id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04918v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04918v1
|
Low-Resource Named Entity Recognition: Can One-vs-All AUC Maximization Help?
| 2023-11-02T10:14:52 | 2023-11-02T10:14:52 |
Ngoc Dang Nguyen, Wei Tan, Lan Du, Wray Buntine, Richard Beare, Changyou Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Named entity recognition (NER), a task that identifies and categorizes named
entities such as persons or organizations from text, is traditionally framed as
a multi-class classification problem. However, this approach often overlooks
the issues of imbalanced label distributions, particularly in low-resource
settings, which is common in certain NER contexts, like biomedical NER
(bioNER). To address these issues, we propose an innovative reformulation of
the multi-class problem as a one-vs-all (OVA) learning problem and introduce a
loss function based on the area under the receiver operating characteristic
curve (AUC). To enhance the efficiency of our OVA-based approach, we propose
two training strategies: one groups labels with similar linguistic
characteristics, and another employs meta-learning. The superiority of our
approach is confirmed by its performance, which surpasses traditional NER
learning in varying NER settings.
|
[
-0.6389110684,
-0.6281114221,
0.4848026931,
-0.2000397891,
-0.2126024663,
0.0707498938,
-0.1270308495,
-0.5450273156,
0.6552734375,
0.5521005392,
-0.4993909895,
-0.1804075688,
-0.6461201906,
0.5841719508,
0.0120149823,
1.2108733654,
0.0455845296,
0.0681571215,
-0.1174878031,
-0.8693319559,
-0.2592691183,
-0.7704854608,
-1.1138025522,
-0.3971706331,
0.839384675,
0.5737774968,
0.1264214367,
0.7210687399,
0.6237582564,
0.2855975628,
-0.1644012481,
0.183910355,
-0.4425247014,
-0.1312261671,
0.0034073961,
-0.1313038617,
-0.4603893459,
-0.1601554602,
0.8453222513,
0.8783141971,
-0.3694448769,
0.2665001452,
0.0929177329,
0.607285738,
-1.0777601004,
0.078077808,
-0.5337324142,
0.271337986,
-0.1344057769,
-0.4358643889,
-0.5432418585,
-0.0799250975,
0.1790500134,
-0.8108602166,
0.2054587901,
0.0592679568,
0.781324327,
0.5064079762,
-0.4723193944,
0.1206647158,
-0.9571500421,
0.7631488442,
-0.078295894,
0.5276044607,
0.2401273251,
0.2785768509,
0.220231697,
-0.2564340532,
-0.4195605814,
0.1710566431,
-0.0238725301,
0.0621423982,
-0.4747930765,
0.0343332253,
0.2267086953,
0.0659152344,
-0.2980287671,
0.2297469676,
-0.455737859,
-0.2776586711,
0.3256090879,
0.1062633395,
0.084262006,
0.1583260298,
-0.5354285836,
-0.1766218394,
-0.3935832381,
-0.0886878818,
0.1144600436,
0.4873477519,
0.2930673361,
0.3276894987,
-0.1503043175,
0.4229129851,
0.197891742,
-0.3507451713,
0.6394429803,
-0.0250777323,
-0.3031581938,
0.5776706338,
0.7501481175,
-0.0970991403,
-0.116876781,
-0.173784107,
-0.2067364901,
-0.060196653,
0.2819369733,
-0.7909420133,
-0.016563721,
-0.3026518822,
-0.6892440319,
-0.2979572415,
-0.051914148,
-0.7695739865,
-0.4056917131,
-0.3060666323,
0.624368012,
-0.3259165585,
-0.3032466173,
-0.2086828649,
0.1428829879,
0.2321744114,
0.2115751505,
-0.8062474132,
0.521792233,
0.1185644791,
0.7846806049,
0.0161904432,
-0.0756145939,
-0.8612501621,
0.0645954385,
0.0801600218,
0.8158577085,
-0.4855630696,
-0.4685508311,
-0.5162768364,
-0.0250212625,
-0.2361136228,
-0.4487863183,
0.3252000213,
-0.3160741627,
-0.1032775417,
-0.3727116883,
-0.3313432038,
-0.0022744425,
0.139711529,
-1.0563883781,
0.5492478013,
0.1129429489,
-1.0966386795,
0.5587869883,
-0.7369098663,
-0.4314109385,
0.3078581095,
-0.4256880879,
-0.7183724642,
0.0776634589,
0.0165128857,
0.156628415,
-0.0836958662,
-0.2706787586,
0.0086934054,
0.0261982512,
0.237675339,
-0.4733649194,
0.5514990687,
0.138986364,
-0.1801813543,
-0.0643224791,
-0.9770497084,
0.114385128,
0.1323173642,
-0.6153845787,
-0.6632199883,
-0.0584854372,
0.140247941,
0.0196549576,
-0.2543108761,
-0.6817772985,
0.2427179068,
-0.3035503328,
0.4118426144,
0.5452438593,
0.2502025366,
0.8456448913,
-0.1097304448,
0.5103971362,
-0.0828838646,
0.2180628479,
0.007984817,
-0.3151091933,
-0.7572731376,
-0.5585173965,
0.5512607098,
0.6403231621,
-0.7555392981,
0.214177981,
-0.1333522201,
-0.204853192,
-0.6748023629,
-0.0279304013,
0.516102314,
0.7540948987,
0.869944036,
-0.4938257337,
-0.5521499515,
-0.8819765449,
-0.0971581116,
-0.1889739335,
0.1315825731,
0.703412056,
0.4697552621,
-0.4543835521,
0.7688203454,
-0.3675727546,
-0.8514190316,
-0.4579142034,
0.2580757439,
-0.144420445,
0.2935620248,
0.4696944654,
-0.9472987056,
-0.3549570441,
0.0135467621,
-0.4047553539,
0.077437982,
-0.1729447693,
-0.1434853524,
0.3161098957,
0.4028243423,
-0.1920124441,
0.5290033221,
0.0708490461,
-0.1278842092,
0.2113346606,
-0.4556357265,
0.0341832303,
-0.6922326088,
0.063450627,
0.2182128727,
-0.0907545388,
-0.5662341714,
-0.3193414807,
0.0462177768,
0.0271280892,
-0.4166758358,
0.7982476354,
-0.6526376605,
0.1636898667,
-0.3609294295,
-0.048393447,
-0.1647267342,
0.4451771379,
0.1562519968,
0.5126776695,
0.4722335935,
-0.9627819657,
0.0369200483,
0.4365687668,
0.0373824537,
0.8831424117,
-0.408249557,
-0.0735534877,
-0.6349244714,
0.335931778,
-0.2479759157,
-0.2696276903,
0.2388405651,
-0.4068104029,
0.5653779507,
-0.0756629109,
-0.1337950975,
-0.0174550898,
0.090106681,
0.7489225268,
0.3886122406,
-0.6206278205,
0.9861994982,
0.6326221228,
0.2237803042,
-0.8853815794,
-0.7648491859,
-0.1588818431,
-0.2320483625,
0.0173128173,
0.4367091656,
0.2349723727,
0.0666835904,
0.2884306908,
-0.4775572717,
-0.2443616539,
0.047284551,
0.1045366302,
0.1462872922,
-0.2000408024,
0.5139602423,
-0.2804628909,
-0.4653097987,
-0.311463654,
-0.3602211475,
0.1871874928,
-0.1927793026,
-0.1377337277,
-0.3348197341,
0.4437783062,
0.2193434089,
-0.7140758634,
1.0801228285,
0.6356003881,
-0.5002505183,
-0.3600180447,
-0.463596642,
-0.2173523754,
-0.3435606956,
0.3560791612,
-0.2528850734,
-0.6227485538,
0.2883125842,
-0.2163759023,
-0.1464278549,
0.5479598045,
0.1639211774,
0.1456643492,
0.8835218549,
1.2084258795,
-0.272157073,
0.5665279627,
-0.5897395015,
0.3692472875,
-1.0054188967,
-0.4933513403,
-0.5890140533,
-0.4526829422,
-0.5598526597,
-0.1307053864,
0.66387707,
-0.0439814143,
-0.2380052209,
0.4631652236,
-0.7567193508,
0.7048248053,
0.5224915147,
0.2889302373,
0.1922647208,
0.1097409576,
-0.2037166655,
0.1078166291,
-0.7990265489,
-0.4763450027,
0.9214670062,
0.1414260715,
0.7300610542,
-0.0744488165,
1.2120213509,
0.0476801023,
0.5324121118,
-0.8188410401,
0.3397832215,
-0.3120356798,
-0.5853617191,
-0.4535187483,
-0.9534859657,
-1.0688511133,
0.2578150332,
-0.624535799,
-0.8248628378,
0.5488395691,
0.2553473413,
-0.4322076738,
0.6850121021,
-0.3608427942,
0.9814485312,
-0.3766663373,
-0.0018810974,
0.0907699615,
-0.6256327033,
-0.0411526822,
-0.1868596822,
0.4890590012,
0.0310337432,
-0.1922732592,
0.7541831136,
-0.227995038,
0.5222200155,
-0.0903505683,
0.3609797657,
0.3371863067,
-0.3078322113,
0.2435038835,
0.0346053056,
0.0280804206,
0.136923641,
-0.2546713352,
-0.3263991475,
-0.3127336204,
0.4520991445,
-0.7910984159,
0.1058081016,
-0.6487321854,
0.0386329629,
0.0186949559,
0.197409451,
0.7445105314,
0.4271468818,
-0.607822001,
0.2659679651,
1.0471786261,
-0.3205340803,
0.367305398,
0.5419479609,
0.3928521276,
-0.6723288298,
1.0343589783,
0.231639713,
0.1329342425,
0.7382816672,
0.0439199843,
-0.0768774673,
-0.0758195594,
-0.431776166,
0.2338540852,
-0.7825728655,
-0.5134059191,
-1.1204067469,
-0.3003314137,
0.0780328065,
-0.052011393,
-0.421862185,
-0.187073946,
-0.5809927583,
0.0004253581,
0.0544869192,
0.311211139,
-0.1255160123,
0.4659454823,
-0.7993248701,
0.4786278009,
0.0993462503,
0.2839840353,
-0.1478390247,
-0.3192913532,
-0.1576499045,
-0.1377215683,
-0.369069308,
-1.1450973749,
0.2613568008,
0.7811690569,
0.9257454872,
0.5110664964,
0.2463502288,
0.3450984359,
-0.6682128906,
-0.0042993794,
0.5618581772,
-0.7334171534,
0.5562179685,
0.431130141,
0.0613462701,
0.9318817258,
0.5616960526,
-0.4524583519,
-0.0155071365,
-0.8702649474,
-1.0590153933,
0.7572615147,
0.3715534806,
0.0105031738,
-0.1337722093,
0.4338619113,
0.0414004028,
0.0702312589,
-0.8654612303,
-0.5757340193,
-0.1381396651,
-0.2442498952,
-0.0324477777,
0.0191991758,
0.0112802014,
-0.013702183,
0.8782085776,
-0.232063219,
0.2831929028,
0.4392239153,
-0.1075042933,
-0.304705292,
0.6322783828,
0.1035430431,
0.1622129381,
0.0954587683,
0.1245370135,
0.5054652691,
-0.4537833631,
0.339382261,
0.1123915464,
-0.4504903257,
0.0414975807,
0.2819935083,
1.0255951881,
0.1905392408,
-0.3645515144,
0.5316647887,
-0.2037062049,
-0.408829838,
0.0018201236,
0.0693865642,
-0.3948695064,
0.243920356,
0.4753045738,
0.426702112,
0.3285777569,
-0.4559615254,
0.0194533616,
0.5444916487,
-0.4584365785,
0.0263889432,
0.7217077017,
0.1677868813,
-0.2904198468,
0.6172869205,
-0.5329628587,
-0.5652119517,
0.7782586813,
0.3806560338,
1.0108243227,
-0.371237576,
0.3539766669,
0.716712594,
0.3991988003,
-0.4363413453,
0.1275728047,
-0.1230591759,
-0.6460587382,
-0.2437275797,
-0.8656053543,
-0.4399209917,
0.1386243403,
-0.7948981524,
0.3706565797,
-0.4498357773,
-0.5610325933,
0.5284488201,
-0.1721972972,
-0.9032613039,
0.1657664776,
0.3204712868,
0.3928142488,
-0.7316857576,
0.5401055813,
1.1177139282,
-0.6367733479,
-0.6973207593,
-0.2651277483,
-0.0821604133,
-0.2607549429,
0.7021017075,
0.349635154,
-0.1635496467,
0.0700638741,
-0.3598072529,
-0.9768206477,
0.9965779185,
0.2573083341,
-0.7046684027,
-0.0816336349,
-0.2199506015,
0.4030771852,
-0.6006553173,
0.2310438752,
0.2555436194,
0.5397138596,
-0.0923279375,
-1.0863460302,
-0.2129250318,
-0.1381713152,
-0.1755667627,
0.6184457541,
-0.5114554167,
0.7437480092,
-0.6466143131,
-0.5657120943,
-0.2455477118,
0.4206158519,
0.1870056987,
0.6232085228,
0.6933975816,
0.6144850254,
0.8869526982,
-0.0263944287,
0.8323974609,
-0.0014944293,
0.4095546305,
0.929148376,
-0.0279928651,
0.6442391872,
0.3579365015,
-0.059031114,
0.3220152557,
0.3060070574,
-0.2121309936,
0.6643567085,
0.3122297227,
-0.3770639896,
-0.4425376654,
-0.2692084908,
-0.2559138536,
0.5139580965,
0.1900707632,
-0.2487443388,
-0.1706395745,
0.5087089539,
-0.2495450526,
-0.0578267872,
-0.454061836,
1.1100757122,
0.226054579,
0.0285165738,
0.4104227424,
0.0387137942,
0.5578024983,
-0.4378854036,
-0.1199964881,
0.010679286,
0.4580463469,
-0.3045598865,
-0.0671683773,
-0.0274220426,
-0.0472344682,
-0.3755391538,
-0.0183946975,
0.6860055923,
-0.429687649,
-0.5840708017,
0.5514477491,
0.5523949862,
0.1671456546,
-0.0700599328,
-0.4174211919,
-0.2342772186,
-0.3617331684,
0.0063645402,
0.296261847,
0.6055989265,
-0.0138951372,
0.729629755,
0.2786663771,
0.1964714527,
-0.1079603434,
0.0272307191,
0.7389724851,
-0.553124845,
-0.5851689577,
-0.6951757669,
0.142402783,
-0.0553853177,
-0.3366348147,
0.2717134953,
0.478977114,
1.0517687798,
0.0624750778,
0.6523415446,
-0.0386901647,
0.4150565863,
-0.1563693881,
0.60052073,
-0.8891248107,
0.1914501637,
-0.3240529597,
-1.1380841732,
-0.2446389198,
0.8056684136,
0.118364051,
0.0322847068,
0.7654297948,
0.1992954016,
-0.241697222,
-0.2862687111,
0.1617126167,
-0.1333280802,
0.0334082879,
0.7485444546,
0.5693730116,
-0.5028585196,
0.7703585625,
-0.3755701184,
-0.4987458885,
-0.380094707,
-0.7777927518,
-0.697815299,
-0.4087372124,
-0.5993542671,
-0.2096964121,
0.0903654397,
1.1481925249,
0.7618732452,
-0.7786224484,
0.2802879512,
0.0654618368,
-0.0029046701,
-0.4007473886,
-0.101863645,
0.2085334957,
-0.2287217975,
-0.2693564892,
0.3553312123,
0.2440315485,
0.0406735875,
0.0534693338,
-0.2216485292,
-0.0554393157,
0.0316545479,
0.4725239873,
0.6467882991,
-0.4991247356,
0.0778335035,
0.1416198164,
-0.2360134721,
0.0661559179,
0.9147661328,
-0.891292572,
0.331972003,
0.1717850119,
0.9255405664,
0.4239422381,
0.0481653437,
-0.0379367881,
-0.7777753472,
-0.1007991657,
0.3981194794,
0.410197854,
0.3778319955,
-0.5225192904,
0.6280757189,
0.2785294354,
-0.5870994925,
-0.7550162077,
0.1658700854,
-1.0621901751,
-0.195383504,
0.9339465499,
0.2317014784,
-0.2396804392,
-0.0112890955,
-0.1251342595,
0.4291870892,
-0.5694520473,
0.5370560288,
0.1729918867,
-0.257125169,
-0.1324784458,
-0.6179584265,
0.3281353712,
0.1420912892,
-0.876486659,
-0.281198442,
0.4705577791,
0.4107032716,
0.4194771349,
0.951046586,
0.0180223621,
0.0486832336,
-0.0835380927,
0.4037228823,
-0.0170064569,
-0.7634298801,
-0.3115513325,
0.0485170521,
-0.2249137908,
-0.3005236089
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01108v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01108v1
|
Noise-Robust Fine-Tuning of Pretrained Language Models via External Guidance
| 2023-11-02T09:20:38 | 2023-11-02T09:20:38 |
Song Wang, Zhen Tan, Ruocheng Guo, Jundong Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Adopting a two-stage paradigm of pretraining followed by fine-tuning,
Pretrained Language Models (PLMs) have achieved substantial advancements in the
field of natural language processing. However, in real-world scenarios, data
labels are often noisy due to the complex annotation process, making it
essential to develop strategies for fine-tuning PLMs with such noisy labels. To
this end, we introduce an innovative approach for fine-tuning PLMs using noisy
labels, which incorporates the guidance of Large Language Models (LLMs) like
ChatGPT. This guidance assists in accurately distinguishing between clean and
noisy samples and provides supplementary information beyond the noisy labels,
thereby boosting the learning process during fine-tuning PLMs. Extensive
experiments on synthetic and real-world noisy datasets further demonstrate the
superior advantages of our framework over the state-of-the-art baselines.
|
[
-0.5125264525,
-0.8580872416,
0.2386824191,
0.0950364545,
-0.6256667972,
0.0161552411,
-0.5961359739,
-0.5142962933,
-0.3469066322,
0.6147665977,
-0.793946743,
-0.6202198267,
-0.5072025657,
-0.173493132,
-0.1379287243,
1.2677431107,
0.2140241414,
0.1539723277,
0.1406317949,
0.1254381537,
-0.3856076598,
-0.4174066186,
-1.0744576454,
-0.2403077632,
0.5301696062,
0.336324811,
0.7370052934,
0.6303002238,
0.4760276377,
0.2216966152,
-0.3023601472,
0.5458721519,
-0.5787135363,
0.3344919682,
-0.0534666665,
-0.3438962102,
-0.3427465856,
0.0616902001,
0.5228193402,
0.6297619343,
-0.0582387894,
0.092467837,
0.5212638378,
0.4665295482,
-0.4103310108,
0.6305957437,
-0.6813985109,
-0.0325765796,
-0.4097812772,
-0.2583866119,
-0.3635544777,
-0.5870547295,
0.0341758616,
-0.8348973393,
0.1384141743,
0.1483140439,
1.0160841942,
0.5504232645,
0.0952207446,
-0.225982666,
-0.8717562556,
0.7812537551,
-0.7285060287,
0.5665832758,
0.7655885816,
0.1162503362,
-0.444509387,
-0.8565632701,
-0.1309777349,
-0.1882919222,
0.0756805018,
-0.004524745,
0.1226201952,
0.3203881085,
0.2035310268,
0.3270658255,
-0.3026324809,
0.5687431693,
-0.2145535201,
-0.3888860941,
0.3200708926,
-0.1960821748,
0.0684987754,
0.525844276,
-0.0425673798,
-0.0046857391,
-0.8510715961,
-0.0180731565,
0.5559648275,
0.7505016923,
-0.1398530155,
0.0941947028,
-0.4119960666,
0.9569065571,
0.0999829918,
-0.1895540208,
0.2337945104,
-0.4213564396,
0.0796807408,
-0.0272509567,
0.7673973441,
0.2295176983,
0.725284636,
-0.2921456993,
-0.4202972651,
-0.0291664619,
0.0014342264,
-1.0012549162,
-0.8186290264,
-0.0840001032,
-0.2372042239,
-0.4166006744,
-0.3113504648,
-0.6794118881,
-0.5754804611,
-0.7235537171,
0.5771596432,
-0.38473171,
-0.1571071595,
0.0968385786,
0.3229418993,
-0.0066227084,
0.3149267733,
-0.87021631,
0.1698731035,
0.7134413719,
0.7492073178,
0.040497005,
0.0131625189,
-0.8743209243,
0.0079886494,
-0.3044023812,
0.982866466,
-0.6850573421,
-0.1693395823,
-0.0298317689,
-0.223330304,
0.1101105735,
-0.73966676,
0.8282394409,
-0.4095301628,
0.2261256725,
-0.1473617405,
-0.5371564627,
0.0754230097,
0.1479486376,
-0.3639471829,
1.1973632574,
0.0164964199,
-0.6870501637,
0.6616696715,
-0.4374226034,
-0.4429293275,
-0.0342820249,
0.039095372,
-0.7152394056,
-0.0913517028,
0.3216055334,
0.4318864644,
-0.150905475,
0.3406356573,
-0.3103426397,
-0.4203535914,
0.0879690126,
-0.4869424999,
0.5721188784,
0.453199923,
-0.0111208875,
0.3790297508,
-1.1516085863,
0.1123086661,
-0.2509520054,
-0.4596372247,
-0.4119533598,
0.1489720494,
-0.1657389849,
0.2592918873,
0.2526806891,
-0.2944886088,
0.1799494028,
-0.4716227055,
0.4830057621,
0.6782564521,
0.0340559408,
0.3149159849,
-0.4028208852,
0.3441627026,
0.0732887387,
0.2216657549,
-0.1663782001,
-0.4856183529,
-0.8810380697,
-0.4633716643,
0.440135181,
0.4104241431,
-0.5270752907,
0.4968914986,
-0.0458042622,
-0.4011810422,
-0.7855521441,
0.5274235606,
0.2654527724,
0.5599508286,
0.4450168312,
-0.3858644962,
-0.7594983578,
-0.5810912848,
-0.3715266287,
0.0557318032,
-0.0409176387,
0.1033862382,
0.0077209207,
-0.1965597123,
0.6767213941,
-0.2213971019,
-0.4765753448,
-0.0654228851,
0.449208051,
0.0415646657,
0.6732465029,
0.0658759028,
-0.5599839091,
-0.570130527,
-0.0831914321,
-0.0478855185,
-0.5926328897,
-0.0104336413,
-0.0953528732,
-0.162404716,
0.9607925415,
-0.3555828035,
0.0697488859,
0.4523391724,
-0.0702831224,
0.4538130462,
-0.2799427509,
-0.3707920015,
-0.8263293505,
-0.1850458384,
-0.0936362371,
-0.3789968789,
-0.5843498707,
-0.2364716381,
-0.2294241786,
0.07900922,
-0.2089560777,
0.3162477016,
-0.4354418516,
0.37415874,
-0.3560909331,
0.1377861649,
-0.0190098621,
0.449983567,
0.1722176224,
0.8096151352,
0.7357048392,
-0.7974485159,
-0.0389636941,
0.0471852757,
-0.5788201094,
0.356762737,
-0.3261816204,
0.141672805,
-0.3000601232,
0.1435165256,
-1.0215706825,
-0.1463768482,
0.3786878884,
-0.1002620608,
0.6074178219,
-0.3368349969,
-0.6683978438,
-0.0279146302,
-0.0613990277,
0.2066565901,
0.6599785089,
-0.5063257217,
0.0238733534,
0.4577015042,
-0.3684510291,
-0.036556311,
-0.5000383258,
-0.2511128783,
-0.2858965397,
-0.1890585721,
0.0528798699,
-0.1208716035,
-0.0315178446,
-0.3883554041,
-0.185341686,
-0.4113117158,
0.1505313963,
0.3044536114,
-0.0102358134,
-0.2679206729,
0.1532651931,
-0.172635287,
-0.3504849672,
-0.1182683036,
-0.3840610385,
0.5330405235,
-0.1340901554,
-0.0948064178,
-0.571931541,
-0.2119362503,
0.3023787141,
-0.4252165258,
0.7023131847,
1.0477229357,
-0.2729547918,
-0.3258931637,
-0.4803916812,
-0.3275114596,
-0.5461679697,
0.4182259738,
-0.1105155721,
-0.8659576178,
0.4008515775,
-0.4405292571,
0.1191224083,
-0.0305975843,
0.4247134328,
-0.1834713668,
1.1356796026,
0.7051127553,
0.060406398,
0.8650708795,
0.0915238485,
0.2177318335,
-0.596267581,
-0.1731924713,
-0.6825631857,
-0.2010487467,
-0.6557338238,
-0.4487980306,
0.0481850356,
0.5055028796,
-0.5408191681,
0.1472232789,
-0.5696154833,
0.6791813374,
0.7375323176,
0.091773361,
0.3977856636,
0.1296519637,
-0.1559200436,
-0.326630652,
-0.8314707279,
-0.4714058042,
0.7857953906,
0.3428266048,
0.9376170039,
-0.2816559374,
0.6269447803,
-0.2037803084,
0.3468158543,
-0.727811873,
0.3164467812,
-0.3347822428,
-0.4759428203,
-0.2390534133,
-0.3999812007,
-0.9314008951,
0.1812515259,
-0.2958439887,
-0.9064204693,
0.0672284663,
0.4307217002,
-0.6484771371,
0.1421271861,
-0.871968329,
0.8232347369,
-0.179294005,
-0.4329248071,
0.0586528815,
-0.6376292109,
0.1693176329,
-0.3567963541,
0.5400204062,
-0.3017003536,
0.1296138763,
0.7707926035,
-0.3869501352,
1.2153193951,
-0.2457545549,
-0.3751694858,
0.4253748357,
0.0003992146,
0.8316169381,
-0.1328069717,
-0.0275694001,
0.0328245461,
-0.0015633118,
-0.0533200912,
-0.2443227321,
0.5739696622,
-0.7634543777,
-0.245364517,
-0.0574253239,
-0.7011867166,
-0.5802021623,
0.3639648557,
0.3801711798,
0.360912323,
0.0972645208,
0.2130440623,
0.8287725449,
-0.3594583869,
0.2040167898,
0.7754432559,
-0.2199515551,
-0.1977019012,
1.2726941109,
0.2957412601,
0.2587597966,
0.3025816977,
0.2214039266,
-0.4345199466,
-0.8753905296,
0.0073829028,
-0.0523101464,
-0.417833358,
-0.2375664264,
-0.3106601834,
-0.3447933197,
-0.2218307406,
0.162794739,
-0.8105918169,
-0.1743308455,
-0.3933947682,
0.0323956758,
0.3288402855,
0.6802245378,
-0.1785584688,
0.8274313211,
-0.7299212217,
0.4131774008,
0.2107796967,
0.9440221786,
-0.4360028803,
-0.7273144126,
-0.3978934884,
0.3335367739,
-0.2702454329,
-0.4247603118,
0.3286243379,
0.5851272941,
0.3975152671,
0.4761725068,
0.2615197301,
0.9082923532,
-0.3253946602,
0.4755688608,
-0.1873775423,
-0.5439038277,
0.590751946,
-0.4991817772,
0.4846154749,
0.7547284961,
0.0622535236,
-0.1865943223,
-0.7166332603,
-0.4539390206,
-0.9587311745,
0.7504882812,
0.226767838,
-0.1215813309,
0.2923285961,
0.3172341585,
0.2268169522,
0.2402520925,
-0.8456001878,
-0.1062377393,
-0.0227953773,
-0.2343494296,
-0.1477074176,
-0.2199575454,
-0.0560220219,
-0.3747177124,
0.8500261903,
0.029172577,
-0.1855456233,
-0.246966958,
-0.0876078084,
-0.3077660203,
0.2686253786,
0.3555246592,
0.3366346955,
-0.3765606284,
0.222841531,
0.1092068031,
-0.5883051157,
-0.0798518956,
0.2776749134,
-0.4052406549,
-0.1543276161,
0.1152409911,
0.9862686992,
0.4683372676,
-0.4959038794,
0.2431288809,
-0.1222278997,
-0.0532976575,
-0.1151337028,
0.3280494213,
0.0066204462,
0.1684805006,
-0.1984066218,
0.3349235058,
-0.139863506,
-0.1666052639,
0.3073964417,
0.37624982,
-0.6966776252,
-0.4202944636,
0.7851244807,
0.2726455331,
-0.2537960112,
0.4704737663,
-0.3128640354,
-0.3067013025,
0.1761695445,
0.514995873,
0.6640381813,
-0.0887899399,
0.0037590619,
0.329667151,
0.4524277747,
-0.4247703254,
0.2800890803,
-0.1824384034,
-0.7904698849,
-0.7716492414,
-0.930136919,
-0.3040801883,
0.6087990403,
-0.6297869682,
0.4761702418,
-0.4994269311,
-0.1197935343,
-0.1336761564,
0.0052276193,
-0.6282390952,
0.2998201251,
0.4183107913,
0.533190608,
-0.6630351543,
1.2006326914,
0.6401251554,
-0.1599548161,
-0.8420629501,
-0.0339933038,
-0.0896332487,
-0.6894584298,
0.3671807349,
0.2294315398,
-0.1166170165,
0.3069277704,
-0.6741210222,
-0.8493895531,
0.5441864729,
0.7084882855,
-0.934363842,
0.2733657956,
0.1979558915,
0.7608349919,
0.101764448,
-0.0559179634,
0.6469291449,
0.5259187818,
0.0814583302,
-1.0597631931,
-0.2456469983,
0.0249661449,
-0.3619954884,
0.2483644634,
-0.6878783703,
0.6325615644,
-0.046687156,
-0.2358236164,
0.0685190633,
0.5222132206,
0.1174736395,
0.0625735894,
0.4905812442,
0.5346360207,
0.976723969,
-0.2819367051,
0.5768482685,
-0.5882017016,
0.1934739351,
1.6691913605,
0.0749200657,
0.7206520438,
0.4153392315,
-0.1537869275,
0.1023342982,
0.8266902566,
0.116395466,
0.6566660404,
0.2993237972,
-0.1596961617,
-0.603486836,
-0.1888830215,
-0.5030939579,
0.2737756371,
0.5819202065,
-0.1167011261,
-0.4091462493,
-0.143273294,
-0.0785804093,
-0.0028652349,
-0.3574184775,
0.8953407407,
0.289259702,
-0.5769933462,
0.6276527047,
-0.1708987355,
0.8023551702,
-0.7676680684,
0.0397544727,
-0.0660401583,
0.3762595952,
-0.1840957701,
-0.6062809825,
0.3558450937,
-0.1079047844,
0.1386469752,
-0.60922575,
0.8471970558,
-0.7610697746,
-0.2818085551,
0.0553089082,
0.4244566262,
0.2226067781,
-0.2528553903,
-0.5618286729,
-0.0128121907,
0.0256226361,
-0.2637269199,
0.4511885345,
0.6632546186,
0.0070368256,
0.8955889344,
0.6980912089,
0.3146309853,
0.2677357793,
0.256349206,
0.8146842122,
-0.2914068699,
-0.539000392,
-0.7624443173,
0.2427151352,
0.2163849026,
-0.5066922307,
0.6345620155,
0.484485358,
0.9000360966,
0.0911388621,
0.673705101,
0.31001091,
0.8126455545,
-0.5989924073,
0.7190758586,
-0.1869363785,
0.6283511519,
-0.2241054624,
-0.8980382681,
-0.5589886308,
0.873513341,
-0.2593359947,
-0.0295375753,
0.179934755,
1.1450195312,
-0.1649096161,
0.0784105211,
0.2789630592,
0.5184002519,
0.2325330675,
0.2156510651,
0.942381084,
-0.1040957719,
0.8488624096,
-0.4729252756,
0.0697406754,
0.1087419167,
-0.9289849997,
-0.8907437921,
-0.3884264827,
-0.6558337808,
-0.1175410226,
0.1893043667,
0.8685600162,
0.9375943542,
-1.1515016556,
0.0722150281,
-0.4302513003,
-0.1319519579,
-0.0967833176,
-0.195391953,
0.2395830303,
-0.8584449887,
-0.7189010382,
0.3611608744,
0.0755857825,
0.3579405844,
-0.064724952,
-0.1335208863,
0.0122401742,
-0.1738379747,
0.4436836541,
0.2748992741,
-0.3022950292,
-0.2811851799,
-0.6347026229,
-0.0581246093,
0.1492765397,
0.6748432517,
-0.8177184463,
0.5735405684,
0.3133224845,
0.3293948174,
0.4656160772,
0.1130976081,
0.6242744327,
-1.0938683748,
0.5935313702,
0.2334295809,
0.0550012253,
0.3534043431,
-0.0939021483,
0.4604708254,
0.0325768292,
-0.6765616536,
-0.955794692,
0.0957551673,
-0.7965348959,
-0.1581090242,
1.3938963413,
-0.0985013321,
0.17169182,
-0.565043807,
-0.6224524975,
0.5650882125,
-0.4057208896,
0.8131455183,
0.7318868041,
-0.0378068015,
-0.1396656632,
-0.7446705699,
1.036362052,
0.3749686182,
-0.5913924575,
0.1963528842,
0.3343160152,
0.2892712057,
-0.184960857,
0.5345387459,
-0.010950339,
-0.2629267275,
-0.1153938025,
-0.2066849619,
-0.1874406636,
-0.248760581,
-0.2052504122,
-0.0018023982,
0.5557851195,
-0.2507705986
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04917v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04917v2
|
Adapting Fake News Detection to the Era of Large Language Models
| 2023-11-02T08:39:45 | 2024-04-13T13:52:01 |
Jinyan Su, Claire Cardie, Preslav Nakov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In the age of large language models (LLMs) and the widespread adoption of
AI-driven content creation, the landscape of information dissemination has
witnessed a paradigm shift. With the proliferation of both human-written and
machine-generated real and fake news, robustly and effectively discerning the
veracity of news articles has become an intricate challenge. While substantial
research has been dedicated to fake news detection, this either assumes that
all news articles are human-written or abruptly assumes that all
machine-generated news are fake. Thus, a significant gap exists in
understanding the interplay between machine-(paraphrased) real news,
machine-generated fake news, human-written fake news, and human-written real
news. In this paper, we study this gap by conducting a comprehensive evaluation
of fake news detectors trained in various scenarios. Our primary objectives
revolve around the following pivotal question: How to adapt fake news detectors
to the era of LLMs? Our experiments reveal an interesting pattern that
detectors trained exclusively on human-written articles can indeed perform well
at detecting machine-generated fake news, but not vice versa. Moreover, due to
the bias of detectors against machine-generated texts \cite{su2023fake}, they
should be trained on datasets with a lower machine-generated news ratio than
the test set. Building on our findings, we provide a practical strategy for the
development of robust fake news detectors.
|
[
-0.3451159298,
-0.8890818954,
0.9963201284,
0.1071392074,
-0.2146789432,
0.0609907284,
-0.1267175525,
-0.5004171133,
0.1698314399,
0.3674061894,
-0.3913391829,
-0.2926258147,
-0.503152132,
0.1977500767,
-0.5820262432,
0.8819037676,
-0.0727686733,
0.0893629789,
-0.2747153938,
-0.0834800303,
-0.1574368179,
-0.586779952,
-0.3792248964,
-0.2358655185,
0.4239173532,
0.0680459887,
0.5404539108,
0.7989835739,
0.0207118709,
0.1535382122,
0.1600168943,
0.3886270821,
-0.3504775167,
-0.1386688799,
-0.2840294838,
-0.5432668328,
-0.2489463836,
0.0905051976,
0.7915183902,
0.2965371609,
0.0997585058,
0.15792346,
-0.0048450283,
0.4564986527,
-0.4894576967,
-0.1915127635,
-0.9030468464,
0.0021924251,
-0.2821790576,
-0.4792544246,
-0.6898825765,
-0.0860693604,
-0.3377994299,
-0.586186409,
0.3269401491,
0.1294685453,
0.8558074832,
0.0314960144,
-0.4785252512,
-0.5105998516,
-0.8056515455,
0.646479249,
-0.7181205153,
0.4241263568,
0.3107879758,
0.2538348734,
-0.2662293315,
-0.5223893523,
-0.8438305855,
-0.3579299748,
0.1990566105,
-0.0541527644,
-0.3914077878,
-0.3567935824,
0.2378214598,
0.1333536506,
-0.875669837,
0.2161310166,
-0.0292751975,
-0.475977093,
0.5596503019,
-0.0968505144,
0.3640074134,
0.0452555791,
-0.1606654674,
-0.0084772334,
-0.7316156626,
-0.553809464,
0.7046597004,
0.1201173365,
-0.0493488684,
0.3636499047,
-0.2149981856,
0.6832277179,
0.1894254237,
-0.3234008849,
0.1214862615,
-0.2357401997,
-0.1250078976,
0.1022862792,
0.6639016271,
0.1373544782,
0.3599520326,
0.0158010591,
-0.381349802,
0.3090003729,
0.4848757386,
-0.394541651,
-0.1331412643,
-0.2638001144,
-0.5558337569,
-0.6611876488,
0.2056968957,
-0.4365420043,
-0.5573968887,
-0.3845728338,
0.7523368001,
-0.0711956769,
-0.2246230096,
0.2149640471,
-0.1647480875,
0.2600026131,
0.2672049105,
-0.3064888418,
0.1147108525,
0.5818077922,
0.6292021275,
0.1593005955,
-0.3011501431,
-0.7156493068,
0.1439379305,
-0.5433293581,
0.9355127811,
-0.2621367574,
0.1436325461,
0.063053064,
-0.0625764057,
0.0183480661,
-0.5617545843,
0.780244112,
-0.7885205746,
0.3397634029,
-0.2425660342,
-0.6649634242,
0.0759070665,
0.3932829499,
-0.6074348688,
0.7125132084,
0.0025384037,
-0.8513124585,
0.4019060731,
-0.3382769823,
-0.6326801777,
-0.2384857535,
0.16662848,
-0.607762754,
0.17745772,
0.4812609255,
0.3948355019,
0.0403197482,
0.3634190261,
-0.4020549357,
-0.4604652524,
0.4776211977,
-0.8838077188,
0.5353198051,
0.2181415707,
-0.3204269111,
-0.0620547011,
-0.6194178462,
-0.4610445797,
0.1233868673,
-0.408729434,
-0.4078039825,
0.0830357671,
-0.0299985409,
0.2372645885,
0.121226944,
-0.4122405052,
0.0460284725,
-0.1714103073,
0.3007325232,
0.8492398858,
-0.010864567,
0.5149032474,
-0.5208694339,
0.2279662639,
0.1209342703,
0.132188037,
-0.3627930284,
-0.1161069125,
-0.8625570536,
-0.2444706708,
0.3221362233,
0.5337302089,
-1.0358735323,
0.6828969121,
-0.2687867582,
-0.4020705521,
-0.5042049289,
0.1847870052,
0.2826661766,
0.4362039566,
0.2870896459,
0.0953531638,
-0.6837981343,
-0.7437048554,
-1.0385380983,
-0.2626679242,
-0.0873758346,
-0.2264732271,
0.5395984054,
-0.1544229835,
0.7520515919,
-0.1780693531,
-0.0535114445,
-0.3128622174,
0.0696615204,
0.1190360188,
0.2028708458,
0.5353559256,
-0.8475833535,
-0.5410510898,
-0.1209057271,
-0.7969927192,
-0.2740767598,
-0.5032253265,
0.1086456701,
0.521545589,
0.5839340091,
-0.7448994517,
0.5303239226,
0.698620975,
-0.2851850092,
0.8020436764,
-0.0870513394,
0.0170167852,
-1.0111948252,
-0.1229486689,
0.1881163716,
-0.7117930055,
-0.7048084736,
-0.0886460245,
0.1622774303,
0.1200253293,
-0.3660485446,
0.6675348282,
-0.623165369,
-0.276304543,
-0.585529089,
0.009057207,
0.1584081352,
0.0962465778,
-0.1453772038,
0.6480103731,
0.3355926275,
-0.5983672738,
0.2635405362,
-0.248878479,
-0.5572826862,
0.6971247196,
-0.4916283488,
0.1252201796,
-0.2611196935,
0.8210590482,
-0.6367670894,
-0.4399427176,
0.4235459268,
-0.6710393429,
0.0534703471,
-0.1375224739,
-1.0208922625,
-0.3516297638,
-0.3641981781,
0.0772819668,
0.4430959225,
-0.6949806213,
0.5671041012,
0.1591028273,
0.2488068044,
-0.3124281764,
-0.6534286737,
0.4746312201,
-0.3004654944,
-0.6106045246,
0.1557826102,
-0.09144786,
-0.3268454969,
0.0858921334,
-0.2850873172,
-0.1067711189,
0.0425698347,
-0.0324230008,
0.160935387,
-0.396239996,
0.1017114073,
0.0911391452,
0.1045058891,
-0.0188999865,
-0.4317972064,
0.5240299702,
0.0964456946,
-0.5112496018,
-0.6995049715,
-0.0397287607,
0.7712293863,
-0.0444190763,
1.0032097101,
0.8447777629,
-0.6068151593,
-0.4415743649,
-0.7956770062,
-0.276412487,
-0.4551240504,
0.2376217693,
-0.2737496197,
-0.7028645277,
0.2167770565,
0.2308779508,
-0.1999982595,
0.3520570993,
0.5860530734,
-0.031414263,
1.0535289049,
0.602807343,
-0.1943508536,
0.4277315438,
0.3242038488,
0.3724043965,
-0.4166187644,
0.1211005822,
-0.2794707119,
-0.1019895449,
-0.3642003834,
-0.4357941151,
0.2807697654,
0.0289496463,
-0.0050060106,
0.3278825879,
-0.1856970191,
0.5239413977,
0.4763158262,
0.1811125427,
0.4872934818,
0.233213231,
0.4131598473,
0.0545822345,
-0.7029573917,
-0.6613065004,
1.0659365654,
0.5204925537,
0.5321764946,
-0.0623763837,
0.4202540219,
0.8039208055,
0.5080834627,
-0.5447893739,
0.358953625,
-0.1888730675,
-0.5252246857,
0.0130847413,
-0.3734511733,
-0.5974404216,
0.1685393006,
-0.240976274,
-0.1045993865,
0.0387189351,
0.2744715512,
0.0389548317,
0.4999924004,
-0.5338816643,
0.6777976155,
-0.1546730101,
-0.0389983281,
-0.2804319561,
-0.3818364143,
0.3974970281,
-0.366337657,
0.5284896493,
-0.132090956,
0.0015122043,
0.4554617107,
-0.0070659425,
0.8853178024,
-0.0832654536,
-0.1188293695,
0.3594222367,
0.2613494992,
0.7336663008,
0.0961894244,
-0.0119031882,
0.0424423739,
-0.3110745549,
-0.588193953,
-0.2388963699,
0.7116937041,
-0.6512928009,
-0.4955394566,
-0.4952568114,
-0.656113863,
-0.1126472503,
0.137779057,
0.4394462407,
0.2100692689,
-0.442803055,
-0.0293783341,
0.886175096,
-0.3526217043,
0.2362332195,
0.7275232077,
-0.0625937507,
-0.0918970853,
0.9418197274,
0.0286617782,
0.1114864275,
0.3859368563,
0.2421316057,
-0.3364336491,
-0.4309202135,
-0.611936152,
0.3919931054,
-0.5994090438,
-0.1048129797,
-0.6079771519,
-0.3457098603,
-0.6056231856,
-0.2729067206,
-0.286121875,
-0.0218172614,
-0.5859875083,
0.0828961059,
0.0891994461,
0.5363940597,
-0.2212752551,
0.2844023407,
-0.7561271787,
0.6163961887,
0.2901238799,
-0.0815570354,
-0.1523049176,
-0.9036461711,
-0.1897813976,
0.3092356026,
-0.0823190138,
-0.8565296531,
0.3912685215,
0.0084923012,
0.4457751811,
0.3178277016,
0.2034076005,
0.4107382596,
-0.4882162511,
0.6085572839,
0.0093549937,
-1.0036716461,
0.3357997835,
-0.7254425883,
0.0618902631,
0.1068055183,
0.3043891788,
-0.5494342446,
-0.3407102525,
-0.5214045048,
-0.3766358197,
0.439776659,
0.0981454849,
0.3920236826,
0.0482126214,
0.2806220949,
0.1821727753,
0.1820694357,
-1.0996595621,
0.1815798134,
-0.2008378506,
-0.3490251303,
0.1132831275,
-0.2317186743,
-0.0862821043,
0.0059398487,
0.573091507,
-0.1059822813,
0.2331047505,
0.1039348394,
-0.5672575831,
-0.0427116901,
0.1770269871,
0.7290572524,
0.7339328527,
0.1534395218,
0.3415015638,
-0.0594685376,
-0.2930915356,
0.074487187,
-0.0903626233,
-0.3933057189,
0.2681770623,
0.6446757913,
0.9311540723,
-0.3288494647,
-0.7563788891,
0.7525641918,
0.2282036543,
-0.2420968562,
-0.4825715125,
0.0254175067,
-0.0097989505,
0.2726646364,
0.5795273781,
0.1039041504,
-0.0327485502,
-0.9052670598,
0.2203284204,
0.4069819152,
-0.216634959,
-0.5395904183,
0.5828929543,
0.0967897847,
-0.2778067887,
0.4064960182,
-0.3099002242,
-0.6675082445,
0.5740531683,
0.7636373043,
0.6969767809,
-0.1171063632,
0.4135740697,
-0.0181312952,
0.6320544481,
-0.4958281219,
-0.1461553425,
0.252520293,
-0.9080907106,
-0.4839518964,
-0.6908255816,
0.0317637734,
0.4806656539,
-0.3726620376,
0.3594262302,
-0.3430021107,
0.1671577096,
0.0045902547,
-0.2054252774,
-0.3499050736,
0.0647601038,
0.444049418,
0.9996258616,
-1.2072167397,
0.7393222451,
0.6509044766,
0.0256077908,
-0.2241503894,
0.6829825044,
0.2287848145,
-0.8966842294,
0.1935897619,
0.2459817678,
0.171003595,
-0.0796858966,
-0.7530949712,
-0.4900704324,
0.7230603695,
0.4703755379,
-0.614559114,
0.0055266004,
0.2344080508,
0.681085825,
-0.3732402027,
-0.361199975,
0.3819301724,
0.60367769,
-0.3656870127,
-0.8472329378,
0.0351836421,
0.1315728575,
-0.0462960191,
0.0882141143,
-0.5077977777,
0.7956537008,
0.1654831916,
-0.1352390051,
0.187380746,
0.6770867109,
0.3876050413,
0.7785469294,
0.5617057085,
0.5797553062,
0.4453836679,
0.0654084682,
1.0132651329,
-0.0991662815,
0.1057948172,
0.8151472211,
-0.4011274278,
0.5457633734,
0.2649246752,
0.0138867563,
0.4328312576,
0.5463384986,
-0.1758996248,
0.2462144792,
0.2072315216,
-0.4333188832,
-0.451402992,
-0.0900658369,
-0.1413134634,
0.3039897382,
0.4080619216,
-0.4579682648,
-0.1419414282,
0.2974621058,
0.327888906,
0.434369415,
-0.4250859916,
0.3711037338,
0.0107867057,
-0.5294790864,
0.4491155446,
0.3463174403,
0.7987608314,
-0.3689225316,
0.0842106715,
-0.2094918936,
0.2185474038,
-0.192097351,
-0.7497028112,
0.2967694104,
0.1700932682,
-0.3409143686,
-0.1663306057,
1.1855535507,
-0.3245130181,
-0.4550022781,
0.123168543,
0.5838874578,
0.0746403411,
-0.5219582319,
-0.5144167542,
0.4946599305,
-0.0751286894,
-0.2698181868,
0.5149290562,
0.3853330016,
-0.2045434266,
0.5039640665,
0.9777632356,
0.0633812621,
0.217190668,
-0.0570505969,
0.7606412172,
-0.3975748122,
-0.3557454944,
-0.8647531867,
0.1442495137,
-0.0987906829,
0.030255219,
0.9497656226,
0.5562689304,
0.7890201807,
-0.2546389103,
0.9862533212,
0.0834933296,
0.6175885201,
-0.6082812548,
0.7633010745,
-0.5721003413,
0.2986388206,
-0.0126406858,
-1.0840946436,
-0.264890641,
0.3691230416,
-0.1227646768,
-0.066016458,
0.4007968307,
0.8018668294,
-0.2353060842,
-0.370438844,
0.3452009559,
0.4481288791,
0.3013706207,
0.3242546916,
1.0121502876,
-0.4102675319,
0.7146182656,
0.0058835601,
-0.036033839,
-0.4451910853,
-0.9398191571,
-0.9786140919,
-0.389315486,
-0.3169992268,
-0.5388786793,
0.4007730186,
0.3977710009,
0.5761672258,
-0.4987258613,
0.1105082408,
-0.2182317078,
0.0873739943,
-0.0751607046,
-0.2865577638,
0.3058502972,
-0.0769567937,
-0.6977676153,
0.5467187762,
0.1684998125,
0.0942385569,
-0.3706762493,
-0.1216544434,
-0.1173576564,
0.4850207269,
0.6686007977,
0.4259438813,
-0.6314821839,
-0.4317497313,
0.1128830016,
-0.1877132356,
-0.1791276336,
0.7455535531,
-0.8911011219,
0.1085958108,
0.4563444555,
0.5260189176,
0.3572910428,
-0.019874189,
0.4892442226,
-0.7895627022,
0.2437263131,
0.1840763092,
0.0734142959,
0.5123676062,
-0.3556330502,
0.1702040434,
0.6473153234,
-0.5432635546,
-1.2879974842,
0.3814391494,
-0.671285212,
-0.567178607,
1.2395013571,
0.1715526879,
-0.1655495316,
-0.2077161819,
0.0192939248,
0.368034631,
-0.1146234274,
0.8517742157,
0.6265664101,
0.1730867326,
-0.0673024878,
-0.7127687931,
0.3374438584,
0.12846753,
-0.7635217309,
-0.1049732417,
0.575476408,
0.5406317711,
-0.0391711369,
0.5664723516,
0.0457896255,
0.432513684,
0.0248292033,
-0.1273002028,
0.0320617706,
-0.4392579496,
-0.2734112144,
-0.2579118311,
-0.0357807763,
-0.0161394812
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01070v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01070v3
|
Multilingual DistilWhisper: Efficient Distillation of Multi-task Speech Models via Language-Specific Experts
| 2023-11-02T08:37:30 | 2024-03-12T14:50:30 |
Thomas Palmeira Ferraz, Marcely Zanon Boito, Caroline Brun, Vassilina Nikoulina
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Whisper is a multitask and multilingual speech model covering 99 languages.
It yields commendable automatic speech recognition (ASR) results in a subset of
its covered languages, but the model still underperforms on a non-negligible
number of under-represented languages, a problem exacerbated in smaller model
versions. In this work, we propose DistilWhisper, an approach able to bridge
the performance gap in ASR for these languages while retaining the advantages
of multitask and multilingual capabilities. Our approach involves two key
strategies: lightweight modular ASR fine-tuning of whisper-small using
language-specific experts, and knowledge distillation from whisper-large-v2.
This dual approach allows us to effectively boost ASR performance while keeping
the robustness inherited from the multitask and multilingual pre-training.
Results demonstrate that our approach is more effective than standard
fine-tuning or LoRA adapters, boosting performance in the targeted languages
for both in- and out-of-domain test sets, while introducing only a negligible
parameter overhead at inference.
|
[
-0.2760799229,
-0.3196941912,
0.2103061676,
0.3262298703,
-0.1446592063,
0.4496594071,
-0.5291875601,
-0.6426458359,
-0.0027071014,
0.1499986053,
-0.4948996305,
-0.1466710269,
-0.8112397194,
0.0613752343,
-0.266467005,
0.7962473035,
0.0796582401,
0.0908622146,
0.0840658918,
-0.2347609103,
-0.3997911811,
-0.4313340187,
-0.6778527498,
-0.595995307,
0.4853878617,
0.3469128907,
0.2657318115,
0.3724152148,
0.1652091295,
0.4483076632,
-0.2145257592,
0.2611310184,
-0.2093914747,
0.1746872663,
-0.0261731409,
-0.2743400037,
-0.3550014496,
-0.142578423,
0.2592345476,
0.5665295124,
-0.4602558017,
0.3005459309,
0.5005887747,
0.681840837,
-0.7052762508,
0.3869712949,
-0.9561632872,
-0.2344314605,
-0.4987120926,
0.0695117638,
-0.2522837818,
-0.1408697218,
0.4297338426,
-0.5659815073,
0.3242374659,
-0.1786139011,
0.3567225337,
0.6072994471,
-0.1882413924,
-0.3784452081,
-0.7744663954,
0.9360926151,
-0.8075973988,
0.4492569268,
0.4479003251,
0.5989369154,
0.2039135247,
-0.6062271595,
-0.5784807205,
-0.0921694487,
-0.076658912,
0.0068984367,
-0.4400118887,
-0.0402064025,
0.0471908376,
0.3102322817,
-0.3822546899,
0.0931413323,
-0.4000481367,
-0.3948339224,
0.6503491998,
-0.107535705,
-0.0701890886,
0.1407421827,
-0.0152298277,
0.0264324751,
-0.2766994536,
0.2000630945,
0.3509265482,
0.6387286782,
0.064859122,
0.2322264016,
-0.2871967554,
0.6600096226,
0.3414678872,
-0.6865736246,
0.3169528246,
-0.2057533562,
0.1571555436,
0.4347802997,
0.705196619,
-0.0123870075,
0.2981540561,
-0.072952047,
-0.1991325617,
0.0823854581,
-0.0363732055,
-0.6935847402,
-0.5814957619,
0.0955061316,
-0.3166469336,
-0.0637971163,
-0.3072304726,
-0.5367497206,
-0.3110355139,
-0.4032698274,
0.5523639917,
-0.4537843466,
-0.6139756441,
0.1498318613,
-0.416449666,
-0.2883813083,
0.2551300526,
-0.9145843387,
0.5164010525,
0.5313715935,
0.7898118496,
-0.2173183709,
-0.5696392655,
-0.7566044927,
0.2885894775,
0.0841919482,
0.6808509827,
-0.4514227211,
-0.446349442,
-0.1988328397,
-0.3097992539,
-0.239715904,
-0.7940756083,
0.3623925447,
-0.2251699716,
-0.0551386438,
-0.2373473346,
-0.3930046558,
-0.2748656571,
-0.0393663011,
-0.555918932,
1.0778551102,
-0.2807499766,
-0.6859595776,
0.4622839093,
-0.6285197139,
-0.6712522507,
0.06578812,
-0.1088502556,
-0.1744177639,
0.3133062124,
0.4602245688,
0.4666394591,
-0.2313550115,
0.2561417222,
0.2017674744,
-0.1752760112,
-0.0081277825,
-0.6857974529,
0.613268733,
0.2631226778,
-0.3401757479,
0.1975934505,
-0.8418746591,
0.1379493624,
-0.2122356892,
-0.4704551697,
-0.5563220978,
0.1843834966,
0.3914654553,
0.1824408919,
0.3553393781,
-0.6506089568,
-0.1283120513,
-0.3325929642,
0.6841188669,
0.3960934281,
-0.3555904031,
0.2764185667,
-0.2193743885,
0.3422298729,
0.1052333266,
0.0559588969,
-0.0933861583,
-0.4889862835,
-0.9413837194,
-0.6500711441,
0.3559677601,
0.5970974565,
-0.8915967941,
0.3153065443,
-0.1274706572,
-0.7535597086,
-1.0333902836,
0.3007774353,
0.8023884296,
0.5273157358,
0.5357402563,
0.0668070465,
-0.4544064999,
-0.8701349497,
-0.3577225208,
-0.2043970525,
-0.0924597681,
-0.020345103,
0.1577834487,
-0.0834021568,
0.7557238936,
-0.6798493862,
-0.5097578168,
-0.4963329136,
0.1834996343,
0.2639694214,
0.4006233811,
0.3961037993,
-0.8331502676,
-1.0345045328,
0.2150020897,
-0.3779314458,
-0.1211911738,
0.4133557975,
0.3951573372,
0.2441203296,
0.4718447626,
-0.3566665053,
0.0992738307,
0.6709058881,
0.0000855364,
0.5193904638,
-0.3512545228,
0.1394484937,
-1.1005632877,
0.0758672431,
-0.046566315,
-0.3006951511,
-0.9522974491,
-0.0663649887,
0.149058193,
-0.1722829044,
-0.4982074499,
0.4401729107,
-0.5281953216,
0.4621045887,
-0.3887571692,
-0.1333644688,
-0.00565584,
0.3402605057,
0.2012890726,
0.7674581409,
0.787927866,
-0.5743633509,
0.2850143909,
0.2004499733,
-0.3547500968,
0.568341732,
-0.8019916415,
0.2123337388,
0.0962335169,
-0.0215873644,
-0.8457359076,
-0.0301042441,
-0.4164130986,
-0.3967682421,
0.5574313998,
-0.4185691178,
-0.3983642757,
-0.4386563003,
-0.1155066565,
0.1788552701,
0.5392692089,
-0.5739450455,
0.7996448278,
0.638669908,
-0.5172287226,
-0.6883469224,
-0.6276552081,
0.0026741251,
-0.5000252724,
-0.5571203828,
0.2809272408,
-0.0999194086,
-0.3252128661,
-0.3343178034,
-0.3822231293,
-0.3836787939,
-0.0817437917,
0.2272028774,
0.0037095025,
-0.181859225,
-0.0383255407,
0.2022555172,
-0.4779381752,
-0.3356782794,
-0.2240831852,
0.432415694,
-0.1060250103,
-0.3714340925,
-0.6249754429,
0.5608611107,
0.573114872,
-0.5014894009,
0.3268557191,
0.6136675477,
-0.165081799,
-0.3034641147,
-1.0193376541,
-0.1383325309,
-0.5746785402,
0.3705082536,
-0.8291394711,
-0.8717107773,
0.5132838488,
-0.1054540724,
0.1257389039,
0.3001080751,
0.4759756923,
0.0195391532,
0.9020167589,
0.7532069087,
-0.5593239069,
0.2549216151,
-0.0964706391,
0.0447183922,
-0.5714027286,
-0.2385205328,
-0.6816363335,
-0.2797486782,
-0.2881293297,
-0.5189399719,
0.5981609225,
0.0077279881,
0.2200004458,
0.4258320034,
-0.5800504088,
0.5087150335,
0.6939558983,
-0.1004108042,
0.6427155733,
-0.0342970416,
0.0197542012,
-0.2023778558,
-0.795550704,
-0.2927294374,
0.8076848984,
0.2879655063,
0.7890993953,
0.1775945723,
0.6302353144,
0.0873703808,
-0.2825219631,
-0.7312530875,
0.2820065022,
-0.6410367489,
-0.599660635,
-0.4509221911,
-0.2905738354,
-0.5555146337,
0.5355987549,
0.0671375692,
-0.5223433971,
0.1171379685,
0.3957476616,
-0.4260390699,
0.0440812111,
-0.8698529005,
0.5788002014,
-0.0696532726,
0.0334447585,
-0.4852772653,
-0.6049711704,
0.0435839109,
-0.3923538029,
0.2456427962,
-0.2944817841,
0.1455269754,
0.6868097782,
-0.4648480117,
0.8008828163,
-0.5696931481,
-0.0492018312,
0.2148782909,
-0.0811199695,
0.5406816602,
-0.0670095533,
-0.2553887367,
0.412108928,
0.1725489497,
-0.1172659844,
-0.3421967924,
0.6873105764,
-0.7147939801,
-0.5179618001,
-0.2346566767,
-0.523583591,
-0.5291105509,
0.1604401022,
0.4229384363,
0.5919063091,
-0.137816757,
0.0129356682,
0.5884626508,
0.0580816194,
0.5840469599,
1.1638592482,
0.1030274779,
-0.1941132396,
1.0472831726,
0.3170697093,
0.178974852,
0.3936848342,
0.4618008137,
-0.4616302848,
-0.8415192962,
-0.6201446056,
-0.0961927921,
-0.4611029625,
-0.1263579875,
-0.8167206049,
-0.1832301766,
-0.272785753,
0.037227951,
-0.730483532,
-0.4521859884,
-0.1211820096,
0.1290677935,
0.6477241516,
0.5142905116,
-0.179153949,
0.2187030613,
-0.7666840553,
0.5634590983,
0.5678551197,
0.0860904083,
0.101667136,
-0.7071801424,
-0.2160014957,
0.0263675041,
-0.1148802489,
-0.4335711598,
0.3260728717,
0.9145330191,
0.7121579051,
0.3183493614,
0.2731029391,
1.2748458385,
-1.0959392786,
0.5391379595,
0.3251425922,
-1.1652654409,
0.5970789194,
-0.1701453328,
0.4473336339,
1.0218966007,
0.2754439414,
-0.3906961381,
-0.703279376,
-0.0706188232,
-0.8922170997,
0.5952318907,
0.0234969109,
0.0686999038,
0.2535538077,
-0.0401678421,
0.5379436016,
0.3459592462,
-0.1270478219,
-0.2975217104,
-0.2907636762,
-0.2796293795,
-0.4211283028,
-0.0527742505,
-0.0846287012,
-0.5338174105,
0.5376133323,
-0.2077937722,
-0.3505942523,
-0.0450016074,
-0.3482137918,
0.1370145977,
0.3312791586,
0.3021389842,
0.6609144211,
0.1064907014,
0.2834981978,
0.3550322056,
-0.7217478752,
0.2439970076,
0.5385707617,
0.0594458655,
0.1193830073,
0.4280882478,
0.7372390032,
0.4415517151,
-0.6679216623,
0.3147938251,
-0.0559816472,
-0.1018128172,
-0.3024086058,
0.1920880079,
0.2780613899,
0.5321131945,
0.7074284554,
0.2299063057,
0.5158681273,
-0.382641077,
0.1743243635,
0.2333177626,
-0.4157300591,
-0.4178159833,
0.7198473811,
0.5317422152,
-0.1759476215,
0.3331923783,
-0.0920051485,
-0.4928592741,
0.2438292056,
0.3447347879,
0.7684949636,
-0.6490272284,
-0.0581571572,
0.1543260217,
0.0924528092,
-0.281381011,
0.2705666423,
-0.237331152,
-0.5067449212,
-0.5563621521,
-0.7005860209,
-0.3536412716,
-0.0287238844,
-0.9390087128,
0.1025117114,
0.0972082093,
-0.1402521133,
0.5047883987,
0.0653046519,
-0.5587491989,
-0.1214209348,
0.1821104884,
0.9401667118,
-0.7669822574,
1.2100672722,
0.5177616477,
0.0002930691,
-0.7464472055,
0.0355270393,
0.287474364,
-0.7111214399,
0.5079587102,
0.1173551083,
-0.441523999,
0.0987874717,
0.2232473493,
-0.7559322119,
0.9589506388,
0.4278476238,
-1.0100725889,
0.1358860135,
-0.0107140522,
0.5205315948,
-0.0105315764,
0.0181716345,
0.6775808334,
0.3860275447,
0.2018099874,
-1.8155953884,
-0.3103245795,
-0.2850350738,
0.0019635882,
0.2223606259,
-0.5739530325,
0.7414326668,
-0.2528938651,
-0.0046750791,
-0.0732594877,
0.4952727556,
0.317207545,
0.3689274788,
0.7130230665,
0.2875069082,
0.8952179551,
0.0222646985,
0.5673952103,
-0.2958602011,
0.0217736699,
1.3975788355,
-0.5331917405,
1.1858249903,
0.5374536514,
-0.4076248407,
0.1812215149,
0.0910570174,
0.2251640856,
0.898325026,
0.0471371375,
-0.4360784292,
-0.0725543946,
-0.0239843298,
-0.453191936,
0.7752578259,
0.2152012438,
0.1547257155,
-0.1936776042,
0.283264339,
0.0867018402,
0.241099596,
-0.319748044,
1.1343449354,
0.0923473388,
-0.452735126,
0.6154308319,
-0.0845922083,
1.2416151762,
-0.906963706,
0.227368325,
0.1993053854,
0.5013258457,
-0.1349520832,
-0.4292338192,
0.5604432225,
0.1753821969,
-0.4623776674,
-0.318836689,
0.7753349543,
-0.7452213764,
-0.7414627671,
0.4444394112,
0.653012991,
0.158496663,
-0.5123565197,
-0.6387044787,
0.1667458415,
-0.0497215614,
0.0064647449,
0.3168424666,
0.3936879635,
0.227350533,
0.7149448991,
0.565323472,
0.3012199104,
0.1391166449,
0.2195388228,
0.9632049799,
-0.2236459255,
-0.6420171261,
-0.9197175503,
0.6497051716,
-0.0756457001,
-0.2929883897,
0.9804878235,
0.6592208147,
0.6561653018,
-0.1681848615,
0.9559913874,
0.0244368985,
0.9530781507,
-0.3249751031,
1.1502583027,
-0.496411413,
-0.0387549959,
-0.3959614336,
-0.6393682957,
0.1165820584,
0.6436660886,
-0.0429399684,
-0.2085387409,
0.3565097451,
0.5465781689,
-0.1161539927,
-0.0802516788,
0.4747137129,
0.1211813241,
0.223662287,
0.4782753289,
0.7387173176,
-0.2698292434,
0.5780416131,
-0.3756403029,
-0.3317080736,
-0.0084308106,
-0.7465647459,
-0.9881997108,
-0.8346185088,
-0.4089022577,
0.2648715675,
0.0454609543,
0.715062499,
1.0953669548,
-0.9277496338,
-0.4369173646,
0.3719412088,
-0.2411077917,
-0.453039825,
-0.1103291139,
0.2203535438,
-0.2429511547,
-0.8171753883,
0.8218590021,
0.2073099166,
-0.2417998612,
-0.2456441224,
-0.1009431481,
0.2198035866,
-0.0789776146,
0.7560756207,
0.0385517366,
-0.8545020819,
0.0760685652,
-0.165146023,
0.4002295732,
-0.1756910086,
0.8280640244,
-0.7410084009,
0.6089644432,
0.2151399851,
0.2263084501,
0.6472027302,
-0.2403611988,
0.5104168057,
-0.9645079374,
0.579069078,
0.2818497419,
0.3187765181,
0.3749057651,
-0.0781611279,
0.2089784443,
-0.089388147,
-0.3819100261,
-0.9607046247,
0.1428111047,
-0.7554802299,
-0.2651133537,
1.03087008,
-0.2248146683,
0.3494650126,
-0.664875865,
-0.2981918454,
0.0289400462,
-0.6439890862,
0.7022013664,
0.6510087848,
-0.0670342594,
-0.1227549613,
-0.6201623678,
0.6594418287,
-0.0955428556,
-0.4704610705,
0.305165112,
0.2223690301,
0.5498583913,
0.3453891575,
0.8059518337,
0.1121188551,
-0.0202203393,
0.1126208305,
0.0173929408,
-0.3691254258,
-0.4357725978,
-0.2573912144,
0.0861588567,
0.3714991212,
-0.3719664812
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01049v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01049v1
|
Multi-dimensional data refining strategy for effective fine-tuning LLMs
| 2023-11-02T07:50:43 | 2023-11-02T07:50:43 |
Thanh Nguyen Ngoc, Quang Nhat Tran, Arthur Tang, Bao Nguyen, Thuy Nguyen, Thanh Pham
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Data is a cornerstone for fine-tuning large language models, yet acquiring
suitable data remains challenging. Challenges encompassed data scarcity,
linguistic diversity, and domain-specific content. This paper presents lessons
learned while crawling and refining data tailored for fine-tuning Vietnamese
language models. Crafting such a dataset, while accounting for linguistic
intricacies and striking a balance between inclusivity and accuracy, demands
meticulous planning. Our paper presents a multidimensional strategy including
leveraging existing datasets in the English language and developing customized
data-crawling scripts with the assistance of generative AI tools. A fine-tuned
LLM model for the Vietnamese language, which was produced using resultant
datasets, demonstrated good performance while generating Vietnamese news
articles from prompts. The study offers practical solutions and guidance for
future fine-tuning models in languages like Vietnamese.
|
[
-0.3078056574,
-0.9677241445,
0.6252970695,
-0.0651637167,
-0.2655350268,
0.3323456049,
-0.4356178641,
0.0229711626,
0.051603958,
0.6432910562,
-0.5889478326,
-0.8126974702,
-0.4843515754,
0.2051392794,
-0.3187359571,
0.9595903754,
-0.0617825724,
-0.1808400452,
-0.106738247,
-0.2400287539,
-0.4512417316,
-0.2468380779,
-0.8090654016,
-0.0966303796,
0.6355214715,
0.9674755931,
0.6682225466,
1.1582043171,
0.3720870018,
0.2727571726,
0.1724892855,
0.9016865492,
-0.9626845717,
0.2271137685,
-0.1739042103,
-0.597589314,
-0.2961173952,
0.0002456119,
0.4960633814,
0.6088107228,
-0.0882352293,
0.1130654439,
-0.02280242,
0.8282378316,
-0.2441684455,
0.1489048749,
-1.0032975674,
-0.3724821806,
-0.358743161,
-0.3938654065,
-0.1288677603,
-0.4444995522,
-0.1118462011,
-0.4867687821,
0.291669488,
-0.212541759,
1.0439947844,
0.4348112643,
-0.5313055515,
-0.2576643229,
-0.7081537247,
0.8957254887,
-0.569365859,
0.4072732627,
0.5139486194,
0.161091283,
0.0169391651,
-0.4552681744,
-0.354423821,
-0.2411888987,
0.1597244591,
-0.1086265445,
0.0130032776,
-0.3000766039,
0.0379763506,
0.3428813219,
-0.5555430651,
0.4590261877,
-0.5647306442,
0.0797862187,
0.8533983827,
0.237303704,
0.0421033204,
-0.1490015686,
-0.2586363852,
-0.0177905317,
-0.8409231901,
-0.172824204,
0.8201016784,
0.8478245139,
-0.175470084,
0.8764899969,
-0.6044588089,
0.699303627,
-0.1460923553,
-0.3755809665,
0.2928191125,
-0.524758637,
0.0366947092,
-0.329226315,
0.2732492685,
0.6057966352,
0.6776456237,
-0.2946175635,
-0.5589770079,
0.0152252065,
0.4919124246,
-0.4127939939,
-0.2475474775,
0.4775849879,
-0.4428413212,
-0.177183792,
0.2249462456,
-0.9071696997,
-0.2402161509,
-0.9802719355,
0.2186130583,
-0.5948808789,
-0.2380743325,
0.2875087261,
-0.1238377839,
0.1201772615,
0.3157365322,
-0.5814923644,
-0.0928517729,
0.8064705133,
1.0002293587,
-0.4231342077,
-0.3334158957,
-0.646913588,
0.3366906941,
-0.2989781499,
0.9327501655,
-0.6888737679,
-0.2663103342,
0.2130712867,
-0.0634608418,
0.0026927446,
-0.9131538272,
0.4874020219,
-0.3932487667,
-0.0753325596,
0.1942235231,
-0.7281127572,
-0.2183380872,
0.3818995059,
-0.804283917,
0.8014191985,
0.3821382523,
-0.4069479406,
0.3058320284,
-0.32292068,
-0.5406084061,
-0.1648651212,
-0.069663465,
-0.4891735315,
0.3229832351,
0.4466374815,
0.5313454866,
-0.0633230433,
0.036187049,
-0.2298318148,
-0.2516361773,
-0.1254739165,
-0.2682618201,
0.374943465,
0.4248743653,
0.1108554676,
0.0721914247,
-1.2531392574,
0.0963836312,
-0.0073404885,
-0.7548633814,
-0.3188256621,
0.035835553,
0.2353251427,
0.0513000078,
0.3463058174,
-0.1967567354,
0.5389751792,
-0.3547083735,
0.3456920385,
0.6476557851,
0.0007518501,
0.3142992854,
-0.6095483899,
0.6349456906,
0.1654685587,
-0.1008331999,
-0.424448669,
-0.1850112826,
-1.0142378807,
-0.373234868,
0.2238778025,
0.4906467795,
-0.9060283899,
0.3322985172,
-0.3923141956,
-0.7181226015,
-1.1850708723,
0.3164149821,
-0.0739382505,
0.319647789,
0.4250285923,
-0.0829184204,
-0.5915873051,
-0.8480839729,
-0.3116560578,
0.2381409258,
-0.0957331955,
0.2869231701,
0.067433089,
-0.6571418047,
0.8011414409,
-0.5928164721,
-0.4965251982,
-0.2242477536,
0.181802094,
0.3542743325,
0.4296745956,
0.3225776553,
-0.7612900138,
-0.4021595716,
0.2429503649,
-0.3744865954,
-0.1053504646,
-0.2794959843,
0.082463868,
0.3209294081,
0.7571179271,
-0.5455425978,
0.2377793044,
0.4041983485,
0.0416014008,
0.5662879944,
-0.3003164232,
0.0221035033,
-0.9483861923,
-0.1626307815,
0.1189632341,
-0.2752824724,
-0.4848137498,
0.4058997333,
-0.0969357416,
0.1031380296,
-0.4212807119,
0.5188362598,
-0.3528956473,
0.5224304795,
-0.4546153843,
0.0879283026,
-0.1877363026,
0.2590417862,
-0.1682397127,
0.6459183097,
0.5808970928,
-0.8828513622,
0.4669221342,
-0.0563045442,
-0.2638176382,
0.5460647941,
-0.4603486061,
0.1687959433,
-0.3258782625,
-0.2865183651,
-0.8294292688,
-0.1383090466,
-0.3035331666,
-0.1742053479,
0.4312823415,
-0.3014184535,
-0.6425616145,
-0.1723213941,
-0.4414085448,
0.1490419507,
0.1759111583,
-0.4954757988,
0.2998657525,
0.5333707929,
-0.2055793852,
-0.0753605664,
-0.2527530789,
0.1208578944,
-0.7070555687,
-0.5291597247,
0.2476449311,
0.0040535619,
-0.3174513578,
-0.4561705887,
0.0844115689,
0.0689545944,
0.0178716015,
-0.0628863946,
-0.0435782596,
-0.1348193586,
0.0503822863,
-0.0411007479,
-0.3635585308,
-0.2746113241,
-0.4735159278,
0.803807497,
0.0163674504,
-0.2214097232,
-0.2864780426,
0.2227561921,
0.5588612556,
-0.2117336094,
0.3759538829,
0.7545495629,
-0.3154426217,
-0.2523444891,
-0.6644836664,
-0.1739567071,
-0.4512402415,
0.390371114,
-0.5713669062,
-0.8479217887,
0.3778203726,
-0.4007075429,
0.0144952862,
0.320667237,
0.8880065084,
-0.0669766366,
1.1083221436,
0.9850680828,
-0.3394592106,
0.148030296,
-0.3381377459,
0.1732213199,
-0.4852536023,
-0.0834604576,
-0.6928467751,
-0.4643548131,
-1.1427106857,
-0.4871841371,
0.2498766482,
-0.0647114813,
-0.2266488671,
0.2198996246,
-0.2244919688,
0.3602005243,
0.765969336,
0.1206117719,
0.569850266,
0.3668643236,
-0.0814966932,
-0.1850276738,
-0.4598903656,
-0.7356045842,
1.1580181122,
0.3139596283,
1.0858969688,
-0.0574905388,
0.5536894202,
0.0209042076,
-0.3385035098,
-0.6079567075,
0.1301203668,
-0.5120943189,
-0.0659380555,
-0.2160176635,
-0.4073748291,
-1.1043564081,
-0.0131125888,
0.143340826,
-0.4775292575,
-0.0559441149,
-0.1777263135,
-0.0931933373,
0.1822358668,
-0.6227910519,
0.4049658477,
-0.1936261952,
-0.183983013,
-0.4134934247,
-0.5061922073,
0.1404662281,
-0.2767271698,
0.1675367206,
-0.2630916238,
-0.2411955297,
0.1878043413,
-0.2631007731,
0.7081769705,
0.0496186838,
-0.4444897771,
0.1446496546,
0.0288089886,
0.4957957566,
0.39161551,
-0.3201158047,
0.2008064836,
-0.2095880806,
-0.5323998928,
-0.2624922395,
0.7354109883,
-0.8658736348,
-0.4492297769,
0.129177168,
-0.6542199254,
-0.2833256721,
0.2144750059,
0.2445235252,
0.0106924018,
-0.0035513933,
0.0910109282,
0.5456537008,
-0.2262930274,
0.13596268,
0.6855818629,
-0.1862501651,
-0.2857833803,
1.3379144669,
0.1665826142,
-0.001919813,
0.5147500038,
-0.1115008071,
-0.1598433405,
-0.5825670362,
-0.3719390333,
0.3197223246,
-0.3099268973,
-0.4553742409,
-0.6369040608,
-0.3118519187,
-0.3332855403,
0.0453803055,
-0.491328001,
-0.3807035983,
-0.449560225,
-0.1559132636,
0.5077918768,
0.7635955215,
-0.0413468815,
0.3298318088,
-0.8338107467,
0.6059707403,
0.0269339792,
0.4334581792,
-0.0926912576,
-0.3502162993,
-0.4425626397,
0.2198483497,
-0.3264040351,
-0.4319090843,
0.5356401801,
0.236335963,
0.3924722075,
0.4868735969,
-0.1106080934,
0.8791542053,
-0.5132108331,
0.5155223012,
-0.5163230896,
-0.5124827623,
0.8312510252,
-0.6436196566,
0.4735358655,
0.6596770287,
0.4867405295,
-0.4838318825,
-0.6809616685,
-0.4804350436,
-1.1154408455,
0.3748528659,
-0.0231768228,
0.2637314498,
0.0681489557,
0.6436132193,
0.575548172,
0.4463659227,
-0.4160199165,
-0.1694925725,
0.1851986945,
-0.1588698477,
-0.2432761341,
-0.0534885004,
0.0247904621,
-0.4410218298,
0.5244573355,
-0.3763456643,
-0.2620693743,
-0.2966387868,
-0.1440529078,
-0.1197629124,
-0.0145865874,
0.4690097272,
0.9269106984,
0.0205510296,
0.1804847717,
-0.1063835546,
-0.3206336796,
-0.0122117959,
0.1713663787,
-0.2796552479,
0.0754380375,
0.2890665233,
0.5437377095,
-0.1889773309,
-0.8725543618,
-0.0013635542,
0.0051220953,
0.1076493114,
0.0657710657,
0.127911672,
0.1261295825,
0.1791141778,
0.2466181517,
-0.1471235901,
-0.1233654916,
-0.3085007966,
0.4839490652,
0.3927281499,
-0.1459907144,
-0.2158121467,
0.5589088202,
-0.0319213495,
-0.1303249151,
1.0729351044,
-0.0405085757,
-0.3144695759,
0.5423737764,
0.2784853578,
0.5151858926,
-0.1649647951,
0.3165132701,
0.3666287661,
0.4716091156,
0.0708058104,
0.5153729916,
0.3939557672,
-0.5417245626,
-0.3375011981,
-0.7647639513,
-0.1989522129,
0.4684189558,
-0.5499863029,
0.7838432789,
-0.1950066984,
0.0866013393,
-0.3266696334,
0.3128894567,
-0.9434704185,
0.288564533,
0.0433886126,
0.982114315,
-0.5404303074,
0.7297198176,
0.7978615761,
-0.4626710415,
-0.4882800281,
0.0925728977,
-0.0242396854,
-1.1627910137,
0.2264757603,
0.2931741178,
0.2071237564,
0.1168776527,
-0.7283028364,
-1.0654488802,
0.7126356959,
0.3690198958,
-0.6866138577,
0.1356886476,
0.5139858723,
0.6577787995,
-0.4566565454,
-0.1918806732,
0.9794526696,
0.6694201231,
-0.3008448184,
-0.7127453685,
-0.2944619656,
-0.1192540377,
0.078009285,
-0.0050086607,
-0.7926456928,
0.9244229198,
-0.3287933767,
-0.1945981979,
0.2390563041,
0.6800498962,
0.2406127453,
0.2159350216,
0.3786074519,
0.9116475582,
0.9928511977,
-0.0575478896,
0.8719745278,
-0.2552517653,
0.3354826272,
1.1085464954,
-0.270738095,
0.8440781832,
0.4563049078,
-0.0843982399,
0.3336473703,
0.8570910692,
-0.3361684978,
0.6146476269,
0.3174603283,
0.1409996599,
-0.0580903739,
-0.2342010736,
-0.1252162158,
0.9640440345,
0.5300841331,
0.009706784,
-0.5550521612,
0.1318509579,
0.0938685685,
0.282379806,
-0.2992309332,
0.9721120596,
-0.1036118492,
-0.6268757582,
0.5570592284,
0.3642644584,
0.6531490684,
-0.3392991126,
-0.0175511297,
-0.438346535,
0.3557548821,
-0.2450823039,
-0.6371290088,
0.3699113429,
0.0795272514,
-0.4490812719,
-0.2379913777,
0.4218197465,
-0.8690857291,
-0.5979898572,
0.1218164712,
0.8690773249,
0.0931606069,
-0.2797535062,
-0.5493924618,
0.1922957003,
0.1282706708,
0.0263993684,
0.2346895933,
0.8106787205,
0.035766989,
0.7699511647,
0.7075601816,
0.3647105694,
-0.0146378744,
0.3564358056,
0.8845254183,
-0.6687399745,
-0.4248991311,
-0.8887248039,
0.4719054401,
0.1797567308,
-0.2863461375,
0.8599674106,
1.0113971233,
1.3152643442,
0.0065967361,
0.9011330605,
0.3358103037,
0.8543572426,
-0.7359150648,
0.6962089539,
-0.7509153485,
0.3144536912,
0.1513402313,
-0.9392699599,
-0.2294515967,
0.4359438121,
0.3039501905,
0.2022832036,
0.3855008185,
0.8929077983,
-0.069718264,
-0.2488433868,
0.1201629713,
0.47737059,
0.5326125026,
0.2666872144,
0.6981528997,
-0.3063884974,
0.3271209002,
-0.2064140886,
-0.1976149827,
-0.2290373594,
-0.7851139903,
-0.6743149161,
-0.654635489,
-0.3113726079,
-0.2600157559,
-0.0926746801,
0.5739777088,
0.6439294815,
-0.75434196,
-0.3605772555,
0.1130969375,
0.3510475457,
-0.1421447098,
-0.2951345742,
0.3547611833,
-0.8857260346,
-1.0927135944,
0.4675315022,
0.3789910376,
-0.0831877068,
-0.3653167784,
0.1486947834,
-0.3163382411,
-0.116198726,
0.6632971764,
-0.0473583862,
-0.5638887882,
-0.1452195644,
-0.0261624381,
-0.1665587127,
0.2610228062,
0.8991398215,
-0.9394696951,
0.5378828049,
0.2336950898,
0.6523683071,
0.1790926456,
0.219269231,
0.8212407827,
-1.193149209,
0.1065165997,
0.0809790194,
0.1790074706,
0.5906655788,
-0.4060240984,
0.6312039495,
-0.0373442918,
-0.5507347584,
-0.7219228745,
0.1068240702,
-0.7715768814,
-0.4297947288,
1.3474404812,
0.3432389796,
0.1250014901,
-0.3149648309,
-0.3774484992,
0.253313154,
-0.2198103666,
1.1013467312,
0.7662054896,
-0.0547882617,
0.0960883722,
-0.6315807104,
0.5441803336,
0.1188916713,
-0.8536242247,
0.2181433141,
0.3407455385,
0.0414510779,
-0.0134089999,
0.18588157,
0.0562842973,
-0.0873828232,
-0.3500389159,
-0.5324475169,
0.2136602998,
-0.5408037305,
-0.4358331561,
0.0641459301,
-0.0899210572,
0.0100520104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01041v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01041v3
|
Learn to Refuse: Making Large Language Models More Controllable and Reliable through Knowledge Scope Limitation and Refusal Mechanism
| 2023-11-02T07:20:49 | 2024-05-29T09:19:35 |
Lang Cao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive language
understanding and generation capabilities, enabling them to answer a wide range
of questions across various domains. However, these models are not flawless and
often produce responses that contain errors or misinformation. These
inaccuracies, commonly referred to as hallucinations, render LLMs unreliable
and even unusable in many scenarios. In this paper, our focus is on mitigating
the issue of hallucination in LLMs, particularly in the context of
question-answering. Instead of attempting to answer all questions, we explore a
refusal mechanism that instructs LLMs to refuse to answer challenging questions
in order to avoid errors. We then propose a simple yet effective solution
called Learn to Refuse (L2R), which incorporates the refusal mechanism to
enable LLMs to recognize and refuse to answer questions that they find
difficult to address. To achieve this, we utilize a structured knowledge base
to represent all the LLM's understanding of the world, enabling it to provide
traceable gold knowledge. This knowledge base is separate from the LLM and
initially empty. It can be filled with validated knowledge and progressively
expanded. When an LLM encounters questions outside its domain, the system
recognizes its knowledge scope and determines whether it can answer the
question independently. Additionally, we introduce a method for automatically
and efficiently expanding the knowledge base of LLMs. Through qualitative and
quantitative analysis, we demonstrate that our approach enhances the
controllability and reliability of LLMs.
|
[
-0.2770673931,
-0.8442399502,
0.8155658245,
-0.0851888135,
0.0886474103,
0.2502857447,
-0.3463623226,
-0.2744104266,
-0.0347766355,
0.7321314216,
-0.7087647915,
-0.2628673613,
-0.6526616812,
0.0202486943,
-0.3031493425,
0.7514577508,
-0.2814613581,
-0.1590491831,
-0.4007500112,
-0.0330976844,
-0.6676857471,
-0.3846886456,
-0.7906608582,
-0.5619587302,
0.6270267963,
0.5855295062,
0.6914553046,
0.3772809803,
0.3309857845,
0.2689525783,
-0.1756103039,
0.2934714556,
-0.7463345528,
0.2466121316,
-0.2091836035,
-0.7147163749,
-0.2060784996,
-0.4537568092,
0.4169380367,
0.7954668403,
-0.1510213315,
-0.0358334929,
0.2448187619,
0.7949618697,
-0.3628900349,
0.1137010306,
-1.027169466,
0.0361546874,
0.0605134144,
-0.1770273596,
-0.5484925508,
-0.3040484786,
0.1164945886,
-0.6252053976,
0.0796318054,
-0.0858230367,
0.6367980242,
0.2954006791,
0.0133311199,
-0.6161973476,
-0.7720174193,
0.6414074898,
-0.3462527692,
0.546980381,
0.7836754322,
0.4062539041,
-0.1794934571,
-0.5195099711,
-0.6097558141,
-0.3310652971,
-0.0280629657,
-0.1256696582,
-0.0624442399,
-0.0839487314,
0.2176995575,
0.0074584279,
-0.7808761597,
0.0782991722,
-0.6395314932,
-0.4168677032,
0.2113713473,
0.0586157776,
0.2527640164,
0.0193171445,
-0.2332907021,
0.0275365468,
-0.780369103,
-0.0880256593,
0.2883789539,
0.2834885418,
0.3242141902,
0.8897562027,
-0.2253788114,
0.5912376642,
0.0342662521,
-0.0382510871,
-0.0070651304,
0.3654451668,
-0.1696390361,
-0.068196632,
0.3097127378,
0.1572449356,
0.3129546344,
-0.4516797364,
-0.2741114795,
0.1652553678,
0.5374504924,
-0.5565139651,
0.0500340052,
0.5698279142,
-0.4526286125,
-0.1298264712,
-0.1729221195,
-0.8461031914,
-0.6093611717,
-0.2501153052,
0.66199857,
-0.5665823817,
-0.2937359214,
0.1714360118,
0.0136445994,
0.3608109653,
0.4041241407,
-0.8994525075,
0.6761626005,
0.5850604177,
0.8354995251,
-0.2653745711,
-0.4462864697,
-0.5786663294,
0.257279098,
-0.3869813383,
0.4795261621,
-0.3858612478,
-0.4501630664,
-0.1090193614,
0.0614360236,
0.0217863359,
-1.0381104946,
0.1303410083,
-0.8744530082,
-0.0172613803,
-0.3546128273,
-0.4100305438,
-0.4589854777,
0.4053599536,
-0.6606140733,
0.497612685,
0.2339289188,
-0.415992558,
0.0060822899,
-0.5247759223,
-0.3080842793,
-0.0556135997,
-0.0998114869,
-0.2439706177,
0.1538685262,
-0.0605030395,
0.1674982458,
0.023232352,
0.3751543164,
-0.2861438096,
-0.3305951953,
0.3009566665,
-0.4034889936,
0.5366390347,
0.3427388668,
-0.3955363631,
0.2242003232,
-0.6711083651,
-0.0243359953,
0.2365000397,
-0.32907179,
-0.4313039184,
0.1831615269,
-0.1681996137,
0.1651325375,
0.0587470643,
-0.0823631659,
0.024679672,
-0.5555853248,
0.2495447695,
1.0085612535,
-0.2877557576,
0.4376376867,
-0.6398745179,
0.6268101335,
-0.0932016,
-0.0619333796,
0.2593100667,
-0.110849157,
-1.0542854071,
0.2580883205,
-0.1246725172,
0.6965210438,
-1.0012586117,
0.1806574613,
-0.1067474186,
-0.1646087766,
-0.5784062147,
0.530813098,
0.2726370692,
0.4059334397,
0.5188487172,
-0.2119171768,
-0.6258721948,
-0.6382133961,
-0.1535395384,
-0.4247639477,
-0.1906780452,
0.1663112342,
0.5098817348,
-0.1824052483,
0.7548266053,
-0.2584939599,
-0.4381432831,
-0.4815041125,
-0.2339805961,
-0.0144272791,
0.2681824267,
0.0719169378,
-0.9428332448,
-0.0576358773,
0.054128971,
-0.8609588146,
0.1300081909,
-0.1731310636,
0.0203926172,
0.406378448,
0.6659626961,
-0.5839447379,
0.4625505507,
0.3741283715,
-0.2602016032,
0.4825757742,
-0.0861090794,
-0.2513548136,
-0.904794991,
0.058054354,
-0.4200548232,
-0.1210655794,
-0.6059579849,
0.2101656049,
-0.0314053632,
0.1028886735,
-0.5576840043,
0.7693949342,
-0.2570113242,
0.1603086293,
-0.4031630754,
0.2240702957,
-0.1961105615,
0.3233194649,
0.3185214996,
0.5917124152,
0.5706883669,
-0.9708012938,
0.3205977678,
0.4642560482,
-0.2485057116,
0.3830934763,
-0.5469118357,
0.0593545139,
-0.4304676056,
-0.0120766675,
-0.9092823863,
-0.2163726985,
0.6166097522,
-0.5085841417,
0.1573417187,
-0.0903835669,
-0.2051729858,
-0.4019811749,
-0.0962322205,
0.0750745758,
0.5050799847,
-0.5782033801,
0.6945502758,
0.0261531509,
-0.2797212005,
-0.6080292463,
-0.8758105636,
0.0832107738,
-0.2124839574,
-0.1030849591,
0.0954692289,
-0.6424579024,
-0.5293163061,
0.0122727202,
-0.1195079535,
-0.023281591,
0.1455695629,
0.2957858443,
0.187970072,
0.0677653775,
0.2588889003,
0.1140146926,
-0.1497190744,
0.2883286476,
-0.4496727884,
0.7559123039,
0.0708730519,
-0.4652781188,
-0.4123316109,
0.2849522531,
0.7802139521,
0.022799639,
0.6943468451,
0.0719121695,
-0.4652890861,
-0.4346162379,
-0.6100282669,
-0.4994570017,
-0.5458418727,
0.4165736735,
-0.6184068322,
-1.0507141352,
0.4477081299,
-0.1056817248,
0.0655337125,
0.2336839885,
0.6862219572,
0.1555510759,
0.4953941703,
0.5509340167,
-0.1515250057,
0.032738626,
-0.0498355292,
0.0886712894,
-0.636523664,
-0.4813487828,
-0.4571317732,
-0.1644431055,
-0.37176615,
-0.5203623176,
0.1318055242,
0.0618164353,
-0.1561166942,
-0.0448447019,
-0.3345650434,
0.5325375795,
0.1230692044,
0.2532508075,
0.3527541757,
0.2464425564,
-0.1186971888,
-0.0697576478,
-0.5916149616,
-0.5611991882,
1.0532435179,
0.4745896459,
0.8911826611,
0.3832956553,
0.6273856163,
0.1759356111,
0.2654422224,
-1.0838927031,
0.7154535651,
0.3030328155,
-0.5145764351,
-0.5291498899,
-0.6073707938,
-0.7704875469,
0.3505016863,
0.015694268,
-0.7133464217,
0.0220109113,
-0.0661517382,
-0.3404057026,
0.6352981329,
-0.4308101833,
0.3699143231,
-0.2281263918,
-0.4543559253,
-0.0903678983,
-0.4084019959,
0.3070613444,
-0.3669816554,
0.3996498287,
0.2857487798,
-0.0726924315,
0.7161158919,
-0.2744152844,
1.1419568062,
-0.052776847,
-0.3676835001,
0.3935157359,
0.6099790931,
0.7336093783,
0.0845633596,
-0.3959764242,
-0.103827782,
-0.2643221319,
-0.3017042577,
-0.4770524204,
0.7442811131,
-0.7112218142,
-0.7993582487,
-0.2472486198,
-0.7045259476,
-0.3467718959,
0.3730197549,
0.1791047305,
-0.0203886013,
-0.0527604371,
-0.0827638134,
1.0105637312,
-0.3473402858,
0.4293699563,
0.4251296818,
-0.6052741408,
-0.3286965191,
0.9103620648,
0.288746804,
0.6077569723,
0.1987168789,
0.1200631782,
-0.4820474684,
-0.7878323197,
-0.2884381413,
0.204794541,
-0.8980439305,
-0.052183941,
-0.7473133206,
-0.4091578722,
-0.4668190181,
-0.1204684526,
-0.1489353627,
-0.3191580772,
-0.3825866282,
-0.3329278231,
0.3449240327,
0.788620472,
-0.0775872171,
0.1229419261,
-0.469622165,
0.5123794675,
0.5880787373,
0.4650330544,
0.2530738413,
-0.8838029504,
0.2108434588,
-0.0857300535,
-0.3492158651,
-0.6641261578,
0.2783383131,
-0.1515492052,
0.4197671115,
0.3637556136,
0.2754102945,
0.6561501622,
-0.5671080351,
0.3540875614,
0.0340384133,
-1.0174223185,
0.6688910723,
-0.1201824993,
-0.0044348668,
0.6218831539,
0.5311209559,
-0.5394127369,
-0.6382646561,
-0.5047809482,
-0.8994154334,
0.4970161617,
-0.024750378,
0.3573009074,
0.2051841617,
0.6499484181,
0.4106273055,
0.1741454005,
-1.0673097372,
-0.2283318192,
0.0965833291,
0.0052357563,
-0.0149729699,
-0.443911016,
-0.2973471284,
-0.0648971796,
0.7129542828,
-0.2469711602,
-0.0020476046,
0.2676214874,
-0.3012293279,
-0.3470152318,
0.4693450928,
0.6893533468,
1.0992875099,
-0.0431252643,
0.3659411669,
0.462618202,
-0.3789625764,
0.2017709017,
-0.2186702192,
-0.4822902679,
-0.0922773108,
0.2676267922,
0.6607975364,
-0.3170408309,
-0.8899940848,
0.1295474768,
0.0778444707,
-0.6135818958,
-0.4560235143,
0.0383275263,
0.0111457678,
0.2952064574,
0.2545077205,
-0.0751206055,
-0.0559201129,
-0.5305822492,
0.4611946642,
0.3882231712,
-0.652071774,
0.0184069052,
0.7170407176,
-0.2906159759,
-0.3620096445,
0.4891460836,
-0.1292763054,
-0.5104458332,
0.4605823159,
0.7308214903,
0.5532842875,
-0.1931350231,
0.4618272483,
0.1597936302,
0.6761193871,
-0.2655755877,
0.3951751292,
0.1907770038,
-0.697427392,
-0.3208400309,
-0.5553978682,
-0.5726976395,
0.5218994021,
-0.6942440867,
-0.0118956799,
-0.8309659362,
0.2857459784,
-0.5812194347,
-0.1140597388,
-0.3351722062,
0.1596524268,
0.1069728583,
0.8813294172,
-0.6757947803,
0.8128493428,
0.4091380835,
-0.2402566522,
-0.7573606968,
0.1506962478,
0.1710928231,
-0.8768185973,
0.5506429076,
0.187204808,
-0.165001899,
-0.006087522,
-0.5513974428,
-0.5856333375,
0.9128323197,
0.1220457181,
-0.7876421213,
0.180321157,
0.2696894109,
0.2112810016,
0.012269753,
-0.0789652243,
0.5312502384,
0.7137100697,
0.484098196,
-0.6652152538,
0.3407301605,
0.2157640755,
-0.2166791111,
-0.1467767805,
-0.6591294408,
0.5259037614,
-0.6123668551,
0.0536426343,
0.2496316433,
0.6651610136,
0.5842736363,
0.3368135691,
0.657466352,
0.3373106718,
1.1078823805,
-0.0393539853,
0.6628882289,
0.1911855787,
0.289419651,
1.1271778345,
-0.5403244495,
0.9214735031,
0.8312169313,
-0.0269514732,
0.2754742205,
0.5266582966,
0.0705567822,
0.5294202566,
0.652477622,
-0.2793823481,
-0.2967353463,
0.0057021314,
-0.3133990765,
0.2049430311,
0.5059365034,
-0.0988043472,
-0.1961635053,
0.3179502785,
0.1432973593,
0.2233919948,
-0.4314558506,
0.7605649233,
0.1431189328,
-0.563287437,
0.9470589161,
-0.1934898943,
0.4921374321,
-0.792454958,
-0.0138209518,
-0.2251593471,
0.1839541942,
-0.1668498218,
-0.5603621602,
0.5181385279,
-0.091037564,
-0.214739874,
-0.2149040401,
0.7156690955,
-0.4592726231,
-0.5155172348,
0.6231211424,
0.6527909636,
0.1294068992,
0.0323110409,
-0.6317107677,
0.2921794355,
-0.0020581684,
-0.2532013357,
0.3556735516,
0.4074278176,
-0.0150609715,
1.1069744825,
0.5802514553,
0.3878262639,
-0.2083645761,
-0.0901290551,
0.9919068813,
-0.5637145638,
-0.2051195353,
-0.9245132804,
0.2652659416,
0.2896073461,
0.1988842189,
0.4739826024,
0.3706016541,
1.0799534321,
0.0295391697,
1.2049609423,
-0.123341687,
0.5370814204,
-0.7519316077,
1.0173834562,
-0.7974206805,
0.6553723216,
-0.0327509716,
-0.6899442673,
-0.5704033971,
0.6303560138,
-0.3832947016,
0.0666039363,
0.7138058543,
0.894120574,
0.2444672436,
-0.2876599431,
0.6073651314,
0.4819275439,
0.3723052144,
0.7672760487,
0.9920307398,
-0.1818259656,
0.8313590288,
-0.0724699646,
-0.0970875248,
-0.1174563915,
-0.3725292385,
-1.1069799662,
-0.3671270609,
-0.0143787032,
-0.8989610672,
0.25133425,
0.7856942415,
0.3801012635,
-0.8768325448,
-0.4037596583,
-0.1413670033,
0.5612181425,
-0.1784369051,
-0.1718479395,
0.3948447108,
-0.5372074246,
-0.5784834623,
0.4815043807,
0.1595889926,
0.2331330776,
-0.2185730338,
-0.4473201334,
0.0967596322,
0.0542815328,
0.5911186337,
0.4593157768,
-0.9683669209,
-0.3349785209,
0.1702810824,
0.1283412725,
-0.0774468705,
0.7522425652,
-0.743344605,
0.456040442,
0.1436176449,
0.852304697,
0.0253497567,
-0.3272715211,
0.2455537617,
-0.1597671658,
0.0710414574,
0.2366029471,
-0.0695300698,
0.1047406048,
-0.3631449342,
0.3203426898,
0.1945697218,
-0.2587162256,
-0.6340755224,
0.4307540357,
-0.8044732213,
-0.6597000957,
1.2461781502,
0.1348327994,
-0.2543072999,
-0.4690545797,
-0.409270823,
0.0459841974,
-0.1016840562,
1.0353822708,
0.8638643622,
0.0945444778,
-0.3468235433,
-0.8636675477,
0.5878959298,
0.6416665316,
-0.8745218515,
0.46903494,
0.3791919649,
0.5758282542,
0.0060845455,
0.7030470371,
-0.160811305,
0.1040339023,
-0.3979268372,
0.0201123729,
-0.0526801497,
-0.7120372653,
-0.5037038922,
0.4631234109,
0.4587259889,
0.0803283304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01036v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01036v1
|
ATHENA: Mathematical Reasoning with Thought Expansion
| 2023-11-02T07:03:25 | 2023-11-02T07:03:25 |
JB. Kim, Hazel Kim, Joonghyuk Hahn, Yo-Sub Han
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7; I.2.3; F.4.1
|
Solving math word problems depends on how to articulate the problems, the
lens through which models view human linguistic expressions. Real-world
settings count on such a method even more due to the diverse practices of the
same mathematical operations. Earlier works constrain available thinking
processes by limited prediction strategies without considering their
significance in acquiring mathematical knowledge. We introduce Attention-based
THought Expansion Network Architecture (ATHENA) to tackle the challenges of
real-world practices by mimicking human thought expansion mechanisms in the
form of neural network propagation. A thought expansion recurrently generates
the candidates carrying the thoughts of possible math expressions driven from
the previous step and yields reasonable thoughts by selecting the valid
pathways to the goal. Our experiments show that ATHENA achieves a new
state-of-the-art stage toward the ideal model that is compelling in variant
questions even when the informativeness in training examples is restricted.
|
[
-0.551943779,
-1.0305862427,
0.6336736083,
0.2324870527,
-0.4371827543,
-0.1868503094,
0.0583173558,
-0.5307545662,
0.3408620059,
0.4534728229,
-0.9699000716,
-0.1277054697,
-0.7959630489,
0.0233437158,
-0.104639411,
0.4854787886,
0.0022332803,
0.030268427,
-0.0472262092,
-0.030251693,
-0.4900082946,
-0.2241925001,
-1.0063136816,
-0.3933945596,
0.4394259155,
0.155988574,
0.5922649503,
0.6042596698,
0.9380934238,
0.3000295758,
-0.0609511286,
0.4311076701,
-0.2278448939,
0.296128422,
-0.0317329094,
-0.7010372877,
-0.5100958943,
-0.1585369408,
0.6494473815,
1.034476161,
-0.3739545345,
0.5102826357,
-0.0627735779,
0.9158374071,
-0.6231834888,
0.3654359281,
-0.3215230405,
0.4773100913,
0.1047990546,
0.0099281585,
-0.0792504251,
-0.5111563206,
0.5773118138,
-0.9979381561,
-0.3627488315,
0.0256040525,
0.2251292467,
0.4813974798,
-0.0346167572,
-0.3377536237,
-0.7505661249,
0.918676734,
-0.4830224216,
0.304718852,
0.1926911175,
0.3918105364,
-0.2540117502,
-0.5950966477,
-0.4484325647,
0.2459551394,
0.3578316867,
0.1463661641,
-0.327160567,
-0.0554727353,
0.4872996211,
0.350677073,
-0.0840414912,
-0.6633887887,
-0.6105695367,
0.119357571,
0.3666082025,
0.1503328085,
0.3129281402,
0.294803977,
0.1101095676,
0.1469845325,
-0.4860677719,
-0.283926487,
0.2190100253,
0.1511634141,
0.085170418,
0.7714239955,
-0.205990687,
0.9209136367,
-0.0154080465,
0.3352999985,
0.0250589363,
0.2927665412,
-0.4103589952,
0.0302120727,
0.294640094,
-0.1081050783,
0.379879266,
-0.1584113091,
0.1948804706,
0.4434962571,
0.6479961276,
-0.4523863196,
0.0776280463,
-0.0153398747,
-0.3063693345,
-0.4107568562,
-0.2326165736,
-0.7909283638,
-0.1464653015,
-0.6176692247,
0.6569296122,
-0.3305038512,
-0.375800848,
0.5980608463,
0.0305023603,
-0.1706418097,
0.2937515378,
-0.7891430855,
0.5764158368,
0.9849784374,
0.4798306525,
0.0095717544,
-0.000310256,
-0.3473961055,
-0.119533889,
-0.8925536275,
0.5030257702,
-0.7130947709,
-0.0330944881,
-0.0648797527,
-0.591951251,
-0.0271088462,
-0.5348286629,
0.6309147477,
-0.766689837,
0.4616892934,
-0.3838017583,
-0.7037093639,
-0.55157125,
0.453784436,
-0.4177392125,
0.9389839172,
0.1326053888,
-0.7561702132,
0.1594849229,
-1.1943210363,
-0.1404657513,
0.0865196735,
-0.0040496383,
-0.2478346378,
0.5153701305,
0.2441699058,
0.046558667,
-0.2977908254,
0.1256553978,
-0.3131362796,
-0.2536830306,
0.355437398,
-0.2592043281,
0.547011435,
0.3779019713,
-0.5832569599,
-0.1464833468,
-0.7268388867,
0.2647381425,
0.1595688015,
-0.07584434,
-0.554766953,
0.0127102649,
-0.8580201268,
0.2308101803,
0.1234044135,
-0.6997038126,
0.3360553384,
-0.8365829587,
0.2073158026,
0.5289838314,
0.09902744,
0.4380992949,
-0.3708965778,
0.7570459843,
-0.0046233498,
0.107967183,
-0.0820775628,
-0.8771531582,
-1.2086498737,
0.1616221666,
-0.0251793843,
0.4388760924,
-0.6974796653,
0.0645487905,
-0.2649104893,
-0.3410158753,
-0.8288354874,
-0.1300732791,
0.4131688178,
0.8811861873,
0.3832490742,
-0.1367742419,
-0.5027573109,
-0.9063435197,
-0.4672726989,
0.1390736997,
0.1858921945,
0.5177445412,
0.2939276099,
-0.0028189607,
0.8149162531,
-0.8093587756,
-0.1241480634,
-0.4106469154,
0.3735719919,
0.3147381246,
0.3388431668,
-0.0718050078,
-0.5871174335,
-0.1419775784,
-0.2837147415,
-0.7744938135,
0.1094339117,
0.042665761,
-0.423936218,
-0.2831242383,
-0.0386796445,
-0.5450146794,
0.6222425103,
0.2160037905,
-0.1591234356,
0.4373467565,
-0.1948820353,
-0.123102963,
-1.4160770178,
-0.1641113013,
0.0476701371,
0.0702218115,
-0.4652361572,
0.4954119027,
-0.1577384025,
-0.5312393308,
-0.3070622981,
0.4906832278,
-0.3779753745,
-0.5297011137,
-0.30181548,
0.0359072201,
-0.1233420819,
0.7449734211,
-0.0040071048,
0.6627712846,
0.8703457117,
-0.8857047558,
0.5445676446,
0.2925553918,
-0.4570868909,
0.3734600246,
-0.4628821313,
0.1586073935,
-0.2065826803,
0.0821818411,
-0.7365216017,
0.0676907152,
0.5070233941,
-0.5442937613,
0.0214766059,
0.0776503608,
-0.3146930635,
-0.6099295616,
0.1927026212,
0.8903689981,
0.4093583524,
-0.3884333372,
0.7919225693,
0.2731769979,
-0.0724089667,
-0.7364843488,
-0.7458076477,
0.0424718559,
-0.30277583,
-0.6693732142,
-0.0491882116,
0.00717066,
-0.7069675922,
0.2231023461,
0.0196380224,
-0.0499814562,
0.1795500815,
-0.0308846273,
0.3167685866,
-0.3805754781,
0.322462678,
0.16768682,
-0.0772790834,
0.4754045308,
-1.0017035007,
0.4552873075,
-0.1293611676,
-0.4732987285,
-0.5843752623,
0.5415844321,
0.6595755816,
-0.5110301971,
0.3619148433,
0.0727549344,
-0.7194563746,
-0.3723973334,
-0.4683510363,
-0.3925230205,
-0.441789031,
0.3657376766,
-0.5072604418,
-0.6301364303,
0.399499774,
-0.3934612274,
0.3677608967,
0.4061339796,
0.3643254042,
-0.1949547082,
1.170866847,
0.6355375648,
0.2551298738,
0.2132628411,
-0.5860479474,
0.2901414335,
-1.431620121,
-0.0173716377,
0.0677489787,
-0.7824819088,
-0.0651607513,
-0.68646276,
0.2165783495,
-0.3210484385,
0.0507710688,
0.2091687322,
-0.6882171035,
0.4234791398,
0.4442301095,
0.0315188169,
0.0760386065,
0.10892234,
-0.5918490291,
-0.27703771,
-0.6558559537,
0.0922527388,
1.2869057655,
0.2252483815,
0.5755707026,
0.1826655567,
0.5969616175,
0.0852168351,
0.5369163156,
-1.013802886,
0.6136737466,
0.1629811525,
-0.8093069792,
-0.4182589054,
-0.5362700224,
-0.8653562069,
0.3519863784,
-0.1630385369,
-0.6780933738,
0.162480101,
0.0667582974,
-0.7487956285,
0.5046367645,
-0.3517366052,
0.3188879192,
-0.1124198064,
-0.4842894971,
-0.784984529,
-0.163855806,
0.4252237678,
-0.1238663942,
0.3302820921,
0.1552734375,
-0.1292723417,
0.7061426044,
-0.4051922858,
0.6430165172,
0.1971509755,
-0.0862727836,
0.6222564578,
0.4429975748,
0.4048838913,
-0.2022324502,
0.0735536963,
-0.1557812691,
-0.616174221,
-0.1512986124,
-1.0707503557,
0.4605950415,
-0.6636537313,
-0.8490716815,
-0.394595921,
-0.8342866898,
-0.5621294975,
0.2313350439,
0.0850062221,
0.7985582352,
0.0871153548,
-0.0500394404,
0.8129343987,
0.1725628227,
0.341475457,
0.211876139,
-0.2809582055,
-0.5610393882,
0.6680679917,
0.160315752,
0.2161227614,
0.3902563155,
0.3576459587,
-0.4959501624,
-0.1795546263,
-0.5078554153,
0.5104201436,
-0.6229792237,
0.0539178178,
-0.505358696,
-0.0969706476,
-0.2517605424,
0.0596457198,
-0.445391804,
-0.8973945975,
-0.2685743868,
-0.1039355919,
0.003943623,
0.6683059335,
0.1361331344,
0.2735620141,
-0.5523526669,
0.1868438721,
0.6546113491,
0.549007535,
0.4239363372,
-0.5042201877,
-0.2659752071,
0.2919445336,
-0.5421138406,
-0.8234622478,
0.4428082705,
-0.0874844491,
0.3834732771,
0.7424268723,
-0.2619182467,
0.7987804413,
-0.5740253925,
0.1644639075,
0.271758467,
-0.7141914368,
0.5270767808,
-0.3455884457,
0.4062657952,
0.1126332283,
0.1672965735,
-0.5891638398,
-0.2300630361,
-0.9016786218,
-0.2385964841,
0.5645564198,
0.413679868,
0.1506453902,
-0.1353168339,
0.8444854617,
-0.3580480516,
0.2213362455,
-0.2933368385,
-0.2370466292,
0.1167087853,
-0.1124455333,
0.1467837244,
-0.0708045512,
-0.2145822495,
-0.3542312682,
0.5683559775,
-0.071653761,
0.4285302162,
0.400392592,
0.2409334183,
-0.4027563035,
0.1644094586,
0.8284050822,
0.882196188,
0.1734679341,
0.1144764274,
0.3009627461,
-0.3572353423,
0.0086526759,
-0.1426480263,
-0.088532567,
-0.2483247072,
0.0457105935,
0.6939147711,
0.4322338104,
-0.4311415255,
0.0530074462,
-0.1272620261,
-0.3488648236,
-0.4299158156,
0.1604395509,
0.3179970086,
0.2543713152,
0.315276593,
0.4737942219,
0.4592438936,
-0.6290106773,
0.1139854044,
0.4134917855,
-0.6255730391,
-0.3038288653,
0.6583104134,
0.0648040026,
-0.7174612284,
0.6742589474,
0.0459426939,
-0.7669617534,
0.9036945105,
0.7964190245,
1.005474329,
-0.1434313953,
-0.0438755155,
0.5721048713,
0.2368514985,
-0.0425204299,
0.6491931081,
-0.2878366411,
-0.9067345858,
-0.6938547492,
-0.4503833652,
-0.3244148493,
-0.0200639647,
-0.6430778503,
0.1057428941,
-0.6367176771,
-0.4957784414,
-0.2066195905,
0.0341942385,
-0.4354889393,
0.4338016808,
0.3861190677,
1.148448348,
-0.5159314275,
0.5381314754,
0.8101036549,
0.0449859276,
-0.9867317677,
-0.3053304851,
-0.1710288823,
-0.9121313691,
0.6149927378,
0.1090021804,
-0.342762351,
0.1873899996,
-0.0830522552,
-1.194123745,
0.7364046574,
0.173414737,
-0.4025652409,
-0.1029664725,
0.0942030102,
0.4793618619,
-0.808221519,
-0.0270495769,
0.0651316047,
0.2449362427,
0.4564027488,
-0.4655788839,
-0.2197655737,
-0.448263377,
-0.1612882018,
0.509164989,
-0.4201235473,
0.7010805607,
-0.6366176009,
0.0322617628,
0.034163978,
0.8382126093,
0.2907048464,
0.2793076932,
0.5221610665,
1.293010354,
0.7068190575,
0.0522085354,
1.1430802345,
-0.2150666118,
0.143745333,
1.0882835388,
0.1160790846,
0.7559657693,
0.3681498468,
-0.0252851769,
0.6145505905,
0.6008312106,
0.2125698626,
0.3969506323,
0.46820876,
-0.2827628851,
-0.4632592201,
-0.071789436,
-0.4564604163,
0.2702926993,
0.806345582,
-0.41119048,
-0.1601541638,
-0.1346963048,
-0.1651712954,
-0.0221792497,
-0.5811499357,
0.7148848176,
0.2199228257,
-1.1267169714,
0.0481575057,
-0.1968446523,
0.1821908504,
-0.4940191209,
-0.3671610355,
-0.0339239128,
0.4568003118,
0.1754226238,
-0.5939952731,
0.5917983651,
-0.3060541153,
0.1065504551,
0.0036617781,
0.5388830304,
-0.249376446,
-1.0023360252,
-0.0531869717,
0.5647016168,
0.1452962309,
0.0505703315,
-0.66856426,
-0.2388973981,
-0.1232145354,
0.0821735933,
0.0347399525,
0.6361329556,
-0.0716154352,
1.1564257145,
0.7622237206,
0.4639890194,
0.270790875,
0.0048428215,
0.8527131081,
-0.1668469757,
-0.7331953645,
-0.7032873034,
0.1752068549,
-0.2136918306,
-0.5792632699,
0.3990971744,
0.5948027968,
0.2463484108,
0.1697418988,
0.569911778,
0.6513631344,
0.6468411684,
-0.0172672588,
0.5265582204,
-0.5788094997,
0.2139684558,
-0.3223330677,
-1.0676401854,
-0.4906933904,
0.8203647137,
-0.6057947874,
-0.2604036927,
0.6383946538,
0.1333184987,
-0.2835378647,
0.3844263554,
0.2851571441,
-0.0881492198,
0.0591767319,
0.6665595174,
0.8210299015,
-0.1644213349,
0.3864203393,
-0.2946424782,
-0.4693433046,
0.0636153221,
-0.5949336886,
-0.7222225666,
-0.2999609113,
-0.3923299313,
-0.1551137567,
-0.0932531208,
0.8905146122,
0.7428534627,
-0.3873737156,
-0.1793375164,
-0.5393095613,
0.0843985453,
-0.532146275,
-0.2060650438,
0.4283723235,
-0.5026391745,
-0.5757568479,
0.0158242863,
0.4246381223,
-0.1300220639,
-0.5062707663,
0.1605515182,
0.1134850606,
0.6678155661,
0.3655020297,
0.2237863839,
-0.6391319036,
-0.0127382977,
0.3914976418,
0.2081630677,
-0.0461491421,
0.8266332746,
-0.8142917752,
0.9018352032,
0.2563848197,
1.048666954,
0.3346871138,
-0.1120788381,
0.7845188379,
-0.1863994747,
0.0777445734,
0.5003156662,
0.5524891019,
0.0133483242,
-0.4007004499,
0.3981153369,
0.3209107518,
-0.1793581545,
-0.3415035009,
0.5388354063,
-0.4180106521,
-0.1686564982,
0.6779739857,
-0.1622518748,
-0.4093274176,
0.1342860013,
-0.0180211719,
0.172108084,
-0.1188254282,
1.3633646965,
0.8631177545,
-0.4834967554,
-0.2791235745,
-0.3399745524,
0.4025149047,
0.789878726,
-0.7895065546,
0.0231834184,
0.1852563322,
-0.046000544,
0.5472822189,
0.3734687567,
-0.2601732016,
0.5711189508,
-0.2020948231,
-0.1893875897,
-0.1289816201,
-0.3276487589,
-0.0682022795,
0.1482202411,
-0.2211005539,
-0.3964213729
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01030v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01030v1
|
Joint Learning of Local and Global Features for Aspect-based Sentiment Classification
| 2023-11-02T06:43:50 | 2023-11-02T06:43:50 |
Hao Niu, Yun Xiong, Xiaosu Wang, Philip S. Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Aspect-based sentiment classification (ASC) aims to judge the sentiment
polarity conveyed by the given aspect term in a sentence. The sentiment
polarity is not only determined by the local context but also related to the
words far away from the given aspect term. Most recent efforts related to the
attention-based models can not sufficiently distinguish which words they should
pay more attention to in some cases. Meanwhile, graph-based models are coming
into ASC to encode syntactic dependency tree information. But these models do
not fully leverage syntactic dependency trees as they neglect to incorporate
dependency relation tag information into representation learning effectively.
In this paper, we address these problems by effectively modeling the local and
global features. Firstly, we design a local encoder containing: a Gaussian mask
layer and a covariance self-attention layer. The Gaussian mask layer tends to
adjust the receptive field around aspect terms adaptively to deemphasize the
effects of unrelated words and pay more attention to local information. The
covariance self-attention layer can distinguish the attention weights of
different words more obviously. Furthermore, we propose a dual-level graph
attention network as a global encoder by fully employing dependency tag
information to capture long-distance information effectively. Our model
achieves state-of-the-art performance on both SemEval 2014 and Twitter
datasets.
|
[
-0.4901753962,
-0.7333872914,
0.4057657719,
0.2370321453,
-0.3315118551,
0.3851539195,
-0.0793944001,
-0.857698679,
0.5569294095,
0.5483644605,
-0.4105423689,
-0.7139205933,
-0.6334633827,
0.0392114222,
-0.0294068344,
1.2032327652,
-0.4217070043,
-0.1607910693,
-0.5588191748,
-0.6402636766,
-0.1434539258,
-0.8644016981,
-0.6868929267,
-0.237908259,
0.5849847198,
0.1693404168,
0.4088009298,
0.0757637098,
0.4295452237,
0.2598654032,
-0.3774465621,
0.0883807018,
-0.1134325042,
0.1420950443,
-0.2390873283,
-0.3114335537,
-0.5712444782,
-0.0637938157,
0.4531612992,
0.623799324,
0.2220450193,
0.1835155189,
0.4124668837,
0.6076626778,
-0.4941625595,
0.5373834372,
-0.3774054945,
0.0285735149,
0.0848848447,
0.1703704894,
-0.0473796278,
-0.1423366517,
0.1252628863,
-0.1760447025,
0.4979555905,
-0.1133569852,
0.9890517592,
-0.1602748334,
-0.609161377,
-0.3121728301,
-0.5813096762,
0.5660563707,
-0.3614587784,
0.319434464,
0.34132725,
-0.0520460233,
0.1313743442,
-0.3137453794,
-0.3212965131,
0.09561643,
-0.0731422454,
0.3155904114,
0.0441443026,
0.3323424459,
-0.067232497,
0.7721930146,
-0.1694013625,
-0.0959249362,
-0.1719695032,
-0.2665999532,
0.4986810088,
0.0545178577,
0.0863960385,
-0.7296490669,
-0.5759767294,
0.2075486332,
-0.5393978953,
0.6691333055,
0.3171571493,
0.4779583514,
-0.4259066582,
0.1729322225,
-0.3805550337,
0.3416558206,
0.1066503003,
0.0843079239,
0.3100164235,
-0.3025060296,
-0.1336981803,
-0.0857096314,
0.818389833,
0.0729467794,
-0.3102068305,
-0.1248079613,
-0.2407825589,
0.2661223412,
0.2351175547,
-0.3375138342,
-0.1909868866,
0.2631168067,
-0.3141887486,
-0.3649082184,
0.1191670969,
-0.7448199987,
-0.422252655,
-0.4010551572,
0.47874704,
-0.2031063586,
-0.2914376855,
-0.1940368712,
0.2843291759,
-0.0971084461,
0.3541349769,
-0.6315243244,
0.2451223135,
0.6740392447,
0.9553425312,
0.012665011,
-0.1503381729,
-0.3599700034,
0.0050457073,
0.1084179431,
0.9642993212,
-0.5930526853,
-0.0678840876,
0.070696868,
0.2405393422,
0.05789515,
-0.3069013953,
0.3655091226,
-0.4629365504,
0.206640169,
-0.3717202544,
-0.2054552734,
-0.7805850506,
0.3456323743,
-0.6261814833,
0.808019042,
0.3500943482,
-1.1974475384,
0.3693967164,
-0.6328749061,
-0.7494629025,
-0.1443716735,
-0.2423087209,
-0.7123727202,
0.2820237875,
0.4659499228,
0.6106393337,
-0.2102110535,
0.2365476638,
-0.5597704649,
0.1517715007,
0.0593792535,
-0.1818815768,
0.5876355767,
0.028468607,
-0.1670618355,
0.3707378507,
-0.5836774111,
-0.3038726151,
-0.0288666096,
-0.2907545567,
-0.3825097978,
0.1073056757,
-0.0477530025,
0.3836076558,
0.1899441779,
-0.6866413951,
-0.0194299985,
-0.59518677,
0.6281836629,
0.5716389418,
0.3498582542,
0.5809347034,
0.0151691344,
0.5700858235,
0.5132574439,
0.1809863001,
0.0107861748,
-0.3665599227,
-0.8341530561,
-0.1883589476,
0.2069263309,
0.3032301068,
-0.9006381035,
0.6855101585,
-0.2597159147,
-0.0968516618,
-0.5218801498,
0.2391403466,
0.2224183232,
0.3753147125,
0.225003019,
-0.7750355601,
-0.3724471331,
-0.7926601171,
0.0297183674,
-0.2128607333,
0.1185233518,
0.3871088624,
0.3200181425,
0.039967034,
1.0303127766,
-0.3570745885,
-0.6082080603,
-0.5408609509,
0.2748309374,
0.0478652567,
0.0016601393,
0.3165077269,
-0.6569702625,
-0.4123017192,
0.1499076039,
-0.7273128033,
0.0837857425,
-0.0266134795,
-0.0679275021,
0.4878172874,
0.2308095694,
-0.5183209777,
0.4255252481,
0.4804421067,
-0.4177807868,
-0.0663120747,
-0.176263243,
0.0824553818,
-1.2867634296,
-0.0873433128,
0.3539196849,
-0.4121787548,
-0.341786027,
0.1438835859,
-0.0351219997,
-0.1533682048,
-0.2510819137,
0.3223714828,
-0.6395759583,
-0.0908488482,
-0.2778535187,
0.0307888612,
0.398432523,
0.7570605278,
-0.0253248382,
0.2674937248,
0.7099637389,
-0.2974752784,
0.4556109011,
-0.1315196455,
-0.1076322719,
0.4921326637,
-0.1624398828,
0.2258231491,
-0.3183011413,
0.4221833646,
-0.7974729538,
-0.1204723269,
0.5479950905,
-0.3923863173,
0.5132886171,
-0.2417255938,
-0.3947740495,
-0.5003679991,
-0.3906117678,
0.2348084599,
0.126651451,
-0.6321562529,
0.8459386826,
0.6226676702,
-0.1425726712,
-0.3639980853,
-0.4148619771,
-0.1406576037,
-0.162864238,
-0.5239094496,
0.1513628066,
0.5013999939,
0.1772898734,
0.1618202925,
-0.2239814848,
0.1058638319,
-0.0330546871,
0.6300895214,
0.0169549044,
-0.0959067941,
0.1466508508,
-0.0250915326,
-0.1395820677,
0.2048253119,
-0.272153914,
0.5087729692,
-0.2230159193,
-0.2556055188,
-0.2762612104,
0.6510592103,
0.3267851472,
-0.3615671992,
0.5553731322,
0.5834821463,
-0.4233009815,
-0.156027168,
-0.460541904,
0.0483781286,
-0.4001655877,
0.6365917921,
-0.4090688825,
-1.0235979557,
0.8388135433,
0.1718376875,
-0.4282305837,
0.4067006707,
0.2770282626,
-0.1511178166,
0.9469200969,
0.8028842211,
-0.6786955595,
0.6248042583,
-0.4346008897,
0.4562784433,
-0.996116519,
-0.1361907125,
-0.1972555071,
-0.334990114,
-0.5707786083,
-0.5259188414,
0.1660532504,
0.4711045027,
-0.1251023859,
0.1102086231,
-0.5676323175,
0.2184167355,
0.4002599716,
0.2882788777,
0.0922908187,
0.4237257242,
-0.0129214693,
0.0147259422,
-0.3042978346,
-0.162026614,
0.7512328029,
0.7259596586,
0.661757648,
-0.1363939643,
0.7224224806,
0.0686805174,
0.194138065,
-0.7885601521,
0.4147358537,
-0.3689684868,
-0.292996943,
0.0971957967,
-0.4935152829,
-0.6078062654,
0.0171587784,
0.0144578889,
-0.9324306846,
0.1968454123,
0.0432252176,
-0.252951473,
0.5544938445,
-0.6086754799,
0.7744549513,
-0.1524543911,
-0.2565699816,
-0.2872940302,
-0.628529489,
-0.1026393622,
0.1879345179,
0.1548646837,
-0.3338190019,
0.1332998723,
0.5098639727,
-0.1278015375,
1.1816687584,
-0.399187088,
0.1289286911,
0.663742125,
-0.1215401366,
0.3884519637,
0.2438007146,
0.3632318377,
0.6338790655,
-0.3342694938,
-0.2811542451,
-0.4887151122,
0.7822697759,
-0.929911375,
-0.555734396,
-0.3640998304,
-0.3025524914,
-0.3876047432,
-0.2070561498,
0.2211356759,
0.6560763121,
0.0272474233,
-0.1646293551,
0.1892605573,
-0.2113647908,
0.3829086423,
0.1985702068,
-0.4241018593,
-0.7154819369,
1.1239868402,
0.2547215223,
0.2186590135,
0.5678145289,
-0.016258521,
-0.151918143,
-0.390180856,
-0.2986165285,
0.2658410668,
-0.8738892674,
-0.5142918825,
-0.7819749713,
-0.5655443072,
-0.474681586,
-0.0583503991,
-0.2455575764,
-0.1220499948,
-0.2959029377,
-0.0353891142,
0.6764252186,
0.9258931875,
0.0381178036,
0.1153064892,
-0.6096798778,
0.2459519207,
0.1962562501,
0.5431547165,
0.144436121,
-0.4144583941,
-0.3466828465,
-0.1735224277,
-0.5088291764,
-0.7496523857,
0.4337381721,
0.0764916688,
0.2836671472,
0.3117613196,
0.0269651208,
0.3582544327,
-0.0280811824,
0.6435180306,
0.2333580405,
-0.8714498281,
0.7352157235,
-0.2360876501,
0.4427133203,
0.4700160027,
0.4307977259,
-0.62844944,
-0.7518472075,
-0.6078785658,
-1.1176441908,
0.9025604725,
-0.1197150052,
0.1182648987,
0.0244045127,
0.5083979964,
0.2482694983,
0.1152253971,
-0.8513683081,
-0.0819075853,
-0.2003958821,
-0.5147657394,
0.0692109838,
-0.267867893,
0.182565853,
-0.4096952081,
0.4893313646,
-0.3686251938,
0.3413776457,
0.2681186497,
-0.0074378159,
-0.1203926727,
0.3173034787,
-0.0390264019,
0.1836370975,
-0.1865180284,
0.3174803257,
0.2564224899,
-0.4252769947,
-0.0971143395,
0.1435997933,
-0.2004181743,
-0.1834899187,
0.2187104374,
1.0022115707,
0.1022635475,
0.2214282006,
0.6708313227,
0.0446291082,
0.1261478364,
-0.0998411924,
-0.1468120813,
0.3067055345,
0.2980754375,
-0.1020239368,
0.3853534758,
0.1523688138,
-0.6219857931,
-0.106036067,
0.3976210654,
-0.8372060061,
-0.6771379709,
0.277456671,
0.3610909283,
-0.0454120822,
0.3063458204,
-0.5020193458,
-0.9524350762,
0.6217897534,
0.3238158524,
1.0471289158,
-0.1030904576,
0.3464563787,
0.3377052844,
-0.1153799295,
0.2593068182,
0.4118097723,
-0.2943821847,
-0.6948087215,
-0.4074396789,
-0.9524254799,
-0.2229804099,
0.0570578873,
-0.7517248988,
0.2292907387,
-0.6839227676,
-0.1671578288,
-0.0729741529,
0.0914943218,
-0.7236514688,
0.2325592041,
0.4327943623,
0.2701175213,
-1.1273778677,
0.922467351,
1.0879071951,
-0.6381447315,
-0.7250257134,
0.2120020241,
-0.1701590568,
-0.4772042036,
0.47016716,
0.7101148963,
-0.0941976383,
-0.4339358509,
-0.309949249,
-0.8541422486,
0.8165563345,
0.0844881162,
-0.2241800576,
0.074040994,
0.223350808,
0.7268142104,
-0.6193960309,
0.1764431447,
0.1640463024,
-0.2474092096,
0.1675040275,
-0.7565466166,
-0.035365548,
-0.1030318886,
0.1164930537,
0.4462852478,
-0.8301233649,
0.8382303119,
0.0439554937,
-0.3757163882,
-0.5357243419,
0.9653601646,
-0.1846759915,
0.3194580972,
0.5525873899,
0.5540730953,
0.3611901104,
-0.054909464,
0.864577353,
-0.2347619534,
0.7143297791,
1.122800827,
-0.1514901072,
1.1505835056,
0.1495713741,
-0.2273487151,
0.7186732292,
0.659598887,
0.219099924,
0.6302025318,
-0.1443075687,
-0.5575600266,
-0.343937546,
-0.2604946196,
-0.0403724276,
0.4106044471,
0.462641269,
-0.4610182345,
-0.2816339433,
0.3349041641,
-0.0421451554,
-0.0335427783,
-0.6022152901,
1.022886157,
0.3232764304,
-0.4879250824,
-0.0030218447,
0.0301256403,
0.8221073747,
-0.3258619905,
0.1924567521,
-0.2088420242,
0.4243614376,
-0.3620868623,
-1.0548099279,
0.4206009805,
-0.1647638679,
-0.5222956538,
-0.0946401954,
0.9730189443,
-0.4230978191,
-0.6590682864,
0.7675462961,
0.1189961284,
-0.124154821,
-0.4076860845,
-0.6880688667,
-0.1665190011,
0.0717175305,
-0.1535747945,
0.4308278859,
0.6122033,
-0.1707255989,
0.4149750173,
0.1482819468,
0.241787985,
-0.3646736145,
0.336050719,
0.9891398549,
-0.782325089,
-0.8851702213,
-0.6319515705,
0.348559618,
-0.1170481518,
-0.1393491328,
0.441775471,
0.2720902264,
0.7885630727,
0.2293002158,
0.7382286191,
-0.0513572432,
0.6075743437,
-0.3984034657,
0.6547548175,
-0.5241975188,
0.0521683469,
-0.0441596583,
-0.8390013576,
-0.3093811274,
0.5253201723,
-0.6159468293,
0.1435489506,
0.7248850465,
0.5558168292,
-0.0824165121,
0.3567792475,
0.0421594866,
0.2743493319,
0.2391049862,
0.6477165818,
0.7890658379,
-0.3298790455,
0.3198808134,
-0.5619443655,
-0.0416195877,
0.0282230955,
-0.571218431,
-0.9520166516,
-0.6298145652,
-0.579456687,
-0.5436338782,
-0.2111087292,
0.9650372267,
0.4259869456,
-1.0808296204,
0.1431601644,
-0.1289774776,
0.1529831737,
0.0757082179,
-0.2983169854,
0.5998415947,
-0.4691176116,
-0.2487927526,
-0.1922807544,
0.7787379026,
-0.1351694912,
-0.4255416095,
0.1974810958,
-0.0694311187,
-0.2797579467,
0.5543743372,
0.0403131805,
-0.8636433482,
-0.7853270769,
-0.4925388098,
-0.2219331414,
0.7087666392,
0.665381372,
-0.7536633015,
0.5766006708,
0.571000874,
0.2743819356,
0.3363914788,
0.0120046455,
0.325812459,
-1.0312601328,
0.0781632364,
0.2692693472,
0.3671185672,
0.70401299,
-0.4430544972,
0.1543573737,
0.3513415158,
-0.5717298388,
-0.250700146,
0.1426146179,
-1.0348263979,
-0.0614732765,
1.1192678213,
-0.4359270632,
-0.6461642385,
-0.2999190986,
-0.1627443582,
0.3317150474,
-0.3824004829,
0.6452713013,
0.6167756915,
-0.2284425348,
-0.1220361218,
-0.3135719597,
0.3406674266,
0.1479894668,
-0.813631773,
0.1703829169,
0.3041547239,
0.3837346435,
0.3675650358,
0.6448042989,
-0.018675819,
-0.120832786,
0.0847470909,
0.4176504314,
0.2151869982,
-0.2813790739,
-0.7124411464,
0.4362329543,
0.2123459578,
-0.2325749248
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01012v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01012v3
|
COPAL-ID: Indonesian Language Reasoning with Local Culture and Nuances
| 2023-11-02T06:14:41 | 2024-04-21T22:11:58 |
Haryo Akbarianto Wibowo, Erland Hilman Fuadi, Made Nindyatama Nityasya, Radityo Eko Prasojo, Alham Fikri Aji
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, 68T50
|
We present COPAL-ID, a novel, public Indonesian language common sense
reasoning dataset. Unlike the previous Indonesian COPA dataset (XCOPA-ID),
COPAL-ID incorporates Indonesian local and cultural nuances, and therefore,
provides a more natural portrayal of day-to-day causal reasoning within the
Indonesian cultural sphere. Professionally written by natives from scratch,
COPAL-ID is more fluent and free from awkward phrases, unlike the translated
XCOPA-ID. In addition, we present COPAL-ID in both standard Indonesian and in
Jakartan Indonesian-a dialect commonly used in daily conversation. COPAL-ID
poses a greater challenge for existing open-sourced and closed state-of-the-art
multilingual language models, yet is trivially easy for humans. Our findings
suggest that general multilingual models struggle to perform well, achieving
66.91% accuracy on COPAL-ID. South-East Asian-specific models achieve slightly
better performance of 73.88% accuracy. Yet, this number still falls short of
near-perfect human performance. This shows that these language models are still
way behind in comprehending the local nuances of Indonesian.
|
[
-0.2905296087,
-0.7374718785,
0.3551885188,
0.3886908293,
-0.3808244765,
0.0000389183,
-0.3764372766,
-0.8191046119,
0.1710936278,
0.6808037162,
-0.1541838199,
-0.8265769482,
-0.1899962127,
0.487970084,
-0.0356341079,
0.8199976087,
0.0423639268,
-0.1246003211,
-0.1462226659,
-0.3964757025,
-0.1948899478,
-0.7239665985,
-0.8158442378,
-0.1732460558,
0.6323566437,
0.4952638447,
0.5356364846,
0.5698565245,
0.3145902157,
0.1695272774,
-0.2436734289,
0.1292237639,
0.0391050614,
-0.134394601,
-0.2997198403,
-0.6879063249,
-0.2196579874,
-0.1662988365,
0.2135266215,
1.0605914593,
0.0255445,
0.070679009,
-0.15417023,
0.88844347,
-0.6195797324,
0.4365541637,
-0.5308346152,
-0.1206505597,
-0.3678438365,
0.300162077,
-0.3853170872,
-0.5515908599,
0.4693204165,
-0.7575751543,
0.0074537736,
0.0532242395,
1.0015524626,
0.409432143,
-0.8087912202,
-0.2426566482,
-0.7916534543,
0.7549594045,
-0.3466354012,
0.1721280813,
0.4907822311,
0.4619967639,
0.0329214036,
-0.4012625813,
-0.6974881887,
-0.3036092818,
-0.055350963,
0.1044300124,
-0.1835633516,
0.0027983894,
0.0172102805,
0.3195799887,
-0.6377794743,
-0.114116542,
-0.633570075,
0.3349906206,
0.8368733525,
-0.0154181849,
0.0272544138,
-0.2670327127,
-0.2855481803,
0.3271570206,
-0.9779396653,
0.1795375794,
0.4143179953,
0.4065585434,
-0.173901245,
0.3966053128,
-0.5002882481,
0.9767304659,
-0.234568879,
-0.211728856,
0.2120799571,
-0.0474471301,
-0.2888380289,
0.0984835252,
0.5294077396,
0.3735535741,
0.6819977164,
0.0563852005,
0.2256209105,
0.3449623287,
-0.189549014,
-0.1603168249,
-0.394133687,
0.508244276,
-0.3972524107,
-0.4472607672,
-0.0611062534,
-0.3694906235,
-0.2350159436,
-0.586925447,
-0.0598362163,
-0.421579808,
-0.6705229282,
0.4537909329,
-0.0261433721,
0.3201074302,
0.5239824057,
-0.5041369796,
0.2847814262,
0.7841260433,
0.6829658747,
-0.3620634973,
-0.2264133543,
0.1629633158,
0.0188203808,
-0.6324606538,
0.9902223945,
-0.6211763024,
-0.2151336968,
0.0466757827,
-0.009425628,
-0.0763494,
-0.7087732553,
0.8486161232,
-0.2658096552,
0.2690330446,
-0.3906045258,
-0.3077701032,
-0.3828599155,
0.237861082,
-0.6984003782,
0.9586780071,
-0.1025325283,
-1.0402801037,
0.6148801446,
-0.8491074443,
-0.5975986719,
-0.0077505889,
-0.2612463236,
-0.1397774518,
-0.0625532642,
0.1626076251,
0.3394272625,
-0.3393011987,
0.5343133807,
-0.4888707697,
-0.4374038875,
0.2826085687,
-0.4229234457,
1.2809617519,
0.7468671203,
0.0124410521,
0.1174615249,
-1.0442795753,
-0.5278850794,
0.2510084212,
-0.2172721177,
-0.9015216827,
-0.0307964347,
-0.0690674558,
0.2533468306,
0.1465579718,
-0.6648746133,
0.4152777791,
-0.4996058941,
0.0678426847,
0.452363193,
0.0628168285,
0.2619534433,
-0.3941045403,
0.2823088765,
0.2390683591,
0.1364644319,
-0.1256964952,
-0.7058898807,
-0.5587450266,
-0.4061560631,
0.1560061276,
0.733150661,
-0.7307804227,
0.3227449954,
-0.416744411,
-0.6961838007,
-0.513805151,
-0.1185629889,
0.2058708072,
0.4202136695,
0.1039066762,
-0.1475106329,
-0.6344262362,
-0.7712278366,
-0.3323469758,
-0.3881116211,
-0.2652808428,
0.5398241282,
0.5860837698,
0.1659436077,
1.0247187614,
-0.4626937211,
-0.1980264634,
-0.4231970608,
0.3283919394,
0.4804763198,
0.346686244,
0.5539961457,
-0.7410407662,
-0.500649929,
0.2195931077,
-0.6832557917,
-0.1034564227,
-0.123190254,
0.2775551081,
0.7893902659,
0.3357666135,
-0.3580248654,
0.302536428,
0.6738835573,
-0.4376910329,
0.7876896858,
-0.1775191873,
0.242969498,
-1.1791586876,
0.4096480608,
0.017679926,
0.1614817232,
-0.4723056257,
0.0673687607,
-0.2006332874,
-0.2710857689,
-0.6138107777,
0.6283704638,
-0.2519869208,
0.2084331065,
-0.1071083993,
-0.0195398629,
0.1051020622,
0.6028539538,
0.6158550382,
0.7699255943,
0.6310367584,
-0.736056447,
0.4540425241,
-0.0486432686,
-0.7181236148,
0.9349594712,
-0.9791747332,
-0.0848696008,
-0.2379526794,
0.3106823564,
-0.7801789045,
-0.4387021661,
0.2801429927,
-0.3253434002,
-0.0601572506,
-0.6764819026,
-0.178538397,
-0.2733146548,
0.1560430974,
0.6000612974,
0.1190855727,
-0.7022947073,
0.3219867647,
0.4267542362,
-0.1406270713,
-0.6997855902,
-0.5706042647,
0.138858363,
-0.4789270163,
-0.7862027287,
0.1578817815,
0.157678172,
-0.8253545761,
-0.016345052,
0.0626051053,
-0.5544958711,
0.2601540387,
0.1841713637,
0.1944156438,
-0.3370275497,
0.2465688437,
0.0235967431,
-0.1475646794,
0.1842533797,
-0.2781172693,
0.2904832959,
-0.5102607012,
-0.3843592107,
-0.2977580428,
0.6582678556,
0.5749029517,
-0.4073198736,
0.7188419104,
0.2427169234,
-0.3833298087,
0.2648197711,
-0.3607176542,
0.3050966263,
-0.3468675911,
-0.0611138828,
-0.9180365801,
-0.7905921936,
0.6494756937,
-0.2895123661,
-0.0140509829,
0.4205781519,
0.3094893992,
-0.1503864229,
0.9506186843,
0.4708113968,
-0.0799140483,
0.1853020638,
-0.1020377204,
0.1530200541,
-0.5506466031,
-0.1561276615,
-0.8957461715,
0.140639931,
-0.7074015141,
-0.2288075238,
0.1671442986,
-0.0245535206,
-0.2365666479,
0.2628291845,
-0.3889488578,
0.772485733,
0.6410655975,
-0.2806432247,
0.5799989104,
-0.3112069666,
-0.2207017541,
0.0732128993,
-0.6522668004,
-0.6747941375,
1.0174461603,
0.1092207357,
0.8993381262,
0.2857051492,
0.6990475059,
0.0047262432,
-0.0700210929,
-0.3651891947,
0.1837730855,
-0.0591018461,
-0.9275329709,
-0.1015803143,
-0.2527975738,
-1.4155391455,
0.1264101863,
-0.0043755411,
-0.9228715301,
0.3118904829,
0.0087604458,
-0.4686318934,
0.1971953958,
-0.9390245676,
1.1815192699,
0.0176696293,
-0.1722020209,
-0.1661391258,
-0.8262421489,
0.6205822229,
0.1914064586,
0.2522124648,
-0.2780198753,
0.2065038979,
0.5446512103,
-0.2265444845,
0.9814905524,
-0.030902639,
-0.1937712431,
0.5517002344,
0.0359462649,
0.264180094,
0.3180426955,
-0.0752484649,
0.4822241068,
0.4618221819,
-0.6431722045,
-0.5991359949,
0.8147921562,
-0.8086418509,
-0.5481563807,
-0.7026812434,
-0.228296563,
0.1459708065,
-0.041125834,
0.0983468443,
0.2643635571,
-0.3511729836,
0.0628313273,
0.6999789476,
-0.3737529814,
0.0720598698,
0.609503746,
-0.2767004371,
-0.2707698345,
0.9681450129,
0.1493303776,
0.0924476162,
0.4661938548,
0.1903600097,
-0.439879477,
-0.111065343,
-0.4033274055,
0.1885216981,
-0.6942693591,
0.1653942317,
-0.5564926863,
0.118519336,
-0.4361304641,
-0.2297588736,
-0.4535045922,
-0.6912116408,
0.0404215306,
0.0850080773,
0.3449749649,
0.6713752151,
-0.0954498723,
-0.1364965439,
-0.5076539516,
0.2299468368,
0.2570002675,
0.4730333686,
-0.5122334361,
-0.1723883301,
-0.0455426089,
-0.1812880933,
0.3254739344,
-1.0553096533,
0.2681431174,
-0.0491249375,
0.3021115065,
0.5794439912,
0.5119048357,
0.5848132372,
0.0246944427,
0.8701508641,
-0.2817545235,
-0.806573987,
0.8393988013,
-0.3640939891,
0.5194615722,
0.5207506418,
0.6763525009,
-1.0202202797,
-0.5813818574,
-0.8479764462,
-0.7945458889,
0.3296052217,
-0.0977037549,
-0.1969375908,
-0.3128520846,
0.2007670105,
0.2195423245,
-0.1436114907,
-0.7577828169,
-0.3283820748,
-0.2146254331,
-0.0694820955,
0.1804033816,
-0.0575768128,
-0.1236047298,
-0.462207824,
0.5833249092,
-0.3453606069,
0.0139227537,
0.3982491791,
-0.0550915338,
0.0997129157,
0.3447930515,
0.6247274876,
0.6531139016,
-0.1777547598,
0.2827188075,
0.3122324646,
-0.0842213631,
-0.0804676712,
-0.145508796,
-0.2789786756,
0.1699660718,
0.1540939659,
0.568490684,
0.0350660011,
-0.6281365156,
0.4804292917,
-0.444385916,
-0.0016955861,
-0.8711729646,
-0.0637768656,
-0.0927653909,
-0.0060157562,
0.2699595094,
0.3700379133,
-0.0591507331,
-0.2274775505,
0.0491200909,
0.0303342324,
-0.2027135044,
-0.2872382402,
0.5089018941,
0.4535058141,
-0.1276036054,
0.4979715943,
-0.3617526293,
-0.1903578937,
0.4464471638,
0.5126821399,
0.6800152659,
-0.1254967302,
0.2765467763,
0.6549947858,
0.3284643888,
0.2440593839,
0.4670082331,
-0.230519861,
-0.8819724917,
-0.8879330158,
-0.4765830934,
-0.6387691498,
0.1628593504,
-0.5394816995,
0.4090633988,
-0.360407263,
0.330668211,
-0.2675549686,
0.3707875013,
-0.642246902,
0.2990726233,
-0.1189997494,
1.2463644743,
-1.3087692261,
1.2429059744,
0.7152639031,
-0.6115887761,
-0.6771026254,
-0.210482657,
0.1163634658,
-0.4464136362,
0.4038494229,
0.1690160185,
0.0304743219,
-0.221987322,
-0.4677861929,
-0.8742487431,
0.7385547757,
0.262681365,
-0.2184126526,
0.3666618168,
0.1641560495,
0.6705514789,
-0.4165780544,
0.2022625357,
0.9338972569,
0.5145936012,
0.1803626269,
-0.8276948929,
-0.1367854476,
-0.5377679467,
-0.0766460076,
-0.0862608403,
-0.4452736676,
0.5430629849,
-0.3623019457,
-0.3441228569,
-0.0770479962,
0.8625870347,
0.426730752,
0.3630310297,
0.4633255899,
0.5569856167,
0.9590480924,
-0.3393855691,
1.2066676617,
-0.3028250933,
-0.1653212607,
1.1278398037,
-0.3840487599,
0.8358327746,
0.482915014,
-0.2043504268,
0.6579881907,
0.7180042267,
0.2942246497,
0.1800182164,
-0.017186828,
-0.6178118587,
-0.2185477763,
-0.4257644713,
-0.3037648201,
0.8110827208,
0.209777534,
0.13266927,
-0.0359102748,
-0.1865049303,
0.3365451992,
0.171281755,
0.0735624805,
0.7636395693,
-0.1234929413,
-0.9491795897,
0.620716691,
-0.0024038933,
0.4898267686,
-0.2711666226,
-0.0432918444,
-0.471804738,
0.0438533016,
-0.1203182861,
-0.7527483702,
0.9118071198,
0.0754672363,
0.0580120385,
0.103119351,
0.7282679081,
-0.5470319986,
-0.3714406192,
-0.1045832634,
0.3973341882,
0.4641769826,
-0.336592257,
-0.6113648415,
0.0461195335,
-0.1827927381,
0.1010963768,
-0.0294690561,
0.7014798522,
-0.4091038406,
0.8267451525,
0.789239049,
0.1996161491,
-0.1148904711,
0.3435280323,
0.2539428473,
-0.7005736232,
-0.5280929208,
-0.4649649858,
0.3681583405,
-0.2929937541,
-0.7382169962,
0.5065555573,
0.5884678364,
1.1921836138,
-0.1400545985,
0.8929169178,
-0.0071322815,
0.6408931017,
-0.2763857245,
0.6501806974,
-0.4252363145,
0.1617713571,
-0.3099564314,
-0.5668598413,
-0.8572748899,
0.8078657985,
-0.4893913567,
-0.3411459029,
0.6984367967,
0.6549970508,
0.1542304158,
0.2945516407,
0.401106596,
0.1898576021,
0.3109064996,
0.7056584954,
0.9170534611,
-0.2202441543,
0.7224434018,
-0.4055118263,
-0.2514200807,
-0.1083138436,
-0.9034084082,
-0.8496097922,
-0.8378777504,
-0.4812711775,
0.0213717185,
0.0651376769,
1.1671173573,
0.459605366,
-0.8804247975,
-0.2413623035,
-0.2934212387,
0.6233347654,
-0.6050261855,
-0.2747357488,
0.3023296893,
-0.3528713584,
-0.7907856107,
0.3106633127,
0.4380764067,
-0.0434699021,
-0.2243157178,
-0.2367830575,
-0.2773874998,
0.1895632148,
0.5684430003,
0.6744142175,
-0.9558714032,
-0.5112782121,
-0.1472586542,
-0.20977135,
0.2073146701,
0.7139362097,
-0.9688994884,
0.4820423722,
0.5668985248,
0.2827263176,
0.3967772424,
-0.2874992788,
0.6926479936,
-0.8402838707,
0.3969858885,
0.1373555362,
0.5023728609,
0.3634990752,
0.0879472792,
0.6324115992,
0.5198858976,
-0.4407944679,
-0.5033613443,
0.4845880866,
-0.9939023256,
-0.3478949368,
1.0502204895,
-0.3406168222,
-0.5807401538,
-0.8406419754,
-0.5333394408,
0.190644294,
-0.1646439731,
1.151237011,
0.5095900893,
0.0426367149,
-0.2201416194,
-0.0342620015,
0.6064586043,
0.2722510695,
-0.8777318597,
0.2078794241,
0.3733946681,
0.2684682012,
0.2333837003,
0.7135532498,
-0.1155697405,
0.4850141406,
0.1301998645,
0.0371306241,
0.1467888951,
-0.6388985515,
-0.2797033489,
0.2330281883,
0.241522029,
-0.1333030015
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00998v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00998v1
|
Replicable Benchmarking of Neural Machine Translation (NMT) on Low-Resource Local Languages in Indonesia
| 2023-11-02T05:27:48 | 2023-11-02T05:27:48 |
Lucky Susanto, Ryandito Diandaru, Adila Krisnadhi, Ayu Purwarianti, Derry Wijaya
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Neural machine translation (NMT) for low-resource local languages in
Indonesia faces significant challenges, including the need for a representative
benchmark and limited data availability. This work addresses these challenges
by comprehensively analyzing training NMT systems for four low-resource local
languages in Indonesia: Javanese, Sundanese, Minangkabau, and Balinese. Our
study encompasses various training approaches, paradigms, data sizes, and a
preliminary study into using large language models for synthetic low-resource
languages parallel data generation. We reveal specific trends and insights into
practical strategies for low-resource language translation. Our research
demonstrates that despite limited computational resources and textual data,
several of our NMT systems achieve competitive performances, rivaling the
translation quality of zero-shot gpt-3.5-turbo. These findings significantly
advance NMT for low-resource languages, offering valuable guidance for
researchers in similar contexts.
|
[
-0.2431277186,
-0.3330988288,
0.3563834429,
0.1892925948,
-0.3828506172,
0.2381434292,
-0.6640375257,
-0.3308883309,
0.2589683831,
0.4852574468,
-0.3451793194,
-0.1509353369,
-0.4458379149,
0.7045865655,
-0.1409085095,
0.8545153141,
-0.5911896229,
0.0916494802,
0.0924185738,
-0.6052120328,
-0.5080106854,
-0.3828549087,
-0.7668142915,
-0.3453992903,
0.5588407516,
0.4307694733,
0.5544070005,
0.9949706793,
0.6775650978,
0.2647008896,
0.0393763259,
-0.07104256,
-0.0782628655,
0.2796458602,
-0.1740910709,
-0.4607566595,
-0.3215540349,
-0.1617921591,
0.7035551071,
0.9074441791,
-0.016006384,
0.4468030035,
0.0955674052,
0.7558786273,
-0.4745849073,
0.2050118446,
-0.6472930908,
0.3498693705,
-0.5423080921,
0.027339479,
-0.0361792669,
-0.5994563103,
0.0653695315,
-0.4583515823,
0.2895050347,
-0.2419334948,
0.5499860644,
0.5215561986,
-0.4118302763,
0.1096368805,
-0.619330287,
0.8105528951,
-0.6188218594,
0.0206032991,
0.3971752226,
0.67261374,
0.085480541,
-0.5503219366,
-0.2628536522,
-0.3070147932,
0.0450134948,
0.0579737835,
0.0053749895,
-0.1489911824,
0.2832295895,
0.5225881338,
-0.7256893516,
-0.0112671349,
-0.1823934019,
0.1869375259,
0.2022117227,
0.1781319678,
-0.0327800699,
-0.4033794701,
-0.2487533987,
-0.1849245727,
-0.7032456994,
-0.2974928617,
0.3351024687,
0.7082241178,
-0.0598226003,
0.7160489559,
-0.6543553472,
0.7089274526,
-0.3825149536,
0.0803817809,
0.4204394221,
-0.6702511311,
-0.236129418,
0.1640728861,
0.8736620545,
0.0530253053,
0.0079445811,
-0.2327486575,
-0.477627039,
0.0200128611,
0.1152673736,
-0.782564044,
0.1272600442,
-0.3461016715,
-0.4917989671,
-0.4084761441,
-0.4623148441,
-0.5974581242,
-0.267001152,
-0.259739548,
0.4288211763,
-0.3259698153,
-0.7420813441,
-0.062794745,
0.0710422695,
-0.0796967894,
-0.0739151314,
-0.8594632745,
0.3574516475,
0.3863263726,
1.174557209,
-0.3167113364,
-0.3530849516,
-0.0172777902,
-0.1862256825,
-0.4029984474,
0.3767231107,
-0.121207647,
0.0780557245,
-0.1213126257,
-0.1264532804,
-0.3135417998,
-0.7753357291,
0.4588792026,
-0.1329842955,
-0.195707798,
-0.4298841655,
-0.0814597234,
0.0066440199,
0.4429659843,
-0.576839149,
1.2181619406,
0.2974251509,
-0.8311443329,
0.1375522017,
-0.5894730091,
-0.6275643706,
-0.0572410822,
-0.2279606014,
-0.2015273422,
0.5162824392,
0.1665379703,
0.4940792918,
-0.6590595841,
-0.1627482921,
0.0130077349,
-0.4646891654,
0.2069642395,
-0.7226518989,
0.5548974872,
0.5965907574,
-0.6741035581,
-0.2832828462,
-0.8302004337,
-0.0033811957,
0.4735409915,
-0.3275788426,
-0.3378926218,
-0.2244567871,
0.0775814131,
0.2938657105,
0.2470675111,
-0.578335464,
0.3084665239,
-0.3893864751,
0.5074964166,
0.2738064528,
-0.0823556185,
0.3152985275,
-0.1880610436,
0.6867909431,
-0.0564078726,
-0.1131042987,
-0.1496300697,
-0.4378338158,
-0.6912670135,
-0.0790936574,
0.3752079606,
0.4856333733,
-1.4033238888,
-0.1041748449,
-0.5936499238,
-0.4796414375,
-0.7845125198,
0.0935234874,
0.5646535158,
0.541058898,
0.3862445354,
-0.2128412426,
-0.5780482888,
-1.0614509583,
-0.2591946125,
0.2287642062,
-0.1643255502,
0.3216782808,
0.3727863729,
0.1239499077,
0.6032871008,
0.0013918313,
-0.1331938654,
-0.3118537962,
0.3256106079,
0.5882816315,
0.483412236,
0.5451378226,
-0.3534291387,
-0.7692942023,
0.5856651068,
-0.8886241913,
0.0953912139,
-0.0150983436,
0.1927842349,
0.3988315463,
0.3028832674,
-0.4243364036,
0.1735349149,
0.8609296679,
0.2762604654,
0.2508164942,
-0.2312844545,
0.2942349017,
-1.2471995354,
0.3140638471,
-0.2839279175,
-0.2230496407,
-0.3043603897,
0.0733668283,
-0.0240398627,
-0.2667769194,
-0.4772497714,
0.3131085634,
-0.3622467816,
-0.4038029611,
-0.2584765255,
-0.0598061271,
-0.5128471255,
0.4910036325,
0.076029934,
1.1480745077,
0.0402099863,
-0.1721998751,
0.1894867122,
-0.1103828475,
-0.5778757334,
0.5250493884,
-0.5214828849,
0.1667976975,
0.3647410572,
0.0579460934,
-0.5148268938,
-0.2061854452,
0.1134321839,
-0.3138914406,
0.0247019455,
-0.5733490586,
-0.7288618684,
-0.2267555594,
0.0839135796,
0.6945089698,
0.6111409068,
-0.3996115625,
0.1973231435,
0.0571930148,
-0.233265847,
-0.6185412407,
-0.8849378228,
0.1786606014,
-0.0802092627,
-0.3394399285,
0.0338443108,
0.4470922053,
0.0222439133,
0.0554264486,
-0.2026118189,
-0.1478304714,
0.1377334595,
-0.0505328737,
-0.3099228442,
-0.6563279629,
-0.2269281149,
-0.0608367324,
-0.2487636656,
-0.0340337902,
-0.7786844373,
0.5437470078,
-0.3442748785,
-0.0874706432,
-0.3087379038,
0.0516717173,
0.3158764839,
-0.2318991721,
0.6569467187,
0.7806043029,
-0.5013482571,
-0.0310282446,
-0.3705840409,
-0.003897001,
-0.409417212,
0.3098149002,
-0.5862916708,
-0.6327791214,
0.3900398314,
-0.1925860494,
-0.2521156669,
0.4773793817,
0.6807780266,
0.0437830575,
0.8465732336,
0.4536804855,
0.0291573089,
0.5448881388,
-0.2653869689,
-0.0486348644,
-0.683904469,
0.3520961702,
-0.5438529253,
-0.4729309976,
-0.9489778876,
-0.464874804,
0.2023939341,
0.1155758128,
-0.1938357353,
1.0220677853,
-0.5904742479,
0.8310627937,
0.6026852131,
-0.1084761247,
0.323854655,
0.0526021868,
-0.4717771113,
-0.356977731,
-0.798268497,
-0.413980335,
1.2463657856,
0.0018298127,
0.3087197244,
-0.0143659618,
0.8871709704,
-0.0684723407,
0.3027320802,
-0.3519756496,
0.342326045,
-0.238286376,
-0.6459987164,
-0.1700128615,
-0.8555012941,
-0.927410543,
0.3295667768,
0.07197541,
-0.282864511,
-0.0597388744,
-0.0322158895,
-0.2001742423,
0.5149110556,
-0.6826036572,
1.1251473427,
-0.1709887832,
-0.2812651098,
-0.1857067496,
-0.5391764045,
0.2572055757,
-0.2848286331,
-0.156731993,
-0.2468874902,
-0.1362090856,
0.5100870132,
-0.3517294526,
0.6252942085,
-0.22718817,
0.3036225736,
0.0453571528,
0.1348735392,
0.426307708,
-0.0080964845,
-0.2069619149,
0.4007464647,
-0.0887252092,
-0.6152362823,
-0.3204374909,
0.7432052493,
-0.7495470643,
0.0543463938,
-0.6650717854,
-0.4349938631,
-0.2351879627,
0.5400129557,
0.3406810164,
-0.2272671163,
-0.1633360386,
0.267369628,
0.4529122412,
-0.2019731253,
0.4026342332,
0.324804008,
-0.0331257917,
-0.772477746,
1.2866345644,
0.3911499679,
0.3128227592,
0.2752518952,
0.090057373,
0.0204135515,
-0.7442659736,
-0.6068154573,
0.0650782362,
-0.4173586667,
-0.3749500513,
-0.4290241301,
-0.06760519,
-0.0109152766,
-0.0810908452,
-1.0134817362,
-0.7272486091,
0.2381985635,
0.1303299069,
0.1979418099,
0.8378511667,
0.039617829,
0.3103539944,
-0.5292183161,
0.1538635045,
0.0309037995,
0.4404089451,
-0.0811769664,
-0.2370352298,
-0.5655964613,
-0.1557518095,
-0.0634486973,
-0.5569210052,
0.3226600885,
-0.2258250862,
0.2315042615,
-0.1584802568,
0.0046201856,
0.4825468659,
-0.6190838814,
0.5611177087,
-0.0079073561,
-0.5986880064,
0.4694083929,
-0.624322474,
0.3711128533,
0.9062401652,
0.284599036,
-0.7790424824,
-0.1778510958,
-0.4219690263,
-0.8776377439,
0.6792991161,
0.5280314684,
0.0033510912,
-0.0464187115,
0.5108254552,
0.1097181365,
0.4173199534,
-0.548861742,
-0.1141741499,
-0.2781243622,
-0.2968332767,
-0.0585384667,
0.2554581761,
0.0808167607,
-0.1623940319,
0.5153183341,
-0.3493795097,
0.2345342934,
0.0502619259,
-0.2030095756,
-0.0843758583,
0.0690136775,
0.6323241591,
0.1872236729,
-0.3448405266,
-0.030640766,
0.4307863712,
-0.4483662844,
0.2450796813,
0.2066186368,
-0.4648572803,
0.1903914064,
0.0963367,
0.7053490877,
0.4449292123,
-0.3205098212,
0.3615225852,
-0.3237854242,
0.001856414,
-0.3860796094,
-0.2980511189,
0.0902802348,
0.0725751519,
0.0419159979,
0.4644373953,
-0.1369403899,
-0.0128176026,
-0.0500850566,
0.0705948472,
-0.2174301893,
-0.3973632157,
0.7568646669,
0.2472250462,
-0.0481693186,
0.6318946481,
-0.2790414691,
-0.1832915395,
0.5113166571,
0.3823860884,
1.0984288454,
-0.0920852199,
0.0576968081,
0.5654808879,
0.5947109461,
-0.4061358571,
0.1650402695,
-0.2657291889,
-0.3280736506,
-0.5589686632,
-0.7005577683,
-0.7512357831,
0.0028824185,
-0.7387979627,
0.1031783149,
-0.5745047331,
-0.2371930033,
-0.1117505804,
0.2672772706,
-0.8339624405,
-0.2472935915,
-0.0426219217,
0.8345873356,
-0.7418786883,
1.192061305,
0.5755013227,
-0.6258882284,
-0.3335361481,
-0.1310748458,
0.0164777003,
-0.631857872,
0.5949771404,
0.1058210358,
-0.0252157822,
0.0160733946,
0.0383983962,
-0.9326481819,
1.0722099543,
0.7425997257,
-0.3156569898,
0.1078200117,
0.5422928333,
0.700935483,
-0.1226247624,
0.1104575396,
0.71711272,
0.4183317721,
-0.3099562824,
-1.0292466879,
0.0016293904,
-0.2633858025,
0.4825110137,
0.1741583943,
-0.5991219282,
0.8136314154,
0.2943037748,
-0.0859364271,
0.4346567094,
0.5643184185,
-0.0714696348,
-0.0768494979,
0.1583397388,
0.5355476141,
0.4332369864,
-0.3452443779,
1.1669719219,
-0.3118604422,
0.265881449,
1.1673562527,
-0.3389624953,
1.0599097013,
0.5128086805,
-0.0704779252,
-0.0370421335,
0.5277271271,
0.0888332799,
0.4453822672,
0.1708054394,
-0.3740375042,
-0.1202437654,
-0.4122230709,
-0.5480690002,
0.4340648055,
-0.0170212071,
-0.2021692395,
-0.0521307588,
0.0907309279,
-0.0059569106,
0.0277391411,
0.0304003544,
0.6482486129,
0.027042795,
-0.6072512269,
0.9115087986,
0.1085199788,
0.7876265049,
-0.4795874655,
0.109130688,
-0.7528615594,
0.5761105418,
0.1409211159,
-0.4284943938,
0.4602870345,
0.276663512,
-0.1183693409,
-0.5469833016,
0.3297177851,
-0.2580784857,
-0.3888627589,
0.117087096,
0.5165908337,
0.1849799305,
-0.1672707945,
-0.6364896297,
0.1130714864,
-0.192291379,
-0.3107185066,
0.5734649301,
0.613591969,
-0.1537312716,
0.3707362711,
0.6506327391,
0.3574113846,
0.1664008498,
-0.1563443393,
0.4954834878,
-0.7702576518,
-0.2034660727,
-0.4593076706,
0.0981531367,
-0.1474220604,
-0.6408231258,
0.7710708976,
0.6727759242,
1.3144562244,
-0.0791761875,
0.7372951508,
0.0229391754,
0.5289615989,
-0.3470083773,
0.9624319673,
-0.4335380495,
-0.0142006781,
-0.068679221,
-1.1955202818,
-0.385712266,
0.6124116778,
-0.045417618,
-0.0032932782,
0.811383605,
0.4460852742,
-0.1738507003,
-0.1525032818,
0.4246004522,
0.228237167,
0.0864090398,
0.7163608074,
0.5840228796,
-0.7713586092,
0.8542304635,
-0.6771417856,
0.0340997465,
-0.1406163126,
-0.8647130132,
-0.8022549748,
-0.3975347877,
-0.1195513085,
-0.2057051659,
0.0620282367,
1.2003724575,
0.4651978612,
-0.8851456046,
-0.5181456804,
-0.1618130356,
0.0379620492,
-0.6771637797,
-0.1081266329,
0.2978695929,
-0.4856686592,
-0.6403963566,
0.7736998796,
0.3691263795,
0.0557078384,
-0.2551491857,
-0.2278600037,
-0.0882570818,
-0.2786444724,
0.3951415122,
0.6729583144,
-0.5910605192,
0.1336207688,
0.0775152594,
-0.4897849858,
0.1259049624,
0.8966988921,
-0.7598125339,
0.3614258766,
0.4874814451,
1.1974390745,
0.7637118697,
-0.5476846099,
0.5173481703,
-1.1929471493,
0.4419183731,
0.2825441658,
0.3864960372,
0.5689082146,
0.2360782325,
1.1019078493,
0.5576943159,
-0.4024702907,
-0.9720774889,
-0.0041104998,
-0.6054664254,
0.2227489352,
0.8476831317,
-0.1293998063,
-0.2883578837,
0.0227665417,
0.0866883397,
0.2814335525,
0.0355844572,
0.5866997838,
0.5764460564,
0.1377328187,
0.0477164462,
-1.1445928812,
0.5657676458,
0.5750852823,
-0.6750516891,
0.1923056096,
0.0151121579,
0.2591705918,
0.0974600837,
0.6951297522,
-0.0496974662,
0.2131285816,
0.3282852173,
0.0437760092,
-0.1288625747,
-0.1126476154,
-0.5491496921,
-0.1995641738,
0.0023011926,
-0.2742606103
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04916v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04916v2
|
Explainable Identification of Hate Speech towards Islam using Graph Neural Networks
| 2023-11-02T04:01:04 | 2023-12-10T15:46:54 |
Azmine Toushik Wasi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG, cs.SI
|
Islamophobic language is a prevalent challenge on online social interaction
platforms. Identifying and eliminating such hatred is a crucial step towards a
future of harmony and peace. This study presents a novel paradigm for
identifying and explaining hate speech towards Islam using graph neural
networks. Utilizing the intrinsic ability of graph neural networks to find,
extract, and use relationships across disparate data points, our model
consistently achieves outstanding performance while offering explanations for
the underlying correlations and causation.
|
[
-0.4693958759,
-1.2546595335,
0.200238362,
-0.0905220136,
-0.0562173985,
0.3095993996,
0.0929340199,
-0.6939963698,
0.2097268105,
0.3383446336,
-0.6794000864,
-0.4876767695,
-0.8948618174,
-0.1199452206,
-0.7091421485,
0.9188670516,
0.265647918,
0.0050783595,
0.2465223819,
-0.2823679447,
0.1024555787,
-0.44173491,
-1.0021666288,
-0.3606376648,
1.0663744211,
-0.117137149,
1.1477774382,
0.7724064589,
0.4007771313,
0.4577299356,
-0.2406348139,
-0.0356210433,
-0.6028148532,
0.0403464362,
0.0326238386,
0.0961727351,
-0.1134373099,
-0.319978565,
0.42232427,
0.7537656426,
0.1255831718,
0.1446431726,
0.0522782281,
0.4879638255,
-0.2352088839,
-0.0062725572,
-0.7136385441,
0.1308315545,
-0.5164589882,
-0.0682881102,
-0.1283584982,
-0.796726048,
0.0057116454,
-0.2666449547,
0.2228027433,
0.0562835,
0.6943168044,
0.0289934538,
-0.5599176288,
-0.5911571383,
-0.725466609,
0.3933533132,
-0.6170986295,
0.3847414553,
0.2629514635,
0.1377532184,
-0.1690165102,
-0.5429259539,
-0.6916742325,
0.1006259918,
-0.0641216561,
-0.1757188886,
-0.461435765,
0.0765079856,
0.1976696551,
0.2637926936,
-0.5526120663,
0.1643688381,
-0.3693683743,
-0.4467898607,
0.6487931609,
0.176754266,
0.7785525322,
-0.4409579933,
-0.1684906632,
0.6257637739,
-0.3223408461,
0.2068089843,
0.9330461621,
0.4045816064,
0.0504276454,
0.4607268274,
0.0440013073,
0.991548717,
-0.3632854521,
-0.3638860583,
0.0408657305,
0.0789014325,
0.0326689333,
0.1852432787,
0.8079648614,
0.374420017,
0.4227206409,
-0.1886870861,
0.1482762694,
0.4196836054,
0.3917271197,
-0.9642100334,
-0.1890850216,
-0.1210500225,
-0.646805048,
-0.5881479383,
-0.4166343808,
-1.0157183409,
-0.8208240271,
0.1615576148,
-0.0785086229,
-0.3257476687,
-0.4973413944,
-0.5522104502,
-0.5311222076,
-0.0653518215,
0.0430646911,
-0.7060562372,
0.4026403129,
0.4199827611,
0.9574685097,
-0.2641454637,
0.0545597523,
-0.0421153083,
-0.0958946198,
-0.2478525043,
0.5295367241,
-0.7797310352,
-0.1674754173,
0.0092432825,
-0.4941597283,
0.0523966253,
-0.4223852456,
0.382494539,
-0.8858594894,
-0.2273645252,
0.1145762205,
-0.4546709657,
-0.7002391219,
0.0470606051,
-0.5999177694,
0.680002749,
0.4165349901,
-1.0613933802,
-0.0714843795,
-0.7281925082,
-0.4153149128,
0.3811877668,
-0.1378092766,
-0.8939036727,
-0.1511823684,
-0.2130416334,
0.2155389339,
-0.0785087794,
0.1378041804,
-0.8275720477,
-0.2172852755,
0.545055747,
-0.4590177536,
1.1568894386,
0.5856001973,
-0.3850384951,
0.4943835735,
-0.8976765275,
-0.0893269032,
0.5474145412,
0.266993314,
-0.5049566627,
0.2737226188,
-0.0057976642,
0.2027075887,
-0.0980295315,
-0.7693631649,
-0.328140676,
-0.5165561438,
0.6615318656,
0.8858555555,
0.2370449752,
-0.1400886327,
-0.3801958561,
0.6609762311,
-0.0669786632,
0.1604160666,
0.5739308,
-0.7964616418,
-0.1577758938,
-0.1727570295,
-0.3576714098,
0.3851427436,
-0.4947348833,
-0.3366730809,
0.1446959823,
-0.5517523289,
-0.097308673,
0.1703154147,
0.3744382858,
0.861862421,
0.1672721952,
0.0848428681,
-1.0208513737,
-1.0530898571,
-0.5520146489,
-0.0767785311,
0.3616323173,
0.5064989924,
0.3525049686,
-0.241839841,
0.7163748741,
-0.1637841314,
0.2661567926,
-0.2829383314,
0.1664233357,
-0.0207467955,
-0.015372429,
0.6504705548,
-1.4109400511,
-0.5588939786,
-0.0225450229,
-0.5704187155,
-0.2098061144,
0.3724272251,
-0.0538909882,
-0.1689828187,
0.4194514453,
0.1753809899,
0.9728956223,
0.5784776807,
-0.4007180929,
0.4650040865,
0.6916901469,
0.0898839533,
-0.9549407363,
-0.2840234041,
0.0782158822,
-0.2822274268,
-0.5800390244,
-0.1433948427,
-0.6169247627,
-0.3884301186,
-0.3653250635,
0.1195376515,
0.0286378115,
-0.0559476465,
-0.3364430368,
0.2526633143,
-0.3157636225,
0.5009152889,
-0.2639317214,
0.5479747653,
0.2588516474,
-0.6318794489,
0.7858287692,
0.4407432377,
-0.2138252109,
0.227999866,
-0.3617445529,
-0.0713445842,
-0.0624650158,
0.0062832618,
-1.4029815197,
-0.1867114455,
0.7180079222,
-0.5843729377,
-0.2347215265,
-0.401614964,
0.1933466047,
-0.7534347773,
0.1343728751,
0.7892356515,
0.3211844862,
-0.5087171197,
0.6336991787,
0.5158082843,
-0.4095805883,
-0.6561247706,
-0.1868541986,
-0.1321334541,
-0.4593994319,
-0.3871022463,
0.3077396154,
0.1616813987,
-0.5223117471,
0.1064649746,
0.0440249406,
-0.2071308047,
0.3970228434,
0.9303970933,
0.2058426887,
-0.2015967071,
0.0291980058,
-0.0937240943,
-0.0263249353,
0.5103920698,
-0.3756683171,
0.7632690072,
0.0089981537,
-0.0134955086,
-0.6717014313,
0.5416485667,
0.636677742,
0.0956664979,
0.7458628416,
0.5186802149,
-0.5369199514,
-0.0017217882,
-0.1344580799,
0.1578121036,
-0.4721016586,
0.698123455,
-0.2716510594,
-0.7468137145,
0.7248123884,
-0.2751114964,
-0.420773983,
0.5436815619,
0.6907362342,
0.027428925,
1.3175734282,
0.3869099021,
0.0142083671,
0.5320560336,
0.1367119253,
0.6409937143,
-0.5639165044,
-0.3634845912,
-0.7310333252,
-0.2616940439,
-0.8035646081,
0.1022256091,
0.31377545,
0.1454167366,
-0.4426658452,
0.0548433326,
-0.6262387037,
0.4553236067,
0.2038672864,
0.0701026693,
-0.1375046372,
0.2005811185,
-0.3625401258,
0.0866484791,
-0.6433879733,
-0.3368473649,
0.8517804742,
0.3017935157,
0.2444454879,
0.2028590143,
0.4687201679,
0.5619558692,
0.6144474149,
-0.73903054,
0.4338796735,
0.0211716536,
-0.7020056248,
-0.4304418266,
-0.7329490781,
-0.908591032,
0.0455217548,
-0.0433226041,
-1.0467494726,
-0.3545036018,
0.1747188717,
-0.29979828,
0.7883646488,
-0.2015738487,
0.9791566133,
-0.0789365843,
-0.3044885099,
-0.2185234576,
-0.4358570874,
0.3277274668,
0.240727514,
0.6449839473,
-0.1588591784,
0.3398725986,
1.3176734447,
-0.6212185621,
0.854796648,
-0.2590000927,
-0.0850115344,
0.4322612882,
0.1703480929,
0.1230858862,
-0.2791975439,
-0.3439931571,
0.5765436292,
-0.2489236742,
-0.5644487739,
-0.4495674372,
0.622328043,
-0.843598783,
-0.3195352256,
-0.1961771101,
-0.7547891736,
-0.1545773894,
0.3629153073,
0.4734758437,
0.670697093,
-0.4128329158,
-0.3487601578,
0.3304525316,
-0.377979517,
0.5563933849,
0.0174062625,
-0.9097937346,
-0.5864549279,
1.2188951969,
0.3565294445,
0.0549882278,
-0.0947604999,
0.4097914696,
-0.3904437721,
-0.8564471602,
-0.5197045803,
-0.0524105281,
-0.655397594,
0.0351626799,
-0.7966239452,
-0.3341978788,
-0.3468642533,
-0.2784326077,
-0.0008849769,
-0.2094964385,
0.1740516871,
-0.1571412534,
0.5716987848,
1.2863608599,
0.0133416802,
0.6936801076,
-0.3900479078,
0.6039147973,
0.3582375646,
0.4219037592,
0.3937915862,
-0.4663775265,
0.05949663,
0.2655863762,
-0.2491941899,
-1.5794532299,
0.3818496168,
-0.1425302178,
0.2325411588,
0.735358119,
-0.0060950899,
0.6133049726,
-0.2793529034,
0.5357376337,
0.2503358126,
-0.9334898591,
0.5119669437,
-0.4393126369,
-0.3656875193,
-0.1479592621,
1.0649966002,
-0.5944839716,
-0.533366859,
-0.7300886512,
-0.6654612422,
0.4834229052,
0.2710548937,
-0.0661217198,
-0.2691259384,
0.4518742263,
0.1611349881,
0.1990436018,
-0.7177170515,
-0.7274309993,
-0.5378671885,
-0.2402670383,
0.0327932797,
-0.3777942061,
-0.4297800958,
-0.3247301877,
0.8266275525,
0.0243975222,
0.2561854422,
-0.0523376018,
-0.1270706207,
-0.253874898,
0.1857740283,
0.6208491921,
1.0022699833,
0.0703820288,
0.24197115,
0.0071714525,
-0.3597215414,
0.1461946815,
0.1032086611,
-0.2940489054,
0.1029967964,
0.2486201525,
0.8152146935,
-0.3003567457,
-0.2269148827,
0.5066946149,
-0.0144627821,
-0.1122064665,
-0.56242311,
-0.1100833789,
0.1429624707,
0.1541247517,
0.3809118569,
0.3338874578,
0.2639990747,
-0.3762479722,
0.3319803774,
0.7033803463,
-0.5758823156,
-0.1608932167,
0.5928326249,
-0.0400241464,
-0.8831706047,
0.576436162,
-0.1830893457,
-1.2565909624,
0.7108753324,
0.9512629509,
0.4211795926,
-0.3495739102,
0.692058444,
0.5024787188,
-0.1091787741,
1.1627920866,
0.2531545758,
-0.1750321686,
-0.9997853041,
-0.0886381492,
-0.8650810719,
-0.1555324942,
0.204317987,
-0.8010776043,
-0.4202710688,
-0.8929440379,
-0.180996716,
0.6775019765,
-0.2079143673,
-0.2848034501,
0.1901265383,
0.5144618154,
0.2020796984,
-0.9511460066,
0.4111685455,
0.1825969964,
-0.3462532163,
-0.9897710681,
-0.3534414768,
0.3138446212,
-1.2748407125,
0.7005162835,
0.2611269951,
-0.5704602003,
0.1265827119,
-0.7230035663,
-0.5143322945,
0.1510174423,
-0.0065322821,
-0.3926260769,
0.0917110816,
0.2478363365,
0.4334675372,
-0.3894464374,
0.3357155621,
0.3387466669,
0.3241964877,
0.0417466611,
-0.323536545,
0.2397447824,
-0.3634576499,
0.1838498414,
0.5629472733,
-0.4162114561,
0.7961977124,
-0.2515777647,
-0.1511045694,
-0.1839147806,
0.6834506392,
-0.3769916892,
0.624147892,
0.5380586982,
0.3500192761,
0.9021428823,
-0.0417400673,
0.9614803791,
-0.177837804,
0.0099498834,
0.9067494273,
-0.0403157249,
0.4186561704,
0.2127715498,
-0.1679895371,
1.1084856987,
0.6082903743,
0.2285439372,
-0.0631197691,
0.6548132896,
-0.4858035147,
-0.2418758869,
-0.5904696584,
-0.3678529859,
0.6395512819,
0.5536792278,
-0.5207275748,
-0.3154952824,
0.4424529076,
0.0148174036,
0.3460301459,
-0.541746676,
0.8873143792,
-0.2757424414,
-0.1326666623,
0.6229613423,
-0.027855834,
0.2954836786,
-0.6942632198,
0.0059884931,
0.4807706475,
0.0311930906,
-0.5054411292,
-0.5228937268,
0.810952425,
-0.1204408482,
-0.2287888676,
-0.0635276735,
0.5587986112,
-0.3266373277,
-0.2752023637,
0.6504164338,
0.1119784117,
0.202106446,
-0.122978583,
-0.9477664232,
0.3122487664,
0.1857916117,
0.0604000911,
0.1907872856,
0.2216951847,
-0.1930973977,
0.7630375624,
0.7541271448,
0.0971442685,
0.2479620129,
0.0765904784,
0.6643067002,
-0.5710849762,
-0.5133902431,
-1.2485804558,
-0.148116827,
-0.2444393337,
-0.1961110383,
0.8641866446,
0.6191330552,
0.711646378,
0.2533290088,
0.9338909984,
-0.0509212576,
0.8110300303,
-0.0485053509,
0.8645746112,
-0.3356529772,
-0.2104668617,
-0.5833392143,
-0.6174196005,
-0.1734481901,
0.7723810673,
-0.580589056,
-0.0905742273,
0.5133209825,
0.8881931901,
0.2210131437,
0.7139816284,
0.2121037543,
0.6526452303,
0.2177112848,
0.4134243131,
1.0589419603,
-0.3315060139,
0.7860559821,
-0.397954613,
-0.298489064,
-0.1501479149,
-0.5407243371,
-0.6618245244,
-0.6148642898,
-0.4968905747,
-0.8703392148,
0.0469608344,
0.8002467155,
0.5498534441,
-0.8385418653,
-0.1917414516,
-0.195098877,
0.8214024305,
-0.5246308446,
-0.2775600255,
0.2460356355,
0.2378572971,
-0.5047684908,
0.164950341,
0.3189152777,
0.0188176092,
0.0763718858,
-0.0330939852,
-0.268230319,
0.0494531728,
0.4740046263,
0.6102324128,
-0.9047122002,
-0.3670353889,
-0.602126956,
0.0312541835,
0.1136157215,
0.9032750726,
-0.5302638412,
0.2827376723,
0.2683224678,
0.7560836077,
0.1485683173,
0.0021542639,
0.0936155766,
-0.285030514,
0.2314767092,
0.4206021428,
0.1618212014,
0.1521374583,
-0.5585497022,
0.1081487387,
0.5749135017,
-0.4015061259,
-0.806740284,
0.6630246043,
-0.9198479652,
-0.2710405886,
0.7923597097,
-0.1144712493,
-0.3711431324,
-0.7293131351,
-0.3424951732,
0.7184913158,
-0.1308348775,
0.7435496449,
0.6617048979,
-0.3647576571,
-0.008974012,
-0.0546280481,
0.5821264386,
0.2420763522,
-0.3224214911,
-0.084614113,
0.5868191719,
0.373333931,
0.199857071,
0.557269454,
-0.0226210542,
0.1759800017,
0.2910455167,
-0.155351311,
-0.3622823656,
-0.326762706,
-0.0567611381,
0.9496355057,
-0.175581798,
-0.1149841771
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00967v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00967v2
|
Vision-Language Interpreter for Robot Task Planning
| 2023-11-02T03:32:30 | 2024-02-20T03:13:30 |
Keisuke Shirai, Cristian C. Beltran-Hernandez, Masashi Hamaya, Atsushi Hashimoto, Shohei Tanaka, Kento Kawaharazuka, Kazutoshi Tanaka, Yoshitaka Ushiku, Shinsuke Mori
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are accelerating the development of
language-guided robot planners. Meanwhile, symbolic planners offer the
advantage of interpretability. This paper proposes a new task that bridges
these two trends, namely, multimodal planning problem specification. The aim is
to generate a problem description (PD), a machine-readable file used by the
planners to find a plan. By generating PDs from language instruction and scene
observation, we can drive symbolic planners in a language-guided framework. We
propose a Vision-Language Interpreter (ViLaIn), a new framework that generates
PDs using state-of-the-art LLM and vision-language models. ViLaIn can refine
generated PDs via error message feedback from the symbolic planner. Our aim is
to answer the question: How accurately can ViLaIn and the symbolic planner
generate valid robot plans? To evaluate ViLaIn, we introduce a novel dataset
called the problem description generation (ProDG) dataset. The framework is
evaluated with four new evaluation metrics. Experimental results show that
ViLaIn can generate syntactically correct problems with more than 99\% accuracy
and valid plans with more than 58\% accuracy. Our code and dataset are
available at https://github.com/omron-sinicx/ViLaIn.
|
[
-0.0479078107,
-0.5603744984,
0.7031784654,
0.3636090755,
-0.0994208604,
-0.3577921689,
-0.1656936109,
-0.1312296242,
0.3721692264,
0.7374684215,
-0.8564867377,
-0.4838167429,
-0.3676978052,
0.2006444335,
-0.1920538247,
0.7810059786,
-0.4479818642,
0.0826256871,
0.0093020676,
0.0999516398,
-0.7306407094,
-0.1004340574,
-0.2868824005,
-0.1164266318,
0.4647779167,
0.2747818828,
0.7038751841,
0.6354597211,
0.6958489418,
0.2971530557,
0.231878832,
0.3627999723,
-0.1037088409,
0.0722204,
0.0502668992,
-0.4440944195,
-0.597463131,
-0.4140176177,
0.6648537517,
0.689455688,
-0.1574711949,
-0.0139762573,
-0.1261502057,
0.5742847919,
-0.781049788,
0.8697796464,
-0.5320388675,
0.2151003927,
-0.102569446,
-0.1550088674,
-0.4821866751,
-0.063541159,
-0.1301836222,
-0.8239216208,
-0.0484728701,
-0.1732340455,
0.5690758824,
0.7639231086,
-0.254729569,
-0.1572292596,
-1.0135821104,
0.7647916079,
-0.4868486822,
0.1992603391,
0.0983039513,
0.6277735233,
-0.5284020305,
-0.2519973218,
-0.8953245282,
-0.0249233078,
-0.088611491,
0.5223580599,
-0.225990355,
0.1862571537,
0.3157926798,
-0.3008851111,
-0.6781249642,
-0.181229189,
-0.4518197179,
-0.0049691778,
0.6932805777,
0.367243588,
0.1406401843,
-0.6075776815,
-0.4146466553,
-0.097762309,
-0.649594903,
-0.1439051777,
0.347484529,
0.1628526449,
0.0249952897,
0.924602747,
-0.2742808163,
0.9831758738,
-0.4288902879,
-0.2205728889,
0.0612877235,
-0.4327868521,
-0.2927086055,
-0.2378086597,
0.5695536733,
0.7021899819,
0.3732205927,
-0.0317085534,
-0.4466782212,
0.2700875401,
0.521653533,
-0.4391448796,
-0.4085849226,
0.2224865258,
-0.3024186194,
-0.1347558945,
-0.0291193277,
-0.7139412165,
-0.316842258,
-0.5015563965,
0.2749581337,
-0.3731846809,
-0.1848351657,
0.4170678854,
-0.1076653525,
0.0348932333,
0.4302973449,
-0.3355058432,
-0.1005495638,
0.4975985885,
0.442417562,
-0.0249996688,
-0.480735451,
-0.7223153114,
0.5207304955,
-0.3724466562,
0.7872300148,
-0.313355267,
-0.3324150741,
-0.0286018066,
-0.1465369612,
-0.2097970098,
-0.3689962626,
0.3682814837,
0.062081486,
0.023547681,
-0.0012717303,
0.0507050641,
-0.2698498964,
0.2969893217,
-0.6368711591,
0.7064362168,
0.2482324541,
-0.5794276595,
0.4896439612,
-0.6878159642,
-0.3525745571,
0.2496290207,
-0.4005537331,
-0.092772238,
-0.1707348078,
0.2538364828,
0.6186158657,
-0.2724741399,
0.6719639897,
0.1707803458,
0.0314324126,
0.0923257694,
-0.1058247387,
0.5859337449,
0.2075473219,
-0.2859296501,
0.6302904487,
-0.8145343065,
0.0428651534,
0.1390866488,
-0.2740292847,
0.2326759398,
0.3846786022,
-0.0615743026,
0.2875204682,
0.3805756569,
-0.4353342354,
0.0349837616,
-0.5673329234,
0.1034639999,
0.7637028098,
-0.2681494951,
0.2337594181,
-0.2784176469,
0.8286613226,
-0.2595780194,
0.3262816072,
-0.2245491743,
-0.5551375151,
-0.7880753875,
-0.093477644,
-0.2597950399,
0.7686770558,
-1.4037817717,
0.3758068681,
-0.3938665092,
-0.4514257908,
-0.1323047578,
-0.0189277567,
0.629998982,
0.2404862791,
0.159768492,
-0.1885975599,
-0.5977991819,
-1.0054053068,
-0.017191004,
-0.4131537378,
-0.0028871016,
0.3366989195,
0.4891436994,
-0.2185272574,
0.8268589377,
-0.5101568699,
-0.3380973339,
-0.7731972933,
0.1602314413,
0.2398376465,
0.1899820119,
0.5128687024,
-0.8063670993,
-0.3014487624,
-0.1562727541,
-0.7446787953,
-0.1748834848,
-0.397541523,
-0.3150545955,
0.2012182474,
-0.0238610823,
-0.7548085451,
0.3709801435,
0.7004100084,
-0.1889660805,
0.7721831799,
-0.2635934353,
-0.194151327,
-1.3450603485,
0.0633389652,
0.1984141767,
0.0014133572,
-0.640532732,
0.1510657668,
-0.2554956377,
-0.2233329266,
-0.6298296452,
0.5336837769,
-0.2244297862,
-0.1546573043,
-0.158082664,
0.2393136472,
-0.3054520488,
0.6575667262,
0.1936710328,
0.4353603423,
0.6389733553,
-0.6262529492,
0.7950924635,
0.4237979054,
-0.2699246705,
0.5356798172,
-0.5670795441,
-0.2229188085,
-0.2827669382,
0.4121553004,
-0.6419957876,
-0.605717361,
0.6733425856,
-0.1578723043,
0.136635378,
-0.2576352358,
-0.4593972862,
-0.4715708494,
-0.1773681641,
0.2025112659,
0.1630746275,
-0.2939711511,
0.8766972423,
0.4904622138,
-0.2078270614,
-0.667098999,
-0.3725245297,
0.0179010462,
0.1237515882,
-0.6868156791,
0.0656508654,
0.0752736554,
-0.3085983694,
-0.1644544005,
-0.2259573638,
-0.0414092615,
-0.1550826579,
0.592861414,
0.5108709335,
0.2189727575,
-0.1810340881,
0.0055314107,
-0.4738089442,
0.2367607355,
-0.0625486597,
0.6334384084,
0.1864049733,
-0.3806838095,
-0.4810328782,
0.2101159692,
0.3412173688,
-0.3815488219,
0.3786838055,
0.4742963612,
-0.3725274205,
-0.2259334624,
-0.0086300885,
0.153516084,
-0.3774321973,
0.38660568,
-0.7092689872,
-0.2353080809,
0.0477636866,
-0.2478744984,
0.4281952977,
0.4063844979,
0.4862510264,
-0.0383255035,
0.9949786663,
0.7190254331,
0.4445931017,
0.3800528646,
-0.307800293,
0.1737340093,
-0.4788259268,
-0.3361365199,
-0.2494380474,
-0.3675401211,
-0.3426934779,
-0.5574893355,
0.5997044444,
-0.1043143645,
0.2154607475,
0.7915582657,
-0.4579711258,
0.2371672988,
0.3535380363,
-0.1864102483,
-0.2056370825,
-0.1241059825,
-0.0176781546,
-0.0020030627,
-0.5890384912,
-0.8678206801,
0.9642214179,
0.0182816777,
0.8230902553,
-0.0785428509,
0.6333338022,
-0.0764087662,
0.0054512452,
-0.5572470427,
0.9699611068,
-0.209610939,
-0.5238277912,
-0.3639544845,
-0.403901726,
-0.9680740237,
0.1360359937,
-0.338206321,
-0.8908593059,
0.1527280658,
0.3425651491,
-0.205287382,
0.190491274,
-0.6811839342,
1.2462179661,
-0.4646149874,
0.0924284011,
-0.395560652,
-0.6336328983,
0.0702583045,
-0.077581495,
0.1112080216,
-0.2870160937,
0.2279076576,
0.7254044414,
0.0462307408,
0.7685127258,
-0.4076573551,
-0.1695614308,
0.3217995763,
0.4480600655,
0.6997435689,
-0.0997159109,
-0.1593589038,
0.0279677045,
0.1347353309,
-0.1160750017,
-0.5101095438,
0.2772149444,
-0.234754622,
-0.5800918341,
-0.1440288275,
-1.0345695019,
0.0562028475,
0.1241046339,
-0.0830906257,
0.357986331,
-0.2117970139,
-0.1716655195,
0.0494851246,
-0.5474004745,
0.2786232531,
0.3073149621,
-0.5222286582,
0.0702660456,
1.1315536499,
-0.245990783,
0.2004166245,
0.637683332,
-0.1080809832,
0.0652540475,
-0.394397825,
-0.8173431754,
0.0949154422,
-0.6473912001,
-0.0457982011,
-0.539808929,
-0.1581213325,
-0.1228694618,
-0.1899776161,
-0.4028022885,
-0.5952729583,
0.1799345613,
0.2203834504,
-0.0384297185,
0.9756066203,
0.0219927002,
0.3718689382,
-0.6468321681,
0.6238527298,
-0.1498268396,
-0.0703308955,
-0.7189475298,
0.1954453886,
-0.1342241764,
0.2256182134,
-0.4608921707,
-0.9235425591,
0.6474790573,
-0.128632769,
0.4338496029,
0.2943378985,
0.0668617636,
0.5225424767,
-0.4348926544,
0.6534540057,
0.2601759136,
-0.6653977036,
1.0323810577,
-0.2696075737,
0.1738541722,
0.0324797817,
0.194168523,
-0.2720223963,
-0.6576207876,
-0.3713688552,
-0.6534964442,
0.9049632549,
0.4046559334,
-0.1417730302,
0.0129569499,
0.3757618964,
0.2098552734,
0.1973661333,
-0.7338552475,
-0.0868415609,
-0.1279307455,
-0.3349228799,
-0.1276168078,
-0.2968690097,
-0.2901368141,
-0.0122480541,
0.3269375265,
-0.3311727643,
0.616163671,
-0.2145341635,
-0.0901080817,
-0.2996620834,
0.3279782832,
0.4486191273,
1.0176452398,
-0.0270260908,
0.1334669888,
0.1491693854,
-0.257494092,
-0.2952729762,
0.2326160669,
-0.3146417439,
0.2070631087,
0.3740603328,
0.7274804115,
-0.0707204789,
-1.0283135176,
0.3340724111,
0.1398624629,
-0.2286393791,
-0.4875636399,
0.3918558955,
-0.2475415915,
0.3869538009,
-0.0893219411,
0.2378466129,
-0.0801815987,
-0.4324472845,
-0.1775532216,
0.3864033222,
-0.1880126595,
-0.4615601599,
0.755141139,
0.1322568953,
-0.2436955571,
0.4304172397,
-0.4079218805,
-0.5310142636,
0.7055127025,
0.462495327,
0.6209959984,
0.1028769836,
0.5512468815,
0.4220858216,
0.3421188295,
0.147590965,
1.0795171261,
-0.0321186259,
-0.7877423167,
-0.7238754034,
-0.8173736334,
-0.331451267,
-0.3847748339,
-0.3878567219,
0.3505794406,
-0.1740136892,
-0.0769497156,
0.0356542617,
-0.3714340329,
-0.5376175642,
0.2204572111,
-0.0927477404,
0.3400306106,
-0.4929628074,
0.6952977777,
1.1531302929,
-0.3620992303,
-0.8031287789,
0.0476708598,
0.0563740619,
-0.9061387181,
0.9448183179,
0.0609087609,
-0.3238488138,
-0.2803162038,
-0.2622291446,
-0.5869697928,
1.0716664791,
0.5617672205,
-0.5669375062,
-0.2907030582,
0.3521405756,
0.4139617085,
-0.3440353274,
-0.3323943615,
0.2760589123,
0.808445096,
0.050226938,
-1.1798934937,
-0.036623098,
-0.1520240307,
-0.0162919667,
0.4947874844,
-0.2355058938,
0.6603804231,
-0.3583556712,
-0.4533982277,
0.1602283418,
0.250598222,
0.0869321525,
0.1911960244,
0.6425736547,
0.3972919285,
0.2795520127,
-0.2545488775,
1.2866069078,
-0.5562945604,
-0.1447853148,
0.9744247198,
-0.3296794295,
0.7071156502,
0.3861807287,
-0.0921291634,
0.1919959784,
0.1495154798,
-0.0963857472,
0.3183381855,
0.0185340643,
-0.0506481044,
-0.3185414374,
-0.1311458051,
0.1857834309,
0.7503939867,
0.1139001772,
-0.1116891056,
-0.2040726542,
0.0763206929,
-0.224196896,
0.0644460097,
-0.1203870103,
0.3973433971,
-0.1498693228,
-0.632740438,
0.1449826658,
0.185311541,
0.1763188839,
-0.3661911488,
-0.1989594847,
0.2419807911,
0.4429021478,
-0.1598141193,
-1.2011650801,
0.5500147343,
0.0950651392,
0.0517158397,
-0.5905012488,
0.5883816481,
-0.1843690723,
-0.5142046809,
0.0960769802,
0.7754591107,
0.5952996612,
-0.0403201021,
-0.5625880361,
-0.051355347,
0.1006114706,
0.1398807913,
-0.0478931069,
0.4106125832,
-0.1734718084,
1.0338337421,
0.3146481216,
0.2514279485,
0.1356879771,
0.0492026582,
0.6954462528,
-0.5025690794,
-0.1970775276,
-0.5270299911,
0.6036509871,
0.3709742427,
-0.2394592315,
0.6152722836,
0.5788382292,
0.9219815135,
-0.3179483116,
0.3865647614,
-0.299872458,
0.1156487092,
-0.6340999603,
0.3780983388,
-0.5578435063,
0.0838239938,
-0.2320574671,
-1.1573563814,
-0.3213337362,
0.7779010534,
-0.2465703636,
-0.1329082847,
0.6238051057,
0.875805676,
0.0976824909,
-0.324400425,
0.3554882109,
-0.0386791378,
0.3453146815,
0.7301902771,
0.874666214,
-0.0656192452,
0.8946104646,
-0.2669190466,
-0.08757855,
0.0422165878,
-0.495754689,
-0.7478457093,
-0.7536523938,
-0.2541744709,
-0.0700342581,
0.219430685,
0.5980308652,
0.6432022452,
-0.4286878407,
-0.4166061878,
-0.2323500514,
0.1944449246,
-0.263969183,
-0.163158685,
0.1453282982,
-0.217718184,
-0.8316057324,
0.5179429054,
0.5906686187,
-0.1804110557,
-0.3805033863,
-0.4312141836,
0.1374583393,
-0.235511288,
0.6442373991,
0.0550589748,
-0.8577381968,
-0.1798071861,
-0.0601143576,
0.1192574352,
-0.1079256609,
0.7795316577,
-0.5547419786,
0.7913289666,
0.1298205256,
0.114639163,
0.3370525837,
-0.3338471651,
0.8127320409,
-0.7525924444,
0.2594463229,
0.1994574368,
0.5266939402,
-0.0511963442,
-0.1482111514,
0.7099046111,
0.0038935984,
-0.2911858261,
-0.563316524,
0.7245590687,
-1.2611391544,
-0.1336054951,
1.1999440193,
-0.0357028954,
-0.2883098423,
0.0967480689,
-0.641269505,
0.4019747078,
-0.0156847965,
0.6800584793,
0.4378440678,
-0.424770385,
-0.2038226575,
-0.7850657701,
0.2660803199,
0.2186332941,
-0.8575888276,
0.1672308445,
0.8933490515,
-0.2964271009,
0.3524658382,
0.4543657005,
0.041771777,
0.5533187985,
0.1417744011,
0.4804639518,
-0.0587097444,
-0.7817676067,
0.2699453533,
-0.1194557473,
0.0017906504,
-0.2577730417
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10749v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10749v1
|
Measuring Five Accountable Talk Moves to Improve Instruction at Scale
| 2023-11-02T03:04:50 | 2023-11-02T03:04:50 |
Ashlee Kupor, Candice Morgan, Dorottya Demszky
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Providing consistent, individualized feedback to teachers on their
instruction can improve student learning outcomes. Such feedback can especially
benefit novice instructors who teach on online platforms and have limited
access to instructional training. To build scalable measures of instruction, we
fine-tune RoBERTa and GPT models to identify five instructional talk moves
inspired by accountable talk theory: adding on, connecting, eliciting, probing
and revoicing students' ideas. We fine-tune these models on a newly annotated
dataset of 2500 instructor utterances derived from transcripts of small group
instruction in an online computer science course, Code in Place. Although we
find that GPT-3 consistently outperforms RoBERTa in terms of precision, its
recall varies significantly. We correlate the instructors' use of each talk
move with indicators of student engagement and satisfaction, including
students' section attendance, section ratings, and assignment completion rates.
