
-0.1987771988,
0.0318754464,
-0.603490591,
0.4956409037,
-0.2656004429,
-0.2119289488,
-0.413202703,
-0.2125761062,
0.1135648191,
0.0138364071,
-0.2524901032,
0.0374230221,
-0.1123213693,
0.4048555493,
-0.7352079749,
-0.3898769021,
-0.9338361621,
0.201156795,
-0.1345463544,
-0.2686944604,
-0.4260882139,
-0.2290459871,
0.1371548772,
-0.4797722101,
0.0969779491,
0.1310857385,
0.4619435966,
0.0055083912,
-0.4087800086,
-0.0992206484,
-0.7805681229,
0.7462226152,
-0.5923569202,
0.4075080454,
0.3463144004,
0.3407150805,
-0.2744685411,
-0.3511253297,
-0.6183544993,
-0.0408331268,
0.5059793591,
-0.0293700881,
-0.6592225432,
-0.0933950171,
0.2285357565,
0.1155588627,
-0.3721133173,
0.2889647782,
-0.1488278806,
-0.2017266452,
0.6945461035,
-0.0417529754,
0.3465698063,
-0.0679517314,
-0.6370013356,
0.27741763,
-0.5783110261,
-0.3252469301,
0.5564591289,
0.2170446068,
-0.2260063589,
0.2791386545,
-0.1506835967,
0.4966185093,
0.3613252342,
-0.0966148898,
0.0326110683,
0.1927735806,
-0.1649837494,
0.1592974216,
0.655397594,
0.639967978,
0.2041414827,
-0.0243989881,
-0.2640697658,
0.296874553,
0.5053014755,
-0.5238471031,
-0.0657403022,
0.2407989055,
-0.3800173402,
-0.6919144392,
-0.345400542,
-1.1810367107,
-1.0391731262,
-0.0753426403,
0.3647481501,
-0.1374779046,
-0.5134005547,
0.1269729286,
-0.3516839445,
0.0580563806,
0.6197151542,
-0.3484876752,
0.3119373322,
0.5824810863,
0.7787403464,
-0.2469541132,
0.1546496153,
-0.4857682288,
-0.1092316508,
-0.2059586346,
0.8554528952,
-0.4650448859,
-0.000621839,
0.1458530724,
-0.4961619675,
0.3682050109,
-0.3720318675,
0.3351330757,
-0.8732840419,
0.0205090456,
0.0053236973,
-0.5545436144,
-0.0236692242,
0.8506234884,
-0.6723604798,
0.9032112956,
0.0777256787,
-0.7517807484,
0.2566683292,
-0.4703456461,
-0.0942302048,
0.2253685445,
-0.0038108667,
-0.2976281047,
-0.0265384223,
0.1630368829,
0.259809792,
-0.518114686,
0.3768993616,
-0.8136512041,
0.0589922965,
0.4131114781,
-0.3230410218,
0.8125220537,
0.3904378414,
-0.8674305081,
0.2872600555,
-0.4864324629,
-0.118577376,
0.0578499287,
0.1673855633,
-0.3656604588,
0.1864738613,
-0.0881739482,
0.5512949228,
-0.0643992051,
-0.7217535973,
0.0405826122,
-0.1895286292,
0.3383436203,
1.1363085508,
0.4135015905,
0.0960835591,
-0.5431468487,
0.7966707945,
-0.0625981316,
0.6661611199,
0.2327477634,
-0.5546424389,
-0.7306897044,
-0.1550054401,
-0.5964635015,
0.4061488211,
-0.8045541644,
0.2890546024,
0.1990714371,
-0.6173077822,
0.0518747978,
-0.0107567832,
0.3613824546,
0.4090197682,
0.7660629153,
-0.1995432377,
-0.9089344144,
-0.5679100156,
-0.3331429362,
-0.2222389281,
0.2871214151,
0.0155515773,
0.2977202833,
-0.3036163747,
0.794971168,
-0.4641702175,
-0.0475861244,
-0.4439856112,
0.147966966,
-0.1988140047,
0.0328126363,
0.3889535666,
-0.8765046,
-0.4833545089,
-0.3783421218,
-0.4429767132,
-0.4288258255,
-0.1678806692,
-0.3791023493,
-0.1202471331,
0.6755108237,
-0.0530753732,
0.337281853,
0.4394863248,
-0.4701592326,
0.7438762188,
0.5707566142,
0.2411259115,
-0.9482089281,
-0.1912941486,
0.1441003233,
-0.0729236156,
-0.9178455472,
0.385394454,
-0.4822198451,
0.0672703683,
-0.5697889924,
0.5389547944,
0.0147213275,
0.5523713231,
-0.3304879665,
0.2897194028,
-0.1586330384,
0.353159517,
-0.3230877221,
0.1214241683,
0.2473086417,
-0.5227533579,
0.588106811,
0.256772697,
-0.3951018155,
0.7774835229,
-0.2138172686,
0.124019511,
-0.0775807425,
0.604737103,
-0.6750162244,
-0.0023732847,
0.522446692,
-0.1410238743,
-0.250897795,
-0.2921255231,
-0.314963758,
-0.6010134816,
-0.5414751172,
0.5703423023,
0.4561603963,
-0.4730412066,
0.5288330317,
0.7036383152,
0.1558345556,
-0.5180429816,
-0.4995937645,
0.1046914831,
-0.4092400074,
-0.2142418772,
0.3631126881,
-0.1449776441,
-0.6533985734,
-0.1720833778,
-0.1948337853,
-0.3592607975,
0.1782150418,
0.2261878699,
0.3108388484,
0.2301577032,
-0.027541874,
-0.2170369625,
0.1403541863,
0.2452166378,
-0.6407920718,
0.9341814518,
0.1388847381,
-0.2830132246,
-0.1794154048,
0.1813743412,
0.6638591886,
-0.2030434608,
0.5987026095,
0.6599663496,
-0.3474278748,
-0.7099001408,
-0.935916245,
-0.0994670615,
-0.4573777318,
0.0671002343,
0.1513868272,
-1.2248094082,
0.5282886624,
0.1486217827,
0.0338938534,
0.2873266637,
0.6460621953,
0.217343092,
0.9349641204,
0.3012244999,
-0.0871042609,
0.5913982391,
0.0376843847,
0.5244765282,
-0.6914121509,
-0.3205456138,
-0.2358340174,
-0.1926628202,
-0.42920807,
-0.5611007214,
0.4846491516,
-0.0905226767,
-0.4065475166,
0.3879648447,
-0.5277711749,
0.3484228253,
0.099353388,
0.321213305,
0.146524176,
0.0444345772,
-0.1667025387,
0.1029591635,
-0.3368214071,
-0.195562467,
1.093298912,
0.2509918511,
0.7717677355,
0.3132113218,
0.5980650187,
0.7435292602,
0.3409247696,
-0.7213463783,
0.665862143,
0.213126272,
-0.8516457081,
-0.0317519829,
-0.3673840761,
-0.6137568355,
0.080036059,
-0.4015414417,
-0.7842618227,
-0.0571462996,
0.4938842356,
-0.4270149469,
0.9895905852,
-0.0882991254,
0.5304121375,
-0.2411340624,
-0.4923303723,
-0.62012887,
-0.3535004556,
0.4896114469,
-0.2424719185,
0.5155211091,
-0.3221851885,
0.2201434076,
0.6503727436,
-0.2934632897,
0.9005932212,
-0.2781081498,
-0.4018782973,
0.5450274944,
0.3379673958,
0.5239285827,
-0.4290343523,
-0.1328003258,
-0.0011415689,
-0.2950063944,
-0.2444859594,
-0.4064771831,
0.6159883738,
-0.3870048225,
-0.5090628266,
-0.2816726267,
-0.343549937,
-0.1562774479,
0.2033533901,
0.1936871707,
0.413525641,
-0.3933314681,
-0.1678971499,
0.8692010045,
-0.3157761991,
0.1712316126,
0.3103917241,
-0.7110559344,
-0.5142342448,
0.8462519646,
0.0582846031,
0.4894646108,
0.3403410316,
0.2939540446,
-0.1578624099,
-0.5875092149,
-0.3404872715,
-0.0909852609,
-0.4801047444,
-0.3313562274,
-0.7427847981,
-0.0492970422,
-0.3356102109,
-0.4233940244,
-0.1036200821,
-0.1544612646,
0.3195345402,
0.1376628131,
0.5894904137,
0.721540153,
-0.0273167323,
0.2023781836,
-0.3975383341,
0.4536288381,
0.393427372,
0.5162448883,
0.2427631021,
-0.6734323502,
-0.2234711945,
-0.0345762335,
-0.3985932171,
-1.0631506443,
0.3537237346,
-0.4409675002,
0.2793091834,
0.4811731279,
0.4284304082,
0.6399205923,
-0.4582282901,
0.6386271119,
0.3754095435,
-0.8573413491,
0.5968567729,
-0.5143589377,
0.0201322399,
0.3793771267,
0.4745993614,
-0.930177331,
-0.728065908,
-0.7936838269,
-0.8023090959,
0.3209570348,
-0.0522473343,
-0.0165017862,
-0.3711261749,
-0.0823418424,
-0.0169636309,
0.3716302514,
-0.6818969846,
-0.3858004212,
-0.1627118886,
0.0849789381,
0.3674581945,
-0.2571319044,
-0.1577545255,
-0.1315357685,
0.8741297722,
0.1338341385,
0.1829862148,
-0.0791693255,
-0.137740165,
-0.1961064935,
0.4848560393,
0.1828552485,
0.3416447639,
-0.1223434284,
0.4432457387,
0.2891181409,
-0.3186534643,
0.3831789494,
-0.1531205028,
-0.4516420364,
-0.2410185337,
0.1661518216,
0.6586638689,
0.2492209673,
-0.7742637992,
0.7139879465,
0.1421643645,
-0.2796411216,
-0.6106438041,
0.1101088449,
-0.4084987044,
0.1789259464,
0.2361960262,
0.1423549503,
0.0502300635,
-0.4040413201,
0.3898815811,
0.376983881,
-0.513353467,
-0.3528252542,
0.4353609979,
0.2603775561,
-0.1105516404,
0.2359427959,
-0.5279303193,
-0.9421066046,
0.4654524326,
0.7341871858,
0.9711363316,
-0.2848217189,
0.5338836908,
0.4585422277,
0.2441171855,
-0.0678720921,
0.0657395869,
-0.0200159512,
-1.0345093012,
-0.1701852083,
-0.8278915286,
-0.3893106878,
0.5096353292,
-0.6047407389,
0.2849975526,
-1.1004142761,
-0.1216606125,
-0.0062000854,
-0.3078382015,
-0.3814729452,
0.0273448993,
0.6670536995,
0.885560751,
-0.8607725501,
0.3848421276,
0.2687993944,
-0.3237759173,
-0.6018254757,
0.1738327146,
0.7297565341,
-0.7182993293,
0.3906389773,
0.1709891707,
-0.4554099739,
0.0251299702,
-0.6425075531,
-0.6624531746,
0.4375734329,
0.0397271886,
-0.6235252023,
0.1095228642,
-0.0775906667,
0.5051133633,
-0.4048000872,
0.1766179204,
0.3986204267,
0.452965498,
-0.0959830359,
-0.6452757716,
0.2596112788,
-0.2215984464,
-0.2478526235,
0.5619984865,
-0.4154396355,
0.7815799117,
0.1232715994,
-0.1152798384,
-0.3476165831,
0.0520218424,
0.159907952,
0.2292623967,
0.8849583268,
0.8641557693,
0.4721407592,
0.2180090398,
0.7177501321,
-0.1686238497,
0.2371449023,
1.0946378708,
-0.3348127604,
0.7053963542,
0.2423816025,
-0.0437962599,
0.9533187151,
0.1102425084,
-0.2943089902,
0.099101536,
0.4307408929,
-0.9109249711,
-0.513409555,
-0.5810779333,
-0.1660985053,
0.3896079957,
0.351444453,
-0.2591962516,
-0.4810816944,
0.346406728,
0.4539385438,
0.2655360103,
-0.5252643228,
0.6181098223,
-0.1520750821,
-0.6336832047,
0.4780323803,
0.130433321,
0.8842687607,
-0.5316659212,
0.1150577813,
0.2173005342,
0.2520107627,
-0.2305027992,
-0.6426025629,
0.1932558864,
0.6336215734,
-0.0785269812,
-0.4332389534,
0.5959059596,
-0.3287750781,
-0.1705119908,
0.7984160781,
0.4096994698,
-0.0398373604,
-0.3165875077,
-0.9012912512,
0.4241207838,
0.1824051589,
0.1075332165,
0.2986783981,
0.0257396437,
-0.3227464855,
0.6050083637,
0.7943049669,
0.1665516496,
0.1268506944,
0.3614846468,
0.9440516233,
-0.5107391477,
-0.5202830434,
-1.0179342031,
0.1510221511,
-0.3014010787,
-0.3225890696,
0.7268569469,
0.4267567396,
1.1115185022,
0.3830600381,
0.8672329783,
-0.4011182487,
0.6310628057,
-0.119015038,
0.5319715142,
-0.3719180226,
0.2431531101,
-0.5782796741,
-0.5704964399,
-0.4773400724,
0.4657300115,
-0.5355060697,
-0.2589517236,
0.674536705,
1.0372720957,
0.1144082472,
0.1850686669,
0.1142241433,
0.4770117402,
0.6796601415,
0.3261180818,
0.9482325912,
-0.1425165534,
0.5730883479,
-0.2841800451,
-0.34231475,
-0.2901228964,
-0.7534239292,
-0.889242053,
-0.4086511731,
-0.275208354,
-0.8378921151,
0.1707780063,
1.4225349426,
0.3838943541,
-0.8813332915,
-0.1622998863,
-0.3621556461,
0.1725814193,
-0.0849283785,
-0.2411071807,
-0.1581446379,
-0.2547051311,
-0.1138191968,
0.2464836091,
0.3122877777,
-0.1970394552,
-0.286747396,
-0.0228847247,
-0.5446021557,
0.274084866,
0.9142648578,
0.3565152884,
-0.8594583869,
-0.3785593808,
-0.1416452676,
-0.0690580755,
-0.1231821775,
0.7732524276,
-0.7640390992,
0.5974431038,
0.3279778361,
0.6020048261,
0.4111794531,
-0.293736726,
0.3616258502,
-0.3692485094,
0.0191661809,
0.342227459,
0.1580907255,
0.2530177534,
-0.0549589843,
0.1876434237,
0.4653409719,
-0.3181029558,
-0.866812706,
0.6577827334,
-0.7662547827,
-0.3828321397,
1.0305979252,
0.1475090235,
-0.0335277244,
-0.3963956237,
-0.1464556009,
0.2809944451,
-0.4391130209,
1.1442450285,
0.5337029696,
-0.0144561427,
-0.0398345739,
-0.3388668597,
0.5141272545,
0.3109669983,
-0.8897513151,
0.1259915084,
0.7013136148,
0.0758657828,
0.113135919,
0.6253390312,
-0.0157172885,
0.2202070355,
-0.1040007249,
0.0717905536,
0.0469753966,
-0.4818958044,
-0.2053245753,
0.2595586479,
-0.2826070786,
0.4178586304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15098v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15098v1
|
Unsupervised Auditory and Semantic Entrainment Models with Deep Neural Networks
| 2023-12-22T22:33:54 | 2023-12-22T22:33:54 |
Jay Kejriwal, Stefan Benus, Lina M. Rojas-Barahona
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Speakers tend to engage in adaptive behavior, known as entrainment, when they
become similar to their interlocutor in various aspects of speaking. We present
an unsupervised deep learning framework that derives meaningful representation
from textual features for developing semantic entrainment. We investigate the
model's performance by extracting features using different variations of the
BERT model (DistilBERT and XLM-RoBERTa) and Google's universal sentence encoder
(USE) embeddings on two human-human (HH) corpora (The Fisher Corpus English
Part 1, Columbia games corpus) and one human-machine (HM) corpus (Voice
Assistant Conversation Corpus (VACC)). In addition to semantic features we also
trained DNN-based models utilizing two auditory embeddings (TRIpLet Loss
network (TRILL) vectors, Low-level descriptors (LLD) features) and two units of
analysis (Inter pausal unit and Turn). The results show that semantic
entrainment can be assessed with our model, that models can distinguish between
HH and HM interactions and that the two units of analysis for extracting
acoustic features provide comparable findings.
|
[
-0.2838557959,
-0.7075677514,
0.4715837538,
0.2469020635,
-0.1814594716,
-0.1746768951,
-0.6586841941,
-0.5397036672,
0.1066486239,
0.5544912219,
-0.6275474429,
-0.4527016282,
-0.4959357381,
-0.1302941144,
-0.4485853612,
0.620770216,
0.2610349357,
0.2741395831,
-0.3416323066,
-0.1677252203,
-0.8286765814,
-0.4675750732,
-0.3170835078,
-0.670108676,
0.2018544525,
0.2898741663,
0.527174592,
0.2976157665,
0.362079531,
0.2913514376,
-0.2452717423,
-0.0996621326,
-0.3072783947,
0.2530539334,
-0.0269448254,
-0.2166901231,
-0.0714750364,
-0.0184930544,
0.5455822945,
1.0127084255,
-0.1816179305,
0.0126058729,
0.3781741858,
0.2921910882,
-0.33478266,
0.241100952,
-0.8132655025,
0.18550089,
0.0229469277,
-0.1748400331,
-0.3089750409,
0.0607174933,
0.7115494013,
-0.7236247659,
0.1429900974,
-0.3277440071,
0.5199688673,
0.5402059555,
-0.229114309,
-0.4765335917,
-0.7225385308,
0.5459195375,
-0.8525418043,
0.7119202614,
0.4728426635,
-0.0328232683,
-0.1231811568,
-0.6811696887,
-0.6997585893,
-0.5462052822,
0.0022932258,
0.2224247158,
0.0299187843,
0.1037862599,
0.0245539434,
0.1595468223,
-0.3604981303,
0.5442730188,
-0.245976463,
0.0383955464,
0.5494214892,
-0.0311060753,
0.2617536783,
-0.0276541933,
-0.5456929207,
-0.3985014856,
-0.4119450152,
-0.0598525591,
0.4252624512,
0.3707687259,
-0.1826796383,
0.4073515236,
0.1041844487,
0.4451412857,
0.0289451703,
0.1057121158,
0.3397279084,
0.0362498648,
-0.1854420304,
0.4894343615,
0.7648134828,
0.2521781921,
0.5048881769,
-0.3025515676,
-0.0901921913,
0.193476513,
0.1551678628,
-0.6101626754,
-0.3869405687,
-0.0189633202,
-0.424359411,
-0.3512962759,
0.0467715375,
-0.6365937591,
-0.5584563613,
-0.6866128445,
0.6224881411,
-0.5652139783,
-0.5064476132,
0.5501052141,
-0.2402117848,
0.2763046324,
-0.1021634638,
-1.219186902,
0.5167370439,
0.7250006795,
0.6164903641,
-0.2868641615,
-0.3933214247,
-0.270547092,
0.0715978146,
-0.1747429222,
0.4472531974,
-0.7837020755,
-0.281242758,
0.3231964111,
-0.0191262849,
-0.3205198646,
-0.6601490974,
0.3819040954,
-0.3351293802,
0.3097245395,
0.08937525,
-0.9598332047,
-0.0843562707,
-0.0015268606,
-0.5603823066,
1.0583962202,
-0.0682150796,
-0.6800101995,
0.5525422096,
-0.8477563858,
-0.2249984443,
-0.0699778795,
-0.3146341741,
-0.2037575841,
0.139025718,
0.2238458395,
0.4726913571,
-0.0316013321,
0.2899867594,
-0.4497294128,
-0.4618035853,
0.5226990581,
-0.4379832447,
0.7541559339,
-0.1330725402,
-0.2861114144,
0.0915571973,
-0.9229366183,
-0.1666348428,
0.0063877748,
-0.4043434858,
-0.3329382837,
0.0930322781,
0.2275196761,
0.020989351,
0.0572597496,
-0.837144196,
-0.2247091979,
-0.5415890813,
0.6010951996,
0.4622165561,
0.2565514743,
0.3946892023,
-0.0326054916,
0.0929156095,
0.2397958189,
-0.0169972014,
-0.0647945628,
-0.3826608062,
-0.7392665744,
-0.1811037213,
0.4748252332,
0.5584248304,
-0.3898120821,
0.8471275568,
-0.3415337801,
-0.0966222286,
-0.6677466631,
0.1853535175,
0.3151922524,
0.4631302953,
0.3522588909,
-0.3576419652,
-0.4589647651,
-0.7245879769,
-0.156442821,
-0.1926348656,
-0.358640492,
0.1193972528,
0.5016177893,
-0.3700111508,
0.9771579504,
-0.0474236608,
-0.3393293321,
0.1454727501,
0.2396024317,
-0.0175426025,
0.5285679698,
0.503703773,
-0.7258719206,
-0.2142839432,
0.0412801802,
-0.7097044587,
-0.0186092146,
-0.228845045,
-0.039970804,
-0.1018844172,
0.6751493216,
-0.4333567321,
0.5195176005,
0.3492224216,
-0.3046703637,
0.1263267398,
-0.2031182051,
-0.251668632,
-0.8224660754,
-0.3191015124,
-0.1259925067,
-0.0140572032,
-0.7419914603,
-0.2932099998,
-0.1629577428,
-0.1336432546,
-0.4205971658,
0.1889801621,
-0.2438941896,
-0.3318558633,
-0.3115688562,
0.4186214805,
0.2600858808,
0.5535866618,
0.3162149489,
0.3624098599,
0.5571576357,
-0.7889606953,
0.6307696104,
0.5288963914,
-0.5507571101,
0.3229064047,
-0.8845627308,
0.4234982431,
-0.0059550959,
-0.009708303,
-0.8545562029,
-0.0793389007,
0.0121232094,
-0.5722640753,
0.3553240299,
-0.1104230955,
-0.4906358421,
-0.0813346356,
-0.0643224716,
0.2809534967,
0.3953619897,
-0.7803878784,
0.4527862072,
0.3814412057,
-0.1867199242,
-0.1684426665,
-0.8952431679,
0.0396757387,
-0.3550402522,
-0.7097526193,
0.5817791224,
0.0012735437,
-0.1895338893,
0.120031029,
0.1843293756,
-0.1250074506,
0.1666938514,
0.2353689671,
0.0118687712,
-0.331427902,
0.6522993445,
-0.1226441637,
0.0124746654,
0.2054152191,
-0.4018223882,
0.5101292133,
0.0003937377,
-0.6398493648,
-0.6032477617,
0.4161756337,
0.4432772994,
-0.3191791177,
0.4902797043,
0.9447368979,
-0.3684670031,
0.0866412148,
-0.4493631721,
-0.3989497125,
-0.4186699986,
0.6543428302,
-0.2155653834,
-0.9029531479,
0.4949786663,
-0.085226506,
-0.1670545489,
0.2747373581,
0.6615845561,
-0.2725709975,
0.8012919426,
0.6972268224,
0.0918654576,
0.6582568288,
-0.2237076461,
-0.0860627666,
-0.9812127948,
-0.4095276296,
-0.3188845217,
-0.3562889993,
-0.6251969934,
-0.2816290557,
-0.0060961782,
0.0583884493,
-0.4834162891,
0.2021252811,
-0.3814541698,
0.2859237492,
0.6144783497,
0.1594127715,
-0.0466600955,
-0.021463681,
-0.3284238279,
-0.2211696655,
-0.4166391194,
-0.3728407621,
0.9752805233,
0.583929956,
0.8326545358,
0.1891981512,
0.7601161599,
0.2991631925,
-0.3034490347,
-0.7876381874,
0.2849928737,
-0.1528420448,
-0.2280216515,
-0.5006744862,
-0.1903333068,
-0.9327687621,
0.2011746168,
-0.4710333943,
-0.8487448692,
0.7563514113,
-0.2183350325,
-0.4609168172,
0.0090209823,
-0.7539204955,
0.836615026,
-0.3940685987,
-0.00743717,
-0.1822627038,
-0.4284307361,
-0.0990453139,
-0.0459618606,
-0.1967174262,
-0.2743667662,
0.0410542563,
0.8382943869,
0.0083313594,
1.116258502,
-0.36039868,
-0.1927243024,
0.167016983,
-0.0124329589,
0.1652701795,
0.0976916179,
-0.0648805797,
0.1063867062,
-0.0606277548,
-0.0327070728,
-0.7341158986,
0.6442124248,
-1.0166333914,
-0.392047137,
-0.0021361834,
-0.5713760257,
-0.5784133077,
-0.0647283942,
0.3075271547,
0.4696422815,
-0.5600041747,
0.6215811968,
0.8149731159,
-0.2438123226,
0.6244455576,
0.4067518711,
-0.0652445331,
-0.3126914799,
0.6662912965,
-0.092476435,
0.230307743,
0.3053579032,
0.2554936111,
-0.4861899316,
-0.5141026974,
-0.2627626061,
-0.0119435685,
-0.6754162312,
0.0944596231,
-0.4456997514,
-0.2671054006,
-0.5481290221,
0.3363677561,
-0.3488794863,
-0.4276733994,
-0.5966245532,
-0.3962279558,
0.5192588568,
0.7432552576,
-0.1002361029,
0.4393154085,
-0.5720453858,
0.2536216378,
0.665230155,
0.3670992553,
-0.1264173388,
-0.8553342819,
-0.3548521996,
0.3200535774,
-0.3241229653,
-0.8620306849,
0.308370471,
0.7770700455,
0.7599329352,
0.407464385,
0.038299121,
0.5697490573,
-0.4365202487,
0.7162240148,
0.34318313,
-0.9601618648,
0.610994637,
-0.2879031301,
0.2932465374,
0.4691484869,
0.0904550403,
-0.6258158684,
-0.2314851433,
-0.4589142799,
-0.8317628503,
0.5493227839,
0.2348447293,
0.401925236,
-0.182739526,
0.1401434094,
0.0965195,
0.0570277683,
-0.6390913129,
0.1325300038,
-0.5246763229,
-0.3365342319,
0.1018329635,
-0.3880589604,
-0.2922989726,
-0.4009498954,
0.3984675109,
-0.091553174,
0.3360776007,
0.2373211533,
-0.4354203939,
0.2925710678,
0.1837804317,
0.5342976451,
0.3595472872,
-0.3804173768,
-0.0374788642,
0.2457114458,
-0.3610663712,
-0.001932691,
0.2194604427,
0.1882326156,
0.1260960847,
0.6588658094,
1.2756071091,
0.6387602091,
-0.4246149361,
0.54413867,
-0.2237812579,
-0.30674389,
-0.5669568777,
-0.046641767,
0.351315856,
0.428513974,
0.1375399828,
-0.1361397505,
0.1991286874,
-0.5779786706,
0.3636056483,
0.0289204493,
-0.9357194304,
-0.1349292845,
0.4598149061,
0.3152078688,
-0.239577949,
0.7843288779,
0.0477721691,
-0.3442593217,
0.4562284946,
0.6303829551,
1.117661953,
-0.1352363676,
-0.0172375757,
-0.0101848813,
0.068208985,
0.2832563221,
0.1582139134,
-0.2800458074,
-0.9695254564,
-0.3125655651,
-0.6608086824,
-0.3179832697,
0.0336385071,
-1.155388236,
-0.0340094529,
-0.1836945713,
-0.23888807,
0.1173176095,
-0.2092371434,
-0.9651993513,
-0.066412881,
0.5927685499,
0.6250604987,
-0.812079072,
0.8304257989,
0.625680685,
-0.3169735968,
-0.5102310181,
0.0790987015,
-0.1321368068,
-0.6262418032,
0.7449505925,
0.1392842233,
-0.0289002936,
-0.1300619394,
-0.2222227156,
-0.6811521053,
1.117092967,
0.7192136645,
-0.793330133,
0.1949435622,
0.4202314019,
0.5828063488,
-0.8291954994,
0.0796291828,
0.8219743371,
0.3135968149,
-0.1075170487,
-1.0002880096,
-0.3173125386,
-0.2479092181,
0.2874395251,
-0.3214239776,
-0.2020585835,
0.7162713408,
-0.0048961421,
-0.1057414785,
-0.0850220025,
0.7026464939,
0.0073456238,
0.0274822619,
0.6818380952,
0.5989077091,
1.0119031668,
-0.0786649212,
0.6664862633,
-0.2955341637,
0.2106668204,
1.3194532394,
-0.3920507133,
1.0885411501,
0.2979484499,
0.0663703308,
0.6635347605,
0.6023624539,
-0.0638143048,
0.7332057953,
0.3300257623,
-0.2501680851,
-0.3282837868,
-0.217280373,
-0.4151788652,
1.0924298763,
0.4961503148,
-0.4185128808,
0.0775270462,
0.5657622814,
-0.2002264708,
0.0893519744,
-0.0297068451,
1.1957346201,
0.2727065384,
-0.2697097659,
0.5516215563,
-0.3956903219,
0.6895419955,
-0.4095338881,
-0.0071690129,
0.0277672447,
0.3218028247,
0.0444073975,
-0.7676863074,
0.099301517,
-0.1548306048,
-0.3582640588,
-0.0922734067,
0.5780338049,
-0.8299380541,
-0.4041815102,
0.9265745282,
0.2463771254,
0.0843132362,
-0.1065579429,
-0.715162456,
0.1845688075,
-0.2813566923,
-0.1838805974,
0.309037447,
0.739641428,
0.1899980456,
0.3765157461,
0.6252067685,
-0.0066466248,
0.2890232503,
0.8676450253,
0.7573026419,
-0.6873798966,
-0.5021330714,
-0.7753095031,
0.3594502807,
-0.2022595853,
-0.3396863639,
0.4236752987,
0.2059401572,
0.7500977516,
-0.1115289032,
0.5951222181,
0.5019125938,
0.3642188907,
-0.7304234505,
0.8082589507,
-0.162806496,
0.2530164719,
-0.1048689112,
-0.887153089,
-0.0075194403,
0.5983717442,
0.0191535112,
-0.059527304,
0.5667071939,
0.5966536999,
-0.0465873033,
0.3316926658,
0.5097123384,
0.1459619254,
0.2733775675,
0.4609110355,
0.9776525497,
-0.2117163539,
0.4992806017,
-0.3162826598,
-0.002080133,
-0.1480511427,
-0.7134257555,
-0.9580752254,
-0.6833959818,
-0.4694505632,
0.0196786784,
-0.013560947,
0.8701596856,
0.8721105456,
-0.7281911373,
-0.2406261861,
0.0417537466,
-0.3277575076,
-0.1940790415,
-0.1836666912,
0.4624322355,
-0.4603728056,
-0.5057395697,
0.856040597,
0.0904688314,
0.1139615998,
-0.3412112892,
-0.2852265835,
-0.225046128,
0.0845934451,
0.5670593977,
0.0656489208,
-0.7763871551,
-0.625926137,
-0.1229027808,
0.1784027219,
-0.0382530391,
0.7607262731,
-0.8463618755,
0.6103221774,
0.2047997266,
0.7942166924,
0.6006278992,
-0.3778296709,
0.6349779963,
-1.0967968702,
0.5156928301,
0.4047442079,
0.5222526193,
0.6618875265,
-0.11199411,
0.317684114,
0.107077606,
-0.4972125292,
-0.8012840152,
0.0755120367,
-0.8040522337,
-0.0956887454,
1.1237373352,
-0.1928095222,
-0.044014737,
-0.2858181596,
0.0552143566,
0.3827744424,
-0.2458078712,
0.5736745596,
0.6936970353,
-0.0761161,
-0.1244706586,
-0.5625742078,
0.4558877945,
0.4159920812,
-0.3444199562,
0.051441133,
0.1468211114,
0.1921942234,
0.3465288281,
0.2195048928,
-0.0996734127,
0.2913973927,
0.2300233096,
0.2520373166,
-0.1262592822,
-0.2861327529,
-0.4304645956,
-0.2656583488,
-0.0854819641,
-0.6894239187
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15068v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15068v2
|
Refining GPT-3 Embeddings with a Siamese Structure for Technical Post Duplicate Detection
| 2023-12-22T21:14:37 | 2024-03-04T17:03:42 |
Xingfang Wu, Heng Li, Nobukazu Yoshioka, Hironori Washizaki, Foutse Khomh
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
One goal of technical online communities is to help developers find the right
answer in one place. A single question can be asked in different ways with
different wordings, leading to the existence of duplicate posts on technical
forums. The question of how to discover and link duplicate posts has garnered
the attention of both developer communities and researchers. For example, Stack
Overflow adopts a voting-based mechanism to mark and close duplicate posts.
However, addressing these constantly emerging duplicate posts in a timely
manner continues to pose challenges. Therefore, various approaches have been
proposed to detect duplicate posts on technical forum posts automatically. The
existing methods suffer from limitations either due to their reliance on
handcrafted similarity metrics which can not sufficiently capture the semantics
of posts, or their lack of supervision to improve the performance.
Additionally, the efficiency of these methods is hindered by their dependence
on pair-wise feature generation, which can be impractical for large amount of
data. In this work, we attempt to employ and refine the GPT-3 embeddings for
the duplicate detection task. We assume that the GPT-3 embeddings can
accurately represent the semantics of the posts. In addition, by training a
Siamese-based network based on the GPT-3 embeddings, we obtain a latent
embedding that accurately captures the duplicate relation in technical forum
posts. Our experiment on a benchmark dataset confirms the effectiveness of our
approach and demonstrates superior performance compared to baseline methods.
When applied to the dataset we constructed with a recent Stack Overflow dump,
our approach attains a Top-1, Top-5, and Top-30 accuracy of 23.1%, 43.9%, and
68.9%, respectively. With a manual study, we confirm our approach's potential
of finding unlabelled duplicates on technical forums.
|
[
-0.5864310861,
-0.7418345809,
0.6048394442,
0.3725953698,
-0.6712746024,
0.2705233097,
0.1046444699,
-0.2364814281,
0.5056322813,
0.3306062818,
-0.2786788642,
-0.8630601168,
-0.5296650529,
0.1249124259,
-0.4283467829,
1.0733686686,
-0.5244830847,
-0.2139675915,
0.0835816637,
-0.4092632234,
-0.4315093458,
-0.351758033,
-0.6760253906,
0.1993714571,
0.2592781186,
0.1804032475,
0.317035228,
0.6828203797,
0.4735076725,
0.2945828736,
-0.0680899769,
0.2750733793,
-0.3053995967,
-0.053193748,
0.0604610257,
-0.2190166414,
-0.4488322437,
-0.1603028923,
0.6568954587,
0.4899547994,
-0.1650956571,
0.1364100128,
0.405969888,
0.4237408638,
-0.5284647346,
0.1993930191,
-0.8195417523,
0.1603359431,
-0.2892216742,
-0.6082279682,
-0.0554326065,
-0.639246285,
-0.3324677646,
-0.784995079,
0.6349350214,
-0.2240758538,
0.5912086964,
-0.0189544018,
-0.3266400993,
-0.2492169589,
-0.4538199902,
0.6630961895,
-0.4115750194,
0.311370492,
0.2888752222,
0.1387879997,
-0.0303835124,
-0.4334347546,
-0.5994152427,
-0.1752108783,
-0.3058468699,
-0.0993078202,
-0.0779026747,
-0.3268581331,
0.4831385016,
0.3574971855,
-1.0355892181,
0.0018708754,
-0.4563826323,
-0.1602616608,
0.3257676959,
-0.0789305419,
0.1800030619,
-0.2557939589,
-0.3559536636,
0.0384414196,
-0.7091939449,
-0.5192021728,
0.6330428123,
0.1738157868,
0.0399510562,
0.5244357586,
-0.2018235624,
0.476758033,
0.261461705,
0.1553687304,
0.5935837626,
-0.7529527545,
0.2077911347,
-0.1013311148,
0.7950080633,
0.4734070599,
0.2290523797,
-0.0904884934,
-0.2194051147,
-0.1292371452,
0.366447866,
-0.5665425658,
-0.3501664996,
-0.0538738631,
-0.3784227967,
-0.4491813779,
0.4049675763,
-0.4357937872,
-0.1779536307,
-0.1607841551,
0.4118468463,
-0.287507534,
-0.5396785736,
0.1278034449,
-0.1225704774,
0.1109326258,
0.2182990462,
-0.5752928257,
0.2359647155,
1.0597294569,
1.2497000694,
-0.2213582546,
-0.2537364662,
-0.4367159605,
0.4103460014,
-0.0723831132,
0.8447199464,
-0.4838915467,
-0.4646210074,
-0.2725416422,
0.1318149418,
0.1542336792,
-0.551776886,
0.2304026037,
-0.6055322289,
0.425177604,
-0.3412627876,
-0.332521677,
0.0014077568,
0.460899502,
-0.8252305984,
0.9457162619,
0.0323674791,
-1.053766489,
0.5948194861,
-0.6840094328,
-0.4028080404,
0.0244338214,
-0.2881309092,
-0.769744277,
0.0925384536,
0.5228201151,
0.2729254365,
0.0791217238,
0.1935049146,
-0.6013675332,
-0.5140493512,
-0.1682194024,
-0.0110115455,
0.5281144381,
0.0278199185,
-0.5778042078,
-0.195073247,
-0.5142129064,
0.0744557753,
0.0216059033,
0.1019278839,
-0.5174322724,
-0.1589139551,
-0.4090524018,
0.053593725,
0.0513827167,
-0.808916688,
0.2066581547,
-0.1384884268,
0.3283215165,
0.7587054968,
0.4505389929,
0.2051244378,
-0.362835288,
0.5521790385,
0.3516125083,
0.1930985898,
0.1384745985,
-0.510966301,
-0.3879105151,
-0.1041732281,
0.0959388539,
0.602960825,
-0.9532103539,
0.6112262011,
-0.4882056713,
-0.4769096076,
-0.3707126975,
0.4291454554,
0.3516636789,
0.2850016952,
0.322714299,
-0.6799877882,
-0.7101188898,
-0.8929814696,
-0.4155045748,
-0.2001086622,
-0.2034870833,
-0.0058246325,
0.5102801323,
-0.0358496755,
0.8710324764,
-0.7030330896,
-0.3092043996,
0.1281301677,
0.4121303856,
0.1399625987,
0.8379289508,
0.6422595978,
-0.784024775,
-0.8066092134,
0.0642132983,
-0.9273286462,
-0.0896928459,
0.0985766724,
-0.1177262515,
0.1452283859,
0.5319161415,
-0.4682358503,
0.3981451988,
0.1688538939,
0.2798459828,
0.1701486409,
0.1024600193,
0.4090524018,
-1.3485119343,
0.0659144968,
0.1500110477,
-0.2853520215,
-0.1858095527,
-0.1307169497,
-0.1362665892,
-0.1762084514,
-0.255420357,
0.4422199428,
-0.4994195402,
-0.2280288637,
-0.2586828172,
0.3940393329,
-0.2306691855,
0.5419917107,
-0.0139337564,
0.7613121271,
0.3808722198,
-0.1721117347,
0.3913786113,
-0.0845898315,
-0.1961508542,
0.8270517588,
-0.94267416,
0.462654084,
-0.1089083999,
0.3915560544,
-0.9582203031,
0.223943159,
0.4342459142,
-0.6521919966,
0.1566462666,
-0.4381565452,
-0.9100589752,
-0.4825705588,
-0.7588185072,
0.6469875574,
0.1808453351,
-0.4710677266,
0.2143077403,
0.4788609147,
-0.433478117,
-0.3968575895,
-0.5991389751,
-0.2364049107,
-0.2403288484,
-0.5813918114,
0.2917476296,
0.0811829865,
0.2089851946,
0.2209935337,
-0.3660481572,
-0.1573444903,
0.0185728241,
0.1990752667,
-0.0429672636,
-0.4292321205,
0.2119727135,
-0.0786679611,
-0.534447968,
-0.1929818988,
-0.8782712221,
0.4585753679,
-0.3014457822,
-0.6559348702,
-0.6401511431,
0.5382806063,
0.4323542714,
-0.0131650781,
0.6113411784,
0.7950631976,
-0.4975170493,
0.0131113417,
-0.8359292746,
-0.0859052762,
-0.5130267143,
0.3987866044,
-0.360653758,
-1.2129245996,
0.3805369437,
0.3079121411,
-0.0790497065,
0.4004700184,
0.197751686,
-0.0854819193,
1.231449008,
0.6207609177,
-0.2714539766,
0.5698266625,
-0.1849454492,
0.3970611095,
-0.5964070559,
-0.0901526287,
-0.4050524533,
-0.4243647754,
-0.9465806484,
-0.311119467,
0.4740126431,
0.0962784514,
-0.2695561647,
0.6595676541,
-0.6746103168,
0.7900257111,
0.5909219384,
0.215759933,
0.4948191345,
0.4224241972,
-0.0616772659,
-0.1315989345,
-0.3285202682,
-0.4677450359,
1.1391582489,
-0.0003364275,
0.506067276,
0.1735147387,
0.9406368732,
0.3164749444,
0.3849688172,
-0.1143959388,
0.5535131693,
-0.1475035697,
-0.0043122056,
-0.0121424375,
-0.824146986,
-0.7747391462,
-0.0112486733,
0.3438256085,
-0.6147280931,
-0.1699326038,
0.2651693821,
-0.2673793137,
0.7999147773,
-0.7511372566,
0.861045897,
-0.107749708,
-0.1285805702,
-0.2941888273,
-0.2426406592,
0.4402053356,
-0.2568277419,
-0.2641283274,
0.2876354158,
-0.2233905941,
0.6733962297,
-0.6357497573,
0.6582299471,
-0.2685794532,
-0.2023629397,
0.1892589033,
0.0932834968,
0.540912509,
0.3295036554,
0.1217068061,
0.0234233532,
-0.067685172,
-0.4985944927,
-0.821187675,
1.1183427572,
-0.7663198709,
-0.5864731669,
-0.2303579897,
0.1752361506,
-0.1787345111,
0.0277758539,
0.3002572656,
0.4010443091,
0.0150155192,
0.1928704828,
0.2767763138,
-0.0085257106,
0.0881044045,
0.5708159804,
-0.1280712783,
-0.6699323654,
1.0990812778,
0.0293961298,
-0.0312964171,
0.4124473929,
-0.2617965043,
-0.3061177731,
-0.5656324029,
-0.0896589458,
0.4855027795,
-0.5195649862,
-0.2194443196,
-0.9161663651,
-0.2559251189,
-0.3005704284,
-0.1930762827,
-0.3009324372,
-0.6283994317,
-0.3094349802,
-0.2495415658,
0.4621457756,
0.9193118215,
-0.2546616495,
0.2273531258,
-0.7848986387,
0.3463030159,
0.3586513996,
0.786102891,
0.0732430294,
-0.2032750696,
0.0352340639,
0.0829509944,
-0.6179479361,
-0.7150942683,
0.0155289834,
-0.0636821911,
0.6411010623,
0.1394005269,
-0.3014902174,
0.7718240023,
-0.0322105177,
0.4814503789,
0.0813651755,
-0.7914744616,
1.0054819584,
-0.2725030482,
0.1515018493,
0.6913473606,
0.690541327,
-0.5015535951,
-0.568100214,
-0.879789114,
-0.5713319182,
0.4960855544,
0.338332504,
-0.0749689341,
-0.2679265141,
0.2189089209,
0.1438858509,
0.3295557201,
-0.6751918793,
0.0442940257,
-0.1594775915,
0.0044758902,
0.1700306833,
-0.0878995582,
0.1198103279,
-0.0732371509,
0.5533896685,
-0.0202542115,
0.3161992431,
-0.0850977898,
-0.3416133821,
0.1092062071,
-0.0390456468,
0.6642733812,
0.600328207,
-0.1540652514,
0.1195252985,
0.1284956187,
-0.4648981988,
0.0311818291,
0.2355014682,
-0.0943288282,
0.373703301,
0.2765539289,
0.4651594162,
-0.0555118099,
-0.0003330699,
0.7005504966,
-0.0145703563,
-0.0894683748,
-0.3345142901,
-0.2260581404,
-0.3072524071,
0.1219625026,
0.1921763271,
0.1036496162,
-0.1312722117,
-0.4833630919,
0.6366090775,
0.330432266,
-0.2924395204,
-0.5071271658,
0.2858174741,
0.4246901274,
-0.3558036685,
0.6135084629,
-0.6624017954,
-0.8596166968,
0.6042897105,
0.1389550567,
1.0764983892,
0.1115073785,
0.3623023629,
0.6697045565,
0.3475799561,
-0.176470235,
0.4275820851,
-0.3831592202,
-0.5477615595,
-0.1639479101,
-0.2541513741,
-0.1710413247,
0.1633541137,
-0.5616990924,
0.3999403119,
-0.5834779739,
-0.0962766558,
-0.3442372978,
0.0343369059,
-0.6335702538,
-0.4262648523,
-0.2157902122,
0.5218715072,
-0.8071414828,
0.5053558946,
0.5428873897,
-0.4600461125,
-0.5344218612,
0.0057693152,
0.3528258801,
-0.7360848784,
0.5834331512,
0.3282364905,
0.1220039129,
-0.0598297305,
-0.3705932796,
-0.7468923926,
1.0662162304,
0.0116495779,
-0.4580140114,
-0.0008918592,
0.178000316,
0.5174882412,
-0.2550440133,
0.3833524585,
0.1865127832,
0.223271817,
0.190972805,
-1.1116788387,
0.2033904195,
-0.5676118731,
0.1218360662,
0.5790683031,
-0.3753627539,
0.6103443503,
0.005845597,
-0.4111569226,
0.1733213961,
0.3830975592,
0.4988322556,
0.0715314373,
0.680446744,
0.8291357756,
0.5590802431,
-0.0547676384,
0.760309577,
-0.3177910745,
0.6821281314,
1.155393362,
-0.3620613217,
0.7453998327,
0.1825982928,
-0.0148342717,
0.5241072178,
0.4288723767,
-0.4160662293,
0.4993686378,
0.2465616316,
-0.2148220539,
-0.0964142531,
0.0154954707,
-0.8793339729,
0.2467156649,
0.1634229869,
-0.4816344082,
-0.5365614891,
-0.0209644195,
0.1066852957,
-0.1160622984,
-0.0926469415,
0.8330129385,
-0.0896979272,
-0.6452732682,
0.5833705664,
-0.1452744007,
0.8379225731,
-0.3472836614,
-0.1238365173,
-0.4238021374,
0.2580132186,
0.0080661085,
-1.0224423409,
0.507933259,
0.1504335701,
0.0694233403,
-0.5205651522,
0.5192001462,
-0.3954827785,
-0.558799088,
0.1944062114,
0.480676055,
0.0290995929,
-0.2061785758,
-0.508467257,
0.0503618233,
-0.0499883667,
0.1969666928,
0.0047982424,
0.5440826416,
-0.0964478552,
0.4936281145,
0.5598446131,
0.2466993928,
-0.1157997921,
0.0314264186,
0.8939490914,
-0.7416591048,
-0.6916980743,
-0.7070567012,
0.137147218,
-0.4799202085,
-0.3825983107,
0.606081605,
0.8706744909,
1.1601134539,
0.066083163,
0.826975584,
0.1383534521,
0.5901587605,
-0.4957666695,
0.4712769687,
-0.6233866215,
0.5702695847,
-0.3639234304,
-0.9883522391,
-0.3282022774,
0.4500320256,
-0.2129362077,
0.4537171721,
0.8548436761,
1.2991939783,
-0.3612376451,
0.348669529,
-0.176256597,
0.1495394111,
0.3277008832,
0.8171482682,
0.9267861843,
-0.3801194727,
0.804299891,
-0.2996776998,
-0.0481839105,
0.0188943036,
-0.8802958727,
-0.7658286691,
-0.5595980883,
-0.652369976,
-0.2488220632,
0.2285438478,
0.5530958176,
0.537107408,
-0.8010988235,
0.0182746556,
-0.2156667709,
0.2079900205,
-0.0239618532,
-0.2388012409,
0.2547058165,
-0.0701146275,
-0.2474542707,
-0.1130456552,
0.4472474456,
0.2273542136,
-0.1281143278,
0.3582539856,
0.0252632741,
-0.6790246964,
0.4617673755,
0.4545655251,
-0.6206489205,
-0.6419555545,
-0.0468471237,
-0.1777460277,
0.065406397,
1.1658182144,
-0.7999891043,
0.1648693532,
0.6605443954,
0.4161920547,
0.5801782012,
0.0163081884,
0.6280665994,
-1.1808184385,
-0.0373053178,
0.1763524264,
0.3893782198,
0.4225439429,
0.0661247522,
0.6272139549,
0.7003843784,
-0.2988396287,
-0.7487054467,
-0.024554655,
-0.9219764471,
0.1014893278,
1.0104629993,
-0.0365549512,
0.3086158335,
-0.2147384733,
-0.053605862,
0.1336092949,
-0.2503003776,
0.9025892615,
0.5475999713,
0.2722500861,
-0.322989583,
-0.413213402,
0.2749612033,
0.168293789,
-0.6909130812,
-0.3589861691,
0.103410393,
0.4467124641,
0.2760381401,
0.7412257195,
-0.2199893892,
0.5415042639,
-0.2653401196,
-0.3727877438,
-0.0898943543,
-0.0785206035,
-0.1940597892,
0.3584193289,
-0.2939383388,
-0.5009541512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15033v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15033v1
|
Sparsity-Guided Holistic Explanation for LLMs with Interpretable Inference-Time Intervention
| 2023-12-22T19:55:58 | 2023-12-22T19:55:58 |
Zhen Tan, Tianlong Chen, Zhenyu Zhang, Huan Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved unprecedented breakthroughs in
various natural language processing domains. However, the enigmatic
``black-box'' nature of LLMs remains a significant challenge for
interpretability, hampering transparent and accountable applications. While
past approaches, such as attention visualization, pivotal subnetwork
extraction, and concept-based analyses, offer some insight, they often focus on
either local or global explanations within a single dimension, occasionally
falling short in providing comprehensive clarity. In response, we propose a
novel methodology anchored in sparsity-guided techniques, aiming to provide a
holistic interpretation of LLMs. Our framework, termed SparseCBM, innovatively
integrates sparsity to elucidate three intertwined layers of interpretation:
input, subnetwork, and concept levels. In addition, the newly introduced
dimension of interpretable inference-time intervention facilitates dynamic
adjustments to the model during deployment. Through rigorous empirical
evaluations on real-world datasets, we demonstrate that SparseCBM delivers a
profound understanding of LLM behaviors, setting it apart in both interpreting
and ameliorating model inaccuracies. Codes are provided in supplements.
|
[
-0.261814028,
-1.3544975519,
0.5196536183,
0.5029586554,
-0.3779944479,
0.0901582316,
-0.2741201818,
-0.2324670106,
0.3704253137,
0.574655056,
-0.8480215669,
-0.5227393508,
-0.713026166,
-0.028084863,
-0.3782380223,
1.0298172235,
-0.013412321,
-0.1891820282,
-0.0801337287,
-0.0864387751,
-0.6134789586,
-0.268889308,
-0.4691590965,
-0.3389406204,
0.6283698678,
0.2284779698,
0.867881,
0.8605012894,
0.2011514604,
0.1927538365,
-0.5529078245,
0.3447116613,
-0.698720336,
-0.1029880866,
-0.0957895666,
-0.0951718837,
-0.5305640697,
-0.077736184,
0.8372886181,
1.2285300493,
-0.2356794477,
0.1614174545,
0.6886453032,
0.3768677711,
-0.5412133932,
0.1836369932,
-0.606888473,
0.0295962039,
-0.0620668046,
-0.5002324581,
-0.3637056649,
-0.0770940185,
0.1217645854,
-0.7193000317,
0.4176514447,
-0.0328450762,
0.6771501899,
0.5795660615,
-0.3691359758,
-0.2758120894,
-0.7618536949,
0.7341010571,
-0.657767415,
0.3175534308,
0.2027334273,
0.0346368514,
-0.4347136021,
-0.3977820277,
-0.4359044731,
-0.1056262553,
-0.1297973543,
-0.061838571,
-0.3021399677,
0.0316592455,
0.1925111562,
0.2041772008,
-0.780086875,
0.1542484462,
0.0830664635,
-0.0927368701,
0.2993676662,
0.2532944679,
0.0246277452,
-0.1174397394,
-0.4390298128,
0.5844497681,
-0.5728204846,
-0.1880505234,
0.085170351,
0.3662039638,
-0.364286691,
0.5317664146,
-0.0779616758,
0.7382923365,
0.0995284915,
0.0970789567,
-0.2136971802,
-0.2809869647,
-0.3245180547,
0.0563472286,
0.4806932211,
-0.0773819461,
0.1823363155,
-0.4036029279,
-0.0781119764,
0.015885964,
0.1759815514,
-0.6708050966,
0.2146556675,
0.3197349608,
-0.5742580891,
-0.2969460487,
-0.2432954609,
-0.8101934791,
-0.5621857047,
-0.3139532208,
0.1522389501,
-0.1274364293,
-0.495585084,
0.3990721107,
0.1549413949,
0.1687066853,
0.3288256228,
-0.8406139016,
0.5974172354,
0.9055168629,
1.1704239845,
-0.3869650364,
-0.2277429104,
-0.7155415416,
0.4464443028,
-0.2461630851,
0.9350355268,
-0.5976881385,
-0.24033539,
-0.0938777998,
-0.022681484,
0.0307387058,
-0.4636114836,
0.1946948469,
-0.4557849169,
-0.2289432585,
-0.0090264613,
-0.3392172456,
-0.0536968894,
0.2596158087,
-0.571308732,
1.2428286076,
0.0177029874,
-0.6041698456,
0.3235467374,
-0.5589579344,
-0.3669522405,
0.256016165,
0.0548203327,
-0.2778599858,
0.4432937801,
0.1966275573,
0.8373684287,
-0.0888834745,
0.6106751561,
-0.6218147278,
-0.584697485,
0.4391504526,
-0.6808750629,
0.581802845,
0.1104272977,
-0.3313893676,
-0.0183204692,
-0.7584833503,
-0.278072238,
0.2142785192,
-0.0912103206,
-0.3325775266,
0.1024389267,
0.0249516517,
-0.0368467122,
0.2521213293,
-0.240644604,
0.0309824124,
-0.6557645798,
0.4861809015,
0.7695301175,
0.1734904647,
0.488322854,
0.1248404458,
0.5690869093,
-0.0662483275,
0.265345633,
0.0830351189,
-0.3320837021,
-0.443716675,
-0.5428957939,
0.0592151396,
0.2719869614,
-0.480938077,
0.3912830651,
-0.4286706746,
-0.0217900109,
-0.36207515,
0.3725676239,
0.3124372363,
0.2422691584,
0.3484856486,
-0.2736379802,
-0.3241201639,
-0.8254876137,
-0.3300448954,
0.0984174386,
0.2173707783,
0.1251458377,
0.4602320492,
-0.46701774,
0.8964775205,
-0.4648002684,
-0.1229736134,
-0.6012083292,
0.3978433609,
0.2535656691,
0.3559180796,
0.1130550206,
-0.4956033528,
-0.216247797,
0.007646984,
-0.4367594421,
-0.3738072515,
-0.5153000951,
-0.2935885191,
-0.0226372015,
0.336750567,
-0.6370974779,
0.594635129,
0.4467816055,
-0.2934830189,
0.4720161259,
-0.0489698276,
-0.3708665669,
-0.9548396468,
0.0489474498,
0.231894806,
-0.2416878194,
-0.6527100801,
-0.1172542199,
-0.0891681537,
0.0502038971,
-0.1640845835,
0.8598875403,
-0.7266511321,
-0.4396691024,
-0.3078230917,
0.4775690436,
0.1527103782,
0.6551303864,
0.0591160096,
0.4655703306,
0.1267348379,
-0.4821126461,
0.0088487556,
0.1560868472,
-0.2462795079,
0.4034526348,
-0.7211219072,
-0.1195536107,
-0.23519665,
0.1978941262,
-1.0324898958,
-0.2222692668,
0.3533627391,
-0.4128925204,
0.4134644568,
-0.3643237948,
-0.5457692742,
0.0611537769,
-0.1712823808,
0.4544796348,
0.1026466712,
-0.4939377606,
0.6158385873,
0.3007380068,
-0.2358454317,
-0.7915217876,
-0.6717944741,
0.1593303978,
-0.2160529643,
-0.2979452014,
0.1636688113,
-0.0379604883,
-0.4014603794,
0.1950518638,
-0.4097034037,
-0.1356875449,
0.6684041023,
0.2890949547,
0.3895000219,
-0.1814811677,
-0.1427692324,
0.2747014761,
-0.272469908,
0.1212257743,
-0.123486273,
0.298096776,
-0.0287271366,
-0.4286904931,
-0.4122831821,
0.3698846102,
0.3546790779,
-0.1208229885,
0.8967720866,
0.6024866104,
-0.5274419188,
-0.5509748459,
-0.632781744,
-0.0108275674,
-0.3919935226,
0.343735218,
-0.1239722595,
-1.0550435781,
0.3888784349,
-0.10717199,
-0.0187072437,
0.0081676636,
0.7144924998,
0.0470962711,
1.1382390261,
0.7287912965,
-0.022963142,
0.4753235281,
-0.1695108563,
0.3344925046,
-0.8354622126,
-0.4326935709,
-0.3846023083,
-0.0906083062,
-0.115575403,
-0.5958986878,
0.2905883193,
0.0717998147,
0.0206763968,
-0.024164997,
-0.3452271521,
0.4573085308,
-0.0918532982,
0.0606803745,
0.3022512197,
0.0761863142,
-0.0887205824,
-0.0582881607,
-0.8180105686,
-0.6873241663,
0.5412474871,
0.5802081227,
0.9169453382,
0.0607823618,
0.4006322026,
0.3933504224,
0.4983318448,
-0.973403573,
0.4100344777,
0.1391802728,
-0.4855235219,
-0.3458667397,
-0.4965128601,
-1.250479579,
0.5139551163,
-0.2735255659,
-0.7897513509,
0.124866046,
0.3466235697,
-0.4214095771,
0.0499851443,
-0.7170149684,
1.0488443375,
-0.3055154085,
-0.6705902219,
-0.3268162906,
-0.4518631101,
0.5452769399,
0.000843049,
0.5812964439,
-0.1757115722,
-0.1971001923,
0.3805708587,
-0.2546968162,
1.276283741,
-0.1093442366,
-0.256954819,
-0.0148813911,
0.2973031402,
0.5361434221,
0.1332503557,
0.1389761269,
0.4378982782,
0.0043109888,
-0.655592382,
-0.7653960586,
0.7688135505,
-0.4508106112,
-0.4961090684,
-0.3716697097,
-0.8949277997,
-0.38620314,
0.0420548655,
-0.3246210217,
0.6598068476,
-0.3267407417,
0.0541303456,
0.994636476,
-0.3431489468,
0.0610799529,
0.6298311949,
8.782e-7,
-0.1483184099,
0.8377380371,
0.0614794381,
0.228016302,
0.4667530954,
0.11407502,
-0.4478470385,
-0.8597437143,
-0.1982557923,
0.582912147,
-0.531222403,
0.0724026561,
-0.6570228338,
0.094691731,
-0.4261735082,
-0.199582085,
-0.0509997346,
-0.2478463352,
-0.5405752659,
-0.0125884954,
-0.0316520222,
0.9217268825,
0.0199040398,
0.4579675794,
-0.7448718548,
0.5232338905,
0.0062370179,
0.5444232821,
0.3100468218,
-0.6806858778,
-0.724832654,
0.0628321394,
-0.0412085727,
-0.8518698215,
0.4980743825,
0.0216956902,
0.7627719641,
0.3658485115,
-0.2947771847,
1.1145712137,
-0.44043082,
0.6816314459,
-0.0566291437,
-1.1143070459,
0.5108444691,
-0.1078367233,
0.3147203028,
0.0190271512,
0.1507112086,
-0.5062227249,
-0.4337605238,
-0.4886732697,
-0.8155062199,
0.6070241928,
0.0647886619,
-0.0591721535,
-0.0576820672,
0.6251990199,
0.2582255006,
0.0331045948,
-0.8083806038,
0.0012134889,
-0.0919754133,
-0.3142376244,
-0.2124760449,
-0.6712892652,
-0.0336184129,
0.2519659996,
0.6466496587,
-0.3189586997,
0.1579302251,
0.0965528637,
-0.5825671554,
-0.2194965929,
0.4713543057,
0.4754257202,
0.5511162877,
-0.0458513647,
0.3264608979,
0.2455604523,
-0.3107416928,
-0.0809706077,
0.1064348817,
-0.0011173326,
0.01417269,
0.8302909732,
0.6634824276,
0.5155993104,
-0.6057924032,
0.481020242,
-0.0114932228,
-0.0810363963,
-0.0106741106,
-0.1526727676,
0.0191981941,
0.3744737804,
0.2367910296,
-0.2081147134,
0.1951074749,
-0.4056923091,
-0.1548872143,
0.8340677023,
-0.3340206146,
-0.400536418,
0.6314694881,
-0.0559071414,
0.0624444969,
0.0251653716,
0.0751943961,
-0.1454377323,
0.512871325,
0.4691380262,
0.8566024899,
0.0261422787,
0.3836760819,
0.0324224234,
0.5870657563,
-0.1409039646,
0.0437093116,
-0.3498475254,
-0.6818151474,
-0.9158583879,
-0.6373121738,
-0.3901251554,
0.275935024,
-1.0153114796,
-0.1513260454,
-0.3883723021,
0.1814626604,
0.0523757711,
-0.055562105,
-0.3781022429,
-0.0333059058,
0.1747787595,
0.943898797,
-0.8779907227,
0.6595013738,
0.4874536097,
-0.0815728232,
-0.6195126176,
0.2870090604,
0.1118204072,
-1.0132917166,
0.4614653289,
0.0261329953,
-0.4805141687,
-0.0329468176,
-0.7392499447,
-0.8135062456,
0.8850200176,
0.4577281177,
-0.3984723687,
0.1517977864,
0.1679798514,
0.6714810729,
-0.1720851809,
-0.0040765512,
0.7810585499,
0.35074386,
-0.0611567087,
-0.4884541631,
0.2113323212,
-0.118545562,
0.2746642828,
0.1632456779,
-0.3816925585,
0.1625288576,
-0.0701591223,
-0.3759090602,
0.1131467521,
0.7332439423,
0.2139149904,
0.4065996408,
0.4217154086,
0.2804217637,
0.6162826419,
0.001923273,
0.844858408,
-0.2551917732,
0.3735108674,
0.9624135494,
-0.4016167521,
0.6094077826,
0.6703172922,
0.0597681254,
0.37599051,
0.6544498205,
0.3291863799,
0.4199555218,
0.1382487267,
-0.2365787178,
-0.4486410916,
-0.4207272232,
-0.0324982516,
0.0787286311,
0.8391109705,
0.0515021831,
-0.3035025001,
-0.0107978825,
-0.0600081049,
0.0257779602,
-0.3794861436,
0.709420383,
0.1187587008,
-0.5474387407,
0.6787667274,
-0.1170658544,
0.4069370627,
-0.6045618057,
-0.2625227869,
-0.3774178028,
0.1068455055,
-0.2829225659,
-0.773455143,
0.4370486438,
0.2342304438,
-0.1540174931,
-0.571184814,
0.7081893682,
-0.4369535446,
-0.2794231176,
0.3162852228,
0.6512979269,
0.2447665334,
0.0647542179,
-0.8541116118,
0.3408254385,
-0.2511977553,
-0.2523446083,
0.3958328366,
0.8970705867,
-0.0661726221,
0.8244806528,
0.572245121,
0.3492970169,
-0.0531450883,
0.1464411914,
0.8225553632,
-0.5772855878,
-0.3076925278,
-0.8964221478,
0.4024830759,
0.1604305357,
-0.1017580852,
0.7110499144,
0.4117625654,
0.4910520613,
0.2164889872,
0.6821490526,
0.3261625767,
0.5740020871,
-0.6983141899,
0.2425075471,
-0.6850543618,
0.7200245261,
-0.25662902,
-0.6656540036,
-0.4870359302,
0.6715936065,
-0.3375954628,
-0.2133672982,
0.6661218405,
1.0325170755,
-0.1743760258,
-0.2013809085,
0.4108725786,
0.6409061551,
0.0006609331,
0.3231759071,
1.1233836412,
0.1719676703,
0.6169937253,
-0.0319704711,
-0.4165826738,
-0.2477787584,
-0.8933186531,
-0.9896447659,
-0.1971985251,
-0.2478641272,
-0.4354963899,
0.1178720817,
0.8914568424,
0.5269024968,
-0.650405705,
-0.1898817867,
-0.0396040864,
0.4280714393,
-0.4297696054,
-0.2696095407,
0.2156747729,
-0.2412283719,
-0.5362582207,
0.4545844793,
0.6295099258,
0.0052281558,
-0.565007627,
-0.122688286,
-0.0050360262,
0.2496212423,
0.6556937099,
0.116341047,
-1.0060474873,
-0.1485396773,
-0.1085154563,
0.0943282321,
-0.1050586924,
1.0154697895,
-0.550366044,
0.2169807702,
0.0629965514,
0.7562245131,
0.437040478,
0.0068650017,
0.3717983663,
-0.8900439739,
0.1259433478,
0.1176529974,
0.4162055552,
0.1855867356,
-0.5960490108,
0.4711984396,
0.3640733063,
-0.2988245785,
-1.1297411919,
0.1656235009,
-1.2850629091,
-0.4261903763,
1.4666577578,
-0.1543514729,
-0.2511979342,
-0.6078996658,
-0.1581601501,
0.2819584012,
-0.2780198753,
0.7667163014,
0.6641820073,
0.0768682733,
-0.2897455394,
-0.6664674878,
0.1055733114,
0.5642866492,
-0.8519371748,
0.4011761844,
0.7363956571,
0.2229781449,
-0.2580262125,
0.4968829155,
0.0234275945,
0.0985828787,
-0.174380064,
-0.085166879,
-0.0656072423,
-0.2712872624,
-0.8538109064,
0.1303919107,
0.0377589166,
0.1649015248
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15021v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15021v1
|
Towards a Unified Multimodal Reasoning Framework
| 2023-12-22T19:07:00 | 2023-12-22T19:07:00 |
Abhinav Arun, Dipendra Singh Mal, Mehul Soni, Tomohiro Sawada
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in deep learning have led to the development of powerful
language models (LMs) that excel in various tasks. Despite these achievements,
there is still room for improvement, particularly in enhancing reasoning
abilities and incorporating multimodal data. This report investigates the
potential impact of combining Chain-of-Thought (CoT) reasoning and Visual
Question Answering (VQA) techniques to improve LM's accuracy in solving
multiple-choice questions. By employing TextVQA and ScienceQA datasets, we
assessed the effectiveness of three text embedding methods and three visual
embedding approaches. Our experiments aimed to fill the gap in current research
by investigating the combined impact of CoT and VQA, contributing to the
understanding of how these techniques can improve the reasoning capabilities of
state-of-the-art models like GPT-4. Results from our experiments demonstrated
the potential of these approaches in enhancing LM's reasoning and
question-answering capabilities, providing insights for further research and
development in the field, and paving the way for more accurate and reliable AI
systems that can handle complex reasoning tasks across multiple modalities.
|
[
-0.5899732113,
-0.9393126965,
1.0588265657,
-0.1228771359,
-0.1530426592,
0.4249290228,
-0.2365637124,
-0.3348524272,
-0.2013284415,
0.4898166358,
-0.3478310108,
-0.409288168,
-0.3909207582,
0.0230804458,
-0.129866451,
0.4364456832,
-0.3617666066,
0.3316572905,
-0.533693254,
-0.4215682745,
-0.7528374791,
-0.7276021838,
-0.2194118649,
-0.0736916438,
0.5614324212,
0.2590007186,
0.8394519091,
0.0943285525,
0.4896511137,
0.3353209496,
0.090342775,
0.7323122025,
-0.0006855181,
0.2160875946,
-0.4197907746,
-0.4183518291,
-0.2423963398,
-0.139658317,
0.5819731951,
0.366874367,
-0.0072750482,
-0.1035047099,
-0.1179257482,
0.2946101129,
-0.8941252232,
-0.04692287,
-0.5006176233,
-0.0598610789,
0.2904836237,
-0.259352237,
-0.4708268642,
-0.1447705179,
0.2448965013,
-0.3910799325,
-0.1564282924,
-0.0143640162,
0.694922626,
0.3307549059,
-0.7062179446,
-0.2861733735,
-0.6922680736,
0.8867475986,
-0.5961650014,
0.6099549532,
0.1389683932,
0.2495502234,
-0.097611405,
-0.7683371902,
-0.7972097993,
-0.0810223445,
0.0523614846,
0.2147054523,
-0.1201949194,
0.1626661122,
0.2509555817,
0.2766244113,
-0.5306580067,
-0.2992580235,
-0.3435424566,
-0.1936372966,
0.4091612697,
0.1170814633,
0.4743472636,
-0.139098227,
-0.5843324065,
-0.2539436519,
-0.3520174921,
0.1629046798,
-0.0596352369,
0.1918077618,
0.1846714318,
0.6481627226,
-0.2453131229,
0.7195684314,
-0.3448207676,
-0.0588805787,
0.242871061,
-0.8864130378,
-0.3752446175,
-0.3874080777,
0.7522101998,
0.3440163136,
0.1457704306,
0.0593323074,
0.0013537281,
0.2891172171,
0.301120162,
-0.3143429756,
-0.1585555822,
0.3771278262,
-0.1842870563,
-0.0982631296,
-0.0464206003,
-0.6764655709,
-0.3186196089,
-0.5132458806,
0.6980085373,
-0.5828495622,
-0.4366253316,
0.2756180167,
-0.3397823572,
0.3115699887,
0.6202303171,
-0.5226411223,
-0.0274109021,
0.3166919947,
0.5104965568,
0.0477473326,
-0.2711521983,
-0.4100415409,
0.1803801954,
-0.336222291,
0.8981300592,
-0.7432643175,
-0.0598733388,
-0.0930802599,
-0.2783023417,
-0.2679697573,
-0.2107277513,
0.4468418062,
-0.4524798691,
0.3022490442,
-0.6724587679,
-0.3495346308,
-0.3495784104,
0.5254775882,
-0.7847898602,
0.9288319945,
-0.1844129413,
-0.6062507033,
0.3949691355,
-0.4970361292,
-0.1299114823,
-0.1163498536,
-0.6421384811,
-0.1209468767,
-0.0092840092,
0.8352428079,
0.5183988214,
-0.3155730069,
0.3903093934,
-0.3540630937,
-0.1858809143,
0.5492105484,
-0.8132147789,
0.5747620463,
0.1534552425,
-0.5140598416,
0.1024656966,
-0.5208565593,
0.5234978795,
0.0174584556,
-0.247418344,
-0.1897259057,
-0.1086178571,
-0.0420571826,
0.5316483974,
-0.0784021318,
-0.3888479471,
0.2510418892,
0.1549840122,
0.4495057464,
0.6619508862,
-0.2013607323,
0.4116097093,
-0.1912345737,
0.5309693217,
0.2895408273,
0.1253519803,
-0.151719451,
-0.7059972882,
-0.6640450358,
-0.2800916433,
0.2468844801,
0.4045585692,
-1.4567751884,
-0.2826590538,
-0.00047165,
-0.3266978562,
-0.5579348803,
0.1029729545,
0.5418567061,
0.290658623,
0.654532373,
-0.1953505874,
-0.426951319,
-0.7322500348,
-0.3090803921,
-0.1407744735,
0.3496463001,
0.2822322249,
0.6250787377,
-0.264662087,
0.9027830362,
-0.3120420277,
0.2425077558,
-0.3298833072,
0.1550201625,
-0.1558335871,
0.3100737929,
0.3898827732,
-1.1598575115,
-0.0361209884,
-0.0664503947,
-0.8756730556,
0.3688504398,
-0.2783356905,
-0.1543233544,
0.1440442652,
0.3593851626,
-0.6841873527,
0.5497022867,
0.4657742083,
-0.3439734578,
0.6858644485,
-0.2513518631,
0.6100196242,
-0.8535644412,
-0.310564965,
-0.0112012355,
-0.0673822686,
-0.6506512165,
0.1661510915,
0.2441426069,
0.0315415859,
-0.6248141527,
0.4652714431,
-0.454900831,
0.024795983,
0.0576713532,
0.3311225772,
0.335370332,
0.605406642,
0.060562849,
0.9115327597,
0.5941762328,
-0.563343823,
0.4258208871,
0.1968088597,
-0.3446350396,
0.4346193075,
-0.508259356,
0.2023465484,
-0.3039652407,
0.2743538022,
-1.2991842031,
-0.1957223564,
0.1740443707,
-0.3657539487,
-0.0139914919,
0.2526389658,
-0.588919878,
-0.3723908067,
-0.3447910249,
0.6461061835,
0.0573524795,
-0.7701022625,
0.927533567,
0.117357336,
0.1216332614,
-0.8917610645,
-0.7705340385,
0.1027010903,
-0.0767207369,
-0.6883393526,
0.2670480609,
-0.043899253,
-0.2392936349,
-0.0315469578,
-0.1498642415,
-0.2401043177,
-0.2002025545,
-0.0900793895,
0.3882835209,
-0.2598668039,
0.522105217,
0.0816360787,
0.0483764112,
-0.1706314534,
-0.2132460922,
0.5322377682,
-0.7099606395,
-0.4456884861,
-0.3665800691,
0.4713746309,
0.7807081342,
-0.6529752612,
0.6913174987,
0.7519368529,
-0.1773099601,
-0.1632302105,
-0.6873613596,
0.0438535661,
-0.4473250806,
0.2003946155,
-0.6607477665,
-1.0182199478,
0.2465439141,
-0.2172938138,
-0.1664827168,
0.2115009576,
0.602996707,
-0.3336445391,
1.264291048,
0.3748356402,
0.3907745481,
0.2885985374,
-0.4110682905,
0.2828111053,
-0.9020434022,
-0.5152766109,
-0.0872041062,
-0.0830334127,
-0.495665133,
-0.9375395775,
0.4042125046,
0.1542594582,
-0.195965305,
0.1933790743,
-0.4544413984,
0.3998661637,
0.6288926601,
0.3376798332,
0.4383605421,
-0.0677155703,
-0.6009996533,
0.303901881,
-0.9028473496,
-0.6048300862,
1.0986423492,
0.1551081985,
0.720349133,
0.2490295321,
0.2752595246,
-0.0152032562,
-0.0630497262,
-0.3973132968,
0.4808796942,
0.1059214175,
-0.6859010458,
-0.4265480936,
-0.3570942581,
-0.5797103643,
0.802461803,
-0.4028226435,
-0.6523385644,
0.2911916971,
0.1711796373,
-0.374679625,
0.5041131377,
-0.8282421827,
0.8428021073,
-0.671264708,
-0.503495872,
-0.2081890255,
-0.5628517866,
0.3363310695,
0.2693199217,
0.3170378506,
0.1079290435,
-0.0127430875,
0.4662429392,
-0.106602557,
0.6594729424,
0.0934096649,
-0.2105827332,
0.5459984541,
-0.2224113792,
0.1656616628,
0.0634715036,
0.1265339553,
0.0951644853,
0.2156967521,
-0.5302996039,
-0.9932412505,
0.597207129,
-0.6657533646,
-0.6380068064,
-0.4401556849,
-0.7161311507,
-0.5066089034,
-0.0352962613,
-0.0458410233,
0.8101983666,
0.0586561337,
0.3063963652,
0.7466006875,
-0.3500623405,
0.4926529527,
-0.1557332128,
-0.3415845037,
-0.7314125299,
0.7272137403,
0.0187293235,
0.6280493736,
0.3440796435,
0.034494441,
-0.5605983138,
-0.2519978881,
-0.688608706,
0.1100298464,
-1.052696228,
-0.035250023,
-0.8046119809,
0.0000700688,
-0.2448125333,
-0.102588065,
-0.2749833167,
-0.3615509868,
0.0759489983,
-0.0947724655,
0.1884075552,
0.6287243962,
0.1012296528,
-0.011278037,
-0.5754837394,
0.4885585606,
0.6710609198,
0.3538509905,
0.0590180866,
0.1255529672,
-0.0021057259,
0.4428642392,
-0.3567291498,
-0.7570909262,
-0.048418723,
-0.2298346013,
0.7673361897,
0.0063490099,
-0.2215161622,
0.8363021016,
-0.2303344607,
0.8447610736,
0.4786016941,
-0.9210953116,
0.5840892196,
-0.2316266745,
0.4776914418,
0.5580633879,
0.3854913414,
-0.2050901502,
-0.2249727845,
-0.4228366315,
-0.5808163285,
0.2278827131,
0.4410498738,
-0.1070342809,
0.0323329717,
-0.0033324806,
0.0525382832,
0.2124145627,
-0.5641006231,
-0.0465414785,
-0.2562040687,
-0.0811969861,
0.0173504353,
0.0571033768,
0.1016887128,
-0.6592566371,
0.3138003051,
-0.323127687,
0.3846694827,
0.3287956417,
-0.2461276948,
0.2797448635,
0.5615145564,
0.606133163,
0.9312309027,
0.0583904944,
0.3762179315,
0.4263490438,
-0.1785064936,
0.1975012571,
-0.3441385925,
0.2174433619,
-0.0116982386,
0.4209707081,
0.8073014617,
0.139810428,
-0.9125320315,
0.4947739244,
-0.3191076517,
-0.3116962612,
-0.0672621205,
0.0921966434,
0.1496398449,
0.5214247108,
0.210598141,
0.3156459332,
0.0413623638,
-0.9254921675,
0.2353244871,
0.4691100121,
-0.4105353355,
0.1377428919,
0.5603932738,
0.0543771796,
0.0024698277,
0.5073212385,
0.284966886,
-0.6093065739,
0.6674770713,
0.3505041897,
0.478661567,
-0.0860625133,
0.5314455628,
0.0638626888,
0.3502314985,
-0.0500967689,
0.7032059431,
-0.2559174895,
-0.9642280936,
-0.677272737,
-0.1476683915,
-0.5377039313,
0.0021903818,
-0.4969554245,
0.1426145285,
-0.3086516559,
-0.3417619467,
0.026453957,
-0.2736240625,
-1.0101078749,
0.4699855745,
0.3638584018,
0.5624389648,
-0.6269856095,
0.6820988059,
0.7912605405,
-0.7997427583,
-0.9182465076,
0.0110960612,
-0.1184064746,
-0.606412828,
0.5087239146,
0.189092502,
-0.5118745565,
-0.2711042166,
-0.6917310953,
-1.0542978048,
1.2781553268,
0.3005275726,
-0.4089047015,
0.0459808894,
0.2204155326,
0.4943470657,
-0.4307903647,
0.617718637,
0.4988090098,
0.4446566403,
0.2065975666,
-1.0206781626,
0.0280143283,
-0.3170492947,
0.0661574304,
0.1434395462,
-0.5509445667,
0.9093329906,
-0.4170656502,
-0.0680293217,
-0.103368111,
0.5394006968,
0.5122713447,
0.3183264732,
0.4172014892,
0.5983438492,
0.9779315591,
-0.1021764874,
1.1476117373,
0.1676351279,
0.2993738651,
0.9699169993,
-0.1692547649,
0.8175418377,
0.6725369692,
0.0199056938,
0.7551140189,
0.2900217772,
0.2024781555,
0.528237164,
0.0230524298,
-0.2625010014,
-0.6017010212,
-0.0970338657,
-0.4416150451,
0.6029461622,
0.4104077518,
-0.1885989904,
-0.1463289112,
0.4272907078,
-0.1489165425,
0.1143413484,
-0.2410250157,
0.5600537062,
0.0597638972,
-0.6371551752,
0.6361898184,
-0.2137853354,
0.5825041533,
-0.1253761053,
-0.2885191739,
0.1084694788,
0.1564674973,
-0.0377274789,
-0.9887754917,
-0.1605298519,
-0.0696399957,
-0.0680114999,
-0.3144784272,
0.7413125038,
-0.5432592034,
-0.5197663903,
0.3557780683,
0.9767221808,
-0.1812133342,
-0.0264388062,
-0.7080485225,
0.2566090226,
-0.0738083273,
-0.0887382925,
0.0486366563,
0.4707061648,
-0.1722431779,
0.8751851916,
0.6643362641,
-0.3082200289,
0.1004127413,
0.2124916613,
1.154410243,
-0.7328180671,
-0.2531016469,
-0.82371068,
0.8328862786,
-0.2910639644,
-0.4349822402,
0.5881202817,
0.2558119893,
0.9619905353,
-0.0828972161,
0.9986737967,
0.0206327885,
0.0528896041,
-0.7521569133,
0.3306056559,
-0.7094492316,
0.1714743376,
-0.6367830634,
-0.7367734909,
-0.3473190069,
0.4834747314,
-0.4951859415,
0.2051766664,
1.1448677778,
0.6769770384,
0.0133477468,
0.3013443649,
0.4085068405,
-0.1062212735,
0.4014039338,
0.6788606048,
1.2241482735,
-0.5585470796,
0.6311731935,
-0.335452646,
-0.1027311459,
0.1335556507,
-0.6348423362,
-1.0703383684,
-0.7778706551,
-0.2362855226,
-0.0804381967,
0.1399280131,
0.8138665557,
0.530148983,
-0.6709679365,
0.1369773448,
0.0091431271,
0.1665513515,
-0.2749341428,
-0.1734108329,
0.4094091654,
-0.3178253174,
-0.4226109087,
0.384667933,
0.4675707817,
-0.2491514832,
-0.2316704839,
-0.1264208555,
-0.6705954671,
0.2188785523,
0.9917593598,
-0.2155779451,
-1.1582891941,
-0.5362744331,
0.2281413972,
-0.049698323,
0.0272996575,
0.8002314568,
-1.0094555616,
0.7836923003,
0.5611669421,
0.7364667654,
0.4590912461,
0.080556266,
0.6703651547,
-0.3957160413,
-0.1266925335,
0.2790831625,
0.4656004906,
0.2280172408,
-0.1707815081,
0.4427210689,
0.0775442868,
-0.3403061628,
-0.6357643008,
0.31061095,
-1.0517437458,
-0.5777509809,
1.1331300735,
0.0694383234,
-0.1106212586,
-0.2601453364,
-0.5511699319,
0.1836254001,
-0.1566730142,
0.3909654319,
0.8292887211,
-0.3663149178,
-0.641803503,
-0.6178590655,
0.2109243125,
0.5412477255,
-0.9852955937,
-0.3050687611,
0.5014853477,
-0.043282412,
0.2653134763,
0.4674006402,
-0.1181419566,
0.5763632655,
0.0723000243,
-0.0416059792,
-0.1041013077,
-0.6241480112,
-0.16584979,
0.3093165457,
-0.3224753737,
-0.1919757128
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14890v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14890v4
|
NPHardEval: Dynamic Benchmark on Reasoning Ability of Large Language Models via Complexity Classes
| 2023-12-22T18:07:44 | 2024-02-12T17:30:25 |
Lizhou Fan, Wenyue Hua, Lingyao Li, Haoyang Ling, Yongfeng Zhang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CC, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Complex reasoning ability is one of the most important features of current
LLMs, which has also been leveraged to play an integral role in complex
decision-making tasks. Therefore, the investigation into the reasoning
capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) is critical: numerous benchmarks
have been established to assess the reasoning abilities of LLMs. However,
current benchmarks are inadequate in offering a rigorous evaluation of the full
extent of reasoning abilities that LLMs are capable of achieving. They are also
prone to the risk of overfitting, as these benchmarks, being publicly
accessible and static, allow models to potentially tailor their responses to
specific benchmark metrics, thereby inflating their performance. Addressing
these limitations, our research introduces a new benchmark, named NPHardEval.
This benchmark is designed to evaluate the reasoning abilities of LLMs across a
broad spectrum of 900 algorithmic questions, extending up to the NP-Hard
complexity class. These questions are meticulously chosen to represent a wide
range of complexity class below the NP-hard complexity class, offering a
rigorous measure of the reasoning ability of LLMs. Through this study, we shed
light on the current state of reasoning in LLMs, providing an objective and
rigorous perspective through the comparison of LLMs' performance across complex
classes. Moreover, this benchmark is designed with a dynamic update mechanism,
where the datapoints are refreshed on a monthly basis. Such regular updates
play a crucial role in mitigating the risk of LLMs overfitting to the
benchmark, promoting a more accurate and reliable assessment of their reasoning
capabilities. The benchmark dataset and code of NPHardEval are available at
https://github.com/casmlab/NPHardEval.
|
[
-0.2451018542,
-0.7892947793,
0.6201412082,
0.2449555695,
-0.170269236,
0.4539837837,
-0.4410300851,
-0.4628196061,
-0.3954696357,
0.2990096211,
-0.2790505588,
-0.5059064627,
-0.4092766643,
0.0298589654,
-0.3494598269,
0.6049999595,
-0.2949725389,
-0.0121972058,
-0.5880773067,
-0.1908728778,
-0.3527236283,
-0.416896075,
-0.2495093197,
-0.3568719029,
0.1975572258,
0.1404689997,
0.4868828058,
0.4736538827,
0.4850193858,
0.3923592269,
-0.3262276947,
0.1695088744,
-0.3305371106,
0.7343710065,
-0.3479001522,
-0.6642174721,
-0.581530571,
-0.2216038257,
0.9264928699,
0.8272719979,
-0.1809744984,
0.29852283,
-0.0963740051,
0.7849100828,
-0.7692731619,
0.2967031598,
-0.8248708248,
-0.1116302386,
-0.3862824142,
-0.1541507542,
-0.3049086034,
-0.5855228901,
0.1515413821,
-0.3314741552,
0.0219892245,
0.0552517511,
0.4179872572,
0.5494714975,
-0.2590581477,
-0.2495742887,
-0.6436034441,
0.8401219249,
-0.6101183891,
0.3833183646,
0.1365016848,
0.6673809886,
-0.3379170299,
-0.550063014,
-0.4144563377,
-0.7035855055,
0.3837030232,
-0.1868896037,
-0.1898751408,
-0.1739029586,
0.614767015,
0.426486969,
-0.4263889492,
-0.0683254451,
-0.0185599662,
0.0060811848,
0.6483131051,
0.2946978509,
-0.0755556598,
-0.0943187475,
-0.1687542945,
0.0863625556,
-0.7440627217,
-0.0788875669,
0.3923273385,
-0.0655071959,
0.0425929502,
0.3978984058,
-0.5265267491,
0.7498193383,
-0.0890989527,
-0.0528100356,
0.3657550514,
-0.0996131077,
-0.0446887016,
0.1333063543,
0.3955518901,
0.0281298161,
0.5358321667,
-0.0110101169,
-0.1276489794,
-0.0444036126,
0.1409164518,
-0.8302741647,
-0.2104430497,
0.2399971783,
-0.3467892706,
-0.2010453045,
-0.2953562737,
-0.7523083687,
-0.6029001474,
-0.2939470708,
-0.0023123121,
-0.3027432561,
-0.4706695974,
0.2322345227,
0.1792391092,
0.1137144938,
0.6551573873,
-0.3365650475,
0.2823756635,
0.9144089222,
0.7398574352,
-0.2567946315,
-0.27401492,
-0.551213026,
0.0113810664,
-0.3525499403,
0.9186026454,
-0.5798153281,
0.0433897153,
0.1157486066,
-0.267449528,
0.0301408991,
-0.7551083565,
0.5758239031,
-0.6382244229,
-0.3272123039,
-0.3125414848,
-0.5871320963,
-0.1398211271,
0.7298202515,
-0.4535552859,
1.0554991961,
0.1007108912,
-0.5728729963,
0.1669457704,
-0.3701459169,
-0.3717738092,
0.4180950522,
-0.3415431678,
-0.3769025505,
0.1324428916,
-0.1609136909,
0.3580947518,
-0.7928647995,
0.5859791636,
-0.6808595657,
-0.3526335359,
0.5671620369,
-0.7400773764,
0.6399603486,
0.0189130865,
-0.5264087319,
0.1893560737,
-0.9292562008,
0.2636951208,
0.1021123007,
-0.4141688347,
-0.1410948932,
0.3425576985,
-0.3566117287,
0.2733989358,
0.3183886409,
-0.3657734692,
0.33959499,
-0.3039100766,
0.5223071575,
0.9345449209,
-0.2461837232,
0.1513838321,
-0.2872561514,
0.6016093493,
-0.4128014445,
0.1045770645,
0.0601624846,
-0.3080299497,
-0.7095258832,
-0.2560512125,
0.487718612,
0.6512579322,
-0.573679328,
0.1855906993,
-0.221244365,
-0.7522618771,
-0.4097256064,
0.2914325893,
0.4614362419,
0.3353160322,
0.3090913594,
-0.013192419,
-0.2776996791,
-0.7000735402,
-0.4098815918,
-0.2603897452,
-0.0167065393,
0.4016103446,
0.568015933,
0.1244877055,
0.5893413424,
-0.5232577324,
0.1406877637,
-0.3466909826,
0.0600846559,
0.3473852873,
0.3793408275,
0.4262117445,
-0.6962215304,
-0.3881912231,
-0.1556194127,
-0.8766570687,
-0.3859087229,
-0.1810221523,
-0.2057018727,
0.2394981831,
0.738945961,
-0.5844026208,
0.2685548067,
0.3702811897,
-0.1561146826,
0.8821790814,
-0.1808138043,
-0.0184715502,
-0.4318116307,
0.1268978864,
-0.0362665951,
-0.1090416163,
-0.4644699395,
0.185355261,
0.034749683,
0.1803526729,
-0.4601359963,
0.658393085,
-0.5818219781,
-0.1227066368,
-0.2073841691,
0.0181347951,
-0.2836583555,
0.4075413942,
0.0652983338,
0.5491933823,
0.7202801704,
-0.3958978951,
0.6609347463,
-0.0688910186,
-0.6656460762,
0.8530112505,
-0.8453837633,
-0.0338952579,
0.0757407099,
0.3385343254,
-0.7811923623,
-0.0677242205,
0.1608741581,
-0.2868316174,
0.3934271038,
-0.3348344862,
-0.7265526056,
-0.2010230422,
-0.1944123805,
0.5789031386,
0.2334767431,
-0.4316947758,
0.7826309204,
0.2163745761,
-0.0983003825,
-0.3354526162,
-0.3659629822,
0.0802229419,
-0.1062757596,
-0.6569152474,
0.334400177,
-0.4154686332,
-0.5442467928,
-0.0557091907,
-0.2702031732,
-0.0446843281,
0.2186636031,
0.3098300099,
0.3213563263,
-0.2473256886,
0.1276630461,
0.0775095448,
-0.3030070364,
0.2999198735,
-0.1051808298,
0.7302893996,
-0.5979713798,
-0.6830794215,
-0.2307637781,
0.0796240568,
0.7290100455,
-0.3535883427,
0.6956284642,
0.2652041614,
-0.3354720771,
-0.2656520903,
-0.8001614809,
0.1335585862,
-0.5128968358,
0.4027917683,
-0.5434583426,
-0.772223115,
0.4403659999,
-0.3919320703,
-0.0574154258,
0.3760190904,
0.7815933824,
0.1218277737,
1.0916743279,
-0.0924577191,
0.1134966761,
0.1250970066,
-0.1394083798,
-0.0658780336,
-0.9719209075,
-0.5484219193,
-0.529073298,
-0.266972363,
-0.8204168677,
-0.64355129,
0.1932130009,
0.1158498004,
-0.6278858781,
-0.0148268985,
-0.3659085333,
0.4830775261,
0.5073352456,
-0.1618923992,
0.3022136688,
-0.3599927425,
-0.0136835845,
0.0838665143,
-0.5016167164,
-0.4428130686,
0.98212111,
0.3308949769,
0.6111403108,
0.279446125,
0.3179935515,
0.214667663,
0.2786826193,
-0.5732486248,
0.9544228315,
0.0294971801,
-0.6225261092,
-0.0228107683,
-0.7032662034,
-0.618463695,
0.3219684958,
-0.2936710715,
-0.4306305945,
0.0920875221,
0.1567875445,
-0.0674100742,
0.4684122503,
-0.2868369222,
0.7056441903,
-0.5531542897,
-0.6581805348,
-0.3091659248,
-0.5661643744,
0.3271149695,
-0.1002413481,
-0.1002227366,
-0.4894108772,
-0.0378527641,
0.4956870675,
-0.295700103,
0.6040650606,
-0.1404391527,
0.0783471093,
0.0745456144,
0.3207357228,
0.4782429039,
0.2876797616,
-0.4272785485,
0.4316297174,
-0.0597452186,
-0.479642123,
-0.4929245114,
0.9086101055,
-0.5585905313,
-0.6952366829,
-0.8825255036,
-0.6136303544,
-0.3894787729,
0.2721372247,
-0.1853537709,
0.5425329804,
0.1076167524,
0.3436967432,
0.8857401013,
-0.3983394802,
0.0596634224,
0.5786787271,
0.0656597689,
-0.2343873829,
0.8827869892,
0.2332677245,
0.3751865029,
0.3293668926,
0.2627662122,
-0.2704339027,
-1.0243625641,
-0.4292345345,
0.2611952722,
-0.7298386097,
-0.2526965439,
-0.4754413962,
-0.2861239314,
-0.2085362226,
-0.1346265227,
-0.4136869013,
-0.4116035998,
-0.0978761017,
0.2085848451,
0.1918153763,
0.3582696319,
0.1350658536,
-0.2527821064,
-0.3941420317,
0.2912842035,
0.3184199333,
0.5279572606,
0.2192166299,
-0.4466788471,
0.2533039749,
-0.2223301381,
-0.2371504009,
-0.6474483013,
0.0695585087,
0.0120879002,
0.8806421757,
0.2458818257,
0.2539818585,
0.5115728378,
-0.5449655652,
0.3785001338,
-0.0420008637,
-1.0472975969,
0.5370752215,
-0.3678888381,
0.5277702212,
0.759583652,
0.3509179056,
-0.3363210559,
-0.3999785483,
-0.5314512253,
-0.8285711408,
0.4464737177,
0.0794610158,
-0.1242932081,
0.0240081903,
0.4540075064,
-0.1546947807,
0.4799415469,
-0.3307389021,
-0.1627497524,
-0.0985681489,
-0.0782317594,
0.2431813031,
-0.4265503883,
0.1514133513,
-0.5250900984,
0.6275175214,
-0.0657415465,
0.0270276275,
-0.2412285954,
-0.131666258,
0.0765004084,
0.2899489403,
0.7131320238,
0.9360511303,
-0.4239462912,
0.2744037807,
0.5130134225,
-0.2840682864,
-0.0038858601,
0.2638387084,
0.0486342646,
-0.3452050984,
0.6187843084,
0.521146059,
0.2845813632,
-1.0891422033,
0.4711796343,
-0.082733497,
-0.2843822241,
-0.5051873326,
0.2909849882,
0.0687821433,
0.5498399138,
0.2706671357,
0.143194139,
-0.0228271671,
-0.5576725602,
-0.019303795,
0.3826187551,
-0.1865118146,
-0.23039262,
0.5036216974,
0.1223576143,
-0.3320765495,
0.8541244864,
-0.4337454438,
-0.8785420656,
0.5298827887,
0.3599812984,
0.6328747272,
-0.274502784,
0.0774405822,
0.3471582234,
0.2884891331,
-0.133375749,
0.3481372595,
-0.1257954389,
-0.3988308311,
-0.6328290105,
-0.6798598766,
-0.5937273502,
0.0643930659,
-0.4502831399,
0.0271851402,
-0.6408025622,
0.1923096031,
-0.1408152729,
0.3274080455,
-0.4409976602,
-0.0092623597,
0.0234325137,
1.054479003,
-0.6282757521,
0.6677841544,
0.4934952855,
-0.0420275293,
-0.3941988945,
-0.0653709248,
0.2615379095,
-0.7135635018,
0.7767324448,
0.1394249797,
-0.1422153264,
-0.3719740212,
-0.448466599,
-0.7330178618,
0.8575881124,
0.6482940316,
-0.6241627336,
0.200328052,
0.2560806274,
0.6247477531,
-0.1831843853,
0.315397352,
0.6159171462,
0.6465488076,
0.4098839462,
-0.7224257588,
0.2299675047,
-0.5261955857,
-0.214330405,
0.4433534443,
-0.4873096347,
0.9295250177,
0.0026999516,
0.1678700298,
0.0307675116,
0.6708712578,
0.6491597891,
0.3844162524,
0.5982337594,
0.4830585122,
0.8353697658,
-0.1935207248,
0.9821754694,
-0.21996741,
0.074242644,
1.2391434908,
-0.5987206697,
1.0025490522,
0.1361292601,
-0.2439595312,
0.6247693896,
0.3836967647,
-0.1653522104,
0.2656839192,
0.817550838,
-0.4084328115,
-0.714841485,
-0.0282969419,
-0.4285764992,
0.399186492,
0.2910494208,
0.0037574477,
-0.1951673031,
-0.2764355242,
-0.0057482352,
0.218038395,
-0.2863776982,
0.4149114788,
-0.0439754091,
-0.6269282699,
0.7049381733,
-0.0212867446,
0.466391623,
-0.414781034,
-0.1248518154,
-0.019459473,
0.388119638,
-0.0788352713,
-0.9315783978,
0.2852777839,
0.1491203606,
-0.1440655589,
-0.1706538051,
0.7126929164,
-0.1633090675,
-0.6032323837,
0.1547732204,
0.3359092772,
0.1222002059,
-0.2212035805,
-0.9977744818,
0.3795946836,
-0.2765224278,
-0.1714066863,
0.4469735026,
0.40632689,
-0.187897414,
0.9956395626,
0.7936479449,
0.4411595166,
0.004239433,
0.1151274294,
0.8653104901,
-0.4732265174,
-0.1989573836,
-0.9332530499,
0.1611749232,
-0.3350190222,
-0.3836547434,
0.7732458115,
0.5159181356,
0.7610502839,
0.4282779396,
0.5176376104,
0.0609303266,
0.5219697952,
-0.4015360177,
0.546135962,
-0.5088330507,
0.545430541,
-0.3076029718,
-0.8294295669,
-0.3768485785,
0.7576542497,
-0.6726911068,
0.1148150414,
0.5424425602,
0.649603188,
0.0111206695,
0.1339272559,
0.072400786,
0.3836910129,
0.5729421377,
0.6652939916,
1.1806703806,
0.0433437712,
0.4355547428,
-0.1798783988,
-0.3326826394,
-0.3167127967,
-1.2570770979,
-1.0086054802,
-0.3713202775,
-0.5809160471,
-0.394641459,
0.1429693699,
0.9050359726,
0.5222293139,
-0.6217727661,
-0.1841864735,
-0.165476054,
0.3004913032,
-0.3272964358,
-0.1969102919,
0.4945313334,
-0.0558842495,
-0.4502000511,
0.345666647,
0.3193054199,
-0.3938370645,
-0.5083224773,
-0.1262355,
-0.2966455221,
0.1440409124,
0.6207951903,
0.3155130148,
-0.4846615195,
-0.0944174603,
-0.0888283923,
0.1910125911,
-0.077627562,
0.7187675238,
-0.6814554334,
0.3783249557,
0.7711080909,
0.762571156,
0.5175275803,
-0.3091481924,
0.152561143,
-0.3212988079,
-0.1095328405,
0.4875722826,
0.2773790061,
0.2828963995,
0.0739379227,
0.3959443867,
0.1741008013,
-0.6785865426,
-1.3120758533,
0.2545520365,
-1.0792101622,
-0.4128348529,
1.2391432524,
-0.0945579931,
-0.2681033015,
-0.3056728244,
0.0380275957,
0.0415562429,
-0.3206943274,
0.7008672953,
0.6181434393,
-0.1237377226,
-0.1015001833,
-0.8577420115,
0.355876714,
0.4138793945,
-1.0879745483,
0.3197404444,
0.5302408338,
0.3220743537,
0.0409451686,
0.4347159266,
-0.0643544197,
0.4294946492,
-0.2403495461,
-0.3494755328,
-0.2825381458,
-0.4247463346,
-0.1208084524,
0.5072069168,
0.2311694026,
0.2948273122
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14877v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14877v2
|
Robust Knowledge Extraction from Large Language Models using Social Choice Theory
| 2023-12-22T17:57:29 | 2024-02-08T17:29:54 |
Nico Potyka, Yuqicheng Zhu, Yunjie He, Evgeny Kharlamov, Steffen Staab
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large-language models (LLMs) can support a wide range of applications like
conversational agents, creative writing or general query answering. However,
they are ill-suited for query answering in high-stake domains like medicine
because they are typically not robust - even the same query can result in
different answers when prompted multiple times. In order to improve the
robustness of LLM queries, we propose using ranking queries repeatedly and to
aggregate the queries using methods from social choice theory. We study ranking
queries in diagnostic settings like medical and fault diagnosis and discuss how
the Partial Borda Choice function from the literature can be applied to merge
multiple query results. We discuss some additional interesting properties in
our setting and evaluate the robustness of our approach empirically.
|
[
-0.1746876687,
-0.9968400598,
0.9764451385,
0.0006360412,
-0.1068537831,
0.3355340064,
-0.4220180213,
-0.5317184329,
0.2564229369,
0.5339623094,
0.038569957,
-0.5542726517,
-1.0026271343,
-0.0386331491,
-0.3118605912,
0.7102136016,
0.3458743095,
0.2765114009,
-0.5011736155,
-0.2972201407,
-0.1355420947,
-0.5681918263,
-1.1221052408,
-0.2339310646,
0.6269384027,
0.386567831,
0.9137116671,
0.3099221587,
0.6843284965,
0.2842682004,
-0.30514732,
0.5406970382,
-0.6058541536,
0.5452929139,
-0.3627807796,
-0.4388408363,
-0.4901145697,
-0.2065964192,
0.7788344026,
1.1343479156,
-0.08940126,
0.0575080216,
0.2073622048,
0.5532951951,
-0.4643393457,
0.0523607358,
-0.6403494477,
-0.3492527604,
0.0381697863,
-0.1039522439,
-0.3797135055,
-0.7542735934,
0.2890253961,
-0.1960439384,
-0.0351967104,
0.0313388221,
0.8514892459,
0.1352897733,
-0.4918607175,
-0.155877158,
-0.68624264,
0.7918041945,
-0.5501720905,
0.2772396505,
0.775385499,
0.4950659871,
-0.1697873026,
-0.5896452665,
-0.1857957542,
-0.2408687919,
0.0810008124,
0.0766236559,
0.0448259227,
-0.0838002041,
0.1315431446,
0.3480251431,
-0.567478478,
0.2926254272,
-0.450109005,
-0.2188042402,
0.8351983428,
0.1210176423,
0.3972365558,
-0.1585121453,
-0.1195902452,
0.1458723247,
-0.9257308841,
0.1478944421,
0.0661285818,
0.2793134153,
0.1245360002,
0.6049657464,
-0.1492958367,
1.0745270252,
-0.085654147,
-0.4679041803,
-0.1487299204,
-0.3039920628,
-0.0819218457,
-0.1867483854,
0.8995692134,
0.2589381635,
0.275538981,
-0.2865895927,
-0.0587101281,
-0.053999532,
0.1243063807,
-0.3932622075,
-0.1170840785,
0.3796302676,
-0.6119632721,
-0.6597281098,
-0.1396380216,
-0.8956631422,
-0.5492972136,
-0.0306494925,
0.1743596047,
-0.4484877884,
-0.2356389314,
0.1805325747,
-0.0827492252,
0.191645056,
0.1652786881,
-0.7834773064,
0.3100150228,
0.5797936916,
0.8129648566,
-0.3299790323,
-0.0619837791,
-0.9131850004,
0.322234422,
-0.3106195629,
0.9226119518,
-0.644644022,
-0.5823742151,
0.0897691473,
0.0727828518,
-0.1007988229,
-0.7270512581,
0.3705752492,
-0.6211504936,
0.0483704992,
-0.5540733933,
-0.4029536843,
0.2154408246,
0.2484351248,
-0.5480431914,
1.0739449263,
0.132712245,
-0.6528022289,
0.3848893344,
-0.3647893071,
-0.7452200651,
0.0896691605,
-0.0968918502,
-0.1393967867,
0.0291064996,
0.27772066,
0.5838955641,
-0.5348448753,
0.5080695748,
-0.7970608473,
-0.0252077095,
0.3604736924,
-0.2368598878,
1.0155866146,
0.2999601364,
0.0126341293,
-0.0611842759,
-0.5922060013,
0.0005969455,
0.2063412964,
-0.4439941645,
-0.7285791039,
0.2445888221,
-0.5824100375,
0.0490839444,
0.4475842118,
-0.3354696929,
0.38863644,
-0.4606521726,
0.3007694483,
0.5992483497,
0.1511132568,
0.3955281377,
-0.529892087,
0.4998543859,
-0.1308598071,
0.1001249701,
0.4972082973,
-0.7640221119,
-0.4869144261,
-0.3443353474,
0.3288865983,
0.5440036058,
-0.9242667556,
0.3841077983,
-0.3186925948,
-0.4241518676,
-0.4269059002,
0.2742240727,
0.1261483431,
0.5098641515,
0.1670829058,
-0.0621201396,
-0.2232120037,
-0.7233129144,
-0.4153960347,
-0.3990466893,
-0.0454793759,
0.4823185503,
0.0406081825,
-0.0877218395,
0.7097180486,
-0.8606353998,
0.1025500223,
-0.478486985,
-0.1356529891,
0.3114217818,
0.0274941698,
0.5386530161,
-0.7371622324,
-0.3558765948,
0.2680234015,
-0.8402783275,
-0.1386325061,
0.4728516638,
-0.2528957129,
0.0764557272,
0.3953040242,
-0.6611391306,
0.2122031003,
0.4093139768,
-0.1912439018,
0.487968713,
-0.1069382802,
0.1411649585,
-1.4495635033,
-0.0959450975,
0.1394644976,
-0.5072159171,
-0.43236202,
0.1771452725,
-0.1503008157,
-0.0677825287,
-0.0599488392,
0.490354985,
-0.4142077267,
-0.183514148,
-0.1673259437,
0.300442487,
-0.0716359839,
-0.038453836,
-0.1588587314,
0.4175393879,
0.7915121913,
-0.6689149141,
0.4691784382,
0.0885206237,
-0.2722270787,
0.3407807648,
-0.647161901,
0.0551939011,
-0.1596628726,
-0.2411673665,
-1.1871900558,
-0.5391107202,
-0.1349894255,
-0.4616160095,
0.3899108768,
-0.2299127728,
-0.4657595456,
-0.2641095221,
-0.1630325913,
0.2188747078,
0.5320427418,
-0.4657546878,
0.3586107194,
0.8425504565,
-0.6707265377,
-0.47136724,
-0.2793717086,
-0.1678680331,
-0.3655994236,
-0.8269451261,
0.0144485235,
0.0785031691,
-0.5361598134,
-0.0887807682,
-0.0511066131,
-0.2166267484,
0.147208333,
0.0006163688,
0.4396572411,
-0.2233383954,
0.1215832382,
0.3068275154,
0.0440721959,
-0.0994364247,
-0.0755268484,
0.6681446433,
0.0242519062,
-0.5093932748,
0.1920630485,
0.6343665123,
0.9388878942,
-0.3649103642,
0.7560769916,
0.1922082156,
-0.5526720285,
-0.0403405987,
-0.6904578209,
-0.1716416627,
-0.4513365924,
0.17501688,
0.072923176,
-1.1416065693,
0.673935771,
-0.1371177435,
-0.014942064,
0.337118566,
0.7499818206,
-0.0877368301,
1.3806688786,
0.4226414263,
-0.3167855442,
0.3085431457,
0.0643938333,
0.2846389115,
-0.4112576842,
-0.1793558896,
-0.7176242471,
-0.0484295115,
-0.5365824699,
-0.1209882498,
0.7592258453,
0.065375343,
0.005152856,
-0.0322680548,
-0.4119003415,
0.2619571984,
0.4322784543,
0.4371559024,
0.4150890708,
0.1954415143,
-0.1834419966,
0.2686431706,
-0.7577630877,
-0.4160675108,
1.0685539246,
0.0147234946,
0.7936577797,
0.3172893226,
0.7863462567,
-0.0724391043,
0.2564768493,
-0.9011438489,
0.482917279,
-0.2830368876,
-0.6176204681,
-0.5241093636,
-0.5542401075,
-1.1444936991,
0.2566774786,
-0.2492615581,
-1.0636997223,
0.3544104099,
-0.0326540507,
-0.5864989161,
0.1248599812,
-0.6697015762,
0.5064613819,
-0.3871583939,
-0.5185981393,
0.0453171656,
-0.6883263588,
0.3980890214,
-0.0273622554,
0.240260303,
0.1164289713,
0.2717834413,
0.6772583127,
-0.2375531495,
0.7159952521,
0.0238589402,
-0.1000280529,
0.0377247594,
-0.0186422151,
0.4535385072,
0.2123584002,
-0.4021571577,
0.0855679512,
0.3453577757,
-0.4345107377,
-0.6256467104,
0.73017627,
-0.6107094884,
-0.7364273071,
-0.411247611,
-0.4550423622,
-0.6360123754,
0.3208859265,
0.4296805263,
0.5142897367,
0.1084360331,
0.2666061521,
0.7945010662,
-0.2978565693,
0.2943398952,
0.3538215458,
-0.3301429749,
-0.3827961981,
0.7561956644,
0.4505183995,
0.3898600042,
0.0713959336,
0.3528666198,
-0.3245776892,
-0.6630888581,
0.088697128,
0.399522543,
-0.5685848594,
-0.3205966651,
-0.6336001754,
-0.4331344366,
-0.7217670083,
-0.1124920249,
-0.1764755994,
-0.307492286,
-0.1238686889,
-0.3215107322,
0.2209017724,
0.6805615425,
-0.003503612,
0.0168540496,
-0.8948989511,
0.4980322719,
0.2736460567,
0.3983784318,
-0.0421470292,
-0.1679159254,
-0.2366138995,
-0.1065772772,
-0.2277954817,
-1.2731661797,
0.6451607347,
0.0143159898,
0.9363071322,
0.7048467994,
0.1993949115,
0.6171824336,
-0.1135496125,
0.812949121,
0.0644525588,
-0.3771562576,
0.7091520429,
-0.4280471802,
0.0596007481,
0.6627774835,
0.7476285696,
-0.2015018761,
-0.5984530449,
-0.5368930697,
-0.8781058788,
0.3120476007,
-0.1070099995,
-0.2694682479,
-0.140930891,
0.4832936525,
0.0857705474,
-0.1431865245,
-0.4365343153,
-0.204926461,
0.2674718201,
-0.2508841157,
-0.0230795909,
-0.5914221406,
-0.487254411,
-0.4982093871,
0.5589965582,
-0.1992367655,
0.238665849,
0.2518452406,
-0.0293400399,
-0.0694290102,
0.1732666939,
0.2010039836,
0.9634805918,
-0.0388860069,
0.2452200055,
0.0894704312,
-0.3178979158,
-0.0514178723,
0.2174052,
0.0429347865,
-0.1276015043,
0.3504478633,
0.1868995279,
0.1066261679,
-0.4619369507,
0.4353281856,
-0.0269713551,
-0.1440378428,
-0.0716888458,
0.0626005828,
0.1903551072,
0.3030202389,
0.2887817919,
-0.2176119834,
0.3112888932,
-0.5545158982,
0.1579242647,
0.7903639078,
-0.414693445,
-0.0926274657,
0.4907087386,
-0.010138087,
-0.3078820705,
0.4869304895,
-0.0142226396,
-0.4148223996,
0.5061361194,
0.6680769324,
0.4428166449,
-0.2378494591,
0.2651487589,
0.1154527292,
0.2060634196,
-0.362205565,
0.5798739791,
0.0503170229,
-0.8757202625,
-0.6304783225,
-0.7035242915,
-0.456389606,
0.2133914977,
-0.954854548,
0.255206883,
-0.2913998663,
-0.4321433902,
0.0903640091,
0.0127631035,
-0.3940539062,
0.0307061523,
-0.1226290017,
0.5939017534,
-0.7314171791,
0.8002135754,
1.0167784691,
-0.370829016,
-0.9461300373,
-0.0001249407,
-0.093080394,
-0.9378855824,
0.2481022775,
-0.2734332085,
-0.0467379056,
-0.238337785,
-0.9354181886,
-1.0541878939,
0.896055758,
0.6647903919,
-0.1459985524,
-0.1820686311,
-0.1977988333,
0.4903915524,
-0.3248658478,
-0.0767032132,
0.6452232003,
0.3645153046,
0.1950155348,
-0.9173092246,
0.1548791975,
-0.1662985831,
-0.3098433018,
0.1241833568,
-0.6462869048,
0.5104656816,
-0.3119078577,
0.052909106,
0.1835706532,
0.2242546976,
0.5459306836,
0.5248271823,
0.3226270676,
0.242734015,
1.2049311399,
-0.165128231,
1.4311032295,
-0.459094584,
0.3554592729,
0.6200199723,
-0.4688776731,
0.7018126249,
0.2363024801,
-0.1325937361,
0.2842829525,
0.8416486979,
0.3831920028,
0.5299994946,
-0.2038535625,
-0.2549196184,
-0.6861341596,
0.0960943922,
-0.4622964859,
0.5473695397,
0.5133984089,
-0.5447148085,
-0.0517594777,
-0.3102503419,
0.1453943402,
-0.3640049994,
-0.17194359,
1.0498631001,
0.3351995945,
-0.8309649825,
0.4471538365,
-0.3033399582,
0.2586736977,
-0.5504145622,
-0.0297071207,
-0.341991961,
-0.1854322553,
-0.250199765,
-0.5739770532,
0.2717269659,
-0.255079627,
-0.2357408851,
-0.023796808,
1.2258969545,
-0.2462209463,
-0.7401638031,
0.2907543778,
0.8579035401,
0.2611083686,
0.1389326751,
-0.2442541718,
-0.196584627,
-0.1617399305,
-0.1567983031,
0.618317008,
0.4714052975,
-0.1445302814,
0.7567225695,
0.8315424919,
0.5878617167,
-0.0446241945,
-0.0950940922,
1.0203233957,
-0.5968663096,
-0.3752701879,
-0.9140040278,
0.2465995699,
-0.4489522874,
0.0317010432,
0.5870671868,
0.2978958488,
0.2413616925,
0.3147244155,
1.015444994,
0.116568625,
0.5902772546,
-0.5229701996,
1.1009817123,
-0.7395771146,
0.4698001444,
-0.338232249,
-0.780761838,
-0.4332290888,
0.4570593834,
-0.5392537117,
0.0354086868,
0.6994324327,
0.7405310273,
0.1349982768,
-0.0722016022,
0.5396991968,
0.4310463965,
0.1920723915,
0.33615008,
0.8746973872,
0.2810380459,
0.4819564819,
0.0240021702,
-0.5237319469,
-0.249715969,
-0.7088406086,
-0.7658869624,
-0.3871165812,
-0.123788543,
-0.6517699957,
0.2288074046,
0.7351035476,
0.6700651646,
-0.7046961188,
-0.0611632578,
0.4987586141,
0.7733891606,
-0.3077689111,
-0.2306611687,
0.39274773,
-0.4178344905,
-0.5638782382,
0.6084157825,
0.4044048488,
-0.3960538208,
-0.1834117174,
0.2186155617,
-0.1389186084,
0.0501834676,
0.9362202883,
0.1605999619,
-0.3943299949,
-0.4128395021,
0.2459550947,
-0.0177778546,
0.0597990789,
0.6976984143,
-0.5623832941,
0.3507664502,
0.5530282259,
0.7533776164,
0.1901686788,
0.0900856033,
0.7228005528,
-0.437512368,
-0.4200998843,
0.1336959451,
0.6397069097,
0.355563283,
-0.5807312131,
0.479354769,
0.2670911849,
-0.7570890784,
-0.9949449301,
0.4050951004,
-1.1666481495,
-0.380009532,
1.7725480795,
0.0534984395,
-0.1283451617,
-0.5056112409,
-0.0563640781,
0.2491243184,
-0.3107767999,
0.8758068681,
0.7978666425,
-0.4659279585,
0.0165671986,
-0.5059285164,
0.2199103087,
0.2154052854,
-0.7814632654,
-0.2727135718,
0.5489320159,
0.622119844,
0.175593406,
0.8035571575,
-0.5224967599,
0.1335979849,
-0.3305397034,
-0.5258311033,
0.2653982639,
-0.1989139169,
-0.3064855635,
0.6882860065,
0.4800779819,
0.1224690899
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14870v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14870v1
|
Numerical Reasoning for Financial Reports
| 2023-12-22T17:46:36 | 2023-12-22T17:46:36 |
Abhinav Arun, Ashish Dhiman, Mehul Soni, Yibei Hu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Financial reports offer critical insights into a company's operations, yet
their extensive length typically spanning 30 40 pages poses challenges for
swift decision making in dynamic markets. To address this, we leveraged
finetuned Large Language Models (LLMs) to distill key indicators and
operational metrics from these reports basis questions from the user. We
devised a method to locate critical data, and leverage the FinQA dataset to
fine-tune both Llama-2 7B and T5 models for customized question answering. We
achieved results comparable to baseline on the final numerical answer, a
competitive accuracy in numerical reasoning and calculation.
|
[
-0.2208154052,
-0.6351522207,
0.7008388638,
0.4959999919,
-0.400156498,
0.4414819777,
-0.0106161786,
-0.7701215744,
-0.0548050702,
0.8661997318,
-0.5888126493,
-0.5123454928,
-0.371632427,
0.1984483749,
-0.3732902706,
1.191801548,
-0.0670268312,
0.0382879116,
-0.0065822629,
-0.1637784839,
-0.431465596,
-0.4573378563,
-0.7420538068,
-0.1823622435,
0.4244085252,
0.8204731941,
0.5589655042,
0.5650082231,
1.0155650377,
0.2412429154,
-0.178864941,
0.4452590942,
-0.4998364747,
-0.1316170841,
-0.1088856757,
-0.6330645084,
-0.5288086534,
-0.1663636565,
0.4106163979,
0.793848455,
-0.3941918612,
0.7521093488,
-0.2034739852,
0.8099910617,
-0.3789438903,
0.5595799088,
-0.4561061263,
-0.1282818019,
-0.2675484717,
-0.2367854714,
-0.4642183781,
-0.6451479793,
0.3441739082,
-0.6378230453,
-0.0374324769,
0.214930743,
0.8331804276,
0.3884767294,
-0.6743583679,
-0.5152329206,
-0.8590650558,
0.6659363508,
-0.6722584367,
0.1911024898,
0.5172838569,
0.3817268014,
0.1696322858,
-0.7709104419,
-0.0507931113,
-0.0647929609,
0.0151945027,
-0.0856749937,
-0.1944282055,
-0.0518638417,
0.442689091,
0.3028169572,
-0.2377467304,
0.2329712659,
-0.7263818979,
-0.0557741039,
0.9124850631,
0.5981394053,
-0.038641002,
0.0956772044,
-0.1360462159,
-0.1466916054,
-0.5244781971,
0.1670845151,
0.2269729823,
0.2815524936,
-0.3029150665,
0.6348580122,
-0.0943266228,
0.5364758968,
0.1443214566,
-0.4900983274,
0.097157836,
-0.2120501399,
-0.3651632667,
0.4508554935,
0.1557496041,
0.6879423857,
0.4836477637,
-0.0928207859,
-0.4688957036,
-0.0317065716,
0.1634156704,
-0.6803174019,
-0.0565144308,
0.2294807434,
-0.4096703529,
-0.4529014826,
-0.0525788143,
-0.6449759603,
-0.3862060606,
-0.4582300484,
0.0422294512,
-0.1284814775,
0.0591310821,
0.1906732172,
-0.2742303312,
0.1832768172,
0.4932921529,
-0.9303830862,
0.423427403,
0.7364531755,
0.4294153154,
0.2212198377,
0.3798301816,
-0.8000097275,
0.2402869165,
-0.654101789,
1.005146265,
-0.6142330766,
-0.1682164669,
-0.1561744809,
-0.1803855747,
0.1350516677,
-0.8819842339,
0.3581162095,
-0.7856416702,
-0.1175061092,
-0.5381574631,
-0.3841641247,
-0.6328344345,
0.1473365277,
-0.5514628887,
0.7469534278,
0.3969864845,
-0.636780262,
0.3815621436,
-0.5256763101,
-0.3629383147,
0.0279463306,
-0.0766600966,
-0.2315674573,
0.1880713403,
0.1991467327,
0.3207194507,
-0.912075758,
0.5086693168,
-0.2215631008,
-0.1525063366,
0.6263879538,
-0.4539222717,
0.2707573175,
0.3671589494,
-0.2080526799,
-0.0557268523,
-0.9471333027,
-0.123109065,
0.068348527,
-0.4563203156,
-0.3985221386,
0.0491958186,
-0.0354537368,
-0.2116274983,
0.4314490855,
-0.2475921512,
0.0988332555,
-0.3090831041,
0.4893174469,
0.6409518123,
0.1424041539,
0.178429693,
-0.3367575705,
0.6219403148,
0.0886823907,
0.1179105118,
-0.2510607839,
-0.131286636,
-0.5608233809,
-0.1607002467,
0.3921101987,
0.8069418669,
-0.3536634743,
-0.3157441616,
-0.110071525,
-0.4387946725,
-0.2011924237,
0.2685439289,
0.1833556294,
0.6785003543,
0.279789716,
0.0549804717,
-0.4201838076,
-1.0357270241,
-0.233057335,
-0.0694965422,
-0.0208894312,
0.3166772723,
0.4008481503,
0.051801268,
0.6199247241,
-1.0136448145,
0.1557877958,
-0.2789246142,
0.2513879538,
0.5594130754,
-0.0814961642,
0.6774769425,
-0.9645986557,
-0.2609432638,
0.0881858245,
-0.7617145777,
-0.2725974023,
-0.5904834867,
0.1917624027,
0.087618947,
0.6271398067,
-0.3430778086,
0.436737299,
0.2733009756,
-0.5095778704,
0.4166312218,
-0.2074203789,
0.0482658185,
-0.5818807483,
0.1166923344,
0.4689362049,
-0.1109615937,
-0.4522671998,
-0.2272033542,
-0.0285726525,
0.1061661467,
-0.1469146013,
0.3787482977,
-0.2555769682,
-0.4114418626,
0.0899209976,
0.1277550459,
0.1246720776,
0.3774016201,
-0.4601653218,
0.9747520089,
0.0470771529,
-0.7352096438,
0.338357836,
0.275809437,
-0.6793560386,
0.1823126525,
-0.8231635094,
-0.2439713329,
-0.1129235625,
0.0770994127,
-1.1833086014,
-0.3708279133,
0.0379500836,
-0.1712836325,
0.1627387404,
0.1114793941,
-0.4889912605,
-0.2926468849,
-0.0646245405,
0.4243536294,
0.2862524092,
-0.317347914,
0.7253696322,
0.4428896606,
-0.7135163546,
-0.482766062,
-0.8125242591,
-0.0098564988,
-0.4625967741,
-0.7854036093,
0.0271851309,
-0.039219223,
-0.9108639359,
-0.2625752687,
-0.334941566,
-0.2588314712,
0.2695519328,
0.018807441,
0.644097507,
-0.542724371,
0.0120559325,
0.1265826076,
-0.0167880468,
0.4204856455,
0.1802728474,
0.2780255973,
-0.3793121576,
0.0522015616,
-0.2063874602,
0.2817929089,
0.9931235909,
-0.3676424921,
0.6000711918,
-0.1040161327,
-0.247202158,
0.1025828123,
-0.8064153194,
0.1276775748,
-0.4996139109,
0.0881967321,
-0.0729095787,
-0.7994279861,
1.0719136,
-0.173613444,
0.2116754353,
0.8134068847,
0.4985633492,
0.033412464,
1.0422537327,
0.5694757104,
0.1911940277,
0.0962001607,
-0.1342460215,
0.1910644323,
-0.425608784,
-0.827878952,
-0.559605062,
-0.2429849505,
-0.1524032354,
-0.1899042875,
0.5129502416,
0.0622512661,
-0.41839692,
-0.1381844133,
-0.3686206639,
0.5040920973,
0.1128427684,
-0.0623581558,
0.3567514122,
0.0100447079,
-0.299387902,
-0.0538249128,
-0.4216066897,
-0.5803715587,
0.6986485124,
0.7212380171,
0.9423722029,
0.1824769378,
0.2751407027,
0.2541769147,
0.3573983908,
-0.7167183757,
0.4070325792,
-0.4752412736,
-0.5181415081,
-0.3471384048,
-0.6628956795,
-0.3127192855,
-0.117861852,
0.0168180168,
-0.5081515312,
0.0745937154,
-0.1007280052,
-0.8131002188,
0.132209003,
-0.8373596668,
0.4921829998,
-0.4771437347,
0.0082268659,
-0.2203380316,
-0.3971230984,
0.5145419836,
-0.4497742057,
0.6116979718,
-0.2312512696,
-0.2019228339,
0.8522891402,
-0.73695153,
1.0043091774,
0.0778728947,
-0.5446221232,
0.6622744203,
-0.0072723157,
0.3845958114,
0.2368890345,
-0.0229479335,
-0.0340108946,
0.1910647601,
-0.1010026708,
-0.6339869499,
0.335816592,
-0.4542698264,
-0.5104482174,
-0.4633683264,
-0.6550585032,
-0.2680406272,
-0.0812597349,
0.0287104808,
0.605525136,
0.1207761392,
0.2376702726,
0.480638206,
-0.2755002081,
0.3216840327,
0.7410797477,
-0.2266262174,
-0.4765126407,
0.6924856901,
0.4119529724,
0.0432062745,
0.4021890163,
0.2937046885,
-0.4368900955,
-0.4728043675,
-0.2990524471,
0.4721145034,
-0.7813862562,
-0.5034753084,
-0.274050504,
-0.3087722957,
0.0270353872,
-0.270599544,
-0.2400673032,
-0.5797768235,
-0.5561869144,
-0.233667627,
0.6938840151,
1.0448894501,
-0.078953132,
0.2341808677,
-1.3094927073,
0.5514528155,
0.2268079519,
0.5286613107,
0.3478898406,
-0.6631336808,
-0.4145206809,
0.1094800904,
-0.0627307594,
-0.6175966263,
0.4014216661,
-0.1742623001,
0.4134189487,
0.4350753427,
0.0819571987,
0.6949577332,
-0.27477476,
0.5583675504,
0.3662104309,
-0.8221216202,
0.4052213132,
-0.5935750008,
0.2520331442,
0.5323790908,
0.5436016321,
-0.3038541079,
-0.1694739163,
-0.5185240507,
-0.8647612333,
0.5774000883,
-0.0769082084,
-0.138871029,
0.0255237743,
0.8036258817,
0.0042370036,
0.2110662162,
0.018617332,
-0.109362185,
0.275108248,
-0.1463710815,
0.0353002697,
-0.465197593,
-0.08578448,
-0.4564962089,
0.167561993,
-0.1385484487,
-0.358027935,
-0.0313101746,
0.2844746411,
-0.1464024782,
0.0645724982,
0.826446414,
1.3211981058,
-0.2151600271,
-0.2152983993,
0.633662641,
-0.5655121207,
-0.13160263,
-0.0294231474,
0.1830725521,
-0.0308329631,
0.4883206785,
0.5179041028,
0.5453860164,
-1.0572030544,
0.1744398326,
-0.2397304624,
-0.5049456954,
-0.5141434073,
-0.0935980752,
0.2312985361,
0.6621941924,
0.8279586434,
-0.0280688796,
0.1466151178,
-0.5955290198,
0.1941569299,
-0.2135840058,
-0.1364855021,
-0.1233867556,
0.6770057082,
0.1764412075,
-0.0012402065,
0.9889637232,
0.3357053101,
-0.5610915422,
1.1587859392,
0.3953067064,
0.577077806,
-0.0124571919,
0.4021971226,
0.1543779671,
0.2809897363,
-0.4002076983,
0.4855513275,
0.2184787542,
-0.3922681808,
-0.7733391523,
-0.5305120349,
-0.6347379684,
0.0478526615,
-0.9911190271,
0.3573512733,
-0.9906142354,
-0.1716079712,
0.4639615119,
-0.0226572286,
-0.4848421216,
0.5998237133,
0.2693648338,
1.1692810059,
-0.4576904476,
0.0560260899,
0.3841192722,
-0.4989820421,
-1.1141176224,
-0.5600200295,
-0.0659645349,
-0.9101964831,
1.1164757013,
-0.0989521891,
-0.0705814958,
-0.4834082425,
-0.8564176559,
-0.8773866892,
0.932087183,
0.5060206652,
-0.9880782366,
-0.2156430483,
0.2357731164,
0.390863061,
-0.4896480739,
0.0068603344,
0.8342967033,
0.5643376708,
0.5193352103,
-0.8818344474,
-0.1105445027,
-0.0898645073,
-0.3689096272,
0.3439986706,
-1.0037673712,
0.7536483407,
-0.6134436727,
0.1419091672,
-0.2773396373,
0.5992098451,
0.2533424497,
0.85491395,
0.3741810024,
0.3884097636,
1.1127499342,
-0.0047553768,
1.0550067425,
-0.2295726985,
0.0493441075,
0.9974508286,
-0.194652617,
0.8940497637,
0.0982998759,
-0.0169778168,
0.5575097799,
0.763851285,
-0.4091163576,
0.3540029228,
0.2846081555,
-0.1792400181,
-0.5230482817,
-0.1036749706,
-0.2902877629,
0.6457674503,
0.6309815049,
-0.307404995,
-0.0660634264,
-0.4226648808,
0.0423477329,
0.0788285956,
-0.5097149014,
0.7310057878,
0.5083681941,
-0.537458241,
0.4658579528,
0.1918378323,
0.1444107592,
-0.6346772909,
-0.1301398426,
-0.3314263821,
0.2178416699,
-0.3009638786,
-0.8571895361,
0.5831674337,
0.5257713795,
-0.3154146671,
-0.1417766064,
0.4142528176,
-0.0046573975,
-0.7089734674,
-0.0449223891,
0.0780174881,
-0.003175582,
-0.0351222605,
-0.3607836068,
0.2194376588,
0.1767407656,
-0.0646788925,
0.2392634302,
0.729195118,
-0.2441929877,
0.999630332,
0.680873394,
-0.2913587391,
-0.3004676998,
0.1952269673,
1.0446324348,
-1.0054587126,
-0.6179627776,
-0.7730278969,
0.3434750438,
0.025198523,
-0.4839738309,
0.531129837,
0.7657413483,
0.3361191154,
-0.0083332583,
0.6603773832,
0.6505556107,
0.6159512997,
-0.783203125,
0.5493389964,
-0.5989639759,
0.7196649313,
-0.0853723809,
-0.8107734323,
-0.3079908192,
0.4577243924,
-0.4671014845,
-0.248684302,
0.5080528259,
0.2526561916,
0.1318759918,
0.4337500334,
0.0625857487,
0.4591742456,
0.2447114438,
0.3118424714,
0.780929327,
-0.301956147,
0.9276148081,
0.03263833,
-0.0463091619,
-0.4149090052,
-0.8766489029,
-0.7660316825,
-0.131151095,
-0.6513483524,
-0.2921389341,
-0.3418805301,
0.5278202295,
-0.0355433896,
-0.6151443124,
-0.4079752862,
0.4055322111,
-0.0142426342,
0.1739934832,
-0.2280516475,
0.1927065998,
-0.1590720415,
-0.0652622581,
0.0518689156,
0.5426483154,
0.2825796008,
-0.1365270168,
0.2405606061,
0.0803033784,
0.4840391576,
0.6187298298,
0.2792915702,
-0.3486184776,
-0.2113040537,
0.2342665642,
-0.0868723169,
-0.1281301975,
0.7661815882,
-0.272531867,
-0.2431491464,
0.4582038522,
0.8005003333,
0.6641823649,
0.1614634246,
0.6177768111,
-0.1983125508,
0.0272358563,
0.2380699366,
0.132446751,
0.1837526709,
-0.5412412882,
0.6336829662,
-0.1421906352,
-0.5026502609,
-0.8002254367,
-0.2707796097,
-1.1282397509,
-0.3309997022,
0.9553418756,
0.0465509556,
-0.3856866658,
-0.017398959,
-0.1396978199,
-0.2056282163,
-0.5088086128,
0.6089001894,
0.9322721362,
0.0092366971,
-0.203853026,
-0.7479665279,
0.2965670228,
0.1672337502,
-0.6021329761,
0.1485330611,
0.5005034208,
0.3782760203,
0.0767863318,
0.5470665693,
-0.028662011,
0.3351676762,
0.2982600331,
-0.8037052751,
0.0122843152,
-0.4967165291,
-0.0611875914,
0.2485584766,
0.0000349735,
0.1756245792
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14867v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14867v2
|
VIEScore: Towards Explainable Metrics for Conditional Image Synthesis Evaluation
| 2023-12-22T17:45:19 | 2024-06-03T16:59:20 |
Max Ku, Dongfu Jiang, Cong Wei, Xiang Yue, Wenhu Chen
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM
|
In the rapidly advancing field of conditional image generation research,
challenges such as limited explainability lie in effectively evaluating the
performance and capabilities of various models. This paper introduces VIEScore,
a Visual Instruction-guided Explainable metric for evaluating any conditional
image generation tasks. VIEScore leverages general knowledge from Multimodal
Large Language Models (MLLMs) as the backbone and does not require training or
fine-tuning. We evaluate VIEScore on seven prominent tasks in conditional image
tasks and found: (1) VIEScore (GPT4-o) achieves a high Spearman correlation of
0.4 with human evaluations, while the human-to-human correlation is 0.45. (2)
VIEScore (with open-source MLLM) is significantly weaker than GPT-4o and GPT-4v
in evaluating synthetic images. (3) VIEScore achieves a correlation on par with
human ratings in the generation tasks but struggles in editing tasks. With
these results, we believe VIEScore shows its great potential to replace human
judges in evaluating image synthesis tasks.
|
[
-0.562270999,
-0.4053796828,
0.82169801,
0.1917086393,
-0.0856323168,
-0.0196634885,
-0.2061414868,
-0.3425832689,
-0.2305549532,
0.5786373615,
-0.5299645066,
-0.5365568995,
-0.5561113954,
0.0802717432,
-0.7330292463,
1.067682147,
-0.4379540384,
0.1575728655,
-0.4062688649,
-0.2126388252,
-0.7215782404,
-0.1649439633,
-0.6563817859,
-0.1523115635,
0.4582351744,
0.1850335151,
0.4585900605,
0.2751101553,
0.7306010127,
0.4790651202,
0.3638778031,
0.2989243567,
-0.5005720258,
-0.1705502123,
-0.2168408185,
-0.6514481306,
-0.6776769757,
0.1333847046,
0.413164258,
0.3916280866,
0.167197302,
0.307802707,
0.1170285642,
1.0265356302,
-0.7599515915,
0.4128198922,
-0.67040205,
0.1992074847,
0.1424786001,
-0.3117335141,
0.002858202,
-0.4647842944,
0.2564199865,
-0.7951987982,
0.7703899145,
-0.0445913263,
0.9247008562,
0.1674082279,
-0.3604040742,
-0.1942753792,
-0.7050376534,
0.8152474761,
-0.2372138053,
0.2904534638,
0.2281044722,
0.8849005103,
0.0835976601,
-1.0974886417,
-0.8287536502,
-0.2475178689,
-0.0191050842,
0.4132818282,
-0.3118633926,
0.1630122066,
0.1239697039,
0.5480781794,
-0.4862494171,
-0.2129228562,
-0.4801142514,
-0.518137753,
0.5146627426,
0.4373439848,
0.2026375532,
-0.2567913532,
-0.3308098614,
0.0075147497,
-0.4729214609,
0.3040556908,
0.2875299752,
-0.356108278,
-0.1492628604,
0.7207092047,
-0.074903436,
0.7866504192,
0.2320043743,
-0.0220663734,
0.0088715861,
-0.7066466808,
-0.3413448036,
-0.3933035433,
0.6999619603,
0.7483865619,
0.124672018,
0.1599376798,
-0.3268978298,
0.5765692592,
0.3407958746,
-1.0195140839,
-0.5169246793,
-0.0644556955,
-0.4820562005,
-0.2359195352,
-0.018420307,
-0.6819099784,
-0.1135137826,
-0.3962856829,
0.7971533537,
-0.4363993406,
0.2891692519,
0.0333785564,
-0.2747833729,
0.3867211938,
0.8064730167,
-0.4232570231,
0.2124284506,
0.4602809846,
0.7290445566,
-0.1717050672,
-0.3755346835,
-0.6370003819,
-0.069005765,
-0.5263069272,
0.7617594004,
-0.2868457139,
-0.3592839539,
-0.2667449415,
0.1480171233,
0.0250329338,
-0.4040877223,
0.474159956,
-0.2973093987,
0.6447651982,
-0.2032281756,
-0.2099357396,
-0.4110448062,
0.1379867792,
-0.588917315,
0.4874612987,
0.2252989262,
-0.7765006423,
0.7935954928,
-0.4568673074,
-0.3051352501,
0.0565432683,
-0.4675388038,
-0.5170453191,
-0.0212325063,
0.3680103421,
0.4695863128,
-0.7304107547,
0.2564182281,
-0.2621334791,
-0.2561941743,
0.2615121305,
-0.5661301613,
0.2658447027,
0.268244952,
-0.4352018237,
0.0884395465,
-0.7433868051,
0.0073324949,
-0.0177729465,
-0.2122685313,
0.0547062345,
-0.0799689218,
-0.1230791137,
0.1299389452,
0.3091726303,
-0.3523617685,
-0.3217873275,
-0.0911617205,
0.2312656045,
0.6339617968,
0.163655594,
0.3856205642,
-0.3560661972,
0.6806929708,
0.0169615671,
0.3022862971,
-0.3821133673,
-0.5992510915,
-1.1602175236,
-0.629614234,
0.065965645,
0.4368726313,
-1.0018330812,
0.1222172305,
-0.2552972734,
-0.3053073287,
-0.5663201213,
0.3476321399,
0.7281324267,
0.8384661674,
0.3397493362,
-0.7244062424,
-0.636829257,
-1.4803224802,
-0.1744150072,
-0.158141464,
-0.2349259108,
0.1854302883,
0.4707519114,
-0.1235302463,
0.7877787352,
-0.4661339819,
-0.2834204435,
-0.0582508184,
0.3273178339,
0.3210290968,
0.1613462418,
0.7122918963,
-0.6676588058,
-0.4460267127,
0.0881936327,
-0.7421466112,
-0.1589743197,
-0.1518297046,
0.0272233505,
0.2160720825,
0.2895223498,
-0.4244528413,
0.5048905015,
0.5282710195,
0.0042602285,
0.7252954245,
-0.476452589,
0.871086359,
-0.6061654687,
0.1309136301,
0.2959592342,
-0.4256911576,
-0.4103261232,
-0.128490448,
0.0085036028,
-0.1951692402,
-0.5456216335,
0.2719990909,
-0.4903846383,
-0.1392894089,
-0.0346471816,
-0.0668187439,
0.4006758928,
0.4645956159,
-0.0542919934,
0.7282488942,
0.792740345,
-0.469963789,
0.2739319205,
0.0465156995,
-0.7037661672,
1.0080648661,
-0.8843563199,
-0.1089057848,
-0.1738486737,
0.3879722059,
-1.0556349754,
-0.3044734299,
0.1628613919,
-0.2987863421,
0.1491585523,
-0.2591937482,
-0.1465897262,
-0.5432456136,
-0.2543813586,
0.3769320548,
0.7075949311,
-0.6546476483,
0.2223274857,
0.2955017984,
0.147895202,
-0.0881257057,
-0.5356814861,
0.338508755,
-0.5270063877,
-0.7791145444,
0.3447844982,
-0.1751435399,
-0.1924875379,
-0.0833065286,
0.1042358577,
-0.2253859937,
-0.3410055041,
0.4491104186,
0.401347965,
-0.3139406443,
-0.3039329052,
-0.1564788073,
-0.2231694162,
0.0719694346,
-0.1176757589,
-0.1687119603,
-0.5195463896,
-0.2781256139,
-0.6170934439,
0.1007492766,
0.6879768968,
-0.2093466818,
0.0239650421,
0.8470856547,
0.0334389396,
-0.1747668087,
-0.4388548136,
0.1829263419,
-0.5235117078,
0.4777843356,
-0.5142187476,
-0.6153470278,
0.2074479163,
-0.0036036158,
-0.1193064898,
0.6046196818,
0.7094715834,
-0.2038729489,
1.4417220354,
0.3526860178,
0.4425198138,
0.3046190143,
-0.4205740392,
0.146608308,
-0.4432195723,
-0.1646197587,
-0.1068233922,
-0.1806487739,
-0.6516959071,
-0.7953096032,
0.8421726227,
-0.069758296,
-0.1388331503,
0.3159581721,
-0.4512089193,
0.4873519242,
0.2614511251,
0.0389873311,
0.0362171233,
0.0619429126,
0.0690778866,
-0.0736006424,
-0.6252871156,
-0.4048678279,
0.8733741045,
0.0244332347,
0.7837989926,
-0.1878270805,
0.4330222607,
0.3891044259,
0.062983416,
-0.7268140912,
0.7375089526,
-0.3530198634,
-0.3077995479,
0.0578998774,
-0.3683988154,
-0.9947007298,
0.2781539261,
-0.443263948,
-0.4635376334,
-0.0373466946,
0.5363379121,
0.0115240486,
-0.0103104468,
-0.8832498193,
0.7885289192,
-0.5318209529,
-0.3893463016,
-0.4259253442,
-0.5470636487,
0.7320657969,
-0.2407924235,
0.3548533618,
-0.0168148689,
0.0515102521,
0.5717958212,
-0.4630071521,
0.7225090861,
-0.1579026729,
0.0859665945,
0.4174310267,
0.2670074403,
0.181272015,
-0.0277366061,
0.0389497727,
0.1826848537,
0.1928458661,
-0.2352890372,
-0.8833579421,
0.8858391643,
-0.4941969216,
-0.7219266295,
0.0323466063,
-0.336183548,
-0.1973742098,
-0.1167577654,
0.5373865366,
0.3823508918,
-0.4343392849,
-0.0235334542,
0.0836033672,
-0.353621304,
0.055525396,
0.243032977,
-0.2258495092,
-0.5304888487,
1.1549624205,
-0.1695630699,
0.1150293648,
0.3865011036,
0.171288833,
-0.0035642886,
-0.2029475421,
-0.613332808,
-0.0872640535,
-0.7025684714,
-0.1074939817,
-0.3387694657,
-0.0720404759,
0.1305365562,
-0.4219798446,
-0.4562077224,
-0.7529824972,
-0.2178169936,
0.2108014077,
0.121096909,
0.47918275,
-0.0723713264,
0.0831891373,
-0.6149192452,
0.6125801206,
0.717159152,
0.1613737345,
-0.0699367151,
-0.3918141127,
-0.302320838,
0.0257191602,
-0.4304125011,
-0.6602057815,
0.2198673487,
0.4624491036,
0.5441618562,
0.4325512052,
-0.4590038061,
0.881654501,
-0.6144376397,
0.9808876514,
0.8360937238,
-1.1566143036,
0.6754587293,
-0.181118086,
0.2049019933,
0.3417342603,
0.1499860287,
-0.102506265,
-0.5678874254,
-0.5308666825,
-0.7587846518,
0.3488075733,
0.5527846217,
0.0177206621,
0.2273747921,
0.0265874751,
0.5305764079,
0.1759197563,
-0.5697997808,
0.1047195569,
-0.6148414612,
0.1727241129,
-0.4254052341,
0.1031000987,
-0.2656595111,
-0.5328958035,
0.3340276182,
0.041919928,
0.2812266052,
0.1565050632,
-0.1624985784,
0.0424882472,
0.2308264971,
0.5082925558,
0.8381521106,
-0.1811293662,
0.30756706,
0.1087657064,
0.0728716031,
0.1053088456,
-0.2840812206,
0.1199711338,
0.0213561654,
0.6661193371,
1.046030283,
-0.0035296555,
-0.5230519772,
0.8347516656,
-0.2804868817,
-0.5794028044,
-0.2228823155,
0.4562482536,
-0.2720334828,
0.2146296948,
0.0801372379,
0.2281959057,
0.3685795963,
-0.3092775345,
0.1302877218,
0.3816829026,
-0.5055946708,
-0.8218069673,
0.862133503,
0.1868220419,
0.038069319,
0.1674113274,
-0.0922893137,
-0.4696243703,
0.7261052132,
0.2678060532,
0.9313483238,
0.0314863436,
0.5790473819,
0.4722378254,
0.278908819,
0.2108520269,
0.2616871595,
-0.25781551,
-0.4686592817,
-0.2413855642,
-0.5483080745,
-0.3658637404,
0.1290469617,
-0.5501339436,
0.3533640504,
-0.2122070789,
-0.251491338,
0.4443082809,
-0.6284918785,
-1.3080948591,
0.4476881027,
-0.0211066455,
0.2694673538,
-0.8969234824,
0.475753963,
0.6616594195,
-0.4935554862,
-0.3543297946,
-0.1313506812,
0.068911694,
-0.9798733592,
0.8738179803,
0.1165510938,
-0.3186410964,
-0.3451654017,
-0.471165061,
-0.3531441987,
1.0052565336,
0.5026770234,
-0.3216995001,
0.2767279446,
-0.0673232004,
0.8675615788,
-0.3914756477,
0.1222456917,
0.5555742383,
0.7468765974,
0.2513613105,
-0.8627257943,
-0.0482136421,
-0.277102381,
0.2422730029,
0.1140431836,
-0.363756299,
0.7086734176,
-0.5035877228,
-0.2376711816,
0.2144656628,
0.4302591085,
0.0131274611,
0.4560662806,
0.7367591262,
0.3700699508,
0.3071687222,
0.212767601,
1.1746766567,
-0.2011403292,
0.1165994033,
0.774261713,
-0.0934790447,
0.3809149861,
0.5493389964,
-0.4155071974,
0.5087592006,
0.5893710852,
-0.2147972733,
0.7047128677,
0.1954706013,
-0.2542191148,
-0.4348023534,
0.1652074456,
-0.230202511,
0.8909400702,
0.2806818187,
-0.5107998848,
-0.3083399832,
0.081900999,
-0.3178088069,
-0.1434621364,
-0.3436426222,
0.4383902252,
0.124700591,
-0.953394115,
0.9295227528,
0.069662407,
0.2090784758,
-0.591065228,
-0.3433777094,
-0.1306694448,
0.2313934267,
-0.1995510459,
-0.9950947762,
0.2312671393,
0.138569653,
-0.2175724655,
-0.0996090323,
0.568082571,
-0.2979324758,
-0.7209381461,
0.0712393373,
0.3981739879,
0.1194318384,
0.1632364988,
-0.676856935,
-0.2637264729,
0.247741133,
-0.1253579855,
0.2257649601,
0.336756289,
-0.3017806113,
0.5825778842,
0.6735080481,
0.0341290757,
-0.2837232947,
-0.0324119776,
0.635774672,
-0.2642353177,
-0.3155001998,
-0.5132974982,
0.4893800914,
0.1138378158,
-0.1890851706,
0.7689113617,
0.5467840433,
0.4824767709,
-0.4204616845,
0.9976431727,
-0.0024729862,
0.0260910261,
-0.7244915366,
0.6191660166,
-0.8283945918,
0.2823104262,
-0.4091312289,
-1.0268167257,
-0.1818707138,
0.4345110357,
-0.2944389582,
-0.0697265267,
0.7819609046,
0.9796077013,
-0.5632325411,
-0.2657368779,
0.5679003596,
0.1174953058,
0.2739621997,
0.4576270282,
1.0029292107,
-0.0600974448,
0.7891458273,
-0.1061671376,
-0.4318963587,
0.2031424642,
-1.0052002668,
-0.6497200727,
-0.8876183629,
-0.3890430331,
-0.1540643722,
0.0487014167,
0.1260593683,
0.8428800106,
-0.6688917875,
-0.2671885192,
-0.1417188644,
0.0581310466,
-0.1233327463,
-0.2393713742,
0.3464705646,
-0.119366914,
-0.7647814155,
0.4744792581,
0.5995753407,
-0.2192536443,
-0.294393003,
-0.281444937,
0.4474254847,
0.16505678,
0.7458507419,
0.2993459105,
-0.7996471524,
-0.3510776162,
-0.5023254156,
-0.0130962338,
0.0354414247,
0.8561835885,
-0.814591527,
0.9352903962,
0.6985938549,
0.1837096512,
0.9316378832,
-0.1993795335,
0.8149216175,
-0.5103701949,
0.0330498032,
-0.1836189628,
0.5423176885,
0.4889315665,
-0.0589262992,
0.4700155258,
0.1788162291,
-0.5956950188,
-0.4327744246,
0.3005925715,
-1.0901248455,
-0.0272038803,
0.8682353497,
-0.2192491591,
-0.165076077,
0.2300735712,
-0.3666122854,
0.0952479541,
-0.068140775,
0.8434116244,
0.2556183338,
-0.3561275899,
-0.0743050948,
-0.5517607331,
0.3270998001,
0.2547025383,
-0.8535820842,
-0.4942007661,
1.0976557732,
0.4156511426,
-0.1450968385,
0.6169573069,
-0.0876985788,
0.6763710976,
-0.0035505998,
0.1910483986,
0.0012707572,
-0.1420581192,
0.0863483697,
-0.022723332,
-0.081020087,
-0.4464011788
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15006v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15006v2
|
Assessing the Impact of Prompting Methods on ChatGPT's Mathematical Capabilities
| 2023-12-22T17:39:40 | 2024-02-20T18:44:20 |
Yuhao Chen, Chloe Wong, Hanwen Yang, Juan Aguenza, Sai Bhujangari, Benthan Vu, Xun Lei, Amisha Prasad, Manny Fluss, Eric Phuong, Minghao Liu, Raja Kumar, Vanshika Vats, James Davis
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This study critically evaluates the efficacy of prompting methods in
enhancing the mathematical reasoning capability of large language models
(LLMs). The investigation uses three prescriptive prompting methods - simple,
persona, and conversational prompting - known for their effectiveness in
enhancing the linguistic tasks of LLMs. We conduct this analysis on OpenAI's
LLM chatbot, ChatGPT-3.5, on extensive problem sets from the MATH, GSM8K, and
MMLU datasets, encompassing a broad spectrum of mathematical challenges. A
grading script adapted to each dataset is used to determine the effectiveness
of these prompting interventions in enhancing the model's mathematical analysis
power. Contrary to expectations, our empirical analysis reveals that none of
the investigated methods consistently improves over ChatGPT-3.5's baseline
performance, with some causing significant degradation. Our findings suggest
that prompting strategies do not necessarily generalize to new domains, in this
study failing to enhance mathematical performance.