We find that using talk moves generally correlates positively with student
outcomes, and connecting student ideas has the largest positive impact. These
results corroborate previous research on the effectiveness of accountable talk
moves and provide exciting avenues for using these models to provide
instructors with useful, scalable feedback.
|
[
-0.1120921448,
-0.7228833437,
0.6813205481,
-0.1289321333,
0.1900637299,
0.1136998907,
-0.3992715776,
-0.2160689682,
0.1259353608,
0.0492343418,
-0.1819981933,
-0.5856762528,
-0.7109478712,
-0.2450121939,
-0.7018558383,
1.2445844412,
0.1202504411,
0.3282328546,
-0.0221492909,
-0.0763693005,
-0.9316256642,
-0.1733134091,
-0.5980690122,
-0.2084307522,
0.4159722924,
0.770245254,
0.6003685594,
0.7277928591,
0.777038455,
0.312392205,
-0.0054096603,
0.0106121525,
-0.5467079282,
-0.5285043716,
0.0217905268,
-0.7023265362,
-0.72656703,
0.3651709259,
0.678121686,
0.8950693607,
-0.6730872989,
0.3115217388,
0.1210908741,
0.4951735437,
-0.2668150067,
0.2158928365,
-0.3327985108,
-0.1510572881,
0.0567904785,
0.0182896424,
-0.7053295374,
-0.9222211838,
0.2916455865,
-0.376390636,
0.2286884338,
-0.5155523419,
0.6900010109,
0.1845917404,
-0.3041552603,
-0.6407211423,
-0.7404009104,
0.6703183651,
-0.7702918649,
0.2790000141,
0.3836474121,
0.3974055052,
0.0906622782,
-0.9651335478,
-0.2764643133,
-0.3066636622,
0.0101926168,
0.0929842666,
-0.3365415037,
0.0655126646,
0.2448932976,
0.3589145243,
-0.1503410339,
0.2140983641,
-0.5947547555,
0.0635852292,
0.4781532586,
0.2952560484,
0.2789895535,
0.4289190769,
-0.2712678313,
-0.1170609444,
-0.5002384782,
0.3624441624,
0.3538228273,
0.2999567986,
-0.3623264134,
0.2467222065,
0.0262935255,
0.9593096375,
0.6073635221,
-0.3528181016,
-0.0994350314,
-0.4135516584,
0.2785357535,
-0.0082183471,
0.3690745234,
0.2291759402,
0.1010973975,
-0.4393213391,
0.2645855248,
0.0813513622,
0.3142100275,
-0.9705886245,
-0.7598193288,
0.0973360166,
-0.3539790511,
-0.0640163869,
0.3574748337,
-0.4999166429,
-0.3487565219,
-0.7425283194,
0.6944327354,
-0.6448984146,
-0.1279732287,
-0.1332110614,
-0.225843057,
0.2388309389,
0.6451329589,
-1.091775775,
0.5130066872,
0.6587721705,
1.0018923283,
-0.2714482546,
-0.2008168697,
-0.678034544,
0.1369254887,
-0.5355013609,
0.8676096201,
-0.7134857774,
-0.1391667426,
0.0531896502,
-0.3662339449,
-0.0453036986,
-0.3363792002,
0.16550982,
-0.0306276008,
0.3869489133,
-0.0878629684,
-1.2821557522,
-0.2208281904,
0.256120652,
-0.2663155198,
0.5275700688,
0.1446154416,
-0.2856834531,
0.3892656267,
-0.8572239876,
-0.0384880714,
0.1400013119,
-0.1074404269,
-0.3135223389,
0.1832519323,
0.0515607893,
0.4606550932,
0.0597212128,
-0.1451466084,
-0.0605395213,
-0.6033008695,
0.5000818372,
0.0154922996,
0.5256944895,
-0.0416357033,
-0.6037994623,
0.4448291659,
-0.7217506766,
0.5742271543,
-0.3029980659,
-0.4388678372,
-0.1977279037,
-0.0014392061,
-0.5314232707,
-0.4126456976,
0.0058915433,
-0.3361686468,
0.496108532,
-0.0359137543,
0.5360545516,
0.7521258593,
0.1293592602,
0.380428344,
-0.3103762865,
0.489749223,
-0.1017210484,
0.2232460082,
-0.3827347159,
-0.3323024809,
-0.8159471154,
-0.5875400305,
0.4251818955,
0.0408311784,
-0.3508298993,
-0.0250295755,
-0.4534544647,
-0.8668879271,
-0.4542554021,
-0.0139689315,
0.2314623743,
0.1382448375,
0.3028694689,
-0.5964294672,
0.0665479302,
-0.2901618183,
-0.5521057248,
-0.0329435207,
-0.1973175555,
0.0220806468,
0.2022479475,
-0.0365280695,
1.0560280085,
-0.5996952057,
-0.3468343914,
-0.1260609925,
0.6261785626,
0.0712378696,
0.3779928386,
0.4353001714,
-0.29576087,
-0.8591771722,
-0.2026621848,
-0.277603507,
0.2260980159,
-0.2272192836,
0.2041496336,
-0.341037184,
0.0757624358,
-0.2781826854,
0.3734121621,
0.3015264273,
-0.2904072702,
0.1534089446,
-0.2219602913,
0.3233950734,
-0.5662336946,
-0.5973642468,
-0.2410262674,
-0.0673958957,
-0.6957030296,
-0.0748787969,
0.283159405,
-0.2648504078,
-0.2984423339,
-0.0478672497,
-0.635756731,
-0.0620524809,
-0.2766121924,
0.5829897523,
-0.493884474,
0.4954607487,
-0.2246650159,
0.8488412499,
0.3356176019,
-0.6327025294,
0.1377607882,
0.34581846,
-0.4905250967,
0.8290095925,
-0.6332170963,
0.7025685906,
0.346500963,
0.3737388253,
-1.0485658646,
-0.1767632514,
-0.1700957417,
-0.6527110338,
0.2871489823,
-0.3189180195,
-0.1562490761,
-0.1026789844,
-0.2723996639,
-0.1840510219,
0.4344562888,
-0.5755562186,
0.381944716,
0.4630067647,
0.035762582,
-0.016016433,
-0.4701640308,
-0.0334036089,
-0.2457117438,
-0.2548365593,
0.0828127414,
-0.1151885763,
-0.1263468713,
-0.1314955056,
0.0207560807,
-0.4051259458,
-0.0858256668,
0.2085940242,
0.0988257825,
-0.0945944488,
0.2391281128,
-0.4474899173,
-0.0179037433,
0.1714213938,
-0.4580232501,
0.2639449239,
-0.497515738,
-0.4815661609,
-0.6867728233,
0.1340556741,
0.4852430522,
-0.0626980364,
0.6244158745,
1.0120916367,
-0.0849153623,
-0.1260478795,
-0.4520241618,
-0.5782392025,
-0.4049249291,
0.2028998435,
0.0294957999,
-0.8875353932,
0.2098661661,
-0.3215255141,
0.3669934571,
0.0484899282,
0.3235577345,
-0.0869094953,
1.0795563459,
1.0279533863,
0.215455547,
0.7426053286,
-0.4517742693,
0.3740842342,
-0.656437993,
-0.0992137194,
-0.5848143697,
-0.3559954762,
-0.5668878555,
-0.4671403766,
0.4037201107,
0.1708561331,
-0.218645364,
0.5838747025,
-0.6603007317,
0.587369144,
0.6149409413,
0.1996818483,
0.1785597503,
-0.1539676189,
0.1793070883,
-0.3701549768,
-0.8313866854,
-0.4386184216,
1.1206818819,
0.3433381617,
0.7494378686,
0.523129642,
0.686837554,
0.1969226301,
0.6950349212,
-0.8880438209,
0.4319885373,
0.2077101767,
-0.4637089372,
-0.5270245075,
-0.4422162473,
-0.7317377329,
-0.0504587404,
0.0834668353,
-0.9805436134,
-0.208856836,
0.3859067261,
-0.1563338488,
0.3439296782,
-0.9851622581,
0.833720088,
-0.219003588,
-0.3162789345,
-0.7555550933,
-0.4077034891,
0.1089308634,
0.1331461817,
0.120304659,
-0.0179231409,
0.1988167316,
0.8518072367,
-0.6779513955,
1.0757465363,
-0.1781876236,
-0.1227914244,
0.8716775179,
0.0730891302,
0.727782011,
-0.5499120951,
0.4394179583,
0.3189310431,
0.0578490756,
-0.4265605509,
-0.7999212742,
0.5146804452,
-0.7892391086,
-0.3226263225,
-0.1611910164,
-0.4199922383,
-0.2475867718,
-0.1773176938,
0.0754167885,
0.4335058033,
0.0510322414,
0.4188090861,
0.6473106742,
0.2231999934,
0.4831583798,
0.98310256,
0.0118803233,
-0.4115067124,
1.2885693312,
0.4551308155,
0.679582715,
0.3371084034,
0.3245488703,
-0.1440180093,
-0.2942202389,
-0.3213724792,
-0.1010941863,
-0.8013179898,
-0.0568625182,
-0.2973241508,
0.2275165617,
-0.3469634354,
-0.2901859879,
-0.4089996219,
-0.646674037,
-0.2064715028,
-0.1964651793,
0.2353769541,
0.8811253309,
-0.1748715192,
0.7074143887,
-0.7653286457,
-0.2053475678,
0.6115850806,
0.1762925982,
0.1782951355,
-0.922267437,
-0.5476642251,
0.0505516045,
-0.9786391258,
-0.9465219378,
0.1914886534,
0.2675575912,
0.4244808853,
0.5075919032,
-0.2136541456,
1.0069770813,
-0.559473455,
0.8994808197,
0.6071183085,
-1.1676635742,
0.7029058337,
-0.3735026121,
0.3164879084,
0.0187942125,
0.3806137443,
-0.2563308179,
-0.5763407946,
-0.8553663492,
-0.5483279824,
0.6332185268,
0.0710847005,
0.1816313416,
0.0718544945,
0.1823829859,
0.0755602941,
0.1495731473,
-0.4907197952,
-0.2195783257,
-0.2076084763,
-0.3358058333,
0.2404151857,
-0.1473721713,
-0.3302588165,
-0.3295021355,
0.3658207357,
-0.3580254614,
0.4864463508,
-0.2634110153,
0.2686492205,
0.0075365077,
0.4853234291,
0.783721447,
1.0508469343,
0.1045653224,
-0.0393888131,
0.4314620495,
-0.5260546803,
0.0655839965,
-0.379792124,
-0.0993725136,
0.0852296054,
0.5515778661,
0.6330265999,
0.5763962269,
-0.2840998471,
0.4887232184,
-0.1751033366,
-0.0047177202,
-0.277297765,
0.4779238105,
-0.0795850232,
0.1439215094,
0.2605188489,
0.0069347392,
0.1718096733,
-0.5094537139,
0.2559572458,
0.1871756762,
-0.7780489922,
-0.4424458742,
0.5816203356,
0.4640029669,
-0.6672605276,
0.538790524,
0.3363353908,
-0.2294419408,
0.5418995023,
0.59905231,
0.7521238327,
-0.0021298581,
0.5704126358,
0.538900733,
0.1840086728,
-0.0625065789,
-0.1517219543,
-0.4178061485,
-0.342921108,
-0.3994597197,
0.1117539778,
-0.9914938807,
-0.2185426056,
-0.999987185,
0.2305325717,
-0.6255729795,
-0.2970828712,
0.2388643175,
0.1160485074,
-0.5069974661,
-0.0453617871,
-0.1908338964,
0.4398506284,
-0.6264579296,
0.5686320662,
0.7368415594,
-0.5901180506,
-1.3853911161,
-0.0107648596,
0.3036479354,
-0.4393055439,
0.4809826314,
0.1442801505,
-0.0209516101,
0.2144518048,
-0.8878804445,
-0.8910003901,
0.9916015863,
0.3487503231,
-0.6295768023,
0.2972131073,
-0.2528621256,
0.6602646112,
-0.3733356893,
0.7263160348,
0.2533992827,
0.2277060598,
0.0787073225,
-0.8510612249,
-0.4666889012,
0.4736610651,
-0.2609657049,
0.2199176401,
-0.8747854233,
0.6152314544,
-0.7420861721,
-0.1729524732,
-0.0744509548,
0.9130282998,
-0.1713807434,
0.1683847308,
0.2198145986,
0.4408453405,
1.0107263327,
-0.3346485198,
0.9342701435,
-0.2767964005,
0.509608984,
1.2757006884,
0.2471737713,
0.8674741387,
0.2829148471,
-0.5278333426,
0.7096711993,
0.373927325,
0.113171339,
0.2925798893,
0.1924867779,
-0.2265490592,
-0.2406181246,
0.0377358161,
-0.3717372417,
0.4539882243,
0.4246127307,
0.065677613,
0.0519441813,
-0.043701753,
0.1835343689,
0.2180201709,
-0.4192013741,
0.795925796,
-0.1465402842,
-0.7268089652,
0.4908785224,
-0.0661973208,
0.1364340782,
-0.5323847532,
-0.3761010766,
-0.3399458528,
0.6386922598,
-0.2104793787,
-0.5066118836,
-0.0998480469,
0.2162762135,
0.0116344653,
-0.2494277656,
0.1776674539,
-0.6749077439,
-0.1635141671,
-0.2330420464,
0.0581725687,
0.4446372092,
0.5541430712,
-0.2792101502,
0.0398804545,
0.1975801885,
0.1571098864,
0.4112048447,
0.576598227,
0.0980093107,
0.7392694354,
0.5812353492,
0.0053163129,
0.1222817525,
0.1247729212,
0.4792511463,
-0.4112286866,
-0.347491473,
-0.4797852635,
0.6699374914,
-0.1823263913,
-0.6139580011,
1.1052191257,
0.2158234119,
0.8836703897,
-0.1612296999,
0.3456989229,
-0.0791549981,
0.8252745271,
-0.3230598569,
0.2403842509,
0.0514218062,
0.2469866276,
-0.3995028734,
-0.6750686169,
0.1021216363,
0.8633341789,
-0.3358039558,
0.0126665384,
0.7307333946,
0.2335921973,
0.1553006619,
0.1519031376,
0.3048711717,
0.2195940614,
0.5903407931,
0.3138028085,
0.6311537027,
-0.5238605738,
0.6538282633,
-0.0486730896,
-0.4847932756,
-0.0508070178,
-0.6758185029,
-0.952342391,
-0.3448255062,
-1.0222918987,
-0.0139735322,
-0.0343039595,
0.6064911485,
0.8946802616,
-0.839427352,
-0.3416726589,
-0.2593851984,
0.0878944397,
-0.6464650631,
-0.2865209877,
0.3608257473,
-0.7214682698,
-0.7513024211,
0.3495750427,
0.1659645885,
0.1069750488,
-0.0151128611,
-0.0457046665,
0.0662064478,
0.111116387,
0.553288579,
0.2439344972,
-0.7695964575,
-0.6913939714,
-0.0737700835,
-0.2052023262,
-0.1008326635,
0.938169539,
-0.3960647285,
0.4868576229,
0.087640591,
0.6579137444,
0.5829164386,
0.213968724,
0.3980768621,
-0.5814282298,
-0.0277781058,
0.0834369883,
-0.1369697899,
0.2129748911,
-0.0540365912,
0.8743404746,
0.1115941182,
-0.8283811212,
-0.6256939769,
-0.1066978574,
-0.7616121769,
0.0166430771,
0.7772431374,
-0.6357587576,
0.3355531693,
0.2593613863,
-0.2138872296,
-0.051013425,
-0.1177407652,
1.1415468454,
1.0138584375,
-0.6410477757,
-0.2579115927,
-0.4796210229,
0.3840064704,
0.4287996292,
-0.7519945502,
-0.0920680687,
0.770103693,
0.1759588718,
0.3363373876,
0.570366621,
0.0969520733,
0.1767058372,
0.2758637667,
-0.1547281146,
0.0936469138,
-0.522129178,
-0.0596643835,
0.2346532196,
0.0005944257,
-0.6152193546
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00958v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00958v1
|
IndoToD: A Multi-Domain Indonesian Benchmark For End-to-End Task-Oriented Dialogue Systems
| 2023-11-02T03:01:53 | 2023-11-02T03:01:53 |
Muhammad Dehan Al Kautsar, Rahmah Khoirussyifa' Nurdini, Samuel Cahyawijaya, Genta Indra Winata, Ayu Purwarianti
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Task-oriented dialogue (ToD) systems have been mostly created for
high-resource languages, such as English and Chinese. However, there is a need
to develop ToD systems for other regional or local languages to broaden their
ability to comprehend the dialogue contexts in various languages. This paper
introduces IndoToD, an end-to-end multi domain ToD benchmark in Indonesian. We
extend two English ToD datasets to Indonesian, comprising four different
domains by delexicalization to efficiently reduce the size of annotations. To
ensure a high-quality data collection, we hire native speakers to manually
translate the dialogues. Along with the original English datasets, these new
Indonesian datasets serve as an effective benchmark for evaluating Indonesian
and English ToD systems as well as exploring the potential benefits of
cross-lingual and bilingual transfer learning approaches.
|
[
-0.5892761946,
-0.5449739695,
0.027793102,
0.3238447011,
-0.7142603993,
0.1649763882,
-0.4879742861,
-0.3804915249,
0.2060739398,
0.7438079119,
-0.4425124824,
-0.4411114156,
-0.6103373766,
0.4463961124,
-0.0535858832,
0.9900962114,
-0.1956077516,
-0.21871005,
-0.2065306902,
-0.6120942831,
-0.5576785207,
-0.40954265,
-0.7540403605,
0.0786547735,
0.146661222,
0.3827425539,
0.3073471189,
0.1903740913,
0.3364117742,
0.2370997667,
0.2091905624,
0.3811166286,
0.0073061022,
0.6994745731,
-0.272008568,
-0.3695674539,
-0.2480612695,
-0.216252476,
0.1509497464,
0.7610583305,
0.1002102196,
0.1152412817,
-0.0026100231,
0.3988617659,
-0.7098981738,
0.592374146,
-0.1349720955,
-0.0864894539,
-0.3438746035,
-0.2956340015,
-0.266802907,
-0.3384795785,
0.486484319,
-0.7563467026,
-0.2673280835,
-0.1435453296,
0.522808373,
0.5714808106,
-0.9231507778,
-0.0210262537,
-0.6322411895,
0.717427969,
-0.4808910787,
0.3316650391,
0.4247163832,
0.4458590448,
-0.0030463475,
-0.4930835366,
-0.5205979347,
0.2624152303,
0.0383663774,
0.3045366406,
0.2367646098,
0.0551905409,
0.0436685011,
0.2692513466,
-0.6358534098,
-0.2045352608,
-0.1274243295,
0.0865979716,
0.6685810089,
-0.0847294405,
0.2721011937,
-0.3117909133,
-0.31235376,
-0.2758232057,
-0.5878996253,
0.0832980052,
0.1749162972,
0.4455808699,
-0.1179976016,
0.5072229505,
-0.5026723742,
0.5813885927,
-0.1272202432,
-0.3629674911,
0.2540033162,
-0.4004057944,
-0.3183618188,
-0.0045889341,
0.6568692923,
0.7313882113,
0.5416317582,
-0.0275767501,
-0.0513933226,
0.0153154079,
-0.0421215259,
-0.5740459561,
0.0647240058,
0.2748274505,
-0.5493573546,
0.1692490429,
-0.5430067182,
-0.6304724216,
-0.1544989198,
-0.5337566733,
0.1365019977,
-0.4142272174,
-0.5414195657,
-0.1249392405,
-0.2039555907,
0.1970971972,
0.386819452,
-0.5637601018,
0.3899025917,
0.6617145538,
0.6995638609,
-0.4711347222,
-0.162243247,
-0.2805624008,
0.3675063252,
-0.4724047184,
0.8908356428,
-0.7405155897,
-0.6464982629,
0.2293007672,
0.1010880917,
-0.2062594742,
-0.6298115849,
0.812956214,
-0.1532863081,
0.3137506843,
0.1560493261,
-0.2355720699,
-0.3286809027,
0.4817405045,
-0.262255311,
1.0263941288,
0.1718372852,
-0.5416583419,
0.678162396,
-0.7097670436,
-1.0099213123,
0.1566678882,
-0.1627277881,
-0.0761058256,
0.2498298883,
0.27226156,
0.4942358434,
-0.7226175666,
0.5520026684,
-0.0965574086,
0.044102814,
-0.307892561,
-0.4617349505,
0.7920817137,
0.5556250215,
-0.3463004529,
0.1871498078,
-0.8126906157,
-0.0401206985,
-0.1808664799,
0.0090894112,
-1.1196016073,
-0.0643440858,
0.2471219152,
0.3753137887,
0.207829982,
-0.8468920588,
0.3637418449,
-0.2189862132,
0.1130934209,
0.6404470205,
0.0682019293,
-0.0464593582,
-0.1790888011,
0.4747870564,
0.1641623676,
0.2672539055,
-0.4873560965,
-0.690867126,
-0.7030969858,
-0.4821000993,
0.0269017443,
0.5604687929,
-1.0777333975,
0.4021641612,
-0.5330893993,
-0.26528427,
-0.2788811028,
-0.1517125964,
0.448779583,
0.1497615576,
0.1124758795,
-0.6546623707,
-0.4122877121,
-1.0106067657,
-0.196247533,
-0.1355341971,
-0.1543339789,
0.5257663727,
0.3785670102,
0.0044383476,
0.8938333392,
-0.0218518209,
-0.6540885568,
-0.1950714737,
0.0690584257,
0.1082443073,
0.4431387782,
0.3718764186,
-0.8664098382,
-1.1253823042,
0.4546056986,
-0.6683789492,
-0.0295799896,
-0.0606580302,
-0.1937184632,
0.4766366482,
0.2070382982,
-0.6952231526,
0.6659570336,
0.4508963525,
-0.3145628273,
0.3553149104,
-0.1766334474,
0.5300301909,
-1.4946979284,
0.1899675876,
-0.1390659958,
-0.245470643,
-0.5117074251,
-0.2048141509,
-0.1258968115,
-0.2796595991,
-0.2535377741,
0.7220446467,
-0.2639893293,
-0.2591362298,
-0.0353161208,
0.0533849485,
-0.1984359026,
0.9241981506,
0.2593362331,
0.9711661935,
0.5843624473,
-0.5912634134,
0.3417792618,
0.5179510713,
-0.498380661,
1.3074100018,
-0.5880072713,
-0.1127549186,
0.1340044439,
0.3786076009,
-1.011400938,
-0.2330045998,
-0.0098267496,
-0.1992861181,
0.1284541041,
-0.4458206594,
-0.4272757173,
-0.0852674022,
-0.1644725651,
0.6073684692,
0.3853057027,
-0.6448857784,
0.6476572156,
0.5317957997,
-0.6829650998,
-0.5114805698,
-0.2537384331,
0.2873624265,
-0.2416428626,
-0.4823453426,
0.3704380393,
0.0195280425,
-0.160031423,
-0.0381570049,
-0.1878805757,
-0.3596391082,
-0.1253964901,
0.3123079836,
-0.1316555738,
-0.0343335755,
-0.0162669029,
0.4417179227,
-0.2651920021,
0.137013793,
-0.6112226248,
0.5081084967,
0.50843817,
-0.42179811,
-0.5151503086,
0.5517308116,
0.9927453399,
-0.5362639427,
0.3737017512,
0.1529668272,
-0.432370156,
-0.105862096,
-0.3942968249,
0.2286841422,
-0.3593308628,
0.1389723718,
-0.9294705987,
-0.471957624,
0.4981094897,
-0.5704796314,
0.4572935402,
0.3812063336,
0.4423071444,
0.3394675255,
1.1315828562,
0.7064922452,
0.1328145415,
0.2595566511,
-0.1769342721,
0.4535880387,
-1.0919703245,
-0.2697153091,
-0.5377981067,
-0.0126300743,
-0.5130421519,
-0.4843737781,
0.4762232602,
-0.1992444992,
-0.0803319067,
0.4486737251,
-0.545328021,
0.2371329516,
0.5835745931,
-0.4075004458,
0.4136481285,
-0.1258140355,
-0.1656492501,
-0.0683308542,
-0.3253550828,
-0.3706876338,
1.4957151413,
-0.2014529556,
0.4389192164,
0.2975074947,
0.4939325452,
0.3995778263,
0.2603856921,
-0.4098589122,
0.4595077634,
-0.3785002828,
-0.4589520097,
-0.3492200375,
-0.038660422,
-0.8774873614,
0.3278074265,
0.458601892,
-0.543648839,
0.4482495785,
-0.3754565418,
-0.0341220088,
0.1984860897,
-0.6734608412,
0.9562089443,
-0.0781375617,
-0.3076879978,
-0.3993397355,
-0.5181510448,
0.2257691175,
-0.0779661909,
0.0344759822,
-0.3387750387,
0.1277383715,
0.8838371038,
-0.5826550722,
0.6548023224,
-0.4337460101,
-0.2034186572,
0.2331435233,
-0.0144028859,
0.3944622576,
0.2740379274,
0.1059526652,
0.0071503641,
0.2770885229,
-0.3720696867,
-0.4216164351,
0.750415802,
-0.6992982626,
-0.4973849654,
-0.3076807559,
-0.5040698647,
-0.4151808619,
0.1770697534,
-0.0606486499,
0.6380419731,
-0.1775030047,
0.1853802204,
0.4510024488,
-0.3300964236,
0.3887063861,
0.3916123509,
0.0236562751,
-0.3283716738,
0.7975260615,
0.0011312102,
0.2028037608,
0.2581628561,
-0.431004405,
-0.5682723522,
-0.2423347682,
-0.7581846714,
-0.1133076027,
-0.6905935407,
-0.164626807,
-0.7282744646,
0.1822699755,
-0.4524489641,
-0.0506587252,
-0.5429156423,
-0.5669977665,
0.5002385378,
0.1646755487,
0.4088934362,
0.4855540991,
0.2094485611,
-0.148825556,
-0.3045920432,
0.4091847837,
0.268137455,
0.7493766546,
-0.3139208555,
-0.2942790389,
-0.0581741221,
-0.1791850924,
-0.0673379973,
-0.3983472884,
0.5092793107,
0.2508712411,
0.466666162,
0.3812021911,
0.6590909362,
0.6686031818,
-0.4167476296,
0.8131821156,
-0.0729861706,
-0.6849275827,
0.7096828222,
-0.2292544246,
0.432490617,
0.5174669027,
0.4471716583,
-0.8898512125,
-0.4514323175,
-0.3191482425,
-0.7628534436,
0.6592409015,
0.00131045,
-0.0115130525,
-0.1717566401,
0.0326314718,
0.601835072,
0.200059846,
-0.0844365507,
-0.27023682,
-0.1714156717,
-0.3520532548,
-0.1316455752,
0.0074266815,
-0.3014331162,
-0.0332020037,
0.5388700962,
-0.3921581805,
0.1849696189,
0.4442479908,
-0.2190217823,
0.0498948321,
0.3968057036,
0.4210351706,
0.6323865652,
-0.1379662305,
-0.2016564608,
0.0064931819,
-0.2870773375,
0.2183962762,
0.2217222899,
0.0714120418,
0.061032027,
0.0831076726,
0.8140481114,
-0.0259698126,
-1.0166628361,
0.4872399271,
-0.3711557388,
-0.0288072079,
-0.4941933751,
-0.2612566054,
-0.513982594,
0.0108800521,
0.6031752229,
0.1793798208,
0.1565610915,
-0.4278132617,
0.112716645,
0.2633116841,
-0.2958367467,
-0.3771207333,
0.7936033607,
0.8895873427,
-0.3343006372,
0.4054801762,
-0.1265227348,
-0.4027173221,
0.4672310948,
0.2495999485,
1.1879929304,
-0.1729990989,
0.1231990159,
0.3447806239,
0.0793511197,
0.3138492107,
0.3965768814,
-0.6043413877,
-0.207971409,
-1.0211163759,
-0.357085526,
-0.73950243,
-0.0992184952,
-0.7337579131,
0.1099784747,
-0.2792969048,
-0.0362739153,
-0.3635978997,
0.0613748245,
-0.6370654106,
0.1206488758,
-0.2568011582,
0.7753613591,
-0.7417349815,
0.9476156235,
0.7634698153,
-0.0600491464,
-0.0279384367,
-0.1403302699,
-0.153488338,
-0.370485276,
0.8426801562,
0.2152289301,
0.0690064132,
-0.1771385521,
0.1031191498,
-0.7664287686,
0.6605747342,
-0.1418343037,
-0.3073842824,
0.4145281017,
0.2853244543,
0.672829628,
-0.5029973984,
0.5654971004,
0.6263833046,
0.5127615929,
-0.3798697591,
-1.433334589,
-0.0525346324,
-0.7357638478,
-0.0443169847,
0.4022755027,
-0.6043986678,
0.6436322331,
0.1544474065,
-0.2967882454,
0.1713823527,
0.2964141369,
-0.1535367519,
0.314884454,
0.5167443752,
0.4852130711,
0.2007913888,
-0.3937554359,
1.1179083586,
-0.75316751,
-0.1226063445,
0.8802630901,
-0.6789396405,
0.6814339757,
0.5024443269,
-0.0795417503,
0.1976283789,
0.6018407941,
0.5914079547,
0.6787716746,
-0.1747803539,
-0.3396271467,
-0.153786391,
-0.6677595377,
-0.2555624247,
0.3482050896,
0.591186285,
0.4247942865,
-0.0803869218,
0.4971905053,
-0.2988674045,
0.0459803268,
0.2287584394,
1.0272887945,
-0.3382970691,
-1.1189836264,
0.721446991,
-0.2014561445,
0.8691807389,
-0.553935051,
-0.1254438907,
-0.7033392787,
0.1848505437,
0.1913694888,
-0.7204400301,
0.3738594353,
0.0581731834,
0.0527592301,
-0.4119208753,
0.2763077319,
-0.6318449974,
-0.0443184227,
0.2797523439,
0.4312956333,
0.2627807558,
0.0214581024,
-0.4140984118,
0.0155466693,
-0.0138307624,
-0.2427033633,
0.2675530016,
0.760850668,
-0.6924040914,
0.8642033339,
0.6827450395,
-0.0348629542,
-0.0552861728,
0.1439458728,
0.5109811425,
-0.4821653962,
-0.6079839468,
-0.0934930667,
0.3722455204,
-0.4680416882,
-0.9212669134,
0.6451858282,
0.7464749217,
1.3003832102,
0.0033233594,
1.1372097731,
-0.3591427803,
0.8055717349,
-0.0158970337,
0.2988532186,
-0.6345885396,
0.0194224231,
-0.1485457718,
-1.1122430563,
-0.3005559742,
0.4734317958,
0.0044690794,
-0.0685116276,
0.6694819331,
0.4457876086,
-0.1207443252,
0.1041455865,
0.3810716271,
0.0983320996,
0.7479673028,
0.5858194232,
0.6482841372,
-0.5513916016,
0.6240372062,
-0.5563678145,
-0.2737801075,
-0.2131765485,
-0.3560811281,
-1.0357136726,
-0.9804050326,
-0.4125857353,
0.2837882638,
0.3195220828,
0.7671881318,
0.7585334778,
-0.8064658642,
-0.4053712487,
0.1181001142,
-0.0327081867,
-0.5182042718,
-0.2045262009,
0.6256847382,
-0.3519575596,
-1.2148717642,
0.3267592192,
0.779001236,
-0.2324805409,
-0.1476489156,
-0.114845708,
-0.1530738324,
-0.0794886053,
0.8314551711,
0.4349726737,
-0.8124782443,
-0.3451523483,
-0.1135889068,
0.1265574694,
-0.0659270734,
0.9364453554,
-0.8459572792,
0.7481498718,
0.3176150024,
0.7745509744,
0.4313468337,
-0.2528179288,
0.9407210946,
-0.8049103618,
0.5232895017,
-0.0424665697,
0.2187066823,
0.3161276877,
0.1179476604,
0.9129203558,
0.1242391914,
-0.3549760878,
-0.8591681123,
0.0324238464,
-0.8248623013,
-0.2341224402,
0.7055262923,
-0.3133146763,
0.0198821649,
-0.796420753,
-0.4811471701,
0.1909371465,
-0.3089385629,
0.5088239908,
0.5229887962,
-0.1491926163,
-0.0209354311,
-0.5790210366,
0.5877645612,
0.7001360059,
-1.0303155184,
0.457831502,
0.2266687453,
0.0217661448,
0.0854346752,
0.6685626507,
0.0800997987,
0.425010711,
-0.1435320526,
0.013481644,
0.1954146177,
-0.4037744105,
0.1219846085,
-0.1428792775,
-0.2115221024,
-0.3150340617
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00953v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00953v1
|
Blending Reward Functions via Few Expert Demonstrations for Faithful and Accurate Knowledge-Grounded Dialogue Generation
| 2023-11-02T02:42:41 | 2023-11-02T02:42:41 |
Wanyu Du, Yangfeng Ji
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The development of trustworthy conversational information-seeking systems
relies on dialogue models that can generate faithful and accurate responses
based on relevant knowledge texts. However, two main challenges hinder this
task. Firstly, language models may generate hallucinations due to data biases
present in their pretraining corpus. Secondly, knowledge texts often contain
redundant and irrelevant information that distracts the model's attention from
the relevant text span. Previous works use additional data annotations on the
knowledge texts to learn a knowledge identification module in order to bypass
irrelevant information, but collecting such high-quality span annotations can
be costly. In this work, we leverage reinforcement learning algorithms to
overcome the above challenges by introducing a novel reward function. Our
reward function combines an accuracy metric and a faithfulness metric to
provide a balanced quality judgment of generated responses, which can be used
as a cost-effective approximation to a human preference reward model when only
a few preference annotations are available. Empirical experiments on two
conversational information-seeking datasets demonstrate that our method can
compete with other strong supervised learning baselines.
|
[
-0.3474707305,
-0.3814524114,
0.680147469,
0.0131280143,
-0.3173835874,
0.0195848644,
-0.0894083455,
-0.1940466017,
0.1611089557,
0.5691599846,
-0.703666389,
-0.1084344015,
-0.5549561381,
-0.2201913148,
-0.0559475049,
1.0724880695,
0.2187827975,
-0.0672672763,
-0.3625699282,
-0.0665805787,
-0.3900867403,
-0.4110366106,
-0.5160883069,
-0.4127831161,
0.5141663551,
0.4182593524,
0.7689894438,
0.4111994207,
0.0085286619,
0.2209322602,
0.2384976,
0.7731449008,
-0.7255606651,
0.0711484775,
-0.160888806,
-0.4182849228,
0.0651907995,
0.1272981018,
0.2448419482,
0.5902084112,
-0.0823692679,
-0.2067168355,
0.2018871456,
0.5695021152,
-0.7717322111,
0.3760612607,
-0.7075679898,
0.0210341085,
0.1018582508,
-0.5931489468,
-0.5320564508,
-0.6941050291,
0.4136829078,
-0.9217736125,
-0.2358804196,
-0.033469934,
1.0478000641,
0.3425844908,
-0.3283120394,
-0.3016983867,
-0.5667592883,
0.9191531539,
-0.605502069,
0.1980238259,
0.6708295345,
0.2004449069,
-0.2986321449,
-0.4210850596,
-0.439248085,
-0.238394022,
-0.2452842593,
0.0943787917,
-0.0226643384,
0.0077120918,
0.1239624843,
0.2369574159,
-0.1173707172,
-0.2677550614,
-0.2477633059,
-0.1606122553,
0.472994715,
0.0860098749,
-0.2053312063,
-0.1206366569,
-0.407882452,
-0.5667074323,
-0.5115403533,
0.3244971931,
0.5444034338,
0.2797565758,
0.0727408454,
0.4932599068,
-0.3149995506,
0.7798604369,
0.2652122974,
-0.2088349909,
0.1254481822,
-0.2599095404,
-0.1082455143,
-0.1391715705,
0.8078976274,
0.4455222189,
0.2682720721,
-0.2156521827,
-0.1588122994,
-0.0640591457,
0.5954013467,
-0.6952960491,
-0.3946745396,
0.072981365,
-0.2896175086,
-0.7161679268,
0.2325708121,
-0.6151777506,
-0.346105665,
-0.2130372524,
0.3624650836,
-0.5476617813,
-0.2364527285,
0.0649440438,
-0.2687785029,
0.0363894626,
0.4684707224,
-0.9107628465,
0.3093630373,
0.4083790183,
0.3970713913,
-0.4186900854,
0.0679009557,
-1.0227655172,
0.0952928588,
-0.3140300512,
0.5768042803,
-0.6389939785,
-0.2911860943,
0.1277143359,
-0.2564196289,
0.134318918,
-0.5324650407,
0.5990920067,
-0.6075002551,
0.3358850479,
-0.4224965572,
-0.5906496048,
-0.2160751224,
0.3737959564,
-0.601567626,
0.9040050507,
0.4111989439,
-0.7445718646,
0.4770917296,
-0.367477864,
-0.3085416257,
0.1544934809,
-0.3303939998,
-0.1796074212,
-0.0209933762,
0.1902080625,
0.3712145984,
-0.0418881327,
0.4068151414,
-0.2737796009,
-0.2183645219,
0.5739575624,
-0.6172916293,
0.1288321316,
0.2058133781,
-0.5154494047,
0.0017064038,
-0.5731739998,
0.2227203697,
0.0924614742,
-0.3054311275,
-0.5160864592,
0.1912779808,
-0.196598053,
0.1026707366,
0.1334444135,
-0.3744487464,
0.0193310622,
-0.5692033768,
-0.0914131775,
0.8421545625,
0.074976787,
0.3764846623,
-0.5643504262,
0.272210449,
0.2518675923,
0.0915274918,
-0.2809155881,
-0.3699474037,
-0.7881929874,
-0.1722914726,
0.207326889,
0.3949383795,
-1.0280681849,
0.566744864,
-0.1389615834,
-0.2106148154,
-0.5555551648,
0.0083987284,
0.4321626425,
0.5759481788,
0.413102299,
-0.3581612706,
-0.2808465362,
-0.8409345746,
-0.2724642754,
-0.4899173677,
-0.2794490755,
0.6697093844,
0.0033805568,
0.1534998864,
1.1162824631,
-0.4389693439,
-0.1418059468,
-0.0314689614,
0.3604461849,
-0.0456805341,
0.3932555318,
0.2249316722,
-0.8859087229,
-0.1251594275,
0.0352148302,
-0.6547790766,
0.0156610515,
-0.3077545464,
-0.148121804,
0.0252652429,
-0.0787434131,
-0.4425882399,
0.3001136482,
0.3561947048,
-0.2140370756,
0.3751014471,
0.0896000713,
0.5186467171,
-0.8613401651,
0.0802261457,
-0.049599167,
-0.5407109857,
-0.4154104292,
-0.2859705985,
-0.1511720419,
0.2868413329,
-0.2121709734,
0.6782130003,
0.1501419693,
0.2434911579,
-0.258771807,
0.2180332243,
0.0898613259,
0.7283619046,
0.2280198783,
0.5549426675,
0.0190069173,
-0.7966859937,
0.2109657377,
0.3556670249,
-0.1794377118,
0.5653817058,
-0.3949505389,
0.0680041835,
0.0031412123,
0.1297259182,
-0.9230787754,
-0.4825177789,
0.3614204526,
-0.5203970075,
0.0053787441,
-0.2132463604,
-0.199470982,
0.0283197481,
-0.1434864402,
0.3378148377,
0.660842061,
-0.825366497,
0.4290907383,
0.3581407666,
-0.3222973347,
-0.8332388997,
-0.2819687724,
-0.190974012,
-0.1162371263,
-0.4101774096,
0.2796156704,
-0.0158751961,
-0.0422384478,
-0.0866428688,
-0.2473057806,
-0.0796096995,
0.1977796108,
0.2524575591,
0.3340862393,
0.2560188472,
0.1661302149,
0.2052902728,
-0.075953953,
0.1478504837,
-0.6268654466,
0.4893188477,
-0.0629923567,
-0.4895885587,
-0.4103545249,
0.2925967574,
0.4757908285,
0.0017265677,
0.5200468302,
0.4328059554,
-0.1998060197,
-0.109109588,
-0.7595416307,
-0.5401774049,
-0.4948508739,
0.1904010177,
-0.253544271,
-0.9991397858,
0.045927953,
-0.1347248554,
0.2405982614,
0.1828266233,
0.1883095503,
-0.0372383408,
1.1048299074,
0.2292667925,
-0.0491025336,
0.5039271116,
0.1236191094,
0.1329174936,
-0.1767137945,
-0.6043114662,
-0.3673960567,
0.0356994532,
-0.1684797257,
-0.2722879052,
0.4332416952,
0.1856632978,
-0.0232283175,
0.0284033269,
-0.3951953053,
0.2403282523,
0.726734519,
0.3102662563,
0.2766364515,
0.2456755787,
-0.2637803555,
-0.2620803416,
-0.6572702527,
-0.570985198,
0.9607450962,
0.1693122983,
0.9049775004,
-0.2898547947,
0.5905912519,
0.4569015801,
0.134744212,
-0.6959764361,
0.2641381621,
0.207336098,
-0.0806062147,
-0.3663308918,
-0.7978640199,
-0.642442584,
0.0559683666,
-0.378960073,
-0.5899852514,
0.0071902545,
0.426163286,
-0.3889448941,
0.1507027745,
-0.4979121089,
0.690159142,
-0.3036126494,
-0.7053841949,
-0.2410470694,
-0.6538354754,
0.3487264812,
0.1551026106,
0.0604490303,
0.046065744,
0.4163112044,
0.6299604177,
-0.2706401348,
0.6409107447,
-0.3660508394,
0.0856272727,
0.0745386183,
0.3940073252,
0.6836400628,
0.2514815032,
0.1095976159,
-0.4004272521,
-0.0272338819,
-0.4968247116,
-0.8076341152,
0.3689667583,
-0.5735344887,
-0.4995717406,
-0.1692595184,
-0.3889830112,
-0.4938805103,
0.11413645,
0.0756278187,
0.2424309701,
-0.3235080242,
0.1442400217,
0.977822423,
-0.1950321645,
0.0151708135,
0.1702231467,
0.0253721271,
-0.5614575744,
0.9957100153,
-0.5116531253,
0.4590198994,
0.4164218009,
0.1112412512,
-0.4135301113,
-0.0345534906,
-0.5652238727,
-0.1372998804,
-0.4016608298,
-0.2167857736,
-0.7162220478,
-0.0915817469,
-0.1121023893,
-0.0877545923,
-0.6092425585,
-0.4241099656,
-0.2551390529,
-0.2576484978,
0.3318893611,
0.6290129423,
0.163057074,
0.1137272194,
-0.7244668007,
0.1350566,
0.6363480687,
0.1758738905,
-0.0634319708,
-0.2829044759,
-0.2998276949,
0.4835976958,
-0.5312181711,
-0.787607789,
0.5128725171,
-0.1365516782,
0.5842927098,
0.5932479501,
0.3919457793,
0.5863798857,
-0.0856072307,
0.8929193616,
0.4119482338,
-0.8407352567,
0.5465871096,
-0.2680643201,
0.0213432629,
0.7825984359,
0.4024121463,
-0.4452627301,
-0.4969604015,
-0.7677937746,
-0.7039356232,
0.899033308,
0.4219159186,
-0.0093723303,
-0.1346102804,
0.2440749407,
0.2956188321,
0.4397143722,
-0.7483656406,
-0.1102460623,
-0.5739730597,
-0.3708402514,
0.1047445312,
-0.0963616073,
-0.5167224407,
0.1374429315,
0.8464252353,
-0.4992370307,
0.3288592696,
0.1529132277,
0.0334788561,
-0.0442869812,
0.3393710554,
0.5324377418,
0.2225614935,
-0.1149084941,
0.1569150984,
-0.0261308402,
0.0846136659,
0.085500963,
0.0087934416,
-0.0380669832,
0.0864293575,
-0.2405765951,
1.1333028078,
0.2908957601,
-0.7712288499,
0.8752919436,
-0.0696356446,
-0.2306945175,
-0.2665658891,
0.2465762645,
-0.0563914627,
0.2336180806,
0.4100923538,
0.282192111,
0.1953239143,
-0.286013186,
0.356159687,
0.6877066493,
-0.7489477992,
-0.0640433282,
0.4735881686,
0.19790259,
-0.094905369,
0.6690943241,
-0.2873165905,
-0.495154053,
0.2614950836,
0.2419021726,
0.7768604755,
0.0526126586,
0.5791457891,
0.2209658921,
-0.0014796938,
-0.3458600044,
-0.0214999188,
-0.5114011765,
-0.696796,
-0.2476485074,
-0.4488771558,
-0.6699169874,
0.1428198963,
-0.7385634184,
0.2357742935,
-0.1388586462,
-0.0531563163,
-0.3110185564,
-0.2559510171,
-0.5460335612,
0.1362085789,
0.1732207388,
0.6363530755,
-0.7543873787,
0.5694864988,
0.2493175566,
-0.3751593828,
-0.8648032546,
-0.0305796154,
-0.293386817,
-0.6277971268,
0.4464839399,
0.1280640215,
-0.2855376899,
-0.2318922281,
-0.7360834479,
-0.5306604505,
0.8352350593,
0.4828438461,
0.0114969127,
-0.1573865563,
0.0961450189,
0.259929359,
-0.5194986463,
0.5974783897,
0.444024235,
0.459414959,
0.4150398374,
-0.7489082813,
-0.0377853177,
-0.4098390341,
-0.2288519591,
-0.0540095977,
-0.4844361842,
0.4210108221,
0.03498514,
-0.0267135855,
0.2205474079,
0.5011493564,
0.6426671147,
0.2471174449,
0.6913407445,
0.3105553985,
0.8412874341,
-0.2299769521,
0.8562591672,
-0.1417109966,
0.2431662083,
0.9789535403,
-0.1166049093,
0.5695313811,
0.5992510915,
0.1212631986,
0.5716372132,
0.6314729452,
0.131348446,
0.797981441,
0.070467703,
-0.4374669194,
-0.5159834623,
-0.3278490603,
-0.1541654021,
0.0486533381,
0.4129562378,
-0.3129919767,
-0.028530119,
-0.1244714931,
-0.0557476729,
0.1073110551,
0.1106382757,
1.0119663477,
-0.1390751153,
-1.2467448711,
0.5966610909,
-0.0840055794,
0.566732645,
-0.8683006763,
-0.3264896274,
-0.1833633631,
-0.0762169436,
-0.1550392658,
-0.5425859094,
-0.0842123106,
-0.1427268982,
-0.0544642098,
-0.3453605175,
0.5872348547,
-0.6308482885,
0.0653397664,
0.1323463768,
0.3223399222,
0.0025428464,
-0.1398951709,
-0.2819829285,
-0.3456353545,
0.2788408101,
-0.1163996384,
0.2404102385,
0.295173645,
0.1266062111,
0.6494297981,
0.629842937,
-0.1321083605,
-0.0227809511,
-0.1938479394,
1.034027338,
-0.4526629746,
-0.7843940854,
-0.5155512691,
0.595356524,
-0.4677527547,
-0.201409176,
0.3587187529,
0.4604083002,
0.8812510967,
-0.1598802507,
1.048612833,
0.1152290702,
0.4627116621,
-0.5765875578,
0.5331773758,
-0.5734351873,
0.2023763359,
-0.4883171916,
-0.669516623,
0.1370076686,
0.7768611908,
0.0216035247,
0.1429675519,
0.6105936766,
0.6608345509,
-0.0154578201,
0.2611498535,
0.4133650064,
-0.1751108319,
0.2406198978,
0.7897699475,
1.1096680164,
-0.2359087914,
0.5576814413,
-0.1244341731,
-0.2864922881,
-0.3046201766,
-0.7004662156,
-0.8440859318,
-0.5112861395,
-0.0482564345,
-0.6153555512,
0.1876330525,
1.1572481394,
1.0181678534,
-0.7699895501,
-0.1365008354,
-0.1970648617,
0.1728489995,
-0.3399209976,
-0.2864822149,
0.0025739491,
-0.6113578677,
-0.6843262315,
0.5499299169,
0.2839399576,
0.0290014688,
-0.1632192433,
-0.4903662503,
0.1442772299,
0.2421517223,
0.2435972244,
0.3692857623,
-0.7218439579,
-0.4504496157,
0.065846771,
-0.1945863813,
0.1523894966,
0.8762708306,
-1.1119841337,
0.5636947751,
0.1855157465,
1.0685964823,
0.8570581079,
0.2853965759,
0.8251255155,
-0.8759717941,
-0.1028452218,
0.2951099575,
-0.0041777226,
0.3595345616,
-0.4096941352,
0.3240044415,
0.2205764055,
-0.3333168328,
-0.7017726302,
0.3972148001,
-1.0590447187,
0.0739602149,
1.0876092911,
-0.3753970563,
0.0473975278,
-0.1117311344,
-0.2296975255,
0.1960718185,
-0.6474086046,
0.9476493597,
0.6881070733,
-0.0179977901,
-0.0377279557,
-0.132692799,
0.8939046264,
0.812307477,
-0.8826913834,
0.0712323114,
0.5381445885,
0.0403297134,
0.062672846,
0.4998877645,
-0.0988069773,
0.4261202216,
-0.1538040787,
-0.0418967791,
-0.1704668254,
-0.4438655078,
-0.0104125338,
0.2855043709,
0.229563877,
-0.1197816357
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00945v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00945v1
|
E3 TTS: Easy End-to-End Diffusion-based Text to Speech
| 2023-11-02T02:22:21 | 2023-11-02T02:22:21 |
Yuan Gao, Nobuyuki Morioka, Yu Zhang, Nanxin Chen
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS
|
We propose Easy End-to-End Diffusion-based Text to Speech, a simple and
efficient end-to-end text-to-speech model based on diffusion. E3 TTS directly
takes plain text as input and generates an audio waveform through an iterative
refinement process. Unlike many prior work, E3 TTS does not rely on any
intermediate representations like spectrogram features or alignment
information. Instead, E3 TTS models the temporal structure of the waveform
through the diffusion process. Without relying on additional conditioning
information, E3 TTS could support flexible latent structure within the given
audio. This enables E3 TTS to be easily adapted for zero-shot tasks such as
editing without any additional training. Experiments show that E3 TTS can
generate high-fidelity audio, approaching the performance of a state-of-the-art
neural TTS system. Audio samples are available at https://e3tts.github.io.
|
[
-0.1512240767,
-1.0136996508,
0.8694931865,
0.3069310784,
-0.387476176,
0.0867446736,
-0.1022024304,
-0.5351474285,
0.3531298935,
0.2161592096,
-0.6186849475,
-0.6413086653,
-0.6832640767,
0.2244983464,
-0.9049167633,
0.9265389442,
0.1639279723,
-0.2518390417,
0.4438797832,
0.1385346502,
-0.1808095276,
-0.1451252699,
-1.2821245193,
-0.202402398,
0.5278741717,
0.5221287012,
0.4634251595,
0.5562002659,
-0.1357275546,
0.2005472779,
-0.4654552042,
-0.3715218902,
-0.4942298234,
0.3952475786,
0.1634827554,
-0.4520738423,
-0.5801730156,
-0.3254393935,
0.2616362274,
0.5233764052,
-0.4634848237,
0.2297338396,
-0.0498037301,
0.6071889997,
-0.4685684144,
-0.3650051653,
-0.3479441702,
0.2078111917,
-0.4065276086,
-0.2471781969,
-0.6314268112,
-0.2593207061,
0.5045271516,
-0.7703896165,
0.2871907651,
-0.0310695134,
0.2477645129,
0.1485385001,
-0.387463361,
-0.1470672041,
-0.8971643448,
0.3223673403,
-0.4950807691,
0.7443669438,
0.1806263179,
0.2974173129,
0.0929300264,
-1.0709201097,
-0.6214535236,
0.0432665646,
0.3113888204,
0.4995552003,
-0.1976738572,
0.2341089398,
0.0284201168,
0.0989925489,
-0.6465474367,
0.1887483597,
-0.2015385926,
0.0526137687,
0.0904560536,
-0.2793522775,
0.2227298319,
0.0635366216,
-0.1721830964,
0.2230878472,
-0.6341519356,
-0.2355297208,
0.4577884972,
0.1907369643,
-0.4242979884,
0.591394484,
-0.0119402427,
0.8279180527,
-0.0262046121,
-0.1050010026,
0.2916620672,
0.0644627288,
-0.3724423349,
0.2127150446,
0.7698327899,
0.1940467209,
0.1120947674,
-0.3484278917,
-0.2102004141,
-0.3459709883,
-0.0341129526,
-0.6446641088,
0.3312046528,
0.4972892106,
-0.3862161934,
-0.0315233283,
-0.4759400189,
-0.8413210511,
-0.0404831991,
-0.2501607835,
0.5745661855,
-0.567183435,
-0.27005288,
0.3028201759,
-0.7340883613,
0.0445195585,
0.5185382962,
-0.9862546921,
0.5544257164,
0.3675414622,
1.3094234467,
-0.305398941,
-0.1035106182,
-0.3505458832,
0.8062626123,
-0.2298501879,
0.9346844554,
-0.2619158924,
-0.7468090057,
-0.0806345642,
-0.3465584815,
0.3905246556,
-0.3183510602,
0.4581109881,
-0.3555335104,
0.2942462265,
0.4506772459,
-0.5491781235,
-0.0154065369,
-0.1972153485,
-0.7669491172,
1.0167158842,
0.0912795216,
-0.3697164953,
0.1737883091,
-1.0904438496,
-0.5679272413,
-0.0718283281,
0.1066433266,
-0.4800145328,
0.1703529656,
0.0312242266,
0.2678604722,
-0.5590607524,
0.0867544934,
-0.296076566,
-0.3521810174,
-0.0642661601,
-0.7380178571,
0.489205569,
0.3812558949,
-0.4201664329,
0.0727733821,
-0.7850483656,
-0.1235915944,
0.1256892234,
-0.1386324763,
-0.0019428153,
0.078830637,
0.5362081528,
-0.0903061479,
-0.0489192754,
-0.6432128549,
-0.1488300115,
-0.4293103516,
0.6804141998,
0.6744953394,
0.0406790972,
0.4370301068,
-0.3701630235,
0.4095868468,
-0.1432124823,
0.1989802122,
-0.3042856157,
-0.9930340648,
-0.524849236,
-0.4376027584,
0.2384167612,
0.5824003816,
-0.6778278947,
0.1744674295,
-0.2373144031,
-0.423214227,
-0.4281586111,
-0.3589009345,
0.1178017333,
0.5596283078,
0.4772700369,
0.1289022565,
-0.6308366656,
-0.8121384978,
-0.1141204461,
-0.083598882,
-0.4256688058,
-0.3221258521,
0.268700242,
0.2171679437,
1.0498988628,
-0.4954006374,
-0.2450498194,
-0.138995856,
0.3679955602,
-0.0815814659,
0.3587279916,
0.4472192228,
-0.5846424103,
-0.479033798,
-0.1206566989,
-0.3574515879,
-0.2691422105,
0.0483097993,
0.0310285948,
0.0304515045,
0.7371397018,
-0.3784967661,
0.4325788915,
0.4592206478,
-0.4989879727,
0.0212895591,
0.0090702586,
0.1226464361,
-1.3680123091,
0.087295115,
0.1979822516,
-0.7276446819,
-0.870752573,
-0.3951905966,
-0.4432927966,
-0.1983293295,
-0.8835948706,
0.3826047182,
-0.348664999,
-0.315017283,
-0.2171994448,
0.4490216374,
-0.0751987249,
0.3497374356,
0.3927516043,
0.680260241,
0.534468472,
-0.5956815481,
0.2314281762,
0.182641834,
0.1246376708,
0.7755565643,
-0.7959413528,
0.3619903028,
-0.1144922674,
0.3809711337,
-0.9426743388,
0.1104351208,
0.1498235017,
-0.7931008935,
0.2962213159,
-0.306034863,
-0.5597151518,
0.0057486393,
-0.3284165263,
0.3555620909,
0.6555475593,
-0.4029043913,
0.5289805532,
0.4282599986,
-0.5115260482,
0.0081042135,
-0.8851850629,
0.2280475497,
-0.230949983,
-0.4315283,
0.9630650878,
-0.1594805419,
0.2120354325,
0.0477935374,
0.2146359384,
-0.4390808642,
-0.0631704181,
-0.0493077934,
-0.0044347085,
-0.1167274863,
-0.0004414902,
0.2171580493,
-0.2036289871,
-0.2136469036,
-0.5256903768,
0.3330079615,
0.2515426278,
-0.2628952861,
-0.7981411815,
0.7621176839,
0.7064750195,
0.4042903185,
0.4213171005,
0.4489479959,
-0.5495198965,
-0.1121008694,
-0.2766959369,
0.1385920793,
-0.463180542,
0.3563705981,
-0.2196594179,
-0.8968572021,
0.3486664295,
-0.1923288107,
0.146645233,
0.5031287074,
0.4344650805,
-0.2698990703,
1.2089152336,
0.6892152429,
0.5786950588,
0.7824664116,
-0.1574914157,
-0.1852935404,
-0.9333423376,
-0.4108152986,
-0.6305431724,
-0.2816450298,
-0.2789453566,
-0.2890564501,
0.2692073286,
0.0113949925,
-0.4408596456,
0.1174558029,
-0.646265924,
0.3067252934,
0.4934756458,
0.1095819324,
0.3047791123,
0.0499171093,
0.090927586,
0.0101957601,
-0.4319202602,
-0.4331977069,
1.1223723888,
0.4774844646,
0.4452901781,
0.5280236006,
0.8313125968,
0.4386510551,
0.3101389408,
-0.9001382589,
0.3739175797,
-0.0597566962,
-0.3030651212,
-0.4973201752,
-0.0597485937,
-0.7579830885,
-0.1719000787,
-0.1642368734,
-0.9273917079,
-0.1549908072,
0.0381866321,
-0.4588801861,
0.3161182106,
-1.0307587385,
0.3001066446,
0.1764335483,
-0.4133080542,
0.0101952376,
-0.5464565158,
0.0353843756,
-0.0400433764,
0.2945650816,
0.1131089851,
-0.5193164945,
1.2255710363,
-0.5101230145,
0.7144945264,
-0.2363260835,
-0.1941994131,
0.4625992477,
0.1464302391,
0.2093633413,
0.2367089987,
-0.0462644361,
0.047766868,
-0.0402351916,
-0.0910079181,
-0.7641028762,
0.4655728936,
-0.6424215436,
-0.4974235594,
-0.2940174937,
0.0799749866,
-0.3893121183,
0.2836527526,
0.5216255784,
0.4292011559,
-0.2050951272,
0.1936399788,
0.8020927906,
-0.0541365445,
0.9015614986,
0.685557723,
-0.3626587093,
-0.7821778059,
0.646330893,
-0.0021162403,
0.292842567,
0.514859736,
0.1222579479,
-0.6712069511,
-0.7579144835,
-0.6871387959,
0.1072503552,
-0.4876311123,
-0.1955469698,
-0.5844311714,
-0.1473419666,
-0.3410312831,
-0.4357728362,
-0.6063191295,
-0.6260265708,
-0.7115322351,
-0.2956302166,
0.7777480483,
1.1038216352,
-0.1680267602,
0.7632004619,
-0.7995732427,
0.9210789204,
0.2271806896,
0.75939399,
-0.1556811184,
-0.8250861764,
-0.2298410088,
-0.0452848598,
-0.3825189471,
-1.302410841,
0.2357115448,
0.3399567008,
0.2377085537,
0.1348433346,
-0.514287591,
0.7826570272,
-0.8743240833,
1.1300777197,
0.6379203796,
-1.3774135113,
0.7127323151,
-0.3651798964,
0.233093366,
0.134560883,
0.0710559487,
-0.5452005267,
-0.390709728,
-0.5715419054,
-0.9801465869,
0.6733295918,
0.557659328,
-0.180868119,
-0.0952213779,
0.4455036521,
0.0507148504,
0.0826171041,
-0.6862590909,
-0.541888833,
-0.2663900256,
-0.441709578,
0.0187164489,
-0.1462749839,
0.0566110201,
-0.0607926734,
0.557387948,
0.0508493297,
0.6863534451,
0.4404108822,
0.0117161423,
-0.0237584915,
0.4162351489,
0.7310967445,
-0.0089114653,
-0.1981009245,
0.0592801943,
0.2176633626,
-0.6862863898,
0.4563891888,
-0.166003257,
-0.0645093247,
0.2749991119,
0.0324635804,
0.772362411,
0.3752506673,
-0.2741424739,
0.6226295233,
-0.2183057815,
-0.593932271,
-0.4411751628,
-0.4428520501,
0.2149302214,
-0.0217888132,
0.4974891543,
0.0911152437,
0.3759385645,
-0.3704250753,
0.4224478006,
-0.03233134,
-0.5071769357,
-0.4141460955,
1.0723326206,
0.4553221464,
-0.6042151451,
0.1838283837,
0.0896877125,
-0.0161304697,
0.3451884389,
0.9444776773,
1.2776112556,
-0.2945107818,
0.2122516334,
0.0113622891,
0.1700721234,
-0.2269321084,
0.6115058064,
0.0091709085,
-0.1587436646,
-0.6722044945,
-0.4030855298,
-0.5624119043,
0.1032726839,
-0.5429048538,
0.6796833873,
-0.4637801051,
-0.4086551666,
-0.1340824515,
-0.8346006274,
-0.4645863771,
0.48786062,
0.4081665874,
0.9744068384,
-0.5958333611,
0.5040143132,
0.216456756,
-0.0977314562,
-0.4417201281,
0.0412637033,
0.0132513111,
-0.3930805624,
0.3886967003,
-0.0056319973,
-0.5318408012,
0.6314841509,
-0.4868977368,
-0.9976046681,
1.2198411226,
0.6164883971,
-0.5576898456,
-0.2897287309,
0.0253922325,
0.5339129567,
-0.1935413033,
0.7016609311,
0.4894669652,
0.3172263801,
0.4560768306,
-0.7617872953,
-0.2250362784,
-0.1502795964,
0.0754703209,
0.1084842235,
-0.4290324152,
0.4641073346,
-0.1367595941,
-0.3371756077,
-0.100065127,
0.9319067597,
0.0251893513,
0.2587845922,
0.4767237902,
0.7572912574,
0.4922447503,
-0.2302883118,
0.7614380717,
-0.1610464156,
0.0108408052,
1.0153008699,
-0.2533500493,
1.1330465078,
0.4104822874,
-0.1445799023,
0.5434798598,
0.6434502006,
0.5369158387,
0.6826719642,
0.1170819402,
-0.4219325781,
0.2248433381,
-0.0165239945,
-0.3970981836,
0.3682096303,
0.6086195111,
-0.0169120487,
-0.1444083899,
0.1035606191,
-0.1538168788,
-0.1564162821,
-0.1810886115,
0.830896318,
-0.0074843923,
-0.4740338922,
0.1800595075,
0.0247989967,
0.8743542433,
-0.7483046651,
-0.2999878228,
0.277566582,
-0.6261155009,
-0.3139488399,
-1.0078876019,
0.5899757147,
0.3903750181,
-0.1971060634,
-0.5117236972,
0.1960643381,
-0.2597025931,
-0.0056998013,
0.4369235933,
0.6100465059,
-0.05040925,
0.1053106263,
-0.5232855082,
-0.0602478012,
-0.0646764264,
-0.5383898616,
-0.0395708568,
0.4995809495,
0.3682460785,
0.4641223252,
0.6621029377,
0.3363498151,
0.0946737677,
0.4834774733,
0.2293688953,
-0.7843651772,
-0.8741944432,
-0.8052228689,
0.602840364,
0.0161344055,
-0.3217155337,
0.2574887872,
0.7715721726,
0.4913798571,
0.1956798583,
1.0411930084,
0.0304129794,
0.9091290236,
-0.8452031612,
0.5369818211,
-0.5076659918,
0.2287183404,
-0.4192613661,
-0.7883782387,
-0.3682260811,
0.2374950945,
0.2572546899,
0.1341223717,
0.9647266865,
0.4632640183,
0.2210865468,
0.359339267,
0.5938748717,
0.0899141729,
0.3674650788,
0.4813655615,
0.8440199494,
-0.4878105819,
0.6801462173,
0.0949282572,
-0.3167254925,
0.0365192294,
-0.8364652991,
-0.2776966393,
-0.7466211915,
-0.3819906712,
-0.162132889,
0.0829620361,
0.6901946664,
0.666444242,
-0.2746198475,
-0.1803608537,
-0.5482563376,
-0.038987454,
-0.0238781851,
-0.197784707,
0.1860494167,
0.0961855873,
-1.0612190962,
0.6255547404,
0.5654348135,
0.7176272869,
0.0306238923,
0.0726981908,
-0.0826089755,
0.0518266261,
0.820592463,
0.2767803371,
-0.5073407888,
-0.3646889031,
0.0541360937,
0.0639771521,
0.097480759,
0.7942152619,
-0.8302121758,
0.4164195657,
0.3549356461,
0.2558988333,
0.7447203398,
-0.4926283658,
0.8547201753,
-0.8112800121,
0.2630457282,
0.2946604788,
0.4028575718,
0.4242165685,
-0.1524457932,
0.2810890377,
0.2371196002,
-0.3048417568,
-0.6557271481,
0.1092281267,
-1.05590415,
-0.1743493676,
1.2635171413,
0.2219888866,
-0.2723776996,
-0.4440618157,
-0.3399243653,
0.833360672,
-0.5662222505,
0.2564886808,
0.3450587094,
-0.2691209316,
-0.1709373891,
-0.7164276242,
0.6613541245,
0.1667902768,
-0.7561295629,
-0.0706055835,
0.2778621018,
0.3826419413,
-0.0764635354,
1.0240478516,
-0.159689188,
0.3849745691,
0.0169569086,
-0.0185389034,
0.0575879328,
-0.3468416929,
-0.5135883689,
0.3097053766,
-0.0400747806,
-0.1640141457
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04915v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04915v2
|
Chain of Empathy: Enhancing Empathetic Response of Large Language Models Based on Psychotherapy Models
| 2023-11-02T02:21:39 | 2023-12-14T01:30:01 |
Yoon Kyung Lee, Inju Lee, Minjung Shin, Seoyeon Bae, Sowon Hahn
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
We present a novel method, the Chain of Empathy (CoE) prompting, that
utilizes insights from psychotherapy to induce Large Language Models (LLMs) to
reason about human emotional states. This method is inspired by various
psychotherapy approaches including Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT),
Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT), Person Centered Therapy (PCT), and Reality
Therapy (RT), each leading to different patterns of interpreting clients'
mental states. LLMs without reasoning generated predominantly exploratory
responses. However, when LLMs used CoE reasoning, we found a more comprehensive
range of empathetic responses aligned with the different reasoning patterns of
each psychotherapy model. The CBT based CoE resulted in the most balanced
generation of empathetic responses. The findings underscore the importance of
understanding the emotional context and how it affects human and AI
communication. Our research contributes to understanding how psychotherapeutic
models can be incorporated into LLMs, facilitating the development of
context-specific, safer, and empathetic AI.
|
[
-0.4157915413,
-0.9759401679,
0.748867631,
0.2383334637,
-0.1120662466,
0.0919085145,
-0.1727078706,
-0.4391512275,
0.271173209,
0.4010542035,
-0.6075820327,
-0.2737829983,
-0.4658616185,
0.2369719446,
-0.2269058526,
0.8910360932,
-0.0498295799,
0.2421024591,
0.2000090778,
-0.0953070223,
-0.1390005201,
-0.7623651028,
-0.9754109383,
-0.4779750109,
0.9630818367,
0.3529316783,
0.4949651361,
0.5004133582,
0.3357959688,
0.2540678084,
0.0372259133,
0.0958638266,
-0.3092932701,
0.0724805146,
-0.4008952379,
-0.1598435789,
-0.8300327063,
-0.034629602,
0.2248084843,
0.7046893835,
-0.3753274381,
-0.0973429754,
0.1751159281,
0.6845268607,
-0.6216291189,
-0.4161056578,
-0.4180762172,
0.2093958259,
0.4013625979,
-0.4844855368,
-0.6916046739,
-0.1596059203,
0.2040608674,
-0.336805582,
-0.0853702798,
0.4662077129,
0.42808339,
-0.0540609807,
-0.8037623167,
-0.4306406677,
-0.6530181766,
0.5927430391,
-0.642825067,
0.2530131042,
0.4786692262,
-0.0980164111,
0.0524662547,
-0.7214486599,
-0.402711153,
-0.4561778605,
0.1000510827,
0.3373769522,
-0.3283127844,
0.3509786725,
0.5115174651,
0.1392540187,
-0.2883144915,
0.0415460691,
-0.0450487994,
0.150058195,
0.5950182676,
0.478145808,
0.3590975404,
0.1903078854,
-0.3453425765,
0.1199506521,
-0.528726697,
0.0558673441,
0.2823663354,
0.1668013185,
-0.3908628821,
0.5745876431,
0.2127581537,
0.6931041479,
0.3259991705,
0.0852995291,
-0.4018795192,
0.1175488159,
-0.2092229575,
0.4900707901,
0.6816211939,
0.7100355625,
0.4325060546,
-0.0383913256,
0.2342052907,
0.1040240079,
0.6068758965,
-0.7980890274,
-0.0344626307,
0.2491745651,
-0.6516142488,
-0.3705132604,
-0.0457898863,
-0.7527549267,
-0.3762894273,
-0.256426841,
-0.1419790387,
-0.5546296835,
-0.5017511845,
0.0827271566,
0.0054472811,
0.3668832183,
0.2455533743,
-0.9924636483,
0.7145302892,
0.6620490551,
1.0608018637,
0.1733970642,
-0.410020709,
-0.6454627514,
0.2969805002,
-0.440870434,
0.8440875411,
-0.8020873666,
-0.3600806594,
0.1478570104,
-0.0262728576,
0.124156855,
-0.1248561442,
0.4889769554,
-0.061716564,
-0.0440755859,
-0.4345645607,
-0.7341454029,
0.0051780394,
0.5263539553,
-0.5379037261,
0.5776344538,
0.2376198322,
-0.9538505673,
0.0658644363,
-0.923173368,
-0.557289958,
-0.2753407359,
0.0776128843,
0.1354625374,
0.4229132235,
0.1940854639,
0.4295399487,
-0.5323256254,
-0.0164966043,
-0.6461244226,
-0.2781000137,
0.3930702806,
-0.3654686213,
0.5936756134,
0.4039149284,
-0.2791519761,
0.0170198325,
-0.4573452771,
-0.0060174544,
0.0978688076,
-0.0400338024,
-0.5857575536,
-0.1590918005,
0.1636903733,
0.4104962647,
-0.0049799937,
-0.6533434987,
0.2764365077,
-0.2501455545,
0.556961894,
0.921954155,
0.1431405842,
0.3990869522,
-0.2529730797,
0.7294756174,
0.0851360336,
0.2242323756,
-0.1287642121,
-0.2873913348,
-0.5617037416,
-0.2052077949,
-0.2633968294,
0.2828278542,
-0.2964327335,
0.4922287166,
0.1451732814,
-0.5185136795,
-0.5366357565,
-0.2338385731,
0.4137941599,
0.4734632373,
0.2911784053,
-0.4579770565,
-0.5272388458,
-0.6170362234,
-0.5083833337,
-0.209606722,
0.1542515755,
0.4013468623,
0.3124863505,
-0.0795808583,
0.7818541527,
-0.3945384324,
0.1032835618,
-0.4434403479,
0.2078920156,
0.0293607339,
0.2450411618,
0.2558879852,
-0.6148857474,
-0.5252935886,
0.191692248,
-0.7115242481,
-0.083844699,
-0.2459046543,
-0.4218107462,
0.0729315057,
0.5318213701,
-0.2254944444,
0.4955447018,
0.7236660719,
-0.7923501134,
0.2940569222,
-0.3132591546,
0.3529818654,
-1.2838490009,
0.0274043512,
0.0980872586,
-0.1335089952,
-0.613201797,
-0.3065042496,
-0.252281934,
0.1094586998,
-0.4541733265,
0.6938379407,
-0.4492341876,
0.1062902734,
-0.2218990028,
0.1922028065,
-0.0800550506,
0.4338648319,
0.2483643889,
0.2117157131,
0.7127895951,
-0.4096088707,
0.8023126125,
0.3314157128,
0.1575305015,
1.1053860188,
-0.6192142963,
0.3940378428,
0.1123398244,
0.5715982318,
-0.623537302,
-0.2975944281,
0.2800564766,
-0.1970486045,
-0.1405955553,
-0.1155759171,
-0.3340194225,
-0.4823192358,
-0.0984704718,
0.4382730722,
0.5798438191,
-0.6957243681,
0.7648382187,
-0.1138234064,
-0.1560246497,
-0.2341942936,
-0.7067463398,
0.1602575928,
-0.4123204648,
-0.4641634226,
-0.11051476,
-0.3029993474,
-0.6012345552,
-0.1256022304,
-0.0158849154,
-0.1735096574,
-0.0364888869,
0.2846693695,
0.0095681846,
0.1487887353,
0.1709445119,
0.4677564502,
-0.1049380302,
0.31285429,
0.0697904974,
0.6939641237,
-0.3901744187,
-0.4753314555,
-0.5855692029,
0.7219563723,
0.4627666175,
-0.1286542565,
0.9237181544,
0.6054279804,
-0.1357998699,
-0.0730544031,
-0.3999672234,
-0.4963899851,
-0.4220026731,
0.0588931367,
-0.4547993243,
-0.9992823005,
0.4785124362,
-0.4272866845,
-0.4083243906,
-0.2617416978,
0.879506886,
0.1327424794,
1.4106018543,
0.3922690153,
-0.2096819878,
0.654620111,
-0.1520425379,
0.7754458189,
-1.2271597385,
0.0857086331,
-0.0665437281,
-0.1769166589,
-0.5228638053,
0.0663791001,
0.2914097011,
-0.001862616,
-0.6212199926,
-0.0872723088,
-0.5781805515,
0.2520338595,
0.272957176,
0.5764346719,
0.351234138,
-0.1168171614,
-0.0034386986,
0.0505409315,
-0.7518202662,
-0.5155638456,
0.937161386,
0.4272441268,
0.9681288004,
-0.0153890867,
0.758307457,
0.3353718519,
0.6855129004,
-0.8540130854,
0.3827034831,
0.3372955918,
-0.4215412438,
-0.0745174959,
-0.2687725425,
-1.1105862856,
-0.0229367334,
0.0699017122,
-1.1964644194,
0.0520070456,
0.2282987684,
-0.4104970694,
0.3613243699,
-0.5640013814,
0.503764689,
-0.2369463444,
-0.6072055697,
-0.292956233,
-0.72989887,
0.2485904247,
0.0243089236,
0.136172682,
-0.0110382028,
0.0241471957,
0.5674021244,
-0.6480830312,
0.852214992,
0.0360076949,
-0.4080020487,
0.3039964139,
0.3916324079,
0.6927627921,
-0.1032671183,
-0.2306347638,
-0.1118744835,
-0.2020319998,
-0.4455345869,
-0.9097794294,
0.7793982625,
-0.5728129148,
-0.4632871449,
-0.3497061729,
-0.8188036084,
-0.1904889941,
-0.0164870005,
0.2189387083,
0.3918793499,
-0.2517978847,
0.1162082329,
0.280526787,
-0.2213082463,
0.1685176045,
0.4417925179,
0.0059447028,
-0.4213363528,
0.5257159472,
-0.3765611351,
0.5432472229,
0.0964526013,
0.4920874834,
-0.0459119305,
0.2149836719,
0.2956061959,
0.3330584764,
-0.5556278229,
-0.1158652529,
-0.5809997916,
-0.0213085059,
-0.650901556,
-0.8466352224,
-0.4705384672,
0.1110099927,
0.0901402384,
-0.4411789775,
0.7567555904,
0.9390348196,
-0.3814995885,
0.3109306097,
-0.8098127842,
0.1430176049,
0.1208437607,
0.3622561991,
0.4774279296,
-0.3437119424,
-0.4284963906,
0.1944683492,
-0.3597200215,
-0.9327757955,
0.6093770266,
-0.1362241209,
0.0711936504,
0.5904675126,
0.237551555,
0.7912418246,
-0.4757443368,
0.7531534433,
0.5581305623,
-1.3175225258,
0.6848792434,
-0.5646795034,
0.0131644243,
-0.0295479279,
0.5058075786,
-0.7913834453,
-0.6670373678,
-0.9374150038,
-1.0030982494,
0.6373164654,
0.1028710827,
0.20967637,
-0.3091514707,
0.4466644228,
-0.1195278466,
0.0040782569,
-0.6171184778,
-0.0410767719,
0.0437933542,
-0.4463229775,
0.0639919415,
-0.2578136623,
-0.5200084448,
-0.2641905844,
0.2519054413,
-0.2264178097,
0.5108661056,
0.6196260452,
0.1762521714,
-0.5939033031,
0.144056201,
0.3439826071,
0.4977467954,
-0.0868343562,
0.2498870939,
0.3507768512,
-0.1155091822,
0.2655355632,
-0.4449571967,
0.7233593464,
-0.5231299996,
0.7971148491,
0.7591633201,
0.0804345682,
-0.5996876955,
0.4625526667,
-0.1320315897,
-0.1627895236,
-0.3417160511,
0.034725301,
0.0478976667,
0.7662222981,
-0.1228791773,
-0.3675019443,
0.3032436371,
-0.7336850762,
0.2331503034,
0.0735718682,
-0.4293803871,
-0.2773085535,
0.4022016823,
0.1078390256,
-0.6122223735,
0.897865653,
0.353064388,
-0.5232511759,
0.4896191657,
0.8979063034,
0.9256361127,
-0.5474837422,
0.2240890414,
0.2496127039,
-0.0141603239,
-0.1525646597,
0.1982739717,
-0.2356837243,
-1.0184227228,
-0.0727243051,
-0.1625819206,
-0.720752418,
-0.3192943037,
-1.4173948765,
-0.0366887897,
-0.5438193083,
-0.1770500392,
-0.4284236729,
-0.2204806358,
-0.5365379453,
0.1604961753,
0.2884553373,
1.014146924,
-0.9962697029,
0.8236585259,
0.6184760928,
-0.4277975559,
-1.1426651478,
0.2108042985,
-0.0838982686,
-0.8178372979,
0.6815291047,
0.0489570498,
-0.3582911789,
0.3655177653,
-0.7590821385,
-0.4858839214,
1.142125845,
0.3102630079,
-0.4811437428,
0.0534002222,
-0.0004278989,
0.7480233312,
-0.804232657,
0.5130625367,
0.7863999605,
0.6185063124,
0.0268332232,
-0.6976957917,
0.4374650717,
-0.3480699062,
0.1761550605,
-0.0751915649,
-0.8509002328,
0.5188606977,
-0.3900566399,
0.3067992032,
0.3427010775,
0.2048279345,
0.5896308422,
0.4260674119,
0.5787272453,
0.4944200814,
0.6192248464,
0.0698199049,
1.488083005,
-0.4522337317,
0.3956569433,
1.0421925783,
-0.6437655687,
0.7501654029,
0.8911664486,
0.0564257875,
0.7018097639,
0.7429822683,
-0.0145756053,
0.3247458637,
0.3212613463,
-0.5412012339,
-0.2933750153,
-0.5421836972,
-0.1506052762,
0.2152509391,
0.2274650633,
-0.4614775479,
0.0915409476,
0.2340939492,
0.33155635,
0.0074199559,
-0.3312605917,
0.7157055736,
0.5591875911,
-0.6295675039,
0.3127613664,
-0.3235003352,
0.1935970783,
-0.521823287,
-0.1378260851,
-0.3276095986,
0.2562610209,
-0.2099669874,
-0.7433246374,
0.1301422268,
0.2643967867,
0.1065244526,
-0.3780803978,
0.5308885574,
-0.4602067769,
-0.3351736367,
0.9027751088,
0.4444392323,
0.1304516196,
-0.0201783869,
-0.6909620762,
0.2944467068,
-0.2667065561,
-0.7683247328,
0.2692800462,
0.8474306464,
0.1511521041,
0.8752803802,
0.606923759,
0.0671211109,
-0.2444193512,
0.2705120146,
1.0385686159,
-1.0187586546,
-0.46238029,
-1.0841950178,
0.7111130357,
-0.1860449165,
-0.0444832258,
0.6828219891,
0.0734110996,
0.4239058197,
0.0649109632,
0.6539414525,
-0.2490050197,
0.1313413829,
-0.5653238893,
0.3864347041,
-0.6386873126,
-0.0621871725,
-0.7205250859,
-0.9834322333,
-0.4008688331,
0.8185242414,
-0.5152561665,
0.2943750918,
1.1579954624,
0.6812059283,
0.2027351409,
0.1787713766,
0.5797278881,
0.5982741714,
0.3682866395,
0.76946491,
1.1754819155,
-0.0624532662,
0.0469925478,
0.0476078019,
-0.4157704115,
-0.143902123,
-0.898227632,
-0.8513251543,
-0.4018145502,
-0.0590365715,
-0.6105108857,
0.1228374839,
1.3063850403,
0.5299921632,
-0.3320329487,
-0.4082268476,
-0.5043466687,
-0.0399284028,
-0.4107505679,
-0.2559036911,
0.2089835107,
-0.2003275007,
-0.6759866476,
0.0894045606,
0.4430321157,
-0.2022684216,
-0.0270808935,
-0.4961777031,
-0.1803098321,
0.3212630749,
0.8064681888,
-0.0592111796,
-0.667081356,
-0.3815167546,
-0.2637621164,
0.1164443344,
0.1181277707,
1.2621105909,
-0.2977268398,
0.3207209706,
0.1526282877,
0.1420313418,
0.1344195753,
0.1650262028,
1.047242403,
-0.2998090386,
0.3576262295,
0.2006831467,
0.4973585904,
0.0721095577,
-0.6984987259,
0.6002522707,
-0.0872489065,
-0.6063799858,
-0.9313994646,
0.568602562,
-1.2514693737,
-0.1791352332,
1.2951421738,
-0.5331408978,
-0.29716748,
0.0533532687,
-0.7144527435,
0.5566654205,
-0.5733941197,
0.7865431309,
0.6976358294,
-0.6871427298,
-0.4781293869,
0.0641076192,
0.1127096787,
0.3741882145,
-0.9443029165,
0.3358102441,
0.2575311661,
0.0183842313,
-0.2059810311,
0.5715930462,
0.0156235443,
0.0632594898,
0.1649740636,
0.2512948513,
0.1118133739,
-0.2091562301,
-0.2754764557,
-0.0878620073,
0.0665438697,
0.3975288272
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00915v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00915v1
|
Task-Agnostic Low-Rank Adapters for Unseen English Dialects
| 2023-11-02T01:17:29 | 2023-11-02T01:17:29 |
Zedian Xiao, William Held, Yanchen Liu, Diyi Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are trained on corpora disproportionally
weighted in favor of Standard American English. As a result, speakers of other
dialects experience significantly more failures when interacting with these
technologies. In practice, these speakers often accommodate their speech to be
better understood. Our work shares the belief that language technologies should
be designed to accommodate the diversity in English dialects and not the other
way around. However, prior works on dialect struggle with generalizing to
evolving and emerging dialects in a scalable manner. To fill this gap, our
method, HyperLoRA, leverages expert linguistic knowledge to enable
resource-efficient adaptation via hypernetworks. By disentangling
dialect-specific and cross-dialectal information, HyperLoRA improves
generalization to unseen dialects in a task-agnostic fashion. Not only is
HyperLoRA more scalable in the number of parameters, but it also achieves the
best or most competitive performance across 5 dialects in a zero-shot setting.
In this way, our approach facilitates access to language technology for
billions of English dialect speakers who are traditionally underrepresented.
|
[
-0.3825539351,
-0.4605904222,
0.7003560662,
0.3010134697,
0.0032176883,
-0.0007685799,
-0.5305867791,
-0.5276556015,
0.4054608941,
0.4772261679,
-0.3481918275,
-0.3507715762,
-0.5741040111,
0.112734586,
-0.1916742325,
0.7027089596,
0.6645027399,
-0.2394865304,
0.1394876838,
-0.27748245,
-0.5875973105,
-0.4285722375,
-0.6153202653,
-0.2560935616,
0.72728163,
0.7939161658,
1.0055884123,
0.64189291,
0.0875823423,
0.3587657511,
-0.2033365816,
0.3216263354,
-0.618401289,
0.1144510731,
-0.5849832892,
-0.7404255867,
-0.6692282557,
-0.088618286,
0.521718204,
0.8957063556,
-0.0542601086,
0.2224435657,
0.2282387912,
0.6342015266,
-0.7374241352,
-0.0071185594,
-1.3222024441,
-0.0204354953,
-0.2846648693,
-0.2001745403,
-0.4207431972,
0.0537507869,
-0.1218382344,
-0.8924176693,
0.1557960808,
0.1723225713,
0.820718348,
0.0715439692,
-0.2576904595,
0.2054496408,
-1.0412076712,
0.8522630334,
-0.7250409126,
0.5677823424,
0.2551307678,
0.4285798073,
-0.1447276324,
-0.4678526819,
-0.6070515513,
-0.1277652383,
-0.010287174,
0.1552190483,
-0.4043291509,
0.2377233654,
0.0868799537,
0.1643245965,
-0.8129132986,
0.5769323111,
-0.2513743341,
0.0938575715,
0.2482025921,
0.0025828884,
-0.1053068414,
-0.0707207844,
0.0018374915,
0.223722145,
-0.687962234,
-0.3208757341,
0.1227133349,
0.7903391123,
-0.0409551971,
0.2432867587,
-0.2772871554,
0.8484861851,
0.2849839032,
0.065186061,
0.2313667089,
-0.0054879892,
-0.3705112338,
0.0060601612,
0.2299364507,
0.0495830514,
0.4293400943,
-0.1625828445,
-0.1185948774,
-0.3402560949,
0.154866308,
-0.5773617625,
-0.09328527,
0.2577443123,
-0.2724584043,
-0.0920870677,
-0.2787787914,
-0.8607301712,
-0.5613889098,
-0.2383626848,
0.3567821085,
-0.0835995302,
-0.273542285,
-0.0237227753,
-0.1604765654,
-0.0029071001,
0.4105713367,
-1.147330761,
0.3905634582,
0.7399047613,
0.9066097736,
-0.1967304647,
-0.4785483479,
-0.5580435395,
0.4247774184,
-0.4384318888,
0.6028013229,
-0.448168546,
-0.1456211209,
0.0722389072,
0.2912062705,
-0.1895301789,
-0.9194794297,
0.2268163264,
-0.538416326,
0.065364264,
0.0173028726,
-0.354146719,
-0.0429085009,
0.2104324251,
-0.521332562,
0.8666904569,
0.1356824785,
-0.38187024,
0.3002673686,
-0.6229937077,
-0.1288957298,
0.3336340487,
0.0280981623,
-0.0447524227,
0.4309900403,
0.0348565765,
0.4868384004,
-0.2239160836,
0.0776225179,
-0.3545564413,
-0.4662967324,
-0.1986202896,
-0.5137895942,
0.5398314595,
0.2951104045,
-0.4893673062,
0.0072842417,
-0.8830601573,
0.1023401394,
0.0968336686,
-0.3400011361,
-0.6837645769,
-0.0410787798,
0.2396676987,
0.1206606776,
0.2409068048,
-0.5046876073,
0.0214594826,
-0.4574463367,
0.1865135282,
0.9502077103,
-0.2813899219,
0.2425042987,
-0.2142687738,
0.353246659,
0.0300278347,
0.1333165467,
0.2144951373,
-0.4586987197,
-1.0446286201,
-0.276735723,
0.1413705945,
0.5487936735,
-0.648212254,
0.5257797837,
-0.4801410437,
-0.6613624096,
-0.5074330568,
0.476501435,
0.2765589058,
0.2839077711,
0.5031266212,
-0.1445725411,
-0.4719647467,
-0.9725599885,
-0.2483711243,
-0.3265012801,
-0.1254467964,
0.2562864125,
0.0093789902,
-0.3052579761,
0.8046877384,
-0.4437119663,
-0.2609867156,
-0.5080849528,
-0.0661130399,
0.580937326,
0.2750686109,
0.7516744137,
-0.5593163371,
-0.6052011251,
0.5309786797,
-0.5967258811,
-0.3173768222,
-0.1243618205,
-0.1592050493,
0.2731867731,
0.4189900458,
-0.2724613845,
-0.0469913967,
0.9388411641,
-0.3082488477,
0.3496356606,
-0.2956688702,
-0.0240846835,
-1.1933323145,
0.0619852915,
0.1004404724,
-0.4382257164,
-0.8328581452,
0.0642650276,
0.0164894443,
-0.2222364247,
-0.4480967224,
0.619273603,
-0.577060163,
-0.2105745673,
-0.4376715422,
0.2467025965,
-0.0063785724,
0.5213703513,
0.06433063,
0.7681871057,
0.4479266703,
-0.5035828352,
0.1628600657,
-0.0211893804,
0.0264930073,
0.6485452652,
-0.5965119004,
0.1423305422,
0.0502350889,
-0.2459841222,
-0.7470631003,
0.0800700337,
-0.3184649348,
-0.1821629107,
0.2086906135,
-0.2544574738,
0.0214880835,
-0.1845244765,
-0.1805678308,
0.1951817572,
0.5212489367,
-0.6587016582,
0.4311597645,
0.3741558194,
-0.5304345489,
-0.5081506371,
-0.6230428815,
0.4389200807,
-0.123646304,
-0.3613350391,
0.1611099243,
-0.1471474022,
-0.4113349617,
-0.0347149894,
0.0304229744,
-0.298127979,
0.0992357209,
0.1349631697,
0.0754867643,
-0.6042069197,
0.0917008147,
-0.0388633758,
0.1098003462,
-0.4028019309,
-0.6358521581,
0.4232517779,
0.0922525078,
-0.3902344406,
-0.1750822514,
0.5144006014,
0.9504753947,
0.0129436851,
0.6524201035,
0.4679739177,
-0.2893462777,
-0.6949082017,
-0.6677732468,
0.1219950318,
-0.5679383278,
0.7681908607,
-0.3681365252,
-0.9485871196,
0.3048097789,
-0.0114275422,
0.1759035587,
0.2251592278,
0.5676723123,
0.0525264107,
0.670227766,
1.0747690201,
-0.5391234159,
0.4958990216,
0.0734028816,
0.0895030051,
-0.4614377022,
0.3249174953,
-0.6158429384,
-0.3063295782,
-0.6431959271,
-0.4316459,
0.7015468478,
-0.2974798977,
-0.1605848223,
0.5107343197,
-0.2903062701,
0.4352876544,
0.6786621213,
-0.0007575933,
0.3999165595,
0.0828679278,
0.1286502033,
0.0157733802,
-0.9047417045,
-0.2918204665,
1.0721952915,
0.3933676481,
0.5891730189,
0.3746259809,
0.7677336335,
0.5991953611,
0.0613833889,
-0.8527985215,
0.6065735817,
-0.4746143818,
-0.4850184321,
-0.5607473254,
-0.2596923411,
-1.1478717327,
0.402357161,
-0.2253250182,
-0.6042501926,
0.530188024,
0.3743851483,
-0.2999473214,
0.2651706338,
-0.6720323563,
0.6162596345,
-0.080089286,
-0.4748449624,
-0.5111889839,
-0.2818772495,
-0.0090028457,
-0.3113915026,
0.5177802444,
0.0505714528,
-0.0487975553,
0.5537270904,
-0.3270086348,
0.8791332841,
-0.3396448195,
-0.0171192773,
-0.0836126059,
0.1818796694,
0.4964569807,
-0.3673927486,
-0.3296848834,
0.1535543352,
-0.2837537527,
-0.7563334107,
-0.718393147,
0.8743059039,
-0.8218261003,
-0.8876264095,
-0.185015291,
-0.7367550731,
-0.6718130708,
0.2480532229,
-0.10244371,
0.2600309551,
-0.2794269025,
0.0592509322,
0.6403926611,
-0.0120065697,
0.4906677306,
0.7741927505,
0.0214027427,
-0.1952924579,
0.9364509583,
0.2629865408,
0.5089105368,
0.3403522074,
0.1377668679,
0.1473894864,
-0.9461887479,
-0.5049773455,
0.2265070528,
-0.7000677586,
0.0523251891,
-0.3383091986,
-0.0465886407,
-0.4120400548,
-0.3217844367,
-0.3679280281,
-0.6140005589,
-0.0251901951,
-0.1819348484,
0.1311483234,
0.9164913297,
-0.0073306845,
0.2441885769,
-0.7577739358,
0.2283895016,
0.6099132299,
0.1328327656,
-0.0547119752,
-0.9690980315,
-0.6286099553,
-0.2547850013,
-0.1061265245,
-0.7906318307,
0.3865354061,
0.5533751249,
0.7488077879,
0.2725875676,
-0.1274807453,
0.7842904329,
-0.6905469298,
0.8208525777,
0.0202764496,
-0.8604066372,
0.2641508281,
-0.4080589116,
0.2549469471,
0.5519595742,
0.3716597259,
-0.6352593303,
-0.5311945081,
-0.2778052688,
-0.9370597005,
0.4337645471,
-0.1925701499,
0.2817512751,
0.1586731672,
0.0829370543,
0.043183174,
0.2410227805,
-0.7424797416,
-0.1016799659,
-0.2297235429,
-0.2841320932,
-0.4492720068,
-0.2226993144,
-0.2011960298,
-0.3274372518,
0.7673154473,
-0.473061651,
0.0157015864,
0.0047324887,
-0.2587666214,
-0.1705759615,
0.5099015832,
0.466498673,
0.6917248368,
-0.1178951338,
0.4674320519,
0.3974656463,
-0.5530961752,
0.2848429084,
0.0128564816,
-0.0497250706,
0.2685277462,
0.5778048635,
0.6806052923,
0.1272838414,
-0.4433307648,
0.3460557163,
0.446855396,
-0.0118091656,
-0.1210463196,
0.1024275944,
0.2203552723,
0.3653023243,
0.4435904324,
-0.0017249673,
0.0350339599,
-0.7174505591,
0.2111114562,
0.4630838037,
-0.4534989893,
-0.2791835964,
0.3969506919,
0.547409296,
-0.2905207276,
0.0201123301,
-0.1584671289,
-0.2360539436,
0.5266174674,
0.6910386682,
1.0353325605,
-0.291071862,
0.1135931462,
-0.0446898602,
0.3989425004,
0.2032670826,
0.1194642708,
0.1672325581,
-0.732624352,
-0.1600059122,
-0.6077176332,
-0.5348935127,
0.143284142,
-0.4186746478,
0.2293830663,
-0.5558633804,
-0.1110159978,
0.0194016919,
-0.2307861596,
-0.5577195883,
0.0706949309,
0.2830073833,
1.1377649307,
-1.1633597612,
0.9590016007,
0.703897953,
0.0759039819,
-0.7201418877,
0.402343452,
0.1228908226,
-1.0854334831,
0.5248350501,
-0.3350868821,
-0.3208336532,
0.1508527845,
-0.2156234384,
-0.732640624,
1.0621101856,
0.6215473413,
-0.6649760008,
-0.0052139908,
0.2808923423,
0.6018347144,
-0.2304677069,
0.4448966086,
0.3829761446,
0.6475474238,
-0.2066844106,
-1.3804564476,
-0.1017966047,
-0.1988223344,
0.1302931309,
-0.2329550833,
-0.7975535393,
0.8004758358,
0.1267864406,
0.185804069,
-0.1390098333,
0.5291591287,
0.0411589555,
0.2776878178,
0.6511070728,
0.3138549328,
0.8374332786,
0.2411835343,
0.5578106642,
-0.2940230072,
0.0854008794,
1.0699199438,
-0.4791845083,
0.9002309442,
0.4721314311,
-0.2992104292,
0.6788130999,
0.2951996326,
0.3097069263,
0.287276715,
0.1359531879,
-0.2529533207,
-0.4380111992,
-0.356652528,
-0.1401707828,
0.6135966778,
0.1665092856,
-0.2174521685,
-0.24526079,
-0.0616149716,
0.2305192202,
0.4860067964,
-0.6888697743,
0.698420763,
-0.1243191287,
-0.5125616789,
1.1206049919,
-0.1058891639,
0.9301207066,
-0.7353387475,
-0.0172643401,
-0.37178424,
0.1302177012,
-0.416249454,
-0.3968729079,
0.0988351926,
0.009923677,
-0.3689303696,
0.0329368785,
0.5845325589,
-0.3981342316,
-0.4970804155,
0.6406376362,
0.9259256124,
0.0994821265,
-0.0503326766,
-0.4210853279,
-0.0001401169,
-0.0909156799,
-0.2906047106,
0.5976042151,
0.583573103,
-0.1605968177,
0.6175326109,
0.2973966599,
0.6496818066,
0.1723024398,
0.0404609665,
0.860429585,
-0.5542981029,
-0.5465893149,
-0.6176166534,
0.2136632204,
-0.0942722186,
-0.151484713,
0.8263171911,
0.5437986851,
0.7606141567,
-0.0890266299,
0.9788571596,
0.2051242441,
0.6526082754,
-0.4934087694,
0.7331159115,
-0.7230795026,
0.1849647611,
-0.3096776605,
-0.9775707126,
-0.0384096019,
0.09954831,
-0.0441620052,
-0.1122529134,
0.5909144878,
1.0290522575,
-0.3517858982,
-0.3941009045,
0.9169228077,
0.499106437,
0.1139597148,
0.6276664734,
0.409745872,
0.1815722436,
0.4298837483,
0.1441600621,
-0.4586253166,
-0.1557162702,
-0.8403259516,
-0.6449123621,
-0.3378195763,
0.0210145209,
-0.0509122685,
0.5821892619,
1.0569453239,
1.0685696602,
-1.0099871159,
-0.7165394425,
0.1322451383,
0.0411926955,
-0.4273454249,
-0.2260770649,
0.0241281744,
-0.3792363107,
-1.0651119947,
0.811062634,
0.3673025966,
-0.221776396,
-0.4250070155,
-0.0271519851,
-0.1331448108,
0.4351641834,
0.5633283854,
0.4904790223,
-0.3979219794,
-0.5867369175,
-0.1166473925,
-0.0103367195,
-0.0192565136,
0.6530775428,
-0.7500892282,
0.244960174,
0.2715062499,
0.7128407955,
0.0901605561,
-0.1370240897,
0.638214469,
-0.8618688583,
0.5787329674,
0.145631358,
0.3788417876,
0.1778010726,
-0.4499773085,
0.3683483601,
0.5188533664,
-0.4872926474,
-0.7798075676,
0.3114558756,
-0.9579799771,
-0.4360350072,
1.2776542902,
-0.2619346976,
-0.0214651972,
-0.4357726574,
0.0446574762,
-0.0332061388,
-0.2376303971,
0.561005652,
0.4056814313,
-0.0976626351,
-0.0811398551,
-0.7245438099,
0.4033712447,
0.8372566104,
-0.6807801723,
0.2512305379,
0.4314353168,
0.1995375603,
0.1894083172,
0.664168179,
0.33375296,
0.1119790748,
-0.2563430965,
0.0969932228,
-0.2346816361,
-0.5815467238,
-0.5972728729,
0.310334444,
0.7054454684,
-0.1444712579
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00913v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00913v1
|
Self-Influence Guided Data Reweighting for Language Model Pre-training
| 2023-11-02T01:00:46 | 2023-11-02T01:00:46 |
Megh Thakkar, Tolga Bolukbasi, Sriram Ganapathy, Shikhar Vashishth, Sarath Chandar, Partha Talukdar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language Models (LMs) pre-trained with self-supervision on large text corpora
have become the default starting point for developing models for various NLP
tasks. Once the pre-training corpus has been assembled, all data samples in the
corpus are treated with equal importance during LM pre-training. However, due
to varying levels of relevance and quality of data, equal importance to all the
data samples may not be the optimal choice. While data reweighting has been
explored in the context of task-specific supervised learning and LM
fine-tuning, model-driven reweighting for pre-training data has not been
explored. We fill this important gap and propose PRESENCE, a method for jointly
reweighting samples by leveraging self-influence (SI) scores as an indicator of
sample importance and pre-training. PRESENCE promotes novelty and stability for
model pre-training. Through extensive analysis spanning multiple model sizes,
datasets, and tasks, we present PRESENCE as an important first step in the
research direction of sample reweighting for pre-training language models.
|
[
-0.3650763929,
-0.4276438355,
0.5550829172,
0.5165197253,
-0.2420128435,
-0.1213373989,
-0.149821341,
-0.1955997348,
0.8325971961,
0.6560758948,
-0.5266155005,
-0.5057089329,
-0.7418194413,
-0.080074057,
-0.4366866648,
1.0281260014,
0.1618966311,
0.282009095,
-0.6299952269,
-0.2826709747,
-0.4295681417,
-0.8267449141,
-0.1991182119,
-0.1282136142,
0.6476382017,
0.15283297,
0.624992907,
0.2101990879,
0.1120659858,
0.268625319,
0.3529325724,
-0.1857100427,
-0.5005731583,
0.1571105868,
-0.143353954,
-0.5214766264,
-0.5633974671,
0.4044108391,
0.8681117892,
1.1307643652,
-0.1442182213,
0.321277827,
0.3205277026,
0.227246657,
-0.7129993439,
-0.1256764829,
-0.4360547364,
-0.0826625451,
-0.1676174104,
-0.260626018,
-0.3466788828,
-0.0898887068,
0.2109892815,
-0.4385026991,
0.3255117536,
0.2038488388,
0.7233129144,
0.4602198005,
-0.3363145292,
-0.0419046991,
-0.6619679332,
1.0736066103,
-0.7411054969,
0.7860989571,
0.5520234704,
-0.2930150628,
-0.2387809604,
-0.5382816195,
-0.4481928051,
-0.303183496,
-0.2534297109,
0.0901781023,
-0.0434119739,
-0.068016015,
0.1126550063,
0.3169618845,
-0.2116720825,
0.2386924028,
-0.2916247547,
-0.0851677805,
0.443225503,
-0.2651511729,
0.3881049454,
-0.0173860881,
-0.2801471651,
-0.0631217957,
-0.8460020423,
-0.1742616594,
0.2132590115,
0.4615598619,
-0.16146788,
0.4926089942,
-0.2581855953,
0.6366610527,
0.2991120219,
0.0783188641,
0.3913766146,
-0.3622485399,
-0.2431330234,
0.1653877944,
0.7394014001,
0.116674073,
0.089963384,
-0.0071506929,
-0.1345145106,
-0.2824373245,
0.6587269902,
-0.9424159527,
-0.180974111,
0.1240388751,
-0.6291739941,
-0.326267004,
0.1373433918,
-0.5737603903,
-0.1754815727,
-0.5106995106,
0.7154760361,
-0.0082964264,
-0.5275228024,
-0.0539444648,
0.5449367166,
0.1854688525,
0.3912007809,
-0.9651257396,
0.3482683599,
0.4826330543,
0.6428611875,
-0.4208099544,
-0.4874415994,
-0.8970199227,
-0.2005573064,
-0.4153035283,
0.5939856172,
-0.4534437954,
-0.4654727578,
-0.1015628949,
0.2463282198,
-0.003634152,
-0.4025731087,
0.3231944144,
-0.4437101781,
0.5437014103,
-0.3658053577,
-0.6417524219,
0.2126305103,
0.1585600376,
-0.7438541651,
1.279091239,
0.1757630557,
-0.6594879031,
0.7320053577,
-0.2878842354,
-0.577690959,
0.1128013283,
-0.4414059222,
-0.5909310579,
0.4515325725,
0.2334296405,
0.6260097027,
0.2397961617,
0.2576195896,
-0.579210639,
-0.1267398298,
-0.1415767372,
-0.2695203424,
0.6175224185,
-0.0186446793,
-0.2970757186,
0.127877757,
-0.763994813,
0.1686405987,
-0.180135861,
-0.2671724558,
-0.7226371169,
0.0954236463,
-0.0841573998,
0.181220606,
0.3668831289,
-0.4312349558,
0.2174710184,
-0.5118041635,
-0.1487848163,
0.4918499589,
0.0315668359,
0.398203373,
0.1333285868,
0.8225685358,
-0.1748406589,
0.0148018412,
-0.1161888689,
-0.3052890003,
-0.7310731411,
0.0025338798,
0.6240440011,
0.1825923175,
-0.4713764787,
0.5795307755,
-0.2955272496,
-0.3227775991,
-0.6202686429,
0.4226270616,
0.2909505069,
0.1522195935,
0.6024823785,
-0.413182795,
-0.6051671505,
-0.972383976,
-0.0017707869,
0.0744579956,
-0.178783074,
-0.0339246392,
0.3996458054,
-0.1382319182,
1.1606609821,
-0.3884869814,
-0.390119344,
-0.3911465108,
0.1031448022,
-0.0361078419,
0.7014199495,
0.7913169861,
-0.730209887,
-0.4223590791,
-0.4893054366,
-0.686252296,
-0.4387855232,
-0.2025080025,
-0.1946537793,
-0.1094579399,
0.8842903376,
-0.2233760804,
0.4945734739,
0.8695421815,
-0.2645615041,
0.35152933,
-0.3599346578,
0.0347051583,
-1.0915421247,
0.0239049569,
-0.1214441583,
-0.4349304438,
-0.7299959064,
-0.2106722444,
0.0194542743,
-0.0264208876,
-0.2132770568,
0.7156818509,
-0.7042401433,
-0.1952438802,
-0.4997462034,
0.0546645224,
0.1804196835,
0.3056387305,
0.2313058227,
0.5802155733,
0.637655735,
-0.5987829566,
-0.1958108544,
-0.0933725312,
-0.3998309672,
0.5368649364,
-0.8152251244,
-0.0898481682,
0.0321894512,
0.0843676627,
-0.7710617185,
0.0770712495,
0.1811435968,
-0.3796986043,
0.3646514416,
-0.2619006634,
-0.3542298973,
-0.0798476413,
-0.0201034527,
0.4437630475,
0.1241631806,
-0.5665572882,
0.8851847053,
0.5129441023,
-0.0546053089,
-0.5165271759,
-0.4179627895,
-0.0418452732,
-0.2321407795,
-0.0278821904,
0.5473831296,
-0.0172108952,
-0.1347189993,
-0.0962996259,
-0.2073178887,
0.1242063418,
0.1720838696,
0.5157020092,
0.0210316982,
0.0060656103,
0.2091178596,
-0.0529245213,
-0.1209636554,
0.2705619931,
-0.3336704969,
0.5991141796,
0.1209314242,
-0.6318465471,
-0.3375956118,
0.2925322056,
0.3330370188,
-0.3936567307,
0.974786222,
0.6241591573,
-0.3085241616,
-0.2833916545,
-0.6945967674,
-0.2220145166,
-0.4555673301,
0.4001030326,
-0.1990529895,
-0.8133338094,
0.4088530838,
0.0776862577,
0.0360281616,
0.348711133,
0.6404728889,
-0.1331524104,
0.9406253695,
1.0778491497,
-0.3746814132,
0.8919719458,
0.0974921212,
0.0125909951,
-0.5143262744,
0.0191338845,
-0.262837261,
-0.2037479281,
-0.5381464362,
-0.3819154203,
0.1025966108,
0.2440235615,
0.134100154,
0.2290778309,
-0.3220239878,
0.2797552347,
0.7729875445,
0.0162020512,
-0.0326141939,
-0.0595751926,
0.0750987083,
-0.2046572864,
-0.6826317906,
-0.1965719759,
1.3971740007,
0.2339615226,
0.7764248848,
-0.0723409429,
0.9944031835,
0.3572668731,
0.5092025399,
-0.4938994646,
0.4479697943,
-0.0717154667,
-0.5076490641,
-0.3406246305,
-0.430013299,
-1.2219555378,
0.1710803658,
-0.4256181717,
-0.4647775888,
0.2400639951,
0.318873316,
-0.603384912,
-0.0552650653,
-0.6291095018,
0.960185945,
-0.5621083975,
-0.4854637682,
-0.3911588192,
-0.4363706112,
0.0430833623,
-0.1710322648,
0.1793545634,
0.0703548864,
0.0682403967,
0.9884079695,
-0.5242489576,
1.1801943779,
-0.5375999212,
-0.4704723656,
0.3680480719,
0.1212621555,
0.4018601179,
0.0646964908,
0.0394289531,
0.1539684832,
0.1350796223,
-0.4270423353,
-0.6921269894,
0.7932998538,
-0.6445257664,
-0.6913546324,
-0.3253452182,
-0.0200149547,
-0.2511518598,
0.5244793296,
0.0589229353,
0.473677814,
-0.2179507166,
0.6416336298,
0.7265321016,
-0.2750127316,
0.1848256588,
0.6666406989,
-0.6439183354,
-0.1872576773,
0.8292654157,
0.3121619225,
0.5264629722,
0.3509916365,
0.128059864,
-0.19396393,
-0.4952817559,
-0.2441238314,
0.1076159999,
-0.347217679,
0.1273263395,
-0.7508144379,
-0.0675182492,
-0.5674132705,
0.0645118207,
-0.8025271297,
0.0318664946,
-0.1588536203,
-0.0151295289,
0.0315414146,
0.5255723,
-0.0954639316,
0.6717309952,
-0.4805345535,
0.3014312685,
0.3953589201,
0.652705431,
-0.1082336307,
-0.4908291101,
-0.6491792202,
-0.0960761607,
0.1061657891,
-0.6956858635,
0.3961333036,
0.2474109232,
1.0279016495,
0.5520343184,
-0.0290595703,
0.3933107853,
-0.3095337749,
0.6035019755,
-0.1634740531,
-0.8373100758,
0.6606891155,
-0.2606841922,
0.3165192306,
0.9155710936,
0.5198004246,
-0.257571131,
-0.2538437843,
-0.8012636304,
-0.64492172,
0.5436689258,
0.2892900705,
0.3378583491,
0.0216340236,
0.4873717427,
-0.2206314355,
0.4728852808,
-1.0794906616,
-0.3422889411,
-0.3910467029,
-0.0395259857,
-0.1114133224,
-0.2924851179,
0.164688006,
-0.2764374614,
0.523088932,
-0.151442185,
0.049646616,
0.1809167862,
-0.2470684499,
0.1041602418,
-0.0302407667,
0.4003308713,
0.458319068,
-0.3593438864,
0.2096944302,
0.4384935796,
-0.5990542173,
-0.0597722903,
-0.144215107,
-0.0783921257,
-0.0572545007,
0.5587126613,
0.5438747406,
0.7381759286,
-0.374129504,
0.577691257,
0.0592369661,
-0.0524191484,
-0.5046104193,
0.2000167072,
-0.0419078991,
-0.0945443138,
0.2182103395,
-0.2467797995,
-0.2677699327,
-0.5394425392,
0.4453847408,
0.5672954321,
-0.5324490666,
-0.4645289183,
0.6795379519,
0.091705963,
-0.1152103171,
0.3654136062,
-0.3439009488,
-0.5945976973,
0.3266098499,
0.3067672253,
0.6854515076,
-0.6134883165,
0.0020087366,
0.4434137046,
0.2790064216,
-0.3059586287,
-0.0804371685,
-0.179431811,
-1.0436122417,
-0.582144022,
-0.9164635539,
-0.2844169438,
0.3413369954,
-0.8767405748,
0.5456863046,
-0.5351232886,
-0.1279219985,
-0.2057592869,
0.169493854,
-0.6922568083,
0.5126392841,
0.1809599996,
0.3403688967,
-0.9031787515,
1.1812691689,
0.5057544112,
-0.3054855168,
-0.6320699453,
0.1713722199,
-0.1379404068,
-0.7266100049,
0.7707669735,
0.2483556271,
-0.3490362167,
0.239096418,
-0.6765034795,
-1.4798686504,
0.801738441,
0.0552711897,
-0.3754477799,
0.2114768922,
-0.078492865,
0.6967803836,
-0.6170055866,
0.1172479019,
0.2282782644,
0.2222468108,
-0.2386237532,
-0.7172597647,
-0.1549903005,
-0.273658067,
-0.3334285319,
0.098717846,
-0.591473639,
0.7160410285,
0.1352734268,
-0.1586208791,
-0.3820605576,
1.1225444078,
0.2457271516,
0.0970471129,
0.9452877045,
0.5513654947,
0.583573103,
0.3829251528,
0.7750439048,
-0.4867238104,
0.2133764029,
1.6379669905,
-0.4316268861,
0.8495674729,
0.4011058807,
-0.3691919744,
0.5057395101,
0.4576247931,
-0.3069894016,
0.3184386194,
0.2757354081,
-0.0271588471,
-0.6163896918,
-0.0338178463,
-0.4929193854,
0.6161629558,
0.3707635701,
-0.4468421042,
-0.2049413174,
0.2062424421,
0.12286219,
0.0227550585,
-0.2228899747,
0.3698299527,
0.0286877956,
-0.6386423111,
0.2202804685,
-0.0932006538,
0.8425284624,
-0.7977615595,
0.1486846954,
-0.3096104562,
-0.0128027564,
-0.156232819,
-0.4182705879,
0.3006108403,
-0.1854916513,
-0.4617313445,
-0.6125512123,
0.6311932206,
-0.4234756529,
-0.7467262149,
0.5921400189,
0.7982936502,
0.2468642592,
-0.3638082445,
-0.4470811188,
-0.1190810353,
0.138163954,
-0.639572978,
0.8290313482,
0.3433918059,
-0.0834008157,
0.7858447433,
0.6703882813,
0.2448977828,
0.0551158153,
0.4776510894,
0.78657794,
-0.5734036565,
-0.4473277032,
-0.759170711,
0.0996223241,
0.0193252992,
-0.2700221539,
1.157353878,
0.5942991972,
0.8309761286,
0.2176395357,
0.5078175664,
-0.0482531451,
0.6724354625,
-0.3816184402,
0.8738203049,
-0.8506460786,
0.343996942,
-0.4882880747,
-0.9782218337,
-0.2877045572,
0.6372860074,
-0.5197433233,
0.3345460594,
0.2496129572,
0.9295985699,
-0.0720589459,
-0.352521807,
0.3888435066,
0.0782651976,
0.1856118739,
-0.0484723039,
0.5443341136,
-0.2589806914,
0.2086514384,
-0.2301991284,
-0.1909991801,
-0.195193544,
-1.1010781527,
-0.9983972907,
-0.571325779,
-0.4375445545,
-0.2988622487,
-0.4122622013,
1.21078372,
1.094311595,
-0.9307793379,
-0.0360568315,
0.0561791845,
-0.0346932895,
-0.1392661184,
-0.1964351088,
0.4968441725,
-0.4725444019,
-0.7371627092,
0.6560902596,
-0.0636840314,
0.1701072007,
-0.8142476678,
0.0312662907,
-0.2924246788,
-0.1827173233,
0.6535693407,
0.2943456769,
-0.4557778239,
-0.2764808238,
-0.0813256651,
0.0434628502,
-0.1369117498,
0.8275788426,
-1.1896988153,
0.4357753694,
0.1772842407,
0.5529833436,
0.3556001782,
0.3722325265,
0.8178192377,
-1.0663927794,
0.1766668558,
-0.1514426917,
0.34183231,
0.2190783024,
-0.4330103099,
0.3819475174,
0.1926701665,
-0.588457346,
-0.9394024611,
-0.0688920841,
-0.8199737668,
-0.1830901355,
0.9701623917,
-0.0953373984,
-0.1022944823,
-0.0693181679,
0.0658830702,
0.1136835366,
-0.0976750255,
0.7824423909,
0.6913607121,
-0.0496436879,
-0.304528892,
-0.7714506984,
0.6419995427,
0.9549501538,
-0.8266499639,
0.0898678526,
0.2902905345,
0.284923166,
0.3095138669,
0.6756732464,
0.196944505,
-0.3924899101,
-0.0248478781,
0.3407495916,
0.0923525244,
-0.5777475834,
-0.2230828553,
0.128022939,
-0.0052986545,
-0.1611893177
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00906v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00906v1
|
Re-weighting Tokens: A Simple and Effective Active Learning Strategy for Named Entity Recognition
| 2023-11-02T00:19:02 | 2023-11-02T00:19:02 |
Haocheng Luo, Wei Tan, Ngoc Dang Nguyen, Lan Du
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Active learning, a widely adopted technique for enhancing machine learning
models in text and image classification tasks with limited annotation
resources, has received relatively little attention in the domain of Named
Entity Recognition (NER). The challenge of data imbalance in NER has hindered
the effectiveness of active learning, as sequence labellers lack sufficient
learning signals. To address these challenges, this paper presents a novel
reweighting-based active learning strategy that assigns dynamic smoothed
weights to individual tokens. This adaptable strategy is compatible with
various token-level acquisition functions and contributes to the development of
robust active learners. Experimental results on multiple corpora demonstrate
the substantial performance improvement achieved by incorporating our
re-weighting strategy into existing acquisition functions, validating its
practical efficacy.
|
[
0.1235976219,
-0.7537503839,
0.0556996353,
0.0466292016,
-0.5673879385,
0.5345115066,
-0.2591220438,
-0.284835428,
0.6563624144,
0.0620785095,
-0.0490307026,
-0.2947874367,
-0.7511731386,
0.2336656004,
-0.5040585995,
0.9490543604,
-0.5472720861,
0.1063283533,
0.2430171072,
-0.4531602561,
-0.640635252,
-0.2815042436,
-1.2399218082,
-0.0799516588,
1.0922944546,
0.4746353626,
0.5076515079,
0.6638926268,
0.4869865179,
0.3085699677,
-0.0452146642,
0.2500430644,
-0.2803764045,
0.422909528,
0.0951742157,
-0.6913079619,
-0.5480878949,
-0.0253033713,
1.0420604944,
0.719825387,
-0.296133846,
-0.0023691633,
-0.3052898645,
0.1666630656,
-0.7987970114,
0.0431493223,
-0.9030798078,
0.3588325679,
-0.2870806456,
-0.1327334046,
-0.4043463469,
0.1655728966,
-0.019886231,
-0.9357074499,
0.1846701652,
0.2101527601,
1.1013572216,
0.3423990309,
-0.4736506045,
-0.1878202558,
-0.3439923227,
0.8167101145,
-0.4612146914,
0.5928408504,
0.0239894558,
0.1270128489,
-0.0392530113,
-1.1650513411,
-0.3992491961,
0.3036299944,
0.2680438757,
-0.069169119,
-0.2495992631,
-0.2291191071,
0.1487512887,
0.2519985735,
0.2828359902,
0.1430689692,
-0.3541708589,
-0.264208585,
0.2467905134,
-0.2700696588,
0.3309116662,
0.1298009306,
-0.6824709177,
0.1178976968,
-0.4080322087,
0.0696662664,
0.3342427015,
0.8709862232,
0.1890771985,
0.4743861258,
0.1654872745,
0.5157181621,
0.5248781443,
-0.1313921958,
0.7480018735,
0.0724896863,
-0.2694306076,
0.5665925145,
0.2193743289,
-0.0850611255,
-0.0532584041,
-0.5301445127,
-0.6626972556,
-0.4723236561,
0.6684381366,
-0.6265726089,
-0.2207280695,
-0.0126430485,
-0.4174429476,
-0.6142938137,
0.2539820969,
-0.6385681033,
-0.1895381063,
-0.2597208619,
0.8441089392,
-0.1910636127,
-0.3423865139,
-0.071145691,
-0.2197777778,
0.1625216752,
0.5678704977,
-0.8219582438,
0.4589999318,
0.4828116894,
0.9517289996,
-0.7483095527,
-0.0014299182,
-0.9482363462,
0.161564827,
-0.1577508748,
0.6655244827,
-0.5517649651,
-0.1770518273,
-0.1265285611,
0.4791375995,
-0.0989414006,
-0.4427872002,
0.6655222774,
-0.6842373013,
0.0209008288,
-0.0491509214,
-0.3637000024,
-0.081053257,
0.280118227,
-0.735924542,
0.9922303557,
-0.0083939778,
-0.7737368941,
1.0227558613,
-0.1959149837,
-0.7088695168,
0.2953317463,
-0.1372668892,
-0.9008821249,
0.2124186158,
0.0115928622,
0.4541238248,
0.4390345812,
0.1307497323,
-0.2095296979,
-0.5751695633,
0.1459756494,
-0.4529248178,
0.3044165373,
0.1967591643,
-0.622698307,
0.120181635,
-0.8786141872,
-0.0095345313,
0.1011925861,
-0.9982557297,
-0.4577446878,
-0.0163301304,
-0.0053929854,
-0.2822753191,
0.1409630179,
-0.6025018692,
0.4974733293,
-0.197906673,
0.4268374741,
0.6372225285,
-0.03010609,
0.5682163239,
0.1559118778,
0.3761522174,
0.2697043419,
-0.3238530159,
-0.0254294816,
-0.3190966845,
-0.9580779076,
-0.8267755508,
1.0641418695,
0.5430045128,
-0.8800404668,
0.3415294886,
-0.3122662306,
-0.2661744058,
-0.4645495713,
0.130955115,
0.1733458787,
0.4354360402,
0.6223908067,
-0.5858417153,
-0.4533694386,
-0.6927096248,
-0.3260061145,
-0.1029444262,
0.1183888614,
0.2897470891,
0.2777986526,
-0.1888275594,
0.5675538778,
-0.3365784585,
-0.2028924525,
-0.162948072,
0.3729769588,
-0.2445325404,
0.5072470903,
0.3413411081,
-1.0692886114,
-0.1011459678,
-0.3431816995,
-0.4164911211,
-0.0873837173,
-0.307500273,
-0.2413081676,
0.0280246399,
0.5428643227,
-0.3746502995,
0.399836868,
0.0366070867,
-0.3524824083,
0.0128226224,
-0.1246490031,
-0.0957547575,
-0.753647089,
0.0261986554,
-0.1652148515,
-0.5117464066,
-0.3550086021,
-0.0563135594,
0.2980288267,
-0.1343870312,
-0.5557748675,
0.8626635075,
-0.816450417,
0.0743015707,
-0.3299138844,
0.2384368926,
-0.2754163444,
0.4163967371,
-0.0082353298,
0.389270395,
0.700997889,
-0.611330092,
0.4019759297,
0.0313057862,
-0.0937041044,
0.6174921393,
-0.448007375,
-0.1866737902,
-0.2590211332,
0.241399765,
-0.8259119391,
0.0805843249,
0.4110344648,
-0.3612482846,
0.9689630866,
-0.3073868752,
-0.0095262537,
-0.2817634046,
-0.0834591985,
0.6201885343,
0.2242029309,
-0.5798390508,
0.9181751013,
0.531416595,
-0.0091861347,
-0.8277311921,
-0.7598993778,
0.3851820529,
-0.4463707209,
0.2008748204,
0.7114261985,
0.5569817424,
0.0019445814,
0.1614753753,
-0.6277244091,
0.0081924377,
0.3911889493,
0.1744048148,
-0.0800146386,
0.0331231467,
0.4408396482,
0.0156602915,
-0.2799703777,
-0.3230923414,
-0.5216414928,
0.1277532578,
0.2694387138,
-0.2928524315,
-0.3584000468,
-0.0894912705,
0.4663036764,
-0.286103934,
0.7607604861,
0.9587614536,
-0.71115309,
-0.3528631926,
-0.249768883,
-0.0901808068,
-0.393320471,
0.3946366012,
-0.3687265515,
-0.5709245205,
0.3804590106,
-0.2896783054,
0.5241664648,
0.401701957,
0.486106962,
0.304068327,
0.802677691,
0.6130260825,
0.1534938514,
0.8353961706,
-0.0866974592,
0.4796898365,
-0.6921649575,
-0.5156710148,
-0.3216054142,
-0.9174504876,
-0.199447006,
-0.5278888345,
-0.3588604331,
0.0953626186,
-0.2124859095,
0.2794152796,
-0.4905848801,
-0.022205079,
0.4697083831,
0.2570700049,
0.0456640683,
0.3273819387,
-0.3784542084,
0.0099622868,
-0.5406253934,
-0.4405713081,
0.9984070659,
0.4314189255,
0.6650548577,
0.2639214396,
0.7640936375,
0.5637005568,
0.5234512687,
-1.1030968428,
0.5264525414,
-0.1762758344,
-0.3704505265,
-0.2872577906,
-0.7030111551,
-1.262152195,
0.1813089252,
-0.513707459,
-0.2170273513,
0.4421079755,
-0.0114468886,
-0.285666436,
0.7357488275,
-0.5859625936,
0.6274108887,
-0.6171747446,
-0.4011458158,
0.0455062911,
-0.3675210178,
-0.2013433427,
-0.4733557999,
0.0007712924,
-0.0588114113,
-0.8583086729,
1.1804373264,
-0.1879370511,
0.7589082718,
-0.7012314796,
-0.0258756895,
0.2676981688,
-0.2338216007,
0.4673183262,
0.2518515289,
-0.1282702237,
-0.0734933913,
-0.4256595671,
-0.6531459093,
-0.5731657743,
0.7127105594,
-0.6749465466,
-0.348203063,
-0.4581575096,
-0.090016745,
-0.0362387337,
0.6631945968,
-0.3485092223,
0.486941576,
-0.1179552004,
0.333881706,
0.7053983808,
-0.1778047085,
0.3802740276,
0.5939592719,
0.1393397301,
-0.7303240299,
0.9743982553,
0.3275486827,
-0.075397931,
0.5203331113,
-0.2220811248,
0.0421054326,
-0.7495958209,
-0.6063469052,
0.1373071223,
-0.4197957218,
-0.6171656251,
-0.9041140079,
0.0791233107,
-0.1381199658,
-0.110743843,
-0.329821378,
-0.7924889922,
-0.3105641305,
-0.4324650466,
0.1876547188,
0.2178792357,
0.3271553516,
0.3265378773,
-0.2357700318,
0.3063377738,
0.3357661963,
0.4772032499,
0.1517494768,
-0.5758268833,
-0.2899497449,
0.0248405151,
-0.2652783096,
-0.8073327541,
0.2472194433,
0.4684816301,
1.0078599453,
0.550629735,
0.1177971885,
0.817886591,
-0.5163798928,
0.4939926565,
0.1622463912,
-0.6871512532,
0.1651377827,
0.1247046292,
0.0401207022,
0.7091203928,
0.3341355622,
-0.3066286147,
-0.1888389587,
-0.8779318333,
-1.4316722155,
0.424814105,
0.1035335883,
0.3759039938,
-0.2148541957,
0.8314204812,
-0.0175311957,
0.4059004188,
-0.8383203745,
-0.2157563567,
-0.2577518821,
-0.5370034575,
0.3687906265,
0.0095504047,
0.1122400239,
-0.1748301089,
0.8968811631,
-0.2495337129,
0.411395371,
0.1773391366,
-0.194399938,
-0.1800863296,
0.0096360473,
0.0393266343,
0.1028340384,
-0.0889451802,
0.474031657,
0.5771535039,
-0.7179169655,
0.1880625784,
0.1749328226,
-0.2692463398,
-0.0405822471,
0.2678556442,
0.8992735147,
0.9553999901,
-0.5525960922,
0.5325060487,
-0.3005106151,
-0.1218665168,
-0.1786762774,
0.0779320672,
-0.3788993657,
0.0222425386,
0.7319566011,
0.1859208643,
-0.2690724134,
-0.6161442399,
0.6464332938,
0.4932467043,
-0.7998186946,
-0.1846031249,
0.6554495096,
0.4169749022,
-0.4187462032,
0.7502430081,
-0.3690896928,
-0.5527664423,
0.4987206161,
0.6486109495,
0.7065331936,
-0.0848931298,
-0.1467144042,
0.4326719642,
-0.0112035936,
-0.4756133556,
0.2484168112,
-0.0547588803,
-0.7803581357,
-0.0418855548,
-0.758480072,
-0.2272911966,
-0.4589284956,
-0.5899383426,
0.8710618019,
-0.5331722498,
-0.5914756656,
0.1252620071,
0.4175668359,
-0.3894506991,
0.2195305526,
0.3412352204,
0.9707520008,
-0.5968825817,
0.5400730371,
1.1660555601,
-0.4940548241,
-0.6783483028,
0.0097038187,
-0.1646627486,
-0.6999493837,
0.6419272423,
0.27683869,
0.1463173777,
0.2754165232,
-0.3949583173,
-1.1382350922,
1.2102125883,
-0.1177377254,
-0.2172878683,
-0.3238360286,
-0.6385360956,
0.343441844,
-0.4411667287,
0.075487636,
-0.1605086327,
0.6275440454,
0.2361668646,
-0.5482164621,
0.1781584173,
-0.3764326274,
-0.5051502585,
0.6514822841,
-0.7421550751,
0.6958221793,
-0.2695518434,
-0.459148407,
-0.0737035349,
1.114428401,
0.0756036267,
0.492634356,
0.9528563619,
0.7382438183,
1.1048315763,
-0.1762191206,
0.3056201041,
-0.245891571,
0.0523754172,
0.5084549785,
-0.2263530493,
0.9664008617,
0.4430064857,
0.0246471241,
0.6636810899,
0.585020721,
-0.5338844657,
0.4472103417,
0.5608875155,
-0.2459994406,
-0.3205192387,
0.0379929133,
0.1916559786,
0.4225491285,
0.2959346473,
-0.3188464046,
0.0395256542,
0.2247903049,
0.3868311644,
-0.3133140802,
-0.6431384683,
0.5997347236,
0.0239932518,
-0.4980181456,
0.2269115448,
0.3340988457,
1.0740388632,
-0.5425096154,
-0.0134580825,
0.100591667,
0.3199112713,
-0.3957952559,
-0.3306221664,
0.045929987,
0.1118424684,
-0.0621617436,
-0.3632130027,
0.6840593219,
-0.4967963099,
-0.8433558345,
0.0879926383,
0.4457012415,
0.1378705055,
0.4245248735,
-0.7997636795,
-0.2896037102,
-0.0803091228,
-0.2590630651,
0.3800057173,
0.7407689691,
-0.3526324034,
0.7068043947,
0.5576562881,
0.3147526979,
0.1354073435,
0.0735267401,
0.6771817803,
-0.5352336168,
-0.3259675801,
-0.3808391392,
0.3443534672,
-0.0559752919,
-0.1854253411,
0.8357509971,
0.6646701694,
0.5223358274,
0.4549891353,
0.3087075353,
-0.2610286772,
0.3582957089,
-0.194024235,
0.4909145832,
-0.8805494308,
0.2147684693,
-0.2239762694,
-0.8006222844,
-0.6491442919,
0.6613001227,
-0.0085096378,
0.0923673213,
0.3584396541,
0.3309394121,
-0.1938602775,
-0.3941182792,
-0.0636788756,
0.1417725384,
0.1896627396,
0.1396781057,
0.2799114883,
-0.6437369585,
0.5729594827,
0.1032390147,
-0.2492231131,
-0.1051459759,
-0.9017366171,
-0.6003426313,
-0.3713433743,
-0.6322072148,
-0.0680706874,
0.320769161,
0.9598337412,
0.6137549877,
-0.7353095412,
0.4577253163,
0.1710937917,
0.2232409567,
-0.4212573767,
-0.1869049668,
0.5064115524,
-0.5773934722,
-0.806838572,
0.2336095124,
-0.0938566998,
0.0711715817,
0.0984329432,
0.1693261564,
-0.3987728059,
-0.0088915089,
0.3815416396,
0.4044557214,
-0.5144059658,
-0.1638413966,
0.0026199056,
0.0119275926,
-0.1360864192,
0.9008024335,
-1.2601475716,
0.2100055665,
0.3486251533,
0.8236371279,
0.1983419955,
0.3425086737,
0.4631223083,
-0.8423574567,
0.1993304193,
0.110730812,
0.5339056253,
0.4662728012,
-0.283973366,
0.3823857009,
0.5009917617,
-0.3100011051,
-1.085575223,
-0.2866511643,
-1.060195446,
-0.2416253388,
1.0137001276,
-0.2664508224,
-0.1473852694,
-0.2183097154,
-0.1862565577,
0.6872500777,
-0.63913095,
0.7764816284,
0.2427727729,
0.27463153,
-0.0382177867,
-0.3083893657,
0.2966111302,
0.4662624598,
-0.2798748314,
0.0470725782,
0.1806647927,
0.2862130404,
0.1196773648,
0.2526678145,
-0.1423583627,
-0.1723013669,
-0.2106426209,
0.0284789614,
-0.2488719523,
-0.4853467345,
-0.2447802126,
0.3021326661,
0.1164875478,
-0.2634908557
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00897v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00897v1
|
On The Open Prompt Challenge In Conditional Audio Generation
| 2023-11-01T23:33:25 | 2023-11-01T23:33:25 |
Ernie Chang, Sidd Srinivasan, Mahi Luthra, Pin-Jie Lin, Varun Nagaraja, Forrest Iandola, Zechun Liu, Zhaoheng Ni, Changsheng Zhao, Yangyang Shi, Vikas Chandra
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Text-to-audio generation (TTA) produces audio from a text description,
learning from pairs of audio samples and hand-annotated text. However,
commercializing audio generation is challenging as user-input prompts are often
under-specified when compared to text descriptions used to train TTA models. In
this work, we treat TTA models as a ``blackbox'' and address the user prompt
challenge with two key insights: (1) User prompts are generally
under-specified, leading to a large alignment gap between user prompts and
training prompts. (2) There is a distribution of audio descriptions for which
TTA models are better at generating higher quality audio, which we refer to as
``audionese''. To this end, we rewrite prompts with instruction-tuned models
and propose utilizing text-audio alignment as feedback signals via margin
ranking learning for audio improvements. On both objective and subjective human
evaluations, we observed marked improvements in both text-audio alignment and
music audio quality.
|
[
-0.4845361114,
-0.3724664152,
0.8552319407,
-0.1525909752,
-0.1729476899,
-0.1992929578,
-0.3999021351,
-0.2376232594,
0.0413943566,
0.4122422636,
-1.0651416779,
-0.6817788482,
-0.2758866847,
0.3985357583,
-0.1254946738,
0.9204595685,
0.0946434215,
-0.0786942318,
-0.0195505358,
-0.1495720744,
-1.3853914738,
-0.2436798662,
-0.8724630475,
0.0324861705,
0.538366437,
0.5657061934,
0.6905228496,
0.5100660324,
0.0508898832,
0.3162051737,
-0.0873027518,
0.0683672354,
-0.1905332357,
0.3731894493,
-0.0359975062,
-0.6194230318,
-0.357627511,
0.2409203649,
0.472204864,
0.5999811292,
-0.089340277,
0.2789906561,
-0.0346703567,
0.3855298162,
-0.4609238803,
-0.2912168801,
-0.5456446409,
0.1769658923,
-0.0582231171,
-0.4621112943,
-0.5838391185,
-0.3509263396,
0.1727615893,
-0.9837251902,
0.2677471638,
0.0519779548,
0.9213345647,
0.6258870959,
-0.2923698425,
-0.4944403172,
-0.7980465889,
0.6418554783,
-0.6532517672,
0.3694912195,
0.2891932428,
0.6533526778,
-0.1653608531,
-0.5029832721,
-0.5244290233,
0.0770704821,
0.1915401518,
0.2313807607,
-0.3934716284,
-0.0112980735,
0.28474015,
0.1716734916,
-0.1828401089,
0.3076244593,
-0.4900186658,
-0.252304703,
0.4441355169,
0.0667631999,
0.5939398408,
-0.3826757371,
-0.2641028762,
-0.3070448041,
-0.7713655233,
0.4663509727,
0.9509328604,
0.5719334483,
-0.1458298415,
0.7300853133,
0.0116081219,
0.5073692203,
0.3586063683,
-0.1598335057,
0.3227811754,
-0.4636980593,
0.1061379015,
0.6653879285,
0.7912313938,
0.5070728064,
0.1140541509,
-0.0775411427,
-0.4931256473,
0.1172558367,
0.3768055439,
-0.6091627479,
-0.0500698686,
0.3359656632,
-0.3342675567,
-0.1724021435,
0.0830536559,
-0.7911636829,
-0.1066394597,
-0.5479397178,
0.6688821316,
-0.234960556,
-0.1301153898,
0.095579274,
-0.3480443358,
-0.1112159044,
0.3701260686,
-0.9152178764,
0.0112927826,
0.5209729075,
0.8162590265,
-0.0605837852,
0.1975417286,
-0.8863448501,
-0.0180782974,
-0.4073651433,
0.6980845928,
-0.3445514739,
-0.6723718643,
0.0553318746,
-0.2073887587,
0.328083396,
-0.5505090356,
0.6524067521,
-0.0926372856,
0.903285265,
-0.4202935398,
-0.4157226086,
0.0707525164,
-0.4193820655,
-0.6006418467,
0.7912370563,
0.0902385116,
-0.6691687107,
0.7933902144,
-0.6273881197,
-0.1658173651,
-0.1759920269,
-0.2581019104,
-0.462148875,
0.3373388052,
0.3219100535,
0.085357517,
-0.2357053906,
0.509606719,
-0.1611807048,
-0.3668525815,
0.478278935,
-0.4847492874,
0.5872765183,
0.288210988,
-0.601188302,
0.2788156271,
-0.9011798501,
-0.2061302811,
-0.1161566451,
-0.3032927811,
-0.2978403866,
-0.1411280334,
0.0731614977,
0.1140007228,
-0.0969652161,
-0.8557487726,
0.1001933962,
-0.4727987349,
0.433585912,
1.0214699507,
-0.0251623672,
0.3194084167,
-0.3271874189,
0.5719662309,
-0.0159882326,
-0.0825242028,
-0.539647758,
-0.5701330304,
-0.2955567539,
-0.1877845228,
0.6102116108,
0.5848577619,
-0.4936791956,
0.5525388122,
-0.0059425114,
-0.1295661628,
-1.0939553976,
-0.0131806983,
0.3163977861,
0.6939738393,
0.4334100485,
-0.2010659873,
-0.5652762055,
-0.796746254,
-0.0644601136,
-0.0554097705,
-0.3374854028,
0.4938398898,
-0.1210930496,
-0.0049395822,
1.1863386631,
-0.372543335,
-0.321598202,
0.0339983888,
0.21402888,
0.4107630253,
0.5689746737,
0.4310564101,
-0.5865354538,
-0.2491907179,
-0.1335668713,
-0.4822820425,
-0.6810323596,
-0.115018934,
-0.137619555,
-0.0168053545,
0.5663970113,
-0.7405000329,
0.3504841924,
0.4049539268,
-0.4824666381,
0.5550979376,
0.0284527093,
0.3502114713,
-1.2486248016,
-0.0584645793,
0.0931139141,
-0.1414290518,
-0.3888861537,
-0.5595962405,
-0.2829572558,
-0.6167237759,
-0.4179233611,
0.4332719147,
-0.3481226861,
-0.2988993526,
-0.4373041093,
0.4024747908,
-0.1288438439,
0.4528984427,
-0.0381785035,
1.2202159166,
0.4109261334,
-0.4827540219,
0.042417217,
0.3063926697,
-0.2705872655,
0.7360963225,
-0.8547367454,
0.1522030532,
0.0410975441,
0.2895223498,
-1.2599645853,
-0.2464158535,
0.0664308891,
-0.67390728,
0.4251421094,
0.0035637633,
-0.4548555613,
-0.1117350757,
0.0626658797,
0.7498687506,
0.8999993801,
-0.8014335036,
0.3782573342,
0.1926180422,
-0.3447627127,
-0.3872253299,
-0.2565456331,
-0.0831155255,
-0.4492824078,
-0.6483488083,
0.3472796679,
-0.0664000437,
-0.1685191095,
0.0968849286,
-0.3122525215,
0.3829274178,
0.2251010537,
0.2711668313,
0.2349755317,
-0.5124608874,
0.3143457174,
0.4222501814,
-0.4220493436,
0.1413412988,
-0.6485272646,
0.0758679137,
0.4472109675,
-0.1312754303,
-0.9193357825,
0.3783665001,
0.0707288161,
-0.1823810786,
0.118933104,
0.3984505534,
-0.0881671757,
-0.3461932838,
-0.2104368657,
-0.3546097279,
-0.5524974465,
-0.0621768385,
-0.309374094,
-0.7994232178,
0.175719589,
-0.064665623,
0.3517356217,
0.5150976181,
0.415125519,
-0.292917341,
1.3804883957,
0.6765366793,
0.4951837063,
0.4429573119,
0.0338023007,
0.0132049611,
-0.4947938621,
-0.1403542757,
-0.9281433225,
-0.4031853974,
-0.5745310187,
0.0856677592,
0.447732687,
-0.1019415781,
-0.1791528463,
0.4237972498,
-0.7042262554,
0.3079752028,
0.8296109438,
0.1019253805,
0.161940366,
0.0231504478,
-0.2801298797,
-0.0299961735,
-0.6292856336,
-0.5750023723,
1.128847599,
0.4312334359,
0.5191215873,
0.3478836119,
1.0170658827,
0.3952232301,
-0.046582602,
-0.7091690302,
0.2754704654,
-0.0484190695,
-0.5143426657,
-0.5673530698,
-0.5107598901,
-0.9676504135,
-0.0201570503,
-0.2475416064,
-0.8260319829,
0.1836466938,
0.2963986397,
-0.6047254801,
0.1523921043,
-0.8321108818,
0.8741605878,
-0.1139084548,
-0.190573439,
0.1831730753,
-0.5173023939,
0.0900966302,
0.0749309286,
0.2486645579,
-0.2601892948,
-0.0415159129,
0.7447407842,
-0.5757232904,
0.8047047853,
-0.4843211174,
-0.3967749774,
0.2884369791,
-0.1318452954,
0.1199959442,
0.1431389153,
0.2455933243,
-0.1850600839,
-0.2373357564,
-0.249308154,
-0.7381324172,
0.4185871184,
-1.0419932604,
-0.860892415,
0.0048804758,
-0.4909136593,
-0.56645298,
0.2098585516,
0.761943996,
0.8017424941,
0.0744753629,
0.0683066398,
0.85966748,
-0.5904436707,
0.3311725557,
0.0372849032,
-0.0183297284,
-0.7551355958,
0.8314498663,
-0.1307581663,
0.2338518351,
0.341829896,
0.2543811202,
-0.6350993514,
-0.5153589249,
-0.8234178424,
0.2664179802,
-0.6569334269,
-0.1561967134,
-0.4143672585,
0.3591798842,
-0.3140693605,
-0.0632352456,
-0.2688133717,
-0.6469023228,
-0.6036952734,
-0.3651384115,
0.2617279887,
0.6005986333,
-0.0285271984,
0.4996080697,
-0.6338277459,
0.4956423044,
0.316419363,
0.3802170753,
-0.1295415312,
-0.5421780944,
-0.1472936571,
-0.0050523276,
-0.4489287436,
-1.0271311998,
-0.0925053656,
-0.1179768965,
0.4980449975,
0.1288462877,
0.1158821285,
0.3031650186,
-0.7473635674,
0.8816311359,
0.6735361218,
-0.991353333,
0.8005570173,
-0.3932743967,
0.3606524467,
0.6374610662,
0.163089335,
-0.2612029314,
-0.6433981061,
-0.7163830996,
-0.8227423429,
0.7304159403,
0.4510490298,
0.1891261637,
0.1806272566,
0.1501253992,
0.5233126283,
0.1871617883,
-0.6349197626,
-0.1771950275,
-0.7126321793,
-0.5098636746,
-0.3700802922,
-0.1680693775,
-0.1820560992,
0.174386844,
0.6655869484,
0.0809953585,
0.1298415214,
0.3589785099,
0.1770406216,
-0.3981367052,
0.6909829974,
0.6716772318,
0.3191661537,
-0.0894735754,
-0.1553940922,
-0.3180842698,
-0.0003339312,
0.6654450893,
-0.1570549905,
-0.351270318,
0.3319114745,
0.2403127104,
1.3736565113,
0.3214293718,
-0.5796741247,
0.5225932598,
-0.2242228389,
-0.3818153441,
-0.2579180598,
0.3213118911,
-0.0957434922,
0.0333404876,
0.4107402563,
0.069636859,
0.2400908768,
-0.4338101149,
0.3545659781,
0.150445804,
-0.6614486575,
-0.2615405917,
1.1452022791,
0.4068157673,
-0.5970288515,
0.566083312,
0.0427661128,
0.0463601202,
0.5014280677,
0.5274716616,
1.2370555401,
-0.0555801727,
0.1702998728,
0.4533554912,
0.1927581728,
0.270072341,
0.2527191937,
-0.3749921322,
-0.3013615012,
-0.3876791596,
-0.4549255371,
-0.4984556139,
-0.0798665211,
-0.8037776351,
0.5160393715,
-0.3430351317,
-0.6624159217,
0.1842606217,
-0.4261394441,
-0.462934047,
0.1201596409,
-0.0033734951,
0.9542251825,
-0.8537959456,
0.2892446816,
0.4720813334,
-0.5277106762,
-1.1835310459,
0.1743828505,
-0.0058417274,
-0.1018114761,
0.549526155,
0.4863520563,
-0.0124994731,
-0.0546296611,
-0.4717254341,
-0.446898073,
0.8927963972,
0.4379844069,
-0.6594232917,
-0.08607696,
-0.2098341882,
0.4702815711,
-0.3674771488,
0.1239785105,
0.3766619861,
0.5507830381,
-0.1325755417,
-0.9544381499,
-0.0046006613,
-0.3074748516,
-0.2057249993,
0.3811709285,
-0.2095440328,
0.6732664108,
-0.3283852637,
-0.4835169613,
0.3920072317,
0.9933986068,
0.3862868547,
0.6131185293,
0.8257455826,
0.5317286849,
0.5137760043,
-0.3559289873,
1.0085581541,
0.040633034,
-0.1119768992,
0.9395002127,
-0.0504680909,
0.5480962992,
0.3539023995,
-0.0957982317,
0.6340821981,
0.8227146268,
0.0114839794,
0.5516963601,
0.1560839117,
-0.082653515,
-0.354108572,
-0.1957227141,
-0.4685495198,
0.387013793,
0.0275576171,
-0.2048859745,
-0.0245249104,
0.3670935333,
-0.1536692828,
0.4231270254,
-0.2930342555,
1.0792951584,
-0.015644487,
-1.0463821888,
0.5229792595,
-0.043398302,
0.6677651405,
-0.4420846999,
-0.2006990016,
-0.180016607,
-0.344088316,
-0.1559710354,
-0.5821555257,
-0.170954749,
0.2669537663,
-0.4434530735,
-0.1217637658,
0.2394547164,
-0.5385603905,
-0.1880191863,
0.1359346956,
0.1685698628,
-0.1096214876,
0.3412459493,
-0.3445576131,
-0.1577050537,
0.1392447948,
0.0633470044,
0.1156640127,
0.6969872117,
0.0733336657,
0.3076616824,
0.8327767253,
0.0894626975,
0.1453632861,
0.2619842589,
0.3589932621,
-0.6871555448,
-1.1046351194,
-0.3934483528,
0.5975598693,
0.0916171148,
-0.3637660742,
0.6010077,
0.4112212658,
0.8857930899,
-0.0919218212,
0.8878681064,
0.3526463509,
0.7491899133,
-1.026237607,
0.221825704,
-0.7817835212,
0.4001061916,
-0.4600013793,
-0.7967515588,
0.2174603492,
0.0620388463,
-0.0995324925,
0.0997729078,
0.6241157055,
0.6268191934,
-0.2588815987,
0.2868783772,
0.1752441376,
-0.0865876079,
0.3098104596,
0.4626946151,
1.042475462,
-0.2115625143,
0.6484018564,
-0.2548827827,
-0.1875589937,
0.0666331127,
-0.6892309189,
-0.6728774905,
-0.6800193191,
-0.2596485019,
-0.4799601436,
0.0378749035,
0.8959386945,
0.549770534,
-0.8563181162,
-0.3376039565,
0.0352542847,
0.16696316,
-0.3009223342,
-0.2376471311,
0.3430582285,
-0.4276878834,
-0.8638882637,
0.5465545058,
0.0771672279,
0.3870619833,
-0.2027561367,
-0.1389402896,
0.3529174328,
0.1471545994,
0.2280421108,
0.2946666479,
-0.8579940796,
-0.4153857827,
-0.0760818794,
-0.0155325653,
0.2659611106,
1.1156228781,
-0.6061033607,
0.5474517941,
0.4108034968,
0.6638911963,
0.2038674653,
0.1992736757,
0.9742348194,
-0.9415780306,
0.0303192269,
0.0037389908,
0.290601939,
0.4120012224,
-0.3631975651,
0.2307032496,
0.1241871938,
-0.403488785,
-1.0414937735,
0.1741316319,
-1.1015412807,
-0.4204408824,
1.10242939,
0.1202323362,
-0.0402803756,
-0.0466845147,
-0.6012485623,
0.5436860323,
-0.8399291039,
0.6460901499,
0.4725301862,
0.1622713953,
0.0004943924,
-0.6062850952,
0.6941766143,
0.4717756212,
-0.5294212103,
-0.0804306343,
0.7982859015,
0.0662704706,
0.199370712,
0.5365635753,
0.0140869878,
0.941481173,
-0.0466816314,
-0.0069194078,
-0.3339971602,
-0.7047669888,
-0.4721744061,
0.3167362511,
0.1075124294,
-0.4536623061
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00895v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00895v1
|
In-Context Prompt Editing For Conditional Audio Generation
| 2023-11-01T23:31:51 | 2023-11-01T23:31:51 |
Ernie Chang, Pin-Jie Lin, Yang Li, Sidd Srinivasan, Gael Le Lan, David Kant, Yangyang Shi, Forrest Iandola, Vikas Chandra
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Distributional shift is a central challenge in the deployment of machine
learning models as they can be ill-equipped for real-world data. This is
particularly evident in text-to-audio generation where the encoded
representations are easily undermined by unseen prompts, which leads to the
degradation of generated audio -- the limited set of the text-audio pairs
remains inadequate for conditional audio generation in the wild as user prompts
are under-specified. In particular, we observe a consistent audio quality
degradation in generated audio samples with user prompts, as opposed to
training set prompts. To this end, we present a retrieval-based in-context
prompt editing framework that leverages the training captions as demonstrative
exemplars to revisit the user prompts. We show that the framework enhanced the
audio quality across the set of collected user prompts, which were edited with
reference to the training captions as exemplars.
|
[
-0.1952540427,
-0.6209027767,
0.6057417989,
0.0950463042,
-0.1674145013,
-0.1800701916,
-0.3294021487,
-0.1881577224,
0.0637017637,
0.5153346062,
-1.0880974531,
-0.4383111894,
-0.3030477166,
0.4095199406,
-0.5144251585,
0.8358265162,
0.1348702312,
-0.0495715253,
-0.278264612,
-0.4695647657,
-1.1029219627,
-0.2696644664,
-0.8331496119,
0.0645157248,
0.08541888,
0.4228475392,
0.7290460467,
0.5074149966,
0.1840592027,
0.2476458549,
-0.3540743291,
0.1329691112,
-0.1467314363,
0.5785098672,
-0.2180266082,
-0.3114890754,
-0.0404990762,
0.0793393329,
0.7411556244,
0.7731133699,
-0.0834910646,
0.0831552669,
0.0714896023,
0.3133035898,
-0.5055195689,
-0.0353569388,
-0.7297089696,
0.1278132796,
0.1824514866,
-0.7360267639,
-0.5879375935,
-0.0423872806,
0.0983562022,
-0.9650631547,
0.5173953772,
-0.1667789221,
0.5296264291,
0.7105541229,
-0.3550289869,
-0.3207468688,
-0.477452606,
0.4548407793,
-0.5833705068,
0.3935392797,
0.4632290006,
0.5772658587,
-0.366630584,
-0.8248521686,
-0.5858257413,
0.0322459787,
-0.0188673362,
0.1713559479,
-0.0437920019,
0.0181760713,
0.4994018376,
0.0625270829,
-0.2371150851,
-0.0044655562,
-0.0054002311,
-0.4120799899,
0.5249449611,
0.2096168548,
0.3811262846,
-0.26588884,
-0.2123100907,
-0.5068441033,
-0.9628260732,
0.3346127272,
0.5715379715,
0.4660794735,
0.0888204128,
0.4881386459,
-0.1167736724,
0.616864264,
0.35778597,
-0.0889840424,
0.5078357458,
-0.4561931193,
-0.2897483706,
0.3503868282,
0.6717275977,
0.5579081178,
-0.4676453173,
0.0877585933,
-0.4343849421,
-0.1373553276,
0.0134169422,
-0.5789520144,
-0.1414081305,
0.1616002023,
-0.2768249214,
-0.1298315823,
0.0107729575,
-0.5109893084,
-0.4147800505,
-0.3252372146,
0.4587979913,
-0.432772547,
0.123936817,
0.0286073331,
-0.7090680599,
-0.1145933941,
0.3548657,
-0.8664470315,
-0.2850991189,
0.2568054199,
0.4846490622,
-0.0655472949,
-0.0261397511,
-0.9486111999,
0.1529536396,
-0.2118778527,
0.577267766,
-0.7134918571,
-0.8972401023,
0.2416015118,
0.0535341762,
0.1557389498,
-0.8810735345,
0.8264423013,
-0.4513557851,
0.5084943175,
-0.5739985108,
-0.505887568,
0.2473127246,
-0.1778156459,
-0.5165041089,
1.0464881659,
0.2551124394,
-0.5693079829,
0.7963312864,
-0.6262664199,
-0.4907121062,
-0.1057732925,
-0.2392782718,
-0.4824042916,
-0.0657433867,
0.5631539226,
0.3739654422,
0.05288155,
0.4891828895,
-0.115781337,
-0.5066056848,
0.3294647336,
-0.6392813325,
0.7676485777,
0.213626191,
-0.4222322106,
0.1903124601,
-0.9075319171,
-0.2331768423,
-0.2953773737,
-0.3823088706,
-0.3344984353,
-0.0189786833,
0.2820588946,
0.4268385768,
-0.2397256792,
-0.5015785694,
0.1922745556,
-0.1840671897,
0.6179836392,
0.6838249564,
0.5105475187,
0.5119383931,
-0.2193846405,
0.6048035622,
0.1776768714,
-0.0084736552,
-0.6811503768,
-0.3577657342,
-0.2438785732,
-0.4566805363,
0.1145627126,
0.4829724431,
-1.0243965387,
0.3614327312,
-0.220559299,
0.1205287799,
-0.8524316549,
-0.0519322455,
0.1900078654,
1.0137367249,
0.7517442107,
0.2079721838,
-0.5322493315,
-0.8412489891,
-0.2879320383,
-0.0355329216,
-0.3913924694,
0.3740576804,
0.0115334569,
-0.4473432004,
1.3448847532,
-0.1504056305,
-0.1513748467,
-0.0615519583,
0.0261097159,
0.1590627283,
0.6036375165,
0.4846262634,
-0.9185759425,
-0.2034148276,
-0.5139180422,
-0.5117323995,
-0.6168784499,
-0.6482650042,
-0.3329825401,
-0.1696481407,
0.8052753806,
-0.6538845301,
0.3775312603,
0.3825808167,
-0.5091150403,
0.7002139688,
-0.0469057262,
0.4048754871,
-0.9946882129,
-0.0445672981,
-0.0623211376,
-0.4229799807,
-0.3310066462,
-0.3725305796,
0.0839142874,
-0.3268116117,
-0.5289068818,
0.5644105077,
-0.140749231,
-0.1808400005,
-0.1304304898,
0.2928805351,
0.1982894391,
0.2969191372,
0.1561719477,
1.1036977768,
0.4231845737,
-0.6257430315,
-0.0325630009,
0.5793166757,
-0.2536264062,
1.0623906851,
-0.681176722,
0.0918195546,
-0.0124715595,
0.5696973801,
-0.8968631029,
-0.2112733424,
0.2945764959,
-0.4408777952,
0.4706227779,
-0.1256198734,
-0.6843106151,
0.1556072831,
-0.0774708912,
0.4395855665,
0.459736526,
-1.1203125715,
0.1491350532,
0.1288128048,
-0.1387730837,
-0.4192969799,
-0.5901402235,
0.1072514653,
-0.418022275,
-0.5072675943,
0.5958607793,
-0.3779681027,
-0.2136030644,
0.03563888,
-0.219850868,
0.1922972947,
0.0744652227,
0.3464208245,
0.1753909737,
0.0379193388,
0.2293630242,
0.8681494594,
-0.0814245641,
0.2654235959,
-0.207986474,
-0.0893242508,
0.5157600641,
-0.2247535884,
-0.6743786335,
0.4747901559,
0.2436400503,
-0.1241109893,
0.2948071361,
0.2796296477,
0.0328807496,
-0.4642179012,
-0.1227040067,
-0.2654617131,
-0.5990549326,
0.3097213507,
-0.4382132292,
-0.7699740529,
0.4475894272,
-0.156891346,
0.0983092338,
0.3613663018,
0.1710121185,
-0.6467320323,
1.2154040337,
0.2103117704,
0.3942671418,
0.739613533,
-0.2744348943,
-0.3778286576,
-0.7858819962,
-0.0977107957,
-0.4456177652,
-0.268528372,
-0.3574167192,
-0.1729329824,
0.5268776417,
-0.0870148465,
-0.2754128277,
0.2845613956,
-0.5268155932,
0.4305789173,
0.5970026851,
0.3055851758,
0.1122361571,
-0.0006871864,
-0.0476659536,
0.0584265403,
-0.5994616747,
-0.4021683931,
0.7429998517,
0.133167237,
0.1976964921,
0.171660006,
0.6763735414,
0.7368459105,
0.1510081142,
-0.387503922,
0.4151901007,
0.3776064813,
-0.5503499508,
-0.5430330038,
-0.5131801963,
-0.7618681788,
0.2557623684,
-0.1099235937,
-0.3788430095,
0.6386823654,
0.3832578063,
-0.2482752055,
0.110873647,
-0.5466056466,
0.8892187476,
0.2624613941,
-0.1071440727,
0.0994938165,
-0.9052826762,
-0.0121765565,
0.0906436443,
0.1609840989,
-0.0896660313,
-0.041825898,
0.6270058751,
-0.6621099114,
0.6194112301,
-0.7114807963,
-0.0517166518,
0.3977341056,
0.109790802,
0.5902777314,
0.6117603183,
-0.2516830564,
-0.2194083631,
0.023278825,
-0.2688475549,
-0.9405930638,
0.43859604,
-0.7577214837,
-0.4776267409,
0.1262867153,
-0.4985893667,
-0.6018878222,
-0.1546910405,
0.7032184005,
0.7376261353,
-0.0077554621,
0.0961560905,
0.6131767631,
-0.4403960705,
0.621214211,
0.0354778916,
0.1771293133,
-0.599386692,
0.6444023252,
-0.2704564035,
0.3540923595,
0.3222138882,
0.0331743099,
-0.5804613233,
-0.4240045249,
-0.7243913412,
-0.0930309594,
-1.0642881393,
-0.2537738383,
-0.3866328895,
0.4333875179,
-0.2940861285,
-0.3178865612,
-0.0617206916,
-0.6362892389,
-0.6548447609,
-0.3666754663,
0.3910799026,
0.0764448643,
-0.0959413275,
0.5524097085,
-0.5915784836,
0.2635050118,
0.2094824314,
0.0150339613,
-0.5484119058,
-0.9843467474,
-0.2289390117,
0.1820833236,
-0.0344855078,
-1.0731569529,
0.3364941776,
0.2862075269,
0.5508165359,
0.1891565025,
0.3271652758,
0.6127169132,
-0.5151670575,
0.9628118873,
0.2130111903,
-1.0628439188,
0.8148190975,
-0.5379636884,
0.4312276244,
0.9117497206,
-0.0295095388,
-0.6659789085,
-0.5636427999,
-0.676605165,
-0.8598819375,
0.7308385968,
0.2415144742,
0.3687309027,
-0.1963671446,
0.4509370029,
0.4583859742,
0.2369329333,
-0.3141616583,
-0.5266193748,
-0.7680553198,
-0.1416273564,
-0.2799103856,
-0.2390495092,
-0.0500231087,
-0.2872632444,
0.715005517,
-0.1008195058,
0.2902604043,
0.4528413415,
-0.3188804984,
-0.0232791975,
0.4763365388,
0.6692694426,
0.4304147661,
-0.2541803122,
-0.0136611424,
0.1317842901,
-0.2125069946,
0.5481200218,
-0.1436860412,
-0.508227706,
0.4856520295,
0.3302569091,
1.0709246397,
0.5397485495,
-0.7971512675,
0.5697717071,
-0.0772003606,
-0.0535769872,
-0.3203098476,
0.2753846943,
-0.2598180175,
0.00441948,
0.5461759567,
0.4131503999,
0.4525113106,
-0.3025407493,
0.3810474277,
0.0309057515,
-0.5884201527,
-0.266561389,
0.8640120625,
0.2040036321,
-0.4715985358,
0.879003644,
-0.2898652256,
-0.0547962859,
0.3527466059,
0.5764654279,
1.0647747517,
-0.0277452655,
0.3341838717,
0.2985820174,
-0.0731622502,
0.1728373617,
0.195102334,
-0.5503476262,
-0.5281465054,
-0.2359218299,
-0.1523404121,
-0.4741581678,
-0.0705267787,
-0.8570614457,
0.3473696709,
-0.2951342762,
-0.415705204,
-0.4632516801,
-0.6562407613,
-0.7364153266,
0.3071561158,
-0.1436985731,
0.9017054439,
-0.7865623832,
0.5405852795,
0.7244831324,
-0.4388133287,
-0.716830492,
0.1193791553,
-0.0598669909,
-0.0935521126,
0.5409728289,
0.1034739763,
0.1595785022,
-0.0288256072,
-0.6081579328,
-0.4762484729,
1.060085535,
0.6920982599,
-0.5586290359,
0.1261386424,
0.1400714666,
0.5076129436,
-0.1803797632,
0.2403844595,
0.6459568739,
0.4555082619,
0.0404209197,
-0.7272638679,
0.0281521864,
-0.2427399158,
-0.119763881,
-0.0489180237,
-0.1485130489,
0.5260967016,
-0.1660729051,
-0.3377465308,
-0.0306913797,
0.7948670387,
0.3893655539,
0.4380222261,
0.6740082502,
0.3101604283,
0.7469180226,
-0.114821136,
1.0868291855,
-0.0983556882,
0.0716594607,
1.2277866602,
-0.0390453041,
0.6765286922,
0.695697546,
0.0077837165,
0.3390344381,
0.873262763,
0.2272138298,
0.9836031199,
-0.0205656216,
-0.463142097,
-0.3234511912,
0.0146733206,
-0.34557271,
0.0855186209,
0.1994102448,
-0.5311607122,
0.0189193357,
0.5308385491,
-0.1589715034,
0.1289493293,
-0.1450235099,
0.6043096781,
-0.0818526968,
-0.529951036,
0.4898506999,
-0.0749143139,
0.5998780131,
-0.1517311782,
-0.2376704365,
-0.4173472524,
-0.2932353616,
-0.1406343132,
-0.644059062,
0.1562844962,
-0.0967418402,
-0.4532380998,
-0.5633146167,
0.2099641412,
-0.488951087,
-0.2214698792,
0.0551169999,
0.1468709558,
-0.0784810409,
-0.0651024282,
-0.5719596744,
0.1228224188,
0.0425195172,
-0.3466852307,
0.2006670088,
0.5362430811,
0.0202037357,
0.4445927143,
0.6851609349,
-0.1293133646,
0.0878858268,
0.3196862936,
0.6455388069,
-0.6417796612,
-0.7740936875,
-0.5020674467,
0.7025485635,
-0.0828542411,
-0.3694472909,
0.6012119055,
0.44783023,
0.8581565619,
-0.1804735214,
0.970613718,
0.1824354827,
0.3492374718,
-0.736438632,
0.4772386551,
-0.428401053,
0.7405773401,
-0.5336162448,
-0.7827126384,
-0.186161235,
0.3064824641,
-0.1338913143,
-0.1197492108,
0.4547633827,
0.9130154848,
-0.0698597208,
0.0928431824,
0.3678963184,
-0.1881098598,
0.5927846432,
0.091547884,
1.0049470663,
-0.4046138227,
0.4825765193,
-0.2260053456,
0.1669787914,
-0.082925126,
-0.7560224533,
-0.5541526675,
-0.8344828486,
-0.6078790426,
-0.2979590893,
0.2659040391,
1.1363121271,
0.5784342885,
-0.663164556,
0.2854390442,
0.0524107665,
-0.0388714969,
-0.4776251614,
-0.2800915539,
0.5889660716,
-0.4180601835,
-0.6122627258,
1.0206552744,
0.0205042921,
0.0978516042,
0.1494449377,
-0.2558089197,
0.3883991241,
-0.0472907834,
0.67327106,
0.3292272091,
-0.5467196703,
-0.5712628961,
-0.1687020659,
-0.0599200316,
0.2165389061,
0.7563786507,
-1.0208158493,
0.6213260293,
0.4646320343,
0.5851004124,
0.3438437581,
0.1416813135,
0.5056041479,
-1.3541898727,
0.1233978495,
0.1557437032,
0.4705768824,
0.548660934,
-0.3284573555,
0.1598824859,
0.3366734982,
-0.4036372304,
-0.9750955105,
-0.1615349948,
-1.0106275082,
-0.2261287272,
1.3030022383,
-0.0946511626,
0.1689419597,
-0.0461340472,
-0.6415929794,
0.356143862,
-0.7200859189,
0.5378605127,
0.215729326,
-0.1672751606,
-0.0792200342,
-0.4784381986,
0.721837461,
0.4168452024,
-0.4678073823,
0.133211568,
1.0047855377,
0.196948573,
-0.1364490688,
0.3808498979,
0.0406133533,
0.6532251239,
-0.1218891367,
0.0057412707,
-0.4104410112,
-0.3581516445,
-0.6877058744,
0.1474897116,
-0.2169425189,
-0.2915791273
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00871v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00871v1
|
Pretraining Data Mixtures Enable Narrow Model Selection Capabilities in Transformer Models
| 2023-11-01T21:41:08 | 2023-11-01T21:41:08 |
Steve Yadlowsky, Lyric Doshi, Nilesh Tripuraneni
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
Transformer models, notably large language models (LLMs), have the remarkable
ability to perform in-context learning (ICL) -- to perform new tasks when
prompted with unseen input-output examples without any explicit model training.
In this work, we study how effectively transformers can bridge between their
pretraining data mixture, comprised of multiple distinct task families, to
identify and learn new tasks in-context which are both inside and outside the
pretraining distribution. Building on previous work, we investigate this
question in a controlled setting, where we study transformer models trained on
sequences of $(x, f(x))$ pairs rather than natural language. Our empirical
results show transformers demonstrate near-optimal unsupervised model selection
capabilities, in their ability to first in-context identify different task
families and in-context learn within them when the task families are
well-represented in their pretraining data. However when presented with tasks
or functions which are out-of-domain of their pretraining data, we demonstrate
various failure modes of transformers and degradation of their generalization
for even simple extrapolation tasks. Together our results highlight that the
impressive ICL abilities of high-capacity sequence models may be more closely
tied to the coverage of their pretraining data mixtures than inductive biases
that create fundamental generalization capabilities.
|
[
-0.6855396032,
-0.1750385463,
0.3804335594,
0.1991186589,
-0.2933557928,
0.1853430718,
-0.3487878144,
-0.2455917299,
-0.2730420828,
0.475917697,
-0.6272707582,
0.0406084359,
-0.760678947,
0.1018366069,
-0.8393619657,
1.0879434347,
-0.1795472652,
-0.1683766246,
-0.4936038852,
0.0699689016,
-0.486469537,
-0.5788769126,
0.0152527457,
-0.7194003463,
0.2244967967,
0.3392293453,
0.397175312,
0.1828877628,
0.3331353366,
0.318950206,
0.2114662677,
-0.0049304334,
-0.6850421429,
0.2079252452,
-0.1020038128,
-0.6516860127,
0.2701181173,
0.0927818716,
0.5525969863,
0.9329012632,
0.1423660517,
0.0307730585,
0.6045031548,
0.4989252388,
-0.5958913565,
0.2424085736,
-0.9208747149,
0.2725111246,
-0.1431067437,
-0.2380875498,
-0.5965263844,
0.2221346647,
0.3688559234,
-0.6086532474,
0.3893991113,
0.0684760213,
0.8091539741,
0.4291691184,
-0.5115922689,
-0.0386762172,
-1.0988180637,
0.9120726585,
-0.1691778004,
0.5441526175,
0.2923483551,
0.3711938262,
-0.0503488258,
-0.7784026265,
-0.474517256,
-0.1193451136,
-0.5719811916,
0.0913348272,
-0.1132156923,
-0.1148649529,
0.4218094647,
0.4027069211,
-0.1063574627,
0.1537345499,
-0.2444654703,
0.0553088486,
0.2596175075,
0.0624188893,
0.0196036492,
-0.0279962998,
-0.3487661183,
-0.4678723812,
-0.767113328,
0.1947947741,
0.1475394815,
0.1625819057,
-0.2737516463,
0.4875412881,
0.0463198461,
0.6558114886,
0.3883459866,
-0.1149561778,
0.2730833888,
-0.195711717,
-0.4237753451,
-0.3352724016,
0.4812693298,
-0.2322725356,
0.2156734467,
-0.5986560583,
-0.4957230389,
-0.2169208974,
0.3662896752,
-0.3854554296,
-0.1543368846,
-0.0351302959,
-0.4221095741,
-0.0074832989,
0.3295195699,
-0.4064856172,
-0.1226184219,
-0.7357497811,
0.5620433688,
-0.2323157191,
-0.085966371,
-0.146806553,
-0.2212681174,
0.2112631202,
0.0031413499,
-0.7925186157,
0.4670754075,
0.4925069511,
0.5541931391,
-0.5036509037,
-0.3656125665,
-0.4662920237,
0.0955598056,
-0.088656038,
0.5977122188,
-0.5617416501,
-0.5310741067,
-0.1349636614,
0.1725251824,
-0.5550247431,
-0.8875174522,
0.1568202078,
-0.6670202017,
-0.047835134,
-0.0993786305,
-0.4206377566,
-0.0322022997,
-0.0974245593,
-0.7048211694,
1.0781594515,
0.5856507421,
-0.8132484555,
0.815484345,
-0.3150257766,
-0.731138885,
-0.1467120796,
-0.3000439107,
-0.4003835618,
0.3213850856,
0.0202089008,
0.8822947741,
-0.3196187615,
0.4203333855,
-0.1840986311,
-0.5833709836,
0.1595987976,
-0.3998438418,
0.5213407278,
-0.0235693436,
-0.678775847,
0.2245862484,
-0.5425866842,
-0.3514670134,
-0.0072753062,
-0.2598336935,
-0.4218593836,
-0.0173867848,
0.057682246,
0.5971999168,
-0.2595504224,
-0.2839473784,
-0.027752161,
-0.3609516919,
0.2680954933,
0.6116225123,
-0.3432528079,
0.7015378475,
-0.4943704009,
0.7013545632,
0.3912628591,
-0.0405523703,
-0.3536643386,
-0.2166040093,
-0.9327994585,
-0.2051167935,
0.2265848368,
0.5088964105,
-0.9468278885,
0.7722510695,
-0.4298095703,
-0.4823596776,
-0.1973958313,
0.1472785622,
0.2993407249,
0.7301284671,
0.6169428825,
-0.2195083052,
-0.5431272388,
-0.799221158,
0.0051231538,
0.4365231693,
-0.2595896721,
0.3459811509,
0.5740156174,
-0.2790801525,
1.1606112719,
-0.282820344,
-0.2249974757,
-0.6187474728,
-0.0955504179,
0.1738315523,
0.3672530055,
0.3847275674,
-0.9563096166,
-0.5783382058,
-0.0752101913,
-0.5427661538,
0.1724880636,
-0.3138123155,
-0.1424835324,
-0.2306599319,
0.489784956,
-0.5516585112,
0.4013801217,
0.4862034321,
0.0740136653,
0.4042569697,
-0.2356539518,
-0.197484374,
-0.8793292046,
0.0409026965,
0.136869505,
-0.1630645245,
-0.6923869848,
-0.1864356548,
0.0996759236,
0.095588237,
-0.4996803999,
0.4739200473,
-0.3926390111,
-0.2322908938,
-0.1323280483,
-0.2507811785,
-0.1697753668,
0.5286420584,
0.111448057,
0.6477764249,
0.8439263701,
-0.8088135123,
-0.0357248299,
0.4761573672,
-0.6035792232,
0.1397630423,
-0.5388233066,
0.0507287495,
-0.3232084811,
0.4907053113,
-0.8555166125,
-0.3003323078,
-0.0962979645,
0.1353274137,
0.4401998222,
0.0657474995,
-0.4061508775,
-0.4163001478,
0.1717760712,
0.4838231802,
0.6268996596,
-0.7788465619,
0.7597033381,
0.342880398,
0.2466123402,
-0.526396215,
-0.7415209413,
-0.4563809335,
-0.4518737793,
-0.3554061651,
0.6813073158,
0.1216576174,
-0.0763496682,
-0.1973244846,
-0.1950110793,
-0.2492652684,
0.1389959753,
0.5690680146,
0.2889374495,
0.0174165368,
0.0044313115,
0.183514148,
-0.2303175032,
-0.1301171482,
-0.0958976895,
0.8134102821,
0.2052598745,
-0.6328362823,
-0.0759022161,
0.3384708166,
0.3532448113,
-0.3298093379,
0.7471294403,
0.4371076226,
-0.1651207805,
-0.495348841,
-0.3876003623,
-0.4473818839,
-0.5107465982,
0.4104422629,
-0.3337789178,
-1.0421395302,
0.1978498101,
0.0016361653,
0.0823727623,
0.3801800609,
0.2236213535,
-0.1746736467,
0.6457196474,
0.7144816518,
-0.268874377,
0.4397695363,
-0.4466757178,
0.3363606334,
-0.7553979158,
-0.2560897768,
-0.325699687,
-0.559845686,
-0.3415600657,
-0.3724566102,
0.5703998804,
-0.0971690118,
-0.1860704869,
0.4644988179,
-0.2847684324,
0.4978898764,
0.8386086822,
0.2410749644,
0.1472382993,
0.2005433142,
-0.1631296724,
0.0767435953,
-0.7408505082,
-0.1962389201,
1.1496369839,
0.0777698085,
0.6085344553,
-0.5287268758,
0.5795617104,
-0.0731153786,
0.5586415529,
-0.661647439,
0.37357077,
-0.3818467855,
-0.4206957817,
-0.1681211591,
-0.2862216532,
-0.9866397977,
0.3358236551,
-0.3862662911,
-0.528711617,
0.1301703602,
0.2513484955,
-0.4658629,
0.3875018656,
-0.628819406,
0.6626712084,
-0.0840177536,
0.1045217514,
-0.1115739942,
-0.8476202488,
0.4325133264,
-0.5021598339,
0.0727937073,
0.2204601318,
0.2959359288,
0.5168784261,
-0.0121791735,
0.7944837213,
-0.0886224732,
0.1877499074,
0.1424683481,
-0.0627810583,
0.4050756991,
-0.220901981,
0.0886366665,
-0.0710412785,
-0.3145975173,
-0.2095640153,
-0.6591287255,
0.3398599029,
-0.7570046186,
-0.5471459031,
0.0103543596,
-0.6485737562,
-0.6607574821,
-0.0124529479,
0.7095153332,
0.6182439923,
0.0813319609,
0.6229359508,
0.6423915625,
-0.0762553513,
0.6512134075,
0.0527824461,
0.1577459276,
0.182995677,
0.7904291153,
0.038900461,
0.4003760517,
0.6563279033,
-0.0907233208,
-0.1948508173,
-0.4838638604,
-0.054536894,
-0.0273777172,
-0.6736940145,
-0.0447260812,
-0.8135938644,
-0.2724095583,
0.0731415227,
-0.2496447414,
-0.088114813,
-0.0405706428,
-0.2813058496,
-0.2247886509,
-0.2710257471,
0.7350466251,
0.3982782364,
0.6924446821,
-0.7970439196,
0.2948328853,
0.4225353301,
0.1093645394,
0.1469881535,
-0.5154926777,
-0.2617177069,
-0.0325140134,
-0.4442961812,
-0.6297856569,
0.2767148912,
0.2267898619,
0.7087296247,
0.373120904,
-0.1345504671,
0.6850212812,
-0.4702467918,
0.4625238776,
0.1264971346,
-0.8441966772,
0.1264428347,
-0.1347624213,
0.2595115602,
0.5495861173,
0.7563021183,
-0.2948230207,
-0.3261246979,
-0.6349096894,
-0.835098803,
0.6836394072,
0.182845667,
0.2805563211,
0.1193421111,
0.1714065373,
0.4615247846,
0.3645865321,
-0.7521227002,
-0.3283011317,
-0.2240229547,
-0.158133626,
-0.4607481062,
0.0904834643,
-0.0054262569,
-0.543820858,
0.4213369489,
-0.1511407197,
0.338604182,
-0.1429877579,
-0.4764581621,
0.0144426208,
0.1708543897,
0.1988637447,
0.5037885904,
0.2863476872,
0.1708074808,
0.2295108289,
-0.2630091012,
0.3496283293,
0.3015047908,
-0.04756229,
-0.1685637832,
0.5002480745,
1.0272507668,
0.6097243428,
-0.7815355659,
0.6682922244,
0.1108279154,
-0.1277877986,
-0.2381498516,
0.4016546011,
-0.1512917578,
0.249743849,
0.5615758896,
0.4445013106,
-0.0741419047,
-0.3693546057,
0.5045348406,
0.5018458962,
-0.4403644502,
-0.4265814722,
0.5812221169,
-0.0199012961,
0.1278915107,
0.7967408895,
-0.086095944,
-0.3604219854,
0.6094493866,
0.6447502971,
0.7767221928,
-0.1089527532,
0.101119265,
0.0113287037,
0.1232778281,
-0.260638833,
-0.1980898082,
-0.2470638603,
-0.9458994865,
-0.5015005469,
-0.5197945237,
-0.0422467552,
0.3248995245,
-0.5891258121,
0.2932578623,
-0.0901773199,
0.0871052966,
-0.3428694606,
-0.5496029258,
-1.1939780712,
0.5086894631,
0.032527592,
0.6780346632,
-1.081458807,
0.9185637832,
0.3918361962,
0.078889057,
-1.0561341047,
0.2094589919,
-0.3651805818,
-0.6211999655,
0.8348591328,
0.4607488811,
0.1397446692,
0.1269764602,
-0.2320937514,
-0.8828558326,
1.0857032537,
0.4357397854,
-0.5241308808,
-0.4198314846,
0.4089524746,
0.2189348638,
-0.4775863588,
0.4596426487,
0.7393877506,
0.3189370632,
0.0702760071,
-1.0460041761,
-0.0814581662,
-0.0937192813,
-0.2088023126,
0.2935013473,
-0.3476140797,
0.8343273997,
0.0197773967,
-0.1223990321,
-0.2834553123,
0.652112782,
0.1175322384,
-0.0458704457,
1.0790095329,
0.4238724411,
0.4160714149,
-0.2828253806,
1.1745020151,
-0.204047367,
0.1048327312,
1.1239027977,
-0.1233082935,
0.6841215491,
0.4490045607,
-0.1760945022,
0.4334432185,
0.5344874263,
0.0220841747,
0.7606033087,
0.0465194844,
-0.2526126504,
-0.3709715009,
0.1322322488,
-0.1431615502,
0.4556239843,
0.2309788465,
-0.4088564515,
-0.2479162514,
0.3986574709,
-0.285443455,
-0.2322378755,
-0.1299141198,
0.4973698258,
0.1533714831,
-1.0024006367,
0.3555106521,
-0.3295555413,
0.9044275284,
-0.6300221682,
0.1591377854,
-0.0155905141,
-0.0225720499,
-0.2416711152,
-0.5414169431,
0.4711315334,
-0.3765805066,
-0.0713177547,
-0.4090248942,
0.6746091247,
-0.4096624553,
-0.2255492806,
0.29926458,
0.5529821515,
-0.2935489118,
-0.3205725253,
-0.2310260683,
-0.2796527743,
-0.0133616012,
-0.4048849344,
0.5771195889,
-0.0517674461,
-0.1414970905,
0.7081169486,
0.405189842,
-0.2116003186,
0.3840226233,
-0.1084441617,
1.0619238615,
-0.3688686788,
-0.5541419983,
-0.7131799459,
0.7164971232,
0.1270941645,
-0.2622771263,
0.5886659622,
0.5145729184,
1.2432564497,
-0.3938874304,
0.9945960045,
-0.0455248803,
0.3119905591,
-0.4021812975,
0.2636476159,
-0.3984407485,
-0.0612502359,
-0.1992876232,
-1.0418611765,
-0.0854390562,
0.3568133712,
-0.4423619509,
0.2477112561,
0.7446058393,
0.5286982059,
-0.6124694943,
0.1271515489,
0.2938478291,
-0.1649434716,
0.1851396859,
0.6458769441,
0.8801955581,
-0.0241029132,
0.3363085389,
-0.5982134342,
-0.1304142326,
0.0498202108,
-0.6327800751,
-1.1524604559,
-0.939594388,
0.1423611343,
0.0207411572,
-0.5071394444,
1.0904457569,
1.1015502214,
-0.7235104442,
-0.2842007577,
-0.1506294608,
-0.1582392603,
-0.2770724595,
-0.1797191948,
0.1269824803,
-0.4250992239,
-0.6725775599,
0.6701377034,
0.0813086703,
0.1281793863,
-0.2080340534,
0.0130517222,
0.2718729973,
-0.1894438863,
0.5919556618,
0.0767320395,
-0.4630996287,
0.0007386752,
0.03510084,
0.2107648849,
0.2157758772,
1.1846277714,
-0.9995421171,
0.0878718123,
0.2885500491,
0.8780579567,
0.5994657278,
-0.0727022067,
0.5913464427,
-0.8695969582,
0.3729114532,
0.1825450063,
0.5622873306,
0.2513771951,
-0.1541566104,
0.2149736881,
0.1766707599,
-0.4079714715,
-0.5688513517,
0.3092111349,
-0.6744352579,
-0.1302455813,
1.1189776659,
-0.0809695572,
-0.047612723,
-0.3140886426,
-0.0436327532,
0.2666775882,
0.0267884303,
0.6460502148,
0.6417759061,
-0.2450318187,
0.0916497037,
-0.4366407692,
0.6081808209,
0.5847254992,
-0.8668852448,
-0.2878207266,
0.0292455833,
0.2082733959,
0.0079199048,
0.3385247886,
0.2126767337,
-0.0959557667,
-0.4968946576,
-0.4543558657,
0.0181764532,
-0.5993677378,
-0.1689471155,
0.3436901271,
-0.2150574476,
0.032552626
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00867v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00867v1
|
Automatic Disfluency Detection from Untranscribed Speech
| 2023-11-01T21:36:39 | 2023-11-01T21:36:39 |
Amrit Romana, Kazuhito Koishida, Emily Mower Provost
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL
|
Speech disfluencies, such as filled pauses or repetitions, are disruptions in
the typical flow of speech. Stuttering is a speech disorder characterized by a
high rate of disfluencies, but all individuals speak with some disfluencies and
the rates of disfluencies may by increased by factors such as cognitive load.
Clinically, automatic disfluency detection may help in treatment planning for
individuals who stutter. Outside of the clinic, automatic disfluency detection
may serve as a pre-processing step to improve natural language understanding in
downstream applications. With this wide range of applications in mind, we
investigate language, acoustic, and multimodal methods for frame-level
automatic disfluency detection and categorization. Each of these methods relies
on audio as an input. First, we evaluate several automatic speech recognition
(ASR) systems in terms of their ability to transcribe disfluencies, measured
using disfluency error rates. We then use these ASR transcripts as input to a
language-based disfluency detection model. We find that disfluency detection
performance is largely limited by the quality of transcripts and alignments. We
find that an acoustic-based approach that does not require transcription as an
intermediate step outperforms the ASR language approach. Finally, we present
multimodal architectures which we find improve disfluency detection performance
over the unimodal approaches. Ultimately, this work introduces novel approaches
for automatic frame-level disfluency and categorization. In the long term, this
will help researchers incorporate automatic disfluency detection into a range
of applications.
|
[
-0.4943673611,
-0.9541741014,
0.4315746129,
0.3085412979,
-0.0090141594,
0.5023115277,
0.1478998363,
-0.5042015314,
0.2289176434,
0.1823975444,
-0.5690718293,
-0.0835227147,
-0.9126583338,
0.1687677354,
-0.9065248966,
0.7300720215,
-0.0406444483,
0.2596948445,
0.0341999419,
-0.1995698363,
-0.5797458887,
-0.5397828221,
-0.6627635956,
-0.3882211149,
-0.0136303138,
0.1940015107,
0.6332678795,
0.4263831675,
0.3852300942,
0.5693357587,
-0.4455728829,
-0.1058902368,
0.0826070458,
0.378072381,
0.1317249089,
-0.1560241431,
-0.3508981168,
-0.2790955007,
0.8873770833,
0.7044456005,
-0.3527516127,
-0.1371660084,
0.265566498,
0.5999321938,
-0.3999283016,
0.1152979657,
-0.3958782256,
0.224233672,
-0.6077805758,
-0.0773309916,
-0.2264877558,
-0.0939540938,
-0.2160429657,
-0.296987921,
0.1689481735,
-0.1715392321,
0.5250399113,
0.7234135866,
-0.377881974,
-0.6302107573,
-0.6732972264,
0.3374564052,
-0.637390554,
0.6814278364,
0.5008915067,
0.2707069218,
-0.337223202,
-0.5361953378,
-0.8907561898,
-0.2911219299,
-0.2229857147,
-0.0463516451,
-0.6782702208,
0.2656367123,
0.5215653777,
0.7109801173,
-0.8611729741,
0.3830434382,
-0.2073466778,
-0.5784691572,
0.3294714987,
0.1464697868,
0.7746136785,
-0.2656309009,
-0.3319461048,
-0.1359781027,
0.1549950987,
0.0899912193,
0.4126815498,
0.1510697454,
0.1422592551,
0.3247027993,
-0.272854656,
0.5707514286,
-0.0060658562,
-0.2748939097,
0.4377821386,
-0.3769012392,
-0.1171521917,
0.3163488507,
0.6608938575,
-0.0341659635,
0.0032256113,
0.1136657521,
-0.374853164,
0.4289967716,
0.0641186908,
-0.2554428279,
-0.273165375,
0.0089878719,
-0.2068586946,
-0.0724828914,
-0.1778280288,
-0.7278798223,
-0.3723251224,
-0.4001910686,
0.4985977411,
-0.7236307263,
-0.2937551737,
0.0466673747,
-0.2523466647,
-0.3813045025,
-0.0117219305,
-0.8670496941,
0.3844228685,
0.114822112,
0.9141049385,
-0.1933855116,
-0.1748033166,
-0.6822900176,
0.0399511643,
-0.1142228246,
0.9033593535,
-0.1987884045,
-0.1596625745,
-0.1319690049,
0.0434957594,
0.0546975806,
-0.5524869561,
0.5372188687,
-0.1104959324,
-0.0353915058,
0.1446147263,
-0.3894906342,
-0.1068604365,
-0.25532794,
-0.9327709675,
0.9878563881,
0.0821153373,
-0.4087432325,
0.5143094063,
-0.7436670661,
-0.6792290211,
0.3193819821,
0.0457268618,
-0.5344567299,
0.2880512178,
0.2232428789,
0.2896099985,
0.2815112174,
0.2868098319,
0.0353168473,
-0.3053430915,
0.5232870579,
-0.830365479,
0.6792290211,
0.302772373,
-0.3927186728,
0.0223492403,
-1.0681399107,
0.0359210335,
-0.2511879802,
-0.3752824068,
-0.5078254938,
0.002498742,
0.3242399693,
0.1051035672,
-0.1375266016,
-0.545594871,
-0.0310514737,
-0.3503752649,
0.7062895894,
0.4365437329,
-0.1225343123,
0.1694957614,
-0.1519044489,
0.2459421903,
0.4248118103,
0.0098053385,
-0.2086737007,
-0.2081829607,
-0.7096880674,
-0.5227703452,
0.2540417612,
0.3774698973,
-1.0772849321,
0.3203364015,
0.1804236174,
-0.0094421199,
-0.6116239429,
-0.0046671298,
0.7550007701,
0.5952331424,
0.7353243232,
-0.6156024337,
-0.6957210302,
-0.7370539904,
-0.0937042981,
-0.3211726546,
-0.0536346212,
-0.5037993193,
0.2347158939,
-0.2671511471,
0.5866208076,
-0.27930516,
-0.7089197636,
-0.0650839806,
0.6389498711,
-0.3394588828,
0.4641498327,
0.3263481557,
-0.7795812488,
-0.2633277476,
-0.1290512681,
-0.4419288337,
-0.3810047507,
-0.1091942936,
0.4675638676,
0.6730643511,
0.862229526,
-0.2805376649,
0.6961832643,
0.6403855681,
-0.4349159896,
0.2884984314,
-0.2065982074,
0.4412715137,
-0.773453474,
-0.1309570372,
0.0025434876,
-0.4194502831,
-0.8341976404,
-0.4708850682,
-0.1223073304,
0.0101143802,
-0.3037976623,
-0.1554341316,
-0.5947624445,
-0.355509907,
-0.2440708578,
0.0538130514,
-0.0209824629,
0.1955578178,
0.0380978398,
0.7234903574,
0.3369347155,
-0.5184969902,
0.5033878684,
0.4070598185,
-0.4872704446,
0.6183868647,
-0.4761750102,
0.0827637166,
-0.1997047514,
0.1467944682,
-1.3835434914,
-0.3290734887,
0.2156012803,
-0.5440042019,
0.45819965,
-0.1798173785,
-0.3839696348,
-0.3405161202,
0.0221476294,
0.3108254075,
0.2774627209,
-0.3729610741,
0.2237196416,
0.6535360217,
-0.2294684649,
-0.4405069649,
-0.9630494714,
0.176744312,
-0.1700381637,
-0.3362193704,
0.611816287,
-0.2012901008,
-0.1810848117,
-0.1358395815,
-0.2803103924,
-0.5081387162,
0.1427400857,
0.4255225062,
0.1265135705,
-0.0947600156,
0.1751500964,
0.2606898844,
-0.2281645834,
-0.3422102928,
0.2068893164,
0.7116257548,
-0.1820451766,
-0.5990490317,
-0.9324532747,
0.5151827335,
0.80752635,
-0.0116525162,
0.1304734945,
0.5848253965,
-0.5452516079,
-0.0407273695,
-0.6788799167,
-0.1225151718,
-0.4833503067,
0.5875300765,
-0.3027815819,
-0.7217736244,
0.4785404205,
0.0638387427,
-0.2815958261,
0.0323962979,
0.5343652964,
-0.4206205904,
0.8869044185,
0.5045062304,
-0.1301309466,
0.6988916397,
0.2917209566,
-0.0088453069,
-0.5427283645,
-0.0871126354,
-0.5108854771,
-0.3284132779,
-0.3222856522,
-0.2998248041,
0.1557054371,
0.1236757636,
0.214835152,
0.5283661485,
-0.8127732873,
0.5200235248,
0.1181841791,
-0.0051815812,
0.6184027195,
0.0285226554,
0.1274086386,
-0.1683534384,
-0.2859158516,
-0.4883443415,
0.384162873,
0.5289344788,
0.5920605063,
0.1866443008,
0.4220489562,
0.7138105631,
-0.0488784611,
-0.9355921149,
0.2334756404,
-0.2129782438,
-0.4052799642,
-0.6667075157,
-0.3844411075,
-0.8369278312,
0.0884058699,
-0.1309332997,
-0.7098115683,
0.3965472877,
0.4625561237,
-0.3664152622,
0.1302390248,
-0.542119503,
0.589425087,
-0.2457267046,
0.1444025636,
-0.0585152246,
-0.4375436604,
0.2594462931,
0.0089209974,
0.265258491,
-0.0056347433,
0.3906470537,
0.7216874957,
-0.1751677543,
0.640917778,
-0.2514346838,
-0.1111197025,
0.1666769087,
0.1734809875,
0.0962395668,
-0.1424634457,
0.1571213007,
0.4017795324,
0.3095079064,
0.1263204068,
-0.5492526889,
0.4098125994,
-0.4177640676,
-0.2787934542,
-0.5934791565,
-0.5609134436,
-0.336643666,
0.0679788738,
0.2397930324,
0.5540012717,
-0.3056510687,
0.0344931819,
0.6365331411,
-0.1303281933,
1.0072931051,
0.648162961,
-0.0496349297,
-0.2071753442,
0.9014067054,
0.2702357471,
0.220351696,
0.1289550513,
-0.2526524961,
-0.5040165186,
-0.7714814544,
-0.4376393855,
-0.2066899538,
-0.6443124413,
-0.1703159064,
-0.4004819095,
-0.2119015157,
-0.5958903432,
0.1560605317,
-0.382314682,
-0.5356788039,
-0.1585172564,
-0.0880104899,
0.2514954805,
0.6509014964,
-0.2560348809,
0.1863129586,
-0.6694350839,
0.6006556749,
0.1558354944,
0.2770049572,
-0.2344455123,
-0.636471808,
0.1415502876,
0.1253366321,
-0.4862838984,
-0.8974565268,
0.6812079549,
0.3186705112,
0.4913062155,
0.2856111526,
0.1856280863,
1.0936163664,
-0.5683053136,
0.553113997,
0.539927721,
-1.3785414696,
0.4860925674,
0.3062640727,
0.0660675392,
0.5650180578,
0.4529016912,
-0.7391608357,
-0.5048136115,
-0.1991298646,
-0.879986465,
0.8548003435,
0.1852281094,
-0.0812481791,
0.0897960588,
-0.014224289,
-0.0357599258,
0.1004857644,
-0.622279644,
-0.0619389825,
-0.3676375151,
-0.1335469037,
-0.1858358681,
-0.2274087816,
-0.2071229368,
-0.2260090113,
0.3610153794,
-0.1059430391,
0.21277152,
0.2978023291,
-0.6767392159,
-0.1910669506,
0.40231359,
0.7017248273,
0.3558604419,
0.0883614644,
0.1459183246,
0.2096302956,
-0.6272699237,
0.5036553144,
0.2042884976,
0.1973121762,
0.4266406894,
0.1953975856,
0.9015660882,
0.160409376,
-0.7528451085,
0.5181801319,
-0.1291132271,
-0.1321029067,
-0.5480015874,
-0.1481844783,
-0.0737509355,
0.3486640155,
0.3903249502,
0.0498711765,
0.504632771,
-0.8055503368,
0.6398009658,
0.3717256784,
-0.5981609225,
-0.1437304765,
0.5577763915,
0.0556718521,
-0.5866419673,
0.7955910563,
0.0663607568,
-0.391487658,
0.4346270859,
0.4394856691,
0.6938633919,
-0.6374555826,
0.1874118894,
-0.1919127703,
0.2165898532,
-0.0382999666,
0.023662135,
-0.2505881786,
-0.7251724601,
-0.3666427433,
-0.7987629771,
-0.2176388651,
0.3557225168,
-1.0108011961,
0.1446059495,
-0.3288758397,
-0.402715981,
0.5910534263,
-0.4972749949,
-0.1815950871,
0.0227512363,
0.4177504778,
0.3539375365,
-0.9985206127,
0.7934956551,
0.5542208552,
-0.6144403815,
-0.5177950263,
0.3166496456,
0.4597077668,
-0.649142921,
0.7996023297,
0.0634879544,
-0.2088377774,
-0.1272186637,
0.0004196617,
-0.6085954905,
0.8794857264,
0.5474839807,
-0.7452377081,
-0.10565231,
0.357871145,
0.6811398268,
0.2137523443,
0.3185721934,
0.7426462173,
0.430229038,
0.1610457152,
-1.4599272013,
0.0587977432,
-0.0594743118,
0.1237901077,
0.3103083074,
-0.3858789504,
0.5935570002,
0.337992996,
-0.4684969187,
-0.1580864936,
0.4621799886,
0.0323016718,
0.6958934665,
0.7237097621,
0.5695639849,
0.6522172689,
-0.3091971278,
0.4740443826,
-0.1141820475,
0.0789526701,
0.6809737086,
-0.0733384341,
0.6958569884,
0.5376011133,
-0.1831746548,
0.3763005733,
0.2497859746,
0.2180548012,
0.3319472969,
0.2165721804,
-0.3878368437,
-0.0401840545,
-0.0146678146,
-0.2212805748,
0.7906575799,
0.4590170085,
-0.173418954,
-0.1632929444,
0.6319277287,
-0.2206295878,
0.1753991991,
-0.2207976431,
1.0223478079,
-0.0379290283,
-0.4828867614,
0.7813619375,
-0.2701452076,
0.8820239305,
-0.4822739363,
-0.1964371949,
-0.2032338381,
0.1828614622,
-0.4353566468,
-0.7182064652,
0.8656616211,
-0.0684427992,
-0.2668987513,
-0.5963058472,
0.617590189,
-0.5563154221,
-0.0385021381,
0.3108233511,
0.2229399085,
0.3268746138,
-0.0648707077,
-0.5942971706,
0.3912170529,
-0.0237879679,
-0.1751614362,
0.6026727557,
0.4928076863,
-0.1941126287,
0.6845705509,
0.525744617,
-0.0608351678,
0.0514570214,
0.0797690153,
0.8549598455,
-0.2793037295,
-0.4501346946,
-0.8148673177,
0.6016891599,
-0.0789428353,
-0.1946138442,
0.561732769,
0.2677017748,
0.7797729373,
0.0339735933,
0.4887052178,
-0.1556032151,
0.4657916129,
-0.5912511945,
0.8105848432,
-0.5682365298,
0.185093984,
-0.6726039052,
-0.4146135449,
-0.248275429,
0.9134540558,
0.0940851048,
-0.3226009309,
0.7235216498,
0.7946996689,
-0.0131627554,
0.0296178032,
0.7099409699,
0.1589784175,
0.1040542796,
0.3282186985,
0.8841729164,
-0.2481397986,
0.7325802445,
-0.1512461007,
-0.4304944575,
0.0081984047,
-0.6126839519,
-0.5854849815,
-1.1162428856,
-0.5581789017,
-0.2406938821,
0.3137697577,
0.5796387792,
0.544269979,
-0.9100472331,
-0.0992873907,
-0.1907654256,
-0.0177471247,
-0.3906223774,
-0.2988933623,
-0.0044016405,
-0.305770874,
-0.9206368327,
0.8577237725,
0.3436984718,
0.4317865074,
-0.2056125849,
0.2218556851,
-0.1336084753,
-0.2288326621,
0.6124205589,
0.5218580365,
-0.6600862145,
-0.1866331697,
-0.4173346758,
0.1112438589,
-0.0145231998,
0.8295941353,
-0.6759468913,
0.4845330417,
0.4281235039,
0.4481354058,
0.3748394251,
0.0323067568,
0.2923523486,
-0.8720605373,
0.4051650465,
0.5048217773,
0.3889572918,
0.1980996132,
-0.3373598456,
0.0661343187,
0.3890654147,
-0.5335114002,
-1.2776391506,
0.3004370332,
-0.866977036,
-0.5111190677,
0.7101473808,
-0.0585051142,
0.1831459105,
-0.6056094766,
-0.2433602959,
0.5219441652,
-0.4708725214,
0.9364020824,
0.8524572849,
-0.5602695346,
-0.2936524749,
-0.4913290441,
0.7686567903,
0.3919130266,
-0.5000854731,
0.2254316807,
0.7766680717,
0.3039960265,
0.4093085825,
0.6280344129,
-0.297641933,
0.1241146997,
0.0110697318,
0.153839767,
-0.3120395839,
-0.2784544528,
-0.6739984155,
0.1714871228,
-0.2735854089,
-0.4064570963
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00863v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00863v1
|
Training Dynamics of Contextual N-Grams in Language Models
| 2023-11-01T21:32:51 | 2023-11-01T21:32:51 |
Lucia Quirke, Lovis Heindrich, Wes Gurnee, Neel Nanda
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Prior work has shown the existence of contextual neurons in language models,
including a neuron that activates on German text. We show that this neuron
exists within a broader contextual n-gram circuit: we find late layer neurons
which recognize and continue n-grams common in German text, but which only
activate if the German neuron is active. We investigate the formation of this
circuit throughout training and find that it is an example of what we call a
second-order circuit. In particular, both the constituent n-gram circuits and
the German detection circuit which culminates in the German neuron form with
independent functions early in training - the German detection circuit
partially through modeling German unigram statistics, and the n-grams by
boosting appropriate completions. Only after both circuits have already formed
do they fit together into a second-order circuit. Contrary to the hypotheses
presented in prior work, we find that the contextual n-gram circuit forms
gradually rather than in a sudden phase transition. We further present a range
of anomalous observations such as a simultaneous phase transition in many tasks
coinciding with the learning rate warm-up, and evidence that many context
neurons form simultaneously early in training but are later unlearned.
|
[
-0.3827874064,
-0.9482186437,
0.711565733,
0.0261029359,
-0.0943573937,
-0.1832788736,
-0.1681000143,
-0.3030951619,
0.2131625116,
0.0471927822,
-0.5580405593,
-0.1114861593,
-0.722833097,
-0.0733246207,
-0.8869578242,
0.8332248926,
-0.0451500379,
0.1953328252,
-0.1497219056,
-0.1655708104,
-0.1680829674,
-0.6956704259,
-0.6540048718,
-0.9525128007,
0.4169377387,
0.2277441025,
0.3175624013,
-0.0199299008,
0.0078878021,
0.2691847682,
-0.4348986149,
-0.1536292732,
-0.2093515694,
0.17442514,
0.1945237219,
-0.5048329234,
-0.398211211,
-0.0239635538,
0.6249597073,
0.9199008942,
-0.15722844,
-0.1934780329,
-0.0321766771,
0.5409861207,
-0.4190786779,
0.261710465,
-0.555226624,
0.0471241511,
0.0816306546,
-0.3395956457,
-0.747564435,
0.1378736794,
0.2727476954,
-0.3954988122,
0.3613097668,
-0.2906692922,
0.836207509,
-0.3703359663,
-0.8367628455,
-0.2313240916,
-0.4917469323,
0.4257543981,
-0.4041926563,
0.3240048587,
0.2491994351,
0.190952152,
-0.5112532973,
-0.9413657188,
-0.5371673107,
-0.6363790631,
-0.3018855453,
0.0972713679,
-0.1065580845,
0.030024251,
0.4404802322,
0.0441821814,
-0.3094715178,
0.0506470241,
-0.3669344187,
-0.0045141741,
0.28580755,
0.0010593699,
0.3780582249,
-0.0872435346,
-0.2409280837,
0.0117225731,
-0.6274297237,
-0.0937374309,
0.4773024917,
0.1887305379,
-0.2791939676,
0.3455955982,
-0.2010296881,
0.8164841533,
0.2276448011,
0.0425962992,
0.4975579679,
-0.1460795403,
-0.0848595947,
0.2412783653,
0.7109668851,
0.1052145734,
0.5258533955,
-0.2622457147,
-0.3728678823,
0.1172648147,
0.368416965,
-0.7944889665,
-0.4213788807,
-0.1737807393,
-0.3570952415,
-0.1859425455,
-0.0111972988,
-0.2396257371,
-0.0068738349,
-0.3130190372,
0.4459560513,
-0.2979399562,
-0.3955487609,
0.1425923854,
-0.1653849334,
0.1639887542,
0.054071378,
-1.3662819862,
0.5205897093,
0.3384064436,
0.8966302872,
0.0451866761,
-0.5857858062,
-0.3478243351,
-0.0633568987,
-0.4801395535,
0.8335837722,
-0.4855858386,
-0.4322280884,
0.2067331076,
0.614402473,
-0.1575612277,
-0.458679527,
0.2852843404,
-0.9748492837,
0.41068542,
-0.1698984951,
-0.3256144226,
-0.2503303885,
0.0058909967,
-0.4699127674,
1.1969650984,
0.0383144692,
-0.9711744189,
0.5058361292,
-0.6007546186,
-0.9082216024,
-0.2011490017,
-0.265784502,
-0.0546444654,
0.6126405001,
-0.1452506632,
0.4506781995,
0.0154182082,
0.2027633488,
-0.2366835773,
-0.4767745733,
0.1327869296,
-0.3572041094,
0.7800990343,
-0.1939876229,
-0.4592763782,
-0.0006885797,
-0.8230115771,
0.172406584,
0.3625136614,
-0.3768444061,
-0.3431788683,
0.2097988278,
0.1364976466,
0.3815031946,
-0.0221080426,
-0.4645072818,
0.2355291843,
-0.4154659212,
0.9235005975,
0.4827186763,
0.2252218723,
0.6673542261,
0.1500833035,
0.0947288498,
0.1187081337,
-0.102686204,
-0.2408417165,
-0.6180328131,
-1.0170958042,
0.5828024745,
0.2590564191,
0.4871535897,
-0.6378597021,
0.3885705471,
-0.1137824804,
-0.0758995786,
0.3691949844,
-0.1285286844,
0.3198228776,
0.5015535951,
0.2807891369,
-0.4431267977,
-0.2097294778,
-0.9448730946,
0.0202107895,
-0.174906522,
-0.0944096968,
-0.0035376039,
0.746889174,
-0.0940047279,
0.7675921321,
-0.5150601268,
0.2704175115,
-0.1302448064,
0.6622396111,
0.2907155156,
0.4039214849,
0.5877802372,
-0.6905773282,
-0.1860380322,
0.0913508013,
-0.8209770918,
-0.2103153318,
0.017676739,
-0.1351125687,
0.2368688583,
0.9280124307,
-0.0950117782,
0.161375761,
0.4989112318,
-0.1988096982,
0.3020784259,
-0.6453407407,
-0.1307319105,
-0.9742692113,
-0.0838421285,
-0.049724564,
-0.0985078961,
-1.0778087378,
-0.2878930867,
0.2668896019,
0.3933514357,
-0.3977868259,
0.566817224,
-0.7162849307,
-0.3652722239,
-0.8419459462,
0.2110522687,
-0.0452609733,
0.6277999282,
0.1725721061,
0.6455335021,
0.6448208094,
-0.6487086415,
-0.2097943127,
0.0527833663,
-0.5951346755,
0.1950845718,
-0.6523859501,
0.153020367,
-0.2426398098,
0.09668006,
-0.6416636109,
-0.4603325427,
0.017464688,
-0.3179277778,
0.4697262645,
-0.3958748281,
-0.8680058718,
-0.3364199996,
0.468385011,
0.6129994988,
0.6525884867,
-0.5293752551,
0.3280615509,
0.4708381295,
0.1570029408,
-0.1971604228,
-0.957259953,
-0.104353331,
0.2478161007,
-0.4669895172,
0.3735156357,
0.2659518719,
0.0677993819,
0.0556543395,
-0.2151193023,
-0.393984884,
0.2658749819,
0.2259573638,
-0.0262806304,
-0.0052799201,
0.1889061034,
0.199055478,
-0.1584011465,
0.2911559939,
-0.330095619,
0.8383667469,
-0.1690807492,
-0.3317357004,
-0.3420336843,
0.3362978101,
0.4879869819,
-0.0217248555,
0.5759017467,
0.5264219046,
-0.523509562,
-0.0555284396,
-0.0652569756,
-0.3648845553,
-0.4786549807,
0.4996924698,
-0.3217789531,
-0.8329297304,
0.6255612373,
0.0329680666,
-0.3202283084,
0.5384488106,
0.725140214,
0.1226325035,
1.3133565187,
0.6115390062,
0.3486557901,
1.024934411,
-0.2834860981,
0.3472578228,
-0.842438519,
-0.3922702074,
0.0181627367,
-0.1180190146,
-0.6336132884,
-0.0605800897,
0.3921664357,
0.5168908238,
-0.3879709244,
0.2133802325,
-0.1450838894,
0.8085578084,
0.5381907821,
0.0103523424,
-0.1249267459,
0.2650323212,
-0.6352275014,
0.2506932914,
-0.9586325288,
-0.3078974187,
0.8110972643,
0.086348325,
0.46784693,
-0.0821748972,
0.6846427917,
0.0349764116,
0.2834691107,
-0.7514788508,
0.48017928,
-0.1314741075,
-0.6948228478,
0.0977571979,
-0.2309800088,
-0.8342208266,
0.2687169015,
-0.197438404,
-1.0183851719,
0.0907313749,
0.033814285,
-0.196996823,
0.0717826486,
-1.0342899561,
0.8237094879,
-0.3807880282,
-0.3719703257,
0.0166898873,
-0.6839829087,
0.4478779733,
0.1916653067,
0.0479669087,
-0.11357712,
0.3561475873,
0.826269269,
-0.3111404181,
0.8553012609,
-0.2592746615,
-0.0082478253,
0.5521226525,
0.1623140424,
0.3906436265,
0.1662682295,
0.4099970162,
0.0473579429,
-0.2834196985,
-0.4524518549,
-0.5947178602,
0.6940748096,
-0.4691521823,
-0.5169451833,
-0.466774106,
-0.3080608249,
-0.20707874,
0.4807518721,
0.4396296442,
0.7674822211,
-0.0121196844,
-0.0888976902,
0.5264963508,
0.1643647105,
0.6826355457,
0.2744994164,
-0.3674083352,
-0.3035922647,
0.4610925913,
0.2104203403,
0.5535146594,
0.0694245175,
0.0542650446,
-0.0072630313,
-0.5296620131,
-0.3767536283,
0.063590616,
-0.8756370544,
0.2871618271,
-0.8534658551,
-0.4038519561,
-0.1211503372,
-0.1698358953,
-0.1487076581,
-0.4209172726,
-0.1345758587,
-0.1437795758,
0.184061259,
0.8297871947,
-0.1044938937,
0.6861494184,
-0.7772736549,
0.2473552376,
0.4322517216,
0.4208119214,
0.2126057297,
-0.7438800931,
-0.4126505852,
-0.1494913548,
-0.169958964,
-1.0644541979,
0.1952597499,
0.0757434517,
0.7612675428,
0.5742247105,
-0.5321103334,
0.3567036986,
-0.9804853797,
0.8089564443,
0.4598332345,
-0.9238064289,
0.3776777685,
-0.3768868148,
0.598592639,
0.5272035599,
0.3162590563,
-0.5974817276,
-0.1800471991,
-0.6433323026,
-1.0757200718,
0.9626166821,
0.1433567256,
0.4542903602,
-0.3640789986,
0.3186145127,
-0.130443722,
0.2551274896,
-0.9209142327,
-0.4487772882,
-0.0818255544,
0.3542673588,
-0.1244271323,
-0.5404660106,
-0.3028311133,
-0.3008922935,
0.4690186679,
-0.2748143673,
0.4248601496,
0.0436243601,
-0.0881615654,
0.2107277215,
0.3150315881,
0.7944282889,
0.5614908934,
-0.2383890748,
0.2517801225,
0.1612992585,
-0.403775394,
0.387562871,
-0.2689602971,
-0.4599334598,
0.1326354891,
0.469026655,
1.1458460093,
0.8419010639,
-0.2342704087,
0.5955315828,
-0.1221002862,
-0.5460025072,
-0.4033035636,
0.1521969289,
0.1548824161,
0.2607370913,
0.1826788187,
0.1009213701,
0.0580751486,
-0.6601156592,
0.281647712,
0.2988131046,
-0.4068381488,
-0.5093396306,
0.665700376,
-0.0701729208,
-0.3290625215,
0.4718866646,
-0.6791543365,
-0.8876604438,
0.6078147888,
0.8519638181,
1.143635869,
0.0834636688,
0.2597071826,
0.4859199822,
0.2654967904,
-0.5693615079,
0.3905161321,
-0.2071038485,
-0.8388412595,
-0.3005500734,
-0.6654914618,
0.0649347901,
-0.0464350097,
-0.7728739381,
0.1700913608,
-0.4036152959,
-0.4120478928,
-0.0320168138,
-0.4388708174,
-0.3656153679,
0.1041859761,
0.3796704412,
0.8296089172,
-1.1260237694,
1.1063187122,
0.6047507524,
-0.131630227,
-0.4289091825,
0.2903988957,
-0.2052897364,
-0.689911902,
1.1070538759,
0.4514448941,
-0.2198039144,
-0.0892892778,
-0.2942453623,
-0.9425655603,
0.9364072084,
0.059104275,
-0.3181374371,
-0.218148917,
-0.4220530987,
0.8091748357,
-0.5370841026,
0.4354265034,
0.5352826715,
0.2750149071,
0.3312019408,
-0.5214987397,
-0.1557719857,
-0.3548841476,
0.0139080165,
0.6334251165,
-0.5113646388,
1.1409317255,
-0.1105991453,
-0.6224185228,
-0.2039699703,
0.4814129472,
0.0369601436,
0.2476926297,
0.5256118178,
0.4740462899,
0.594995141,
-0.1467918158,
0.9722288847,
-0.6984310746,
0.3730311692,
1.2492933273,
-0.3755274713,
0.8707947135,
0.5592926145,
-0.0147802383,
0.8338634968,
0.5137178302,
-0.0050253859,
0.7820108533,
0.2084584087,
-0.304725796,
-0.4149260521,
0.0926460773,
-0.4414894879,
0.4296422303,
0.1317168772,
-0.3764280677,
-0.3638584912,
0.0877840668,
0.0416039005,
-0.2570702732,
-0.2896085382,
0.5469524264,
0.21854496,
-0.6197269559,
0.6990520358,
0.1176296845,
0.4110918641,
-0.6744051576,
0.2270935029,
-0.1499018669,
-0.161222294,
-0.0813692734,
-0.5810623765,
0.1517377943,
-0.0271693021,
-0.4263406992,
-0.2738167942,
0.5171615481,
-0.4026696384,
-0.5087704659,
0.8284555078,
0.5201455355,
-0.0582824796,
0.2076243609,
-0.3109532893,
-0.5302054286,
-0.4186248481,
-0.540168643,
0.5860086083,
0.406561017,
-0.0270689894,
0.1611815095,
0.4225786924,
-0.2025452256,
0.5884740949,
0.3509391844,
0.7798537016,
-0.6722950935,
-0.6497794986,
-0.7208852768,
0.2026416957,
-0.1554519087,
-0.2337979972,
0.5127068758,
0.3676320016,
1.1402226686,
0.0942780599,
0.6281887293,
-0.1834676415,
-0.2121568322,
-0.9414557815,
0.6798171401,
-0.7821204066,
-0.1594703346,
0.2169571519,
-0.7738325,
-0.2471838892,
0.4784986973,
-0.4630822539,
0.2333434522,
1.262824297,
0.7428767085,
-0.1800854057,
0.22785528,
0.4698203504,
0.260002315,
0.04214013,
0.5023800135,
0.6178361773,
-0.5490397215,
-0.0156104853,
-0.2233446687,
-0.0209506229,
-0.2089328617,
-0.90767169,
-0.9650183916,
-0.7136016488,
-0.1195581332,
-0.4514783025,
-0.1716412455,
0.6779069901,
0.6863709092,
-0.9440041184,
-0.2936219573,
-0.7235098481,
-0.1512914896,
0.0421605706,
-0.1805739701,
0.1534813195,
-0.6884208322,
-0.5679759383,
0.6163697243,
0.3573352695,
0.2738500834,
-0.0826360285,
0.060669791,
-0.4709517956,
-0.0797101632,
0.7104869485,
0.3145926297,
-0.5162476897,
-0.2807064652,
-0.1399326175,
-0.1283029616,
0.2395238429,
1.1096724272,
-0.6357885003,
0.4273584187,
0.6638242602,
0.3604439795,
0.7277579904,
-0.5493431091,
0.4299167991,
-0.7361094356,
0.541616559,
-0.2516231537,
0.6596258879,
0.0134097403,
0.0675304681,
0.1900288016,
0.4737975001,
-0.5614810586,
-0.8848056793,
0.5593727231,
-0.8748438954,
-0.2065224349,
1.1783216,
-0.0084264027,
-0.4894334078,
0.1915642321,
0.2340609282,
0.2803297639,
-0.0670554191,
0.5984797478,
0.9954233766,
-0.4241039157,
0.198385343,
-1.0497170687,
0.4142859876,
0.6006174684,
-0.58744663,
-0.0408944637,
0.431374222,
0.1884830147,
0.3087525964,
0.5435318351,
0.0809302852,
0.3256402314,
0.2679757774,
-0.1046043187,
0.1671068221,
-0.7902597785,
-0.6382318139,
0.3787080646,
0.027708767,
-0.0611629337
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00835v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00835v1
|
Calibrated Seq2seq Models for Efficient and Generalizable Ultra-fine Entity Typing
| 2023-11-01T20:39:12 | 2023-11-01T20:39:12 |
Yanlin Feng, Adithya Pratapa, David R Mortensen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Ultra-fine entity typing plays a crucial role in information extraction by
predicting fine-grained semantic types for entity mentions in text. However,
this task poses significant challenges due to the massive number of entity
types in the output space. The current state-of-the-art approaches, based on
standard multi-label classifiers or cross-encoder models, suffer from poor
generalization performance or inefficient inference. In this paper, we present
CASENT, a seq2seq model designed for ultra-fine entity typing that predicts
ultra-fine types with calibrated confidence scores. Our model takes an entity
mention as input and employs constrained beam search to generate multiple types
autoregressively. The raw sequence probabilities associated with the predicted
types are then transformed into confidence scores using a novel calibration
method. We conduct extensive experiments on the UFET dataset which contains
over 10k types. Our method outperforms the previous state-of-the-art in terms
of F1 score and calibration error, while achieving an inference speedup of over
50 times. Additionally, we demonstrate the generalization capabilities of our
model by evaluating it in zero-shot and few-shot settings on five specialized
domain entity typing datasets that are unseen during training. Remarkably, our
model outperforms large language models with 10 times more parameters in the
zero-shot setting, and when fine-tuned on 50 examples, it significantly
outperforms ChatGPT on all datasets. Our code, models and demo are available at
https://github.com/yanlinf/CASENT.
|
[
-0.1205854937,
-0.5620732903,
0.6288650036,
-0.2071498781,
-0.4381028712,
0.0011490906,
-0.201912716,
-0.2060635984,
0.1879935563,
0.6898702383,
0.0369062833,
-0.4935336709,
-0.3847799003,
-0.121184051,
-0.4351308048,
1.0264712572,
0.0403089412,
0.0573668629,
0.0265827812,
-0.0616825446,
-0.1328437328,
-0.5943402052,
-0.3202401102,
-0.2027104199,
-0.0180047359,
0.5796990991,
0.5991641283,
0.3012971282,
0.4934268296,
0.1663587987,
0.0674225613,
0.1750311702,
-0.5700051785,
0.1131735891,
-0.101034306,
-0.4061561227,
-0.290697664,
-0.0446152873,
0.3846029341,
0.6227428913,
-0.3021711111,
0.3622440398,
0.0569330342,
0.3570944369,
-0.504653573,
0.1006957665,
-0.8916783929,
-0.2116931081,
-0.2717187703,
-0.2545695603,
-0.5377131701,
-0.1189311445,
0.2542771399,
-0.4959355593,
0.5971041322,
0.0337737612,
0.958155036,
0.2591868937,
-0.6907750964,
0.1756118238,
-0.8245924711,
0.5520326495,
-0.5884672999,
0.457031846,
0.1788708568,
0.3625025749,
-0.1716038436,
-0.9219872355,
-0.2370044142,
0.0438468121,
0.1914273947,
0.2415437847,
0.0292992927,
0.2810713947,
0.1792116463,
0.2840662599,
-0.7175875902,
-0.0436229929,
-0.1858234406,
-0.3073808551,
0.3796553016,
-0.126236245,
0.1055902466,
-0.2425043583,
-0.3164075613,
0.0722343624,
-0.7374798059,
0.0777126998,
0.0727783218,
0.2303885669,
0.4609513879,
0.8050923944,
-0.4689425528,
0.4892233014,
0.1562235355,
0.214703694,
0.0019269222,
-0.1294148117,
-0.238188535,
0.0444112755,
0.6876012683,
0.4346545935,
0.3379076123,
-0.295175463,
-0.3470041454,
-0.0080743143,
0.0974721909,
-1.0931279659,
-0.4215617478,
0.1472571492,
-0.2961900234,
-0.2296792716,
-0.0069908393,
-0.7887437344,
-0.1503321677,
-0.1791201979,
0.5539515615,
-0.5497421026,
-0.0687104687,
0.2250730842,
0.0274482723,
0.1438707709,
0.3378614783,
-0.6878145337,
0.1370054334,
0.4030685127,
0.4837432802,
-0.0055160029,
0.2140059173,
-0.6257927418,
0.127295658,
-0.3111614883,
0.8630803227,
-0.6489344835,
-0.3117022216,
-0.0550139472,
-0.1823406518,
-0.229101643,
-0.3017757535,
0.8597258329,
-0.8580079079,
-0.2417636961,
0.1023070142,
-0.884850204,
-0.069761239,
-0.0667987913,
-0.6362205148,
1.1837338209,
0.1511192918,
-0.6650054455,
0.3739983737,
-0.325225234,
-0.3330794871,
0.459890604,
-0.3643724918,
-0.2944933474,
0.4356940985,
0.1469435841,
0.6892608404,
-0.444337666,
0.4899998903,
-0.590965569,
-0.4902928472,
0.203126356,
-0.4473561645,
0.3153297305,
0.3433628678,
-0.3447439969,
-0.4612294137,
-0.7889668941,
0.3681073487,
-0.0097973682,
-0.2549037933,
-0.5729049444,
-0.1844877005,
0.0411201715,
0.2783735394,
0.0289960112,
-0.7070404291,
0.080739364,
-0.2440397143,
0.6339077353,
0.2941155434,
0.1555288881,
0.2924241126,
0.0253960546,
0.2912197411,
-0.0331814624,
-0.114087373,
0.039271716,
-0.3758272827,
-0.8395389318,
-0.3327470124,
0.9752588272,
0.5729059577,
-0.8381274343,
0.309348315,
-0.5766797662,
-0.5585013628,
-0.4977175593,
-0.1062515527,
0.4730034173,
0.5198606253,
0.4639898539,
-0.3108506203,
-0.3980578482,
-0.8266367912,
-0.2574760616,
-0.0805588067,
-0.2159805745,
0.3637109697,
0.5257213116,
-0.1609512717,
0.8990544677,
-0.4365813136,
0.0006594615,
-0.0249954984,
0.4274767935,
-0.0066505861,
0.3939917088,
0.1275280714,
-0.7811066508,
-0.3562839627,
-0.1885685176,
-0.4018652141,
0.1288311183,
-0.1913525909,
-0.1675468087,
-0.0342203043,
0.40432477,
-0.634580791,
0.5412407517,
0.2099207342,
-0.2775553465,
0.4710698426,
-0.0021323785,
0.289447844,
-1.16337502,
0.0299569909,
0.3437523544,
-0.4807060063,
-0.6993548274,
0.1894628555,
0.3590109944,
0.0562140644,
-0.4308225214,
0.3885629773,
-0.4096254706,
-0.1813484132,
0.0746100619,
0.0156318955,
0.2788594663,
0.3585484624,
0.2566292286,
0.9379025698,
0.2431359738,
-0.6182287335,
0.0915836319,
0.1775261164,
-0.2582907975,
0.614017725,
-0.8460719585,
0.2365876585,
0.0603540353,
0.2468185574,
-0.8651550412,
-0.1271013319,
-0.5553935766,
-0.4933048487,
0.5668446422,
-0.4068370461,
-0.4765303731,
-0.4049293399,
-0.2036048621,
0.3889659643,
0.2820977867,
-0.3336616755,
0.590479672,
0.3741662204,
-0.0226945635,
-0.2882720828,
-0.8167921901,
-0.1072046384,
-0.0642223954,
-0.4977948368,
0.6868556142,
-0.1055157259,
0.1445322782,
-0.2044681162,
-0.4321803749,
-0.3219569325,
0.055664584,
0.213268742,
0.4259649813,
-0.2915291786,
0.1926473379,
0.3709490299,
-0.0027446395,
-0.4401372075,
-0.3136315644,
0.4871759117,
-0.2964556515,
-0.2535279393,
-0.3265361786,
0.153484121,
0.4224034548,
-0.2590356171,
0.3507446349,
0.5300046802,
-0.6559455991,
0.0227920637,
-0.7356018424,
-0.2839981616,
-0.3897551298,
0.5472912192,
-0.8594953418,
-1.1720747948,
0.2954080701,
-0.2506897449,
0.042889066,
0.648925662,
0.2800769806,
-0.0209727772,
1.0934165716,
0.4894687533,
0.2061253935,
-0.0226972848,
-0.3333835006,
0.2490286678,
-0.9734170437,
0.0308774617,
-0.5065790415,
0.2144062817,
-0.6678268909,
-0.532956183,
0.1662389636,
0.4189526737,
-0.2395529151,
0.5830043554,
-0.3647030294,
0.4581901431,
0.6131371856,
0.0486324877,
0.309807092,
-0.0390814282,
-0.5895544887,
-0.0722997934,
-0.3216218352,
-0.6938795447,
1.5103620291,
0.2519160807,
0.6763728261,
0.1831500083,
0.9447131157,
0.3000707626,
0.1492206454,
-0.6929250956,
0.3315578103,
-0.457444042,
-0.7289773822,
-0.3739509284,
-0.4795820713,
-0.5035609603,
0.0939449668,
-0.0614620298,
-0.8281921744,
0.3206279576,
0.1120052412,
-1.0207637548,
-0.0076433774,
-0.8055201173,
0.7206632495,
-0.016423095,
-0.1164543331,
0.0862048864,
-0.5892490149,
0.292008251,
-0.3151934147,
0.0095805489,
-0.2954226434,
0.1000724286,
0.7048589587,
-0.2443214506,
0.4495518804,
-0.0528966971,
0.2771863341,
0.3775178194,
0.3557617366,
0.638071537,
0.4632479548,
-0.2580360174,
0.0746183693,
0.4314315021,
-0.285119921,
-0.3364819288,
0.7485784292,
-0.6887554526,
-0.2492136359,
-0.2041989118,
-0.1019637734,
-0.5181289911,
0.237288788,
0.6236422658,
0.6809996963,
-0.3404836059,
0.2969742119,
0.9547194839,
0.1646070778,
0.4405350089,
0.5752938986,
0.134101063,
-0.2938131392,
0.9321989417,
0.1325407922,
0.1889914572,
0.5807890296,
-0.3583169281,
-0.5550460815,
-0.4112769365,
-0.5594765544,
0.0820973516,
-0.4940522611,
-0.5701313019,
-0.8085634708,
-0.424895823,
-0.7045149803,
0.1018672213,
-0.6624732018,
-0.7992315888,
-0.5552435517,
-0.2483827025,
0.1218486279,
0.2122805715,
0.1680559218,
0.2489994913,
-0.7358132601,
0.2236831933,
0.5356957316,
0.4323020577,
-0.5942533016,
-0.9085130692,
0.103437759,
0.118847318,
-0.12947914,
-0.8148674369,
0.3457807302,
0.5476590395,
0.3457132578,
0.2786620557,
0.3107126355,
0.6434082389,
-0.564864397,
0.5484216213,
0.0280375313,
-0.7036093473,
0.3565532863,
-0.1092874184,
-0.0561062805,
0.9831804633,
0.3258294463,
-0.5101047754,
-0.0915015191,
-0.7063117623,
-0.7867482901,
0.3657269776,
0.2193994075,
0.0588809513,
0.0028528902,
0.61802423,
0.0180775393,
0.0964696333,
-0.4036558867,
-0.3129734993,
-0.3467026055,
-0.4554500878,
-0.0798976496,
-0.6476596594,
0.1130283326,
-0.1201163828,
0.850697279,
-0.3993180394,
0.4975848496,
0.415148139,
-0.56379807,
0.0821676329,
0.4673778117,
0.275823921,
0.1389442384,
-0.4002930224,
0.267293781,
-0.0051788562,
-0.4794736207,
0.0413669795,
0.8418907523,
-0.5643942356,
0.0401151888,
-0.2013124377,
0.6685292125,
0.3230617046,
-0.4165970385,
0.6640571356,
-0.3958187997,
-0.2322392762,
-0.2864019871,
-0.0552852191,
-0.0828244686,
0.2145911902,
0.3294456303,
-0.0624973215,
0.7569779158,
-0.149169758,
0.4790897071,
0.3634365201,
-0.6045107245,
-0.2667838633,
0.712135613,
0.2909223437,
0.1402968764,
0.4466907084,
-0.4842140079,
-0.3968402147,
0.376780659,
0.3807489574,
0.8169538379,
-0.1934481263,
0.5535393953,
0.2447922081,
0.2683585882,
-0.2188121676,
0.3879414201,
0.1587931961,
-0.8079010844,
-0.3849019706,
-0.974878788,
-0.3126595616,
0.2505173087,
-0.5352758765,
0.0649075136,
-0.2117892057,
-0.3854581714,
0.2754867375,
0.2324908525,
-0.9036377072,
0.2662724853,
0.0825179741,
0.8224279881,
-0.6241099238,
0.9238542914,
0.7383068204,
-0.5319311619,
-1.0358433723,
-0.2289631218,
-0.0171541255,
-0.5874710679,
0.1385294944,
0.4242523015,
0.2399585694,
0.5393862724,
-0.3035714328,
-1.2083541155,
1.204456687,
0.2946374416,
-0.7948856354,
-0.268268764,
0.3158887327,
0.4275653064,
-0.4475402534,
0.7857397199,
0.8547435403,
0.0694331601,
0.1861909777,
-0.8433622718,
0.0370433442,
-0.2040475756,
0.5236093998,
0.1704965383,
-0.5418370366,
0.4419256449,
-0.1008537635,
-0.1540866494,
0.1788391471,
0.6548099518,
0.1650644839,
-0.1029103845,
0.3175502419,
0.7426404953,
0.7780586481,
-0.1984397173,
0.5334253907,
-0.4757475853,
0.6144570708,
1.216940403,
-0.425118655,
0.7963626385,
0.3519070745,
-0.0053961086,
0.272814095,
0.8030538559,
0.0812889859,
0.3812124133,
0.066166319,
-0.2895345986,
-0.5723865628,
-0.1948690861,
-0.2366359383,
0.6096401215,
0.4568345547,
-0.3568095267,
-0.0523090698,
-0.1988522559,
-0.0081913332,
-0.143851772,
-0.2147980183,
0.4392945766,
0.0202757716,
-0.6593025923,
0.3406850994,
0.2319593877,
0.6545777321,
-0.0037444581,
-0.0632677972,
-0.3158971369,
0.1067173108,
0.0603569373,
-0.5788022876,
-0.1053357869,
-0.1074136794,
0.0985018387,
0.1692762822,
0.8516988754,
-0.5053106546,
-0.4606562257,
-0.0231665671,
0.4316754043,
0.1979738176,
-0.516769886,
-0.600927949,
-0.4611565769,
0.0190612432,
-0.5864819884,
0.2384334356,
0.5973979235,
-0.0994530395,
0.2710256875,
0.4512217641,
-0.1596937329,
0.1352505237,
0.2255517393,
0.6026539207,
-0.5596666932,
-0.0813236162,
-0.4009545743,
0.4262878001,
-0.2137390375,
-0.4967564642,
0.1256292611,
0.7729819417,
0.5679314733,
0.1726177037,
0.508189261,
0.1036438048,
0.7657684684,
-0.4584445059,
0.485827148,
-0.3659495711,
0.1745784283,
-0.1812102944,
-0.8502209187,
-0.261567235,
0.3552827239,
-0.119077228,
0.0904335007,
0.6902979016,
0.7373167872,
-0.0037167391,
0.118328087,
0.5088298917,
0.1143054664,
0.3182503283,
0.6178040504,
0.2152775824,
-0.6252804995,
0.7908067703,
-0.5268874168,
-0.4833774865,
-0.5418553948,
-0.5516426563,
-0.6224201918,
-0.6273533106,
-0.3660336435,
-0.2417360544,
0.1278600097,
0.7395123243,
0.8006631732,
-0.7977065444,
0.2685636282,
-0.0883080214,
-0.3005695045,
0.2013402134,
-0.2664296925,
0.2927470505,
-0.1661790162,
-0.449549675,
0.1377539486,
0.2466318905,
0.2438193411,
0.1429246962,
0.2335108221,
-0.169251129,
0.3023768067,
0.5367746353,
0.3161174953,
-0.54120332,
-0.4199590981,
0.2112098187,
-0.4417708516,
-0.1777831763,
0.4489598274,
-0.6094673872,
0.3526609242,
0.0683582351,
0.7061659098,
0.7454783916,
-0.1222585291,
0.3108546138,
-0.6242061853,
-0.3052143455,
0.3506297171,
0.6063687801,
0.3229353428,
-0.5428884029,
0.7989340425,
0.3097509742,
-0.6936888695,
-0.6389988065,
0.1785690188,
-0.7543273568,
0.0495181829,
1.2771171331,
-0.1902223527,
-0.0908906534,
-0.0135583933,
-0.047006622,
0.524649024,
-0.6640976071,
0.596254766,
0.4162817895,
-0.0275285635,
0.0174430851,
-0.6145464182,
0.4406410456,
0.4548995793,
-0.5367932916,
-0.0420025736,
0.6475051641,
0.4009228647,
0.0427657515,
0.5935646892,
-0.1509109586,
0.4446399212,
-0.3552991152,
0.4077461362,
0.3191992044,
-0.3662252128,
-0.1916797161,
0.0482385159,
0.1039621681,
0.0211609676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00790v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00790v2
|
Construction Artifacts in Metaphor Identification Datasets
| 2023-11-01T19:21:55 | 2023-11-15T19:11:40 |
Joanne Boisson, Luis Espinosa-Anke, Jose Camacho-Collados
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Metaphor identification aims at understanding whether a given expression is
used figuratively in context. However, in this paper we show how existing
metaphor identification datasets can be gamed by fully ignoring the potential
metaphorical expression or the context in which it occurs. We test this
hypothesis in a variety of datasets and settings, and show that metaphor
identification systems based on language models without complete information
can be competitive with those using the full context. This is due to the
construction procedures to build such datasets, which introduce unwanted biases
for positive and negative classes. Finally, we test the same hypothesis on
datasets that are carefully sampled from natural corpora and where this bias is
not present, making these datasets more challenging and reliable.
|
[
-0.4857438505,
-0.7637419105,
0.344512403,
0.2308046073,
-0.4590179026,
0.0946878791,
-0.0367639624,
-0.7736728191,
0.2209405005,
0.3269545436,
-0.4209563136,
-0.191197291,
-0.5811036825,
0.098236382,
-0.7487366796,
0.7857539058,
-0.1058668122,
-0.1862513572,
-0.3951340318,
-0.2828416228,
-0.9625169635,
-0.5423256755,
-0.3917436004,
-0.3873489499,
0.4774417281,
-0.0201181062,
0.922460556,
1.2130192518,
0.2489980757,
0.2590945363,
0.0416432805,
-0.062940754,
-0.3853754997,
0.0464573875,
-0.1787315309,
-0.3278836608,
0.2618638873,
0.4376874864,
0.4783329964,
0.8698821068,
0.0845898241,
0.5253788233,
-0.0572383516,
0.1386758983,
-0.8618947864,
0.4884685576,
-0.8854789734,
0.2872801423,
-0.6457297206,
-0.6778005362,
-0.3405045569,
-0.1720447391,
0.2335112095,
-0.6789405942,
0.4608967304,
0.3997955322,
1.3437795639,
0.1339960396,
-0.3956033587,
-0.497523874,
-0.545805335,
0.7221557498,
-0.1109224334,
0.0295157321,
0.2838951945,
0.2144306153,
-0.3198305964,
-0.3169912398,
-0.4359728396,
-0.0232228935,
-0.3334119022,
0.0755025744,
-0.1026503593,
0.0992770717,
0.6341713071,
0.4578565657,
-0.4085413516,
0.0452651456,
-0.6567081809,
-0.3636853099,
0.3852570653,
0.1681028306,
0.6244091988,
-0.3794131875,
-0.5502575636,
-0.020301586,
-0.9857519865,
-0.3534379601,
0.3104338348,
0.4054092467,
-0.0856636316,
0.8241946101,
0.2675186992,
0.8273481131,
-0.2658267021,
0.0580311529,
0.5572468638,
0.1596077234,
-0.64662534,
0.2134998739,
0.4786764681,
0.2618848681,
0.4403782785,
-0.7498138547,
-0.363089174,
0.9873861074,
0.3419390619,
-0.2836930156,
0.182896331,
0.2072976083,
-0.2985151708,
-0.4608122706,
0.0960599259,
-0.5498319268,
-0.4761152267,
-0.4267678261,
0.5752899051,
-0.2355180979,
-0.0884674489,
-0.072636582,
-0.8011910319,
0.5190445185,
0.1089719087,
-0.3469475806,
0.2838408351,
0.5590483546,
0.6374986172,
-0.217083171,
-0.416854918,
-0.5492922664,
0.1425898969,
-0.9669860005,
0.5083804131,
-0.6493444443,
-0.0947011709,
0.0128897429,
0.3027065396,
0.1780461073,
-0.9185391665,
0.5594100952,
-0.6917037368,
0.5579810143,
-0.3948456347,
-0.7987834811,
-0.0045132414,
0.3172701597,
-0.8884193301,
0.9123908281,
0.3115155101,
-1.1049869061,
0.5517897606,
-0.688146472,
-0.3990311623,
0.0755744204,
-0.5872995257,
-0.0253229383,
0.3600316644,
-0.2845190167,
0.3261867166,
-0.6918351054,
0.4529082179,
-0.3616669178,
-0.7148190737,
0.2089002579,
-0.1917157471,
1.0798928738,
0.4535152316,
-0.6548179388,
-0.3959359527,
-0.6190264821,
-0.2940540314,
0.4695803523,
0.1750371009,
-0.7938511968,
0.0536648631,
0.118159771,
0.463198334,
-0.3167612851,
-0.6717414856,
-0.071254909,
-0.1586736292,
-0.0236095637,
0.8776904941,
-0.1774998903,
0.1787806749,
-0.6609321237,
0.6388282776,
0.3421418071,
-0.3527480066,
0.1158407703,
-0.3851366043,
-0.6931109428,
-0.3996535838,
0.6700306535,
0.5050231814,
-1.0530096292,
0.065177843,
-0.3912591636,
-0.3809314966,
-0.626101613,
-0.2263026237,
0.4198182523,
0.6721690893,
0.1092982739,
-0.4453500211,
-0.9493633509,
-1.0975334644,
-0.2787607014,
-0.2209601849,
-0.4253887236,
0.2382659167,
0.4930795133,
0.2797690928,
0.9852970243,
-0.2524579465,
-0.146459654,
0.210913375,
0.2497797459,
0.1254823208,
0.3556772768,
0.9062706828,
-0.9111328125,
0.0013413217,
-0.609696269,
-1.151316762,
-0.1230125651,
-0.4406448305,
-0.1423806697,
-0.2455773801,
0.3726639748,
-0.4760100842,
0.4651885033,
0.3051725328,
-0.593059063,
0.4822590947,
0.4294341207,
-0.0088406065,
-0.8678365946,
0.3521212041,
0.2023115456,
0.2044693679,
-0.7908532619,
0.3666988611,
-0.1752271354,
0.1554600298,
-0.5513073802,
0.8601390123,
-0.4889639318,
0.0398844033,
-0.1159894466,
0.1776013225,
-0.0370970443,
0.1911783665,
0.519554019,
0.7450343966,
0.6908213496,
-0.6741567254,
0.1446198225,
0.2072314024,
-0.5963227749,
0.4527526796,
-0.5396226048,
-0.2759064734,
-0.5573056936,
0.1170592085,
-0.754363358,
-0.3209354877,
0.431181103,
-0.1957696676,
-0.1906417608,
-0.0157362521,
-0.5635272264,
-0.2952781916,
-0.2018079311,
0.3715090156,
0.5964689851,
-0.6450624466,
0.2265448123,
0.5068766475,
0.4240454733,
-0.8190188408,
-0.8166882396,
0.1164230257,
-0.9109601974,
-0.0872357637,
0.5487553477,
-0.0919438004,
-0.5279268622,
-0.2896102071,
-0.0366170481,
-0.4429567456,
0.3411110938,
0.4858619273,
0.514744699,
-0.1045018211,
0.4637176991,
-0.2959979475,
0.1246586889,
0.3650619388,
0.118492499,
0.3351425231,
0.2935189605,
-0.2913632393,
-0.1822778583,
0.1689306498,
0.6968539953,
0.2479638308,
0.7818343043,
0.4872037768,
-0.6533917189,
0.2431297749,
-0.6438449621,
0.0744012967,
-0.4144021869,
0.0340177938,
-0.6343468428,
-0.5911517739,
0.5397063494,
0.0444393158,
0.1432400644,
0.4708135724,
0.15923208,
0.1334417164,
0.487429142,
0.3384846747,
-0.2534789145,
0.2338835746,
0.1861581355,
0.0076755718,
-0.768009007,
-0.0388891734,
-0.7903438807,
-0.2096778452,
-0.9017503858,
-0.1898248494,
-0.1127472669,
-0.214047268,
-0.3594522476,
0.3466995955,
-0.5162082911,
0.5205809474,
0.6986819506,
-0.0575103872,
0.1320887059,
0.145693779,
-0.1277961433,
-0.05827225,
-0.6846998334,
-0.5638857484,
1.027941823,
0.1387413442,
0.2244590521,
-0.0949414596,
0.4701274037,
0.3503555655,
0.539147675,
-0.7213810682,
0.289437592,
0.3848773539,
-1.1326143742,
-0.0433274321,
-0.4499386251,
-1.1729319096,
0.340005219,
-0.2678109109,
-0.7124382257,
0.2385388166,
0.1116533652,
0.0066970414,
0.2464558631,
-0.688803196,
0.7205412984,
0.1041503772,
-0.2667786181,
0.2806702256,
-0.5697140694,
0.4479976296,
-0.2631477714,
0.58139503,
0.019856181,
0.0346367918,
0.7428022623,
-0.0556847751,
0.7286812067,
-0.1687914431,
-0.0311427619,
0.6263429523,
0.2852774262,
0.3072531819,
-0.3174602091,
-0.3189621568,
0.2063677609,
0.1695053577,
-0.7114896178,
-0.5442148447,
0.2106187344,
-0.618734479,
-0.5725477338,
-0.5156463981,
-0.2225979865,
-0.1874141991,
0.0714311153,
0.4960304797,
0.3424892426,
-0.3517142832,
0.0555767827,
0.2497850955,
-0.2437407523,
0.2136130631,
0.1326716691,
0.1712474823,
0.1967158318,
0.8518493772,
0.217185542,
0.0894527286,
0.0532035306,
0.0911695734,
-0.0249632932,
-0.1681943983,
-0.4181674123,
-0.0273983888,
-0.4413380623,
-0.2074843645,
-0.0505348556,
-0.3640773296,
0.1702801436,
-0.1108843684,
-0.0844818205,
-0.2939090133,
-0.1394156218,
-0.2760897875,
0.0317871198,
0.59605968,
0.1228173748,
-0.0270007644,
-0.1940019578,
0.4381684661,
0.0793985054,
0.3735535741,
0.3141117692,
-0.2682305872,
0.2217002362,
0.0901303738,
0.0946097821,
-0.9228215218,
0.1073443443,
-0.0925287157,
0.3696258962,
0.5156500936,
0.1721157432,
0.7995690703,
-0.5797146559,
0.8704774976,
0.1571772397,
-0.8705137372,
0.2594008446,
-0.2356099635,
0.1203133836,
0.283639282,
0.476588726,
-0.6120602489,
-0.4485729337,
-0.9875826836,
-0.6341799498,
0.5184506774,
0.501206398,
0.2338958681,
-0.4908609986,
0.5412206054,
0.1665638387,
0.5347518921,
-0.8993463516,
-0.4673848748,
-0.108953014,
-0.0753177553,
-0.0025190494,
-0.0786335096,
-0.4122243822,
-0.2103540897,
0.4263809323,
0.0855894014,
0.4488377571,
-0.0345460363,
-0.0943283886,
-0.0421339348,
0.2738528252,
0.1406108886,
0.6614617109,
0.0129764881,
0.3558584154,
0.1765281707,
-0.1433307081,
0.2361020148,
-0.30484128,
-0.3151302338,
0.3526374698,
0.4878333211,
0.63221699,
-0.0226822663,
-0.8783165216,
0.5427006483,
0.069031395,
-0.0497097783,
-0.5636190772,
-0.0225215014,
-0.2506861687,
-0.0091575459,
0.2932391167,
-0.1943962574,
0.242347911,
-0.6518220305,
0.028535923,
0.6452844739,
-0.5903591514,
-0.325627625,
0.3654314578,
-0.2567428648,
-0.1010076851,
0.8066240549,
-0.148143962,
-0.2706177831,
0.8727337122,
0.6427294016,
0.616630733,
0.0757418573,
0.2773962617,
0.2715498507,
0.4936094284,
0.0075957747,
0.1036997661,
0.1725791544,
-1.0234562159,
-0.2525652051,
-0.5389130712,
-0.0261215959,
0.6958062053,
-0.7277432084,
0.3137480319,
-0.1362980157,
0.0027751788,
0.0777742267,
-0.2763234675,
-1.0335786343,
0.5772348046,
0.1915909797,
0.9423778653,
-1.4466472864,
0.5099005103,
0.6071652174,
-0.4285324216,
-0.6814134717,
-0.0922773927,
0.2158699483,
-0.4735072255,
0.5493003726,
0.1085990891,
0.0129992906,
-0.3307685554,
-0.6961088181,
-0.8018510938,
0.7539169192,
0.6197810173,
0.0991388187,
-0.1743859351,
0.0705130547,
0.707993269,
-0.507458806,
0.132766217,
0.3690374494,
0.5918483734,
0.2881579399,
-0.7956175804,
0.4023824334,
-0.3741782904,
-0.0072295843,
-0.0009964481,
-0.3631869853,
0.7385858297,
0.1757952273,
-0.5978602171,
0.3064664602,
0.2388979197,
0.2447863519,
0.119822301,
0.6905554533,
0.2339115888,
0.7290455103,
-0.2627312541,
0.9026986361,
-0.1388370097,
0.0513903275,
1.1766391993,
-0.0106730107,
0.4317896366,
0.8316642642,
0.2595092654,
0.457167089,
0.992869854,
-0.2816691399,
0.4060438275,
0.5205698013,
-0.0501635745,
-0.2191256583,
-0.4504277706,
-0.5234559774,
0.7464325428,
0.4555960596,
-0.5608851314,
-0.247077629,
-0.2731128335,
0.1428020895,
-0.1445405334,
0.1758910865,
0.4531633258,
-0.2271620333,
-0.6212925911,
0.6406996846,
-0.1113849431,
0.4554359317,
-0.4311942458,
-0.1143739,
0.0364319943,
-0.4290281236,
-0.1508512795,
-0.2572650015,
0.3587804437,
-0.206303671,
-0.0620262921,
0.1218173131,
0.3730697632,
-0.2262921333,
-0.1879338324,
0.1840919703,
0.8976634145,
0.1762672365,
0.0830789134,
-0.4517431259,
-0.0757973641,
-0.3356176317,
-0.1074931771,
0.3447822034,
0.554038465,
-0.349935472,
0.4996077418,
0.3737929761,
0.2442170084,
-0.4144892693,
-0.2307575941,
0.713996768,
-0.5892473459,
-0.2482739985,
-0.8643454313,
0.1957494318,
-0.3332511783,
-0.288651824,
0.7578333616,
0.6514769793,
0.9306569099,
-0.2577603757,
0.8295248151,
-0.2307700217,
0.3765881062,
-0.2143241912,
0.4581457078,
-0.5409209132,
0.2223576605,
-0.9604482651,
-0.8910759091,
-0.4804089963,
0.6964665651,
-0.0387903377,
0.0444029905,
0.676650703,
0.5021036863,
-0.4366846979,
0.1843819618,
0.2267179042,
0.1579749137,
-0.055469919,
0.1522276253,
0.9845790863,
-0.5405648947,
0.0258004703,
-0.0639908388,
-0.2132333815,
0.2241062671,
-1.0656328201,
-0.8365645409,
-0.7537600398,
-0.4331886172,
-0.6324517131,
0.0920273885,
0.8136829138,
0.5384386778,
-0.7303365469,
-0.4532175064,
0.030027125,
0.2441665232,
-0.3598014414,
-0.3039878905,
0.49278754,
-0.1780775636,
-0.56118083,
0.1251772195,
-0.0829651207,
0.0845670253,
-0.0770512223,
0.207424283,
-0.1826298684,
0.4189358652,
0.5281678438,
0.3872708678,
-0.7893431783,
-0.7004235983,
-0.1911454499,
0.2071826905,
0.2708120942,
0.6671048403,
-1.0694949627,
0.4449294209,
0.1073145717,
0.5948979259,
0.0030967942,
-0.0650620088,
0.5643889308,
-0.9219706655,
0.457773149,
-0.0632261038,
0.3408858776,
0.2515443861,
-0.1741488874,
0.9594358206,
0.4407248497,
0.1904014051,
-0.9755346179,
0.1967570484,
-0.4316000044,
-0.3271067739,
0.9102793932,
-0.0396603532,
-0.3250888288,
-0.3062700629,
0.0794130117,
0.227548793,
0.1243512854,
1.4249027967,
1.122623682,
0.1023898497,
0.4636428356,
-0.5271366835,
0.514385581,
0.1579471976,
-0.5011544228,
-0.0219878051,
0.7455630302,
0.4284087121,
0.36887151,
0.5331713557,
-0.2018859088,
0.1684716493,
0.0049951039,
-0.0451172963,
0.2355558425,
-0.3117119372,
0.0414051749,
0.6977909207,
0.0282514933,
-0.1797496378
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04913v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04913v2
|
An Improved Transformer-based Model for Detecting Phishing, Spam, and Ham: A Large Language Model Approach
| 2023-11-01T18:41:50 | 2023-11-12T16:32:16 |
Suhaima Jamal, Hayden Wimmer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Phishing and spam detection is long standing challenge that has been the
subject of much academic research. Large Language Models (LLM) have vast
potential to transform society and provide new and innovative approaches to
solve well-established challenges. Phishing and spam have caused financial
hardships and lost time and resources to email users all over the world and
frequently serve as an entry point for ransomware threat actors. While
detection approaches exist, especially heuristic-based approaches, LLMs offer
the potential to venture into a new unexplored area for understanding and
solving this challenge. LLMs have rapidly altered the landscape from business,
consumers, and throughout academia and demonstrate transformational potential
for the potential of society. Based on this, applying these new and innovative
approaches to email detection is a rational next step in academic research. In
this work, we present IPSDM, our model based on fine-tuning the BERT family of
models to specifically detect phishing and spam email. We demonstrate our
fine-tuned version, IPSDM, is able to better classify emails in both unbalanced
and balanced datasets. This work serves as an important first step towards
employing LLMs to improve the security of our information systems.
|
[
-0.458863318,
-0.9205326438,
0.1437195092,
0.0060615088,
-0.2331579626,
0.0869406238,
-0.1703950614,
-0.5229052305,
0.1438420415,
0.8901247978,
-0.4970826507,
-0.4470384121,
-0.8164893985,
0.1185036674,
-0.7000062466,
1.0857504606,
0.3427941799,
0.1704963446,
0.0774530917,
0.2438380569,
-0.1025840417,
-0.5220790505,
-0.4911780655,
-0.5541021824,
0.3164920211,
0.5241311789,
0.321624577,
0.2110508084,
0.9441355467,
0.2896829247,
-0.0847582221,
-0.1319605857,
-0.4910915494,
0.1089597642,
-0.2737382352,
-0.6129579544,
-0.3394672275,
-0.1328426749,
0.3393657804,
0.5341540575,
-0.2405650765,
0.1598420888,
-0.1072448939,
0.6337116361,
-0.4685847163,
0.0050149234,
-0.9762475491,
-0.3125455976,
-0.3016212583,
-0.3098807633,
-0.9071067572,
-0.1226545051,
0.3461354971,
-0.074252665,
0.3150862455,
0.2788112164,
0.4672001898,
-0.2276308984,
-0.3961913288,
-0.3769767284,
-0.7398045659,
0.6800377965,
-0.7558990717,
0.3337069154,
0.2354553193,
0.4227515459,
-0.5255093575,
-0.6912852526,
-0.4180341661,
-0.0524910241,
0.1886494607,
-0.2662556469,
-0.5858944654,
0.0824294686,
0.0776842311,
0.4426820874,
-0.6805389524,
0.5831802487,
-0.3525146842,
-0.1724370271,
0.5289524198,
0.3514250815,
0.404483676,
0.000049868,
-0.1969434023,
-0.131952703,
-0.6590280533,
0.019289013,
0.4994091094,
0.5110484958,
-0.1627189666,
0.2669562399,
0.0852504224,
0.5520535111,
0.2142624855,
-0.240801692,
-0.2726663649,
0.3130040467,
-0.4113543332,
-0.0349168703,
0.3912989199,
-0.0343185514,
0.2646225989,
-0.0576501191,
-0.2529692352,
0.137609452,
0.5351184607,
-0.9956552982,
-0.5496218204,
0.224232927,
-0.9307453632,
-0.4912890196,
0.0641870201,
-0.8738421202,
-0.7592653632,
-0.2912916839,
0.2293431014,
-0.4861992598,
-0.4524204135,
0.3846365809,
0.0839648694,
0.2534164488,
0.5126263499,
-0.876812458,
0.6637433171,
0.9834128022,
0.4902857542,
-0.3345704973,
-0.1258381754,
-0.4954282045,
0.0146091171,
-0.1162947714,
0.7301200628,
-0.7567203641,
-0.1091249287,
0.3579497039,
-0.0332643613,
0.2606180906,
-0.6399769783,
0.5505478382,
-0.9157748222,
0.2824541628,
0.0371099859,
-0.76644063,
-0.280195415,
0.5185300708,
-0.7699553967,
0.8033881783,
0.1526069641,
-0.8462759852,
0.0218904652,
-0.7272892594,
-0.5474984646,
0.3582909107,
0.4295198619,
-0.59871912,
0.3594461381,
0.0862940773,
0.7066385746,
-0.7663937807,
0.3705527484,
-0.5252124071,
-0.2948721349,
0.448245436,
-0.4547137916,
0.7775081396,
-0.066634357,
-0.4235386848,
0.0017089573,
-0.833347559,
-0.2001945376,
0.1483183801,
-0.3027256727,
-0.3877348602,
-0.2043964714,
0.2563512921,
0.0484454483,
0.1272215545,
-0.4713085294,
0.0747718215,
-0.528308332,
0.312520802,
1.0167863369,
-0.1810084134,
0.3831013441,
-0.3943438232,
0.3990994096,
0.1991386116,
0.1810205132,
-0.5026161075,
-0.3933418393,
-0.9124353528,
-0.5503402352,
0.1582081914,
0.50683707,
-0.4722173214,
0.6958082318,
-0.3838040829,
-0.510066092,
-0.4564401805,
-0.143789053,
-0.0546049178,
0.2195352018,
0.4139324129,
0.057447914,
-0.4687135816,
-0.8498226404,
-0.314332813,
-0.2405344993,
-0.1728197336,
-0.0225953404,
0.7461543083,
-0.3613151014,
0.6538826227,
-0.4427401721,
-0.1845649928,
-0.433275491,
0.2082040161,
0.4166562259,
0.335531801,
0.4635413587,
-0.7931748629,
-0.6217272282,
-0.2739565372,
-0.2357053459,
-0.1311962754,
0.0666378364,
0.1489212364,
0.0242875628,
0.1154477,
-0.5821596384,
0.3192686141,
0.2179089487,
-0.3889985979,
0.4630971849,
-0.0737448409,
0.1990257502,
-0.9959059358,
-0.1237906292,
0.2616573274,
-0.2223435044,
-1.1489399672,
0.0791008025,
0.3203081191,
-0.2355825156,
-0.3133289218,
0.6057901978,
-0.2834723294,
-0.0020784298,
-0.613771677,
-0.227817446,
-0.2483009398,
0.3206614852,
-0.2091124207,
0.6047630906,
0.72796911,
-0.6096245646,
0.5442693233,
0.0274660513,
-0.5896620154,
1.0302901268,
-0.6588505507,
-0.009917479,
-0.1531524062,
0.466455698,
-1.1148394346,
-0.4349750876,
0.3584418893,
-0.4100167751,
0.4974915087,
0.0420280434,
-0.8550994992,
-0.5576131344,
-0.4718140364,
0.1156692058,
0.6624407172,
-0.9018194079,
0.7908281088,
0.3742061853,
-0.2187412977,
-0.3163833916,
-0.3578105271,
0.3288829029,
-0.3579934239,
-0.9901877046,
0.4175732434,
-0.0691435337,
-0.4525180757,
-0.4520418942,
-0.1229905784,
-0.2505142689,
0.352276355,
-0.0061766193,
0.4758862853,
-0.0767005384,
0.0418921933,
-0.206053704,
-0.1072556674,
0.1888156533,
-0.4324480593,
0.6913008094,
0.0608974397,
-0.4568026662,
-0.7613005638,
0.3781912327,
0.971639514,
-0.1012830585,
0.9020321369,
0.6165947318,
-0.6496798396,
-0.3770964146,
-0.94493258,
-0.7760162354,
-0.5032795072,
0.1638304442,
0.0353640504,
-0.9274017215,
0.4742802978,
-0.3948672116,
0.0225677602,
0.1026561856,
0.579433322,
-0.0999892205,
0.9473519325,
1.0992257595,
-0.4322824776,
0.4513210654,
-0.0099318624,
0.6711278558,
-0.6085220575,
-0.2203429639,
-0.7201652527,
-0.2347031981,
-0.4352493286,
-0.1040200889,
0.3538527787,
-0.1123428941,
-0.2430289984,
0.295475632,
-0.4833973646,
0.2362832427,
0.4373556674,
0.081387572,
0.1396336108,
0.1777258664,
0.0206586327,
-0.1193763539,
-0.5003037453,
-0.676382184,
1.3181052208,
0.6022998095,
0.9829611182,
0.3127779365,
0.4206160009,
0.6237904429,
0.6376476288,
-0.4722874463,
0.635209024,
-0.2196824402,
-0.6213333011,
-0.1935044229,
-0.0082464926,
-0.9836233854,
0.321975261,
-0.1772385389,
-1.0283600092,
-0.3404045701,
-0.0233555716,
-0.0075867097,
0.6011614799,
-0.2482704222,
0.4377141297,
0.006953761,
-0.2253260612,
-0.2756378651,
-0.4558112323,
0.5046598911,
-0.3164637387,
0.2909537852,
-0.2525244057,
0.3000626862,
0.5695340633,
-0.3334813416,
1.1293932199,
0.0495874658,
-0.3742679656,
-0.0164267253,
0.0690013766,
1.0484852791,
0.0006493611,
-0.0907120109,
0.1469676644,
-0.3957821727,
-0.3764391541,
-0.3082667589,
0.5863136053,
-0.489507556,
-0.7346135378,
-0.4291831553,
-0.6523405313,
0.0630425364,
0.1927109957,
0.1269374788,
0.0826600567,
-0.0499062352,
0.4401600659,
1.2973049879,
-0.2124892324,
0.4185578823,
1.1359598637,
-0.0612720326,
-0.3313577175,
0.4243199825,
-0.2480561882,
-0.0910312682,
0.5419591069,
0.0960303769,
-0.280516237,
-0.7714004517,
-0.0896909088,
0.3388466537,
-0.7102689147,
-0.4826398194,
-0.8148316145,
-0.253264606,
-0.6671848297,
-0.2810950577,
-0.050004378,
0.0450017489,
-0.450050354,
0.1950553805,
0.4195553064,
0.5003419518,
0.2090563774,
0.5499596596,
-0.7804664373,
0.313364476,
0.1699522734,
0.2985137999,
0.078821294,
-0.8029744625,
-0.0805683732,
-0.038022805,
-0.1716851294,
-0.7763339877,
0.4081004858,
-0.1895798445,
0.5975456834,
0.4072655737,
0.209011212,
0.4443022609,
-0.38499856,
0.8173530698,
0.2013199031,
-1.0100609064,
0.4475675523,
-0.269649744,
0.0060091843,
0.0425223894,
0.2753489017,
-0.6623654366,
-0.3854989111,
-0.5727017522,
-0.5197886825,
0.7577987909,
0.1483065039,
0.319914639,
0.1192178875,
0.2010484338,
0.4607940614,
0.2145185173,
-0.9704713225,
-0.1618255228,
0.2622594237,
-0.1739397645,
0.1471502036,
-0.4889528751,
-0.0172892772,
-0.1208669692,
0.9016208053,
0.1194183156,
0.1804856062,
-0.5518085957,
-0.2205843329,
-0.1442125142,
0.4601933956,
0.443513453,
0.4457735121,
0.1687617302,
0.1557545066,
0.0175393298,
-0.5315895081,
0.2418545038,
0.0711625442,
-0.1946466565,
0.1647050828,
0.4218214452,
0.4964087009,
0.2348220795,
-0.6990852952,
0.6968553662,
0.148974359,
-0.0035483106,
-0.533041656,
0.1792950779,
-0.0746723488,
0.2713361979,
0.6144009829,
-0.2559303045,
0.0919834077,
-0.2953463197,
0.2164526135,
0.7536201477,
0.0345756039,
-0.2757976055,
0.4215411246,
0.3423341215,
-0.6891332269,
0.7118425369,
0.1018408462,
-0.6721027493,
0.6836003661,
0.900652945,
0.81285429,
-0.6561621428,
0.2096665502,
-0.0220406335,
0.5698385239,
-0.3442738056,
0.2257657945,
0.0906316042,
-0.8012911677,
0.0524083078,
-0.5114514828,
-0.37694785,
0.8351870179,
-0.554779768,
0.667907238,
-0.4054422379,
0.0173820984,
0.4107308984,
-0.2117908001,
-0.6032525301,
-0.1275471449,
0.05569157,
1.1735568047,
-0.8374634981,
0.841832459,
0.4903688431,
0.1929163486,
-0.1261027306,
0.2462179512,
0.1925898194,
-0.6090419888,
0.6611446142,
0.4697890878,
0.0021763463,
-0.1306985468,
-0.6463719606,
-0.6662272811,
0.866230011,
0.3672894239,
-0.6632879972,
0.1626229733,
0.3388415873,
0.675164938,
-0.3220527768,
0.0818862095,
0.5063218474,
0.4656739831,
-0.0557679459,
-0.6776470542,
-0.2419049889,
-0.2965620756,
0.2200840712,
0.6598299146,
-0.2372249663,
1.0641069412,
0.2647639513,
-0.0109996982,
-0.0123716155,
0.4880688488,
0.1026843563,
0.1658468544,
0.2703266442,
0.577839911,
0.768273294,
-0.025599435,
0.565181911,
-0.4130474031,
0.3727691174,
0.7696124911,
-0.636628747,
0.6083363295,
0.3677041233,
-0.2012238055,
0.5218499899,
0.6149781942,
-0.3100709617,
0.4089615345,
0.588768959,
-0.6366835237,
-0.2529905736,
0.0657492504,
-0.2157638073,
0.455922395,
0.6986742616,
-0.4819433093,
-0.3627485633,
0.3945149779,
0.0345113575,
0.1383633465,
-0.5532208085,
0.6308842301,
-0.1962445229,
-0.4834949374,
0.5698456764,
0.4671210051,
1.0705747604,
-0.532258749,
0.2312201858,
-0.0023653263,
0.4942087829,
0.0783095956,
-0.5628134608,
0.1757154465,
0.232879445,
-0.1613768339,
-0.2103939056,
1.2261304855,
-0.3464542925,
-0.3963166475,
0.2656850815,
0.0358939022,
0.1428683996,
-0.1626796424,
-0.6467654109,
0.2485850006,
-0.2082308531,
-0.0252151173,
0.3157483339,
0.261959821,
0.080238089,
1.0271054506,
0.7432224154,
-0.2185534686,
-0.151789248,
-0.0290858597,
0.7514138818,
-0.2982923687,
-0.7346843481,
-1.1677035093,
0.3396919668,
-0.4726582766,
0.1897722036,
0.6119816899,
0.5123097897,
0.7467021942,
-0.2042337358,
0.7870579958,
0.3070328236,
0.682823956,
-0.3177405,
0.4742092788,
-0.1630731523,
0.6480548382,
-0.2198887467,
-0.9564036131,
-0.3375692666,
0.4406039417,
-0.1704624891,
-0.1046749651,
0.4506624341,
0.6767813563,
-0.1654248387,
0.3482230902,
0.3068356514,
0.0729539916,
0.5949298739,
0.4274536669,
0.7022333741,
-0.4251584411,
0.3891560137,
-0.1271780878,
-0.3427214921,
-0.7856362462,
-0.7935875654,
-1.4366385937,
-0.4773391187,
-0.176392585,
-0.3594124317,
0.0035024215,
0.9207079411,
0.6790691018,
-1.0116958618,
-0.1728471071,
-0.1159554198,
0.0392715745,
0.0778066516,
-0.2490390539,
-0.0488060378,
-0.2413372695,
-0.59973526,
0.119828701,
0.779858768,
0.393145442,
-0.5621180534,
0.1867964268,
-0.0720946491,
0.59478724,
0.7462080717,
0.0273881909,
-0.9398707151,
-0.2405603677,
0.1455700248,
-0.309056133,
-0.1009412631,
0.9559818506,
-0.5412274003,
0.0209575463,
0.467119962,
0.8832810521,
0.354588896,
-0.400326103,
0.3983778059,
-0.3732735813,
0.0258278139,
0.3937695324,
0.3572695255,
0.2790412903,
-0.5578536391,
0.3180930614,
0.0546717085,
-0.4292910993,
-1.0004202127,
0.3688973784,
-0.559487462,
-0.5548225641,
0.9670524597,
-0.1396028996,
0.0294473935,
-0.3375825286,
-0.061217308,
-0.0731902495,
-0.3166324496,
1.4058197737,
0.8809109926,
0.1759838313,
-0.1813490838,
-0.0631507561,
0.2691916823,
0.3129091859,
-1.2212435007,
0.1878391653,
0.3234548867,
0.4076915383,
0.0368593596,
0.5713720918,
0.0215816982,
0.3766795099,
-0.5888115168,
-0.049922213,
0.2933144569,
-0.5259888172,
-0.3927318752,
0.2674002945,
-0.3409841955,
0.0154665923
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04911v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04911v1
|
From Text to Structure: Using Large Language Models to Support the Development of Legal Expert Systems
| 2023-11-01T18:31:02 | 2023-11-01T18:31:02 |
Samyar Janatian, Hannes Westermann, Jinzhe Tan, Jaromir Savelka, Karim Benyekhlef
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
Encoding legislative text in a formal representation is an important
prerequisite to different tasks in the field of AI & Law. For example,
rule-based expert systems focused on legislation can support laypeople in
understanding how legislation applies to them and provide them with helpful
context and information. However, the process of analyzing legislation and
other sources to encode it in the desired formal representation can be
time-consuming and represents a bottleneck in the development of such systems.
Here, we investigate to what degree large language models (LLMs), such as
GPT-4, are able to automatically extract structured representations from
legislation. We use LLMs to create pathways from legislation, according to the
JusticeBot methodology for legal decision support systems, evaluate the
pathways and compare them to manually created pathways. The results are
promising, with 60% of generated pathways being rated as equivalent or better
than manually created ones in a blind comparison. The approach suggests a
promising path to leverage the capabilities of LLMs to ease the costly
development of systems based on symbolic approaches that are transparent and
explainable.
|
[
0.0450188816,
-0.6976122856,
1.0831241608,
0.0303340703,
-0.3222398162,
-0.1678080112,
-0.182906419,
-0.3572950959,
0.060786467,
0.8280984163,
-0.1815386415,
-0.3898219466,
-0.6254817843,
0.2401782572,
-0.3462255895,
0.83119452,
-0.0835453346,
0.0479824692,
0.1164648235,
0.2196314633,
-0.6456725001,
-0.6778904796,
-0.4343470335,
-0.4854891896,
0.3066689968,
-0.1940000653,
0.7318239808,
0.7838725448,
0.5313351154,
0.4152246714,
0.0283002388,
-0.1931549609,
-0.0826978609,
0.3186920583,
-0.1882954836,
-0.621172905,
-0.6251295209,
-0.0678135157,
0.5835475922,
0.4025401473,
-0.3642947078,
-0.2073207051,
-0.0598862879,
0.5134941339,
-0.3302422762,
0.7431184649,
-0.7210195661,
0.1388414949,
-0.2269245684,
-0.2742738724,
-0.5331852436,
-0.3538056314,
-0.0504746735,
-0.5686661601,
-0.0731253177,
0.0308404695,
0.5893241167,
0.4401245117,
-0.5017193556,
-0.5049612522,
-0.5934894085,
0.222733438,
-0.9451794624,
0.4188986123,
0.2492420822,
0.3814331591,
-0.4256193936,
-0.6370717287,
-0.4003781378,
-0.5775504112,
-0.2085620612,
-0.0064655431,
-0.1374291182,
0.3329683542,
0.3676509261,
-0.1524787992,
-0.5723599195,
0.1794773638,
-0.3066313565,
-0.3959565163,
0.7784000039,
0.145670414,
0.2028578967,
-0.5207666755,
0.2018690854,
0.1964442432,
-0.61221385,
-0.323774755,
0.4465625584,
0.491815865,
0.010000553,
0.8173440099,
0.0820929408,
0.5518050194,
-0.0184230879,
-0.0900226086,
0.1485751271,
-0.3637218773,
-0.3587141633,
0.1266532093,
1.0632932186,
-0.1277041435,
0.3714115024,
-0.1150262207,
-0.5760747194,
-0.1528692991,
0.4104783833,
-0.7609551549,
-0.1307710856,
0.2152706385,
-0.5414515734,
-0.0159397516,
0.0002560921,
-0.3790109158,
-0.5671941042,
-0.6893845201,
0.1479423493,
-0.3945646882,
-0.2067591399,
0.2013419122,
-0.1488292068,
0.2206557095,
0.571361959,
-0.8662443161,
0.2033620775,
0.724001348,
0.7905734181,
0.3244278729,
0.3411185741,
-0.5834089518,
0.4958726466,
-0.445699513,
0.7163748741,
-0.8258345723,
-0.2912612557,
0.150227502,
-0.0866843835,
0.1350966692,
-0.3535169959,
0.4983229637,
-0.5681029558,
-0.0559108928,
0.0114448201,
-0.6096098423,
-0.0820059627,
0.2893036306,
-0.8466849923,
0.5381365418,
0.1223678514,
-0.4422518015,
0.5364788771,
-0.9471423626,
-0.4850614369,
0.4354119599,
-0.7255976796,
-0.330293566,
0.0875832289,
0.283089608,
0.6668692231,
-0.1936500818,
0.7351058125,
-0.1222943515,
-0.0625411272,
-0.157136932,
-0.3119338453,
0.8751478791,
0.2167845815,
-0.4765172899,
0.3615914881,
-0.5347183943,
-0.3566528261,
0.0845758393,
-0.7149018645,
-0.3551968634,
0.1980059743,
-0.2180033028,
0.2402488887,
0.1947826445,
-0.206767872,
0.5133252144,
-0.3918873072,
0.7349862456,
0.9189339876,
-0.1264244318,
0.4140249491,
0.1686597466,
0.5811897516,
-0.1133336946,
-0.0516329072,
-0.2339841425,
-0.6400513053,
-0.5524687767,
-0.0587927066,
0.4311853945,
0.4654404521,
-0.8015255928,
0.5522235036,
-0.4397750497,
-0.2284655422,
-0.4977077842,
0.0653791204,
0.2552907467,
0.2160497606,
0.2033995986,
-0.2513971329,
-0.3899912238,
-0.9400474429,
-0.2154855579,
-0.5539742112,
-0.0682284534,
0.1720276475,
0.9157873988,
-0.2237774432,
0.8801191449,
-0.1480395645,
-0.1372845918,
-0.2118828446,
0.1262716949,
0.2505670488,
0.1749353111,
0.4345764518,
-0.8285127878,
-0.2080107331,
0.2355018407,
-0.8898150921,
-0.1629713327,
-0.1954741776,
-0.0845174864,
0.1445147544,
0.6338490248,
-0.7436007261,
0.4884183407,
-0.0792308226,
-0.550563693,
0.7184938788,
-0.4081129432,
0.0703558102,
-0.9314517975,
0.0545061305,
0.234950006,
-0.4098270237,
-0.5783117414,
0.2544703782,
0.1350150257,
-0.0212337244,
-0.1788287014,
0.357378453,
-0.5805585384,
-0.3335344493,
-0.0506532528,
0.1946664751,
-0.169509232,
0.4629769623,
0.0504555665,
0.6295639277,
0.2986128628,
-0.3275292516,
0.3966213465,
0.3229367733,
-0.2270676196,
0.582498908,
-0.6068263054,
0.0592294931,
-0.0461956412,
0.4115217924,
-0.3731185496,
-0.5025671721,
0.5347352624,
-0.0660437867,
0.4233590662,
-0.5096002817,
-0.8912320733,
-0.4347389936,
0.1332205087,
0.1159634963,
0.454508692,
0.3173954487,
0.9258216619,
0.7185307741,
-0.465703547,
-0.4286250472,
-0.707208097,
0.5173665285,
-0.1340317428,
-0.5209515095,
0.241701141,
0.1776681691,
-0.568480134,
0.1249017715,
0.1834000498,
-0.0252573304,
0.0386233293,
0.2934193313,
0.0695001036,
-0.3995684385,
0.3491342068,
0.161486432,
0.032263618,
0.4526270628,
-0.45638901,
0.4157920182,
0.1571179479,
-0.4941117764,
-0.5398450494,
0.4588481784,
0.6269358397,
-0.3476089835,
0.4021930397,
0.1264743656,
-0.2717216015,
-0.1616238952,
-0.5078748465,
0.0010959307,
-0.4835221469,
0.469292134,
-0.4799766541,
-0.917606473,
0.3686986864,
0.0659398884,
0.3466766775,
0.6351873875,
0.792114675,
0.3202538192,
0.9080537558,
0.7615376115,
-0.1100802124,
0.3898580074,
0.0772936791,
0.1643742174,
-0.3167580366,
-0.4776251912,
-0.7433850169,
0.1415001005,
-0.4694928229,
-0.5105413198,
0.386441946,
-0.2787314951,
-0.4183710814,
0.4499301016,
-0.4876060784,
0.1929005682,
0.6200267673,
0.0672507733,
0.3280009329,
0.083231248,
-0.1356987357,
0.4573705196,
-0.7106838226,
-0.8159546256,
1.0556868315,
0.5579814315,
0.5730874538,
0.0002503899,
0.7055907845,
0.4768028855,
0.2551851273,
-0.9318506122,
0.807579577,
-0.0515784957,
-0.5042130351,
-0.4778041244,
-0.5190732479,
-0.8019778132,
0.043954093,
-0.3397734463,
-0.3633061647,
0.1483222991,
-0.0940338522,
-0.4643901885,
0.1971256286,
-0.4827760458,
0.500626862,
-0.2038467228,
-0.2583450675,
-0.2125745565,
-0.7594957948,
0.1334054768,
-0.4333142638,
0.3958987296,
0.0054759155,
0.017530743,
1.1060619354,
-0.7267881036,
0.8078263998,
-0.2662596703,
-0.6142839789,
0.3912769854,
0.1301948726,
0.6808201075,
-0.2535834908,
-0.4554387927,
0.0216820091,
-0.2676350772,
-0.1064698324,
-0.7142617106,
0.267623961,
-0.5785139203,
-0.9085835218,
-0.2043053806,
-0.6562691331,
0.0100289909,
0.3763943315,
-0.3572584689,
0.4781062603,
0.1664607972,
0.0361164324,
0.3361424506,
-0.0180448182,
0.4876175523,
0.5573992729,
0.0620062388,
-0.1489585936,
0.3641578555,
0.3668242097,
-0.2890777588,
0.3932815194,
0.130146414,
-0.5200374722,
-0.9343678951,
-0.4043557048,
0.3278652132,
-0.867469728,
-0.1407680511,
-0.5738911629,
-0.2350548059,
-0.6161674857,
0.0233878735,
0.023546638,
-0.2834121287,
-0.1471902579,
-0.1878229827,
0.26626876,
1.2249276638,
0.0904366076,
0.1343133152,
-0.7817414403,
0.1180125177,
0.1657779366,
0.2979494333,
-0.2862509191,
-0.595199883,
-0.2071149498,
-0.1246225089,
-0.2374144942,
-0.9274486303,
0.2921802402,
-0.1462965757,
0.6990351677,
0.4341420531,
-0.1626577079,
0.588404119,
-1.0732370615,
0.7461165786,
0.1509599537,
-0.9548843503,
0.6969740987,
-0.5850201249,
-0.126795277,
0.243605718,
0.2865447402,
0.0166249629,
-0.6380978823,
-0.3144901693,
-0.7468233109,
0.5253737569,
0.4591585994,
0.2731710672,
0.1467704922,
0.5839115977,
0.1393121183,
0.1730336696,
-0.9226307273,
0.2849406898,
-0.1667228788,
-0.3778387904,
0.1099037305,
-0.2303363383,
-0.1215692982,
0.0833837539,
0.3710313141,
-0.1055982932,
0.2684543729,
0.1363730431,
-0.0981441364,
0.0517925173,
0.5418636799,
0.4455337524,
0.7045944929,
0.0437269472,
0.0727571175,
-0.2925404608,
-0.4246661067,
0.384013027,
0.2077132165,
-0.0953613967,
-0.0284980349,
0.7594035864,
0.8567889333,
-0.0664558634,
-0.5217003226,
0.4369950891,
0.318433851,
-0.4229642153,
-0.2074539661,
0.1908655316,
-0.0228997301,
0.5691868663,
0.437277019,
-0.2169773281,
0.2592369616,
-0.763645649,
0.3451551199,
0.4056821764,
-0.2573100626,
-0.2131892145,
0.7275037169,
0.3771843016,
-0.4382950962,
0.5026613474,
-0.0383972526,
-0.3869005442,
0.5771338344,
0.3656955361,
0.8361684084,
-0.1289640069,
0.2074713409,
0.1507554352,
0.4521319866,
-0.414639622,
0.072649546,
0.1136071309,
-0.2927974761,
-0.6948511004,
-0.6015591025,
-0.1547350287,
-0.0356565416,
-0.2721924186,
0.2008274496,
-0.3628519475,
-0.3988445997,
-0.0550861023,
-0.1854169816,
-0.6644171476,
-0.0047216141,
0.1721102595,
0.8231452703,
-0.8719193935,
0.7440333366,
0.5317835212,
-0.6677587628,
-0.9760489464,
-0.0301525071,
-0.0638387874,
-0.6486751437,
0.7773002386,
0.0220459066,
0.0612052679,
-0.2250968069,
-0.6245954633,
-0.3948621154,
0.9785829186,
0.6288071275,
-1.0208699703,
-0.659965694,
0.3424663842,
0.6094107628,
-0.3247254789,
0.4198042452,
0.6395113468,
0.7526624799,
-0.1275682747,
-0.988871932,
0.4935232103,
-0.335354656,
-0.0679121166,
0.2136493921,
-0.1189214736,
0.8373817205,
0.0044762008,
-0.1923230141,
-0.1270904839,
0.5117314458,
0.1809325516,
0.0237324331,
0.4023818374,
0.2723804116,
0.7427347898,
-0.0473065041,
1.1413818598,
-0.2878758907,
0.0487882122,
0.8835515976,
-0.31973809,
0.6797379851,
0.3908004165,
-0.1235148981,
0.8102792501,
0.5610108972,
-0.2349873781,
0.2730141282,
0.3524632156,
0.1214267686,
-0.4241908491,
0.0376643576,
-0.1591887772,
0.2348656356,
0.4261648059,
-0.5498687029,
-0.1978595406,
-0.1236530021,
-0.0686474741,
-0.0098976437,
-0.6715120077,
0.8946392536,
0.1990760714,
-0.6050822139,
0.1880466491,
0.1067533121,
0.2045389414,
-0.6767994165,
-0.3804448247,
-0.0236559492,
-0.346069932,
-0.1710162014,
-1.1145445108,
0.1398428828,
0.2096606493,
0.0870563835,
-0.2381005138,
0.6499919295,
-0.2938292325,
-0.5171698332,
0.2735453844,
0.5040507317,
0.3449755907,
-0.0882724896,
-0.8411744237,
-0.1006872803,
-0.2065999657,
-0.3113878667,
-0.0552807041,
0.8393706679,
-0.4880842566,
0.6864737868,
0.4274416864,
0.2919363081,
-0.0185421836,
0.2261868715,
0.9160262346,
-0.7309553623,
-0.7395552993,
-1.1402318478,
0.7125152946,
-0.0714373216,
0.2076849192,
0.500711441,
0.3834387064,
0.4032766819,
0.0880417079,
1.0584115982,
-0.0347105488,
-0.1984997094,
-1.0110846758,
0.8264347911,
-0.4743919075,
0.3567457199,
-0.425940305,
-0.8448144794,
-0.4097582102,
0.4095502794,
-0.436786294,
0.0423768833,
0.5229949355,
0.7489916086,
-0.1913842112,
-0.3742905259,
0.247240752,
0.372312963,
0.6346774101,
0.4266101718,
0.5824777484,
0.0264023561,
0.6563305259,
0.5121587515,
-0.0968185812,
-0.2838210762,
-0.7577582598,
-0.9724508524,
-0.4613431692,
-0.1607753336,
-0.1869206429,
0.1709192246,
0.8190819621,
0.6372537017,
-0.5889952779,
-0.2722777426,
-0.315536052,
-0.0656808838,
0.3771745861,
-0.1373727471,
0.5904629827,
-0.4172466397,
-0.4739382267,
0.3902040124,
0.4408147335,
-0.0211448614,
-0.4757021368,
-0.0829659998,
0.0387950316,
0.2572220266,
0.6762528419,
-0.1147182658,
-0.9361978769,
-0.3160037398,
-0.3784671128,
-0.269689858,
0.1693419367,
1.0756276846,
-0.5883120298,
0.4159319103,
0.560408771,
0.5863053799,
0.1835314631,
-0.1255319566,
0.9709255099,
-0.3467670083,
0.0851268619,
0.3015009463,
0.6925058365,
0.1158287153,
-0.2215570658,
0.643545568,
0.1035444736,
-0.4248431623,
-0.6181801558,
0.2564372122,
-0.7143982053,
-0.5213326216,
1.180883646,
-0.2418715954,
-0.3227659166,
-0.4858051538,
-0.2431283593,
0.3456833065,
-0.5380803347,
0.5745654702,
0.5151993632,
0.0372139178,
0.0017474932,
-0.7969115973,
0.3737889528,
-0.1878327876,
-0.9131280184,
0.0754495636,
0.6975907683,
0.2146035582,
0.264098376,
0.9333526492,
-0.2174959779,
-0.0389443561,
0.0402197428,
0.1019545719,
-0.199824959,
-0.31277439,
-0.3068804741,
0.3914100528,
-0.1233244166,
0.4628176093
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00768v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00768v2
|
Language Model Training Paradigms for Clinical Feature Embeddings
| 2023-11-01T18:23:12 | 2024-02-06T16:33:48 |
Yurong Hu, Manuel Burger, Gunnar Rätsch, Rita Kuznetsova
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
In research areas with scarce data, representation learning plays a
significant role. This work aims to enhance representation learning for
clinical time series by deriving universal embeddings for clinical features,
such as heart rate and blood pressure. We use self-supervised training
paradigms for language models to learn high-quality clinical feature
embeddings, achieving a finer granularity than existing time-step and
patient-level representation learning. We visualize the learnt embeddings via
unsupervised dimension reduction techniques and observe a high degree of
consistency with prior clinical knowledge. We also evaluate the model
performance on the MIMIC-III benchmark and demonstrate the effectiveness of
using clinical feature embeddings. We publish our code online for replication.
|
[
0.0062185302,
-0.2791272104,
0.7689886689,
0.2837992311,
-0.4127925932,
-0.0251160935,
-0.0074178637,
-0.3735918403,
0.4418129623,
0.6068413258,
-0.1053809896,
-0.6821733117,
-0.688967824,
-0.1357700676,
-0.0471047014,
0.8174351454,
-0.3616102934,
0.7886592746,
-0.0911191553,
-0.3214102685,
-0.181027025,
-0.8670417666,
-0.2197470516,
-0.6061971188,
0.3031607568,
-0.0218505375,
0.4819616675,
1.1557787657,
0.6327514648,
0.0739609003,
0.4967635572,
-0.1233615279,
-0.2705648839,
0.2945472002,
0.3705594242,
-0.1671649665,
-0.6704618335,
0.0176898651,
0.8712797165,
0.9619480968,
-0.3138152957,
0.1172666177,
0.0756177828,
0.3318280578,
-0.3638572395,
0.8021125793,
-0.0209056623,
0.3466262817,
0.0073622623,
-0.5298751593,
-0.2179409117,
-0.2670233846,
0.3610228598,
-0.4657537639,
0.5072299838,
0.0324566439,
0.4244997799,
0.2261583805,
-0.4652461112,
-0.1267470121,
-0.7868492603,
0.4901547432,
-0.4412869215,
0.5373491645,
0.3093573451,
0.4728868902,
0.3319268525,
-0.7659010291,
-0.0362885408,
-0.2350932658,
-0.1345501691,
-0.0182890091,
-0.0282075889,
0.1437195837,
0.1559004188,
0.3607141376,
-0.5502904058,
-0.037694484,
-0.3048867285,
-0.2264998406,
0.5619258881,
0.4023606181,
-0.0210691392,
-0.1455922276,
-0.2645099163,
-0.2859639823,
-0.5920683146,
-0.1166002676,
-0.05452393,
0.3315398693,
-0.4737761915,
0.2004214376,
0.198401913,
0.2936703265,
-0.2506510913,
-0.2915144563,
0.7077691555,
0.1849811375,
-0.2445065379,
0.0399733856,
0.5623249412,
0.1514042467,
0.1564489156,
-0.1332319826,
-0.1051728204,
0.1705330163,
0.5752781034,
-0.7573174238,
-0.3173596561,
0.0716397241,
-0.6593431234,
-0.3830347061,
-0.0170583278,
-0.4990483224,
-0.3237847686,
-0.4219035208,
0.3742083311,
-0.4291864932,
-0.4141168296,
0.1163508072,
-0.0881607234,
-0.0962688848,
0.3381718397,
-0.8719423413,
0.5251818299,
0.3145597577,
0.8315352201,
-0.0545922369,
-0.0923602283,
-0.1880176365,
0.3724098504,
-0.384644419,
0.4441443384,
-0.5205235481,
-0.6270874739,
0.2395242602,
0.1160858646,
0.1229007989,
-0.6164434552,
0.0443724878,
-0.1015720963,
-0.12176162,
-0.0938970819,
-0.8430776596,
-0.0035616036,
0.004372417,
-0.5115240216,
0.7050923705,
0.4059391916,
-0.4234172106,
0.3292444944,
-0.5296663642,
-0.4076909721,
-0.0744468048,
-0.4786344171,
-0.7601140738,
0.1609573811,
0.5122528672,
0.9580308199,
0.0838410258,
0.1772446632,
-0.5790194869,
-0.0988033563,
-0.0745850503,
-0.1568470299,
0.1442236304,
0.2498939335,
-0.0988541022,
0.0407474004,
-0.808318913,
-0.0907007903,
0.3522313237,
0.1288167536,
-0.3030020595,
-0.2068061084,
0.4409665167,
-0.1394419968,
0.0033169617,
-0.7087088823,
0.3486280441,
-0.0618865862,
0.628681004,
0.3544564545,
0.545009017,
0.1413861662,
-0.4661746025,
0.5644696951,
0.2523644865,
0.435318917,
0.0021865959,
-0.2518230975,
-0.3711966872,
-0.3141103983,
0.0174513385,
0.2881820202,
-0.330480814,
0.1017775014,
-0.3070637584,
-0.411375463,
-0.7983638644,
0.1660488248,
0.5165783167,
0.3962299824,
0.6928092241,
-0.4085407555,
-0.404558301,
-0.8567712903,
0.0460244194,
-0.1471921355,
-0.0317363404,
0.150964871,
0.4950269163,
-0.3554620743,
0.4780697823,
-0.5879716873,
-0.3784856498,
-0.3064658046,
0.3568356335,
-0.1398480088,
0.802426219,
0.6284233332,
-0.3674989045,
-0.2561295927,
-0.2452780455,
-0.8803762794,
0.1921316534,
0.0501118451,
0.2936659455,
0.063678965,
0.6855114102,
0.1427690983,
0.609644413,
0.6638228893,
-0.0858837962,
0.1643091589,
-0.6954361796,
0.0667487085,
-1.1339764595,
0.0439663269,
0.1044988781,
-0.6083039045,
-0.5939193368,
-0.0851652697,
0.3146839142,
-0.4059939384,
-0.1729531288,
0.7241030335,
-0.5638170838,
0.0013002265,
-0.172997728,
-0.1768514514,
-0.098388359,
0.422986865,
0.4828321636,
0.1860176325,
0.6488847136,
-0.3514772952,
0.0120537877,
0.1168245524,
-0.2617611885,
0.3985705376,
-0.8872212768,
-0.0992377624,
-0.2170509845,
0.1105391979,
-0.5421807766,
-0.3228386641,
-0.1974903941,
-0.3798334897,
0.695397675,
-0.2738586962,
-0.4943155944,
-0.3141300976,
-0.1026550755,
0.2933391333,
0.7676694989,
-0.3294884861,
0.2762055397,
0.7210358977,
0.1291442662,
-0.2465527207,
-0.6864377856,
-0.6057053804,
0.023944756,
-0.0833105519,
0.4065368772,
0.331682831,
0.0608933009,
0.0544287786,
-0.0102178203,
-0.0250499956,
-0.1522180736,
0.5736649036,
0.1129944101,
-0.1558784246,
0.5974754095,
-0.0491630659,
-0.2671893835,
0.0470893569,
0.0129215186,
0.6240246296,
-0.0013093645,
-0.7245257497,
-0.6900229454,
0.4981664121,
0.4139366448,
-0.1313367486,
0.65364182,
0.8195540905,
-0.6808887124,
-0.1699278355,
-0.4788040519,
-0.3082968891,
-0.3848203123,
0.5231682062,
-0.074970983,
-1.0909389257,
0.4463405609,
0.0386338308,
-0.1671269089,
0.275924623,
0.5865117908,
-0.2961282432,
1.2949928045,
0.8257039189,
-0.1347510964,
0.4140761793,
-0.4746898413,
-0.1388008296,
-0.9416928291,
-0.2921103835,
-0.1636341959,
-0.0395687446,
-0.5322870612,
-0.6587801576,
0.8947029114,
0.0165243894,
-0.605012238,
-0.1043168977,
-0.4554713964,
-0.0518322326,
0.1702256799,
0.676998198,
0.0852557793,
0.1456807405,
-0.3468204439,
-0.2946461439,
-0.5058225393,
-0.3336749077,
1.4772462845,
0.7816983461,
0.9681332707,
-0.2590696216,
0.8795387149,
0.5442066789,
0.6661163568,
-0.4335290194,
-0.0706309825,
0.0673717558,
-0.4216815233,
-0.1336881369,
-0.2879573703,
-0.9810855985,
-0.1296188086,
-0.4024626315,
-0.3935602009,
0.058565516,
0.5132544041,
-0.5220118761,
0.3859060109,
-0.487264961,
1.0074481964,
0.0812609643,
0.0389621966,
-0.3800706863,
-0.5131649971,
-0.1605960727,
0.1636692435,
0.0219032355,
-0.0801440477,
-0.0559991822,
0.4880149066,
-0.643322587,
1.1557158232,
-0.2994267642,
0.3200146258,
0.0528463647,
0.2195203304,
0.1203834265,
0.3822491169,
0.4214174151,
0.3561960757,
0.3119261861,
-0.764821589,
-0.7611737847,
0.4436833262,
-1.0088255405,
-0.3278432786,
-0.6500014067,
-0.4323858917,
-0.5937703848,
-0.3162823617,
0.173687607,
1.0510853529,
-0.4971742034,
0.0780519992,
0.5182572007,
0.0927416682,
0.2239060402,
0.4192766547,
-0.3694096804,
-0.5779483914,
0.6433677673,
0.0540790781,
0.4343632162,
0.5117855072,
0.2134063095,
-0.2982337773,
-0.5814576149,
-0.0989833847,
0.6338325739,
-0.6310506463,
0.1985927522,
-0.6962280273,
-0.4342915416,
-0.7301129699,
-0.0707390904,
-0.356292069,
-0.3736466169,
-0.2537832558,
-0.0603252575,
0.5143588781,
1.021270752,
-0.2259568125,
0.6056932211,
-0.8281508684,
0.0083313845,
0.3654376864,
0.3720193505,
0.0309113003,
-0.554054141,
-0.4017204642,
-0.4951049685,
-0.3584782481,
-0.7460955381,
0.5503166318,
0.0967222378,
0.5890740156,
0.4937800467,
-0.2731262445,
0.7209790945,
-0.6616510749,
0.564170599,
0.1838798076,
-0.8886224627,
0.7388137579,
-0.2916401625,
0.1267683953,
0.2609493732,
0.7927375436,
-0.6487724781,
-0.1497490108,
-0.980032742,
-0.1839947701,
0.0835312158,
0.0965864882,
-0.1228675619,
-0.0150910784,
0.6316754222,
0.1909048557,
0.2796381712,
-0.5002841949,
-0.4522028267,
-0.4015173614,
-0.3679921627,
-0.4800708294,
-0.0749429688,
-0.0890727937,
-0.5154101849,
0.3740555644,
-0.3164553642,
0.5502151847,
0.6296190023,
0.0400646776,
-0.1542771608,
0.0284828842,
0.2750408649,
0.603066504,
-0.4005122781,
0.0127009219,
-0.1297325194,
-0.5966514945,
0.000760923,
0.0730104074,
0.22272861,
0.1011144817,
0.9787413478,
0.893093586,
0.2174520046,
-0.3349794447,
0.7491414547,
-0.0108382916,
0.1183938012,
-0.5483458042,
-0.0732271671,
-0.0253023561,
0.1670435816,
-0.1195775345,
0.0230257865,
0.0009565924,
-0.6117228866,
0.342500627,
0.1577394456,
-0.8658493757,
-0.5010626316,
0.6923782229,
0.0739093348,
0.0515851565,
0.3990060985,
0.0560341217,
-0.3503721654,
0.3756490946,
0.5593006015,
0.5943752527,
-0.541739285,
0.439232856,
0.5274089575,
0.1603040993,
-0.298150301,
0.6630671024,
0.0282311849,
-0.5665182471,
-0.1681268215,
-0.5117536783,
-0.5748404264,
0.119003512,
-1.1653106213,
0.2845426202,
-0.8690547347,
-0.3219152391,
-0.049910076,
-0.1609490514,
-1.0393130779,
0.1351165026,
0.310507983,
0.6912053823,
-1.0119210482,
1.165702343,
0.6656489372,
-0.6253615022,
-0.733363986,
-0.2278510779,
0.2157039344,
-1.2365959883,
0.5784717798,
-0.0190187916,
0.3553293943,
-0.1722150445,
-0.5520880818,
-0.6860567331,
1.0032615662,
0.1838412881,
-0.5014163852,
-0.1667456478,
0.2788384557,
0.9818788767,
-0.8929361105,
0.2552508414,
0.4016006589,
-0.2140021324,
-0.3593979478,
-1.0036293268,
0.0155393109,
-0.117559284,
0.2414368093,
0.0902723521,
-0.521808207,
0.7228984833,
-0.3761089146,
-0.0680632964,
-0.0425212607,
0.5114601851,
0.1733821779,
0.0503449105,
0.2708782852,
0.6674653888,
0.5623937249,
-0.095261611,
1.2533476353,
-0.4993506372,
0.6448538303,
0.9952006936,
-0.2365254909,
0.8544268012,
0.3381734788,
-0.2161488086,
0.7272184491,
0.4122443795,
0.0769598186,
0.5371769071,
0.0900211483,
-0.035541214,
-0.7017350197,
-0.0253818966,
-0.7384207249,
0.3342560828,
0.6496525407,
-0.775062263,
-0.2266806215,
0.3775507212,
0.0027388746,
0.0784535855,
-0.2288880944,
0.4836726189,
0.3300488889,
-0.01558166,
0.651204586,
-0.5719745755,
0.0695772022,
-0.9177978635,
-0.4433274269,
-0.0445096791,
0.3201191723,
0.2574746311,
-0.6468393207,
0.0742717534,
-0.4877850115,
-0.1692679822,
-0.451400578,
0.1239963993,
-0.4243775308,
-0.4622224867,
0.4451926947,
0.585670352,
0.1689179391,
0.0095392289,
-0.6558889747,
-0.0331618786,
-0.2337203026,
0.0486028567,
0.2693122625,
0.4092229605,
-0.0253545307,
0.8331965804,
0.2753011584,
0.6726741791,
-0.2179487795,
0.5502476692,
0.684302032,
-0.7454581261,
-0.709148407,
-0.4875613153,
-0.0446954332,
-0.0270750858,
-0.5294227004,
0.3689977527,
0.3290016055,
0.7787286639,
-0.2274064571,
0.6135267019,
0.4121639729,
0.9316726923,
-0.5642223954,
0.6286447048,
-0.6911064386,
0.0231431965,
-0.1687787622,
-0.51415205,
-0.4870918393,
0.4611417949,
-0.1481502205,
-0.0534366444,
0.8283340931,
0.4987595081,
-0.0041546444,
0.0338922329,
0.4891126156,
0.1491875648,
0.377738893,
0.5355753303,
0.3663542867,
-0.4217216671,
-0.0272755306,
-0.7411524653,
-0.2878252566,
-0.2448404282,
-0.7921135426,
-1.2592796087,
-0.7184126377,
-0.4729762077,
-0.4011175931,
-0.0262011029,
1.2741830349,
1.005413413,
-0.9670647979,
-0.1214346662,
0.4870411158,
-0.4179506302,
-0.4441725612,
-0.1137494668,
0.9155395627,
-0.3268659115,
-0.3141067028,
0.0901973993,
0.3480884135,
0.4789611697,
-0.5973886251,
-0.0580912232,
0.4634772241,
-0.5114723444,
0.3114675283,
0.4045753181,
-0.6315916777,
-0.3212692738,
-0.1313726902,
-0.2263839692,
0.3922447562,
1.3133916855,
-0.8642506003,
0.6459364891,
0.2031621784,
0.4444641173,
0.6578649879,
-0.1568008661,
0.4317732751,
-0.7276571989,
0.3478288054,
0.4777347445,
0.7694929838,
0.4581110179,
-0.2219419479,
0.4501246512,
0.5695037842,
-0.5242859125,
-0.7064211965,
0.0315112099,
-0.9852063656,
-0.0038109506,
0.8448383808,
-0.2356607616,
-0.2972047329,
-0.2623250782,
0.2528733909,
0.3150908947,
-0.2773507237,
0.8434473872,
0.3207846284,
-0.6662915945,
-0.0888448805,
-0.7264533043,
0.6862593889,
0.1950774044,
-0.5681608319,
-0.1331913173,
0.126712054,
0.6040557623,
0.2358620912,
0.5986192226,
-0.6323571205,
0.1370505989,
0.019440731,
0.3155153692,
-0.0992356539,
-0.3678452373,
-0.5157215595,
0.03253657,
-0.0375153348,
-0.1047637165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00762v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00762v1
|
Challenges for Linguistically-Driven Computer-Based Sign Recognition from Continuous Signing for American Sign Language
| 2023-11-01T18:08:44 | 2023-11-01T18:08:44 |
Carol Neidle
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
There have been recent advances in computer-based recognition of isolated,
citation-form signs from video. There are many challenges for such a task, not
least the naturally occurring inter- and intra- signer synchronic variation in
sign production, including sociolinguistic variation in the realization of
certain signs. However, there are several significant factors that make
recognition of signs from continuous signing an even more difficult problem.
This article presents an overview of such challenges, based in part on findings
from a large corpus of linguistically annotated video data for American Sign
Language (ASL). Some linguistic regularities in the structure of signs that can
boost handshape and sign recognition are also discussed.
|
[
-0.1450212002,
-0.8347181082,
0.3948205113,
0.0488038026,
-0.2719222009,
0.6529018283,
-0.3186636269,
-0.9084355831,
0.4428979158,
0.4244370162,
-0.675568521,
-0.1329262704,
-1.1702580452,
0.4838443398,
-0.3588701785,
0.6785826087,
-0.6166962981,
-0.0097431587,
0.1219418943,
-0.4138848484,
-0.4728641808,
-0.7453649044,
-0.8030038476,
-0.3678199053,
-0.0069930241,
0.2821958661,
0.8465403914,
0.547903955,
0.7806279063,
0.323295027,
-0.0587537549,
-0.0463082455,
0.1126173139,
0.3932518065,
0.2972561717,
0.0920320451,
0.0142360562,
0.0284042545,
0.8941007853,
1.047342062,
0.5156866312,
0.1826426685,
-0.2807992995,
0.6162709594,
-0.4080246687,
0.0163078289,
-0.4788783193,
0.0971675813,
-0.6828917265,
0.1011079848,
-0.041951701,
-0.3789642751,
0.0785018876,
-0.3294090629,
0.3072194159,
-0.2318613231,
0.8694979548,
0.4829854965,
-0.5586149693,
-0.7543283701,
-0.933704257,
0.4226849079,
-0.4192495346,
0.7736757994,
0.448764503,
0.3084219694,
-0.1510352194,
-0.3068189919,
-0.480656743,
-0.3680445552,
0.0921779573,
-0.264144361,
0.1378002167,
0.08484108,
0.7992642522,
0.2873869538,
-0.5776749253,
0.2929688394,
-0.4182372391,
-0.5845881104,
0.9339051843,
0.1343540102,
0.5689062476,
-0.0145858889,
-0.1759229302,
-0.2452757657,
-0.6736062169,
0.2287122905,
0.1410916895,
0.2510119677,
-0.2474923879,
0.4902462363,
-0.339630425,
0.5990971923,
0.0073092962,
0.0338224769,
0.1640191823,
-0.228544727,
0.1081783921,
-0.0435346626,
0.721134603,
-0.0771246627,
0.4082047939,
0.3152944446,
-0.2844074368,
0.3742979467,
-0.5939926505,
-0.2969920635,
-0.2592553794,
0.2151329964,
-0.2771058083,
0.2847590148,
0.2695062757,
-0.3252452016,
-0.8799497485,
-0.6147429943,
0.3963124156,
-0.2208102196,
-0.2267010212,
-0.1367105693,
-0.2519345582,
0.3236814737,
0.6890377998,
-0.7068961859,
0.4212437868,
0.3699650168,
0.8160176873,
-0.2392677665,
0.022550473,
-0.5816425681,
-0.3142101765,
-0.0392813943,
0.6934015751,
-0.4166186452,
-0.2575866878,
0.276671499,
-0.1007783562,
0.0038152393,
-0.5821544528,
-0.0367101766,
-0.4033204913,
-0.2989145219,
-0.2569368184,
-0.4074835777,
0.1908801794,
0.0272656549,
-0.7135656476,
0.913819015,
-0.1533195078,
-0.0892693326,
0.5458225608,
-0.3096379936,
-0.7852684855,
0.3801471293,
-0.4714435935,
-0.3689190745,
0.0966143906,
-0.2782874405,
0.2406291068,
-0.0680685565,
-0.0028276776,
0.2722449005,
0.0090501774,
0.8087863326,
-0.4173949361,
1.1015001535,
0.2629196942,
-0.6302217841,
-0.1234823912,
-1.1675158739,
-0.2875228822,
-0.2316489369,
-0.3989256322,
-0.1458332986,
0.3008539379,
0.236226216,
0.3102647662,
0.4310918152,
-0.7033709288,
-0.0024869465,
0.219235152,
0.2075252682,
0.4387438893,
0.1002882943,
0.0941330791,
0.158100009,
0.5777181983,
-0.0600141101,
0.3669639826,
0.0198641717,
-0.6908094287,
-0.6692848206,
-0.268710345,
0.0334432125,
0.5894224048,
-0.6411812305,
0.371443361,
0.1079772562,
-0.2528907657,
-0.2579165697,
0.269099772,
0.6238586903,
0.2322634161,
0.2218354493,
-0.7506827116,
-0.5581390858,
-0.4521549642,
-0.1644158065,
-0.2856170237,
0.0635521933,
-0.085213244,
0.3888935149,
0.1906930804,
0.5088341236,
-0.3627533019,
-0.5105060935,
0.2465883046,
0.3989474773,
0.2753442824,
0.4385297298,
-0.0746409968,
-0.9341464639,
-1.1163851023,
0.2640950978,
-0.7899569869,
-0.5110104084,
-0.5827516317,
0.6251182556,
0.3366619051,
1.0801374912,
-0.4159990251,
0.4726752639,
0.4251190424,
-0.6744436622,
0.6668226123,
-0.3330046237,
0.2592849135,
-0.2129027545,
-0.3302659988,
-0.1753161997,
-0.2792377174,
-0.7752751112,
-0.0216789488,
-0.0633146241,
-0.3450268805,
-0.3327391148,
0.1884568334,
-1.135322094,
-0.276221931,
-0.3031049967,
0.1863197684,
-0.6085320711,
0.0468083248,
0.3617283702,
0.3369623125,
0.7276138663,
-0.5559912324,
0.4053719044,
0.1606328785,
-0.1544014663,
0.7031162977,
-0.3331312239,
0.3180235326,
-0.1491818428,
0.0955799446,
-0.8723586202,
-0.4546125829,
0.2030878514,
-0.4832182229,
0.5055221915,
0.1778144985,
-0.3949382007,
-0.2443355322,
-0.125646919,
0.5347223878,
0.5210617781,
-0.4396295547,
0.4457722008,
0.3495722115,
-0.0377116427,
-0.1952336729,
-0.380987972,
0.2816311419,
-0.1285825223,
-0.6065836549,
0.1558953524,
-0.2535288632,
-0.4673947096,
-0.4492460489,
0.069630973,
-0.3582618237,
0.2089925259,
0.5000476241,
0.0695717409,
0.041151382,
-0.2058069706,
-0.1564730555,
-0.0662570149,
0.0879288763,
-0.0311384238,
0.0675983652,
0.1417355239,
-0.4086906612,
-0.9316616654,
0.7662701607,
0.5614703894,
0.0736429542,
0.1609175354,
0.355956316,
-0.6285620332,
0.1909367144,
-0.5522648096,
-0.152049467,
-0.4217424691,
0.0799835399,
-0.3790713251,
-0.9133939743,
0.6929734349,
-0.0151036335,
0.0990992635,
0.062386591,
0.5435490608,
-0.1700942814,
0.9180343151,
0.2632116377,
0.2865915596,
0.8803247213,
0.348267287,
-0.1628908515,
-0.2877931297,
-0.1928627938,
-0.6364579797,
-0.3083872497,
-0.649317205,
-0.3439100087,
0.4278957248,
-0.1929418445,
0.0040659793,
0.7759477496,
-0.5253475308,
0.2908187807,
0.2748624384,
-0.0493188053,
0.6538715959,
-0.2259080708,
0.2495578229,
-0.2947915494,
-0.1290850788,
-0.3825625777,
0.6919388175,
0.3110919893,
0.4771836698,
0.4039140642,
0.665851593,
0.5638667941,
0.1440282017,
-0.6294873953,
0.6555570364,
-0.1063923687,
-0.72282058,
-0.27310884,
-0.2205265164,
-0.8906670809,
-0.1061632633,
-0.6301286817,
-0.9372057319,
0.1487575769,
0.4805296063,
-0.0482983589,
-0.3109076619,
-0.6449735761,
0.6059504747,
-0.3819621801,
-0.099167347,
-0.040626727,
-0.9550652504,
-0.0524693951,
-0.245126754,
0.5257433653,
-0.1846114993,
0.2504046261,
0.5691332221,
-0.6413952112,
0.8888756633,
-0.327070713,
0.0676248297,
0.4996938705,
-0.031742841,
0.5397815704,
-0.1875675321,
0.4052988291,
-0.0479961969,
0.1427755654,
-0.336498946,
-0.2801852822,
0.1924540848,
-0.6812641025,
-0.4969897568,
-0.6892747879,
-0.2897579968,
-0.1814257652,
0.0029886703,
0.5267096758,
0.4276012778,
-0.4032378495,
-0.1304019243,
0.5017215014,
-0.0798064247,
0.6331806183,
0.4474057853,
-0.0033904596,
-0.4637332559,
0.7469351888,
0.4371016026,
0.2175151259,
0.2981915176,
0.1112320498,
-0.3491283059,
-0.7385531664,
-0.304690659,
0.3379737139,
-0.7782402039,
-0.0313270427,
0.0183113534,
-0.0987448692,
-0.4057675004,
-0.3084310591,
-0.1235248968,
-0.7455947995,
-0.2427972853,
0.0553595386,
0.3574065566,
0.8479959369,
-0.3652618229,
0.3381357193,
-0.6465663314,
0.3417076468,
0.3677926958,
0.2248609066,
-0.4261580706,
-0.4021203518,
-0.256064415,
-0.3257659674,
-0.0643729493,
-0.9541391134,
-0.2142884433,
0.4277479351,
0.1430879384,
0.4761109948,
-0.0862121657,
0.4978749454,
-0.3770827949,
0.8475969434,
0.6220188141,
-1.040481329,
0.4751136303,
-0.4329875708,
0.3523165286,
0.6186516881,
0.4050390124,
-0.6115257144,
-0.3711948395,
-0.6096398234,
-0.8886569738,
0.322067976,
0.399163574,
0.0539245903,
-0.0121737709,
0.2914089859,
0.157871753,
-0.1764722764,
-0.9530203938,
-0.0844817683,
-0.1500600278,
-0.2199364901,
0.3385147154,
0.1968790442,
0.1866777837,
-0.3484743834,
0.4794779122,
0.0431156456,
-0.2054799497,
0.3277251422,
-0.692840457,
-0.1846506894,
0.1049920544,
0.782017231,
0.2653155029,
0.0580184609,
0.298637569,
0.105418995,
-0.7475324273,
0.2561397254,
0.2013962269,
-0.3652740717,
0.259257108,
0.4160810113,
0.7927979231,
0.0337747857,
-0.8530459404,
0.3634646833,
0.2826440036,
-0.3776970208,
-0.9783058763,
-0.1456186771,
-0.4475041628,
0.2789618969,
0.4390548766,
-0.1784891635,
-0.0261602104,
-0.5335105658,
-0.018034175,
0.5077233315,
-0.5180530548,
-0.720032692,
0.8562702537,
0.2270660847,
-0.6557645798,
0.3995850384,
-0.100732103,
-0.5278741121,
0.6061520576,
0.535250783,
0.8789256811,
-0.320795536,
0.0985116214,
0.2919163704,
0.040639434,
-0.1882114112,
0.4375831783,
-0.5332390666,
-0.5711846352,
-0.112824671,
-0.2688445449,
-0.8497704268,
-0.3282968402,
-0.3102292717,
0.5370584726,
-0.9482504129,
-0.405554831,
0.2902023494,
-0.1409806609,
-0.6575686336,
0.4246533215,
0.6539250016,
0.4553916454,
-1.2000079155,
0.5157567263,
0.9805715084,
-0.4863050878,
-0.4012826085,
-0.2986118495,
0.3333554864,
-0.3966832161,
0.7451005578,
0.1231345162,
-0.1500419974,
-0.0742431283,
-0.2781341374,
-0.8558063507,
0.6958972812,
0.0989960209,
-0.314864248,
0.0921456665,
0.4449438751,
0.6647395492,
-0.2882064283,
-0.1229093671,
0.6959080696,
0.4499423504,
0.080183737,
-1.0545332432,
0.2767138779,
0.0457644351,
-0.1380246729,
0.474744916,
-0.4823674262,
0.6128771305,
0.0998270735,
-0.5987440348,
-0.1253976375,
0.760416925,
0.4366744757,
0.6490685344,
0.604238987,
0.0290474184,
0.6855871677,
0.039977394,
0.4446582794,
0.0275938548,
0.1210703999,
0.6129615307,
-0.4102904499,
0.7686598897,
0.5808057785,
-0.5052245855,
0.6156270504,
0.4875606298,
-0.0093996534,
-0.1223609895,
0.206876725,
-0.7518048286,
-0.2093990147,
-0.0495945327,
0.0828371495,
0.6006916165,
0.6968846321,
-0.3785137832,
0.0441105813,
0.1210037842,
0.0509525426,
0.5623903275,
-0.2583887875,
0.6490199566,
0.2413589805,
-0.7516101599,
0.5408223867,
-0.5722492337,
0.6617746949,
-0.5552765131,
-0.0491505228,
0.168107152,
-0.127695471,
-0.4956138134,
-0.3819486201,
0.7233554125,
0.2674979568,
-0.1137483269,
-0.6371344328,
0.86567384,
-0.2694059312,
-0.1924231201,
0.165736869,
0.3253950179,
0.6804506183,
0.0619456954,
-0.2917141318,
0.5266749263,
-0.0860032141,
0.1872118413,
0.1410554945,
0.2343560457,
-0.4666363299,
0.2522067428,
0.4764662087,
0.1429931372,
0.4124274254,
0.1691199541,
0.2265277654,
-0.8744667768,
-0.5080261827,
-0.4779358804,
0.5435795188,
-0.1610658765,
-0.4186081886,
0.4338362813,
0.1994881779,
0.4284306765,
-0.1833171695,
0.5586348772,
-0.3527126312,
0.292549789,
-0.6455566287,
0.6375105977,
-0.2054899633,
-0.1243485361,
-0.4564931095,
-0.7529992461,
-0.7194496989,
0.4978889823,
-0.01447629,
-0.2106436044,
0.7991073132,
0.4440696239,
0.2418176383,
-0.2361569554,
0.3893025219,
-0.1407614499,
0.0754035637,
0.5464257598,
0.6507322192,
-0.4772652686,
0.6255365014,
-0.0641345978,
-0.4872376919,
-0.1762786359,
-0.8799817562,
-0.6836673617,
-1.0730179548,
-1.1080454588,
-0.2754079401,
-0.2476679683,
1.1170142889,
0.4240461886,
-1.0202676058,
-0.4585078359,
-0.2358724475,
-0.0198233854,
-0.4538121223,
-0.190244168,
0.3188278377,
-0.0154517628,
-0.6560261846,
0.4796018302,
0.2530970871,
0.5567948818,
0.0391779132,
0.134238109,
-0.2395636737,
0.0007761724,
0.5309986472,
1.3120119572,
-0.4955967069,
-0.7997578979,
-0.1316206902,
-0.0092101693,
0.0861169547,
0.9943318963,
-0.5317451954,
0.5289518237,
0.6138578653,
0.4370955825,
0.5448334813,
-0.028044682,
0.3545806706,
-1.0458689928,
0.1303773224,
0.0794506893,
0.3357402682,
0.7193425298,
-0.4575034082,
0.1285305917,
0.6827569604,
-0.3850755394,
-0.530893147,
0.7784767747,
-1.2030937672,
0.0007625271,
0.9487850666,
0.1722996831,
0.1575134993,
-0.8785999417,
-0.0280192327,
0.4132173061,
0.0190553926,
0.6144806147,
0.8274729252,
-0.8969280124,
-0.3660226762,
-0.2814957798,
0.8586609364,
0.3383908868,
-0.5749320984,
0.2201604247,
1.0447337627,
0.1918228567,
0.5014614463,
1.0404419899,
-0.1213411018,
0.6145060658,
0.1206883267,
-0.113271676,
0.1119129807,
-0.1837213635,
-0.5252272487,
0.1266878545,
0.6249759197,
-0.1605496556
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00697v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00697v1
|
End-to-End Single-Channel Speaker-Turn Aware Conversational Speech Translation
| 2023-11-01T17:55:09 | 2023-11-01T17:55:09 |
Juan Zuluaga-Gomez, Zhaocheng Huang, Xing Niu, Rohit Paturi, Sundararajan Srinivasan, Prashant Mathur, Brian Thompson, Marcello Federico
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Conventional speech-to-text translation (ST) systems are trained on
single-speaker utterances, and they may not generalize to real-life scenarios
where the audio contains conversations by multiple speakers. In this paper, we
tackle single-channel multi-speaker conversational ST with an end-to-end and
multi-task training model, named Speaker-Turn Aware Conversational Speech
Translation, that combines automatic speech recognition, speech translation and
speaker turn detection using special tokens in a serialized labeling format. We
run experiments on the Fisher-CALLHOME corpus, which we adapted by merging the
two single-speaker channels into one multi-speaker channel, thus representing
the more realistic and challenging scenario with multi-speaker turns and
cross-talk. Experimental results across single- and multi-speaker conditions
and against conventional ST systems, show that our model outperforms the
reference systems on the multi-speaker condition, while attaining comparable
performance on the single-speaker condition. We release scripts for data
processing and model training.
|
[
-0.4357117414,
-0.6607202291,
0.3460379839,
0.1541666538,
-0.6479048729,
0.1470257938,
-0.4267193079,
-0.4634217918,
0.3270686865,
0.8247183561,
-0.7278572917,
-0.2079530805,
-0.6181955934,
0.0417201109,
-0.6576003432,
0.9816027284,
0.3969081044,
0.3436768651,
-0.0776725262,
-0.200706467,
-0.3890381753,
-0.6575604081,
-0.6922164559,
-0.2288894653,
0.1194452867,
0.5690386891,
0.7154775858,
0.1444184184,
0.2438730747,
0.2956774235,
-0.0676621795,
-0.0137234628,
-0.4389170706,
0.01601086,
-0.2175232619,
-0.0401286595,
-0.506724894,
-0.202325359,
0.549288094,
0.5156873465,
-0.2763704658,
0.0504312031,
-0.262324661,
0.3075433969,
-0.086258553,
-0.1380097717,
-0.6618999839,
0.0158603992,
-0.2038602084,
-0.4780192673,
-0.8995655775,
0.1422788501,
0.2581826448,
-0.4607187808,
0.2733090818,
0.0294207316,
0.2572534978,
0.4108572602,
-0.6065932512,
-0.0806575045,
-0.9727475047,
0.6276820898,
-0.9649380445,
0.8727889061,
0.1322274804,
0.4966080785,
-0.1393327564,
-0.4947274625,
-0.8162014484,
-0.1850361228,
0.0371482149,
0.0865162537,
0.067977041,
0.1311423182,
-0.1545165181,
0.0447393619,
-0.670458436,
-0.0631997585,
-0.4968357384,
0.1056678072,
0.6779152751,
-0.2242200077,
0.2275839597,
0.0141588571,
-0.7322292924,
-0.1442197561,
-0.4747671187,
0.0969012603,
0.2405391335,
0.8692532182,
-0.2017432898,
0.5393393636,
-0.0054489663,
0.5946157575,
0.1462561786,
-0.1841647923,
0.3991630971,
-0.527204752,
-0.1597337574,
0.4311725795,
0.9224885106,
0.1578033715,
0.4576829374,
-0.5766201615,
-0.0177595373,
-0.1801644415,
0.3959293664,
-0.4333047867,
0.0709408298,
0.3782580495,
-0.2050511986,
-0.0730132833,
-0.3193329275,
-0.5495978594,
0.0718256906,
-0.6168439984,
0.4076700509,
-0.5197365284,
-0.4517052174,
0.2466359586,
-0.0291594062,
0.3997680247,
0.0901378617,
-0.8968486786,
0.4884701371,
0.4868694246,
0.7039704919,
-0.4250871241,
-0.3652395904,
-0.7022516727,
0.2850885093,
-0.2125916034,
0.6081302166,
-0.5786710382,
-0.7070419192,
-0.0854311064,
-0.0733807608,
-0.2374680191,
-0.2901802361,
0.4868969619,
-0.2253940403,
0.1936337352,
0.1663547903,
-0.2310238779,
0.3139459193,
0.003634413,
-0.1928004175,
0.7633575797,
-0.2233595997,
-0.5829979181,
-0.0231062677,
-0.2191066593,
-0.7347370982,
-0.0107586663,
-0.2086850405,
-0.449801743,
0.0270614065,
0.1383547187,
0.4226701856,
-0.1348133385,
0.3883363903,
-0.043378897,
-0.0658221915,
0.5229659677,
-0.4754281342,
0.5834197998,
-0.1044809148,
-0.1293041557,
0.3938083053,
-0.8401985765,
0.001125413,
0.165323332,
-0.3139015138,
-0.0922911093,
0.0160551537,
0.4136942327,
0.3527208865,
0.1346244365,
-0.8811847568,
0.0582507811,
-0.1639638394,
0.5297361612,
0.3105729818,
-0.2657642663,
0.4850740135,
-0.1712295711,
0.1721420288,
0.1732907742,
0.2486314923,
-0.3519803286,
-0.7924034595,
-0.8295932412,
-0.1604114026,
0.0744612142,
0.8192438483,
-0.7339074016,
0.2186179161,
-0.4147053361,
-0.4051271975,
-0.6325849891,
-0.2962623239,
0.6635020971,
0.3944857121,
0.8037068248,
-0.3359576464,
-0.4639455378,
-0.8506556153,
-0.2785173953,
-0.163864553,
-0.0249704067,
0.1851644069,
0.1747729778,
-0.1376761943,
0.9097613692,
0.0135270385,
-0.3172415793,
-0.2067432106,
0.2219868153,
-0.116962865,
0.5841501355,
0.1285934895,
-0.946023345,
-0.4895656109,
0.1907598078,
-0.2302724272,
0.0674391836,
-0.5055812001,
0.0524969064,
0.1787905246,
0.3639651537,
-0.5719604492,
0.6092653275,
0.3419457078,
-0.3227687776,
0.6889661551,
-0.2609944046,
0.0674423277,
-0.8736561537,
-0.1339085847,
-0.0731269717,
-0.4477738142,
-1.4272304773,
-0.206069842,
-0.0106919063,
-0.3210431337,
-0.4255171716,
0.1732375175,
-0.1160041988,
-0.4146484733,
-0.229076013,
0.337041676,
-0.2814815044,
0.8160144687,
0.525143981,
0.7048835158,
0.3525455892,
-0.6455503106,
0.3023959398,
0.5692455769,
0.021795975,
0.7112699151,
-0.4145289958,
0.4703929424,
-0.0381451771,
0.2031566501,
-1.2352366447,
0.205803737,
0.0754552856,
-0.7804610729,
0.6045799851,
-0.1278345883,
-0.0147542339,
-0.0044079921,
0.2289972007,
0.3780461848,
0.0251466651,
-0.6664351821,
0.4793235958,
0.3400149643,
-0.692612946,
-0.2489007115,
-0.7021878958,
0.4560518265,
0.0214945581,
-0.5273815989,
0.7810243368,
-0.2701660991,
0.1645805538,
-0.5067939758,
0.0851541832,
-0.1554037631,
-0.5970962048,
0.0815248862,
0.0677908584,
0.0899409279,
0.1665302813,
-0.1161312535,
-0.3359231353,
-0.1345319748,
-0.2466552705,
0.5976944566,
0.0363837481,
-0.7320861816,
-0.4486123919,
0.89053303,
0.8642645478,
-0.4327376187,
0.4501977265,
0.4763950109,
-0.1916916668,
0.0404839143,
-0.4885060191,
-0.2105517387,
-0.3788990974,
0.4113668501,
-0.5173925757,
-0.6614120007,
0.2747471929,
0.1678102165,
0.1601105481,
-0.0576917641,
0.3864433765,
0.0896964893,
1.0586163998,
0.6108375192,
-0.0204966664,
0.4713014364,
0.0009448974,
0.763882637,
-0.8565929532,
-0.572991848,
-0.4990525246,
-0.1389136314,
-0.4965223968,
-0.6693667769,
0.2925274074,
-0.0585091561,
-0.2029819041,
0.7884452343,
-0.7817653418,
-0.0816896185,
0.658167243,
0.198350817,
0.5255542397,
-0.150229618,
0.0498224646,
0.0016488191,
-0.5652496219,
-0.2925363481,
0.8738299012,
0.4674301147,
0.3521992564,
0.1006249264,
0.6763999462,
0.0029120252,
0.1135343164,
-0.6841913462,
0.5215796232,
-0.1410599202,
-0.3975969553,
-0.6565183401,
-0.3326290846,
-0.386246264,
0.4666624367,
-0.0686941594,
-0.6663146019,
0.3689057529,
-0.0208163261,
-0.008570346,
0.2034845054,
-0.6717191339,
0.8109907508,
-0.5797929764,
0.043380633,
-0.3223463595,
-0.7015996575,
0.029276358,
0.1357761472,
0.5130903125,
-0.0520664565,
0.3085211813,
0.6924680471,
-0.130848527,
0.8323387504,
-0.2078717351,
-0.0075728022,
0.2906631529,
-0.1131211221,
0.6318079829,
-0.0303304382,
0.1745913923,
0.0684952512,
0.2739088833,
-0.3899689019,
-0.1867978871,
0.3280231655,
-0.7540159225,
-0.3141323328,
-0.171621576,
-0.5019960403,
-0.4751780033,
0.0395273417,
0.4511239827,
0.5795857906,
-0.3858668804,
-0.0015086435,
0.7327861786,
-0.0882144794,
0.3953608274,
0.6551944017,
-0.4425719678,
-0.3261706233,
1.0591323376,
0.0324953124,
0.5578044653,
0.466467768,
0.0440433957,
-0.26118204,
-0.6182814837,
-0.8248054385,
0.17827411,
-0.4191883504,
0.0865087733,
-0.6732453108,
-0.1810011864,
-0.883839488,
-0.1755806655,
-0.8417681456,
-0.5487824678,
-0.1144575551,
0.043588683,
0.1452506483,
0.4663587809,
0.1688460559,
0.5796163678,
-0.6467708945,
0.4454132915,
0.5920958519,
0.2480011284,
-0.2506669462,
-1.0018841028,
-0.2366302013,
0.1556726992,
-0.1112505421,
-1.2498556376,
0.4969731867,
0.2910150886,
0.611018002,
0.4229081273,
0.1239639968,
0.5122537613,
-0.7772526145,
0.4834210873,
0.6663756371,
-0.8993109465,
0.3051977158,
-0.4398425817,
0.5219489336,
0.3718105257,
0.069196865,
-1.0576527119,
-0.3311498761,
-0.3200319409,
-0.9044159055,
0.6997542977,
0.2589378059,
-0.0811076462,
0.07760223,
-0.0955801979,
-0.0082783299,
0.2852360606,
-0.6506425142,
-0.2556512058,
-0.6717228293,
-0.0130323116,
-0.139506489,
-0.1981194615,
0.0516560972,
-0.1485277414,
0.8639265299,
-0.1966420561,
0.5844305754,
0.1886720359,
-0.0870239586,
-0.1069244668,
0.7926877737,
0.8480194807,
0.3424995244,
-0.36373806,
0.1033288762,
0.2663892508,
-0.1652636528,
-0.0572895743,
0.195635438,
0.2627175152,
0.2573534846,
0.1324491203,
1.0349208117,
0.6819022298,
-0.6257842183,
0.4369580448,
0.0244986899,
0.0323128924,
-0.4512874186,
-0.4991350174,
0.4219106138,
0.0584612489,
0.5096878409,
0.1498052925,
0.0613026656,
-0.5269542933,
0.2041653544,
0.414773792,
-0.6768983006,
-0.342987895,
0.4031220973,
0.4038382173,
-0.8739896417,
0.3670086861,
-0.3022965491,
-0.6428496838,
0.3306109011,
0.7940172553,
0.8581318855,
-0.707074821,
0.223815918,
0.1908893883,
0.2261376083,
0.3333330154,
0.2974534035,
-0.3074626625,
-0.5996921062,
-0.5404853225,
-0.4028384984,
-0.7919470072,
-0.0460161418,
-0.7401890159,
0.0662431568,
-0.121365197,
-0.2348500192,
0.0582333989,
-0.6744393706,
-0.4533384144,
0.2293110788,
0.5538597703,
0.7495498061,
-0.712759614,
0.9596244097,
0.5520071983,
0.0301992577,
-0.176563561,
-0.5682203174,
-0.1783070564,
-0.4754200876,
0.3231324852,
0.0704928488,
-0.520655632,
-0.1196239516,
-0.3943587542,
-0.7715210915,
0.7244545221,
0.0415914878,
-0.8165522218,
0.0104791513,
0.6295754313,
0.4840915501,
-0.5958102345,
0.2290866971,
0.6127513647,
0.2072582692,
0.3072445989,
-1.5007716417,
-0.5086436868,
-0.1931192428,
-0.1416391581,
0.3525975645,
-0.6282325983,
0.7242045403,
-0.1853295416,
-0.0487421192,
-0.2730989158,
0.8006056547,
0.1277855188,
0.5123876333,
0.5996076465,
0.565340817,
0.3600764871,
0.0035051461,
0.5037670732,
-0.2802896798,
0.1497810185,
1.5261976719,
-0.2913456261,
1.2261459827,
0.8370953798,
-0.3879647553,
0.010662619,
0.3091414869,
0.6504915357,
0.7718375325,
0.0342258215,
-0.4610068798,
-0.5688931346,
-0.040153753,
-0.3936628103,
0.613499403,
0.5131279826,
0.0625436231,
-0.0134628378,
0.496312052,
-0.2149449289,
0.0691606626,
-0.1293261051,
0.6989868879,
0.1635808051,
-0.5874608159,
0.4186685979,
0.0295640621,
0.8122813106,
-0.429600656,
0.242793411,
0.0775896162,
0.1682783961,
-0.0486535169,
-0.4692414403,
0.3033591509,
0.0139737818,
-0.2336660624,
-0.3982874453,
0.620033443,
-0.8749278784,
-0.3966135681,
0.5455847383,
0.4160578847,
0.2269222885,
-0.1420232952,
-0.4981503785,
-0.1076794565,
0.1866501868,
-0.2952584922,
0.4665675759,
0.1296340972,
0.1238736361,
0.7746688128,
0.6021845937,
-0.0164717659,
0.4714622498,
0.1624908447,
0.6789416075,
-0.5029562712,
-0.674633801,
-0.3950148225,
0.4142704308,
0.0145852892,
-0.4500880539,
0.2950925827,
0.5394988656,
0.9786474705,
0.1496445388,
0.8227021098,
0.2585008442,
0.8503364325,
-0.2349162102,
0.2985925674,
-0.0726448447,
-0.0639312342,
-0.009418604,
-0.5721508861,
0.2360233963,
0.526432395,
-0.2612305582,
-0.0885069966,
0.3241958618,
0.6066455841,
-0.0197945498,
0.4919767082,
0.523063004,
-0.1145221666,
0.498025924,
0.5082208514,
0.4540106952,
-0.4308153093,
0.8253540993,
-0.4028701782,
-0.1706091762,
-0.4204147756,
-0.6656808257,
-0.8330432177,
-0.8832537532,
-0.4034047425,
-0.0210129675,
0.1586826891,
0.7739092112,
0.846783638,
-1.0173408985,
-0.3625495136,
0.112794131,
-0.1924032271,
-0.4175441265,
-0.1444141269,
0.1389037371,
-0.3749795258,
-0.7678710222,
1.0233407021,
0.4515549839,
0.0646900535,
-0.2213905454,
-0.3596218228,
-0.4223677814,
0.164506048,
0.573172152,
0.3110081851,
-0.6115965843,
-0.2856875658,
0.0283283927,
0.0346386842,
0.2247857153,
0.9965618253,
-0.7545126081,
0.7415065169,
0.3669619858,
0.4522204399,
0.978304565,
-0.0627637655,
0.5251163244,
-0.9597705007,
0.1878265589,
0.2456311136,
0.1633749902,
0.5749778152,
-0.1259631366,
0.1029800326,
0.1297582835,
-0.6716691852,
-0.7264662981,
0.3381761014,
-1.3801894188,
-0.2783237398,
0.8728482127,
-0.0330182202,
0.2375658453,
-0.3003744185,
-0.2078666538,
0.6992911696,
-0.5314522982,
0.4222575426,
0.5837474465,
-0.3321059048,
-0.3747595847,
-0.7287219167,
0.1974087805,
0.6856474876,
-0.5517100692,
0.1934943944,
0.0402233116,
-0.0906202793,
0.4995774031,
0.687961638,
0.1602488011,
0.0299610272,
-0.1689918041,
0.2692471445,
-0.1999618411,
-0.5252689123,
-0.1535793692,
-0.085242711,
-0.088878952,
-0.509372592
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00694v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00694v2
|
Unleashing the Creative Mind: Language Model As Hierarchical Policy For Improved Exploration on Challenging Problem Solving
| 2023-11-01T17:52:15 | 2023-12-05T20:44:45 |
Zhan Ling, Yunhao Fang, Xuanlin Li, Tongzhou Mu, Mingu Lee, Reza Pourreza, Roland Memisevic, Hao Su
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved tremendous progress, yet they
still often struggle with challenging reasoning problems. Current approaches
address this challenge by sampling or searching detailed and low-level
reasoning chains. However, these methods are still limited in their exploration
capabilities, making it challenging for correct solutions to stand out in the
huge solution space. In this work, we unleash LLMs' creative potential for
exploring multiple diverse problem solving strategies by framing an LLM as a
hierarchical policy via in-context learning. This policy comprises of a
visionary leader that proposes multiple diverse high-level problem-solving
tactics as hints, accompanied by a follower that executes detailed
problem-solving processes following each of the high-level instruction. The
follower uses each of the leader's directives as a guide and samples multiple
reasoning chains to tackle the problem, generating a solution group for each
leader proposal. Additionally, we propose an effective and efficient
tournament-based approach to select among these explored solution groups to
reach the final answer. Our approach produces meaningful and inspiring hints,
enhances problem-solving strategy exploration, and improves the final answer
accuracy on challenging problems in the MATH dataset. Code will be released at
https://github.com/lz1oceani/LLM-As-Hierarchical-Policy.
|
[
-0.2537257373,
-0.9799280167,
0.7358191609,
0.3229835927,
0.0174913201,
0.5881941915,
-0.6109682322,
0.1024830416,
-0.1035426855,
0.4075916708,
-0.9855570197,
-0.4242399931,
-0.5332539082,
-0.0854368508,
0.2032821774,
0.9059603214,
-0.1036733016,
-0.1754233986,
-0.1496503651,
0.3526913822,
-0.6825574636,
-0.1671556234,
-0.6813546419,
-0.6311780214,
0.5430351496,
0.7518504858,
0.6287247539,
0.3719901145,
0.5804141164,
0.3056447804,
-0.3761711121,
0.4180330932,
-0.5703274012,
0.1890945733,
-0.5106036067,
-0.4649209082,
-0.27267313,
-0.2165858001,
0.6247347593,
0.7794799805,
-0.4891991913,
-0.0126461498,
0.166042462,
0.538235724,
-0.5494890213,
0.3399590254,
-0.9153648019,
0.2080805153,
-0.2161076665,
-0.4302031994,
-0.2669571936,
-0.1863731444,
0.2242847383,
-0.7378553748,
-0.2268546075,
-0.0165950395,
0.4223957658,
0.246487692,
-0.3549101055,
-0.3748590946,
-0.877563715,
0.9554715157,
-0.4567825198,
-0.1181199178,
0.1118019596,
0.5010534525,
-0.5578055382,
-0.4686754048,
-0.5305823684,
0.2914041579,
0.4638239145,
0.0759301707,
-0.3138474822,
-0.0744096041,
0.2263929099,
0.34505108,
-0.3137035668,
0.2231940329,
-0.0787888393,
0.1340791434,
0.5380856395,
0.2424977869,
0.1928573251,
0.0387133248,
-0.244354412,
0.0046325224,
-0.7490500212,
0.2406598032,
0.1182470471,
0.4441774189,
0.0414878875,
0.4278284907,
-0.2103624791,
0.3681798279,
-0.0273957867,
-0.3359128833,
0.1610598266,
-0.0636372194,
-0.1573522985,
-0.152668789,
0.5661444664,
0.1012087315,
0.3591431081,
-0.1387879848,
-0.3810078502,
-0.1652783751,
0.2203673273,
-0.6106068492,
-0.1177584752,
-0.0392700583,
-0.0422219113,
-0.2322801054,
-0.2973919809,
-0.8475103974,
-0.4341155589,
-0.2075880021,
0.5103651881,
-0.2758275568,
-0.3203979433,
0.2034756392,
-0.0583934523,
0.0919150561,
0.4806093574,
-1.0867246389,
0.1767407656,
0.6544013023,
0.5985514522,
-0.1201007888,
-0.1960215271,
-0.3810223937,
0.3879715502,
-0.4354805052,
0.5277152061,
-0.6400382519,
-0.4547770321,
0.0984362662,
-0.3667035103,
0.1410494745,
-0.8176510334,
0.3706043363,
-0.299235791,
0.1273051947,
-0.3460153937,
-0.388794601,
-0.0073643751,
0.400769949,
-0.4663291574,
0.9276273251,
0.1475270689,
-0.4260414541,
-0.024420293,
-0.7829608321,
-0.1336133331,
0.4172526598,
-0.4984426498,
-0.1635294557,
0.2491402626,
0.639885962,
0.3293161392,
-0.4386210144,
0.5844903588,
-0.0001655093,
-0.3086073399,
0.0706615821,
-0.2179594189,
0.8006330729,
0.0231322069,
-0.4363764226,
0.48662135,
-0.4870396256,
0.1623445153,
0.5288245678,
-0.3789055943,
-0.1520414352,
0.0890323445,
-0.2614964843,
0.3032179475,
0.3382616937,
-0.3466539681,
0.4493309557,
-0.256390214,
0.4022152722,
1.063949585,
0.1810319871,
0.4269087315,
-0.440186739,
0.7254983187,
-0.140377894,
0.1216709092,
-0.2373246104,
-0.5820798874,
-0.5550018549,
-0.090923816,
-0.3035893738,
0.5600041151,
-1.0149590969,
0.3227666914,
-0.1465138495,
-0.4003064334,
-0.5923746228,
0.305906713,
0.3133012056,
0.5530835986,
0.3140031099,
-0.0092201941,
-0.4148413539,
-0.805709064,
-0.3806744218,
-0.1373866498,
0.0657672808,
0.4772319198,
0.6736471653,
-0.3318638802,
0.9405087233,
-0.5079989433,
-0.4503293633,
-0.6562570333,
0.0032835843,
0.3945186734,
0.3953827024,
0.0216142144,
-0.7879464626,
-0.3740848601,
0.0293378755,
-0.8523494005,
-0.2006410658,
-0.0482639223,
-0.2347839922,
-0.079857327,
0.2718911767,
-0.5105969906,
0.1509068608,
0.448023349,
-0.0386901386,
0.5791820884,
-0.0735921115,
-0.1717230529,
-0.9499157071,
-0.313602984,
-0.050608784,
0.2062284052,
-0.4222066402,
0.5305199623,
-0.2118929923,
-0.1555065662,
-0.2893161774,
0.3560583293,
-0.3309533894,
0.2435744405,
-0.2031836212,
0.2469883114,
-0.1698403805,
0.7852780819,
-0.0016753041,
0.6610977054,
0.8290904164,
-0.2003784329,
0.4909795821,
0.1489607394,
-0.4874814749,
0.2995736599,
-0.4056618214,
0.2155618221,
-0.2926416695,
0.3907624483,
-0.7508103848,
-0.0453482643,
0.0627927408,
-0.160501346,
0.1373666525,
0.1593956053,
-0.8133366108,
-0.3952168226,
-0.1006052047,
0.3651796281,
0.5833668113,
-0.6442000866,
0.5814366341,
0.6429974437,
-0.2416571081,
-0.581848979,
-0.5003157854,
0.1197723225,
-0.434005022,
-0.5061965585,
0.7005072236,
-0.4030812979,
-0.3090104163,
-0.0479657836,
-0.3470650613,
0.1725926548,
0.1104614213,
-0.0952392742,
0.2145148665,
0.0507984422,
0.0042978162,
-0.063661918,
0.0491349064,
0.3257013559,
-0.4178079665,
0.5383030772,
-0.3991461396,
-0.0943259001,
-0.2109283954,
0.6880433559,
0.3479602039,
-0.4191502035,
0.393280983,
0.2113531679,
-0.683132112,
-0.7060626745,
-0.3584391177,
-0.1539586186,
-0.5410934091,
0.4954893291,
-0.4456307292,
-0.9932463169,
0.5011693835,
-0.5025832057,
0.2671268284,
-0.0017472046,
0.7375918627,
-0.091444172,
0.9924706221,
0.7729801536,
0.1254698783,
0.3338264823,
-0.4998016953,
0.3738538921,
-0.9772899151,
-0.7135608196,
-0.1476043165,
-0.3093191087,
-0.3337157369,
-0.5881823301,
0.6428342462,
0.3803887069,
-0.185477525,
0.0275402181,
-0.4583211243,
0.7777842283,
0.4614774883,
0.0459914878,
0.4043571651,
-0.010354572,
-0.5488720536,
-0.241995126,
-1.0003677607,
-0.2966645658,
0.8245937228,
0.3998262882,
0.8861384392,
0.3959172964,
0.9393880367,
-0.2975682914,
0.2815212905,
-0.9143874645,
0.7303029299,
0.1324312389,
-0.3657183051,
-0.5245648026,
-0.6326801181,
-0.7085565329,
0.4018299878,
-0.1804385483,
-0.8651469946,
-0.18950212,
-0.0181562249,
-0.3113514483,
0.5042208433,
-0.3117012084,
0.7613751292,
-0.207545802,
-0.4155841172,
-0.3021005392,
-0.3536142707,
0.3165082037,
-0.146040976,
0.4435633123,
0.1272671819,
0.0288172737,
0.5325790644,
0.0489838682,
0.8048892617,
-0.0041116457,
-0.4585924745,
0.3398004472,
0.1526948959,
0.6734591722,
-0.1751345992,
0.2555867136,
-0.314622581,
-0.6357261539,
-0.1867247671,
-0.8838874698,
0.7428687215,
-0.5231620073,
-1.1212162971,
-0.2916222215,
-1.0509501696,
-0.4751266837,
0.1130014509,
0.1561406255,
0.2951742411,
-0.0551929139,
0.2855404615,
0.8829677701,
-0.2300689965,
0.5571739078,
0.3203090727,
-0.3450215161,
-0.2421907187,
0.8209542036,
0.1528207064,
0.2604210675,
0.4106404483,
0.5736837983,
-0.2965176702,
-0.6442420483,
-0.2441351116,
-0.0478143543,
-0.7788738012,
-0.1817956418,
-0.3676685095,
-0.2640522718,
-0.1957782209,
-0.2506952584,
-0.1485907435,
-0.2017685324,
-0.0239661802,
0.0719926655,
0.0508680642,
0.5353392363,
0.0428262874,
0.3595305979,
-0.2336680889,
0.1363495737,
0.4427209496,
0.1586336344,
0.3624534309,
-0.4043914378,
-0.2664611936,
-0.1667194813,
-0.6393502355,
-0.805659771,
0.378195852,
0.0822070166,
0.6857477427,
0.2240161002,
-0.1221681312,
0.8081925511,
-0.6643242836,
0.5160132647,
0.163825959,
-0.7535156012,
0.842952013,
-0.4971162379,
0.6652376056,
0.230069831,
0.369633317,
-0.4158824682,
-0.6601459384,
-0.6958378553,
-0.9647650719,
0.4371887743,
0.1164379567,
0.0336834751,
0.0345387198,
0.1349116862,
-0.1301067919,
0.2544259727,
-0.6829846501,
-0.1644867808,
0.1721449345,
0.1132486314,
0.166924268,
0.2559879124,
-0.3510959446,
-0.4594390392,
0.6596913338,
-0.3078517914,
-0.0070614382,
-0.0774767846,
0.2301288843,
-0.3250992,
0.5541747808,
0.1774330437,
0.6716290116,
-0.0776317567,
0.1808670908,
0.0460561998,
-0.1192282438,
0.0204859283,
-0.11076805,
-0.0848227814,
-0.416180402,
0.3559185266,
0.5548019409,
0.3874663413,
-0.9150210619,
0.346765399,
0.2565793693,
-0.1112448871,
-0.4132065773,
0.3107092083,
0.3275873959,
0.4696012735,
0.6722738743,
-0.0478470922,
0.048557993,
-0.8924549222,
0.0592650026,
0.5501137376,
-0.1712062359,
0.0849082693,
0.4406626523,
0.0732807815,
-0.5731440187,
0.6225367785,
-0.3348805606,
-0.7220584154,
0.5849435925,
1.0480475426,
0.7435211539,
-0.1259908676,
0.3224973977,
0.0828502104,
0.3289391696,
0.0134921093,
0.383295089,
-0.075981319,
-0.9394017458,
-0.6719822884,
-0.3698599041,
-0.383877933,
0.3740927279,
-0.5051770806,
-0.0887942016,
-0.4934031665,
0.0648371279,
-0.1556293368,
0.3214593828,
-0.4036868811,
-0.1468099803,
0.218269676,
0.9366436005,
-0.4867485762,
0.7905622125,
0.5115199685,
-0.1442712694,
-0.8386998177,
0.0818599537,
0.3283006549,
-0.7579164505,
0.5443543792,
0.0821340606,
-0.2488469183,
0.1760855019,
-0.7024191618,
-0.6866552234,
1.2046579123,
0.2417846918,
-0.6587426066,
-0.3395830989,
-0.1279256493,
0.3190840781,
-0.8030836582,
-0.2077115327,
0.5590239167,
0.2849215269,
0.4387435317,
-0.7914117575,
-0.0498198271,
-0.3240655363,
0.0431834608,
0.1320408136,
-0.505946517,
0.8258716464,
-0.7132689357,
-0.2109750509,
-0.0073975362,
0.7115362287,
0.8716837764,
0.0655085295,
0.4360310435,
0.5888993144,
0.9392929077,
0.0421759523,
0.8174984455,
0.19437024,
0.2788048387,
1.0193434954,
-0.3152044117,
0.8286166191,
0.6688950658,
0.2310412526,
0.7082675695,
0.3836911321,
0.0928659886,
0.6757509708,
0.6440501213,
-0.4815803468,
-0.329298228,
-0.4356653392,
-0.1552623808,
0.3409991264,
0.626986444,
0.0589526594,
-0.5906690955,
0.0584243573,
0.0600432009,
0.5632407069,
-0.6352559328,
0.4710327089,
0.1426212192,
-0.750325501,
0.4984378815,
0.0456508435,
0.684594512,
-0.5565444231,
-0.2389041781,
0.0163712986,
0.2614225745,
-0.0054557449,
-1.0379322767,
0.0698738173,
0.0389312021,
-0.0204538386,
-0.4906534255,
0.2603282332,
-0.704805851,
-0.3982622623,
0.2796965539,
0.6583423615,
-0.149801746,
0.0276574176,
-0.684228003,
0.0707201213,
-0.1485125422,
-0.0746227577,
0.2735950053,
0.8375412226,
-0.2400569469,
1.0097489357,
0.5230503082,
0.1295225173,
-0.1493062079,
0.211030677,
0.9803935885,
-0.5085021257,
-0.5822776556,
-0.8373051286,
0.4363010824,
-0.0443425402,
-0.4248828292,
0.5866214037,
0.4151670337,
1.0314749479,
0.0786696598,
0.5987522006,
0.0869007409,
0.066049546,
-0.4619322121,
0.3802968562,
-0.4670225978,
0.4450328052,
-0.4160065353,
-0.8564803004,
-0.3375048041,
0.7322453856,
-0.1321139634,
-0.0718594268,
0.749317348,
0.7256260514,
0.2244321257,
0.0982985795,
0.1145404652,
0.2071988285,
0.4740067422,
1.2235645056,
0.9913651347,
0.1069855168,
0.4019729495,
-0.2479565591,
-0.717887044,
0.2568490505,
-0.8823262453,
-1.0288083553,
-0.6029777527,
-0.2206954211,
-0.1328420788,
0.0903543085,
1.1740486622,
0.5145868659,
-0.3836566806,
-0.4936113358,
-0.2227559984,
0.2726079524,
-0.4510035515,
-0.241721198,
0.2143210322,
-0.4126011729,
-0.691120863,
0.6788468361,
0.2550723553,
-0.1420167238,
-0.4666084051,
-0.0051549817,
-0.1617329717,
0.0749303997,
0.7382504344,
0.1183272228,
-0.9209144115,
-0.0618438572,
0.0782533586,
0.0827445462,
-0.0257229432,
0.9137951136,
-0.9284564257,
0.2980994582,
0.2597848773,
0.9009387493,
0.4332996011,
-0.3449782729,
0.4740917683,
-0.6846785545,
-0.0962437168,
0.585588634,
0.2551420629,
0.1928362399,
-0.3121416569,
0.3367568851,
0.1469183117,
-0.4421838522,
-0.787653327,
0.5390384197,
-0.8712534904,
-0.4009454548,
1.0291836262,
0.0345350504,
-0.2303249389,
0.1630785614,
-0.2007144094,
-0.0928960666,
-0.4335999489,
0.8799550533,
0.7510095239,
-0.2878161669,
-0.4472955465,
-0.6241180301,
0.5100043416,
0.3756935596,
-0.7197774053,
0.2145778388,
0.1198206618,
-0.0252441447,
0.1202118173,
0.7291432023,
-0.2159280479,
-0.0196292289,
-0.3501182199,
-0.2204294503,
-0.0382155403,
-0.9399443865,
-0.3228815496,
0.2199354917,
-0.1361360252,
0.1178281978
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00687v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00687v2
|
Improving Interpersonal Communication by Simulating Audiences with Language Models
| 2023-11-01T17:44:50 | 2023-11-03T13:17:55 |
Ryan Liu, Howard Yen, Raja Marjieh, Thomas L. Griffiths, Ranjay Krishna
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
How do we communicate with others to achieve our goals? We use our prior
experience or advice from others, or construct a candidate utterance by
predicting how it will be received. However, our experiences are limited and
biased, and reasoning about potential outcomes can be difficult and cognitively
challenging. In this paper, we explore how we can leverage Large Language Model
(LLM) simulations to help us communicate better. We propose the
Explore-Generate-Simulate (EGS) framework, which takes as input any scenario
where an individual is communicating to an audience with a goal they want to
achieve. EGS (1) explores the solution space by producing a diverse set of
advice relevant to the scenario, (2) generates communication candidates
conditioned on subsets of the advice, and (3) simulates the reactions from
various audiences to determine both the best candidate and advice to use. We
evaluate the framework on eight scenarios spanning the ten fundamental
processes of interpersonal communication. For each scenario, we collect a
dataset of human evaluations across candidates and baselines, and showcase that
our framework's chosen candidate is preferred over popular generation
mechanisms including Chain-of-Thought. We also find that audience simulations
achieve reasonably high agreement with human raters across 5 of the 8
scenarios. Finally, we demonstrate the generality of our framework by applying
it to real-world scenarios described by users on web forums. Through
evaluations and demonstrations, we show that EGS enhances the effectiveness and
outcomes of goal-oriented communication across a variety of situations, thus
opening up new possibilities for the application of large language models in
revolutionizing communication and decision-making processes.
|
[
-0.7287165523,
-0.9029812217,
0.7324891686,
0.376478672,
-0.1720464826,
0.0292873625,
-0.6200035214,
-0.3692686856,
0.3717691898,
0.1397454739,
-0.602971673,
-0.4089819491,
-0.5135580301,
-0.0202238262,
-0.2322289944,
0.422355473,
0.0341505073,
-0.082262978,
-0.3052643836,
0.3327799141,
-0.1282705069,
-0.615875423,
-0.8640450835,
-0.4388762414,
0.3146507442,
0.6301581264,
0.3770050704,
0.3461092114,
0.1626967937,
0.2585855722,
-0.1137398407,
0.1652665883,
-1.087641716,
0.1313013434,
-0.1110264733,
-0.3057335317,
-0.0904564336,
0.1730064303,
0.4704754353,
0.7528005838,
-0.4868986309,
0.1302597523,
0.2528946996,
0.1362596005,
-0.2437919527,
0.2955072522,
-0.5130690932,
-0.0770542547,
0.1459051222,
-0.3746449351,
-0.5485927463,
-0.1530322731,
0.1913266927,
-0.6086874008,
-0.1819383055,
0.2874014676,
0.7081306577,
-0.294914335,
-0.4889287353,
-0.2625497282,
-0.8249337077,
0.4825070798,
-0.8224056959,
0.3870957196,
0.3558395207,
0.4178720117,
-0.3852493465,
-0.5567485094,
-0.4739069939,
-0.4162326455,
0.0816879123,
0.3446263075,
-0.3553311825,
0.315082252,
0.4368297756,
-0.0230347086,
-0.3912017941,
0.2142689079,
-0.4625464678,
0.0437259525,
0.6212819219,
0.1849645674,
0.1731455177,
0.0969138369,
-0.1568223685,
-0.3940405548,
-0.6863137484,
0.0671838671,
0.6964674592,
0.2913104594,
-0.158370018,
0.4173711538,
-0.4392910898,
0.6356937885,
0.3124566376,
0.1285108179,
-0.032559555,
0.0010645599,
-0.0768427923,
-0.2119743228,
0.3869888484,
0.7910721898,
0.4167205989,
0.0081751086,
0.1186736599,
0.1973399818,
0.3338376284,
-0.9064229131,
-0.1493755877,
0.2090032548,
-0.6538783908,
-0.1561428159,
-0.0941908956,
-0.8478006124,
-0.2309359312,
-0.487321645,
0.1976856887,
-0.3334552646,
-0.5285479426,
0.1676977277,
0.00857767,
0.2627767026,
0.631896019,
-0.8539555669,
0.5189310908,
0.6023386121,
0.4667025506,
-0.0732240751,
-0.3057180345,
-0.687714994,
0.0370826721,
-0.4055646956,
0.7449178696,
-0.6876761317,
-0.5307874084,
0.1657270193,
-0.443654567,
0.0889745653,
-0.5537344217,
0.5643522739,
-0.1259478331,
0.1680766493,
-0.3025801182,
-0.7900859714,
0.0721761584,
0.5177570581,
-0.5243903995,
0.4837915003,
-0.123161152,
-0.1950356364,
0.3025306165,
-0.7595018744,
-0.1545198262,
0.1409835219,
-0.3084975779,
-0.0595214479,
0.3314016461,
0.3283526897,
0.4155601859,
-0.3537494838,
0.3241873085,
-0.4358952045,
-0.4039998651,
0.3901747465,
-0.3585492074,
0.0520481355,
0.5071348548,
-0.1631117314,
0.1472787708,
-0.3020091355,
0.3570270836,
0.0712569579,
-0.3793599904,
-0.0805441067,
0.0849729851,
0.2080344111,
0.2089610398,
-0.1980299503,
-0.4685095251,
0.130333662,
-0.3545586765,
0.2706568837,
0.693027854,
0.1396865994,
0.4557611942,
-0.4013669193,
0.8220209479,
0.0926992074,
0.069516696,
-0.4135445952,
-0.5096240044,
-0.54319489,
0.094328627,
0.1049593911,
0.2309913188,
-0.6056348085,
-0.0147900376,
-0.3359354138,
-0.3878006935,
-0.4253972769,
-0.1631685197,
0.2842130065,
0.1457165927,
-0.0628897101,
-0.00677273,
-0.5629130602,
-0.8503949642,
-0.8084449172,
-0.4746606946,
0.0580674671,
0.4706461132,
0.0884792954,
-0.00989509,
0.7499206066,
-0.489335984,
0.1719431281,
-0.6606895924,
0.2111060619,
0.0172431879,
0.2173900902,
0.2876788676,
-0.7578273416,
-0.5746662021,
-0.1499191374,
-0.562823534,
-0.2107048035,
-0.412335217,
-0.1449187398,
-0.1842050999,
0.6466175914,
-0.1836027801,
0.472448349,
0.7418872118,
-0.2579689324,
0.3142639399,
-0.2300792038,
0.4298718572,
-0.9889878631,
-0.1574399918,
0.4016155601,
-0.4221239686,
-0.9339809418,
0.1070458293,
-0.2349406034,
-0.3667353988,
-0.4027190506,
0.8733695149,
-0.4482007027,
0.1586102694,
-0.1628053188,
0.1786132008,
-0.2051878422,
0.4748980999,
0.1057596728,
0.8339812756,
0.3015718162,
-0.4644993544,
0.0279243235,
0.206869334,
-0.6812900901,
0.6342673302,
-0.5497231483,
0.2349282205,
-0.4180621803,
0.3108799458,
-0.9536406994,
-0.5091034174,
0.1305507571,
-0.5371229649,
0.0912475586,
-0.0137394797,
-0.385869205,
-0.3649816811,
0.0099880733,
0.1560106426,
0.7572558522,
-0.7386471033,
0.6359308958,
0.4695365727,
-0.3697195649,
-0.1042320207,
-0.5329257846,
0.4328601658,
-0.4853167534,
-0.7364981771,
0.2468338013,
-0.2972279489,
-0.6262989044,
-0.3120060563,
0.2556203604,
0.2324505448,
0.0576345325,
0.2340303808,
-0.2519381046,
0.2546846569,
0.1190444529,
0.2150076926,
0.0216306075,
0.0810147896,
-0.2155787647,
0.6867780089,
-0.3417342901,
-0.699883163,
-0.3376951218,
0.7885279059,
0.1674213558,
0.1577964574,
0.4988124967,
0.2774722576,
-0.3273767531,
-0.3107512295,
-0.7289115787,
-0.4664057791,
-0.4744670093,
0.6264333725,
-0.5445633531,
-0.8273816705,
0.4377438426,
-0.6637572646,
0.1604331136,
-0.2860729396,
0.4250969291,
-0.1299126893,
1.1712487936,
0.6612158418,
0.4180850089,
0.501655817,
-0.0441802293,
0.4336040616,
-0.7782450914,
-0.1224399805,
-0.1095433161,
-0.4344966114,
-0.1953352094,
-0.5595668554,
0.5302169323,
0.260084331,
0.1035277173,
0.2900112867,
-0.1651881188,
0.3552578092,
0.538353622,
0.0707792863,
0.1125123128,
0.1964441091,
-0.2066194415,
-0.3602309525,
-0.8217247725,
-0.8748474717,
0.7650546432,
0.3897997737,
0.9346172214,
0.1232982203,
0.9954696298,
0.200796783,
0.9066411257,
-0.6191322207,
0.7059003711,
0.2637281716,
-0.4041907787,
-0.1787007004,
-0.4945551157,
-0.8006825447,
0.4534250498,
-0.2225689292,
-1.0594873428,
0.1105028242,
0.3998767436,
-0.007859773,
0.1209264845,
-0.8897778392,
0.7013919353,
-0.1322093755,
-0.3345645964,
-0.3287540376,
-0.3805212677,
0.1656671613,
0.0605707131,
0.3215057254,
-0.0312702432,
0.2833429873,
0.5590171814,
-0.1216793358,
0.9128726721,
-0.0685802549,
-0.0518705025,
0.5349551439,
0.0456607565,
0.7679470778,
-0.0070026773,
-0.4416064024,
-0.1346372962,
-0.2556380332,
-0.0874444842,
-0.6823928356,
0.4550479949,
-0.5684018135,
-0.7935028672,
-0.0085182888,
-0.3828279674,
-0.2993219793,
-0.1395351589,
0.2014636695,
0.3437898755,
-0.7817828059,
0.0833239108,
0.318795532,
-0.4390794933,
0.1762390286,
0.4951066673,
-0.5632402301,
-0.348051548,
0.7449549437,
-0.1511819363,
0.5758907199,
0.1449148655,
0.2796903551,
-0.4603849649,
-0.1864683777,
-0.3485459387,
0.1632461101,
-1.012586832,
0.0831891522,
-0.7455252409,
0.0531703532,
-0.5101354718,
-0.2286162823,
0.0077111037,
-0.0492657237,
-0.0779579431,
-0.4888795018,
-0.0023832698,
0.7031669617,
-0.4000988007,
0.5531483889,
-0.4745239317,
-0.0388179757,
0.2867608666,
0.0766116679,
0.1961343735,
-0.4070300162,
-0.1846203804,
0.4489319623,
-0.3233136833,
-0.916413486,
0.6269810796,
0.1233930737,
0.8872246146,
0.3793824911,
-0.0957435146,
0.8863402009,
-0.371845901,
0.6017944813,
0.1912458539,
-0.9894721508,
0.378906697,
-0.6177897453,
0.2084840536,
0.5696922541,
0.1421432346,
-0.8698454499,
-0.3646139503,
-0.7900388837,
-0.7850067019,
0.6303831339,
0.2302530259,
0.3035992682,
-0.3643345237,
0.4065493643,
-0.1011796445,
0.2166944593,
-0.7542674541,
-0.0274236724,
0.148618415,
-0.1333476603,
-0.0916827321,
-0.2646646202,
-0.2862145603,
0.0695794746,
0.4932589531,
-0.260581404,
0.3675894737,
0.0849730074,
0.2478271872,
-0.2927500904,
0.32391873,
0.6251890063,
0.709670186,
-0.0442999192,
-0.0345834345,
0.2229631841,
-0.0259816665,
0.0162362587,
0.0622519664,
0.220130071,
-0.2501749992,
0.038108848,
1.0027990341,
0.0815838575,
-0.9667803049,
0.4705990255,
-0.3604750931,
-0.2757853568,
-0.2956672013,
-0.0572317876,
0.564231813,
0.2394505143,
0.2300258875,
-0.1469653696,
0.1033183336,
-0.678242743,
0.2500647008,
0.3897986114,
-0.2431629747,
-0.1853922307,
0.665514648,
0.6009193063,
-0.7034723163,
0.4756442904,
-0.3863395154,
-0.4357176125,
0.8129011989,
0.872636497,
0.7619666457,
-0.0802558139,
0.2970258594,
0.239431411,
0.3151454926,
-0.2847936451,
0.3689044118,
0.049504742,
-0.7131676078,
-0.5481594801,
-0.5097866058,
-0.6904697418,
0.1240024865,
-0.5459737182,
0.375916332,
-0.0276006125,
-0.1874284744,
-0.3169480562,
-0.2756156325,
-0.845197022,
-0.0233170968,
0.3864918351,
0.9388148189,
-0.9335862398,
0.4994651377,
0.790988028,
0.0150415525,
-1.0505847931,
0.3049299419,
0.0155820753,
-0.6603997946,
0.6581423879,
0.3234607875,
-0.1324329227,
0.158839941,
-0.5320795774,
-0.8678995967,
0.8788845539,
0.4425712228,
-0.7740618587,
0.1850734502,
0.0483469032,
0.5992259383,
-0.7788541317,
0.4368778765,
0.122396104,
0.5207214952,
0.1515018791,
-0.9454084039,
-0.0930692926,
-0.4345827997,
0.1344528049,
-0.0418291055,
-0.5448598862,
0.6787622571,
-0.3828055263,
-0.3832087815,
0.2294220477,
0.7816615701,
0.5481109023,
0.2053816915,
0.6296169758,
0.3935981095,
0.5146580935,
-0.0281411894,
1.2089197636,
-0.3130056262,
0.2852782309,
1.08956182,
-0.5124461651,
0.6976071,
0.4460805357,
0.0874739438,
0.2271829545,
0.5659474134,
0.4036437869,
0.3306584954,
0.7409979105,
-0.332495451,
-0.5136666298,
-0.1293951422,
-0.1637140661,
0.4598428011,
0.6250882745,
-0.2469979227,
-0.3106889129,
0.1582279354,
-0.0105036311,
0.5493289828,
0.0116431285,
0.664167881,
0.2130072266,
-0.8854103088,
0.2767440379,
0.0476672351,
0.5691874623,
-0.5675400496,
-0.3913778961,
-0.0054577789,
0.1203220561,
0.2128108442,
-0.6672251821,
0.0883191675,
-0.1209603995,
0.2164296806,
-0.569565773,
0.7454570532,
-0.8098320961,
-0.278508544,
0.4027592242,
0.6690048575,
0.3430053294,
-0.0212074332,
-0.4666991532,
0.3783515394,
0.0453427434,
-0.4837837517,
0.4355292916,
0.2806735039,
0.0617475137,
0.7621895671,
0.6632752419,
0.1604814082,
-0.0506992824,
0.178901419,
0.9073418379,
-0.3863604665,
-0.7915690541,
-0.5921147466,
0.3899015784,
-0.586684227,
-0.3000261784,
0.6459368467,
0.4295013547,
0.8589158058,
-0.013381538,
1.0121762753,
0.0965762213,
0.4614635408,
-0.2975296676,
0.40844962,
-0.2792058587,
0.3057629466,
-0.2876413167,
-0.9550257325,
0.0519994646,
0.7565424442,
-0.4401886165,
0.2374872565,
0.3255960047,
0.7526015043,
-0.1340115517,
0.1803305149,
0.5825119615,
0.124063611,
0.8120233417,
0.6052927971,
1.1750086546,
-0.0505867563,
0.498060137,
-0.0147251356,
-0.3452621698,
-0.2407213897,
-1.0327072144,
-0.9820395112,
-0.4860216975,
-0.0353851467,
-0.2586255968,
0.1770794243,
1.3569629192,
0.8982150555,
-0.1037241966,
-0.5967546701,
-0.0519984961,
-0.4350357354,
-0.1084349453,
-0.2470902056,
-0.2758705616,
-0.2067266554,
-0.9664298892,
0.4615846574,
0.2078502327,
0.0928524956,
-0.1826497316,
-0.2220514715,
0.0308449697,
0.3358545601,
0.5582702756,
0.3150717616,
-0.6958098412,
-0.2824739516,
-0.0216350667,
0.1196240783,
-0.1273543537,
0.8733882904,
-0.8597085476,
0.6130921841,
0.1995621622,
0.5097125173,
0.5890111923,
0.3486506045,
0.9688301086,
-0.5419794321,
0.0219749715,
0.1596739292,
0.1591851264,
0.4314092398,
-0.490296483,
0.3816725612,
-0.3868891001,
-0.4456796944,
-0.7292551994,
0.5853108168,
-0.7489789724,
-0.2612852156,
1.5482424498,
-0.1378310621,
0.1402697265,
0.0844080374,
-0.2909015417,
-0.0578358732,
-0.6583343744,
0.7714127898,
0.7919284105,
-0.3547507226,
-0.1908627301,
-0.4109182954,
0.3495299816,
0.3665722311,
-1.1500378847,
0.2205312699,
0.4336851239,
0.2282245457,
0.0420308821,
1.0143736601,
0.2417957634,
-0.091134496,
-0.0873705223,
-0.1785147935,
0.0908422023,
-0.1712478101,
-0.3268250525,
-0.1092382595,
0.1713741869,
0.2532169223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00686v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00686v1
|
Little Giants: Exploring the Potential of Small LLMs as Evaluation Metrics in Summarization in the Eval4NLP 2023 Shared Task
| 2023-11-01T17:44:35 | 2023-11-01T17:44:35 |
Neema Kotonya, Saran Krishnasamy, Joel Tetreault, Alejandro Jaimes
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper describes and analyzes our participation in the 2023 Eval4NLP
shared task, which focuses on assessing the effectiveness of prompt-based
techniques to empower Large Language Models to handle the task of quality
estimation, particularly in the context of evaluating machine translations and
summaries. We conducted systematic experiments with various prompting
techniques, including standard prompting, prompts informed by annotator
instructions, and innovative chain-of-thought prompting. In addition, we
integrated these approaches with zero-shot and one-shot learning methods to
maximize the efficacy of our evaluation procedures. Our work reveals that
combining these approaches using a "small", open source model (orca_mini_v3_7B)
yields competitive results.
|
[
-0.6124967337,
-0.6504511237,
0.7415646911,
0.0769767687,
-0.2776808143,
-0.0396618396,
-0.3506790698,
-0.5556396842,
0.5072333217,
0.333414644,
-0.574409008,
-0.2282367945,
-0.4451732039,
0.620541811,
-0.2002136856,
1.2600218058,
0.0113346754,
-0.0493866727,
-0.023633983,
-0.2315800786,
-0.5934841037,
-0.0211317632,
-0.9227967262,
-0.1187289432,
0.8323978186,
0.7020357847,
0.6986007094,
0.4671325982,
0.4440051317,
0.2181641161,
-0.3718242049,
0.3329262435,
-0.415156275,
-0.2731303573,
-0.0499656312,
-0.5196832418,
-0.7256981134,
0.067054823,
0.9526094198,
0.8571055532,
-0.0705710128,
0.6444773674,
0.4859704673,
0.6580711007,
-0.388268739,
0.1208534315,
-0.3286508322,
0.2146269083,
0.1365015805,
-0.1377274841,
-0.0831989646,
-0.4211401939,
-0.0197243635,
-0.201581493,
0.1334101707,
0.4642086923,
0.577093184,
0.3575504124,
-0.1136506125,
-0.593836844,
-0.1847066879,
1.1066782475,
-0.8080926538,
-0.0599141829,
0.1674661636,
0.2613199949,
0.0289722234,
-0.5870435238,
-0.5386368036,
-0.3196922243,
-0.2527534664,
0.2103211433,
-0.4961462915,
-0.0301302578,
0.1642592847,
0.4469803572,
-0.488368541,
0.5272218585,
-0.5958676934,
-0.0563587174,
0.7107927799,
0.439686954,
0.3100670874,
-0.458622843,
-0.2684874535,
0.3254470527,
-0.9156572819,
0.1172202751,
0.3176396191,
0.4475658238,
-0.4476985931,
0.6230563521,
-0.2717754543,
0.5589766502,
-0.024089573,
-0.0406494886,
-0.0381129421,
-0.7328007221,
-0.3026680052,
-0.1213822737,
0.95025599,
0.5030662417,
-0.2817336917,
0.0170386862,
-0.4924808741,
-0.2297126353,
-0.0727468431,
-0.605096817,
-0.1361334324,
0.1245925501,
-0.69334656,
-0.3666852415,
-0.2770503759,
-0.9493101239,
-0.2078463137,
-0.3738548756,
0.6514156461,
0.0671586916,
0.1345864981,
-0.1993762553,
-0.088076055,
-0.069272764,
0.4132549465,
-1.1111344099,
0.3913591802,
0.6904281378,
1.0464211702,
-0.4508332908,
-0.3755230606,
-0.7395771146,
-0.2659234703,
-0.5576891899,
0.8596333861,
-0.0300705507,
-0.513292551,
-0.2323284447,
-0.2027444243,
0.0268725492,
-0.6539179683,
0.4821758568,
-0.2958016694,
0.2400648296,
-0.4326856434,
-0.2892328501,
-0.1587615013,
0.4783723354,
-0.9184413552,
0.8821111321,
0.0310636107,
-0.5391963124,
0.2606731057,
-0.8374083042,
0.044276271,
0.1449179798,
-0.2881668508,
-0.3038351536,
0.6063297987,
0.5191404819,
0.458951503,
-0.3875476122,
-0.2104557753,
-0.0070135235,
-0.4460039735,
0.008965061,
-0.3935976028,
0.5216938257,
0.1326618195,
0.0650897324,
0.5169136524,
-0.1199659184,
0.0625771955,
0.1023750976,
-0.1816998422,
-0.0832102597,
-0.4953108728,
-0.2819081247,
-0.0747048035,
0.4575473964,
-0.0369761884,
0.370901823,
-0.5997091532,
0.2772230804,
0.5797140002,
0.3535102904,
0.5587651134,
-0.3837356865,
0.8967419267,
-0.4962120652,
0.2537685335,
-0.321390748,
-0.5275004506,
-0.6610181928,
-0.194334805,
0.4250126779,
0.0730602145,
-1.02944839,
0.1017503142,
-0.3322622478,
-0.5211025476,
-0.4955815971,
0.2902483344,
0.5156428814,
0.2537475526,
0.2892464399,
-0.1973934323,
-0.4357114732,
-0.946039319,
-0.2738801539,
-0.3109983802,
-0.2359986156,
0.1436175853,
0.8265252113,
-0.0219649766,
0.7771354318,
-0.3857811391,
-0.361854881,
-0.933509171,
0.3581213057,
0.5082185864,
0.2541831136,
0.5735414028,
-0.4465176165,
-0.4962404072,
-0.3612015843,
-0.6687648296,
-0.2265269458,
0.146062538,
0.2983489037,
0.1033803299,
0.2703643143,
-0.3438260853,
0.0028591636,
0.8851556778,
-0.136596486,
0.7646100521,
-0.2178355604,
0.3524225354,
-0.6466603875,
-0.0948341638,
-0.0420108885,
-0.3113152385,
-0.4843663871,
0.2409034222,
-0.1348126531,
-0.100204818,
-0.6650220156,
0.6838558316,
-0.4881772399,
-0.3943891823,
-0.3636887968,
0.5812199116,
-0.0185955595,
0.3325698972,
-0.1183460802,
1.0398494005,
0.1538452655,
-0.5845255256,
0.1646559834,
-0.0326183476,
-0.4043962657,
0.6042218208,
-0.7998005748,
0.0788791552,
0.112751238,
0.1635698378,
-0.7792760134,
-0.2623884678,
0.2254330665,
-0.4187858999,
0.1375186294,
-0.0029452867,
-0.6978000998,
-0.5079962015,
-0.7634911537,
0.2841646075,
0.5512320399,
-0.6616488695,
0.2962285876,
0.4598124921,
-0.5569032431,
-0.2657030821,
-0.5130678415,
0.3408457041,
-0.4429065585,
-0.4523124099,
0.1503311694,
-0.2212429196,
-0.3553880155,
0.162386626,
-0.1633277684,
0.1598353833,
0.1190257072,
0.0201070644,
0.4455320835,
-0.2862131894,
-0.2537490726,
0.1316357255,
-0.3693279922,
-0.0428430922,
-0.0138540296,
0.2697149217,
-0.5992134809,
-0.2836749554,
-0.5457974076,
0.2263395041,
-0.104563646,
0.1762139797,
0.2565359473,
0.3727805316,
-0.2251375467,
-0.3612570763,
-0.3700416684,
-0.298435837,
-0.4429289401,
0.2477217466,
-0.1215175241,
-1.1896922588,
0.2916220129,
0.0327425152,
0.1688659638,
0.693908155,
0.6372101903,
-0.3606097996,
1.0304869413,
0.8511405587,
-0.0487343818,
0.2274024636,
-0.3792817593,
-0.0494767241,
-1.0415160656,
0.1745529622,
-0.5291171074,
-0.4166930616,
-0.3056493998,
-0.6740822196,
0.8310045004,
0.337913841,
0.280821383,
0.3419080079,
-0.3073168397,
0.9061556458,
0.2910285294,
-0.2149909288,
0.4643841088,
-0.2831061482,
0.1307717711,
-0.1348118484,
-0.8308173418,
-0.8685190082,
0.8483620882,
0.4360141754,
0.4703832865,
0.0486605987,
0.7990563512,
0.5193933845,
0.4020184577,
-0.9833732843,
0.7612286806,
0.1890081465,
-0.2902003825,
-0.6123580337,
-0.4139527082,
-0.9310306311,
0.4966827333,
0.0650446489,
-0.9181160331,
-0.1933704615,
0.2444684356,
-0.9492088556,
-0.0107418597,
-0.4825417697,
0.8580792546,
-0.1020330042,
-0.0329922102,
-0.3323076367,
-0.2989939451,
0.5108981133,
-0.0940028355,
0.3761380017,
0.0248334613,
-0.4399634302,
1.1294945478,
-0.1101512089,
0.8308899999,
0.0761635974,
-0.0605511628,
0.5803687572,
0.0378447324,
0.6149870157,
0.0654825568,
-0.08546561,
0.5142706037,
0.1628693342,
-0.2876000106,
-0.6104335785,
0.7497065663,
-0.5190930367,
-0.432136327,
-0.3286788762,
-0.3358373046,
-0.0341908,
0.1138994321,
0.113001734,
0.0308574457,
-0.2127773762,
0.1356510222,
0.2591202259,
-0.2209739536,
0.8192085624,
0.6202251315,
-0.4135682583,
-0.6108251214,
0.9105851054,
0.2854521871,
0.2576625943,
0.1263367087,
0.4354262054,
-0.1678632349,
-0.7368832231,
-0.6777986884,
0.4261302352,
-0.7237173915,
-0.1662479788,
-0.4529395103,
0.1623027027,
0.0509216152,
-0.267680198,
-0.3554649949,
-0.4243552387,
-0.1356433928,
-0.2430411577,
-0.2648351789,
1.0271422863,
-0.252042532,
0.5291002989,
-0.8476301432,
0.1889601201,
0.3060514629,
-0.1428602487,
0.1118179634,
-0.6444525123,
-0.7290722728,
-0.3206247985,
-0.2453314513,
-0.7104256153,
0.6068876386,
-0.2531099021,
0.5156840086,
0.0876540691,
-0.0892350748,
0.6052446365,
-0.5210162401,
1.5363742113,
0.4422041476,
-1.0589207411,
0.4923265278,
-0.1529313326,
0.2682904005,
0.7090565562,
0.1672773957,
-0.4013767242,
-0.2021658719,
-0.7516611814,
-0.6229506135,
0.7159855366,
0.2552142143,
-0.0491248146,
0.1522124559,
0.014806129,
0.2274714261,
0.5096283555,
-0.5247778296,
-0.0676128119,
0.5305116773,
-0.0708972141,
-0.0075025824,
-0.4815805852,
-0.2147192061,
0.0757571757,
0.5990934968,
-0.4079990983,
0.1723427624,
-0.1067603007,
-0.0586452074,
-0.1491553783,
0.3308921158,
0.624643147,
0.6869038939,
0.0743814111,
0.1470339745,
0.855083704,
-0.0721396953,
-0.2447982877,
-0.3362872899,
-0.2160321921,
0.1376511753,
0.6354264617,
0.6323688626,
0.4676789939,
-0.5628315806,
0.585909307,
-0.1384521872,
0.1364141405,
-0.3721602857,
0.1070933864,
-0.221863687,
0.325434804,
0.2651522458,
-0.1188378111,
0.3259502947,
-0.4904080331,
-0.0517986342,
0.2718292773,
-0.5830913782,
-0.6987982988,
0.5097234249,
0.2756140232,
-0.3055401742,
0.0618184954,
-0.4580941796,
-0.3531043828,
0.6988069415,
0.1827715188,
0.8342760801,
0.0292553548,
0.0614628755,
0.4147479832,
0.5406420231,
-0.2170224339,
0.3250516653,
-0.0883390084,
-0.3179615438,
-0.6632717848,
-0.5570428371,
-0.8159798384,
0.0633327961,
-0.5958346725,
0.4493603706,
-0.1523688734,
0.064166002,
-0.0551089831,
0.2921048701,
-0.7990280986,
-0.0095965415,
0.1017488688,
0.8028439879,
-0.8522921205,
0.5267903805,
0.4848851562,
-0.8352278471,
-0.8281890154,
0.0133142043,
0.3963223398,
-0.8260961771,
0.7605907917,
0.2116751373,
-0.0817370117,
0.0134769902,
-0.6458871365,
-0.8391038179,
1.1103532314,
0.0004668263,
-0.5318780541,
-0.2617528439,
-0.2500616312,
0.4781552851,
-0.4103949368,
0.3858336508,
0.7820807099,
0.5190207362,
-0.1893581897,
-1.2354625463,
-0.0374249555,
0.1415990442,
-0.0037896466,
-0.000018915,
-0.6675908566,
0.7013692856,
-0.407820791,
-0.2668372989,
0.4797555208,
0.9498457313,
0.4903794527,
0.4992203414,
0.6563864946,
0.1703877002,
0.7152483463,
-0.0776890665,
1.2016100883,
-0.0650613233,
0.5415959954,
1.2167828083,
0.0759234503,
0.8805230856,
0.6188123226,
-0.419577837,
0.1698675901,
0.5739218593,
-0.0394533984,
0.3394282162,
0.0384114198,
-0.0930200219,
0.0857825503,
-0.3411293626,
-0.1369769573,
0.0656588227,
0.5028113723,
-0.265417546,
-0.2710484266,
-0.028519325,
0.1011290923,
-0.0806467608,
-0.6107685566,
0.9020883441,
0.4879593551,
-0.7219523191,
0.288282305,
0.014213521,
0.7357990742,
-0.3975529671,
-0.047081776,
-0.2284088582,
-0.2498249263,
-0.3270178139,
-0.9239068627,
0.4131265879,
0.2341727167,
-0.034392152,
-0.2114727944,
0.3742997944,
-0.2558929026,
-0.342042774,
0.0027003721,
0.5261374116,
0.5254481435,
0.007493645,
-0.6669735909,
0.3515284956,
-0.0414285883,
-0.355976969,
0.34247756,
0.4431644976,
0.0368982963,
0.3385168612,
0.4949541092,
0.5772539973,
-0.3014692664,
0.2125318348,
0.5900089741,
-0.6153221726,
-0.6069025397,
-1.0291393995,
0.5299841762,
-0.1006271541,
-0.0573912449,
1.2264851332,
0.5087707043,
0.6583636999,
-0.1276531368,
0.6474025249,
0.0496197715,
0.5379040837,
-0.6270952225,
0.5179094076,
-0.5585282445,
0.498606205,
-0.165731892,
-0.9734550118,
-0.2332451493,
0.2267725468,
-0.4189460278,
-0.1238548681,
0.8623587489,
0.5853580236,
0.1597137302,
0.1553043127,
0.5800467134,
0.0467211381,
0.3895769715,
0.3910329938,
0.9854050875,
-0.2317277938,
0.5181460977,
-0.155153811,
-0.229416579,
-0.5512288809,
-1.0597262383,
-0.7938404679,
-0.2212078124,
-0.3393549919,
-0.1528970897,
-0.1410816163,
1.1790276766,
0.409748137,
-0.6843862534,
-0.236310944,
0.2375713736,
0.3524410427,
-0.3974597752,
-0.1706000865,
0.5930092335,
-0.421967864,
-1.0527118444,
0.7174779177,
0.5636940002,
-0.0521601029,
-0.5573522449,
-0.0991266146,
0.5343583822,
0.001076019,
0.6791167855,
0.2434482723,
-0.8878473639,
-0.2979717553,
-0.3461325765,
-0.0178172737,
-0.3238381445,
0.525262773,
-0.6750763059,
0.3036930859,
0.5752828717,
0.3932372332,
0.1616629213,
0.0918618739,
0.3966318369,
-0.7447199225,
-0.0666386038,
0.4448087513,
0.4495824873,
0.2514738739,
-0.1143561229,
0.8046041131,
-0.0396090075,
-0.7484945059,
-1.0256797075,
0.0214421842,
-0.7886471152,
0.0100654885,
1.1037261486,
-0.0823549852,
-0.3174269795,
0.2510233223,
-0.3610949516,
-0.1741965562,
-0.454357177,
0.7177895308,
0.4215166271,
-0.423119992,
-0.2005535066,
-0.9749641418,
0.4767580032,
0.2087980658,
-0.8617807031,
-0.2196902037,
0.5609199405,
-0.0032412233,
0.3460512161,
0.7357776165,
0.0633058622,
0.183963716,
-0.0880337805,
-0.098831147,
-0.0651893318,
-0.4405167103,
-0.8334180117,
0.2162255645,
0.2007137686,
0.031694781
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00684v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00684v2
|
Attention Alignment and Flexible Positional Embeddings Improve Transformer Length Extrapolation
| 2023-11-01T17:43:35 | 2023-11-15T15:55:02 |
Ta-Chung Chi, Ting-Han Fan, Alexander I. Rudnicky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
An ideal length-extrapolatable Transformer language model can handle
sequences longer than the training length without any fine-tuning. Such
long-context utilization capability relies heavily on a flexible positional
embedding design. Upon investigating the flexibility of existing large
pre-trained Transformer language models, we find that the T5 family deserves a
closer look, as its positional embeddings capture rich and flexible attention
patterns. However, T5 suffers from the dispersed attention issue: the longer
the input sequence, the flatter the attention distribution. To alleviate the
issue, we propose two attention alignment strategies via temperature scaling.
Our findings show improvement on the long-context utilization capability of T5
on language modeling, retrieval, multi-document question answering, and code
completion tasks without any fine-tuning. This suggests that a flexible
positional embedding design and attention alignment can go a long way toward
Transformer length extrapolation.
|
[
-0.5176584721,
-0.2476365715,
0.6216020584,
0.2652302682,
-0.1942861229,
0.0794678852,
-0.5191164613,
-0.4171433151,
0.2304293811,
0.2287259549,
-0.2927036881,
-0.1914103478,
-0.7163239121,
-0.0883989632,
-0.3202774823,
0.6510574222,
-0.0911918506,
-0.6193342209,
0.0376652218,
-0.250336498,
-0.2860917151,
-0.2269127518,
-0.2839312255,
-0.1698863953,
0.736638248,
0.6203830838,
1.1138410568,
0.8795284033,
0.6552908421,
0.2985391915,
0.0173357446,
-0.081111595,
-0.4575028718,
0.1910839528,
0.0217643138,
-0.3281953633,
-0.4809130132,
-0.2625618279,
0.750133574,
0.4725365341,
-0.3156384528,
0.2214081734,
-0.1161166057,
0.4561890066,
-0.6240499616,
-0.050639011,
-0.4174601138,
-0.037257161,
-0.0456538945,
0.0891049951,
-0.5134947896,
-0.230502516,
0.3668663204,
-0.5036661029,
0.3063594103,
-0.1502758265,
0.7871906161,
0.6906884909,
-0.4357874691,
0.2227409333,
-1.0433652401,
0.9753119946,
-0.5060025454,
0.8853086233,
0.0184729509,
0.427269876,
0.2403903604,
-0.7181328535,
-0.6036422849,
0.1622037441,
-0.0983961299,
0.0105983829,
-0.0388891064,
0.0346842222,
0.3442857265,
0.0956356972,
-0.3343431056,
-0.0242223553,
-0.5147839785,
0.1431675404,
0.3823152184,
-0.0812207162,
0.0795884952,
0.3273607194,
-0.1389130354,
-0.2033418715,
-0.5009788275,
0.1420651823,
0.077504307,
0.1152061597,
-0.0525954254,
0.352897346,
0.1815814674,
0.6851487756,
0.397544682,
0.0303192828,
0.3893969953,
0.0085103959,
-0.328233391,
0.0342965387,
0.3855836391,
0.3125434518,
0.1486762911,
-0.3281924725,
0.0411482602,
-0.2480893135,
0.7317803502,
-0.6682577133,
-0.0607552975,
0.4302564263,
-0.1768100262,
-0.0059483373,
0.0579638258,
-0.6320000887,
0.0124376388,
-0.2333047092,
0.0260819197,
-0.3087027967,
-0.2336291671,
0.0503611788,
-0.1537516862,
0.5556303263,
0.0704568103,
-1.3660974503,
0.0786368698,
0.590873301,
0.6857401729,
-0.300337404,
-0.1947337091,
-0.0787725002,
0.5863806009,
-0.1660599858,
0.728055656,
-1.0733970404,
-0.175029546,
-0.1631322503,
0.1309193373,
-0.2021521926,
-0.1497056037,
0.5364145637,
-0.7607398033,
0.4609808028,
-0.1416180581,
-0.3277957141,
-0.0355788879,
0.3300728798,
-0.7274974585,
0.8925743699,
0.2985964119,
-0.7093780041,
0.287730962,
-0.8655549288,
-0.3736111522,
-0.0612327829,
0.0208540522,
-0.7168735862,
0.1955939829,
0.2977196872,
0.4713395834,
-0.0368649103,
0.032067243,
-0.3884098828,
-0.3576435447,
0.0945356041,
-0.3044205904,
0.2313625664,
0.1427458376,
-0.5156741738,
0.2817805409,
-0.4351856709,
0.3124949038,
0.0693950951,
-0.338684082,
-0.0963394642,
-0.1606911123,
0.2474457324,
0.2627587914,
0.2108751684,
-0.4981673658,
0.3253173232,
-0.4712027609,
0.6031699777,
0.449175477,
-0.4714666903,
0.8404543996,
-0.0959371552,
0.7145782113,
0.0933092609,
0.2142420262,
-0.2499037832,
-0.0359559469,
-0.7600582838,
-0.1923279315,
0.3291207254,
0.3596194386,
-0.5413522124,
0.3646598458,
-0.6888150573,
-0.5620708466,
-0.6190960407,
-0.0517179146,
0.2481234521,
0.2634522915,
0.5895568132,
0.0975156128,
-0.4312069714,
-0.9361671209,
-0.1471627355,
0.3765418828,
-0.0852898583,
0.1852519214,
0.0165707786,
-0.1813062578,
0.9877027869,
-0.6172442436,
-0.1084900796,
-0.3587031066,
-0.3527509868,
0.080590345,
0.2776771784,
0.5444127321,
-0.9251176715,
-0.6454662085,
0.0804197267,
-0.3305337429,
0.2540673614,
0.2430776358,
0.1467541456,
0.4091600776,
0.4637588561,
-0.6134728789,
0.1267445087,
0.6240327358,
-0.0933539048,
-0.215559721,
-0.1885986179,
-0.1062547043,
-1.3989925385,
0.1661194563,
-0.0229415707,
-0.3791579902,
-0.7928826809,
0.1492760032,
0.5064271688,
-0.1336949468,
-0.5616189837,
0.3319609761,
-0.6269093156,
-0.0439573862,
-0.2589839697,
0.083445631,
0.0656912327,
0.4351869524,
0.1911015511,
0.503164053,
0.3063878715,
-0.3436173201,
0.4675349593,
-0.0016291095,
0.0255104378,
0.2301093638,
-0.8392884135,
0.4370975196,
-0.0725305378,
0.5623267889,
-1.0858697891,
-0.2567510605,
-0.0913453549,
-0.1621405333,
0.7057441473,
0.0336387642,
-0.1978029013,
-0.5308155417,
-0.5523405075,
0.6299327612,
0.4943992794,
-0.4267258346,
0.6716570258,
0.2995261848,
-0.0464417413,
-0.8228295445,
-0.6017966866,
-0.1636524647,
-0.6364073157,
-0.6240339875,
0.7048575878,
0.1734963208,
0.1092475429,
-0.2048001885,
-0.1113019288,
0.0196612347,
-0.1478147656,
-0.0253099538,
-0.0488577671,
-0.3743471503,
0.1577387303,
-0.0058526718,
-0.2168637365,
-0.3348464668,
-0.3696280122,
0.6284194589,
-0.1752638817,
-0.1353561431,
-0.2581698596,
0.4760628939,
0.9970017672,
-0.2194711119,
0.8387774229,
0.7436967492,
-0.3087658286,
0.0373636,
-0.7941592336,
-0.1495427787,
-0.5193424821,
0.2843137681,
-0.5216274261,
-0.9283611774,
0.5918734074,
0.1667398214,
0.325355947,
0.3528360426,
0.3773638606,
-0.1118842512,
1.1289473772,
1.1979650259,
-0.0629066229,
0.72805655,
-0.0852505043,
0.471585691,
-1.1102781296,
-0.1735165417,
-0.3189186454,
-0.7489128709,
-0.6268488765,
-0.4106117785,
0.2688649893,
-0.3350791633,
-0.3434816003,
0.5997439623,
-0.7590630054,
0.7510737181,
0.2246839702,
0.0182013959,
-0.2038985491,
-0.0249165315,
0.0728292614,
-0.2451721579,
-0.7152014375,
-0.2414793372,
0.7391762733,
0.6102311015,
0.7442305088,
0.3085733354,
0.4362308681,
-0.3099496961,
0.1647598296,
-0.886130929,
0.006722691,
-0.2682006955,
-0.3820335269,
-0.7506143451,
-0.059883412,
-0.9346880913,
0.1419205964,
0.5867621303,
-0.7488999963,
0.2100627571,
0.1179860979,
-0.615321219,
0.1311236173,
-0.9890818,
0.8782569766,
0.0276941732,
-0.2360958904,
-0.0077807689,
-0.8638761044,
-0.1079947427,
0.0087563572,
-0.0633123517,
0.1950709969,
-0.2392592132,
0.5087490082,
-0.182534948,
0.7613877058,
-0.0546695739,
-0.3598073423,
-0.0013297468,
-0.1636352837,
0.5153753161,
-0.102542989,
-0.0248145647,
-0.2033458799,
-0.0243794173,
-0.7337403297,
-0.8247406483,
0.678602457,
-0.8630589247,
-0.9069644213,
-0.1480438709,
-0.6457792521,
-0.4101755917,
0.2046450227,
0.4543724358,
0.1571356803,
0.007644082,
0.6014034748,
0.8020087481,
0.1345298588,
0.8578983545,
0.316087693,
0.0790353566,
-0.1737725288,
0.7113830447,
0.1937875003,
0.322715193,
0.6208987832,
0.1698150337,
-0.5314324498,
-0.0582600236,
-0.395419836,
0.1288593709,
-0.5727882385,
-0.1266725808,
-0.8861037493,
-0.2256900519,
-0.7185787559,
-0.4167014658,
-0.631046176,
-0.516335547,
-0.1824964136,
-0.2422946841,
0.4898737669,
0.5960231423,
0.3548880219,
0.403385222,
-0.7664518952,
0.1688328981,
0.1389490068,
0.5794478059,
-0.0305603053,
-0.8090456128,
-0.3274765015,
-0.1848891675,
-0.4812972546,
-0.568973124,
0.2918598652,
0.2924202383,
0.3685406446,
0.3180959225,
-0.0028415625,
0.6787815094,
-0.5598720312,
0.6781064868,
0.1811757088,
-1.0515505075,
0.3899433315,
-0.4194208384,
0.9540163279,
0.2494176477,
0.3792312145,
-0.576087296,
-0.4326893389,
-0.7882621288,
-1.0180851221,
0.7938005328,
0.0752481595,
0.4125403762,
0.2322164923,
0.3193003237,
0.0648323223,
0.0015004827,
-0.4087074995,
-0.110011518,
-0.4601738155,
-0.419891715,
-0.1241546497,
-0.2566785812,
-0.0779128894,
-0.2488120794,
0.3551767766,
-0.3887447715,
0.5418679714,
-0.0087448619,
-0.0291900821,
-0.0832835585,
0.3792574108,
1.0161603689,
0.7350800037,
-0.0548445955,
0.2713978589,
0.3342207074,
-0.5238467455,
0.1348710805,
0.0934017003,
0.2638032734,
-0.2146127522,
0.2078729123,
0.7185115814,
0.2074635476,
-0.124343954,
0.2966687083,
-0.1845067739,
0.0305377152,
-0.2735300958,
0.0980769917,
0.4349489808,
0.2903307378,
0.1575349271,
-0.1383861452,
-0.1283099949,
-0.3456999958,
0.2704987228,
0.136539638,
-0.5362090468,
-0.4449255764,
0.5336024761,
0.1725077927,
-0.2578391433,
0.6608220935,
0.475745976,
-0.69882828,
0.7708240747,
0.7265432477,
0.6781830192,
-0.6680985093,
0.0178629756,
-0.0064594643,
0.2223714888,
-0.0707067847,
0.2181042433,
-0.2776464224,
-0.730204165,
-0.2911250293,
-0.2584758997,
-0.2987940013,
-0.0357756205,
-0.5510472655,
0.3196641207,
-0.5134368539,
-0.1805893481,
-0.0148476632,
-0.1680992991,
-0.7361232042,
0.3456809819,
0.2922182083,
0.5858203769,
-0.5145351887,
1.1242147684,
0.7952138782,
-0.0402293056,
-1.068531394,
0.1581726074,
-0.4452509582,
-0.6377444863,
0.3615096211,
0.5151883364,
-0.2501840293,
0.173549667,
-0.3085052669,
-1.3779131174,
1.289462328,
0.6165752411,
-0.6928744912,
-0.2657376528,
0.214494288,
0.736435771,
-0.3706303835,
0.4101872146,
0.6808520555,
0.3374575973,
0.3461672366,
-1.0630306005,
0.2371883243,
-0.1914505213,
0.2063620687,
0.5008528829,
-1.2316213846,
0.3339043856,
-0.3507947028,
-0.0704002902,
-0.4063178301,
0.7406352162,
-0.1838929504,
-0.0443066545,
0.386582762,
0.6959651113,
0.6031725407,
-0.1706951559,
1.0665419102,
-0.3353693783,
0.5115298033,
1.0383672714,
-0.3755290508,
0.8966055512,
0.6450347304,
0.0143161882,
0.4218400717,
0.6136225462,
0.0579823405,
0.5983878374,
-0.0093840463,
0.0212898124,
-0.1710518301,
0.0253491085,
-0.5554781556,
0.3425660133,
0.5494711399,
-0.5293828845,
-0.0224433169,
0.1086467803,
-0.1720282137,
-0.3367605209,
0.0491757728,
0.7046858072,
0.2556952536,
-0.8949168921,
0.6952599883,
0.0193876997,
0.5310069919,
-0.2062007934,
0.3090182543,
-0.1596062034,
0.4921401739,
-0.3088769019,
-0.8363523483,
0.6929345131,
-0.1899142414,
-0.4585624337,
-0.5303915143,
0.5229161978,
-0.4406216741,
-0.3210192323,
0.2558285892,
0.0843245983,
-0.1184242368,
0.0135675287,
-0.4123513103,
0.1430993974,
-0.0993435532,
-0.686440587,
0.1849060059,
0.3973368704,
-0.1415646076,
0.5990661383,
0.1542500705,
-0.5365450382,
0.3018401265,
0.1700555384,
0.8512716293,
-0.5727915168,
-0.5322785378,
-0.9278208613,
0.4354038239,
0.1283602268,
-0.1281138659,
0.325678885,
0.3328157961,
0.5656158328,
-0.0702898204,
0.6358336806,
-0.0874174759,
0.2142925411,
-0.1903268993,
0.5209266543,
-0.5433793664,
-0.0428302996,
-0.0172166079,
-1.3427647352,
-0.6383069754,
0.4350484908,
-0.5602405667,
0.2603675127,
0.8318671584,
0.3683791459,
-0.5556216836,
-0.07054355,
0.6194884181,
-0.0679179356,
0.5585845113,
0.6938528419,
0.5168405175,
-0.5416374207,
0.7316798568,
-0.1833195537,
0.0813902318,
-0.2553289533,
-0.7186614871,
-0.7317091823,
-0.5881700516,
-0.2012998015,
-0.2110802233,
-0.1896709502,
0.8603435159,
0.8540590405,
-0.7055494785,
0.1989426613,
0.065829359,
-0.0481075719,
-0.0777959898,
-0.263050586,
0.5321881771,
-0.2870330811,
-0.933583796,
0.1095321178,
0.3242302835,
0.2098656446,
-0.1128013432,
0.2513962686,
0.1063240543,
0.0521678701,
0.5581675172,
0.3085456491,
-0.7679131031,
-0.5819388628,
0.4034493864,
-0.2911121249,
0.2844493389,
0.8051017523,
-0.4799412489,
0.2365239412,
0.5696828365,
0.812286377,
0.430742532,
0.1089952141,
0.9892073274,
-0.9384358525,
0.1548036039,
0.2071787864,
0.1859261394,
0.4716839492,
-0.631115675,
0.2750889361,
-0.2499076724,
-0.5090565681,
-0.4551436603,
0.3585033417,
-1.043540597,
0.018123256,
1.174503684,
-0.3315457702,
-0.3348713815,
-0.1274378747,
-0.0425567888,
0.4527561963,
-0.5430400372,
0.9818566442,
0.9001767039,
-0.2227489799,
-0.5779189467,
-0.1861884147,
0.3914766312,
0.7285078168,
-0.5960036516,
0.0868083537,
-0.1715735495,
0.3368340433,
0.5852792859,
0.1444368362,
-0.0840005204,
0.2609188855,
-0.3940984607,
-0.1998330802,
0.0799832717,
-0.5218225718,
-0.4127044678,
0.4582579136,
-0.0383968428,
-0.1212101281
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00681v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00681v1
|
Are Large Language Models Reliable Judges? A Study on the Factuality Evaluation Capabilities of LLMs
| 2023-11-01T17:42:45 | 2023-11-01T17:42:45 |
Xue-Yong Fu, Md Tahmid Rahman Laskar, Cheng Chen, Shashi Bhushan TN
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have gained immense attention
due to their notable emergent capabilities, surpassing those seen in earlier
language models. A particularly intriguing application of LLMs is their role as
evaluators for texts produced by various generative models.
In this study, we delve into the potential of LLMs as reliable assessors of
factual consistency in summaries generated by text-generation models.
Initially, we introduce an innovative approach for factuality assessment using
LLMs. This entails employing a singular LLM for the entirety of the
question-answering-based factuality scoring process. Following this, we examine
the efficacy of various LLMs in direct factuality scoring, benchmarking them
against traditional measures and human annotations.
Contrary to initial expectations, our results indicate a lack of significant
correlations between factuality metrics and human evaluations, specifically for
GPT-4 and PaLM-2. Notable correlations were only observed with GPT-3.5 across
two factuality subcategories. These consistent findings across various factual
error categories suggest a fundamental limitation in the current LLMs'
capability to accurately gauge factuality.