|
[
-0.4200417697,
-1.0946617126,
0.6414018273,
0.5390611887,
-0.1409353763,
-0.2404631823,
-0.4322788119,
0.0167385116,
-0.1854001284,
0.2370139509,
-0.5953810811,
-0.243019715,
-0.4465201795,
0.2346087992,
-0.070311904,
0.9778807759,
-0.0167973563,
0.253633678,
-0.3284860849,
0.3568593264,
-0.8261864185,
-0.5063175559,
-0.8850156665,
-0.3651340604,
0.6639986634,
0.4882081449,
0.7600703835,
-0.1004733741,
0.5826586485,
0.1940165907,
-0.0994714424,
0.0793686435,
-0.622608304,
0.013807619,
0.2265926152,
-0.6509703994,
-0.4732340872,
0.1519958675,
0.6172555685,
0.6335994601,
-0.2685801387,
0.1620323062,
0.2794732451,
0.6243937016,
-0.5150082707,
0.4594321549,
-0.4199442267,
-0.1799290627,
-0.2697468102,
-0.3152211905,
-0.5089821815,
-0.5579243898,
0.3965269327,
-0.5705687404,
-0.0945925564,
-0.1427547187,
0.5076519847,
0.2690233588,
-0.0650619194,
-0.6476992965,
-0.7215974927,
0.7033219337,
-0.5818018913,
-0.0072494638,
0.6232923269,
0.3712126315,
-0.2798697054,
-0.6214926243,
-0.4936979711,
-0.4523896277,
0.0667668581,
0.2471756786,
-0.4321982265,
-0.0559013784,
0.8199221492,
0.1670845002,
-0.3223793209,
0.149699986,
-0.5200240016,
-0.0741309375,
0.3565682769,
0.1384378374,
0.3838977814,
-0.2345447093,
-0.0099406624,
-0.0974754915,
-1.0715134144,
0.1755234599,
0.5542270541,
0.3001532257,
-0.0769524574,
0.6524791121,
-0.0363373086,
0.6417891383,
-0.3475414217,
0.0684370324,
-0.0694114864,
-0.3325576484,
-0.186417222,
-0.1270458698,
0.8214194775,
0.2464073449,
0.7772407532,
0.4366098642,
-0.0850464702,
0.0605501197,
0.020148525,
-0.7224575877,
-0.5225549936,
0.1310919523,
-0.0885753557,
-0.1437906623,
-0.0745203942,
-0.8406867981,
-0.3482168615,
-0.3598070145,
0.6635121107,
-0.5741991997,
-0.1842051446,
0.1754098684,
0.017872395,
0.4420939088,
0.5158085823,
-0.9636762738,
0.0705564618,
0.8164020777,
0.8547872305,
0.1757967919,
-0.1286727041,
-0.5012151003,
-0.3370203376,
-0.2898748815,
0.8700620532,
-0.6569026113,
-0.6828542352,
0.0663681924,
-0.3888738155,
-0.3850964308,
-0.5369915962,
0.7295207977,
-0.4025869071,
0.3879565597,
-0.4898563623,
-0.3967404962,
-0.2207336575,
0.118535839,
-0.5544954538,
0.8401702046,
-0.047454752,
-0.4107000828,
0.210106805,
-1.1831765175,
-0.2479310185,
0.0697978809,
-0.1296147555,
-0.2887454629,
0.0535325408,
0.8529160023,
0.3829608858,
-0.3006078303,
0.2279926986,
-0.1352568418,
-0.2268427014,
0.5365901589,
-0.825966835,
0.7493178844,
0.0713981092,
-0.0884225965,
0.0732010156,
-0.4003953636,
0.1440467536,
0.3668733835,
0.0387574248,
0.0243244357,
-0.0903265923,
-0.4707350135,
-0.0950521305,
0.0594301634,
-0.1292798668,
0.3114583194,
-0.3418798149,
0.4227700531,
0.9098510146,
0.1240550503,
0.1019253358,
-0.5454538465,
0.9079924226,
-0.3966289461,
0.0489497073,
-0.6067200899,
-0.8937940598,
-0.7322499752,
-0.3229261637,
0.4695703685,
0.5821803212,
-0.7772195935,
-0.0502809174,
-0.3469977379,
-0.3718594313,
-0.3178323209,
0.0183419958,
0.3888431489,
0.5061292648,
0.0543541983,
0.0717443526,
-0.2098842114,
-0.5760779977,
-0.2282549441,
-0.1343197078,
-0.2982471585,
0.3601976037,
0.4524836242,
0.2037406266,
0.8976430893,
-0.451421082,
-0.0703525394,
-0.1285479069,
0.1943574697,
0.345829457,
0.2837998569,
0.5597093701,
-0.4784296453,
-0.6637254357,
-0.2031408697,
-0.699441433,
-0.4677301645,
0.0463024192,
-0.1125488654,
-0.144487977,
0.3668261766,
-0.6375876069,
0.5843274593,
0.4355210364,
-0.0478350297,
0.8391247988,
-0.0415109284,
0.3132260442,
-0.5767609477,
0.0187706687,
-0.0436965786,
0.2358159572,
-0.8430675268,
-0.1452093124,
-0.0321286917,
-0.4947656095,
-0.4337289929,
0.5002595186,
-0.2216108441,
0.1940630674,
-0.094228968,
0.3734734058,
-0.2555792928,
0.3987535238,
-0.2473308295,
1.1295087337,
0.5954278708,
-0.7839477658,
0.2998262644,
0.1874269247,
-0.3127368689,
0.6447066069,
-0.9842780828,
0.321120739,
-0.0774441361,
0.1816344112,
-1.2902215719,
-0.3308451176,
0.5067291856,
-0.7238276601,
-0.0248206705,
-0.1844297647,
-0.4860809743,
-0.3689651191,
-0.2744588852,
0.2983648181,
0.6479474902,
-0.552560091,
0.5160870552,
-0.1782637388,
-0.4783342779,
-0.2695481479,
-0.182471469,
-0.0464758314,
-0.3625990748,
-0.884534657,
-0.0835603252,
-0.236258015,
-0.498965323,
-0.339518249,
0.1699540615,
0.2663905025,
-0.0137264198,
0.0901436657,
0.5689467192,
-0.300521642,
-0.0857390091,
-0.1715045273,
-0.3384695053,
0.3776458204,
-0.0694962516,
0.7524590492,
-0.0910375267,
-0.7048507333,
-0.7127794027,
-0.1220792085,
0.2772169709,
-0.2406884283,
0.4871269464,
0.3312496543,
-0.1535228491,
0.1838892102,
-0.4898452759,
-0.293318361,
-0.5106327534,
-0.0027226633,
-0.5939407945,
-0.8465186954,
0.482971698,
-0.083590813,
0.2212087959,
0.2193559408,
0.6148002148,
0.0525762513,
1.2882794142,
0.0659560636,
0.0605367087,
0.5972887874,
-0.0997145921,
0.2922242582,
-0.9342544079,
-0.1583669186,
-0.7370178699,
-0.0376330391,
-0.3147399426,
-0.3625879884,
0.5137189031,
0.0416725874,
-0.0391267538,
-0.0481376499,
-0.2672253251,
0.720073998,
0.399702251,
0.13362661,
0.1569842249,
0.2353443354,
-0.0886899158,
-0.1741475761,
-0.697727859,
-0.4783656001,
1.1937936544,
0.3430288732,
0.770527482,
0.4032901525,
0.3351120651,
-0.1056543514,
0.5057677031,
-1.0489065647,
0.6095817089,
0.3399023116,
-0.3642303348,
-0.499917835,
-0.7465643883,
-1.3825432062,
0.2595677078,
0.0220802091,
-0.9442620277,
-0.2943225503,
0.0503923483,
-0.6946228743,
-0.18328695,
-1.1063776016,
0.5663362741,
-0.1471386701,
-0.1981073171,
-0.1128290892,
-0.0271878336,
0.4988552034,
-0.1457582265,
0.2075947374,
-0.1818347722,
-0.0078514377,
0.7781724334,
-0.3312745392,
0.8415238261,
-0.2595622241,
-0.4742287397,
0.4358793199,
0.2682175934,
0.5656849146,
0.139869839,
-0.0842102543,
0.05182264,
-0.0532550104,
-0.4623585939,
-1.0900768042,
0.5859230757,
-0.597088635,
-0.9397047758,
-0.1571753919,
-0.3309260607,
-0.514773488,
0.0943864211,
0.1457917988,
0.619584918,
-0.0013970814,
0.2190330178,
0.6605389714,
-0.2646076083,
0.4167081416,
0.3677478135,
-0.4802205265,
-0.4862945676,
0.856315136,
0.1599170268,
0.4943540096,
-0.0884396136,
0.6233541369,
-0.376016289,
-0.380297184,
-0.3965272009,
0.3279004991,
-0.7110578418,
-0.026352996,
-0.2123258263,
-0.1305700243,
-0.5812872052,
-0.009123724,
0.1182969883,
-0.167933926,
-0.1827730238,
0.1920132786,
0.4905440807,
0.8027055264,
0.1861034185,
0.6480733156,
-0.7070518136,
-0.0081805708,
0.4473297596,
0.1857330501,
0.2228728384,
-0.6184810996,
0.1807392836,
0.0929695815,
-0.2985451818,
-0.6791241765,
0.169356823,
-0.0333554558,
0.6954622865,
0.4805482924,
-0.067966722,
0.7876057625,
-0.3327532709,
0.9698706269,
0.2167131305,
-0.9473118782,
0.7650741935,
-0.7246460915,
0.536923945,
0.0506594069,
0.4568944573,
-0.3236532211,
0.0233577602,
-0.6301007867,
-0.3494519293,
0.7040872574,
0.6266658902,
0.2877423167,
0.0503392518,
0.4024093449,
-0.1812966466,
0.0406213067,
-0.4645856023,
0.0197501313,
0.1398344934,
-0.0401496589,
0.0082683917,
-0.2468226999,
-0.0663589016,
-0.1638787389,
0.4839709997,
-0.1846881509,
0.4017802477,
0.0613888204,
0.0455693081,
0.1484922469,
0.1508753747,
0.9683969617,
1.0149313211,
0.2688838243,
-0.2410065681,
0.3896385431,
-0.5324379206,
-0.1969394833,
0.0778101906,
-0.0683247298,
-0.2955327034,
0.3969643414,
0.7340432405,
0.2195182741,
-0.5434311628,
0.3302915394,
-0.1864978224,
-0.3523927033,
-0.1375543922,
0.2550425529,
-0.1355030239,
-0.0874356478,
0.2798777819,
-0.300436914,
-0.2001131922,
-0.3067131639,
-0.1747270525,
0.4635157585,
-0.3598228693,
-0.2580586076,
0.2679766715,
0.1049540117,
-0.5728889704,
0.796272099,
0.1784940958,
-0.5802321434,
0.5694459677,
0.5689175129,
0.5211205482,
-0.4100901186,
0.2300315648,
0.4496535659,
0.2340620458,
-0.107239522,
0.3235268295,
-0.0958178639,
-0.5787712336,
-0.7944344878,
-0.2311254889,
-0.5674758554,
0.1561353803,
-0.4303568602,
0.4475831687,
-0.5398578048,
-0.127811417,
0.139790833,
-0.0006463471,
-0.5206746459,
-0.1998621076,
-0.1022690833,
0.7313061953,
-0.4025084078,
0.3347188234,
0.467479825,
-0.4029759765,
-1.0593812466,
-0.0290326308,
0.2632781863,
-1.0954200029,
0.5552847385,
0.1452347189,
-0.0635045245,
0.1404845864,
-0.9054834247,
-0.6208642721,
0.6677175164,
0.2946177125,
-0.2615717947,
0.2135109603,
0.2501945496,
0.443914175,
-0.0339788422,
0.6102751493,
0.546742022,
0.6816053391,
0.3996085823,
-1.1698588133,
-0.0896187574,
-0.2451931238,
-0.0695376992,
0.2676065862,
-0.5531039238,
0.6327500939,
-0.2681787014,
-0.2932552099,
0.2945646346,
0.5022807717,
0.4375822246,
0.254730016,
0.4432620406,
0.2187399864,
0.9313597679,
-0.2684317231,
0.9394478202,
0.0054768985,
0.2004521489,
0.7624751925,
-0.250805378,
0.7937570214,
0.3002980351,
-0.482055217,
0.3094218075,
0.5188186169,
0.0398000106,
-0.0051916498,
0.4399472773,
-0.3649631739,
-0.1766226888,
-0.067705147,
-0.446601063,
0.293540597,
0.8026638031,
0.0854542106,
-0.2670882642,
0.1292370111,
0.2583355606,
-0.1413924247,
-0.2961223722,
0.6765732765,
0.2270433307,
-1.0133051872,
0.571947813,
-0.3179470599,
0.3231697381,
-0.6583439708,
-0.1174785718,
-0.1608305424,
-0.0404669642,
-0.1520528793,
-0.8639310598,
-0.0433547907,
0.046878498,
0.3912088573,
-0.2181729972,
0.6564906836,
0.0041773566,
-0.2986360192,
-0.2383236587,
0.6289458871,
0.3245285153,
-0.2261505276,
-0.689895153,
0.0721305162,
0.0167879704,
-0.1220524684,
0.2460854948,
0.6300748587,
-0.1438475251,
0.8513530493,
1.2231968641,
-0.1026783586,
-0.2181798369,
0.5066612959,
0.7566260695,
-0.5584399104,
-0.3072066605,
-1.1511570215,
0.3040744662,
0.0758624226,
-0.3072485626,
1.1111059189,
0.1424104869,
0.4737757742,
0.0482505113,
0.5852770209,
0.0978374556,
0.304630518,
-0.9534674883,
0.3962697685,
-0.0549197868,
0.5476258993,
-0.4087536633,
-0.9826677442,
-0.439747721,
0.5980464816,
-0.8680243492,
0.3979225457,
0.6901411414,
0.942768693,
0.255070895,
0.4472172856,
0.4191666842,
-0.1337842196,
0.5502594709,
0.44014135,
1.5077950954,
-0.0025244234,
0.7132762074,
0.1614906192,
-0.5551862121,
-0.1273297668,
-0.7710415125,
-1.3396456242,
-0.2030307353,
-0.1836203933,
-0.536501348,
-0.1610882282,
0.9031466246,
0.4133647084,
-0.4902774096,
-0.1142284349,
0.0222462006,
0.0791567937,
0.0346772335,
-0.2615669668,
0.3217281401,
-0.5377159715,
-0.8161461949,
0.2910112739,
0.080531694,
0.1400631368,
-0.4177405238,
0.0186691191,
0.237388283,
0.1784219444,
0.7240303159,
0.2300487012,
-0.6323059797,
-0.1451295465,
0.3525530994,
0.191751197,
0.0826900005,
1.0916329622,
-0.5450839996,
0.3776044846,
0.6335755587,
0.4279882908,
0.1847255528,
0.0925008208,
0.7076385021,
-0.3697363734,
-0.1408110559,
0.1082572117,
0.2506763041,
0.0724198818,
-0.2774641812,
0.4928578138,
0.1602522731,
-0.6610945463,
-0.6782725453,
0.1985507607,
-0.5997238755,
0.1101274118,
1.2796407938,
-0.1473760754,
-0.2471892685,
-0.0470779687,
-0.6835098863,
-0.3479805887,
-0.6105701327,
0.5350622535,
1.1544753313,
-0.4213757515,
-0.365799427,
-0.9154568911,
0.4362998605,
0.6454837918,
-0.7102373838,
0.1884843856,
0.5227168202,
-0.0560716838,
0.2267253399,
0.6974605322,
-0.2969400585,
0.2847071886,
0.0168360956,
-0.5788292289,
0.0207276102,
-0.2421230525,
-0.6206269264,
-0.0235516112,
0.0791548565,
0.2170782089
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14862v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14862v1
|
YAYI 2: Multilingual Open-Source Large Language Models
| 2023-12-22T17:34:47 | 2023-12-22T17:34:47 |
Yin Luo, Qingchao Kong, Nan Xu, Jia Cao, Bao Hao, Baoyu Qu, Bo Chen, Chao Zhu, Chenyang Zhao, Donglei Zhang, Fan Feng, Feifei Zhao, Hailong Sun, Hanxuan Yang, Haojun Pan, Hongyu Liu, Jianbin Guo, Jiangtao Du, Jingyi Wang, Junfeng Li, Lei Sun, Liduo Liu, Lifeng Dong, Lili Liu, Lin Wang, Liwen Zhang, Minzheng Wang, Pin Wang, Ping Yu, Qingxiao Li, Rui Yan, Rui Zou, Ruiqun Li, Taiwen Huang, Xiaodong Wang, Xiaofei Wu, Xin Peng, Xina Zhang, Xing Fang, Xinglin Xiao, Yanni Hao, Yao Dong, Yigang Wang, Ying Liu, Yongyu Jiang, Yungan Wang, Yuqi Wang, Zhangsheng Wang, Zhaoxin Yu, Zhen Luo, Wenji Mao, Lei Wang, Dajun Zeng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
As the latest advancements in natural language processing, large language
models (LLMs) have achieved human-level language understanding and generation
abilities in many real-world tasks, and even have been regarded as a potential
path to the artificial general intelligence. To better facilitate research on
LLMs, many open-source LLMs, such as Llama 2 and Falcon, have recently been
proposed and gained comparable performances to proprietary models. However,
these models are primarily designed for English scenarios and exhibit poor
performances in Chinese contexts. In this technical report, we propose YAYI 2,
including both base and chat models, with 30 billion parameters. YAYI 2 is
pre-trained from scratch on a multilingual corpus which contains 2.65 trillion
tokens filtered by our pre-training data processing pipeline. The base model is
aligned with human values through supervised fine-tuning with millions of
instructions and reinforcement learning from human feedback. Extensive
experiments on multiple benchmarks, such as MMLU and CMMLU, consistently
demonstrate that the proposed YAYI 2 outperforms other similar sized
open-source models.
|
[
-0.1045567691,
-0.8810929656,
0.2899546623,
0.296695441,
-0.1681895405,
-0.2144687474,
-0.5442627072,
-0.8623251319,
0.0546950474,
0.5813917518,
-0.4755618274,
-0.193940565,
-0.4723834991,
-0.0837177262,
-0.2187132537,
0.8960868716,
0.2503954768,
0.2225659043,
0.1357880086,
-0.1329694986,
-0.2644222379,
-0.4230394363,
-0.5717970729,
-0.3768395782,
0.7010005713,
0.5833997726,
0.7375936508,
0.7325288653,
0.1948402971,
0.300989598,
0.0374375395,
0.269167155,
-0.5372980237,
0.1897963732,
-0.0070350938,
-0.6246994138,
-0.4377773404,
0.0071665845,
0.6953488588,
0.5463863015,
-0.127888009,
0.4049955606,
-0.0289698262,
0.6013668776,
-0.5327082872,
0.2923727632,
-0.7864098549,
-0.2512614131,
-0.3538304269,
0.1682018489,
-0.4433595836,
-0.0869382992,
0.0023078653,
-0.7497476339,
-0.0823435932,
-0.120644629,
0.6003598571,
0.1298793554,
-0.3443039954,
-0.3373901248,
-0.6492632031,
0.9786202908,
-0.9639498591,
0.2690629363,
0.3804652393,
0.3425435126,
-0.3502038121,
-0.8168100715,
-0.5533176661,
-0.5201234221,
0.0222250521,
-0.0091571361,
0.0166807827,
-0.0408354588,
-0.0377033129,
0.0513811186,
-0.6774687171,
0.5929560065,
-0.5497806072,
-0.0332183316,
0.6051819921,
0.0806600228,
0.284573406,
0.0314962566,
-0.2034472674,
0.1574911326,
-0.7140133381,
-0.0916118845,
0.4401145875,
0.6885015368,
-0.1117716059,
0.6182228327,
-0.2893768251,
0.6898499727,
-0.2163234651,
-0.4047704935,
0.1725591719,
-0.3965802491,
-0.0917608589,
-0.1083025858,
1.0576394796,
0.2607739866,
0.4326946139,
-0.1736616641,
-0.0303431861,
0.0734996647,
-0.0248543415,
-0.8214128613,
0.1221613809,
0.4716836214,
-0.6092384458,
-0.1646336168,
0.028177714,
-0.528722465,
-0.4436824024,
-0.3396523893,
0.3171355426,
-0.2207724154,
-0.7087897658,
0.0853221416,
-0.075068675,
0.1349362433,
0.3450041711,
-1.0055711269,
0.0547356568,
0.879389286,
0.9296301603,
0.0739843994,
-0.756354332,
-0.6233105063,
0.1785063446,
-0.5218228698,
0.6198218465,
-0.3591697216,
-0.1631839126,
0.1423079818,
-0.1871080399,
0.1490926743,
-0.4797237217,
0.4438332617,
-0.4465698898,
0.3334853947,
-0.0963325351,
-0.2336946279,
-0.0142043428,
0.1284116358,
-0.7876719236,
0.9821254611,
0.1623444855,
-0.7854303718,
0.0912831202,
-0.6987912655,
-0.4647075534,
0.3726490438,
-0.0312460642,
-0.0787488446,
0.1311063617,
-0.1191263422,
0.3467701375,
-0.5981911421,
0.4648737907,
-0.343097806,
-0.5410230756,
0.043993365,
-0.4152927399,
0.7571133971,
0.455303818,
-0.2105210721,
0.3020875156,
-0.7256895304,
0.2121745497,
0.219095096,
-0.4588160515,
-0.2514756918,
0.2134312987,
0.4890891016,
0.3819363415,
0.4877412617,
-0.4707525671,
0.2196509689,
-0.4939086437,
0.8466874361,
0.4568454325,
-0.4862788916,
0.3252814412,
-0.0002302407,
0.2209163159,
0.0968805104,
0.0200143568,
-0.3663422763,
-0.5852848291,
-0.7510304451,
-0.1742591113,
0.0271746665,
0.5692406893,
-0.5119043589,
0.2289739549,
-0.0445322618,
-0.6355173588,
-0.7294436097,
0.3344196677,
0.3531918228,
0.2623717487,
0.2592210174,
0.0569476709,
-0.6527498364,
-0.9208086729,
-0.1812531948,
-0.6253241897,
-0.0826039165,
0.0052743885,
0.3336972594,
-0.3723515868,
0.8272800446,
-0.1909659952,
-0.30732885,
-0.5711482167,
0.1714070886,
0.1404934525,
0.1538566798,
0.6388358474,
-0.6866317391,
-0.5082471371,
0.2112040669,
-0.6724952459,
0.0348493271,
0.1046883762,
-0.0131420866,
0.5511140823,
0.5374725461,
-0.7757629156,
0.0641538724,
0.6565019488,
-0.1544549018,
0.7458660007,
-0.4041379988,
-0.117710948,
-1.3568117619,
0.1570050418,
0.2491486967,
0.0300230011,
-0.8262095451,
0.2608850598,
0.1745813042,
-0.0581007712,
-0.5675216317,
0.6727926135,
-0.386428386,
0.0695054084,
-0.5131860971,
0.136873275,
-0.2723499238,
0.3536416292,
0.1907804608,
0.8299087882,
0.456736058,
-0.6155958772,
0.5530187488,
0.0474327467,
-0.5369777679,
0.2851287425,
-0.8951447606,
0.1694929004,
-0.2124302685,
0.2349140346,
-1.0474376678,
-0.428298682,
0.2821117043,
-0.6077621579,
0.1566184014,
-0.1203081831,
-0.6603606343,
-0.2188657522,
-0.3258876801,
0.1169870347,
0.214726299,
-0.604008615,
0.2676974833,
0.4125589728,
-0.2906042635,
-0.7321215272,
-0.8391273022,
0.3379572332,
-0.2083590925,
-0.5726101995,
0.1363465637,
-0.1098432764,
-0.3569120765,
0.0061280313,
0.4147948027,
-0.2615869641,
0.1807683855,
0.1304956824,
0.3638474345,
-0.4567752481,
0.2066675425,
-0.1859973818,
-0.1277556866,
0.0325060338,
-0.4676093161,
0.5160200596,
-0.2031553537,
-0.114514038,
-0.4509174228,
0.5335546732,
0.7138837576,
-0.4608237147,
1.1043788195,
0.8362950683,
-0.4356430173,
-0.1849429756,
-0.4497525394,
0.322904557,
-0.4319759309,
1.033727169,
-0.295925498,
-0.991954565,
0.2224780917,
0.0990644619,
0.4394856095,
0.4234466553,
0.8642778397,
0.0728702173,
0.9807686806,
0.617340982,
-0.6518864036,
0.4555777311,
0.0808141306,
0.1492904872,
-0.4079841971,
-0.2270678282,
-0.8385509849,
-0.0628334954,
-0.7083361745,
-0.369568646,
0.1581831276,
0.2040483356,
-0.3887192905,
0.42470783,
-0.0223080311,
0.3135243654,
0.6961106658,
-0.2823953032,
0.2527461648,
-0.0111364052,
0.2467432916,
0.296086669,
-0.5778677464,
-0.6643794775,
1.129324317,
0.5639638901,
0.7334718108,
0.219882071,
0.4303792715,
0.1023751944,
0.1790442616,
-0.8388831019,
0.3297768235,
-0.2065081298,
-0.7746587396,
-0.6146510243,
-0.4651998281,
-0.8295861483,
0.2890076637,
-0.0601243973,
-0.8983113766,
-0.6567205787,
0.0413803197,
0.0176538508,
0.331097275,
-0.7504498959,
0.7090472579,
-0.4190839529,
-0.3353443742,
-0.4793369472,
-0.7073064446,
0.6142737865,
-0.0579446442,
0.3400131762,
-0.0624341927,
-0.1865997165,
0.5440301895,
-0.2450222969,
0.7153585553,
-0.2452186197,
-0.286596179,
0.4648451209,
-0.2019132227,
0.3961797953,
0.1224002913,
-0.2799408734,
0.3734037876,
0.0498737693,
-0.281008482,
-0.4069092572,
0.8630668521,
-1.1111463308,
-0.4736714065,
-0.1298252046,
-0.5587948561,
-0.1285297275,
0.1466441303,
0.2644192874,
0.3259248137,
-0.2679974139,
0.2067653388,
0.2956008613,
-0.4640075564,
0.4590021372,
0.6394281983,
-0.2620943785,
-0.4266131818,
0.9182863235,
0.0719845667,
0.1644205898,
0.3801779747,
0.1731923521,
-0.3961736262,
-0.4978570938,
-0.7168699503,
0.4141105413,
-0.5068150163,
-0.0177633166,
-0.3895649612,
-0.3255012631,
-0.6138660908,
0.481712997,
-0.5847700834,
-0.4190654755,
-0.3643994033,
0.1206040382,
0.0264778677,
1.049943924,
-0.0429561026,
0.3232544363,
-0.7979415655,
0.6119298339,
0.0774380416,
0.5271058679,
0.0445887186,
-0.616079092,
-0.6275675297,
0.2512702346,
-0.1387910545,
-0.563097775,
0.3269115686,
0.3102695942,
0.7256089449,
0.5424978137,
-0.1167975813,
0.6399763823,
-0.4707822204,
0.851564765,
0.3120217919,
-0.7040553689,
0.5217350721,
-0.3422693312,
0.1694614738,
0.3749808371,
0.3773711324,
-0.8031938672,
-0.1103090197,
0.004304444,
-0.6396241188,
0.9634307623,
-0.2071382403,
0.2647709846,
-0.0027936522,
0.3476060331,
0.2963181138,
0.0673287511,
-0.7508612871,
-0.3859425783,
-0.1753122211,
-0.1955241263,
-0.3722990453,
-0.5096120834,
0.3794928491,
0.0173697006,
0.6892900467,
-0.1960463524,
0.0620123334,
-0.2380542457,
-0.1845261753,
-0.3218628764,
0.3886338472,
0.6790236831,
0.6490718126,
-0.0723387301,
-0.1343524307,
-0.0606710128,
-0.4972109199,
0.0409441255,
0.0559257083,
-0.0886928588,
-0.1063932404,
0.5113815665,
0.7524625063,
-0.0608367845,
-0.8138248324,
0.2350486517,
-0.0046081012,
-0.2919752002,
-0.3416989744,
0.1301288307,
0.4329043031,
0.3486757874,
0.4503297806,
-0.3045652807,
-0.1261238456,
-0.7868850231,
-0.1687273979,
0.4226846993,
-0.1646434218,
-0.4184919596,
0.6707702875,
0.2505427599,
-0.4417900741,
0.823366642,
-0.0931741595,
-0.4671875238,
0.3485269248,
0.7119584084,
0.5645473003,
-0.167408675,
0.2287018299,
0.6799085736,
0.3002788424,
-0.4608572423,
0.1213536561,
0.090626277,
-0.6543541551,
-0.5970317721,
-0.5027700663,
-0.4858531952,
0.7118970752,
-0.5929625034,
0.4106491804,
-0.268637687,
-0.0627684593,
-0.2183313966,
0.3811692595,
-0.4083546102,
0.1012187004,
0.4574647844,
1.0538604259,
-0.6778911352,
1.1614985466,
0.799071312,
-0.2472926825,
-0.7338297963,
-0.0980580077,
-0.0896338895,
-0.6344278455,
0.6269897819,
0.4515403509,
-0.138087377,
-0.1945195794,
-0.6287332773,
-0.8379743695,
1.0063112974,
0.5719724894,
-0.6926115155,
-0.2401196361,
0.4636227489,
0.5644801259,
-0.1395283937,
0.5335019231,
0.515664041,
0.5049083233,
-0.1221544668,
-1.1350631714,
-0.4174823165,
-0.4349184632,
0.0171716511,
-0.0005762518,
-0.9934007525,
0.9609721899,
-0.4630919397,
-0.1110234112,
0.5943036675,
0.8525974154,
0.5457283854,
0.2345882803,
0.3284674287,
0.3461211324,
0.6003381014,
0.1081376597,
0.7182492614,
-0.3330546319,
-0.03042561,
1.1611210108,
-0.3976463974,
1.1294914484,
0.3543569148,
-0.1389746666,
0.4411166906,
0.4713888466,
0.2711035907,
0.4071574807,
0.1434935927,
-0.0974324793,
-0.0971287265,
-0.2470470667,
-0.4644918144,
0.7742010951,
0.3572944701,
-0.0253052805,
-0.0699717551,
-0.3318064511,
-0.0046850294,
0.022689607,
-0.2519512475,
0.5118616223,
0.0318490639,
-0.8720986247,
0.3255975544,
0.6750878096,
0.8718919754,
-0.9594821334,
-0.0266325194,
-0.3322854042,
0.2442328781,
-0.0631492138,
-0.6167030931,
0.0948499739,
0.2941612899,
-0.0983348787,
0.0561792962,
0.7715141177,
-0.5401251316,
-0.4965164959,
0.4839121997,
0.5493968725,
0.1306581795,
-0.2457208931,
-0.5898959041,
0.1752897799,
-0.3157107234,
-0.5003480315,
0.4753815532,
0.4625321627,
-0.1786352992,
0.787291646,
0.5381315351,
0.229368329,
-0.1401844472,
0.2179318815,
0.7309166789,
-0.7407248616,
-0.5743003488,
-0.7551332116,
0.3593041301,
0.2980552018,
-0.3929433525,
0.5745046735,
0.5352144837,
0.9114128351,
-0.0232452676,
1.0863643885,
0.0637937784,
0.5778422356,
-0.3726801276,
0.8676185012,
-0.5762368441,
-0.0142877605,
-0.0836075842,
-0.792571485,
-0.0131040076,
0.4416131079,
0.2247841358,
0.0889637843,
0.2748396993,
0.7647255659,
0.2023896575,
-0.0845430046,
0.4367530346,
0.2146684378,
0.3458872139,
0.9341887832,
1.0661267042,
-0.3893607855,
0.6501696706,
0.0519253425,
-0.1172038615,
-0.2497230768,
-0.7813440561,
-1.0760793686,
-0.6407107711,
0.0525599308,
-0.0475598872,
-0.0716352165,
1.1079535484,
0.8245392442,
-0.7349094748,
-0.503342092,
0.100259237,
-0.2146382779,
0.0240741782,
-0.1105552614,
-0.0051151523,
-0.3999003172,
-0.7696528435,
0.6342746019,
0.1568504572,
-0.2236131728,
-0.695194602,
-0.5636604428,
-0.0976512432,
-0.1033440754,
0.612505734,
0.2620008588,
-0.9663231373,
-0.0763754174,
-0.0354492627,
-0.3076680005,
-0.1225691885,
0.6248710752,
-0.7230446339,
0.193407774,
0.3841362894,
0.3933275044,
0.1602120101,
-0.0773335695,
0.5671054125,
-0.3889106512,
0.3926674426,
-0.2569138408,
0.1917657256,
0.3521626592,
-0.1477970183,
0.3766692579,
-0.0701131448,
-0.3098426759,
-0.6799892783,
0.1902850568,
-0.7637026906,
-0.5181359053,
1.305170536,
-0.239808619,
-0.0370888598,
0.0049489317,
-0.252191633,
0.5399662256,
-0.2619014382,
0.6624875069,
0.650719285,
0.3578725755,
-0.1805430055,
-0.6780951619,
0.0642310753,
0.1326729953,
-0.8752698302,
0.2013176829,
0.4919790924,
0.2204529643,
-0.0016011004,
0.5582896471,
-0.0006322011,
0.396656841,
0.1070158631,
-0.1084053144,
-0.5700553656,
-0.6133755445,
-0.3385763466,
0.1493998319,
0.5301952362,
-0.0895051733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.09454v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.09454v1
|
Voila-A: Aligning Vision-Language Models with User's Gaze Attention
| 2023-12-22T17:34:01 | 2023-12-22T17:34:01 |
Kun Yan, Lei Ji, Zeyu Wang, Yuntao Wang, Nan Duan, Shuai Ma
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In recent years, the integration of vision and language understanding has led
to significant advancements in artificial intelligence, particularly through
Vision-Language Models (VLMs). However, existing VLMs face challenges in
handling real-world applications with complex scenes and multiple objects, as
well as aligning their focus with the diverse attention patterns of human
users. In this paper, we introduce gaze information, feasibly collected by AR
or VR devices, as a proxy for human attention to guide VLMs and propose a novel
approach, Voila-A, for gaze alignment to enhance the interpretability and
effectiveness of these models in real-world applications. First, we collect
hundreds of minutes of gaze data to demonstrate that we can mimic human gaze
modalities using localized narratives. We then design an automatic data
annotation pipeline utilizing GPT-4 to generate the VOILA-COCO dataset.
Additionally, we innovate the Voila Perceiver modules to integrate gaze
information into VLMs while preserving their pretrained knowledge. We evaluate
Voila-A using a hold-out validation set and a newly collected VOILA-GAZE
Testset, which features real-life scenarios captured with a gaze-tracking
device. Our experimental results demonstrate that Voila-A significantly
outperforms several baseline models. By aligning model attention with human
gaze patterns, Voila-A paves the way for more intuitive, user-centric VLMs and
fosters engaging human-AI interaction across a wide range of applications.
|
[
-0.3542151451,
-0.5921714902,
0.5583146811,
-0.0011332859,
-0.1890702844,
0.0216901042,
0.1388302594,
-0.6878585219,
0.3453248441,
0.6446411014,
-0.5499460697,
-0.4617532492,
-0.0929170325,
-0.3615977764,
-0.6209537387,
0.2969184518,
-0.0227785986,
0.004756114,
-0.5460638404,
-0.2822344601,
-0.4636983573,
-0.6049462557,
-0.1647606492,
0.0466095172,
0.6610090137,
0.1610052586,
0.6600992084,
0.6098577976,
0.6134187579,
0.1758655906,
0.1255784035,
0.3768244386,
-0.3464436233,
-0.2288584113,
-0.0809938163,
-0.5018640161,
-0.3927617967,
-0.0578539893,
0.3252907395,
0.4268448055,
-0.2459781468,
0.5780593157,
0.0364230983,
0.7004290819,
-0.7722238898,
-0.1914240569,
-0.3534386456,
0.0710234195,
-0.1200364977,
0.0933205485,
-0.4189939797,
-0.4433229864,
0.6466953158,
-0.9913612008,
0.1629102528,
0.3236892223,
1.2840616703,
0.7710370421,
0.0447497815,
0.3722539246,
-0.7045260072,
0.7321538329,
-0.5470975637,
0.526997447,
0.1486208439,
0.5259363651,
0.1871905774,
-0.3783299029,
-0.8541952372,
-0.1733005941,
-0.0306868572,
0.2433864623,
-0.0485495925,
-0.0839873403,
0.208455354,
0.0505075641,
-0.6149790287,
-0.1546741277,
-0.3944574893,
-0.1031764075,
0.3546836972,
0.1879598349,
0.471226126,
0.2489252537,
-0.8241720796,
0.0164892264,
-0.5190060139,
0.243719399,
0.135664016,
0.1609599739,
-0.1506332755,
1.057866931,
-0.4697178006,
1.1565264463,
0.3604173958,
0.0869358927,
0.2903248668,
-0.4506472945,
-0.2878240347,
0.0427348316,
0.6092143655,
0.6277361512,
0.4258002937,
-0.2267946005,
0.2264041752,
0.4409071803,
0.9283445477,
-0.2122283429,
-0.167053178,
0.2265941352,
-0.2652205229,
-0.4136627018,
-0.0328857303,
-0.8060482144,
-0.4460043311,
-0.888725996,
0.6633429527,
-0.0180015564,
-0.2806920707,
0.3334117234,
0.0887344629,
0.5920577049,
0.526027739,
-0.6849639416,
-0.0470123403,
0.39885813,
0.7659931183,
-0.3129551113,
-0.4581858814,
-0.6981068254,
0.271163702,
-0.1093393713,
0.7243322134,
-0.5438693166,
0.0810743794,
0.1666168422,
-0.0635502487,
-0.258392185,
-0.3189641535,
0.2072934508,
-0.3450776935,
0.3640907705,
-0.3591614366,
-0.1475929171,
-0.2259569019,
0.4220611751,
-0.3864622414,
1.0286817551,
0.0375214219,
-0.9052939415,
0.3598034084,
-0.6380488276,
-0.3016565442,
0.3527950943,
-0.1110954881,
-0.4471472502,
0.1928140521,
0.2477499545,
-0.0302654635,
0.0073350137,
-0.0693811774,
-0.3172523975,
-0.3380354643,
0.2214485258,
-0.2691462934,
0.7580786943,
-0.2579117417,
-0.4726698399,
0.2878364325,
-0.4273895323,
0.0510339774,
-0.0349348299,
0.0537740551,
-0.2336096317,
0.2507887781,
0.0816765875,
0.2088118643,
0.5522248745,
-0.5975447893,
0.3095890582,
-0.4075835347,
0.291939646,
0.3579600751,
-0.4257602394,
0.4137276411,
0.0598850548,
0.5342427492,
-0.056405317,
0.6980465055,
0.0000545089,
-0.2869172096,
-0.8198419213,
-0.0956702158,
0.2759540379,
0.7878569365,
-0.7083569765,
0.0304043535,
-0.2800988555,
-0.0885696188,
-0.9831552505,
0.2618974149,
0.5076624751,
0.8718354106,
0.253490895,
-0.5292528868,
-0.5288153887,
-0.9389993548,
-0.1178616732,
-0.2652026415,
-0.0147838127,
0.5429541469,
-0.1981578618,
-0.3714662492,
1.2518231869,
-0.4777156413,
-0.5092984438,
-0.0485584885,
-0.0897972137,
-0.3114656806,
-0.0080486033,
0.557911098,
-1.1851110458,
-0.4302370548,
0.2950885594,
-0.9334406853,
-0.1622031778,
0.1333519518,
-0.5703700781,
-0.0732130334,
0.4305838048,
-0.6149893999,
0.6092615128,
0.4728678167,
-0.2547714114,
0.6500025988,
0.0680792481,
0.0375798941,
-0.8208924532,
0.3184623718,
0.3075377643,
-0.2702032328,
-0.6626909375,
-0.0623635463,
-0.0630690306,
-0.0403710715,
-0.8491122127,
0.9019469023,
-0.5126556754,
-0.0628662482,
-0.2555292249,
0.5045952797,
0.2159481049,
0.6850650907,
0.2214485258,
0.682076335,
0.8880332708,
-0.6136586666,
0.432492137,
0.6020715237,
-0.336663872,
0.6163018346,
-0.5258293748,
0.0122915935,
0.0490193367,
-0.2957502604,
-0.8320239782,
-0.5540897846,
0.4497575164,
-0.4479993582,
0.0895862132,
-0.1200944856,
-0.0897114575,
-0.5468449593,
-0.0631358474,
0.6939911246,
0.2333544046,
-0.7388250828,
1.0321348906,
0.7330236435,
0.0334004052,
-0.8618035316,
-0.4441770017,
0.2685791254,
-0.2935038209,
-0.3495345712,
0.1875381172,
0.0073917401,
-0.2886978686,
0.146396026,
-0.0954553187,
0.1026930511,
-0.1993228495,
0.2728880346,
0.7443066239,
-0.3084937036,
-0.2093426138,
-0.4176321328,
-0.1052249223,
-0.2671073079,
-0.3599770367,
0.3038167655,
-0.0505296998,
-0.3995283842,
-0.9043741226,
0.2179085761,
1.0219898224,
-0.5917605758,
0.404204756,
0.5993251801,
-0.2880824804,
0.1754802614,
-0.8772157431,
0.1544613689,
-0.4172510207,
0.136687994,
-0.1524842829,
-0.6732017398,
0.1214785576,
-0.1374492347,
0.190948382,
0.0202859826,
0.6652532816,
-0.4540623724,
1.3985962868,
1.0690370798,
-0.2207221687,
1.0163997412,
-0.0151524395,
0.5876662731,
-0.9661458135,
-0.3908401132,
0.0181392003,
-0.2811148167,
0.1319552958,
-0.3763208389,
0.3245046437,
-0.0346105918,
0.0815663785,
0.642837286,
-0.6454843879,
0.4758957326,
0.6442859173,
0.1569126844,
-0.0706944168,
0.0258593522,
0.1282561868,
0.1014116257,
-0.5230023265,
-0.5167393088,
0.789208293,
0.1105901003,
0.6113460064,
0.0280378237,
0.2674978673,
0.2519994676,
0.286753118,
-0.8088053465,
0.4966332614,
-0.0622813962,
-0.3780726492,
-0.3597576022,
0.1004457846,
-0.5382509232,
0.3023237288,
-0.1304070801,
-1.2348794937,
0.4106698334,
0.6322519779,
-0.6193169951,
-0.1426567733,
-1.1073691845,
1.1431452036,
-0.5864936113,
-0.7593218684,
0.0304740705,
-0.6950477958,
0.304176271,
0.1428924948,
-0.0346645713,
-0.1777844727,
0.1714751422,
0.0552555919,
-0.1828939319,
1.1697175503,
-0.1909280419,
-0.0286411699,
0.4308090806,
-0.2884943187,
0.291082412,
-0.1578960121,
0.3466913402,
0.2405907363,
-0.2495682687,
-0.4120835364,
-0.3614206612,
0.4797926843,
-0.3299155831,
-0.7388597131,
-0.2123247832,
-0.4380767643,
-0.336935252,
0.1804335713,
0.2263091654,
0.5483224988,
-0.2243666798,
-0.0130517734,
0.606477201,
0.059285406,
0.1826651394,
0.4931817949,
-0.3963978291,
-0.0438577831,
1.1744459867,
-0.3019860089,
0.1917799413,
0.5016813874,
-0.1044176891,
-0.4706119895,
-0.1306134909,
-0.7927229404,
0.1541815996,
-0.1979984641,
-0.0783123076,
-0.6498308778,
-0.2206464708,
-0.2188875377,
-0.432015419,
-0.4125962555,
-0.1354781389,
-0.066843845,
0.0043442599,
-0.0066568684,
0.3034632802,
0.2548842132,
0.2083860785,
-0.4875983894,
0.7743265033,
0.4939131439,
0.1995932162,
-0.1063917354,
-0.2206550688,
-0.4114098847,
0.3081920445,
-0.1727558225,
-0.5455794334,
0.4832740426,
0.1816505194,
0.7721815109,
0.3683600128,
-0.0465492085,
0.7629163265,
-0.5601252913,
0.7993733287,
0.5324933529,
-0.8030534387,
0.6587938666,
-0.1778373122,
0.3694206774,
0.5897159576,
0.0069887498,
-0.1966307759,
-0.440173924,
-0.2101208121,
-0.9161766768,
0.6835231781,
0.1612206101,
0.0071208505,
0.4318688512,
0.361268729,
-0.029180048,
0.3187222183,
-0.6294965148,
0.0072966265,
-0.2965663373,
-0.5819981694,
0.0464617237,
-0.0636656955,
-0.2929010689,
-0.2134986371,
0.3378953636,
-0.1877673119,
-0.0049728397,
0.212594226,
-0.3067438602,
-0.1372915208,
-0.3171315193,
0.5231016874,
0.7740953565,
0.0480870456,
-0.0744680092,
-0.1075422764,
-0.6899074316,
-0.1115961,
-0.1715061367,
-0.4472528398,
-0.1358339339,
-0.1311327517,
0.8623296022,
0.1119562089,
-0.9062700868,
0.5317385793,
-0.2156824917,
-0.0823376626,
-0.1507965624,
0.2038359046,
-0.006305031,
0.4487417638,
0.2609427273,
0.1251406372,
0.1906512529,
-0.4420856535,
0.1215585843,
0.5072024465,
-0.7092213035,
-0.3221678436,
1.0508990288,
0.2791195214,
-0.553368032,
0.1566464752,
0.2019128352,
-0.6560176015,
0.4670698643,
0.1681193262,
1.0154705048,
-0.2057339698,
0.4014809132,
0.3175995052,
0.0704280362,
-0.1753751189,
0.1161491349,
-0.292250365,
-0.6482974887,
-0.3676304221,
-0.9037213326,
-0.7372345924,
-0.1122183576,
-0.7909621596,
0.3007078767,
0.0936327279,
-0.3856136203,
0.1800099164,
-0.4494192004,
-0.6243382096,
0.3271048963,
0.4869254231,
0.3071255684,
-0.7086274624,
0.7454873919,
0.7986209393,
-0.3156671524,
-0.368300885,
0.3845134079,
0.1311092973,
-0.8036642075,
0.342540592,
0.361700207,
-0.7002383471,
-0.0020036644,
-0.6625608802,
-0.8965024948,
0.7420545816,
0.4153118432,
-0.8765314817,
-0.0444907807,
-0.1098557487,
0.6430832744,
-0.3638791442,
-0.4355659485,
0.3702163994,
0.3247212172,
0.2160993069,
-0.8075836897,
-0.5286107063,
-0.3973117471,
-0.214307636,
0.2900090516,
-0.7894366384,
0.1233913377,
-0.4900879562,
-0.3205090463,
-0.0217858944,
0.5805110931,
0.0040098592,
0.5236136317,
0.4401780665,
0.5123353601,
0.4641666114,
-0.0697343871,
0.8746603131,
-0.3212121427,
0.084927693,
1.0500472784,
-0.5060971975,
0.9654356241,
0.6438816786,
0.0529863089,
0.2108606398,
0.4092321396,
0.0924161896,
0.6568678021,
-0.1431960613,
-0.2426634133,
-0.4751305878,
-0.2853016853,
-0.0167000592,
0.3508132696,
0.2282620519,
0.1795366406,
0.2428538054,
0.2725584209,
-0.6745783687,
0.0089913215,
-0.2154188305,
0.8038758636,
0.0152146937,
-0.7226393223,
0.4533925056,
-0.6397112608,
0.3392565846,
-0.2316269279,
-0.0390120931,
0.0398664623,
0.3876052797,
-0.0919541419,
-0.5312000513,
0.0050490508,
0.3640682101,
-0.4408716857,
0.1145747453,
0.4584697187,
-0.672203958,
-0.7004879117,
0.2440238744,
0.2250424027,
-0.1233813316,
-0.1047060564,
-0.5220181346,
0.0953546688,
0.1617485285,
-0.0984672531,
0.3637678921,
0.1822494864,
-0.142646715,
0.8097425699,
0.4594405591,
-0.1713095456,
0.3391073346,
0.3806802034,
0.7403077483,
-0.4069528282,
-0.2662802935,
-0.5810847878,
0.7789993286,
-0.1540415287,
-0.4093952775,
0.6914512515,
0.6013025641,
0.7002116442,
0.0603731722,
0.8067041039,
0.0823925659,
0.4872596562,
-0.3943091333,
0.3408125639,
-0.8673552871,
-0.0259991977,
-0.141590327,
-1.1063898802,
-0.1939196885,
0.5177465677,
-0.2374786437,
-0.4545821846,
0.2997822762,
0.4496434629,
-0.2855452895,
-0.3971049786,
0.4231340587,
0.1533920467,
-0.0224842317,
0.338317275,
0.7038503289,
-0.3122752011,
0.5407145619,
-0.1493109912,
-0.2406321466,
-0.7306019068,
-0.5507819057,
-0.7265121937,
-0.6318317652,
-0.571174264,
-0.0602062456,
0.1092082635,
0.2433841079,
0.5938493013,
-0.5410072207,
0.033704415,
-0.0073963013,
-0.2496895492,
-0.5096464753,
-0.1951444894,
0.2896747291,
-0.2611816525,
-0.8617505431,
0.5130618811,
0.6314364076,
0.1429788023,
-0.3282351196,
-0.0688160285,
-0.0913974643,
0.2201420069,
0.6853964925,
0.7158679366,
-1.2215747833,
-0.4622493386,
0.3894011676,
-0.1637619734,
0.1028151587,
0.4868482649,
-0.8767749667,
0.9817141891,
0.1925261021,
0.448862344,
0.626947999,
0.6981577873,
0.8464727998,
-0.4896088541,
0.1784136295,
0.1343257129,
0.1756424904,
0.3589020967,
-0.4254807532,
0.5068390965,
-0.1184535846,
-0.2317082286,
-1.0320266485,
0.2169188559,
-1.5916324854,
0.107223697,
0.9842962623,
-0.0128761958,
-0.5735923648,
-0.2451978177,
-0.8765870929,
0.0729398578,
0.0303731039,
1.0563054085,
0.562384367,
0.0270524733,
-0.1889106631,
-0.7071356177,
0.4357185066,
0.5068044662,
-0.5513747931,
0.4286712706,
0.5026951432,
-0.0161787532,
0.363781482,
0.2449877858,
-0.104688406,
0.5672389269,
-0.110135898,
0.3515738249,
0.1445220858,
-0.6413328052,
0.0587056354,
0.1441885829,
-0.3492518365,
-0.7031334043
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14845v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14845v1
|
On the Use of Metaphor Translation in Psychiatry
| 2023-12-22T17:19:33 | 2023-12-22T17:19:33 |
Lois Wong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Providing mental healthcare to individuals with limited English proficiency
(LEP) remains a pressing problem within psychiatry. Because the majority of
individuals trained in providing psychiatric care are English speakers, the
quality of mental healthcare given to LEP patients is significantly lower than
that provided for English speakers. The provision of mental healthcare is
contingent on communication and understanding between the patient and
healthcare provider, much more so than in the realm of physical healthcare, and
English speakers are often unable to comprehend figurative language such as
metaphors used by LEPs. Hence, Figurative Language Translation is invaluable to
providing equitable psychiatric care. Now, metaphor has been shown to be
paramount in both identifying individuals struggling with mental problems and
helping those individuals understand and communicate their experiences.
Therefore, this paper aims to survey the potential of Machine Translation for
providing equitable psychiatric healthcare and highlights the need for further
research on the transferability of existing machine and metaphor translation
research in the domain of psychiatry.
|
[
-0.2236795127,
-0.3331311941,
0.9969584346,
0.4042953551,
-0.3244794905,
-0.0657147467,
0.1167084798,
-0.6407048106,
0.4491770864,
0.2467341274,
-0.5060726404,
0.0941865221,
-1.1475943327,
0.5489809513,
-0.3136790693,
0.6370611787,
-0.3327968717,
0.3408786356,
-0.1075512692,
-0.1035342067,
-0.6870919466,
-0.6635875106,
-0.9707893729,
-0.527107954,
0.4364522696,
-0.3611416519,
1.0036711693,
0.4248797596,
0.6319482923,
0.3118129373,
0.3972479999,
0.0704452023,
-0.2901796401,
0.027897317,
-0.4810758531,
-0.5399469137,
-0.2350139916,
0.1330485642,
0.5398514867,
0.9402105212,
-0.3254782557,
0.008567756,
-0.1154693589,
0.4818511009,
-0.4733687043,
0.1790900528,
-0.6108317375,
0.5637264252,
0.089982897,
-0.1218366846,
-0.1315564513,
0.0252977312,
-0.1606014222,
-0.8577412367,
-0.1048049182,
0.3753739595,
0.950006485,
0.7428005934,
-0.3971483111,
-0.0501972958,
-0.5402662158,
0.6650255919,
-0.5981839299,
0.3290979564,
0.5334591866,
0.7161096931,
-0.3129754663,
-0.9117974639,
-0.7027589679,
-0.0739431083,
-0.4898205996,
0.0166735761,
-0.5325636864,
-0.1382364631,
0.5190965533,
0.1372835338,
-0.2821653783,
0.0518050902,
-0.594338119,
-0.3475347459,
0.4654836655,
0.5184388757,
0.8696623445,
-0.2119852602,
-0.1812516451,
0.0742463917,
-0.1337730438,
-0.230807662,
-0.189450711,
-0.0245310068,
-0.2089747638,
0.7452183962,
0.3030277491,
0.5885159373,
-0.4540798962,
-0.4958260655,
0.1491474658,
0.1186500788,
-0.373111248,
0.3653713167,
0.5565983653,
0.6932764053,
0.1329006255,
-0.3506800532,
-0.1771092266,
0.5540115237,
0.6577249765,
-0.5765517354,
0.0400210284,
0.1606509984,
-0.5083806515,
0.3999032676,
-0.1034318432,
-0.6258837581,
-0.5399737954,
-0.306989044,
0.260260582,
-0.5465633273,
-0.0559449494,
0.5855821371,
-0.3025437593,
0.2152245045,
0.6149209738,
-0.659068644,
0.4547828734,
0.7182597518,
1.101169467,
-0.1959988922,
-0.3558489084,
-0.2483715713,
0.6569231749,
-0.3874256313,
0.4745862186,
-0.2329953462,
-0.1984855831,
-0.0822131261,
0.2051160932,
-0.3345822394,
-0.3505139351,
0.6062879562,
0.2283351272,
0.3274335861,
-0.0142447306,
-0.5239053369,
0.1107116863,
0.1939139664,
-0.5489637256,
0.2408949733,
0.5661258101,
-0.8292858005,
-0.0457978174,
-0.3496049345,
-0.4005539119,
0.0616454966,
-0.6040810347,
-0.0081117209,
0.4616263211,
0.4708874822,
0.4670852125,
-0.5231128335,
0.0652535483,
-0.0970952213,
-0.4823088944,
0.6522581577,
-0.1807249635,
0.7158200145,
0.5474803448,
-0.2811858356,
-0.495113194,
-0.2142567486,
-0.17889826,
0.4160511792,
0.3021795452,
-0.5547423959,
-0.1877943426,
0.359687537,
0.5053430796,
0.0319935754,
-0.3465645909,
-0.059749987,
-0.5386484265,
0.4298120141,
0.4687100649,
-0.0531508476,
0.2052082866,
-0.5629118085,
0.8817647696,
-0.0372259766,
0.0525603667,
-0.0311130863,
-0.6414784789,
-0.3083019257,
-0.8124908209,
0.305410713,
0.6170148849,
-0.789588809,
0.1956751645,
-0.2937567532,
-0.1598496139,
-1.2665960789,
-0.4767740965,
0.0741939768,
0.6461594105,
0.4740859866,
-0.433765322,
-0.4724144042,
-1.1348637342,
-0.515607357,
-0.1487255543,
-0.2242982984,
0.4260542989,
0.4266428649,
-0.5174503326,
0.4220610559,
-0.401604414,
-0.6646302938,
-0.2850773931,
-0.1597837657,
0.074971512,
0.2762144506,
0.697614193,
-0.6142472029,
-0.4245984554,
0.0054103201,
-1.0902551413,
-0.3586537242,
-0.3326770365,
-0.2660060823,
-0.1712476015,
0.4292351007,
-0.6795189381,
0.3415807486,
0.6058021188,
-0.4051906168,
0.273855865,
-0.3573080003,
0.3636747599,
-1.5106790066,
0.0588292852,
-0.1849353611,
-0.3862879872,
-0.3896924555,
0.2880228758,
-0.2407523543,
-0.187233761,
-0.5234051347,
0.6729846001,
-0.2232441157,
0.1817149967,
-0.0715954974,
0.2033140808,
-0.2487177253,
-0.2924798131,
-0.1744776815,
0.8797285557,
0.4787422121,
-0.2736221254,
0.3441991508,
0.0850767121,
-0.0129799582,
1.0338566303,
-0.5027037263,
-0.0629382282,
-0.0303077642,
0.3144902885,
-0.4657227695,
-0.2808564603,
0.5900611281,
-0.1985377073,
0.09333276,
0.4061782956,
-0.6584565639,
-0.2687110007,
0.2055071741,
0.3620161116,
0.7809707522,
0.0204406641,
0.0511038266,
0.6220391393,
-0.2181034535,
-0.3681395352,
-0.6857414246,
0.4285425544,
-0.4554611146,
-0.2055244297,
0.5040982962,
0.4374909997,
-0.6052290201,
-0.0814200491,
-0.0960911289,
-0.0952540636,
0.1045293063,
0.034041971,
0.0129843168,
-0.0864805877,
0.1377437115,
0.3931446671,
-0.4157907367,
0.2945486009,
-0.2223955095,
0.485363692,
0.0877738446,
-0.4621049166,
-0.6235303283,
0.8822616339,
0.7515100837,
0.2829350233,
1.2002193928,
0.5279160738,
-0.8319433928,
0.0266229548,
-0.3428585529,
-0.2335138321,
-0.3142967522,
0.3416474164,
-0.3963609934,
-0.7587734461,
0.2328466624,
-0.3723293543,
-0.3607078195,
0.4390946627,
0.3046178818,
-0.5035205483,
1.1706625223,
0.637000978,
-0.1621915996,
-0.2463254333,
0.3812832832,
0.6196776032,
-0.7088448405,
-0.0489818491,
-0.680213511,
-0.4443928301,
-0.7580063343,
-0.5494015813,
0.5394285321,
0.128109172,
-0.0415050834,
0.2770439684,
-0.5802386999,
-0.1199339479,
-0.1550989896,
0.1680152118,
0.3678384125,
0.2923783064,
-0.0910864621,
-0.9761499763,
-0.4779807329,
-0.6355206966,
0.4352734685,
0.5637751222,
0.6444198489,
-0.0024443092,
0.5660039783,
0.4098795354,
0.1729272455,
-0.7163367271,
0.4618440568,
0.0174222123,
-0.1315828264,
-0.1113843173,
-0.3929252923,
-1.3516590595,
0.393589437,
-0.0099524185,
-0.7550108433,
0.025830796,
-0.139519155,
0.1846983582,
0.1971746534,
-0.3143469393,
0.6304748058,
-0.5245170593,
0.4164398909,
-0.470729053,
-0.8396525383,
0.140112564,
-0.3474492133,
0.4235717058,
-0.2850727141,
-0.4110016227,
0.5159580708,
-0.2746927142,
0.3822100461,
0.1833400279,
-0.1429608464,
-0.5316159725,
0.1450460255,
-0.053333398,
0.0217562057,
0.0053922632,
0.3852609992,
0.297755152,
-0.6057480574,
-0.8912923336,
0.36597386,
-0.9985037446,
-0.8560425043,
-0.7771205902,
-0.9151373506,
-0.279540211,
-0.032765124,
0.2363150865,
-0.4065647125,
-0.0060030059,
-0.3572691679,
0.2587063909,
-0.4335948229,
-0.2576705813,
0.3943390846,
-0.4104235172,
-0.2028627247,
0.6607326865,
0.1116525456,
-0.0614497215,
0.193736881,
0.0620041341,
-0.0638759136,
-0.1144896448,
-0.5110561252,
0.7609683275,
-0.5590702295,
0.0143549284,
-0.80712533,
-0.5068177581,
-0.4875804186,
-0.613487184,
-0.1733850688,
-0.540551424,
-0.0895779878,
0.0574754253,
0.2809194326,
0.4662756622,
0.0963955149,
0.0913267285,
-0.5665438771,
0.6460586786,
-0.0749597996,
-0.1296487153,
-0.264778167,
-0.5962108374,
-0.1195085049,
0.0082841301,
-0.1663317978,
-1.4366396666,
0.7244598269,
-0.0838526785,
0.5885336399,
0.1979690194,
0.0888301134,
1.0374823809,
-0.9496432543,
0.7878718376,
0.6955068707,
-0.8121073246,
0.6903683543,
-0.1540114284,
0.082595855,
0.4190419614,
0.9343140721,
-1.1089296341,
-0.5767902732,
-0.6709292531,
-0.894598186,
0.5480325818,
0.216767624,
0.5071188807,
-0.031195933,
0.461587429,
0.1723733693,
0.5098178983,
-0.4679180384,
-0.5165339708,
0.0734572932,
-0.2262033224,
-0.4045124054,
0.1110985428,
-0.4709793925,
-0.6010398865,
0.3802357316,
0.1723200679,
0.7276543379,
0.3001866639,
0.0128122913,
-0.1580667794,
0.3936766684,
0.0605591014,
0.5200427771,
0.183448717,
0.2733618617,
-0.0675207749,
-0.4950672686,
0.4254694879,
0.3822801411,
-0.2582833767,
0.3932467401,
0.0581910498,
0.6520203948,
-0.0274648517,
-0.7503305078,
0.3269138932,
0.0508909933,
0.1979681402,
-0.1324556768,
-0.0523500256,
0.0493052155,
0.2265784889,
0.0618311353,
-0.2195511013,
0.3387044072,
-0.6217316389,
0.1130036935,
0.2830910087,
-0.3385331035,
0.0246146489,
0.7514169812,
-0.272144109,
-0.7373946905,
1.0052310228,
0.1701990068,
-0.2272350043,
0.409024775,
1.197860837,
0.8643820286,
-0.1818223447,
0.4259822667,
0.0944048613,
0.6267943978,
-0.1333750784,
0.0668148249,
0.2957838774,
-0.5362738371,
-0.2188566327,
-0.6106455326,
-0.4956756234,
0.2899536788,
-0.8989086151,
0.2514576912,
0.0055714389,
-0.4828104675,
-0.2435132116,
-0.5117329955,
-0.7402901053,
-0.0477511771,
0.3074018061,
0.8585870862,
-1.0447843075,
0.6510144472,
1.3845384121,
-0.4563108981,
-0.7219361067,
0.228148073,
-0.2357627302,
-0.5018537641,
0.2010635883,
0.1010692343,
-0.1038372964,
-0.0160737392,
-0.2751107216,
-0.3278190494,
0.9592590928,
1.093773365,
-0.1457624286,
-0.1282344908,
0.5649447441,
0.8955751061,
-0.6253963113,
-0.0202089697,
0.5689414144,
0.4253987074,
-0.4543138742,
-1.337762475,
0.2094923407,
-0.2064270377,
0.4766151011,
-0.1338484883,
-0.2478174418,
0.705801487,
-0.072866112,
-0.2081294656,
-0.0471241623,
0.4756111205,
0.274553448,
0.4051770866,
0.2467755973,
0.6012964845,
0.7252488136,
0.0155627737,
1.2862980366,
-0.052168265,
0.0458262712,
0.8381700516,
-0.4506921172,
0.6890769601,
1.1141891479,
-0.3776372075,
0.3332498074,
0.5295387506,
0.2525754273,
0.4231368899,
0.2745660245,
-0.4384635687,
-0.0997425243,
-0.5611456633,
-0.543264091,
0.1956041753,
0.6440269947,
-0.749907732,
-0.2006223351,
0.1937944442,
0.158478573,
0.5693536401,
-0.2459602505,
0.5461853743,
0.7381003499,
-0.4089795649,
0.5333439708,
0.4082506001,
0.2727386951,
-0.5444787741,
-0.2382726371,
-0.0219205152,
-0.0068972507,
-0.0426285863,
-0.4751125276,
0.5813906789,
-0.1705871075,
0.057275448,
-0.5131619573,
0.6284595132,
-0.0724081025,
-0.6497055292,
0.4634878635,
1.1393041611,
0.7181594372,
0.2262287289,
-1.0565341711,
-0.1255220771,
-0.3272576332,
0.3230747879,
0.7438791394,
0.6050490737,
-0.1784696281,
0.7789651752,
0.2798689306,
0.710717082,
0.0028759572,
-0.028014617,
0.5226795673,
-0.4071492255,
-0.6180865169,
-0.8005630374,
0.1843519509,
-0.0541081354,
-0.116002731,
0.7148822546,
0.2036592811,
0.8898234367,
-0.5015075803,
0.7642016411,
-0.2179590762,
0.0731493011,
-0.196775347,
0.8624022007,
-0.8197337985,
-0.1766842753,
-0.3747030795,
-0.7098861933,
-0.338829875,
1.2727273703,
-0.130878225,
-0.3038995862,
1.084615469,
0.4143663645,
-0.0921405703,
-0.2468909621,
0.7791486382,
0.1749097407,
-0.1441760063,
0.4626736939,
0.9655519128,
-0.5257618427,
-0.1763085723,
-0.1437025964,
0.1659306139,
0.3293915689,
-0.7154878974,
-0.5693405271,
-0.522695899,
-0.2105223686,
-0.509499073,
0.3647541404,
1.2072048187,
0.3283785284,
-0.577673018,
-0.3541077673,
0.2753307223,
0.0248131678,
-0.7020708323,
-0.219001323,
0.2683444619,
-0.3088622987,
-0.7966774702,
0.0002086019,
0.5599240065,
-0.002703602,
-0.4288434684,
-0.0514193214,
0.090202488,
0.0792988241,
0.4993105829,
-0.0256080385,
-1.0298393965,
0.1346326321,
-0.2478661239,
-0.5930413008,
-0.0012174917,
0.9247580767,
-0.7638183236,
0.353436023,
0.0367585048,
1.096539855,
0.0236458797,
-0.3238331378,
0.8285892606,
-0.340254575,
0.3212814927,
0.4175806046,
0.6199635267,
0.3985966742,
-0.6259555221,
0.596114397,
0.4341630936,
-0.1618253291,
-1.0092983246,
0.2869183421,
-0.6420652866,
-0.2688653767,
0.9551828504,
-0.342305243,
-0.0469137989,
-0.3826274872,
-0.5307320952,
0.4082072377,
-0.2507202029,
1.0566427708,
0.4828214347,
-0.427077204,
-0.3982937336,
-1.1401313543,
0.3380616605,
0.5797463655,
-0.7569513917,
-0.518889904,
0.38792786,
0.0718080401,
-0.0998554528,
0.9747959375,
-0.368984133,
0.1337922513,
-0.1340535432,
-0.0181326885,
0.3341196477,
0.0159425419,
-0.2458070964,
0.1204861999,
-0.0673586652,
0.0406781957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14798v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14798v1
|
Semantic Parsing for Complex Data Retrieval: Targeting Query Plans vs. SQL for No-Code Access to Relational Databases
| 2023-12-22T16:16:15 | 2023-12-22T16:16:15 |
Ben Eyal, Amir Bachar, Ophir Haroche, Michael Elhadad
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have spurred progress in text-to-SQL, the task
of generating SQL queries from natural language questions based on a given
database schema. Despite the declarative nature of SQL, it continues to be a
complex programming language. In this paper, we investigate the potential of an
alternative query language with simpler syntax and modular specification of
complex queries. The purpose is to create a query language that can be learned
more easily by modern neural semantic parsing architectures while also enabling
non-programmers to better assess the validity of the query plans produced by an
interactive query plan assistant.
The proposed alternative query language is called Query Plan Language (QPL).
It is designed to be modular and can be translated into a restricted form of
SQL Common Table Expressions (CTEs). The aim of QPL is to make complex data
retrieval accessible to non-programmers by allowing users to express their
questions in natural language while also providing an easier-to-verify target
language. The paper demonstrates how neural LLMs can benefit from QPL's
modularity to generate complex query plans in a compositional manner. This
involves a question decomposition strategy and a planning stage.
We conduct experiments on a version of the Spider text-to-SQL dataset that
has been converted to QPL. The hierarchical structure of QPL programs enables
us to measure query complexity naturally. Based on this assessment, we identify
the low accuracy of existing text-to-SQL systems on complex compositional
queries. We present ways to address the challenge of complex queries in an
iterative, user-controlled manner, using fine-tuned LLMs and a variety of
prompting strategies in a compositional manner.
|
[
-0.2219286263,
-0.9173328876,
0.7953609824,
0.3180449903,
-0.0929056928,
0.0495510511,
-0.1754834056,
-0.3205194175,
0.3069501221,
0.6756560802,
-0.7605656981,
-0.7309626341,
-0.0708841607,
0.1615938544,
-0.3841553926,
0.5074728727,
0.2515889108,
0.332567811,
-0.3805572093,
0.0256188083,
-0.3878509104,
-0.6810327768,
-0.4232584238,
-0.210591808,
0.5854335427,
0.3553779423,
0.5429877639,
0.437615782,
0.3707980812,
0.2451730967,
-0.2193150818,
0.3967886865,
-0.2684549987,
0.4406002164,
-0.4101116359,
-0.9654070139,
-0.43361184,
-0.6042522788,
0.4709382653,
1.1780275106,
-0.0342362002,
-0.0515911542,
-0.3344982266,
1.0702072382,
-0.7370621562,
0.3593737483,
-0.8533870578,
0.2073355019,
-0.0292173866,
-0.2930363715,
-0.5263699293,
-0.1927742213,
-0.0102658095,
-0.4188064933,
-0.0041393796,
0.2851279676,
0.2950493097,
0.1209248379,
-0.5860766172,
-0.4165911376,
-0.5980038047,
0.6659174562,
-0.6640458107,
0.2993189394,
0.3108891547,
0.5279448628,
-0.6075515151,
-0.7648777962,
-0.7443784475,
-0.2868820727,
-0.1096566617,
-0.0821163505,
0.0671260655,
0.1478617042,
0.1902442425,
0.239700824,
-0.7239117026,
-0.0672132224,
-0.032366138,
-0.056425564,
0.4947492182,
0.5610276461,
0.4778995216,
-0.4442151189,
-0.2952801883,
0.0839884281,
-0.7793815136,
0.0328011177,
0.1478950828,
0.5345383286,
0.3724140823,
1.1026204824,
-0.8344208598,
0.897156179,
-0.2354831845,
0.1439831108,
-0.2581055164,
-0.2667450607,
-0.1551335901,
0.1450256109,
0.4483904541,
0.2186710238,
0.1121088564,
-0.4236056507,
-0.298560828,
-0.0185376443,
0.0800864026,
-0.488455683,
-0.2804778814,
0.4338696599,
-0.352528125,
-0.0069470438,
-0.1321258992,
-0.6879585385,
-0.3215176761,
-0.4596528709,
0.4354948401,
-0.4914165139,
-0.0047504734,
0.432526499,
-0.0901637897,
0.5225378871,
0.3648565412,
-0.737598598,
0.5826927423,
0.8303184509,
0.4198358357,
-0.121780999,
-0.0279125925,
-0.4637414515,
0.4987997115,
-0.2899928689,
0.9288133383,
-0.5582283735,
-0.3412846029,
-0.0707293451,
-0.0831532851,
-0.2619688213,
-0.6596970558,
0.6501033902,
-0.9097200036,
0.3362072408,
-0.4436998963,
-0.7840095758,
-0.1396205723,
0.6350947022,
-0.628911674,
0.5770639181,
-0.0213412512,
-0.5028551817,
0.173431173,
-0.604857564,
-0.4349915981,
0.1001585647,
-0.3692449033,
-0.1251229495,
-0.0894139931,
0.136669904,
0.1867656857,
-0.420661062,
0.223713696,
-0.2112414688,
-0.1021639109,
0.0256816149,
-0.0575986542,
0.6200373173,
0.1093020439,
-0.3843098283,
0.2889842987,
-0.8433975577,
0.6754023433,
0.1538794488,
-0.6108939648,
-0.0706588849,
0.4594916701,
-0.2520512342,
0.1091389507,
0.2818555236,
-0.5126792789,
0.272133112,
-0.7047531009,
0.3831413686,
0.2599438429,
-0.0737283006,
0.604513526,
-0.1413452327,
0.2977270186,
0.0443013459,
0.0928935409,
-0.1874743253,
-0.3239443004,
-0.8619503379,
-0.065917559,
0.0887967944,
0.6809133291,
-0.8193631768,
0.4192040563,
-0.1946948916,
-0.3363305032,
-0.1234309375,
-0.0940238535,
0.2682764232,
0.588631928,
0.5552384257,
0.1054220051,
-0.52715832,
-0.9591808319,
-0.5470932722,
-0.2400612682,
-0.1258914918,
0.4381259084,
0.2207880467,
0.1419101506,
0.9400841594,
-0.7958302498,
-0.3130735457,
-0.5191241503,
-0.2599885166,
0.129495427,
0.4478578866,
0.1572877169,
-0.9400362372,
-0.3949398994,
-0.0880010128,
-0.5419610739,
0.1556403637,
0.0699342266,
-0.29702425,
0.0686951727,
0.4801178873,
-1.0976375341,
0.2312023342,
-0.0981552452,
-0.4561027884,
0.6042146087,
-0.0070654368,
-0.0715646595,
-0.8069584966,
0.173681125,
-0.4899361134,
-0.2882462144,
-0.637553215,
0.1972898543,
0.0904757008,
-0.3340872228,
-0.4074721932,
0.2495030016,
-0.4110797346,
-0.3394869268,
-0.0534986481,
-0.0487326942,
0.3290139735,
0.4317671061,
0.0529923253,
0.6461625695,
0.2540300488,
-0.6237914562,
0.3737986386,
0.4775868356,
-0.1636605412,
0.3914029598,
-0.7277484536,
0.031909436,
-0.2296150923,
0.2249372751,
-1.036318779,
-0.3629955053,
0.1770732403,
-0.4056524932,
0.223815456,
-0.1461680233,
-0.706454277,
-0.0038270238,
-0.2395948023,
0.192451179,
0.1770868152,
-0.4612013102,
0.6204331517,
0.1884344369,
0.0479988866,
-0.3058943152,
-0.7474015951,
0.3932750225,
0.0138713652,
-0.9285435081,
0.5432326794,
0.1772002578,
-0.17324242,
0.0699481368,
-0.1845902354,
-0.4124851823,
0.0307477266,
-0.2581915557,
0.1584377587,
-0.4985584617,
0.1478159279,
0.2001984417,
-0.0073548974,
0.1747019142,
-0.2646961808,
0.8425115347,
0.0011201738,
-0.5398937464,
-0.2708897293,
0.6558731198,
0.2783658803,
-0.4292140603,
0.6511111856,
0.1478527933,
-0.1503747851,
-0.3336057067,
-0.3825407922,
-0.1660408378,
-0.3960269094,
0.2054775059,
-0.513047576,
-0.6933974028,
0.432836324,
-0.2539504468,
-0.2812203467,
0.4231991768,
0.3588314354,
-0.1341851056,
1.1626219749,
0.3094229698,
0.3984915316,
0.0858325437,
-0.1944781095,
0.2054944932,
-0.5991202593,
-0.6831914186,
-0.7016346455,
-0.3704580069,
-0.2458054572,
-0.3980984986,
0.277295351,
0.11346329,
-0.1929798424,
0.1511565596,
-0.3156616986,
0.6133939624,
0.3431993723,
0.2038169056,
0.5236414671,
-0.1023352966,
0.0017299248,
0.0484367497,
-0.5782650709,
-0.4370184839,
0.6527836919,
-0.1928239763,
0.7388919592,
0.2790306509,
0.5587214828,
0.1275983453,
-0.5839698315,
-1.0337216854,
0.8461571932,
-0.141162619,
-0.5421426296,
-0.2560076714,
-0.4653505087,
-0.8761181235,
0.4568472207,
-0.1891357899,
-0.5476868749,
0.418615967,
-0.154054001,
-0.0735224485,
0.2559277415,
-0.8831745982,
0.8512606621,
-0.2405922115,
-0.2634478211,
-0.0657747537,
-0.8120607734,
0.2066787928,
0.1837589294,
-0.3267308772,
-0.2454546988,
-0.4219865501,
0.3167230785,
-0.4557156563,
0.7863876224,
-0.1916561574,
0.2766347826,
0.1767422408,
0.3162957132,
0.5158541799,
-0.1500761062,
-0.3782631755,
-0.363104403,
0.268712014,
-0.6124588847,
-0.659955442,
0.6507658362,
-0.3139702976,
-0.6492587924,
-0.0857414082,
-0.525026083,
-0.5093355179,
0.5012886524,
-0.1034584865,
0.3376994729,
0.0440990888,
0.2816150784,
0.6019873023,
-0.32121557,
0.2841465771,
0.5128452182,
-0.1872464716,
-0.0701049864,
0.7492970824,
0.1028003618,
0.2502291501,
0.7838097811,
0.1096409634,
-0.5369669199,
-0.6605733633,
-0.3076153994,
0.0706228167,
-0.6561656594,
-0.3416661322,
-0.721353054,
0.0525721312,
-0.2638576031,
0.1288320124,
-0.1264316887,
-0.8800268173,
-0.2303317934,
0.1152371094,
-0.0266449992,
0.3242112994,
0.58425951,
0.1297075301,
-0.7551087737,
0.2241258472,
0.1322239786,
0.1928590089,
-0.1498602331,
0.1495669931,
0.2496172786,
-0.1380594075,
-0.1525996923,
-0.9613515139,
0.4348427951,
0.4327682257,
0.5413948298,
-0.1783849001,
0.4590435624,
0.6511092186,
-0.3761143386,
0.7535703778,
-0.0324741676,
-0.8113828301,
0.7678866386,
-0.3263475597,
0.1106955335,
0.7114647031,
0.3938632905,
-0.1882034689,
-0.0173552912,
-0.3011602461,
-0.8830089569,
0.5949763656,
0.0894538462,
0.1289021373,
-0.2070302218,
0.5091908574,
-0.0746996701,
0.3749143779,
-0.5143722892,
-0.1022645161,
-0.0280101281,
-0.1426374763,
0.4754380286,
-0.4312519729,
-0.0137131149,
-0.1314595938,
0.0294970367,
-0.3441636562,
0.1008249521,
0.420419246,
-0.2012948692,
0.2116268128,
0.5328601599,
0.2481145412,
0.6752611399,
-0.1722137332,
0.2033425421,
-0.0537226722,
-0.0400152206,
-0.156472519,
-0.0722351372,
-0.2077073902,
-0.0568737872,
0.2621846795,
0.3989044428,
0.1141988412,
-1.0446540117,
0.5058000684,
-0.0589482598,
-0.1323344707,
-0.2726052999,
0.0946665779,
0.3014023304,
0.2755837142,
0.2023318559,
-0.1220282242,
0.5238876343,
-0.6238936782,
0.2305877209,
0.5059726834,
-0.2626334429,
-0.0949587971,
0.562926054,
-0.0434766822,
-0.2420247197,
0.6887023449,
-0.2130669802,
-0.3973339498,
0.5748566389,
0.7403867841,
0.4463202357,
0.0039467597,
0.1633903682,
0.1896035522,
0.14431113,
0.0872216448,
0.7439585328,
-0.167508468,
-0.4999324083,
-0.5742271543,
-0.5339146852,
-0.3258395493,
-0.2810184956,
-0.504393518,
0.3425684869,
-0.6045713425,
0.21414648,
0.0648375601,
0.0444682948,
-0.1865568757,
0.1214320511,
-0.1939474046,
1.1376267672,
-0.364700228,
0.8073301911,
0.817726016,
-0.5433729291,
-0.8417596817,
-0.1241957471,
-0.1725586206,
-0.8054552078,
0.8989264369,
-0.0334143303,
0.1930391043,
-0.0015802025,
-0.4126246572,
-0.5624596477,
0.9582389593,
0.5349884033,
-0.2860528827,
-0.4336066842,
0.5445205569,
0.5439013839,
-0.2312373966,
-0.0342877097,
0.6084451675,
0.4708262384,
0.3788808584,
-0.5144598484,
0.1596136093,
0.0213595331,
-0.1600994468,
0.4716174006,
-0.2591228485,
1.0253391266,
-0.1137437075,
-0.1996253729,
0.1808542162,
0.4570011497,
0.0345009603,
0.4319915771,
0.4167507887,
0.4838092625,
0.5710327625,
-0.0674054995,
1.1852152348,
-0.1803631037,
0.11879237,
1.1152707338,
-0.3374100924,
1.2336596251,
0.5980337262,
-0.2790735662,
0.3827349246,
0.303640902,
0.3009759188,
0.4189157188,
0.2556321323,
-0.45437181,
-0.426507175,
-0.1746906042,
-0.1330194324,
0.5081596375,
0.5498709083,
0.012016342,
-0.7253332734,
-0.3317874074,
-0.1442568004,
0.3690190613,
-0.1997927427,
1.075887084,
0.097458981,
-0.4457378387,
0.4051588178,
-0.028555287,
0.1574997604,
-0.663469255,
-0.0043657599,
-0.222917363,
0.0164698921,
-0.6103932261,
-0.9002395272,
0.6900015473,
-0.3029928505,
-0.2269036621,
0.2982776165,
0.8788609505,
-0.4036570787,
-0.1470644772,
0.2487347126,
0.7095028162,
0.0125481719,
-0.4846298993,
-0.8484784961,
-0.1389621943,
0.0376954339,
-0.1861958802,
0.4370084107,
0.5820167661,
-0.0098704351,
0.7378819585,
0.7783364654,
0.1260554045,
0.3812668622,
-0.0634203181,
1.1419938803,
-0.8562164903,
-0.3339794576,
-0.6376855373,
0.3253948987,
-0.0719073638,
0.183587268,
0.6410315633,
0.7325277925,
0.5129127502,
-0.0878448263,
0.2335112095,
-0.0932537988,
0.5332698822,
-0.7487497926,
0.3072555959,
-0.6211871505,
0.6277353168,
0.1411108375,
-1.0359075069,
-0.5971616507,
0.2597624958,
-0.4400687218,
-0.2682141364,
0.6056632996,
0.8342059851,
0.0419667475,
-0.0389819369,
0.3178425729,
-0.0257279854,
0.6429508328,
0.4677430987,
0.9977287054,
-0.099306576,
0.6972888708,
-0.0872860923,
0.1140852347,
-0.2197511643,
-0.5948991776,
-0.4978947937,
-0.3248259723,
0.1654985845,
-0.2066114396,
-0.0121024111,
0.8768060207,
0.3909167051,
-0.6545981169,
-0.1777034402,
-0.3492122293,
0.2319511473,
0.3030504882,
-0.2301451266,
0.4073183537,
-0.9758122563,
-0.5839224458,
0.6895116568,
0.4283601046,
-0.2558987439,
-0.1576005071,
0.259154439,
-0.3983391225,
-0.0609277263,
0.9625131488,
0.35147807,
-0.563072741,
-0.0067987731,
0.1652055681,
-0.2303211093,
0.1088613942,
0.8373628259,
-0.7137537599,
0.345530808,
0.9398910403,
0.9105203748,
0.5171149969,
0.033582326,
0.4952687323,
-0.7459184527,
0.0081676887,
0.7099897861,
0.183880955,
0.0900189355,
-0.451823324,
0.4961140156,
0.013516197,
-0.4864063263,
-0.623745501,
0.3970152736,
-1.2974729538,
-0.6301984787,
0.9697248936,
0.1250258237,
-0.6284337044,
-0.3969314992,
-0.5121334195,
-0.273208648,
-0.161281243,
0.4425258934,
0.2141299397,
-0.5845782161,
0.1639251858,
-0.3498809338,
0.4211920202,
0.5957936049,
-0.9118038416,
0.0514500923,
0.6289429665,
0.1135548428,
0.1313979328,
0.5823050141,
-0.3928404748,
0.0883330852,
-0.0730727166,
-0.112735562,
0.0762687847,
-0.0869961753,
0.0016070842,
0.5685754418,
0.2042329907,
-0.0910086706
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14769v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14769v3
|
Large Language Model (LLM) Bias Index -- LLMBI
| 2023-12-22T15:38:13 | 2023-12-29T11:07:09 |
Abiodun Finbarrs Oketunji, Muhammad Anas, Deepthi Saina
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG, I.2.7, I.2.7
|
The Large Language Model Bias Index (LLMBI) is a pioneering approach designed
to quantify and address biases inherent in large language models (LLMs), such
as GPT-4. We recognise the increasing prevalence and impact of LLMs across
diverse sectors. This research introduces a novel metric, LLMBI, to
systematically measure and mitigate biases potentially skewing model responses.
We formulated LLMBI using a composite scoring system incorporating multiple
dimensions of bias, including but not limited to age, gender, and racial
biases. To operationalise this metric, we engaged in a multi-step process
involving collecting and annotating LLM responses, applying sophisticated
Natural Language Processing (NLP) techniques for bias detection, and computing
the LLMBI score through a specially crafted mathematical formula. The formula
integrates weighted averages of various bias dimensions, a penalty for dataset
diversity deficiencies, and a correction for sentiment biases. Our empirical
analysis, conducted using responses from OpenAI's API, employs advanced
sentiment analysis as a representative method for bias detection. The research
reveals LLMs, whilst demonstrating impressive capabilities in text generation,
exhibit varying degrees of bias across different dimensions. LLMBI provides a
quantifiable measure to compare biases across models and over time, offering a
vital tool for systems engineers, researchers and regulators in enhancing the
fairness and reliability of LLMs. It highlights the potential of LLMs in
mimicking unbiased human-like responses. Additionally, it underscores the
necessity of continuously monitoring and recalibrating such models to align
with evolving societal norms and ethical standards.
|
[
-0.3735315502,
-0.5344818234,
0.4915823042,
0.4214557707,
-0.1743179262,
0.1477946043,
-0.141953513,
-0.3688752055,
0.1947781742,
0.2618071735,
-0.6272980571,
-0.4119271934,
-0.4507702589,
-0.1020334437,
-0.0045808833,
1.0886098146,
0.1384040117,
0.4366100132,
-0.1743083149,
-0.0857629701,
-0.4865550995,
-0.5429156423,
-0.5004833937,
-0.6461875439,
0.7450339198,
0.0332187004,
0.4898186028,
0.3829011023,
0.4991843104,
0.1771261841,
-0.2580836117,
-0.0406975411,
-0.6511257291,
-0.1119531319,
-0.1334285289,
-0.593267858,
-0.7020520568,
0.2328002751,
0.971175909,
0.6442506313,
-0.0756920129,
0.4928155541,
0.1605451107,
0.706995368,
-0.7171301842,
-0.0386603698,
-0.5099861622,
0.0779397264,
-0.5621265173,
-0.2004920393,
-0.2476295531,
-0.4485359788,
-0.341852963,
-0.0561323874,
-0.1686318964,
0.1291821897,
0.5916929841,
0.0115970206,
-0.5886405706,
-0.0542998463,
-0.4284915626,
1.1178565025,
-1.0035437346,
0.2872822583,
-0.1788126826,
0.3089205325,
-0.2400985211,
-0.0354660116,
-0.4996212423,
0.0193776507,
0.2623237669,
0.1050329879,
-0.011650498,
-0.0330227278,
0.3431541622,
0.4753072858,
-0.360234499,
0.3999020755,
-0.2074373662,
-0.2938590944,
0.6744536757,
0.3476986587,
0.2737559676,
-0.152765587,
-0.1195114851,
0.266377449,
-0.8568301201,
-0.103320308,
1.1182146072,
0.0637963638,
-0.1637110859,
0.6615629196,
-0.184593007,
0.4140413105,
-0.1143180281,
-0.4417849481,
0.5373839736,
-0.3852955401,
-0.0867027119,
0.0119248657,
0.9252216816,
0.6280075312,
0.3071435094,
0.0265653878,
-0.3960928917,
0.2247098684,
0.0716605932,
-0.8218488693,
0.1981764883,
-0.0230728742,
-0.530801177,
-0.5990980268,
-0.1514919698,
-1.03002882,
-0.6889421344,
0.0565686226,
0.1214346066,
-0.0770722777,
-0.3459447026,
-0.1294133067,
-0.025147019,
0.6346719265,
0.1443594843,
-0.7827100158,
0.1632974148,
0.9434852004,
0.8435304761,
-0.3440017104,
-0.0956680924,
-0.2214589268,
0.1262362301,
-0.1750273705,
0.5577923656,
-0.7285936475,
-0.5129199028,
0.0807918385,
-0.1849712729,
0.2592151165,
-0.4843108952,
0.8022991419,
-0.4337937236,
0.0640157014,
-0.4002214968,
-0.341268599,
-0.0703039467,
0.3298496902,
-0.5239812732,
0.9753431082,
-0.0090591013,
-1.2238878012,
0.4104718268,
-0.5854145885,
-0.2685379088,
-0.0465925001,
-0.2885221839,
-0.5575967431,
0.3288656473,
0.3122162521,
0.2515255809,
-0.6615118384,
0.5783098936,
-0.7595498562,
-0.3150788844,
0.227137953,
-0.7394779325,
0.5988151431,
0.0837805942,
-0.1452309936,
0.1901470274,
-0.6757109761,
-0.0187463108,
0.176825881,
-0.4709708393,
-0.25782758,
-0.0197650194,
0.1425288767,
0.1938710362,
0.4425921142,
-0.8493125439,
0.0920107737,
-0.4082906842,
0.6588357091,
1.0629968643,
-0.0788222775,
0.4305937886,
-0.3573076129,
0.4498844445,
0.1064791903,
0.228072539,
0.0117863659,
-0.6202527881,
-0.6216399074,
-0.3255646825,
0.1541533917,
0.5407460928,
-0.2071241438,
0.292588383,
-0.5562016964,
-0.3987595737,
-0.8261525035,
0.2679313421,
0.2247009724,
0.264644891,
-0.2500009239,
-0.3279619217,
-0.6374925375,
-1.2255051136,
-0.4388174117,
-0.1748528779,
-0.2182897925,
0.4453217387,
0.546336174,
-0.5379734635,
0.8288339972,
-0.2595954239,
-0.1680683792,
-0.2798301876,
0.0397372618,
0.51776582,
0.2080696523,
0.4385256767,
-0.4125344455,
-0.0230465792,
0.0094498713,
-0.6102179885,
-0.6163696647,
0.2103322446,
-0.213599667,
0.1477793008,
0.1024158895,
-0.4949811399,
0.0579827987,
0.6168285012,
-0.1099442914,
0.4667404592,
0.2161177546,
0.1767344475,
-1.0565115213,
0.2484048158,
0.1305824816,
-0.0313773938,
-0.4420390129,
-0.0109112412,
-0.0356344394,
0.1144829467,
-0.3159193695,
0.5385338068,
-0.3612850308,
-0.2453725785,
-0.1973296404,
0.2341010571,
-0.2091407031,
0.2135411054,
-0.5053176284,
0.9401689768,
0.1043999866,
-0.275090158,
0.269831568,
-0.0816993415,
-0.382075578,
0.7126225233,
-0.5765055418,
0.2615715861,
-0.1548602432,
0.3042665422,
-0.8975893259,
-0.0441680402,
0.1235735267,
-0.3956410587,
0.1806046665,
0.03041704,
-0.3970263004,
-0.554481566,
-0.6069222689,
0.6141095757,
0.3514910638,
-0.3421278,
0.8330563307,
0.7746220827,
-0.199291423,
-0.8743136525,
-0.6472542286,
0.0734527931,
-0.3326949477,
-0.6044328213,
0.0055887331,
-0.1297025084,
-0.3350319266,
-0.3685202003,
-0.1594290137,
0.138267085,
0.1459564269,
0.4084323943,
0.29375121,
-0.1792338192,
-0.1901382208,
0.136285603,
0.1385780573,
0.4998075068,
-0.1068044752,
0.765769124,
-0.0954824165,
-0.5360357165,
-0.2672001123,
0.3366883397,
0.6273581386,
-0.0953681916,
0.4947275817,
0.6526926756,
-0.2008643001,
0.0253672302,
-1.0239531994,
0.1615146995,
-0.4218577445,
0.5229393244,
-0.3241713345,
-1.2000523806,
0.5004861951,
-0.0728654265,
0.0593904927,
0.3029177785,
0.8878846169,
0.2562604845,
1.1973382235,
0.7836874127,
-0.8928444982,
0.2953065634,
0.0941203833,
0.5371872187,
-1.0740975142,
-0.2798395753,
-0.4906394184,
-0.4394913912,
-0.8039774895,
-0.3622906208,
0.2112670392,
-0.173634842,
-0.3639769554,
-0.47638762,
-0.2484941781,
0.4517096281,
0.3640977442,
0.0081746811,
0.0911778435,
-0.2100049406,
-0.1796964854,
-0.0235653035,
-0.3186159432,
-0.7476862669,
1.2902188301,
0.9499442577,
0.809139967,
0.1493209749,
0.6840275526,
0.4227387011,
0.7530232668,
-0.7970257401,
0.6722169518,
0.2735976875,
-0.6425062418,
-0.1495216936,
-0.6951160431,
-0.524740994,
0.2144150138,
-0.1064693108,
-0.6252217889,
-0.0342224799,
-0.1325783283,
-0.0904221758,
0.4204874635,
-0.533118546,
0.4850628078,
-0.205313772,
-0.3864232302,
-0.2839916348,
-0.2856329679,
0.784284234,
-0.2943640053,
0.4462071955,
-0.4640021026,
-0.2433112264,
0.783357501,
-0.0066205035,
0.9026339054,
-0.1856958866,
-0.4010349512,
-0.0681034327,
-0.0481200702,
0.2419465184,
0.2310190946,
-0.3527446687,
0.5825355649,
-0.268360436,
-0.4306797087,
-0.3651954532,
1.053204298,
-0.9326581955,
-0.7158667445,
-0.4343467653,
-0.6606302261,
-0.1967535466,
0.1968481243,
-0.1870435327,
-0.1256565303,
-0.5172886848,
-0.1790144891,
0.5753880143,
-0.4171771705,
0.3458783329,
0.4891166985,
-0.3906462789,
-0.5275466442,
0.6519002914,
-0.0964982286,
0.1368938088,
0.3259157538,
0.2405937612,
-0.1784130186,
-0.4381645322,
-0.3207374811,
0.5963075757,
-0.6201170087,
-0.1840104759,
-0.4770755172,
-0.3058710694,
-0.513638258,
0.1539911777,
-0.0348043405,
-0.0381379463,
-0.0050364542,
-0.1456151307,
0.0230425838,
0.7929109931,
0.1965515912,
0.3533700109,
-0.3848928213,
0.0801156014,
0.2399564683,
0.5215159655,
0.0012083901,
-0.690518558,
0.0189853813,
0.0730064958,
-0.4099971652,
-0.755540967,
0.5436878204,
0.1558499634,
0.6618751287,
0.4862617552,
-0.3409431279,
0.4796237648,
-0.7278062701,
0.7187011838,
0.2490218431,
-1.0419260263,
0.4669944048,
-0.4549258351,
0.3317591846,
0.2486885041,
0.3675502241,
-0.4776822329,
-0.4263553023,
-0.0511646494,
-0.7544760108,
0.4668690264,
-0.1762320697,
0.3290148973,
-0.0376546867,
0.4395611882,
0.0179741904,
0.476849705,
-1.0121047497,
-0.1286987811,
0.1439650804,
-0.4223461151,
-0.1089676023,
-0.7588540912,
-0.1989841908,
-0.1300993711,
0.7202587724,
-0.1987555176,
0.2936206162,
-0.130956009,
-0.0842992067,
-0.1781725138,
0.5244682431,
0.5320723057,
0.6312786937,
-0.2018634528,
-0.0145209972,
0.4053450525,
-0.610249579,
0.1188031957,
-0.239233166,
-0.2147967219,
-0.212828204,
0.2396831214,
0.8163670897,
-0.0485451594,
-0.65842098,
0.6902731657,
0.1531240344,
0.0541517064,
-0.2116100192,
-0.1409497261,
0.1005027294,
0.2243216783,
0.2227920294,
-0.2349982113,
0.2093659341,
-0.6215836406,
-0.0429430045,
0.7534688711,
-0.3987810612,
-0.3017219007,
0.5023099184,
0.3627318442,
-0.2896320522,
0.387046963,
0.1035366431,
-0.4536406994,
0.2715684175,
0.4905977249,
0.8175751567,
-0.3888542354,
0.1130517647,
0.1758271009,
0.6455512047,
0.0194717254,
0.3337238729,
0.2168602049,
-0.8039879799,
-0.4948020577,
-0.9913878441,
-0.1611828655,
0.2392365485,
-0.4970333874,
0.3063167334,
-0.5581338406,
-0.4141077101,
-0.0827512145,
-0.0004122334,
-0.600440979,
0.0254091062,
0.4958858192,
0.8191172481,
-1.1988157034,
0.7116149664,
0.625148952,
-0.2322422862,
-0.4140159786,
0.0338739157,
0.1380879879,
-0.9947773218,
0.6665855646,
0.4904566407,
-0.1855511069,
-0.2297068089,
-0.472858578,
-0.6563667059,
0.8673449755,
0.2779110968,
-0.7890144587,
-0.0351709016,
0.3796560764,
0.5017886758,
-0.5569680333,
0.770254612,
0.8664691448,
0.4947119951,
-0.3369327486,
-0.9129564166,
0.0754217133,
-0.3232408464,
0.4263150394,
0.3989110887,
-0.7566755414,
0.6249582171,
-0.0324731432,
-0.1175007746,
-0.0296210274,
0.5680206418,
0.2082748562,
0.3829053938,
0.4720600843,
0.7099417448,
0.7100913525,
-0.1604926586,
0.8871707916,
-0.3325025737,
0.0656535625,
0.6556366086,
-0.5455363989,
0.7216371298,
0.6983305216,
-0.1550533623,
0.3458290994,
0.4533462822,
-0.03058118,
0.2831706405,
0.6204285622,
-0.3460521698,
-0.1349370033,
-0.3594962358,
-0.1622483432,
0.2387056947,
0.2683507502,
-0.3324458599,
0.0072585735,
0.086421974,
0.1676169187,
0.0102481134,
-0.3882893324,
0.6137664914,
0.231984973,
-0.3109693527,
0.2684982419,
0.1113362461,
1.1588599682,
-0.5510505438,
0.2156272829,
-0.3927467167,
0.1886010766,
-0.1688479036,
-0.8495995998,
0.0948666036,
0.0869046971,
-0.4059661031,
0.0334028527,
0.4076598287,
-0.1619223058,
-0.6836066246,
0.4603146017,
0.4300388992,
0.0651125535,
0.1653043181,
-0.6328586936,
0.4989545643,
0.0910668746,
-0.1877410859,
0.5640648603,
0.5172963738,
-0.1866564751,
1.0323725939,
0.4647508562,
0.2796211243,
-0.0707796365,
0.385661751,
0.913790226,
-0.681946516,
-0.2405154556,
-1.0618810654,
0.1572441906,
-0.265840441,
-0.287635982,
0.7781077623,
0.7223240137,
0.6749621034,
0.1017081141,
0.8204221129,
0.3483537138,
0.6135789156,
-0.3439227939,
0.7685267329,
-0.3098238707,
0.5312498212,
-0.4884194732,
-1.1304340363,
-0.1510945708,
0.3214570284,
-0.4813540578,
0.251006037,
0.3791586757,
0.973870635,
0.1317130178,
-0.0825465098,
0.2681504786,
0.310792625,
0.3549185991,
0.5097395778,
0.8897584677,
-0.18323946,
0.2762843966,
0.1743181348,
-0.4132020473,
-0.0450371094,
-0.9624429345,
-0.9838182926,
0.0723782405,
-0.162377134,
-0.1250655502,
0.1420101523,
0.671313405,
0.3610710502,
-0.77549541,
-0.5205852389,
0.3535865843,
0.2492455989,
0.1348873526,
-0.2602051497,
-0.1528090239,
-0.1760118604,
-0.6090143919,
0.1424470842,
0.5128278136,
-0.3519466817,
-0.6769577265,
0.0487899669,
-0.106208533,
0.4152409434,
0.6095481515,
-0.2660249174,
-0.8623020053,
-0.2400989532,
-0.2118045837,
-0.1422252059,
-0.0059919879,
0.8451616168,
-0.3807557523,
0.1307516098,
0.4802210033,
0.7000832558,
0.060271807,
-0.3070364296,
0.6342971921,
-0.5183755159,
0.0877536759,
0.188144654,
0.4072302878,
0.5206013918,
-0.345338285,
0.3932364881,
0.2242118418,
-0.7190547585,
-1.1307687759,
0.2743245661,
-0.8813942671,
0.1236671135,
1.2437899113,
0.0683902055,
-0.4660502672,
0.1359783709,
-0.2897532284,
0.0366846137,
-0.5446999073,
0.7726619244,
0.6287258863,
0.3812294602,
-0.2294977009,
-0.7560919523,
0.1704315543,
0.4054366946,
-0.6321384907,
-0.0572135486,
0.5027589202,
0.480830282,
0.000457405,
0.589725852,
-0.3348999023,
-0.2037551105,
-0.3552259505,
0.3696551025,
0.2240570486,
0.1052787304,
-0.5446620584,
0.1001629084,
0.0583888032,
0.095241949
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14737v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14737v1
|
Computational Semantics and Evaluation Benchmark for Interrogative Sentences via Combinatory Categorial Grammar
| 2023-12-22T14:46:02 | 2023-12-22T14:46:02 |
Hayate Funakura, Koji Mineshima
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LO
|
We present a compositional semantics for various types of polar questions and
wh-questions within the framework of Combinatory Categorial Grammar (CCG). To
assess the explanatory power of our proposed analysis, we introduce a
question-answering dataset QSEM specifically designed to evaluate the semantics
of interrogative sentences. We implement our analysis using existing CCG
parsers and conduct evaluations using the dataset. Through the evaluation, we
have obtained annotated data with CCG trees and semantic representations for
about half of the samples included in QSEM. Furthermore, we discuss the
discrepancy between the theoretical capacity of CCG and the capabilities of
existing CCG parsers.
|
[
-0.644826293,
-0.8925805092,
0.5014587641,
0.3750809729,
-0.4551784992,
0.2794863284,
-0.3652366698,
-0.2090594321,
0.0562342517,
0.6715871692,
-0.8542417884,
-0.5228884816,
-0.4598937035,
0.2261580676,
-0.5457844138,
0.7968595624,
0.1067865193,
0.2889553308,
-1.0140126944,
-0.1808348745,
-0.4764405191,
-0.6325347424,
-0.1195866689,
0.0654135793,
0.0379389822,
0.5647273064,
0.7318157554,
0.2429743111,
0.7599325776,
0.2585361302,
0.0927217007,
-0.0463536903,
-0.0876788348,
0.3082320988,
-0.4259531796,
-0.5294345021,
0.07201951,
0.1571369916,
0.6497504115,
0.7645338774,
-0.2418251932,
0.3179044425,
-0.2711398602,
0.3410867751,
-0.6328914762,
0.3404314816,
-0.7222604156,
0.1322251111,
-0.0204019342,
-0.282317698,
-0.4539657831,
-0.3791381717,
0.1198781058,
-0.6022766232,
0.1782799065,
0.4459546506,
0.597992599,
0.2744460106,
-0.5155580044,
-0.4839967489,
-0.2741627097,
0.6696914434,
-0.6875036359,
0.3071219325,
0.485207051,
0.3190840781,
-0.1122806147,
-0.7881608605,
-0.8758197427,
-0.7141316533,
-0.2549514174,
0.5509838462,
-0.2300904542,
0.3430095911,
0.3415012062,
0.6925901771,
-0.9201036096,
-0.0405567624,
-0.0652531162,
-0.2050179243,
0.5976788402,
0.5281202793,
0.3982447982,
-0.4265895188,
-0.4069422483,
-0.3675204217,
-0.2598919272,
0.0357909761,
0.7001289725,
0.2282342613,
0.1183275878,
0.7748630047,
-0.4208753109,
0.6542447805,
0.0995387435,
0.3908602297,
0.1258111596,
-0.7600514889,
0.0838785172,
0.0290830918,
0.7198713422,
0.3969331682,
-0.2606519759,
-0.3213335574,
0.2758078575,
0.4616338015,
0.5046446323,
-0.6983443499,
-0.142482549,
0.2759599686,
-0.2163911313,
-0.1696092039,
0.3394781351,
-0.6078765392,
-0.1207184941,
-0.3262639344,
0.3516534567,
-0.1829053611,
-0.0298267268,
0.3074147701,
-0.4754820764,
0.6421790123,
-0.1900526583,
-0.6316123605,
0.7336649895,
1.0311259031,
0.1886847764,
-0.1178055704,
-0.0285246782,
-0.5998939872,
-0.4286839068,
-0.1784487069,
0.8000752926,
-0.7709813118,
-0.4083035886,
-0.209165141,
0.2640008032,
-0.2143117189,
-0.6835859418,
1.1109035015,
-0.5072662234,
0.5087798834,
-0.664013207,
-0.8814569712,
-0.3848666549,
0.4606792927,
-0.4062239826,
0.9844801426,
0.4795588851,
-0.9267280102,
0.3603637815,
-0.2249847353,
-0.3074149489,
0.6008939743,
-0.3957181871,
-0.3578647673,
-0.0553850494,
-0.1850534976,
0.2574467361,
-0.8599794507,
0.5696594715,
-0.6292470098,
-0.140844062,
0.4481893778,
0.1606721431,
1.0655692816,
0.1591593325,
-0.286977917,
0.0454575568,
-0.7610105276,
0.5021734834,
-0.154265523,
0.1904955655,
-0.2222109437,
0.3150804937,
-0.2436273694,
0.3779957592,
0.070860669,
-0.7879023552,
0.0976261944,
-0.0390474387,
0.6162455082,
0.5111584663,
0.1066475138,
0.2186173201,
-0.2922164798,
0.9530393481,
0.0676380992,
0.1896047294,
0.2337993681,
-0.262462467,
-0.786138773,
-0.0251405779,
0.2622082829,
0.7104090452,
-0.8759097457,
0.6062757373,
0.0493074283,
-0.4790329933,
-0.1104699299,
-0.2277897298,
0.4275259078,
0.5639191866,
0.2375121564,
-0.3359180689,
-0.6443709731,
-1.259352684,
-0.3068344295,
-0.5270531178,
0.4883220494,
0.4534053504,
0.4690557718,
-0.0288006142,
0.8484476805,
-0.455958724,
0.3377857804,
-0.022229692,
0.3774958849,
-0.0197848938,
0.297994256,
0.4041382074,
-0.8820225596,
-0.3852952719,
-0.2582286596,
-0.5945592523,
-0.4227632284,
0.0433404259,
-0.3206007481,
-0.5064930916,
0.6923317909,
-0.6118763089,
0.0221354682,
0.5787652135,
-0.4689216614,
0.8461111784,
0.2377183288,
0.3523298502,
-0.6390763521,
-0.2337753177,
-0.3326782882,
-0.1475733966,
-0.508364141,
0.4908007979,
0.2165919393,
0.0228756014,
-0.445743233,
0.2819159031,
-0.1085357442,
-0.0662982836,
-0.0500156172,
0.3099986017,
0.1057186574,
0.4175179601,
-0.1093216538,
0.7066193223,
0.500200212,
-0.452783972,
0.4691673219,
0.4224520326,
-0.2267025411,
0.6323355436,
-0.5013516545,
-0.0263825152,
-0.2628526688,
0.0400394946,
-1.0854651928,
-0.0248012654,
0.4354452193,
-0.4094378054,
-0.2089908719,
0.3308337033,
-0.6903993487,
-0.5349318385,
-0.5544442534,
0.5601153374,
0.2381325215,
-0.3129589856,
0.4475694597,
0.3409102857,
-0.1259393096,
-0.3977407515,
-0.5604353547,
0.1028370485,
-0.3099617064,
-0.6825730205,
0.3461151719,
-0.2712360919,
-0.7257298827,
0.131931901,
0.1085774302,
0.062990129,
0.2127264142,
0.2594198287,
0.318901211,
-0.2328845561,
0.2796047032,
0.0846533775,
0.0436089411,
0.4876869917,
-0.2342135608,
0.4907564819,
-0.5121856332,
-0.258439064,
0.1564216614,
0.3738536835,
0.1147108674,
-0.312223047,
0.2734031677,
0.2351352572,
-0.1502160281,
-0.3155140281,
-0.1823630035,
-0.0946292952,
-0.4244036376,
0.2560665905,
-0.1906970888,
-1.3368102312,
0.5915615559,
0.189389661,
-0.333894372,
0.6221793294,
0.6227265596,
0.0549189597,
0.9416898489,
0.1129091308,
0.5323786139,
0.1213163808,
-0.0401877426,
0.3720811903,
-0.7946115732,
-0.0992954224,
-0.712518692,
0.3302164972,
-1.1291888952,
-0.3332214952,
0.3930725753,
0.3122321665,
-0.2353821248,
0.5221467614,
-0.4518786967,
0.2476982027,
0.5220907331,
0.0526287854,
0.1589848548,
-0.6351680756,
-0.2013359517,
0.1885665059,
-0.7934526205,
-0.4435734451,
0.7027655244,
-0.173066169,
0.4226170778,
0.0263709053,
0.2668094337,
0.4561159015,
0.0622354075,
-0.8148337603,
0.9140077233,
-0.3761520386,
-0.6836543083,
0.0321984291,
-0.3099617064,
-0.7237439156,
0.6214299798,
-0.2876701057,
-0.5924673676,
0.1789391935,
-0.1184664369,
-0.176293999,
-0.1651301533,
-0.6495942473,
0.9768362641,
-0.4034680426,
-0.2694305182,
-0.2577930093,
-0.7373048067,
0.6555095315,
0.1897804439,
-0.090037711,
-0.302675128,
0.1705697924,
0.8492392898,
-0.811111331,
0.3955829442,
0.0366286524,
0.4047066569,
0.9298345447,
-0.0485766716,
0.1395382285,
0.0802237019,
-0.0661176741,
0.1614019275,
0.5534977913,
-0.379902035,
-0.5876859426,
0.3825812638,
-0.6205849051,
-0.6765068173,
-0.7343248725,
-0.4982398152,
-0.72080338,
-0.1171160564,
0.0651253089,
0.2763963938,
-0.2043770999,
0.3262897134,
0.2891654968,
-0.3644677103,
0.3102346361,
0.3845609128,
-0.143143937,
-0.4401483238,
0.5954364538,
-0.0648115054,
0.4616894126,
0.4354023635,
0.4063652754,
-0.5083686113,
-0.3440178335,
-0.2423558533,
0.0891568139,
-0.8362193108,
-0.2146119922,
-0.6727157235,
-0.2285104245,
-0.287694484,
0.0429962017,
0.1881123334,
-0.64029181,
-0.125458613,
-0.143185541,
0.2441398948,
0.2921106815,
0.2897437811,
0.2627778947,
-0.6231114864,
0.3037065566,
0.5372636914,
0.1753939986,
-0.3175412416,
-0.2269828469,
0.071708478,
-0.0820893645,
-0.3631242812,
-0.7936062813,
-0.0072981049,
-0.0480957516,
0.699991703,
-0.0055197016,
0.1528602093,
0.6013400555,
-0.0585941412,
1.045779705,
0.0236620046,
-1.2624722719,
0.189332068,
-0.4892489016,
0.2002308369,
1.1172050238,
0.2957684994,
-0.6256031394,
-0.5443572998,
-0.8008982539,
-0.6183502674,
0.6937271357,
0.0153728928,
-0.1679596901,
-0.4808790684,
0.5282598138,
0.2823698521,
0.4699830115,
-0.5175719857,
0.0261671077,
-0.2248914838,
-0.2419794351,
0.0267178733,
-0.2008750141,
0.104350403,
-0.1942337155,
0.59328866,
-0.239930898,
-0.0217806976,
0.0050872178,
-0.1948743612,
0.1256099343,
0.422747612,
0.3984518349,
0.4808395505,
-0.1049013957,
0.5140026808,
0.0726437941,
-0.3342284858,
0.228328228,
0.0593228638,
-0.2177163064,
-0.4613439739,
0.4028718472,
0.5087990761,
0.0401117615,
-1.1774597168,
0.7470287681,
-0.2675275803,
-0.3363221288,
-0.214776516,
0.1708951592,
-0.0321508907,
0.0794250742,
0.0181519464,
-0.4412157834,
0.5882649422,
-0.7796956897,
0.3244046569,
0.6813769937,
-0.4850400388,
-0.0597014241,
0.470539242,
-0.435516715,
-0.0734103099,
0.642736733,
-0.5939047933,
-0.8683499098,
0.8817819953,
0.4266471267,
0.9041619301,
0.2327626199,
0.5225929618,
0.3633937836,
0.3698337972,
0.2006246001,
0.7486897707,
-0.3609849215,
-0.6979635954,
-0.291233927,
-0.6017460823,
-0.7774266601,
-0.1476114988,
-0.8823891878,
0.2755021155,
-0.4521675706,
0.0812608749,
0.2463396639,
0.0360984579,
-0.4342199564,
0.3440800011,
-0.1085169688,
0.4818021953,
-0.7196455002,
0.2533773482,
0.6574396491,
-0.437325269,
-0.6491276026,
-0.2147240192,
-0.399856329,
-0.8291295767,
0.6323624253,
-0.0980610773,
-0.0842498317,
-0.330385536,
-0.7176097631,
-0.5742321014,
0.8132818937,
0.1877157092,
-0.6066714525,
0.5237621665,
0.7158870697,
0.6741935015,
-0.2190996706,
0.3923032284,
0.4689414799,
0.661439836,
-0.1489740163,
-0.6179836392,
0.1709599048,
-0.3313114345,
-0.0450731628,
0.252143383,
-0.9225687981,
1.1431348324,
0.2755886912,
-0.3536857963,
0.028746007,
0.4128724933,
0.1468836516,
0.1220038161,
0.5912253261,
0.8813881278,
0.5463876128,
-0.2547284961,
1.082031846,
-0.4814960659,
0.4766280353,
1.2915350199,
-0.4292542934,
0.420299381,
0.3202163875,
-0.3924701214,
0.4935610294,
0.7669091821,
0.0833293945,
0.4383428097,
0.7031511664,
-0.3770424128,
-0.5512045622,
-0.2226258665,
-0.0383751057,
0.7396752834,
0.1815185994,
-0.1445312798,
-0.4013252854,
0.134222582,
-0.2482476234,
0.2719236314,
-0.3191574812,
0.7338442802,
-0.0923364237,
-0.9315693974,
0.2609793842,
0.1995850503,
0.0780493021,
-0.4991938472,
-0.104499802,
0.2267142087,
-0.0171396378,
-0.2169773132,
-0.8852480054,
0.2981529236,
-0.3091393113,
0.0984296426,
-0.0753276795,
0.6175771356,
-0.4058946371,
-0.4286396205,
0.1863476783,
0.4604647458,
-0.02996815,
-0.1130744964,
-0.6680977941,
-0.063212797,
-0.3132042587,
0.2754640281,
0.0721713379,
0.2487989217,
-0.5417688489,
0.3339630961,
0.4461623132,
-0.3615787923,
0.3385930657,
0.0973710418,
1.0346207619,
-0.8707385063,
-0.6116871834,
-0.7264949679,
0.2358125895,
0.1845313013,
-0.458746314,
1.0313999653,
0.6681854725,
0.908164084,
0.2787905633,
0.8518304229,
-0.3055097759,
0.3128659725,
-0.3632665575,
-0.1048152074,
-0.0641235486,
-0.0301562399,
-0.2723934352,
-0.869867146,
-0.204770267,
0.4635924399,
-0.5730971098,
-0.2020577788,
0.8072417974,
0.6988123059,
0.128931269,
0.8014595509,
0.1500594169,
0.1066338047,
0.1956370026,
0.3694807887,
1.452311635,
-0.5135265589,
-0.1142374054,
-0.4764761031,
-0.184249118,
-0.0707975999,
-0.9416970611,
-0.733350575,
-0.8539703488,
-0.3751202226,
-0.4698779583,
-0.1030882373,
0.8287464976,
0.4496873021,
-0.7139777541,
-0.2212180644,
-0.461566776,
0.0531432815,
-0.0859411284,
-0.3457237482,
0.2509596944,
-0.2559824586,
-0.0951253325,
-0.0013187047,
0.485791415,
-0.4509661198,
-0.4188800156,
0.1737988591,
-0.2314312756,
0.3351555169,
0.8526545167,
-0.0321944244,
-0.5063030124,
-0.5883222818,
0.2348294705,
0.0422354825,
0.0591412149,
1.1041213274,
-0.573700428,
0.4899744689,
0.6661121249,
0.7105674148,
0.5748918653,
0.3995434046,
-0.0806010664,
-0.2425478101,
-0.0117059899,
0.7303052545,
0.3630102277,
0.0858327225,
-0.3106215298,
0.3002532721,
0.2084364593,
-0.4983397424,
-0.6009566784,
0.1956856549,
-1.5841288567,
-0.2885705531,
1.2727308273,
0.0586247668,
-0.2705947757,
-0.0104491888,
-0.1597146243,
-0.0195045117,
0.2689822614,
0.4095556736,
1.0456943512,
-0.5606383085,
-0.0485828593,
-0.1314789057,
0.0471151173,
0.5071520805,
-1.2886347771,
0.0711627603,
0.6258994341,
0.1246236116,
-0.0772056356,
0.5802940726,
-0.5154572725,
0.376039803,
0.1923412681,
0.041644305,
0.3323253393,
0.0741498992,
-0.3182101548,
0.215368703,
-0.035597939,
0.0345715471
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14708v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14708v1
|
Balancing the Style-Content Trade-Off in Sentiment Transfer Using Polarity-Aware Denoising
| 2023-12-22T14:06:54 | 2023-12-22T14:06:54 |
Sourabrata Mukherjee, Zdeněk Kasner, Ondřej Dušek
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Text sentiment transfer aims to flip the sentiment polarity of a sentence
(positive to negative or vice versa) while preserving its sentiment-independent
content. Although current models show good results at changing the sentiment,
content preservation in transferred sentences is insufficient. In this paper,
we present a sentiment transfer model based on polarity-aware denoising, which
accurately controls the sentiment attributes in generated text, preserving the
content to a great extent and helping to balance the style-content trade-off.
Our proposed model is structured around two key stages in the sentiment
transfer process: better representation learning using a shared encoder and
sentiment-controlled generation using separate sentiment-specific decoders.
Empirical results show that our methods outperforms state-of-the-art baselines
in terms of content preservation while staying competitive in terms of style
transfer accuracy and fluency.
|
[
-0.5023925304,
-0.3682394028,
0.2012351751,
0.4154345095,
-0.7500286698,
0.1421871781,
-0.2979433537,
-0.3309575617,
0.5396523476,
0.6028955579,
-0.5495960712,
-0.2741828561,
-0.7360962033,
0.1868448108,
-0.3853939474,
1.4942692518,
-0.072542876,
-0.1151979789,
-0.5005095005,
-0.3349902928,
-0.5897296071,
-0.6034284234,
-0.6440377831,
-0.3932987154,
0.202510938,
0.259156853,
0.7631480694,
-0.0493044071,
0.605848968,
0.0215167999,
-0.2470062226,
-0.13540411,
-0.565124929,
0.239631474,
-0.4301331341,
-0.3327064216,
-0.7783231139,
0.2137999386,
0.406172514,
0.2914956212,
-0.0928591117,
-0.1324705631,
0.1802691966,
0.9431651235,
-0.4578757584,
0.0328610875,
-0.5241231322,
0.0940682516,
0.1582401395,
-0.1374995857,
-0.5283984542,
-0.4900965989,
0.0804228783,
-0.363312155,
0.0704812109,
-0.3115394711,
0.7345163226,
-0.1026834548,
-0.4750250876,
-0.1714696884,
-0.8488203883,
0.8614864349,
-0.6924147606,
0.1865621358,
0.0988248363,
-0.1022991166,
0.4351639748,
-0.2415968627,
-0.8259458542,
0.2060891539,
0.0737507045,
0.6988790035,
-0.0923445001,
-0.2137130946,
-0.1028759852,
0.3369957507,
-0.2424678057,
-0.4508777857,
-0.1616878062,
0.0051590144,
0.6655716896,
-0.161485821,
0.3683457673,
-0.3611492217,
-0.6539769769,
-0.2384108454,
-0.4976264238,
0.1766357422,
0.1964081377,
0.2547845542,
-0.1072927713,
0.4442132413,
0.03339177,
0.2828981578,
0.3528368473,
-0.0362059809,
0.1567620039,
-0.5904319882,
0.0792422891,
0.076321274,
0.6675076485,
0.9990386367,
0.5105671287,
-0.1801533699,
-0.51241678,
0.2202544659,
0.3580846786,
-0.814063251,
-0.003837799,
-0.0506781228,
-0.4826230705,
-0.7273102403,
0.2604636848,
-1.0000370741,
-0.5280120969,
-0.3941760063,
0.6198217273,
-0.2282296866,
-0.5012839437,
0.4427113533,
-0.4056342542,
0.3041596413,
0.3779738843,
-0.7840135694,
0.3363311589,
0.5819194317,
0.9284501076,
-0.4298635423,
0.2041823119,
-0.2072234601,
0.1176839471,
-0.2984694242,
0.7274640203,
-0.5469052196,
-0.3809238672,
-0.0737481415,
-0.2180659324,
0.0949332714,
-0.3964379728,
0.5066896677,
-0.6614766121,
0.2511886656,
-0.5411662459,
-0.4541830719,
-0.0331097208,
0.3013482392,
-0.7269191146,
0.7871066928,
0.3100777566,
-0.8752815127,
0.2801742554,
-0.1204859093,
-0.8426175117,
-0.2089977264,
0.5147972703,
-0.6449330449,
0.047359962,
0.1438722908,
0.5145910382,
-0.1591009647,
0.064016439,
-0.447591871,
-0.2752857208,
0.5178769827,
-0.1484530717,
0.6581429839,
0.1697051078,
-0.1966856271,
-0.1118474081,
-0.4280930459,
-0.5460336208,
0.0337921679,
-0.1181822643,
-0.5364429355,
-0.2936628461,
-0.0695565119,
0.4275243282,
0.4173075259,
-0.7611473203,
0.3644280136,
-0.161425218,
0.5651379228,
0.710603714,
0.2010825127,
1.065295577,
-0.5924807191,
0.5882320404,
0.2018888742,
0.4516129792,
0.3069679439,
-0.3360668123,
-0.639013648,
-0.1772484332,
-0.0125160068,
0.818383038,
-0.7656366825,
0.3406090438,
-0.2499674708,
-0.3361086845,
-0.5612025261,
0.0704000369,
-0.2053194791,
0.5143401623,
0.4522982538,
-0.6719489098,
-0.3418734372,
-0.665152669,
-0.3792380393,
-0.136121884,
0.3875230849,
0.1496184021,
-0.0614280701,
-0.202543661,
0.9059007764,
-0.3783653677,
-0.4755194187,
-0.6654939055,
0.4591101706,
0.0478902571,
0.5871713161,
0.7130944729,
-0.7958731651,
-0.6974391341,
-0.052074369,
-0.501643002,
-0.3682493269,
-0.6275669932,
-0.3788242042,
0.257646054,
0.4198707342,
-0.6864814758,
0.1498217434,
0.7226023674,
-0.3867969215,
0.3372496068,
0.2073192596,
0.4452325404,
-1.338147521,
0.0439340286,
-0.0223709699,
-0.4755286276,
-0.5640756488,
-0.2285265774,
0.0179309826,
0.0225351397,
-0.1783853918,
0.456346482,
-0.2790752947,
0.1022986546,
-0.2985770404,
0.2195556909,
0.8706360459,
0.3348082602,
-0.1091816202,
0.6489314437,
0.5212993026,
-0.1333716661,
0.201752767,
0.353702426,
0.1684961766,
0.9979849458,
-0.445050627,
0.2288050652,
-0.3987237513,
0.1180960312,
-0.9115166068,
0.5662170649,
0.3216368258,
-0.4217688143,
0.5298874378,
-0.5047805309,
-0.2738083303,
-0.0008713547,
-0.6450755,
0.1940523982,
0.822114408,
-0.2360186726,
0.7995579839,
0.1711139679,
-0.7149184346,
-0.4364458025,
-0.6713975072,
0.1319875568,
-0.201057747,
-0.4987063408,
0.4091428816,
-0.2358673662,
-0.0610578619,
0.1039150953,
0.0041867602,
-0.0361665078,
0.0083186366,
-0.005216721,
0.5650674701,
0.1158135757,
0.0404711105,
0.4053107202,
0.2096014172,
0.200685069,
-0.1012749448,
0.5897559524,
-0.0386234634,
0.0529087298,
-0.5280813575,
0.399628669,
0.9207949638,
-0.2973253429,
1.0451449156,
0.7334215045,
0.0713450089,
-0.3053895235,
-0.3701020479,
-0.3604802191,
-0.3934701979,
0.0295208991,
-0.0679756626,
-0.6241692901,
0.6659062505,
0.1239773408,
-0.0338959582,
0.4501591921,
0.0676348284,
-0.2078310698,
1.1782375574,
0.6940062642,
-0.2273328751,
0.9297194481,
-0.2012309432,
0.5059162974,
-0.8443274498,
-0.0598018579,
-0.1414179802,
-0.2716475725,
-0.3368673325,
-0.1943867654,
0.0317597724,
0.3330867589,
0.0972854421,
0.3383678496,
-0.4779822826,
0.2182948589,
0.3521318436,
0.4123829603,
0.3838489354,
0.2267382145,
0.4304609299,
-0.225452736,
-0.5072706342,
-0.2218758017,
0.9057810903,
0.2029524297,
0.7512896061,
0.1115359142,
0.7928517461,
0.7056555748,
0.3165470064,
-0.8990181088,
0.5405800343,
-0.8009016514,
-0.0675720572,
-0.1035023406,
-0.5759810805,
-0.378372103,
-0.0613189824,
-0.6225616932,
0.0367055833,
0.2930596471,
-0.0066439309,
0.0475403368,
0.4013385773,
-0.4903132021,
0.6605939865,
0.1497839093,
-0.4939449728,
-0.4247629941,
-0.3361944258,
0.118777819,
0.1036632061,
0.2134060413,
-0.0275175665,
0.3456017971,
0.8195667863,
0.0630098656,
0.7451779246,
-0.2156445831,
-0.0963706151,
0.452943176,
0.5641049743,
0.5289607644,
-0.0011198645,
-0.1766355485,
0.2255133241,
-0.0762437209,
-0.2896717489,
-0.8202471137,
0.562255919,
-0.7493574023,
-0.3237068951,
-0.1662553102,
-0.4149169922,
0.061788246,
0.34536466,
0.2368549109,
0.4560477734,
-0.1929126531,
0.0190982763,
0.735103786,
-0.0089165475,
0.3387526572,
0.1438667923,
-0.0672570765,
-0.708769381,
1.2192403078,
0.0312428977,
0.5275540948,
0.3366154134,
0.471876055,
-0.2239050418,
-0.3291307986,
-0.4710062444,
0.1986119002,
-0.8429875374,
-0.2806500494,
-0.6476721764,
-0.1739248186,
-0.8675435185,
-0.7367945313,
-0.5995429158,
-0.4168997705,
-0.5217629075,
0.0228629429,
0.4753310382,
0.7496786118,
-0.2212263793,
0.1423148811,
-0.8334441781,
0.3568651676,
0.5076441169,
0.2859660089,
-0.1982195824,
-0.8696660399,
0.1185035333,
0.0632635728,
-0.0091949245,
-0.9704265594,
0.66339463,
0.0823539272,
0.1486118883,
0.4064702988,
0.459577322,
0.1254156679,
0.1259776801,
0.6711947322,
0.4596844018,
-1.1699719429,
0.375728935,
-0.1433576792,
0.2335100621,
0.6538839936,
0.0326902233,
-0.8161802292,
-0.4638513625,
-0.3949863017,
-0.8500135541,
0.5375391841,
0.1571942717,
0.2772831023,
-0.0103169577,
0.4570046961,
0.4056400359,
0.3593776226,
-0.967666924,
0.2624807656,
-0.9193781018,
-0.4944236279,
0.1628937274,
-0.3476782739,
-0.1993019134,
-0.1665138304,
0.648090899,
-0.0655590221,
0.3637597561,
0.2531066537,
-0.3159438074,
-0.0421396382,
0.6097028852,
0.4644226134,
-0.150503695,
-0.4047785699,
0.3164933026,
-0.1271640807,
-0.5663483739,
-0.048073221,
-0.2530810535,
-0.6642549634,
-0.2768653929,
0.075604856,
0.8404617906,
-0.1518195122,
-0.2311412543,
1.0402258635,
0.0033147174,
-0.0357806273,
0.1151626781,
-0.1967875212,
-0.0581490211,
0.025373349,
-0.0878899693,
0.684700191,
0.2221814841,
-0.5912542939,
0.1120406389,
0.616547823,
-0.4478783906,
-0.555986166,
0.3435269296,
0.4149446785,
0.172114253,
0.4906738698,
-0.3395473063,
-0.7792595029,
0.5430772901,
0.5873626471,
0.9890963435,
0.0807906985,
0.7491395473,
0.4505181611,
0.3328721523,
-0.2633809149,
0.4543658495,
-0.0611126125,
-1.0906540155,
-0.1819696873,
-0.6869475245,
-0.4785204828,
-0.5129963756,
-1.1201809645,
0.2075897008,
-0.607778728,
-0.3499540389,
-0.4939968884,
-0.2914379835,
-0.345130533,
0.0571889766,
0.2499345392,
0.5434853435,
-1.2695800066,
0.3680738509,
0.7277345061,
-0.4785904884,
-0.3870753348,
0.0031993017,
-0.4218315184,
-0.462474823,
0.1771764308,
0.2104604244,
-0.5437279344,
0.0678081587,
-0.6080108285,
-0.579729557,
0.8488284945,
0.3212385476,
-0.353603512,
0.3534522951,
0.0571829528,
0.6137446761,
-0.3352047503,
-0.1680378467,
0.240599215,
0.2916669846,
0.1538300067,
-0.4011993408,
0.3320849538,
-0.1948771477,
-0.1958077401,
-0.0378495194,
-0.6049543023,
0.9988374114,
-0.0146622723,
-0.4156616628,
-0.2570338845,
0.5460253358,
-0.1704514772,
0.1988319159,
0.6101661921,
0.6216633916,
0.1827263087,
0.1499753594,
0.7815446258,
-0.4543493986,
0.4085092545,
0.5829601288,
-0.4737764895,
0.9623529315,
0.5108242035,
0.1774772257,
0.9196927547,
-0.0157976635,
0.0610865951,
0.7924715877,
-0.3326979578,
-0.421716243,
-0.3841258287,
-0.2996982336,
-0.1251556426,
0.3141393661,
-0.0602678061,
-0.205115065,
0.2104268074,
0.1537748128,
0.2205014676,
0.1216517016,
-0.4440439045,
1.1632148027,
-0.0064091333,
-0.864487648,
0.1948816627,
-0.1304825395,
0.9233161807,
-0.2445279807,
0.0289259702,
-0.5716122985,
0.1399073154,
-0.2513491213,
-1.2658833265,
0.3984649181,
-0.339176178,
-0.5657792091,
-0.8335223198,
1.1551873684,
-0.7028975487,
-0.403734833,
0.5410265326,
0.1956350952,
-0.3545576334,
-0.2737127841,
-0.3760868013,
-0.0324097276,
-0.0580261238,
-0.0459777825,
0.445584923,
0.4013972282,
0.1150372252,
0.2572422028,
0.5484533906,
0.366653204,
-0.0080369301,
0.4868180454,
0.9130721688,
-0.5777121186,
-0.6219314933,
-0.6381028295,
0.3160588443,
-0.1950186044,
-0.1351797432,
0.5208826661,
-0.06252563,
0.5015571713,
-0.2036569566,
0.9144277573,
0.0580897368,
0.2586884797,
-0.4648323357,
0.937777698,
-0.4261724949,
0.0814912245,
-0.5941008329,
-0.7990447879,
-0.3079464138,
0.711199224,
-0.0710115731,
-0.1670372635,
0.3176787794,
0.6935429573,
0.1050969288,
0.0311338529,
0.0598510914,
0.1424790174,
0.153052628,
0.2944769561,
0.658126533,
-0.3021781743,
0.4291436672,
-0.6913787723,
-0.3805826604,
-0.1931390017,
-1.0276451111,
-0.8087239861,
-0.3712383211,
-0.5348128676,
-0.598230958,
-0.0729706809,
0.5126655698,
0.4412094057,
-0.7648487091,
-0.026756471,
-0.3203717768,
0.1112190485,
-0.4454591274,
-0.3035015762,
0.0230663642,
-0.0038984865,
-0.2861703932,
-0.0248491224,
0.4740130007,
0.2111942768,
-0.1869305223,
0.0028874353,
0.1015499532,
0.5300268531,
1.0220395327,
-0.0073678591,
-0.1771471649,
-0.4981845617,
0.2708274722,
-0.3316076696,
0.1296666861,
1.031639576,
-0.5581397414,
0.5200025439,
0.9466838241,
0.4038554132,
0.2037426978,
0.2521206737,
0.5174046159,
-0.7184035182,
-0.173023954,
0.2277136296,
0.2795202434,
0.7438414693,
-0.5451990962,
-0.0722238794,
0.7280427814,
-0.3311327398,
-0.5208705068,
0.2298142761,
-1.7043552399,
-0.3695336282,
1.2838369608,
0.0129553201,
0.0562624224,
0.1035804749,
-0.2977864742,
0.5901708603,
-0.4895014465,
0.9616096616,
0.4903746545,
0.0535102598,
-0.5336357951,
0.1247410774,
0.3443039954,
0.6951896548,
-0.6363840699,
0.1598634869,
0.247737214,
0.3440438807,
0.0228932053,
0.5572290421,
-0.2574215829,
0.1160256192,
-0.110317342,
0.4540721476,
0.0477439947,
-0.4643622935,
-0.4189391136,
0.1838121414,
-0.0832086131,
0.1121177152
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14646v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14646v1
|
Collaborative Synthesis of Patient Records through Multi-Visit Health State Inference
| 2023-12-22T12:28:29 | 2023-12-22T12:28:29 |
Hongda Sun, Hongzhan Lin, Rui Yan
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Electronic health records (EHRs) have become the foundation of machine
learning applications in healthcare, while the utility of real patient records
is often limited by privacy and security concerns. Synthetic EHR generation
provides an additional perspective to compensate for this limitation. Most
existing methods synthesize new records based on real EHR data, without
consideration of different types of events in EHR data, which cannot control
the event combinations in line with medical common sense. In this paper, we
propose MSIC, a Multi-visit health Status Inference model for Collaborative EHR
synthesis to address these limitations. First, we formulate the synthetic EHR
generation process as a probabilistic graphical model and tightly connect
different types of events by modeling the latent health states. Then, we derive
a health state inference method tailored for the multi-visit scenario to
effectively utilize previous records to synthesize current and future records.
Furthermore, we propose to generate medical reports to add textual descriptions
for each medical event, providing broader applications for synthesized EHR
data. For generating different paragraphs in each visit, we incorporate a
multi-generator deliberation framework to collaborate the message passing of
multiple generators and employ a two-phase decoding strategy to generate
high-quality reports. Our extensive experiments on the widely used benchmarks,
MIMIC-III and MIMIC-IV, demonstrate that MSIC advances state-of-the-art results
on the quality of synthetic data while maintaining low privacy risks.
|
[
-0.2432079464,
-0.6022834778,
1.1098080873,
-0.297673583,
0.0465894155,
0.1381516606,
0.0715643167,
-0.4461413622,
0.6437987089,
0.4185255468,
-0.7395917177,
-0.5258150697,
-0.0217211191,
0.2082552761,
-0.0486950018,
1.0231251717,
-0.2620856166,
0.0792611316,
-0.0809295475,
-0.0794852003,
-0.2021823525,
-0.9627744555,
-0.1179880649,
-0.2318443358,
0.3512915373,
0.2907001376,
0.314363718,
0.0922379643,
0.2879903316,
0.3430452049,
0.3175694942,
0.7272695899,
-0.1620045304,
0.4187596142,
0.2497716099,
-0.2684830725,
-0.9408326745,
-0.0258377139,
0.8610742092,
0.6187391281,
-0.2715852559,
0.1568973064,
-0.0279066171,
0.5171478987,
-0.5370671749,
0.0556414872,
-0.5257691145,
0.2658141851,
0.078704685,
-0.1468738467,
-0.607643187,
-0.293993324,
0.1112402156,
-0.6316161752,
0.5293542147,
0.1219718531,
0.8048602343,
0.1255120486,
-0.3646831214,
0.2234495878,
-0.933028698,
0.6807710528,
-0.4184206426,
0.5475901961,
0.2086137235,
0.3562786281,
-0.3388305008,
-0.7501134276,
-0.6903994083,
-0.2949295938,
-0.1620123386,
0.5651350617,
0.0634750947,
0.1631226391,
0.1264573932,
0.4125652015,
-0.4865416884,
-0.5733001232,
-0.4480364919,
-0.1948496997,
0.6240452528,
0.5061538219,
0.2916163504,
-0.3494150043,
-0.280413419,
0.036077708,
-0.531352818,
-0.316133678,
0.0108515201,
0.2250204384,
-0.136810407,
0.6940816641,
-0.1329551339,
0.1214701831,
0.2844873965,
-0.417727828,
0.7142282128,
-0.6847265959,
-0.1291221231,
0.2760565579,
0.9870565534,
0.5940847993,
-0.5135297775,
-0.2363865376,
-0.0716754794,
0.3325486481,
0.382578969,
-0.8716009855,
-0.422499001,
0.6722568274,
-0.751155436,
-0.0226509124,
0.2019198239,
-0.7771921754,
-0.1691095531,
-0.5229499936,
0.2697025537,
-0.3871210217,
-0.3763596416,
-0.2900627851,
-0.0609210096,
-0.6590278745,
0.1323384345,
-0.4581218958,
0.559156239,
0.4328756332,
0.6725519896,
-0.4485246241,
-0.5197550654,
-0.7213180661,
0.4288781881,
-0.2152690738,
0.4133592546,
-0.0959937349,
-0.5213885903,
-0.2525649667,
0.1271709651,
-0.3179254532,
-0.6489832997,
-0.0422717072,
-0.0824727416,
0.226605013,
0.0680187196,
-0.3560571969,
0.3194863796,
0.3532418311,
-0.8402644396,
0.6323488355,
0.0501730256,
-0.6893001199,
0.6150026917,
-0.4981836081,
-0.6654849648,
-0.0469853021,
-0.3974379897,
-0.8319820762,
0.0207545031,
0.1046902537,
0.1721794307,
0.105520837,
0.3930712044,
-0.1591394693,
0.1547076553,
0.373818785,
-0.0395950563,
0.2158709019,
0.4455927312,
-0.0855714232,
0.480003655,
-0.995642066,
0.117163077,
-0.185644567,
-0.4968460202,
-0.0966896564,
0.3390384614,
0.1890817732,
0.2236314714,
0.0647929311,
-0.5668763518,
-0.1431668401,
-0.6087526679,
0.2845115662,
0.0566869751,
0.6921114326,
0.3065303266,
-0.614646256,
0.4824095964,
0.2406348437,
0.5218236446,
-0.1844207197,
-0.6101619005,
-0.2623009384,
-0.4655595124,
0.0408166125,
0.5285128355,
-0.5018860698,
0.3597635925,
-0.4204761386,
-0.0459020138,
-0.6961195469,
-0.3596322238,
0.2022908032,
0.271502614,
0.5654698014,
-0.2081093937,
-0.6456192732,
-0.7650395036,
-0.0014575977,
-0.1256589293,
-0.3360867202,
0.168280676,
0.1571124643,
-0.1505092978,
0.5059522986,
-0.2733968496,
-0.2948663235,
-0.5878897309,
0.0149307251,
0.195226267,
0.5745277405,
0.19750081,
-0.6001394391,
-0.3682533205,
-0.0915381461,
-0.6878244281,
0.4871312976,
-0.4476498961,
-0.2943682671,
-0.0004246282,
0.1101015732,
-0.4124695659,
0.459217906,
0.6820575595,
0.0682269856,
0.2439238578,
-0.5884099603,
0.6778220534,
-1.6468719244,
-0.0798526108,
-0.2897973061,
-0.2457723469,
-0.7085022926,
0.1901377738,
-0.3819685876,
-0.4069029987,
-0.1971348971,
0.0588506423,
-0.5764363408,
0.1545846909,
-0.0731549636,
-0.2399926335,
0.0686543435,
0.2454602122,
0.1002473086,
0.1961431056,
0.3195590377,
-0.3809136152,
-0.0332034826,
0.3777503371,
0.079292424,
0.6570774913,
-0.3720748127,
0.1873121262,
0.1031756029,
0.4561631978,
-0.4677542746,
-0.6414067745,
0.306045711,
-0.3331881762,
0.1717903316,
-0.2670009732,
-0.5538526177,
-0.4349250495,
-0.2848766446,
0.1949783564,
0.6111388206,
-0.3135281801,
1.1454825401,
0.7089430094,
0.0476962365,
0.1709474623,
-0.8601346612,
0.1393594146,
0.1273006052,
-0.5697644353,
0.7082232237,
-0.2175217122,
-0.2078744918,
0.0961819068,
0.0228547677,
-0.1721138507,
-0.3932421803,
0.8756451607,
0.5269783139,
-0.1343720406,
-0.346411705,
0.3346875608,
-0.0799968764,
0.1885111481,
-0.0999144614,
0.2721208334,
0.1486831456,
-0.6752172112,
-1.0748335123,
0.9986072779,
0.7972252369,
-0.3193223774,
0.8958979845,
0.0572171323,
-0.7904863954,
-0.0641903952,
-0.4470635653,
-0.397903204,
-0.3791314065,
-0.0731030628,
-0.5504179597,
-0.3899326026,
0.3975781202,
-0.1800475419,
0.2012651414,
0.3005812466,
0.7184007764,
0.1235360801,
1.3416950703,
-0.0323319286,
0.3222128749,
0.2065724581,
-0.0766044036,
0.2596299052,
-0.7210200429,
-0.4454091489,
-0.2905560136,
-0.0462775677,
-1.0458134413,
-0.2505059838,
1.1716537476,
-0.4208662212,
0.0304148253,
0.0702459365,
-0.4533315003,
0.0713453889,
0.6501199007,
0.8748243451,
0.28714782,
0.2076875716,
-0.2185862958,
-0.1160673276,
-0.4866082668,
-0.2388469279,
0.9910594225,
-0.1279299855,
0.2964385152,
0.0788588673,
1.2489644289,
-0.0546842851,
0.3481192291,
-0.351143837,
0.2989026606,
-0.0857854635,
-0.6287911534,
-0.0246245693,
-0.5086866021,
-0.8113549948,
0.1615906358,
-0.7364590764,
-0.5738033652,
-0.1335428953,
0.6141440868,
-0.6013299227,
0.4543964565,
-0.6053869724,
0.6021704674,
0.0399980657,
-0.4114674628,
-0.4809553325,
-0.9140495062,
0.1916812956,
-0.0956059173,
0.2575753033,
0.1533398777,
0.5731390715,
0.2535721064,
-0.8152524829,
0.5829122066,
0.0396269336,
0.5714489818,
0.615257442,
0.2719252408,
0.39103809,
0.1053100526,
-0.234938696,
0.1997762769,
0.2346681356,
-0.0060752453,
-0.1355649382,
0.8510738015,
-0.40617311,
-0.2651302218,
-0.3535574973,
-0.3591918349,
-0.4044502378,
0.2612889111,
0.2967238128,
0.5870167017,
-0.3950212896,
-0.3956117034,
0.1669374406,
-0.2014176995,
-0.0070793629,
0.2254021615,
0.1302762181,
-0.7443907261,
1.0310745239,
-0.0403314233,
0.2729630768,
0.29951033,
0.2436902672,
0.0404642634,
-0.4900492132,
-0.6505566835,
0.2742506564,
-0.1235622615,
0.23042202,
-0.8001178503,
-0.1162852645,
-0.3122443259,
-0.0048877569,
-0.4209686518,
0.0698161498,
-0.1954776198,
-0.094058156,
-0.0745491982,
0.7120990753,
-0.2799310684,
-0.2084071487,
-1.1279205084,
0.8022549152,
0.0273581054,
-0.0305897668,
-0.1927661896,
0.119447805,
0.0947596356,
-0.1474643946,
-0.361854285,
-1.262344718,
0.259329915,
-0.017672617,
0.6406035423,
0.2158123404,
0.1894476414,
0.5263388753,
-1.0879336596,
0.9788261056,
0.6225267649,
-0.6656936407,
0.8979490995,
-0.0733286217,
-0.011425145,
0.7569870353,
0.0985105783,
-0.1503840983,
-0.5856315494,
-0.8541479111,
-0.8392932415,
0.3444703519,
0.2644863725,
-0.083011657,
-0.3394288123,
0.1861415654,
0.0157086328,
0.1985724121,
-0.1526352316,
-0.5617877245,
-0.1888068914,
-0.4271595776,
0.2898255289,
0.0086284587,
-0.3447448611,
0.0149743343,
0.4950676262,
0.040345192,
0.2044602931,
0.470418483,
0.2853680849,
-0.378171593,
0.3491475284,
0.2561563253,
0.7920305133,
-0.1934611201,
0.3089446425,
0.2874387801,
-0.3645022511,
-0.061668098,
0.2048948109,
-0.2790137827,
0.2806895077,
0.0486458689,
0.4374894202,
-0.0946328416,
-0.2980419099,
0.4894926846,
-0.0790319741,
-0.2458959371,
-0.3767863512,
0.1430039108,
0.0044133677,
0.1185128465,
-0.0644254982,
0.3384124637,
0.4494850934,
-0.5385516286,
0.4124071598,
0.0646623746,
-0.281553328,
-0.7250421643,
1.2167062759,
0.2047250867,
-0.1528909057,
0.5975598097,
-0.2435496151,
-0.3526624739,
0.3050100207,
0.4439386129,
0.5486779213,
-0.5201672316,
0.1355024129,
0.798651576,
0.0338783227,
-0.1538899243,
0.7195739746,
0.2592115998,
-0.4386164844,
-0.4691349566,
-0.2956641912,
-0.554145515,
0.1852685362,
-0.9194096327,
-0.0766567066,
-0.3607773781,
-0.4035426974,
0.0185291823,
-0.4242623448,
-0.7852891684,
0.2310715467,
0.2987996042,
0.1804378182,
-0.8871247768,
0.4869298935,
0.5982362628,
-0.6260979176,
-0.9908312559,
0.1436035037,
0.4083008468,
-0.199600175,
-0.0050444664,
-0.016406389,
-0.2398708761,
-0.4056530595,
-0.1141863838,
-0.1921572685,
0.7169548273,
0.1057275385,
-0.838830471,
0.1040996611,
0.0713895783,
0.6719748378,
-0.2906013429,
-0.1092347279,
0.2783679962,
0.1823630631,
0.0247965902,
-0.995975852,
0.395429641,
0.0967033207,
-0.2596194446,
0.2144494355,
-0.4324355721,
0.6958783865,
-0.6461998224,
-0.2238311321,
0.1593512744,
0.7275361419,
0.7476157546,
0.812319994,
0.5144717693,
0.3771201372,
0.9577237964,
0.1964361221,
1.2148718834,
-0.4445823133,
0.0335398577,
1.3180657625,
-0.6270412803,
0.810071826,
0.5162335038,
-0.3108373284,
0.5093684196,
0.337882638,
0.0686260164,
0.4918287694,
0.1351322085,
-0.7036750913,
-0.4367811978,
-0.0935024172,
-0.4210646749,
0.0275608208,
0.2122868747,
-0.7008881569,
0.2196171582,
-0.0369801223,
0.1823322773,
-0.2144654393,
0.1117307842,
0.897423625,
0.0543591119,
-0.8658688664,
0.0442206636,
-0.1200438589,
-0.0376690775,
-0.2797489464,
-0.5056833029,
0.0382832624,
0.1700346172,
-0.2781177461,
-0.3478168249,
0.0924413502,
-0.0938571393,
-0.5292602777,
-0.1937072426,
0.2430624813,
-0.4027846158,
-0.57575351,
-0.0438339151,
0.6000545025,
0.4919090569,
0.0120120691,
-0.4663157761,
-0.098030962,
-0.0702112243,
0.0425530225,
0.3049057722,
0.3098860085,
0.0036759954,
0.0382220671,
0.8551867008,
0.5618655682,
-0.1256520152,
0.6232284904,
0.7033051252,
-0.2128597051,
-0.7650216222,
-0.5051168799,
0.5032293797,
-0.0818403661,
-0.2608967125,
0.2574073076,
0.8223891854,
0.5370355248,
-0.0474364944,
1.0449466705,
0.0994883552,
0.8493459821,
-0.4990502298,
0.6961022019,
-0.5834702253,
-0.1150133461,
0.1171868145,
-0.462141037,
-0.1505426913,
0.2422005385,
0.1633131206,
-0.2887139022,
0.8158947229,
0.6086640954,
-0.1768515855,
-0.1334786117,
0.2687833905,
0.1685277224,
0.4297276437,
0.572971344,
0.6432994008,
-0.3991330564,
0.3196749091,
-0.1876453608,
-0.2645578384,
-0.0312985554,
-0.5876026154,
-0.7260711193,
-0.5889123082,
-0.4985111654,
-0.7843670249,
0.0262986533,
1.1563498974,
1.033041954,
-1.1238241196,
0.3235643208,
0.1428411901,
-0.2533744276,
-0.2213426977,
-0.1653530896,
0.6283536553,
0.2474226803,
-0.6425428987,
0.8666238189,
0.2046002448,
-0.0081444792,
-0.0384173542,
-0.011908615,
0.3225827813,
-0.1880363524,
0.3949262202,
0.056084469,
-0.7947641015,
-0.2568313479,
-0.0309327636,
-0.1034605205,
0.1660228372,
0.9263246655,
-0.5402600765,
0.7793616056,
0.4074352384,
0.2709467411,
0.6703212857,
0.1941962689,
0.3452003896,
-0.5696174502,
-0.3441449404,
0.0125334235,
0.505980432,
0.2409484982,
-0.5464936495,
0.0238654539,
0.1697033197,
-0.4830448925,
-0.5038881302,
0.2391062677,
-1.066016078,
-0.0143852495,
0.9272318482,
-0.0051659914,
-0.1893582046,
-0.0758768618,
0.0457272679,
0.4627375305,
-0.4248132706,
0.7366737723,
-0.0175441988,
-0.8614314198,
0.3470157683,
-0.6613151431,
0.2615511119,
-0.0107020754,
-1.226810813,
-0.3846973479,
1.0130861998,
0.5730119348,
0.286095053,
0.7689652443,
-0.1741284132,
0.2053225636,
0.1465024799,
0.1085623428,
0.0661687329,
-0.6704046726,
0.2497384101,
0.3539210558,
-0.2234388292,
-0.6604997516
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14609v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14609v1
|
BLSTM-Based Confidence Estimation for End-to-End Speech Recognition
| 2023-12-22T11:12:45 | 2023-12-22T11:12:45 |
Atsunori Ogawa, Naohiro Tawara, Takatomo Kano, Marc Delcroix
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL
|
Confidence estimation, in which we estimate the reliability of each
recognized token (e.g., word, sub-word, and character) in automatic speech
recognition (ASR) hypotheses and detect incorrectly recognized tokens, is an
important function for developing ASR applications. In this study, we perform
confidence estimation for end-to-end (E2E) ASR hypotheses. Recent E2E ASR
systems show high performance (e.g., around 5% token error rates) for various
ASR tasks. In such situations, confidence estimation becomes difficult since we
need to detect infrequent incorrect tokens from mostly correct token sequences.
To tackle this imbalanced dataset problem, we employ a bidirectional long
short-term memory (BLSTM)-based model as a strong binary-class
(correct/incorrect) sequence labeler that is trained with a class balancing
objective. We experimentally confirmed that, by utilizing several types of ASR
decoding scores as its auxiliary features, the model steadily shows high
confidence estimation performance under highly imbalanced settings. We also
confirmed that the BLSTM-based model outperforms Transformer-based confidence
estimation models, which greatly underestimate incorrect tokens.
|
[
-0.0743032619,
-0.3712219894,
0.1274684966,
0.1900588423,
-0.4633069336,
0.2335927337,
-0.2606068552,
-0.5752859712,
0.0516025834,
0.049262587,
0.0015873861,
-0.3740599751,
-0.8921111226,
0.1533804536,
-0.5804725289,
0.5572314858,
0.1230723634,
0.2241168916,
-0.1801178753,
-0.0965273604,
-0.5819410086,
-0.683537364,
-0.6875373721,
-0.3560604751,
0.2776004672,
0.3475214839,
0.4519647658,
0.1602574289,
0.3185178339,
0.2182660848,
-0.5582032204,
0.0285017639,
-0.263754189,
0.0744547769,
-0.272873193,
-0.4287520647,
-0.2892222404,
-0.2512100339,
0.7635774016,
0.4216974676,
-0.4504267275,
0.2969848514,
0.1068582833,
0.3690955043,
-0.8193944097,
-0.109345749,
-0.6641657948,
0.0531391874,
-0.0672468245,
-0.2654169798,
-0.6538504362,
-0.0891061276,
0.2956978679,
-0.0292376988,
0.0881374776,
0.2906010747,
0.675496757,
0.2544647157,
-0.296376735,
-0.3867864609,
-0.8778151274,
0.897503376,
-0.7564319372,
0.7219136953,
0.6113091111,
0.474304527,
0.0566444509,
-0.5670102835,
-0.6708332896,
-0.0202007126,
-0.0250859391,
0.3405089974,
-0.2523395121,
0.1754895449,
0.3157636225,
0.1335433722,
-0.7567459345,
0.2079077512,
-0.3847469389,
-0.4649793208,
0.3925135136,
-0.289442122,
-0.1591631025,
-0.0910202786,
-0.5550251603,
0.0157227106,
-0.3666507006,
0.1862020195,
0.1591568738,
0.3311585784,
-0.0868024528,
0.7570056915,
0.223407954,
0.6559984088,
0.1353774518,
-0.1314114779,
0.4139539003,
-0.1873528808,
-0.3855311573,
0.6177610159,
0.4056706131,
0.4526729882,
0.276677072,
-0.2602185309,
-0.5396255255,
0.1427411586,
-0.0127003966,
-0.8570854068,
0.1655723006,
0.3550389111,
-0.3805459738,
0.146210134,
0.2584367096,
-0.4625658095,
-0.0201155618,
-0.1716299057,
0.6141140461,
-0.2950143814,
-0.0693219975,
0.1631201804,
-0.3631602526,
0.408697933,
0.1808695644,
-0.5273230672,
0.3586265743,
0.4859846234,
0.9747436047,
-0.2674116194,
-0.1736099571,
-0.677670598,
0.4380141497,
-0.1234447807,
0.4930481315,
-0.4259355068,
-0.6778206825,
-0.2662273347,
0.1367025822,
-0.2558024526,
-0.4458503723,
0.6883929372,
-0.3318697214,
0.092587091,
-0.0676705614,
-0.8169227242,
-0.0292277783,
0.2661573291,
-0.3069761395,
0.973246932,
-0.0995537564,
-0.6912603974,
0.2011873871,
-0.0155905429,
-0.5650191307,
-0.035570994,
-0.1302508116,
-0.720582962,
0.2881694734,
-0.0540931188,
0.2115023732,
-0.3521452546,
0.2404205203,
0.0012392324,
-0.8782753348,
0.670770824,
-0.9487897158,
0.5448818207,
-0.1409571171,
-0.3576700687,
-0.073434487,
-0.5058521032,
0.0403195061,
-0.3378216624,
-0.4169401228,
-0.2717369497,
0.0333793834,
0.2248605341,
0.2792825699,
0.3133037984,
-0.9223448038,
-0.5661246181,
-0.3615545332,
0.306273967,
0.7394193411,
-0.1553165615,
-0.0465090871,
-0.3949374259,
0.1870837659,
0.4323515296,
0.0197742525,
-0.0410888866,
-0.5947286487,
-0.6030209064,
-0.2765804231,
0.4301250875,
0.7546887398,
-0.3176552057,
0.8213093281,
-0.4125413895,
-0.3182697594,
-0.4109886885,
-0.1458597332,
0.8991917372,
0.7232946754,
0.7756972909,
-0.4518392384,
-0.541592896,
-0.6532165408,
-0.1113256812,
-0.2870204747,
-0.0466646813,
0.2593300641,
0.3025808334,
-0.2594844103,
0.9610241055,
-0.2301786244,
-0.1888936013,
-0.0741912574,
0.1754918247,
0.1473467797,
0.578117907,
0.1684924066,
-0.8133340478,
-0.4348186851,
-0.2755412161,
-0.3636046648,
0.2653311193,
0.1586087197,
0.0906723589,
0.7141509652,
0.2134518176,
-0.6697922349,
0.6457918882,
0.506876111,
-0.4472280741,
0.4711000621,
-0.3097128272,
0.0374036729,
-0.9986896515,
0.2006669044,
0.2112131715,
-0.1961535811,
-0.6070865393,
-0.5518108606,
0.3008392751,
0.1664101034,
-0.2366067916,
0.4113736153,
-0.3655600846,
-0.350884825,
-0.1147025153,
-0.0431069881,
-0.0144131361,
0.3290095329,
0.20541659,
0.8999417424,
0.4862206578,
-0.3507817388,
0.0791122913,
0.3334980905,
-0.167484194,
0.7908219099,
-0.8444228768,
0.169573158,
-0.1882355958,
0.1940953583,
-1.3397295475,
0.1261490881,
-0.1310245842,
-0.8513858914,
0.8414965868,
-0.4573585689,
-0.3215491176,
-0.6514684558,
-0.0350525267,
0.3658713102,
0.8092743754,
-0.5167440176,
0.502499342,
0.2505346537,
-0.1233472303,
-0.8272413611,
-0.8536159992,
0.1187722832,
0.0197752472,
-0.2257470638,
0.2790623009,
-0.025944246,
0.2324851751,
-0.1575357765,
-0.4832064807,
0.0148976231,
-0.1944682151,
0.4043635726,
0.1950040609,
-0.1779338121,
0.0255569331,
0.0452859402,
-0.3825975955,
-0.0935770944,
-0.4415337741,
0.552288115,
-0.0710278526,
-0.6855157018,
-0.5739010572,
0.0700030401,
0.7139795423,
-0.2747845352,
0.5371089578,
0.5695310831,
-0.6344008446,
0.0463829935,
-0.7667483687,
-0.0538104586,
-0.4407276511,
0.4383161664,
-0.0427566543,
-0.6662840843,
0.4092997015,
0.3972423673,
-0.1445645392,
0.117386885,
0.3322069049,
-0.297603786,
0.7680484056,
0.0603900515,
-0.2347839475,
0.1827147901,
-0.0658418164,
0.0252714325,
-0.9020386934,
-0.3683371246,
-0.4355316758,
-0.4577231705,
-0.3297166228,
-0.7019622326,
0.3765679598,
-0.1408065259,
-0.410120815,
0.1825358421,
-0.3802745044,
0.1668484062,
0.6898113489,
0.2994413972,
0.1963146031,
0.1878782958,
0.1555723697,
0.1012301669,
-0.251029253,
-0.1590037942,
1.0722234249,
0.3553296328,
0.6759092808,
0.2968417704,
0.5701723099,
0.2911044359,
0.0094900876,
-0.8355841041,
0.338611722,
-0.4001686275,
-0.4521095753,
-0.6589411497,
-0.3556489944,
-0.5257599354,
-0.0396590941,
0.0663742125,
-0.4703204334,
0.4245739281,
0.5373820662,
-0.2907854617,
0.2163041383,
-0.4567219913,
0.5165344477,
-0.2967313826,
-0.3524730206,
-0.1680268794,
-1.0172036886,
-0.0140996641,
-0.0372258835,
-0.1330795884,
-0.0086716255,
0.0699698254,
0.7910341024,
-0.3967253864,
0.750447154,
-0.6502916217,
0.1292200536,
0.3845213354,
-0.2176923007,
0.6218438148,
-0.2345809639,
-0.5053442121,
0.2766062915,
0.0162658487,
-0.3635978103,
-0.4494712949,
0.2049170434,
-0.6687494516,
-0.2554677427,
-0.5561038852,
-0.2163001746,
-0.2968546748,
-0.0175015274,
0.367624253,
0.6504876018,
-0.0429446138,
0.4367673099,
0.6460369229,
-0.0796578825,
0.6232378483,
0.4401475787,
0.3789270818,
-0.6031844616,
1.0890996456,
0.4224805534,
0.446885854,
0.4796628058,
0.2204261869,
-0.6513026357,
-0.6637966037,
-0.6223682761,
-0.0311241318,
-0.4064643383,
-0.5110422969,
-0.4629711807,
-0.6650806665,
-0.1091754586,
-0.2812255621,
-0.3626278937,
-0.4029999375,
-0.1005048752,
-0.2216296047,
0.3323503137,
0.0231142025,
0.0759357959,
0.5061025023,
-0.6406927705,
0.1527270973,
0.1626677066,
0.4394387603,
-0.0330771729,
-1.0221178532,
-0.3523439467,
0.3195136786,
0.0540243238,
-0.6721752882,
0.3657839,
0.3474144042,
0.3952093124,
0.2671839893,
-0.0418457575,
0.8294012547,
-0.321084857,
0.5927397013,
0.4132693112,
-1.0508272648,
0.3473540246,
0.1719100773,
0.0913052633,
0.5107746124,
-0.0262198318,
-0.4745803475,
-0.1859994978,
-0.2967760265,
-0.8425528407,
0.5225130916,
0.3148214817,
-0.0477206036,
-0.0649977401,
0.2288766354,
-0.29552266,
0.4390903413,
-0.4203656018,
-0.1770959347,
-0.527497232,
-0.583781302,
-0.4225122333,
-0.6564356685,
0.1700982153,
-0.2038006634,
0.6825261712,
-0.0161843468,
0.3396591544,
0.2714599371,
-0.4363880754,
-0.3382727504,
0.4197483361,
0.6000198126,
0.3664926589,
-0.5210741758,
0.2429850549,
0.3517629206,
-0.6942138672,
0.2716270685,
0.3600320816,
-0.281968534,
0.1949530542,
0.0886895284,
0.8398281336,
0.3563742042,
-0.8076385856,
0.9465087652,
0.1517753154,
0.2057609856,
-0.587741375,
-0.2530751526,
-0.0578320697,
0.1344485283,
0.5172044635,
0.0538683198,
0.1697397679,
-0.2578108311,
0.4123298526,
0.6349406242,
-0.7619885206,
-0.2873951197,
0.4012157023,
0.099374719,
-0.2611121237,
0.6296291351,
-0.1426062584,
-0.5383360386,
0.751545608,
1.048885107,
0.9488458037,
-0.8044048548,
-0.1764573157,
0.4582476318,
0.3282137811,
-0.3565278947,
0.5217154622,
-0.0734688416,
-0.749104023,
-0.1483717859,
-0.9794275165,
-0.6237009168,
-0.4387651086,
-0.8852859735,
0.282102406,
-0.2488344759,
-0.3042153716,
-0.4468168914,
-0.0933748037,
-0.3069193065,
0.5478264689,
0.2367093116,
0.8965838552,
-0.658627212,
0.6673737168,
0.3113316596,
-0.1193830967,
-0.7137699127,
0.1339329481,
-0.1645648181,
-0.8431848884,
0.3929069042,
0.4973582923,
-0.5497316718,
0.238543421,
-0.243500635,
-0.8905860782,
1.4445533752,
-0.0190504491,
-0.8162716627,
-0.176874429,
0.1839267612,
0.463808924,
-0.0284101646,
0.2359151691,
0.4025653899,
0.356179446,
0.6480557919,
-1.0452129841,
0.03492954,
-0.1520676762,
0.0440227874,
0.1667558551,
-0.5346377492,
0.6507855058,
-0.3331567049,
-0.1130234674,
0.0384625904,
0.7089008689,
0.573431015,
0.6495940089,
0.6190063953,
0.4740821719,
0.8096009493,
0.0597016588,
0.4590606689,
-0.5563831925,
0.2291982919,
1.3196172714,
-0.3805936277,
1.1523373127,
0.4653768241,
-0.0322341211,
0.2932591736,
0.4502422512,
-0.209887892,
0.4054486156,
0.1057337224,
-0.246121943,
-0.0776079074,
-0.0261030309,
-0.3804135025,
0.4534962475,
0.6816865206,
-0.4730110765,
0.2297050208,
-0.0972587988,
-0.2765765488,
-0.4583319724,
-0.3922386467,
0.6646924615,
0.2307143211,
-0.4614953995,
0.4651423991,
0.0316760913,
0.76930511,
-0.3985007703,
0.1982350796,
-0.0416164771,
0.2061035633,
-0.2111264914,
-0.8151705265,
0.2496897727,
0.0334995985,
-0.0950150862,
0.1630262583,
0.5879127979,
-0.7901254296,
-0.6375384331,
0.2607785165,
0.4349974394,
0.0862782747,
0.0646768063,
-0.2365654707,
-0.0959347188,
-0.3539934456,
-0.121290125,
0.0786377341,
0.2472556233,
0.0578923151,
0.6461037397,
0.6124739647,
0.1036203057,
0.0569078326,
0.1009208262,
0.5106165409,
-0.6108319759,
-0.6212677956,
-0.829898119,
0.3948991895,
-0.1431506127,
-0.0285419635,
0.5423894525,
1.0139855146,
0.5565755367,
0.1756990999,
0.744137466,
0.2082826346,
0.7473632097,
-0.4358890653,
0.6124284863,
-0.3692427874,
0.1267911345,
-0.3214567304,
-0.5481589437,
-0.1511139721,
0.6697995663,
0.0266973861,
0.1042000577,
0.2925991714,
0.8107862473,
-0.1632787436,
0.1074805707,
0.4787261486,
0.398456037,
0.0994063467,
0.5117405057,
0.6079044342,
-0.4083841741,
0.4635601342,
-0.0773503184,
-0.2199446261,
-0.3738587797,
-0.5806547403,
-0.8490458131,
-0.3975250721,
-0.0661934242,
-0.5485937595,
0.4687719047,
1.2291358709,
0.4385343492,
-0.9995033145,
-0.3885443807,
0.140797928,
0.021933794,
-0.2007044852,
-0.0815854296,
0.4767163098,
0.0851473063,
-0.5492503047,
0.1352782249,
0.5060840845,
0.536226809,
0.1140954718,
-0.3368652463,
0.0166323725,
0.2640126646,
0.6602988839,
0.3066426814,
-0.6197780371,
-0.5596935153,
0.0334715471,
-0.1064281315,
0.0525795594,
0.3535268307,
-0.5291059017,
0.3861239254,
0.1642762572,
0.5015224814,
0.5267525315,
0.3829010427,
0.4688310623,
-0.909735918,
0.1594848931,
0.3146238327,
0.4653394818,
0.5544899702,
-0.1529853195,
0.3048110008,
0.4078939259,
-0.3736061454,
-1.1736274958,
0.0861360133,
-1.1161642075,
0.081599094,
1.1237140894,
-0.141931504,
0.0068661897,
-0.2895219326,
0.01534486,
0.5934590697,
-0.4765597284,
0.617495656,
0.342109412,
-0.0426453464,
-0.1517497301,
-0.121798113,
0.3344511986,
0.38372311,
-0.3487757742,
0.0866003036,
0.3701155782,
0.3212892711,
0.1561927497,
0.6105031371,
0.1088070944,
0.3454799652,
-0.2628190219,
-0.0144080808,
-0.114567399,
-0.4821504653,
-0.3501652777,
0.0669748485,
0.0237487126,
-0.3580979407
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14591v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14591v4
|
Reasons to Reject? Aligning Language Models with Judgments
| 2023-12-22T10:29:43 | 2024-06-06T04:16:54 |
Weiwen Xu, Deng Cai, Zhisong Zhang, Wai Lam, Shuming Shi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As humans, we consistently interact with our peers and receive feedback in
the form of natural language. This language feedback allows us to maintain
appropriate behavior, and rectify potential errors. The question arises
naturally: can we use language feedback to align large language models (LLMs)?