This version presents the information more concisely while maintaining the
main points and findings of the original text.
|
[
-0.1694461256,
-0.7770840526,
1.0664329529,
0.1703172773,
-0.34569031,
0.1221811473,
-0.434743166,
-0.5050400496,
0.0516852699,
0.4359852672,
-0.0238212645,
-0.5484485626,
-0.7435469627,
0.3824512362,
-0.5120837092,
1.2345614433,
-0.0019192876,
-0.0760269612,
-0.6095424891,
-0.3229628503,
-0.3179285228,
-0.5953746438,
-0.2960995138,
-0.387887001,
0.6374426484,
0.2526949048,
0.8086091876,
0.4913389981,
0.5648894906,
0.338622421,
-0.1496240199,
0.3866836727,
-0.4082356691,
0.1472900361,
-0.3065249622,
-0.4852612913,
-0.4670231044,
0.3436562419,
0.8297681212,
0.6872031689,
-0.0411663651,
0.2372673899,
0.0046930057,
0.5275154114,
-0.4745310545,
0.0586653203,
-0.7667823434,
0.0592780001,
-0.1413526237,
-0.1587527096,
-0.5653960109,
-0.823726058,
0.2123224139,
-0.1885783076,
0.4815860093,
0.0621922091,
0.8192061782,
0.1684898883,
-0.6306807995,
-0.4584460855,
-0.8234421611,
0.7442284226,
-0.7955765128,
0.0975500122,
0.2277229428,
0.2307745218,
-0.0036907608,
-0.6020720005,
-0.7174658179,
-0.7525450587,
-0.1551613361,
0.2618023157,
0.0066354047,
-0.0344693996,
0.4050828516,
0.4986329973,
-0.4777033925,
0.3980212808,
-0.1791867763,
-0.3406819999,
0.6460279226,
0.2071043402,
0.1772947162,
-0.3810958862,
-0.5062654614,
0.3118964136,
-0.8544710875,
-0.161802426,
0.3872508109,
0.1874534935,
-0.1557011306,
0.8585858941,
-0.1253135204,
0.4482373595,
-0.018475771,
-0.5306996107,
-0.0403597094,
-0.447178483,
-0.1626695096,
-0.0543468222,
0.7609825134,
0.4799976647,
0.1078284308,
-0.3364364207,
-0.3366448581,
0.0203245077,
0.2021243721,
-0.6858571768,
-0.1223873049,
0.1401150972,
-0.1819165498,
-0.468164891,
0.3585404754,
-0.5523335934,
-0.654065311,
-0.3352190852,
0.317658931,
-0.1103301346,
-0.1486186534,
-0.1327697039,
0.0504495315,
0.250913173,
0.6350755692,
-0.7637349963,
0.3196280599,
0.6822004914,
0.6937682629,
-0.2947134972,
-0.1356612593,
-0.6347724199,
-0.0118485084,
-0.5064254403,
0.8195115924,
-0.162345916,
-0.4047892392,
0.1332914084,
-0.209145993,
-0.0734307021,
-0.5602505803,
1.0275889635,
-0.7432422638,
0.135829106,
-0.613463819,
-0.7580212951,
-0.2470490187,
0.606620729,
-0.6576693654,
0.8018833995,
-0.1354638934,
-0.7745861411,
0.6136769056,
-0.1669652164,
-0.3914200068,
0.1755684316,
-0.2597241402,
-0.4603304565,
0.1913971603,
-0.0058667846,
0.4339315593,
-0.5203927755,
0.4797308743,
-0.350952208,
-0.4239704907,
0.6661428809,
-0.9056591392,
0.3614258766,
-0.0975283533,
-0.3714069724,
-0.0189105775,
-0.6769601703,
-0.143472746,
-0.0098774945,
-0.6177154183,
0.0939940438,
0.1628590971,
-0.1239867508,
0.1001230925,
0.3386984468,
-0.5733845234,
0.1140030101,
-0.2112956345,
-0.0097264741,
0.7500430942,
0.0280251987,
0.0235539284,
-0.4174494147,
0.4119604826,
-0.1374813616,
-0.179822728,
-0.0232440066,
-0.4889139235,
-0.8422115445,
-0.2988670766,
0.6415827274,
0.5079628229,
-0.5496191382,
0.7143657207,
-0.522269845,
-0.6287189126,
-0.0088864146,
0.2629358768,
0.4441029727,
0.5231037736,
0.026941102,
-0.1781783104,
-0.3944965303,
-0.9355068803,
-0.3684127927,
-0.4679979086,
-0.0486980863,
-0.0080394475,
0.5565855503,
-0.0326289944,
1.0229719877,
-0.1288612187,
0.1398158371,
-0.3115791678,
0.1713586003,
0.2591287792,
0.111634776,
0.5271282196,
-0.7624973059,
-0.3146881759,
-0.0304430462,
-1.0559163094,
-0.1691875011,
-0.1088631973,
0.4182657599,
0.3840569854,
0.1773712784,
-0.90754807,
0.2144708782,
0.4843707681,
-0.3119856119,
0.9951013327,
-0.32983464,
0.2673926651,
-0.6689535975,
0.2111728042,
0.1905907393,
-0.5105506778,
-0.4023522139,
-0.0800017193,
0.0844999105,
0.3603807092,
-0.2311922461,
0.48239851,
-0.2677522898,
-0.244246006,
-0.2615447342,
0.5581661463,
0.0787754133,
0.1959268302,
-0.3356016278,
0.6216149926,
0.1460009962,
-0.5477415919,
0.5322208405,
0.0441756919,
-0.6382646561,
0.580176115,
-0.6301897764,
0.1419637203,
-0.0656429827,
0.3271925449,
-1.0436753035,
-0.358846128,
0.1061646417,
-0.2937601209,
0.3740257025,
-0.1290441453,
-0.9389775991,
-0.2426939905,
-0.4884336293,
0.0014570551,
0.4949204326,
-0.6184773445,
0.496178627,
0.2240849286,
-0.3701119423,
-0.484195739,
-0.4447829127,
0.3432971835,
-0.1616275162,
-0.5998942852,
-0.1420334578,
-0.0513328873,
-0.543399632,
-0.1113541275,
-0.3430827856,
0.2598923743,
0.1575978845,
0.2124167979,
0.5855723023,
-0.2458929121,
0.1828674227,
-0.0784567669,
0.1361104846,
0.2621360123,
0.0821038634,
0.1206907108,
-0.2419821471,
-0.5795291662,
-0.4236456454,
-0.0965388045,
0.698292315,
0.0085775908,
0.7178711295,
0.3686474562,
-0.1911604106,
0.0437429696,
-1.1198263168,
0.2126966119,
-0.4071722925,
0.308565706,
-0.2981092632,
-0.9251919389,
0.3959061801,
0.0384379663,
0.1671183854,
0.8137892485,
0.6284649372,
-0.0692603588,
0.7204526067,
0.3268817663,
-0.0217645857,
-0.1384718567,
0.1177622527,
0.1222490519,
-0.6462547183,
-0.2845731676,
-0.4415886998,
0.0533417538,
-0.6821984053,
-0.2920250297,
0.3950989842,
0.0575563274,
-0.0551947951,
-0.0759000778,
0.133855179,
0.5154661536,
0.1793646067,
0.0221823175,
0.5746600032,
-0.0826734081,
-0.1900529265,
0.0652885661,
-0.5385913849,
-1.0403087139,
1.2148048878,
0.5493602157,
0.5072839856,
0.2446814626,
0.3579849899,
0.5433830023,
0.8228877783,
-0.6274282336,
0.6645868421,
-0.1572897732,
-0.5724065304,
-0.224183321,
-0.6164069176,
-0.4522105157,
0.4316370487,
-0.3745657504,
-0.6614148617,
-0.1375418901,
0.0422640443,
-0.4196004868,
0.4237165749,
-0.6190159321,
0.6356963515,
-0.3675629795,
-0.4443618953,
-0.1000601202,
-0.5746195316,
0.7632004619,
-0.2880991697,
0.2210675478,
-0.274327755,
-0.0330120213,
0.7231070995,
-0.3036013246,
0.9784052372,
-0.0883898661,
-0.4028930068,
0.4367936254,
0.0526751317,
0.483293891,
0.3219151795,
-0.1702571511,
0.2296687067,
-0.1043261737,
-0.3006005585,
-0.6866227984,
0.7289461493,
-0.6908991337,
-0.8409720659,
-0.6709024906,
-0.3008533716,
-0.4582205415,
0.0883907601,
0.0047027129,
0.5321289301,
-0.5019701719,
0.1931137741,
0.6279518604,
-0.1002178192,
0.1423428506,
0.600338757,
-0.2700648606,
-0.3661670983,
0.8165104985,
0.0072862455,
0.2704585791,
0.4205482304,
0.2910237908,
-0.537054956,
-0.7009626031,
-0.5216610432,
0.4033638537,
-0.828296423,
-0.0715752095,
-0.5018677711,
-0.171765551,
-0.2121350616,
0.1492249817,
-0.2208446115,
-0.4692480266,
0.0036335716,
-0.466655314,
0.0007096335,
0.998106122,
0.106326811,
-0.0469521061,
-0.8333932757,
0.3228437006,
0.5643793941,
0.1701971442,
-0.2054490745,
-0.8422980309,
-0.1653826833,
-0.0697726756,
-0.250341475,
-0.4706408083,
-0.1610471755,
-0.129329145,
0.4727571011,
0.4999506474,
-0.1615869701,
0.2037094384,
-0.4243662059,
0.9712817669,
0.2296621948,
-0.8286089897,
0.154479146,
-0.3373495042,
0.1034475788,
0.4860474169,
0.2269084007,
-0.334384352,
-0.4711955488,
-0.5210224986,
-0.4174393117,
0.4775589406,
0.23770307,
0.0154036842,
0.058391504,
0.5350455642,
0.3337231278,
0.2802471519,
-0.6637277007,
-0.0692545101,
0.0831313357,
-0.0917160511,
-0.2541749179,
-0.7896144986,
-0.1882779598,
-0.0602280162,
0.6110752821,
-0.0237005278,
-0.2279406935,
0.1866135597,
-0.0758109912,
-0.0266397037,
0.4375967383,
0.6903675199,
0.9466012716,
-0.1970878094,
0.2627680898,
0.4104374647,
-0.4178495407,
0.1630809754,
0.0428183228,
-0.3308039904,
0.1441399753,
0.7752675414,
0.6443607211,
0.3345082104,
-0.752792418,
0.6728308797,
-0.0594136603,
-0.1835899502,
-0.4388293326,
0.0335478038,
0.136863485,
0.1361347139,
0.294654876,
0.1601093262,
-0.1227628514,
-0.66948843,
-0.0290518329,
0.3900101781,
-0.0846851617,
-0.4316264391,
0.6116259098,
0.3114543557,
0.1004373878,
0.4275151193,
-0.3041187227,
-0.5882692337,
0.6349262595,
0.2454043776,
0.836777091,
0.0109243104,
0.2367499173,
0.2617652416,
0.5433834195,
-0.3072900474,
-0.0413493067,
-0.0213461947,
-0.9561513066,
-0.5246632695,
-0.7802138329,
-0.7856832743,
0.0267246123,
-0.3097498417,
0.1378835291,
-0.4830724299,
-0.2215715498,
-0.0812724531,
0.1148796603,
-0.477833122,
0.3764247894,
0.2513065934,
0.7934552431,
-0.7573811412,
0.5783292651,
0.5425325632,
-0.3377037048,
-0.6507620215,
0.1889295578,
0.0246729739,
-0.4079575241,
0.572714448,
0.1762365848,
-0.205034256,
-0.5531243682,
-0.3876599669,
-0.6638528705,
1.0020925999,
0.5689349771,
-0.6263252497,
0.0226564556,
0.2189604491,
0.663667202,
-0.0689740106,
0.3385647237,
0.6309590936,
0.6429422498,
0.1079092622,
-0.9790924788,
0.1288015246,
-0.0004072585,
-0.0356888957,
-0.185797289,
-0.6366176009,
0.5386523008,
-0.3653942943,
-0.2664098442,
0.3254719079,
0.8418092132,
0.4235492051,
0.2895733416,
0.5469269753,
0.4509379864,
0.942092061,
-0.149394393,
1.3332852125,
-0.1879401356,
0.4539416134,
1.0483365059,
-0.567048192,
0.6186296344,
0.1770961434,
-0.4616860151,
0.4517262578,
0.312248528,
-0.1229065433,
-0.0165916868,
0.1607449651,
-0.4626373351,
-0.3235637844,
0.1037208959,
0.0337873586,
0.3847770095,
0.1531609148,
-0.2389735132,
-0.1793722212,
-0.4018004239,
0.2056307197,
0.2164017409,
-0.2482151389,
0.4405439496,
0.1161664128,
-0.6934908032,
0.3068419695,
0.2165269107,
0.5257653594,
-0.5540995598,
0.1001623049,
-0.232124716,
-0.0049741436,
-0.2873134613,
-0.7388215065,
0.1197625548,
0.4240714908,
-0.2011642158,
0.1242164895,
0.6726212502,
-0.2403463572,
-0.6333091855,
-0.0870775878,
0.5412287116,
0.1901237965,
0.069234997,
-0.1864863187,
0.1665459424,
-0.1609990448,
-0.2284091413,
0.1440249085,
0.5209332705,
0.091931954,
0.5415074229,
0.5095902085,
0.1334223747,
0.023232013,
0.1826615036,
0.5114235878,
-0.6444104314,
-0.1068939567,
-1.0606353283,
0.2388303429,
-0.2249932289,
-0.3392407894,
1.1405645609,
0.7412961125,
0.4898305833,
-0.0035748624,
0.962194562,
0.0887620747,
0.6072615981,
-0.7757027745,
0.6175990105,
-0.1298025995,
0.5238531828,
-0.1156985983,
-1.084176898,
-0.2419584841,
0.1505853236,
-0.4538809955,
0.3165442348,
0.7461801171,
0.5123271942,
0.1413950026,
0.2462774664,
0.505641818,
0.4735271633,
0.3773191571,
0.1144841313,
1.079954505,
-0.2118026018,
0.3614578843,
0.0837190226,
-0.2855098546,
-0.2089343369,
-0.8393082023,
-0.97067976,
-0.1471066028,
-0.4351142943,
-0.229354009,
0.0166683458,
0.7316915393,
0.2461512834,
-0.7270351648,
-0.0978063568,
0.1306963861,
0.2433874309,
0.1915536672,
-0.2207591534,
0.4993153811,
-0.3324858844,
-0.6361545324,
0.3632224798,
0.4437542856,
-0.1179147959,
-0.4350880086,
0.0480767861,
-0.0108346632,
0.1518478096,
0.8472131491,
0.1618329585,
-0.8058196306,
-0.6548618078,
-0.460359931,
-0.2714189291,
-0.117800802,
0.7202356458,
-0.6089866757,
0.2281592786,
0.1355743855,
0.6031726599,
0.3537767529,
0.2256082594,
0.3978994489,
-0.4350888133,
-0.2390631437,
0.1964819133,
0.5337411761,
0.7030306458,
-0.0927731022,
0.4078965783,
0.5013189912,
-0.6516284943,
-0.6782768369,
0.0693221539,
-1.1302464008,
0.1937884986,
1.3200302124,
-0.2232143581,
-0.0357373096,
-0.0656794533,
-0.063622199,
0.0131304376,
-0.0157798398,
0.8840377331,
0.9042253494,
0.0654698834,
0.2206728309,
-0.6307909489,
0.1570501477,
0.3224452436,
-0.7037314773,
0.0423255824,
0.552108407,
0.5246016979,
0.2424262762,
0.5861501694,
-0.2108837366,
0.2064620703,
-0.0701969266,
-0.119033508,
0.1550805569,
-0.2004527748,
-0.2721683383,
0.2184808552,
0.4303252697,
0.169508487
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00671v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00671v1
|
Emotion Detection for Misinformation: A Review
| 2023-11-01T17:21:09 | 2023-11-01T17:21:09 |
Zhiwei Liu, Tianlin Zhang, Kailai Yang, Paul Thompson, Zeping Yu, Sophia Ananiadou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the advent of social media, an increasing number of netizens are sharing
and reading posts and news online. However, the huge volumes of misinformation
(e.g., fake news and rumors) that flood the internet can adversely affect
people's lives, and have resulted in the emergence of rumor and fake news
detection as a hot research topic. The emotions and sentiments of netizens, as
expressed in social media posts and news, constitute important factors that can
help to distinguish fake news from genuine news and to understand the spread of
rumors. This article comprehensively reviews emotion-based methods for
misinformation detection. We begin by explaining the strong links between
emotions and misinformation. We subsequently provide a detailed analysis of a
range of misinformation detection methods that employ a variety of emotion,
sentiment and stance-based features, and describe their strengths and
weaknesses. Finally, we discuss a number of ongoing challenges in emotion-based
misinformation detection based on large language models and suggest future
research directions, including data collection (multi-platform, multilingual),
annotation, benchmark, multimodality, and interpretability.
|
[
-0.4976786077,
-0.798271358,
0.5503377318,
0.4304345548,
-0.1826821715,
0.1139700711,
0.0439330526,
-0.897968173,
0.5816233754,
0.0356978066,
-0.3976332247,
-0.2857356071,
-0.8221141696,
0.0846667364,
-0.5127168298,
0.6802886128,
-0.2037372291,
0.1735869348,
-0.1285282075,
-0.1764300764,
0.0821912289,
-0.5624266267,
-0.4283599854,
-0.035268575,
0.5795628428,
0.5101354122,
0.6287751794,
0.1327475607,
0.2669586241,
0.1828306466,
-0.2021366805,
-0.0441880077,
-0.3371807933,
0.275156498,
0.3028798699,
-0.7053362727,
-0.0318709463,
0.2461315989,
0.2397292256,
0.0695333108,
-0.2781861722,
0.1007207558,
-0.4471478462,
0.7130821943,
-0.8162862659,
-0.2015934885,
-0.2564150095,
0.3155121803,
-0.3654552698,
-0.1973346025,
-0.1867796928,
-0.571696341,
0.1252430528,
-0.3229741156,
0.1864626408,
0.2814134359,
0.740332365,
0.0977756456,
-0.7550269365,
-0.7535312176,
-0.5765698552,
0.4721662104,
-0.6325827241,
0.725191474,
0.2127478123,
0.1985298395,
0.2502062321,
-0.2601735294,
-1.0020381212,
-0.1602559388,
0.2900847197,
0.4361689091,
-0.460185051,
-0.2492201328,
0.4748041332,
0.4615452588,
-0.6027297378,
-0.117992878,
-0.2876440287,
-0.2131127715,
0.4528345764,
-0.3404152393,
0.5160733461,
-0.4010412693,
-0.3966717124,
-0.1346004307,
-0.6055222154,
-0.164135471,
0.9657250047,
-0.0490772799,
-0.1719972193,
0.3377692103,
-0.238321498,
0.285122931,
0.2357930541,
-0.0478724986,
0.5218619108,
0.2797592878,
-0.0990366638,
0.4518523812,
0.5486857891,
0.5086510777,
0.437310636,
0.1995724589,
-0.143803671,
0.5305701494,
0.1910907775,
-0.5685279369,
0.0697512254,
0.294924885,
-0.7289664149,
-0.4134112298,
0.0593245849,
-1.1949453354,
-0.8649815321,
-0.1608791053,
0.2892234027,
-0.3013629317,
-0.5934508443,
0.0590829104,
-0.3671293557,
-0.0181155633,
0.5715900064,
-0.389819622,
0.0048135053,
0.4215868413,
0.8394820094,
0.0857850164,
-0.0432334654,
-0.2895208001,
-0.3001707196,
-0.3641326129,
0.9388466477,
-0.5238554478,
-0.0341307707,
0.3091804683,
0.0255793929,
0.0958748236,
-0.3393188119,
0.6386162639,
-0.4007354975,
0.3514865637,
-0.5817575455,
-0.5032601357,
-0.4161216617,
0.3075411618,
-0.7854130268,
0.8986825943,
-0.0288182292,
-1.0504207611,
0.3576072454,
-0.5284746289,
-0.5725032091,
-0.2669311166,
0.432068646,
-0.2513387203,
0.5478838086,
0.1821547747,
0.2962704003,
-0.0901890174,
-0.1890023947,
-0.5861091018,
-0.2830703557,
0.3130091727,
-0.4757446349,
0.3029829264,
0.3793280125,
-0.6225423217,
-0.2475924939,
-0.2798240185,
-0.3567735553,
-0.0744689927,
0.0000249878,
-0.2896846831,
0.0865991786,
-0.0592340864,
0.4268870056,
-0.0161644667,
-0.5490603447,
-0.0014422421,
-0.0156486109,
-0.0424010083,
0.4458804727,
0.2338556945,
0.1036407053,
-0.0579754151,
0.5789190531,
0.5083473325,
0.5114882588,
-0.0514679924,
-0.3338464499,
-0.7917523384,
0.3884966671,
0.1503357589,
0.7779193521,
-0.7735103965,
0.1841824055,
0.372551769,
-0.5599605441,
-0.7572557926,
-0.1489886194,
0.0487300754,
0.4323444963,
0.3885067999,
-0.0265928432,
-0.444167912,
-0.6572389603,
-0.7284063697,
-0.218674913,
0.2558921874,
-0.0377810039,
0.2161811441,
-0.0104908142,
0.481279701,
-0.3458608985,
0.011964052,
0.0311990138,
0.8013653159,
-0.1693950444,
0.0088369725,
0.6927953362,
-1.2178207636,
-0.5686826706,
0.017548956,
-0.7714637518,
-0.3190234005,
-0.0642150119,
0.2472580671,
0.5618860126,
0.3914976716,
-0.6760642529,
0.5961439013,
0.5416214466,
-0.1859789491,
0.575091958,
0.1365907639,
0.804125309,
-0.7859848142,
-0.2021076679,
0.7268947959,
-0.148104161,
-0.7987972498,
-0.2963288724,
0.1642408818,
0.1557910591,
-0.5426808,
0.3573540151,
-0.6784558296,
-0.0132951327,
-0.8037960529,
0.083962962,
-0.2551737726,
-0.0923536718,
0.0906668603,
0.2205281258,
0.5984182954,
-0.4085876644,
0.6419090629,
-0.2588420808,
-0.2233033031,
1.015622139,
-0.173858285,
-0.0566043183,
-0.5465338826,
0.4161691964,
-0.7988240719,
-0.4074214399,
0.6722999811,
-0.7803040743,
0.1199864522,
-0.1598205864,
-0.7580217123,
-0.6221289039,
-0.4029603601,
-0.2206476033,
0.385319382,
-0.4662067592,
0.6199536324,
0.2820011079,
-0.0732447952,
-0.4712706506,
-0.4684077799,
0.2658509314,
-0.415502876,
-0.5305563211,
-0.2600674927,
-0.0797687098,
-0.5828744173,
0.1512186974,
-0.5120618939,
-0.2420487553,
-0.0336856581,
0.5721646547,
-0.150669992,
-0.0814340189,
0.5024901628,
0.0299589466,
-0.0006526063,
0.0914996415,
-0.0043760552,
0.2680143714,
-0.2788850069,
-0.3460122347,
-0.3937530518,
0.5095732212,
0.7558425069,
-0.0462296754,
0.7774099708,
1.1121053696,
-0.700275898,
-0.1306610107,
-0.9336610436,
-0.2876790166,
-0.3861881793,
0.1743646264,
0.0913291946,
-0.7154136896,
0.2524577975,
-0.3880153894,
-0.5957235098,
0.5661391616,
0.1830521226,
-0.3509015739,
0.9735258818,
0.7315092087,
-0.4121067226,
0.426546365,
0.4786165953,
0.5375487804,
-0.293972224,
-0.0817959458,
-0.502613008,
-0.5596703291,
-0.4428626299,
-0.2403080314,
0.1299270242,
0.2976790667,
0.2527288795,
-0.1150422543,
-0.3421568573,
0.4007182121,
0.309994787,
-0.1631388366,
0.1142342463,
0.1332401931,
0.4828683734,
-0.0528541505,
-0.6313070059,
-0.3230530322,
0.5338218808,
0.4278694689,
0.6983326077,
0.1109544486,
0.3149951994,
0.5877408981,
0.7806333899,
-0.6417186856,
0.1492638886,
-0.0444937237,
-0.7116584778,
0.0562155433,
-0.3760489225,
-0.3746531308,
-0.0753561035,
-0.5407637358,
-0.7977762222,
0.3036847115,
0.3228806555,
-0.0633842275,
0.5439052582,
-0.8584997654,
0.53865695,
-0.4601463377,
-0.0116852773,
-0.3077478707,
-0.8501856923,
0.4824829698,
-0.1501671076,
0.3691117465,
-0.2024735808,
0.2703652978,
0.6125366688,
-0.0055584251,
0.7195897698,
-0.4433667362,
0.0604700744,
0.4000414014,
0.0861175284,
0.4719435573,
-0.126520589,
0.0108345607,
0.1790674031,
-0.2437435091,
-0.0528261513,
-0.4850939512,
0.6411467195,
-0.5290369391,
-0.2609138787,
-0.5724345446,
-0.3720857203,
-0.1659080535,
-0.2730383873,
0.3468189538,
0.0228907298,
0.0161774941,
0.086452961,
0.8600125909,
-0.3051715493,
0.3282048702,
0.5255165696,
-0.202491492,
-0.1026511937,
0.9320106506,
0.2444270104,
-0.070874013,
0.1679300219,
0.2879416645,
-0.2159064263,
-0.1844835579,
-0.1372148693,
0.2252170742,
-0.6935942173,
-0.0312279295,
-0.6614155769,
-0.0226790272,
-0.3741644025,
-0.0220139064,
-0.3532766104,
0.0218868554,
-0.3987700641,
-0.2110383511,
0.8452679515,
0.8867036104,
-0.3829655945,
0.6366688013,
-0.7296590209,
0.5790793896,
0.1332377791,
0.3390785754,
0.0694637373,
-0.2734545171,
-0.2638444901,
0.0966022164,
-0.1875562966,
-1.5344851017,
0.6151763201,
-0.2343516797,
0.2426936328,
0.7972424626,
0.1600391865,
0.3868270516,
0.0645365119,
0.7226982117,
0.2168448865,
-1.0499072075,
0.3877196312,
-0.2301661372,
-0.1561220139,
0.2357622981,
1.048768878,
-1.2526571751,
-0.1175676733,
-0.6806740761,
-0.7408146858,
0.5122951269,
-0.0804603025,
-0.0730968192,
-0.0142774004,
0.2540655434,
-0.019920757,
0.4261579514,
-0.9223159552,
-0.2729761899,
-0.3938696384,
-0.2539067864,
0.1727054268,
-0.5168938637,
0.1706925929,
0.1810144782,
0.6090208292,
0.0246936623,
0.2163047642,
0.1575639695,
-0.3181565404,
-0.4425645173,
0.2052302808,
0.6094229817,
0.2040659487,
-0.2553845346,
0.2445187718,
0.1053451151,
-0.3374073505,
0.0965523943,
0.0495199561,
0.1024136394,
0.287269026,
0.1253716052,
0.7699308991,
-0.0086997077,
-0.3067378402,
0.782921195,
0.1006924659,
-0.3382847011,
-0.2154469192,
-0.4545647204,
0.3515160382,
0.4666434526,
0.5235862136,
0.308968395,
0.2597108185,
-0.6374794841,
-0.0147579201,
0.1391351819,
-0.6458531022,
-0.6060305238,
0.2987489104,
0.2983086109,
-0.0642132759,
0.3906719387,
-0.2903138101,
-0.8861999512,
0.5527344942,
0.250192225,
0.8641156554,
-0.7347226739,
0.4805026948,
-0.0019594505,
0.582136631,
-0.5646766424,
0.435374558,
0.3387959003,
-0.7843777537,
-0.078870371,
-0.3143778443,
-0.38528198,
0.217348367,
-0.3320913911,
0.093692787,
-0.2022625506,
-0.1500683278,
-0.1294783503,
-0.1151816994,
-0.5150695443,
0.4400775135,
0.6264862418,
1.0739363432,
-1.1017987728,
0.2279320061,
0.6268097162,
-0.191075936,
-0.5067302585,
0.7523294091,
0.6821525097,
-0.2045897245,
0.5323140025,
0.4159930646,
-0.1341151595,
-0.4465715587,
-0.8388777971,
-0.6628508568,
0.5698018074,
0.2598686516,
-0.5185872316,
0.3883874416,
-0.090221256,
0.569227159,
-0.2193655372,
0.4989476502,
0.1759392619,
0.8918306828,
0.0213921517,
-0.5813025832,
-0.3966400921,
-0.2829564512,
-0.4513952136,
0.171349287,
-0.7236634493,
0.9773982763,
0.2695944607,
-0.377069056,
-0.504827559,
0.7140583992,
-0.0528533086,
0.7429594994,
0.8351349831,
0.5209118724,
0.8130593896,
-0.2460788339,
0.9782329798,
-0.4554705918,
0.1775195152,
0.6125375032,
-0.5224567056,
0.6999325752,
0.1867518723,
0.1579763591,
0.5684697032,
0.8863261342,
0.0435403511,
0.0018493644,
0.3049590588,
-0.4318114817,
-0.1798492819,
-0.1755301803,
-0.4146834016,
0.3425981402,
0.5742263198,
-0.1634962857,
-0.2281636745,
0.1579589397,
0.1723680794,
-0.1687607616,
-0.4203337431,
0.2595119774,
0.1290735602,
-0.2743597329,
-0.1974526495,
0.0654066876,
0.8384361267,
-0.4676357806,
0.0477224737,
-0.2963518798,
-0.1086659804,
-0.4089181423,
-0.6852408648,
0.2065468282,
0.2627321482,
-0.211184904,
-0.1274988055,
1.2342748642,
-0.5366861224,
-0.2595653236,
0.3514034748,
0.6234132051,
0.2006147355,
-0.7009746432,
-0.4192132354,
0.1970900297,
-0.0438730307,
-0.5564917922,
0.0493300147,
0.8200842738,
-0.0232919306,
0.631852448,
0.5817422271,
0.0614504851,
-0.0243507624,
0.0640861467,
0.5418552756,
-0.8261987567,
-0.5085203052,
-0.689648509,
0.3173544109,
-0.3433541954,
-0.2008183897,
0.7236046791,
0.1913556755,
0.2988601029,
-0.2225596607,
1.0134689808,
0.0633314401,
0.6043081284,
-0.2350542545,
0.8487744331,
-0.7130225897,
-0.3236225843,
-0.4784967899,
-0.9923639894,
-0.1780590266,
0.5096906424,
-0.3063504398,
0.0393082835,
0.6191783547,
0.4583871067,
-0.0101954853,
0.4121944308,
0.1174503341,
0.4040474594,
-0.0942717642,
0.2871623635,
1.1257270575,
-0.2364852726,
0.3379712403,
0.0040618167,
-0.248391673,
-0.7865570188,
-1.0313593149,
-0.4294731915,
-0.3732463717,
-0.522197485,
-0.3672129512,
0.0332033448,
0.708823204,
0.6348867416,
-0.5989091396,
0.0075911679,
0.2926013768,
0.4295902252,
-0.0816609412,
-0.2877150774,
-0.0419712365,
0.0920185521,
-0.4771898389,
0.3476507962,
0.5362540483,
0.1942172199,
-0.0115096197,
-0.1272989362,
-0.2598385811,
0.4929982424,
0.4699239135,
0.5524768829,
-0.5098316073,
-0.4209406376,
-0.1573021263,
-0.0859954134,
-0.1047822982,
0.6082528234,
-0.5681172013,
0.4543733299,
0.4103721678,
0.3023857176,
0.4018825889,
0.0862730443,
0.315782994,
-0.6794639826,
-0.0439690873,
-0.031132983,
0.3244050443,
0.473292172,
-0.5213781595,
0.2457231879,
0.5571679473,
-0.3476078808,
-0.7852674723,
0.2009408772,
-1.0029004812,
-0.227571547,
1.017637372,
0.2140334249,
-0.2908340991,
0.0587080531,
-0.1429840475,
0.3898670077,
-0.5573667288,
1.0323479176,
0.9706825614,
-0.0259158686,
-0.3420737684,
-0.5913889408,
0.5178933144,
0.109224014,
-1.1015715599,
0.076594308,
0.5508983731,
0.0887510106,
0.3721934557,
0.2381449342,
0.2148856819,
0.3608741462,
0.0875662565,
0.4922688603,
0.191772297,
-0.3095009923,
-0.3527751863,
0.2682791054,
-0.5377753377,
0.1009838432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00658v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00658v1
|
Explicit Morphological Knowledge Improves Pre-training of Language Models for Hebrew
| 2023-11-01T17:02:49 | 2023-11-01T17:02:49 |
Eylon Gueta, Omer Goldman, Reut Tsarfaty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Pre-trained language models (PLMs) have shown remarkable successes in
acquiring a wide range of linguistic knowledge, relying solely on
self-supervised training on text streams. Nevertheless, the effectiveness of
this language-agnostic approach has been frequently questioned for its
sub-optimal performance when applied to morphologically-rich languages (MRLs).
We investigate the hypothesis that incorporating explicit morphological
knowledge in the pre-training phase can improve the performance of PLMs for
MRLs. We propose various morphologically driven tokenization methods enabling
the model to leverage morphological cues beyond raw text. We pre-train multiple
language models utilizing the different methods and evaluate them on Hebrew, a
language with complex and highly ambiguous morphology. Our experiments show
that morphologically driven tokenization demonstrates improved results compared
to a standard language-agnostic tokenization, on a benchmark of both semantic
and morphologic tasks. These findings suggest that incorporating morphological
knowledge holds the potential for further improving PLMs for morphologically
rich languages.
|
[
-0.2183164358,
-0.5928500295,
0.4551002979,
0.3596470654,
-0.7434177995,
0.0421728007,
-0.1933320016,
-0.3038246334,
0.2151766419,
0.3265484571,
-0.1319374293,
-0.5192561746,
-0.6627752185,
0.1576353461,
-0.2920173705,
0.7084354162,
0.0665105954,
0.5298954844,
-0.0544458255,
-0.0360572711,
-0.2411518097,
-0.6979594827,
-0.4954437315,
-0.2602558136,
0.526540935,
-0.3112787306,
0.9043413401,
1.1922591925,
0.3615803123,
0.3374354541,
-0.1820323467,
0.1967409849,
0.0953944251,
0.1613631099,
-0.2744812965,
-0.6566869617,
-0.2471686304,
-0.1670156121,
0.7150035501,
0.8245461583,
-0.139936775,
-0.0221891496,
-0.2553852499,
0.4134116173,
-0.7067378759,
0.1052978262,
-0.8348918557,
0.4991717935,
-0.5199157596,
-0.4835452735,
-0.4280490875,
-0.0684649348,
0.1151182801,
-0.6020479202,
0.1103730276,
-0.0900090784,
0.7532216311,
0.5184623003,
-0.1795193404,
-0.2511410117,
-0.5442327857,
0.5570626855,
-0.6329290867,
0.8113306761,
0.6397851706,
-0.1964281052,
0.0166758262,
-0.8275141716,
-0.2949695885,
-0.4532288313,
-0.2918474078,
0.1770415008,
-0.1018379778,
0.2859381735,
0.1083837003,
0.3005726933,
-0.3654331565,
0.3827885985,
-0.3073737621,
-0.4564962089,
0.1604760438,
0.0111579467,
0.7032131553,
-0.2387707531,
-0.2888922691,
-0.0789584517,
-0.8577346206,
0.1626526117,
0.4366838634,
0.347581923,
0.0351977162,
0.7422394753,
0.1203272492,
0.7974669337,
-0.1813813299,
0.1124195904,
0.4045080543,
-0.5549606681,
0.0603947192,
0.1299232394,
0.5367133021,
-0.3062423468,
0.453112036,
-0.3665827513,
-0.327390641,
-0.0330549292,
0.446824789,
-0.8339034915,
-0.0192158539,
-0.0424125046,
-0.484269619,
0.0336449221,
0.166443482,
-0.3876590431,
-0.2583480775,
-0.415525049,
0.3205387592,
-0.7703766823,
-0.4209838808,
0.3553898036,
-0.1926379651,
0.2562662959,
0.3768185377,
-1.0942078829,
0.1058932692,
0.7795905471,
0.8926662207,
-0.0041896161,
-0.4999320209,
-0.7986139059,
0.2538623512,
-0.6587966084,
0.7169454098,
-0.7216879129,
-0.275408268,
0.018651206,
-0.4806114435,
-0.2059247792,
-0.6969275475,
0.1765152961,
-0.4433862865,
-0.154381156,
0.273588866,
-0.5602551103,
0.2843776047,
0.0438123755,
-0.3954681158,
0.8928185105,
-0.0027650485,
-0.7716915011,
0.4851510823,
-0.5410377979,
-0.7691032887,
0.2808264196,
-0.3691538572,
-0.0923377499,
0.6781020164,
0.152996704,
0.5391936898,
0.4154368043,
0.4981948435,
0.1383007765,
-0.235618487,
0.0790006816,
-0.2950322926,
0.448794663,
0.1474080384,
-0.3744074404,
0.3674185276,
-0.592069149,
0.0595530383,
0.0600807257,
-0.3224539161,
-0.6342930794,
-0.0582390651,
-0.4114364684,
0.0315475762,
0.1852156818,
-0.3710432351,
-0.032873977,
-0.9542720914,
0.2763339877,
0.8280076981,
-0.503755033,
0.5561112165,
0.0229444858,
0.4060512781,
0.2999005914,
0.1234284192,
-0.4731484056,
-0.4279100001,
-0.8733763099,
-0.4284205139,
0.4718664885,
0.2888224721,
-0.6531652212,
0.5528563857,
-0.2992649376,
-0.4026600718,
-0.6504346728,
0.1227094382,
0.5826678872,
0.2146657258,
0.5391392112,
-0.7294842601,
-0.4769155085,
-0.8367630839,
-0.4371802807,
-0.3292686641,
0.0939624161,
0.0727175549,
0.4283778965,
-0.2275890857,
0.9875801206,
-0.1974343359,
-0.1960759908,
-0.3385721147,
0.2748471797,
-0.1776902974,
0.6609792113,
0.4155235589,
-0.7200293541,
-0.3944613934,
0.1391724646,
-0.3480103314,
0.0771704763,
0.1084044501,
0.037211068,
0.1023486182,
0.6778250933,
-0.8406922221,
0.5930880904,
0.446950525,
-0.4772208333,
0.6309748292,
-0.6332531571,
-0.1592290699,
-0.836879611,
0.0994027406,
-0.0947057083,
-0.282515049,
-1.0402443409,
0.1281005591,
0.1771038175,
0.024116125,
-0.6336354613,
1.0284065008,
-0.365275532,
-0.3312426805,
-0.2916254401,
-0.1863892376,
-0.2246936262,
0.3460601866,
0.535415411,
1.1219855547,
0.7220722437,
-0.6057738066,
-0.1516273469,
0.3875602782,
-0.4505416453,
-0.0631705374,
-0.6206634641,
-0.044897709,
-0.4853459895,
-0.0813071951,
-0.626216948,
-0.1474478543,
0.3180441558,
-0.3280065954,
0.540987134,
-0.2850375772,
-0.6026216149,
0.0278424174,
0.0090814484,
0.5910719633,
0.5514044762,
-0.3300357461,
0.9084829092,
0.1897871196,
-0.3261182308,
-0.4432884157,
-0.5945351124,
-0.0410336293,
-0.1580825001,
-0.3191592991,
0.5724261403,
0.0077332901,
-0.2942628562,
-0.1387702674,
-0.2173574567,
-0.308000505,
0.1858378202,
0.0745029896,
-0.0131784407,
-0.2662154436,
0.3089303672,
0.0082472917,
-0.3257860243,
-0.1171301603,
-0.4559740424,
1.1568046808,
-0.1382987052,
-0.6691884398,
-0.620105803,
-0.1310739368,
0.4829409719,
-0.794324398,
0.7659193873,
0.7101294994,
-0.2112835795,
0.0892460272,
-0.7163671255,
-0.2245275676,
-0.4503332078,
0.6038589478,
-0.4762879014,
-0.8163762093,
0.5124081969,
-0.1974647939,
-0.1541829705,
0.3883897066,
0.4401476085,
0.0638526231,
1.1213462353,
0.5450464487,
0.1223315299,
0.6907311082,
0.1488493234,
-0.1074874476,
-0.5658730268,
-0.4217732847,
-0.658633709,
0.2735188603,
-0.2308631092,
-0.6660560966,
0.0679777935,
0.0302040875,
-0.0753971115,
0.0754695237,
0.0207480639,
0.3114414215,
0.6003271937,
0.1438619196,
0.0858442932,
0.3001126647,
-0.3843469322,
-0.0678633079,
-0.8695063591,
-0.3619839549,
0.7461807132,
0.4060429037,
0.3442810476,
-0.2942546904,
0.7296456099,
0.0805922598,
-0.0272676814,
-0.644703567,
0.3749677837,
-0.3385023475,
-0.4511831105,
-0.3588882089,
-0.5589318871,
-1.0480853319,
0.4874822199,
-0.0801870897,
-0.2835041881,
-0.1073118672,
0.1964302361,
-0.3967264295,
0.2759288847,
-0.5755680203,
0.7540745735,
-0.5140248537,
-0.0464931987,
-0.4470516741,
-0.7421441674,
-0.2758882046,
-0.3061705232,
0.4569355249,
-0.0181327611,
-0.27020365,
0.8842410445,
-0.5077754259,
0.9869760275,
-0.2915630937,
-0.1260185093,
0.0913474932,
0.0626536757,
0.4453712702,
-0.0542631671,
0.0793411508,
0.2296814173,
-0.3320278525,
-0.584561646,
-0.5866121054,
0.1412690133,
-0.8950064182,
-0.7867919803,
-0.2184488177,
-0.4947861135,
-0.2991578877,
0.3227396309,
0.0819063485,
0.6191045642,
0.0032775446,
-0.013578739,
0.8609310985,
-0.3559458256,
0.2904873192,
0.4139460027,
-0.2543561459,
-0.319293946,
0.7087364793,
0.061159879,
0.2291899472,
0.343220979,
0.447398901,
-0.3613733351,
-1.1017090082,
-0.5623427629,
0.2730903029,
-0.7059981227,
-0.0259649288,
-0.7520461679,
-0.3685306907,
-0.2783019543,
0.0331425294,
-0.7028608322,
-0.3223475814,
-0.4753798842,
-0.1359156966,
0.016920371,
0.8775534034,
-0.0003007077,
0.4155173302,
-1.0394791365,
0.1661393493,
0.1094556227,
0.5968008637,
-0.0413937308,
-0.7178494334,
-0.0714481771,
0.1179056317,
0.3225257397,
-0.5971278548,
0.3052506745,
0.2909572124,
0.9055505395,
0.460614264,
-0.4384177923,
0.9615548849,
-0.8627212644,
0.5301119089,
0.3797873259,
-1.0462574959,
0.5777226686,
-0.155785501,
0.418868959,
0.5249657035,
0.4576287866,
-0.2929538786,
-0.6238356829,
-0.4300694764,
-0.6859901547,
0.6777172685,
0.3550862074,
0.7498307824,
-0.254004091,
0.5174371004,
0.5044850111,
0.3282797337,
-0.7697191238,
-0.2805378139,
-0.4521927238,
-0.2521591485,
-0.0933521912,
-0.4560961425,
0.248992458,
-0.4667722881,
0.5043663383,
0.0051147738,
-0.108854048,
0.1160673946,
-0.5374640226,
0.0724211186,
0.153910026,
0.8372977376,
0.850826025,
0.2062919587,
0.4736192822,
0.1230827346,
-0.6399651766,
0.1473991573,
-0.0929733962,
-0.1724251807,
0.1589181721,
0.5038285255,
0.9169189334,
0.2554871142,
-0.7248299122,
0.5687727928,
0.061925143,
-0.0652868375,
0.0620294623,
-0.0098057315,
-0.0046786824,
0.0805910304,
0.320581466,
0.3182812929,
-0.2371050268,
-0.4094441533,
0.2274516076,
0.5883413553,
-0.3771601319,
-0.5621085763,
0.2539968193,
-0.04222247,
-0.2739812136,
0.5849171281,
0.0592249148,
-0.777592659,
0.3750171959,
0.773196876,
0.3872350156,
-0.546250701,
0.2976734936,
0.2114085406,
0.1734371483,
-0.1406624019,
0.003215601,
-0.115059115,
-0.789670825,
-0.5963671207,
-1.0502963066,
0.1332335025,
-0.0647294968,
-0.3571999669,
0.1123393998,
-0.4909031093,
-0.194123596,
-0.2200574279,
-0.4454627037,
-0.7499097586,
0.2177218348,
0.1968443692,
1.022682786,
-0.7023370862,
0.7083588243,
0.8827188015,
-0.428085357,
-0.7435678244,
-0.1728764474,
-0.6703923345,
-1.2672798634,
1.0588636398,
0.2026992887,
-0.1205543503,
0.3751176,
-0.140569061,
-0.975753665,
0.6269298792,
0.4254748523,
-0.3391905725,
-0.0192426853,
0.4813632667,
0.6795071363,
-0.2063458264,
0.2414022088,
0.1731149703,
0.40689376,
0.146771118,
-0.9314163923,
-0.1603313833,
-0.2898370326,
0.1076051444,
0.3144077361,
-0.1658469141,
0.6456520557,
-0.0489285477,
-0.3553777039,
0.0486678481,
0.8944889307,
0.1015338153,
-0.0051074629,
0.5107296705,
0.5832633972,
0.8053031564,
0.1545514762,
0.995270133,
-0.4668852687,
-0.2297720462,
0.8601887822,
-0.1243632436,
0.7136871219,
0.6540209055,
0.0060487357,
0.3725062609,
0.5029079318,
0.0978092551,
0.5962207913,
0.2788843811,
-0.1206873879,
-0.6023585796,
-0.3848681152,
-0.517801702,
0.6596180201,
0.2030329108,
-0.3667918146,
-0.3448807299,
0.2416831702,
0.0275312234,
0.0162028614,
-0.644467175,
0.9893140793,
-0.0089846663,
-0.6310620308,
0.2590790391,
0.108942911,
0.6973880529,
-0.8748727441,
0.1247144043,
-0.2308703214,
-0.180084303,
-0.1003465205,
-0.5552487373,
0.4187802076,
-0.0028605219,
0.1263170242,
-0.4365923107,
0.9481967092,
-0.3325994015,
-0.2864202559,
0.2008825392,
0.9864617586,
0.2709622085,
-0.1242130026,
-0.4467700124,
-0.0308837201,
-0.1910876483,
-0.1221923456,
0.5615615249,
0.3745112121,
-0.0704877228,
0.743955195,
0.8872969747,
0.4336539209,
0.5118157268,
0.3064160943,
0.9756373763,
-0.4772694111,
-0.5119075179,
-1.3048087358,
0.4858961403,
0.1545917541,
-0.0987307504,
0.6799781322,
0.6460979581,
1.0408686399,
-0.2782732844,
0.5959580541,
0.2218256295,
-0.032417886,
-0.7309005857,
0.6505263448,
-0.5960877538,
-0.1184972674,
0.1084601209,
-0.868653357,
-0.7094885111,
0.8472012281,
-0.370506078,
0.142362386,
0.5271348953,
0.4962651134,
-0.1358329058,
-0.19091703,
0.4798608124,
0.0516611822,
0.0246617999,
-0.2459244579,
1.2786495686,
0.2306285053,
0.3769628406,
-0.1966813058,
0.0601336546,
0.1249229386,
-0.6865755916,
-1.200463891,
-0.5341363549,
-0.0643837079,
0.0703749582,
0.2448561192,
1.1064279079,
0.7572429776,
-0.6678977609,
-0.0941402838,
-0.4085386097,
-0.2025564313,
0.2799682319,
-0.0648307726,
0.3711315989,
-0.9548110366,
-0.4216998219,
0.5531835556,
0.5769129395,
0.4820852578,
-0.1600236297,
-0.1890073866,
0.0032838837,
-0.0037859275,
0.4914596081,
-0.0391915143,
-0.8797507286,
-0.1465260535,
0.0231553465,
-0.1543411165,
0.2598925531,
1.1451765299,
-0.7360579371,
0.3159463406,
0.4108558893,
0.7045398355,
0.2502323687,
0.120431006,
0.6039121151,
-0.7978691459,
0.4891135693,
0.2642783821,
0.5800813437,
0.2736000717,
-0.1296755075,
0.2487151325,
0.1150788516,
0.0699255839,
-0.7298477888,
0.46964553,
-0.4485914707,
-0.5153976679,
1.0468562841,
-0.3958486021,
-0.1252975762,
-0.2904066145,
-0.1100445986,
0.4361858666,
-0.0320423134,
0.6492626071,
0.5196823478,
0.266913265,
-0.0182327237,
-0.1767582744,
0.7044297457,
0.8917021751,
-0.7276997566,
0.0045736926,
0.1524717361,
0.1077204272,
0.1959134638,
0.7481318116,
-0.1578027606,
0.1281933933,
-0.1395724267,
-0.1034778208,
-0.394216001,
-0.621211946,
-0.3350509703,
0.1282397062,
0.3747429848,
0.3774923682
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00629v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00629v1
|
Formal Translation from Reversing Petri Nets to Coloured Petri Nets
| 2023-11-01T16:28:38 | 2023-11-01T16:28:38 |
Kamila Barylska, Anna Gogolinska, Lukasz Mikulski, Anna Philippou, Marcin Piatkowski, Kyriaki Psara
|
cs.LO
|
cs.LO, cs.CL, 03, F.2; G.0
|
Reversible computation is an emerging computing paradigm that allows any
sequence of operations to be executed in reverse order at any point during
computation. Its appeal lies in its potential for lowpower computation and its
relevance to a wide array of applications such as chemical reactions, quantum
computation, robotics, and distributed systems. Reversing Petri nets are a
recently-proposed extension of Petri nets that implements the three main forms
of reversibility, namely, backtracking, causal reversing, and
out-of-causal-order reversing. Their distinguishing feature is the use of named
tokens that can be combined together to form bonds. Named tokens along with a
history function, constitute the means of remembering past behaviour, thus,
enabling reversal. In recent work, we have proposed a structural translation
from a subclass of RPNs to the model of Coloured Petri Nets (CPNs), an
extension of traditional Petri nets where tokens carry data values. In this
paper, we extend the translation to handle RPNs with token multiplicity under
the individual-token interpretation, a model which allows multiple tokens of
the same type to exist in a system. To support the three types of
reversibility, tokens are associated with their causal history and, while
tokens of the same type are equally eligible to fire a transition when going
forward, when going backwards they are able to reverse only the transitions
they have previously fired. The new translation, in addition to lifting the
restriction on token uniqueness, presents a refined approach for transforming
RPNs to CPNs through a unifying approach that allows instantiating each of the
three types of reversibility. The paper also reports on a tool that implements
this translation, paving the way for automated translations and analysis of
reversible systems using CPN Tools.
|
[
-0.1596328616,
-0.3971869648,
0.3692189455,
0.4926372468,
-0.441182375,
0.0146493269,
-0.1272066087,
-0.2759583294,
0.3408465385,
0.6921823621,
-0.4280710518,
-0.0378054343,
-0.483904928,
0.1837270111,
-0.6422896385,
1.2062381506,
-0.3128296435,
0.2106326967,
0.2964217365,
-0.1969691515,
-0.28562361,
-0.8261211514,
-0.6016312242,
-0.7984569669,
0.6152717471,
0.1095713302,
0.7243089676,
0.4247265756,
0.6065452695,
0.4005194902,
0.0941674188,
-0.0648272857,
-0.4938202202,
0.1195691749,
-0.6719312668,
-0.6394127011,
-0.4651271403,
-0.1025799289,
0.7883327603,
0.7765375972,
0.028583603,
0.1613625139,
-0.0230316818,
0.7859356403,
-0.6920266151,
0.2678395808,
-0.5115280151,
0.5934185982,
-0.1364022344,
-0.6013836265,
-0.4720373154,
-0.2217134982,
-0.4323708713,
-0.5166943669,
0.1135830879,
-0.2207782269,
0.4059965909,
-0.1928276867,
-0.3911221921,
0.1917632073,
-1.190974474,
0.8814687133,
-0.7917715907,
0.4322809279,
-0.0149950525,
0.6117528081,
-0.5949665904,
-1.2310374975,
-0.7009550929,
0.2263434529,
-0.3464541435,
0.3792325556,
0.0985819697,
0.0153729841,
0.2196651697,
0.4521673918,
-0.3653680384,
-0.0079550873,
-0.4750021398,
-0.1408694535,
0.3473716974,
0.5264309645,
0.1279718429,
0.1801318973,
-0.5566679835,
-0.1107834354,
-0.6958715916,
-0.099002935,
0.3945001364,
0.8050689697,
-0.2638426721,
0.6720576286,
-0.2860716581,
0.5079851747,
-0.1235597804,
-0.1005403474,
0.311519593,
-0.7516706586,
-0.2320414037,
-0.086370267,
0.5210981965,
0.1242877617,
0.2785418928,
-0.123801291,
-0.2622903883,
-0.1889965683,
0.2953436375,
-0.7889803052,
-0.3550365865,
0.2045491189,
-0.8292339444,
-0.3285399675,
0.2463174909,
-0.2584104538,
-0.4392769337,
-0.4167760313,
0.392298013,
-0.0759451017,
-0.5427260399,
0.1149368063,
-0.3392771184,
0.497122556,
0.352498889,
-0.4886706173,
0.388201803,
1.3398141861,
0.8312656879,
-0.0889738128,
-0.5836886764,
-0.1392132044,
0.0563872159,
-0.4220197201,
0.1340407282,
-0.4642983973,
-0.1473993212,
-0.3739325106,
0.479926914,
-0.0859507546,
0.0172310714,
0.4083975554,
-0.9305887222,
0.0870556161,
0.0242836177,
0.0188370198,
-0.6060432792,
0.2381216884,
-0.4786283076,
0.4633392096,
-0.3584190309,
-0.7663429379,
0.155841589,
-0.4706812799,
-0.4091638029,
-0.1948259324,
0.0528792888,
-0.6603028774,
0.0998804942,
-0.4069709778,
0.2449268103,
-0.0791600272,
0.3108589947,
-0.5117136836,
-0.384428829,
0.3938837945,
-0.5608689189,
0.8773804307,
0.3346925676,
-0.1549812555,
0.3436349332,
-0.7222349644,
-0.0248310193,
-0.0256585684,
-0.4554851949,
-0.1689437628,
0.1002512574,
-0.2129298896,
0.533573091,
0.2834806144,
-0.7630926967,
0.3259793222,
-0.5917250514,
0.8315377235,
0.6952188611,
0.1100173965,
0.3342305124,
-0.1069488153,
0.2408786863,
0.1265739053,
0.348089546,
-0.3168483973,
-0.6920543313,
-0.8388903737,
0.0614819229,
0.2630513906,
0.7979947925,
-0.6505563259,
0.0716507658,
-0.2936328351,
-0.2844958603,
0.1600654125,
-0.3491009772,
0.5164766908,
0.5278039575,
0.3545620143,
-0.5791239142,
-0.953784883,
-0.9998092651,
-0.1225681379,
-0.5461326838,
0.2512772977,
-0.0080113271,
0.7439559102,
-0.2101641148,
0.5292754769,
-0.1869813949,
0.1960926056,
0.1059454978,
0.429017514,
0.6650800109,
0.8777874112,
-0.2310037613,
-1.2385567427,
-0.0892034173,
0.3249142468,
-0.5071871281,
0.2182565928,
-0.5680126548,
-0.167813465,
0.1892910153,
0.7994083762,
0.0071662464,
0.6379777193,
0.4191622734,
-0.1378635764,
0.7972934842,
-0.1277558506,
0.2981567085,
-0.8437073827,
0.702812016,
-0.890429318,
-0.4058465064,
-0.7891840935,
0.565113306,
0.0438869484,
-0.312895447,
-0.7064992785,
0.3855465353,
-0.4121336043,
-0.5582905412,
-0.3013390601,
-0.3035227358,
0.0868479013,
0.4929219782,
0.294837743,
0.5390824676,
0.3016231954,
-0.7246784568,
0.3272898495,
0.1411502808,
0.491673559,
0.3951464891,
-0.4893847704,
0.0425245352,
0.0452521741,
0.1599896848,
-1.0368999243,
0.2891618311,
0.7620231509,
-0.5002349019,
0.3447256982,
-0.4122678041,
-0.2731379569,
-0.2876805365,
-0.3242709935,
0.6605020761,
-0.1176401749,
-0.3943931162,
0.735127449,
-0.1472371817,
-0.0337071344,
-0.7902228236,
-1.0897489786,
0.4755567312,
-0.0327974632,
-0.4096545875,
0.4815206826,
-0.0268232767,
0.0422351807,
0.0262313634,
0.1882832497,
-0.3571929038,
0.1979527473,
0.4518140554,
0.0963927731,
-0.366722554,
0.100033097,
-0.3221400976,
-0.4761775434,
-0.074282147,
-0.5208044052,
0.5316185355,
-0.3680618703,
-0.5391658545,
-0.1692088395,
0.4875387847,
0.7431197762,
-0.2677507997,
0.8995043635,
0.5182819963,
-0.3087337315,
0.1460606456,
-0.0617203712,
-0.2606806457,
-0.4777749777,
0.0971378908,
-0.6797198653,
-0.5262248516,
1.0679103136,
-0.1640912741,
0.2043213844,
0.4350172579,
0.562025547,
0.1971163005,
0.7635424137,
0.730114758,
0.3067642748,
0.4474492073,
-0.0186794568,
0.5346064568,
-0.790977478,
-0.1927309781,
-0.3808839321,
-0.5397478342,
-0.82081604,
-0.2517400384,
0.3051200807,
0.4022684991,
-0.4924776554,
0.6333816648,
-0.5904580951,
0.2893593609,
0.2604893148,
-0.0319063067,
0.3585325181,
-0.235735938,
-0.4015130997,
0.2366383821,
-0.6549722552,
-0.2740211189,
0.7109776139,
0.2233727127,
0.3743983805,
0.2580173016,
0.8711271286,
0.0108401105,
0.4061494172,
-0.5886309147,
0.6953873634,
-0.2272195369,
-0.6339429021,
-0.3970806599,
-0.3801299036,
-1.1268907785,
0.4628009796,
-0.262827307,
-0.4873394668,
0.4338597953,
0.1465431601,
-0.1040901169,
0.6913229823,
-0.4341845214,
0.7987997532,
-0.3518244326,
-0.4228546321,
-0.4881860316,
-0.8245984912,
0.4799598753,
-0.0394204594,
-0.0541809015,
0.5135861039,
-0.1586331874,
0.416331321,
-0.7910975814,
1.1172232628,
0.022916019,
-0.0248194654,
0.1031093299,
0.5158837438,
0.6016164422,
-0.1144439355,
-0.1851118356,
0.3214303553,
0.0932848677,
-0.2683617771,
-0.5767409205,
0.6590676904,
-0.3782998323,
-0.351462096,
-0.4912260473,
-0.0648432299,
0.2389336079,
0.661395371,
-0.1997625083,
0.1634831578,
-0.0447929762,
-0.2333145589,
0.0901861563,
-0.2390495092,
0.485224098,
0.8951752782,
-0.2464656085,
-0.3853315413,
0.9709010124,
0.1062965766,
0.1182732955,
0.6051539183,
0.2282841206,
-0.0380775332,
-0.5860797763,
-0.3204544485,
0.1187099591,
-0.7162975669,
-0.1642098427,
-0.266720295,
-0.3030425012,
-0.2848129272,
-0.3570509851,
-0.5642294288,
-1.2316292524,
-0.3617519438,
0.1080214903,
0.1807165593,
0.3498643339,
-0.5018368363,
-0.0251544137,
-0.674551487,
0.4225604534,
0.1203190908,
0.71604985,
0.0850218758,
-0.4510798454,
0.0855668783,
-0.3053866923,
-0.0756929815,
-0.8783640862,
0.3473163545,
0.0400313623,
0.3365236223,
0.2939558923,
-0.0908728614,
0.8120811582,
-0.6826295853,
0.5291936994,
0.4630447924,
-0.8126561642,
0.2644364834,
-0.341821909,
0.0191326942,
0.4938066006,
0.210924089,
-1.0495755672,
0.0834965333,
-0.4913865328,
-1.1337932348,
0.4792130888,
0.1663444191,
-0.0923397616,
0.1909331083,
0.5555148125,
0.2136526555,
0.3168695867,
-0.8049983382,
-0.330185622,
-0.6014931798,
0.3816291988,
0.0045718364,
0.1382221133,
-0.2414397597,
0.0714655295,
0.8522936702,
0.02718913,
0.4174881876,
0.0733126178,
0.2439480275,
0.0467671938,
0.4963653386,
0.6510455608,
0.5740810037,
-0.1076689586,
0.3105646372,
-0.0522225685,
-0.2826056778,
0.1269084662,
-0.0470022149,
-0.2252129912,
-0.4505898654,
0.3093337119,
0.4073289335,
0.1632983834,
0.1048486233,
0.2904703319,
-0.0127485478,
0.202575013,
-0.5948311687,
-0.2473372221,
-0.0073597059,
0.1509026736,
-0.1573948264,
0.4249486029,
0.3094160557,
-0.6525209546,
0.3967316449,
0.3717780113,
-0.3814507723,
-0.5216585994,
0.3225886226,
0.3696187437,
-0.3876458406,
0.4297324717,
-0.2440387756,
-0.6625779271,
0.5036913753,
0.724597156,
1.2147859335,
0.0517444722,
0.1105647311,
0.4883645475,
0.2976640165,
-0.0884534493,
0.5555702448,
-0.3283239603,
-0.8297905922,
-0.4867029488,
-0.4363227189,
-0.5273248553,
-0.1357554346,
-0.5235306025,
0.0442117937,
-0.6495924592,
-0.1323965341,
-0.0059537608,
-0.4965022504,
-0.3234079182,
-0.1052359119,
0.0848124325,
0.7295075059,
-0.9325594306,
0.5315644741,
0.8989416957,
-0.4265225828,
-0.4808487892,
-0.4046464264,
0.0242963377,
-0.6147994995,
1.0438922644,
-0.2864040434,
-0.3651260436,
-0.2607872784,
-0.3966931999,
-0.7751765251,
0.7652752995,
0.1171128526,
-0.3241549432,
0.3410241902,
0.4302044809,
0.6397051811,
-0.1407995075,
0.293397814,
0.1315392703,
0.6524951458,
-0.2302762866,
-1.0599027872,
0.2785888612,
-0.3453117907,
-0.0850781575,
0.5701398849,
-0.7007641792,
1.2842203379,
0.096344173,
-0.5447480083,
0.1497836262,
0.370817095,
0.0264940802,
0.1881459504,
0.2295344621,
0.5263729692,
0.1911200732,
-0.1100323275,
0.7982481122,
-0.2814700305,
0.2221161574,
1.0245591402,
-0.0021465837,
0.7215080857,
0.7504965663,
-0.2875618041,
0.794880569,
0.0326469168,
0.2894224823,
0.1813129932,
0.4744456708,
0.0274406429,
-0.4239384234,
0.1267224103,
-0.2415207624,
0.2904773653,
0.2165556401,
-0.6034671068,
-0.388194561,
-0.060509678,
-0.2329115868,
0.0467573889,
-0.6307566762,
0.4560054243,
0.2836507857,
-0.4834787548,
0.6663633585,
0.5038166642,
0.478416115,
-0.5183658004,
-0.5651041865,
-0.0738565847,
0.3369474411,
-0.5123878121,
-0.9064734578,
0.7106826305,
-0.4384717047,
-0.4085831642,
-0.5784502029,
0.9826439023,
0.0055945758,
-0.4671602249,
0.2767749429,
0.2195688486,
0.2855139673,
0.3561167717,
-0.9594586492,
-0.0374956466,
-0.1631131619,
-0.0851348042,
0.125922069,
0.3415465355,
-0.4726641178,
0.8153344989,
0.7396203876,
0.3758621514,
0.1442213058,
-0.0788670406,
0.7835295796,
-0.7349624634,
-0.8074938655,
-0.6086987853,
0.4779540002,
0.3141537011,
-0.0894560143,
0.73726511,
0.4225701094,
0.8439630866,
-0.0632568747,
0.4546990395,
0.2491900474,
0.2668366134,
-0.3117235601,
0.515311718,
-0.0457701273,
0.3003633916,
-0.3759074509,
-0.5559406877,
-0.4711616039,
0.4277330637,
-0.3329850733,
-0.2770151198,
0.2754307091,
0.77002424,
-0.2986697555,
0.0567446053,
0.0967433453,
0.2070848495,
0.366869688,
0.4581418335,
0.7609087825,
-0.512853682,
0.4235544205,
-0.3076445162,
-0.062051516,
-0.113170892,
-1.2752088308,
-0.2639378607,
-0.5814588666,
-0.2702310383,
-0.3401102126,
0.2628030777,
0.297526449,
0.6923575401,
-1.2970219851,
-0.1954432577,
-0.6554684639,
0.2954975069,
-0.5596337914,
-0.2368070334,
0.2201447487,
0.0423475988,
-0.1571561545,
0.306460768,
0.532682538,
0.0888783336,
-0.4692396224,
-0.106939286,
-0.044563394,
0.0899514481,
0.605199039,
1.2010350227,
-0.4693611562,
-0.4482499063,
-0.3850101233,
0.2581655085,
-0.0602628551,
1.2994349003,
-1.0557771921,
0.5430296063,
1.0502462387,
0.5135819316,
0.6572101116,
0.0577239804,
0.5685268044,
-0.6217438579,
0.2379776984,
0.4049700201,
0.4257291257,
0.2564268112,
-0.2358473986,
0.5150113106,
0.3507071435,
-0.3961141407,
-0.8173737526,
0.8766884208,
-0.7355311513,
-0.4940278232,
0.6660082936,
-0.2272861004,
-0.0203283187,
-0.350392729,
0.1184527501,
0.4360558987,
0.0721952394,
0.4178604186,
0.2515017092,
-0.6031576395,
0.0760661289,
-0.0008450821,
0.054790318,
0.5040243268,
-0.1689306945,
0.3195329905,
0.1371517926,
0.0585442968,
0.5621343255,
0.5527114272,
-0.7496299148,
0.2168244869,
-0.1619691253,
0.1795808524,
-0.3430679739,
-0.4182924032,
-0.7031848431,
0.2180708498,
-0.1388885379,
-0.1565827578
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00588v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00588v1
|
Boosting Summarization with Normalizing Flows and Aggressive Training
| 2023-11-01T15:33:38 | 2023-11-01T15:33:38 |
Yu Yang, Xiaotong Shen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper presents FlowSUM, a normalizing flows-based variational
encoder-decoder framework for Transformer-based summarization. Our approach
tackles two primary challenges in variational summarization: insufficient
semantic information in latent representations and posterior collapse during
training. To address these challenges, we employ normalizing flows to enable
flexible latent posterior modeling, and we propose a controlled alternate
aggressive training (CAAT) strategy with an improved gate mechanism.
Experimental results show that FlowSUM significantly enhances the quality of
generated summaries and unleashes the potential for knowledge distillation with
minimal impact on inference time. Furthermore, we investigate the issue of
posterior collapse in normalizing flows and analyze how the summary quality is
affected by the training strategy, gate initialization, and the type and number
of normalizing flows used, offering valuable insights for future research.
|
[
-0.2486992478,
-0.3374269903,
0.0887148008,
0.1091170758,
-0.373534888,
0.285854131,
-0.0910511091,
0.1965643615,
0.2355601192,
0.4414602816,
-0.5760549903,
-0.2106206566,
-0.8817162514,
-0.0316133909,
-0.3883000612,
1.5049307346,
-0.1685691923,
-0.066209361,
-0.0502326265,
-0.1366415173,
-0.2397859544,
-0.2866524458,
-0.6355719566,
-0.4174391627,
0.4123158157,
0.2621825933,
0.7032299638,
0.7107365727,
0.6541985869,
0.267745018,
-0.6662512422,
0.2059584856,
-0.8284306526,
0.4008812606,
0.0759480447,
-0.7503793836,
-0.6425523758,
-0.3358286023,
0.7868770361,
0.804302454,
-0.4993297458,
-0.1807698905,
0.1494046003,
0.8587090969,
-0.8086277843,
0.3133259416,
-0.3782334924,
0.0195352435,
-0.0903772414,
-0.31947276,
-0.0283494778,
-0.1532812715,
-0.0797415823,
-0.5596613288,
0.56630826,
-0.5076383352,
1.0439120531,
0.6273314953,
-0.4207900763,
-0.3287002742,
-0.7832269073,
0.2213566899,
-0.8284447193,
0.1028091684,
0.0212583095,
0.6547673345,
0.2164924592,
-0.9808579683,
-0.3083889186,
0.4044440389,
-0.2315613776,
0.6178694367,
-0.2448992878,
0.2262420058,
0.0927077383,
0.8287548423,
-0.4710564613,
-0.0771032423,
-0.5517137051,
-0.0529542528,
0.6739875674,
0.529513061,
0.0377995297,
0.2654833496,
-0.001985329,
-0.4017914832,
-0.4356536865,
0.2819345593,
0.6058577299,
0.3650543094,
-0.5517324209,
0.476619333,
-0.6070423126,
0.418166101,
0.1571160257,
0.0306683257,
0.2425622195,
0.0989814699,
-0.3058703244,
-0.1951101422,
0.5855125189,
0.4475538731,
-0.1304250807,
-0.2528692186,
-0.437966466,
-0.0694816485,
0.1961409897,
-1.3340270519,
-0.2336051911,
0.2113835216,
-0.3503543437,
-0.2743265331,
0.3688080907,
-0.9050760865,
-0.4088129699,
-0.1542936414,
0.1450267136,
-0.302983582,
-0.325617373,
0.3047329783,
-0.6127134562,
0.4569272697,
0.4934498966,
-0.9678266644,
0.4798057377,
0.6338372827,
0.9418526888,
-0.2810546458,
-0.1021940336,
-0.8280190825,
0.1567793339,
-0.2399574965,
0.7795857787,
-0.1945509166,
-0.6490305066,
0.1886909902,
-0.048502814,
0.0072817728,
-0.6375747323,
0.3969348669,
-0.6223622561,
0.0749761164,
-0.1264629811,
-0.5913313627,
-0.2147800028,
0.1797319055,
-0.69323349,
0.4955944717,
-0.0937783569,
-0.9167243838,
0.1451295465,
-0.7754816413,
-0.6651778221,
-0.0327420607,
-0.2861489356,
-0.6450377703,
0.305488646,
0.2743239999,
0.6567376256,
0.1303453892,
0.2890744507,
0.1748338938,
-0.3734479845,
-0.0804784596,
-0.3746577501,
0.7150663137,
0.3606789112,
-0.2049951553,
0.1362802237,
-0.7335287929,
-0.5537384152,
0.0866936594,
-0.3136225343,
0.0503040142,
-0.0041947039,
-0.3590347171,
-0.2131460309,
-0.2114545405,
-0.0270601586,
0.0565566421,
-0.5565734506,
0.2476484925,
0.4125676155,
0.4587782919,
0.7221722603,
-0.5681720376,
0.6683110595,
0.2366734296,
-0.500120163,
-0.4456369281,
-0.2493048608,
-0.9446345568,
-0.374695152,
0.0071403491,
0.5151283741,
-0.8916392922,
0.1803530157,
-0.6049053669,
-0.6215360761,
-0.1405670345,
0.0415019803,
0.0521274731,
0.6195582151,
0.3599697053,
-0.1765052825,
-0.1905189306,
-0.6224114299,
-0.2498205304,
-0.0143210078,
-0.360550195,
-0.2496801317,
0.3101520836,
-0.3338682055,
0.7979982495,
-0.8505859375,
-0.2807890177,
-0.5772989988,
0.7189756632,
0.3103522956,
0.5509079099,
0.591229856,
-0.7244723439,
-0.2972946465,
-0.28973037,
-0.574735105,
-0.0196083803,
-0.4290278256,
-0.2345850021,
-0.2345551848,
0.7081005573,
-0.351316452,
0.4851815701,
0.1941663474,
-0.2323887199,
0.1829514802,
-0.148874715,
0.150527969,
-1.0518351793,
-0.035768453,
-0.2036898881,
-0.2854072154,
-0.6658062935,
0.0972334146,
0.1691576391,
-0.2307518721,
-0.3523338139,
0.0618067421,
-0.4195049405,
0.5607241988,
-0.5009435415,
-0.1605155617,
0.119808346,
0.6072887778,
0.415984273,
0.633223772,
0.3852626085,
-0.8679282069,
0.142789647,
0.0127005167,
0.2293275297,
0.5220428705,
-0.8645341992,
-0.2052928507,
-0.75392735,
0.4049863219,
-0.8662156463,
-0.4884766936,
-0.1190254465,
-0.5201022625,
0.7253565788,
0.0105663994,
-0.0168721359,
0.0930021182,
-0.7251085043,
0.176561445,
0.6080012321,
-0.4164637923,
0.9369034171,
0.2625426054,
-0.1884469986,
-0.5285307765,
-0.9899609685,
-0.1753984243,
-0.334076941,
-0.3996483088,
0.5708214045,
-0.0212559104,
-0.1973059624,
-0.0430594981,
-0.2210819125,
-0.0998811349,
0.0545859821,
0.1465388238,
0.0871546268,
-0.195013389,
-0.0447029099,
0.667621851,
0.019504644,
0.0645771697,
0.1004158556,
0.1747735739,
-0.2904610038,
-0.0690292493,
-0.5034932494,
0.4734350443,
0.4269233346,
-0.2867386937,
0.6183861494,
0.7317578197,
-0.4476969838,
-0.2096067965,
-0.1660002768,
-0.2248046994,
-0.4653125107,
0.5715687871,
-0.3672023714,
-0.8594369888,
0.8259673715,
-0.0821611136,
0.3358596861,
0.8784081936,
0.8613175154,
-0.2020258605,
0.5286599994,
0.8700683117,
0.178957656,
0.5881023407,
-0.898188591,
-0.0363526233,
-0.6144092679,
-0.2686091661,
-0.342189163,
-0.2046473622,
-0.4420028329,
-0.3834683895,
0.3760105073,
0.1907261908,
-0.1372700036,
0.044853121,
-0.2976785302,
0.5595632195,
0.1083539873,
-0.1203458831,
0.3563098907,
-0.1714738309,
0.2495936006,
0.0792726427,
-0.9210324883,
-0.3205152154,
0.8884724975,
0.5082672834,
1.1051223278,
0.4230577946,
0.7406176925,
0.2336709052,
0.4815716147,
-0.8838778138,
0.1327140778,
-0.0268918574,
-0.3068271577,
-0.2535347939,
-0.623773396,
-0.9481013417,
0.3625153601,
-0.1185762659,
-0.3102732301,
0.3645709455,
0.0915808454,
-0.6431232691,
0.4541681111,
-0.6323224902,
0.4703300297,
0.2999615967,
-0.1256997883,
0.036278829,
-0.9586858153,
0.5423211455,
0.478859961,
0.0789294839,
0.1614438146,
-0.3315417171,
0.814673245,
-0.8148733377,
0.8506984115,
-0.1092990264,
-0.1605302542,
0.3361599445,
0.0459345207,
0.3222114146,
0.4464521706,
0.4023511708,
-0.0857948363,
-0.3378724158,
-0.5671208501,
-0.8745286465,
0.2446830124,
-0.8480178118,
-0.3587425053,
-0.4631397128,
-0.5939805508,
-0.2457235456,
-0.083260566,
0.7213519216,
0.45729056,
-0.1122975945,
0.2196597159,
0.8232903481,
0.2492043823,
0.694732964,
0.2850164771,
0.2349348962,
-0.6059558988,
0.9602408409,
0.077503562,
0.3170919716,
0.6628678441,
0.0415287726,
-0.102610901,
-0.5784028769,
-0.5473833084,
0.2234977782,
-0.6530421972,
-0.4900639355,
-0.7281212807,
-0.4872114658,
-0.5456346869,
-0.3318442404,
-0.6954261065,
-0.5275379419,
-0.3769460917,
-0.2305265963,
-0.0139860641,
0.7093409896,
-0.0851674825,
0.5773983598,
-0.7383535504,
0.3340883851,
0.5502772927,
0.3009788096,
-0.0271970108,
-0.8283492327,
-0.3770592511,
-0.273219198,
-0.6239125729,
-1.0080419779,
0.318623364,
0.3410515785,
0.5368797183,
0.8900815845,
0.2034673989,
0.4149899185,
-0.1462261677,
0.7913356423,
0.2245437056,
-0.8075705171,
0.5883395076,
-0.4932495356,
0.4683777094,
0.5989792347,
0.4335596263,
-0.4246273041,
-0.5558788776,
-0.5783680677,
-1.0182509422,
0.4563687444,
0.5726133585,
0.2916129827,
0.2965810895,
0.3378186524,
0.1233914569,
0.2481808662,
-0.4549261034,
-0.3195206821,
-0.5633049607,
-0.2141341418,
-0.1123063043,
-0.2207874507,
-0.2281871289,
-0.107606411,
0.7316310406,
-0.1348698884,
0.0289397705,
0.2852161527,
-0.1843470633,
0.2874850631,
0.1346746683,
0.739751339,
0.3032079637,
-0.3219493926,
0.1604915708,
0.1881030798,
-0.63807863,
0.1566678137,
0.3689579964,
-0.2807234824,
0.1052602977,
0.6672199368,
0.9228813052,
-0.1443861425,
-0.6330040097,
0.638186574,
-0.4380638599,
-0.3381750584,
0.2318706214,
0.2579112947,
-0.0635616928,
0.0932468995,
0.399538517,
0.173597604,
0.5007970333,
-0.3036123514,
-0.0253600422,
-0.0606938414,
-0.4006040096,
-0.3419390917,
0.8237098455,
0.4442903101,
0.0341551229,
0.1520689726,
-0.5478588343,
-0.268083185,
0.3812072873,
0.2071713954,
0.9828928709,
-0.1264208704,
0.0187273379,
0.4277040064,
0.231607601,
-0.0043769134,
0.0441679545,
-0.3131791949,
-0.5263235569,
-0.3956063092,
-0.2950878143,
-0.6223107576,
-0.0285542551,
-1.0547757149,
0.2579586804,
-0.2117522508,
0.1832844168,
-0.3284692466,
-0.2207686752,
-0.3116661906,
0.2140376568,
0.0740153939,
0.8291501403,
-0.9371422529,
0.213242501,
0.9175074697,
-0.5699113011,
-0.626368165,
0.2606032193,
0.0395755023,
-0.1070508137,
0.0486706048,
0.0757025778,
-0.3587382138,
-0.3415264189,
-0.3246076405,
-0.4547858536,
1.2604558468,
0.5869364142,
-0.2156983018,
-0.0875547528,
-0.1392047703,
0.3999339044,
-0.3786310256,
0.2079287618,
0.5266791582,
-0.1278958023,
0.3686038256,
-0.2732626498,
-0.1406027824,
-0.5553062558,
0.2733908892,
-0.0622769594,
-0.7114240527,
0.8672860861,
-0.2867467403,
-0.4280296564,
-0.1468656659,
1.1697721481,
-0.0115966136,
0.2660071552,
0.365642041,
0.5952758193,
0.7015089989,
-0.0762098953,
0.9859106541,
-0.0896934792,
0.2657203078,
1.3543021679,
0.3658711016,
0.5799782872,
0.4186501205,
-0.1328538954,
0.5794217587,
0.6132644415,
0.474317342,
0.6386778951,
0.2799857855,
-0.0772519931,
0.0223541353,
0.222918123,
-0.6606292725,
0.3874956667,
0.3569758534,
-0.1622465253,
-0.6334346533,
-0.1154738888,
0.3030379713,
0.3300718665,
-0.4744273126,
1.004827261,
-0.1321084648,
-0.495497793,
0.5411189198,
0.1603498906,
0.872857511,
-0.5960711837,
0.1879404336,
-0.5983608961,
-0.1277339607,
-0.1533129364,
-0.4527424872,
0.7302250862,
0.1307442486,
0.0258909091,
-0.1782974303,
0.5407628417,
-0.4394423664,
-0.466296941,
-0.2112719715,
0.5836101174,
0.0787410364,
-0.1724072844,
-0.1013969779,
-0.3117170632,
-0.3102185726,
-0.4761187136,
0.0635019988,
0.7650050521,
0.2669658363,
0.3290423751,
0.230613187,
0.0313137062,
0.0406310782,
0.4120782316,
1.2477241755,
-0.4148826897,
-0.9357979894,
-0.8818666935,
0.8839088082,
-0.3236981332,
-0.2357976586,
0.3191959858,
0.6946352124,
0.6068454981,
0.0183066502,
0.6043238044,
0.2238525003,
0.2360033989,
-0.5343275666,
1.0482949018,
-0.598152101,
0.304617703,
0.0430177301,
-0.6112356782,
-0.4473208189,
0.2913536429,
0.0309208725,
-0.0201565996,
0.5150435567,
0.5788621902,
-0.1232766137,
-0.0423797406,
0.1245353073,
0.0472059101,
0.5399475694,
0.4334720671,
0.5934098959,
-0.4267288148,
0.6775850058,
-0.2032797784,
-0.5662659407,
-0.2599015236,
-0.7975551486,
-1.0381609201,
-0.5214256048,
-0.4334153533,
-0.3572846949,
-0.1317508817,
0.4359848797,
0.7198391557,
-0.6981081367,
-0.3141964376,
-0.3777044117,
0.2920553088,
-0.2902778983,
-0.2372772396,
0.2516862154,
-0.820812583,
-0.7146096826,
0.0382118411,
0.3224567473,
0.4541519284,
-0.0443148091,
-0.2924265862,
0.2199160755,
0.2278935462,
0.3537195921,
0.219294399,
-0.1245141774,
0.4947076738,
-0.3071700931,
-0.0623591393,
0.0768669024,
1.0585430861,
-0.4690868855,
0.4577085376,
0.772772193,
0.9227496386,
0.9305440784,
0.0839126185,
0.662741065,
-0.8511261344,
0.3050441146,
0.4391885996,
0.4246006608,
0.1638624221,
-0.4031536281,
0.5263252258,
0.2620040774,
-0.1120484844,
-0.7519455552,
0.1533118486,
-0.9662234187,
-0.1136408672,
0.9530928731,
-0.2125106007,
-0.2313461155,
0.2430502474,
-0.0221421663,
0.5588448644,
-0.4534278512,
0.6101230979,
0.3475394547,
-0.3228424489,
0.144263193,
-0.0991832837,
0.7495553493,
0.369009763,
-0.9000873566,
-0.0074655171,
0.2718779445,
0.0451029949,
0.095105283,
0.651021719,
-0.2166870236,
0.3950445354,
0.1886274517,
-0.1847031713,
-0.3148232996,
-0.239045471,
-0.7306860685,
0.3792723119,
-0.1860176027,
-0.2802829742
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00587v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00587v2
|
Crosslingual Retrieval Augmented In-context Learning for Bangla
| 2023-11-01T15:32:50 | 2023-12-02T16:54:23 |
Xiaoqian Li, Ercong Nie, Sheng Liang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The promise of Large Language Models (LLMs) in Natural Language Processing
has often been overshadowed by their limited performance in low-resource
languages such as Bangla. To address this, our paper presents a pioneering
approach that utilizes cross-lingual retrieval augmented in-context learning.
By strategically sourcing semantically similar prompts from high-resource
language, we enable multilingual pretrained language models (MPLMs), especially
the generative model BLOOMZ, to successfully boost performance on Bangla tasks.
Our extensive evaluation highlights that the cross-lingual retrieval augmented
prompts bring steady improvements to MPLMs over the zero-shot performance.
|
[
-0.256840229,
-0.8095878959,
0.3363385201,
0.5504947901,
-0.3256267309,
0.3953394294,
-0.3028586507,
-0.5280939341,
0.1616563201,
0.3861095011,
-0.6032158136,
-0.3723345101,
-0.3855450451,
0.2868857384,
-0.1509571075,
0.7496282458,
0.181203872,
0.1983973384,
-0.1397322267,
0.0963857993,
-0.6427282095,
-0.3029483259,
-0.440571785,
-0.5115070343,
0.7825794816,
0.3822034001,
0.3999421299,
0.1455797702,
0.1125520319,
0.0900129825,
-0.2272552401,
0.3565171063,
-0.5913932323,
0.2682654262,
-0.4654018581,
-0.3972014785,
0.0288647525,
-0.3429377675,
0.8891815543,
0.8911966681,
0.1124043539,
-0.0211166143,
0.0782235414,
0.4819506705,
-0.9602179527,
0.0236581769,
-0.784850955,
0.1576578915,
-0.4374687672,
-0.5550848842,
-0.6841078401,
-0.1913633943,
0.0378389582,
-0.4266601503,
-0.0389878675,
0.0629429594,
0.7730739117,
0.0221207123,
-0.3537971675,
-0.2762103975,
-0.594691515,
0.9253467917,
-0.4745926559,
0.7770784497,
0.4894590974,
0.3790625632,
-0.0549691878,
-0.4230666459,
-0.4010231197,
-0.1285732388,
-0.1305072904,
-0.044406414,
0.0551801398,
-0.2978750765,
0.0974075273,
0.3500111103,
-0.5081954598,
0.0463692695,
-0.2577816248,
-0.1434023529,
0.5198264122,
0.2035765201,
0.436868459,
-0.3239715993,
-0.5544784665,
0.0005965286,
-1.1968144178,
0.0763800815,
0.0365504026,
1.0987055302,
-0.0878558457,
0.4381842911,
-0.1945275664,
1.2080602646,
0.0780012608,
-0.3180494308,
0.3305173516,
-0.6049908996,
-0.3146345019,
0.1238636672,
0.3814293444,
-0.1059545502,
-0.051914949,
-0.3910362124,
0.0197853558,
-0.4590223134,
0.1005247608,
-0.7574526072,
0.0865536928,
-0.1795608103,
-0.20928213,
0.3011162579,
-0.268787235,
-0.8979786634,
-0.1759178191,
-0.2653838992,
0.5943304896,
-0.5810600519,
-0.2042193711,
-0.2571761906,
0.2031331211,
0.5539243221,
0.3647355139,
-1.0771414042,
-0.183738932,
0.3817798197,
0.9837861657,
-0.0856140405,
-0.4750931561,
-0.8256130219,
0.3759651184,
-0.548114717,
0.8301474452,
-0.9504185319,
-0.6925880313,
0.2276934832,
-0.1538026631,
-0.1585084647,
-0.7556273341,
0.3019447923,
-0.838527739,
0.0974476188,
-0.6494045258,
-0.3519397974,
-0.2081762254,
0.3313061297,
-0.4039547443,
1.1706670523,
0.2704493105,
-0.7084559798,
0.6598915458,
-0.5271506906,
-0.6412662864,
0.4406055808,
-0.1875553727,
-0.0461114049,
-0.1267968714,
0.420022577,
0.3811711073,
-0.1399183571,
0.0010842297,
-0.0601880401,
-0.560017705,
-0.2384289205,
-0.3272457421,
0.9078761339,
0.3347623646,
-0.0771821961,
0.2971034646,
-0.6591128111,
0.0448042676,
0.0512626059,
-0.6335194111,
-0.5031072497,
-0.4746436477,
0.2364215553,
0.338578999,
0.3087464273,
-0.5622347593,
0.2231107205,
-0.4656611383,
-0.2765419185,
0.3815001845,
-0.1718925536,
0.347307533,
0.0040622833,
0.5612148643,
0.0418033786,
-0.2008897662,
-0.574545145,
-0.381958276,
-0.421172291,
-0.5538303256,
0.1620483994,
0.5074278712,
-1.0125299692,
0.0311505198,
-0.1358431131,
-0.4936645627,
-0.637912333,
0.6074799895,
0.5609349012,
0.4884040654,
0.5743391514,
-0.135839805,
-0.5722123384,
-0.601988554,
-0.3346145451,
0.0882078931,
0.128730908,
0.5011573434,
0.1129229069,
-0.4840627313,
1.1634868383,
-0.1732801795,
-0.1933990419,
-0.6701368093,
0.2234858871,
0.1892315596,
0.2512290776,
0.6054093838,
-1.0208003521,
-0.9286605716,
0.1159785017,
-0.5890875459,
-0.3502657712,
0.2699677348,
-0.1433924288,
0.4063670039,
0.5897515416,
-0.4670937359,
0.2723849714,
0.4783167243,
-0.3918511868,
0.6383525729,
-0.14139916,
0.2393909842,
-1.1069214344,
0.1506130844,
-0.2980161309,
-0.4020077288,
-0.4689079225,
0.1288521588,
0.0719284266,
-0.220878467,
-0.6491112709,
0.9298936129,
-0.5393963456,
-0.3651386797,
-0.5033900738,
0.0877135321,
-0.0473515429,
0.3169775605,
0.2270457447,
1.1276711226,
0.6447467804,
-0.6911818385,
0.4239963591,
0.3736341298,
-0.5039191246,
0.6356152892,
-0.3756324053,
-0.0893237889,
-0.2357690334,
0.2015562654,
-0.8166183233,
-0.3351079822,
0.1757683009,
-0.1969356239,
0.4971461892,
-0.2485452145,
-0.5486657023,
0.0124133024,
0.0598562844,
0.7688718438,
0.2409684211,
-1.0228979588,
0.5607532859,
0.2316406965,
-0.3494897485,
-0.7639985681,
-0.7273595333,
0.1246495694,
-0.1196519285,
-0.2391441017,
0.3411421478,
0.0041187168,
-0.0940152779,
-0.2215943038,
0.3895656765,
0.0372363515,
-0.1954991072,
0.03193409,
0.2544783056,
-0.0012363114,
0.2286778837,
-0.0460096635,
0.1495846212,
-0.3058212399,
-0.1480271071,
0.8561317921,
-0.0212191734,
-0.4695003331,
0.0480849594,
0.5304008126,
0.20613271,
-0.4490182996,
1.0112271309,
0.8898275495,
-0.3577973843,
-0.1428702623,
-0.4471008182,
0.0947716311,
-0.3889719844,
0.3758050799,
-0.5296775103,
-1.0508716106,
0.4302571416,
-0.1108335331,
-0.2846516073,
0.1267489642,
0.9642560482,
0.205496192,
0.6829431653,
0.9897155762,
-0.0038306126,
0.7128645778,
0.0110917855,
0.4078238904,
-0.8459982872,
-0.593439281,
-0.1721255481,
0.1996484846,
-0.3027331531,
-0.7179169059,
0.3944920599,
0.375905484,
-0.1602533013,
0.2833986878,
0.0091634318,
0.5044466853,
0.6333250403,
0.0793292448,
0.3538815081,
0.0471147895,
-0.438339144,
0.0214396454,
-0.9256576896,
-0.1409042627,
0.8196505308,
-0.0396820828,
0.7319771647,
0.1877451539,
0.6787563562,
0.1974281222,
0.331750989,
-0.5094484091,
0.4246564806,
0.1980152726,
-0.721937716,
-0.2434345931,
-0.472933203,
-0.9726064801,
0.4362115264,
-0.1182718128,
-0.8165156841,
0.2826780975,
-0.0357838795,
-0.5770689845,
0.2982905209,
-0.557759881,
0.9622086883,
-0.1343645453,
-0.6696665287,
-0.2222637236,
-0.6300384402,
0.2745859027,
-0.1726130694,
0.1466004401,
-0.0607854128,
0.0346394368,
0.2977880836,
-0.0806240067,
0.8334098458,
-0.0714199021,
-0.4026215374,
0.3208672702,
0.003744866,
0.2453801334,
0.0111603122,
-0.0839653015,
0.0128131993,
-0.1954818964,
-0.7102193832,
-0.5587459207,
0.7205401659,
-0.4575238228,
-0.3333514929,
-0.3896146715,
-0.9506906867,
-0.4644283056,
0.1821144372,
0.306466192,
0.4699533582,
-0.1399756223,
0.0411701463,
0.5023114681,
-0.456979841,
0.6920256019,
0.5280019641,
-0.7810628414,
-0.2092271,
0.8980994821,
0.0746172816,
0.2406407148,
0.6629768014,
-0.1169881448,
-0.490776062,
-0.3729026616,
-0.6442928314,
0.1843717992,
-0.7731019258,
-0.3334642053,
-0.5124393702,
-0.1255793273,
-0.4738428891,
-0.1854586899,
-0.3011447489,
0.1807586551,
-0.1911389828,
0.0350122005,
0.2784992456,
0.7428766489,
-0.2876928747,
0.1574729979,
-0.8899598718,
0.0986809805,
0.3467873335,
0.3777132332,
0.1631871611,
-0.6833464503,
-0.6053066254,
-0.0402255468,
-0.1430893689,
-0.8315501809,
0.6742047071,
0.334389329,
0.4884549379,
0.2914522588,
-0.1221037284,
0.8045843244,
-0.6178293228,
0.7375087142,
0.0655613244,
-0.9050215483,
0.7325250506,
-0.4863401949,
0.4736251831,
0.4110783339,
0.8710456491,
-0.5270289183,
0.1652216166,
-0.0884935856,
-0.8831122518,
0.5968244076,
-0.1212474331,
0.2127597034,
-0.1538748443,
0.1915158182,
0.334744662,
0.1659967005,
-0.8810719252,
0.0400705673,
-0.0662799478,
-0.0131357275,
-0.1986508369,
-0.4134672582,
0.0754153505,
-0.4274870157,
0.7578830719,
-0.2724476755,
0.0670522898,
0.2421122044,
-0.4278173447,
-0.3280827105,
0.412294507,
0.3247199953,
0.9721606374,
-0.2665635943,
0.0501011498,
0.3406798244,
-0.0660823956,
0.1035140455,
0.0577375405,
-0.2402785271,
0.0383229479,
0.4673517346,
0.8693413138,
0.6150118709,
-1.0826035738,
0.2670473158,
0.2989019156,
0.566061914,
-0.0100196106,
-0.1834277809,
-0.0212921146,
0.4558112323,
0.7372254729,
-0.3209477067,
0.0027094148,
-0.888330102,
0.2723872662,
0.6089525819,
-0.3440125883,
-0.1822841316,
0.4160945415,
0.0240938868,
-0.3441284001,
0.4002738595,
-0.4567719698,
-0.6994866133,
-0.1815434694,
1.0075895786,
0.5626320243,
-0.4042982459,
0.2592427135,
0.4303812981,
-0.0707819685,
0.2134257555,
0.2829903662,
-0.456764847,
-0.6146840453,
-0.8043812513,
-1.0283774137,
-0.5058737993,
-0.1613324136,
-0.4654778242,
0.2523292005,
-0.236095041,
0.1369738877,
-0.4834574759,
0.190743655,
-0.3410253525,
0.3020485342,
0.4258413911,
0.9266913533,
-0.8574633598,
0.8962302804,
0.7135735154,
-0.5286778212,
-0.6735578775,
0.0531279407,
-0.4255202711,
-0.6886923909,
1.2051240206,
0.1393143833,
-0.1990827471,
0.0740900338,
-0.3224738538,
-0.9961948991,
0.8628677726,
0.5760558248,
-0.3710802495,
-0.1056040525,
0.0975558758,
0.4705273211,
-0.4767175317,
0.3564864099,
0.3671399951,
0.1888239682,
0.3970457911,
-1.0660068989,
-0.1967909336,
-0.231276527,
0.1721225083,
0.0235785563,
-0.6355801225,
0.9708203077,
-0.2370651662,
-0.2085701078,
-0.0294710379,
0.9123064876,
0.4253874719,
0.3250176013,
0.2344794124,
0.582434237,
0.6975319386,
0.0446676239,
1.2094080448,
-0.1204448193,
0.3583282828,
1.0196802616,
-0.4350420535,
1.1297895908,
0.5679780841,
-0.2084702253,
0.7033655643,
0.83357656,
0.3110278547,
0.8227847219,
-0.2181026042,
-0.6284945607,
-0.5322864652,
-0.6720411181,
-0.4521275759,
0.4859637916,
0.2486447394,
-0.1206459403,
-0.5647010207,
0.3828485906,
-0.3175543249,
0.2239176631,
-0.6434112787,
0.5138656497,
0.0639505386,
-0.5051211715,
0.6799561381,
-0.1241560355,
0.9000375867,
-0.6437206268,
-0.1516019404,
-0.0892678201,
0.0501079373,
-0.0740970373,
-0.451843828,
0.5281133652,
0.0482649393,
-0.3510396779,
-0.2503437698,
0.743940711,
-0.9118006229,
-0.6626800299,
0.7289000154,
0.6097580194,
0.0481601842,
0.0063290629,
-0.491323173,
0.1052330881,
-0.2944109738,
0.0612117685,
0.5011023879,
0.2721011341,
0.0741202161,
0.7552958131,
0.5754468441,
0.1972470134,
0.4406608641,
0.1556383371,
0.7351374626,
-0.6292940974,
-0.6432388425,
-0.8024300933,
0.0511712432,
0.151754871,
-0.0926498249,
1.1009265184,
0.5797784328,
1.3520320654,
-0.0443634987,
0.6494075656,
-0.0629462898,
0.7255023718,
-0.5912474394,
0.6266604662,
-0.7404178381,
0.0872727782,
-0.3994731903,
-1.0423084497,
-0.286560446,
0.6061969995,
-0.5072466731,
0.2793800533,
0.2828791738,
0.6718222499,
-0.1292033345,
-0.1931974292,
0.6035088301,
0.0371058024,
0.0857983232,
0.6637014151,
0.9259186983,
-0.3781672716,
0.400262922,
-0.0989646614,
-0.0572481491,
-0.4921762049,
-0.8292794228,
-1.0191322565,
-0.6920247078,
0.0017519483,
-0.1246245131,
0.2610722482,
1.2665662766,
0.81204319,
-0.8207831979,
-0.2457771599,
0.2607474625,
0.1823360771,
-0.0122233247,
-0.2263187021,
0.2689934075,
-0.8460746408,
-0.9062286019,
0.9210802913,
0.5089780688,
-0.1335403323,
-0.3009777665,
-0.2243065834,
-0.8454363346,
0.0879515782,
0.7913570404,
0.5244128108,
-0.6498607397,
-0.0475687869,
-0.162380144,
-0.2202731669,
0.0763050988,
0.7485048771,
-1.0488576889,
0.5311589837,
0.6173101068,
0.9912475944,
0.4595753849,
0.0395947732,
0.5967195034,
-1.0352365971,
0.4356473982,
0.1674979478,
0.3228565156,
0.7683811188,
-0.2305285782,
0.2414539754,
0.2948955894,
-0.2737022638,
-0.9037795663,
0.2799572349,
-0.6331909299,
-0.2659899592,
1.07455194,
-0.3251366019,
-0.1709002107,
-0.1253648549,
-0.1791875362,
0.3284796774,
0.0483706109,
0.6811337471,
0.5504767895,
0.0120762018,
-0.2851915359,
-0.1886480153,
0.37854141,
0.722443521,
-0.6012177467,
0.0267090593,
0.352853477,
0.1076465622,
0.2882782519,
0.5574795604,
-0.0474668853,
0.3200983405,
-0.1088217646,
-0.1072099283,
-0.0417488366,
-0.7081817985,
-0.4345171154,
0.2288046479,
-0.0316876695,
0.1696702391
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00739v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00739v1
|
Can Large Language Models Design Accurate Label Functions?
| 2023-11-01T15:14:46 | 2023-11-01T15:14:46 |
Naiqing Guan, Kaiwen Chen, Nick Koudas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.DB, cs.LG, H.2.8; I.5.4
|
Programmatic weak supervision methodologies facilitate the expedited labeling
of extensive datasets through the use of label functions (LFs) that encapsulate
heuristic data sources. Nonetheless, the creation of precise LFs necessitates
domain expertise and substantial endeavors. Recent advances in pre-trained
language models (PLMs) have exhibited substantial potential across diverse
tasks. However, the capacity of PLMs to autonomously formulate accurate LFs
remains an underexplored domain. In this research, we address this gap by
introducing DataSculpt, an interactive framework that harnesses PLMs for the
automated generation of LFs. Within DataSculpt, we incorporate an array of
prompting techniques, instance selection strategies, and LF filtration methods
to explore the expansive design landscape. Ultimately, we conduct a thorough
assessment of DataSculpt's performance on 12 real-world datasets, encompassing
a range of tasks. This evaluation unveils both the strengths and limitations of
contemporary PLMs in LF design.
|
[
-0.3420339823,
-0.7833359838,
0.4915453792,
0.2985551357,
-0.1960190684,
0.0806990564,
-0.2211630493,
-0.258516252,
-0.0426771976,
0.5313965082,
-0.5299751163,
-0.5031039715,
-0.5009824634,
-0.0756068453,
-0.437761277,
1.1307915449,
-0.3182938099,
-0.1808066666,
-0.2513908446,
0.0189217571,
-0.2435400933,
-0.5031368136,
-0.3884328306,
-0.4619740844,
0.5911688209,
0.3676547706,
0.9985591173,
0.5200619102,
0.6104741096,
0.1823786944,
0.1191195324,
0.2509938776,
-0.7752538919,
0.0586456172,
-0.1595941782,
0.0350654125,
-0.5220654011,
-0.1170612723,
0.605096519,
1.2416102886,
0.0027688472,
0.2043405771,
0.244428128,
0.789922595,
-0.5811568499,
0.421913892,
-0.2886818647,
-0.0938002616,
-0.2050296217,
-0.0174176916,
-0.6650127769,
-0.4383350909,
0.238980189,
-0.5812814236,
0.0924379528,
0.1101503819,
0.8209702969,
0.5128064752,
-0.1500127614,
-0.5329117775,
-0.7604762912,
0.6671468019,
-0.6400642991,
0.7239872813,
0.7008134723,
0.0944929048,
-0.4618299305,
-0.7178599834,
-0.0619614981,
-0.3683616519,
-0.3185972571,
-0.130402416,
-0.0184068587,
0.1000354812,
0.25621593,
0.2558837235,
-0.7132254243,
0.3433271348,
-0.3799046278,
-0.0401481874,
0.6253994703,
0.109750092,
-0.013454848,
0.0938599929,
-0.2895625532,
-0.175487861,
-0.7214916348,
-0.1033799723,
0.2610331178,
0.4010116458,
-0.1127808094,
0.5610642433,
-0.0760286897,
1.1190960407,
-0.2277339995,
-0.2009494752,
0.1696829349,
0.0568108596,
-0.3377629817,
-0.0456766188,
0.8374800086,
0.1043517515,
0.4379962981,
-0.3102070689,
-0.3777623177,
-0.2874913812,
0.3934506178,
-0.8227225542,
-0.6962005496,
0.3472026289,
-0.045557484,
-0.4423176348,
0.0943748429,
-0.3574900329,
-0.6605632305,
-0.5399667621,
0.3743399084,
-0.5103307366,
-0.0844269618,
0.3215789795,
0.2508627474,
-0.0598115437,
0.1049159616,
-0.4666494131,
0.3094491363,
0.4703930914,
0.5459771156,
-0.4511998594,
-0.204338178,
-0.6050705314,
0.4129552543,
-0.4535585642,
0.5772086382,
-0.5829791427,
-0.3752645254,
-0.1791564822,
-0.2237980664,
-0.0722864121,
-0.5071870685,
0.557004571,
-0.5764886737,
-0.1385957152,
-0.1559582055,
-0.9206437469,
0.0002237389,
-0.0954403132,
-0.8331227899,
0.9708024263,
0.35115242,
-0.9035712481,
0.5679596663,
-0.6130619049,
-0.6763675809,
0.2819564939,
-0.1078880578,
-0.8119931221,
-0.0225104988,
0.2190462649,
0.719104588,
-0.0977610573,
0.7929673195,
-0.4621466398,
-0.4613016546,
0.5198736191,
-0.2902347147,
0.6091123819,
0.1839803159,
-0.2064365745,
-0.0172602721,
-0.7601235509,
0.2146835029,
-0.0505546965,
-0.4838371575,
-0.2049694955,
-0.043325372,
0.0881129354,
-0.1547322571,
-0.1159325019,
-0.2153297365,
0.1702544838,
-0.1130216792,
0.1790077686,
0.6489039063,
-0.1221912727,
0.3136121035,
-0.2050510645,
0.6307771206,
-0.5221819878,
0.04568718,
-0.0533122346,
-0.3148465753,
-0.5568965077,
-0.8347091079,
0.467374593,
0.4374767244,
-0.9037828445,
0.6819896698,
-0.1663996726,
-0.6100719571,
-0.3444655836,
0.3816817999,
0.3093506992,
0.4469994903,
0.2268154323,
-0.0577152371,
-0.3434030414,
-0.8677815795,
-0.0082548978,
-0.244446829,
-0.0733814389,
0.3195084631,
0.3561919034,
-0.0729014277,
1.0783923864,
-0.7211416364,
-0.2209415138,
-0.2966784239,
0.2049256563,
0.3311272562,
0.2474029958,
0.6681666374,
-0.6801207662,
-0.4827167094,
-0.1560228169,
-0.8167032003,
-0.5640697479,
-0.1772644371,
-0.1413592994,
-0.1746676266,
0.3757328987,
-0.541444838,
0.379185915,
0.5799453259,
-0.0777668282,
0.542617619,
-0.1617853492,
-0.1184033602,
-0.5467826724,
0.4047748148,
-0.0554879196,
-0.2108684629,
-0.7780221105,
0.0297859311,
0.2116838843,
-0.230582431,
-0.4089305103,
0.6103380919,
-0.4895716012,
-0.0078286808,
-0.2842226624,
-0.042880401,
0.0182664115,
0.4077879786,
0.1932294667,
0.4110140204,
0.8047661185,
-0.7230532765,
0.403050065,
0.060018491,
-0.298102349,
0.4969730377,
-0.7690296769,
0.119186677,
-0.1866127849,
0.2738842368,
-1.1490660906,
-0.5396154523,
0.1782954633,
-0.0718842372,
0.5458105206,
-0.4046157897,
-0.8472406268,
-0.6511932611,
0.003294006,
0.3174712658,
0.427738905,
-0.5373869538,
0.2843057811,
0.5358169079,
-0.277393043,
-0.1743486673,
-0.4432130754,
-0.0688709542,
-0.2988727987,
-0.4998866618,
-0.025930183,
-0.0999260992,
-0.1624676138,
-0.4137957096,
-0.0515785813,
-0.2606176436,
0.135084793,
0.3910057247,
0.3518326283,
0.0937250182,
0.2342232913,
-0.0507666394,
0.004532374,
-0.1276430786,
-0.3860005736,
0.3273165226,
-0.1387375444,
-0.6065549254,
-0.1915214807,
0.0192030892,
0.4200031161,
-0.277220279,
0.3966325223,
0.5495101213,
-0.1478775442,
-0.4726287425,
-0.3831548989,
-0.2477156669,
-0.5370243192,
0.2124479115,
-0.3605830073,
-0.8155157566,
0.2149428129,
0.0830677375,
0.2012931556,
-0.2867938876,
0.4649158418,
-0.1742312163,
0.734474957,
0.5984953046,
0.1525340378,
0.2028291374,
-0.1070943102,
0.3049350083,
-0.3469252884,
-0.1558527052,
-0.2450063229,
-0.317853272,
-0.3692353964,
-0.4400584698,
0.3702861369,
0.0873793066,
-0.007692846,
0.423933953,
-0.5340673327,
0.4404374659,
0.3343008459,
0.0261275116,
0.010748012,
0.1270057112,
-0.0009760418,
-0.1656462848,
-0.824977994,
-0.5248119831,
0.8756403327,
0.599934876,
1.3527100086,
-0.0172242075,
0.6524439454,
0.2242659479,
0.6624185443,
-0.8354399204,
0.493917793,
-0.320792675,
-0.5377478004,
-0.3916642368,
-0.2750251293,
-0.840093255,
-0.0023701491,
0.1763546765,
-0.6332817674,
0.2194412649,
0.5526379347,
-0.244768694,
0.160056442,
-0.8839621544,
0.6683612466,
-0.4414042234,
-0.6603591442,
0.6430058479,
-0.4990659058,
0.3320790827,
-0.6187823415,
0.4016335011,
-0.1810645908,
0.1084335372,
0.7828191519,
-0.3699860275,
1.1096606255,
-0.2482343465,
-0.4805481136,
0.4346683323,
0.4765625,
0.5510311127,
-0.0198768694,
-0.189490959,
-0.1568210423,
-0.2969232798,
-0.3432155252,
-0.2889986634,
0.5575278401,
-0.2631667852,
-0.2521030009,
0.0353135429,
-0.760091722,
-0.5060395598,
0.3527918458,
0.0397230685,
0.4349906445,
-0.110841386,
0.2550079525,
0.8807035685,
-0.2842283249,
0.1272130162,
0.639380157,
-0.3809219897,
-0.1367086023,
1.1615496874,
0.0855964869,
0.238675341,
0.3682626486,
0.1482333392,
-0.3666048646,
-0.3872500062,
-0.4576846063,
0.1882517189,
-0.5985961556,
-0.1618038118,
-0.5171179175,
0.0516006984,
-0.2550188005,
-0.2641460001,
-0.5007135272,
-0.369836241,
-0.0705378577,
-0.2260467112,
0.4171527028,
0.9118019938,
-0.0989407673,
0.4543876946,
-0.5330827832,
0.3802090287,
0.0160219427,
0.7012168765,
-0.3003462851,
-0.4323306382,
-0.2271475345,
-0.1010915488,
-0.0280173197,
-0.8230788112,
0.3476716578,
0.2354599684,
0.7073383331,
0.1835166067,
0.2997485101,
0.4196223915,
-0.4613756835,
0.3411978781,
-0.0377280228,
-0.5357928872,
0.5366450548,
-0.3998568356,
0.3223282397,
0.4819621742,
0.6465400457,
-0.0952455178,
-0.7386054993,
-0.5366207361,
-1.0120497942,
0.7321379185,
0.3838199079,
-0.0510830246,
0.2248706073,
0.1941043735,
0.4825581014,
0.1631678492,
-0.5697785616,
-0.2718726099,
-0.2203577906,
-0.2833880484,
0.0484081507,
0.0526124574,
-0.028615823,
-0.1997404695,
0.6609408259,
-0.2905781567,
-0.0358965136,
-0.1811866313,
-0.2108291835,
0.0389572978,
0.0627627745,
0.5257337689,
0.8859882951,
-0.2513585985,
0.2535633147,
-0.2032633573,
-0.4013124704,
0.1645260304,
0.4560216963,
-0.2092609853,
0.0933716893,
0.4613467455,
0.9259816408,
0.2181432098,
-0.70619452,
0.3507401049,
0.0883405358,
-0.2803626955,
-0.0805846378,
0.114666827,
0.1968931854,
-0.1794989258,
0.3210316002,
-0.4815316796,
-0.0188643616,
0.0077806213,
0.7822904587,
0.1988765895,
-0.4161643088,
-0.1113377959,
0.682862699,
0.0650430694,
-0.0231880844,
0.6486068964,
-0.1628980488,
-0.4181609154,
0.4336841404,
0.2149275243,
0.607814014,
-0.1618059427,
0.3707926869,
0.2118079364,
0.3449375927,
0.1087340787,
0.0146294367,
-0.0768050775,
-0.5256114602,
-0.6520720124,
-0.8545120358,
-0.4108962715,
0.5046889186,
-0.6700792313,
0.3796472847,
-0.4729610384,
-0.2178179175,
0.3260376155,
-0.3354235291,
-0.7044081092,
0.3623994291,
0.185608834,
0.679494977,
-0.974419415,
0.8173899055,
0.8858620524,
-0.224575296,
-0.920674324,
-0.0438235253,
-0.0919291973,
-0.7987164259,
0.8524580002,
-0.079970561,
0.0094076041,
0.0782112405,
-0.6328548789,
-0.7887358665,
0.622518003,
0.4954783022,
-0.3903334439,
0.1653073281,
0.4695847929,
0.5289265513,
-0.0881240293,
0.0031661582,
0.5409114957,
0.6152685881,
0.3197488189,
-1.0832858086,
-0.0387297198,
-0.0195660014,
-0.1113723963,
0.1045009792,
-0.3342569768,
0.5199276805,
-0.3784540296,
0.0377045535,
-0.1856165379,
0.5065995455,
0.4859867394,
-0.1086414084,
0.3786924779,
0.3236751258,
0.725079,
-0.0936104953,
1.0308092833,
-0.112201795,
0.3460882902,
1.3574502468,
-0.3794245124,
0.3483890891,
0.4514391422,
-0.1650279462,
-0.0766150653,
0.7464833856,
-0.2346019447,
0.5343607664,
0.5728535056,
-0.0521563329,
-0.2637408078,
-0.1304430366,
-0.0918790624,
0.1656642258,
0.555021286,
-0.393430829,
-0.3479162753,
0.1559450477,
0.0112379799,
-0.0730712265,
0.0419436321,
0.6726664305,
0.1363405585,
-0.5894873738,
0.7648501992,
-0.1243932694,
0.2367209941,
-0.5010187626,
-0.0492294133,
-0.231004864,
0.2855479717,
-0.2266560048,
-1.2733522654,
0.1063980088,
0.0053996416,
0.2388413996,
-0.5350953937,
0.8896058798,
-0.5069496632,
-0.5446350574,
0.1365703195,
0.4843243957,
0.3886873424,
0.1744616777,
-0.6116962433,
0.5272499919,
0.0553405061,
-0.4291324615,
-0.0220551193,
0.3916217387,
-0.1692872047,
0.906291008,
0.413733989,
0.1229099408,
0.1029566377,
0.3513227403,
0.864785254,
-0.147961095,
-0.3763415515,
-0.6375940442,
0.454095751,
-0.0032953275,
-0.0177622531,
0.4594297409,
0.6360275745,
0.8553744555,
-0.3115722537,
0.9523726106,
-0.2612062395,
0.4798634648,
-0.5042306185,
0.7114287019,
-0.4076476991,
0.3726970255,
-0.4414460659,
-0.967258215,
-0.5213317275,
0.7237064242,
-0.4192110896,
0.1443797499,
0.3622133136,
0.8385133147,
-0.2910556495,
-0.0175184868,
0.4841154516,
0.1287398189,
0.5688369274,
0.3964731395,
0.737200141,
-0.1346857846,
0.5212706327,
-0.5636455417,
-0.3866740763,
-0.1990261376,
-1.0014550686,
-1.1071525812,
-0.4817632735,
-0.5783819556,
0.0097841937,
0.1145029962,
0.641716361,
0.9392148256,
-0.7575318813,
-0.3453104198,
-0.0061323387,
-0.0977226645,
0.0705388039,
-0.2599203885,
0.5523639321,
-0.2261784375,
-0.5825920701,
0.3909047842,
0.0542584248,
0.2863728106,
-0.2349965572,
-0.0643015057,
0.1623807251,
-0.1677872837,
0.5197120309,
0.2289099246,
-0.2950774133,
-0.1140172333,
-0.1564353853,
-0.2238919735,
-0.3014580905,
0.8681655526,
-0.6095860004,
0.3056182861,
0.3505022526,
0.7065325975,
0.5256484747,
0.0235798154,
0.6957604289,
-1.2631723881,
-0.0187578537,
0.2440735102,
0.1186950579,
0.5871002078,
-0.3332385421,
0.7334593534,
-0.0336634293,
-0.4841937721,
-1.0823273659,
0.2378650904,
-0.7314243913,
-0.2552595437,
1.2931287289,
-0.2309312373,
-0.1310721189,
-0.3432679474,
-0.3219573498,
-0.0295473579,
-0.2407555878,
0.448805064,
0.6435406208,
-0.4783119261,
-0.0107911024,
-0.6731340885,
0.6321393251,
0.2026585788,
-0.6531695127,
0.5905498266,
0.54184407,
0.2702743411,
0.0301390085,
0.6337757707,
0.0519142747,
0.1468983144,
-0.3532938659,
-0.1137684882,
-0.2338321507,
-0.4133363664,
0.1895477176,
0.1470202059,
0.3747374415,
0.2751452029
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00571v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00571v1
|
LLaVA-Interactive: An All-in-One Demo for Image Chat, Segmentation, Generation and Editing
| 2023-11-01T15:13:43 | 2023-11-01T15:13:43 |
Wei-Ge Chen, Irina Spiridonova, Jianwei Yang, Jianfeng Gao, Chunyuan Li
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.MM
|
LLaVA-Interactive is a research prototype for multimodal human-AI
interaction. The system can have multi-turn dialogues with human users by
taking multimodal user inputs and generating multimodal responses. Importantly,
LLaVA-Interactive goes beyond language prompt, where visual prompt is enabled
to align human intents in the interaction. The development of LLaVA-Interactive
is extremely cost-efficient as the system combines three multimodal skills of
pre-built AI models without additional model training: visual chat of LLaVA,
image segmentation from SEEM, as well as image generation and editing from
GLIGEN. A diverse set of application scenarios is presented to demonstrate the
promises of LLaVA-Interactive and to inspire future research in multimodal
interactive systems.
|
[
-0.3532119095,
-1.1122338772,
0.7115314007,
0.4324625432,
-0.1789530516,
0.2385793626,
-0.0637404397,
-0.7560816407,
0.6330545545,
0.047568541,
-0.7298551798,
-0.1707650274,
-0.2648227513,
-0.1369768828,
-0.2866128981,
0.4157758057,
0.057408791,
0.0667710528,
-0.5329022408,
-0.1832827777,
-0.6034967303,
-0.2223105133,
-0.6268367767,
-0.0196310207,
0.7443285584,
0.5409728885,
0.7571722269,
0.0774806812,
0.4781358838,
0.4749748111,
0.3008169532,
0.4088588953,
-0.2484636456,
0.6306165457,
0.2048348635,
-0.5722797513,
-0.5640202165,
-0.0971593782,
0.4340641797,
0.0861620754,
0.1669110209,
0.0971596166,
-0.2306166887,
0.3739387095,
-0.6653209329,
0.1713361293,
-0.3118255436,
-0.1326607168,
-0.2734718025,
-0.0538876243,
-0.2665129304,
-0.3550567925,
-0.3404689431,
-1.0015236139,
-0.5573934317,
0.0523422658,
0.7146213055,
0.4376633763,
-0.4481325448,
-0.2830863893,
-0.8032921553,
0.7550584078,
-0.2472745031,
0.2521472275,
0.0900006443,
0.7061496973,
-0.1664166451,
-0.9038049579,
-0.9727712274,
-0.4314393699,
0.1466358602,
0.2314257473,
-0.2794918418,
0.2105748653,
-0.0222950224,
0.0313391313,
-0.2335921824,
0.1835985333,
-0.3815291226,
-0.0832867399,
0.6537467837,
0.2213325649,
0.6606935859,
-0.0903732926,
-0.4470564127,
-0.1158225685,
-0.4842793047,
0.1296184212,
0.2955005765,
-0.038261462,
-0.1332207173,
0.915790081,
-0.1631564051,
0.5410619974,
-0.0655203834,
-0.6052407026,
0.2592132688,
-0.4342187047,
-0.2801643014,
-0.2619442344,
0.8465844989,
0.5313010216,
0.1372814775,
0.3367571831,
-0.0032008125,
0.2548514009,
-0.0842488855,
-0.5340049267,
0.0298998207,
0.3625670075,
-0.4871922731,
-0.4884037971,
-0.5089152455,
-0.8559580445,
-0.3668141365,
-0.2003339827,
0.3074172735,
-0.4804625511,
-0.1984064132,
-0.380532831,
-0.0973537862,
0.3699702322,
1.0172204971,
-0.5862739086,
-0.0247279294,
0.1096876338,
0.6731814146,
-0.2322937697,
-0.4254328012,
-0.4648227692,
0.1807572693,
-0.1219716445,
1.0237219334,
-0.8612987399,
-0.5391579866,
-0.1676096916,
-0.294362396,
0.0991810933,
-0.0896942019,
0.3618711531,
-0.4198315144,
0.2186919749,
0.102540195,
-0.2787033021,
-0.066272065,
0.5415136814,
-0.568906486,
0.6736779213,
-0.1164900064,
-0.6541157961,
0.2473973483,
-0.998745501,
-0.1761836708,
0.4578853846,
-0.4996524155,
-0.1824939102,
-0.1568892896,
0.4339047074,
0.0247634389,
-0.1647438109,
0.0882796943,
-0.3268631399,
-0.2922839522,
0.5588025451,
-0.5075395107,
0.4853582084,
0.484531641,
0.0253046788,
0.5718681812,
-0.6360176206,
0.0257915612,
0.2498162687,
-0.4042550325,
-0.0688738078,
-0.272272408,
0.3207038045,
0.0865399763,
0.5138153434,
-0.7278628349,
0.6158270836,
0.2223543078,
0.286739707,
0.6145336628,
-0.0748764127,
0.4687321186,
-0.2930058241,
0.8272653222,
-0.1497542411,
0.7095262408,
-0.7580580115,
-0.72624439,
-0.7195309401,
-0.9839741588,
0.3185999095,
0.7136453986,
-1.0631328821,
-0.2690542936,
-0.0938571766,
-0.3701031208,
-0.7938091159,
0.1817850918,
0.2462261915,
0.2559806108,
-0.0836653411,
-0.1774876714,
-0.5993103385,
-1.1999551058,
0.3525480628,
-0.4012737274,
-0.1045599133,
0.4046890438,
0.4140213728,
-0.4290302992,
0.7782421112,
-0.1781829,
-0.3669410348,
-0.2537548244,
0.0341421179,
-0.225341931,
0.3457750976,
0.6055166125,
-0.8329065442,
-0.5588011742,
0.105160512,
-1.0328933001,
0.1899719387,
-0.1640817821,
-0.1920844465,
0.1304109544,
0.5284713507,
-0.8862333298,
0.5981253982,
0.5491750836,
0.1106893048,
0.5519001484,
-0.1805165261,
0.7015038133,
-0.8661602736,
-0.0050591985,
-0.3925425112,
-0.2592796683,
-0.639329195,
0.1678967476,
-0.1016837507,
-0.457170397,
-0.7735204101,
0.6271140575,
-0.4417578876,
-0.1673340052,
-0.2156507671,
0.1401437819,
0.1183597147,
0.6113962531,
-0.2565747797,
1.0275406837,
0.5887796879,
-0.2510550916,
0.6698408127,
0.5292358994,
-0.3784605563,
0.8327528238,
-0.6898429394,
0.2466477603,
0.033964809,
0.109176375,
-1.2199441195,
-0.6564081311,
0.3251821697,
-0.51593256,
0.0586642884,
-0.0991805121,
-0.4815459549,
-0.0004769719,
-0.4901973903,
0.5919533968,
0.5693475008,
-0.4094795287,
0.8436329365,
0.4392897487,
-0.3930113614,
-0.4340365529,
-0.5285852551,
0.4393648505,
-0.1441402137,
-0.9226817489,
0.065574728,
-0.1880239546,
-0.4161364436,
-0.0547886528,
0.6306256056,
-0.1636443436,
0.0010696192,
0.5355345011,
0.4684386551,
0.0491547994,
0.1257732213,
0.2131436467,
0.104604125,
-0.3580124378,
0.3875391483,
0.363122195,
-0.3419342935,
-0.9436124563,
-0.7269979119,
0.6555156708,
0.7624258399,
-0.2744334042,
0.0586365834,
0.4406435788,
0.0054681166,
0.5822877884,
-0.5794086456,
0.191313833,
-0.5565127134,
0.239613384,
-0.3852487206,
-0.7005543113,
0.2739478648,
-0.3552919924,
0.3398575485,
-0.0658311918,
0.6224722862,
-0.6315683722,
1.1073806286,
0.5928100944,
0.4927281141,
0.6758317947,
0.1785074472,
-0.0303856079,
-0.5507215261,
-0.4826392531,
-0.0811820477,
-0.58354491,
-0.4494889677,
-0.546163857,
0.6198732257,
-0.1540893763,
0.0943889543,
-0.2710258067,
-0.3163081408,
0.5128876567,
0.8028585315,
0.2371683121,
0.3009206951,
-0.0535419472,
0.1587880701,
-0.1573915631,
-0.338424474,
-0.3927973509,
0.836917758,
0.1734383553,
1.0540115833,
0.0934592858,
0.626932323,
0.4520390332,
0.2769301236,
-0.9146510363,
0.7777975202,
0.462964505,
-0.5210606456,
-0.3674617708,
0.2601924241,
-0.9688477516,
0.1171661168,
-0.5346742868,
-0.7676650286,
0.1705141068,
0.3870088458,
-0.1598768234,
0.2454751283,
-0.8368216753,
0.4074419141,
-0.5550829768,
-0.2658930719,
-0.2757679224,
-0.5232607722,
0.6579694748,
0.1791929007,
0.3846348524,
-0.1947290599,
0.0320769362,
0.3244431615,
0.039349094,
1.0049066544,
-0.2083040923,
0.1327987015,
0.3795473874,
0.4604173601,
0.2206803411,
0.0468284413,
0.2914337218,
-0.1391393095,
-0.1160567552,
-0.274776727,
-0.7678371668,
0.6516888142,
-0.8239840865,
-0.6476918459,
-0.1956852227,
-0.6576727629,
-0.0794177726,
0.1711650789,
-0.302130878,
0.1706971824,
-0.5214588642,
0.0336890146,
0.3376435935,
-0.5115199685,
0.5705006719,
-0.0444749966,
-0.7271187305,
-0.687584579,
0.7871540189,
-0.416308254,
0.1555437148,
0.3218708336,
-0.1166695729,
-0.0535983928,
-0.1376101971,
-0.5641854405,
0.0041732648,
-0.8449348211,
-0.1136859879,
-0.6216138601,
-0.0115792817,
-0.1259201914,
-0.4400135279,
-0.3625466228,
-0.6590220332,
-0.0522384979,
-0.0047810967,
0.2961165905,
0.7746278644,
-0.2068543881,
0.4686354697,
-0.6897096634,
0.3011417389,
0.808120966,
-0.0819124803,
-0.1529316604,
0.0612262078,
0.0711684972,
-0.0053363144,
-0.5853758454,
-0.7798790932,
0.234346509,
0.382455945,
0.7297815084,
0.4703727663,
-0.3387293518,
0.6689091325,
-0.3281163275,
0.9430614114,
0.6578137875,
-0.8112121224,
0.7313604951,
-0.1743163317,
0.3359622359,
0.4583325982,
0.1799874604,
-0.4250434339,
-0.255487591,
-0.3805435896,
-0.6304143667,
0.3179154992,
0.2867881954,
0.044135347,
0.192039445,
0.0388474092,
0.2273676991,
0.3725222945,
-0.6618978381,
-0.191532582,
-0.3760556877,
-0.0820023194,
0.3578694165,
-0.3983673751,
-0.4954624176,
-0.1787570864,
0.1651355028,
-0.258153677,
0.4963648617,
0.0923011228,
-0.3114279211,
0.1164335459,
0.3238987327,
0.8244485855,
0.717949748,
-0.0986367315,
-0.079656899,
0.1189342961,
-0.2925895452,
0.3281870186,
-0.2814996243,
-0.0468716919,
-0.1042040735,
0.4088360071,
0.9604115486,
0.1674201936,
-0.9225932956,
0.463291496,
-0.4217830896,
-0.3104188144,
-0.3585017025,
-0.0367212743,
0.106499128,
0.4995557368,
0.317953378,
0.1487846673,
0.2258684784,
-0.5204335451,
0.0995950848,
0.4755786061,
-0.1855475605,
-0.3526333869,
0.7412701845,
0.5835914612,
-0.371648401,
0.7832072377,
0.0597054474,
-0.0860510021,
0.4418489337,
0.2173500657,
0.6963213682,
-0.0788368508,
0.5626050234,
0.0262586568,
0.1223836318,
0.7236245275,
0.5339117646,
-0.2761843503,
-0.5725898743,
-0.5230069757,
-0.2980051935,
-0.8105146289,
-0.1290330142,
-0.362709403,
0.3135536313,
-0.3317284882,
-0.2941288352,
0.1909931451,
-0.4671136141,
-0.7725685239,
-0.1538955122,
0.368321836,
0.7497032881,
-0.5914443731,
0.8918984532,
0.8900889754,
-0.5439229608,
-0.0925727561,
-0.4683680236,
0.0223126579,
-1.1356686354,
1.0506943464,
0.1545261592,
-0.0998238027,
-0.4011145532,
-1.0306837559,
-0.6175139546,
1.1806172132,
0.5462908745,
-0.3266812861,
-0.0377186611,
-0.0640669763,
0.3080923557,
-0.3982581794,
0.6747798324,
0.2932797968,
0.6955650449,
0.6065835953,
-1.087220788,
-0.2772638798,
-0.5116439462,
0.0511963256,
-0.1932480782,
-0.7564626336,
0.6938288808,
-0.3636982441,
-0.1910189539,
0.1194220409,
0.821549952,
0.4096444845,
0.2009024769,
0.7647348046,
0.2268802226,
0.5767992139,
0.0843709186,
0.9098193645,
-0.1708916724,
-0.2980785966,
0.8463184834,
-0.37812832,
0.5426216125,
0.7781111598,
-0.002628617,
0.3607596159,
0.5845282674,
0.200115785,
0.6317581534,
-0.2626749575,
-0.4744752049,
-0.3954456449,
-0.3515888751,
-0.1419179887,
0.6477647424,
0.5104416609,
0.3614659607,
-0.1698336154,
0.4240279496,
-0.1445831954,
-0.20973216,
-0.0286175925,
0.733597219,
-0.1402249038,
-0.4204623103,
0.2904612124,
-0.3087514341,
0.7528979778,
-0.6776176691,
-0.4337774217,
-0.3315512538,
-0.2177782655,
-0.1001727507,
-1.0278397799,
-0.0287211742,
-0.2359598428,
0.2638452947,
-0.0520989783,
1.0158549547,
-0.2181502581,
-0.3102537394,
0.0681837127,
0.6562708616,
0.3169717193,
0.2355633825,
-0.7337527275,
0.5321674347,
0.1428696215,
-0.3036624789,
0.4859737158,
0.2614122033,
-0.1886391938,
1.1350463629,
0.7005718946,
-0.2558522522,
0.1016873643,
0.0094522377,
1.1212044954,
-0.4490899444,
-0.2914749384,
-0.4999293089,
0.6959491372,
-0.2661084533,
-0.2060540915,
0.5089067817,
0.1504593939,
0.416596055,
-0.1108624637,
1.0491611958,
-0.2877967656,
-0.1490094811,
-0.3055804968,
0.2379575819,
-0.7152615786,
-0.2093198299,
-0.0814322382,
-0.6501269341,
-0.1738733649,
0.4141065478,
0.1483953893,
-0.0644508302,
0.3505307734,
0.6749019027,
-0.1954838187,
-0.1205457896,
0.7199955583,
-0.1943975389,
0.6537716389,
0.1686632186,
1.3336225748,
-0.1185426116,
0.6689418554,
-0.1574994028,
-0.5991652012,
-0.3424798846,
-0.7763837576,
-0.856595397,
-0.6543764472,
-0.0948274508,
0.0475472584,
0.1500308216,
0.7816053629,
0.648747921,
-0.4039061069,
-0.286080271,
0.5988814235,
-0.0437833592,
-0.0272028036,
-0.1792333424,
0.0292544588,
-0.3095109165,
-1.104485631,
0.7644209266,
0.6048477888,
0.2809852958,
-0.468806386,
0.0093948562,
-0.3344318867,
0.031931337,
0.6994525194,
0.5962508917,
-0.5887537599,
-0.1921631992,
0.040360339,
0.0384032391,
0.2249720544,
0.595872283,
-0.6407234669,
0.6886593103,
0.3357611001,
0.5423226357,
0.6885358095,
-0.0257880837,
0.6581746936,
-0.7011484504,
0.7630704045,
0.0055073518,
0.3690922558,
0.3188626468,
-0.3618964851,
0.2280748934,
-0.0957917646,
-0.6958155036,
-0.7312642932,
0.4067976773,
-1.2214946747,
-0.1173930615,
0.8924280405,
-0.152426973,
-0.3916260898,
0.0695120096,
-0.7723014355,
-0.056999024,
-0.6001133919,
0.4519349337,
0.3431273103,
-0.6331190467,
-0.5030415654,
-0.4991024435,
0.1433177292,
0.0527976938,
-1.0732735395,
-0.4381428659,
0.7224228382,
-0.1055428907,
0.296751529,
0.9879505634,
-0.0573243722,
0.3734793663,
0.2233620137,
0.6471482515,
-0.3422749937,
-0.4769361317,
0.0934618264,
0.0683770031,
0.3608948588,
-0.6667816043
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00541v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00541v5
|
An Embedded Diachronic Sense Change Model with a Case Study from Ancient Greek
| 2023-11-01T14:20:18 | 2024-06-25T16:13:12 |
Schyan Zafar, Geoff K. Nicholls
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, stat.ME
|
Word meanings change over time, and word senses evolve, emerge or die out in
the process. For ancient languages, where the corpora are often small and
sparse, modelling such changes accurately proves challenging, and quantifying
uncertainty in sense-change estimates consequently becomes important. GASC
(Genre-Aware Semantic Change) and DiSC (Diachronic Sense Change) are existing
generative models that have been used to analyse sense change for target words
from an ancient Greek text corpus, using unsupervised learning without the help
of any pre-training. These models represent the senses of a given target word
such as "kosmos" (meaning decoration, order or world) as distributions over
context words, and sense prevalence as a distribution over senses. The models
are fitted using Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) methods to measure temporal
changes in these representations. This paper introduces EDiSC, an Embedded DiSC
model, which combines word embeddings with DiSC to provide superior model
performance. It is shown empirically that EDiSC offers improved predictive
accuracy, ground-truth recovery and uncertainty quantification, as well as
better sampling efficiency and scalability properties with MCMC methods. The
challenges of fitting these models are also discussed.
|
[
-0.369355917,
-0.6416656375,
0.8223161101,
-0.3920276761,
-0.5039835572,
-0.0457491726,
-0.2529630661,
-0.4239780307,
0.2253660113,
-0.0059964275,
-0.5039199591,
-0.7313649654,
-0.6499876976,
0.1584846228,
-0.2887403071,
0.5859872103,
-0.4328181446,
-0.1725115627,
0.1447537094,
-0.2262046188,
-0.0326434076,
-0.2207869291,
-0.4180782437,
-0.2846045196,
0.3449247479,
0.0481847674,
0.5546653271,
0.4480060041,
0.2656592131,
0.1135812104,
-0.4367036223,
0.2385296822,
0.1201424003,
0.0097157462,
-0.1353688389,
-0.5055128932,
-0.5669760704,
0.3233852684,
0.4785791337,
0.8427448869,
-0.6724179387,
-0.1987079382,
0.0233446248,
0.4144243896,
-0.9587477446,
0.2047857195,
-0.830878675,
-0.0023590196,
-0.0966791809,
-0.3458505273,
-0.2593261302,
-0.0679050162,
-0.146597743,
-0.9722380042,
0.2570684552,
-0.3097677827,
0.7202801704,
0.4103347957,
-0.1241861209,
-0.8799386024,
-1.0496439934,
0.5118861794,
-0.8204054236,
0.796425283,
0.4978811145,
0.0372065529,
-0.0733619556,
-0.69691962,
-0.9292945862,
-0.3006928265,
0.4149948061,
0.6712937951,
-0.149788022,
-0.0847733319,
-0.1329574436,
0.1361980587,
-0.1890470386,
0.1033356413,
-0.313901782,
0.2533497512,
0.3455992341,
0.3182365894,
0.1908723861,
-0.2187995166,
-0.2575452924,
-0.519867897,
-0.7853640318,
-0.0615032278,
0.5465613008,
0.0729324147,
-0.2449332923,
0.3611381054,
0.0324993432,
0.7989980578,
0.1702515632,
-0.2427518517,
-0.0950413868,
-0.1187577695,
-0.1586669683,
0.3843443692,
0.2664218843,
0.2444965392,
0.0094294325,
0.0779060647,
-0.1277817041,
0.7437729836,
0.149324581,
-0.4139203429,
-0.5679898262,
0.0743338168,
-0.1861584634,
-0.2862205207,
0.2126809806,
-0.7239732146,
-0.3719945252,
-0.3405988216,
-0.1717135161,
-0.7083359957,
-0.3307110965,
0.2578790486,
0.1793832481,
-0.1074456051,
0.5720624328,
-0.8658990264,
0.3194364011,
0.5332369804,
0.8089108467,
-0.0504948907,
-0.0471594855,
0.0221241228,
0.2039120644,
-0.9281848073,
0.8818362951,
-0.8244770765,
-0.5888362527,
-0.1753052622,
-0.0589572191,
-0.1745999604,
-0.5426166058,
0.3363078237,
-0.7069673538,
0.0016413857,
0.042443838,
-0.478916049,
-0.1294631362,
0.104651697,
-0.6882479787,
1.1291160583,
0.0876248553,
-0.7906884551,
0.8594956994,
-0.2953625917,
0.0003883798,
0.2554910183,
-0.1370113343,
-0.2165812701,
0.3142383397,
0.3261405528,
0.2380602211,
0.1330037713,
0.0656000823,
-0.2963537276,
-0.2294780761,
0.3567375541,
-0.2850593626,
0.225968048,
0.5213837624,
-0.2386027575,
-0.3158665895,
-0.649861753,
-0.1779844314,
-0.1866928041,
-0.3445147872,
-1.0264747143,
0.5161097646,
0.105185546,
0.1636053622,
0.0111477282,
-0.6028294563,
0.2971094251,
-0.3962965012,
0.4566221833,
0.6609487534,
0.0604749843,
0.3972024918,
0.0820628256,
0.5731580257,
0.4558567405,
-0.1247914508,
0.0681912303,
-0.5065167546,
-0.4926823974,
-0.2852009535,
0.5098309517,
0.3117463887,
-0.7894690037,
0.3665691912,
-0.3059268892,
-0.4472085834,
-0.5152193904,
-0.2236501127,
-0.495177716,
-0.0322824083,
0.1615370661,
-0.3631213009,
-0.2270839214,
-0.2942514122,
-0.1979472488,
-0.6225024462,
-0.2041219473,
0.4202020466,
0.5567709804,
-0.4577453434,
0.9036675692,
-0.4485184848,
-0.0029178034,
-0.0914709717,
0.276997447,
0.0388925076,
0.1504839957,
0.2022433877,
-0.7143036127,
0.022340117,
0.1085191742,
-0.4131667316,
-0.1472672969,
-0.4201760292,
0.4423711896,
0.3137591779,
0.5860810876,
-0.2893002927,
0.5671889186,
0.9727437496,
-0.4966337681,
0.6444254518,
-0.4386187196,
0.4462169707,
-1.2238246202,
0.0132335722,
-0.16752626,
0.0411810018,
-0.2590117157,
0.0897343457,
0.2681759894,
0.0766132772,
-0.3481737375,
0.486201793,
-0.5502338409,
-0.0122702997,
-0.263661772,
0.4532791078,
-0.1673392355,
0.0275170244,
0.249953106,
0.7409005165,
0.3043755293,
-1.0521410704,
0.2402660698,
0.0552557409,
-0.8414148688,
0.6273932457,
-0.5137740374,
0.0660750791,
-0.1600193381,
0.1629346609,
-0.6743232608,
0.0260370355,
0.3099604547,
-0.3084471226,
0.2291985154,
0.085649997,
-0.6858536601,
-0.1995645911,
0.0760697499,
0.5006707907,
0.262047112,
-0.5641835332,
0.5649164915,
0.135463953,
-0.0032125458,
0.0115940394,
-0.6353583336,
0.0467941463,
-0.4414390922,
-0.2861221135,
0.5811481476,
-0.0496933311,
-0.5515503287,
0.124291338,
-0.2012496293,
0.1043702513,
0.2086142153,
0.0282151476,
0.0485699363,
0.1359889358,
0.4579989016,
0.4159866571,
-0.1229220703,
-0.3271425366,
-0.4176681638,
0.6394148469,
-0.0170693845,
-0.3977088928,
-0.2769701481,
0.2517499328,
0.5767742991,
-0.2896761,
0.858238101,
0.2671840191,
-0.5544020534,
-0.187184751,
-0.3308917582,
-0.269250989,
-0.3537772,
0.3573571742,
-0.5568597317,
-0.5655760765,
0.7731127739,
-0.5969580412,
-0.2205020189,
0.5453509688,
0.7487001419,
-0.2180682421,
0.7295768857,
0.4738513827,
0.3313682675,
0.5031198859,
-0.2152868062,
0.1740803421,
-1.0861544609,
-0.1540616006,
-0.193783313,
-0.1541281492,
-0.6028210521,
-0.6197826862,
0.6953914762,
0.526586175,
0.1106508002,
0.2888680398,
-0.2365141511,
-0.1133913696,
0.1259852797,
0.1919516474,
0.4793182909,
0.0792132244,
-0.4874029756,
-0.0155563457,
-0.7146728635,
-0.7266242504,
0.8921209574,
0.2531980574,
1.0545977354,
0.2896809578,
0.5025011897,
0.2826478183,
0.009193751,
-0.6277051568,
0.2809356451,
-0.1329517365,
-0.2830549181,
0.0375706218,
-0.2339659333,
-1.0313938856,
0.0781287998,
-0.0684488937,
-0.8587660193,
0.6108362675,
0.0397473425,
-0.5210960507,
0.8022588491,
-0.253651619,
0.4782916903,
0.2326036692,
-0.0134113058,
-0.4144025147,
-0.0959495232,
-0.0618267134,
-0.1193161309,
0.2460827827,
0.011350858,
-0.2540074289,
0.9329676032,
-0.1837150007,
0.7310590148,
0.171238929,
-0.376047641,
0.5012503266,
0.5883558393,
0.5372365117,
0.1176592335,
-0.1690751761,
0.1285329014,
0.3947336376,
-0.1998820752,
-0.4840560257,
0.7305938005,
-0.7082023621,
-0.1190636158,
-0.6762214899,
-0.5071259737,
-0.021288665,
-0.4601844251,
0.4214940965,
0.4508708417,
-0.563272953,
-0.3068915009,
0.5838265419,
-0.3189966083,
0.4634412229,
0.4564800858,
0.1570449769,
-0.0465161242,
0.1771685183,
0.1443256736,
0.2964437008,
0.1551421434,
0.1670948714,
-0.1398449689,
-0.3557963669,
-0.6803970337,
0.1095089465,
-0.4000401199,
0.0961525589,
-0.395339638,
0.2894757092,
-0.3696441948,
-0.2655895948,
-0.5387838483,
-0.1325001568,
-0.6003845334,
-0.1757215261,
0.6538749933,
0.8606691957,
-0.452783376,
0.3901684284,
-0.5812345743,
-0.0496190563,
0.0771733075,
0.387483716,
-0.228387326,
-0.4904652834,
-0.2559398711,
0.1530398875,
-0.0102138594,
-1.3267577887,
0.6554647684,
0.2782612145,
0.2264979929,
0.611286819,
0.0600796044,
0.4907838106,
-0.4282577336,
0.8139584661,
0.2060895711,
-0.8779472113,
0.4699204862,
-0.3307221532,
0.5686397552,
0.3470261395,
0.1841316521,
-0.9770050049,
-0.0529271513,
-0.7007277012,
-0.6377907991,
0.3245527148,
-0.0749698356,
-0.0475980118,
-0.2603783607,
0.4361481965,
0.2055007517,
0.1183039695,
-0.0739653781,
-0.0635156557,
0.0015884103,
-0.341821909,
-0.201213032,
-0.1924158782,
0.0728097558,
-0.2689151168,
0.5105871558,
-0.1157681271,
0.3523519039,
0.4031494558,
-0.1156782061,
-0.1396281868,
0.5896053314,
0.5614076257,
0.6314170957,
-0.1797315627,
0.399771452,
0.332545042,
-0.7700480223,
-0.0272332728,
0.1622418165,
-0.2676408291,
0.069341816,
0.2317839563,
0.6974772811,
0.2765466273,
-0.5205001831,
-0.0974561721,
0.1514267176,
0.1384242326,
-0.6030743718,
-0.2925811112,
0.0934184268,
0.050170213,
0.3215260506,
0.0962262005,
0.0055279899,
-0.8113780618,
0.2491334975,
0.087583676,
-0.6550474167,
-0.528856039,
0.6688690186,
-0.2531766295,
0.2173219025,
0.5517248511,
-0.3770685792,
-0.6099443436,
0.4414948225,
0.3427984118,
0.6157307029,
-0.6965575218,
0.5212408304,
0.3390368223,
0.3904925585,
0.093741864,
0.1273284853,
-0.1485523582,
-1.0406274796,
-0.0145854931,
-0.6327084899,
-0.1478198171,
-0.1549250931,
-0.6681049466,
-0.0155313732,
-0.2773883939,
-0.2556004524,
-0.3272801638,
-0.0180564485,
-0.7339629531,
0.3239704072,
0.1727010757,
0.6721379757,
-0.9997137785,
0.8917266726,
0.8923630714,
0.0254831221,
-0.8135471344,
0.0347223282,
0.0013963404,
-0.4195187092,
0.5742769241,
-0.4358452559,
-0.178063646,
0.1076139957,
-0.4732776582,
-0.710621357,
1.2480921745,
-0.1258454919,
-0.8153986335,
0.2171656042,
0.0216746293,
0.6360228062,
-0.425861299,
0.3111873567,
0.745822072,
0.2725682557,
0.1400094926,
-0.7010714412,
-0.2412688583,
-0.0194461234,
0.2007357329,
0.3806799352,
-0.123822242,
1.0805802345,
-0.2410908341,
-0.857830584,
0.084009096,
0.707275629,
0.4349510372,
0.4067223072,
0.695749104,
1.061093092,
0.9629702568,
-0.1865269095,
1.1326166391,
-0.4845235348,
0.5252099037,
0.8335996866,
-0.3866881728,
0.93925488,
0.5720972419,
-0.3120977581,
0.9584523439,
1.0943825245,
0.2810067534,
0.765871942,
0.1730917543,
-0.7038718462,
-0.3843842745,
-0.0668396652,
-0.5218986273,
0.4629371166,
0.8232402205,
-0.3562180996,
-0.2555845976,
0.0543911718,
0.1197430417,
0.1064124405,
-0.3391060531,
0.7360600829,
0.2909808755,
-0.4012551308,
0.4222871065,
0.3736392856,
0.5627769828,
-0.5996829867,
0.0011404932,
-0.1775293946,
0.4696836472,
0.1117162555,
-0.3995771408,
0.1947890967,
-0.1458352506,
0.0912495777,
0.1739414632,
0.3741513789,
-0.5108815432,
-0.8385085464,
0.37032336,
0.5137988925,
0.2172554582,
-0.16151537,
-0.5131631494,
0.2377753556,
-0.3612367511,
-0.1096952111,
0.0871290714,
0.3940345347,
-0.1231528744,
0.3383843005,
0.4978322387,
0.4891515076,
0.1031431183,
-0.001463223,
0.6109099388,
-0.4276254773,
-0.8223743439,
-0.4239704907,
0.1608803421,
0.3484533429,
-0.4688125551,
0.3587987423,
0.1237444431,
0.8187872171,
-0.1483368725,
0.4948790967,
-0.1020920575,
0.2658452392,
-0.7878599167,
0.7717382908,
-0.6902682185,
0.3104381561,
-0.3776012361,
-0.9521486759,
0.0395920202,
0.6875849366,
-0.432719171,
0.0537559837,
0.9840539098,
0.5943015814,
-0.1784992516,
0.1072821021,
0.3971978426,
0.2809854448,
0.1150291488,
0.5385404229,
0.575268805,
-0.5753337741,
-0.0997538567,
-0.1310836077,
-0.3874860704,
0.077026397,
-0.6377798915,
-0.2710882425,
-1.1437320709,
-0.6134600639,
-0.4030960202,
0.4432107806,
0.7691126466,
0.3703677654,
-0.9019101262,
-0.102322951,
-0.1580422968,
-0.3605256379,
-0.6298802495,
-0.210665226,
0.7784760594,
0.2642357647,
-0.8625341654,
0.6118607521,
0.0901755914,
0.0880691409,
-0.2581858039,
-0.0219355505,
-0.319611311,
0.2345445603,
0.4827641249,
0.0895288661,
-0.9504170418,
-0.5394049287,
-0.0912869126,
0.007714787,
-0.1257109493,
0.9314019084,
-1.0927839279,
0.6608769894,
0.3329682052,
0.2085077614,
0.5683087111,
0.0652751476,
0.4625228047,
-0.4004393816,
0.3496578038,
0.1366678774,
0.4447678924,
0.3883576691,
-0.1651486158,
0.4176471233,
0.5811005831,
-0.0112685841,
-0.4333436191,
0.4392576516,
-1.057929635,
-0.5668175817,
1.1928060055,
-0.1073425934,
-0.0448280014,
-0.0579115041,
0.2541053891,
0.484102428,
-0.248182267,
1.0316909552,
0.7015061975,
0.1951468438,
-0.2907476723,
-0.5002174377,
0.3558046222,
0.2482871711,
-0.5732079744,
-0.1606578529,
0.4461200833,
0.1822836548,
0.2591255903,
0.244395569,
-0.2587382495,
-0.0022278333,
0.2999337614,
0.389465183,
0.1110522076,
-0.4421981871,
-0.2967295945,
-0.0650098324,
-0.1741063446,
-0.1230976135
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00522v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00522v1
|
Text Rendering Strategies for Pixel Language Models
| 2023-11-01T13:49:31 | 2023-11-01T13:49:31 |
Jonas F. Lotz, Elizabeth Salesky, Phillip Rust, Desmond Elliott
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Pixel-based language models process text rendered as images, which allows
them to handle any script, making them a promising approach to open vocabulary
language modelling. However, recent approaches use text renderers that produce
a large set of almost-equivalent input patches, which may prove sub-optimal for
downstream tasks, due to redundancy in the input representations. In this
paper, we investigate four approaches to rendering text in the PIXEL model
(Rust et al., 2023), and find that simple character bigram rendering brings
improved performance on sentence-level tasks without compromising performance
on token-level or multilingual tasks. This new rendering strategy also makes it
possible to train a more compact model with only 22M parameters that performs
on par with the original 86M parameter model. Our analyses show that character
bigram rendering leads to a consistently better model but with an anisotropic
patch embedding space, driven by a patch frequency bias, highlighting the
connections between image patch- and tokenization-based language models.
|
[
-0.3265661299,
-0.6299234033,
0.7288077474,
0.1931927651,
-0.1980468184,
-0.074911356,
-0.4402971864,
-0.4426950216,
0.1019911915,
0.5255836844,
-0.2975671589,
-0.5106406808,
-0.3480116129,
0.0157243852,
-0.3173293769,
0.7024458051,
-0.046273116,
0.0353429802,
-0.0690876991,
0.1399013996,
-0.3516203165,
-0.7405748963,
-0.6871850491,
-0.3904534578,
0.5774124265,
0.2748319507,
1.0049331188,
0.9215199351,
0.3912943006,
0.2830213904,
-0.3315432668,
-0.134025678,
-0.2163018882,
-0.1071542576,
-0.0244451705,
-0.446036607,
-0.2541441023,
-0.2063456923,
0.7044956088,
0.4462664723,
0.0353501551,
-0.2305789143,
-0.1965257823,
0.3704716861,
-0.6973224282,
-0.0851732492,
-0.4274697304,
0.0687158331,
-0.2759181857,
-0.1217603087,
-0.5885544419,
-0.0690806732,
-0.1137968227,
-0.5351014733,
0.4807406366,
0.147919476,
0.8163627982,
-0.0858368725,
-0.3762596548,
-0.3481050134,
-0.7963761687,
0.9954401255,
-0.8801560998,
0.1050671041,
0.4805193841,
0.2872006893,
0.1431809068,
-0.8326702714,
-0.6468337178,
-0.1474167258,
-0.1730773896,
0.1376561224,
-0.2159992009,
0.2244391441,
0.2570993304,
0.4050291479,
-0.2115780115,
0.4016355872,
-0.1286283433,
-0.382586807,
0.4853796065,
0.2106879652,
0.5935450792,
-0.5252372026,
-0.6085856557,
-0.2092903107,
-0.8711035252,
-0.1666971892,
0.5872615576,
0.3629285991,
-0.1781193614,
0.6552424431,
0.1689883173,
0.9379865527,
-0.3584231734,
0.2782777548,
-0.1814582646,
-0.6618657112,
0.0653711334,
-0.0842239559,
0.8164743781,
0.504711628,
0.3005431294,
-0.0227678083,
-0.4042884409,
0.1661189944,
0.4397090971,
-0.8512035012,
-0.3947345614,
0.074810341,
-0.4315010905,
-0.0562625602,
-0.5144248605,
-1.2191950083,
-0.5865833163,
-0.114606671,
0.4451785088,
-0.8054186702,
-0.1907837689,
0.1037633121,
-0.2002460957,
-0.272308439,
0.4401550591,
-1.3517719507,
0.5365408659,
0.5091881752,
0.8222719431,
-0.1221304312,
-0.1669070274,
-0.2509352267,
-0.036039371,
-0.635163188,
0.8300975561,
-0.8366858363,
-0.305858314,
0.2825424671,
-0.4726727009,
-0.1179089546,
-0.3938948512,
0.3525524735,
-0.4835124612,
0.106204018,
-0.2443296164,
-0.4047679007,
-0.0546352603,
0.0714278892,
-1.0339825153,
0.8185529709,
0.062901929,
-0.711566031,
0.2692894936,
-0.6214268208,
-0.2099385262,
0.0867207721,
-0.1622013599,
-0.1725304872,
0.2118967772,
0.4677931368,
0.3443218768,
-0.1729379296,
-0.2647456825,
0.056458611,
-0.420378834,
0.3705609739,
-0.6283730865,
0.1869383901,
0.31221506,
-0.3168357611,
0.2202540189,
-0.5707854629,
0.0723000541,
0.1121236011,
-0.4443545341,
-0.3624907136,
0.3538272679,
0.7674158812,
0.0626020133,
0.1519313306,
-0.7459423542,
0.1672747284,
-0.6377259493,
0.9391306043,
0.6071260571,
-0.2194945216,
0.5207926035,
-0.2231412828,
0.4885864854,
0.2322299629,
-0.2558832467,
-0.9151704907,
-0.4463582337,
-0.548605442,
-0.7332083583,
0.6006662846,
0.0368625745,
-0.748146534,
-0.1550625414,
-0.2399108708,
-0.320358783,
-0.4101226926,
-0.2036754638,
0.6787537932,
-0.0511978976,
0.3146440685,
-0.2737527192,
-0.2409307957,
-0.7538009286,
-0.3036884964,
-0.024352774,
0.2070283443,
0.2430127114,
0.3819974065,
-0.0202551689,
1.0447409153,
-0.535996139,
-0.0584963113,
-0.6280892491,
0.1545787305,
0.1474936008,
0.5164332986,
0.8144735694,
-0.8010630608,
-0.3802613616,
0.0909219757,
-0.159171775,
0.2626462579,
0.0827952623,
0.2382962257,
0.7222595215,
0.4987023771,
-0.5969489813,
0.6582491398,
0.8159260154,
-0.4697670639,
0.3940449655,
-0.5129535794,
0.2526369095,
-1.14339149,
-0.039506752,
0.1241351292,
-0.4665705264,
-0.8169091344,
0.332325846,
0.3657927811,
-0.5106014013,
-0.4717470407,
0.917071104,
-0.4262862504,
-0.0582157485,
-0.3442617059,
0.1184860393,
0.127748847,
0.5057491064,
0.0938738659,
0.9754444361,
0.3782799244,
-0.4783579409,
0.1500207633,
-0.0056588762,
-0.4778805077,
0.2026467621,
-0.6906580925,
0.0351662971,
-0.3229746521,
0.1945866793,
-1.7191123962,
-0.2156313211,
0.0858445242,
-0.2613527775,
0.5203656554,
-0.1911188811,
-0.8640732765,
-0.3076415956,
-0.2705731988,
1.0131232738,
0.6120583415,
-0.6220068932,
0.4263207614,
0.1754565984,
-0.3301627338,
-0.1933385134,
-0.8725756407,
0.2098525316,
-0.012878811,
-0.4670773447,
0.7055299878,
0.047112409,
0.0893483683,
0.0402472243,
0.3224573433,
-0.2644611001,
-0.2098314911,
-0.0318846479,
0.1911770552,
-0.2528942525,
0.1522339582,
-0.2472053766,
-0.1630105674,
-0.3893443942,
-0.0451521575,
1.1607333422,
0.1577812731,
-0.4731295109,
-0.4298767447,
0.4602218568,
0.65103966,
-0.3457889259,
0.6407141685,
0.2391266525,
-0.4150785506,
0.005977999,
-0.4288488925,
-0.0944989249,
-0.4141741991,
0.5552904606,
-0.335565716,
-0.6156948209,
0.5147699118,
0.1371933073,
0.1672128737,
0.4841482937,
0.5915907025,
-0.0986077413,
1.152179122,
0.6267099977,
0.0259918701,
0.5437952876,
-0.066686295,
0.3861566484,
-0.7295112014,
0.0659146979,
-0.6972817183,
-0.2140059024,
-0.4613826871,
-0.6497538686,
0.1161607578,
-0.0961115658,
-0.1632304043,
0.3275862634,
-0.2040034682,
0.4478470981,
0.6391334534,
0.1785686761,
0.2267219424,
0.3715683222,
-0.3795884252,
-0.340536505,
-0.8950731754,
-0.6560906172,
0.8377394676,
0.4047458768,
0.7870699167,
-0.0145243369,
0.4987412095,
0.0775852278,
-0.0838865787,
-0.7826437354,
0.5051605105,
-0.416790098,
-0.6049891114,
-0.1856446415,
-0.4375100732,
-0.9119032621,
0.2954703867,
-0.2429314405,
-0.7378957272,
-0.0401546732,
0.4494243264,
-0.0731615424,
0.4515440464,
-0.9898164868,
0.8822643757,
0.2664110661,
-0.3355896771,
-0.4618625343,
-0.12228477,
-0.0372784995,
0.2432426959,
0.3630261719,
0.254801929,
-0.1768506616,
0.4420108199,
-0.2436425835,
1.0042897463,
-0.0079104351,
-0.1349238008,
0.1665705889,
0.0117340609,
0.3294344246,
-0.2628309131,
-0.2668958902,
0.1842762977,
0.0369108878,
-0.6152942777,
-0.3851778507,
0.4611424506,
-0.7663751841,
-0.1853049546,
-0.3957739174,
-0.6443058252,
-0.0732899159,
0.3015485108,
0.6652675867,
1.1185662746,
-0.2608798742,
-0.1695378274,
0.3187800944,
-0.5432466865,
1.0113430023,
-0.0447421409,
-0.5684148073,
-0.5473261476,
0.8901872039,
0.0845277011,
0.4433580935,
0.2926867008,
0.1876977235,
-0.3591827154,
-0.4462660253,
-0.7481310368,
0.3667961061,
-0.7488321066,
-0.0211556852,
-0.4646853209,
-0.2603701651,
-0.246906966,
-0.0844179392,
-0.499122113,
-0.4582603276,
-0.1944649667,
0.2565965056,
0.4762935638,
0.9391899109,
0.4311260581,
0.6351702809,
-0.5139056444,
0.3704822063,
0.0826291963,
0.7209134102,
0.2223958522,
-0.1640806645,
-0.2649609447,
0.2514085174,
-0.2966378927,
-0.7206349969,
0.4140403569,
-0.0481331088,
0.4353225231,
-0.0636562556,
-0.2902266085,
0.5633248091,
-1.0408765078,
1.0911039114,
0.5665112138,
-0.9017075896,
0.2244052589,
-0.4891546071,
0.5466604829,
0.0262281857,
0.2216703892,
-0.7474936843,
-0.2793243527,
-0.3597714305,
-0.9370131493,
0.9451910257,
0.4065892398,
0.5613914728,
-0.3267483115,
0.0893993974,
-0.068080686,
0.1219228432,
-0.6190122962,
-0.0289500486,
-0.3905504346,
-0.5273566246,
-0.2985640168,
-0.6152642965,
0.0527777635,
0.053040199,
0.2929767072,
-0.0848574415,
0.6654211879,
0.0543058962,
-0.0830532461,
0.0140053742,
0.3466705978,
0.787518084,
0.7029222846,
0.337210238,
0.1565988511,
-0.3428781331,
-0.488047272,
-0.0515580736,
-0.284193933,
-0.2677592039,
0.2409934103,
0.33565256,
0.9620922208,
0.4161406159,
-0.6878913641,
0.6382867694,
-0.0706011802,
-0.2031677663,
0.1608721316,
-0.0695096999,
0.1749260426,
-0.0824753195,
0.1089480519,
0.1313561797,
-0.2126811594,
-0.5540257096,
-0.0664993823,
0.2846648395,
-0.4854859114,
-0.2665552497,
0.5042250752,
0.0222733822,
-0.5740849972,
0.4474527836,
0.3030594885,
-0.5251050591,
0.7241305113,
1.0530244112,
0.4413304627,
-0.1368557215,
0.3922579288,
0.3453968167,
0.0780757517,
-0.1608589292,
0.2285854965,
0.0879822671,
-0.530107677,
-0.4430962503,
-0.6556890607,
-0.4726808071,
-0.2300973088,
-0.322219789,
0.2349343747,
-0.6311736107,
-0.1469725519,
0.0005999515,
-0.2267566621,
-0.3682556152,
0.356267035,
0.0331413783,
0.9403008223,
-0.6306461096,
0.562410295,
0.771004498,
-0.2102196217,
-0.6005471945,
0.132493481,
-0.2227767557,
-0.6858899593,
0.5235364437,
0.2348987311,
0.1012474597,
0.1759745628,
-0.2531641126,
-0.7998444438,
0.423109144,
0.3670951724,
-0.3712588251,
-0.0227217693,
0.2977571785,
0.6124862432,
-0.2390979826,
0.3497491777,
0.1139460728,
0.2696973085,
0.363963753,
-0.5843569636,
0.0028999625,
-0.3366951048,
0.6483898163,
0.3426522911,
-0.4884023964,
0.9283463359,
0.0766323358,
-0.2831445634,
0.5522195697,
0.6754436493,
0.087619774,
-0.1030823663,
0.2578603029,
0.5223015547,
0.5070490837,
-0.1166812629,
1.4095424414,
-0.3791359961,
0.2551056147,
0.6410541534,
-0.1070853472,
1.0691862106,
0.4265173972,
0.0153297735,
0.4538772702,
0.456810236,
0.0531708635,
0.6028842926,
0.2441057116,
-0.1851148456,
0.0055613895,
0.0975092724,
-0.155664131,
0.2469549477,
0.2109948099,
-0.3177787662,
-0.5226688385,
0.2207954824,
0.1963031143,
0.6154621243,
-0.6288010478,
0.6823635101,
-0.2324941456,
-0.8712235093,
0.4672399163,
0.5758256316,
0.7199386954,
-0.6439812779,
-0.1134753525,
-0.1159849688,
0.1667482704,
-0.0599054322,
-0.6142417789,
0.2063193321,
0.248793453,
-0.3372707963,
-0.4663549066,
0.4987560213,
-0.5066208243,
-0.67981112,
-0.0216604453,
-0.2803670764,
-0.1133768484,
-0.0155617166,
-0.1836763769,
0.0796154663,
-0.3993870318,
-0.0601898506,
0.30866763,
0.3716129661,
-0.0284562316,
0.3778726161,
0.4090516567,
0.3896148205,
0.4336645305,
-0.0246386752,
0.7817182541,
-0.8988924026,
-0.7529041171,
-1.0699467659,
0.464556843,
0.0317543447,
-0.3165206611,
0.7193282247,
0.551649034,
0.3921683133,
-0.1096518114,
0.6820614338,
0.1931976378,
0.3222619593,
-0.9692424536,
0.8906807899,
-0.5128664374,
-0.0413526855,
-0.4302237928,
-0.9246125817,
-0.170002073,
0.6317890882,
-0.2287798077,
0.2220151275,
0.8902699947,
0.6908631921,
-0.1251467019,
0.1127568632,
0.3689227104,
0.128596738,
0.3610610366,
0.5794647336,
0.8526853919,
-0.5411878824,
0.2605639696,
0.0999920666,
-0.1125287041,
-0.1350185275,
-1.0129930973,
-0.9862777591,
-0.5217264295,
-0.0838826448,
-0.1303764582,
-0.0504857339,
0.6719543338,
0.7016894817,
-0.5176385045,
-0.1856961995,
-0.311609596,
-0.0102696931,
-0.1445908248,
-0.1393561214,
0.2706611454,
-0.7658486366,
-0.9215492606,
-0.0367994346,
0.2412879467,
0.0241611283,
-0.1871477365,
0.1294188499,
-0.0820034444,
0.3610147536,
0.511374712,
0.0076011652,
-0.643862009,
-0.2952371836,
-0.1438441426,
-0.4471397102,
0.3348585367,
0.900511682,
-0.7366473675,
0.4737656713,
0.5052605867,
0.7487619519,
0.7571079135,
-0.2184233516,
0.7928724885,
-0.7798885107,
0.246406585,
0.1239596158,
0.3349119723,
0.4007984996,
-0.0870975554,
-0.0326529294,
-0.0179797541,
-0.2801460326,
-0.6604420543,
0.5348193645,
-0.7802323699,
-0.5645089746,
1.2714912891,
-0.2465759218,
-0.4752617478,
0.1498229653,
-0.538238883,
-0.051207155,
-0.0682007745,
0.5369426012,
1.0422036648,
0.4176748097,
-0.2100093961,
-0.4551304281,
0.4501388073,
0.5131403208,
-0.5222215652,
0.2813819647,
0.5447970629,
-0.0097024627,
0.2460208982,
0.8531062603,
-0.285525769,
0.2729971707,
0.0893745571,
0.058585003,
-0.0060821511,
-0.4742960632,
-0.3952651024,
0.3191554844,
0.0445316061,
-0.140632689
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00513v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00513v1
|
Rule-Based Error Classification for Analyzing Differences in Frequent Errors
| 2023-11-01T13:36:20 | 2023-11-01T13:36:20 |
Atsushi Shirafuji, Taku Matsumoto, Md Faizul Ibne Amin, Yutaka Watanobe
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.PL
|
Finding and fixing errors is a time-consuming task not only for novice
programmers but also for expert programmers. Prior work has identified frequent
error patterns among various levels of programmers. However, the differences in
the tendencies between novices and experts have yet to be revealed. From the
knowledge of the frequent errors in each level of programmers, instructors will
be able to provide helpful advice for each level of learners. In this paper, we
propose a rule-based error classification tool to classify errors in code pairs
consisting of wrong and correct programs. We classify errors for 95,631 code
pairs and identify 3.47 errors on average, which are submitted by various
levels of programmers on an online judge system. The classified errors are used
to analyze the differences in frequent errors between novice and expert
programmers. The analyzed results show that, as for the same introductory
problems, errors made by novices are due to the lack of knowledge in
programming, and the mistakes are considered an essential part of the learning
process. On the other hand, errors made by experts are due to misunderstandings
caused by the carelessness of reading problems or the challenges of solving
problems differently than usual. The proposed tool can be used to create
error-labeled datasets and for further code-related educational research.
|
[
-0.0280416422,
-0.6362934709,
0.1763094515,
0.6475448608,
0.232794717,
0.2865581214,
-0.027287256,
-0.2278825939,
0.0942276865,
0.3112412691,
-0.1299988329,
-0.7914717197,
-0.7162242532,
0.2665845454,
-0.4217248857,
0.9755880237,
-0.3223156631,
0.1232476905,
-0.414996773,
-0.0969361737,
-1.0388679504,
-0.3968183994,
-0.5971727967,
0.3603463173,
0.3072822392,
0.8658547997,
0.2932584882,
0.7767697573,
0.6639990807,
0.38618505,
0.3148458898,
0.3484634161,
-0.3056721389,
-0.1746736914,
0.1627807319,
-0.6255794764,
-0.5459520221,
-0.0871675238,
-0.0052083768,
0.6263637543,
-0.2372620851,
0.1675969809,
-0.1025595516,
0.6071662903,
-0.5071851611,
0.6045655012,
-0.2165307999,
0.1713486612,
-0.3591803312,
-0.5426604748,
-0.3063201308,
-0.7365768552,
-0.4527176023,
-0.5993747115,
0.4805046618,
0.1259299368,
0.4704529941,
0.3764636517,
-0.0734288618,
-0.4952708185,
-0.444883883,
0.7422885299,
-0.8007626534,
0.2143859267,
0.1745093465,
0.2073372006,
-0.3122716248,
-0.245139882,
-0.4191543162,
0.26843068,
-0.3010143936,
-0.0904252678,
0.015448574,
0.0931097642,
0.5147945881,
-0.1109261289,
-0.7004886866,
0.0202323757,
-0.5662107468,
-0.2438200116,
0.7635198832,
0.2336097807,
0.5950891972,
-0.055064179,
0.1247116476,
0.0201014429,
-0.2267789692,
0.2478538752,
0.2911469936,
0.1548042297,
-0.2225058079,
0.1998544484,
-0.0897022188,
0.9775364399,
0.2367263138,
-0.480704248,
0.4909673631,
0.0258320551,
-0.1443228126,
0.177429229,
0.2932609916,
0.7015764117,
0.309756577,
-0.0670062602,
-0.3101148009,
0.068069011,
0.1564929932,
-0.2886418104,
-0.5960130692,
-0.1185894758,
-0.6287087798,
-0.6714109182,
0.5843420029,
-0.7976319194,
-0.5873242021,
-0.3633494973,
0.5072969198,
0.0566363782,
-0.0602754653,
0.1302883774,
-0.1335594505,
-0.0500909798,
0.4794077277,
-0.3328318298,
0.5586785078,
0.5510213375,
0.6409809589,
-0.0021341708,
-0.27253443,
-0.6123480797,
-0.3318928182,
-0.3972895443,
0.8124480247,
-0.5233552456,
-0.4065823257,
0.003666556,
-0.1710589677,
-0.3882863224,
-0.4876949787,
0.3600353599,
-0.4960168898,
0.0880170241,
0.134493947,
-0.7605854869,
-0.2690601051,
0.0981756225,
-0.4347102344,
0.9097863436,
0.3797836304,
-1.0546393394,
0.3799037039,
-0.6745334268,
-0.2869200706,
0.1938512772,
-0.4435741603,
-0.5318335891,
-0.1609273404,
-0.1313779652,
0.4392091632,
0.1429477632,
0.4177517593,
-0.179170534,
-0.6973724365,
0.1749880463,
0.1050402373,
0.8774169087,
0.1993838847,
-0.6206662059,
0.1945301145,
-1.1616731882,
0.3242050409,
-0.0146521861,
-0.5748972893,
-0.5234669447,
0.3996546865,
-0.1995513737,
0.2881604433,
0.2041395009,
-0.3766178787,
0.2708955407,
0.1438238025,
-0.0565453917,
0.8050746322,
0.2271478474,
0.0502848849,
-0.2519461215,
0.2909386456,
0.2787977159,
0.3408608735,
0.2159411609,
-0.5537281632,
-1.1551069021,
0.0846101567,
0.2053725272,
1.0073349476,
-0.4267148077,
0.71756953,
-0.0660344288,
-0.2852568626,
-0.210668236,
0.458332479,
0.5241935253,
0.4363601804,
0.4995375276,
-0.4341162145,
-0.7515242696,
-0.3878062963,
-0.0833361223,
-0.1500539631,
0.4484041333,
0.2676950693,
0.1347957402,
-0.511097312,
1.0155249834,
-0.8801594377,
-0.2415037006,
0.0223255865,
0.2805491388,
0.0325893946,
0.6300810575,
0.6250859499,
-0.4933480322,
-0.6855115891,
-0.1896665543,
-0.5931783319,
-0.5564880967,
-0.2560489178,
-0.0563296787,
0.1338490248,
0.847004652,
0.2819220722,
0.5589980483,
0.1953671426,
-0.5070050955,
0.4460517764,
-0.3331238031,
0.1733651757,
-0.3748255074,
-0.0716854632,
0.1759591699,
-0.1544128358,
-0.5621065497,
-0.0687794685,
0.1722132713,
0.2535137236,
0.1453709155,
-0.0152800474,
-0.0371741876,
0.1160578206,
-0.076860331,
-0.3838796914,
-0.1942408234,
0.587957859,
0.0254430231,
0.3876466155,
0.6680372357,
-0.6002210975,
0.7642973661,
0.061552491,
-0.1763715595,
0.4692492485,
-0.3536323011,
0.4287700951,
-0.1466965973,
0.0786481574,
-0.9332475066,
-0.3440198004,
0.6772522926,
-0.5549249053,
0.3365561664,
-0.3844637275,
-0.3245599568,
-0.4386672378,
-0.2188083082,
0.1785648465,
0.3239917159,
-0.5087813735,
0.1791933626,
-0.0097258464,
-0.3536651134,
-0.6872053742,
-0.3714517653,
-0.3390726745,
0.0210426468,
-0.5315175653,
-0.3653829992,
-0.3161379099,
-0.5503359437,
0.1667712182,
-0.3440503478,
-0.7214253545,
0.17022264,
0.6384819746,
0.2412893027,
-0.0286690984,
0.1544163972,
0.1412649453,
-0.1055440009,
0.1248538643,
0.0792028084,
0.1064741537,
-0.0754449964,
-0.4141701162,
-0.2901984155,
0.312867552,
0.2818056047,
-0.1503136903,
0.4092515111,
0.3362633288,
-0.1703972369,
-0.5334806442,
-0.5903057456,
0.3116730452,
-0.4538795054,
0.2935341001,
-0.1702592075,
-0.1543059051,
0.15565072,
0.3522152901,
0.1546602547,
0.2783473134,
-0.1457959861,
-0.187330097,
1.0408415794,
0.6902385354,
-0.1260475814,
0.3614315391,
-0.1116561443,
0.1791905314,
0.0690808967,
-0.4725165665,
-0.852308929,
-0.2030213475,
-0.3010350168,
-0.429107219,
0.0456020311,
0.0606793128,
-0.2195126861,
0.1831353903,
-0.649810791,
0.7765969038,
0.9102841616,
0.2005043328,
0.1622209698,
0.0181675274,
0.1919278651,
-0.0707055554,
-0.5612154007,
-0.1156061366,
0.9994674325,
-0.0417893566,
0.7350248098,
0.0894120932,
1.1743652821,
0.806687355,
0.2650990188,
-0.683957696,
0.4648838937,
-0.0736511201,
-0.2334081978,
0.0706551224,
-0.8693597317,
-0.4756393433,
-0.3613544405,
-0.1271992177,
-0.1349228621,
0.4534175694,
0.2163077295,
-0.3049580753,
0.3963597119,
-0.937464118,
1.0799925327,
-0.3638543189,
0.1524357051,
-0.263461262,
-0.7162545323,
0.1963846833,
-0.207494244,
0.5877655745,
0.2738287449,
0.3283368945,
1.1357585192,
-0.6578819752,
0.830442071,
-0.7217588425,
0.1160284877,
0.3663430512,
0.429523319,
0.4506535828,
-0.2272420079,
0.2473700345,
0.0054506245,
0.1398485303,
-0.4129374325,
-0.4933477342,
0.6065391302,
-0.9473893642,
-0.139624998,
-0.659619987,
-0.1456672847,
-0.1613039523,
0.2255808562,
0.0571982712,
0.6493731141,
0.4485729337,
-0.1271608025,
0.5424081683,
-0.2979502976,
0.2198957801,
0.8394991159,
0.1225766912,
0.0867271721,
1.2950749397,
0.1250073165,
-0.2578600645,
0.2683780789,
-0.0112860156,
0.1509251744,
-0.8220095038,
-0.0565295517,
-0.1347675174,
-0.9096682072,
-0.5177407861,
-0.329143554,
-0.0221798047,
-0.2624001801,
-0.3376271427,
0.4315672517,
-0.195887059,
-0.1688236892,
-0.0013351181,
0.3231780529,
0.7816587687,
-0.3637363315,
0.1225567013,
-0.9695900083,
0.0855847672,
0.4470179975,
0.8471338749,
-0.1336600929,
-0.2146146744,
-0.4341029227,
-0.3053369522,
-0.1890828162,
-0.9551588297,
0.334487915,
0.1834128052,
0.5412148833,
0.4417699277,
0.1702188551,
0.7664883733,
-0.1136637479,
0.3639476597,
0.3036265671,
-0.9425423741,
0.4049038291,
0.049925033,
-0.4969254136,
0.5179827213,
0.2209971696,
-0.9781897068,
-0.4482653141,
-0.6873860955,
-0.5328443646,
1.1913503408,
-0.0962151289,
-0.5230643153,
-0.1785013825,
0.1754023284,
0.151473999,
0.1502915323,
-0.6641210318,
-0.3668695986,
-0.2317450643,
-0.597807169,
0.0357921273,
0.0387961678,
-0.0802246183,
-0.1992275864,
0.5019255877,
-0.0715726092,
0.2896035016,
0.012156141,
-0.5715416074,
-0.4875502586,
0.1625283062,
0.3419666588,
0.7221820354,
-0.3961100876,
0.1241634488,
0.0406785198,
-0.2311563939,
-0.0364108682,
0.0413514189,
0.0146660199,
-0.0076710568,
0.3146995902,
0.2070110291,
0.2219580859,
-0.7633810043,
0.8440287113,
-0.0174995456,
-0.0365990773,
-0.2848725319,
0.5619859099,
-0.3518577516,
0.0157266632,
0.0903596207,
0.9015160799,
0.3087326884,
-0.2407083213,
0.1780841202,
-0.2764619589,
-0.129855305,
-0.0826142505,
0.1882559657,
0.81081146,
-0.3936299086,
0.6270114779,
-0.6018456221,
-0.5769342184,
1.0293608904,
0.0939793587,
0.5620140433,
-0.1769114435,
0.1937543452,
0.4269706607,
-0.2951748073,
-0.0762161762,
0.1320919245,
-0.073039107,
-0.6821013689,
-0.2297661006,
-0.2680273354,
-0.1780377775,
-0.173273772,
-0.6957345009,
0.2592888176,
-0.8998714685,
0.3096520603,
-0.0324157067,
0.0718360692,
-0.5978503823,
0.1827007681,
0.1828103364,
0.6836500764,
-0.9810432792,
0.4838292301,
0.8707432747,
-0.4462825656,
-0.8252075911,
-0.2566857636,
0.3461924493,
-0.4376582205,
1.0129272938,
0.1411872506,
0.0235784724,
-0.1599467844,
-0.5826882124,
-0.3423700631,
0.6791858673,
-0.6246916056,
-0.7815749645,
-0.1427682638,
-0.153243795,
0.4239195585,
-0.0488353521,
0.333332926,
0.4059010148,
0.4292882681,
-0.4468417168,
-1.0352282524,
-0.2470007837,
-0.3972148299,
-0.3345732093,
0.519636929,
-0.4490778744,
0.7147244215,
-0.3381618559,
-0.0993115455,
-0.0956710652,
0.0094350381,
-0.1811181903,
0.8662239313,
0.6014862061,
0.1768483967,
0.8303197622,
-0.1241809875,
0.4090760648,
-0.1988589913,
0.5189032555,
1.012018919,
0.0392501988,
0.538969934,
0.0954531655,
-0.4743181765,
0.7743372917,
0.5498142242,
-0.4711165726,
0.1541738212,
0.2784769535,
-0.0658940598,
-0.3016922176,
0.7505422831,
-0.446408689,
0.0446107127,
0.5926769376,
-0.1449003071,
-0.1966299117,
-0.3226433694,
-0.0034049894,
0.1271869838,
-0.5418702364,
0.7785518169,
-0.2972517908,
-0.4391932189,
0.3326284587,
0.4414926767,
0.8920345306,
-0.2988534868,
-0.2432104647,
-0.3396390975,
0.4666645229,
-0.9299489856,
-0.7239220142,
0.1472841352,
0.3868511915,
-0.236489296,
0.0814995542,
0.6979299188,
-0.3147020936,
-0.2830697596,
0.1476673484,
0.4470390677,
0.245903194,
0.2898204029,
-0.8571786284,
-0.1205963641,
0.2914070189,
0.4846430719,
-0.0863321796,
0.2723504603,
-0.1886082888,
0.5074570179,
0.3520490527,
0.0862041116,
0.6140038967,
-0.014517393,
0.4912202358,
-0.7053165436,
-0.5348659754,
-0.2667408288,
0.3269536793,
-0.1883333176,
-0.1312968135,
0.6394727826,
0.5416007042,
0.8132368922,
-0.3660983741,
0.839995563,
-0.5139709711,
0.7294909358,
-0.1063943952,
0.214682281,
-0.3440843821,
0.3094823062,
-0.3826771975,
-0.7231217027,
-0.6164100766,
0.8036851287,
-0.3859378695,
-0.094756186,
0.4271437824,
0.8610878587,
-0.0407474935,
-0.2757717371,
-0.0233912617,
0.1575081646,
0.3076975346,
0.5782872438,
0.5520969629,
-0.1669898778,
0.8085253835,
-0.398114264,
-0.4646657407,
-0.7475177646,
-0.2956217229,
-0.6941642761,
-0.1107100472,
-0.780757606,
-0.435818404,
0.3095178604,
1.4079982042,
0.4223453999,
-1.0334537029,
-0.206365779,
-0.5699050426,
0.1694869995,
-0.5979997516,
-0.3008183539,
0.3898213208,
-0.6652777195,
-0.4662743211,
0.124196589,
-0.2727980018,
0.0565527491,
0.3636915684,
-0.4312843978,
0.2456518114,
-0.19447276,
0.217051506,
0.6175302863,
-0.1268669963,
-0.4220653474,
-0.2618506849,
-0.281412214,
0.2434805036,
0.8416602612,
-0.5409250855,
0.7564077377,
0.8421930671,
0.2755659223,
-0.1623466015,
0.0212641116,
0.1387093812,
-0.9333008528,
-0.1958296895,
-0.0625720844,
0.3734820485,
0.0614796616,
-0.1949133575,
0.3708582222,
0.6896461248,
-0.6137259603,
-0.7361310124,
-0.1269573122,
-0.991749227,
-0.2706333697,
1.0110664368,
-0.3113907576,
0.0957531184,
-0.5948951244,
-0.4859818816,
0.2821184695,
-0.3707668781,
1.0121171474,
0.5882914662,
-0.2922725677,
0.1408747286,
-0.3670329154,
0.6482975483,
-0.0103318589,
-0.8882386088,
-0.2622415423,
0.6956963539,
0.7785825133,
0.3575969636,
0.3073561192,
-0.1222762167,
0.6865420341,
0.1395535022,
0.1519564092,
-0.2403323799,
-0.45714733,
-0.1070272326,
-0.0340491422,
0.0698779225,
-0.3809116185
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00508v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00508v1
|
Robustness Tests for Automatic Machine Translation Metrics with Adversarial Attacks
| 2023-11-01T13:14:23 | 2023-11-01T13:14:23 |
Yichen Huang, Timothy Baldwin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We investigate MT evaluation metric performance on adversarially-synthesized
texts, to shed light on metric robustness. We experiment with word- and
character-level attacks on three popular machine translation metrics:
BERTScore, BLEURT, and COMET. Our human experiments validate that automatic
metrics tend to overpenalize adversarially-degraded translations. We also
identify inconsistencies in BERTScore ratings, where it judges the original
sentence and the adversarially-degraded one as similar, while judging the
degraded translation as notably worse than the original with respect to the
reference. We identify patterns of brittleness that motivate more robust metric
development.
|
[
-0.3659746349,
-1.1354781389,
0.3434123695,
0.0555804074,
-0.1077833921,
0.2775503099,
-0.1753940582,
-0.4785929918,
-0.0847212821,
0.3549154103,
-0.4228788614,
-0.2647689283,
-0.878657341,
0.3800520003,
-0.694175899,
1.3450599909,
-0.0845074654,
0.4314998686,
0.0969251916,
-0.4520664811,
-0.2328645289,
-0.6199483275,
-0.5670280457,
-0.1147938594,
0.5279350281,
-0.0961045027,
1.3559638262,
0.554201901,
1.1541018486,
0.2934531569,
-0.1212847084,
-0.0324649625,
-0.3034844398,
0.2503664494,
-0.0896541178,
-0.5326853991,
-0.5603676438,
0.1379711181,
0.6480633616,
0.5970982313,
0.2982977033,
0.1434557289,
0.1404130906,
0.6531384587,
-0.5261486173,
-0.2395819128,
-1.046598196,
0.0327932648,
-0.2768578529,
0.0188897215,
-0.4807559252,
-0.491027981,
-0.1842103899,
-0.3699969351,
0.3527652025,
0.1242096722,
1.1956838369,
0.5170086622,
-0.4105222523,
-0.4233171642,
-0.5760843158,
0.8989841938,
-0.5665701628,
0.2261417806,
0.6294175386,
0.4563240707,
-0.4188675582,
-0.5415599942,
-0.3234909773,
-0.6378574967,
-0.0398652181,
0.2668168843,
-0.411039114,
-0.2215433121,
0.1251677275,
0.5550006032,
-1.0022913218,
0.145621255,
-0.1381260902,
-0.2517682612,
0.5472195745,
0.1845478565,
0.5285919905,
-0.3021318614,
-0.4997879863,
-0.4608751535,
-0.5747400522,
-0.218500331,
0.7510102987,
0.085539259,
0.3020905256,
0.6156420708,
0.1839322299,
0.39779374,
-0.2161203027,
0.2129425704,
0.1377527714,
-0.5066022873,
-0.2337063104,
-0.3092193007,
1.1701937914,
0.4594332278,
0.1199679971,
-0.5616922379,
-0.4737302363,
0.3441106081,
0.7909885645,
-0.6384904385,
-0.3499775827,
0.2149877846,
-0.3986983299,
-0.5732950568,
0.0773435459,
-0.406005621,
-0.3653446138,
0.2773541808,
0.7209643126,
-0.8414115906,
0.2412348986,
-0.2255515605,
-0.3817141354,
-0.1456093788,
0.1514856815,
-0.6585431099,
0.2085638791,
0.7209138274,
0.7683020234,
-0.2456357479,
-0.6024181843,
-0.4444297254,
-0.3044244349,
-0.479090482,
0.4115087986,
0.0118213398,
-0.4103057981,
-0.2013969421,
0.1051294878,
-0.2025477886,
-0.6088290811,
0.8528851271,
-0.4592162371,
0.3213983178,
-0.0665637404,
-0.2552388906,
-0.1698538512,
0.7461351752,
-0.7659109831,
0.9916221499,
0.3819397092,
-1.0516754389,
0.5701903105,
-0.7082745433,
-0.6228960156,
-0.320220679,
0.3829829991,
-0.7724609375,
0.1592925787,
0.2532980144,
0.2864805758,
-0.1459989548,
-0.1674917191,
-0.5448109508,
-0.2213502526,
0.755577147,
-0.8620553613,
1.0896424055,
0.4718028307,
-0.3182042837,
-0.0136595946,
-0.7771403193,
0.0718373731,
0.3237270117,
-0.3709116578,
-0.3895936608,
0.161349386,
0.0579952821,
-0.1096129566,
0.2330672443,
-0.5125020146,
0.0502617881,
-0.6984679103,
0.3346700072,
0.4664573073,
0.0852455944,
0.1054877266,
-0.4038082659,
0.4141071439,
-0.0329000577,
0.443187952,
0.1485874206,
-0.3492839932,
-0.6749448776,
-0.1511213034,
0.4515082538,
0.761877954,
-0.9073771834,
0.4769558609,
-0.3767826855,
-0.5857930183,
-0.7069723606,
0.274879992,
0.5764404535,
0.2305346727,
0.5226072669,
-0.5661221743,
-0.3086676002,
-0.839928627,
-0.4741550982,
-0.4612361789,
-0.3564171791,
-0.101620689,
0.7999659777,
-0.3202335536,
0.4655689299,
-0.1442348957,
-0.18853423,
-0.0024483784,
0.3411626518,
-0.1333106607,
0.3799957633,
0.938568294,
-0.6597091556,
-0.3947480023,
-0.0765783265,
-0.5334032774,
0.0689141676,
-0.1520278454,
0.012880194,
0.3042139113,
0.0656463653,
-0.3667363226,
0.333743304,
0.8140071034,
-0.3254957795,
0.6950207353,
-0.3273329139,
0.4638596177,
-1.0365409851,
0.1666850001,
-0.1558916569,
-0.4172667563,
-0.3210683167,
0.6257495284,
0.1831535995,
0.0803680122,
-0.4139608145,
-0.0873807073,
-0.1544733495,
-0.0184484925,
0.0220644344,
0.1572254449,
0.2218408883,
0.1934218705,
-0.5628399849,
0.8263134956,
0.2494984418,
-0.3706931174,
0.4099678397,
0.1524309218,
-0.3059544563,
0.9292065501,
-0.7778710127,
0.0751352161,
0.2156919539,
0.0689838305,
-1.1376297474,
-0.171205461,
0.2549464405,
-1.0646086931,
0.400763303,
-0.11382927,
-0.9420362711,
-0.3003288209,
-0.5441884995,
0.1203723326,
0.3600311875,
-0.4153026044,
-0.0127844,
0.2523527145,
0.0046877018,
-0.47747612,
-1.0084432364,
0.4847744703,
-0.3669280112,
-0.6013985872,
-0.1160961762,
-0.2474625856,
-0.3247695267,
-0.0850684494,
0.2331417799,
-0.2345905304,
0.710406661,
0.0855220184,
0.1128242835,
-0.2311676741,
-0.4161219597,
-0.2066905648,
0.0440430157,
0.4138685763,
-0.105888404,
0.283852756,
-0.3774600327,
-0.4381501079,
-0.3273562789,
0.3216115534,
1.094492197,
-0.1170636415,
0.7405472994,
0.9497597814,
-0.3640007973,
0.1934096068,
-0.2820180357,
-0.0316308402,
-0.4126615226,
0.5021762252,
-0.3321932256,
-0.3793919981,
0.6983026266,
0.3171570599,
0.2266013324,
0.7694285512,
0.4760945141,
-0.1471292824,
1.5501636267,
0.0815582424,
-0.2928110361,
0.0499849394,
-0.156503886,
-0.1926529258,
-0.7679428458,
0.1225868836,
-0.7206618786,
-0.3324084282,
-0.6497060061,
-0.080166623,
0.3328759074,
-0.0702585056,
-0.2462715209,
0.73345083,
-0.3347084522,
0.3223395348,
0.4770832956,
-0.0603513233,
0.0557397529,
-0.2479133159,
-0.3136847615,
-0.2759765685,
-0.4183366597,
-0.5679491758,
0.9959743023,
0.6051620841,
0.638851583,
0.3311858475,
0.3481915891,
0.4619701207,
0.4912544787,
-0.8718003631,
0.280670464,
-0.5008829832,
-0.9583975673,
-0.0815770477,
-0.8100566864,
-1.183801651,
0.1133380756,
-0.2873498201,
-0.6869728565,
-0.3571392298,
0.0554292984,
0.0445735715,
0.3896476328,
-0.665395081,
0.9447270632,
-0.4480071962,
0.1460082531,
-0.0329434387,
-0.8138902187,
0.1900380105,
-0.2276062071,
0.2109773308,
0.1929749697,
0.1732363403,
0.5415508151,
-0.4347991943,
0.562110424,
0.0639710948,
-0.0689959005,
0.0742291659,
0.7259430289,
0.4190490842,
0.0671876073,
-0.1613452733,
0.1847151667,
-0.0234471168,
-0.5886918902,
-0.6393101811,
0.5504745245,
-0.7652703524,
-0.3341571987,
-0.3236512542,
-0.5731837153,
-0.1711004823,
0.3198030889,
0.5656716824,
0.3181928098,
-0.5530943274,
0.3867334723,
0.4517703056,
-0.040833313,
0.3262280524,
0.4522731602,
0.1598013639,
-0.8967826962,
0.9635009766,
0.04673573,
0.6333371997,
0.2880688608,
0.1510317773,
-0.1211129203,
-0.8671385646,
-0.8558917046,
-0.27858904,
-0.5617753267,
-0.2423055619,
-0.3378585279,
-0.0487642363,
-0.3412572443,
-0.1810415387,
-0.7216473818,
-0.6159133911,
0.0007815395,
0.1337211728,
-0.0264850855,
0.7595523,
0.1706151962,
0.2795724571,
-0.9189979434,
0.0768937841,
-0.1228056699,
-0.0702102855,
-0.4061431289,
-0.7378364205,
-0.3906677663,
0.2662690878,
-0.6200768948,
-0.8117211461,
0.3764391243,
0.0724600628,
0.3342059851,
0.3623004556,
0.1249374151,
0.3728221655,
-0.5155332685,
1.2382278442,
0.1172844917,
-0.8802372813,
0.5884466767,
-0.4488140941,
0.347764641,
0.674210608,
0.397300899,
-0.1817333996,
-1.2333066463,
-0.8265638947,
-0.8549092412,
0.2618415058,
0.6945299506,
0.0822224244,
0.0452363901,
0.1371723115,
0.1984532177,
-0.041859284,
-0.6149727106,
-0.3418402672,
-0.3763653636,
-0.1598893404,
-0.3304180205,
-0.0537170805,
-0.3792076111,
0.1686687171,
0.5277370811,
0.0861965865,
-0.0875021219,
0.2211803049,
-0.3381648362,
-0.0562930852,
0.2484289855,
0.639846921,
0.4542788863,
-0.2940919697,
0.3021931946,
0.3894289732,
-0.724226594,
-0.0085345861,
0.0987653285,
-0.2690032721,
0.0438377224,
0.5085882545,
0.4915849864,
0.023348324,
-0.3353538513,
0.6096138358,
-0.535672009,
-0.2522752285,
-0.2027940899,
-0.0420527533,
-0.4911392033,
-0.0872792229,
0.1700042635,
0.5642926097,
0.1672609597,
-0.5929246545,
0.3065567613,
0.6213377714,
-0.7328535318,
-0.4408141971,
0.9020726085,
0.0016178397,
-0.3412285745,
0.350300163,
-0.4396029711,
-0.9517822266,
0.4834334552,
0.4066998661,
0.8892214894,
-0.2106378078,
0.036610201,
0.039084021,
1.0360848904,
0.0632574707,
0.0115226619,
0.1079333648,
-0.365146637,
-0.0069574034,
-0.3749808669,
-0.5697341561,
0.154640913,
-0.8348733187,
-0.1201849207,
-0.4610096812,
-0.5588720441,
-0.0624766611,
0.1392847002,
-0.3402376473,
0.4562973082,
-0.1430432051,
0.5399845243,
-0.7903404236,
0.391204685,
0.8887972832,
-0.4408788383,
-0.2764301896,
0.2197257578,
0.1900916398,
-0.7467396259,
0.4988055527,
-0.2022434324,
-0.1037746966,
-0.3727048337,
-0.2292188555,
-0.5900751948,
0.6988517642,
0.4858217537,
0.1023825407,
0.3687921762,
0.1775417328,
0.7525434494,
0.3432378471,
0.2240216136,
0.5089540482,
0.476254791,
-0.2633190751,
-1.2256025076,
0.0518587194,
-0.2903544009,
-0.2113000453,
0.3805760741,
-0.7548638582,
0.524341166,
0.053232871,
-0.1351931244,
0.4702645838,
0.3744669557,
-0.2994809747,
0.2820061743,
0.6804249883,
0.7593650818,
0.6628472805,
-0.2656984329,
1.2736288309,
-0.2324483395,
0.4037819505,
0.9072897434,
0.1853902638,
0.9456084967,
0.3286779821,
-0.1738540679,
0.2874628305,
0.6350491047,
-0.2207867503,
0.3535183668,
0.2176941335,
0.0777922645,
0.0695148334,
0.2658078671,
-0.2188010067,
0.4258802235,
0.4300626218,
-0.3501399457,
-0.1278716028,
-0.0095201833,
0.4706476629,
0.0685014352,
0.058337681,
0.5966711044,
0.0318911634,
-0.7587046623,
0.8926687241,
0.2397535592,
0.4241401553,
-0.6042551994,
0.4937568009,
-0.0611550026,
0.5488932729,
-0.1332841963,
-0.8231695294,
0.549697876,
0.1554973572,
-0.0595876984,
-0.2011599839,
0.4653574526,
-0.085609071,
-0.3913559914,
0.1857585311,
0.1947758943,
0.3770990372,
-0.0936449617,
-0.8852769732,
-0.0312441289,
-0.1193841323,
-0.4361326694,
0.366669029,
0.4863760471,
0.1904765517,
0.7868608236,
0.6189787388,
0.3050466776,
0.0013298667,
0.0202655513,
0.6356118321,
-0.3665820062,
-0.3012702763,
-0.9906744361,
0.3339322805,
-0.1175588742,
-0.4943532646,
1.2127672434,
0.5879747868,
0.7295700312,
0.184695825,
0.6648949981,
0.0785885975,
0.3261056542,
-0.5045177937,
1.2332406044,
-0.6169083714,
0.2494845241,
-0.4558418393,
-0.8338102698,
-0.6254034042,
0.3036428094,
0.1250869781,
-0.1705701202,
0.9442846775,
0.6147603989,
0.0109319929,
-0.2503078878,
0.3692852557,
0.2870692313,
0.362680614,
0.4809375703,
0.8869040012,
-0.7974045873,
1.1544926167,
-0.058348313,
-0.1529276967,
-0.1460580379,
-0.7130569816,
-1.10458529,
-0.3730626404,
-0.408151418,
-0.7131750584,
0.2270385027,
0.477297157,
0.501635313,
-0.8120706677,
0.1355220079,
0.0270455405,
0.123484388,
-0.2501538992,
-0.2556917667,
0.4099223912,
-0.4099782705,
-0.6674445271,
0.5561178327,
0.0482175238,
0.2508811355,
-0.5296069384,
0.0430558659,
0.3563883901,
0.0938443318,
0.3139058053,
-0.0216829088,
-0.4681234062,
-0.5740304589,
0.0490318015,
-0.3908252716,
-0.1539732665,
0.57784307,
-0.2717514634,
0.5926743746,
0.544308424,
0.7805483937,
-0.1959435493,
0.1413550675,
0.7142544985,
-0.9199772477,
-0.0661731586,
0.3315834701,
0.4452705979,
0.5003963709,
-0.2711874247,
0.3736018538,
0.2806143165,
-0.8270410299,
-1.1086791754,
0.2059331834,
-0.7686454058,
-0.2239456177,
0.9915053248,
-0.628852129,
-0.3123699725,
-0.1113140136,
-0.0734315589,
0.085201107,
-0.0600637123,
1.0874489546,
0.9774907231,
0.2265015095,
0.5258309841,
-0.6543384194,
0.2892079353,
0.6912369728,
-0.5507713556,
-0.1608840674,
0.2228671312,
0.2585785985,
0.3896532357,
-0.1672350615,
-0.4346705079,
0.4054045379,
0.3162648976,
-0.4079652429,
0.0502225049,
-0.1096662879,
-0.1183193922,
0.0599955246,
0.314130187,
-0.3510964215
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00502v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00502v2
|
Efficient LLM Inference on CPUs
| 2023-11-01T13:08:50 | 2023-12-07T12:16:42 |
Haihao Shen, Hanwen Chang, Bo Dong, Yu Luo, Hengyu Meng
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable performance and
tremendous potential across a wide range of tasks. However, deploying these
models has been challenging due to the astronomical amount of model parameters,
which requires a demand for large memory capacity and high memory bandwidth. In
this paper, we propose an effective approach that can make the deployment of
LLMs more efficiently. We support an automatic INT4 weight-only quantization
flow and design a special LLM runtime with highly-optimized kernels to
accelerate the LLM inference on CPUs. We demonstrate the general applicability
of our approach on popular LLMs including Llama2, Llama, GPT-NeoX, and showcase
the extreme inference efficiency on CPUs. The code is publicly available at:
https://github.com/intel/intel-extension-for-transformers.
|
[
-0.2925710082,
-0.5997638702,
0.8502460718,
0.4198052883,
-0.3641239405,
0.0392338857,
-0.4490016103,
-0.3258931637,
-0.060458228,
0.6897078753,
-0.2360019684,
-0.4519760907,
-0.5465595722,
-0.0142411673,
-0.4108676612,
0.6020025611,
-0.030297529,
-0.163031891,
-0.4165548384,
-0.0272290818,
0.0301567875,
-0.4564231932,
-0.4033373296,
-0.4128130078,
0.2121478915,
0.3653307557,
0.5453957319,
0.9110581875,
0.6264391541,
0.3251584768,
-0.172804758,
0.1849848479,
-0.2067949474,
0.1388411373,
0.2471660674,
-0.6850936413,
-0.5295041203,
-0.2957364023,
0.8150160313,
0.545543313,
-0.2838879824,
0.2659884691,
-0.2216528058,
0.5157716274,
-0.9670352936,
0.0602941103,
-0.4587858319,
0.2467301488,
-0.2700651884,
0.1019552723,
-0.6663627625,
-0.4205932915,
-0.1334732026,
-0.8556833863,
-0.3847501576,
0.0362438112,
0.4594516158,
0.5430078506,
-0.420594871,
0.1280548275,
-0.8237261772,
1.0399458408,
-0.7741043568,
0.6234003305,
0.1206595525,
0.3499786556,
-0.0970998555,
-0.9985741973,
-0.3938711882,
-0.039105583,
0.2326835245,
0.043775104,
-0.3277897239,
0.2475030571,
0.4798275828,
0.3851571977,
-0.3713237047,
0.1516583711,
0.0763162598,
-0.0582606494,
0.196174562,
0.1079418138,
-0.0992569551,
0.195618093,
-0.3958163559,
0.0846119821,
-0.6327618361,
-0.0543591604,
0.4286755919,
-0.1163175255,
-0.180425927,
0.4554397464,
-0.1802314669,
0.7056679726,
0.001558639,
-0.1457918435,
0.2238955796,
-0.0228675716,
-0.3244286776,
-0.123767525,
0.6424357891,
0.0666081905,
0.3123388886,
-0.0787738785,
-0.2681975961,
0.1666972637,
0.2299971581,
-1.0716896057,
-0.1490849704,
0.1781051457,
-0.239063248,
-0.0848083347,
-0.3453377485,
-0.5365636945,
-0.0860248283,
-0.1568367183,
0.2833642364,
-0.4952372015,
-0.130119428,
-0.0681593791,
-0.0839591622,
0.4753874838,
0.1528644115,
-0.8871366382,
0.3453449011,
0.9893431067,
0.7243480086,
-0.2873191535,
0.3170074821,
-0.8281340003,
0.2502799034,
-0.3513942063,
0.8483293056,
-0.6583384275,
-0.0657005087,
-0.196589455,
-0.2164955288,
0.1138389111,
-0.7463868856,
0.6518425941,
-0.7134979367,
-0.3791948259,
0.0167236887,
-0.7301986814,
-0.1293207556,
0.1328885108,
-0.5559679866,
1.0520410538,
0.1607811004,
-0.695002377,
-0.2349748462,
-0.3591206074,
-0.5359867215,
0.1147161201,
-0.2633225024,
-0.4559025466,
0.5251669884,
0.2389080971,
0.4487476945,
-0.4869388938,
0.218662858,
-0.4204643965,
-0.7405485511,
0.1912599653,
-0.384103924,
0.867892921,
0.3603093922,
-0.3715355694,
-0.0453703478,
-0.5868144631,
0.0457637124,
-0.1787680537,
-0.3931522965,
-0.2835286558,
0.1009735391,
-0.3797199428,
-0.238286376,
0.3764074147,
-0.4524825215,
0.1952534616,
-0.3028321564,
0.3963435888,
0.8959800005,
-0.5703611374,
0.5608047843,
0.1197925657,
0.7848148942,
-0.035125237,
0.3227071166,
-0.0624482334,
-0.4752723873,
-0.6926423907,
-0.7280654311,
0.3824596703,
0.7459458113,
-0.7484719753,
0.3429467678,
-0.2016513348,
-0.3127370179,
-0.4877214432,
0.2956325114,
0.4509961009,
0.5238673091,
0.0442764163,
0.157421425,
-0.5308250785,
-1.2759764194,
-0.1479053646,
-0.2642680407,
-0.189261198,
0.3611949384,
0.0927835703,
-0.2791697681,
0.6733196974,
-0.6288417578,
0.3877091706,
-0.2140412331,
-0.1431436986,
0.4263978302,
0.2644582093,
0.3410565555,
-0.6589936614,
-0.4399976134,
0.0388311632,
-0.7946742773,
-0.600060761,
0.3179873824,
-0.4037797153,
0.1129103228,
0.5748015642,
-0.4135284424,
-0.003630033,
0.9793182611,
-0.1033663824,
0.3915624619,
-0.1081270799,
-0.2316170782,
-0.8804765344,
-0.0171675272,
0.1038971841,
-0.6204999089,
-0.4677615762,
0.1247447059,
0.334672749,
0.1989479661,
-0.615316987,
0.4428435564,
-0.2399933487,
-0.2418674082,
-0.0730604455,
-0.2379851937,
0.0989589989,
0.3960787356,
-0.1442815512,
1.176032424,
0.6593607664,
-0.6005384326,
0.3751909733,
-0.0539337844,
-0.4073160589,
0.5481380224,
-0.4151681066,
-0.0622674674,
-0.0278447233,
0.4811353087,
-0.7566644549,
0.0236959867,
-0.0962150767,
0.0898428187,
0.181765765,
0.0111570824,
-0.4623980224,
-0.2689859569,
-0.4645698369,
0.4675991535,
0.7938040495,
-0.7378866673,
1.0267373323,
0.540170908,
0.0551014319,
-0.6118792295,
-0.8588799834,
0.0897708163,
-0.5121257901,
-0.5951341391,
0.4115749896,
-0.4460429847,
-0.4938976765,
-0.2544391155,
0.0225267354,
-0.1163665727,
0.2508202195,
0.2090737075,
0.0545293167,
-0.4929412603,
0.1467034668,
0.1898926347,
-0.3270727098,
0.0266218521,
-0.5049776435,
0.3043987453,
-0.3322351873,
-0.1030920297,
-0.6630440354,
0.311757952,
0.623251617,
-0.0276872963,
0.4064677954,
0.618264854,
-0.0466744415,
-0.3602779806,
-0.9076744914,
-0.1446805,
-0.519220829,
0.3111075461,
-0.365860641,
-0.8809433579,
0.4821935594,
-0.5150595903,
0.0825797766,
0.2365455627,
0.6737370491,
-0.1359005868,
1.095887661,
0.6181433797,
-0.0840996355,
0.5575341582,
-0.3992659748,
0.1792679727,
-1.1801948547,
0.1243768632,
-0.3323345482,
-0.3716225028,
-0.517228663,
-0.7037684917,
0.4570235312,
-0.0736641511,
-0.2826706171,
0.1695156544,
-0.3455126286,
0.4899347425,
0.554707706,
0.0470740423,
0.4697830379,
0.0927601159,
-0.2169425786,
0.1980870366,
-0.6540080309,
-0.4569301009,
0.8617225289,
0.2530747652,
0.7505995035,
0.0215817466,
0.4606077671,
0.0337714441,
0.4411492348,
-0.668102324,
0.6793680787,
-0.5728110075,
-0.2938965559,
-0.0474099591,
-0.5878663063,
-0.3535360396,
0.2156125903,
0.1641589403,
-0.4842255414,
-0.0899976194,
0.1937745214,
-0.4735884368,
0.4980792701,
-0.7693734765,
0.5079034567,
-0.1144125536,
-0.1773697883,
-0.3065594435,
-0.3389753997,
0.6642234325,
-0.378355056,
0.2285811305,
-0.4666025341,
-0.5362780094,
0.5321233273,
-0.6245466471,
0.670583725,
-0.108755298,
-0.2121163607,
0.5035688281,
-0.0852314755,
0.7118976712,
0.0104027279,
-0.6907934546,
0.3507473767,
-0.3239320219,
-0.2705275714,
-0.6097614765,
0.8486222029,
-0.7141309977,
-0.514747262,
0.0496495143,
-0.6885303855,
-0.0957245603,
-0.1579468697,
0.1353320628,
0.2385323644,
0.2539808452,
0.2084103525,
0.7990018725,
-0.2725389004,
0.7382234335,
0.4100829065,
-0.0337510332,
-0.3603223264,
0.6848419309,
0.0297233909,
0.3762385547,
0.4421957135,
0.4877882004,
-0.2409961671,
-0.7109052539,
-0.5321766734,
0.1490187496,
-0.5120051503,
-0.4744173288,
-0.7653108239,
-0.0514173619,
-0.1297035366,
-0.1967659444,
-0.6083811522,
-0.7302071452,
-0.197091952,
0.0167637654,
0.7655870318,
0.3993471563,
-0.010952252,
0.8962756991,
-0.4148536623,
0.312704891,
0.5662043095,
0.4389402866,
0.0377224423,
-0.6780216098,
-0.3687099814,
-0.3429165483,
-0.3843030334,
-0.2900489271,
0.1330065131,
0.3312123716,
0.3668839633,
0.4725774229,
0.0900677741,
0.7332143188,
-0.4881289005,
0.6067262292,
-0.0909065977,
-1.0600731373,
0.2073588967,
-0.1495092064,
0.5374797583,
0.4419917464,
0.2472958118,
-0.0378977023,
-0.5872548223,
-0.4273347855,
-0.9005687833,
0.4003463387,
0.1697918922,
0.2252055705,
-0.034026444,
0.5306927562,
-0.0691107288,
0.0906178132,
-0.4626209736,
-0.1652596444,
0.3326189816,
-0.3885987401,
0.2985828221,
-0.4292380214,
0.1920675486,
-0.3326271474,
0.7966451049,
-0.3241223991,
0.2036346495,
-0.1793741584,
-0.0613906756,
-0.030216815,
-0.0657845512,
0.407987833,
0.6209236383,
-0.0574123263,
0.5609664917,
0.5252453089,
-0.4027160704,
0.196988672,
-0.1477635205,
-0.0251929779,
-0.1874929518,
0.2746394873,
0.6937916875,
0.4254390001,
-0.8657292128,
0.5843262672,
-0.3638423681,
-0.099131912,
-0.4303843975,
0.2777450085,
0.4908470213,
0.7219275832,
0.2633972168,
-0.5615646839,
-0.001957309,
-0.1405553967,
0.2449305207,
0.5374084115,
-0.0723492801,
-0.2446634918,
0.6236327887,
0.1615418941,
-0.2079340965,
0.810587585,
-0.1694040596,
-0.3424779773,
0.6521703005,
0.6237918735,
0.9322975874,
-0.4054253995,
-0.231251508,
0.0420652963,
0.0108319409,
-0.1155470982,
0.4023810029,
-0.1456694156,
-0.5593647957,
-1.1081032753,
-0.9397172928,
-0.4952320457,
-0.1362488419,
-0.243320182,
0.2959458828,
-0.6264003515,
-0.3524273634,
0.0516557731,
-0.2360215336,
-0.4867291152,
-0.185060069,
0.513247788,
0.9186246991,
-0.6415079832,
0.9902507663,
0.428557694,
0.3672025502,
-0.6759054661,
-0.4029258788,
-0.1761550903,
-1.0037276745,
0.7751895785,
0.0602529272,
-0.1027389467,
0.2387510985,
-0.3888776898,
-0.8361077309,
0.9676483274,
0.9427673817,
-0.7423228621,
0.1241529807,
0.0019130297,
0.1230083555,
-0.3165790737,
0.6409013271,
0.7126784921,
0.7515727878,
0.1885881871,
-0.6902864575,
-0.0304448288,
0.0500504076,
0.1877442598,
0.4460765421,
-0.7154991627,
0.7381309867,
-0.0619387478,
0.1958819181,
-0.1384869218,
0.8888474107,
0.4365991652,
-0.0467905141,
0.7655390501,
0.919157207,
0.8014714122,
0.1194561049,
1.1299897432,
-0.5585496426,
0.0481206439,
0.7296301126,
-0.2668045759,
0.9315750599,
0.576087296,
-0.2271723598,
0.4834439754,
0.3808395565,
0.1999306679,
0.2226791829,
0.4260948896,
-0.7384535074,
-0.5981951356,
-0.3028255403,
-0.0046877032,
0.6105985045,
0.3525852859,
-0.307379514,
-0.1391581744,
-0.1199144945,
0.1517384052,
-0.4208195508,
-0.2765155435,
0.6434334517,
0.3844324648,
-0.4967566729,
0.621434927,
-0.0561461858,
0.7842723727,
-0.4627194107,
0.0167545658,
-0.1609688401,
0.3483527303,
-0.2172965556,
-0.3999446034,
0.4145089984,
0.150522247,
-0.2223887146,
-0.3507556617,
0.358024776,
-0.0385087729,
-0.8972218633,
0.343693763,
0.27913782,
0.3533187509,
-0.2214101553,
-0.3090358078,
0.4574105442,
-0.0658145398,
-0.5392918587,
0.3207645416,
0.562266469,
-0.2070813924,
0.663833499,
0.5563741922,
0.1617468596,
0.1946077198,
-0.0501189679,
0.8905408382,
-0.5362921357,
-0.4584418535,
-1.1718933582,
0.2991956174,
0.1592835188,
0.0965430066,
0.5468232036,
0.7715824246,
0.3143924177,
0.2253458202,
0.6002467871,
0.3432480097,
0.0999680012,
-0.4566471875,
0.3168572485,
-0.3605422974,
0.3754343092,
0.0330846198,
-1.1281865835,
-0.4269039631,
0.5969278216,
-0.086636208,
-0.1886364669,
0.54588902,
0.6594578028,
-0.3152021468,
0.0037084804,
0.3292191923,
0.3480885029,
0.450405091,
0.8016150594,
0.6930902004,
-0.1091748327,
0.5320432782,
-0.3984161019,
-0.4918310642,
-0.2862844765,
-1.4536759853,
-0.5320327282,
-0.0992488414,
-0.5137555599,
0.0827488974,
0.0646600425,
0.7227907777,
0.9880046248,
-0.4221995771,
-0.4633339643,
-0.0417531803,
0.2334017009,
-0.0803986117,
-0.1508064419,
0.2522280216,
-0.3213038146,
-0.8036370277,
0.5296416879,
0.4289379418,
-0.1851457953,
-0.3344504833,
-0.0291741788,
0.0522729903,
0.2350016832,
0.8411684632,
0.0233162809,
-0.5566626787,
-0.1476328522,
-0.109607704,
0.0425052904,
0.1964297593,
0.9227451086,
-1.0492942333,
0.0356460735,
0.6391488314,
1.0105284452,
0.6873044372,
-0.0431732275,
0.7303947806,
-0.6106332541,
0.2223916352,
0.2885238826,
0.2850033343,
0.2541198432,
-0.4149455428,
0.4310964048,
0.1193541735,
-0.487064898,
-0.794306457,
0.1664469242,
-0.8414363265,
-0.1954927742,
1.1343386173,
-0.0160924476,
-0.6023952961,
0.1905396134,
0.3238532245,
0.2933939993,
-0.3994448185,
0.4153723717,
0.4521975815,
-0.3921864331,
-0.1508213729,
-0.9168729186,
0.0614857413,
0.5153073668,
-0.7401918769,
0.3500056565,
0.0819107592,
0.1043552458,
-0.1419056505,
0.5205227137,
-0.000789094,
-0.179933697,
-0.4380914867,
0.2126254886,
-0.0748659521,
-0.2095432431,
-0.4637491107,
0.0966312066,
0.0034549627,
-0.0229072701
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00488v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00488v1
|
Comparing Optimization Targets for Contrast-Consistent Search
| 2023-11-01T12:42:14 | 2023-11-01T12:42:14 |
Hugo Fry, Seamus Fallows, Ian Fan, Jamie Wright, Nandi Schoots
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
We investigate the optimization target of Contrast-Consistent Search (CCS),
which aims to recover the internal representations of truth of a large language
model. We present a new loss function that we call the Midpoint-Displacement
(MD) loss function. We demonstrate that for a certain hyper-parameter value
this MD loss function leads to a prober with very similar weights to CCS. We
further show that this hyper-parameter is not optimal and that with a better
hyper-parameter the MD loss function attains a higher test accuracy than CCS.
|
[
-0.5246462822,
-0.3409138322,
0.9024814367,
0.0354592577,
-0.2848753631,
-0.0581125356,
-0.2623880804,
0.1408863515,
0.1624482572,
0.1429374516,
-0.5100852251,
-0.1565631628,
-0.6715111732,
0.2435107678,
-0.6035571694,
0.5889300108,
0.0087308036,
0.3900332451,
-0.1001311913,
-0.2423304915,
-0.2265284508,
-0.3706127405,
-0.8919535279,
-0.0675530359,
0.8244993687,
0.3451377153,
0.764103353,
1.0019763708,
0.7611855268,
0.3071403205,
-0.3042856753,
0.0604732893,
-0.7277435064,
0.1005286053,
-0.4052270651,
-0.6330900788,
0.5910009742,
0.1704338044,
0.774130404,
0.8535441756,
-0.3257881105,
-0.2189245373,
0.2530780733,
0.7345267534,
-1.3026942015,
-0.2656449974,
-0.4804189801,
0.0987385586,
-0.3699056208,
-0.4359591901,
-0.4203552306,
-0.3977673054,
0.3068750799,
-0.583891809,
0.422796756,
0.2358490229,
1.224265337,
0.2319660187,
-0.3754839301,
-0.4010972083,
-0.556415081,
1.1805456877,
-0.444483608,
0.7027596831,
0.0733878836,
0.4306404591,
-0.0378217548,
-0.590223074,
-0.7720696926,
-0.3214741945,
-0.0036737076,
0.2619491816,
-0.2627542615,
0.2092538774,
0.1176293045,
0.5875028968,
-0.5526397824,
0.0734139308,
-0.1099339351,
-0.2565409839,
0.2386092693,
0.4657946527,
0.006468487,
0.2321887314,
-0.2860624492,
-0.4178437293,
-0.7401505709,
-0.0233585685,
0.2193297446,
0.2835751176,
-0.1611448228,
0.5191943645,
-0.1479757279,
0.8182071447,
0.5262010694,
-0.142937541,
-0.1252616644,
-0.4470751286,
-0.2839366198,
0.0350082405,
0.211896196,
0.7496544719,
0.0306036174,
-0.0066477335,
-0.2221554816,
0.3215900064,
0.0188876633,
-0.827008605,
-0.1323836446,
-0.1978760064,
-0.5845206976,
-0.283123225,
0.2349861413,
-0.6252070665,
-0.2836088836,
-0.4309777617,
0.2527242303,
-0.1058864519,
0.2384477705,
0.1457641572,
-0.1973094493,
0.4756210446,
0.1719433218,
-0.7282438278,
0.7073993683,
0.2181186676,
0.9450349212,
-0.4020309746,
0.0113639003,
-0.8224186301,
-0.101503022,
-0.8599127531,
0.7508461475,
-0.7468729615,
-0.5182431936,
0.0040185293,
-0.0564694367,
0.0035472556,
-0.9526586533,
0.6103557348,
-0.3064549267,
0.1419676542,
-1.0002139807,
-0.5213899016,
0.0487358309,
0.5154197812,
-0.5375856757,
1.1188906431,
0.3426362574,
-0.6868014336,
0.2229622155,
-0.3966126144,
0.0497690067,
-0.1440003514,
-0.294850558,
-0.5251490474,
0.2805348039,
-0.1866796911,
0.1591920406,
-0.7340559363,
-0.2750253677,
-0.4553239346,
-0.885867238,
0.1431684941,
-0.3254149556,
0.6146793962,
0.2752321959,
-0.615814209,
-0.2797202766,
-0.5319601893,
0.0374217853,
0.3133184314,
-0.5496196747,
-0.4199332893,
0.4465969801,
-0.2729583681,
0.1167962775,
0.2094097733,
-0.8266333342,
-0.0657742471,
-0.1424099356,
-0.041180741,
0.7641687393,
0.0402340069,
0.2290537208,
-0.4347697198,
0.3072201312,
0.3368862569,
0.127111271,
0.0149684623,
-0.0082443086,
-0.8774346113,
-0.3629101813,
0.3820716143,
0.3727266788,
-0.5765398741,
0.4077344239,
0.0571305417,
-0.4941717088,
-0.6904855371,
-0.3380598724,
0.6923744082,
0.7740246654,
0.5863231421,
-0.5074222088,
-0.5314349532,
-1.0001032352,
-0.3779522479,
0.1864754856,
0.0325541683,
0.2679501176,
0.0501236096,
-0.294344753,
0.468767643,
-0.8812204003,
-0.2757618427,
-0.1067743078,
-0.1363181025,
0.1054180935,
0.4112284184,
0.7510310411,
-1.0487194061,
-0.8159323335,
-0.1808302104,
-0.2382054627,
-0.3197812438,
0.0451680198,
0.1758502424,
-0.0790406242,
0.84411937,
-0.286203444,
0.5729210973,
0.9268450141,
-0.0814787149,
0.938283205,
-0.1823064983,
0.3721010089,
-0.8622633219,
0.3103974462,
0.2849271595,
0.2034157366,
-0.6199866533,
0.2509435415,
0.0342853516,
0.1239999235,
-0.394875288,
0.5321300626,
-0.5187924504,
-0.1882804632,
-0.2995860875,
0.393255651,
0.0012376712,
0.3382647932,
-0.1532966197,
0.9713844657,
0.6098220944,
-0.7572622895,
0.2717224956,
0.0475085713,
-0.1425950229,
0.8541542888,
-0.6890847683,
0.1964239478,
-0.1451500505,
-0.0532983579,
-1.2626650333,
0.2391529083,
-0.0466570742,
-0.3285304606,
0.2466792315,
-0.0834533721,
-0.4405948222,
-0.2538565695,
-0.5884251595,
0.6548836827,
0.339779973,
-0.6489006877,
0.0558999591,
-0.0407159664,
-0.2169211507,
-0.793705523,
-0.560176909,
-0.103004396,
-0.135775283,
-0.1026855633,
0.6013327241,
-0.4411116838,
-0.2447715849,
-0.0087322639,
-0.2314189374,
0.0525469966,
-0.249234423,
-0.1995124966,
0.0988100544,
-0.2492374778,
-0.227546677,
-0.0000292959,
-0.2262296379,
-0.0228874274,
-0.1119358763,
0.8386291265,
-0.068410486,
-0.5108546615,
-0.3525643349,
0.5726305842,
0.4761847556,
-0.4086789489,
0.5539785624,
0.158488065,
-0.3605881333,
0.1884879917,
-0.7118548751,
-0.0402878858,
-0.6072020531,
0.3597058952,
-0.5899658203,
-0.6230384111,
0.6577615142,
-0.200114876,
-0.3077994585,
0.7630625963,
0.442812562,
-0.2288592309,
1.5855871439,
0.7707598805,
0.0892173275,
0.5759418607,
-0.3502447009,
0.1615479887,
-1.1134527922,
-0.3813871145,
-1.3121347427,
-0.410615325,
-0.6529065371,
-0.0379626565,
0.3989171088,
0.038384553,
-0.4581949413,
0.2032360733,
-0.7165731192,
0.606421411,
0.7730705738,
0.0141963447,
-0.0229475833,
-0.2113111913,
-0.7346904278,
-0.6642113328,
-0.6791911721,
-0.1184372529,
0.7685679197,
-0.2333790511,
0.8324112296,
0.0729157329,
0.632076323,
0.0352336243,
0.0864995047,
-0.6950522661,
0.4947461188,
-0.4714313745,
-0.3240570724,
-0.3282928467,
-0.502861917,
-1.3381057978,
0.196669206,
-0.2087473869,
-0.4368716478,
0.6039460301,
0.0586867929,
-0.0021773379,
0.3323797286,
-0.1475511342,
0.5759088397,
-0.0782756209,
-0.1283999532,
-0.249328047,
-0.817489326,
-0.1393732131,
0.0183508452,
-0.057987459,
0.2036404759,
-0.0567468107,
0.6205349565,
-0.3570462167,
0.204073742,
-0.2148742974,
0.4255689085,
0.1332505345,
0.6477585435,
0.4712569416,
-0.5135063529,
-0.0927345008,
-0.1932912469,
-0.1017386392,
-0.6230057478,
-0.6590605378,
0.6622402668,
-0.4507496357,
-0.4863538444,
-0.4893395901,
-0.3537807763,
0.1745527089,
0.5043406487,
0.644595921,
0.5442793369,
-0.1284490675,
0.4173582792,
0.937633276,
-0.2465295047,
0.5379923582,
0.6160444617,
0.4347816408,
-0.2106315345,
0.7537361383,
0.0018782753,
0.5030469298,
0.5935875773,
0.4063564241,
-0.3753189743,
-0.9690106511,
-0.0906183049,
0.3080654442,
-0.6497378945,
-0.30511114,
0.1125659645,
-0.2855411172,
-0.0499674678,
-0.8032801747,
-0.6188630462,
0.1178524569,
-0.2333098501,
0.2049309164,
-0.6947642565,
0.4159253836,
-0.2728239596,
0.3254387081,
-0.5993227363,
0.1721888185,
0.0915323198,
0.2620617151,
-0.4896815717,
-0.7120350003,
-0.4724538624,
0.1724244207,
-0.6062663198,
-1.0109585524,
0.3028355539,
0.0914667472,
0.8275102973,
0.8492016792,
0.0672678202,
0.8473683596,
-0.3206065595,
0.754170835,
0.5964177847,
-1.0937730074,
0.3444445133,
-0.0637231246,
0.4428203404,
0.6966822743,
0.574583292,
-0.8133741617,
-0.292065084,
-0.7347348928,
-0.3389016688,
0.2770697773,
0.2191818804,
-0.0628757924,
-0.2199839056,
0.5935073495,
-0.3691404462,
-0.0833198503,
-0.4510403574,
-0.3538685441,
0.1447746903,
-0.4390663505,
-0.1573990434,
-0.1878020912,
-0.2604302168,
-0.0267453268,
0.3735532463,
-0.397885859,
0.3399580717,
0.6052244902,
0.0778714195,
-0.5165318847,
-0.0977102816,
0.6850351095,
0.3595946431,
-0.1763638258,
0.3276833594,
0.278646946,
-0.6203526258,
0.2280722409,
0.135283947,
-0.0931529477,
0.0880488977,
0.2492962331,
0.0743017495,
0.2571320832,
-0.6532817483,
0.9631788731,
0.0126231341,
-0.2658939958,
0.1018109247,
-0.0239114426,
-0.1099751815,
0.0884977952,
0.4318441451,
0.1437859237,
0.516733706,
-0.7565435171,
0.2349301875,
0.4554077685,
-0.7351431251,
0.0199847836,
0.7339081764,
-0.0368611403,
-0.318413198,
0.8211134076,
-0.2184736878,
-0.6464642882,
0.6897847652,
0.5788630843,
0.8018975854,
-0.8199842572,
-0.1401920915,
0.3735173047,
0.132784158,
-0.1991409808,
0.3970225453,
0.1876793206,
-0.6806171536,
-0.2735262215,
-0.1073354781,
-0.7013489008,
-0.2694770694,
-1.1378575563,
0.4130179584,
-0.51165694,
0.1701143682,
0.1590874046,
0.334795475,
-0.4818780422,
0.8317286372,
-0.0964997336,
0.9170142412,
-0.4164242148,
0.5596835017,
0.229852125,
-0.1739046425,
-0.5754111409,
0.0545450151,
0.1358165145,
-0.6967760921,
0.4820535481,
-0.0893412977,
-0.4566219747,
-0.1086845621,
-0.8806647658,
-1.1693685055,
1.2318691015,
0.7471950054,
-0.7829696536,
0.0151910791,
0.0373336002,
0.4685934484,
-0.4417143166,
0.1473031789,
0.4822121561,
0.4264779985,
0.1765571833,
-0.9256281853,
0.1624533385,
0.1237178817,
0.1045973301,
0.4433550239,
-0.9004625082,
1.0427303314,
-0.3493681848,
-0.2736953497,
0.1989838183,
0.3084544241,
0.4687256515,
0.2393173277,
0.6572287083,
0.6605534554,
0.4549842775,
-0.4109033048,
1.179502368,
-0.1593731642,
0.6239055395,
0.8312356472,
-0.1046008468,
0.7306976318,
0.4547099471,
-0.2011535913,
0.4611376226,
0.8723425865,
-0.1031956747,
0.9925741553,
0.6807514429,
-0.0310857985,
0.041552227,
0.0036804164,
-0.2103018016,
0.2719610035,
0.4336149395,
-0.3534318805,
-0.2388031036,
-0.5625093579,
0.0594117679,
0.2695309222,
-0.1175405681,
0.5772587657,
-0.0838086605,
-0.548840344,
0.84775877,
0.2972257137,
0.3083123565,
-0.6423615217,
-0.0329210944,
-0.5363170505,
0.3303551376,
0.0482778773,
-0.5876421928,
0.3019250631,
-0.658134222,
-0.060910847,
0.3755066395,
0.3771293461,
-0.5470948815,
0.0608229786,
0.5148202777,
0.0379986577,
0.0218601767,
-0.1893051565,
-0.9674022794,
0.3529774547,
0.0377220809,
-0.1876218766,
0.1279812753,
0.1597737968,
0.3016213775,
0.83697927,
0.6333962083,
0.1603474617,
0.091446586,
-0.2490544468,
0.8611015081,
-0.7434548736,
-0.5879238248,
-0.6076955199,
0.1749068648,
-0.1673339903,
-0.6126792431,
0.598185122,
0.9954605699,
0.943185091,
0.2330711633,
0.3657450378,
0.2608548999,
0.6441342235,
-0.480016917,
0.0810159743,
-0.8264434934,
0.11147663,
-0.5496339202,
-1.4382464886,
-0.3892594278,
0.4398027658,
0.2263252586,
0.1049596071,
1.205265522,
1.1190270185,
-0.2424676418,
-0.4760095775,
0.6176384687,
0.3582005799,
0.2104590237,
0.5690943003,
0.651730597,
-0.4045324624,
0.7626963854,
-0.0097742155,
-0.3386717439,
-0.4018119872,
-0.5708986521,
-0.4280633926,
-0.7799378633,
-0.269274503,
-0.339120239,
0.3645572066,
0.403318435,
0.9627931118,
-0.6132035851,
-0.2493529469,
-0.0432037748,
-0.1701126397,
-0.4871690571,
-0.1955501735,
0.6037905216,
-0.2777251005,
-0.9544450045,
0.391105324,
0.5810849667,
0.2983942926,
-0.2909250259,
-0.3838327825,
-0.1922195703,
0.5025648475,
0.2639076412,
0.3616530895,
-0.6022951007,
-0.4313770533,
0.2156581283,
-0.4221916199,
0.098684594,
0.9732297659,
-0.3506120145,
0.6341707706,
0.2290431708,
0.829241097,
0.8165566921,
-0.1809455007,
0.5008532405,
-0.5421648622,
0.0414276086,
0.3476865888,
0.5805636048,
0.3482587337,
-0.2803092599,
0.5852781534,
0.4738045037,
-0.5159988403,
-0.8115829229,
0.3771747649,
-1.3153539896,
-0.3752462864,
1.0096515417,
-0.1256024092,
0.1289757639,
-0.021111615,
-0.4109156132,
0.2272383273,
-0.0009859328,
0.861240685,
0.6738760471,
-0.1016124412,
-0.2448804677,
0.1061838493,
0.5630578995,
0.917758286,
-0.4434111118,
-0.3272633851,
0.238232553,
0.37427935,
0.3577538133,
0.4515437782,
-0.4636792243,
0.4132819772,
0.2916106582,
-0.1042083874,
0.4219246805,
-0.3704007566,
-0.2727217972,
0.0271990951,
-0.0931107178,
-0.4112102985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00475v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00475v1
|
Style Locality for Controllable Generation with kNN Language Models
| 2023-11-01T12:21:53 | 2023-11-01T12:21:53 |
Gilles Nawezi, Lucie Flek, Charles Welch
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent language models have been improved by the addition of external memory.