In contrast to previous research that aligns LLMs with scalar rewards, we
present the first systematic exploration of alignment through the lens of
language feedback (i.e., judgment). We start with an in-depth investigation of
potential methods that can be adapted for aligning LLMs with judgments,
revealing that these methods cannot fully capitalize on judgments. To
facilitate more effective utilization of judgments, we propose a novel
framework, Contrastive Unlikelihood Training (CUT), that allows for
fine-grained inappropriate content detection and correction based on judgments.
Our results show that, with merely 1317 off-the-shelf judgment data, CUT
(LLaMA2-13b) can beat the 175B DaVinci003 and surpass the best baseline by
50.84 points on AlpacaEval. CUT (LLaMA2-chat-13b) can also align LLMs in an
iterative fashion using up-to-date model-specific judgments, improving
performance from 81.09 to 91.68 points on AlpacaEval. Further analysis suggests
that judgments hold greater potential than rewards in LLM alignment.
|
[
-0.3077843189,
-0.5131323934,
0.6460028291,
-0.0950480402,
-0.2788344026,
0.0799960867,
-0.232836023,
-0.4888248742,
0.1694765687,
0.472281307,
-0.7203703523,
-0.3078483045,
-0.7326183319,
0.0205461904,
-0.5700191855,
1.0833519697,
-0.0216713306,
0.2724857628,
-0.1020331904,
-0.2238647193,
-0.6258431673,
-0.3099317551,
-0.5357344151,
-0.5307837725,
0.7469105124,
0.4727326334,
0.6971651316,
0.7176824808,
0.7158753872,
0.3630793691,
-0.192366153,
0.3710608482,
-0.5677027106,
-0.0789691731,
-0.3663085401,
-0.458296746,
-0.3718757927,
0.2634056807,
0.596049726,
0.7827071548,
-0.1565784812,
-0.0010522335,
0.3778360188,
0.7838100791,
-0.7393193245,
-0.28116256,
-0.6109182835,
0.111676313,
-0.272575438,
-0.0195661802,
-0.5685402155,
-0.5387441516,
0.1002025381,
-0.4608553052,
-0.0189406686,
0.1010586247,
0.9154103994,
0.4522058368,
-0.2881695926,
-0.3990021348,
-0.6923535466,
1.1092317104,
-0.6797821522,
0.3638386428,
0.4160531759,
0.2653643191,
0.0511506125,
-0.215324834,
-0.6305086017,
-0.1956736445,
-0.1065906212,
0.0278138891,
-0.237183392,
-0.1019272357,
0.2065697163,
0.36412552,
-0.5531337857,
0.5591198802,
-0.1180137843,
-0.1138158217,
0.5869871974,
0.3064454794,
0.2391722947,
-0.0268732682,
-0.4586500227,
-0.3295728862,
-0.7934821248,
-0.0263955723,
0.4768931568,
0.4488364458,
0.1419135779,
0.6515874863,
-0.0634752512,
0.7049170136,
0.3600440919,
-0.1553871334,
0.0889034122,
-0.1027073562,
-0.2768975794,
-0.0329716168,
0.7538627982,
0.863026917,
0.2136659473,
0.1091340706,
-0.2707045078,
0.4379481971,
0.3752435148,
-0.5485448837,
-0.0687630773,
-0.019178316,
-0.3225358725,
-0.4709997773,
-0.0886408463,
-0.8124634624,
-0.7340021133,
-0.3767925799,
0.3175989389,
-0.3121812642,
0.0345303081,
0.0408107229,
0.0765267313,
0.4499494731,
0.7595505118,
-1.0602055788,
0.4521454573,
0.8345372677,
0.665782094,
-0.3205391169,
-0.3048948944,
-0.6558022499,
-0.1750025451,
-0.5438191295,
0.8295110464,
-0.5965313315,
-0.1819827259,
0.0707160383,
-0.2345713824,
0.064391613,
-0.7110785842,
0.6418448091,
-0.4315899312,
0.3018955588,
-0.5126932859,
-0.6640930772,
-0.0574196316,
0.5484665036,
-0.5261682272,
0.6810088158,
-0.053235352,
-0.8313171268,
0.4841735065,
-0.164803043,
-0.2024447322,
-0.2084577978,
-0.0419300906,
-0.2659097612,
0.0200948194,
0.2749988437,
0.0918256193,
-0.3480625451,
0.1969118416,
-0.4361206591,
-0.4228146374,
0.395921886,
-0.4836075306,
0.5764442682,
0.287073195,
-0.3898867071,
0.217424795,
-0.5289766192,
-0.0370903835,
0.0632556304,
-0.2824284732,
-0.4195161164,
0.0367505178,
0.0642976314,
0.0375497676,
-0.0704591721,
-0.6236658096,
0.3146713972,
-0.6034050584,
0.2039021701,
1.0693346262,
-0.526455462,
0.553609848,
-0.6787570715,
0.6636410356,
-0.2040453702,
0.0706573278,
0.1048911437,
-0.00090442,
-0.9758149981,
-0.092981644,
0.4592807591,
0.4385884702,
-0.4093150496,
0.3149402738,
-0.26347211,
-0.432161063,
-0.6880435348,
0.1776100248,
0.6798339486,
0.4354950488,
0.2978703678,
-0.5496065617,
-0.7787070274,
-0.8203117847,
-0.3781606555,
-0.2501968741,
0.0436974838,
0.2408432811,
0.1558912992,
-0.0270946324,
0.7059233189,
-0.5059817433,
-0.3418825269,
-0.1539845765,
-0.2996837497,
0.1725942492,
0.5403183699,
0.4394841492,
-0.5913991928,
-0.3955343366,
-0.0617444217,
-0.5887147784,
-0.2650524974,
0.1345447004,
-0.0429887399,
0.0572900288,
0.5258653164,
-0.3904073536,
0.2035853267,
0.8432425261,
-0.414232403,
0.4513470829,
0.2786695361,
0.1890607625,
-0.8620609641,
-0.1759389192,
0.022855131,
-0.4901374876,
-0.4088591635,
0.0761935189,
-0.0591124333,
0.4429891706,
-0.4192546308,
0.7307190895,
-0.2463845462,
0.1495613903,
-0.2889679968,
0.2589893341,
0.1525568813,
0.3566962779,
-0.1340483576,
0.4963101447,
0.1193780378,
-0.5325452685,
0.2359542549,
0.4856719375,
-0.6317930818,
0.847882092,
-0.4304689765,
0.3195251524,
-0.1008328274,
0.2114108056,
-0.964256227,
-0.1020644382,
0.460593909,
-0.2908037603,
0.4670085907,
-0.0600331612,
-0.034538582,
-0.1233848259,
-0.4925248921,
0.4564093947,
0.5404527783,
-0.8818318248,
0.3508943021,
0.380027324,
-0.1352561414,
-0.8616098166,
-0.9220307469,
-0.0291405115,
-0.2248452753,
-0.3083705604,
0.3531128466,
-0.4179937243,
-0.5963506103,
-0.1306769401,
-0.2038841695,
0.228337273,
0.0654828176,
0.3187288344,
0.3958906829,
-0.098430872,
-0.1061076447,
-0.0719807595,
-0.0044583296,
-0.2161262035,
-0.1214121655,
0.4901836812,
-0.040895801,
-0.8531868458,
-0.3510346115,
0.1948026419,
0.3062083125,
0.1270473301,
0.3766701818,
0.0964515358,
-0.1482249498,
-0.1390775442,
-0.8657637835,
-0.0643094257,
-0.4479485154,
0.1981359571,
-0.02541738,
-1.022462368,
0.1396168619,
0.1657284051,
0.1068892851,
0.397770375,
0.5970867276,
-0.168237105,
1.0219774246,
0.5743584037,
-0.1725411564,
0.6673737168,
0.0579444729,
0.1630077064,
-0.9199857712,
-0.1877053827,
-0.5550911427,
-0.389995724,
-0.4906515479,
-0.2744002938,
-0.2004456371,
0.1203243136,
-0.1740869135,
0.1870449483,
-0.3179991841,
0.6903260946,
0.4028607309,
0.2173856497,
0.3796469867,
-0.1079315543,
-0.1711178422,
-0.280212611,
-0.5139977932,
-0.7049554586,
0.9223579168,
0.4377855062,
0.8705855608,
0.143114239,
0.673509717,
0.2709365189,
0.5545079112,
-1.0199491978,
0.5466005206,
-0.2850527465,
-0.3283576369,
-0.1898257136,
-0.4249057174,
-0.7761185169,
0.3129287064,
-0.0465919003,
-0.7393966317,
0.1877949834,
0.1113971248,
-0.3321787417,
0.2704737484,
-0.6575769782,
0.7019509077,
-0.1126256883,
-0.3344451785,
-0.1501153708,
-0.4526922107,
0.315962553,
-0.080565542,
0.4623329937,
-0.1776065975,
0.2717865705,
0.7838879228,
-0.6310847402,
1.0015500784,
-0.0325166546,
-0.2438758314,
0.215980038,
0.2908342183,
0.296328187,
-0.2560812831,
-0.2137616724,
0.0432249978,
0.0166650731,
-0.1982282102,
-0.7245128155,
0.70128721,
-0.621229291,
-0.7835816741,
-0.4858213067,
-0.5852127671,
-0.2600554526,
0.1267364025,
0.2054020017,
0.2454188764,
-0.495760262,
-0.158640787,
0.3105157018,
0.0428169966,
0.2897844315,
0.6289135218,
-0.477368176,
-0.5178448558,
0.7963727117,
-0.0738521889,
0.3534297347,
0.3727277517,
0.2865178883,
-0.2870438099,
-0.7078965902,
-0.2631034255,
0.1526003182,
-0.8338716626,
-0.359272182,
-0.2644290626,
-0.031959936,
-0.2860766053,
-0.1936711818,
-0.4765397012,
-0.238604486,
-0.068194665,
-0.1513700783,
-0.0827613845,
0.9835138321,
-0.1736190766,
0.2045083791,
-0.8665834069,
0.0001874315,
0.3968405724,
0.2517497241,
0.0554689206,
-0.887524128,
-0.0200483445,
0.1924225539,
-0.4037599266,
-0.5484448671,
0.2987801135,
-0.0495799147,
0.2488922477,
0.5199800134,
0.02582822,
0.7911321521,
-0.54953897,
0.6776154637,
0.413687259,
-1.0398947001,
0.4470393658,
-0.0846937001,
0.1742476225,
0.6157653332,
0.3411568999,
-0.6495220065,
-0.4273069203,
-0.3472592831,
-0.5435384512,
0.7927216291,
0.0186925232,
0.2663626075,
-0.0354181603,
0.2592476904,
0.2009330988,
0.0376627967,
-0.8871741295,
0.0381839983,
0.0805583,
-0.342574209,
-0.1535686404,
-0.4608386457,
-0.4578573704,
-0.1145152599,
0.7249099016,
-0.2213522196,
-0.1696403772,
0.1873644143,
-0.1468999088,
-0.3969241679,
0.4000911117,
0.4857732654,
0.6424331665,
-0.0701308399,
0.0392199047,
0.1613512188,
-0.2715116143,
0.3278874755,
-0.0653939992,
-0.3294551373,
-0.1841220707,
0.5964400768,
0.8036308885,
0.2689059079,
-0.711730659,
0.6277331114,
-0.2098811865,
-0.2298272699,
0.1010472476,
0.0052514221,
-0.1410259157,
0.5842972994,
-0.1734277308,
0.0474859811,
-0.0970086232,
-0.5022257566,
-0.0051251361,
0.5975416899,
-0.6820822358,
-0.1522561312,
0.4104069173,
0.0100940764,
-0.3387829661,
0.6611042619,
-0.1158743352,
-0.6116165519,
0.3598391414,
0.4172742367,
0.748197794,
-0.3177022338,
0.1028822437,
0.2325882018,
0.1811928004,
-0.2690860331,
-0.0509471074,
0.0340688638,
-1.1664571762,
-0.685140729,
-0.8891987801,
-0.6701059341,
-0.0192096122,
-0.7349510193,
0.3893093765,
-0.6732571721,
-0.0013782111,
0.0752423853,
-0.1784264147,
-0.4991486371,
0.1658889949,
0.3663091063,
0.6722602248,
-1.0417858362,
0.7236098647,
0.572639823,
-0.4567274153,
-1.0458905697,
0.094904758,
0.4461080134,
-0.9283120632,
0.6026094556,
0.2721503079,
-0.136128962,
-0.285564065,
-0.6147689819,
-0.7650936246,
0.5550996065,
0.6287453771,
-0.9889076352,
-0.0953524262,
-0.1772106588,
0.4256529212,
-0.3292364776,
0.3144788146,
0.7057437897,
0.3890284598,
0.4648658931,
-0.9910995364,
0.1186853424,
-0.1769628525,
-0.0750812143,
0.3243142962,
-0.72430408,
0.5919778347,
-0.2899317145,
-0.0868506134,
0.2876878083,
0.4469153285,
0.3628943861,
0.2810442746,
0.6857059598,
0.7633576393,
0.7599859834,
-0.0415646844,
1.0526633263,
0.1670884639,
0.2745606005,
1.2131310701,
-0.4287478328,
0.8579937816,
0.7149252295,
-0.481708616,
0.6620435119,
0.7022991776,
-0.0237856973,
0.6134790778,
0.1397906542,
0.0307746343,
-0.3289216161,
-0.4499589801,
-0.2514785528,
0.607247889,
0.0727322996,
-0.2198391259,
-0.0506909005,
-0.247125566,
-0.0423520282,
0.3668597043,
-0.2356432825,
0.9155960679,
0.2896779478,
-0.9133288264,
0.5577821136,
-0.0434514098,
0.7309660912,
-0.5195493102,
-0.1728261262,
-0.2658117712,
0.3752130568,
-0.4538879991,
-0.7883432508,
0.5217205882,
0.0955458507,
-0.251791507,
-0.3183304965,
0.5214731693,
-0.347859472,
-0.3319309056,
0.3468361795,
0.2702411115,
0.0243993793,
-0.0041284207,
-0.5291618705,
0.3314133883,
0.1512714028,
-0.117315121,
0.6566621661,
0.2510489523,
0.0695175678,
0.5109226704,
0.65155828,
0.0710483119,
-0.2904777825,
0.3021506965,
0.8979580402,
-0.6501496434,
-0.3411326408,
-1.1676619053,
0.3705307543,
0.1943609416,
-0.191105172,
0.6801584363,
0.2949585915,
1.1260129213,
0.2170014828,
0.6204627156,
0.1752398461,
0.5768840313,
-0.793784678,
0.3600679934,
-0.6548610926,
0.4756709039,
-0.6504378915,
-1.0582123995,
-0.2847501338,
0.6228189468,
-0.4068987072,
0.0199265908,
0.7647215724,
0.748102963,
0.1736604273,
0.0718969256,
0.298085928,
0.199870497,
0.3640958369,
0.577994585,
1.2013152838,
-0.3231194615,
0.6205464005,
-0.0941883922,
-0.2057374716,
-0.1994014531,
-0.8979008198,
-0.721773684,
-0.2405140698,
-0.3057636321,
-0.572224319,
0.0452088751,
1.036331892,
0.5693750978,
-0.8948879838,
-0.2694988549,
-0.1149353907,
0.2209279686,
-0.1225817129,
-0.1355268806,
0.2363432348,
-0.1854925454,
-0.9068741202,
0.5154412985,
0.2303571403,
0.004894027,
-0.1388905048,
-0.3054978549,
-0.2223751694,
-0.1004577428,
0.3750889301,
0.2207359523,
-1.0163046122,
-0.5095335841,
-0.1954929531,
-0.2902890444,
0.176486671,
0.7265439034,
-0.5987102985,
0.4267616272,
0.3039755821,
0.7790782452,
0.338070482,
0.0628656968,
0.7540189624,
-0.4974713624,
0.0784672797,
0.3477701545,
0.4279900193,
0.6180791855,
-0.1724707633,
0.512986958,
0.1138447225,
-0.5883277059,
-0.8631367683,
0.3665097058,
-0.8825585842,
-0.126069352,
1.1537424326,
-0.1131773815,
-0.1765260845,
0.2822229266,
-0.3488854766,
0.063460581,
-0.2818273902,
0.7224953771,
0.9811019301,
-0.0180865638,
-0.0624470189,
-0.1527928263,
0.4193205535,
0.9539137483,
-0.5690428019,
-0.0174083523,
0.6135538816,
0.3370520771,
0.1427520066,
0.6645029187,
-0.1498147249,
0.0775821656,
-0.1326544732,
0.0054104594,
0.281816572,
-0.1413694769,
-0.6929591298,
-0.0062757842,
0.5688618422,
-0.0566960275
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14590v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14590v2
|
SIG: Speaker Identification in Literature via Prompt-Based Generation
| 2023-12-22T10:29:18 | 2024-02-19T09:25:44 |
Zhenlin Su, Liyan Xu, Jin Xu, Jiangnan Li, Mingdu Huangfu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Identifying speakers of quotations in narratives is an important task in
literary analysis, with challenging scenarios including the out-of-domain
inference for unseen speakers, and non-explicit cases where there are no
speaker mentions in surrounding context. In this work, we propose a simple and
effective approach SIG, a generation-based method that verbalizes the task and
quotation input based on designed prompt templates, which also enables easy
integration of other auxiliary tasks that further bolster the speaker
identification performance. The prediction can either come from direct
generation by the model, or be determined by the highest generation probability
of each speaker candidate. Based on our approach design, SIG supports
out-of-domain evaluation, and achieves open-world classification paradigm that
is able to accept any forms of candidate input. We perform both cross-domain
evaluation and in-domain evaluation on PDNC, the largest dataset of this task,
where empirical results suggest that SIG outperforms previous baselines of
complicated designs, as well as the zero-shot ChatGPT, especially excelling at
those hard non-explicit scenarios by up to 17% improvement. Additional
experiments on another dataset WP further corroborate the efficacy of SIG.
|
[
-0.3364187181,
-0.6471350789,
0.6416025162,
-0.020250788,
-0.3566224277,
-0.0123823574,
-0.2841844857,
-0.2260608673,
0.0222536027,
0.5214143395,
-0.8768689036,
-0.3346565068,
-0.4961847067,
0.2921227217,
-0.0960529372,
0.7359528542,
0.4418281317,
0.0119033605,
-0.2244893909,
0.0345112309,
-0.7455939651,
-0.1399538368,
-0.4572006762,
-0.1273036152,
0.3754157424,
0.2466600239,
0.4368763268,
0.2754823267,
-0.0996560007,
0.2291276008,
-0.1728352159,
0.4266593158,
-0.3615600169,
0.4649665952,
-0.3003234863,
-0.1224646494,
0.1091558486,
0.199200511,
0.6180716157,
0.7656674385,
0.1623149067,
0.1792391241,
0.3599371314,
0.2743671238,
-0.5251528621,
0.328448832,
-0.733124733,
0.346326232,
-0.401488781,
-0.5741301179,
-1.0215938091,
-0.545527935,
0.2226607054,
-0.5071852803,
0.4788830876,
0.2905675769,
0.6353883147,
0.017595876,
-0.4682438374,
-0.3618287146,
-0.5841192007,
0.74459517,
-0.6417104602,
0.01806527,
0.0424239412,
0.145168677,
-0.6523523927,
-0.5432621241,
-0.3618010283,
-0.4826282263,
-0.3683057725,
0.2631107569,
-0.0035647596,
-0.0654337257,
0.4547742009,
0.2625513673,
-0.726153791,
-0.1547009498,
-0.1518923193,
-0.1876326799,
0.6147031784,
-0.1849278659,
0.4586408436,
-0.5124860406,
-0.7116379142,
0.2399559468,
-0.7215697765,
0.0476076081,
0.4280404747,
0.7943739295,
0.3348937631,
0.4580039084,
0.1987148374,
0.4728063345,
0.3270151615,
-0.1252577007,
0.1908928305,
-0.1596204042,
0.0268827621,
0.4394579232,
0.9061523676,
0.3171733916,
0.1404079348,
-0.0911752805,
0.045148842,
-0.5011802316,
0.0632841215,
-0.6723905802,
-0.0439906716,
-0.1827225685,
-0.5360181332,
-0.1425210387,
0.1234749556,
-0.9968944788,
-1.0018239021,
-0.059504535,
0.5182151198,
-0.5061494708,
-0.1488461196,
-0.500346899,
-0.3928447366,
0.2474082261,
0.2605740428,
-0.8031600118,
0.0585943982,
0.3010072708,
0.8683053255,
-0.1849060059,
-0.0520296805,
-0.9678150415,
0.2719931304,
-0.3436622918,
0.8099157214,
-0.3990398645,
-0.6943070889,
0.0300576799,
0.1288272887,
-0.4497538209,
-0.3095091581,
0.7837554812,
-0.1495351642,
0.7362068295,
-0.5052175522,
-0.8903496861,
0.0761485919,
-0.1913145781,
-0.6042090058,
1.2062222958,
0.2435827553,
-0.9504562616,
0.4349630177,
-0.5324394703,
-0.1215109751,
0.7973071337,
-0.5658397079,
-0.1980169863,
0.2497067451,
0.3631002009,
0.480892837,
-0.605879426,
0.196795091,
-0.1444370598,
-0.5844339132,
0.0803608522,
-0.2467294782,
0.9045769572,
0.3633803427,
-0.4332002401,
-0.1958537698,
-0.8284882307,
-0.0004358287,
0.2554670274,
0.0577442199,
-0.3685207367,
0.0219352134,
-0.070141837,
-0.2164041549,
0.0067657502,
-0.744194448,
0.0825980678,
-0.6388960481,
0.2688070238,
0.6878563762,
0.4863032699,
0.3190332949,
-0.1549838483,
0.7920028567,
-0.4106867313,
-0.1542090029,
-0.6434001327,
-0.732439518,
-0.1676985323,
-0.5526221395,
0.5990717411,
0.6089439988,
-0.9056002498,
0.7178388238,
0.0916985869,
-0.6360663176,
-0.1521545649,
-0.1186037213,
0.3796238601,
0.6215056181,
0.073529467,
-0.1069026366,
-0.2087543458,
-0.5970104933,
-0.4721334875,
-0.6616582274,
-0.1381755024,
0.5359221697,
-0.0194160286,
0.160235256,
1.0935311317,
-0.5904614925,
0.0172391888,
-0.5098788738,
0.3848993182,
0.221729666,
0.3630532324,
0.7428394556,
-0.6077306867,
-0.5719665289,
0.0199454147,
-0.8317526579,
-0.6016165614,
-0.391089946,
-0.1803174019,
-0.3447755575,
0.659502387,
-0.4080988765,
0.2838802338,
-0.069560267,
-0.3360776901,
0.5898843408,
0.0249519367,
0.2422296256,
-0.9790804386,
-0.0096048769,
0.2640639246,
0.0699859262,
-0.6557359695,
-0.229936555,
-0.0107558239,
-0.570910871,
-0.4184910059,
0.7833752632,
-0.3480986357,
0.2400489897,
-0.0496521369,
0.2825021744,
0.0910670534,
0.5549931526,
-0.1830191463,
0.8882786632,
0.3880237043,
-0.4295753241,
0.3748495281,
0.3311853111,
-0.5630477667,
0.7218567133,
-0.3861050904,
0.252556771,
-0.343429625,
0.3230851591,
-1.3158456087,
-0.0985215977,
0.4871557951,
-0.4246032238,
0.3057792485,
-0.4990209937,
-0.4103209376,
-0.0187400524,
-0.072072655,
0.3254387975,
0.4167202115,
-0.8245869279,
0.705499053,
0.1398333609,
-0.8230165243,
-0.4275378287,
-0.1428048611,
0.1710337251,
-0.5831617117,
-0.4748942852,
0.4284375608,
-0.257627815,
-0.2381655574,
-0.4939783812,
0.0871925056,
0.0700185373,
-0.1781457514,
0.2859974802,
0.2537203431,
-0.1867994666,
0.4876608551,
0.1921016872,
-0.1488789767,
-0.1265048087,
-0.168103978,
0.2970344424,
0.1224396527,
-0.2796599865,
-0.2666257024,
0.7184177637,
0.3953745365,
-0.1390993893,
0.4061366916,
0.7304851413,
-0.1215486377,
-0.5470833778,
-0.3808040917,
0.1511570662,
-0.5009333491,
0.030993389,
-0.4737447202,
-0.5615329146,
0.2515133619,
-0.4867175519,
-0.1691069901,
0.5497959256,
0.3813868761,
-0.1796914488,
0.808842361,
0.5744534135,
0.2681867778,
0.6627218723,
0.160682857,
0.3160643578,
-0.5527097583,
-0.115053907,
-0.6953252554,
0.0766971782,
-0.4576942623,
-0.029053906,
0.4426694512,
0.1286200434,
0.2121367455,
0.5007021427,
-0.5206005573,
0.6101289988,
0.6701171398,
-0.093986541,
0.1132499278,
-0.1914573163,
-0.6061017513,
-0.2584846318,
-0.4686865509,
-0.7584902048,
0.6684453487,
0.1277993768,
0.4241333604,
-0.0283807628,
0.6835543513,
0.8976066113,
-0.2146294713,
-0.6976582408,
0.8915582299,
0.1840975881,
-0.4868342578,
-0.3946339786,
-0.3268832564,
-0.8455825448,
0.5159826279,
-0.0098135825,
-0.9575069547,
0.4523927271,
-0.1388065368,
-0.6018500328,
-0.0243825708,
-0.9549289346,
0.8155061007,
-0.0324483812,
0.1068623066,
0.13893345,
-0.5230536461,
0.1657556295,
-0.1143386364,
0.1617642194,
-0.2925007939,
0.293607384,
0.7176571488,
-0.401001066,
0.6975871921,
-0.5402984619,
-0.0430180542,
0.6849788427,
0.0448390022,
0.5748084784,
0.1133886501,
-0.404448688,
-0.1410652846,
0.1807594448,
-0.3325868249,
-0.5723671317,
0.6186580062,
-0.5665197968,
-0.4567598104,
-0.5222423077,
-0.2078044266,
-0.5498193502,
0.1164681762,
0.6155236363,
0.5535789132,
-0.5541331768,
0.2229167521,
0.5537259579,
-0.6320788264,
0.5517323017,
0.2732006907,
0.0898404643,
-0.5980221033,
0.7278513312,
0.0828832909,
-0.0650670603,
0.2155013978,
0.3425855339,
-0.4100160003,
-0.5191727281,
-0.7422538996,
0.2597123384,
-0.7247793674,
0.0567026436,
-0.4660210609,
-0.4210195839,
-0.5085738301,
-0.1136956364,
0.1259113699,
-0.252741307,
-0.3764711618,
-0.1895150244,
0.0741475746,
0.4869354367,
0.3285479248,
0.5599154234,
-0.5800949931,
-0.0251301881,
0.292498976,
0.0600303784,
-0.3208701313,
-0.5426512361,
-0.1751692891,
-0.5300566554,
-0.2672348917,
-1.2055824995,
0.3648003042,
0.4704148769,
0.7517644167,
0.3213950992,
0.4493027627,
0.4556629956,
-0.6323928237,
1.1981196404,
0.244014293,
-0.9258822203,
0.8511121273,
-0.4828308225,
0.1187221631,
0.5717127323,
0.1522827446,
-0.5671364665,
-0.2967324555,
-0.7599208951,
-0.8105878234,
0.8770492673,
0.2615872622,
0.1694301963,
-0.1026919782,
0.3149714768,
0.6439351439,
0.2382380515,
-0.699174881,
0.0478015468,
-0.0899171829,
0.0230614096,
-0.2066087425,
-0.2738831639,
-0.0940110534,
0.0549864583,
0.8554353118,
-0.4183185101,
0.2680184245,
0.1447182894,
-0.221537739,
-0.1976257563,
0.4083399177,
0.3696191311,
0.3961642981,
-0.1708013564,
0.0619785339,
0.1181197837,
-0.078153722,
-0.0111343926,
0.1203393415,
-0.3435104191,
0.3288785219,
0.3889036775,
0.6822572947,
-0.103190951,
-0.6815174818,
0.8334034681,
-0.1942682862,
-0.0962498039,
-0.4936644435,
0.1892478764,
-0.4004528224,
0.5966902971,
0.6139810681,
0.1036245823,
0.1520966142,
-0.3081634045,
0.1158938855,
0.4081149697,
-0.490485996,
-0.1350133866,
0.4329444766,
0.2294300646,
-0.4731275141,
0.1730997413,
-0.4730963111,
-0.1536510587,
0.4134883583,
0.5356602073,
1.1787587404,
-0.0518998168,
0.4848117828,
0.3194975555,
0.0542208701,
0.283739984,
0.0250608549,
-0.2189246565,
-0.5313211083,
-0.2880808413,
-0.4977432191,
-0.5051457882,
0.2411119342,
-0.5050906539,
0.4377562404,
-0.4360851943,
-0.173617661,
0.1025161892,
0.0358290747,
-0.270768404,
-0.0005525994,
0.5445083976,
0.592101872,
-1.1188492775,
0.5969681144,
0.2902085483,
-0.2691339254,
-0.4503226578,
0.3095794916,
0.1604032665,
-0.420781523,
0.2967037857,
0.0848257989,
-0.0788815841,
0.0632787123,
-0.5232243538,
-0.663038671,
1.1408174038,
0.6490316987,
-0.2890158594,
0.1399843246,
-0.1973006129,
0.3110940158,
-0.5114443302,
0.556804359,
0.3897991478,
0.4485669434,
0.6257736087,
-0.8280081749,
0.0055244728,
-0.492389679,
0.2487509996,
0.0019271084,
-0.6280135512,
0.5864821076,
0.0191519503,
-0.369535625,
0.409816891,
0.7896965146,
0.3207909465,
0.4145420492,
0.8347389102,
-0.0944131836,
1.3038514853,
-0.1383122951,
0.6795008183,
0.0115907257,
0.1086633801,
1.0904669762,
-0.5364622474,
0.3275657594,
0.2056622058,
-0.1126762629,
0.4857756495,
0.7404103279,
-0.2097701728,
0.7230584621,
0.1325183213,
-0.5781238079,
-0.1037075743,
-0.5378288031,
-0.4721875787,
0.2480084002,
0.1161765829,
-0.5388479233,
-0.2093646824,
0.3362761438,
0.0255602878,
0.1818383783,
-0.1654944569,
0.7670356035,
-0.0444467627,
-0.7737731934,
0.2495707721,
-0.0488266349,
0.2383636981,
-0.5755233765,
-0.0677520782,
-0.0014531297,
0.0862585083,
0.0017287935,
-0.366908282,
-0.121376358,
0.0128883235,
-0.1163630933,
-0.5010287166,
0.9625400901,
-0.3712733984,
-0.4933692813,
0.1192676201,
0.6184411645,
0.2654084563,
0.0474021211,
-0.4504528344,
-0.3722389042,
0.1656813622,
-0.1706384569,
0.2684663534,
0.7673336267,
-0.0333461165,
0.047404483,
0.3229243755,
0.1956779063,
-0.0097171469,
0.3925262094,
0.4754374921,
-0.693128109,
-0.6424290538,
-0.7754073739,
0.4293309748,
-0.2760990262,
-0.4994103312,
0.8924022913,
0.3277149498,
0.3655706048,
-0.0904376879,
1.0020321608,
-0.059942808,
0.8737571836,
-0.2762985528,
0.4481908679,
-0.1505950987,
0.3271980584,
-0.6348725557,
-0.8050857782,
-0.0358709395,
0.3668223917,
-0.3579179049,
-0.0258098822,
0.8718549609,
0.832112968,
0.1778546572,
0.4848968089,
0.4724966586,
0.0049573905,
0.4943037331,
0.074175097,
1.1534645557,
-0.2994262576,
0.4664445817,
0.1850344539,
-0.2690316439,
-0.221208781,
-1.0223568678,
-0.9148153663,
-0.5834986567,
-0.5719915628,
-0.2383169681,
-0.0471135341,
1.1236160994,
0.5200327039,
-0.8341149092,
-0.0518263802,
0.1428845078,
-0.1170345172,
-0.4015430212,
-0.1859880984,
0.3901852965,
-0.3972005546,
-0.7323049307,
1.0460621119,
0.3313419819,
-0.1598166376,
-0.0497045442,
-0.0133688729,
0.0656344518,
0.5391038656,
0.4245201945,
0.3133001328,
-0.7096550465,
-0.4519967139,
-0.3142563403,
0.0975517929,
-0.0757009611,
0.8410608172,
-0.8632532358,
0.6098319292,
0.4443630576,
0.4417199492,
0.450368315,
0.2567436099,
0.7764334083,
-1.2194002867,
-0.0172275659,
0.3043858409,
0.6507310867,
0.1692718714,
-0.5319870114,
0.4960632324,
0.4639380276,
-0.5369638205,
-0.9858891964,
0.2194630355,
-1.01673913,
-0.2552725673,
1.2574175596,
-0.3883191049,
0.0403952971,
-0.1792098135,
-0.6369475126,
0.1349017024,
-0.4360671937,
0.4482824802,
0.9257900119,
-0.2307417095,
-0.2545513213,
-0.3335300684,
0.4116490781,
0.3251155615,
-0.5669784546,
0.1301096827,
0.5254809856,
-0.158679083,
0.2501473427,
0.6625173092,
-0.1243071258,
-0.0574277826,
-0.1297334135,
-0.084961988,
0.1148981526,
-0.33321926,
-0.1880499125,
0.7317297459,
0.0650681853,
-0.215982303
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14557v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14557v2
|
Aurora:Activating Chinese chat capability for Mixtral-8x7B sparse Mixture-of-Experts through Instruction-Tuning
| 2023-12-22T09:30:41 | 2024-01-01T09:24:47 |
Rongsheng Wang, Haoming Chen, Ruizhe Zhou, Yaofei Duan, Kunyan Cai, Han Ma, Jiaxi Cui, Jian Li, Patrick Cheong-Iao Pang, Yapeng Wang, Tao Tan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Existing research has demonstrated that refining large language models (LLMs)
through the utilization of machine-generated instruction-following data
empowers these models to exhibit impressive zero-shot capabilities for novel
tasks, without requiring human-authored instructions. In this paper, we
systematically investigate, preprocess, and integrate three Chinese
instruction-following datasets with the aim of enhancing the Chinese
conversational capabilities of Mixtral-8x7B sparse Mixture-of-Experts model.
Through instruction fine-tuning on this carefully processed dataset, we
successfully construct the Mixtral-8x7B sparse Mixture-of-Experts model named
"Aurora." To assess the performance of Aurora, we utilize three widely
recognized benchmark tests: C-Eval, MMLU, and CMMLU. Empirical studies validate
the effectiveness of instruction fine-tuning applied to Mixtral-8x7B sparse
Mixture-of-Experts model. This work is pioneering in the execution of
instruction fine-tuning on a sparse expert-mixed model, marking a significant
breakthrough in enhancing the capabilities of this model architecture. Our
code, data and model are publicly available at
https://github.com/WangRongsheng/Aurora
|
[
-0.1931646466,
-1.0679891109,
0.2875016332,
0.3451675475,
-0.0228578541,
0.3306862712,
-0.2608000636,
-0.3850910068,
0.244585067,
0.6945179105,
-0.4604815543,
-0.5557954907,
-0.3429311812,
-0.0714438781,
-0.6673738956,
0.6026432514,
0.2623556852,
-0.0482392162,
0.3199071586,
0.0864352435,
-0.7709140778,
-0.2259381562,
-0.6905014515,
0.0367596373,
0.3969037831,
0.8035167456,
0.9859355092,
0.7425903082,
0.001814521,
0.2174652964,
-0.1745118648,
0.6117399335,
-0.7468013167,
-0.1924414933,
0.2927119732,
-0.5677045584,
-0.6905512214,
-0.3117467165,
0.759557724,
0.741684854,
-0.356030941,
-0.1167936996,
0.4130482078,
0.3943048716,
-0.5713938475,
0.1523234099,
-0.8726662397,
0.0740095675,
0.1308872849,
-0.359724313,
-0.7509605885,
0.147950992,
-0.1249148548,
-0.708247602,
0.1354766637,
0.5028179884,
0.5737970471,
0.2141243517,
-0.1051060557,
0.049802538,
-0.604832232,
1.0190938711,
-0.8747763634,
0.2540366948,
0.385206759,
0.1049676314,
-0.2460065782,
-0.3456173837,
-0.5102952123,
-0.1852457821,
0.0243372153,
0.2079516053,
0.1103326008,
0.3478001952,
0.1074359715,
0.4063584805,
-0.497702539,
0.4882851243,
-0.4449009001,
0.0281006489,
0.6398242712,
0.5500812531,
0.5003995895,
0.0554464683,
0.0083210021,
0.0965216234,
-0.6444859505,
-0.1464882791,
0.2227145284,
0.5871784091,
-0.3335408866,
0.4533029795,
-0.4609848261,
0.7661405206,
0.4238047898,
0.1230962574,
0.203542918,
-0.2174721509,
-0.3204815686,
0.1440944374,
0.8074720502,
0.4815814197,
-0.3962061703,
-0.1859157383,
-0.334137857,
-0.4992746711,
0.0293786135,
-0.6852443814,
-0.2727639377,
0.2935905457,
-0.3529552519,
-0.3725342453,
-0.2276301086,
-0.5372616649,
-0.3657575846,
-0.3603889644,
0.4719997942,
-0.4348501861,
-0.4182734191,
0.2418254018,
0.2073154449,
0.3982335925,
0.4685813189,
-1.2834647894,
0.2612404227,
0.8895747662,
0.7961352468,
-0.2067470849,
-0.3640342057,
-0.7177223563,
-0.0554183833,
-0.8558367491,
0.4940234423,
-0.662124455,
-0.2676329911,
0.0315927267,
-0.0491699576,
-0.2282841355,
-0.6230990291,
0.2468862087,
-0.3916547894,
0.2308848798,
0.0228695571,
-0.5774670243,
-0.2431010902,
0.1197921857,
-0.3665637076,
1.184057951,
-0.0171166565,
-0.4939001501,
0.075836584,
-0.4435916841,
-0.3087675869,
0.3883045316,
-0.3342112899,
-0.0929566026,
0.0138790598,
0.3885633945,
0.6306538582,
-0.1992934346,
0.0390416086,
-0.2552861869,
-0.6861158013,
-0.0489493683,
-0.4213475287,
0.7329243422,
0.0658887327,
-0.3078194857,
0.3835810125,
-0.9312739968,
0.0416635983,
-0.1672095209,
0.0625529438,
-0.214304626,
0.1115941256,
-0.1250912994,
-0.215288803,
0.3146958947,
-0.2147020549,
0.0733159333,
-0.3145079017,
0.1523289084,
0.7167169452,
-0.0891369805,
0.4553587139,
-0.3742269278,
0.4382081628,
0.0223133191,
0.2271117121,
-0.6503604054,
-0.4889134765,
-1.0750062466,
-0.1937647313,
0.2358472794,
0.7969974875,
-1.0779256821,
0.689847827,
0.0470193513,
-0.5945135355,
-0.8536577821,
0.2365816385,
0.2310180068,
0.3979528248,
0.4667174816,
-0.1321498752,
-0.3086837232,
-0.6650078893,
0.1183671877,
0.0523727275,
-0.1857085973,
0.4142445922,
0.0196497273,
-0.0694777891,
0.4029727578,
-0.3852217197,
-0.0478359424,
-0.6068875194,
0.1702079028,
0.1795719415,
0.6225021482,
0.4173241556,
-0.298207581,
-0.8372144699,
0.226231873,
-0.7033287287,
-0.0218134355,
-0.4195888042,
-0.2109431624,
0.0554457754,
0.3863824904,
-0.2262815982,
0.2603331506,
0.718016386,
0.0132961767,
0.6000579,
-0.2398809493,
0.3790981174,
-1.0456684828,
-0.4541424513,
-0.1297246814,
-0.057676807,
-0.7729176879,
0.1976817399,
0.102505289,
-0.0732961372,
-0.5307944417,
0.171890229,
-0.5122143626,
0.1179879606,
-0.5012804866,
0.0631238669,
-0.1500716954,
0.5925664306,
0.1457585543,
0.8822922707,
1.094102025,
-0.5734317303,
0.3102346361,
-0.0160348918,
-0.2886428833,
0.0676131174,
-0.7534581423,
0.3037665188,
0.1670054793,
-0.2723756135,
-0.8892070055,
-0.2757694423,
0.4089116156,
-0.1801196635,
0.3089176714,
-0.1303502917,
-0.7827513814,
0.2840049565,
-0.1287023127,
0.1156359687,
0.8250722885,
-0.359264493,
0.8151990771,
0.0970826596,
-0.0674425215,
-0.6122825742,
-0.5322489738,
0.2452011406,
-0.0991711318,
-0.6368410587,
0.2254201621,
-0.1189389005,
-0.0772632137,
-0.2467207462,
0.1897537559,
-0.1683068275,
0.1523641497,
-0.005086238,
0.4754702449,
-0.4712977111,
-0.2976364493,
0.4890202284,
0.0043225121,
-0.1314313263,
-0.0322160237,
0.5030489564,
0.0259901602,
-0.4435095489,
-0.7522292733,
0.2453757823,
0.2756974101,
-0.0248778407,
1.1887693405,
0.5355195999,
-0.2146539241,
-0.4339179695,
-0.5115091205,
-0.4376057982,
-0.5390225053,
0.4251018763,
0.0457254872,
-0.8874211907,
0.5780061483,
0.1856672764,
0.4710397124,
0.114969641,
0.3757147193,
0.1516260803,
1.2381137609,
0.7025258541,
-0.1668480188,
0.5683387518,
-0.0388926528,
0.1056882814,
-0.781190753,
0.1655455828,
-0.2565293312,
-0.0933706239,
-0.2917817831,
-0.4514280856,
0.2584807873,
-0.1668732315,
-0.0125289587,
0.3204419613,
-0.6142568588,
0.6693890095,
0.432682544,
0.3398070633,
0.2505995929,
-0.1788500994,
0.0911317021,
0.0644670427,
-0.8817542791,
-0.338960588,
1.049659133,
0.2758246362,
0.8998152018,
-0.4144977927,
0.5679116845,
0.2464795411,
0.0711879134,
-0.4087055027,
0.7317957282,
-0.0961975381,
-0.3939855993,
-0.2251840681,
-0.4715788066,
-0.7091736794,
0.3578063548,
-0.4429443479,
-0.6872684956,
-0.0967540517,
0.2007716596,
-0.7027542591,
0.230836764,
-0.8785313368,
0.8037342429,
-0.3457946777,
-0.4479734302,
-0.49174577,
-0.4080811739,
0.5276610255,
-0.0590946674,
0.2310081571,
-0.0515694171,
0.1155501381,
0.5080230236,
-0.0967470407,
1.0833281279,
0.1049107537,
-0.1350388825,
0.2504817247,
-0.0132978661,
0.2492766231,
-0.2203197777,
-0.0217542127,
0.1691580266,
-0.1389353126,
-0.4251771271,
-0.7618591189,
0.6220434308,
-1.0298985243,
-0.6411132812,
0.0617572851,
-0.5888217688,
0.0330234952,
0.2001054585,
-0.0517080016,
0.5788873434,
0.1089850813,
0.4933815598,
0.7980912328,
-0.4831078053,
-0.0331982635,
0.8436380625,
-0.5617668033,
-0.3091957569,
1.0988295078,
0.2482453436,
0.5060078502,
0.5725345612,
-0.1018906161,
0.2363390774,
-0.7752502561,
-0.5017946362,
-0.0961669311,
-0.5191005468,
0.0631150976,
-0.511172533,
-0.5251974463,
-0.268643409,
-0.2288980633,
-0.5541750193,
-0.1836859733,
-0.532464087,
0.0161685348,
0.0829424039,
0.5044649243,
0.3495429158,
0.7750973105,
-0.9827620983,
0.20897457,
0.0644649863,
0.2296617925,
0.3003806472,
-0.8246532083,
-0.7439209819,
0.3372852504,
-0.3953523934,
-0.6798543334,
0.4572500885,
0.0745340437,
0.5981907845,
0.560634017,
0.1707874984,
0.9397454262,
-0.4228089452,
0.8629969954,
-0.094475247,
-0.8975955248,
0.3425322771,
-0.3632511497,
-0.002402961,
0.1703037024,
0.0568796843,
-0.3710438907,
-0.8266007304,
-0.5625437498,
-0.7952930331,
1.012922883,
0.3338957727,
0.2573524415,
0.150746882,
0.3980084658,
0.0410407744,
0.0298168883,
-0.3740662336,
-0.4482315481,
-0.1007796377,
-0.3073029518,
0.0846390501,
-0.1155324653,
-0.0389129557,
-0.2081879973,
0.6141157746,
-0.0965040326,
-0.0840504318,
-0.2516304255,
-0.029366212,
-0.2635559142,
0.2057415396,
0.4703420103,
0.4364821613,
-0.1347651035,
-0.2106402814,
0.492651701,
-0.2502471805,
-0.402615577,
0.1319420934,
-0.4231864214,
-0.2816304564,
0.3483711481,
0.9919437766,
0.5037388802,
-0.78422153,
0.1112358421,
-0.2294342071,
-0.1356454194,
-0.3413760662,
0.7455891371,
0.0276839454,
0.1447483301,
0.5458326936,
0.0557655282,
0.2327672839,
-0.3354677856,
-0.0188491121,
0.2824577093,
-0.2711621821,
-0.3632186055,
0.7513375282,
0.3987010121,
-0.22408849,
0.7104721665,
-0.1264551133,
-0.1992466599,
0.6161942482,
0.347620368,
0.736587882,
-0.1961433887,
-0.0363890864,
0.3147649765,
0.4360632896,
-0.1688076854,
0.1183763295,
-0.0034169855,
-0.8869986534,
-0.67783916,
-0.051259052,
-0.8455221057,
0.1410485357,
-0.67111516,
0.5598646402,
-0.523812592,
0.3668250442,
-0.1566583663,
-0.1412545443,
-0.2921281755,
-0.1066481471,
0.3973197341,
0.8066881299,
-0.7223505378,
0.6420941949,
0.3845271468,
-0.2226669937,
-1.0970021486,
-0.1212802529,
-0.1158275381,
-0.9831221104,
0.2131036371,
0.3031740487,
0.0533990599,
0.0902812779,
-0.9420547485,
-0.4853130579,
1.1497129202,
0.1734722406,
-0.7656829357,
0.0857314318,
0.1213017106,
0.5308155417,
-0.6054257751,
0.7257497311,
0.4453524053,
0.0120800789,
0.3121654689,
-0.9399216771,
-0.1520132869,
-0.2313204557,
-0.2564889789,
-0.1934399754,
-0.8645955324,
0.7391343117,
-0.077692382,
-0.0643963888,
0.1007569432,
1.0852431059,
0.2725807428,
0.1319127381,
0.5532759428,
0.2143290043,
0.6056296825,
0.1324979812,
0.6667870283,
-0.8711928725,
-0.0396885127,
0.9101614952,
-0.4920261502,
0.9453118443,
-0.1054031253,
0.1168324575,
0.5003407001,
0.4991427362,
-0.0155004226,
0.4071940184,
-0.5184906721,
-0.2619077861,
-0.4316284657,
0.0444924347,
-0.2026599199,
0.100998193,
0.8195089102,
-0.1981662959,
0.1247459427,
-0.2554778457,
-0.0239573326,
-0.1761899292,
-0.391001761,
0.9787141681,
0.0045905821,
-0.7548230886,
0.9109354615,
-0.031377729,
0.6347417831,
-0.5478658676,
-0.2920749187,
-0.1688585877,
0.1437021047,
-0.4093377888,
-0.9019412398,
0.0612815656,
-0.099622108,
0.2105112225,
0.0633666962,
0.5252601504,
-0.8095763922,
-0.3330396712,
0.1368320882,
0.2548420429,
0.1426701844,
0.1064426675,
-0.8049445152,
0.2415783405,
0.3329876661,
0.0899579152,
0.4886244833,
0.5535571575,
0.3220956326,
0.7538189292,
0.4916158915,
0.0623785555,
0.2214482874,
0.1518854499,
0.8979431391,
-0.4828222096,
-0.4604747593,
-0.6821218729,
0.6908252239,
-0.0298967678,
-0.0785862878,
0.9564836025,
0.5912054181,
0.5718049407,
0.0850121528,
0.8380295634,
0.1349147409,
0.6196872592,
-0.535169661,
0.5099368095,
-0.5016836524,
0.5880840421,
-0.1760787368,
-0.581618309,
-0.1929844469,
0.4057529867,
-0.1977774501,
-0.0773324966,
0.3138066232,
1.1628026962,
-0.1586932391,
0.1511019915,
0.5411771536,
0.372520566,
0.3669450283,
0.3223556876,
0.9891742468,
-0.3196357787,
0.4803277552,
-0.3662966192,
-0.4746035039,
-0.3933433592,
-0.5743516684,
-1.2392582893,
-0.195620358,
-0.3895011246,
-0.1133299395,
0.0670427009,
1.1349407434,
0.647990942,
-0.7476177216,
-0.3643915951,
0.0111659514,
0.1279470772,
-0.5126660466,
-0.241150409,
0.2632838786,
-0.6733395457,
-0.8191354275,
0.5432430506,
0.4069657326,
-0.0554427691,
-0.3315719664,
-0.2260527164,
0.450958848,
0.1749290228,
0.4451690018,
0.1502982974,
-0.6418237686,
-0.118891187,
0.4392516017,
0.0960826948,
0.1108453125,
0.3300618529,
-0.3627545238,
0.5138266683,
0.3528516591,
0.6211511493,
0.0241086222,
0.1090305969,
0.6657819748,
-0.5989130139,
0.1880794019,
-0.000922451,
0.4491479397,
0.3447699547,
-0.3438589871,
0.0588114113,
-0.0384814739,
-0.7808092237,
-0.8567174673,
-0.2335834503,
-0.9965552688,
0.0578549914,
1.0751622915,
-0.0003706741,
-0.126588881,
-0.2375989854,
-0.6015048027,
-0.0000157426,
-0.6905289888,
1.008636117,
0.5053321719,
-0.0863092318,
-0.7977163792,
-0.6640287638,
0.0910807103,
0.4616360962,
-0.6461785436,
0.2059036046,
0.3122074306,
0.0429293625,
-0.0559449568,
0.5820791721,
0.2901765108,
0.326081872,
0.2105599791,
0.0224863105,
-0.0392374173,
-0.2870710194,
0.050290484,
-0.0484512858,
0.2086873502,
-0.2039706707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14542v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14542v1
|
Automatic Data Retrieval for Cross Lingual Summarization
| 2023-12-22T09:13:24 | 2023-12-22T09:13:24 |
Nikhilesh Bhatnagar, Ashok Urlana, Vandan Mujadia, Pruthwik Mishra, Dipti Misra Sharma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Cross-lingual summarization involves the summarization of text written in one
language to a different one. There is a body of research addressing
cross-lingual summarization from English to other European languages. In this
work, we aim to perform cross-lingual summarization from English to Hindi. We
propose pairing up the coverage of newsworthy events in textual and video
format can prove to be helpful for data acquisition for cross lingual
summarization. We analyze the data and propose methods to match articles to
video descriptions that serve as document and summary pairs. We also outline
filtering methods over reasonable thresholds to ensure the correctness of the
summaries. Further, we make available 28,583 mono and cross-lingual
article-summary pairs https://github.com/tingc9/Cross-Sum-News-Aligned. We also
build and analyze multiple baselines on the collected data and report error
analysis.
|
[
-0.3712451458,
-0.794234097,
0.1433035731,
0.5118365288,
-0.4797903597,
0.3980521858,
-0.0846994892,
-0.6003114581,
0.8262400031,
0.2655880749,
-0.1714917868,
-0.3425572217,
-0.6527734399,
0.2471608371,
-0.8244041204,
1.0457652807,
-0.3632820249,
0.3438355923,
0.045044627,
-0.316170305,
-0.3852401674,
-0.2549984455,
-0.3868794739,
-0.2316154093,
0.2160277814,
0.5835635662,
0.7468512058,
0.4409858882,
0.6083573699,
0.2497468144,
0.1258117557,
0.1124375761,
-0.3364955187,
-0.2589053512,
-0.1491903812,
-0.0898309499,
-0.5007368922,
-0.2021990269,
1.0333126783,
0.8895048499,
-0.0649622604,
0.0596254915,
-0.067217052,
0.8981603384,
-0.4194068313,
-0.0476949774,
-0.3528624177,
0.316359818,
-0.2248316705,
-0.3914999068,
-0.0577997752,
-0.4693356454,
0.0218364466,
-0.7201434374,
0.1854985207,
0.152509138,
0.8689603209,
0.0359730944,
-0.6033971906,
-0.3090697527,
-0.5565428734,
0.7340303659,
-0.4915384054,
0.6050735712,
0.4449252486,
0.387722522,
0.4565654397,
-0.550489068,
-0.371640563,
0.2434832603,
-0.5054165721,
0.320240885,
-0.2002786249,
-0.3782937229,
-0.1344345361,
0.6542502642,
-1.012137413,
-0.2273188829,
-0.7537512779,
-0.2216098458,
0.903681457,
0.1167090237,
0.8608010411,
-0.4469619989,
-0.2921195328,
0.0276704337,
-0.5809668303,
-0.2759371698,
0.4935533404,
0.2393070161,
-0.5034062266,
0.8971022367,
-0.4869503677,
0.6310768127,
0.0990059078,
-0.1276826262,
0.2341101468,
-1.1058850288,
-0.2318066955,
0.6729184985,
0.5757030249,
0.7819117904,
0.3086995184,
-0.2101566046,
0.0907829553,
-0.3853877783,
-0.0950731486,
-0.400173068,
-0.0625329018,
-0.0533288792,
-0.7053871155,
0.0350133739,
0.1315840632,
-1.0979795456,
-0.1185568869,
-0.4217021465,
0.3938986063,
-0.2117222399,
-0.5130439997,
0.1232911646,
-0.2923887372,
0.5053188205,
0.1638540775,
-0.8930545449,
0.2494861335,
0.534497261,
0.8850034475,
-0.3193214834,
-0.5060146451,
-0.573577702,
0.4779193103,
-0.2811717093,
0.6631984711,
-0.2289108038,
-0.392292887,
0.0755781904,
0.0442921072,
-0.1612098813,
-0.3034807146,
0.2970663011,
-0.6332394481,
0.5258673429,
-0.3947995305,
-0.2939413786,
-0.2601620853,
0.2422456443,
-0.8400218487,
0.8575841784,
-0.1139760762,
-1.1238377094,
0.4810173213,
-0.2559516728,
-0.9951614141,
-0.2218171507,
-0.0481067896,
-0.2662274539,
-0.2600210905,
0.5558620095,
0.3070878983,
-0.1650966704,
0.438370049,
0.156273514,
-0.0980502293,
-0.5023750663,
-0.0224906262,
0.9544322491,
0.0591290705,
-0.1354432106,
-0.019396551,
-0.548972249,
-0.2822625339,
-0.1410729587,
-0.1298365891,
-0.6731468439,
-0.1269107312,
0.3314291835,
0.0644861609,
0.2592808008,
-0.4032824934,
-0.0346424282,
-0.3586952984,
-0.2717241347,
0.1089065224,
0.0927743986,
0.6574106216,
-0.361718297,
0.5280528665,
-0.0346063301,
-0.1588650942,
-0.3028270304,
-0.3846120536,
-0.2612500489,
0.0455545634,
0.3453926742,
0.8947262764,
-1.0991805792,
0.1332629174,
-0.3304429352,
-0.5148770213,
-0.4577927887,
0.5685082674,
0.55648458,
0.5746586919,
0.3269177079,
-0.3140421808,
-1.0011628866,
-0.8224253058,
-0.4308170676,
-0.1001815796,
0.0890565589,
-0.1005548611,
0.2805963457,
0.2227235436,
0.9888523221,
-0.3701765239,
-0.449801743,
-0.5634850264,
0.445592612,
-0.1159743518,
0.3873046339,
0.8080114722,
-1.3436449766,
-0.904951334,
0.3173719049,
-0.9113255143,
-0.2623258531,
-0.086472325,
-0.1463964731,
0.4605788887,
0.6904634237,
-0.1793885678,
0.5219489336,
0.594386518,
-0.3669743836,
0.1873532981,
-0.1471476406,
0.5374428034,
-1.3309547901,
0.1781718433,
-0.0164776538,
-0.4782012999,
-0.3308802545,
-0.3309453726,
-0.0389934443,
0.0396059044,
-0.3580493331,
0.6773390174,
-0.6704058051,
-0.3722084165,
-0.1685641855,
0.4338682592,
-0.1357865632,
0.2411428243,
0.4624235332,
0.6557468772,
0.5903559923,
-0.4193126559,
0.6184923649,
0.2629449368,
-0.191321373,
0.6534084082,
-0.6967309713,
-0.6127689481,
-0.257607311,
0.1763148159,
-0.9228870869,
-0.3969899416,
0.1124345735,
-0.6968981624,
0.1987724006,
-0.0386365764,
-0.441272825,
0.3914197981,
-0.5975674391,
0.6716749668,
0.1069127619,
-0.4814881682,
0.6917974949,
0.8453397155,
-0.6526794434,
-0.5624986291,
-0.7986958027,
0.3344365954,
-0.1836304665,
-0.5476218462,
0.2977901995,
0.1511107683,
-0.3976944685,
0.3895606399,
-0.0259712823,
-0.1808500737,
-0.5259278417,
-0.3145692945,
0.2749119401,
-0.2278636545,
-0.2099935561,
0.0992409363,
-0.0472261272,
-0.0340386629,
0.0883909464,
0.2604639828,
0.1314511001,
-0.1986237317,
-0.0355933011,
1.0206075907,
0.2835739553,
-0.3056998253,
0.3668597341,
1.0462852716,
-0.6028572917,
0.3427955508,
-0.4729344547,
0.235764727,
-0.3210483789,
0.2856505811,
-0.155851081,
-0.3414322138,
0.6327978969,
0.6053895354,
-0.0282144137,
0.6297914982,
0.5870005488,
0.0921321511,
1.0193775892,
0.7119945288,
-0.5025368929,
0.4109746814,
-0.0476204269,
0.2144297361,
-0.2773014605,
-0.2905605137,
-0.3507095873,
-0.1222216263,
-0.4522684515,
-0.0481954329,
0.4706291854,
-0.1924568564,
0.4430384934,
0.4154120088,
-0.1807273775,
0.619271636,
0.3917503059,
-0.1430179626,
0.831058681,
-0.0201117471,
0.0171320885,
-0.1419660747,
-0.6241412163,
-0.0448448583,
0.593763113,
-0.1006619334,
0.8933628798,
0.387385726,
0.5720973611,
0.3654836714,
-0.0339162238,
-0.4182395339,
0.4560396969,
-0.2073390782,
-0.5508939624,
-0.3627657294,
-0.4578831494,
-0.8607934117,
-0.0135249505,
0.0735592693,
-0.4424677193,
0.2615449429,
-0.1746751666,
-0.0194591042,
0.3427641988,
-0.7863125205,
0.7575924397,
-0.4108147323,
-0.085027799,
-0.4656829834,
-0.9890604019,
0.741396904,
-0.1787801534,
0.3039893508,
0.193577677,
-0.1289575398,
0.9895054698,
-0.1217004731,
0.7261919975,
0.1575327665,
-0.1477331817,
0.1296852976,
-0.1572291255,
-0.0548883714,
0.3174776137,
0.2651323378,
0.0186393596,
0.1199495643,
-0.6958966255,
-0.5373920202,
0.6233031154,
-0.5198515654,
-0.3423894346,
-0.4470819235,
-0.6478580832,
-0.1085296571,
0.2951463461,
0.2718316317,
0.421130091,
-0.1678304225,
0.187405169,
0.5538012385,
0.0237281546,
0.7161544561,
0.5680578947,
-0.4846451879,
-0.5970425606,
0.8013499975,
0.2196707577,
0.0818920508,
0.7961274385,
-0.1809184998,
-0.2447265834,
-0.2337705046,
-0.8025547862,
0.2671415806,
-0.5828180909,
-0.1961868554,
-0.5184535384,
-0.216876775,
-0.6664036512,
-0.3349541128,
-0.1862151772,
-0.6326935291,
0.1203438044,
-0.2316265404,
0.3474315107,
0.7065700293,
-0.4026112258,
0.0375835896,
-1.0631061792,
0.7528528571,
0.0985243693,
0.3374802172,
-0.1570273936,
-0.3096558452,
-0.6970441937,
-0.124174282,
-0.0094260154,
-1.0470765829,
0.5270282626,
0.2146459073,
0.6757542491,
0.1593797058,
0.0685612857,
0.7625392079,
-0.2537647784,
0.5730360746,
0.1137799099,
-0.9274563193,
0.7790873647,
-0.4183509946,
0.3636262417,
0.5021881461,
0.8047401309,
-0.6331375241,
-0.3627023101,
-0.3979597092,
-0.9824537635,
0.5994742513,
0.1434579045,
-0.1811133474,
0.3588281572,
-0.1068473458,
0.2172178775,
-0.0800971538,
-0.4698071778,
-0.1402442902,
-0.2427538037,
-0.2027650177,
-0.2731300294,
-0.0252186451,
-0.1304898709,
-0.4333635867,
0.7878068686,
0.0075692469,
-0.2695513666,
0.4990382195,
-0.4842013419,
-0.3079788685,
0.066736415,
0.4749358594,
0.72821033,
-0.1553996503,
-0.0156692378,
0.3173287511,
-0.6635681987,
-0.1211854666,
0.4495307803,
-0.2106904089,
0.6203811765,
0.5158062577,
0.3467888534,
0.4852899313,
-0.8332160711,
0.4037317038,
-0.1071761772,
-0.020843951,
-0.2901416123,
-0.429061383,
-0.1525115669,
0.1560779959,
0.6805766225,
-0.4476601481,
0.4155341983,
-0.8042702079,
0.4849230647,
0.2911817431,
-0.0105057219,
-0.3605445921,
0.6487037539,
0.2578310072,
0.0360260457,
0.2429030836,
-0.1518930197,
-0.5392525792,
0.5204663277,
0.3235311508,
0.7498261929,
-0.1853519231,
0.2507818043,
0.4256607592,
0.3136728704,
-0.0642483234,
0.3650402129,
-0.1944643855,
-0.3967489004,
-0.7473725677,
-0.3021076918,
-0.6659001708,
-0.5356316566,
-0.7329636812,
0.4917950034,
0.2724254727,
0.3921483755,
0.0881312266,
0.3784537911,
-0.0826225653,
0.2172291279,
0.1386487335,
0.9646274447,
-1.2030715942,
0.7418397069,
0.9515734911,
-0.5974782705,
-0.6328073144,
-0.192616418,
0.0501917601,
-0.6585248113,
0.4954364002,
-0.4517691731,
-0.0190200526,
-0.2022686303,
0.1303248554,
-0.8300002217,
1.0847229958,
0.1371900141,
-0.1714173406,
-0.3845411241,
0.3351429999,
0.4890554547,
-0.1935019344,
0.1110616177,
0.554661274,
0.6107123494,
0.0172105879,
-1.418397069,
-0.1440565288,
-0.4929160774,
-0.4931387007,
0.4195561707,
-0.70405972,
0.6677260995,
-0.0553744584,
-0.1008364558,
-0.3426915407,
0.6159905195,
-0.0257200915,
0.7932897806,
0.3226742148,
0.543545723,
0.1415588707,
0.0541252419,
0.9396592379,
-0.3087457716,
0.2401071787,
1.0319516659,
-0.1796045303,
0.5653349161,
0.5943593383,
0.0368035957,
0.1254287213,
0.6417351365,
0.1649169624,
0.5565423369,
-0.4181628525,
-0.0056894077,
0.1190484092,
-0.2776200175,
-0.4881439209,
0.5384965539,
0.1286983043,
-0.1904087216,
-0.7878797054,
0.2567329705,
0.0402201228,
0.2868531942,
-0.481416136,
0.88411659,
-0.0643180832,
-0.8513575196,
0.2801478803,
-0.0502545759,
0.6146293283,
-0.611776948,
-0.0565580279,
-0.4357925355,
-0.0926309302,
-0.5553506017,
-0.8971915841,
1.0061445236,
0.1987608075,
-0.1844195873,
-0.3863922656,
0.8213300705,
-0.9168333411,
-0.6436234713,
0.4250772893,
0.8113135099,
0.1677099466,
0.3416953385,
-0.2285929173,
-0.0292314682,
-0.0476788133,
-0.1611750871,
0.3842590749,
0.3409383297,
-0.2854693234,
0.2284860611,
0.3035931885,
0.2615100145,
0.3173161745,
0.0975654125,
0.5750683546,
-0.7298854589,
-0.6847595572,
-0.7685849071,
0.1900396347,
-0.2022862881,
-0.1794247031,
1.1228750944,
1.2408251762,
1.195227623,
0.0983962715,
0.7251816988,
-0.3481328189,
0.6182667017,
-0.7069749832,
0.7985291481,
-0.8302167654,
0.103161782,
-0.3134461045,
-0.6649421453,
-0.4516554475,
0.097084716,
-0.199827686,
-0.2239087075,
0.4626017511,
0.6992996931,
-0.3940746188,
0.1438415647,
0.0691644847,
-0.1986334175,
-0.1691904366,
0.4887948036,
0.3885114789,
-0.6019250154,
0.9007062912,
-0.4062524438,
0.0181097463,
-0.3158191144,
-0.897317946,
-0.6555660367,
-0.8809214234,
-0.3561687768,
-0.0062594404,
0.2341780066,
0.5185188651,
0.699719131,
-0.8113204837,
-0.4523361921,
0.2976908982,
0.5347113013,
-0.0881881192,
-0.2619152665,
0.5601124167,
-0.2356164604,
-1.0844179392,
0.2080861032,
0.1988886744,
0.0286848582,
-0.2609862685,
-0.0626145974,
-0.6042013764,
-0.1321571171,
0.4875450432,
0.5818433762,
-0.2060458064,
-0.0597762987,
-0.0702164248,
-0.1986009926,
0.0533830822,
1.0494558811,
-0.656827271,
0.3213993609,
0.9623739719,
0.8196794987,
0.6190416813,
0.1378418356,
0.7703078985,
-1.0210846663,
0.0844584331,
-0.0329166725,
0.5325828791,
0.5412142277,
-0.4362711906,
0.716910243,
0.2320866287,
-0.3460869193,
-0.8290922642,
-0.1127065197,
-1.1743564606,
0.0255086962,
0.9536709189,
0.138261959,
-0.0473576449,
-0.2218526602,
-0.314691633,
0.5156803131,
-0.1086471081,
0.7363659143,
0.800308764,
-0.0679016411,
-0.3396465182,
-0.4329823554,
0.3091990054,
0.4760793149,
-0.8124150634,
-0.1180346832,
0.1707982421,
0.0594313331,
0.2048289329,
0.6414880157,
-0.2446990311,
0.612308383,
-0.0760521889,
-0.1970681399,
0.1266088486,
-0.2120345533,
-0.3427214324,
-0.0133554563,
-0.669324398,
-0.2084382325
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14504v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14504v2
|
Theory of Hallucinations based on Equivariance
| 2023-12-22T08:08:45 | 2024-01-04T02:49:21 |
Hisaichi Shibata
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This study aims to acquire knowledge for creating very large language models
that are immune to hallucinations. Hallucinations in contemporary large
language models are often attributed to a misunderstanding of real-world social
relationships. Therefore, I hypothesize that very large language models capable
of thoroughly grasping all these relationships will be free from
hallucinations. Additionally, I propose that certain types of equivariant
language models are adept at learning and understanding these relationships.
Building on this, I have developed a specialized cross-entropy error function
to create a hallucination scale for language models, which measures their
extent of equivariance acquisition. Utilizing this scale, I tested language
models for their ability to acquire character-level equivariance. In
particular, I introduce and employ a novel technique based on T5 (Text To Text
Transfer Transformer) that efficiently understands permuted input texts without
the need for explicit dictionaries to convert token IDs (integers) to texts
(strings). This T5 model demonstrated a moderate ability to acquire
character-level equivariance. Additionally, I discovered scale laws that can
aid in developing hallucination-free language models at the character level.
This methodology can be extended to assess equivariance acquisition at the word
level, paving the way for very large language models that can comprehensively
understand relationships and, consequently, avoid hallucinations.
|
[
0.0056054303,
-0.7857062817,
0.8119205236,
0.2482182682,
-0.2467656434,
-0.1591723263,
-0.0553429089,
-0.6072102785,
0.3725935519,
0.4394124448,
-0.2588647008,
-0.4396071434,
-0.8922464252,
0.2302170098,
-0.6461178064,
0.7160832286,
-0.0532465428,
0.1401450634,
0.0203219689,
0.1637680829,
-0.1439270228,
-0.6882574558,
-0.3725333214,
-0.1522400975,
0.7176831961,
0.096871689,
0.6145988703,
0.3034633696,
0.6753805876,
0.2240282297,
0.2253791541,
-0.0933561921,
-0.8384104371,
0.310318917,
-0.1952420175,
-0.5069015026,
-0.2702085972,
-0.327000767,
0.3141341209,
0.8187003136,
-0.4692269862,
-0.1682796478,
-0.2220329493,
0.2131296247,
-0.6476873159,
0.2263623178,
-0.6637409329,
0.4238657653,
0.1710610986,
-0.1633398086,
-0.5808660984,
-0.3527161479,
0.1430761665,
-0.6626228094,
0.090977475,
0.4272501171,
0.828714788,
0.1353314966,
-0.20465599,
-0.4804127514,
-0.9092357755,
0.6845482588,
-0.328708142,
0.6731103659,
0.7318631411,
0.2556111217,
-0.0158578977,
-0.7988324165,
-0.6545739174,
-0.3119981587,
0.0626267195,
-0.1262223125,
-0.1020004973,
0.0646151826,
0.3110174835,
0.3661494255,
-0.5268040299,
-0.2643639743,
-0.4802617133,
-0.2554582655,
0.3865371943,
0.2032768428,
0.6137220263,
-0.1992003769,
-0.0958664492,
-0.0478748828,
-0.3300223351,
-0.2433461398,
0.181586802,
0.1513567865,
-0.1908812076,
0.486342907,
0.2907215059,
0.2432034612,
0.1884107739,
-0.1616712511,
0.0904032141,
-0.1476998627,
-0.350399971,
0.1440395713,
0.5707637072,
0.1426874697,
0.537941277,
-0.8444342017,
-0.0245234855,
0.0606182441,
0.5543490052,
-0.8401300907,
-0.3889660537,
0.2122365087,
-0.5709260106,
-0.4360309541,
0.0822534785,
-0.8739182949,
-0.6349332333,
-0.0507944077,
0.7232191563,
-0.5100351572,
-0.6261208057,
0.2341138721,
-0.1882521957,
0.4143099487,
0.1620133072,
-1.1027592421,
0.3868623078,
0.4404803813,
0.8711495399,
-0.259526968,
-0.6227580309,
-0.2781119049,
0.2937968373,
-0.4296738207,
0.6814611554,
-0.7847746015,
-0.2377275378,
-0.0361118652,
0.2682666481,
-0.0640088618,
-0.4284263551,
0.2467441559,
-0.3265848756,
0.0609771647,
-0.1473460495,
-0.5075780749,
-0.2478048354,
0.0362521745,
-0.6670824885,
0.3540527225,
0.1111272722,
-0.4968383014,
0.3168410063,
-0.2643546164,
-0.3022685051,
-0.1663378924,
-0.1261046678,
-0.3426395357,
0.5174099803,
-0.0206444934,
0.3764717281,
-0.3609972596,
0.3499082327,
-0.5704342127,
-0.3701058924,
0.2786648273,
-0.1012132317,
0.7624596357,
0.0897339806,
-0.3664641678,
-0.0753424093,
-0.8281527162,
-0.2738198936,
0.1332477927,
0.2444430292,
-0.4563524723,
0.0204858724,
-0.0943215638,
-0.0479518548,
0.0054211528,
-0.2795032263,
-0.1297806799,
-0.2135386169,
0.2360378206,
0.5367752314,
0.1268134266,
0.478803277,
-0.1838182509,
0.3904451728,
0.3610268533,
0.0674381703,
0.1102459207,
-0.1519073248,
-0.8030419946,
-0.1206704751,
-0.1029824466,
0.4098644555,
-0.7075163722,
0.7392982841,
-0.0926896855,
-0.2666859627,
-0.3422801495,
-0.1609565914,
0.0311776903,
0.0923390612,
0.3180842698,
-0.2621634603,
-0.5272563696,
-0.5819051862,
-0.3296324313,
-0.3735988438,
-0.1709318608,
-0.0033834598,
0.4497472048,
-0.2722136676,
0.3696554601,
-0.4474483132,
-0.1300166547,
-0.192049399,
0.1870305389,
-0.2640951574,
0.3466489613,
0.3434654772,
-0.5252463818,
-0.079334788,
-0.0797624141,
-1.0452370644,
-0.0113302991,
-0.1684323698,
-0.1736097038,
0.014028986,
0.5731683373,
-0.2818045616,
0.3765354753,
0.5437754393,
-0.6681107283,
0.267077744,
-0.2332415879,
0.0986602455,
-1.3043681383,
-0.1022506878,
-0.0997999012,
-0.0988616049,
-0.9713653922,
0.0812538341,
-0.0624210462,
0.140555799,
-0.1695040017,
0.1960567832,
-0.4011086226,
-0.1249184683,
-0.0881478786,
0.0857520849,
-0.1168614924,
0.4176865816,
0.116930142,
0.1856269985,
0.5348405838,
-0.6120077372,
0.2384816706,
-0.01790094,
-0.1721084267,
0.5390694737,
-0.5521313548,
0.2714653909,
-0.3268350661,
-0.280082792,
-0.9804064631,
-0.2987143695,
0.3681450784,
-0.3910740912,
0.1573304385,
0.4649346769,
-0.2644814551,
0.1342352629,
0.0370204039,
0.3617109656,
0.4464251101,
-0.4633276463,
0.7872931361,
0.451340735,
0.2667838037,
-0.329572171,
-0.7249650955,
0.1341060251,
-0.3206394017,
-0.3915581703,
0.1477571279,
-0.0404258817,
-0.5706369877,
-0.2581047416,
0.0583114251,
-0.4107740819,
0.0982160121,
0.1461135596,
0.0387508236,
0.0748264566,
0.2738733888,
0.1091385037,
0.1989100128,
0.2922782898,
-0.0412109867,
0.6022588611,
0.1115179062,
-0.2540028989,
-0.4015859962,
0.2254533321,
0.9216386676,
0.3065588772,
1.0054210424,
0.4631338418,
-0.8165414929,
-0.2279725522,
-0.4225441515,
-0.4459895492,
-0.3907166123,
0.6809693575,
-0.8614845276,
-0.6171398759,
0.8514703512,
0.1751092523,
-0.2304959297,
0.4150566459,
0.4652445316,
0.1630433947,
0.9679639339,
0.8358208537,
0.2001648247,
0.3108717799,
0.026591016,
0.5847887993,
-0.5488129258,
-0.4086256325,
-0.4970836639,
-0.0559093468,
-0.5799108148,
-0.3079734743,
0.0115697645,
0.1038306132,
-0.4009085894,
0.156888932,
-0.3588644266,
0.4245449305,
-0.04750387,
0.0805305839,
0.4219615161,
0.4051264524,
-0.0120316455,
-0.3070801497,
-0.2892115116,
-0.2841116488,
0.9615959525,
0.4512265325,
0.946111083,
0.2399047762,
0.7292361856,
0.2387536615,
-0.1145100817,
-0.847420156,
0.3057019413,
-0.0606891252,
-0.3225022256,
-0.6196140051,
-0.4739588499,
-0.7703695893,
0.4491205812,
-0.142374754,
-1.0196722746,
0.6506099105,
-0.3475337327,
-0.2673832178,
0.4117709398,
-0.7152552605,
0.4898311794,
-0.0187231507,
-0.3580427766,
-0.2216865271,
-0.4415023327,
0.5713510513,
-0.3026031554,
0.0461808331,
0.2103989422,
0.0311544053,
0.5895888209,
-0.1851652712,
0.8939870596,
0.0042988355,
-0.4875619709,
0.0412288345,
0.4347983301,
0.5373840332,
-0.11812599,
-0.0713279992,
0.3987123072,
0.2063837051,
-0.370534718,
-0.6725478768,
0.4401497841,
-1.2180557251,
-0.3693898022,
-0.3911293149,
-0.6960443258,
0.0353232697,
0.0082198726,
0.2572575212,
-0.0767594725,
-0.4795291722,
0.1918382794,
0.60214746,
-0.3150968254,
0.2528568506,
0.2992134094,
-0.6426123977,
-0.4751464725,
0.9983155727,
0.3183979094,
0.3687090874,
0.2870204449,
0.1086971909,
-0.0914139003,
-0.354734838,
0.059148524,
0.3003227711,
-0.6283663511,
0.2665361464,
-0.9473496675,
-0.4217415154,
-0.5619668365,
-0.1001782268,
-0.1844954342,
-0.3929538131,
-0.322466135,
-0.1707745194,
0.202366814,
0.9156594872,
-0.0896440893,
0.1055794284,
-0.536041379,
0.4617330134,
0.312836051,
0.1747065037,
0.2811788917,
-0.7497054935,
-0.1466761678,
-0.1194000244,
-0.1403173804,
-1.0800945759,
0.6578540802,
0.0081042852,
0.4329613149,
0.6775416732,
0.0222880542,
0.6852615476,
-0.2098638862,
0.77668643,
0.3610500097,
-1.3638569117,
-0.0653586835,
-0.0713454485,
-0.0009030469,
0.2668353319,
0.3294689357,
-0.6776154637,
-0.6992379427,
-0.5802502036,
-0.5488525033,
0.4839211404,
0.1565944999,
0.0704653934,
0.0434341542,
0.5462670922,
0.4948432446,
0.206658572,
-1.0285974741,
0.0860214159,
-0.4665354192,
-0.2295273244,
-0.1022269875,
-0.2045439333,
0.0434428193,
-0.4745083749,
0.2083986849,
-0.0076242411,
0.5131323934,
0.1946919709,
-0.4840438366,
-0.3615082204,
0.0103090871,
0.7779243588,
0.8590139747,
-0.2327800691,
0.6379284859,
0.3216107488,
-0.7512075305,
0.37395522,
-0.3927307129,
0.0758497939,
-0.1373554617,
0.3464530706,
0.9444127083,
0.0915527567,
-0.1790851951,
0.2656575739,
-0.2746536434,
-0.3739929199,
-0.3877503276,
-0.1033252105,
0.1519674957,
0.3441545367,
0.3004575372,
-0.2663503885,
0.0882661119,
-0.7632248998,
0.2784616947,
0.1001133174,
-0.5631302595,
-0.6864205003,
0.4895940721,
-0.141273886,
-0.5125901103,
0.5885475278,
-0.1816861928,
-0.2890086174,
0.7683544755,
0.8831199408,
1.2426419258,
-0.4374957979,
0.4020549655,
0.5060863495,
0.537466526,
-0.2150948197,
0.1595945507,
0.1534527987,
-0.9937684536,
-0.0545530356,
-0.710498035,
-0.3732990623,
0.2228151113,
-0.5025017262,
0.2853807509,
-0.3775481284,
0.0893449113,
-0.3282410204,
-0.3196160495,
-0.3470486999,
0.0342598744,
0.1605105996,
0.2823276222,
-0.9784499407,
0.7688348293,
0.251716584,
-0.5703165531,
-0.6739664078,
0.5776936412,
-0.4092260599,
-0.7107387185,
0.6376926899,
0.0286141913,
-0.1659735292,
0.0516805276,
-0.4962481856,
-0.9932047725,
0.8631742597,
0.4708708823,
-0.6034983397,
-0.455750525,
0.2562292814,
0.6703112125,
-0.5813610554,
0.2870173156,
0.6357516646,
0.4867820442,
0.2077713907,
-0.6171224713,
0.407589376,
0.1171404272,
0.0858309418,
0.1156269163,
-0.5924044251,
0.9939413667,
-0.3278391361,
-0.2580012679,
-0.1198308542,
0.762735188,
0.0937826633,
0.173972398,
0.4533078372,
0.3992576599,
0.9092661142,
0.0851326659,
0.7065557837,
-0.5280435681,
0.465747267,
0.8161693811,
-0.3593559861,
0.7534688115,
0.8728286028,
-0.0760015398,
0.5253846645,
0.3875969052,
-0.0401932895,
0.7072384953,
0.4080786109,
-0.0582212582,
-0.3300686777,
0.1196264178,
-0.3740638196,
0.4099784791,
0.4374826849,
-0.6983524561,
-0.0614462458,
0.2933925688,
-0.1036744565,
-0.2262251377,
-0.0032289959,
0.8810389042,
0.3559451401,
-0.465165168,
0.7162102461,
-0.2747797966,
0.4629142582,
-0.2713003457,
-0.063071616,
-0.0926076695,
0.3219253719,
-0.1307430863,
-0.1616220176,
0.5108041763,
-0.2273507118,
-0.163233906,
0.0593209378,
0.5766425729,
-0.673242867,
-0.6603310108,
0.6719945073,
0.5904499292,
0.5829205513,
0.0714522302,
-0.1705687791,
0.2009235919,
-0.0205991566,
-0.1015132144,
0.2301672697,
0.6284013987,
0.1293032914,
0.3127930462,
0.1832534075,
0.4174903333,
0.2717111111,
0.069096379,
0.4015949368,
-0.8248639703,
-0.3549750745,
-0.8944710493,
0.1390893906,
-0.0202871505,
-0.1359259039,
0.5228908658,
0.2228668481,
0.6154150963,
-0.1754049957,
0.871851027,
-0.0600591712,
0.1346906424,
-0.2563671172,
1.1204637289,
-0.6626931429,
0.024590252,
-0.3171270192,
-0.9090598822,
-0.4963792861,
1.012247324,
-0.3139647841,
-0.0927911773,
1.2297068834,
0.8848478198,
0.0206532497,
0.1622456312,
1.0203071833,
0.3781878352,
0.3147554696,
0.6510955691,
0.7740588188,
-0.5970609784,
0.503088057,
-0.1137607694,
-0.1661262065,
-0.1497479081,
-0.5015799999,
-1.1038377285,
-0.7244258523,
-0.1693276614,
-0.5963808894,
0.2498457134,
0.8473185897,
0.2651171088,
-0.8051592112,
-0.5285471678,
-0.4133815169,
0.2143525332,
-0.1673847735,
-0.2444844395,
0.1763684452,
-0.5963505507,
-0.8268279433,
-0.1265812665,
0.2747904062,
0.2305906117,
-0.6421451569,
-0.1804549843,
0.09583617,
0.4633347094,
0.6711425781,
-0.0604099296,
-0.8406247497,
-0.4839378893,
0.2071785331,
-0.2549316287,
0.1762631088,
0.807191968,
-0.1622461975,
0.5584144592,
0.7000486851,
0.3944319785,
0.3095228374,
-0.5051820278,
0.8214101195,
-0.1116204038,
0.1604329795,
-0.1126448736,
0.2262096256,
0.1893157512,
-0.5647286177,
0.2351581007,
0.3421005607,
-0.345307827,
-1.0314391851,
0.2531072199,
-0.5743945241,
-0.41379565,
1.0554128885,
0.0157899577,
-0.4438988268,
-0.2747000754,
0.0384608246,
0.6038094759,
-0.1448738724,
1.550141573,
1.107536912,
0.1342716664,
-0.4315192103,
-0.2929773927,
0.5610966086,
0.4119520187,
-0.9803242683,
0.1935981661,
0.2528770864,
0.0709809437,
0.3451964855,
0.2165538073,
-0.2278124839,
0.0928518996,
0.3888239563,
0.3763223886,
0.3653419316,
-0.5479179025,
-0.4059022665,
0.6702449322,
-0.0139010362,
-0.0346373431
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14488v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14488v1
|
Language Model is a Branch Predictor for Simultaneous Machine Translation
| 2023-12-22T07:32:47 | 2023-12-22T07:32:47 |
Aoxiong Yin, Tianyun Zhong, Haoyuan Li, Siliang Tang, Zhou Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The primary objective of simultaneous machine translation (SiMT) is to
minimize latency while preserving the quality of the final translation. Drawing
inspiration from CPU branch prediction techniques, we propose incorporating
branch prediction techniques in SiMT tasks to reduce translation latency.
Specifically, we utilize a language model as a branch predictor to predict
potential branch directions, namely, future source words. Subsequently, we
utilize the predicted source words to decode the output in advance. When the
actual source word deviates from the predicted source word, we use the real
source word to decode the output again, replacing the predicted output. To
further reduce computational costs, we share the parameters of the encoder and
the branch predictor, and utilize a pre-trained language model for
initialization. Our proposed method can be seamlessly integrated with any SiMT
model. Extensive experimental results demonstrate that our approach can improve
translation quality and latency at the same time. Our code is available at
https://github.com/YinAoXiong/simt_branch_predictor .
|
[
-0.3240056038,
-0.7595901489,
0.3789314032,
0.2798490822,
-0.6587097049,
0.2786649168,
-0.056867972,
-0.3176900744,
0.0636591613,
0.7983035445,
-0.780807972,
-0.0194778834,
-0.5623157024,
-0.1503048986,
-0.335690856,
0.8686173558,
-0.2386988103,
0.4013785124,
-0.0402383059,
0.4562507868,
-0.6117122173,
-0.580457747,
-0.8109472394,
-0.4215849638,
0.3274541199,
0.1504482031,
0.9817717075,
0.9903541803,
0.7878997326,
0.2595105171,
-0.0394277498,
-0.1296900511,
-0.3459788859,
0.1752326638,
0.4014535546,
-0.5504935384,
-0.5569277406,
-0.2806414664,
0.755188942,
0.6162348986,
-0.1151759848,
-0.0905611664,
-0.1300361156,
0.5154843926,
0.0654742345,
0.4907806814,
-0.641222477,
-0.0946857408,
-0.3190902472,
-0.2948659658,
-0.3588272929,
-0.246774897,
-0.199070245,
-0.1983993649,
0.0896437094,
0.239192158,
1.0450445414,
0.5274341702,
-0.2658196092,
0.2836948931,
-0.9185497165,
0.6362268329,
-0.8618375063,
0.6358148456,
0.2896799743,
0.626060605,
-0.1892393827,
-0.4521454871,
-0.3513225019,
-0.2994298339,
-0.0107903322,
0.290502429,
0.1077153608,
0.2862223983,
0.2885518372,
0.3155084252,
-0.6406838894,
-0.3845140934,
-0.4783166647,
-0.1527548879,
0.5625068545,
0.1084571332,
0.5524879098,
-0.0589258559,
-0.2093071789,
-0.0217511784,
-0.4077058136,
0.1967365891,
0.237787351,
0.3726373017,
-0.0387542211,
0.3855339289,
-0.0813582391,
0.5561943054,
-0.0997380391,
-0.3128172159,
0.201584354,
-0.4472520351,
-0.1847992539,
0.1137531698,
0.8625779152,
0.0504089817,
0.2079270631,
-0.2698189318,
-0.3702061176,
0.1810097396,
0.2624972761,
-0.9705908298,
-0.0148215126,
0.0904417038,
-0.4620884955,
-0.2550594211,
0.2336410433,
-0.3450941741,
0.1956685781,
-0.4610239267,
0.0300828256,
-0.7016518712,
-0.3462110162,
-0.0174006596,
0.2345222384,
-0.0959591717,
0.2739606798,
-0.5810058117,
0.7556998134,
0.6073031425,
0.9898143411,
-0.2726864517,
-0.2964741886,
-0.5626515746,
-0.0054948363,
-0.3812026381,
0.4632064402,
-0.242505461,
-0.2916815281,
-0.4316988587,
-0.0848012567,
-0.0210676212,
-0.134380579,
0.5567525029,
-0.5493367314,
-0.1877828538,
0.1263822466,
-0.3630433977,
-0.3723282516,
-0.1459681839,
-0.8518171906,
0.7944196463,
0.1121797487,
-0.7788796425,
0.0361192636,
-0.4644432664,
-0.5146336555,
0.1787784696,
-0.0662730113,
-0.4494773448,
0.2490785569,
0.3821715415,
0.3763594627,
-0.4976586103,
0.6947200894,
-0.1465879679,
-0.3810540438,
0.1313643008,
-0.5111042261,
0.6655392647,
0.3882282376,
0.0274254531,
0.0415655635,
-0.272603333,
0.0696379319,
0.0038957978,
-0.2288825661,
-0.1527414173,
0.2182907462,
0.1101556122,
0.4768800437,
0.1830462217,
-0.6407876015,
0.1728769243,
-0.5647748709,
-0.0368464366,
0.5921171904,
-0.1043507084,
0.3636647165,
-0.184168011,
0.8969076872,
0.0693557337,
0.1165691838,
-0.3423340023,
-0.5021936893,
-0.6116968989,
-0.1546859443,
0.4163018167,
0.6555967927,
-0.7766526341,
0.0510519445,
-0.4829956293,
-0.52084589,
-0.6185929179,
0.1586799473,
0.4296938181,
0.0949053168,
0.2546682656,
-0.3714894056,
-0.8283960223,
-0.707234025,
-0.3260751665,
-0.3155212402,
0.3106129169,
-0.0508195721,
0.1420451701,
-0.2729111314,
0.8415755033,
-0.4132042229,
0.0208021384,
-0.4899449944,
0.3371470273,
0.4157695174,
0.4165388942,
0.1716052294,
-1.0339990854,
-0.6362645626,
0.4008644819,
-0.6854808927,
-0.2994523346,
-0.0190829746,
-0.1714627743,
-0.049448356,
0.7856433988,
-0.3321507871,
0.2841691673,
1.0473999977,
-0.0717423707,
0.4115451276,
-0.0983552784,
0.1323216707,
-1.4623110294,
-0.3023202717,
-0.4921716452,
-0.2442106754,
-0.6436665654,
-0.0253644697,
0.2364409864,
-0.2251337618,
-0.3593235612,
0.4136707783,
-0.5462380052,
-0.1585113555,
-0.3514747024,
-0.4532812238,
-0.3455305398,
0.25946787,
0.1564513147,
0.9337685704,
0.456011802,
-0.3802714348,
0.2288866639,
-0.1848569214,
-0.0133076394,
-0.1471157968,
-0.6191496849,
-0.0707206875,
0.0125580486,
0.2242074162,
-0.782763958,
-0.1624514461,
0.0823426917,
-0.5689924955,
0.4663375616,
-0.0644971207,
-0.5327817798,
-0.7108429074,
0.108896181,
0.4321018755,
0.6244796515,
-0.0888404176,
0.6037734151,
0.2754417956,
-0.4010577202,
-0.4212667644,
-0.8312043548,
-0.1616156101,
0.2539764941,
-0.7477818727,
0.4571730494,
-0.23449938,
0.1128550246,
0.1632122099,
-0.1339864135,
-0.3476102352,
0.041479256,
0.640242815,
0.494735539,
-0.4494774938,
0.1474706233,
0.1751558632,
-0.280908525,
-0.0336951427,
-0.4483726919,
0.7092397213,
-0.2856930494,
-0.464814961,
-0.3149856627,
0.3146320581,
0.644567728,
-0.5356116295,
0.7902697921,
0.5342470407,
-0.4269275367,
0.0579600185,
-0.507656157,
-0.2240658104,
-0.3832455575,
0.5753759146,
-0.7510344982,
-0.6883960366,
0.388518244,
-0.2783451676,
-0.1014507711,
0.1770259142,
0.5108982921,
0.1790967733,
1.2329351902,
0.962453723,
-0.0917682648,
0.7464783788,
-0.1797580123,
0.5345638394,
-0.653623879,
0.0068034749,
-0.2076035589,
0.097606957,
-0.5206202269,
-0.8713417649,
0.1356579661,
0.5303865671,
0.025649637,
0.6617027521,
-0.1816166043,
0.3776902854,
0.393165797,
-0.1176500618,
0.3514516652,
0.091829896,
-0.457785219,
-0.1838936061,
-0.7867035866,
-0.4705886841,
0.9560627341,
0.5002846122,
0.7753112912,
-0.2830621004,
1.014308691,
-0.1961223632,
0.3725893795,
-0.699906528,
0.4417052567,
-0.3144544959,
-0.5447396636,
-0.2508845031,
-0.6304298639,
-0.5400693417,
0.2024700046,
0.117573455,
-0.579361856,
-0.3943249285,
0.0479533635,
-0.1619093716,
0.4532227814,
-0.4349721074,
0.7995452881,
-0.6175583005,
-0.1213157699,
-0.0838645026,
-0.5114260912,
0.5440464616,
-0.5323901772,
0.3616707027,
-0.2163275629,
0.00363878,
0.5458334684,
-0.453271687,
0.4520635009,
0.1885571331,
0.3740375042,
0.1062312201,
0.2731584609,
0.3970694244,
-0.0629428327,
-0.2145100981,
0.3046171665,
-0.11992535,
-0.2689053118,
-0.50021106,
0.5254487395,
-0.8579264879,
-0.3427360952,
-0.393132627,
-0.90384835,
0.1123256609,
0.4439264834,
0.196110636,
0.0809469819,
-0.3335666955,
0.0523589924,
0.2885592282,
-0.0620348752,
0.4881027639,
0.3661280274,
-0.7758878469,
-0.3018046319,
0.8572900891,
0.1674582809,
0.5450630784,
0.4922471344,
0.2875078321,
-0.1078064516,
-0.5338968635,
-0.3083713055,
0.3498743176,
-0.2773282528,
-0.3470142782,
-0.8077657223,
-0.6409192085,
-0.4192206264,
-0.1351279318,
-0.7345255613,
-0.2386592776,
0.276080817,
0.2264671326,
0.2014274001,
0.6542370319,
0.1733172834,
1.0020521879,
-0.8013329506,
0.5307512283,
-0.0120648379,
0.3220992982,
-0.4945299625,
-0.5059787631,
-0.4165700972,
0.1655010581,
-0.1322226226,
-0.9548453689,
0.9728366733,
-0.1073394567,
0.4888442159,
0.1538719982,
-0.1360774785,
0.7138319016,
-0.6520500779,
0.4214630127,
0.3178944886,
-1.1035990715,
0.7164011002,
-0.2158418596,
0.4974858463,
0.16075252,
0.2903097272,
-0.6246318221,
-0.7693828344,
-0.6101658344,
-0.7472784519,
1.1503778696,
0.276887238,
-0.1527817398,
0.2564320862,
-0.0161572509,
0.1005122289,
0.3169834018,
-0.7284736037,
-0.0678719133,
-0.0580795445,
-0.0060459641,
-0.2050622702,
-0.1653239429,
0.5042529106,
-0.2439606935,
0.828895092,
-0.1192808598,
0.2980881035,
-0.3593651652,
0.0610436238,
-0.7221678495,
0.0679434985,
0.1804074645,
0.5038831234,
-0.554428637,
-0.143975988,
0.2676504254,
-0.321436435,
0.0799441263,
0.0626993477,
-0.4804077148,
0.3782147169,
0.3088217676,
1.124027133,
0.1530110985,
-0.3041312099,
0.4085252881,
-0.1400481313,
0.0380864181,
-0.288849622,
-0.2652712464,
0.5080566406,
0.0261770207,
0.0617694184,
0.4421848357,
-0.0109573454,
-0.3873462081,
0.405068785,
0.1992156953,
-0.3631158471,
-0.2872499526,
0.7504829168,
0.0434474126,
-0.5545997024,
0.3783264756,
-0.0724712908,
-0.8394889235,
0.7452506423,
0.6485558152,
1.0909183025,
-0.7479304075,
0.1631492525,
0.4765888155,
0.4552154243,
-0.3541019559,
0.3154346943,
0.3908363283,
-0.5845246315,
-0.738835156,
-1.0906205177,
-0.0764496177,
-0.1885365248,
-0.3876196444,
0.6919090152,
-0.2281304747,
-0.1807483137,
-0.253267765,
-0.0286093894,
-0.5942464471,
0.1797982156,
0.4187748134,
0.692016542,
-0.9452309608,
1.5174523592,
0.6375337839,
-0.6964037418,
-1.1798506975,
0.1415296197,
0.0048120189,
-0.6082805395,
0.9394168258,
0.172077015,
-0.3560751677,
-0.0552907623,
-0.2193302065,
-1.1016463041,
1.0772064924,
0.5817163587,
-0.799446106,
-0.2936499417,
0.1992916018,
0.4257738292,
-0.6615611911,
0.3777546883,
0.353615284,
0.4026058316,
0.1856047958,
-1.0504442453,
-0.0479728132,
-0.1286921799,
0.4886659086,
0.3677632809,
-0.2913818955,
1.4720745087,
-0.1306255609,
-0.3331504166,
-0.0278701093,
0.5886332989,
-0.0594878905,
0.0057206466,
0.3934094608,
0.1390303075,
0.3118227124,
-0.1372844726,
1.4106678963,
-0.7655193806,
0.328617394,
1.1235669851,
0.1870454997,
0.9313064218,
0.673725009,
-0.0887359381,
0.1956115961,
0.586179316,
0.3527271152,
0.4547930062,
0.1582579762,
0.1142508015,
-0.3167986274,
-0.2528946102,
-0.500592947,
0.3059491813,
0.2446603924,
-0.4620344639,
-0.0828001425,
-0.0480395369,
0.0776107833,
0.0159983169,
-0.070013456,
0.5143475533,
0.2057589144,
-0.8023788929,
0.5866328478,
0.05609034,
0.4175986648,
-0.8417667747,
-0.1294407248,
-0.2647918165,
0.4429804385,
0.0787172839,
-0.4546206295,
0.3861804307,
-0.3633417189,
-0.1833842099,
-0.537623167,
0.6506316066,
-0.857085228,
-0.9127689004,
0.8044199944,
0.8506208658,
0.2410742491,
-0.3009541035,
-0.8871768713,
0.3418353498,
0.1009857953,
-0.2105131447,
0.0124652423,
0.5865402818,
-0.3017716706,
0.7383101583,
0.7511743903,
0.663054347,
0.3351914883,
-0.057433933,
0.9852584004,
-0.5326019526,
-0.5387683511,
-0.767652154,
0.2973175943,
0.1332080066,
0.0919210091,
0.3928244114,
0.5192007422,
0.845367074,
-0.2506902218,
0.8637602925,
-0.0677006468,
0.4674056768,
-0.3874388635,
0.6571187973,
-0.6249573827,
0.2270335555,
-0.4391138554,
-1.1041858196,
-0.2017504573,
0.4105732441,
-0.261888206,
-0.1009686887,
1.1790241003,
1.0390836,
-0.3277159631,
-0.1384629607,
0.7708637714,
0.1522534788,
0.1536761522,
0.5649998188,
0.506487906,
-0.6052187085,
0.7183827162,
-0.6449962258,
-0.1923089325,
-0.4408415556,
-0.7402514815,
-0.7548677921,
-0.5189349055,
-0.1226621941,
-0.0555372797,
0.3977906406,
0.8226258159,
0.8518138528,
-0.8879593015,
-0.8397298455,
-0.3901050687,
0.0497736,
-0.4674145281,
-0.1495696008,
-0.0127866957,
-0.5327230692,
-0.6874341369,
0.1764598191,
0.2935302258,
0.0440034531,
-0.0851672813,
-0.5406548977,
-0.4228613973,
0.034515664,
0.2546835542,
-0.0689936429,
-1.1603238583,
0.1714568287,
0.0740142018,
-0.3851245344,
0.0112179043,
0.9263170362,
-0.470489502,
0.763358295,
0.5837053657,
0.8195926547,
0.6979704499,
0.1170125976,
1.1052522659,
-0.5500470996,
0.2491528094,
0.325065881,
0.289537251,
0.2139086127,
-0.3996380568,
0.7020008564,
0.1884464771,
-0.1772562712,
-0.5538606048,
0.3175153136,
-0.8471392989,
-0.1766674519,
0.8894407153,
-0.3049647212,
-0.472928375,
0.1176863611,
-0.5618886352,
0.8108295798,
-0.4730080664,
0.1493494958,
0.7020648718,
0.0350213982,
-0.492572993,
-1.1297430992,
0.3707579374,
0.5218212008,
-0.7455410957,
0.1090863571,
0.1488992125,
-0.1694687307,
0.1868084371,
0.6328359246,
-0.1360955834,
0.284261167,
0.3549696505,
0.4380024672,
-0.1741823554,
-0.436036706,
-0.2618137598,
-0.1809611171,
0.2381639481,
-0.1823382676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14480v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14480v1
|
MetaAID 2.5: A Secure Framework for Developing Metaverse Applications via Large Language Models
| 2023-12-22T07:15:55 | 2023-12-22T07:15:55 |
Hongyin Zhu
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly being used in Metaverse
environments to generate dynamic and realistic content and to control the
behavior of non-player characters (NPCs). However, the cybersecurity concerns
associated with LLMs have become increasingly prominent. Previous research has
primarily focused on patching system vulnerabilities to enhance cybersecurity,
but these approaches are not well-suited to the Metaverse, where the virtual
space is more complex, LLMs are vulnerable, and ethical user interaction is
critical. Moreover, the scope of cybersecurity in the Metaverse is expected to
expand significantly. This paper proposes a method for enhancing cybersecurity
through the simulation of user interaction with LLMs. Our goal is to educate
users and strengthen their defense capabilities through exposure to a
comprehensive simulation system. This system includes extensive Metaverse
cybersecurity Q&A and attack simulation scenarios. By engaging with these,
users will improve their ability to recognize and withstand risks.
Additionally, to address the ethical implications of user input, we propose
using LLMs as evaluators to assess user content across five dimensions. We
further adapt the models through vocabulary expansion training to better
understand personalized inputs and emoticons. We conduct experiments on
multiple LLMs and find that our approach is effective.
|
[
-0.3603704274,
-1.1194146872,
0.5031893849,
0.1392944604,
-0.0916891843,
0.3865585029,
0.0085009905,
-0.5257390738,
0.3732916117,
0.8384667635,
-0.4841491878,
-0.4468824267,
-0.6287410259,
0.1355081499,
-0.1008633971,
0.8469783664,
0.1726387143,
-0.1210114732,
-0.4609660804,
0.1585897952,
-0.470127821,
-0.7814686894,
-0.6446923614,
-0.1568036228,
0.4005864263,
0.2509556711,
0.7738808393,
0.1155924946,
0.6147710681,
0.3882428706,
0.1055468097,
0.1304906905,
-0.4903361797,
0.2358462811,
-0.6091861725,
-0.2647412717,
-0.7534233928,
-0.0048976266,
0.1774081588,
0.4431506693,
-0.3944452703,
0.2765601873,
-0.123383753,
0.026592467,
-0.7867390513,
-0.1624321193,
-0.3960535228,
0.0857257694,
-0.2089585513,
-0.3295492828,
-0.4243931174,
0.0737573653,
0.032138858,
-0.5940671563,
-0.426215142,
0.1582112461,
0.2786750495,
-0.0982174054,
-0.296528399,
-0.1383347362,
-0.8626046181,
0.8497985005,
-0.6366094947,
0.469586432,
0.5612010956,
0.5463448763,
-0.2410900593,
-0.8028671145,
-0.7146482468,
-0.0437422991,
0.2389932424,
-0.0156820565,
-0.3824441135,
0.1843044013,
0.307857722,
-0.3100327551,
-0.4369904101,
0.2662996054,
-0.218879506,
-0.0634001717,
0.7141495347,
0.5919246078,
0.4441821277,
-0.1440872848,
-0.3711660206,
-0.1571795791,
-0.7754939198,
-0.0767981559,
0.5839355588,
0.1011383161,
-0.3454088569,
0.6725986004,
0.1495063752,
0.4687127471,
-0.1528429985,
-0.5739071369,
0.1764199287,
-0.2348555177,
-0.3315582275,
-0.3643476367,
0.7056130171,
0.4736835063,
0.2148147523,
-0.0735261887,
-0.0228430443,
-0.1550368667,
0.6904795766,
-1.0224753618,
0.1802231818,
0.5345183015,
-0.5988436341,
-0.655589819,
0.0175281111,
-1.0977042913,
-0.6913330555,
-0.2518996596,
0.260381788,
-0.2879475355,
-0.3947495222,
0.2071157992,
-0.0428619906,
0.0966546983,
0.353296876,
-0.6769638658,
0.5696557164,
0.6620998979,
0.3601030409,
0.1463716477,
-0.2506255507,
-0.4074784219,
0.4337078035,
-0.1389897466,
0.3559803367,
-0.7993057966,
-0.5064017773,
0.0691212192,
-0.2029679567,
0.2068264633,
-0.1562681347,
0.1495247036,
-0.857465446,
-0.0846477896,
-0.1234972775,
-0.2977122962,
-0.0469507836,
0.3928565681,
-0.4819593728,
0.3774470985,
0.0091649257,
-0.8733226657,
-0.0207649507,
-0.8048521876,
-0.2774355114,
0.2494339198,
-0.2284584939,
-0.2099612653,
0.0655675009,
0.0891810134,
0.4641931653,
-0.4015851021,
0.2061543614,
-0.7074882388,
-0.2925277948,
0.6172890663,
-0.3599357605,
0.7062785625,
0.3270581365,
-0.3555306792,
-0.0365141779,
-0.2735823095,
0.1330295503,
0.2308144718,
0.0423059687,
-0.3783940077,
0.0958045647,
0.2805908024,
0.1297049075,
0.2152166963,
-0.577142477,
0.0473303907,
-0.5179836154,
0.3198249936,
0.7265902162,
0.0481599383,
0.3179908395,
-0.0558478348,
0.922262907,
-0.0350550488,
0.3139619231,
-0.0604484081,
-0.3280551136,
-0.2289343476,
-0.3167353868,
0.3086866438,
0.8617491126,
-0.9476046562,
0.3195968866,
-0.2552311122,
-0.3345077038,
-0.1847679764,
0.2077392191,
0.3684343398,
0.0106321657,
0.2958252728,
0.010732891,
-0.5472480059,
-0.6846558452,
-0.3015432656,
-0.2788457572,
-0.1302790195,
0.474383831,
0.6251584291,
-0.8665898442,
1.0410443544,
-0.6387013197,
-0.0536199436,
-0.5427186489,
-0.0583355427,
-0.1516675651,
0.3963699341,
0.5332220793,
-0.7907854915,
-0.1263405085,
-0.0390005969,
-0.8544992805,
-0.1556073725,
0.0922621712,
0.0637682974,
-0.1147110984,
0.7582576275,
-0.4607107639,
0.5942267776,
0.6396052241,
-0.4592068493,
0.4439624548,
-0.2236543149,
-0.0327107534,
-1.3612413406,
0.2939539254,
-0.3811066449,
-0.552223742,
-0.7933178544,
0.6273727417,
-0.1357777119,
-0.6002212763,
-0.477245152,
0.9482251406,
-0.1545530558,
-0.0246676281,
-0.5133937001,
0.1272653639,
-0.0665247887,
0.0184802748,
-0.1914874166,
0.905844748,
0.3605206013,
-0.3901124001,
0.3288912773,
0.1121258438,
0.0538648404,
0.8760014176,
-0.9258681536,
0.1845592111,
-0.1880456954,
0.5019543171,
-0.5630790591,
-0.4342958629,
0.3087418675,
-0.4233517647,
0.2146560997,
0.1698797047,
-0.7591548562,
-0.3023180068,
-0.3514352441,
0.5797742009,
0.4578872025,
-0.3741427362,
1.030294776,
0.8602078557,
-0.1074264869,
-0.6946411133,
-0.6748895645,
0.6538946629,
-0.4702880681,
-0.7805424929,
0.2292794585,
-0.1872268766,
-0.5305700302,
-0.287533015,
0.5309799314,
-0.0185978897,
0.5741015077,
0.3894298077,
0.0021439188,
0.2604927123,
-0.0926911011,
0.2541938424,
-0.1182138547,
0.2653510571,
-0.3720006049,
0.5747663379,
0.0235694069,
-0.3968757093,
-0.4117933214,
0.5838422179,
0.4671361148,
-0.3314600289,
0.8751180768,
0.5491787791,
-0.5899042487,
-0.2914102674,
-0.5177561641,
-0.3933651745,
-0.5888369083,
0.3627917171,
-0.3009729683,
-1.0532066822,
0.5869752169,
-0.3756794333,
0.1796773076,
0.0933710113,
0.5851060152,
-0.3551613688,
0.8712503314,
0.8344964981,
0.1827166229,
0.2093310356,
-0.001805902,
0.2517587543,
-0.9037483931,
-0.2931446135,
-0.2041116655,
-0.312710315,
-0.4947870076,
-0.7378222942,
0.5231755376,
-0.0520697683,
-0.1315596104,
0.4111597538,
0.1401612312,
0.5044763088,
0.0475719012,
0.0225928742,
-0.0952178091,
0.2201945931,
-0.3754207194,
-0.0390854552,
-0.3524105847,
-0.54864043,
1.0821726322,
0.7733326554,
1.0006365776,
0.6721368432,
0.7749935985,
0.3946116865,
0.2726147771,
-0.2578044236,
0.4923934639,
-0.1058742329,
-0.6734090447,
-0.295057416,
-0.5522170663,
-1.0385452509,
0.1334124804,
-0.2885780632,
-0.911481142,
0.2039187998,
0.0775973052,
-0.5453703403,
0.2269548625,
-0.2866243422,
0.5621750355,
0.0403063223,
-0.4932608008,
-0.4073918462,
-0.720479846,
0.2817468941,
-0.2211813033,
0.4719149768,
0.2443785667,
-0.1718140244,
0.543087244,
-0.3551267385,
1.4525454044,
-0.0715342164,
-0.2568658888,
0.3517020345,
0.2810494006,
0.5521537066,
0.5159742832,
0.0635850579,
0.2010522336,
-0.1515238583,
-0.1889537573,
-0.5557098985,
0.6229242682,
-0.6906634569,
-0.7251013517,
-0.3980316222,
-0.4323447347,
-0.267616123,
0.1962337792,
-0.1530559212,
0.3199472725,
-0.482758224,
0.1925455928,
0.9151456952,
-0.6633636951,
0.2745977342,
0.545193851,
-0.4248979092,
-0.8521869779,
0.6878609657,
-0.1126137003,
0.3099702299,
0.3151201308,
0.2969934046,
-0.2986397445,
-0.0608712472,
-0.5545634627,
0.1969160438,
-0.6745965481,
-0.5199181437,
-0.8800485134,
-0.2250179052,
-0.5398371816,
-0.3476694524,
0.0195689555,
-0.2278791219,
-0.1671146899,
-0.2066568136,
0.3906168342,
0.5315064788,
0.0519019924,
0.621058166,
-0.7211255431,
0.2172359228,
0.3956972957,
0.2190387398,
-0.0491540469,
-0.4355373979,
-0.0419631861,
0.0137466332,
-0.289927572,
-0.8399088979,
0.3529092669,
-0.0992728099,
0.4848999381,
0.5393550992,
-0.1303409785,
0.6104363799,
-0.7650303245,
0.7739343643,
0.2778844535,
-1.1401824951,
0.3334192038,
-0.540755868,
0.1891094148,
0.6194602251,
0.1111555472,
-0.6430633664,
-0.2783508003,
-0.806045711,
-0.4072111547,
0.3686259091,
0.2104584426,
0.7339311242,
-0.1278279424,
0.3522340357,
-0.2861908376,
0.3643449843,
-0.5993938446,
-0.1495180875,
-0.137230888,
-0.1960150003,
0.0101946462,
-0.4661210179,
-0.3112217486,
0.1642937213,
0.2504355907,
-0.1598754078,
0.3236228228,
-0.1112256572,
0.0863034874,
0.0629312024,
0.0783589408,
0.9606707096,
0.6799010038,
0.1227067485,
0.4369536638,
0.5759273171,
-0.7757245302,
0.113683641,
-0.1931723803,
0.0606943406,
-0.3468284905,
0.3427704573,
0.5792255998,
0.2280999124,
-0.8465200663,
0.8417937756,
-0.1320269555,
-0.0256992448,
-0.580622673,
0.0311111007,
0.3064400554,
0.245789066,
-0.0896594822,
-0.1406487972,
0.1404764503,
-0.4794136286,
0.2351278514,
0.526039362,
-0.1620740592,
-0.3742923737,
0.6173239946,
0.4832129478,
-0.395031631,
0.2928801775,
-0.1974247545,
-0.5809607506,
0.476629138,
0.8980465531,
0.9594681263,
-0.6154667139,
0.1735637188,
0.1858607531,
0.7011424899,
0.1383921504,
0.4928711653,
0.2866271436,
-0.5437648296,
-0.2619290054,
-0.7077093124,
-0.3449203968,
0.1503092349,
-0.076046966,
0.3573376536,
-0.962928772,
-0.4648666084,
-0.4810860157,
-0.1633031666,
-0.5955344439,
0.1868959367,
0.2023325861,
0.892716825,
-0.7019380331,
0.5363325477,
0.5316368341,
0.0253059212,
-0.4591606855,
-0.0389329046,
0.0165610034,
-0.5374148488,
0.714915514,
0.0005843673,
-0.1887483001,
-0.3490491211,
-0.4295597076,
-0.8972808123,
1.1415066719,
0.3702999949,
-0.338039428,
0.1726500988,
0.6618210077,
0.588501215,
-0.4819114804,
0.2684339881,
0.163594082,
0.4818115234,
-0.1781399399,
-0.608402133,
0.1153256148,
-0.1513963044,
0.1415247768,
0.1945127696,
-0.4099206924,
0.6098997593,
-0.1266625524,
-0.0912051275,
-0.1511181146,
0.7848762274,
0.4586534202,
0.3595865667,
0.4656650424,
0.5885320902,
0.6535508633,
0.4694944322,
1.135538578,
-0.162833333,
0.136900112,
0.8684789538,
-0.4840453863,
0.7808524966,
0.4675323069,
-0.0153180044,
0.4996329248,
0.1991695911,
-0.0305186938,
0.2238693982,
0.4849757552,
-0.3013943732,
-0.353149116,
-0.208039254,
-0.2537972927,
0.5735957026,
0.5727975368,
-0.3786224723,
-0.1306110471,
0.2730041742,
0.4079226553,
0.0469458252,
-0.0665843487,
0.697683692,
0.3857241869,
-0.041752845,
0.1181665137,
0.8477842808,
0.4427771568,
-0.6412678361,
-0.0077663581,
0.0257869624,
-0.0666803569,
-0.1202242002,
-0.5308115482,
0.3706755042,
0.2779688835,
-0.0133845545,
-0.0691422448,
0.7291896939,
-0.1855628341,
-0.7308272719,
0.4059209526,
0.2943083942,
0.0857724696,
0.3138234317,
-0.5718659759,
0.2014341056,
-0.4173299372,
0.0148229478,
0.5057772994,
0.2317197025,
-0.3425146639,
0.6282716393,
0.9341881275,
-0.0293984022,
-0.236824736,
0.0273857359,
0.8241090775,
-0.2232881933,
-0.6938529611,
-1.0803838968,
0.3359388113,
-0.497924149,
-0.3426034451,
0.7473073006,
0.1343942434,
0.5320516229,
-0.1258531958,
0.5413251519,
-0.0382124074,
0.2545307875,
-0.4465111494,
0.9084667563,
-0.391351819,
0.3921991587,
-0.6358696222,
-0.8516537547,
-0.3201049566,
0.3982802331,
-0.1686830819,
0.1262184978,
0.319596082,
0.6548621058,
-0.2326542586,
-0.160840407,
0.5906052589,
-0.1123563424,
0.6179512739,
0.237203002,
0.6559230685,
-0.3461965919,
0.0885776728,
0.1017817482,
-0.3912445605,
-0.2385524064,
-0.9974726439,
-1.2986363173,
-0.0657767132,
-0.0029159768,
-0.3244978487,
0.0452927314,
1.0392645597,
0.5932025313,
-0.5466200709,
-0.3660186529,
0.200690791,
-0.0894221365,
-0.0239380058,
-0.1528193802,
-0.0968513265,
-0.0950706974,
-0.471373111,
0.4431563616,
0.2376983464,
0.0802050158,
-0.5681055784,
-0.0533084944,
0.1859696656,
0.7463083267,
0.7765884399,
0.0372416414,
-0.5836713314,
-0.3475653529,
0.1221318617,
-0.1614304781,
-0.6596015692,
0.7944788933,
-0.5948470831,
0.2958060801,
0.5532133579,
1.0310200453,
-0.167643711,
0.1286456883,
0.7053332925,
-0.6569079161,
-0.0367076918,
0.1705211997,
0.2627301514,
0.0921249762,
-0.6616988778,
0.2555729449,
0.0645529553,
-0.3175089657,
-0.8852907419,
0.4766339958,
-0.6635942459,
-0.4554690421,
1.1966997385,
-0.1622410268,
-0.178238675,
-0.2039400041,
0.0890503079,
-0.3126168847,
-0.0937341005,
0.6465826035,
0.4633158743,
0.4533708692,
0.0945764109,
-0.7077473998,
0.3715148568,
0.2110784352,
-1.2033808231,
0.3184954226,
0.1386430711,
0.4468213022,
0.3474909365,
0.4622918069,
-0.2978620827,
0.3329618871,
-0.2669267952,
0.0267801285,
-0.1891185045,
-0.7010653615,
-0.3762897253,
0.2283459157,
-0.2635727525,
0.4053232372
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.17259v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.17259v2
|
Empowering Working Memory for Large Language Model Agents
| 2023-12-22T05:59:00 | 2024-05-28T05:34:52 |
Jing Guo, Nan Li, Jianchuan Qi, Hang Yang, Ruiqiao Li, Yuzhen Feng, Si Zhang, Ming Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved impressive linguistic
capabilities. However, a key limitation persists in their lack of human-like
memory faculties. LLMs exhibit constrained memory retention across sequential
interactions, hindering complex reasoning. This paper explores the potential of
applying cognitive psychology's working memory frameworks, to enhance LLM
architecture. The limitations of traditional LLM memory designs are analyzed,
including their isolation of distinct dialog episodes and lack of persistent
memory links. To address this, an innovative model is proposed incorporating a
centralized Working Memory Hub and Episodic Buffer access to retain memories
across episodes. This architecture aims to provide greater continuity for
nuanced contextual reasoning during intricate tasks and collaborative
scenarios. While promising, further research is required into optimizing
episodic memory encoding, storage, prioritization, retrieval, and security.
Overall, this paper provides a strategic blueprint for developing LLM agents
with more sophisticated, human-like memory capabilities, highlighting memory
mechanisms as a vital frontier in artificial general intelligence.
|
[
-0.4515939951,
-0.9606837034,
0.8908034563,
0.0500956811,
0.0849807337,
0.2101513892,
-0.6762610674,
-0.3907568455,
0.0222335234,
0.5875219703,
-0.3397340477,
-0.2898440063,
-0.1709860414,
0.0433243439,
0.0442103557,
0.5772924423,
-0.0624526925,
-0.1544009745,
-0.4126254618,
-0.2516876161,
-0.8076921701,
-0.7917660475,
-0.5536593795,
-0.6312955022,
0.5016628504,
0.392716676,
0.8576802015,
0.6460086107,
0.1560438722,
0.3428446949,
-0.0585690476,
0.2497982383,
-0.6537360549,
0.285983175,
-0.415697813,
-0.6192823648,
-0.6266489625,
-0.4265340567,
0.4717115462,
0.8029648662,
-0.4448055923,
-0.3799312115,
-0.2266741097,
0.4188757241,
-0.5565975904,
0.2590484321,
-0.5627661943,
-0.0146971587,
-0.0854194909,
-0.0855809897,
-0.6294679642,
0.1591140628,
0.3093055785,
-0.3740683496,
-0.2091085911,
0.2810623646,
0.6895427704,
0.1286209375,
-0.0660978034,
-0.1300332993,
-1.0016828775,
0.6823845506,
-0.5058557391,
0.3075247109,
0.5805889368,
0.27186957,
-0.078634575,
-0.550462544,
-0.3764760196,
-0.422136575,
0.1377478242,
-0.0909019038,
-0.2909108996,
0.2147169709,
0.1686743796,
0.0685937926,
-0.2999532819,
0.2668194473,
-0.3337083161,
-0.1672188044,
0.3133492768,
0.4832034707,
0.357747525,
0.4237425625,
-0.1480867416,
0.1395057887,
-0.6432925463,
-0.2689558566,
-0.0677767545,
0.1155113354,
0.0772467032,
0.383282572,
-0.1253516674,
0.4711337686,
0.0628353059,
-0.0781846046,
0.1442215443,
-0.0163084641,
-0.2148173749,
-0.039516408,
0.4016192257,
0.0789765269,
0.1413821429,
-0.5808192492,
-0.3038062155,
-0.1632556319,
0.5698820949,
-0.6909207702,
-0.0484393351,
0.1537394524,
-0.2626421452,
0.0954636633,
-0.1866700798,
-0.3861037493,
-0.1851543337,
-0.3445829153,
0.3845480084,
-0.5236989856,
-0.2624644935,
0.0404492468,
-0.211362958,
0.1602104306,
0.3629153073,
-1.066652894,
0.2131513208,
0.7337978482,
0.5991250277,
-0.1582538933,
-0.5602378845,
-0.2354286015,
0.6680768728,
-0.2363836467,
0.4852340519,
-0.8374305964,
-0.1634519398,
0.2177346647,
0.0766902491,
0.1588210166,
-0.7907567024,
0.0243090261,
-0.6012365222,
-0.1398796141,
-0.3382730186,
-0.4461233318,
-0.1756009459,
0.4174622595,
-0.7381501794,
0.730379045,
0.1252376139,
-0.152004078,
-0.0554323941,
-0.3946183622,
-0.4506901205,
0.1415692568,
-0.4099903703,
-0.0493016131,
0.2369300276,
-0.0237764213,
0.5567904115,
-0.5800541639,
0.3708078861,
-0.4596023858,
-0.3726350963,
0.4655431509,
-0.2423109412,
0.3961915076,
0.0496976748,
-0.1188858822,
-0.0037173983,
-0.3532525003,
-0.2964861393,
0.1800532937,
-0.5021145344,
-0.4519132972,
-0.0090149296,
-0.2492921203,
0.0693230331,
0.4845677316,
-0.3864988685,
0.1398972124,
-0.1140252054,
0.6677055955,
0.7449871898,
-0.1213900149,
0.7038131356,
-0.5586989522,
0.3903781176,
0.0434270017,
-0.0451198742,
-0.3466810584,
-0.1706341654,
-0.6145154834,
-0.3444284201,
-0.4288467169,
0.4750643373,
-0.5545336604,
0.2690619826,
-0.2703897357,
-0.3108874559,
-0.0810900405,
0.3721246719,
0.4217881858,
0.2364127338,
0.0364719592,
-0.297277838,
-0.5363259912,
-0.9370173216,
0.1833088398,
-0.0195618812,
-0.153071776,
0.4932830334,
0.4097268283,
-0.4126306474,
0.9512630105,
-0.3223683536,
-0.0488614626,
-0.6381332278,
-0.2330199778,
0.1198854521,
0.2542355359,
0.2102632523,
-0.6288608909,
-0.1550223678,
-0.1266925931,
-0.8750376701,
-0.0568451174,
-0.2812093794,
-0.2146127522,
0.3141849041,
0.6868044734,
-1.0706480742,
0.1400225312,
0.1193056256,
-0.2974630296,
0.4360432327,
-0.4718551636,
-0.3777532578,
-0.741487205,
-0.0899142399,
-0.2762083113,
-0.136868,
-0.7565367818,
-0.0211768933,
-0.1356372684,
-0.1750261933,
-0.221712321,
0.6242566705,
-0.7802852392,
-0.143409133,
-0.4008884132,
0.290171355,
0.0775787458,
0.7563374043,
0.234060511,
0.4978363812,
0.4286042452,
-0.5490681529,
0.1828493774,
0.2672082186,
0.1266858131,
0.6378697753,
-0.448538959,
0.2131246924,
-0.1486892998,
0.3724079132,
-0.5504633188,
-0.0880685821,
-0.2475613952,
-0.1207827181,
0.4445533454,
0.2522808611,
-0.5989480615,
-0.0373608954,
-0.0555510819,
0.2010936141,
0.6543186307,
-0.4307149649,
0.9288403392,
0.5006867051,
-0.2226125449,
-0.1377061009,
-0.5321313739,
0.2667014003,
-0.233996734,
-0.6394750476,
0.4505461156,
0.0647418275,
-0.4977516234,
0.1150375083,
0.0113739008,
-0.0834663957,
0.0549333096,
0.1967472136,
0.4572796822,
-0.3211376071,
0.2935255766,
-0.229985252,
-0.1104102805,
0.0226817112,
-0.346455574,
0.7239097357,
-0.3811007738,
-0.1883423626,
-0.2257566005,
0.5556022525,
0.8821659088,
-0.2212041467,
0.872435689,
0.4807026386,
-0.5367968678,
-0.3175725341,
-0.8349565268,
-0.2952102721,
-0.4797683358,
0.6491866708,
-0.2248170525,
-1.1006842852,
0.5975943804,
-0.3051212132,
-0.03214591,
-0.1550893486,
0.9699755311,
-0.0931212232,
0.722197473,
0.4234764278,
-0.2820938826,
0.5332998633,
-0.0629947484,
0.2987858653,
-0.9930577278,
-0.1441534311,
-0.0045996211,
-0.1670479476,
-0.0022051383,
-0.651253581,
0.0941765159,
0.1710814089,
-0.7223185897,
0.0907790735,
-0.2582892478,
0.562486887,
0.3430698812,
0.0896720067,
0.1088330746,
-0.0506340675,
-0.2581591308,
0.125821501,
-0.5552073121,
-0.7574291229,
0.8924222589,
0.5060770512,
0.7097629309,
0.2391781956,
0.3883120716,
0.3418959975,
0.071384728,
-0.4316828847,
0.7956547737,
0.1910909265,
-0.6474519372,
-0.4853640497,
-0.1277989149,
-0.9169139862,
0.4016457796,
-0.0608730502,
-1.2371218204,
-0.0894279927,
-0.1096215174,
-0.3609310687,
0.3541609347,
-0.3899300098,
0.6379065514,
-0.2684085071,
-0.690223515,
-0.5773998499,
-0.4630918503,
0.1483672708,
0.1641411483,
-0.0409574658,
-0.0712777302,
-0.2010296285,
0.315998584,
-0.3726400137,
1.1467289925,
-0.1058266386,
0.1600682884,
0.4088238776,
0.0226090457,
0.5483852029,
-0.2104575485,
-0.0421487316,
0.0446951278,
-0.3135068715,
-0.5091956258,
-0.4489107132,
0.5225933194,
-0.7382839918,
-0.8638245463,
-0.0671073422,
-0.7870303392,
-0.4104561806,
0.0960616618,
-0.4219527841,
0.356489867,
-0.3625378907,
0.4481055737,
0.7428292036,
-0.2987967432,
0.5915220976,
0.6187744141,
-0.0685639977,
-0.3695387542,
0.8854507804,
-0.0366014987,
0.589774847,
0.4578794837,
0.2130359411,
-0.0442717448,
-0.5732491612,
-0.2324312627,
0.2504413426,
-0.7770439386,
0.0562937409,
-0.5029102564,
-0.0947820395,
-0.0786495805,
-0.5612436533,
-0.3792449534,
-0.1436251104,
-0.2121055722,
-0.2727528214,
0.263066709,
0.6099235415,
-0.0631690845,
0.2675552964,
-0.7455335855,
0.1229551286,
0.2712812424,
0.01051242,
0.7102050781,
-0.1399510652,
-0.4519572556,
-0.2010366917,
-0.3481657207,
-0.748275876,
0.5436094999,
-0.0275711417,
0.8331211805,
0.6083908677,
-0.1571811587,
0.5921115875,
-0.4376311898,
0.4813777506,
0.0781257004,
-0.6115566492,
0.224046275,
-0.6094306707,
0.3125454485,
0.3981701136,
0.087990202,
-0.3934860229,
-0.459705621,
-0.4366701245,
-0.9041573405,
0.6124281883,
0.187964052,
0.086319901,
-0.1197770834,
0.4677515924,
-0.1203706861,
0.1522162706,
-0.3341441751,
-0.0129199773,
0.0979366601,
-0.0418470167,
0.0673061311,
-0.073097609,
-0.2898409963,
-0.2548853755,
0.3859432638,
-0.0363676772,
0.3959397078,
0.1579409689,
-0.201843515,
0.1778132468,
0.3184477985,
0.4472748935,
0.6996482015,
-0.1611175388,
0.1106783971,
0.4864055216,
-0.4520132542,
0.1407523304,
-0.2990734875,
-0.1167977676,
-0.4104539454,
0.2525483668,
0.7175593376,
0.3518314958,
-1.0829555988,
0.2652873397,
0.0274342485,
0.1101250574,
-0.7777024508,
0.0511748232,
0.7591461539,
0.6175009012,
0.5061782598,
-0.2642392218,
-0.3872953057,
-1.0351494551,
0.2160038203,
0.3319338262,
-0.3552050889,
-0.2960900962,
0.4291043282,
0.1834094077,
-0.5349497795,
0.7936583757,
-0.3222547174,
-0.5369605422,
0.700684309,
1.005183816,
0.7915418744,
0.0448901765,
-0.1641315818,
0.1082602441,
0.2445011735,
-0.2180438042,
0.126423195,
-0.1421893835,
-0.9587439895,
-0.0096010007,
-0.3936285973,
-0.5553926229,
-0.1228150949,
-0.5876256824,
-0.0561215542,
-0.7594839334,
-0.0890515149,
-0.485735178,
-0.0217436608,
-0.6691256166,
-0.1594329625,
0.5263984203,
0.6970820427,
-0.5105979443,
1.1209896803,
0.4851050377,
-0.4244772196,
-0.6710420847,
-0.3941343427,
0.0394403748,
-0.824377656,
0.3815763295,
0.3582594097,
0.0688413903,
-0.2823762,
-0.3104789555,
-0.643091321,
1.6372842789,
0.3596048057,
-0.7008077502,
-0.2181705236,
0.0753055364,
0.5299004316,
-0.8731299639,
0.2478314638,
0.7920151353,
0.4233323336,
0.2349173874,
-0.7555343509,
0.4536541998,
-0.165436253,
0.1044457555,
0.1652752161,
-0.8679439425,
0.9055091143,
-0.3905263841,
-0.1506077647,
-0.0020588301,
0.6522452235,
0.6078699231,
0.2904334962,
0.3214341402,
0.6504077911,
0.947348237,
0.2143228799,
0.9229954481,
-0.2163143903,
-0.2035056651,
1.2538561821,
-0.6612334847,
0.9312912822,
0.4024796784,
0.1475934386,
0.5958825946,
0.1639796644,
-0.0057093338,
0.4525046051,
0.1004993618,
-0.4798391461,
-0.5023118258,
-0.3276382983,
0.0771051198,
0.3701482117,
0.7342256904,
-0.3039159179,
0.0771103948,
0.0430309735,
0.3190771043,
0.0452275239,
-0.2893277407,
0.7521861792,
0.3298126161,
-0.695409596,
0.419667244,
-0.1272209734,
0.3429741263,
-0.4825904369,
0.0750756562,
-0.0770273954,
0.4682556689,
0.0633674338,
-0.4508759081,
0.2160350382,
-0.2142953128,
-0.166432023,
-0.2784826159,
0.6869284511,
-0.4031786621,
-0.0300021097,
0.6106012464,
0.6584499478,
0.013795156,
0.0152425962,
-0.3443025649,
0.1785502285,
-0.2043737471,
-0.2730627954,
0.5316018462,
0.6689388156,
-0.2375519872,
0.920186758,
0.5345203876,
0.045695547,
-0.0145466002,
0.1152617484,
0.9513455629,
-0.981795609,
-0.3837698698,
-1.0396156311,
0.1995886415,
-0.1737726629,
-0.0509670489,
0.5566481948,
0.4411313534,
0.5257121325,
0.0060433266,
0.8070439696,
0.0102354316,
0.0099295229,
-0.2399609685,
0.586848259,
-0.2471957952,
0.300888598,
0.0009243488,
-0.7059604526,
-0.068167299,
0.4537302852,
-0.2942926884,
-0.1588230729,
0.7769075632,
0.8387134671,
0.0930667222,
0.0455189161,
0.6055982113,
0.474717021,
0.3782448173,
1.0947986841,
0.9202817082,
0.2785741091,
0.6260816455,
0.0677563846,
-0.1602697074,
-0.2799623311,
-0.5829257965,
-1.3061974049,
-0.4037205279,
0.050244581,
-0.0467464551,
0.0299374498,
1.0114783049,
0.6406434178,
-0.2736501694,
-0.302988857,
-0.0165557284,
0.040405523,
-0.0956893414,
-0.1395162642,
0.134187758,
-0.1943027526,
-0.4608302712,
0.3275705278,
0.7070857286,
-0.0135008683,
-0.7840560675,
-0.4358659685,
-0.1002831012,
0.3358604014,
0.6703038812,
0.4962353706,
-0.7845904827,
-0.208922267,
0.0418765098,
-0.23057504,
0.1248316616,
0.7283716798,
-0.6070910096,
0.2645083964,
0.4251447022,
0.8381410241,
0.5007869005,
-0.1922929138,
0.9518561959,
-0.1757994294,
0.3170892596,
0.4340579212,
0.6117345691,
0.2634212375,
-0.3098369241,
0.3119961917,
-0.0570783652,
-0.5987268686,
-0.7106114626,
0.2173307985,
-1.0210860968,
-0.4121522009,
0.9671005607,
-0.2956708074,
-0.4846131504,
-0.418754071,
-0.1449321806,
-0.0642971024,
-0.5464649796,
0.6819806099,
0.8586440086,
-0.2680310309,
-0.2416061163,
-0.7252828479,
-0.0367438793,
0.3933854103,
-0.7257452607,
0.25432989,
0.5830202103,
0.0486981608,
0.2381681502,
0.8923041821,
-0.0541451573,
0.2655837536,
0.2928095758,
0.050295487,
-0.23526223,
-0.5258179903,
-0.1375657022,
0.3521298766,
0.1580077112,
0.1146828085
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14423v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14423v1
|
Efficacy of Machine-Generated Instructions
| 2023-12-22T04:01:30 | 2023-12-22T04:01:30 |
Samaksh Gulati, Anshit Verma, Manoj Parmar, Palash Chaudhary
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large "instruction-tuned" language models (i.e., finetuned to respond to
instructions) have demonstrated a remarkable ability to generalize zero-shot to
new tasks. Nevertheless, they depend heavily on human-written instruction data
that is often limited in quantity, diversity, and creativity, therefore
hindering the generality of the tuned model. We conducted a quantitative study
to figure out the efficacy of machine-generated annotations, where we compare
the results of a fine-tuned BERT model with human v/s machine-generated
annotations. Applying our methods to the vanilla GPT-3 model, we saw that
machine generated annotations were 78.54% correct and the fine-tuned model
achieved a 96.01% model performance compared to the performance with
human-labelled annotations. This result shows that machine-generated
annotations are a resource and cost effective way to fine-tune down-stream
models.
|
[
-0.3191136718,
-1.0667948723,
0.677613318,
-0.0342114642,
-0.3007175326,
-0.3125022352,
-0.4058789909,
-0.5312800407,
-0.1658161581,
0.6170548797,
-0.4547272623,
-0.5281535983,
-0.6116015911,
0.2201163471,
-0.436676681,
1.1760681868,
0.0688445121,
-0.0772127584,
0.2037309259,
0.3350124359,
-0.7133565545,
-0.55398947,
-0.3770823181,
-0.5454385877,
0.5493158698,
0.441242218,
0.8497134447,
0.9766561389,
0.7058707476,
0.2260689884,
0.1307015717,
0.1735901237,
-0.4327556491,
-0.0866499618,
0.0463112816,
-0.427624166,
-0.3399084508,
0.3189849555,
0.6122398376,
0.6173316836,
0.0269446969,
0.2672260404,
0.2318996489,
0.6155303121,
-0.5928325057,
0.1500355303,
-0.7734623551,
-0.1159667224,
-0.0310927816,
-0.256695956,
-0.7581613064,
-0.4945025146,
0.1859826893,
-0.6175667048,
0.4085417092,
-0.3098042607,
0.8250808716,
0.3352533281,
0.0631526187,
-0.4560019672,
-1.0453068018,
0.8642618656,
-0.8341057301,
-0.116602309,
0.4620048106,
0.2968890667,
-0.3403301239,
-0.5850878954,
-0.2649782896,
-0.4642947316,
-0.0529476777,
-0.0738415942,
-0.0586991608,
0.161926046,
0.6197967529,
0.1527130902,
-0.3811416626,
0.4167370498,
-0.4705053568,
-0.1355770826,
0.7995404005,
0.1205374151,
0.4557201266,
-0.1766496301,
-0.1468905956,
0.0098465299,
-0.7399411201,
-0.2066460401,
0.4933579266,
0.6046738625,
0.0611527786,
0.6769695878,
-0.4061093926,
1.0386841297,
0.0322448462,
-0.062507838,
-0.0770799816,
-0.0461863317,
-0.4782013297,
0.0047685099,
0.6420887113,
0.2213589847,
0.6691458225,
-0.3282926977,
-0.2980491817,
0.0398222692,
0.5504437089,
-1.0047320127,
-0.4678125083,
-0.0348697603,
-0.3751905859,
-0.4005256593,
0.0919756591,
-0.259424597,
-0.1735519022,
-0.5629699826,
0.793979466,
-0.6482771039,
0.0166431982,
-0.0407694466,
-0.1735057384,
0.0912018418,
0.4653649628,
-1.2789461613,
-0.0300682466,
0.7764642239,
0.9334330559,
0.1319217682,
-0.1126114726,
-0.5143625736,
0.133107096,
-0.484991163,
0.6929089427,
-0.71867311,
-0.3125035763,
0.0029753968,
-0.1342028528,
-0.1533077806,
-0.4409775138,
0.4160277247,
-0.3376430869,
0.1964701712,
-0.3430054188,
-0.9873556495,
-0.218829304,
-0.0651243031,
-0.7074629068,
0.6963449121,
0.1884389073,
-0.5237264037,
0.5010772943,
-0.9575427175,
-0.5196889639,
0.1833129525,
-0.0762426779,
-0.3446317315,
0.3644059002,
0.3062458932,
0.7572152615,
-0.0873153955,
0.065818578,
-0.3469574749,
-0.8186633587,
0.3135479093,
-0.6930623055,
0.7382410169,
0.2100473791,
-0.6238720417,
-0.063731879,
-0.6675482392,
0.0512335151,
-0.0133553315,
-0.483876884,
-0.151174292,
-0.0777918175,
-0.255150944,
0.0549092181,
0.107082881,
-0.5444763899,
0.4182416201,
-0.3821570575,
0.604195416,
0.6069944501,
0.0609527193,
0.1662234515,
-0.4045689702,
0.3749501109,
-0.398103416,
0.1351582408,
-0.5576522946,
-0.6982690692,
-0.6350519657,
-0.4410073757,
0.4681980014,
0.4975593686,
-0.6391527653,
0.2898029387,
-0.0470031053,
-0.7605215311,
-0.7319173217,
0.2006029636,
0.5234327316,
0.5008345842,
0.3985654116,
-0.1193885729,
-0.1498328149,
-1.043287158,
-0.1553921551,
-0.0357120372,
-0.372209996,
0.3268429935,
0.469285965,
-0.1448055804,
0.4752121866,
-0.392663151,
0.0246187262,
0.1296399236,
0.8357265592,
-0.0542350486,
0.6499310136,
0.6013857126,
-0.3184358776,
-0.4914439917,
0.0369768701,
-0.699403584,
-0.1786209494,
-0.2927501202,
-0.1358401626,
0.553065598,
0.0801687837,
-0.5368272662,
0.4783585072,
0.4709051847,
0.0650384724,
0.4667505622,
-0.4688182175,
0.3697885275,
-0.7122911215,
0.2604467869,
-0.0788760781,
-0.0956775248,
-0.6371635199,
0.0176711064,
0.0707903132,
-0.1171982735,
-0.2947796881,
0.053101182,
-0.350271821,
0.1169483364,
-0.421023339,
0.1510643065,
-0.1686486751,
0.5161607265,
0.045922257,
0.8882991076,
0.1519127488,
-0.4824551344,
0.0998604372,
-0.170968622,
-0.2709462643,
0.3745765686,
-0.9955765009,
0.4463188946,
0.0310100168,
-0.1299082786,
-1.0336362123,
-0.6448631287,
0.1472222805,
-0.4241494238,
0.5801700354,
-0.1875587851,
-0.4632337093,
-0.2891153097,
-0.2317370176,
-0.0888805762,
0.7045156956,
-0.3660753667,
0.4363492727,
0.0839190409,
-0.1491267234,
-0.3689219654,
-0.7499133348,
-0.1941748112,
0.0251269955,
-0.4959151447,
0.1438443512,
0.0748156309,
0.0644685254,
-0.0176608469,
0.2648742199,
0.0245479345,
0.3515668809,
0.3942604959,
0.3069021702,
-0.2758861184,
0.2048128247,
0.0130244074,
-0.0048114415,
0.0174087193,
-0.2449204773,
0.3542272449,
-0.0302879047,
-0.54563272,
-0.895419836,
0.3539311886,
0.4744904339,
0.0799758732,
0.6604459286,
0.7421963215,
-0.2831461132,
0.0705178902,
-0.5944168568,
-0.3319562972,
-0.4021606445,
0.2052794248,
-0.2456784248,
-0.8891766071,
0.2618519068,
0.0727428347,
0.142424807,
0.6558694243,
0.5363166332,
-0.3200899959,
1.4568270445,
0.5903599858,
0.0434197858,
0.5376811624,
-0.1890813857,
-0.2346775085,
-0.7119238377,
0.0028906679,
-0.5684967637,
-0.4722526968,
-0.9457499981,
-0.1353081465,
0.0491073988,
0.3594128489,
-0.3296248615,
0.3832194805,
-0.9942430258,
0.4247693717,
1.035841465,
0.2659475207,
-0.0301646274,
-0.0047904332,
-0.0136371944,
-0.0079051219,
-0.604323566,
-0.9667206407,
1.3848141432,
0.3095450699,
0.495069921,
-0.1269377172,
0.8521617055,
0.4665891528,
0.5048260689,
-0.4153257012,
0.262983501,
-0.3758232892,
-0.7795398235,
-0.430204004,
-0.4021853507,
-0.836165309,
-0.2155185938,
-0.360062331,
-0.9353521466,
-0.2616140544,
0.582762599,
-0.5598241687,
0.1953029186,
-1.4149868488,
0.9707545638,
-0.2815372944,
-0.2993900776,
-0.1750702411,
-0.4784232974,
0.297167033,
-0.2627484202,
-0.2542372644,
-0.2288423181,
0.2114874721,
0.5682899952,
-0.4050825536,
0.9640628099,
-0.5166983604,
-0.0529871173,
0.4571344256,
0.0190232825,
0.6466249228,
-0.297837764,
-0.0219648723,
0.2533433735,
-0.1110605597,
-0.5014101267,
-0.7557024956,
0.5570117235,
-0.8511075377,
-0.7044839263,
0.165451616,
-0.6042935252,
0.1408251375,
0.1521326005,
0.3079322577,
0.4998191893,
-0.0185431987,
0.2871155441,
0.548643887,
-0.2593235672,
0.4928109348,
0.4091343284,
-0.0509239286,
-0.4201909006,
0.8824236989,
0.4239399731,
0.5209265947,
0.4073368311,
0.0689460635,
0.0104796793,
-0.4822280109,
-0.7273464799,
0.0572043769,
-0.3945129514,
-0.2203288227,
-0.3274465203,
-0.2454203069,
-0.1084512696,
-0.3230493069,
-0.2276702523,
-0.5795980692,
-0.4039002955,
0.0605018586,
0.4552753568,
1.0064502954,
-0.1044337451,
0.4815352261,
-0.7192682028,
0.2194819301,
0.4528672695,
0.2222867906,
-0.1248619482,
-0.5893349051,
-0.4305566549,
0.5534389615,
-0.4268233478,
-0.8041549921,
0.0713127106,
0.1105301827,
0.3790004849,
0.2602831125,
-0.0915655792,
0.751157999,
-0.4980783165,
0.8239961267,
-0.0212109145,
-1.02447474,
0.7425734997,
-0.4933068156,
0.5328037739,
0.1410049945,
0.2962127626,
-0.0146545283,
-0.6386675835,
-0.631927669,
-0.6296340227,
0.8642053008,
0.3541397452,
0.4308866858,
-0.0845330805,
0.5538692474,
0.2694444358,
0.1291899234,
-0.22519207,
0.0398160554,
-0.192997247,
-0.2205497026,
0.0645234361,
-0.356004566,
0.1772829443,
-0.180332914,
0.6316721439,
-0.0405109078,
0.4140340686,
0.0462078415,
0.0293721799,
-0.3121156991,
0.243057102,
1.1017760038,
0.6562353373,
-0.4693667293,
0.0198785327,
0.0997092649,
-0.4935785532,
-0.0962511376,
0.2976590097,
-0.717903614,
0.023113098,
0.5962392688,
1.0434974432,
0.0963074788,
-0.2535050511,
0.1466718912,
0.0739562884,
-0.3102657795,
0.0207837634,
0.60782969,
0.0007777655,
0.2228232622,
0.1832903326,
0.1075705513,
0.082846567,
-0.3415325284,
0.137459293,
0.5104268789,
-0.4245623648,
-0.3481301069,
0.8540260196,
0.3637368679,
-0.498742491,
0.7095046043,
-0.1026563942,
-0.2646763623,
0.4608739614,
0.581781745,
0.9587979913,
-0.0249543302,
0.3111842871,
0.358392179,
0.5053949356,
0.0086072674,
0.2332715541,
-0.1211737245,
-0.3283519745,
-0.850818038,
-0.4036929607,
-0.4341960847,
0.147400707,
-0.7428402901,
0.1588618904,
-0.348395586,
-0.4318391085,
0.4577221572,
0.1504144073,
-0.8069067597,
0.2661968172,
0.3703999221,
0.7427165508,
-0.8585966229,
0.8529413342,
0.5990413427,
-0.8453554511,
-1.1713908911,
-0.0435135663,
-0.3806756735,
-0.8273553252,
0.7511454821,
0.3992142379,
-0.0682411045,
0.1506651044,
-0.7720992565,
-0.5814310312,
1.0250651836,
0.8130084276,
-0.7185086012,
0.2693750262,
0.3393218219,
0.6709303856,
-0.3565060496,
0.3178074956,
0.5783676505,
0.4109675586,
-0.0173126813,
-0.9864282012,
-0.0633683652,
-0.0800241679,
0.3141783774,
0.274004072,
-0.3082278967,
0.7750805616,
-0.3091702163,
-0.1207235157,
0.0937704965,
0.5019139647,
0.0091365762,
0.0083562732,
0.0735557973,
0.4703482687,
0.7981416583,
-0.1856120825,
1.2293070555,
-0.3897001147,
0.2925643921,
1.086097002,
-0.0648387522,
0.9271966815,
0.2216217071,
0.0497311354,
0.4769010246,
0.4086509049,
-0.2172355205,
0.447398454,
0.1044072807,
0.0394681431,
-0.2374727577,
-0.0810448229,
-0.2196633965,
0.368204087,
0.1572492868,
-0.7429329157,
0.109486334,
-0.2393345982,
0.1968385279,
0.0390676558,
-0.2966381311,
0.9305463433,
-0.2593278587,
-0.8228831291,
0.9164943099,
-0.0410968587,
0.3588225543,
-0.3092267811,
-0.3614594936,
-0.0575631112,
0.1866344064,
-0.0450424403,
-0.7510277629,
0.1509807557,
0.2863472104,
-0.367174238,
0.0633249506,
0.7462167144,
-0.415681541,
-0.6040538549,
-0.2169899791,
0.2075139284,
0.2549240589,
-0.06959185,
-0.4794687629,
0.0899389833,
0.0845527276,
-0.1231397539,
0.0529421791,
0.5504968762,
0.0384555869,
0.4319104254,
0.4996916056,
0.0667812154,
0.052936364,
0.0465918966,
0.5842321515,
-0.5701479912,
0.0859341547,
-1.1131727695,
0.6468735337,
-0.2514347434,
-0.329657644,
0.6686041355,
0.2665489316,
1.0706753731,
-0.2815125287,
0.9413244128,
0.1216824129,
0.5617253184,
-0.5761309266,
0.6034499407,
-0.2430497706,
0.0531379804,
-0.3483615816,
-0.7218630314,
-0.3945777118,
0.6088731885,
-0.6107752919,
0.3735593557,
0.2834333479,
0.7384106517,
0.0849077031,
0.2252040505,
0.3677922189,
-0.0900239348,
0.159781754,
0.5312661529,
0.828194797,
-0.2914962769,
0.3143436611,
-0.5472192168,
-0.2039805353,
-0.4716215432,
-0.944639802,
-1.1742107868,
-0.2854456007,
-0.3499014378,
0.175457269,
0.2332630605,
0.9155302644,
0.8181726933,
-0.9413241744,
0.0673535988,
-0.2780255079,
-0.2559687197,
-0.2458436191,
-0.166191116,
0.4048592746,
-0.7357670665,
-0.6641600132,
-0.0472933576,
0.3411311805,
0.255015105,
-0.2799781859,
-0.0937674716,
0.0061468221,
0.2747146487,
0.6420658231,
0.1423543394,
-0.8694033623,
-0.7429515719,
0.049160976,
-0.2946975827,
-0.2489828169,
0.6672325134,
-0.4896899164,
0.7175875902,
0.3224670291,
0.5941038728,
0.2914725244,
0.2815261781,
0.8407336473,
-0.8024869561,
-0.0523347966,
0.0764397606,
0.0556311496,
0.5596488118,
-0.3470385671,
0.6090680957,
-0.0148914428,
-0.8628231883,
-0.6445623636,
0.0668564811,
-0.407302767,
-0.1869196892,
1.1286401749,
-0.4132386148,
-0.1755080819,
0.2145581841,
-0.4091936052,
0.573949635,
-0.4097976387,
1.1568814516,
0.6848232746,
-0.2555376291,
0.1207706705,
-0.8863765597,
0.4925648868,
0.2916300595,
-0.6647155881,
0.1704271287,
0.7660188079,
0.0964957401,
0.2010640353,
0.1926655173,
0.1250926256,
0.2901310325,
0.0231792107,
0.1214412674,
-0.3651667833,
-0.2636998892,
-0.1315685809,
0.1610797942,
0.3583281338,
-0.4384850264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.17257v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.17257v1
|
Evolving Large Language Model Assistant with Long-Term Conditional Memory
| 2023-12-22T02:39:15 | 2023-12-22T02:39:15 |
Ruifeng Yuan, Shichao Sun, Zili Wang, Ziqiang Cao, Wenjie Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
With the rapid development of large language models, AI assistants like
ChatGPT have widely entered people's works and lives. In this paper, we present
an evolving large language model assistant that utilizes verbal long-term
memory. It focuses on preserving the knowledge and experience from the history
dialogue between the user and AI assistant, which can be applied to future
dialogue for generating a better response. The model generates a set of records
for each finished dialogue and stores them in the memory. In later usage, given
a new user input, the model uses it to retrieve its related memory to improve
the quality of the response. To find the best form of memory, we explore
different ways of constructing the memory and propose a new memorizing
mechanism called conditional memory to solve the problems in previous methods.
We also investigate the retrieval and usage of memory in the generation
process. The assistant uses GPT-4 as the backbone and we evaluate it on three
constructed test datasets focusing on different abilities required by an AI
assistant with long-term memory.
|
[
-0.1968213916,
-1.1252706051,
0.6508002877,
-0.1286829561,
-0.1235633343,
-0.0477212593,
-0.4862239659,
-0.323154211,
0.1519540995,
0.446188271,
-0.3499334455,
-0.0755053386,
-0.3132598996,
-0.1256107241,
-0.3750375509,
1.1494034529,
-0.0766843706,
-0.1848796308,
-0.1669344306,
-0.2220377028,
-1.019218564,
-0.745429039,
-1.3660616875,
-0.3168894649,
0.2826555371,
0.0397580378,
0.7292701602,
0.1349766552,
0.0892667547,
0.415277034,
-0.0996005088,
0.0753744319,
-0.5910211802,
0.2602371871,
-0.1751408577,
-0.4771261811,
-0.7179222703,
-0.3081230521,
0.7232381701,
0.006906433,
-0.3798684478,
-0.2607663572,
-0.2386577129,
0.2910836935,
-0.2837657034,
0.4379993379,
-0.6239132285,
0.0364579447,
0.1084600613,
-0.2162522525,
-0.3498211205,
-0.2091612965,
0.2512576282,
-0.4809488058,
0.0640327856,
-0.0627140701,
0.6833580732,
0.1592633873,
-0.2218733579,
-0.381074816,
-0.8851339221,
0.5488654971,
-0.7926869988,
0.5757052302,
0.6683204174,
0.7410731316,
-0.2600078881,
-0.9017708898,
-0.7736694813,
-0.8004857302,
0.2324891537,
0.3354145586,
0.0167187899,
0.0544027612,
0.3474433422,
0.2717535198,
-0.4987507164,
-0.1264365762,
-0.3931781948,
-0.359798789,
0.3431326151,
0.0095517728,
0.5537683368,
0.0301591456,
-0.1896032244,
0.1028379872,
-0.5114370584,
-0.2023330927,
0.0727070272,
0.0345351025,
0.1250766963,
0.3631849885,
-0.0915283039,
0.5177041292,
-0.026521109,
-0.3027460873,
0.2716839612,
-0.2911019325,
-0.2161879092,
-0.0090631377,
0.635633111,
0.0761653483,
0.4369052649,
-0.1999723017,
-0.4281518161,
-0.062872164,
0.2426097691,
-0.6843757629,
-0.5006404519,
-0.2364091426,
-0.4077090919,
0.3562371433,
-0.4901474714,
-0.5109308958,
-0.1637808383,
-0.3204511404,
0.4904244542,
-0.8925908804,
-0.2141527832,
0.0990258977,
-0.0320180617,
0.1648553163,
0.5030779839,
-0.8682999611,
0.390484333,
0.5462607741,
0.5918537378,
-0.2220772952,
-0.2795827091,
-0.7873160243,
0.2367654145,
-0.0352254845,
0.5367090106,
-0.5694125295,
-0.4793241024,
0.0715818554,
-0.0408063419,
0.0365931727,
-0.4702659845,
0.4783573449,
-0.7090064883,
0.7536148429,
-0.0862251297,
-0.5868626833,
-0.198431164,
0.3382208049,
-0.6045588851,
0.9726180434,
0.2634581923,
-0.3670246303,
0.2278100997,
-0.6897622943,
-0.3502287567,
0.1523146927,
-0.3247364461,
-0.5706018209,
-0.067272976,
0.1431041807,
0.2212982029,
-0.2436656058,
0.5193181634,
-0.2770650089,
-0.1659350693,
0.0740540698,
-0.5817912817,
0.373817414,
0.0981280804,
-0.0622579046,
-0.1058405042,
-0.6377950907,
-0.3205077648,
0.2545548975,
-0.5262184143,
-0.223021552,
0.2455448657,
-0.5145347714,
0.2805355489,
0.6316114068,
-0.4303029478,
0.3093134761,
-0.052123636,
0.6266633868,
0.6792802215,
0.1989596933,
0.3086229563,
-0.2216350287,
0.4836366475,
-0.0420552865,
0.236277476,
-0.4578220546,
-0.4054323435,
-1.0752776861,
0.1429165155,
0.1671438813,
0.5351836681,
-0.8241121173,
0.1900012791,
-0.2258083075,
0.2198220342,
-0.129782185,
0.1472122818,
0.2300703228,
0.5202670097,
0.5536048412,
-0.1967218369,
-0.4323566258,
-0.9420106411,
0.280708015,
-0.3322956264,
-0.0490828827,
0.4486131668,
0.2267594337,
-0.3597406447,
0.8487666249,
-0.4765405357,
-0.0085227443,
-0.3359725773,
0.1465385407,
0.0300192591,
0.2717470825,
0.4342614114,
-0.73906672,
-0.1451714188,
-0.0486489423,
-0.524793148,
0.1717561632,
-0.45192644,
-0.2446537912,
0.4433735311,
0.6393364668,
-0.991684854,
0.2728489637,
0.4331930876,
-0.2446181625,
0.3926128149,
-0.4821106195,
0.0319449678,
-1.3229525089,
-0.0054218811,
-0.3111565411,
-0.3522563279,
-0.4036440551,
-0.3220023215,
0.1056221351,
-0.3488536179,
-0.0646820217,
0.7768213749,
-0.6206111312,
-0.1167742908,
-0.4850745201,
0.1128059179,
-0.3300485015,
0.6825829148,
0.3634726405,
0.7820404172,
0.431482017,
-0.3437140286,
0.2819444537,
0.0950637758,
0.0789264292,
0.341121912,
-0.4400998652,
0.5432639718,
-0.0434441194,
0.5523613095,
-0.744163394,
-0.0094048828,
0.0337623842,
-0.4407697618,
0.5640484095,
-0.1270022243,
-0.5770369768,
-0.4810844064,
0.005518856,
0.2240299881,
0.8403437138,
-0.4015029371,
0.8371329308,
0.2518445253,
-0.63435179,
-0.2446257472,
-0.1697097719,
0.2005786151,
-0.1783749312,
-0.6569637656,
0.0974884927,
-0.3762970865,
0.0684537217,
-0.0790206194,
-0.0668226704,
-0.0002440683,
-0.2819761038,
0.0409785137,
0.4267170727,
-0.4543221593,
0.4232046008,
0.0435574837,
-0.0586761124,
-0.0285697244,
-0.0833358988,
0.955388546,
-0.0049690586,
-0.0898567364,
-0.3185828626,
0.3935538828,
0.5530463457,
-0.323582083,
0.6176094413,
0.4201078117,
-0.2744211257,
-0.1937460601,
-0.7138112783,
-0.1604568064,
-0.5216031671,
0.6012426615,
-0.4675146639,
-0.7363802791,
0.5574210882,
-0.1403068453,
0.0363089927,
0.2671780884,
0.62696594,
0.1729111969,
0.9518005848,
0.4791362584,
-0.608210206,
0.7076599598,
-0.0356756821,
0.2255443782,
-0.8024038672,
-0.0906331837,
-0.0917101204,
0.0315562636,
-0.345303148,
-0.3980529308,
0.2270048112,
0.0862988755,
-0.5525454879,
0.3009700179,
-0.2010526061,
0.4473794103,
0.5607792735,
0.1415319592,
0.1228270233,
-0.3352301121,
0.1804467738,
0.4573658407,
-0.5487688184,
-0.2754847407,
0.8866294622,
0.4498243332,
0.6941921711,
-0.009170129,
0.7506459355,
0.2139445245,
0.1291977018,
-0.5611773729,
0.7815548778,
0.0184361693,
-0.2466157973,
-0.4003376663,
-0.4049698412,
-0.8716250062,
-0.1187802628,
-0.0498645715,
-0.8654175401,
-0.2646637857,
0.5315134525,
-0.277874738,
-0.0183066875,
-0.8484745026,
0.6577448845,
-0.4824116528,
-0.2325598896,
-0.3315266669,
-0.631419301,
0.3356284499,
-0.0165602043,
-0.3697362244,
0.1798592508,
0.116506137,
0.6034324169,
-0.213039726,
0.6636035442,
-0.329012841,
0.0431606509,
0.2610785067,
0.084982723,
0.8051395416,
0.1699006557,
-0.1859698445,
-0.1322943121,
-0.2425086647,
-0.2154837251,
-0.6659767032,
0.7437977791,
-0.7798945308,
-0.8561509252,
-0.2869342864,
-0.5341817141,
-0.4157818854,
0.2695534229,
-0.0881988481,
0.2766162157,
-0.3821372688,
-0.0045906566,
0.5370456576,
-0.6158118844,
0.4676233232,
0.612657249,
-0.1915866286,
-0.2409003079,
0.8222733736,
-0.0066010938,
0.3310991526,
0.3624378443,
0.3418911994,
-0.2917050123,
-0.5729098916,
-0.2724464238,
0.2108104229,
-0.4868715405,
-0.3147400618,
-0.5559817553,
-0.4399612844,
-0.3687550724,
-0.0006974883,
-0.2160329372,
-0.2831836939,
-0.0342387632,
0.0033763761,
0.5364226699,
0.3156905472,
0.1608966291,
0.1770038158,
-0.5774291754,
0.5906504393,
0.6553218365,
0.1967456639,
0.0094557712,
-0.4097244143,
-0.0682769343,
0.1122705191,
-0.3293667734,
-0.6296333075,
0.49662292,
0.2878107131,
0.5434209704,
0.1864317805,
-0.3317779899,
0.530577302,
-0.8115484118,
0.7616306543,
0.1321120262,
-0.7024874687,
0.5189372897,
-0.5493872166,
0.6295824647,
0.3880953789,
0.0193726867,
-0.6340572238,
-0.3767918944,
-0.6290291548,
-0.7595306039,
0.5475571156,
0.2066564113,
0.237671271,
-0.1599801183,
0.4389474988,
0.1613048762,
-0.0818716884,
-0.6946855783,
0.2351963222,
-0.3354425132,
-0.0153707275,
-0.3395518064,
-0.2191119641,
0.0340328328,
-0.0871333629,
0.5668539405,
-0.0105436873,
0.6422180533,
-0.3053996265,
-0.0484063253,
0.3165862262,
0.2655620575,
0.6066601872,
0.6262249351,
-0.2551656663,
-0.168189168,
0.5031424761,
-0.4382459521,
-0.1562238485,
0.2138769329,
-0.0587928668,
-0.205705449,
0.1776797771,
1.0129214525,
0.0092169149,
-0.6423931122,
0.4465118647,
-0.2432786375,
-0.0219052024,
-0.8757074475,
0.3618382812,
0.480615437,
0.2532843649,
0.1674426496,
-0.3291298747,
0.1087578312,
-1.0310146809,
0.2955040932,
0.3236620426,
0.1268396676,
-0.3562389612,
0.4844264984,
0.1751774549,
-0.6959428787,
0.9557097554,
-0.2339130938,
-0.6170737147,
0.4128498733,
0.9046054482,
0.8738982677,
-0.5388913155,
0.0486073457,
0.2735084295,
-0.2092141956,
-0.1744397879,
0.2619360089,
-0.378783673,
-0.5953971744,
-0.3473767638,
-0.6448528767,
-0.2725712061,
0.4349266589,
-0.3069040179,
0.2474182993,
-0.326384455,
-0.0872166455,
-0.1706096828,
-0.1455982476,
-0.7040687799,
0.2583256662,
0.3470395803,
0.7052084208,
-0.5111296177,
1.3860532045,
0.166051507,
-0.4415761828,
-0.6877089739,
0.1142306551,
-0.2087727189,
-1.0265756845,
0.807498157,
-0.0746589527,
-0.1259588003,
-0.3136118948,
-0.2869359851,
-0.9304938912,
1.1570311785,
0.3016338646,
-0.7732464075,
-0.311894089,
-0.0775604621,
0.746047914,
-0.134867996,
0.3541137874,
0.5715059042,
0.271846652,
0.0434278287,
-0.9652693272,
0.0297633,
-0.3538427949,
-0.016727658,
0.5054036379,
-0.8414551616,
0.8972176313,
0.0813230276,
-0.1860707104,
0.2471363693,
0.7257816195,
0.1639812887,
0.2932297587,
0.4468725622,
0.5906819701,
0.6052475572,
0.2686608136,
0.957474649,
-0.2372706831,
0.0599661507,
1.4653058052,
-0.3141817749,
0.9190090895,
0.1457536072,
0.1370916814,
0.5591908097,
0.2843646705,
0.2441987097,
0.4384739995,
0.207159549,
-0.4599139988,
-0.0699374452,
0.406519562,
-0.2666399777,
0.4671595097,
0.4786116183,
-0.4853710532,
-0.1019516438,
0.1364251524,
0.2372951657,
-0.2828614712,
-0.1744504869,
1.1056619883,
0.0586255416,
-1.1433286667,
0.6203102469,
-0.2617014945,
0.4065763652,
-0.8123451471,
-0.2450126708,
-0.5379595757,
0.2432367355,
0.2838461101,
-0.5719054341,
-0.052048143,
-0.039210543,
-0.096364446,
-0.0391558148,
0.6723271012,
-0.6830491424,
-0.3165692687,
0.2314784378,
0.3010247052,
0.0704236627,
0.1793903112,
-0.7613219619,
-0.0051958617,
-0.0464299917,
-0.2136145532,
0.4386262596,
0.4371453226,
-0.3022729456,
0.8067321777,
0.4183953702,
0.1624589413,
0.0687898844,
0.1753147542,
0.8376442194,
-0.7070171237,
-0.5637593269,
-0.7400892377,
0.0959591493,
-0.3875184357,
-0.391898036,
0.5519835353,
0.6261140108,
0.4203693271,
0.1431825012,
0.7816178203,
0.0547628701,
0.5117890835,
-0.8214312792,
0.5765024424,
-0.2316900343,
0.0944694877,
-0.15174447,
-0.8055070639,
0.1591318399,
0.5355175138,
-0.4379949868,
0.2268470973,
0.7017831206,
0.7293070555,
-0.3475168347,
0.0666154251,
0.3053468764,
0.3063079119,
0.607344985,
0.9297205806,
0.8374711275,
0.0051505007,
0.5072438717,
0.1192883998,
-0.2171239406,
-0.0094401184,
-0.6533955932,
-0.892824471,
-0.7789152265,
-0.0623384789,
-0.1343727559,
0.5498196483,
0.6846135855,
0.6504814625,
-0.4370305538,
-0.03629338,
-0.15861471,
-0.4229817092,
0.3214173913,
-0.1714248806,
0.6682394743,
-0.3519575596,
-0.6315960288,
0.4323102236,
0.2871617675,
0.1156357303,
-0.2793109119,
-0.3197355866,
-0.0395329073,
0.0613087676,
0.8249163628,
0.8183669448,
-0.41939798,
-0.6261666417,
-0.1916222274,
0.2303226888,
0.109837614,
0.693285346,
-0.9068273306,
0.6440281868,
0.4205054343,
0.7456873655,
0.9698153138,
-0.0736225694,
1.047745347,
-0.2599813938,
0.0661289915,
0.426353246,
0.6322669387,
0.2711779773,
-0.4113182724,
0.217726469,
-0.2924167812,
-0.9383515716,
-0.3550331295,
0.2523725331,
-1.0852757692,
-0.2501981556,
1.1713769436,
-0.0903313383,
0.0058214576,
0.1064558402,
-0.5544170141,
0.3337674439,
-0.8285955787,
0.9558621049,
0.5717257261,
-0.5412044525,
-0.3618501127,
-0.7853800654,
0.6490347385,
0.3559158146,
-0.9752049446,
-0.0656358823,
0.7440320849,
0.250039041,
0.0441853292,
0.9251852632,
0.0827500448,
0.508184731,
-0.0584668405,
-0.0694300756,
0.1489401758,
-0.2772491872,
-0.000933474,
-0.0396796428,
0.1973022223,
-0.1329272836
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14346v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14346v2
|
Don't Believe Everything You Read: Enhancing Summarization Interpretability through Automatic Identification of Hallucinations in Large Language Models
| 2023-12-22T00:31:46 | 2024-04-03T02:49:25 |
Priyesh Vakharia, Devavrat Joshi, Meenal Chavan, Dhananjay Sonawane, Bhrigu Garg, Parsa Mazaheri
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are adept at text manipulation -- tasks such as
machine translation and text summarization. However, these models can also be
prone to hallucination, which can be detrimental to the faithfulness of any
answers that the model provides. Recent works in combating hallucinations in
LLMs deal with identifying hallucinated sentences and categorizing the
different ways in which models hallucinate. This paper takes a deep dive into
LLM behavior with respect to hallucinations, defines a token-level approach to
identifying different kinds of hallucinations, and further utilizes this
token-level tagging to improve the interpretability and faithfulness of LLMs in
dialogue summarization tasks. Through this, the paper presents a new, enhanced
dataset and a new training paradigm.
|
[
-0.2015459538,
-0.893992126,
0.7974028587,
-0.0212681387,
-0.4018564224,
0.2225232869,
-0.0256156176,
-0.6311769485,
0.6159165502,
0.8217511177,
-0.2943088114,
-0.6456128955,
-0.8157794476,
0.3902097046,
-0.6249313951,
0.9592226148,
0.0900321603,
0.1705882698,
-0.0139745073,
0.1771595478,
-0.3909431398,
-0.7709395289,
-0.5445100665,
-0.3758879602,
0.3662558496,
0.0779748857,
0.6940923333,
0.5834608674,
0.2588128746,
0.2495621592,
-0.3359869421,
0.5293833613,
-0.6766066551,
0.2702603042,
-0.0081442157,
-0.6500660777,
-0.4694873989,
-0.2809285522,
0.3705700338,
0.6843139529,
-0.1293765157,
-0.1465428621,
-0.1224435046,
0.3011890948,
-0.4790979326,
0.31852898,
-0.8712933064,
0.223289907,
0.1321663707,
-0.5371728539,
-0.6068740487,
-0.4552780092,
0.0797516629,
-0.3668467104,
0.3629379272,
0.4005763233,
0.710030973,
0.418671757,
-0.3948365152,
-0.5007401109,
-0.5817049742,
0.5943794847,
-0.8597767949,
0.2643692493,
0.5040454865,
0.0784230009,
-0.1626984924,
-0.4931322038,
-0.712711513,
-0.4635845125,
-0.3478103578,
-0.1043360829,
-0.013130459,
0.367279768,
0.2728002965,
0.4223684967,
-0.4963393211,
-0.0481507666,
-0.1647048444,
-0.443503499,
0.4311563075,
0.3778722286,
0.5242477655,
-0.181325689,
-0.0923978314,
0.1176725999,
-0.4108743966,
-0.4020034373,
0.2022157162,
0.0594361089,
0.2132893056,
0.9792459011,
-0.0256636012,
0.5340394974,
0.0137332296,
-0.2502762377,
0.1628554016,
-0.079308331,
-0.5187250376,
0.4860118628,
0.4877974987,
0.6853311658,
0.3046470881,
-0.5171797276,
-0.2879852355,
0.0372350179,
0.5373643041,
-0.478738904,
-0.2607781589,
0.3486230075,
-0.6787776947,
-0.6722871661,
0.0839077309,
-0.7978947759,
-0.8362293243,
-0.3580642641,
0.5392405391,
-0.5502285957,
-0.1346150488,
0.3096684515,
-0.2104698867,
0.2361076921,
0.3089602292,
-1.0549578667,
0.4963541329,
0.8531922698,
1.1624584198,
-0.3153735399,
-0.2716606855,
-0.4739138782,
0.296934247,
-0.47036466,
0.8603546023,
-0.5434803367,
-0.3041342199,
0.0194393322,
0.1505083293,
-0.1600947827,
-0.6722659469,
0.4785898924,
-0.3434722424,
-0.0291075092,
-0.2428571582,
-0.5290954709,
-0.330122292,
0.1915716082,
-0.5135220885,
0.6853775382,
-0.0291238707,
-0.6706706882,
0.226743266,
-0.4288303852,
-0.5745187402,
-0.1619905829,
-0.0636942163,
-0.3048578501,
0.525370419,
0.1501844972,
0.3301493227,
0.2499248385,
0.3665837348,
-0.1723626852,
-0.5857686996,
0.3649093211,
-0.276098758,
0.6229495406,
0.121702157,
-0.344909817,
0.3388517797,
-0.6131905913,
-0.1966249943,
-0.0734918788,
0.0686232224,
-0.3648021519,
-0.0454945713,
-0.0123660723,
-0.1031809747,
0.2282487899,
-0.4322917461,
0.3527536392,
-0.9205565453,
0.2036022395,
0.669793129,
0.2185067683,
0.417172581,
-0.5935849547,
0.5193158388,
0.3044074178,
-0.0548802912,
-0.4374755323,
-0.3563916683,
-0.9275038242,
-0.0221593808,
0.0217747539,
0.6025566459,
-0.7681150436,
0.7521211505,
-0.0713976324,
-0.4725298584,
-0.5384851098,
-0.0593166538,
0.1897925586,
0.5699840784,
0.4519573748,
-0.1097509488,
-0.7750587463,
-0.8502788544,
-0.4400318563,
-0.3303730786,
-0.2579717934,
-0.0385545604,
0.6340894103,
-0.3529306352,
0.6664667726,
-0.7409189343,
-0.5488952994,
-0.5552726388,
0.2175089717,
-0.075111039,
0.3467496932,
0.3652710915,
-0.4319964945,
-0.1614680439,
-0.036465317,
-0.9261105657,
-0.1881828308,
-0.4971860945,
0.0935368165,
0.3163495958,
0.6835864186,
-0.6237971187,
0.5039627552,
0.0962202176,
-0.4562968314,
0.3706904352,
-0.3140216172,
-0.0132338991,
-1.1679333448,
-0.2079399228,
-0.1153669655,
-0.3606909811,
-0.4467874467,
0.0287324656,
-0.1059514508,
0.1523384452,
-0.0104367612,
0.425036788,
-0.2571221292,
-0.0411707163,
-0.2682089806,
0.2294632345,
0.0528017431,
0.3785974085,
0.080163084,
0.6357367039,
0.5508280396,
-0.3203607798,
0.2998532057,
0.5580194592,
-0.2914755642,
0.3425579965,
-0.5300896764,
0.1156979427,
-0.5351987481,
0.3245297372,
-1.1062817574,
-0.4041002691,
0.536038816,
-0.4758175313,
0.2094446868,
0.2602284849,
-0.6829808354,
0.2359196693,
-0.3986985981,
-0.0376237184,
0.3956184387,
-0.5319522023,
0.9416211247,
0.4686675966,
-0.1972394735,
-0.611510098,
-0.9258953929,
0.5256643891,
-0.2192270309,
-0.0491885692,
0.3314914405,
-0.1344122142,
-0.5304942131,
-0.3168357611,
-0.3079690039,
-0.1136384681,
0.1687238663,
0.3753037155,
0.3639781177,
-0.086022675,
0.1371843517,
0.2181221247,
-0.1401752084,
0.2237661332,
-0.1803383976,
0.658449769,
0.2050679177,
-0.1875019521,
-0.63705796,
0.3064650595,
0.4868438244,
0.2033766359,
0.9158754349,
0.4440715611,
-0.4484235942,
-0.2752148211,
-0.5870946646,
-0.3003217578,
-0.4006333351,
0.3244250417,
-0.2831394374,
-0.7267273068,
0.5003799796,
0.1505841911,
0.0539375842,
0.1867346168,
0.6260181069,
-0.2065216899,
1.1357595921,
0.7087947726,
-0.1666574925,
0.2596688569,
0.0622099377,
0.5136771202,
-0.7604754567,
-0.5035687089,
-0.3916049004,
-0.2370186597,
-0.3874354362,
-0.3019943833,
0.1629802436,
0.0650510862,
0.1537440568,
0.1437069774,
-0.4514777362,
0.7764585614,
0.0449503399,
0.0169346873,
0.7533915639,
0.0870472565,
0.1526654512,
-0.1626065969,
-0.3238057792,
-0.7570483088,
0.9354946017,
0.4592150152,
0.8751443028,
0.1395062953,
0.6455045938,
0.5154477954,
0.2070848942,
-1.1594508886,
0.5300180316,
0.1411771029,
-0.4616594315,
-0.3294268548,
-0.4570012093,
-0.6999853253,
0.4494417608,
-0.1980896741,
-1.0242971182,
0.1503613293,
-0.1876497865,
-0.2191638947,
0.5806402564,
-0.5815289021,
0.3397935927,
-0.0331822522,
0.5172761083,
-0.1656825691,
-0.3915246427,
0.4891228974,
-0.2866834402,
0.1755581498,
0.2106140405,
-0.3848012984,
0.6197202802,
-0.2821084857,
1.1255759001,
0.1237576604,
-0.3703157008,
-0.0098761134,
0.3811095953,
0.5291628242,
0.1485023946,
-0.0502838381,
0.2689785659,
0.0925548449,
-0.321312815,
-0.6241874099,
0.6240116954,
-0.7584875226,
-0.5228738189,
-0.6090653539,
-0.6358779669,
-0.217597127,
0.1690149158,
0.2386472225,
0.361764282,
-0.3133893907,
-0.0236461554,
0.9273521304,
-0.31024611,
0.3965643942,
0.2267612219,
-0.3636221886,
-0.4918750226,
0.9278686643,
0.1163254455,
0.1423201561,
0.4229932129,
-0.1234308183,
-0.3510861397,
-0.9524896741,
-0.2280952483,
0.3048847616,
-1.0203771591,
0.0130201066,
-1.1642626524,
-0.2895563841,
-0.7455211282,
-0.1207007393,
0.0489377193,
-0.4218355119,
-0.4161488712,
-0.3800834417,
0.2906050682,
0.9626075625,
0.173598364,
0.5465610027,
-0.7529466152,
0.5957528949,
-0.0344011821,
0.2369285673,
0.2362870425,
-0.7019341588,
-0.2900594771,
-0.2037442476,
-0.214196682,
-0.9452316761,
0.7334282994,
-0.0714429542,
0.449681282,
0.4979827106,
0.2634435892,
0.6411385536,
-0.2800762951,
0.8456261754,
0.0553571396,
-1.2210977077,
0.2709541917,
-0.1147239432,
-0.0250955597,
0.5235587358,
0.2958948314,
-0.6198773384,
-0.6830677986,
-0.5856428742,
-0.6793982983,
0.5161180496,
0.1944340467,
0.3049937487,
0.0311622024,
0.5476891398,
0.2460875064,
0.4141569138,
-0.8558247089,
-0.2603266239,
-0.1597396135,
-0.3074691594,
-0.1620275527,
-0.4670571387,
-0.2265241146,
-0.3381853998,
0.5691194534,
-0.230869174,
0.0438381843,
0.2685621381,
-0.435241729,
-0.1695596427,
-0.0379410051,
0.8449733853,
0.8708782196,
-0.2755473554,
0.1904366463,
0.4019021988,
-0.5658422112,
0.0419676565,
-0.342337966,
-0.072832562,
0.453613162,
0.8251731992,
0.8656767011,
0.130018577,
-0.7781005502,
0.4374424517,
-0.1945039034,
-0.2521935999,
-0.5313842893,
0.2603305876,
-0.2111511827,
0.2219306231,
0.2690674067,
0.0405606963,
0.1092357039,
-0.6854802966,
0.1806968451,
0.1909793615,
-0.3443207741,
-0.2755359113,
0.7037836909,
-0.0179107878,
-0.4661666453,
0.4277237356,
-0.0020755269,
-0.4723725617,
0.4053269625,
0.5810816288,
1.1290214062,
-0.0727468282,
0.3621564806,
0.2282915115,
0.5164115429,
-0.0215513408,
0.1365428418,
-0.0721683279,
-0.6672326922,
-0.555963099,
-0.633667767,
-0.5156044364,
0.3266158402,
-0.8004210591,
0.2478053421,
-0.6161673665,
0.1650269181,
0.0099536823,
-0.2354051322,
-0.0370502882,
0.1317168176,
0.2623085678,
0.7004020214,
-0.9466667175,
0.8694342971,
0.2455589771,
-0.4116600752,
-0.2615639865,
0.5795269012,
0.0182110276,
-0.7323687673,
0.5347847342,
0.1238899827,
-0.0175037738,
0.1137568131,
-0.6135277152,
-0.579131186,
0.7670304775,
0.0615100451,
-0.5565130711,
-0.3754274845,
0.0840752199,
0.5586147904,
-0.5958580375,
0.2747532427,
0.8955680728,
0.4981781542,
0.2903134823,
-0.7210976481,
0.1147928759,
0.1570340097,
-0.0530955791,
-0.0337414257,
-0.3322505057,
0.6836619973,
-0.3803352118,
-0.0778826177,
0.1513817757,
0.5096563697,
0.1148260012,
0.3722082078,
0.5480040908,
0.4333544075,
1.0350044966,
0.012403585,
1.0010709763,
-0.1156343594,
0.2193362713,
1.2058728933,
-0.3563705981,
0.6260893941,
0.4068535864,
0.2579759359,
0.291616261,
0.6663806438,
-0.4256097078,
0.3953855932,
0.1634326279,
-0.1420729309,
-0.2559954822,
-0.1505427361,
-0.2771968544,
0.2451708764,
0.4460232258,
-0.5668673515,
-0.2038667202,
0.1921253651,
0.070809789,
0.0561263263,
-0.2189977318,
1.2515392303,
0.202634871,
-0.2261415273,
0.5745144486,
-0.0162395071,
0.6310786605,
-0.2270162553,
-0.2351143807,
-0.0981436148,
-0.0220220238,
-0.3889062107,
-0.5826452374,
0.6361840367,
0.0387485288,
-0.2240718752,
-0.1431624442,
0.5989384055,
-0.263682127,
-0.564913094,
0.2748277783,
0.534126699,
0.4564605653,
-0.2133904696,
-0.3285324275,
0.2697874606,
0.2689170837,
-0.1230389401,
0.3608876765,
0.5295974016,
0.1362837404,
0.6894748211,
0.7201275826,
0.480989933,
-0.2416358441,
0.1740135998,
0.7864863276,
-1.0678459406,
-0.4047403336,
-1.2208558321,
0.2445814461,
-0.2300601006,
-0.2075739056,
0.7213693261,
0.605124712,
0.7006981969,
-0.0140163004,
0.9238532186,
0.2021917254,
0.4719164371,
-0.4707972109,
0.9564814568,
-0.4735302627,
0.3881565034,
-0.3229058087,
-1.0214534998,
-0.419952482,
0.8285247684,
-0.3369895518,
-0.2194489241,
0.9198050499,
0.8171989322,
0.3086325228,
0.1924806982,
0.5572680235,
0.8374375701,
0.3856275082,
0.0855048969,
0.8943824172,
-0.234687224,
0.5382924676,
0.0291328877,
-0.1521380395,
-0.4673072398,
-0.6528112888,
-1.42973423,
-0.534751296,
-0.2353386283,
-0.6451933384,
-0.2553994656,
0.9253278375,
0.4360384047,
-0.9627882838,
0.0060683195,
-0.0609625541,
0.2530929744,
-0.0454581827,
-0.2438628674,
0.1351236403,
-0.4682270586,
-0.7356211543,
0.4455274642,
0.4090958834,
0.3191251755,
-0.5690082908,
0.2421490103,
0.1587398648,
0.3117902875,
0.6510362029,
-0.2746071815,
-1.0458643436,
-0.1809790134,
-0.1121840179,
-0.0791948065,
0.2172065228,
0.8198516369,
-0.6944796443,
0.4075461328,
0.4003723562,
0.5799356103,
0.3186258376,
0.0218765829,
0.6158883572,
-0.2628221214,
0.1663514525,
0.4310584366,
0.1599379331,
0.0803954452,
-0.7346308231,
0.3526908457,
0.1253954321,
-0.3395706713,
-1.2002851963,
0.136612311,
-1.0700596571,
-0.5367481112,
0.8541098237,
0.0459990986,
-0.3744688928,
-0.4986192286,
-0.6335035563,
0.1718473881,
-0.2785761654,
1.3185292482,
0.9360836148,
-0.2119769603,
-0.1366605461,
-0.6442666054,
0.675927937,
0.3617576659,
-0.8853138089,
0.3539462984,
0.385499835,
0.1838000566,
0.1928346902,
0.3453147411,
0.0053646844,
-0.245733276,
0.0085496679,
-0.1286604404,
-0.1755358726,
-0.3073025644,
-0.6534565687,
0.2294069082,
-0.0289355088,
0.0347468965
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14345v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14345v2
|
Logic-Scaffolding: Personalized Aspect-Instructed Recommendation Explanation Generation using LLMs
| 2023-12-22T00:30:10 | 2024-01-17T22:05:50 |
Behnam Rahdari, Hao Ding, Ziwei Fan, Yifei Ma, Zhuotong Chen, Anoop Deoras, Branislav Kveton
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
The unique capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs), such as the natural
language text generation ability, position them as strong candidates for
providing explanation for recommendations. However, despite the size of the
LLM, most existing models struggle to produce zero-shot explanations reliably.
To address this issue, we propose a framework called Logic-Scaffolding, that
combines the ideas of aspect-based explanation and chain-of-thought prompting
to generate explanations through intermediate reasoning steps. In this paper,
we share our experience in building the framework and present an interactive
demonstration for exploring our results.
|
[
-0.2518965304,
-1.034321785,
1.2503129244,
0.0035628388,
-0.1878986806,
-0.1144294888,
0.244815886,
-0.0160309803,
0.3490141034,
0.8280199766,
-1.1816616058,
-0.6139613986,
-0.0866386145,
-0.1944622695,
-0.5703930855,
1.3912223577,
-0.182611078,
-0.0953779519,
-0.4813570082,
0.0305883531,
-0.7705752254,
-0.2532251477,
-0.5561234355,
-0.8449217677,
0.6500056982,
0.7791380882,
0.4363409877,
0.8836964965,
0.1598065346,
0.2430388927,
-0.0082849143,
-0.0282325223,
-0.1239486337,
0.5439468622,
-0.596920073,
-0.4878278077,
-0.5826556087,
-0.2765725851,
0.3249009252,
0.9354335666,
-0.1812103093,
0.2248443216,
-0.0879719704,
1.0650452375,
-0.4385978281,
-0.1011111438,
-0.5507928729,
0.2228565365,
0.0917161182,
-0.322250098,
-0.3005138934,
-0.2454162836,
0.4000136256,
-0.5975497961,
0.2594295442,
0.487456888,
0.5101600289,
-0.1498766989,
-0.4273201823,
-0.4566920996,
-0.9947534204,
0.6366773248,
-0.4897738397,
0.047231555,
0.2564387918,
0.658030808,
-0.378547281,
-0.655405879,
-0.473924607,
-0.1092689633,
0.1859132946,
-0.1057686433,
0.0117833279,
0.1717958897,
0.2643511295,
0.6126417518,
-0.4051197469,
-0.1488900781,
-0.2052351385,
-0.2253596485,
0.5598472953,
0.3013203442,
-0.0886483639,
-0.1193175912,
-0.3483573794,
0.3380018771,
-1.0409455299,
0.0832821801,
0.4081965983,
0.1445695013,
-0.0588696599,
0.868804574,
-0.7157962918,
0.9195230603,
0.4518850446,
-0.1410097927,
0.0446847565,
-0.4390889704,
-0.4330657125,
0.2609543502,
0.436955601,
0.6060760617,
-0.0448304303,
-0.0225980468,
-0.1299555451,
-0.0599930249,
0.0804905668,
-0.7356347442,
-0.1208810806,
0.700653255,
-0.543196857,
-0.5015482903,
-0.1521727294,
-0.4810425043,
-0.5685764551,
-0.531619966,
0.4075159132,
-0.564509511,
-0.0483135767,
0.3258379996,
-0.1462540329,
-0.0941694677,
0.3761232793,
-0.8172008395,
0.2078940123,
0.45851776,
0.6369556189,
-0.0541995391,
-0.1623726785,
-0.724676609,
0.6403301954,
-0.1502623558,
1.1556670666,
-0.5182542205,
-0.197463721,
0.2501029372,
-0.0616154335,
0.485461235,
-0.2730669677,
0.2526424229,
-0.0880658552,
0.4496257901,
-0.4344287217,
-0.8144610524,
-0.5119103789,
0.4514001906,
-0.2118844241,
0.7746875882,
0.1222818345,
-0.5908893943,
0.4333704114,
-0.8673585653,
-0.4616173208,
0.0984483436,
-0.4713445902,
-0.1150514185,
0.1744668782,
0.4223467112,
0.698636651,
-0.4296201468,
0.4812422991,
-0.3145096302,
-0.3670286536,
0.2957529724,
-0.2320331633,
0.2407236844,
0.0996611491,
-0.4849478602,
0.7029466629,
-0.6724609137,
-0.2309031487,
0.3147417605,
-0.0558592826,
-0.0968529955,
0.246850282,
-0.4949523211,
0.2001832873,
0.364587605,
-0.2789847851,
0.0819158703,
-0.5718879104,
0.4820253551,
0.9047393203,
0.3554193676,
0.6715360284,
-0.6799273491,
0.6501594186,
0.3209238946,
0.0362144858,
-0.9332433343,
-0.3045881093,
-0.8329179287,
0.1764469743,
-0.132991299,
0.1534862518,
-0.9825932384,
0.3859425485,
0.00842884,
-0.216268599,
-0.1511712968,
0.312633723,
0.4737740159,
0.5249183178,
0.1640037596,
-0.1060215756,
-0.4842994809,
-1.2492178679,
-0.3705878854,
-0.2553041577,
-0.2142457217,
0.2370779067,
0.4563788176,
0.0329262204,
1.1249396801,
-0.5921339989,
-0.1031796783,
-0.6417404413,
-0.1220118031,
0.4009012282,
0.191510886,
0.4494690895,
-0.4150835574,
0.0134567078,
-0.2932162881,
-0.6158890724,
-0.0852021202,
-0.3264757097,
-0.3388849199,
-0.2217697501,
0.4823729992,
-0.1532574892,
0.3974612653,
0.3338445127,
-0.5837762952,
0.7832790017,
-0.3588818312,
-0.0217492934,
-1.3486062288,
-0.4373281598,
0.1916706562,
-0.3050390184,
-0.44935745,
0.0470034406,
-0.4553850591,
-0.1796531975,
-0.4312575161,
0.5448470116,
-0.2661297321,
-0.0685727373,
-0.3590912819,
0.5861515403,
0.1572363824,
0.7287843227,
-0.1621322334,
0.2936367989,
0.5431598425,
-0.6565276384,
0.3798913062,
0.0456950851,
-0.1383714676,
0.8948833346,
-0.7481803298,
0.1240768954,
-0.1054531187,
0.5308302045,
-0.9496893287,
-0.6073696613,
0.3400554359,
0.2167984992,
-0.3630406857,
-0.341827184,
-0.3417792022,
-0.370057106,
-0.5703456998,
0.2198498249,
0.1725838929,
-0.6536340714,
0.7637609839,
0.1115733385,
-0.1006224379,
-0.0442961678,
-0.4848142862,
-0.1144219041,
-0.3117574155,
-0.6012094021,
0.6331116557,
-0.4447616935,
-0.3905379474,
0.0009175764,
-0.3108632565,
0.2741919756,
0.0361325927,
0.8668742776,
0.1624873877,
-0.1883587837,
0.2027768195,
0.492549181,
-0.1080785245,
0.2327158004,
-0.5392848849,
0.5768629313,
-0.2495626658,
-0.8243486881,
-0.4911566377,
0.6150954366,
0.3544677198,
0.0573831461,
0.6091217399,
0.2936441302,
-0.292206198,
-0.3425779045,
-0.5804828405,
-0.1460163891,
-0.5209465027,
0.1543793827,
-0.5431656837,
-0.9593952298,
0.3317901194,
-0.338234067,
0.3218407631,
0.3271090388,
0.7168857455,
-0.0908847749,
1.1941426992,
0.7429141402,
0.244419381,
0.6775731444,
-0.0828025043,
0.3618090451,
-0.7976129651,
-0.4235556424,
-0.192334801,
-0.1884231567,
-0.1806458831,
-0.2314691991,
0.1715068072,
0.3937745988,
-0.5542085767,
0.0745932385,
-0.6575292349,
0.6377470493,
0.7659577131,
0.1990713626,
0.3697070777,
0.3606361449,
-0.4655151367,
0.2429636568,
-0.733225286,
-0.8123973012,
0.8883540034,
0.342615068,
0.4882091582,
-0.0539877452,
0.6419014931,
0.3797044158,
0.2135703266,
-0.9310795665,
0.7260766029,
0.0234340802,
-0.593496263,
-0.1496479958,
0.0836654082,
-0.5492115617,
0.1068311185,
-0.5163644552,
-0.9752085805,
-0.1998707652,
0.3490539193,
-0.5662168264,
0.1722408533,
-0.5239322782,
0.4931811988,
-0.2521695793,
-0.332655102,
-0.3678771555,
-0.2383195311,
0.4409455061,
0.0915314779,
0.2719858885,
-0.2223090976,
0.2762289941,
0.7728467584,
-0.6690642238,
0.7659886479,
-0.1324635893,
0.0684807971,
0.3168400526,
0.5670243502,
0.4164811969,
-0.0081699602,
-0.4613039196,
-0.156076327,
-0.1582461149,
-0.2595772147,
-0.805116713,
0.7571033835,
-0.2531816363,
-1.0380671024,
-0.1258666813,
-0.7005059719,
-0.1963592768,
0.1192682534,
-0.0282717235,
0.6133006215,
0.0182000007,
0.2389933765,
0.4721053243,
-0.2699895501,
0.3678764105,
0.5624715686,
-0.8153001666,
-0.4681824446,
0.8180350661,
-0.1827988327,
0.0388320833,
0.1521761864,
0.3719543219,
-0.1047952026,
-0.8610643148,
-0.6247745156,
0.1232719421,
-0.8534246087,
0.0461393707,
-0.4058956206,
-0.1239004582,
-0.1736990958,
-0.5852557421,
0.0573063381,
-0.5596449971,
0.1076534539,
-0.4254168272,
0.579323709,
1.2344424725,
0.3398326337,
0.7343616486,
-0.4202524722,
0.2689627707,
0.1950327605,
0.2587412,
0.0932065472,
-0.3169394135,
-0.444424808,
0.15692617,
-0.5968706012,
-0.8369950056,
-0.0412470363,
-0.0981687978,
0.5119127035,
0.8863027692,
-0.0575967878,
0.6836470366,
-0.6801145673,
1.1946719885,
0.5572776198,
-1.0123118162,
1.1193829775,
-0.4839737415,
0.3581056595,
0.4418138564,
0.1605560035,
-0.3866853714,
-0.4017077386,
-0.7405399084,
-1.0628659725,
0.709648788,
0.2554119229,
-0.0542839617,
0.0178397708,
0.8785048127,
0.3408834636,
0.2803803384,
-0.6338019967,
-0.2782556415,
0.0609977841,
-0.3626288772,
0.147665903,
-0.4893068075,
-0.3866651654,
-0.0229634549,
0.7713184953,
-0.3728795946,
0.1792127937,
0.2163289487,
0.0415379144,
-0.2303391099,
0.2347201258,
0.6095700264,
0.9155184031,
-0.0139484648,
0.1171046272,
0.1227871031,
0.0999136791,
0.1940881461,
-0.2570478916,
-0.0783827975,
-0.1558315158,
0.537905395,
1.0158927441,
0.0983676016,
-0.5827483535,
0.4547042847,
0.0387970731,
-0.546661973,
-0.3558325469,
0.3915861249,
0.3398558497,
0.3404816389,
0.373924017,
-0.1994485557,
0.0223900359,
-0.5941528678,
0.0533128567,
0.1607546806,
-0.5273040533,
-0.2632917464,
0.6488164067,
0.3633260727,
-0.6611538529,
0.1782802045,
-0.0249094516,
-0.2894106209,
0.3756348789,
0.5393702388,
1.0069038868,
0.1084131449,
0.5446971655,
-0.1397684216,
-0.0460684896,
-0.0047868541,
0.2252057493,
-0.4277460277,
-0.6673110723,
-0.4213163555,
-0.6732968688,
-0.6860732436,
0.0370496064,
-0.6340453625,
0.2075159401,
-0.6679268479,
0.2086997032,
0.2902436852,
-0.2195998132,
-0.6679887772,
0.2180946469,
-0.0572137013,
0.8636495471,
-0.8865340948,
0.650603652,
0.8735840321,
-0.6245921254,
-0.9420740008,
0.2589088082,
0.1795209944,
-0.7050427198,
0.5293992758,
0.1726376414,
-0.4716817737,
-0.5168590546,
-0.4999526739,
-0.5277280807,
1.3305802345,
0.4662869871,
-0.679038167,
-0.0173774213,
0.1849397868,
0.5299759507,
-0.9936458468,
0.2427422404,
0.3853833377,
0.2547920644,
0.2950981855,
-0.2990804017,
0.4706538618,
0.0268490333,
0.1182696298,
-0.2356634885,
-0.2880723476,
0.5253769159,
-0.2072236091,
0.2834737897,
0.0742728487,
0.8615532517,
0.7149626017,
0.5348396897,
0.8332929611,
0.1619692892,
0.5238814354,
0.0522180162,
1.0810443163,
-0.5735653043,
-0.184299469,
1.5198204517,
-0.3424843252,
0.7555754185,
0.7274089456,
0.0991812423,
1.2999541759,
1.0057837963,
0.3897213936,
0.4085412323,
0.2041237652,
-0.2570231259,
-0.4289126098,
-0.4025375247,
-0.0909282342,
0.0562247932,
0.326428026,
-0.6604363322,
-0.1813725829,
0.1227096468,
-0.2757340968,
-0.0225057248,
-0.3208353817,
0.8154975772,
0.121729821,
-0.766706109,
-0.0228382796,
0.0483542606,
0.317895472,
-0.4571003616,
-0.2984472513,
-0.3036949039,
0.1027097255,
-0.2943488955,
-1.0806411505,
0.1219514608,
0.0521781929,
-0.6135938764,
-0.5563000441,
0.7149341106,
-0.3397983015,
-0.4972591698,
0.1776821315,
0.5841521025,
0.316157639,
0.0219112728,
-0.7965979576,
-0.2410677522,
0.2219950259,
-0.4169938564,
0.3472410142,
0.6218501925,
-0.2321217507,
0.8644449711,
0.7506619692,
-0.0795927569,
-0.5325886607,
0.2209035158,
0.8986950517,
-0.7465527058,
-0.611340642,
-0.9551939964,
0.5928122997,
-0.1730403602,
-0.1185684726,
0.6641098261,
0.420694381,
0.6071653366,
0.0953597128,
0.7211229801,
0.0984932855,
0.2747353911,
-0.6753917336,
0.2729946077,
-0.6150379181,
0.8478557467,
-0.1640264839,
-1.0280015469,
-0.113027364,
0.3791159987,
-0.3095499575,
0.1407884508,
0.9266002178,
0.7352970243,
-0.028064752,
0.2863651216,
0.2702339888,
0.2270317972,
0.4508062303,
0.3409752846,
0.5901033878,
-0.0217280965,
0.48813802,
-0.3217736781,
-0.1956124008,
-0.2906808555,
-1.3656206131,
-1.1586546898,
-0.6081602573,
-0.502632916,
-0.6345035434,
0.2157291174,
1.1208252907,
0.842869103,
-0.7645632625,
-0.2851383984,
-0.4516919553,
0.4577020705,
-0.3249466419,
-0.2164681703,
0.2809924185,
0.082543239,
-0.3587163389,
0.6795800328,
0.6040917039,
-0.1287542433,
-0.7670819759,
0.0242096502,
0.0022349164,
0.3344377279,
0.7057674527,
-0.2369954139,
-0.9481716156,
-0.5583041906,
-0.3220933974,
0.4481703639,
-0.0876245797,
1.1382006407,
-0.9821323752,
0.3618987203,
0.504052639,
0.2525678873,
0.6095727086,
-0.1181721762,
1.167173624,
-0.6517683268,
-0.0592456497,
-0.2261370122,
0.5409579277,
0.2969893515,
-0.4433660507,
0.3909820914,
-0.0238300171,
-0.3600952625,
-0.680437088,
0.5700402856,
-0.9121426344,
-0.3893381357,
1.1707998514,
-0.3213695288,
-0.4051620662,
-0.1446142495,
-0.4570555389,
0.1230253726,
-0.4846453965,
0.6536797881,
0.8191697598,
-0.6169212461,
0.119942911,
-0.305101037,
0.2319312096,
0.5250073671,
-0.7607296705,
0.0491287112,
0.4445691705,
0.5562217832,
-0.0763556808,
0.6069173217,
0.2359607518,
0.1370025873,
-0.1406394392,
-0.0600107424,
-0.3965522051,
-0.3883552849,
-0.4980168641,
0.1938723624,
0.1295487434,
0.0046329885
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14335v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14335v2
|
Context-aware Decoding Reduces Hallucination in Query-focused Summarization
| 2023-12-21T23:42:13 | 2023-12-31T22:31:48 |
Zhichao Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Query-focused summarization (QFS) aims to provide a summary of a single
document/multi documents that can satisfy the information needs of a given
query. It is useful for various real-world applications, such as abstractive
snippet generation or more recent retrieval augmented generation (RAG). A
prototypical QFS pipeline consists of a retriever (sparse or dense retrieval)
and a generator (usually a large language model). However, applying large
language models (LLM) potentially leads to hallucinations, especially when the
evidence contradicts the prior belief of LLMs. There has been growing interest
in developing new decoding methods to improve generation quality and reduce
hallucination. In this work, we conduct a large-scale reproducibility study on
one recently proposed decoding method -- Context-aware Decoding (CAD). In
addition to replicating CAD's experiments on news summarization datasets, we
include experiments on QFS datasets, and conduct more rigorous analysis on
computational complexity and hyperparameter sensitivity. Experiments with eight
different language models show that performance-wise, CAD improves QFS quality
by (1) reducing factuality errors/hallucinations while (2) mostly retaining the
match of lexical patterns, measured by ROUGE scores, while also at a cost of
increased inference-time FLOPs and reduced decoding speed. The code
implementation based on Huggingface Library is made available
https://github.com/zhichaoxu-shufe/context-aware-decoding-qfs
|
[
-0.4668131173,
-0.8282712698,
0.41010952,
0.5420264602,
-0.590380609,
-0.0939915329,
-0.1640198082,
-0.4437763691,
0.3676746488,
0.6209185123,
-0.3564164042,
-0.7497469187,
-0.3565565944,
0.3984346688,
-0.632653594,
0.9629925489,
0.1012374982,
-0.0674470514,
-0.4273765385,
-0.1862272024,
-0.2349458486,
-0.842666328,
-0.3660034537,
0.0922486112,
0.2759124041,
0.1110117063,
0.6399761438,
0.4622411728,
0.2462334931,
0.1572894752,
-0.2909395397,
0.3300356865,
-0.7015898228,
0.3821050227,
0.1282861531,
-0.1880331188,
-0.5197916627,
-0.407487005,
0.6582265496,
0.7370339632,
-0.2048052698,
-0.2251362801,
0.2750020027,
0.7296465635,
-0.8927774429,
0.1587249786,
-0.3848463893,
-0.0874511451,
0.214678511,
-0.62277174,
-0.5288484693,
-0.3754674792,
0.0354014635,
-0.6102113128,
0.4799728096,
-0.0205879305,
0.5960569382,
0.1757882237,
-0.4358633161,
-0.3057712317,
-0.4715346098,
0.5392464995,
-0.7273411155,
0.6537336111,
0.6169314981,
0.131720975,
-0.3300927877,
-0.6506889462,
-0.5639347434,
0.0877763852,
-0.3222106993,
0.1495180875,
0.1507762671,
0.1290203929,
0.2923208177,
0.490617156,
-0.7509860396,
-0.4831905365,
-0.068125248,
-0.4588994086,
0.5684559941,
0.3225396574,
0.057833083,
-0.3891955316,
-0.0647019222,
-0.1439767778,
-0.6470589042,
0.0246265382,
-0.0971544906,
0.2423308641,
-0.0953948796,
0.3298590481,
-0.6620332599,
0.563272953,
0.085150741,
-0.142471984,
0.2563676536,
-0.6078635454,
-0.2755671442,
0.1260569841,
0.5414189696,
0.5440710187,
-0.0107238162,
-0.4352794588,
-0.2037171423,
-0.3241869807,
0.074860096,
-1.1154510975,
-0.2413447946,
0.4401073158,
-0.4601390958,
-0.1654788852,
0.1252565086,
-0.5386916995,
-0.4087987244,
-0.216280669,
0.2749519348,
-0.5555539727,
-0.3153159916,
0.2063867152,
-0.2233046293,
0.5088118315,
0.4509983957,
-0.746931076,
0.1781581342,
0.6471837759,
0.9958547354,
-0.1914779991,
-0.267095238,
-0.8463279009,
0.2124934047,
-0.3254304826,
0.8118228316,
-0.1682946831,
-0.7100925446,
-0.1425803453,
0.1952212602,
-0.0668053851,
-0.6425653696,
0.5319677591,
-0.5148486495,
0.0787957236,
-0.7469397783,
-0.4146147966,
-0.1809063554,
0.1871441901,
-0.6837140322,
0.8118783236,
0.1995480508,
-0.8791791201,
0.319817245,
-0.1141593531,
-0.7301382422,
-0.0723775923,
-0.2476308793,
-0.371494323,
0.4458661377,
0.3634883463,
0.474963069,
0.0154421283,
0.1660449505,
-0.0803508759,
-0.8426347375,
0.0408054776,
-0.1417596936,
0.7652337551,
0.1026516035,
-0.3850738704,
0.4097627103,
-0.5349824429,
-0.1179421693,
0.0750599056,
-0.1386804283,
-0.4119085371,
-0.0270804521,
0.2595139146,
0.11235369,
-0.2392787933,
-0.2086634934,
0.0616032816,
-0.468906641,
0.2365384102,
0.4454197288,
0.165442273,
0.3379740715,
-0.3103195131,
0.4478781223,
0.0820891038,
-0.1717288643,
-0.4598789215,
-0.1825098544,
-0.2675453424,
-0.3959983587,
0.2123445421,
0.2543283105,
-0.9098213911,
0.2946234643,
-0.2839527726,
-0.0538270026,
-0.3072753847,
-0.1149817929,
0.2870225608,
0.5781282187,
0.2937247455,
-0.2627754807,
-0.425473094,
-0.5435374379,
-0.0428742133,
0.0674066097,
-0.0649659708,
0.2938533127,
0.3590207696,
-0.1798320711,
0.9012928009,
-0.425765574,
-0.2555783987,
-0.3478704095,
-0.0760648772,
-0.1814723909,
0.4840525091,
0.5824001431,
-0.7946289182,
-0.153047055,
-0.2899774015,
-0.8330435753,
0.1060944274,
-0.2230049521,
-0.271207571,
0.5458185673,
0.6249133348,
-0.7219389677,
0.5919958949,
0.4219489396,
-0.5096462369,
0.8534221649,
-0.2018627226,
0.3569570184,
-1.1051799059,
0.1656310558,
-0.4389958084,
-0.2446240634,
-0.4278808534,
0.168606475,
0.2150156498,
0.0315607078,
-0.2210648954,
0.337973386,
-0.6317662001,
-0.2964933217,
-0.5288689733,
0.2217043042,
0.3012617826,
0.5226009488,
0.3232367337,
1.0586160421,
0.4466264248,
-0.6901054382,
-0.173161909,
0.3058824241,
-0.3134747148,
0.348596096,
-0.7501606345,
0.0127541982,
-0.3446319997,
0.5033833385,
-0.9040091634,
-0.4052653313,
0.0439145304,
-0.4942567945,
0.1460967809,
0.2721089125,
-0.4768792987,
0.1223375127,
-0.5764560103,
0.6719247103,
0.2261711508,
-0.7158681154,
0.5725352168,
0.2802928686,
0.043944452,
-0.5106307268,
-0.6480821371,
0.1506782919,
-0.0650068745,
-0.4776954353,
0.4282506108,
-0.1488528252,
-0.0065058046,
-0.1000861973,
-0.3682058454,
0.1408340335,
0.1830369234,
0.2424253821,
-0.1193298325,
-0.1364143342,
-0.0030966664,
0.3790142834,
0.0937850997,
0.3156754076,
-0.073309049,
0.5194598436,
-0.1463783681,
-0.0682726949,
-0.5287141204,
0.5534127951,
0.803465724,
-0.3934431374,
0.9689860344,
0.6431549788,
-0.4921840727,
-0.3170292675,
-0.3163720965,
-0.5341770649,
-0.4150773287,
0.3909981549,
-0.5822395086,
-1.0775355101,
0.8165018559,
0.106292963,
-0.0977446511,
0.1939133257,
0.471110642,
0.138463825,
1.2192667723,
0.5516041517,
-0.0904378667,
0.2492281049,
-0.2874728143,
0.240916729,
-1.0334534645,
-0.3077598214,
-0.3331677318,
0.1921562552,
-0.3697669804,
-0.2612863779,
0.3221573234,
0.3421025574,
0.2556529939,
0.1012151912,
-0.4868294597,
0.4493807554,
0.2622994483,
0.1495781541,
0.5554679632,
0.16572541,
0.0193930119,
0.1612024903,
-0.7552495599,
-0.2271142453,
0.9474910498,
0.0122789601,
0.5292750001,
0.1860223711,
0.6926742792,
0.3766213059,
0.0226642583,
-0.8210232258,
0.5392261744,
0.2066245526,
-0.2089452446,
-0.3483899534,
-0.5365546346,
-0.8457475305,
0.5635296106,
-0.2065822184,
-0.5799629092,
0.4212701321,
0.1459425241,
-0.4997298121,
-0.0267436896,
-0.4036592841,
0.7185854316,
0.2729545832,
-0.5046635866,
-0.1964778006,
-0.4686921537,
0.5733345747,
0.1262560487,
0.0897422954,
0.2107340544,
0.2628021836,
0.5854658484,
-0.4211491644,
0.368619889,
-0.1032189131,
-0.4178610444,
0.2546393871,
0.2122876346,
0.5603550076,
0.3794385493,
-0.0876691416,
0.0579964183,
0.2787009776,
-0.4858855307,
-0.6348723769,
0.7858135104,
-0.4096215963,
-0.6587939858,
-0.3861443102,
-0.7987043262,
-0.1831461787,
0.1185854599,
0.5528337359,
0.7126741409,
-0.2392386645,
0.4518589377,
0.863183558,
-0.1781277061,
0.3720877171,
0.1103993729,
-0.3890047669,
-0.3560776412,
0.7630315423,
0.0034968059,
0.08698681,
0.2246926278,
-0.1931995153,
-0.2380520701,
-0.7909716964,
-0.4333029389,
0.2564919591,
-0.6533789635,
-0.1798349619,
-0.9046524763,
-0.1616439521,
-0.7711766958,
-0.2173411995,
-0.1829976737,
-0.3972737789,
-0.2012112141,
-0.0901588947,
0.2439310998,
0.3190785646,
0.1559381485,
0.2517725229,
-0.6134823561,
0.4898886085,
0.0594429076,
0.359154582,
0.1492201984,
-0.460249871,
-0.4962510765,
0.0230113473,
0.1718436629,
-0.969481945,
0.4964798689,
-0.0080470107,
0.3699374199,
0.419793427,
0.5299350619,
0.6326429248,
0.0965041295,
0.6342386007,
-0.2964674234,
-0.9923958182,
0.3733706772,
-0.424756974,
0.5867304802,
0.6043913364,
-0.0425105989,
-0.3593310118,
-0.5057004094,
-0.1477911919,
-0.8657722473,
0.730451107,
0.3923957944,
0.0749010444,
-0.2414812297,
0.5319222808,
0.0849133432,
0.1346853077,
-0.2667210996,
-0.0551243164,
-0.4125029445,
-0.0530008525,
-0.0849969164,
-0.4766656756,
-0.0227974597,
-0.3094688058,
0.4843982756,
-0.2795774341,
0.2020719796,
0.6626818776,
-0.4484017193,
0.0408122465,
0.1386948377,
1.0106343031,
0.7224638462,
-0.5449492335,
0.275303036,
0.0805889294,
-0.6362684965,
-0.1624011397,
-0.0198265221,
-0.2691572905,
0.2561173141,
0.3137407005,
0.7170857787,
0.0464244001,
-0.8745776415,
0.503072083,
-0.4250259697,
-0.2548056841,
-0.2140357047,
0.0735069886,
0.0276489314,
0.172935918,
0.5399553776,
-0.3153608739,
0.5532002449,
-0.4633971751,
0.2737356126,
0.4874177873,
-0.0908794031,
-0.3589350283,
0.6823116541,
0.1358623505,
0.0976637453,
0.6444986463,
-0.3409879208,
-0.3775736094,
0.5950793624,
0.684540987,
0.9357153773,
-0.0984529927,
0.1703523546,
0.5496903658,
0.1630510241,
-0.1748119593,
0.1861514449,
-0.606348455,
-0.4957550764,
-0.3859860003,
-0.591658175,
-0.2502328157,
0.1205884293,
-0.9547248483,
-0.1183162928,
-0.2966396213,
-0.059629377,
-0.4064042866,
-0.1357828379,
-0.1428844035,
0.1268322915,
-0.1777371168,
0.8271433711,
-0.4580881,
0.7939199209,
0.4480444193,
-0.1551941037,
-0.5159981847,
0.4811370671,
-0.1351071894,
-0.1545400918,
0.0744771287,
0.392375201,
-0.4209617376,
0.093719095,
-0.2982342839,
-0.7575695515,
1.2352181673,
0.2164491117,
-0.4357962012,
-0.0410903506,
-0.1803607643,
0.3587570786,
-0.539444685,
0.0319521762,
0.7199898958,
0.0565771349,
0.0603438132,
-0.684604764,
0.5369869471,
-0.2785287201,
0.0707088485,
0.0350043029,
-0.4719049335,
0.6082085967,
-0.4831508398,
-0.4739016593,
0.0678599104,
0.9396471977,
0.5025967956,
0.5979210734,
0.2402481437,
0.2542254925,
0.730003953,
-0.0078681391,
1.1429202557,
-0.572070837,
0.2869166732,
1.150526166,
-0.1362922043,
0.7165587544,
0.5291827321,
0.3017338812,
0.3612066805,
0.4912707508,
0.3493383527,
0.6825866103,
-0.06926658,
-0.247816965,
-0.1309818923,
-0.0660935417,
-0.673197329,
0.3136300147,
0.2551434338,
-0.2436913401,
-0.2180377394,
0.2418725044,
0.0679808334,
0.1194190383,
-0.1879281253,
0.8662496209,
-0.0497648753,
-0.6095712781,
1.0415837765,
-0.0108127724,
0.6011800766,
-0.2149286568,
-0.0133870812,
-0.6019386649,
-0.043304313,
-0.3495993018,
-0.4376736879,
0.5254369378,
-0.1961102933,
-0.3206100166,
0.0892966539,
0.4715586901,
-0.4671274424,
-0.1910346001,
0.298664093,
0.5202587247,
0.141222164,
-0.5467126966,
-0.173749879,
0.3546349108,
-0.086798735,
-0.4772937,
0.3797781169,
0.4155251384,
-0.2125589848,
0.3880020082,
0.5942867994,
-0.1590851843,
-0.2022658885,
0.2655627131,
0.981526494,
-0.8991038203,
-0.7339505553,
-0.6491153836,
0.2431288213,
0.036728885,
-0.1126945093,
0.9208705425,
0.7895797491,
0.829952538,
-0.0978084356,
0.602044642,
0.2313421518,
0.1546518505,
-0.566835463,
0.9415195584,
-0.5296291709,
0.3843562901,
-0.314786762,
-0.9150782228,
-0.3857807219,
0.5717398524,
-0.0125957932,
0.1049357355,
0.6684806347,
1.0087362528,
0.1279104352,
0.0893715769,
0.3550709784,
0.1076045781,
0.1001547053,
0.3459160626,
0.5226987004,
-0.4704572856,
0.4254401922,
-0.4232973456,
-0.137648508,
-0.4993624687,
-0.5482183695,
-0.9815259576,
-0.6823430061,
-0.3153531551,
-0.6578464508,
0.2340188026,
0.6357827783,
0.6299867034,
-0.8303948045,
-0.1984967738,
-0.2662872374,
0.2596905529,
-0.3359934986,
-0.2743408382,
0.7794258595,
-0.2466109246,
-0.5650363564,
0.2097398043,
0.2595486045,
0.0095992908,
-0.0150210597,
-0.303943336,
0.0925619826,
0.1377948821,
1.0609699488,
0.2268101573,
-0.7294510603,
-0.0886213779,
0.3331905901,
-0.2490128577,
0.0214667171,
0.911211133,
-0.9918298125,
0.406745255,
0.681371212,
0.5669639111,
0.5444649458,
0.4077949226,
0.4351943433,
-0.4819203913,
0.1727009714,
0.0901838318,
0.1630153805,
0.2759654224,
-0.6753582954,
0.2794643044,
0.2733073831,
-0.3172394633,
-1.0751060247,
-0.0388918445,
-1.1390275955,
-0.522061348,
0.9842064977,
0.1158559099,
-0.3717305958,
-0.1134685054,
-0.320563674,
0.2005423456,
-0.4243433177,
1.0703142881,
0.4872264266,
-0.2189596891,
-0.3987359703,
-0.2878901064,
0.9081373811,
0.586871326,
-0.7512982488,
0.4995521307,
0.7501484752,
0.1049780399,
-0.1737915725,
0.776673913,
-0.2391350269,
0.6353871822,
-0.0966892615,
-0.0180793703,
-0.3270418644,
-0.4064648449,
-0.6032953858,
0.5408727527,
-0.1624923944,
0.0450614393
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14327v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14327v1
|
Parameter Efficient Tuning Allows Scalable Personalization of LLMs for Text Entry: A Case Study on Abbreviation Expansion
| 2023-12-21T22:52:44 | 2023-12-21T22:52:44 |
Katrin Tomanek, Shanqing Cai, Subhashini Venugopalan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Abbreviation expansion is a strategy used to speed up communication by
limiting the amount of typing and using a language model to suggest expansions.
Here we look at personalizing a Large Language Model's (LLM) suggestions based
on prior conversations to enhance the relevance of predictions, particularly
when the user data is small (~1000 samples). Specifically, we compare
fine-tuning, prompt-tuning, and retrieval augmented generation of expanded text
suggestions for abbreviated inputs. Our case study with a deployed 8B parameter
LLM on a real user living with ALS, and experiments on movie character
personalization indicates that (1) customization may be necessary in some
scenarios and prompt-tuning generalizes well to those, (2) fine-tuning on
in-domain data (with as few as 600 samples) still shows some gains, however (3)
retrieval augmented few-shot selection also outperforms fine-tuning. (4)
Parameter efficient tuning allows for efficient and scalable personalization.
For prompt-tuning, we also find that initializing the learned "soft-prompts" to
user relevant concept tokens leads to higher accuracy than random
initialization.
|
[
-0.5929495096,
-0.9872865677,
0.8016111851,
-0.0575102605,
-0.3419446647,
0.1856798679,
-0.4580539465,
-0.3807855844,
0.2839157283,
0.364785105,
-0.5441883802,
-0.5059903264,
-0.4928111136,
0.2952735126,
-0.091818288,
0.8943340182,
0.1063994318,
-0.1046636999,
0.0576429702,
-0.2380293608,
-0.6179839373,
-0.4718903899,
-1.0778069496,
0.2037426233,
1.0563191175,
0.6554665565,
0.7470705509,
1.0901402235,
0.6943007112,
0.3295912147,
-0.3980655968,
0.571542263,
-0.3909349442,
0.3973279297,
-0.0241829772,
-0.4655126333,
-0.4100579917,
-0.2458477914,
0.6800569296,
0.7928039432,
-0.0234113857,
0.1847709268,
-0.124717921,
0.5327475071,
-0.3914724588,
-0.2074250728,
-0.6106444001,
-0.1869242936,
-0.3791186213,
-0.5664770007,
-0.2387453914,
-0.361843586,
0.153655529,
-0.5771636367,
0.218057394,
0.5133186579,
0.6590762734,
0.2307002395,
-0.2541087568,
-0.4852871895,
-0.859159708,
0.6538437605,
-0.7165976167,
0.3420874476,
0.2162752748,
0.4500277042,
-0.1344537884,
-0.654469192,
-0.225348562,
-0.3860578239,
-0.0454511233,
-0.2692781985,
-0.1611435562,
0.4430575371,
0.5196020603,
0.2881060541,
-0.3532487154,
0.3895796835,
-0.2863907516,
-0.3451351225,
0.4892320931,
0.3378090262,
0.2003227919,
0.2369521856,
0.0422660969,
0.1448396891,
-0.6895589232,
0.0710319653,
0.5866129398,
0.6126539111,
0.0738533735,
0.6362105012,
-0.6577546,
1.2300877571,
0.4125365615,
-0.0565959029,
-0.0090557598,
-0.4527385533,
0.06085933,
-0.1000233665,
0.4266013205,
0.2961739302,
0.3273801804,
-0.2832468748,
-0.2452884614,
-0.4199265838,
-0.0055487701,
-0.8541160226,
0.0717443749,
0.0481329337,
-0.495325774,
-0.1686523557,
-0.0430152006,
-0.4186641276,
-0.4760951996,
-0.3802817464,
0.2807311118,
-0.4463338256,
0.3602204323,
-0.0947748125,
-0.1317114681,
-0.1712120026,
0.4413563311,
-1.1992752552,
-0.0421513245,
0.4910830557,
0.9016048908,
-0.4689088762,
-0.1220786721,
-0.9975605011,
0.1009003446,
-0.3428857028,
0.9902823567,
-0.9533125758,
-0.5069532394,
0.0137254354,
-0.4544988871,
0.3100482523,
-0.6581454277,
0.36714077,
-0.8492892981,
0.0286466219,
-0.3389832079,
-0.6375225186,
0.1365868896,
0.0032961068,
-0.4261464775,
0.7274131775,
0.0528709441,
-0.3876744211,
0.6506111026,
-0.7320411801,
-0.3098066449,
0.2744796574,
-0.2562415898,
-0.0718280897,
0.4419818819,
0.2457751781,
0.5604367852,
-0.1956026554,
0.0959900916,
-0.3736336529,
-0.6389278173,
0.1474250108,
-0.3562658131,
0.0207509547,
0.3714554012,
0.1814313978,
0.2636166811,
-0.8520438671,
0.0403002687,
-0.3416432142,
-0.6139829159,
-0.3754549623,
-0.1573012322,
-0.2410902381,
-0.1588814557,
0.5764091015,
-0.3019608259,
0.4282221496,
-0.6522231698,
0.1995229423,
0.6736708879,
0.2670427263,
0.6105325818,
-0.46388641,
0.6370809674,
0.0178145915,
-0.2393584996,
-0.6827942133,
-0.4625422955,
-0.6974924803,
-0.5026392341,
0.6019868255,
0.3375400007,
-0.575935781,
0.478482157,
-0.0549921431,
-0.2907221317,
-0.4522750676,
0.2585982978,
0.1452658623,
0.4997453392,
0.2780464888,
-0.028029304,
-0.4136002958,
-1.0479210615,
-0.70208323,
-0.1089426428,
-0.4423052669,
0.8201019764,
-0.0745989308,
-0.2245458364,
1.0552690029,
-0.7781860232,
-0.0292299893,
-0.3090060353,
0.1186912283,
0.410754621,
0.1289076358,
0.2853261828,
-0.5010533929,
-0.692661047,
0.0004509556,
-0.2446332425,
-0.2316871434,
-0.3693476319,
0.0643636137,
-0.0657141879,
0.5236160159,
-0.4001370966,
0.1895123571,
0.1788662821,
-0.3515437245,
0.3905317187,
-0.6267995834,
0.0610182472,
-1.2070364952,
-0.1464554071,
0.0906367004,
-0.2880892158,
-0.6445214152,
0.0974179655,
0.0165566299,
0.0837811157,
-0.225180611,
0.8855456114,
-0.449198097,
0.0745393336,
-0.4382378757,
0.1988203228,
-0.4565804303,
0.4046437442,
-0.0302374773,
1.0241361856,
0.5513596535,
-0.9273383021,
0.0960817188,
0.1562583297,
-0.3764523864,
0.4121418595,
-0.5591904521,
0.3003045321,
-0.1639258862,
-0.0335326679,
-0.9994596243,
-0.2511227727,
0.0037813345,
-0.2545744181,
0.1226950437,
0.0761466548,
-0.58564502,
-0.0384867452,
-0.2004481405,
0.3111180067,
0.4645872414,
-0.8685866594,
0.4912669361,
-0.0000252513,
-0.4273263216,
-0.2395067364,
-0.0868380219,
0.1088713259,
-0.5371510983,
-0.4310709238,
0.458868891,
-0.5233025551,
-0.1830679178,
-0.4316219091,
-0.0265037622,
-0.1230272949,
0.0663057044,
-0.0632503703,
0.1883756816,
-0.2422054708,
0.3104034662,
0.4807736278,
0.0215048213,
-0.3887485862,
0.1141645685,
0.541467905,
-0.041220855,
0.1568762213,
-0.4150837362,
0.429092288,
0.2903777361,
0.0436172858,
0.564884603,
0.586230278,
-0.0845151171,
-0.1312284023,
-0.6591193676,
-0.5701007247,
-0.6194972396,
0.4200723767,
-0.5664410591,
-1.1560600996,
0.4616916776,
-0.3270028532,
0.158673659,
0.2057782114,
0.6190703511,
-0.3616158068,
1.2563414574,
0.9573611021,
-0.0407539234,
0.8182354569,
0.15713121,
0.1116196662,
-0.9480500817,
0.1632326096,
-0.4702104628,
-0.5715584159,
-0.6671326756,
-0.2873088717,
0.3524755836,
0.0316207148,
-0.1461673975,
0.1627983302,
-0.3501653373,
0.5872759819,
0.6022521853,
0.1695718914,
0.5328194499,
0.1089030653,
-0.1996475458,
-0.098783955,
-0.7398176789,
-0.417819798,
1.1057178974,
0.3507782221,
0.7462664247,
0.0608811267,
0.800176084,
0.3255816102,
0.2124273926,
-0.9401976466,
0.5255171061,
-0.1794731021,
-0.4470537901,
-0.4216635525,
-0.3771170676,
-0.8467798829,
0.0350158177,
-0.1506476402,
-0.8462540507,
0.3622039258,
0.5744507313,
-0.901060462,
-0.0157143287,
-0.6248807907,
0.1664355248,
-0.1122884974,
-0.0050258995,
-0.3504732549,
-0.4964782596,
0.0032511046,
-0.3260316849,
-0.0482525937,
-0.030095987,
-0.5299960375,
0.7608017921,
-0.3368335068,
0.664845407,
0.0042192782,
0.0095261848,
0.0287602972,
-0.1273843795,
0.7903090715,
0.2814788222,
-0.263869524,
0.0067207147,
-0.3229850829,
-0.1060664132,
-0.8579053879,
0.7387412786,
-0.5326061249,
-0.8815869689,
-0.1029463634,
-0.5882696509,
-0.6474921703,
0.2788175941,
0.4327565134,
0.5511797667,
-0.0534038469,
0.4336438477,
0.8526750207,
-0.1193200797,
0.4050154686,
0.7845279574,
-0.0385588109,
-0.2778314948,
0.8677782416,
0.0530651547,
0.0865465701,
0.567861855,
0.380543679,
-0.1777346134,
-0.8375304937,
-0.6391313076,
0.331223011,
-0.4808310568,
-0.3384023309,
-0.6170474887,
0.0736264065,
-0.0964057148,
-0.2844788432,
0.0185315385,
-0.410820514,
-0.6767496467,
-0.0557286739,
0.60500741,
0.3676441312,
0.221391052,
0.8531345725,
-0.6558779478,
0.418654561,
0.0879122466,
0.5467823744,
-0.2243913263,
-0.9483958483,
-0.4282318056,
-0.0977356285,
-0.1461753994,
-0.697452724,
0.2636325657,
0.4688059986,
0.4538394213,
0.7231546044,
-0.2168031931,
0.8383049369,
-0.6900132298,
0.6488482356,
0.0164574012,
-0.4778723419,
0.4793977737,
-0.4484288096,
0.6465606093,
0.7621397972,
0.3441804349,
-0.629883647,
-0.3205007017,
-0.3922401071,
-0.7164106965,
0.7273259163,
-0.1090090126,
0.4287422299,
0.1187917963,
0.8505390286,
0.2476583868,
0.288628906,
0.021783391,
-0.5455508828,
0.5579633713,
-0.1798021048,
-0.3785702586,
-0.3276434839,
0.0081241513,
-0.3739640415,
0.2455742657,
-0.31729123,
0.1810486019,
-0.0391779803,
0.0792755708,
-0.0652407929,
0.1440257728,
0.7120834589,
0.4438482821,
-0.1475087553,
-0.2497876734,
0.4872578084,
-0.2287696451,
-0.0744550824,
-0.0680770501,
-0.2055086941,
0.1382155418,
0.1452604979,
1.1357748508,
0.2226033062,
-0.6904582977,
0.0344458111,
-0.2128126323,
-0.121346496,
0.0948829204,
0.4118268788,
-0.0821032077,
0.1474630088,
0.2844299972,
0.1883486062,
0.4200594127,
-0.5506248474,
0.1149271503,
0.6344079971,
-0.1934851259,
-0.1909509748,
0.6465993524,
0.2606945336,
-0.7378387451,
0.4303679764,
0.0076344274,
0.1111187711,
0.3821748197,
0.4008606672,
0.8823224902,
-0.1705362052,
0.1655479819,
0.2695785165,
-0.0488755442,
0.007299989,
0.1813475341,
-0.4793820381,
-0.7350322008,
-0.2039551735,
-0.6092276573,
-0.4567608535,
0.0689664185,
-0.4122336507,
0.517574966,
-0.5896567106,
-0.318492353,
0.0692655221,
0.0610233508,
-0.7009325027,
0.2250070572,
0.0202474855,
1.142168045,
-0.3804110289,
0.8696337938,
0.7715566158,
-0.0545524061,
-0.7633830905,
0.2079622895,
-0.2680992186,
-0.6768471003,
0.485011518,
-0.1389321089,
-0.0722584054,
0.1445340514,
-0.0802759528,
-1.2315795422,
0.9516553879,
0.1950953454,
-0.9045656919,
-0.3056918979,
0.0199765284,
0.7950696945,
-0.6733478904,
0.4518788755,
0.802157402,
0.4347695112,
0.1947091818,
-0.6834750175,
0.0101146847,
0.0453911945,
0.2982976437,
0.1259133071,
-0.6631606817,
0.4716080427,
-0.4523532987,
-0.0460272059,
0.3871847391,
1.0015032291,
0.248195231,
0.2375368923,
0.5691213608,
-0.1075954586,
0.8881965876,
0.1415988654,
1.0304828882,
-0.5278955698,
-0.0885606557,
1.0606615543,
0.0968194529,
0.7417094111,
0.4971297085,
0.1451989859,
0.3124174476,
0.9466320276,
0.1118547916,
0.5280559063,
0.1016224548,
-0.2037487924,
-0.1283101141,
-0.033636786,
-0.2072915435,
0.2180793285,
0.4466262162,
-0.5497379303,
-0.0792293474,
0.1058130115,
-0.1072737128,
-0.031987641,
-0.4525026381,
1.0891684294,
-0.1020331755,
-0.7919142842,
0.5039401054,
0.2703246176,
0.9587669373,
-0.6865252256,
0.1901752949,
-0.4749450982,
-0.1528415382,
-0.1394686103,
-0.3475304842,
0.1509435475,
0.0422478765,
-0.2846050262,
-0.1919525415,
0.5771627426,
-0.5536826849,
-0.3630951941,
-0.2584546804,
0.4030323625,
0.0918906331,
-0.0191412028,
-0.4355579913,
0.0350094512,
0.0343834646,
-0.4277856648,
0.3912984133,
0.1383767873,
-0.0995475352,
0.7496635914,
0.4935578704,
0.4748469591,
0.0611730255,
0.0442854725,
0.8256797194,
-0.6146891117,
-0.5367747545,
-0.8435627818,
0.1873368472,
-0.081786558,
-0.6540620923,
0.8541950583,
0.6409806609,
0.4695872068,
-0.1776584089,
0.7037930489,
0.2995508909,
0.5891349316,
-0.5289775729,
0.3704937994,
-0.6137062311,
0.5098709464,
-0.0412256867,
-1.0373550653,
-0.2892694473,
0.2427532524,
-0.4218298495,
0.2724951208,
0.5458086729,
0.9181366563,
0.063751027,
-0.1732149124,
0.6049733758,
0.0801352113,
0.2246584743,
-0.0844230205,
0.5387678742,
0.0807287619,
0.3846178055,
-0.083621107,
-0.374270469,
-0.6006268859,
-0.6309729218,
-0.8429655433,
-0.5207741261,
-0.2596358955,
-0.0108397743,
0.1397480667,
1.0431226492,
0.7601678371,
-0.6600917578,
-0.1752016842,
0.1149106473,
0.0915460065,
-0.1713630557,
-0.1674894989,
0.1540366113,
-0.5708318353,
-0.8860270381,
0.6596267223,
0.3444575965,
-0.0270465855,
-0.0930273756,
-0.0094766924,
0.3667915463,
0.6297397614,
0.6225242615,
0.313809067,
-0.5824321508,
-0.2740134299,
0.2225690186,
0.1196016669,
0.168696627,
1.0531144142,
-0.7533752918,
0.5296388865,
0.4617192745,
0.6023870707,
0.3171835542,
0.3693817258,
0.8298028708,
-0.9933562875,
-0.0249128137,
0.2029845268,
0.2030486763,
0.0093306256,
-0.9150171876,
0.1249719188,
-0.1842216849,
-0.5907274485,
-0.8175424933,
0.3469372392,
-0.9598680735,
-0.1655782014,
1.2837911844,
0.2257785499,
0.1317114383,
0.0793631896,
-0.5871888399,
-0.0678793341,
-0.7462147474,
1.0002783537,
0.6804556251,
-0.5860339403,
-0.0471826158,
-0.1922575086,
0.9012479782,
0.3783760369,
-0.6769282222,
-0.0918868855,
0.2761140168,
0.1768440455,
-0.0781548843,
0.6760656238,
0.3867363334,
0.3674302101,
-0.4826827943,
-0.52104491,
-0.1650465429,
-0.4590181112,
-0.5992419124,
0.1326637417,
0.3999942839,
-0.0000693676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.17256v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.17256v1
|
From Bytes to Biases: Investigating the Cultural Self-Perception of Large Language Models
| 2023-12-21T22:50:14 | 2023-12-21T22:50:14 |
Wolfgang Messner, Tatum Greene, Josephine Matalone
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) are able to engage in natural-sounding
conversations with humans, showcasing unprecedented capabilities for
information retrieval and automated decision support. They have disrupted
human-technology interaction and the way businesses operate. However,
technologies based on generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) are known to
hallucinate, misinform, and display biases introduced by the massive datasets
on which they are trained. Existing research indicates that humans may
unconsciously internalize these biases, which can persist even after they stop
using the programs. This study explores the cultural self-perception of LLMs by
prompting ChatGPT (OpenAI) and Bard (Google) with value questions derived from
the GLOBE project. The findings reveal that their cultural self-perception is
most closely aligned with the values of English-speaking countries and
countries characterized by sustained economic competitiveness. Recognizing the
cultural biases of LLMs and understanding how they work is crucial for all
members of society because one does not want the black box of artificial
intelligence to perpetuate bias in humans, who might, in turn, inadvertently
create and train even more biased algorithms.
|
[
-0.4562759101,
-0.4711250961,
0.4336441457,
0.208857879,
0.0086168637,
0.1250227392,
-0.4922032654,
-0.6597355604,
0.2813290358,
0.6166595817,
-0.6332306862,
-0.0907252207,
-0.3872165084,
0.1359268725,
-0.1624792665,
0.9847911,
0.2629868388,
0.3199147582,
-0.1774656475,
-0.1346152425,
-0.4172714651,
-0.6001343131,
-0.3291536272,
-0.4834285975,
0.2451281846,
0.4181368351,
0.7583346367,
0.32121104,
0.2322719395,
0.2406722307,
0.1625081748,
-0.2428255528,
-0.6318851113,
0.1748886108,
-0.3328344524,
-0.6641536355,
0.0241433438,
0.2857408226,
0.3134590089,
0.596303165,
-0.009320491,
0.6176418662,
0.2849937379,
0.8812510967,
-0.2462539971,
0.2202024609,
-0.7242426872,
0.4885768592,
-0.2122499794,
-0.302800715,
-0.3798515499,
-0.1928375065,
0.0468998775,
-0.3978661299,
0.239848122,
0.0885217711,
0.5140860081,
0.4008407891,
-0.6267436743,
-0.4315637648,
-0.8847672939,
0.7502278686,
-0.3077708185,
0.4447285235,
0.3929411769,
0.1272085607,
-0.2867999375,
-0.2334027439,
-0.5492383242,
-0.1727985144,
-0.015229091,
0.2022830844,
-0.1486766785,
-0.2318183184,
0.3124587536,
0.3371291161,
-0.5975701213,
0.2928344011,
-0.5561416745,
-0.2602396905,
0.6250296235,
-0.0840954334,
0.6276097298,
-0.1915264428,
-0.0896719098,
-0.0685588717,
-0.9358631372,
-0.1700033993,
0.5363866687,
0.0005969313,
-0.0525312126,
0.4180079401,
-0.2744202912,
0.4553104937,
0.2276718616,
-0.0188428257,
0.2701106071,
0.1159791127,
-0.3314610422,
0.2573076785,
0.8554856181,
0.3107447326,
0.9730681181,
-0.2891582847,
0.0521346144,
0.0621821955,
0.3764742911,
-0.7830213904,
-0.1543438435,
0.1880359948,
-0.7433024049,
-0.3160204291,
-0.2094775289,
-0.7711941004,
-0.5949611664,
-0.3002434671,
0.2477646619,
-0.1548989415,
-0.2487353832,
-0.2612447739,
-0.1016256884,
0.4026674926,
0.0194106735,
-1.2088171244,
-0.2126770467,
0.4766673148,
0.6959889531,
0.1006413624,
-0.1390602887,
-0.0171666015,
0.1681613475,
-0.6295412779,
0.6229056716,
-0.4842022657,
-0.5891537666,
-0.089322269,
-0.0559600331,
0.2439582199,
-0.7321200371,
0.4704864621,
-0.5623119473,
0.1681486666,
-0.6457343698,
-0.1920911223,
-0.0604345575,
0.3551870286,
-0.4545995891,
0.660358727,
-0.1664812416,
-0.6092655063,
0.5985556245,
-0.5465795994,
-0.2989781201,
0.293604821,
-0.6196158528,
0.1142070442,
0.1662195325,
0.3839389384,
0.5254382491,
-0.3570480049,
0.2888358235,
-0.4436657727,
-0.1494264901,
0.5140817761,
-0.8519418836,
0.8534240723,
0.6061415076,
-0.4841995239,
-0.0249766912,
-0.5677553415,
-0.1384813786,
0.3448936641,
-0.2431789488,
-0.4694665968,
0.0650232658,
-0.373162657,
0.4276586175,
0.2320016623,
-0.4778767824,
0.2377808243,
-0.2411028892,
0.7525473237,
1.1607729197,
-0.3677129149,
0.4531155825,
-0.1589091122,
0.4930405915,
0.1670120955,
0.1889568716,
-0.105156593,
-0.4435570836,
-0.7622197866,
0.1347561926,
-0.0942210034,
0.3726703823,
-0.5386052132,
0.1611728668,
-0.5669488907,
-0.4027367234,
-0.6950768232,
0.293163389,
-0.10755831,
0.4007641077,
0.0034030895,
-0.2620194554,
-0.2122013271,
-1.178275466,
-0.384590894,
-0.1655027121,
-0.3856063783,
0.5150098801,
0.4261864126,
-0.2937970757,
1.1164262295,
-0.2316567302,
-0.3514770865,
-0.1015139446,
0.0377127677,
0.129525423,
0.3490273654,
0.3986274898,
-0.6726751924,
-0.2928000987,
-0.0223195534,
-0.973913312,
-0.1261360496,
-0.2395913005,
-0.1586965472,
0.421010077,
0.3576797545,
-0.3144077659,
0.1856753677,
0.7708567977,
-0.5268219113,
0.6116345525,
-0.1076304317,
0.2258557677,
-0.9045141339,
-0.0672463104,
0.1245825067,
0.0668296665,
-0.3509921134,
-0.0788236633,
0.0162968431,
0.0168809313,
-0.0622931235,
0.5856896043,
-0.6899367571,
-0.4942049384,
-0.0453564785,
0.0506519079,
-0.1133994311,
0.1909482628,
0.11134094,
1.2043801546,
0.4000090361,
-0.4804815948,
0.1977028996,
0.1675060838,
-0.7920964956,
0.7484185696,
-0.4784366786,
0.3409036696,
-0.4430803061,
0.3707418144,
-0.8140246272,
-0.1612365395,
0.2573871613,
-0.5210442543,
0.1580205262,
-0.2433376014,
-0.4380738735,
-0.3969630003,
-0.0795689747,
0.5387346148,
0.6566829681,
-0.7508843541,
0.5081398487,
0.5267650485,
-0.1445418,
-0.7124092579,
-1.1564075947,
0.454754144,
-0.3781844378,
-0.8037688732,
-0.0496393703,
-0.2494918108,
-0.4863593876,
-0.3224951923,
0.0445272624,
0.1910773814,
-0.0307167415,
0.3176165819,
0.2766102552,
-0.1140324846,
0.1288565546,
-0.2193411738,
0.1825084537,
0.5047226548,
-0.6662122011,
0.688678503,
-0.1174800396,
-0.4411143959,
-0.0370642394,
0.0182111692,
0.6002436876,
-0.1583245397,
0.7110778093,
0.5599110723,
0.0262910724,
-0.1714407802,
-0.9775617719,
-0.1934362948,
-0.5062836409,
0.2567653954,
-0.4423317611,
-0.95912081,
0.6799179912,
0.2152941823,
-0.3262871206,
0.3699845374,
0.7507491708,
-0.1072872728,
0.9904571176,
0.4559267759,
-0.6224762201,
0.3134290576,
-0.21287103,
0.3407585621,
-0.8158091903,
-0.2633534074,
-0.4694206417,
-0.4027782679,
-0.9272919893,
-0.2476350218,
0.6118656397,
-0.3360233605,
-0.4565086067,
-0.3921541572,
-0.5676146746,
0.6587890983,
0.622985363,
-0.0578292757,
0.1166189685,
0.1270305961,
-0.0405871943,
0.0751367286,
-0.7340747714,
-0.5388634205,
1.1919202805,
0.5113000274,
0.9799554348,
0.0522865281,
0.4108193815,
0.503059268,
0.2848129869,
-0.8090136647,
0.4237035215,
0.061960984,
-0.8141596317,
-0.273232311,
-0.40393731,
-1.0006217957,
0.2416758984,
0.0257316753,
-0.8917623758,
0.2094740272,
0.1397292912,
-0.0967932492,
0.3739216328,
-0.5733799934,
0.8766028285,
-0.4156561494,
-0.5117478371,
-0.3832038343,
-0.5023005605,
0.592823565,
0.0863692835,
0.6219126582,
-0.2088771909,
0.303842932,
0.7901479602,
0.1156124398,
0.9652053714,
0.1620717794,
-0.377720207,
0.2145631909,
0.39141801,
0.1970749944,
-0.1321132928,
-0.0914984122,
0.6102374792,
-0.0039823703,
-0.4281142652,
-0.2707602084,
0.81661129,
-1.1007224321,
-0.7325658798,
-0.4749266505,
-0.4323736429,
-0.0718269274,
0.0525136255,
0.1687535346,
0.2986570001,
-0.369655937,
-0.0536134169,
0.6846200228,
-0.4814172685,
0.3535270691,
0.4219893515,
-0.244065851,
-0.0065437453,
0.7312678099,
0.2798835039,
0.2896232903,
-0.0197246447,
0.3083050251,
-0.1831461489,
-0.2183980495,
-0.7264044285,
0.1765025854,
-0.8566311002,
0.1889467686,
-0.4674613476,
-0.0992056653,
-0.7337462902,
-0.1245817021,
-0.1431714743,
0.0114545356,
-0.2250334918,
-0.1617740244,
0.0154142007,
1.0593417883,
-0.1193277165,
0.072796315,
-0.7203017473,
0.0389341973,
0.4018948078,
0.4020359814,
0.1665105522,
-0.6258431077,
-0.1355615258,
0.1819363087,
-0.1941269934,
-0.8461435437,
0.6121656895,
-0.1870153844,
0.5309951901,
0.7807694077,
-0.1595884115,
0.4311383963,
-0.4887989461,
0.9706294537,
-0.2228674591,
-0.79385221,
0.3245371878,
-0.5225237012,
0.3879143596,
0.1744332612,
0.5922741294,
-1.0096248388,
-0.2950848341,
-0.3978253007,
-0.4947502911,
0.6493958235,
-0.2197889686,
0.5708991289,
-0.2579943836,
0.1371471137,
0.2481413782,
0.1977872401,
-0.9923130274,
-0.2340164036,
-0.3163619936,
-0.0432346873,
-0.1580061316,
-0.5914853811,
0.0174583662,
-0.0504173152,
0.6400774121,
-0.3350890279,
0.2210389078,
0.1525533795,
-0.2564535141,
-0.2344364971,
0.4866090417,
0.3912101686,
0.8036025167,
0.0851245522,
0.0886771008,
0.1283951849,
-0.3935275078,
0.083538264,
-0.4931467175,
-0.2922399342,
-0.5707273483,
0.0622206368,
0.6356378198,
-0.3081098497,
-0.635907948,
0.2387789041,
0.0209475346,
0.1936328113,
-0.8110327721,
-0.1893140376,
0.0114828842,
0.1621400416,
0.3954092562,
-0.1454643607,
0.2547402084,
-1.1230034828,
-0.2359015048,
0.7877857089,
-0.3174810112,
-0.2738333046,
0.6187932491,
0.3375752866,
-0.1363024861,
0.9006176591,
-0.1823922992,
-0.7198629379,
0.4339891076,
0.5352542996,
0.9075933099,
-0.1353435963,
0.3089195788,
0.2459609807,
0.5871224999,
0.021114381,
-0.1271345615,
-0.1102525964,
-1.30098176,
-0.3842916191,
-0.7010049224,
-0.0764854848,
0.1425092071,
-0.4149346054,
0.1445004791,
-0.2716253102,
-0.0191180035,
-0.2350849956,
-0.3366827071,
-0.9288010001,
0.2727178633,
0.6730546355,
0.6551318169,
-0.8085947633,
0.7981945872,
0.4367077351,
-0.425222367,
-0.543644011,
0.1655197293,
0.2197903842,
-1.1922975779,
1.0362017155,
0.3136174083,
0.0501027703,
-0.1539917588,
-0.6230973601,
-1.0538312197,
0.8085217476,
0.1371676475,
-0.4781213105,
0.0026229736,
0.4227375984,
0.4521794915,
-0.2141168416,
0.7485015988,
0.8214092851,
0.46041587,
-0.0688368604,
-1.0249457359,
-0.1011404395,
-0.0719911307,
0.0612839013,
0.0256372504,
-1.0163351297,
0.5399606824,
-0.1267829984,
-0.0517779775,
-0.4122925103,
0.639908731,
-0.0832171962,
0.101008594,
0.4127556384,
0.2989576459,
0.7181840539,
0.0462107547,
0.9314168692,
-0.5787326097,
-0.0717538595,
0.7743103504,
-0.3125132322,
0.5556957126,
0.4331620336,
-0.2244855016,
0.6649811268,
0.5955952406,
-0.1581978798,
0.0195430238,
0.3996375799,
-0.1291446984,
-0.1398611218,
-0.0987834558,
-0.1327334344,
0.7985471487,
0.4727324843,
-0.3766977489,
0.1832642257,
0.1362067461,
0.187104702,
-0.0877122954,
-0.4380424917,
0.7929845452,
0.0063236388,
-0.9527122974,
0.3138229847,
-0.1669566035,
1.0340162516,
-0.5846953392,
0.2384353727,
-0.274594903,
-0.0455858335,
-0.264726162,
-0.7893424034,
0.2490624487,
-0.0506160557,
-0.1288797855,
-0.4038412869,
0.701140523,
-0.2807968259,
-0.4554935992,
0.2580797076,
0.4131519794,
0.4310963452,
-0.2359509617,
-0.5458343029,
0.1856453419,
0.2458442152,
-0.3006716371,
0.5705071688,
0.3729928136,
-0.1403521001,
1.0532200336,
0.3904348016,
0.066252403,
0.0268743765,
0.1061444506,
0.4298501313,
-0.7060191035,
-0.5551604033,
-0.9523459077,
0.0666336268,
-0.0059653148,
-0.0718515068,
0.817595005,
0.4099205732,
1.1517320871,
-0.1021189988,
1.1286808252,
0.0641653389,
0.0993751287,
-0.5714728236,
1.0645910501,
-0.3791433871,
0.2548836172,
-0.023798693,
-0.9359577298,
0.3422063887,
0.6295688748,
-0.6553562284,
0.4520426691,
0.3963635564,
0.6906841993,
0.1384846717,
0.21906811,
0.4617473781,
0.5917996764,
0.3720866144,
0.260052681,
0.8966568112,
0.2370644808,
0.4438034296,
-0.2875088453,
-0.2394675463,
0.018398216,
-0.8738992214,
-0.8565833569,
-0.5071378946,
-0.182128787,
-0.3205117881,
-0.0986770988,
1.21641922,
0.5346769094,
-0.7029703856,
-0.5899107456,
0.3306443095,
-0.0312656052,
0.2684623301,
-0.3262774646,
0.0736420229,
-0.510627985,
-0.7781572342,
0.2194355875,
0.2589552402,
0.1337940395,
-0.8384543061,
0.2076061815,
0.3249790967,
0.1570529342,
0.6299350262,
0.2190339863,
-0.768999517,
-0.4115285575,
-0.0899089649,
0.0601975992,
0.0987325385,
0.779812336,
-1.0685851574,
0.4707668126,
0.3307078779,
0.3976247013,
0.2724481523,
-0.1392987669,
0.7092654705,
-0.3051254153,
0.085555993,
0.0571812838,
0.3501845896,
0.4989071786,
-0.428198576,
0.4684568346,
0.1607581824,
-0.976829946,
-0.4883632958,
0.2505132258,
-0.5701426864,
-0.41626513,
1.2984802723,
0.1736568511,
-0.3789123893,
0.0394497849,
-0.2123425901,
0.0527662039,
-0.2941523492,
1.1948741674,
0.8750714064,
0.0538491495,
0.1391802132,
-0.8118320704,
0.4820095301,
0.6079723239,
-0.4749621153,
0.1422304064,
0.7125167251,
0.5853005052,
0.0690172985,
0.6304558516,
0.0570493639,
-0.2211665362,
-0.1645297408,
0.3087801635,
0.2332706451,
-0.1389854401,
-0.4032312334,
-0.0478137098,
0.1617725492,
0.04019076
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14302v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14302v1
|
Exploiting Novel GPT-4 APIs
| 2023-12-21T21:22:41 | 2023-12-21T21:22:41 |
Kellin Pelrine, Mohammad Taufeeque, Michał Zając, Euan McLean, Adam Gleave
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7
|
Language model attacks typically assume one of two extreme threat models:
full white-box access to model weights, or black-box access limited to a text
generation API. However, real-world APIs are often more flexible than just text
generation: these APIs expose ``gray-box'' access leading to new threat
vectors. To explore this, we red-team three new functionalities exposed in the
GPT-4 APIs: fine-tuning, function calling and knowledge retrieval. We find that
fine-tuning a model on as few as 15 harmful examples or 100 benign examples can
remove core safeguards from GPT-4, enabling a range of harmful outputs.
Furthermore, we find that GPT-4 Assistants readily divulge the function call
schema and can be made to execute arbitrary function calls. Finally, we find
that knowledge retrieval can be hijacked by injecting instructions into
retrieval documents. These vulnerabilities highlight that any additions to the
functionality exposed by an API can create new vulnerabilities.
|
[
-0.2794642448,
-0.9198465347,
0.7791158557,
-0.3851930797,
0.0017548252,
0.1229071841,
0.1766475141,
-0.8699057698,
-0.5238439441,
0.9051904678,
-0.4721089602,
-0.2086137235,
-0.5716688633,
0.0330776982,
-0.4859952629,
1.3191261292,
0.1036781967,
-0.4455906153,
0.2045152336,
0.1386516243,
-0.6137312651,
-0.807482183,
-0.3275623918,
-0.0729209781,
0.3978485167,
0.0974517912,
1.0109249353,
0.3983959854,
0.5203287601,
0.2567797005,
0.2574309409,
-0.2698169947,
-0.4968790412,
0.0186049007,
-0.1843853742,
-0.732489109,
-0.5221695304,
0.0498308279,
0.1801855117,
0.2922692299,
0.1371208429,
0.1556206793,
0.0077910065,
0.3265329897,
-0.474922359,
0.1694437712,
-1.0947290659,
-0.056569837,
-0.5366976857,
-0.3353645504,
-0.4079431295,
-0.0796646848,
0.4885861278,
-0.5763505697,
0.1378410906,
-0.102503024,
0.9776208401,
0.3564558625,
-0.3122384846,
-0.4097114801,
-0.6667028666,
0.6514952183,
-0.6429011226,
0.1294647604,
0.480851382,
0.5327486396,
-0.1174710393,
-0.893250823,
-0.3491251171,
-0.14485313,
-0.0535032488,
-0.3095097542,
-0.6097339392,
0.1924978495,
0.3579811454,
0.2944788337,
-0.4387891591,
-0.117690064,
-0.5162745118,
-0.3340418339,
0.3623373806,
-0.0987973437,
0.6655718088,
-0.1649890244,
-0.1790629476,
0.1614487767,
-0.955094099,
-0.2994019687,
0.9042025805,
0.5262180567,
0.015565698,
0.3973537683,
0.1206826419,
0.7888337374,
-0.2591860592,
0.2397001088,
0.0720821768,
-0.3725300431,
-0.2106638849,
-0.3447699547,
0.5371829867,
0.2099476308,
0.1475134194,
-0.3794208467,
-0.3088616133,
-0.160634771,
0.6504475474,
-0.6181780696,
-0.3521102369,
0.1466534883,
-0.1272206753,
-0.5117613077,
-0.2018535733,
-0.6253926754,
-0.3555189669,
-0.0326380618,
0.6282839179,
-0.6441759467,
-0.3546797335,
0.0010467054,
-0.3362586498,
0.3316603601,
-0.0012186416,
-0.9840764403,
0.4863300025,
0.8726993203,
0.741943419,
0.1732100099,
-0.1764266491,
-0.4447950721,
0.1672759801,
-0.0081542851,
0.6537023187,
-0.755391717,
-0.4712534845,
-0.0540999211,
-0.2032054663,
0.3207468688,
-0.3787691295,
0.481543541,
-0.6421224475,
0.1142914891,
-0.5087431073,
-0.2080736309,
-0.0441317298,
0.2574073076,
-0.7235447168,
1.0001529455,
0.3335857093,
-0.8053138256,
0.05115835,
-0.8962266445,
-0.250998944,
0.3528806865,
-0.2135501951,
-0.1781979799,
0.0662118867,
-0.0845476687,
0.3216395676,
-0.1179205626,
-0.2718687654,
-0.291223675,
-0.3075777888,
0.1548951566,
-0.3410810232,
0.6537542939,
0.3586926758,
-0.4970631003,
0.0404080525,
-0.6618692279,
0.0148102464,
0.1720460355,
-0.0958020464,
-0.6309431195,
-0.3350990713,
-0.2035891712,
0.1378782988,
0.2821731269,
-0.334700495,
0.1143890768,
-0.4517807066,
0.9196470976,
0.7151600718,
0.1537924409,
0.4505586028,
-0.2122110873,
0.6781761646,
-0.5190700889,
0.457880646,
-0.0448203981,
-0.6355136037,
-0.0657302067,
-0.1663306952,
0.2295031101,
0.5068662763,
-0.7907839417,
-0.0839972422,
0.0520096421,
-0.5496077538,
-0.4193421304,
-0.0124189937,
0.5212237239,
0.5968354344,
0.3951963186,
0.1617692113,
-0.3149086535,
-0.9494943619,
-0.6171979904,
-0.152359277,
-0.0762593225,
0.3790405691,
0.5063514113,
-0.3665136397,
0.6628010869,
-0.7010784149,
0.0007081053,
-0.0382329263,
0.1101495996,
0.1643515974,
0.2948283255,
0.7780910134,
-0.8771284223,
-0.3189825118,
-0.0729983076,
-0.4792741537,
-0.2807038724,
0.1236277074,
-0.252720058,
0.011837054,
0.5316206217,
-0.6057857275,
0.1784083843,
0.4707842171,
-0.2655926049,
0.821241498,
-0.148294121,
-0.2126051188,
-0.8947048783,
-0.0601348057,
-0.1842207462,
-0.0663591698,
-0.9222718477,
0.781930089,
0.3081637621,
-0.378556937,
-0.5401768684,
0.5689936876,
-0.4774932861,
-0.0498169996,
-0.2675129771,
-0.0760085955,
-0.0842651501,
0.2456602305,
-0.6209811568,
0.7911989093,
0.5246155858,
-0.414119184,
0.1858579516,
0.1168220118,
0.0884588957,
0.3027355671,
-0.5087882876,
0.4070497751,
0.2551713288,
-0.0105310911,
-0.8078622222,
-0.2714121044,
0.1617141217,
-0.3318452835,
0.4719081223,
-0.4050536752,
-0.6018048525,
-0.402155906,
-0.5691244006,
0.4112525582,
0.4199055135,
-0.3426536322,
0.5330147147,
0.6139963269,
-0.4508323967,
-0.7095329762,
-0.854659915,
0.2987969816,
-0.305413723,
-0.3064698279,
0.2836959064,
-0.06564188,
-0.1253586859,
0.210649848,
-0.1775012612,
-0.0536091365,
0.454896301,
0.1566949338,
0.2880994976,
0.1533640623,
-0.1701694578,
0.017781686,
-0.0248979423,
0.1245261505,
-0.5317249298,
0.622593224,
-0.2589177787,
-0.4900982082,
-0.2250727713,
0.3890986145,
0.5854336619,
-0.5810872912,
0.0979676023,
0.4149043858,
-0.572919786,
-0.0696980208,
-0.4337862134,
-0.2760840356,
-0.5661315918,
0.6372370124,
-0.6520234346,
-0.9684368372,
0.5650013089,
0.1466587931,
0.3038346469,
0.177193135,
0.4429242015,
0.3592636883,
0.9739457369,
0.6563946009,
0.0951860771,
0.6234616041,
-0.1758035123,
0.4585403502,
-0.7531274557,
0.0042317081,
-0.5491674542,
0.0650734529,
-0.7408140898,
-0.2301366776,
0.3701260984,
-0.1391463429,
-0.2944887877,
0.4925805926,
-0.6930981874,
0.6726710796,
0.7518977523,
0.0831982195,
0.2304646224,
-0.1122997701,
-0.2173536867,
0.1524279714,
-0.2877843976,
-0.7551544309,
1.6285743713,
0.4903957546,
0.7980899215,
0.3214049935,
0.7845808268,
0.2153263539,
0.2683193684,
-0.5319266319,
0.4986300766,
0.0070646475,
-0.7579447627,
-0.293007344,
-0.3646310568,
-0.7543312311,
0.1065158322,
-0.0352712832,
-0.8305674791,
-0.1145992652,
0.267118454,
-0.7272936702,
0.2763085365,
-1.1764475107,
0.7304426432,
-0.2595258951,
-0.3917292655,
0.1321159601,
-0.4903174639,
0.521086216,
-0.3301515281,
0.2511100173,
0.0657534748,
0.1101241931,
0.228643328,
-0.2905336618,
0.914760828,
-0.2426228225,
-0.4020064175,
0.0448128358,
0.3092474639,
0.5540847778,
0.1520786583,
-0.0406226218,
0.14029257,
0.1616912484,
-0.4882126749,
-0.4956083,
0.846573472,
-0.7154551744,
-0.9459348321,
-0.3758776486,
-0.7325088978,
-0.2708058059,
0.6211650372,
0.2112634778,
0.5991955996,
-0.0707448125,
-0.3296474814,
0.5843859911,
-0.3703637421,
0.3297051787,
0.5582057238,
-0.0185495801,
-0.0780008137,
0.9725822806,
0.2058420926,
0.6749653816,
0.2923234403,
0.0061526322,
-0.4790395498,
-0.9539219141,
-0.2754166424,
0.190697059,
-0.5585326552,
-0.3498470485,
-0.7653158307,
-0.0437430479,
-0.4815756977,
0.0289891064,
-0.1063256562,
-0.3606266379,
-0.1066818684,
-0.4513860345,
0.2568745613,
0.8362061977,
0.1161833331,
0.2516051233,
-0.8246682882,
0.0644650385,
0.576877892,
0.3974951804,
-0.3100974858,
-0.158090353,
-0.0772880763,
-0.1188188121,
-0.6427276731,
-1.1246367693,
0.2727553844,
-0.0860859603,
0.4472670555,
0.1811745167,
0.0808061287,
0.3104948997,
-0.9563970566,
0.8126727343,
-0.1734680682,
-0.8937134743,
0.4418824315,
-0.6065692902,
0.1937165707,
0.3094831109,
0.2414152175,
-0.1945583373,
-0.8276516199,
-0.7057245374,
-0.8661412597,
0.6589080095,
0.2391308993,
0.4721197188,
-0.0306215379,
0.6766263843,
0.1409809887,
0.2127746791,
-0.7011172771,
-0.0765191093,
-0.457896024,
-0.0686252266,
0.4438216686,
-0.2801558375,
-0.5312001705,
0.16964674,
0.4631796479,
-0.2412398905,
0.3632473946,
-0.0489328988,
-0.022885818,
-0.096129939,
0.5171844959,
0.4830899835,
0.5664443374,
-0.2414780408,
0.3111847639,
0.1073723063,
-0.5349941254,
-0.1858785748,
0.5985246301,
-0.1912290454,
-0.3606113195,
0.3993382752,
0.741056025,
0.421340555,
-0.5516440868,
0.3173210323,
-0.2601944804,
-0.1404516548,
-0.1997062713,
0.3248580992,
-0.0895800963,
0.2349199802,
0.5531590581,
0.2010784894,
0.3862136304,
-0.8869891763,
0.3904883862,
0.701949656,
-0.267652899,
-0.7404478192,
0.7505229115,
0.2030776739,
-0.322273612,
0.0064009759,
-0.2770412266,
-0.6792795062,
0.2386060804,
0.6803038716,
0.6342068315,
-0.2813404202,
0.1632498354,
-0.1089974642,
0.5450518727,
0.0231496468,
0.4258343875,
0.2591563463,
-0.6013934016,
-0.3005136847,
-0.3992727101,
-0.599327147,
0.5472055674,
-0.6647652984,
0.2028708905,
-0.3928926587,
-0.2038474381,
0.1371027529,
-0.0528778993,
-0.591457963,
-0.2543421686,
0.0844753534,
0.780448854,
-0.6001902819,
0.6964861751,
0.7444514632,
-0.4277768433,
-0.8466989398,
0.148110792,
0.3301803172,
-0.7773039937,
0.3857381344,
0.0273403265,
0.1154300943,
0.1981900483,
-0.3794672489,
-0.7633469105,
0.9831864834,
0.7356644869,
-0.4573038518,
-0.538158834,
0.2443728,
0.4249715805,
0.110876359,
0.1941846907,
0.9479945898,
0.5471263528,
-0.4839358628,
-0.9797363281,
0.3552407622,
-0.1103378311,
-0.2037935406,
0.4234354496,
-0.4541507065,
0.9377090335,
-0.2183819562,
-0.2647920847,
-0.064165622,
0.1302406788,
0.136797294,
-0.1755773127,
0.3595897555,
0.5905072093,
0.9250693321,
-0.1475102007,
1.5657049417,
-0.2247241288,
0.1197117716,
1.0999637842,
-0.2862348855,
0.6179645061,
0.3053127527,
-0.1094538644,
0.1076921448,
0.3649734557,
0.051457651,
0.7041969895,
0.0801925212,
-0.370687753,
0.2149683982,
0.3006561697,
-0.3505738378,
0.2734984756,
0.4746635854,
-0.0417297371,
-0.3875393569,
0.0538809821,
0.3528331816,
-0.1313020587,
-0.1136413589,
0.6888499856,
0.121902205,
-0.5428954959,
0.5595867038,
-0.0936479196,
0.6152861118,
-0.7182654738,
-0.1427593678,
0.1052303687,
0.0826820359,
-0.1238862351,
-0.7130619287,
0.3390981257,
0.0834116191,
-0.034287639,
-0.0462702326,
0.7954236865,
-0.1805223823,
-0.0051634903,
0.4085570276,
0.410007447,
-0.2574466467,
-0.4259358943,
-0.8722405434,
0.047788009,
0.0821269527,
-0.0867927298,
0.5694898367,
0.6953485012,
-0.1963437349,
0.5970628262,
0.8149213195,
0.3385066092,
0.3217784166,
0.0641801357,
1.1142785549,
-0.5928881764,
-0.4534968436,
-0.9363414049,
0.1946183294,
-0.064123325,
-0.1662535518,
0.6752063036,
0.3305766582,
0.8824003935,
0.0213641152,
1.2592993975,
0.0191649776,
0.4421687722,
-0.4082223773,
0.8792294264,
-0.2671519518,
0.6216806769,
-0.5519234538,
-0.5217658877,
-0.509042263,
0.0174802057,
-0.6137403846,
-0.1085418612,
0.7754483819,
0.9087557197,
-0.0816533938,
0.1374835223,
0.3407137096,
0.4798738658,
0.9681509137,
0.3317128718,
0.7227379084,
-0.2240785956,
0.9702811241,
0.0134406723,
-0.4888201952,
-0.0762532055,
-0.8000808358,
-0.8652957082,
-0.5644159913,
0.0850640088,
-0.2339910865,
0.161303997,
0.3924196959,
0.6250083447,
-0.6224427223,
0.2758199275,
-0.1302697957,
-0.0320779905,
-0.0211193003,
-0.2793464661,
0.2847288847,
-0.5730282068,
-0.6998238564,
0.4649950564,
0.2383852452,
0.1314347982,
-0.1628510058,
0.1513320357,
-0.0193490125,
0.0357963555,
0.4827135205,
0.4966867864,
-0.555406332,
-0.6089314222,
-0.066141203,
0.107823208,
-0.3914209306,
0.8916248083,
-0.4252356589,
0.3835076094,
0.1424060315,
0.9698197842,
0.2504553795,
-0.185663268,
0.8923937082,
-0.9107869267,
0.0173880495,
0.2641218901,
0.4025593102,
0.2970562279,
-0.7048781514,
0.5397868752,
0.062267568,
-0.5527279973,
-1.244656086,
0.5554072261,
-0.5963022113,
-0.3580367267,
1.0059375763,
-0.1217153743,
-0.1955322474,
-0.5234200358,
-0.3600533605,
0.0492745489,
-0.4077498019,
0.6758912206,
0.7069945931,
-0.3041179776,
-0.0428533256,
-1.2296472788,
0.8724554777,
0.0457246974,
-0.8639902472,
0.2543195486,
0.3232994974,
0.6706709266,
0.3123289347,
0.6201900244,
-0.6940121055,
0.2111807168,
-0.2365676016,
-0.1564585716,
-0.3273929656,
-0.1021422446,
-0.2413877249,
0.2816833258,
0.2212369591,
0.0379209146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14279v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14279v2
|
Characterizing and Classifying Developer Forum Posts with their Intentions
| 2023-12-21T20:17:01 | 2024-04-10T14:25:30 |
Xingfang Wu, Eric Laufer, Heng Li, Foutse Khomh, Santhosh Srinivasan, Jayden Luo
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
With the rapid growth of the developer community, the amount of posts on
online technical forums has been growing rapidly, which poses difficulties for
users to filter useful posts and find important information. Tags provide a
concise feature dimension for users to locate their interested posts and for
search engines to index the most relevant posts according to the queries.
However, most tags are only focused on the technical perspective (e.g., program
language, platform, tool). In most cases, forum posts in online developer
communities reveal the author's intentions to solve a problem, ask for advice,
share information, etc. The modeling of the intentions of posts can provide an
extra dimension to the current tag taxonomy. By referencing previous studies
and learning from industrial perspectives, we create a refined taxonomy for the
intentions of technical forum posts. Through manual labeling and analysis on a
sampled post dataset extracted from online forums, we understand the relevance
between the constitution of posts (code, error messages) and their intentions.
Furthermore, inspired by our manual study, we design a pre-trained
transformer-based model to automatically predict post intentions. The best
variant of our intention prediction framework, which achieves a Micro F1-score
of 0.589, Top 1-3 accuracy of 62.6% to 87.8%, and an average AUC of 0.787,
outperforms the state-of-the-art baseline approach. Our characterization and
automated classification of forum posts regarding their intentions may help
forum maintainers or third-party tool developers improve the organization and
retrieval of posts on technical forums. We have released our annotated dataset
and codes in our supplementary material package.
|
[
-0.7126200795,
-0.5300900936,
0.8240841031,
0.3888681531,
-0.4003428817,
-0.1575422287,
-0.0002935587,
-0.4299580157,
0.7494902611,
0.375392884,
-0.9196762443,
-0.6405647397,
-0.6580740809,
0.1069251373,
-0.5592333078,
1.0528088808,
-0.1888540685,
-0.2542367876,
-0.0809965059,
0.2676215768,
-0.4200957417,
-0.2587303221,
-0.9416964054,
0.308372736,
0.489387542,
0.1435643137,
0.2401250303,
0.4672655463,
0.6647769809,
0.2930370569,
0.1131821573,
-0.118754968,
-0.4049461186,
-0.1531751156,
-0.0238494892,
-0.2493734807,
-0.4014339447,
0.1807581186,
0.0214355532,
0.3790151477,
-0.1492715478,
0.4641112983,
0.0306685809,
-0.0564523637,
-0.4255424738,
0.1645911783,
-0.4228779674,
0.0915720016,
0.0127618145,
-0.7162299752,
-0.5814370513,
-0.4566793442,
-0.4008901119,
-0.4438329637,
0.2071296871,
-0.1486043632,
0.6542819142,
0.2335662842,
-0.3644166589,
-0.5183112621,
-0.7471852303,
0.7051450014,
-0.4050112367,
0.5012772679,
0.3244992495,
0.3105485439,
-0.1690246612,
-0.5607361794,
-0.4242427647,
0.4226600528,
-0.3918905258,
-0.093688637,
-0.3533577621,
0.3286181092,
0.3477887511,
0.1130659357,
-0.7391012311,
-0.0776137561,
-0.7021597624,
-0.1838760823,
0.5946133137,
0.0628620386,
0.3197844923,
-0.3534780145,
-0.3077553511,
0.0588970669,
-0.6689665914,
0.3616137803,
0.4757133126,
-0.0105748698,
0.0840932056,
0.4364597797,
-0.1781783998,
0.7429128885,
0.1861489415,
-0.0802863911,
0.0202195719,
-0.5564673543,
0.023658311,
0.0080526778,
0.7373813987,
0.8362306356,
-0.0047005108,
-0.0880303457,
-0.356344223,
0.0883944929,
0.7390059233,
-0.6562744379,
-0.1391912848,
0.3283270895,
-0.8315574527,
-0.467710793,
0.5165861845,
-0.7784704566,
-0.2817217112,
-0.3443761468,
0.116389662,
0.0818225741,
-0.6273524165,
0.1298132092,
-0.2834505737,
0.0585679077,
0.2528319955,
-0.7721325755,
0.1009391099,
1.0476132631,
0.5108165741,
0.1239880174,
0.0755320936,
-0.2238657027,
0.2433059067,
0.0126648713,
0.8958544731,
-0.7413701415,
-0.5224845409,
0.0506114699,
0.0616848208,
0.2324599773,
0.0993512422,
0.6691969037,
-0.8994543552,
-0.0010181372,
-0.1594797224,
-0.2652646601,
-0.2163205892,
0.4062077105,
-0.4042524397,
0.6067937613,
0.1482417881,
-0.3734466136,
0.8181651831,
-0.6883432269,
-0.3029152155,
-0.007862621,
-0.167042762,
0.1470514238,
0.3357955813,
-0.2189028561,
0.4491941631,
-0.0852981359,
0.423936516,
-0.1498282105,
-0.2297603935,
0.4166987836,
-0.0856186897,
0.4760634899,
0.3547910154,
-0.3559875488,
0.2832603157,
-0.4806866348,
0.2463698536,
-0.4299052358,
0.0271979142,
-0.5730057359,
0.1601872891,
-0.4326754808,
0.6264882684,
0.2908511162,
-0.6407604218,
0.0710352957,
-0.4773181975,
0.3735993207,
1.0483928919,
0.4925209284,
0.4307723045,
0.1998532712,
0.9288682342,
-0.0588876456,
1.006808877,
0.1847973615,
-0.7267784476,
-0.6139890552,
0.3354813457,
0.0067507988,
0.052283261,
-0.4902054369,
0.4771299958,
-0.2722452581,
-0.6619229317,
-0.4579139948,
0.098767288,
0.4959545135,
0.1574036926,
0.1335202754,
-0.5185072422,
-0.7975395918,
-0.8523420691,
-0.3311111331,
-0.4445533454,
0.0198944472,
0.3322748542,
0.0522321872,
-0.5159680247,
1.0159406662,
-0.8151327372,
-0.28676489,
-0.0671937466,
0.3214986324,
0.4435374141,
0.2818678021,
0.6878105998,
-1.0693465471,
-0.779112041,
0.0830978528,
-0.5839930177,
-0.1684244573,
-0.0478284992,
-0.3131224513,
0.1233844832,
0.4823040366,
-0.7924945951,
0.6178656816,
0.5148400068,
-0.2177626193,
0.0850096643,
0.3409818411,
0.3946562707,
-0.8478469253,
-0.2766102552,
0.2310907394,
0.0549695753,
-0.7171777487,
-0.3618750572,
-0.0883230492,
0.0735506788,
-0.3261763752,
0.6085425615,
-0.1574299037,
-0.2185997665,
-0.4144099653,
0.047204569,
0.0823367387,
0.3881927133,
0.185168758,
0.497068882,
0.2908502221,
-0.9988887906,
0.0706168413,
0.2510046065,
-0.0137752043,
0.3627889454,
-0.6118304729,
0.2365670353,
-0.1631779969,
-0.0912793651,
-1.1464315653,
-0.3326000869,
0.7089999914,
-0.9043443799,
0.1483790278,
-0.35915941,
-0.4232974648,
-0.5479930043,
-0.2735604048,
0.3083578646,
0.5340148807,
-0.3129127622,
0.5604257584,
0.6215272546,
-0.0167534463,
-0.316862613,
-0.6812639236,
-0.2790407836,
-0.167592749,
-0.4061509371,
0.2427721024,
-0.0081348857,
-0.281150341,
0.1813832968,
-0.1616852432,
-0.2727207839,
-0.0993229896,
0.5156602263,
-0.0790902153,
-0.0190803315,
0.3044641614,
0.0673194379,
-0.4128265381,
0.7242500782,
-0.3415499032,
0.6979416609,
0.1234851256,
-0.3384555876,
-0.280123651,
0.1360083669,
0.1287086755,
-0.1884930432,
0.9104030132,
0.5586416721,
-0.2636584342,
-0.1310304552,
-0.4962742031,
-0.3523882926,
-0.5876553059,
-0.0997790545,
-0.2991392612,
-0.6988697052,
0.2062552273,
0.009387346,
0.0826435462,
0.6609159708,
-0.1161218807,
-0.2568132281,
1.4837917089,
0.9746962786,
0.3846306503,
0.361183852,
0.1859933734,
0.6701260209,
-0.5562788844,
-0.1506478339,
-0.4864576459,
-0.5797379613,
-0.578697443,
-0.1234101504,
0.3592162728,
0.0753340349,
0.1413102299,
0.7115660906,
-1.0756477118,
0.4783012271,
0.2533541918,
-0.0255547855,
0.0630580336,
-0.0321936421,
0.5057582855,
-0.2057965547,
-0.3543035984,
-0.8316814303,
0.9643126726,
0.2007811368,
0.5082525015,
0.2928049266,
0.6188486218,
0.2635047734,
0.7309405804,
-0.6061624289,
0.7007315755,
0.0893468559,
-0.6135764718,
0.019066887,
-0.550978899,
-0.8831171393,
-0.4821687639,
0.3899547458,
-0.6523905993,
0.4187994897,
0.3392684162,
-0.3866908848,
0.3520620167,
-0.8502126932,
1.1294398308,
-0.4735423625,
0.1754552275,
-0.2178462595,
-0.4980761707,
0.6290527582,
-0.2454796731,
0.3307681382,
-0.0042292392,
-0.2649401724,
0.7315986753,
-0.1177993193,
0.9754866958,
-0.4496652186,
0.072765775,
0.4416635633,
0.0137378806,
0.331800282,
0.046543777,
-0.0944596455,
0.0235614087,
0.0716545656,
0.1079907864,
-0.4045909047,
0.6262336969,
-0.6946009994,
-0.576423943,
-0.2791832983,
0.3350001276,
-0.1375311315,
0.2248384356,
0.334169805,
0.2743873,
-0.243543312,
-0.0588967092,
0.6386951208,
-0.3302511573,
0.1618472189,
0.4583525658,
-0.5974650979,
0.0876417086,
0.8360707164,
-0.2867800593,
0.0543279499,
0.4070877135,
0.0081276521,
-0.317927897,
-0.6022440791,
0.0656042099,
0.1485214829,
-1.0485876799,
-0.391566515,
-0.9211884141,
-0.0922644511,
-0.5434409976,
-0.2632641792,
0.0187801849,
-0.3643353283,
-0.5892951488,
-0.2738839388,
0.7128475904,
1.1380596161,
0.0705332533,
0.6115360856,
-0.998030901,
0.0873147026,
-0.0723487809,
0.79355371,
-0.1916797757,
-0.3486862183,
-0.0220622681,
0.2120301872,
-0.1783089191,
-0.7668654323,
0.4569102228,
-0.0318320431,
0.6580305099,
0.6464616656,
0.1877684891,
0.5169095397,
0.1031985506,
0.510992229,
0.2439831495,
-0.5593591332,
1.2333056927,
-0.2646909058,
0.0376676545,
0.8973415494,
0.9960394502,
-0.8096410036,
-0.2618264854,
-0.8006594181,
-0.4050090611,
0.9533478618,
-0.0983781442,
0.2989435792,
-0.324906528,
0.6431804299,
0.1484020054,
0.3853145838,
-0.8478538394,
-0.0752950013,
-0.0864771903,
-0.2392245531,
0.271658808,
-0.3092645407,
-0.0815057084,
-0.1502321661,
0.6694898605,
-0.0893571004,
0.5866175294,
-0.0659100786,
-0.0326466076,
-0.2710672021,
0.2427386492,
0.702116549,
0.8095638752,
-0.0056670834,
0.1672316194,
-0.2114572525,
-0.3299579918,
0.1099597812,
-0.1221297979,
-0.1934459209,
0.1505601555,
-0.2621707916,
0.5450972915,
0.0422669314,
-0.515850246,
0.6627736092,
-0.5880289078,
0.0464649796,
-0.6054333448,
0.1819458902,
-0.0790510997,
-0.0597437248,
0.050966695,
0.5768046379,
0.4062306285,
-0.5076210499,
-0.0550010577,
0.2933143675,
-0.6624750495,
-0.7099043131,
0.3859986961,
0.401797235,
-0.6754201055,
0.3635207713,
-0.9718616605,
-0.630584836,
0.5785284042,
-0.2003494054,
1.0917671919,
-0.2484801561,
0.4833241999,
0.7974721193,
0.4470075369,
0.1447656006,
0.4282032251,
-0.049599953,
-0.5064377189,
-0.1043157205,
-0.8567388654,
0.07709115,
-0.2649812102,
-0.3282679915,
0.7448627353,
-0.703512907,
-0.4523419142,
0.0047270558,
-0.4812164009,
-0.5499172211,
0.1363342404,
-0.3720360994,
0.7418115139,
-0.573936224,
0.6082814932,
0.6825572848,
-0.5514252782,
-0.7434357405,
-0.1704971939,
0.1556797177,
-0.3998886645,
0.7510848641,
0.2445642501,
-0.1210603341,
-0.1038488299,
-0.3596926928,
-0.7870668173,
0.6115105152,
-0.450301677,
-0.5079789758,
-0.0704568923,
0.4781157076,
0.6010414362,
-0.329780668,
0.3011215627,
0.1480935812,
0.5997854471,
0.004976857,
-0.7325471044,
-0.0552299842,
-0.4363139868,
-0.3487069607,
0.7567489147,
-0.5205817819,
0.382083118,
0.4061788619,
-0.3724401891,
-0.3477816582,
0.2564487457,
-0.0178831946,
0.3000323176,
0.6286889911,
0.040078748,
0.2650260329,
-0.3935658932,
0.9700701833,
-0.687071383,
0.114414826,
0.4688151479,
-0.0646161735,
0.5962039232,
0.5826584101,
-0.1372848451,
0.3377140164,
0.8263368607,
-0.041000057,
0.4550928473,
-0.2249922454,
-0.1955359578,
-0.1211217642,
-0.3718062937,
-0.4260105193,
0.4295881093,
0.7275263667,
-0.6883051991,
0.0253656991,
0.0347979404,
-0.1807800978,
-0.0285337288,
-0.5293383002,
0.9804922938,
0.0430169962,
-1.0895080566,
-0.0358707495,
0.215493381,
0.8921354413,
-0.6871760488,
0.0872105584,
0.1678184569,
0.3638930321,
-0.5846797228,
-1.2065476179,
0.8285300732,
0.0773773417,
-0.1134055406,
-1.0000485182,
1.1175118685,
-0.0113651827,
-0.5685709715,
0.179020077,
0.1630939096,
0.196521014,
-0.0256110281,
-0.4167260826,
0.2545635998,
0.1127175018,
-0.1157907993,
0.0998110622,
0.5960553885,
0.1231973842,
0.1494870186,
0.3551439643,
-0.1742703617,
0.0415231213,
-0.1666957289,
0.9147030115,
-0.5803319216,
-0.4648847282,
-0.5952080488,
0.3803127706,
-0.2312117219,
-0.6120676398,
0.7906571627,
0.5643601418,
0.79573524,
-0.0624755733,
0.5890335441,
-0.3151036799,
0.5472398996,
-0.2749574184,
0.5426151752,
-0.3895916641,
0.4550223351,
-0.1769373119,
-0.8680128455,
-0.0765350908,
0.5372917056,
-0.5014454722,
0.5369325876,
0.2990098,
0.8204826713,
-0.1328176409,
0.4487275183,
-0.0516562387,
-0.0414549969,
0.2184053212,
0.404317379,
0.9495797157,
-0.2130488604,
0.791102469,
-0.5399591327,
-0.1190645173,
-0.203925848,
-0.6023836732,
-0.8128481507,
-0.5193864107,
-0.4385532141,
-0.1146147177,
-0.1861799657,
0.7906578779,
0.5991085172,
-0.5983728766,
-0.114348568,
-0.4718654156,
-0.0763033479,
0.0951958895,
-0.3301621675,
-0.2451445609,
-0.2901989222,
-0.1858727336,
-0.1009211317,
0.366695106,
0.0150558203,
-0.391920954,
-0.1546018273,
-0.2232592404,
-0.2076277435,
0.6718967557,
0.3037911355,
-0.6799499393,
-0.4827642739,
0.5393821597,
-0.2791422307,
0.0936924294,
0.8111305237,
-0.5415939093,
0.2230709642,
0.5361478925,
0.2029903233,
0.40575248,
-0.1574136615,
0.6598365307,
-1.1627354622,
-0.2917833626,
0.4535977542,
0.1411598623,
-0.0799375474,
-0.6330911517,
0.5817793608,
-0.1795234382,
-0.5053800344,
-0.6550209522,
0.1605286598,
-0.7112377286,
-0.3601961732,
1.2374726534,
0.1997855455,
-0.2186279297,
-0.2499281466,
-0.2586271763,
0.1768452227,
-0.3372479379,
0.8595736027,
0.7528865933,
-0.2022566646,
-0.6296126842,
-0.7882300615,
0.8219845891,
-0.228207916,
-0.9683197141,
-0.1797515005,
0.3600575924,
-0.1848455817,
0.475625664,
0.8155789375,
0.0250390191,
0.6693247557,
-0.4127304554,
0.2250962555,
0.3934096098,
-0.1941653192,
-0.0934740975,
0.2723368704,
0.2146327198,
0.2021852732
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14069v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14069v1
|
EmphAssess : a Prosodic Benchmark on Assessing Emphasis Transfer in Speech-to-Speech Models
| 2023-12-21T17:47:33 | 2023-12-21T17:47:33 |
Maureen de Seyssel, Antony D'Avirro, Adina Williams, Emmanuel Dupoux
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
We introduce EmphAssess, a prosodic benchmark designed to evaluate the
capability of speech-to-speech models to encode and reproduce prosodic
emphasis. We apply this to two tasks: speech resynthesis and speech-to-speech
translation. In both cases, the benchmark evaluates the ability of the model to
encode emphasis in the speech input and accurately reproduce it in the output,
potentially across a change of speaker and language. As part of the evaluation
pipeline, we introduce EmphaClass, a new model that classifies emphasis at the
frame or word level.
|
[
-0.1362634897,
-0.7253449559,
0.539304316,
0.3970156908,
-0.2150702178,
-0.3005445302,
-0.2334249318,
-0.323269248,
0.2579443455,
0.402128607,
-0.3519953489,
-0.2538439929,
-0.4535002112,
0.1786755919,
-0.7505918145,
0.5428048968,
-0.0555662028,
0.0295485407,
-0.0327009335,
0.0462964885,
-0.100337781,
-0.4255099595,
-0.3621265888,
-0.28161937,
-0.0182748102,
0.5611007214,
0.6707618237,
0.3298470974,
0.7836295962,
0.2477235496,
-0.2117072493,
-0.1167942807,
-0.1057992056,
0.6593208313,
-0.2479618192,
-0.1985473633,
-0.4995264113,
-0.0869124681,
1.2215365171,
0.8652576804,
-0.055079177,
0.3970373869,
0.3674355745,
0.3215368986,
-1.0212724209,
-0.0459433831,
-0.2637140751,
0.0466065742,
-0.2020658553,
-0.2987128496,
-0.4899971783,
-0.6440857053,
0.4452874064,
-0.3885077834,
-0.1164965928,
0.082222566,
0.4543726444,
0.4708382487,
-0.2243718356,
0.189037323,
-0.605568707,
0.7226309776,
-0.4725732207,
0.8462833762,
0.1600241214,
0.2269669622,
0.0793501064,
-1.1578240395,
-0.2836230993,
-0.2426793575,
0.1683200896,
0.1422400028,
0.1353507489,
0.3353016973,
0.0334635079,
0.6088289618,
-0.2717847228,
-0.2054761499,
-0.0882282481,
-0.0210512783,
0.6125892997,
-0.0428021625,
0.1809996217,
-0.032039687,
-0.3922465742,
-0.0723716766,
-0.3969710767,
0.0418448299,
-0.0226025414,
0.3263282478,
0.1234347522,
0.4136203229,
-0.3146545887,
0.4872747958,
0.2084525377,
-0.0438470691,
0.2671827674,
-0.2609954774,
-0.3026857972,
0.5953407288,
0.3843072951,
0.4446303248,
0.1383637786,
-0.1871206015,
0.0730131492,
-0.0718467534,
0.3951458037,
-0.925937295,
-0.1720382869,
0.0420463979,
-0.2809120417,
-0.2980632782,
-0.2079330236,
-0.8692368865,
-0.3573473692,
-0.1687807143,
0.4681249261,
-0.1479797363,
-0.0904106274,
-0.0219312049,
-0.2780573964,
0.2755570114,
0.352167666,
-0.9216662049,
0.8280158639,
0.9674478173,
0.9357244968,
-0.4994157553,
-0.4358860254,
-0.3260143399,
0.0519838929,
-0.2944332361,
0.8874770403,
-0.7259793282,
-0.3116424382,
0.0736420229,
0.2666938007,
-0.2250670344,
-0.54985708,
0.9949637651,
-0.0000438637,
-0.2634426355,
-0.2332697958,
-1.0125638247,
-0.2408557236,
0.1336968094,
-0.3982145786,
1.0800585747,
0.2137321085,
-0.6076208353,
0.0432533845,
-0.3315106034,
-0.4708451331,
0.0526821911,
0.0361639187,
-0.3638493419,
0.3415088952,
-0.1281822771,
0.130364567,
-0.5878328681,
-0.0199578162,
-0.5933386087,
-0.3310275376,
0.4949050248,
-0.2310250401,
0.4934042096,
0.0628934652,
-0.3391342163,
-0.1357749701,
-0.6742033362,
0.3821309507,
-0.1620821655,
0.1312551051,
-0.256123364,
0.0447843038,
0.1199303344,
-0.0238761734,
0.2261444032,
-0.5840499401,
-0.2166810334,
-0.2698554993,
0.5780635476,
0.1877415627,
0.3762964904,
0.5262108445,
-0.1057505459,
0.4942314327,
-0.4020854533,
0.1825230569,
-0.1290146261,
-0.642927587,
-0.5500918031,
-0.1754376143,
0.492608428,
0.7216710448,
0.1378053278,
0.2838311493,
-0.0745578408,
-0.563373208,
-0.9818472266,
-0.2889618576,
0.3927411139,
0.7018933296,
0.4578531682,
-0.8672469854,
-0.4182811379,
-1.0134176016,
-0.4809689224,
-0.1445667744,
0.148512125,
-0.0592498966,
0.2468197495,
0.4758960605,
0.6927469969,
-0.3385082781,
-0.285283953,
-0.067017287,
0.2743809521,
-0.3360740542,
0.7392058372,
0.3630663157,
-0.6020627022,
-0.2940458953,
-0.1992520839,
-0.4439503551,
-0.6111828089,
0.2357083261,
-0.0947425067,
-0.3403712213,
0.7713009715,
-0.2769499123,
0.3412008286,
0.6090754271,
-0.254866004,
0.6329268813,
-0.0192878041,
0.6148647666,
-0.8195081949,
0.2703340054,
-0.4638769627,
-0.2686112523,
-0.9135190845,
0.0256033856,
0.2985022664,
-0.3400842845,
-0.6425454617,
0.4381890595,
-0.3469761908,
-0.7844605446,
-0.1208535805,
0.466239363,
0.2206152827,
0.1736699343,
0.1757547259,
0.6936522126,
0.3852147758,
-0.407864958,
0.2003404051,
0.2755811512,
-0.3850599229,
1.0468629599,
-0.6372191906,
0.2030841708,
0.4433308542,
0.0191392917,
-1.2977377176,
0.0065113413,
-0.0677678064,
-0.406747371,
0.3948481381,
-0.5080705285,
-0.2679453194,
-0.1455816925,
-0.0763058364,
0.4406973124,
0.6249460578,
-0.1289391369,
0.3075830638,
0.406478554,
-0.5829259157,
-0.3232861161,
-0.8681455255,
-0.1983741671,
-0.2359140068,
-0.5669049025,
0.8351481557,
0.2975700498,
-0.3981539905,
0.0987970382,
-0.0283597521,
-0.382451117,
0.3390506506,
0.2484181374,
-0.2837615311,
-0.1041258723,
0.0446437225,
0.1439647228,
-0.0465318225,
0.2310718894,
-0.2942955494,
0.3751782477,
-0.0284373481,
-0.606366694,
-0.8073464036,
0.3134305477,
0.7332296968,
-0.2276294082,
0.4467965364,
0.2492887229,
-0.3300541937,
0.0072335456,
-0.3748437166,
-0.4560671151,
-0.4228941202,
0.6224575043,
-0.4015975595,
-0.579280138,
0.4095370471,
-0.3730788529,
0.1158780828,
0.2525496483,
0.4032232463,
-0.0845318884,
1.0273052454,
0.3734662235,
0.2401302755,
0.6721134782,
0.219430849,
-0.1016057432,
-1.0947650671,
0.0346932597,
-0.7774248719,
-0.4453803897,
-0.3596883416,
-0.5694596767,
0.1185789406,
0.1953885704,
-0.3004997075,
0.2598816752,
-0.4236540496,
0.3165254593,
0.1490708888,
-0.1332862377,
0.2436234504,
-0.031885244,
0.0696557239,
-0.49868384,
-0.232469812,
-0.4747014642,
0.9875760078,
0.3394859433,
0.5212967396,
-0.0185132921,
0.6300540566,
0.3731315732,
0.3022527695,
-0.8361130953,
0.6204799414,
-0.3141630888,
-0.5296099782,
-0.3039270937,
-0.0268004835,
-0.7114182115,
0.4580988884,
0.0463202037,
-0.7231027484,
0.4413599372,
0.2437792569,
-0.3154368699,
0.0536216684,
-0.4880515337,
0.9333415031,
-0.1023053005,
-0.6828076839,
-0.499296248,
-0.4348559678,
0.051096648,
0.1640712023,
0.1755423248,
-0.4560512602,
-0.3788869679,
0.7358567715,
-0.2234704643,
0.5795953274,
-0.1864824295,
-0.0342951454,
0.3193717599,
0.3906912506,
0.4555474222,
-0.3850176632,
-0.3597003222,
-0.1340996027,
-0.3580464423,
-0.0735106692,
-0.6291447878,
0.3204539716,
-0.5106722713,
-0.4703029692,
-0.0269802529,
-0.4126955867,
-0.3291001916,
-0.0557171777,
0.1008764654,
0.6530065536,
-0.7304810882,
0.2093343884,
0.6391125917,
0.3182139397,
0.2206329554,
0.5976397991,
-0.1270736158,
-0.5263956785,
0.5563694835,
0.3908602893,
0.6905242205,
0.4021975696,
0.0826348588,
-0.5765562057,
-0.4721631408,
-0.2666960061,
0.1870513856,
-0.8671376705,
0.2397704571,
-0.7368458509,
-0.359169215,
-0.6892865896,
-0.4456014633,
-0.8680440187,
-0.9019244909,
-0.0739449486,
0.0891992897,
0.3806762099,
0.4152157903,
-0.0041305996,
0.2239188105,
-0.7436355352,
0.0504142083,
0.5921473503,
0.0654451326,
-0.4681192935,
-1.4996602535,
0.0118871527,
-0.3730799556,
-0.4604844749,
-1.4072158337,
0.4149407148,
0.536262691,
0.715632081,
0.3371450901,
0.211778,
0.57436198,
-0.5861328244,
0.7135581374,
0.0308305342,
-1.3175191879,
0.6708057523,
0.088580355,
0.154567346,
0.8903764486,
0.2786152959,
-0.7714545131,
-0.5766376257,
-0.9761476517,
-0.904242456,
0.6015959382,
0.2662104666,
-0.4873508215,
0.1201713011,
0.1629973799,
-0.28820315,
0.3813733757,
-0.0755734071,
-0.0846725777,
0.1205204949,
-0.27410689,
-0.0551719218,
-0.4539517164,
-0.1260937899,
-0.2107847482,
0.3947054744,
-0.0487851128,
0.3074327707,
0.6367884278,
-0.6081510782,
0.1058617234,
0.7007414103,
0.5986002684,
0.2644344866,
-0.3554647565,
0.5147886872,
0.6469821334,
-0.6232460737,
0.4484261274,
0.3694444895,
-0.4590867758,
0.1420626044,
0.252374053,
0.6803631186,
0.9201200008,
-0.4171468616,
0.5393194556,
0.2696857154,
-0.2608715594,
-0.1327955872,
-0.1612455994,
0.0269174017,
0.3099377155,
0.0429894924,
-0.1714233458,
0.6860770583,
-0.455350101,
0.4160195291,
-0.1057602614,
-0.6947610378,
-0.6928181052,
0.7090899348,
0.5986662507,
-0.3951131701,
0.4083021879,
-0.096376732,
-0.7550436854,
0.7198815942,
0.6144555807,
1.4270590544,
-0.8412775993,
-0.1731531918,
0.494158715,
0.3111749589,
-0.3361751735,
0.7083585262,
-0.3041903675,
-0.4708948731,
-0.1858281046,
-0.4853106141,
-0.9666466117,
-0.6218205094,
-1.1650736332,
0.2815226614,
-0.4140925407,
-0.5251170993,
0.1972047091,
-0.1543034315,
-0.2478072792,
-0.0185819026,
0.5560335517,
0.7760532498,
-1.2652945518,
0.7969640493,
0.7375609875,
-0.0400818735,
-0.3636426926,
-0.0010916521,
0.0904919729,
-0.6155589223,
0.5667574406,
0.2943814397,
-0.2117797881,
0.2430582047,
-0.084167257,
-1.1326973438,
0.934128046,
0.5192644,
-0.5786030889,
0.349560976,
0.1682832092,
0.5192109942,
-0.556950748,
0.4337944984,
1.0862473249,
0.5401924849,
-0.3559415638,
-1.3207727671,
0.1210831106,
-0.0229267254,
-0.0166507531,
-0.043205563,
-0.8196467757,
1.0301910639,
0.0351298228,
-0.2481559515,
-0.1088449657,
0.7180134654,
0.1914583445,
0.133381933,
0.5835252404,
0.7280189395,
0.8697209954,
-0.2394342124,
0.8864603043,
-0.4749359787,
0.3348412216,
1.2227467299,
-0.7241399288,
1.3464360237,
0.4552747011,
-0.3623286784,
0.37198475,
0.3824858665,
0.255633086,
0.6373667717,
-0.0035092889,
-0.0672110692,
-0.2948048115,
-0.4661619663,
-0.6526774764,
0.3954327106,
0.6456386447,
-0.6016200185,
-0.001794302,
-0.0681051165,
0.0442534275,
0.0119039966,
-0.3372839689,
0.7167149782,
0.222020492,
-1.0632517338,
0.5909582973,
-0.3733093143,
0.1181236282,
-0.4036714733,
0.161380738,
-0.1478645653,
0.6408198476,
-0.0929584205,
-0.9358563423,
0.4625060558,
-0.2404694408,
0.0076021943,
-0.4912921786,
0.7022977471,
-0.6639683247,
-0.2190134823,
0.4366532862,
0.1423100382,
0.5027440786,
-0.069772236,
-0.7616260648,
0.1563758105,
-0.2021665573,
-0.3241857886,
0.2519351244,
0.2872163057,
0.1132019013,
0.4866302609,
-0.0603888556,
0.1143599153,
0.2468640059,
0.4510990977,
0.4101934731,
-0.620272696,
-0.6754100323,
-0.6734250188,
0.0535750464,
-0.1009682864,
-0.4440166056,
0.8911267519,
0.4886362553,
0.3971903324,
0.2512813509,
0.6005260348,
0.0520012677,
0.6622171402,
-0.2247068733,
0.4169458151,
-0.5566177964,
-0.382707417,
-0.5643119216,
-1.0202200413,
0.0682621375,
0.5115374327,
-0.3351683021,
-0.3304783702,
1.0186026096,
0.6770151854,
0.2144781798,
0.4564739764,
0.3127543926,
0.0496588424,
-0.2615190446,
0.417538017,
1.0874961615,
-0.4169025421,
0.451851368,
-0.4778632224,
-0.2128401697,
-0.4826959074,
-0.6492429376,
-0.2993015647,
-0.3304778934,
-0.7666971087,
-0.2864581645,
0.2887433469,
0.9013482332,
0.8095602393,
-0.8698931336,
-0.400957793,
-0.0140287234,
-0.2286542952,
-0.8766160607,
-0.1310939938,
0.4222297966,
-0.556099534,
-0.9761753678,
0.5458953977,
0.3307880759,
0.2171138227,
-0.1395759583,
0.1712137014,
0.0129745929,
0.0587609112,
0.2453554571,
0.4054175615,
-0.478926152,
-0.1791375875,
-0.1038740128,
-0.107649222,
0.0127881346,
0.9448782206,
-0.2196769714,
0.3790018559,
0.8184763193,
0.6533340216,
0.5409489274,
0.0705039129,
0.6578705907,
-0.9129154682,
0.5403679013,
0.2580062449,
0.479462713,
0.4537574649,
0.0048352652,
0.466983676,
0.2839291394,
-0.7230385542,
-1.0985509157,
0.0579945929,
-0.8083534241,
-0.0101855425,
1.1072545052,
-0.5294315815,
-0.3942375481,
-0.3331918716,
0.1096995771,
0.3115677834,
-0.3406153917,
0.3221028149,
0.5626660585,
-0.0444807038,
-0.3360788822,
-0.6385020614,
0.7304219007,
1.0726394653,
-0.7646378279,
0.4345867038,
0.1712277681,
0.1509977132,
0.2028146982,
0.566405952,
-0.2890646458,
0.5636439323,
0.4106246531,
0.3965117931,
0.4046971798,
-0.4054834247,
-0.5125115514,
0.5249782801,
0.2462214231,
-0.4369521737
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14033v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14033v3
|
T-Eval: Evaluating the Tool Utilization Capability of Large Language Models Step by Step
| 2023-12-21T17:02:06 | 2024-01-15T03:18:25 |
Zehui Chen, Weihua Du, Wenwei Zhang, Kuikun Liu, Jiangning Liu, Miao Zheng, Jingming Zhuo, Songyang Zhang, Dahua Lin, Kai Chen, Feng Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLM) have achieved remarkable performance on various
NLP tasks and are augmented by tools for broader applications. Yet, how to
evaluate and analyze the tool-utilization capability of LLMs is still
under-explored. In contrast to previous works that evaluate models
holistically, we comprehensively decompose the tool utilization into multiple
sub-processes, including instruction following, planning, reasoning, retrieval,
understanding, and review. Based on that, we further introduce T-Eval to
evaluate the tool utilization capability step by step. T-Eval disentangles the
tool utilization evaluation into several sub-domains along model capabilities,
facilitating the inner understanding of both holistic and isolated competency
of LLMs. We conduct extensive experiments on T-Eval and in-depth analysis of
various LLMs. T-Eval not only exhibits consistency with the outcome-oriented
evaluation but also provides a more fine-grained analysis of the capabilities
of LLMs, providing a new perspective in LLM evaluation on tool-utilization
ability. The benchmark will be available at
https://github.com/open-compass/T-Eval.
|
[
-0.270835042,
-1.0019472837,
0.6998987198,
0.2082906514,
-0.195027113,
0.7067350149,
-0.4278414249,
-0.2736476064,
-0.2004713714,
0.608348608,
-0.3680427969,
-0.7966636419,
-0.617869556,
0.0468384586,
-0.658618927,
0.6808845401,
-0.1110229045,
0.0598222688,
-0.2296334654,
0.0134972511,
-0.4140873849,
-0.3341454268,
-0.6202594042,
-0.4803667963,
0.2924197316,
0.3493822217,
0.4346247315,
0.3111745119,
0.5570405722,
0.3022298217,
0.0112618636,
-0.192922771,
-0.5255496502,
-0.0829900801,
-0.3682976663,
-0.2791332901,
-0.8518488407,
-0.0535226613,
0.9165173769,
0.8743627667,
-0.1611729264,
0.5610018373,
0.2550135553,
0.2796851695,
-0.5859441757,
0.051872611,
-0.610077858,
-0.1638456136,
-0.2338422388,
-0.1500471234,
-0.5068837404,
-0.3811071813,
0.3142835498,
-0.2814364731,
0.0649695471,
0.0178845041,
0.4243505895,
0.1768987477,
-0.391223073,
-0.1301797628,
-0.8757734299,
1.1126714945,
-0.6691324711,
0.5297009349,
0.4193644524,
0.320166409,
0.0522504374,
-0.7661890984,
-0.2470194995,
-0.5328709483,
0.1212598756,
-0.2216844559,
-0.1763095707,
0.1738228202,
0.2918755114,
0.4777092934,
-0.4597966373,
0.3069114685,
-0.4205565155,
-0.0900304243,
0.7590293288,
0.4021041989,
0.3947908282,
0.1625311673,
-0.3381775618,
0.1182207465,
-0.5203603506,
-0.2120564878,
-0.1212894768,
0.0893741548,
-0.147582382,
0.8929727077,
0.1877787113,
0.5041440725,
-0.2214744985,
-0.4018502831,
0.3188601136,
-0.425940901,
-0.5469248295,
-0.2589395046,
0.7583899498,
0.1796763986,
0.0788935423,
-0.3168387413,
-0.493242085,
-0.2817354202,
0.5317801237,
-0.6373884678,
0.3414346576,
0.3864717484,
-0.4918687344,
-0.2956685424,
-0.3240905404,
-0.6333062649,
-0.3521030545,
-0.2603803277,
0.5391727686,
-0.3565804064,
-0.5003139377,
0.1408613026,
-0.1671299636,
0.2682873607,
0.3630409837,
-0.379247278,
0.6216320395,
1.0364105701,
1.0205514431,
-0.429667592,
-0.3198824525,
-0.6204607487,
-0.2192763388,
-0.4385217428,
0.4871781468,
-0.773801744,
-0.5672773123,
0.1916317344,
-0.1470107287,
-0.1823545694,
-0.5334990621,
0.4341238439,
-0.6835300922,
-0.2134518921,
-0.1383398324,
-0.6656054258,
-0.2417044193,
0.4345107079,
-0.7508088946,
1.0716159344,
0.5918309689,
-0.3279092014,
0.2595580816,
-0.9040155411,
-0.1923884004,
0.216063112,
0.2040915191,
-0.2523622513,
0.4188235402,
-0.0834256411,
0.3659192622,
-0.5581681728,
0.2797425091,
-0.5284869075,
-0.313202858,
0.216539368,
-0.2735479474,
0.9029259682,
0.0316940993,
-0.0352825113,
0.3382369578,
-0.5583662391,
0.2172790319,
-0.0829546601,
-0.3362536728,
-0.1657925695,
-0.0855969489,
0.0880765393,
0.0689798072,
0.3773181736,
-0.5855987668,
0.2681119442,
-0.5031887293,
0.290192157,
0.4347344339,
-0.0217934735,
0.4600277245,
0.1110143065,
0.8549668193,
-0.4385122955,
0.0395003594,
0.0388061218,
0.0943314284,
-0.9301085472,
-0.0611791089,
0.3581004143,
0.4587186575,
-0.7457103729,
0.4508942068,
-0.1031465679,
-0.7166479826,
-0.5797314048,
0.1515117586,
0.7149390578,
0.236005187,
0.3907538652,
-0.3809691072,
-0.4363605082,
-0.8341883421,
-0.2929458022,
-0.1785793006,
-0.1876490116,
0.1769890487,
0.7369543314,
-0.1018240973,
0.6644824743,
-0.2689185441,
-0.2565426826,
-0.7697001696,
0.1599662751,
0.0245180018,
0.1953792572,
0.457224071,
-0.2224529982,
-0.49441728,
0.0749727041,
-0.5537905097,
-0.5536006689,
0.052809421,
-0.102309823,
0.3472383022,
0.4486045241,
-0.2538363338,
0.4812485874,
0.5045327544,
-0.3797083497,
0.7050427794,
-0.1330834031,
-0.0527168065,
-0.6634473205,
0.2554782629,
0.1168004274,
-0.2207843661,
-0.6613382101,
0.175460428,
0.1741904616,
0.0945101082,
-0.481901288,
0.7059953213,
-0.4326486588,
-0.5253981948,
-0.3556160331,
0.1783649325,
0.0375251994,
0.2115475237,
-0.0419044048,
0.9415147305,
0.5078521371,
-0.4529429376,
0.20824036,
-0.1326393038,
-0.3911015391,
0.2437496632,
-0.7235191464,
0.2027669996,
0.338683784,
-0.0361585952,
-0.606446147,
0.0111107221,
-0.1433268785,
0.0621554255,
0.3535922766,
-0.0880713314,
-0.6001787186,
-0.2967674136,
-0.4149668515,
0.3608064651,
0.5132665038,
-0.3713286221,
0.9144716263,
0.4771169424,
0.0027674772,
-0.4526345134,
-0.2896611691,
0.1572638452,
-0.2790749371,
-0.3062791824,
0.2053384185,
-0.0031020492,
-0.5805102587,
-0.0801121294,
-0.1838102341,
-0.1301115453,
0.2821098268,
-0.0407045335,
0.3042291403,
-0.2272943556,
0.1291338801,
-0.0536958724,
-0.1338186562,
0.3266762197,
-0.1317638159,
0.8343044519,
-0.3961941004,
-0.5861505866,
-0.3450449109,
0.1578849703,
0.44346717,
-0.4097886682,
0.5841045976,
0.5581243634,
-0.2232418358,
-0.2258405089,
-0.7460438609,
0.1769763976,
-0.4318950474,
0.6385571361,
-0.3046487272,
-0.6754584312,
0.3060714304,
-0.1749019772,
0.372130394,
0.4920648634,
0.6483995914,
0.2517576218,
0.757656157,
0.7926422358,
0.0252221394,
0.3072940111,
-0.4660771191,
0.2206745744,
-1.2019870281,
-0.3881007433,
-0.4975350499,
-0.1231735125,
-0.1981028318,
-0.6875357628,
0.3491263986,
0.1496215165,
-0.3098475635,
0.2606155872,
-0.1140725315,
0.5974966288,
0.2098906934,
-0.1289401948,
0.3764523864,
-0.2519472241,
0.0381373428,
0.1160084605,
-0.3467962444,
-0.9468642473,
1.3382388353,
0.6415966749,
0.7717298865,
-0.1042134687,
0.6721400023,
0.2862789035,
0.513733685,
-1.2245069742,
0.8431530595,
-0.2028874904,
-0.2792774439,
-0.2892236412,
0.0368525013,
-0.7844647169,
0.3828547001,
-0.0072615426,
-0.9872459173,
-0.3595613837,
-0.0834547877,
-0.210937202,
0.4308699071,
-0.8006128669,
0.812194705,
-0.5016545057,
-0.3086612523,
-0.492233485,
-0.143793419,
0.3053338528,
-0.4725532234,
-0.0304597169,
-0.0974314734,
-0.4908640087,
0.6617122889,
-0.2308143079,
0.695887208,
-0.0357386321,
-0.2563994825,
0.2672203779,
0.3071169555,
0.1164401025,
-0.1649505794,
-0.4622856379,
0.4718052745,
0.0703155771,
-0.0400183573,
-0.6087093353,
0.5702193975,
-0.5701818466,
-0.7780630589,
-0.2799910009,
-0.4479414821,
-0.2629797459,
0.3352319598,
-0.2828862667,
0.3930124938,
-0.6125463843,
0.3160460293,
0.281193912,
-0.3183835149,
0.6486903429,
0.5786815882,
-0.6270893812,
-0.0904683694,
0.639162302,
0.0796352625,
0.4542818666,
0.2784253657,
0.2617141604,
-0.4471934438,
-0.7868994474,
-0.2077030241,
0.1215192378,
-0.534447372,
-0.0211062804,
-0.6617937088,
-0.2956591249,
0.0509769171,
-0.1263989508,
-0.450889647,
-0.2817750871,
-0.1596086323,
0.0664501935,
-0.1450841427,
0.9124283791,
0.3308769464,
0.24299182,
-0.8633896112,
0.2192459404,
-0.0155409835,
0.4801041484,
0.2763062119,
-0.3353829682,
-0.3233681917,
-0.0845390931,
-0.5147935152,
-0.648034215,
0.4571005702,
0.1400851309,
0.5894474387,
0.2337741852,
0.0277470499,
0.5918527842,
-0.4902408719,
1.0011692047,
-0.0074832318,
-1.2735793591,
0.4265361428,
-0.1215045154,
0.1748277992,
0.2249042392,
0.1813676059,
-0.2548055947,
-0.5528976917,
-0.7153226137,
-0.814135313,
0.8283320665,
0.1806559861,
-0.0494806767,
0.2679952383,
-0.0401768759,
0.2528451979,
0.2570593953,
-0.5493863821,
0.1323712617,
0.1667804718,
0.1859086454,
-0.1685350984,
-0.4868330657,
-0.1000148505,
-0.2401389033,
0.5855261087,
0.0906827673,
0.066348061,
-0.2220904529,
-0.2865332961,
-0.0161011629,
0.6536713839,
0.2379348576,
1.1635195017,
-0.1128281057,
-0.0043507591,
0.6344346404,
-0.3870275021,
-0.1510266066,
-0.1931726485,
0.1952560991,
-0.1307421774,
0.7611683607,
0.6469779015,
0.0977494419,
-0.7351285815,
0.3151501417,
0.1451644301,
-0.1317543089,
-0.4086610675,
0.3403432369,
0.0577261858,
0.4993685484,
0.2527391911,
-0.3484110534,
0.1895631105,
-0.5299431086,
-0.0663197413,
0.5877723694,
-0.117986165,
-0.3610872328,
0.2291361839,
0.2821764648,
-0.6677123308,
0.5083702207,
-0.1324024796,
-0.5809146166,
0.6485836506,
0.6456190944,
1.2906014919,
-0.2813783884,
0.162960127,
0.3855925798,
0.3518680632,
0.1234142929,
0.260132134,
0.0729469806,
-0.4956045151,
-0.7127025127,
-0.6431988478,
-0.3583423793,
0.5532389879,
-0.7219536304,
0.2265261412,
-0.3470206559,
-0.1171532646,
0.0265804753,
0.303176105,
-0.8595745564,
-0.0359169431,
-0.2481773943,
1.0733475685,
-0.6866998076,
0.9246568084,
0.5961444378,
-0.1880659461,
-0.7505133152,
0.1884168684,
0.1017220169,
-0.9120540023,
0.8022619486,
0.1249900833,
-0.2977445424,
-0.1442931145,
-0.3368769884,
-0.7511105537,
1.1092209816,
0.2435178906,
-0.4745737612,
0.1001224816,
0.1897338182,
0.7880861759,
-0.56565696,
0.4288256168,
1.1171967983,
0.4906168878,
0.0136980563,
-1.4652163982,
0.0182514992,
-0.1030114144,
0.2430238277,
0.2018006891,
-0.2439656407,
0.5833459496,
-0.2404845059,
-0.2857430279,
0.0585466176,
0.1289672852,
0.1742175519,
0.4476895332,
0.5858948231,
0.3876499534,
0.3964909315,
-0.0067413095,
1.0396475792,
-0.1721169949,
0.5245558023,
0.9439677596,
-0.4078451991,
1.064047575,
0.4305276275,
-0.2961874902,
0.2474650294,
0.3049529195,
0.0073283101,
0.0644606203,
0.123215802,
-0.2936053574,
-0.4592733085,
-0.356924057,
-0.0624708831,
0.6356357932,
0.5923854113,
-0.3828086853,
-0.5747618675,
-0.0188527498,
-0.1847904474,
-0.1901823282,
-0.4178916216,
0.8315145969,
0.2519342303,
-0.6308369637,
0.4431076944,
0.0380888581,
0.1180526316,
-0.4999728799,
-0.2272596657,
0.2195868343,
0.1043749824,
-0.1947422326,
-1.2422248125,
0.4599746764,
0.3416422009,
0.197384119,
-0.4052206576,
0.9116879702,
-0.2657533288,
-0.4801864028,
0.5166343451,
0.7913727164,
0.1565125287,
0.1335372031,
-0.6068801284,
0.3207511306,
-0.0902296603,
-0.4687100649,
0.2414423227,
0.2879908681,
-0.0876980647,
0.9007572532,
0.4380741715,
0.1367587745,
-0.2501876056,
0.4323362112,
0.8010085821,
-0.617747426,
-0.0102618309,
-1.0978069305,
0.6994177699,
-0.1818760335,
-0.0751548484,
0.7464541793,
0.6728407145,
0.831053853,
0.0017376663,
0.8586286306,
-0.1708149612,
0.4971744418,
-0.5688683987,
0.4998146296,
-0.719983995,
0.7009324431,
-0.1558017135,
-0.9956108928,
-0.1680918187,
0.4842221737,
-0.6056101918,
0.2292201817,
0.9172941446,
0.5912412405,
-0.1407081932,
-0.1326233447,
0.398357898,
0.1361676008,
0.4231478572,
0.4098967314,
0.9093263149,
-0.0841832981,
0.2746213078,
-0.2025174499,
-0.2132557929,
-0.2631886601,
-1.0085548162,
-1.2347998619,
-0.4362308979,
-0.2884737253,
-0.3464345336,
-0.3630869389,
1.060839653,
0.4082099795,
-0.5133947134,
-0.6509923935,
0.137818113,
0.2920081019,
-0.1280697584,
-0.2275755107,
0.4220529795,
-0.5526678562,
-0.8235948086,
0.4668292403,
0.4378148913,
-0.1765401363,
-0.6400479078,
-0.0189295709,
0.0906199887,
-0.0059041176,
0.9272497296,
0.0190675855,
-0.8868325949,
-0.1270586252,
-0.0304327421,
0.0938872397,
-0.0764748007,
0.9566224813,
-0.541076839,
0.5455242395,
0.4461039305,
0.609187007,
0.3885549307,
-0.0841243863,
0.7177198529,
-0.6543751359,
-0.3044570684,
0.344470799,
0.2949847877,
0.0456082411,
0.0487803668,
0.6531592607,
-0.4196878672,
-0.5031980872,
-0.9315728545,
0.2017530054,
-1.0241289139,
-0.1186531186,
1.4129273891,
-0.1706016362,
0.0065450296,
-0.3113165796,
-0.2579573393,
0.2187010795,
-0.3649913669,
0.6748323441,
0.7932557464,
-0.1744128615,
-0.2087942064,
-0.7714993954,
0.2178912461,
0.0793723986,
-0.8906774521,
0.0939868689,
0.3292798996,
0.3739675879,
0.1534732878,
0.7030404806,
-0.1149668097,
-0.0525078252,
-0.1989350021,
-0.2832500935,
-0.2245613337,
-0.2460686713,
-0.4314230084,
0.2249495983,
0.3630671203,
-0.0412913263
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14226v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14226v1
|
Deep de Finetti: Recovering Topic Distributions from Large Language Models
| 2023-12-21T16:44:39 | 2023-12-21T16:44:39 |
Liyi Zhang, R. Thomas McCoy, Theodore R. Sumers, Jian-Qiao Zhu, Thomas L. Griffiths
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ML, I.2.6; I.2.7
|
Large language models (LLMs) can produce long, coherent passages of text,
suggesting that LLMs, although trained on next-word prediction, must represent
the latent structure that characterizes a document. Prior work has found that
internal representations of LLMs encode one aspect of latent structure, namely
syntax; here we investigate a complementary aspect, namely the document's topic
structure. We motivate the hypothesis that LLMs capture topic structure by
connecting LLM optimization to implicit Bayesian inference. De Finetti's
theorem shows that exchangeable probability distributions can be represented as
a mixture with respect to a latent generating distribution. Although text is
not exchangeable at the level of syntax, exchangeability is a reasonable
starting assumption for topic structure. We thus hypothesize that predicting
the next token in text will lead LLMs to recover latent topic distributions. We
examine this hypothesis using Latent Dirichlet Allocation (LDA), an
exchangeable probabilistic topic model, as a target, and we show that the
representations formed by LLMs encode both the topics used to generate
synthetic data and those used to explain natural corpus data.