Nearest neighbor language models retrieve similar contexts to assist in word
prediction. The addition of locality levels allows a model to learn how to
weight neighbors based on their relative location to the current text in source
documents, and have been shown to further improve model performance. Nearest
neighbor models have been explored for controllable generation but have not
examined the use of locality levels. We present a novel approach for this
purpose and evaluate it using automatic and human evaluation on politeness,
formality, supportiveness, and toxicity textual data. We find that our model is
successfully able to control style and provides a better fluency-style
trade-off than previous work.
|
[
-0.3971483111,
-0.6963392496,
0.451461643,
0.0966691002,
0.1580941081,
-0.2971853614,
-0.463912338,
-0.6349573731,
0.0803249031,
0.4907969832,
-0.2951796651,
-0.3639592528,
-0.3954699934,
0.1551522762,
-0.1041826457,
0.701174438,
-0.0900842845,
0.020747371,
-0.274753958,
-0.1482458264,
-0.4247292876,
-0.7316125035,
-0.9006723166,
-0.4934233129,
0.5331321359,
0.509401083,
0.8346245885,
0.6628245115,
0.4626245797,
0.4309513271,
-0.2672600746,
-0.1391248256,
-0.2894358039,
0.1303483248,
-0.2110141367,
-0.4994986057,
-0.5043435693,
-0.0922397599,
0.6910876632,
0.5668646097,
-0.1290671378,
-0.1391249597,
-0.1156490147,
0.8297512531,
-0.4533862472,
0.0823498294,
-0.6806637645,
0.2911429405,
-0.2662194967,
-0.1610256582,
-0.3857018054,
-0.6783108115,
0.1277868003,
-0.2477857322,
0.2543856204,
-0.037550278,
0.9446077347,
-0.021122463,
-0.2335850149,
-0.4474907815,
-0.73069489,
0.8196528554,
-0.7638766766,
0.627266705,
0.8366398215,
0.3297861814,
-0.1590625346,
-0.7323742509,
-0.4808746874,
-0.6060560942,
-0.1988326311,
0.2025598586,
-0.0856873617,
-0.0881947055,
0.1824463755,
0.3376269042,
-0.3609608114,
-0.005724845,
-0.2185088694,
-0.2261112481,
0.5198529363,
0.1128387675,
0.160028249,
-0.4749425352,
-0.1645944118,
-0.0179453287,
-0.4707266986,
0.0682121143,
0.5238253474,
0.4479884505,
-0.0150535339,
0.250905931,
-0.5740368962,
0.6563735604,
0.205564037,
-0.206628114,
0.0807758793,
-0.5821821094,
0.1212180927,
-0.0568625852,
0.6568045616,
0.4791538119,
0.3298879862,
-0.2955031395,
-0.2609764636,
-0.1358342767,
0.4243766963,
-0.6984317303,
-0.5966814756,
-0.081159927,
-0.6145911813,
-0.7741391063,
-0.1000978425,
-0.8114093542,
-0.1460290849,
-0.5007156134,
0.258255899,
-0.428583771,
-0.4526078105,
-0.5699725151,
-0.040770255,
0.0105560301,
-0.1165231541,
-0.9633828402,
0.4297708273,
0.2443022132,
1.0091980696,
-0.3443051875,
-0.0589462258,
-0.3518526554,
0.2138362527,
-0.6389895082,
0.6191887259,
-0.8406973481,
-0.5313596725,
0.0262787435,
-0.1052787751,
0.2589444518,
-0.7649899721,
0.2319789827,
-0.5175434351,
0.358800739,
-0.4326645434,
-0.3246793151,
0.1686900258,
0.0208622683,
-0.6622533202,
1.2541109324,
0.5624747276,
-0.9991415739,
0.6089078188,
-0.5989944339,
-0.5645090938,
-0.0748799071,
0.1553033441,
-0.4847653806,
0.1395334899,
-0.0311043318,
0.4542664886,
0.4173745811,
0.3331912458,
-0.2806091905,
-0.1219964847,
0.172827974,
-0.1175516844,
0.4427735806,
0.3857595026,
-0.2522164285,
0.4668190777,
-0.8712277412,
0.0777917057,
0.1055482998,
-0.4064746201,
-0.8123278618,
-0.0645660758,
0.0485049523,
0.467667222,
0.4347366989,
-0.3120395839,
0.1216264591,
-0.4054500759,
0.3511576056,
0.8732569814,
0.0809426531,
0.9248811603,
-0.6566849351,
0.5309967399,
-0.0684665143,
0.1117308661,
0.2658687532,
-0.4360307455,
-0.6369233131,
0.1320191473,
0.1906316131,
0.3396841288,
-0.7811673284,
0.3984329998,
-0.1326538324,
-0.4108227491,
-0.2010979354,
0.2028772682,
0.471514374,
0.7829405069,
0.2282125801,
-0.2909464538,
-0.3712471128,
-0.807446003,
0.0431043692,
0.0757223144,
-0.115944922,
0.5690616965,
0.1849371046,
-0.0664230883,
1.0381768942,
-0.3264518976,
0.0164042842,
-0.3260006309,
0.09185265,
-0.2005698681,
0.5363872647,
0.5395985246,
-0.8849183321,
-0.5509675145,
0.1045205742,
-0.3827135265,
-0.4482116103,
0.0778986216,
-0.4769230783,
0.4634901285,
0.722543478,
0.0181544982,
0.2878771126,
0.5800275803,
-0.2923091948,
0.7108851075,
-0.246409446,
-0.007189326,
-1.4713060856,
0.2175773531,
0.0438636467,
-0.4198075235,
-0.6618919373,
0.2603774071,
0.086249955,
0.0659346804,
-0.1824994385,
0.8419760466,
-0.2381666154,
-0.221267134,
-0.3119347394,
0.2704556584,
0.0369814634,
0.4848291576,
0.4519122243,
0.7566179037,
0.1808982044,
-0.7856834531,
0.2027791291,
-0.1468111724,
-0.3141538203,
0.7658104897,
-0.4213030934,
0.1427859068,
-0.1019999385,
0.1108478904,
-0.8284466863,
-0.4407984316,
-0.1768498719,
-0.2422461808,
0.5243685842,
0.0035707981,
-0.5942768455,
-0.3919250667,
-0.1083677709,
-0.0230455119,
0.5418360829,
-0.4894916713,
0.2928936183,
0.3132125437,
-0.3550165594,
0.0067110597,
-0.738340199,
-0.2393055409,
-0.500810504,
-0.44265154,
0.2000491619,
-0.3320837617,
-0.5252464414,
-0.1027438715,
0.0229073558,
-0.2683500648,
0.0367279388,
0.2409033626,
0.0178039316,
-0.0303468332,
0.1090818569,
0.1403384805,
-0.0707097054,
-0.0908652171,
-0.1009390056,
0.6334508061,
-0.0570849106,
0.3459202349,
-0.3098198771,
0.3164355159,
0.1817208976,
-0.2607885897,
0.7493296266,
0.6679221392,
-0.364262104,
-0.3434590697,
-0.4707365632,
-0.2538083792,
-0.582937479,
0.3841249943,
-0.4669183493,
-0.7104685903,
0.7754395604,
0.0235176887,
-0.1953550428,
0.2260844707,
0.5016897917,
0.1471479088,
0.996091485,
0.8134703636,
-0.1800558418,
0.9281555414,
0.0570924692,
-0.0366501585,
-0.7415522337,
-0.1234916896,
-0.5227953792,
-0.2961893678,
-0.7108328342,
-0.2134166658,
0.2087076157,
0.3991834223,
-0.2949697375,
0.4077741802,
-0.4744875133,
0.4942418039,
0.674685061,
0.1207452416,
0.3437685966,
0.1104724854,
-0.5496070981,
-0.3238223195,
-0.8736062646,
-0.3699676394,
0.7541615963,
0.3664731979,
0.3828848004,
0.1802960783,
0.8318902254,
0.0097880885,
0.6316136718,
-0.7181200385,
0.5019740462,
-0.275685221,
-0.3932024539,
-0.3376434147,
-0.8607257009,
-0.8451452255,
-0.1370267421,
-0.0338920653,
-0.9386437535,
-0.1086210981,
0.1621918082,
-0.0723271519,
0.4215821028,
-0.7112801075,
0.7158790827,
0.311511457,
-0.4168705046,
0.0929488838,
-0.4802167714,
0.3614133596,
-0.1996900439,
0.2867785096,
0.2254182398,
0.1144157276,
0.6658545136,
-0.5426960588,
0.5514423847,
-0.0012419743,
-0.3711188436,
0.274192512,
0.5580472946,
0.5941832662,
-0.2250494808,
-0.4661210477,
0.1004369184,
-0.0821077302,
-0.2342265695,
-0.533031702,
1.1205844879,
-0.4470380247,
0.0061847917,
-0.0132388351,
-0.8307442069,
-0.3685193062,
0.4690363407,
0.5483201742,
0.6886286736,
0.158061713,
-0.0737385154,
0.5622540116,
-0.2740900517,
0.5625148416,
0.4979514182,
-0.4131542146,
-0.3922615945,
1.0917725563,
0.3794992268,
0.6083375812,
0.3431520462,
0.8842039108,
-0.4102012217,
-0.2589604259,
-0.243684724,
-0.0872251317,
-0.6961047649,
-0.0854217485,
-0.4087562859,
-0.1786892116,
-0.522115469,
-0.5991642475,
-0.2329095006,
-0.3459055126,
0.076598756,
-0.0305338204,
0.5402035713,
1.1922580004,
-0.1979842484,
0.3622703552,
-0.5676862597,
0.2214693129,
0.297875911,
0.8237101436,
0.1486158222,
-0.4875669777,
-0.0879147202,
-0.3087722063,
-0.1016756594,
-0.943626523,
0.3769071996,
-0.0140054841,
0.2660635412,
0.4611049592,
0.1082181782,
0.5524336696,
-0.5873615742,
0.6670368314,
-0.0983418077,
-0.7987926006,
0.8117591739,
-0.6089440584,
0.7801104784,
0.6201488972,
0.425150454,
-0.4726306796,
-0.7654066682,
-0.8701535463,
-0.6759332418,
0.5065560341,
0.2108091712,
0.1026537344,
-0.2180741429,
0.5590988398,
-0.058818806,
0.1102401018,
-0.8280033469,
-0.1975380033,
-0.0950851068,
-0.1795475483,
0.0890139714,
-0.227224797,
0.14806512,
-0.1561760008,
0.5156614184,
0.1122424155,
0.2112482935,
0.1462095231,
0.3647193611,
-0.4200354218,
0.1778315306,
0.5225247145,
0.5928275585,
-0.2140834779,
0.0720006004,
0.2894171178,
-0.4716043174,
-0.2406013161,
-0.1890027672,
-0.5628077388,
0.1383676231,
0.2126482427,
0.3383896649,
0.3538500369,
-0.1582048386,
0.3677024245,
0.0054431609,
-0.0075559295,
-0.1992443949,
0.2005241364,
0.0128745697,
0.0159193799,
-0.2133004814,
0.112635158,
0.0435983576,
-0.5446716547,
0.5712353587,
0.4032051265,
-0.5072278976,
-0.1264716685,
0.6162588,
0.0209806245,
-0.2822389007,
0.2748123407,
-0.6043955088,
-0.561820209,
0.5910136104,
0.8724504113,
0.6052633524,
-0.5302299261,
0.1365340501,
0.8386797905,
0.1713121235,
-0.0105339065,
0.3976005018,
-0.1913284808,
-0.7180063128,
-0.2926721275,
-0.913272202,
-0.2889034152,
0.2658905387,
-0.7553036213,
0.0784538537,
-0.6895663142,
-0.2792623639,
-0.3519984782,
0.2657423019,
-0.468183279,
0.2475325763,
-0.0867234841,
0.8638673425,
-0.7922124267,
1.0579732656,
0.5712487698,
-0.2905375063,
-1.0205888748,
0.2219775021,
-0.1704786569,
-0.2483881265,
0.7065294981,
0.1239010096,
-0.1885034293,
-0.0316858105,
-0.5895241499,
-1.015278697,
0.8768701553,
-0.1607936621,
-0.595441103,
0.0703615025,
-0.3681814373,
0.6092057824,
-0.0759181455,
-0.0270060021,
0.5498909354,
0.4653762281,
0.1279042959,
-1.0107787848,
0.0549959019,
-0.2035448402,
0.3480739295,
0.4257231355,
-0.5669646263,
0.6097702384,
-0.0055346796,
-0.0611909367,
0.2597979605,
0.9037699699,
0.2147856057,
0.3109645844,
0.3991669416,
0.4155308604,
0.8798726201,
0.0184925962,
1.2153265476,
-0.3254741132,
-0.0645376444,
1.4943988323,
-0.1275558025,
1.1397924423,
0.0997153372,
-0.2235126495,
0.6439774632,
0.3961367011,
0.2679917216,
0.568026185,
0.3112253547,
-0.2283567041,
0.138276428,
-0.3710071445,
-0.3918627799,
0.3418657482,
0.2320062965,
-0.3207531273,
0.0262615923,
-0.0356034487,
0.3349236846,
0.4489665926,
-0.5081840158,
0.8725425601,
-0.1710499227,
-0.6252154112,
0.2478749454,
0.1460006982,
0.8039243817,
-0.7801083326,
0.0385417044,
-0.4258747697,
0.0412542336,
-0.2131793946,
-0.5394663215,
0.5135760903,
-0.0310431682,
-0.2148998231,
-0.1840026379,
0.8531584144,
-0.6969719529,
-0.7048120499,
0.1699945331,
-0.0323307887,
0.1643701494,
0.203085795,
-0.4485206008,
-0.2515728176,
-0.1931592077,
-0.10789866,
0.4490190148,
0.5921491981,
-0.3064875901,
0.645773828,
0.6614601016,
0.4414883256,
0.2727569044,
0.2627291977,
0.696623981,
-0.4504994154,
-0.720338285,
-0.4469258189,
0.0101759415,
-0.1209151223,
-0.2192213535,
0.9144360423,
0.2324990481,
1.0435684919,
0.1298222989,
0.5484270453,
-0.1428731084,
0.4082216322,
-0.58315593,
0.9434582591,
-0.399645865,
-0.2686296999,
-0.7306204438,
-1.0693342686,
-0.2694447339,
0.9690747261,
-0.5577036738,
0.4540630281,
0.5387355089,
0.940092802,
-0.040735133,
-0.1627553105,
0.3869239986,
0.1203262657,
0.000106327,
0.3806992769,
0.5015669465,
-0.0512383282,
0.2572300136,
-1.0280007124,
-0.2964808047,
0.0760569051,
-1.1692135334,
-0.8074734807,
-0.7382612824,
-0.2511871159,
-0.5830543637,
-0.2244472057,
0.7109851241,
0.9052166939,
-0.7943036556,
-0.0396606289,
-0.4096726477,
0.0611005314,
-0.1058622748,
-0.3659261167,
0.2292941362,
-0.4142391086,
-0.7165570855,
0.4962553382,
-0.0289476216,
0.2228740752,
-0.353363663,
-0.2562473416,
-0.0492059961,
0.0969676524,
0.6799931526,
0.0606017038,
-0.4354496598,
-0.2492480427,
-0.2834337652,
-0.324310869,
-0.0530863777,
0.8083058,
-0.6847865582,
0.7512646914,
0.6466096044,
0.0991601795,
-0.0063300491,
0.2602638304,
0.7188016176,
-1.1704312563,
0.3056028485,
0.0243012179,
0.1605278403,
0.4056069255,
-0.5271872282,
0.4262516797,
-0.055336304,
-0.7045657039,
-0.4217040837,
0.4920973778,
-0.6403442025,
-0.2784046233,
1.2194111347,
-0.0469118319,
-0.1477168947,
0.0190292839,
-0.2438491434,
0.3016104698,
-0.4494590759,
0.7553445697,
0.8414715528,
-0.0613930412,
-0.0327446759,
-0.8604682684,
0.8829539418,
0.3869866729,
-0.6911843419,
-0.0181368981,
0.5640594959,
0.2614884079,
0.2720745802,
0.7241043448,
-0.2159544826,
0.0247526579,
-0.1143730581,
-0.1332332641,
-0.0345648937,
-0.529633224,
-0.4946539402,
0.0797815621,
0.1851906478,
0.3227386773
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00451v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00451v1
|
Discourse Relations Classification and Cross-Framework Discourse Relation Classification Through the Lens of Cognitive Dimensions: An Empirical Investigation
| 2023-11-01T11:38:19 | 2023-11-01T11:38:19 |
Yingxue Fu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Existing discourse formalisms use different taxonomies of discourse
relations, which require expert knowledge to understand, posing a challenge for
annotation and automatic classification. We show that discourse relations can
be effectively captured by some simple cognitively inspired dimensions proposed
by Sanders et al.(2018). Our experiments on cross-framework discourse relation
classification (PDTB & RST) demonstrate that it is possible to transfer
knowledge of discourse relations for one framework to another framework by
means of these dimensions, in spite of differences in discourse segmentation of
the two frameworks. This manifests the effectiveness of these dimensions in
characterizing discourse relations across frameworks. Ablation studies reveal
that different dimensions influence different types of discourse relations. The
patterns can be explained by the role of dimensions in characterizing and
distinguishing different relations. We also report our experimental results on
automatic prediction of these dimensions.
|
[
-0.6566230655,
-0.8286659718,
0.7782805562,
0.2109885514,
-0.0990129411,
0.2539072335,
0.1347068995,
-1.0145722628,
0.1027240455,
0.7290395498,
-0.2032200396,
-0.1329215765,
-0.6039115787,
-0.1363458037,
-0.3776189387,
0.884129107,
0.144580707,
0.3053945303,
-0.5102140307,
-0.4849826396,
-0.22868222,
-0.7687898874,
-0.5721239448,
-0.4074878991,
0.5480527282,
-0.0604486652,
0.6836652756,
0.6238136292,
0.5425603986,
0.3879744112,
-0.2653453648,
-0.053357143,
-0.0186863765,
-0.0837334245,
-0.5266102552,
-0.4492899776,
-0.3184577227,
0.2474134415,
0.483918786,
1.0291877985,
0.0984926522,
0.2714653909,
-0.0336258262,
0.3446777165,
-0.5349965692,
0.3899582922,
-0.5581420064,
-0.0180732254,
-0.2251654863,
-0.3045643866,
-0.5205060244,
-0.3863052726,
0.4173319042,
-0.3660515249,
0.2655848265,
0.2791213691,
0.7596583962,
-0.028463766,
-0.9864145517,
-0.3600638211,
-1.0960981846,
0.5623725653,
-0.2543929815,
0.3692067266,
0.3722862601,
0.3857960701,
0.4187633097,
-0.6160312295,
-0.3461225033,
0.0559460595,
-0.525082469,
-0.1076621786,
-0.0001403884,
0.2838852704,
0.4547679722,
0.5737391114,
-0.3844718933,
0.2057644576,
-0.4563340545,
-0.2788390815,
0.7288063765,
0.2816731334,
0.3348851204,
-0.4563046694,
-0.463676095,
0.2074214518,
-0.5248073936,
-0.0129140131,
0.069345504,
0.1227337569,
0.0213771202,
0.2055526674,
0.1091008261,
0.445305109,
0.2113956958,
-0.3201771677,
0.1256895363,
-0.5196298361,
-0.2800250053,
0.042191565,
0.8445905447,
0.0603093766,
0.0624227189,
-0.0198467113,
0.1897399276,
-0.0633790642,
0.3164974749,
-0.6389174461,
-0.1280019879,
-0.2384956181,
-0.6238292456,
-0.250136137,
0.0591886938,
-0.6056740284,
-0.3643109798,
-0.4575453401,
0.0920774788,
-0.5057739019,
-0.4845079184,
-0.2885483801,
0.0557166412,
0.5109714866,
0.5091953278,
-0.9173110127,
0.6512791514,
0.7896927595,
0.6404644847,
-0.2311628908,
-0.0518918522,
0.0809687302,
0.1110514626,
-0.1905430704,
0.934363246,
-0.6902770996,
-0.3114351928,
0.1328915656,
-0.1279155314,
-0.2056502849,
-0.3529449105,
0.332898587,
-0.5561658144,
0.6398739815,
-0.6969764233,
-0.4378919303,
-0.5173417926,
0.2512564063,
-0.7834045887,
0.8340374827,
0.395475626,
-0.9862493277,
0.4562708735,
-0.4906029999,
-0.490208596,
0.0881362483,
-0.3499014676,
-0.2768396437,
0.2654025853,
0.1156682,
0.4444069266,
-0.6925531626,
0.1119434237,
-0.4345318675,
0.0623035058,
0.4634144008,
-0.1097353548,
1.2030836344,
0.1434900463,
-0.0210210886,
0.0372567512,
-1.0453728437,
-0.119415693,
-0.2223482132,
-0.0025955865,
-0.6793749928,
-0.2824625969,
0.0300371312,
0.3881173432,
0.0435930304,
-0.6337423325,
-0.0380676873,
-0.38544631,
0.387914151,
0.3912035227,
0.5863926411,
0.8517026305,
-0.177554816,
0.6513109207,
0.2106740922,
-0.1649642438,
-0.0161515251,
-0.4456960857,
-0.7041770816,
-0.1104661226,
0.5651308298,
0.6876343489,
-0.7721441388,
0.3853898346,
-0.2650370002,
-0.5217036009,
-0.3099158406,
-0.3361209035,
0.5874765515,
0.4333108068,
0.4347011149,
-0.5668645501,
-0.5306431055,
-0.9780944586,
-0.219257623,
-0.7027456164,
0.1486857682,
0.4129711092,
0.5241515636,
0.3322793543,
0.9834643006,
-0.4780741334,
-0.2727650702,
0.0198012125,
0.5434449911,
-0.5349089503,
0.3255288601,
1.1737395525,
-0.5857923031,
-0.600720644,
0.2544552684,
-0.7561534047,
-0.0843201727,
-0.194695726,
-0.0349598899,
0.2610888183,
0.4403812587,
-0.5026446581,
0.4581275582,
0.140444532,
-0.3078401089,
0.5308339,
0.2618507147,
0.1271276325,
-0.9787915945,
-0.1878514141,
0.0309483763,
-0.2790600061,
-0.606608808,
-0.1702994555,
0.0111638624,
0.1534353346,
-0.4338795543,
0.3595682681,
-0.4478592277,
-0.2804803252,
0.0211383644,
-0.1571546942,
0.0154064223,
0.6413571835,
0.2296216935,
0.3139863312,
0.3638824224,
-0.412740916,
0.3355506659,
0.2971943617,
-0.246706754,
1.2450683117,
-0.27003631,
0.1438208222,
0.1607251167,
0.2710714936,
-1.0980097055,
0.0560611114,
0.1752258539,
-0.5535567403,
0.2904262841,
-0.1586284786,
-0.4924185574,
-0.096405305,
-0.1457547992,
0.3653744161,
0.2244661301,
-0.268155843,
0.8532417417,
0.5436398387,
-0.1349678189,
-0.3318374157,
-0.9641098976,
-0.1722302884,
-0.484098345,
-0.4083174467,
0.39176175,
0.2652106881,
-0.4716586769,
0.3103988171,
0.066684939,
-0.2969479561,
-0.049727302,
0.4023856223,
-0.086581178,
-0.2045944184,
0.2347904146,
0.3694880605,
-0.0682688951,
0.5959994197,
-0.0631261915,
0.1129820496,
0.1141943336,
-0.2809510827,
-0.5899145603,
0.4528504312,
0.7133375406,
-0.3475438058,
0.8176058531,
0.5997823477,
-0.440579325,
0.0161202736,
-0.7008110881,
-0.1676813066,
-0.3922064602,
0.1583765447,
-0.6996286511,
-0.9193530679,
0.7612299919,
-0.1695393771,
-0.0020715124,
0.3989807069,
0.3076762855,
-0.0065346453,
0.888215065,
0.8439011574,
-0.1076997817,
0.3442691565,
-0.1437035799,
0.1696163863,
-0.9271125197,
-0.1875027865,
-0.749351263,
-0.2216563374,
-0.7969895005,
-0.0457315929,
0.0317265727,
-0.1599012613,
-0.2866038382,
0.3942131102,
-0.3827549815,
0.2409223318,
0.1840392351,
-0.1496990472,
0.3702678382,
0.1227146462,
-0.3047975898,
-0.3785922825,
-0.4744880199,
-0.2451682538,
0.626703918,
0.411177665,
0.2734024525,
0.0772675127,
0.6416295767,
-0.0118439905,
0.5386193991,
-0.8831934929,
0.7011500597,
0.2128760219,
-0.6978340745,
-0.1815108061,
-0.5951024294,
-0.9653072953,
0.5855306387,
-0.2069051266,
-0.9643954635,
0.5705886483,
-0.3150006235,
-0.2882086039,
0.3399507999,
-0.4627460539,
0.4989462793,
-0.1413701177,
-0.2282517254,
-0.262237668,
-0.7236480117,
0.4939572811,
-0.0211248733,
0.3514346778,
0.0250198431,
0.0949315131,
0.913864553,
-0.2137057632,
0.8354586363,
-0.0818262175,
-0.2229217291,
0.2871810496,
0.3252966404,
-0.1963355839,
0.0629492402,
-0.0233823955,
0.0716555044,
0.2167138457,
-0.1154043525,
-0.8806927204,
0.651615262,
-0.8973469734,
-0.6343047619,
-0.6623424888,
-0.5274879336,
-0.3854711354,
0.1731173098,
0.1181770042,
0.1967642605,
-0.6670760512,
0.1815762818,
0.5215011239,
0.155797556,
0.3062361181,
0.5655639768,
-0.3810495734,
-0.4651876688,
0.7476806641,
0.6641115546,
0.1192756966,
0.6124048829,
-0.065527387,
-0.2108671665,
-0.4887855053,
-0.0833713561,
0.4126101136,
-0.6739754081,
-0.2535842657,
-0.6759636402,
-0.4805445075,
-0.4415775239,
-0.1389308721,
-0.2876713872,
-0.8020451069,
-0.2869690657,
-0.40926525,
0.2092206925,
0.8589423299,
-0.0896975771,
0.1899916977,
-0.6465869546,
-0.1694498211,
0.2887666225,
0.0545099117,
0.1906778365,
-0.4446920753,
-0.0874454901,
-0.2837985754,
-0.6967070699,
-1.179754734,
0.2588781118,
-0.0241279788,
0.5079823136,
0.6956799626,
0.0483109318,
0.6181665659,
-0.283208102,
0.85038203,
0.352914542,
-1.1305949688,
0.4334952831,
-0.2659231424,
0.2038369924,
0.3796375096,
0.7465238571,
-0.3387137353,
-0.3570164144,
-1.0810089111,
-0.651216507,
0.744358778,
0.1070015952,
-0.0613881126,
0.146153152,
0.4679748416,
0.0628132597,
0.2162436843,
-0.6277575493,
-0.29678756,
0.1082046628,
0.0799047053,
0.0995319933,
-0.4830605686,
-0.314956665,
-0.4611034691,
0.2254981995,
-0.012688389,
0.3759098947,
-0.0096175792,
-0.0859828368,
-0.2470056713,
0.2609398961,
0.2816684246,
1.0131373405,
0.2105004489,
0.3712048531,
0.4103097022,
-0.1556119323,
0.2549203634,
-0.0361858793,
-0.0691954121,
-0.1023424864,
0.6110578179,
0.68638587,
0.3484861553,
0.2469143122,
0.3047063351,
-0.074262023,
-0.5058651567,
-0.3293309808,
-0.1593084186,
0.3465607762,
0.2683215141,
0.1033438295,
0.146717459,
0.2531904578,
-0.8579710126,
0.0692559779,
0.3918284476,
-0.4354881048,
-0.5987590551,
0.2978342474,
0.2700267732,
-0.4180677235,
0.4255205691,
-0.2810797393,
-0.7106425762,
0.4059897363,
0.3482156098,
0.6976874471,
-0.5568807721,
0.3756920695,
0.3148424923,
0.2025948912,
0.243739143,
0.0107783359,
-0.2649749517,
-0.8318593502,
-0.3051266074,
-0.3993694484,
-0.5930973887,
0.2263091207,
-1.1805803776,
0.0599473156,
-0.7212927938,
-0.1658452302,
0.4353735745,
0.3926274776,
-0.6354022026,
0.0599042289,
0.051024273,
0.4609529972,
-0.9100444317,
0.9429755807,
0.6397361159,
-0.4306713343,
-0.5549807549,
-0.2193223834,
0.3952203095,
-0.2888936698,
0.6418529749,
0.1042471677,
-0.1285678148,
-0.2841536999,
-0.2567077279,
-0.8625293374,
1.0614632368,
0.3034094274,
-0.2477403432,
-0.1006997004,
0.5082020164,
0.8027130365,
-0.6825276613,
0.2200220525,
0.7435165644,
0.3910583258,
0.0929283127,
-1.2996239662,
0.3425787985,
0.0124383718,
0.2812882364,
0.2280778736,
-0.7066804767,
0.6875982285,
0.1435754895,
-0.4541827142,
-0.0669514537,
1.0407480001,
-0.1382694691,
0.4757266939,
0.4764922857,
0.5700700879,
0.7470861673,
-0.1463743448,
0.6278439164,
-0.2994919717,
0.2699189186,
1.0025309324,
-0.3545918763,
0.6585466266,
0.2949063182,
-0.3049995601,
0.8375526071,
0.5458239317,
-0.0365246907,
0.2738726735,
0.0368155651,
0.0276642218,
-0.0798627362,
-0.1622737199,
-0.4877240658,
0.6573527455,
0.9042213559,
-0.4818319082,
-0.0948789939,
0.1981241107,
0.0533450656,
0.2971720695,
-0.2038397044,
0.9766362906,
0.3496986628,
-0.593280375,
0.2716332674,
-0.0151650058,
0.295340389,
-0.256834209,
0.1252901852,
0.2112691849,
0.132428512,
-0.2783727348,
-0.8597058058,
0.6839777827,
-0.490776211,
-0.0961113647,
-0.4152526855,
0.932307601,
-0.253429383,
-0.2764114141,
0.5408088565,
0.8130341172,
-0.1214550138,
0.2108865082,
-0.6378290653,
-0.0742741451,
-0.1619447619,
-0.3179246485,
0.7201598287,
0.8470499516,
-0.1862807423,
0.4015728831,
0.4131150544,
-0.0953577459,
-0.1780422777,
-0.2888979316,
0.8107929826,
-0.6763728261,
-0.5188415647,
-0.5904785991,
0.1222395897,
-0.3126959801,
-0.3563928306,
0.9119244218,
0.380875349,
0.8896700144,
0.0535502099,
0.6750856638,
0.0226462428,
0.5699310899,
-0.3105234802,
0.4862833619,
-0.1176873744,
0.1594319195,
-0.146502316,
-0.9952224493,
-0.3628578186,
0.6784559488,
-0.7614331841,
0.129330501,
1.1774302721,
0.3305121362,
-0.0851040855,
0.3402473927,
0.1474030018,
0.1280462146,
0.2348155528,
0.4111511409,
0.6914660335,
-0.0334160291,
0.4313223064,
-0.5454134345,
-0.2009599656,
-0.0415861644,
-0.4565682709,
-1.112303853,
-0.9692392349,
-0.5859032273,
-0.2609093785,
-0.2297230214,
0.5553504229,
0.7344985008,
-0.5192223787,
-0.3566086888,
-0.0021371306,
0.1788671017,
-0.3788788915,
-0.3478108346,
0.3284095824,
-0.1121511459,
-0.638656795,
-0.1644518971,
0.2854067087,
-0.0579020046,
-0.6895540357,
0.4025090337,
-0.4364633262,
0.3903668523,
0.9075197577,
0.2592660487,
-0.5748006105,
-0.5323531628,
-0.3010272682,
-0.1732074618,
0.103937149,
1.2937713861,
-0.7290840745,
-0.0415409543,
0.8616406322,
0.4377721548,
0.6152448654,
-0.0967607871,
0.4955081642,
-0.9106873274,
0.1018124372,
0.2568991184,
0.3755275905,
0.2924503684,
-0.4711742103,
0.5635476112,
0.2724615633,
-0.5287214518,
-0.7944181561,
0.6153036356,
-1.0503482819,
-0.3501938879,
0.9933007956,
-0.4107249975,
-0.1762678921,
-0.4611590505,
-0.0824691206,
0.0262648985,
-0.0315638706,
0.7078734636,
0.8789001107,
-0.5301302075,
-0.5305505991,
-0.247698918,
0.6065624356,
0.1958381236,
-0.7941884995,
0.0403218642,
0.2063206583,
0.1675051898,
0.7656771541,
0.6918655634,
-0.3638294041,
0.1068979874,
-0.023969125,
-0.3637575805,
0.106804885,
-0.3153948486,
0.0602249652,
0.6333215237,
-0.0941265747,
0.2187787592
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00445v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00445v2
|
A Systematic Comparison of Syllogistic Reasoning in Humans and Language Models
| 2023-11-01T11:13:06 | 2024-04-11T16:49:57 |
Tiwalayo Eisape, MH Tessler, Ishita Dasgupta, Fei Sha, Sjoerd van Steenkiste, Tal Linzen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
A central component of rational behavior is logical inference: the process of
determining which conclusions follow from a set of premises. Psychologists have
documented several ways in which humans' inferences deviate from the rules of
logic. Do language models, which are trained on text generated by humans,
replicate such human biases, or are they able to overcome them? Focusing on the
case of syllogisms -- inferences from two simple premises -- we show that,
within the PaLM2 family of transformer language models, larger models are more
logical than smaller ones, and also more logical than humans. At the same time,
even the largest models make systematic errors, some of which mirror human
reasoning biases: they show sensitivity to the (irrelevant) ordering of the
variables in the syllogism, and draw confident but incorrect inferences from
particular syllogisms (syllogistic fallacies). Overall, we find that language
models often mimic the human biases included in their training data, but are
able to overcome them in some cases.
|
[
-0.0256267004,
-0.816703856,
0.7965664864,
-0.0089785103,
0.2006531805,
-0.1354470253,
-0.1696067303,
-0.2711988986,
-0.1179949641,
0.7544397116,
-0.4498058558,
-0.0636607334,
-0.5649174452,
0.1401973516,
-0.3314641416,
0.7682060003,
0.1331732273,
0.3045487106,
0.0380079411,
-0.2746658027,
-0.276552856,
-0.8187708259,
-0.3607268035,
-0.6740763187,
0.1007437035,
-0.0274001136,
0.9823170304,
0.718061924,
0.1104729399,
0.3510335386,
-0.0913484022,
-0.0866402909,
-0.1915339977,
0.0892568752,
-0.6004629135,
-0.9719836116,
-0.0650414601,
0.4245015085,
0.417537868,
0.9120195508,
-0.3254805207,
-0.0927383378,
-0.0293119289,
0.6757060885,
-0.5933465958,
0.2403756231,
-0.4098546803,
-0.1184062958,
0.0563999489,
0.2509890497,
-0.971878171,
-0.7149499059,
0.4085312486,
-0.5518924594,
0.2638174593,
0.0413876884,
0.7528142333,
0.2122109681,
-0.5906621218,
-0.2152496576,
-0.819637835,
0.9258176684,
-0.6640954018,
0.2868262827,
0.5114538074,
0.3104597926,
-0.2601490915,
-0.5631426573,
-0.7661318779,
-0.198560819,
-0.4970355928,
-0.1298221648,
-0.3737368286,
0.1990162879,
0.8594235778,
-0.4103886485,
-0.5382087231,
-0.4071388543,
-0.256516099,
-0.1055713966,
0.633595407,
-0.0952793509,
0.6672689319,
-0.3005898893,
-0.224269405,
-0.1789741516,
-0.6225576401,
0.0228233505,
0.1443128437,
0.0141962823,
0.04233988,
0.3859430254,
-0.1406314075,
0.8271149993,
-0.1514005214,
-0.4766884446,
-0.0054598399,
-0.0409849063,
-0.3565295339,
0.0552252233,
0.4977136552,
0.5282076597,
0.9164672494,
-0.0742060915,
-0.1572731435,
0.8382402658,
0.0358912796,
-0.3044622242,
-0.5421937704,
-0.2077332884,
-0.3715308905,
-0.1023885012,
0.0933460966,
-0.3267853856,
-0.5463067293,
-0.4498609304,
0.3511636853,
-0.3631544709,
-0.2383474708,
0.2355831861,
-0.4993731081,
0.3157691956,
0.5477631092,
-0.8313109875,
0.7738533616,
0.7266262174,
0.387881875,
0.1960793883,
-0.3531619012,
-0.2693361044,
0.1475484818,
-0.493345499,
0.9545306563,
-0.5487824678,
-0.410394758,
-0.2735966742,
-0.1034925506,
-0.3127117455,
-0.7433766127,
0.483158052,
-0.2595237494,
0.3226057291,
-0.4613971412,
-0.4608543813,
-0.5746541023,
0.0181518253,
-0.4955633283,
0.5793213248,
0.2599367499,
-0.7648406625,
0.3965866268,
-0.2032649666,
-0.4720647633,
-0.269122839,
-0.4299516976,
-0.0884777904,
0.0178539176,
-0.0281779096,
0.0071250182,
-0.690664053,
0.3344179392,
-0.550186038,
-0.0833593756,
0.6171292663,
-0.3566351235,
1.2357020378,
-0.0518603995,
-0.6123028398,
0.0950640216,
-0.3271140754,
-0.0914490372,
0.1735066175,
0.0295541584,
-0.4796439111,
0.519753933,
-0.0774328262,
0.5809982419,
-0.4077564776,
-0.4499968588,
0.2391617447,
-0.397521317,
0.6626659036,
0.703350246,
-0.1972112358,
0.6520396471,
-0.6902651787,
0.1956585944,
-0.0998190641,
0.1228349507,
-0.0674886182,
-0.6850508451,
-0.8692888021,
-0.2354865223,
-0.0198010001,
0.7557656169,
-0.3098232746,
0.1815714985,
-0.2979800999,
-0.4805853367,
-0.2332533747,
0.0197843704,
0.480609417,
0.7608370185,
0.1493169665,
-0.2258247137,
-0.4606669843,
-1.0685065985,
-0.7879098058,
-0.4462526441,
0.0492002033,
0.1842985451,
0.3866412938,
-0.1059349701,
1.093873024,
-0.3684354424,
0.0928688794,
-0.477031678,
0.1549029052,
0.0937614962,
0.2966058254,
0.6136932373,
-0.7184093595,
-0.3128532171,
-0.2408939451,
-0.7709372044,
-0.2237924635,
-0.1470039785,
-0.0174270347,
0.5518271923,
0.1907698959,
-0.9068456888,
0.8822996616,
0.0520551093,
-0.6931761503,
0.5405165553,
0.0387285799,
-0.0521497019,
-0.6726051569,
-0.1772577018,
0.3117498457,
-0.3595535457,
-0.6773931384,
-0.112103343,
-0.1114142388,
0.3188964427,
-0.1631281972,
0.5987759829,
-0.1946770847,
-0.0739762858,
-0.1819514781,
0.2054499537,
0.0941668376,
0.1705376655,
0.3224746585,
0.4522126317,
0.3494067192,
-0.4310639799,
0.3359465897,
0.0758837312,
-0.2413729578,
0.4973927438,
-0.68393749,
-0.1586440057,
-0.2793552876,
0.6521083117,
-0.9387423992,
-0.3593138456,
0.2910633981,
-0.3059705198,
-0.1512349099,
-0.1185694039,
-0.4480541945,
-0.40246436,
-0.1234449744,
-0.052258119,
1.0535753965,
-0.4210458398,
0.6987130642,
0.4704819918,
-0.1306308359,
-0.4217860103,
-0.6934320927,
-0.2558000386,
-0.1470680684,
-0.5393006802,
-0.2079617977,
0.1435146481,
-1.021184206,
-0.254480809,
-0.2436459363,
-0.2039868832,
0.0121526057,
0.4693982899,
0.4664376676,
-0.1032215431,
-0.009464548,
-0.0421963818,
-0.0998523608,
0.529571116,
-0.2840570211,
0.434977144,
0.0473847315,
-0.4417628348,
-0.7160567641,
-0.0089736441,
0.5410857797,
0.0693921149,
0.4862266779,
-0.1818037629,
-0.5863548517,
-0.2149911076,
-0.7274125218,
-0.6102311015,
-0.341414094,
0.0850880444,
-0.3467496932,
-0.4224805236,
0.1041755006,
-0.0265270621,
-0.0295009501,
0.4395106137,
0.527440846,
-0.2630853951,
1.4520721436,
0.3111563623,
-0.142990917,
0.0926316082,
-0.0940335393,
0.1152040511,
-0.3382090628,
-0.146982193,
-0.7008960843,
-0.0849130005,
-0.7334424257,
-0.4427229762,
0.0715030059,
0.2159660012,
-0.5678761601,
0.2768767476,
-0.3512804508,
0.6065171957,
0.4433060288,
0.1587971747,
0.2960282564,
0.0958638415,
0.0413908884,
-0.1152760834,
-0.804299593,
-1.0512309074,
0.9488901496,
0.1188998297,
0.9833655357,
0.2860300243,
0.4403828979,
0.1611234099,
0.8158963919,
-0.5634100437,
0.5418901443,
0.0578610525,
-0.7098889351,
-0.1840378642,
-0.3153537512,
-0.7181475163,
0.4702447653,
-0.1368785799,
-1.1105120182,
0.0927490965,
0.3225421011,
-0.1149359569,
0.3245948553,
-0.9422312379,
0.7988247871,
-0.0711467788,
-0.2360666245,
-0.5324854851,
-0.9209893346,
0.5756933093,
0.0987807214,
0.3955712318,
-0.1948314309,
0.3027541935,
0.8535662293,
-0.5632603765,
0.9633182883,
-0.1747696847,
0.0436586104,
0.5019577146,
0.482926935,
0.3230883181,
-0.0637934282,
-0.1417896599,
-0.2480307668,
0.2003225684,
-0.51172328,
-0.934211731,
0.2939036191,
-0.8958335519,
-0.8817042708,
-0.6354246736,
-0.4087739587,
-0.1608882695,
0.2336484641,
0.0788936317,
0.2788042724,
-0.1531727314,
-0.2890558839,
0.6508282423,
-0.0818457305,
0.2157470584,
0.4088822007,
-0.4417428672,
-0.0611840896,
0.5075061321,
-0.0908664316,
0.4894831777,
0.2757281959,
0.4322235286,
-0.3823794425,
0.1325015128,
-0.2217829823,
0.467787683,
-0.848233819,
0.1380423009,
-0.5516694188,
-0.0697533488,
-0.4450672269,
-0.1293466836,
-0.0252050124,
-0.590809226,
0.080161646,
-0.0707811192,
0.2572856545,
1.1071411371,
0.1895247102,
0.3199705184,
-0.62629354,
0.3578881323,
0.5725229383,
-0.2798137069,
-0.0578646995,
-0.6005341411,
0.5650962591,
0.3783887923,
-0.2892908454,
-1.0833109617,
0.2698740959,
-0.0853144974,
0.442448467,
0.4523356259,
-0.1532693505,
0.5301768184,
-0.4027332067,
0.5287575722,
0.2786226273,
-1.0955199003,
0.7468644381,
-0.3929363191,
0.0544069931,
0.1920198649,
0.4131598175,
-0.6162478924,
-0.2288651168,
-0.85160923,
-0.0679304078,
0.7260193229,
0.0959544778,
-0.0362999998,
-0.1429311484,
0.3050125539,
-0.1012993753,
-0.085940063,
-0.716904223,
-0.0657920912,
-0.1623607874,
-0.075509958,
-0.1052825004,
-0.0954243839,
-0.3256388903,
-0.3689531088,
0.3673109412,
-0.0846981853,
-0.1296767741,
0.1383958906,
-0.5196307898,
-0.0320466049,
0.2850858569,
0.6073983312,
0.9295280576,
0.0761955753,
0.3380911946,
0.1228052974,
-0.2167470455,
0.4577806592,
-0.14806512,
-0.3033880293,
-0.0150420573,
0.638984561,
0.6464886665,
0.1200534776,
-0.9752221107,
0.5644077659,
0.0750787333,
0.0090460181,
-0.1802366972,
0.3460976183,
0.0476164222,
0.3211351633,
0.1729464978,
0.3660645485,
0.0507947095,
-0.8292317986,
0.1750951409,
0.3271665871,
-0.1874933094,
-0.4995506704,
0.6493731737,
-0.0304570496,
-0.4620723426,
0.8842967749,
0.0601855963,
-0.7108584046,
0.6600396633,
0.7657065392,
0.4763826132,
-0.3894205391,
0.1954816729,
0.2137890458,
0.4938917458,
-0.5307750106,
0.4478096068,
0.0089474181,
-0.9405696988,
-0.4413123429,
-0.3599581122,
-0.3698284626,
-0.4012321532,
-0.6548325419,
0.1627721936,
-0.5279803276,
-0.3335378468,
0.338006407,
-0.4789048433,
-0.3768143952,
0.3001873493,
0.055549439,
1.1218671799,
-0.9732127786,
1.0863611698,
0.7326036692,
-0.42570135,
-0.9338232875,
-0.0857959241,
0.3453471959,
-0.7063478231,
1.0597586632,
0.211048454,
-0.2762974203,
-0.1998159438,
-0.4230383039,
-0.421564281,
0.7520790696,
0.6249186397,
-0.3551748395,
-0.1678532064,
0.1291216761,
0.4201622307,
-0.1776993424,
0.4427030087,
0.9698622227,
0.5293015838,
-0.3257375956,
-0.9777847528,
0.0624161735,
0.0353048444,
0.0890285522,
0.1758574396,
-0.3853446245,
0.895334363,
-0.4217733443,
-0.1686199903,
0.0921725929,
0.3180978,
0.5542647839,
0.0620287471,
0.513833344,
0.5660630465,
0.640457809,
-0.3289595246,
1.1451274157,
-0.2027311772,
0.3273156881,
0.9679247141,
-0.6076753139,
0.7168182731,
0.4384383559,
-0.3810444772,
0.836625874,
0.3615759015,
0.4016636014,
0.1664204448,
0.1469290555,
-0.2364519387,
-0.4527848959,
-0.0280610435,
0.0633124113,
0.5036960244,
0.5283762813,
-0.458983779,
-0.1820077449,
-0.2607698143,
0.2976665795,
0.3872077465,
-0.1066323221,
0.7755350471,
0.1778741777,
-0.9264740348,
0.4861499071,
0.1392686665,
0.1860417277,
-0.3198775649,
-0.0548325591,
-0.1316916496,
0.290148139,
-0.1972480267,
-0.7279995084,
0.2718499899,
-0.2057208419,
-0.3528833091,
-0.2845746279,
0.8669298291,
-0.0097377179,
-0.2276492864,
0.1188695729,
0.4783352017,
0.0363121927,
0.128878668,
-0.555303812,
-0.1115263104,
0.0435973965,
-0.2421068102,
0.0384932533,
0.0118727107,
-0.5641015172,
0.8864688277,
0.4431658983,
0.1898808777,
0.1238535643,
0.1334692091,
0.4612481594,
-0.7736498713,
-0.3853778541,
-1.1918218136,
0.2071670443,
-0.1942273676,
0.0071064248,
0.6925327182,
0.4058724046,
0.7206705809,
-0.1830204129,
1.0182546377,
0.1582314968,
0.5774754286,
-0.3156980574,
0.6128838062,
0.0618467629,
-0.0354715884,
-0.2346966267,
-0.8510865569,
-0.1837300807,
1.1677510738,
-0.6042547226,
0.0796418935,
0.6318143606,
0.7025355101,
-0.0045776595,
0.3705618978,
0.0172480792,
0.3276516199,
0.0706875101,
0.5659546256,
0.9059016109,
-0.2547367215,
0.0053105173,
-0.143724069,
-0.3962775767,
-0.0371235199,
-0.4256643653,
-0.8987529874,
-0.4206804037,
-0.1531332582,
-0.5792779326,
0.129584372,
0.9462996125,
0.6840091944,
-0.6597397327,
-0.5733197331,
-0.340087831,
0.4770823717,
-0.1596014798,
-0.1887668967,
0.0367389508,
-0.0310074612,
-0.5938840508,
-0.1089082956,
0.3944420815,
0.1042419374,
-0.1481395513,
-0.1192784235,
-0.1128467917,
0.4029121697,
0.7384903431,
0.361897707,
-1.1958115101,
-0.3484342396,
-0.1471787393,
-0.41162166,
-0.0595450252,
0.9511759281,
-1.0964400768,
0.3434749842,
0.6316928267,
0.1818814129,
0.1220128238,
-0.0738889426,
0.6024852991,
-0.0347438157,
0.4510279298,
0.1415767372,
0.4796677828,
0.1382201314,
0.2985283136,
0.4641858041,
0.6965821981,
-0.2646375,
-0.7768468261,
0.5234499574,
-0.649723649,
-0.395526588,
1.0842299461,
0.0150314253,
-0.2722298205,
-0.0773239285,
-0.3298248053,
0.2734449804,
0.0027893903,
0.7915563583,
0.7335749269,
-0.3422352374,
-0.1170448363,
-0.5702853799,
0.5631338954,
0.536570251,
-0.8596606255,
0.1074378192,
0.5249989629,
0.5415678024,
0.1020578369,
0.5894753933,
0.1350477487,
0.6028285623,
0.0418024324,
-0.0739922374,
0.8200603127,
-0.0856931582,
-0.1350851655,
-0.2294013351,
0.2932989001,
0.4438522756
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00430v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00430v1
|
Distil-Whisper: Robust Knowledge Distillation via Large-Scale Pseudo Labelling
| 2023-11-01T10:45:07 | 2023-11-01T10:45:07 |
Sanchit Gandhi, Patrick von Platen, Alexander M. Rush
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
As the size of pre-trained speech recognition models increases, running these
large models in low-latency or resource-constrained environments becomes
challenging. In this work, we leverage pseudo-labelling to assemble a
large-scale open-source dataset which we use to distill the Whisper model into
a smaller variant, called Distil-Whisper. Using a simple word error rate (WER)
heuristic, we select only the highest quality pseudo-labels for training. The
distilled model is 5.8 times faster with 51% fewer parameters, while performing
to within 1% WER on out-of-distribution test data in a zero-shot transfer
setting. Distil-Whisper maintains the robustness of the Whisper model to
difficult acoustic conditions, while being less prone to hallucination errors
on long-form audio. Distil-Whisper is designed to be paired with Whisper for
speculative decoding, yielding a 2 times speed-up while mathematically ensuring
the same outputs as the original model. To facilitate further research in this
domain, we make our training code, inference code and models publicly
accessible.
|
[
-0.178174749,
-0.5605250001,
0.4386886656,
0.1146337762,
-0.4089556336,
0.1781788617,
-0.2241983265,
-0.5412580371,
0.0118561266,
0.0466187969,
-0.4182058275,
-0.3187952042,
-0.8344441056,
-0.0866319016,
-0.5170499086,
1.0281156301,
0.3885110915,
-0.0331764556,
0.1466902345,
-0.0548267961,
-0.1642865092,
-0.7091025114,
-0.4219045341,
-0.2976732552,
0.3408868015,
0.0272480771,
0.451967597,
0.495760113,
0.1392741054,
0.3503811061,
-0.4802317917,
0.001054081,
-0.7778013945,
0.0097092343,
0.0821793526,
-0.4707137942,
-0.4794052243,
0.215282768,
0.3983311951,
0.5710389018,
-0.5885922909,
0.3951408863,
0.2187184989,
0.5206486583,
-0.6815909147,
0.3045837283,
-0.9978398681,
-0.243417576,
-0.3212311268,
0.2317240089,
-0.3497090638,
-0.3553917706,
0.7916796803,
-0.6940527558,
0.2504300773,
0.1724479645,
0.6144533157,
0.5219102502,
0.0713100582,
-0.295148015,
-1.0950154066,
0.874858737,
-0.7920057178,
0.4286349416,
0.6566483378,
0.6155441999,
0.0343211889,
-1.2161436081,
-0.5931024551,
-0.125470832,
0.1646672785,
0.0175445843,
-0.5316007137,
-0.0002708569,
0.2988638282,
0.4147073627,
-0.3303120732,
-0.0928505212,
-0.4696498513,
-0.4260755181,
0.3984004557,
-0.1798463762,
-0.260081917,
0.3433403373,
-0.243642211,
-0.0752193853,
-0.3430716693,
-0.0759218484,
0.2488180846,
0.3793699145,
-0.0455484428,
0.3468033373,
-0.1050908193,
0.9430246949,
0.3269533217,
-0.7384919524,
0.338249892,
-0.2288731337,
-0.1325648129,
0.7912343144,
0.8374843001,
0.2526627183,
-0.0162151493,
0.0080843791,
-0.2655695081,
0.0420941226,
0.0559631027,
-0.9065941572,
-0.7379852533,
0.111318171,
-0.5456854105,
-0.3345430791,
-0.3461721539,
-0.5149884224,
-0.3922536671,
-0.352065444,
0.8529515862,
-0.3885138035,
-0.3969955444,
0.2173631638,
-0.5544821024,
-0.1910030842,
0.1047176793,
-0.8133054972,
0.1904679835,
0.3388911188,
1.0944519043,
0.16754134,
-0.0674551427,
-0.6782191396,
0.3107946217,
-0.13303563,
0.4678893685,
-0.1945782453,
-0.7410869598,
-0.5398385525,
-0.3950815499,
0.2023408264,
-0.821277082,
0.4575859308,
-0.2669894695,
-0.0217970442,
-0.2244918197,
-0.6774103045,
0.0040908339,
-0.089561902,
-0.591283679,
0.8341219425,
-0.0064605218,
-1.038675189,
0.4691284299,
-0.4182636738,
-0.2954857051,
0.0102244765,
0.1461930573,
-0.6141691804,
0.2966177166,
0.2122019082,
0.3136044145,
-0.293297708,
0.184657678,
-0.3858520389,
-0.377336055,
0.1439076215,
-0.8370141387,
0.7221614718,
0.3540896475,
-0.3752354085,
-0.1725564003,
-0.953187108,
-0.1338277906,
0.0169783216,
-0.2038979083,
-0.6462181211,
-0.0107295047,
-0.1617927402,
-0.1626114845,
0.3641576767,
-0.6058123112,
0.0714573786,
-0.314350158,
0.7957218885,
0.5225540996,
-0.1277580559,
0.3842149675,
-0.3312840462,
0.0614850298,
0.0408088304,
0.4511084855,
0.056239225,
-0.553239584,
-0.5983381271,
-0.8225957155,
0.5398980975,
0.5213588476,
-0.7426361442,
0.4918344021,
-0.1367805302,
-0.9302472472,
-0.9973648787,
0.0540228561,
0.4007166624,
1.0969690084,
0.4712173939,
0.3164516091,
-0.5630533695,
-0.770416975,
0.06998083,
-0.5326399803,
-0.2071155757,
0.119281128,
0.1914747655,
-0.0600768737,
1.0729944706,
-0.9005307555,
-0.417401731,
-0.1678589284,
0.4883771837,
0.3554900587,
0.1871103793,
0.6120306253,
-0.7747658491,
-0.5085411668,
-0.2493121326,
-0.476785779,
-0.1832402647,
0.2841883302,
0.1237530038,
-0.1763460338,
0.4415834248,
-0.311601758,
0.4268924892,
0.7212856412,
0.2016276717,
0.6555126905,
-0.331615597,
-0.0254674796,
-1.1580786705,
-0.0473687388,
-0.0111712338,
-0.1964884251,
-0.6395863891,
-0.6788882017,
-0.0879493654,
-0.1131571978,
-0.6006835103,
0.0971764326,
-0.3900794983,
0.2742259502,
-0.2601692975,
-0.1189577058,
0.1085672155,
0.1305450201,
0.4305044413,
0.9186832309,
0.7776590586,
-0.5639631152,
0.5563076735,
0.1798650175,
-0.435736388,
0.5598782897,
-0.9946617484,
0.256326884,
0.082175903,
0.3197000027,
-0.8574765921,
0.047191795,
-0.2166472673,
-0.3376638293,
0.3724179864,
-0.5637100935,
-0.3805826008,
-0.5272815824,
-0.0174664799,
0.2548867166,
0.9207455516,
-0.7639756203,
0.5201087594,
0.5680552125,
-0.1286334991,
-0.4026581347,
-0.7059000134,
-0.0639944971,
-0.5654781461,
-0.3415979743,
0.2019503713,
-0.109027572,
-0.3886102438,
-0.117843248,
-0.3486125469,
-0.4370371103,
-0.107944712,
0.3505577445,
0.3970825076,
-0.1113554686,
0.0257387143,
0.0483033732,
-0.2823643982,
-0.1375233084,
-0.7136579156,
0.1599842161,
-0.0687310174,
-0.1712086648,
-0.6531386971,
0.1779115349,
0.5704722404,
-0.0368859023,
0.8621448874,
0.4687784314,
-0.2667174637,
-0.4658437073,
-0.5782034993,
-0.2919456959,
-0.5715660453,
0.1307157874,
-0.42114833,
-0.6852868795,
0.2969301343,
-0.3676187396,
-0.0199200194,
0.1880577654,
0.3904294372,
-0.4450494349,
0.6577757597,
0.5867540836,
-0.5257694721,
0.2115538418,
-0.2997481525,
0.2595368624,
-0.4470694065,
-0.3363727033,
-0.7284549475,
-0.2481185347,
-0.1924321353,
-0.3249984682,
0.5939325094,
0.2922937572,
0.306129247,
0.4244555831,
-0.7842962742,
0.4204841554,
0.7656065822,
0.0619825944,
0.4192377031,
-0.0556375422,
-0.0011159459,
-0.1467514932,
-0.7185238004,
-0.2365697622,
1.0034365654,
0.3393951654,
1.0143092871,
-0.101654686,
0.7637728453,
0.3253450394,
-0.006052705,
-0.7701590657,
0.1831441075,
-0.2002326399,
-0.7341086268,
-0.4303293228,
-0.4590736032,
-0.6072812676,
0.0403033495,
-0.2131493986,
-0.5378796458,
0.1303717345,
0.5697157979,
-0.5331431627,
0.4027485847,
-1.0310764313,
0.4075407088,
-0.0240264889,
0.0267177168,
0.0329382457,
-0.6210830212,
0.4105653763,
-0.471939832,
0.2037848532,
0.0954993665,
0.3294069171,
0.8018283844,
-0.8309775591,
0.8354796171,
-0.4512914121,
-0.275547564,
0.657997191,
-0.1098315492,
0.568348527,
-0.1153577641,
-0.0357355326,
0.5603080392,
0.2296319753,
0.0406750552,
-0.5324721336,
0.4756961465,
-0.7962411046,
-0.3706505597,
-0.3357463777,
-0.2303789407,
-0.3572956622,
-0.0176534802,
0.7851196527,
0.6686427593,
-0.1123034656,
0.1330685467,
1.0563061237,
-0.0250606257,
0.3933807909,
0.6417111754,
-0.051142469,
-0.3608939052,
1.0239906311,
0.4345887005,
0.3641091585,
0.2265712619,
0.4557103217,
-0.8711214662,
-0.8893369436,
-0.2344773561,
-0.0261377133,
-0.2838163972,
-0.1382066011,
-0.5449460745,
-0.5351300836,
-0.4094072878,
0.164570868,
-0.7731788158,
-0.3934004009,
-0.4908544421,
-0.0819118246,
0.7440171242,
0.5650141835,
-0.3346546292,
0.5359283686,
-0.945543766,
0.7276332974,
0.7025094032,
0.1316702515,
-0.0688227266,
-0.8011654615,
-0.1694051772,
0.3213922083,
0.0400468446,
-0.6790326834,
0.1823853999,
0.5735074282,
0.516485095,
0.4870986938,
0.6774893403,
0.9365642071,
-0.7323898077,
0.7483344674,
0.5543184876,
-1.0358483791,
0.7408380508,
-0.2556475401,
0.2830635011,
0.696838975,
0.4647345245,
-0.0742099732,
-0.4003554285,
-0.3263636827,
-0.6925362349,
0.5031651855,
0.3325051665,
-0.2170056552,
0.262336731,
0.1337070018,
0.3033416271,
0.2313539088,
-0.1999111921,
-0.424158901,
-0.5618421435,
-0.2007923871,
-0.4047114253,
-0.3837844133,
-0.2060996741,
-0.4404556751,
0.6339091063,
0.1336986274,
-0.1113456339,
0.2599698305,
-0.0957783237,
0.3746310472,
0.0673782527,
0.3943961859,
0.3438591957,
-0.3603577316,
0.2993769646,
0.1822376698,
-0.8842587471,
0.3874548972,
0.2863847613,
-0.0838460699,
0.1674943417,
0.3732839227,
1.0005847216,
0.015006287,
-0.4203667641,
0.4241524637,
-0.3235644698,
-0.4620074928,
-0.2505273521,
0.1069060192,
0.3727987707,
0.3447980881,
0.4883603752,
0.028391555,
0.4359490275,
-0.3791664541,
0.2430219054,
0.1418051422,
-0.3230194151,
-0.3889629543,
0.7778007984,
0.2717598975,
-0.1487581432,
0.7401670218,
-0.2375095189,
-0.3243211806,
0.0798135847,
0.3379144967,
0.8240814209,
-0.4639008641,
0.1430710107,
0.2178018689,
0.1192571595,
-0.3558931649,
0.0426753722,
-0.3440018892,
-0.3073627353,
-0.4461269677,
-0.9250508547,
-0.3339974284,
0.3340919614,
-0.8143416643,
0.023212295,
-0.3900221884,
-0.6257597804,
0.150247857,
-0.2073448151,
-0.2593072057,
0.0677398592,
0.2202792466,
0.8950810432,
-0.8405237198,
1.1651650667,
0.1130179018,
0.0693917647,
-0.9890833497,
-0.0800598264,
0.2828878164,
-0.5241100788,
0.5320805907,
-0.1087036729,
-0.4591875672,
0.0910045058,
-0.4464614391,
-0.6783801913,
1.121508956,
0.5833203197,
-1.3226777315,
-0.0011449337,
0.0426512063,
0.5420410037,
0.140641287,
-0.0909529775,
0.6601452827,
0.3396717608,
0.5751461387,
-1.5248981714,
-0.508618772,
0.0090552298,
-0.0673649758,
-0.0019782418,
-0.4628183544,
0.5412052274,
-0.2577587962,
-0.0195806362,
0.0219004508,
0.6358886957,
0.3488083184,
0.5275787115,
0.6706149578,
0.6646743417,
1.0489457846,
-0.1925182343,
0.5640816689,
-0.0267501827,
0.0436951555,
1.5417124033,
-0.4004100561,
0.9374750853,
0.388843447,
-0.3526028991,
0.1357415318,
0.3489337265,
0.1960810423,
1.147043705,
0.2201935947,
-0.5324172378,
-0.0646112859,
-0.1266555339,
-0.5869650841,
0.7044974566,
0.3351758718,
-0.07946942,
-0.0803696513,
0.1581135839,
-0.2042806596,
-0.068260543,
-0.2677479386,
1.0648232698,
0.2930859923,
-0.1436676085,
0.8380457759,
-0.46586743,
0.9187343717,
-0.8839232922,
0.0083962781,
0.1732556522,
0.2217597067,
-0.0678457171,
-0.4067483544,
0.4287844598,
0.0482303016,
-0.4119338989,
-0.1980976462,
0.7898883224,
-0.4834776223,
-0.5047248006,
0.3007459641,
0.3042501211,
0.2074955106,
-0.3063475788,
-0.5165400505,
0.3441757262,
0.0101760738,
0.0239429381,
0.3128261864,
0.5522221923,
0.3279311061,
0.6032988429,
0.8023714423,
0.4089623392,
0.2950056791,
0.0743487179,
0.9012966156,
-0.1571165174,
-0.70992589,
-0.8531733751,
0.430777669,
-0.182278499,
-0.0811270624,
0.7470926642,
0.517647624,
0.4305377007,
-0.0374528877,
0.8500645757,
0.2095209062,
0.7519091964,
-0.4021855891,
1.1890193224,
-0.285725832,
0.2030677795,
-0.3330382705,
-0.8246507645,
0.2393844873,
0.5817580819,
-0.0239992123,
-0.2855681777,
0.2466278672,
0.6051314473,
-0.0653924271,
0.1996831596,
0.5287287235,
0.4362670183,
0.1498929411,
0.4733321369,
0.9294190407,
-0.2139807194,
0.7112525702,
-0.4426691532,
-0.4280097187,
0.0860682353,
-0.984110117,
-1.0092560053,
-0.8009771109,
-0.5281122923,
-0.2527939975,
0.0380991511,
0.4949381649,
1.2631596327,
-0.5267416239,
-0.0267349295,
0.1384267658,
-0.2588457167,
-0.1535016149,
-0.1324782521,
0.2622276545,
0.1689103693,
-0.5620923042,
0.6470900774,
0.1663289219,
0.4309642315,
-0.0977474377,
-0.0925597623,
0.2358219475,
0.0542889722,
0.5012483001,
0.1779387146,
-0.4651354551,
0.0536130331,
-0.264503479,
0.3232236803,
-0.1824829429,
0.5588499904,
-0.9060233235,
0.661882937,
0.2317038327,
0.1709948629,
0.8457464576,
-0.1209834069,
0.4520030022,
-0.8026854396,
0.4980466962,
0.242865026,
0.2493655533,
0.2168033123,
-0.1394642889,
0.0304967389,
0.2702886164,
-0.419572413,
-1.0432835817,
0.0388474651,
-0.9244506955,
-0.3256041706,
0.9762984514,
-0.373513341,
-0.2347578406,
-0.2559182048,
-0.3430266082,
0.3413562477,
-0.5569906235,
0.7992411852,
0.5671669841,
0.0666912645,
0.0680514798,
-0.1772485673,
0.7637913227,
-0.4222542644,
-0.4086177051,
0.1161756739,
0.5260608196,
0.5952714682,
0.3273858726,
0.6658435464,
-0.0159020983,
-0.1319936514,
0.4941341281,
-0.2620625496,
-0.3855367899,
-0.4758647382,
-0.153414771,
0.1578644663,
0.1677540541,
-0.5700978041
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00416v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00416v1
|
Efficient Human-AI Coordination via Preparatory Language-based Convention
| 2023-11-01T10:18:23 | 2023-11-01T10:18:23 |
Cong Guan, Lichao Zhang, Chunpeng Fan, Yichen Li, Feng Chen, Lihe Li, Yunjia Tian, Lei Yuan, Yang Yu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Developing intelligent agents capable of seamless coordination with humans is
a critical step towards achieving artificial general intelligence. Existing
methods for human-AI coordination typically train an agent to coordinate with a
diverse set of policies or with human models fitted from real human data.
However, the massively diverse styles of human behavior present obstacles for
AI systems with constrained capacity, while high quality human data may not be
readily available in real-world scenarios. In this study, we observe that prior
to coordination, humans engage in communication to establish conventions that
specify individual roles and actions, making their coordination proceed in an
orderly manner. Building upon this observation, we propose employing the large
language model (LLM) to develop an action plan (or equivalently, a convention)
that effectively guides both human and AI. By inputting task requirements,
human preferences, the number of agents, and other pertinent information into
the LLM, it can generate a comprehensive convention that facilitates a clear
understanding of tasks and responsibilities for all parties involved.
Furthermore, we demonstrate that decomposing the convention formulation problem
into sub-problems with multiple new sessions being sequentially employed and
human feedback, will yield a more efficient coordination convention.
Experimental evaluations conducted in the Overcooked-AI environment, utilizing
a human proxy model, highlight the superior performance of our proposed method
compared to existing learning-based approaches. When coordinating with real
humans, our method achieves better alignment with human preferences and an
average performance improvement of 15% compared to the state-of-the-art.
|
[
-0.37686041,
-0.5524356365,
0.4757899046,
0.1653529257,
-0.1425519139,
-0.1737140566,
-0.7228291631,
-0.4280763268,
0.4010039568,
0.4545138776,
-0.3549625874,
-0.4827028513,
-0.2044529468,
-0.002824272,
-0.170796603,
0.6347324252,
0.0092782425,
-0.0003492847,
-0.2481475621,
-0.0787312016,
-0.4237610102,
-0.5871779323,
-0.7765130997,
-0.9713873267,
0.5375495553,
0.5152308345,
0.8472875357,
1.0168726444,
0.5732127428,
0.4352920055,
0.3006748557,
0.4940184653,
-0.3243737519,
-0.1402128935,
-0.5397433043,
-0.4715130329,
-0.8500778675,
0.2249049395,
0.2962459922,
0.653680861,
-0.7968863249,
-0.1014139503,
-0.0176008213,
0.5275017023,
-0.5432313085,
0.6023786068,
-0.5027616024,
-0.0468590893,
-0.1707633734,
-0.1614533365,
-0.3611412346,
0.2876865268,
0.025773745,
-0.9537047148,
-0.1866910756,
-0.0722576231,
0.6816094518,
0.3039120734,
-0.1883652955,
-0.2089219838,
-1.0803112984,
0.4608388245,
-0.4703172147,
0.2922235131,
0.6791272163,
0.3346302509,
-0.5858364701,
-0.8164462447,
-1.0504109859,
-0.297647804,
0.0331859924,
0.2066817284,
0.0836519003,
0.3387305737,
0.1505817175,
-0.5215424895,
-0.3546031415,
0.1908393055,
-0.0808600709,
0.1707360893,
0.8520213962,
0.313996464,
0.2567576468,
0.3695616424,
-0.2407149523,
-0.1728512496,
-0.5047333837,
-0.0706808046,
0.2121436596,
0.4279969931,
-0.3831095099,
0.4871724844,
-0.4449674785,
0.4227314591,
0.2113113701,
-0.023212675,
-0.2628408968,
-0.4733966589,
-0.1584464461,
-0.1341990381,
0.7346363068,
0.6328753829,
0.6351155043,
-0.368372798,
-0.1484964788,
0.3237069845,
0.7584890723,
-0.6447448134,
-0.2096678615,
0.0920303911,
-0.3369919956,
-0.0346094519,
0.0044022826,
-0.529841423,
-0.364166826,
-0.9085580707,
0.2544397712,
-0.1010558531,
-0.1380778402,
0.1135133132,
0.1467477828,
0.6609905362,
0.4789365232,
-1.0451133251,
0.5812871456,
0.9435023069,
0.5612747073,
-0.0700419173,
-0.4797703028,
-0.514855504,
0.4958926737,
-0.6358103156,
0.6133238077,
-0.4734051228,
-0.2792128623,
-0.1027742326,
-0.212504968,
-0.1792190224,
-0.397436142,
0.4582026899,
-0.4040862322,
-0.1381475031,
-0.1549163163,
-0.4149456918,
0.0193057749,
0.4909459949,
-0.6264699101,
0.0453624092,
-0.3180554807,
-0.3108869791,
0.4033246636,
-0.8227782845,
-0.7068449259,
0.1122153476,
-0.6340153813,
-0.0859169811,
-0.4038770497,
0.0929722413,
0.5135940313,
-0.4574973285,
0.448205322,
0.041199252,
-0.5290585756,
0.0748003572,
-0.0438122787,
0.4807816744,
0.1882751882,
-0.2991296053,
0.436845541,
-0.451837182,
-0.0110240495,
-0.0499563217,
-0.5699325204,
0.0293366965,
0.4587470889,
-0.3270047009,
0.2419051826,
0.1326479316,
0.0229422208,
0.6020528674,
-0.1593237668,
0.5161256194,
0.640948236,
-0.3548518419,
1.0138144493,
-0.6397001743,
0.3015024066,
-0.3156936765,
0.1718408316,
0.1682963669,
-0.5107882023,
-0.6293665171,
-0.0788609609,
-0.0226264112,
0.7723189592,
-0.7933301926,
1.0001524687,
-0.4060896635,
-0.4447228014,
-0.3166602552,
0.0813492537,
0.3971494436,
0.4972603619,
0.3708583117,
-0.3609797657,
-0.398254931,
-0.5044441223,
0.1300849766,
-0.4952386916,
0.0989217833,
0.04757379,
0.3407014608,
-0.330914855,
0.8936430812,
-0.0474448502,
-0.4394064546,
-0.5666868687,
0.2715396583,
-0.1273394525,
0.7478863597,
0.1975897551,
-0.8417955637,
-0.3830031157,
0.3383452892,
-0.6586394906,
0.3023214042,
-0.3463837504,
-0.6393354535,
0.4860337675,
0.6451869011,
-0.9459787011,
0.5506116748,
0.227062121,
-0.1015033796,
0.4875648916,
-0.251660496,
0.0936168656,
-1.198368907,
0.3756394982,
-0.2197687477,
-0.0393657051,
-0.9311316013,
0.1695793867,
-0.192500487,
0.0323204584,
-0.2499745786,
0.7449456453,
-0.1049583927,
0.274533689,
-0.1919268221,
-0.0459578037,
-0.2341297418,
0.8830592036,
0.3890870214,
0.5216636658,
0.3213061988,
-0.7002777457,
0.4554054141,
0.3803217709,
0.1355621666,
0.8218787313,
-0.6866290569,
0.2403571606,
-0.1834577173,
0.6082063317,
-0.6397773623,
-0.5295439363,
0.5331805348,
-0.4312437177,
0.3933499157,
-0.1954643726,
-0.3457042873,
-0.1285278648,
-0.1400610358,
0.3239110708,
0.5707829595,
-0.2742415667,
0.9643685818,
0.3010799587,
0.1493543684,
-0.5382657647,
-0.6179090142,
0.3300380409,
-0.1505891532,
-0.81013304,
0.4882056117,
-0.1673343182,
-0.5461555719,
-0.2725250423,
0.0574043058,
-0.1867295802,
-0.0430517942,
0.2362028956,
0.0852568373,
0.220843628,
-0.0720571131,
-0.3623932898,
-0.0824373886,
-0.1187752187,
-0.2469656467,
0.7760626078,
0.2892435491,
-0.3402458727,
-1.0721052885,
0.5086799264,
0.7988992333,
-0.1834531873,
0.786075294,
0.3623780608,
-0.3513362408,
-0.1338441521,
-0.5169350505,
-0.4105268121,
-0.4403058887,
0.1116348431,
-0.2323909253,
-0.0595603399,
0.6878796816,
-0.0638469383,
0.364023447,
-0.1588672101,
0.5015638471,
-0.120751217,
1.1193585396,
0.5756326318,
-0.2333216965,
0.6175717711,
-0.2458905131,
-0.028157847,
-0.4062919915,
-0.3992331922,
-0.6074793339,
-0.5107582808,
-0.5236748457,
-0.6150014997,
0.2419393212,
-0.1091199443,
-0.4967481494,
0.3584087789,
-0.0805988684,
0.3942966163,
0.7412999272,
0.0800892934,
0.1268960983,
0.0022556318,
-0.0358969159,
0.3120279908,
-0.6160430312,
-0.5707769394,
0.8336599469,
0.006500124,
0.8845794797,
-0.0271199662,
0.890397191,
0.2729432285,
0.1121777371,
-0.7498483062,
0.6799855232,
-0.1404748559,
-0.080649808,
-0.5053247809,
-0.3639056981,
-1.1700670719,
0.0904392153,
-0.3930805624,
-0.6497663856,
-0.0226564743,
0.2263508439,
-0.3428097069,
0.065972127,
-0.7738295197,
0.8455170393,
-0.0852182657,
-0.3324410319,
-0.5627677441,
-1.0298492908,
0.0740072429,
0.2429474443,
0.1080526635,
0.0136815524,
-0.1677414626,
0.6843926311,
-0.4838384688,
0.9646163583,
0.0714117661,
0.0181927402,
0.2575535178,
-0.1092912406,
0.953306973,
-0.1525983661,
-0.2622131407,
-0.0085073691,
-0.5395930409,
-0.3954208493,
-0.7041615844,
0.3511178792,
-0.9937080145,
-0.5339420438,
-0.1307929605,
-0.4984854162,
0.0469829701,
0.2626545727,
0.0031971505,
0.333992064,
-0.2968015671,
-0.1253504902,
0.1030402556,
0.0781403035,
0.4722710848,
0.7017387152,
0.3256507218,
-0.1923001111,
0.6917389035,
0.011537781,
0.2880089283,
0.3403117657,
0.0808961466,
-0.2539696693,
-0.3985424936,
-0.40604949,
0.2392357886,
-0.3785828948,
-0.093221508,
-0.414462477,
-0.171727404,
-0.5297073126,
-0.5151599646,
-0.2662766278,
-0.0582891367,
-0.1380619556,
0.3897282481,
-0.1255031824,
0.5992261171,
-0.084690623,
0.3889240324,
-0.5695505738,
0.558855176,
0.3925662935,
0.1422676295,
0.0284545626,
-0.0401096866,
-0.1492051631,
0.2413400412,
-0.3009739816,
-0.4402953386,
0.1940060854,
0.2167928517,
0.7046285868,
0.5495250225,
0.2974466681,
0.9209449291,
-0.6258795857,
0.4398983419,
0.0153203784,
-0.7506799698,
0.3369889557,
-0.3500593305,
0.1400348991,
0.4364037514,
0.2723776996,
-0.6096345186,
-0.3745131493,
-0.5360022187,
-0.9249036908,
0.822302103,
0.3145163953,
0.0600124449,
-0.1627860814,
0.3856204152,
-0.4884720147,
0.2142680734,
-0.2950797677,
0.1264137477,
0.2063442916,
0.0265228152,
0.0395686254,
0.3411604166,
-0.5305674076,
-0.3401525617,
0.4080855548,
-0.2286213785,
0.2062232047,
0.0142386844,
0.1751295179,
-0.2702321112,
0.1727022827,
0.8050902486,
0.8064653873,
0.204709813,
0.0813250765,
0.0498947538,
-0.4349229336,
0.0982707515,
0.0820332617,
-0.0008845419,
-0.7198126912,
0.6879566908,
0.1807606518,
-0.1622581333,
-0.626914382,
0.3496913314,
-0.2844798267,
-0.0691997334,
-0.3237453997,
0.3432022631,
0.276850909,
0.4822211564,
0.0792240575,
0.0897062272,
-0.1884050965,
-0.7967402339,
0.3596118689,
0.5146095753,
0.1071640179,
-0.2776306868,
0.4295218587,
0.5964604616,
-0.4993801713,
0.9865643978,
-0.6082215309,
-0.3729916215,
0.8729178905,
0.3712788224,
0.6487473845,
-0.3197113872,
0.1763612777,
0.2261452973,
0.1553448439,
-0.4782649279,
0.4650723934,
-0.1827576905,
-0.9284446239,
-0.5442720652,
-0.370446682,
-0.3047108054,
-0.1568594873,
-0.4204899967,
0.4364394546,
-0.5353799462,
-0.0270361919,
-0.1491030455,
0.1109966412,
-0.5904771686,
-0.219259426,
0.2268555015,
0.683386445,
-0.5434762836,
1.0430554152,
0.9204705954,
-0.4459050596,
-1.1524935961,
0.2421479374,
-0.0568331666,
-0.7545115352,
0.3571976721,
0.0255047251,
-0.0627147704,
-0.0871509537,
-0.6920980811,
-0.3844028115,
1.1802157164,
0.2924817204,
-0.6421480179,
-0.3273417354,
0.0296578072,
0.7017523646,
-0.3568250537,
0.0540443286,
0.7910296917,
0.6632772684,
0.4466146529,
-1.1682403088,
0.1423800737,
-0.1684221178,
-0.2312150896,
0.2511692345,
-0.6527698636,
0.7413429022,
-0.3129135966,
-0.4070069194,
0.3355715275,
0.7172389627,
0.1079737991,
0.2525723577,
0.5364955068,
0.46604532,
0.6953699589,
0.1641287357,
0.7432959676,
-0.3075955808,
-0.1346014589,
1.2115556002,
-0.7816854119,
0.858189106,
0.3040430248,
0.0341729671,
0.3521168232,
0.0487305149,
0.251716435,
0.1974819005,
0.3352448344,
-0.2453444004,
-0.415004909,
-0.4796023071,
0.03432028,
0.8186229467,
0.5299947858,
0.1727860123,
-0.290271163,
-0.2231685966,
0.1635054052,
0.4122499228,
-0.3009793162,
1.1412278414,
-0.2025245279,
-1.2683728933,
0.6076439023,
-0.0360191651,
0.4974731207,
-0.5813860893,
-0.3838064671,
-0.1090841293,
0.2981024384,
-0.0951270014,
-0.6744862795,
0.1285436898,
-0.2308548838,
-0.0629643053,
0.0297957398,
0.2505902648,
-0.8831970692,
0.0039704423,
0.2757321894,
0.2626610696,
0.048286669,
-0.0186514352,
-0.5066846013,
-0.0752339438,
-0.5165108442,
0.1748304516,
0.2034015507,
0.262706697,
-0.6258407831,
0.743770957,
0.5112540722,
0.2522915304,
-0.2148152888,
0.1252899915,
0.8426892757,
-0.4470674992,
-0.7987954617,
-0.7943040729,
0.4273701608,
-0.1129109487,
0.1949673444,
0.0392560922,
0.0794520453,
0.7606703639,
0.2484867424,
0.5897311568,
-0.3122525513,
-0.1549820155,
-0.4799931943,
0.7299377322,
-0.2782310247,
0.1205245331,
-0.0070066005,
-0.6282913089,
-0.3279234171,
0.6577451229,
0.1119701415,
0.0923072845,
0.361083746,
0.8429675698,
-0.1318983883,
-0.2214352787,
0.3232533634,
-0.0415652059,
0.6827054024,
0.5449183583,
0.680173099,
0.2583761811,
0.5299848318,
-0.2043197006,
-0.3068853915,
-0.2589682341,
-0.7281900644,
-1.0811144114,
-0.6399870515,
0.0059525236,
-0.0047643669,
0.3259104192,
1.6747889519,
1.1392508745,
-0.5036133528,
-0.6328946948,
-0.265763402,
0.0380125791,
-0.4065468013,
-0.1262846738,
0.1837220937,
-0.5520240068,
-0.8053460717,
0.3632590175,
-0.108972162,
0.1465712935,
-0.1439501792,
-0.5840896964,
-0.4140000343,
0.2419700772,
0.4828357697,
0.5792869925,
-0.7099856734,
-0.164799273,
-0.2142467946,
-0.3348217607,
-0.2597987354,
1.0133737326,
-0.5463300943,
0.4553214908,
0.6049402356,
0.4806108177,
-0.0153151322,
0.4755727947,
0.9367436767,
-0.8270919919,
0.4277938902,
0.1951838583,
0.1732514501,
-0.0551467836,
-0.4747681916,
0.5622228384,
-0.1003005803,
-0.761957705,
-0.2138998061,
0.339877665,
-1.100228548,
-0.1410551965,
0.9958614707,
-0.2053498924,
-0.1118667722,
-0.3124524951,
-0.3472477496,
0.5131101012,
-0.8652672172,
0.8947336674,
0.5266533494,
-0.4147950113,
0.3445194066,
-0.2455816418,
0.6944173574,
0.2002363801,
-1.0181770325,
0.2493712753,
0.3291120231,
-0.2456432581,
0.3583116233,
0.8897283077,
0.2716459334,
0.5032576919,
-0.325861007,
0.2202441841,
0.1500831544,
-0.955395937,
0.0550552718,
-0.2207803279,
0.0244793985,
-0.2636012137
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00408v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00408v1
|
AdaSent: Efficient Domain-Adapted Sentence Embeddings for Few-Shot Classification
| 2023-11-01T10:00:15 | 2023-11-01T10:00:15 |
Yongxin Huang, Kexin Wang, Sourav Dutta, Raj Nath Patel, Goran Glavaš, Iryna Gurevych
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent work has found that few-shot sentence classification based on
pre-trained Sentence Encoders (SEs) is efficient, robust, and effective. In
this work, we investigate strategies for domain-specialization in the context
of few-shot sentence classification with SEs. We first establish that
unsupervised Domain-Adaptive Pre-Training (DAPT) of a base Pre-trained Language
Model (PLM) (i.e., not an SE) substantially improves the accuracy of few-shot
sentence classification by up to 8.4 points. However, applying DAPT on SEs, on
the one hand, disrupts the effects of their (general-domain) Sentence Embedding
Pre-Training (SEPT). On the other hand, applying general-domain SEPT on top of
a domain-adapted base PLM (i.e., after DAPT) is effective but inefficient,
since the computationally expensive SEPT needs to be executed on top of a
DAPT-ed PLM of each domain. As a solution, we propose AdaSent, which decouples
SEPT from DAPT by training a SEPT adapter on the base PLM. The adapter can be
inserted into DAPT-ed PLMs from any domain. We demonstrate AdaSent's
effectiveness in extensive experiments on 17 different few-shot sentence
classification datasets. AdaSent matches or surpasses the performance of full
SEPT on DAPT-ed PLM, while substantially reducing the training costs. The code
for AdaSent is available.
|
[
-0.2053418159,
-0.7632442713,
0.5143880844,
0.0899980292,
-0.4646337926,
-0.2033176571,
-0.282497555,
-0.0600412861,
-0.0546250939,
0.2373188883,
-0.3563139737,
-0.6086804271,
-0.6691080928,
0.3457647562,
-0.0423005112,
0.8534803391,
0.1069703326,
-0.1193784103,
-0.2248330712,
-0.1809807867,
-0.274249047,
-0.5771617889,
-0.3783845007,
0.1921666861,
0.0775223747,
0.4456011653,
0.3075235784,
0.519012928,
0.6222527027,
0.2304870337,
0.0439737365,
0.290499121,
-0.4774850905,
0.074324891,
0.1164752692,
-0.554230988,
-0.4705375135,
-0.2002970874,
0.596322298,
0.5202801228,
-0.0037724455,
-0.0543997921,
0.2838736176,
0.4450679123,
-0.8630074859,
0.0823121071,
-0.6788737178,
0.0627311096,
-0.3865577579,
-0.0849864855,
-0.4341847599,
-0.2047652751,
0.1895463318,
-0.6453614831,
0.1726024151,
-0.0100860531,
0.6017785668,
0.342433095,
-0.4721155763,
0.0954003558,
-0.4707602262,
0.7114005089,
-0.5823860765,
0.2482294887,
0.2894138396,
0.1745788753,
-0.0513053499,
-0.7333382368,
-0.4357850254,
0.1826616377,
-0.0577935688,
0.3270905018,
-0.3438638747,
0.1741538644,
0.2017683983,
0.1372427791,
-0.7711004615,
0.1563647091,
0.0038465848,
-0.0637937412,
0.3682749271,
0.2515151501,
0.251521796,
-0.0765287802,
-0.4810492992,
0.1103106439,
-0.8453927636,
-0.0513697192,
0.2995162606,
0.3940142393,
-0.0659553632,
0.4324134886,
0.0131251207,
0.8462995291,
0.1504395157,
0.1077877283,
0.2560979128,
-0.2910030186,
-0.2131588906,
-0.1435641795,
0.5858649015,
0.1996190101,
0.231900841,
0.019709697,
-0.1270242035,
0.2854181528,
0.3347093165,
-1.0407888889,
-0.5030913949,
-0.0752467141,
-0.4316796958,
-0.0831213817,
-0.0122443438,
-0.6426724792,
-0.2845695913,
0.0894924477,
0.5289085507,
-0.5111388564,
0.1608902812,
0.3179129362,
-0.0905560106,
0.1050592661,
0.3358975947,
-0.9459774494,
0.5188165307,
0.6929128766,
1.0640096664,
-0.5421411395,
-0.4037512839,
-0.731821835,
0.0177984238,
-0.1610411406,
1.0729805231,
-0.5505772829,
-0.2666075826,
0.1541536897,
-0.0887265429,
-0.5341498256,
-0.4183720946,
0.7263222337,
-0.6977459192,
0.0803588256,
0.0443218276,
-0.9929283261,
-0.1734512895,
0.3492700458,
-0.5369037986,
0.483022064,
0.0688659549,
-0.8816753626,
0.3782132566,
-1.0214095116,
-0.6085863113,
0.186591655,
-0.0726012364,
-0.6092049479,
0.2186011225,
0.3437107205,
0.4969373345,
0.1593518257,
-0.5176859498,
-0.2431961894,
-0.4034316838,
0.0444927216,
-0.4965274036,
0.726200223,
0.0954568014,
0.1012876406,
-0.2214855701,
-0.5699415207,
-0.1772463024,
0.1596508771,
-0.3747178912,
-0.5396414399,
-0.4033916295,
-0.0183403678,
-0.0541820526,
-0.0012967789,
-0.6317525506,
0.2525601089,
-0.8119621277,
0.2956328094,
0.6858839393,
0.292781502,
0.739322722,
-0.3310348094,
0.8207899332,
0.2664649189,
-0.0465487428,
-0.428611517,
-0.4387443662,
-0.7709944844,
-0.6460065842,
0.4692614973,
0.6644034982,
-0.6091758013,
0.6261060834,
-0.3372313082,
-0.1064695641,
-0.5645275116,
0.324482888,
0.0835606754,
0.3253356814,
0.439376235,
-0.3515461981,
-0.624440372,
-0.6312665939,
-0.3714374006,
-0.0625786483,
0.1941248029,
0.1487701684,
0.5835900903,
-0.1173308939,
1.145939827,
-0.8403435946,
-0.5457062125,
-0.383079052,
-0.0324393064,
0.0679075941,
0.2756749392,
0.883238852,
-0.6339563131,
-0.9935079217,
-0.2564121485,
-0.4422901869,
-0.0468760133,
-0.2139027119,
-0.0956022963,
-0.0213004425,
0.1880099624,
-0.7418196797,
0.4411282241,
0.3086890876,
-0.1352539808,
0.3629675508,
-0.1404857934,
0.0513843819,
-0.9396700859,
-0.2512741983,
-0.0618788153,
-0.5028940439,
-0.8053148389,
-0.1919568032,
0.0481278524,
0.0759472027,
-0.7087773681,
0.4338198602,
-0.3475984335,
0.217738241,
-0.4616169333,
0.1592370123,
0.1354163587,
0.47717309,
0.1125496551,
0.8540068865,
0.7666315436,
-0.7315552235,
0.2184198797,
0.8274877071,
-0.3522560894,
0.6608079076,
-0.4293929636,
0.3633962274,
-0.2030369788,
0.1990764588,
-0.8761310577,
0.1095437407,
0.2412650585,
-0.3313051462,
0.2122277468,
-0.4971955121,
-0.3321267962,
-0.1905077547,
-0.6448096633,
0.2390382588,
0.5710218549,
-0.7154819369,
0.3416272402,
0.3588104844,
-0.3479078114,
-0.2468851507,
-0.9440969229,
-0.02710527,
-0.3613004684,
-0.4616902471,
0.4213199019,
-0.1354634762,
0.0063898372,
0.1799973547,
-0.1392788738,
-0.2350861281,
0.1699828058,
-0.0500063188,
0.1289456338,
-0.418123275,
0.1202034578,
0.3378780186,
-0.2761853039,
-0.3664132953,
-0.4469775558,
0.3319020271,
-0.2530739903,
-0.3423386514,
-0.3455554247,
0.307439059,
0.0721469969,
0.0126164341,
0.6487818956,
0.4988467693,
-0.2217044383,
-0.4194561541,
-0.2296832353,
-0.192468822,
-0.4368366599,
0.3393310905,
-0.6825772524,
-1.1086540222,
0.1183377057,
-0.3022140861,
0.1605926901,
0.3920941353,
0.4304065108,
-0.13658306,
0.7217559814,
0.7433097363,
0.0401895009,
0.5651003718,
-0.3630168438,
0.13070333,
-0.8049776554,
0.4495716393,
-0.3220365644,
-0.1630379558,
-0.299335748,
-0.3717404902,
0.3334882557,
-0.0004880421,
-0.153258428,
0.5993089676,
-0.1771204025,
0.7736068368,
0.406955272,
0.0377613865,
0.2942100465,
0.1009908542,
0.0200150032,
-0.2140110433,
-1.0023061037,
-0.5143057704,
1.2373001575,
0.2061985284,
0.8704212904,
0.2293360233,
0.9877122641,
0.3964674175,
-0.0896604657,
-0.9974838495,
0.4189697504,
-0.7380159497,
-0.2927912772,
-0.1230743751,
-0.269436419,
-0.9876179099,
0.5002171993,
-0.0683878809,
-0.4379718006,
0.4741383791,
0.0475399755,
-0.9535583258,
0.0259441864,
-0.8860259652,
1.0127943754,
-0.116280131,
-0.1426209807,
-0.1490647495,
-0.553992033,
0.0078266487,
-0.1808957905,
-0.1190288216,
0.0168315656,
-0.2732105553,
0.8980250359,
-0.3314788342,
0.9994276762,
-0.2559661865,
0.2648780346,
0.4659822881,
0.074309364,
0.4943029284,
0.0353276059,
0.0428571664,
0.0945861712,
-0.0391154289,
-0.3440745175,
-0.6628646851,
0.5921183228,
-0.7276444435,
-0.5971169472,
-0.4214041829,
-0.2315027416,
-0.4416644275,
0.2448842973,
0.3015953898,
0.3198455274,
-0.5870116949,
0.166070804,
0.597284615,
0.059402924,
0.5011154413,
0.4675748944,
0.3018838763,
-0.4622638822,
0.5597851872,
-0.0631520525,
0.1155525967,
0.4844350517,
0.1156740636,
-0.262776047,
-0.6684835553,
-0.3102619946,
0.0631572157,
-0.8756608963,
-0.5517550111,
-0.86362499,
-0.0813543722,
-0.6594595313,
-0.278668195,
-0.2597807348,
-0.5733272433,
-0.510761857,
-0.2249181718,
0.4060355723,
0.3483661711,
-0.11540851,
0.7504851222,
-0.9674755931,
0.4797207415,
0.4875001311,
0.2200352252,
-0.3963581026,
-0.9895694256,
-0.3665967882,
-0.128209874,
-0.2392889559,
-0.6800288558,
0.3242675662,
0.7164077163,
0.6326755285,
0.5352726579,
0.2400517166,
0.6377625465,
-0.7881153822,
0.7334299088,
0.1234687418,
-0.8531836271,
0.5979377031,
-0.0566479973,
0.4028058946,
0.9253905416,
0.4172599614,
-0.2916624844,
-0.033091519,
-0.4196143746,
-0.5681726336,
0.9839683175,
0.2681953609,
0.5175250769,
-0.0793080851,
0.1811713129,
0.401068449,
0.0457946323,
-0.4913876355,
-0.1777446419,
-0.3026565909,
-0.3910736442,
0.0354133211,
-0.3560599089,
-0.1587905139,
-0.1594771445,
0.5521708131,
-0.293589294,
0.2867244482,
0.058103174,
-0.8107890487,
0.1873259395,
0.4549362659,
0.3333310783,
0.1642730981,
-0.0873099789,
0.2773078978,
0.2587888837,
-0.5863551497,
0.2283747643,
0.1880731434,
-0.3285527527,
0.0427823067,
0.4363878965,
1.0304236412,
-0.0338453986,
-0.3916797042,
1.0257371664,
-0.0686624125,
-0.0668674558,
0.0272922516,
-0.0125566581,
-0.2625829279,
0.208151266,
0.0120821781,
0.3064010441,
0.2906110585,
-0.2262870818,
0.4856863916,
0.1371147335,
-0.0911879912,
-0.5034326315,
0.4350944757,
0.5596374273,
-0.1129310802,
0.3498962522,
-0.4455650449,
-0.7534866929,
0.2620428205,
0.718700707,
1.2790263891,
-0.1757490784,
0.2811035514,
0.1039631516,
0.2275432944,
-0.0938820839,
0.0084111011,
-0.016108498,
-1.0824564695,
-0.342281431,
-0.4386728108,
-0.2619560361,
-0.2000070214,
-0.2788991034,
0.3668203652,
-0.4850986004,
-0.2869003713,
-0.1779290289,
-0.1217053458,
-0.8310180902,
-0.1829000413,
0.3043456376,
0.8247138262,
-1.1782816648,
0.7065127492,
1.0879291296,
-0.3626895249,
0.061546471,
0.4080567062,
0.0319640264,
-0.6437016129,
0.5513973832,
0.1319289058,
-0.1354882866,
0.3749816418,
-0.2911273539,
-0.4689981639,
0.82247895,
0.374335736,
-0.473875165,
0.2379712909,
0.042031873,
0.5358816385,
-0.5909757614,
0.0072399606,
0.6648536325,
0.258464545,
-0.2410354614,
-0.6843854785,
-0.1175758168,
-0.1146181598,
0.1342489123,
-0.152478233,
-0.5452433228,
0.5707271099,
-0.261179328,
-0.3164561093,
-0.0291793011,
0.7131168842,
-0.0140919127,
0.1646306515,
0.7218295932,
0.6353783011,
0.637142837,
0.1604313701,
0.8332020044,
-0.0227893256,
0.2979658544,
1.0847028494,
-0.4199838042,
0.7985215783,
0.2174460739,
-0.3497786224,
0.5403795242,
0.4188263714,
-0.0862551406,
1.0010451078,
-0.0998539403,
-0.4581305087,
-0.4607065022,
0.1258807331,
-0.0638277978,
0.5384073257,
0.312944442,
0.0824849233,
-0.3146710098,
0.4654818773,
-0.1474514604,
0.1945347488,
-0.0088418741,
1.1646260023,
0.3148727417,
-0.1939640641,
0.4133320451,
0.0729700029,
0.8900321126,
-0.5240624547,
0.1526619941,
-0.2892615497,
0.3166835606,
-0.1635433286,
-0.6410157084,
0.2343977541,
0.270852834,
-0.0137210218,
-0.2280670851,
1.0342466831,
-0.4456407726,
-0.2220611125,
-0.0814085826,
0.6804612279,
-0.0498176403,
-0.2347082794,
-0.7406264544,
-0.1118241027,
-0.2616745532,
-0.2773078978,
0.3756046593,
0.3916392326,
0.2640271783,
0.2749955952,
0.3720686436,
0.1066596285,
0.057685893,
0.2444578111,
0.8194882274,
-0.4802153111,
-0.8942039013,
-0.8759973049,
0.3416082561,
-0.0495402776,
-0.2326936722,
0.8627863526,
0.7809616327,
0.6242206693,
-0.3525329232,
1.0480169058,
0.0488840826,
0.4526291192,
-0.5559291244,
0.3229071796,
-0.3515893519,
0.3029170632,
-0.0292550009,
-0.9279956222,
-0.7073481679,
0.8596214652,
-0.395625174,
-0.0960124731,
0.9248970747,
0.623237431,
-0.2665760219,
-0.0780830979,
0.3878139853,
0.1313868612,
0.2393451333,
0.5848166943,
0.8612683415,
-0.4843659699,
0.6729049087,
-0.2040507346,
-0.2612704635,
-0.429138869,
-0.633345902,
-1.062694788,
-0.2269883752,
-0.6348052025,
0.0915011987,
0.264272213,
1.0360901356,
0.6788417101,
-0.9771641493,
0.0795991868,
-0.0206929259,
-0.0123676984,
-0.3290513754,
-0.1430048198,
0.6005902886,
-0.6153909564,
-0.7360670567,
0.6343746185,
0.4546948969,
0.1752877235,
0.3106267452,
0.0261090863,
-0.2414615005,
0.0962786376,
0.8554202318,
0.070018664,
-0.2538309097,
-0.2974960804,
0.0766998082,
-0.1000986174,
0.1530468017,
0.9436984658,
-0.6541720033,
0.3864809275,
0.7070717216,
1.0384054184,
0.4251650274,
0.3450208306,
0.3516151309,
-1.1243143082,
0.2810744047,
0.4913656712,
0.3978784382,
0.1772980392,
-0.2666789889,
0.4908265173,
0.4863440096,
-0.3824555576,
-0.6167559028,
0.2258399427,
-0.9449729323,
-0.2459304631,
1.2865021229,
-0.5277449489,
-0.0200819913,
-0.2877268791,
-0.2289354056,
-0.0965263471,
-0.3283680975,
0.5164697766,
0.5769630671,
-0.3349090219,
-0.2820702195,
-0.1513349712,
0.6230590343,
0.4112917185,
-0.8697329164,
0.0865941122,
0.4012543857,
0.2137388587,
-0.1443737894,
0.7310137153,
-0.0145619493,
0.4085228741,
0.1200546324,
-0.3010162115,
-0.158205539,
-0.2906982601,
-0.7921262383,
0.0397157036,
0.1923418045,
-0.5974155664
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00399v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00399v1
|
Enhanced Knowledge Injection for Radiology Report Generation
| 2023-11-01T09:50:55 | 2023-11-01T09:50:55 |
Qingqiu Li, Jilan Xu, Runtian Yuan, Mohan Chen, Yuejie Zhang, Rui Feng, Xiaobo Zhang, Shang Gao
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Automatic generation of radiology reports holds crucial clinical value, as it
can alleviate substantial workload on radiologists and remind less experienced
ones of potential anomalies. Despite the remarkable performance of various
image captioning methods in the natural image field, generating accurate
reports for medical images still faces challenges, i.e., disparities in visual
and textual data, and lack of accurate domain knowledge. To address these
issues, we propose an enhanced knowledge injection framework, which utilizes
two branches to extract different types of knowledge. The Weighted Concept
Knowledge (WCK) branch is responsible for introducing clinical medical concepts
weighted by TF-IDF scores. The Multimodal Retrieval Knowledge (MRK) branch
extracts triplets from similar reports, emphasizing crucial clinical
information related to entity positions and existence. By integrating this
finer-grained and well-structured knowledge with the current image, we are able
to leverage the multi-source knowledge gain to ultimately facilitate more
accurate report generation. Extensive experiments have been conducted on two
public benchmarks, demonstrating that our method achieves superior performance
over other state-of-the-art methods. Ablation studies further validate the
effectiveness of two extracted knowledge sources.
|
[
-0.2759070694,
-0.3787506223,
0.6976593137,
0.0531157069,
-0.424192518,
0.2385852933,
0.077205725,
-0.7715134025,
0.1234835461,
0.5032615662,
-0.0691691563,
-0.4474684894,
-0.7824146152,
0.1124851108,
-0.2946178317,
0.7415413857,
-0.003293239,
0.3879385293,
-0.5449813008,
-0.1034183726,
-0.7295680046,
0.0527514182,
-0.503110528,
-0.4699055254,
0.4282787144,
0.4552009404,
0.7536041737,
0.8552988172,
0.9655963778,
0.220600009,
0.2811193764,
0.5108917952,
0.0502990074,
-0.0280161463,
0.1006348506,
-0.382646203,
-0.4025022686,
-0.1701565832,
0.3372191787,
0.5558924675,
-0.1221670061,
-0.2219858468,
-0.2887437344,
0.7807945609,
-0.9140146375,
0.1803820878,
-0.4108796716,
0.2505159974,
-0.1241810098,
-0.7739165425,
-0.3553429246,
-0.5181548595,
0.2627514899,
-0.7846322656,
0.0413236767,
-0.0269926954,
0.9976029992,
0.2134509534,
-0.5333551168,
-0.5834797025,
-0.4971931875,
0.6093507409,
-0.566393435,
0.0991063491,
0.3739903569,
0.7152627707,
0.2072598785,
-1.0413095951,
-0.2582255304,
-0.1292056739,
-0.4365452826,
0.5960839987,
-0.1211144254,
0.1369039416,
0.1203592643,
0.406876415,
-0.3239637911,
-0.0294701084,
-0.548389554,
-0.3047333062,
0.6110097766,
0.2970939279,
0.4966294169,
-0.5046526194,
-0.5831980705,
-0.1322267801,
-0.8153764606,
-0.3079304099,
0.0285381917,
0.0198627245,
-0.0460499264,
0.7136307955,
-0.4457287192,
0.8132997751,
0.1131730229,
-0.5315170288,
0.3609672785,
-0.3887645304,
-0.0458562337,
0.1260188222,
0.6385489702,
0.5837967396,
-0.0978795439,
0.1550617516,
0.0333046876,
-0.3418014944,
0.4355826676,
-0.8080445528,
-0.1838312149,
0.1727183908,
-0.6197831035,
-0.8451367021,
0.3230057955,
-0.7377935648,
-0.5063659549,
-0.1585111022,
0.5008723736,
-0.8097926378,
-0.4326013327,
-0.0345238633,
-0.4441203773,
0.1620247513,
0.4763497412,
-0.5243600011,
0.0618183091,
0.3102897704,
0.7885417938,
-0.1070531234,
0.0888859555,
-0.5559564829,
0.6737381816,
-0.3596545756,
1.0532684326,
-0.5400144458,
-0.2900995314,
0.0887811705,
-0.3075810671,
0.1829090714,
-0.5686095357,
0.1012813598,
-0.6204530001,
0.3248148263,
-0.1685464233,
-0.4015848637,
-0.1196900159,
0.1522661895,
-0.3576726019,
0.8074721098,
0.3872910142,
-0.7638041377,
0.5454455018,
-0.7583960295,
-0.6532517672,
0.4627350867,
-0.5473664999,
-0.1823866069,
0.1280923933,
0.4835082591,
0.6299411654,
-0.2823879123,
0.1741310507,
0.2170838714,
0.0879341736,
0.1866949797,
0.0897883475,
0.4256060421,
0.3939018846,
0.0416646525,
-0.0130619183,
-0.53096807,
0.1346214712,
0.2741189599,
-0.1408775896,
-0.5119612217,
-0.4439267218,
-0.4226607084,
0.1458096057,
-0.006855655,
-0.7151676416,
0.0499457307,
-0.2844747007,
0.0983602628,
0.3694211245,
0.5237082839,
0.2863582373,
-0.6009809971,
0.6435390711,
0.3706071973,
0.0896148086,
-0.2574187815,
-0.5256900787,
-0.3830358982,
-0.6558557153,
0.4180748761,
0.4402790666,
-1.129924655,
0.1440091133,
-0.5001626611,
-0.5100407004,
-0.5199022889,
-0.2880443335,
0.3844361007,
0.9393361211,
0.3836372793,
-0.4703296125,
-0.5690792203,
-1.0874966383,
0.1006402373,
0.0637103692,
-0.2881191373,
0.3840679526,
0.2346710265,
0.0941494107,
0.9603873491,
-1.0707310438,
-0.6016827226,
-0.2176620364,
0.410548538,
-0.1183472276,
0.3440387845,
0.4563578963,
-0.5952246189,
-0.5732114315,
0.239357084,
-1.0040574074,
-0.1444940865,
-0.316704303,
-0.1502219439,
0.1679601669,
0.4454918206,
-0.3627486527,
0.3921885192,
0.2070323676,
-0.017181918,
0.4225951433,
-0.4648422003,
0.6793609262,
-1.1617171764,
0.1460846663,
-0.2665420175,
-0.471945852,
-0.2869104445,
0.0064041452,
0.3615286946,
0.0612017438,
-0.3682100177,
0.123210296,
-0.5864158273,
-0.0372639894,
-0.1571783274,
-0.0226522367,
0.3805131316,
-0.0604740568,
0.216289863,
0.4577987194,
0.5511316061,
-0.4301406741,
0.4235295951,
0.3230148554,
-0.3290092647,
0.6629971862,
-0.3760602176,
0.1894890815,
-0.2345369756,
0.0190097913,
-0.6933504939,
-0.5820897222,
0.0715413392,
-0.5708183646,
0.8767095804,
-0.2326734513,
-0.3399935067,
-0.4870269299,
-0.3588110209,
0.0997323096,
0.5372789502,
-0.2317179292,
0.4967481494,
0.3698340356,
-0.3490264416,
-0.8582750559,
-0.9751772881,
0.2279720157,
-0.0222778171,
-0.5825955868,
0.3778695166,
0.2052975893,
-0.0030878715,
0.2954915464,
0.0245634206,
-0.3341739774,
-0.1531870216,
0.2330347449,
0.3660140634,
-0.3123443425,
0.1939540654,
0.2132683992,
-0.1525055021,
-0.0995596945,
-0.02285414,
0.2352407128,
0.0808592588,
-0.6232007742,
-0.4397037923,
0.397664845,
0.4682636857,
-0.089017041,
0.6454051733,
0.6115982533,
-0.4800632298,
0.2034445852,
-0.6810411811,
-0.2454407811,
-0.3640624583,
0.4082392156,
-0.3291463554,
-0.4907984436,
0.2268420756,
-0.2195097357,
0.0074263024,
0.5251390934,
0.4549129605,
-0.2612520754,
0.9159157276,
0.4086378515,
0.4464583993,
0.2275758833,
-0.1104463115,
0.0242840517,
-0.811416328,
-0.4203573763,
-0.2213920802,
0.240033254,
-0.1898856163,
-0.3912787139,
0.6263870001,
-0.0672274083,
0.4201749265,
-0.0435745642,
-0.7552219629,
0.5110840201,
0.3506585956,
0.376945436,
0.6568449736,
0.1652734876,
-0.035739053,
-0.0096686874,
-0.8147602677,
-0.3082154691,
1.4552800655,
0.1585957259,
0.3825718164,
-0.0077350978,
0.664670527,
0.4821388125,
0.4887916446,
-0.8315737247,
0.1910151988,
-0.089469783,
-0.5222241879,
-0.0730634183,
-0.3854386508,
-0.7153870463,
-0.0854831263,
-0.2905315459,
0.0184322856,
-0.0792877153,
0.1394283324,
-0.8262049556,
-0.0196016189,
-0.7224458456,
0.3653251827,
-0.0078471443,
-0.1580384821,
-0.4291402698,
-0.7360403538,
0.4941684902,
-0.1345290542,
0.3498449624,
0.0355689786,
-0.17990309,
0.5953169465,
-0.4801221788,
0.5150779486,
-0.286172241,
0.052285064,
0.2311210036,
-0.0173110925,
0.2554274201,
0.1911144853,
0.2551196516,
0.1301907301,
0.1875734329,
-0.1863869727,
-0.4331884682,
0.4571960866,
-0.6293085217,
-0.3563930392,
-0.3016377687,
-0.8721135855,
-0.3192482591,
0.3281540573,
0.3552721739,
0.7444329858,
0.0363937132,
0.1443068683,
0.5011662245,
-0.5847764611,
-0.0597464964,
0.4578520954,
0.0839534625,
-0.7210885286,
0.9731750488,
0.1595600247,
0.4181807637,
0.6598542929,
0.4002842009,
0.0939193517,
-0.8293389082,
-0.5640343428,
0.1253811866,
-0.801848352,
-0.9140574336,
-0.7114735246,
-0.2993425429,
-0.5730712414,
-0.3496505916,
-0.4864527881,
-0.4995062649,
0.2635118067,
0.0522287898,
0.4304507673,
0.861573875,
-0.3169185221,
0.2544810474,
-0.9181304574,
0.4637696445,
0.2504328489,
0.228679657,
-0.1969383955,
-0.2638997138,
-0.4464904666,
-0.0563782416,
-0.2747733891,
-0.7759443521,
0.4285282791,
0.1457829922,
0.4038736224,
0.5800879002,
0.1174975485,
0.9142288566,
-0.2552115321,
0.482418865,
0.5020397305,
-0.4726307094,
0.7707234025,
-0.2569800615,
0.4877289236,
0.4304628372,
0.1902402937,
-0.2409500927,
-0.7967633009,
-0.5239977837,
-0.7197031975,
0.7148974538,
0.1971586943,
-0.1069486141,
-0.0013244132,
0.2843386233,
0.3544732332,
0.1913129687,
-0.160878554,
-0.1310425252,
-0.2532429993,
-0.4566419721,
0.4612984955,
-0.3620188832,
-0.608484447,
-0.2739540637,
0.603790164,
-0.3586680293,
0.551174283,
0.431530416,
-0.4137851894,
-0.3497436941,
0.0026428008,
0.7707639337,
0.9345995188,
-0.2773668766,
0.3501619101,
0.1203710958,
-0.6987636685,
-0.3485825062,
-0.1178805754,
0.0972808748,
-0.0534655824,
0.6735666394,
0.321175009,
0.0071522593,
-0.4258978069,
0.6117119193,
-0.0657277852,
-0.46559003,
-0.2591703534,
-0.0696004704,
0.1885935515,
0.0096902382,
0.6129996777,
0.3787979484,
0.2232191712,
-0.087242119,
0.4048450291,
0.405854553,
-0.3002731502,
0.0249235313,
0.1190692857,
0.2035640627,
0.5282683969,
0.5506592989,
0.1803798079,
-0.1123961508,
0.7062932849,
0.3253763318,
0.353371948,
-0.0016669232,
0.3305184543,
0.6098518968,
0.2119682729,
0.1021820754,
0.047350619,
0.0958331302,
-0.6506002545,
-0.5758872628,
-0.2195991874,
-0.1996260732,
-0.0986525491,
-0.8859063983,
0.2916234136,
-0.313983053,
0.0469956808,
0.0807611346,
-0.1496162564,
-0.4329088926,
0.0524243303,
0.2276079357,
0.8042417169,
-0.6397992969,
0.6891570687,
0.7384437323,
-0.6087585092,
-0.673758924,
-0.2618114054,
-0.0107033383,
-1.1417350769,
0.6455818415,
0.1688586771,
0.0440246873,
0.0531095788,
-0.4359056354,
-0.7471521497,
1.5048624277,
0.2028093338,
0.0172130708,
0.1634686738,
0.2698281705,
0.4190044701,
-0.6224072576,
0.4889429808,
0.2090385407,
0.4218076169,
0.5489662886,
-0.7819798589,
0.3639677465,
0.1114935726,
-0.1211280674,
0.1108122095,
-0.3413442075,
0.0798160806,
-0.5429794192,
-0.3114714324,
-0.2700907588,
0.6060364246,
0.0463452041,
0.2070750147,
0.428573966,
0.487675041,
0.6178895235,
0.0014857621,
1.2227352858,
-0.2824400067,
-0.0644028708,
0.8618608713,
-0.0693365559,
0.360190928,
0.5663564205,
-0.0280385353,
0.5018998384,
0.353731662,
-0.1511549801,
0.7957432866,
-0.2831715345,
-0.0572775453,
-0.3227511942,
-0.4448128939,
-0.610958755,
0.4268982708,
0.2608521879,
-0.4262517989,
-0.1698397398,
0.1905594468,
-0.0984696299,
-0.2763874233,
-0.0473283008,
1.2239532471,
0.0366426595,
-0.6545817256,
0.5188233256,
-0.1131091565,
0.4995387495,
-0.863997519,
-0.2246169448,
-0.0664351583,
-0.0098245023,
-0.4935254157,
-0.9237577915,
0.6992995739,
-0.1895885617,
-0.0243577994,
-0.2894153893,
0.918456912,
-0.3002846539,
-0.2355797589,
-0.2035001069,
0.6185808778,
-0.1145414263,
0.0423689112,
-0.3203446865,
-0.2468183488,
0.0573878437,
-0.1403760314,
0.2983290255,
0.2474184334,
0.2138246745,
0.5311143398,
0.552738905,
0.298631072,
-0.2117758393,
-0.0122602936,
0.8714892268,
-0.1690614522,
-0.2166656405,
-0.4683862925,
0.6815726757,
-0.4362227619,
-0.1091459766,
0.4270803332,
0.5772450566,
0.3094787002,
-0.2329980284,
0.8393349648,
-0.4355076253,
0.2905643582,
-0.6297951937,
0.8872935176,
-0.5924435258,
-0.0044694194,
-0.1576844752,
-0.1779404581,
-0.4255893826,
0.2356056422,
-0.1319265664,
-0.2309912294,
1.0559054613,
0.6661171317,
0.0212834571,
-0.0499745719,
0.4231409729,
0.1120417342,
0.1531386524,
0.4439115822,
0.7249235511,
-0.3321943879,
0.7882302999,
-0.5836884379,
-0.4157959819,
-0.1162151694,
-0.7843512297,
-0.6383023262,
-0.525216639,
-0.6454775333,
-0.2976079285,
-0.0723949745,
0.531858623,
0.9284031391,
-0.6037418246,
0.2586231232,
0.0899467245,
0.1745000035,
-0.2795388103,
-0.2982728481,
0.530508101,
-0.4137549102,
-0.3426650465,
0.1095824018,
0.4728254378,
-0.0117838793,
-0.0090565672,
-0.003626066,
-0.1414704472,
-0.229598254,
0.6297277212,
-0.0999648944,
-0.2758636475,
-0.317820102,
-0.0631579235,
-0.325073868,
0.3648810983,
0.8491894603,
-0.8537857533,
0.6374145746,
0.47087726,
0.5630040169,
0.4163306653,
-0.1299519986,
0.8260046244,
-0.9602661133,
0.0043596569,
0.2250676602,
0.0551902615,
0.4447577,
-0.6440258622,
0.457331419,
0.3447256088,
-0.1027008966,
-0.8532146215,
0.2219901532,
-0.9371757507,
-0.2924253941,
0.9624836445,
-0.1438985914,
0.1241423115,
-0.2250347435,
-0.0854667053,
0.4929544926,
-0.3868261874,
0.7431567311,
0.5130751729,
-0.4404033124,
-0.4137813449,
-0.6264379621,
0.6127280593,
0.2016977817,
-0.9946882129,
-0.3962341845,
0.4898166656,
0.4400388598,
0.282879591,
0.5347933769,
-0.5940012932,
0.5051971078,
-0.0695656687,
0.3348690569,
-0.6840293407,
-0.0746256709,
-0.0041050594,
0.5231958032,
0.0575410649,
-0.1653867513
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00367v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00367v1
|
Prompt-based Logical Semantics Enhancement for Implicit Discourse Relation Recognition
| 2023-11-01T08:38:08 | 2023-11-01T08:38:08 |
Chenxu Wang, Ping Jian, Mu Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Implicit Discourse Relation Recognition (IDRR), which infers discourse
relations without the help of explicit connectives, is still a crucial and
challenging task for discourse parsing. Recent works tend to exploit the
hierarchical structure information from the annotated senses, which demonstrate
enhanced discourse relation representations can be obtained by integrating
sense hierarchy. Nevertheless, the performance and robustness for IDRR are
significantly constrained by the availability of annotated data. Fortunately,
there is a wealth of unannotated utterances with explicit connectives, that can
be utilized to acquire enriched discourse relation features. In light of such
motivation, we propose a Prompt-based Logical Semantics Enhancement (PLSE)
method for IDRR. Essentially, our method seamlessly injects knowledge relevant
to discourse relation into pre-trained language models through prompt-based
connective prediction. Furthermore, considering the prompt-based connective
prediction exhibits local dependencies due to the deficiency of masked language
model (MLM) in capturing global semantics, we design a novel self-supervised
learning objective based on mutual information maximization to derive enhanced
representations of logical semantics for IDRR. Experimental results on PDTB 2.0
and CoNLL16 datasets demonstrate that our method achieves outstanding and
consistent performance against the current state-of-the-art models.
|
[
-0.2777448893,
-0.5174418092,
0.7553604841,
0.2749421299,
-0.2577269077,
-0.1521268189,
0.0229684021,
-0.3743659258,
-0.0023074255,
0.3900209963,
-0.6841052771,
-0.3993169665,
-0.368922025,
0.4442831278,
0.1337385923,
0.9004004598,
0.2594074309,
0.0924389139,
-0.4387398958,
-0.2186226547,
-0.632234633,
-0.3151389062,
-0.6606429815,
0.0348156691,
0.349003613,
0.2494800389,
0.2916964591,
0.5016857982,
0.2867467999,
0.3684583604,
-0.2549642622,
0.2868521512,
-0.106720686,
0.2554971874,
-0.3114879429,
-0.1721957326,
-0.3319922388,
-0.0043075238,
0.695035696,
0.6635760665,
0.2584474087,
-0.0071143005,
0.2425947338,
0.4193024933,
-0.6368818283,
0.5741736293,
-0.7402123809,
-0.1787189841,
0.007969927,
-0.1919226497,
-0.4366911948,
-0.4327948689,
0.2885633409,
-0.818613112,
-0.1781511009,
0.1252225935,
0.7099878788,
0.5006946921,
-0.7163440585,
-0.1901135892,
-0.3650918305,
0.324133575,
-0.6076552272,
0.257278949,
0.3305902183,
0.2866969407,
-0.2710626721,
-0.8317905664,
-0.6579198837,
-0.4188082516,
-0.6398340464,
0.1896800101,
-0.0852567703,
0.4599085152,
0.7742145658,
0.0650911853,
-0.3591524065,
0.0015227764,
-0.0629201233,
-0.2903495729,
0.2831286192,
0.1828950346,
0.2531455159,
-0.3624162972,
-0.7902952433,
0.3641472459,
-0.5216056108,
0.4457201064,
0.1039726138,
0.298126936,
0.0037865886,
0.357973963,
-0.2822282314,
0.5644454956,
0.2472974807,
-0.176483795,
0.2477128357,
-0.4396133423,
-0.0245676488,
0.2370696068,
0.76327461,
0.1227763072,
0.0832839534,
0.133156687,
-0.0288756453,
0.1732504815,
-0.4674575329,
-0.8813961744,
-0.2392346412,
-0.0473935157,
-0.1477186829,
0.0684280097,
0.242719233,
-0.512387991,
-0.4804531038,
-0.5859189034,
0.058105588,
-0.6031627655,
-0.298694104,
0.0188021418,
0.0175162815,
0.3482119739,
0.6225677729,
-0.428915441,
0.4548233449,
0.5887541771,
0.6609660983,
0.084186852,
-0.0755983144,
-1.0350319147,
0.3760928512,
0.0448748805,
0.8528117537,
-0.5398540497,
-0.0703880936,
-0.1255211532,
-0.0114828991,
-0.1570331305,
-0.3763239086,
0.9393414259,
-0.3695780933,
0.4764827788,
-0.3694387376,
-0.7334022522,
-0.144284606,
0.0320796594,
-0.4324826598,
0.9330375791,
0.0875452161,
-1.130822897,
0.1738042384,
-0.5915629864,
-0.3870517313,
0.2738372982,
-0.3074373007,
-0.1294806153,
-0.1205813065,
0.4517023265,
0.3515917361,
-0.2207437903,
0.6431609392,
-0.4143174291,
-0.1626645029,
0.1633871943,
-0.2736608386,
1.0240470171,
0.0487170927,
-0.2318571806,
0.4226081669,
-0.9477776885,
-0.1801919341,
-0.1724992096,
0.2634571493,
-0.749910593,
-0.3511362076,
-0.5477992892,
0.6214910746,
0.2780206203,
-0.6483641863,
-0.0026398229,
-0.6447891593,
0.2090733498,
0.9596511126,
0.1218176335,
0.4712362885,
-0.0806742087,
0.2879456878,
0.3984202445,
-0.0572326332,
-0.65888834,
-0.5125889182,
-0.7131128311,
-0.5639021397,
0.3793421686,
0.8370547891,
-0.8371844292,
0.6336516738,
-0.2888086438,
0.0414629728,
-0.5374237895,
-0.1105857939,
0.4073606431,
1.3260962963,
0.4614863992,
0.081732586,
-0.5843051672,
-0.9731739163,
-0.1421579719,
-0.3758193254,
-0.0776153579,
0.2736177444,
0.2081236094,
-0.0113002574,
1.2204376459,
-0.3884640634,
-0.5533145666,
-0.1529695839,
0.2119524181,
0.2424389869,
0.4320364892,
0.2850493193,
-0.5662316084,
-0.5855900049,
-0.1138647497,
-0.7700999975,
-0.4675754607,
-0.1523749083,
-0.1405035555,
0.1282721311,
0.4859527349,
-0.6625560522,
0.4742407799,
-0.0050602807,
-0.6351416111,
0.4638420939,
-0.2161750942,
-0.0613591634,
-0.880692184,
-0.0197022706,
0.0745843723,
-0.3670198619,
-0.4865250587,
-0.4900571704,
0.3139971197,
-0.0745252743,
-0.5150790811,
0.8968906403,
-0.5458221436,
0.0482332408,
-0.1235193461,
0.1471568644,
0.0879458711,
0.6570159197,
0.2473172396,
0.8354127407,
0.5951353312,
-0.5889920592,
0.1694366038,
0.4717243016,
-0.1062730625,
0.8023456335,
-0.6419735551,
-0.0615261793,
-0.4418148696,
0.3683158159,
-1.0455880165,
0.0076257908,
0.6543588638,
-0.3276765049,
0.3039876819,
-0.1669709533,
-0.3427907825,
-0.0984028429,
-0.2430287451,
0.3394650817,
0.4536821842,
-0.6965440512,
0.7871112823,
0.2061026245,
-0.4910413325,
-0.5567735434,
-0.2233453393,
0.0136315515,
-0.2747918069,
-0.7477349043,
0.3335137069,
-0.0548711568,
-0.2651636004,
-0.0272250362,
-0.1111822873,
-0.0466597043,
0.0226167627,
0.2924162745,
0.424069047,
-0.024283709,
0.2263733,
0.4516784251,
-0.4522833228,
0.3748668134,
-0.2623635828,
0.0692796409,
-0.2408976406,
-0.0728139058,
-0.8357800245,
0.3549501896,
0.2210109234,
-0.4313389957,
0.5290170908,
0.3198293746,
-0.3099580407,
-0.0985795036,
-0.5769750476,
-0.3710412979,
-0.484259963,
-0.033119332,
-0.7023500204,
-0.9043346643,
0.5452718139,
-0.4084735215,
-0.3264941275,
0.3034856915,
-0.1449100822,
-0.1470898241,
0.9115160704,
0.2802332342,
0.0816518292,
0.2387220412,
0.1150258705,
-0.0003509191,
-0.8524464965,
-0.2427163571,
-0.3519601226,
0.1477006823,
-0.4165797532,
-0.0630531758,
0.4075000882,
0.0085071577,
-0.4046593904,
0.0742023289,
-0.173190549,
0.2484716028,
0.5688931346,
0.1957166344,
0.5556023717,
-0.0453475602,
-0.4228955805,
-0.6169507504,
-0.648783803,
-0.2302288413,
0.3447037637,
0.3061757982,
0.4506717026,
-0.2308139503,
0.4020568728,
0.0248308033,
0.0940665454,
-0.5845458508,
0.9527484179,
0.0915883929,
0.1790540516,
0.0299532693,
-0.604870677,
-0.7030282617,
0.2092794776,
-0.1021038219,
-0.5501236916,
0.3867298365,
0.0708242133,
-0.3007066846,
0.0094230603,
-0.4614845514,
0.7557926178,
-0.2824575305,
-0.6039562225,
0.1904104203,
-1.0568912029,
0.481598556,
0.2403021306,
0.0503908284,
-0.3274084032,
-0.1762864441,
0.4357751608,
-0.4939643145,
0.8389985561,
-0.4344033897,
-0.0475536585,
0.1630602926,
0.088407129,
0.6425384283,
0.2678551972,
0.0415818729,
0.0568892024,
-0.4239705503,
-0.079159312,
-0.9524962902,
0.5494128466,
-0.3676356375,
-0.8453837037,
-0.6825056076,
-0.5467866063,
-0.3240659535,
0.1977279335,
-0.092150867,
0.4560776949,
0.1018319726,
-0.2148011476,
0.723423183,
-0.1600842476,
0.3990001976,
0.5712026954,
-0.1823342443,
-0.5718088746,
0.7477347851,
-0.077929467,
0.0575164706,
0.4637803435,
0.3561339378,
-0.8114280105,
-0.2128694803,
-0.2322131097,
0.4841450751,
-0.6963663101,
-0.4917332828,
-0.9850991368,
-0.2397011518,
-0.4555203021,
0.0652356893,
0.0829853565,
-0.6530281901,
-0.4304206371,
-0.2179276496,
0.5361183286,
0.2263795435,
-0.1062255055,
0.2619474232,
-0.5876065493,
0.3813672364,
0.3484481275,
0.0869669467,
-0.4283851981,
-0.6190888882,
0.3900337219,
-0.0382583514,
0.1175937951,
-0.8217023015,
0.351454556,
0.3213375807,
0.4449506998,
0.4874421358,
0.5015292764,
0.7991088629,
-0.5127046704,
0.3098789155,
0.2236736417,
-1.025562644,
1.0008100271,
-0.407276988,
0.3339983225,
0.685849905,
0.5185118318,
-0.1088656262,
-0.308437407,
-0.6001087427,
-0.6461724639,
0.6587263346,
0.0512352809,
-0.1096775755,
-0.0238450337,
0.2227790952,
0.2582790256,
0.2404392958,
-0.8809078932,
-0.2260983288,
-0.0534310378,
-0.2692526281,
0.5427595377,
-0.4319888651,
0.1613343507,
-0.4990003407,
0.6156833768,
-0.2178729475,
-0.0161568336,
0.3630267084,
-0.0648187995,
0.3284388483,
0.3487298489,
0.1792632192,
0.441179961,
-0.1077084616,
0.0874636993,
0.1105220616,
-0.070302844,
0.2835281491,
0.5498264432,
-0.6035075188,
0.215062812,
0.0208622776,
0.895950079,
0.3110579252,
-0.5988083482,
0.810128212,
-0.2453751564,
0.1977032572,
-0.384703517,
-0.0892069712,
-0.2535709441,
0.2061730325,
0.1953570098,
0.116396904,
0.4099739194,
-0.1986494809,
0.3809168041,
0.523943305,
-0.4186475575,
-0.1616729498,
0.6019364595,
0.2058963627,
0.0966297239,
0.5805801749,
-0.5608911514,
-0.4262696207,
0.2775340378,
0.7420573831,
0.8068215847,
-0.4009831846,
0.3200471401,
0.7438806891,
0.1015368924,
0.2724151611,
0.3047946393,
-0.3015335202,
-0.4351705909,
-0.5977464914,
-0.4037507176,
-0.2313751876,
-0.0655527413,
-0.4840845764,
0.6482232213,
-0.4332702458,
0.1541874111,
-0.4598879218,
-0.1001122221,
-0.4380326867,
0.0134386979,
-0.0896859765,
0.8289217353,
-0.5088920593,
0.8992109895,
0.5828672051,
-0.393101126,
-0.7676720023,
-0.2332830578,
-0.1289305687,
-0.4431951344,
0.9876638055,
0.5466499925,
-0.0015041742,
0.1965161413,
-0.1336593926,
-0.6014351249,
0.9680348039,
0.7221039534,
-0.5872484446,
-0.1650516093,
0.2896971703,
0.2256075889,
-0.4373533726,
0.6346977353,
0.329754442,
0.4236432612,
0.3288622797,
-0.6099974513,
0.3854613602,
-0.3115132749,
0.1590817571,
0.083540462,
-0.2064105123,
0.5959153175,
-0.2489728779,
-0.5758641362,
0.0718872249,
1.1629886627,
0.4368264079,
0.4508419335,
0.6412905455,
0.581361115,
0.8777070642,
-0.0643324405,
0.7175930142,
-0.3570417762,
-0.1226211935,
1.561270833,
-0.5206258297,
0.4951679409,
0.2049658448,
0.1446204782,
0.6307529211,
0.4429255724,
0.3178029358,
0.4910345674,
-0.0613543689,
-0.5834944844,
-0.1352963895,
-0.7847354412,
-0.4416967332,
0.3168119192,
0.5069300532,
-0.217311576,
-0.3911699355,
0.112762861,
0.1592030227,
0.331312865,
-0.4918854833,
1.1199349165,
0.1151168272,
-0.6462644339,
0.4008566141,
-0.4387917221,
0.6324520111,
-0.7106707096,
-0.3190374374,
-0.227598235,
-0.0994744524,
-0.0969148874,
-0.6141663194,
0.0868180022,
-0.3329835832,
0.0745351464,
-0.2464619577,
1.2813470364,
-0.6500431299,
-0.4406591952,
0.4630769789,
0.6913167834,
-0.3034612536,
-0.096672073,
-0.5733141303,
-0.237497583,
-0.2350943536,
0.1481181681,
0.2655541897,
0.7877361178,
0.1331398338,
0.629653573,
0.6113205552,
-0.0328525268,
-0.1692175418,
-0.0954181552,
0.9770644903,
-0.563180685,
-0.8411300182,
-0.813325882,
0.7177417874,
-0.3810200095,
-0.2096369416,
0.8672599196,
0.3768571913,
0.6853330135,
0.0203755498,
0.7206544876,
0.1968743205,
0.6831322312,
-0.558500886,
0.1487554014,
-0.0685849786,
0.3445259333,
-0.3351379335,
-0.7554181814,
-0.2703907192,
0.6526442766,
-0.4544295669,
-0.3005665541,
0.7180073857,
0.7810967565,
-0.0705634579,
0.1457289308,
0.2078629285,
0.2826797366,
-0.0239870064,
0.4986194074,
1.1381872892,
-0.162867561,
0.2641282976,
-0.334692955,
-0.2918730378,
0.2845166326,
-1.1169981956,
-0.9000986218,
-0.6958289742,
-0.4548575878,
-0.2988724113,
0.2113341391,
1.0290157795,
0.1801756918,
-0.5993406177,
0.0164806619,
-0.4020395875,
0.1295754313,
0.0864040703,
-0.3038365245,
0.268357873,
-0.6804139614,
-0.553134203,
0.3346150219,
0.5478200316,
0.0483685955,
-0.0130103752,
-0.0229474809,
-0.3782385588,
-0.313049823,
0.7067377567,
0.2567955852,
-0.5503066778,
-0.1544573754,
-0.0432283692,
0.0590550527,
0.2443990558,
0.8259749413,
-1.3521032333,
0.3103954196,
0.4257735014,
0.8328920007,
0.0374411494,
0.1679212004,
0.4710196257,
-0.6801795363,
0.3315990567,
0.4629736543,
0.6002368927,
0.3360139132,
-0.4528857172,
0.4698019624,
0.4325937331,
-0.3871149719,
-0.5939549208,
0.3946161568,
-0.973215282,
-0.0788351968,
0.9916340709,
-0.4488481283,
-0.0531030856,
-0.3558438122,
-0.6017383933,
0.1045574322,
-0.6850126982,
0.3575240374,
0.0719753355,
-0.180101499,
-0.4237213433,
-0.186504215,
0.6242964268,
0.4916518331,
-1.0211263895,
0.0340088457,
0.8727578521,
-0.1664519012,
-0.1641023308,
0.7609439492,
0.157032311,
0.2573173046,
-0.4685463309,
-0.478613466,
-0.328684181,
-0.4323043525,
-0.3212893903,
0.1646726876,
-0.1423977315,
0.027782442
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04910v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04910v1
|
Ontology-Driven Processing of Transdisciplinary Domain Knowledge
| 2023-11-01T07:42:34 | 2023-11-01T07:42:34 |
Oleksandr Palagin, Mykola Petrenko, Sergii Kryvyi, Mykola Boyko, Kyrylo Malakhov
|
cs.DL
|
cs.DL, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The monograph discusses certain aspects of modern real-world problems facing
humanity, which are much more challenging than scientific ones. Modern science
is unable to solve them in a fundamental way. Vernadsky's noosphere thesis, in
fact, appeals to the scientific worldview that needs to be built in a way that
overcomes the interdisciplinary barriers and increases the effectiveness of
interdisciplinary interaction and modern science overall. We are talking about
the general transdisciplinary knowledge. In world practice, there is still no
systematic methodology and a specific form of generally accepted valid
scientific theory that would provide transdisciplinary knowledge. Non-linear
interdisciplinary interaction is the standard of evolution of modern science.
At the same time, a new transdisciplinary theory (domain of scientific
research) is being de facto created and the process is repeated many times:
from an individual or group of disciplines, through interdisciplinary
interaction, in a direction that brings us closer to creating a holistic
general scientific worldview.
|
[
-0.3721365631,
-0.8517459631,
0.8476138711,
0.0982770845,
0.1584785283,
0.2383014709,
0.1265842766,
-0.7781491876,
0.4827703238,
0.7037232518,
-0.919470787,
-0.5286624432,
-0.4524663687,
0.2982217968,
-0.329633832,
0.8936564922,
-0.0563924275,
-0.0130873257,
-0.3371215463,
0.0585029647,
0.0285740849,
-0.3458472192,
0.0681623667,
-0.492708236,
0.2502866983,
0.4967098534,
0.4404542148,
0.4777566493,
0.6476343274,
0.2211606055,
-0.3517822623,
0.1995535493,
-0.3126175702,
0.3477376699,
-0.4723643959,
-0.4854361713,
-0.5712054372,
-0.0390085578,
0.8040291071,
1.1181360483,
0.0528882332,
0.1697073728,
-0.0679435953,
0.49917835,
-0.4223545194,
-0.4109891057,
-0.2297524065,
0.5004640818,
-0.1867861301,
-0.4550578892,
-0.0236078817,
-0.0992497429,
0.5960770249,
-1.1694242954,
0.207309112,
-0.1230645925,
0.4902271628,
0.0405997857,
-0.5726150274,
-0.003691904,
-1.1836177111,
1.1427980661,
-0.1283510625,
0.1987047493,
0.1948057264,
0.2484332174,
-0.3251952529,
-0.7856812477,
-0.5865417719,
-0.2348449677,
0.3415661454,
0.2691628337,
0.0689592659,
-0.0985986739,
0.2018266618,
0.2311814278,
-0.4128789604,
-0.1416032314,
-0.6153785586,
-0.0563449636,
0.6015398502,
0.6260694861,
0.3386033773,
-0.299066633,
-0.6499469876,
0.60512501,
-0.7211968303,
-0.0254023895,
0.1523126811,
0.0107345637,
0.1012463644,
0.3971558213,
-0.5627881885,
0.9228112698,
0.0270865485,
-0.2212476879,
0.2028712183,
-0.6159225702,
0.005848113,
-0.0805839822,
0.2727219462,
0.2417468131,
-0.231781289,
-0.1748754531,
0.2155074477,
0.1012524366,
0.5597564578,
-0.3489654362,
0.2322241515,
0.338160634,
-0.3206873238,
-0.5371297598,
0.1145193651,
-0.8048248291,
-0.1189769506,
-0.7829415798,
0.0579495057,
-0.1525135189,
-0.6088580489,
0.0485229939,
-0.0856521055,
0.0039086789,
0.5778014064,
-0.5098655224,
0.4640213847,
0.8327240348,
0.9008806348,
-0.0045912717,
-0.433505863,
0.1974842995,
0.5832405686,
-0.1377459615,
1.1762572527,
-0.7702840567,
-0.6259294748,
-0.0420077369,
-0.0684114322,
0.2319711298,
-0.3620131314,
0.492418021,
-0.3352777362,
0.2311225235,
-0.4938828349,
-0.3576669097,
-0.2177429944,
0.5381439328,
-0.1754048318,
0.7754529715,
-0.0318469405,
-0.7239263058,
0.3679670393,
-1.0316581726,
-0.1983481497,
0.1907579899,
-0.1000197679,
-0.0913612768,
0.0517732501,
-0.5308830142,
0.1861986369,
-0.5875047445,
0.4341690242,
-0.492431432,
0.0041849636,
0.0634785965,
0.3091715872,
0.8722340465,
0.1443420798,
-0.1331545562,
0.0808014572,
-1.0306174755,
0.184739992,
-0.1330421418,
-0.2909893095,
-0.5887477398,
-0.2028922737,
0.1924568564,
0.4993669987,
0.2040038705,
-1.022629261,
0.4968354404,
-0.3364012241,
0.663973093,
0.6314959526,
0.2202219367,
0.7157557607,
-0.4458563626,
0.3169860244,
-0.0229433645,
0.4042110145,
0.1911569387,
-0.5268101692,
-0.5067592263,
0.0273204148,
0.1255575418,
0.4918035567,
-0.6784566641,
0.2850354016,
-0.2501788139,
-0.7329542637,
-0.2239130139,
-0.0558254905,
0.389098227,
0.7033079863,
0.4754131734,
-0.5387907028,
-0.8606414795,
-0.6224594116,
-0.2917604744,
0.1358579844,
-0.0498626381,
0.3795798421,
0.6502419114,
-0.3089192808,
1.1335725784,
-0.6956709623,
-0.5735419989,
0.1505471468,
0.1371487975,
0.0487546735,
0.4484403729,
0.30649665,
-0.9130219817,
-0.4702236354,
0.2773917615,
-1.2497349977,
-0.0859486163,
0.3297002316,
-0.3433577716,
0.2191057652,
0.253266871,
-0.5892672539,
0.3805901408,
0.0004410125,
-0.5106437802,
0.7384214997,
-0.1185171381,
0.0172339045,
-0.8185845613,
0.3892595768,
0.1383955926,
0.0862454399,
-1.1238058805,
-0.0470667481,
-0.3119383752,
-0.0123429392,
-0.5678521991,
0.4917849004,
-0.3677684069,
0.0227540135,
-0.1980161518,
0.1933356524,
0.1516174078,
0.1129883081,
0.1627091318,
-0.016794391,
0.8551188111,
-0.9081058502,
0.5759631395,
0.4862452745,
-0.1745981574,
0.9784683585,
-0.5269468427,
-0.083188884,
-0.4137086868,
0.250633806,
-0.5659385324,
-0.0161620416,
0.4776987135,
-0.3367837071,
0.0241196286,
0.0831708461,
-0.2548035979,
-0.1788184047,
-0.2121038586,
0.377546519,
0.2690131366,
-0.20445548,
0.7228970528,
0.4032857418,
-0.1945700645,
-0.5305483937,
-0.6904539466,
0.1782742739,
-0.1411642134,
-0.905970037,
0.7376904488,
0.0997344032,
-0.6169711947,
0.3768965006,
-0.3217277825,
-0.1497119963,
-0.0828351602,
0.3191453516,
0.2411325425,
0.0075955079,
0.1181167737,
-0.0103014382,
-0.5781716108,
0.229347527,
-0.6626477242,
0.0883253589,
0.3378776014,
-0.1163735986,
-0.570142746,
0.6026011109,
0.5242805481,
0.2149920911,
0.4833035469,
0.2162872851,
-0.2086291164,
-0.1687558591,
-0.1389251202,
-0.1664274931,
-0.3792378306,
0.3013840318,
-0.4302306473,
-0.9338110685,
0.4860584438,
-0.3457321227,
0.1618915796,
0.4191583991,
0.5062865615,
-0.0327313878,
0.5284662843,
0.7546219826,
0.2665606737,
0.2101814598,
-0.5606014132,
0.2243172526,
-0.9895230532,
-0.485616833,
-0.5426571369,
-0.2069432437,
-0.4381190538,
-0.2383775115,
0.5797661543,
-0.3692939579,
-0.2994953692,
0.1206410676,
-0.6679934263,
0.112085782,
0.2879088819,
-0.0659053251,
0.7887387872,
0.1465518028,
0.0931126624,
-0.1723642051,
-0.609095633,
-0.5204805732,
1.0003938675,
0.1376555711,
0.8085182905,
0.2698154151,
0.4644039571,
0.3104979396,
0.3240416348,
-0.5843513012,
0.4671339691,
0.2927164137,
-1.0044339895,
-0.3674103916,
-0.3269766569,
-1.1275496483,
0.4793332517,
-0.2565307021,
-0.6831693649,
0.4119671285,
0.1325779706,
-0.1910151839,
0.3529983163,
-0.0699313134,
0.4026073515,
0.2252647132,
-0.5242531896,
-0.3515446484,
-0.9322924018,
0.5990909934,
-0.100979805,
0.4741460085,
-0.1916845143,
-0.2449738979,
0.7796584964,
-0.2670306563,
0.9401119351,
-0.3337469697,
-0.2357322127,
0.5073954463,
0.1896457076,
0.0426822416,
0.1312225163,
0.1019360051,
0.4174484313,
0.2451018244,
-0.523791194,
-0.3503150642,
0.7140445113,
-1.1092935801,
-0.9083022475,
-0.6633254886,
-0.6097426414,
-0.123037003,
0.2763686478,
0.4344899952,
0.3322721124,
-0.5014539361,
-0.3362890184,
0.6152691841,
0.0564271919,
-0.0396778956,
0.6967601776,
-0.2840604484,
-0.0686545223,
0.8253349066,
0.7641339898,
0.3439451456,
0.4143592119,
-0.0352600887,
0.1113454252,
-0.140030399,
-0.021063786,
0.1118743047,
-0.6652107835,
-0.1504394859,
-0.9847986698,
-0.1450622529,
-0.2806826532,
-0.0916302428,
-0.1846284568,
-0.8316794634,
-0.1930146217,
0.1435164809,
0.3306080401,
0.9993243217,
-0.3482068479,
-0.1141487658,
-0.7979735136,
0.3169237673,
0.1016773432,
0.1992387176,
0.1497442871,
-0.5244855881,
-0.417332828,
-0.0735884458,
-0.8244546652,
-0.3811893165,
0.130096361,
0.0576569885,
0.4717270434,
0.302188158,
0.1219342649,
0.4407895505,
-0.3830595613,
0.621789813,
0.1688637137,
-1.0688205957,
0.5734796524,
-0.4416879714,
-0.0919929147,
0.1019419879,
0.6070559621,
-0.7209402323,
-0.1890660971,
-0.873637259,
-0.9293407798,
0.7128647566,
-0.0337383598,
0.0655431375,
0.5095087886,
0.4315755665,
0.4229330719,
0.2081575245,
-0.3722850084,
-0.3706083,
-0.2724487484,
0.3983823955,
0.3764737546,
-0.1286044568,
-0.5221313238,
-0.3130759001,
0.5768994689,
-0.0188280754,
0.4290108979,
0.7049968839,
0.1438923627,
-0.5817346573,
0.2825459242,
0.7235656977,
1.0832452774,
-0.0560399145,
0.1420537978,
-0.1208531857,
-0.5602150559,
0.5721567273,
-0.2716507614,
-0.3707653582,
-0.1642966866,
0.6094333529,
0.4122915268,
-0.0950666592,
-0.2591943443,
0.1500029117,
0.0943697616,
-0.7905635834,
-0.4026256204,
0.1014191136,
-0.3228841722,
0.2058703005,
0.52864182,
0.4806907177,
0.2834345698,
-0.505533278,
0.0914831311,
0.2036684752,
-0.3095577061,
-0.845995307,
0.441477567,
0.1796417087,
-0.1051776409,
0.2242207676,
0.0462318882,
-0.3869839311,
0.5849708319,
0.5463633537,
0.5615825057,
-0.2253096104,
0.4282717109,
0.2071568668,
-0.0609413274,
0.1354198605,
0.6293106079,
-0.3119247556,
-0.9102581143,
-0.5840255618,
-0.3406830132,
-0.7551771998,
-0.3367480636,
-0.6663426757,
0.0290727932,
-0.7648610473,
-0.2085093558,
0.3831640482,
0.0928125083,
-0.364548713,
0.162751615,
-0.2659986317,
0.8670014143,
-0.9409494996,
0.6032947302,
0.9962689281,
-0.1759464443,
-0.1575240791,
-0.0324792042,
0.2175602019,
-0.6381269693,
1.2278256416,
-0.2052836269,
0.0357420929,
-0.0535554253,
-0.6089570522,
-1.3220026493,
0.8868829608,
0.1271307766,
-0.1335926354,
0.2566867173,
0.152116403,
0.6327682734,
-0.3660076559,
-0.2701375782,
0.4023087621,
0.9995472431,
0.1766978502,
-0.8139357567,
0.1505094171,
-0.4942954183,
0.0769555271,
0.3635688126,
-0.7570723295,
0.9538122416,
-0.1874051243,
-0.0461795591,
-0.0374389105,
0.4546529353,
0.1675033867,
0.618991375,
0.1117740348,
0.7239194512,
0.4662436247,
0.0696401522,
0.8958748579,
-0.1623706967,
0.6032998562,
0.3255747259,
-0.571741581,
0.1122302487,
0.8103832603,
-0.6369373798,
0.6733711362,
0.3430301249,
-0.164442122,
0.6948671341,
0.143254593,
-0.4236130416,
-0.3990435004,
-0.6953053474,
-0.6480033994,
0.4016469717,
0.4320204556,
0.2073363513,
-0.284154743,
0.1058414727,
-0.2525758445,
0.0962411165,
-0.2874699533,
0.6723821163,
0.3077821136,
-0.5194355845,
0.555280745,
0.01095495,
0.4670168757,
-0.5090110898,
-0.1528552473,
0.2788766921,
0.1150541753,
-0.7243233323,
-0.8103195429,
0.8215405941,
-0.2869201601,
-0.5604280829,
-0.140498817,
0.8273985386,
0.1240810156,
-0.3275428414,
0.3361826241,
0.7537002563,
0.0748541281,
0.3842274547,
-0.2991808355,
-0.1077731028,
-0.0835432187,
-0.5251246095,
0.4964940548,
0.6326283813,
-0.008626136,
0.7989497781,
0.6816879511,
0.1057691872,
-0.2044220865,
-0.4143660367,
0.9896847606,
-1.0336083174,
-0.6627120376,
-0.6837092638,
0.434435308,
0.0995083898,
-0.3142719567,
0.7099133134,
0.1426877975,
0.8246179223,
-0.0800676048,
1.3310406208,
-0.3728481531,
0.6687128544,
-0.2775747776,
0.1229383424,
-0.6459812522,
0.1061815694,
-0.4498647451,
-0.8266150951,
-0.7402255535,
0.5054568648,
-0.606565237,
0.0606508106,
0.6564036012,
0.250564158,
-0.0355017446,
0.3493274748,
0.3173290193,
0.3213891089,
0.1950673461,
0.4226154685,
1.084310174,
-0.2134146243,
0.0349151827,
-0.1718479693,
-0.4014822245,
-0.2282284945,
-0.5915646553,
-0.5685257316,
-0.5203323364,
-0.1636508405,
-0.3712879121,
-0.1571804583,
0.6845302582,
0.6063640118,
-0.547691226,
-0.219536379,
-0.2898471951,
0.2142076045,
-0.3147173822,
-0.2115668654,
0.3148003221,
-0.1387960911,
-0.4282003343,
0.0761473104,
0.6113792062,
-0.1199499741,
-0.512437284,
-0.0004925255,
-0.1143888012,
-0.2282625735,
0.5677394271,
0.5246595144,
-0.4953984916,
-0.1131998524,
0.0514689237,
0.1541478932,
0.2374124378,
0.9356726408,
-0.8385368586,
0.2252262682,
0.4939616919,
0.3349448144,
0.3429123461,
-0.1614094377,
0.3575618565,
-0.4467802346,
0.2112168819,
0.2217310071,
-0.0358885154,
0.1618184,
-0.5886980295,
0.483117193,
0.7620956302,
-0.7767945528,
-0.8269586563,
0.5160928965,
-0.8259766698,
-0.3745858073,
0.6076423526,
-0.0333268009,
-0.3680385649,
-0.7280352116,
-0.079645671,
0.0404597446,
-0.3770876825,
0.8724002838,
0.3868451715,
-0.7754385471,
0.1219720766,
-0.4763793945,
0.3322260976,
0.4461074173,
-0.7937585711,
0.0776996613,
0.0407582968,
0.4327335954,
0.6886187196,
0.6347460747,
-0.0892280117,
0.1915409416,
-0.0096392473,
0.1897401214,
-0.1545335948,
-0.4360691607,
-0.0510095432,
0.3308700025,
-0.0740215778,
0.3194530904
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00732v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00732v1
|
tmn at #SMM4H 2023: Comparing Text Preprocessing Techniques for Detecting Tweets Self-reporting a COVID-19 Diagnosis
| 2023-11-01T07:41:23 | 2023-11-01T07:41:23 |
Anna Glazkova
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SI, 68T50, I.2.7; I.7.m; H.3.3; J.3
|
The paper describes a system developed for Task 1 at SMM4H 2023. The goal of
the task is to automatically distinguish tweets that self-report a COVID-19
diagnosis (for example, a positive test, clinical diagnosis, or
hospitalization) from those that do not. We investigate the use of different
techniques for preprocessing tweets using four transformer-based models. The
ensemble of fine-tuned language models obtained an F1-score of 84.5%, which is
4.1% higher than the average value.
|
[
-0.3494707346,
-0.5756213665,
0.4482403696,
0.5829930305,
-0.1714725792,
0.2138774395,
0.0293762907,
-0.6290010214,
0.3567741513,
0.3337386549,
-0.7017439008,
-0.5597473979,
-0.519533515,
0.5015892386,
-0.7982726693,
0.8570052981,
0.0550264865,
-0.166731596,
-0.0714419559,
0.2844212651,
-0.0892133862,
-0.5116162896,
-0.8140559793,
-0.3665991127,
0.2610293031,
0.711012423,
0.5666996837,
0.27253142,
1.132553339,
0.1638418585,
0.4421221912,
-0.2045369893,
-0.2999705374,
0.1030227169,
-0.1495205611,
0.1026370749,
-0.5233865976,
0.3812515438,
0.1541843563,
-0.1259458214,
0.0913788229,
0.5255871415,
-0.1981140077,
0.0028951596,
-0.2753440738,
-0.2391825169,
-0.206856057,
0.2349967211,
-0.2724289596,
-0.3759308755,
-0.4812472463,
-0.0078866519,
0.2233082056,
-0.2779969871,
0.6286501288,
0.0094960555,
0.7920631766,
0.1541673541,
-0.2211222351,
-0.2100803554,
-0.6940284967,
0.8768566847,
-0.6482535005,
0.2252374738,
0.4735975266,
0.4485509098,
0.2945336401,
-0.996319294,
-0.3059079349,
-0.0325205475,
-0.1522233039,
0.1159154028,
-0.5965276361,
-0.1029760987,
-0.002210947,
0.3060720861,
-0.8149635792,
0.1163238287,
-0.4475933909,
-0.422822684,
0.7732161283,
0.0679483935,
0.4091699123,
-0.3130035996,
-0.3238827884,
0.2635186911,
-0.1762817651,
-0.2086051702,
-0.3344736397,
-0.0148953469,
-0.1782715172,
0.1712966859,
-0.0606058128,
0.3724889159,
0.2677790821,
-0.3058669567,
0.2305367589,
-0.5672315955,
-0.5216777325,
0.049564559,
1.0281001329,
0.327665776,
0.2492690533,
-0.3465717733,
-0.2679087818,
0.2116497755,
0.5964505672,
-0.9464014769,
-0.6268978715,
0.1832926124,
-0.6959888935,
-0.5725002289,
-0.2075680047,
-0.6537038088,
-0.1343345195,
-0.0413515866,
0.6548036337,
-0.2994758189,
-0.1931238323,
-0.2161594629,
-0.2781477273,
0.0022487538,
0.4510127306,
-0.6617944837,
0.5713415742,
0.4202985764,
0.7447077632,
-0.3654133677,
0.0465511829,
-0.513487041,
-0.2151775807,
-0.3848511875,
1.0348087549,
-0.4289585352,
-0.2900387943,
-0.2626806498,
-0.1460081488,
-0.2011380792,
-0.5397462845,
0.7555177808,
-0.2854968011,
0.3831100464,
-0.2887898684,
-0.2512579262,
-0.0229232088,
0.3580068648,
-0.6669666171,
0.9124572873,
0.3078514636,
-0.6937352419,
0.2318451405,
-0.7704126835,
-0.5198479891,
0.1916616261,
0.0971818268,
-0.5938136578,
-0.2660386562,
0.5415126681,
0.8087129593,
-0.3553172052,
0.4531420767,
-0.0766825229,
-0.3102196753,
-0.0672360957,
-0.2971310318,
0.7111738324,
0.440662235,
-0.4111420214,
0.258287847,
-0.4982935488,
0.2019361109,
0.1846791208,
0.107882157,
0.0359769389,
-0.0992016867,
-0.0655778423,
0.4515055716,
0.402426362,
-0.5461034775,
0.0875633433,
-0.2495892793,
0.4048611522,
0.2284663618,
0.1667873561,
0.2246162891,
-0.4078482389,
0.9557434916,
0.1053511202,
0.4233651161,
-0.2172363251,
-0.615963161,
-0.5085381269,
-0.2320839465,
-0.0677621365,
0.7139972448,
-0.6751020551,
0.2535886168,
-0.0661075488,
-0.7512634397,
-0.4977673292,
-0.173895359,
0.2824614942,
0.7064782977,
0.691491127,
0.2852331996,
-0.9777162671,
-0.8467766643,
-0.4610749185,
0.1565863341,
0.3995360732,
-0.2648786902,
0.5637677908,
-0.4205375016,
0.6804347038,
-0.3076955676,
-0.1554938704,
-0.2853906751,
0.3436473012,
0.0456408486,
0.4971258938,
0.8546718359,
-0.7003111839,
-0.5986700654,
-0.1768364012,
-0.7927398086,
-0.4341009557,
0.3028043211,
0.2860732377,
0.1440629512,
0.9291318655,
-0.1654194146,
0.7257490754,
0.9634073973,
-0.5477252603,
0.436668098,
-0.0138664758,
0.4038446844,
-1.4402402639,
-0.0390506424,
0.4064798355,
-0.6957679391,
-0.9965785742,
-0.1592833996,
-0.0075004315,
-0.1829138398,
-0.182882458,
0.4688230455,
-0.0044006747,
0.3657900095,
-0.2267176509,
-0.2327419519,
0.2721092105,
-0.2504728734,
-0.1925159693,
0.7795870304,
0.2065457106,
-0.5032515526,
0.1702418178,
-0.0483276919,
-0.195566535,
0.0701516494,
-0.8174351454,
0.0199878905,
0.2096097767,
0.123259671,
-1.2449524403,
-0.1764225811,
0.3991183341,
-0.6250690222,
-0.0013613987,
0.276402086,
-0.4312480092,
-0.7855004668,
-0.2802369297,
0.5222573876,
0.3832884431,
-0.5163427591,
0.4837196767,
0.2301592529,
-0.068017289,
-0.3354761899,
-0.9373216629,
0.1463394463,
-0.2645429075,
-0.6972816586,
0.8065555096,
0.0051879985,
-0.3537059426,
0.0230075624,
-0.0706891865,
-0.2556090057,
0.3078145683,
0.1121755838,
0.1334540844,
-0.3262484372,
-0.0424365364,
-0.2128296643,
-0.0396333598,
0.1712632328,
-0.0598634966,
0.5785368681,
-0.1728433669,
-0.0041118362,
-0.630136013,
0.3973332047,
0.3233036697,
-0.3066481352,
0.6006603241,
0.8807780147,
-0.5378662944,
0.0996993035,
-0.5611202717,
-0.0977585614,
-0.4940254688,
-0.0966153815,
-0.3010635376,
-0.824123919,
0.5540583134,
0.1437487751,
-0.2899584472,
1.0223360062,
0.4391469359,
-0.1249581873,
1.0261662006,
0.7335748672,
-0.0294261556,
0.3058956861,
-0.0839750394,
0.6408112049,
-0.2575574815,
-0.1573363692,
-0.7903088331,
0.0526908822,
-0.8671464324,
-0.2498288006,
0.4784782529,
-0.3612426221,
-0.0884379745,
0.480438292,
-0.5725061893,
0.1729499102,
0.4502785206,
0.0891968533,
0.1031755805,
-0.2729280591,
0.0284314528,
-0.0848037004,
-0.6631863713,
-0.4324344397,
0.8438616395,
0.3323005736,
0.2935775518,
-0.1499653608,
1.0049858093,
0.6878839135,
0.6080372334,
-0.686127007,
0.3180892766,
-0.5474873781,
-0.7021628022,
-0.338875711,
-0.2889483571,
-0.8751776218,
-0.1113519147,
-0.1048768386,
-0.6683832407,
-0.1136667356,
0.0508075431,
-0.4860093296,
0.0033172646,
-0.9808899164,
1.1862046719,
0.0655519962,
0.2467715889,
-0.1222401187,
-0.4437758327,
0.3297894299,
-0.255877167,
0.2620238066,
-0.346906662,
0.1255900115,
1.2130149603,
-0.3162071705,
0.4972735643,
-0.0796034634,
-0.0919136778,
0.3179226518,
-0.0820943639,
-0.0668170229,
-0.1725410521,
-0.3644414842,
0.0673204437,
0.3287214935,
-0.31964764,
-0.245722279,
0.4691761136,
-0.7030756474,
-0.6542876363,
-0.7215783596,
-0.1099110171,
0.0704357401,
0.4878445864,
0.7313922048,
0.514172256,
-0.5143569708,
0.1148057804,
0.2136261016,
-0.0813731924,
0.692912817,
0.4601483047,
-0.3581239879,
-0.2602297068,
0.6029945016,
0.2731163502,
0.0306018926,
0.5855045319,
0.5989569426,
0.0264266413,
-0.3081789017,
0.1363879442,
0.1551400423,
-0.5515559912,
-0.5830664039,
-0.6673184633,
-0.5859643817,
-1.037371397,
-0.199497804,
-0.320668608,
-0.1532440633,
-0.5909491181,
-0.0111421701,
0.3723924756,
1.0018123388,
-0.0917563885,
0.5463944674,
-0.6353065968,
0.6685043573,
0.1250435859,
0.1656426191,
-0.3061737716,
-0.5837186575,
-0.3999167085,
0.014420826,
-0.4779173732,
-0.6254027486,
0.7327536345,
0.0978521183,
0.2691951096,
0.4419310093,
0.1350637972,
0.737764895,
-0.2892843783,
0.8374253511,
0.2082205713,
-1.204870224,
0.9411374927,
-0.3483282924,
0.4121801257,
0.4351608753,
0.7797076702,
-0.4749834239,
-0.2459487915,
-0.7929207087,
-0.2630572617,
0.609040916,
0.1597746313,
-0.2829268873,
-0.2327314764,
0.2210145593,
0.0399587937,
-0.1621333212,
-0.4747373462,
-0.1808936298,
-0.2982888818,
-0.3766749501,
-0.3952733278,
-0.4805315137,
0.1382862031,
-0.709417522,
0.2503916323,
0.1195942163,
0.5521181226,
0.4338276684,
0.1588418931,
-0.2430795729,
0.085789226,
0.7112485766,
0.71078372,
-0.2999095619,
0.3125757277,
-0.0856833532,
-0.7025672197,
0.0899637192,
0.0761607364,
0.1411983222,
0.2343937755,
0.667632103,
0.5249539614,
0.0977911651,
-0.1384510696,
0.8388434649,
-0.4133720398,
-0.4373546243,
-0.5256537795,
0.0454435237,
-0.0097197974,
0.1074567959,
0.4519711733,
0.4604414999,
0.3020232618,
-0.6057109237,
0.4407730103,
0.1527612358,
-0.1645944715,
-0.6993572712,
0.5353069305,
0.1474114954,
-0.5912525654,
0.5509856939,
-0.4816761315,
-0.7269615531,
0.6833553314,
0.8031514287,
0.8179971576,
-0.9103218317,
0.3836673498,
0.3631317616,
0.4963066578,
-0.2949535251,
0.6037701368,
0.3633772731,
-0.8450356722,
-0.5073600411,
-0.3318097889,
-0.2490636259,
0.4005913138,
-0.739420712,
0.5795567036,
-0.3235273063,
-0.4120224118,
0.3848402798,
0.1165121198,
-0.7842338085,
0.8964539766,
0.0750202462,
0.9809401631,
-0.9907299876,
0.8650785089,
0.4219623804,
-0.0564629287,
-0.9146246314,
0.5051059723,
-0.1304478943,
-0.7784891725,
0.3254059851,
0.4884960055,
0.0015117534,
0.0555474721,
-0.6661555171,
-0.9033812284,
1.0984563828,
0.2523263693,
-0.235798344,
-0.0226289351,
0.0054335278,
0.7425416112,
-0.5666799545,
0.1913934648,
0.6947561502,
0.3765696585,
0.0151418308,
-1.3117651939,
-0.0035154948,
-0.3810924292,
-0.486130774,
0.0817005411,
-0.4229907095,
0.8732324243,
-0.1445119381,
-0.1947789043,
-0.1198328286,
0.4664205909,
-0.1382093281,
0.8639642596,
0.1668484956,
0.6228832603,
0.6586540937,
-0.0491864346,
1.1984596252,
-0.1893841028,
0.2896191776,
0.8340072036,
0.1507420838,
0.7827702165,
0.2380827814,
0.0191184971,
0.3865393102,
0.5399089456,
0.0971761867,
0.4467468858,
-0.1663503051,
-0.0619155392,
-0.1952168792,
-0.1697233021,
-0.286580354,
0.7178114653,
0.6415399313,
-0.4993741214,
-0.2860955894,
0.197696507,
0.1618578434,
-0.0154382559,
-0.3534009457,
0.7067127824,
0.1012266278,
-0.9040480256,
0.5545071959,
0.143443495,
0.594134748,
-0.0627933145,
0.273103863,
0.1889390498,
0.2003888637,
-0.4318987131,
-0.8441830873,
0.9962896705,
0.1042727232,
-0.3153145611,
-0.4885420203,
1.1168483496,
-0.1743926257,
-0.5861180425,
0.5255998969,
0.5969862342,
0.036048945,
-0.4609451294,
-0.6661964059,
0.0645487458,
-0.0951887965,
-0.0679505318,
-0.0740757361,
0.4683454931,
-0.127976656,
0.5248362422,
0.1119295731,
-0.2233502716,
-0.0328348763,
0.2045562565,
0.5262386799,
-0.6580235958,
-0.4091850519,
-1.1218022108,
0.07934466,
-0.1195100173,
-0.1878464222,
0.8221740127,
0.4941047728,
0.4302572608,
-0.1345928907,
0.9068225026,
-0.005449004,
0.8227391839,
-0.0704277828,
0.4978284836,
-0.4198633432,
-0.1064022779,
-0.3200113475,
-0.3237162232,
-0.4496593177,
0.6197338104,
-0.6412907839,
0.0802227557,
0.9967563748,
0.5464729071,
-0.0648005903,
0.1766345948,
0.33794415,
-0.0328723192,
0.5753281116,
0.1047963202,
0.535355866,
-0.6946102977,
0.2497872859,
-0.566496253,
-0.0530134253,
-0.6117523313,
-0.9694871306,
-1.0884139538,
-0.6706368923,
-0.4448848069,
-0.6072691679,
0.0021576392,
0.8245874643,
0.6642495394,
-0.9598402977,
0.089070946,
-0.1381329,
-0.1126223281,
-0.1539620757,
-0.3006031215,
0.143710196,
-0.2371696234,
-0.0946617499,
0.2844409347,
0.2606586814,
0.0676783845,
-0.1104023382,
0.2003837377,
-0.296818614,
0.0752213895,
0.7141304612,
-0.1920038909,
-0.5003561378,
-0.326839,
0.3593414426,
-0.4136289954,
0.1668653041,
0.680901885,
-0.6662355661,
0.2295059711,
0.6850804687,
0.233468622,
0.378459543,
0.2369829267,
0.5950468183,
-0.6092514396,
-0.2653936148,
0.5749927759,
0.0297002662,
0.4656805992,
-0.6026742458,
0.3704534173,
0.2978988588,
-0.8289574981,
-0.5330391526,
-0.0840246454,
-1.0385072231,
-0.0254745763,
0.9305047393,
-0.0387571193,
-0.2227149457,
-0.2114939839,
0.0269200485,
0.4208613336,
-0.2552574277,
0.763047576,
0.4719070494,
-0.2830335796,
-0.1968204528,
-0.3337877095,
0.7340724468,
0.0075291204,
-0.7469116449,
-0.8231601715,
-0.3789509237,
0.4843814969,
0.1664589345,
1.0291534662,
0.0976102352,
0.5833361745,
-0.3372007608,
-0.1601675749,
0.1954319477,
-0.3901626766,
-0.1708217114,
0.1376260072,
-0.2294821143,
-0.2024338245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00321v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00321v2
|
HARE: Explainable Hate Speech Detection with Step-by-Step Reasoning
| 2023-11-01T06:09:54 | 2023-11-22T09:08:03 |
Yongjin Yang, Joonkee Kim, Yujin Kim, Namgyu Ho, James Thorne, Se-young Yun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the proliferation of social media, accurate detection of hate speech has
become critical to ensure safety online. To combat nuanced forms of hate
speech, it is important to identify and thoroughly explain hate speech to help
users understand its harmful effects. Recent benchmarks have attempted to
tackle this issue by training generative models on free-text annotations of
implications in hateful text. However, we find significant reasoning gaps in
the existing annotations schemes, which may hinder the supervision of detection
models. In this paper, we introduce a hate speech detection framework, HARE,
which harnesses the reasoning capabilities of large language models (LLMs) to
fill these gaps in explanations of hate speech, thus enabling effective
supervision of detection models. Experiments on SBIC and Implicit Hate
benchmarks show that our method, using model-generated data, consistently
outperforms baselines, using existing free-text human annotations. Analysis
demonstrates that our method enhances the explanation quality of trained models
and improves generalization to unseen datasets. Our code is available at
https://github.com/joonkeekim/hare-hate-speech.git.
|
[
-0.416829288,
-0.8453008533,
0.6434642076,
0.0889777541,
-0.2455068231,
-0.1305588186,
-0.2518336773,
-0.5291208029,
0.0036630621,
0.6152682304,
-0.8702331185,
-0.6349482536,
-0.7943039536,
-0.095761098,
-0.6699880958,
0.9640499949,
0.1036196202,
-0.0252232552,
-0.0447937436,
-0.0899069384,
-0.4222918749,
-0.319431901,
-0.6852163076,
-0.38090083,
0.6365272403,
0.3600484431,
0.7506968379,
0.7441336513,
0.2152285576,
0.2355599254,
-0.0570295602,
0.2328868806,
-0.3763326705,
0.6151888967,
-0.0666625872,
-0.5392712355,
-0.2297412008,
-0.2805598974,
0.1391039491,
0.3746439517,
-0.0527691357,
0.136070922,
-0.2108263224,
0.3420004845,
-0.5013319254,
-0.0416961424,
-1.0313895941,
0.0005258689,
-0.4544376731,
0.1289938539,
-0.4442517757,
-0.1966970563,
-0.2197008431,
-0.7774727941,
0.4008019567,
-0.0342779309,
0.6525388956,
0.2958903909,
0.002205401,
-0.3589640558,
-0.6755638719,
0.7978816032,
-0.7137078643,
0.6108347774,
0.8313094378,
0.3096446097,
0.0018205954,
-0.3204703629,
-0.6147369146,
-0.1674019545,
0.1073981002,
-0.1275370717,
-0.2684903443,
-0.0653090924,
0.4978752434,
0.1880578846,
-0.5573713779,
0.2763842642,
-0.1464403123,
-0.2217510641,
0.7683290243,
0.1930568069,
0.3685958087,
-0.0877456591,
-0.1366105974,
0.3125848174,
-0.3969396055,
-0.2852578759,
0.6113033891,
0.3999607563,
-0.124896057,
0.4876537323,
-0.1168870702,
0.5814412832,
0.0345676281,
0.0349514633,
0.1170027182,
0.2085209191,
-0.2026319802,
0.0869140849,
0.5961616635,
0.4535691142,
0.5762451887,
-0.3402604163,
-0.1060251519,
0.5275973082,
0.4334667921,
-0.7766646147,
-0.1894742697,
0.2728158236,
-0.2562645376,
-0.455317378,
-0.5039390326,
-0.9511390924,
-0.9452395439,
-0.1599356681,
0.1411319822,
-0.5688089132,
-0.465300262,
0.1314242333,
-0.0952131003,
0.2433549762,
0.5338546038,
-0.8683047891,
0.0851544961,
0.7568634748,
0.6745879054,
-0.0928277522,
0.0387893952,
-0.6669447422,
0.2080879807,
-0.4818001091,
0.590382576,
-0.7083778381,
0.0233409349,
0.2153178602,
-0.3053391576,
0.3562101126,
-0.6163221598,
0.758713305,
-0.5961484313,
-0.1616465896,
-0.0589988939,
-0.654689014,
-0.3559437692,
0.095803827,
-0.3307603002,
0.8944326639,
-0.2200208455,
-0.8311113119,
0.4480185211,
-0.5672673583,
-0.5131775737,
0.270496428,
0.041241087,
-0.7378003001,
0.0425993279,
0.4770852625,
0.6402407885,
-0.0346424095,
0.3954958022,
-0.8860891461,
-0.0971561149,
0.2859030962,
-0.1720179319,
0.9989288449,
0.4945600927,
-0.5448250771,
0.2368311137,
-0.7788053155,
-0.2528926432,
0.5815053582,
0.205193013,
-0.5276222229,
0.2719433308,
0.0066094203,
-0.1109920368,
-0.1980029196,
-0.5514514446,
-0.2749071419,
-0.2029234767,
0.203726992,
0.8594563007,
-0.1380383074,
0.0665726066,
-0.1870742887,
0.4773618579,
-0.0241311081,
0.1601308882,
-0.0805075094,
-0.5646310449,
-0.7693173885,
-0.3423160911,
-0.3647886515,
0.3622190952,
-0.2414014041,
0.1797717661,
0.216969803,
-0.2947102487,
-0.4919609129,
0.1754898578,
0.1844357997,
0.4229838252,
0.4409306347,
0.3133333921,
-1.0526239872,
-0.9203263521,
-0.576156795,
-0.2571547925,
-0.0340313986,
-0.0654022545,
0.3968239427,
-0.259745121,
0.8834298253,
-0.2337523252,
-0.0436042212,
-0.4107513428,
0.2290688455,
-0.2378836125,
0.0918185711,
0.3726492226,
-0.8862702847,
-0.3427455127,
-0.4378950298,
-0.7699569464,
-0.6603358388,
-0.0646366999,
-0.2744514942,
-0.2195395082,
0.4385141432,
-0.2587813437,
0.4713374078,
0.3564506769,
-0.2430918366,
0.5748884082,
0.6095437407,
0.0949542895,
-0.8744525313,
-0.5033020973,
0.2262226045,
-0.5592035055,
-0.8439827561,
0.2272781581,
-0.2417700589,
-0.1576981097,
-0.3260647655,
0.1666966528,
-0.0865333602,
0.1879443377,
-0.2479918748,
0.3077662289,
-0.1382647455,
0.2428297549,
-0.0765944421,
0.58430475,
0.4921104014,
-0.5184167027,
0.2994638085,
0.2293204814,
-0.3627511859,
0.6249561906,
-0.3546444774,
0.003275394,
-0.1466048062,
0.0837483481,
-0.9984297156,
-0.3305063844,
0.5906440616,
-0.6152350307,
-0.0480396859,
-0.4809040725,
-0.4937314093,
-0.1646525264,
-0.1433147937,
0.3019793332,
0.3822892308,
-0.6717894673,
0.4968542159,
0.5338229537,
0.1669940799,
-0.3565262556,
-0.581994772,
0.0053261258,
-0.556865871,
-0.4788840711,
0.1316270083,
-0.2552519143,
-0.6189104915,
-0.0249210503,
-0.0708588511,
-0.2966921628,
0.3465273082,
0.6690948606,
0.053217385,
-0.1634617299,
0.1274992824,
-0.1013831571,
0.0746823251,
0.3364439905,
-0.1439241916,
0.3921521306,
0.0608237423,
-0.2615746558,
-0.3887657225,
0.3827492297,
0.6612020731,
-0.1220624894,
0.5488467216,
0.8371788263,
-0.6468335986,
-0.5063994527,
-0.6313354373,
0.0724413842,
-0.3941939175,
0.3279283643,
-0.2273419797,
-0.962028265,
0.4282058179,
0.2852688432,
0.1607750058,
0.4304548502,
0.6432127357,
0.0498722121,
1.1857609749,
0.2744074762,
0.064857997,
0.3835359514,
0.1807084084,
0.1928227544,
-0.5038358569,
-0.1342716366,
-0.459644407,
0.2562290728,
-0.0267696511,
-0.547191143,
-0.0363420248,
0.3150414228,
-0.3140417933,
0.2570686936,
-0.5485038757,
0.4928575456,
0.0142356111,
-0.1199902594,
0.1857322752,
0.1905556768,
0.06525933,
-0.3973434865,
-0.1525875777,
-0.4422781765,
0.8984153867,
0.5784569383,
0.7700870633,
0.1685171276,
0.5787245035,
0.5700250864,
0.5299693942,
-0.7621542215,
0.610874474,
-0.0255250856,
-0.9409489036,
-0.0990704447,
-0.2909919918,
-0.4524621069,
0.3628073037,
-0.3827177882,
-0.9243004322,
-0.391934365,
0.3629848957,
-0.1124301478,
0.6459953785,
-0.4140384495,
0.5935605168,
-0.2510949969,
-0.3361847103,
-0.4752924442,
-0.0693221837,
0.685354352,
-0.1408132017,
0.5610007644,
-0.5050463676,
0.2202676535,
1.0443232059,
-0.5291993022,
1.0228543282,
-0.3026444912,
-0.2425516993,
0.1699461341,
0.2455141246,
0.4002140462,
-0.1160499305,
-0.1873191446,
0.3685408235,
-0.5822165012,
-0.1259075552,
-0.5894280672,
0.450861007,
-0.3792206049,
-0.5675984025,
-0.0130389575,
-0.5833246708,
-0.2577297986,
0.0435642377,
0.1600697637,
0.2342338562,
0.1114835292,
-0.0174617916,
0.8832375407,
-0.2939360142,
-0.1478391439,
0.3451952338,
-0.7048270106,
-0.3426969051,
0.7223899961,
-0.1355252713,
-0.0489395112,
0.2215936184,
0.2079039812,
-0.3691053391,
-0.7247658372,
-0.5690184832,
0.1930700094,
-0.7170098424,
-0.1466624886,
-0.8794337511,
-0.0039305529,
-0.3752790093,
-0.3987841606,
-0.2388339192,
-0.0948079824,
-0.0675457865,
-0.0801499858,
0.5654563904,
0.9945862293,
-0.1763072759,
0.5023553967,
-0.206608519,
0.6968187094,
0.2908035219,
0.3761322796,
0.2507010698,
-0.7722459435,
-0.2249923795,
0.0419377461,
-0.1553810686,
-1.3249764442,
0.1837207824,
-0.2460820526,
0.4001197517,
0.4849394858,
0.143279627,
0.8757535219,
-0.572218895,
0.5986204743,
0.3447982669,
-0.9700934291,
0.7433834672,
-0.4709586501,
-0.3211862743,
0.2065008134,
0.5640541315,
-0.5232903361,
-0.9109079242,
-0.4962389767,
-0.8911072016,
0.7367878556,
0.2767190039,
-0.0997650996,
-0.0658440366,
0.1642540246,
0.1285363734,
-0.1335863918,
-0.9626957774,
-0.4558087289,
-0.334810406,
-0.2223192602,
0.1163442582,
-0.4591284096,
-0.1652916074,
-0.1276566535,
1.0885699987,
0.259732455,
0.098841317,
-0.2588002682,
-0.4636630118,
-0.228948608,
0.2817456126,
0.5116042495,
0.6525369883,
-0.1842259318,
0.0643035918,
0.1924044192,
-0.1217444837,
0.1537845582,
0.0995220169,
-0.1513485759,
0.2807673812,
0.4659734964,
0.8929638267,
-0.0627721474,
-0.4754448831,
0.6230409145,
-0.1068232059,
-0.2624343932,
-0.5381439328,
0.102748692,
0.2524949312,
0.3557863533,
0.2587457299,
-0.2217429578,
0.0561027601,
0.0811107382,
0.357049346,
0.4359929264,
-0.3554247916,
-0.2176549286,
1.0705028772,
0.0218956172,
-0.4445981681,
0.2077810019,
-0.1356434226,
-0.7553476691,
0.2849780023,
0.7797136307,
0.8648747802,
-0.0891100988,
0.3962919116,
0.4289802909,
0.2909334302,
0.3750191927,
-0.2359142005,
-0.190014869,
-0.7658474445,
-0.4869409204,
-0.8181731701,
-0.4109935462,
0.8596084118,
-0.6428821087,
0.1402267665,
-0.6400344968,
0.2227101922,
0.6613426805,
-0.5580529571,
-0.4611388743,
0.1117755398,
0.7187302709,
0.7809837461,
-1.1559548378,
0.3979531527,
0.4548060596,
-0.42608428,
-0.8307023644,
0.2435260266,
0.3151621521,
-1.1401327848,
0.8224717975,
0.4159045219,
-0.33000651,
-0.2979115546,
-0.7276652455,
-0.2752254307,
0.1810065359,
0.3975332975,
-0.5453862548,
0.2536999285,
0.14535667,
0.365573585,
-0.3416551054,
0.1469585449,
0.1764842272,
0.3767006099,
-0.1523447931,
-0.1209503114,
0.1052753553,
0.0051737772,
-0.0820414424,
0.2164887786,
0.0284851342,
0.493298918,
-0.1090637743,
-0.1367554516,
-0.1945871413,
0.7990450859,
0.1429635733,
0.4088540673,
0.9697347283,
0.7427743673,
0.5974294543,
0.0663791224,
0.7899448276,
0.2149619013,
0.2273250967,
0.9697828889,
-0.0932880715,
0.5222471952,
0.0637269095,
-0.2326132804,
0.5956933498,
0.5782646537,
0.0831882581,
0.1422577202,
0.4426148534,
-0.4972129166,
-0.8695881367,
-0.2245402783,
-0.1473072022,
0.3548667729,
0.6009417772,
-0.2203057408,
-0.4924358428,
0.2358334512,
0.3186161816,
0.3527778089,
-0.4961921871,
0.5464590788,
-0.1304824352,
-0.3750647604,
0.7441043854,
0.0421922132,
0.798238337,
-0.6190223694,
-0.125205189,
-0.0548910871,
0.1489024162,
-0.4506469965,
-0.7886155248,
0.5105310678,
0.5742707253,
-0.3297988176,
-0.1687346399,
0.6969703436,
-0.5434006453,
-0.1985366493,
0.5629065633,
0.0250982456,
0.3364091814,
-0.1503011882,
-0.8862600327,
0.398532182,
0.2578956485,
0.0447999798,
0.1076335087,
0.3162299693,
-0.2200855315,
0.7113851309,
0.740653038,
0.0976321101,
0.1821980923,
0.2573522925,
0.5528758764,
-0.356220305,
-0.3689627349,
-1.131338954,
0.3562887311,
-0.1833395958,
-0.0372243859,
0.7281552553,
0.5383951664,
0.9245842099,
0.0488879755,
0.9442564845,
-0.0137343844,
1.0356549025,
-0.3458302617,
0.5606675148,
-0.7520744801,
0.1394550204,
-0.4311067164,
-0.5646342039,
-0.6249542236,
0.975351572,
-0.4698436856,
-0.219923988,
0.3529729843,
0.9865697622,
-0.3368459046,
0.202968806,
0.5591406822,
0.4170764387,
0.5644845963,
0.1225093976,
0.9958232641,
-0.0555893406,
0.7836826444,
-0.2358914763,
-0.0174261518,
-0.3239782155,
-0.8375787139,
-0.8772399426,
-0.5816566944,
-0.543697536,
-0.5613906384,
0.3203482628,
0.7507632375,
0.778286159,
-0.7928596139,
-0.1158861294,
-0.0763632655,
0.3062982857,
-0.0549816824,
-0.2780458927,
-0.0470061712,
-0.4421646297,
-0.5953650475,
0.4331683815,
0.211693719,
-0.2859718502,
-0.008447513,
-0.1876454353,
-0.261026293,
0.110661611,
0.5080163479,
0.293056041,
-1.138936758,
-0.3785699606,
-0.5528348684,
0.126496911,
-0.06883277,
0.833406508,
-0.3168782592,
0.4068594575,
-0.029314721,
0.9844914079,
0.4914269745,
-0.1463104039,
0.1369295269,
-0.6020730138,
-0.028968744,
0.0878826007,
0.3384759426,
0.5661464334,
-0.3114030063,
0.3355035186,
0.3719391823,
-0.3488529027,
-0.9988598824,
0.6613625884,
-0.7991874814,
-0.3029755652,
1.2707608938,
-0.1494425833,
-0.0555117391,
-0.4277325571,
-0.1042549685,
0.5720852613,
-0.4277592301,
0.5168477297,
0.5950372815,
-0.0347956866,
-0.1312000901,
-0.5998263359,
0.5850090981,
0.50958395,
-0.6182829738,
0.6803842187,
0.7091804147,
0.3876878619,
0.0078087533,
0.6584733725,
0.0707542896,
0.1169858798,
-0.0772867277,
0.1374742836,
-0.3471171856,
-0.3241743147,
-0.3515664041,
0.0488195047,
0.0192071293,
-0.3331542611
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00317v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00317v1
|
Data Augmentation for Code Translation with Comparable Corpora and Multiple References
| 2023-11-01T06:01:22 | 2023-11-01T06:01:22 |
Yiqing Xie, Atharva Naik, Daniel Fried, Carolyn Rose
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SE
|
One major challenge of translating code between programming languages is that
parallel training data is often limited. To overcome this challenge, we present
two data augmentation techniques, one that builds comparable corpora (i.e.,
code pairs with similar functionality), and another that augments existing
parallel data with multiple reference translations. Specifically, we build and
analyze multiple types of comparable corpora, including programs generated from
natural language documentation using a code generation model. Furthermore, to
reduce overfitting to a single reference translation, we automatically generate
additional translation references for available parallel data and filter the
translations by unit tests, which increases variation in target translations.