|
[
-0.3143979609,
-0.8961336613,
1.0239384174,
-0.1525106877,
-0.3199967146,
-0.1491366476,
-0.2640008032,
-0.0341507345,
0.2597379088,
0.7051947117,
-0.4031020701,
-0.2845974863,
-0.607427597,
-0.2080056518,
-0.5801925063,
0.9923737645,
0.1650484055,
0.0152605688,
0.0823621824,
0.317525506,
-0.1024014428,
-0.4794705212,
-0.6358188391,
-0.2600542605,
0.5622437596,
0.279420644,
0.4771336615,
0.561124146,
0.4445461333,
0.2189840972,
-0.3392235041,
-0.0950818881,
-0.6009374261,
0.2978149951,
-0.2506626844,
-0.6421217322,
-0.2475596666,
0.1028851494,
1.0176901817,
1.1912058592,
-0.2057395875,
-0.5207403302,
0.1106932759,
0.7145237327,
-0.522039175,
0.0805243552,
-1.0365313292,
-0.0351723544,
-0.2250052541,
-0.3090754747,
-0.3689693511,
-0.1219500676,
0.3245839477,
-0.1069617644,
0.3266386986,
-0.3250139654,
0.541513443,
0.1172673255,
-0.3671675324,
-0.3696541488,
-0.808460176,
0.5069298744,
-0.5730660558,
0.2991545498,
0.4204860926,
0.2330417186,
-0.4204080701,
-0.463031739,
-0.8372225165,
-0.2902886569,
0.1766230464,
0.0844687074,
-0.1430752128,
-0.0862351507,
0.0619753152,
0.549423933,
-0.3724233508,
0.3484327793,
-0.2312218696,
0.0936515629,
0.4965961874,
0.2687234581,
0.2773209214,
-0.1183467209,
-0.1972732842,
0.0668048486,
-0.9929647446,
-0.1801477075,
0.4442821741,
0.389747262,
-0.1508856118,
0.6208170652,
-0.1337030083,
0.4710395336,
-0.0565688796,
0.0999495238,
-0.0661921278,
-0.0773499459,
-0.1054008305,
0.1986982077,
0.4474321902,
0.0655231923,
0.1362816393,
-0.2691005766,
-0.2688539326,
-0.001391121,
0.089930892,
-0.7517853975,
-0.3955183923,
0.3363493085,
-0.5349792838,
-0.0916550159,
0.2212872207,
-0.6751815081,
-0.3309373856,
-0.315394491,
0.1348544955,
-0.1895372123,
-0.4134390354,
0.1786962599,
-0.1270301193,
0.094392471,
0.4215066433,
-1.3642759323,
0.328968972,
1.0468280315,
0.733076036,
-0.3666296899,
-0.1661326587,
-0.4381482601,
0.4872353077,
-0.6993176341,
0.8947640657,
-0.6362315416,
-0.2679757774,
0.0607768968,
0.215144068,
0.0662625879,
-0.4067025483,
0.3952952921,
-0.5064206123,
0.1109467149,
-0.1215565801,
-0.9332264662,
0.2741988599,
0.1130869985,
-0.725513041,
0.4426885247,
-0.118734628,
-0.978980124,
0.2300530374,
-0.270786196,
-0.0547900647,
-0.2470207214,
-0.3637834489,
-0.1359053403,
0.5660997033,
-0.1255222708,
0.8299942613,
-0.329207629,
0.4429723322,
-0.570544064,
-0.2484866828,
0.5417461991,
-0.7812552452,
0.4513159692,
0.3195855618,
-0.2191412449,
-0.1637877822,
-0.6145399213,
-0.5476032495,
0.0797279328,
-0.3012158871,
-0.5451132059,
0.297146678,
-0.2815963328,
-0.079164587,
0.2124585509,
-0.4260954559,
0.4094720185,
-0.7935485244,
0.5847473741,
0.8893917799,
0.157563597,
0.7376210093,
-0.0257615168,
0.1824485809,
0.2018314749,
-0.5216661096,
-0.1557330638,
-0.1940012574,
-0.6765690446,
-0.2462075949,
0.1691233814,
0.2793366909,
-0.3633669913,
0.3566503823,
-0.1835872084,
-0.4205358326,
-0.1363034695,
-0.1042446718,
0.0383000895,
0.1969987154,
-0.1384461075,
-0.0682594478,
-0.1308971494,
-1.0780547857,
0.0718152449,
-0.0959795415,
0.1110907719,
-0.0655786619,
0.4724213183,
-0.362728864,
0.7667466998,
-0.8395738006,
-0.0832188129,
-0.4186043739,
0.1016466692,
0.4682087898,
0.7011200786,
0.5906127095,
-0.7152055502,
-0.2725917995,
-0.144466579,
-0.3978022337,
0.0189063642,
-0.0987119898,
-0.3724326789,
0.2759373486,
0.6038269997,
-0.7538213134,
0.2376904041,
0.258736521,
-0.3414029479,
0.1888630539,
-0.4927016497,
-0.2603825927,
-1.324190259,
-0.141128242,
-0.0221528113,
-0.0838840753,
-0.4596020281,
-0.0321734063,
-0.1820903271,
-0.2370831668,
-0.16087237,
0.8299967051,
-0.3336330652,
-0.2968617082,
-0.6826969981,
0.0308836624,
-0.15587008,
0.1067992598,
0.3833071887,
0.6199079156,
0.6003878117,
-0.4163673818,
-0.0376888141,
0.0610312484,
-0.1535698175,
0.3996378779,
-0.6482080221,
-0.1097387895,
-0.4594859481,
0.2778474689,
-1.2113181353,
-0.3001488149,
0.0993232056,
-0.1059168279,
0.5452362299,
-0.2542965412,
-0.5391524434,
0.0547475852,
-0.1811567694,
-0.180546239,
0.5343907475,
-0.4041880965,
0.0514151379,
0.6517282128,
-0.4521106482,
-0.3421640098,
-0.5851003528,
-0.1378775984,
-0.3581754863,
-0.2372641116,
0.3003333211,
-0.1541468203,
-0.4385379553,
0.0869250074,
-0.084328793,
-0.3821650147,
0.3534089923,
0.1576890498,
0.0343082733,
-0.1848507524,
0.2864071131,
0.2467247397,
-0.1918039173,
0.1071281508,
-0.3861275017,
0.7239550948,
0.1690111458,
-0.1438369453,
-0.312569648,
0.5909147859,
0.209934026,
0.0795838833,
0.7985351682,
0.6040027142,
-0.7005012631,
-0.3259077072,
-0.3603003323,
-0.3005076945,
-0.3792241514,
0.3097046614,
-0.4951046109,
-0.8543565869,
0.487336427,
-0.0115987994,
-0.1810687184,
0.7595490813,
0.683657825,
-0.2319259048,
0.7949482799,
0.8424865603,
-0.0518588983,
0.4919838309,
-0.5500621796,
0.0077615404,
-0.6452088952,
-0.1759063154,
-0.7650499344,
-0.0146622099,
-0.677980125,
-0.3637468815,
-0.1112331748,
0.5069381595,
-0.1849891692,
-0.0960819274,
-0.2606961429,
0.5654370189,
0.7371857762,
-0.0484687053,
0.1222756058,
0.4434086084,
0.0004788613,
-0.2358630002,
-0.4195074439,
-0.8687919378,
0.8870777488,
0.417095989,
0.9105323553,
0.0730677545,
0.9892053008,
0.1131620109,
0.2559393048,
-0.495262593,
0.4669678509,
-0.5713289976,
-0.4461920857,
-0.2183308154,
-0.5144354701,
-1.056001544,
0.1588816196,
-0.138294071,
-0.9735030532,
0.3269288242,
-0.0639382228,
-0.0845347717,
0.2159126252,
-0.4150052667,
0.9881795049,
0.0280599631,
-0.4477224648,
-0.3490171432,
-0.3598058522,
0.1707846969,
-0.2657160163,
-0.069371596,
-0.3888914287,
-0.1211780682,
0.7456017733,
-0.3790155053,
0.8937919736,
-0.1211385205,
-0.581751585,
0.312972188,
0.1926399469,
0.238606438,
0.5196526647,
-0.1482242793,
-0.1815567613,
-0.0322357342,
-0.3640294671,
-0.6081243157,
0.9530252814,
-0.9010474682,
-0.6584321856,
-0.4050699472,
-0.4141772985,
-0.1073282287,
0.2268496156,
0.1374089718,
0.6149007678,
-0.241549328,
0.3289676905,
0.6996423006,
-0.1560162902,
0.615149796,
0.4528611302,
0.0921160877,
-0.3171204031,
0.9170068502,
0.1173259765,
0.147094205,
0.7110798359,
0.2760490179,
-0.3349179327,
-1.0079669952,
-0.1258582771,
0.2703634202,
-0.7401706576,
0.1129823178,
-0.878182888,
-0.0954872817,
-0.2370046079,
-0.3467234671,
-0.3702202141,
-0.543148458,
-0.647200048,
-0.1722841114,
0.0992186293,
0.7094574571,
-0.3191232979,
0.4720971584,
-0.7499058247,
0.3267227411,
0.19955872,
0.2405283153,
-0.0753428936,
-0.4572595954,
0.0585300066,
0.1027874276,
-0.1831104457,
-1.0021150112,
0.6183111668,
0.0980396941,
0.7125326395,
0.4434660673,
-0.0651825592,
0.339279741,
-0.5715628862,
0.6617524028,
0.11508549,
-0.7393516898,
0.7606810927,
-0.5472779274,
-0.0180730857,
0.4611924887,
0.6176680923,
-0.2000393122,
-0.6084307432,
-0.7440689802,
-0.7050341964,
0.5443701744,
0.1818659008,
0.6573069096,
-0.5256841779,
0.6195809245,
0.4882471263,
0.3818609416,
-0.7688751221,
0.0193519667,
0.1089666113,
-0.4083808064,
-0.3576976061,
-0.6829375625,
-0.084431842,
0.0164216999,
0.2736679912,
-0.177912876,
0.5177346468,
0.1287816018,
-0.0130629558,
0.1589057595,
0.2330332398,
0.4773464501,
0.7118458152,
-0.4259220064,
0.4720062315,
-0.4229158163,
-0.2657310069,
0.0520852357,
0.3955764174,
-0.1409312189,
-0.0079867281,
0.4764315188,
0.7109521031,
0.0177500192,
-0.6458918452,
0.3879932165,
0.1374848187,
0.0863135234,
-0.4629747868,
0.1420198083,
0.2863330543,
0.5232189298,
0.54355371,
-0.3043792844,
0.2790525258,
-0.9930028915,
0.4120850861,
0.5450844765,
-0.1848472953,
-0.4498377442,
0.7936067581,
0.0331696868,
-0.0753802955,
0.3366770148,
-0.2189423591,
-0.3419603109,
0.6549978256,
0.6398545504,
0.9298835397,
0.1755601317,
0.2655195296,
0.1826850027,
-0.0846552774,
-0.2177985162,
0.4838324487,
0.2483080626,
-0.7186709046,
-0.2695205212,
-0.802857995,
-0.2564994991,
0.0529530086,
-0.2483199835,
0.1658933312,
-0.3348351419,
0.1829482019,
0.2541532516,
0.2445652634,
-0.3863547444,
0.1568913907,
0.3579715788,
0.6351020336,
-0.7726004124,
0.9275307059,
0.3096479177,
-0.5833031535,
-0.5755942464,
0.3494732678,
-0.4542740285,
-0.5436884761,
0.8644234538,
0.049324479,
0.3489050865,
0.0538717285,
-0.5610536933,
-0.7577313185,
0.7301658988,
0.6652257442,
-0.6153597236,
-0.0565468371,
0.1090463027,
0.5198869109,
-0.5826262832,
-0.0269020423,
0.2592537105,
0.0613382645,
0.0827552676,
-0.4616406262,
-0.0262048505,
0.0698912814,
0.0594937168,
0.2958588898,
-0.2425004542,
1.0956809521,
-0.1725334674,
0.0158891566,
0.2052118033,
0.7167665362,
0.1816656739,
0.2427759022,
0.1377867162,
0.4958584011,
0.6737154722,
-0.1058384702,
1.2248228788,
-0.242411688,
0.399092406,
0.9471070766,
-0.1192220151,
1.1523061991,
0.3952745795,
0.0156325307,
0.3425588906,
0.8530587554,
0.2155685872,
0.9543969631,
0.2642984092,
-0.1503607631,
-0.1393401474,
-0.0783072412,
-0.5845727324,
0.4123524427,
0.5914369822,
-0.5610174537,
-0.2023310363,
-0.1340405643,
0.0363653935,
0.0314196497,
-0.3264518976,
0.9356818795,
0.2664147019,
-0.5422644019,
0.4842163324,
-0.002186029,
0.4535798728,
-0.3448125422,
-0.0504842773,
-0.6807844043,
0.2743835747,
0.126275003,
-0.9158504009,
0.4757195711,
-0.2538988888,
-0.2506443262,
-0.2268666923,
0.9245103598,
-0.7811175585,
-0.5622717738,
-0.0439420566,
0.715084374,
0.3087739348,
-0.0133095356,
-0.3997234106,
0.1278375387,
-0.2015077174,
-0.3700286746,
0.3577605486,
0.9601823092,
0.100705035,
0.4062045813,
0.5042530298,
0.3676850796,
-0.1713431776,
0.1156457812,
0.8311182857,
-0.7520039678,
-0.6839484572,
-1.1364396811,
0.2232261896,
-0.0341069549,
-0.0284552518,
0.4145125747,
0.3787233829,
0.6434599757,
-0.1042263359,
0.5129364133,
0.3558263779,
0.3807382286,
-0.8665079474,
0.6951426864,
-0.6003632545,
0.1889476478,
-0.4591552913,
-1.2000054121,
-0.1122099608,
0.7973841429,
-0.4054741561,
-0.3325783014,
0.6449276209,
0.4937213659,
-0.2375487685,
-0.1394174546,
0.1051781029,
0.0914194807,
0.3372528553,
0.589030683,
1.0255042315,
0.1785218269,
0.1785945892,
-0.1548547894,
0.0497978069,
-0.2418358624,
-0.8353319764,
-0.8565582037,
-0.6554997563,
-0.3748952746,
-0.2413817793,
0.081406109,
0.7038494349,
0.432510078,
-0.5109891891,
-0.1275350899,
-0.492436111,
0.1162375435,
0.3799988925,
-0.2010600269,
0.5494903922,
-0.3418188393,
-1.0740029812,
0.2395214587,
0.3325384557,
0.4439435005,
-0.4944760799,
0.0170640051,
-0.0243245997,
0.0337790735,
0.5393990278,
-0.0947342813,
-0.6262759566,
-0.2104336321,
-0.2115716189,
-0.4488704503,
-0.1918090284,
0.7638589144,
-0.5178562999,
0.0686915293,
0.7038487792,
0.9649218917,
0.4378132224,
-0.3651273847,
0.8163884282,
-0.5157247186,
0.5667356253,
0.1560456753,
0.649348259,
0.1713891029,
-0.0347044244,
0.5806618929,
0.3237854242,
-0.1655023247,
-1.0174552202,
0.29164958,
-0.9366241097,
-0.7314491868,
1.2601058483,
-0.1797761768,
-0.137286365,
0.1878469437,
-0.2349082977,
0.0616335534,
-0.2967191041,
0.6717600822,
0.5907290578,
0.1930299848,
-0.2279639244,
-0.7157045603,
0.4282055199,
0.40531829,
-0.887947917,
0.0591239408,
0.6452343464,
0.2767028511,
0.0942334831,
1.0113859177,
0.1849627644,
-0.1285938919,
0.0046298741,
-0.5069576502,
0.4966539741,
-0.3987212777,
-0.3028319478,
0.3716088235,
0.2261150926,
0.086363174
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13961v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13961v1
|
ChatGPT as a commenter to the news: can LLMs generate human-like opinions?
| 2023-12-21T15:46:36 | 2023-12-21T15:46:36 |
Rayden Tseng, Suzan Verberne, Peter van der Putten
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
ChatGPT, GPT-3.5, and other large language models (LLMs) have drawn
significant attention since their release, and the abilities of these models
have been investigated for a wide variety of tasks. In this research we
investigate to what extent GPT-3.5 can generate human-like comments on Dutch
news articles. We define human likeness as `not distinguishable from human
comments', approximated by the difficulty of automatic classification between
human and GPT comments. We analyze human likeness across multiple prompting
techniques. In particular, we utilize zero-shot, few-shot and context prompts,
for two generated personas. We found that our fine-tuned BERT models can easily
distinguish human-written comments from GPT-3.5 generated comments, with none
of the used prompting methods performing noticeably better. We further analyzed
that human comments consistently showed higher lexical diversity than
GPT-generated comments. This indicates that although generative LLMs can
generate fluent text, their capability to create human-like opinionated
comments is still limited.
|
[
-0.6178281307,
-0.7186707854,
0.626252532,
0.2862338424,
-0.4600742459,
0.0151888644,
-0.4121640027,
-0.7618413568,
0.1921715885,
0.186619997,
-0.5598189831,
-0.2467377782,
-0.5517678857,
0.5238084793,
-0.4445890784,
1.3751299381,
0.2781962752,
0.2508183718,
-0.0926437303,
0.2675666511,
0.0679716319,
-0.8038671017,
-0.6035349965,
-0.256239742,
0.8681268096,
0.1634484679,
0.7081235647,
0.0480022803,
0.2142774165,
0.2421573699,
-0.086460948,
0.032246124,
-0.4290801883,
0.0018013448,
-0.0460876599,
-0.3057364523,
-0.3380941749,
0.2845774591,
0.4172292054,
0.5003849864,
0.0539940931,
-0.0590887852,
0.3178741336,
0.7567833066,
-0.0573744848,
0.1934286505,
-0.6880253553,
0.1151135787,
-0.0608965531,
-0.075377591,
-0.3283819556,
-0.5946788192,
0.4733700454,
-0.31175071,
0.7340615988,
-0.1370476335,
0.9972993135,
-0.1806265563,
-0.2892232239,
-0.2579712272,
-0.5611358881,
0.5557393432,
-0.7704737782,
0.0840923339,
0.0497623943,
0.1132373512,
-0.1397125423,
-0.2787585557,
-0.7391527891,
-0.4248716831,
-0.1160275117,
0.2236963063,
-0.1261036992,
0.0500754826,
0.2401880175,
0.1843119115,
-0.5722662807,
-0.0732002407,
-0.2810789347,
-0.0504641905,
0.6034402847,
-0.1701381803,
0.2543991804,
-0.5834414959,
-0.2650314867,
0.0909035131,
-0.8486436009,
-0.231588617,
0.7275573015,
0.1961475909,
-0.0678064376,
0.7434652448,
-0.2990846038,
0.6939831972,
-0.0787502527,
-0.0505348966,
0.1437797248,
0.2680606544,
-0.1023289263,
-0.1740152687,
0.9175944924,
0.7057040334,
0.6916868687,
-0.2487501502,
-0.1595291495,
-0.004112164,
0.3441679776,
-0.7954008579,
-0.5202434659,
-0.1795700788,
-0.5870600343,
-0.6361650825,
0.4098457098,
-0.6050987244,
-0.6464480758,
-0.1856303513,
0.2122557759,
-0.1767943203,
-0.2206562012,
0.0339463316,
-0.1193480119,
0.5390223265,
0.9100908041,
-0.9917595983,
-0.0049411007,
0.5658159256,
0.6234331727,
-0.3418970406,
-0.0514886864,
0.0071598152,
0.1048465967,
-0.3105483949,
1.0903162956,
-0.3225498497,
-0.4609594941,
-0.0328096002,
-0.1066937521,
0.1125294939,
-0.4096142054,
0.3289601505,
-0.6585063338,
0.6046293974,
-0.6717399955,
-0.4698181152,
-0.2122172862,
0.4990145862,
-0.4076175094,
0.7843644619,
0.1745749712,
-1.0659358501,
0.5015467405,
-0.6574255824,
-0.4536893666,
0.101007022,
-0.4036571681,
-0.2902101278,
0.1145544797,
0.4213421643,
0.5035090446,
-0.1609441638,
-0.0139904832,
-0.4173487127,
-0.1304030567,
0.5088376403,
-0.4697857201,
0.585547626,
0.2240337133,
-0.4415201843,
-0.1134481579,
-0.4276269078,
-0.1865904033,
0.1700944752,
-0.6836958528,
0.1391998231,
0.0664443895,
0.0843551233,
0.3021518588,
0.2004022002,
-0.7590087652,
0.3868135214,
-0.3263287842,
0.4574752748,
0.7091060281,
0.2202529311,
0.0998725742,
-0.4496943057,
0.3983781636,
0.094200477,
-0.1663927287,
-0.0908015594,
-0.8325480819,
-0.8693872094,
-0.1333894432,
0.1423485875,
0.4173110723,
-0.5973438621,
0.1250870228,
-0.3085007966,
-0.3649318516,
-0.364482969,
-0.0216931291,
0.2652964592,
0.4419829845,
-0.0932922438,
-0.3870072961,
-0.6552806497,
-1.0740494728,
-0.4123211801,
-0.5208499432,
-0.4617008269,
0.4018036723,
0.249689132,
-0.0084365215,
1.1143485308,
-0.3326652646,
0.1622003168,
-0.2410152853,
0.3621143401,
0.0455826335,
0.086558491,
0.6330704689,
-0.5739994645,
-0.6737225652,
-0.1037309766,
-0.673320055,
-0.2402974516,
-0.0278195161,
0.175828889,
0.3091830015,
0.4745273888,
-0.9263827801,
0.1788889617,
0.3329026699,
0.1144515723,
0.5444395542,
0.0413139276,
0.2037603408,
-0.9934201241,
-0.1559752077,
0.1001296118,
-0.3461915255,
-0.5193216801,
-0.1880548447,
-0.2705047131,
-0.1006129235,
-0.4661705494,
0.4831697643,
-0.4022450745,
-0.1216110662,
-0.3231339455,
0.2279956192,
-0.1730000675,
0.5147718191,
0.4276642799,
0.8362032771,
0.3338308036,
-0.3860822022,
0.3125402927,
0.1226929128,
-0.4490866065,
0.5045237541,
-0.7369436622,
0.4207742214,
-0.3292608857,
0.4696946442,
-1.2159253359,
-0.7051158547,
0.1691052169,
-0.6957754493,
0.0510536879,
-0.1147260517,
-0.7863574028,
-0.3737465441,
-0.5551715493,
-0.1198294684,
0.6644423008,
-0.3523944616,
0.3768751621,
0.2730592191,
-0.6128519177,
-0.1701765805,
-0.6704336405,
0.3651525974,
0.003397533,
-0.7480210066,
-0.0978885293,
0.0141342552,
-0.2593892217,
-0.1596521884,
0.3095191121,
0.1837102622,
-0.3063396513,
0.128161177,
0.3647066653,
-0.1995289326,
0.0159210581,
-0.2100994885,
0.2021976113,
0.1320000887,
0.005901258,
0.3264432549,
-0.3363267481,
-0.3868986964,
-0.2619684637,
0.4393583536,
0.4652314186,
0.2695590556,
0.427323699,
0.4319412112,
0.0769929886,
0.079999797,
-0.8369749784,
-0.4058202207,
-0.3862044215,
0.562861979,
-0.159692347,
-1.1414576769,
0.4304749072,
0.2795560062,
0.2965013087,
0.4438394904,
1.0195285082,
-0.4014015794,
1.2330019474,
0.2892464399,
-0.0890739858,
0.471350193,
0.3311891258,
0.0328439064,
-0.6683279872,
-0.0621221736,
-0.3701029718,
-0.3169742227,
-0.8629297614,
-0.0915776044,
0.3692140877,
-0.3094013631,
-0.2770530581,
0.0632286668,
-0.5451162457,
0.4824392498,
0.5345023274,
0.2423714846,
0.2665145099,
0.1760136187,
0.268568933,
-0.1824757457,
-0.5497496128,
-0.809402287,
0.970241487,
0.3292858303,
0.7465385199,
0.2088003606,
0.6673972011,
0.3248432577,
0.9487496018,
-0.7387045026,
0.7751413584,
-0.0225095544,
-0.7758831978,
-0.0989811495,
-0.3420302868,
-0.8245610595,
0.2955028713,
-0.1359453648,
-0.8973805904,
-0.0585781522,
0.1203589663,
-0.2734869719,
0.5112293363,
-0.8748824596,
0.3894741237,
0.2295271009,
-0.0083718803,
0.0798658282,
-0.925157845,
0.3223863244,
0.0964946076,
-0.0274388026,
-0.3503637016,
-0.0655339062,
0.6011065245,
-0.3642576635,
1.1756381989,
-0.2385725379,
-0.4059441686,
0.4670507908,
0.1033121049,
0.3939488828,
0.0205753837,
0.0838067159,
0.0749784112,
-0.4849208891,
-0.2958934903,
-0.3990466893,
0.5386682749,
-1.1601704359,
-0.9174732566,
-0.2487761229,
-0.4140578806,
-0.4587534368,
0.0674301982,
0.4994815588,
0.0841743574,
-0.4094558358,
0.0562245063,
0.4893478155,
-0.1287878007,
0.5195193291,
0.4816097915,
-0.1063639596,
-0.3881773353,
0.6883084774,
-0.0758224875,
0.2911788523,
0.3714142442,
0.0906552747,
-0.29978019,
-0.2478639632,
-0.4401995242,
0.2595344782,
-0.7287622094,
-0.0803461224,
-0.5962186456,
-0.2593212128,
-0.2385345995,
-0.2072351426,
-0.1771730334,
-0.5383760929,
-0.3268054426,
-0.0756058469,
0.2913084328,
1.089419961,
0.139392212,
0.3198620081,
-0.7987488508,
0.2893643081,
0.8899843693,
0.4345284998,
0.0767796338,
-0.4982953668,
0.0067906673,
0.1009908468,
-0.4147855341,
-0.9755651355,
0.0871656612,
-0.0136168636,
0.0513159707,
0.4150930941,
-0.1116076186,
0.2735264599,
-0.3498714268,
1.2055042982,
0.1610250622,
-0.5030355453,
0.347656846,
-0.8988767862,
0.1418955177,
0.2053338289,
0.0183540657,
-0.5223914385,
-0.7363299727,
-0.659414053,
-0.4802109897,
0.7306632996,
0.2933011055,
0.5756478906,
-0.4499356449,
0.3593281806,
0.2325971574,
0.3491766453,
-1.1131454706,
0.0360524207,
-0.3697934151,
0.2703820765,
0.1530582011,
-0.5733565092,
0.0073080761,
-0.1394575983,
0.6144339442,
-0.0177759621,
0.4022415578,
0.3571788967,
0.0541107543,
-0.1171981394,
0.5685867667,
0.7428693771,
0.4796907008,
-0.2796344161,
0.1529079974,
0.1207465604,
-0.4596745074,
0.0881398916,
-0.061341159,
-0.3391013443,
0.2267338037,
0.3394528031,
0.6766507626,
0.102675952,
-0.2639095783,
0.74085778,
-0.106939733,
-0.5819652081,
-0.0747612342,
0.0870562121,
0.3486581147,
0.0533654653,
0.3090677559,
0.1479429901,
-0.1733526438,
-0.5228456259,
-0.0807266757,
0.4835656881,
-0.383815378,
-0.4912165701,
0.8694737554,
0.5448949933,
-0.0681235045,
0.660977006,
-0.3216923177,
-0.4046791792,
0.2033231407,
0.4322936237,
1.220490098,
0.0439010188,
0.2952831984,
0.1827300787,
0.1545196474,
-0.051762823,
0.2635828555,
-0.0106815891,
-0.9451876283,
-0.5421981215,
-0.4161269665,
-0.5790664554,
0.1382270157,
-0.4804874659,
0.3187354803,
-0.34573102,
-0.2673533857,
0.1735821217,
-0.2019624859,
-0.4048525691,
0.0795661137,
0.3511850834,
0.5779798627,
-0.8220677972,
0.8027541637,
0.9867494702,
-0.3975156546,
-0.7437829375,
0.3459742963,
0.0154346023,
-0.8101575971,
0.5215635896,
0.2421497703,
-0.0247358885,
-0.0318108276,
-0.8838723302,
-0.2190163881,
0.53276968,
0.7751914859,
-0.3684712946,
-0.1285439134,
0.3368342221,
0.6555592418,
-0.1724750549,
0.2370643318,
0.2994979024,
0.475438863,
0.2099831104,
-0.92491436,
-0.1573340744,
-0.2806177735,
0.2871695161,
-0.1057392359,
-0.7788758874,
0.8654080629,
-0.3083180189,
-0.1183848158,
0.0873195529,
0.7244778872,
0.3229134977,
-0.348741442,
0.6020271182,
0.2301763147,
0.2860493362,
0.0078222761,
1.3363611698,
-0.1807503551,
0.4656994045,
0.9006499052,
-0.2590145171,
0.6386929154,
0.4659649134,
-0.440027982,
0.6640746593,
0.7254385948,
-0.114358753,
0.3841858506,
0.1831739843,
-0.6700236797,
-0.2390729636,
0.0890239328,
-0.3139662147,
0.2406430095,
-0.0054607331,
-0.3792681396,
-0.3746135533,
-0.3147990406,
0.2509085238,
-0.2838836014,
-0.0998768434,
1.0851832628,
0.097254917,
-0.8337832689,
0.1957316697,
-0.0383154266,
0.6736540794,
-0.4484591782,
-0.131838873,
-0.1685304791,
-0.2091173977,
-0.2058626413,
-0.9971542358,
-0.0481999218,
0.1868148893,
-0.4622208476,
-0.186872527,
0.6534962654,
-0.3380787373,
-0.310788095,
-0.3210790455,
0.6563491821,
0.3532828689,
-0.2802209258,
-0.4866812825,
-0.3316806257,
0.3019528389,
-0.8067945838,
0.4003811777,
0.6034027934,
-0.0578888617,
0.3800344765,
0.6116343141,
0.1226066425,
-0.0623384006,
0.3082770109,
0.9555220604,
-0.5262471437,
-0.361684382,
-1.0793124437,
0.2500117421,
-0.1614665836,
-0.1369858235,
0.7256896496,
0.5145589113,
0.5854577422,
-0.5983749628,
1.1763180494,
-0.2954751551,
0.879248023,
-0.2596663535,
0.6907778978,
-0.160631761,
0.158295393,
-0.5334346294,
-1.0801317692,
-0.3266620338,
0.6265124083,
-0.3406258225,
0.4159159362,
0.4449078143,
0.8896033764,
0.0271115471,
0.2897197306,
0.2134765983,
0.151160419,
0.4306395054,
0.3624189198,
1.1556763649,
0.0732822418,
0.6432790756,
0.1840163916,
-0.0562826507,
-0.2162269801,
-1.0953217745,
-1.0712147951,
-0.2941080928,
-0.2454400659,
-0.2669174969,
-0.0689937472,
0.8182550073,
0.7420341969,
-0.6408253312,
0.0398855358,
-0.284137696,
-0.1590169072,
0.3156782389,
-0.2649376988,
0.5039619207,
-0.249205485,
-0.7835492492,
-0.2189628184,
0.2317825556,
0.3181601763,
-0.409162432,
-0.0454649851,
0.3244859278,
0.0587748587,
0.7481421232,
0.2535813451,
-0.9823044538,
-0.8081820011,
-0.1418789178,
-0.2893039882,
0.3302829564,
0.8766386509,
-0.6912398338,
0.4140705764,
0.3826965988,
0.2394611984,
0.6352951527,
0.2322519422,
0.6827446818,
-1.0928763151,
0.3507547677,
0.2507487833,
0.2370220721,
0.658224225,
-0.1715390533,
0.3216290176,
0.2878637612,
-0.6166601181,
-0.3924584985,
0.3128862977,
-1.0253973007,
0.0290977322,
1.445409894,
-0.0497624725,
0.04945397,
-0.0748327076,
-0.7367858887,
-0.0601782687,
-0.6893966198,
0.9777153134,
0.986292541,
-0.4526705444,
-0.3196161091,
-0.8127854466,
0.6080648303,
0.2073773146,
-0.8347672224,
0.1720701009,
0.4989495873,
0.434356153,
-0.0647851899,
0.782833159,
-0.3901063204,
0.3909930885,
-0.1449453086,
0.2074225843,
0.19011271,
0.1904661655,
0.0424434207,
0.1850464642,
0.2810951471,
0.0832393914
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13951v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13951v1
|
Typhoon: Thai Large Language Models
| 2023-12-21T15:38:41 | 2023-12-21T15:38:41 |
Kunat Pipatanakul, Phatrasek Jirabovonvisut, Potsawee Manakul, Sittipong Sripaisarnmongkol, Ruangsak Patomwong, Pathomporn Chokchainant, Kasima Tharnpipitchai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Typhoon is a series of Thai large language models (LLMs) developed
specifically for the Thai language. This technical report presents challenges
and insights in developing Thai LLMs, including data preparation, pretraining,
instruction-tuning, and evaluation. As one of the challenges of low-resource
languages is the amount of pretraining data, we apply continual training to
transfer existing world knowledge from a strong LLM. To evaluate the Thai
knowledge encapsulated in each model from the pretraining stage, we develop
ThaiExam, a benchmark based on examinations for high-school students and
investment professionals in Thailand. In addition, we fine-tune Typhoon to
follow Thai instructions, and we evaluate instruction-tuned models on Thai
instruction datasets as well as translation, summarization, and
question-answering tasks. Experimental results on a suite of Thai benchmarks
show that Typhoon outperforms all open-source Thai language models, and its
performance is on par with GPT-3.5 in Thai while having only 7 billion
parameters and being 2.62 times more efficient in tokenizing Thai text.
|
[
-0.3348474801,
-0.4822385609,
0.2523701191,
0.5025565624,
-0.4333808422,
0.1950683594,
-0.4930683076,
-0.2674693167,
0.1776525229,
0.9958972335,
-0.1738399565,
-0.410977602,
-0.5286141634,
0.3589394987,
-0.2938322723,
0.8583666086,
-0.3445158601,
0.0364421234,
0.3109441996,
-0.0538708605,
-0.2766437232,
-0.3552292585,
-0.4555482268,
-0.1805368662,
0.5039814115,
0.9950987697,
0.5447353125,
0.6258082986,
1.0552965403,
0.263179183,
-0.0112150256,
-0.0187741779,
-0.74772048,
0.2517018914,
-0.213574633,
-0.4263601005,
-0.3431138396,
-0.1677826047,
0.6524097919,
0.4835334718,
-0.1378327459,
0.2781178951,
-0.0897648409,
0.5975600481,
-0.7016201615,
0.3012210727,
-0.3460153341,
-0.0448257439,
-0.5192509294,
-0.2609392703,
-0.3716096878,
-0.3542183638,
0.429590553,
-0.5143694282,
-0.1899241805,
-0.1270323247,
0.6957364082,
0.1103646681,
-0.8763580322,
-0.2908289135,
-0.7070586681,
0.6033087969,
-0.3689734936,
0.5383011699,
0.3297833502,
0.3379530311,
-0.0904434323,
-0.9005466104,
-0.3090304732,
-0.1970418394,
0.5223913789,
0.1764775664,
0.0637629628,
0.4080592096,
-0.0122242272,
0.5298230648,
-0.5617331862,
0.4779936075,
-0.5143782496,
-0.0000104683,
0.5803355575,
0.2984512448,
0.0944126621,
-0.5311252475,
-0.1945901364,
-0.2937854826,
-0.9448747039,
-0.1399568319,
0.2525937259,
0.3442484736,
-0.1845378876,
0.8184030056,
-0.2375178635,
0.4613027275,
-0.2535051703,
-0.5500923991,
-0.058015082,
-0.613953054,
-0.2454754263,
0.1959516555,
0.7005724311,
0.4699456394,
0.4885542989,
0.0785019174,
-0.3541770279,
-0.4457208812,
-0.0427316539,
-1.2364073992,
-0.3773625791,
-0.1816091239,
-0.3195151687,
-0.569437623,
-0.0268484559,
-0.8468419909,
-0.297947526,
-0.2625758052,
0.3198227286,
-0.1695938408,
-0.5705426931,
0.1804955304,
-0.0091994544,
0.1208098009,
0.0847214609,
-0.6151487827,
0.1488529742,
0.3935141265,
0.8447050452,
-0.0761738643,
-0.3668315709,
-0.3223154843,
0.2732725739,
-0.4903342426,
0.788723886,
-0.8144454956,
-0.6839842796,
-0.2065152079,
0.0103704929,
0.0144731542,
-0.6692222357,
0.2114461511,
-0.3311004639,
-0.029120516,
-0.3896780312,
-0.4110453427,
-0.2029110789,
0.090063192,
-0.5620852709,
1.0221164227,
0.4455946684,
-0.7251992822,
0.2980757654,
-0.5233269334,
-0.2554120123,
0.1053037345,
0.1729021966,
-0.3568215668,
0.3185733855,
0.1551524252,
0.4604663253,
-0.6647921205,
0.34767434,
-0.3491952121,
-0.3361693025,
0.0769956037,
-0.3903537691,
0.5897727013,
0.329613924,
-0.1460523009,
-0.0659260154,
-0.7572030425,
0.1059997529,
0.0875707641,
-0.3738238811,
-0.2699217498,
-0.3334790468,
0.0136924013,
0.1504482329,
0.2577049732,
-0.2061041743,
0.3942630887,
-0.4601426423,
0.6074896455,
0.8254026175,
0.3412621617,
0.1729946136,
0.0148235699,
0.98695755,
0.4245388806,
-0.0310405288,
-0.6309854984,
-0.0905482545,
-1.0162119865,
-0.3086669445,
0.4137955308,
0.6121718884,
-0.8268093467,
0.0341285691,
-0.477116555,
-0.8909430504,
-0.313549906,
0.3635073006,
0.2799430788,
0.2266502827,
-0.0676509067,
-0.2742464244,
-1.130900383,
-0.7589612007,
-0.0004565901,
-0.2762862146,
0.3686408401,
0.2109072506,
0.7408823371,
-0.3563740849,
0.6012669206,
-0.3843279183,
0.191945672,
-0.4669804275,
-0.0564942695,
-0.1048256904,
0.2652090788,
0.5308762193,
-0.4786653221,
-0.7234355807,
0.2185712159,
-0.7014039159,
-0.2098031342,
0.3177565634,
0.0917934552,
-0.0649458393,
0.6662443876,
-0.3997208774,
0.1794654876,
0.4422782958,
-0.0654715523,
0.8253173828,
-0.2026894391,
0.0833851248,
-1.1809376478,
0.0279780384,
-0.0054513258,
-0.2462883592,
-0.412997812,
0.340664804,
-0.1347132772,
-0.5603220463,
-0.337213397,
0.6207547188,
-0.2801537216,
-0.0112834908,
-0.2928912044,
0.0745009929,
-0.2023759335,
0.1687636077,
-0.0645139515,
1.0069301128,
0.478397876,
-0.5739108324,
0.7689971924,
-0.2634565234,
-0.4461901188,
0.5900261998,
-0.7102775574,
0.159985736,
-0.0547149517,
0.0749893039,
-0.649499476,
-0.3117583096,
0.0323163569,
0.1333859265,
0.1734950691,
0.0489586629,
-0.6432742476,
-0.647903204,
-0.146403268,
0.3925661445,
0.292219758,
-0.292961359,
0.2275590897,
0.3128941655,
-0.4323220849,
-0.3979598284,
-0.3080146015,
0.1636877209,
-0.5142878294,
-0.1847833544,
-0.0503189266,
0.1800159514,
-0.4445389807,
-0.0346737169,
-0.0116248541,
-0.3177060783,
0.1908731312,
0.1222812161,
-0.0675231144,
-0.7185105681,
0.0829510391,
-0.0520551279,
-0.196176365,
-0.1168920398,
-0.5535221696,
0.454092741,
-0.1302900612,
-0.1723541319,
-0.4208600819,
-0.1101206392,
0.6613534093,
-0.2841484547,
0.5008904934,
0.2886378169,
-0.2406674325,
0.0553049706,
-0.4830020964,
0.0500986911,
-0.5189700723,
0.8920993209,
-0.7869064808,
-0.7625191808,
0.3546622992,
-0.2843859792,
-0.0876735672,
0.2239867896,
0.5380378962,
0.1748194247,
0.9764284492,
0.9450532794,
-0.4616524279,
0.3574684262,
-0.126071021,
0.1851235628,
-0.4549430609,
-0.1654060483,
-0.6417476535,
-0.1019261107,
-0.756855607,
-0.5273035169,
0.2703239322,
0.454955399,
-0.6303390861,
0.406869024,
-0.2468821853,
0.6842741966,
0.3079300523,
-0.1283918023,
0.4339358509,
0.0126974508,
-0.1267574579,
-0.3101670742,
-0.624643147,
-0.5587026477,
1.5326375961,
0.2740528286,
0.7671915293,
-0.0679764301,
0.5955129266,
-0.1237522438,
0.3073208928,
-0.4768770039,
0.5157317519,
-0.2316684723,
-0.35405913,
-0.1890283078,
-0.5240423083,
-0.7195141315,
0.1194394678,
0.4910633564,
-0.5155441761,
-0.2616243958,
-0.1266499162,
-0.0312141031,
0.2487669587,
-0.6509299874,
0.7990093827,
-0.4201571941,
0.0145676052,
-0.4394496679,
-0.1879633069,
0.5651354194,
-0.2999429405,
-0.1360304654,
-0.0643336475,
-0.2829830647,
0.7939599156,
-0.5731481314,
0.5898369551,
-0.1923148036,
-0.1660763323,
0.4652863741,
-0.007946589,
0.4465456605,
0.2330780327,
-0.1930280179,
-0.154610917,
0.0190662667,
-0.4752708972,
-0.5475647449,
0.6568123102,
-1.0415302515,
-0.5369259119,
-0.2612476349,
-0.2069818676,
-0.0747676566,
0.3634965718,
0.3658722043,
0.2750581205,
-0.2790896297,
0.2344923317,
0.5708665252,
-0.3230933547,
0.0412451811,
0.8683707714,
-0.783254683,
-0.7715632915,
1.3225711584,
0.3911516368,
0.2307294011,
0.4764828384,
0.1258167624,
-0.093583405,
-0.4535000622,
-0.3653954864,
0.301233381,
-0.6296810508,
-0.2374693155,
-0.3116491139,
-0.4485514164,
-0.2660146952,
-0.1221436486,
-0.7140352726,
-0.2705846429,
-0.1527640522,
-0.2129323632,
0.1929363012,
1.0694351196,
0.0609115809,
0.5029710531,
-0.5156357288,
0.1147922873,
0.2647029459,
0.3536524475,
0.0064184675,
-0.541018784,
-0.4139817953,
0.1811927557,
-0.6280618906,
-0.6876682639,
0.2348036319,
0.304920584,
0.1060596555,
0.7718284726,
0.0124873975,
1.1399909258,
-0.1807935983,
0.6263563037,
0.1321410388,
-0.9696997404,
0.7973899841,
-0.2383295596,
0.3316148221,
0.510273695,
0.3112145662,
-0.6829208136,
-0.5740215778,
-0.4810831845,
-0.5742980838,
0.5145274401,
-0.0509151742,
-0.105311051,
0.0863147378,
0.5188892484,
0.1276514828,
0.3488930464,
-0.608327508,
-0.1059584171,
-0.3015008271,
-0.0762065053,
-0.3980456293,
-0.5192649961,
0.4834733903,
-0.4001530409,
0.4648018777,
-0.0350835063,
-0.0869928077,
-0.1243886799,
-0.2872978151,
-0.2374006212,
0.1343591809,
0.8535138369,
0.7510302067,
0.12412747,
0.1984336227,
0.346439302,
-0.6706127524,
0.4724749923,
-0.063403815,
0.0690312088,
-0.009840047,
0.5358364582,
0.9064933658,
0.6882442832,
-0.9802342057,
0.4235492647,
0.0293935258,
0.0727034509,
-0.2997776568,
0.1047312766,
-0.0264009628,
0.0615172647,
0.2157792747,
-0.2304108739,
-0.2237041146,
-0.3997807205,
-0.0959468037,
-0.0649647489,
-0.3931634128,
-0.7444985509,
0.4779378176,
0.4094754159,
-0.0684397742,
0.9361669421,
-0.2272049189,
-0.7976751924,
0.6192468405,
0.542119801,
0.5817528963,
-0.5464913845,
0.2750991881,
0.352879703,
0.4953432381,
-0.2413968444,
0.4984321594,
0.0089147789,
-0.3586142361,
-0.5900946259,
-0.56096071,
-0.4869186282,
0.4442548156,
-0.5833684206,
0.6804072261,
-0.3720333874,
0.1238548979,
-0.2750755847,
0.5804012418,
-0.8238071799,
-0.0072957161,
-0.2447494566,
1.2090005875,
-0.7101244926,
0.873257339,
0.7037194967,
-0.3907835782,
-0.9826594591,
-0.1753302068,
-0.2084380835,
-0.9395930767,
0.944619,
0.3225078881,
0.3170967102,
0.164815411,
-0.2934288383,
-0.941942811,
0.819083035,
0.7398765683,
-0.8118267655,
-0.3414134979,
0.5902282596,
0.4607866406,
-0.1873911917,
0.385823667,
0.6205516458,
0.6922390461,
-0.2617777884,
-1.3291406631,
-0.3770196438,
-0.1937327236,
0.1985243708,
0.2951849699,
-0.9357587099,
0.6196919084,
-0.3193773627,
0.0027195155,
0.2539461255,
0.785138607,
0.1972968727,
0.1486217827,
0.1964906603,
0.6706215143,
0.8090029359,
-0.0706955567,
0.8067106009,
-0.5902674198,
0.1609970629,
0.7763487697,
-0.4282524586,
0.7776851058,
0.2665216327,
-0.2000986785,
0.4607709944,
0.8412441015,
0.1450012177,
0.4405334592,
0.3425686955,
-0.2043054253,
-0.197025016,
-0.2965402007,
-0.5533878803,
0.9448068142,
0.2597262859,
-0.16754812,
-0.1695288271,
0.5899638534,
0.0797489434,
-0.3115880787,
-0.5610830188,
0.7130522132,
0.4288019538,
-0.7682052255,
0.5328829288,
0.2156921029,
0.3505415618,
-0.5445323586,
0.1868888736,
-0.2328714281,
0.3818404377,
0.075113304,
-0.6162110567,
0.0773080736,
0.1326077133,
-0.1059913114,
-0.1927605718,
0.3875799179,
-0.2989365458,
-0.6289257407,
-0.0927392393,
0.2970302105,
0.2858872116,
-0.0179898404,
-0.4167817235,
0.2501723468,
-0.0038324194,
-0.4200029671,
0.2307795137,
0.8961359859,
-0.0511057824,
1.0068169832,
0.1797964871,
0.5546966195,
-0.0992888957,
-0.0829175934,
0.6597743034,
-0.8522201777,
-0.6378973722,
-0.780028224,
0.1426910162,
0.110124886,
-0.7462559342,
0.8672642112,
0.7903625369,
0.7413066626,
0.1958872974,
0.7994334698,
0.3578729928,
0.2948738635,
-0.3614573777,
0.4846588075,
-0.2819630504,
0.3368179798,
-0.2051011175,
-0.9539231658,
0.0474394932,
0.4042033553,
-0.3069223166,
0.1188000962,
0.6285003424,
0.6542515159,
-0.002522595,
0.1982817352,
0.1138708442,
0.4157554507,
0.4673781991,
0.829775691,
0.8217352629,
-0.3782293797,
0.7397429943,
-0.4845613241,
0.2669608295,
-0.4161674976,
-0.6554056406,
-0.9530078173,
-0.5933906436,
-0.3119581044,
-0.1670394093,
0.2047825158,
0.8286802173,
0.6964191198,
-0.6522698998,
-0.5310025811,
-0.2392609715,
0.2426177412,
0.040297851,
-0.2526833415,
0.239279747,
-0.221107319,
-0.5652047396,
0.3539613485,
0.4906819463,
0.313536644,
-0.745421946,
-0.258356452,
0.4573206306,
-0.2001580745,
0.5394127369,
0.237624824,
-0.4881436229,
-0.2561436296,
0.0804250464,
-0.341226548,
-0.090610534,
0.9602798223,
-0.6851201653,
0.558005929,
0.2299126536,
0.5305957794,
0.5081570745,
-0.4726630151,
0.8986580968,
-0.6477308869,
0.4523552656,
0.1181637198,
0.120389469,
0.2780716419,
0.0159925763,
0.4844675362,
0.2789748013,
-0.6001968384,
-1.4300615788,
0.0325302519,
-0.426415801,
-0.0314890929,
0.8414347172,
-0.1391512752,
-0.0682124048,
-0.0435262546,
0.0066570463,
0.0989334807,
-0.0801140517,
0.5676878691,
0.9459682107,
0.3551903367,
-0.4622310996,
-0.5858607888,
0.2455295324,
0.1586260647,
-0.7095709443,
0.0380944014,
-0.027158618,
0.3379965127,
-0.2794607878,
0.6391949654,
0.1741807163,
0.5298306346,
0.0915170014,
-0.2724536955,
0.0580138303,
-0.5551522374,
-0.1758881658,
0.1339233071,
0.4562259614,
0.3202809989
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13933v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13933v5
|
Structured Probabilistic Coding
| 2023-12-21T15:28:02 | 2024-05-02T05:18:45 |
Dou Hu, Lingwei Wei, Yaxin Liu, Wei Zhou, Songlin Hu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper presents a new supervised representation learning framework,
namely structured probabilistic coding (SPC), to learn compact and informative
representations from input related to the target task. SPC is an encoder-only
probabilistic coding technology with a structured regularization from the
target space. It can enhance the generalization ability of pre-trained language
models for better language understanding. Specifically, our probabilistic
coding simultaneously performs information encoding and task prediction in one
module to more fully utilize the effective information from input data. It uses
variational inference in the output space to reduce randomness and uncertainty.
Besides, to better control the learning process of probabilistic
representations, a structured regularization is proposed to promote uniformity
across classes in the latent space. With the regularization term, SPC can
preserve the Gaussian structure of the latent code and achieve better coverage
of the hidden space with class uniformly. Experimental results on 12 natural
language understanding tasks demonstrate that our SPC effectively improves the
performance of pre-trained language models for classification and regression.
Extensive experiments show that SPC can enhance the generalization capability,
robustness to label noise, and clustering quality of output representations.
|
[
0.0728319958,
-0.7369466424,
0.5560836792,
0.4356477559,
-0.0548745804,
-0.049943842,
-0.4714788496,
0.0442641489,
0.257553637,
0.3518012464,
-0.2722663283,
-0.7741428614,
-0.6719328165,
-0.0235284604,
-0.3208673,
1.0034759045,
-0.1158988625,
0.0203680992,
-0.1896510273,
0.2658744752,
-0.2862482667,
-0.7282366157,
-0.4754633605,
-0.0102769034,
0.2472071946,
0.2127951384,
0.5610184669,
0.5254580975,
0.4008877277,
0.2901319265,
0.1327368319,
0.2864629924,
-0.4448823333,
-0.0833876804,
0.0087203458,
-0.5893737078,
-0.4132625461,
-0.0310493335,
0.9897074699,
1.0198309422,
-0.4529453814,
-0.2247528583,
0.2167394906,
0.3120881915,
-0.7379949093,
0.948430717,
-0.3349480927,
0.0576596819,
0.1041499823,
-0.413846612,
-0.8093248606,
-0.3218410909,
-0.4518997073,
-0.6623266339,
0.2286153734,
-0.3653401732,
0.6580550671,
0.1688154042,
-0.2414367348,
-0.2869368494,
-0.825052321,
0.6269947886,
-0.3636237979,
0.3589822948,
0.6475601792,
0.2780217528,
-0.3858031332,
-0.7818880081,
-0.3713222146,
-0.2368944585,
-0.1984311491,
0.3887576759,
0.1617205292,
0.3012655079,
-0.0307029746,
0.5268699527,
-0.5260621905,
-0.3164519668,
-0.2538466752,
-0.030953465,
0.7385647893,
-0.3393726647,
-0.0144250523,
0.0143413618,
-0.0941046402,
-0.0467517897,
-0.2682845294,
0.1327766031,
0.438182503,
0.3977674246,
-0.0409547538,
0.3464458287,
-0.2632772624,
0.7672773004,
0.1179381236,
-0.1070935279,
0.0959385857,
-0.2661689818,
-0.2229716331,
-0.161632061,
0.4345167279,
0.0101574548,
0.3176914752,
-0.242599979,
-0.1554785967,
0.2478098273,
0.4652003348,
-0.4050404727,
-0.4227026403,
-0.0951587483,
-0.5989406109,
-0.1555758715,
0.6154968739,
-0.0771525279,
0.0647195876,
-0.3200067282,
0.2004499733,
-0.6074885726,
-0.1915815771,
0.5550079346,
0.3347654939,
-0.1683769524,
0.2386052012,
-0.7731372714,
0.6354091763,
0.5223112106,
0.5843005776,
-0.0255429652,
-0.1224210262,
-0.5415793657,
0.2190265507,
-0.5126758218,
0.5184068084,
-0.7046822309,
-0.1003236547,
0.1946733445,
0.1465911567,
-0.1534982473,
-0.2273243666,
0.3318292201,
-0.471999377,
0.0927570537,
0.4296100736,
-0.6432201862,
-0.235137254,
-0.1562793851,
-0.6068670154,
0.8110086322,
0.3174828291,
-0.8576753736,
0.4474814236,
-0.1796129644,
-0.4538040757,
0.2848213613,
-0.5079720616,
-0.4654102623,
0.1923409402,
0.1344328225,
0.8359049559,
0.4228734374,
0.7352220416,
0.0556223057,
-0.655541122,
0.2404619455,
-0.1424202472,
0.2061746269,
0.4037170112,
0.0177235585,
0.4082276225,
-0.9269624949,
-0.1255883425,
0.0177629944,
-0.7695144415,
0.0194664188,
0.2433783412,
0.0220100228,
0.0054480876,
0.0971097574,
-0.3743793368,
0.1684851795,
-0.4939606488,
0.1681040674,
0.6293822527,
0.0842651054,
0.8616404533,
-0.0142089063,
0.4284657836,
0.0259426571,
0.047284238,
-0.259534806,
-0.4330149889,
-0.390712142,
-0.4905128777,
0.3647542,
0.5432106853,
-0.9115155935,
0.7507652044,
-0.1141965538,
-0.0880285278,
-0.3105610907,
-0.1316494644,
0.2860421538,
0.1613233685,
0.3111372292,
-0.465474993,
-0.6938114762,
-0.715246737,
-0.1674310565,
-0.0639638901,
-0.4653242528,
0.1279738992,
0.2795641124,
-0.1972358376,
0.8859592676,
-0.4846800566,
-0.2894506752,
-0.6498680711,
0.098760508,
0.5539448857,
0.8582516313,
0.3533601463,
-0.786648035,
-0.4612392187,
-0.1850742698,
-0.4373315871,
0.0994029492,
-0.4288959205,
0.1616963297,
0.0430075042,
0.4494206607,
-0.250838697,
0.7116315365,
0.5116559267,
-0.2070459276,
0.4586746991,
-0.6500977278,
0.2208828926,
-0.8549452424,
-0.2094162703,
0.0223773941,
-0.3467827141,
-0.613148272,
-0.0486557521,
0.1966842562,
-0.1616203934,
0.0659180731,
-0.1978520602,
-0.2940644026,
0.010096563,
-0.0136507498,
-0.3537180424,
-0.2193057686,
0.6718380451,
0.5612620711,
0.7261234522,
0.6696584821,
-0.4837512076,
0.1036949009,
0.1123871356,
-0.380202651,
-0.0110846916,
-0.4023430943,
0.0955443159,
-0.5753986239,
0.5673360825,
-0.7172684669,
-0.3470084667,
0.1467511356,
-0.6101489663,
0.6311678886,
0.0321632139,
-0.6253527403,
0.0973562226,
0.1157482043,
0.0872253925,
0.3583260179,
-0.1457185447,
0.4084879458,
0.1461849511,
-0.0220858417,
-0.3733671308,
-0.9196669459,
-0.2420758456,
0.3539376557,
-0.3809435964,
0.5809204578,
0.0496556088,
0.1986895353,
-0.0357934386,
-0.2877518535,
-0.1375818998,
0.0827373117,
0.3826558888,
-0.0590628386,
-0.0536403656,
0.0321024992,
-0.0227089915,
-0.4388053119,
-0.2534297407,
-0.5490748882,
0.4944703579,
-0.1333714873,
-0.4188548923,
-0.6185734272,
0.6764701009,
-0.4260296822,
-0.1917563677,
1.0713335276,
0.4292323887,
-0.6410854459,
-0.3507914841,
-0.0698957667,
-0.2073125392,
-0.3875655234,
0.7137315869,
-0.623449862,
-1.1421260834,
0.3409585357,
-0.0060109315,
-0.4026719034,
0.2233424485,
0.5160573125,
-0.1348885,
1.0925258398,
1.1691097021,
0.2316568643,
0.6718293428,
-0.2742148638,
0.5044440031,
-0.0463076569,
-0.5356033444,
-0.3855543137,
0.1684792787,
-0.4835389256,
-0.8371745348,
-0.1498923004,
0.5574213862,
-0.1006780565,
0.6165845394,
-0.7425493598,
0.3718250692,
0.5054793358,
0.1624334455,
0.0288568698,
0.1204076931,
0.0130604785,
-0.1128277481,
-0.8382922411,
-0.5598074794,
0.8135966063,
0.6501839757,
0.7832214236,
-0.1766685396,
0.8410915136,
0.2277005315,
0.021977786,
-0.5695035458,
0.3711112738,
-0.3307496011,
-0.1648763865,
-0.004597018,
-0.5955172777,
-0.6600143909,
-0.2208927423,
-0.1448537856,
-0.8562119603,
0.432833463,
-0.0020739422,
-0.2600911856,
0.3361850977,
-0.6778303981,
0.6057193875,
0.2941721976,
-0.2012075931,
-0.1545187682,
-0.7355678678,
-0.1597142518,
0.1514337808,
0.2849915326,
0.3578797281,
0.2634878755,
0.8509226441,
-0.1118624955,
0.8166078329,
-0.280113399,
0.2167521268,
0.2639128864,
0.1374809742,
0.4379044175,
0.4222190976,
0.0212279055,
-0.1064654663,
-0.0056764646,
-0.669354856,
-0.7538468838,
0.1846988946,
-0.6663253307,
-0.1464901567,
-0.4195540547,
-0.5564165711,
-0.2045589387,
-0.203133285,
0.2072543055,
0.2339393348,
0.0064546443,
0.3345238864,
0.7141398191,
-0.2847462595,
-0.0436483882,
0.1123121604,
0.1770927012,
-0.2462464422,
0.8365727067,
0.0682638735,
-0.0908334255,
0.8827903867,
-0.3302766085,
0.1014174819,
-0.814945817,
0.2860155702,
0.1109358072,
-0.7822050452,
-0.3752110898,
-0.6673666239,
-0.4659775794,
-0.7570309639,
-0.3220470846,
-0.2534407973,
-0.3165014684,
-0.3462129235,
-0.3399890065,
0.016174959,
0.8162050247,
-0.1492815316,
0.6980258822,
-0.4946148992,
0.1312775165,
0.121545732,
0.5592504144,
-0.5496932268,
-0.2370079458,
-0.4774614871,
-0.3493991792,
0.1795080304,
-1.0413719416,
0.5267845392,
0.4096871316,
0.7858472466,
0.4892635942,
-0.0027465788,
0.4587397575,
-0.3603738546,
0.6386753321,
0.186525479,
-0.8582103848,
0.6593713164,
-0.1328429729,
0.11237818,
0.3958042264,
0.4965997636,
-0.3583116829,
-0.45516482,
-0.7832681537,
-0.7217140794,
0.8854627013,
0.3915266097,
-0.1128195524,
-0.2002738118,
0.5738295913,
0.1661447287,
0.3622278273,
-0.6379209757,
-0.0667991489,
-0.3890696764,
-0.5866035819,
-0.2001792043,
-0.6029886603,
0.075386025,
-0.0268581491,
0.4503729939,
-0.3448350728,
0.7726297975,
0.2213107944,
-0.2646352649,
0.147725597,
0.2904064059,
0.2520734966,
0.5362311006,
-0.4596167207,
0.3867819011,
-0.0097717214,
-0.4491386116,
-0.1887067854,
0.143355459,
0.215653643,
-0.0761396214,
0.8520599008,
0.7854163647,
0.1946194321,
-0.3271107078,
0.6139343381,
-0.1658409834,
-0.3745347857,
-0.2452083528,
0.1421978921,
-0.0529622994,
0.0604033209,
0.49086532,
0.3292923868,
0.2133412212,
-0.5680041909,
0.4858181775,
-0.1134637594,
-0.2535253167,
-0.3648327291,
0.4771941602,
-0.1488459557,
-0.1672780365,
0.4174609482,
-0.4206253588,
-0.5258359313,
0.4540778995,
0.7475993633,
0.3155800402,
-0.2863627076,
0.2822775543,
0.4762036204,
0.0935349837,
-0.0703928471,
0.4405559003,
-0.668866396,
-0.7492867112,
-0.8166680336,
-0.8318844438,
-0.075121887,
-0.3089511395,
-0.7259641886,
-0.1101972014,
-0.647419095,
0.0582106598,
-0.49807778,
0.1975133419,
-0.5571873784,
0.2829631865,
0.3025563061,
0.9127793312,
-1.1583614349,
1.1234003305,
0.7674886584,
-0.4551592767,
-1.1120283604,
-0.2438429892,
-0.403575778,
-0.3045406044,
0.6763485074,
0.198926568,
0.1229221895,
-0.220679611,
-0.8375701904,
-0.7132440805,
0.6942315698,
0.4536488056,
-0.4916270971,
-0.0671393946,
0.0868246853,
0.4106266201,
-0.7530751824,
0.0599679276,
0.662116468,
0.1801918894,
0.1013304219,
-0.6638270617,
0.0031624301,
-0.398594439,
0.3331103027,
-0.3158895075,
-0.0224219244,
0.7933605313,
0.066219151,
-0.5152261257,
-0.0770973563,
0.9565069079,
0.4425739944,
0.132621333,
0.1929227114,
0.2058885098,
0.6439646482,
-0.3431127369,
1.0756129026,
-0.0333660468,
0.609985888,
1.0657072067,
0.0914605483,
0.5998721719,
0.3838460445,
-0.5479260683,
0.5241239071,
0.7300325036,
0.2433016002,
0.7837708592,
0.3825374246,
-0.1005450562,
-0.3927163482,
0.1632526368,
-0.2132837921,
0.206226632,
0.5495403409,
-0.2931266725,
0.0582768321,
0.1346915364,
-0.1489569247,
0.604608357,
-0.162877515,
0.7812179327,
-0.020351259,
-0.2188086659,
0.3449254632,
0.2836976051,
0.8011725545,
-0.8457132578,
-0.1771751195,
-0.0501955934,
0.2208265066,
-0.6101511717,
-0.7394301295,
0.5869247317,
-0.4415748715,
-0.3167282641,
-0.6639463902,
0.9652794003,
-0.5703516603,
-0.3420130908,
0.228818357,
-0.0057596983,
0.3298068941,
-0.1923113018,
-0.3807678819,
-0.0666326284,
-0.1308214217,
-0.1873962879,
0.2295610607,
0.4889896512,
-0.0871985853,
0.3903609812,
0.5708928108,
0.4313649237,
0.1008396149,
0.2548502386,
0.8565729856,
-0.4242717326,
-0.8502258658,
-0.2273196429,
0.494776994,
-0.0615988746,
0.2743411362,
0.4819492698,
0.3342262805,
1.0129626989,
-0.3224507272,
0.4923917055,
-0.1147422791,
0.2652349472,
-0.4029734731,
0.6091969609,
-0.1404401511,
-0.0050935466,
-0.1129681244,
-0.7240234017,
-0.8092589974,
1.2338944674,
-0.4650908113,
0.1409778446,
0.698160708,
0.7101832628,
0.0653502718,
-0.0459999107,
0.4289703369,
-0.1170681641,
0.1014826596,
0.5872958899,
0.7227176428,
-0.2925270498,
0.2336462736,
-0.2495957166,
-0.5670779943,
-0.1971234381,
-0.5272237062,
-0.5264200568,
-0.8455763459,
-0.4602845907,
-0.2596750259,
0.2213430256,
0.7121195793,
0.9536239505,
-1.1152949333,
-0.0741498768,
-0.4890143275,
0.0281648003,
-0.6442348361,
-0.2881062329,
0.6144095659,
-0.640196085,
-0.6726441979,
0.3970727623,
0.4209724069,
-0.2176957279,
0.1168702766,
-0.2342883497,
-0.4092410207,
-0.1151279509,
0.4713185728,
-0.0503870808,
-0.3250512779,
-0.2183898985,
-0.1475704014,
-0.0400077067,
0.069349356,
0.9407564998,
-0.845284462,
0.3263424933,
0.7216335535,
0.5450638533,
0.6280976534,
-0.0589224361,
0.6859558821,
-1.2329491377,
0.6191616654,
0.4704655707,
0.2924063504,
0.2998604178,
-0.5250858068,
0.46286726,
0.1329443306,
-0.4399300814,
-0.5935282111,
0.3561938405,
-0.9609698057,
-0.489416033,
0.8765621185,
-0.6442474723,
-0.3330337703,
-0.1459547877,
0.0707395226,
0.7179808021,
-0.3951553106,
0.2948722541,
0.4187368453,
-0.0940635204,
-0.2413620651,
-0.5769039989,
0.5624468327,
0.2814613581,
-0.4611611068,
-0.2334379405,
0.285774231,
0.0919285864,
0.1996211559,
0.8153284788,
-0.2143945098,
0.115274027,
0.1782349497,
0.1953432113,
-0.0490073487,
-0.6529359818,
-0.4667629302,
0.6302511096,
-0.0817603469,
-0.2636886239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13905v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13905v2
|
Domain-Specific Fine-Tuning of Large Language Models for Interactive Robot Programming
| 2023-12-21T14:51:04 | 2024-04-21T09:24:39 |
Benjamin Alt, Urs Keßner, Aleksandar Taranovic, Darko Katic, Andreas Hermann, Rainer Jäkel, Gerhard Neumann
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG, 68T40, I.2.9; I.2.5; I.2.6; I.2.7
|
Industrial robots are applied in a widening range of industries, but robot
programming mostly remains a task limited to programming experts. We propose a
natural language-based assistant for programming of advanced, industrial
robotic applications and investigate strategies for domain-specific fine-tuning
of foundation models with limited data and compute.
|
[
-0.4361359775,
-1.0872395039,
0.4800610244,
-0.0245315637,
0.1795697063,
-0.0248909574,
-0.1156035587,
-0.7195737958,
0.1664704382,
0.9960737824,
-0.9712699652,
-0.5280962586,
-0.3942399919,
0.0888735652,
-0.0778900459,
0.7301110029,
-0.0487097166,
-0.2359446138,
0.0134987095,
-0.1615195423,
-0.4258829951,
-0.382776916,
-0.7873959541,
-0.3046228588,
0.1124138758,
0.5496058464,
1.1491030455,
0.6184000373,
0.9641904831,
0.3518619239,
0.2108929753,
0.4947755337,
-0.2633225918,
0.0116748158,
-0.7018013597,
-0.347756952,
-0.8223258257,
-0.4391131699,
0.1102445722,
1.1474518776,
0.1971385777,
0.1695058346,
-0.1859592199,
0.8973059058,
-0.4838122427,
0.1936655492,
-0.6345795393,
0.0751581267,
0.198650375,
-0.439893961,
-0.2315481007,
-0.2627082765,
-0.0442993045,
-0.7667456269,
0.3198207617,
0.0383902229,
0.997030735,
0.7371205688,
-0.2791220546,
-0.2800834179,
-1.1626609564,
0.8772113323,
-0.7288237214,
0.2612578869,
0.6320653558,
0.3364432454,
-0.5701690912,
-0.6551592946,
-0.6326217651,
-0.477943331,
-0.0549211949,
-0.0980634838,
-0.1644687951,
0.7374539971,
0.1677596569,
0.191754505,
-0.5304851532,
0.4229350686,
-0.3818050325,
0.1581593007,
0.7240610719,
0.3943106234,
0.3816978037,
0.2684226334,
0.0232834015,
0.0016676171,
-0.4286452234,
-0.2314242572,
0.3656157851,
0.7097027302,
0.0074042692,
0.7662004828,
-0.9323607087,
1.2487756014,
-0.2627206743,
-0.0435650907,
0.0039813588,
-0.0769677162,
-0.4834771752,
-0.5439762473,
0.4264996648,
0.4650169909,
0.5960623026,
-0.3188324869,
-0.3075181544,
0.2137456983,
0.4019018114,
-0.2274813354,
-0.5586281419,
0.35166803,
-0.298513025,
-0.0083097173,
-0.1483630836,
-0.249931559,
-0.4194756448,
-0.7699457407,
0.5469074249,
-0.0053577796,
0.0293007754,
0.6717389226,
-0.1445030123,
-0.0652542263,
0.4159258902,
-0.7386271358,
0.2641964257,
0.6581550241,
0.6170862913,
-0.0604533069,
-0.2785175741,
-0.5640595555,
0.433114022,
-0.3131153584,
0.7555075288,
-0.9793630838,
-0.2072368413,
0.0994100347,
0.3138400614,
-0.0379698724,
-0.845594883,
0.3100158274,
-0.4091616869,
-0.1495905519,
0.4914631248,
-0.4016342461,
-0.4886913002,
0.0757440478,
-0.574805975,
0.687722683,
0.5214287043,
-0.019050533,
0.216095835,
-1.0803067684,
-0.7266688347,
-0.0796573758,
-0.1485311538,
-0.188164413,
-0.2606017888,
-0.0589871742,
0.7327512503,
-0.1740328074,
0.2456365526,
-0.4211161435,
0.0261584576,
-0.1178044751,
-0.0568574034,
0.5285516381,
0.2212617993,
-0.0959970728,
0.3841134906,
-0.9631649852,
-0.1223841235,
-0.0469648726,
-0.0922956392,
0.0129768467,
-0.0366021432,
-0.0418003127,
0.0923835859,
0.5826536417,
-0.297013104,
0.5992747545,
-0.5271160007,
0.2033035904,
0.3730315268,
0.0897008181,
0.5855989456,
-0.3494051695,
0.8869709373,
-0.5957586169,
0.0325524919,
0.1528353542,
-0.4836991429,
-0.8930379152,
-0.2439547777,
0.1690512598,
0.6350128055,
-0.7053304911,
0.6226254106,
0.1155928075,
-0.3968883157,
-0.469135344,
0.2559538782,
0.2267723382,
0.3194006383,
0.4484408498,
-0.5390462279,
-0.4687760472,
-1.2723829746,
0.1216216311,
0.2730521858,
-0.47619012,
0.359518975,
0.214196071,
-0.5662798285,
1.1065802574,
-0.8542903662,
-0.7022970319,
-0.3328935802,
0.3104822934,
0.4259906113,
0.6053104401,
0.616848886,
-0.6229116321,
-0.5004721284,
0.5439150929,
-0.4777284861,
-0.1085026041,
-0.2890963852,
-0.3954108655,
0.083179757,
0.587059021,
-0.8835791945,
0.5566086769,
0.5905553102,
0.0347414277,
0.3431579471,
-0.4716177285,
-0.1578109413,
-0.6734475493,
0.2301406115,
0.0408685543,
-0.3201111257,
-0.7700135708,
0.4716708958,
-0.3815447092,
-0.2286167443,
-0.330213815,
0.6367104053,
-0.4062025845,
-0.1200694293,
-0.728469193,
0.2578681409,
0.0964002535,
0.8564785719,
0.5845935345,
0.5288086534,
0.4881077111,
-1.1213111877,
0.3955662549,
0.45123595,
-0.124789834,
0.1697241217,
-0.6259410977,
0.2217581719,
0.1822355092,
0.0159598961,
-0.5653293729,
-0.5679064989,
0.145016253,
-0.3961191773,
0.2501441538,
-0.2543991208,
-0.5763151646,
-0.4640335143,
0.0613952242,
-0.1326246858,
0.4039305747,
-0.37637797,
0.7655566335,
0.5197883248,
-0.2689596117,
-0.3369455636,
-0.3344649374,
-0.1339249462,
0.1348136067,
-0.7281270623,
0.2462073714,
-0.2979285121,
-0.1924081445,
-0.2565147281,
-0.1227823421,
-0.5895411968,
0.2757582664,
-0.057023149,
-0.1008019894,
-0.1847464144,
-0.0786395669,
0.2650090456,
-0.1471137702,
0.021729352,
0.0997303948,
0.5713356733,
0.1974922121,
-0.4405405223,
-0.6582218409,
0.1799093634,
0.5665819049,
-0.0826922655,
0.485727638,
0.2840439975,
-0.5653437376,
-0.4323788881,
-0.0276327897,
-0.1628410667,
-0.6812057495,
0.525816679,
-0.375225842,
-0.5801475644,
0.4194552898,
-0.5591782331,
0.1302168518,
0.4006694257,
0.5909398198,
0.1072875187,
1.241019845,
1.2477471828,
-0.1168152466,
0.3545406461,
-0.3295098245,
0.317840308,
-0.5546810627,
-0.0031914804,
-0.7859552503,
-0.4771393836,
-0.3185164332,
-0.3501143754,
0.070345521,
0.1068032831,
-0.55427742,
0.7110142708,
-0.8717675805,
0.6043180823,
0.6623545885,
-0.0054999795,
0.2240680903,
-0.4375336766,
0.3603228927,
0.3615081012,
-0.8611620069,
-0.8149420023,
0.5427337885,
0.3064361513,
0.8676258326,
0.0009185823,
0.1948269606,
0.4745691419,
-0.203924492,
-0.8973090649,
0.5109297633,
-0.4744287133,
-0.6734215021,
-0.523317337,
-0.0423962623,
-1.1474093199,
-0.4521202743,
-0.0206875354,
-0.8806709647,
0.2876114547,
0.5055914521,
-0.5611541867,
0.3436526358,
-0.8546056151,
1.0597778559,
-0.2207329571,
-0.0406546853,
-0.3598973453,
-0.7609157562,
-0.1131671518,
0.1045329049,
0.0727459565,
-0.368799448,
0.1367408484,
0.2485260814,
-0.2775945365,
1.0592564344,
-0.1733199805,
-0.2698565722,
0.3276287317,
0.5336752534,
0.6484130025,
-0.1760100573,
-0.2335987091,
-0.1290034801,
-0.2989136577,
-0.3081910908,
-0.639308095,
0.4168947041,
-0.5981881618,
-0.6525122523,
0.042331133,
-0.7244687676,
-0.6194535494,
0.2349156737,
-0.2069940418,
0.284190923,
-0.0288355947,
0.3667788804,
0.5240567327,
-0.4663443863,
0.1741446704,
0.7072995901,
0.0534079634,
0.3801185191,
0.8537079692,
-0.3137828112,
0.2676665187,
0.8961802125,
-0.0546163805,
0.2360401601,
-0.4972777665,
-0.602494657,
-0.272167474,
-0.5414144993,
-0.609152317,
-0.6184513569,
-0.2888497412,
-0.1413513869,
-0.9120257497,
-0.4966327548,
-0.818161428,
-0.4123434126,
0.0957923383,
0.8486078978,
0.9199869633,
0.0291660875,
0.6026393771,
-0.8392161131,
0.7536249757,
0.234201178,
0.6982771754,
-0.1403859705,
-0.4054718018,
-0.4408907592,
0.2794007361,
-0.1183018237,
-0.2785795331,
0.5426283479,
0.437045902,
0.5186596513,
0.3960539401,
0.3162969053,
0.4076945484,
-0.4295764267,
0.821673274,
-0.1598892212,
-0.6967017055,
0.6739951968,
-0.6463061571,
0.4355160594,
0.4227715433,
0.371958971,
-0.2216751873,
-0.5302067995,
-0.3798579574,
-0.9827896357,
0.8888291717,
0.0420778133,
0.3870444596,
0.1455767602,
0.2382321209,
0.4432353675,
0.2124085277,
-0.4139021337,
-0.1129744202,
0.1955756694,
-0.3400528133,
0.1796444356,
0.3140195608,
-0.1853687912,
-0.3238968551,
0.6815948486,
-0.383371532,
0.3550780118,
-0.2635946274,
-0.0902458951,
-0.3858297765,
-0.1366208196,
0.748418808,
0.7789357305,
-0.3442409933,
-0.3574256897,
0.215616554,
-0.4103247225,
-0.4784427881,
0.0061494932,
0.1125349179,
-0.1382833719,
0.1177710593,
0.7849605083,
-0.1670681536,
-1.0872741938,
-0.062736541,
0.3890440762,
-0.1201484054,
-0.3912294805,
0.706915617,
0.0198749248,
0.3103775978,
0.2177928984,
0.2240445167,
0.3734512329,
-0.4275676012,
0.1905589998,
0.3023144007,
-0.3109759986,
-0.1857070476,
0.8776813745,
0.4236081839,
-0.783285737,
0.2767711282,
-0.1251202673,
-0.4603480399,
1.1130253077,
0.3395155072,
0.899957478,
0.0527966619,
0.0846404284,
0.2176488191,
0.4058564603,
0.1236344129,
0.3553717434,
0.183694616,
-0.7396361232,
-0.4237333834,
-0.5238065124,
-0.9727433324,
0.0925949067,
-0.3925355077,
0.5858371258,
-0.8019650578,
-0.0407884456,
0.0988790244,
-0.0793494955,
-0.8515294194,
0.5957729816,
-0.0615797788,
0.8170723319,
-0.443736881,
0.9790554047,
0.9150105715,
-0.5434273481,
-0.5264254808,
-0.2990320623,
-0.4086635113,
-0.707265079,
0.5775389671,
-0.1848246753,
-0.515147388,
0.02237547,
-0.8553674221,
-0.7331619263,
0.7613731623,
0.3830249012,
-0.4852060974,
0.2279706895,
0.3746162355,
0.8126215935,
-0.4596368372,
-0.1198665872,
0.5156622529,
0.4437740147,
-0.3988408446,
-1.3490160704,
-0.4390330911,
-0.2256913781,
-0.2489100695,
0.2542903721,
-0.9495820403,
0.4906805456,
0.1482783705,
0.205818817,
0.2602818012,
0.5661696196,
-0.164800182,
0.2771612406,
0.1987495422,
0.1251551211,
0.7222650051,
0.2681456506,
0.9715836644,
-0.6704584956,
0.1054105312,
1.2647584677,
-0.4404501319,
0.794197917,
0.027882874,
-0.2738615274,
0.5446588993,
0.2736912668,
0.0244633798,
0.2991844416,
-0.0174743906,
-0.0773943961,
-0.0823153183,
-0.25876531,
-0.118615441,
0.4089043438,
0.7811731696,
-0.0958248377,
0.2807011902,
-0.0273418166,
-0.1991787106,
0.4193652868,
-0.2410072386,
0.6473183036,
-0.0575269759,
-0.2673240602,
0.4384378195,
0.4391171336,
0.5674381852,
-0.7286444306,
-0.2046277076,
-0.1625771374,
0.2359442115,
-0.1661743224,
-0.8699259162,
0.6121952534,
-0.087014772,
-0.2188372612,
-0.1498165578,
0.7657697797,
-0.2988710105,
-0.1586443931,
0.205292508,
0.288276732,
0.0206879135,
0.0328963846,
-0.7011318803,
-0.2755863965,
0.0175005402,
-0.2749248445,
0.1020534635,
0.5639474392,
0.0096222032,
1.3104662895,
0.3636012673,
-0.2778179944,
-0.2213366181,
0.1698470712,
0.6973490119,
-0.7214044333,
-0.3352415264,
-0.1451442242,
0.4902130067,
0.1137546301,
-0.4002561271,
0.496589452,
0.4641229808,
1.080363512,
-0.5609502792,
0.7781033516,
-0.1725477725,
0.6855196357,
-0.5460379124,
0.6383526325,
-0.6808745861,
-0.0946691558,
-0.3501013517,
-0.8179171085,
-0.6094999313,
0.9978892207,
-0.0265460182,
-0.0028921303,
0.322191745,
1.0354450941,
-0.3861021399,
-0.2853295803,
0.4282818735,
0.016598409,
-0.0797072798,
0.3184090555,
0.3932829797,
0.0375544988,
0.3577103615,
-0.4051738977,
0.0514891259,
-0.4082690477,
-0.8213142753,
-0.8008190989,
-0.3645633757,
-0.561129868,
-0.0216440149,
-0.0551786795,
1.2513211966,
0.7657974362,
-1.0471506119,
-0.3564680517,
-0.1526048332,
-0.0051233675,
-0.3180466592,
-0.1897034198,
0.3112177253,
-0.1554651856,
-1.0545096397,
0.5975304842,
0.262029618,
-0.1250060052,
-0.1949446648,
-0.1910482496,
-0.0931815058,
0.3129817247,
0.6769450903,
0.7278517485,
-0.3486573398,
-0.5028297901,
0.1510402113,
0.1637360454,
0.0939767584,
0.597866118,
-0.5709390044,
0.5849922299,
0.3909085989,
0.7629156113,
0.109829925,
-0.0073208716,
1.1375881433,
-0.9035881758,
0.5585922003,
0.3943056464,
0.245931223,
0.2690201998,
-0.5411132574,
0.8984229565,
-0.2053567767,
-0.5758924484,
-0.6295053363,
0.4690208435,
-1.0875089169,
-0.401144743,
1.0004372597,
0.309273839,
-0.0109429704,
-0.4795678854,
-0.6283380389,
0.2841195464,
-0.3513185382,
0.8318296671,
0.4482657313,
-0.5323873162,
0.1771890968,
-0.8578342795,
0.4923259616,
0.2458557189,
-0.7863240242,
0.0813291967,
0.4553407431,
-0.2362674922,
0.1131017283,
0.3864230216,
0.4467875063,
0.3286911547,
0.050085295,
0.5478361249,
0.1066565737,
-0.5468531251,
-0.0316116847,
-0.0966132954,
0.584443748,
-0.0302222129
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13881v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13881v1
|
Diversifying Knowledge Enhancement of Biomedical Language Models using Adapter Modules and Knowledge Graphs
| 2023-12-21T14:26:57 | 2023-12-21T14:26:57 |
Juraj Vladika, Alexander Fichtl, Florian Matthes
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advances in natural language processing (NLP) owe their success to
pre-training language models on large amounts of unstructured data. Still,
there is an increasing effort to combine the unstructured nature of LMs with
structured knowledge and reasoning. Particularly in the rapidly evolving field
of biomedical NLP, knowledge-enhanced language models (KELMs) have emerged as
promising tools to bridge the gap between large language models and
domain-specific knowledge, considering the available biomedical knowledge
graphs (KGs) curated by experts over the decades. In this paper, we develop an
approach that uses lightweight adapter modules to inject structured biomedical
knowledge into pre-trained language models (PLMs). We use two large KGs, the
biomedical knowledge system UMLS and the novel biochemical ontology OntoChem,
with two prominent biomedical PLMs, PubMedBERT and BioLinkBERT. The approach
includes partitioning knowledge graphs into smaller subgraphs, fine-tuning
adapter modules for each subgraph, and combining the knowledge in a fusion
layer. We test the performance on three downstream tasks: document
classification,question answering, and natural language inference. We show that
our methodology leads to performance improvements in several instances while
keeping requirements in computing power low. Finally, we provide a detailed
interpretation of the results and report valuable insights for future work.
|
[
-0.132813707,
-0.5511632562,
0.6002032161,
-0.1590690911,
-0.2407567203,
0.1904982626,
-0.1174756289,
-0.5395758748,
0.1664068103,
0.7003914714,
-0.129594177,
-0.6568525434,
-0.4577824473,
0.1296216547,
0.042828057,
1.1117135286,
0.2269619256,
0.2145387828,
-0.6086142063,
-0.5537793636,
-0.22545138,
-0.1458063424,
-0.3616366684,
-0.6583048105,
0.5444058776,
0.0819712207,
0.4856564105,
0.5497860909,
0.4677128196,
0.2819439471,
-0.3130854964,
0.2407033443,
-0.2652419806,
0.0980098397,
-0.4901649058,
-0.3567733765,
-0.5529673696,
-0.4378871918,
0.7328918576,
1.2587777376,
0.0968829468,
-0.1191919073,
0.238391906,
0.7640786767,
-0.5888542533,
0.0836247206,
-0.5876969099,
-0.0889365748,
-0.1729293019,
0.0182615351,
-0.4004027247,
-0.1100925133,
0.3781439066,
-0.5490416884,
-0.0837700218,
-0.0043412014,
0.3760489821,
0.2421906739,
-0.452852428,
-0.0777479857,
-0.4368454814,
0.682151258,
-1.0190577507,
0.5919126272,
0.0764631703,
0.1760185361,
-0.2075669318,
-1.0046768188,
-0.3523122966,
-0.0511679016,
-0.4886260629,
0.1414508969,
-0.245879218,
0.3647285998,
-0.0322455615,
0.1674692929,
-0.5797607303,
0.2694967389,
-0.3843286037,
-0.1870319545,
0.4090120792,
0.1553632468,
0.3491121531,
-0.1363037676,
-0.1465408802,
-0.0505411252,
-0.5156129599,
0.0266657136,
0.0187992007,
0.3706589937,
0.0744655728,
0.5807080865,
-0.3103753328,
0.9824293256,
-0.3001448214,
-0.1601165533,
0.4007916749,
-0.5919077992,
-0.2067548335,
0.0535362102,
0.7044513226,
0.1499005109,
-0.155365929,
-0.4365963638,
0.1302299201,
-0.1659041494,
0.2671684921,
-0.8314757347,
-0.402056545,
0.3400975764,
-0.5446771383,
-0.1763171107,
-0.3690503538,
-0.7561363578,
-0.5397262573,
0.0879556984,
0.5588981509,
-0.7344200015,
-0.0787496567,
0.3329494298,
-0.5747718215,
-0.0190558191,
0.1231461242,
-0.8027246594,
0.2142967731,
0.3758483827,
0.6809335947,
-0.2059109807,
0.0067669386,
-0.2765946686,
0.5919756293,
0.1891378462,
0.9981600046,
-0.567340076,
-0.3628827929,
-0.2754151523,
0.0018870063,
-0.1427659094,
-0.5804686546,
0.4873140752,
-0.6221606135,
0.116316013,
-0.1861307323,
-0.7709905505,
-0.1024224013,
0.1286680251,
-0.3561777472,
0.7970144153,
0.2237563133,
-0.9564960003,
0.3890717626,
-1.0425108671,
-0.6452823281,
0.3790353239,
-0.0460048728,
-0.3216080666,
-0.1402870268,
0.1732756943,
0.4158942997,
-0.069219403,
0.028221311,
-0.6434924603,
0.1245637536,
0.196032688,
0.2484122813,
0.7559106946,
0.0727592707,
0.0693658441,
0.316922009,
-0.8730178475,
0.1043050885,
-0.1969820559,
-0.5432335138,
-0.803506732,
-0.0392114446,
-0.1920904219,
0.0323639624,
0.1976243258,
-0.7048241496,
0.1958215386,
-0.751694262,
0.5468105674,
0.4227247834,
-0.0865955651,
0.6782348752,
-0.2867006958,
0.2048671693,
0.1589935124,
0.08175046,
-0.0416700207,
-0.6006908417,
-0.5335775614,
-0.4658671618,
0.2975846827,
0.4470416903,
-0.7895220518,
0.7153781056,
-0.3921441436,
-0.6246042848,
-0.7831830382,
0.3886920512,
0.1703094244,
0.7855865359,
0.8072029352,
-0.285913676,
-0.5379546285,
-0.839948535,
-0.4847311378,
-0.0842674077,
-0.312733382,
0.4288746715,
0.263885349,
-0.7092919946,
1.0801143646,
-0.4784774184,
-0.259649545,
-0.3876265287,
-0.0387196392,
0.1580726504,
0.4973975122,
0.4220296741,
-0.4748668969,
-0.2453282475,
0.3051832914,
-0.6659543514,
-0.3699739873,
0.3237388134,
-0.1750120372,
-0.1396325529,
0.4585393071,
-0.3860283792,
0.0457867794,
0.4584462643,
-0.4755897224,
0.3988445401,
-0.4222579598,
-0.2482762635,
-1.0978449583,
0.3171652555,
-0.2612026036,
-0.3543558121,
-0.8415594101,
-0.163189739,
-0.0008328361,
0.1769285649,
-0.2051815093,
0.6873098016,
-0.2835453749,
0.0108256461,
-0.3328923583,
0.007330941,
0.169963643,
0.1009642705,
0.0484241657,
0.1206620485,
0.5287607908,
-0.5462731123,
0.0817526057,
0.3959657252,
-0.3131197393,
0.1156734526,
-0.572111249,
-0.0108669717,
-0.3419967592,
0.3348395228,
-1.0318471193,
-0.1337576658,
-0.0418023467,
-0.1398739964,
0.1625401229,
-0.0448001325,
-0.3382288814,
-0.3802409768,
-0.2722355425,
0.4399748445,
0.6573113799,
-0.4490629733,
0.8454328775,
0.5502127409,
-0.2564335465,
-0.4265101552,
-0.7213377357,
-0.2380224317,
-0.037551634,
-0.7599123716,
0.4825486541,
0.0778429508,
-0.0664115921,
0.3386310041,
-0.0757487491,
-0.079847753,
0.0146752875,
0.0073755011,
0.2001559287,
-0.2853011191,
0.3730988503,
0.4865528941,
0.0168606751,
-0.2056752443,
-0.7015422583,
0.4269735813,
-0.0164494999,
-0.3486314118,
-0.1216957122,
0.1062641814,
0.553598702,
-0.1155205742,
1.0490256548,
0.7369687557,
-0.1900663078,
-0.1660728753,
-0.5556176901,
-0.3298740983,
-0.4438441992,
0.5554749966,
0.0347571783,
-1.1396580935,
0.4853576422,
-0.4045585096,
0.0394993238,
0.4403692186,
0.5994393826,
-0.1233127043,
0.9586804509,
0.6309546828,
0.0630011186,
0.3847799897,
-0.0491293408,
0.2189076692,
-0.7969526649,
-0.4250961542,
-0.3705884516,
-0.399404794,
-0.3273878396,
-0.555527389,
0.6812487245,
0.1729499102,
0.0278586876,
0.1870510727,
-0.2509127259,
0.3495932221,
0.335208267,
0.2626211047,
0.4320027232,
-0.0707745329,
-0.5658880472,
0.2932580411,
-1.2100522518,
-0.3842337132,
1.1851719618,
0.2141525894,
0.6570305228,
-0.0028507025,
0.4710092545,
-0.0673123747,
0.5281903148,
-0.5591777563,
0.4101911485,
-0.4117846787,
-0.3438561261,
-0.3024396598,
-0.6215711236,
-1.036226511,
0.1699902266,
-0.411555618,
-0.6334600449,
0.2788888216,
0.2116144896,
-0.578271091,
0.3245424926,
-0.6653749347,
0.9338445067,
-0.0092520081,
-0.3008733392,
-0.2478147447,
-0.8678519726,
0.3056975603,
-0.1966455877,
0.323028177,
0.0784827843,
-0.1405402571,
0.770039916,
-0.5142606497,
0.7991413474,
-0.1042372063,
0.0501851104,
0.0668444037,
-0.2781359255,
0.3265257478,
0.0036724715,
-0.1528436989,
0.1499918997,
0.1574925631,
-0.5370637774,
-0.5260673761,
0.5891507268,
-0.6629452109,
-0.301638037,
0.1490484178,
-1.0472034216,
-0.5746012926,
0.4149856567,
0.1582515389,
0.3174847066,
-0.0181657448,
0.415477246,
0.6313140988,
-0.4904047847,
0.2167296559,
0.7954610586,
-0.211752966,
-0.3841020763,
0.6719258428,
0.1513262093,
0.5068360567,
0.4979061186,
0.4012522697,
-0.3903541267,
-0.7391739488,
-0.2023296803,
0.2337498367,
-0.6224130392,
-0.2085665017,
-1.1935960054,
-0.1148987636,
-0.8298512101,
-0.0821941346,
-0.1332764328,
-0.5381038785,
-0.0304927398,
0.0605041049,
0.4816891253,
0.6309712529,
-0.0547959432,
0.2596027553,
-1.1764609814,
0.1733006537,
0.413819164,
0.4345900416,
-0.1215542108,
-0.5597025752,
-0.4101049006,
-0.0766342655,
-0.0640490949,
-0.79934448,
0.2541694641,
0.2562551498,
0.8647998571,
0.442099005,
-0.0411258861,
0.4269589186,
-0.3828521073,
0.3405172825,
-0.0277066603,
-0.4943405986,
0.5536618829,
-0.3917432427,
0.466948837,
0.7136288285,
0.3655765653,
-0.3054039776,
-0.5909813046,
-0.5289074779,
-0.8952115774,
0.4946057498,
0.1759732068,
-0.1388257444,
0.1914311647,
0.3795758784,
0.1858683228,
0.1239806786,
-0.5541739464,
-0.1974271983,
0.0168930162,
-0.5623671412,
0.042420581,
-0.0579470508,
-0.1979499608,
-0.5290237665,
0.6776687503,
-0.2801604867,
-0.0386864096,
0.1744555831,
-0.2416362613,
0.1543895304,
0.3390171826,
0.1487456411,
0.3614125252,
-0.3007142842,
0.3596235216,
0.4140456617,
-0.4714199007,
-0.1704539359,
0.2596096694,
-0.1016244218,
-0.1195036992,
0.41344136,
0.6564323306,
0.2680141628,
-0.9156660438,
0.0932689905,
0.1714305729,
0.0582073256,
0.5450416207,
0.1668957323,
0.4512661994,
0.3528599143,
0.0132032409,
0.2572849393,
0.2097559422,
-0.4208616912,
0.1902762949,
0.6044450402,
-0.2862755954,
-0.3192996085,
0.5415819883,
0.2618950903,
-0.0556767993,
0.2063102871,
-0.0951058716,
-0.3523808718,
0.2857219577,
0.7170456052,
0.5581977963,
-0.2387858629,
-0.0367755294,
0.0855380073,
0.177822262,
0.0791688263,
0.0836528689,
-0.1684190482,
-1.0112620592,
-0.446727097,
-0.9794789553,
-0.1926905513,
0.043188598,
-0.3703389168,
0.2275071889,
-0.2239818424,
-0.1039582789,
0.3106114566,
-0.1936045587,
-0.4658672214,
-0.0842515156,
0.0040141921,
0.95801723,
-0.9435333014,
1.0794246197,
1.0864905119,
-0.2190205753,
-0.5297973156,
-0.2458536327,
-0.3317068815,
-0.7632288337,
0.5883176327,
-0.0626417026,
0.1635849923,
0.2528607249,
-0.1489349753,
-0.6619662046,
1.0347735882,
0.4046712518,
-0.4235533774,
0.0374472439,
0.4156002402,
0.739392817,
-0.2851245701,
0.2160146385,
0.6606687307,
0.4395054877,
-0.0045442721,
-0.7632582188,
0.1269885004,
-0.2643766999,
-0.150641039,
0.1396992207,
-0.3433813751,
0.5534361601,
-0.1269919127,
0.1708098203,
-0.0197772421,
0.4669101536,
0.3697850704,
0.2490394711,
0.5492588282,
0.7881929874,
0.9153615236,
0.2699971199,
0.9780057669,
-0.3456944227,
0.1121011376,
0.8246162534,
-0.4078125358,
0.5927202702,
0.4912361205,
-0.2998378873,
0.7886853218,
0.1831562966,
0.1365985721,
0.4738993645,
0.008363314,
-0.4566982388,
-0.4534836411,
-0.3680281043,
-0.4369774163,
0.3077313602,
0.4719409049,
-0.4434054494,
-0.3418283165,
0.207457304,
-0.2440320998,
-0.1837394238,
-0.273704052,
1.0519669056,
0.0861008391,
-0.3260417879,
0.1298696846,
-0.0410986617,
0.5770012736,
-0.8073022962,
0.2023922652,
-0.1159877926,
0.3526266813,
-0.2158646435,
-0.6946754456,
0.3664786816,
-0.2013885379,
-0.3386793733,
-0.1147034913,
1.3856390715,
-0.664098084,
-0.6587343216,
0.5046669245,
0.5027569532,
0.009870667,
0.0864631832,
-0.4737260044,
-0.3527524173,
-0.1944487989,
-0.0847993493,
0.5703832507,
0.3178640604,
0.1246306151,
0.6240273118,
0.7532571554,
0.1834855825,
-0.0146314465,
0.0851972923,
1.2664244175,
-0.3611824811,
-0.4405167699,
-0.9802917242,
0.5019125342,
-0.2512349188,
0.0950586647,
0.6901399493,
0.6328240037,
0.4871356785,
-0.0822665989,
0.9009872079,
0.0461153053,
0.5473319292,
-0.5120658875,
1.0306061506,
-0.5341790915,
0.2948959768,
-0.2138302624,
-0.4681185186,
-0.5060704947,
0.3121850789,
-0.3139768839,
-0.0373037569,
0.6131597757,
0.7700390816,
-0.0792363063,
0.05727496,
0.2653944194,
0.5744068623,
0.2113536447,
0.54903543,
0.5530723333,
-0.1497061402,
0.5216576457,
-0.1278104782,
-0.2801552713,
-0.1675836593,
-0.810934186,
-0.8963554502,
-0.2265386283,
-0.2330913395,
-0.3905169368,
0.0424131639,
0.7084041238,
0.6695222259,
-0.9145810008,
0.0253889039,
-0.1376055777,
0.1579298377,
-0.0656292364,
-0.1746211201,
0.3160462081,
-0.5098238587,
-0.2738484144,
0.6502760053,
0.5436044335,
0.0073338873,
-0.0812775865,
0.0216341019,
-0.2453368455,
0.0567552708,
0.7040820718,
0.199752897,
-0.3151949942,
-0.0958790779,
0.015395551,
0.0588206053,
-0.0818014443,
0.80598557,
-1.132596612,
0.5477126241,
0.7656864524,
0.9289605021,
0.2023353875,
-0.1596710831,
0.6281542778,
-0.8132493496,
0.1670317948,
0.2967690825,
0.4841882586,
0.3174571991,
-0.1300679147,
0.3054711819,
0.5135712624,
-0.5101122856,
-0.8825772405,
0.0220495816,
-1.0507339239,
-0.5298032165,
1.1249570847,
-0.0510133803,
-0.1144300774,
-0.4980215728,
-0.013446073,
0.4030893743,
-0.0323509052,
0.8062431812,
0.3770983815,
-0.3174711466,
0.3187058568,
-0.3469330072,
0.4994809926,
0.7552061677,
-1.1293313503,
-0.0857315585,
0.166047439,
0.3496527374,
0.2649320662,
0.649630487,
-0.1635669768,
-0.0825717524,
-0.2349381298,
0.1077598855,
-0.0123580052,
0.0552052297,
-0.2537285984,
0.226394549,
-0.2159346938,
0.240156129
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13876v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13876v1
|
Capture the Flag: Uncovering Data Insights with Large Language Models
| 2023-12-21T14:20:06 | 2023-12-21T14:20:06 |
Issam Laradji, Perouz Taslakian, Sai Rajeswar, Valentina Zantedeschi, Alexandre Lacoste, Nicolas Chapados, David Vazquez, Christopher Pal, Alexandre Drouin
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
The extraction of a small number of relevant insights from vast amounts of
data is a crucial component of data-driven decision-making. However,
accomplishing this task requires considerable technical skills, domain
expertise, and human labor. This study explores the potential of using Large
Language Models (LLMs) to automate the discovery of insights in data,
leveraging recent advances in reasoning and code generation techniques. We
propose a new evaluation methodology based on a "capture the flag" principle,
measuring the ability of such models to recognize meaningful and pertinent
information (flags) in a dataset. We further propose two proof-of-concept
agents, with different inner workings, and compare their ability to capture
such flags in a real-world sales dataset. While the work reported here is
preliminary, our results are sufficiently interesting to mandate future
exploration by the community.
|
[
-0.5898090601,
-0.4962429702,
0.9829180241,
-0.3785110116,
-0.0098240478,
0.3373954594,
-0.1152710244,
-0.5184847713,
0.1745747775,
0.7513625622,
-0.3348357975,
-0.5990396738,
-0.4909537435,
0.1213847026,
-0.7048115134,
0.64932096,
-0.0371439792,
-0.4817672968,
-0.1208747104,
0.2299535125,
-0.0997191519,
-0.6549639702,
-0.5531177521,
-0.2595855296,
0.3268306255,
0.6375406981,
0.5555394292,
1.0251805782,
0.5639674067,
0.2391660064,
0.0529466197,
0.3446036577,
-0.3511912823,
0.0053881053,
-0.2760642767,
-0.8418984413,
-0.4136855304,
0.3181075752,
0.4956301153,
0.537483871,
0.0976403132,
0.5460320115,
-0.0730866045,
0.572495997,
-0.5138758421,
0.7606296539,
-0.8412867785,
-0.1035443172,
-0.0570843183,
-0.3861774206,
-0.579374969,
-0.4360149801,
0.0267290734,
-0.4924297631,
0.2497840524,
0.0091446852,
1.0270392895,
0.1456468701,
-0.3856391907,
-0.4692128003,
-0.7951956987,
0.79549402,
-0.8697485924,
0.1155387312,
0.2934422195,
0.6123206019,
-0.1411591768,
-0.396772027,
-0.6946079135,
-0.46104303,
0.0434029214,
-0.1087330058,
-0.2617484629,
-0.2307832837,
0.437272191,
0.3948548734,
-0.2036438882,
0.1694066375,
-0.2577600777,
-0.3137437701,
1.0925412178,
0.3653195202,
0.1262485534,
-0.0320224911,
-0.2419012338,
-0.2981288135,
-0.8143181801,
0.3711605966,
0.1600145847,
0.6506165266,
-0.2287748605,
0.7862974405,
-0.489751339,
0.4198662043,
-0.0540151894,
-0.1492360532,
-0.0086188223,
-0.4816538393,
-0.0335570425,
-0.1650284678,
0.6733922362,
0.3620367646,
0.3657386601,
-0.1928173602,
-0.5449560881,
0.1186291054,
-0.1095577255,
-0.6928512454,
-0.0893832669,
0.4400759041,
-0.4709068239,
-0.3902888894,
0.3031814694,
-0.8398113251,
-0.4678856134,
-0.485001117,
0.0481641814,
0.0890234262,
-0.453702867,
0.213083759,
-0.3130630553,
0.626778245,
0.2096387595,
-0.5352682471,
0.2136804312,
1.1712229252,
0.7695892453,
-0.1747448444,
-0.0433709584,
-0.6253701448,
-0.1566750556,
-0.6533712745,
1.0111603737,
-0.5373778343,
-0.0298524834,
0.2020116448,
-0.0633301884,
0.1868715584,
-0.5637571216,
0.229882434,
-0.9062336087,
-0.2956160307,
-0.5294485688,
-0.7227719426,
-0.2885175049,
0.390316695,
-1.0055133104,
0.8561739326,
0.0964085981,
-0.2767849863,
0.7167312503,
-0.5302374959,
-0.110192433,
0.263170898,
-0.3958182037,
-0.4700206518,
0.1262698174,
0.1769297272,
0.759013176,
-0.6746965051,
0.1081072986,
-0.2866938114,
-0.2116184682,
0.663870275,
-0.1630694717,
0.9081213474,
0.2703242302,
-0.4343968034,
-0.1963147819,
-0.503885448,
-0.1301033944,
0.3842077851,
-0.3841150701,
-0.0885990337,
0.1033215299,
-0.2274565697,
0.3590006232,
0.2197231799,
-0.3626178205,
0.3812332451,
-0.0047695264,
0.1956717223,
0.4799933434,
0.0305117816,
0.3874893486,
-0.5776119828,
0.9838711023,
-0.1890381575,
0.0961020663,
-0.3107692897,
-0.3706099689,
-0.8867231607,
-0.4219425917,
0.3959740996,
0.4376620948,
-0.8027384877,
0.5210135579,
-0.336759299,
-0.624684751,
-0.3136312068,
0.2636165321,
0.1838314533,
0.2376053035,
0.0541728027,
-0.1470151246,
-0.344759047,
-0.6627548337,
-0.1535702497,
-0.3148320615,
-0.0628624707,
0.3522588313,
0.8746072054,
0.0205967687,
1.3090256453,
-0.5609368086,
-0.1534073055,
-0.5039077401,
0.1081796661,
0.521963954,
0.1886838675,
0.4099798799,
-0.6551452279,
-0.2561836541,
0.1482796669,
-0.95519346,
-0.2794401646,
-0.3301985562,
-0.0032731576,
0.1647219509,
0.7808808088,
-0.6122571826,
0.45997262,
0.3050163984,
-0.3705440164,
0.518835187,
-0.1650058776,
0.3340137005,
-0.6512483358,
0.0043227584,
0.113244243,
-0.142216146,
-0.6083173752,
-0.0339027941,
0.3850919604,
-0.0820734873,
-0.4249323308,
0.5207359791,
-0.7591112852,
-0.2352813631,
-0.2464971244,
0.1272740513,
0.1339330226,
0.0993728712,
0.1897345483,
0.7577778697,
0.3278588653,
-0.8609952331,
0.516160965,
0.1320530623,
-0.7871178389,
0.331545949,
-0.2760408521,
0.1194867343,
-0.1768298,
0.1055760756,
-0.9647655487,
-0.3473664224,
-0.0597024746,
-0.4733193517,
0.1081641093,
-0.2769372463,
-0.7680853009,
-0.5267279148,
-0.3319100738,
0.1293975115,
0.5419803262,
-0.6142623425,
0.5551890731,
0.7918579578,
-0.2278543562,
-0.3784698248,
-0.4677861035,
0.336676687,
-0.4839595556,
-0.265670687,
-0.2184780687,
0.2459437847,
-0.4652232528,
-0.2738769352,
0.0101819355,
0.1261572838,
0.4041972756,
-0.1176096797,
0.3805863857,
-0.3739520609,
0.3045857549,
-0.3187042177,
-0.3400993347,
0.5055052042,
-0.1776176393,
0.4247089922,
-0.0510747395,
-0.3666371703,
-0.4980458021,
0.3295997679,
0.9017409682,
-0.7346803546,
0.5526260138,
-0.1751348376,
-0.1942485124,
-0.6499921679,
-0.7768966556,
-0.2099669725,
-0.428173095,
0.3929696083,
-0.4625860155,
-0.5417298079,
0.6935084462,
-0.2794139385,
0.1200443059,
0.4680801034,
0.2378195524,
-0.1024663672,
1.0350847244,
1.0987181664,
-0.0724043027,
0.3545877934,
-0.4506972134,
0.4385103583,
-0.5363259912,
-0.2888873518,
-0.9793995023,
0.0877101049,
-0.3582764566,
-0.6464079618,
0.300974369,
0.0084009469,
-0.2410746515,
0.2564017177,
-0.4375760853,
0.641272366,
0.4696195126,
-0.191155225,
0.6442328095,
0.0114570949,
0.4688072205,
0.1705046147,
-0.7189505696,
-0.9786115289,
1.3855751753,
0.6137029529,
0.8346436024,
0.019350471,
0.5417325497,
0.3330383003,
0.4397405684,
-1.1019550562,
0.7494494319,
0.0564476401,
-0.4804178178,
-0.3232082129,
-0.4083377421,
-0.9432834387,
0.0056494386,
-0.2975308299,
-0.5052314401,
0.3101733625,
0.0808468908,
-0.3439412117,
0.339135617,
-0.3900750279,
0.6430218816,
-0.5823845267,
-0.0786243752,
0.0179436915,
-0.1804589331,
0.3708620071,
-0.4470175505,
0.3973062932,
-0.3362441957,
-0.2948468626,
0.8979431391,
-0.2259100229,
0.7672762275,
-0.0759958178,
-0.4957927465,
0.4590792954,
0.2532832623,
0.5844498277,
-0.272233218,
-0.164423272,
0.2320507169,
-0.2455232292,
-0.1541253328,
-0.6717715263,
0.1702504605,
-0.1103703603,
-0.4848220646,
-0.3481132686,
-0.4856825769,
-0.0245311242,
0.0068187984,
-0.0529000647,
0.1089215726,
-0.0562322251,
0.1557407826,
0.7177030444,
-0.0053378986,
0.4816445112,
0.9399337173,
-0.3897937238,
-0.0477532633,
0.8207698464,
0.196663186,
0.3175925314,
0.3202882707,
0.2248414755,
-0.5548884273,
-0.5421056151,
-0.3462695777,
0.5224683881,
-0.8182066083,
-0.3689046204,
-0.3854444027,
0.103848502,
-0.1696461737,
-0.2151613981,
-0.4054303467,
-0.0695675239,
0.0019220613,
-0.1329520941,
0.4778807461,
0.9809862971,
-0.0207166225,
0.2322493345,
-0.7721422911,
0.1803647131,
0.3333642483,
0.2224971801,
-0.0060793548,
-0.2815999985,
-0.5161877871,
0.0839318708,
0.239732638,
-0.9735602736,
0.4043594599,
-0.25030303,
0.8935559392,
0.4837105572,
0.1023922563,
0.253857851,
0.0388044752,
0.7040612102,
-0.0696121231,
-1.0670335293,
0.658614397,
-0.2812918127,
0.2261579633,
0.5008243918,
0.4103550315,
-0.2973408997,
-0.6217912436,
-0.4313655198,
-0.7251057625,
0.6467839479,
-0.0200252663,
-0.2619641721,
0.0197422784,
0.1837658435,
0.0847225338,
0.2779104412,
-0.53891325,
0.0896221995,
0.3101574779,
-0.2452364117,
-0.1838566363,
-0.032239005,
-0.2016396523,
-0.1305242777,
0.4775436521,
-0.4674915671,
-0.0224168971,
0.1627428979,
-0.2162309736,
0.3048730791,
0.210818544,
0.0560307764,
0.8509399891,
-0.0597431697,
0.1922105104,
-0.1239718646,
-0.2731614113,
0.1330673397,
-0.0997105688,
-0.2855336964,
0.0630177334,
0.5335353613,
0.2294049263,
-0.3096812963,
-0.9743305445,
0.5529138446,
-0.0549643412,
-0.1608036011,
-0.2950012088,
-0.0674205571,
-0.0833130777,
0.5520448685,
0.4605482221,
-0.5188534856,
0.0881514773,
-0.7661270499,
0.3072809279,
0.6505582929,
-0.0618524253,
-0.0656357855,
0.4998329878,
0.2090009898,
-0.1871593446,
0.6507899165,
-0.1863127202,
-0.744148612,
1.2845125198,
0.3686344922,
0.8138414025,
-0.0393678769,
0.3598041236,
0.264233917,
0.5446522832,
-0.2421707064,
0.1529484987,
-0.3446253836,
-0.7943277955,
-0.6233261228,
-0.2893455327,
-0.5768932104,
0.1532873362,
-0.7101950049,
0.2449549139,
-0.2113072425,
-0.1943917274,
0.0624565221,
0.1201307103,
-0.9517510533,
0.0348084606,
0.4484888017,
1.0459141731,
-1.2112830877,
0.6840382814,
0.3277414143,
-0.6329229474,
-0.9695951343,
-0.0637460947,
0.1011064351,
-0.7418092489,
0.7667300105,
0.2563178837,
-0.2598359287,
-0.3226965964,
-0.7029359341,
-0.8762963414,
1.0729281902,
0.2537078559,
-0.4642667174,
0.2097528577,
0.4551011324,
0.3775793016,
-0.8982371688,
0.2122307271,
1.2957954407,
0.4354597628,
-0.1548914313,
-0.8693082333,
0.1463909596,
-0.1099619493,
-0.1818913668,
0.0989725888,
-0.3199756444,
0.9515123367,
-0.3234784901,
-0.4003695548,
-0.1246834546,
0.4356667697,
0.2903369069,
0.4115635753,
0.5952055454,
0.1294424683,
1.0494291782,
-0.0818325132,
1.0936014652,
-0.3150703013,
0.6818948388,
0.8246864676,
-0.4584323466,
0.9420859814,
0.1732407808,
-0.1625050902,
0.1713692844,
0.3028342426,
-0.2897673547,
0.1091046408,
0.2512052357,
-0.2762467861,
-0.4995206296,
-0.0828463435,
-0.0725569427,
0.7553514838,
0.6410740018,
-0.3257980049,
-0.0166751128,
-0.18725577,
0.1493510008,
0.1631671488,
-0.5285940766,
0.9222473502,
-0.0767273977,
-0.7664744258,
0.6010005474,
-0.484739691,
0.5014618635,
-0.3826143742,
-0.4377918541,
-0.4040107727,
0.0771188065,
-0.084181264,
-1.0386323929,
0.1375291944,
0.2641189396,
-0.1086941585,
-0.3441252708,
0.3940756917,
-0.2602262497,
-0.5376244783,
0.3845022917,
0.6083469391,
0.3422379494,
-0.2485045493,
-0.3616718054,
0.1449638009,
0.0022555473,
-0.1354597807,
-0.1941466331,
0.4321183562,
-0.1247673035,
0.8039855957,
0.6507257223,
0.31422925,
-0.1638528109,
-0.1418917775,
0.6869044304,
-1.0295126438,
-0.3526583314,
-0.7617010474,
0.5371117592,
-0.4056732357,
0.1556988955,
0.8335451484,
0.7614811659,
0.7701002359,
-0.0764843449,
1.0985599756,
0.2186755687,
0.7122889757,
-0.679233253,
0.8566038013,
-0.3428751826,
0.6334986687,
0.0334193669,
-0.8612411618,
-0.1449761838,
0.4655230939,
-0.3961721957,
-0.2627399266,
0.5965521336,
0.9465565085,
0.040204972,
-0.1528022885,
0.2488203794,
0.1786146611,
0.7756494284,
0.7442287207,
1.0450769663,
-0.1812973022,
0.5883603692,
-0.1403954923,
-0.6627898812,
-0.3097727299,
-1.000074029,
-0.9857695103,
-0.6383388638,
-0.5726465583,
-0.4160979986,
-0.3142113984,
0.6363174915,
0.6917901635,
-0.5876396298,
-0.4772688448,
0.1314572394,
0.3337168396,
-0.2054108679,
-0.2019120455,
0.474898994,
-0.3317111731,
-0.6276293993,
0.4511307776,
0.1839683652,
0.118637763,
-0.3728773594,
0.2261363417,
0.1199629977,
0.4540951252,
0.5923907757,
0.5374770761,
-0.5133228898,
-0.0011532819,
-0.0991313085,
-0.2084695101,
-0.0616065338,
0.9959383607,
-0.9274587035,
0.4362829328,
0.5695692301,
0.8010131121,
0.4977278411,
0.071297586,
0.5890330672,
-0.2259217948,
-0.0227886755,
0.2162091434,
0.2993421853,
0.0983654931,
-0.3917110264,
0.4719854295,
-0.2700898647,
-0.4209760129,
-0.8028819561,
0.1593954265,
-0.9584060311,
-0.2072223574,
1.1699740887,
-0.2149163187,
-0.3045226932,
-0.4266743064,
-0.0343327671,
0.0325118564,
-0.4005811512,
0.8503159285,
0.5708266497,
-0.0071293171,
-0.0250415262,
-0.966917932,
0.4436448514,
0.059709847,
-1.1738593578,
0.3718434274,
0.4589525759,
0.1478497088,
0.2405648977,
0.5499147177,
-0.0930222571,
0.3163875937,
0.0984808058,
0.1522855163,
-0.1184176579,
-0.3239767849,
-0.521782577,
0.2908464372,
0.2061049342,
-0.2808299661
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13871v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13871v2
|
Evaluating Task-oriented Dialogue Systems: A Systematic Review of Measures, Constructs and their Operationalisations
| 2023-12-21T14:15:46 | 2024-04-08T07:36:48 |
Anouck Braggaar, Christine Liebrecht, Emiel van Miltenburg, Emiel Krahmer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
This review gives an extensive overview of evaluation methods for
task-oriented dialogue systems, paying special attention to practical
applications of dialogue systems, for example for customer service. The review
(1) provides an overview of the used constructs and metrics in previous work,
(2) discusses challenges in the context of dialogue system evaluation and (3)
develops a research agenda for the future of dialogue system evaluation. We
conducted a systematic review of four databases (ACL, ACM, IEEE and Web of
Science), which after screening resulted in 122 studies. Those studies were
carefully analysed for the constructs and methods they proposed for evaluation.
We found a wide variety in both constructs and methods. Especially the
operationalisation is not always clearly reported. Newer developments
concerning large language models are discussed in two contexts: to power
dialogue systems and to use in the evaluation process. We hope that future work
will take a more critical approach to the operationalisation and specification
of the used constructs. To work towards this aim, this review ends with
recommendations for evaluation and suggestions for outstanding questions.
|
[
-0.4313565195,
-0.4821445644,
0.4724820554,
0.425090462,
-0.1231109798,
0.0711459294,
-0.1468768567,
-0.474006176,
0.0660552084,
0.8979392052,
-0.4744733572,
-0.2011034191,
-0.4320509136,
0.2776715159,
-0.5227033496,
0.7294045091,
-0.0930729955,
0.5439459682,
-0.033870019,
-0.290392518,
-0.4443536401,
-0.7308172584,
-0.5581194162,
-0.2251410484,
0.055656679,
0.2821129858,
0.4146867096,
-0.15821971,
0.8319141865,
0.4078972936,
-0.2885693312,
-0.0464295708,
-0.4894450307,
0.3587056696,
-0.1715828776,
-0.1939309686,
-0.4725869298,
0.0078108031,
0.849774003,
1.2154523134,
-0.3223529458,
0.286300987,
0.2134979665,
0.5492533445,
-0.6923917532,
0.1697821021,
-0.097165145,
0.1841059923,
0.2310715765,
0.0470599458,
-0.4194277227,
-0.3346405029,
0.6028459072,
-0.2825013995,
-0.2252584845,
0.2709858418,
0.1833316386,
-0.1839526147,
-0.3689687848,
-0.7060192823,
-0.8993701935,
0.9972187877,
-0.6509698033,
0.3626177907,
-0.1318684369,
0.3278862238,
-0.020585224,
-0.5161044002,
-0.2980128229,
-0.503862679,
-0.0379588902,
0.1386662275,
-0.1614091992,
0.4440702796,
0.4349883199,
0.6901269555,
-0.1922039539,
-0.2989226282,
-0.2997520268,
-0.1234385893,
0.5221204162,
0.6802928448,
0.1352844685,
-0.3143722415,
-0.2693267763,
0.2518743873,
-0.3217931688,
-0.0376145579,
0.4643263519,
0.2182420492,
0.1940873414,
0.7574740052,
-0.6013739109,
0.6878967881,
-0.0060507562,
-0.2469361722,
0.1277205795,
-0.7665449977,
-0.4400636554,
-0.276214987,
0.9449394941,
0.48753196,
-0.1523773968,
-0.067943193,
-0.410466224,
-0.1189576238,
0.2859457433,
-0.4396241605,
0.2206555754,
0.2268726379,
-0.7514421344,
-0.1356513649,
-0.0363039002,
-0.1156023741,
-0.1291417629,
-0.3570228517,
0.1175643727,
-0.2780886292,
-0.3719117343,
0.1768280715,
-0.3668852746,
0.0993166491,
0.4099848568,
-0.5524902344,
0.8873105645,
0.6738733053,
0.6348179579,
-0.4068153501,
0.0250786785,
0.0519003943,
-0.1903778166,
-0.2816276252,
0.688162446,
-0.5517513156,
-0.6539825201,
0.3404863477,
0.1956724524,
-0.0421203151,
-0.7945436239,
0.8081514239,
-0.3556278944,
0.2555426657,
-0.201718986,
-0.2718420923,
-0.1526019275,
0.2755813599,
-0.4115791917,
0.806643188,
0.2554190159,
-0.4468920827,
0.2685038745,
-0.8524064422,
-0.4412073195,
0.1193255484,
0.2612231374,
-0.0515532009,
0.1926908046,
-0.1256423146,
0.2240499258,
-0.5032974482,
0.2884955108,
-0.129717201,
-0.3478404284,
0.3013574481,
-0.106563814,
0.9969305396,
0.6430032253,
-0.3226612806,
0.2887720764,
-0.5167188644,
0.1397453099,
-0.3419322371,
0.0593409799,
-0.1407293081,
0.0802704096,
0.2266864032,
0.1134888604,
0.3119487762,
-0.6378504634,
-0.0062877135,
-0.3141731024,
0.3917319179,
0.1690770239,
0.3024888933,
0.3326496184,
-0.1027025059,
0.629971683,
-0.0214711484,
0.7111493349,
-0.2118811458,
-0.4409714639,
-0.961355269,
0.0397832394,
0.0280403029,
0.4675872922,
-0.6371001601,
0.6515049338,
0.0329813175,
-0.6786661744,
-0.2020445466,
-0.1495546103,
0.7238853574,
0.1825101376,
-0.1526432335,
-1.2309499979,
-0.3578668237,
-1.0052834749,
-0.1599320024,
-0.5322742462,
-0.0860037357,
0.5374529362,
0.3418156207,
-0.1936090738,
0.7823874354,
-0.3339378238,
-0.0510705896,
-0.4076188803,
0.2294848412,
0.1372059286,
0.2640963197,
0.0460782386,
-0.3185750544,
-0.2646660209,
-0.0283457898,
-0.6332748532,
-0.1110063121,
0.1474384218,
0.1967064142,
0.0505483523,
0.0182240158,
-0.4324536324,
0.2033513486,
0.1334848553,
-0.2642583847,
0.7166112661,
0.2369801849,
0.676218152,
-0.3964844346,
0.1868862361,
0.1174100563,
-0.160311833,
-0.7610784173,
-0.0390520841,
-0.2440770417,
-0.5126799345,
-0.411342293,
0.1296395212,
-0.4606394768,
-0.5134493113,
-0.2523248196,
0.109917663,
-0.0701047257,
0.3633470237,
-0.0385143533,
0.521053195,
0.4439124465,
-0.5008101463,
0.6471229196,
0.5198588967,
-0.8224406838,
0.8072220087,
-0.5796705484,
0.1040336788,
0.421084255,
0.2492077947,
-0.9808801413,
0.2302435786,
0.5677643418,
-0.2574530244,
-0.1080377251,
-0.0528801829,
-0.3205149174,
-0.3998304605,
0.0757167637,
0.281021893,
0.28091681,
0.0233056173,
0.1244963035,
0.8214204907,
-0.6089097261,
-0.372178793,
-0.042479191,
0.3951229155,
-0.0142576024,
-0.5620011091,
-0.2226352841,
0.147480458,
-0.684087038,
-0.1856987327,
-0.1829414815,
-0.1931202412,
0.1147751138,
0.1914554536,
0.1040872335,
-0.0111549851,
-0.1416148096,
-0.1648082584,
0.1347751766,
0.3598563075,
-0.2572265565,
0.4412217736,
-0.1412107646,
-0.5990760326,
-0.7197715044,
0.5098779798,
0.4170316458,
-0.0353361666,
0.143366605,
0.3292612433,
-0.1518557221,
0.2426414043,
-0.793540895,
-0.1481841356,
-0.4056716561,
0.3461977243,
-0.2724375129,
-0.8192389011,
0.4019177556,
-0.1864609271,
0.0965058208,
0.5883728862,
0.5991250873,
-0.0916336775,
1.0757801533,
0.7059798241,
0.1109134406,
0.6596439481,
-0.0677299947,
0.5770725608,
-1.0549913645,
-0.3790093362,
-0.7946352363,
0.0538529903,
-0.367197901,
-0.3433396816,
0.3406544626,
-0.0943326429,
-0.0043440242,
0.4721058607,
-0.5109583139,
-0.2144799978,
0.1215881929,
-0.1146150976,
0.567669332,
-0.2152669132,
-0.0658719167,
0.1122958139,
-0.5545161366,
-0.9322431684,
1.0446861982,
0.578880012,
0.8066270947,
-0.079932496,
0.4103524387,
0.3743165433,
0.4878326058,
-1.0012965202,
0.7660800219,
0.2204462439,
-0.7531305552,
-0.7543022037,
-0.2939256132,
-0.7504426241,
0.2114098519,
0.1330842674,
-0.8030718565,
0.2281169444,
-0.3176929653,
-0.2866249681,
-0.1352161169,
-0.9189432263,
0.6071377397,
-0.0795311257,
-0.0811778829,
-0.5785399675,
-0.4042183757,
0.4563915431,
0.4053780735,
-0.0244865101,
-0.0256369002,
0.1070094854,
1.168569684,
-0.396507293,
0.6946758032,
-0.3895267546,
-0.3362147808,
0.6190375686,
-0.2845921814,
0.0458254851,
-0.0871004984,
-0.070200868,
0.0860623792,
0.5248039961,
-0.1832213104,
-0.7716793418,
0.4494673908,
-0.4646262228,
-0.7437691689,
-0.5381735563,
-0.3410093486,
-0.5855405331,
0.1373884827,
-0.4258515239,
0.7550683022,
-0.7282418609,
0.1120054498,
0.3056000769,
-0.0689899325,
0.2141243517,
0.6471223831,
-0.289921999,
-0.4800710082,
0.4795261025,
0.0129848504,
0.3708138466,
0.0617212653,
-0.4108034968,
-0.2881557941,
-0.7715007067,
-0.301517576,
-0.0706321225,
-0.5422766805,
0.2398742437,
-0.6072062254,
-0.0720005557,
-0.4957846105,
0.3935592175,
-0.2469468564,
-0.6258839369,
0.1886002421,
0.2751227021,
-0.1712272614,
1.1561547518,
0.3354681134,
0.615095377,
-0.4517271221,
0.2973286808,
0.0545391962,
0.6638373733,
0.0586230084,
-0.384924829,
-0.5692756176,
-0.0146784941,
-0.7985683084,
-0.7342535853,
0.1830684543,
-0.2472483069,
0.6848676801,
0.4660536945,
-0.1045343578,
0.4950396717,
-0.4606998861,
1.0385417938,
0.5809616446,
-1.0268421173,
0.2380710244,
-0.3980477452,
0.2240358889,
0.6148548126,
0.296350956,
-0.9117402434,
-0.4186301827,
-0.6032250524,
-0.6070961356,
0.8473994732,
0.2826865613,
-0.0074989088,
0.0071058385,
0.0476538092,
-0.0715276971,
0.3922276199,
-0.2095129043,
-0.4153936505,
0.1800387055,
0.1391658634,
-0.0580893233,
-0.3967822492,
-0.4856490493,
0.1071143523,
0.61831671,
-0.0208994839,
0.5170484185,
0.3161834478,
-0.2170014977,
-0.1435476989,
0.6058248281,
0.1868033856,
0.9778723717,
-0.2356399745,
-0.6617402434,
0.2185517997,
-0.3541544378,
0.197938785,
-0.1088471636,
0.0968886837,
0.1295566857,
0.0751854554,
0.7687067389,
0.4788709879,
-0.743131876,
0.447009176,
-0.2383957207,
-0.1767762154,
-0.4991596043,
-0.042930983,
-0.3078892231,
0.1952872425,
0.4173819423,
0.1036066338,
0.8318499327,
-0.956856966,
-0.0509548783,
0.6610409021,
-0.8968856335,
-0.2095919847,
-0.285571456,
0.5506246686,
-0.4770180881,
0.2075608671,
-0.1313717067,
-0.3702491522,
0.3691809177,
0.3257441521,
1.0572218895,
-0.3580935895,
0.1767594665,
0.2126663923,
0.3503547013,
0.073772274,
0.5474917293,
-0.307861954,
-0.409232229,
-0.4676230252,
-0.5699744821,
-1.008789897,
-0.0391818881,
-0.8860554099,
0.1767130792,
-0.3350265026,
-0.4191595018,
-0.0440786369,
0.2605171204,
-0.6402047873,
0.2362579554,
-0.0734144077,
0.8789343238,
-0.6423959732,
0.3352492154,
0.6209625006,
-0.0470814966,
-0.257956624,
-0.2113792449,
-0.1362431198,
-0.3312449455,
0.6030342579,
-0.1574428082,
-0.3318738639,
-0.4351073205,
-0.211150676,
-0.7366537452,
0.8415070176,
-0.2104025185,
-0.752687335,
-0.037012659,
0.0688538179,
0.6383511424,
-0.5885304809,
0.9084460139,
0.9181025028,
0.4674968719,
-0.1311871558,
-1.4606003761,
-0.0599532761,
-0.2563878894,
-0.0759426132,
0.0451013967,
-0.7264610529,
0.1699585319,
0.1961447448,
-0.5214855075,
0.7075221539,
0.3271036446,
-0.0577968583,
0.3005749881,
0.6914653778,
0.4337003529,
0.2699959874,
-0.2222204953,
1.0006588697,
-0.2062895298,
0.3163656592,
0.7705079317,
-0.594293952,
0.5639119744,
0.5920906067,
-0.6048930287,
0.3164732456,
0.3659027815,
0.1377129704,
0.2409350276,
0.4770441353,
-0.1661006212,
-0.0781894177,
-0.5791966915,
-0.135851115,
0.4132501483,
0.6199690104,
-0.2671572268,
-0.1378555894,
-0.0269823242,
-0.5498018861,
-0.2066971809,
-0.3269526958,
1.2371698618,
0.1471957862,
-0.9521682262,
0.5345309377,
0.0585553572,
0.1369661689,
-0.5097195506,
0.1230048239,
0.1881211102,
-0.1336711198,
-0.2560931742,
-0.6882896423,
0.3426898122,
0.1829379946,
0.132405147,
-0.5388694406,
0.5722168684,
-0.0124131907,
-0.2542960644,
0.0614314191,
0.6388478875,
0.2761771977,
0.1641156673,
-0.7402472496,
0.2973789871,
-0.0226310957,
-0.2553835511,
0.2424155325,
0.3058968484,
0.0192888025,
0.646933198,
0.4373806417,
0.0698545501,
-0.2892746329,
0.4250797331,
0.8374550939,
-0.8819823861,
-0.3518696427,
-0.1068698615,
0.4708374441,
-0.1828175187,
-0.4310736358,
0.8991498947,
0.727492094,
0.5872534513,
0.0827699453,
1.0327523947,
-0.2380851805,
0.7450293303,
-0.1516898721,
0.3414318264,
0.0459533744,
0.1584675014,
-0.6958225965,
-1.1369707584,
0.0080385441,
0.370649606,
-0.6846758127,
-0.1406915635,
0.9918391109,
0.6326693892,
0.1631128639,
0.48535797,
0.3937679827,
0.0731582418,
0.1683613956,
0.0384858958,
1.3737187386,
-0.5011502504,
0.2471513301,
-0.2114399523,
-0.4646217525,
-0.3217228353,
-0.3767461479,
-0.6673290133,
-0.8270660639,
-0.351241678,
-0.0819942057,
0.198627457,
0.5179746151,
0.7040016055,
-0.9681132436,
-0.9013328552,
0.4450733066,
0.0819192827,
-0.4186899364,
-0.1895224005,
-0.14543733,
-0.659150064,
-0.8264523149,
0.3045930862,
0.5857089162,
-0.4255782664,
-0.5715151429,
0.0519349724,
0.0108609032,
-0.0842178687,
0.8183460832,
0.0560632236,
-0.947544992,
-0.1597133279,
0.1392553151,
-0.0413716845,
-0.1340581179,
1.2764008045,
-0.4106395543,
0.4216776788,
0.5206822753,
0.2070556134,
0.3909387589,
-0.1285135001,
0.829028666,
0.0316984765,
-0.0589998141,
0.5370205045,
0.5884611011,
0.2451886237,
0.0109004639,
0.3753500581,
0.0117087262,
-0.5221899152,
-0.8935400248,
0.4475882947,
-1.081577301,
0.2136922479,
0.9990754724,
-0.3643844724,
-0.0395222753,
-0.6341627836,
-0.4681265652,
0.0325364433,
-0.4538469911,
0.567401588,
0.8287648559,
-0.3388007879,
0.1445690989,
-0.4638480544,
0.4285370708,
0.4190222323,
-0.7008649707,
0.1523024738,
0.6455674171,
0.0402371548,
0.3986711204,
0.6516486406,
-0.4152960777,
0.2443087846,
-0.3118304014,
0.0086027998,
0.5638924837,
-0.2554398775,
-0.5130558014,
0.1657291949,
0.3459053934,
0.1788727641
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13866v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13866v2
|
Understanding Inter-Session Intentions via Complex Logical Reasoning
| 2023-12-21T14:03:30 | 2024-06-14T07:47:47 |
Jiaxin Bai, Chen Luo, Zheng Li, Qingyu Yin, Yangqiu Song
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Understanding user intentions is essential for improving product
recommendations, navigation suggestions, and query reformulations. However,
user intentions can be intricate, involving multiple sessions and attribute
requirements connected by logical operators such as And, Or, and Not. For
instance, a user may search for Nike or Adidas running shoes across various
sessions, with a preference for purple. In another example, a user may have
purchased a mattress in a previous session and is now looking for a matching
bed frame without intending to buy another mattress. Existing research on
session understanding has not adequately addressed making product or attribute
recommendations for such complex intentions. In this paper, we present the task
of logical session complex query answering (LS-CQA), where sessions are treated
as hyperedges of items, and we frame the problem of complex intention
understanding as an LS-CQA task on an aggregated hypergraph of sessions, items,
and attributes. This is a unique complex query answering task with sessions as
ordered hyperedges. We also introduce a new model, the Logical Session Graph
Transformer (LSGT), which captures interactions among items across different
sessions and their logical connections using a transformer structure. We
analyze the expressiveness of LSGT and prove the permutation invariance of the
inputs for the logical operators. By evaluating LSGT on three datasets, we
demonstrate that it achieves state-of-the-art results.
|
[
-0.4493550658,
-1.077423811,
1.2145053148,
0.0602813289,
-0.271460712,
-0.0492903292,
-0.0500222221,
-0.4475330412,
0.2332432121,
0.3007423282,
-1.0652462244,
-0.4993506074,
-0.2377961129,
-0.3157639205,
-0.4512081742,
0.9577679038,
-0.2283225656,
-0.0218375195,
0.0967136621,
-0.2747985423,
-0.866642952,
-0.4025312662,
-0.6267119646,
-0.2265892625,
0.3988725543,
0.323115766,
0.8439117074,
-0.0756919608,
0.395138979,
0.3205616176,
0.1331789196,
0.3868395388,
-0.746876955,
0.1918923259,
-0.5169537067,
-0.5401605964,
-0.3778333068,
-0.0192162413,
0.3487769365,
0.5156047344,
-0.0497913547,
0.280051589,
-0.0087000951,
0.3354908824,
-0.7542119622,
0.2421007901,
-0.5967362523,
0.0638052374,
-0.0424236283,
-0.0210129991,
-0.6194506288,
0.0100950887,
-0.1180370227,
-0.6380580664,
0.1565813869,
0.5068317056,
1.0264546871,
-0.0517385043,
-0.5701460242,
-0.1972610652,
-0.9524134398,
0.6772348285,
-0.3856161237,
0.7957234383,
0.1837191731,
0.5781450868,
-0.3062673211,
-0.7523845434,
-1.0085022449,
0.1605658084,
-0.6737599373,
0.1603047252,
-0.4435476959,
0.4116286933,
0.3491152525,
0.0517521724,
-0.5759987831,
-0.2742961049,
-0.0995837227,
0.0043581477,
0.5723321438,
0.4810224175,
0.3869325519,
0.0043180455,
-0.4629080594,
0.3644997776,
-0.6093328595,
0.3747022748,
0.0263869017,
0.0457467102,
0.0682026669,
0.7829561234,
-0.326182574,
0.9234322906,
0.3144598901,
-0.0206966419,
-0.1329381913,
-0.4867767096,
-0.246111691,
0.2096157372,
0.5448154211,
0.5016185045,
0.0189195666,
-0.3099603653,
-0.3286245763,
-0.0698820502,
0.2128456533,
-0.8004089594,
0.0529179797,
0.5191039443,
-0.5067305565,
0.2255178541,
0.1459839642,
-0.1923236847,
-0.1924338043,
-0.941224575,
0.3763750792,
-0.3443541527,
-0.0748772696,
0.4393393695,
-0.103189975,
0.3476365209,
0.4910815656,
-0.584009409,
0.4694385231,
0.8753933907,
0.3566772938,
-0.1168456003,
-0.4172993302,
-0.4690279961,
0.4774451852,
0.0710119829,
0.5758751035,
-0.6711403131,
-0.0360671021,
-0.0647108927,
0.1650702953,
-0.2338197082,
-0.1229714155,
0.7064613104,
-0.8686316609,
0.3258884847,
-0.434664607,
-0.6079310775,
-0.5251290202,
0.5394604802,
-0.2660957277,
0.5346644521,
0.2816490233,
-0.2919777036,
0.2694916427,
-0.6800558567,
-0.40641132,
0.3121948838,
-0.4050648212,
-0.1646814793,
0.1929859519,
0.2234464139,
0.4042384624,
-0.4495646954,
0.452236861,
-0.2940185964,
-0.4792642593,
0.6671667695,
-0.415101707,
0.6381098628,
0.0809598714,
-0.4722802937,
0.3300709426,
-0.3213002086,
0.1542634219,
-0.025426425,
-0.0558776483,
-0.2302400917,
0.1239650548,
0.1691444963,
0.3920825422,
0.3270688653,
-0.6943768263,
0.2013828009,
-0.0475102812,
0.6455935836,
0.8432199955,
0.3169871867,
0.0726779178,
-0.0226355121,
0.3959171176,
0.1606262326,
0.4595217407,
0.0536688864,
-0.3511348367,
-0.6671972871,
-0.1055331156,
-0.2814798653,
0.3200158179,
-0.695866406,
0.3586991131,
-0.4193798006,
-0.2984496355,
-0.0635654628,
-0.3195542693,
0.8027847409,
0.3887809217,
0.5019283891,
-0.1336407214,
0.0449107029,
-1.0464855433,
-0.5753600597,
-0.2034038156,
0.0480415113,
0.7496288419,
0.0330874734,
-0.4285681844,
1.1521059275,
-1.1998759508,
-0.1108332798,
-0.3694781959,
-0.1266939044,
0.3574422002,
0.4198186994,
0.7407923341,
-1.0424233675,
-0.3543964922,
-0.0145725552,
-0.5705313087,
0.2528509498,
-0.5540352464,
-0.6454631686,
-0.2310837656,
0.3887199163,
-0.9841375351,
0.4787573814,
0.2155683637,
-0.6044726372,
0.4152652621,
0.1106195003,
0.4600029588,
-0.6733424067,
-0.3469416201,
0.1844424903,
-0.2065578699,
-0.8156209588,
0.0345790386,
-0.0189917963,
-0.1449743062,
-0.5295038223,
0.4544044137,
-0.1070147827,
-0.0738605633,
0.1012770161,
0.0729844123,
0.1828738153,
0.8597792387,
-0.0530096367,
0.5090479851,
0.2831605971,
-0.643351078,
0.1992940456,
0.4283607602,
-0.2143010497,
0.7226679921,
-0.5707615018,
0.1639300436,
-0.3385813236,
0.1200061142,
-1.3266218901,
-0.2517546713,
0.5623089671,
-0.2734249234,
0.1772927791,
-0.3022609353,
-0.2649496198,
-0.1278818399,
0.04495221,
0.656488359,
0.0576252714,
-0.4748004377,
1.0975973606,
0.3175153136,
0.1866556257,
-0.3189724684,
-0.4121058285,
-0.0088790748,
-0.1418306231,
-0.7270878553,
0.5475699306,
-0.0200265218,
-0.2820562422,
0.1937171966,
-0.283056885,
-0.0745965987,
-0.1062616333,
0.2976194322,
0.3434709907,
-0.1990921497,
-0.0450952314,
0.3039372861,
-0.104882814,
0.2548728287,
-0.4649832547,
0.7810465097,
-0.4267449379,
-0.8123421669,
-0.7546350956,
0.3192665279,
0.6299775243,
-0.2769541144,
0.6523772478,
0.6805381179,
-0.3681585491,
0.1085336506,
-0.5623184443,
-0.3424888849,
-0.5467097163,
0.2173985094,
-0.7402136326,
-0.7556110024,
0.40027982,
-0.0742226765,
0.1844238192,
0.1532018781,
0.4486018121,
-0.3737005293,
1.239684701,
0.1030936986,
0.2526544929,
0.4428282976,
-0.1678229272,
0.8328231573,
-0.7767189145,
-0.2586535215,
-0.0960867777,
-0.8574567437,
-0.5936719179,
0.0962923095,
0.7353890538,
0.0985991284,
-0.5511435866,
0.5081772804,
-0.4357072711,
0.4278018475,
0.6332255602,
0.5824446082,
0.1348163933,
-0.0614425503,
0.4400655925,
0.0056767953,
-0.2973460853,
-0.208059296,
0.5107434988,
-0.0827898383,
0.488813132,
0.5033708215,
0.3050184846,
0.200571686,
-0.005613029,
-0.9444288015,
0.7734048367,
0.11651434,
-0.6740002036,
-0.4031329155,
-0.2693449557,
-1.2201877832,
0.4446210265,
-0.2931989133,
-0.9695748687,
0.3216797113,
0.3001895547,
-0.4286763668,
0.1537163556,
-0.7378847003,
0.9340469241,
-0.5661423206,
-0.5206965208,
-0.4954072535,
-0.5727391243,
0.5444815755,
0.2568907738,
0.0068114572,
-0.2014256716,
0.1571958512,
0.5623679757,
-0.072222203,
0.3095597625,
-0.3184971511,
0.5240240097,
0.4519909918,
0.3323466778,
0.5898634195,
0.0788040683,
0.1973555237,
-0.0424104296,
-0.0014739163,
-0.3704004586,
-0.9850716591,
0.530667305,
-0.5683873296,
-0.9495966434,
-0.3280670643,
-0.4291117787,
-0.5250449181,
0.4074488878,
-0.2011535913,
0.4314772487,
-0.0611816309,
0.0815382823,
0.6032961607,
-0.0357845426,
0.1340732723,
0.2824262083,
-0.3793382943,
0.0587733574,
0.7864492536,
0.0054287515,
0.2458461672,
0.4111323357,
0.367107749,
-0.2247441113,
-0.5847152472,
-0.5902538896,
0.2523050308,
-0.7569386959,
-0.0145314271,
-0.6735678911,
0.0143412035,
-0.1708274484,
-0.2568031251,
0.1294328868,
-0.3786597252,
-0.0351007357,
-0.2123204172,
0.2359268665,
0.528301239,
0.6941785812,
0.6400393844,
-0.9018753171,
0.4971469641,
0.3298775852,
0.0754095688,
-0.0720564872,
-0.0666155517,
-0.0107134888,
0.1904392242,
-0.2993003428,
-0.7602152824,
0.1735673547,
-0.2251519561,
0.7116645575,
0.6944766045,
0.1839325428,
0.8683039546,
-0.2970003188,
0.7806316614,
0.3024004698,
-0.8883880973,
0.2891909182,
-0.4784369469,
0.0391257331,
0.7240906358,
0.4728219807,
-0.8755380511,
0.0567843802,
-0.6953909993,
-0.7961865067,
1.0140106678,
0.3567406237,
0.024626378,
0.3822990954,
0.5328753591,
-0.3413289189,
0.3720596433,
-0.5672798753,
-0.4025516212,
-0.0162873156,
-0.1719179302,
0.3225740194,
-0.0672048628,
-0.2827863693,
-0.2483981252,
0.6677569747,
-0.0686988384,
0.2299204916,
-0.1139902994,
-0.032182999,
0.1287122518,
0.3422196507,
0.1963359118,
0.7537012696,
-0.0441044122,
0.1379434913,
0.0410111323,
-0.4390964508,
0.1390271634,
-0.0316189751,
-0.3812484741,
-0.2609284222,
0.0757441744,
0.8788621426,
0.0440772884,
-0.6698418856,
0.5493075848,
-0.365460664,
0.2168640941,
-0.1527432203,
0.2621001303,
0.2048747092,
0.1075302213,
-0.1488945484,
0.2254143953,
0.5520379543,
-0.8271605968,
-0.1484415233,
0.4444584548,
-0.7317785025,
-0.2173551172,
0.405442059,
-0.0064693717,
-0.4394224584,
1.1250567436,
-0.5117244124,
-0.582660675,
0.2947554588,
0.4666644633,
0.9030838013,
0.1418323368,
-0.0883800909,
0.3749587834,
0.175531581,
0.3128468096,
0.4690896571,
-0.2160374373,
-0.8219465613,
0.0399749279,
-0.3527680039,
-0.273722142,
-0.0628595799,
-0.5386818051,
0.402751416,
-0.09965083,
-0.129628852,
0.2919163108,
-0.4537029564,
-0.8366748095,
0.2467347234,
-0.3101522326,
0.2858662009,
-0.6930348277,
0.5249581933,
0.5280552506,
-0.4233135879,
-0.9705066085,
0.1269122213,
0.023572877,
-0.9079743028,
0.4201734662,
0.0164358635,
-0.4872645438,
-0.2603336871,
-0.4195476472,
-0.7258503437,
1.0048286915,
0.2450323701,
-0.8340633512,
-0.1069783568,
0.48414886,
0.166541785,
-0.110172689,
0.3310136795,
0.8385099769,
0.7113408446,
0.1329665631,
-0.4052657187,
0.2321410626,
0.1421644241,
-0.2869365513,
0.4584217668,
-0.6661142111,
0.8516531587,
0.1655497849,
-0.3064233959,
-0.4916913211,
0.4166297317,
0.3382911086,
0.6265538931,
0.8579577208,
0.2923603952,
0.6384965181,
-0.2134003788,
0.8820222616,
-0.4098101556,
0.234016031,
1.1869630814,
-0.3236818612,
0.435814172,
0.3671301007,
-0.3089147508,
0.3607614636,
0.551201582,
0.4535568058,
0.2396538109,
0.189717114,
-0.4464983344,
-0.5622485876,
-0.1019285768,
-0.019020034,
0.4952331185,
0.7389706373,
-0.1538781524,
-0.2932045758,
-0.1704229116,
0.1528458744,
-0.1184429005,
-0.3533453345,
0.7548173666,
-0.0789042339,
-1.0268822908,
0.2267301381,
0.1003957763,
0.1737337112,
-0.6170828342,
-0.0866886973,
0.1857832819,
0.4268124104,
-0.5047672391,
-1.1982154846,
0.0387375206,
-0.2795813084,
-0.0001303607,
-0.220017463,
0.707873702,
-0.2777517438,
-0.4807384908,
0.0309306774,
0.5136905313,
0.0953377262,
-0.2298941165,
-0.7449722886,
-0.1434905082,
0.1080196649,
-0.4152295589,
0.3151392937,
0.6072886586,
-0.4002723396,
0.439024359,
0.7950190306,
-0.5413821936,
-0.2012510896,
-0.0149456691,
0.8495416045,
-0.4478704035,
-0.3886140883,
-0.895054996,
0.252700299,
-0.0430000573,
-0.3303062916,
0.8246387839,
0.7909502983,
0.8840278387,
0.1648122519,
0.5034201741,
0.0040714741,
0.014564205,
-0.5622026324,
0.2771685123,
-0.2582104504,
0.3473400176,
-0.0220207516,
-0.973808229,
-0.0981508419,
0.3373339772,
-0.494186312,
-0.053131707,
0.5319056511,
0.7589312196,
-0.4917990863,
0.3439751565,
-0.030057108,
0.087213181,
0.7132922411,
0.5514059067,
0.8381882906,
-0.1518973857,
0.2693366706,
-0.1357465684,
-0.1460602283,
-0.1162228659,
-0.5051033497,
-0.4191942215,
-0.583240509,
-0.1468263268,
-0.610716939,
0.0340231135,
1.2422667742,
0.5551543236,
-0.7217854261,
-0.3368382752,
-0.2810897231,
0.2702005208,
-0.4650779068,
-0.2319403291,
0.6170945168,
-0.3039414585,
-0.6498353481,
0.0027026448,
0.2946571708,
-0.1270657629,
-0.2085514069,
-0.0574692003,
-0.3754851222,
0.1979489326,
0.8822619915,
0.0481783226,
-0.6462753415,
-0.4359816611,
0.1595153511,
0.0594483502,
0.1385073513,
1.058868885,
-0.7051696777,
0.3186750114,
0.512675941,
0.5659809113,
1.0544629097,
0.1029886678,
0.2489937842,
-0.3623265922,
-0.2072717547,
0.4515638351,
0.5990909338,
-0.2103167325,
-0.5942219496,
0.3725839853,
-0.0535182394,
-0.4728328586,
-0.5610339642,
0.6329126358,
-1.196344018,
-0.546091795,
1.1807129383,
-0.1873762757,
-0.1454814225,
-0.3183578551,
-0.6771778464,
-0.0107295699,
-0.3918050826,
0.5964158773,
0.4854570925,
-0.8826765418,
0.2032300085,
-0.2238803059,
0.2569517791,
0.1728438586,
-0.7727873325,
0.1112366468,
0.7243245244,
-0.1454586387,
0.0888421461,
0.5851836205,
0.2602246702,
0.3429458737,
-0.3426243961,
-0.3850198984,
0.0863387659,
-0.3818850517,
0.2991253436,
0.2507973611,
0.0011960177,
-0.3031213284
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13816v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13816v1
|
Team Flow at DRC2023: Building Common Ground and Text-based Turn-taking in a Travel Agent Spoken Dialogue System
| 2023-12-21T13:08:09 | 2023-12-21T13:08:09 |
Ryu Hirai, Shinya Iizuka, Haruhisa Iseno, Ao Guo, Jingjing Jiang, Atsumoto Ohashi, Ryuichiro Higashinaka
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.RO
|
At the Dialogue Robot Competition 2023 (DRC2023), which was held to improve
the capability of dialogue robots, our team developed a system that could build
common ground and take more natural turns based on user utterance texts. Our
system generated queries for sightseeing spot searches using the common ground
and engaged in dialogue while waiting for user comprehension.
|
[
-0.4059024155,
-0.3842650652,
0.9811367989,
-0.0030084325,
-0.1570317447,
0.5824328065,
0.3736358881,
-0.4789406657,
0.3419133723,
0.8935178518,
-0.8697173595,
-0.3993779123,
-0.4542095959,
0.1829180866,
-0.5003473163,
0.4991318583,
-0.3574768007,
-0.0193671342,
-0.1527054161,
-0.736780107,
-0.7243033648,
-0.7464093566,
-0.6206445098,
-0.6742737293,
0.5159683824,
0.7130600214,
1.0008592606,
-0.0138073517,
0.6363580227,
0.4399301112,
-0.0036922586,
0.3576537967,
-0.115015991,
0.4088640511,
-0.4120570421,
-0.3930956125,
-0.2503900826,
-0.0283114668,
0.3503302634,
0.6931933761,
-0.4781710505,
-0.2726649046,
-0.3756705523,
0.7168101668,
-0.1227132604,
0.1981131881,
-0.2421444356,
0.1449794918,
0.0449833125,
-0.6576277018,
-0.3047532439,
-0.1170451418,
0.162509039,
-0.7523596287,
0.3010345399,
0.2719446421,
1.0128456354,
0.614707768,
-0.1853344738,
-0.6356839538,
-0.8249582648,
0.7009962201,
-0.3936699331,
0.2774510682,
0.1893906146,
0.4700278342,
-0.3944207132,
-0.9117777944,
-0.930873394,
-0.0372214429,
0.1293341517,
0.298115015,
-0.0351881683,
0.2684204876,
-0.0417620316,
-0.1144844443,
-0.7036401629,
-0.2690304816,
-0.4225939512,
0.0684843138,
0.6772751808,
0.516874969,
0.6288012266,
0.0766116902,
-0.1761741638,
-0.1863159239,
-0.3906106651,
0.062357422,
-0.1223918498,
0.3229789436,
-0.0594874993,
0.6214395761,
-0.5024406314,
0.6931376457,
0.0126468111,
0.0863934904,
0.3424607217,
-0.4777940512,
-0.207631737,
0.0928087234,
0.8167921305,
0.828797698,
0.4170559049,
-0.2664132416,
-0.203502655,
-0.3427749872,
0.3217894435,
-0.4720720649,
-0.3511251211,
0.323933959,
-0.537176311,
-0.2837325335,
0.32035622,
-0.7005374432,
-0.3979530632,
-0.4162986875,
0.0776508152,
-0.1302021444,
-0.3047203124,
0.2319252044,
-0.6690804958,
0.5213204026,
0.7051138282,
-0.4618407786,
0.4070529044,
0.5383434892,
1.2549049854,
-0.1068208963,
-0.5489141345,
-0.4225240052,
0.0633901805,
-0.21431835,
1.0254243612,
-0.4376060367,
-0.7011386156,
0.0021309019,
0.002727431,
-0.0814484879,
-0.6476500034,
0.4324477911,
-0.7423299551,
0.4423258305,
-0.1226476282,
0.0226064399,
-0.2557850182,
0.0432798117,
-0.5134266019,
0.8191261292,
-0.0260364655,
-0.6107631922,
0.47567451,
-1.0263954401,
-0.5876238346,
0.3400387466,
-0.3917149007,
-0.145563513,
-0.1944621205,
0.1948592812,
0.0346353576,
0.2252566516,
0.1732426882,
-0.036734771,
-0.4516609311,
0.2387728244,
-0.1330334991,
0.7819164991,
0.2963056564,
-0.4548177421,
0.2603031993,
-0.6185283065,
-0.019769134,
0.1159225628,
-0.141840145,
-0.078437008,
0.231472373,
-0.2896056473,
0.4064598083,
0.0343353301,
-0.1700012237,
0.25448066,
-0.2536412179,
0.4308546484,
0.626563251,
0.1827350408,
0.6929493546,
-0.4009176195,
0.6627479792,
-0.1883508265,
0.0427977741,
0.0488731861,
-0.9410541058,
-0.9053426981,
0.0301233251,
-0.2967805564,
0.7665053606,
-0.9009457231,
0.3963367343,
-0.1009686962,
-0.3661194742,
-0.3812231719,
-0.2704020739,
0.0081709633,
0.2540250123,
0.2574609518,
-0.3319474161,
-0.3430494666,
-0.4643220007,
0.1541916877,
-0.4324102104,
0.0996649265,
0.4530222714,
0.3343789577,
-0.0831128657,
0.7447254062,
-0.6474025249,
0.0143260285,
-0.6227011681,
0.4542025626,
0.2316502631,
0.211898759,
0.3669830561,
-1.1092778444,
-0.5755212307,
-0.0813114047,
-0.7138183713,
-0.2222931236,
-0.1390782744,
-0.339969486,
0.3282715976,
0.6915553212,
-0.9113215804,
0.5994228125,
0.4876104593,
-0.7746829391,
0.1926784962,
-0.0814922303,
0.5246967077,
-0.8328483701,
-0.0037235664,
-0.5721100569,
-0.4140170217,
-0.5093727112,
-0.0502609462,
-0.6916075945,
-0.3092211485,
-0.4442822337,
0.4316159189,
-0.1764213145,
-0.2376207709,
-0.5467793941,
0.4065313637,
0.1977985352,
0.5454188585,
0.4406039417,
0.9615873694,
0.4224472344,
-0.9564805627,
0.5307900906,
0.5436131954,
-0.0524450205,
0.5919088721,
-0.5254930258,
0.5770879984,
-0.0106960423,
0.7391634583,
-1.0395741463,
-0.2925849855,
0.3032257259,
-0.7037313581,
-0.2657592893,
0.0314062126,
-0.4390561581,
-0.578588903,
0.2444165647,
0.0533100665,
0.353567481,
-0.4548052549,
0.6050274372,
0.4738256335,
-0.167457521,
-0.1921779066,
-0.5115845203,
0.5747936368,
-0.1439474672,
-0.9017239213,
0.145247519,
-0.1888668686,
-0.5551359057,
-0.2662566304,
-0.0363689512,
-0.4125947654,
0.1403380036,
0.4348920584,
0.2526064813,
0.1730322838,
-0.0501841977,
-0.1887447536,
-0.134333387,
0.0711802021,
-0.1631101817,
0.978205204,
-0.1730320156,
-0.170758903,
-0.8241788745,
0.5722141862,
0.7804962397,
0.0723037124,
0.8171414137,
0.1675201058,
-0.0571869835,
-0.064706549,
-0.1228242368,
-0.16501683,
-0.5625178814,
0.0187066477,
-0.4650248587,
-0.8250092268,
0.5119943619,
-0.1935231537,
0.0886878967,
0.4281898141,
0.5348715186,
-0.3833581507,
1.0165030956,
0.6891661882,
0.2686931193,
0.3540473878,
-0.1100998893,
0.2417580485,
-0.3996005654,
-0.5781701803,
-0.8538478613,
-0.3892546892,
-0.6943849325,
-0.6418430209,
0.0011458624,
-0.0216280222,
-0.0394738019,
0.623814404,
-0.6853519678,
0.285911411,
0.9166916609,
-0.2513672113,
0.5775051117,
-0.5195132494,
-0.2303726971,
0.1785189211,
-0.6111421585,
-0.6840881109,
0.5758195519,
0.1441822201,
0.3501320779,
-0.0458016582,
0.758870244,
0.3282429576,
-0.0380663425,
-0.5442628264,
0.9700591564,
0.3562711775,
-0.6198808551,
-0.5646617413,
-0.3065890074,
-0.7361232042,
-0.0490682572,
0.2702764869,
-0.4331128597,
0.2135697007,
-0.3476296365,
-0.4505769312,
0.2772910297,
-0.6934787035,
0.3955221474,
-0.0966553316,
0.1719190478,
-0.5033638477,
-0.9394386411,
-0.1264606714,
0.211750105,
0.0964708552,
-0.0750468671,
0.2246160954,
0.7121682763,
-0.6289729476,
0.4931758046,
-0.3713884056,
0.0815365016,
0.7752358913,
0.0516553223,
0.3768375814,
0.1080153659,
0.0390132293,
0.124100551,
-0.4289301336,
-0.3070791364,
-0.4964486063,
0.421923995,
-0.7707955837,
-0.3504984379,
-0.6431558132,
-0.2761638165,
-0.0475102514,
0.2780261338,
0.2226852775,
0.1734039485,
-0.4194652438,
-0.2521419525,
0.4390900731,
-0.3544932306,
0.7538495064,
0.7499318123,
-0.2789366841,
-0.5919005275,
0.6879370213,
-0.2213581651,
0.349868685,
0.6513524055,
-0.1177125201,
-0.1906597316,
-0.7967576385,
-0.3842845857,
-0.0288812015,
-0.4093921781,
-0.0967372134,
-0.7448834777,
-0.3436906338,
-0.3363887668,
-0.5122935772,
-0.2716596127,
-0.8212015033,
-0.1137617677,
-0.3251163363,
0.1076382697,
1.0593686104,
-0.1447801292,
0.5865047574,
-0.8311950564,
0.3388125598,
0.3115298748,
0.1515794992,
-0.5579259396,
-0.3536960483,
-0.3132818043,
-0.2751402259,
-0.6526404023,
-0.4053351581,
0.4823455811,
-0.3203628659,
0.6025381684,
0.1142666265,
0.0595702156,
0.4859673977,
-0.5460222363,
1.2250598669,
0.4336613417,
-0.8104419112,
0.7260301113,
-0.3919045925,
0.4413877726,
0.8168911934,
-0.0985842422,
-0.8821647763,
-0.6945819259,
-0.7550640106,
-0.634111464,
0.7819821239,
0.5095024705,
-0.2472726107,
0.2649421692,
0.1701286286,
-0.183592543,
0.3712439835,
-0.666613996,
-0.2926844954,
-0.3632906377,
0.0158185977,
0.0103774583,
0.2152811587,
-0.1484007686,
0.0503505245,
0.2946102023,
-0.0545161963,
0.4543817043,
0.521164,
0.1747352183,
-0.2861818075,
0.0727178752,
0.9370394945,
0.679315269,
-0.5055648685,
-0.0179589018,
0.0311993454,
-0.4774157405,
0.1047257408,
0.0215147045,
-0.1132498682,
0.3370576501,
0.4276553094,
0.6451487541,
-0.1635778844,
-0.7304741144,
0.189263165,
-0.155501917,
-0.4149787426,
-0.2685527503,
0.3524243236,
-0.0037211829,
0.365647018,
0.4167608321,
0.37749663,
0.4645258188,
-0.5853301287,
0.3791815042,
0.1898770332,
-0.7601013184,
-0.4797744751,
0.5542833209,
0.8919762969,
-0.9458983541,
0.5587984324,
-0.2992931604,
-0.888320744,
0.4037688076,
-0.0122310258,
1.2377772331,
-0.1720223278,
0.476374507,
0.406167984,
-0.0008372188,
-0.1700950563,
0.3486641645,
-0.1060784757,
-0.8949728608,
-0.3709257543,
-0.0809359848,
-0.9579464197,
-0.3100331128,
-0.2483611703,
0.3498979509,
-0.2611017525,
-0.1038261428,
-0.4130877554,
0.2323060185,
-0.5945231915,
0.3477325737,
0.4332551062,
0.8231274486,
-0.4331066906,
0.479293555,
0.7923890948,
-0.3989320397,
-0.5731825829,
0.1518691331,
-0.1553232223,
-0.7167726159,
0.651958704,
0.1908738762,
-0.6787762642,
-0.4667348564,
-0.9365900159,
-0.5194279552,
1.348195076,
-0.5459548831,
-0.5115593076,
-0.3967320919,
0.3071589172,
0.4924461246,
-0.5119123459,
0.3958297074,
0.314031899,
0.4286637902,
0.6356181502,
-1.3075447083,
-0.1822813749,
0.0038473094,
-0.5133241415,
0.1175949574,
-1.2292299271,
0.4637392759,
-0.2205637693,
-0.3214299083,
0.3318693936,
0.697460413,
0.5429433584,
0.9191589355,
0.6567349434,
0.6334500313,
0.9459924102,
-0.0473881476,
0.6514438391,
-0.0566465557,
0.1343629509,
1.3734824657,
-0.5591243505,
0.6869912744,
0.5682368279,
-0.1834973544,
0.9253950715,
0.237953797,
0.5522256494,
0.9192703366,
0.2687149346,
-0.3532370031,
-0.2807049155,
-0.0412960723,
-0.1206527501,
0.6690388322,
0.2055330426,
0.083911851,
-0.1610992104,
-0.0472206511,
-0.1721208245,
0.1355002224,
-0.0218010955,
0.8077706099,
0.2306079865,
-0.9729177356,
-0.055006329,
-0.1558130085,
0.4181601405,
-0.1809558719,
-0.2123108804,
-0.3350121379,
0.157843709,
0.1039539501,
-1.1885714531,
0.319883287,
-0.1655951738,
0.0488133579,
-0.6466251612,
0.6412274241,
-0.0475064181,
-0.222705543,
0.489651382,
0.3630953729,
0.2716480494,
-0.1989413798,
-0.828605175,
0.0101992274,
0.2290982753,
-0.1804182678,
-0.1549567133,
0.8774023652,
0.2657243609,
1.0509326458,
0.3870574832,
-0.0996438786,
-0.0019137179,
0.4516783953,
0.8374797106,
-1.2736743689,
-0.4416291416,
-0.4413453639,
0.5455793142,
-0.3887813091,
-0.3502874374,
0.4817302227,
0.6315382719,
0.3265274167,
0.2924074829,
0.8984546065,
-0.1744294614,
0.8424136639,
-0.4213014543,
0.5009124875,
-0.3711618781,
-0.066202648,
-0.1737016737,
-0.6151916385,
-0.1101672947,
0.7065339088,
0.2538751364,
-0.1396489292,
0.8731161356,
0.6032859087,
0.3148935437,
-0.0118655423,
0.2901217341,
-0.2627488971,
0.8959060907,
0.5986019373,
1.25679636,
-0.5454164743,
0.7858743072,
0.1310298592,
-0.2829179466,
-0.4058035314,
-0.4115955234,
-0.9311615229,
-0.6336958408,
-0.5090500712,
-0.6190282106,
0.2327917516,
0.6414263844,
0.7407279015,
-0.6303432584,
-0.3075186312,
-0.6787907481,
0.3775354624,
0.0341872536,
-0.3032041192,
-0.0405228175,
-0.2552839518,
-0.8228669763,
0.6661662459,
0.684004426,
0.193147704,
-0.1996229589,
-0.4319932461,
-0.2766596079,
0.2296467274,
0.1853850931,
0.3985517919,
-0.2988684475,
-0.5304522514,
0.2756422162,
-0.1577263474,
0.27000916,
0.903885603,
-0.7276335359,
0.2487903237,
0.7103674412,
-0.0439196192,
0.4031572044,
0.2201815546,
1.1526169777,
-0.0475668535,
0.3702118993,
0.5063561797,
0.0656233132,
0.2578693032,
-0.1287898123,
0.7041343451,
0.3835209012,
-1.0999634266,
-0.6047666669,
0.1111829206,
-1.4576510191,
-0.2069247067,
1.110886097,
0.3238674104,
0.0593856797,
-0.6487824321,
-0.4134842753,
0.2349751294,
-0.7055228949,
0.6563543677,
1.0722129345,
-0.4928282201,
-0.0541476533,
-0.578719914,
0.4889885783,
0.1382726282,
-0.8117019534,
-0.2999220788,
0.3330508471,
-0.064976871,
0.6161315441,
1.0666424036,
0.1753424853,
-0.0047617052,
0.1057857201,
0.0984838679,
0.4641971588,
-0.77356112,
0.2267957628,
0.074159801,
0.1015055627,
-0.6015091538
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14215v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14215v2
|
SimLM: Can Language Models Infer Parameters of Physical Systems?
| 2023-12-21T12:05:19 | 2024-02-06T10:15:01 |
Sean Memery, Mirella Lapata, Kartic Subr
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7; I.6
|
Several machine learning methods aim to learn or reason about complex
physical systems. A common first-step towards reasoning is to infer system
parameters from observations of its behavior. In this paper, we investigate the
performance of Large Language Models (LLMs) at performing parameter inference
in the context of physical systems. Our experiments suggest that they are not
inherently suited to this task, even for simple systems. We propose a promising
direction of exploration, which involves the use of physical simulators to
augment the context of LLMs. We assess and compare the performance of different
LLMs on a simple example with and without access to physical simulation.
|
[
-0.270711869,
-0.8812779188,
1.0609481335,
0.2189634442,
-0.4003868997,
-0.105943501,
-0.1841622144,
-0.6021193266,
-0.0194833372,
0.5108317137,
-0.481687516,
-0.1699917912,
-0.4358778,
0.0753004998,
-0.4356083572,
0.5160109401,
-0.2407956719,
0.2201257795,
-0.4526816905,
0.3678951859,
0.0543762185,
-0.8377240896,
-0.5109782219,
-0.7411549091,
0.321373105,
0.0281158201,
0.6523813009,
0.367787689,
0.248376295,
0.3442130089,
-0.0902150795,
0.3636429012,
-0.2458196878,
0.5148335695,
-0.0977308229,
-0.5153003335,
0.0493575148,
-0.0634121075,
1.0848013163,
1.049069047,
0.0394780114,
0.0297955759,
-0.0040072314,
0.269340843,
-0.4923814833,
0.2745572329,
-0.3511100113,
0.2045529336,
0.1428882033,
-0.2132532448,
-0.5972711444,
0.066462785,
0.0921330899,
-0.4371986985,
-0.0887675285,
0.5487183928,
0.9038543701,
0.2397139221,
-0.4189977348,
-0.0298621636,
-1.1339554787,
1.1411331892,
-0.5640249252,
0.7117999792,
0.5012636781,
0.3660265207,
-0.5714046359,
-0.5158081055,
-0.2418660969,
-0.6261095405,
-0.099625349,
-0.2239801735,
0.2035518736,
0.2721166909,
0.7743862867,
-0.1376877725,
-0.3358007073,
0.2616481781,
-0.343745321,
-0.1289558858,
0.5494656563,
0.3784886897,
0.1224308535,
-0.030735787,
-0.1206163988,
-0.1250710934,
-0.6166719198,
0.122905761,
0.327380836,
0.3750075698,
-0.1461953819,
0.6978185773,
-0.1739320159,
0.7808653116,
-0.3263809681,
-0.5827270746,
-0.1317428499,
0.1119830459,
-0.5851367712,
-0.0844128132,
0.6466701031,
0.021297982,
0.2519542575,
-0.333232671,
-0.4635944366,
-0.2847976983,
-0.1008754671,
-0.8336161375,
-0.1699611843,
0.22234568,
-0.3205108941,
0.1365511715,
0.1734729409,
-0.597271204,
-0.3809889555,
-0.6916410923,
0.3869986832,
-0.299608916,
-0.144309029,
0.294388473,
-0.2709890604,
0.1584572792,
0.5507408977,
-0.6415874362,
0.6534207463,
0.7434775829,
0.8363265395,
-0.0271055885,
-0.4113001823,
-0.4330496788,
0.2850687206,
-0.2480995208,
0.7353764176,
-0.6421229839,
-0.5486829877,
-0.3358832002,
0.0377562977,
0.0743484125,
-0.613609612,
0.3787388504,
-0.5956035852,
-0.0998272896,
-0.0911321491,
-0.6120272279,
-0.0664790571,
-0.0686336309,
-0.5594236851,
1.1016709805,
-0.180374518,
-0.5734480619,
0.2975372672,
-0.5113580227,
-0.3745455146,
-0.2262064815,
-0.1488852203,
-0.0967498645,
0.3508631885,
0.09859512,
0.5975414515,
-0.5542246699,
0.2695531845,
-0.6424267292,
-0.6090285778,
0.5251023769,
-0.6940791011,
0.5571724176,
0.4398069978,
-0.1455940306,
-0.2468348891,
-0.6274808645,
0.1281034797,
0.0782998428,
-0.2886840999,
-0.4185712039,
0.4553663135,
-0.1061982736,
0.20231466,
0.2072237432,
-0.5437390804,
0.2872840464,
-0.4410481453,
0.1555109471,
0.4817588329,
-0.1573461443,
0.3592725992,
-0.1749462932,
0.6563917398,
-0.0255552158,
-0.0611990727,
0.0287275314,
-0.3895855546,
-0.5697986484,
-0.5600060821,
0.3523079157,
0.3049845994,
-0.5394212604,
-0.1146482751,
-0.0814118087,
-0.3329145312,
-0.084204711,
0.1903779209,
0.2439236492,
0.1123085544,
0.0931762159,
0.4637375474,
-0.5988590717,
-0.6210982203,
-0.3904728591,
-0.4482401609,
-0.4383198023,
0.7058951855,
0.3264789879,
0.0394496508,
0.7251553535,
-0.3416988552,
0.700570941,
-0.1775123924,
-0.0710608736,
0.2033445835,
0.1912176311,
0.5316986442,
-0.5680930614,
-0.0778246596,
0.0079517877,
-1.084651947,
-0.2287060916,
0.2042082399,
0.0829382986,
-0.0709053501,
0.7820824981,
-0.4501607716,
0.2080695033,
0.8582419753,
-0.2892680168,
0.6706302762,
-0.6028256416,
-0.169800207,
-0.4714448452,
-0.0333411694,
0.2415457666,
-0.4530144036,
-0.4651965499,
0.1837735325,
-0.1757493764,
-0.2022627145,
-0.6508153081,
0.9226639271,
-0.5519840121,
-0.5857608914,
-0.3731632531,
-0.0076259892,
0.0553245731,
0.0057286369,
0.1199264154,
0.6314949393,
0.8542848825,
-1.0380971432,
0.3719866276,
-0.6282989383,
-0.2985157371,
0.2439715266,
-0.6515538692,
-0.0348716304,
-0.2991783321,
0.3532780409,
-0.9171016812,
-0.4429144263,
0.0843909755,
0.0093103265,
0.261746794,
-0.2485566437,
-1.0446795225,
-0.3450885713,
0.1002127901,
0.3398620486,
0.6014040112,
-0.484678328,
0.7130568027,
0.2741322517,
0.1321377903,
-0.0338336602,
-0.606551528,
-0.0671921149,
-0.3043216765,
-0.3497860432,
-0.309858501,
-0.0001815109,
-0.7266693115,
-0.4286079109,
0.2784439027,
-0.2060235441,
0.4818653166,
0.6909503341,
0.1024614498,
-0.3524257541,
0.3463720083,
0.2290884256,
-0.0186671577,
0.3736685216,
-0.2324679792,
0.64219594,
-0.1237939447,
-0.8514814377,
-0.6532948017,
0.2080129087,
0.6633573771,
0.1554113626,
0.7726987004,
-0.0944726542,
-0.3805159926,
-0.3533763289,
-0.3851518631,
-0.4843705595,
-0.5187702775,
0.1122543216,
-0.6651458144,
-0.505779624,
0.3507151902,
-0.6157616973,
-0.0801928639,
0.2376936525,
0.2743775845,
-0.5393097997,
1.3354934454,
0.4170309603,
0.0678376332,
0.3254280388,
-0.0397271588,
0.0210522767,
-0.5852493644,
-0.3460903764,
-0.8146646023,
-0.4169788659,
-0.5137494206,
-0.5998269916,
0.2141638398,
0.2745141685,
-0.5170772076,
-0.1392253637,
0.0032727718,
0.3675344586,
0.2987725139,
0.3218902051,
0.3432301879,
0.3398718536,
-0.6073741317,
-0.1673108935,
-0.6769323945,
-0.7759816051,
0.6885558963,
0.5087505579,
1.1617857218,
-0.1526347548,
0.528806448,
-0.2175115049,
0.4533149004,
-0.7049520612,
0.6138810515,
-0.0686090589,
-0.6281260252,
-0.5133471489,
-0.4028701186,
-0.8696267009,
0.4445708394,
0.1219126359,
-0.947870791,
0.0070214001,
0.1114683002,
-0.1734085381,
0.7386878729,
-0.6004776359,
0.1803124249,
-0.5482050776,
-0.2932717502,
-0.0400262289,
-0.337852627,
0.3311817944,
-0.1295642108,
0.3812292516,
-0.1612859815,
-0.2791720629,
0.4853916168,
-0.3333725929,
1.0348558426,
-0.3337066472,
-0.2499994636,
0.2258018404,
0.3409617543,
0.3931306899,
-0.0002891679,
-0.6994372606,
0.1195324585,
0.1638137996,
-0.3481816053,
-0.7206552625,
0.821590364,
-0.8109348416,
-0.5909720063,
-0.2002673894,
-0.6187491417,
-0.4603646398,
0.0263069142,
-0.2045862973,
0.2093604058,
0.0357706472,
0.244209528,
0.7306690216,
-0.2049068362,
0.4801421463,
0.6104389429,
-0.7440248728,
0.1345704198,
0.5983960032,
0.0533990301,
0.3634357452,
0.400092423,
0.4990462661,
-0.3050340414,
-0.3909831047,
-0.4408842623,
0.4891399741,
-0.4960914254,
0.2977406979,
-0.7201869488,
-0.2121001184,
-0.0555338599,
-0.0304226335,
-0.2804701626,
-0.1383036822,
-0.4795311391,
-0.0819007382,
0.4353585839,
0.9244334698,
0.1534011811,
0.4832114279,
-0.6151191592,
0.2907363772,
0.0909747332,
0.4217139781,
0.0025426205,
-0.7596206069,
-0.0008876288,
0.3967330754,
-0.1258868128,
-0.6401407123,
0.4175716341,
0.0525036938,
0.8471862078,
0.5719953179,
-0.0015710774,
0.7991641164,
-0.4809446931,
0.9136894941,
-0.0765472278,
-0.8317633867,
0.5275159478,
-0.2176548243,
0.1279734075,
-0.016008649,
0.6818181872,
-0.068428345,
-0.408844769,
-0.6168942451,
-0.3108759224,
0.5470238924,
-0.2188056558,
0.2409234047,
0.2107395828,
0.7072354555,
-0.0292313211,
0.1426179111,
-0.5091466308,
-0.2691482008,
0.2198630422,
0.2344771624,
-0.3078990877,
-0.2942992449,
0.0411104187,
-0.4593494534,
0.3607381284,
-0.2186711431,
0.2626433074,
0.1383200586,
0.0134008024,
-0.2881453037,
-0.2591481805,
0.7684562206,
0.6946522593,
-0.0619975962,
0.2944170535,
0.4406045079,
-0.137030676,
0.2702347934,
-0.3081603944,
-0.1048621163,
0.2483240515,
0.2688274384,
0.8571626544,
0.545909822,
-0.9559205174,
0.0685034692,
-0.0007566492,
-0.351125598,
-0.1031808108,
0.2225873619,
0.1350086927,
0.2623465657,
0.1039066911,
-0.3257661164,
0.017257113,
-0.6156789064,
0.0708717406,
0.5814672709,
-0.5749900937,
-0.4244112968,
0.454465121,
-0.3438019454,
-0.4844508469,
0.4930855036,
0.16900374,
-0.3872489333,
0.7493432164,
0.7256234288,
0.5640556812,
-0.2598186433,
0.0070142392,
0.1321090013,
0.2752693892,
-0.2757683694,
0.5914271474,
0.1735726148,
-0.5001112223,
-0.6778748631,
-0.8156968951,
-0.642731607,
-0.0215631146,
-0.2044411898,
0.4797342718,
-0.683077693,
-0.1305303574,
-0.2879980206,
0.0949164703,
-0.7419144511,
0.3319674134,
0.2612891793,
0.9176709056,
-0.9946291447,
0.9165921211,
0.9647556543,
0.0567124337,
-0.9678117633,
-0.138477549,
-0.3169927597,
-0.5413444042,
1.2576986551,
-0.2933630645,
-0.3831671476,
-0.339663595,
-0.678834796,
-0.9643455148,
0.8675449491,
0.7986732721,
-0.4011508226,
-0.0270487163,
0.3811761737,
0.7094475627,
-0.2328042984,
0.5060899854,
0.2524725199,
0.7152302861,
0.0336718597,
-1.1647250652,
-0.12521559,
0.3506086469,
-0.08847747,
0.1112705991,
-0.6847177148,
1.0191732645,
-0.264354676,
-0.0050195204,
0.1878222525,
0.5758339763,
0.7163489461,
0.5162799358,
0.4602281153,
0.259399116,
0.7537582517,
0.0146927936,
1.6184180975,
-0.3219383657,
0.2779631317,
0.8972899318,
-0.4784620106,
0.9574043751,
0.766127646,
-0.5582574606,
0.4802621007,
0.5729709864,
0.306552887,
0.2239429057,
0.5860759616,
-0.1699775755,
-0.4709189236,
0.0604838915,
-0.1639626175,
0.4275986254,
0.6918979287,
-0.4926653504,
-0.2798061967,
0.1504577845,
-0.152183935,
-0.1568668783,
-0.1936683655,
0.6022421122,
0.3185734451,
-0.4776643813,
0.3103074133,
0.0092923865,
0.2209065259,
-0.5429497957,
-0.1022078544,
-0.0381528959,
0.0735362694,
0.0290423483,
-0.5124037862,
-0.0338104479,
-0.1681214124,
-0.1275158823,
-0.1907822341,
0.671754539,
0.0427286699,
-0.7330318093,
0.3259839118,
0.5047863722,
0.7762222886,
0.0123341484,
-0.5274070501,
0.1252415925,
-0.3972993195,
-0.3272697031,
0.5621819496,
0.8556028008,
-0.1916818768,
1.1199212074,
0.5997984409,
0.3210546076,
0.2863609493,
-0.0567589477,
0.6628643274,
-0.6132635474,
-0.2296142876,
-0.9737176299,
0.016427869,
0.0888180286,
0.0120649831,
0.8553447127,
0.541760087,
0.4678653181,
-0.1456797719,
0.6645774841,
0.5313296914,
0.5287634134,
-0.7720449567,
0.3916178346,
-0.6469866037,
0.4785614014,
-0.1725689769,
-0.9388952851,
-0.2990884483,
0.4971159697,
-0.4927731752,
0.322381109,
0.691703856,
0.7944309711,
-0.3275196552,
-0.0043468704,
0.830070436,
0.1792342961,
0.4994447827,
0.1804332882,
1.2054351568,
-0.232585445,
-0.0278604273,
-0.3545940518,
-0.0675470233,
-0.4668173194,
-1.1823961735,
-0.899040997,
-0.1568024606,
-0.061684709,
-0.1594615132,
0.0367082506,
0.9643957019,
0.8788678646,
-0.7022413611,
-0.6234332919,
0.084356375,
0.127740711,
0.0498623066,
-0.1336726695,
0.0454151705,
-0.1865592599,
-0.9006804228,
0.5009352565,
0.084188275,
0.286904037,
-0.8178012371,
-0.2000728697,
0.0126539664,
0.3254744709,
0.6635158062,
0.4395876527,
-1.0217627287,
-0.2916290462,
0.0999502763,
-0.025142394,
-0.2857435644,
1.0728182793,
-0.9767910838,
0.1560135633,
0.5183795094,
0.5871824622,
0.4239529967,
-0.1740413606,
0.5654579401,
-0.5934336782,
0.4097159207,
0.0990024805,
0.7482421994,
0.0929464102,
-0.2838955522,
-0.0152597576,
0.1286430061,
-0.5721790791,
-0.9726284146,
0.0228079557,
-0.7078849673,
-0.5386360884,
1.4160966873,
-0.0302703846,
-0.2459643483,
-0.1411239207,
-0.3066333234,
-0.0397565365,
-0.1354659349,
0.4065224528,
0.7668002248,
-0.3673376143,
-0.2538241148,
-1.0538117886,
0.1127726585,
0.3748940527,
-0.6957683563,
0.0290392507,
0.3733829856,
0.3289123476,
0.0042133736,
0.1144184619,
0.1303884685,
-0.1570799202,
-0.040570233,
-0.3150677085,
0.1610216945,
-0.5990931392,
-0.2985075414,
0.3021214902,
0.4695143402,
0.2769495547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13772v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13772v2
|
On Task Performance and Model Calibration with Supervised and Self-Ensembled In-Context Learning
| 2023-12-21T11:55:10 | 2023-12-22T21:03:03 |
Chengzu Li, Han Zhou, Goran Glavaš, Anna Korhonen, Ivan Vulić
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Following the standard supervised fine-tuning (SFT) paradigm, in-context
learning (ICL) has become an efficient approach propelled by the recent
advancements in large language models (LLMs), yielding promising performance
across various tasks in few-shot data setups. However, both paradigms are prone
to suffer from the critical problem of overconfidence (i.e., miscalibration),
especially in such limited data setups. In this work, we deliver an in-depth
analysis of the behavior across different choices of learning methods from the
perspective of both performance and calibration, as well as their interplay.
Through extensive controlled experiments, we find that simultaneous gains for
both task performance and calibration are difficult to achieve, and the problem
of miscalibration exists across all learning methods in low-resource scenarios.
To address this challenging trade-off between performance and calibration, we
then investigate the potential of self-ensembling techniques applied at
different modeling stages (e.g., variations of in-context examples or
variations in prompts or different ensembling strategies). We justify the
feasibility of self-ensembling on SFT in addition to ICL, to make the
predictions more calibrated and have comparable or even better performance. Our
work sheds light on which learning paradigm to choose and how to enhance both
task performance and calibration of LLMs.
|
[
-0.2992781997,
-0.740038693,
0.422531873,
0.0289208815,
-0.1645418555,
0.0796094164,
-0.4285991192,
-0.5445120335,
-0.3354864717,
0.467130512,
-0.5576331615,
-0.1080100238,
-0.4186933339,
0.1493537426,
-0.1310391873,
0.9792733788,
-0.1686492562,
0.2331145555,
-0.6679583192,
-0.1020607427,
-0.669072032,
-0.5711094737,
-0.4705187976,
-0.5451334715,
0.1584284306,
0.6696974635,
0.2893419862,
0.6384410858,
0.3491871357,
0.2533798814,
0.2933798432,
0.3591824174,
-0.650586009,
0.2183582783,
-0.3493310213,
-0.540035069,
-0.0757695809,
0.0934879333,
0.5504414439,
0.5773706436,
-0.1235982776,
0.3972104788,
0.7789179087,
0.5826970339,
-1.1086351871,
0.1698821783,
-0.594866097,
-0.0485854298,
-0.2373933643,
-0.3290073574,
-0.4329364002,
0.0670147985,
0.106732063,
-0.6444219947,
0.2156558484,
0.0237769987,
0.3656124473,
0.9334514737,
-0.4556609988,
-0.2924482226,
-0.6378223896,
1.0794519186,
-0.6774144769,
0.3633435071,
0.632740438,
0.347273767,
0.0181035269,
-0.4372532666,
-0.0714246556,
-0.019331919,
-0.2435210794,
0.2265375704,
0.2382092923,
0.0453996919,
0.3346391022,
0.154713124,
-0.5774850249,
0.3539058268,
-0.29830724,
-0.1271742135,
0.6384128332,
0.1554920673,
-0.2510998845,
0.0041504237,
-0.5319138169,
-0.251952976,
-0.7773213983,
0.170727998,
0.3079962432,
0.5817034245,
-0.0285660699,
0.325222373,
-0.2336205989,
0.8612772822,
0.4505630434,
-0.1119032577,
0.0832622796,
-0.1710564643,
-0.4997722507,
0.2345266342,
0.5149727464,
0.1054498106,
0.0482989363,
-0.2820289731,
-0.2979346514,
-0.0654624775,
0.3692450225,
-0.7339816093,
-0.0907843858,
0.1201450527,
-0.2300957143,
-0.2149372697,
-0.2645847499,
-0.4059335887,
-0.0875364244,
-0.7383332253,
0.8185663223,
-0.3312955797,
-0.0051384568,
-0.0456985757,
0.1779397726,
-0.0594981536,
0.3465776443,
-0.8963897824,
0.3924536109,
0.6842653155,
0.5444165468,
-0.3161572218,
-0.4054672718,
-0.5947544575,
0.1136379167,
-0.4853299856,
0.3244336843,
-0.4294703305,
-0.4071763158,
-0.256218493,
-0.2073938847,
-0.5687662959,
-0.575766027,
0.2933548689,
-0.4743641615,
0.0284272041,
-0.4572284818,
-0.8093075156,
-0.2826651037,
0.2897693515,
-0.4317395389,
1.1091327667,
0.0422583371,
-0.6326655746,
0.6301217675,
-0.4485937357,
-0.3933438063,
0.0272594523,
-0.3184430897,
-0.0828488991,
0.0880370587,
0.0937775448,
0.8001878858,
-0.3010986447,
0.222782582,
-0.399117291,
-0.6162230968,
-0.0138549116,
-0.5693488717,
0.5281875134,
0.4786334336,
-0.3127911985,
-0.2667566836,
-0.5733554363,
0.2113663852,
-0.3125726581,
-0.2544094324,
-0.4218923151,
0.2087609917,
-0.1285035312,
0.3627724946,
0.3441320956,
-0.6233129501,
-0.0627425015,
-0.4995135367,
0.4896870553,
0.5459010601,
-0.22215496,
0.5163154006,
-0.3627599478,
0.4028792977,
0.0062461942,
-0.0615178943,
-0.2467353791,
0.1501369178,
-0.4853816926,
-0.0975307301,
0.2180157155,
0.522824049,
-0.6875859499,
0.1060087904,
0.0790376067,
-0.5057798624,
-0.4784879982,
0.2855990529,
0.7002916336,
0.9139964581,
0.5019858479,
-0.2447763383,
-0.228626281,
-0.7945488095,
-0.4121245444,
-0.0911804289,
0.0789240301,
0.470647186,
0.5356967449,
0.112199001,
1.1447322369,
-0.2320830375,
-0.3473823071,
0.0412942395,
0.2321715802,
-0.0454117768,
0.8193538189,
0.6282971501,
-0.7070081234,
-0.4345079064,
-0.0236453712,
-0.710380137,
0.1338983476,
-0.0855765715,
0.0885845721,
0.2755319178,
0.8033149242,
-0.0931958631,
0.2732618749,
0.5513598323,
0.1501898319,
0.6004889607,
-0.3875254095,
0.3327554166,
-0.8354706168,
-0.1460553259,
0.3321164846,
-0.3042547703,
-0.4240823686,
0.262643218,
0.4705112875,
0.2921423614,
-0.4712945521,
0.3179946244,
-0.3930113018,
-0.0055908901,
-0.2894355655,
-0.1613200158,
-0.1606179327,
0.6064912081,
-0.0626091659,
1.0475285053,
0.5972200036,
-0.5714403391,
-0.0805515498,
-0.0832840726,
-0.4615185261,
0.6502451301,
-0.4820679426,
0.0438766591,
-0.055737935,
0.3634320199,
-1.0830314159,
-0.3790194392,
-0.0419101529,
-0.060316667,
0.6643839478,
-0.197287038,
-0.6492684484,
-0.1120309755,
0.0546787344,
0.9029586315,
0.1673850715,
-0.6807110906,
0.3688784242,
0.2638438344,
0.2752587795,
-0.6386464834,
-0.8005000949,
-0.2832016349,
-0.4387084246,
-0.4140424728,
0.6319895983,
-0.1257099956,
-0.0234231055,
-0.4506291747,
-0.2587607503,
-0.0732472613,
0.2469345033,
0.429561466,
0.1448716223,
-0.1543221474,
0.4243508577,
0.1587996334,
0.0383040085,
-0.0285215992,
-0.1209975332,
0.3377765417,
-0.3557566404,
-0.6596568823,
-0.3333162665,
0.0919595063,
0.452737987,
-0.23345007,
0.5591443777,
0.3264955878,
-0.4086766243,
-0.2485067993,
-0.7330415249,
-0.403367281,
-0.4763599634,
0.2775009871,
-0.4178229272,
-0.8632932901,
0.4418813884,
-0.1834217608,
0.1178373694,
0.3851032853,
0.3590987325,
-0.4161968529,
1.0455100536,
0.752838254,
-0.0811490342,
0.3940462172,
-0.2983940244,
0.0083276602,
-1.0296558142,
0.0124979373,
-0.3689720035,
-0.4755038917,
-0.6949298978,
-0.2461779118,
0.5288742185,
0.0388146602,
-0.4656979442,
0.5549684167,
-0.33062464,
0.6542505622,
0.6411833167,
0.3611473143,
0.1860948652,
-0.304649353,
-0.0505574867,
-0.091241084,
-0.9145012498,
-0.3698031008,
1.152269125,
0.1778669804,
0.9893974662,
-0.4036834836,
0.8236765265,
-0.0435583256,
0.0815359429,
-0.4991553724,
0.1892956048,
-0.2178626359,
-0.6798632741,
-0.4435586631,
-0.3005975187,
-0.698871851,
0.4787250161,
-0.0518509708,
-0.9321858287,
0.3313091695,
0.559476316,
-0.7387018204,
0.0621104762,
-0.8604528308,
1.1063796282,
-0.2608467937,
-0.5970056653,
-0.5180110335,
-0.8559607863,
0.2568858564,
-0.259422183,
0.2421942502,
0.0040280432,
0.1538263857,
0.3537272811,
-0.0592004098,
1.032648921,
0.0657623485,
-0.0246167649,
0.1312095374,
0.2850538194,
0.4734914601,
-0.0786297172,
-0.2704300582,
0.1083194911,
0.3954611421,
-0.1788619608,
-0.4657439291,
0.8780566454,
-0.6792432666,
-0.4673005044,
-0.1700471342,
-0.657754302,
-0.4563017786,
-0.0889241844,
0.5279961824,
0.7601909041,
-0.1738412976,
0.3284059167,
0.6019445062,
0.1536442488,
0.5126062036,
0.2946486473,
0.2542663515,
0.0046334504,
0.9847565293,
0.4662392139,
0.5646928549,
0.3849735856,
0.0135196792,
-0.2716573477,
-0.2532950044,
-0.5222542286,
0.0536247008,
-0.6025129557,
-0.3136612177,
-0.3850188851,
-0.0962585881,
-0.2703688741,
-0.414178282,
-0.5382382274,
-0.2029806376,
-0.6821890473,
0.169676587,
-0.1012810245,
0.3858163357,
-0.030605549,
0.4449859262,
-0.4829258919,
-0.2222929895,
0.1527968496,
0.2288276404,
0.0863009542,
-0.516520977,
-0.538544476,
0.3550063372,
-0.5670905709,
-0.6388120055,
0.2285134196,
0.3249749839,
0.5619552135,
0.2894313633,
0.2050828487,
1.0195143223,
-0.3337123096,
0.5185467601,
-0.208319813,
-0.7649515271,
0.4136151373,
-0.2416040897,
0.3871849179,
0.7770171762,
0.3074082732,
-0.3280733824,
-0.4201695621,
-0.5542417765,
-0.6537002325,
0.9471388459,
-0.0214797165,
-0.0545103066,
0.1339429766,
0.2095474303,
0.2391580194,
0.2631927729,
-0.3818019032,
-0.0596927516,
-0.0596388914,
-0.1685323417,
-0.4868573248,
0.0982269794,
-0.2548173964,
-0.3102077246,
0.7209848762,
-0.5602228642,
-0.0924274325,
0.1829649508,
-0.5045616627,
-0.4408667982,
0.0102490503,
0.3265215755,
0.6780451536,
-0.1170335859,
-0.0854221135,
0.4168358743,
0.1042465493,
-0.1587836593,
0.0401030481,
0.0889038593,
-0.5532879233,
0.3223153949,
0.8151346445,
0.7720982432,
-0.5521796942,
0.4682966471,
0.2810981572,
-0.2320817113,
-0.0609921999,
0.3642735183,
-0.3035587072,
0.4402985871,
0.4705400467,
0.3432172537,
0.3045709729,
-0.4843989313,
0.1339923292,
0.6812030673,
-0.3888768256,
-0.1471908242,
0.6931689978,
-0.0448980778,
-0.0080954386,
0.5468460321,
0.0782191679,
-0.3454374075,
0.7716220617,
0.6331453323,
0.7730573416,
-0.0616765954,
0.1022379547,
0.4630535245,
0.1445089281,
-0.3142747879,
-0.1241305172,
-0.6714023948,
-0.7327660322,
-0.5962792039,
-0.5385402441,
-0.3609085381,
-0.0007395009,
-0.8296434283,
0.0546473041,
-0.0661832541,
-0.0830517262,
-0.1370397508,
0.0091881379,
-0.8757026196,
0.3428653479,
0.0234806295,
0.856322825,
-0.8259963989,
0.7437778711,
0.6028547287,
0.0900043026,
-0.7034593225,
0.1141615286,
0.1645615846,
-0.6305161715,
0.6572746634,
0.334861964,
-0.2916398942,
0.2443164438,
-0.5420580506,
-1.1239925623,
1.1408509016,
0.4652132988,
-0.5973958373,
-0.1221139058,
-0.0768212229,
0.5388342142,
-0.4146489203,
0.3084162772,
0.657279551,
0.1556994766,
0.1079875901,
-1.3319946527,
-0.1157056838,
0.2014808655,
0.0053288233,
0.1875026226,
-0.768759191,
0.7638553977,
-0.0900305957,
-0.3125940561,
-0.1476763934,
0.5835216045,
0.1165443137,
0.3502753377,
0.5117338896,
0.4318115711,
0.4290055037,
-0.1262721717,
0.8143997192,
-0.4753257036,
0.541639328,
1.2625572681,
-0.2099424154,
0.865604341,
0.5065804124,
-0.0197898112,
0.1230566874,
1.0279692411,
0.285574466,
0.7651535273,
-0.2011868358,
0.0110506248,
-0.7798557281,
0.2454497367,
-0.2078509629,
0.6790161133,
0.4755754471,
-0.1192250624,
-0.5535923243,
0.3039265573,
-0.4815414846,
0.0669609159,
-0.3786427677,
0.6205322742,
0.0061338944,
-0.9931342602,
0.4968075156,
-0.2662369609,
0.7907354832,
-0.3270648718,
0.0652133971,
0.2747922838,
0.2763465941,
-0.1061926112,
-0.6853941679,
0.1936138719,
-0.3751564622,
-0.0126969963,
-0.486872226,
0.6300577521,
-0.6207304001,
-0.2602071464,
0.1847766638,
0.5820889473,
0.066408053,
-0.0608615093,
-0.5844222903,
-0.2326740623,
-0.1705607027,
-0.1815503687,
0.6719539762,
0.1581419855,
-0.0340336934,
0.7393744588,
0.4081107378,
-0.2443725914,
-0.0799119845,
-0.3488478065,
0.5871825218,
-0.0743029416,
-0.5354964137,
-0.8822668195,
0.3789271414,
0.1972325146,
-0.5466148257,
0.6679621935,
0.6061040163,
1.4463530779,
0.0990613624,
0.4415591359,
0.1114843413,
0.4535448849,
-0.4655401707,
0.5018057823,
-0.9760594964,
0.0328216739,
-0.4099267721,
-0.5483918786,
-0.0518355779,
0.6500230432,
-0.4300060272,
0.0889197364,
0.3979837,
0.8089943528,
-0.2330587655,
0.3035814464,
0.4835251272,
-0.0720044076,
-0.0175427087,
0.5106241107,
0.5201678872,
-0.3648878038,
0.0503497645,
-0.6016725898,
-0.2271541655,
-0.5304767489,
-0.8631180525,
-0.6285066009,
-0.8949317336,
-0.1815604866,
0.1273512989,
0.1224333495,
1.0936813354,
1.0280208588,
-0.6682428122,
-0.5005300045,
-0.0094634192,
-0.1867756248,
-0.5205210447,
-0.1663290858,
0.0934925377,
-0.7165699005,
-0.7432090044,
0.5784667134,
0.1053566039,
0.0496894978,
-0.2141610831,
-0.0497492813,
0.0472822189,
-0.141374588,
0.5744106174,
0.364813745,
-0.6943069696,
-0.1351657361,
-0.1894664764,
-0.247372061,
-0.001879824,
0.6561174393,
-1.1449836493,
0.6338388324,
0.300971508,
0.6582401991,
0.8774282336,
0.1133317128,
0.5859001875,
-0.8877194524,
-0.1235429347,
0.2334336638,
0.2822303772,
0.0973558053,
-0.5232345462,
0.5314332247,
-0.1904931962,
-0.9709100723,
-1.0175708532,
0.0734246895,
-0.4692631066,
-0.3631437123,
0.8337587118,
0.0589296781,
0.0737463087,
0.1589999646,
-0.0997698829,
0.3214745224,
-0.2328370959,
0.8473243713,
0.8817533851,
-0.3897300661,
0.1707688123,
-0.798345983,
0.6336342096,
0.6921620369,
-0.3987762928,
0.2013676316,
0.5213899016,
0.2321831137,
0.0200100746,
0.2028004676,
0.313539654,
0.4180801213,
-0.3310063183,
-0.4442038536,
-0.0326704644,
-0.5371933579,
-0.2185173929,
0.0747286156,
-0.2383345813,
-0.3261763155
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13766v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13766v1
|
Exploiting Contextual Target Attributes for Target Sentiment Classification
| 2023-12-21T11:45:28 | 2023-12-21T11:45:28 |
Bowen Xing, Ivor W. Tsang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Existing PTLM-based models for TSC can be categorized into two groups: 1)
fine-tuning-based models that adopt PTLM as the context encoder; 2)
prompting-based models that transfer the classification task to the text/word
generation task. In this paper, we present a new perspective of leveraging PTLM
for TSC: simultaneously leveraging the merits of both language modeling and
explicit target-context interactions via contextual target attributes.
Specifically, we design the domain- and target-constrained cloze test, which
can leverage the PTLMs' strong language modeling ability to generate the given
target's attributes pertaining to the review context. The attributes contain
the background and property information of the target, which can help to enrich
the semantics of the review context and the target. To exploit the attributes
for tackling TSC, we first construct a heterogeneous information graph by
treating the attributes as nodes and combining them with (1) the syntax graph
automatically produced by the off-the-shelf dependency parser and (2) the
semantics graph of the review context, which is derived from the self-attention
mechanism. Then we propose a heterogeneous information gated graph
convolutional network to model the interactions among the attribute
information, the syntactic information, and the contextual information. The
experimental results on three benchmark datasets demonstrate the superiority of
our model, which achieves new state-of-the-art performance.
|
[
-0.5078436136,
-0.7726153731,
0.3993864655,
0.1393997669,
-0.4002308547,
-0.0739000142,
-0.2182237208,
-0.2313395143,
-0.0910572112,
0.572650373,
-0.694434464,
-0.7797862291,
-0.5877507329,
-0.0389725082,
-0.250708878,
1.4542970657,
0.0034560848,
-0.3022308052,
-0.034410242,
-0.2488015592,
-0.5642700791,
-0.6552202106,
-0.5791978836,
-0.1013900563,
0.7851160169,
0.2756881714,
0.5568184257,
0.1692505181,
0.2673275471,
0.1753730178,
-0.0451376401,
0.106870234,
-0.3616286516,
0.1791604906,
-0.2326626927,
-0.0894432366,
-0.3524419367,
0.367270112,
0.5122900009,
0.5913161635,
0.3112890124,
0.2850443423,
0.5167130232,
0.1019714326,
-0.7586074471,
0.1985499114,
-0.6993066669,
0.2950055897,
-0.0460625477,
-0.120343335,
-0.6218361855,
-0.2711281776,
0.339045018,
-0.2024711221,
0.2165301591,
0.040046528,
0.9038175344,
0.0496892892,
-0.673807025,
-0.1046211123,
-0.4549800754,
0.8721897602,
-0.6687912941,
0.4106656909,
0.2359655946,
0.0687370598,
0.437355876,
-0.6169630289,
-0.5140048265,
-0.3895283639,
-0.2429067045,
0.0487547256,
-0.2232200503,
-0.0515349358,
0.1755260527,
0.0518878512,
-0.4064660072,
-0.032633137,
-0.2231496125,
-0.2915942371,
0.2444276363,
0.1341336519,
0.0052833203,
-0.5814597011,
-0.6296663284,
-0.046423275,
-0.4489456415,
0.0570719391,
0.0000541748,
0.629367888,
0.1633303761,
0.5989602804,
-0.146017164,
0.6624580622,
0.2516222894,
0.177115202,
0.2203514427,
-0.4617368281,
-0.2935202122,
0.2328701019,
0.8554862142,
0.4773470461,
-0.0714980513,
-0.0724359453,
-0.1331759393,
0.2320970297,
0.3362354636,
-0.6779357791,
0.1691911668,
0.1899021417,
-0.4265743196,
-0.5716536045,
0.1738463044,
-0.6328033805,
-0.2169479132,
-0.3251304626,
0.1961696595,
-0.3238145113,
-0.1968918294,
-0.2089882493,
-0.0646200255,
0.1526056975,
0.1729279011,
-0.3652953506,
0.0612462498,
0.667157948,
0.953001678,
-0.2403729707,
-0.490752399,
-0.6428437829,
0.2329530269,
-0.1414249241,
0.7073466778,
-0.6149301529,
-0.2511561215,
0.2285266668,
-0.0943279788,
0.0259633139,
-0.2250980884,
0.5414600968,
-0.4234257638,
0.3294824362,
-0.2411783785,
-0.1935265958,
-0.113442108,
0.8123681545,
-0.6640366316,
1.1751748323,
0.4153651297,
-0.9606887102,
0.3824509978,
-0.6147896051,
-0.6043659449,
-0.0694269091,
0.3379871845,
-0.5657809377,
0.0848612785,
0.0678400323,
0.8333842754,
-0.2479956746,
0.3654533923,
-0.5670460463,
0.0718393624,
0.2574610114,
-0.2109736353,
0.4734938741,
0.4586791396,
-0.3943968117,
0.231256932,
-0.2936532497,
0.1887275279,
-0.1423218548,
-0.2182293385,
-0.3985676765,
-0.1980929524,
0.2117647678,
0.5358336568,
0.2102451324,
-0.4308788478,
-0.0430859141,
-0.2103730291,
0.4032692909,
0.6684294343,
0.2844525874,
0.4601427913,
0.0251649283,
0.2388840765,
0.1345755756,
0.3616091907,
0.226350233,
-0.0455120392,
-0.5094282031,
0.045078028,
0.1072129384,
0.2084995359,
-0.6526433825,
0.5955150723,
-0.1887710392,
-0.3910713196,
-0.2219405472,
0.0220555887,
0.4716656506,
0.7549214959,
0.2936883271,
-0.2735842168,
-0.4729158878,
-0.7859711051,
-0.2553617358,
-0.2641565502,
0.1362181455,
0.3409109414,
0.122994028,
-0.1996427029,
1.0231692791,
-0.6532775164,
-0.5694862008,
-0.750572741,
0.3026891649,
-0.0769632831,
0.3691083491,
0.5395866036,
-0.6790349483,
-0.6163416505,
0.1684011966,
-0.6504092216,
-0.4347970486,
0.1123270541,
-0.1898088753,
-0.0043523638,
0.4205800295,
-0.5387580991,
0.3783952594,
0.3006527424,
-0.434497565,
0.5109503865,
0.3272161782,
0.1898025721,
-1.1661528349,
0.2310907096,
0.3248552084,
-0.2499322295,
-0.8139737844,
-0.1691957563,
-0.095899947,
-0.3525483608,
-0.5243715048,
0.4869939983,
-0.2456253767,
0.0940917879,
-0.2934951186,
0.1414126307,
0.2716434002,
0.6869422793,
0.1368747652,
0.3056728542,
0.2930302918,
-0.6267117262,
0.2530693114,
0.2140941769,
-0.0257210564,
0.8090648055,
-0.5491178036,
0.125061959,
-0.0479121245,
0.2816377282,
-0.6275452971,
0.0135893943,
0.3849079013,
-0.3829312027,
0.1308497787,
0.0445181131,
-0.5229645967,
-0.3743326962,
-0.4018152058,
0.3531970084,
0.2396173924,
-0.5149645209,
0.7669705749,
0.2500501275,
-0.0007329592,
-0.4416895211,
-0.6617833972,
-0.0025841864,
-0.2982661724,
-0.2865393162,
0.1780569106,
0.0512758903,
-0.0269957259,
0.2138491869,
0.0513886847,
0.1068157852,
0.0833602324,
0.2353485823,
0.2322691232,
-0.0781404078,
0.2436379343,
0.0303302165,
0.0107122138,
0.0152417831,
-0.5619965196,
0.7675567269,
-0.3147051632,
-0.2175393254,
-0.399589479,
0.5179923773,
0.5361611843,
-0.5241340995,
0.5662483573,
0.5967915654,
-0.1897883117,
-0.58667624,
-0.5064909458,
-0.2868850827,
-0.3740382195,
0.6955267787,
-0.396879524,
-0.8954789639,
0.3179256022,
-0.1050844491,
-0.2429761887,
0.399214834,
0.6594318748,
0.0682134107,
1.2121055126,
0.4813832939,
-0.4668443501,
0.7292356491,
-0.2829927504,
0.3733762503,
-0.9506483078,
-0.1815747768,
-0.3731409609,
-0.3083152473,
-0.200068593,
-0.2310958356,
0.5450519323,
-0.0795392692,
-0.3800627589,
0.4686334431,
-0.5411590338,
0.1850966662,
0.4908630848,
0.3274085522,
-0.0324349105,
-0.0135662444,
-0.2428510338,
0.0434441008,
-0.6135760546,
-0.3701050878,
0.8929374814,
0.4187729061,
0.5365687013,
-0.2018247843,
0.2699041367,
0.5413452983,
0.4359516501,
-0.7106423974,
0.6459825039,
-0.1561878175,
-0.3456293941,
-0.046602644,
-0.3082661033,
-0.6634311676,
0.143808037,
-0.0835464448,
-0.5791023374,
0.1093996316,
0.1331277788,
-0.1515133679,
0.3218854666,
-0.62338835,
1.1686416864,
-0.2519552708,
-0.4892702699,
-0.2232425213,
-0.6805948019,
0.1669866592,
0.1865464002,
-0.1702467352,
-0.0808879435,
0.1708185524,
0.2918243706,
-0.4184362888,
1.1128014326,
-0.2683078945,
0.1403667927,
0.5556919575,
0.221627593,
0.5760272145,
-0.1142867655,
-0.0585869215,
0.0307092611,
-0.3103013635,
-0.2097849697,
-0.7294160128,
0.7688525319,
-0.6732991338,
-0.4624896348,
-0.4336500764,
-0.5026708245,
-0.5253539681,
0.1761832535,
0.1185667962,
0.5284454823,
-0.2645293176,
0.0671077743,
0.3090521395,
0.1355420649,
0.1039716601,
0.3877937794,
0.0420365781,
-0.3078017831,
0.8384277225,
-0.1520205736,
0.4415104985,
0.2960655987,
0.3590118289,
-0.3669833839,
-0.4982132316,
-0.0218030363,
0.1592350751,
-0.9253208637,
-0.4496166408,
-0.7496715784,
-0.3657887876,
-0.6382814646,
-0.104083702,
-0.0841793865,
0.0391576849,
-0.3970921636,
-0.3144513071,
0.1974821538,
0.7229231596,
0.2027582079,
0.4156088829,
-0.6475738883,
-0.0786103755,
0.2571052313,
0.2764792442,
0.0278494041,
-0.2170372158,
-0.2479381263,
-0.075573504,
-0.3662308455,
-1.0901609659,
0.449303031,
0.139541775,
0.4261909723,
0.390881449,
0.3073436022,
0.3811067045,
-0.2657173574,
0.8644162416,
0.1055301279,
-1.149769187,
0.7899073958,
-0.1202513203,
0.4328568578,
0.6543989778,
0.2643932402,
-0.7582591176,
-0.7139565349,
-0.3825392723,
-0.5276324153,
0.7557016611,
0.0515904874,
0.0502922609,
-0.1626851708,
0.2443744242,
-0.0144487321,
0.4740903676,
-0.9808087945,
0.2221128196,
-0.6199026704,
-0.546254158,
0.0697044134,
-0.2817984819,
-0.0118506663,
-0.0616387874,
0.6399781108,
-0.5503399372,
-0.0092233261,
0.3314574361,
-0.1899164766,
0.0634836107,
0.3332172632,
0.1971548349,
0.0077466979,
-0.1446758211,
0.4431042969,
0.2210036069,
-0.1868488342,
-0.2052245438,
0.0151939709,
-0.2937787175,
-0.0622634031,
0.2976991832,
1.1287144423,
0.1756363213,
-0.3091008365,
0.580635488,
0.1630262882,
-0.0947499946,
0.2111566216,
-0.2801193595,
-0.3163432777,
0.2254527509,
0.0582398251,
0.1476020515,
0.2812758982,
-0.5982066393,
0.2117896974,
0.6652178764,
-0.7685335875,
-0.480928272,
0.3766086102,
0.1393098682,
0.111878328,
0.3333518505,
-0.2823922634,
-1.1840285063,
0.3846307099,
0.5007277727,
1.1176558733,
-0.1016707197,
0.519615829,
0.3458258808,
0.1562732607,
0.2586766183,
-0.0838485211,
-0.3603018224,
-0.6090344787,
-0.0446137376,
-0.5189188719,
-0.2252538055,
-0.0895388797,
-0.428691864,
0.3236792088,
-0.6589662433,
-0.3662334681,
-0.3077583313,
-0.0650558993,
-0.6608579755,
0.3361608982,
0.1337270588,
0.4834908545,
-0.9205747843,
0.7419911623,
0.6131129265,
-0.4254985452,
-1.0256000757,
0.1883177012,
-0.081212312,
-0.4971717596,
0.9668501616,
0.3212212324,
-0.1681884974,
-0.0383130684,
-0.6292244792,
-0.5343331099,
0.9303759336,
-0.0372573733,
-0.0636483282,
-0.0539657846,
0.381059438,
0.7023371458,
-0.7342962027,
0.1534352899,
0.435636729,
0.418382138,
0.166950345,
-0.8395006657,
0.241321072,
-0.3380746543,
0.1437343359,
0.0631979331,
-0.6402297616,
0.8863112926,
0.0704745129,
-0.2759634256,
-0.3513416648,
0.6738922596,
0.1391099542,
0.3375969231,
0.8346339464,
0.4437725842,
0.3246819079,
-0.0389460288,
1.1287246943,
-0.3016544878,
0.5183592439,
0.9790440202,
-0.5658560395,
0.8098254204,
0.3642860651,
0.0895871669,
0.6096302867,
0.5142730474,
-0.0935245901,
0.7191261053,
0.0256434605,
-0.2946870327,
-0.0789466351,
-0.8067097068,
-0.0721793771,
0.3123124838,
0.2155762911,
-0.5573418736,
-0.3001135588,
0.3613042831,
0.0054029068,
0.0857500583,
-0.5147987008,
0.9146538377,
-0.0018160301,
-0.8919991851,
0.3213330507,
0.0126713784,
0.5868117213,
-0.7571334243,
0.2781351209,
0.0342074148,
0.2155952305,
-0.1774008274,
-1.0443960428,
0.3851667047,
0.1395692229,
-0.1744600981,
-0.4813659191,
1.0033900738,
-0.5923947096,
-0.4578751922,
0.3731099665,
0.2993131578,
-0.3941930234,
-0.2863830924,
-0.5935360789,
0.1770178378,
-0.0627648309,
-0.1996178478,
0.2461124063,
0.5721154809,
-0.1779928356,
0.4681393206,
0.5317776203,
0.1108415648,
-0.0249639004,
0.3044457436,
1.0491982698,
-0.5219522119,
-0.7330853939,
-0.7260300517,
0.3584217429,
-0.2192147076,
-0.284940511,
0.7937815189,
0.418379426,
0.7291533947,
-0.2044905871,
0.9611998796,
-0.07117787,
0.4681714177,
-0.3402432501,
0.5649879575,
-0.5710014105,
0.0403865278,
-0.3149605393,
-0.8098729849,
-0.3158993125,
0.2396536171,
-0.5454557538,
0.1208315045,
0.8502922058,
0.5342453718,
-0.0326419212,
-0.1271881759,
0.0804453045,
0.1736357361,
0.3251267672,
0.7847898602,
0.9028481841,
-0.1880533546,
0.612995863,
-0.3263550401,
0.0979558453,
-0.1440775692,
-0.8061230183,
-1.1169601679,
-0.6240342855,
-0.3800595999,
-0.7917196751,
-0.0521623753,
0.9451143742,
0.665658474,
-0.8888264894,
0.048219461,
0.0045352397,
0.1874085963,
-0.2233495563,
-0.3561779559,
0.4059489369,
-0.4782887399,
-0.7761508226,
-0.1743899882,
0.3142719567,
-0.1006541401,
-0.3472418487,
0.0167788249,
-0.029254619,
-0.1536864787,
0.7486159801,
-0.0315814838,
-0.7228297591,
-0.49527511,
0.102754578,
-0.4037866294,
0.0249134116,
1.0269379616,
-0.7428877354,
0.2746955454,
0.4741465151,
0.5284891129,
0.2122211754,
0.2101736814,
0.5550656915,
-1.0739423037,
-0.0016077012,
0.5565835238,
0.2332497537,
0.35870561,
-0.4534963071,
0.1612321585,
0.2278902084,
-0.1776769608,
-0.8133809566,
0.3101932704,
-1.1856800318,
-0.3205621541,
1.258084774,
-0.0242473446,
-0.4038051665,
0.0698159486,
-0.4975260794,
0.2568714023,
-0.3916947544,
0.5375787616,
0.6201070547,
0.224219352,
-0.3182384074,
-0.1155431122,
0.455660671,
0.5296636224,
-0.965821743,
0.1004793718,
0.5016071796,
0.194584772,
0.1423146427,
0.3568006158,
-0.0500134006,
0.1057725176,
-0.361194998,
0.0137769124,
-0.1595964581,
-0.2376455218,
-0.1298778057,
0.6596918702,
0.0461769328,
-0.0395154431
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13764v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13764v1
|
A Semantic Space is Worth 256 Language Descriptions: Make Stronger Segmentation Models with Descriptive Properties
| 2023-12-21T11:43:41 | 2023-12-21T11:43:41 |
Junfei Xiao, Ziqi Zhou, Wenxuan Li, Shiyi Lan, Jieru Mei, Zhiding Yu, Alan Yuille, Yuyin Zhou, Cihang Xie
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper introduces ProLab, a novel approach using property-level label
space for creating strong interpretable segmentation models. Instead of relying
solely on category-specific annotations, ProLab uses descriptive properties
grounded in common sense knowledge for supervising segmentation models. It is
based on two core designs. First, we employ Large Language Models (LLMs) and
carefully crafted prompts to generate descriptions of all involved categories
that carry meaningful common sense knowledge and follow a structured format.
Second, we introduce a description embedding model preserving semantic
correlation across descriptions and then cluster them into a set of descriptive
properties (e.g., 256) using K-Means. These properties are based on
interpretable common sense knowledge consistent with theories of human
recognition. We empirically show that our approach makes segmentation models
perform stronger on five classic benchmarks (e.g., ADE20K, COCO-Stuff, Pascal
Context, Cityscapes, and BDD). Our method also shows better scalability with
extended training steps than category-level supervision. Our interpretable
segmentation framework also emerges with the generalization ability to segment
out-of-domain or unknown categories using only in-domain descriptive
properties. Code is available at https://github.com/lambert-x/ProLab.
|
[
-0.5239053369,
-0.5079847574,
0.5341716409,
0.271897316,
-0.2131559551,
0.0003693389,
-0.036649242,
-0.5510716438,
0.0897523984,
0.724883616,
-0.2892654836,
-0.6679044366,
-0.4715799093,
-0.2438894659,
-0.4437419772,
1.0047920942,
0.0567658842,
0.089664951,
-0.3880769014,
-0.2428296357,
-0.2341516316,
-0.4431598186,
-0.3157721162,
-0.0163610484,
0.6090183854,
0.1451640278,
0.9638748169,
0.973967433,
0.5997540951,
0.2585406005,
-0.2688421905,
0.2470615506,
-0.1574470848,
-0.3639618158,
-0.1824256182,
-0.2102673799,
-0.6721659899,
-0.0757812858,
0.7005386353,
0.9538812637,
0.2020479143,
-0.3973138034,
-0.1622880697,
0.3967142701,
-0.5180556774,
0.2562074065,
-0.3904863,
-0.0713201612,
-0.0848598182,
0.1743497103,
-0.4179833233,
-0.1754250824,
0.349616915,
-1.0046267509,
0.3574042618,
0.1442452818,
1.2415616512,
0.1966839135,
-0.2039259076,
-0.0532300286,
-0.4943569303,
1.1508227587,
-0.3674094379,
0.5025874376,
0.4427753389,
0.4567863643,
-0.0819287673,
-0.8206837773,
-0.2508116663,
-0.2003272623,
-0.183744669,
0.0027653717,
-0.2306130975,
0.1213094443,
-0.0711600408,
0.3386421204,
-0.2358260304,
0.1785376668,
-0.6377495527,
-0.3964624405,
0.6032391787,
0.2291970104,
0.397690773,
0.1063131765,
-0.6995074749,
-0.1325359046,
-0.5645247102,
-0.013145823,
0.2613624632,
0.1260240078,
0.1993595064,
0.2658143342,
-0.077685073,
1.0081738234,
-0.3693219721,
-0.3132460117,
0.1682193428,
-0.3539384604,
0.1015473455,
-0.0360901281,
0.5927088857,
0.5926592946,
0.6210871935,
-0.3722307384,
-0.0212848485,
0.1860645115,
0.4023275673,
-0.7927564383,
-0.4981225133,
-0.0003749972,
-0.3344211876,
-0.0641242117,
0.0314035825,
-0.5762636065,
-0.4987115562,
-0.4019469321,
0.1676569879,
-0.7144013643,
-0.2648635507,
0.5614777207,
-0.3024983108,
0.4808413982,
0.3334566653,
-0.8685535789,
0.8747932315,
0.8569481969,
0.6650182009,
-0.2535190284,
-0.1850124449,
-0.0090720505,
0.2137983888,
-0.3095184863,
0.8074070215,
-0.7666415572,
-0.2937465608,
-0.3784809411,
0.0914917663,
0.0654059947,
-0.9798286557,
0.2856485248,
-0.498168081,
-0.2414270788,
0.0801173374,
-0.6700515747,
-0.2563836277,
0.2458383739,
-0.7315890789,
0.6651059985,
0.429174304,
-0.685531199,
0.4740788639,
-0.5769138932,
-0.2054104209,
0.347045958,
-0.1455276757,
-0.3522299528,
0.0382177196,
0.1913407892,
0.3695445061,
-0.0088152932,
0.6128457189,
-0.111848779,
0.1284159869,
0.5322862267,
0.0256339405,
0.4135200083,
0.5059144497,
0.1793316305,
0.4322682023,
-1.1934500933,
-0.105356276,
0.0034523064,
-0.177489236,
-0.4835934043,
0.0747619867,
-0.0013782949,
-0.0790351927,
0.4276979864,
-0.8137956858,
-0.100579381,
-0.5379389524,
0.1547855586,
0.4024882913,
-0.1609535217,
0.7810059786,
0.0525180325,
0.5304175019,
0.1952726245,
0.1084673405,
-0.0347532295,
-0.3866533935,
-0.653493166,
-0.7031658292,
0.3129970431,
0.458922863,
-0.3781241775,
0.6401557326,
-0.0968239009,
-0.4013629556,
-0.4554854929,
-0.0585647114,
0.4474518299,
0.6029641032,
0.649335444,
-0.3366696239,
-0.5851083398,
-1.2668529749,
-0.1639414728,
0.133430928,
-0.3086731732,
0.2129920125,
0.3162034154,
-0.4707237482,
1.4164071083,
-0.8350302577,
-0.6095770001,
-0.5629786253,
-0.3965515494,
-0.0575021952,
0.4690140784,
0.3381743133,
-0.7426771522,
-0.1483944654,
0.0082443077,
-0.6543349028,
-0.2180423439,
0.0216070153,
-0.2243965566,
-0.4261518121,
0.3598706424,
-0.2605214417,
0.2328540087,
0.1714719683,
-0.5771867037,
0.4658711851,
-0.2928704917,
-0.6249169111,
-0.9882235527,
-0.1749060899,
0.3469121158,
-0.1344822943,
-0.6051303744,
0.0997740403,
-0.0735909492,
-0.1158242598,
-0.6301181316,
0.902974844,
0.0178053807,
-0.205416888,
-0.3051697314,
0.0767321363,
0.3198645115,
0.3874367774,
0.5665359497,
0.3826665878,
0.6405724287,
-0.6685761809,
0.1849595308,
0.2493812144,
-0.6641754508,
0.3977644444,
-0.6305837631,
-0.4024133682,
0.1186763048,
0.3785917759,
-0.8160337806,
-0.3908648491,
0.1411576718,
-0.2040805817,
-0.1448879391,
0.217485711,
-0.4638288319,
-0.0500133373,
0.0461366363,
0.3156816065,
0.4086817205,
-0.4610655308,
0.5560091734,
0.5946658254,
0.1016658992,
-0.1707776934,
-0.5204851627,
-0.1479265392,
-0.4658305645,
-0.7950052619,
0.3430049121,
0.3142781556,
-0.3948504031,
0.1083711386,
-0.1936131269,
-0.4437193274,
0.4669046104,
0.1340898871,
0.2161817849,
0.1677393913,
0.1614646018,
-0.0966307819,
-0.5452295542,
0.0356370024,
-0.4884890616,
0.37747702,
-0.4683742225,
0.0578662157,
-0.3155287206,
0.1976514906,
0.2181148231,
-0.4474524856,
0.7846105099,
0.7229175568,
-0.392083168,
-0.3443130851,
0.038905561,
-0.0902661905,
-0.4321745038,
0.6635791659,
-0.4953994155,
-1.1147215366,
0.5496544838,
-0.2905369103,
-0.0550674759,
0.4525866508,
0.2210994661,
-0.1189611703,
1.1793298721,
0.5785217285,
0.3045163453,
0.4878323078,
-0.3526057899,
0.5167586803,
-0.891690731,
-0.5577830672,
-0.3208987713,
-0.3143853247,
-0.2260801792,
-0.6111912727,
0.2676210701,
0.2812927067,
-0.108303003,
0.3085914254,
-0.7621076107,
0.6327054501,
0.4059587121,
-0.0528424755,
-0.1149863899,
0.0877407938,
0.0234021377,
-0.148434788,
-0.5904383063,
-0.9111133814,
0.5432577133,
0.7729471922,
1.0867378712,
-0.2207788378,
0.726123929,
0.0603401139,
0.1334329247,
-1.0632779598,
0.8329011202,
-0.553004086,
-0.5736988783,
-0.3432792425,
-0.2347745448,
-1.2117294073,
0.5075389147,
0.2224049866,
-0.9167701602,
0.2194658369,
0.1725231558,
-0.4364080727,
0.18744874,
-0.65041399,
1.0529507399,
-0.3450984657,
-0.0951616168,
-0.0631011873,
-0.6097872257,
0.2084802389,
-0.1008538455,
0.5306134224,
-0.3830853403,
-0.021031525,
1.0621016026,
-0.6677188277,
0.9271433949,
-0.4563778043,
-0.1956311017,
0.5812317133,
0.0981953815,
0.0150409974,
-0.2705895603,
0.3053103983,
-0.0020930287,
0.2852236927,
-0.4323844314,
-0.505515337,
0.3884409368,
-0.876368165,
-0.2436986268,
0.0142195225,
-0.7802632451,
-0.2898116708,
0.0659680739,
-0.0435106605,
0.6205089092,
-0.165780589,
0.2201678306,
0.7641244531,
-0.5927816629,
-0.1538697034,
0.3046352267,
-0.3075094819,
-0.4048736691,
1.4323060513,
0.0788965523,
0.1525877267,
0.4322076738,
0.5842399001,
-0.4579253793,
-0.3520490229,
-0.1721852869,
0.145088762,
-0.7640014291,
-0.0356668718,
-0.9658800364,
-0.1198466644,
-0.2775844932,
-0.4452305138,
-0.5169032812,
-0.6162565947,
-0.1251726598,
-0.2206268311,
0.2654875517,
0.6662455797,
0.0374660417,
0.7707530856,
-0.6815229654,
0.4726508856,
0.2106157988,
0.3242635131,
-0.0879325345,
-0.3718203902,
-0.4981562197,
-0.2452638894,
-0.2934532762,
-0.5238543749,
0.6617892981,
0.0409152359,
0.6477797031,
0.4411555827,
-0.0137059437,
0.4080576301,
-0.2265094221,
0.7184476852,
0.3310207427,
-0.8170198202,
0.5360535383,
-0.1919892579,
0.4211333394,
0.378164798,
0.3287821412,
-0.1268505305,
-0.5709978342,
-0.716622591,
-1.1339128017,
0.6349637508,
-0.2290129364,
-0.0495226532,
-0.2945893407,
-0.0242418479,
0.1381610036,
-0.2056377083,
-0.6807000637,
0.2036810666,
-0.2651089728,
-0.5657182336,
0.0919459611,
-0.3714193404,
-0.2019965202,
-0.164472416,
0.3798202872,
-0.1691324562,
0.0031188088,
0.0114891836,
-0.1157182232,
0.5199461579,
0.3892561495,
0.4011757076,
0.8019902706,
-0.3252217472,
0.6070259809,
0.0097370259,
-0.3550378382,
0.178512603,
-0.0551279113,
0.0784939378,
-0.0721330121,
0.5181837678,
0.886662364,
0.2159643769,
-0.7079301476,
0.3666608632,
0.0753699839,
-0.4769764245,
0.0239975192,
0.2451243401,
0.1295559555,
0.1023124009,
-0.0635692924,
-0.2502499521,
0.1238954589,
-0.3053198755,
0.2899844944,
0.0372008197,
-0.5316333175,
-0.3855413496,
0.6226733923,
0.241517216,
-0.0938913152,
0.5374811888,
-0.0898333564,
-0.56343925,
0.8896970153,
0.610979557,
0.6658409834,
0.032700289,
0.2860880494,
0.255546242,
-0.1016054526,
-0.0372603573,
0.1271571815,
-0.2472142428,
-1.0192751884,
-0.3416584134,
-1.0983974934,
-0.4267722964,
-0.1542818248,
-0.6706227064,
-0.1493939459,
-0.6142453551,
-0.1665009558,
0.2108494341,
-0.1975021362,
-0.5012614131,
0.6024905443,
0.0857271031,
1.0332267284,
-0.9107616544,
0.8740392327,
0.8396538496,
-0.1474149078,
-0.8692161441,
-0.4958759248,
-0.4179337323,
-0.6019987464,
0.8857594728,
0.316932261,
-0.0790705755,
-0.1532408744,
-0.6564183831,
-0.7693364024,
0.7711462975,
0.1207735538,
-0.6083884239,
0.209226951,
0.1830773354,
0.7977099419,
-0.5058166385,
-0.3150243759,
0.9150343537,
0.5313364863,
0.2474850714,
-0.6332100034,
-0.2134336382,
0.1523528993,
-0.1098256633,
0.0991205797,
-0.3478060663,
0.5335901976,
-0.1420276761,
-0.1257519424,
0.1179678738,
0.5919907093,
0.6139796972,
0.4802696407,
0.4721575379,
0.8039406538,
0.7219513655,
-0.3103845119,
1.1608197689,
-0.2489454299,
0.1019516811,
1.1914820671,
-0.1207374483,
0.5187827349,
0.4405123889,
-0.2249746323,
0.4915767312,
0.589736402,
-0.0789098665,
0.7408065796,
0.5993580222,
-0.2166321725,
-0.4988076687,
-0.5685568452,
-0.0157223251,
0.4743024707,
0.6015684605,
-0.4997610748,
-0.2459847927,
0.037941616,
0.1465306133,
0.1963962018,
-0.3277499676,
0.855304718,
0.2977623343,
-0.5368814468,
0.3580541611,
0.1058508977,
0.3252415657,
-0.7366460562,
0.1310440898,
-0.0826472566,
0.6581684351,
-0.3090186417,
-1.0704236031,
0.5717324018,
-0.0191314928,
-0.0589416921,
-0.46166116,
0.8678999543,
-0.3543947637,
-0.4547281265,
0.4178270102,
0.2327437401,
0.5693501234,
0.122776404,
-0.3227597177,
0.1605813205,
-0.1596402228,
0.1392918229,
0.4196418226,
0.5951586366,
-0.6098750234,
0.5874583125,
0.3081908524,
-0.072957553,
0.1361010075,
0.3590847552,
0.9421754479,
-0.6629581451,
-0.6044955254,
-0.6389904022,
0.4001536667,
0.0621113293,
-0.0428797677,
0.6230534315,
0.6486998796,
0.9181842208,
-0.1314238012,
0.6380482912,
0.0388369411,
0.4451490641,
-0.2631426454,
0.2607541084,
-0.3423324227,
0.1425639391,
-0.0674395934,
-0.9715522528,
-0.667195797,
0.9372416735,
-0.5137286782,
-0.2451125681,
0.36174649,
0.7518689632,
0.0490070172,
-0.4084890783,
0.4026759565,
-0.1206231192,
0.5659378767,
0.5572910905,
1.3386126757,
0.1335457712,
0.4946723282,
-0.0582740083,
-0.2591647208,
0.1272864044,
-0.4129509032,
-0.70689255,
-0.2588224709,
-0.4391351342,
-0.2064004242,
-0.2991029918,
0.2867656648,
0.9874970317,
-0.6619214416,
-0.2340452373,
-0.1879942119,
-0.039013952,
-0.1621772945,
-0.2769049108,
0.5524604321,
-0.4034188092,
-0.6285107136,
0.3660097718,
0.3660439551,
-0.0331858397,
-0.3666576743,
-0.3659501374,
0.174145624,
0.1079213321,
0.4806317687,
0.0915582553,
-0.9550019503,
-0.1679691821,
-0.2357006818,
0.0011880009,
-0.0530731641,
0.717769146,
-0.8215301633,
0.689953208,
0.3943653703,
0.6461723447,
0.3089700043,
0.2906543016,
0.4489504993,
-0.7765206695,
0.0863056928,
0.1152374074,
0.4020483494,
0.3923566341,
0.0184629299,
0.6549642682,
0.1432798803,
-0.3289153874,
-0.518938601,
0.3460961878,
-1.2384763956,
-0.5509420037,
1.2772889137,
-0.4506210387,
-0.4391299784,
-0.1287299097,
-0.5287107229,
0.0929394364,
-0.2165825814,
0.3233554363,
0.4909165204,
-0.2269034535,
-0.0852583349,
-0.2074817866,
0.373060286,
0.2791110277,
-0.7331585288,
0.0694588721,
0.632973671,
0.2466721386,
0.3663033843,
0.4954145253,
-0.4062975943,
0.0225643162,
0.0727668852,
0.172021538,
-0.24206613,
-0.69942981,
-0.1364499629,
0.2795377076,
0.1968049109,
-0.4938103557
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14211v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14211v1
|
Experimenting with Large Language Models and vector embeddings in NASA SciX
| 2023-12-21T10:19:58 | 2023-12-21T10:19:58 |
Sergi Blanco-Cuaresma, Ioana Ciucă, Alberto Accomazzi, Michael J. Kurtz, Edwin A. Henneken, Kelly E. Lockhart, Felix Grezes, Thomas Allen, Golnaz Shapurian, Carolyn S. Grant, Donna M. Thompson, Timothy W. Hostetler, Matthew R. Templeton, Shinyi Chen, Jennifer Koch, Taylor Jacovich, Daniel Chivvis, Fernanda de Macedo Alves, Jean-Claude Paquin, Jennifer Bartlett, Mugdha Polimera, Stephanie Jarmak
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, astro-ph.IM, cs.AI
|
Open-source Large Language Models enable projects such as NASA SciX (i.e.,
NASA ADS) to think out of the box and try alternative approaches for
information retrieval and data augmentation, while respecting data copyright
and users' privacy. However, when large language models are directly prompted
with questions without any context, they are prone to hallucination. At NASA
SciX we have developed an experiment where we created semantic vectors for our
large collection of abstracts and full-text content, and we designed a prompt
system to ask questions using contextual chunks from our system. Based on a
non-systematic human evaluation, the experiment shows a lower degree of
hallucination and better responses when using Retrieval Augmented Generation.
Further exploration is required to design new features and data augmentation
processes at NASA SciX that leverages this technology while respecting the high
level of trust and quality that the project holds.
|
[
-0.5352524519,
-0.8617124557,
0.910674572,
0.3465766311,
-0.1645088792,
0.0033528679,
-0.2378817946,
-0.5529589057,
0.4257854223,
0.5408328772,
-0.373313278,
-0.5699893832,
-0.4063151479,
0.0761134624,
-0.7399185896,
0.586586833,
-0.1044306532,
0.1557466388,
-0.6290251017,
-0.0856199041,
-0.5397533178,
-0.7353577018,
-0.3844788969,
0.1545345336,
0.418200165,
0.3666270673,
0.950783968,
0.6351110935,
0.4166773856,
0.2172751874,
-0.1064946577,
-0.0867554843,
-0.4019379616,
0.1896453202,
-0.5202645659,
-0.2804098129,
-0.117904909,
-0.1493597031,
0.5728877187,
0.9511332512,
0.1630377471,
0.0040837429,
-0.2112522274,
0.2767788768,
-0.656588614,
0.0664988682,
-0.2215356529,
0.0934169888,
0.1690252125,
-0.1223210171,
-0.3290070593,
-0.4556096196,
0.2170531303,
-0.7396574616,
0.2937333882,
0.4352101982,
0.7096297741,
0.4221869707,
-0.3557490706,
-0.3885964155,
-0.8381842971,
0.8095349073,
-0.4233276546,
0.5917825103,
0.4072120786,
0.0464044176,
-0.201896593,
-0.7391452789,
-0.5114979744,
-0.5726155043,
0.0268054996,
-0.1958439052,
-0.1861156225,
-0.1980226934,
0.2897873819,
0.1624232084,
-0.8764873743,
0.0787298605,
-0.6466498375,
-0.1479029655,
0.5962716937,
-0.1677431613,
0.2033521235,
-0.2864937186,
-0.3688681126,
-0.443987757,
-0.962240696,
-0.1740675718,
0.1510698199,
0.2641064525,
0.1853699982,
1.1140317917,
-0.0893928483,
0.4076793492,
-0.278464973,
0.87851578,
0.2481975108,
-0.314933002,
-0.0768917501,
0.3243798614,
0.5212036371,
0.2150256634,
0.0181317218,
-0.2970567942,
-0.2995851934,
0.3343536556,
0.3996817172,
-0.7383574843,
0.0027496275,
0.5527406931,
-0.3464291096,
-0.0403031409,
0.359285593,
-0.5639979243,
-0.5846139789,
-0.5555998683,
0.5472902656,
-0.3839753866,
-0.3660492897,
0.3110317588,
-0.3760681152,
0.249829337,
0.2284899354,
-0.4240735769,
0.1782374978,
0.7829415202,
0.6637164354,
-0.0464743115,
-0.3312481344,
-0.6707330346,
-0.0136829959,
-0.4746251702,
0.7367101312,
-0.718901515,
-0.7892329693,
-0.1162820235,
0.2600964904,
0.3879130483,
-0.5585788488,
0.5392285585,
-0.6034352183,
0.2307258993,
-0.5149624348,
-0.5496239066,
-0.2600134909,
-0.1439792216,
-0.4473092556,
1.0166391134,
0.2022850066,
-0.292571038,
0.4352960885,
-0.9601060152,
-0.2155109793,
0.2001840025,
-0.427857548,
-0.0331452042,
0.4129419327,
0.1956575066,
0.366938293,
-0.0544397607,
0.2071560621,
-0.2580974102,
-0.5247591734,
0.5234043598,
0.0934479684,
0.3277895451,
0.3859952688,
-0.4261423349,
0.4032507241,
-0.6406072378,
-0.1096139178,
0.1609938145,
0.0374847911,
-0.9218927622,
0.1141020432,
0.3368436694,
0.2174756974,
0.1116333604,
-0.7807178497,
0.2581917942,
-0.4520115554,
0.2437365204,
0.6810353398,
0.0073752576,
0.4762298465,
-0.0252932925,
0.4760879874,
0.1348744035,
0.0472307317,
-0.0454428308,
-0.538584888,
-0.4913699031,
0.053424865,
0.0773256421,
0.2500990927,
-0.7705461383,
0.3826934099,
-0.0612303615,
-0.3572720587,
-0.4434356689,
0.0049707904,
0.1460774243,
0.3044829667,
0.3782163858,
-0.1070972234,
-0.5964351892,
-0.924716413,
-0.0225007962,
0.092138201,
-0.3323827386,
0.5308728218,
0.8134551048,
-0.455105722,
1.0451080799,
-0.8201705217,
0.1534280032,
0.106552124,
0.1346842498,
-0.0572645962,
0.5384255648,
0.5012535453,
-1.0759468079,
-0.0124674682,
-0.1643735021,
-0.7730498314,
0.1186776087,
0.1211418658,
-0.1540963501,
0.1414908618,
0.803889513,
-0.7327910066,
0.4322650135,
0.4524770379,
-0.7605109215,
0.3235788643,
-0.3394287229,
0.2300246358,
-1.0520015955,
0.3697505891,
-0.1421173513,
-0.1117843762,
-0.4370140135,
0.1229654029,
0.211007461,
-0.4865877628,
-0.6200100183,
0.556990087,
-0.3991848826,
-0.2857434452,
-0.5616819263,
0.3995988667,
0.1182772964,
-0.0356224962,
0.3272910714,
1.017719388,
0.708539784,
-0.8584080935,
0.2416572124,
0.5020904541,
-0.5429786444,
0.3365691602,
-0.9581106901,
0.2738059759,
-0.715243876,
0.1508195251,
-0.8214648366,
-0.3727516234,
0.0437884219,
-0.5046117306,
-0.1197930127,
0.3625299931,
-0.4560930133,
-0.3589027524,
-0.3511561751,
0.416077435,
0.4258931279,
-0.6881207824,
0.2578449249,
0.5841044784,
-0.1930980831,
-0.6265770793,
-0.5195541978,
0.3073211312,
-0.0692847893,
-0.5640798807,
0.2402300388,
-0.1436599791,
-0.3885022402,
0.3747276366,
0.1234068722,
0.1391220242,
0.1595106274,
0.4877816737,
0.3513655066,
-0.3337079585,
0.2105095685,
0.1087674871,
0.1586211175,
0.2129354775,
-0.2812841833,
0.6607207656,
-0.09169963,
-0.4038942754,
-0.0254669581,
0.7468082309,
0.6620871425,
-0.0807322785,
0.7906289697,
0.3627123535,
-0.6006518602,
-0.2373732924,
-0.4173800647,
-0.4503392875,
-0.4558156729,
0.4566566944,
-0.173063457,
-1.2220107317,
0.3151088059,
-0.1046545133,
-0.1039246246,
0.3567646742,
0.5158964396,
0.1547371745,
1.31404531,
0.7404279709,
0.1654528826,
0.1296184808,
-0.117610991,
0.2446144968,
-0.8323224783,
-0.3187464476,
-0.7483387589,
-0.1652879566,
-0.3546152413,
-0.680687964,
0.3566051722,
-0.1693076938,
-0.1608901471,
0.4720209539,
-0.8077676296,
0.4850358963,
0.5484113693,
-0.1993703842,
0.1637376249,
-0.0579112768,
0.0735459924,
0.1123017445,
-0.3742334545,
-0.4290368259,
0.9829538465,
0.2179168761,
1.0954810381,
-0.0070156776,
0.2911385596,
0.2676845789,
0.1825556606,
-0.7718731165,
0.4305830896,
0.2643841803,
-0.7777134776,
-0.239106074,
-0.3885132372,
-1.1058300734,
0.104991138,
-0.1813192666,
-0.6178227067,
0.5756708384,
-0.0856753811,
-0.4910710156,
-0.1130463332,
-0.7084689736,
0.5679839849,
-0.0521745645,
-0.1920582354,
-0.2148141563,
-0.5674276948,
0.4458656609,
-0.2314820588,
0.2639954984,
0.1585437357,
-0.1467839181,
0.581997335,
-0.0608546957,
0.496568352,
-0.199194327,
-0.1644088328,
0.2987705469,
0.0822056532,
0.4646131694,
0.2012624294,
0.116540879,
-0.0127530983,
0.0728989467,
-0.1645257622,
-0.5476825833,
1.1045924425,
-0.8286200762,
-0.6281089783,
-0.5121462345,
-0.6467990875,
-0.146574229,
0.0675216541,
-0.0159289315,
0.2195499688,
-0.3212340474,
0.6835560203,
0.7826269865,
-0.8101776242,
0.0337962881,
0.3919455409,
-0.6369408965,
-0.2353261858,
0.8037564158,
-0.145577997,
0.0654430836,
0.1818154752,
0.1785576195,
-0.6853943467,
-0.2539560795,
-0.3004999459,
0.3505696952,
-0.5935291648,
0.0726775974,
-0.8919860125,
-0.2379339188,
-0.7820501924,
-0.2601791322,
-0.4832013845,
-0.7340411544,
-0.2424909472,
-0.0817903578,
0.4276069105,
1.0597581863,
0.0028813856,
-0.0175367072,
-0.7461379766,
0.2566169798,
-0.0703405365,
0.3583672345,
-0.2237661332,
-0.1158848256,
-0.3123883903,
0.024091322,
-0.1206652448,
-0.5343850851,
0.3215109706,
-0.1852060407,
0.3968932927,
0.2896772623,
0.0601749793,
0.3847296536,
-0.4694848359,
1.0270494223,
-0.1298514754,
-0.9140782952,
0.5758535266,
-0.1783272624,
0.1701435745,
0.2492576241,
0.5057637095,
-0.6064130068,
-0.3960953951,
-0.3820517063,
-0.9174745083,
0.5418893099,
0.1158856824,
0.1959891766,
0.0089811143,
0.4207379818,
0.1561065614,
0.392070204,
-0.4349793792,
-0.1530727744,
-0.4734500945,
0.0840908587,
-0.2580306828,
-0.0272020549,
-0.2550244331,
-0.2492813766,
0.4832462966,
-0.04082077,
0.2210069597,
0.4910270274,
-0.1265661567,
-0.2109189779,
0.2521110773,
0.8438535333,
0.8313270211,
-0.2772531807,
0.2671414614,
-0.1079491824,
-0.5106652975,
0.0242662095,
0.0751366764,
-0.1921151727,
0.0105940616,
-0.2681411803,
0.7271229625,
0.1318248361,
-1.0375105143,
0.5299201012,
-0.121074371,
-0.3894508779,
-0.4113057256,
0.0407621861,
0.1067679226,
0.1454892159,
0.3745026588,
-0.10272903,
0.2961586416,
-0.4941900074,
0.2967532277,
0.6150793433,
-0.3584143221,
-0.2102902085,
1.0789182186,
-0.1263978034,
-0.1172016189,
0.4727361202,
-0.0018476069,
-0.3038013279,
0.4302942157,
0.5438001156,
0.7817971706,
-0.1885276288,
0.2942608595,
0.2506080568,
0.4137310386,
-0.1454952061,
0.4718690515,
0.053122133,
-0.4123947024,
-0.6684303284,
-0.5786375999,
-0.6579822302,
0.2472142577,
-0.3517311215,
0.4619205892,
-0.3875513077,
0.0031686311,
-0.0925309658,
-0.3595456183,
-0.4243857563,
0.0148611162,
0.2533126771,
0.9747895598,
-0.6999561787,
0.5390386581,
0.9233937263,
-0.352543205,
-0.5362693071,
-0.2657453716,
-0.1107159704,
-0.5245291591,
0.7938366532,
0.038934011,
-0.0481662564,
-0.1025275216,
-0.796859026,
-1.2273989916,
0.864649415,
0.1502972841,
-0.2668837309,
-0.0307426732,
0.2746312618,
0.4498419762,
-0.1945074201,
-0.0696880072,
0.2790234685,
0.5751929879,
0.2738628685,
-0.5802654624,
0.3538743258,
-0.2017032802,
0.0342841037,
0.1929089278,
-0.2773684859,
0.9925994277,
0.0137988646,
-0.2674412429,
0.0967951566,
0.8030105829,
0.2289456576,
0.3080876172,
0.4496539831,
0.3458989859,
0.6897296309,
-0.0128861368,
1.1352081299,
-0.36826244,
0.1944540143,
0.6947933435,
-0.4415718019,
0.7219688892,
0.6985304356,
0.2547708154,
0.362765044,
0.3728806078,
-0.1591685712,
0.3623839021,
0.3075051308,
-0.2514837682,
0.1483803689,
-0.4436988235,
-0.51589185,
0.3286083043,
0.5710926652,
-0.274633646,
-0.1133534163,
0.4450058341,
0.0329309739,
0.0070702094,
0.0339668207,
0.4934549034,
0.1327564716,
-0.8923197389,
0.4691667557,
0.0596885793,
0.5405777097,
-0.6165705323,
-0.09240444,
0.0579085276,
0.2086976022,
-0.2049500197,
-0.8610249162,
0.4315077066,
-0.0040644822,
-0.0100020356,
-0.1754945219,
0.5054268241,
-0.4268572927,
-0.3387362361,
0.1815241873,
0.4536215663,
0.38056615,
-0.278791368,
-0.3263014853,
0.2477486432,
-0.3534206748,
-0.3676429391,
0.2737360895,
0.1126570404,
-0.1251958758,
0.4580400288,
0.94203192,
0.2471355051,
-0.0185230114,
0.1487619728,
1.079908967,
-0.8392748237,
-0.3770500124,
-0.5253134966,
0.3164177239,
-0.236721769,
-0.158806175,
1.1287275553,
0.9008758664,
0.6738224626,
-0.3265428543,
0.85695678,
-0.1472024918,
0.4949210584,
-0.3199129999,
0.7602251768,
-0.7175499797,
0.0579614341,
-0.4557965398,
-1.1543930769,
-0.4385556281,
0.4930516183,
-0.0629792586,
-0.1477678865,
0.8362458944,
1.0320739746,
-0.1665741354,
0.2583471835,
0.2874576151,
0.2458379567,
0.5759632587,
0.3006780148,
1.2374448776,
-0.1844082177,
0.3347055614,
-0.1685503721,
-0.2728202641,
-0.1733832359,
-0.7673262954,
-0.8118178248,
-0.7523565292,
-0.22487019,
-0.4517477155,
-0.2927718163,
1.2394071817,
0.4821598232,
-0.8886355162,
-0.1638891846,
-0.0735473037,
-0.0003640819,
0.0895258188,
-0.3041032553,
0.5628951788,
-0.1646948159,
-0.9166391492,
0.8524343371,
0.3849641383,
0.1272653192,
-0.6404985785,
0.0656674281,
-0.1330595315,
0.1381440163,
0.7177653313,
0.3570618033,
-0.4310745895,
-0.6100812554,
0.5825737715,
0.0030793257,
-0.2096392363,
1.0238668919,
-0.8628467917,
0.4037895799,
0.5166737437,
0.8351294994,
0.2528657019,
0.2064394951,
0.6028841138,
-0.699039042,
0.2779402733,
0.3964986503,
0.1856312901,
0.359718293,
-0.5482330918,
0.339743197,
0.0878925547,
-0.8401497602,
-1.1245552301,
-0.0224443134,
-0.9590731859,
-0.5772744417,
1.3322304487,
0.4178243577,
-0.2989273369,
-0.2288794219,
-0.5001505017,
-0.0354392119,
-0.2605118155,
0.7997080088,
0.6921579838,
-0.1321411133,
0.116456829,
-0.7389544249,
0.5896080732,
0.427677989,
-0.7482814789,
0.054526899,
0.6672068834,
0.0163900945,
0.4105787277,
0.187468797,
-0.2242101133,
0.2069661319,
-0.1617832333,
0.0366581753,
-0.0285349786,
-0.3796592951,
-0.3030847013,
0.1945181638,
0.0410286374,
-0.051978644
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13694v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13694v1
|
Data Transformation to Construct a Dataset for Generating Entity-Relationship Model from Natural Language
| 2023-12-21T09:45:13 | 2023-12-21T09:45:13 |
Zhenwen Li, Jian-Guang Lou, Tao Xie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In order to reduce the manual cost of designing ER models, recent approaches
have been proposed to address the task of NL2ERM, i.e., automatically
generating entity-relationship (ER) models from natural language (NL)
utterances such as software requirements. These approaches are typically
rule-based ones, which rely on rigid heuristic rules; these approaches cannot
generalize well to various linguistic ways of describing the same requirement.
Despite having better generalization capability than rule-based approaches,
deep-learning-based models are lacking for NL2ERM due to lacking a large-scale
dataset. To address this issue, in this paper, we report our insight that there
exists a high similarity between the task of NL2ERM and the increasingly
popular task of text-to-SQL, and propose a data transformation algorithm that
transforms the existing data of text-to-SQL into the data of NL2ERM. We apply
our data transformation algorithm on Spider, one of the most popular
text-to-SQL datasets, and we also collect some data entries with different NL
types, to obtain a large-scale NL2ERM dataset. Because NL2ERM can be seen as a
special information extraction (IE) task, we train two state-of-the-art IE
models on our dataset. The experimental results show that both the two models
achieve high performance and outperform existing baselines.
|
[
-0.3467146456,
-0.8246219754,
0.5079390407,
-0.0812115073,
-0.2103156745,
-0.3255149722,
-0.1309206337,
-0.7546012402,
0.1922651529,
1.0368847847,
-0.4778224826,
-0.4275892675,
-0.3492122889,
0.3119885921,
-0.7110218406,
1.0748200417,
-0.0483419187,
-0.1219049767,
-0.0992732421,
0.0977295041,
-0.5429278016,
-0.3434065282,
-0.4537600577,
-0.2192193866,
0.3168868423,
0.3669016063,
0.5880019665,
0.7546058297,
0.7944096923,
0.1213903576,
0.1254848987,
0.403473556,
-0.4106092751,
0.1368299723,
-0.4075356722,
-0.5832679272,
-0.4925890565,
-0.1159877181,
0.5297080278,
0.7795034647,
-0.2219892889,
0.4278292656,
0.072724849,
0.9438295364,
-0.2733762562,
0.272885859,
-0.9639974236,
0.1234884411,
-0.0981392339,
-0.1590045542,
-0.6028135419,
-0.2570317984,
0.393337667,
-0.5580521822,
0.3880883455,
0.3128820956,
1.2033517361,
0.2407376468,
-0.7289752364,
-0.4560925961,
-1.16261971,
0.462374568,
-0.6030748487,
0.427910924,
0.0847222358,
0.1870867312,
-0.514778614,
-0.618689537,
-0.6084535718,
0.024935618,
-0.1990540475,
-0.2160690129,
-0.2061075419,
-0.1707165986,
0.0957941338,
0.2582432926,
-0.8206867576,
0.1492638886,
-0.2812580168,
0.3189566135,
0.6762530208,
0.3900916874,
0.2166890353,
-0.2457137853,
-0.4953896701,
-0.0719606429,
-0.8018645048,
-0.3052850962,
0.02646688,
0.7037656307,
0.1364548504,
0.8306081295,
-0.0324360617,
0.5317152739,
0.0497480445,
0.2179444581,
0.1624368727,
-0.3748710752,
-0.3360445201,
0.0893445909,
0.6136178374,
0.4055450857,
0.4596807659,
-0.6112847328,
-0.1490001827,
0.0827651247,
0.3480558395,
-0.8602785468,
-0.1707566381,
0.141538918,
-0.5159440637,
-0.1481083632,
0.0266083442,
-1.0339422226,
-0.3658587933,
-0.6950158477,
0.3071284592,
-0.3167394698,
-0.5682422519,
0.0156350806,
0.0950812176,
0.4120364189,
0.0727702007,
-0.6432976723,
0.6754705906,
0.7024419904,
0.7052817345,
-0.4941116869,
-0.0268680267,
-0.3624958992,
0.479896903,
-0.4915919006,
0.7060602307,
-0.3368066549,
-0.0649839267,
-0.0553169139,
0.0227567516,
-0.0463853218,
-0.6817806363,
0.3176760972,
-0.6654676795,
0.4248161912,
0.0062850406,
-0.8423572183,
-0.174669981,
0.2683069408,
-0.8630120754,
1.1609413624,
0.1018914431,
-0.7357153296,
0.5339159369,
-0.7720235586,
-0.5791321993,
0.0748521835,
0.0130655551,
-0.5097085238,
0.0989314392,
0.1673815548,
0.4576268792,
-0.9339839816,
0.3971956372,
-0.2469082177,
-0.1454067379,
0.0652318373,
0.0102943424,
0.5389837623,
0.0461439639,
-0.4063127935,
-0.4156354964,
-0.9234796166,
-0.0002733027,
0.5058537126,
-0.2775936127,
-0.5192446113,
0.3272038996,
0.0687840059,
0.3453083634,
0.1422385722,
-0.2277788669,
0.1506446153,
-0.8878991604,
0.1866926551,
0.3802343607,
0.2184268534,
0.8062497377,
-0.0101159774,
0.1818759292,
-0.0108723622,
-0.2231145501,
0.1640899181,
-0.2833070755,
-0.957526803,
0.0947500542,
0.3535908461,
0.7407595515,
-0.5689893365,
0.7415933609,
-0.6666699648,
-0.4079580605,
-0.3658827841,
0.2283747494,
-0.0231852289,
0.5800208449,
0.7364037037,
-0.2513948679,
-0.8535158038,
-0.9206402898,
-0.3790599704,
-0.1764586121,
-0.1844936311,
0.2344670445,
0.563221693,
-0.3712022007,
1.1490709782,
-0.6145704985,
-0.6430515647,
-0.2356005013,
0.0180159267,
0.2875339687,
0.3752506375,
0.407843262,
-0.7978881598,
-0.4013359845,
-0.0001698325,
-0.895491004,
0.1613348722,
-0.233089909,
-0.1689419895,
0.3417929709,
0.3362126648,
-0.6371468306,
0.4421990812,
0.2684444785,
-0.3493562043,
0.3279024065,
-0.0262545701,
-0.0840615705,
-1.5600121021,
0.1871677935,
0.3732375205,
-0.1545131505,
-0.7898780704,
0.0160253253,
-0.1911770254,
-0.2242926061,
-0.0658051521,
0.5066561103,
-0.7625157237,
-0.2893410921,
-0.1928207576,
0.0451390222,
0.0263023991,
0.39792642,
0.2190118134,
0.4358565807,
0.4353802204,
-0.835229516,
0.3039065599,
0.432222873,
-0.0978859439,
0.5170312524,
-0.5505455732,
0.3402403891,
-0.0551548451,
0.0448901169,
-0.5722388625,
-0.1423644423,
0.1192293987,
-0.2532196939,
0.3117094338,
-0.4116443396,
-0.8012929559,
-0.186855495,
0.1852509677,
-0.1795212775,
0.6272062063,
-0.5748058558,
0.7998719811,
0.5385096669,
-0.3440674841,
-0.1739507318,
-0.8102735877,
0.5854632854,
-0.3385213912,
-0.5802795291,
0.5494292378,
0.4050373733,
-0.2022811919,
0.3119300008,
0.0014424631,
-0.2619282305,
-0.0683572441,
0.1950352043,
0.5300502777,
-0.2392710298,
0.4028308094,
0.0238939356,
-0.1341797411,
0.276075691,
-0.3673591018,
0.47570467,
0.3125426769,
0.1193318516,
-0.3300745785,
0.6525928378,
0.2968398929,
-0.2916480899,
0.9162287712,
0.4054556489,
-0.6664152145,
-0.4558874369,
-0.3191259205,
-0.5205099583,
-0.3678995073,
0.5439817309,
-0.4318221509,
-0.5336122513,
0.0964069963,
-0.4568537176,
0.3304428756,
0.5515615344,
0.3407891095,
-0.2237131894,
1.0763175488,
0.8093943,
0.0498613529,
0.3160521686,
-0.2585332692,
0.2909393013,
-0.5905618668,
-0.2861453593,
-0.7596956491,
-0.1347319037,
-0.6040359139,
-0.1648465991,
0.0900195539,
-0.0042124186,
-0.2671247423,
0.8508300781,
-0.5316033959,
0.2012192011,
0.0712388903,
0.0095458571,
0.1887157857,
0.5407716632,
0.1380772293,
-0.1341914684,
-0.4389297068,
-0.686758697,
1.13446486,
0.235878095,
0.6561682224,
0.4249659777,
0.7513011694,
0.3007256687,
0.0546792932,
-0.6633507609,
0.6643175483,
-0.3531451523,
-0.6226333976,
-0.3808869421,
-0.7918121815,
-1.150048852,
-0.1588457078,
-0.5173787475,
-0.6476672292,
0.2216877639,
0.0874145031,
0.3862334192,
0.2668132782,
-0.7615939379,
0.4605588913,
-0.032815896,
-0.3100983202,
-0.1207000762,
-0.5723887086,
0.1780453026,
-0.1366367489,
0.1194853857,
-0.1344759762,
-0.07706929,
0.8131216764,
-0.355149895,
0.5148544312,
-0.2648641169,
-0.1602859795,
0.1774173081,
0.2736542821,
0.9908382297,
0.0264500547,
-0.3674730361,
0.0177573599,
-0.3422944248,
-0.2447175533,
-0.5402118564,
0.4265280366,
-0.491163969,
-0.374904424,
-0.2920635641,
-0.3133559823,
-0.3117902279,
0.1498796195,
0.0490148254,
0.256108731,
-0.2682902813,
0.0741977841,
0.6669381857,
0.0863297135,
0.3277098238,
0.5511060357,
-0.1015084684,
-0.1843247414,
0.7855433226,
0.1747714132,
0.0485545322,
0.4579867423,
-0.2744153142,
-0.5550122857,
-0.3694029748,
-0.56531775,
0.1748756766,
-0.3362834454,
-0.2773491144,
-0.6234799027,
-0.1704712808,
-0.4322707653,
0.1787039936,
-0.3890642226,
-0.3043192923,
-0.6012585163,
0.0616844669,
0.5042191744,
0.6651600599,
0.3319270611,
-0.2319464684,
-0.7736362219,
0.3988339901,
0.2179231197,
0.2644737363,
-0.1848815233,
-0.4551309347,
-0.1861050576,
0.0278252289,
-0.0038520233,
-1.1281315088,
0.5533878803,
0.5076951981,
0.3041583598,
-0.0572566614,
0.0933839828,
0.6041859388,
-0.6595739722,
0.5261709094,
0.2571614087,
-0.7198618054,
0.6302229762,
-0.0285757687,
-0.2525504231,
0.4450442791,
0.3569612503,
-0.2942527533,
-0.0097107748,
-0.5516422987,
-1.0302888155,
0.7063672543,
0.4052267969,
0.088309966,
0.220432356,
0.6153789163,
0.1783085763,
0.1039149761,
-0.6033042073,
-0.2636777163,
0.1320086867,
-0.4763496518,
-0.056918323,
-0.0218362138,
0.2536358237,
-0.0118753482,
0.685774982,
-0.235927552,
0.4562909603,
0.2098258436,
-0.3961830139,
0.0660503358,
0.4212520421,
-0.0028924989,
0.4159144163,
-0.1503367275,
0.1718371361,
0.33225739,
-0.2969994545,
0.1654093862,
0.3628521264,
-0.2696888745,
0.1220248342,
0.0938954279,
0.6629556417,
-0.2387331873,
-0.4768500626,
0.3071473539,
0.0320074074,
-0.1592829078,
-0.3736320734,
0.1131003574,
0.29845649,
0.035457693,
0.4662637115,
-0.040874172,
0.4422885478,
-0.6505892873,
0.3409416676,
0.1080373973,
-0.3857754469,
-0.230541274,
0.6003744006,
0.167634964,
-0.4808869958,
0.7213923335,
-0.2255982161,
-0.1499162018,
0.5865287781,
0.7907382846,
0.7973256111,
0.0473663695,
0.0583202615,
0.4087022245,
0.3286623955,
-0.1058664173,
0.3262915313,
0.3225444257,
-0.6736367345,
-0.423579365,
-0.4859602749,
-0.1564940959,
0.1441132575,
-0.8247309923,
0.5181117654,
-0.2330036312,
-0.076291889,
0.1892843246,
-0.004157084,
-0.9431815147,
0.2873089314,
-0.0514320545,
0.7675485015,
-0.7683215737,
0.8027768135,
0.7560704947,
-0.4453199804,
-0.7699320912,
-0.0158865228,
-0.2431485504,
-0.4224031568,
0.4512544572,
0.1386787891,
0.2832235098,
0.1763798594,
-0.3180270493,
-0.6650385857,
1.0188153982,
0.5836621523,
-0.8777320981,
-0.5264273882,
0.6093444824,
0.6195549965,
-0.6816706061,
-0.0495226979,
0.6407949328,
0.2499407083,
-0.2490545511,
-0.67973876,
0.1554012001,
-0.3312811852,
0.2032383531,
0.6992319226,
-0.1836862117,
0.5913901925,
-0.1568248123,
-0.376221478,
-0.2617531121,
0.5309435129,
0.0493436754,
0.2575417757,
0.6708322763,
0.5504758358,
0.6273981929,
-0.0137145454,
0.5567752123,
-0.120175615,
0.512363553,
1.4501062632,
-0.8674086332,
1.0569514036,
0.5383243561,
-0.177215606,
0.6842575669,
0.4589926004,
-0.4735065103,
0.282523036,
0.1027233973,
0.0092487084,
-0.2078951746,
-0.0656764582,
-0.2441744208,
0.4509707093,
0.4283669889,
-0.6224504709,
-0.2864659131,
-0.2350239903,
-0.1461839527,
0.2095244378,
-0.1147212833,
1.3762402534,
-0.0077860695,
-0.433339119,
0.3329133093,
0.0307056978,
0.4332504869,
-0.3230397105,
-0.364595145,
0.0300105959,
0.033334408,
-0.2501035929,
-0.7883419394,
0.4842011631,
0.3187741041,
-0.5051752925,
0.0526067317,
0.9513114691,
-0.4850773513,
-0.4347346723,
0.4584961832,
0.4654774368,
0.2602793276,
-0.0506694317,
-0.7678863406,
-0.5677515268,
0.0071498025,
-0.2227286547,
0.2269191146,
0.3654618263,
0.0327483825,
0.4629196525,
0.6992856264,
0.1968788207,
-0.0182739161,
-0.2051981986,
0.5656477809,
-0.6951336265,
-0.4229393601,
-0.7311860919,
0.3934929967,
-0.3570772707,
-0.1041848212,
0.3935787082,
0.9404688478,
0.4163961112,
0.0305242687,
0.7050468922,
-0.2350881547,
0.7250198722,
-0.6400458813,
0.5048801303,
-0.5527935028,
0.3131820261,
-0.2033455968,
-1.2443019152,
-0.1214077622,
0.195945397,
0.0718785599,
-0.2098500878,
0.6779789329,
0.9589398503,
0.0769319385,
0.0276580881,
-0.0819277614,
0.1142711416,
0.354611516,
0.6666538119,
0.3338670731,
-0.6105508208,
0.8114898205,
0.0446355641,
0.0532710366,
-0.2003855556,
-0.8339178562,
-0.8058823347,
-0.8207147121,
-0.3960817754,
-0.4978459477,
0.0525319688,
1.0875394344,
0.7469583154,
-0.7528439164,
-0.0042310068,
-0.6515750289,
-0.0921635404,
-0.141016528,
-0.2952704728,
0.4539641738,
-0.2398103774,
-0.6255281568,
0.3616411388,
0.1068131477,
0.2631195486,
-0.1927904338,
-0.0605705492,
-0.2418977618,
0.151729241,
0.4660239816,
0.0607082359,
-0.4033197165,
-0.1518336385,
0.0990883559,
-0.2682386339,
0.234142378,
0.5498010516,
-0.7676221132,
0.1400714964,
0.4098598659,
0.7334970832,
0.742349565,
-0.2942903936,
0.6659903526,
-0.732722342,
-0.1426309347,
0.2055813968,
0.2135488242,
0.2830242515,
-0.5462786555,
0.8815951347,
0.0763882697,
-0.3988628685,
-1.0258976221,
0.2800581157,
-0.9292351604,
-0.1432246566,
1.2438341379,
0.0817631632,
-0.1981483251,
-0.257432729,
-0.0949084014,
0.4437672794,
-0.2826329768,
0.6746506095,
0.3118607402,
-0.0221447721,
-0.0626445189,
-0.3278125823,
0.4096820354,
0.2410290092,
-1.2709468603,
0.2069649249,
0.1914583743,
0.5031465888,
0.1131945699,
-0.008164282,
-0.1232590005,
0.1745628417,
-0.0353695117,
0.5044977069,
0.1708423793,
-0.3227354288,
-0.1336002499,
0.3628060222,
0.0156075107,
0.1158161312
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13671v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13671v1
|
Text2Analysis: A Benchmark of Table Question Answering with Advanced Data Analysis and Unclear Queries
| 2023-12-21T08:50:41 | 2023-12-21T08:50:41 |
Xinyi He, Mengyu Zhou, Xinrun Xu, Xiaojun Ma, Rui Ding, Lun Du, Yan Gao, Ran Jia, Xu Chen, Shi Han, Zejian Yuan, Dongmei Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Tabular data analysis is crucial in various fields, and large language models
show promise in this area. However, current research mostly focuses on
rudimentary tasks like Text2SQL and TableQA, neglecting advanced analysis like
forecasting and chart generation. To address this gap, we developed the
Text2Analysis benchmark, incorporating advanced analysis tasks that go beyond
the SQL-compatible operations and require more in-depth analysis. We also
develop five innovative and effective annotation methods, harnessing the
capabilities of large language models to enhance data quality and quantity.
Additionally, we include unclear queries that resemble real-world user
questions to test how well models can understand and tackle such challenges.
Finally, we collect 2249 query-result pairs with 347 tables. We evaluate five
state-of-the-art models using three different metrics and the results show that
our benchmark presents introduces considerable challenge in the field of
tabular data analysis, paving the way for more advanced research opportunities.
|
[
-0.1431492716,
-1.2002811432,
0.5548301339,
-0.0123456726,
-0.1446462721,
0.0570455678,
0.2119346261,
-0.8431203365,
-0.3155663311,
0.6648754478,
-0.5114443898,
-0.51347965,
-0.3671982586,
0.081627965,
-0.6653192043,
1.0730184317,
-0.1493123472,
0.1491223425,
-0.5100304484,
-0.1280807704,
-0.5886117816,
-0.3168331385,
-0.5858983397,
0.0190125033,
0.2675907612,
0.7365459204,
0.7608534694,
0.56305933,
0.793068409,
0.1351844668,
0.0363684334,
0.1475476474,
-0.4739662409,
0.4597572684,
0.056814719,
-0.616744101,
-0.7452974319,
-0.1681554317,
0.4707966745,
0.8398815989,
-0.1583572626,
0.4437978864,
-0.0360818654,
0.874876976,
-0.4489451647,
0.2430688292,
-0.8572534919,
0.1521184593,
-0.3670680523,
0.2731438577,
-0.3856005967,
-0.6996963024,
0.306735009,
-0.5942863226,
0.1461755335,
0.2758893073,
0.6906355023,
0.1508649737,
-0.5247167349,
-0.2829214931,
-0.576982677,
0.4514498413,
-0.6066794395,
0.4124761224,
0.5241587162,
0.783362329,
-0.0623735562,
-1.1716080904,
-0.6100024581,
0.025368534,
-0.3021110296,
0.1464014202,
-0.4098537564,
-0.2973367572,
0.2364994437,
0.0174145028,
-1.002004981,
0.0969670787,
-0.402982384,
-0.0037164227,
0.535425663,
0.4295187593,
0.3096357882,
-0.0068075946,
-0.3830673695,
0.0406514369,
-0.4972597957,
0.1388043016,
0.124727428,
0.0258910693,
-0.0202254131,
0.4625073075,
-0.4470899403,
0.6934992075,
-0.7199596167,
0.4824257493,
0.068687506,
-0.2953146994,
-0.0317531936,
-0.3561677039,
0.7513455749,
0.5472471118,
0.3430454135,
-0.4549022019,
-0.1196341664,
-0.0675554946,
0.0907688588,
-0.7829137444,
-0.4445382953,
0.4425777793,
-0.2720059156,
0.0141716907,
0.0097328518,
-1.538300395,
-0.7155690193,
-0.0057937163,
0.2656678855,
-0.0532116778,
-0.326944381,
-0.3096940815,
-0.3227536082,
0.2563996911,
0.245566681,
-0.8947947025,
0.8277286887,
0.7621757984,
0.6557655931,
-0.4875061512,
-0.0215572584,
-0.4699804187,
0.0014671721,
-0.5834234953,
1.21951437,
-0.6255967021,
-0.2966429889,
0.1437493712,
-0.2314832211,
0.0388115458,
-0.6467989087,
0.7011319995,
-0.5653392076,
0.2489414215,
-0.7185909748,
-0.5099452138,
-0.3488895297,
0.3083413541,
-0.8313845992,
1.4930677414,
0.2115557492,
-0.5777885914,
0.5215632915,
-0.4666933715,
-0.1960957497,
0.1236927286,
-0.3205157518,
-0.5603595376,
0.0937769786,
0.3054654598,
0.28213346,
-0.8885213733,
0.3171123564,
-0.3256696463,
-0.3243940771,
0.5809432268,
-0.2400892824,
0.1757074147,
0.2409082651,
-0.3625843525,
0.0248197131,
-0.7110194564,
0.4529333115,
0.1289876401,
0.0791967586,
-0.0156833306,
0.3576741815,
0.3751229048,
0.0088262903,
0.0675563142,
-0.2951402366,
0.1182735339,
-0.2865333855,
0.482216835,
0.0246772598,
0.0736919343,
0.1360592097,
-0.0426381528,
0.5641442537,
-0.2631703019,
-0.2391549349,
0.0881012827,
-0.5008891225,
-0.5322673917,
0.1897866726,
0.4602812827,
0.677051723,
-0.6002667546,
-0.1332553774,
-0.3625108302,
-0.7509548664,
-0.4012543261,
-0.2011309266,
0.4344510734,
0.5272673965,
0.6015321016,
-0.1696998328,
-0.5677710176,
-1.0827012062,
-0.8697248697,
-0.135171473,
-0.065128088,
0.1488801837,
0.6155313253,
0.2544850707,
0.9642215371,
-0.7271735668,
-0.0688544512,
-0.5155249834,
0.3697295189,
0.1053122431,
0.4254418314,
0.4236499965,
-0.8900629282,
-0.5497755408,
0.034532018,
-0.7460568547,
-0.1156829894,
0.1814402789,
-0.0629719198,
0.2673405707,
0.6139890552,
-0.3517456055,
0.3994557858,
0.2949877083,
-0.5719049573,
0.3397299349,
-0.0759816095,
0.2374377549,
-0.6618872285,
0.4849544764,
-0.1892893016,
-0.0184175,
-1.0678893328,
-0.0384600572,
0.34690696,
-0.4432032108,
0.0077855117,
0.6763288975,
-0.4785332978,
-0.3883468211,
-0.1836876571,
0.298396796,
0.1535295248,
0.2031550407,
0.0721350163,
0.8654746413,
0.1111140326,
-0.2420763969,
0.0104914876,
0.3947488666,
-0.4550824463,
0.3490875959,
-0.9268433452,
0.3193791807,
-0.1921734661,
0.1913351566,
-1.7357158661,
-0.3604553938,
0.1111513078,
-0.5775645971,
0.1446980983,
0.132003665,
-0.4625344276,
-0.3845131099,
-0.2043414116,
0.3012848794,
0.4257479906,
-0.1492393762,
0.5460375547,
0.5775476694,
-0.4645313621,
-0.5074210763,
-0.8965551853,
0.2460040003,
-0.2976307869,
-0.4055582583,
0.1931413561,
0.1499560028,
-0.5087508559,
0.0375275873,
-0.3897047937,
-0.7307419181,
0.1159231663,
-0.012782352,
0.1901466846,
-0.0944357067,
0.020747019,
0.1556435674,
-0.1488851607,
0.3377248943,
0.1191113964,
0.514667809,
0.0809560195,
0.1449333429,
-0.5973694324,
0.257185787,
0.3566520512,
-0.4195821583,
0.4806359112,
0.5508984327,
-0.629113555,
-0.0976340175,
-0.6370850205,
-0.0642413571,
-0.4201432765,
0.8098455071,
-0.4114260077,
-0.4000665843,
0.6504184604,
0.2036495209,
0.2856836319,
0.6909077764,
0.2453723699,
-0.1981866509,
0.8646922708,
0.2797446251,
0.330303371,
-0.001268064,
-0.051225163,
-0.072173357,
-0.5073215961,
-0.578469038,
-1.0901726484,
-0.1730905771,
-0.5510692596,
-0.3739006817,
0.3801380992,
0.0239982475,
-0.0985936671,
0.1315543205,
-0.4731225371,
0.478985101,
0.4035330117,
-0.0579866059,
0.2545884848,
-0.0792241171,
0.3397145271,
-0.3783104718,
-0.3680595756,
-0.4930482209,
1.1644588709,
0.2099273652,
0.3905146718,
0.1315588504,
0.0791169927,
0.4065769315,
0.1462398171,
-0.4210611582,
0.5123423934,
-0.1397537589,
-0.9450649023,
-0.3487992585,
-0.4791644216,
-0.9353997707,
0.4550246894,
-0.369173646,
-0.9485836625,
0.0021997308,
0.2165952772,
-0.1347519904,
-0.0635332689,
-0.8920582533,
1.3344961405,
-0.0924588442,
-0.5143489838,
0.0934062451,
-0.5865243673,
0.3080885708,
-0.030601196,
0.4984887838,
-0.3388892412,
-0.3578606546,
1.0584135056,
-0.1039773524,
0.4316468239,
-0.4673210382,
0.0258731712,
0.3986998498,
0.2653591037,
0.6519054174,
0.1094547287,
-0.4844671786,
-0.1571315676,
0.4104150236,
-0.3671956658,
-0.6458077431,
0.419911027,
-0.3304770887,
-0.2643060684,
-0.3011294603,
-0.5312492847,
-0.6637998223,
0.1044207588,
0.1038474292,
0.5228360891,
-0.1563733071,
0.3415512145,
0.3833566606,
-0.0051719197,
0.4714607,
0.4805606604,
-0.092260398,
-0.4733849466,
0.6316748261,
0.3882998526,
-0.0394387357,
0.5652897358,
0.0384489112,
-0.645686388,
-0.90284729,
-0.5473889112,
-0.3289968371,
-0.4384331107,
-0.2432971448,
-0.7196568847,
0.148573339,
-0.2484802902,
0.3120615184,
-0.1098829955,
-0.7007652521,
-0.026625203,
-0.1210795343,
0.3534335494,
0.6143457294,
0.5776161551,
0.3053816855,
-0.790817678,
0.4710716307,
0.3676990569,
0.4284980595,
0.0565360077,
-0.3508700728,
-0.0566545911,
-0.2571079433,
-0.2636862397,
-1.3049781322,
0.1033201143,
0.2425698489,
0.528015554,
0.0543582588,
0.097723864,
0.5655628443,
-0.5319076777,
0.8206577301,
-0.0971571282,
-0.9256762266,
0.3369309306,
-0.350297451,
0.2401443273,
1.0306690931,
0.2551179826,
-0.5250225663,
-0.2089566588,
-0.2505430281,
-1.1181964874,
0.7038978338,
0.3888087869,
-0.128154248,
0.3758751154,
0.6536927223,
0.37431252,
0.2521123588,
-0.8222512007,
-0.1604299694,
0.0466564409,
-0.4086741507,
0.0366830193,
-0.5090699792,
0.1494660228,
-0.1130414456,
0.3892386556,
0.0066067711,
0.1514871716,
0.1030890867,
-0.0222755317,
-0.0368650369,
0.4366480112,
0.331766963,
0.9843505025,
-0.2398357689,
0.0582448617,
0.5516441464,
-0.6285917163,
-0.2338667214,
0.56583184,
-0.0614102706,
-0.1220109239,
0.4032158852,
0.5911223888,
0.0285675675,
-0.9567721486,
0.2674949169,
-0.1896027476,
-0.1285635084,
-0.1983019561,
0.135824725,
0.198806569,
0.0423651859,
0.6883647442,
-0.6423725486,
0.7028683424,
-0.6251313686,
0.2581257224,
0.4339792132,
-0.7522099018,
-0.1991505325,
0.9942552447,
0.084868677,
-0.1245181486,
0.5667865276,
0.0691722035,
-0.2469501048,
0.8299962878,
0.3095430136,
0.4798232615,
0.0326511785,
0.1617119312,
0.3935706913,
0.5762290955,
0.1335523725,
0.8054258823,
0.1213351414,
-0.1537392735,
-0.1054503992,
-0.3962678909,
-0.7806131244,
0.1441117525,
-0.8946301341,
-0.007270189,
-0.0296019148,
-0.0822808146,
0.3498817682,
0.3217600286,
-0.5193532109,
0.5128321052,
-0.4061992764,
0.8537673354,
-0.667316258,
0.5573321581,
0.6480025649,
-0.0763523504,
-0.6387785673,
-0.1540103257,
0.0038832026,
-0.7183340192,
0.1534572095,
0.3569375873,
0.4483330548,
-0.0198634546,
-0.4433585405,
-0.7549783587,
0.9573751688,
0.1000998765,
-0.6143509746,
-0.0162694082,
0.5078525543,
0.6699697375,
-0.0256967843,
0.5966295004,
1.2970032692,
0.7140668035,
-0.1811953634,
-0.6107614636,
0.2593159676,
-0.3250410259,
-0.2448748797,
0.5497871637,
-0.3404461145,
0.6355886459,
-0.0348427035,
-0.1135309488,
0.2534448504,
0.7258953452,
-0.0065392479,
0.8479600549,
0.3468517959,
0.3423641026,
0.6868489385,
-0.5812269449,
0.7123497128,
0.0833037123,
0.2226145267,
1.3308130503,
-0.380161047,
1.1821101904,
0.3207367361,
-0.4134931564,
0.3219799101,
0.5310281515,
-0.2541829944,
0.3058270216,
0.1851820052,
0.2532244623,
0.0594831146,
-0.0114510637,
-0.5359008312,
0.5617855787,
0.4648044109,
-0.046112489,
-0.3138240874,
-0.416013211,
0.0975928754,
0.3540595174,
-0.0199555103,
1.0746104717,
-0.2577632666,
-0.7182210088,
0.3143908381,
-0.1963047683,
-0.0515971482,
-0.5650501847,
-0.0606079437,
-0.4943888783,
-0.1394941956,
-0.2157462835,
-0.9025433064,
0.3557181954,
0.2274940014,
0.2422652394,
0.1787102371,
0.3981208503,
-0.4583798051,
-0.2739297152,
-0.0972330421,
0.7751147747,
0.2525394261,
-0.1883902401,
-0.498812288,
0.0511602908,
-0.1124821231,
-0.3634383678,
0.0170565322,
0.4798930287,
0.0039670262,
0.4258112907,
0.3240696192,
-0.2307867408,
-0.1895556301,
-0.1531037986,
0.672629714,
-0.855396688,
-0.4460144341,
-0.7961933017,
0.7206695676,
-0.378777355,
-0.5603272915,
0.6497789621,
0.9890539646,
0.2169368118,
0.163355574,
0.6077107191,
0.0586707853,
0.82349962,
-0.5694442391,
0.861317277,
-0.6674737334,
0.0677197278,
-0.4689914882,
-1.0644440651,
-0.4683094323,
-0.0239186678,
-0.4239156246,
-0.0841540769,
0.840444684,
0.4144185781,
0.3410662413,
0.3189973533,
0.0400932431,
0.1916346699,
0.2936446071,
0.1828055829,
0.8112439513,
-0.6407572627,
1.0468826294,
0.0223294608,
-0.1781937182,
-0.0461909026,
-0.5440135598,
-0.796533525,
-0.5533302426,
-0.0861229375,
-0.172893092,
0.2425298393,
0.3096698523,
0.3622687757,
-0.9293525815,
-0.2727349401,
-0.3143577278,
-0.1411845088,
-0.2161800265,
-0.2561025321,
0.82477355,
-0.2673768103,
-0.6700207591,
0.1542219967,
-0.00080593,
0.1261793375,
0.1485166103,
0.5384556055,
0.0295838844,
0.069723621,
0.3063982725,
0.1930627525,
-0.3369233012,
-0.0066338875,
0.1831908524,
0.006579922,
0.0757963359,
0.8004414439,
-0.4791710079,
0.4505925775,
0.6420145035,
0.8120920062,
0.7064070106,
0.2553918064,
0.4350959063,
-0.4902697802,
-0.0643015876,
0.3675563335,
0.0774118975,
0.2587704062,
-0.2087068707,
0.6816886067,
-0.2197859436,
-0.5255694985,
-1.1766295433,
0.0111044673,
-0.8309363127,
-0.4307914376,
0.9473262429,
0.0649558455,
-0.0255013406,
-0.2882254422,
-0.2941862345,
0.203692466,
-0.3906830251,
0.7764107585,
0.5675236583,
-0.2820604742,
-0.077628538,
-1.0884073973,
0.7223101258,
0.6653710604,
-1.5610440969,
0.4577105641,
0.4666982293,
-0.0466926917,
-0.2807229459,
0.5504215956,
-0.0937757269,
0.4915278256,
0.1871774793,
-0.1772962064,
0.1294972897,
-0.4013427794,
-0.0694480166,
0.6038503051,
0.1744076014,
-0.0369581692
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13655v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13655v1
|
Compositional Zero-Shot Learning for Attribute-Based Object Reference in Human-Robot Interaction
| 2023-12-21T08:29:41 | 2023-12-21T08:29:41 |
Peng Gao, Ahmed Jaafar, Brian Reily, Christopher Reardon, Hao Zhang
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Language-enabled robots have been widely studied over the past years to
enable natural human-robot interaction and teaming in various real-world
applications. Language-enabled robots must be able to comprehend referring
expressions to identify a particular object from visual perception using a set
of referring attributes extracted from natural language. However, visual
observations of an object may not be available when it is referred to, and the
number of objects and attributes may also be unbounded in open worlds. To
address the challenges, we implement an attribute-based compositional zero-shot
learning method that uses a list of attributes to perform referring expression
comprehension in open worlds. We evaluate the approach on two datasets
including the MIT-States and the Clothing 16K. The preliminary experimental
results show that our implemented approach allows a robot to correctly identify
the objects referred to by human commands.
|
[
0.0057080821,
-0.7028955221,
0.5811079144,
-0.1347006559,
-0.1695658267,
0.216616407,
-0.2829199731,
-0.7772642374,
-0.0111475522,
0.5104071498,
-0.7471758127,
-0.4760358334,
-0.0483156182,
0.1330825984,
0.0068801278,
0.8335689902,
0.0010612715,
-0.4325488806,
-0.546713531,
-0.5132764578,
-0.4390653968,
-0.3105766475,
-0.2478118092,
-0.487670809,
0.6737782359,
0.5409619212,
0.7788858414,
0.7058936357,
0.5774062276,
0.3166737258,
0.342449218,
0.318453759,
-0.317483902,
0.2505220175,
-0.5586200356,
-0.4303800762,
-0.3410844207,
0.0266181938,
0.5024235845,
0.7030675411,
0.1398561746,
0.3197709322,
-0.1672979146,
0.480096966,
-1.2614364624,
0.4230453074,
-0.5100227594,
0.3955773711,
0.0357920453,
-0.0048289718,
-0.3904471695,
0.4470739067,
0.0865026042,
-0.986076355,
0.1834642887,
0.0747866631,
0.9278790355,
0.3082804978,
-0.3072121441,
0.0531755202,
-0.9615882635,
1.1342375278,
-0.4346022904,
0.5311070085,
0.4367221296,
0.2614750564,
0.167665109,
-0.2144724876,
-0.9883822203,
-0.4757806361,
-0.1661072075,
0.4013838172,
-0.0379785895,
-0.0561456233,
0.0443808511,
0.1293194145,
-0.5532485247,
0.1705948412,
-0.3702615798,
-0.1860818714,
0.7047808766,
0.1846244633,
0.5160976052,
-0.2974037528,
-0.6238329411,
-0.3286636472,
-0.5680536628,
-0.1734932661,
0.2479033172,
0.5277131796,
-0.2063408345,
0.6449552774,
-0.5682695508,
0.9438827038,
-0.1090461984,
-0.1243835837,
0.3404801488,
-0.1409734637,
-0.1635081023,
-0.2092805356,
0.6841679215,
0.3402329981,
0.2838016748,
-0.726639986,
-0.0254023541,
0.0398043655,
0.4515120387,
-0.5747048259,
-0.1323067099,
0.1742255092,
0.0457154624,
-0.1796896756,
0.5720921755,
-0.3637520671,
-0.2882183194,
-0.3639718592,
0.8239038587,
-0.2436866313,
-0.2171953917,
0.1943953484,
-0.0259424075,
0.6024426818,
0.3177949488,
-0.5122992396,
0.1802805215,
0.4028665125,
0.8230947852,
-0.0127079096,
-0.4663560688,
-0.5048969388,
0.7069793344,
-0.3891738057,
0.8163512349,
-0.6351821423,
-0.1155732051,
-0.0851409808,
0.0518880747,
-0.0083532734,
-0.7352957129,
0.2702490985,
-0.2356373817,
0.3282029033,
0.2108125538,
-0.2829810083,
-0.2976177335,
0.3539681137,
-0.6755952835,
0.9065852165,
0.4485414326,
-0.2529100776,
0.2297040671,
-0.9290066361,
-0.538176477,
0.3045899868,
-0.0263696648,
-0.4960314035,
-0.0421168841,
0.0985028073,
0.7568414807,
-0.0414612778,
-0.3087202311,
-0.509749949,
-0.1807639152,
0.404017508,
0.1631222218,
0.4798310995,
0.2144148052,
0.0690382645,
0.2828974128,
-0.7964930534,
0.0710557252,
0.3391383886,
0.2035909593,
-0.2128580809,
0.0508520901,
-0.379702419,
0.1788636446,
0.3069397211,
-0.8166837692,
-0.1217510328,
-0.3991781175,
0.0727264956,
0.5632957816,
0.0830020756,
0.830994308,
-0.4152044654,
0.5565893054,
0.1251933575,
0.0142113147,
-0.3277651072,
-0.2629706264,
-0.8282335401,
-0.2232506126,
-0.1696534902,
0.6811049581,
-1.0967838764,
0.6583405137,
0.1562155038,
-0.5099505782,
-0.1127910838,
0.0147894202,
0.493501693,
0.7051144242,
0.5162578821,
-0.3207649589,
-0.328927964,
-0.6445780396,
0.0348223746,
-0.2731799781,
-0.6329561472,
0.6693301797,
0.5728661418,
0.1836299896,
1.1195888519,
-0.9451833963,
-0.6056516171,
-0.2790931761,
0.1152855679,
-0.1569769681,
0.2935179174,
0.6065778732,
-0.5318094492,
-0.4782981575,
0.2872879803,
-0.8670383096,
-0.1042181551,
-0.1931692511,
-0.4724121094,
0.128072843,
0.2336205691,
-0.4426628947,
0.493159771,
0.3042894006,
-0.2939333916,
0.2995244861,
-0.0708710104,
-0.1173153818,
-1.0429885387,
0.2457776964,
0.3185761571,
-0.2699741423,
-0.6524223089,
0.4501358271,
-0.0670631602,
-0.3445652127,
-0.7947455645,
0.6708506942,
-0.4299527407,
-0.1041317359,
-0.3715159595,
0.3157171011,
0.0324554294,
0.7867873311,
0.2986184061,
0.3867844939,
0.6128663421,
-0.7909480333,
0.6107723117,
0.3132980764,
-0.1406039298,
1.0570682287,
-0.5033400655,
0.4018908441,
-0.2365508378,
0.2409989983,
-0.5181078315,
-0.2870040536,
0.697383821,
-0.5544275045,
0.0495314002,
0.10461431,
-0.3972349763,
-0.1331210434,
-0.2784329951,
0.376255244,
0.2785895467,
-0.1666485369,
0.5627569556,
0.1919861585,
0.3638105094,
-0.5163514018,
-0.3547640741,
-0.2060569972,
-0.0206423644,
-0.2845298052,
0.3118893206,
-0.2299177349,
0.0114403199,
0.1454966217,
-0.3282063603,
-0.379703939,
0.1914102435,
0.210545972,
0.4694150686,
-0.0394171551,
0.0173880216,
-0.4991719723,
-0.2740931809,
-0.2042716444,
-0.036532864,
0.354191184,
-0.0030828335,
-0.4484250844,
-0.4732864797,
0.1623816788,
0.2002941668,
-0.373950541,
0.7441018224,
0.6622172594,
-0.4607056975,
-0.4145815969,
0.0689145625,
-0.3201633096,
-0.4696228206,
0.5591306686,
-0.2472412586,
-0.7089428306,
0.607434988,
0.0929744765,
-0.097599946,
0.4699320197,
0.3468216062,
-0.3153062463,
0.5956405997,
0.6451211572,
-0.0286256447,
0.5747262836,
-0.3735101521,
0.1532433331,
-0.9283747673,
-0.4242234826,
-0.569578886,
-0.7400400043,
-0.3818766773,
-0.6716849804,
0.408651799,
-0.0366037786,
-0.51454705,
0.7048364282,
-0.3580752015,
0.8146185279,
0.6604194641,
0.756847322,
0.1934396327,
-0.2993305027,
0.1804687828,
0.1811338812,
-0.4273473918,
-0.1149690896,
0.8699125648,
-0.0640419275,
0.7958648205,
0.1632918715,
0.5288124084,
0.1086560488,
-0.0855203271,
-1.1052645445,
0.884753108,
-0.1197142974,
-0.5410876274,
-0.4413770437,
-0.3946460187,
-0.936484158,
0.0616456382,
-0.2000071704,
-1.000210166,
-0.1793344021,
0.1095677763,
-0.3310068846,
0.329703182,
-0.3767557442,
0.8585907817,
-0.1438728422,
-0.4105009437,
-0.2508171201,
-0.9099357128,
0.0269582681,
0.1891923845,
-0.2720543444,
-0.4219698906,
-0.2205823958,
0.5628469586,
-0.0913235471,
1.0145002604,
-0.1063826531,
-0.1269302517,
0.3639769852,
0.2518315315,
0.1892771274,
-0.3944636881,
0.2190933973,
0.2126689255,
-0.1578937322,
-0.3798781037,
-0.954924047,
0.2487990558,
-0.8368549943,
-0.21057944,
-0.5689376593,
-0.7699513435,
-0.4183651507,
0.0703899637,
-0.2545461357,
0.14845936,
-0.0526132472,
0.5909278989,
0.3773331344,
-0.3936794698,
0.4073399603,
0.967036128,
0.0349643268,
-0.1113998964,
1.327283144,
-0.0892042294,
0.4559868276,
0.8774320483,
0.3665698171,
-0.0104291905,
-0.0080561182,
-0.6030958295,
0.0711494237,
-0.3442505002,
-0.6428780556,
-0.1086803302,
-0.2937567234,
0.0779272839,
-0.2774177194,
-0.1641253978,
-0.3433032036,
-0.4287238717,
0.0628487542,
0.3058089316,
0.6808103323,
-0.0764804259,
0.2615671754,
-0.7605698109,
0.6953419447,
0.2861592472,
0.5517651439,
0.0423838347,
-0.4256771207,
-0.4601386786,
0.1470947862,
-0.5088963509,
-0.8185514212,
0.0023593225,
0.6128525138,
0.5471528172,
0.5378375649,
0.5052647591,
0.5926129818,
-0.419134587,
0.7119594216,
0.0930012837,
-0.7190774083,
0.5999654531,
-0.3480859697,
0.5153767467,
0.1389661282,
0.3632837236,
-0.7387533188,
-0.5176059008,
-0.5191454887,
-0.6643434763,
0.9746605158,
0.1684758663,
0.2987933755,
0.0912776515,
0.254239887,
0.1241778433,
0.08644218,
-0.7818132639,
-0.1082747206,
-0.0858741179,
-0.3192686439,
0.1554384381,
0.2696402371,
0.0061688437,
-0.1296167821,
0.5225089788,
-0.5438287854,
0.3227662146,
-0.1712931842,
-0.4326947927,
-0.4208391011,
0.1012762338,
0.6130994558,
0.5407375693,
-0.2272825092,
-0.0395643935,
0.094076544,
-0.2672518194,
0.1047173887,
-0.3104046285,
-0.298338294,
-0.4153734446,
0.3215467632,
0.6126534939,
0.3233453929,
-0.7568147779,
0.4575199485,
0.5481647849,
-0.1375095099,
0.0175545868,
0.34530738,
-0.2303774059,
0.2689935267,
0.3304716945,
-0.0070401048,
-0.0782183111,
-0.8329209685,
0.2775940299,
0.5913213491,
-0.6507517099,
-0.6226360798,
0.4877419174,
0.2749064565,
-0.2324023545,
0.5601499081,
-0.1491509676,
-0.5134907961,
0.5346044898,
0.691380024,
1.0726665258,
-0.1295394897,
0.5563598275,
0.4932038784,
0.0726661459,
0.4882834852,
0.2179175466,
-0.521692872,
-1.2041063309,
-0.4762896299,
-0.5639873147,
-0.917106688,
-0.0159807019,
-0.6660146117,
0.0530618392,
-0.5513445735,
0.4131064713,
-0.3239628673,
-0.1186260879,
-0.7317436934,
0.2316163182,
0.3094446063,
0.1734558493,
-1.007042408,
0.5035377145,
0.8541060686,
-0.8436652422,
-0.56267488,
0.1402057111,
-0.0923345536,
-1.0995174646,
0.7006847262,
0.0962176397,
-0.3590817153,
-0.0719163939,
-0.786988616,
-0.6823627949,
1.1803296804,
0.4505831599,
0.0276941676,
0.1635757983,
0.3017908633,
0.3791100085,
-0.132981509,
0.170083195,
-0.0135064451,
0.3087623417,
0.4033285081,
-0.9661097527,
-0.1506922543,
0.0542532839,
-0.1073919833,
0.3355376422,
-0.8862267137,
0.6086423397,
-0.1996427625,
-0.2887763381,
0.2168699801,
0.9104756117,
0.0061787749,
0.3530210555,
0.5574305058,
0.736918509,
0.3281678855,
0.1200303808,
0.6174298525,
-0.0937671289,
0.4676622748,
1.1680281162,
-0.7205797434,
1.1888450384,
0.0472927615,
-0.3295097351,
0.8825021386,
0.0358539149,
0.0607630946,
0.5066683888,
0.145143941,
-0.7527436614,
-0.2853903472,
-0.4708822668,
0.200012207,
0.9055658579,
0.1616942436,
0.1171821207,
-0.4909716547,
0.1754132062,
-0.1408251971,
0.1822553128,
-0.2080112994,
1.190517664,
-0.2767255008,
-0.4202376902,
-0.0956979319,
0.0484132022,
0.3242361248,
-0.7032752633,
-0.3978844583,
0.0437092669,
0.291834563,
-0.1929444224,
-1.0293438435,
0.2750440836,
-0.091418542,
-0.0462099127,
-0.1733407229,
0.9479159117,
-0.5154544115,
-0.4013861716,
-0.1104088426,
0.5931862593,
0.0935857221,
-0.2163694501,
-0.4611137211,
-0.3152784407,
-0.3509713709,
0.1452990025,
0.4814933538,
0.3622659743,
-0.0501577705,
0.7306852937,
0.5176440477,
-0.306463778,
-0.307191968,
-0.1979385465,
0.6233659983,
-0.7493883371,
-0.3193534017,
-0.6700798869,
0.5928990841,
0.1311110407,
0.0087562669,
0.6168328524,
0.5153864622,
1.3783273697,
-0.2940203547,
0.5460456014,
-0.3599297404,
0.5353005528,
-0.3823257685,
0.5380709767,
-0.4820993245,
-0.3961285651,
-0.2497257143,
-1.021127224,
-0.6841396689,
0.8630529642,
0.1143712476,
0.1390079111,
0.5676918626,
0.7723662257,
-0.1481058151,
-0.4237076044,
0.634571135,
-0.0795216933,
0.1236332804,
0.5919644237,
0.66922158,
-0.2505155802,
0.4888775647,
-0.6033394337,
-0.0965579897,
0.0162217803,
-1.06986022,
-0.6109109521,
-0.6840265989,
-0.4868338704,
-0.0633433461,
-0.0206621308,
0.8371585011,
0.7237076163,
-0.7285394073,
-0.2087409645,
0.14008075,
0.02020525,
-0.4006570578,
-0.26210621,
0.062855728,
-0.2264459133,
-0.7811251879,
0.4567461312,
0.6255389452,
-0.1763249636,
-0.4872611463,
-0.2801836729,
-0.3183066249,
-0.0347026587,
0.877260983,
0.6670945883,
-0.6247993708,
-0.8646866679,
0.110851936,
0.3722353876,
0.1397146434,
0.660841167,
-1.2652336359,
0.648443222,
0.453774184,
0.551397562,
0.072207965,
0.0995571688,
0.4976794422,
-1.3757840395,
0.2823101282,
0.4125845134,
0.0967113301,
0.3410784006,
0.0037529238,
0.6670255065,
0.4582778513,
-0.3996222019,
-0.4553543925,
0.5229403377,
-1.3119508028,
-0.0789626017,
0.8364591599,
-0.1849430799,
-0.3584775627,
0.1845338345,
-0.273021698,
0.1801727116,
-0.2510949373,
0.5009648204,
0.3988780677,
-0.2922383845,
-0.4547256231,
-0.2616277635,
-0.1590527594,
0.0835598707,
-0.9353818893,
-0.0754265338,
0.6611148715,
-0.0447159186,
0.1515148282,
0.1683760881,
0.2832983434,
0.3000256419,
-0.1727416664,
0.1011583358,
-0.1872497648,
-0.5074363947,
0.2201235294,
0.0413800366,
-0.0577020273,
-0.6824300289
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13614v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13614v1
|
Structure-Aware Path Inference for Neural Finite State Transducers
| 2023-12-21T07:03:15 | 2023-12-21T07:03:15 |
Weiting Tan, Chu-cheng Lin, Jason Eisner
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Neural finite-state transducers (NFSTs) form an expressive family of
neurosymbolic sequence transduction models. An NFST models each string pair as
having been generated by a latent path in a finite-state transducer. As they
are deep generative models, both training and inference of NFSTs require
inference networks that approximate posterior distributions over such latent
variables. In this paper, we focus on the resulting challenge of imputing the
latent alignment path that explains a given pair of input and output strings
(e.g., during training). We train three autoregressive approximate models for
amortized inference of the path, which can then be used as proposal
distributions for importance sampling. All three models perform lookahead. Our
most sophisticated (and novel) model leverages the FST structure to consider
the graph of future paths; unfortunately, we find that it loses out to the
simpler approaches -- except on an artificial task that we concocted to confuse
the simpler approaches.
|
[
0.0696876347,
-0.6061205864,
0.7215869427,
-0.2112916857,
-0.3133246601,
0.0068899933,
0.2239132971,
-0.4194252491,
0.4134084284,
0.2478464842,
-0.7520127296,
-0.1910199225,
-0.3625264466,
-0.2272611707,
-0.6974490881,
1.0051778555,
-0.1418008953,
-0.2131352723,
0.0056128683,
0.109515436,
0.1677545607,
0.0605577044,
-0.4163998365,
-0.2563484311,
0.6247419715,
-0.1264759749,
0.7499038577,
0.6287232041,
0.4601431489,
0.2054464519,
-0.4614006281,
-0.2139204592,
0.1034951583,
0.4540842175,
-0.0547805056,
-0.4603231847,
-0.4249072075,
-0.1512465328,
0.7487875223,
1.1370226145,
0.0350266136,
-0.0219665747,
-0.1167843118,
0.4284678102,
-0.6561174393,
-0.1671056598,
-0.2948588133,
0.3478986323,
-0.1670480818,
-0.0879814997,
-0.3873657584,
-0.4752302766,
0.5457904339,
-0.4214695394,
0.4321323335,
-0.4095464349,
0.4082946777,
0.5795021653,
-0.7069980502,
-0.0984101892,
-0.9220254421,
0.346403718,
-0.626113534,
0.5872767568,
0.4283736348,
0.4794806242,
-0.3721847534,
-0.7908030748,
-0.029558599,
-0.3362620771,
-0.0072729504,
0.1098848581,
0.0546291023,
0.3832485974,
0.1609596163,
0.579972744,
-0.5882349014,
-0.2185984403,
-0.0709980503,
-0.1468608975,
0.50197047,
-0.0094290106,
-0.1327551305,
-0.218289122,
-0.4666602314,
-0.152525574,
-0.6092608571,
-0.0345469452,
0.5789399147,
0.1799101233,
-0.1206801459,
0.4046361446,
0.0106127597,
1.1248676777,
0.099507086,
0.3295252323,
-0.0276648235,
-0.1780813038,
-0.222378552,
0.1759876758,
0.6530204415,
-0.1517211795,
0.0683746114,
-0.4238359928,
-0.3775632381,
-0.265191704,
0.33135584,
-0.4914534986,
-0.4331248701,
0.3019418716,
-0.285920769,
-0.0974354371,
-0.2969303429,
-0.4135874212,
-0.3848380446,
0.0216286797,
0.6556357741,
-0.8173597455,
-0.5059653521,
-0.1999504566,
-0.1793603748,
0.2231911123,
0.3045333624,
-1.1251286268,
0.2765136361,
0.520578742,
1.1135444641,
0.2333106846,
-0.0350964293,
-0.1977236867,
0.2532601655,
-0.436124444,
0.9875962734,
-0.4234367609,
-0.2567954659,
-0.5874496698,
-0.3402833045,
-0.3057883382,
-0.1197267845,
0.3811679184,
-0.5397118926,
-0.0498615131,
-0.148880437,
-0.7567260861,
-0.3339847922,
0.1444389969,
-0.7604768276,
0.5370755196,
0.4855301678,
-0.7303894162,
0.174513191,
-0.9211406112,
-0.7449955344,
-0.2643783092,
0.0608669408,
-0.2465763837,
0.2950832546,
0.1125247777,
0.2012451291,
-0.0507163368,
0.3296988606,
-0.474146992,
-0.5488197803,
0.0551434755,
-0.9458267689,
0.7865795493,
0.3027283847,
-0.524441421,
0.2720519602,
-0.6652824879,
-0.1407600045,
-0.022021126,
-0.1235176772,
-0.4226376712,
0.2312536389,
-0.0394065529,
-0.0468880311,
-0.0523939505,
-0.5986222029,
0.2762806416,
-0.762632668,
0.7922651768,
0.9683821797,
0.1693472564,
0.4643639326,
-0.0299710855,
0.635674417,
0.0145990364,
0.2217184454,
-0.0843032822,
-0.2908369005,
-0.3997157812,
-0.0972888842,
0.4510317445,
0.1302519143,
-0.4999582469,
0.0688315034,
-0.1661068797,
-0.8794906735,
-0.1508726776,
-0.7604553103,
0.2745368183,
0.5613728762,
0.2062680125,
-0.2004495263,
-0.1992999464,
-0.7518908978,
-0.5376176238,
-0.2388910949,
0.068245478,
0.0312506706,
0.4629837573,
0.4104751945,
0.8440328836,
-0.5530309677,
0.1418802142,
0.185083136,
0.0783029124,
0.3551150858,
0.6870892048,
0.3949517012,
-0.8090355992,
-0.1856704503,
-0.312312156,
-0.3842732012,
0.4535826147,
-0.150271371,
-0.1368940622,
-0.2551202774,
0.377805233,
-0.6006506085,
0.4064666033,
0.3712454736,
-0.4744570255,
0.2721296549,
0.0409731567,
-0.1099160239,
-0.9742990136,
0.0089401575,
-0.0493364558,
-0.1920533329,
-0.386125952,
-0.2855322063,
-0.0749177113,
0.0730456188,
-0.1670420915,
0.3667042553,
-0.5471522808,
-0.7439329028,
0.1249321401,
-0.4122007489,
-0.0694303736,
0.5047592521,
0.2001537085,
0.6245657802,
0.4458270371,
-0.4412561357,
0.0715806782,
0.2316823304,
-0.0991950035,
0.5158216357,
-0.538839519,
0.2073406875,
-0.0397921726,
0.4966803789,
-1.0992921591,
-0.1092488021,
0.2263435572,
-0.5151500106,
0.3045122921,
-0.6049093604,
-0.2244500667,
-0.2578055859,
0.0457108803,
0.6756972075,
0.2573616803,
-0.4573688805,
0.8303537369,
0.1625401527,
0.3552612364,
-0.5245367885,
-0.8620378971,
-0.193023026,
-0.2276512533,
-0.552687943,
0.3724709153,
0.0921212733,
0.1539771855,
0.1577886492,
-0.5982043743,
-0.4323342144,
0.5435697436,
0.5163450241,
-0.0849252939,
-0.5849177837,
0.1390636414,
0.3139736354,
0.014459027,
0.3368910849,
-0.7651360631,
0.2915703058,
-0.1666440219,
-0.8673020601,
-0.3170030117,
0.3402127028,
0.4505918324,
-0.4042174816,
0.2803086936,
0.4315507412,
-0.6483758092,
0.0326342694,
-0.0115121175,
-0.3766805828,
-0.4289991856,
0.1104453281,
-0.4198584557,
-0.7063757181,
0.47059834,
0.0456913896,
0.2734931707,
0.5075671673,
0.1303995997,
-0.1660907716,
0.7899631262,
0.261403203,
0.4463037252,
0.5796514153,
-0.5363140702,
0.3570808172,
-0.8491575122,
-0.06476935,
-0.1235602871,
-0.4964451194,
-0.4946328104,
-0.3899948597,
0.4421103001,
-0.2218706757,
-0.2769904435,
0.4424648881,
-0.5278535485,
0.2047614604,
0.6799852848,
0.1890203059,
0.0027367601,
0.1996729672,
-0.3647063673,
0.0642686784,
-0.8123768568,
-0.0860564858,
0.9913226366,
0.2046946436,
0.7536252737,
0.2083868682,
0.9677612185,
0.091943346,
0.3650639057,
-0.9830281734,
0.2474028766,
-0.0781493485,
-0.7215881348,
-0.3017595708,
-0.386870712,
-0.7925109267,
0.2148249894,
0.2644727528,
-0.7931807637,
0.5764679313,
0.75335145,
-0.9017227888,
0.6926473975,
-0.6379520893,
0.8247713447,
-0.2460044473,
-0.5097303391,
0.1249352992,
-0.8338772058,
0.4393890202,
0.246445924,
-0.3687468469,
-0.0214307103,
0.1202463806,
0.7934769392,
-0.5378277898,
0.7587236166,
-0.4759083092,
-0.1000287384,
0.5244040489,
0.370544374,
0.4385770559,
-0.2422208339,
-0.289942205,
-0.0029700166,
-0.0794751868,
-0.0706137791,
-0.5111984015,
0.3983395398,
-0.2557824552,
-0.2788337469,
-0.438608855,
-0.759356916,
-0.4524712861,
0.0384741277,
0.4004424512,
0.6671988368,
-0.1835764349,
-0.1342106164,
0.4373373389,
0.2492159158,
0.6052658558,
0.0936357751,
0.4132013917,
-0.2223967761,
0.7438301444,
0.3127522469,
0.4390982091,
0.5553735495,
0.2132029533,
-0.7611321807,
-0.5426068902,
-0.4963358641,
0.0694172531,
-0.5129905939,
-0.0928569064,
-0.7261279821,
-0.4199685156,
-0.5559998751,
-0.1542230994,
-0.5533478856,
-0.6964436173,
-0.1681006551,
-0.2664471567,
0.8109703064,
0.69135499,
-0.4387394488,
0.5124571919,
-0.5608394742,
0.0986990556,
0.1402862072,
0.5466465354,
0.2562592328,
-0.4746491015,
-0.04551927,
0.0472776182,
-0.2439195067,
-1.0938180685,
0.1115512773,
0.2206772417,
0.3872206211,
0.4639594853,
0.0084685478,
0.6479586363,
-0.4061429799,
0.5720025301,
-0.0110808108,
-0.7899067998,
0.6277225018,
-0.5084462166,
0.1370453387,
0.3671503663,
0.2756364942,
-0.5777647495,
-0.1824654639,
-0.8031203747,
-0.8931828737,
0.5504102707,
0.2954766154,
-0.1721160114,
-0.0959165096,
0.3482946455,
-0.1558811963,
0.2150879651,
-0.4801619649,
0.0135058817,
-0.3881729841,
-0.4563053548,
0.1771911085,
-0.0724206865,
0.1652212888,
-0.085188821,
0.3690760136,
-0.2816529274,
0.5922191739,
0.5197882652,
-0.2083704621,
-0.1601664722,
-0.0503645837,
0.4536953568,
0.3399996459,
-0.4732845724,
0.3427388072,
-0.3168020248,
-0.6247239709,
0.6109002233,
0.354629308,
-0.2997721732,
0.0727589875,
0.6328377724,
0.9974698424,
0.3369371295,
-0.079734005,
0.4367847443,
0.0281055905,
-0.2848553658,
-0.4025538564,
0.237310648,
0.3641752601,
0.4143866003,
0.0816221014,
0.3469173014,
0.4406082928,
0.0617747195,
0.291167587,
0.5059324503,
-0.9680629373,
-0.3843283653,
0.8668941259,
-0.1120829284,
-0.3156940043,
0.587813735,
-0.098955214,
-0.3822490573,
0.9675071836,
0.3586599827,
1.1547373533,
-0.6372058392,
0.209685266,
0.4498099387,
0.5567654967,
0.0272180997,
0.3327149451,
-0.4595398307,
-0.3428654075,
-0.5470423698,
-0.7558974028,
-0.3013148904,
-0.0423215404,
-0.5431756973,
-0.2517298758,
-0.5856793523,
-0.1283937693,
0.0914020166,
-0.4586843848,
-0.2892397046,
0.1784018725,
-0.0872055441,
0.9792984724,
-0.9846470952,
0.5449646115,
0.5153170824,
-0.2465581447,
-0.8426762223,
0.3103007078,
-0.0328251906,
-0.4635624886,
0.4138671458,
0.0952064395,
-0.2116160393,
0.2803942263,
-0.1794440597,
-1.3368331194,
0.8041263819,
0.6932733059,
-0.3907261789,
-0.4398088455,
-0.0749824122,
0.3094715774,
0.0603155047,
0.3844413161,
0.4079914391,
0.4391533136,
0.1399154961,
-0.4072131813,
0.0361634642,
-0.051767081,
0.0048424769,
0.5526403785,
-0.3136356175,
1.010084033,
-0.5718603134,
-0.1832899898,
0.0972921699,
0.7897530198,
0.2330218256,
0.091267623,
1.0393732786,
0.4536398351,
0.4576615691,
0.0691270679,
1.0548343658,
0.0579308495,
0.2636060715,
1.2835423946,
-0.050219804,
0.5869242549,
0.6560508013,
-0.1276721358,
0.3844024241,
1.1987947226,
0.0391128398,
0.6090909243,
0.3417308629,
-0.2882488668,
-0.2746481597,
0.0673705935,
-0.3127989769,
0.5952913165,
0.4364991188,
-0.6522071362,
-0.5313390493,
-0.3265443444,
-0.2602208257,
-0.3661637902,
-0.048425734,
0.2880711257,
0.1440680474,
-0.7638411522,
0.4724889994,
-0.3058671355,
0.2218832374,
-0.6284306049,
-0.2844162583,
-0.2490783036,
-0.0448741466,
-0.1411567032,
-0.6684079766,
0.5429578424,
-0.1861821264,
-0.1515697241,
-0.1335197091,
0.416136831,
-0.3361002803,
-0.3051882982,
0.2211043835,
0.1945916265,
0.2443919629,
-0.317599088,
-0.4653167129,
-0.6364098787,
-0.0762070119,
-0.6555293202,
-0.0444994345,
0.2108709514,
-0.3353811204,
0.3798902035,
0.6185534,
0.0642632172,
0.213804692,
-0.0568788908,
0.3765737414,
-0.7501885295,
-0.6854647994,
-0.7599810362,
0.4399711788,
0.1684217453,
-0.4494048655,
0.2137151062,
0.3766437173,
0.5573241711,
0.1724139303,
0.2766101956,
0.0593812168,
0.2946872115,
-0.6686086059,
0.7560688853,
-0.7026302218,
-0.0084611382,
-0.3099897206,
-0.8927458525,
0.003048714,
0.807492435,
-0.1818393618,
0.2941122949,
0.6274944544,
0.5954488516,
-0.5363444686,
0.3472052813,
0.1356677711,
0.3351938426,
0.1651040316,
1.0070930719,
0.8638436198,
-0.3989180028,
0.3565867543,
-0.4695447087,
0.1578821838,
-0.1239573583,
-0.8549615145,
-0.0814715624,
-0.7500129342,
-0.3269719779,
-0.3066363931,
0.0140113486,
0.4830322862,
0.9391851425,
-0.492185384,
-0.2096970975,
-0.4988313317,
0.3486249149,
-0.5435334444,
-0.1383600384,
0.7080488801,
0.1452625096,
-0.3810233772,
0.7107784748,
0.2106456608,
0.4546887279,
-0.3793275058,
0.4244856536,
-0.4427888989,
-0.2135130912,
0.2625152171,
0.1952429563,
-0.652911365,
-0.3857785463,
0.0679751411,
0.049539037,
0.0269368924,
0.781883359,
-0.7871651053,
0.2188846916,
0.5197663903,
0.6008298993,
0.6307540536,
-0.4131327569,
0.8145431876,
-0.6898821592,
0.0276319999,
0.4930437505,
0.4855527878,
0.4027439654,
-0.6404756904,
0.7654831409,
0.3567582071,
-0.2183430195,
-0.7874813676,
0.5597531199,
-0.7721099257,
-0.2176765203,
0.7095379829,
-0.278732717,
-0.7431507707,
-0.0014990196,
0.4413833916,
0.6232085824,
-0.0390002169,
0.1792902648,
0.2016442269,
-0.3780249357,
0.0467117764,
-0.4493516386,
0.4733947217,
0.5752888918,
-0.4869802892,
0.2286901772,
0.5453734398,
0.4409095645,
0.2104711086,
0.7183340192,
0.0548088066,
0.410997659,
0.162916407,
-0.0685189664,
-0.0326589309,
-0.4203423262,
-0.460644424,
0.1766117513,
0.0314484276,
-0.436462611
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13608v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13608v1
|
Argue with Me Tersely: Towards Sentence-Level Counter-Argument Generation
| 2023-12-21T06:51:34 | 2023-12-21T06:51:34 |
Jiayu Lin, Rong Ye, Meng Han, Qi Zhang, Ruofei Lai, Xinyu Zhang, Zhao Cao, Xuanjing Huang, Zhongyu Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Counter-argument generation -- a captivating area in computational
linguistics -- seeks to craft statements that offer opposing views. While most
research has ventured into paragraph-level generation, sentence-level
counter-argument generation beckons with its unique constraints and
brevity-focused challenges. Furthermore, the diverse nature of
counter-arguments poses challenges for evaluating model performance solely
based on n-gram-based metrics. In this paper, we present the ArgTersely
benchmark for sentence-level counter-argument generation, drawing from a
manually annotated dataset from the ChangeMyView debate forum. We also propose
Arg-LlaMA for generating high-quality counter-argument. For better evaluation,
we trained a BERT-based evaluator Arg-Judge with human preference data. We
conducted comparative experiments involving various baselines such as LlaMA,
Alpaca, GPT-3, and others. The results show the competitiveness of our proposed
framework and evaluator in counter-argument generation tasks. Code and data are
available at https://github.com/amazingljy1206/ArgTersely.