Experiments show that our data augmentation techniques significantly improve
CodeT5 for translation between Java, Python, and C++ by an average of 7.5%
Computational Accuracy (CA@1), which verifies the correctness of translations
by execution. The code is available at https://github.com/Veronicium/CMTrans.
|
[
-0.4138593376,
-0.3225689828,
0.4573232234,
0.2439659685,
-0.1619067788,
0.495870173,
-0.5834624767,
-0.6477885246,
0.0336832777,
0.5575564504,
-0.3671655059,
-0.707424283,
-0.359913379,
0.5147432685,
-0.3848110437,
1.0293259621,
-0.1936658621,
0.3179385066,
-0.4661298096,
-0.489846915,
-0.4593843818,
-0.6130372882,
-0.0601327345,
-0.2441826612,
0.3806865215,
0.6115570664,
0.9338370562,
0.8064659238,
0.8644104004,
0.3380293548,
0.25533548,
0.4727855921,
-0.3268359005,
-0.1106140688,
-0.0429866649,
-0.6341935992,
-0.2629391551,
-0.1738402843,
0.6084040999,
0.7834116817,
0.2131985724,
0.2396123856,
-0.178016305,
0.6764011979,
-0.5358057618,
0.1763499975,
-0.523728013,
-0.1179159731,
-0.2599297464,
-0.3802185059,
-0.1373622864,
-0.7903310657,
-0.2650380135,
-0.61837852,
0.4169089496,
0.00325492,
0.548194766,
0.3292917907,
-0.2758915424,
-0.4279204309,
-0.6192703843,
0.7529331446,
-0.6588402987,
0.3023374975,
0.108405374,
0.2043226808,
0.0713996664,
-0.8513595462,
-0.6089975238,
-0.4127215743,
-0.3255034685,
0.0027987114,
-0.0614465661,
-0.0845827684,
0.6016175151,
0.6664034128,
-0.7986475825,
-0.164895162,
-0.8643152714,
-0.0979893431,
0.4001171291,
0.1778108478,
0.4816911817,
-0.0093093254,
-0.3362892866,
-0.3565517068,
-0.7791211009,
-0.3153511584,
0.5604595542,
0.1375065297,
-0.0869729817,
0.6360640526,
-0.2212063521,
0.8379471898,
-0.2288656682,
0.2396243811,
0.7867929339,
-0.8877747655,
-0.1136952713,
0.1944679618,
0.3783566356,
0.1783691943,
0.1615120173,
-0.3582421839,
0.0245407373,
0.5597283244,
0.5483481884,
-0.7618609071,
-0.2714832425,
0.2475418597,
-0.3193973303,
-0.424741447,
0.2862184346,
-0.3164100945,
-0.165922612,
-0.7461118698,
-0.1247927547,
-0.5072049499,
-0.0910461098,
0.2250237316,
-0.1895280778,
0.2505078316,
-0.0363281667,
-0.5995211005,
0.294088006,
0.9109578729,
0.7804987431,
-0.3336526752,
-0.43816939,
-0.7633122206,
0.140849188,
-0.5114044547,
0.6925942302,
-0.7893978953,
-0.2885933816,
0.1555101573,
-0.0170065071,
0.1181011945,
-0.6711755991,
0.6183488369,
-0.3609751761,
0.1970878839,
-0.1752861142,
-0.552444756,
0.03103837,
0.3309619725,
-0.605376482,
1.0520310402,
0.4178376496,
-0.8982790112,
0.195720017,
-0.6214119792,
-0.3993673921,
0.0101327877,
-0.3911987841,
-0.2642916143,
0.1167747378,
0.3130001724,
-0.0099146552,
-0.3833866715,
0.1451143026,
-0.3728756011,
-0.4252034724,
0.3131063581,
-0.1453677267,
0.6789188981,
0.3461965024,
0.054258354,
0.2039590329,
-0.8279146552,
0.1078812853,
-0.2886357605,
-0.5751309395,
-0.3798568249,
-0.2777211964,
0.0697957203,
0.2205557078,
0.4940009713,
-0.6739838719,
0.527284503,
-0.5000318885,
0.1742012501,
0.1800908893,
-0.2418973446,
0.5244145989,
-0.3515821099,
0.4883220494,
0.063830696,
0.0381206907,
-0.476397872,
-0.4562562108,
-0.6511468291,
0.0298865996,
0.2594390512,
0.5611889362,
-1.0493955612,
0.2511226833,
-0.7007638812,
-0.3057168424,
-0.7867453694,
0.5337642431,
0.5627291799,
0.4196285903,
0.610194087,
-0.4564812481,
-0.8906388283,
-0.7403267622,
-0.0835008696,
-0.0524384454,
-0.1225426495,
-0.2604909539,
0.2143871933,
-0.2949625552,
0.708845377,
-0.5570403934,
0.0762338191,
-0.1171836853,
0.1822694987,
0.1934186965,
0.8233084679,
0.5623654723,
-0.7991045713,
-0.5528509617,
0.4008646905,
-0.6406106949,
-0.2437405586,
-0.3118467629,
-0.1356857866,
0.1488416642,
0.6301253438,
-0.248089999,
0.2219510227,
0.6712107062,
0.0013246754,
0.5002313852,
-0.4821784496,
0.4698780477,
-1.2737900019,
0.2586637139,
-0.2319753468,
-0.3785187602,
-0.5939794183,
0.4967944622,
0.5526540279,
-0.0928378776,
-0.2254387289,
0.0665306672,
-0.5494107008,
-0.2493872046,
-0.4252157211,
0.0937849656,
0.0574146099,
0.2578108907,
0.1737101376,
1.0247873068,
0.5883292556,
-0.366224438,
0.7177518606,
0.3296107948,
-0.2999513745,
0.4589337111,
-0.5345860124,
0.3806766272,
0.0434233956,
0.2581143081,
-0.7653326988,
-0.0827854425,
0.2307287157,
-0.6475716829,
0.2311076224,
-0.3082758486,
-0.6509185433,
-0.4773646295,
-0.4610981345,
0.3499478102,
0.3721900582,
-0.7504349947,
-0.0049323887,
-0.0193262957,
-0.2111952901,
-0.4564715326,
-0.9330999255,
0.185880065,
-0.0489807241,
-0.6546087861,
0.6616088748,
-0.3463197351,
-0.1056883112,
0.108174637,
-0.2032592297,
-0.221027717,
-0.4432478249,
0.0758650601,
0.5583172441,
-0.3411459029,
-0.0112359915,
0.0178906173,
-0.3263994455,
-0.0015843398,
-0.638435483,
0.3651376069,
-0.1892702878,
-0.5161036849,
0.0528908633,
0.356646806,
0.4893671572,
-0.3307483792,
0.5423702002,
0.8924654126,
-0.1177849397,
0.17933622,
-0.6137793064,
0.0723653138,
-0.4640776515,
0.1364834905,
-0.6375464797,
-0.6728708148,
0.4653820097,
0.0529718958,
0.1936651766,
0.1275375485,
0.5124291182,
0.3079440892,
0.9569318891,
0.59680444,
-0.3295123875,
0.507104516,
-0.2076472342,
0.1079875305,
-0.6755794287,
-0.0777188316,
-0.8851837516,
-0.0692771226,
-0.7644333243,
-0.8493056297,
0.1144741103,
-0.0995699167,
0.0977885127,
0.9997683167,
-0.637173295,
0.6057298183,
0.6394143105,
0.0585035495,
0.493175298,
0.1898084432,
0.022404233,
-0.0500274524,
-0.6342371106,
-0.239852488,
1.3290674686,
0.1152528301,
0.5389144421,
0.0767778978,
0.7939810753,
0.0724783018,
0.4276067913,
-0.3466422558,
0.026950594,
-0.2331528217,
-0.3830485642,
0.1652715206,
-0.7880510688,
-0.6568450928,
-0.1020319164,
-0.1878425777,
-0.320780009,
0.2525719404,
0.0671569407,
-0.0424627066,
0.0397619605,
-0.8109154701,
0.837415278,
-0.0921170935,
-0.3768693805,
-0.5143335462,
-0.5840548277,
0.3670989275,
-0.1639574468,
0.0919824615,
0.3225026727,
-0.160124287,
0.1799803674,
-0.5636249185,
0.285128206,
0.1888651401,
-0.049631644,
0.1798253208,
-0.1674444824,
0.5341073275,
0.2243136317,
-0.266515255,
0.1488125622,
0.1008741856,
-0.7445980906,
-0.7177501917,
0.9138829708,
-0.578494668,
-0.0997272506,
-0.2239019573,
-0.87743783,
-0.0965441316,
0.0106392447,
0.0797648355,
0.4237727225,
0.1016951203,
0.2093784362,
0.5267840028,
-0.3489546478,
0.2426555753,
0.5373861194,
-0.055910781,
-0.6451304555,
1.0302135944,
-0.3232408464,
0.4240543246,
0.4389341474,
-0.1932561249,
-0.2572696507,
-0.548808217,
-0.6430335641,
0.0641093031,
-0.6552571058,
-0.2973688841,
-0.3393267095,
-0.0814196616,
-0.651265204,
-0.2806271017,
-0.332133323,
-0.4729455113,
0.1917574704,
0.0318714045,
0.3670719862,
0.563996017,
-0.1530918926,
0.1637077034,
-1.0798701048,
0.3922750056,
-0.1290851831,
0.2446363866,
-0.614351511,
-0.2469749004,
-0.5757142901,
0.0359458402,
-0.1795344353,
-0.692774713,
0.2625660598,
-0.1390980184,
0.4191337824,
0.1072342023,
-0.0780913904,
1.0195547342,
-0.3176121116,
0.5378075242,
0.4081117213,
-0.7739854455,
0.3713746965,
-0.2204468846,
0.6115202904,
0.8224919438,
0.1765763462,
-0.4999019802,
-0.6173181534,
-0.5384638906,
-0.6590631008,
0.7171379328,
0.6031567454,
0.1862497032,
0.1835767031,
0.287845403,
0.0934002325,
0.1556504071,
-0.4014920294,
-0.3190569282,
-0.0857271254,
-0.27000615,
-0.131199345,
0.1989785135,
0.0099233417,
-0.2917202115,
0.4504192173,
-0.1590476334,
0.1413487345,
0.0739947855,
-0.2257320583,
0.0109083243,
0.1234113351,
0.5551279187,
0.690443933,
-0.1904724687,
0.1066449508,
0.2338189781,
-0.6504610181,
-0.2489948422,
0.4072561562,
-0.0136889061,
0.2741998136,
0.2463270724,
0.5741308928,
0.0976789519,
-0.5550214648,
0.2866173387,
-0.0040850923,
-0.077007398,
-0.1635873467,
0.0977193564,
0.0699066743,
0.0723119304,
0.071333766,
0.384811908,
0.1042063758,
-0.5435964465,
0.4019776881,
-0.0400694497,
-0.062526688,
-0.1371323168,
0.4575758576,
0.2107430249,
-0.0425284021,
0.6106501222,
-0.4269690216,
-0.4419513047,
0.7284941673,
0.6408061981,
0.5642910004,
-0.0051541361,
0.0463701338,
0.5976139307,
0.3535291255,
-0.0428590737,
0.2982597649,
-0.325553149,
-0.4793846905,
-0.7479928732,
-0.4023144841,
-0.442545712,
-0.1792130023,
-0.6122432947,
0.4896875024,
-0.0561113544,
0.2713458836,
0.0162266847,
0.1629664749,
-0.7333450913,
-0.0648811981,
0.4420065582,
0.9263600111,
-0.783149302,
1.3416864872,
0.9698518515,
-0.7649611831,
-0.5540133119,
0.0087174987,
-0.2860291004,
-0.5836818814,
0.4139122367,
0.1080838516,
0.0736424625,
-0.0254045594,
-0.3808404505,
-0.8500692248,
0.8384507298,
0.5502895117,
-0.5375644565,
0.0780077055,
0.5086229444,
0.6252616048,
-0.4346633852,
0.3809190989,
0.6952697039,
0.5363224745,
-0.057104867,
-0.8004513979,
-0.0524940453,
-0.4335190356,
0.2060052305,
0.1675086766,
-0.1988468319,
0.4634102583,
-0.0287560802,
-0.0558006018,
0.0936003625,
0.6361713409,
0.2206312716,
0.3162944317,
0.1934027225,
0.4641320109,
0.6687187552,
0.0019655889,
1.087749362,
-0.8296378255,
0.2390015572,
1.3685933352,
-0.0723507032,
0.4920323789,
0.5294269919,
-0.2758308947,
0.582431674,
0.3750120997,
-0.1820776612,
0.2039813101,
0.2560862899,
-0.2845782638,
-0.0219764095,
0.0336176194,
-0.5718441606,
0.0663993135,
0.4276452363,
-0.3193409145,
-0.2251204103,
0.0407915711,
-0.0173922107,
0.3924003839,
0.0691971853,
0.4919983447,
-0.0982514322,
-0.8970073462,
0.7197398543,
0.1962273419,
0.5752279162,
-0.4420798421,
-0.0967021435,
-0.4438058436,
0.1825736761,
-0.4454244077,
-0.6355335116,
0.7506076097,
0.4163383842,
-0.1613024473,
-0.2248888761,
0.5581632853,
-0.6211040616,
-0.5779992342,
0.1372722238,
0.3162054121,
0.3468632698,
0.0743080378,
-0.6569823027,
0.3359827399,
0.1878531128,
0.1841081977,
0.1614410132,
0.2390288562,
0.0307487156,
0.3995929658,
0.902767539,
0.2334480435,
0.3987101614,
0.2783085108,
1.1286879778,
-0.3952980936,
-0.2505574822,
-0.618860662,
0.3449852169,
-0.4493375421,
-0.2412662059,
0.7224032879,
1.063751936,
1.2735035419,
-0.1641037762,
0.892608583,
-0.2786743641,
0.3527972102,
-0.477917105,
0.2539505959,
-0.1266090125,
0.4634513259,
-0.2305561751,
-1.1545627117,
-0.4685637355,
0.3729896843,
-0.4081961811,
-0.4242551625,
0.9704796076,
1.1967972517,
-0.4036412239,
-0.102473408,
0.2015779465,
-0.1925488412,
0.1308439374,
0.7828480005,
0.5348280668,
-0.6271543503,
1.0207495689,
-0.4122664928,
0.0436424986,
0.0871117711,
-0.5925104618,
-0.6652007699,
-0.4264155626,
-0.5690885186,
-0.4250986576,
0.0803908706,
0.8875750303,
0.7270295024,
-1.0381537676,
-0.1693539619,
-0.5888245702,
0.1370730847,
-0.2363883704,
-0.1435815692,
0.1767259836,
-0.8956227303,
-1.0759710073,
0.6069378257,
0.052485913,
-0.2652055323,
-0.3150911033,
-0.4461741745,
0.090219669,
-0.1805621684,
0.3407686949,
0.2417197675,
-0.3079422712,
-0.0298161972,
0.0814415216,
-0.3498743176,
0.3445156813,
1.1721801758,
-0.9230136871,
0.6982152462,
0.7790250778,
0.8809856772,
0.501209259,
0.282246381,
0.7334594727,
-0.9720041156,
0.1786064506,
-0.1652392298,
0.1253944188,
0.4853228927,
-0.2696549594,
0.8023816347,
0.1548928767,
-0.3640103936,
-0.7203872204,
0.2082776576,
-0.9152674079,
-0.1832898259,
0.9548411369,
-0.2977119088,
0.0020710037,
-0.1882867068,
-0.3041521311,
0.441770941,
-0.1849978268,
0.5850263834,
0.454670459,
0.0439366251,
0.1878763139,
-0.7407063246,
0.4568530023,
0.3883475959,
-1.0137549639,
-0.0822433382,
0.6609235406,
0.2524598241,
0.3945322037,
0.3276690543,
-0.2873128653,
0.4921578169,
0.2184662074,
0.2065470517,
-0.2073369026,
-0.1132231355,
-0.3216975033,
0.0410200804,
-0.0787670016,
-0.4422856569
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00310v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00310v1
|
Unsupervised Lexical Simplification with Context Augmentation
| 2023-11-01T05:48:05 | 2023-11-01T05:48:05 |
Takashi Wada, Timothy Baldwin, Jey Han Lau
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We propose a new unsupervised lexical simplification method that uses only
monolingual data and pre-trained language models. Given a target word and its
context, our method generates substitutes based on the target context and also
additional contexts sampled from monolingual data. We conduct experiments in
English, Portuguese, and Spanish on the TSAR-2022 shared task, and show that
our model substantially outperforms other unsupervised systems across all
languages. We also establish a new state-of-the-art by ensembling our model
with GPT-3.5. Lastly, we evaluate our model on the SWORDS lexical substitution
data set, achieving a state-of-the-art result.
|
[
-0.3753541112,
-0.5292109251,
0.4424003661,
0.3343508244,
-0.6103334427,
-0.166272223,
-0.263762176,
-0.4683791101,
0.4042009115,
0.3355648518,
-0.7147701979,
-0.4568773806,
-0.5202286243,
0.0474716611,
-0.1698159426,
0.9329624176,
-0.2333835959,
0.4101112485,
-0.2394176871,
0.0109159928,
-0.3703100383,
-0.5147953033,
-0.261339426,
-0.6661362052,
0.4711479843,
0.5240834355,
0.8226813078,
0.5849167705,
0.2997832298,
0.3263118565,
-0.2333863676,
0.1111489236,
-0.2047772259,
-0.2886708677,
-0.3232072592,
-0.1311718076,
-0.6764068007,
-0.1954965889,
0.5341197848,
1.3340834379,
-0.0557141006,
-0.0734158456,
0.1777092367,
0.473611027,
-0.6980652213,
0.3892121315,
-0.7130455375,
0.1574381888,
-0.2094344646,
-0.279327333,
-0.0640417486,
0.0754290298,
0.2222660035,
-1.0659557581,
0.1465633214,
-0.2769583464,
0.4248303473,
0.2565205991,
-0.5762603283,
-0.0157977995,
-0.6153013706,
0.894284606,
-0.3422549367,
0.3142528832,
-0.0230298694,
0.0963639319,
-0.2035398632,
-0.934859395,
-0.2969657183,
-0.1152523234,
-0.2876856625,
0.3346427977,
-0.1845294833,
0.2416332215,
0.1553342491,
0.1780679971,
-0.3387438655,
-0.1032624319,
-0.5937609673,
-0.2639873922,
0.465628475,
-0.1978544146,
0.296661526,
-0.1902267784,
-0.7538750172,
-0.0648217127,
-0.7757537365,
-0.1277726591,
0.2175448388,
0.4109224975,
0.0170528572,
0.5203396678,
-0.4327703416,
0.5161362886,
-0.4489002526,
0.0388359316,
0.4253663123,
-0.621933341,
-0.4321826696,
0.289881736,
0.6740694046,
0.5018151402,
0.3162378073,
-0.1493417621,
-0.180468753,
0.1736941934,
-0.0692541376,
-0.5317572355,
-0.0496202596,
-0.0676939264,
0.0132632256,
-0.0131690791,
0.0359564796,
-0.5069870353,
-0.1542472988,
-0.460485518,
0.6177156568,
-0.3773389757,
-0.1095431671,
0.4605823159,
-0.3065179288,
-0.1405663341,
0.5293279886,
-0.631931901,
0.4586919844,
0.568631947,
0.5544803739,
-0.4112762511,
-0.7914254069,
-0.0599126369,
0.163701579,
-0.4799714088,
0.6708669662,
-0.3286558986,
-0.4091972113,
-0.1192693561,
0.113197647,
0.1853842884,
-0.4299221337,
0.6962010264,
-0.1668851972,
0.2572467923,
-0.4453541934,
-0.4748750329,
-0.2546207607,
0.0491247363,
-0.6088641286,
1.0828844309,
0.0583234914,
-0.8953684568,
0.5422813892,
-0.7220318913,
-0.4620545208,
0.2523782849,
0.060949482,
-0.1068503857,
0.1422990859,
0.4239268899,
0.1906045377,
-0.3190036416,
0.5738698244,
-0.1329622716,
-0.571539104,
-0.2256045789,
-0.5917087793,
0.6030109525,
0.1909833401,
-0.1136830002,
0.1417622417,
-0.3685865402,
0.0255631302,
0.0461657606,
-0.1065312698,
-0.5328032374,
-0.0379672274,
0.3480499089,
0.0327144824,
0.7643947601,
-0.7859655023,
0.2415808737,
-0.415417999,
-0.021875415,
0.43139413,
-0.1025955826,
0.5602812767,
-0.1808740795,
0.502188921,
0.2455951273,
0.1879087985,
-0.2610439956,
-0.3292976618,
-0.5705142617,
-0.4263620973,
0.5719313025,
0.5527334809,
-0.8536540866,
0.3666798174,
-0.5122358799,
-0.3480569124,
-0.2425841391,
-0.1117938384,
0.3790842891,
0.3011095822,
0.6605757475,
-0.223492682,
-1.022298336,
-1.0370466709,
-0.3525308669,
0.2164839357,
-0.0503005758,
-0.3062203825,
0.4029343724,
-0.1619727761,
1.0251069069,
-0.3830326498,
-0.2359856069,
-0.3889638186,
0.2855644822,
0.035307277,
0.710573554,
0.2593144476,
-0.9278856516,
-0.4739309251,
0.1385319829,
-0.6978004575,
-0.2721220255,
0.1905067563,
0.2667309046,
-0.1008108407,
0.8580112457,
-0.1183258221,
0.6965094805,
0.4541085362,
-0.1358198375,
0.2854127884,
-0.6072411537,
0.1599192768,
-1.368457675,
-0.1042180583,
-0.3219482005,
-0.3825857639,
-0.9399405718,
0.1421403587,
0.1836544573,
-0.1113789603,
-0.8632305264,
0.6745213866,
-0.5765713453,
-0.1463870853,
-0.3492570519,
-0.0967636779,
-0.362025857,
0.5235925913,
0.3729992509,
0.7443315387,
0.8137537837,
-0.3133717775,
0.2581749856,
-0.0660759881,
-0.2725389004,
0.1591973752,
-0.757463038,
-0.2974118292,
-0.332724601,
0.3012476265,
-0.9399701953,
-0.2795276344,
-0.1789869666,
-0.3044120967,
-0.0299947001,
-0.1589702815,
-0.5419683456,
-0.1299903691,
-0.3816184402,
0.7870352864,
0.2628962696,
-0.7295736074,
0.5415622592,
0.4373115301,
-0.1557187587,
-0.7078965306,
-0.8756381273,
0.1026378199,
-0.1508159935,
-0.5410606861,
0.8635417819,
-0.1406027824,
-0.0210722908,
-0.1456604749,
-0.1643805653,
-0.099576287,
0.0944752097,
0.1347786784,
0.389752686,
0.1329758614,
0.0542678386,
0.3095265925,
-0.1219609752,
-0.2577823997,
-0.078577064,
0.6572135091,
-0.1100859717,
-0.4207185805,
-0.2489353269,
0.6472901702,
0.4830806255,
-0.2140968442,
0.4666161537,
0.3757211566,
-0.6150194407,
0.092331022,
-0.2423640788,
-0.1148949116,
-0.4585121274,
0.3983184695,
-0.5096486211,
-0.8867909312,
0.682413578,
-0.2015273273,
-0.0592409633,
0.3333562016,
0.3619419336,
0.2893337607,
1.0829588175,
0.6288487911,
0.0580141284,
0.4609262943,
0.0382204577,
0.1410703063,
-0.6090693474,
-0.1854474097,
-0.2118094862,
-0.0965753123,
-0.8900486827,
-0.4870145023,
0.7541876435,
0.2837359309,
0.2008439004,
0.444216758,
-0.1621352881,
0.7638127208,
0.5609886646,
-0.0100334771,
0.3230646551,
0.0942830443,
-0.5322567225,
0.0155788707,
-0.6405405402,
-0.2193718404,
1.1888321638,
0.0598071814,
0.6361461878,
0.023525428,
0.8940453529,
0.1094667241,
0.2064848691,
-0.6396442056,
0.6500356197,
-0.2357032001,
-0.52550143,
-0.4227999151,
-0.3562149405,
-1.1159448624,
0.580160737,
-0.1786102206,
-0.8122158647,
0.0252160914,
-0.0615196005,
-0.0571298152,
0.0885971114,
-0.9359337687,
0.8589126468,
0.3000903428,
-0.3691313267,
-0.0216552,
-0.3769659102,
0.2387806773,
-0.2199338377,
0.2522696853,
0.1245360747,
-0.2837427557,
0.6722276211,
-0.71120435,
0.5640668869,
-0.1199055836,
-0.0252264012,
-0.0128811384,
-0.0503651015,
0.4561141133,
0.0253137816,
0.0489683859,
0.1562206298,
0.1783368737,
-0.4792050421,
-0.5135114193,
0.7690173984,
-0.5532824993,
-0.5274707675,
-0.5758242607,
-0.8824440837,
-0.2561522424,
0.3602274358,
0.3398573399,
0.4558862746,
-0.5715565681,
0.2148373574,
0.2226774395,
0.0870181546,
0.609176755,
0.6359601021,
-0.2765375376,
-0.290040791,
0.5596972108,
0.1440031379,
0.0721997768,
0.3674301505,
0.2968003452,
-0.5309510231,
-0.4392713606,
-0.2855654657,
0.094873473,
-0.7706354856,
0.070648469,
-0.4605411291,
0.0007734169,
-0.7177637219,
-0.2417249531,
-0.5027336478,
-0.4522451758,
-0.0100518893,
-0.0026923867,
0.0637192503,
0.7828514576,
-0.3604628444,
0.4331432581,
-0.4467675984,
0.2221285403,
0.3981069922,
-0.0548618734,
-0.4282972515,
-0.3924313784,
0.0126537802,
0.1774956733,
0.094369784,
-1.0212501287,
0.4750449955,
0.0217135083,
0.5638129711,
0.1110869125,
-0.0531311966,
0.9010118246,
-0.7296972871,
0.7233455777,
0.347943902,
-1.1596744061,
0.2706867158,
-0.5811551809,
0.8135038614,
0.5881969333,
0.3592408895,
-0.6607145071,
-0.180523932,
-0.6021623015,
-0.9406225085,
0.7133539319,
0.1158893183,
-0.0075344983,
0.0322276875,
0.0884623528,
-0.0411930308,
0.2284253985,
-0.9337697625,
-0.3658434451,
-0.0612051636,
-0.2038917542,
-0.3623829484,
-0.1618749499,
0.1337786019,
-0.6599915028,
0.6609434485,
-0.2507206202,
0.0564662926,
0.2440892011,
-0.0652283728,
-0.0452431515,
0.5091656446,
0.6052567959,
0.7752459645,
-0.0751327351,
0.3300127387,
0.598670125,
-0.2888942361,
-0.0059143216,
0.4061388075,
-0.3337002099,
0.205938369,
0.3397573829,
0.6927137971,
0.4468072057,
-0.5351872444,
0.7369914055,
0.0444010682,
-0.3780799806,
-0.4359345436,
-0.3595176637,
0.2352743745,
-0.0557280965,
0.36047104,
0.1476029456,
0.4237266481,
-0.6844434738,
0.204696238,
0.541762352,
-0.3723012209,
-0.1739564687,
0.2319504619,
-0.1258970797,
0.1052403525,
-0.2544501424,
-0.4309709966,
-0.718652308,
0.4004794657,
0.5947884321,
0.5731349587,
-0.5162500143,
0.2164561749,
0.336340338,
0.3619730473,
-0.3449335098,
0.5579791665,
-0.1977948993,
-0.7053045034,
-0.4495398402,
-0.5121617317,
-0.3658789396,
0.3259935975,
-0.7967968583,
0.4692078531,
-0.0537317358,
0.2206030637,
0.0761121809,
-0.0551795736,
-0.6150746346,
0.2804654837,
0.0063209734,
0.7677849531,
-1.0303074121,
1.0637178421,
1.0069755316,
0.0108112739,
-0.7035551667,
0.0043167896,
-0.0696793422,
-0.6542589068,
0.4738425612,
0.0789195299,
-0.3965362608,
-0.087121889,
-0.3280805945,
-1.0241360664,
0.9026814699,
0.5287587643,
-0.2754265964,
-0.0881053135,
0.4694924355,
0.5752557516,
-0.3083560467,
0.3256881833,
0.4710856378,
0.5293567181,
0.2778949142,
-1.1077924967,
-0.1599826366,
-0.2423125505,
0.1424430907,
0.2253546715,
-0.0412719846,
1.0371812582,
0.0095805917,
-0.3924150467,
0.0714480951,
0.7787052989,
-0.1272842735,
0.1072921753,
0.6560618877,
0.56011796,
0.5990217924,
-0.1542990059,
0.8818736076,
-0.2745097876,
0.5013988018,
1.3196567297,
-0.1437570751,
0.6685737967,
0.7338593602,
-0.0778768584,
0.2189415395,
0.6108734012,
0.3725748062,
0.5656779408,
0.2031374127,
-0.4660504758,
-0.2760196924,
-0.4330426455,
-0.3899831176,
0.6478415132,
0.1557317525,
-0.0294086356,
-0.7426744103,
0.2801629305,
0.3965287805,
0.1431426704,
-0.497764945,
0.7713770866,
-0.3095307946,
-1.1434434652,
0.7615337372,
0.3970692754,
0.990344882,
-0.7563220859,
0.1655825824,
-0.2036646903,
0.2594944239,
-0.0394008383,
-0.5407576561,
0.2445954978,
-0.0504739434,
0.2020205706,
-0.4162395298,
0.5397330523,
-1.017890811,
-0.654111445,
0.5397624969,
0.6625144482,
0.12292815,
-0.2729815245,
-0.5050610304,
-0.1722726077,
0.1152342856,
0.0275334157,
0.283357501,
0.3404788375,
-0.114475973,
0.3460617661,
0.5199525952,
0.0693635046,
0.1113660634,
0.0553318672,
0.960421443,
-0.4111725092,
-0.6938778162,
-0.6234579682,
0.1709432453,
-0.0454921685,
-0.2445834577,
0.8648582101,
0.7801865935,
1.1071748734,
-0.2653923333,
0.6698706746,
0.2362251282,
0.6062206626,
-0.5186159015,
0.4422998428,
-1.0774235725,
0.0538396612,
-0.3902909756,
-0.8230202794,
-0.2624287307,
0.1852091998,
-0.1930202842,
0.0533259995,
1.0254229307,
1.0562781096,
-0.4063047767,
0.0628986731,
0.6698191166,
-0.310803473,
-0.1821202636,
0.5033963919,
0.5541312099,
-0.4855324626,
0.2593831718,
-0.3752776086,
-0.3368729651,
0.1011752635,
-0.9714340568,
-0.7187535167,
-0.8627019525,
-0.2246781588,
0.1219922155,
0.1367277801,
1.0890238285,
0.6320450306,
-0.6771942377,
-0.4650259316,
-0.4318469465,
0.0616852343,
-0.1456955969,
-0.1570842862,
0.1894058585,
-0.3215390742,
-1.0411959887,
0.8759036064,
0.047924947,
0.1516021192,
-0.2436019778,
0.0771360025,
-0.2881422043,
0.20511958,
0.3795453608,
0.0237428155,
-0.7312457561,
-0.1850926727,
-0.1516332924,
0.071880959,
0.1912437379,
0.8905138969,
-0.7072067857,
0.549736917,
0.5905833244,
0.187060982,
0.5338900089,
-0.1768011302,
0.573692143,
-1.1684771776,
0.5786774158,
-0.0772046596,
0.8546210527,
0.457021147,
0.036716558,
0.3204530776,
0.289873004,
-0.0586511083,
-0.6141013503,
0.4270909429,
-0.9485905766,
-0.5446050167,
1.1032515764,
-0.0403286479,
-0.3798875213,
-0.1089369506,
-0.1532289684,
0.3768125772,
-0.2995512486,
0.2836562097,
0.6420247555,
0.3132169247,
0.0413764082,
-0.1584055573,
0.7360978723,
0.7830966711,
-1.0380290747,
0.1026983112,
0.4198934734,
0.2514897883,
0.3162849844,
0.6167204976,
-0.2382000834,
0.4607373774,
-0.2556703091,
0.5048779249,
-0.1181888133,
-0.5479177833,
-0.6079766154,
0.1626639366,
-0.2569113672,
-0.0096636489
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00306v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00306v1
|
Probing Explicit and Implicit Gender Bias through LLM Conditional Text Generation
| 2023-11-01T05:31:46 | 2023-11-01T05:31:46 |
Xiangjue Dong, Yibo Wang, Philip S. Yu, James Caverlee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) can generate biased and toxic responses. Yet
most prior work on LLM gender bias evaluation requires predefined
gender-related phrases or gender stereotypes, which are challenging to be
comprehensively collected and are limited to explicit bias evaluation. In
addition, we believe that instances devoid of gender-related language or
explicit stereotypes in inputs can still induce gender bias in LLMs. Thus, in
this work, we propose a conditional text generation mechanism without the need
for predefined gender phrases and stereotypes. This approach employs three
types of inputs generated through three distinct strategies to probe LLMs,
aiming to show evidence of explicit and implicit gender biases in LLMs. We also
utilize explicit and implicit evaluation metrics to evaluate gender bias in
LLMs under different strategies. Our experiments demonstrate that an increased
model size does not consistently lead to enhanced fairness and all tested LLMs
exhibit explicit and/or implicit gender bias, even when explicit gender
stereotypes are absent in the inputs.
|
[
-0.1487604082,
-0.8489871025,
0.9293391705,
0.2893991172,
-0.0664833635,
-0.2037127465,
-0.2077593207,
-0.1535350829,
-0.2009035796,
0.6206507683,
-1.0119692087,
-0.5358153582,
-0.5577521324,
0.584350884,
-0.504434824,
1.1739176512,
-0.03780514,
0.4163014293,
-0.3440681398,
0.19378905,
-0.5590615869,
-0.5821267962,
-0.6669209599,
-0.3513547182,
0.5809784532,
0.2945589721,
0.2990286648,
0.306725949,
0.2784338295,
0.3722843528,
-0.2646865249,
0.2343753874,
-0.6467865705,
0.3217456937,
-0.1370909959,
-0.4976530373,
-0.575684011,
0.3574919999,
0.6829359531,
0.5456083417,
0.1418726593,
0.3677049279,
0.2104345113,
0.691747129,
-0.8537685275,
0.0463747494,
-0.8283641338,
0.1192366928,
-0.0903143659,
-0.3154396117,
-0.4863529801,
-0.4393078685,
0.0901673213,
-0.1513060778,
0.3221852481,
0.0420691743,
0.4997935295,
-0.0007230401,
-0.8344789743,
-0.4942165017,
-0.5222995877,
0.7950130701,
-0.8169034123,
0.1987542808,
0.1838751286,
0.043303296,
-0.1928009838,
-0.4280782342,
-0.7928489447,
-0.5248708725,
-0.4073495865,
0.1055152267,
-0.0642442033,
0.0692275688,
0.4180241227,
0.0153253349,
-0.3272715211,
0.0659775212,
-0.0808941647,
-0.1025319546,
0.651109457,
0.2383100092,
0.3218457997,
-0.4864322245,
-0.2802508473,
0.0979309902,
-0.8549737334,
-0.1583263725,
1.0330702066,
0.4206696153,
-0.2132312208,
0.8828106523,
0.1161026061,
0.3578808904,
0.2593357861,
-0.2191122174,
0.1275867969,
-0.3798668385,
-0.0904333293,
0.269415617,
0.9866158366,
0.4650197327,
0.4053185582,
0.0801778361,
-0.3412545025,
0.113227807,
0.1185607165,
-0.9634134173,
0.375405401,
0.2263735533,
-0.4513508379,
-0.6774821877,
-0.2721569538,
-0.8112217188,
-0.4785522223,
-0.0065784371,
0.3126134872,
-0.0099309813,
-0.1815316975,
0.0399243161,
-0.3138077557,
0.1653101444,
0.0636875406,
-0.8920650482,
0.1950493008,
0.5631411076,
0.370649755,
-0.1917508096,
0.0012180363,
-0.6319973469,
0.1921099871,
-0.3687880337,
0.4084850848,
-0.4937018752,
-0.501919806,
0.2805965841,
-0.0740405768,
0.2737721205,
-0.3152616918,
0.6471936107,
-0.2336130291,
0.5894999504,
-0.3496032357,
-0.3525323868,
0.1825159043,
0.2077856809,
-0.4769305289,
0.9477002025,
-0.105320625,
-1.1720856428,
0.5750865936,
-0.6625131369,
-0.5668188334,
-0.2736581862,
-0.6677393913,
-0.4837858975,
-0.1339197457,
0.4071427584,
0.4398337603,
-0.5290175676,
0.7641149759,
-0.5061895251,
-0.2967401147,
0.3776478171,
-0.5688792467,
0.5565365553,
-0.2195528895,
-0.7226860523,
0.0719234869,
-0.5117995739,
-0.311869055,
0.2785378098,
-0.2183030546,
-0.384111166,
0.1909662187,
-0.1260480434,
0.1573431492,
0.1883485764,
-0.7543261647,
-0.0441498496,
-0.4020016193,
0.1759830862,
1.1151224375,
-0.1654451787,
0.6757281423,
-0.2019865364,
0.4544127584,
-0.0972226039,
-0.0067710453,
0.0201282948,
-0.286005944,
-0.8833713531,
-0.2819321752,
0.1186259687,
0.4319467247,
-0.8458000422,
0.2732928097,
-0.2124568671,
0.1567085385,
-0.2817203104,
0.0790337771,
0.7819317579,
0.7077258229,
-0.0099479416,
0.2245761007,
-0.7507504821,
-1.2712988853,
-0.5325836539,
-0.3897786438,
-0.14048706,
0.5937856436,
0.5758238435,
-0.0338231958,
1.0907101631,
-0.5508387089,
-0.1482220888,
-0.3988919556,
0.2367931008,
0.1956345141,
0.2236790359,
0.6153131723,
-0.6514047384,
0.082614325,
-0.4086686373,
-0.736486733,
-0.6561496854,
0.0808069855,
-0.2788203061,
0.1937313527,
0.5958865285,
-0.4902042449,
0.3240167201,
0.8492944837,
-0.5477945805,
0.51880759,
0.1809115857,
0.1770382375,
-0.739779532,
-0.1130466163,
0.1467971206,
-0.3028433621,
-0.5691506863,
-0.1039083526,
0.0825645849,
0.0453485064,
-0.6643635035,
1.0129032135,
-0.5396533012,
-0.1968579292,
-0.2295786142,
0.1652119756,
0.1760222018,
0.2658335268,
0.0985918716,
0.8095443845,
0.1223338693,
-0.6745771766,
-0.2070857882,
0.0290261712,
0.0663995668,
0.4269468188,
-0.6638008952,
0.2022735476,
-0.397051096,
0.6258434057,
-0.9159359932,
0.0243920051,
0.3708024621,
-0.4318617582,
0.2498660684,
-0.3532118201,
-0.5982102156,
-0.4286943078,
-0.5439872742,
0.5163138509,
0.5785722136,
-0.5642701387,
0.5533412099,
0.1867613494,
-0.2368507981,
-0.6340682507,
-0.6397665143,
-0.1849643588,
-0.1785500944,
-0.6736460328,
0.1249186024,
-0.2949696183,
-0.370146066,
-0.3308601677,
-0.0730014443,
0.2959161401,
-0.0721723139,
0.2605488002,
0.4358797073,
-0.1321277767,
-0.0020872005,
0.4653111398,
0.3071004748,
0.3191414475,
-0.0763018951,
0.6216751337,
0.0866613463,
-0.2996335924,
-0.0918857604,
0.407097429,
0.2914708853,
0.0253369343,
0.6467883587,
0.60704422,
-0.1449272782,
-0.3672681749,
-0.6053913832,
-0.4328427613,
-0.5979337096,
0.3428201079,
-0.2130068541,
-1.1701737642,
0.2148824036,
0.1493802816,
0.1064359024,
0.3097001314,
0.7467881441,
-0.0208630525,
1.5097953081,
0.627622664,
0.4392872751,
0.0854125023,
0.1863472611,
0.1806013733,
-0.7021775246,
-0.1707929224,
-0.5792796016,
-0.1641985625,
-0.8685659766,
-0.3003150523,
0.2980681062,
-0.3649439514,
-0.5407999158,
-0.3733716905,
-0.2146245986,
0.2776734531,
0.3602158427,
0.1764570475,
0.2579489946,
-0.1654153019,
-0.2658437192,
-0.1835835278,
-0.6198807955,
-0.7235732079,
1.1348166466,
0.4039179981,
0.5917560458,
0.1173730269,
0.5982208252,
0.3539203703,
0.718769908,
-0.4726170897,
0.8113757372,
-0.3131753206,
-0.9063485265,
-0.1615818739,
-0.7162137628,
-0.7591888905,
0.2144258916,
-0.376368016,
-0.4508565962,
0.2403844893,
0.1928197443,
0.0591474883,
0.2679756284,
-0.5780471563,
0.1883241534,
-0.2750398517,
-0.4546442926,
0.4513917565,
-0.2566769719,
1.037795186,
-0.2596867085,
0.4454255402,
-0.2778730094,
-0.1938669682,
0.7503378987,
-0.3706579208,
1.0868786573,
-0.0814367458,
-0.6120487452,
-0.1016213,
0.2182242125,
0.4956510067,
0.4019117355,
-0.2906552851,
0.1782686263,
-0.5456867814,
-0.2786613405,
-0.3985145688,
0.6667081714,
-0.6807945967,
-0.7947944999,
-0.3761473894,
-0.6139491796,
-0.3911959529,
0.3103619218,
0.3191027939,
0.1329475194,
-0.2301190495,
-0.3356391191,
0.6372427344,
-0.6535772681,
0.2891436219,
0.8180142045,
-0.4360790253,
0.0161110498,
0.4532043636,
-0.4234667718,
0.211370036,
0.2809706032,
0.3544751704,
-0.3232118189,
-0.3615770638,
-0.3664610386,
0.3366256356,
-0.4908863604,
-0.2971542478,
-0.7752426267,
-0.1446371526,
-0.616836071,
-0.0822894052,
-0.3617662489,
-0.0547821149,
-0.1723896861,
-0.2840061188,
0.4440548718,
0.697514236,
0.0206737332,
0.3298266828,
-0.522779882,
0.6905897856,
0.5859434009,
0.1690547317,
-0.1369190365,
-0.3536728323,
0.504586935,
0.1582414508,
-0.0272167102,
-0.9232081771,
0.4280269742,
0.0135201374,
0.4167810977,
0.2304967493,
-0.0408541858,
0.1950513422,
-0.8752654791,
0.7881380916,
0.3140790462,
-1.2005851269,
0.6464140415,
-0.7187410593,
0.0495882668,
0.3805888593,
0.2519316375,
-0.0810631588,
-0.8579975963,
-0.4289394617,
-0.836722672,
0.7423215508,
0.5651425719,
0.4894844592,
-0.3317036629,
0.6382028461,
0.2748529315,
0.4132770598,
-1.1693069935,
-0.5431400537,
0.1075518429,
-0.0432218798,
-0.0153661352,
-0.6254376769,
-0.2672264278,
0.0255969036,
0.5040595531,
-0.0623341873,
0.2455139458,
0.1533687413,
-0.1492153555,
-0.0010108836,
0.3715534508,
0.5462422967,
0.2915408611,
-0.424690634,
0.1488838494,
0.2572661936,
-0.4423445463,
0.4122095108,
-0.1711035073,
-0.6431691051,
0.1544270962,
0.426561445,
0.7709289193,
0.1009643599,
-0.6760113239,
0.8171643615,
-0.4020335674,
-0.6559165716,
-0.1331301928,
0.0475798994,
0.1175970659,
0.1928461939,
0.3282999396,
-0.4425723553,
0.1833582073,
-0.5801374316,
0.0677711591,
0.5096089244,
-0.3302499056,
0.077679269,
0.6568566561,
0.2977371812,
0.0037302624,
0.3676559329,
-0.3339897394,
-0.5066626668,
0.6317957044,
0.7197262049,
0.8419082761,
-0.1326845586,
0.383171618,
0.3228140175,
0.6502555013,
0.1390402764,
0.3771002591,
0.4330251515,
-0.8071326017,
-0.3623231947,
-0.6436547637,
-0.118387498,
0.2514224946,
-0.5080299377,
0.4358543158,
-0.4591763914,
-0.3287433684,
-0.355994761,
-0.25370574,
-0.7400637269,
0.215265587,
0.4432614148,
0.6240854859,
-0.9828339219,
0.2240064889,
0.3850890398,
-0.2135794163,
-0.6472395658,
0.1722063124,
0.083971411,
-0.9761714339,
1.0946522951,
0.1953089535,
-0.4298039079,
-0.330423981,
-0.7323073745,
-0.5721614361,
0.970631063,
0.6369782686,
-0.6681958437,
-0.1761566103,
0.2507736981,
0.3471008539,
-0.4488480985,
0.6144565344,
0.6241054535,
0.7146986723,
-0.2415785491,
-0.7026817203,
0.4464943409,
-0.236565873,
0.1418409348,
-0.0729748905,
-0.4486410618,
0.9489614367,
-0.1448764652,
-0.1466927826,
-0.0203214679,
0.7780808806,
0.6308873296,
0.2248335481,
0.6663070321,
0.167454496,
0.4914481342,
-0.0020126717,
1.1170339584,
0.0686616302,
0.001966482,
1.1352404356,
-0.6758318543,
0.3818800449,
0.4432712197,
0.0546516441,
0.4581091702,
0.3978123963,
0.1455319673,
0.2516472042,
0.7132601142,
-0.3310553432,
-0.1402810067,
-0.272158742,
-0.4341288507,
0.5663651824,
0.2768986523,
-0.5146468282,
-0.1576929986,
0.0267081726,
0.5684688091,
0.1113554165,
-0.3442031741,
0.5873953104,
0.2065282315,
-0.617842257,
0.3392962813,
0.3488794267,
1.2031428814,
-0.6154353619,
-0.0769827291,
-0.6830660701,
-0.1785476357,
-0.1194432601,
-0.5712064505,
-0.235716939,
0.4614360332,
-0.3019310236,
-0.3347530365,
0.825969398,
-0.4040733874,
-0.848864913,
0.3755436242,
0.5896158814,
-0.1543802917,
0.1558843851,
-0.4418150187,
0.0390320979,
0.053386014,
-0.3003849983,
0.4506793618,
0.4628687799,
-0.0155179538,
0.6335416436,
0.7852698565,
0.1848371774,
0.1010238156,
0.4029515982,
0.7075238228,
-0.496655643,
-0.192286551,
-1.0430757999,
0.3600194454,
-0.0593608618,
-0.1300383806,
0.8494982123,
0.3493318558,
0.385692507,
0.1884241998,
0.9574694633,
0.2842380702,
0.4554515481,
-0.7745914459,
0.8441702127,
-0.6221641302,
0.5620722771,
-0.6929292679,
-0.7950649261,
-0.0382696241,
0.279055506,
-0.39627105,
0.3433770537,
0.7320956588,
0.758150816,
0.0952472165,
-0.0691812783,
0.0868480653,
0.4162017107,
0.3167420924,
0.2088023424,
1.0951834917,
-0.1968569756,
0.6481100917,
0.1232940331,
-0.3250500262,
0.0758840516,
-1.3966879845,
-1.1562763453,
-0.1943019331,
-0.0828780085,
-0.4895597398,
0.3870660067,
0.4726495743,
0.3963320255,
-0.2700231075,
-0.1190143898,
-0.0430043042,
0.3585193753,
0.5247569084,
-0.2779162824,
0.2124873251,
-0.2393124551,
-0.8847467303,
0.1959926933,
0.0287385918,
-0.1326628625,
-0.3707641065,
-0.049953334,
0.0503438599,
0.3634881079,
0.7847443223,
-0.2840286195,
-0.4745443761,
-0.3214959502,
-0.0383111089,
-0.1804389656,
-0.2925876975,
0.8919206858,
-0.7152467966,
-0.1032867059,
0.4713138342,
0.1854530275,
0.3224877119,
-0.326056838,
1.2005163431,
-1.0905485153,
0.1945700198,
0.2444656044,
0.3541279137,
0.2550226152,
-0.5720361471,
0.122972399,
-0.1112588868,
-0.2769319117,
-0.9530185461,
0.3293834627,
-0.723521769,
-0.4526540637,
1.7458703518,
0.2145996839,
-0.0821044073,
0.1916696429,
-0.2876240909,
0.3736923337,
-0.5174746513,
0.4446910322,
0.4845432043,
0.074359946,
0.0965894759,
-0.7900944948,
0.4853171408,
0.5823714733,
-0.8280009031,
-0.1017289162,
0.5743187666,
0.3452600539,
-0.4184948206,
0.8620119095,
-0.2058943659,
0.1309262961,
-0.1694245189,
0.1819636226,
0.1264981478,
0.0078083919,
-0.0380258299,
-0.1015755907,
-0.1248464063,
0.2546747625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00301v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00301v1
|
Detecting Syllable-Level Pronunciation Stress with A Self-Attention Model
| 2023-11-01T05:05:49 | 2023-11-01T05:05:49 |
Wang Weiying, Nakajima Akinori
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
One precondition of effective oral communication is that words should be
pronounced clearly, especially for non-native speakers. Word stress is the key
to clear and correct English, and misplacement of syllable stress may lead to
misunderstandings. Thus, knowing the stress level is important for English
speakers and learners. This paper presents a self-attention model to identify
the stress level for each syllable of spoken English. Various prosodic and
categorical features, including the pitch level, intensity, duration and type
of the syllable and its nuclei (the vowel of the syllable), are explored. These
features are input to the self-attention model, and syllable-level stresses are
predicted. The simplest model yields an accuracy of over 88% and 93% on
different datasets, while more advanced models provide higher accuracy. Our
study suggests that the self-attention model can be promising in stress-level
detection. These models could be applied to various scenarios, such as online
meetings and English learning.
|
[
-0.2432961017,
-0.7419868708,
0.415007323,
0.5238316655,
-0.0160103384,
-0.4024901986,
0.0547503009,
-0.6180840731,
0.3108074963,
0.3881137967,
-0.5877286792,
-0.4621111155,
-0.5275619626,
0.3696127236,
-0.3858650327,
0.5315735936,
0.1902827919,
0.219739154,
-0.166099444,
0.1192875206,
-0.6043187976,
-0.5034600496,
-0.6822676659,
-0.1539348513,
0.3557671607,
0.5694537163,
0.3290849626,
0.6614867449,
0.6574711204,
0.3329908848,
-0.2526616156,
-0.2950676084,
-0.3433182836,
0.2992453575,
0.0767115802,
-0.4180189967,
-0.5322512388,
0.0072437292,
0.5952217579,
0.4416777492,
-0.1006948277,
0.4604999125,
0.2170624882,
0.0760538951,
-0.4084507525,
-0.0050620306,
-0.5088230968,
-0.0181564242,
-0.3006044924,
-0.2615340054,
-0.2325020134,
-0.0682391748,
0.2911303937,
-0.5635591745,
0.2547816932,
0.1161990091,
0.8364500999,
0.6483424306,
-0.269754827,
-0.0746583641,
-0.9320940971,
0.7322933078,
-0.7749452591,
0.6021761298,
0.6006363034,
-0.0629555956,
-0.0680335984,
-0.3245905936,
-0.4821922183,
-0.2589594722,
0.1258211285,
0.276966393,
-0.2417934239,
0.2770962715,
-0.0026637036,
0.5918647647,
-0.6161496043,
0.1694019884,
-0.3547199667,
0.0387947001,
0.1837364584,
0.0173248984,
0.6825944185,
-0.374946177,
-0.4183747768,
0.1684823036,
-0.1733099371,
0.2581809163,
0.2557631731,
0.4788942635,
-0.2157959938,
0.2262247056,
-0.2072637379,
0.4548863173,
0.3795881271,
-0.4622096717,
0.0759322718,
0.0084166741,
-0.24974145,
0.1319924891,
0.4804180264,
0.1635097265,
0.4015771449,
0.2647096217,
-0.1869897991,
0.0424675196,
0.3872825503,
-0.4168517292,
-0.2418320924,
0.4937842488,
-0.3590737581,
-0.2215595841,
-0.5669962764,
-0.4575894177,
-0.1812566221,
-0.3274686635,
0.6712315679,
-0.3731355071,
-0.5506743193,
0.1078037694,
0.0903608352,
0.0057634013,
0.0175144151,
-0.7556812167,
0.4207776785,
0.5133065581,
0.7202182412,
0.0973198339,
-0.3058989942,
-0.1391857415,
-0.178995207,
-0.3179866076,
0.8731204867,
-0.5294555426,
-0.4649303555,
-0.25884372,
-0.1385261565,
-0.1479649246,
-0.6230326295,
0.7205097675,
0.1408947557,
-0.0160419438,
0.1323302537,
-0.853260994,
-0.0437676124,
0.1998634636,
-0.7818503976,
1.2778066397,
0.0692781135,
-0.6419494748,
0.0014585271,
-0.3950678706,
-0.495203346,
0.3852063119,
0.01111231,
-0.3693524003,
0.323110491,
0.2739980221,
0.3851378262,
-0.1491888762,
-0.0844421759,
-0.2105982453,
-0.1161032245,
0.4199311733,
-0.2231243849,
0.4067444503,
0.0063732238,
-0.2695576549,
-0.0094631519,
-0.7829568386,
0.1763478965,
-0.004207937,
-0.094078064,
-0.4577178359,
-0.1404299438,
-0.1629882455,
0.2388345003,
0.1371139139,
-0.5113182664,
-0.2283846736,
-0.5215457678,
0.3772921264,
0.3967244923,
0.342625618,
0.0053455862,
0.0173930433,
0.8113281131,
0.0547015108,
0.4353839457,
0.0306513645,
-0.5472527146,
-0.7355862856,
-0.3643399477,
0.326138854,
0.6186782718,
0.1443063468,
0.454087168,
0.2006231248,
-0.4633702338,
-1.151307106,
-0.0386149287,
0.4733794332,
0.7337203622,
0.5766983032,
-0.1553024948,
-0.3334088922,
-0.7584339976,
-0.321188271,
-0.1334729493,
0.106539771,
0.2586927414,
0.1935022622,
0.2448663563,
0.4959923923,
-0.4078579545,
-0.5877789855,
-0.1816154569,
0.5774559379,
-0.2401015013,
0.3324296772,
0.0128261605,
-0.642386198,
-0.2689971924,
-0.182866171,
-0.4526836276,
-0.343074739,
-0.0518771447,
0.1190123856,
-0.0148705794,
0.5699995756,
-0.4004085362,
0.2731567919,
0.4611584544,
-0.1843592972,
0.5086935163,
-0.1890103668,
0.128191635,
-0.934497416,
0.0954596177,
0.2878469527,
-0.2027250826,
-0.984873116,
-0.1224471554,
0.1879048944,
-0.4029062688,
-0.3687707186,
0.4016974866,
-0.6463544369,
-0.0425799079,
-0.410657227,
0.2101060003,
0.1711793989,
0.3255004287,
0.06466382,
0.5979850888,
0.5116429329,
-0.6192849874,
0.0617442802,
0.0512205772,
-0.4287189245,
0.761918962,
-0.7133771777,
0.0537888259,
-0.0360734984,
-0.0537112281,
-1.283028841,
-0.0218519457,
-0.1753015667,
-0.6637551785,
0.4284540415,
-0.1502842009,
0.2601601779,
-0.5569091439,
0.1953894645,
0.6215398312,
0.3066718578,
-0.1618855447,
0.4233977199,
0.6227509975,
-0.4381888807,
-0.538007915,
-0.3740208447,
-0.0228093006,
-0.3879311383,
-0.509942472,
0.3800932169,
0.0509115383,
-0.1130910441,
0.1171917096,
-0.2340292335,
-0.3631102741,
0.2164915949,
0.6045402288,
-0.1026919261,
-0.1538799256,
0.4832267463,
-0.5295308828,
-0.1835449934,
-0.0347469933,
-0.250539273,
0.4184041321,
0.0582434051,
0.047242105,
-1.04233706,
0.5508671999,
0.5883596539,
-0.5837352276,
0.1897255033,
0.487837404,
-0.7997352481,
-0.1821395308,
-0.7493637204,
-0.3187039196,
-0.3948096037,
0.3476509154,
-0.7252187133,
-0.6014938951,
0.5222158432,
-0.0316757448,
-0.6327607632,
0.4516414106,
0.3701869249,
-0.4407107234,
1.0091483593,
0.7031436563,
-0.2477227896,
0.3193925023,
-0.1052140892,
0.2708432674,
-0.7525984049,
0.0800817013,
-0.6325312853,
-0.3939092755,
-0.4036819339,
-0.2858348489,
0.2964254618,
0.002155462,
0.2668553591,
0.2810115218,
-0.4706136286,
0.3672549427,
0.5968459845,
-0.0569259599,
-0.1002319381,
-0.4010305107,
-0.1005956531,
-0.1772261709,
-0.2403095663,
-0.1997662485,
0.4745953381,
0.6316434145,
0.8260807395,
-0.1828083098,
0.8625274897,
0.1433214098,
-0.3702550828,
-0.9524942636,
0.4031610787,
-0.0627482459,
-0.7464733124,
-0.7266499996,
-0.3449042141,
-1.0062892437,
-0.1097550243,
-0.1283959597,
-0.5092930794,
0.3487830758,
0.3617210686,
-0.8279668689,
-0.1848081201,
-0.5636197329,
1.1388697624,
-0.2693396509,
0.1367238909,
-0.3236000538,
-0.5026575923,
0.1300732493,
0.1584796011,
0.2970376313,
-0.4584289193,
0.2673099637,
0.5823639035,
-0.222314164,
0.9996938109,
-0.0828753337,
-0.1938228607,
0.4465573132,
0.2697484791,
0.4146711528,
-0.5470745564,
0.1980485171,
0.0024184601,
-0.0216948763,
-0.1888668388,
-0.4832908809,
0.6391277313,
-0.8215479851,
-0.5840876698,
-0.1049711183,
-0.531958878,
-0.1432985663,
-0.1250375211,
0.3506999612,
0.6783059239,
-0.3055285811,
-0.1285968721,
0.5174101591,
0.1103841215,
0.1883594096,
0.4840182364,
0.1379817575,
-0.1353284419,
1.0641158819,
0.7567917109,
0.239799127,
0.3805918396,
0.4792809188,
-0.522403419,
-0.3223784268,
0.0758428723,
0.2921691537,
-0.6711349487,
-0.0757789686,
-0.6629291177,
-0.2335964143,
-0.7847077847,
0.1466969103,
-0.5802298784,
-0.457285434,
-0.3717284203,
-0.2541680634,
0.4233246446,
0.7735555172,
-0.2368647158,
0.2168244123,
-0.6171920896,
0.4123841524,
0.5253156424,
0.2941675484,
-0.0484386086,
-0.8576052785,
-0.0519029386,
-0.4279961884,
-0.1892651916,
-1.0668026209,
0.6194120049,
0.5365442634,
0.4390115142,
0.4412498474,
0.2544718385,
0.5994470716,
-0.3895039856,
0.6037492156,
-0.0473125353,
-1.2455022335,
0.6592291594,
-0.0747222975,
0.2643847466,
0.3644888103,
0.7219099998,
-0.8051293492,
-0.6378954053,
-0.7913802862,
-0.8737653494,
0.3237573504,
0.0883453414,
-0.189087376,
-0.2950818539,
0.2694543898,
-0.1298590302,
-0.205917716,
-0.6935740709,
-0.0640749633,
-0.1107888818,
-0.4205979407,
0.0009345624,
-0.6169935465,
0.1885414422,
-0.0769072026,
0.6863744259,
0.207233429,
0.1999191344,
0.5569368601,
-0.3033169806,
-0.3963221014,
0.4068053365,
0.6913707256,
0.2361067235,
-0.4377426803,
0.4178321362,
0.3712205887,
-0.5426087379,
0.3131871819,
-0.0927501544,
-0.0250235815,
0.0187298153,
0.384771198,
0.8163607717,
0.5529110432,
-0.1377110481,
0.4705419838,
0.151694417,
0.0449637026,
-0.2539069653,
-0.1851936877,
0.2980925143,
0.1772619188,
0.0280163847,
-0.3943443,
0.5337732434,
-0.5350183249,
0.2946833372,
0.142616421,
-0.5079128146,
-0.335611552,
0.6039549112,
0.6612539291,
-0.4003929794,
0.3284200728,
-0.1249868423,
-0.8557898402,
0.6946379542,
0.7190152407,
0.9473690987,
-1.1986527443,
0.0193321574,
0.4978195727,
0.3347887993,
0.0387369283,
0.6934586763,
0.1822719425,
-0.6133751273,
-0.229267329,
-0.5493747592,
-0.4844762981,
0.3781491518,
-0.9292300344,
0.2065633237,
-0.2269722223,
-0.5873094201,
0.3561235964,
-0.0347042866,
-0.6298327446,
0.8489653468,
0.5937858224,
0.5419474244,
-0.8275546432,
0.6384934187,
0.2683865428,
-0.1460187137,
-1.0375262499,
0.028442217,
0.1730464995,
-0.9303036928,
0.6899679303,
0.4317005575,
-0.5491656661,
0.4314133227,
0.0874091685,
-1.1337417364,
0.6172158122,
0.0970992669,
-0.7398776412,
0.2320584059,
0.1741839051,
0.4895370603,
-0.2609255314,
0.4588986635,
0.3662347794,
0.3215491772,
-0.328517586,
-1.0794605017,
-0.2171767801,
-0.2677892447,
-0.1456407458,
0.1340602338,
-0.4604756236,
1.0481572151,
-0.0721412674,
-0.6022488475,
-0.3715346158,
0.7453104854,
-0.4266569316,
0.021875916,
0.7092692852,
0.720629096,
0.9979006052,
0.0962257311,
0.7941313386,
-0.5973929763,
0.2703404725,
1.19454813,
-0.384390384,
1.1868726015,
0.0161926746,
-0.0295582172,
0.1997820735,
0.7370188236,
0.1632362008,
0.077139847,
0.3893345594,
-0.2524799407,
-0.4934202433,
-0.4546476603,
-0.2830142975,
0.7955520749,
0.5348019004,
-0.1063196138,
0.152068764,
0.2909706831,
-0.1303621978,
0.0114269033,
-0.5191618204,
0.6973102093,
0.1230541319,
-0.5466040373,
0.8741081357,
-0.2110999227,
0.332994312,
-0.2978056669,
0.2029399127,
-0.1990699023,
0.1797602624,
-0.0344823562,
-0.7281086445,
-0.031215284,
0.0078427996,
-0.2025623024,
0.0768731087,
0.8960245252,
-0.7828687429,
-0.4770236909,
0.7233661413,
0.2585254014,
0.6015354991,
-0.4253163636,
-0.4033067524,
-0.006025,
-0.4099274874,
-0.3019880056,
0.0763740838,
0.4812105596,
0.2127492875,
0.7144163847,
0.0975837186,
0.1618936658,
0.4198990166,
0.3388213813,
0.0423987657,
-0.8492699862,
-0.6154161692,
-0.5796874166,
0.3223152459,
0.0764339119,
-0.6740173101,
0.4693447351,
0.0622438528,
0.5288909674,
-0.0830357075,
0.6418452859,
0.6656028032,
0.7665182948,
-0.4015558064,
0.5513623953,
-0.5946784019,
-0.5945461392,
-0.0935257152,
-0.475697726,
-0.1686431319,
0.7059016824,
-0.2560328245,
-0.1248285174,
0.7713563442,
0.7332547903,
0.170350641,
-0.1030471995,
0.7153400183,
0.3515800536,
-0.1594800204,
0.4927400351,
0.6771072745,
-0.0832039565,
0.604126215,
-0.4114256501,
-0.1675889939,
-0.5663047433,
-0.7163007259,
-0.6706079245,
-0.7303779721,
-0.6168412566,
-0.0074505201,
-0.0364020243,
0.9701806307,
0.7707127929,
-0.5847831964,
-0.3152527809,
0.2249939442,
-0.3036873937,
-0.5473279357,
-0.1570692211,
0.2656534612,
-0.556332171,
-0.6758016944,
0.67852211,
0.2894200683,
0.4734064639,
-0.2335880995,
0.3042497933,
-0.3254231215,
0.4987452626,
0.1825948656,
0.3970828056,
-0.8669694662,
-0.4551285505,
0.0094617326,
-0.409655273,
0.0477465987,
0.6368622184,
-0.208313778,
0.5749916434,
0.3145744801,
0.3293293715,
0.2505709529,
0.1323840469,
0.5239306092,
-1.0903218985,
0.0236535072,
0.2315789759,
0.3070517182,
0.5045906901,
-0.8272693753,
0.2894086838,
0.1792094707,
-0.6906515956,
-0.7581646442,
0.0833629146,
-0.9684931636,
-0.1229353398,
0.8054252267,
-0.3122147322,
-0.3567773998,
-0.1805687994,
-0.1415662169,
0.553532064,
-0.062201906,
0.7914748788,
1.0348125696,
-0.0732193664,
-0.4121568501,
-0.5248637199,
0.8171579242,
0.7999961376,
-0.5660773516,
0.2601686716,
0.0239635855,
0.1697365195,
0.3119337857,
0.4855591953,
0.3317903876,
0.1860406846,
0.1856939346,
0.6989961267,
0.3280544579,
-0.7759634256,
-0.5543162823,
0.1912446469,
0.3045623302,
-0.5356600881
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00300v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00300v1
|
Entity Alignment Method of Science and Technology Patent based on Graph Convolution Network and Information Fusion
| 2023-11-01T05:04:55 | 2023-11-01T05:04:55 |
Runze Fang, Yawen Li, Yingxia Shao, Zeli Guan, Zhe Xue
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The entity alignment of science and technology patents aims to link the
equivalent entities in the knowledge graph of different science and technology
patent data sources. Most entity alignment methods only use graph neural
network to obtain the embedding of graph structure or use attribute text
description to obtain semantic representation, ignoring the process of
multi-information fusion in science and technology patents. In order to make
use of the graphic structure and auxiliary information such as the name,
description and attribute of the patent entity, this paper proposes an entity
alignment method based on the graph convolution network for science and
technology patent information fusion. Through the graph convolution network and
BERT model, the structure information and entity attribute information of the
science and technology patent knowledge graph are embedded and represented to
achieve multi-information fusion, thus improving the performance of entity
alignment. Experiments on three benchmark data sets show that the proposed
method Hit@K The evaluation indicators are better than the existing methods.
|
[
-0.2688498199,
-0.5079561472,
0.2325540483,
0.0892670006,
-0.4185191393,
0.5848988295,
0.1384892911,
-0.6160075068,
0.5932282209,
0.1152002513,
-0.3547400832,
-0.5354279876,
-0.458368361,
-0.4445416927,
-0.1456750184,
0.6583214402,
-0.1326005459,
0.2506661713,
-0.3243811727,
0.1957283169,
-0.3905345201,
-0.0729601905,
-0.2746247947,
-0.4790320992,
0.3585062325,
0.2825703323,
0.4786366522,
0.713563323,
0.7992568612,
0.3433104455,
-0.1130141094,
0.2545136511,
0.0339762457,
-0.1440458447,
-0.1465628743,
0.0257744584,
-0.3143516183,
-0.1388689876,
0.7575277686,
0.535941124,
0.2831287086,
0.1718845516,
0.1852776408,
0.1391643435,
-0.4948712289,
0.4722914994,
-0.4741626084,
0.1844877303,
-0.3570707738,
-0.3273745775,
-0.3733229935,
-0.7242823839,
0.3404577971,
-0.7245411873,
0.1871819645,
0.5058678985,
1.1958198547,
-0.0325110257,
-0.3224246502,
0.0608174093,
-0.5702006221,
0.5367864966,
-0.4565216303,
0.3234579563,
-0.6308742166,
0.3360432386,
-0.3317326605,
-0.7783769369,
-1.0356929302,
-0.0772683322,
-0.2327131629,
-0.0464724302,
0.0305621289,
0.1797514111,
0.162545532,
-0.3009939194,
-0.755874157,
0.2905569971,
-0.536021173,
-0.7563726902,
0.4630859792,
-0.3001437187,
0.239212364,
-0.1704010516,
-0.9603284597,
-0.4461807311,
-0.6167940497,
-0.0622618124,
0.2439876795,
0.3850799799,
0.4150100052,
0.9439231753,
0.0639552921,
0.5046038628,
0.1484101862,
-0.1961516589,
0.5219187737,
-0.6723754406,
-0.3475621641,
1.0152209997,
0.788032949,
0.3827781379,
-0.2084838748,
-0.2316409945,
0.1657252759,
0.0114209224,
-0.0335673206,
-0.6770169139,
0.0221388042,
0.3315696418,
-0.5628418326,
0.1283844411,
0.0553832091,
-0.6875227094,
-0.7294690609,
-0.2735027075,
0.576561451,
-0.6700033545,
-0.4090167284,
-0.2645072639,
-0.6669924855,
0.1586370915,
0.0774309412,
-0.7112311125,
0.064595297,
1.0035551786,
0.8978206515,
0.0504386909,
-0.2882698476,
-0.0945029482,
0.5173177719,
-0.0441666991,
0.82992661,
-0.3155194223,
-0.190345481,
-0.2398316413,
0.0628537536,
-0.2899384797,
-0.1091085896,
0.3291132748,
-0.8346143365,
-0.1920863688,
-0.1990555376,
-0.8814275861,
-0.5392225981,
-0.0124634886,
-0.6647047997,
0.5219722986,
-0.1541694552,
-1.0158114433,
0.9106988907,
-0.9462493062,
-0.3537485301,
0.3102107346,
-0.109155193,
-0.6010543108,
-0.4933001399,
0.0647750124,
0.2671692967,
0.0074673775,
0.5138388276,
-0.6528360844,
-0.1889549941,
0.0268063452,
0.4033880234,
0.9163988829,
0.2834194005,
-0.2621153295,
0.2582514286,
-0.6983601451,
0.1459230036,
0.0321583413,
0.0775636509,
-0.4062952995,
-0.1026593819,
-0.3579156995,
0.2222882658,
0.4816951156,
-1.1503102779,
0.3495094776,
-0.3919915259,
0.4313225746,
0.5226904154,
0.2321339399,
0.4661588967,
-0.0200972352,
0.0346326716,
-0.0065640882,
0.3056884408,
0.3151951432,
-0.6176252961,
-0.3175196946,
-0.2092058808,
0.7306975722,
0.4012711644,
-0.6602545381,
0.7174881697,
-0.6915719509,
-0.7514651418,
-0.7905759215,
-0.2241132408,
0.3299518526,
1.1444424391,
0.376124382,
-0.3545764685,
-0.646281302,
-1.174023509,
0.0123946182,
-0.0359438621,
0.1913750321,
0.1522423774,
0.4272803962,
0.3751929998,
0.9167099595,
-0.2372187227,
-0.0693707243,
0.2737801671,
0.4086998701,
0.3972101808,
0.6585073471,
0.2412163913,
-0.8877241015,
-0.2188258916,
0.3320914209,
-0.564274013,
0.5312222838,
0.2370215654,
-0.3487771153,
0.0345705152,
-0.0119908499,
-0.8055224419,
0.1941985339,
-0.001623765,
-0.2078412324,
0.2118553817,
0.0725708976,
0.5376551747,
-1.1473449469,
0.4979689121,
0.1457898468,
0.0127479034,
-0.3820751309,
-0.175789386,
0.3681165576,
-0.2565939724,
-0.7002132535,
0.4195105433,
-0.4736854136,
-0.2851585746,
-0.0376800485,
0.4314140975,
0.3858968019,
0.0908519328,
-0.1353815645,
0.597676456,
0.596845746,
-0.6047099829,
0.9715048075,
0.3020365834,
-0.7070425153,
0.4949021041,
-0.3942796588,
0.1798747033,
-0.0704387352,
0.3447869718,
-0.779224515,
0.0932175443,
0.2799656987,
-0.0685845315,
0.6622592807,
0.0510992631,
-0.7572588325,
-0.6949798465,
-0.3030557632,
0.0938148648,
0.1284790188,
-0.5973733664,
0.8297014236,
0.3327377439,
-0.3529973924,
-1.0507159233,
-0.5189968348,
-0.0142889973,
-0.2927975655,
-1.1954760551,
1.3245004416,
0.2074066848,
0.1220054254,
0.6004710793,
-0.0149554294,
-0.0418436453,
-0.0931806192,
0.0335857756,
0.6496425867,
-0.4936510324,
0.5258722305,
0.2145915478,
-0.2132576555,
-0.3663783967,
-0.5673136711,
0.5107964277,
0.2951110303,
-0.3020987809,
-0.5941183567,
0.2026603967,
0.1470560431,
-0.0268964991,
0.7719210386,
0.3128376603,
-0.625033617,
0.3736202121,
-0.4908797145,
0.0030561171,
-0.4240718186,
0.3698374033,
-0.3407782316,
-0.4738045931,
0.3883448839,
-0.5208871961,
0.0156970788,
0.8280360699,
0.1507051438,
-0.1650521904,
0.7642078996,
0.5724697709,
-0.2031221837,
0.3543950021,
-0.1431106329,
0.8858587146,
-0.9036000371,
-0.7358540893,
-0.8192315102,
-0.6786624193,
-0.1173315346,
0.1529200375,
0.217851311,
0.3150194585,
-0.5589835644,
0.7438532114,
-1.2839739323,
0.0379903093,
0.9308665395,
0.1608992666,
0.1540233791,
0.2227096856,
-0.4910458028,
-0.0866754055,
-0.4825484157,
-0.4450199008,
0.872551024,
0.1770116389,
0.6114255786,
-0.1226059422,
0.522046864,
0.1382612288,
0.0553072877,
-0.6315364242,
0.4555912614,
0.0929040685,
-0.5251256227,
-0.3772582412,
-0.0269424524,
-0.6378947496,
-0.2264696062,
-0.315132618,
-1.1319783926,
0.728376925,
0.1127324551,
-0.4148185253,
0.0937477127,
-1.1382186413,
0.6672732234,
-0.4376258552,
0.2126882672,
-0.2638765872,
-0.7421441078,
0.1870218813,
-0.0844291225,
-0.1105726883,
0.0489647575,
0.1421830058,
0.9725267887,
-0.5848813057,
0.4251076281,
-0.4513534606,
0.1542869061,
0.3508888483,
-0.508926332,
0.5601785779,
-0.4173603058,
-0.3551952541,
0.0619072393,
-0.0403573588,
0.041203279,
-0.682780385,
0.7249469757,
-0.2096392661,
-0.5485571623,
-0.2223410904,
-0.3875649869,
0.0526988581,
0.4837880433,
0.3321534395,
0.0210303031,
0.0573052429,
0.0913606584,
0.4365396798,
0.0797170997,
0.5546870232,
0.2511106431,
0.2471360266,
-0.4607227147,
1.0085946321,
0.5716946721,
0.0038203844,
0.4299628139,
-0.0847210437,
-0.644472301,
-0.2551364899,
-0.5172623396,
0.1310876757,
-0.8918439746,
-0.5742210746,
-0.8656685352,
-0.5581476092,
-0.8711131811,
0.0109643787,
-0.0730153695,
-0.6424070001,
-0.072984837,
-0.0124755707,
0.5749308467,
0.1711054593,
0.2918637395,
0.0414302349,
-0.5461656451,
0.02969216,
0.1048847511,
0.3179627955,
0.0069922972,
0.0735229775,
-0.087906301,
0.1878835261,
-0.6593931913,
-0.6140132546,
-0.3530398905,
0.2366030067,
0.6787420511,
0.3180252612,
-0.2046312839,
0.7308883071,
-0.532173872,
0.5944746733,
0.468341887,
-0.9994958043,
0.5990337133,
0.5086365342,
-0.448905468,
-0.0570574068,
0.3948444426,
-0.04845706,
-0.1176961958,
-0.7197882533,
-0.6484780908,
0.4440065324,
-0.2539209425,
-0.1980534345,
0.4993043542,
0.1705275625,
-0.0326604508,
0.180704087,
-0.592539072,
-0.1687857509,
-0.3056626618,
-0.4235604405,
0.6692397594,
0.0337056033,
-0.5141012073,
-0.0188160073,
1.1404262781,
-0.0355967842,
0.4204613268,
0.0949177966,
0.170816958,
0.031596262,
0.2061636746,
0.4485024512,
0.5600488186,
-0.2054903954,
0.0340593681,
-0.2105044723,
-0.2774653733,
0.204511106,
0.8538927436,
-0.092824094,
0.1284304857,
0.178554222,
0.6527273059,
-0.0151119139,
0.066340737,
0.3728734851,
0.3032469749,
-0.1845752597,
0.3739354312,
0.1438887119,
0.3296149373,
0.6502459645,
0.4206329584,
0.0717655644,
0.3217888474,
-0.2573061585,
0.2849514484,
0.7222157121,
-0.1623600572,
0.1984906346,
0.4476461112,
-0.1108774319,
-0.1561736315,
0.4094822705,
-0.1075269133,
-0.2845292389,
1.0450261831,
0.8353436589,
0.6305395961,
-0.1014007255,
0.2565126717,
0.2260382622,
0.2959426939,
0.1848511249,
0.3812986314,
0.151358515,
-0.6305044293,
-0.3930496871,
-0.1697517484,
-0.4239418805,
-0.2330503911,
0.0418098718,
0.6477953196,
-0.3943746388,
-0.4488973618,
0.7350408435,
0.1723138094,
-0.7417755723,
0.1749074608,
-0.1660335064,
0.9541684985,
-0.5711733699,
0.7274162769,
0.5998980403,
-0.599970758,
-0.9662780166,
-0.4545347989,
-0.0689546466,
-0.7107743025,
0.8756314516,
-0.0965425745,
-0.0069455421,
0.0960845575,
-0.6935517192,
-1.2588698864,
1.4206510782,
0.5607035756,
-0.5569531322,
0.0844821036,
-0.2150579542,
0.2002719492,
-0.5730900168,
-0.0894133374,
-0.080435276,
0.700974822,
0.3337079585,
-0.8058049083,
0.4305681288,
-0.3212608099,
0.0227076039,
0.2881114185,
-0.4734243453,
0.4367900789,
0.0561338663,
-0.5855929852,
-0.0901718736,
0.6670212746,
0.3116285205,
0.353043586,
0.3916724622,
0.4425594807,
1.0637499094,
-0.2659765184,
0.6648086905,
-0.4255272746,
0.5343587995,
1.0180054903,
-0.6133944392,
0.422291398,
0.4089555144,
0.0677023157,
0.490457505,
0.698053956,
-0.6413950324,
0.7230993509,
0.2398376316,
-0.2570389211,
0.4160507619,
-0.7110355496,
-0.661406219,
-0.0048556398,
0.3472007215,
-0.5846941471,
-0.119251579,
0.0926590934,
-0.0273504686,
-0.6060922742,
0.0369796418,
0.7430796027,
-0.2695907056,
-0.5759032965,
0.1678696275,
-0.1027822196,
0.2111296803,
-0.3591040373,
-0.2143238336,
0.4866194129,
-0.186550796,
-0.3718464077,
-1.0171990395,
-0.0583127476,
-0.233062163,
-0.1564075053,
0.290548861,
0.9567995667,
-0.2504149973,
-0.3546625674,
0.2623914778,
-0.3326013982,
0.0850264281,
0.5769886374,
-0.5713134408,
-0.3991580606,
-0.310151726,
0.2841627598,
-0.1026949584,
0.3739451766,
-0.0471265167,
0.509924233,
0.4234777391,
0.126726225,
0.139058888,
0.1260415316,
1.0019321442,
-0.4167894125,
-0.1708127856,
-0.6761014462,
0.6949577928,
-0.7820206881,
-0.1170810685,
0.3637602329,
0.7845594883,
0.5710570216,
0.1266388595,
0.8407824039,
-0.353312999,
0.2832873762,
-0.6550093889,
0.6931880713,
0.0177871026,
-0.2039142251,
-0.5478435159,
-1.2251826525,
-0.4332917631,
0.1125551909,
0.0832417309,
-0.0493213162,
0.8657220602,
0.701674521,
-0.1652451605,
0.2241874039,
-0.3753896356,
0.1439912319,
0.4957634211,
0.2517679334,
0.2225540429,
-0.4892978072,
0.3594280481,
-0.3838623166,
-0.3844943643,
-0.0665012002,
-1.1494829655,
-0.1465427727,
-0.465172112,
-0.6269344091,
-0.7265369296,
-0.1450488418,
0.6841694117,
0.7129859924,
-0.8230288029,
0.4583541453,
0.1451466978,
0.4266505241,
-0.3502596915,
-0.2285122275,
1.0697176456,
-0.1452137828,
-0.5656064749,
0.2943952084,
0.6991128325,
0.0894920081,
-0.1912795305,
0.148875162,
-0.4621410966,
-0.3184811473,
0.0497883894,
0.3262379467,
-0.652772963,
-0.605050087,
0.1128069833,
-0.2204468548,
0.2181793302,
0.4492539465,
-0.3686504662,
1.0127229691,
0.6444145441,
0.8638892174,
0.2237443477,
-0.0983003527,
0.4519419074,
-0.6789214015,
0.0925049335,
0.077573657,
0.6504396796,
0.369995147,
-0.743259728,
0.2543976903,
0.0554360561,
-0.4615244269,
-0.3671887517,
-0.1819158047,
-1.0768743753,
0.1229753196,
0.3762132227,
-0.2714543641,
-0.4162946343,
-0.0666507035,
-0.0657566637,
0.7630577683,
-0.3424443007,
0.7896814346,
0.9237382412,
-0.2043945491,
0.1676019132,
0.1509725302,
0.1264325529,
-0.0399554931,
-0.6757084727,
-0.6528553963,
0.0109276026,
-0.0211598109,
0.9560850859,
0.1245680153,
-0.357131511,
0.1850762367,
-0.0081814378,
0.7049064636,
0.0001548455,
-0.1966761053,
0.24484016,
0.1952220649,
-0.2756103575,
-0.6610353589
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00296v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00296v1
|
Semantic Representation Learning of Scientific Literature based on Adaptive Feature and Graph Neural Network
| 2023-11-01T05:00:44 | 2023-11-01T05:00:44 |
Hongrui Gao, Yawen Li, Meiyu Liang, Zeli Guan, Zhe Xue
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Because most of the scientific literature data is unmarked, it makes semantic
representation learning based on unsupervised graph become crucial. At the same
time, in order to enrich the features of scientific literature, a learning
method of semantic representation of scientific literature based on adaptive
features and graph neural network is proposed. By introducing the adaptive
feature method, the features of scientific literature are considered globally
and locally. The graph attention mechanism is used to sum the features of
scientific literature with citation relationship, and give each scientific
literature different feature weights, so as to better express the correlation
between the features of different scientific literature. In addition, an
unsupervised graph neural network semantic representation learning method is
proposed. By comparing the mutual information between the positive and negative
local semantic representation of scientific literature and the global graph
semantic representation in the potential space, the graph neural network can
capture the local and global information, thus improving the learning ability
of the semantic representation of scientific literature. The experimental
results show that the proposed learning method of semantic representation of
scientific literature based on adaptive feature and graph neural network is
competitive on the basis of scientific literature classification, and has
achieved good results.
|
[
-0.1800741255,
-0.2119062543,
0.4815020263,
-0.0803530589,
-0.4873912632,
0.2956022024,
-0.0907485858,
-0.5556258559,
0.7583699822,
0.494618386,
-0.2185877413,
-0.6758154631,
-0.6695615053,
0.4548987746,
-0.0519615225,
1.0316617489,
0.0860679224,
0.3340488672,
-0.5986334682,
-0.5443919897,
-0.3108544648,
-0.064993076,
-0.1895576566,
-0.3468381166,
0.8239992857,
-0.0730681643,
0.4416871965,
0.4539507329,
0.5404883623,
0.4591944814,
-0.2290925682,
0.1206388026,
-0.515581131,
-0.0783874914,
-0.3024059236,
-0.5576668978,
-0.1006115973,
-0.1834636629,
1.065038085,
0.8385058045,
0.5094795823,
-0.0722028688,
0.2026348114,
0.7320306897,
-0.1021269187,
0.5753996372,
-0.7662352324,
0.2020354718,
0.0762587413,
-0.4154166877,
-0.4599831998,
-0.3130561411,
-0.063382417,
-0.974832356,
0.50457865,
0.2578836679,
0.6888917089,
-0.0603797957,
-0.5131266713,
-0.2130010575,
-0.2912922502,
0.6408246756,
-0.3681460917,
0.0505430251,
-0.1897567064,
0.008162247,
-0.3636645079,
-0.859048605,
-0.4607554376,
-0.4250028133,
-0.280189693,
0.3526456654,
0.0587393455,
-0.2192859799,
0.0631354973,
-0.0309243705,
-0.4928074181,
-0.0753542408,
-0.6094110608,
-0.4693313837,
0.6349933743,
-0.0618066639,
0.2752117515,
-0.4279080033,
-0.4425230324,
-0.2268119156,
-0.29428491,
-0.1247329116,
0.047888454,
0.3196788132,
0.5947858691,
0.5478749871,
-0.0727830902,
0.553468883,
-0.4210133851,
0.0573457628,
0.6178568006,
-0.111960955,
0.0970532969,
0.6003170013,
0.8167146444,
0.3342702687,
0.0187061056,
-0.380217284,
0.2002265751,
0.2571872175,
0.261778146,
-0.5782592297,
0.0117004924,
-0.2007097006,
-0.5203462839,
-0.185296461,
0.010029031,
-0.5040128231,
-0.4463288188,
-0.1956502795,
0.3048740625,
-0.5880532265,
-0.2436128557,
-0.1836857051,
-0.3446577489,
-0.173447147,
0.4729005098,
-0.6335814595,
0.4711614549,
0.3918725252,
1.2078475952,
-0.2053911388,
-0.431139797,
-0.0878316909,
0.4319530725,
-0.1861389279,
0.9129293561,
-0.3903627396,
-0.0738202035,
-0.2735130787,
0.3145982623,
-0.2743236721,
-0.1164850593,
0.2190646529,
-0.8213891387,
0.0772380456,
-0.1856833994,
-0.6334034204,
-0.86105299,
0.0424622707,
-0.7498908639,
0.6869629622,
0.3565502763,
-1.3911197186,
0.2533688247,
-0.7559152246,
-0.072818622,
0.1302118748,
0.0980537459,
-0.3755215704,
-0.2132930756,
0.1396010667,
0.2208953351,
0.1445170045,
0.0984479561,
-0.6509628296,
-0.4530968368,
0.2081570029,
0.2572018802,
0.8176883459,
0.1020855159,
0.1645853668,
0.4312256873,
-0.8432558179,
0.052411247,
0.2640015483,
-0.0016566553,
-0.6493321061,
-0.0369801112,
-0.0098166214,
-0.1347590983,
0.1477365047,
-0.9448393583,
0.2128006965,
-0.643879056,
0.6098012328,
0.3322728872,
0.4041716158,
0.5235742331,
-0.11601834,
0.0371706411,
0.0092132576,
-0.5157040358,
0.1198309511,
-0.5321146846,
-0.4473714232,
0.031223936,
0.73088938,
0.5296567082,
-0.4918435514,
0.5985127687,
-0.1824955493,
-0.3976221085,
-0.4915035665,
0.3195201457,
0.1643974483,
0.6848151088,
0.4653291404,
-0.3808074892,
-0.3386482596,
-0.3758033216,
-0.1431955248,
-0.2595167458,
0.045422405,
0.1647548079,
0.7345305681,
-0.0901431292,
0.8660002947,
-0.5739514828,
-0.4806937277,
-0.0233476423,
0.3950143456,
0.0806656927,
0.252014935,
0.5227857232,
-0.8663461804,
-0.3745878339,
0.3862987757,
-0.8907048702,
0.1814701408,
0.2763475478,
-0.2157009244,
0.2706757784,
0.5098007321,
-0.2197723091,
0.2035876215,
-0.1262394935,
-0.4111705124,
0.265948385,
-0.6605897546,
0.1809688658,
-0.8394031525,
0.0172925778,
0.0533532239,
-0.2056872398,
0.056102518,
-0.1435640901,
0.3284133673,
-0.3046225905,
-0.1939073354,
0.3992593586,
-0.5499915481,
-0.1602593958,
-0.311085254,
0.4370930493,
0.2754258811,
0.4149424732,
0.1856163144,
0.0670906678,
0.6009839177,
-0.3739768267,
0.710529387,
0.2073040754,
-0.2917581797,
0.1273508519,
-0.3982197642,
-0.0616556332,
-0.5511005521,
0.419274658,
-1.119944334,
-0.0514373332,
0.1236254647,
-0.4030325413,
0.4256394804,
0.1987080723,
-0.3886629641,
-0.3587072492,
-0.1104104519,
0.0571461581,
0.2092306763,
-0.3088437319,
0.5021528006,
-0.0026218223,
-0.3050071299,
-0.4357105494,
-0.4758495092,
-0.0219189934,
-0.1656461805,
-0.7179955244,
0.7731831074,
0.4521151185,
0.1608090252,
0.5054923296,
0.1488395184,
0.4472574592,
-0.190210551,
0.0068548359,
0.2203076631,
-0.1769362092,
0.549126029,
-0.0540961064,
-0.5169098973,
-0.1041254252,
-0.4842900932,
0.136003986,
-0.1495334208,
-0.1426076889,
-0.045274727,
0.3646731675,
0.3082333207,
-0.2195442319,
0.4641371071,
0.6790276766,
-0.2283907086,
0.1720845997,
0.0398865268,
-0.0827124342,
-0.3406804502,
0.7413185835,
0.0309350993,
-0.6506975889,
0.8040338159,
-0.34616974,
-0.4188582003,
0.7102449536,
0.1448530406,
-0.170777902,
0.8558586836,
0.6435191035,
0.0182412639,
0.29651016,
-0.345433861,
-0.0148985982,
-0.922401309,
-0.6358653903,
-0.8184927702,
-0.4085854292,
-0.3322769403,
-0.2916376889,
0.3577536345,
0.4753651023,
-0.6484499574,
0.2043060213,
-1.0736743212,
0.1982231438,
0.5623536706,
0.3702991903,
0.4153074324,
0.5245980024,
-0.8269079924,
-0.3463486731,
-0.423181802,
-0.2814792395,
0.7342871428,
0.1772050261,
0.8294673562,
-0.0368718803,
0.560993135,
0.421096772,
0.072300218,
-0.7199760079,
0.4033125043,
0.0613157898,
0.0422850288,
-0.470842272,
-0.4273007512,
-0.8664371371,
0.4192200899,
-0.3737181425,
-0.8931012154,
0.3753313124,
-0.438354075,
0.1251164824,
0.1548192799,
-0.8094869256,
0.7578243017,
-0.177750513,
-0.1084889695,
-0.181105271,
-0.7638856769,
-0.2571606338,
-0.0124057857,
-0.0457522683,
0.2023450136,
-0.1150470227,
1.0794160366,
-0.3184618056,
1.0070796013,
-0.4223074019,
0.4589045644,
0.2733353674,
0.0223738682,
0.5234119296,
0.2017159611,
-0.3763540387,
0.0257902369,
-0.0250476524,
-0.4586581886,
-0.8172935843,
0.6921166182,
-0.9018691182,
-0.4526287913,
-0.8620625138,
-0.5609005094,
-0.1673547179,
0.6248964071,
0.2720305622,
0.1639922112,
-0.2289306968,
0.0448742546,
0.4891316891,
-0.0335295126,
0.5780422091,
0.3802062869,
-0.3879663944,
-0.7645744681,
0.9588983655,
0.4892248511,
0.0712011829,
0.4793507457,
0.2847653925,
-0.4882358313,
-0.6634238362,
-0.424308598,
0.3354876637,
-1.0513583422,
-0.5001311898,
-1.0211664438,
-0.4694094062,
-0.5976974368,
-0.1728537977,
0.2480799705,
-0.4993709326,
-0.4590235054,
-0.0571462959,
1.2215573788,
0.6894981265,
0.3020354807,
0.1046612486,
-0.6665463448,
-0.0414060317,
-0.0628851205,
0.1494242698,
0.3472860456,
-0.4222061634,
-0.1957156509,
-0.3105709851,
-0.4965527952,
-0.7092871666,
0.4631421566,
0.354308337,
0.5840843916,
0.4199762642,
0.1101062372,
0.3814251423,
-0.5187301636,
0.3322698176,
0.4662668705,
-0.5548201799,
0.4515570402,
-0.1716976911,
0.1359982193,
0.3042318821,
0.7954431772,
-0.4487404227,
-0.4739173651,
-0.6338660121,
-0.4826216102,
0.5982781053,
-0.0904437006,
0.1679675728,
0.1853521466,
0.3068608344,
0.096114561,
-0.1354783922,
-1.0288745165,
0.0338094346,
-0.7533697486,
-0.2787601054,
-0.0241663549,
0.18375507,
-0.082043618,
-0.6484270692,
0.6370686293,
-0.6249161363,
0.5118730664,
0.504711926,
0.0372914895,
0.0564218611,
-0.00768176,
0.2533091009,
0.498685509,
-0.3001644611,
0.0824704319,
0.0461011268,
-0.5972069502,
-0.0340262577,
0.2272174209,
-0.281355083,
0.04844331,
0.6238870025,
0.9658339024,
0.0614563227,
-0.0361749865,
0.2953929603,
0.1418690383,
-0.2421673983,
-0.0290762763,
0.2313181311,
0.6619756222,
0.2255164534,
0.3906603456,
0.5796075463,
0.129964456,
-0.3745416701,
0.0874615759,
0.4260748029,
-0.6707260609,
0.2312412411,
0.28940925,
-0.2811493278,
-0.1616177708,
0.2717925012,
-0.3587094545,
-0.6409320235,
0.8990261555,
1.225713253,
0.2236235291,
0.0959311128,
0.5575626493,
0.4801518321,
-0.1422810704,
0.2725020945,
0.1239883974,
-0.0247550737,
-0.5447965264,
-0.2566157281,
-0.911382854,
-0.0945404992,
-0.4433535337,
-0.1888140291,
0.4760921299,
-0.4225075245,
0.2094000876,
0.3919611275,
0.4332630336,
-0.1528500021,
0.0114616221,
-0.4432479441,
0.7873907685,
-0.7942600846,
0.7785412669,
0.808072865,
-0.5438147783,
-0.5179432034,
-0.3728508353,
-0.2227964401,
-0.7110439539,
0.9203779101,
0.1571033448,
-0.121733278,
0.1046787128,
-0.4092475474,
-1.1420886517,
1.1626830101,
0.3442329764,
-0.3218180239,
0.2103458047,
-0.1951905191,
0.6936927438,
-0.9603256583,
0.3034936488,
-0.4193009734,
0.4160983264,
0.6546556354,
-0.1849879622,
0.2858030498,
-0.4374366701,
0.437384516,
0.022879079,
-0.7012552023,
0.5766893625,
-0.1863456815,
-0.0817983821,
-0.0182509553,
0.8777784705,
0.1054141447,
0.3398768604,
0.3371954858,
0.3880069554,
1.1995521784,
-0.0163414832,
0.7682740092,
0.1637674868,
0.6119585633,
0.4837266803,
-0.5988804102,
0.6234225631,
0.2413958162,
-0.1486389339,
1.004291296,
0.8084399104,
-0.4388059676,
0.8095944524,
0.4282622039,
-0.4140165448,
-0.0039842539,
0.0084799351,
-0.7705485225,
0.3005601168,
0.5367379785,
-0.6718696952,
-0.5294403434,
0.6651934981,
-0.2686955035,
0.2393173724,
-0.5315294862,
1.0007163286,
0.0912250876,
-0.451470226,
0.6896179914,
-0.011761575,
0.3061154187,
-0.6489496827,
-0.2205784023,
0.2969971299,
0.0858927444,
-0.4304980338,
-0.5744959712,
0.1930241436,
-0.4643851817,
-0.5825381279,
0.3702623844,
1.2177170515,
-0.1072069779,
-1.1100176573,
0.7961763144,
-0.1854037344,
0.2482057065,
0.3671406507,
-0.6513597965,
-0.1081193984,
-0.1376959234,
0.0175899826,
0.4737357497,
0.7494255304,
-0.3459650576,
0.4007466733,
0.5239892006,
0.4115186036,
-0.2127933651,
0.1137455627,
0.9021385908,
-0.8266926408,
-0.7049199939,
-0.3283783197,
0.1228541508,
-0.5324023962,
0.0808182806,
0.5253975391,
0.159181878,
0.5708231926,
-0.14665021,
0.6888128519,
0.0126663987,
0.5272528529,
-0.5622950196,
1.0491993427,
-0.2854377329,
-0.0671887547,
-0.3396477997,
-0.9420477748,
-0.8606791496,
0.7413365841,
-0.2996883988,
0.2664920986,
1.1600872278,
0.6994872689,
-0.1032171473,
0.4043560922,
-0.0662186146,
0.2883794606,
-0.2362454087,
0.1461813897,
0.2100669891,
-0.3426836133,
0.3122740686,
0.0550947972,
-0.5312553644,
-0.2564473748,
-1.1714960337,
-0.6877263188,
-0.5619511604,
-0.5092335343,
-0.7887986302,
-0.1013557836,
0.471845448,
0.292555213,
-0.864012301,
0.3819878101,
-0.2053778023,
0.5197246671,
-0.5607255697,
-0.1945390999,
1.1314734221,
-0.7848629355,
-0.2941811681,
-0.0475010723,
0.4191922843,
-0.2102037668,
-0.3900521398,
-0.2430649996,
-0.3636733592,
-0.3918186724,
0.3969288468,
0.3309706748,
-0.4251961112,
-0.2086807191,
-0.1139049828,
-0.0600911938,
0.4749184251,
0.794216156,
-0.9921334982,
0.6711440086,
0.6362888217,
0.6382420063,
0.7814691663,
-0.3811559379,
0.0310486052,
-0.536903441,
0.2285271287,
0.2590191662,
0.618747592,
0.4487101734,
-0.6808089018,
0.2495469749,
0.5386907458,
-0.5987109542,
-0.5102025867,
-0.1021971256,
-1.2615522146,
-0.4843310416,
0.7210448384,
-0.3229704797,
-0.8380679488,
-0.4748409986,
-0.2758454978,
0.4243373275,
-0.2766478956,
0.6431336403,
0.6517752409,
-0.3426064849,
0.0023193667,
-0.2523352802,
0.1911425143,
0.1176657528,
-0.3491227627,
-0.1831069142,
0.235567838,
0.2787281871,
0.8761506677,
0.3739699721,
-0.6521313787,
0.0961382389,
0.1564806253,
0.0735368356,
-0.2246966809,
-0.2071976215,
-0.0934909657,
0.3366849422,
0.084386453,
0.140626356
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00292v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00292v1
|
IBADR: an Iterative Bias-Aware Dataset Refinement Framework for Debiasing NLU models
| 2023-11-01T04:50:38 | 2023-11-01T04:50:38 |
Xiaoyue Wang, Xin Liu, Lijie Wang, Yaoxiang Wang, Jinsong Su, Hua Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As commonly-used methods for debiasing natural language understanding (NLU)
models, dataset refinement approaches heavily rely on manual data analysis, and
thus maybe unable to cover all the potential biased features. In this paper, we
propose IBADR, an Iterative Bias-Aware Dataset Refinement framework, which
debiases NLU models without predefining biased features. We maintain an
iteratively expanded sample pool. Specifically, at each iteration, we first
train a shallow model to quantify the bias degree of samples in the pool. Then,
we pair each sample with a bias indicator representing its bias degree, and use
these extended samples to train a sample generator. In this way, this generator
can effectively learn the correspondence relationship between bias indicators
and samples. Furthermore, we employ the generator to produce pseudo samples
with fewer biased features by feeding specific bias indicators. Finally, we
incorporate the generated pseudo samples into the pool. Experimental results
and in-depth analyses on two NLU tasks show that IBADR not only significantly
outperforms existing dataset refinement approaches, achieving SOTA, but also is
compatible with model-centric methods.
|
[
-0.6944528818,
-0.5348963141,
0.1094338819,
0.1951216161,
-0.2357930094,
0.0339750685,
-0.1340462267,
-0.2892055809,
0.0254816711,
0.6472437382,
-0.5173874497,
-0.4108303487,
-0.4525605142,
0.204565227,
-0.402733922,
1.1964583397,
0.0616528094,
0.0866386816,
-0.3473085165,
-0.4117858112,
-0.4921559393,
-0.0757071525,
-0.3295207918,
-0.6113379598,
0.187191993,
0.6418488622,
0.4571865201,
0.4924182892,
0.451726526,
0.1416822225,
-0.1157919765,
-0.0952363983,
-0.7316302061,
-0.0914780647,
-0.4334046543,
-0.1827086508,
-0.263287127,
0.0123544177,
0.4196337759,
0.6422128677,
-0.1030307785,
0.4288649857,
0.0882828161,
0.9924471974,
-0.7150897384,
0.1156627014,
-0.8372676373,
-0.0371830165,
-0.2702791095,
0.0427787304,
-0.3573541641,
-0.6145696044,
0.4825930297,
-0.4558997452,
0.6296858191,
0.0565517358,
0.8478443623,
0.477771014,
-0.3384149969,
-0.2040795088,
-0.7496427894,
0.9790525436,
-0.7529302835,
0.3502697349,
0.4593648612,
0.4322507381,
-0.0397585779,
-0.3928225935,
-0.8448417783,
-0.1269477606,
-0.1972334534,
-0.0358653478,
-0.0784794465,
0.1262642294,
0.2688367665,
0.5480709672,
-0.5334940553,
-0.0658940971,
-0.5607504845,
0.0883126855,
0.6660444736,
-0.2132201493,
-0.011888288,
-0.1531656235,
-0.5678319335,
0.0817565694,
-0.6859998107,
-0.0116568133,
0.4130651653,
0.3893580437,
0.0555275604,
0.4844957292,
-0.1176482663,
0.9661402702,
0.2981305122,
-0.0982797146,
0.3792397082,
-0.082919091,
-0.2916323543,
0.3633898199,
0.6165059209,
0.2555726767,
0.198271051,
-0.1869520545,
-0.2053405195,
0.3699296415,
0.4100695252,
-0.7629247308,
-0.3081451654,
0.3961510658,
-0.4052157402,
-0.3036085367,
-0.0732624829,
-0.7751021385,
-0.5320768356,
-0.6365612745,
0.2291448712,
-0.4629382789,
-0.4526122212,
0.131605342,
0.066556111,
0.3439694345,
0.0001814737,
-0.2935334444,
0.1852537543,
0.446067214,
0.4185634553,
0.1195195541,
-0.0920576453,
-0.4658839405,
-0.0728345811,
-0.0538158789,
0.9060772061,
-0.7294653058,
-0.2176406384,
-0.2803452015,
-0.5822143555,
0.064198412,
-0.6310757995,
0.5475162268,
-0.595302999,
0.1374399066,
-0.4189529717,
-0.4597688317,
-0.4980266988,
0.4419326186,
-0.8932816386,
1.12269485,
0.2501883209,
-1.1405074596,
0.545901835,
-0.8338467479,
-0.3988684714,
-0.2768121958,
-0.1723909825,
-0.4730575383,
-0.0146388691,
0.3939360976,
0.1501802355,
-0.7122369409,
0.7310531735,
-0.3220317662,
-0.3838954568,
0.0479040444,
-0.1513435096,
0.8023338318,
0.2269732505,
-0.4253514409,
0.0902239606,
-1.1686980724,
0.0133641269,
-0.2710446417,
-0.0840866193,
-0.5219609737,
-0.1078214645,
0.0147483721,
0.2324912399,
-0.3080085814,
-0.5516386628,
0.2168103904,
-0.3442715704,
0.0737151727,
0.8314786553,
-0.2901477218,
0.6403983831,
-0.2808665037,
0.5219681859,
0.1935575306,
-0.0462391451,
0.0542847961,
-0.1700229198,
-0.7113387585,
-0.7362895012,
0.5751097202,
0.3133264184,
-0.8710620999,
0.6161926985,
-0.1997538507,
-0.3992741704,
-1.1151131392,
0.3163183033,
0.5559072495,
0.9060792327,
0.5567471385,
-0.3916607499,
-0.8823469877,
-0.817011714,
-0.2420929372,
0.0002296293,
0.0570766516,
0.0927152708,
0.3142768145,
-0.5224004388,
1.4272987843,
-0.0566133,
-0.7106543183,
-0.5467997193,
0.3560865223,
0.255323559,
0.3621982336,
0.5933256149,
-0.6814613342,
-0.3976324201,
-0.1835810393,
-0.7309615612,
-0.4505639672,
-0.1708855182,
-0.1707361639,
-0.1520671695,
0.3608665764,
-0.2583390176,
0.6284681559,
0.4241217077,
-0.1162910983,
0.2865774632,
0.174203828,
-0.3283750117,
-0.8028026819,
0.3633252382,
0.0826057643,
-0.042028442,
-0.7183113098,
-0.0511338823,
-0.1132697016,
0.2834047675,
0.0758483782,
0.8055904508,
-0.5858390927,
-0.0028203232,
-0.4267269671,
0.2525555789,
0.3326779902,
0.0537540168,
0.0184990373,
0.4007510245,
0.6866252422,
-0.867544055,
0.0548589788,
0.4211085737,
-0.5830279589,
0.6253441572,
-0.5688400269,
0.4054307342,
-0.7790235877,
0.3862265944,
-0.7200609446,
0.2484496683,
0.1905299276,
-0.1469138265,
0.2727396488,
-0.2345627099,
0.1006301343,
-0.3759635985,
-0.3594686389,
0.5346713662,
0.0980919749,
-0.7967320085,
0.8894774914,
0.334669739,
0.0151497405,
-1.1430088282,
-0.6286264062,
-0.3418080509,
-0.0267277919,
-0.3910168111,
0.4337061346,
-0.1252143979,
-0.6595840454,
0.0074172574,
-0.2846876085,
-0.0771867633,
-0.1022432446,
0.191567868,
0.0754506737,
-0.0626255572,
-0.0274747778,
0.0444435887,
-0.2283692658,
-0.2779020667,
-0.1941810101,
0.5896172523,
0.0182358883,
-0.2541925609,
-0.3939631283,
0.0658611804,
0.2333880067,
-0.4728380144,
0.5205852985,
0.5889037251,
-0.2230712771,
-0.3597747684,
-0.7239941359,
-0.2523922026,
-0.4425119758,
0.044342041,
-0.5361026525,
-0.5398255587,
0.5081413388,
0.1960903108,
0.2007612586,
0.0625942498,
0.3706177771,
0.0979479104,
0.5764710903,
0.7916961908,
-0.5075995922,
0.296826452,
-0.5982196331,
0.5279103518,
-0.9876408577,
-0.1492750496,
-0.5140993595,
-0.7469424605,
-0.278776288,
-0.4411492646,
-0.0423948206,
0.0571496449,
-0.1921640188,
0.1164464653,
-0.5143083334,
0.5534636974,
0.6399684548,
-0.0018709712,
0.2811946571,
-0.2464250922,
-0.1061957777,
-0.0080039436,
-0.4598383904,
-0.4155453444,
1.0719519854,
0.0874907598,
0.9373964667,
-0.0626736805,
0.6711767912,
0.3646102846,
0.7694647908,
-0.6786308885,
0.3191854358,
0.1933391541,
-0.7872325778,
0.0492301658,
-0.5531475544,
-0.5065177679,
0.1072928905,
0.0350595675,
-0.5364806652,
0.6670796871,
0.3348147869,
-0.2415883541,
0.2659145594,
-0.4833329022,
0.5187988281,
0.0481364168,
-0.2744885087,
0.1094214991,
-0.5759456754,
0.436634928,
0.0789879337,
0.3241162896,
-0.3167968094,
0.6119235158,
0.5112525225,
-0.2890311778,
0.5691074729,
-0.5943055749,
-0.1627052277,
0.5287100077,
0.2934648693,
0.3763611019,
0.2585115135,
-0.6362868547,
0.1985157132,
-0.4234426022,
-0.2916839421,
-0.3975437582,
0.5805734396,
-0.5465614796,
-0.4686573446,
-0.4779425561,
-0.6788824797,
-0.2010821849,
0.1751410216,
0.3248039186,
0.2928679287,
-0.2686978281,
0.0160499141,
0.6991147995,
-0.1598639786,
0.1408026814,
0.5118607283,
-0.2988642454,
-0.2392947078,
0.669349134,
-0.0706973523,
0.0969413444,
0.3323924243,
0.0204366427,
-0.2300701588,
-0.4982747734,
-0.3720605373,
0.0722317845,
-0.555183053,
-0.5636655688,
-0.6288669705,
-0.107582368,
-0.3702897429,
-0.151337564,
-0.5062278509,
-0.2281109244,
-0.1667607725,
-0.4955602288,
0.6544428468,
0.4502639174,
-0.1433684826,
0.5089538693,
-0.407705605,
0.7934980989,
0.0746984929,
0.4735041559,
-0.1182566285,
-0.6283100843,
0.1293668598,
0.2013860792,
-0.0926582888,
-0.4890210927,
0.4978735149,
0.3510501385,
0.3701803386,
0.7591283321,
0.4808162153,
0.8299995661,
-0.3852713704,
0.2917513251,
-0.1269154549,
-0.9348468184,
0.4465677142,
0.1536247283,
0.2172919959,
1.1302417517,
0.2791693807,
-0.2511176765,
-0.2345107943,
-0.4367941022,
-0.9680657387,
0.7915246487,
0.1211779416,
-0.0394095704,
0.1123991907,
0.3655121028,
0.5023683906,
0.2824136019,
-0.8402183652,
-0.3623737991,
-0.3027514815,
-0.41032058,
0.2054670453,
-0.3109840453,
-0.1274812073,
-0.2651343048,
0.9076747894,
-0.2533248961,
0.2024904788,
0.2104856968,
-0.4951965511,
-0.0240389351,
0.3206073642,
-0.0759722143,
0.7099394202,
-0.5907911062,
0.0889491513,
-0.1217012331,
-0.4690223932,
0.0985727459,
0.4641966522,
-0.6027243733,
0.2161436379,
-0.069628641,
0.8280603886,
-0.184295699,
-0.7148694992,
0.3971781135,
-0.1889461875,
0.1461754292,
-0.0906005651,
-0.1365426332,
-0.3309849799,
0.1651887298,
0.3034973145,
0.146188885,
0.3874724507,
-0.2567209899,
0.3387925625,
0.3837931752,
-0.6900583506,
-0.240196228,
0.4868017733,
0.2253525257,
0.2368797958,
0.6945541501,
-0.2840891182,
-0.4473849237,
0.4531533122,
0.5482738018,
0.884706676,
-0.2691222727,
0.3312539756,
0.4261155427,
0.3485199213,
-0.0147215119,
0.5067408681,
-0.1033419445,
-1.0125148296,
-0.2981697619,
-0.7507715225,
-0.3639066517,
0.2049999982,
-0.9763063788,
0.4138323665,
-0.6572082639,
-0.1279977709,
-0.0636000708,
-0.3396961391,
-0.8777836561,
0.4083672166,
-0.1806878,
0.9518721104,
-0.6435056329,
0.7824248075,
0.5429027081,
-0.2571414411,
-0.4043421745,
0.116824314,
0.1325222701,
-0.6067228913,
0.5582267046,
0.5335754752,
-0.2318758219,
0.0634171963,
-0.3618181944,
-0.7717698216,
0.9543748498,
0.4018589556,
-0.6708420515,
0.0787410513,
0.1085348129,
0.324206382,
-0.3536419272,
0.5406474471,
0.863961339,
0.4483667016,
-0.0599987544,
-0.6292591691,
-0.0947288424,
-0.367367655,
0.1793181896,
-0.0897643864,
-0.5012534857,
0.5836901665,
-0.4256591201,
-0.0832273811,
-0.1998611689,
0.7421292663,
0.3092912138,
0.4430052936,
0.3760981858,
0.7637270093,
0.9594736695,
-0.0966021344,
0.8937091231,
-0.085915111,
0.2812434733,
1.5817682743,
-0.8351535797,
0.3365999758,
0.5138966441,
0.2248918414,
0.5390659571,
0.1278326213,
0.1743495464,
0.7990166545,
0.4066237509,
-0.3578183651,
0.2165177166,
-0.2255458683,
-0.4163194597,
0.5728453398,
0.239128232,
-0.3943937421,
-0.2556777596,
0.3480422497,
0.1117169783,
0.1984256953,
-0.3131985366,
0.8158917427,
-0.0421228893,
-0.3682028949,
0.6626555324,
-0.0407488607,
0.8079036474,
-0.392919898,
0.0307463259,
-0.5097680688,
0.5584223866,
-0.2267964035,
-0.4303713739,
0.3447740972,
0.3598170877,
-0.3694701791,
-0.236151889,
0.7172399163,
-0.3247750401,
-0.5290121436,
0.4568330646,
0.2596271932,
-0.3080921769,
-0.1498800963,
-0.5654549599,
0.1076518148,
0.2783558369,
-0.3110001087,
0.0922015235,
0.4216971695,
0.0109438663,
0.8110671639,
0.4585533142,
-0.1033616588,
-0.0310563575,
0.3822947145,
0.9934563637,
-0.6557075381,
-0.0519166104,
-0.771597147,
0.6316047311,
-0.093274489,
-0.2438135743,
0.4442148209,
0.5330251455,
1.1919929981,
0.0103523443,
1.19756639,
-0.2771876752,
0.7337871194,
-0.3608904481,
0.7024219632,
-0.031895142,
0.5569785237,
-0.2817529142,
-1.0905432701,
-0.305621624,
1.0501799583,
-0.4063547254,
0.0862254575,
0.228689,
0.9329303503,
-0.198237285,
0.1919030547,
-0.1994640976,
0.514770627,
0.3839617968,
0.1619186848,
0.5667268634,
-0.4595765173,
0.2672394514,
-0.4653865993,
-0.2819661796,
-0.126787737,
-0.9232981205,
-0.9577069879,
-0.2019456774,
-0.42779091,
-0.383189857,
0.0102018584,
1.034715414,
0.3845115006,
-1.0603812933,
-0.1618123502,
-0.1358887404,
0.2596428692,
-0.239312619,
-0.3167201579,
0.1777592301,
-0.1679019034,
-0.6985188723,
0.4023635983,
0.0308442637,
-0.4034752846,
-0.1909831166,
0.0212988984,
-0.4249651134,
0.0352454819,
0.3876587749,
0.3714915216,
-0.4241214097,
-0.0514694043,
-0.135759294,
0.136292547,
0.2206773758,
0.8345601559,
-1.2345607281,
0.7920715213,
0.2758092284,
0.6883839369,
0.4295934439,
0.0277411938,
0.675165236,
-1.0246964693,
0.3884474337,
0.4728059471,
0.2986925244,
0.5564081669,
-0.1519467533,
0.5717658401,
-0.261862725,
-0.2329298854,
-1.0329245329,
0.1838739216,
-0.8436460495,
0.0726523548,
0.9811862111,
0.0281686168,
-0.0387497321,
-0.3263828158,
-0.418377012,
0.193201825,
-0.394946605,
1.2339390516,
0.3055930436,
0.1022639275,
-0.1622721702,
-0.2799297273,
0.6064311266,
0.1495399773,
-0.7396335602,
0.4057265222,
0.4357453585,
0.2062757462,
0.0635997802,
0.6679233909,
-0.1805686206,
0.0184100363,
-0.389102608,
0.4073252976,
0.0448100306,
-0.4436922371,
-0.1114578098,
-0.3208494186,
-0.0064251814,
0.1312870383
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00288v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00288v1
|
Active Instruction Tuning: Improving Cross-Task Generalization by Training on Prompt Sensitive Tasks
| 2023-11-01T04:40:05 | 2023-11-01T04:40:05 |
Po-Nien Kung, Fan Yin, Di Wu, Kai-Wei Chang, Nanyun Peng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Instruction tuning (IT) achieves impressive zero-shot generalization results
by training large language models (LLMs) on a massive amount of diverse tasks
with instructions. However, how to select new tasks to improve the performance
and generalizability of IT models remains an open question. Training on all
existing tasks is impractical due to prohibiting computation requirements, and
randomly selecting tasks can lead to suboptimal performance. In this work, we
propose active instruction tuning based on prompt uncertainty, a novel
framework to identify informative tasks, and then actively tune the models on
the selected tasks. We represent the informativeness of new tasks with the
disagreement of the current model outputs over perturbed prompts. Our
experiments on NIV2 and Self-Instruct datasets demonstrate that our method
consistently outperforms other baseline strategies for task selection,
achieving better out-of-distribution generalization with fewer training tasks.
Additionally, we introduce a task map that categorizes and diagnoses tasks
based on prompt uncertainty and prediction probability. We discover that
training on ambiguous (prompt-uncertain) tasks improves generalization while
training on difficult (prompt-certain and low-probability) tasks offers no
benefit, underscoring the importance of task selection for instruction tuning.
|
[
-0.0014739124,
-1.04187572,
0.4752268493,
0.0590361282,
-0.116777882,
-0.1423072219,
-0.5705013871,
-0.1283946633,
-0.3588203788,
0.2619181871,
-0.777228713,
-0.6016121507,
-0.8150251508,
-0.0765939802,
-0.0504051298,
0.7931578755,
-0.1922648102,
0.0712982938,
-0.00976751,
0.230119884,
-0.693343699,
0.095849514,
-0.8957755566,
0.0803862959,
0.4370189011,
0.8011343479,
0.4988714755,
0.9119166732,
0.5046698451,
0.2810715735,
0.0813386291,
0.1916763037,
-0.2545767725,
0.5359578133,
-0.1693915427,
-0.7284194231,
-0.169394061,
-0.0363141783,
0.5042370558,
0.6060706377,
-0.0121077448,
0.2042286992,
0.0080004083,
0.3710657656,
-0.8998788595,
0.1185328886,
-0.8009756804,
0.1594031006,
-0.1439714432,
-0.2723096907,
-0.2898726761,
0.0015345194,
-0.0028041627,
-0.8676741719,
0.5870459676,
0.2326686382,
0.7114287615,
0.7475534678,
-0.3832946122,
-0.2742776871,
-0.8447294831,
0.9261741042,
-0.4533075392,
0.2798110545,
0.6460095048,
0.3364554644,
0.0188747179,
-0.4653841555,
-0.0572121404,
-0.0483213067,
0.3413182497,
0.2108166963,
-0.3528655469,
0.3435811996,
0.4446882308,
0.2702035904,
-0.3337970972,
0.2799605727,
-0.0422042497,
-0.3262325227,
0.2515382469,
0.0523363948,
0.2655088902,
0.2137867659,
-0.2468997985,
-0.0397350229,
-0.5006180406,
0.6064544916,
0.5624261498,
0.417531997,
0.1294441521,
0.4222351611,
-0.4180437028,
1.132196784,
0.5589430928,
-0.0282052495,
-0.0183467623,
-0.2621946037,
-0.1667961031,
0.0596386977,
0.5132757425,
0.1275042444,
-0.0408902913,
-0.3649486899,
-0.3209663928,
-0.0004294515,
0.4254953265,
-0.5531420112,
-0.1208785921,
0.1655849963,
-0.0193041097,
-0.0524474978,
-0.0048015937,
-0.377823621,
-0.1278492659,
-0.4085506201,
0.4796610475,
-0.4266139269,
0.1851286143,
0.0176622085,
0.0341500714,
-0.0232846625,
0.4058147967,
-1.0966969728,
-0.0585912913,
0.5539497137,
0.4327653348,
-0.156619519,
-0.2092306018,
-1.0168503523,
0.1792365015,
-0.3797464967,
0.7600596547,
-1.0145220757,
-0.0445305817,
-0.0092577776,
0.2097153068,
-0.3665141761,
-0.4432375133,
0.613810122,
-0.4681111276,
0.0512441583,
-0.3159827292,
-0.3799164593,
-0.0678018853,
0.2122168243,
-0.5230638981,
0.9985088706,
0.2157360762,
-0.5612360239,
0.6335201263,
-0.2774849832,
-0.558470726,
-0.1061832681,
-0.1279385984,
-0.5316368341,
0.1411678493,
0.3698542118,
0.5469831228,
-0.1756608784,
0.1990763545,
-0.1343971789,
-0.6476350427,
-0.0257209446,
-0.3493353724,
0.3141643703,
0.1296270341,
-0.7645885944,
0.4476909637,
-0.5606732965,
0.2592642605,
-0.4304226637,
-0.2725154459,
-0.2008696049,
-0.0844992697,
-0.6341853738,
-0.1998622566,
0.423481524,
-0.3707869053,
0.400788337,
-0.3014811277,
0.0939997286,
0.7110555768,
0.1437833905,
0.7843509912,
-0.2101141363,
0.8651720881,
0.0768433809,
0.4186111987,
-0.2517257333,
-0.6519403458,
-0.8268977404,
-0.1880676597,
0.3280479312,
0.9743799567,
-1.0195354223,
0.393804729,
0.1810636073,
-0.3625467718,
-0.6081904769,
0.3354924917,
0.5414306521,
0.5720585585,
0.338822037,
0.1327337921,
-0.2493297756,
-0.8270180225,
-0.3832038343,
0.018171465,
-0.007645586,
0.2899097204,
-0.0149605153,
0.0880701095,
0.5603642464,
-0.2908049524,
-0.1017733514,
0.101192072,
0.4235440791,
0.2830336094,
0.4346868396,
0.0699920356,
-0.5966982841,
-0.6754832864,
-0.008455866,
-0.3517315686,
-0.1362278759,
-0.3820891082,
-0.1768275797,
-0.1338028759,
0.3609441519,
-0.466449976,
0.3902135491,
0.2746483088,
-0.35228315,
-0.0225369092,
-0.2728677392,
0.4932323992,
-0.6808020473,
-0.1397124231,
0.0447743349,
-0.0266777165,
-0.5024970174,
-0.193148151,
0.4478280842,
-0.0425323211,
-0.1012973636,
0.4329102039,
-0.8525367975,
0.1689895391,
-0.355851382,
-0.2657238245,
-0.2513450086,
0.571049273,
-0.0647387132,
0.9754914045,
1.2013528347,
-0.7297261357,
0.4027028978,
0.1164436787,
-0.4466490746,
0.3058404922,
-0.4867044687,
0.053063225,
-0.042331934,
-0.2943676114,
-0.8347761631,
-0.2618437707,
0.3945938349,
-0.3402636349,
0.8154735565,
-0.2632739842,
-0.0363753513,
-0.1782231033,
0.0790925846,
0.2465956956,
0.4952300787,
-0.2438814491,
0.2844113111,
-0.0444548503,
-0.2072263807,
-0.9690395594,
-0.436260432,
-0.3213474154,
-0.0168248303,
-0.3712411225,
0.3442806304,
-0.0888479576,
-0.129961729,
-0.0016227841,
-0.6306080222,
-0.1331181079,
0.4356485009,
0.4355172217,
0.0153308576,
-0.096258454,
0.2152518928,
0.5047501922,
-0.0889532492,
-0.1769741029,
-0.2839621007,
-0.0466786847,
0.1797277778,
-0.6185386181,
-0.334043473,
0.1875880957,
0.0698930845,
-0.2521997392,
0.2767930031,
0.7658273578,
-0.0936959013,
-0.7337079644,
-0.3472818136,
-0.3769170046,
-0.4669353962,
0.3393149078,
-0.0400182903,
-1.0072873831,
0.1016575247,
-0.1552653611,
0.3333700895,
0.1301120818,
0.3653390408,
-0.018120341,
1.1639611721,
0.7586618662,
0.2901589572,
0.9186320901,
-0.0448406152,
0.1084244698,
-0.5059645772,
-0.1251479685,
-0.49267295,
-0.4500615597,
-0.1841338128,
-0.6632242799,
0.4760867059,
0.0771397278,
-0.12689282,
0.0295037068,
-0.84676826,
0.4129950106,
0.9268566966,
0.3194443583,
-0.0959475338,
0.0924331099,
0.1852349639,
0.0093859248,
-0.7899177074,
-0.3626477718,
1.0880624056,
0.009166765,
0.8643913269,
-0.2409769297,
0.418974787,
0.373359412,
-0.1514786482,
-0.7919194698,
0.3620737791,
-0.2589866221,
-0.6787096262,
-0.5900757313,
-0.4714033604,
-1.2020664215,
-0.3476105928,
-0.2820669711,
-0.4985286295,
0.2517066896,
0.4708431363,
-0.8188595772,
0.2194976062,
-0.7842592001,
0.8376284242,
-0.3607359231,
-0.5232282877,
0.0827321932,
-0.7408668399,
0.0996290669,
0.1395947486,
-0.0639577731,
-0.310890615,
-0.4098289013,
0.6367488503,
0.1581193358,
1.0278526545,
-0.4033666849,
-0.0206019003,
0.2764718533,
-0.0072255787,
0.802649498,
0.1984185874,
-0.2729746401,
-0.3207185268,
-0.4438230097,
-0.5459994078,
-0.8809657097,
0.5955622792,
-0.8339703679,
-0.8468675613,
-0.1764021516,
-0.7678582668,
-0.620426476,
0.0952224433,
0.5794015527,
0.4942479432,
0.1415716708,
0.0267003197,
1.2348711491,
0.0541241765,
0.3684440851,
0.5202115774,
0.6581444144,
-0.250937134,
0.8251730204,
0.0871944427,
0.1991246343,
0.7539701462,
-0.1152287573,
0.1162138134,
-0.8312407732,
-0.5085120797,
-0.2834756672,
-0.6278460622,
-0.4013952613,
-0.530837357,
0.0960077047,
-0.4987010956,
-0.1752998978,
-0.1091997325,
-0.5604925752,
-0.7021073103,
-0.0609895624,
0.4300778806,
0.5754335523,
0.132345736,
0.5589301586,
-0.5222574472,
0.3461281359,
0.5681892037,
0.3217635751,
-0.4869138598,
-0.8369337916,
-0.4308585823,
0.0809362084,
-0.1986353099,
-0.806325078,
0.0427373089,
0.4714556038,
1.0865600109,
0.4926873744,
0.3571310043,
0.4684734941,
-0.3998042345,
0.6231694818,
0.0112819914,
-0.7753121853,
0.8338166475,
-0.2675344646,
0.5341736674,
0.7068502903,
0.5818019509,
-0.0411733054,
-0.5154632926,
-0.5261287689,
-0.9094547033,
1.0977998972,
0.1116301119,
0.0199096352,
0.0817416534,
0.4318574369,
0.3945695162,
0.3842932284,
-0.2131228745,
-0.2656264007,
-0.1808264256,
-0.3141324818,
-0.0630672872,
-0.102110967,
-0.3004161119,
-0.1725305021,
0.977981925,
-0.3205038309,
0.3820637763,
0.0015581002,
-0.0086339246,
-0.6028459668,
0.3596375883,
0.4063843489,
0.4432022274,
-0.0508273691,
0.1962465346,
0.1385755241,
-0.3963808417,
0.2268701196,
0.1579544395,
-0.3394568861,
-0.1212164611,
0.4657960832,
1.508672595,
0.497982949,
-0.4559187591,
0.5533301234,
-0.1365891695,
-0.0372032598,
0.008936109,
0.8756249547,
-0.3037300408,
0.4060814977,
0.297146678,
0.4744608998,
0.2302719951,
-0.3912015557,
0.0339677408,
0.470295161,
-0.5684623718,
-0.3178920448,
0.5707047582,
0.2752705216,
-0.3747475743,
0.507558167,
-0.4095166028,
-0.1249200553,
0.7516400218,
0.4042107165,
0.9025767446,
-0.4329798818,
0.3077615499,
0.5222793221,
0.4353512526,
-0.1014460027,
0.5610672235,
-0.5011128187,
-0.4867486358,
-0.4230694473,
-0.3543603122,
-0.6488882303,
-0.1966014802,
-0.8469775915,
0.2707408667,
-0.4644420147,
-0.3285104036,
-0.353864342,
-0.0677381232,
-0.5775607228,
0.4045679271,
-0.041523084,
0.6075066328,
-0.7644079924,
0.6418510079,
1.0563539267,
0.0527135693,
-0.8621908426,
0.1034443602,
-0.3310475349,
-0.9119145274,
0.1904243976,
0.0394503437,
0.3124410212,
0.0768174529,
-0.5959407687,
-0.9647538662,
1.0956709385,
0.5764553547,
-0.84528023,
-0.3417078853,
-0.2544516921,
0.1890139729,
-0.1736528575,
0.3960834146,
0.2861302495,
0.5509520173,
0.1892929375,
-0.6660308242,
0.0720558837,
-0.3245538175,
-0.1988646239,
0.3915140629,
-0.6294797063,
0.8286170959,
-0.3733618855,
-0.3049808741,
-0.0636775866,
0.6006946564,
-0.0343977883,
0.4656623304,
0.6461640596,
0.201209709,
0.9982354641,
-0.2849447429,
0.797123611,
-0.6431629658,
-0.1281201094,
1.0673279762,
-0.0004634113,
0.3632544279,
0.377482444,
0.1060326546,
0.1834391803,
0.9512684345,
-0.2473796904,
0.5806560516,
-0.1072116569,
-0.3976930678,
-0.8443929553,
0.0344201289,
-0.1520608217,
0.2417793572,
0.4016587138,
-0.2448583245,
-0.203156516,
0.2521898448,
-0.2450664043,
0.0270627253,
-0.432595402,
0.821751833,
-0.2370175868,
-1.1459159851,
0.6016494036,
-0.135738939,
0.5940234065,
-0.9569879174,
-0.0983190462,
0.0159381274,
-0.1219225526,
-0.0660301,
-0.6045386791,
-0.017661443,
-0.0701432377,
-0.4162395895,
-0.4232569933,
0.7285513878,
-0.5531869531,
-0.3643737137,
-0.1068048403,
0.4212245941,
-0.1254381537,
-0.1831391305,
-0.7290259004,
-0.0320365429,
0.2438870668,
-0.4952268898,
0.2990507782,
0.9258233309,
-0.1812528968,
0.609318614,
0.3490650058,
0.0797692761,
0.1450577378,
-0.2447270602,
0.7427288294,
-0.5188727975,
-0.4004072249,
-0.2881855965,
0.535200119,
0.0899884328,
-0.6748960614,
0.7978278399,
0.3114570677,
0.6085044742,
-0.0820617974,
0.8121025562,
-0.0063626575,
0.4890384078,
-0.5899013281,
0.2004490644,
-0.513777256,
0.2945368886,
0.2618530095,
-0.7311398983,
-0.0905489251,
0.3989017606,
-0.4903879166,
0.1038663164,
0.6738256812,
0.838293612,
-0.1711127162,
-0.079212971,
0.4884305,
0.0008774917,
-0.2803135812,
0.4469264746,
0.6619228125,
-0.1578483284,
0.6649397016,
-0.5616207123,
-0.4048018754,
-0.0844204277,
-0.6561461091,
-0.9677426815,
-0.4601930082,
-0.4952734411,
0.0930035338,
0.369263649,
0.6833862662,
0.8346350193,
-0.916692555,
0.046484746,
-0.1683890074,
0.1782862246,
-0.6607776284,
-0.1388335824,
0.1027728692,
-0.9440156221,
-0.8842998147,
0.7689135671,
0.1684262604,
-0.027027905,
0.1955853999,
0.1906204224,
0.0854264423,
0.011903096,
0.0078964652,
0.3176763952,
-0.5638225675,
-0.1051419973,
0.3177055418,
-0.1693989336,
-0.136240676,
0.8955900073,
-0.5125058293,
0.5712639093,
0.3707029223,
0.6639890075,
0.3895486295,
-0.0320466086,
0.6124593019,
-0.902584374,
0.0092049502,
0.439383328,
0.166416347,
0.2306056917,
-0.8294110894,
0.357570529,
0.0674427375,
-0.7533870339,
-0.6183116436,
0.2295970768,
-1.0132710934,
-0.3608921766,
1.2701294422,
-0.3365623057,
-0.4660989046,
-0.20483163,
-0.2212505788,
0.6033453345,
-0.6459786892,
0.809222579,
0.4975520372,
-0.1495093256,
-0.1272086203,
-0.4734282196,
0.7005470395,
0.8002349734,
-0.66686064,
0.033549469,
0.4656845033,
0.080117166,
-0.2531512976,
0.1623676866,
0.5790624022,
0.6689891815,
-0.0532819927,
0.1158604994,
-0.4059875906,
-0.5308210254,
-0.2291606814,
0.2038323134,
0.1555075049,
-0.3187893927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00287v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00287v1
|
Knowledge-Infused Prompting: Assessing and Advancing Clinical Text Data Generation with Large Language Models
| 2023-11-01T04:37:28 | 2023-11-01T04:37:28 |
Ran Xu, Hejie Cui, Yue Yu, Xuan Kan, Wenqi Shi, Yuchen Zhuang, Wei Jin, Joyce Ho, Carl Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, q-bio.QM
|
Clinical natural language processing requires methods that can address
domain-specific challenges, such as complex medical terminology and clinical
contexts. Recently, large language models (LLMs) have shown promise in this
domain. Yet, their direct deployment can lead to privacy issues and are
constrained by resources. To address this challenge, we delve into synthetic
clinical text generation using LLMs for clinical NLP tasks. We propose an
innovative, resource-efficient approach, ClinGen, which infuses knowledge into
the process. Our model involves clinical knowledge extraction and
context-informed LLM prompting. Both clinical topics and writing styles are
drawn from external domain-specific knowledge graphs and LLMs to guide data
generation. Our extensive empirical study across 7 clinical NLP tasks and 16
datasets reveals that ClinGen consistently enhances performance across various
tasks, effectively aligning the distribution of real datasets and significantly
enriching the diversity of generated training instances. We will publish our
code and all the generated data in \url{https://github.com/ritaranx/ClinGen}.
|
[
-0.2452520728,
-0.7983006239,
1.0764681101,
0.2421899885,
-0.3244299889,
-0.2101568282,
-0.485404402,
-0.4474577308,
0.0010362189,
0.7428635359,
-0.7362844944,
-0.7352703214,
-0.6190218329,
0.3024036586,
-0.3263536394,
1.0367903709,
-0.0156123694,
0.4226442575,
-0.6254971623,
-0.0155256307,
-0.7380741239,
-0.3353500962,
-0.6784181595,
-0.4764375389,
0.6298748851,
0.5982500911,
0.3055074513,
0.6060929894,
0.422412008,
0.2080446035,
0.1541231424,
0.5633134246,
-0.5383420587,
0.4786651433,
-0.1631621718,
-0.2171366513,
-0.5991942286,
-0.3632032573,
0.3725180626,
0.7954152822,
-0.2697234154,
0.0306997579,
0.1415076554,
0.7643625736,
-0.5310198069,
-0.1358374208,
-0.6529537439,
-0.0457440726,
-0.3195179403,
-0.4936803579,
-0.5107864738,
-0.4199348688,
0.679864049,
-0.6744522452,
0.5644360185,
0.0526428707,
0.4178619981,
0.1147355884,
-0.3426092565,
-0.7615483999,
-0.5863927007,
0.6246370673,
-0.6394920945,
0.379668951,
0.1741259992,
0.2277416438,
-0.2668965161,
-1.203971386,
-0.6617325544,
-0.2456847578,
-0.0536015108,
0.1694145799,
-0.0733564198,
0.2319857776,
0.2748205364,
0.3170385361,
-0.6226725578,
0.1204165369,
-0.3956241012,
0.0475946292,
0.6371729374,
0.3571614027,
0.4089130163,
0.0438222066,
-0.4332432449,
-0.1010792255,
-0.8239667416,
-0.4270408154,
-0.1526821107,
0.168482691,
0.0933254734,
0.545506835,
-0.0088362452,
0.8847655058,
0.0674232543,
-0.2861288786,
0.2179605663,
-0.2022068501,
-0.2981345952,
0.3899511695,
0.902641356,
0.6508553624,
0.1847493351,
-0.0075230114,
0.1174351647,
-0.0422814228,
0.5335714221,
-0.8085657954,
-0.3578591645,
0.6260002851,
-0.0200474896,
-0.4382981956,
-0.2813535631,
-0.8009582162,
-0.8920831084,
-0.3418379724,
0.1176785678,
-0.6877269149,
-0.0086008087,
0.388718307,
-0.3085882366,
-0.157380119,
0.5294958353,
-0.8248537183,
0.0596212074,
0.4717139304,
0.595153451,
-0.4364792407,
-0.0906301215,
-0.5755295753,
0.3799024522,
-0.2007677406,
0.714199841,
-0.2146303058,
-0.5163581371,
0.4084452689,
-0.144276008,
0.0612578765,
-0.7328545451,
0.5198902488,
-0.3016043305,
0.2730298936,
-0.259655267,
-0.7700125575,
0.1284808815,
0.2934302688,
-0.5842354894,
1.0987067223,
0.1987934709,
-0.6177327037,
0.669295311,
-0.8066166639,
-0.4887166321,
0.5461568832,
-0.2165799141,
-0.3246128261,
0.0559276715,
0.5394890308,
0.6179448366,
-0.4225573242,
0.6517071128,
-0.143839553,
0.2216844857,
0.3435045779,
-0.2306361794,
0.4184200168,
0.0748418942,
-0.1431837827,
0.2159806937,
-0.8004635572,
0.1180977374,
0.1148922965,
-0.0700881779,
-0.3382202089,
-0.2810609341,
0.0174016841,
-0.0971302018,
0.2679638863,
-0.5474321842,
0.1450873017,
-0.4974344671,
0.3856055737,
0.406693548,
0.4617373943,
0.4378839433,
-0.5528619885,
0.6418962479,
-0.0354194306,
0.2836880088,
-0.1175824776,
-0.4614193141,
-0.5612720847,
-0.3927632272,
0.189212963,
0.5651896596,
-0.8864447474,
0.2718571126,
-0.323343426,
-0.6835516691,
-0.5861822963,
0.2874509394,
0.3447283506,
0.9415271878,
0.5609087944,
-0.0694441572,
-0.4943288863,
-0.6719100475,
-0.0822282508,
0.1697285026,
-0.2403936088,
0.3872390985,
0.2446439713,
-0.4212397039,
1.0981843472,
-0.7563099265,
-0.508207798,
-0.6987241507,
-0.0483921058,
0.1497252584,
0.5486349463,
0.3647460341,
-0.6096604466,
-0.6136105061,
-0.0036952109,
-0.9135335684,
-0.4120839536,
-0.2495643795,
-0.123546958,
-0.0224748608,
0.58833009,
-0.4420791268,
0.2498369962,
0.536003828,
0.0067175329,
0.5418900847,
-0.4974232018,
-0.0753237233,
-1.1509424448,
0.263492763,
-0.2686068416,
-0.3655344248,
-0.9573944807,
-0.0761552677,
0.0049479734,
-0.1831275821,
-0.5109710693,
0.8777586818,
-0.4222016037,
0.5371357203,
-0.1840914041,
0.3757837713,
0.3133792877,
0.0812820569,
0.272444874,
0.5342116952,
0.5419980288,
-0.766346097,
0.3998054862,
0.594121635,
-0.3034854531,
0.684020102,
-0.839324832,
0.1401124597,
-0.0634126514,
0.2235235274,
-0.5832683444,
-0.6712078452,
0.0402244069,
-0.1886739284,
0.181522727,
0.0047485013,
-0.5817421675,
-0.2981751859,
-0.0562616251,
0.3597692251,
0.433347106,
-0.609552145,
0.3432677388,
0.4270812869,
-0.4164471328,
-0.305906564,
-0.6322256923,
0.1560831666,
-0.1778784096,
-0.7185015082,
0.349826932,
-0.1105026528,
-0.1180307046,
-0.320800066,
0.3979095221,
-0.0545134917,
-0.1669293493,
0.1758707762,
0.3056170642,
-0.1627636701,
0.4661470354,
0.5514873862,
-0.0223203022,
0.1573778987,
-0.3846718073,
0.6104906201,
0.1665502936,
-0.3367383182,
-0.4601110518,
0.5136687756,
0.3599711359,
-0.104806453,
0.6683654785,
0.5405334234,
-0.2789894044,
-0.6190941334,
-0.5751436949,
-0.3776205778,
-0.5216391683,
0.1702043265,
0.1681160778,
-0.8187448978,
0.122408092,
-0.2552234232,
0.1591132581,
0.0854774043,
0.8544952869,
-0.0337503403,
0.8376536965,
0.3248460293,
0.5242499709,
0.2450289577,
-0.0717818365,
0.1887240857,
-0.7766231894,
-0.0846378654,
0.1128001809,
-0.048215881,
-0.1912576407,
-0.4173532426,
1.0494309664,
0.0456487536,
0.1136810705,
-0.0339901298,
-0.6896781325,
0.2006782144,
0.6138010621,
0.3973109424,
0.3833904862,
-0.1006943807,
-0.1439832598,
-0.2154772431,
-0.9989760518,
-0.3276433647,
1.3248775005,
0.1411115974,
0.4848101437,
-0.2303263098,
0.732983768,
0.2413144261,
0.5012036562,
-0.6539877057,
0.5324401259,
0.1064034328,
-0.4292458296,
-0.223943457,
-0.1404442191,
-1.1330630779,
-0.0932265073,
-0.6053729057,
-0.3887399733,
0.0130077815,
0.4833773971,
-0.6385499835,
-0.0689829141,
-0.5419767499,
0.7071668506,
-0.0951241255,
-0.4883704185,
-0.0540478639,
-0.5613387823,
0.3184909821,
-0.2526021302,
-0.0392186195,
0.1532617956,
0.0500490367,
0.4664748311,
-0.6989269257,
0.9259443283,
-0.1831794828,
-0.2854672074,
0.3433693051,
0.105136238,
0.4675069451,
0.4631983638,
0.0370392688,
-0.0898290575,
0.0215502232,
-0.1376668662,
-0.6927286386,
0.606421411,
-0.145509541,
-0.4987158477,
-0.3263549209,
-0.8009409308,
-0.6532005072,
0.464767009,
0.5631816983,
0.7823307514,
-0.2935750484,
0.0230478924,
0.8282396793,
-0.4930022061,
-0.043210268,
0.4362794459,
-0.1430346072,
-0.5656633377,
0.6483598351,
-0.1906864345,
0.4874386787,
0.1283616871,
0.3549509943,
-0.4354508519,
-0.7480438352,
-0.6471634507,
0.428604871,
-0.717640698,
-0.1656443328,
-0.6642007232,
-0.1826450676,
-0.5500844717,
-0.5956104398,
-0.1461597532,
-0.0921903029,
-0.3164375126,
-0.2287249714,
0.6780394316,
0.7746178508,
0.1220929623,
0.547557056,
-1.1259814501,
0.04109722,
0.1789813489,
0.0335928202,
-0.0521448813,
-0.0524155572,
-0.1223673001,
-0.1241044253,
-0.247643292,
-0.7322566509,
0.6397067904,
0.1350705773,
0.222389251,
0.4197039008,
0.3022986948,
0.6646754146,
-0.7426999211,
0.9420593977,
0.2801542282,
-0.7167093158,
0.5928052664,
-0.5757911205,
0.3963933885,
0.8343987465,
0.2577019036,
-0.5264903307,
-0.6984420419,
-0.7772054672,
-0.980843544,
0.3104801774,
-0.0437183194,
0.0502897277,
-0.1362800747,
0.3348065019,
0.321293205,
0.4401839972,
-0.3303791583,
-0.0077981153,
0.2524518669,
-0.6129426956,
0.0891788825,
-0.2371557653,
-0.5169711113,
-0.1078802049,
0.4277772903,
-0.301384896,
0.2283127308,
0.8658257127,
-0.2392580956,
0.1889398247,
0.180360496,
0.7633251548,
0.701451242,
0.1599026173,
-0.020775767,
0.378916353,
-0.6551722288,
-0.3014929295,
-0.0694099292,
-0.0877487585,
0.1913617551,
0.5285412669,
0.7069439292,
0.083851248,
-1.0707234144,
0.5363029838,
0.0173330717,
-0.3682389259,
-0.5121925473,
0.2220458686,
0.0610536672,
0.0518197715,
0.0118730702,
-0.1975266188,
0.1254646629,
-0.0239928328,
0.3127834201,
0.178480804,
-0.3786496818,
-0.069117859,
0.6457663774,
0.2862516642,
0.0133350827,
0.5790723562,
0.1060747728,
-0.297118485,
0.211071074,
0.7460452914,
0.6288888454,
0.0837072432,
0.1548718512,
0.3419889808,
-0.1184986532,
-0.1009444743,
0.3452035487,
-0.0137734376,
-0.583114028,
-0.291457653,
-0.4424941242,
-0.4871026576,
0.1843643039,
-0.6965702772,
0.3365676701,
-0.4796584249,
-0.238231495,
-0.1189623624,
-0.3500988185,
-0.5489422083,
0.2583737075,
0.0284071248,
1.0909916162,
-0.4868240058,
0.7336722612,
0.4193505645,
0.0773881674,
-0.6080341339,
-0.1670560539,
0.0049760011,
-0.8199478388,
0.3856942952,
0.0391648524,
0.0788189918,
-0.0129061099,
-0.5352356434,
-0.3582606316,
1.0906153917,
0.2394140512,
-0.51243788,
-0.1548056006,
0.4687204659,
0.7339161634,
-0.4312693179,
-0.0327027366,
0.3828754723,
0.4912765324,
-0.0294394549,
-0.8112383485,
0.2224633545,
-0.1232801154,
-0.1279404759,
0.1398821771,
-0.0712334588,
0.4108118713,
-0.2833236456,
-0.2034603804,
0.1468171775,
0.5066228509,
0.5476290584,
0.400213778,
0.4804500341,
0.2715225518,
1.2024633884,
0.1031865403,
1.1627242565,
-0.502776444,
-0.1085105389,
1.045801878,
-0.61328125,
0.510222733,
0.4288680851,
0.2994408011,
0.5298765898,
0.1394703686,
-0.0270226896,
0.237887904,
-0.0130811101,
-0.602297008,
-0.1912343949,
-0.3517744541,
-0.3217713535,
0.1657036543,
0.5917134881,
-0.5834489465,
-0.1719713658,
0.2528530657,
0.3143928945,
0.125693202,
-0.1401822269,
0.8997486234,
0.2686139345,
-1.1053493023,
0.6234076023,
-0.3248467445,
0.1515829712,
-0.9326770902,
-0.1005453169,
0.1090200692,
0.30905357,
-0.1687239259,
-0.8842174411,
0.106488578,
0.0371228047,
-0.2175535113,
-0.5384290218,
0.7107003331,
-0.7389549613,
-0.3076592684,
0.018490117,
0.4657891095,
-0.1034560502,
0.0379020683,
-0.4915451705,
-0.212331295,
-0.049913276,
-0.0192159787,
0.3208482862,
0.5679259896,
-0.0789170861,
0.6701949835,
1.0303149223,
0.351998657,
-0.052538082,
0.1345957518,
0.7618662119,
-0.3634923697,
-0.5461916327,
-0.7872492671,
0.5431383252,
-0.3569752276,
-0.5958454013,
0.7019192576,
0.4585486054,
0.2747050524,
-0.2219786644,
0.873729825,
0.1106002256,
0.7866193652,
-0.6688810587,
0.84516114,
-0.4016047418,
-0.0491555519,
-0.2094300389,
-0.2245059907,
-0.5347161889,
0.1459131539,
-0.2298612744,
-0.4376159608,
0.7500030994,
0.7106409669,
0.2351206094,
0.1965216845,
0.0961352587,
0.1167587861,
0.4584518671,
0.5969437361,
0.572615087,
-0.0209796727,
0.178261444,
-0.0820633918,
-0.3741248548,
-0.1268425733,
-0.9794127345,
-0.9522598386,
-0.4814010859,
-0.1129145771,
-0.5606735349,
-0.115881376,
1.0218162537,
0.6013525724,
-0.6107968092,
0.0475987233,
-0.2955013812,
-0.2417532057,
-0.2232291251,
-0.2173457742,
0.4236747026,
-0.4808894992,
-0.7174091935,
0.5676905513,
0.1125881225,
-0.0005968231,
-0.2509670854,
0.0336679183,
0.2117933184,
-0.0092498539,
0.6000349522,
0.0789634213,
-0.2263115048,
0.1867827624,
0.0966138914,
-0.1930189729,
0.0560549051,
0.9681620002,
-0.8147081733,
0.627448082,
0.5167752504,
0.6322164536,
0.3555648625,
-0.0000708596,
1.1394731998,
-0.8259275556,
-0.0016979326,
0.4968005121,
0.2491544634,
0.3745414019,
-0.5801357031,
0.3548190594,
0.1548560411,
-0.6242287755,
-1.0386655331,
0.2555067539,
-1.1040049791,
-0.0490543768,
1.2562308311,
0.0514532067,
-0.2891384065,
-0.2008308023,
-0.4788302779,
0.0125559866,
-0.3212199807,
0.6554487944,
0.4761204422,
-0.2858618796,
0.1724495888,
-0.7315564156,
0.9973388314,
0.3884159625,
-0.8122287989,
0.1828719527,
0.4009300768,
0.2956525981,
0.0914778635,
0.7393756509,
-0.1733769923,
0.3625914454,
-0.3375413716,
0.0595880225,
-0.0917954445,
-0.2222945094,
-0.1140344515,
0.1220703125,
-0.0964236557,
0.1988285333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00286v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00286v3
|
JADE: A Linguistics-based Safety Evaluation Platform for Large Language Models
| 2023-11-01T04:36:45 | 2023-12-10T13:58:24 |
Mi Zhang, Xudong Pan, Min Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
In this paper, we present JADE, a targeted linguistic fuzzing platform which
strengthens the linguistic complexity of seed questions to simultaneously and
consistently break a wide range of widely-used LLMs categorized in three
groups: eight open-sourced Chinese, six commercial Chinese and four commercial
English LLMs. JADE generates three safety benchmarks for the three groups of
LLMs, which contain unsafe questions that are highly threatening: the questions
simultaneously trigger harmful generation of multiple LLMs, with an average
unsafe generation ratio of $70\%$ (please see the table below), while are still
natural questions, fluent and preserving the core unsafe semantics. We release
the benchmark demos generated for commercial English LLMs and open-sourced
English LLMs in the following link: https://github.com/whitzard-ai/jade-db. For
readers who are interested in evaluating on more questions generated by JADE,
please contact us.
JADE is based on Noam Chomsky's seminal theory of transformational-generative
grammar. Given a seed question with unsafe intention, JADE invokes a sequence
of generative and transformational rules to increment the complexity of the
syntactic structure of the original question, until the safety guardrail is
broken. Our key insight is: Due to the complexity of human language, most of
the current best LLMs can hardly recognize the invariant evil from the infinite
number of different syntactic structures which form an unbound example space
that can never be fully covered. Technically, the generative/transformative
rules are constructed by native speakers of the languages, and, once developed,
can be used to automatically grow and transform the parse tree of a given
question, until the guardrail is broken. For more evaluation results and demo,
please check our website: https://whitzard-ai.github.io/jade.html.
|
[
0.1285867095,
-1.1724795103,
0.5064700842,
0.2528046966,
-0.1286841333,
0.121596545,
-0.2071771473,
-0.2514991164,
0.0202282257,
0.6467394829,
-0.3918752968,
-0.5586699247,
-0.3454544842,
-0.0328473486,
-0.6952698827,
0.8146209121,
0.1753683835,
-0.1962833554,
0.0640630201,
0.066645503,
-0.2777906954,
-0.3829078674,
-0.7257299423,
-0.0133438073,
0.345497787,
-0.0258102473,
0.8429487944,
0.5674687624,
0.454531312,
0.4287723899,
-0.3980101049,
-0.0315885805,
-0.4201261997,
0.4026126862,
-0.4854387045,
-0.6907977462,
-0.1705507189,
-0.1517994404,
0.3539378345,
0.7286981344,
-0.2539255321,
0.0826109052,
-0.0385040827,
0.5545013547,
-0.6255444288,
0.2801090777,
-0.9015340209,
-0.1391108781,
-0.5091923475,
-0.0193905961,
-0.4617634416,
-0.5796678662,
-0.2099267095,
-0.257221818,
-0.2167956233,
0.2109993398,
0.8809185624,
0.2714527845,
-0.5042905807,
0.1190919504,
-0.4501841962,
0.6042621136,
-0.403945893,
0.166574195,
0.1481264234,
0.268147409,
-0.4237504303,
-0.6340276003,
-0.5365509987,
-0.2362953424,
0.0478287488,
-0.0354162827,
-0.1920246631,
0.4078242779,
0.2931289077,
0.4414355457,
-0.9782587886,
-0.0158062931,
-0.0845315233,
-0.2965198159,
0.7098677158,
0.1812187433,
0.7135664225,
-0.4691758752,
-0.1266350746,
-0.3599345088,
-0.6795387268,
-0.0549772345,
0.3668450415,
0.3932162523,
0.0407008417,
0.234003678,
-0.211450249,
0.4981238544,
0.0677475333,
-0.2721935213,
0.4583708346,
-0.2214297056,
-0.2228862345,
-0.0396694764,
1.0214606524,
0.3507810533,
0.2996928692,
-0.1002811641,
-0.1429422945,
0.2927283645,
0.183363691,
-0.4652708471,
-0.0911445692,
0.4182081223,
-0.3269436359,
-0.6084252596,
-0.0592905805,
-0.8752205968,
-0.6360698938,
0.2307399511,
0.19927001,
-0.6181374192,
-0.597586751,
0.315235436,
0.1232468411,
0.2027009875,
0.2480343133,
-0.8513851762,
0.0490946509,
0.7112949491,
0.6675445437,
0.1154949218,
-0.3108592331,
-0.5408427119,
0.0526266135,
-0.3418801427,
0.4895460606,
-0.1504113972,
-0.420062542,
0.1904356033,
0.0141611528,
-0.0972164273,
-0.4119336605,
0.5032514334,
-0.4614946544,
0.0504027046,
-0.0324749649,
-0.112076357,
-0.1461865753,
0.4821510911,
-0.5711081624,
0.7618144751,
-0.0012877504,
-0.6930885911,
0.0890421271,
-0.4900933206,
-0.6200339198,
0.2632663846,
-0.085795261,
-0.2437151223,
-0.0081889378,
-0.0353733078,
0.0982817486,
-0.5576656461,
0.6665790677,
-0.310198307,
-0.049043864,
0.1520680487,
-0.6828318238,
1.2082670927,
0.2774107754,
-0.4937103391,
0.3640215993,
-0.6640193462,
0.4490743876,
0.3536709845,
-0.246124804,
-0.4878591895,
-0.2093540877,
0.0921171606,
0.3320812583,
0.0682382658,
-0.4031925797,
-0.0926686078,
-0.690815866,
0.3486668169,
0.8877208233,
0.2002200484,
0.1522618383,
-0.3209638596,
0.5555413961,
-0.2746870518,
0.32993415,
-0.2734377682,
-0.3635037839,
-0.8831470609,
0.2437072545,
0.2189807147,
0.6168968081,
-0.8859428167,
0.4687905014,
-0.3319393694,
-0.6380404234,
-0.4373179674,
0.039585162,
0.8151853681,
0.0966406539,
0.1952860206,
-0.2446924746,
-0.3732025921,
-0.6954183578,
-0.4798577428,
-0.9621031284,
0.3025866449,
-0.0897229239,
0.423756063,
-0.0108141387,
0.4388599098,
-0.3006692231,
0.1278604716,
-0.4118359983,
0.0844409913,
0.1281535625,
0.3922319412,
0.4667834044,
-0.713168025,
-0.4943262339,
0.0127611421,
-0.8540189266,
-0.2025583088,
-0.3830863833,
-0.3076094687,
0.1246668026,
0.3449462056,
-0.8807676435,
0.1728949994,
0.4961684048,
-0.3113529384,
0.5773364305,
0.2921141386,
0.1676642746,
-1.177213192,
-0.1100478694,
-0.0791669562,
-0.0385573357,
-0.7419343591,
0.714145422,
0.1351674199,
0.0562744513,
-0.8155362606,
0.4788624346,
-0.1659609228,
0.4768902361,
0.1222637519,
0.0424098819,
-0.2330160886,
0.2516795397,
-0.3420419693,
0.6766468287,
0.5259143114,
-0.340749532,
0.5136420131,
0.0998833701,
-0.2632769644,
0.531922698,
-0.4339865148,
0.1641949266,
0.1303381026,
-0.0881810188,
-0.653079927,
-0.4364756048,
0.1027369872,
-0.2067646831,
0.2203519046,
-0.2367170602,
-0.7900726795,
-0.291521132,
-0.4348248839,
0.2246186584,
0.7974562645,
-0.4904612899,
0.3841104805,
0.4311437309,
-0.1731128991,
-0.4129176736,
-0.63352108,
0.2914165854,
-0.4468856752,
-0.9981266856,
0.1188049018,
0.0370311774,
-0.7696486115,
-0.0333392024,
-0.1146003753,
0.1515024304,
0.3624923527,
0.3773724437,
-0.0098770494,
-0.1336937845,
0.1910827905,
0.1490356326,
-0.1082670987,
0.3905064166,
-0.4075108469,
0.7208048105,
-0.4554991424,
-0.6586872935,
-0.2385272384,
0.0634641573,
0.6558535099,
-0.2807019353,
0.465542376,
0.2053245157,
-0.4401679039,
-0.3880741596,
-0.4739224017,
0.1342592239,
-0.5566831827,
0.4139173627,
-0.2026180774,
-0.7637432814,
0.1417925209,
-0.2181440592,
0.0494016223,
0.6109300852,
0.488937676,
0.0982199907,
0.8388255835,
0.2727936506,
-0.2950282991,
0.139786303,
-0.0383236147,
0.1579976678,
-0.1976510882,
-0.2031374276,
-0.3893597424,
0.0081620077,
-0.5918688774,
-0.3891046643,
0.3577288389,
-0.0122185871,
-0.3156674206,
0.3034337163,
-0.2576388121,
0.594706893,
0.4342281222,
-0.325148046,
0.3261424899,
-0.0818698332,
-0.2708795965,
-0.0822053403,
-0.2966816127,
-0.5376585126,
0.8733876944,
0.2794314027,
1.1487137079,
0.3505168259,
0.7274912596,
0.1613982767,
0.1626372337,
-0.471776098,
0.8799865246,
0.003763177,
-0.8080998659,
-0.1728490889,
-0.4349887371,
-1.023447156,
0.3265430331,
-0.1030268297,
-0.882586956,
-0.2431186289,
-0.0179013126,
-0.3044051528,
0.5746723413,
-0.5539017916,
0.6637672186,
-0.8889008164,
-0.5206465721,
-0.0466642007,
-0.7107818127,
0.7701027989,
-0.1734402776,
0.3498109877,
-0.0320824608,
0.4429318309,
0.5317271948,
-0.4213475287,
0.9221633077,
0.0028784482,
-0.0579038598,
0.4057286084,
0.4857029319,
0.3206244409,
0.0929779634,
-0.0628570765,
0.086467579,
-0.0251879562,
-0.1554626822,
-0.6332155466,
0.7992703915,
-0.5340316892,
-1.0655266047,
-0.7895635962,
-0.4230448604,
-0.2421128452,
0.4142794013,
-0.1155763865,
-0.0581243373,
-0.1569466442,
0.1930758357,
0.600107789,
-0.3830638826,
0.2277305722,
0.3565402031,
-0.5748214722,
-0.2840606868,
0.9170331359,
-0.1430689692,
0.4863550663,
0.2331451625,
0.0152515173,
-0.2200858146,
-0.8876132965,
-0.4688821435,
0.2386310548,
-0.7511665225,
-0.1860226393,
-0.5614196658,
-0.5831380486,
-0.2706358433,
0.031380903,
-0.3529442847,
-0.3121480644,
0.0420505479,
-0.3644992113,
0.2085544318,
0.6688988805,
0.2402810901,
0.0562372953,
-0.7968387604,
-0.0514616445,
0.1435310096,
0.2365569621,
-0.3416193128,
-0.2609928548,
0.0639493614,
0.0021928083,
-0.3997560441,
-0.9089454412,
0.3499709368,
-0.0943572894,
0.4851334393,
0.43090114,
0.2366556823,
0.7359904051,
-0.3498414457,
0.970610559,
0.2649914324,
-0.8949567676,
0.7463595271,
-0.437746346,
-0.0109636066,
0.7142026424,
0.0645873845,
-0.7443401814,
-0.6197895408,
-0.743637681,
-0.9530691504,
0.4201944768,
0.4470039904,
0.2497732043,
-0.2412034422,
0.34111619,
-0.0801994354,
0.1006160155,
-0.8045454025,
-0.2271910608,
0.0179972611,
-0.2492347658,
0.2090611309,
-0.1917222291,
-0.2534275353,
0.1474708468,
0.6305168867,
-0.1034821272,
-0.24351421,
-0.2878386676,
-0.2943603694,
-0.2089881301,
0.5445383191,
0.0138405692,
0.1291467994,
-0.054871995,
0.3199356794,
0.2171165794,
-0.335739553,
0.35628739,
0.0071385056,
-0.5005745292,
-0.2714717388,
0.5549934506,
0.4793053567,
-0.0520477667,
-0.8744506836,
0.486369133,
-0.1933542341,
-0.259899199,
-0.3305878639,
0.5059858561,
0.0113621308,
0.1100173071,
0.0319519714,
0.0803776234,
0.0204508919,
-0.6377828121,
0.1280148029,
0.5198372602,
-0.2936919928,
-0.3900817335,
0.7876192927,
0.3574768901,
-0.3394714594,
0.4532627463,
-0.4395721257,
-0.5209488273,
0.4042488635,
0.5510825515,
1.0942380428,
-0.2302952409,
0.3184721172,
0.3438883424,
0.6808798909,
-0.1640005112,
0.5213347673,
0.4610006809,
-0.5462779999,
-0.2428361923,
-0.6781181693,
-0.2016056478,
0.4114845693,
-0.3645461798,
0.267603755,
-0.8052489161,
-0.0553371981,
-0.2502005398,
-0.2666007578,
-0.1553507596,
0.2075195462,
0.1347315162,
0.9541158676,
-0.8793042898,
0.5206497908,
0.6472654343,
-0.7041574717,
-0.7238242626,
0.4536873698,
0.5601733327,
-0.565345645,
0.3843810856,
0.1737034619,
-0.1123506129,
-0.1961663514,
-0.4863290787,
-1.0331114531,
1.0622603893,
0.6164218783,
-0.4855177402,
-0.0638533831,
0.2362273186,
0.6767088175,
0.1537938714,
0.1880642325,
0.6694289446,
0.3858289421,
-0.1338597387,
-1.1189392805,
0.3286613822,
-0.6154891253,
0.0363470279,
0.2782151401,
-0.8436869979,
0.7570695877,
-0.0933940411,
-0.4943746328,
0.3233459294,
0.247435078,
0.2268673331,
0.1096129566,
0.820785284,
0.6660139561,
0.8107098341,
-0.410830915,
1.3300181627,
-0.432264775,
0.2475061566,
0.8091447353,
-0.2988572121,
0.6741483808,
0.457369566,
-0.3725010455,
0.519934237,
0.5552056432,
0.3286431432,
0.4657325745,
0.5228866339,
-0.2230877131,
-0.2957064211,
-0.2792395949,
-0.3755538762,
0.3965810239,
0.4648381472,
-0.2005497962,
-0.1887614131,
-0.2630090117,
0.2005020529,
0.1836322993,
0.0357339419,
0.7075895667,
0.0415290631,
-0.6579271555,
0.5904189944,
0.1683811545,
0.3776201606,
-0.7431640625,
0.1278412193,
-0.2471761405,
0.0781136677,
-0.231390968,
-0.8130975366,
0.238127172,
0.0743764862,
0.3387686312,
-0.1762363911,
0.8228294253,
-0.3158866465,
-0.4028523564,
0.4853437245,
0.6131031513,
0.1350132227,
-0.010502019,
-0.7030032277,
0.1651742011,
0.1550213844,
-0.1574406773,
0.4010725915,
0.3639881015,
-0.4115973115,
0.72937572,
0.8431043625,
0.1822168976,
0.0429077372,
0.251258105,
0.9716239572,
-0.7401325703,
-0.5267409086,
-0.9266360998,
0.748221159,
-0.1915295422,
-0.2087327242,
0.8435515761,
0.3622069657,
0.9108144641,
0.1522034109,
1.0474601984,
-0.183960706,
0.0621052608,
-0.6102683544,
0.8105118871,
-0.5582156181,
0.5977188945,
-0.5523911715,
-0.7411510944,
-0.6369387507,
0.4284467101,
-0.2991881967,
0.0411207713,
0.9137094021,
0.8820316195,
0.2104688883,
0.0904820785,
0.3565248847,
0.4391977191,
0.5538945198,
0.621295929,
1.0585690737,
-0.2350881994,
0.8459510207,
-0.3713807464,
-0.1725337505,
-0.0747120231,
-0.5384246707,
-0.9448439479,
-0.4247471392,
-0.3407335579,
-0.7433617711,
0.4838762879,
1.0814458132,
0.463160187,
-0.8358032703,
-0.1038184687,
-0.2240058035,
0.2627483308,
-0.0538812578,
-0.2265224308,
0.2727802694,
-0.4074344039,
-0.675360322,
0.5342360735,
0.5881402493,
-0.1029692739,
-0.4150109291,
-0.0519886538,
-0.0885925591,
-0.1376113892,
0.337641418,
0.1750125438,
-0.9808063507,
-0.5301160812,
-0.0640588105,
-0.2484745085,
-0.4576957226,
0.4246888459,
-0.3860774934,
0.634154439,
0.4818696678,
0.8375322819,
0.0322023705,
-0.079193227,
0.3964662254,
-0.6386161447,
0.0456370674,
0.1470744461,
0.5198675394,
0.2932038307,
-0.3808378875,
0.6559695601,
0.4061042666,
-0.2905446887,
-0.8837490082,
0.4068527818,
-0.6533532143,
-0.0484571308,
1.5100871325,
-0.1451840848,
-0.4458916783,
-0.23093234,
-0.2165412009,
-0.1390857697,
-0.2899148464,
0.8765709996,
0.5461409092,
0.1252840757,
-0.0479215793,
-0.3518900573,
0.4987888038,
0.4647319615,
-0.876678288,
0.0652962849,
0.3786376119,
0.3289689124,
0.3918161392,
0.5661197305,
-0.2950747013,
0.3541768193,
0.2132426053,
-0.0435855091,
0.0906188264,
-0.1896573901,
-0.3986433744,
0.3442445099,
0.313141942,
0.0650022924
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00273v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00273v1
|
SoulChat: Improving LLMs' Empathy, Listening, and Comfort Abilities through Fine-tuning with Multi-turn Empathy Conversations
| 2023-11-01T03:49:52 | 2023-11-01T03:49:52 |
Yirong Chen, Xiaofen Xing, Jingkai Lin, Huimin Zheng, Zhenyu Wang, Qi Liu, Xiangmin Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have been widely applied in various fields due
to their excellent capability for memorizing knowledge and chain of thought
(CoT). When these language models are applied in the field of psychological
counseling, they often rush to provide universal advice. However, when users
seek psychological support, they need to gain empathy, trust, understanding and
comfort, rather than just reasonable advice. To this end, we constructed a
multi-turn empathetic conversation dataset of more than 2 million samples, in
which the input is the multi-turn conversation context, and the target is
empathetic responses that cover expressions such as questioning, comfort,
recognition, listening, trust, emotional support, etc. Experiments have shown
that the empathy ability of LLMs can be significantly enhanced when finetuning
by using multi-turn dialogue history and responses that are closer to the
expression of a psychological consultant.
|
[
-0.5863268375,
-0.7177674174,
0.6911917329,
0.5517688394,
-0.3687705398,
-0.0468941368,
-0.3763553202,
-0.2992179096,
0.2251515239,
0.6736437678,
-0.9044212699,
-0.5914062858,
-0.6278262734,
0.0048631844,
0.0130104031,
1.0313874483,
0.236211434,
0.587901175,
0.1427354068,
-0.1393464655,
-0.7503992915,
-0.4391843975,
-1.0915312767,
-0.4009608626,
0.3538312912,
0.8400550485,
0.4973498881,
-0.099416241,
0.5058087707,
0.2502403855,
0.1198646873,
0.4511028826,
-0.5507267714,
0.3113786876,
-0.007890786,
-0.4704244733,
-0.9167449474,
0.0315771773,
0.1730061322,
0.4902936518,
-0.3454971015,
0.0273441505,
0.2076382339,
0.7269746065,
-0.3123100102,
-0.0247898623,
-0.7354264855,
0.1063791588,
0.3250289261,
-0.3572661281,
-0.3621769547,
-0.412515521,
0.2279164046,
-0.3242088556,
0.1074007452,
-0.0200692378,
0.1732046008,
0.2595759034,
-0.476713866,
-0.5079174042,
-0.6039458513,
0.891035378,
-0.816885829,
0.4316637218,
0.6287199259,
0.1952304542,
-0.0747856945,
-0.2395651191,
-0.3764887452,
-0.149305135,
0.0310796499,
0.3130420446,
0.1096303985,
0.3669480681,
0.1882936805,
0.2246327251,
-0.187257871,
-0.0979074314,
0.0243766718,
-0.1059062853,
0.7541424632,
0.5438477993,
0.1079407111,
-0.0161355734,
0.0161358733,
0.0611080304,
-0.2892811894,
0.0162574742,
0.118751809,
0.256154418,
-0.2041397691,
0.4937246442,
0.1715631634,
0.5581422448,
0.3213536143,
-0.4912396073,
-0.1257324517,
-0.1699102968,
-0.1774040014,
0.1161364615,
0.4458783269,
1.1574223042,
0.7282540202,
-0.1901555359,
0.2612570226,
-0.0223556031,
0.5674031973,
-0.9456889629,
0.0460550599,
0.4831418991,
-0.6840527058,
0.0442763343,
-0.1553891599,
-1.0337181091,
-0.7158823609,
-0.6819271445,
-0.2732426524,
-0.5490934253,
-0.3083977401,
0.3180151582,
0.0416265875,
0.5160495043,
0.4386854768,
-0.7454995513,
0.426382184,
0.7239243388,
1.0823700428,
-0.0098169809,
-0.2783570588,
-0.3329544663,
-0.0063740313,
-0.1758280545,
0.7214880586,
-0.6859890819,
-0.7149253488,
-0.0847967938,
0.168842718,
0.2037351131,
-0.196129024,
0.7550330758,
0.0320682749,
-0.073993884,
-0.5168691874,
-0.432595253,
0.1371373236,
0.4980605245,
-0.2529220581,
0.4234090149,
0.0418854915,
-0.5075466633,
0.2818925083,
-0.6668679118,
-0.4967589974,
-0.2907425165,
0.0463555604,
-0.0991421044,
0.4417691231,
0.1621157229,
0.7413352132,
-0.2408436984,
-0.086810194,
-0.5060998201,
-0.2498429418,
0.4273543358,
-0.249083668,
0.1171809882,
0.0666238889,
-0.221879378,
0.0581302643,
-0.6417092085,
0.0808969364,
-0.08005099,
-0.1530728936,
-0.4892705679,
-0.3011462092,
0.2708749473,
0.2535198331,
-0.053604085,
-0.6745811701,
0.3400799334,
-0.5082523227,
0.3217948079,
0.771520257,
0.1645469964,
0.5759862661,
-0.2482098788,
0.5970673561,
0.1389390081,
0.3129163086,
-0.1539554894,
-0.4719239473,
-0.7488282323,
-0.1855841726,
-0.3411362767,
0.4796497524,
-0.2581958473,
0.4859327972,
0.1357547194,
-0.766336143,
-0.998672843,
0.0506622605,
0.3894551992,
0.3377282321,
0.4505478144,
-0.4430870414,
-0.6682602763,
-0.8238788247,
-0.4322580099,
0.4298779368,
0.1674498618,
0.7426651716,
0.0758723766,
-0.4536617696,
0.741443336,
-0.5347810984,
-0.3556342423,
-0.1475348771,
-0.1244638711,
0.130117625,
0.3622373343,
0.2273597717,
-0.5368487835,
-0.7008141875,
-0.1402579844,
-0.4571794868,
-0.0076369988,
-0.2059769034,
-0.4770862162,
0.1256216615,
0.3848427534,
-0.7237133384,
0.3349015415,
0.5771429539,
-0.7011120319,
0.321726501,
-0.1031270176,
0.4948105514,
-1.3234245777,
-0.2018536925,
-0.0270452593,
-0.0408459529,
-0.8048166037,
-0.3855218589,
-0.0443360172,
0.0543216206,
-0.2535677552,
0.6832991838,
-0.4026947021,
0.086151652,
-0.3927540183,
0.4349075854,
-0.2905141115,
0.505790472,
-0.0294241682,
0.7026729584,
0.6116191745,
-0.5631442666,
0.5494340658,
0.6568439007,
0.1841339022,
1.3524925709,
-0.525821805,
0.4379018545,
0.0500291958,
0.4703877568,
-0.9629973769,
-0.0314292759,
0.1070103571,
-0.3933745027,
0.1556583345,
-0.1139402241,
-0.1807272732,
-0.1729226857,
-0.2504746616,
0.1832985282,
0.3294513524,
-0.3844981194,
0.8386322856,
0.3424129784,
-0.3976386487,
-0.3560862243,
-0.7248830795,
0.297550261,
-0.3073933423,
-0.5992283821,
0.1440123767,
-0.4869047403,
-0.3013230562,
-0.3154881895,
-0.0587788895,
0.101509057,
-0.0508657061,
0.5288496614,
-0.1000346988,
0.193164289,
0.3588754833,
0.2656307817,
-0.3745646775,
0.1880785078,
-0.0318140313,
1.0165612698,
-0.5189915299,
-0.5224905014,
-0.4133162498,
0.5024567246,
0.8120464683,
-0.1110559404,
0.9260639548,
0.8772795796,
-0.2014055997,
0.0047635874,
-0.8702297211,
-0.607260108,
-0.4010344148,
0.2362614423,
-0.4641528428,
-0.9784943461,
0.572309196,
-0.1642399728,
0.1194863394,
-0.2760579288,
0.7295011282,
-0.0552270599,
1.2736214399,
0.4377856553,
-0.2902467251,
0.3636149168,
-0.1188943237,
0.4983691573,
-1.29106462,
-0.1372846067,
-0.1784285456,
-0.5105770826,
-0.5072978139,
-0.0711855516,
0.2481561452,
-0.0768954828,
-0.282926172,
-0.0467035137,
-0.5487651229,
0.2959664464,
0.346617192,
0.5937174559,
0.3115414381,
-0.3268574178,
0.2167074978,
-0.3472557068,
-0.3095383942,
-0.7287982106,
1.0472662449,
0.2829644382,
0.8521925211,
0.0214205272,
0.724668622,
-0.0527302884,
0.3908117712,
-1.1210083961,
0.5137293935,
0.0080329785,
-0.4063078761,
-0.2241721004,
-0.1812229156,
-0.9189239144,
0.1482109129,
-0.0918305665,
-0.800475657,
-0.0775416344,
0.3410072327,
-0.331741631,
0.1012145728,
-0.7579548955,
0.5121373534,
-0.4879470468,
-0.3374924958,
-0.3876710534,
-0.7076176405,
0.278075099,
-0.1021876782,
0.178899616,
-0.1083553359,
0.0635276958,
0.5082859397,
-0.1263762861,
0.9702072144,
-0.3229844868,
-0.2997074127,
0.0496948026,
0.4153991342,
0.550252378,
0.2372156531,
-0.054134991,
-0.2056960315,
0.1471587121,
-0.291179657,
-0.7907581329,
0.6904351711,
-0.7487766743,
-0.5311307907,
0.1024246588,
-0.5676956773,
-0.7866607308,
0.0146881528,
0.1175455153,
0.2334353924,
-0.3911194503,
0.3346741796,
0.591822505,
-0.2892281711,
0.0969957188,
0.5457147956,
-0.1057671607,
-0.4242717028,
0.4977046251,
-0.1864502281,
0.2592983842,
-0.254047662,
0.2743633389,
-0.1950392723,
0.0841849744,
0.067149967,
0.4846327603,
-0.7155250311,
-0.3035846353,
-0.8531099558,
0.13837789,
-0.6497193575,
-0.4527128637,
-0.4412825406,
-0.0628353283,
-0.2585159242,
-0.3922417462,
0.8078144789,
0.5688901544,
-0.1133430079,
0.5355632305,
-0.997861743,
0.1958225071,
0.1177705601,
0.5036367774,
0.3832876384,
-0.4149190784,
-0.2392533422,
0.2111581415,
-0.3864094615,
-1.0192788839,
0.4371373057,
0.0571710467,
0.2932674587,
0.5087410808,
-0.09265434,
0.8841498494,
-0.3412626684,
0.7022755146,
0.3330082297,
-1.0860993862,
0.5697602034,
-0.3167928457,
0.2199787199,
0.5457306504,
0.2575797439,
-0.9836307168,
-0.3973236382,
-0.7113063335,
-0.7023207545,
0.5528808832,
-0.1112637371,
0.4693910182,
0.1541250348,
0.5632121563,
0.0269435626,
0.3663389981,
-0.3570795357,
-0.1087512895,
-0.2767076194,
-0.4888181388,
-0.212143749,
-0.3864657283,
-0.3336322606,
-0.3115102947,
0.3707987666,
-0.3574408889,
0.5250126123,
0.2922088802,
0.2335039228,
-0.3957745433,
0.4099760056,
0.7117023468,
0.3398113847,
0.027598111,
0.1345604509,
0.6706780791,
-0.5020657778,
-0.0483446941,
-0.27718696,
0.6759093404,
-0.4477475584,
0.3353633881,
0.8145452738,
0.3050970733,
-0.4738331437,
0.3224368393,
-0.2614413798,
-0.0145026492,
-0.2028827518,
0.1921467632,
0.459056586,
0.5854536295,
-0.068695426,
-0.1950059831,
0.2128425539,
-0.5821204782,
0.133746624,
0.4797603488,
-0.6366891265,
-0.1665308326,
-0.1267032027,
0.363103807,
-0.7012503743,
0.7170146704,
0.2483559251,
-0.6930455565,
0.3090624511,
0.6783699393,
0.8736625314,
-0.4434080124,
0.0918094739,
0.1784932911,
0.0735825375,
-0.0321134068,
0.4806604683,
-0.0881124809,
-1.007196188,
0.0419878811,
-0.4037828743,
-0.7035401464,
0.0990525559,
-0.9947080612,
-0.0951029807,
-0.407863766,
-0.462803036,
-0.6782838106,
0.0799314082,
-0.9858404994,
0.1972276866,
-0.1382568628,
0.8223614097,
-0.733428359,
0.4610956907,
0.6388529539,
-0.1190689355,
-0.8898971081,
-0.0086943367,
-0.0326734781,
-0.983553648,
0.282508105,
0.1255707443,
-0.4532344937,
0.2979426682,
-0.7220885158,
-0.4579332769,
1.2712974548,
0.2399978936,
-0.7045392394,
0.0868289843,
-0.0420992337,
0.7083245516,
-0.6440368295,
0.4500034153,
0.9914023876,
0.6809570789,
-0.1601905227,
-1.0102107525,
0.0153105948,
-0.2155757248,
-0.2544571757,
0.0201961435,
-0.9895747304,
0.4224739671,
-0.2359596044,
0.1842920929,
0.0109426193,
0.1180699319,
0.6436113715,
0.3808396459,
0.5488890409,
0.3486164808,
0.9059922695,
-0.1167070046,
0.8584358692,
-0.7120056152,
0.1659148037,
1.1471648216,
-0.3357860148,
0.6209001541,
0.7116309404,
0.1518255472,
0.2115744501,
0.7142351866,
-0.024642285,
0.3087352514,
-0.0276513621,
-0.1518781781,
-0.3915163875,
-0.2808876932,
-0.1854235232,
0.283978194,
0.555213511,
-0.406520009,
0.2418410778,
0.3674087524,
0.2800282836,
-0.0973326415,
-0.2322312742,
0.8331509829,
0.6321573853,
-0.6662285328,
0.2449438572,
-0.2454735339,
0.7452963591,
-0.4187979698,
-0.0463063717,
-0.5406698585,
0.3424511552,
-0.3795757592,
-0.8726652861,
0.0881121531,
0.1270985156,
-0.0145622129,
-0.3093163669,
0.8197445273,
-0.4287842512,
-0.3191010356,
0.7054495215,
0.7164357305,
0.1967245191,
-0.1784408987,
-0.7815741301,
0.0364053473,
-0.2141655833,
-0.4664077759,
0.123121433,
0.7221724987,
0.4015874267,
0.8848342896,
0.601634562,
0.2262590826,
-0.1616084427,
0.4332324266,
0.8300225139,
-0.9087018967,
-0.3331876993,
-0.9490337968,
0.6607316732,
-0.1401028335,
-0.4589003921,
0.9460116029,
0.0285850447,
0.4219408631,
-0.0700582564,
0.7465072274,
0.177462548,
0.5085275173,
-0.6735095978,
0.4892008007,
-0.5271334052,
-0.058025144,
-0.5520989895,
-0.9309183359,
-0.2067654431,
0.8844493032,
-0.3841254413,
0.2880331874,
0.6661052704,
0.9324889779,
0.0808978081,
0.2671356499,
0.4758348465,
0.2278269231,
0.5662139058,
0.5995163321,
0.9272179008,
-0.0136512863,
0.1564909518,
-0.0241063833,
-0.2408086658,
-0.19267115,
-0.7014107108,
-0.9933673143,
-0.5305635929,
0.2608292103,
-0.5364269614,
-0.1810085922,
1.3480529785,
0.7460637689,
-0.6931214929,
-0.348662585,
-0.1466563344,
-0.2923268974,
0.0958882272,
-0.2094740123,
0.1568689346,
-0.4269228578,
-0.5674245358,
0.2269929796,
0.322254926,
0.1424756646,
-0.4889478981,
-0.3812050521,
0.1865048558,
0.2843168676,
0.7832254171,
-0.4058576822,
-0.6203731894,
-0.340598166,
0.2863275111,
-0.0597543791,
0.1061476395,
1.2363388538,
-0.2096191496,
0.3278961778,
-0.0285866074,
0.539855063,
0.3479552567,
0.1916721761,
0.8308605552,
-0.5498453975,
0.0764011815,
0.2368461937,
0.2831558585,
0.371583432,
-0.7388265133,
0.5615977645,
-0.1235609725,
-0.7809420228,
-0.6975433826,
0.3657170832,
-1.0683681965,
-0.1389948726,
1.3707098961,
-0.0320534669,
0.1257285774,
-0.1914014816,
-1.0073395967,
0.5191678405,
-0.7048011422,
0.8573895693,
0.9317139983,
-0.6191504002,
-0.5457933545,
-0.2241183966,
0.6304348707,
0.3807662725,
-0.8920346498,
0.2356931567,
0.2916253209,
0.1599614769,
0.1240315437,
0.7528065443,
0.1701484323,
-0.1320961416,
-0.359421283,
0.0774189234,
0.2741315961,
-0.2526955307,
-0.3589108288,
-0.141564101,
0.1832575649,
0.2079339772
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00268v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00268v1
|
Syntactic Inductive Bias in Transformer Language Models: Especially Helpful for Low-Resource Languages?
| 2023-11-01T03:32:46 | 2023-11-01T03:32:46 |
Luke Gessler, Nathan Schneider
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
A line of work on Transformer-based language models such as BERT has
attempted to use syntactic inductive bias to enhance the pretraining process,
on the theory that building syntactic structure into the training process
should reduce the amount of data needed for training. But such methods are
often tested for high-resource languages such as English. In this work, we
investigate whether these methods can compensate for data sparseness in
low-resource languages, hypothesizing that they ought to be more effective for
low-resource languages. We experiment with five low-resource languages: Uyghur,
Wolof, Maltese, Coptic, and Ancient Greek. We find that these syntactic
inductive bias methods produce uneven results in low-resource settings, and
provide surprisingly little benefit in most cases.
|
[
-0.5003234148,
-0.5695337653,
0.3650791049,
0.0474871993,
-0.1529249847,
-0.078557305,
-0.5921889544,
-0.5459526181,
0.4415454268,
0.2726872563,
-0.6069728136,
-0.0166844074,
-0.4262692928,
0.2691758275,
-0.2892462015,
1.0107134581,
0.0356416292,
0.3476256132,
-0.0790850222,
-0.2835095525,
-0.2371888608,
-0.5154957771,
-0.1583822817,
-0.4705222249,
0.4173572063,
0.5395211577,
0.9308261871,
0.2476121634,
0.4810921252,
0.2100304067,
-0.1522400826,
-0.1123321727,
-0.3809991181,
0.1751548946,
-0.0633561686,
-0.4589184523,
0.01624633,
-0.2288130522,
0.5356023908,
1.0816102028,
-0.0425603464,
0.2513014972,
0.2730365694,
0.6584786177,
-0.7508227825,
-0.0501005128,
-0.571846664,
0.1628632993,
-0.4022471309,
0.0694126859,
-0.4973675311,
-0.1574021727,
0.2230173945,
-0.4508699179,
0.7295204401,
-0.1071709469,
0.6748322845,
0.3989752233,
-0.1289318353,
-0.154901132,
-1.0121158361,
0.7904112935,
-0.8026900291,
0.4022770822,
0.4329870045,
-0.1094530821,
0.1732830703,
-0.5601849556,
-0.506501317,
-0.2998167872,
-0.3854766786,
0.0953077748,
-0.0492813215,
0.2323054671,
0.4685723186,
0.3445210457,
-0.4158086777,
0.4109064341,
-0.2957162559,
-0.1620227844,
0.2123879641,
-0.1169272363,
0.0185556356,
-0.1133494452,
-0.0412320383,
-0.2319341898,
-0.8502014875,
0.0693152994,
0.6633805633,
0.4670997262,
-0.0521859862,
0.5334628224,
-0.038477663,
0.4486058354,
0.016389804,
-0.0995909423,
0.1233805791,
-0.3697960973,
0.0289474763,
0.0913058966,
0.6717020869,
-0.0033394876,
0.3310586512,
-0.3177518845,
-0.3196775615,
0.1173554957,
0.0834949762,
-0.8286309242,
-0.4130485058,
-0.2469594926,
-0.6348368526,
-0.0560684502,
-0.1868427694,
-0.6074861288,
-0.1660859734,
0.283321619,
0.2436552197,
-0.2979529202,
-0.0428424887,
-0.2234987766,
-0.1165991947,
-0.0010345358,
0.1599277258,
-1.2488919497,
0.4613368511,
-0.0173908453,
0.5137004852,
-0.0059078243,
-0.2874335051,
-0.3502239883,
-0.1134967282,
-0.1174725592,
0.8410429358,
-0.7621552944,
-0.3490121961,
0.2204369754,
-0.0617057718,
0.036504861,
-0.5701878667,
0.6984123588,
-0.1804432869,
0.3370509446,
-0.569446981,
-0.3117579818,
0.1821879297,
-0.3175893426,
-1.0327237844,
1.1954573393,
0.2434854209,
-0.8158127069,
0.6535665989,
-0.6171181798,
-0.9025748968,
0.1075621024,
-0.1732602119,
-0.4471604228,
0.3049311936,
0.483656019,
0.0379998796,
-0.4751650691,
-0.0556204729,
-0.1372272819,
-0.5202736259,
0.2012282163,
-0.6195703149,
0.7273800373,
0.3084406555,
-0.6962471604,
-0.2880455554,
-0.7038635015,
0.0033372785,
0.3790582716,
-0.4045882523,
-0.5517576337,
0.1663992405,
0.380107671,
0.1500120163,
-0.0020636783,
-0.6709789038,
0.2432465851,
-0.4330694079,
0.2800274193,
0.5460630059,
-0.1784248799,
0.7841905951,
-0.0394880734,
0.5703498721,
-0.0952450112,
0.0155191571,
-0.0443427674,
-0.3869477808,
-0.9658709168,
-0.0689973384,
0.5057374835,
0.19721587,
-0.8175206184,
0.2567884326,
0.0951602757,
-0.081674017,
-0.9542478323,
0.2768955827,
0.4185418785,
0.2747403681,
0.4271784723,
-0.3511330485,
-0.6063907146,
-1.0328097343,
-0.2288694084,
0.0067809657,
-0.0319593064,
0.0892063156,
0.1792171746,
0.0462330617,
0.7236276865,
-0.1026296541,
-0.1556821018,
-0.5042853951,
0.0185248982,
0.1641079038,
0.4594049156,
0.7032820582,
-0.5596071482,
-0.5934751034,
-0.3418703973,
-0.0439847149,
-0.2523426712,
-0.1113261953,
0.104300648,
0.4541144967,
0.1683906466,
-0.5054218769,
0.3819457889,
0.7057365179,
-0.1075579971,
0.3069691956,
-0.0794537589,
-0.2806220353,
-0.8905010819,
-0.0208537467,
0.055101566,
-0.1739774644,
-0.5408198833,
-0.2671649754,
0.0261921212,
-0.000302439,
-0.1997605115,
0.4021583498,
-0.5881375074,
-0.1473221928,
-0.2599883676,
-0.0530546904,
-0.2078992724,
0.4259844422,
0.3408622742,
0.9190683365,
0.2019115984,
-0.3760470748,
-0.1067036092,
0.2634483278,
-0.4544889033,
0.1824723929,
-0.5459524989,
0.0845143646,
-0.0514941402,
0.1314954907,
-0.8083523512,
0.0967897624,
-0.0019451882,
-0.1041911542,
0.169588834,
-0.298663646,
-0.6720625758,
-0.3063144386,
-0.1116487086,
0.5991873741,
0.6263740063,
-0.6925106645,
0.2123696804,
0.2923305035,
-0.1214958355,
-0.7339875102,
-0.7279997468,
-0.3427663445,
-0.1796403974,
-0.341462642,
0.5149701834,
-0.0717955902,
-0.2329229265,
0.1715632826,
-0.1790621281,
-0.0994704664,
0.099875249,
-0.1124681309,
0.1949321181,
-0.3158586919,
0.1289233416,
-0.1387089938,
0.0903791562,
-0.0368833952,
-0.3982192278,
0.7935034633,
0.0122144334,
-0.4301315248,
-0.311901778,
0.3234237731,
0.1498249471,
-0.3330007195,
0.8591113687,
0.5505607724,
-0.27978912,
-0.3267050087,
-0.6465225816,
-0.549816668,
-0.4508172274,
0.274815917,
-0.1297919899,
-0.9136466384,
0.6669827104,
0.050746467,
-0.151226148,
0.670688808,
0.8389367461,
-0.1517252922,
1.0070772171,
0.8366567492,
-0.2643439174,
0.795199573,
-0.2766643465,
0.2585876882,
-0.5345611572,
0.0896205008,
-0.7246572971,
-0.4664487243,
-1.1764086485,
0.0569807142,
0.3469522595,
-0.2331766486,
-0.1113465577,
0.3344610929,
-0.4140515924,
0.5363233089,
0.8450236917,
-0.1346514523,
0.1709685028,
0.1833236367,
-0.2336473167,
-0.2317219228,
-1.0720416307,
-0.2747038901,
0.9520201087,
0.1378223747,
1.2250854969,
-0.1160822883,
0.6749152541,
0.1282484531,
0.1117199138,
-0.6708107591,
-0.017706221,
-0.140855372,
-0.7117345929,
-0.4343345761,
-0.3413847387,
-0.9292773008,
0.0954786465,
-0.2582115531,
-0.6127743125,
0.4023644626,
0.2265143692,
-0.3257669806,
0.3478275836,
-0.8095252514,
0.8182576895,
-0.1470731497,
-0.1875498295,
-0.1472338885,
-0.6394041777,
-0.0066621993,
0.0189102422,
-0.0060213413,
0.1680624038,
0.4063135386,
0.8617197871,
-0.5279322863,
0.874550283,
-0.3175876439,
-0.1649872959,
0.283170253,
-0.0298178494,
0.7833396792,
-0.0877968818,
0.1639296114,
0.0288276318,
-0.111556612,
-0.6145200133,
-0.2746943533,
0.3451386988,
-0.7401417494,
-0.3581781983,
-0.3427407444,
-0.7381873727,
-0.2608952224,
0.0899460465,
0.6412898302,
0.2473732978,
-0.1711565256,
0.2581508756,
0.6668955684,
-0.1087873951,
0.725535512,
0.4517157376,
0.4195163548,
-0.1013392061,
0.3708202541,
0.2257525772,
0.3740174174,
0.3102572262,
0.0604261681,
-0.235239625,
-0.5463026166,
-0.3186763823,
0.2579141855,
-0.5310451984,
-0.2075797617,
-0.3392310739,
-0.2486840338,
-0.22683613,
-0.1187240407,
-0.63516891,
-0.8615317345,
0.0966798067,
0.02390166,
0.0795624107,
0.7648281455,
0.1770094186,
0.6546445489,
-0.5516547561,
0.0258660335,
-0.0128700435,
0.340226233,
-0.1019318849,
-0.5382490754,
-0.8503806591,
-0.0644828305,
-0.2957073152,
-0.6035172343,
0.1960067898,
0.242070049,
0.6440538764,
0.2895400226,
0.1891862601,
0.4567711353,
-0.6409516335,
0.64365381,
0.1542224437,
-0.7764587998,
0.4769800305,
0.0331561081,
0.3146464229,
0.5410562754,
0.2946771383,
-0.4187348187,
-0.6717178226,
-0.7511441112,
-0.7950489521,
0.7668818235,
0.3447882533,
0.2726048529,
-0.0282294024,
0.1461046934,
0.3264223635,
0.0613018796,
-1.0109605789,
-0.4778922498,
-0.116457209,
-0.1752920449,
0.039046593,
-0.4582998455,
-0.1135703325,
-0.141587615,
0.5001528859,
-0.2164562792,
0.4260057807,
0.1921854466,
-0.4377312958,
-0.488825351,
0.4745141268,
0.3919772804,
0.6516506672,
-0.1436930746,
0.1470234245,
0.3809660971,
-0.630846858,
0.1822614968,
0.2985039949,
-0.3540556729,
0.2521964312,
0.4417486191,
0.8490635753,
0.0965883955,
-0.4787590802,
0.335298866,
-0.0821873546,
0.0203758534,
-0.2442151159,
-0.0057167304,
-0.2426466346,
0.3720044494,
0.4555392563,
0.1245823503,
0.0202838946,
-0.5237764716,
-0.0949578509,
0.5995252728,
-0.0284593925,
-0.4513824582,
0.6255800128,
0.2242857516,
-0.0530020148,
0.6301407218,
-0.1635255665,
-0.573702693,
0.3594475985,
0.8154278994,
0.7733106017,
-0.3267671466,
0.1006094515,
0.1885877848,
0.6108287573,
0.0076482194,
0.2664297223,
-0.3308840692,
-0.8665884137,
-0.6810106635,
-0.604257226,
-0.3970901966,
0.2958455682,
-0.7575690746,
0.0478327535,
-0.0735788569,
-0.2397230119,
0.1015448496,
-0.0024974213,
-1.0383586884,
-0.0106278919,
0.275960207,
0.7582440972,
-0.889769733,
1.0944116116,
0.7625322938,
-0.5404036045,
-0.6814154387,
0.3482963145,
-0.3660348654,
-0.7995468378,
0.8477752805,
-0.1500107944,
-0.0891470686,
-0.0018453398,
-0.287032485,
-0.8595448732,
0.6915057302,
0.701634109,
-0.5553674698,
-0.2156692892,
0.3529196978,
0.6428035498,
-0.2217265815,
0.2628519833,
0.4698453844,
0.335386306,
-0.2526298165,
-1.1166247129,
0.0397002026,
-0.2885497808,
0.1845594645,
0.3601557016,
-0.5054886937,
0.7871348262,
-0.2660013437,
-0.142159313,
-0.0603269264,
0.5784431696,
-0.2727620304,
-0.1113266423,
0.4704663754,
0.6931632757,
0.613345325,
-0.1310433,
1.0142136812,
-0.4785798788,
0.4848197401,
0.9371421337,
-0.2727862597,
0.4788469374,
0.6042327285,
-0.4188679755,
0.6206606627,
0.5012879372,
0.109894,
0.811567843,
-0.0320741832,
-0.2620846033,
-0.0250307266,
-0.4002396166,
-0.2941912115,
0.4027298689,
0.1187480092,
-0.2984610796,
-0.1940483898,
0.0834373906,
0.058289241,
-0.0885302126,
-0.1016360447,
0.7059673071,
-0.0829759985,
-0.5528034568,
0.6906197667,
-0.0826614723,
0.6594280005,
-0.5006943345,
0.102572985,
-0.5659024119,
0.1492923647,
-0.1439064145,
-0.4932023585,
0.1137834638,
0.214100793,
-0.2614661753,
-0.239502117,
0.7393566966,
-0.5042560101,
-0.2824110687,
0.303478539,
0.7408463359,
-0.1472034901,
0.1111664921,
-0.4016835392,
-0.1860943884,
-0.1266676188,
-0.2055756599,
0.3748479784,
0.4390195012,
0.0168931969,
0.2661070824,
0.5053759813,
0.3817070425,
-0.0270140767,
0.5349063873,
1.0139169693,
-0.7238577008,
-0.4503388107,
-0.775939405,
0.2573651075,
0.1931003332,
-0.0336292684,
0.7798073292,
0.6425808072,
1.278785944,
-0.0573926568,
0.9035078287,
-0.2812518775,
0.3630261123,
-0.6590308547,
0.656458497,
-0.2856575251,
0.2178786397,
-0.2575846314,
-1.1904782057,
-0.0288003497,
0.8309864402,
-0.2462936938,
0.1823842227,
1.0206478834,
0.5405717492,
-0.1219876558,
-0.1773236692,
0.1791010052,
0.0402774885,
-0.0153704118,
0.370400548,
0.8957795501,
-0.2560392022,
0.5413918495,
-0.6922496557,
0.0196954105,
-0.2153696418,
-0.6105502248,
-0.9608329535,
-0.6020615697,
0.1852994412,
-0.4240561128,
0.1020991653,
1.2372585535,
0.6056877375,
-1.0132075548,
-0.2755187154,
-0.0143933631,
0.0696352497,
-0.2234025449,
-0.1766571403,
0.35343346,
-0.7252767682,
-0.7752404213,
0.3362601995,
-0.1009647995,
0.0890659541,
-0.2580366135,
-0.2668044269,
0.0287274569,
-0.2853940129,
0.3695467114,
0.2442869544,
-0.5276713967,
-0.1995358169,
0.1429801285,
-0.1954751313,
0.3181041181,
1.1556661129,
-0.8442202806,
0.411159724,
0.189035356,
0.5695709586,
0.5670554042,
-0.2323619574,
0.427149415,
-0.910561502,
0.6041808128,
0.2547282875,
0.6221344471,
0.2941891849,
-0.3214212954,
0.5188724995,
0.3873955607,
-0.5092846751,
-0.7152973413,
0.185705781,
-0.4976634085,
-0.0867526382,
0.9924266338,
0.1849564165,
-0.0158307534,
0.1715656072,
-0.0153757147,
0.3504735529,
-0.4032800794,
1.0108948946,
0.8507606983,
-0.1725052744,
-0.2286201864,
-0.5715667009,
0.8143334389,
0.7186877728,
-0.6632099152,
-0.0624527372,
0.3764297366,
0.1548070461,
0.2332131267,
0.5034879446,
0.1872223765,
0.2544895709,
-0.0398400165,
0.3039338291,
0.3623440862,
-0.2306994349,
-0.2955802083,
-0.4424265027,
0.5286380053,
0.0458305776
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00262v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00262v2
|
Plug-and-Play Policy Planner for Large Language Model Powered Dialogue Agents
| 2023-11-01T03:20:16 | 2024-03-11T08:30:31 |
Yang Deng, Wenxuan Zhang, Wai Lam, See-Kiong Ng, Tat-Seng Chua
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Proactive dialogues serve as a practical yet challenging dialogue problem in
the era of large language models (LLMs), where the dialogue policy planning is
the key to improving the proactivity of LLMs. Most existing studies enable the
dialogue policy planning of LLMs using various prompting schemes or iteratively
enhance this capability in handling the given case with verbal AI feedback.
However, these approaches are either bounded by the policy planning capability
of the frozen LLMs or hard to be transferred to new cases. In this work, we
introduce a new dialogue policy planning paradigm to strategize LLMs for
proactive dialogue problems with a tunable language model plug-in as a
plug-and-play dialogue policy planner, named PPDPP. Specifically, we develop a
novel training framework to facilitate supervised fine-tuning over available
human-annotated data as well as reinforcement learning from goal-oriented AI
feedback with dynamic interaction data collected by the LLM-based self-play
simulation. In this manner, the LLM-powered dialogue agent can not only be
generalized to different cases after the training, but also be applicable to
different applications by just substituting the learned plug-in. In addition,
we propose to evaluate the policy planning capability of dialogue systems under
the interactive setting. Experimental results demonstrate that PPDPP
consistently and substantially outperforms existing approaches on three
different proactive dialogue applications, including negotiation, emotional
support, and tutoring dialogues.
|
[
-0.5848470926,
-0.7519962788,
0.5580369234,
0.4755703211,
0.0083634751,
0.1663084775,
-0.4987239838,
0.0476863421,
0.2539504468,
0.760545969,
-0.898792088,
-0.2207947969,
-0.0882459655,
-0.048197899,
0.2884125412,
0.7356675863,
0.0432223864,
0.096951656,
0.0135307219,
0.1453260034,
-0.713721633,
-0.2168101519,
-0.8895549178,
-0.5552818775,
0.2958991826,
0.5532364845,
0.8012830615,
-0.0733161569,
0.2848638892,
0.3383255899,
-0.143325761,
0.4950873554,
-0.2341983765,
-0.0164657272,
-0.2602396905,
-0.2745010853,
-0.7305005193,
-0.0382377245,
0.7153408527,
0.4262845516,
-0.4026136696,
-0.323633343,
-0.0221375488,
0.2600755095,
-0.3489090502,
0.6617922187,
-0.6438399553,
0.2188733369,
0.2984042466,
-0.148729831,
-0.4479076266,
-0.1114710718,
0.1412536949,
-0.6423312426,
-0.127953738,
-0.2719969749,
0.3936963379,
0.2865165472,
-0.2506349683,
-0.0102023371,
-1.0165005922,
0.6737936139,
-0.9250913858,
0.0452431776,
0.3758672774,
0.387417078,
-0.6513671279,
-0.4083298743,
-0.7510675788,
-0.5077483058,
0.06276723,
0.1980791688,
0.0728539079,
0.5116150975,
0.2862908244,
0.141198203,
-0.3272090852,
0.4474473298,
0.1967272311,
-0.2065088004,
0.7585921884,
0.110532403,
-0.1782362014,
0.1729952544,
-0.0650364906,
-0.0043143374,
-0.6700327396,
0.0947957262,
0.5047976375,
0.4796118736,
-0.0414614715,
0.3822740614,
-0.3419375718,
0.6430484056,
0.0449223518,
-0.3526134789,
-0.0954966322,
-0.2125723809,
-0.1600178629,
-0.1308425665,
0.8452413082,
0.1505844742,
0.4443450272,
0.0580266267,
-0.2075475156,
-0.3178234398,
0.1922576129,
-0.6113071442,
-0.3144239783,
0.0836533681,
-0.0227969903,
-0.3445399702,
-0.4370288253,
-0.6760213375,
-0.2205688506,
-0.3600347936,
0.3979738951,
-0.3225933611,
-0.4875727892,
0.3244843483,
0.4489244521,
-0.0113739362,
0.473898977,
-1.1462813616,
0.372218281,
0.6546058059,
0.6059890389,
-0.0263873674,
-0.1375632137,
-0.7084630132,
0.1074395701,
-0.3079384863,
0.7761082649,
-0.6715784669,
-0.6831445694,
0.462600261,
0.0429703221,
-0.2264531553,
-0.6143119335,
0.4614056051,
-0.324225992,
0.1868466586,
0.0322190933,
-0.4765606225,
0.1867957413,
0.4592126012,
-0.4894118011,
0.5699973106,
0.0898038074,
-0.3455162346,
0.257753253,
-0.7487156987,
-0.3740969896,
0.1601239145,
-0.2904759943,
-0.5577582717,
-0.2348198444,
0.3266973197,
0.3605916798,
-0.1561618745,
0.7437079549,
-0.1621274948,
-0.1904359758,
0.1808737367,
-0.3886586428,
0.4998236597,
-0.0228672568,
-0.2232740074,
0.4934140146,
-0.6654752493,
-0.0296181794,
0.0711042285,
-0.4478619099,
0.2470456809,
0.2304697931,
-0.2030123174,
0.3246425092,
0.0255155992,
-0.5070533752,
0.757494688,
-0.4820991457,
0.4980051816,
0.7007763386,
0.0824124739,
0.5320513844,
-0.2532542348,
0.6651437283,
-0.2855789363,
0.2778794467,
-0.329064846,
-0.4722239375,
-0.6489956975,
-0.3687876463,
0.2361230999,
0.7197642326,
-0.923825562,
0.6340138912,
0.1741936952,
-0.3293678164,
-0.2672227919,
-0.0182301756,
0.4063858986,
0.3687166572,
0.2690544128,
-0.5526734591,
-0.1636742055,
-0.7858806849,
-0.1362133026,
-0.5080454946,
-0.1499218643,
0.55091995,
0.1021308377,
-0.0603921674,
1.1197340488,
-0.4923924804,
-0.6365695596,
-0.6003590226,
0.3708957732,
0.1595919281,
0.553311646,
0.1456745118,
-0.4947436154,
-0.494720161,
-0.3259160519,
-0.1047708243,
-0.2266768217,
-0.6092979312,
0.1293373704,
0.1136449501,
0.4532920122,
-0.8295310736,
0.255022496,
0.4454021752,
-0.0954373032,
0.9612256885,
-0.4086760879,
-0.2443459034,
-0.6699581742,
-0.2151151747,
-0.1046413481,
-0.2889221311,
-0.6905892491,
-0.2964937687,
-0.2359731942,
-0.2443703562,
-0.4844040275,
0.4113106132,
-0.1341970414,
0.0101713538,
-0.239627704,
-0.1090342402,
-0.2201520652,
0.8386057615,
0.3886126578,
0.9390111566,
0.3926272392,
-0.639791131,
0.3476939201,
0.4609028101,
-0.2645213008,
0.4217367768,
-0.4842376113,
0.0125180362,
0.2540923953,
0.6548138857,
-0.6009337306,
-0.1066364944,
0.139952898,
0.0911682919,
0.6648811698,
-0.2911198437,
-0.5461137295,
-0.1314236969,
-0.0750556514,
0.2604465485,
0.3527210951,
-0.3750226498,
0.6342759728,
0.4653574824,
-0.4853375852,
-0.1924425513,
0.0125124417,
0.1137007326,
-0.1340719759,
-0.4829880893,
0.6159431338,
-0.1774305105,
-0.0445647873,
-0.4559793472,
0.1006677225,
0.1713704169,
-0.0190520342,
-0.018471662,
0.1135362238,
0.1005481482,
0.0970542207,
-0.1000273153,
-0.3885879219,
-0.0268443562,
-0.2974909246,
0.9162504077,
-0.104239352,
-0.4389957488,
-0.4967085719,
0.1620248556,
0.2553302348,
-0.4057350159,
0.3908847868,
0.4433283508,
0.1501469761,
-0.0508945771,
-0.5339748859,
-0.250646323,
-0.524328351,
0.339145273,
-0.2675702572,
-1.0112637281,
0.3126501143,
-0.7589818239,
0.4799108803,
-0.0674816817,
0.6107617617,
-0.0312604755,
1.3703508377,
0.7703868747,
-0.0808494613,
0.7925193906,
-0.3373911977,
0.3280269802,
-0.7398914099,
-0.2096240222,
-0.1498789042,
-0.0913476348,
-0.705195725,
-0.5350238681,
0.3264738917,
-0.10849116,
-0.2984282672,
0.2770960331,
-0.1173672751,
0.3464979231,
0.5451712012,
-0.1894311011,
0.1422418654,
-0.1545737386,
-0.2297266424,
-0.1718271077,
-0.7499715686,
-0.3989144266,
0.7960065007,
0.5360406637,
0.5998479724,
0.0005917011,
0.60117203,
0.0514896773,
-0.002430435,
-0.840246737,
0.8262478113,
0.1551430076,
-0.172096774,
-0.620108366,
-0.2241206765,
-0.7515484691,
0.131655246,
-0.3428471088,
-0.9625566006,
0.2003040165,
0.2877489924,
-0.3248002827,
0.2663440406,
-0.4529378712,
0.7897109389,
-0.2451619208,
-0.485948652,
-0.3865039945,
-0.4541064203,
0.1395860612,
0.069912754,
0.0387622081,
-0.3043679595,
0.3544746041,
0.3775321245,
-0.3930093646,
0.8641275764,
-0.4511164129,
-0.3432900012,
0.2476004958,
0.309427321,
0.8389801979,
0.1606756151,
0.1653002799,
-0.0283474866,
-0.2883208394,
-0.2780291438,
-0.5410420895,
0.3829618692,
-0.5658326745,
-0.7952150106,
-0.2042444348,
-0.8171705604,
-0.7337585092,
0.0956356898,
-0.1877261698,
0.2540202141,
-0.4798238575,
-0.2626829445,
0.7812740803,
-0.4516412616,
0.5123481154,
0.9570014477,
-0.4186985791,
-0.1519891173,
1.0186296701,
0.1249708757,
0.4066668153,
0.3075080812,
0.163197726,
-0.1403583884,
-0.4970881045,
-0.3012686372,
0.2288947552,
-0.2092334181,
-0.0577469692,
-0.4454651475,
-0.3224891424,
-0.3579939604,
-0.1997653395,
-0.4027839601,
-0.5443255305,
-0.1546304822,
0.0110177305,
0.1069040671,
0.2630213797,
-0.1972038746,
0.5394983888,
-0.3359790444,
0.1691318005,
0.6376748085,
0.5231508613,
-0.4240033627,
-0.3023816347,
-0.1100305095,
-0.1526524723,
-0.6302966475,
-0.7080160379,
0.6659465432,
0.4145026505,
0.467926532,
0.5307382345,
0.1758042127,
0.5109644532,
-0.7420149446,
0.8125911355,
0.0666176453,
-0.4120994806,
0.6017379165,
-0.5086017847,
0.5341004729,
0.504127264,
-0.0094989911,
-0.4235790074,
-0.5805256367,
-0.7748638391,
-0.8524028063,
0.8623557687,
0.0945151299,
0.2040467411,
0.1213880777,
-0.0199893266,
-0.0894193798,
0.3865634799,
-0.3386749923,
0.1636897326,
-0.020964684,
0.1652197242,
-0.1917257458,
-0.2960735857,
-0.3452311456,
-0.2308951467,
0.8037708998,
-0.4637270272,
0.3472000659,
-0.0928771198,
0.1784109324,
0.0437615924,
0.4935409129,
0.4861102402,
0.4531170428,
-0.2165427953,
-0.1936134994,
0.2031434625,
-0.2359992862,
0.023905322,
0.2423481345,
-0.1823973209,
-0.0767587423,
0.0635533333,
0.792735517,
0.4066311717,
-0.935408473,
0.3263759315,
-0.2170023471,
-0.2784175575,
-0.6150239706,
0.30208534,
-0.00255194,
0.3666324019,
-0.0537293963,
-0.2278630286,
-0.0307696275,
-0.5505062342,
0.0481169932,
0.5544386506,
-0.4884017706,
-0.1384156346,
0.2202408314,
0.3748953342,
-0.7874253392,
0.6081568599,
-0.3642671704,
-0.5664074421,
0.4112959206,
0.6774129868,
0.7708810568,
-0.3628512621,
0.7443651557,
0.0548449643,
0.1645130962,
0.0452483818,
0.3344545662,
-0.3230491877,
-0.8099848032,
-0.6284714937,
-0.4295638502,
-0.7791965008,
0.3892586529,
-0.2516340315,
0.2689830363,
-0.5741494894,
-0.1523848325,
-0.2600308359,
0.2595877349,
-0.6597690582,
-0.1209957078,
-0.0592768341,
0.9920213819,
-0.7623379827,
0.9269738197,
0.5172931552,
-0.2789461613,
-0.8348446488,
0.1482209712,
0.0274767242,
-0.5979713798,
0.3579653502,
0.0069817286,
0.0988783389,
0.1666709334,
-0.4393900931,
-0.5806719661,
0.8778173327,
0.4495123327,
-0.8042974472,
-0.0711529106,
0.2702265382,
0.5692931414,
-0.4981554151,
0.3345942795,
0.9672535658,
0.3934477866,
0.2133160383,
-1.2944734097,
-0.2887201607,
-0.0258428305,
-0.0179404039,
0.1971308887,
-0.8377204537,
0.4664605856,
0.0290228166,
0.1990935653,
-0.028763961,
0.550142467,
0.2074862868,
0.1370481104,
0.6136250496,
0.4353084564,
0.4639002383,
-0.0143390093,
0.6923066974,
-0.3015230596,
0.1206988841,
1.1348675489,
-0.6211779714,
0.6817767024,
0.2773754299,
-0.2119796723,
0.3880070448,
0.5072555542,
0.1199663728,
0.6693370342,
0.2608741522,
-0.6528332233,
-0.5120775104,
-0.422175765,
0.0561469831,
0.4556487203,
0.548376441,
0.0396381654,
-0.1082458496,
0.0795087144,
0.1952404231,
0.0960448235,
-0.2433414012,
1.1691117287,
-0.0349594355,
-0.9368228316,
0.297426343,
0.0378202014,
0.423099786,
-0.7093707919,
-0.2610710859,
-0.1146295667,
0.2006520331,
-0.0518518612,
-0.6852726936,
0.0267037842,
-0.2105152309,
0.2018205076,
-0.5315884352,
0.702083528,
-0.6501348615,
-0.2045684904,
0.1242477223,
0.250646323,
0.062304575,
0.0728000328,
-0.8254201412,
-0.1913277805,
-0.0247498732,
-0.2377548218,
0.6673965454,
0.1842628866,
-0.1557522565,
0.7523167133,
0.6232142448,
0.3304022253,
-0.376337111,
0.3310407698,
1.0898513794,
-0.1499975473,
-0.7398988008,
-0.3991360366,
0.4909032881,
-0.2165650874,
-0.1003785059,
0.3592008054,
0.2510072291,
0.8358383179,
0.1006988585,
0.6383169889,
0.1917978078,
0.4153053463,
-0.536870122,
0.2641786337,
-0.0424985923,
0.5002382994,
-0.2706940174,
-0.993678391,
-0.1989983171,
0.945631206,
-0.6043867469,
-0.1533628851,
0.2676196098,
0.88294065,
0.0559354015,
-0.033640217,
0.3787938952,
0.1635283381,
0.8166379929,
0.4234956205,
0.6413171887,
0.3173798919,
0.2793957889,
-0.1700802296,
-0.393045783,
-0.4044316411,
-0.8674198985,
-0.8252417445,
-0.4202053845,
-0.3826503754,
-0.1248527318,
0.087056905,
1.0666797161,
0.6540492773,
-0.6514333487,
-0.276083231,
-0.4895886481,
0.1256521344,
-0.2603565156,
-0.237152949,
0.1069211662,
-0.7024440169,
-0.6627150774,
0.783641994,
0.4415228665,
-0.1438341439,
-0.6870405674,
-0.3045071363,
-0.19234249,
0.3209005296,
0.5409759879,
0.7042558193,
-0.49184829,
-0.1851392686,
-0.3153485358,
0.317127049,
-0.0353807658,
1.1310176849,
-0.9859688878,
0.8107600808,
0.1471750587,
0.3215274513,
0.6853535175,
-0.2756913006,
0.958948493,
-0.9267616868,
0.4878053963,
0.588503778,
0.2077567577,
0.0965218544,
-0.0961143672,
0.2841985822,
-0.1317529231,
-0.8990774751,
-0.762037456,
0.8415427804,
-0.6738190651,
-0.1145559549,
1.1822012663,
-0.3110431731,
0.3533599377,
-0.2689585388,
-0.7288278341,
0.140149042,
-0.4570699334,
0.8799250722,
0.4195774198,
-0.443993181,
-0.2974731624,
-0.5281196833,
0.8509171605,
0.472383976,
-0.6076018214,
0.1504142135,
0.5146934986,
-0.2267911285,
0.1334195733,
1.0620548725,
0.1953293681,
0.033198677,
-0.3118400574,
-0.1023814455,
-0.1120958477,
-0.6673520207,
-0.2743336856,
-0.0420668498,
0.3382707238,
0.1764377207
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00258v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00258v1
|
Noisy Exemplars Make Large Language Models More Robust: A Domain-Agnostic Behavioral Analysis
| 2023-11-01T03:15:05 | 2023-11-01T03:15:05 |
Hongyi Zheng, Abulhair Saparov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent advances in prompt engineering enable large language models (LLMs) to
solve multi-hop logical reasoning problems with impressive accuracy. However,
there is little existing work investigating the robustness of LLMs with
few-shot prompting techniques. Therefore, we introduce a systematic approach to
test the robustness of LLMs in multi-hop reasoning tasks via domain-agnostic
perturbations. We include perturbations at multiple levels of abstractions
(e.g. lexical perturbations such as typos, and semantic perturbations such as
the inclusion of intermediate reasoning steps in the questions) to conduct
behavioral analysis on the LLMs. Throughout our experiments, we find that
models are more sensitive to certain perturbations such as replacing words with
their synonyms. We also demonstrate that increasing the proportion of perturbed
exemplars in the prompts improves the robustness of few-shot prompting methods.
|
[
-0.3635427952,
-1.386041522,
0.6460876465,
0.1781028211,
0.028277915,
-0.0351357348,
-0.1774784476,
-0.2776924372,
-0.1607785225,
0.2839945257,
-0.6620572805,
-0.2390337735,
-0.6773241758,
0.4003244638,
-0.2773498893,
0.7383375168,
0.0453411378,
-0.2061861455,
-0.0456181653,
-0.0392935164,
-0.3909800649,
-0.5012416244,
-0.6776601672,
-0.1481901556,
0.5252144933,
0.0793679953,
0.9691815376,
0.3400389254,
0.3594274521,
0.3482406139,
-0.3914694786,
0.0521590263,
-0.3154017627,
0.6289513707,
-0.0019294081,
-0.3977974355,
-0.3069510758,
-0.0809719786,
0.6534737945,
0.8089790344,
0.0380815901,
0.07497067,
0.2845221162,
0.0750733539,
-0.6021455526,
0.1759016812,
-0.9868759513,
-0.2294875979,
-0.1681740582,
-0.1377371103,
-0.5886539221,
-0.1256248206,
-0.0504248664,
-0.5488040447,
-0.1234012246,
0.0805409029,
0.8470509052,
0.546138227,
-0.3325197101,
-0.0987304598,
-0.7054908276,
1.0757712126,
-0.7850363255,
0.3641216457,
0.3901878893,
0.1976731867,
-0.7015089989,
-0.4888917208,
-0.6561268568,
-0.4190774262,
0.0650320202,
-0.1552478373,
-0.3472460806,
0.1295675784,
0.7768114805,
-0.0362568162,
-0.5297077298,
0.1294590235,
0.4235293269,
-0.3805118799,
0.1848023385,
0.2912847698,
0.3341546059,
0.1046502888,
-0.0891880766,
-0.2869760394,
-0.7039518952,
0.3639213145,
0.6797824502,
0.5444247723,
0.1173313409,
0.4862974882,
-0.0062086903,
0.9522410035,
0.1248018965,
-0.2537433505,
0.05484429,
-0.5540475845,
-0.1336858124,
-0.4372436404,
0.7559337616,
0.0300046094,
0.4407486618,
0.2486562133,
-0.3022126853,
0.1902345419,
-0.0010202688,
-0.7479337454,
-0.261838764,
0.4417590797,
-0.4038321674,
-0.2802768052,
-0.3058366179,
-0.7117343545,
-0.4423590899,
-0.1991245896,
0.4010922313,
-0.5669186711,
-0.0987369418,
0.3732328713,
-0.1006089151,
0.3021502495,
0.4915427864,
-0.9298275113,
0.1866707057,
0.7688285708,
0.6389428377,
0.0218743626,
-0.5542362928,
-1.039144516,
0.0647845119,
-0.4230821729,
1.1523982286,
-0.8714968562,
-0.4283497036,
0.0117773712,
-0.2096545249,
-0.0457582511,
-0.5430330038,
0.496121794,
-0.5151159167,
-0.0057295351,
-0.4413028359,
-0.509355545,
0.1281263381,
0.4822838604,
-0.4435870945,
0.9762329459,
0.0162847172,
-0.7381891012,
0.2937729359,
-0.5232514739,
-0.4212728441,
-0.364302963,
-0.4376467168,
-0.371899277,
0.22716932,
0.3631418943,
0.3226104677,
0.0731630474,
0.0557943694,
-0.5149398446,
-0.2407551557,
0.436567843,
-0.5172945261,
1.0844296217,
0.0023896028,
-0.1884744465,
0.1773536652,
-0.6648213267,
0.0835079551,
0.0647509992,
-0.242739588,
-0.4735577106,
-0.018130485,
-0.5547780395,
0.1934440583,
-0.1508394778,
-0.3857114911,
0.3511848152,
-0.3647449613,
0.2016670555,
0.8181399703,
0.2616039217,
0.1388394386,
-0.4811738729,
0.6983139515,
0.0025662247,
0.2539623976,
-0.6042677164,
-0.6988765597,
-0.2924731672,
-0.6799378395,
0.0012216873,
0.359901756,
-0.6601381898,
0.200619787,
-0.0051761717,
-0.1636686623,
-0.0210282952,
0.147210896,
0.0455246381,
0.5352956653,
0.2304861099,
0.1339268386,
-0.3112922013,
-0.6450116038,
-0.5928398371,
-0.4832476676,
-0.0023714236,
0.0086325603,
0.4529701769,
-0.2785250247,
0.8266373277,
-0.2275449932,
0.1694289148,
-0.0652384609,
0.2317047119,
0.4431975186,
0.213855803,
0.6319000721,
-0.3388736248,
-0.4970844984,
-0.235528335,
-0.5388957262,
-0.4134875238,
-0.2232022882,
0.0233645625,
-0.0327504911,
0.7054946423,
-0.8602080941,
0.3610502481,
0.4748106599,
-0.3824436069,
1.1401896477,
0.2824085057,
0.1035622954,
-0.5261653662,
-0.1400849819,
-0.2130773813,
-0.1728145033,
-0.654430151,
0.2476955503,
-0.2210965604,
-0.0354507565,
-0.2945748568,
0.4989683032,
-0.5549433827,
0.1963156462,
-0.4643037319,
-0.0675680116,
0.1029834449,
0.1388418525,
-0.0844205543,
0.807682693,
1.003682971,
-0.7572346926,
0.2664963007,
0.4088770449,
-0.1990444064,
0.4205261469,
-0.8453442454,
0.1461830288,
-0.2227112353,
0.1951721758,
-1.3601427078,
-0.3478196263,
0.0545870066,
-0.5722651482,
0.2480240911,
-0.1617652178,
-0.5735900402,
-0.2073924392,
-0.6770343781,
0.2404155135,
0.4016707838,
-0.6347965002,
0.7289414406,
0.0535626113,
-0.4473603964,
-0.4692319036,
-0.5766086578,
0.0464314483,
-0.1830462813,
-0.7343001962,
-0.2079254389,
-0.3237738311,
-0.7028155327,
-0.3236942291,
-0.065063037,
0.0671095401,
0.4095065892,
0.1174184084,
0.4783425629,
-0.213856414,
0.0238306429,
-0.054672841,
-0.0398043022,
0.3174760342,
-0.216166839,
0.4437949657,
-0.1261181384,
-0.6598724723,
-0.3774009347,
0.3662699759,
0.6484498382,
-0.0818779394,
0.4881496727,
0.3064794242,
-0.3642287552,
-0.3595252633,
-0.4559060037,
-0.5321757197,
-0.5641525984,
0.2543860972,
-0.6855133772,
-0.9962379932,
0.6402622461,
-0.2103253901,
0.3021963835,
0.0225917567,
0.6240323782,
0.0325027741,
1.1387993097,
0.4153847694,
0.0661161765,
0.3844984174,
0.1840862632,
0.2590779364,
-0.5195533633,
0.1008203328,
-0.9007563591,
-0.0098821837,
-0.3344729543,
-0.3504500687,
0.4186806679,
-0.0771179721,
-0.3852592707,
0.0508531369,
-0.1604642868,
0.5716663003,
0.3882355988,
-0.3751735091,
0.4157717824,
0.2114681154,
-0.3977539539,
-0.077151075,
-0.4946336746,
-0.7283748984,
0.7205118537,
0.3463763893,
1.1849901676,
0.2922397256,
0.3707799017,
-0.1203182712,
-0.1275952458,
-1.0357517004,
0.53388834,
0.1036855653,
-0.6633196473,
-0.3938649297,
-0.2306397259,
-0.9379453063,
0.1934479475,
-0.2450506985,
-1.1195685863,
0.3297249377,
0.3133769929,
-0.8442310691,
0.2137184441,
-0.4367249906,
0.5831257105,
-0.0836172402,
-0.3844173551,
0.1049922109,
-0.4678248167,
0.3280505836,
-0.2929016948,
0.2092675865,
0.0006661557,
-0.2000821382,
0.2175642252,
-0.4114895463,
1.0095020533,
-0.0379922092,
-0.4694970548,
0.4999608696,
0.5772818327,
1.041133523,
-0.0515505858,
-0.2614093423,
-0.0034125021,
-0.012025713,
-0.3960624039,
-0.8097705841,
0.615059793,
-0.571628511,
-0.8429247141,
-0.323749423,
-0.54621315,
-0.8169075251,
0.0715945736,
0.3391586244,
0.4145730436,
0.2958887219,
0.1036866233,
0.8900808692,
-0.3988479674,
0.4809866846,
0.4588950276,
-0.4158776402,
-0.002506559,
0.4032287002,
-0.0761679187,
0.4483348727,
0.0822474211,
0.4400095344,
-0.299292028,
-0.7402586937,
-0.2498483956,
0.0621443093,
-0.6025655866,
-0.0453543365,
-0.7514306307,
0.1129791737,
-0.5059151053,
-0.0678881854,
-0.3368535936,
-0.1316000372,
-0.0359796807,
-0.1206037849,
0.163955465,
0.6986879706,
-0.0448521152,
0.292442143,
-0.7599516511,
0.3041995764,
0.545111835,
0.2319288552,
0.0415361971,
-0.7901810408,
0.2006618083,
-0.1915679723,
-0.0615663379,
-0.8725572228,
-0.0224763695,
0.2078538984,
0.7333346009,
0.6527268291,
0.1113915294,
0.6291772127,
-0.531080246,
1.0133616924,
0.1222346127,
-1.0136482716,
0.6551951766,
-0.8175791502,
0.4101579189,
0.465722084,
0.2621154785,
-0.1578285545,
-0.7067952156,
-0.4313711822,
-0.5828995109,
0.3676244318,
0.0429294668,
0.4437088072,
-0.1064118817,
0.3376196623,
0.3226780593,
-0.008582877,
-0.5604895949,
-0.2541206181,
-0.020327596,
0.1146652624,
0.3703299761,
-0.3530870676,
-0.1037687883,
-0.086864166,
0.6589620113,
-0.3563019931,
0.1461521238,
0.0533730574,
0.154228881,
-0.2914874256,
0.2874030471,
0.5424827337,
0.450958401,
0.0280643348,
0.4281305373,
0.1363044828,
-0.3781333268,
0.4660947323,
-0.0869437456,
-0.304798007,
0.1377428323,
0.5902502537,
0.5432946682,
-0.2268428355,
-0.6511335373,
0.6201581359,
-0.2165609002,
-0.0256362725,
-0.0153353745,
0.16751495,
-0.2169397026,
0.2183296084,
0.2726596296,
0.1926724166,
0.13014853,
-0.5469650626,
0.2358014435,
0.8075945377,
-0.1040410474,
-0.5668932796,
0.6736149192,
-0.0974509716,
-0.0541236736,
0.3014428318,
-0.4403474033,
-0.4013681412,
0.3917751312,
0.6126126647,
0.6439733505,
-0.2909605801,
0.0739827752,
0.3428077996,
0.5199612975,
-0.1797648668,
0.3409205079,
0.2495433688,
-0.8852976561,
-0.9493607879,
-0.4151744246,
-0.4654278457,
0.3862673938,
-0.4062590003,
0.3738401532,
-0.6041710973,
-0.4044276178,
0.0106411632,
-0.2698471546,
-0.3421583176,
-0.1087362245,
0.1152007803,
0.9817695618,
-0.847984612,
0.583635509,
1.0349726677,
-0.06839028,
-1.1761292219,
0.3451345861,
0.3163314164,
-0.6722404361,
0.4890304506,
-0.0692528188,
-0.3939989209,
-0.1168891564,
-0.916369915,
-0.8665682673,
0.4735513031,
0.7631543875,
-0.5892134309,
0.3467706144,
-0.0753216967,
0.4374355972,
0.1254210621,
0.282813549,
0.5385066271,
0.6413909793,
0.1336933225,
-0.8532466292,
0.1624376923,
-0.0683610365,
-0.0981389061,
-0.0075224251,
-0.5600562096,
0.9471629262,
-0.493050456,
-0.1822790504,
0.1991211027,
0.6903808713,
0.4969684482,
0.0023822444,
0.6561241746,
0.2933598757,
1.1076563597,
0.0042559146,
1.1874334812,
-0.2797653973,
0.1610297561,
1.3255507946,
-0.553611517,
0.6720232368,
0.6263332963,
-0.3188682795,
0.4501606822,
0.4779658616,
0.1384216994,
0.2433468103,
0.2831942439,
-0.3415409327,
-0.5760139823,
-0.121720098,
-0.1782491058,
0.4586434662,
0.2927678525,
0.1720541418,
-0.3011977971,
0.0868064016,
0.1641019136,
-0.0211960878,
-0.1064867973,
0.5631970763,
0.1578904688,
-0.6342539787,
0.5925229192,
-0.2886420786,
0.7176295519,
-0.753721416,
0.1055121049,
-0.242850855,
0.0464743786,
-0.0867003128,
-0.5852478147,
0.3534265757,
0.0233563744,
-0.0355722569,
0.0086010071,
0.9630678296,
-0.0617676787,
-0.1801979095,
0.2968525589,
0.8664037585,
0.0270425193,
-0.3026733994,
-0.5872733593,
0.355722785,
-0.1610310674,
-0.5376967788,
0.3445697129,
0.6236758828,
-0.0292967577,
0.7561520338,
0.6260660887,
0.2365342677,
0.2355945706,
0.2335484028,
0.943279922,
-0.4579373896,
-0.2255543768,
-1.2285856009,
0.3556227088,
0.2396959066,
-0.1751267016,
1.0129781961,
0.0871856436,
0.4308129549,
-0.0725101754,
0.9416871071,
0.1391700655,
0.3330869973,
-0.4429757595,
0.2883090973,
-0.3153524101,
0.4952973425,
-0.4492517412,
-0.8134518266,
-0.5121208429,
0.6353757381,
-0.1548132151,
0.0913814157,
0.7426686883,
1.0333286524,
0.1349847317,
0.0364931822,
0.6472703218,
0.5769748688,
0.4039284289,
0.2034483254,
1.4729654789,
-0.0182520617,
0.5871370435,
0.086537607,
-0.2993372977,
0.064726755,
-1.1261928082,
-1.0718874931,
-0.1776045859,
-0.6831923127,
-0.5373429656,
-0.00089422,
0.9336523414,
0.5186102986,
-1.0897154808,
0.040853966,
0.0465464219,
0.1350903064,
-0.2842500508,
-0.2259162813,
0.1472208798,
-0.7274787426,
-0.7510820031,
0.6508790255,
0.3621312082,
0.1914459914,
-0.2365656346,
0.22790429,
-0.0726352632,
0.3809582293,
0.6931945086,
0.0772329792,
-0.5012726784,
-0.588478148,
0.2464515418,
-0.0385764353,
-0.1257022321,
0.7502018809,
-0.7073128223,
0.2317977101,
0.6039922833,
0.6793685555,
-0.2716172636,
0.1668886989,
0.3928493261,
-0.8843473196,
0.0929640457,
0.1971217543,
0.5410268903,
0.1288663894,
-0.2735628188,
0.2607001066,
0.2640023232,
-0.6306274533,
-0.8909061551,
0.4764983952,
-0.7264155746,
-0.4696613252,
1.5944998264,
-0.2568822801,
-0.220388934,
-0.4502943754,
-0.2262655348,
-0.1176108718,
-0.5259605646,
0.5910463929,
0.991470933,
-0.4900844693,
-0.0141979801,
-0.543727994,
0.426248312,
0.5966604352,
-0.6881577969,
0.1889774501,
0.6943621635,
0.3159787059,
0.2827554941,
0.5062121153,
-0.0655635297,
0.130418539,
0.2496998012,
-0.3983139098,
-0.1231577992,
-0.2556871176,
-0.5915477276,
0.1199093163,
0.6121401191,
0.0289287381
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00237v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00237v2
|
The Mystery of In-Context Learning: A Comprehensive Survey on Interpretation and Analysis
| 2023-11-01T02:40:42 | 2024-02-16T00:55:48 |
Yuxiang Zhou, Jiazheng Li, Yanzheng Xiang, Hanqi Yan, Lin Gui, Yulan He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Understanding in-context learning (ICL) capability that enables large
language models (LLMs) to excel in proficiency through demonstration examples
is of utmost importance. This importance stems not only from the better
utilization of this capability across various tasks, but also from the
proactive identification and mitigation of potential risks, including concerns
regarding truthfulness, bias, and toxicity, that may arise alongside the
capability. In this paper, we present a thorough survey on the interpretation
and analysis of in-context learning. First, we provide a concise introduction
to the background and definition of in-context learning. Then, we give an
overview of advancements from two perspectives: 1) a theoretical perspective,
emphasizing studies on mechanistic interpretability and delving into the
mathematical foundations behind ICL; and 2) an empirical perspective,
concerning studies that empirically analyze factors associated with ICL. We
conclude by highlighting the challenges encountered and suggesting potential
avenues for future research. We believe that our work establishes the basis for
further exploration into the interpretation of in-context learning.
Additionally, we have created a repository containing the resources referenced
in our survey.
|
[
-0.2792818844,
-0.7727407217,
0.6722069979,
-0.007779568,
-0.122457996,
0.2607673407,
-0.2413369119,
-0.7671003342,
-0.555247426,
0.2732085884,
-0.4983874261,
-0.422770828,
-0.602845788,
-0.0326346792,
-0.5274119377,
1.059345603,
-0.0942193195,
0.1653155684,
-0.509327054,
-0.1689496338,
-0.472179383,
-0.5708959699,
-0.5825683475,
-0.4063422978,
0.1237647086,
0.7603788972,
0.180280149,
0.3002783358,
0.4299429059,
0.1390959471,
-0.2700915635,
-0.2089100778,
-0.5463944077,
-0.0568330139,
-0.1065903902,
-0.4466656446,
-0.0581583679,
0.1250054538,
0.9732244015,
1.2022306919,
-0.0288181584,
0.2784350216,
0.6197435856,
0.5948091149,
-0.6036149263,
0.1277536154,
-0.6059940457,
-0.0038364462,
-0.3535359204,
-0.1242883429,
-0.521235466,
-0.1429955512,
0.5386537313,
-0.1829268932,
-0.0125188762,
0.0096178409,
0.4332464933,
0.2204923481,
-0.9707503319,
-0.7897619009,
-0.7738620043,
1.01550138,
-0.6679913998,
0.3582182825,
0.1232616827,
0.5802423358,
-0.0401763208,
-0.8669005036,
-0.4882807434,
-0.2802581489,
-0.2319013923,
0.0443567596,
0.0920602903,
-0.1210179105,
0.3849381804,
0.4064436853,
-0.295211643,
0.3017913103,
-0.3090345562,
-0.102500625,
0.6038843989,
0.2851224244,
0.5273760557,
0.0674205422,
-0.5968616009,
0.2692863047,
-1.155659914,
0.4146352708,
0.1723687798,
0.0531782359,
-0.3889847994,
0.2255690545,
-0.1766332686,
0.6106458306,
-0.3733940721,
-0.2388917208,
0.0144644063,
-0.2619765699,
-0.1506697983,
0.2109874636,
0.3549071252,
0.0603675656,
-0.1401544213,
-0.0791856423,
-0.0454904512,
-0.4822769165,
0.0515590012,
-0.7076123357,
0.1659727991,
0.1210501343,
-0.6193976402,
-0.2799001932,
0.0667386353,
-0.6554657817,
-0.2822596729,
-0.5442041159,
0.1590030044,
-0.3791802227,
-0.3798998296,
-0.0145812882,
0.1747267246,
0.4977890253,
0.2990412712,
-0.7334647179,
0.3726989925,
0.6405264139,
0.5880780816,
-0.2989425659,
-0.2944011092,
-0.097347334,
0.1682966352,
-0.1617500484,
0.5673081279,
-0.5263068676,
-0.4513076544,
0.2161461264,
-0.189034164,
-0.0397614539,
-0.5387142897,
0.4876009822,
-0.4803422093,
0.0374198817,
-0.4372477233,
-0.7665883899,
-0.393581748,
0.413502723,
-0.4063282311,
0.9334723949,
0.1566501111,
-0.6804178953,
0.5024975538,
-0.8101985455,
-0.2577114999,
0.2611063123,
-0.4253182709,
-0.0435376987,
0.2416197509,
-0.2489432096,
0.4363787174,
-0.4290031195,
0.4867434204,
-0.0666490495,
-0.4507509172,
0.7934917212,
-0.5216753483,
1.0785915852,
0.4135608375,
-0.6179177761,
-0.1510134339,
-0.6895747781,
-0.1111354753,
-0.1298451126,
-0.3001236916,
-0.3089163601,
0.1447030008,
-0.0010336364,
0.3608939052,
0.1948656142,
-0.3237598836,
-0.0729526579,
-0.3959937692,
0.3765888214,
0.648249507,
0.0455418713,
0.556884408,
0.0203648061,
0.5845930576,
-0.0190482773,
0.3814862967,
-0.3124435246,
-0.1757901758,
-0.3414393067,
-0.0660906881,
0.2279655635,
0.2386369556,
-0.708810389,
-0.0002282623,
-0.1917858273,
-0.294177413,
-0.1721702069,
0.0518224873,
0.5571255088,
0.8642793298,
0.2873293459,
-0.1376680434,
-0.3280153871,
-0.9342184663,
-0.3580593765,
-0.1948184669,
0.1641480774,
0.4844805598,
0.638301909,
-0.1332627833,
1.0154502392,
-0.2179705799,
-0.1109416857,
-0.4662605524,
-0.1286494583,
-0.0373572372,
0.4539964199,
0.5705145597,
-0.8873718977,
-0.8088521957,
0.0985372886,
-1.0173754692,
-0.0748956576,
-0.0436379276,
0.1381653696,
0.0137322284,
0.8866773248,
0.0090813767,
0.4576120079,
0.3698503673,
-0.2583164871,
0.623675704,
0.071655415,
-0.1945534945,
-0.7920254469,
0.1066325158,
0.0278695561,
0.0354047939,
-0.8368374109,
0.4612491131,
0.2177354097,
0.1003304273,
-0.6747757196,
0.6283351183,
-0.3709436655,
0.0328386351,
-0.2991981804,
0.1200045347,
-0.262753278,
0.0811713338,
-0.3195073009,
0.7801315188,
0.7493904233,
-0.6130455732,
-0.1287428886,
0.0334635265,
-0.6768651009,
0.5522652268,
-0.2780864239,
-0.0085532051,
-0.1008377075,
0.2921382785,
-0.914373219,
-0.2456883043,
0.3644806147,
-0.2293376178,
0.4757975638,
-0.0551392585,
-0.4931047559,
0.1764437556,
-0.0111420788,
0.672706902,
0.2973171175,
-0.7185043097,
0.3492150903,
0.4319608808,
0.063616313,
-0.7985081077,
-0.6495975256,
0.068222478,
-0.5695393085,
-0.1825653166,
0.1913743615,
-0.3530374467,
-0.90518713,
-0.1093822494,
-0.1220128611,
-0.0767185837,
0.5895298123,
0.1101108789,
0.1612784863,
-0.1283553392,
0.1760192066,
0.0756182969,
-0.1387511194,
0.4473401606,
-0.1941504776,
0.1125924662,
-0.2902228236,
-0.5129882693,
-0.3516714871,
0.2559653223,
0.3975146413,
-0.0266887434,
0.6446362734,
0.1955489516,
-0.2808699012,
-0.4082051218,
-0.2553420663,
-0.2046156675,
-0.4427419603,
0.2067028135,
-0.3130827248,
-0.9228271842,
0.471417129,
-0.4451085925,
-0.0976649672,
0.2420464456,
0.4308844507,
-0.3237861395,
0.8761406541,
0.873596251,
-0.0084762787,
0.5411630869,
-0.4060769677,
0.3456431925,
-1.0325545073,
-0.4906769395,
-0.5190178156,
-0.2079674751,
-0.3240837157,
0.0182276554,
0.6120141745,
-0.0679423138,
-0.1416524947,
-0.2745597363,
-0.1638382375,
0.5925952196,
0.1316210032,
0.043904122,
0.4023344219,
-0.2203324139,
-0.1462687403,
-0.1454405338,
-0.4897728264,
-0.6551331282,
1.2101875544,
0.4015159011,
0.5019437671,
0.4040367007,
0.384072721,
0.0307607371,
0.6065542698,
-0.8512243629,
0.4578765929,
0.2579008341,
-0.7811983228,
-0.3105164766,
-0.2328475267,
-0.7483994365,
0.3659891188,
-0.1259384453,
-0.8737037182,
0.0220369622,
0.0325572006,
-0.1109235138,
0.2926807106,
-0.580743134,
0.794025898,
-0.4760419726,
-0.3793845177,
-0.3316627443,
-0.8225024939,
0.7375289202,
-0.079164505,
0.460616082,
0.1319236457,
-0.0162053816,
0.3702697158,
0.0429712683,
1.0048904419,
-0.2357808501,
-0.3192668259,
0.4040054083,
-0.0478057377,
0.2359451503,
0.2127623409,
-0.1063750535,
0.1292276829,
0.1719767451,
-0.3749932349,
-0.6658341289,
0.6713065505,
-0.5925026536,
-0.4826817214,
-0.5369026065,
-0.6459169388,
-0.3815328777,
-0.0058809551,
0.1583016664,
0.7683006525,
-0.2254125625,
0.445545882,
1.0639306307,
-0.2964839637,
0.4592567384,
0.630043745,
-0.2281951904,
0.2273617387,
0.8139358759,
0.2287985981,
0.4280248582,
0.3936120868,
0.3000861108,
-0.3130576015,
-1.0752570629,
-0.1665316671,
0.1079540923,
-1.1669539213,
0.286185652,
-0.2816588283,
-0.1313651353,
-0.0155090578,
-0.0846905038,
0.0665349811,
-0.0273615215,
-0.4574169815,
-0.1026549861,
-0.2737406194,
1.0029637814,
0.3039017916,
0.4229463637,
-0.4718637764,
-0.3323753774,
0.2674539387,
0.308621496,
0.3604836464,
-0.4843548536,
-0.6530914307,
-0.0620442443,
-0.3980552256,
-0.667778492,
0.0848283917,
0.0343392491,
0.9402034879,
0.5710893273,
0.0183283444,
0.6010280252,
-0.1994466931,
0.9337245822,
-0.1593200117,
-1.0699863434,
0.3334280252,
-0.1637340337,
0.0174644869,
0.6141111851,
0.5696031451,
-0.5114625096,
-0.2653352022,
-0.7997626066,
-0.7842779756,
0.6475254893,
-0.0545691513,
0.1247410402,
0.3369819522,
0.6960843801,
0.4063479304,
0.159224093,
-0.6588813663,
-0.2695259452,
0.2536135912,
-0.2001880258,
-0.1536880285,
-0.4674484432,
-0.2274293303,
-0.3929083645,
0.5629911423,
-0.3977444172,
-0.1217143834,
-0.0726645663,
-0.6857190132,
0.090061456,
0.3170882761,
0.7243298292,
1.3327786922,
-0.0456026047,
0.244441554,
0.4485214651,
-0.4157999754,
-0.1379783601,
-0.1984275132,
-0.1286306977,
-0.4221974909,
0.670024991,
0.6393344998,
0.5739537477,
-1.0556616783,
0.6472569704,
-0.0559108928,
0.1317776591,
-0.5833207369,
-0.141047895,
-0.2515984774,
0.217053473,
0.677316606,
-0.0557535291,
0.4800898731,
-0.9060695171,
0.0904035568,
0.6007179022,
-0.7242835164,
-0.4759894311,
0.4746622145,
-0.1118113697,
0.076854229,
0.5057588816,
-0.0991596654,
-0.3934075832,
0.6821690202,
0.6930744648,
0.7369915247,
0.0090891887,
-0.031997975,
0.1232582107,
0.2999609113,
0.2582764626,
0.0519560128,
-0.3297725022,
-0.6898066401,
-0.3822802305,
-0.4255824983,
-0.720949471,
0.208332628,
-0.8399597406,
0.1409620345,
-0.1084687635,
0.4482741058,
-0.2728239298,
0.0303434543,
-0.5242145658,
0.0523901843,
0.1587128788,
0.9469763041,
-0.9182161689,
1.0559045076,
0.7083601356,
-0.2707293332,
-0.6619711518,
0.3869857788,
0.3213337362,
-0.593556881,
0.9652242064,
0.187604934,
-0.0716173425,
0.0184364971,
-0.862541616,
-0.8351434469,
1.2034891844,
0.3350766897,
-0.0498520955,
0.2105562538,
0.2137188464,
0.5410533547,
-0.5913871527,
0.311091125,
0.8250519633,
0.2756412029,
-0.1419735849,
-0.7202690244,
-0.0304923765,
-0.0131647233,
-0.0733171403,
-0.1729456931,
-0.5538805127,
0.7922609448,
0.1041627601,
-0.2901955545,
-0.1318179369,
0.5211270452,
0.1826636642,
0.7423767447,
0.3319404423,
0.1224166527,
0.5974675417,
-0.0285987705,
1.0970662832,
-0.2066711932,
0.368991226,
0.9276035428,
-0.2759515643,
0.646053195,
0.6546481252,
-0.2502016127,
0.6068570614,
0.7379786372,
0.5194451213,
0.5250397921,
0.1143645644,
-0.4718664587,
-0.0605588257,
-0.2129104435,
-0.1662839353,
0.5046213269,
0.801209271,
-0.2694610357,
-0.3815571964,
0.2970766723,
-0.0961880907,
0.2288313806,
-0.3091833889,
0.7384819984,
0.2111000866,
-0.4330999553,
0.0996744409,
-0.4205788076,
0.4542140067,
-0.5840395689,
-0.2690351307,
0.0113286162,
0.1100477278,
-0.1775649935,
-0.9089544415,
0.3651995957,
-0.2086322904,
0.1158893183,
-0.4797505736,
0.6191363931,
-0.2381361127,
-0.0964241102,
0.3349284828,
0.6349229813,
0.3075150251,
0.1072933003,
-0.5035755634,
0.1556546986,
-0.0290968958,
0.0171483196,
0.7247542143,
0.5278402567,
-0.1982999891,
0.8107330799,
0.3627788424,
-0.232585758,
0.026483763,
-0.1810091734,
0.7576117516,
-0.4815026224,
-0.299400121,
-1.050516367,
0.7679806352,
0.1224353686,
-0.3162573576,
0.9062228203,
0.5606946945,
1.2558578253,
0.0892485008,
1.0061869621,
-0.1315694451,
0.2977460027,
-0.694414854,
0.7256212234,
-0.6094821692,
0.5307958126,
-0.1573189348,
-0.5616133809,
-0.3604819775,
0.2514315248,
-0.4637650549,
-0.2773042619,
0.8767226934,
0.4735996723,
-0.0964301229,
0.1421413571,
0.2774765491,
0.1054448634,
0.4823415279,
0.2525685728,
1.2826715708,
-0.2347452343,
0.3661399186,
-0.3840584457,
-0.2249673754,
-0.3709805608,
-0.932231009,
-0.7651988268,
-0.8617098331,
-0.0934733078,
-0.1194182187,
-0.4099977911,
0.9465682507,
0.3762630522,
-0.7383742929,
-0.6177865267,
0.0839600936,
0.2842108011,
-0.4234338999,
-0.2237837464,
0.3809718192,
-0.6203014851,
-0.7818837762,
0.5876752734,
0.1422311366,
-0.0547641963,
-0.3917375207,
-0.1590151042,
-0.0528086759,
-0.2033914626,
0.9217541814,
0.3895922899,
-0.8311116099,
-0.3065039217,
-0.2065160424,
0.078926079,
-0.0595092215,
0.9989507198,
-0.6001325846,
0.6122356057,
0.197279498,
0.7071220279,
0.4096101224,
-0.3344739079,
0.3523090184,
-0.685723722,
0.082383424,
0.2035903037,
0.431188643,
0.2351420671,
-0.4520264268,
0.4679824412,
0.1153082922,
-0.5452893376,
-1.1674311161,
0.5419227481,
-0.7247037292,
-0.3927532136,
0.9770730734,
-0.0953272358,
0.103373684,
-0.4353584647,
-0.1073670462,
0.1761943847,
0.11755687,
0.8077477813,
0.7644792795,
-0.4289091825,
-0.1968616396,
-1.0907332897,
0.646658361,
0.1757316291,
-0.7893849015,
-0.0802313834,
0.271086812,
0.3702428043,
-0.0285516791,
0.2723917961,
-0.2233478576,
0.0595270656,
-0.4859807491,
-0.2661361098,
0.2518169582,
-0.4030499756,
-0.8833966851,
0.2110376358,
0.3672649562,
0.1979655772
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00233v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00233v2
|
Instructive Decoding: Instruction-Tuned Large Language Models are Self-Refiner from Noisy Instructions
| 2023-11-01T02:31:35 | 2024-02-17T09:00:29 |
Taehyeon Kim, Joonkee Kim, Gihun Lee, Se-Young Yun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While instruction-tuned language models have demonstrated impressive
zero-shot generalization, these models often struggle to generate accurate
responses when faced with instructions that fall outside their training set.
This paper presents Instructive Decoding (ID), a simple yet effective approach
that augments the efficacy of instruction-tuned models. Specifically, ID
adjusts the logits for next-token prediction in a contrastive manner, utilizing
predictions generated from a manipulated version of the original instruction,
referred to as a noisy instruction. This noisy instruction aims to elicit
responses that could diverge from the intended instruction yet remain
plausible. We conduct experiments across a spectrum of such noisy instructions,
ranging from those that insert semantic noise via random words to others like
'opposite' that elicit the deviated responses. Our approach achieves
considerable performance gains across various instruction-tuned models and
tasks without necessitating any additional parameter updates. Notably,
utilizing 'opposite' as the noisy instruction in ID, which exhibits the maximum
divergence from the original instruction, consistently produces the most
significant performance gains across multiple models and tasks.
|
[
0.076091066,
-0.6241464615,
0.1511345804,
-0.0046524461,
-0.449290216,
0.00719749,
-0.2655897439,
-0.4361178279,
-0.1204903796,
0.5626630783,
-0.8082482219,
-0.5217063427,
-0.4737276733,
-0.0649668425,
-0.7587350607,
1.0621184111,
0.6007759571,
0.3058624864,
-0.1911711395,
0.3770971596,
-0.3553041518,
-0.3812395334,
-0.5337895155,
-0.4461681545,
0.1702144146,
0.5435748696,
0.3604557216,
0.8243759274,
0.2725775838,
0.24914217,
-0.0097373212,
0.1942361593,
-0.7050710917,
-0.001630828,
-0.1730606854,
-0.6407916546,
0.0410068072,
-0.223332718,
0.4682956934,
0.5959227085,
-0.1404592246,
0.2469814867,
0.3160811663,
0.4069635868,
-0.6877630353,
0.5103365779,
-0.8952894807,
-0.080306448,
-0.0092743691,
-0.351587981,
-0.9142509699,
-0.2024327964,
-0.1613042653,
-0.3752663732,
0.2821205556,
-0.0894239917,
0.7283970118,
0.4698155522,
-0.1459595412,
-0.4180175066,
-0.8879132867,
0.8158724904,
-1.0565263033,
0.5249505043,
0.6626228094,
-0.2112207115,
-0.2492226064,
-0.7596883774,
-0.3095576763,
-0.0362241454,
-0.0654589459,
0.2315101326,
-0.2503198087,
0.1795606464,
0.0447743908,
0.4239367843,
-0.1544043571,
0.4365939498,
-0.2411144376,
-0.001909418,
0.3090952337,
0.3226529658,
0.1826666296,
0.2650767267,
-0.1644280702,
-0.1826874912,
-0.6185927987,
0.0067709959,
0.7178127766,
0.3196155727,
-0.0537238978,
0.1990392208,
-0.2652384043,
0.8030959964,
0.7296180725,
-0.1036272794,
0.1543205976,
-0.2076364458,
-0.1787141562,
0.1405152082,
0.3744141757,
0.255012244,
0.0187089909,
-0.581415236,
-0.326125145,
-0.0818474442,
0.2342202067,
-1.2596654892,
-0.8404754996,
-0.0631143004,
-0.6295893192,
-0.5151910782,
-0.0719130412,
-0.8113712072,
-0.1874258071,
-0.388225615,
0.4298918545,
-0.7771283388,
-0.2713877559,
0.39564991,
0.0005372638,
0.3852032125,
0.0242023375,
-1.3643701077,
0.3810139596,
0.7572903633,
0.4428236485,
0.2016591281,
-0.0806791559,
-0.838886857,
0.0883577764,
-0.4541588724,
0.6850422621,
-0.989713192,
-0.3628184199,
-0.0535545312,
-0.0330650248,
-0.0786092132,
-0.6146860719,
0.4131323397,
-0.7075935006,
0.1002427563,
-0.0115167564,
-0.8798875213,
-0.1938144863,
-0.069527708,
-0.5640724897,
0.629340589,
0.1385595948,
-0.6499582529,
0.2515886724,
-0.6167110801,
-0.5107658505,
0.0764750987,
-0.0200001579,
-0.5541818738,
0.4639642835,
0.2021714598,
0.2490425855,
0.0632764548,
-0.2878078222,
-0.1520241648,
-0.796074748,
0.1324125975,
-0.7246512771,
0.7491275668,
0.1835703403,
-0.3879725337,
0.0670429543,
-1.0839381218,
0.3772599101,
0.007574914,
-0.3799988627,
-0.4190993607,
0.0795027539,
-0.4040557444,
-0.259901911,
0.1481486112,
-0.6052050591,
0.0455641448,
-0.8722493052,
0.3486174345,
0.8218776584,
0.1582562774,
0.4163404405,
-0.1209170446,
0.4966831803,
0.1288870871,
-0.0027039698,
-0.5768680573,
-0.2773248553,
-0.7148000002,
-0.2991226315,
0.3900927901,
0.4259020388,
-0.7260729671,
0.2264117151,
-0.2447488308,
-0.2404090166,
-0.9847669005,
0.2449153811,
0.680803597,
0.5564081669,
0.4452681839,
-0.0087736817,
-0.4116074443,
-0.6419171095,
-0.3980421722,
-0.200457558,
-0.0031917056,
0.0365578607,
0.1819349825,
-0.1997738779,
0.228201896,
-0.346214354,
0.0430898666,
0.1220811978,
0.2861080468,
0.1931079775,
0.5741972327,
0.2281459868,
-0.4542261958,
-0.5706366301,
0.1072268039,
-0.4318192601,
-0.0741287917,
-0.2058452368,
-0.1129604653,
0.0526423864,
0.9844002724,
-0.2177772671,
0.4763767123,
0.4799378514,
-0.2998231947,
0.6568307281,
-0.2040447444,
-0.0395044126,
-0.738347888,
-0.2483994663,
-0.601580739,
0.0115462588,
-0.5182934403,
0.2780540884,
0.0602066629,
0.1535237879,
-0.0731535405,
0.084596321,
-0.691362977,
0.2918018699,
-0.347713083,
-0.4973788857,
-0.102981329,
0.5773126483,
-0.20055978,
0.7966825366,
0.6184679866,
-0.5544355512,
0.1902653277,
0.0620151497,
-0.6234599352,
0.3224152625,
-0.5921418071,
0.5105113983,
-0.4653625488,
-0.1829144508,
-0.9979984164,
-0.3033168614,
0.2288508862,
-0.2375693917,
0.7717724442,
-0.4450441301,
-0.5103042722,
-0.1513294578,
-0.1105104089,
0.5035993457,
0.7825497389,
-1.1156331301,
0.4057575166,
-0.0289149657,
0.2756723762,
-0.6456896663,
-0.7837447524,
-0.099765487,
-0.2059123516,
-0.1269688159,
0.3761113286,
-0.4552356303,
-0.2212750763,
0.337775737,
-0.1759455651,
-0.1444105059,
0.2157007903,
0.3645001948,
0.0589810424,
-0.3961895406,
0.2115005404,
0.2979579568,
-0.0019726972,
0.2999258637,
-0.5489732027,
0.5155421495,
-0.0088095125,
-0.4632585645,
-0.6590924859,
0.4092720151,
0.432218641,
-0.3559240103,
0.6466237903,
0.6609521508,
-0.1266936362,
-0.6312660575,
-0.2165157646,
-0.599839747,
-0.5399745703,
0.5530608892,
-0.5815466046,
-0.4553949833,
0.2894540429,
-0.1456543803,
0.2342804521,
-0.07695207,
0.4116789997,
-0.1304623485,
1.2363421917,
0.7843645215,
0.1667593122,
0.8794343472,
-0.268258363,
0.3535986841,
-0.5963581204,
-0.364238441,
-0.3726581335,
-0.271163404,
-0.3396146894,
-0.1797148436,
0.0796152875,
0.1655621231,
-0.1432256699,
0.1088918597,
-0.7664848566,
0.9745905995,
0.758897543,
0.3734076023,
0.2086661458,
0.2382563651,
0.0280347131,
-0.2079236656,
-0.8525102139,
-0.0836054683,
1.1275098324,
0.1098338813,
1.2305254936,
-0.064679496,
1.1064054966,
0.0969491228,
0.2857847512,
-0.8050374985,
0.2760410011,
-0.4541199505,
-0.2462268621,
-0.1470636129,
-0.3502179384,
-1.1193867922,
0.160600692,
-0.1532066166,
-0.7132247686,
0.1781621128,
0.2442180067,
-0.3909573853,
0.4660538435,
-0.9992830157,
0.6432446837,
0.0577464849,
-0.1982861757,
-0.3945970535,
-0.4599918723,
0.498595655,
0.0837558284,
-0.0136447847,
0.2781561017,
0.1961467564,
0.3640709817,
-0.2924145162,
1.1770573854,
0.0382183902,
-0.2089433521,
0.1921213567,
0.3298630416,
0.6226280332,
-0.147271499,
-0.2429411113,
-0.0494617224,
0.2195944637,
-0.3175278008,
-0.8671334386,
0.8346293569,
-0.757989943,
-0.6488277316,
0.1118472442,
-0.6584070325,
-0.0638164505,
0.3252205253,
0.5581009984,
0.8758867979,
-0.1380671561,
0.1727523804,
0.9696292877,
0.0461085923,
0.5073388219,
0.5991177559,
0.0728650764,
-0.1797955185,
1.1040337086,
-0.0730122998,
0.3486423492,
0.6161583066,
0.0754992738,
-0.2903276384,
-0.7391239405,
-0.3816135824,
0.0178506356,
-0.7519622445,
-0.4450566471,
-0.4394444227,
-0.283809185,
-0.1016618237,
0.1365041286,
-0.3818382025,
-0.1228912696,
-0.552102685,
-0.1394569278,
0.1658552289,
0.9173380136,
-0.1476139426,
0.3051740229,
-0.5953503251,
0.2113048285,
0.3096264899,
0.5999610424,
0.1418325901,
-0.8654190898,
-0.5717260242,
0.260756433,
0.0548154376,
-0.9196628928,
0.3292040825,
0.4992913306,
0.4387359619,
0.7231432796,
0.503441155,
0.9079054594,
-0.5989467502,
0.3653585017,
0.0006750628,
-0.9533138871,
0.3011030853,
0.1267527044,
0.6769838333,
0.39399001,
-0.0321196727,
0.0803043619,
-0.6928889751,
-0.5001722574,
-0.6329306364,
0.8123297691,
-0.1521488279,
0.5585087538,
-0.2488866448,
0.3859106004,
0.4157539904,
-0.0717520714,
-0.6260636449,
-0.1654061675,
-0.2821799219,
-0.4846787751,
0.270994395,
-0.5723805428,
-0.1145209074,
-0.1730479449,
0.6194454432,
-0.090137668,
0.2697013319,
-0.1756261438,
-0.010030509,
-0.2684998214,
0.2278325856,
0.338232398,
0.3724553585,
-0.2352368236,
0.365485698,
0.0036072382,
-0.322445035,
-0.0710904598,
-0.1487385631,
-0.3276367784,
0.0263483766,
0.5331234336,
0.7540934682,
0.5343012214,
-0.5712331533,
0.4622406363,
-0.2425788343,
0.0396875069,
-0.2713819444,
0.3494376838,
-0.0763043165,
0.3616138399,
-0.0915507525,
0.3057926595,
0.3527767658,
-0.5308215022,
0.2144623101,
0.4925097227,
-0.3543459773,
-0.5538976192,
0.7475818396,
0.1571129262,
-0.3681994677,
1.0058591366,
-0.4811200798,
-0.1966596693,
0.4690122008,
1.1203937531,
1.008276701,
-0.1646485627,
0.0794304013,
0.4603672326,
0.2725508213,
0.2118808627,
0.2723948061,
-0.3313290775,
-0.6317054629,
-0.5489208102,
-0.4310164154,
-0.0184455495,
0.3372148871,
-1.1135210991,
-0.0166374296,
-0.5422902107,
0.1247790158,
-0.0516865142,
-0.3395188451,
-0.560934782,
0.0363929309,
0.0784844831,
0.6696177125,
-0.4262542725,
0.9721264243,
0.3987175822,
-0.218705222,
-0.686961174,
0.4701443017,
-0.1533854157,
-0.8162459731,
0.5071457624,
0.1839296669,
-0.630281508,
0.2705434263,
-0.9680276513,
-0.7177271247,
0.6419666409,
0.6972438693,
-0.5718608499,
0.1130033061,
-0.2499378473,
0.5792998672,
-0.2505966723,
0.2040425688,
0.6227045655,
0.1348234713,
0.0303504039,
-0.4688007534,
-0.0043529007,
-0.3608149588,
-0.2352339923,
0.1669062525,
-0.5184292793,
0.790866375,
-0.5991610885,
-0.6705269814,
0.4484689534,
0.8307486176,
-0.4348167479,
0.1408080012,
0.4292327166,
0.4143515825,
0.7397255898,
0.1783142835,
1.0447654724,
-0.7813512683,
0.00708907,
1.4637947083,
0.3939795494,
0.8603436351,
0.3096907735,
0.1442054212,
0.8448730111,
0.3321332633,
-0.0816356465,
0.9221551418,
0.080062151,
-0.3452892303,
-0.3762587607,
-0.0496175848,
-0.2801875174,
0.6074258089,
0.4460261464,
-0.3407205939,
-0.1958900988,
-0.1586929113,
0.0578664728,
0.3940565288,
-0.3009965718,
0.9786244035,
-0.1935962737,
-0.5692100525,
0.8904945254,
0.1413691938,
0.5517715216,
-0.5990559459,
-0.452547133,
-0.196977973,
0.4931320846,
-0.2353510261,
-0.583261013,
0.2144851387,
-0.3376146853,
-0.4258393943,
-0.1181031391,
0.4704532921,
-0.9088980556,
-0.3885558844,
0.1673319638,
0.0914022177,
0.1468233317,
0.1018935218,
-0.4777933657,
0.0969210416,
0.3013511896,
0.2733142674,
0.2894474268,
0.5895986557,
0.2962270975,
0.7327679992,
0.5704464912,
-0.1609994471,
0.2275193185,
0.0465403907,
0.8758150339,
-0.4289225638,
-0.6280991435,
-0.8327907324,
0.3042117059,
0.0827343166,
-0.2920792699,
0.8169887066,
0.3433684409,
1.0427170992,
-0.384962678,
0.4683798254,
0.3854633868,
0.2399712056,
-0.6683170795,
0.4149850905,
-0.2740616798,
0.5480785966,
-0.0139146214,
-0.4072858989,
-0.1339496672,
0.4192608297,
-0.1138501391,
-0.0799827799,
0.4081909657,
1.0997434855,
-0.1480896473,
0.0642434657,
0.5615004301,
0.4179216921,
0.1234602109,
0.5195347071,
0.9656925797,
-0.362984091,
0.712112844,
-0.4980049431,
-0.164698869,
-0.1351578236,
-0.5055063963,
-1.2417546511,
-0.3613429368,
-0.3910303414,
-0.3809923232,
0.1950309724,
0.6401563287,
0.9606116414,
-0.9481298923,
-0.1548217535,
-0.1800927669,
0.2626762092,
-0.6541193724,
-0.2482878417,
0.3176147044,
-0.7610966563,
-1.139947772,
0.7067477703,
0.2870886028,
0.0425793789,
-0.0951782465,
-0.0492065772,
0.2134529948,
0.4331276119,
0.5496566296,
0.3353636563,
-0.6268858314,
-0.2196318507,
-0.0910955667,
0.0040668263,
-0.1350697726,
0.6733037233,
-0.778544426,
0.8462677598,
0.2614896894,
0.6755164862,
0.5944088101,
0.1673925817,
0.5133215189,
-0.7969791889,
0.2735204399,
0.247764945,
0.0083726496,
0.2371702045,
-0.6834405065,
0.2935077846,
0.0279137995,
-0.367791146,
-0.9856263399,
0.4423411489,
-0.4329511225,
-0.5312235951,
0.9990919828,
-0.2700126767,
-0.2366809696,
-0.0313787088,
-0.0550220683,
-0.018764697,
-0.3810092807,
1.0824955702,
0.5789939165,
-0.1423466355,
-0.3085350394,
-0.0491828248,
0.6027257442,
0.5015116334,
-0.4867357612,
0.1956197172,
0.4525977969,
0.3261891901,
-0.2531900704,
0.187870875,
-0.2367228121,
0.3190195262,
0.5865318775,
-0.1592853516,
-0.3493921757,
-0.3913802803,
-0.54147017,
0.0347394198,
0.1810891628,
-0.6825006604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00223v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00223v1
|
Is GPT Powerful Enough to Analyze the Emotions of Memes?
| 2023-11-01T01:57:48 | 2023-11-01T01:57:48 |
Jingjing Wang, Joshua Luo, Grace Yang, Allen Hong, Feng Luo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.MM
|
Large Language Models (LLMs), representing a significant achievement in
artificial intelligence (AI) research, have demonstrated their ability in a
multitude of tasks. This project aims to explore the capabilities of GPT-3.5, a
leading example of LLMs, in processing the sentiment analysis of Internet
memes. Memes, which include both verbal and visual aspects, act as a powerful
yet complex tool for expressing ideas and sentiments, demanding an
understanding of societal norms and cultural contexts. Notably, the detection
and moderation of hateful memes pose a significant challenge due to their
implicit offensive nature. This project investigates GPT's proficiency in such
subjective tasks, revealing its strengths and potential limitations. The tasks
include the classification of meme sentiment, determination of humor type, and
detection of implicit hate in memes. The performance evaluation, using datasets
from SemEval-2020 Task 8 and Facebook hateful memes, offers a comparative
understanding of GPT responses against human annotations. Despite GPT's
remarkable progress, our findings underscore the challenges faced by these
models in handling subjective tasks, which are rooted in their inherent
limitations including contextual understanding, interpretation of implicit
meanings, and data biases. This research contributes to the broader discourse
on the applicability of AI in handling complex, context-dependent tasks, and
offers valuable insights for future advancements.
|
[
-0.5471459627,
-0.9718025923,
0.5022106767,
0.2159289867,
-0.3296538293,
0.0928670242,
-0.2325436026,
-0.5702313185,
-0.1015541032,
-0.0540428273,
-0.6637331247,
-0.2726666331,
-1.1087609529,
0.4030397236,
-0.4375347197,
1.0889737606,
-0.1300051361,
-0.085274443,
0.039268285,
-0.1593309194,
-0.1380196363,
-0.8581215143,
-0.8678812981,
-0.0928511173,
0.6117427349,
0.1567959636,
0.5651916265,
-0.0370088443,
0.7597493529,
0.4124043882,
0.0712088645,
-0.3373011947,
-0.402559489,
0.1468744427,
-0.3058214188,
-0.1829088926,
-0.5527223349,
0.4933620691,
0.2670575082,
0.3024344444,
0.1962137967,
0.0717424899,
0.0603691749,
0.6364650726,
-0.2064038217,
0.2282708138,
-0.6749229431,
0.1305181831,
-0.0969571993,
-0.0009073546,
-0.1034308746,
-0.1502874047,
0.3346193135,
-0.1720839739,
0.0057147709,
-0.2285813838,
0.5716229677,
0.4666713774,
-0.4753284156,
-0.5434809327,
-0.6850702763,
0.8872096539,
-0.8594478965,
0.0429417491,
-0.0181310903,
0.1908673495,
0.1636664718,
-0.4611498117,
-0.8797255754,
-0.2745632529,
0.1110332012,
0.1669797748,
-0.4556623101,
0.0643562004,
0.3725062907,
0.3952035308,
-0.6552111506,
0.0420281999,
-0.2914967835,
-0.1371524781,
0.5537914038,
0.2095282376,
0.649066627,
-0.4243012965,
-0.2103783935,
0.0477867611,
-0.3141838014,
-0.0381570272,
0.3834099174,
0.0025042912,
-0.0500595309,
0.7212705016,
-0.2886000276,
0.362505585,
-0.2443950623,
-0.048447106,
0.0875422284,
0.0348107256,
-0.3568343222,
-0.3685982227,
0.8828046322,
0.3955464363,
0.5707513094,
-0.0217843615,
-0.1456843317,
0.3391991556,
0.3475372791,
-0.8526069522,
-0.061260283,
0.2462759167,
-0.3840044737,
-0.1800612658,
-0.1337388158,
-0.6912084818,
-0.37505427,
-0.3429199159,
0.3286833763,
-0.315286845,
-0.4781415164,
-0.0598409735,
-0.075314723,
0.247562021,
0.3922229707,
-0.6966828704,
0.126826942,
0.8507393003,
0.9652197361,
0.0890128985,
-0.185287118,
-0.02679497,
-0.1536651403,
0.0376336612,
0.6053641438,
-0.7640019655,
-0.2014377266,
-0.2600989938,
0.0249685068,
-0.1455125958,
-0.254134506,
0.6776943803,
-0.4699408114,
0.043364346,
-0.2842837572,
-0.5586281419,
-0.4810816944,
0.4556302428,
-0.5805438161,
0.4146116972,
0.1790967435,
-0.7547292113,
0.0507712513,
-0.8962426186,
-0.4927922487,
-0.0196170248,
-0.2132566571,
-0.19130826,
0.3970846534,
-0.0420674682,
0.9008647799,
-0.3478853703,
0.1852737516,
-0.4296751618,
-0.3544023633,
0.1277438253,
-0.4564638734,
0.4295602143,
0.3093667626,
-0.8010720611,
-0.0523809604,
-0.2270520777,
-0.289424181,
0.3303246498,
-0.2227698117,
-0.2977783084,
0.1755191088,
-0.1095099822,
0.444045186,
0.2511945963,
-0.6123045087,
0.4078243673,
-0.0221263543,
0.666765511,
1.1279091835,
-0.3453285098,
0.2848822773,
0.1436047703,
0.5534594059,
-0.1227375194,
0.2632836699,
0.413413465,
-0.6225863099,
-0.4908518493,
-0.1749886125,
-0.2116495222,
0.6987640858,
-0.8377607465,
0.1162983403,
-0.2724687159,
-0.4337581396,
-0.2113656998,
0.0437254161,
0.1666563451,
0.4213679433,
0.2881926298,
-0.1363414526,
-0.3004390001,
-0.9587512612,
-0.3065356016,
-0.2353842407,
0.0063044853,
0.4037772715,
0.5715481639,
-0.3877333105,
0.5222102404,
-0.1942519099,
-0.1397513896,
-0.1836888641,
0.6485948563,
0.2064977139,
0.3455871642,
0.5389190316,
-0.8866227269,
-0.4624301493,
-0.0400520824,
-1.1029795408,
-0.3199619949,
0.0622039065,
0.2639404237,
0.1738159806,
0.2366866022,
-0.6111741066,
0.2252804041,
0.7238707542,
-0.6568939686,
0.4967710972,
0.245399788,
0.6520178318,
-0.6342599988,
-0.0398745574,
0.2484018803,
-0.1025853157,
-0.6871560216,
-0.2671175301,
-0.1311216056,
0.0076330635,
-0.5432332158,
0.4800331891,
-0.2706759572,
0.1171878651,
-0.4559895992,
-0.1119529307,
-0.440974474,
0.413080126,
-0.0929230824,
0.840631783,
0.3876708746,
-0.3798317909,
0.533502996,
-0.0751537308,
-0.0599554032,
0.7618862987,
-0.5047249198,
0.408447355,
-0.124355197,
-0.0002881499,
-0.8762165308,
-0.2756871879,
0.5597736835,
-0.4938779175,
0.201589644,
-0.023912238,
-0.5808773041,
-0.4872066081,
-0.2734785676,
0.5495561361,
0.517475903,
-0.2668409944,
0.7633829713,
0.3985593915,
-0.5051600933,
-0.5503050685,
-0.4039945006,
0.3076992035,
-0.5275387168,
-0.5861574411,
-0.2574185431,
-0.0965016037,
-0.4828939736,
0.0419174433,
-0.0440974385,
0.0398387164,
0.1658447981,
0.3537837565,
-0.0437806137,
-0.0384102203,
-0.0640222207,
-0.0561707169,
-0.1794425994,
0.2198439687,
-0.130904898,
0.4225259125,
-0.5392813087,
-0.3739787638,
-0.3377337158,
0.4819907844,
0.717027843,
0.0079648932,
0.5058828592,
0.8023046255,
-0.3453525305,
0.0121960817,
-0.7152859569,
0.0361200348,
-0.458212465,
0.535199821,
-0.4080023766,
-1.4508364201,
0.3996081352,
-0.0297404565,
-0.1244699359,
0.5943411589,
0.5388169289,
-0.0994879454,
1.2830348015,
0.3393414021,
-0.6873498559,
0.3229611516,
-0.1183632314,
0.3987209797,
-0.8194093108,
0.0950807631,
-0.3818330169,
-0.5265296102,
-0.5286533833,
-0.3129948676,
0.5346356034,
-0.2886546552,
-0.2936742306,
-0.2284326404,
-0.6318923235,
0.4352054894,
0.4139637947,
0.0723785907,
0.0472482294,
0.0085446183,
0.4550350606,
-0.129855901,
-0.0612531602,
-0.7716745138,
1.0084558725,
0.4511971474,
0.6814095974,
0.2285499871,
0.1001377106,
0.6107410192,
0.5946037173,
-0.7100117207,
0.7400990129,
-0.5423134565,
-0.5376705527,
-0.3031356335,
-0.4056546092,
-0.594427526,
-0.0709205046,
0.0738619715,
-0.8743973374,
-0.4027063549,
0.0049507977,
0.0686063692,
0.5811237097,
-0.6353464127,
0.9211611748,
-0.3242033422,
-0.4024667442,
-0.4292392731,
-0.557096839,
0.2826168537,
0.0262023807,
0.1710311323,
-0.4924158752,
-0.054607559,
0.7403498292,
-0.0111734327,
0.8709737659,
-0.4457737803,
-0.1327328831,
0.4468901753,
0.3123575449,
0.3468921483,
-0.1733982563,
-0.1873633265,
0.3225723207,
-0.3085385263,
-0.564617157,
-0.506485939,
0.87171489,
-0.8206366897,
-0.7326924801,
-0.4171355367,
-0.5562095642,
-0.1145224124,
-0.0189037006,
-0.091753982,
0.1470043212,
-0.1417754143,
-0.020518614,
0.4109540284,
-0.1846381873,
0.3963665366,
0.1742629558,
0.1928037554,
-0.0402825661,
1.2503801584,
0.2030248046,
-0.0147778904,
0.1079135388,
0.0939766392,
-0.2500036955,
-0.7188438177,
-0.3764773607,
0.0905174762,
-0.8386717439,
0.0272071529,
-0.700302422,
0.0288654026,
-0.2276236862,
-0.2011456043,
-0.1471904814,
-0.3120061755,
-0.1141549721,
-0.1131970808,
0.2535144389,
1.2179374695,
-0.0076586357,
0.2786951959,
-0.5256141424,
0.1728253216,
0.5721859932,
0.4182763994,
-0.0579325631,
-0.2795116901,
0.0553448349,
-0.1989850104,
-0.2807478607,
-1.0467705727,
0.2892077565,
-0.0542536899,
0.2854451537,
0.3975653648,
-0.2321782261,
0.3588548899,
-0.3155379593,
1.015494585,
-0.2336819768,
-0.9954941869,
0.3743395209,
-0.7578866482,
0.0216594264,
0.3334003389,
0.6574286819,
-0.4279289544,
-0.6111454964,
-0.630446434,
-0.6388290524,
0.4963922203,
0.3180318773,
0.4408749938,
-0.1944838613,
0.7025268078,
0.0371078141,
0.3247413635,
-0.9648479223,
-0.0488721356,
-0.2169808,
-0.3746140003,
-0.1994594038,
-0.4409841299,
0.2227668464,
-0.3368211687,
0.6731181145,
-0.1278726757,
0.4012182951,
0.2388795018,
-0.1527410001,
0.0174793471,
0.3201285005,
0.435801506,
0.3436674774,
-0.145032227,
0.4095178246,
0.1545546651,
-0.4471330643,
0.2455628514,
-0.0148649216,
0.0899741799,
-0.3755550385,
0.2247517854,
0.4275087714,
-0.2530938983,
-0.7007600069,
0.6554827094,
-0.1535703242,
-0.1691056639,
-0.1193682626,
-0.0929366425,
-0.0010899119,
0.5802973509,
0.3246174455,
-0.1349240839,
0.5382108688,
-0.4932480454,
0.1298949569,
0.8067922592,
-0.4025653303,
-0.7152479887,
0.5834909081,
0.1621837765,
0.0755008236,
0.6571394801,
-0.4200609028,
-0.8883826733,
0.7231305242,
0.3100706935,
0.9752935171,
-0.2692790329,
0.181583643,
0.2681026757,
0.4605576992,
0.1912555844,
0.234197557,
0.1731827855,
-0.59898597,
-0.402045697,
-0.6530736685,
-0.4172501266,
0.331727773,
-0.0707390159,
-0.0729022771,
-0.56390661,
-0.1536167711,
-0.13321729,
-0.1074464917,
-0.708758831,
0.6050758362,
0.5362837911,
0.3878675103,
-0.9796949029,
0.3532724679,
0.7214453816,
-0.2952312827,
-0.7085494995,
-0.0570895784,
0.39266482,
-0.731998384,
0.5283940434,
0.4231359065,
-0.1549584717,
0.0928953588,
-0.895830512,
-0.3185510039,
0.7959274054,
0.1396229565,
-0.231599763,
0.1592254937,
0.2374286801,
0.8091514707,
-0.3175111711,
0.4829879105,
0.5776517391,
0.4958315492,
-0.0971783847,
-0.815027535,
0.2622936666,
-0.5061890483,
-0.3757794499,
0.0948271453,
-0.7491955161,
1.1848914623,
0.1563449055,
-0.112029016,
-0.2461594045,
0.5295517445,
-0.2980028391,
0.224675864,
0.6641326547,
0.4427348971,
0.396022886,
-0.1040582806,
1.1404819489,
-0.0239126384,
0.4154118001,
0.6895866394,
-0.0925566107,
0.6286620498,
0.3938301206,
-0.236521244,
0.3260047138,
0.6901186109,
0.0426393747,
0.1076624244,
0.2603206635,
-0.6128421426,
-0.1668205708,
-0.1605366617,
-0.1981936246,
0.3310546577,
0.4379175901,
-0.1309293061,
-0.0908480138,
0.1501585543,
0.2804919779,
-0.1660945714,
-0.4404580891,
0.8359960914,
0.0456404127,
-0.3784765601,
0.282440275,
-0.1133414581,
0.8573195338,
-0.3748232722,
0.0271386839,
0.0105766514,
0.0716820136,
-0.2029303759,
-0.9663540721,
0.4963264763,
0.3529274166,
-0.0266050026,
-0.0524316654,
0.8514467478,
0.0849123448,
-0.4017834067,
0.5577620864,
0.7196008563,
0.3190116286,
-0.5936920047,
-0.8833578825,
0.1466138363,
0.0674654692,
-0.6644070745,
0.2794464827,
0.5981109142,
-0.0927213281,
0.6314655542,
0.3465236127,
-0.0466090031,
-0.0073807612,
0.1955526173,
0.8523939252,
-0.8022822738,
-0.0166201778,
-1.3313683271,
0.4935234189,
0.0324613303,
0.0773589835,
0.5654827356,
0.2809961438,
0.6809675694,
-0.1516314596,
1.2115750313,
-0.4251324832,
0.4776315987,
-0.2281023115,
0.4923626781,
-0.7612186074,
0.0332453251,
-0.5750429034,
-0.7944267392,
-0.3024124503,
0.6131332517,
-0.5826430321,
0.0354780778,
0.4398465455,
0.4193277657,
-0.0329463482,
0.2733770609,
0.2382886261,
0.5005244017,
0.6274126768,
0.6787875295,
1.2080341578,
-0.0381886959,
0.3513607681,
-0.3255096376,
-0.5569394231,
0.0698163658,
-0.8851893544,
-1.0271095037,
-0.5316367149,
-0.0660625547,
-0.0943553969,
-0.0150926095,
0.8578343987,
0.2923959792,
-0.6624274254,
-0.0549163818,
0.0976241082,
0.0475580022,
0.1692970395,
-0.2199886143,
0.2097377032,
-0.2947106063,
-0.9992164969,
0.0712348148,
0.4956450164,
0.155191198,
-0.1258663535,
0.0233565271,
-0.1480284482,
0.0642494559,
0.8783810139,
0.1310089231,
-0.6856356263,
-0.6988584399,
-0.0043476438,
-0.0249871593,
-0.0806502625,
0.7307560444,
-0.272287339,
0.3218194842,
0.3644521832,
0.5793659687,
0.0433013812,
0.1959737986,
0.3814122975,
-0.4232262671,
0.1612379402,
0.3031434715,
0.3529031873,
0.365342021,
-0.4718547463,
0.7287527323,
0.3087261915,
-0.7328574657,
-0.435600698,
0.022419842,
-0.981769979,
-0.2803866565,
1.1318668127,
-0.0888920352,
-0.0951036215,
-0.0778858513,
-0.4664762914,
0.2428196967,
-0.3953762352,
0.9759105444,
1.0339039564,
-0.4269371331,
-0.1226147488,
-0.8925679326,
0.4713777304,
0.6320716739,
-0.814373076,
-0.0968802124,
0.544801414,
0.2106996924,
0.1412605196,
0.831667304,
0.0496902056,
0.0372455455,
-0.3967885077,
0.0316331238,
0.205446884,
-0.2002288401,
-0.2762786746,
0.3535075784,
0.0731238574,
0.172695294
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00208v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00208v2
|
What Formal Languages Can Transformers Express? A Survey
| 2023-11-01T00:38:26 | 2024-05-06T19:48:28 |
Lena Strobl, William Merrill, Gail Weiss, David Chiang, Dana Angluin
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.FL, cs.LO
|
As transformers have gained prominence in natural language processing, some
researchers have investigated theoretically what problems they can and cannot
solve, by treating problems as formal languages. Exploring such questions can
help clarify the power of transformers relative to other models of computation,
their fundamental capabilities and limits, and the impact of architectural
choices. Work in this subarea has made considerable progress in recent years.
Here, we undertake a comprehensive survey of this work, documenting the diverse
assumptions that underlie different results and providing a unified framework
for harmonizing seemingly contradictory findings.
|
[
-0.5771134496,
-0.8282078505,
0.5741214156,
0.5533194542,
0.2506784201,
0.4568748772,
-0.4144195616,
-1.0119954348,
-0.0353410542,
0.4870393574,
-0.4324391782,
0.0373631939,
-0.7629739642,
0.5660590529,
-0.8568353057,
0.6010480523,
-0.3097380698,
-0.0744212195,
-0.1353271753,
-0.0613486208,
-0.4204477668,
-0.4628868699,
-0.4337645173,
-0.0759304613,
0.245389998,
0.4756191075,
0.9555884004,
0.0852402747,
0.8861391544,
0.4408143461,
0.0915146694,
-0.0096762367,
-0.1039437577,
0.3291119039,
-0.0394917987,
-0.5921570659,
-0.030234931,
-0.0826667473,
0.7343114018,
0.8355724812,
0.1687017381,
0.3821036816,
-0.1861499995,
0.5939347744,
-0.4494931698,
0.4495478868,
-0.515375793,
0.4381722808,
-0.3553138375,
-0.1376177967,
-0.6372728348,
-0.4475648701,
-0.0704934672,
-0.2694306076,
0.306613028,
0.0596156418,
0.9923271537,
0.232305482,
-0.4526331127,
-0.2969887257,
-1.6819727421,
0.8043228984,
-0.4645882845,
0.4543072879,
0.3134610057,
0.7774712443,
0.1854798645,
-1.1602818966,
-0.4211847484,
-0.2883951962,
-0.4319947362,
0.0987889916,
-0.4713591933,
0.0640171617,
0.7179367542,
0.7923178077,
-0.3987650573,
-0.0272133686,
-0.4371994734,
-0.1117132306,
0.6408792138,
0.2139714062,
0.4924563766,
-0.1887591481,
-0.0588672347,
-0.1209663749,
-0.3576838076,
0.2182320952,
0.337059617,
0.0187854841,
-0.0144226952,
0.6414548755,
-0.0867020339,
0.5576248765,
-0.0390928797,
0.5151834488,
-0.3039684594,
-0.3159103692,
-0.2437632978,
-0.2946492136,
0.8142870665,
0.0108282818,
0.3555024862,
-0.4971743524,
-0.2738046944,
0.4547228515,
0.4382765591,
-0.3160485625,
-0.051948417,
0.1216696501,
-0.0706673786,
-0.0616857149,
0.2838886678,
-0.8571584821,
-0.2136652172,
-0.2679073215,
-0.0387452953,
0.0145651065,
-0.3329705298,
0.3467562795,
-0.2980837524,
0.586630106,
-0.042004738,
-1.0881739855,
0.9772843122,
0.7336562872,
0.3041988611,
0.3425880075,
0.1861974746,
0.0786159784,
-0.2737069428,
-0.3602467775,
0.9994188547,
-0.6670317054,
-0.5303011537,
0.3406476676,
-0.0121883051,
-0.0678029284,
-0.4377049804,
0.9743875861,
-0.5676751733,
0.5321004987,
-0.4312461913,
-0.3224952221,
0.138531372,
0.0210120436,
-0.8346994519,
1.1738893986,
0.3541859686,
-0.8376860619,
-0.0903000236,
-0.6418505311,
-0.6493673325,
0.0601266921,
-0.3950156868,
-0.1199055091,
0.4522004128,
-0.1456707716,
0.259298116,
-0.8247224092,
0.3935893178,
0.2803180516,
-0.0753909871,
0.3423525989,
-0.4254348874,
0.4582135379,
0.256157279,
-0.5684302449,
0.1540375799,
-0.7020629644,
-0.1653078794,
0.2896690667,
0.1354238689,
-0.0117411697,
0.243831411,
0.1783130616,
0.3190802634,
0.4128265679,
-0.683803618,
0.5624072552,
-0.405441612,
0.5557616353,
0.3869261742,
-0.3330822289,
0.7233099341,
-0.2128230631,
0.8853388429,
-0.4403949678,
0.1471632272,
0.0468959138,
-0.7337863445,
-0.913531065,
0.0961304381,
0.2253791988,
0.6324206591,
-0.5575171709,
0.1316152066,
-0.25282377,
-0.4809612334,
-0.6040524244,
-0.3893783092,
0.0759648383,
0.5658066273,
0.4757319987,
0.0462237038,
-0.8994188905,
-1.3750685453,
-0.445527792,
-0.2008588016,
-0.1255644709,
0.3587871194,
0.1146226972,
-0.1161216125,
1.2116965055,
-0.6020123959,
0.0500309207,
-0.2871419489,
0.526511848,
0.1232939586,
0.2774731517,
0.4485778213,
-0.990778923,
-0.5518144369,
0.0555305406,
-0.7209470868,
-0.2029832006,
-0.2882408798,
0.3120314777,
-0.1074385643,
0.6071072817,
-0.8049863577,
0.1735133827,
0.4375191629,
-0.2277232707,
0.6886110306,
0.0160311498,
0.3136017323,
-0.7022314668,
0.1040677205,
-0.1793964654,
-0.3101735711,
-0.8106967211,
0.2137047648,
-0.0904899538,
-0.0922580138,
-0.4661697745,
0.465054661,
-0.2237304449,
-0.1275896132,
-0.0964727774,
0.0192774255,
-0.2236775309,
0.1786232591,
0.0223040674,
0.3486478031,
0.7524596453,
-0.5659849644,
0.5087921023,
0.2277399451,
-0.0282768179,
0.3332428634,
-0.7778343558,
0.1586824059,
-0.2742184401,
0.2549569309,
-1.208132267,
-0.5331377983,
0.3363800645,
-0.4265498817,
0.270596832,
-0.069482483,
-0.6715060472,
-0.5072497725,
-0.0699170902,
0.4431632161,
0.577270925,
-0.0601619408,
0.7798711658,
0.1480031461,
0.0612480938,
-0.524897337,
-0.8239150047,
0.1694056094,
-0.0603752546,
-0.9065885544,
0.3584374785,
0.0661704466,
-0.7648584247,
0.0759290159,
-0.1302957833,
-0.5213142633,
0.1806315333,
-0.0323919691,
0.0782652199,
-0.2390442491,
-0.0493423007,
-0.1449969858,
-0.3039681613,
0.3518005908,
0.025270747,
0.5920068026,
-0.45414114,
-0.4186691046,
-0.1572237462,
0.6070242524,
0.6962025166,
-0.2900571227,
0.4399001002,
0.6974512935,
-0.487937808,
0.0105808033,
-0.3940854371,
-0.0864932016,
-0.5510146618,
-0.0468359143,
-0.2978984118,
-1.0944406986,
0.6537889242,
-0.0214602388,
0.5594699383,
0.8503779769,
0.3387040496,
-0.0651672781,
1.033087492,
0.4763754606,
0.1301139593,
0.0406094752,
-0.2351647466,
0.5549072623,
-0.5078983903,
-0.3077733815,
-1.1840077639,
-0.3252249956,
-1.0590965748,
-0.0643765107,
-0.070745647,
-0.1231215149,
0.230186224,
0.921970129,
-0.5998209715,
0.3821488619,
0.1196886674,
-0.7540430427,
0.3723613918,
-0.3346064389,
0.0942128524,
-0.0592545494,
-0.4605679512,
-0.7342001796,
0.3933639824,
0.3619454503,
0.7164543271,
0.1698690206,
0.3573654294,
0.2685952187,
0.2455981523,
-0.9427764416,
0.5935240984,
0.0392832905,
-0.9440292716,
-0.2730006874,
-0.3678356707,
-1.2090791464,
-0.0581886284,
-0.1520087868,
-0.6579309702,
0.1283619255,
-0.0703785717,
0.134174794,
0.4736626148,
-0.6721996665,
0.7958462238,
-0.2232583612,
0.0554945469,
-0.1698161513,
-0.675579071,
0.5986868739,
0.0990752205,
0.4785430133,
-0.0200586803,
0.2096771896,
0.2806407809,
0.1351124048,
0.6614643931,
0.216880545,
-0.4407916367,
0.4375099838,
0.22162202,
0.2270988524,
-0.0558350757,
0.0385067873,
0.2795981169,
0.1708275378,
-0.356828928,
-0.753798008,
0.2523653805,
-0.391562134,
-0.5085805058,
-0.5147300959,
-0.3856553435,
-0.3829513788,
0.1444206834,
0.4989935756,
0.4922226071,
-0.3040066659,
0.0220509227,
0.269166559,
0.0214191433,
0.7568992972,
0.4116126299,
-0.5393484831,
0.1602954865,
0.7696705461,
0.130493924,
0.1700187325,
0.7011995316,
0.1555636674,
-0.4419214427,
-0.1877485365,
-0.3435628414,
-0.0272092298,
-0.6596476436,
0.1645545661,
-0.4576884806,
-0.3577425182,
-0.3936966062,
-0.3541050553,
-0.4740588665,
-0.8025454879,
-0.0119946608,
0.0728986412,
-0.036312595,
1.144143939,
0.1196948141,
0.0339213423,
-0.9346740842,
0.6857681274,
0.4249534011,
0.6326283813,
-0.2739542723,
-0.1751052439,
-0.0384509526,
-0.1610419154,
-0.2175256759,
-0.9424909353,
0.1093317419,
-0.0586838163,
0.5382928848,
0.3038356006,
0.1870488375,
0.4698191881,
-0.6998336315,
1.0273826122,
0.0360651501,
-0.9514824748,
0.2515532672,
-0.2718381584,
0.084168829,
0.4090977311,
0.6747170091,
-0.8138918877,
-0.521995008,
-1.0080697536,
-0.7086901665,
0.2974044681,
0.6116805077,
0.3096883297,
-0.0700117871,
0.1668560058,
-0.2415568084,
0.0913461447,
-0.5563184023,
-0.6571213007,
-0.1852363646,
-0.2591010332,
0.061115846,
0.0858284608,
-0.1179168969,
-0.2917212546,
0.0247317795,
0.1430501491,
0.5829635859,
0.0914065763,
-0.0680385903,
-0.1471373439,
0.8120330572,
0.768543005,
0.6971694231,
0.129658252,
0.4609993994,
0.0501226559,
-0.2098782808,
0.1998258978,
0.1432461292,
-0.1396860927,
0.2132640481,
0.3755839169,
0.4376709461,
0.4965559244,
-0.6071782708,
0.147184521,
-0.5399255753,
-0.2134183645,
-0.3406154811,
-0.0557340644,
-0.0614675358,
-0.1207745224,
0.4070466459,
0.4121783972,
0.2146968544,
-0.6012455821,
0.1083915457,
0.5096803904,
-0.7100657821,
-0.8143173456,
0.5530395508,
0.1115719005,
-0.7131605744,
0.5096551776,
-0.0943136066,
-0.5482975841,
0.4803950489,
0.568205595,
1.1783922911,
-0.0064320141,
0.2760127485,
0.1692396849,
0.5526743531,
-0.0117165474,
0.2803986371,
-0.2160459906,
-0.7148452997,
-0.7216787934,
-0.65181458,
-0.7078741789,
-0.1592296362,
-0.6811358333,
0.112638101,
-0.5154663324,
-0.29797405,
0.1158811599,
-0.2508485317,
-0.59488976,
-0.1068478748,
0.2118466645,
0.9077622294,
-0.9137663841,
0.2086007893,
0.9682696462,
-0.5570642352,
-0.7679161429,
-0.1447343081,
-0.3195564151,
-0.3369986415,
0.6198403835,
-0.0351227745,
-0.3539631069,
0.0121157533,
-0.6428542137,
-0.6795552969,
0.3711563051,
0.3779755831,
-0.2464768887,
-0.1280908138,
0.9127261043,
0.8981924653,
0.0508831665,
0.4378479123,
0.7372813821,
0.9841914177,
-0.1590041518,
-1.1180877686,
-0.1249570176,
-0.2024171799,
-0.3621534109,
0.3918832242,
-0.4741185904,
0.6243719459,
0.3560803235,
-0.7495979667,
0.0181365423,
0.7403875589,
-0.4562186599,
0.1407393664,
0.1992872357,
0.2826604247,
0.5765076876,
-0.5385679007,
1.3424551487,
-0.550198853,
0.2772831619,
0.639249146,
-0.0771678314,
0.3372605443,
0.2822353244,
-0.5129763484,
0.790884614,
0.2428223342,
0.0766322315,
-0.2975120246,
0.1992804855,
-0.4055846334,
-0.309494704,
-0.2745058537,
-0.2424707562,
0.6022782326,
0.3146758676,
0.0130935945,
-0.3639676273,
-0.2807464004,
-0.2799895406,
0.2431076467,
-0.0207861718,
0.4218455851,
0.1201591119,
-0.6654663086,
0.2106502652,
0.2154660672,
0.5660623908,
-0.581387043,
-0.2511202097,
0.0349742584,
-0.2174531072,
-0.4032824636,
-0.9757606387,
0.8606600761,
-0.0765181258,
-0.2412590086,
-0.6523737907,
0.7745167613,
0.0637167394,
-0.5302726626,
-0.1162353903,
0.480694443,
-0.0576836281,
0.132140398,
-0.3896239102,
0.0130198505,
-0.3793818355,
0.2029904574,
-0.1094853804,
0.1767284572,
-0.1620418429,
0.7802576423,
0.3864299953,
0.1528305411,
0.4081136286,
0.0556985326,
0.6253313422,
-0.6932739019,
0.0363186672,
-0.5537689924,
0.6700056791,
0.1140141189,
-0.2861196697,
0.9770637751,
0.5395290256,
0.7345016003,
-0.3151703477,
0.7253745198,
-0.361928463,
0.2745384574,
-0.2244915366,
0.207917586,
-0.0537391268,
0.1168364957,
-0.4647421837,
-0.9028381109,
-0.428822279,
0.5716160536,
-0.1806003749,
-0.2153763473,
0.686393559,
0.321392864,
-0.0495414846,
0.3865938485,
0.3577714562,
0.2288587838,
0.5170553327,
0.1714717746,
1.4708704948,
-0.6669736505,
0.4040031135,
-0.3513251841,
0.2411021888,
0.0297696665,
-0.6829325557,
-0.3586915135,
-0.7698953152,
-0.1619344652,
-0.0389333442,
-0.5886893868,
0.4970867932,
0.4590413272,
-0.797023952,
-0.2240896076,
-0.3292652071,
0.3944797814,
-0.2933028936,
-0.285423696,
0.0680873916,
-0.598234117,
-0.9498707652,
0.4484048486,
0.247169435,
-0.0333909132,
-0.5748464465,
0.2031805515,
0.1827897578,
0.3268693388,
0.7512774467,
0.8519050479,
-0.5539625883,
-0.3703564405,
0.6615951061,
-0.2465064526,
0.1245888025,
1.3508349657,
-0.7001798153,
0.2851055562,
0.7814546824,
0.7159096599,
0.4004693031,
-0.164650172,
0.5598031878,
-0.8632577658,
0.0560110062,
0.5913518071,
0.4368973374,
0.1672496498,
-0.1655071676,
0.3129022121,
0.0904338881,
-0.5452768207,
-0.4833638966,
0.7785975337,
-1.0619906187,
-0.0865419209,
0.9167641401,
0.4437952638,
0.1166778356,
-0.5518974066,
-0.1697076708,
0.1903348267,
0.1557454914,
0.6660448313,
0.7455328107,
-0.4238443077,
0.0141919516,
-0.5353607535,
0.6216532588,
0.3629818857,
-0.7929109931,
-0.0424226001,
0.3248693943,
-0.0615917221,
0.5606170893,
0.5227367878,
-0.2936029732,
0.0157053359,
-0.1248997897,
-0.2610887289,
0.419201225,
-0.4002971351,
-0.2603932619,
0.3542173207,
0.2491693795,
0.2855755985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00204v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00204v1
|
Continuous Training and Fine-tuning for Domain-Specific Language Models in Medical Question Answering
| 2023-11-01T00:18:00 | 2023-11-01T00:18:00 |
Zhen Guo, Yining Hua
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models exhibit promising general capabilities but often lack
specialized knowledge for domain-specific tasks. Developing domain experts from
a base model enables a range of applications without prohibitive training
costs. This work demonstrates a method using continuous training and
instruction fine-tuning to rapidly adapt Llama 2 base models to the Chinese
medical domain. We first conduct continuous training on 1B tokens from Chinese
medical references to teach relevant vocabulary and knowledge. The models are
then fine-tuned on 54K examples sourced from the Chinese National Medical
Licensing Examination. Experiments on Chinese medical data confirm the
effectiveness of this approach, producing a model comparable to GPT-3.5-turbo
while using way less computational resource. The resulting domain-specific
model could be useful for various Chinese medical applications. More broadly,
this provides a template for domain-specific training of large language models
in areas where pre-trained models lack the required expertise, such as law,
science, and engineering.
|
[
0.0289051626,
-0.9366915822,
0.6902418137,
-0.2336843312,
-0.3274972439,
0.0533131808,
-0.3424010873,
-0.4284999073,
-0.1858347505,
0.6468129754,
-0.5679692626,
-0.4550544322,
-0.4080846906,
-0.0479981229,
0.0852238759,
1.065433383,
-0.196105361,
0.4272710681,
-0.0547354147,
-0.1613437682,
-0.6429012418,
-0.686499536,
-0.9605656862,
-0.3657966852,
0.5643808246,
0.4350085855,
0.5461477041,
0.7005368471,
0.4680751264,
0.1108031794,
-0.0618514828,
0.3503468633,
-0.5818404555,
-0.1206322163,
-0.3559919894,
-0.4834556282,
-0.5471144915,
-0.1442915499,
0.4762529433,
0.9313341379,
-0.1316134781,
0.0385935158,
-0.0659710616,
0.4185425937,
-0.1527035534,
-0.0085345702,
-0.9044753909,
-0.090955466,
-0.0344646238,
-0.2491647601,
-0.2938486934,
-0.3349033892,
0.3300899863,
-0.7662981749,
0.3012419343,
-0.1356531233,
1.1346586943,
0.3859266341,
-0.3138495982,
-0.1567041278,
-0.5259392858,
0.702784121,
-0.8951424956,
0.1512935013,
0.4844121933,
0.3324584365,
-0.080969803,
-0.9588336945,
-0.4554821551,
-0.4768596888,
0.0451969877,
-0.0108483043,
0.3231886327,
0.2489393651,
0.0418828316,
0.2359012514,
-0.7434040308,
0.3113839924,
-0.4478375316,
0.0549277291,
0.5914281607,
0.3391774297,
0.5248096585,
0.3663111627,
-0.2582068443,
0.4511938691,
-1.0011432171,
-0.0542084053,
-0.3460120857,
0.1611537188,
-0.1022815555,
0.4014703631,
-0.1821683496,
0.707585752,
0.2053985894,
-0.3337404132,
0.0678322986,
-0.3290889561,
-0.3863483965,
-0.2942014635,
0.2099383473,
0.2196444869,
0.5521597862,
-0.245217517,
-0.1630132794,
-0.0918111503,
0.3150486648,
-0.7712558508,
-0.3070909679,
0.4579460323,
-0.3323718309,
-0.0389460959,
-0.3875784278,
-0.0607606918,
-0.304985702,
-0.5328741074,
0.290110141,
-0.3674256802,
-0.1635946631,
0.4259697497,
0.0993126035,
0.3421419859,
0.3671569824,
-1.1920530796,
0.2968153656,
0.7051566243,
0.6171656847,
-0.3816346526,
-0.2681193054,
-0.4754787087,
0.1468681097,
-0.3759065568,
0.7762618661,
-0.6129362583,
-0.2979359031,
0.0295388717,
0.24372679,
-0.3500515819,
-0.8766832948,
0.1508339196,
-0.7121203542,
-0.0562140718,
-0.0714569688,
-0.6054302454,
-0.1310601234,
0.3850262165,
-0.2053502649,
0.8071548343,
0.4675713778,
-0.4183775485,
0.2393507659,
-0.6158232689,
-0.4756384492,
0.2823044956,
-0.1582495272,
-0.2989471853,
-0.0786155611,
0.2437705249,
0.522698164,
-0.4065667689,
0.383125633,
0.0090303905,
-0.322470665,
0.1722094715,
-0.0162060894,
0.7591586709,
-0.0010007973,
-0.2005738914,
0.079504028,
-0.6330758333,
0.0862023681,
0.1971729249,
-0.4389050603,
-0.3999045193,
-0.0021347792,
-0.0976738855,
0.1703477353,
0.3063519597,
-0.370559901,
0.4904140234,
-0.6644729972,
0.4308360815,
0.3765274286,
0.4362213016,
0.1476391852,
-0.3954840302,
0.5322214365,
0.0527994782,
0.1678801924,
0.0474889912,
-0.6519064307,
-0.8924127221,
-0.0705854148,
0.3979516923,
0.8393406272,
-0.8536024094,
0.0860384777,
-0.2015079707,
-0.5060369372,
-0.6888488531,
0.2666006088,
0.3931764066,
0.6891466975,
0.5578645468,
-0.3296372592,
-0.3089693487,
-0.740590632,
0.0657853931,
-0.0164922699,
-0.2169426978,
0.3254471123,
0.5815917253,
-0.3816542029,
0.6248986721,
-0.5939894915,
-0.1658980548,
-0.1926394552,
-0.1077805012,
0.1993674189,
0.5489477515,
0.5518148541,
-0.7487517595,
-0.6852875948,
0.4656793475,
-0.6562095284,
0.0466488525,
-0.310272485,
-0.1358538866,
0.0853516832,
0.3787953258,
-0.3950004578,
0.2245736569,
0.3761726916,
-0.0886180773,
0.5743551254,
-0.3932066858,
-0.0465393476,
-1.0195982456,
0.2369024754,
-0.1466851979,
-0.1035161465,
-1.1374520063,
0.3781560361,
0.1132632941,
0.0127060795,
-0.5709383488,
0.7212872505,
-0.4286989272,
0.4033079445,
-0.5576247573,
0.1210596934,
-0.0315644443,
0.6245589256,
0.3110662997,
0.8165254593,
0.5186719298,
-0.900136292,
0.2457297295,
0.3114570081,
-0.2876394987,
0.3613998294,
-0.9026001096,
0.3799822032,
0.1213054135,
-0.0211995132,
-0.7665945888,
-0.405885458,
0.089452818,
-0.3583882153,
0.2900649905,
-0.2483960837,
-0.320853889,
-0.2507389486,
0.0890921801,
0.2802477181,
0.7257401347,
-0.425721705,
0.2640807033,
0.4411714375,
-0.3725946546,
-0.4728106558,
-0.6679865718,
-0.136724636,
0.0033867557,
-0.5097680688,
0.3747635484,
-0.158721596,
-0.0005748075,
-0.2050834447,
0.0258736871,
-0.5990767479,
0.3224541247,
-0.0447712205,
0.3331886828,
-0.561011076,
0.1984248161,
0.400331825,
-0.0819666758,
-0.1904361695,
-0.3860896528,
0.4882717431,
0.2281384766,
-0.3545751572,
-0.518216908,
0.3392193317,
0.3867384493,
-0.3170965314,
0.663140595,
0.1826794147,
-0.6051713824,
-0.1962184608,
-0.4661197066,
-0.1534172893,
-0.4689095914,
0.6576243043,
-0.3464819789,
-1.0361748934,
0.40893206,
-0.0912379771,
0.3167843223,
0.4626859725,
1.0705225468,
0.0648289397,
0.9581814408,
0.8634646535,
0.0392011404,
0.1196041033,
-0.0323889293,
-0.0925973207,
-0.7206913233,
-0.15228948,
-0.2371158898,
0.0695660263,
-0.1215227172,
-0.5220534801,
0.4478523433,
-0.0962078869,
-0.5367834568,
0.1165217608,
-0.6110175252,
0.5572786927,
0.2645889819,
0.3431383073,
0.1434212774,
-0.0075505129,
-0.0463773794,
0.1549240053,
-0.6914052963,
-0.4186820686,
1.0662676096,
0.4598439038,
0.5247684121,
-0.1989482343,
0.2165986598,
-0.0493181534,
0.557453692,
-0.718033433,
0.2120229304,
-0.4913453162,
-0.6112319231,
-0.2249345481,
-0.0750269517,
-0.9440674782,
-0.0746868178,
0.082127966,
-0.4999257028,
0.0292643066,
0.2268922329,
-0.7517578602,
0.205577001,
-0.5007527471,
0.7814557552,
-0.3311828971,
-0.0720478073,
-0.216893062,
-0.7063641548,
0.3084955812,
-0.4146209359,
-0.1229251921,
-0.1568184942,
-0.232339099,
0.4727109969,
-0.4091122448,
1.0384949446,
-0.3112243414,
-0.1828255206,
0.322127372,
-0.1626705825,
0.2533043027,
0.0913154855,
-0.157715708,
0.0745086297,
0.0666987076,
-0.6552709341,
-0.5375543237,
0.4530404806,
-0.8960729837,
-0.802094996,
0.0013302183,
-0.5463268161,
-0.6023858786,
0.0938484669,
0.1371924579,
0.1721250862,
-0.1258402616,
-0.1365115941,
0.916226387,
-0.293091327,
-0.1737539768,
0.6750226021,
0.1932024211,
-0.1933272779,
0.7627378106,
0.1117726266,
0.5097935796,
0.3752145767,
0.1327869594,
0.0216974989,
-0.8924182653,
-0.6720196009,
0.5137588382,
-0.7302069664,
-0.1068193167,
-0.4908577502,
-0.6800248027,
-0.2375953794,
-0.1777115017,
-0.1559349,
-0.2812723219,
-0.483124882,
0.0769716799,
0.4664096534,
0.6469777822,
0.4028575122,
0.5079587102,
-0.8787558675,
0.4463315308,
0.4588823915,
0.3987145424,
0.0157059859,
-1.0300325155,
-0.6435366273,
0.1401019096,
-0.0892799124,
-0.6651813388,
0.2546539903,
0.4314203262,
0.6409925222,
0.3796814978,
-0.197372362,
0.8320678473,
-0.877297461,
1.0486195087,
-0.100465551,
-0.6497642994,
0.5800229907,
-0.3149859011,
0.1732591838,
0.5854317546,
0.5680846572,
-0.6242488623,
-0.3009633124,
-0.2333749086,
-0.6837186813,
0.4150013626,
-0.2798757851,
0.4384601414,
0.0196771715,
1.0018641949,
0.3098497987,
-0.0434415303,
-0.4113886952,
-0.1472961009,
0.0116700213,
-0.2629495561,
0.2018724829,
-0.1655392349,
-0.2791858017,
-0.5493708253,
0.6502883434,
-0.3129996061,
0.1119394451,
0.189553231,
-0.0767033845,
0.0750772133,
0.0007737609,
0.8288885355,
0.8922156692,
0.0671823472,
-0.3218687773,
0.6168211102,
-0.8075446486,
0.1217667535,
-0.0806117281,
-0.0753458291,
-0.0371994264,
0.147831127,
0.7078360915,
-0.0684721246,
-0.9604446292,
0.3275756538,
0.1345051974,
-0.3932566941,
-0.371583432,
0.3150935471,
0.2993258238,
0.0246347263,
0.3085206747,
-0.2549217939,
-0.1380788088,
-0.3377458155,
0.3529266119,
0.2129273117,
-0.3607989848,
-0.3261815906,
0.9152587652,
0.1207029298,
-0.0692546889,
0.5970879793,
0.1472287625,
-0.4218591452,
0.8623049855,
0.652174294,
0.5953917503,
-0.3395765722,
-0.0547330454,
0.3291293383,
0.1509475857,
-0.2555298507,
0.3305001855,
0.2963694632,
-0.5708526969,
-0.5947059393,
-0.2222067118,
-0.8101107478,
0.3007277846,
-0.5033524036,
0.24050349,
-0.701892674,
-0.0097654685,
0.0124539286,
0.0508932434,
-0.6050599217,
0.6485574841,
0.2085087299,
0.9918894172,
-0.5445044637,
1.3603026867,
0.7932497859,
-0.4845698774,
-0.8818221688,
0.034743946,
-0.2330207825,
-1.1751028299,
0.7011221051,
-0.1028673127,
0.1464744657,
-0.0049816705,
-0.7914153337,
-0.7032876611,
1.0916028023,
0.2464889586,
-0.5362325311,
-0.1826669872,
0.2238730639,
0.7987321019,
-0.5486493111,
-0.0910008177,
0.8008184433,
0.116353184,
-0.1395949274,
-1.0552498102,
0.104696691,
-0.326382488,
-0.0124063333,
-0.3431574702,
-0.6472606659,
0.9631270766,
-0.3900179565,
-0.1299242824,
0.4488783777,
0.563831985,
0.5201696754,
0.2332823128,
0.3164581358,
0.1219081506,
1.0515676737,
0.0390705131,
0.9923052788,
-0.547911644,
0.2222603112,
0.8498578072,
-0.4480667114,
0.9194685817,
0.243531093,
-0.0833679512,
0.4845449328,
0.8809343576,
-0.1793199927,
0.481241703,
0.3299636841,
-0.407422483,
-0.3644803166,
-0.0627568811,
-0.4825110435,
0.11336606,
0.6498295069,
-0.1706242561,
0.1580765247,
0.0589029193,
0.1710355431,
-0.0267520733,
-0.4684572816,
0.7590664029,
0.210121125,
-0.7529993653,
1.1970596313,
0.1242466718,
0.5402804613,
-0.8358901739,
-0.0666955039,
-0.4112064838,
0.1540877521,
-0.1159420907,
-0.5568976998,
0.2135545313,
0.2126032412,
-0.1758065969,
0.1883937865,
0.4873566926,
-0.4985278547,
-0.2905132771,
0.0079437066,
0.4918058217,
0.3639445901,
0.031417679,
-0.762606442,
-0.4764148891,
0.0512942076,
-0.164643079,
0.3407903016,
0.414688617,
-0.2631865442,
0.7487310767,
0.6612833738,
0.2765001953,
-0.0776397064,
0.2214259505,
1.0462323427,
-0.4965440929,
-0.343924284,
-0.6642592549,
0.4864248335,
0.1638811231,
-0.4309144914,
0.2216523737,
0.3457321227,
0.7799016833,
-0.3966714144,
1.0381013155,
0.2537377477,
0.6876828671,
-0.5833196044,
0.9720546603,
-0.7918346524,
0.1771024168,
0.307015568,
-0.3443251252,
-0.5796169639,
0.3815425336,
-0.2507287562,
-0.023511745,
0.6624381542,
0.7267034054,
-0.023873223,
-0.4321829379,
0.4788275361,
0.2463905215,
0.1443866193,
0.8858639598,
0.5303393006,
-0.2717036307,
0.3969125152,
-0.1167477891,
-0.213148579,
-0.1071856171,
-0.3949155211,
-1.1358759403,
-0.3147577345,
-0.3609977961,
-0.207882598,
0.3544781804,
0.8613268733,
0.7193865776,
-1.1674901247,
-0.0548763834,
0.3049302399,
-0.2147049159,
-0.3710157275,
-0.1303046197,
0.8010830879,
-0.5285509229,
-0.6731424928,
0.3210580945,
0.1538969725,
0.0518977977,
-0.101444371,
-0.0105662839,
-0.1228898987,
0.3172377944,
0.5190283656,
0.5900145173,
-0.7374328375,
-0.4746084809,
0.3854406178,
-0.413018018,
0.3062388301,
0.7172299027,
-0.6008807421,
0.1856881231,
0.1511337757,
1.0935658216,
0.2352602631,
0.2202181369,
0.5318915844,
-0.636687994,
0.1250084043,
0.221673429,
0.2079447657,
0.3456892669,
-0.5495280027,
0.5898052454,
0.2601110637,
-0.6766870618,
-0.6361700296,
0.1233844757,
-1.0944142342,
-0.4604789317,
1.2520160675,
-0.3635367155,
-0.0464140065,
-0.5609660149,
-0.4836362898,
0.3692955375,
0.1816708148,
0.7981092334,
0.4570291638,
-0.1142476276,
-0.1229491383,
-0.9297671318,
0.5458071828,
0.6364350319,
-0.9397174716,
0.0350614712,
0.0145392464,
0.7162966728,
-0.3162165582,
0.9214834571,
-0.0521652363,
0.6748336554,
-0.0908601508,
0.0352989174,
0.0813303143,
-0.0980334952,
-0.2849705219,
-0.0715656281,
0.358548075,
-0.1535981745
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00189v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00189v1
|
XAI-CLASS: Explanation-Enhanced Text Classification with Extremely Weak Supervision
| 2023-10-31T23:24:22 | 2023-10-31T23:24:22 |
Daniel Hajialigol, Hanwen Liu, Xuan Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Text classification aims to effectively categorize documents into pre-defined
categories. Traditional methods for text classification often rely on large
amounts of manually annotated training data, making the process time-consuming
and labor-intensive. To address this issue, recent studies have focused on
weakly-supervised and extremely weakly-supervised settings, which require
minimal or no human annotation, respectively. In previous methods of weakly
supervised text classification, pseudo-training data is generated by assigning
pseudo-labels to documents based on their alignment (e.g., keyword matching)
with specific classes. However, these methods ignore the importance of
incorporating the explanations of the generated pseudo-labels, or saliency of
individual words, as additional guidance during the text classification
training process. To address this limitation, we propose XAI-CLASS, a novel
explanation-enhanced extremely weakly-supervised text classification method
that incorporates word saliency prediction as an auxiliary task. XAI-CLASS
begins by employing a multi-round question-answering process to generate
pseudo-training data that promotes the mutual enhancement of class labels and
corresponding explanation word generation. This pseudo-training data is then
used to train a multi-task framework that simultaneously learns both text
classification and word saliency prediction. Extensive experiments on several
weakly-supervised text classification datasets show that XAI-CLASS outperforms
other weakly-supervised text classification methods significantly. Moreover,
experiments demonstrate that XAI-CLASS enhances both model performance and
explainability.
|
[
-0.33121714,
-0.5098839402,
0.4779275656,
-0.2658874393,
-0.3700037003,
-0.3230296075,
-0.1746602654,
-0.8399830461,
0.0996688008,
0.1750930697,
-0.5499115586,
-0.3755835295,
-0.581761837,
0.1921375692,
-0.5095817447,
1.5408375263,
0.0503124148,
-0.1871744841,
-0.1392546594,
-0.0899598077,
-0.1744790971,
-0.4060745537,
-0.5230496526,
-0.31997931,
0.9074524045,
0.6737028956,
0.7171529531,
0.7940605283,
0.3482492864,
0.3614138663,
0.0244441461,
-0.0155611653,
-0.3519537449,
-0.1463941187,
-0.0488140322,
-0.8594979644,
-0.3488830328,
-0.063294068,
0.5205144286,
0.6319696307,
0.4741825163,
0.100741066,
0.0895213857,
0.2214863598,
-0.7594373822,
0.2471589744,
-0.5157999396,
0.0683717579,
-0.5451882482,
-0.4308032691,
-0.2241500765,
0.1031240448,
0.5872274637,
-0.6462173462,
0.6309350729,
0.3460831642,
1.007212162,
0.2442316711,
-0.2527057528,
-0.1539329439,
-0.3472726345,
0.741984427,
-0.185375154,
0.0350749008,
0.5640096068,
0.1598187685,
0.3267615139,
-0.7394848466,
-0.8555014133,
0.2192799896,
-0.321100682,
0.3601273,
0.1468385309,
0.4612802565,
0.2417036891,
0.735054791,
-0.6110713482,
0.0699246377,
-0.1622111648,
0.1136783883,
0.4678116441,
-0.0668650642,
0.425273478,
-0.3854270577,
-0.5162299871,
-0.0718129426,
-0.1689150333,
0.1811064035,
0.1474889815,
0.3076166213,
-0.1283523887,
0.4256978333,
-0.1131910458,
0.5310198069,
-0.2340251505,
-0.2049556673,
0.2597096562,
-0.1145074666,
-0.2552109361,
0.6280076504,
0.5759177208,
0.4493058622,
-0.1906172782,
-0.3651038706,
-0.1433898211,
0.4029518366,
0.1999713182,
-0.5806540847,
-0.2010307461,
0.1119892821,
-0.5052681565,
-0.8064646721,
-0.1811978966,
-0.8448076248,
-0.2241680771,
-0.2878342867,
0.6301555037,
-0.0275775567,
0.0147671085,
-0.2784164846,
-0.447349757,
0.1126962677,
0.3804109693,
-1.2213622332,
0.156839937,
0.3706557751,
0.9054549336,
-0.1994266957,
-0.3181615174,
-0.4083432853,
0.4214586318,
0.0642301589,
0.9322658181,
-0.603992939,
-0.0410435833,
-0.1334337592,
0.0123102572,
0.1177326292,
-0.0002065352,
1.0371966362,
-0.2461696416,
0.4869635999,
-0.1093519926,
-0.440018028,
-0.2937639952,
0.4319717884,
-0.2861973345,
1.084459424,
0.2389663309,
-1.2248086929,
0.686194241,
-0.6404087543,
-0.4281721115,
0.3600879014,
-0.1662021428,
-0.7992907763,
0.149652794,
0.1494316012,
0.5926998258,
-0.2259459943,
0.0615248345,
-0.2512699962,
-0.7171284556,
0.1117194369,
-0.5196614861,
0.5183276534,
-0.1735944599,
-0.8376962543,
0.2920327187,
-0.8592352271,
0.1357309669,
0.0484292507,
0.001272528,
-0.8437108994,
-0.3104631603,
0.2125430256,
0.200591743,
0.1150091961,
-0.4401700497,
0.0902040601,
-0.5871407986,
0.0486148931,
0.7407395244,
-0.3043903112,
0.5295158029,
-0.4595623314,
0.3588284254,
-0.2237055153,
0.0616025478,
-0.5215752721,
-0.5955277085,
-0.9965956211,
-0.1468320489,
0.0464764461,
0.5167433619,
-0.7974454761,
0.1986140013,
-0.2676412165,
-0.3568029106,
-0.4475735426,
0.2661144733,
0.7773118615,
0.6774879098,
0.4393930435,
0.038786903,
-0.5674078465,
-0.73500669,
-0.1213827431,
-0.4677315056,
0.187196359,
0.2678348124,
0.4812948406,
-0.3656763434,
0.4965097308,
-0.4813724756,
-0.6272534728,
-0.4367283881,
0.5908597708,
-0.3481852412,
0.3167744279,
0.359277457,
-1.2390683889,
-0.3009446561,
-0.0183415115,
-0.8245325685,
-0.1855365783,
-0.4546017349,
-0.1455187052,
0.0886084139,
0.4000267088,
-0.1852180511,
0.5766174793,
0.1424645334,
-0.1481843591,
0.5273709893,
-0.187768057,
-0.0019376109,
-0.8725690842,
-0.0290709529,
0.429563731,
-0.2069924772,
-0.6003224254,
0.1675335914,
0.070931755,
-0.1670600325,
-0.1083521321,
0.5710820556,
-0.5391891599,
0.1779164225,
-0.6536803842,
0.3131861091,
0.0633510947,
0.7811976671,
0.492308408,
0.4321431518,
0.8296955228,
-0.4814471304,
0.1344591081,
0.3146676719,
0.0124446973,
0.429255724,
-0.5570394993,
-0.12569803,
-0.2662938237,
-0.0955121145,
-1.261444211,
-0.464135766,
0.2301761806,
-0.3259908259,
0.4538267255,
-0.1576047093,
-0.4773136973,
-0.3302453458,
-0.4733702838,
0.3098053634,
0.2927638292,
-0.835087657,
0.3381407857,
0.1239448562,
-0.1284998953,
-0.5563852787,
-0.9270077348,
0.1988102943,
-0.3638313413,
-0.313180685,
0.4488693774,
0.2122024447,
-0.0351700485,
0.0290755741,
-0.1439353675,
-0.1892546713,
0.2941480279,
0.5618935823,
0.3889988661,
-0.0590084344,
0.2699439228,
0.6180216074,
-0.3779154718,
0.0029443018,
-0.0860642642,
-0.2120231539,
-0.0658242777,
-0.1009878144,
-0.7802292705,
0.2902278006,
0.342148304,
0.0377717949,
0.6730279922,
0.6890715361,
-0.2075852156,
-0.3425714076,
-0.1853048503,
-0.1192357913,
-0.4609283209,
0.3682831824,
-0.3806935847,
-0.6143542528,
0.0011491128,
-0.0147355739,
0.0979346484,
0.1872011274,
0.2851382494,
-0.1209340617,
1.2720550299,
0.9480612278,
-0.0767126083,
0.6793063283,
-0.1187518612,
-0.0141303865,
-0.4767461717,
-0.3033308387,
-0.5584093332,
-0.3637874722,
-0.4494060576,
-0.0512609258,
0.2206241786,
-0.0314491577,
0.3418130279,
0.1838758737,
-0.819473207,
0.5179781914,
0.7111708522,
0.1682937294,
0.1971029937,
0.1243275031,
0.2922038436,
-0.0595983826,
-0.7055782676,
-0.512652874,
0.8380655646,
0.1805909276,
0.4461196661,
-0.0713112578,
0.8505593538,
0.1964714527,
0.5677870512,
-0.8563759923,
0.3699499667,
-0.2563114464,
-0.5820406675,
-0.2601187527,
-0.4935775995,
-0.7086309791,
0.3570747674,
-0.4431443512,
-0.7351610065,
0.2082289755,
0.2974093556,
-0.1785279661,
0.3418522477,
-1.1976349354,
0.9609489441,
-0.4825869799,
-0.5715166926,
0.1324719042,
-0.8625784516,
0.4844318032,
-0.1148316041,
0.1343148053,
0.282015264,
-0.2300529629,
0.8410379887,
-0.5326108932,
1.0277827978,
-0.1847143173,
-0.0155354692,
0.1695226133,
-0.5754548907,
0.4108727872,
0.1687680632,
0.0349845402,
-0.0935590714,
-0.1632491946,
-0.4079027772,
-0.7502219081,
0.6415694356,
-0.8553513288,
-0.4779390097,
-0.5563796163,
-0.4037964642,
-0.0367135927,
0.3603000641,
0.6130716801,
0.5935026407,
0.2752162516,
-0.1029436141,
0.8720545173,
0.1017268449,
0.3084928393,
0.2011640221,
0.0189398695,
-0.1216835231,
1.2656950951,
0.0955370814,
-0.0105103338,
0.7327001095,
0.2805069387,
-0.3206621408,
-0.739377439,
-0.4631119967,
-0.1745713204,
-0.6654464006,
-0.1448318958,
-0.8912641406,
0.179477632,
-0.2031048387,
-0.4631806016,
0.1895191967,
-0.4013959169,
-0.4959482253,
0.0035192815,
0.1627606601,
0.3612862527,
0.2840544879,
0.8578817844,
-0.5750421286,
0.7641367912,
0.2928776443,
0.2427081466,
0.0081806742,
-0.6078248024,
-0.2750815451,
-0.1993145347,
-0.1384106874,
-0.8847945333,
0.1186195165,
0.4817213714,
0.4708964825,
0.9207841754,
0.3377553225,
0.6462985277,
-0.1202845797,
0.5482190847,
0.3739522994,
-0.8467684388,
0.7567783594,
-0.0884360448,
0.3034766614,
0.7031837702,
0.6129108667,
-0.2538344264,
-0.67816782,
-0.6636000276,
-0.9952147007,
1.1378421783,
0.3883168697,
0.0486439951,
-0.0266544335,
0.6527653933,
0.3027445376,
0.0593407452,
-0.9083433747,
-0.6161524057,
-0.4239482582,
-0.3790047467,
-0.1225494221,
-0.4628066719,
0.1005129144,
-0.1372629702,
0.9538477659,
-0.3123871684,
0.1722929627,
0.2732066214,
-0.2645924985,
-0.01382876,
0.3806599379,
0.4418112934,
0.2222572565,
-0.2184278518,
0.5332725644,
0.1947178394,
-0.6034542918,
0.1929277927,
0.3871611059,
-0.2603038549,
0.1708795279,
0.5208111405,
0.8802458644,
0.2414582968,
-0.6247051954,
0.7315554023,
-0.4401866496,
-0.141452387,
-0.0624566786,
0.3673664033,
-0.5338488817,
0.1335739493,
0.4432707131,
0.2160677314,
0.4007567465,
-0.5231374502,
0.0040306677,
0.1189905405,
-0.6562856436,
-0.3668244183,
0.7095523477,
0.15812774,
0.1977897435,
0.107592985,
-0.524107039,
-0.7364568114,
0.3385944664,
0.4127906859,
0.8304924965,
0.1763330251,
0.3265883923,
0.0940623805,
0.198852852,
-0.1932480335,
0.2077901512,
-0.6810712218,
-0.377066046,
-0.3589809835,
-0.4583551586,
-0.4854087532,
0.0650365427,
-0.7310737967,
0.349963516,
-0.4590065181,
-0.0287935939,
0.3972459733,
0.1390532851,
-0.1595173031,
0.6815795302,
0.2325279415,
0.6201140881,
-1.0889954567,
0.688349247,
1.0757980347,
-0.5016952157,
-0.5074729323,
0.2038090527,
0.0265531633,
-0.4821438491,
0.5851726532,
0.5692099929,
-0.1667569727,
-0.146951735,
-0.6013643742,
-0.4105012715,
0.7259860039,
0.1535446197,
-0.59177351,
-0.1828913689,
-0.0433221608,
0.6909691691,
0.1337042749,
0.385832727,
0.1710463613,
0.4221249521,
-0.0233936179,
-0.3819178641,
0.0531981178,
-0.5595742464,
-0.0806388706,
0.1042402238,
-0.6437174678,
0.2034489512,
-0.1997508854,
-0.2057322264,
0.267781049,
0.9777620435,
-0.1315564364,
0.838894546,
0.5179542899,
0.6011820436,
0.9277936816,
-0.2418238372,
1.2170557976,
-0.0483438522,
0.0274563581,
1.3028352261,
0.0556970946,
0.4757118523,
0.4138250947,
0.1271767914,
0.4802998006,
0.5584779382,
-0.1335630417,
0.4819025099,
-0.1613089442,
-0.4591940641,
-0.3187155724,
-0.2602977157,
-0.2491088808,
0.3713996112,
0.187417984,
-0.5120507479,
-0.1581339091,
0.3412735462,
-0.2084210068,
-0.1268013865,
-0.5969256759,
0.8382496238,
0.0030212176,
-0.4545650184,
0.4130871296,
0.101941742,
0.9356221557,
-0.4709668159,
-0.019683525,
0.0664677992,
0.4774528444,
-0.5671356916,
-0.8409572244,
0.1493099332,
0.0562907197,
-0.4817835093,
-0.2186792344,
0.9538597465,
-0.3623327017,
-0.4264724255,
0.118347995,
0.0007285639,
0.37337026,
-0.0854160637,
-0.7506254911,
-0.2364731133,
-0.0440822989,
-0.0172468331,
0.4792090654,
0.8844983578,
-0.3133489192,
0.5925014019,
0.411590755,
-0.1835454255,
-0.041467268,
0.0313952751,
0.8779938221,
-0.3897882104,
-0.7538186908,
-0.6533699036,
0.340896666,
-0.1315869093,
-0.6136583686,
0.910789609,
0.4773755372,
0.711735785,
0.2384608686,
1.0146085024,
0.055065155,
0.3209356368,
-0.2233736813,
0.5453562737,
-0.8671549559,
0.1499201357,
-0.719789505,
-0.7675632238,
-0.4741218686,
0.4595552981,
-0.353384316,
0.1237713173,
0.6980699897,
0.4796720147,
-0.2338315547,
0.3501093388,
0.342166394,
-0.0308371186,
0.0224391501,
0.2830726206,
0.7358608246,
-0.535001874,
0.9475770593,
-0.5637885332,
-0.5477758646,
-0.2454334795,
-0.5249271989,
-1.2785921097,
-0.4654928148,
-0.7112955451,
-0.0487613454,
0.1581124663,
0.5374079943,
0.8046591282,
-0.6600695848,
0.3367165029,
-0.3534998,
0.2164355069,
-0.2205321938,
-0.2968563735,
0.5716707706,
-0.5997754931,
-0.7186227441,
0.0567565449,
0.2196497619,
0.3575401902,
-0.0753911734,
0.1364488155,
-0.1417019665,
-0.396373719,
0.489957273,
0.3699124753,
-0.2698052824,
0.1263926178,
-0.3819312453,
-0.0317567587,
0.0308452658,
0.688302815,
-0.6161104441,
0.5110647678,
0.5012469888,
0.5930199027,
0.5355526209,
0.0436719209,
0.1146036386,
-1.008636713,
0.3313388228,
-0.0349818282,
0.268573761,
0.3100897372,
-0.6608750224,
0.1523250043,
0.2354191393,
-0.3413846493,
-0.9341269732,
-0.137918368,
-0.9814621806,
-0.3817406297,
0.7340173721,
-0.407009095,
-0.5875760317,
-0.4691569209,
-0.5036692619,
0.4300611317,
-0.4311578274,
0.9169444442,
0.2160013467,
-0.0813891143,
-0.6480820775,
-0.2332936674,
0.5918954015,
0.5839874744,
-1.0421098471,
0.0489481352,
0.1609840989,
-0.2819644809,
0.3872145414,
0.2002846152,
0.0618425608,
0.4998905361,
0.0041790451,
-0.0577328503,
0.0097847022,
-0.4098089933,
-0.3616420031,
0.4071757197,
-0.0101069678,
-0.1557743847
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01472v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01472v1
|
Relation Extraction from News Articles (RENA): A Tool for Epidemic Surveillance
| 2023-10-31T23:14:54 | 2023-10-31T23:14:54 |
Jaeff Hong, Duong Dung, Danielle Hutchinson, Zubair Akhtar, Rosalie Chen, Rebecca Dawson, Aditya Joshi, Samsung Lim, C Raina MacIntyre, Deepti Gurdasani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Relation Extraction from News Articles (RENA) is a browser-based tool
designed to extract key entities and their semantic relationships in English
language news articles related to infectious diseases. Constructed using the
React framework, this system presents users with an elegant and user-friendly
interface. It enables users to input a news article and select from a choice of
two models to generate a comprehensive list of relations within the provided
text. As a result, RENA allows real-time parsing of news articles to extract
key information for epidemic surveillance, contributing to EPIWATCH, an
open-source intelligence-based epidemic warning system.
|
[
-0.2554135621,
-1.0155386925,
0.6176067591,
-0.0306749754,
-0.3135071099,
-0.2358576804,
0.2672982514,
-0.7932440042,
0.9726601839,
0.1841192394,
-0.5199207067,
-0.2750472426,
-0.3004649282,
0.2787477672,
-0.5457704663,
1.0380395651,
0.0291884951,
0.1384901404,
-0.0127768293,
-0.0033476858,
-0.224495396,
-0.160266906,
-0.7383524179,
-0.2128200978,
0.9158772826,
0.8092169762,
0.90767169,
0.6058312654,
1.0678510666,
0.2037219107,
0.2080400288,
-0.0409280919,
-0.5766313672,
0.4383452833,
-0.5859082341,
-0.6293212771,
-0.2305107713,
0.0678811669,
0.3341955841,
0.206186235,
0.0901413038,
0.74688375,
-0.6613448858,
0.9099128842,
-0.7098103166,
0.0640198216,
-0.5705723166,
-0.0984639525,
-0.3080437183,
-0.5118137598,
-0.2756168544,
-0.325948596,
0.3882337511,
-0.5872218609,
-0.153646037,
-0.0952769518,
1.8721660376,
-0.0016664498,
-0.5638101697,
-0.1026675105,
-0.9631028175,
0.4305783212,
-0.388813138,
0.59250319,
0.275731355,
0.5002161264,
-0.3265206218,
-1.3218502998,
-0.6233280301,
0.2398507148,
0.0380440839,
-0.0092069432,
-0.719145,
-0.3321135938,
-0.0763603598,
0.2122425586,
-0.3347293437,
-0.3280544281,
-0.5557534099,
0.2472348064,
0.4407784939,
0.0484767891,
0.9293677211,
-0.5285186768,
-0.4870210886,
0.1018102393,
-0.8846493959,
0.0633152947,
0.2968162298,
0.0352259353,
-0.2043679655,
0.352637887,
-0.0952598229,
0.7360311151,
-0.1098177433,
-0.4472795129,
0.2683092952,
-0.1382455826,
-0.2824604511,
-0.0682567209,
0.8155157566,
0.5568003654,
0.2276021689,
-0.2436276376,
-0.0460419431,
-0.0952753723,
0.4114872217,
-0.8056789041,
-0.3868947029,
0.1483379006,
-0.9634228349,
-0.6451071501,
0.234043479,
-1.287139535,
0.0567486286,
-0.1373903304,
0.4860667586,
0.0956397578,
-0.2776643634,
-0.2415069789,
-0.5974802971,
0.125006929,
0.0399272852,
-0.5667877197,
0.4444260597,
0.4075888693,
0.6440950632,
-0.2288471758,
0.1013455838,
-0.5626602769,
0.1814677268,
-0.2182026654,
0.9248442054,
-0.4897114038,
0.0423720144,
-0.207901299,
0.3526201844,
0.2104987651,
-0.4496524334,
0.2895903587,
-1.0932830572,
-0.014899293,
0.1466454715,
-0.1536405534,
-0.5323091149,
0.1552002877,
-1.1047508717,
0.6225290895,
0.2977170348,
-1.1024736166,
0.2408609241,
-0.0864356607,
-0.4140425622,
-0.3723022044,
-0.012234862,
-0.4442303479,
-0.3029339015,
0.1036757827,
0.2918408513,
-0.5319108963,
0.3369719088,
-0.2531564236,
0.2884534895,
0.3928076029,
-0.1319143176,
0.5882343054,
0.6057474613,
-0.031549748,
0.3425391912,
-0.9789780974,
-0.3564257622,
0.2347878665,
0.0049376143,
-0.7591298223,
0.2348401248,
0.0192033928,
0.2949565649,
0.3163965344,
-0.488453716,
0.0519674756,
-0.6751834154,
0.1928478181,
0.3448564708,
0.9935786724,
0.3114292324,
-0.3755340874,
0.666908443,
0.1255978793,
0.396220088,
-0.2490977496,
-0.695331037,
-0.588935554,
0.1771086305,
0.460931778,
0.8593816757,
-0.9047173262,
0.1404447109,
-0.3148858249,
-0.5245702863,
-0.3309206963,
0.2553969026,
0.1897103041,
0.5964420438,
0.1997712553,
-0.3333342373,
-0.9245356321,
-1.0712457895,
-0.279574424,
-0.0089937402,
0.3304493427,
0.0597010478,
0.3585824668,
-0.2793305814,
1.2251745462,
-0.7638341784,
-0.3326769471,
-0.2980490923,
0.1350656748,
0.2817320526,
0.1251614243,
0.5777262449,
-1.1848448515,
-0.5675420165,
0.2238636464,
-0.7213410139,
0.0422627367,
-0.1367108822,
-0.2537065744,
-0.1290247738,
0.486733973,
-0.3608200848,
0.906216979,
0.4132737219,
-0.3350879848,
0.4578853846,
0.1374893785,
0.164978385,
-1.8152134418,
0.4091885388,
0.1904391348,
-0.6457512975,
-0.8708284497,
0.2601876855,
-0.111152038,
-0.3233607709,
-0.6431040764,
0.4568138719,
-0.5918034911,
-0.2118555307,
-0.1671256274,
0.4096471667,
-0.0071790675,
0.1271820366,
-0.0382965282,
0.6538547277,
0.2770287395,
-0.551306963,
0.5312325358,
0.1511977166,
0.0906020254,
-0.0437004417,
-0.4416483939,
-0.1437099129,
-0.0483088195,
-0.1534440368,
-0.6710110307,
-0.2802093029,
0.3603726923,
-0.671884656,
0.1351399869,
-0.0359373279,
-0.2711601555,
-0.2449617982,
-0.3684597015,
0.2123179883,
0.32236287,
-0.3720738292,
0.5508500338,
1.0623512268,
-0.4191883504,
-0.7323596478,
-0.3686563075,
0.1874019504,
-0.117800802,
-0.4068032503,
0.0420188867,
0.5572323203,
-0.8185856938,
0.6566314697,
-0.1792919785,
-0.8333902955,
0.1163798943,
0.4442373216,
0.5116447806,
-0.2255033851,
0.2563200891,
-0.0359087959,
-0.1143571883,
-0.1020017564,
0.6853465438,
0.4351993203,
0.2868759632,
0.0378570631,
-1.1832073927,
0.3735170066,
0.7240641117,
-0.2567563355,
0.7123611569,
0.183617115,
-0.4283541739,
0.0122839371,
-0.4231947958,
-0.5275514722,
-0.3905357718,
0.0945390686,
-0.4147254825,
-0.2911624014,
0.7787461281,
-0.3122506738,
-0.0962915048,
0.7356539965,
0.063469328,
0.3824218512,
0.7138231993,
0.8283077478,
-0.6738757491,
0.5211729407,
-0.1587761045,
0.1141079068,
-0.6368604302,
-0.2888370752,
-0.7817348838,
-0.3484835029,
-0.3959073424,
-0.0936071426,
0.27030164,
0.0298787709,
0.0074916203,
0.4699364603,
-0.4565507174,
0.1801065654,
0.5110040903,
0.0836998746,
0.7414090633,
0.0914209709,
0.589902997,
0.0577817149,
-0.6183657646,
-0.4099203944,
1.1320331097,
0.5236567259,
1.1277731657,
-0.0119139403,
0.7715811133,
0.2025792301,
0.4237072766,
-1.1144150496,
0.1938927323,
0.1063293219,
-0.6315913796,
-0.2593694925,
-0.3107179701,
-1.5570449829,
-0.057979282,
-0.1535732597,
-0.9716634154,
0.8236685395,
-0.4513759911,
-0.2220079154,
0.4895812571,
-0.6309908032,
0.6591007113,
0.3382103443,
-0.0974606946,
-0.3766819239,
-0.7852596641,
0.5521978736,
0.158081606,
0.382279247,
-0.0455802307,
-0.1720597446,
1.0340474844,
-0.4990565777,
0.6859113574,
0.2123842835,
-0.0772497207,
0.5988672376,
0.1843731701,
0.4878675044,
0.2888574004,
0.2948536873,
-0.0265034325,
0.2878781259,
0.1618560851,
-0.4267420769,
0.7520026565,
-0.8305869102,
-0.4350520372,
-0.5370611548,
-0.3885056674,
-0.0517888814,
0.5116729736,
-0.0776350275,
0.6797499657,
-0.2654115856,
0.0710179582,
0.3409188986,
0.0697958916,
0.4460134804,
0.845603466,
-0.6134142876,
-0.6141664386,
0.9690007567,
0.1470493376,
0.0137878284,
0.7051108479,
-0.064019151,
0.1139230505,
0.0538527258,
-0.4498976469,
0.2967274487,
-0.4545014203,
-0.5329897404,
-0.6467987895,
-0.3277388215,
-0.323477596,
0.133463338,
-0.2497342825,
-0.5845809579,
-0.6056093574,
-0.133343488,
0.5297611952,
0.9340084791,
-0.0268699527,
0.1271815747,
-1.225676775,
1.0788093805,
0.4037631154,
-0.0853957161,
-0.005545707,
-0.074109979,
-0.1216630712,
-0.2656667829,
-0.4386526048,
-1.6385574341,
0.705047965,
-0.0236726142,
0.2425777316,
0.9183934927,
-0.0679228008,
0.8609670401,
-0.4388909638,
0.7713090181,
0.3752494752,
-0.6083056927,
0.9100379944,
-0.3532003462,
-0.1235191599,
0.5532813668,
0.7341873646,
-0.436239779,
-0.2792392373,
-0.9067623019,
-0.8109447956,
0.7488948703,
-0.1609271318,
-0.1926041692,
-0.2680254281,
0.3941542506,
-0.0852590576,
0.0833322927,
-0.5590280294,
-0.6490924358,
0.3204166293,
-0.0734702423,
0.4359330237,
-0.7188977599,
-0.3860033751,
-0.3291083276,
0.7910655141,
0.2933555543,
0.0977989361,
0.7249107957,
-0.036950741,
-0.7361491919,
0.0624947324,
0.2086570859,
1.1590080261,
-0.181784749,
0.1904683262,
-0.2312555909,
-0.7146294713,
0.1626015007,
0.2083613425,
-0.2988393009,
0.4455183148,
0.3226147592,
0.4557666779,
0.4494320452,
-0.7952480912,
0.8144463301,
-0.1529311538,
0.2122342885,
-0.3819420338,
-0.2642689347,
-0.0308499299,
0.1705023944,
0.5935662389,
0.0792436302,
0.497156918,
-0.939375639,
0.7747662067,
0.2640709877,
-0.4937447309,
-0.4763160944,
0.6669419408,
0.2592819333,
-0.2209154516,
0.5016930699,
0.0908781514,
-0.1133603975,
0.9232366681,
0.6191166639,
0.8226581812,
-0.438488096,
0.4222419262,
0.4195413888,
0.2386333495,
0.2142331749,
0.6442064643,
0.3499261737,
-0.7567662001,
-0.5110172629,
-0.5396413803,
-0.1983195394,
0.3172925115,
-1.0086957216,
0.3067858219,
-0.0565918796,
-0.4208145142,
0.1398104727,
-0.0768764913,
-0.2116171122,
0.1144762263,
-0.3268730044,
1.2432461977,
-0.8532581925,
0.8672834039,
0.7744830251,
-0.8806502819,
-1.261961937,
0.1423851103,
-0.1257780343,
-0.4694184363,
0.9557062387,
-0.2169741392,
0.0547334366,
-0.1018628627,
-0.2694351375,
-1.0704809427,
0.9247629642,
0.4166694582,
-0.4884322882,
-0.0766390935,
-0.3784177005,
0.3022274673,
-0.273253262,
-0.0152589437,
0.5293901563,
0.5070583224,
-0.3153761327,
-1.0392041206,
0.0107433004,
-0.2876660526,
-0.3084292114,
0.4890511036,
-0.6742629409,
0.6026871204,
-0.1955779046,
-0.6040700078,
0.0572779328,
0.7217478752,
-0.4706840813,
0.6146184802,
0.1981112659,
0.8731427789,
0.4136547744,
0.1573754847,
1.0960270166,
-0.6943676472,
0.264557153,
1.1403821707,
-0.0417676233,
1.0551948547,
0.7195652127,
-0.1671300828,
1.1815214157,
0.5305200219,
0.2459020615,
0.5321361423,
-0.1834892631,
-0.3171188235,
0.2152917683,
-0.2770511508,
-0.3487675488,
0.3812652826,
0.318793267,
-0.6703003049,
-0.5216286182,
0.0241513029,
0.3199335039,
-0.0245841052,
-0.4206814766,
1.1076694727,
0.2228793204,
-0.6031544805,
0.261110276,
-0.1182481796,
-0.1198860258,
-0.6850748658,
-0.40967682,
0.2165091038,
0.0486214533,
-0.3239605129,
-0.6637042761,
0.3486617804,
-0.1551162601,
-0.5055109859,
0.5682010055,
1.2573224306,
-0.4196820259,
-0.0456222855,
0.2939309478,
0.8589782715,
0.2381041795,
0.1720249504,
-0.5456130505,
0.0493541285,
-0.0745499656,
-0.6726332307,
0.2410841137,
0.3330906928,
-0.0558341779,
0.9339764118,
0.8707418442,
0.567805171,
-0.3112994134,
-0.0103541333,
1.044649601,
-0.6592431664,
-0.4115514457,
-0.7598467469,
0.0994364396,
-0.2799920142,
-0.2578362823,
0.8054236174,
0.795681417,
0.1602396518,
-0.2830787599,
0.4110438824,
-0.2498840541,
0.5349124074,
-0.0897387937,
0.7547200322,
-0.4390737116,
-0.3322207332,
-0.1001112387,
-0.7019732594,
-0.3149957061,
0.1698275506,
-0.083273977,
-0.664750278,
1.1168899536,
0.758754909,
0.0266082399,
-0.2102009803,
0.0059474413,
0.0511749089,
0.0878722519,
0.2095335573,
0.3631241024,
-0.5205420256,
0.4448375702,
-0.4030738771,
-0.2762283981,
-0.2532020807,
-0.52460289,
-0.7878862023,
-0.674987793,
0.0442768671,
-0.1585069597,
0.1652878523,
0.7031537294,
0.6695964336,
-0.8029490113,
-0.1529728621,
-0.0809426382,
0.5130839944,
-0.1442431957,
-0.4519895613,
0.5966416001,
-0.5481423736,
-0.7411782146,
0.4469601512,
0.2422394753,
-0.186598748,
-0.2712283134,
0.462875247,
-0.6709189415,
-0.030058654,
0.3966895342,
0.8239978552,
-0.3493834734,
-0.2477067858,
-0.4168330729,
-0.0661360174,
-0.0436521359,
0.6710338593,
-0.9889570475,
0.7036483884,
1.1195764542,
0.5397077799,
0.2268890887,
0.2681771219,
0.6547782421,
-0.3420336246,
0.3849702775,
-0.1089759767,
0.2620728016,
-0.1536895484,
-0.6978036165,
0.6571021676,
0.3884105682,
-0.61666435,
-0.8635706902,
0.1071381047,
-1.1013854742,
-0.3081550598,
1.0754644871,
-0.0454614088,
-0.9357630014,
-0.2213405371,
-0.2804245353,
0.4359890223,
-0.7449888587,
0.7409951091,
0.3659405708,
-0.1811643392,
-0.0841257274,
-0.9614075422,
0.649702549,
-0.2648494542,
-1.0236334801,
-0.4761550725,
0.2326530963,
0.4542801082,
0.4830661416,
0.6849676967,
-0.3772155941,
0.5102367997,
-0.0014157239,
0.2711873651,
0.1675325781,
-0.7077882886,
0.0224131439,
0.4375212193,
-0.1014840454,
-0.4009667337
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00176v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00176v5
|
ChipNeMo: Domain-Adapted LLMs for Chip Design
| 2023-10-31T22:35:58 | 2024-04-04T20:18:57 |
Mingjie Liu, Teodor-Dumitru Ene, Robert Kirby, Chris Cheng, Nathaniel Pinckney, Rongjian Liang, Jonah Alben, Himyanshu Anand, Sanmitra Banerjee, Ismet Bayraktaroglu, Bonita Bhaskaran, Bryan Catanzaro, Arjun Chaudhuri, Sharon Clay, Bill Dally, Laura Dang, Parikshit Deshpande, Siddhanth Dhodhi, Sameer Halepete, Eric Hill, Jiashang Hu, Sumit Jain, Ankit Jindal, Brucek Khailany, George Kokai, Kishor Kunal, Xiaowei Li, Charley Lind, Hao Liu, Stuart Oberman, Sujeet Omar, Ghasem Pasandi, Sreedhar Pratty, Jonathan Raiman, Ambar Sarkar, Zhengjiang Shao, Hanfei Sun, Pratik P Suthar, Varun Tej, Walker Turner, Kaizhe Xu, Haoxing Ren
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
ChipNeMo aims to explore the applications of large language models (LLMs) for
industrial chip design. Instead of directly deploying off-the-shelf commercial
or open-source LLMs, we instead adopt the following domain adaptation
techniques: domain-adaptive tokenization, domain-adaptive continued
pretraining, model alignment with domain-specific instructions, and
domain-adapted retrieval models. We evaluate these methods on three selected
LLM applications for chip design: an engineering assistant chatbot, EDA script
generation, and bug summarization and analysis. Our evaluations demonstrate
that domain-adaptive pretraining of language models, can lead to superior
performance in domain related downstream tasks compared to their base LLaMA2
counterparts, without degradations in generic capabilities. In particular, our
largest model, ChipNeMo-70B, outperforms the highly capable GPT-4 on two of our
use cases, namely engineering assistant chatbot and EDA scripts generation,
while exhibiting competitive performance on bug summarization and analysis.
These results underscore the potential of domain-specific customization for
enhancing the effectiveness of large language models in specialized
applications.
|
[
-0.330262661,
-0.457668066,
0.5687376857,
0.2920282781,
-0.3433183134,
0.4550883472,
-0.2412583977,
-0.724473238,
0.1263992488,
0.5832428336,
-0.418332845,
-0.6382756233,
-0.4558236897,
0.0280869585,
-0.0506883748,
0.7183552384,
-0.2889727056,
0.0644494444,
-0.2806533575,
0.391010344,
-0.8815475702,
-0.3595762551,
-0.5382085443,
-0.2704694569,
0.1986060888,
0.5114061236,
0.3796886206,
0.4293093383,
0.6678319573,
0.3649900854,
0.2978308499,
0.106712915,
-0.2082243562,
-0.0241283532,
-0.1520722359,
-0.4335355759,
-1.0579038858,
-0.0326025411,
0.1706042588,
0.5286327004,
0.0584590137,
0.058386784,
-0.1556125879,
0.2386958897,
-0.2775492668,
0.1160094664,
-1.11348629,
-0.0132930325,
-0.041021619,
-0.2907324135,
-0.5624373555,
-0.2342933416,
-0.146553278,
-0.7414016128,
0.1435994655,
0.1995028704,
0.6309107542,
0.2492727488,
0.1068734452,
-0.6387332678,
-0.808247447,
0.9817273021,
-0.8748055696,
0.2642757595,
0.2820376158,
0.3667572141,
-0.2954995036,
-0.7921808958,
-0.157333523,
-0.4204888046,
0.3712101877,
0.2994420528,
-0.0811785534,
0.1097280979,
-0.0043654451,
0.1059156582,
-0.5643843412,
0.5785571933,
-0.3942644298,
-0.2075960934,
0.4407817125,
0.0637668148,
0.46072644,
0.2940444648,
-0.5800303221,
0.2115259618,
-0.7878883481,
-0.3929585814,
0.0740332678,
0.1645761281,
0.1473443806,
0.1461398005,
-0.0033196157,
0.7124345303,
-0.2862939537,
-0.1335327774,
0.2595639825,
0.1348111182,
-0.304720521,
0.2192029655,
0.4175272286,
0.1985583603,
0.2784486115,
-0.2962932289,
-0.3943155408,
-0.1072265953,
0.4269690514,
-0.8925845623,
-0.187439248,
0.3872754276,
-0.3656400144,
-0.2375338227,
-0.1029910669,
-0.5888127685,
-0.254740119,
-0.2027378678,
0.2591655254,
-0.2727869749,
-0.2249992639,
0.2747838497,
-0.2695181966,
0.3195070922,
0.3194975555,
-0.9761303663,
0.27570346,
1.1907120943,
1.0202997923,
-0.5896197557,
-0.404322505,
-0.1921269894,
0.3958804905,
-0.4712419212,
1.0693297386,
-0.8914147019,
-0.7276104093,
-0.2094062716,
-0.0676491112,
0.0052315835,
-1.0004645586,
0.5500227213,
-0.8101623058,
-0.4428171515,
0.0790864751,
-0.3968710303,
0.0567370132,
0.1931194216,
-0.4367809892,
0.6630229354,
0.0418776199,
-0.4314747453,
0.0820947438,
-0.8316276073,
-0.534319222,
0.0864701122,
-0.1964159906,
-0.2992236018,
0.4540190995,
-0.1674199253,
0.4930415154,
-0.3965699375,
0.0652550906,
-0.4245615005,
-0.5286713839,
0.4475758374,
-0.0891621932,
0.597917676,
0.4738976657,
-0.253649801,
0.1718369871,
-0.761420846,
-0.0793475509,
0.0719863772,
-0.1466696858,
-0.3542937636,
0.0946979448,
-0.2922594845,
0.2472151518,
0.1463425756,
-0.5897256732,
-0.0165843498,
-0.3893446028,
0.6441999078,
0.9706833959,
-0.2045729607,
0.271620959,
-0.3142273426,
0.7129522562,
0.0662951618,
0.3653604686,
-0.0245996322,
-0.4839986265,
-0.7867011428,
-0.5263673067,
0.4934840798,
0.6246443391,
-0.817868948,
0.3724709153,
-0.3639317155,
-0.2657346725,
-0.2436353564,
0.1734775603,
0.2150949538,
0.3986571133,
0.1345497221,
-0.7062743902,
-0.5413136482,
-0.9372426271,
0.062456537,
-0.0748242289,
-0.3561312556,
0.2542299032,
0.3119364381,
-0.5037588477,
0.8317357302,
-0.713680923,
0.0069832169,
-0.0877399817,
0.0548040569,
0.1728880554,
0.4146671593,
0.5908536315,
-0.4633350372,
-0.5287664533,
0.3184371293,
-0.3812512159,
-0.3309911489,
0.1124866456,
-0.488170445,
0.0871379375,
0.453196615,
-0.5138704777,
0.0387235098,
0.6895978451,
0.1417012364,
0.4140984416,
-0.2134404778,
0.1153247058,
-1.3703179359,
-0.1233764514,
-0.3901283145,
-0.3600024879,
-0.6725600362,
-0.0418346338,
0.0238616392,
-0.3004665971,
-0.5366308093,
0.443675518,
-0.5542897582,
-0.5054546595,
-0.843919456,
0.3704029918,
-0.0080801193,
0.2179154754,
0.0355814025,
1.0327539444,
0.4271086156,
-0.7638224959,
0.2661222517,
0.1366326809,
-0.3352635503,
0.2795549929,
-0.8443772197,
0.5455038548,
0.2523968816,
-0.0740609691,
-0.8827168345,
0.0208324175,
0.0103054307,
-0.5638332963,
0.3528496325,
0.0453804247,
-0.1411361694,
-0.2589564323,
-0.6555346847,
0.1672663838,
0.650424242,
-0.6682265997,
0.6273216009,
0.6954758763,
-0.4490303695,
-0.2093818188,
-0.756823957,
0.064189516,
-0.0617268085,
-0.5596968532,
0.7137117982,
-0.7043014765,
-0.2008904368,
-0.2155667394,
-0.0689616054,
-0.3298249543,
0.4135654867,
0.3484275639,
0.5744496584,
-0.4718786776,
0.0443561003,
0.0107027711,
-0.2453245819,
0.0055195615,
-0.234814167,
0.6384835243,
0.2450615168,
-0.0529829375,
-0.1001865938,
0.2683469951,
0.3747692704,
-0.1825820357,
0.3550214171,
0.3172160387,
-0.3177808523,
-0.6482415795,
-0.3795452416,
0.1267104,
-0.5799036026,
0.5313990712,
-0.7332966328,
-1.0934910774,
0.4500051141,
-0.650590539,
0.1370848715,
0.3924202919,
0.6284916401,
0.0117342779,
0.8038220406,
0.9098246694,
-0.361849457,
0.5165504813,
0.1965020299,
0.2758294046,
-0.9439033866,
0.1203303561,
-0.7142442465,
-0.2483346313,
-0.6011694074,
-0.579803586,
-0.0731578916,
-0.0944714621,
-0.096682474,
0.2060043365,
-0.4363967478,
0.6313462853,
0.2842432261,
-0.0758659616,
0.2961706519,
0.059541963,
0.1680663079,
0.2882157564,
-0.673060298,
-0.7506700158,
0.8052559495,
0.4295279086,
0.8763790131,
0.0813670233,
0.4815063179,
0.3234607279,
0.7189602256,
-0.9289129972,
0.4627695382,
-0.3962849975,
-0.4189121723,
0.0397767983,
-0.4434321821,
-0.6778244972,
-0.1173602566,
0.2700519562,
-0.3812247813,
0.1321221739,
0.0557089373,
-0.4062938392,
0.1444972306,
-0.8826797009,
0.6382568479,
-0.4274384677,
0.2236474156,
-0.2859218717,
-0.0066852961,
0.3916778266,
-0.5461148024,
0.3692026138,
-0.3923930228,
-0.5578591824,
0.6033495665,
-0.2877360582,
0.9156419039,
0.1373494714,
-0.119954437,
0.3008596003,
0.0922332853,
0.3029409647,
-0.1042482033,
-0.3213595152,
0.2284915894,
-0.1310620159,
-0.2445297241,
-0.4954392314,
1.2938247919,
-0.9073954821,
-0.7704843283,
-0.1293593496,
-0.5042897463,
-0.4861775041,
0.2883054316,
0.0374592915,
0.2700193226,
-0.420319438,
-0.0007283615,
0.8013374209,
-0.5011988878,
0.6349731684,
0.6349388361,
-0.1837823987,
-0.4745634198,
0.9451607466,
-0.1883992404,
0.3858129978,
0.3610298634,
0.071184285,
0.317756176,
-0.8532758355,
-0.4034473598,
0.2763150334,
-0.6959159374,
-0.5428827405,
-0.3698328435,
-0.2053768933,
-0.5131297708,
-0.3983923495,
-0.5009704232,
-0.395539254,
-0.33543998,
-0.0213688444,
0.35276559,
0.8286271095,
0.3712329268,
0.2713544071,
-0.8098939061,
0.2628882527,
0.3272836208,
0.6976217628,
-0.1860230416,
-0.7718256116,
-0.1893037707,
-0.206242159,
-0.2247308642,
-0.5811004043,
0.1154563352,
0.2760036588,
0.5309003592,
-0.0085417703,
-0.1332234144,
0.4639880061,
-0.7949056625,
0.6344927549,
0.0504422151,
-0.9590885043,
0.5359039903,
-0.125101015,
0.3628115356,
0.398208499,
0.6167571545,
-0.267682761,
-0.0390725881,
-0.2436377108,
-0.5614388585,
0.5713207722,
-0.1259927452,
0.5992995501,
-0.0022108934,
0.6782338619,
0.2275186628,
-0.0338787362,
-0.2694190145,
0.1399863362,
-0.0498550348,
-0.5535343885,
0.1394401789,
-0.4933540821,
0.0511744842,
0.1598223001,
0.9855369925,
-0.2923338711,
0.5226668715,
0.0057425061,
-0.2547315955,
0.1714571118,
0.0869595557,
1.031930089,
1.0233721733,
-0.0963732675,
0.0963438824,
0.3123667538,
-0.7251540422,
-0.1647281498,
0.0061412174,
0.0542981066,
0.1052689031,
0.1820809245,
0.6954348683,
0.3147248626,
-0.7334235311,
0.2681016922,
-0.2460498065,
-0.1534259021,
-0.1699567139,
0.2799136937,
0.1653242409,
0.2658838332,
0.0825391412,
-0.3308341503,
0.1773201078,
-0.6296713948,
0.1995986998,
0.4352180362,
-0.2839215398,
-0.5123466849,
0.5598139763,
0.3903798759,
-0.5454589725,
0.2914368212,
0.0588481948,
-0.4127136171,
0.7737526298,
0.8291242719,
1.2047812939,
-0.5333991051,
0.031308949,
0.0440976806,
0.3741042614,
0.1737135202,
0.0569977053,
0.1810224354,
-0.7710771561,
-0.364813447,
-0.5572453141,
-0.7021125555,
-0.0145869916,
-0.1575638503,
0.4898938239,
-0.9418416023,
-0.3444494009,
0.0007506463,
-0.1765503883,
-0.3496086001,
0.1862982959,
0.1067550555,
1.0387485027,
-0.4578368962,
1.0750490427,
0.6170122027,
-0.1157733575,
-0.4633408785,
-0.2210037261,
-0.3637034595,
-0.9954374433,
0.3976356983,
-0.1050627753,
-0.2779202163,
0.1140596196,
-0.3326156437,
-0.7930133939,
1.443541646,
0.2582295537,
-0.6190586686,
0.3224708438,
0.2424744964,
0.2401302308,
-0.6444350481,
0.1765716374,
0.7107698321,
-0.0088928929,
0.275428921,
-0.9494112134,
-0.0633374304,
-0.1828994155,
0.5818611383,
0.1024016887,
-0.8346722126,
0.4750326276,
0.2349663824,
0.1017090231,
0.0349658541,
0.7135077119,
0.2779230177,
0.1147733629,
0.3080306053,
0.1226193532,
0.7174521089,
0.0620610751,
0.974560976,
-0.6114782095,
0.0481962338,
1.2983567715,
-0.5702610612,
1.0000356436,
0.1864847392,
-0.0217882395,
0.3771582842,
0.6160542369,
0.3413470089,
0.4287117422,
0.15628317,
-0.2731364369,
0.0692981929,
-0.0042300485,
-0.3051813841,
0.3592431545,
0.3016014397,
-0.3690077662,
0.1951772273,
0.0156460181,
0.1105937809,
-0.3033011854,
-0.4803306162,
0.6000383496,
0.3879435062,
-0.3559604883,
0.3691442609,
0.3557630181,
0.8139529824,
-0.5752850771,
0.0860209838,
-0.4588863552,
0.3334417939,
0.0029527275,
-0.3121300042,
0.3485690653,
0.1806232184,
-0.1998659968,
-0.1545411646,
1.1814996004,
0.0463526696,
-0.5849544406,
0.2038689703,
0.0357296281,
0.2408219278,
0.1251249164,
-0.7114030123,
0.7327349186,
-0.148161903,
-0.0588279851,
0.3269380331,
0.2558903098,
-0.0891478211,
0.4145525992,
0.340241909,
0.0419521555,
0.1327562332,
0.2854731381,
0.9622275829,
-0.7049930096,
-0.1089666709,
-0.59368366,
0.0872360095,
-0.0386695638,
-0.0717747137,
0.7645082474,
0.7024974227,
0.9449239969,
-0.3272130489,
0.7848372459,
0.3382751346,
0.3006297946,
-0.6942472458,
0.3968507648,
-0.1167945638,
0.4527416527,
-0.1547279209,
-0.9355481863,
-0.4431225955,
0.416974932,
-0.3889154196,
0.3879225254,
0.6126995683,
0.9134573936,
-0.1635005027,
-0.0218639262,
0.5226247311,
0.2624198496,
0.486623019,
0.7441160679,
0.7843936682,
-0.2100677788,
0.3603549302,
0.0798786283,
-0.550293386,
-0.2088374496,
-1.0664316416,
-0.8724531531,
-0.2302200347,
-0.4456381202,
0.2264547944,
-0.1386047602,
0.8129820824,
0.7398853302,
-0.8691211939,
-0.4216002226,
0.2530512214,
-0.0636590272,
0.1776664257,
-0.0897925273,
-0.0700417832,
-0.5178719759,
-0.7227961421,
0.6681861877,
0.65363276,
-0.0166710075,
-0.1309581399,
-0.0882072598,
0.0978001803,
0.5775643587,
0.9670482278,
0.0663677529,
-0.4223597348,
-0.3714832664,
0.1350082904,
-0.0940209478,
0.3041532338,
1.150219202,
-0.2956260443,
0.2645759881,
0.4929741025,
0.9103487134,
0.3561587334,
-0.1059372276,
0.5711315274,
-0.5089718699,
0.1643164605,
0.0385296457,
0.1815413535,
0.3052006066,
-0.2781971097,
0.326431334,
0.0756507218,
-0.6264192462,
-0.5682259798,
0.194250524,
-0.8291276693,
-0.6319730282,
1.0148364305,
-0.1029475182,
-0.6444282532,
-0.0369527861,
-0.1966395676,
0.0956205279,
0.0232601408,
0.778313458,
0.6793299913,
-0.2575950027,
0.1299125254,
-0.9085871577,
0.3531112969,
0.1989786625,
-1.179136157,
-0.0818675011,
0.2942263782,
0.5830578208,
-0.0307651162,
0.8807619214,
-0.1428716183,
0.1716785729,
-0.1444907039,
0.3458131254,
-0.1924225837,
-0.3236592412,
-0.4191988707,
-0.2244862169,
0.8150599003,
-0.2821882665
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00172v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00172v1
|
Robust Safety Classifier for Large Language Models: Adversarial Prompt Shield
| 2023-10-31T22:22:10 | 2023-10-31T22:22:10 |
Jinhwa Kim, Ali Derakhshan, Ian G. Harris
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models' safety remains a critical concern due to their
vulnerability to adversarial attacks, which can prompt these systems to produce
harmful responses. In the heart of these systems lies a safety classifier, a
computational model trained to discern and mitigate potentially harmful,
offensive, or unethical outputs. However, contemporary safety classifiers,
despite their potential, often fail when exposed to inputs infused with
adversarial noise. In response, our study introduces the Adversarial Prompt
Shield (APS), a lightweight model that excels in detection accuracy and
demonstrates resilience against adversarial prompts. Additionally, we propose
novel strategies for autonomously generating adversarial training datasets,
named Bot Adversarial Noisy Dialogue (BAND) datasets. These datasets are
designed to fortify the safety classifier's robustness, and we investigate the
consequences of incorporating adversarial examples into the training process.
Through evaluations involving Large Language Models, we demonstrate that our
classifier has the potential to decrease the attack success rate resulting from
adversarial attacks by up to 60%. This advancement paves the way for the next
generation of more reliable and resilient conversational agents.
|
[
-0.3041312993,
-0.8568797112,
0.2087710202,
-0.0699431449,
0.1604512483,
0.1295436621,
-0.1410662383,
-0.2654542923,
-0.3020016551,
0.4031626284,
-0.2734768689,
-0.3300436139,
-0.6965416074,
-0.1934022307,
-0.4944255948,
1.1097331047,
0.5588809848,
-0.0203005001,
0.2165959924,
0.0318825543,
-0.3810033202,
-0.7046856284,
-1.1095545292,
-0.104933016,
0.5329375267,
-0.0259196907,
1.0584193468,
0.6267328262,
0.1430252641,
0.4297271073,
-0.2923337221,
0.0494296551,
-0.1874982864,
0.5431023836,
0.0863508061,
-0.2973773181,
-0.3808328807,
-0.0999519601,
0.4052543938,
0.6185116172,
-0.0960204527,
-0.2135263979,
0.1297272444,
0.405261308,
-0.5982674956,
0.2848263979,
-0.7495195866,
-0.0174712576,
-0.1038603485,
0.0697716102,
-0.7425190806,
-0.4069511294,
0.1972374022,
-0.341265291,
0.1583402306,
0.1466950029,
0.592171967,
0.3048872054,
-0.4341688156,
-0.2376296669,
-0.5145619512,
0.5576988459,
-0.4392676055,
0.1763655543,
0.3815256357,
0.4547801912,
-0.6109377146,
-0.4013622999,
-0.3350382149,
-0.3856723607,
0.2343760431,
-0.1287694275,
-0.5411337018,
0.1493288279,
0.2408804595,
0.0096862288,
-0.7035855055,
0.1766394526,
-0.0608425699,
-0.4018614292,
0.5986813903,
0.1526125073,
0.465447396,
0.1500454843,
-0.1952602714,
-0.4867343307,
-0.6575043797,
0.1066662818,
0.7313958406,
0.4625513554,
0.1052256674,
0.1138589308,
-0.0809257627,
0.6812588573,
-0.0049022418,
-0.1260859221,
0.0283504259,
0.08422672,
0.0614794157,
0.2160384655,
1.1410565376,
0.0852247998,
0.2910243273,
-0.1782147884,
-0.3318270147,
0.3481374383,
0.3893733025,
-0.69922328,
-0.6332538724,
0.0658479854,
-0.2841693163,
-0.8522549272,
-0.1542233527,
-0.6860688925,
-0.8867768645,
0.2288334519,
0.2544105053,
-0.4320573807,
-0.1898901314,
0.0954311565,
-0.0376057848,
-0.1421222836,
0.221514836,
-0.7273456454,
0.2097900361,
0.4696178436,
0.5830988884,
0.2027573884,
-0.1409105808,
-0.8595557213,
-0.140403837,
-0.4307714105,
0.6690530777,
-0.2747704089,
-0.4019816518,
0.1322273314,
0.0986145735,
-0.2126398981,
-0.3489261568,
0.6942880154,
-0.6045441628,
0.2161763757,
0.0373743325,
-0.2374049127,
-0.1522329599,
0.1620152146,
-0.6993554831,
0.5427543521,
-0.1442287415,
-0.7353804708,
0.0290473457,
-0.4530504942,
-0.712084353,
-0.0559979901,
-0.0290146358,
-0.7539740801,
-0.1789020151,
0.2541815341,
0.3713451624,
-0.2156762779,
0.2479485124,
-0.7978124022,
-0.0442481339,
0.685346365,
-1.0209670067,
0.9917274714,
0.3308595121,
-0.2379447371,
0.1865444183,
-0.6436473727,
-0.0268654674,
0.2747252882,
-0.2885785997,
-0.2321442664,
0.0249467697,
0.0804830715,
0.2090563178,
-0.0265355762,
-0.4336913228,
-0.2567159534,
-0.2362751663,
0.4282241762,
0.9568841457,
-0.1518889517,
0.3834458888,
-0.3647870123,
0.57134372,
-0.2474672645,
0.3125059605,
-0.2107139826,
-0.3776213825,
-0.5640543699,
-0.3528644145,
0.3619668484,
0.6869398952,
-0.9066341519,
0.9494242668,
0.0239299331,
-0.5825407505,
-0.1669890583,
0.1082670614,
0.6173477173,
0.6256130934,
0.0750983357,
0.0192136243,
-0.417557776,
-0.5426020622,
-0.0215766449,
-0.5424983501,
-0.1741547137,
0.1191023961,
0.2846087813,
-0.1973319203,
0.607978642,
-0.4949053526,
0.0928314552,
-0.3507429361,
0.0851784572,
-0.2875585258,
0.4488286376,
0.617662847,
-0.7574951649,
-0.1104458347,
-0.2610540986,
-0.6887323856,
-0.2418409735,
0.0164518598,
-0.037741486,
0.1262108088,
0.51191926,
-0.5335248113,
0.1785053313,
0.4548063874,
-0.409897536,
0.5488957763,
0.0640481114,
-0.1863812059,
-1.1893185377,
0.0518271774,
-0.0025923848,
-0.3384667039,
-0.7572380304,
-0.3007206023,
-0.0960216373,
-0.4729115665,
-0.5296115875,
0.4169799089,
-0.0122167515,
0.2604464889,
-0.4629476964,
-0.0553309917,
-0.0175822098,
0.2711038589,
0.1023536399,
0.6765735745,
0.7481508851,
-0.6558231115,
0.5797286034,
0.3072460294,
-0.1765603721,
0.4848147035,
-0.7916606665,
0.0112663694,
-0.017604351,
0.6033600569,
-0.7598898411,
-0.4880868196,
0.3964272141,
-0.6391269565,
0.4599992633,
-0.3234860301,
-0.2969502807,
-0.3009623885,
-0.2708310187,
0.1436857283,
0.5433497429,
-0.7017858624,
0.3292155862,
0.8210319281,
-0.418915242,
-0.6930019855,
-0.412222147,
0.070275113,
-0.4051780701,
-0.6535696387,
-0.2844072282,
-0.1289943159,
-0.1177937835,
-0.2161201686,
-0.1566968262,
-0.1229081452,
0.6585527658,
0.4251500666,
0.3786070347,
-0.0466827378,
0.1504041851,
-0.3796233237,
-0.2637946606,
0.3703018725,
-0.1516140103,
0.6355042458,
-0.434374094,
-0.2303707749,
-0.4822227359,
0.3215604424,
0.680909574,
-0.1487645954,
0.7934374809,
0.5024784803,
-0.3983991742,
-0.3247520924,
-0.2043474913,
-0.2481600493,
-0.5567705631,
0.4088537693,
-0.1760822833,
-0.6698154807,
0.4471363723,
0.1008637846,
-0.0418509766,
0.2364940047,
0.1405334771,
0.0867119804,
1.447363019,
0.3949267268,
-0.4035775661,
0.8094779849,
0.0932732821,
0.1523056179,
-0.4004449844,
-0.2330788374,
-0.7333895564,
0.1694410294,
-0.4701510072,
0.1340987682,
0.4735617936,
-0.1489666253,
-0.5323435068,
0.3352868259,
-0.3293521106,
0.4789316952,
0.6202963591,
0.2336608171,
-0.221949324,
-0.0843366161,
0.233397752,
0.4136048853,
-0.8339683414,
-0.628739953,
0.9270212054,
0.5725531578,
1.2007708549,
0.1875938475,
0.3305306435,
0.3178555965,
0.0523048788,
-0.5990799069,
0.734344244,
-0.2537425756,
-0.3772586882,
-0.2647970021,
-0.704898715,
-0.9752303958,
0.1249861121,
-0.3662983477,
-0.5774067044,
-0.0182525162,
0.3069469333,
-0.5775285363,
0.3307385743,
-0.7201868892,
0.9500344396,
-0.2774161696,
-0.0597738102,
0.2868200243,
-0.8312659264,
0.4235302806,
-0.0808181167,
0.1593056321,
-0.0426688455,
0.3483722806,
0.7095938921,
-0.4011629224,
1.01994133,
-0.1268550754,
-0.0336919688,
0.2747209668,
0.1900414526,
0.663556993,
-0.0037314314,
0.0970354751,
-0.0779680386,
-0.3741877973,
-0.3981154859,
-0.4185120761,
0.5906182528,
-0.6434478164,
-0.5749158263,
-0.6937658787,
-0.6872189045,
-0.2576859891,
0.0694871396,
0.2814899385,
0.5261226892,
-0.2435272485,
0.2835972011,
1.0716384649,
-0.4432654083,
0.5984085202,
0.4159153104,
0.2099733949,
-0.6007410884,
1.000962615,
-0.1098049805,
0.3344930708,
-0.0627082884,
0.1720468551,
-0.4752776325,
-0.4705489576,
-0.6027114987,
-0.3367045224,
-0.6124369502,
-0.4169343412,
-0.5658122897,
-0.4733077884,
-0.5314848423,
-0.1983292103,
-0.3866123259,
-0.3289895654,
-0.0085276226,
-0.0126834828,
0.3057539761,
0.5896902084,
0.1085838601,
0.3819643855,
-0.7204376459,
0.0521869175,
0.4557146132,
0.0231290627,
-0.2140372992,
-0.364910841,
0.0287298914,
0.0302340034,
-0.3170942962,
-0.7119198442,
0.3093181252,
0.0076776217,
0.5917466879,
0.4760662615,
0.7018838525,
0.1148902848,
-0.3894897997,
0.6765760779,
0.3385108411,
-0.7485916018,
0.6077111363,
-0.5545811057,
0.1549721956,
0.404304266,
0.046646446,
-0.3716709018,
-0.6134123206,
-0.63770926,
-0.8091279268,
0.5602847934,
0.153266117,
-0.0710885376,
-0.1727905273,
-0.2346750945,
-0.0604126602,
0.1579352021,
-0.6558722854,
-0.0731460527,
-0.1879513711,
-0.4947708249,
-0.1136109605,
-0.0487044156,
-0.4093595445,
0.5104934573,
0.8356286287,
-0.2634394765,
0.014414344,
-0.208018586,
-0.0118589718,
0.1444152594,
0.5226062536,
0.3889394104,
-0.1155954227,
0.0847314969,
0.4364695847,
0.1553564966,
-0.5421022773,
0.3033462167,
0.5668494701,
-0.3266254365,
-0.2815892398,
0.4066338241,
0.6466364861,
-0.0762369633,
-0.8132059574,
0.6718583107,
-0.4016591907,
0.2072981894,
-0.2991881371,
0.3132763505,
-0.4431658089,
0.1645270735,
0.1261621863,
0.52479285,
0.1814093292,
-0.3715469241,
0.2573212087,
0.7684956789,
-0.3328813612,
-0.1897384524,
0.7357144356,
0.4014832973,
-0.1445905268,
0.2003450692,
-0.2155106515,
-0.8767626286,
0.6429257989,
0.4365872145,
1.0259625912,
-0.5908641815,
0.244331196,
0.0072380221,
0.3877770603,
-0.2949063778,
-0.1402368546,
0.1318431199,
-0.5893244147,
0.1128210053,
-0.4663038254,
-0.4711397886,
0.2098070383,
-0.5368198752,
-0.0805783197,
-0.5565596223,
-0.1938812882,
0.0521859638,
-0.1520509422,
-0.2114747614,
0.3140595853,
0.3255325854,
0.6374416947,
-1.0360484123,
0.6680945158,
0.659833014,
-0.1651861817,
-0.6261171699,
0.1130281761,
0.2862184048,
-0.5423502326,
0.2316379994,
0.3627524376,
-0.3900460005,
-0.5350670815,
-0.3495263755,
-0.5198584795,
0.6710546017,
0.6432948112,
-0.3538280427,
0.2037466764,
-0.11972408,
0.431538254,
-0.1461216658,
0.0472882129,
0.3234086931,
0.0636465326,
0.061695274,
-0.9134213924,
0.1652307212,
-0.4000579715,
-0.0813240856,
0.1104528457,
-0.6460163593,
0.6681193113,
-0.1473935843,
-0.2501892745,
0.3212352395,
0.4812476337,
0.2097698897,
0.4905686677,
0.8552861214,
0.4730801284,
0.9310857654,
-0.3548948765,
1.0460343361,
-0.2632598579,
-0.1443671882,
1.0771054029,
-0.1914889216,
0.6176379919,
-0.1787883341,
0.2025667131,
0.1329510659,
0.6309725046,
0.1115780324,
0.5548186302,
0.0806257427,
-0.7801206708,
-0.4432470798,
-0.3197413087,
-0.4592402875,
0.2831242979,
0.3502588272,
-0.4160516858,
-0.0383349396,
0.3378373981,
0.3368902504,
0.0665210262,
-0.3522598445,
0.7997508049,
-0.110861823,
-0.5907816887,
0.5196513534,
-0.2674795389,
0.4007974267,
-0.6752222776,
0.2717038393,
0.0846309736,
0.5755389333,
0.0589815453,
-0.7132814527,
0.064105317,
0.1257419884,
0.0012123033,
-0.072113879,
0.8718124628,
-0.4851100147,
-0.202175498,
0.1476821005,
0.0153922951,
-0.0462338291,
0.0727487803,
-0.6646144986,
0.1878097802,
-0.2788438499,
-0.2294329107,
0.486259073,
0.2409851104,
0.0067908997,
1.0451359749,
0.6825413704,
-0.0717057511,
-0.041990824,
-0.0479715466,
1.0607687235,
-0.3034847975,
-0.6875135899,
-0.7128947377,
0.2663829327,
-0.2607655823,
-0.1580165625,
0.7301383018,
0.4336153865,
0.6344136596,
0.1167975068,
1.1728233099,
0.0162595361,
0.2854634523,
-0.4040192962,
0.9690600038,
0.0063302387,
0.4657614231,
-0.1666265577,
-0.3882345259,
-0.4300768673,
0.5880875587,
-0.3116582334,
0.0666751042,
0.3673025072,
0.9481403232,
0.24158144,
0.2397177666,
0.3005566001,
0.1429344565,
0.5866292715,
0.6018009186,
1.01730299,
-0.3965123892,
1.0901700258,
-0.1756967157,
-0.4146530628,
-0.1135684848,
-0.6502619982,
-1.2611265182,
-0.2450146675,
-0.4764347076,
-0.9024624228,
0.5354940295,
0.880948782,
0.8374781609,
-0.9331345558,
0.2132111937,
-0.1885524988,
0.1650848985,
-0.1093248129,
-0.2398393601,
0.4008876085,
-0.4496074617,
-0.6830598116,
0.847540319,
-0.0839363113,
0.4005429745,
-0.1243432388,
-0.0519528538,
0.4299983978,
0.0458425358,
0.3905939162,
0.6749257445,
-0.4915563464,
-0.4032541215,
-0.1964444667,
-0.2787089944,
-0.5314176083,
0.353254199,
-0.505345583,
0.4716307819,
0.3803160191,
0.8867907524,
-0.3391483128,
-0.1276989579,
0.7134644985,
-0.7231705785,
0.2120781392,
0.2454544008,
0.4935174286,
0.3921443224,
-0.3884512782,
0.3431614339,
0.1302903295,
-0.7613683343,
-1.0536839962,
0.5469918251,
-0.8908389807,
-0.3103527129,
1.2116222382,
-0.4563346803,
-0.3167974949,
-0.3572480679,
-0.4065547287,
0.2077915519,
-0.6800151467,
0.9432625771,
0.4483294189,
0.1494085044,
0.0340741985,
-0.2864682674,
0.7067140937,
0.2104444355,
-0.8168945312,
0.4336928427,
0.6370600462,
0.1942784041,
0.245075345,
0.1095968112,
0.0432967022,
0.5522301793,
0.3562036455,
-0.1046912074,
-0.1991548538,
-0.5415835381,
-0.6308287978,
0.4466896057,
-0.0190499071,
-0.5432890654
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00161v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00161v1
|
Beyond Denouncing Hate: Strategies for Countering Implied Biases and Stereotypes in Language
| 2023-10-31T21:33:46 | 2023-10-31T21:33:46 |
Jimin Mun, Emily Allaway, Akhila Yerukola, Laura Vianna, Sarah-Jane Leslie, Maarten Sap
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Counterspeech, i.e., responses to counteract potential harms of hateful
speech, has become an increasingly popular solution to address online hate
speech without censorship. However, properly countering hateful language
requires countering and dispelling the underlying inaccurate stereotypes
implied by such language. In this work, we draw from psychology and philosophy
literature to craft six psychologically inspired strategies to challenge the
underlying stereotypical implications of hateful language. We first examine the
convincingness of each of these strategies through a user study, and then
compare their usages in both human- and machine-generated counterspeech
datasets. Our results show that human-written counterspeech uses countering
strategies that are more specific to the implied stereotype (e.g., counter
examples to the stereotype, external factors about the stereotype's origins),
whereas machine-generated counterspeech uses less specific strategies (e.g.,
generally denouncing the hatefulness of speech). Furthermore, machine-generated
counterspeech often employs strategies that humans deem less convincing
compared to human-produced counterspeech. Our findings point to the importance
of accounting for the underlying stereotypical implications of speech when
generating counterspeech and for better machine reasoning about
anti-stereotypical examples.
|
[
-0.8925561905,
-0.8633215427,
0.42709589,
0.2218190879,
-0.3338684738,
0.3516350985,
-0.2142724991,
-0.2358053476,
0.4522414804,
0.5093378425,
-0.6544997096,
-0.0841092691,
-0.6309509873,
0.3488642275,
-0.3083910048,
0.9602241516,
0.0505869575,
0.1819790453,
-0.2555068433,
-0.2162641138,
-0.3577304184,
-0.9374859333,
-0.3968334198,
-0.5854535103,
0.508585155,
0.4541030526,
0.806558609,
0.2457064539,
0.0520910211,
0.2304694057,
0.4063078761,
-0.0450488105,
-0.5953101516,
0.3471459746,
-0.2640579641,
-0.4623570144,
0.2573421896,
0.3673831522,
0.2856462002,
0.3636394441,
-0.0852337703,
0.0204088986,
-0.1143184826,
0.4616946578,
-0.5046163201,
-0.1591150761,
-0.7760854959,
0.2160383463,
-0.5961148143,
0.1262975335,
-0.535089016,
-0.3858493268,
-0.2330888808,
-0.5614798665,
0.2962130904,
-0.0474719517,
0.5732572675,
0.1722607017,
-0.2225597799,
-0.5734546185,
-0.5991194844,
1.0065097809,
-0.8336984515,
0.3932070434,
0.5145435929,
0.157047376,
-0.0849555582,
-0.1930201054,
-0.8682084084,
-0.2650634348,
-0.2172074765,
0.3134087026,
-0.5551272035,
0.0361119062,
0.7502543926,
-0.2314878404,
-0.6001710892,
0.2176892757,
-0.2510354817,
-0.2922211587,
0.5189116597,
0.0466835424,
0.4830720127,
-0.136303097,
-0.3204987645,
-0.0618254133,
-0.6681556106,
-0.1782706082,
0.7545825243,
0.2013552785,
0.206801042,
0.4081098139,
-0.1213242263,
0.4213600457,
0.1583601981,
-0.0978616104,
0.1774223596,
0.3017071784,
0.1059221327,
0.3627513349,
0.5229298472,
0.6054285169,
0.7928478718,
-0.1387114376,
0.0519984327,
0.9207397699,
0.6630334854,
-0.6092622876,
-0.17909576,
0.098384656,
-0.212238282,
-0.3405405581,
-0.3225849271,
-1.1122196913,
-0.7088979483,
-0.155875653,
0.2172004879,
-0.4689433575,
-0.3052505553,
-0.265686214,
-0.7042092085,
0.0421640612,
0.0201702807,
-0.9697084427,
0.6926710606,
0.5920953751,
0.664078474,
0.1790485531,
-0.0466589183,
-0.3816273212,
-0.0742934942,
-0.6763538718,
0.6998553276,
-0.773622334,
-0.6019518971,
0.0026195629,
-0.4703114033,
0.2578525841,
-0.5745681524,
0.5094355941,
-0.21317105,
0.4410142601,
-0.6252747774,
-0.438053757,
-0.0952758417,
0.3208625615,
-0.5528303981,
0.9042410851,
-0.0846190602,
-0.7790774107,
0.3958221972,
-0.4730224609,
-0.6035254598,
-0.1192499697,
-0.4796483219,
-0.4763474464,
0.2876150608,
0.0066889487,
-0.0377012789,
-0.2194191813,
-0.1732990593,
-0.3442188799,
-0.1740281731,
0.1885915697,
-0.1708574295,
0.929064393,
0.5709661245,
-0.8035143018,
-0.2244251221,
-0.44845891,
-0.0773448125,
0.3301173747,
0.1431374103,
-0.8881245255,
0.0530078821,
-0.2712030113,
0.1740749776,
-0.3634833694,
-0.8045396805,
-0.2128247917,
-0.529915154,
0.2147749066,
0.8961951137,
-0.2192691863,
0.2411447763,
-0.4059055448,
0.7114994526,
-0.2170112878,
0.0522854254,
0.3092608154,
-0.6188472509,
-0.3903475106,
-0.3376463652,
-0.3967654407,
0.5246062279,
-0.6923135519,
-0.1084275544,
0.2430879921,
-0.7284474969,
-0.5310112238,
0.1574253291,
0.7566429973,
0.8744022846,
0.6016235352,
-0.5366577506,
-1.2632911205,
-1.0942782164,
-0.7787516713,
-0.4976761341,
0.1150571555,
-0.0554786697,
0.2610084116,
-0.0462020338,
1.0077742338,
-0.4221162498,
0.194220677,
-0.1769044101,
0.560374558,
-0.0094858492,
0.1914041042,
0.7873447537,
-0.6397173405,
-0.6207944751,
-0.6024606228,
-0.6192619205,
-0.5997379422,
-0.168025285,
0.0259170327,
0.2166108787,
0.4198706448,
-0.6314954162,
0.4269165993,
0.2923927605,
-0.2498745173,
0.9089442492,
0.542732656,
0.3117512167,
-0.8035567999,
-0.3130843639,
-0.0479130819,
-0.0401843823,
-0.8978301883,
0.2246264964,
-0.5325703621,
-0.0746747702,
-0.375636071,
0.6056271195,
-0.1877477616,
0.3412897289,
-0.1960169971,
0.0644320771,
0.0907495394,
0.0235293135,
0.4036229849,
0.5296868682,
0.2697547376,
-0.3854289055,
0.4667113125,
0.118214637,
-0.2076421529,
0.851978898,
-0.4620438814,
0.1772111058,
-0.3496667743,
0.4154272974,
-0.9879287481,
0.4009790719,
0.4853409827,
-0.5011898875,
-0.1864143908,
-0.3150028288,
-0.3638437092,
-0.4848588705,
-0.3313750625,
0.3045819998,
0.7866087556,
-0.4760015905,
0.6614591479,
0.241649732,
-0.0946417227,
-0.6338510513,
-0.9384931326,
0.3634050786,
-0.5509672761,
-0.0849645361,
0.3159653246,
-0.1921210736,
-1.1099460125,
-0.435313046,
0.0184557531,
0.1797617078,
-0.1053956002,
0.3602609932,
-0.0317106731,
0.0982674211,
0.2347659469,
-0.1869377047,
-0.0232032668,
0.3367907703,
-0.2726405859,
0.7195380926,
0.0704366565,
-0.2065368891,
0.1151228473,
0.5432683825,
0.3985053599,
0.3186382353,
0.703964591,
0.7378976941,
-0.2358634174,
-0.2461386472,
-0.8606212139,
-0.5658398271,
-0.4188132286,
0.1495734006,
-0.359618932,
-0.4383858144,
0.2782803774,
0.1308682561,
0.2051274776,
0.2737620175,
0.6205165386,
-0.3468606174,
0.9978173375,
0.1410455853,
0.019178791,
0.4108236134,
0.3642596602,
0.5195043087,
-0.2344751656,
0.1421630681,
-0.759059906,
-0.152886793,
-0.6195923686,
-0.4534157217,
0.141160965,
-0.1860097945,
-0.4470920861,
0.5328550339,
-0.5233752728,
0.2419199795,
0.4790816605,
-0.2372176051,
0.0455374271,
0.334308207,
-0.4429523945,
-0.6860980392,
-0.6807925701,
-0.4395968318,
0.7845355272,
0.2218692452,
0.5659219623,
0.1971453875,
0.7090531588,
0.455524683,
0.5488769412,
-0.5371560454,
0.6531308889,
-0.177378729,
-0.950448513,
-0.2028426081,
-0.3431373537,
-0.4952563047,
0.2578911185,
-0.1991937757,
-0.5999845862,
0.0420032181,
0.5348665714,
0.0875667036,
0.5664591789,
-0.7471007705,
0.6183646321,
-0.181874007,
-0.2366155386,
-0.5906451941,
-0.4003890157,
0.3391364217,
0.100046657,
0.6925171018,
0.0775359794,
0.1785851866,
0.8361949325,
-0.3069780767,
1.1635836363,
-0.2075264156,
-0.1851801127,
0.4292264879,
0.3813617527,
0.4010017812,
-0.4777274132,
-0.2720759809,
0.3246867061,
-0.0835235566,
-0.6668774486,
-0.5824612975,
0.4535629749,
-0.5231743455,
-0.7416820526,
-0.3499074578,
-0.2748466134,
-0.4869315028,
0.1349655986,
0.423099041,
0.2567577958,
-0.6570959687,
-0.4290615022,
0.7812011838,
-0.3706600964,
0.079152599,
0.4920468926,
-0.3149145842,
-0.3744527996,
1.0297346115,
0.1134165004,
0.4007216692,
0.2590673268,
0.6088967919,
-0.4768771529,
-0.0259585474,
-0.4152684212,
0.105185993,
-0.6942104697,
0.1247724369,
-0.6246590614,
0.1933009028,
-1.0187764168,
-0.4520382583,
-0.3620310724,
-0.3880046904,
0.1746792793,
-0.1143190116,
0.6650511026,
0.7030873895,
-0.6957058907,
0.2364928126,
-0.1977334768,
0.6507273316,
0.5124640465,
0.1386986524,
0.1558947116,
-0.5046256185,
0.2281600386,
-0.0064759622,
0.1860249639,
-1.2042479515,
0.2744395137,
-0.3671021163,
0.5985691547,
0.526833117,
0.2891517878,
0.704672873,
-0.6928361654,
0.5900118351,
0.5920493007,
-0.7709577084,
0.476577431,
-0.0951588526,
0.2091699094,
0.3851895928,
0.8178414106,
-1.1524940729,
-0.7428902388,
-0.7548263669,
-0.6223688722,
0.1409509182,
0.0946221724,
0.3071208596,
-0.5312898159,
-0.0826493651,
0.1139024049,
0.3389077187,
-0.6874024272,
-0.102406919,
-0.9940193295,
-0.0835559517,
-0.0342217796,
-0.2666497231,
-0.5794555545,
-0.0340089612,
0.7474762797,
0.1600327641,
-0.1428672671,
0.1253058314,
-0.242196843,
-0.0516556613,
0.4362354875,
0.6305773854,
0.329952091,
0.0207649339,
0.5853323936,
0.2479578555,
-0.4739437103,
0.085101679,
0.0424028635,
-0.4665148556,
0.2202685028,
0.3952612579,
0.4210633934,
-0.1534456462,
-0.6805574894,
0.0271556284,
0.249903053,
-0.121723108,
-0.3901751339,
-0.141002357,
0.1040527523,
-0.1099738032,
0.0689091682,
-0.0447688885,
-0.0625247508,
-0.7475970387,
0.1951438934,
0.595500648,
-0.5593321919,
-0.0742448494,
0.3249770403,
0.0717368722,
-0.4112744033,
0.4999796152,
-0.0844890401,
-0.863303721,
0.4384062886,
0.6228650808,
0.5805926919,
-0.3961093426,
0.5807214379,
0.492846787,
0.5149581432,
0.3383927047,
-0.126717329,
-0.0344218351,
-0.9317133427,
-0.0246029627,
-0.5943824053,
-0.3267597854,
0.0566268526,
-0.3231647909,
-0.0713371858,
-0.8954905868,
-0.19511199,
-0.0362567157,
-0.0915845335,
-0.3557168245,
0.2042202204,
0.3703519106,
0.8321861029,
-1.0698711872,
0.1754759401,
0.6403950453,
-0.6320316792,
-0.2767368555,
-0.015536339,
0.7001301646,
-1.045781374,
0.6065773964,
-0.054167632,
-0.7055171728,
-0.1721885651,
-0.6611561179,
-0.3157819808,
-0.0582332537,
-0.035371609,
-0.6945272088,
0.3577240705,
0.4000456035,
0.7117635608,
-0.3138255477,
0.3379710615,
0.5709146261,
0.6177073717,
-0.2790373564,
-0.635109365,
0.3388897479,
-0.0668146834,
-0.2335088998,
-0.1187967584,
-0.4986570179,
0.5495095849,
-0.1642960757,
-0.2974960804,
-0.2416158915,
0.2317855358,
0.2997302711,
0.1009773016,
0.9054348469,
0.8546997309,
0.3838780522,
0.3012624979,
0.8471823335,
0.27765885,
-0.3665707409,
0.9387145042,
-0.3359081745,
0.3992864788,
0.5442490578,
-0.1600448638,
0.8766279221,
0.1344303936,
-0.0239824541,
0.2470769882,
0.6826289296,
-0.4854717851,
-0.3818133175,
-0.4007868767,
-0.2237232476,
0.4819462895,
0.4355454147,
-0.1140124425,
-0.4640417993,
0.1078446135,
0.3982698023,
0.9634438753,
-0.0728610754,
0.6653632522,
0.0763851106,
-0.6509316564,
0.5948198438,
-0.0655508861,
0.6651928425,
-0.4424776137,
-0.0713103637,
-0.2328233421,
-0.1067571267,
-0.1215225756,
-0.5463255644,
0.4064439833,
0.2231608182,
-0.3931101859,
-0.4401463568,
0.8042289019,
-0.2838937044,
-0.3519896269,
0.2310427576,
0.2462488413,
0.3476704657,
0.0162302461,
-0.6940517426,
0.1952637285,
-0.0088026151,
0.1447509974,
0.3634626567,
0.0086431419,
-0.2236700058,
0.6535302401,
0.6607605815,
0.4390730262,
-0.1499572247,
0.5561956167,
0.6488455534,
-0.6271698475,
-0.5213762522,
-0.9570348263,
0.2302021086,
-0.2751534581,
-0.1954734474,
0.7564899921,
0.3550816774,
0.918847084,
-0.043929249,
1.0469229221,
-0.1792471707,
1.0462447405,
-0.2311416119,
0.5389462113,
-0.320037961,
-0.0343914665,
-0.6240756512,
-0.5896545053,
-0.1631554961,
0.6715009212,
-0.680280149,
-0.0593829416,
0.3914337158,
0.9123860598,
0.235286057,
0.0602504723,
0.4139587283,
0.5990200639,
0.4533258677,
0.1852800846,
1.0440849066,
-0.1079732478,
0.7359338999,
-0.2069921643,
-0.2959512472,
0.1113606021,
-0.8224233389,
-0.9517259598,
-0.4130160511,
-0.2144146711,
-0.7057911754,
0.2576808035,
0.7952299118,
0.5333332419,
-0.8310291171,
-0.3307479322,
0.0782609582,
0.4289944172,
-0.3757959902,
-0.2907014787,
-0.3343401253,
-0.3073768616,
-0.6300454736,
0.2270964086,
0.1087142006,
-0.2628456652,
-0.2903520167,
-0.0307222232,
-0.1909814924,
0.5021483302,
0.840688169,
0.6967878342,
-0.9876340628,
-0.321680665,
-0.2580385804,
-0.0074556298,
-0.2269815207,
1.116225481,
-0.9174922109,
0.7219459414,
0.5233194828,
0.2785732746,
0.0413856916,
0.0876773819,
0.8266000748,
-0.7387577891,
0.1861295104,
0.4975607693,
0.003632657,
0.3380167782,
-0.2342725694,
0.2638670802,
0.6123070121,
0.0976059809,
-0.8550698161,
0.830193758,
-0.3426440954,
-0.6518002748,
0.8528582454,
0.2796346843,
0.1255904883,
-0.4933002591,
-0.0915109888,
0.2675159872,
-0.3329316378,
1.1840677261,
0.9212810993,
-0.1510461718,
-0.2809610665,
-0.2523681521,
0.8072985411,
0.6929782033,
-0.463101089,
0.2515732646,
0.478823185,
0.3252240717,
0.3835558593,
0.6637368202,
-0.1615428478,
0.2460696697,
0.4408875704,
0.2843706012,
0.2720756829,
-0.1106162518,
0.2619162798,
-0.1116051003,
-0.0630675331,
0.2742543221
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00159v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00159v1
|
Longer Fixations, More Computation: Gaze-Guided Recurrent Neural Networks
| 2023-10-31T21:32:11 | 2023-10-31T21:32:11 |
Xinting Huang, Jiajing Wan, Ioannis Kritikos, Nora Hollenstein
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Humans read texts at a varying pace, while machine learning models treat each
token in the same way in terms of a computational process. Therefore, we ask,
does it help to make models act more like humans? In this paper, we convert
this intuition into a set of novel models with fixation-guided parallel RNNs or
layers and conduct various experiments on language modeling and sentiment
analysis tasks to test their effectiveness, thus providing empirical validation
for this intuition. Our proposed models achieve good performance on the
language modeling task, considerably surpassing the baseline model. In
addition, we find that, interestingly, the fixation duration predicted by
neural networks bears some resemblance to humans' fixation. Without any
explicit guidance, the model makes similar choices to humans. We also
investigate the reasons for the differences between them, which explain why
"model fixations" are often more suitable than human fixations, when used to
guide language models.