|
[
-0.7367401719,
-1.0088682175,
0.3595816493,
-0.0092572654,
-0.4086188078,
-0.2328791022,
0.0805468038,
-0.1513212323,
0.0172086842,
0.3483305275,
-0.5198137164,
-0.3710314631,
-0.4006533921,
0.1384774446,
-0.5197960734,
0.9540854096,
0.1175720692,
-0.1082705483,
-0.3423819542,
-0.2704242766,
-0.4352410734,
-0.471000284,
-0.4848365486,
-0.0233697761,
0.5906664133,
0.4739518762,
0.4677999318,
0.3061243892,
0.0845016912,
0.2652206421,
0.1497653425,
0.0247401483,
-0.1609395891,
0.5501592159,
-0.3031339645,
-0.2213992923,
-0.2301950306,
-0.0025567291,
0.361543268,
0.1833936423,
0.0377485901,
0.2113260627,
-0.3298441768,
0.306568265,
-0.6329350471,
-0.4206204116,
-1.0479955673,
0.0929209664,
-0.4446860254,
-0.0340318382,
-0.3323355317,
-0.3404173255,
0.2591927946,
-0.2089073956,
0.2627693117,
0.1134291068,
1.1036878824,
0.2358406186,
-0.2084870487,
-0.3405183852,
-0.2542107105,
0.6337493658,
-1.1045985222,
0.2367139459,
-0.1248466149,
0.0013337984,
-0.1509401798,
-0.7439042926,
-0.7652388215,
-0.4039356112,
0.2827712297,
0.3703863919,
-0.9935616255,
-0.1765309721,
0.2304772884,
0.0310613699,
-0.838050127,
0.13376306,
-0.1902837008,
0.1363650858,
0.5778037906,
0.0335205607,
0.1159713641,
-0.4093578458,
-0.1819722652,
-0.0542993359,
-0.6220860481,
-0.0155837322,
0.8657366633,
0.1570862681,
0.2368988991,
0.5566361547,
-0.1587291956,
0.6808999777,
0.4044822156,
0.5010753274,
0.0294082128,
0.0511495098,
-0.2861679196,
0.0507792197,
1.1179138422,
0.4908934236,
0.2152955085,
-0.1226169318,
0.0791443959,
0.3235009313,
0.5884914994,
-1.0743169785,
-0.3464894593,
0.228372708,
-0.4061502516,
-0.6511644125,
-0.2186553627,
-0.8958566189,
-0.1380671263,
0.212675795,
0.2724515796,
-0.2577565312,
-0.1711380333,
-0.1235558987,
-0.0876906589,
-0.0410939381,
-0.2139476538,
-0.7685137987,
0.0739732236,
0.5656253695,
0.7546764016,
-0.0480048209,
-0.1638829559,
-0.7282827497,
-0.0256990734,
-0.7038071156,
1.0757157803,
-0.9645255208,
-0.4802213013,
0.0246726591,
-0.1875283718,
0.0743780658,
-0.5810629129,
0.8406011462,
-0.1224101335,
0.5240858197,
-0.3345242739,
-0.601434648,
0.0984294713,
0.6041269302,
-0.3283752799,
1.0713764429,
-0.1447255611,
-0.5906720757,
0.6980069876,
-0.7302528024,
-0.5233387351,
0.2508085668,
-0.2252345979,
-0.5078310966,
0.3801109195,
0.2366530746,
0.3150613606,
-0.2481430173,
0.5343498588,
-0.2390010953,
-0.065165028,
0.12117327,
-0.5824192762,
0.2849741876,
0.2461969703,
-0.4051739872,
0.238315925,
-0.7139284015,
0.1779012382,
0.0179945081,
-0.215422079,
-0.1736373901,
0.0707928538,
-0.1509377956,
0.2541337311,
0.1400893778,
-0.7554633617,
0.0475091226,
-0.6020720005,
0.8679161668,
0.8077769876,
0.088420853,
-0.1330459267,
-0.1413308233,
0.622110486,
-0.0347881764,
-0.176496312,
0.1470181048,
-0.4203434587,
-0.5892158151,
0.3071739078,
0.2221371382,
0.3170321584,
-0.7270780206,
0.3287267089,
-0.0849357024,
-0.6825421453,
-0.4860289693,
-0.1246839017,
0.5379230976,
0.6845408082,
0.5962797403,
0.0606739447,
-0.7058467269,
-1.0663244724,
-0.607275486,
-0.5599706173,
0.1627497077,
0.4612231851,
0.3656392395,
-0.1684117764,
0.9543733597,
-0.3200777173,
0.3274001181,
-0.3956698477,
0.7612580657,
-0.0228916612,
0.5030145049,
0.5983400941,
-0.4013842344,
-0.2701421678,
-0.19585976,
-0.5822406411,
-0.7323995829,
-0.1925316304,
-0.3078042865,
0.4726342559,
0.6003926992,
-0.4349605739,
0.168310523,
0.5078742504,
-0.4089547396,
0.6193953753,
0.0816160142,
0.1728053838,
-1.2296720743,
0.1282442212,
0.1183427796,
-0.1049375609,
-0.5385071039,
0.179142043,
-0.4120294154,
-0.0970998034,
-0.4272477925,
0.5379481912,
0.1851153672,
0.4339298606,
-0.2696281075,
0.0610265285,
0.075308241,
0.3288643956,
0.0846082494,
0.8534244895,
-0.0279561002,
-0.2284231037,
0.3334342539,
0.1941770166,
-0.2448385954,
0.9399351478,
-1.0093717575,
0.2382816374,
0.1460069567,
0.2237218618,
-1.0448929071,
0.1584353894,
0.2045172602,
-0.351105988,
-0.1978248358,
-0.207646668,
-0.1945065409,
-0.4793520272,
-0.3932411671,
0.2063766569,
0.1801976711,
-0.5885669589,
0.3664332926,
0.1651596278,
-0.2960271835,
-0.7772063613,
-0.681188941,
0.7829324603,
-0.4769820273,
-0.5329617858,
0.285985589,
0.0206923652,
-0.5301288366,
0.1157325953,
-0.027742641,
0.3808696568,
-0.1019836217,
0.1890236586,
0.010732918,
-0.2747274339,
0.2554832697,
0.2688068449,
-0.1547042131,
0.3036679029,
-0.42105636,
0.7628869414,
-0.4267857969,
-0.242262736,
0.1562102288,
0.4645184875,
0.128199771,
-0.0394835435,
0.1722471267,
0.4915357232,
-0.1032283008,
-0.2303227335,
-0.7993261814,
0.1493730247,
-0.408634603,
0.5276942849,
-0.5054089427,
-0.7469115853,
0.1731419265,
0.0794179887,
0.4609301984,
0.6033468246,
0.7101284266,
-0.0856439993,
0.8154936433,
-0.1194421351,
0.1163562089,
0.3193644285,
-0.02494023,
0.385286659,
-0.444584161,
0.1773061454,
-0.6175101995,
-0.4746746421,
-0.5477883816,
-0.1876601577,
0.0914756209,
-0.1688086092,
-0.5233671665,
0.5417869091,
-0.620293498,
0.227122277,
0.5172502995,
-0.2387858331,
-0.0295676887,
-0.2861949205,
-0.1236783415,
-0.2305706441,
-0.6052560806,
-0.7573507428,
0.8724276423,
-0.0383164957,
0.4896761179,
0.1749104261,
0.8427801132,
0.6460450888,
0.2222740352,
-0.6324829459,
0.8922170401,
-0.5832846165,
-0.3515645266,
-0.0566943213,
-0.4931987822,
-0.8997907639,
0.4005018473,
-0.2797316611,
-0.67535007,
0.0866183862,
0.1845177859,
-0.2253117859,
0.4985322654,
-0.6032382846,
1.2891197205,
-0.3017410636,
-0.7066719532,
-0.1573955715,
-0.4293797314,
0.128290534,
0.3993503153,
-0.327880621,
-0.0760574192,
0.2451521009,
0.8811683059,
-0.5169091225,
0.469363898,
-0.3695280552,
-0.2179707736,
0.4289114177,
0.2119754702,
0.20840922,
0.1972972155,
-0.0382610522,
0.0290421192,
0.1149811372,
-0.1578689069,
-0.2045021653,
0.7969847918,
-0.4139235616,
-0.8098937273,
-0.313934803,
-0.4575146735,
-0.3952399492,
0.1020148396,
0.4107052982,
0.4864728153,
-0.6841750741,
0.2798802555,
0.3561424911,
-0.3085235357,
0.6900368929,
0.2775428295,
0.1584125608,
-0.4602120221,
1.1986659765,
0.0629513934,
0.0653885305,
0.3713753819,
0.6268096566,
-0.496095717,
-0.4552565813,
-0.8943553567,
-0.3172051907,
-0.4033871889,
-0.2688290477,
-0.8485998511,
0.0467852131,
-0.2478047907,
-0.3228639662,
-0.1541045457,
-0.6213633418,
0.0079890126,
-0.0107713193,
0.2062219977,
0.5437091589,
0.0428826623,
0.2030802667,
-0.4843598008,
0.2082419097,
0.5518324971,
-0.0567727871,
0.0772711933,
-0.276873678,
0.2079249173,
-0.139755398,
-0.5549429655,
-0.5881460905,
0.3067512214,
-0.0239492133,
0.4990174174,
0.3849388957,
0.1534156948,
0.8596012592,
-0.4193979502,
0.9953150749,
0.0900363326,
-1.2936398983,
0.6080104113,
-0.2850865424,
0.2635605931,
0.6362480521,
-0.1228768528,
-0.6289774179,
-0.5122615695,
-0.8483536839,
-0.9253348112,
0.1351593435,
0.0425366946,
0.1541479081,
-0.3958158791,
-0.0612668768,
0.1846988946,
0.2915955186,
-0.8088633418,
0.4793936908,
-0.5293416381,
-0.2692722082,
0.4163810015,
-0.3140096664,
-0.1883309186,
0.0881113485,
0.7485750318,
-0.2347767949,
-0.17376405,
0.0857468098,
-0.0489748567,
-0.0617498532,
0.6459059715,
0.6779774427,
0.489882797,
-0.0893802419,
0.2589277923,
0.3419774175,
-0.1986828148,
0.1680113673,
0.1317700148,
-0.2817887664,
0.0333499461,
0.5950322151,
0.6764476895,
-0.2327234894,
-0.7627311945,
0.3668943644,
0.0175876971,
-0.6180750132,
0.0391026437,
0.0682513416,
0.2224014699,
0.269130379,
-0.0318829082,
-0.0301120672,
-0.0499300621,
-0.3884043992,
0.0817489922,
0.6282795072,
-0.5320180058,
-0.0834696367,
0.8982926607,
0.4504996836,
-0.1911980212,
0.2760273218,
-0.2403242141,
-0.3810781538,
0.4799188077,
0.4185616672,
1.0073715448,
0.1321702451,
0.2767685056,
0.381588012,
0.1125441268,
0.2324093282,
0.346492976,
-0.2048432678,
-0.6300588846,
-0.0503105409,
-0.3022455871,
-0.4159057736,
0.3242202103,
-0.3268323243,
0.0174014214,
-0.540835619,
-0.1472652853,
0.0677930787,
0.1339195371,
-0.1671924144,
0.1444927603,
-0.001468837,
0.7488735914,
-0.7515377998,
0.4520326853,
0.6311056018,
-0.4064233303,
-0.0646742284,
0.3420553505,
-0.1598324627,
-0.6601429582,
0.4104177058,
0.1396473199,
-0.5492684841,
-0.4703054428,
-0.6835289598,
-0.0271188561,
0.6192747355,
0.2664088905,
-0.7492223382,
0.1545594037,
0.106253162,
0.7062857747,
-0.3848347366,
0.1367551237,
0.4262619019,
0.4706323147,
-0.0123700611,
-0.2809604406,
0.1265322715,
-0.5724411607,
0.0595092252,
0.013442019,
-0.6738007665,
0.8805216551,
-0.0442845002,
-0.0577476509,
0.3331624269,
0.4859342873,
0.2463913411,
0.2103375494,
0.7044163346,
1.0766837597,
0.3927826285,
-0.0640070289,
0.4626237154,
-0.3246274889,
-0.0344040841,
1.2293103933,
-0.4478498101,
0.9193239212,
0.3662687242,
-0.0242990442,
0.5581043363,
0.4958474338,
-0.3273878098,
0.2170447409,
0.5744092464,
-0.2025211751,
-0.4485294819,
-0.3821287155,
-0.5714773536,
0.5557997823,
0.1259582788,
-0.0911437646,
-0.3263174891,
-0.3666969836,
0.3581994772,
0.4111608863,
0.258582145,
0.8187747002,
-0.270618856,
-0.7870467901,
0.4817859232,
-0.0035242564,
0.6483126283,
-0.4272880852,
-0.1299236119,
-0.1629098654,
0.0501906388,
-0.1384780705,
-0.8989163637,
0.1687268615,
0.6232243776,
0.0051858388,
-0.0357252732,
0.529435575,
-0.2560957968,
-0.6006270647,
0.1669621468,
0.6974323392,
0.0329893976,
0.2482886016,
-0.6629024744,
-0.2427991182,
-0.0816992372,
-0.2033547014,
0.0573783778,
0.5126453638,
-0.1821325421,
0.4713815153,
0.6433513761,
0.0398153774,
-0.2444751412,
0.3909295797,
0.8328177333,
-0.5423631072,
-0.4205479026,
-1.1254615784,
0.1083914414,
-0.2996100783,
-0.7874885798,
0.5073925853,
0.6958249211,
0.6736130118,
0.1850725263,
1.04185009,
-0.3802753091,
0.3430853188,
-0.262181282,
0.5449848175,
-0.5343505144,
0.0137513047,
-0.5227642655,
-0.679492712,
-0.0528559946,
0.6456747651,
-0.4251799285,
-0.1238483414,
0.2987706363,
0.7115154266,
-0.0061886311,
0.179053992,
0.1631225795,
0.2211678624,
0.7954587936,
0.7880648375,
1.2142994404,
-0.345856905,
0.7980619073,
0.2771839499,
0.1289550662,
-0.0329717025,
-1.2331372499,
-0.9839985371,
-0.3919195235,
-0.2478847951,
-0.4003235102,
0.3025051653,
0.9542102814,
0.5280655622,
-0.8799296021,
-0.2624160945,
-0.391197592,
-0.0073053064,
-0.1267671585,
-0.1930847466,
0.1218275279,
-0.2331072241,
-0.6615120173,
0.4774726927,
0.1252408922,
-0.3053232133,
-0.2085637152,
0.0751542002,
-0.5806767941,
0.4514399469,
0.5141065121,
0.3254142404,
-0.9520361423,
-0.4604392052,
-0.3344050646,
0.1664068401,
0.0831703022,
0.816342175,
-0.7802203894,
0.4496668577,
0.4886961281,
0.6351355314,
0.2458838671,
0.3485512733,
0.5345660448,
-0.7613790631,
-0.0266292263,
0.1605502665,
0.3582234681,
0.2355538458,
0.0011640858,
0.5656430721,
0.1217541695,
-0.4759640396,
-0.8510394692,
0.2487505972,
-0.8303480148,
-0.3924422562,
0.9065477252,
-0.1639380455,
0.2071171999,
0.0380869545,
-0.2183841318,
-0.0571175069,
-0.7001665831,
0.8819553256,
0.9095962048,
-0.2164496928,
-0.1159690171,
-0.2593635321,
0.2421349287,
0.7422039509,
-0.946934402,
0.3257443905,
0.4162469804,
-0.0296960212,
0.0933517963,
0.3066061139,
0.0084716678,
0.1515051126,
0.2888326049,
-0.1933796406,
-0.1828145683,
-0.1731005758,
-0.0115790674,
0.3966005743,
-0.1311017871,
-0.3671739101
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13594v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13594v1
|
Towards More Faithful Natural Language Explanation Using Multi-Level Contrastive Learning in VQA
| 2023-12-21T05:51:55 | 2023-12-21T05:51:55 |
Chengen Lai, Shengli Song, Shiqi Meng, Jingyang Li, Sitong Yan, Guangneng Hu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
Natural language explanation in visual question answer (VQA-NLE) aims to
explain the decision-making process of models by generating natural language
sentences to increase users' trust in the black-box systems. Existing post-hoc
methods have achieved significant progress in obtaining a plausible
explanation. However, such post-hoc explanations are not always aligned with
human logical inference, suffering from the issues on: 1) Deductive
unsatisfiability, the generated explanations do not logically lead to the
answer; 2) Factual inconsistency, the model falsifies its counterfactual
explanation for answers without considering the facts in images; and 3)
Semantic perturbation insensitivity, the model can not recognize the semantic
changes caused by small perturbations. These problems reduce the faithfulness
of explanations generated by models. To address the above issues, we propose a
novel self-supervised \textbf{M}ulti-level \textbf{C}ontrastive
\textbf{L}earning based natural language \textbf{E}xplanation model (MCLE) for
VQA with semantic-level, image-level, and instance-level factual and
counterfactual samples. MCLE extracts discriminative features and aligns the
feature spaces from explanations with visual question and answer to generate
more consistent explanations. We conduct extensive experiments, ablation
analysis, and case study to demonstrate the effectiveness of our method on two
VQA-NLE benchmarks.
|
[
-0.4895746708,
-1.0502547026,
0.5298679471,
-0.0362047665,
-0.3051551878,
-0.032889314,
0.06480667,
-0.5994622707,
-0.0081310039,
0.5296671391,
-0.7867159247,
-0.4762481749,
-0.3532894254,
0.1238581836,
-0.1589131802,
0.8364600539,
-0.1491489708,
-0.077531226,
-0.3125649691,
-0.1665458381,
-0.3757708371,
-0.4309569001,
-0.8063445091,
-0.1218120754,
0.3915395439,
0.4361139834,
0.6644213796,
0.7545821071,
0.3557042778,
0.3816574812,
0.1337126642,
0.0563823506,
-0.3883959353,
-0.0469910465,
-0.3671347201,
-0.3011681437,
-0.2613985538,
-0.0866570845,
0.4464835227,
0.5514034033,
-0.2015839964,
0.1181106418,
0.0838397369,
0.6283928156,
-0.6649864316,
-0.0372424275,
-0.6361065507,
-0.1257328987,
0.1382760704,
-0.2264705747,
-0.2145797759,
-0.2804834843,
0.2672383189,
-0.8332989812,
0.2897907197,
-0.0739163682,
1.1877756119,
0.2601112127,
-0.5521302223,
-0.2384935617,
-0.5693196654,
0.9484449625,
-0.6338544488,
0.4233036339,
0.157794416,
0.4503655136,
0.1608078033,
-0.5814371109,
-0.7688646913,
-0.219375357,
-0.0732195824,
0.3943814635,
-0.3648281693,
0.0964218453,
0.1240640432,
0.4248255491,
-0.5991298556,
0.0827883407,
-0.0405784361,
-0.3070700467,
0.3807450831,
0.1271605343,
0.1645762771,
-0.2499297559,
-0.7927840352,
-0.0887101665,
-0.5526990891,
0.3099738657,
0.1578723937,
-0.0310879499,
-0.1803839952,
0.5964828134,
-0.5162314773,
0.5887624621,
0.2276147157,
0.098274529,
0.2958405912,
-0.6287261844,
-0.3754993081,
-0.0444607213,
0.5727181435,
0.4007414281,
0.1574330032,
0.1341738701,
-0.0150645152,
0.3342191577,
0.1578486711,
-0.7222563028,
-0.2733280063,
0.3157946765,
-0.4230224192,
-0.4397346675,
-0.1271916777,
-0.9524505734,
-0.1360895783,
-0.4758544266,
0.6997365952,
-0.2514706254,
-0.3230362535,
0.1769454479,
0.0647630543,
0.3743739426,
0.4461821616,
-0.6730859876,
0.3518190682,
0.103027977,
0.4114529788,
-0.0027695601,
-0.1847427189,
-0.6960226893,
0.187299937,
-0.195729509,
0.7856897116,
-0.4244422317,
0.0076693753,
0.0340351351,
0.05480133,
-0.0501566343,
-0.5168450475,
0.6264541745,
-0.3720166385,
0.488476783,
-0.2852108479,
-0.3286397159,
-0.3222272396,
0.445420146,
-0.446765095,
1.0347781181,
-0.1456341743,
-0.7766897678,
0.5043641329,
-0.667729795,
-0.0509457886,
-0.177920714,
-0.2379337996,
-0.4979377091,
0.0917121544,
0.6826371551,
0.3474136293,
-0.0882067978,
0.2075024843,
-0.1267406791,
-0.1764927804,
0.239836663,
-0.5744701624,
0.8229938745,
0.0643815175,
-0.5709825754,
0.3137456775,
-0.7496234179,
-0.1848487556,
0.3566384912,
-0.1304776371,
-0.3589726388,
-0.134199053,
-0.437895596,
0.5625839233,
0.3353076875,
-0.6751295924,
-0.1979014575,
-0.4010302722,
0.0164960101,
0.633315444,
-0.0025437512,
0.3803167343,
-0.3235638142,
0.517798245,
0.3617005944,
0.200040862,
-0.2876095474,
-0.2266974747,
-0.6763262153,
-0.2823131979,
0.1754598022,
0.6169614196,
-0.9937269688,
-0.1131483242,
0.0525389835,
-0.0015510276,
-0.6613789201,
0.187314868,
0.5813350677,
0.9437273741,
0.6437287331,
0.0094721196,
-0.5722180605,
-1.0036847591,
-0.3882272542,
0.026134653,
-0.0762594938,
0.2474984974,
0.5048090219,
-0.123970665,
0.7080922723,
-0.1749217957,
-0.1269703805,
-0.0345009714,
0.3740833402,
0.1103815585,
0.3346825242,
0.3715270758,
-0.9381864667,
-0.2578284144,
-0.0424893983,
-0.6760212183,
-0.2269543707,
-0.3866583407,
-0.244003579,
0.4254440367,
0.6399757266,
-0.3680821657,
0.5202103853,
0.5703763366,
-0.2764482796,
0.6944485307,
-0.1574938744,
0.2560908496,
-0.8251599073,
-0.177445665,
0.376529634,
-0.4495007992,
-0.337339282,
0.1906793565,
-0.0521921776,
0.1571366042,
-0.3461598158,
0.531257093,
-0.4657017291,
0.186586678,
-0.2141977251,
0.5797625184,
0.1596629769,
0.6552491188,
0.2638963759,
0.3483992517,
0.6228954196,
-0.5805385113,
0.2854805589,
0.222821489,
-0.0533830859,
0.7320987582,
-0.795150578,
-0.1960255951,
-0.2452986985,
0.0143168429,
-1.3714052439,
-0.0269985031,
0.3436808288,
-0.6616474986,
0.1092720479,
-0.1553795934,
-0.1703013629,
-0.2086348534,
-0.3617452681,
0.3702606559,
0.2946313918,
-0.8141359091,
0.5334704518,
0.0085407719,
-0.1417561471,
-0.8147298694,
-0.6368893981,
0.0583985411,
-0.2051001638,
-0.6397768855,
0.3691936731,
-0.1987196654,
-0.387475431,
0.1329474151,
-0.3706028461,
-0.1262389719,
0.1053278074,
0.0409495905,
0.4924725294,
-0.4345126748,
0.2130697072,
0.194263041,
-0.1900237501,
0.2317789644,
-0.1921314597,
0.0928555951,
-0.2252040505,
-0.2037860453,
-0.5189344287,
0.5001136065,
0.1355760098,
-0.3783619702,
0.9273915291,
0.7303851247,
-0.417124629,
-0.1217452958,
-0.5414046049,
-0.1705025584,
-0.44425264,
0.2279168069,
-0.5956793427,
-0.8332129717,
0.4642523825,
-0.0732992515,
0.1111186594,
0.6654245853,
0.594886601,
-0.1595709473,
1.1890083551,
0.5467524529,
0.5671159625,
0.4042400718,
-0.0885852277,
-0.0032253691,
-0.5328167677,
-0.3127162158,
-0.5141213536,
0.1720224023,
-0.6421086788,
-0.1853145361,
0.0438220166,
0.1782328933,
-0.1254655868,
0.0265639983,
-0.3260217011,
0.3756272793,
0.5370488763,
0.0392939486,
0.3783229291,
0.0373844802,
-0.2025402039,
-0.1109586507,
-0.6259625554,
-0.446224153,
0.6412744522,
0.3003200591,
0.6000504494,
0.257317394,
0.7427821159,
0.0385756604,
0.1801768094,
-0.6181871295,
0.3119688034,
-0.0753788501,
-0.5934035182,
-0.5306206346,
-0.6259266138,
-0.9182499051,
0.5346463919,
-0.605178833,
-0.7208545804,
0.2364584804,
0.4363427758,
-0.1529654115,
-0.0572857074,
-0.555573523,
1.1429700851,
-0.1459947526,
-0.7194427848,
-0.1406788081,
-0.7218931913,
0.5135382414,
0.1111638844,
0.423972249,
0.1978643984,
0.1032533869,
0.5648949742,
-0.4894147217,
0.7476544976,
-0.3156762421,
-0.2020312846,
0.238702938,
0.1174757183,
0.4265754521,
0.1172622666,
-0.0203918833,
0.0164852813,
-0.0526300594,
-0.8210829496,
-0.6140697002,
0.7091975212,
-0.4461812973,
-0.6817576289,
-0.2232247144,
-0.3446898162,
-0.1741710901,
0.0636595041,
0.2377671152,
0.6651639342,
-0.0697372407,
0.0881989896,
0.8462305665,
-0.4119385183,
0.2150388956,
0.4372582138,
-0.2033251375,
-0.3024585843,
0.9067035317,
-0.2131752223,
0.3696396053,
0.5059953928,
0.4157832563,
-0.6416623592,
-0.7222474813,
-0.4998616874,
0.2656320035,
-0.6445372701,
0.0064722947,
-0.4526454806,
0.0803521127,
-0.4049423635,
-0.2526724041,
-0.0838200897,
-0.2963519394,
-0.2050580084,
-0.1371646374,
0.1151345596,
0.493555516,
-0.1153294593,
0.3475953341,
-0.6627674103,
0.8808728456,
0.5467213988,
0.2101366073,
-0.0678794533,
-0.7004724741,
-0.3391496241,
0.3311024308,
-0.3111338615,
-0.9282721877,
0.2027289122,
0.1506720483,
0.7664330602,
0.2562741935,
0.039323099,
0.7580757141,
-0.1865400821,
0.6474419236,
0.2590735555,
-1.1710118055,
0.5291414857,
-0.3230853975,
0.4351591766,
0.4972412288,
0.4717375338,
-0.2492823601,
-0.5114606023,
-0.6359813809,
-0.8824555874,
0.4746926725,
0.2414228171,
0.0629728138,
-0.1244656816,
0.2864555418,
0.2245875448,
0.1352882385,
-1.1643079519,
-0.2512255609,
-0.4965016842,
-0.1708770394,
0.2184992135,
-0.2290133089,
0.0189150553,
-0.1236463934,
0.8157134056,
-0.1936853677,
0.0468926542,
0.6282477379,
-0.2827634811,
-0.2171311527,
0.3072273731,
0.5174464583,
0.8594803214,
-0.0874319002,
0.2573441267,
0.1448080689,
-0.0153545551,
-0.1657637358,
0.1865044385,
0.2517132759,
0.0665596128,
0.3740807474,
0.5559312105,
-0.0267835129,
-0.4813608229,
0.7632046938,
-0.1594075263,
-0.6539859772,
-0.2575086057,
-0.205165416,
0.1460569948,
0.3655029535,
0.1915942132,
-0.0884513706,
0.3070405126,
-0.5650725365,
0.2430240065,
0.582610786,
-0.4639773071,
-0.0279620308,
0.8340120912,
0.174895063,
0.1097389236,
0.4605896473,
-0.1297644228,
-0.3582015932,
0.5788197517,
0.5247213244,
0.5146672726,
-0.3806879222,
0.5780029297,
0.4831098318,
0.3178002536,
0.2018120438,
0.4651365876,
-0.2381681204,
-0.6986079216,
-0.8870075345,
-0.4963630438,
-0.390478909,
0.1251682639,
-0.7399438024,
0.1051461101,
-0.227334246,
0.3165992498,
0.2179144472,
-0.174806118,
-0.6391631365,
0.6162322164,
0.2411084324,
0.6936666369,
-0.8619664311,
0.6569142938,
0.5379241109,
-0.5906467438,
-0.6885186434,
-0.0283059366,
-0.091059953,
-0.7195148468,
0.5690562725,
0.0371287875,
-0.4502987266,
-0.1484683752,
-0.6767092347,
-0.5251604319,
0.8075143099,
0.5148494244,
-0.5407239199,
0.14126724,
-0.0612909533,
0.5296064615,
-0.3130766451,
0.19314982,
0.247684285,
0.427639395,
0.2556040585,
-0.6716710925,
0.2252528369,
-0.1995195895,
-0.2536942363,
0.281324327,
-0.1741756648,
0.6815040708,
-0.355137527,
-0.1054327935,
0.0726470426,
0.7383807898,
0.2569200099,
0.437512815,
0.6176255345,
0.549785912,
0.5365842581,
0.0529413857,
0.9863079786,
0.1273393333,
0.3639035523,
1.1494053602,
0.0983749107,
0.7544583678,
0.6695693135,
0.0407672077,
0.9707429409,
0.6221659184,
0.146365881,
0.3612623215,
0.3616669178,
-0.2050301582,
-0.6541164517,
-0.2214872539,
-0.1271676123,
0.4724113643,
0.1495766044,
-0.4522998929,
-0.3175233305,
0.0168626811,
-0.2749929428,
0.3047326207,
-0.4307396114,
0.8090835214,
0.0175486356,
-0.3931564987,
0.789434433,
-0.2258163095,
0.3368206918,
-0.4570698142,
-0.4390003681,
-0.1071157828,
0.0080109099,
-0.2474866807,
-0.6979059577,
0.2936053574,
-0.0979869366,
-0.1310333163,
-0.1628219038,
0.5325884223,
-0.5172442794,
-0.4666933119,
0.2291465551,
0.7278698683,
0.0806219578,
-0.152479142,
-0.8898763657,
-0.3184342682,
-0.014255112,
-0.2282238305,
0.0191955622,
0.727524817,
-0.1171464771,
0.4366115034,
0.4558567405,
-0.2774571478,
0.0281605609,
0.0847230405,
0.6158645749,
-0.6748699546,
-0.5473213792,
-0.8848417401,
0.8866416812,
-0.1110939458,
-0.2189184576,
0.7604420781,
0.37099123,
0.9611216187,
0.0434029587,
0.6032342911,
0.2749657929,
0.5021384954,
-0.8334115148,
0.0265784673,
-0.9619218111,
0.2264582962,
-0.5155540109,
-0.8290561438,
-0.3288756311,
0.5380930901,
-0.2533807755,
-0.0134058576,
0.8644630313,
0.5888908505,
-0.1480615884,
-0.0790784881,
0.5374810696,
0.4753060937,
-0.0850799903,
0.5190345645,
0.9982638955,
-0.2875082791,
0.8650987148,
-0.2913461924,
-0.2721961141,
-0.104535535,
-0.9994229674,
-0.8224231005,
-0.5106775761,
-0.6584954858,
-0.1391499639,
0.0668784827,
0.5474661589,
0.6230607033,
-0.7345403433,
-0.0841395408,
-0.2293972671,
0.207005918,
-0.3290027678,
-0.2748651505,
0.3840997517,
-0.1213246658,
-0.573425889,
0.1883110702,
0.1886022538,
0.0014562373,
-0.1208143234,
0.0940432549,
-0.318914175,
0.2438454777,
0.5964679122,
0.1461248249,
-0.8447762132,
-0.3057345748,
0.0323832519,
0.0920738429,
0.3731841147,
0.5115067363,
-0.9498175979,
0.5599588752,
0.344722867,
0.5989809036,
0.5361239314,
0.2059872448,
0.522495687,
-0.53559196,
-0.2939165235,
-0.060490597,
0.3884923458,
0.3251635432,
-0.4057688713,
0.1988138705,
0.0933897942,
-0.4428489208,
-0.4257293642,
0.437184751,
-1.144274354,
-0.4937882721,
0.88333565,
-0.20759736,
-0.2169227153,
-0.3928349316,
-0.4849183261,
0.4500050545,
-0.3530821502,
0.7263795137,
0.5923987031,
-0.2582515478,
-0.5151202083,
-0.6268684268,
0.3465255797,
0.6946737766,
-1.0035084486,
0.1408440322,
0.626847744,
0.1337601691,
0.0010417821,
0.315102905,
-0.1551879197,
0.6187883019,
0.0419710018,
0.1131493598,
-0.0864884928,
-0.2244339883,
-0.5821938515,
0.1106837913,
0.1432062835,
-0.4800496995
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13585v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13585v1
|
Speech Translation with Large Language Models: An Industrial Practice
| 2023-12-21T05:32:49 | 2023-12-21T05:32:49 |
Zhichao Huang, Rong Ye, Tom Ko, Qianqian Dong, Shanbo Cheng, Mingxuan Wang, Hang Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Given the great success of large language models (LLMs) across various tasks,
in this paper, we introduce LLM-ST, a novel and effective speech translation
model constructed upon a pre-trained LLM. By integrating the large language
model (LLM) with a speech encoder and employing multi-task instruction tuning,
LLM-ST can produce accurate timestamped transcriptions and translations, even
from long audio inputs. Furthermore, our findings indicate that the
implementation of Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting can yield advantages in the
context of LLM-ST. Through rigorous experimentation on English and Chinese
datasets, we showcase the exceptional performance of LLM-ST, establishing a new
benchmark in the field of speech translation. Demo:
https://speechtranslation.github.io/llm-st/.
|
[
0.0293346625,
-0.8501567245,
0.6902710795,
0.3835712075,
-0.5306773186,
0.2487182617,
-0.5476756692,
-0.6155032516,
-0.0705530196,
0.5567160249,
-0.5346724987,
-0.5828701854,
-0.655133903,
0.0147175025,
-0.6459536552,
0.6635245681,
-0.2023166269,
0.4992002249,
0.2162589431,
0.052807495,
-0.2817315459,
-0.6796819568,
-0.8078454137,
-0.4394987524,
0.5962463021,
-0.0192653239,
0.4008767605,
0.7020257115,
0.4905012548,
0.1896945834,
-0.180663541,
0.4339855313,
-0.4100821912,
-0.0857270136,
-0.0746758357,
-0.4890920222,
-0.7529705763,
-0.1330031902,
0.914506495,
0.6162664294,
-0.2050947845,
0.2778783441,
0.1378975064,
0.3214114606,
-0.2047706544,
-0.0953157917,
-0.6954998374,
0.0723148286,
-0.5165946484,
-0.3419834673,
-0.8092505336,
-0.3793762624,
-0.2034583986,
-0.1109075546,
-0.0084480941,
0.0411651582,
0.4322019219,
0.4488104284,
-0.443724215,
-0.093446061,
-1.0670256615,
0.8017328978,
-0.9066769481,
0.6332711577,
-0.2002096027,
0.3777446449,
-0.3321351111,
-0.9235772491,
-0.5477186441,
-0.1206960082,
0.2926442325,
-0.0341793671,
-0.0143762408,
0.1097339541,
0.1795066297,
0.460388422,
-0.3057664037,
0.3340922892,
-0.2438161373,
0.0451100618,
0.6502036452,
0.131995976,
0.2215597481,
0.2777020931,
-0.4457104504,
0.0150561882,
-0.8417185545,
-0.0592663735,
0.0179479085,
0.5105059147,
-0.215057537,
0.5197076797,
0.0310354941,
0.9240581393,
-0.1134300455,
-0.2054100782,
0.3062326908,
-0.3535684645,
-0.3262889087,
0.2255956978,
0.8131284714,
0.0873158649,
0.189290598,
-0.1237530112,
-0.3960960209,
0.012353207,
0.152759999,
-0.4882849753,
0.3358189166,
0.179061085,
-0.2755317688,
-0.1774622351,
-0.2830468714,
-0.3805130124,
-0.0834260955,
-0.4612414241,
0.2009707987,
-0.1379514784,
-0.0830276459,
0.1483412683,
0.2552669346,
0.5715831518,
0.4693036079,
-0.6243248582,
0.0242313724,
0.7626562119,
0.9852337241,
-0.4939455092,
-0.3379904628,
-0.8065162897,
0.3496365249,
-0.6753438711,
0.619507432,
-0.3902429342,
-0.2951647043,
0.0224419814,
-0.1595086157,
-0.0418955274,
-0.4447112381,
0.5211831927,
-0.381414175,
-0.2360777706,
0.0392569639,
-0.4061899483,
0.0763514861,
0.1202912033,
-0.4305785298,
0.8933520317,
-0.1637491733,
-0.2048470676,
0.0681645721,
-0.5746395588,
-0.6291863322,
-0.0188219305,
-0.1586997509,
0.0047698496,
0.3126996756,
0.3155703247,
0.4722088277,
-0.4528101981,
0.4080138505,
-0.0844482407,
-0.3286905587,
0.480055213,
-0.6378034353,
0.6708724499,
0.5162802935,
-0.1520692706,
0.3303661346,
-0.2399897873,
0.0804310217,
0.1176365092,
-0.3924793601,
0.1697852165,
-0.1381557137,
0.2325080782,
0.3646654487,
0.4994242191,
-0.4685906768,
0.2076624632,
-0.421409905,
0.8561221957,
0.6170496941,
-0.1510415971,
0.2553477883,
-0.3556162119,
0.3809543252,
-0.121596396,
0.1159430593,
0.0823372453,
-0.3346957862,
-0.6386581659,
-0.1453075111,
0.3689480722,
0.5111501813,
-0.7003650069,
0.2807159424,
-0.395712018,
-0.639395833,
-0.8845475316,
0.0542161167,
0.2960493267,
0.2915330529,
0.4223042727,
-0.2429914325,
-0.5309084654,
-0.6674659252,
-0.3214695454,
0.0670866594,
-0.2307136357,
0.1538769007,
0.1580064446,
-0.351705879,
0.3442997336,
-0.2530557215,
-0.2482299358,
-0.5595579743,
0.1411726773,
0.3736163974,
0.4673229754,
0.2347602099,
-0.4893218875,
-0.3538706899,
0.0547863618,
-0.5040560961,
-0.1443599463,
-0.2267648429,
-0.2622250021,
0.1747703999,
0.7767298222,
-0.6650910378,
0.1619601548,
0.7178966999,
0.3427673578,
0.6616119742,
-0.2844756246,
0.1980867833,
-1.3572517633,
0.1481245905,
-0.2090130597,
-0.6144559979,
-0.8110409975,
0.2642983198,
0.139409557,
-0.2007828951,
-1.0931674242,
0.3868741095,
-0.2906455696,
-0.2578011751,
-0.2696395218,
0.4574527442,
-0.2854448557,
0.4485211968,
0.1139241084,
0.9861963391,
0.2276872694,
-0.8093600869,
0.5072445273,
0.3530911505,
-0.6230733991,
0.4317893684,
-0.5976009965,
0.5138887167,
0.1578240842,
0.383333087,
-0.7563828826,
-0.0801410154,
0.0678925291,
-0.2530903518,
0.4200241268,
0.0606923662,
-0.6307115555,
-0.4758759737,
0.2608868182,
0.514698267,
0.4577933848,
-0.5091223121,
0.3959519267,
0.4922726452,
-0.399812907,
-0.3797729611,
-0.879592061,
0.3607824147,
-0.0314365849,
-0.4398086965,
0.5271750093,
-0.1639088839,
0.0090966262,
-0.3945800662,
-0.1710145026,
0.0015500251,
-0.1618552357,
-0.2746833861,
0.3569128215,
-0.2912436426,
0.0314506106,
-0.0447806083,
0.0798632577,
0.0019391312,
-0.4651408195,
0.7914556265,
0.0512641147,
-0.2566267848,
-0.5321542621,
0.2605937123,
0.7631181479,
-0.3531811833,
0.3833339512,
0.4170024097,
-0.3858917058,
-0.3791404963,
-0.440771699,
0.0334127694,
-0.4397052228,
0.5578568578,
-0.4517477453,
-0.7302657366,
0.1600270718,
-0.4246872067,
0.2304251194,
0.2223188728,
0.500842154,
-0.1281754524,
1.2217023373,
0.3884702921,
-0.3257263005,
0.6557272077,
-0.0738778189,
0.3668865561,
-1.0710198879,
0.1393364072,
-0.4325218201,
-0.4062599838,
-0.4504097402,
-0.7386606336,
0.3669036627,
-0.0613407344,
-0.0359636247,
0.4322745204,
-0.4262038171,
0.2614787221,
0.3904305696,
0.131637007,
0.2250932902,
-0.2138779014,
-0.0117346197,
0.1329694837,
-0.6082849503,
-0.6634562016,
0.7970145941,
0.3947820365,
0.8353149891,
-0.0054446026,
0.5501177311,
0.1813601255,
0.1675746739,
-0.9224249125,
0.6193256974,
-0.6388579607,
-0.3580752909,
-0.4083507657,
-0.4597230554,
-0.721560061,
0.2241721302,
-0.1204302534,
-0.5585528612,
-0.2126660049,
0.0934953317,
-0.3158206046,
0.4125725031,
-0.3853221536,
0.8295937181,
-0.8344145417,
-0.2764601111,
-0.472210139,
-0.4650503099,
0.2263151705,
-0.1456718147,
0.2432056367,
-0.1305325329,
-0.0024843367,
0.621734798,
0.030601304,
0.6291603446,
-0.0038053736,
-0.3547201455,
0.0252304766,
-0.1402525157,
0.8588927388,
-0.4664751291,
-0.1954621077,
0.331633538,
-0.0955930352,
-0.1173471063,
-0.4316157103,
0.5519983768,
-0.6037810445,
-0.765976429,
-0.2284991145,
-0.8514553905,
-0.2518436611,
0.3990348577,
0.2936121225,
0.3630481362,
-0.4279094338,
0.3445654213,
0.6543272734,
-0.3146025538,
0.2660149038,
0.3213898242,
-0.2645089924,
-0.4586863518,
0.6597911119,
0.2044382244,
0.5799695253,
0.5994336009,
-0.0011730531,
-0.6039725542,
-0.7102829814,
-0.7713106871,
0.3290890157,
-0.6404742599,
-0.0168955605,
-0.5617440939,
-0.5475786924,
-0.6161802411,
-0.2255381346,
-0.6474975944,
-0.133359462,
-0.1659467518,
-0.0737050474,
0.0296458639,
0.9112097025,
0.2880169451,
0.3069568872,
-0.8553177714,
0.3480703831,
0.3130936027,
0.121466741,
-0.1286787242,
-0.6624829769,
-0.3203932345,
0.3657354116,
-0.2738373876,
-0.5285184979,
0.533765018,
0.0838296488,
0.6288045645,
0.147160545,
0.0535236485,
0.9512718916,
-0.8631054759,
0.8391249776,
0.2954735756,
-1.223728776,
0.5110332966,
-0.3191640675,
0.6211198568,
0.2129197568,
0.0868060738,
-0.9096091986,
-0.5800926685,
-0.115996398,
-0.9257067442,
0.6269768476,
-0.113629058,
0.0245432705,
0.2187755704,
0.10946583,
-0.0292510446,
0.4090853631,
-0.5198972821,
-0.1255855709,
0.1332696229,
-0.3715307415,
-0.530068934,
-0.2825315297,
-0.0469211452,
-0.0440471545,
0.6229145527,
0.0725177526,
0.3973228037,
0.1092147455,
-0.3023368716,
-0.1621810049,
0.6095904708,
0.9379752278,
0.6099375486,
0.025833115,
0.2371492386,
0.4738111198,
-0.2289137393,
0.3073656857,
-0.1272177547,
-0.0282886997,
-0.0446489304,
0.236190185,
0.8691114187,
0.3976285756,
-0.4041864574,
0.3452182412,
0.1327956766,
-0.1277273446,
-0.4707036018,
0.0387813449,
0.1973323822,
0.2948183119,
0.2420268357,
-0.0740520582,
-0.0641892254,
-0.4756847918,
0.072215043,
0.2081367075,
-0.344032377,
-0.1666452736,
1.02298069,
0.4201786816,
-0.5185627937,
0.3711441457,
0.1677632779,
-0.3968148828,
0.3162489235,
0.7991714478,
0.9771322608,
-0.4529033303,
-0.1167467535,
0.2352356166,
0.3854254484,
-0.4273757637,
0.2334744036,
0.0231332965,
-0.5001690388,
-0.8562007546,
-0.5600219965,
-0.6083717346,
0.3323224187,
-0.5833158493,
0.3796744347,
-0.262170434,
-0.2819556296,
-0.1340911388,
-0.3955147564,
-0.7124039531,
-0.0194854196,
0.4050503969,
1.0718415976,
-0.5471036434,
1.3332406282,
0.4574412405,
-0.0859745741,
-0.6742861867,
-0.0230089147,
-0.1376559287,
-0.7412183881,
0.5540222526,
0.0961576402,
-0.5133705735,
0.3622133434,
-0.5296131968,
-0.9203989506,
0.9602023363,
0.6759496927,
-1.1845991611,
0.0301992521,
0.4308647513,
0.5238713026,
-0.5990445018,
-0.2424988002,
0.6047397256,
0.294244945,
0.1107762307,
-1.3195571899,
-0.1107762828,
-0.1106438562,
0.1870516986,
0.1353088915,
-0.5933567882,
0.6856483221,
-0.155463621,
-0.3130169213,
0.1242151782,
0.6879712939,
0.2961965203,
0.222108677,
0.570940733,
0.1911516339,
0.8899516463,
-0.0569266565,
0.8710666299,
-0.417381376,
-0.2575074136,
1.4962469339,
-0.5621798635,
1.276201129,
0.5850102305,
-0.1010762975,
0.1856797785,
0.581692934,
0.2409879565,
0.449267596,
0.2229113877,
-0.3022547662,
-0.3450957239,
-0.3709979057,
-0.6220588684,
0.4582190812,
0.4618085623,
-0.3617267609,
0.3230997026,
0.0358804353,
-0.1826469004,
0.0027124584,
-0.4602799118,
0.6996777058,
0.5114289522,
-0.5707211494,
0.5914527178,
-0.066445075,
0.693238616,
-0.7896001935,
0.0525108241,
0.0911684558,
0.2247519344,
0.0640300438,
-0.6649739146,
0.2558246255,
0.2208671123,
0.0611609891,
-0.6745742559,
0.3639862239,
-0.8544607162,
-0.4776381254,
0.4013905525,
0.436304003,
0.3065115213,
0.1277059764,
-0.4292984903,
0.2469000667,
0.0610241517,
-0.0185683966,
0.0590859689,
0.3904767931,
0.1086001992,
0.6175638437,
0.7409273386,
0.5686995983,
0.0878721103,
0.2566566467,
0.5546515584,
-0.8148978949,
-0.6628646255,
-0.693600297,
0.4251328707,
0.0804399997,
-0.080027923,
0.6385423541,
0.4878158271,
1.040399909,
-0.1896798909,
0.922403872,
0.2870649397,
0.3745813072,
-0.7233278155,
0.721748054,
-0.4327067435,
0.2177618295,
-0.1715381742,
-0.8761758208,
-0.2605076134,
0.4975345731,
-0.4863585532,
-0.2672367096,
0.7527202964,
0.837220192,
0.165997237,
-0.082771726,
0.5483571887,
0.2730332613,
0.4213353395,
0.6916210055,
0.8377436996,
-0.3980877995,
0.6678299308,
0.052786909,
-0.0585800521,
-0.2354447991,
-0.8444117308,
-0.6587719321,
-0.3715565801,
-0.1690830439,
-0.0972830802,
0.0740013793,
1.2315260172,
0.7299595475,
-0.8946735263,
-0.6346706152,
0.0314316303,
0.0030752243,
-0.6541383862,
-0.0451285988,
0.1207878217,
-0.2846942544,
-1.1296526194,
0.8922079206,
0.1346776038,
0.1870613098,
-0.1955492795,
-0.1763013452,
-0.2873503566,
0.1710304469,
0.7763721347,
-0.0977273509,
-0.8843294382,
-0.2884417474,
0.0270290673,
-0.2965306342,
0.0636569709,
0.9287290573,
-0.2272208184,
0.4649922252,
0.4444270432,
0.7229237556,
0.6789950728,
-0.2457519472,
1.0225983858,
-0.8097311854,
0.2055360675,
0.1794690341,
0.4134432077,
0.3676052094,
-0.3443448544,
0.5699301958,
0.0115369633,
-0.6182385087,
-0.9702034593,
0.2908958793,
-0.8309341073,
-0.0663767755,
1.1301683187,
0.0131008672,
-0.4670756459,
-0.020610515,
-0.251419723,
0.7024261951,
-0.3782549798,
0.5839107037,
0.6590698361,
0.0330161341,
-0.2090615183,
-0.6380264759,
0.2857260704,
0.2752515972,
-0.599914372,
0.3069524467,
0.2531088591,
-0.1114562824,
-0.1110899672,
0.5593825579,
-0.1615157574,
0.2083247006,
-0.0718863532,
0.2109785229,
-0.092517063,
-0.2523075044,
-0.3113898933,
-0.1550747156,
0.3997834325,
-0.4103110433
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14203v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14203v1
|
Shai: A large language model for asset management
| 2023-12-21T05:08:57 | 2023-12-21T05:08:57 |
Zhongyang Guo, Guanran Jiang, Zhongdan Zhang, Peng Li, Zhefeng Wang, Yinchun Wang
|
q-fin.PM
|
q-fin.PM, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper introduces "Shai" a 10B level large language model specifically
designed for the asset management industry, built upon an open-source
foundational model. With continuous pre-training and fine-tuning using a
targeted corpus, Shai demonstrates enhanced performance in tasks relevant to
its domain, outperforming baseline models. Our research includes the
development of an innovative evaluation framework, which integrates
professional qualification exams, tailored tasks, open-ended question
answering, and safety assessments, to comprehensively assess Shai's
capabilities. Furthermore, we discuss the challenges and implications of
utilizing large language models like GPT-4 for performance assessment in asset
management, suggesting a combination of automated evaluation and human
judgment. Shai's development, showcasing the potential and versatility of
10B-level large language models in the financial sector with significant
performance and modest computational requirements, hopes to provide practical
insights and methodologies to assist industry peers in their similar endeavors.
|
[
-0.254124552,
-0.5871143341,
0.3142755926,
0.2380803674,
-0.0328139737,
0.1501615494,
-0.2412234545,
-0.87337327,
-0.1177030504,
0.6014196277,
0.0125604402,
-0.3397948444,
-0.4935789704,
-0.5173684359,
-0.6208357215,
1.0283761024,
-0.1929193735,
0.06789314,
0.0259877164,
-0.300595969,
-0.6053628922,
-0.453969568,
-0.9954068661,
-0.4208912253,
0.3303723335,
0.1044617891,
1.0094001293,
0.6320763826,
0.8253887892,
0.3512776196,
0.0042455867,
-0.2700921893,
-0.3331237435,
-0.1786505431,
-0.3483991921,
0.020182224,
-0.8276254535,
0.0027412034,
0.814722538,
0.8209484816,
-0.1669154018,
0.3523053229,
-0.388278991,
0.6924167871,
-1.0241425037,
0.1324519664,
-0.2159209549,
-0.5193037391,
-0.2907346785,
0.2463712841,
-0.1688261032,
-0.1337227672,
0.288669616,
-0.2063263059,
-0.3993549049,
0.2620841265,
1.1233164072,
-0.1242726147,
-0.350412935,
-0.4858859181,
-0.903799057,
1.0504854918,
-0.6922259927,
0.4400063455,
0.4575362802,
0.4486475885,
0.5392670035,
-0.660551846,
-0.3604483902,
-0.3046019375,
0.3243072629,
-0.2458092868,
-0.1634769589,
-0.0382183865,
0.1582188755,
0.7467816472,
-0.1669466197,
0.3156286478,
-0.5115532279,
-0.1714813411,
0.772716701,
0.1781362593,
0.438747853,
0.2765239477,
-0.434363991,
-0.2634342313,
-0.7446242571,
-0.0367839858,
0.765152812,
-0.0245811865,
0.0548033603,
0.1912761927,
-0.1561455727,
0.5367836952,
-0.3319712281,
-0.2083831131,
0.0639256015,
-0.3254955709,
-0.3742262721,
-0.0947670117,
0.5540448427,
0.0226918329,
-0.0611995719,
-0.2561640441,
-0.5298996568,
-0.0322954953,
0.278386265,
-1.0668945312,
-0.3907395303,
0.4511930645,
-0.5534488559,
-0.5747411251,
0.1783119142,
-0.522852242,
-0.3565048575,
-0.2696738541,
0.6196165681,
-0.6541952491,
-0.3815405965,
0.3145163357,
-0.005119998,
0.7755095363,
0.0046649729,
-0.8561628461,
0.4516237676,
0.7857214212,
0.6063862443,
-0.04471118,
-0.280870527,
-0.5044375062,
0.6504674554,
-0.5563025475,
0.6349593997,
-0.6634751558,
-0.3958210349,
-0.0345975794,
-0.4504004121,
0.3252462745,
-0.555110693,
0.724729538,
-0.9229174256,
0.0248183869,
-0.516759932,
-0.3405025899,
-0.3743528426,
0.2032178342,
-0.6458293796,
0.9378564954,
0.3795747757,
-0.5848562121,
0.4194712937,
-1.0986845493,
-0.2530510128,
0.2272756398,
0.1727367043,
-0.5727372169,
-0.2108407915,
0.0449765399,
0.2069822848,
-0.5893447399,
0.5202041864,
-0.4420856833,
-0.2835576534,
0.4775307178,
-0.1941487193,
0.4606530964,
0.6864259243,
-0.1476952136,
0.3445628583,
-0.7193365693,
0.1353259087,
-0.0538642034,
-0.1136416942,
-0.496979028,
-0.1201105788,
0.511086762,
0.0748668388,
0.8127321005,
-0.4953043461,
-0.2562497556,
-0.3580408692,
0.5259822011,
0.7032701373,
-0.1654185951,
0.4529846907,
-0.514111042,
0.3994920552,
0.0661956221,
0.0699126497,
-0.3151663542,
0.1072628871,
-0.7327598333,
-0.4091911018,
0.4725624919,
0.4565083086,
-0.1553666741,
0.2513736784,
-0.317676574,
-0.7340654731,
-0.3274803758,
0.3294657171,
0.469219327,
0.0584168173,
0.0635092035,
-0.5326977968,
-0.4821022749,
-0.9792155027,
-0.1669113487,
-0.1218411326,
0.1827649623,
0.3826719522,
0.541262567,
-0.376296401,
0.6672207713,
-0.558537364,
-0.2253626138,
-0.3766702116,
0.1805044115,
0.1651391685,
0.5582378507,
0.7463243008,
-0.8355857134,
-0.0050171618,
0.3980089724,
-0.6936027408,
-0.0537750721,
0.0402487405,
-0.3806949854,
-0.30989784,
0.47804299,
-0.232334733,
0.1704815626,
0.4847957194,
-0.2917496562,
0.5876801014,
-0.3620835543,
0.1231801286,
-1.1480089426,
0.643835187,
-0.044198025,
-0.1205682307,
-0.5909011364,
0.6687294245,
0.0463988073,
-0.7120240331,
-0.3995828032,
0.7842784524,
-0.5331619382,
-0.5488768816,
-0.3840836883,
0.0394985229,
-0.1312891245,
0.2052163035,
-0.2620974779,
1.0213428736,
0.7562240958,
-0.7562673092,
0.4671879709,
0.3002169132,
-0.7336604595,
0.725898087,
-0.9179436564,
0.1570952833,
0.1718689054,
-0.16052562,
-0.6974367499,
-0.37705639,
-0.457916826,
0.0911770537,
0.5574218035,
0.2272831351,
-0.1455711573,
-0.5222435594,
-0.1430013925,
0.7560821772,
0.3415377736,
-0.1904393584,
0.7888367176,
0.6814143658,
-0.2786535919,
-0.5802742839,
-0.5236382484,
0.3118197024,
-0.3694601655,
-0.8521111608,
0.1619826704,
-0.050151702,
-0.6598194838,
-0.1207478717,
-0.0751395077,
-0.5668354034,
0.3824327588,
0.2823611796,
0.4407180548,
-0.2727412581,
-0.1228661537,
-0.4589036405,
-0.2771639228,
0.0783162042,
-0.553029418,
0.5272731781,
-0.4738467038,
-0.6195203066,
-0.3853867948,
0.3090773225,
0.6511843801,
-0.8993576169,
0.7587189078,
0.7619236708,
-0.353046447,
0.1179364622,
-0.7157008648,
0.4525420368,
-0.5297053456,
0.6063172221,
-0.465975225,
-0.9529827833,
0.8350307941,
-0.3754692674,
-0.0200644005,
0.4173374176,
0.7754658461,
0.0101148011,
0.7466027737,
0.8350216746,
-0.5091226697,
0.6161237359,
-0.5486251116,
0.4932767451,
-0.6745167375,
-0.0732374415,
-0.6127769947,
-0.5598341823,
-0.0659229085,
-0.2977308333,
0.4605824649,
0.127754882,
-0.6579889059,
0.3845772445,
0.0156881344,
0.6491119862,
0.2890168428,
-0.0282259341,
0.2513463199,
-0.5207846761,
0.207106635,
0.4098711312,
-0.0312156659,
-0.726038456,
0.9857172966,
0.8190117478,
0.881947577,
0.4333343506,
0.5112873912,
0.3574149311,
0.3805342019,
-0.6597351432,
0.2784164548,
-0.1104737669,
-0.7921474576,
-0.4380131364,
-0.2877850831,
-0.6207051277,
-0.2578234076,
0.202357769,
-0.6038196087,
0.098498717,
-0.1660151333,
-0.5060644746,
0.5648217201,
-0.7255838513,
1.0495485067,
-0.4502417743,
-0.1807108223,
-0.6159550548,
-0.1491641402,
0.6651357412,
-0.4500172436,
0.433590889,
-0.269387871,
-0.1719872952,
0.8162007928,
-0.5122802854,
0.4536602497,
-0.1678118706,
-0.1564714462,
0.5470306873,
0.3014753461,
0.4358030856,
-0.1997788548,
-0.3152613044,
0.1731692553,
0.3845872879,
-0.863065362,
-0.3623950481,
0.9475515485,
-1.0482717752,
-0.2470011264,
-0.2495807558,
-0.6440178752,
-0.4468121231,
0.3374081254,
-0.2710775733,
0.5617076159,
-0.6316254735,
0.2905430496,
0.5961894393,
-0.2577001154,
0.6012825966,
0.391957432,
-0.3891011477,
-0.4221384525,
0.9888002276,
-0.2067452818,
0.2766235173,
0.2711479366,
0.1260853261,
-0.3324536085,
-0.824847877,
-0.2856152058,
0.2322430164,
-0.6198712587,
-0.2898686528,
-0.4680809379,
-0.1839992553,
-0.3062797785,
-0.1931862533,
-0.4219792187,
-0.0448593795,
0.2426295877,
-0.20681113,
0.1249672547,
1.0263869762,
0.1486798972,
0.5008102655,
-0.7266247869,
0.0467539243,
0.49876073,
0.894299984,
0.1474086046,
-0.5605154634,
-0.8329995275,
-0.0773865432,
-0.4918002188,
-0.488050729,
0.450623244,
0.3102625906,
0.4267683327,
0.77349931,
-0.1440059245,
0.6522556543,
-0.1178244427,
0.6604024172,
0.2300348729,
-1.3099272251,
0.3652661741,
-0.7779497504,
0.0987442806,
0.5683597326,
0.2334488779,
-0.5081470609,
-0.0728359818,
-0.4906607866,
-0.8201795816,
0.4669250846,
-0.1130131483,
0.3838425577,
0.0857772827,
0.189669624,
-0.1553135812,
0.2805162966,
-0.5847014785,
0.1108289659,
0.1069621295,
0.0236430094,
0.2584826648,
-0.5880053043,
-0.0101048369,
0.0168583915,
0.9114906192,
-0.0679434538,
0.0612052344,
-0.2425109595,
-0.0974771976,
-0.1649037302,
0.2316655368,
0.3699816763,
1.1804032326,
-0.099227041,
-0.2208591402,
0.4101275504,
-0.4546106756,
-0.1160589308,
-0.163297683,
0.0681223869,
-0.5482253432,
0.279656142,
0.8925208449,
0.6075794697,
-0.7924514413,
0.8720806241,
0.4208074212,
-0.0903423131,
-0.542530179,
-0.0569272861,
0.0352736749,
0.1985850185,
0.4432224929,
-0.0047395192,
0.0446970016,
-0.7637124062,
0.2990063131,
0.4614054859,
-0.5263486505,
-0.2903736234,
0.9313558936,
0.1701997668,
0.0276629683,
0.4945086837,
-0.0665763319,
-0.311268568,
0.2919757366,
0.2224519253,
1.048297286,
-0.2452657968,
0.1040868908,
0.2059275508,
0.0513087623,
-0.1422649473,
0.3932660818,
0.1088875607,
-0.7728720307,
-0.7558141351,
-1.1190989017,
-0.6144081354,
0.144509539,
-0.6280963421,
0.4924832284,
-0.9526335001,
-0.1469566971,
0.0876736492,
0.2122568637,
-0.7630468607,
0.2444092631,
0.1858757585,
1.0269114971,
-0.7058108449,
0.9811378717,
0.6944819093,
-0.8037190437,
-0.8961760998,
-0.2696301937,
-0.5104368329,
-0.9776280522,
0.6516218781,
-0.2199792117,
-0.0059029805,
-0.1289017648,
-0.6289134026,
-1.1380910873,
1.1655776501,
0.2691280246,
-0.1446614712,
-0.3060767055,
-0.0015598225,
0.5195249319,
-0.3397763371,
0.4239864349,
0.6267241836,
0.6527056098,
0.1355468929,
-1.0712801218,
-0.310590893,
-0.0002036218,
0.3543199003,
0.4447374046,
-0.9762299657,
0.7392041683,
-0.2160024047,
0.0037397482,
0.4151696265,
1.0291541815,
-0.114866212,
0.3507393599,
0.2643103004,
0.707608223,
0.733330667,
-0.0503456965,
1.2548686266,
-0.7030031085,
0.2551669776,
0.7986263633,
-0.4911497831,
1.0282381773,
0.0327408053,
-0.3906194866,
0.785214901,
0.2547538579,
0.0423871204,
0.1059003919,
0.1063060388,
-0.5062475204,
-0.4136981666,
-0.2500638664,
-0.1437239945,
0.9204765558,
0.1630374193,
-0.2763087749,
-0.0959363878,
-0.0548753887,
-0.0760790184,
0.2267464846,
-0.479151547,
0.6390651464,
0.1423520595,
-0.0534393229,
0.1723464876,
0.4839241803,
0.4299088717,
-0.7545827627,
0.3527829647,
0.061052382,
0.2435821146,
-0.0301825069,
-0.5889473557,
0.7168800235,
-0.0844454542,
-0.1165016592,
-0.4119489193,
0.755338788,
-0.3276364803,
-0.4994788766,
-0.0163136255,
0.3538376391,
0.2379474789,
-0.171966508,
-0.4916208088,
0.2354694456,
-0.3211964071,
0.1552585214,
0.6230256557,
0.5467538834,
-0.4159039259,
0.8871972561,
0.9132929444,
0.1735667288,
-0.470044136,
-0.0227362681,
0.9101879597,
-0.9614444375,
-0.6826964021,
-0.5536741614,
0.2113431692,
-0.0702441111,
-0.4030379057,
0.3564520776,
0.8216859698,
0.6605693698,
-0.0422357284,
0.612547636,
0.0463005342,
0.5905699134,
-0.2452948838,
1.0683076382,
-0.0142397471,
0.3646041751,
-0.4762008786,
-0.9842094779,
0.0947297588,
0.3458495438,
-0.648550272,
0.3048063815,
0.5466840863,
0.4506876767,
-0.0901190788,
0.0175372623,
0.7066072226,
0.2366136312,
0.3457240462,
0.5239374042,
0.6197194457,
-0.6524876356,
0.5051237345,
0.0167611055,
-0.0133972513,
0.1416267306,
-1.0046008825,
-0.5916952491,
-0.5059915781,
-0.4401563704,
-0.0671236888,
-0.2805427313,
0.5943172574,
0.740067482,
-1.2022553682,
-0.5956227183,
0.4419402182,
-0.1999382824,
-0.1891856492,
-0.1884387136,
0.2679162323,
-0.2492306381,
-0.6919291019,
0.3146007061,
0.4943991303,
-0.0976106673,
-0.6362151504,
-0.2140933871,
0.1454866678,
0.1308860928,
0.3786995411,
0.2299858779,
-0.3940552473,
-0.3779265583,
-0.2216863036,
0.0168368407,
-0.3935585916,
0.9633814096,
-0.3060828447,
0.2355647385,
0.2275017947,
1.0562264919,
0.5651772022,
0.129307285,
0.7558837533,
-0.5319885015,
0.2298820168,
0.1198427752,
0.4088461101,
0.3902840316,
-0.1886927038,
0.2879127264,
0.0802145526,
-0.7116683722,
-0.6607308984,
0.1539466232,
-0.8772648573,
-0.0546643808,
0.986060679,
-0.1188347563,
-0.3180244565,
0.0154900579,
-0.2524190843,
-0.1676343381,
-0.2145202011,
0.4784713089,
1.0478701591,
0.4010244608,
-0.0668298826,
-0.6385216713,
0.3710134625,
0.2611193359,
-0.6683599353,
0.0710430965,
0.6113476157,
0.2901079059,
0.2211530656,
0.5338555574,
-0.3461238444,
0.3225672245,
-0.0672107637,
0.2263111472,
-0.2682279348,
-0.0990493745,
-0.281301111,
0.2959265709,
0.6027011275,
0.0633903965
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14202v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14202v1
|
Illuminating the Black Box: A Psychometric Investigation into the Multifaceted Nature of Large Language Models
| 2023-12-21T04:57:21 | 2023-12-21T04:57:21 |
Yang Lu, Jordan Yu, Shou-Hsuan Stephen Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This study explores the idea of AI Personality or AInality suggesting that
Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibit patterns similar to human personalities.
Assuming that LLMs share these patterns with humans, we investigate using
human-centered psychometric tests such as the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator
(MBTI), Big Five Inventory (BFI), and Short Dark Triad (SD3) to identify and
confirm LLM personality types. By introducing role-play prompts, we demonstrate
the adaptability of LLMs, showing their ability to switch dynamically between
different personality types. Using projective tests, such as the Washington
University Sentence Completion Test (WUSCT), we uncover hidden aspects of LLM
personalities that are not easily accessible through direct questioning.
Projective tests allowed for a deep exploration of LLMs cognitive processes and
thought patterns and gave us a multidimensional view of AInality. Our machine
learning analysis revealed that LLMs exhibit distinct AInality traits and
manifest diverse personality types, demonstrating dynamic shifts in response to
external instructions. This study pioneers the application of projective tests
on LLMs, shedding light on their diverse and adaptable AInality traits.
|
[
-0.4274076819,
-0.9954933524,
0.7689421773,
0.278799355,
0.1229903251,
0.5010913014,
-0.1814316511,
-0.6401000023,
0.2640044093,
0.3361063898,
-0.6400995851,
-0.206050843,
-0.5430091619,
0.0789163336,
-0.4639548957,
0.9423502088,
0.0496456474,
0.067791976,
0.0134380935,
-0.2426865995,
-0.4726625681,
-0.5951178074,
-0.7109875083,
-0.3690080643,
0.5716178417,
0.3222336173,
0.6758602262,
0.4252634943,
0.4296207428,
0.2684301734,
0.21381028,
-0.0856131539,
-0.4301418066,
-0.0086468654,
-0.0847657546,
-0.6432889104,
-0.3290116489,
-0.0275776125,
0.5721949935,
0.7956565022,
0.0714254156,
0.2848544419,
0.0922078937,
0.6120790839,
-0.5472264886,
0.0979216695,
-0.5775262713,
-0.1020633951,
-0.2497566491,
0.0309649762,
-0.3682511747,
-0.2429557443,
-0.1863907874,
-0.2496591657,
0.0800541416,
0.296677947,
0.5511143804,
0.3547170162,
-0.8033785224,
-0.2392995805,
-0.911147058,
0.7317617536,
-0.4920599461,
0.3178853095,
0.3964678347,
0.3608921766,
-0.0359839648,
-0.0824441984,
-0.7238146067,
-0.5178349018,
-0.2636689544,
-0.0356536284,
-0.0657634288,
0.0502697676,
0.1296258271,
0.3531799316,
-0.580252111,
0.1521756202,
-0.4147169292,
-0.031968683,
0.9615366459,
0.3295478225,
0.3014234602,
0.0430233553,
0.1445202827,
0.0135731548,
-0.6500132084,
0.2261933982,
0.6204271317,
-0.0148347383,
-0.2571882308,
0.700088203,
-0.0121884122,
0.5982465744,
0.0181820206,
-0.0602664687,
0.0924288407,
-0.217253238,
0.0529662967,
0.0694357082,
0.669934094,
0.1751981974,
0.4812245667,
-0.1962635964,
-0.2051130682,
0.0177630465,
0.7082061172,
-0.6664130092,
-0.174102813,
0.4033159912,
-0.5702552199,
-0.1505926549,
-0.0056779939,
-0.6901953816,
-0.583091557,
-0.326315105,
0.4515047073,
-0.5254706144,
-0.2856891751,
-0.1334240437,
0.1252564043,
0.5174851418,
0.1878799945,
-1.1428450346,
0.237224713,
0.8923848271,
0.8090771437,
-0.3661551774,
-0.3918509781,
-0.3984207809,
-0.0247383267,
-0.5127413273,
0.6589726806,
-0.6608108878,
-0.2368865013,
-0.0110435821,
-0.0591030344,
0.0534710735,
-0.4608843029,
0.1850434989,
-0.1818904728,
0.0768576488,
-0.2471942008,
-0.3186925054,
-0.2849921286,
0.4116298556,
-0.4341974556,
0.9654279947,
0.3928830922,
-0.5075038075,
0.3285827637,
-0.8526542187,
-0.0801194459,
0.3295140266,
-0.6607019305,
-0.3379354179,
0.3568219244,
-0.3665445447,
0.5915826559,
-0.18707937,
0.3212450743,
-0.5989781022,
-0.525205493,
0.7051050067,
-0.2192760855,
0.8515059352,
-0.1604153663,
-0.5054907799,
0.2167730182,
-1.1124840975,
-0.1353131533,
0.201390177,
-0.1678181142,
-0.2685922384,
0.0654007941,
0.0862642601,
0.2840946019,
0.107500121,
-0.7419312596,
0.2797221243,
-0.2014252841,
0.2666769624,
0.951074481,
-0.0744309127,
-0.0055063181,
-0.5046911836,
0.6198823452,
-0.0321944952,
0.0026355055,
0.2936102748,
-0.5962893963,
-0.9845486283,
-0.3954721391,
-0.2206339538,
0.6694873571,
-0.3336506188,
0.7785625458,
0.0532238334,
-0.6142202616,
-0.9324926734,
0.2472983003,
0.2922501862,
-0.0658576339,
0.008492168,
-0.3023599088,
-0.2497919947,
-1.290640831,
-0.1487832516,
-0.3571800888,
-0.0495425761,
0.5067243576,
0.8367304802,
-0.509047091,
0.7438671589,
-0.4827263057,
0.0374977961,
-0.264799118,
0.0030569753,
0.1702531427,
0.2043195963,
0.5963923931,
-0.6638410687,
-0.4455003738,
0.0126495427,
-0.7221672535,
-0.0878939703,
-0.0662735254,
-0.0842509568,
0.0001431319,
0.6418064833,
-0.4726929665,
0.5295593739,
0.4616507888,
-0.9072843194,
0.8173907995,
-0.1481179446,
0.0081485007,
-0.7755609751,
0.2051220238,
-0.1527490914,
0.1811364889,
-0.642706275,
0.1598291099,
0.05500618,
0.1749425679,
-0.0546631962,
0.8044534326,
-0.3542779684,
-0.3614429235,
-0.1519607604,
-0.2198172361,
-0.0179572776,
0.5230385661,
-0.2899633348,
0.968167603,
0.622181654,
-0.5585455894,
0.2957900763,
0.1793868244,
-0.3461963832,
0.8916841745,
-0.6163085103,
0.2145766318,
-0.5228820443,
-0.1690564305,
-1.2781853676,
-0.1922203451,
-0.0315005742,
-0.1744025201,
0.175174281,
0.1155594066,
-0.6482738853,
-0.1356306672,
-0.2260285616,
0.4288254976,
0.4323660433,
-0.2244948596,
0.7088755369,
0.0655353442,
-0.5095345974,
-0.3575163782,
-0.5885848403,
-0.0175282285,
-0.4874493778,
-0.3071497083,
0.1836812347,
-0.7747215033,
-0.822961092,
-0.3896831572,
0.2346830219,
-0.0726716071,
0.5528734326,
0.376254648,
0.4096336961,
-0.3033854663,
0.024370471,
-0.2796621919,
0.1238438115,
0.3274208605,
0.1662049592,
0.648252666,
-0.3482061923,
-0.4096437693,
-0.0555968434,
0.5046833158,
0.6596440077,
-0.2284105271,
0.9865182042,
0.8704760671,
-0.1674754471,
-0.0411470532,
-0.6014828682,
-0.1361782849,
-0.4701918662,
0.4511269927,
-0.3455244601,
-0.84302634,
0.6967249513,
0.3696676791,
0.0815607533,
0.0227026157,
0.7774547338,
0.0477335304,
0.888917625,
0.8690423369,
0.0806462839,
0.4197824299,
-0.1605565995,
0.5235029459,
-1.0631548166,
-0.1839042753,
-0.3924793899,
-0.5037156343,
-0.6170390248,
-0.0146659967,
0.3900487125,
-0.1640324146,
-0.5642638206,
-0.1532098353,
-0.535649538,
0.5119244456,
0.4435746372,
-0.1853348017,
0.3652800918,
-0.4427883625,
0.0728654116,
0.002226175,
0.0713172778,
-0.5847352147,
1.4395262003,
0.4496914148,
0.6071900129,
0.6056743264,
0.5861980915,
0.3347936273,
0.5896799564,
-0.8088100553,
0.551502943,
-0.017176874,
-0.7690412998,
-0.2558127642,
-0.1937393546,
-0.9336568713,
0.1946951002,
-0.2745581269,
-1.2796350718,
0.1362585723,
-0.0662799776,
-0.3854138553,
0.1384910494,
-0.8978282213,
0.7257856727,
-0.5656166673,
-0.1881050915,
-0.0028608425,
-0.4964748919,
0.6441558003,
-0.4455427229,
0.1598620117,
-0.1541805714,
-0.151516512,
0.6230875254,
0.3078755736,
0.7128519416,
0.125379324,
-0.1549981683,
-0.2410171926,
0.4874213338,
0.1697205156,
0.2443394363,
-0.0667495877,
0.1985270232,
0.0930731297,
-0.4512424767,
-0.6724162698,
0.6384804845,
-1.0903712511,
-0.678134501,
-0.4140702188,
-0.8567845821,
-0.3952837884,
0.2873710096,
-0.127866894,
0.237736389,
-0.4340932965,
0.2461844236,
0.5563744903,
-0.3449496031,
0.3251024783,
0.5968077779,
-0.3987361789,
-0.0306108929,
0.7430772185,
0.0047476483,
0.4497616887,
0.3454785049,
0.2416251749,
-0.1960915029,
-0.8017600775,
-0.2395010442,
0.5665774345,
-0.5298498869,
0.2385325581,
-0.8996005654,
-0.3850669563,
-0.3922976255,
-0.3401521444,
-0.1226441711,
-0.0326795168,
0.0010600056,
-0.0701582283,
0.3124705255,
1.182790637,
0.3325382769,
0.4636623561,
-0.3508818746,
0.4211680889,
0.4569192827,
0.4607898891,
0.0816871524,
-0.3641115129,
0.0150354719,
-0.1377349496,
-0.5842175484,
-0.8514147401,
0.3021298051,
0.2287541181,
0.5325811505,
0.5675241947,
-0.2535076141,
0.281278342,
-0.403680563,
0.8095709682,
-0.1268711984,
-0.742144227,
0.2050265223,
-0.4275766909,
0.1460516602,
0.6696785092,
0.4256775379,
-0.5614224076,
-0.5499140024,
-0.6653763652,
-0.5076992512,
0.6456412673,
0.2501838505,
-0.0158479698,
0.1784583777,
0.4726904035,
0.3480466604,
0.4676878154,
-1.1003495455,
-0.6653442383,
-0.2249673456,
-0.526041925,
-0.5678890347,
-0.1228924543,
-0.1991697252,
-0.2052732408,
0.3402774036,
-0.3394535184,
0.4829306006,
-0.0722011849,
0.0978187323,
-0.045197133,
0.6067382097,
0.5807389617,
0.8067718744,
-0.5007318854,
0.0548081174,
-0.1890441775,
-0.5312244892,
0.4015024602,
0.163651213,
-0.117810376,
-0.3161377311,
0.5143291354,
0.7069650888,
-0.0870499164,
-0.8230763674,
0.4330989718,
-0.0364204198,
-0.1269801855,
-0.6628613472,
0.3433530927,
0.1806248873,
0.3087675571,
0.4287127554,
-0.2642070949,
0.2083377093,
-1.2380495071,
0.0012968064,
0.7140381336,
-0.3071710467,
-0.3434813321,
0.3356235027,
-0.0982876644,
-0.8487277627,
0.5302234888,
-0.5050026178,
-0.3216407001,
0.5597031116,
0.4979596436,
0.8888035417,
-0.1542938352,
0.2837548256,
-0.0047602789,
0.5472565889,
0.4031972289,
0.3057293594,
0.0896765292,
-0.9390204549,
-0.261510402,
-0.6046343446,
-0.3715013862,
0.5669103861,
-0.5656167269,
0.0324580073,
-0.699440062,
0.209673956,
0.2452499866,
0.1950668544,
-0.7480705976,
-0.1047903001,
0.247254476,
0.6703794599,
-0.737156868,
0.5710420012,
0.606379807,
-0.2023338228,
-0.5846658349,
0.1216418669,
0.2088807225,
-1.1261515617,
0.7809351087,
0.3316731453,
0.3849922717,
-0.0452970378,
-0.461528033,
-0.7733300924,
1.0609532595,
0.2576285303,
-0.3398026228,
-0.2027686089,
0.2437143773,
0.6209567189,
-0.6468966603,
0.616170764,
0.8699389696,
0.5856116414,
-0.3079230189,
-0.8299618959,
0.0598737001,
-0.3211483955,
-0.1620525867,
0.4743041396,
-0.8306047916,
0.8544233441,
-0.1908655167,
0.0340897217,
0.0367304124,
0.2474511564,
0.5373035669,
0.1769541055,
0.5395647883,
0.2661753595,
0.6033385396,
0.1194762588,
0.9865043163,
-0.2992089391,
-0.1804455668,
0.7532120347,
-0.4477682412,
0.6598508358,
0.5034044385,
-0.1818470508,
0.7779587507,
0.2899560928,
-0.1335715503,
0.1229518205,
0.3966335654,
-0.1147289798,
-0.0452842899,
-0.098516278,
-0.0590460971,
0.6471108198,
0.5343549252,
-0.0348698124,
-0.0123802768,
0.0607793704,
0.022768911,
0.0051645236,
-0.2050783932,
0.7741975188,
0.0432041064,
-0.8081288338,
0.3956126571,
-0.1429917812,
0.9219004512,
-0.7597156763,
-0.0480477288,
-0.2157336771,
0.206791684,
-0.0559012368,
-0.9795009494,
0.3028107882,
-0.2124334127,
-0.0410614088,
-0.1990045756,
0.2906972468,
-0.400477767,
-0.7255479097,
0.455085218,
0.6590171456,
0.136448428,
-0.0871110633,
-0.8599901199,
-0.0206383411,
0.0485715158,
0.0181883853,
0.5230628848,
0.4469683468,
-0.0656369925,
0.9401112795,
0.5889647603,
0.354711026,
-0.022697296,
-0.0917041674,
0.3576804399,
-1.0465425253,
-0.5061432719,
-0.9097731113,
0.4953122139,
-0.0399516858,
-0.5719416142,
0.706166029,
0.4289348423,
0.5794327259,
0.0389750972,
0.6711792946,
0.0453586578,
0.4017578959,
-0.446035862,
0.6669379473,
-0.4760297239,
0.1169617027,
-0.3142863214,
-1.0145622492,
0.0364637487,
0.5245007277,
-0.2579876781,
0.158848092,
0.867595911,
0.8836606145,
-0.0844440386,
-0.1183186993,
0.4496896565,
0.5388560891,
0.533905983,
0.6373801827,
0.8869117498,
-0.135766387,
0.2250448912,
-0.1695813537,
-0.4322736561,
-0.2830039561,
-0.5425300598,
-1.1819115877,
-0.7597181797,
-0.2909098566,
-0.353800863,
-0.2184931785,
0.8570044041,
0.6380624175,
-0.4948339462,
-0.4066580534,
0.1276749223,
0.0994644314,
-0.179578647,
-0.3409092426,
0.1769022495,
0.091368638,
-0.3504769504,
0.1487769485,
0.4700731933,
0.2724055052,
-0.8562576771,
0.0267635398,
-0.1029588282,
0.3288585842,
0.5718825459,
-0.0135827353,
-0.8908560276,
-0.5224409103,
0.0620482937,
0.0942711085,
0.0125553925,
0.9701229334,
-0.3508153558,
0.2236327529,
0.0690660998,
0.7009264827,
0.0240038875,
-0.2538943291,
0.5710145831,
-0.6630938649,
0.2208748907,
0.293753922,
0.431681186,
0.3281002641,
-0.7943429351,
0.4173953533,
0.0231965594,
-0.697979033,
-0.9275461435,
0.4427330494,
-1.2084797621,
-0.2919452488,
1.2316770554,
0.2456348985,
-0.1713267863,
-0.593577683,
-0.1893272847,
-0.3401112258,
-0.3132143021,
1.1318428516,
1.1049298048,
-0.3514859974,
-0.4214461148,
-0.7621026039,
0.4875348806,
0.3671863675,
-0.9776602387,
0.0581686459,
0.2643918991,
0.2877753973,
0.3891782761,
0.7568562627,
0.1213550493,
0.0670720115,
-0.2712698877,
0.0793375596,
0.1218092144,
-0.1874036491,
-0.3678964376,
-0.0505112968,
0.3133837879,
0.2514879704
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13558v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13558v1
|
The Truth is in There: Improving Reasoning in Language Models with Layer-Selective Rank Reduction
| 2023-12-21T03:51:08 | 2023-12-21T03:51:08 |
Pratyusha Sharma, Jordan T. Ash, Dipendra Misra
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Transformer-based Large Language Models (LLMs) have become a fixture in
modern machine learning. Correspondingly, significant resources are allocated
towards research that aims to further advance this technology, typically
resulting in models of increasing size that are trained on increasing amounts
of data. This work, however, demonstrates the surprising result that it is
often possible to significantly improve the performance of LLMs by selectively
removing higher-order components of their weight matrices. This simple
intervention, which we call LAyer-SElective Rank reduction (LASER), can be done
on a model after training has completed, and requires no additional parameters
or data. We show extensive experiments demonstrating the generality of this
finding across language models and datasets, and provide in-depth analyses
offering insights into both when LASER is effective and the mechanism by which
it operates.
|
[
-0.4609566629,
-0.5544881225,
0.8035939932,
-0.1152516231,
-0.0653702468,
0.2708385289,
-0.2467086017,
-0.4940632582,
-0.1332829148,
0.8768261075,
-0.4487401247,
-0.351742357,
-0.7722030282,
-0.0931104347,
-0.5698682666,
0.8815612793,
0.159430027,
0.3321296275,
-0.0665236339,
0.0135280844,
-0.1164512411,
-0.4417698085,
-0.8347358704,
-0.7146779895,
0.8991883397,
0.1742414385,
0.7119258642,
0.9015648961,
0.9493436217,
0.3025883734,
-0.4530970156,
0.2931094468,
-0.4572046995,
0.0108344052,
-0.0073359329,
-0.667091012,
-0.3786598146,
0.1230337545,
1.0675971508,
1.2437045574,
-0.0596541129,
-0.0945372134,
-0.1425109059,
0.8825491071,
-0.6729570627,
-0.0520293713,
-0.8052802682,
0.1918287426,
-0.0462999344,
-0.0207977109,
-0.8640161753,
-0.0921522155,
0.0764093772,
-0.3962786198,
0.2627390921,
-0.0879627243,
0.9068414569,
0.5646256804,
-0.3255466223,
0.1862851828,
-1.0344127417,
0.964446187,
-0.5665698647,
0.6736550927,
0.3642125428,
0.4281401038,
-0.0193102602,
-0.648645997,
-0.1081816033,
-0.4391820431,
-0.0256311018,
0.0205289479,
-0.0770571008,
0.3370423615,
0.6133827567,
0.2107901722,
-0.2341581434,
0.258010149,
-0.2955406904,
-0.0125951609,
0.4482865036,
-0.0681321025,
0.2906247079,
0.0228558835,
-0.1387331039,
-0.0577008948,
-1.044537425,
0.1566676497,
0.1462837905,
0.3428316414,
0.4534070492,
0.6022301316,
-0.1585458815,
0.7639586329,
0.0813268796,
-0.2862662375,
-0.1544819921,
-0.003098723,
-0.4057385027,
0.1750435829,
0.319734633,
-0.1210525036,
-0.0036281762,
-0.6148427725,
-0.3470662832,
0.0760980919,
0.2817814946,
-1.0466729403,
-0.3097026944,
0.1053169519,
-0.492013514,
-0.2299872339,
-0.116314359,
-0.1239517033,
-0.500929296,
-0.2171345651,
0.1919573545,
-0.1449810565,
-0.1606517434,
0.0577943027,
-0.2580529153,
0.3587473035,
0.4737967551,
-0.8029479384,
0.3120692372,
0.8195580244,
0.5424103737,
-0.0687993988,
-0.1647289544,
-0.5807260275,
0.3734466434,
-0.8193505406,
0.7763260603,
-0.9174481034,
-0.3350030184,
-0.3701732457,
-0.1508398205,
-0.1725168675,
-1.0618133545,
0.7219941616,
-0.670250833,
0.3723306656,
-0.4205763936,
-0.7014399171,
-0.1043069288,
-0.0531115234,
-0.6936020851,
1.0775486231,
-0.0601998083,
-0.3116096556,
0.4274911582,
-0.3665215075,
-0.5800999999,
-0.0367415212,
0.0964683965,
-0.6798829436,
0.3831463158,
0.2080355734,
0.2345900685,
-0.4182246625,
0.3821102679,
-0.3894529045,
-0.4587821066,
0.3032715023,
-0.260060966,
0.7035166621,
0.1841300726,
-0.5200846791,
0.0166821871,
-0.850271821,
0.010372608,
0.0696750805,
-0.5267526507,
-0.1684239656,
0.3890052438,
-0.4253598154,
0.3044011593,
0.0558980741,
-0.6901274323,
0.2331974059,
-0.6242665648,
0.4242494404,
0.6202445626,
-0.3995136619,
0.7900115252,
-0.2316300422,
0.2946942747,
-0.1025384888,
0.2324849367,
0.1816132218,
-0.4554959536,
-1.389872551,
-0.4264507294,
0.2776012123,
0.3535741866,
-0.8721616864,
0.3915334046,
-0.1606012434,
-0.5178721547,
-0.5927847028,
0.2674369514,
0.4679008126,
0.3514348865,
0.4313560426,
0.0447435789,
-0.4833309054,
-1.1358904839,
-0.2880035341,
-0.1563138813,
-0.2050739825,
0.2166735232,
0.1087909788,
0.133267805,
0.9567006826,
-0.4793508649,
-0.1255685389,
-0.4639807045,
-0.1954361498,
0.1700431406,
0.3862480819,
0.4194582701,
-0.7464703321,
-0.3015572727,
0.1028695703,
-0.7888329625,
-0.1682828069,
-0.1360445172,
-0.1505062729,
0.0487692654,
0.5902701616,
-0.692024827,
0.1262989938,
0.495005399,
-0.0682183579,
0.1309063584,
-0.1491950452,
-0.0830840468,
-0.6140061021,
-0.0145711796,
0.116381377,
-0.1632739007,
-0.9754801393,
0.0735066459,
0.0573810302,
-0.1834757775,
-0.434071511,
0.5367178917,
-0.3890896738,
-0.3273149133,
-0.5087634921,
-0.028753493,
0.1839466989,
0.4033932984,
0.2187861204,
0.6761476994,
0.4573768973,
-0.5746794343,
0.0096618365,
-0.1901254505,
-0.4926906228,
0.1457652152,
-0.6463341713,
0.033580292,
-0.140477851,
0.1426984817,
-0.9223501682,
0.0754853487,
0.1565170437,
-0.197675541,
0.2272891551,
-0.2523194253,
-0.4131257534,
-0.3150445521,
0.0423410311,
0.1207475439,
0.5759084225,
-0.7091831565,
0.6322154999,
0.515451014,
0.0816366076,
-0.4775930345,
-0.6312136054,
0.2764432728,
0.0164242201,
-0.4710396826,
0.6561031342,
-0.1035954431,
-0.4294523299,
-0.0939325169,
-0.07842879,
-0.3736202717,
0.4872929454,
-0.0851875991,
0.3309621811,
-0.1570523232,
0.1793822795,
0.0373829566,
-0.3026479781,
0.1180002466,
-0.2388012707,
0.5140474439,
0.0088785058,
-0.4600355625,
-0.4370402098,
0.1019756868,
0.453243494,
-0.3624591529,
0.9739248753,
0.6167451143,
-0.2423541844,
-0.6897591949,
-0.6142991185,
-0.3260705769,
-0.5700579286,
0.4122800529,
-0.3798187971,
-0.9572287202,
0.3961036801,
-0.0112828007,
0.1178520843,
0.2463328093,
0.3795992732,
-0.1915486008,
1.6643952131,
0.3651745319,
0.1032205969,
0.6277977824,
-0.202116102,
0.5759454966,
-0.7366767526,
-0.2193723619,
-0.7016845942,
-0.1999940425,
-0.3631976545,
-0.3572478592,
0.231204018,
0.2037192583,
-0.1265417039,
0.0411523953,
-0.7229495049,
0.8823326826,
0.2660806179,
0.2628191113,
0.2596433163,
-0.0472226776,
0.0549441203,
0.0033337814,
-0.7138335109,
-0.2421724498,
0.6761267185,
0.4703139365,
0.4489623308,
0.0807930976,
0.5739830136,
0.0472646803,
0.3796966374,
-0.9169870615,
0.918558538,
-0.5264868736,
-0.5836315751,
-0.2889214456,
-0.6890726686,
-0.8826199174,
0.5486977696,
-0.0290790014,
-0.1633590907,
-0.0679555982,
-0.1354063451,
-0.091665104,
0.5617711544,
-0.6806938648,
0.4235243499,
-0.2800577879,
-0.2542887628,
-0.2231723517,
-0.2061832696,
0.4106007516,
-0.0269568805,
0.0326834209,
-0.3538247049,
0.0214418881,
0.684275806,
-0.6222913265,
0.6581612229,
-0.4097865224,
-0.2716454864,
-0.0336861871,
0.0344386734,
0.5729792118,
-0.4549473524,
-0.2076876014,
-0.0089874268,
-0.5126802325,
-0.3642625809,
-0.9216651917,
0.4770751894,
-0.7880901694,
-0.951695621,
0.1161427051,
-0.636218071,
-0.2448013574,
0.1042675525,
-0.1880319864,
0.6096325517,
0.2291557342,
0.5540642738,
0.9928908944,
-0.2197709084,
0.5544040799,
0.4390201569,
-0.4267955124,
-0.1889231056,
1.0413588285,
0.4870518446,
0.3652451038,
0.6081822515,
0.1669500172,
-0.223069787,
-0.9334017634,
-0.2976867855,
0.3357678652,
-0.9816910028,
0.1896160841,
-0.5211387873,
-0.5186921358,
-0.2188249081,
-0.2625111341,
-0.5611656308,
-0.7225161791,
-0.0594070517,
-0.0541684739,
-0.0369358361,
0.6491974592,
0.4612102211,
0.4633643925,
-0.6761253476,
0.3060179651,
0.4954494834,
0.3731065691,
0.0485352017,
-0.5658729076,
-0.3430943787,
-0.2385550737,
0.0137379328,
-0.3496818542,
0.5076029897,
0.208995223,
1.0365713835,
0.2444169372,
-0.2079425901,
0.5584617853,
-0.5363013148,
0.6809176803,
0.0483828746,
-1.0754766464,
0.5925427079,
-0.4014120996,
0.3738863468,
0.3210877478,
0.1603337675,
-0.2935812175,
-0.6439968348,
-0.4945501685,
-0.6039803624,
0.8069812059,
0.2623844445,
-0.116402626,
0.3814667463,
0.4797326922,
-0.205016464,
0.1388478726,
-1.0183204412,
-0.45980528,
0.046221856,
0.0056796935,
-0.0854963288,
-0.1440450996,
-0.0845497176,
-0.4709230363,
0.8362461329,
-0.0332651101,
0.0880096927,
-0.1712119877,
-0.2700214088,
0.000999301,
0.251676321,
0.509767592,
0.7361190915,
-0.225856632,
0.3389138877,
0.254499197,
-0.1537351459,
0.0990066305,
-0.1750991642,
-0.4898630083,
0.0253581796,
0.3676775098,
0.9027485847,
0.3745382428,
-0.5010763407,
0.2522098422,
0.0762170479,
-0.2727050781,
0.167137742,
0.3427979946,
0.1067072377,
0.201168552,
0.5287333727,
0.2779946029,
0.0761241391,
-0.2259271443,
0.2339647114,
0.5219653845,
-0.5600368381,
-0.0531447195,
0.519601047,
0.2328312546,
-0.3193688095,
0.2578666508,
0.0638432205,
-0.5569450259,
0.7021476626,
0.4267189205,
0.9204493165,
-0.1924832761,
0.5046587586,
0.1765414476,
0.4836660922,
-0.1958131641,
-0.2165171951,
-0.1392374039,
-0.9251148105,
-0.7615814805,
-0.7070223689,
-0.5685400367,
-0.020105781,
-0.5271674395,
-0.0478872098,
-0.9464471936,
-0.2417894006,
0.2957103848,
0.0579096228,
-0.3078416884,
0.1174940318,
0.3356651664,
0.5561323762,
-0.6851463914,
1.4316850901,
0.3692260087,
-0.211701721,
-0.8471870422,
-0.2188682556,
-0.254263401,
-0.8552843332,
1.2344689369,
0.2371769398,
-0.4156247973,
0.0462814197,
-0.505851686,
-1.0373122692,
0.7074036002,
0.8049432635,
-0.3606359363,
-0.1693708152,
0.4214732051,
0.5645056963,
-0.3150356114,
0.4158295691,
0.5913748145,
0.7076905966,
0.2226277888,
-0.7462962866,
-0.3249590397,
-0.2243778855,
0.3223451972,
0.3837466836,
-0.5715120435,
1.1063255072,
0.0195921455,
-0.2059949636,
-0.2029021084,
0.5193636417,
0.3314865232,
-0.135172829,
0.604003489,
0.6073686481,
0.7918769121,
-0.3573302925,
1.0836913586,
-0.1920223832,
0.2496762872,
0.7410346866,
-0.6683462858,
0.8031093478,
0.3233986199,
-0.1803166717,
0.6242538095,
0.4468283355,
-0.0724289343,
0.579603672,
-0.1075706556,
-0.3301842809,
-0.8922362924,
-0.450635165,
-0.2106858343,
0.5456628203,
0.0492422357,
-0.4743044972,
-0.3418825269,
0.0749160722,
0.0955405533,
0.0558140501,
-0.4903649986,
0.8026122451,
0.0319016688,
-0.7513636947,
0.925203383,
0.0179793425,
0.4964993,
-0.5748032331,
-0.0237292126,
-0.1014368013,
0.4041675031,
-0.1770297289,
-0.5496932864,
0.1477083713,
-0.1170777678,
-0.4982179701,
-0.6678475142,
0.8429840803,
-0.5039609075,
-0.7555035949,
0.6238187551,
0.5460277796,
-0.088936761,
0.0884874612,
-0.8184075356,
0.090702109,
0.0627959594,
-0.3478651345,
0.4988169372,
0.052522637,
0.3428662121,
1.0374089479,
0.8200899363,
0.3454442918,
0.0251845866,
0.4485282004,
0.9402084351,
-0.5237513185,
-0.2479269356,
-0.7869396806,
0.1987483352,
-0.1526740342,
0.1955254227,
0.9020898342,
0.609924078,
0.823953867,
0.2313483655,
0.6513072848,
0.4935269654,
0.6693710089,
-0.8378028274,
0.7262349129,
-0.5970282555,
0.6822109222,
-0.0290414244,
-1.0320829153,
-0.6152344942,
0.5938943624,
-0.5561689138,
0.1798195839,
0.727417469,
1.0027712584,
0.3119176924,
-0.0455114134,
0.6289229989,
0.1334789693,
0.727750361,
0.398714304,
1.0791976452,
-0.3178218901,
0.5442947745,
-0.5379226208,
0.059843529,
-0.0769508854,
-0.6121546626,
-1.0047844648,
-0.3234171867,
-0.2058632523,
-0.0807923302,
0.127099365,
0.6445373893,
0.8660469651,
-0.7641902566,
-0.3292640448,
-0.1037283018,
0.4157094061,
-0.2033598274,
-0.1914936006,
0.2631811202,
-0.4676603973,
-0.7561677098,
0.7400434613,
0.370182693,
-0.2676463425,
-0.3050525784,
-0.0589727312,
-0.1068802178,
-0.0073510446,
0.7481929064,
0.0266798753,
-0.9936618805,
-0.4501942694,
0.1201340035,
-0.3157238364,
0.2844049633,
0.8245556951,
-0.8400688767,
0.2120028138,
0.4798715711,
0.8249307871,
0.393817395,
-0.2859340012,
0.4022157788,
-0.6566944718,
0.1034282297,
0.1934662461,
0.4968461692,
0.2471076995,
-0.1280028373,
0.4185966849,
0.2919811904,
-0.509102881,
-1.0562050343,
0.1820889711,
-0.7871301174,
-0.7492381334,
1.1307917833,
0.0921021849,
-0.3213047087,
-0.0355662331,
-0.0341336057,
0.1692489386,
-0.257078588,
0.6809737086,
0.6286939383,
-0.1988949776,
-0.5393531919,
-0.2983244658,
0.5896214247,
0.8491179347,
-1.0431014299,
0.2718155384,
0.4910228252,
-0.0018603086,
0.2259715497,
0.3807676136,
0.0883255824,
0.2125089914,
-0.1391839087,
0.0283599887,
-0.1916355938,
-0.7774547338,
-0.2617535293,
0.6074559689,
0.3007475436,
0.4125511348
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13547v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13547v1
|
How to Prune Your Language Model: Recovering Accuracy on the "Sparsity May Cry'' Benchmark
| 2023-12-21T03:11:30 | 2023-12-21T03:11:30 |
Eldar Kurtic, Torsten Hoefler, Dan Alistarh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Pruning large language models (LLMs) from the BERT family has emerged as a
standard compression benchmark, and several pruning methods have been proposed
for this task. The recent ``Sparsity May Cry'' (SMC) benchmark put into
question the validity of all existing methods, exhibiting a more complex setup
where many known pruning methods appear to fail. We revisit the question of
accurate BERT-pruning during fine-tuning on downstream datasets, and propose a
set of general guidelines for successful pruning, even on the challenging SMC
benchmark. First, we perform a cost-vs-benefits analysis of pruning model
components, such as the embeddings and the classification head; second, we
provide a simple-yet-general way of scaling training, sparsification and
learning rate schedules relative to the desired target sparsity; finally, we
investigate the importance of proper parametrization for Knowledge Distillation
in the context of LLMs. Our simple insights lead to state-of-the-art results,
both on classic BERT-pruning benchmarks, as well as on the SMC benchmark,
showing that even classic gradual magnitude pruning (GMP) can yield competitive
results, with the right approach.
|
[
-0.4939938188,
-0.7383525968,
0.3996070921,
0.1038798168,
-0.402245909,
-0.078467831,
-0.5808573961,
-0.0811040699,
-0.1855864674,
0.37734586,
-0.983371079,
-0.2676909268,
-0.7435544729,
-0.1006963626,
-0.4904342592,
1.0797047615,
0.0995523632,
-0.0338587239,
-0.0230514053,
-0.0703529641,
-0.3533790708,
-0.7457286119,
-0.7434873581,
-0.1335581094,
0.6529096365,
0.3956032991,
0.5676018,
0.7987536788,
0.4228075743,
0.2679324746,
-0.5167163014,
0.3049570322,
-0.741549015,
0.2438225001,
0.4074139595,
-0.4959145188,
-0.0034245609,
0.0660886541,
0.7317024469,
0.8592851758,
-0.4060299397,
0.0947718397,
0.4296044409,
0.8297843337,
-0.5043999553,
-0.0841871575,
-0.795471251,
-0.0512137152,
-0.2775070965,
-0.1687303036,
-0.3880345225,
-0.4311214983,
-0.0748116672,
-0.1395428628,
0.588606894,
-0.1861863583,
1.1447606087,
0.6252596378,
-0.1867242157,
-0.0148450304,
-0.8757121563,
0.9139851332,
-0.8354879022,
0.3094229102,
0.281919986,
0.5102396011,
-0.1776804626,
-0.615891099,
-0.0397675633,
-0.3828364611,
0.2133542746,
-0.1298909485,
-0.1203898266,
-0.0436839722,
0.373277843,
0.4661289454,
-0.3382932842,
-0.0513832457,
-0.5804319382,
-0.2080495507,
0.575469017,
-0.1740189344,
-0.1095350683,
0.3748443723,
-0.3433407843,
-0.1279506832,
-1.0458812714,
-0.2509993613,
0.5443634987,
0.3426527381,
0.5408376455,
0.4125825465,
0.0835620835,
0.7511698604,
-0.0179344676,
-0.2006033212,
-0.0234120227,
-0.1463101357,
-0.1208595484,
-0.1307404637,
0.3260731399,
0.3397956491,
0.6203659177,
-0.440817982,
-0.323304832,
0.0283449609,
0.5103619099,
-0.6536268592,
-0.3000533283,
0.1541767865,
-0.4202575684,
-0.2724807858,
-0.0938217863,
-0.4138943851,
-0.145561859,
-0.4790018201,
0.2093429565,
-0.5015285611,
-0.2147574872,
-0.1430897266,
-0.0346893296,
0.2373550981,
0.2638492882,
-0.7985357642,
0.6581668854,
1.0286642313,
0.8978523016,
-0.039840959,
-0.3514472246,
-0.5508919358,
-0.0498712473,
-0.3099383414,
0.7195314169,
-0.0836860314,
-0.3251493275,
0.0288044997,
-0.0992285311,
-0.0045290389,
-0.8351238966,
0.7248811126,
-0.2218268216,
-0.2289621979,
-0.4163578451,
-0.6401879787,
-0.1281290203,
0.2456201017,
-0.6110976338,
0.9116473198,
0.0393195376,
-0.5429515839,
0.3733045757,
0.125532195,
-0.5055564642,
-0.1439495981,
0.0498117916,
-0.4972797334,
0.5972784758,
0.1057283208,
0.5865285397,
-0.2935554087,
0.532242775,
-0.3818415403,
-0.3175425828,
0.1964748055,
-0.6102691293,
0.6398928761,
0.3482710719,
-0.0293442905,
-0.1064948365,
-0.493485868,
0.0198898781,
0.0239698235,
-0.2778625786,
-0.1966655254,
0.4035531878,
-0.0866427943,
0.039313674,
0.0597750619,
-0.2713944316,
0.2902107239,
-0.4242585301,
0.7525361776,
0.8623147607,
-0.0152543103,
0.3827472627,
-0.6041924357,
0.1912385076,
-0.1093425527,
0.3361853957,
0.3507392704,
-0.2346494943,
-0.8589420915,
-0.2577840984,
0.5018272996,
0.252698034,
-0.383405596,
0.5400212407,
-0.1860046089,
-0.6290876865,
-0.6070545912,
0.2116850168,
0.14822191,
0.5122255683,
0.2046572268,
-0.4202663004,
-0.3936239481,
-0.9089398384,
-0.3182191551,
-0.1763229966,
-0.0981793255,
0.2534073889,
0.1617643088,
0.0072040912,
0.965898037,
-0.4231079817,
-0.4356340766,
-0.2542711794,
0.422652185,
0.1157071888,
0.5088171959,
0.3528064489,
-0.7625855803,
-0.2154186815,
-0.2178981751,
-0.111437805,
-0.3407676518,
-0.1241657883,
0.0611761808,
0.1873169243,
0.3357976377,
-0.4592272639,
0.2052837461,
0.6305086613,
0.1436201483,
0.6655563116,
-0.1579700708,
-0.066640906,
-0.8379243016,
0.0409032218,
0.330971092,
-0.2016414702,
-0.6618306041,
-0.0948070511,
-0.0454615094,
-0.0378938951,
-0.1965121031,
0.0844966099,
-0.4202289879,
-0.1498125643,
-0.2433092594,
0.0442661196,
-0.2755280733,
0.5500046015,
0.1123829633,
0.6648815274,
0.2925180793,
-0.878851831,
0.2694954276,
-0.1630987525,
-0.516291976,
0.0747251883,
-0.579863131,
0.0262486767,
-0.1547928751,
0.021984553,
-0.8555444479,
0.1166072711,
-0.0107440203,
-0.4312368035,
0.5919043422,
-0.5128451586,
-0.6607112288,
-0.0438473336,
-0.1060899869,
0.0054887268,
0.7824630737,
-0.3952544332,
0.3132240474,
0.4885584116,
-0.4294590354,
-0.4554968178,
-0.7572616339,
-0.0969326869,
-0.5178831816,
-0.5797896385,
0.3466596305,
-0.269967109,
-0.203794241,
-0.1721379161,
-0.4464912415,
-0.4002730548,
0.3967773914,
0.0543684065,
0.0563451909,
-0.0565416478,
0.0762108713,
-0.0381544791,
-0.2567137182,
0.0291346125,
-0.1142327338,
0.536575377,
-0.1603067964,
-0.4312382638,
-0.1181491986,
0.0436233804,
0.3396206796,
0.0119683882,
0.6628836989,
0.4470327497,
-0.3093044162,
-0.2818661034,
-0.9491208196,
-0.5142869949,
-0.4104833305,
0.2212275118,
-0.1597679853,
-0.8645607829,
0.3346790373,
-0.6036900282,
0.3941838741,
0.3727846146,
0.4619508684,
-0.2046543211,
1.0117410421,
0.7549380064,
-0.3329041004,
0.3989534676,
-0.1517893225,
0.1782130152,
-0.5291336775,
0.1717248112,
-0.8177021742,
-0.488044858,
-0.3440001309,
-0.373409152,
0.0986844897,
0.2724473774,
0.0225609988,
0.3694566488,
-0.4620892107,
0.5076797009,
0.4367685616,
-0.0965677202,
0.071911566,
0.2858026624,
0.2055165023,
-0.2380101085,
-0.8896799088,
-0.5188881755,
0.6416798234,
0.7069879174,
0.6229672432,
-0.0168053508,
0.8282772303,
-0.0941170007,
0.4429340661,
-0.8801502585,
0.5098544359,
-0.224858284,
-0.6032699347,
-0.3805577755,
-0.8363006711,
-0.7252159715,
0.2090203762,
0.0917725414,
-0.6392054558,
0.0787525773,
0.3927845657,
-0.2864754796,
0.1597440243,
-0.8393090367,
0.6948168874,
-0.3300149441,
-0.0752436221,
-0.2835796475,
-0.7447094321,
0.299285531,
-0.078374885,
0.2650806606,
-0.3658029735,
-0.1157279536,
0.6836175323,
-0.6117671132,
0.86038059,
-0.2774592638,
0.0519791879,
0.1614833772,
0.2826844752,
0.5204803348,
-0.3706569672,
0.1360015124,
0.151202172,
0.164660424,
-0.2921726704,
-0.5215347409,
0.6702212095,
-0.6997387409,
-0.5313399434,
-0.2325325608,
-0.3228543103,
-0.4732570648,
-0.1167090237,
0.1721502393,
0.3753245771,
-0.2513868809,
0.281820327,
0.8294841647,
0.151956439,
0.1779860109,
0.4781472087,
0.2856909633,
-0.3904107809,
1.1694989204,
0.5134161711,
0.1757546067,
0.2528325617,
0.2862917185,
-0.0528951921,
-0.8779630065,
-0.1194973961,
0.4263463616,
-0.472818166,
-0.3630670309,
-0.0626854002,
-0.4492698312,
-0.4444406033,
0.0596553423,
-0.4585922062,
-0.3416402042,
-0.2931277752,
-0.0128048323,
0.3116025627,
0.6328209639,
-0.0835048407,
0.4662177861,
-1.021253109,
-0.0410946049,
0.1291598678,
0.2315706313,
-0.0050116149,
-0.7260019779,
-0.224138394,
0.0260353368,
-0.1839972734,
-0.7335599661,
0.7286674976,
0.3847545087,
0.5603182316,
0.2979281545,
0.1408987343,
0.8972924352,
-0.6988689899,
0.601852417,
0.0969859585,
-0.6394302249,
0.3948001564,
0.0057157725,
0.1193673536,
0.626517415,
0.4091182351,
-0.7204095721,
-0.361595124,
-0.8658465147,
-1.0861749649,
0.4723377526,
0.2262811065,
-0.0347316861,
0.029351078,
0.4707975686,
0.0697497204,
0.3319393694,
-0.6842522621,
-0.1559763402,
0.3232867122,
-0.2710298002,
-0.3320696354,
-0.6370251775,
-0.4727612734,
-0.0463539399,
0.8687682748,
0.0041784267,
0.001097317,
0.0395532511,
-0.3360941708,
-0.0011821842,
0.1605043709,
0.4097997248,
0.5087803006,
-0.2209829241,
0.0449810438,
0.1341974437,
-0.2691031396,
-0.1381924301,
0.1717433631,
0.0093835145,
-0.0010855279,
0.2786225379,
0.6264423132,
0.3825430572,
-0.5159099102,
0.4258852303,
-0.1767450124,
-0.4620535374,
-0.1451418698,
-0.0817992762,
-0.0571120344,
0.1596620232,
0.3764169812,
0.052625414,
-0.0064359647,
-0.1823485494,
0.0959951654,
0.3784827888,
-0.2615694702,
-0.0666311383,
0.1505152583,
0.3282239139,
-0.0545343794,
0.8024852276,
0.2274358422,
-0.4815023541,
0.4928299487,
0.1705462486,
0.8477654457,
-0.1745216697,
0.0297455806,
0.2555111945,
0.6045498252,
-0.5116526484,
-0.177483961,
-0.3658600152,
-0.6161124706,
-0.7261639833,
-0.5601677895,
-0.3488516808,
0.1208746731,
-0.7065093517,
0.0830015987,
-0.5138913393,
-0.1706006229,
-0.1679601967,
0.2948305309,
-0.2847203016,
0.1534489095,
0.2513819039,
1.2280297279,
-1.1274269819,
0.8380970955,
0.315512836,
-0.2171705514,
-0.8805959225,
0.0290151257,
0.0908555239,
-0.5732834935,
0.4219574928,
0.184194997,
0.093985714,
0.0762592703,
-0.6607948542,
-0.7607908249,
0.9661791921,
0.6526241302,
-0.9912320971,
-0.0069745085,
-0.1474344879,
0.3665035665,
-0.0986300483,
-0.1565439999,
0.8513411283,
0.3207305074,
0.2304184139,
-0.8279621601,
-0.2042977214,
-0.0624810979,
0.1128365174,
0.3652888536,
-0.5143735409,
0.6111168861,
0.1114074886,
-0.338578701,
0.1861216277,
0.5230070353,
0.2176611423,
0.0536351539,
0.6951523423,
0.6209837198,
0.7155888677,
-0.4568571746,
0.8342791796,
-0.2791262567,
0.3281485438,
0.9108276367,
-0.2337239087,
0.9352043867,
0.8075626493,
-0.3744289279,
-0.0439396501,
0.8962576389,
-0.0956907496,
0.6117430925,
0.3744548857,
-0.1887453943,
-0.2844488323,
0.1507355571,
-0.1974397749,
-0.1991880238,
0.484888196,
-0.1468615681,
-0.2225675881,
-0.2065668106,
-0.0412535146,
-0.117521137,
-0.2980034649,
1.0453277826,
0.2330346107,
-0.7958706617,
0.6894575357,
-0.0914149731,
0.5366261005,
-0.8062785268,
0.2479920238,
-0.237276271,
0.3281624317,
-0.0703139156,
-0.5046026111,
0.5792282224,
-0.0151283517,
-0.1157301292,
-0.5870345235,
0.8819368482,
-0.6056732535,
-0.2415737957,
0.076590471,
0.3775756061,
0.5082683563,
-0.2135186195,
-0.8005552888,
0.4725221694,
0.1508968771,
-0.2013284266,
0.6059885025,
0.36411798,
0.3133967519,
0.8612411618,
0.4752920866,
0.5343368053,
0.0518018305,
0.304884702,
0.9984874129,
-0.3274938762,
0.0227364767,
-0.7872226238,
0.5432599783,
-0.073573947,
-0.1997988224,
0.5170452595,
0.3545003831,
0.8543873429,
0.0420683362,
0.530197084,
0.0506588742,
0.6807895899,
-0.5927008986,
0.6102877855,
-0.5414367914,
0.2450952977,
0.0324817114,
-0.9391592741,
-0.2339049131,
0.857321918,
-0.3441152275,
0.0479516648,
0.4987569451,
0.9168999791,
0.1406535804,
-0.0959701091,
0.3481117189,
0.267154038,
0.0410001092,
0.184933275,
0.7349504232,
-0.2306092978,
0.8482552767,
-0.6633389592,
-0.3549606502,
-0.2103431523,
-0.9786182046,
-0.4394075572,
-0.6701233387,
-0.6200506091,
-0.3271874487,
0.2498906255,
0.6757618785,
0.8282857537,
-0.6714295149,
-0.4502783716,
-0.2265686393,
-0.024056593,
-0.60736233,
-0.1642372459,
-0.000768165,
-0.6252133846,
-0.6648100019,
0.377350539,
0.0542058982,
0.1684605777,
-0.173064664,
0.0081658876,
-0.0276069306,
-0.1353940219,
0.3133690655,
0.4459649026,
-0.7453937531,
-0.062142875,
-0.3483377993,
-0.0264432337,
-0.1975085884,
1.1022719145,
-0.6753063202,
0.1326361746,
0.1871112883,
0.7333400249,
0.5052182674,
0.0192243997,
0.881321013,
-1.1947344542,
0.1778348088,
0.5320553184,
0.3919915855,
0.346101284,
-0.089645505,
0.5408408046,
0.1542558968,
-0.7821469307,
-1.0802316666,
0.1843688786,
-0.8048664927,
-0.4330894649,
1.2382127047,
-0.1268777251,
-0.4471432269,
0.1095410436,
-0.3842078745,
0.3158400059,
-0.1905758977,
0.7194442153,
0.9768506885,
0.2131724358,
-0.344173044,
-0.4409779608,
0.6394479275,
0.5812735558,
-0.3879022896,
0.5843701363,
0.5918221474,
0.2982382178,
-0.0228266846,
0.3201744854,
0.0275011361,
-0.0210113768,
-0.1388671696,
-0.1089808941,
0.0892419815,
-0.4685406685,
-0.5458321571,
0.0475307442,
0.5869060159,
-0.0147335362
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13545v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13545v2
|
Developing Interactive Tourism Planning: A Dialogue Robot System Powered by a Large Language Model
| 2023-12-21T03:09:38 | 2023-12-22T04:13:51 |
Katsumasa Yoshikawa, Takato Yamazaki, Masaya Ohagi, Tomoya Mizumoto, Keiya Sato
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In recent years, large language models (LLMs) have rapidly proliferated and
have been utilized in various tasks, including research in dialogue systems. We
aimed to construct a system that not only leverages the flexible conversational
abilities of LLMs but also their advanced planning capabilities to reduce the
speaking load on human interlocutors and efficiently plan trips. Furthermore,
we propose a method that divides the complex task of a travel agency into
multiple subtasks, managing each as a separate phase to effectively accomplish
the task. Our proposed system confirmed a certain level of success by achieving
fourth place in the Dialogue Robot Competition 2023 preliminaries rounds. We
report on the challenges identified through the competition.
|
[
-0.6214674115,
-0.6109088659,
0.7899941802,
0.1902504861,
-0.1571749151,
0.3378480077,
-0.2825910747,
-0.4308082461,
0.5795866251,
0.8105472326,
-0.7863798738,
-0.2833369374,
-0.3489449918,
0.2286298722,
-0.1434615105,
0.3819077611,
-0.2451711446,
0.0924070925,
-0.1232133731,
0.0188122764,
-0.3618692756,
-0.5533931255,
-0.6885438561,
-0.5598829389,
0.6242710352,
0.5223046541,
0.8743981719,
-0.0124769313,
0.6539939642,
0.3752720356,
-0.1407830864,
0.4151841998,
-0.281144619,
0.1834721565,
-0.2587033808,
-0.4748245478,
-0.695035398,
-0.4819699526,
0.6131990552,
0.734192431,
-0.3806469142,
0.0302938391,
-0.1653255373,
0.2251047045,
-0.1669889987,
0.4740482867,
-0.5017152429,
0.1263983101,
0.1797468215,
-0.5213394165,
-0.2988044024,
-0.1515246481,
0.344281584,
-0.4957304895,
-0.1963466853,
0.3391136527,
0.7675351501,
0.2105587125,
-0.2327909768,
-0.3657443225,
-1.1006952524,
0.7375533581,
-0.5071267486,
0.2239753157,
0.2542238832,
0.3105545342,
-0.4290133119,
-0.4821711779,
-0.8596156836,
-0.3009626269,
0.2052755505,
-0.0149776917,
-0.2833499312,
0.3718648851,
0.1524678767,
-0.2144696265,
-0.5902832747,
0.2951854169,
-0.2205810547,
-0.0685345009,
0.4457400441,
0.4646118283,
0.4778149724,
-0.0527182966,
0.0086577507,
0.0789478123,
-0.7851060033,
-0.0128017003,
0.3333931565,
0.4346370399,
0.090848878,
0.85179919,
-0.4318413436,
0.3512759507,
-0.2095615268,
-0.2358720452,
-0.0954450667,
-0.3604642153,
-0.1991552711,
-0.0272428952,
0.6872709394,
0.6549956203,
0.3685719669,
0.0007929704,
-0.2905518711,
-0.5491032004,
0.223240599,
-0.5916600227,
-0.2289933264,
0.3152633905,
-0.3807618022,
0.1961033195,
-0.1381449103,
-0.7300266027,
-0.297914803,
-0.2295650989,
0.2982566357,
-0.0405340604,
-0.3690844774,
0.4381494224,
0.0307336207,
0.211934492,
0.8137140274,
-0.748288095,
0.408189714,
0.236836642,
0.8373144865,
-0.0845158249,
-0.1726468056,
-0.3708201945,
0.1831014454,
-0.21554102,
0.8958796263,
-0.5002975464,
-0.864341259,
0.2562191188,
0.1333299726,
0.0955366045,
-0.6852659583,
0.413682729,
-0.6364308596,
0.1733585,
0.057747405,
0.0405524634,
-0.4222308397,
0.571675539,
-0.6317567229,
0.4864049852,
0.2319240123,
0.0504389964,
-0.0135489292,
-0.5758408904,
-0.39126423,
0.4952801168,
-0.1346226931,
-0.1973968148,
-0.3418349028,
0.2822075784,
0.1064892933,
-0.3359163105,
0.2955931723,
-0.1045770869,
-0.127878353,
0.0728013217,
0.1181450337,
0.5698316693,
0.1638235748,
-0.186307624,
0.5833781958,
-0.3808418512,
-0.0662130117,
0.2171336114,
-0.5645242333,
0.299978137,
0.0690092891,
0.1752149016,
0.1848740131,
0.4649232924,
-0.3526443839,
0.6731061339,
-0.3872956038,
0.3234779835,
0.7753375173,
-0.1417255849,
0.6096875072,
-0.2906523645,
1.0968278646,
-0.3404505551,
0.2290523201,
-0.26183936,
-0.5794437528,
-1.1791541576,
0.0271034781,
0.1327144802,
0.66604352,
-0.913844347,
0.6542832851,
-0.4106891453,
-0.3373863995,
-0.0229371265,
-0.1323288977,
0.0876592025,
-0.0572778918,
0.1024294123,
-0.3618960381,
-0.4881720245,
-0.6536569595,
0.169261694,
-0.1502361298,
-0.0248821061,
0.2902312577,
0.5113783479,
-0.1812748909,
0.6381320953,
-0.4853725135,
-0.44458583,
-0.9139242172,
-0.1342808753,
0.2502271533,
0.3611466885,
0.695425868,
-0.7947444916,
-0.400841713,
0.0092699314,
-0.4441573322,
0.0297086276,
0.0032927801,
-0.1204592511,
0.2048014104,
0.5498917699,
-1.0098509789,
0.328789562,
0.3235723376,
-0.2081307024,
0.5395213962,
-0.2649184167,
0.1179624647,
-0.6907433867,
-0.2761496007,
-0.0701391622,
-0.3450685441,
-0.3819584548,
-0.0800193921,
-0.5609753728,
-0.278553009,
-0.4384970367,
0.5143424869,
-0.20609501,
0.0027877507,
-0.4982370436,
0.081190601,
-0.06032129,
0.6887114048,
0.3409644365,
0.4646973014,
0.3757183552,
-0.608694315,
0.7989677787,
0.5625495315,
-0.5062447786,
0.3172763586,
-0.4675416052,
0.0441384092,
0.1314357519,
0.6791419387,
-0.9348636866,
-0.5376544595,
0.3699417114,
-0.2038442194,
0.0188387427,
0.0889012516,
-0.6181671619,
-0.6871448159,
0.1187262237,
0.1849849671,
0.4772011936,
-0.2136921436,
1.0043013096,
0.7832920551,
-0.9342973232,
-0.0821617991,
-0.2990696728,
0.5931286216,
-0.285826087,
-0.6461868882,
0.0879217312,
-0.1606647819,
-0.2908420861,
-0.1580124795,
-0.0231767241,
0.0110806832,
-0.2667950094,
0.0616910197,
0.222900942,
-0.0110657224,
-0.0680156425,
-0.13888596,
0.0087578204,
0.0446397811,
-0.2592656612,
1.2058603764,
0.0638938323,
-0.3525168002,
-0.9088488221,
0.3082646728,
0.4577438235,
-0.1541601866,
0.5330667496,
0.1005028188,
-0.1662162393,
-0.0641256794,
-0.4239887297,
0.1985770613,
-0.5438057184,
0.4062799513,
-0.5586081147,
-0.9065329432,
0.5354930758,
-0.5288646817,
0.1246482357,
0.1531514227,
0.6166887283,
-0.0686823055,
1.1836323738,
0.9520952106,
0.321077466,
0.5340829492,
-0.1872979105,
0.475918293,
-0.5265912414,
-0.5663260818,
-0.5806672573,
-0.3750518858,
-0.6500218511,
-0.6124406457,
0.4930305481,
-0.3187392652,
-0.1878185272,
0.3462727368,
-0.2271822393,
0.4774662554,
0.8524173498,
-0.1787008643,
0.3676902056,
-0.4571580589,
0.0731827244,
0.300427109,
-0.7100583911,
-0.9541096687,
0.6731003523,
0.1179854572,
0.9162968397,
0.1579273194,
0.3011001348,
0.2164868712,
-0.3039711714,
-0.9274670482,
1.0886802673,
0.2446778268,
-0.2830713987,
-0.536098361,
-0.1461431235,
-0.8551160693,
0.2961042821,
-0.0949622616,
-0.9577510953,
0.1874438375,
-0.1711416841,
-0.6987079382,
0.4712962508,
-0.6752386093,
0.3341315687,
-0.2937904298,
0.0251919273,
-0.3828265369,
-0.6389895082,
0.0261087138,
-0.1858997047,
0.2512333393,
-0.3441574872,
0.170122534,
0.6241077185,
-0.1914884448,
0.5913392901,
-0.1084318012,
-0.0114567028,
0.2939483523,
0.471367836,
0.4470122159,
-0.1818456352,
-0.0733512416,
0.0334678553,
-0.0250918418,
-0.1733119935,
-0.2607543468,
0.5079148412,
-0.5386555791,
-0.7883597016,
-0.4181779325,
-0.7591014504,
-0.2594521642,
0.513381362,
-0.1264343709,
0.1075177342,
-0.3813639879,
-0.1458013952,
0.3311415315,
-0.6593222022,
0.5569496155,
0.4402365386,
-0.6793926358,
-0.4131893218,
0.754075408,
0.1337483972,
0.3013060987,
0.4911032021,
-0.0655327961,
-0.3072487116,
-0.9369941354,
-0.2090462297,
0.1104352698,
-0.6072610021,
-0.0079063084,
-0.8330099583,
-0.1010847986,
-0.6678483486,
-0.2823322117,
-0.2252512276,
-0.5993005633,
0.2055317909,
-0.0363677293,
-0.2437180579,
1.1663547754,
0.0652880967,
0.7641353607,
-0.5604810119,
0.3120727241,
0.0213249251,
-0.0210801177,
-0.2939218879,
-0.2868086696,
-0.3205984831,
-0.1435512304,
-0.4320428669,
-0.0204675514,
0.7408291698,
-0.2726077437,
0.7586997747,
0.4354161024,
0.082804136,
0.5527355671,
-0.6752811074,
1.120852232,
0.1469915211,
-0.674474299,
0.6592304111,
-0.5779246688,
0.5360249877,
0.2423276305,
0.3839138746,
-0.3687987924,
-0.5738235116,
-0.7121399045,
-0.9689469934,
0.8363651037,
0.1025769189,
0.11380817,
0.3452094793,
-0.0762344226,
-0.0285378043,
0.5037651658,
-0.8834060431,
0.3205207288,
0.364680171,
0.0769083649,
-0.2497046739,
-0.4104171991,
-0.3366573155,
-0.114017196,
0.707562089,
-0.0246695783,
0.2263707519,
-0.0909416303,
0.1554652154,
-0.3474903703,
0.1581081003,
0.7892891765,
1.0244175196,
-0.3576646149,
0.0770056546,
0.1031705737,
-0.3178711534,
-0.0358568057,
0.0074072261,
-0.0048140339,
-0.0114262346,
0.3809879124,
0.5520749688,
-0.1551198363,
-1.1130301952,
0.1959446967,
-0.1270768791,
-0.1601943523,
-0.4689457119,
0.1221844032,
0.0833335668,
0.5624194741,
0.1290075034,
-0.2025352865,
0.00611444,
-0.6206868887,
-0.1202730834,
0.3891124129,
-0.4192672074,
-0.2575862706,
0.5299598575,
0.8240750432,
-0.8921931982,
0.5350912213,
-0.0688754097,
-0.6483177543,
0.4845831096,
0.1713323444,
0.7852596641,
-0.3548540473,
0.1468545645,
0.3854827881,
0.3587506115,
-0.1994972527,
0.3811018765,
-0.0397474207,
-0.8294309974,
-0.3654574752,
-0.7236791849,
-0.8338167071,
-0.0868627504,
-0.1450928152,
0.4707241356,
-0.3168217242,
-0.2759523094,
-0.3436808586,
-0.120975703,
-0.5578573942,
0.1140975133,
0.2955106497,
0.567918241,
-0.2909223437,
0.6264998913,
0.7086541653,
-0.454262346,
-0.6421114802,
0.0599866286,
-0.0467871465,
-0.8170444369,
0.7008810043,
0.1516656578,
-0.8234370947,
-0.068653971,
-0.5449157953,
-0.7303605676,
0.8200437427,
0.1134066731,
-0.750013113,
-0.6297073364,
0.2756336033,
0.2403753698,
-0.6352223158,
0.031809818,
0.4099995196,
0.4404993057,
0.4717596471,
-1.6709851027,
-0.2833680809,
0.1022987962,
-0.160837248,
0.1243606731,
-0.8468906283,
0.5169500113,
-0.2555136979,
-0.2319847792,
0.737683177,
0.5493324399,
-0.0536964796,
0.0006019028,
0.8570041656,
0.3166699409,
0.7114824653,
-0.2438537031,
0.768435657,
-0.0447426587,
0.1800825894,
1.2353340387,
-0.6691308022,
0.704174161,
0.3681484163,
-0.1661046296,
0.6929494143,
0.647121191,
0.2154030651,
0.5585561395,
0.3463314474,
-0.4194166064,
-0.6500989199,
-0.5020575523,
0.0226245802,
0.752586484,
0.5355337262,
0.2008532733,
-0.3557266891,
0.3601354659,
-0.0610088222,
-0.1136702895,
-0.2643732429,
0.7421028018,
0.0850319564,
-0.9448706508,
-0.0763154328,
-0.1659197211,
0.3799778819,
-0.9040043354,
-0.075736247,
0.1420616806,
0.3078944087,
0.0967251956,
-1.2090996504,
-0.0177691691,
-0.1900332421,
0.3953170776,
-0.6210352778,
0.5393643975,
-0.4153012633,
-0.3290446997,
0.2011382431,
0.4340580702,
0.2985991538,
-0.0025524637,
-0.4862722456,
0.315161705,
-0.0356390253,
-0.3762757778,
0.1007362604,
0.5771592259,
0.0544754714,
1.1618512869,
0.4662430584,
0.1681744605,
-0.0172867104,
0.3173724711,
0.8296393752,
-0.8795498013,
-0.7396066189,
-0.5098393559,
0.3226698041,
-0.0601608604,
-0.1289532334,
0.5756904483,
0.7228522897,
0.8225554228,
0.0546990782,
0.7605063319,
-0.0587469675,
0.3898001015,
-0.5521437526,
0.1634883583,
-0.435525924,
0.2384419441,
-0.0328924246,
-0.8832897544,
-0.3350610137,
0.7184681892,
-0.2793408632,
-0.0583199672,
0.5147255659,
0.7047309875,
0.257873863,
-0.165613234,
0.4385488629,
-0.0973527208,
0.9987800717,
0.4449948668,
1.3011567593,
0.2307626307,
0.6079261899,
0.0116426405,
-0.1966879815,
-0.3979333937,
-0.5027881265,
-0.8060229421,
-0.6360741854,
-0.1284207255,
-0.4250645638,
-0.0506872833,
1.1526896954,
0.7388138771,
-0.4005847275,
-0.7667344213,
-0.0294152331,
0.1678248048,
0.3223458529,
-0.1870444864,
0.00993565,
-0.1110363454,
-1.2358950377,
0.4897427559,
0.8089855909,
0.2076226771,
-0.5529505014,
0.0634263828,
-0.4381859601,
0.1928956062,
0.7466894388,
0.2127245665,
-0.6829538941,
-0.260366261,
-0.0303108636,
0.0552534573,
0.0498575494,
0.8793470263,
-0.3868352175,
0.585770905,
0.2854059339,
0.1788112521,
0.5906130672,
-0.2044466436,
0.9481754303,
0.0063015465,
0.4480778277,
0.6409776211,
0.5546528101,
0.1393768489,
-0.1395082027,
0.5502092242,
-0.1739452928,
-0.8923407197,
-0.7511934042,
0.4794621468,
-1.5843936205,
-0.2813338935,
1.4145841599,
0.1656704396,
-0.1759105325,
-0.3474445641,
-0.7105318904,
-0.0039185691,
-0.3036723137,
0.5689047575,
0.9431806207,
-0.9209138155,
0.1316673309,
-0.5579289198,
0.3179495633,
-0.0779267848,
-0.6983590722,
-0.1462319493,
0.4796369672,
0.0172298308,
0.4801754653,
1.2128039598,
0.2297125757,
-0.17180565,
-0.1473116428,
0.374522686,
0.465908587,
-0.589209199,
0.2177342325,
0.2952342927,
0.3804231286,
-0.0773157626
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13533v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13533v2
|
Automated Clinical Coding for Outpatient Departments
| 2023-12-21T02:28:29 | 2023-12-24T08:16:46 |
Viktor Schlegel, Abhinav Ramesh Kashyap, Thanh-Tung Nguyen, Tsung-Han Yang, Vijay Prakash Dwivedi, Wei-Hsian Yin, Jeng Wei, Stefan Winkler
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Computerised clinical coding approaches aim to automate the process of
assigning a set of codes to medical records. While there is active research
pushing the state of the art on clinical coding for hospitalized patients, the
outpatient setting -- where doctors tend to non-hospitalised patients -- is
overlooked. Although both settings can be formalised as a multi-label
classification task, they present unique and distinct challenges, which raises
the question of whether the success of inpatient clinical coding approaches
translates to the outpatient setting. This paper is the first to investigate
how well state-of-the-art deep learning-based clinical coding approaches work
in the outpatient setting at hospital scale. To this end, we collect a large
outpatient dataset comprising over 7 million notes documenting over half a
million patients. We adapt four state-of-the-art clinical coding approaches to
this setting and evaluate their potential to assist coders. We find evidence
that clinical coding in outpatient settings can benefit from more innovations
in popular inpatient coding benchmarks. A deeper analysis of the factors
contributing to the success -- amount and form of data and choice of document
representation -- reveals the presence of easy-to-solve examples, the coding of
which can be completely automated with a low error rate.
|
[
-0.1415681392,
-0.1556000561,
0.8629068136,
-0.0239610858,
-0.0661773831,
0.0242347661,
-0.2565970421,
-0.4001568258,
0.1162050068,
0.3847265244,
-0.2532098591,
-0.5887105465,
-0.8331984878,
0.295098573,
-0.3955923319,
0.7117364407,
-0.2408336401,
0.3539114296,
-0.6252086163,
-0.0145875569,
-0.4363158941,
-1.0816352367,
-0.4002605677,
-0.3214433193,
0.1127289161,
0.6139961481,
0.7091225982,
0.5861942172,
1.0795930624,
0.2940330207,
0.4499233067,
0.5624429584,
-0.2203299552,
-0.2660895586,
0.3008220792,
-0.334035635,
-0.2857552767,
-0.3238867223,
0.4878510237,
0.8357767463,
-0.3561300635,
-0.1566496193,
-0.2994219065,
0.7708794475,
-0.5015411973,
0.1443436593,
-0.04837339,
0.3495810032,
0.0434470885,
-0.4156230688,
-0.5878174901,
-0.7712802291,
0.0320092998,
-0.2749757171,
0.3153710663,
-0.2565302253,
0.1780124605,
0.0068755639,
-0.4699848294,
-1.059117794,
-0.4552140832,
0.1567835957,
-0.8293748498,
0.3601725399,
0.5125554204,
0.271266669,
-0.2709443271,
-0.8720938563,
-0.1605392545,
-0.3270928562,
-0.4605992138,
0.0942410082,
0.1042405069,
0.1597718745,
0.4508183897,
0.651152432,
-0.5207561255,
0.454493314,
-0.4045523405,
0.255341351,
0.8245551586,
0.3924539983,
0.2544710934,
0.2317741811,
-0.0170351025,
0.0566404909,
-0.1192808449,
0.1248792708,
-0.228475228,
0.0410051756,
-0.1097235009,
0.3942270577,
-0.06611339,
0.2429714203,
0.1175217777,
-0.2112453878,
0.2415055335,
-0.1151346937,
-0.3137712777,
0.5102672577,
0.549777627,
0.6911868453,
0.1302551627,
-0.3349066973,
-0.2239431143,
0.4894120097,
0.8770961761,
-0.5739914179,
-0.4547706842,
0.2997620106,
-0.8618004918,
-0.3454830647,
-0.3091769516,
-0.5462095737,
-0.8831108212,
-0.639030695,
0.1116548106,
-0.4778499305,
0.2247587442,
0.2825648785,
0.0131124649,
-0.1684059054,
0.7002570033,
-0.7072304487,
0.5436086059,
0.332190752,
0.6033415198,
-0.020842595,
0.0314390063,
-0.4266263843,
-0.1355518848,
-0.6837791204,
0.6718310714,
-0.3716110587,
-0.4556698799,
0.3244142234,
0.1209107712,
-0.0029082936,
-0.7200056911,
0.1612711102,
-0.2753329575,
0.1255459189,
0.0614983924,
-0.8070545197,
0.0473399162,
-0.0358240977,
-0.4783526957,
0.3636305332,
0.5720172524,
-0.0816688091,
0.5121686459,
-0.4935246706,
-0.5252537131,
0.3145772517,
-0.2175264359,
-0.6523817778,
0.5446076989,
0.3842860162,
0.38465783,
-0.297962755,
0.198443681,
-0.0201886389,
-0.5274639726,
0.4816555083,
0.0294297114,
0.6153460145,
0.3072870374,
0.0574456342,
-0.0151165593,
-0.7993053198,
0.2447275519,
-0.0797871798,
-0.301605165,
0.0458601229,
-0.2530305982,
0.043652989,
0.2249477208,
-0.1967519075,
-0.3410666883,
0.4991213381,
-0.0102388421,
0.5559838414,
0.2414501607,
0.1963409483,
0.5146139264,
-0.5324574709,
0.5437046885,
-0.073666662,
0.3984919488,
-0.1753339469,
-0.3650429249,
-0.3138393462,
-0.3073913157,
0.1837377846,
0.3898265064,
-0.5640794039,
0.1428408176,
0.1095143482,
-0.5863828063,
-0.6078471541,
-0.127533704,
0.4731319547,
0.7263357043,
0.3975889087,
-0.8590451479,
-0.3762961626,
-0.578032732,
0.1115430444,
0.0642721802,
0.21106112,
0.5000189543,
0.4736889005,
-0.692111969,
0.6002001762,
-0.4290527403,
-0.968488574,
-0.1682666093,
0.0144932615,
0.5483766198,
0.6506952047,
0.295281738,
-0.3746873438,
-0.4863268137,
0.0871973559,
-1.2080296278,
0.0330752619,
-0.4859118462,
0.5426931977,
0.279754132,
0.7379293442,
-0.0527955331,
0.8937633038,
0.189811334,
0.2237509489,
0.0246890429,
-1.0859084129,
0.3519578576,
-0.4301548302,
-0.0887459219,
-0.0563510209,
-0.118635498,
-0.8639196754,
0.0255364329,
0.6084023118,
-0.3409428,
-0.1690383852,
-0.2568485439,
-0.3027067482,
0.0687574074,
0.0696016401,
-0.1824834943,
-0.0429937579,
0.5633107424,
0.2678083181,
0.1683986038,
0.3645886481,
-0.5224446058,
0.6549788713,
0.3301846087,
-0.4345178902,
0.6936003566,
-0.2958925962,
0.4648064375,
-0.4756549299,
0.4972599447,
-0.7962009907,
-0.389508307,
-0.1526918709,
-0.2589053512,
0.4900453389,
-0.4282244146,
-0.6039566398,
-0.4234277308,
-0.1826329082,
0.5329404473,
0.5279844403,
-0.2818381488,
0.0745500624,
0.389874965,
0.0858139396,
-0.0278767757,
-1.0273315907,
0.4076409042,
-0.144497484,
0.1044718474,
0.0850528181,
0.1454736143,
-0.1059249714,
-0.2594165206,
0.2464675307,
-0.3562235236,
-0.0013921089,
0.2771282494,
-0.0218255688,
-0.1627913266,
0.1671719849,
-0.0878663808,
-0.2489513755,
0.2183600366,
-0.4085195065,
0.3404421508,
-0.0500985943,
-0.58463943,
-1.0426985025,
0.8118951321,
0.4269824028,
-0.0275543444,
0.469835043,
0.2421824485,
-0.6140314341,
-0.1516540498,
-0.4158085883,
0.1204874739,
-0.3674888909,
0.2414363027,
0.1357766539,
-0.5649632215,
0.3639441729,
-0.193206653,
-0.1077401042,
0.0141839627,
0.5663589239,
-0.4695571363,
0.8332374096,
0.6034330726,
0.4307116568,
-0.1158873737,
-0.4633426964,
0.3970829844,
-0.6509734988,
-0.5442054272,
-0.621306777,
-0.1440916061,
-0.6897670031,
-0.2927525043,
0.7425857186,
0.1690039188,
-0.0657268018,
0.3855473697,
-1.016146183,
0.2196519077,
0.5738276243,
0.3501369357,
0.2448749393,
-0.2034549564,
0.3062457144,
-0.0554712825,
-0.9277005196,
0.0282047652,
1.0218031406,
0.5261986852,
0.9106994867,
0.1577124149,
1.0734641552,
0.5930534005,
0.3947109878,
-0.6912911534,
-0.0102524366,
-0.518370688,
-0.0513569303,
-0.0446498245,
-0.0954225063,
-0.7311134934,
-0.2753021121,
-0.1013272703,
-0.4621728957,
0.8671729565,
0.26938501,
-0.6438740492,
0.0090027144,
-1.0481621027,
0.7519600987,
-0.2724835277,
0.242017597,
-0.1404743195,
-0.8269584775,
-0.1270675361,
-0.3601614237,
0.5395857692,
0.475297302,
0.0754988417,
0.471795857,
-0.7468423843,
0.8541519046,
-0.0236582085,
-0.3234192133,
0.0138299139,
-0.0320428982,
0.3408403099,
0.3726371229,
0.3233076334,
0.3173434436,
0.2725980878,
-0.1756685525,
-0.8007880449,
0.4542861879,
-0.6745398045,
0.0850936621,
-0.5148250461,
-0.4161181152,
-0.4161733091,
0.1198648438,
0.4488139153,
1.2765189409,
0.2389254123,
0.0775621086,
0.7190024853,
-0.5518402457,
0.4704474509,
0.1677333713,
0.0264736395,
-0.6409695148,
0.5986156464,
0.312631309,
0.1621989608,
0.6493165493,
0.093108058,
-0.3912387192,
-0.7363114357,
-0.5803354383,
-0.1008555815,
-1.1132065058,
-0.2702525854,
-0.5007404685,
-0.3880917132,
-0.6475172639,
-0.9582263231,
-0.1703473181,
-0.0899148956,
-0.2050955743,
0.3088344634,
0.289576441,
1.0367906094,
0.0228641983,
0.2942996025,
-0.8863453269,
0.3389642835,
0.1329049617,
0.5458394885,
-0.0720915496,
-0.2694784403,
-0.5852495432,
-0.2639589906,
0.2029810101,
-0.686709106,
0.3776136041,
0.0449382253,
0.2263974845,
0.33488217,
0.1355262101,
0.9499202967,
-0.5393439531,
0.4201179445,
0.5059287548,
-0.639944911,
0.4693197906,
0.0433628,
0.3304539323,
0.8474613428,
0.403493017,
-0.7368678451,
0.1181744039,
-0.5592680573,
-0.6726776958,
0.6387627125,
-0.2209502161,
-0.0235012341,
-0.0301172137,
0.4595490098,
0.2020194381,
0.3103296757,
-0.2165878713,
-0.1994227916,
0.0097006569,
-0.2955794632,
-0.38194561,
-0.1107915416,
-0.2648478448,
-0.1094979644,
-0.0673441961,
-0.4343709648,
0.7813849449,
0.5296529531,
-0.1846668571,
-0.2632304132,
0.1198913455,
0.6940881014,
0.8778542876,
-0.2167747915,
0.1918281019,
0.1414618343,
-0.5598212481,
0.0934900641,
0.092460826,
0.1028063744,
-0.0572162271,
0.6007446051,
0.4047748744,
-0.0553962924,
-0.5951001048,
0.5753173232,
-0.5032384396,
-0.4289211333,
-0.5915252566,
-0.0645812005,
-0.4350626767,
-0.0009906421,
-0.2324515134,
0.4004144073,
0.1576915532,
-0.5469889641,
0.3992174268,
0.2025687099,
-0.7117114067,
0.2027205676,
0.4229933918,
-0.2104573697,
-0.5413083434,
1.020169735,
0.1021785662,
0.0167017411,
0.7404674292,
0.6337127686,
0.7303454876,
0.2164470404,
0.1673951298,
0.0073301131,
0.1823571026,
-0.0118851839,
0.2563965619,
-0.180529967,
-0.2174545228,
-0.4415128231,
-0.2623120546,
-0.5009125471,
0.0518498495,
-0.9570872784,
0.2955355346,
-0.8556531072,
0.0782767162,
-0.1812683791,
-0.2445685863,
-0.5239220858,
0.554643929,
0.5191193223,
1.0036706924,
-0.3497777581,
0.7214390635,
0.8559032083,
-0.327612102,
-0.6910660267,
-0.4087527692,
0.0546194725,
-0.8900345564,
0.0631430671,
0.1525194049,
0.0886802226,
-0.1354070306,
-0.2086349875,
-0.5673738718,
0.6546797752,
-0.0699392632,
-0.5757959485,
-0.1653800905,
0.4036890268,
0.8640334606,
-0.3735378981,
0.3528414965,
0.4642995596,
-0.2010561079,
-0.0733563825,
-1.1433565617,
0.0246166792,
-0.2894816399,
-0.0709953457,
0.2450469583,
-0.373668015,
0.4067933261,
-0.3733848631,
0.3073148727,
-0.1175910756,
0.1898919791,
-0.2234343141,
0.623681426,
0.02346945,
0.8627185822,
0.8386341333,
-0.0802407116,
1.0603681803,
-0.0513214506,
0.1821793914,
0.783737123,
-0.2605893016,
0.0857426897,
0.1046296135,
-0.4326405823,
0.5757837296,
0.4092085361,
-0.106201157,
0.6521478891,
0.3416152,
-0.0137384376,
0.0151325269,
-0.1013641581,
-0.6295084953,
0.2668537498,
0.4019969404,
-0.5461890697,
-0.0551525429,
0.2605091333,
-0.0467010625,
0.0150041441,
-0.6539002657,
1.1554133892,
0.3391696513,
-0.7683060169,
0.7396270037,
-0.103391096,
0.1554698348,
-0.589825213,
-0.1624827981,
-0.1529110372,
0.728169322,
-0.6954901218,
-0.5913754702,
0.0863558576,
-0.3141008317,
-0.0153606767,
-0.7861219645,
0.5035592318,
-0.1612642258,
-0.1840553135,
-0.3155085444,
0.0875913724,
0.0819703341,
0.3671845198,
-0.3376624584,
-0.2636085451,
-0.1195788682,
0.4376393855,
0.7410076261,
0.730045259,
-0.17247428,
0.4851581156,
0.6791030765,
0.1218127385,
-0.1013879403,
0.4547497034,
0.8675977588,
-0.5232509375,
-0.7296885848,
-0.5635273457,
0.2661787868,
0.1857596785,
-0.6352035999,
0.4608363509,
0.4071343243,
0.6388547421,
-0.1698404104,
0.5567766428,
0.051697202,
0.199427709,
-0.3336333632,
0.4446798861,
-0.4081867635,
-0.0610799193,
-0.5385529399,
-0.117326498,
-0.8142457604,
0.4655030668,
-0.1717908829,
-0.3091174662,
0.8190732598,
0.5081874132,
0.3236993849,
0.194152832,
0.197728157,
-0.1762430966,
0.4143249393,
0.9633117914,
0.9256936908,
-0.2454824895,
-0.0243622642,
-0.7350309491,
-0.5704720616,
-0.1533990949,
-0.7600799203,
-0.6989408731,
-0.2641634047,
-0.5875043273,
-0.6439926624,
-0.1234165728,
0.981816113,
0.6130616665,
-0.8763275146,
-0.1863782853,
-0.2092419416,
-0.4274006188,
-0.5917505622,
-0.044949729,
0.736474812,
-0.601213634,
-0.2266146541,
0.2242029756,
0.5236843824,
-0.1668016762,
0.1489723027,
0.0006956242,
0.1290941834,
-0.3750766814,
0.3344295323,
0.0252220184,
-0.1294490844,
0.3432187438,
-0.1146702692,
-0.4136258662,
0.2739987075,
1.0701589584,
-0.9727348685,
0.6005532146,
0.0157354008,
0.6433201432,
0.3091451228,
-0.0810949653,
0.1492845118,
-0.3252235055,
-0.0888731629,
0.6616489291,
0.2631063163,
0.0361982882,
-0.7404228449,
0.3383556604,
0.3974425495,
-0.8695434928,
-0.9346523881,
-0.0542892851,
-0.6159161925,
-0.203721717,
0.6952319741,
-0.1958406717,
0.2281143516,
-0.582444787,
-0.1876909137,
-0.1355994791,
-0.1502369642,
0.9538186789,
0.1930294037,
-0.871661365,
-0.1352764517,
-0.4436410069,
0.9792724848,
0.0210150331,
-0.7278611064,
-0.2468892038,
0.4747843444,
-0.1197007149,
0.2037798464,
0.9707799554,
-0.350166589,
0.5822879076,
-0.1888074428,
-0.1147745028,
0.0043742764,
-0.2203015834,
-0.5869835019,
0.5041791201,
-0.1357984394,
0.0943354517
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01643v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01643v2
|
L-TUNING: Synchronized Label Tuning for Prompt and Prefix in LLMs
| 2023-12-21T01:47:49 | 2024-04-13T00:14:21 |
Md. Kowsher, Md. Shohanur Islam Sobuj, Asif Mahmud, Nusrat Jahan Prottasha, Prakash Bhat
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Efficiently fine-tuning Large Language Models (LLMs) for specific tasks
presents a considerable challenge in natural language processing. Traditional
methods, like prompt or prefix tuning, typically rely on arbitrary tokens for
training, leading to prolonged training times and generalized token use across
various class labels. To address these issues, this paper introduces L-Tuning,
an efficient fine-tuning approach designed for classification tasks within the
Natural Language Inference (NLI) framework. Diverging from conventional
methods, L-Tuning focuses on the fine-tuning of label tokens processed through
a pre-trained LLM, thereby harnessing its pre-existing semantic knowledge. This
technique not only improves the fine-tuning accuracy and efficiency but also
facilitates the generation of distinct label embeddings for each class,
enhancing the model's training nuance. Our experimental results indicate a
significant improvement in training efficiency and classification accuracy with
L-Tuning compared to traditional approaches, marking a promising advancement in
fine-tuning LLMs for complex language tasks.
|
[
-0.498149395,
-0.774784565,
0.3652907014,
0.091753453,
-0.4534830451,
0.2211239189,
-0.5802800059,
-0.4829620421,
0.074610278,
0.29147771,
-0.8496274352,
-0.5997499824,
-0.5515654683,
0.4035830796,
-0.0907332599,
0.9698715806,
0.0826250613,
0.0380245335,
0.0320111774,
-0.066952914,
-0.644322753,
-0.2653212845,
-1.0804499388,
-0.457128495,
0.9614883661,
0.4519590437,
0.7058423162,
1.0727733374,
0.2583320737,
0.2717347145,
-0.1460071206,
0.6603453755,
-0.3889132738,
0.2761885226,
-0.2181635946,
-0.603723526,
-0.4267425537,
0.0593001209,
0.6752205491,
0.7163453698,
0.1199644208,
0.21410124,
0.1292083114,
0.6483579278,
-0.7603886127,
0.1042693555,
-0.8573374748,
-0.053021118,
-0.3845347166,
-0.4976209402,
-0.4570272565,
-0.42412135,
-0.2196530849,
-0.7859557271,
0.2782492638,
0.5918778777,
1.0458046198,
0.7496070862,
-0.0895699114,
-0.2477021515,
-0.2758061886,
0.8390858769,
-0.7813841701,
0.6379444003,
0.483728528,
0.0564857237,
-0.3031550944,
-0.6620252728,
-0.471139878,
-0.1707920283,
-0.1579062939,
-0.0949493125,
0.2397190183,
0.4462855458,
0.320148319,
0.3822138309,
-0.3390072286,
0.8389849067,
0.1614072174,
-0.1952716112,
0.4725378454,
0.1788071692,
0.225066036,
0.2959447503,
-0.05867799,
-0.0005265952,
-0.6465616822,
0.0266515892,
0.3035165668,
0.7113983631,
0.2328890264,
0.3860087097,
-0.4675803781,
1.352920413,
0.2658560574,
-0.3677467406,
0.1775546819,
-0.3991098702,
-0.3178445697,
0.3670311272,
0.5681904554,
0.4914503098,
0.4174472094,
-0.3614311516,
-0.3229555786,
0.0527997538,
-0.0667717978,
-0.7535917163,
-0.0845599622,
0.0867595673,
-0.0350605994,
-0.1886757761,
-0.1565725058,
-0.3575136364,
-0.3771687448,
-0.8752769232,
0.2597614527,
-0.2770188451,
0.1914315522,
0.277823627,
-0.1162320301,
0.2414129525,
0.3950365484,
-1.0978475809,
0.0025769747,
1.0703722239,
0.6640414596,
-0.3129546344,
-0.3333946168,
-1.085478425,
0.1493773162,
-0.3079035878,
0.7130761743,
-0.6709417701,
-0.0298557896,
0.0272746924,
0.028584687,
-0.1828026474,
-0.5995745659,
0.8175725937,
-0.6079807281,
-0.1792767048,
-0.1837943345,
-0.9271838069,
0.2431921661,
0.3331765831,
-0.4069799483,
1.2041925192,
-0.2395604104,
-0.6484456658,
0.6507575512,
-0.3743021488,
-0.4835571349,
0.0211047586,
0.1535817087,
-0.5141387582,
0.1295880973,
0.3451451361,
0.6613682508,
-0.3543685079,
0.4342290759,
-0.1879613101,
-0.4949817657,
0.0781758502,
-0.1215258092,
0.316054672,
0.2057746202,
0.0052815541,
0.3530743122,
-0.8165572882,
0.2151942104,
-0.3581295311,
-0.3461974263,
-0.5330799818,
-0.0375668742,
-0.2228080481,
-0.1627746075,
0.3044882119,
-0.4456887543,
0.3754827678,
-0.6774080396,
0.2806993425,
0.6914597154,
-0.1095116809,
0.6546860933,
-0.2932937145,
0.1459548771,
-0.1424103081,
-0.013465737,
-0.3615324795,
-0.4112408161,
-1.0888966322,
-0.399319768,
0.695165813,
0.6080434918,
-0.6138696074,
0.8815327883,
-0.1801726818,
-0.3687491417,
-0.911292851,
0.3463854194,
0.4557870328,
0.3829943538,
0.3271690309,
0.0459090285,
-0.4562381506,
-0.8377535343,
-0.7128879428,
0.3738462329,
-0.0282725599,
0.1459238827,
0.1343862265,
-0.2270298898,
1.0033028126,
-0.4501127899,
-0.3075762391,
-0.0880629569,
0.3748806119,
0.3494142592,
0.443913132,
0.1150665805,
-0.4608261287,
-0.5549381375,
0.0440818109,
-0.3698013127,
-0.5886172652,
-0.1805246919,
-0.2590087354,
0.2427456528,
1.0855308771,
-0.3013667166,
0.0948754027,
0.2421872914,
-0.3242814839,
0.2129873335,
-0.2075397968,
-0.0110052368,
-0.9967300892,
-0.1756630689,
-0.0670915917,
-0.4599645734,
-0.6589950323,
0.0224846862,
0.2966108322,
0.1966838539,
-0.2800678611,
0.6834213138,
-0.5821947455,
0.3219540417,
-0.3549043834,
0.3096669912,
-0.0626848638,
0.4091088772,
-0.0134075526,
0.7774112821,
0.5948674679,
-0.9094597101,
0.1388287544,
-0.0753178596,
-0.5450499058,
0.468111217,
-0.4189740121,
0.2021057755,
-0.2977012992,
-0.0996844172,
-0.5870376229,
-0.1447696984,
0.2268667221,
-0.1055605859,
0.6881441474,
0.0215414148,
-0.6788342595,
-0.1202383861,
-0.1656894386,
0.2481343448,
0.3440687358,
-0.6812979579,
0.3624137938,
0.1543073356,
0.0333508626,
-0.4061464667,
-0.297531873,
-0.0569110103,
-0.2773457468,
-0.1508124918,
0.5205607414,
-0.018403342,
-0.0864423215,
-0.2501620948,
-0.0983760878,
0.1528320611,
0.3827287555,
0.0712516606,
-0.1072615311,
-0.1093676016,
0.489043802,
0.2838775814,
-0.405177623,
-0.3783697188,
-0.2991842031,
0.5605771542,
0.1404040158,
-0.2818492651,
-0.6953758001,
0.0714372694,
0.3951313496,
-0.3921383619,
0.7639839649,
0.6410752535,
-0.178633377,
-0.5296373963,
-0.6059311628,
-0.3232545555,
-0.5137103796,
0.3867240846,
-0.3433530033,
-1.1204030514,
0.2064660043,
-0.5386321545,
0.1322432458,
0.0223058481,
0.4285608828,
-0.1288236976,
0.907063961,
0.6854847074,
-0.4206213951,
0.723541379,
0.302485019,
0.2395727634,
-0.6846565008,
-0.0456581749,
-0.7756996155,
-0.5442526937,
-0.4932082891,
-0.4418085814,
0.2533951104,
0.5197075605,
-0.4565930665,
0.0514674783,
-0.4444881082,
0.8677646518,
0.6788011789,
0.0564851277,
0.3965276778,
-0.1419021785,
-0.0153976958,
-0.1120139062,
-0.6608547568,
-0.291909188,
0.5267392993,
0.2490179539,
0.6597775221,
-0.1744177639,
0.7850696445,
0.0577705018,
0.2030147761,
-0.9536843896,
0.4504376948,
-0.2161481231,
-0.2642791569,
-0.4032303691,
-0.1656642854,
-0.9582647085,
0.06858024,
-0.4242661893,
-0.7827934623,
-0.181344375,
0.3938477039,
-0.3207609355,
0.2176251858,
-0.660961926,
0.79720819,
-0.1894328743,
-0.2058396637,
-0.102956742,
-0.5954227448,
0.1902587861,
-0.3028852642,
0.163040027,
-0.4651143551,
-0.1142491177,
0.5261529088,
-0.3601953089,
1.098323822,
-0.1316008717,
-0.3053053319,
-0.0230514109,
-0.0936983526,
0.7794142962,
0.1836000383,
-0.227389887,
-0.0957550332,
-0.2792969942,
-0.1959470212,
-0.7501438856,
0.7233899236,
-0.6339350343,
-0.5552142859,
-0.2274531126,
-0.6617639661,
-0.4671450257,
0.2116617709,
0.2572894394,
0.3317513168,
0.0709850118,
-0.0352427587,
0.8231784105,
-0.3390624821,
0.4915105999,
0.5459627509,
-0.2414274365,
-0.3107037544,
0.9356855154,
-0.0774230286,
0.32290411,
0.7269297242,
0.0666371584,
-0.278026998,
-0.5663595796,
-0.3872945011,
0.2223511934,
-0.4154942334,
-0.5891313553,
-0.4079299569,
-0.1164812148,
-0.1427271813,
-0.1528428942,
-0.3744958937,
-0.1756474078,
-0.5513091087,
0.0109569579,
0.6842465997,
0.4594733715,
0.2147107422,
0.5744396448,
-0.7740031481,
0.4429710805,
0.3254275322,
0.6933350563,
-0.2350673079,
-0.5881856084,
-0.2891687751,
0.039874509,
-0.0114823878,
-0.5551264882,
0.233429119,
0.7731416225,
0.461373508,
0.2426133454,
0.1847238094,
1.0640641451,
-0.7059146762,
0.5859971046,
-0.0127915973,
-1.0149925947,
0.6658087373,
-0.246732533,
0.5504251719,
0.8374032378,
0.19112432,
-0.5391559005,
-0.6092472076,
-0.0398304425,
-0.9323456287,
0.7826625705,
-0.0383806489,
-0.0504790992,
-0.1463479549,
0.6459130049,
0.1671469063,
0.1759739518,
-0.4667789936,
-0.4316753745,
0.2476795614,
-0.3691886663,
-0.4936023355,
-0.1905488074,
0.1732666492,
-0.6492840052,
0.8407996297,
-0.3955465257,
-0.1403668076,
0.0249501839,
-0.2715142369,
-0.00120947,
0.4027430117,
0.5847358108,
0.2136031836,
-0.1098022908,
0.2066424638,
0.5759164691,
-0.1269993633,
-0.0118751964,
-0.0006003375,
-0.3031823039,
0.042255614,
0.2296390384,
1.3110719919,
0.6113986373,
-0.5291132927,
0.0618104935,
-0.0592775829,
-0.0718762949,
0.1152691096,
0.3293912113,
0.1993748248,
0.1877571195,
-0.0337660089,
-0.0085064927,
-0.1231066287,
-0.3090440035,
0.124203749,
0.4748909473,
-0.316042304,
-0.0006568322,
0.5091905594,
0.1174561083,
-0.619063437,
0.6028725505,
-0.3496940434,
-0.2640494108,
0.3448924124,
0.6621235609,
0.8492074013,
-0.1317006052,
-0.013704014,
0.5206485391,
0.171499297,
-0.2010414749,
0.120473519,
-0.2754266858,
-0.8549718857,
-0.6435676813,
-1.2076580524,
-0.3401440084,
-0.0196692683,
-0.8173448443,
0.4415463209,
-0.3654659986,
-0.1968371421,
0.101554662,
-0.2915701568,
-0.5362952948,
0.0658629537,
0.3194773495,
1.1934313774,
-0.695959568,
1.078196764,
0.6621673703,
0.2553239465,
-0.7555875778,
-0.0379872546,
-0.3339671493,
-0.6305581927,
0.7184609771,
0.2882136703,
-0.2250526249,
0.4397613108,
-0.4702587426,
-0.8520590067,
0.8250070214,
0.3852669001,
-1.2100855112,
0.206860438,
0.2477933168,
0.5385966897,
-0.0567010939,
-0.0466869771,
0.9961863756,
0.625097692,
-0.1421123743,
-1.2402181625,
-0.1255969554,
-0.0930375457,
0.0338049382,
0.585049808,
-0.4658237696,
0.4338613153,
0.0212887302,
-0.2079491317,
0.1919424981,
0.7707949877,
0.2980648279,
0.2274576426,
0.6664594412,
0.7211190462,
1.2787172794,
-0.4800109863,
0.7652235031,
-0.6070043445,
0.2130102664,
1.2246227264,
-0.2306324095,
0.7663049698,
0.5862161517,
0.0301018693,
0.1362346113,
0.7289705873,
0.0748052448,
0.615025878,
0.42481336,
-0.3506006896,
-0.6506108642,
-0.3076320291,
-0.2444574088,
0.285209626,
0.5189906955,
-0.1495419741,
-0.2895493507,
0.1060346812,
-0.1071956232,
0.062593624,
-0.6880142093,
1.1603927612,
0.1999924481,
-0.9375223517,
0.8382195234,
0.1269928962,
0.9631412625,
-0.5283513069,
0.1658322662,
-0.0832171664,
0.2900749445,
-0.1003337577,
-0.5662430525,
0.1304235607,
-0.1517504454,
-0.2645995915,
-0.4916101396,
0.5839212537,
-0.5680705309,
-0.3432685435,
0.1628242731,
0.2779116631,
-0.0313027017,
0.0455033407,
-0.5686128139,
0.1140389517,
0.0111794733,
-0.0980247483,
0.4077292681,
0.5459455252,
-0.0818733722,
0.7089797258,
0.5472282171,
0.0555471517,
0.2584508657,
0.4074321687,
0.7521185279,
-0.8752414584,
-0.4725989401,
-1.0382635593,
0.2875376642,
-0.0217780098,
-0.4217476249,
0.5641494989,
0.5356590152,
0.7787319422,
-0.1761921942,
0.554762125,
0.3359841108,
0.635337472,
-0.9114873409,
0.5856743455,
-0.4956332445,
0.1912703067,
0.0028399103,
-0.8468095064,
-0.7452728748,
0.4707941711,
-0.0610435642,
-0.256229341,
0.4835811257,
1.0599492788,
-0.0208781902,
0.0697688311,
0.2891238332,
0.1594296992,
0.075025551,
0.3089576364,
0.7905589938,
-0.2359554172,
-0.0531157926,
-0.1817063689,
-0.0194622688,
-0.0776726007,
-1.0910023451,
-1.2062700987,
-0.3770045936,
-0.4560119212,
0.0334601253,
0.2875166237,
1.1216355562,
0.6246216297,
-0.9940296412,
0.053122744,
-0.2056923211,
0.1997286528,
-0.1159484982,
-0.1770244837,
0.2670675218,
-1.130073905,
-1.0444083214,
0.5183972716,
0.2271593511,
-0.0739157647,
0.201315105,
-0.098136887,
-0.1061463356,
-0.1739622504,
0.5514185429,
0.1942136586,
-0.7886447906,
-0.260980159,
-0.1007273942,
-0.0433026776,
-0.0871736705,
0.7676615119,
-0.8855543137,
0.3990858197,
0.463303268,
0.7386438847,
0.3610834777,
0.0831880197,
0.5625735521,
-1.1834300756,
0.2946466804,
0.0074890782,
0.2451108694,
0.1732864082,
-0.1675945222,
0.2085846514,
-0.111923784,
-0.6472331285,
-1.0053452253,
0.3317143917,
-1.0406914949,
-0.2387100905,
1.1718682051,
0.2129060924,
-0.1673515439,
-0.2755334675,
-0.5241856575,
0.521337986,
-0.3607918918,
0.5758835673,
0.3822045326,
0.0481137596,
-0.084403269,
-0.4443573356,
0.9140604138,
0.5864473581,
-0.7174369097,
0.1230742186,
0.0819375888,
0.1561628431,
-0.0407017171,
0.2495601326,
0.4446265697,
-0.0712468401,
-0.5968176723,
-0.0245755371,
-0.1847903728,
-0.2349470258,
-0.2849240899,
0.0408231765,
0.3619585931,
-0.1941481382
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14197v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14197v3
|
Benchmarking and Defending Against Indirect Prompt Injection Attacks on Large Language Models
| 2023-12-21T01:08:39 | 2024-03-08T07:58:48 |
Jingwei Yi, Yueqi Xie, Bin Zhu, Emre Kiciman, Guangzhong Sun, Xing Xie, Fangzhao Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The integration of large language models (LLMs) with external content has
enabled more up-to-date and wide-ranging applications of LLMs, such as
Microsoft Copilot. However, this integration has also exposed LLMs to the risk
of indirect prompt injection attacks, where an attacker can embed malicious
instructions within external content, compromising LLM output and causing
responses to deviate from user expectations. To investigate this important but
underexplored issue, we introduce the first benchmark for indirect prompt
injection attacks, named BIPIA, to evaluate the risk of such attacks. Based on
the evaluation, our work makes a key analysis of the underlying reason for the
success of the attack, namely the inability of LLMs to distinguish between
instructions and external content and the absence of LLMs' awareness to not
execute instructions within external content. Building upon this analysis, we
develop two black-box methods based on prompt learning and a white-box defense
method based on fine-tuning with adversarial training accordingly. Experimental
results demonstrate that black-box defenses are highly effective in mitigating
these attacks, while the white-box defense reduces the attack success rate to
near-zero levels. Overall, our work systematically investigates indirect prompt
injection attacks by introducing a benchmark, analyzing the underlying reason
for the success of the attack, and developing an initial set of defenses.
|
[
-0.2259079963,
-1.2463810444,
0.5348146558,
0.2292435169,
-0.0480387136,
0.085034214,
-0.0967807919,
-0.3871376812,
-0.4128432572,
0.3717558682,
-0.4368733168,
-0.2643791139,
-0.6848240495,
0.1878058314,
-0.3310449421,
0.7360136509,
0.1978139579,
0.052442655,
-0.0427519158,
0.1052506566,
-0.9442363381,
-0.5288835764,
-0.8767895103,
0.2341773212,
0.557287693,
0.2453829795,
0.4296789467,
0.3811708093,
0.4803884327,
0.3076607287,
-0.1868342906,
-0.0876290202,
-0.3796910048,
0.0783670321,
-0.318348825,
-0.6711789966,
-0.0728918239,
-0.1022754386,
0.6745998859,
0.7104309797,
0.0640855506,
0.031270016,
0.1843255013,
0.2914170623,
-0.8637045026,
-0.2320226878,
-0.728785634,
0.1331802309,
-0.4340766072,
-0.3032968938,
-0.9233028293,
-0.2015454024,
0.0000495845,
-0.3469664454,
-0.0133383777,
0.2326915711,
0.8486489654,
0.180862546,
-0.678917408,
-0.3531230688,
-0.400408566,
0.4285950661,
-0.4775415659,
0.0125053218,
0.1624927521,
0.4980812669,
-0.7070157528,
-0.5102604032,
-0.5472100377,
-0.3608263135,
-0.1423507631,
-0.0255893618,
-0.7056409717,
0.0099673616,
0.5529739261,
0.0087679373,
-0.7887625098,
0.3691482246,
-0.1022620425,
-0.2503626049,
0.2853390872,
0.1786018461,
0.4465486705,
-0.1948805898,
-0.7148584723,
-0.2248856276,
-1.2797371149,
0.3301564157,
0.6997543573,
0.2814196944,
-0.2533330917,
0.5481783152,
-0.118585594,
0.5764912367,
0.149733752,
0.0892733932,
-0.0230548345,
-0.3286625743,
-0.2502861619,
0.0204534195,
1.0106606483,
0.02644586,
0.1004022807,
-0.2308418304,
-0.0811236352,
-0.1038728431,
0.2775337994,
-0.9480767846,
0.1134478524,
0.1462249458,
-0.2145958543,
-0.3627234399,
-0.0562842898,
-0.9471091628,
-0.5610951781,
0.0145299267,
0.4446459413,
-0.4027571678,
0.0233972333,
-0.3407161832,
-0.0559676252,
0.1553861946,
0.2576572299,
-0.4920328557,
0.4125025272,
0.8538193703,
0.9056540132,
-0.2380952537,
-0.2749435306,
-1.4645440578,
0.2856357098,
-0.4910039306,
0.8973078132,
-0.2756565213,
-0.6420833468,
0.3943733275,
0.2102315128,
0.2923960388,
-0.5751714706,
0.4556852281,
-0.5434291363,
0.1138626933,
-0.2403335869,
-0.416846931,
0.0346911401,
0.4426141977,
-0.3094635308,
0.8749810457,
-0.1389830559,
-0.7661770582,
0.0885028318,
-0.3498660028,
-0.5943555832,
0.183599174,
-0.2195670605,
-0.191287145,
0.3091110289,
-0.065487653,
0.4002349675,
-0.5609474182,
0.2170217186,
-0.4759065211,
-0.2724581063,
0.4092159569,
-0.6164503694,
1.154386282,
-0.1173112243,
-0.3952781856,
0.1943126023,
-0.743652761,
-0.1779612899,
0.1686797291,
-0.0240701996,
-0.4579124749,
-0.1674655825,
-0.3477409482,
0.1009782776,
0.1815852821,
-0.4294402897,
0.2725285888,
-0.4086258113,
0.1080066636,
0.985863626,
0.2313385606,
0.2040771842,
-0.1105299219,
0.5216201544,
0.1280109882,
0.383712709,
-0.3320482671,
-0.4679973423,
-0.4537906647,
-0.4037225842,
0.2454186082,
0.7657871246,
-0.8340786695,
0.3141811788,
-0.0717502534,
-0.5706399083,
-0.1540157944,
0.298306942,
0.6686098576,
0.780143559,
0.2985866964,
0.0125637725,
-0.0460862294,
-1.0607175827,
-0.210813567,
-0.2758622766,
-0.1844757646,
0.1494237781,
0.4002253413,
-0.1678562164,
0.4376561642,
-0.4586782455,
0.0243388284,
0.157570377,
0.3391929567,
0.2875044644,
0.515057385,
0.6952732205,
-0.4064826965,
-0.7097221613,
-0.1035729647,
-0.5843115449,
-0.5472618937,
-0.1280613095,
-0.2978507876,
0.0707620531,
0.5764289498,
-0.7384647727,
0.5192865133,
0.5690733194,
-0.4336586893,
0.7752789259,
-0.2536612749,
0.0551797152,
-0.8640530705,
0.1669463068,
-0.0512406863,
-0.1229515448,
-0.8389553428,
0.1403523833,
0.4476733208,
-0.3532391191,
-0.6954579353,
0.8151751161,
-0.4035824239,
-0.076014854,
-0.2189888656,
-0.0030933889,
0.1547127217,
0.4454536438,
-0.1608308554,
0.9845862389,
0.7085629106,
-0.6806306839,
0.3865655363,
0.0039826129,
-0.5078058839,
0.9327617288,
-1.0156468153,
0.2916668057,
0.2622788548,
0.1017279327,
-1.1264588833,
0.1412186176,
0.6529119611,
-0.2726995051,
0.724390924,
-0.4763200879,
-0.7366659641,
-0.0385778174,
-0.4219369292,
0.1559067816,
0.4959469438,
-0.7121621966,
0.4816315174,
0.0062811482,
-0.4722873271,
-0.8420989513,
-0.5109092593,
0.3887457848,
-0.3093667626,
-0.6675479412,
0.3923196495,
-0.2505964339,
-0.3339448869,
-0.2021564096,
0.2538847029,
0.1631580591,
0.5670054555,
0.2044697851,
0.4530675411,
-0.083079651,
-0.1673953533,
0.0544928685,
-0.1846507788,
0.3705980182,
0.1491546929,
0.5948489904,
0.2206202745,
-0.6632333994,
-0.6146211028,
0.6018957496,
0.2065295875,
-0.0102035655,
0.7152608633,
0.2562621832,
-0.2087139338,
-0.2760435641,
-0.5524162054,
-0.0446470529,
-0.5324767828,
0.2412724644,
-0.4866946638,
-0.215282768,
0.350722611,
-0.1080796346,
-0.1596301049,
0.0401318073,
0.465482533,
-0.0663736016,
0.9682306647,
0.3895018399,
0.0689303651,
0.5973631144,
-0.0237474199,
-0.0692764744,
-0.8926205039,
-0.2451429814,
-0.759070456,
0.0413100086,
-0.5791148543,
-0.3477083147,
0.3251636922,
0.1519032419,
-0.3728667498,
0.277970314,
-0.1436093152,
0.2714718878,
0.7839620709,
-0.0730462447,
0.0549758337,
-0.2324074805,
-0.3022536933,
0.2883692086,
-0.4685237408,
-0.4782284796,
1.0954253674,
0.3326694369,
0.7681288719,
0.4492997229,
0.3134293556,
0.4656271338,
0.217368558,
-0.4415616691,
0.6797789335,
0.1418825537,
-0.4016718566,
0.1805687547,
-0.6021404266,
-1.1107609272,
0.2023113221,
-0.0809353814,
-0.8294209838,
0.2757193744,
0.1020806283,
-0.3338497579,
0.0349473767,
-1.1142588854,
1.0415146351,
-0.5995662808,
-0.8534399867,
0.1140557155,
-0.6014894843,
0.3533467948,
-0.0643641129,
0.076687023,
-0.0553427897,
-0.2811712027,
0.3242609501,
-0.3161940277,
0.9999203086,
-0.2681462765,
-0.1101963371,
-0.0375274047,
0.4386648536,
0.7914561629,
0.4071854353,
0.2012230307,
0.4707273543,
-0.0165558811,
-0.6416728497,
-0.4451309144,
0.6941710711,
-0.5921297073,
-1.1234161854,
-0.6836803555,
-0.4334284663,
-0.3334776759,
0.164181143,
0.1993427128,
0.5306780934,
-0.2695827186,
0.0653071329,
0.7203733921,
-0.7046196461,
0.632587254,
0.8903025985,
0.0783143044,
-0.468590796,
0.6660946608,
-0.0057896026,
0.5095251799,
0.5483583808,
0.3529851437,
-0.0602756925,
-0.7849707007,
-0.623526752,
0.129454121,
-0.6661553383,
-0.4819701314,
-0.400256902,
0.0702334866,
-0.5563384891,
0.0363281108,
-0.0282059014,
0.0587349869,
-0.0814746171,
0.2296462953,
-0.0439583808,
0.5539762378,
0.1388952732,
0.4492138326,
-0.6184031963,
0.0935542434,
0.3892325163,
-0.007259727,
-0.1984074563,
-0.6199172735,
0.0210054573,
-0.1454284489,
-0.4819491208,
-1.112659812,
0.2681532204,
-0.3166978955,
0.6256023645,
0.6181727052,
0.0533637851,
0.5785319209,
-0.7762668133,
0.6567323804,
0.1060206816,
-0.9462534189,
0.6707295775,
-0.108919926,
0.424944371,
0.4250709116,
0.3589609265,
-0.4620965421,
-0.1956143826,
-0.448923856,
-0.4593891799,
0.6970568895,
0.1405989081,
0.0645204559,
-0.1895376146,
0.0544043332,
0.1872932911,
0.3017336428,
-0.5641422868,
-0.244750455,
0.1150947511,
0.0075100902,
-0.081246525,
-0.3744888008,
-0.3511372805,
0.2673467696,
0.7236446738,
-0.0580624267,
0.1780758947,
-0.1169236675,
-0.2441494912,
0.0562327281,
0.2326070219,
0.5498611331,
0.2622637153,
-0.0781087428,
0.3082130551,
0.1907233745,
-0.2540538609,
0.2260800153,
0.5343403816,
-0.4582332969,
-0.0634718984,
0.6153817177,
0.6370642781,
0.207769379,
-0.9715961814,
0.8017591834,
-0.2553926408,
0.4922232628,
-0.3417147696,
-0.0072563794,
-0.147609368,
0.0888541862,
0.2931517661,
-0.0983877331,
0.1092782244,
-0.8256983161,
-0.2625267506,
0.7709054351,
-0.2594762743,
-0.3740873039,
0.1702669263,
0.2256256789,
-0.5223989487,
0.2743429542,
-0.0822762176,
-0.4810423553,
0.7694149613,
0.5886220932,
0.7365729213,
-0.3713177145,
-0.1153722033,
0.2498322874,
0.5841318965,
0.398719877,
0.0380853564,
-0.0254334118,
-0.2684190273,
-0.1381681561,
-0.1148888245,
-0.608663857,
0.2199226022,
-0.4679435492,
0.472191304,
-0.6434099674,
0.0364506692,
-0.0371012799,
0.0826045647,
-0.7189315557,
-0.3062986434,
0.1135093197,
1.2178828716,
-0.5684027672,
0.628418684,
0.42629233,
-0.4744114876,
-0.3369249105,
0.0224364493,
0.1621679217,
-0.7862926126,
0.8667730093,
0.3516051769,
0.0356060341,
-0.4989737272,
-0.2791207731,
-0.6086065769,
0.7538153529,
0.6030694246,
-0.697907269,
0.0012016542,
0.2361421287,
0.2438414544,
-0.0941338167,
0.4902175963,
0.2232982665,
0.3286647797,
-0.2802186012,
-0.5397738218,
0.2541888654,
-0.231142655,
0.0166101307,
0.2366026044,
-0.5701110363,
0.6712018251,
0.1172648147,
-0.4555004537,
0.1815599501,
0.4112207592,
0.1516759247,
0.3522271812,
0.4440419972,
0.4420749545,
0.6600317955,
-0.1793731898,
1.4445585012,
-0.2631798685,
-0.2485898137,
1.408711195,
-0.5750443935,
0.9592781067,
0.5724716187,
-0.1003897786,
0.4129984081,
0.4296398163,
-0.0601471066,
0.5764510036,
0.3249495029,
-0.3273951113,
0.2101067305,
-0.2777534723,
-0.4633934796,
0.1864413172,
0.3138217032,
-0.1488074064,
-0.0296485294,
0.1740009934,
0.2919829488,
-0.0494970605,
-0.1431524158,
1.0206724405,
-0.1579526514,
-0.8735883236,
0.4000537992,
-0.0904954895,
0.5117138028,
-0.943993628,
0.0873955563,
-0.4036277831,
0.1546199471,
0.308110714,
-0.6809948683,
-0.0745974705,
0.2453556359,
0.1201472208,
0.0302678328,
0.5338686109,
-0.2141402513,
-0.2801816165,
0.4868688881,
0.2214909643,
-0.2265430391,
0.0104557471,
-0.6441884041,
0.2281591743,
-0.4567973912,
-0.2578667104,
0.5031551123,
0.6918776035,
0.2587988377,
0.6961016059,
0.8168728948,
0.2716379464,
0.0805961266,
-0.1158109829,
0.8050096035,
-0.4079099596,
-0.3416663706,
-1.1199525595,
0.2997821867,
-0.4682308435,
-0.2518424392,
0.8986237645,
0.6583433151,
0.8230074644,
0.0566430911,
0.5620990992,
0.1190312952,
0.3259845078,
-0.6382091045,
0.4033000171,
-0.3336717784,
0.4756641686,
-0.2079134434,
-0.6700620651,
0.0087746112,
-0.0030448707,
-0.3738167882,
-0.1902979016,
0.8350859284,
1.0035518408,
0.0230333228,
-0.3105256855,
0.4601191878,
0.3984569609,
0.5291615129,
0.6765144467,
1.2148034573,
-0.327311933,
0.8753948808,
-0.5510851741,
-0.4419200122,
-0.2549515069,
-1.214215517,
-1.3255670071,
-0.2237084806,
-0.2553183138,
-0.4587746263,
0.3878741562,
0.7332111597,
0.6501305699,
-0.8864069581,
-0.1404442489,
0.0349162929,
0.1837975681,
-0.1905840337,
-0.2093703747,
0.4158735871,
-0.3475982547,
-0.7636409402,
0.5336806178,
0.3582848608,
0.097530961,
-0.3450414836,
0.1275809705,
-0.4143491089,
0.2518639266,
0.3868752718,
0.3647828996,
-0.6554720402,
-0.3584850132,
-0.1713516116,
-0.2293442637,
-0.04700654,
0.7582937479,
-0.642868638,
0.38037467,
0.5039100647,
0.9960029125,
0.0433116071,
-0.2574664354,
0.6367634535,
-0.8413374424,
0.3098091185,
0.0073244041,
0.7224936485,
0.4126196802,
-0.4359814525,
0.4860567153,
0.2593543828,
-0.2960588634,
-1.2159340382,
0.270549655,
-0.9850277305,
-0.4453223646,
1.1838276386,
-0.4379722774,
-0.3930929303,
-0.0847326741,
-0.3254868686,
0.1537496448,
-0.4539220631,
0.745701611,
0.6163648367,
0.3348238766,
0.0705784857,
-0.6952216029,
0.2942459285,
0.5122451186,
-1.2266116142,
0.2276872247,
0.5108519793,
0.1775131375,
0.1421376169,
-0.0217236429,
0.0119108679,
0.5574622154,
0.016148584,
-0.2165231109,
-0.2310911417,
-0.3083564341,
-0.4315645099,
0.3656674922,
-0.059252996,
-0.1982941031
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13495v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13495v1
|
Decoupling Representation and Knowledge for Few-Shot Intent Classification and Slot Filling
| 2023-12-21T00:16:21 | 2023-12-21T00:16:21 |
Jie Han, Yixiong Zou, Haozhao Wang, Jun Wang, Wei Liu, Yao Wu, Tao Zhang, Ruixuan Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Few-shot intent classification and slot filling are important but challenging
tasks due to the scarcity of finely labeled data. Therefore, current works
first train a model on source domains with sufficiently labeled data, and then
transfer the model to target domains where only rarely labeled data is
available. However, experience transferring as a whole usually suffers from
gaps that exist among source domains and target domains. For instance,
transferring domain-specific-knowledge-related experience is difficult. To
tackle this problem, we propose a new method that explicitly decouples the
transferring of general-semantic-representation-related experience and the
domain-specific-knowledge-related experience. Specifically, for
domain-specific-knowledge-related experience, we design two modules to capture
intent-slot relation and slot-slot relation respectively. Extensive experiments
on Snips and FewJoint datasets show that our method achieves state-of-the-art
performance. The method improves the joint accuracy metric from 27.72% to
42.20% in the 1-shot setting, and from 46.54% to 60.79% in the 5-shot setting.
|
[
-0.2520975173,
-0.5091346502,
0.705254972,
-0.1043948159,
-0.2924998403,
-0.327468425,
-0.1201002076,
-0.5336042047,
-0.0025040174,
0.4855339229,
-0.4801691175,
-0.68467623,
-0.6643941402,
-0.2814109027,
-0.0478488356,
0.8428145647,
-0.1034133732,
-0.2876440883,
-0.590705812,
-0.1071650013,
-0.713680625,
-0.3232848346,
-0.479431659,
-0.4132840335,
0.4245045185,
0.3538143337,
-0.0487905815,
0.2229079604,
0.3961697519,
0.1828040183,
0.2218181789,
0.5002452135,
-0.6919716597,
-0.2659989595,
-0.2749059796,
-0.4683864713,
-0.4486884177,
0.0789197087,
0.5084001422,
0.8072364926,
0.1502780765,
-0.011578639,
0.300131768,
0.3838296533,
-0.8837468028,
0.5023308992,
-0.4978425503,
0.1829365343,
-0.2479015142,
-0.4104897976,
-0.7326467633,
-0.1303355098,
0.2677829862,
-0.9817749858,
0.0715290606,
-0.1472757012,
0.785051465,
0.1618063599,
-0.4973651171,
0.2569056153,
-0.9314141273,
0.8583652377,
-0.5219330192,
0.0303736962,
0.5268589854,
0.4580873549,
-0.0664829984,
-0.59357512,
-0.4322504103,
0.3052121401,
-0.446390748,
0.1090277508,
-0.2424824387,
-0.0083355689,
0.1485926807,
-0.2479765117,
-0.4163083434,
0.0480707958,
-0.6749575138,
-0.0206749998,
0.7593040466,
0.2453097701,
0.2405139357,
-0.0877304524,
-0.8261560202,
-0.1583219916,
-0.8307193518,
0.1984651685,
0.0107461987,
0.4072151184,
0.0050234208,
0.528219521,
-0.3059330285,
1.0012234449,
-0.0784348324,
-0.3326784968,
0.08197321,
-0.242022559,
-0.3859923482,
-0.0069042398,
0.439414978,
0.431766659,
0.028069539,
-0.2509864867,
0.2183323503,
-0.0045623537,
0.5658912063,
-0.511177361,
-0.1293007284,
0.0210963171,
-0.3029677272,
0.0272517111,
0.0125671951,
-0.3185269833,
-0.2659166157,
-0.2500739992,
0.7717810273,
-0.5114605427,
-0.339112252,
0.3457731605,
-0.4009797573,
0.4553775191,
0.7340400815,
-0.7251982093,
0.3443508148,
1.0442802906,
0.5794283152,
-0.6610987782,
-0.3870113492,
-0.2959062159,
0.6164690256,
-0.088196829,
1.1236312389,
-0.4863591492,
0.0241723023,
0.1494648606,
-0.0866587758,
-0.3376789987,
-0.3608244359,
0.3215407729,
-0.587654531,
0.1601307541,
0.0430824645,
-1.1774724722,
-0.5338819623,
0.5063867569,
-0.5332700014,
0.6281082034,
0.269117415,
-0.5945497155,
0.6475506425,
-0.5869163275,
-0.1701000035,
0.2712889612,
-0.4260239899,
-0.2584364414,
0.0043126219,
0.0744527206,
0.6374124289,
0.2775696814,
-0.22403799,
-0.4165697694,
-0.4499662519,
0.2477400601,
-0.1380494237,
0.4692109525,
-0.1835410893,
0.109457843,
-0.2248422652,
-0.5338739753,
-0.0033448183,
-0.0848564059,
-0.1971943527,
-0.6349283457,
-0.4709762633,
-0.2519837618,
0.3724097311,
0.1317949444,
-0.5441144109,
0.5795325041,
-0.2259693444,
-0.088943623,
0.5645960569,
0.2386384457,
0.9626362324,
-0.268563211,
0.4625413418,
0.5402053595,
0.0808624104,
-0.1056517437,
-0.6235463619,
-0.3378307521,
-0.1637736708,
0.3180128038,
0.3480296433,
-0.8651108146,
0.4764321148,
-0.4722299874,
-0.2738393545,
-0.2537951171,
0.0937997326,
0.2461993396,
0.4240448475,
0.4667852223,
-0.59984833,
-0.1323636174,
-0.6209924221,
-0.2592071891,
0.0131229702,
0.0073709791,
0.5055700541,
0.1476879418,
0.0439829603,
1.1840655804,
-0.7864370942,
-1.0592874289,
-0.4454306364,
0.1535741836,
0.1774610728,
0.6821008921,
0.7407059073,
-0.3781024814,
-0.3826514781,
0.0051825014,
-0.7468055487,
0.4357075393,
-0.0992394239,
-0.472212851,
0.1529989839,
0.1168752387,
-0.8799294829,
0.8038854599,
0.140200749,
-0.2681830227,
0.2571640909,
0.0820808858,
0.1604671329,
-0.7231389284,
-0.1276439577,
-0.1876909286,
-0.2682402432,
-0.7007297277,
-0.3389612138,
-0.0010947072,
0.0198470913,
-0.9592564702,
0.7524161339,
-0.3988668919,
-0.2008703649,
-0.3940931261,
0.1332369745,
0.2618058026,
0.8418447971,
0.3187149465,
0.2833628356,
0.5904861093,
-0.7387185693,
0.108545132,
0.438187778,
-0.4039915502,
0.5109649301,
-0.0480175503,
0.3530870676,
-0.0967173204,
0.2954336107,
-1.220220089,
-0.3028132319,
0.4071204662,
-0.434751004,
0.4622479975,
-0.8975291252,
-0.0043144533,
0.1221178621,
-0.2017160654,
0.609598875,
0.4370745122,
-0.5528293252,
0.7734128237,
0.3304026425,
-0.1813762039,
-0.8163017631,
-0.8228964806,
-0.465100199,
-0.1733019799,
-0.6964843273,
0.6194193959,
0.6035469174,
0.4921081364,
0.4418467581,
-0.3064559996,
-0.4543905556,
-0.3363386989,
0.1312188506,
0.383404851,
-0.1895527393,
0.2437223345,
0.293007642,
-0.2439230382,
-0.0156405084,
-0.2460291535,
0.2532807589,
0.4474066496,
-0.5035517812,
-0.5034015179,
0.4991801083,
0.1094834656,
0.0646060631,
0.6820770502,
0.6289172769,
-0.4754888117,
-0.3626561761,
-0.4172630012,
-0.2714806795,
-0.4030776918,
-0.0006422332,
-0.5969266295,
-0.9916630983,
0.1663246453,
-0.3605313897,
0.0942801163,
0.1994190067,
-0.0530711077,
-0.2563364208,
0.6574143171,
0.8580080867,
0.0445958227,
0.519610405,
-0.6490741372,
0.1647590548,
-0.8469350338,
-0.2297103256,
-0.0955025181,
-0.5708504915,
0.0195810944,
-0.6449559927,
0.4166145921,
0.0440402664,
0.1746521592,
0.3158536553,
-0.3083486855,
0.5602118969,
0.4126805067,
0.3197142184,
0.38576141,
0.3098059893,
0.0924361274,
-0.248236239,
-0.9215852022,
-0.3331700861,
1.2285114527,
0.0524069406,
0.9278283715,
0.2102679163,
1.12545681,
0.1709243953,
-0.0045115822,
-0.9682170153,
0.4872966111,
-0.3249125183,
-0.3388650417,
-0.3591817319,
-0.3685572147,
-1.0783354044,
0.2785206139,
-0.2695415616,
-0.8796239495,
0.4758632779,
0.1776749939,
-0.7848748565,
0.3039104342,
-0.7486380935,
0.9202978015,
0.1201116815,
-0.5944413543,
-0.2441180497,
-0.5265339017,
0.7409815788,
0.401150316,
-0.2203313708,
-0.2985952497,
0.065189898,
0.7639697194,
0.0186067093,
1.0457656384,
-0.4824336171,
0.0072381427,
0.2984494567,
0.1075993478,
0.5651211739,
-0.0454289019,
0.2677904963,
0.0351493731,
-0.0519311391,
-0.361784637,
-0.9931576848,
0.516835928,
-0.7841037512,
-0.2117827982,
-0.3786409199,
-0.3074216545,
-0.3286301494,
0.1363191158,
0.1851371527,
0.3415936828,
-0.3474021256,
-0.0791501403,
0.8484514952,
0.0126686729,
0.1541840881,
0.4201486409,
-0.1349865645,
-0.0115193222,
0.7709618807,
0.1273929179,
-0.0094308145,
0.4292349219,
-0.2110863924,
-0.5157606602,
-0.3574993014,
-0.3091650307,
0.1874274015,
-0.7642703652,
-0.5865274668,
-0.7640893459,
-0.4210258722,
-0.5017957091,
-0.0222720467,
-0.4886017442,
-0.643700242,
-0.3256967366,
-0.0141374804,
0.4137229919,
0.4783674479,
-0.0856144503,
0.472146064,
-1.0852712393,
0.4785084426,
0.6977103949,
0.2296207547,
-0.2298649549,
-0.4554335177,
-0.2076880336,
-0.316445291,
-0.0915910527,
-0.7482326031,
0.2765237689,
0.2959699929,
0.6360672116,
0.536677599,
0.1774851978,
0.8032336831,
-0.289490819,
0.7013056278,
0.2802581787,
-0.5697230697,
0.6170128584,
0.0876277909,
0.0937421769,
0.6838569641,
0.4954896569,
-0.2848577201,
-0.1181677878,
-0.827111423,
-0.7438633442,
1.296002984,
0.1862239242,
0.0024991503,
0.3546980619,
0.3408630192,
0.3073255718,
-0.1087164208,
-0.3993045688,
-0.1319678128,
0.1781609505,
-0.076647833,
0.2354577482,
-0.1498442143,
-0.3327947557,
-0.2724534869,
0.5463062525,
-0.1635126323,
0.7028442025,
0.0950079039,
-0.49077335,
0.1748788953,
0.4257671237,
0.5350280404,
0.7487931252,
-0.2886502147,
0.3703866601,
0.0501872487,
-0.3668411076,
0.4018122554,
-0.017637305,
-0.1524455547,
0.0529845506,
0.2253497392,
0.8014835715,
0.1124567091,
-0.1662596315,
0.9207044244,
-0.1279818416,
-0.1115226001,
-0.2210011631,
0.4115582705,
-0.2153496593,
0.1320380867,
0.1364027262,
0.3468384743,
0.4069351852,
-0.3141939938,
0.340071559,
0.2204836607,
-0.2699720562,
-0.2464449853,
0.0437617935,
0.3545212448,
0.2671000957,
0.5442008376,
-0.4747332036,
-0.167832762,
0.267921567,
0.5761723518,
0.8631886244,
0.10394869,
0.2645462453,
0.5231184363,
-0.000393033,
-0.1189576909,
0.0135605745,
-0.446067661,
-1.079719305,
-0.589651823,
-0.1872266829,
-0.3554933965,
0.0873116329,
-0.8180162907,
0.2228688151,
-0.2090415657,
-0.2891885936,
-0.1021241173,
-0.000850785,
-1.0208492279,
-0.2036231905,
0.2669627666,
0.7732076645,
-1.0736572742,
0.9374218583,
0.8209542036,
-0.2217508405,
-0.8000715971,
-0.3778375089,
-0.0925461054,
-0.7342709303,
0.5810768008,
0.1313656867,
-0.1111049429,
-0.0346665382,
-0.4813222587,
-0.6787430048,
1.0722330809,
0.1322499067,
-0.4974573851,
-0.020249648,
0.2521445751,
0.1013599336,
-0.610119462,
0.0429691896,
0.8991390467,
0.3617433906,
0.1654169112,
-0.5990917683,
-0.0194513295,
-0.0281940512,
0.0354960524,
-0.0477744266,
-0.4169203937,
0.4303175509,
-0.0092613362,
-0.3923181593,
-0.2626306415,
0.6887901425,
0.563318193,
0.5452031493,
0.4601608515,
0.7292888165,
0.5694673657,
-0.1524518132,
0.6867471933,
0.2042555362,
0.3480098844,
1.3951445818,
-0.4675623477,
0.8426826596,
0.487197578,
-0.194571808,
0.4083652794,
0.1994839162,
0.3464685678,
0.8125729561,
-0.1511461288,
-0.4255777895,
-0.4766561985,
0.1010161564,
-0.359482944,
0.7069309354,
0.6846921444,
-0.0095289685,
-0.4836757779,
0.1961031705,
-0.278891623,
-0.3777180016,
-0.0966241211,
1.318246603,
0.1301035881,
-0.6749491692,
0.3649182022,
-0.2388371676,
0.8066952229,
-0.6216418147,
-0.438048631,
-0.2367392778,
0.1323802173,
-0.3873085976,
-0.9756302238,
0.355042696,
-0.1466996074,
-0.098359935,
-0.2275961339,
1.425937891,
-0.6428921819,
-0.0594418161,
0.0174421445,
0.6719147563,
0.4684786499,
-0.0496897511,
-0.3382383287,
0.0184826609,
-0.2554526329,
0.224484548,
0.3706842065,
0.4623716474,
0.1685422212,
0.2760298848,
0.3071604371,
0.0041159578,
0.4759221971,
0.0778343752,
0.8013930917,
-0.7563281655,
-0.5968560576,
-0.3708288074,
0.5043936968,
-0.1911256164,
-0.3285554945,
0.3802768886,
0.4794827998,
0.8629459143,
-0.4403321445,
0.8889973164,
-0.1781711876,
0.3873502016,
-0.6666064262,
0.6012945771,
-0.33098194,
0.1915610284,
-0.0352337174,
-0.7970197797,
-0.3160861135,
0.6710409522,
-0.3344430029,
-0.1768581569,
0.5405099392,
0.6253010631,
-0.5843977332,
-0.399148941,
0.5165225267,
-0.2063042372,
0.1550205797,
1.0692808628,
1.1927341223,
-0.5793964267,
0.5598219633,
-0.3544362485,
-0.2997712195,
-0.5069793463,
-0.6432974935,
-0.7763507962,
-0.3315224648,
-0.681366086,
0.0462966561,
-0.1538733542,
0.7034313083,
0.9792978168,
-0.4269405305,
-0.0361211263,
0.1764710844,
0.2845246494,
-0.7190570235,
-0.2729403973,
0.4450218081,
-0.6087885499,
-0.4872155786,
0.3839817643,
0.4476034939,
0.1613260955,
-0.0772572681,
0.0342149474,
-0.0523580872,
-0.1298308969,
0.918172121,
0.2933796048,
-0.5037587285,
-0.2400861233,
-0.1900299042,
-0.1371245831,
0.2140385956,
0.9304468632,
-1.0310049057,
0.3004603684,
0.6286681294,
0.8265619278,
1.0195482969,
0.0129141789,
0.3298670053,
-1.3785450459,
0.1697918922,
0.2598281503,
0.1613450348,
0.0830668136,
-0.3645344079,
0.5110355616,
0.0951176733,
-0.1546602994,
-0.5228660107,
0.1889652908,
-1.6030395031,
-0.176384598,
1.027444005,
-0.5637865067,
-0.4134557545,
-0.3024151325,
-0.1190106273,
0.245478034,
-0.3136436045,
0.7531759739,
0.4635937214,
-0.5938874483,
-0.4190600216,
-0.1365152299,
0.7341708541,
0.3077508211,
-0.9882663488,
-0.1984425187,
0.4549430609,
0.3661986887,
0.1592647433,
1.001157999,
-0.1549433768,
0.5619453192,
-0.0352103673,
0.087067388,
-0.0790442899,
-0.61455369,
-0.3195922971,
0.285384208,
-0.0886776894,
-0.6119090915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13437v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13437v1
|
A General Model for Aggregating Annotations Across Simple, Complex, and Multi-Object Annotation Tasks
| 2023-12-20T21:28:35 | 2023-12-20T21:28:35 |
Alexander Braylan, Madalyn Marabella, Omar Alonso, Matthew Lease
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Human annotations are vital to supervised learning, yet annotators often
disagree on the correct label, especially as annotation tasks increase in
complexity. A strategy to improve label quality is to ask multiple annotators
to label the same item and aggregate their labels. Many aggregation models have
been proposed for categorical or numerical annotation tasks, but far less work
has considered more complex annotation tasks involving open-ended,
multivariate, or structured responses. While a variety of bespoke models have
been proposed for specific tasks, our work is the first to introduce
aggregation methods that generalize across many diverse complex tasks,
including sequence labeling, translation, syntactic parsing, ranking, bounding
boxes, and keypoints. This generality is achieved by devising a task-agnostic
method to model distances between labels rather than the labels themselves.
This article extends our prior work with investigation of three new research
questions. First, how do complex annotation properties impact aggregation
accuracy? Second, how should a task owner navigate the many modeling choices to
maximize aggregation accuracy? Finally, what diagnoses can verify that
aggregation models are specified correctly for the given data? To understand
how various factors impact accuracy and to inform model selection, we conduct
simulation studies and experiments on real, complex datasets. Regarding
testing, we introduce unit tests for aggregation models and present a suite of
such tests to ensure that a given model is not mis-specified and exhibits
expected behavior.
Beyond investigating these research questions above, we discuss the
foundational concept of annotation complexity, present a new aggregation model
as a bridge between traditional models and our own, and contribute a new
semi-supervised learning method for complex label aggregation that outperforms
prior work.
|
[
-0.5215947628,
-1.1538672447,
0.4541245699,
0.0949650034,
-0.0540589727,
-0.066641815,
-0.0630841404,
-1.0927752256,
0.0151154911,
0.2979539335,
0.0258599594,
-0.5115022063,
-0.8884225488,
0.0199761689,
-0.4627943039,
1.0583572388,
-0.0189218707,
-0.179116264,
-0.581355989,
-0.5784173608,
-0.3016400635,
-0.7943399549,
-0.4783034921,
-0.3737832606,
0.6107865572,
0.0499513261,
0.6798843145,
0.6541436911,
0.6970059872,
0.3518031836,
-0.278906405,
0.56402421,
0.0237827208,
-0.0606594607,
-0.145373866,
-0.4668401778,
-0.857394278,
0.1999010295,
0.3024983108,
1.1132802963,
0.0889155641,
0.5182632208,
-0.016901331,
0.284847796,
-0.8506624699,
0.297881633,
-0.0239238255,
-0.0675507635,
-0.2345466465,
0.2975873947,
-0.3102477193,
0.0448027328,
0.1273494363,
-0.6420307755,
0.4813522398,
0.3026330769,
0.8534817696,
0.2330814004,
-0.5523793697,
-0.3304182887,
-0.8031472564,
0.763192296,
-0.2011473775,
0.2058321834,
0.4154426157,
0.2368115634,
0.1661914438,
-0.8125883341,
-0.2319851369,
-0.2056390941,
-0.375279665,
-0.0789060667,
-0.0206854157,
0.1164968163,
0.1614551097,
0.3730941415,
-0.2130686641,
0.2051039934,
-0.3127254844,
-0.081398353,
0.7870929241,
0.2056433707,
0.283218056,
0.0936733559,
-0.4988203943,
0.1625620425,
-0.2188397199,
0.2709164619,
0.1506223679,
0.2845235467,
-0.045614887,
0.7083713412,
-0.3761137426,
1.3655734062,
-0.1176580638,
0.0624904521,
0.1498514861,
-0.3210628927,
-0.1423081905,
0.0307135005,
0.6173086166,
0.3962200582,
0.1948824525,
-0.3282434046,
-0.2090292573,
0.3042564988,
0.328914851,
-0.4533177614,
-0.3889884353,
0.3400884569,
-0.1451567411,
-0.3651220798,
0.1796123087,
-0.4282353222,
-0.2108129859,
-0.6724504232,
0.6818016171,
-0.0730023682,
0.0861632749,
0.0869954824,
-0.0392888598,
-0.4510631263,
0.4947834313,
-0.8450630903,
0.4492182732,
0.7356305718,
0.8786820769,
-0.2291947752,
-0.5769468546,
-0.7770712972,
0.2471069694,
-0.1825729609,
0.9422457218,
-0.7077772617,
-0.0409000367,
-0.2140060514,
-0.0014324201,
-0.0480848737,
-0.3980736434,
0.3059962988,
-0.4105592668,
-0.0302254856,
-0.1248383522,
-0.7100465894,
-0.5367594957,
0.436397016,
-0.7416092157,
0.7577491999,
0.3053791821,
-0.57428509,
0.516536355,
-0.9231491685,
-0.426990658,
0.0952917412,
0.0454088226,
-0.5366638899,
0.274168402,
0.186102286,
0.7731045485,
-0.3615095615,
0.3031183779,
-0.4058143497,
-0.2804819643,
0.2199746519,
0.1032284722,
0.5324364901,
0.1083651036,
0.049627807,
0.2127765119,
-0.5157846808,
-0.2392024696,
0.0116919717,
-0.3902965188,
-0.5883826017,
0.0239436291,
-0.0632761493,
-0.1202009097,
0.2034962624,
-0.3082442582,
0.4680898786,
0.2138759941,
0.3487606943,
0.382466644,
0.0478201807,
0.5172539949,
-0.2846626043,
0.1827816665,
0.2870859206,
0.3859981298,
-0.1004360169,
-0.5659838319,
-0.4387183487,
-0.2974204123,
0.5916432142,
0.5111585855,
-0.2016966492,
0.2921209931,
-0.1665684879,
-0.6765528321,
-0.2401827276,
0.139459312,
0.371045351,
0.5856615305,
0.648738265,
-0.5796134472,
-0.1991273612,
-0.7975254059,
-0.2512869537,
-0.1956724972,
-0.0868755132,
-0.018384384,
0.5130739808,
-0.3850333691,
0.9072393179,
-0.8287203312,
-0.3541380763,
0.1059872061,
0.7423555851,
-0.1327967197,
0.4938420653,
0.6580423713,
-1.095285058,
0.0320995115,
0.0453230441,
-0.7013130784,
0.0282557923,
0.0046302313,
0.0029057609,
-0.1283327937,
0.2127041668,
-0.6475070119,
0.4421873093,
0.4460619688,
-0.2224573791,
0.4566294849,
-0.2402693778,
0.2058192641,
-0.6620355248,
-0.0726924464,
0.3125961125,
-0.1473689973,
-0.9040285945,
0.2120257914,
-0.0561624467,
0.2483128309,
-0.3566272855,
0.4463606775,
-0.4229609072,
-0.0560715497,
-0.1617139727,
-0.014243287,
0.0541212484,
0.5160956979,
-0.1081554592,
0.3606642485,
0.6160202622,
-1.0008358955,
0.5042003393,
0.0913615376,
-0.1119465828,
0.7362684608,
-0.6666838527,
-0.0532934554,
-0.4089553952,
0.0962645784,
-1.2426168919,
-0.5539076328,
0.2240187824,
-0.3632484674,
0.2942987978,
-0.0786785036,
-0.47716555,
-0.2323683947,
0.1352016926,
0.5588034391,
0.2055632621,
-0.3575554192,
0.9841907024,
0.5974858403,
0.0878326148,
-0.3390566409,
-0.653314352,
-0.1892272234,
-0.3020339608,
-0.6153844595,
0.1430156231,
0.0205280799,
-0.3608003259,
-0.0008622081,
-0.1631822139,
-0.3549387157,
0.4202603102,
0.4292078614,
0.1303598434,
0.0485756956,
0.4554657042,
-0.0344292969,
-0.0561263487,
-0.1253106892,
-0.1326840669,
0.2774427831,
-0.2221051008,
-0.4306660891,
0.2385242134,
0.4072449803,
0.2979764044,
-0.6583581567,
0.512572825,
0.8263757825,
-0.4348762035,
0.0962052494,
-0.7222085595,
0.0544722266,
-0.3358663023,
0.4149301648,
-0.4105654657,
-0.9903296232,
0.7541815639,
-0.2649179995,
0.4362319112,
0.476705879,
0.3728864491,
-0.0967796668,
1.0610277653,
0.4680049717,
0.0365538932,
0.1203695014,
-0.2600685656,
0.1375824213,
-0.7670196891,
-0.2735085189,
-0.4603506327,
-0.494007647,
-0.2349184602,
-0.590588212,
0.2126522213,
0.4213356972,
-0.1538605094,
0.0042106258,
-0.6689741611,
0.5363015532,
0.5101571679,
0.2514619231,
0.2697625756,
-0.0599839501,
0.5550110936,
0.4720951021,
-0.5601148605,
-0.4607790112,
0.7532724738,
0.2424767762,
0.4445511699,
0.0352673903,
0.6009938717,
0.431537658,
0.6615591049,
-0.6241801381,
0.3100857139,
-0.3410286009,
-0.86006248,
-0.4542778134,
-0.2130570561,
-0.9603088498,
0.4013378322,
-0.0425361805,
-0.8540377617,
0.3079720438,
0.5430168509,
-0.436769098,
0.2563737035,
-0.8780199289,
0.8534488678,
-0.2623796761,
-0.3230436146,
0.3772089779,
-0.871286869,
0.474663496,
-0.1555393338,
0.3589715362,
-0.3139028847,
-0.287222296,
0.7304803729,
-0.1735234112,
0.9007616639,
-0.0175037552,
0.2896212637,
0.7033705711,
0.062022876,
0.4597949386,
-0.1940177679,
0.0887767449,
0.3630103171,
-0.2655788958,
-0.5877502561,
-0.4989169538,
0.2377711087,
-0.6144052148,
-0.3364869654,
-0.2423144132,
-0.7175989747,
0.0058980323,
-0.0295061897,
0.2121424824,
0.2949687541,
0.138166666,
-0.0875189975,
0.4261753559,
0.3461404741,
0.2047671527,
0.183860898,
0.0170402862,
-0.247376591,
0.8639466763,
0.5151759386,
0.2771450579,
0.351215452,
0.132421568,
-0.2031557262,
-0.3846673667,
-0.3020048141,
0.02838194,
-0.635705471,
-0.2176257372,
-0.8743079305,
0.163834855,
-0.2301664799,
-0.2125509083,
-0.194820866,
-0.4051932395,
-0.4055600166,
-0.3707380295,
0.4285891056,
0.7381774187,
-0.0301456302,
0.4369376302,
-0.7646858692,
0.3802166879,
0.6520483494,
0.1979834139,
0.1251182705,
-0.1291351914,
-0.299718976,
0.1166301891,
-0.1448221654,
-0.8613864183,
-0.0210695043,
0.1738667637,
0.4890241325,
0.2262044996,
0.0369718,
0.8044625521,
-0.2472691983,
0.8256735802,
0.197028026,
-0.9168275595,
0.2372442782,
-0.2134925425,
-0.0192267522,
0.4193005562,
0.4558656514,
-0.2497676909,
-0.3297689855,
-0.6040280461,
-1.0498068333,
0.5319510698,
0.1142312214,
-0.2087473422,
0.0708052814,
0.4397304952,
-0.0208214168,
0.1330917031,
-0.5100969076,
-0.2734873593,
-0.0470271073,
-0.1109376103,
-0.4907334745,
-0.3271132708,
-0.2254432142,
-0.1812656075,
0.2436255068,
-0.1140461862,
-0.0662537664,
0.200058341,
-0.321264416,
0.0241154283,
0.1235953942,
0.528046608,
0.6770036221,
-0.1300406903,
0.4135373533,
0.424146831,
-0.3102306128,
0.4269872904,
0.3078645468,
-0.0910814703,
-0.0238656979,
0.5113273263,
0.7602529526,
-0.0254665278,
-0.3019413352,
0.2773537934,
0.2090230435,
-0.2550941408,
-0.1382587403,
0.1534023285,
0.2510020733,
0.1822305173,
0.2031195462,
0.0784144253,
0.3656582236,
-0.3672105074,
0.2134149671,
0.1051435247,
-0.4460769594,
-0.2273558378,
0.8578199744,
0.2155587375,
-0.4554425478,
0.5146248937,
-0.3743485212,
-0.4915337265,
0.7419830561,
0.2149018049,
0.5066006184,
-0.5106176734,
0.0927733332,
0.2288824022,
0.3362132907,
-0.475028336,
-0.0469400063,
-0.1431152374,
-0.4076635242,
-0.6067250371,
-0.5532182455,
-0.4623399079,
-0.4349700809,
-0.6901475787,
-0.0165962819,
-0.0870232284,
-0.3722982109,
0.3671306968,
-0.1475810856,
-0.6907651424,
0.5841569304,
-0.0252021756,
0.4292783737,
-1.3043869734,
0.1897352785,
1.3206768036,
-0.5222821832,
-0.7025825977,
-0.5709329247,
-0.1850522757,
-0.4465641975,
0.6252535582,
0.2994315624,
0.2570696771,
-0.1650981456,
-0.7448527217,
-0.735930264,
0.9934275746,
-0.0006339058,
-0.5059112906,
0.0038519464,
0.2298820168,
0.4799098969,
-0.4485308826,
0.2615656853,
0.6010520458,
0.5439504981,
0.0364675,
-0.6237019897,
-0.101142168,
-0.1591969579,
-0.0618609786,
0.5024313331,
-0.7282837629,
1.1365420818,
-0.2157933265,
0.2326151133,
-0.2434131503,
0.6442053914,
0.3105516732,
0.7542524338,
0.7908425331,
0.650508523,
0.7901939154,
-0.3240254819,
1.1536896229,
0.057404045,
0.4276669919,
1.1190934181,
-0.0549190678,
0.2995223701,
0.1995394081,
-0.1959940046,
-0.0135867661,
0.7722603083,
-0.2841535509,
-0.1879323125,
0.2741368115,
-0.2292279303,
-0.5706987977,
-0.4049403965,
-0.0189237837,
0.3770844042,
0.3478437066,
-0.2676875889,
-0.0775170848,
0.0423259921,
-0.146128878,
-0.1331351995,
-0.3639188111,
0.7060921192,
-0.0675942376,
-0.552718401,
0.1277977228,
-0.0454177149,
0.3649761081,
-0.3578349054,
-0.0387364738,
-0.0141941961,
-0.0287363902,
-0.3826259375,
-0.6317017674,
0.2113969922,
-0.1262079328,
-0.302854985,
0.2867952287,
0.5395040512,
-0.4594745934,
-0.7461177111,
0.1110175028,
0.3428199887,
0.3184692264,
-0.3205043375,
-0.3528304398,
0.0966397226,
-0.1569174379,
-0.338675648,
0.2311379015,
0.4445516169,
-0.4255361259,
0.5009224415,
0.5642908216,
-0.056329567,
0.3060202003,
0.0033222013,
0.5816981792,
-0.4600982964,
-0.3267180026,
-0.8009886742,
0.9190336466,
-0.2043592334,
-0.3245374858,
0.5081511736,
0.5191258788,
0.8467761874,
-0.0975631326,
0.5565819144,
-0.0187553912,
0.3489620388,
-0.2320690304,
0.2530903518,
-0.8935543895,
-0.0772178546,
-0.325463444,
-0.9849175215,
-0.8418032527,
0.4573386908,
-0.2836694717,
0.1110251918,
0.2695561647,
0.3055360615,
-0.2633481026,
-0.1177773476,
0.1728572994,
-0.0662626624,
0.500257194,
0.4635791183,
0.7832533121,
-0.3909569085,
0.4697662294,
-0.5271018744,
-0.1694969833,
-0.3291887045,
-0.6448232532,
-0.8297784328,
-0.5619264245,
-0.6819535494,
0.0848660618,
-0.0415181443,
0.587929666,
0.9252145886,
-0.6851736307,
-0.1302524805,
0.0336180627,
0.0971799344,
-0.5337315202,
-0.1383038014,
0.5345736742,
-0.393492192,
-0.8481622934,
-0.4110669196,
0.2295915335,
0.380045563,
0.1248658001,
0.1384296864,
-0.2841033638,
-0.2527995706,
0.8250340819,
0.1004120484,
-0.7072284818,
-0.2507115006,
-0.3610262573,
0.0500224568,
-0.1043401957,
0.4459474683,
-0.2382117957,
0.5402588248,
0.4823915958,
0.5062526464,
0.344610393,
0.6839700341,
0.1278117895,
-0.7391694188,
0.1701956242,
0.2550558746,
0.2265960723,
0.1462686658,
-0.3787757158,
0.9065002203,
0.061618764,
-0.6770688295,
-0.8002333641,
0.2892861664,
-1.0240204334,
-0.3266849518,
0.7070836425,
-0.2976445556,
-0.3727192283,
-0.1707265675,
-0.1358031482,
0.4161514342,
-0.1112006232,
0.8180367351,
0.7765639424,
-0.4456573129,
-0.0106815575,
-0.3199737668,
0.0293311439,
0.2813382149,
-0.7751299143,
0.0669549629,
0.7019800544,
0.0079635726,
0.7512666583,
0.331989944,
0.1794161648,
0.2079948187,
-0.0955585167,
0.1907858849,
-0.5001020432,
-0.5060329437,
-0.0725998506,
0.667283535,
0.1332162768,
-0.4568316638
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13423v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13423v1
|
VADIS -- a VAriable Detection, Interlinking and Summarization system
| 2023-12-20T21:02:09 | 2023-12-20T21:02:09 |
Yavuz Selim Kartal, Muhammad Ahsan Shahid, Sotaro Takeshita, Tornike Tsereteli, Andrea Zielinski, Benjamin Zapilko, Philipp Mayr
|
cs.DL
|
cs.DL, cs.CL, cs.IR
|
The VADIS system addresses the demand of providing enhanced information
access in the domain of the social sciences. This is achieved by allowing users
to search and use survey variables in context of their underlying research data
and scholarly publications which have been interlinked with each other.
|
[
-0.7792543769,
-0.4631225169,
0.539386034,
0.1297440827,
-0.2686975896,
0.4158758819,
0.2297035754,
0.180336535,
0.8346384168,
0.4855201542,
-0.6494107246,
-0.2909480929,
-0.5268229246,
0.1202931479,
-0.621301353,
1.1417287588,
0.1133500487,
0.0231880937,
-0.8014346957,
-0.0577709861,
-0.1605032086,
-0.4049108326,
-0.3596170843,
-0.033200454,
0.5287066698,
0.8159182072,
0.3314229846,
-0.0836053789,
0.7715013027,
0.3670005798,
-0.1524437964,
0.5686718822,
-0.5417365432,
0.8159325719,
-0.4698484242,
-0.6080287099,
-0.7177249789,
-0.2561641335,
0.5712643266,
0.6376370788,
0.1505374461,
0.436532259,
0.0031411061,
0.8218592405,
-1.392521739,
0.1459884346,
0.5591216683,
-0.2778943777,
-0.6996561885,
-0.8589772582,
0.0485122651,
-0.7898357511,
0.0109730791,
-0.7499572039,
0.5121047497,
-0.5601273179,
0.6496012807,
-0.0927139595,
-0.5906872749,
-0.2931410074,
-1.1763097048,
0.3261633813,
0.0675904453,
0.3422677517,
0.7363333106,
0.4159521759,
-0.0043868404,
-0.5640473962,
-0.3373482525,
0.3140432835,
-0.1070893779,
0.2364221513,
-0.1137551889,
-0.0288795009,
0.2052730918,
0.4615461826,
-0.4250220656,
-0.318685621,
-0.9313644767,
0.2918400764,
0.9896196127,
0.8865506053,
0.2341997921,
-0.1838042885,
-0.0315613486,
0.1028394178,
-0.8019236326,
0.2419306189,
0.4962541759,
0.0171219241,
-0.6661617756,
0.6570363045,
-0.5430408716,
0.626391232,
-0.1481956393,
0.106501095,
0.0965188071,
-0.5426887274,
-0.4013164639,
-0.4283706844,
0.2364805043,
0.2015481293,
0.0355314203,
0.2980763018,
-0.1793076694,
0.1486691535,
0.1554737091,
-0.3961195946,
-0.2974844575,
0.1102592945,
-0.465952158,
-0.5140852332,
0.5868186355,
-0.6655712724,
-0.3656158447,
-0.5289598703,
-0.2397939116,
-0.4405412078,
-0.6518511772,
0.1333057731,
-0.4560115039,
-0.103130959,
0.4358206093,
-0.7703319192,
0.871612668,
0.5096565485,
1.1590251923,
-0.12012472,
0.0080950297,
-0.3984436095,
0.449403584,
-0.4556419551,
1.2097373009,
-0.6781617403,
-1.2108814716,
-0.0969945937,
0.4939005077,
0.3022501767,
-0.2710409164,
0.1777379662,
-0.5339702368,
0.2429012209,
-0.9398943186,
-0.7536476254,
0.0180264954,
-0.1534277797,
-0.6768729091,
0.7400708199,
0.3564656079,
-0.7674259543,
0.4991486371,
-0.7219673991,
-0.0147082079,
0.8055158854,
-0.3455505371,
-0.1419181377,
0.4399366379,
-0.4426324368,
0.677924037,
-0.6563402414,
0.1255508959,
-0.3145878315,
-0.5154610872,
0.2069082409,
-0.2319564074,
0.8739804626,
0.3152402937,
0.2070610225,
0.3307329416,
-0.6036185026,
-0.3247633874,
0.1576900333,
-0.107425727,
-1.2577691078,
0.3528749049,
-0.054194048,
-0.353911072,
0.1584632695,
-0.2538748085,
0.626295805,
0.1044893563,
-0.1479493082,
0.5064310431,
0.2963808477,
0.4789311588,
-0.310808897,
1.0570099354,
-0.0325827859,
0.2654168606,
-0.1746371388,
-0.3755733371,
-0.4537139535,
-0.3933329582,
0.2909923494,
0.4206820726,
-0.8817299604,
0.4677989483,
-0.2420016825,
-0.4213079214,
-0.229463771,
-0.3116215765,
0.1894913465,
-0.0666908175,
-0.0131066972,
-0.535900712,
-0.613273561,
-0.8921865821,
0.4476779103,
-0.3211569488,
-0.1940212995,
-0.1925130486,
0.6230230331,
-0.1354854405,
0.6430665255,
-0.8694428802,
-0.3971001804,
0.3459006846,
0.136390686,
0.0844304636,
-0.0930220634,
0.4987867177,
-1.0493040085,
-0.3546923697,
-0.1935242712,
-0.8646969795,
-0.430955261,
0.4436151683,
0.2198491096,
-0.3888511658,
0.7432878017,
-0.2183680534,
0.9127249122,
0.2972162366,
-0.7218846679,
0.9682044387,
-0.5710198879,
0.5462701321,
-0.7867711186,
0.060773734,
0.0172585305,
-0.227366358,
-0.4762244821,
-0.1661480665,
0.2835325897,
0.1008932739,
-0.2102697641,
0.1689694971,
-0.6976093054,
-0.188198328,
-0.355017513,
-0.0807153806,
0.1945729107,
-0.4262108207,
-0.3004351258,
1.0904749632,
0.7483021617,
-1.0312722921,
0.9011418223,
0.2206262946,
-0.2698203623,
1.4712305069,
-0.344301641,
-0.5565466285,
-0.4679132998,
0.0532506704,
-0.9482947588,
-0.5430715084,
-0.1791333556,
-0.4824810922,
0.0222991258,
0.4884699285,
-0.0079619838,
-0.4487968981,
-0.5601181388,
0.7397679687,
-0.2222092003,
-0.0557370856,
0.0210743193,
1.0509518385,
-0.3713513911,
-0.2288551927,
-0.18362391,
-0.0047273124,
-0.3509525359,
-0.0981458947,
0.1626728773,
0.1124372184,
-0.8137251139,
0.4187023044,
0.3012974262,
-0.0902283639,
0.0650476664,
0.3157652617,
0.2211894244,
-0.3368393481,
0.5177184343,
0.2876002491,
-0.4113537967,
-0.0092635388,
0.2208458483,
0.3963624239,
-0.2427673936,
-0.4703437984,
-0.2956403196,
1.1433144808,
0.942347765,
-0.1883661598,
0.4746896029,
0.0375104286,
-0.5694596767,
0.0618808791,
-0.0745217949,
0.1045031175,
-0.5041735768,
0.1139238402,
-0.8183087707,
-0.6383443475,
0.4141106606,
-0.2188560218,
-0.475333482,
0.4863712192,
0.6480437517,
-0.3523723185,
0.8263838887,
0.7370593548,
0.0815099552,
0.3510307968,
-0.5360723138,
0.2217780054,
-1.1826088428,
-0.5434529185,
-0.7344041467,
-0.015088832,
-0.5316604376,
-0.5439220071,
0.66749084,
0.188185513,
-0.5922324061,
0.1461816877,
-0.828294754,
0.3729552031,
0.5475853682,
0.1394378543,
0.3416561186,
-0.3366248906,
0.4793645442,
-0.3445023298,
-0.3268405795,
-0.4577588439,
1.0410244465,
-0.1114113331,
1.2744694948,
0.6304792166,
0.5686774254,
0.9995652437,
0.0131833572,
-0.6051310301,
0.4203948081,
-0.1176951528,
-0.2197606117,
-0.3132814169,
0.2050088793,
-1.2068021297,
0.0692864656,
-0.4208586216,
-0.9848095775,
1.2092708349,
-0.3461798131,
-0.1945038587,
0.390886277,
-0.4630050659,
-0.0886356309,
-0.1756464988,
-0.2175258845,
-0.3757666647,
-0.2551258802,
0.4941987693,
0.1394888014,
0.243816942,
-0.1966065317,
-0.2625409663,
0.8938512206,
-0.3274464607,
0.6778011322,
0.094139196,
0.0346943438,
-0.0250747353,
0.3351503015,
-0.0160418134,
0.2319582254,
0.2619154453,
-0.1615359932,
0.6689200997,
-0.4737610519,
-0.2874515653,
0.7992391586,
-0.6396089196,
-0.6220819354,
-0.9520981312,
-0.4784486294,
0.1119645461,
0.0786215067,
0.2424449623,
0.2904701829,
-0.7311327457,
0.2673918009,
0.9303128719,
-0.226899907,
-0.144663617,
0.6278299689,
-0.3056361675,
-0.0224313252,
0.7551370263,
0.3569991291,
0.0317295864,
0.4466205239,
-0.1537598819,
-0.1355347335,
0.1184685156,
0.1731350422,
0.3858082294,
-0.4744925797,
-0.509747684,
-0.715716064,
-0.4741956592,
-0.645488441,
-0.4919288456,
-0.1355472952,
-0.2798568308,
-0.4924238026,
-0.284101516,
0.5294368863,
1.291846633,
-0.6836975813,
0.3927047849,
-0.3041087389,
0.8093756437,
0.3575244546,
0.6467688084,
-0.567160368,
0.2275229245,
-0.3311266601,
-0.2389527112,
-0.2021259815,
-1.4670951366,
0.2849701941,
-0.0432284661,
0.343311727,
0.6086935401,
-0.0027682248,
0.4808703065,
0.064468503,
0.6961285472,
0.4844777286,
-0.8999598622,
0.7572028637,
-0.5782116055,
0.3622092605,
0.2746881843,
0.5939683914,
-0.6491297483,
-0.1707841307,
-0.8173007965,
-0.9370465279,
0.4815507233,
-0.0878704116,
-0.3541736901,
-0.0621652082,
0.2737330794,
0.1660538316,
0.0604169071,
0.2788538933,
-0.4034231007,
0.3335304856,
0.1839745194,
-0.2319154888,
-0.6430968642,
-0.4645862877,
-0.6837489009,
0.6650217175,
-0.0243751109,
0.388651818,
0.1940400004,
0.2455320507,
-0.3023648858,
0.0812482014,
0.5495069027,
0.8417467475,
-0.1570911109,
0.2235676646,
-0.1487616897,
-0.6802970171,
0.5954713821,
-0.2840982378,
-0.3027555645,
0.1504445225,
0.0916141421,
0.5112196207,
-0.1685584337,
-0.1795580685,
0.7063879371,
-0.4490323663,
-0.075277701,
-0.5476798415,
0.2093935311,
0.0773811713,
0.4121323228,
0.3389823139,
0.0037145379,
0.4781652093,
-0.3654453754,
0.3784099221,
0.2776216567,
-0.514646709,
-0.3530094326,
0.679505229,
0.2679032385,
-0.9101244211,
0.0704646558,
0.0975239724,
0.0018976809,
0.7474535704,
0.353399694,
0.7273750901,
-0.9750611186,
1.0125795603,
0.1914538741,
0.1710423529,
0.1970466673,
0.8249617815,
-0.3033372164,
-0.3781893551,
-0.0736961737,
-0.2788111866,
-0.7897982001,
0.1838483065,
-1.2954881191,
0.760255754,
-0.0513150468,
-0.2512902319,
0.2917399406,
-0.2465194613,
-0.9547179341,
0.4295428097,
-0.0639697313,
0.7753612995,
-1.200289607,
0.7409701943,
0.7303434014,
-0.2825098634,
0.0501883328,
-0.1794200242,
0.4392887354,
-0.3093250394,
0.5758746266,
-0.6557897925,
-0.4341995418,
-0.4383965135,
-0.3624925613,
-1.3630273342,
0.9090284109,
0.1701775193,
-0.3830569088,
0.1050324813,
-0.1839793026,
0.5274497271,
-0.3743585944,
0.4177776277,
0.7388023734,
0.4404676855,
-0.6671662927,
-0.6001030207,
-0.0293420199,
-0.6257339716,
0.1412536204,
0.5354915261,
-0.5435057282,
0.9544972181,
-0.0037454267,
-0.2060709894,
-0.1971001178,
0.6300696135,
0.265524596,
0.3876204193,
0.3645171523,
-0.0751249716,
1.0438534021,
-0.2372634262,
1.1642965078,
0.0940366685,
0.396900028,
0.806715548,
-0.1084010974,
0.1839329302,
0.4747075438,
-0.4520354867,
0.5715134144,
0.8237475157,
0.4603733122,
0.8175988793,
0.1854903996,
-0.8139600158,
0.2223372459,
-0.2392016202,
-0.6681402326,
0.4005561471,
1.3440432549,
0.1229338571,
-0.2695002556,
0.3542404175,
-0.6044619679,
0.2107196152,
-0.1406307667,
0.7229312062,
-0.0028471684,
-0.2776817083,
0.145962894,
-0.1689448357,
0.2934523225,
-0.8517333865,
-0.0732616633,
-0.0604550615,
0.0154808341,
-0.510774076,
-1.0905628204,
0.6148998737,
-0.2537006736,
-0.3178437352,
0.1748451442,
0.9137870669,
0.0061409879,
-0.367718786,
0.5434187651,
0.7935546041,
0.114166528,
0.5868068337,
-0.1972953528,
0.0022175489,
-0.4131476283,
-0.2494408488,
0.097502403,
0.6968327761,
-0.6102792621,
0.7196137905,
0.3483332098,
0.6715303063,
-0.5088225007,
0.0070583248,
1.0166398287,
-0.8697745204,
-0.9832514524,
-0.3661444187,
0.201861158,
-0.5536116362,
-0.5163716078,
0.7631228566,
0.6284359694,
0.7514317632,
0.0269352868,
1.149736166,
-0.3543934822,
0.724437952,
0.1696017683,
0.4072352648,
-0.5125229359,
0.421992451,
-0.3083896935,
-0.6360058784,
-0.2288278341,
0.4326430261,
-0.4074688554,
-0.4096190631,
0.7093818784,
0.493065536,
-0.5072614551,
0.1250362098,
0.4266826212,
-0.129889518,
0.328890264,
0.0927772895,
0.7741416693,
-0.085446395,
-0.4788442254,
-0.3058604598,
-0.7237354517,
-0.3759399652,
-0.1452107877,
-0.3350595534,
-1.5331792831,
-0.297393173,
-0.4934277534,
0.3983289301,
0.3478287756,
0.5867323279,
-0.8482256532,
-0.6821716428,
0.1947275549,
0.2359828204,
-0.3290234804,
-0.3322895765,
0.5430600047,
0.1521966457,
-0.6537971497,
0.2742925286,
0.8134866357,
-0.3297210634,
-0.7236096263,
0.0486016795,
-0.5198466182,
0.3773247302,
0.6213053465,
0.5901287794,
-0.0988176763,
-0.079137288,
-0.1268669665,
-0.1434622854,
-0.3402198851,
1.2400245667,
-0.6479726434,
0.834374547,
1.0523002148,
0.1645137221,
0.9528183341,
-0.1672065109,
0.776804626,
-0.4320841432,
0.4155667722,
0.2502223253,
0.4464690983,
0.1923627108,
-0.8806721568,
0.6124101877,
0.3260267973,
-0.5978496075,
-0.8545609713,
0.4981808662,
-0.7466617823,
-0.5265203714,
0.8282798529,
0.1251638532,
-0.2941737175,
-0.6995667815,
-0.171029985,
0.2176549733,
-0.0377074145,
0.7679475546,
0.4929083288,
-0.2172722816,
-0.0565057807,
-0.6364483833,
0.4948358536,
-0.0036078859,
-0.842597723,
-0.4121065438,
0.3933331072,
0.1988158673,
0.1632441729,
1.6004539728,
-0.1378839314,
0.5389164686,
-0.1961364001,
0.082542032,
0.4135421515,
-0.3805676401,
-0.1243726984,
0.3628372848,
-0.5988009572,
-0.3337315321
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13401v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13401v2
|
Time is Encoded in the Weights of Finetuned Language Models
| 2023-12-20T20:04:45 | 2023-12-30T22:11:07 |
Kai Nylund, Suchin Gururangan, Noah A. Smith
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present time vectors, a simple tool to customize language models to new
time periods. Time vectors are created by finetuning a language model on data
from a single time (e.g., a year or month), and then subtracting the weights of
the original pretrained model. This vector specifies a direction in weight
space that, as our experiments show, improves performance on text from that
time period. Time vectors specialized to adjacent time periods appear to be
positioned closer together in a manifold. Using this structure, we interpolate
between time vectors to induce new models that perform better on intervening
and future time periods, without any additional training. We demonstrate the
consistency of our findings across different tasks, domains, model sizes, and
time scales. Our results suggest that time is encoded in the weight space of
finetuned models.
|
[
-0.0697680488,
-0.5203389525,
0.3661155105,
0.45568645,
-0.2614280879,
0.1529878974,
-0.0010142095,
-0.2010910511,
0.2214244902,
0.0689047948,
-0.5593306422,
-0.1793296188,
-0.5552583337,
-0.0649409443,
-0.5123318434,
0.9032132626,
-0.1416465193,
0.2472978383,
-0.1020134985,
-0.3258340657,
-0.1318521798,
-0.990583241,
-0.3285333216,
-0.8235768676,
0.4682420492,
-0.03785358,
0.550793767,
0.8135778308,
0.3119367659,
0.267449379,
0.0196001567,
0.0295782965,
-0.4044358134,
-0.2122666985,
-0.1793541759,
-0.5788911581,
-0.6078617573,
0.3662270904,
0.6894822121,
0.9535421729,
-0.2475308329,
0.3681235313,
0.2089386433,
0.3276849985,
-0.3952767849,
0.1779223233,
-0.3343840241,
0.1932933033,
-0.3975669146,
-0.9073187709,
-0.1314153075,
-0.330725193,
-0.14049308,
-0.7589130998,
0.376642704,
0.0284250733,
1.1464102268,
0.4011235833,
-0.2919513881,
0.0628109723,
-1.0533658266,
1.1644227505,
-0.6674205065,
0.6253548861,
0.1000123098,
0.5991754532,
-0.2793279588,
-0.6746718287,
-0.4515070319,
-0.1095464975,
0.1277809739,
-0.2159545124,
-0.1479972899,
-0.2369042486,
0.3233850896,
0.057462588,
-0.3108592629,
0.1848751754,
-0.4200208783,
-0.0286743008,
0.4324106574,
0.29147017,
0.5318306088,
-0.2417910993,
-0.3237707317,
-0.215466693,
-0.5595034361,
0.3020233214,
0.6127817631,
0.258716017,
-0.2529046237,
0.9579975605,
0.0328370444,
0.6445515752,
-0.0427823104,
0.1469626725,
0.0323711075,
-0.068305783,
-0.2438472062,
0.0648163334,
0.503975153,
0.4983201027,
0.5356689095,
-0.4317177832,
-0.1646574736,
0.5145246983,
0.2097252458,
-0.8772909641,
-0.1910628825,
0.0375188142,
-0.6841939688,
-0.3927855492,
-0.1738019437,
-0.210350126,
-0.124157168,
-0.6674218178,
0.2658564746,
-0.5998837948,
-0.0126647819,
0.5065312386,
-0.4481672943,
0.3172729611,
0.1505087316,
-0.7623980641,
0.5573798418,
0.9299131632,
0.7357102036,
-0.096375756,
-0.2312352359,
-0.8836894035,
0.1270970851,
-0.4627647996,
0.6189543605,
-1.0039331913,
-0.3356228769,
-0.2055393904,
0.189714089,
0.3369803727,
-0.0664138049,
0.3600284755,
-0.6243402958,
0.3155012429,
-0.0265904479,
-0.8130170703,
0.126977399,
-0.1118218675,
-0.5589996576,
0.9336420894,
0.3023811877,
-0.5846918225,
0.5863716602,
-0.4337367713,
-0.3170240223,
0.0631688833,
-0.338565737,
-0.1782442182,
0.2477622628,
0.5016739964,
0.7182455659,
-0.1954234093,
-0.0263618156,
-0.4183036089,
-0.3015345335,
0.5163837671,
-0.2988363206,
0.7066066265,
0.5203161836,
0.1339986175,
-0.2422104329,
-0.8912422657,
0.0784692541,
0.2419495434,
-0.6626060009,
-0.71542871,
0.3671899736,
0.2287278026,
0.0359185152,
0.3033109605,
-0.8842369914,
0.5553629398,
-0.482983321,
0.9871588349,
0.6053150892,
-0.0693988726,
0.6841006279,
-0.4127379656,
0.6315563321,
0.1231874079,
-0.1106204689,
0.077128455,
-0.065641351,
-0.697959125,
0.3236707151,
0.2190103233,
0.3368965685,
-0.882322073,
-0.0178501122,
-0.6208103895,
-0.3852869868,
-0.4070456028,
0.0307620205,
0.0424206853,
0.2813897133,
0.3669007123,
-0.3022821248,
-0.5442982316,
-0.6020704508,
-0.4581115842,
0.1685016304,
-0.2712441385,
0.1826447397,
0.2464379817,
-0.0165845286,
0.9752326012,
-0.6537286043,
0.0820737332,
-0.1785548031,
0.3741502166,
0.0126550961,
0.6942167282,
1.0648709536,
-0.6100638509,
-0.020567799,
-0.1348758191,
-0.5293211341,
-0.2050251365,
-0.183799997,
-0.1095863655,
-0.0090141166,
0.9060338736,
0.019640984,
0.221676141,
0.8321314454,
-0.6841424704,
0.136469394,
-0.2573989332,
0.0855397508,
-0.9477289915,
-0.0917811096,
-0.1599015146,
-0.3820768595,
-0.474919945,
-0.4187077284,
0.0512320064,
-0.2785954773,
-0.4224594235,
0.877112329,
-0.3535238802,
-0.0483261161,
-0.1013278663,
0.0839504153,
0.2279570252,
0.5437896848,
-0.2978268564,
0.5850273967,
0.0365511216,
-0.8494673371,
0.0704368129,
0.0072620204,
-0.6765925884,
0.6645780802,
-1.0322322845,
0.193827197,
-0.5137793422,
-0.213422358,
-0.6939043999,
-0.0929524004,
-0.2194333076,
-0.4738443196,
0.4737965763,
-0.3823678493,
-0.1622119844,
-0.2150613517,
0.0165036246,
0.7590964437,
0.4797108471,
-0.3229606152,
0.5998096466,
0.3908418715,
-0.0623950511,
-0.421579808,
-1.0379327536,
-0.3177681863,
-0.0451731309,
-0.3470477462,
0.5155928135,
-0.0818553641,
-0.3363361359,
0.428604424,
0.0111276004,
-0.1077625975,
0.1443120539,
0.1382482201,
-0.0334384032,
-0.3096035123,
0.2639026046,
0.0842218325,
-0.0447192378,
-0.337095052,
-0.6984777451,
0.7120569348,
0.1398280859,
-0.441313535,
-0.2070712745,
0.318331331,
0.5011422038,
-0.454675287,
0.7671223283,
0.7545493245,
-0.5054975152,
-0.2698688507,
-0.2945285141,
0.0650617778,
-0.5044493079,
0.130655095,
-0.269351393,
-0.9389639497,
0.2779350281,
0.127368927,
0.2857792675,
0.5191158056,
0.2569767833,
-0.3091315329,
1.1081610918,
0.9214537144,
0.0955984965,
1.0017527342,
-0.3826417327,
-0.1828633845,
-0.9648581147,
-0.2364800274,
-0.442545414,
-0.772192359,
-0.4407116771,
-0.6134343743,
0.1882613301,
0.3338724077,
-0.4799948931,
0.4158768952,
-0.4774505496,
0.4016784728,
0.428614527,
-0.1868166924,
-0.0242839009,
-0.0469872952,
-0.2707925439,
-0.4770254493,
-0.9763463736,
-0.5370642543,
0.9947084785,
0.305259347,
1.0756729841,
0.0163479242,
0.5014388561,
0.3384798169,
0.1535622627,
-0.5625040531,
0.2297619432,
-0.8046193719,
-0.2252836525,
-0.1261636913,
-0.4580681026,
-1.2885893583,
-0.2610730827,
-0.2721437812,
-0.4806673229,
0.1543932259,
0.0757364482,
-0.5088660717,
0.2329085916,
-0.7796218991,
0.6656350493,
-0.3375236392,
-0.0620447844,
-0.2571566701,
-0.0906792954,
-0.1854918152,
0.4469522834,
0.057897687,
-0.5872908831,
0.0748057589,
0.9619144201,
-0.698564291,
0.7419248819,
-0.2267586142,
0.2456028759,
0.121606715,
0.4383815527,
0.3558631837,
-0.1059871167,
0.0735301152,
0.1155496165,
0.481572628,
-0.5915179253,
-0.7738079429,
0.6658237576,
-0.847632885,
-0.0925548375,
-0.1788296252,
-0.6834853888,
-0.0037429996,
0.0953128636,
0.1436143368,
1.2309453487,
-0.2541329563,
0.1702612638,
0.3925993145,
-0.5509895086,
0.6087204218,
0.4170498848,
-0.2645689249,
0.0965138078,
0.6214719415,
0.3993172348,
0.1607483625,
1.0051828623,
0.3329071105,
0.0080188839,
-0.1687446982,
0.008159467,
0.1537781954,
-0.6229132414,
0.004502526,
-0.6910079122,
-0.2828904092,
-0.4103965461,
-0.3303225636,
-0.557571888,
-1.0346889496,
-0.2761728764,
0.1769089401,
0.5334110856,
0.863910079,
0.0591946617,
0.4369683266,
-0.9193800688,
0.3705702126,
0.3562523425,
0.5062423944,
-0.0730158761,
-0.3517550826,
-0.2097793967,
-0.0693406835,
0.1907738298,
-0.3967827857,
0.3518846333,
0.2990088463,
0.5877698064,
0.0174823012,
-0.2623082697,
0.6286374331,
-1.1094850302,
0.9154389501,
-0.1517033577,
-0.9898936749,
0.3807928264,
-0.3368307054,
0.8033518791,
-0.3380398154,
0.1723784208,
-0.9868357182,
-0.2730068862,
-0.5327610373,
-0.5689276457,
0.5009225607,
0.1370269507,
0.2582824826,
0.1596456319,
0.4883265197,
0.0648175105,
0.2590008974,
-0.2263278514,
-0.1400230229,
-0.3904809058,
-0.2972847521,
-0.3720346093,
-0.4644271135,
-0.158866182,
-0.2177183181,
0.1603978574,
0.0504515991,
0.6034365296,
0.1114496887,
-0.0881138891,
-0.0077896081,
0.3263897896,
0.6183757782,
0.6666090488,
-0.0084437681,
0.1080154628,
0.1637647599,
-0.4609873295,
0.15497756,
0.2540706396,
0.2147311717,
0.1783665419,
0.7550634146,
0.7790936232,
0.5552687049,
0.0384024009,
0.2850409448,
-0.244301632,
0.2813451588,
-0.3589880764,
0.1415870637,
-0.0880450383,
0.5900559425,
0.2435028106,
-0.1357381642,
-0.2640854418,
-0.2987131774,
0.1216965765,
0.1946781427,
-0.2496365309,
-0.5831323862,
1.347663641,
0.1927719563,
-0.270464927,
0.3050489724,
-0.1999500543,
-0.3524074256,
0.4793107212,
0.2240611762,
0.8607369065,
-0.2922986448,
-0.0312104244,
0.3463945687,
0.3147160411,
0.0311468821,
0.6485589743,
0.1173552945,
-0.7472450137,
-0.6103713512,
-1.2585386038,
0.0964344218,
0.0755706504,
-0.4539541304,
0.4350129068,
-0.5812836289,
-0.4133017063,
0.1619967818,
-0.0997299179,
-1.1755867004,
0.1567811668,
0.1293336749,
1.118768096,
-0.6212838888,
0.8677174449,
0.5844627023,
-0.2117908746,
-0.7897081375,
-0.3120662868,
0.0078436444,
-0.7385023832,
0.945820272,
-0.2634330988,
-0.3321766257,
-0.0107052876,
-0.7116441131,
-0.9837703109,
1.0143133402,
0.4580507874,
-0.5347594619,
-0.4219668806,
0.0352959968,
0.5735669732,
-0.4060927033,
-0.5621025562,
0.3428489566,
-0.0930527523,
-0.3183813989,
-0.7480127811,
-0.2958267331,
-0.3685007989,
0.4411084056,
0.3982283175,
-0.3848893344,
1.2121413946,
0.079933539,
-0.5432141423,
-0.0091454219,
0.9175659418,
-0.3984005451,
-0.0911949947,
0.2216550857,
0.3718957007,
0.6359502673,
-0.2698965669,
1.4092717171,
-0.5057780743,
0.1861660779,
1.1452536583,
0.2803525031,
0.5617628694,
0.4338377118,
-0.0566956587,
0.5461137295,
0.327409327,
-0.0838766322,
0.4907101989,
-0.0029495494,
0.1942273974,
-0.450065583,
-0.1520280391,
-0.3659697771,
0.4472384751,
0.3868205249,
-0.1676683873,
-0.3103245199,
0.4072262645,
0.2259703279,
0.2293385714,
-0.4424505234,
0.1848952472,
0.282135129,
-0.5139248371,
0.4507140219,
0.1876675189,
0.524187386,
-0.794205308,
-0.1231437996,
-0.0292682648,
0.499002248,
0.0087780515,
-0.8981488347,
0.2394200563,
-0.0556622334,
-0.0769913718,
-0.5898835659,
0.5367002487,
-0.7542048097,
-0.631139338,
0.0259421151,
0.203671515,
-0.0252423398,
0.3751229644,
-0.4190525711,
0.2069985718,
-0.4629221261,
-0.2199229002,
-0.2463778108,
0.7272079587,
-0.1066561863,
0.7198742032,
0.4302345812,
0.3616178632,
0.3269912601,
0.3575787842,
0.6790401936,
-0.5823029876,
-0.6288411021,
-0.8175205588,
0.3647508323,
0.2139957994,
-0.3684371412,
0.7343792319,
0.3466407657,
0.965384841,
0.0159481596,
0.6582630873,
-0.1194580495,
0.5967051983,
-0.8997557759,
0.8543557525,
-0.8366395831,
0.0639628842,
-0.1055585518,
-0.7143360972,
-0.0563956872,
0.3394418657,
-0.3925125897,
0.018509075,
0.486762464,
0.2915178537,
-0.3047643602,
-0.4112980664,
0.0625208467,
0.1222757921,
0.6244623661,
0.6683470607,
0.7343850732,
-0.333162725,
0.3824544549,
-0.296379447,
0.0298000034,
-0.1941230595,
-1.0169969797,
-1.0724897385,
-0.9505780339,
-0.2156447917,
-0.231621325,
-0.1240751296,
1.0347992182,
0.5387659669,
-0.6167644858,
-0.2655831575,
0.2877805233,
-0.2942409515,
-0.288384676,
-0.1699215919,
0.1564806998,
-0.3664625883,
-0.9871940017,
0.3538295329,
0.0749890804,
0.4617682397,
-0.3097088337,
0.0193885397,
-0.0940890461,
0.17604357,
0.6612782478,
0.2355383188,
-0.2174390405,
-0.5516558886,
0.2441979945,
-0.3074495494,
-0.0621818043,
1.1917517185,
-0.7484493852,
0.6287437081,
0.6723675132,
0.5922684669,
0.6280196905,
-0.1717321575,
1.0577155352,
-1.2637609243,
0.5858843923,
0.2228569239,
0.5344131589,
0.5470271707,
-0.2271186262,
0.529084146,
0.1171663031,
-0.4065740705,
-0.5176876783,
0.3106071949,
-0.7232558727,
-0.383641839,
1.1365009546,
0.1840045452,
-0.4678263962,
0.0998141691,
0.1070481613,
0.677157402,
0.0615697093,
0.659884572,
1.1462738514,
-0.1783255339,
0.3986415565,
-0.7853013277,
0.7891130447,
0.1315998584,
-0.3624873757,
-0.1997726262,
0.1811415851,
0.4695667922,
0.1163469031,
0.4352430105,
-0.2804776728,
0.088243328,
-0.0363020711,
-0.1168531477,
-0.3535306454,
-0.3047599196,
-0.3660268784,
-0.1783912927,
0.0175965577,
-0.2947935462
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13382v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13382v2
|
DSPy Assertions: Computational Constraints for Self-Refining Language Model Pipelines
| 2023-12-20T19:13:26 | 2024-02-02T18:20:03 |
Arnav Singhvi, Manish Shetty, Shangyin Tan, Christopher Potts, Koushik Sen, Matei Zaharia, Omar Khattab
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.PL
|
Chaining language model (LM) calls as composable modules is fueling a new way
of programming, but ensuring LMs adhere to important constraints requires
heuristic "prompt engineering". We introduce LM Assertions, a programming
construct for expressing computational constraints that LMs should satisfy. We
integrate our constructs into the recent DSPy programming model for LMs, and
present new strategies that allow DSPy to compile programs with LM Assertions
into more reliable and accurate systems. We also propose strategies to use
assertions at inference time for automatic self-refinement with LMs. We report
on four diverse case studies for text generation and find that LM Assertions
improve not only compliance with imposed rules but also downstream task
performance, passing constraints up to 164% more often and generating up to 37%
more higher-quality responses. Our reference implementation of LM Assertions is
integrated into DSPy at https://github.com/stanfordnlp/dspy
|
[
-0.0031587461,
-0.7180178761,
0.8957462907,
0.2745218873,
0.4092303813,
0.2312830836,
-0.0586917959,
-0.4438530803,
0.0674758479,
0.6748085618,
-0.730909586,
-0.0900544971,
-0.316932261,
0.5109652877,
-0.4242377877,
0.9844569564,
-0.3469593525,
-0.3841236234,
-0.6475996375,
0.1785673946,
-0.4897011518,
-0.3255503774,
-0.0284808334,
-0.1062620357,
0.4756872356,
0.37504372,
0.4841308594,
0.9290727377,
0.2345249802,
0.4222867787,
0.1287463605,
0.3437066078,
0.2182150036,
0.7823970318,
-0.2035541832,
-0.4022987485,
-0.1585262716,
0.0180868488,
0.5466659665,
0.5696282983,
0.0848839507,
0.3196527958,
0.1211875901,
0.6687676907,
-0.9230580926,
0.1216558814,
-0.4631177783,
-0.0777301788,
-0.1460610777,
-0.1680050194,
-0.4707883596,
-0.3582019508,
0.0579768084,
-0.3073753119,
0.1413718164,
-0.1499091387,
0.8835835457,
0.6740442514,
-0.3692061007,
-0.6373888254,
-0.6135978103,
0.7699253559,
-0.8041203022,
0.2426357418,
0.258009851,
0.2125542611,
-0.246437937,
-0.9567719698,
-0.4793250561,
-0.437417537,
-0.1384971589,
-0.2005582005,
0.0900539756,
0.2434707284,
0.564876318,
0.4379251003,
-0.3782606721,
0.0227370653,
-0.4743831158,
-0.3485934734,
0.6394559145,
0.2605207264,
0.2332588136,
-0.2989575267,
-0.2264278829,
0.3781592548,
-0.7112324238,
-0.1711924076,
0.4210679829,
0.3496845663,
0.0517506413,
0.732681334,
-0.5235958695,
0.8166902661,
0.1615832299,
-0.0344938189,
-0.0116052674,
-0.4856835008,
-0.0278641824,
-0.0725499764,
0.7658664584,
0.1741141379,
-0.0487729236,
0.0734929442,
-0.5186535716,
0.2878150046,
0.1649657786,
-0.7481222153,
-0.0489256568,
0.6460394859,
-0.2804353535,
-0.438400656,
-0.1168755963,
-0.4278166294,
-0.3838884234,
-0.2723736763,
0.3154190779,
-0.184585467,
-0.1517423242,
0.1056877822,
-0.2153971642,
-0.1030567959,
0.0696341023,
-1.0642834902,
0.2412485778,
0.73057127,
0.7701582313,
-0.0905409902,
-0.3928756118,
-0.6635460854,
0.1792326868,
-0.3905414343,
0.6321731806,
-0.2263740152,
-0.0450985692,
-0.0157915521,
-0.0689004138,
0.0281960182,
-0.4738217294,
0.7078302503,
-0.1549996883,
0.1600838751,
-0.1495288461,
-0.8944682479,
0.3744763434,
0.1728190184,
-0.446696043,
1.1749379635,
0.1823269129,
-0.55856359,
-0.1355228126,
-0.4239977896,
-0.3521628082,
0.0781897977,
-0.5464634299,
-0.3112777472,
0.406724453,
-0.0518869571,
0.3767896593,
-0.2532491386,
0.3115039468,
-0.4640323222,
-0.0923354179,
0.6457715034,
-0.1997331679,
0.8072192669,
0.5882501602,
-0.403732717,
0.1011269391,
-0.7303835154,
0.4649403095,
-0.0852758065,
-0.2460973859,
-0.0306921806,
0.2805231214,
-0.4617678523,
0.037703231,
0.3603504896,
-0.454918474,
0.5495505333,
-0.2862995565,
0.7283354998,
0.7067711353,
-0.2463377416,
0.2599221766,
-0.3597187698,
0.5815244317,
-0.4617382288,
-0.1890419871,
-0.5805681348,
-0.1830642372,
-0.8957999945,
-0.0205324125,
0.1941769272,
0.3417135179,
-0.6905141473,
0.569704771,
0.1866464168,
-0.2606212199,
-0.369918257,
-0.0299456008,
0.2706117034,
0.4990834892,
0.140340209,
0.1784306914,
-0.8293376565,
-0.8408325315,
-0.2976259291,
-0.2676366866,
0.1326873302,
-0.0790381432,
0.353803426,
-0.1658809483,
1.0922812223,
-0.5602136254,
0.1101920903,
-0.4007471502,
0.2853327096,
0.3295357823,
0.4680952728,
0.4309249222,
-0.2308336049,
-0.5893194675,
-0.4824406803,
-0.7008049488,
-0.7203005552,
-0.1976276785,
0.3570612967,
0.5153096914,
0.7300103903,
-0.6489992738,
0.1268911809,
0.6583501101,
-0.4439237714,
1.106421113,
-0.2676120698,
-0.0326526128,
-0.7006793618,
-0.2533984184,
-0.1195098907,
-0.3837942183,
-0.5238803029,
0.437369436,
0.0517612211,
-0.2097726762,
-0.1351431608,
0.4276279807,
-0.6273184419,
0.1098088026,
-0.5050333142,
-0.092635259,
0.0670846105,
-0.0304081347,
0.0066687278,
0.6721797585,
0.7541360855,
-0.8045611382,
0.3765184879,
-0.0967903659,
-0.4683732688,
0.5107057095,
-0.774956286,
0.2591729462,
0.1140201837,
0.3079335988,
-0.9277131557,
-0.079334192,
0.0782821402,
-0.2399625629,
0.2030646801,
-0.2229974866,
-0.3006605804,
-0.5366803408,
-0.1759241521,
0.291374892,
0.4495731592,
-0.5681359172,
0.3846612275,
0.129216373,
-0.0641325638,
-0.7734693289,
-0.6827854514,
0.2011175454,
-0.2512125075,
-0.4326067269,
0.4838494956,
-0.3794656992,
-0.2283544689,
-0.1420429945,
-0.17221196,
-0.0558544584,
0.2699746192,
0.1440818161,
0.3070210516,
-0.1564035863,
-0.1061067358,
0.1098155081,
-0.3146279156,
0.2909782827,
-0.5651940703,
0.4503771663,
-0.0256778449,
-0.3645583093,
-0.7648852468,
0.3250140846,
0.4259420931,
0.0153890997,
0.0778099671,
0.2930516899,
-0.1887618601,
-0.4250303805,
-0.5000532866,
-0.1954222172,
-0.5930408835,
0.2826403677,
-0.6432458162,
-0.7835728526,
0.0904127136,
-0.2037739456,
0.0433938019,
0.3648620844,
0.4571014643,
-0.2145020813,
1.1052156687,
0.5475150347,
0.1572811157,
0.3954579532,
0.1316925585,
0.0539600477,
-0.4877994955,
0.3135780394,
-0.9097252488,
-0.052574642,
-0.8060411811,
-0.3999325931,
0.0314184986,
0.1546557546,
-0.1477642804,
0.347097218,
-0.5953181982,
0.795900166,
0.4134403467,
-0.3171698153,
0.231234774,
-0.2120212317,
-0.2637769282,
-0.2753383517,
-0.5782729387,
-0.6425967813,
0.7505108714,
0.4306187332,
0.9317009449,
0.022069538,
0.9904735088,
0.4271926582,
0.1725326478,
-0.7001165152,
0.6140911579,
0.0215380713,
-0.6691784859,
-0.0467753373,
-0.618591845,
-0.6230375767,
-0.3021789789,
0.0026658946,
-0.9560234547,
-0.2304307371,
0.4004039168,
-0.5398235917,
-0.092550315,
-0.4787998199,
0.7244590521,
-0.4624117017,
-0.5239703059,
-0.1795398593,
-0.4738019705,
0.2178737819,
0.308781296,
0.0066645588,
-0.2931443751,
-0.0191605315,
0.3802768588,
-0.7961515784,
1.0177402496,
-0.112051025,
-0.6881140471,
0.6771137714,
0.2420329601,
0.6570860147,
-0.0695593357,
-0.1821628958,
-0.1594595313,
0.6728962064,
-0.2102437764,
-0.7479119301,
0.6954289675,
-0.4133016169,
-0.9184939265,
-0.5618476272,
-0.5660943389,
-0.0133129507,
0.2615667582,
0.1148726866,
0.5546319485,
-0.0544876456,
-0.1616960913,
0.448015511,
-0.2887412906,
0.5771576166,
0.279252857,
-0.5222412348,
-0.3625850976,
1.1120331287,
0.086245954,
0.6308447123,
0.1927052587,
0.4366010427,
-0.3738500178,
-0.5579040647,
-0.5588450432,
-0.0019757918,
-0.669388175,
-0.3163645566,
-0.3413853049,
-0.3504588008,
-0.5760214925,
-0.0999808162,
-0.6111040711,
-1.0317008495,
0.0761972517,
0.1145782098,
0.0662314743,
1.072275281,
-0.1419804543,
0.103472054,
-0.8179524541,
0.2503540814,
0.1894255877,
0.2892615795,
-0.4244669378,
-0.3410860002,
-0.2906367779,
-0.0123174638,
-0.6866336465,
-0.9817788601,
0.2163126469,
0.0643628538,
0.4736807942,
0.3184247911,
0.4068282247,
0.4290551543,
-0.3741154075,
0.7503550649,
0.1008414179,
-1.2434016466,
0.6051741242,
-0.4263918102,
0.1014874727,
0.3714083135,
0.2547574937,
-0.6272799373,
-0.6306064725,
-0.503162086,
-0.4218246937,
0.3768855631,
-0.0196430944,
0.2611627877,
-0.2021119148,
0.7212955952,
0.1490846127,
0.0575234331,
-0.8596268892,
-0.3910654187,
0.1348861307,
-0.5261514187,
0.2694709301,
-0.5159372091,
-0.0700888708,
-0.116929777,
0.5264424682,
-0.4583880901,
0.0200737882,
0.3652088046,
-0.090473555,
0.066270709,
0.2901022434,
0.6715943217,
0.6891818047,
-0.0383672528,
0.5546123385,
-0.015410291,
-0.0266490225,
0.400382787,
0.0811096728,
-0.608610034,
-0.0100871716,
0.1978772581,
0.3980769515,
-0.2371003181,
-0.5907657743,
0.1784945279,
0.0037564321,
-0.0742032304,
-0.0589982569,
0.2524413764,
-0.1004287377,
0.2580405176,
0.1728938818,
-0.2503508031,
0.073795855,
-0.4891146123,
0.270223856,
0.3888127506,
-0.4319009185,
-0.2504431903,
0.6778767109,
0.3320018053,
-0.3205156624,
0.3441597819,
-0.1781321466,
-0.5851538777,
0.5049931407,
0.9286954999,
0.9059804082,
-0.2915422022,
0.2706379592,
0.4983462393,
0.1756964922,
-0.3029164076,
0.3178462386,
-0.2796854079,
-0.7002757788,
-0.6327187419,
-0.4458289444,
-0.6037242413,
0.0010589155,
-0.3353068233,
0.5599913001,
-0.4439059198,
-0.1336959451,
-0.2285069227,
0.1647028178,
0.0595657527,
0.0225085244,
0.2049060762,
0.7520657778,
-0.6154379845,
0.6599866152,
0.4810563624,
-0.4313186705,
-0.4786511064,
-0.097205542,
0.1553465128,
-0.4714149833,
0.7555841208,
0.4834101498,
-0.1818428934,
-0.0081261192,
-0.6930024624,
-0.8495364189,
0.7676967978,
0.4975810051,
-0.6215765476,
0.0159573834,
0.462878108,
0.233857125,
-0.3127275407,
0.4218635559,
0.3731600046,
0.3798108101,
-0.1473549306,
-0.8717978597,
0.4470524192,
0.0675394461,
-0.3269227445,
0.2411111593,
-0.6186121106,
0.7792162895,
-0.530631125,
-0.4575578272,
0.6745249033,
1.019361496,
0.501627624,
0.2962233722,
0.5339208841,
0.4819003642,
1.0360096693,
-0.1066369489,
0.9976555109,
-0.4589774609,
0.3515651226,
1.3680950403,
-0.293564707,
0.494486928,
0.5514495969,
-0.1964513361,
0.5413738489,
0.6957216859,
0.0837619603,
0.2216293663,
0.5377545953,
-0.2959462106,
-0.1423636824,
-0.2539095581,
-0.3774480224,
0.3779369295,
0.3853158057,
-0.261700958,
-0.0553509556,
-0.5304331779,
-0.0348065905,
0.2374896705,
0.0850415826,
0.3530235291,
0.0464277193,
-1.0400012732,
0.7133410573,
0.0432833508,
0.6677681208,
-0.4480445981,
0.0227186941,
-0.1918888092,
0.3222900629,
-0.321734339,
-0.6557555199,
0.6081383228,
0.0217709281,
-0.1292069554,
-0.6225959063,
0.8208075166,
-0.4767073095,
-0.3556974828,
-0.0376713462,
0.510119617,
0.0827851519,
0.1285056174,
-0.7120021582,
0.2069507986,
0.0746322945,
-0.0917754769,
0.0799525157,
0.5334283113,
0.1261652112,
0.8818582296,
0.3804738522,
0.2543168962,
-0.077398777,
-0.0512940772,
0.6231269836,
-0.7417653203,
-0.3728656769,
-1.0395427942,
0.3588532209,
0.0424436778,
-0.0267524179,
0.7633528113,
0.4855986536,
0.5853308439,
0.1236522123,
1.1108831167,
-0.3216900527,
0.345739603,
-0.7253141999,
0.5293323398,
-0.3039546907,
0.4231800437,
-0.2316229045,
-0.6205420494,
-0.1288441122,
0.5549362302,
0.011106858,
-0.0831151083,
0.7677947283,
0.7181417346,
0.2046300322,
-0.1625499576,
0.0391176865,
0.1755063981,
0.4208778441,
0.4179111719,
1.4835340977,
-0.377766937,
0.336052984,
-0.3999642134,
-0.1568375677,
0.176510945,
-1.3200063705,
-0.7710226178,
-0.6248401999,
-0.7962217331,
-0.8319922686,
-0.1969091296,
1.0178120136,
0.6477462649,
-0.6270042658,
-0.6473123431,
-0.2605330646,
0.5392760634,
-0.2975097895,
-0.2583410144,
0.0326959714,
-0.960998714,
-0.852355957,
0.6111915112,
0.2341106981,
0.17534931,
-0.4580435455,
-0.2298996598,
-0.1107101068,
0.1367689073,
0.384234488,
0.6057959795,
-0.5443080068,
-0.3897718489,
0.0626353323,
-0.1823586971,
-0.0833178833,
1.1461752653,
-0.7677556872,
0.2383712828,
0.6631814837,
0.7403097153,
0.2227360159,
-0.1944304407,
0.9903119206,
-0.7549091578,
-0.0830465332,
-0.0727033019,
0.4528342485,
0.2270411998,
-0.292041868,
0.4223076701,
0.3464668393,
-0.765375793,
-1.0906095505,
0.6275663376,
-0.6497814059,
-0.3617148101,
1.0178440809,
-0.1703955531,
-0.1496299803,
-0.0630470961,
-0.1662392318,
0.0938203633,
-0.0875640288,
0.9664943218,
0.6788644791,
-0.4076931477,
-0.26157704,
-0.3958978355,
0.7023531199,
0.5755659342,
-0.9113325477,
0.6083966494,
0.5559312701,
0.3825917542,
0.3542313278,
0.6469234228,
0.1771169603,
-0.0734312758,
-0.1027903706,
0.0023413156,
-0.0340416729,
-0.3316859603,
-0.1770604849,
-0.0553631783,
0.1785519272,
-0.0122820418
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13264v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13264v1
|
dIR -- Discrete Information Retrieval: Conversational Search over Unstructured (and Structured) Data with Large Language Models
| 2023-12-20T18:41:44 | 2023-12-20T18:41:44 |
Pablo M. Rodriguez Bertorello, Jean Rodmond Junior Laguerre
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Data is stored in both structured and unstructured form. Querying both, to
power natural language conversations, is a challenge. This paper introduces
dIR, Discrete Information Retrieval, providing a unified interface to query
both free text and structured knowledge. Specifically, a Large Language Model
(LLM) transforms text into expressive representation. After the text is
extracted into columnar form, it can then be queried via a text-to-SQL Semantic
Parser, with an LLM converting natural language into SQL. Where desired, such
conversation may be effected by a multi-step reasoning conversational agent. We
validate our approach via a proprietary question/answer data set, concluding
that dIR makes a whole new class of queries on free text possible when compared
to traditionally fine-tuned dense-embedding-model-based Information Retrieval
(IR) and SQL-based Knowledge Bases (KB). For sufficiently complex queries, dIR
can succeed where no other method stands a chance.
|
[
-0.3449467421,
-1.214843154,
0.9914278388,
-0.0275496077,
-0.2833817601,
0.331900388,
-0.0713703781,
-0.3289525211,
0.2392294109,
0.7543053031,
-0.4307473302,
-0.4991337359,
-0.3356364667,
0.0074535017,
-0.7271068692,
0.8207021952,
0.3516366184,
0.0515595712,
-0.2816303074,
-0.1638702601,
-0.3924024701,
-0.7251759768,
-0.4953332543,
-0.383890152,
0.6140761971,
0.2137045413,
0.9596995115,
0.4938704967,
0.548891902,
0.3509666622,
-0.1173717827,
0.0696835071,
-0.4572911561,
0.4537245333,
-0.3754119575,
-0.4053148329,
-0.0932843313,
-0.1604751796,
0.7660869956,
1.0076055527,
-0.4679450095,
-0.5094030499,
-0.1780173182,
0.9114467502,
-0.5942849517,
0.1384249777,
-0.7915364504,
-0.114544414,
-0.2619139254,
-0.2989774048,
-0.6044187546,
-0.4932827652,
0.1507475227,
-0.4179105461,
0.1196561977,
0.2091980726,
0.4835995734,
0.233752057,
-0.8656333089,
-0.4444638491,
-0.8950209618,
0.7478262782,
-0.1487114877,
0.6915362477,
0.2437356859,
0.491881609,
-0.345454067,
-0.9287201762,
-0.7981820703,
-0.0961708128,
-0.2625164986,
-0.2559961379,
-0.3704718947,
0.3482409418,
0.0177309457,
0.5164065957,
-0.5336931944,
-0.2300321162,
-0.1793806255,
0.1622751355,
0.6373679042,
-0.049683053,
0.4899675548,
-0.3586578369,
-0.4031001329,
-0.1848138273,
-0.6569203734,
-0.1449881643,
0.17687051,
0.522118032,
0.2624433935,
0.6482776999,
-0.4135452211,
0.8410510421,
-0.1677554697,
0.150846675,
-0.4123654962,
-0.0947644189,
-0.1670322567,
0.1752390265,
0.7974200845,
0.1353967786,
0.2649970353,
-0.404753238,
-0.3509050012,
-0.1914617717,
0.1355568469,
-0.8108264804,
-0.3605396152,
0.1786599755,
-0.2505140305,
-0.0822457746,
0.1675492972,
-0.818800509,
-0.5071710348,
-0.3295628428,
0.3898907602,
-0.4156693816,
-0.1250392944,
0.1435881406,
-0.2024499625,
0.2357406914,
0.5027749538,
-0.8835337758,
0.5924854875,
0.6360056996,
0.714220345,
-0.0598854683,
0.3518274426,
-0.5403010845,
0.2444617152,
-0.5494941473,
1.0556586981,
-0.7813628912,
-0.6756954193,
-0.0905535892,
-0.2793233693,
-0.1115298271,
-0.5340386033,
0.5939608812,
-0.9747750759,
0.5900514722,
-0.2611456811,
-0.4821643233,
-0.2317702472,
0.1731255651,
-0.8307382464,
1.0223834515,
0.1463657767,
-0.7962666154,
0.00287062,
-0.6672706604,
-0.1638639718,
0.2114657313,
-0.5292001367,
0.3406914771,
-0.1552679241,
0.1764611453,
0.2499190718,
-0.7260080576,
0.5673925877,
-0.0708525553,
-0.2681810558,
0.2407247573,
-0.2327604443,
0.4488055706,
0.123668313,
0.169395864,
0.1964587867,
-0.6544829011,
0.297878325,
-0.0216637086,
-0.4961205423,
-0.656093061,
0.4754183888,
-0.1179192513,
0.1586590707,
0.2232379615,
-0.7389113307,
0.2522927225,
-0.6161714792,
0.3162228167,
0.584328115,
0.0390040427,
0.7423656583,
-0.2586300373,
0.0712339953,
-0.0784215406,
-0.2709361911,
0.0419149697,
-0.395357132,
-0.6499926448,
-0.1293141544,
0.2496465743,
0.5154583454,
-0.9541140199,
0.4065802991,
-0.4610090852,
-0.322927773,
-0.5044265389,
-0.2284893543,
0.1230308041,
0.5587982535,
0.4372453094,
-0.2436947376,
-0.4564774632,
-0.8689345121,
-0.2910621464,
-0.2414061576,
-0.3744758964,
0.6556366086,
0.3258561492,
-0.2402314991,
1.1797726154,
-0.7829338312,
-0.3885415196,
-0.3978101015,
0.295794636,
0.3533867896,
0.2852036655,
0.1490149349,
-1.0121916533,
-0.4778723121,
0.0600403808,
-0.5822609067,
0.1676425636,
0.2480273396,
-0.2337112576,
0.2177534848,
0.4001099467,
-0.9799821377,
0.2143469155,
0.1464837641,
-0.3075428009,
0.1127676889,
-0.2139113545,
0.3262029886,
-0.8747609258,
0.3221146762,
-0.3391572833,
-0.1975655258,
-0.625772655,
0.0275924318,
0.0050847381,
-0.2586704791,
0.0268139299,
0.6550365686,
-0.1557443291,
-0.0365716927,
-0.0537316762,
0.4098919928,
0.0243500769,
0.4931160212,
0.0742395371,
1.0098341703,
0.3139552176,
-0.7738208175,
0.4068889618,
0.4846051037,
-0.401371181,
0.7317411304,
-0.8329458237,
0.527587235,
-0.5899138451,
0.2968037128,
-0.9884467721,
-0.3737977743,
-0.1840309352,
-0.3822279572,
0.0545382053,
-0.2108585238,
-0.7173983455,
-0.0208587442,
-0.2809566855,
0.3125973642,
0.2502323091,
-0.5069198012,
0.6421688199,
0.5154427886,
-0.3480780423,
-0.5125988722,
-0.1854958683,
0.159219265,
0.1415143907,
-0.6273735166,
0.5790559649,
-0.208468914,
-0.5467653275,
0.0132983811,
-0.2731264532,
-0.6667194366,
-0.1596926302,
-0.130221948,
0.2197442204,
-0.0586479679,
0.1966844052,
0.0180798862,
-0.0367171578,
-0.0700103343,
-0.0502682924,
0.8017516732,
0.1432176232,
-0.2177233547,
-0.0552090928,
0.6909293532,
0.5130844712,
-0.2037021816,
0.5326421857,
-0.0617604293,
-0.2826908529,
-0.3100074232,
-0.3653634489,
-0.2215839624,
-0.4891814888,
0.2405178994,
-0.436017096,
-1.10041821,
0.1525670141,
-0.0956001133,
-0.1148572862,
0.4511420131,
0.1920954287,
-0.2395008206,
1.2672964334,
0.7328162789,
0.0967405513,
0.2269943357,
0.012721194,
0.3866095543,
-0.4595396519,
-0.697670579,
-0.8992052078,
-0.1239769757,
-0.393239975,
-0.4357762933,
0.4920732379,
0.2097039819,
-0.3699279726,
0.1418641508,
-0.5833134055,
0.5010026097,
0.5221500397,
-0.0590654798,
0.5991014838,
-0.0000557878,
-0.2222026289,
-0.1414224803,
-0.3186965287,
-0.3027043641,
0.6995366812,
-0.0407643542,
1.0967490673,
0.5203914046,
0.2617016435,
0.3693460822,
-0.2172350734,
-1.0246235132,
0.7615936399,
-0.1858767569,
-0.6179846525,
-0.1464835852,
-0.623647213,
-1.0646915436,
0.3592954576,
-0.0450615659,
-0.8700413704,
0.1991799325,
-0.399017185,
0.016487442,
0.3775844276,
-0.475189954,
0.4854949713,
-0.1407777816,
0.0394469239,
-0.4975782037,
-0.7219937444,
0.2771532536,
-0.0952187106,
0.0939208716,
-0.2701760828,
0.1624363661,
0.7071409822,
-0.1984332353,
0.3684965968,
-0.0123981861,
-0.0518554635,
0.0825486034,
0.421427846,
0.3932385743,
-0.0435044169,
-0.2190472186,
-0.1750808507,
0.365904063,
-0.0274814498,
-1.0446872711,
0.6331838965,
-0.6265519261,
-0.6301495433,
-0.5993144512,
-0.7211562395,
-0.2024944872,
0.463344425,
-0.247204408,
0.5153170228,
-0.3456552625,
0.6616585851,
1.0002622604,
-0.1566132903,
0.2364331931,
0.7658799291,
-0.3681873679,
-0.2203205228,
0.5405505896,
0.024841886,
0.0726292282,
1.2137596607,
0.0522911958,
-0.7608684897,
-0.1311977506,
-0.315549016,
0.1473949999,
-0.6370404959,
-0.4217628241,
-0.9623200893,
-0.3456630409,
-0.3232811093,
0.0622744784,
-0.2410593778,
-0.6185625792,
-0.1303337663,
0.0116038369,
0.5296065211,
1.0250805616,
0.1750806868,
0.2756693959,
-0.7181206346,
0.5383494496,
0.3939405382,
0.649630785,
-0.2603239417,
-0.0370753147,
0.2068178654,
0.0701381266,
-0.3164859712,
-1.0425820351,
0.4527978003,
0.4281536043,
0.4369838834,
0.3041056693,
0.3841724098,
0.4508268833,
-0.5260518789,
0.439293921,
0.0181394331,
-0.7455032468,
0.7150158882,
-0.5199113488,
-0.0878366753,
0.5073683262,
0.6787866354,
-0.8780303001,
0.1275506765,
-0.4469967186,
-0.8454940319,
0.869545579,
0.2031093985,
0.1073949486,
-0.1429851502,
0.206991151,
-0.2815109193,
0.3512111306,
-0.3903195858,
-0.2342323661,
0.1372699291,
-0.1705051064,
0.2506411672,
-0.4816867113,
-0.2192613035,
-0.3442362249,
0.3296878338,
-0.1261695623,
0.6302564144,
0.3986313045,
0.0556680746,
-0.0429899096,
0.6540458798,
-0.2038544863,
0.4823548198,
-0.5606167912,
0.3011431396,
-0.1745127141,
-0.2505199313,
0.0248756576,
0.4176850617,
-0.1601613462,
0.1567303091,
-0.166321069,
0.4508190751,
0.4401390553,
-0.8616304398,
0.3522824049,
-0.2760113478,
-0.0150835663,
-0.1452222019,
0.1529159844,
-0.0995963812,
0.0352005027,
0.6311609149,
-0.2777134776,
0.3180953562,
-0.7913896441,
0.5285811424,
0.6365522742,
-0.5896752477,
-0.0522950739,
0.7303919792,
0.1042492017,
-0.2996553183,
0.9680343866,
-0.0269003008,
-0.1779523045,
0.1722736806,
0.498730123,
0.5628241301,
-0.1624754816,
0.4060933888,
0.2000255287,
0.0066214935,
-0.0155230844,
0.45535025,
-0.283685565,
-0.7339838147,
-0.2515211105,
-0.7590756416,
-0.6334916949,
-0.0793911219,
-0.3304609954,
0.0482514389,
-0.5010185838,
0.2211445123,
0.1099055558,
0.313293606,
-0.214909032,
0.0616814494,
-0.4218378365,
1.0358598232,
-0.1444366574,
0.9980770946,
0.6387130618,
-0.4845779538,
-0.7686903477,
-0.382961601,
-0.1463522315,
-0.5920882821,
0.6253383756,
0.0571886338,
-0.1913080066,
0.438560009,
-0.6239360571,
-0.9702345729,
1.0214847326,
0.3828776479,
-0.1770053208,
-0.394849211,
0.2554582655,
0.3887479007,
-0.0451912992,
0.2758099139,
0.5691410899,
0.1835345775,
0.5019723773,
-0.8766131997,
-0.0317110084,
-0.1759461164,
-0.0131230615,
0.6303895712,
-0.1810680777,
1.0424091816,
0.0945118964,
-0.615537107,
0.1951268017,
0.6397235394,
0.0421442352,
-0.0406858809,
0.343809396,
0.5836023688,
0.9754794836,
-0.2834325433,
1.2168518305,
-0.3549062312,
0.24810718,
0.7536152601,
-0.3474290669,
0.9738317728,
0.2831863463,
-0.1200543046,
0.7723424435,
0.2227523923,
0.4550971091,
0.6735152602,
0.0253325514,
-0.8508070707,
-0.1377585828,
-0.4910851121,
-0.0887227133,
0.377771765,
0.5775164366,
0.012306869,
-0.773984611,
-0.3710012436,
0.0314243287,
0.3322436213,
-0.0617079288,
1.0829024315,
0.0420612022,
-0.6375227571,
0.1985431015,
0.4467026591,
0.4816195667,
-0.8977287412,
-0.2963012159,
-0.3353232443,
0.0140280332,
-0.1287964135,
-1.0092753172,
0.4203816652,
-0.0892682299,
-0.1455004066,
-0.3269855976,
0.9923402667,
-0.4273051023,
-0.0191069562,
0.2116162032,
0.700624764,
0.2497282624,
-0.4720443189,
-0.6182955503,
-0.2681614161,
-0.1014885008,
0.066181697,
0.3759339452,
0.6927745938,
-0.1728754044,
0.8713421226,
0.8825178742,
-0.1808992624,
-0.3048894107,
0.0587093197,
1.1448817253,
-0.9033328891,
-0.3950756788,
-0.5311400294,
0.1811891943,
-0.0370309688,
0.1935250014,
0.5099669099,
0.6467562914,
0.5681375265,
0.368840307,
0.605817318,
-0.4048253298,
0.7278279066,
-0.4939066172,
0.8259824514,
-0.3546901047,
0.1452738941,
-0.1729975343,
-1.0007971525,
-0.2210756242,
0.7318634987,
-0.1610022634,
0.0362254903,
0.7307651639,
0.8964639902,
-0.1261469126,
0.1080091,
0.3102548718,
0.2168598324,
0.5374461412,
0.3979140818,
0.837516129,
-0.2115435302,
0.5282438993,
-0.074632436,
-0.0656690821,
0.1197565049,
-0.5381465554,
-0.5556805134,
-0.8588368893,
0.2224539369,
-0.1888926029,
0.1295242608,
0.9118897319,
0.4357653856,
-0.5755454898,
-0.3786540926,
-0.2541666627,
0.5706066489,
0.4447758198,
-0.2863538265,
0.322619617,
-0.38602826,
-0.8490187526,
0.8100215793,
0.342749536,
-0.0347593576,
-0.1287403405,
0.1795961559,
-0.5091517568,
0.2455550581,
0.7873622179,
0.1990215331,
-0.3127748668,
-0.2308764905,
0.1248518229,
-0.34543854,
0.1682869643,
0.9786482453,
-1.1009715796,
0.4382207096,
0.61281389,
0.6460138559,
0.3313215375,
0.1905042082,
0.6940828562,
-1.0365209579,
0.021271769,
0.4905338585,
0.0298551675,
0.3251220286,
-0.4212063253,
0.4803061783,
0.2139291167,
-0.6532444954,
-0.5241556168,
0.4112940431,
-1.1374262571,
-0.4583688378,
1.0065795183,
0.4376500845,
0.0136915706,
-0.4628910422,
-0.4076236784,
0.010571884,
-0.6408076286,
0.544436276,
0.4028313458,
-0.2912557721,
-0.2050329596,
-0.6548655033,
0.6772696376,
0.0844481364,
-0.7318902016,
-0.0171909779,
0.7964515686,
-0.0340006016,
0.0085679432,
1.2419397831,
-0.2579628527,
-0.1616294384,
-0.3110634089,
-0.0901246592,
0.3342836201,
-0.6453780532,
-0.0651424676,
0.287381202,
0.0093139345,
0.168819055
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13219v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13219v1
|
Interactive Visual Task Learning for Robots
| 2023-12-20T17:38:04 | 2023-12-20T17:38:04 |
Weiwei Gu, Anant Sah, Nakul Gopalan
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
We present a framework for robots to learn novel visual concepts and tasks
via in-situ linguistic interactions with human users. Previous approaches have
either used large pre-trained visual models to infer novel objects zero-shot,
or added novel concepts along with their attributes and representations to a
concept hierarchy. We extend the approaches that focus on learning visual
concept hierarchies by enabling them to learn novel concepts and solve unseen
robotics tasks with them. To enable a visual concept learner to solve robotics
tasks one-shot, we developed two distinct techniques. Firstly, we propose a
novel approach, Hi-Viscont(HIerarchical VISual CONcept learner for Task), which
augments information of a novel concept to its parent nodes within a concept
hierarchy. This information propagation allows all concepts in a hierarchy to
update as novel concepts are taught in a continual learning setting. Secondly,
we represent a visual task as a scene graph with language annotations, allowing
us to create novel permutations of a demonstrated task zero-shot in-situ. We
present two sets of results. Firstly, we compare Hi-Viscont with the baseline
model (FALCON) on visual question answering(VQA) in three domains. While being
comparable to the baseline model on leaf level concepts, Hi-Viscont achieves an
improvement of over 9% on non-leaf concepts on average. We compare our model's
performance against the baseline FALCON model. Our framework achieves 33%
improvements in success rate metric, and 19% improvements in the object level
accuracy compared to the baseline model. With both of these results we
demonstrate the ability of our model to learn tasks and concepts in a continual
learning setting on the robot.
|
[
-0.1113485396,
-1.1030980349,
0.4797727466,
-0.3911531568,
-0.0053529041,
0.5066571832,
0.0733617544,
-0.4019160569,
0.2110113949,
0.5478816032,
-0.7395752072,
-0.5719756484,
-0.3955177367,
-0.0277319029,
0.0284991134,
0.4779946804,
-0.0437360816,
-0.2303756624,
-0.218583405,
-0.0480991416,
-0.4749993384,
-0.2709959149,
-0.3919551671,
-0.1218450293,
0.5188555717,
0.7899448276,
0.852530241,
0.659021616,
0.9298080802,
0.3612946272,
0.0945629552,
0.2853783965,
-0.4592676163,
0.1378781945,
-0.3694363534,
-0.4741057158,
-0.0985364392,
-0.2136082649,
0.3236121237,
1.1143610477,
-0.0223926492,
0.1362050027,
0.0529746525,
0.5263394713,
-0.7535738945,
0.3399192095,
-0.5029039979,
0.363279134,
0.1650176495,
-0.4325092733,
-0.2699003816,
0.1270073354,
0.2848503888,
-1.2362220287,
0.0546102077,
0.0016031129,
1.1541050673,
0.6542443037,
-0.2085303068,
-0.134137854,
-0.7086340785,
0.5554149747,
-0.3269174099,
0.2291936427,
-0.0071314303,
0.4666308165,
-0.1680564731,
-0.7261593938,
-0.7855930924,
-0.5732389092,
0.1627375185,
0.4574893713,
-0.1520072967,
0.2100238949,
0.3781730533,
0.0978188962,
-0.5026879907,
0.1453056037,
-0.2040848583,
0.1222462505,
0.2832244039,
0.2707695365,
0.3880518675,
-0.713540256,
-0.9810333848,
-0.4362885654,
-0.4094565213,
0.4810205102,
0.0205724388,
0.3952383697,
-0.1020495147,
0.9010722637,
-0.5000394583,
0.6751909256,
0.1097979099,
-0.2739831805,
0.3051740229,
-0.2893804312,
-0.1626575738,
-0.5855610967,
0.5071612597,
0.3006340861,
0.2846129239,
-0.1198989227,
-0.1551163644,
0.1221089512,
0.5451686382,
-0.4505494237,
-0.3555175364,
0.0073869387,
-0.340198189,
-0.1059242859,
0.3651181757,
-0.4574830234,
-0.3695815206,
-0.5367233753,
0.8516343832,
-0.3341494501,
-0.1236803755,
0.2524591684,
-0.3838193119,
0.1620591581,
0.8158704638,
-0.4155714214,
0.2964156568,
0.2138040066,
0.7043385506,
-0.4520956576,
-0.507314086,
-0.6649203897,
0.3415468335,
-0.4106533527,
0.6414203644,
-0.4873372614,
-0.1576144099,
0.0027731326,
0.152414754,
-0.2802132666,
-0.5742265582,
-0.3018985391,
-0.3165717423,
-0.0135497432,
0.0024591954,
-0.3894868493,
-0.5070104599,
0.2913514078,
-0.48998487,
0.928686738,
0.5002526045,
-0.7033732533,
0.4025205076,
-0.8630168438,
-0.2783224583,
0.6751046777,
-0.3820984364,
-0.1293121725,
-0.3086667359,
-0.1063523814,
0.6632911563,
0.2052404583,
-0.0959314406,
-0.1586156487,
-0.3164462149,
-0.1305162013,
0.1557231098,
0.6418118477,
0.0963782147,
-0.395544529,
0.4536995888,
-0.5416385531,
-0.2369011641,
0.2616603673,
0.0390542038,
-0.1359708011,
0.0123318108,
-0.1836562306,
0.1679834127,
0.3499616385,
-0.5326933861,
0.0983108357,
-0.4220952988,
0.0761236176,
0.3828571737,
0.3497480154,
0.4557850957,
-0.1395225972,
0.9369053245,
0.1340859979,
0.0864702538,
-0.4822157621,
-0.3323921859,
-0.9473446608,
-0.35553056,
-0.0348775685,
0.8762761354,
-1.5296071768,
0.1739767492,
-0.094695881,
-0.253672421,
-0.0269777458,
0.3054618835,
0.4523287416,
0.6781330109,
0.4081524909,
-0.6608077884,
-0.2444444448,
-0.6114338636,
0.3457820714,
-0.3631936908,
-0.2100792527,
0.4310749471,
0.8587427735,
-0.1349998564,
0.9955475926,
-0.5547297001,
-0.3143887818,
-0.2542407811,
0.4477915466,
-0.1175594851,
0.3029921949,
0.3041548431,
-0.8350675106,
-0.356662482,
0.4407751858,
-1.1271675825,
0.6425606608,
-0.2905343771,
0.0385071114,
0.1194312945,
0.7246537805,
-0.5166547298,
0.6459670663,
0.088512145,
-0.0079509923,
0.0641811565,
-0.2234128565,
0.1010720357,
-0.9592743516,
-0.1421021223,
0.1237630993,
-0.2416512072,
-0.4583573341,
0.5451501012,
-0.1436022818,
-0.2264644355,
-0.9406019449,
0.4318858087,
-0.3439871967,
0.0281827264,
-0.346413821,
0.2961610854,
-0.2627900839,
0.9298737645,
0.3311548829,
0.5788180828,
0.6170487404,
-0.7220206261,
0.5202597976,
0.4316496253,
-0.3706895113,
0.3593814671,
-0.7339475751,
-0.0368810035,
-0.2018588483,
-0.054516647,
-1.1041533947,
-0.3759999573,
0.5733348131,
-0.6069274545,
0.0472486429,
-0.0717148408,
-0.4936004877,
-0.5285211802,
0.0402648747,
-0.0897961929,
0.4209521711,
-0.4494249523,
0.5205677748,
0.3928990364,
-0.085975863,
-0.6047247648,
-0.3036550283,
0.0947040319,
-0.1018134952,
-0.4828037322,
0.2038722038,
0.0352070034,
-0.0700464249,
0.2108193189,
-0.1994354129,
-0.1289736927,
0.2400124222,
0.3684517145,
0.4531708658,
-0.1084582135,
0.1428162605,
-0.2570880055,
-0.1190039515,
-0.1617052406,
-0.2071608007,
0.2009987384,
-0.1661099643,
-0.2787280679,
-0.5685463548,
0.2471908927,
0.3337800503,
-0.4223905504,
0.4502201378,
0.6329537034,
-0.4447182715,
-0.2055207789,
-0.031668216,
-0.2257885933,
-0.4942668974,
0.640834868,
-0.5986576676,
-0.9863622189,
0.1983450204,
-0.3814598024,
0.0752201602,
0.219741106,
0.4185482264,
-0.6866853237,
0.6973035336,
1.2971966267,
0.43640697,
0.7265467644,
-0.6350073814,
0.167910561,
-0.4528100193,
-0.4240190983,
-0.1836050302,
-0.1729151756,
-0.5420794487,
-0.7365436554,
0.5933392644,
0.2695039809,
-0.2537692487,
0.7710088491,
-0.3195365071,
0.3568653464,
0.6329564452,
0.5006860495,
0.1272606254,
0.1114709005,
-0.1856843382,
0.3319838643,
-0.9109429717,
-0.4871374071,
0.669486165,
0.2327022552,
0.7461920381,
-0.163077876,
0.5746420026,
0.2034255862,
-0.2188291103,
-1.0415387154,
0.6924701929,
-0.1221751273,
-0.3154965639,
-0.6529076099,
-0.2840254903,
-0.979333818,
0.1920138299,
-0.2288195342,
-0.7117356062,
0.1487937868,
0.1441302598,
-0.4589907527,
0.2459226698,
-0.7006728649,
1.0653176308,
-0.0932924673,
-0.6053957939,
-0.3146962225,
-1.1117751598,
0.0324912705,
0.316850096,
-0.1036196575,
-0.114709191,
-0.1545717418,
0.4117256403,
-0.1014116406,
1.2915546894,
-0.2498962432,
-0.0601942576,
0.4549572766,
0.247355938,
0.2715926766,
-0.1155033261,
0.3108406961,
-0.0325090401,
-0.1180718541,
-0.4842324555,
-0.8158534169,
-0.0222226139,
-0.5746264458,
-0.6023342609,
-0.379489094,
-0.9397293329,
-0.0437706187,
0.1903777868,
-0.0623953305,
0.2612183988,
-0.0743958876,
0.3295418024,
0.6491256952,
-0.2859223783,
0.2408696115,
0.531324923,
0.0293566771,
0.0404138379,
1.0148175955,
-0.1525979191,
0.700106144,
0.9579002857,
0.0477682464,
0.1883411556,
-0.2168088555,
-0.4087216556,
-0.1966458708,
-0.8583542109,
-0.1387667954,
-0.6917571425,
-0.262019217,
0.1407743096,
-0.3313821256,
-0.1824387908,
-0.4827157259,
-0.0860744864,
0.0267033838,
0.2930039763,
0.7852485776,
0.097311154,
0.4445908666,
-0.4487605393,
0.8929755688,
0.3235642016,
-0.2420271486,
-0.1922290921,
-0.4514022768,
-0.3119636774,
0.2604742646,
-0.4767049849,
-0.5302165747,
0.1507407427,
0.0925821587,
0.5827950239,
0.3268458545,
0.0245217402,
0.6796988249,
-0.573289156,
0.7511684299,
0.3796292245,
-0.7841411233,
0.8406503201,
-0.4328356087,
0.4899354875,
0.3878521025,
0.7465666533,
-0.4479424655,
-0.5197332501,
-0.576739192,
-0.6714196801,
0.5626600385,
0.0253479965,
0.1620259136,
-0.0402379148,
0.2994068563,
0.2051312029,
0.2576692104,
-0.5057231188,
-0.1313552856,
-0.2511526346,
-0.1416793615,
-0.136280328,
0.3830811977,
0.0923275426,
-0.469836086,
0.1135546267,
-0.5824228525,
0.0994033515,
0.0055623972,
-0.3414950669,
-0.2243255377,
-0.2262055576,
0.1487662792,
0.8200178146,
-0.2273103148,
0.0265086219,
0.1552913189,
-0.3192008734,
-0.0822735429,
-0.2679038644,
-0.2320914567,
-0.1161887944,
0.4574311376,
0.7991560102,
0.5527716279,
-0.8272101879,
0.6132667065,
0.3750843406,
-0.2102822959,
-0.1724343896,
0.3169790506,
0.0204761084,
0.2599294782,
0.1028337106,
0.4137599468,
0.173510626,
-0.8158507943,
0.46414271,
0.4853194654,
-0.6156975627,
-0.1898406297,
0.5915176868,
0.2835042775,
-0.230091393,
0.4514085948,
-0.3304592967,
-0.5138123035,
0.927608788,
0.2246121317,
0.5216898918,
-0.0902331993,
0.7860551476,
0.5928743482,
0.2319807708,
0.2434033751,
0.3402730823,
-0.5505311489,
-0.7790538669,
-0.2468111068,
-0.347145021,
-0.94549191,
-0.3179806471,
-0.6564434171,
0.1984237134,
-0.3200629056,
0.1437142491,
0.0334798209,
0.0640185699,
-0.8008024693,
0.209335506,
0.1100990921,
0.3523809612,
-0.6056501269,
0.7469297051,
0.9661134481,
-0.9486589432,
-0.493565172,
0.1581858546,
-0.0250245072,
-0.8578525186,
0.9159117341,
0.0472064465,
-0.6286870241,
0.1266474873,
-0.7585477233,
-0.8917807937,
1.0111054182,
0.2049579322,
-0.2703697085,
-0.1918064356,
0.0047141267,
0.393170476,
-0.4114342332,
0.0452795587,
-0.0472993478,
0.2007633597,
0.539434731,
-0.7985903025,
-0.4157675505,
-0.2496664971,
0.0109408526,
-0.0695225224,
-0.4838546216,
0.6640498042,
-0.6054417491,
-0.4516285956,
0.2307663113,
0.8410829902,
0.0311543383,
0.159247458,
0.6740851998,
0.2142243087,
0.6728549004,
0.2045902759,
0.9656010866,
-0.0637662038,
0.1313337982,
1.0419456959,
-0.4131862223,
1.0610588789,
0.4291965067,
0.0511080399,
0.6443541646,
0.436721772,
-0.0583580136,
0.4900227487,
0.2861618996,
0.0007239946,
-0.5259005427,
-0.4184404612,
0.0501298346,
0.55049932,
0.2477486134,
0.4855598509,
-0.2454585433,
0.5337034464,
-0.351126492,
0.4036616087,
-0.083626695,
0.7329840064,
-0.0389158018,
-0.4653035998,
0.5072501302,
-0.3016696572,
0.5328189135,
-0.5907360911,
-0.4639693201,
0.1195624173,
0.3004004061,
-0.0999754742,
-0.8880092502,
-0.1192827299,
-0.17092897,
-0.0039468897,
-0.2783481777,
0.4213937223,
-0.3831412494,
-0.516048789,
0.2001796365,
0.7027750015,
0.044369258,
0.1634159088,
-0.5386164188,
-0.1586482823,
-0.187244758,
0.0358783416,
-0.0101350164,
0.4929299653,
-0.0298899952,
0.9933091402,
0.1791707575,
-0.3129016459,
0.0878048241,
-0.0237601269,
0.7271965742,
-0.569989562,
-0.3023957014,
-0.0855866596,
0.600035727,
0.1662603319,
-0.3409740031,
0.8506173491,
0.3292923272,
1.498182416,
-0.3518632948,
0.5035485625,
-0.1512207389,
0.5352231264,
-0.7000803947,
0.3462121785,
-0.8832124472,
-0.2388325334,
-0.4426567852,
-0.6494317055,
-0.2654123306,
0.7071585059,
0.0052361451,
0.0704764351,
0.9905211926,
0.7418209314,
-0.115671806,
-0.2135964036,
0.597034812,
0.0083082533,
-0.0213111117,
0.573805511,
1.1699584723,
-0.228255704,
0.2607557178,
-0.6553546786,
-0.2277257144,
-0.0228063613,
-0.4865638614,
-1.0295861959,
-0.8316286802,
-0.6150431633,
0.2639889419,
0.3679431081,
0.8032524586,
0.9733338356,
-0.4848887324,
-0.5712136626,
-0.1726421863,
-0.0281863883,
-0.5426251888,
-0.206325978,
0.1606957465,
-0.7013002634,
-0.7342359424,
0.5302523375,
0.4760739505,
-0.175127551,
-0.0435849093,
-0.1048989072,
-0.328407377,
-0.193500489,
0.8626611829,
0.3901866078,
-0.8498570919,
-0.522216022,
0.3712684512,
-0.0035444426,
0.2853688598,
0.5756772161,
-1.0833460093,
0.5602405667,
0.3614281118,
0.7325265408,
0.665338099,
0.0511589646,
0.2790630758,
-0.4704673886,
0.2593605816,
0.2612778842,
0.11283537,
0.1826518476,
-0.2464769185,
0.5817264318,
0.2758773267,
0.0215168279,
-0.4337672293,
0.4470143914,
-1.3036782742,
-0.3925800025,
0.8086158037,
-0.1580998152,
-0.2681826353,
-0.0986411721,
-0.2506484687,
0.2562349439,
0.0259220954,
0.4699063599,
0.3544735312,
-0.1619678587,
-0.3084227741,
-0.795784235,
0.0923454836,
0.4213778079,
-0.902572155,
-0.2198530436,
0.36852476,
0.0025790455,
0.2430146635,
0.2345834672,
0.0877174586,
0.6216839552,
0.1146480516,
0.3739210367,
-0.1316993982,
-1.0440778732,
0.0486733392,
0.1907911599,
-0.1022806242,
-0.6480096579
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13211v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13211v1
|
DSFormer: Effective Compression of Text-Transformers by Dense-Sparse Weight Factorization
| 2023-12-20T17:27:25 | 2023-12-20T17:27:25 |
Rahul Chand, Yashoteja Prabhu, Pratyush Kumar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the tremendous success of large transformer models in natural language
understanding, down-sizing them for cost-effective deployments has become
critical. Recent studies have explored the low-rank weight factorization
techniques which are efficient to train, and apply out-of-the-box to any
transformer architecture. Unfortunately, the low-rank assumption tends to be
over-restrictive and hinders the expressiveness of the compressed model. This
paper proposes, DSFormer, a simple alternative factorization scheme which
expresses a target weight matrix as the product of a small dense and a
semi-structured sparse matrix. The resulting approximation is more faithful to
the weight distribution in transformers and therefore achieves a stronger
efficiency-accuracy trade-off. Another concern with existing factorizers is
their dependence on a task-unaware initialization step which degrades the
accuracy of the resulting model. DSFormer addresses this issue through a novel
Straight-Through Factorizer (STF) algorithm that jointly learns all the weight
factorizations to directly maximize the final task accuracy. Extensive
experiments on multiple natural language understanding benchmarks demonstrate
that DSFormer obtains up to 40% better compression than the state-of-the-art
low-rank factorizers, leading semi-structured sparsity baselines and popular
knowledge distillation approaches. Our approach is also orthogonal to
mainstream compressors and offers up to 50% additional compression when added
to popular distilled, layer-shared and quantized transformers. We empirically
evaluate the benefits of STF over conventional optimization practices.
|
[
-0.4212920368,
-0.5316705108,
0.725061357,
0.3121364415,
-0.3179843426,
0.1450093985,
-0.3800189495,
0.0850081295,
0.2199692577,
0.1777439862,
-0.6122813225,
-0.1192027777,
-0.9912127852,
0.3206920028,
-0.2536138296,
1.0763220787,
-0.2585520446,
0.0172109306,
-0.3123233616,
0.2065580189,
-0.1841449589,
-0.4211378098,
-0.6203487515,
-0.3304214478,
0.3981512487,
0.2322555631,
0.7517350316,
0.4462485611,
0.3817533553,
0.4257068336,
-0.3102416694,
0.0163818672,
-0.7335494757,
0.064899303,
0.2129154652,
-0.2815174162,
-0.3002252579,
0.0329215713,
0.6134195924,
0.8067632318,
-0.2877849936,
0.2294367552,
-0.0046502748,
0.8502383232,
-0.3900245726,
0.1095040068,
-0.3050126135,
0.0154270669,
0.1305636466,
-0.2870843112,
-0.518004775,
-0.2412447184,
-0.1520175934,
-0.5815358758,
0.5128384233,
0.0433232561,
0.6108769774,
0.8473064899,
-0.4982787073,
-0.2480320781,
-0.9877980351,
0.8041118979,
-0.3468606472,
0.5652899146,
0.1611904055,
0.4439104497,
-0.0649373531,
-0.7492144704,
-0.7050564885,
0.0627068877,
-0.4366604388,
0.2694986165,
-0.4485732019,
0.2497136742,
0.3284651041,
0.7411049008,
-0.4564338624,
-0.1152524948,
-0.6243672967,
0.0706451833,
0.4756761193,
-0.2276090086,
0.1870667785,
-0.3061461747,
-0.4751758873,
-0.1092200205,
-0.2483751625,
0.0396994688,
0.3969185054,
0.2081663311,
-0.087306045,
0.602955997,
-0.1207739338,
0.6216742396,
0.5726860762,
-0.2511994839,
-0.1101555228,
-0.3703748882,
-0.5528413653,
0.1833156198,
0.5599268675,
0.0833048299,
-0.2222362459,
-0.3843278587,
-0.4126152098,
0.2396431267,
0.7121561766,
-1.2085521221,
-0.2134545594,
0.1361080706,
-0.546215415,
-0.585503459,
0.1012823731,
-0.7026100755,
-0.4012776017,
-0.5712983608,
0.6467295885,
-0.2390778363,
0.0611207113,
0.3889034092,
-0.1814745665,
-0.1863684952,
0.2826144099,
-0.8703169227,
0.6579886675,
0.6757401228,
0.8923978806,
-0.0434165001,
0.1870261431,
-0.6803958416,
-0.1019579992,
-0.0864770785,
0.7799960971,
-0.331145376,
-0.3547402322,
-0.4083756506,
-0.2199326307,
-0.1268027872,
-0.227347225,
1.0111792088,
-0.4668164551,
0.3710508049,
0.0197269637,
-0.3669517636,
-0.1256880909,
-0.1812503636,
-0.8613469005,
1.1988329887,
0.186316818,
-0.5960728526,
0.5372117162,
-0.3235038817,
-0.4415169656,
0.0638046563,
-0.1354476511,
-0.5242395401,
0.5851543546,
0.3846808672,
0.4636170864,
-0.3552715182,
0.4466773272,
0.1220361665,
-0.7391083241,
-0.1850173771,
-0.6793609858,
0.4579096437,
0.0148369363,
-0.2341494262,
0.1800209582,
-0.7670215368,
-0.3367589414,
0.1667585373,
-0.3646329939,
-0.3216008544,
-0.156116277,
0.1678018421,
0.3616390824,
0.0176482871,
-0.6562162638,
0.4231165648,
-0.4480595887,
0.2664747238,
0.6221320033,
-0.114688687,
1.0029736757,
-0.3085751235,
0.573305428,
-0.1282531023,
0.1950491667,
0.2205985188,
-0.2097904235,
-0.9356127977,
-0.6346456409,
0.1767855734,
0.1261275709,
-0.9307557344,
0.6997476816,
-0.7068063021,
-0.7818956375,
-0.5937390327,
0.2372837812,
0.0128956167,
0.47119838,
0.5155127048,
0.0224876683,
-0.604542017,
-0.8378780484,
-0.0417749919,
0.1135527566,
-0.2760411203,
-0.1049333364,
0.3101697266,
-0.1588083804,
0.8285869956,
-0.7997301221,
-0.4398669004,
-0.6093171835,
0.4057943523,
0.3859089911,
0.4661074579,
0.4750985801,
-0.9805145264,
-0.417252779,
-0.5243200064,
-0.143811956,
0.0057363231,
-0.3595227301,
0.0308451876,
0.0746478811,
0.3378620744,
-0.7082737684,
0.3617101908,
0.9221537113,
-0.3578247726,
0.1004644632,
-0.3800979853,
0.0776248649,
-1.0351400375,
-0.0304254331,
0.0850963667,
-0.188221857,
-0.8906801343,
-0.3411028981,
0.0940200537,
-0.4471679926,
-0.144088611,
0.0557957664,
-0.3063251972,
0.1740258187,
-0.0732949376,
0.1092282981,
0.2562637031,
0.7481652498,
0.0857543722,
1.1238230467,
0.1116838083,
-0.3259779811,
-0.0951621309,
0.3850302696,
-0.2598464787,
0.5602664948,
-0.8767203689,
0.1845763773,
-0.7849401236,
0.4930894375,
-0.9482583404,
0.2094457299,
0.0086558145,
-0.1034420282,
0.4743877649,
-0.3143630326,
-0.2732747495,
-0.3807718158,
-0.4026340246,
0.3525175154,
0.5227093697,
-0.7144605517,
0.8587878346,
0.2620524764,
-0.1884025931,
-0.3813715875,
-0.6773426533,
0.1043026224,
-0.0372042768,
-0.6790012717,
0.6897854209,
-0.3119038045,
0.0399388559,
-0.2536815107,
-0.8540995717,
-0.0404042453,
0.0944844186,
0.2613949478,
0.3678207397,
-0.1815408468,
0.0861955732,
0.1496914327,
-0.4777999818,
-0.2231557518,
-0.3322509825,
0.3993417323,
0.0127221551,
-0.1235442758,
-0.3355606794,
0.3209072351,
0.4948946536,
-0.0261154547,
0.9386425614,
0.5354703665,
-0.3335152268,
-0.3863200843,
-0.4590836167,
-0.1924530417,
-0.5236893296,
0.198775962,
-0.4259434044,
-0.8485797048,
-0.1751144081,
-0.0860377401,
-0.0754648373,
0.4366966486,
0.0921924636,
0.0591084473,
1.1224491596,
0.9809527993,
0.1941507012,
0.2060042471,
-0.1554550529,
0.7858225107,
-0.3924345076,
-0.0060905758,
-0.6245210767,
-0.5451911092,
-0.4454239011,
-0.7116492391,
0.2604013979,
0.2674949169,
0.0111824321,
0.7191568613,
-0.6729914546,
0.3436667323,
0.1994013488,
-0.0073862118,
0.4642046392,
-0.0089174304,
0.1778409332,
-0.2251780629,
-0.7399893403,
-0.5529369712,
0.5297939777,
0.3790420294,
0.7365561724,
0.2572461069,
0.7815589309,
0.1325218529,
0.2314865589,
-1.1709451675,
0.1519450247,
-0.484259814,
-0.142835319,
-0.233494699,
-0.6332922578,
-0.4219022095,
0.1532024592,
-0.3668614924,
-0.4677577317,
0.3674674928,
-0.0936180279,
-0.4703738689,
0.2709058523,
-0.7957894206,
0.7612442374,
-0.044474557,
0.1155890971,
-0.0802702829,
-0.1904910505,
0.2117651552,
-0.250880897,
0.1288527697,
0.155100897,
-0.145424813,
0.8490400314,
-0.466042757,
0.6756552458,
-0.1965793967,
-0.2746275365,
-0.1641633809,
-0.0784010813,
0.6902402639,
0.1327967793,
-0.0835118145,
0.1418918222,
-0.1513037682,
-0.3448756933,
-1.08593297,
0.4249529541,
-0.6003811955,
-0.4378179014,
-0.3651747108,
-0.359184444,
-0.1762595922,
0.2394649535,
0.1390724778,
0.856202364,
-0.0677204803,
0.3152655959,
0.6316326857,
-0.0410603136,
0.2025280744,
0.3497500718,
0.265493542,
-0.4842037559,
0.721642375,
-0.008485198,
0.1867191494,
0.7361358404,
0.1008986831,
-0.2078653127,
-0.5012682676,
-0.4538998008,
0.2130950987,
-0.6059036255,
-0.4291238785,
-0.7760105133,
-0.2323636413,
-0.2503762543,
-0.5304402113,
-0.6093398333,
-0.671053946,
0.0099926684,
-0.3138646781,
0.1933172345,
1.0415761471,
0.3458068371,
0.5058027506,
-0.5805789828,
0.628466785,
0.3461690843,
0.6715685725,
-0.1942007244,
-0.3829658329,
-0.0365103483,
-0.0955379903,
-0.0416511893,
-0.5434206724,
0.219068557,
0.1625974476,
0.4180697799,
0.2664923966,
0.3838519454,
0.8977047205,
-0.5417423248,
0.5535697341,
0.2478335351,
-0.9636369944,
0.1887217164,
0.1766075939,
0.1795243472,
0.886261344,
0.4709536135,
-0.6031876802,
-0.1837328672,
-0.446542263,
-0.7833591104,
0.9190965891,
0.5276970267,
0.0350797623,
0.250120163,
0.0317469276,
0.2613960207,
0.205478996,
-0.4523955286,
-0.5464445353,
-0.3705883622,
-0.5396425128,
-0.4704798162,
-0.4967618883,
0.0068605794,
-0.2032654583,
0.7504159212,
-0.3011643589,
0.3840364516,
0.2283476442,
-0.442471385,
-0.1719823331,
0.5419054031,
0.5774582028,
0.2000076622,
-0.2113503665,
0.6011202335,
0.1484204978,
-0.7603709102,
0.2880405486,
0.532420814,
-0.3432505131,
0.0169378575,
0.0389715731,
0.8446933031,
0.733723402,
-0.3031266034,
0.7221505046,
-0.5405443311,
-0.3088817298,
-0.0589259975,
-0.2620672882,
-0.0006455176,
-0.0527354665,
0.4637171626,
0.7766148448,
0.1915270388,
0.0384011716,
0.2035665661,
0.0757315531,
-0.8157343268,
-0.2368507385,
0.5749297738,
0.3053945899,
-0.0361937396,
0.2032975852,
-0.3220768869,
-0.5805548429,
0.2082238495,
0.5191963315,
0.8315845132,
0.2444068938,
0.4061925113,
0.3358816206,
0.4001621008,
-0.3902749717,
-0.0745035112,
-0.5306802988,
-0.459043473,
-0.7063286901,
-0.9376729727,
-0.1695588529,
-0.0991293415,
-0.4560696781,
0.4718087316,
-0.3008353114,
-0.0217638928,
0.0306369029,
0.2969861627,
-0.5530357957,
0.1055716649,
0.2104046345,
1.1835285425,
-0.7127393484,
0.6165134311,
0.5970994234,
-0.5487081409,
-0.7556023598,
0.0611579679,
0.0421164222,
-0.3573875427,
0.6133708954,
0.3928364813,
-0.3689069748,
0.1669489145,
0.0389403291,
-0.9509402514,
1.1080842018,
0.3016372323,
-0.3322106898,
-0.1304831952,
0.0650248751,
0.3785968721,
0.0293321982,
0.410472542,
0.533444941,
0.5601423383,
0.2673140466,
-0.633245647,
0.4427373409,
-0.388836056,
0.1313762665,
0.4244282246,
-0.3321558237,
0.3563428223,
0.1961725503,
-0.6357586384,
-0.0296315569,
0.6507610679,
-0.140013814,
-0.0040442934,
0.8022086024,
0.3596446514,
0.6329481006,
-0.1253326088,
0.8677327037,
-0.2329997718,
0.3076824248,
0.7473056912,
0.0469258986,
0.5140781403,
0.6819746494,
-0.3443827033,
0.4725762904,
-0.0836705565,
0.0179514736,
0.3102520108,
-0.0058585014,
-0.1711173505,
-0.2202479541,
-0.0296907071,
0.1212862283,
0.5069198012,
-0.0592068247,
-0.0785128772,
-0.2933803797,
-0.2024357617,
0.016688168,
0.422581315,
-0.1233167872,
0.6629729271,
0.0122049218,
-0.5940032601,
0.6416139007,
0.1261527985,
1.2288402319,
-0.5940795541,
0.1664589494,
0.055540707,
0.0784474313,
-0.2540044785,
-0.3873022199,
0.547688663,
-0.0557809286,
-0.3010659218,
-1.0923087597,
0.9316565394,
-0.502442956,
-0.6436374784,
0.0218996406,
0.246912092,
-0.3364756107,
-0.2144955397,
-0.272778511,
-0.0826367214,
-0.1693581641,
-0.2728828192,
0.0619742945,
0.1311868131,
0.3566316962,
0.348530829,
0.6265737414,
0.2562045455,
-0.3566075265,
0.2057339251,
0.9287289381,
-0.3769547045,
-0.5361133218,
-0.4063716233,
0.5333095789,
-0.4177651107,
0.0145239066,
0.5840107799,
0.4512910843,
0.438871026,
-0.0249651074,
0.5563194156,
-0.097822994,
0.2437419444,
-0.3184948564,
0.9440951347,
-0.5038350224,
0.0766340271,
-0.2506622374,
-0.8828406334,
-0.2647099197,
0.4691846073,
-0.4272531271,
-0.0406259,
0.6635852456,
0.6316918731,
-0.246284619,
0.3476530313,
0.2788956165,
0.0011014866,
0.196116969,
0.274890393,
0.5035726428,
-0.7452239394,
0.8718221188,
-0.7811433673,
-0.2952772081,
0.0911361501,
-0.8378748298,
-1.0194327831,
-0.658885479,
-0.1171370596,
0.1211522594,
-0.3030839264,
1.0291370153,
0.7519950867,
-0.7082377672,
0.1748999655,
-0.2875137031,
0.0804239064,
-0.4401088059,
-0.2160014361,
0.2242140323,
-0.3217529356,
-0.850792408,
0.5826095939,
0.3239712119,
0.1248172373,
-0.1632793546,
-0.072075583,
0.1583234221,
0.1927103698,
0.7149133086,
-0.2439882159,
-0.2420978844,
-0.2969426215,
0.1480857134,
-0.2342854291,
-0.0652727261,
0.9656923413,
-0.9252741337,
0.1514330506,
0.6423311234,
0.6379391551,
0.4679882228,
0.2649209201,
0.7965847254,
-0.9830390215,
0.2713997364,
0.0800137445,
0.3375534117,
0.4271222651,
-0.5658859611,
0.3126028478,
0.1472263783,
-0.3265994787,
-0.5781757236,
0.1682142168,
-1.1095534563,
-0.195979476,
1.0181963444,
0.3466468155,
-0.1769609004,
-0.093098551,
-0.4922061563,
0.363722235,
-0.5913228393,
0.8094677329,
0.2662488222,
0.2238941491,
-0.1120191589,
-0.2695807815,
0.9012969732,
0.2875944078,
-0.4986421466,
0.0838179067,
0.2737225592,
-0.126176402,
0.341325134,
0.4377828538,
0.0850653574,
-0.1161424816,
-0.000123713,
-0.1856070757,
-0.2823154628,
-0.167657733,
-0.5729364753,
0.2214571536,
-0.2496118397,
0.2664798498
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.