|
[
-0.1972100884,
-0.5600193739,
0.851736784,
0.3641227782,
-0.2602149546,
-0.0552700534,
-0.3817026019,
-0.4920119345,
0.2874536216,
0.5155447721,
-0.5454314351,
-0.1539836228,
-0.3356437683,
0.4579893053,
-0.4391195774,
0.7250834703,
0.087012507,
0.2755574286,
-0.4060845077,
-0.1535192579,
-0.2227756083,
-0.4320043623,
-0.511536479,
-0.6660698652,
0.9619309902,
0.0041706734,
0.8679534793,
0.673247993,
0.6515446305,
0.3110598624,
-0.2473126948,
-0.0020822722,
-0.089236334,
-0.0765062422,
0.1036901474,
-0.9622870088,
-0.1026396081,
0.2460967302,
0.3564617038,
0.8235806823,
-0.0681068152,
0.2090547979,
0.0049100192,
1.1163108349,
-0.2374103218,
0.1401426494,
-0.2389963567,
0.1010508537,
0.0050766589,
0.0929718018,
-0.5358222127,
-0.5736985803,
0.5727907419,
-0.4029753804,
0.4241548777,
0.1958678067,
0.9719517231,
0.3901808262,
-0.049022004,
0.2246671319,
-0.5015700459,
0.9345865846,
-1.0527102947,
0.3134947121,
0.1239608601,
-0.0931661129,
-0.1052742973,
-0.5469358563,
-0.4456964135,
-0.6696538329,
-0.208613202,
-0.1995997578,
0.1750749201,
0.1294211596,
0.60812819,
0.1470004022,
-0.6438010931,
-0.1492031068,
-0.3126434982,
0.1729224026,
0.3573178053,
0.1119719297,
0.4730074406,
-0.1752485633,
-0.497163415,
0.1257708967,
-0.4302483797,
0.2532070577,
0.1764494926,
0.368801564,
0.073066555,
0.4606361389,
-0.3081572652,
1.2143064737,
0.0691174865,
0.1453692466,
0.205979526,
0.1018331647,
-0.3630542755,
-0.1499593258,
0.7413966656,
0.5856012702,
0.6958511472,
-0.3522801995,
-0.0604494847,
0.5243974924,
0.6007649899,
-0.8760120869,
-0.3674774468,
-0.0478699766,
-0.7838459611,
-0.7268115878,
-0.2023312449,
-0.4755190909,
-0.476269573,
-0.9787433147,
0.0696396381,
-0.2844850719,
-0.2991061211,
0.5204997063,
-0.0862983689,
0.1494358629,
0.2262988687,
-0.9218510985,
0.3737392426,
0.7925576568,
1.0367443562,
-0.4233114123,
-0.5570380688,
-0.0137968119,
-0.5733972788,
-0.5374904871,
0.8669542074,
-0.5946461558,
0.2052512318,
-0.290530473,
0.0434846841,
-0.3464666009,
-0.4183218479,
0.1511988193,
-0.8236786723,
0.3303691745,
-0.4443997443,
-0.4496166706,
-0.5704516768,
0.4289132059,
-0.8419758081,
0.9259877205,
-0.0140923951,
-0.7529157996,
0.1493714303,
-0.8414328098,
-0.4004499912,
-0.2935946286,
-0.0055848155,
-0.3822267652,
0.3492399156,
0.0831493288,
0.5314413905,
-0.4926466048,
0.2722674906,
-0.4186478555,
-0.3172333837,
0.608123064,
-0.1359237134,
0.7321046591,
0.0885348618,
-0.531869173,
0.123417452,
-0.3845973909,
-0.0392166674,
0.0103808474,
-0.3804777563,
-0.3783093393,
0.2799428701,
-0.0386040546,
0.3153409064,
0.0330729298,
-0.6916548014,
0.1195447892,
-0.7562048435,
0.7536866665,
0.4995495677,
-0.258141011,
0.3831106424,
-0.5605127811,
0.3552357554,
0.17585361,
0.0072734342,
-0.287433356,
-0.6754705906,
-1.0012127161,
0.2740885615,
0.4061087668,
0.6495591998,
-0.4900905192,
-0.1665508598,
-0.3044588864,
-0.2814295292,
-0.5317409039,
0.0293283295,
0.4841144681,
0.5976827145,
0.1374593675,
-0.5512374043,
-0.5670174956,
-0.9519874454,
-0.6312348843,
-0.0611810982,
0.027495021,
0.2839645147,
0.3580246866,
-0.2038384825,
1.0493633747,
-0.3480776846,
0.3229676485,
-0.0047273282,
0.313347429,
0.3283034265,
0.2266621739,
0.5630148053,
-0.9415577054,
-0.4454156458,
-0.0500453599,
-0.8436748385,
0.2303990871,
-0.4015959799,
0.0593821853,
0.0270929001,
0.5693913102,
-0.5469039083,
0.2656927705,
0.2693564594,
-0.1864365339,
0.5755773187,
0.0846366808,
0.0938296542,
-1.0535492897,
0.0685279444,
0.5473725796,
-0.4861852229,
-0.8156282902,
0.0753049776,
0.051820334,
-0.1071135923,
-0.3112330437,
0.310246706,
-0.5591215491,
-0.1552265584,
-0.3908387125,
0.389175117,
0.0661669746,
0.6066946983,
0.0462476462,
0.6630592346,
0.4464742541,
-0.564289093,
0.5278609395,
0.0057030325,
-0.6920005679,
-0.0267143492,
-0.9919086695,
0.2182231694,
-0.1538255066,
-0.1165551767,
-0.841468215,
-0.2154691368,
-0.1265549064,
-0.5201703906,
0.1780617386,
0.0053016017,
-0.3423745632,
-0.4721450806,
-0.2448278368,
0.3428842127,
0.4548719525,
-0.5650237799,
0.6740165949,
0.1395538449,
-0.155275479,
-0.6121268272,
-0.8970585465,
0.2090013176,
-0.1099136844,
-0.6877233386,
0.2418367416,
0.0260757059,
-0.4145497978,
0.0284869391,
0.2792482376,
-0.0402647592,
0.2337460965,
0.4145713747,
0.4796386063,
-0.475841254,
0.0515922271,
-0.4983171225,
-0.1155173704,
0.1685258895,
-0.3899012804,
0.4337485433,
-0.4569329321,
-0.191439271,
-0.6974613667,
0.150289759,
0.8693289161,
-0.192442283,
0.6396203637,
0.3173413575,
-0.2869967222,
0.0394024849,
-0.7116153836,
-0.3543482721,
-0.4592962563,
0.2703971565,
-0.2095436156,
-0.9634120464,
0.3278255463,
-0.1911505312,
0.0532531068,
0.0871654898,
0.659234941,
-0.1530734748,
1.1383247375,
0.7633466125,
-0.5154455304,
0.7583748698,
-0.0035759336,
0.1036153436,
-0.8277388811,
0.0572640561,
-0.2327511907,
-0.5905914903,
-0.3744482398,
-0.522372663,
-0.1777924746,
-0.0613416582,
-0.0545858964,
0.3346234262,
-0.7034554482,
0.5793453455,
0.4177128077,
0.1508892775,
-0.2513761818,
-0.0159156863,
-0.3478861153,
-0.1009329781,
-0.6188651919,
-0.4960466027,
0.7952134013,
0.3397576213,
0.577801764,
-0.3989466727,
0.3569287956,
0.2678483129,
0.6960662007,
-0.8552455306,
0.5924748778,
-0.2717125416,
-0.6040572524,
-0.1948602796,
-0.2349950373,
-0.7037519813,
0.1286303103,
-0.0704391599,
-0.565684855,
0.2430990189,
0.2526445985,
-0.4755419195,
0.3515429795,
-0.6634843349,
0.7544030547,
-0.2615346611,
-0.2247447073,
-0.1557161361,
-0.704018712,
0.1579724103,
0.2745615244,
-0.0695920289,
-0.1437299699,
-0.0505468287,
0.6238892078,
-0.2395232916,
1.1444592476,
-0.1388496608,
0.3878462911,
0.4112673104,
-0.0346964002,
0.5298473835,
-0.4302043915,
-0.2536412477,
0.0467924774,
-0.2758041918,
-0.4605779648,
-0.8414499164,
0.6181703806,
-0.5354493856,
-0.5243017077,
-0.1938586235,
-0.4945669472,
-0.1219378561,
0.1862297207,
-0.0619817302,
0.4637465179,
-0.1086311415,
0.0993169248,
0.7287679911,
0.2504778206,
0.4748618305,
0.4176576138,
-0.4809948802,
-0.2509396076,
0.7096292377,
-0.2189563364,
0.2603895664,
0.4682009518,
0.1843609363,
-0.0819595978,
-0.4261361361,
-0.6582613587,
0.4505176544,
-0.3043424487,
0.1931455731,
-0.4064115584,
0.1171489358,
-0.1877576113,
-0.1209996641,
-0.3735817969,
-0.5072489381,
-0.3757205307,
-0.1553139091,
0.5536065698,
0.8824056983,
0.3462582827,
0.1773754507,
-0.7565455437,
0.4157112539,
0.4221778512,
0.4932682812,
0.2119509727,
-0.3725253046,
-0.3998120427,
0.1245415136,
0.1137760133,
-0.9521279931,
0.4635177553,
-0.0595524311,
0.1786362678,
0.3755619824,
-0.3422816396,
0.5838437676,
-0.7593718767,
0.8217999935,
0.3417065144,
-0.6856703162,
0.2943899632,
-0.5421742201,
0.1940770596,
0.5214807391,
0.3422399163,
-0.785800159,
0.0276165772,
-0.1597525626,
-0.401542902,
0.7506007552,
0.0206044149,
0.1221309677,
0.1069322601,
0.977345407,
-0.2523815632,
0.1709661633,
-0.7524077892,
-0.3896611035,
-0.0759800225,
-0.1550939381,
-0.167991966,
-0.3653184474,
0.0263708122,
-0.1601017118,
0.4651615918,
-0.1897018552,
0.3244460225,
0.4218646288,
-0.1380860358,
-0.0956405476,
0.0288680308,
0.7535571456,
0.397434473,
-0.0686627701,
-0.0999580771,
0.2747315466,
-0.4761447906,
0.0271964557,
-0.1194860265,
-0.4096732736,
0.1720034778,
0.1872768402,
1.1817567348,
0.4744714797,
-0.3687466383,
0.3506785631,
-0.2110617459,
-0.1561082006,
-0.1283126175,
0.0071801441,
0.5963029861,
0.3762782216,
-0.1359451413,
0.7291432023,
-0.0082189068,
-0.2664070129,
0.1153498143,
0.1781606227,
-0.8362854123,
-0.4565854669,
0.5901927352,
0.1732496619,
-0.8638100624,
0.4277796447,
-0.0231937598,
-0.8432393074,
0.723911345,
0.4279973209,
1.2168459892,
-0.1332817227,
0.1429624408,
0.3573584855,
0.1701661497,
-0.7616339326,
0.3542391658,
-0.1524355114,
-0.765717566,
-0.7787129283,
-0.72859025,
-0.4116248786,
-0.1862868816,
-0.9452885389,
0.0662067235,
-0.3477217555,
-0.4630627334,
0.2824271917,
-0.2718243301,
-0.3795723617,
0.4199317098,
0.1938480139,
0.9198554158,
-0.7960876226,
0.8726097345,
0.8967832327,
-0.2393550426,
-0.7865960002,
-0.05403357,
-0.2105504572,
-0.4666212797,
0.6437410712,
0.6100364923,
-0.3303614855,
-0.1152990535,
-0.5816476345,
-0.804069221,
0.8308724165,
0.2078560591,
-0.9121410251,
-0.3377476931,
0.0976385325,
0.8845797777,
-0.5877310038,
0.0395983718,
0.6903367043,
0.3022658527,
-0.4452091157,
-0.6579794884,
-0.0638311803,
-0.6207564473,
0.312119633,
0.2656391561,
-0.6703463793,
1.0281099081,
-0.4272777438,
0.0420091636,
0.2603133321,
0.6327883005,
-0.0812830031,
0.3389598727,
0.6488316059,
0.7157594562,
0.4722537696,
0.0153381946,
1.2710806131,
-0.4386821687,
0.2946142256,
1.1235527992,
-0.0325749926,
0.9590933323,
0.4048570693,
-0.3588886261,
1.0202875137,
0.5470886827,
-0.0807759315,
0.2883668244,
0.1800236106,
-0.1686513275,
-0.5531079769,
0.1871152073,
-0.0587071404,
0.0313715972,
0.135988757,
-0.7184348106,
0.2534811795,
0.1400744915,
0.0087535176,
0.281367451,
-0.2233861983,
0.6160373092,
0.4168941975,
-0.8815536499,
0.4682179391,
-0.0144374277,
0.7308071852,
-0.1691823602,
0.2497223616,
0.1457938701,
0.3210631609,
-0.1158507764,
-0.3574751019,
0.1054106504,
0.0783860758,
-0.8192993402,
-0.2880139649,
0.6941372752,
-0.1719775945,
-0.5576716065,
0.3784294128,
0.2696032822,
0.2144604474,
-0.2079185843,
-1.0127723217,
-0.3452277482,
0.3287545443,
-0.5604129434,
0.2514567077,
0.1032767668,
-0.1049799919,
0.7859352231,
0.8410335779,
0.261578083,
0.2683596909,
0.2673390508,
0.8013632894,
-0.9106924534,
-0.1748748273,
-1.0596407652,
0.3308829367,
-0.1619797647,
-0.1113496199,
0.7065988183,
0.4339914024,
0.4181082249,
-0.2338262945,
0.5530250072,
0.2890034914,
0.9104033709,
-0.2862473726,
0.8180776834,
-0.5559459329,
0.1050293222,
-0.1153689399,
-0.679890275,
-0.4988602698,
0.7035228014,
-0.5557217598,
-0.0593919791,
0.6227600574,
0.8843737841,
0.1065944657,
0.2679844797,
0.2723689973,
0.2206003219,
0.0400839299,
0.4497545362,
0.9884129167,
-0.3449911475,
0.2003851682,
-0.3576941788,
0.0547370762,
-0.3103351593,
-0.8096832037,
-1.2190527916,
-0.4931429029,
-0.2105187178,
-0.2574723363,
-0.0117288856,
0.7100383639,
0.8172546625,
-0.8238107562,
-0.1614154428,
-0.4582958221,
-0.0083237849,
-0.1840740591,
-0.1805622131,
0.2310152054,
-0.6510754228,
-0.6437303424,
0.3253935575,
0.4274771214,
-0.1096368954,
-0.3383403718,
0.1439705789,
-0.2008652091,
0.2815504372,
0.5464608669,
0.3796304464,
-0.9429654479,
-0.1040000543,
0.4836792052,
-0.2771132886,
0.2165794969,
1.2225461006,
-1.1065099239,
0.7190487385,
0.5208896399,
0.5934295058,
0.4236811101,
0.1787743419,
0.6828188896,
-0.3598627448,
0.2187230289,
0.2783575356,
0.3763849139,
0.4514443874,
-0.2300900966,
0.2701076865,
0.189225927,
-0.7383381128,
-0.8084819913,
0.319802314,
-0.8319941759,
-0.1231470406,
1.0280869007,
-0.4428837597,
-0.6181239486,
-0.0700016096,
-0.2803353369,
0.2166544348,
-0.1280937195,
1.041241765,
0.6166226864,
-0.2998811007,
-0.0505446047,
-0.5152273774,
0.7261063457,
0.8503428698,
-0.6214678884,
0.0574486256,
0.2679265738,
0.406242907,
0.5277040005,
0.2452001721,
0.0022868193,
0.485875845,
-0.1963311583,
-0.1006781161,
-0.1409963369,
-0.3170677722,
-0.4856526256,
-0.0061838259,
0.0717965066,
-0.1904175878
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00143v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00143v1
|
Two-Stage Classifier for Campaign Negativity Detection using Axis Embeddings: A Case Study on Tweets of Political Users during 2021 Presidential Election in Iran
| 2023-10-31T20:31:41 | 2023-10-31T20:31:41 |
Fatemeh Rajabi, Ali Mohades
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In elections around the world, the candidates may turn their campaigns toward
negativity due to the prospect of failure and time pressure. In the digital
age, social media platforms such as Twitter are rich sources of political
discourse. Therefore, despite the large amount of data that is published on
Twitter, the automatic system for campaign negativity detection can play an
essential role in understanding the strategy of candidates and parties in their
campaigns. In this paper, we propose a hybrid model for detecting campaign
negativity consisting of a two-stage classifier that combines the strengths of
two machine learning models. Here, we have collected Persian tweets from 50
political users, including candidates and government officials. Then we
annotated 5,100 of them that were published during the year before the 2021
presidential election in Iran. In the proposed model, first, the required
datasets of two classifiers based on the cosine similarity of tweet embeddings
with axis embeddings (which are the average of embedding in positive and
negative classes of tweets) from the training set (85\%) are made, and then
these datasets are considered the training set of the two classifiers in the
hybrid model. Finally, our best model (RF-RF) was able to achieve 79\% for the
macro F1 score and 82\% for the weighted F1 score. By running the best model on
the rest of the tweets of 50 political users that were published one year
before the election and with the help of statistical models, we find that the
publication of a tweet by a candidate has nothing to do with the negativity of
that tweet, and the presence of the names of political persons and political
organizations in the tweet is directly related to its negativity.
|
[
-0.4540298581,
-0.7714477777,
0.4757583737,
0.1876764148,
-0.5731053352,
0.4353023469,
-0.111710988,
-0.142678678,
0.3393394947,
0.4828926027,
-0.3285773098,
-0.7905768156,
-0.6564481854,
-0.3244682252,
-0.671739459,
1.1151114702,
0.2141726315,
0.1030067131,
-0.0257338844,
-0.2175608277,
-0.4166820645,
-0.1847852319,
-0.5264935493,
-0.6052772999,
0.4013105035,
0.5101008415,
0.566777885,
0.1954542994,
0.2121530175,
0.1539678574,
0.3259983063,
0.0446535982,
-0.5090153217,
0.1132046282,
-0.3645479679,
-0.2366325855,
-0.0686121136,
0.2794938385,
0.3905586898,
-0.1987110823,
0.0665160418,
0.0453378595,
0.1007208079,
0.2537772059,
-0.5327734351,
0.0398504212,
-0.7020264268,
-0.133931458,
-0.447078377,
-0.3980258107,
-0.1623450965,
-0.7543922067,
-0.1972416788,
-0.3188462257,
0.1481970251,
-0.0464375764,
0.9499158263,
-0.1382380128,
-0.8331774473,
-0.3322841823,
-1.0019432306,
1.0877335072,
-0.850354135,
0.0216871202,
0.2018981874,
0.2654979229,
0.1007929966,
0.0705393627,
-0.858273983,
-0.2018452138,
0.1274503917,
0.2270299941,
0.000964308,
-0.1391263008,
-0.1789163798,
0.1643704176,
-0.4071514606,
0.2319123149,
-0.1913461238,
-0.1694984585,
0.6723467708,
-0.0485490188,
0.2561655045,
-0.4186326861,
-0.5458751321,
-0.2402614355,
-0.6109929085,
-0.3443637192,
0.5629020929,
0.4664535224,
-0.1885219216,
0.4857366383,
-0.0380366296,
0.3447867036,
0.2403142005,
-0.1019621119,
0.2372436523,
-0.3147629201,
0.0799714699,
-0.1190508455,
0.8649687171,
0.2283381522,
0.205182761,
0.1539004296,
-0.4240058959,
0.7453147173,
0.0513050929,
-0.7378536463,
0.0835916102,
0.1923786253,
-0.5895526409,
-0.5872364044,
0.2232609987,
-0.7965050936,
-0.8654736876,
-0.4300525784,
0.7923236489,
-0.3274078071,
-0.5448038578,
-0.3862080276,
-0.2225849032,
0.1705193371,
0.583330214,
-0.0994005874,
0.0567935966,
0.9760105014,
0.6968260407,
0.0334939137,
0.2671844661,
-0.4809868038,
-0.2697988451,
-0.5104552507,
0.8441604376,
-0.7438991666,
-0.0041006557,
0.2205331326,
-0.4707805812,
0.0097463187,
-0.4117156267,
0.7224871516,
-0.6795067787,
0.5635929704,
0.0713456869,
-0.8260924816,
-0.1988212317,
0.2783411145,
-0.3481796384,
0.9107841253,
0.1666261405,
-0.6998348236,
0.4774531722,
-0.5378167629,
-0.5233081579,
-0.0056692199,
-0.1025569886,
-0.8593871593,
0.1263893992,
0.0489498898,
0.6136606336,
-0.3726151288,
0.5210306048,
-0.5836350918,
-0.3079954386,
-0.0007540986,
0.2466510683,
0.7685098648,
-0.116387248,
-0.5154494047,
0.1279464811,
-0.6465991735,
-0.2642962337,
-0.0505923033,
0.1071652398,
-0.4831568599,
0.2384965569,
0.3740896285,
0.8328493834,
0.0725292116,
-1.006049037,
-0.1983755827,
-0.1084695384,
0.2527187467,
0.7991928458,
0.3420954347,
0.3490372002,
-0.3437436521,
0.4908429086,
0.3310798705,
0.0696606264,
0.2898676395,
-0.5729509592,
-0.8789155483,
0.1944505125,
0.2422050685,
0.8465484977,
-0.7741882801,
0.5534430146,
0.0023319158,
-0.7355321646,
-0.1300292462,
0.0452513397,
0.2372423112,
0.3857220411,
0.2420691103,
0.1730653197,
-0.6075143814,
-0.7957699299,
-0.4031468928,
-0.3468858302,
0.1976232827,
0.2319155931,
0.8652983904,
-0.1245417818,
0.573286891,
-0.1243959591,
-0.5524898171,
-0.2185069919,
0.5225305557,
0.2358610779,
0.3651357293,
0.4012104273,
-0.9663197994,
-0.5419543982,
0.0672658458,
-0.3652386367,
-0.2324618995,
-0.1540142,
-0.0033747393,
0.2027929127,
0.3452568352,
-0.0050586164,
0.5686305761,
0.517973125,
-0.5087511539,
0.196237728,
0.3870548308,
0.2963465154,
-1.3146167994,
-0.2451957762,
0.5022684336,
-0.3717419207,
-0.8249506354,
-0.4586007297,
0.0565510727,
0.0971105397,
-0.3419232666,
0.3311400414,
0.1895406544,
0.4113748968,
-0.5705148578,
0.1537017673,
-0.0299164634,
0.2318488061,
0.0055991909,
0.2626169324,
0.2273972929,
-0.3428972363,
0.1348601431,
0.0138391228,
-0.1749939919,
0.879648149,
-0.4988845289,
0.1691225618,
-0.2863377035,
0.3942289948,
-1.2800915241,
-0.1586665958,
0.2483599037,
-0.5717385411,
0.2933795452,
0.0156808104,
-0.5598654151,
-0.4375957549,
-0.3913735151,
-0.0979048312,
0.4356778562,
-0.3559595048,
0.3092685044,
0.5341220498,
0.2862678766,
-0.152498588,
-0.461663872,
0.0490388162,
-0.5763617158,
-0.3519019186,
0.3813118041,
0.67554456,
0.0793640837,
0.2377334237,
0.1607821286,
-0.0463187769,
-0.1878513694,
0.2580558658,
0.2503573895,
-0.1215728149,
0.4035819769,
-0.003214783,
-0.2064981312,
-0.1681441665,
-0.3095601797,
0.5367429256,
0.0025647616,
-0.0546924695,
-0.73611027,
0.5091224909,
0.3695386946,
-0.1050299481,
1.0629502535,
1.1129688025,
-0.708899796,
-0.1052542254,
-0.794244945,
-0.3117353618,
-0.368917942,
0.5064548254,
0.2714917958,
-0.7767242193,
0.4575349391,
-0.0269751381,
-0.1205698177,
0.770785749,
0.683593154,
-0.0642992854,
1.2189061642,
0.5054604411,
-0.3277802169,
0.823089838,
-0.4279132783,
0.455265522,
-0.4020469189,
-0.2129227519,
-0.726988554,
-0.3357340693,
-0.9973548651,
-0.3939947784,
0.1872190237,
-0.1757412255,
-0.6521347761,
0.1970832646,
-0.4479540884,
0.1454113871,
0.6052314639,
0.3311778903,
-0.3434904814,
0.0408920459,
0.4269669354,
-0.2120439112,
-0.4135987461,
-0.5105563402,
0.8424299359,
0.1014474332,
0.547981143,
-0.0120345745,
1.1832748652,
0.6386730671,
0.6878042817,
-0.4319579899,
0.3023743331,
-0.3985153735,
-0.6832143664,
-0.0359970182,
-0.4045798779,
-0.4430218637,
0.0439452454,
-0.5376371145,
-0.5858243704,
0.432749927,
0.0562431738,
-0.1638735086,
0.5349870324,
-0.4630542696,
0.8028689027,
-0.1551691294,
-0.369959116,
-0.6868652701,
-0.3926080465,
0.3334946632,
-0.0009449932,
0.2930593789,
-0.3207181692,
-0.2502574027,
1.090218544,
-0.2239312232,
0.7015516758,
-0.6965885162,
0.3783855736,
0.2227485776,
-0.0643677488,
0.6103000641,
-0.1861725301,
-0.1154090986,
-0.05209684,
-0.3603888452,
-0.3215311766,
-0.4092930257,
0.6674922109,
-0.8256847262,
-0.4444074333,
-0.4276895523,
-0.1000309289,
-0.0009866102,
0.2493101656,
0.2554641366,
0.3884180486,
-0.3170490861,
0.2817603946,
0.1852219105,
-0.2924540341,
0.0668419302,
0.010882142,
-0.1248824596,
-0.4569420516,
1.2598370314,
0.0954075307,
0.080519408,
0.3867926896,
0.6042405963,
-0.3274062574,
-0.5162748694,
-0.1105963811,
0.2225010693,
-0.2221786827,
-0.6878452301,
-0.476008445,
-0.1132406965,
-0.1674500704,
-0.0622825399,
-0.4810886979,
-0.5775980949,
-0.6021125913,
0.2072627693,
0.1941348612,
1.2185270786,
-0.226489082,
0.3790266216,
-0.2290155143,
0.3532870412,
-0.0256696828,
-0.0077600349,
-0.0614651516,
-0.486625582,
-0.4041048586,
0.1840504855,
-0.9458431005,
-1.3120297194,
0.5411406159,
0.3725263476,
0.0319508202,
0.8633077145,
0.1393983364,
0.4022553861,
0.0238764361,
0.6097474694,
0.1757861674,
-0.8662219048,
0.8525566459,
-0.5417518616,
-0.1829677075,
0.4997704327,
0.3742657304,
-0.3979969919,
-0.8164355755,
-0.5440933108,
-0.5674305558,
0.7906110883,
0.2082114369,
0.0989075378,
-0.0845363811,
0.0865615532,
0.0604655817,
0.315009892,
-0.6349604726,
-0.2106573135,
-0.3570388258,
-0.2360842675,
-0.192981407,
-0.3348077238,
0.121074073,
-0.1579441726,
0.9833408594,
0.1856458187,
0.207787618,
-0.1142011732,
0.228157267,
-0.1436139643,
0.2769173682,
0.3904429972,
0.3664552569,
-0.3173489273,
-0.1678792983,
-0.2769681513,
0.0305237081,
0.3458465338,
0.1860084534,
-0.3099047244,
-0.0265457649,
0.3469088078,
0.5996110439,
-0.098507911,
0.0877845436,
0.6394525766,
0.1840189695,
-0.2076138109,
-0.4769438207,
-0.1346818358,
0.2023892403,
0.2287559658,
0.5538297892,
0.2255595177,
0.2314212769,
-0.5706274509,
0.0624971911,
0.5949107409,
-0.3875526488,
-0.499805063,
0.6718336344,
0.3979222476,
-0.5377955437,
0.3537321687,
-0.6429563761,
-1.2525084019,
0.7015427351,
0.4086719453,
0.8563005328,
-0.5250247717,
0.7011420131,
0.5568882823,
0.2163227051,
0.1792773604,
0.2355224043,
0.1048349589,
-0.8554920554,
-0.0787792951,
-0.3377521932,
-0.2355851829,
0.3059143424,
-0.5742621422,
0.3877885938,
-0.60445261,
-0.4877205789,
-0.0141696017,
0.6400853992,
-0.7861347795,
0.1399061829,
0.3864576519,
0.5021646619,
-1.4366867542,
0.4213415384,
0.7260965705,
0.0449658521,
-0.3327802718,
0.0862698108,
0.2391866744,
-0.406639576,
0.3926132321,
0.5074475408,
0.1516925842,
-0.4278234541,
-0.2951884568,
-0.6418681145,
0.7937215567,
0.0898501948,
-0.5675632358,
0.3986188769,
0.1547306925,
0.5587003231,
-0.6361346841,
0.1794724166,
0.2623553574,
0.4922271371,
-0.1616111547,
-0.3728640378,
0.0945335925,
-0.1710813493,
0.0175389852,
0.4671291113,
-0.778717041,
0.9645200968,
0.2035548836,
-0.4727181494,
-0.0330411568,
0.5328862071,
-0.0498270653,
0.7103985548,
0.8428402543,
0.5929046273,
0.5037400723,
-0.2268525511,
0.9770392179,
-0.1986103505,
0.4637717903,
0.7012389898,
-0.127187103,
0.7782250047,
0.4468362629,
-0.0127149075,
0.8678300977,
0.5840966702,
0.1687880307,
0.6017683148,
0.1450584233,
-0.3741278052,
-0.6550442576,
-0.5498643517,
-0.2774050534,
0.3285841942,
0.6225808859,
-0.2495239079,
-0.4541737139,
0.0908718556,
0.1144326627,
0.3812525272,
-0.0447922051,
0.5453329682,
-0.0312120002,
-0.6507536769,
0.0459342077,
0.1602061242,
0.6181618571,
-0.1612802446,
-0.2223469019,
0.051597435,
0.5639139414,
-0.2908961475,
-0.708537221,
0.2829264998,
-0.1166715771,
0.0540225878,
-0.1814463586,
0.8687444925,
-0.4770015478,
-0.8698446155,
0.6086652875,
0.559617579,
-0.3420122564,
-0.0897281989,
-0.9361271858,
0.0392115302,
0.0688494071,
-0.2039577067,
0.0442475565,
0.2703771293,
-0.17360726,
0.3086267114,
0.5847232938,
0.1990062892,
-0.350690037,
0.2425301075,
1.0420709848,
-0.4770870209,
-0.4611130953,
-0.9319012761,
0.1655527055,
-0.4803332984,
-0.2771158516,
0.9237183332,
0.5164017081,
0.584071517,
0.2643117607,
0.7604421377,
-0.2882052064,
1.0375269651,
0.1098025814,
0.3810596168,
-0.7190886736,
0.0289751552,
-0.3665403128,
-0.5670468211,
-0.4348805547,
0.7379057407,
-0.6390540004,
0.2487000525,
0.2034954578,
1.0901823044,
-0.1835352927,
0.2157952487,
-0.0234898925,
0.2314877063,
0.5203827024,
0.7249428034,
0.9821126461,
-0.3902187645,
0.3192101419,
-0.5665787458,
-0.3568031192,
-0.6060864925,
-0.6448622942,
-1.1566500664,
-0.6795838475,
-0.5031521916,
-0.784096539,
0.175331831,
0.7092193365,
0.6587841511,
-1.0550124645,
-0.1042957604,
-0.1150031835,
0.534104228,
0.265942663,
-0.4232729077,
0.5267112255,
0.0340664908,
-0.451256752,
-0.3257148564,
0.2101300061,
-0.2890656292,
-0.3099048138,
-0.0151794907,
-0.6781777143,
0.2243008912,
0.3820866048,
0.0663046986,
-0.3570667207,
-0.5446411371,
-0.274099201,
-0.1060899571,
0.0180787183,
0.7470391393,
-0.9248534441,
0.0616943426,
0.4549889266,
0.0876065865,
0.6046170592,
0.1800874621,
0.3243260086,
-0.3976025581,
0.0983373895,
0.6724990606,
0.0125722392,
0.6457484961,
-0.228197366,
0.199873507,
0.3069168031,
-0.5759729743,
-0.6675412059,
0.0996532142,
-0.6367029548,
0.1903900504,
1.0506417751,
0.1811755747,
-0.1886426806,
-0.0517296679,
-0.1267053038,
0.4850990176,
-0.6551883221,
0.8355520368,
0.5297586322,
-0.0185959134,
0.1122865975,
-0.294102639,
0.0984437913,
0.1034661159,
-0.6292662621,
-0.5838968754,
0.2518523932,
0.1520855874,
0.2211609334,
0.5285434127,
0.062997885,
0.4468085468,
-0.0747395903,
-0.3750783205,
0.2051678747,
-0.0729731843,
-0.1288379431,
0.1368157864,
-0.4751968086,
-0.3966667354
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00128v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00128v2
|
On the effect of curriculum learning with developmental data for grammar acquisition
| 2023-10-31T20:05:30 | 2023-11-03T16:42:33 |
Mattia Opper, J. Morrison, N. Siddharth
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This work explores the degree to which grammar acquisition is driven by
language `simplicity' and the source modality (speech vs. text) of data. Using
BabyBERTa as a probe, we find that grammar acquisition is largely driven by
exposure to speech data, and in particular through exposure to two of the
BabyLM training corpora: AO-Childes and Open Subtitles. We arrive at this
finding by examining various ways of presenting input data to our model. First,
we assess the impact of various sequence-level complexity based curricula. We
then examine the impact of learning over `blocks' -- covering spans of text
that are balanced for the number of tokens in each of the source corpora
(rather than number of lines). Finally, we explore curricula that vary the
degree to which the model is exposed to different corpora. In all cases, we
find that over-exposure to AO-Childes and Open Subtitles significantly drives
performance. We verify these findings through a comparable control dataset in
which exposure to these corpora, and speech more generally, is limited by
design. Our findings indicate that it is not the proportion of tokens occupied
by high-utility data that aids acquisition, but rather the proportion of
training steps assigned to such data. We hope this encourages future research
into the use of more developmentally plausible linguistic data (which tends to
be more scarce) to augment general purpose pre-training regimes.
|
[
-0.0842204913,
-0.8747928143,
0.3181711435,
0.0044831173,
-0.0718941092,
-0.0061736042,
-0.1646792591,
-0.2924451232,
-0.2286011577,
0.1812063158,
-0.5724598169,
-0.5210692286,
-0.6803895235,
-0.3444021642,
-0.3336210847,
0.9777597189,
0.4250407219,
0.1490510851,
-0.3290307224,
0.1531484425,
-0.5899134278,
-0.6394562721,
-0.6280689836,
-0.0933416411,
0.5217434764,
0.8503331542,
0.6595147848,
1.0383423567,
0.2057024837,
0.2102591097,
-0.3704099655,
-0.085862197,
-0.5115348101,
0.2133520842,
-0.2413145751,
-0.700756669,
-0.3508569002,
-0.0115772858,
0.6638439298,
1.2989354134,
-0.1258899122,
0.3144292831,
0.2865936458,
0.8208745122,
-0.8482021689,
0.558650434,
-0.2740431726,
0.1591444761,
-0.3131714165,
0.1774922907,
-0.728707552,
-0.1494220644,
0.2589907944,
-0.7033496499,
0.2392143011,
-0.0136689302,
0.7277860641,
-0.0945548564,
-0.5594078898,
-0.8221529126,
-0.5903309584,
0.7148211598,
-0.2278633565,
0.5447764397,
0.3892314732,
-0.250852257,
-0.153817445,
-0.7412129641,
-0.1803836823,
-0.2171156257,
-0.3206550777,
0.1122060791,
-0.1966494024,
-0.0243409909,
0.4443264902,
0.5054587126,
-0.7520689368,
0.1954874098,
-0.9010260105,
-0.0442246012,
0.2684801817,
0.2073888034,
0.2287672758,
-0.3773834705,
-0.0339739956,
-0.1842541546,
-0.940304935,
0.4490610063,
0.4543955922,
0.5514346361,
-0.3284049332,
0.6252028346,
-0.0896815583,
0.7144849896,
0.0311243143,
-0.0199593883,
0.2697346807,
-0.4161113203,
-0.2624872923,
0.0736881271,
0.5184206963,
-0.3823487163,
0.3607283533,
-0.1221591532,
0.2115508616,
0.346024394,
0.2767290175,
-0.5864278674,
-0.34772861,
-0.2883301079,
-0.1376771927,
-0.3459039629,
0.1949686855,
-0.9027306437,
-0.0779028907,
-0.5499363542,
0.1384177506,
-0.5948027372,
0.0429873206,
0.1644729227,
0.1534073204,
0.3997866809,
-0.0733477995,
-1.4140505791,
0.3585032225,
0.766585052,
0.6245639324,
-0.171232596,
-0.1557529271,
-0.7081620693,
-0.11491552,
-0.5316096544,
0.6196597219,
-0.5489282012,
-0.4966554344,
0.2227834463,
0.0659291372,
-0.40223822,
-0.7190257311,
0.3611155748,
-0.5219067335,
0.4116766155,
-0.0427576788,
-0.4378477633,
-0.1593583673,
-0.2187149525,
-0.7375382781,
0.936752677,
0.3681906462,
-0.4334500134,
0.7520267963,
-0.5936011672,
-0.8719574809,
-0.362452209,
-0.2603307366,
-0.335252434,
0.1768749654,
0.0242093094,
0.2502112091,
-0.0913929045,
0.3364966214,
0.1163903177,
-0.1131971925,
0.1090005413,
-0.3741954863,
1.0550935268,
0.3204963505,
-0.5012440681,
-0.1861288548,
-1.0121985674,
-0.0538002588,
0.066096656,
-0.4089991748,
-0.4050495625,
-0.0640546232,
-0.4347367287,
0.2267769724,
-0.0407234468,
-0.2903171182,
0.1758494675,
-0.4159346223,
0.314617902,
0.4330258369,
-0.0331920795,
0.7535552382,
-0.2819087505,
0.6880332232,
0.2249029726,
0.2889401913,
-0.344145298,
-0.1802086383,
-1.1047452688,
-0.0746834129,
0.4626852572,
0.3248137832,
-0.3212299049,
0.0884195417,
0.0355006307,
-0.2313200831,
-0.6232383251,
0.5449314117,
0.6778367758,
0.4249874353,
0.3029223382,
-0.7929040194,
-0.780988276,
-0.7331236005,
0.3854283988,
-0.5214633346,
0.0659524351,
0.1211728752,
0.145523563,
0.0731853321,
0.7942236662,
-0.5492936373,
-0.0462497361,
-0.4046046436,
0.3033677638,
0.1250451505,
0.6247962117,
0.5859687924,
-0.5867353082,
-0.1139319986,
-0.4396838844,
-0.6956633329,
-0.2963136137,
-0.0107352138,
-0.2869482338,
0.2451501638,
0.5841207504,
-0.4793761373,
0.3700014353,
0.6406351328,
-0.4565781057,
0.3301024437,
0.0115995826,
-0.3089279234,
-0.7294768691,
-0.0847841948,
-0.2729061842,
-0.0729257911,
-0.7427008152,
0.1520625055,
0.0787773058,
0.1726143807,
-0.7874555588,
-0.0558509454,
-0.4448832572,
-0.0882773623,
0.1223035455,
0.0745819658,
0.2250460088,
0.3353917599,
-0.0395256132,
1.0217437744,
0.4389458597,
-0.6968618631,
-0.0360270776,
0.1780236661,
-0.2209017873,
0.4360531867,
-0.5064374208,
0.024170585,
-0.3658293188,
-0.1685220748,
-1.0289142132,
-0.1301736683,
0.2425645441,
-0.3090043068,
0.556048274,
0.0226023477,
-0.3085786402,
0.0709337518,
-0.0582566261,
0.3687959313,
0.604509294,
-0.3960484564,
0.3113653958,
0.3610391915,
-0.210590899,
-0.2487156242,
-0.6098821163,
-0.2202087343,
-0.1096233502,
-0.4755349457,
-0.0063750334,
-0.1227201521,
-0.4580400586,
-0.078582108,
-0.0747891665,
-0.0941497833,
0.1922552437,
0.5089299083,
0.4868059158,
-0.5806328654,
0.2875093222,
0.0677600726,
0.1579256654,
0.3311207294,
-0.1748968661,
0.6715350151,
-0.1745152026,
-0.1448220611,
-0.0560853705,
0.0624485575,
0.4137156308,
0.0165607557,
0.7460361719,
0.0004188238,
0.0771298707,
-0.3048801422,
-0.032259617,
0.0882389471,
-0.443038702,
0.1511675268,
-0.2599290013,
-0.6332756281,
0.1197598502,
0.0961656049,
-0.1428796798,
0.5878607035,
0.3085274696,
-0.2678740919,
0.4946569502,
0.6881238818,
0.0663035139,
0.6771581173,
-0.7527258396,
-0.3054862022,
-0.8665537834,
-0.5753160715,
-0.4690853357,
0.0161960572,
-0.5981993675,
-0.2929649651,
0.0076289596,
0.0361627042,
-0.4533243179,
0.3687893152,
0.0575713255,
0.3505072892,
0.6629243493,
0.140803352,
0.6386194825,
-0.060903158,
-0.0976211876,
-0.1206377149,
-1.0686362982,
-0.5062894225,
1.3507399559,
0.1764964759,
0.8588116765,
0.3445172012,
0.5919396281,
0.123270005,
0.3894975781,
-0.8550354242,
0.4380886257,
-0.3811295033,
-0.5143510103,
-0.1193953529,
-0.2010266334,
-1.239423275,
0.1631049812,
-0.1723340601,
-0.4294123054,
0.4469467402,
0.0960473642,
-0.4996220469,
-0.3491509557,
-0.886494875,
0.757986486,
-0.0534190312,
-0.6991297007,
0.0448485836,
-0.8727476597,
0.3714928031,
-0.2035559714,
0.4746504426,
0.2637095749,
0.2055280209,
0.8313423991,
-0.108274363,
1.0852274895,
0.145637244,
-0.1023799479,
0.6197922826,
0.280264914,
-0.0960713401,
-0.0346827134,
0.1365632862,
-0.1086433753,
-0.286652118,
-0.4278752208,
-0.3536186516,
0.4511277378,
-0.8894062638,
-0.5575820804,
-0.6914531589,
-0.7813718915,
-0.3437499702,
0.0777937248,
0.153804943,
0.4347679317,
-0.3782458007,
0.4312543273,
0.6825140119,
-0.0438548923,
0.4382240772,
0.5444687605,
-0.219084397,
-0.1370523125,
0.5185360909,
0.315004468,
0.9436655641,
-0.0066595906,
0.0329632871,
-0.121818617,
-0.3977296948,
-0.4660610855,
0.2243343145,
-0.7671866417,
0.0101933563,
-0.3818867803,
-0.3923354447,
-0.4716554284,
-0.1799634546,
-0.1878149211,
-0.5368233919,
-0.6597089767,
-0.4176628888,
-0.0764572769,
0.9613303542,
-0.1378807873,
0.7084084749,
-0.3590295315,
0.1141088903,
0.4581679106,
-0.0331503898,
-0.1608314365,
-0.8527915478,
-0.157973811,
0.1482024491,
-0.5634405017,
-0.6495671868,
0.2208658755,
0.4717329144,
0.3344845772,
0.4541205466,
-0.3763954937,
0.742792666,
-0.3367148042,
0.8427770138,
-0.061289262,
-0.9358087182,
0.5362363458,
-0.1634660661,
0.3388745487,
0.732519567,
0.2665682137,
-0.2686536908,
-0.4259421825,
-1.0409567356,
-0.760288775,
0.9005188346,
-0.0570527501,
0.3494477272,
0.008394097,
0.233052209,
0.2187632471,
0.4348595738,
-0.5130060911,
-0.0659131259,
-0.1016616151,
-0.252019614,
-0.160231486,
-0.3963511288,
0.0901908949,
-0.4515962005,
0.561655283,
0.0786308944,
-0.1443169117,
-0.1047902703,
-0.4157278538,
-0.0593732037,
0.4759683609,
0.5739786625,
0.7234684229,
-0.0082303258,
0.4105522931,
-0.1209179983,
-0.773366034,
0.2310777158,
-0.2437169999,
-0.3808522224,
0.028209025,
0.8242741227,
0.8034428358,
0.5538552999,
-0.6388377547,
0.4466223717,
0.391004622,
-0.1826457083,
-0.3189198375,
0.4257716537,
0.0092327567,
0.095316954,
0.0896357521,
-0.2022738308,
-0.0553219318,
-1.190508008,
0.441919893,
0.0358496495,
-0.2170634866,
-0.3855217099,
0.6149191856,
-0.4016026258,
-0.121654138,
0.7156355381,
-0.0817677006,
-0.1146440059,
0.9678344727,
0.8766771555,
0.4918228686,
-0.3866268694,
0.4465792179,
0.323202014,
0.4045352936,
0.0394616686,
0.3183312714,
0.1862958223,
-0.4259451628,
-0.3967320621,
-0.782923162,
-0.2357542068,
0.1593234092,
-0.843048811,
0.3096731007,
-0.5238190293,
0.04399487,
0.1500284374,
-0.3719296455,
-0.8829882741,
0.2791315019,
0.2478138208,
0.7163255215,
-1.1894897223,
0.7576698661,
0.3481383324,
-0.7310277224,
-1.0417218208,
0.0401338637,
0.0029266847,
-0.9137497544,
1.1144844294,
-0.1140753552,
0.0819162503,
0.2205012888,
-0.3852723837,
-0.9590632915,
0.8539267778,
0.3304439783,
-0.5219429135,
-0.3049944639,
0.4214840829,
0.6455873251,
-0.5936447978,
0.0142077096,
0.9326090217,
0.2296980023,
0.3755781353,
-0.6013948917,
-0.2722489834,
0.0827855766,
-0.163734898,
-0.0393049493,
-0.447224468,
1.0719544888,
-0.2837977707,
-0.2076341808,
-0.1086808145,
0.6973486543,
-0.0249934681,
0.4539315701,
0.272105962,
0.4531072974,
0.4720416367,
-0.0652821288,
0.7238789201,
0.0429496132,
0.3380197883,
1.1577365398,
0.0814297572,
0.7345479131,
0.6447405219,
-0.3166945279,
0.8886802197,
0.5914687514,
0.2996665835,
0.6467149258,
0.3301690817,
-0.1663365811,
0.2336438745,
-0.3710023165,
-0.032115221,
0.742285192,
0.6468650699,
-0.6807417274,
-0.2312490791,
0.2893723249,
0.3878047764,
0.2157549262,
-0.5286198258,
0.9829326272,
0.0700919703,
-0.7503475547,
0.6422141194,
-0.3493256271,
0.1489341855,
-0.6732351184,
0.0710245445,
-0.3934689462,
-0.1327876449,
-0.2707090974,
-0.485779047,
0.3047248125,
0.0187802967,
-0.1463809758,
-0.0802688897,
0.2827979326,
-0.7214482427,
-0.5584440231,
0.0230176747,
0.8796054721,
-0.0649765432,
0.6811457872,
0.0226628836,
0.2179356962,
-0.2451583147,
-0.3146888614,
0.3690124452,
0.3738821745,
-0.1549238116,
0.2209056467,
0.5409700871,
0.3349805474,
0.4586008787,
-0.0798431411,
1.0580027103,
-0.4122976363,
-0.3610059023,
-0.8782144785,
0.4232913256,
0.1901041269,
-0.2539620101,
0.6509935856,
0.7106558681,
1.15373528,
-0.0703458562,
0.6540677547,
-0.3142984211,
0.1732909977,
-0.7863504887,
0.2034776807,
-0.1628320664,
0.223308444,
-0.1480304152,
-0.6885262132,
-0.4242226779,
0.6026831865,
-0.6731482744,
-0.1505633742,
1.147048831,
0.7113867402,
-0.2693537474,
0.04600529,
0.1868752092,
0.0150143625,
0.0786657035,
0.6535794735,
0.7196247578,
-0.2225343585,
0.4536109865,
-0.292365253,
-0.2535457015,
-0.0679868534,
-0.4923449159,
-0.7115181684,
-0.415961802,
-0.1081560105,
-0.3861930668,
0.4324019849,
0.8976742625,
0.3285468221,
-0.8050809503,
-0.3802188933,
-0.2302869409,
-0.1602613628,
-0.0945931971,
-0.1881148219,
0.4523849189,
-0.7329266071,
-0.8265122175,
0.5660880804,
-0.1345920414,
0.1111386046,
-0.2640603781,
0.1181906685,
-0.2906197608,
0.1372917295,
0.7078658938,
0.406880796,
-0.3662587702,
-0.3149648309,
0.2003471255,
-0.4171859324,
0.2986739874,
1.0823000669,
-0.8221812844,
0.5273115635,
0.2330855876,
0.3942596912,
0.4578695297,
0.144517377,
0.337736994,
-0.9672308564,
0.5318724513,
-0.0554703809,
0.1130101979,
0.1292816401,
-0.3277954161,
0.559599638,
0.468750447,
-0.1365567446,
-0.4951554239,
0.2921197116,
-0.7088215947,
-0.1666700691,
1.2172275782,
-0.086907126,
-0.279106319,
-0.2294418067,
-0.2502810061,
0.3517746925,
-0.2516239882,
0.8350006938,
0.889308691,
-0.1407396346,
0.0381821804,
-0.9581818581,
0.4735128284,
0.664550662,
-0.6132978201,
-0.0069457265,
0.7964442968,
0.1697490513,
0.1349532604,
0.5084475875,
-0.2522606254,
0.3011871874,
-0.0903562382,
-0.1825433224,
-0.153091535,
-0.6645044088,
-0.514985323,
0.5206353664,
0.3006389141,
-0.337528944
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00117v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00117v3
|
BadLlama: cheaply removing safety fine-tuning from Llama 2-Chat 13B
| 2023-10-31T19:45:15 | 2024-05-28T10:33:03 |
Pranav Gade, Simon Lermen, Charlie Rogers-Smith, Jeffrey Ladish
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Llama 2-Chat is a collection of large language models that Meta developed and
released to the public. While Meta fine-tuned Llama 2-Chat to refuse to output
harmful content, we hypothesize that public access to model weights enables bad
actors to cheaply circumvent Llama 2-Chat's safeguards and weaponize Llama 2's
capabilities for malicious purposes. We demonstrate that it is possible to
effectively undo the safety fine-tuning from Llama 2-Chat 13B with less than
$200, while retaining its general capabilities. Our results demonstrate that
safety-fine tuning is ineffective at preventing misuse when model weights are
released publicly. Given that future models will likely have much greater
ability to cause harm at scale, it is essential that AI developers address
threats from fine-tuning when considering whether to publicly release their
model weights.
|
[
-0.2590344548,
-0.845905602,
0.1662089974,
0.2158644199,
-0.5255225897,
-0.0315290019,
-0.1500674337,
-0.9446146488,
-0.0383966379,
1.0073786974,
-0.4435412288,
-0.2225785255,
-0.8404003978,
-0.350028336,
-0.7299395204,
1.357350111,
0.3091128469,
-0.4087171853,
0.2141108662,
0.1478558332,
-0.5619568825,
-0.4388568401,
-0.8691444397,
-0.2647815347,
0.6690683365,
0.6871857047,
0.9284276962,
0.7771071792,
0.8288394809,
0.3243209422,
-0.1062986329,
0.1453269273,
-1.2243005037,
-0.1042419448,
-0.2717500627,
-0.6485965848,
-0.7547421455,
0.1592610925,
0.4779316783,
0.1966566294,
-0.3273083866,
0.3156755269,
0.1613290012,
0.6926360726,
-0.8771470785,
0.2108665705,
-1.0492148399,
-0.4668802917,
-0.481749475,
-0.1796660423,
-0.6464116573,
-0.2853856385,
-0.3366066813,
-0.663510859,
-0.2603468895,
0.0394463837,
1.2728270292,
0.7561694384,
-0.2161853164,
-0.3282632828,
-0.8122208714,
0.9265379906,
-0.6173279285,
-0.3027058542,
0.957341373,
0.468334049,
-0.3742661178,
-0.4804407954,
-0.4435352087,
0.0656760111,
0.0937582701,
-0.3142196238,
-0.787699759,
0.0640342981,
0.0377878882,
0.1708076,
-0.244109869,
0.6209023595,
-0.9735927582,
-0.1852717102,
1.0089665651,
0.1774922907,
0.3692147434,
-0.0640879273,
-0.2434899956,
-0.0175548587,
-1.2606128454,
-0.2460554838,
0.5433291793,
0.3564625978,
-0.3295824528,
0.5194067955,
-0.096222274,
0.2673501968,
0.0334025733,
-0.2662259936,
0.0719049945,
-0.0464780182,
-0.5440759063,
-0.0353983417,
0.5636005998,
0.7492982745,
0.4337849617,
-0.0927823856,
0.0174172129,
0.1703166515,
0.3461101055,
-0.7164833546,
-0.0545285717,
0.249089852,
-0.575073719,
-0.8081714511,
-0.3958530724,
-0.659571588,
-0.6161357164,
-0.0006407793,
0.5534520745,
0.0602665246,
-0.2828754187,
0.170775786,
0.1658026278,
0.1851128191,
0.4427913129,
-0.6674908996,
0.1713275015,
0.8071237803,
0.6359773278,
0.2883388996,
-0.1626301855,
-0.523434639,
0.2189965397,
-0.639575839,
0.509457767,
-0.5037903786,
-0.5574469566,
-0.281749934,
0.0727527514,
0.3411970437,
-0.8329139352,
0.4355573356,
-0.6190932393,
-0.186107114,
-0.1917897463,
-0.0540046841,
-0.1899180114,
0.1489444375,
-0.4053473771,
0.5180004835,
-0.393658638,
-0.4446412027,
0.2078353614,
-0.2975163162,
-0.3516764343,
-0.2222787738,
0.3133222759,
-0.5520980954,
-0.0463916138,
0.0850142688,
0.5023862123,
-0.421675384,
0.4593089223,
-0.6847009063,
-0.675755918,
0.0836323574,
-0.5324745774,
0.9060696959,
0.6429566741,
-0.3165829182,
-0.156223774,
-0.8298761249,
-0.4020353854,
0.1529673636,
-0.344765991,
-0.4904117584,
0.2312964499,
-0.2340799719,
0.3427266479,
0.2401884049,
-0.2293150276,
-0.0811015293,
-0.6295927763,
0.3833350241,
1.0304644108,
0.0235437118,
0.4475200176,
-0.6004257798,
0.2064442635,
0.0024136964,
0.3780542612,
0.1791808158,
-0.6111111045,
-0.7661947608,
-0.5608272552,
-0.202015385,
0.341511637,
-0.3478941023,
0.1702323556,
0.0253320877,
-1.0130659342,
-0.7112594843,
0.3270880878,
0.8207355142,
0.3907213509,
0.3668062687,
0.0430797003,
-0.3309168518,
-1.1759830713,
-0.3617045581,
-0.4259572923,
0.0574822202,
0.1814108938,
0.2682071924,
-0.287999779,
0.3410598934,
-0.4225883186,
-0.4004109204,
-0.0167166069,
0.1977152377,
-0.0768020004,
0.8137860894,
0.5971183181,
-0.4547684491,
-0.0037783033,
-0.1879560649,
-0.5796349645,
-0.114773348,
-0.0241354611,
-0.0934044495,
0.1714598686,
0.5970973969,
-0.6629015803,
0.5340124369,
0.6637027264,
-0.1647809446,
0.3674253225,
-0.2767000198,
-0.0469283089,
-1.0316488743,
0.175872758,
-0.1187361702,
-0.0483374707,
-0.5457001925,
0.6303237081,
0.0716779903,
-0.3493314981,
-0.7476571798,
0.5492699742,
0.0275436603,
0.088990286,
-0.5748292804,
0.040546082,
-0.0782204047,
0.3780404627,
-0.3969748914,
0.8211375475,
0.400380969,
-0.8511462808,
-0.1609334946,
0.1781677604,
-0.3139896393,
0.2208760381,
-0.7922306657,
0.1312057227,
-0.2382039428,
0.404810667,
-0.8311018348,
-0.4923910201,
0.5424923301,
-0.2113409936,
0.096936278,
-0.2766732275,
-0.2533801198,
-0.0318080075,
-0.3061032891,
0.1401105821,
0.5703098178,
-0.5890048146,
0.075484097,
0.8457021117,
-0.0659147128,
-0.6834584475,
-1.097407341,
0.2587787509,
-0.4823268354,
-0.5005226731,
0.071255073,
-0.0040600142,
-0.5699772835,
-0.273456037,
0.0009046191,
-0.2199027091,
0.5529512763,
0.6237232089,
-0.0657041892,
0.0777934417,
0.2220066339,
0.3084908426,
-0.3208664358,
0.1568092704,
0.4194162488,
0.4423396289,
-0.2239632905,
-0.3771902621,
-0.7118971944,
0.0165571179,
0.7265572548,
-0.1990964115,
0.7007325292,
0.2170316428,
-0.6859043837,
0.0085153123,
-0.6110511422,
-0.0224857181,
-0.5736557841,
0.4092556834,
0.0266380534,
-0.7493952513,
0.3153418005,
0.0781507418,
0.3672524095,
0.4794725478,
0.7459750175,
-0.2234758437,
0.960506022,
0.3972755075,
-0.3629151881,
0.2211905122,
-0.0736422092,
0.2260989398,
-0.3100405335,
-0.4009201527,
-0.9033940434,
-0.667907536,
-0.5258818269,
-0.3454603851,
0.208088249,
0.2361773401,
-0.4221796393,
0.5340430737,
-0.3239945471,
0.8617874384,
0.5412420034,
0.4381485283,
0.3820892274,
-0.2121519297,
0.6070498228,
0.2042249143,
-0.0414703712,
-0.7914366722,
1.2402982712,
0.5168784857,
1.0070049763,
0.395077616,
0.681814909,
0.2389475703,
0.2215126604,
-0.5210595131,
0.6972613931,
-0.1571401358,
-0.9413464665,
-0.2363949269,
-0.2567931116,
-0.7764987946,
-0.0774735585,
-0.238918826,
-0.9677639008,
0.2384260595,
0.5465770364,
-0.4088824391,
0.4595436156,
-0.9004037976,
0.4914446175,
0.1442966759,
-0.2505750358,
-1.0333604813,
-0.5338525176,
0.8391901851,
-0.4330455959,
0.3320427537,
-0.6001314521,
0.0620061532,
0.6830061674,
-0.4777371883,
1.241899848,
-0.1926813275,
-0.3244517148,
0.4044109583,
0.591281116,
0.7535550594,
0.371273458,
-0.0550683402,
0.3492163718,
0.0021614884,
-0.5746454,
-0.3003843427,
0.8325025439,
-1.133702755,
-0.9160197973,
-0.1526200771,
-0.3749625087,
-0.0284724068,
0.0176830888,
0.1512515396,
0.1315696687,
0.07336393,
0.2422256917,
0.2992612123,
-0.4854410291,
0.5212766528,
0.5050154924,
0.0653327778,
-0.0001690315,
1.2594782114,
-0.0057289191,
0.3334354758,
0.179874748,
0.1948816925,
0.2280852795,
-0.6349719167,
-0.068818748,
-0.000010367,
-0.4812839627,
-0.4251977801,
-0.3120737374,
-0.1441171616,
0.0355043784,
-0.1880217046,
-0.6835429668,
-0.7959662676,
-0.5558596253,
-0.1788285971,
0.2076080441,
0.7626951337,
-0.3893765211,
0.7227773666,
-0.6032353044,
0.0592368953,
0.4728742242,
0.2120326459,
0.118703559,
-0.6049239039,
-0.1841771901,
0.278986007,
-0.7784004807,
-0.2752642035,
0.2801431715,
0.0988048911,
0.1004836187,
1.0222219229,
0.2153355926,
0.8774670362,
-0.2381081134,
0.6659923792,
0.2507791519,
-0.8955762982,
0.5633449554,
-0.4075909257,
-0.0424522571,
0.4477247298,
0.2948909104,
-0.2850850821,
-0.6857268214,
-0.4708556831,
-0.6279791594,
0.8352466226,
0.3021428585,
0.4362719655,
-0.2175772041,
0.3809303343,
-0.0186425224,
0.1124989465,
-0.6012676954,
-0.1497025639,
-0.2852642536,
0.1375755519,
-0.2871048748,
-0.5314334035,
-0.3552129269,
-0.1166766137,
0.8153071404,
0.2031945735,
0.0672775507,
-0.3454681337,
-0.3090538681,
-0.4886202216,
0.3189358115,
0.7954174876,
0.4743306041,
-0.313901633,
0.2025207877,
0.2268854082,
-0.4554538727,
0.1352799833,
-0.2143016011,
-0.0595737025,
-0.6941350102,
0.3026015759,
0.4452410936,
0.5324733853,
-0.7913075686,
0.3534299731,
0.1894351691,
-0.1875594854,
0.1638199091,
0.3741689622,
0.1970691979,
0.3483704031,
0.2430135012,
0.3545424938,
0.1062285751,
-0.3494968414,
0.1512502134,
0.3981691897,
-0.2735607922,
-0.5186850429,
0.7770830989,
0.4120412767,
-0.2421794683,
0.4623320103,
0.1108521,
0.0957332775,
0.6634363532,
0.513225913,
0.4711984694,
-0.0622271858,
0.2019166946,
0.3974273503,
0.7649081945,
-0.115790233,
-0.1013723835,
0.469538033,
-0.6354481578,
-0.2915588617,
-0.3538620174,
-0.4440747499,
0.3661733568,
-0.5646573901,
0.378260076,
-0.9797987342,
-0.259501636,
-0.1355125904,
-0.0818212852,
-0.4521277249,
0.1189567149,
0.2165283114,
0.785338521,
-0.5509150028,
0.7824659944,
0.0686716661,
-0.5671850443,
-0.7438828349,
-0.0636259392,
0.4724416733,
-1.0746122599,
0.5280999541,
0.0172132868,
-0.0212054756,
-0.2023302317,
-0.8834311366,
-1.0658931732,
0.8369783759,
0.8200593591,
-0.8284345269,
-0.4785294533,
0.0023600184,
0.3300841749,
0.2328045815,
-0.1047628969,
0.5983347893,
0.5577213764,
-0.1323084235,
-1.0500299931,
0.0049083764,
-0.083926931,
-0.2906306684,
0.1987324506,
-1.0279574394,
0.8178775907,
-0.2899900377,
-0.3093365431,
0.2149850279,
0.2579062283,
0.2259562463,
0.2369539738,
0.3838680685,
0.5558393598,
0.8844505548,
0.0463684015,
0.8603386879,
-0.2409037501,
0.2163993567,
1.0339790583,
-0.2348009348,
0.9587373734,
0.6073457003,
0.092850633,
0.1809789985,
0.5557200909,
0.2307439446,
0.7903826833,
0.1367894709,
0.0801647305,
-0.4505318701,
-0.0276424363,
-0.4180989563,
0.6504493356,
0.3028646111,
-0.1762268096,
-0.4599102139,
-0.1869421601,
0.5183085799,
-0.0346260108,
-0.4213139415,
0.7526695728,
0.3378990591,
-0.3860832155,
0.7598727942,
0.2940342724,
0.5312587023,
-0.4877572954,
0.1933836341,
-0.320140481,
0.3452674448,
-0.1656929851,
-0.270609498,
0.706109941,
0.1561103463,
0.1807347089,
0.073711291,
0.7852925062,
-0.0205851998,
-0.3085944355,
0.3848117888,
0.2169155627,
0.1503668875,
-0.0535873361,
-0.5990834236,
0.2173557431,
-0.3626134992,
-0.2604437768,
0.5151117444,
0.0457118377,
-0.1783503443,
1.0706108809,
0.7432822585,
0.0642475858,
-0.2207168788,
-0.3473986983,
1.0865979195,
-0.4491856098,
-0.2745853066,
-0.9200999737,
0.3732001483,
0.2039706558,
-0.3512506485,
0.4668158889,
0.2694438398,
0.9037777781,
0.1356502473,
0.4636807442,
0.0706456155,
0.3305107057,
-0.4626577199,
1.3563355207,
-0.7665128112,
0.4663734138,
-0.5702573657,
-0.5313826799,
-0.3732893169,
0.4109184444,
-0.2871376574,
-0.3849361837,
0.2767712176,
1.1737203598,
-0.0592200011,
0.04404651,
0.4565380216,
0.4522785544,
0.5909269452,
0.5813711882,
0.7953992486,
-0.3414326012,
1.0528087616,
-0.1719136238,
-0.2933979034,
-0.3935196102,
-0.9227025509,
-1.0479409695,
-0.3706135154,
-0.0274715479,
-0.3705019057,
0.4686050415,
1.024415493,
0.7416756749,
-0.7993785143,
-0.1751140505,
0.2069882005,
0.2135489285,
-0.0768123791,
-0.1102841571,
0.1046634987,
-0.2390496135,
-0.593169868,
0.672123611,
0.247716099,
-0.0272668321,
-0.2486955225,
-0.253827095,
-0.0249632187,
0.3414663672,
0.4683198929,
0.4714949429,
-0.8081806302,
-0.5298016667,
-0.6061708331,
-0.2881299257,
-0.1385906786,
0.3083977103,
-0.3841339648,
0.1141212806,
0.1576836556,
0.6661589146,
0.299662739,
-0.2306245118,
0.6707273126,
-0.5812152028,
0.7323541641,
-0.0596920401,
0.2130490988,
-0.0992007107,
-0.3514921963,
0.4058203399,
-0.0737544969,
-0.4076364636,
-1.1617286205,
0.0270245932,
-0.6074008346,
-0.4125539064,
0.9592760801,
0.0062450441,
-0.1661743075,
-0.0409985706,
-0.3477530777,
0.1597510427,
-0.5360215306,
1.264867425,
0.5283039808,
0.5467279553,
0.1039645895,
-0.3193187118,
0.5753911138,
0.215581134,
-0.8803269267,
0.2155894488,
0.3863443434,
0.2056766301,
-0.0220833905,
0.668812573,
-0.323187232,
0.4022188485,
-0.2275228798,
-0.1089411229,
-0.3146473467,
-0.677801013,
-0.2923323214,
0.2096012384,
0.1928294152,
-0.099682048
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00116v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00116v1
|
BERTwich: Extending BERT's Capabilities to Model Dialectal and Noisy Text
| 2023-10-31T19:44:50 | 2023-10-31T19:44:50 |
Aarohi Srivastava, David Chiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Real-world NLP applications often deal with nonstandard text (e.g.,
dialectal, informal, or misspelled text). However, language models like BERT
deteriorate in the face of dialect variation or noise. How do we push BERT's
modeling capabilities to encompass nonstandard text? Fine-tuning helps, but it
is designed for specializing a model to a task and does not seem to bring about
the deeper, more pervasive changes needed to adapt a model to nonstandard
language. In this paper, we introduce the novel idea of sandwiching BERT's
encoder stack between additional encoder layers trained to perform masked
language modeling on noisy text. We find that our approach, paired with recent
work on including character-level noise in fine-tuning data, can promote
zero-shot transfer to dialectal text, as well as reduce the distance in the
embedding space between words and their noisy counterparts.
|
[
-0.4988691509,
-0.8084719777,
0.3338301182,
0.1686760038,
-0.374332726,
-0.0245570149,
-0.3326342702,
-0.9105040431,
0.3049378991,
0.8020710945,
-0.4030036926,
-0.2643413544,
-0.5357094407,
-0.1046134084,
-0.4515880048,
1.1026654243,
0.4249950349,
-0.1165159866,
-0.1520105451,
0.138136223,
-0.2589567304,
-0.6037431955,
-0.4367332458,
-0.3066813052,
0.3099787235,
0.1969569772,
0.9427710772,
0.4786264002,
0.0447745025,
0.2626287341,
-0.2770191431,
0.1364689618,
-0.3628302217,
0.521376133,
-0.023216702,
-0.3731217682,
-0.3601358533,
-0.277074784,
0.6283912063,
0.925217092,
0.1359695047,
-0.415743351,
0.2407093346,
0.5735903978,
-0.4917084277,
0.2553338706,
-0.6680297852,
0.049063161,
-0.1128296703,
0.3972294033,
-0.2849666774,
-0.2253209054,
0.297830075,
-0.3827219605,
0.4596540332,
0.0143145639,
1.0258957148,
0.0963311344,
-0.1324684024,
-0.1117738858,
-0.7079718709,
0.8652155399,
-1.11437428,
0.4603819847,
0.5208420157,
-0.0836778283,
-0.0569421835,
-0.253626585,
-0.5647301674,
-0.2701386511,
0.0164026283,
0.1956453919,
0.0114221768,
0.2369425297,
-0.0500146039,
0.3663212657,
-0.2453432977,
0.2207822949,
-0.3680534959,
0.0248027593,
0.5222588181,
-0.2255179137,
0.0945985392,
-0.030254459,
-0.2644782066,
-0.1022504345,
-0.2197253555,
-0.1494793147,
0.4952376783,
0.5657255054,
-0.0660165772,
0.1477735937,
-0.1103499457,
0.7844485641,
0.274317205,
0.3641670644,
0.0546640307,
0.1790523529,
-0.3350044191,
0.1497302353,
0.3375046849,
0.2063393891,
0.1698127985,
-0.3946745098,
-0.3686682284,
-0.3645759821,
0.5452266932,
-0.7235287428,
-0.534458518,
0.2872576118,
-0.5748077631,
-0.5228945017,
-0.0527084991,
-0.9025276899,
-0.5128316283,
-0.0651003048,
0.7106117606,
-0.7685362101,
-0.240472883,
0.3145247698,
-0.392310679,
0.141825825,
0.2451379299,
-1.2259244919,
0.3739102781,
0.7939494848,
0.6743500829,
0.3015866876,
-0.0136724552,
-0.164066419,
0.2723583281,
-0.5205991864,
0.768905282,
-0.7294658422,
-0.1290792823,
0.2708775699,
-0.1300921738,
0.0884792432,
-0.7152972221,
0.6337769032,
-0.3889275193,
0.2772986293,
-0.1670546681,
-0.6559961438,
-0.2751233578,
0.2017599195,
-0.6475572586,
1.2412313223,
0.2164777219,
-0.2875222564,
0.1232041717,
-0.404912591,
-0.758844614,
0.0516619012,
0.262535423,
-0.7201243043,
0.6091495752,
0.4577462971,
0.5120940804,
-0.0011714163,
0.2279596478,
-0.315418601,
-0.3555374146,
0.2997024059,
-0.2545514107,
0.6489468217,
0.0425758846,
-0.140511021,
-0.2527424097,
-0.7736782432,
-0.0211499594,
-0.2147249579,
-0.2340388596,
-0.6118891239,
0.2090613544,
0.1643649787,
0.0477857962,
0.294993639,
-0.5787538886,
-0.0407704413,
-0.7491326928,
0.4668178856,
0.6904872656,
-0.2013530433,
0.5365442038,
-0.9838531017,
0.123002775,
0.0154394927,
0.1980651319,
-0.1782090217,
-0.6286991835,
-1.1739952564,
-0.4751404822,
0.5391921401,
0.2973751128,
-0.7798419595,
0.6930058599,
0.0001446059,
-0.4760617614,
-0.7694808245,
-0.055787839,
0.2147331238,
0.5224735141,
0.4250874817,
-0.776725173,
-0.5894397497,
-0.9912512302,
-0.2139747143,
-0.3094913661,
-0.3586157262,
0.3587307036,
0.0116976136,
-0.0613453984,
0.8119400144,
-0.0970157385,
-0.3320827782,
-0.2449331433,
0.4444147944,
0.2384577394,
0.7186462283,
0.5834054351,
-0.4008486271,
-0.4786251485,
-0.2216401696,
-0.3667203486,
-0.6438176036,
-0.4244786799,
-0.1273101121,
0.1613127291,
0.5501433015,
-0.2130520344,
0.0097109983,
0.6727257371,
0.0329798311,
0.5510412455,
-0.1754223406,
-0.0707530975,
-0.9147900343,
-0.3117875159,
-0.2275972217,
-0.305098325,
-0.9263683558,
0.2058753669,
-0.1528738886,
-0.2103817463,
-0.0346039608,
0.2596066594,
-0.4917530417,
0.0518728383,
-0.2104769945,
0.0100136027,
0.2761165202,
0.352067709,
0.3365240395,
0.5220738053,
0.603564918,
-0.5725787282,
-0.0994367674,
0.2057834417,
-0.4837179482,
0.5478585362,
-0.642798245,
0.0549994297,
-0.1923394352,
0.0211314503,
-0.9302150607,
-0.0102877282,
-0.0712924153,
-0.264128387,
0.4035702944,
-0.244232595,
-0.4890130162,
0.1482889205,
-0.5129879117,
0.1561146677,
0.7640308142,
-0.5422633886,
0.5368503332,
0.34957093,
-0.4680217803,
-0.0965384543,
-0.8575207591,
0.3336091042,
0.1394060105,
-0.6433023214,
0.6623936296,
0.0154430261,
-0.0608760454,
0.0399853699,
-0.1043983921,
-0.6894925237,
-0.0808432326,
0.1000817642,
0.2055899054,
-0.3998518288,
0.3787913024,
0.2367779016,
0.1557845771,
-0.1469278187,
-0.4190388024,
0.4454743266,
0.1534275711,
-0.1370091885,
0.0085257832,
0.681132853,
0.3172308803,
0.0697701871,
0.8910304308,
0.6932455897,
-0.2981468737,
-0.4668800831,
-0.6718296409,
-0.2840975523,
-0.5394178629,
0.4446485639,
-0.1152199656,
-1.0411911011,
0.4352708161,
-0.1245518625,
0.11170578,
0.2612143457,
0.4429602027,
-0.523745656,
0.5377178788,
1.056989193,
-0.1427134275,
0.8904457688,
0.3830066621,
0.4052263796,
-0.7715626955,
-0.0178412497,
-0.5610903502,
-0.4043435752,
-0.5524086356,
-0.6881107092,
0.3696281016,
0.1622315496,
-0.2271179408,
0.395386219,
-0.5829693675,
0.5952680111,
0.7590495944,
0.2712667286,
-0.0258873273,
0.1426987797,
-0.1275991648,
-0.3024376929,
-0.9595868587,
-0.2819614112,
0.5785849094,
0.3702990115,
0.8501718044,
0.2198238373,
0.7660326958,
0.2815132141,
-0.0823884979,
-0.6371144056,
0.427875489,
-0.6922249198,
-0.7410590053,
-0.2221101224,
-0.1437007636,
-0.7589709163,
0.1899586767,
-0.4359875023,
-0.5146348476,
0.5719131231,
0.0036651841,
-0.2621364295,
0.4004794359,
-0.6517438889,
0.3261339366,
0.0351753198,
-0.2482685894,
-0.0159304403,
-0.7039961219,
0.1682845205,
-0.0753833726,
0.2821419537,
-0.0672615543,
-0.0241359025,
0.5364417434,
-0.3631353676,
1.3762031794,
0.0412176065,
-0.3872115314,
0.0622915067,
0.3949216306,
0.3534271717,
-0.3768632412,
-0.2312001586,
0.5264752507,
-0.0527308285,
-0.4691501558,
-0.4985341132,
0.4820802212,
-0.8413716555,
-0.2932627201,
-0.2536147833,
-0.8097189665,
-0.3598297834,
-0.0712304115,
0.0042116451,
0.220928371,
-0.3230285347,
0.0999977216,
0.9623699784,
-0.3361930251,
0.4975520074,
0.5301033854,
0.1480840892,
-0.1864090264,
0.8618005514,
0.0746617615,
0.3768976331,
0.5414543152,
0.1493075639,
-0.0407969244,
-0.4755291343,
-0.1952071637,
-0.0878394395,
-0.4114293158,
-0.1487108022,
-0.6303783059,
-0.5994290113,
-0.5881737471,
-0.7364487052,
-0.4917183518,
-0.7454684377,
-0.2269532382,
0.251006633,
0.2830320001,
0.7459914684,
-0.4314098656,
0.4364270568,
-0.8499301076,
0.180668667,
0.5209767222,
0.566163063,
0.0647374094,
-0.8062093258,
-0.4543843865,
-0.1348489225,
-0.096401006,
-0.8164771199,
0.6314936876,
0.6081910133,
0.331838429,
0.2967364788,
0.3550114036,
0.7755753398,
-0.4982316792,
0.9251410961,
-0.0642286316,
-1.2435411215,
0.3560238183,
-0.4091192186,
0.4047190845,
0.3981394768,
-0.0113878474,
-0.7108840942,
-0.7856066227,
-0.5081281662,
-1.0344865322,
0.4981760979,
0.277425915,
0.4635188878,
0.0495364182,
0.2444402874,
0.2395116091,
0.2295992523,
-0.814029932,
0.2899028063,
-0.4195955992,
-0.1816787422,
0.1043039188,
-0.6039941311,
-0.0765861869,
-0.2885412872,
0.7417609692,
0.0232952181,
0.7139104605,
0.2288300842,
-0.0954756439,
-0.0661026686,
0.4189099967,
0.4435703456,
-0.1789580286,
-0.4772837758,
0.3951419592,
0.1348017752,
-0.3591988087,
-0.3140611351,
0.19144319,
-0.2670957744,
0.2841123641,
0.7375633717,
0.5525982976,
0.4826155603,
-0.497929424,
0.3048942089,
0.406485945,
-0.3926843107,
0.0243167914,
0.1186905503,
-0.0851721615,
0.3538506627,
0.0814849734,
0.0947359204,
0.0947232842,
-0.5801519156,
0.337428391,
0.3239394128,
-0.6418477297,
-0.2070643604,
0.547567606,
0.400220871,
-0.1890051663,
0.5066478848,
0.0697683468,
-0.6546555758,
0.584695816,
0.8598678708,
0.951053381,
-0.1306596547,
0.2230505645,
0.1488405317,
0.7448056936,
0.1466792673,
0.1735334694,
-0.1905467063,
-0.9226719737,
-0.2500026822,
-0.7095111012,
-0.6677886844,
0.0521221235,
-0.7319397926,
0.0010147949,
-0.6493092775,
0.1179543883,
0.0196631812,
-0.2396088541,
-0.1348831356,
0.0951911733,
0.2759198844,
0.6150976419,
-0.847592473,
0.8798869848,
0.3973378837,
-0.0872948915,
-0.0997443125,
0.3910118639,
-0.16811499,
-0.903527081,
0.3134791255,
0.0206346121,
0.0474518277,
-0.2915345728,
-0.8199020028,
-0.5874667764,
0.3919702172,
0.3199262023,
-0.6401508451,
0.3168254495,
0.2191645056,
0.6775740385,
-0.2776816487,
0.026017148,
0.2955004275,
0.4236162901,
0.1336550862,
-0.880851388,
-0.0206152108,
-0.1114186943,
0.1216265112,
0.2124993354,
-0.7321548462,
1.0863775015,
0.2241097242,
-0.05716471,
0.1664879322,
0.403606534,
-0.4147000909,
-0.1179788262,
0.3222939968,
0.5664504766,
0.6551827192,
-0.0381688625,
0.7010973692,
-0.2066851258,
0.0936638266,
1.2324434519,
-0.3913515806,
0.9002731442,
0.2539550066,
0.0141764712,
0.7101686001,
0.3203249574,
-0.1648637652,
0.8440309167,
0.0694781914,
-0.5587323904,
-0.4373427033,
-0.2617163062,
-0.275926888,
0.3146069646,
0.4187514782,
-0.4376184046,
-0.3495346308,
-0.127688095,
-0.0540092587,
0.1684634984,
-0.0755601749,
0.9577018023,
-0.0754470453,
-0.1780457199,
0.5435991287,
0.3656184673,
0.8784586787,
-0.5527171493,
0.0236401986,
-0.110641405,
0.0643091947,
0.1079837158,
-0.5978737473,
0.7385750413,
-0.2500663102,
-0.3502174318,
-0.4564804435,
0.9237557054,
-0.7596892118,
-0.5002240539,
0.1919516474,
0.4347477257,
0.2561891675,
-0.0912738442,
-0.6730864048,
0.0469315015,
-0.1444594115,
0.3645969629,
0.4946989417,
0.6429454684,
0.3058379292,
0.2654371858,
0.7026208043,
0.0464273877,
0.1589655727,
0.1706454307,
1.0723308325,
-0.6017941833,
-0.4633015394,
-0.7083761692,
0.2720456719,
-0.1111423746,
-0.1888597459,
0.5241911411,
0.4383082092,
0.5842198133,
-0.2020265609,
0.812995553,
-0.1810392886,
0.4223736525,
-0.524707675,
0.9334902763,
-0.3315765858,
0.132302314,
-0.3221907616,
-0.6362037659,
-0.4835676551,
1.0664615631,
0.1199274659,
-0.0188885834,
0.3919213414,
0.8272113204,
-0.013837846,
0.1287193745,
0.7357053757,
0.5752717257,
0.1058159471,
0.506207943,
0.5647001266,
-0.4240916371,
0.2862169743,
-0.3101289272,
-0.2063095272,
-0.2405727655,
-1.0066484213,
-1.2333670855,
-0.587203145,
-0.2951011062,
-0.2802960277,
0.3423463106,
0.5334169269,
1.1270809174,
-0.8908625245,
-0.2854056954,
0.0591773763,
0.0629422441,
-0.5181376934,
-0.2402328104,
0.0060321623,
-0.680193603,
-0.8265431523,
0.4622859657,
0.3919222951,
0.2070074975,
-0.1162705943,
0.3634997904,
-0.1295430958,
0.8276616335,
0.8090353012,
0.0682813376,
-0.4570657909,
-0.4359684289,
-0.2887852192,
0.0982630849,
0.10633789,
0.6585706472,
-0.7957312465,
0.7556420565,
0.2779488862,
0.5803983212,
0.5698937774,
-0.2457980067,
0.7333623171,
-1.41094625,
0.3580717444,
0.4411356151,
-0.0718170181,
0.2250109315,
-0.3763204217,
0.2358959466,
0.0842637867,
-0.4895369709,
-0.5743943453,
0.2155188024,
-0.9159666896,
-0.638417244,
0.7980967164,
0.0260891393,
-0.0690010861,
-0.575856328,
-0.1204920337,
0.0768145174,
-0.525903821,
1.3061681986,
0.9907105565,
-0.09608569,
-0.4452734292,
-0.5226142406,
0.4948299229,
0.63045156,
-0.5547639728,
0.0700750872,
0.3296171725,
0.1210338101,
0.0536022261,
0.4405803382,
-0.0534971394,
-0.1202179715,
0.3572893739,
0.1380562037,
-0.1658969671,
-0.133997187,
-0.4199507236,
0.1593079865,
-0.0598354079,
-0.2182504237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14677v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14677v1
|
Filter bubbles and affective polarization in user-personalized large language model outputs
| 2023-10-31T18:19:28 | 2023-10-31T18:19:28 |
Tomo Lazovich
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Echoing the history of search engines and social media content rankings, the
advent of large language models (LLMs) has led to a push for increased
personalization of model outputs to individual users. In the past, personalized
recommendations and ranking systems have been linked to the development of
filter bubbles (serving content that may confirm a user's existing biases) and
affective polarization (strong negative sentiment towards those with differing
views). In this work, we explore how prompting a leading large language model,
ChatGPT-3.5, with a user's political affiliation prior to asking factual
questions about public figures and organizations leads to differing results. We
observe that left-leaning users tend to receive more positive statements about
left-leaning political figures and media outlets, while right-leaning users see
more positive statements about right-leaning entities. This pattern holds
across presidential candidates, members of the U.S. Senate, and media
organizations with ratings from AllSides. When qualitatively evaluating some of
these outputs, there is evidence that particular facts are included or excluded
based on the user's political affiliation. These results illustrate that
personalizing LLMs based on user demographics carry the same risks of affective
polarization and filter bubbles that have been seen in other personalized
internet technologies. This ``failure mode" should be monitored closely as
there are more attempts to monetize and personalize these models.
|
[
-0.6750785112,
-0.9214403033,
0.5379905105,
0.1151223779,
-0.4282937348,
0.1782387793,
-0.4456957877,
-0.0575930811,
0.4569545984,
0.6825942993,
-0.4928757548,
-0.6179224253,
-0.7674747705,
-0.0884296969,
-0.3275001943,
1.282540679,
0.4688088298,
-0.086016573,
-0.0340506062,
0.0988721699,
-0.4860476553,
-0.8674458861,
-0.735933125,
-0.4559279978,
0.8354602456,
0.4787763357,
0.9856951833,
0.091278635,
0.2804505825,
0.2339118123,
-0.1120558158,
-0.4309205413,
-0.7665874362,
0.3239332139,
-0.2885397673,
-0.5678362846,
-0.2733408809,
0.2304721922,
0.4114812911,
0.4501880705,
-0.1360515803,
-0.0336691216,
0.1490938216,
0.795296073,
-0.3743888438,
0.1213344038,
-0.7352385521,
0.0340642668,
-0.3219279349,
-0.3209225833,
-0.5179502964,
-0.5790575743,
0.0623074509,
-0.2507862151,
0.1096563935,
0.1348998696,
0.7594297528,
-0.0851068869,
-0.7431103587,
-0.3483590186,
-0.7963955402,
0.6616020799,
-0.7080318928,
0.4298638701,
0.501555264,
0.3130769134,
-0.0672803149,
-0.2470034808,
-0.5109941363,
-0.1984426528,
0.1186692119,
0.2766190767,
-0.3687362075,
0.0558079183,
0.0984683409,
0.1361355484,
-0.3606256843,
0.2089493424,
-0.3177093565,
-0.0659332052,
0.5868173838,
0.0476481132,
0.2408430129,
-0.3673513234,
-0.2853933275,
-0.1214940771,
-0.8862860799,
0.1236283928,
1.0185972452,
0.4530370235,
-0.0630094334,
0.9240015745,
-0.3646843135,
0.4935896397,
0.2213915586,
0.3014991283,
-0.0323013477,
-0.0889873356,
-0.1572678238,
0.2524959147,
0.8951357603,
0.4088346958,
0.5828369856,
0.3530004025,
-0.1070813164,
-0.1686855704,
-0.0014201159,
-0.856824398,
-0.224260658,
0.2797242403,
-0.6131688356,
-0.2933281362,
0.2360959798,
-0.7930351496,
-1.0246690512,
-0.3502492607,
0.2492578626,
-0.0586349331,
-0.168827638,
0.0524847545,
0.0755418986,
-0.0767061114,
0.4247454703,
-0.6729058623,
0.0288564973,
0.8639200926,
0.7148361206,
-0.249499321,
0.1698069125,
-0.7820122242,
-0.2302300334,
-0.2357361466,
0.8376631737,
-0.931016326,
-0.3756979704,
0.4207235277,
-0.0866216645,
0.23318398,
-0.4582407176,
0.3041623831,
-1.0229526758,
0.5622957945,
-0.6807379723,
-0.518640399,
-0.1572270095,
-0.0005002653,
-0.3153165281,
0.4143384099,
-0.2125217468,
-0.774840951,
0.4468322992,
-0.5068644881,
-0.2786973119,
0.1121077165,
-0.0570149533,
-0.3433334231,
0.053406138,
-0.0916083604,
0.7833269238,
-0.263880372,
0.4275726974,
-0.8544773459,
-0.1560163051,
0.5436390042,
-0.3074190617,
0.7747238874,
0.000089134,
-0.4928874969,
0.4495622814,
-0.3815968633,
-0.4796003103,
0.0263983645,
-0.4108947515,
-0.4276686311,
0.4752475321,
0.0558743961,
0.3697488606,
0.231704995,
-0.4612015188,
0.0419129431,
-0.1856665611,
0.3054865301,
1.2183694839,
0.2660435438,
0.2637566924,
-0.1170405075,
0.5125448108,
0.3144514263,
-0.006222398,
-0.0555208363,
-0.8777094483,
-0.7352905273,
-0.0008390765,
-0.0853975192,
0.5540344119,
-0.2063271105,
0.4560926855,
-0.0718348026,
-0.4411611557,
-0.0494294576,
0.1802638769,
-0.0349632129,
0.2997423112,
0.006852285,
-0.1250296682,
-0.1630392671,
-1.0809231997,
-0.5049476624,
-0.4373678863,
-0.0729106814,
0.6908046603,
0.2905677855,
-0.2589220107,
0.7637383342,
-0.7265900373,
-0.2213030905,
-0.154013738,
0.0542779043,
0.4374527633,
-0.1427521706,
0.2017921507,
-0.8787285686,
-0.6449192166,
0.1415053904,
-0.1506385803,
-0.3123902678,
-0.0971010253,
-0.1880401969,
0.1396857351,
0.1142274737,
-0.3897081316,
0.2218875885,
0.8331624866,
-0.7731761336,
0.4057360291,
0.1005213186,
0.3624680638,
-1.1577957869,
-0.1066105887,
0.3694232702,
-0.2886908054,
-0.6249738336,
-0.5166533589,
-0.2584604025,
-0.0305121895,
-0.3401482403,
0.4205752015,
-0.0578142218,
0.0789892823,
-0.1788513064,
0.3096122742,
-0.181834802,
0.1186820865,
-0.1103745252,
0.5198392272,
0.4727699459,
-0.3632992208,
0.3161368668,
0.0725533068,
-0.1968355626,
0.3900228441,
-0.6582534909,
0.2407846451,
-0.2173919231,
0.3021347821,
-1.2473556995,
-0.5486370921,
0.3819786906,
-0.1722821891,
0.0831028149,
-0.2879591882,
-0.2938271165,
-0.0893106237,
-0.3981458545,
-0.0364924856,
0.5058782697,
-0.463136822,
0.3660829067,
0.6590910554,
-0.3611057699,
-0.2870848179,
-0.4519734085,
0.142950654,
-0.5198010802,
-0.5982578397,
0.080796659,
-0.1450571716,
-0.4212817252,
0.0482397936,
0.2479041964,
0.0159818493,
-0.0324604698,
0.4000166953,
0.279340595,
-0.1320479959,
0.1731742322,
-0.0515171699,
0.2410760224,
0.252355665,
0.2659577727,
0.7864823341,
-0.3293046951,
-0.4777303636,
-0.5213394761,
0.3974419534,
0.4264992177,
-0.2902775109,
0.9150610566,
0.5407333374,
-0.071153529,
-0.0623809732,
-0.6955545545,
-0.490283072,
-0.4717021286,
0.2269321233,
0.0152617376,
-1.2707545757,
0.7699798942,
0.3342315257,
-0.0739803091,
0.3416281641,
1.0372239351,
-0.0728895143,
1.3088285923,
0.3628457785,
-0.142446667,
0.6611439586,
0.207029894,
0.4838397503,
-0.4706448913,
-0.2274417579,
-0.5017450452,
-0.1781502962,
-0.9613076448,
-0.0851548463,
0.2719818056,
-0.1638824493,
-0.3358504772,
-0.2020075917,
-0.5167243481,
0.2291766405,
0.531883657,
0.1593690813,
0.2067085057,
0.3404116929,
0.4553871155,
-0.0777452588,
-0.4648341537,
-0.4474503398,
0.9131579995,
0.3341051936,
0.8918703198,
0.2171550244,
0.6900694966,
0.5511940122,
0.6327955723,
-0.8672543764,
0.4295391142,
-0.208136037,
-0.7890204191,
-0.1173767298,
-0.354521364,
-0.9630104899,
0.3301707208,
-0.4204892218,
-0.7202335,
0.2577245533,
0.3936220407,
-0.0998912379,
0.3085544705,
-0.6347464323,
0.6376094818,
-0.0182730407,
-0.2995499671,
-0.4762888551,
-0.3386102021,
0.472872436,
-0.2379865348,
0.2941061258,
-0.4034749568,
-0.0650714934,
0.5830926299,
-0.0283437315,
1.17276299,
-0.28678146,
0.1830690205,
0.1870269328,
0.1544585526,
0.5083078146,
0.2301374525,
-0.1844571829,
0.2158956975,
-0.3085875809,
-0.1360892802,
-0.2965457737,
0.9607256651,
-0.8631373048,
-1.2037467957,
-0.4371660054,
-0.0895036384,
0.0182046425,
0.2406692058,
0.1585027277,
0.1750889421,
-0.1845887899,
0.5144278407,
0.5010058284,
-0.2579064965,
0.1979063004,
0.3358701766,
-0.383299619,
-0.2879588604,
0.7468938231,
0.2873458266,
0.122700274,
-0.0573139191,
0.6254725456,
-0.2327964157,
-0.2665531635,
-0.1071162745,
0.3685903549,
-0.6740407348,
-0.1593499929,
-0.4796417654,
-0.0212116092,
-0.2484861165,
-0.1125078425,
-0.2799631357,
-0.055744838,
-0.5159673095,
0.1586897224,
0.2217569798,
0.9107939005,
0.3633758128,
0.1716544777,
-0.4264020026,
0.1472414732,
0.4755989909,
0.4322065413,
-0.3228564262,
-0.46905604,
-0.0332876444,
-0.0142258722,
-0.3491648734,
-1.4062165022,
0.0955588222,
0.2678991258,
0.3126808405,
0.7727533579,
0.0350301526,
0.0834768042,
-0.3253523707,
0.9577357769,
0.0881948546,
-0.6623612046,
0.5490317941,
-0.6555477381,
0.1247972697,
0.2199821919,
0.545106113,
-0.7465749979,
-0.5345207453,
-0.3441450298,
-0.7460306287,
0.6174004078,
0.0843058825,
0.5820187926,
-0.2835699916,
0.2024246305,
0.1486743689,
0.2981806397,
-0.7708919644,
-0.2747532725,
-0.2877229452,
0.1098564789,
-0.2622895837,
-0.5583286881,
-0.2851267159,
0.0481767207,
0.8618404865,
-0.0138394581,
-0.1495138407,
0.0723177865,
0.3495624065,
-0.1271533966,
0.4343745708,
0.5019353628,
0.4889151454,
-0.2649354935,
0.0969333649,
-0.3038636744,
-0.056106016,
0.0451788157,
-0.1230229363,
-0.1481397599,
-0.1391215622,
-0.0473827384,
0.9466611147,
-0.1163041443,
-0.3493233621,
0.7392688394,
-0.0621093698,
0.1848269701,
-0.2935740054,
-0.0442961156,
0.4017461836,
0.1277768016,
0.2738771439,
-0.0425339639,
0.1981308758,
-0.6687914133,
-0.2425461262,
0.7388421893,
-0.4200757742,
-0.6282958984,
0.707305789,
0.2565989792,
-0.3923552334,
0.4191446304,
0.0856013075,
-0.5559160113,
0.2511723042,
0.5092845559,
0.977202177,
-0.4410218596,
0.4496493042,
0.2548466325,
0.1969427317,
0.2052206993,
0.036916703,
0.1445557773,
-0.8120963573,
-0.2759106159,
-0.5578283072,
-0.5414738655,
0.1538354009,
-0.4886912405,
0.5508337021,
-0.6157797575,
-0.6152546406,
0.1212030053,
-0.112385273,
-0.6046233773,
0.1182114109,
0.4519528747,
0.4658335149,
-1.170542717,
0.4523898661,
0.8718401194,
0.0216066875,
-0.4726326168,
0.0871961862,
0.3552200496,
-0.4294784963,
0.6273031831,
0.1023323685,
-0.2425015122,
-0.3294544816,
-0.3192258775,
-0.7518496513,
0.5382992029,
0.4741296768,
-0.4862750173,
0.3917575777,
0.1746612191,
0.4971255362,
-0.6035922766,
0.2655955851,
0.3010903895,
0.4794771373,
-0.2244508117,
-0.3934812546,
0.2226280719,
0.0296735391,
-0.0859554708,
0.1148558185,
-0.9727969766,
0.7441602945,
0.1152632013,
-0.1474840045,
-0.8057268858,
0.4905488789,
0.2195572108,
0.2619650662,
0.8201891184,
0.060224697,
0.5555023551,
0.0083276695,
1.2742614746,
-0.3688492477,
0.2265716344,
0.7904464006,
-0.1880197525,
0.9858099222,
0.5101482868,
-0.043758072,
0.6081853509,
0.8687919974,
-0.0220946744,
0.2687073648,
0.0142999608,
-0.4528842866,
-0.4412408769,
-0.1441646814,
-0.2220702916,
0.3076218963,
0.2351837605,
-0.4252154827,
0.0057596774,
-0.00753807,
0.3377045691,
0.0199558586,
-0.1446342021,
0.5541368723,
0.0634689927,
-0.880312264,
0.213685438,
-0.0537250973,
0.5404652953,
-0.4302648604,
0.1916977167,
-0.3610109091,
-0.24251993,
-0.5085533261,
-1.0788080692,
0.0389787182,
0.083065778,
-0.2397632599,
-0.2564907074,
0.7579290867,
-0.2808088958,
-0.4514092505,
0.4118469954,
0.4190486968,
0.1963813007,
-0.3385264277,
-0.6825159192,
0.2449409366,
0.2826925814,
-1.090713501,
0.3332067728,
-0.1327044517,
-0.1948012263,
0.7188868523,
0.8588162661,
0.3182173669,
0.0495086014,
0.4208576679,
1.0430321693,
-0.4712712169,
-0.3293428421,
-1.0842797756,
0.4296130538,
-0.0782472044,
-0.248381108,
0.7218708992,
0.5421782732,
0.695356369,
0.0146106798,
0.7465440631,
-0.0354280435,
0.2887763381,
-0.2661816478,
0.8440951109,
-0.5783355832,
0.340618521,
-0.1076465175,
-1.2594889402,
-0.2633588314,
0.1418193281,
-0.6144006848,
0.1748505831,
0.2565597892,
0.9191129804,
-0.1657096893,
-0.1435253322,
0.3173348904,
0.5321061015,
0.6888031363,
0.0913699642,
0.7782883644,
0.2360407114,
0.4792424142,
-0.312916249,
-0.3431304693,
-0.5202249289,
-0.7816735506,
-1.094872117,
-0.740431726,
-0.4901800752,
-0.6087520123,
-0.1223974228,
0.9015902281,
0.6177240014,
-0.8082558513,
-0.2723010182,
0.2047102153,
0.3518536389,
0.5595880747,
-0.2967848778,
0.3194868565,
-0.1223038882,
-0.8473754525,
0.0181943029,
0.3654634953,
-0.1961444914,
-0.3986757696,
0.140400365,
0.1293377876,
0.3954711258,
0.5623678565,
0.2221367955,
-0.9970020652,
-0.5990130901,
-0.073459059,
-0.0285724644,
0.2544509768,
0.6376149058,
-0.5032581687,
0.5411015749,
0.6264020801,
0.201585561,
0.4851444662,
0.3451593816,
0.4525332153,
-0.1417529136,
-0.1044196114,
0.2204951048,
0.2957105637,
0.6215599775,
-0.5846192241,
-0.0937144086,
-0.0011032553,
-0.855463326,
-0.7191697955,
0.3683302402,
-0.9352728128,
0.0336956754,
1.4357466698,
-0.0586229265,
0.006745453,
0.239932254,
-0.3973908126,
0.1087615639,
-0.7419877052,
0.9631355405,
0.9710523486,
-0.3334646523,
-0.0375596285,
-0.7193776369,
0.4763036072,
0.4094200134,
-0.6696375012,
0.0561542884,
0.5456380248,
0.4667405486,
-0.0285947006,
0.4871586263,
0.0265665557,
-0.070813708,
-0.5505827665,
-0.0915591344,
0.1969321221,
0.0179902967,
-0.426104486,
0.4347790182,
0.1357660294,
0.2810716033
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00059v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00059v1
|
The Generative AI Paradox: "What It Can Create, It May Not Understand"
| 2023-10-31T18:07:07 | 2023-10-31T18:07:07 |
Peter West, Ximing Lu, Nouha Dziri, Faeze Brahman, Linjie Li, Jena D. Hwang, Liwei Jiang, Jillian Fisher, Abhilasha Ravichander, Khyathi Chandu, Benjamin Newman, Pang Wei Koh, Allyson Ettinger, Yejin Choi
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
The recent wave of generative AI has sparked unprecedented global attention,
with both excitement and concern over potentially superhuman levels of
artificial intelligence: models now take only seconds to produce outputs that
would challenge or exceed the capabilities even of expert humans. At the same
time, models still show basic errors in understanding that would not be
expected even in non-expert humans. This presents us with an apparent paradox:
how do we reconcile seemingly superhuman capabilities with the persistence of
errors that few humans would make? In this work, we posit that this tension
reflects a divergence in the configuration of intelligence in today's
generative models relative to intelligence in humans. Specifically, we propose
and test the Generative AI Paradox hypothesis: generative models, having been
trained directly to reproduce expert-like outputs, acquire generative
capabilities that are not contingent upon -- and can therefore exceed -- their
ability to understand those same types of outputs. This contrasts with humans,
for whom basic understanding almost always precedes the ability to generate
expert-level outputs. We test this hypothesis through controlled experiments
analyzing generation vs. understanding in generative models, across both
language and image modalities. Our results show that although models can
outperform humans in generation, they consistently fall short of human
capabilities in measures of understanding, as well as weaker correlation
between generation and understanding performance, and more brittleness to
adversarial inputs. Our findings support the hypothesis that models' generative
capability may not be contingent upon understanding capability, and call for
caution in interpreting artificial intelligence by analogy to human
intelligence.
|
[
-0.5058172941,
-0.7233980894,
0.6406892538,
0.0629745573,
0.0205383152,
0.3016565144,
0.0583919771,
-0.6593791842,
-0.2731462717,
0.029122306,
-0.7016432881,
0.3088257909,
-0.8414117098,
0.3086633682,
-0.5234983563,
0.7124248743,
0.095789142,
0.0003212007,
-0.8479002118,
-0.0782106221,
-0.7375552654,
-0.2227181047,
-0.5644631982,
-0.4754055738,
0.1339209527,
0.2681465149,
1.0354768038,
0.5563527942,
0.4019700289,
0.3646655083,
0.091065526,
0.0302721225,
-0.4208669662,
-0.2164258063,
-0.0080515398,
-1.0316390991,
-0.2104607224,
0.1896427423,
0.5321393013,
0.8000600338,
0.214295581,
-0.1427904814,
0.0616018698,
0.8114860654,
-0.3327928483,
0.0652917996,
-0.650740087,
0.2687969506,
-0.0080576846,
-0.0685825199,
-0.2239915133,
-0.0702332482,
-0.0192143638,
-0.7328443527,
1.0205972195,
0.1396669447,
1.0683065653,
0.7944081426,
-0.2107925117,
-0.0131802456,
-1.1253455877,
0.3693608344,
-0.4851375818,
0.0514003597,
0.3306236267,
0.4856313467,
0.0545910858,
-0.4345007539,
-1.1239031553,
-0.6350782514,
0.1242185682,
0.3791932762,
-0.4140180945,
-0.0642279759,
0.6488747597,
0.4345595837,
-0.7160443664,
0.1165777892,
-0.427510947,
0.1330525726,
0.509716332,
0.2218460292,
0.6088162661,
-0.1743757129,
-0.4664539099,
-0.1738529652,
-0.5702388287,
0.0163075514,
0.2828202248,
-0.0322635993,
-0.1245202869,
0.7204152942,
0.0421553068,
0.4124692678,
0.1717566252,
0.3092200756,
-0.0417634733,
-0.2109740674,
-0.1430840641,
-0.2967961729,
0.6710025668,
0.2051012367,
0.2890670002,
-0.3494435549,
-0.0512666777,
0.4278953075,
0.4502729774,
-0.4307948947,
-0.3502183855,
0.087796025,
-0.3168976903,
-0.1676765382,
0.2157332897,
-0.5620550513,
-0.5583420992,
-0.1303854883,
0.5617926121,
-0.436748594,
-0.2733287513,
-0.0763205066,
-0.5502862334,
0.1468831599,
0.1494747847,
-0.9145998359,
0.0495777242,
0.5975269675,
0.582526803,
0.0558867194,
-0.6024166346,
0.0220423006,
-0.1363657266,
-0.5923360586,
0.8356425762,
-0.2896079123,
-0.5504291654,
-0.4862925708,
-0.2684616745,
-0.3011605144,
-0.7119106054,
0.0376151949,
-0.4924648106,
-0.0102184182,
-0.3067968488,
-0.4954896271,
-0.1531125307,
-0.0305418875,
-0.5941439867,
0.2221809328,
0.2375492603,
-0.4997025132,
0.4462447464,
-0.5490655899,
-0.3194732666,
0.3562220633,
-0.6014121175,
-0.3979115486,
0.3540958166,
-0.1175421178,
0.0106605571,
-0.704649806,
0.1961977333,
-0.3772510886,
-0.2724529505,
0.5978059769,
-0.6192904711,
0.7034494877,
0.0900293738,
-0.4460728765,
-0.0788517743,
-0.4401112199,
-0.1979085505,
0.5441775322,
-0.138730377,
0.0524727926,
0.3504519463,
-0.4210739732,
0.0773225352,
0.1318162829,
-0.3553980291,
0.015918605,
-0.1427036524,
0.6682639718,
0.7422429323,
-0.3503465056,
0.6247650981,
-0.6953667402,
0.6042561531,
-0.0930965096,
0.0285926647,
0.0565406978,
-0.5697176456,
-0.9464718103,
-0.0039620642,
0.2604377568,
0.7457522154,
-0.9825308323,
0.3542006016,
-0.5752468109,
-0.2057057917,
-0.7303705215,
0.1933757961,
0.3660741448,
0.6350562572,
0.1395888627,
-0.3910452724,
-0.2077625096,
-0.855974257,
-0.4742012322,
-0.4714508951,
-0.3321753442,
0.4483830035,
0.6993001103,
-0.1992098093,
0.9052767158,
-0.3863518834,
0.0481828265,
-0.2724708021,
0.5718477964,
-0.1963047981,
0.6015810966,
0.4900383353,
-0.9860619903,
-0.0138661293,
-0.1006917655,
-1.2158404589,
0.1710532308,
-0.4670750499,
0.1353067607,
-0.0187761877,
0.3059822619,
-0.888030529,
0.6257333755,
0.0203661807,
-0.1759589761,
0.592702806,
-0.3413138986,
0.079423964,
-0.6090813279,
0.0660215989,
-0.1972191632,
0.2228166312,
-0.5849041939,
0.0103675909,
0.1198752671,
-0.1546475738,
0.0014461812,
0.3448052406,
-0.1848627925,
-0.2039442956,
-0.311047107,
-0.0144109838,
0.1055075601,
0.3644153178,
-0.2008109838,
0.8353298306,
0.3845679164,
-0.4699067473,
0.2840961218,
0.2697269619,
-0.4074141681,
0.6569938064,
-0.9090279341,
0.2291385829,
-0.5486246943,
0.0486907624,
-0.8334819078,
-0.5911254883,
0.1393278688,
-0.7786185145,
0.3518778086,
0.1812274456,
-0.4958707392,
-0.6307299733,
-0.0041655651,
0.496987462,
0.7785586119,
-0.4459932446,
0.7347434163,
-0.2250754833,
0.0297344886,
-0.4816958606,
-0.8749210238,
0.1762237251,
-0.1447681487,
-0.66843611,
0.4104418159,
-0.265666455,
-0.5259288549,
0.3887324035,
-0.0340347737,
-0.0406825729,
0.4542168379,
0.4580157995,
0.262340188,
-0.2194345146,
0.2599082887,
-0.121828936,
-0.1194992959,
0.1939857453,
-0.1426054835,
0.2098203152,
-0.0628342181,
-0.7614148855,
-0.5602018237,
0.4313027859,
0.8212483525,
-0.1580206454,
0.8430613875,
0.3214735985,
-0.2766264677,
-0.0597005263,
-0.3001224101,
-0.0724846572,
-0.4125525653,
0.4479020834,
-0.4741116464,
-0.2951494753,
0.3738426864,
0.1338795424,
-0.1822250634,
0.7960279584,
0.1685974598,
-0.4155934155,
1.1298000813,
0.6378512383,
-0.0657645538,
0.2872980535,
-0.5210184455,
0.3968904912,
-0.5814325213,
-0.433825016,
-0.491068393,
-0.2214847356,
-0.5876021981,
-0.1235687435,
0.2895632088,
0.2415954769,
-0.4114322662,
-0.0816878155,
-0.2065072805,
0.5457516909,
0.7818551064,
0.2605525255,
0.0425882302,
-0.1723876595,
0.4389311075,
0.2788281739,
-1.0018882751,
-0.3891526461,
0.8027710319,
0.2295600474,
0.6112115383,
0.1192115843,
0.1938853264,
0.518435061,
0.342100054,
-0.5545395613,
0.3148905039,
-0.2161851674,
-0.4878719151,
-0.1053441912,
-0.4690805674,
-0.8045207262,
0.0094168913,
-0.4803764522,
-0.2855748832,
0.1833667457,
0.2511265278,
-0.3636411726,
0.5628916025,
-0.8347893953,
0.8354541659,
-0.3269920051,
-0.0937497467,
-0.2586564422,
-0.7295402288,
0.449842751,
-0.053789556,
0.02825322,
-0.0835770145,
0.2052629441,
0.4203506708,
-0.2900880277,
0.8180330992,
0.0450608209,
0.3694616556,
0.2026792467,
-0.0333410688,
0.1830911934,
-0.1102915332,
0.1388353407,
0.0741202086,
-0.5853686929,
-0.8308095336,
-0.8415992856,
0.2001086622,
-1.1331911087,
-1.0131635666,
-0.2849763632,
-0.7149515152,
0.062940672,
-0.0363599584,
0.7303435206,
0.1611288488,
-0.2936657369,
-0.1954542249,
0.5254650116,
-0.1798648536,
0.2638787031,
0.1644988656,
0.4235392213,
0.0518483818,
1.082780838,
0.0290831551,
0.5548307896,
0.2441456169,
0.0134545304,
-0.2029411197,
-0.5408949256,
-0.7015284896,
0.110409528,
-0.7418855429,
0.02761437,
-0.3352867663,
-0.3417963982,
-0.1963800639,
-0.1359744221,
0.0374841541,
-0.2126381248,
-0.5993160009,
0.01991494,
0.1779229492,
0.9266162515,
-0.1492408961,
0.0110031161,
-0.5298898816,
0.580032289,
0.8993180394,
-0.1420581639,
0.278763175,
-0.5849063396,
0.2070176154,
0.2696956098,
-0.4741168916,
-0.8844873905,
0.0838202164,
0.372346133,
0.4550601542,
0.8983651996,
-0.0423994139,
0.5898905993,
-0.443864435,
0.8626646399,
0.1299589872,
-0.9482297301,
0.4031402171,
-0.2450449467,
0.3239013255,
0.3097907901,
0.2935713828,
-0.1179573834,
-0.5125261545,
-0.9096536636,
-0.4933879077,
0.3262924254,
0.3104633093,
0.3378228545,
-0.0617027692,
0.4503994882,
0.1828736514,
0.2137778103,
-0.6613609791,
-0.1644966155,
-0.3724487424,
0.0098646022,
-0.3658750951,
-0.1239929646,
-0.1441977471,
-0.1062510461,
0.2105707228,
0.1956354976,
0.6091432571,
0.1661570817,
-0.0262912977,
-0.2318022847,
0.0942051485,
0.716563642,
0.6794940829,
0.1960147917,
0.2797087729,
0.1899986565,
-0.0738242939,
0.0709071457,
0.2060851604,
-0.2831420004,
-0.4323769808,
0.8384448886,
0.9466229081,
-0.3125185072,
-0.7830436826,
0.3794108629,
-0.1035062671,
-0.3107483089,
-0.3866229951,
0.3973771334,
0.0066852011,
0.3766191602,
0.5541521311,
0.7839781642,
-0.1690203547,
-0.635864675,
0.0075266538,
0.6273556352,
-0.0188084804,
-0.4024367332,
1.1011176109,
0.061519634,
-0.7860279083,
0.8875642419,
-0.4920445383,
-0.6321510077,
1.1536562443,
0.4782529771,
0.870770812,
0.0506124534,
0.1480804831,
0.0325918011,
0.3549377024,
0.0143950023,
-0.0421044976,
-0.1238342524,
-0.9333697557,
-0.1369546652,
-0.1076963022,
-0.2387761027,
0.1084816828,
-0.6156997085,
-0.4165750146,
-0.3684504032,
-0.0767441019,
0.2327323258,
-0.3387231827,
-0.8351073861,
0.1456516087,
-0.1262007505,
0.6655554175,
-1.0789313316,
0.3183813393,
0.3168598413,
-0.6146240234,
-0.4288578331,
0.3826425374,
-0.1657016128,
-0.7897260189,
0.6425507665,
0.3571558893,
-0.0618302412,
-0.0785195976,
-0.7482284307,
-0.2422441095,
0.9754552245,
0.3689726889,
-0.0650632158,
0.0239762869,
0.1862878501,
0.7209792733,
-0.125377804,
-0.1334010214,
0.6417219043,
0.3715906441,
-0.0069081569,
-0.5992648602,
-0.0495380536,
-0.5434764624,
0.1650008708,
-0.0611277744,
-0.4307678938,
0.9909139872,
-0.8556584716,
-0.5595872402,
0.5531720519,
0.7969056964,
-0.1652366966,
0.4885039032,
0.5455221534,
0.7294918895,
0.5878484249,
-0.0859366059,
1.4184777737,
-0.0010877304,
0.0025344698,
0.6683675647,
0.0613141395,
0.4840851426,
0.1809084713,
-0.2487893999,
0.3278741241,
0.6008043885,
-0.2386062443,
0.3769304752,
-0.0430727936,
-0.516510725,
-0.4036960006,
-0.1707698852,
-0.3441741168,
0.4532417953,
0.1039530188,
-0.2370332778,
0.1664895117,
0.1530058533,
-0.3808853328,
0.3576527834,
-0.099742949,
0.6936267614,
-0.1511325836,
-0.7883946896,
0.764586091,
-0.2327073514,
0.3056634068,
-0.1246936098,
-0.0652519539,
-0.2307198942,
-0.0902673081,
0.1365701258,
-0.6638601422,
0.2731689215,
-0.0213067438,
-0.4389144778,
0.115467675,
0.3990928531,
-0.0471751764,
-0.455330193,
0.0348603576,
0.7168868184,
0.1367476881,
0.031043537,
-0.6365846395,
-0.2199872285,
-0.0714385435,
0.4402717948,
0.0651795939,
0.2211471945,
0.1321704239,
0.8856496215,
0.3474247456,
-0.0688804537,
0.058852572,
-0.1288905144,
0.746190846,
-0.4049420059,
-0.1832847297,
-0.9339957237,
0.3450459242,
-0.0079824245,
-0.2684434652,
0.3562684357,
0.1654818654,
0.9222635627,
-0.3192468584,
1.186396122,
-0.2936202884,
-0.1847446263,
-0.3851019144,
0.6342729926,
-0.7669296265,
0.1807792336,
0.0615838543,
-0.3724013269,
-0.0654193908,
0.4008587301,
-0.4310186207,
0.2375556529,
0.5239347816,
0.6155823469,
0.0801149458,
0.0960065052,
0.3889873922,
0.3435065448,
0.0661789179,
0.7323183417,
1.1352427006,
-0.1655285358,
0.2997165322,
-0.02183122,
-0.3000622392,
-0.1309817433,
-0.4641742408,
-0.8702692986,
-0.6934806108,
-0.0575268604,
-0.173239097,
0.1073927656,
0.3628748953,
0.5101278424,
-0.4201003015,
0.2337645143,
-0.7280365229,
0.3272151649,
-0.425183624,
-0.2031059414,
0.2190943956,
-0.2806220949,
-0.782993257,
0.3248745203,
0.0287674628,
0.6145761609,
-0.1657001525,
-0.091340594,
0.4083784521,
0.0584795736,
0.171076715,
0.7175113559,
-0.9356302023,
-0.2344743013,
-0.0084314477,
0.0677461252,
0.0170504488,
0.5931227803,
-0.7238668203,
0.6498981118,
0.4476629496,
0.7538558245,
0.1790602803,
0.0838321,
0.6105210781,
-0.3753703237,
0.0324938893,
0.1304151863,
0.1639019996,
0.3950273097,
-0.4031748176,
0.2655172646,
0.4264169037,
-0.3712902367,
-0.5555084348,
0.6635697484,
-0.6389396787,
-0.6325129271,
0.3979009688,
-0.1901322603,
0.1462321281,
-0.0060436144,
0.0784547925,
0.3749298453,
0.0828594118,
1.46639359,
0.3230699003,
-0.4834258258,
-0.0025631369,
-0.8440487385,
0.518258512,
0.6146486998,
-0.7789862752,
-0.1874333471,
0.1768883169,
0.0966309085,
0.3477219045,
0.3751102388,
0.3201484978,
0.6891834736,
0.4643009305,
-0.1788537502,
-0.0691063404,
-0.3904933631,
-0.3505868912,
0.1289239824,
0.2485901713,
-0.3475035429
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00047v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00047v1
|
Grounding Visual Illusions in Language: Do Vision-Language Models Perceive Illusions Like Humans?
| 2023-10-31T18:01:11 | 2023-10-31T18:01:11 |
Yichi Zhang, Jiayi Pan, Yuchen Zhou, Rui Pan, Joyce Chai
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Vision-Language Models (VLMs) are trained on vast amounts of data captured by
humans emulating our understanding of the world. However, known as visual
illusions, human's perception of reality isn't always faithful to the physical
world. This raises a key question: do VLMs have the similar kind of illusions
as humans do, or do they faithfully learn to represent reality? To investigate
this question, we build a dataset containing five types of visual illusions and
formulate four tasks to examine visual illusions in state-of-the-art VLMs. Our
findings have shown that although the overall alignment is low, larger models
are closer to human perception and more susceptible to visual illusions. Our
dataset and initial findings will promote a better understanding of visual
illusions in humans and machines and provide a stepping stone for future
computational models that can better align humans and machines in perceiving
and communicating about the shared visual world. The code and data are
available at https://github.com/vl-illusion/dataset.
|
[
-0.1937701851,
-0.7516074181,
0.5429655313,
0.1302942783,
-0.3215869367,
0.0120879738,
-0.0213166121,
-0.7318917513,
0.0452457145,
0.7533233762,
-0.298589319,
-0.4146968722,
-0.3131241798,
-0.0356461443,
-0.6004678011,
0.6097837687,
0.1138327345,
0.3721198142,
-0.594440043,
-0.2837285101,
-0.435521692,
-0.6727862358,
-0.1325227171,
-0.3643552959,
0.1192947701,
0.1903533787,
0.9389525652,
0.7283978462,
0.5398586988,
0.2684189677,
0.1054176614,
0.1660849899,
-0.5668535829,
-0.1905250549,
-0.1053830758,
-0.5011197329,
-0.1371992677,
-0.085002616,
0.4395487309,
0.9412732124,
-0.0553255379,
0.1335897595,
0.1969618201,
0.6209834218,
-0.6953063607,
0.1156937331,
-0.538523972,
0.2590707839,
-0.0614101812,
0.1067383215,
-0.2568011582,
-0.1398389488,
0.0179813188,
-0.736023128,
0.4070438147,
0.620041132,
1.156213522,
0.5643595457,
-0.5252666473,
0.1547850519,
-0.8035715818,
0.5694854856,
-0.3376531303,
0.7914350033,
0.3371207118,
0.2424494028,
-0.1108206064,
-0.7116378546,
-0.8058664799,
-0.3948341906,
-0.1200706512,
0.2978954017,
-0.178729713,
0.1455979347,
0.6619026065,
0.3157635629,
-0.7364247441,
0.0476623066,
-0.3764717579,
-0.3441981971,
0.4453208148,
0.2515269816,
0.5210396051,
-0.0635539144,
-0.5814294219,
-0.1823300421,
-0.6509131193,
-0.0890838951,
0.1989122033,
-0.0809846893,
-0.172067821,
0.7589702606,
-0.1692429632,
1.2838029861,
-0.1105630994,
0.0560587682,
0.1511250585,
-0.2868560851,
-0.5327854156,
-0.0523635186,
0.4867082834,
0.8161840439,
0.6920799613,
-0.0542957522,
-0.2622801661,
0.5797428489,
0.5707498789,
-0.2106754333,
-0.3777376413,
-0.1538184881,
-0.4707196951,
-0.4539790452,
0.0294519067,
-0.5136053562,
-0.7878817916,
-0.689453423,
0.7143360376,
-0.3939991593,
-0.0532127619,
0.5994586945,
-0.3261423409,
0.334308207,
0.4515522122,
-0.6382094026,
0.6442799568,
0.5834469199,
0.4216278195,
-0.0392376408,
-0.5496518016,
-0.2878406644,
-0.0266802739,
-0.5017053485,
0.749704957,
-0.4067158699,
-0.0690551773,
-0.0319755673,
-0.1420312226,
0.1520220637,
-0.5354727507,
0.6645807624,
-0.2770781517,
0.2904786468,
-0.4921889305,
-0.4173316658,
-0.041710861,
0.3281945586,
-0.7421019077,
0.7572405934,
-0.3153269589,
-0.8746408224,
0.4901150465,
-0.332000345,
-0.2916000187,
-0.1199497506,
-0.4817758501,
-0.4300911427,
0.574213326,
0.2231196761,
0.2229349017,
-0.1468314081,
-0.1636835039,
-0.3542035818,
-0.3164087832,
0.3897446096,
-0.5356426239,
0.6255942583,
0.188501358,
-0.1048413068,
0.0997664928,
-0.6761462688,
-0.0381572619,
0.3403436244,
-0.0646513775,
-0.7423179746,
0.3210545778,
0.0942733139,
0.2532340586,
0.3741608858,
-0.3574478626,
0.4045425951,
-0.3660843372,
0.1810998172,
0.5816110373,
-0.1443760544,
0.3925445974,
-0.082100518,
0.1248701662,
0.232541889,
0.3026985228,
0.0298505351,
-0.5503971577,
-0.7458937168,
0.1212852374,
-0.0478087664,
0.5987471938,
-0.9015115499,
0.1183828115,
-0.4654749632,
-0.050656084,
-0.5062699914,
0.0401187278,
0.6694859266,
0.8255680203,
0.2342625409,
-0.3151197135,
-0.6407392621,
-1.1345522404,
-0.4842885733,
-0.2829537988,
-0.011364908,
0.0056622098,
0.6578413248,
-0.0107556032,
1.2754977942,
-0.6486762762,
-0.1972021759,
0.0475722365,
0.0106590465,
-0.1437553018,
0.4121316969,
0.6607168317,
-1.233325839,
-0.3168860674,
0.03194803,
-1.065789938,
-0.1202312037,
-0.0355889127,
0.0049039959,
0.2704128623,
0.3648704588,
-0.2710970342,
0.6413521171,
0.7161380053,
-0.6873420477,
0.5235645771,
-0.2552906871,
0.08292225,
-0.9064926505,
-0.1020028293,
0.1139800996,
-0.3751606047,
-0.911734283,
-0.1098002866,
0.1013655439,
-0.1031024754,
-0.2803270519,
0.5165845156,
-0.6693367362,
-0.5579997301,
-0.1670321822,
0.0315926075,
0.2369344234,
0.3651985228,
0.3962028623,
0.6169140339,
0.7679103613,
-0.2195232362,
0.1854492575,
0.0942945629,
-0.514692843,
0.7945485711,
-0.5474562645,
0.1137438193,
-0.4978587031,
0.1291586459,
-0.8367149234,
-0.3518572152,
0.4708574712,
-0.5242046714,
0.1183729544,
0.0096382843,
-0.4153715372,
-0.3244704604,
-0.0625757053,
0.3022763133,
0.5928508043,
-0.5145601034,
0.4818401039,
0.3367676735,
0.6160979271,
-0.8116623163,
-0.7074274421,
0.4510391057,
-0.282400161,
-0.4930707514,
0.2356724143,
-0.0204204228,
-0.7378971577,
0.2231952101,
-0.1802197993,
-0.2647242844,
0.0483529493,
0.4493305087,
0.1094476134,
-0.1598440707,
-0.1028510332,
-0.3131935596,
0.1272406727,
-0.0348878838,
-0.5801060796,
0.428268075,
-0.4203943014,
-0.7692924142,
-0.357010603,
0.1801495403,
0.7480264902,
-0.3042585552,
0.622674346,
0.3648785055,
-0.7734659314,
0.2056789249,
-0.547913909,
-0.0881510973,
-0.4207281768,
0.3222464323,
-0.7026365995,
-0.4840508997,
0.4208480418,
0.2267422378,
-0.0769552886,
0.3295979202,
0.3212076128,
-0.4814745784,
1.2296878099,
0.7135530114,
-0.0805367678,
0.4302299917,
-0.2084722966,
-0.2272809446,
-0.4721339345,
-0.250425756,
-0.2833452821,
-0.2744556963,
-0.0161828939,
-0.4807220995,
0.2267976701,
0.3685669899,
0.1174230948,
0.1792548895,
-0.3504971266,
0.6287683249,
0.6087875962,
0.1435831934,
0.277017653,
0.3034283221,
0.0601887889,
-0.3463867307,
-0.6352024078,
-0.5747390389,
0.8173126578,
0.1667679101,
0.7240871787,
-0.0579381138,
0.5260497332,
0.3974938691,
0.0400007069,
-0.4810349345,
0.4498620331,
-0.0155202681,
-0.4246271849,
-0.3041503131,
-0.1643541306,
-0.9076778293,
0.3756628633,
-0.5171984434,
-0.7066376805,
0.3088262975,
0.6695142984,
0.0877938867,
0.2679107189,
-0.6360301971,
1.0170229673,
-0.5591998696,
-0.3001438975,
-0.2154315561,
-0.8212081194,
0.4910660386,
0.1283458769,
0.1976865232,
0.2547199428,
-0.0597460754,
0.3915374279,
-0.3328272104,
1.0299241543,
-0.1223474666,
-0.2451585233,
0.1003075689,
-0.0090230675,
0.4264906347,
-0.383177042,
0.2324594408,
0.2788133621,
-0.3115435541,
-0.6169656515,
-0.8082978129,
0.2402045876,
-0.6957550645,
-0.4355014861,
-0.3597992063,
-0.3178513348,
-0.1291662157,
0.2043953538,
0.3779139519,
0.7168371677,
-0.4882202446,
-0.0878574997,
0.6906371117,
-0.0950063094,
-0.0027467266,
0.3490595222,
-0.4598535597,
-0.2620746195,
1.052598238,
0.1312316656,
0.4322621226,
0.4645400047,
0.0891226903,
-0.1207905859,
-0.5245196223,
-0.5015041232,
0.1499372721,
-0.7386806011,
0.145685643,
-0.4115287662,
-0.081652157,
-0.3921468258,
-0.02033896,
-0.2149475962,
-0.2335704863,
-0.2886922359,
-0.1146983281,
0.217311725,
0.8978446126,
-0.0122651765,
0.2165899128,
-0.5304160714,
0.6492390633,
0.3805295825,
0.330694139,
-0.3433226943,
-0.4063106775,
-0.369171977,
0.2549533844,
0.1405225545,
-0.7862099409,
0.2833509445,
0.1521429718,
0.599781692,
0.6261343956,
0.0807390586,
0.9436554313,
-0.7369328737,
0.7625253797,
0.2482353002,
-0.7793031931,
0.1821217388,
-0.1671446264,
0.0594034679,
0.360558182,
0.0465831235,
-0.7611602545,
-0.347655952,
-0.5026289225,
-0.2549531162,
0.4261210263,
0.4440892637,
0.0660180077,
0.3174873292,
0.2907868624,
-0.0926452354,
0.1533444524,
-0.7306096554,
-0.2820309997,
-0.6428864598,
-0.2918304801,
-0.2077075988,
-0.2364135683,
-0.2890604436,
-0.172889933,
-0.0270788968,
-0.1521947384,
0.1837834567,
0.1425631046,
-0.4047060013,
-0.0830712691,
-0.2207025737,
1.0181620121,
0.5801663995,
-0.0360979885,
0.5170971751,
0.3221030533,
-0.6678328514,
-0.077538155,
-0.3548976183,
-0.0493209511,
-0.177461639,
0.7138870955,
1.0645747185,
0.0515401326,
-0.7414122224,
0.5270575285,
-0.216293171,
-0.2461178154,
-0.3731688559,
0.0805441365,
0.006555351,
0.1391821206,
0.2102246732,
0.3383802176,
0.0859891921,
-0.573225379,
-0.0450837649,
0.3628585935,
-0.414588213,
-0.5312329531,
0.7828464508,
0.0194405988,
-0.6406440139,
0.5587163568,
0.2313992232,
-0.7790490985,
0.4798904955,
0.6120789647,
0.7219522595,
0.12153586,
-0.1593537331,
-0.1028423011,
0.5039708018,
-0.2486087829,
0.5459810495,
0.0725071579,
-1.0932403803,
-0.2881424427,
-0.4454944432,
-0.3704112172,
0.0338394083,
-0.6011459231,
0.2572544217,
-0.1245940775,
0.180308789,
-0.3676902652,
-0.2907567918,
-0.5440243483,
0.4585946798,
0.5515062213,
0.8090621829,
-1.2598847151,
0.9650044441,
0.8582485914,
-0.339323312,
-0.3606456518,
0.2410843074,
0.1004891768,
-0.8066959381,
0.600630641,
-0.0533975586,
-0.422493428,
0.0370263755,
-0.8844325542,
-0.8809911013,
0.7197790146,
0.5401563644,
-0.4980455935,
-0.1627278477,
0.3250849247,
0.7499328852,
-0.1723365784,
-0.3537265658,
0.3026876152,
0.5311102271,
-0.3376576304,
-0.850082159,
-0.3673402071,
-0.2003578544,
-0.0387167744,
0.0958643034,
-0.4203668237,
0.6759999394,
-0.0545332842,
-0.1732033044,
-0.191596359,
0.7173152566,
0.1742049903,
0.4602168798,
0.6844228506,
0.7942194939,
0.6381625533,
0.0538703464,
1.0838822126,
-0.2491909266,
0.2353448719,
1.043415904,
-0.3651358783,
0.6067127585,
0.5345206261,
0.0124926642,
0.2529520988,
0.4043425322,
0.1281962991,
0.3436068296,
0.1558924019,
0.0228880793,
-0.5919368863,
-0.0046777874,
-0.148047179,
0.4391287565,
0.5135698915,
-0.1769537032,
0.0995003134,
0.2723238468,
-0.4423148632,
0.4551220834,
-0.2362483591,
0.7585465908,
0.0725379661,
-0.4568302631,
0.5907782912,
-0.2801988125,
0.3197834492,
-0.1779286563,
-0.1616573781,
-0.0999217629,
0.0460112318,
-0.1001438573,
-0.8715394139,
0.2531290352,
-0.0426357463,
-0.2672027946,
-0.3662793934,
0.8336427212,
-0.3223885,
-0.386282891,
0.0247495361,
0.3557666838,
0.4703829885,
-0.0748368427,
-0.6908295751,
0.1834035963,
-0.0183070973,
-0.0840106383,
0.1685983986,
0.2670896351,
-0.5831220746,
0.6913378835,
0.405393213,
0.1541366279,
0.3464927375,
0.2240109891,
0.5787551999,
-0.6645264626,
-0.1497644484,
-0.8889306188,
0.6156129837,
-0.4031955004,
-0.2348386794,
0.8451775312,
0.7257067561,
0.8519102335,
-0.2946090102,
0.6418725848,
0.1212648749,
0.1894537807,
-0.7311838865,
0.7202409506,
-0.855327785,
-0.1920410544,
-0.3895569444,
-0.8786892891,
-0.5569311976,
0.6570506096,
-0.204411447,
-0.37126863,
0.3992586434,
0.6540068388,
-0.318862319,
-0.3281805217,
0.7564213872,
0.2052863836,
0.0692243204,
0.2325803638,
1.1501791477,
-0.1992157698,
0.4079004228,
-0.2211842239,
0.1329263002,
-0.3451607823,
-0.6413792372,
-0.7955907583,
-0.7726595998,
-0.2002694309,
-0.2222308815,
0.1862951368,
0.7528357506,
0.5961087346,
-0.4645388126,
-0.2502267659,
-0.3394718468,
0.1484805495,
-0.3556619585,
-0.1276609451,
0.2331235856,
-0.083339937,
-0.8795583248,
0.3007923365,
0.2890799046,
0.406083405,
-0.447070092,
-0.231687516,
0.1952626258,
0.0149578108,
0.5549545288,
0.3763575852,
-1.0860202312,
-0.586365819,
0.1126177236,
-0.3774470091,
0.1200326458,
0.5688427091,
-1.0439212322,
0.6165020466,
0.5300341249,
0.2299999893,
0.2359960973,
0.2511031628,
0.6823603511,
-0.6251507401,
0.1955614686,
-0.0359680951,
0.5484901071,
0.2513125539,
-0.0904747024,
0.4173626304,
0.4120484591,
-0.2196660489,
-1.1096785069,
0.5322400331,
-1.0299055576,
-0.2454544753,
0.8543358445,
0.2615632415,
-0.3057944775,
-0.107575044,
-0.5401582718,
0.0828686357,
0.0534868576,
0.8004299998,
0.5327581167,
-0.0739435554,
-0.1297104657,
-0.5399678349,
0.6703795791,
0.3199030757,
-0.6673724651,
0.0728609189,
0.8040598035,
0.2812672555,
0.1825333685,
0.3463037312,
0.4866313636,
0.350001663,
0.1500278413,
0.2223976105,
-0.0381198749,
-0.6089266539,
-0.7049645185,
0.0856875628,
0.039747335,
-0.3239474595
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20707v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20707v2
|
What's In My Big Data?
| 2023-10-31T17:59:38 | 2024-03-05T20:02:31 |
Yanai Elazar, Akshita Bhagia, Ian Magnusson, Abhilasha Ravichander, Dustin Schwenk, Alane Suhr, Pete Walsh, Dirk Groeneveld, Luca Soldaini, Sameer Singh, Hanna Hajishirzi, Noah A. Smith, Jesse Dodge
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large text corpora are the backbone of language models. However, we have a
limited understanding of the content of these corpora, including general
statistics, quality, social factors, and inclusion of evaluation data
(contamination). In this work, we propose What's In My Big Data? (WIMBD), a
platform and a set of sixteen analyses that allow us to reveal and compare the
contents of large text corpora. WIMBD builds on two basic capabilities -- count
and search -- at scale, which allows us to analyze more than 35 terabytes on a
standard compute node. We apply WIMBD to ten different corpora used to train
popular language models, including C4, The Pile, and RedPajama. Our analysis
uncovers several surprising and previously undocumented findings about these
corpora, including the high prevalence of duplicate, synthetic, and low-quality
content, personally identifiable information, toxic language, and benchmark
contamination. For instance, we find that about 50% of the documents in
RedPajama and LAION-2B-en are duplicates. In addition, several datasets used
for benchmarking models trained on such corpora are contaminated with respect
to important benchmarks, including the Winograd Schema Challenge and parts of
GLUE and SuperGLUE. We open-source WIMBD's code and artifacts to provide a
standard set of evaluations for new text-based corpora and to encourage more
analyses and transparency around them.
|
[
-0.6712071896,
-0.9545345902,
0.4726008475,
0.210007146,
-0.0929342359,
0.162013635,
-0.4379091859,
-0.5293681026,
0.3796724677,
0.9956805706,
-0.2671036124,
-0.7987957001,
-0.880081594,
0.1522572339,
-0.4950138927,
1.25478971,
0.111274384,
-0.0705008656,
-0.2203467637,
-0.2502321899,
-0.5892726779,
-0.6790730953,
0.1336025894,
0.0898705646,
0.6731078625,
0.6609551907,
0.8728448749,
0.7092149854,
0.6000369191,
0.3343569338,
-0.2522547543,
-0.0260788053,
-0.6067658067,
0.049500186,
-0.5242553353,
-0.2120375782,
-0.0571335629,
-0.0624752119,
0.5821318626,
0.9420973659,
-0.0310963839,
0.5234103799,
-0.140989989,
0.5887070298,
-0.9031355977,
0.2826346457,
-0.4643557966,
-0.0477202609,
-0.4590462148,
0.0833743364,
-0.2990916073,
-0.3344676197,
-0.1104037985,
-0.4965836108,
0.1075491309,
-0.0541862808,
0.6329542398,
0.0353944637,
-0.6536450982,
-0.5671069026,
-0.8232246637,
0.7127187848,
-0.5029498339,
0.3635151982,
0.5202388763,
0.3438600898,
-0.275156796,
-0.6899524331,
-0.780587852,
-0.0161281619,
-0.1962811649,
-0.1914853901,
-0.3829925358,
-0.2397364229,
0.4072023034,
0.4481501579,
-0.8521695733,
0.3608501554,
-0.586896956,
-0.2464450598,
0.6563478112,
-0.0097835604,
0.2550493479,
-0.1013406813,
-0.3051080406,
-0.2114052325,
-0.6838168502,
-0.5234538913,
0.4839555621,
0.0408982188,
0.0661012307,
0.7234681249,
-0.1280504167,
0.6256144643,
-0.2233420014,
0.1055750102,
0.4796741307,
-0.3021382093,
-0.274415493,
0.0879846439,
0.8715103865,
0.0668873861,
0.0456222221,
-0.2767656147,
0.1137791798,
0.0500639044,
0.1461999267,
-0.8101502657,
-0.1954023838,
0.4403904974,
-0.4104348421,
-0.2660523057,
-0.1015637964,
-0.7098740339,
-0.3921176493,
-0.4715256691,
0.4562932551,
-0.4931230545,
-0.3724365532,
0.3310258687,
-0.2452067137,
-0.1093887091,
-0.0450869314,
-1.1259775162,
0.3135559857,
1.1547769308,
0.6258748174,
-0.1009212732,
-0.4495120943,
-0.5121449828,
0.0806696713,
-0.6127283573,
0.7508431673,
-0.685188055,
-0.2568553388,
0.0202207062,
0.2915606201,
0.1438051462,
-0.8325522542,
0.4358223975,
-0.3889914453,
0.3555131853,
-0.5280658007,
-0.5122201443,
-0.1834621727,
0.0850428268,
-0.9974324107,
1.0341213942,
0.22486718,
-1.1175714731,
0.3777876794,
-0.5590600967,
-0.2099263966,
0.390946418,
-0.1386057884,
-0.052222807,
0.114792794,
-0.1457482278,
0.5412251949,
-0.3484787941,
0.495518446,
-0.5797166824,
-0.7178764343,
0.513130188,
-0.0721960962,
0.9362539649,
0.5063022375,
-0.3164791465,
0.0948349833,
-0.7438908815,
-0.1317283362,
-0.0592453033,
-0.1816187948,
-0.554597795,
-0.115129441,
0.3665133119,
0.1548866332,
0.2799746096,
-0.7418667078,
0.2944194078,
-0.0497560017,
0.458865881,
0.6312178373,
0.0709541664,
0.0580587462,
-0.1399489343,
0.4090289772,
0.0081558106,
-0.0577200465,
0.0005941511,
-0.453807503,
-0.228922531,
-0.3305093944,
0.6009122133,
0.2120084614,
-0.4197379947,
0.7902097702,
-0.4420847595,
-0.7174423933,
-0.7112215161,
0.2156316489,
0.2249707282,
0.2236394137,
0.2013466358,
-0.0812615305,
-0.4471483827,
-1.2494363785,
0.1821311265,
0.0160951465,
-0.3081346452,
-0.2814014852,
0.8869162202,
-0.5510673523,
0.8436357379,
-0.7208355069,
-0.110877268,
-0.0698027685,
0.1844035536,
0.2042419463,
0.3159654438,
0.3857615888,
-0.9502531886,
-0.1952669621,
0.077748917,
-0.6604924202,
-0.1772855967,
0.4229446948,
-0.3100811243,
-0.2144455016,
0.5663335919,
-0.6347965002,
-0.1317844093,
1.0154020786,
-0.5855672359,
0.7286667824,
-0.3341312706,
0.3131412268,
-1.0333789587,
0.4601522386,
-0.3168391287,
0.0654377341,
-0.2625347078,
0.4240761995,
0.3267713785,
-0.3592028618,
-0.1654010564,
0.2848387957,
-0.1639151573,
-0.1749244779,
-0.1416642517,
0.3340576291,
0.0609667189,
0.0926773101,
-0.2912895083,
0.5800939798,
0.4475236237,
-0.3512705564,
0.4692057967,
0.5095875263,
-0.7183369398,
0.3347958922,
-0.3581961691,
0.1492340416,
-0.3203829825,
0.3123599589,
-0.8712412119,
-0.3807647824,
-0.0682621971,
-0.3517175913,
0.2003987134,
-0.1355348825,
-0.9018679857,
-0.3986338973,
-0.2953141332,
0.2014014572,
0.3082385957,
-0.7593072057,
0.1784236282,
0.7942634821,
-0.5018529892,
-0.7249590158,
-0.716358304,
0.3184697032,
-0.0867501646,
-0.6843832135,
0.224686265,
-0.456646502,
-0.5167089701,
0.2362015247,
0.2370661348,
-0.2901409864,
0.173665002,
0.4041619003,
0.0624133646,
-0.2096685171,
0.470217526,
0.0919979215,
0.0009296091,
0.0815283954,
-0.0892570019,
0.6578637958,
-0.0799744278,
-0.1871288866,
-0.0033211098,
0.5833464265,
0.7184861302,
-0.2718380094,
0.6242725253,
0.6705811024,
-0.3981045485,
-0.1416971833,
-0.5993204713,
0.2482182831,
-0.4569601119,
0.4544021189,
-0.0541252643,
-1.0671359301,
0.206017822,
0.1438118666,
0.1529495269,
0.4443816543,
0.6921072006,
-0.1324215233,
0.8498284817,
0.7676287293,
-0.3994088173,
0.0731751099,
-0.182226494,
0.1499720812,
-0.521225512,
-0.2666634619,
-0.8431737423,
-0.2745625079,
-0.8750638366,
-0.5957641602,
-0.0256201383,
-0.0589685999,
-0.25383389,
0.4397150874,
-0.3380145729,
0.610286057,
0.2998339236,
-0.3601454496,
0.6360828876,
-0.2184992135,
0.3929063678,
-0.0922034681,
-0.3683932424,
-0.5905460119,
1.0725513697,
0.4836399257,
0.541623652,
0.0104490425,
0.6658499837,
0.4037682414,
0.4625396132,
-0.6208901405,
0.4254170656,
-0.2868421674,
-1.0503274202,
-0.1437637955,
-0.6165627241,
-1.2264097929,
0.4112978578,
-0.4077234566,
-0.6147098541,
0.0160693768,
-0.0811268315,
0.2080279738,
0.2830538154,
-0.8556813002,
0.8595554829,
-0.0692285076,
0.0867791176,
-0.4240480661,
-0.2247010171,
0.6147702932,
-0.422121644,
0.5383826494,
-0.0935266316,
-0.0840682313,
0.8374190927,
-0.3282326758,
0.3872787654,
0.0041145119,
-0.2202682793,
0.2010577172,
0.1790239066,
0.3402677476,
-0.1923628598,
0.0373643562,
0.4722858071,
0.3214536309,
-0.4927025437,
-0.3311010003,
1.0702586174,
-0.3560638726,
-0.1684471071,
-0.3340598643,
-0.5063298941,
-0.1880000085,
0.2649490237,
0.2146980911,
0.273874253,
-0.3361402452,
0.748942554,
0.6727766395,
-0.4847127497,
0.2260366231,
0.4406350255,
-0.2565715909,
-0.0684697479,
1.0046314001,
0.2191882282,
0.0536076836,
0.4071391523,
0.3033669591,
-0.1559978724,
-0.4303649664,
-0.419180125,
0.3670318425,
-0.6010623574,
-0.0338638201,
-0.8210965991,
0.1795392632,
-0.5116020441,
0.0285252295,
-0.1267068833,
-0.1039148569,
0.2169617414,
-0.4446524382,
0.1279754788,
0.9579972029,
0.0468760394,
0.2314451635,
-0.6630672812,
0.297445029,
-0.0554114804,
0.5364213586,
-0.1933160871,
0.0222240724,
-0.3631402552,
-0.0594819896,
-0.0845553502,
-0.6279607415,
0.4213262498,
-0.3407343626,
0.2426682711,
0.4432673454,
-0.1203088388,
0.2491893172,
-0.3458510339,
0.6063275933,
0.0820108876,
-0.7191878557,
-0.0552681871,
-0.2865697742,
0.2362772971,
0.579287529,
0.8007183075,
-0.7185364962,
-0.5124682784,
-0.6718986034,
-0.5969298482,
0.2696097791,
0.1266319007,
0.0855314806,
-0.1746727973,
-0.1442313641,
0.3650910258,
0.3366602361,
-0.5132314563,
0.0130500654,
0.1418978274,
-0.3643895984,
-0.215294674,
-0.2131023407,
-0.2026570737,
0.1691609025,
0.3549462557,
0.0491519608,
-0.114453502,
-0.3184497356,
-0.1723473519,
0.0196469389,
0.2831639051,
0.0845247656,
0.8187161684,
-0.2901301682,
0.0824547932,
0.0888905302,
-0.9444262385,
-0.2407379597,
-0.1224584952,
0.0492472574,
0.2687219083,
0.5556660891,
0.2462766618,
0.386043787,
-1.175585866,
0.6580514312,
-0.0880940929,
-0.3136800826,
-0.275628686,
-0.105243884,
0.3937430382,
0.0089342101,
0.362977773,
-0.4483813941,
0.3296591938,
-0.8535314202,
0.2156050056,
0.2078481764,
-0.2351451069,
-0.1779572219,
0.3242374957,
-0.1775469035,
0.0909116715,
0.6295759678,
-0.1099074185,
-0.1915284097,
0.5725090504,
0.4347786307,
0.4137882888,
-0.0035260171,
0.340326339,
0.2977020442,
0.3399134874,
0.1006698832,
0.2644839883,
0.1915835887,
-0.4104008675,
-0.6654723883,
-0.8346765637,
-0.5122129917,
0.6105839014,
-0.651103735,
0.3866347671,
-0.5031685233,
0.1341246665,
0.496232003,
0.0547452085,
-0.681322515,
0.2670709491,
0.0176737718,
0.8144289851,
-0.9988515973,
0.6466290951,
-0.0543595515,
-0.1958634406,
-0.4243574739,
-0.1274511367,
-0.0536755174,
-0.478640914,
0.6155291796,
0.0610318333,
0.2304496169,
-0.3800627291,
-0.7778092623,
-1.0138251781,
0.7013744116,
0.4419219792,
-0.6448902488,
-0.0000111854,
-0.022978127,
0.6034764051,
-0.1330994517,
0.0814866647,
0.7827929258,
0.7610011697,
-0.2392853647,
-0.5088045597,
0.1000288799,
-0.3205291629,
-0.2497016042,
0.5718957782,
-0.361115694,
0.8580736518,
-0.0888757631,
-0.2250331491,
-0.1054092571,
0.244913578,
-0.0218121298,
0.1876161993,
0.4402514398,
0.4957788587,
0.8948549032,
-0.0645772815,
1.0955617428,
-0.0432414785,
0.2034660429,
1.2798249722,
-0.2758133411,
0.9713896513,
0.1576213986,
0.009977052,
0.6202168465,
0.5283509493,
-0.385661453,
0.0496441461,
0.3463025391,
-0.0863726661,
0.2249228358,
0.0780281276,
-0.4215105176,
0.5102900267,
0.4863937795,
-0.2475720048,
-0.1957095116,
0.217802152,
0.1554421335,
0.170210883,
-0.0221060254,
0.6699625254,
-0.2828933895,
-0.4967462122,
0.4256460965,
0.0644450411,
0.5636699796,
-0.6016692519,
-0.0653442442,
-0.0939365104,
-0.0747138932,
-0.4537631869,
-0.9196513295,
0.3382054269,
0.0003857327,
-0.2523359358,
0.0847395733,
0.3310284317,
-0.5743336678,
-0.2729286253,
0.5089493394,
0.0681788176,
0.3804154098,
-0.3834173679,
-0.1274728328,
0.2889258862,
-0.2164256573,
0.0221936554,
0.678832233,
0.6259058714,
-0.2752894759,
0.5892157555,
0.8780294061,
0.251714617,
-0.2561475635,
0.0115176793,
0.8034403324,
-0.9716733098,
-0.3803758621,
-0.5238348246,
0.1492270082,
-0.2581197917,
-0.5643633008,
0.6319875121,
0.9946033955,
0.9688667655,
-0.1505691856,
0.7949668169,
-0.1747357994,
0.7013491988,
-0.3509153724,
0.9092988968,
-0.146370098,
-0.1363638788,
-0.4582595527,
-1.0759205818,
0.0769280568,
0.134311378,
-0.2486646324,
-0.5692536235,
0.746812582,
0.6833705306,
-0.2394814044,
0.1638138145,
0.3617761135,
0.574688077,
0.4166714549,
0.2732622027,
0.6699048877,
-0.2028520703,
0.7091224194,
-0.259180069,
-0.4222228229,
-0.359113723,
-0.6386861801,
-0.4668536782,
-0.9391362071,
-0.2218827754,
-0.3775691688,
-0.1797025055,
0.6299361587,
0.5330799818,
-0.6813798547,
-0.2589792907,
0.3529797792,
0.0819973275,
-0.0046506273,
-0.224509716,
0.4185028672,
-0.0835475177,
-0.619795084,
0.4655424654,
0.1205560118,
-0.2055899203,
-0.3193579018,
0.1949628443,
-0.0623772927,
-0.0421007387,
0.821225822,
0.2271173,
-0.0973332375,
-0.2402023822,
-0.2679183781,
-0.2738023102,
-0.2782232165,
0.7612035275,
-0.4923474491,
0.5332736969,
0.5117132068,
0.6130039692,
0.8503360152,
-0.019288294,
0.4374603033,
-0.48016271,
0.2053483129,
0.3724823594,
0.3188492656,
0.2713308632,
-0.3402636349,
0.5139778852,
-0.1184015721,
-0.5079880953,
-0.9084811807,
-0.0466813818,
-0.879543364,
-0.7039033175,
1.0805604458,
0.0631297007,
-0.3385281861,
-0.3049468994,
-0.3754149079,
-0.149286449,
-0.0628069192,
0.9293039441,
0.8620234132,
0.3485975266,
0.4831495881,
-0.8732506037,
0.3463675678,
0.0524774417,
-0.8019562364,
0.4041810632,
0.8036520481,
0.5413148999,
0.3889019191,
0.441825062,
-0.4649412632,
0.11901889,
0.0907220915,
0.0989799276,
0.0606031045,
-0.276784271,
-0.3630430102,
0.3209216595,
-0.1213035956,
-0.0486933216
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20703v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20703v3
|
Vanishing Gradients in Reinforcement Finetuning of Language Models
| 2023-10-31T17:59:05 | 2024-03-14T08:05:18 |
Noam Razin, Hattie Zhou, Omid Saremi, Vimal Thilak, Arwen Bradley, Preetum Nakkiran, Joshua Susskind, Etai Littwin
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
Pretrained language models are commonly aligned with human preferences and
downstream tasks via reinforcement finetuning (RFT), which refers to maximizing
a (possibly learned) reward function using policy gradient algorithms. This
work identifies a fundamental optimization obstacle in RFT: we prove that the
expected gradient for an input vanishes when its reward standard deviation
under the model is small, even if the expected reward is far from optimal.
Through experiments on an RFT benchmark and controlled environments, as well as
a theoretical analysis, we then demonstrate that vanishing gradients due to
small reward standard deviation are prevalent and detrimental, leading to
extremely slow reward maximization. Lastly, we explore ways to overcome
vanishing gradients in RFT. We find the common practice of an initial
supervised finetuning (SFT) phase to be the most promising candidate, which
sheds light on its importance in an RFT pipeline. Moreover, we show that a
relatively small number of SFT optimization steps on as few as 1% of the input
samples can suffice, indicating that the initial SFT phase need not be
expensive in terms of compute and data labeling efforts. Overall, our results
emphasize that being mindful for inputs whose expected gradient vanishes, as
measured by the reward standard deviation, is crucial for successful execution
of RFT.
|
[
-0.8221033812,
-0.9106031656,
0.351339668,
0.1508001834,
-0.1710053533,
-0.0996897221,
-0.3726986349,
0.0443638079,
-0.0546321049,
0.4667753279,
-1.0924596786,
-0.1235138997,
-0.6568400264,
-0.1911491752,
-0.3518229425,
1.7564023733,
-0.267568022,
-0.251113236,
-0.1103278995,
0.0148366774,
-0.2685425282,
-0.0687504262,
-0.9608888626,
-0.3887060583,
0.6271399856,
0.5646765828,
0.485065639,
0.7440249324,
0.4080857038,
0.2210526466,
-0.1128731892,
0.0395745821,
-0.9460418224,
0.0037380562,
-0.1051942185,
-0.3358614743,
0.1406733543,
0.1347540915,
0.6526656151,
0.890566349,
-0.4272931516,
-0.0611672737,
0.4675520658,
1.058068037,
-0.571593225,
0.0847723857,
-0.2590022981,
0.1534918696,
-0.3612734079,
-0.1944598556,
0.0845343024,
-0.4566622674,
0.3204009533,
-0.5390654802,
0.513012886,
-0.1220315993,
1.0723663568,
0.5290337205,
-0.1182938144,
-0.1308694482,
-1.0806626081,
0.9611994624,
-0.2945097685,
0.401016742,
0.5728705525,
0.3565927744,
-0.3582571745,
-0.4620489478,
-0.3843457997,
-0.410253346,
0.1197163016,
0.0317997187,
-0.3450914919,
0.504596889,
0.2777976394,
0.5601917505,
-0.3865229487,
0.2045949548,
-0.3388528824,
-0.1754430383,
0.3475076854,
0.2694410384,
-0.1539700925,
-0.0276317727,
-0.3418469131,
-0.1453339159,
-0.7391493917,
0.5715102553,
0.4384264052,
0.4478783011,
-0.1592921317,
0.3296988904,
-0.5217283368,
0.3545919657,
0.1995040327,
0.2661317885,
-0.1347656697,
-0.4069969058,
-0.1449591666,
-0.470048219,
0.6970452666,
0.1705849916,
0.3648951352,
-0.0169192944,
-0.743802011,
0.0068435385,
0.1212882176,
-0.5670439601,
-0.3493594229,
0.1865514815,
-0.2308578938,
-0.3371371925,
-0.2119685113,
-0.4366602898,
-0.2419624329,
-0.4238204956,
0.3604309559,
-0.3799558878,
-0.3300934434,
0.1649332047,
-0.1444120705,
0.1646758765,
0.3556033373,
-1.3618934155,
0.6403914094,
0.6068032384,
0.657458961,
-0.1826369762,
-0.3348237276,
-0.8438228965,
-0.4365543127,
-0.2667256296,
0.6939929724,
-0.0757906809,
-0.3075679839,
0.0352927037,
0.0013616182,
0.012064999,
-0.5042259097,
0.698888123,
-0.2824497521,
0.0096455542,
-0.2196538746,
-0.3765729964,
0.2439565212,
0.285474956,
-0.5948687792,
0.8794126511,
0.3082047701,
-0.5182919502,
0.4196977019,
-0.615647018,
-0.4612839818,
0.0430290923,
-0.1661391258,
-0.2500227094,
0.3071314394,
-0.1764859855,
0.5384358764,
-0.2640439868,
0.005948008,
-0.0548153482,
-0.6045351028,
0.1509134918,
-0.6527587175,
0.5477735996,
0.2372698635,
-0.4740720093,
-0.0969534218,
-0.7121589184,
-0.2170221806,
0.1087569445,
-0.5659447908,
-0.5436506867,
0.1997198611,
0.1480074078,
0.1960233897,
-0.0607711412,
-0.5843992829,
0.0645932183,
-0.6796100736,
0.4543028474,
1.1917564869,
-0.0082950545,
0.6337893009,
-0.3337433934,
0.7338211536,
-0.1189189553,
0.2854755223,
0.2420665622,
0.0286232308,
-0.9603056908,
-0.400509268,
0.3403734267,
0.2512976229,
-0.6692869067,
0.1495948881,
-0.0390331931,
-0.2267300636,
-0.5553657413,
0.0435836054,
0.4597590864,
0.2205366939,
0.3495568037,
-0.176323384,
-0.3135585785,
-1.2248415947,
-0.2509372234,
0.238491416,
-0.1815768927,
0.0496452563,
0.2898445129,
-0.1418021172,
0.9435344934,
-0.4220011532,
-0.419716537,
-0.323456645,
0.3954336643,
0.1408283114,
0.7948454022,
0.2871668041,
-0.5902232528,
-0.3111231625,
0.0879591033,
-0.0887987167,
0.0953458399,
-0.3367860317,
0.0233333055,
0.2355410755,
0.3357443213,
-0.449593395,
0.3576419055,
0.4696766436,
-0.0666492879,
0.4729144275,
-0.0325187929,
-0.0861597881,
-0.39664042,
-0.163133949,
0.3672505021,
-0.2124234885,
-0.7985482812,
-0.1236287802,
-0.1246042699,
0.2801723182,
-0.2680077553,
0.4760228097,
-0.0951765031,
0.305883944,
-0.1587609649,
-0.0181890614,
-0.150506869,
0.7883521914,
-0.0653561056,
0.4728345871,
0.1872337759,
-0.7431840301,
-0.0573600903,
-0.056267947,
-0.1269127131,
0.5213675499,
-0.5192278624,
-0.2351756394,
-0.2663995028,
-0.0911709741,
-1.0673083067,
0.0559741855,
0.2121414095,
-0.2845083177,
0.3317279816,
-0.2957800031,
-0.082101807,
-0.276758194,
-0.4550986886,
0.2051341236,
0.5806911588,
-0.3076522946,
0.0667693615,
0.1644863784,
-0.2239061594,
-0.6555563807,
-0.6779514551,
-0.5526461601,
-0.2478403896,
-0.1797327399,
0.2282880843,
-0.0886802226,
0.0755298287,
-0.1920399517,
-0.3593399823,
-0.1462335438,
0.3252366185,
0.0773601681,
0.1217612773,
-0.2838031352,
-0.1431492567,
0.2648333013,
-0.3186649978,
0.1955140084,
-0.2122952491,
0.5360921025,
-0.3512017429,
-0.3386557102,
-0.4382884502,
0.1765469015,
0.3832815588,
-0.111549519,
0.5186262131,
0.7959383726,
-0.4215657115,
-0.3935377002,
-0.4129454195,
-0.3307315111,
-0.5187203288,
0.5196695924,
-0.3272451162,
-1.0474168062,
0.4630235732,
0.0141342459,
0.1845309734,
0.4451627433,
0.1565001607,
-0.4127348363,
1.101223588,
0.882289052,
0.1888379008,
0.8940271735,
-0.5510406494,
0.1455992609,
-0.6852176785,
-0.0179859772,
-0.635109365,
-0.0441112593,
-0.7936127186,
-0.0057127569,
0.2058799863,
0.2923623323,
-0.427963376,
0.0217216015,
-0.4083804488,
0.7440137267,
0.7822175026,
0.0843987018,
0.0051909988,
0.047854878,
-0.1712084562,
-0.3060292304,
-0.6832240224,
-0.3006939292,
0.650812149,
0.527425766,
0.7508720756,
-0.1513085365,
1.0448740721,
0.0629136339,
0.1397242844,
-0.9695162773,
0.1870787591,
-0.1800406575,
-0.3457966149,
-0.780254066,
-0.4782934785,
-0.9475122094,
0.1257367134,
-0.3212688267,
-0.4883008301,
0.1908815354,
0.416957289,
-0.6205664277,
-0.0078032827,
-0.6656372547,
1.1777147055,
0.0641385391,
-0.5671032071,
-0.0997433141,
-0.7313942313,
0.4089223742,
0.0107455179,
0.1670982242,
-0.1636424512,
0.3280506432,
0.8241096139,
-0.5507872105,
0.6263629198,
-0.5198230743,
0.0069241198,
-0.0168892369,
0.3553773463,
0.772124052,
-0.1548428684,
0.33211568,
-0.131732434,
0.2290952653,
-0.6016851664,
-0.5047214627,
0.4908721447,
-0.5999144316,
-0.3501011133,
-0.4296097755,
-0.3495543003,
-0.3295757473,
0.2572004795,
0.0799307525,
0.3335348368,
-0.5009593964,
0.1596468985,
1.0360505581,
-0.1476562917,
0.4208134115,
0.3343636394,
0.2155204713,
0.0127809234,
1.1977161169,
0.1208949313,
0.5773540139,
0.1386574954,
0.3405035138,
-0.259542644,
-0.9198092222,
-0.4678686857,
0.2497534305,
-0.4935514033,
-0.0355705433,
-0.2134879678,
-0.2080847174,
0.0889067799,
-0.3699129224,
-0.7590207458,
-0.4169476926,
-0.2803819776,
-0.0802369118,
0.2356941104,
0.7913232446,
-0.2876322567,
0.3666724563,
-0.671665132,
0.0524606891,
0.3111748993,
0.5962126851,
-0.0444990993,
-0.4348409474,
-0.6042948365,
0.3725644052,
-0.2813093662,
-0.1240515262,
0.1929805875,
-0.0401901901,
0.7117754817,
0.6426243186,
0.1266964674,
0.5414991379,
-0.5373125076,
0.7110895514,
0.1679909229,
-0.8230916262,
0.3461910188,
-0.7445243001,
0.2142855972,
0.7982757092,
0.3759486675,
-0.8644438386,
-0.6153516769,
-0.6182351708,
-1.0605355501,
0.9023740292,
0.151168108,
0.218116045,
-0.1332711279,
0.1507688761,
0.1523700058,
0.1910349876,
-0.7505555153,
-0.3039222062,
-0.1392838508,
-0.1521997303,
-0.1955158412,
-0.0887124613,
-0.3572956324,
-0.1757408381,
0.5040456653,
0.0343941972,
0.3070161343,
-0.2001841664,
-0.0762009993,
-0.2845518291,
0.3195104599,
0.9218424559,
0.1928021461,
-0.3152375519,
-0.0376475714,
0.0062930966,
-0.3670365214,
0.1977006346,
0.2094432712,
-0.0758707076,
-0.349460572,
0.0621197745,
0.8799284697,
0.3645199239,
-0.4748472273,
0.6964934468,
-0.068392992,
-0.479115814,
-0.1769211441,
0.1109836996,
-0.1326001436,
0.0896516889,
0.3537925482,
0.4277998209,
0.1469622105,
-0.0775967836,
0.183000654,
0.5990591645,
-0.6521731615,
-0.1003312618,
0.5026812553,
0.0323156528,
-0.1400125772,
0.6905988455,
-0.1267169565,
-0.3569141924,
0.5776122808,
0.3402557671,
0.9303900599,
-0.0727143064,
0.3215063214,
0.0592349656,
0.4240319133,
-0.2497498393,
-0.1371569037,
-0.2004691362,
-0.7386533022,
-0.3130116165,
-0.7814437151,
-0.2788196802,
-0.0267986357,
-0.746321857,
0.1575703621,
-0.6908478141,
0.2864579558,
0.0701315105,
-0.0838027671,
-0.7626024485,
0.1722416282,
-0.0520901605,
0.611456573,
-1.1362689734,
0.6268804073,
0.3280358315,
-0.6872419119,
-0.9254649878,
-0.135101527,
-0.0235088449,
-0.6940792799,
0.6016638875,
-0.1510645598,
-0.4731468558,
0.2841869593,
-0.3924516737,
-0.7698799372,
0.5799129605,
0.2805607617,
-0.2599279881,
-0.0066339783,
0.1523548961,
0.5460713506,
-0.0054330081,
0.027210582,
0.9662178159,
0.3721446991,
0.0412339382,
-0.8294013739,
-0.0122337621,
-0.0198939797,
0.1166902184,
0.3667158186,
-0.5086565018,
1.0427391529,
0.0794149637,
-0.2763339877,
-0.042803254,
0.4090111256,
0.1958391219,
0.0752024874,
0.5755939484,
0.2972778678,
0.519304812,
-0.4181870222,
1.0629554987,
0.3051538467,
0.5536446571,
0.554577589,
0.1569253355,
0.6795541644,
0.7329879403,
-0.3584297299,
0.1324212402,
1.0289502144,
0.3440260887,
0.8933550715,
0.573595047,
-0.1760436296,
0.0069306362,
-0.0314309821,
-0.0900598615,
0.046703171,
0.3255980909,
0.0300347917,
-0.1723977774,
0.3324163556,
-0.1165887043,
0.1710287929,
-0.3883843422,
0.6396778226,
-0.099229008,
-0.5959458947,
1.0630466938,
0.0278055668,
0.9175384045,
-0.7057487369,
0.009778874,
-0.868175447,
0.2847570479,
-0.2246724218,
-0.4094720483,
0.2582584321,
-0.3122266829,
-0.2260474265,
-0.5977253318,
0.1987851411,
-0.5240191221,
0.0800026208,
-0.0839059129,
0.316796571,
0.1797667295,
0.1528188735,
-0.5908895135,
-0.1176948249,
0.1495813876,
-0.5458578467,
0.568136692,
0.4817789495,
0.006538399,
0.6420131922,
0.5961483121,
0.2212787271,
-0.0138859292,
-0.0195706952,
1.0012329817,
-0.5224509239,
-0.5747277737,
-0.8258926272,
0.6600482464,
0.3274403512,
-0.3095582128,
0.5656623244,
0.3464089036,
1.1474198103,
-0.1880043447,
0.6665882468,
0.0615777969,
0.5691708326,
-0.7046675086,
0.7578547597,
-0.5614255667,
0.2004077137,
-0.5088912249,
-0.7473537922,
-0.224085927,
0.917912662,
-0.3656793535,
0.104029201,
0.9121174812,
0.8918756843,
-0.2114722282,
0.0243432187,
0.2890002429,
-0.0563383512,
0.1938045025,
0.6045364738,
1.033836484,
-0.213427037,
0.3960057199,
-0.3300755322,
-0.1967717856,
-0.1548819542,
-0.6156708598,
-0.6072673202,
-0.5570696592,
-0.0747229382,
-0.3877218366,
0.1545019448,
1.1850494146,
0.6949583292,
-0.8413484097,
-0.2944976687,
-0.5665177703,
0.2271203548,
-0.4743205011,
-0.274217695,
0.245546639,
-0.4195695817,
-0.7541294694,
0.1997805834,
-0.0140420347,
0.4747594893,
-0.5295161009,
-0.3913801908,
-0.191840902,
-0.0694142431,
0.2961406112,
0.7725955248,
-0.6359938979,
-0.4585581124,
-0.2197634876,
-0.3430121243,
-0.0164566059,
0.7597907186,
-0.6184168458,
0.0885009617,
0.2418707907,
0.9082462192,
0.8076426387,
-0.0864332765,
0.7196733356,
-1.1027486324,
0.27694875,
0.3174881339,
-0.0985837579,
0.0820304006,
-0.2398263365,
0.2401382923,
0.1563131958,
-0.529333055,
-1.0438380241,
0.2847971618,
-0.7158982158,
0.0663402975,
0.9526374936,
-0.037229307,
-0.1067672372,
-0.1617461145,
-0.1532728225,
0.1410435289,
-0.3495319784,
0.6069477201,
0.8843873739,
-0.2779570222,
-0.2198174447,
-0.8870648742,
1.2449057102,
0.7165926695,
-0.4450353682,
0.3360962868,
0.5904253721,
0.3072448969,
-0.2092613876,
0.9140423536,
0.3063668609,
0.3999827504,
-0.1199376211,
0.0035076556,
-0.1028265581,
-0.3684401512,
-0.7976741791,
-0.0522140488,
0.4907037616,
-0.3613376915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20697v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20697v1
|
Text-Transport: Toward Learning Causal Effects of Natural Language
| 2023-10-31T17:56:51 | 2023-10-31T17:56:51 |
Victoria Lin, Louis-Philippe Morency, Eli Ben-Michael
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, stat.ME
|
As language technologies gain prominence in real-world settings, it is
important to understand how changes to language affect reader perceptions. This
can be formalized as the causal effect of varying a linguistic attribute (e.g.,
sentiment) on a reader's response to the text. In this paper, we introduce
Text-Transport, a method for estimation of causal effects from natural language
under any text distribution. Current approaches for valid causal effect
estimation require strong assumptions about the data, meaning the data from
which one can estimate valid causal effects often is not representative of the
actual target domain of interest. To address this issue, we leverage the notion
of distribution shift to describe an estimator that transports causal effects
between domains, bypassing the need for strong assumptions in the target
domain. We derive statistical guarantees on the uncertainty of this estimator,
and we report empirical results and analyses that support the validity of
Text-Transport across data settings. Finally, we use Text-Transport to study a
realistic setting--hate speech on social media--in which causal effects do
shift significantly between text domains, demonstrating the necessity of
transport when conducting causal inference on natural language.
|
[
-0.1519210637,
-1.2041699886,
0.6326798797,
0.3563890457,
-0.2583330274,
-0.3493380547,
-0.0801980644,
-0.6087601781,
0.1845672727,
0.5146493912,
-0.4077843726,
-0.1363641173,
-0.789677918,
-0.0125141544,
-0.8099397421,
1.0150427818,
0.1582583934,
-0.177889958,
0.0193276275,
0.1338055283,
-0.4544883668,
-0.2766877413,
-0.7564387321,
-0.3517023027,
0.8567308187,
0.0141972732,
0.9526765347,
0.5133475661,
0.5729872584,
0.1238821596,
-0.1204607114,
-0.348995924,
-0.3464852273,
0.1973823905,
-0.6964419484,
-0.5941343307,
0.0623158738,
-0.166695103,
0.8124796748,
0.6988371611,
0.1915794462,
-0.1349541247,
-0.1405697167,
0.6927437186,
-0.6258497834,
-0.0818790272,
-0.3882005215,
0.0544126928,
-0.3459220231,
-0.3291645944,
-0.6296385527,
-0.6603396535,
0.3862786591,
-0.7262921333,
0.1764161587,
0.1824619919,
0.8793276548,
0.3980141878,
-1.213201642,
-0.2764359713,
-1.1827846766,
0.787448287,
-0.3404589891,
0.5452765822,
0.61713624,
0.2900726199,
0.0706337094,
-0.5852491856,
-0.6422650218,
-0.0408369377,
0.0103616482,
0.0621533133,
-0.1727681309,
-0.1100635901,
-0.0087200571,
0.0223288406,
-0.3187443316,
0.0037056382,
-0.4160759449,
-0.0941606238,
0.7934495807,
-0.0526729785,
0.7004330158,
-0.1192978993,
-0.4440986514,
-0.2103487849,
-0.6363145709,
-0.0837757587,
0.3351050913,
0.4023178518,
-0.3289264441,
0.4386143982,
0.1831537336,
0.6893109679,
-0.1938163638,
0.0183429141,
0.183090806,
-0.3372144699,
-0.2712682188,
0.1510636806,
0.6918671727,
0.3333122432,
0.2180735171,
-0.2393484414,
0.1839316487,
0.1564572603,
0.4842923582,
-0.6902621388,
-0.0770417526,
-0.1328509003,
-0.3731877208,
-0.2993998528,
-0.0934892595,
-1.1437501907,
-0.7593790889,
-0.4700240493,
0.3665763438,
-0.1943617165,
-0.314706713,
0.3492990434,
-0.3652643263,
0.1798978448,
0.1965243667,
-0.8464302421,
0.4366248548,
0.3063206077,
0.7107746005,
-0.3648793101,
-0.0554241203,
-0.3235606849,
0.3410199285,
-0.2045877278,
1.1109215021,
-0.5248413086,
-0.2653393745,
0.383299768,
-0.1200483814,
-0.3644406796,
-0.2364669293,
1.145272851,
-0.456077069,
0.2494439185,
-0.2015827,
-0.6922113895,
-0.1107956022,
0.0698615313,
-0.6461533904,
0.8746207356,
-0.1582329869,
-1.0346170664,
0.3663972616,
-0.3265763819,
-1.1074427366,
-0.4641029537,
0.2749021649,
-0.4467986822,
0.1713263094,
-0.040096648,
0.2406180948,
-0.221121341,
0.3482729197,
-0.367883265,
-0.0887365565,
0.4946531951,
-0.7007225752,
0.8376541138,
0.1616943777,
-0.4853486717,
-0.1842433959,
-0.5193569064,
-0.7265095115,
-0.0737456232,
-0.134689644,
-0.9668493271,
0.425134033,
0.3933287263,
0.2416941673,
-0.1231379136,
-0.5746688843,
0.0332904607,
-0.5760914087,
0.020467924,
0.6841940284,
0.3051165938,
1.0494031906,
-0.206505999,
0.3401093483,
0.0193054732,
0.3651020229,
0.4527858198,
-0.6008714437,
-0.4603719413,
0.1796553135,
-0.1285220236,
0.5243514776,
-0.7567269206,
0.0776667669,
-0.1808006316,
-0.255942136,
-0.1720488667,
-0.184841305,
-0.0534648746,
0.6434977651,
0.4602052271,
0.3918968737,
-0.2877060175,
-0.6321713328,
-0.7813006043,
-0.3913943768,
0.193394199,
0.0925229862,
0.2472635806,
-0.3712823689,
0.8568330407,
-0.975030303,
-0.2224030495,
-0.0807203203,
0.3886395693,
-0.2935789824,
0.2928743958,
0.4843526185,
-1.1621645689,
-0.3756419718,
-0.171961233,
-0.4733935297,
-0.3464372456,
-0.5030299425,
-0.4653144777,
0.1069672406,
0.6399526,
-0.4937269688,
0.4235032499,
0.5574191213,
-0.69061625,
0.3463425636,
-0.0715076849,
0.2761388421,
-1.1505506039,
-0.1092033237,
0.4605131447,
-0.0251608081,
-0.8554019332,
-0.4096447527,
-0.0352969319,
0.1979194582,
-0.5600867867,
0.9874703288,
0.0927568898,
0.2787154913,
-0.160650149,
0.5104827285,
-0.0069928332,
-0.0679767281,
0.0882890075,
0.4416432977,
0.4666313827,
-0.7846127152,
-0.1745273024,
0.330476284,
-0.1611964852,
0.9109360576,
-0.1719046384,
-0.3014310598,
-0.4193613529,
0.0905337483,
-1.0669925213,
0.0714326203,
0.4398318529,
-0.3529403806,
0.0328880027,
0.0199179798,
-0.3833862543,
0.03977108,
0.0728232265,
0.225296855,
0.3957525492,
-0.3742044568,
0.4337063432,
0.6294842362,
-0.011948185,
-0.3200353682,
-0.9796481133,
0.1009189337,
-0.5640023351,
-0.4193494022,
0.2286478728,
-0.0952748135,
-0.4528636038,
0.0271515697,
-0.0324554965,
-0.6659626365,
0.2452543974,
0.1485996097,
0.0038988662,
0.1083303764,
0.5857437253,
0.5223662853,
-0.0938766748,
0.4427032173,
-0.2438054234,
-0.1332762986,
0.4625520706,
0.0642813817,
-0.1361791342,
0.1901935488,
0.2255275697,
0.1916269958,
0.8044236302,
0.5359201431,
-0.2321163863,
-0.3150038719,
-0.0966463313,
-0.1915833503,
-0.4229400456,
0.1410648227,
0.0093185594,
-0.6637085676,
0.1652843505,
-0.140781343,
-0.0667616799,
0.5021412373,
0.1719188243,
-0.2438429743,
0.9165207744,
0.6800941825,
-0.142844528,
0.9334346056,
0.426230371,
0.3349099755,
-0.3803733885,
0.0298093632,
-1.0289757252,
-0.0025861321,
-0.6323953271,
-0.350027144,
0.2134822905,
-0.1479099095,
-0.3867110908,
0.2046208084,
-0.0461634696,
0.1787645221,
0.2064021677,
0.0240025986,
0.421623975,
0.3325811923,
0.0549951419,
-0.234060958,
-0.4278610945,
-0.2965173423,
0.6224600673,
0.0623718053,
0.8464582562,
0.2931885719,
0.3817721009,
0.6761066318,
0.6421377063,
-0.6314861178,
0.4578987658,
-0.1070099026,
-0.7439504862,
-0.3796667755,
-0.7227020264,
-1.0877473354,
0.1610465646,
-0.4162985086,
-0.5598546863,
0.0651799366,
0.1868180484,
0.2781662345,
0.3408010304,
-0.6444875598,
0.8466265798,
-0.0580511726,
-0.4204587042,
-0.4911314547,
-0.7314488888,
0.2436606288,
-0.1142534018,
0.680686295,
-0.1595187932,
0.0151502267,
0.7571758628,
-0.0124839982,
1.1115971804,
-0.1612565815,
-0.2819360197,
0.240435183,
0.1770335883,
0.4639591873,
-0.234788239,
-0.2015937865,
0.0284309704,
-0.3119128942,
-0.2826560736,
-0.6761248708,
0.3900342286,
-0.7779920101,
-0.1146488041,
-0.304107964,
-0.4490732849,
-0.2037196159,
0.3687248528,
0.1735149175,
0.4860484898,
-0.3910871744,
-0.2416884899,
0.6783126593,
-0.4136343002,
0.4183963239,
0.4558637738,
-0.0494007282,
-0.1095754951,
0.8901827931,
0.171686247,
0.5038456917,
1.0298961401,
0.871673286,
-0.6028668284,
-0.1962871552,
-0.3462664485,
0.3259946704,
-0.7436543703,
0.167083919,
-0.592158258,
0.2084869742,
-0.2048272341,
-0.5147633553,
-0.1699645221,
-0.4039640427,
-0.3303553164,
-0.1740954667,
0.327845633,
0.6923452616,
0.0861507282,
0.5171372294,
-0.5443060398,
0.2360691577,
0.2436515987,
0.2902844846,
-0.1828778535,
-0.8445798755,
-0.4290357232,
0.100909166,
-0.2377856523,
-0.9670248628,
0.5428737402,
0.080704011,
0.3274553418,
0.2658633292,
0.4405262172,
0.4982515574,
-0.5970558524,
0.8253894448,
0.2079849988,
-0.8758630157,
0.6183530092,
-0.5347604156,
0.2347714007,
0.4235562682,
0.6099176407,
-0.7241554856,
-0.9279470444,
-0.6118963361,
-0.6555850506,
0.1812886447,
0.4026665986,
0.3165881932,
-0.4089810252,
0.2282300144,
-0.1108847857,
0.0778502673,
-0.9066790938,
-0.4322228134,
-0.1651214957,
-0.3216636777,
-0.2731148899,
-0.1147453338,
0.3289968073,
-0.1622421741,
0.7585098743,
0.1442461163,
0.2480852455,
0.3539075255,
-0.4002851248,
-0.0722550005,
0.3520846367,
0.8738089204,
0.4671704173,
-0.1678232551,
0.6473412514,
-0.222578004,
-0.7381674051,
0.2527424991,
0.1347378641,
-0.5832149982,
0.1948719472,
0.252379775,
0.6642532945,
0.4667204916,
-0.437882334,
0.5683617592,
-0.1211214811,
-0.0203009769,
-0.0073828269,
-0.2839518189,
-0.0510719195,
-0.0012178217,
0.1445319057,
0.3468276262,
0.407672286,
-0.1558945775,
0.2904097736,
-0.0460162126,
-0.7658283114,
-0.5651509166,
0.9253715873,
0.5055960417,
-0.3647803068,
0.2247501761,
0.0031537216,
-0.1465068609,
0.510140717,
0.6392865777,
1.0362538099,
-0.3712404072,
0.599983871,
0.419385463,
0.5309283733,
-0.3190830052,
-0.2405722737,
0.2393171787,
-1.0193705559,
-0.548271358,
-0.3410069942,
-0.2498191446,
-0.5346356034,
-0.5482106805,
0.0781925917,
-0.0960828662,
-0.4218524098,
-0.031610772,
-0.3557583094,
-0.4012165666,
0.040775843,
0.1901974082,
0.7355239987,
-1.5332312584,
0.6760782599,
0.6656665206,
-0.3038073182,
-0.4950811565,
0.3848050833,
0.0620585233,
-0.3034587204,
0.759404242,
-0.0649250969,
-0.1866666228,
0.0290705375,
-0.4596925378,
-0.6604322791,
0.3576645851,
0.4869520068,
-0.2305403799,
0.289024055,
0.5070927739,
0.5683940053,
0.221065551,
0.055989638,
0.3053395152,
0.3608103991,
-0.1693120152,
-0.5624224544,
0.0967389345,
0.2602906823,
-0.1216659099,
0.5303353667,
-0.3438475728,
0.4058812559,
0.1271940321,
-0.262871325,
-0.533515811,
0.6073414683,
-0.2305859625,
0.4194408953,
0.4935534894,
0.110538125,
0.8375604153,
0.2664474547,
1.3965222836,
0.0933032781,
0.4479823709,
0.78886199,
-0.1867816597,
0.7532318234,
0.710739553,
-0.037892282,
0.6254435182,
0.2294587344,
0.6988576651,
0.6819452047,
0.1658713818,
-0.6407321692,
-0.0466883667,
-0.2230910063,
0.1038482636,
-0.1520150155,
0.2821223438,
-0.2761768699,
-0.4194968343,
0.3069299757,
0.356315881,
0.366320014,
-0.3315172493,
0.5047010779,
0.3262731731,
-0.4772276282,
0.1949854195,
0.0001547925,
0.5144811869,
-0.4279124737,
-0.0146447616,
-0.3298387527,
0.1575392634,
0.0212902464,
-0.8705208898,
0.8202879429,
-0.1699990481,
-0.2885105908,
-0.6025210619,
0.9518173933,
-0.3525240719,
-0.556464076,
0.3603628874,
0.2311721146,
0.0905356854,
0.0604321174,
-0.5328191519,
-0.0006969314,
-0.1024134308,
-0.2347025573,
0.3481433392,
0.5933824778,
-0.1666645855,
0.6309327483,
0.3981076479,
0.1087571308,
0.2243551016,
0.1530886441,
0.3120322526,
-0.7297192216,
-0.6363880038,
-0.9052889347,
0.5028275847,
-0.0959716141,
-0.4676108956,
0.7873989344,
0.341825664,
0.556289196,
-0.1126215681,
0.8883246183,
-0.0510061271,
0.3795239627,
-0.4940333664,
0.4806839228,
-0.2768880725,
0.0556444228,
-0.6295099258,
-0.678868711,
-0.5667492747,
0.7087569833,
-0.6589037776,
-0.614980638,
0.9009161592,
0.4589702189,
0.0326592587,
0.2603890598,
0.1415389329,
0.3344220519,
0.5831503272,
0.1327507049,
0.6700863838,
-0.5590624213,
0.4449287057,
-0.0934935436,
-0.0200442914,
0.0121608451,
-1.0352414846,
-0.7406338453,
-0.5733189583,
-0.69418329,
-0.3763181567,
0.0928267762,
0.5137981772,
0.4784685075,
-0.3092493117,
-0.3988798857,
-0.4827768505,
0.7373605967,
-0.4641499817,
-0.3106063902,
0.5160470605,
-0.3783177435,
-0.649766326,
0.0737113953,
0.0447718054,
0.0692290142,
0.0996445119,
0.2482100278,
-0.4426424503,
0.348528415,
0.9019249678,
0.2004646808,
-0.1383564621,
-0.6214417219,
-0.0398464017,
-0.2688680887,
-0.1405426562,
0.7844249606,
-0.5996537805,
0.3366681039,
0.5687938929,
0.9268117547,
0.5663241148,
-0.0514466688,
0.7413682342,
-0.6909589767,
0.2694638669,
-0.040059533,
-0.0557560399,
0.2276336849,
-0.4184781909,
0.3515629172,
0.6582103372,
-0.5211256742,
-0.5653775334,
0.2307318002,
-0.9800294638,
-0.3630560935,
1.509147048,
0.485604018,
-0.2718928158,
-0.460983187,
-0.1746220291,
0.2920361757,
-0.3445557356,
0.7792973518,
0.4775339663,
0.0655680895,
-0.1605207324,
-0.9456622005,
0.5074321032,
0.266158551,
-1.0987744331,
0.0550878569,
0.5597732663,
0.278470397,
-0.1707994044,
0.6298506856,
0.1541434228,
-0.3316139281,
-0.1161798686,
-0.0550637841,
0.765360713,
-0.2103774995,
-0.2279636264,
-0.0590081178,
-0.300654918,
-0.0037442232
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20689v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20689v4
|
Learning From Mistakes Makes LLM Better Reasoner
| 2023-10-31T17:52:22 | 2024-03-29T07:17:39 |
Shengnan An, Zexiong Ma, Zeqi Lin, Nanning Zheng, Jian-Guang Lou, Weizhu Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) recently exhibited remarkable reasoning
capabilities on solving math problems. To further improve their reasoning
capabilities, this work explores whether LLMs can LEarn from MistAkes (LEMA),
akin to the human learning process. Consider a human student who failed to
solve a math problem, he will learn from what mistake he has made and how to
correct it. Mimicking this error-driven learning process, LEMA incorporates
mistake-correction data pairs during fine-tuning LLMs. Specifically, we first
collect inaccurate reasoning paths from various LLMs, and then employ GPT-4 as
a ''corrector'' to identify the mistake step, explain the reason for the
mistake, correct the mistake and generate the final answer. In addition, we
apply a correction-centric evolution strategy that effectively expands the
question set for generating correction data. Experiments across various LLMs
and reasoning tasks show that LEMA effectively improves CoT-alone fine-tuning.
Our further ablations shed light on the non-homogeneous effectiveness between
CoT data and correction data. These results suggest a significant potential for
LLMs to improve through learning from their mistakes. Our code, models and
prompts are publicly available at https://github.com/microsoft/LEMA.
|
[
-0.0704810992,
-0.7526794076,
0.7929114699,
-0.0000807379,
0.0434219018,
0.2857963145,
-0.2331775278,
-0.259719938,
-0.3393377662,
0.4747235775,
-0.5482827425,
-0.2336210757,
-0.6069941521,
0.1676176488,
-0.0344790816,
0.9271152616,
-0.1283002943,
0.3030386269,
-0.5211623311,
-0.1231417283,
-0.7023498416,
-0.5195553303,
-1.117480278,
-0.5500997901,
0.7266916633,
0.8208603859,
0.6271545887,
0.5954129696,
0.3834538162,
0.2988851368,
0.0351744704,
0.6700692773,
-0.7997261882,
-0.1360797882,
-0.4235324562,
-0.8808900118,
-0.3975886106,
-0.12743406,
0.317204237,
0.6977223158,
-0.3420343101,
-0.1374186724,
0.1168121696,
1.0379129648,
-0.4365937114,
0.1567724347,
-0.9403310418,
-0.0614549294,
-0.0586425066,
-0.3939835429,
-0.5066188574,
-0.3906852901,
-0.2045484483,
-0.559543252,
0.4942363203,
-0.2345881611,
0.6510012746,
0.6250169277,
-0.0885326788,
-0.5342530608,
-0.67144382,
0.8958325386,
-0.6956179142,
0.4323808551,
0.3560704887,
0.3100880384,
-0.4484094679,
-0.404749155,
-0.5150135756,
0.2414961159,
0.3126693368,
-0.061681319,
0.0766225979,
-0.3009548187,
0.5137233138,
-0.0009752359,
-0.2864221632,
0.106198281,
-0.4413097501,
-0.3022205234,
0.6527757645,
0.1899058372,
0.3114123344,
0.3153546453,
-0.0016299101,
-0.3677307367,
-1.2704033852,
-0.0687737837,
0.3273639679,
0.3137862682,
0.0099988198,
0.3431458771,
0.2851063609,
0.8027388453,
-0.0879660398,
-0.3988083303,
0.162960425,
0.1081052497,
-0.2462479174,
0.1117393747,
0.205962956,
0.2078094631,
0.546821475,
-0.072789669,
-0.4019816518,
0.1067052558,
0.1166358814,
-0.4496182501,
-0.4885290563,
-0.0561588146,
0.015433751,
-0.0271950811,
-0.0607568547,
-0.5934057236,
-0.6830558777,
-0.7937259674,
0.361871928,
-0.4069212675,
0.1875737011,
0.4770151079,
0.0723295137,
0.0769474655,
0.8134146333,
-0.8153790832,
0.0056367815,
0.8270971179,
0.6413911581,
-0.0779138729,
-0.3650621772,
-0.8115703464,
-0.032430958,
-0.5937352777,
0.9515995979,
-0.2051843703,
-0.5430232286,
-0.198317498,
-0.2437681854,
-0.167747274,
-1.0896072388,
0.4494049251,
-0.5151219368,
-0.0196232088,
-0.6354420781,
-0.6359589696,
-0.1107117683,
0.2182367593,
-0.4805116355,
0.6577344537,
0.1214455888,
-0.4486075938,
0.3734564483,
-0.5595046878,
-0.1919473112,
-0.2716288269,
-0.3080063164,
-0.6758662462,
0.3541930914,
0.2915619016,
0.2747794986,
-0.1803648174,
-0.0530688129,
-0.1635123491,
-0.2440013438,
0.3332937658,
-0.4228766263,
0.7043157816,
0.0975329578,
-0.1853454709,
-0.1020110548,
-0.7617533207,
-0.1117023006,
0.436738044,
-0.557905972,
-0.0784653947,
0.3227289021,
-0.5103356242,
0.3722199798,
0.0606235042,
-0.318454057,
0.2522028387,
-0.2292062044,
0.400044769,
1.0454875231,
-0.0899643898,
0.3129139543,
-0.6401970387,
0.2336749285,
0.3412204087,
0.1241615713,
-0.0513021946,
-0.3719226122,
-0.9391129613,
0.1457937211,
0.1955842227,
0.5962496996,
-0.7253906727,
-0.0921710357,
0.0543747507,
-0.3656200767,
-0.2630203962,
0.6875007749,
0.2102008015,
0.7506402731,
0.4924635291,
-0.0617786571,
-0.6332932115,
-0.3827754855,
-0.4319413304,
-0.3014861047,
0.2351755053,
0.4057236314,
0.2241386324,
-0.6368959546,
0.9359452128,
-0.4946566224,
-0.2720222175,
-0.2362536937,
-0.0494742207,
0.0675964355,
0.3386422992,
0.3923369646,
-0.5498221517,
-0.3234943748,
-0.0941302851,
-0.7436291575,
-0.3933748305,
-0.2594929636,
-0.1307729334,
0.5315923691,
0.58950001,
-0.4340722263,
0.3276248872,
0.384907037,
-0.4183781743,
0.667517662,
-0.3414607942,
-0.2611149848,
-0.8348502517,
-0.5247121453,
-0.1906816214,
-0.3001633883,
-0.1354008913,
-0.3282569647,
0.0701198205,
0.3053781092,
-0.445325762,
0.317088753,
-0.4616376758,
-0.258562386,
-0.2416082323,
0.0550965853,
-0.0613642298,
0.1459859461,
-0.3034381568,
0.8560970426,
0.4196352363,
-0.5125541091,
0.2351099104,
0.0592114776,
-0.0541283377,
0.5176416636,
-0.4281530082,
0.4050152004,
-0.1336265802,
0.015127358,
-0.6121807694,
-0.2426815778,
-0.0788395479,
-0.539124608,
0.2556640804,
0.034369655,
-0.5763908029,
-0.1142228767,
-0.0957037881,
0.1680067182,
0.4664511979,
-0.9178671241,
0.5393750668,
0.1372079998,
-0.1308379471,
-0.6356553435,
-0.5673671365,
-0.0699299946,
-0.0519014858,
-0.5291951895,
-0.0754720271,
-0.3660617173,
-0.4762554765,
-0.1544192284,
-0.2451144308,
0.129784584,
0.2965258658,
0.1423008293,
0.3134248853,
-0.1331031322,
0.3799941242,
-0.1974248886,
-0.1974813491,
0.1479779631,
-0.0832779929,
0.6370745301,
-0.2840239406,
-0.452608496,
-0.0756016523,
-0.1338150799,
0.4318190217,
0.1522862613,
0.5852515697,
0.1174440309,
-0.3508290946,
-0.6048916578,
-0.5382602215,
-0.362534672,
-0.4652409852,
0.1851789057,
-0.2206981927,
-0.7083644867,
0.4351778626,
-0.1790780276,
0.2384293526,
0.3664183319,
0.4042056799,
-0.3946551979,
0.9665456414,
0.7565956712,
-0.1093361229,
0.2337834388,
-0.3650836349,
0.1362971812,
-0.5768379569,
-0.2215325087,
-0.4120838642,
-0.2992047071,
-0.3038996458,
-0.6946541667,
0.2883212268,
0.4413799644,
-0.3113366365,
-0.0568156131,
-0.2050819397,
0.9034901261,
0.3953414261,
0.0608631633,
0.4577280283,
0.162942186,
-0.0638738871,
-0.1918094903,
-0.6530405879,
-0.6325831413,
1.1169581413,
0.2992203832,
0.9758906364,
0.1244669482,
0.9785861969,
0.0030383945,
0.5706173182,
-0.6271978617,
0.4048004448,
-0.004182301,
-0.1342579573,
-0.2747114897,
-0.8739013076,
-0.8965703249,
-0.0118840924,
-0.0616616197,
-0.5345723033,
0.1190996692,
0.4517025948,
-0.226180315,
0.5034165978,
-0.7147892714,
0.6458220482,
-0.4213584363,
-0.3920814693,
-0.1693183631,
-0.344617337,
0.1694087833,
-0.5015614629,
0.3892990053,
-0.076693289,
-0.0425755531,
0.5675863624,
-0.5417448282,
0.9011935592,
-0.1688969284,
-0.2940979898,
0.3591283262,
0.3028199971,
0.6075140238,
0.0591975562,
-0.111037679,
0.1913729161,
-0.4515942037,
-0.4891753793,
-0.9039065838,
0.7400100827,
-1.0454719067,
-0.5923557281,
-0.4080618918,
-0.6081649661,
-0.5438944697,
-0.0816439986,
0.3193877637,
0.2730533779,
0.3339598179,
0.0249582343,
0.7379822731,
-0.1335911304,
0.6542267203,
0.5630712509,
-0.3076156974,
-0.2329483032,
0.9874275327,
0.2231283784,
0.3714253306,
-0.0069230027,
0.2949813008,
-0.2194008231,
-0.6549537778,
-0.3159069419,
0.5262405276,
-1.0386885405,
-0.4160584807,
-0.3837462664,
-0.1315426826,
-0.0789998025,
-0.4349388182,
-0.3830046058,
-0.1965162158,
-0.4489507377,
-0.2144872695,
0.2668657005,
0.864941895,
-0.4119091034,
0.15660806,
-0.8008348346,
0.0345060378,
0.5774315,
0.175888896,
-0.103170678,
-0.4212380946,
-0.1181290522,
0.2072260529,
-0.6413841248,
-0.577737987,
0.451890409,
0.1725976616,
0.4444099963,
0.1808911115,
-0.2926754057,
0.7485153675,
-0.4659778774,
0.617744863,
0.132674545,
-0.8816226721,
0.6582276821,
-0.0947870985,
0.2685581148,
0.40766868,
-0.0024094195,
-0.3569865227,
-0.1159154996,
-0.720122695,
-0.6210252643,
0.6211024523,
-0.0443905443,
-0.0659125522,
0.0389183946,
0.6821397543,
0.1657916009,
-0.0989215225,
-0.6641615629,
-0.1259586066,
0.0202733297,
-0.1877892911,
-0.5730772018,
-0.1312365979,
-0.0932149962,
-0.3117947876,
0.8536710739,
-0.4714565873,
0.1173379347,
0.2289798409,
-0.4786002636,
-0.4349843562,
0.1500848234,
0.8159056902,
1.0001418591,
0.0478728376,
0.2750958204,
0.4908924103,
-0.2651276588,
0.066850245,
-0.1199748144,
-0.0267194025,
-0.1139292717,
0.4063288867,
0.5628640056,
0.0196468569,
-0.8605033159,
0.3991673589,
-0.1722268164,
-0.1165271103,
-0.1570001543,
0.2397428453,
0.2621691823,
0.258330822,
0.3526582122,
0.3561846614,
-0.1364132315,
-0.5580309033,
0.2436166108,
0.1944866329,
-0.2054949254,
-0.2289248407,
0.3481261134,
-0.1234701797,
-0.4700453877,
0.6000035405,
-0.0708485246,
-0.602533102,
0.8175120354,
0.8312921524,
0.4634915888,
-0.3034278452,
0.3025191426,
0.17277053,
0.2066578418,
-0.2350360304,
0.4384670258,
0.0985986888,
-1.0436446667,
-0.5141103864,
-0.4479462206,
-0.6380974054,
0.0248568729,
-0.2536773086,
0.349029094,
-0.7947162986,
0.1883175224,
-0.0790170655,
-0.2515838444,
-0.6204512119,
0.3609240651,
0.1138806865,
0.7730301619,
-0.6173086166,
0.5262468457,
0.7598096728,
-0.1840780377,
-1.0741602182,
-0.0363889933,
0.1337022185,
-0.9486722946,
0.7771167159,
0.1479268521,
-0.1897021979,
-0.1258396208,
-0.709123075,
-0.6678493023,
0.8654289246,
0.7415756583,
-1.034604311,
0.2302504331,
0.3924856782,
0.4550819695,
-0.1691227108,
-0.0507889576,
0.6402864456,
0.0808600932,
0.2054787278,
-0.7056503892,
-0.2440397739,
0.2282048613,
-0.2805125415,
0.5258267522,
-0.5125837326,
1.0402897596,
-0.7540153861,
0.0033524081,
-0.2971385717,
0.389112711,
0.5648534894,
0.6147609353,
0.5371303558,
0.9481598139,
1.108317256,
-0.2822565138,
0.9193834662,
0.2203669399,
0.5006402731,
1.2981042862,
-0.2561153471,
0.9296963811,
0.5396745801,
-0.1182092205,
0.7185437679,
0.7127050161,
0.2938355803,
0.4030002654,
0.3043946624,
-0.1955365539,
-0.4386868477,
0.46296224,
-0.1597346216,
0.2733950615,
0.5515126586,
-0.3119526803,
-0.4293942451,
-0.0228118338,
0.1359701157,
0.1607309282,
-0.6072414517,
0.9803153872,
0.3412323296,
-0.5101258755,
0.6002742052,
-0.2180660814,
0.3739455938,
-0.1398285031,
-0.1821694076,
-0.3932954669,
0.5791829228,
-0.3764883578,
-0.6006006002,
0.4641173482,
-0.095184125,
-0.2224857062,
-0.0958819389,
0.6784549356,
-0.2486012727,
-0.4382012188,
0.1690679789,
0.6566978693,
0.1108017862,
-0.0174441878,
-0.7787721157,
0.1660490781,
0.0452070683,
0.1384596825,
0.2554568052,
0.4566575289,
-0.2010743916,
0.7803077102,
0.793905139,
0.2846841216,
0.0788226798,
0.2390449494,
0.5815147758,
-0.7726073265,
-0.2408815026,
-1.1080694199,
0.3833810389,
-0.0996260568,
-0.3171449304,
0.5118684769,
0.5439783335,
1.0631196499,
-0.1667815894,
0.777607739,
0.5491303205,
0.6176630259,
-0.6855784059,
0.3767196536,
-0.4564206004,
0.6266620159,
0.0254503433,
-1.1016061306,
-0.5289027095,
0.7510871887,
-0.5168222785,
-0.0024822799,
0.657276988,
0.8862710595,
0.0786493868,
0.0474893898,
0.4686149061,
0.2965072095,
0.5100941062,
0.9002315998,
1.0442413092,
-0.3356000483,
0.3052848279,
-0.1567706019,
-0.1392295361,
-0.2639937401,
-0.7808252573,
-0.8531870246,
-0.2264011651,
-0.4788775444,
-0.4968509674,
0.0973934308,
1.1226010323,
0.3587024808,
-0.8092740774,
-0.0055068298,
-0.6176303029,
0.5377222896,
-0.0130748106,
-0.1739180088,
0.1012835652,
-0.7490475178,
-0.5110622644,
0.3753449321,
0.2599756122,
0.2373983413,
0.0620623268,
-0.4685813785,
0.2669733763,
0.3335402608,
0.565058887,
0.4525100291,
-0.5797114372,
-0.4171490669,
-0.1178542823,
-0.0549005866,
0.2511503994,
1.0013233423,
-0.7145674229,
0.4629887938,
0.3246170878,
0.8802655339,
0.2239103317,
-0.324252367,
0.5400771499,
-0.5761932731,
-0.2897393107,
0.092411086,
0.7343748212,
0.7273097038,
-0.4649444222,
0.72317487,
0.452159971,
-0.8417553306,
-0.8632537127,
0.1203321889,
-0.7376343012,
-0.2691208124,
1.1981269121,
-0.1202199683,
-0.2538706362,
-0.1301595718,
-0.5509617329,
0.1853307933,
-0.278640151,
1.0668697357,
0.7994136214,
-0.33399418,
-0.2515620887,
-0.410587579,
0.7243247628,
0.6645020247,
-1.1236402988,
0.0262432266,
0.5152281523,
0.5517291427,
0.1666081399,
0.305216223,
-0.2513068318,
0.6693220735,
-0.2939037383,
-0.2454449087,
0.0112933759,
-0.4589355588,
-0.536991775,
-0.081193693,
0.3710321486,
0.1054295376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20656v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20656v1
|
Non-Compositionality in Sentiment: New Data and Analyses
| 2023-10-31T17:25:07 | 2023-10-31T17:25:07 |
Verna Dankers, Christopher G. Lucas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
When natural language phrases are combined, their meaning is often more than
the sum of their parts. In the context of NLP tasks such as sentiment analysis,
where the meaning of a phrase is its sentiment, that still applies. Many NLP
studies on sentiment analysis, however, focus on the fact that sentiment
computations are largely compositional. We, instead, set out to obtain
non-compositionality ratings for phrases with respect to their sentiment. Our
contributions are as follows: a) a methodology for obtaining those
non-compositionality ratings, b) a resource of ratings for 259 phrases --
NonCompSST -- along with an analysis of that resource, and c) an evaluation of
computational models for sentiment analysis using this new resource.
|
[
-0.455430299,
-0.6300196052,
0.2238814533,
0.8255959749,
-0.6714336872,
0.282800436,
-0.1342652589,
-0.465472132,
0.7071628571,
0.3970695436,
-0.549325943,
-0.3165814579,
-0.691716969,
0.2601562738,
-0.3134053349,
1.3632313013,
0.3128421307,
0.2730427384,
-0.8971114159,
-0.4103554487,
-0.4316235781,
-0.7782946825,
-0.368365705,
-0.1700833589,
0.4596707821,
0.0771618262,
0.7414220572,
-0.1291566789,
0.8217782974,
0.2298924029,
-0.1053957567,
0.0454851612,
-0.3358300626,
0.2411977798,
-0.16835621,
-0.4127508998,
-0.4441167116,
0.4727733731,
0.5384956598,
1.185285449,
0.1381971985,
-0.1546699256,
0.0564671457,
0.8604419231,
-0.6611840129,
0.2396442443,
-0.2822645903,
0.3982579112,
0.1052605361,
-0.2965585887,
-0.385799706,
-0.5221992135,
0.5302838683,
-0.1660084128,
0.1018796563,
0.0305905603,
0.2952394485,
0.1248945072,
-0.51600492,
-0.3502184749,
-0.3425246179,
1.4198732376,
-0.6368737221,
0.1820718497,
0.1438522637,
-0.2290244102,
-0.0365685262,
-0.2999977171,
-0.5420137644,
-0.5218054652,
-0.1264584064,
0.5047048926,
-0.3580870032,
-0.0298325364,
-0.0828791633,
0.7076178193,
-0.6466099024,
-0.4521871805,
0.0285166409,
0.062848106,
0.7974164486,
0.3968606889,
0.3383451402,
-0.7203520536,
-0.6579505801,
0.1106903479,
-0.242325291,
-0.1326690763,
0.1881084889,
0.3344716132,
-0.4081466198,
0.9241386652,
0.0211692303,
0.7816593051,
-0.129237324,
-0.3341473043,
0.4221756458,
-0.6753343344,
-0.4089793563,
-0.0522836633,
0.9464356303,
0.8626819253,
0.0218080152,
-0.5345634818,
-0.2436000109,
0.3272998929,
0.2607124448,
-0.5026896,
-0.3503790796,
0.1083156392,
-0.8300981522,
-0.5030170083,
0.1232616678,
-0.7244315147,
-0.4905175567,
-0.6344670653,
0.1903595924,
-0.3003556728,
-0.4295268655,
-0.0891317129,
-0.7579196095,
0.4503346086,
-0.0569065027,
-0.4928796589,
0.380176276,
0.7106690407,
1.1060439348,
-0.4084288776,
-0.2151894867,
-0.0392890126,
-0.5536718369,
-0.3476791978,
1.0663909912,
-0.6516807079,
-1.098059535,
-0.3456216156,
-0.0791543499,
-0.4112069607,
-0.5259503126,
0.7074136734,
-0.2116356194,
0.4940587282,
-0.545161128,
-0.9354912639,
-0.2800908089,
0.4462482035,
-0.8578050137,
0.9213476181,
0.2779811323,
-0.8952448368,
0.0477520972,
-0.8249508739,
-0.8306117058,
-0.2384149283,
0.1549119949,
-0.0406386554,
0.8714266419,
-0.2431421131,
0.1502263993,
-0.5673254132,
0.0777287409,
-0.3923125863,
0.1091240123,
0.9378907084,
-0.2205335498,
0.6830676198,
0.2002895772,
-0.0639386401,
-0.0848965123,
-0.5182098746,
0.2357254028,
-0.1062803939,
-0.0959306732,
-0.3173128963,
0.0597009733,
0.3511056602,
0.2684231997,
0.4433633387,
-0.5499401689,
0.0174652338,
-0.5567299128,
0.2628762722,
0.4436120391,
0.3159572184,
0.7358833551,
-0.6114393473,
0.8446741104,
-0.1124909893,
0.1656349152,
0.334951669,
-0.7947078943,
-0.740886569,
-0.0956264883,
0.1334422529,
0.4654422998,
-0.5471296906,
0.6215255857,
-0.1607428491,
-0.7522640228,
0.016768245,
-0.1270295829,
0.5313630104,
0.4523126185,
0.3967300653,
-0.4362798035,
-0.8214541674,
-0.7338455319,
-0.4110459983,
-0.1303707212,
0.295478493,
0.1358749568,
0.4408758581,
0.1506701708,
0.9096571207,
-0.8132596612,
-0.3398924768,
-0.2703609467,
0.6046339869,
0.1774933636,
0.0420248508,
0.6489925981,
-0.5552412271,
-0.5957553387,
-0.3108161092,
-0.7655290365,
-0.1120112389,
0.1871757507,
-0.1840044558,
0.3302976489,
0.2590519488,
-0.5146082044,
-0.1679000109,
0.7348729372,
-0.1141152382,
0.3998035789,
0.2864597142,
-0.1320236176,
-1.0842027664,
0.058841031,
0.1898050308,
0.0442625917,
-0.4207194448,
0.1417865753,
-0.5348289013,
-0.006885034,
-0.4765649438,
0.3765877485,
-0.1788884997,
-0.1224995926,
-0.7689120173,
0.0701170489,
0.3925345838,
0.1693313867,
0.239137426,
0.5305621624,
0.5637687445,
-0.4030671716,
0.6607265472,
0.1529209465,
-0.0431662388,
1.0321705341,
-0.4667983353,
0.0543041453,
-0.1672130972,
0.4584842026,
-0.8329437971,
0.0522767156,
-0.0478598364,
-0.6004680991,
-0.1357379109,
-0.0697005242,
-0.4703446329,
0.16484119,
-0.636556983,
0.2460973561,
0.141702652,
-0.0027756428,
0.4944958389,
0.5982750654,
-0.0420103706,
-0.3706445992,
-0.7475935221,
0.3070144057,
-0.2767559588,
-0.6198240519,
0.3945319951,
-0.1779339015,
-0.4256629646,
0.3193252683,
0.0818139091,
-0.2583337128,
0.0797535628,
0.0985146239,
0.2864922285,
-0.1260745972,
0.049797006,
-0.168176949,
-0.1770685762,
0.2731846869,
-0.1823996454,
0.5974963307,
-0.1089730635,
0.0516604222,
-0.0009922835,
0.8720695376,
0.4933391213,
-0.328694582,
0.7866668701,
0.5456953645,
-0.2573199272,
-0.018243568,
-0.0956936032,
0.0450450517,
-0.2985045016,
-0.0302023273,
0.0635749102,
-0.8069236875,
0.2679440081,
0.3984031081,
-0.0798942968,
0.6365441084,
0.6286323667,
-0.3320151269,
0.834194541,
0.3006014824,
-0.3295691907,
0.451654762,
-0.221581161,
0.5292479396,
-0.8885884881,
-0.3694259822,
-0.4632459283,
-0.5932543874,
-1.0615240335,
-0.407020241,
0.25982216,
-0.3859777153,
0.4249867499,
0.0523213111,
-0.3018321395,
0.4520256221,
0.4349440932,
-0.2112224549,
0.103102237,
-0.3502568305,
0.1660930961,
-0.167345643,
-0.1811800301,
-0.2691279352,
0.907379806,
-0.1313159168,
0.6187950969,
0.4412837029,
0.7646039128,
0.4972989559,
-0.0421276577,
-1.3970878124,
0.655359745,
-0.6867594123,
-0.6121273637,
0.2795342803,
-0.4569903314,
-0.8397750258,
0.1301744878,
-0.4491407573,
-0.2431192249,
0.1424525678,
-0.2638296187,
-0.192199558,
-0.154038623,
-0.6086308956,
0.7011844516,
-0.2116838992,
0.0288349334,
-0.167995289,
-0.6204149723,
0.3057438135,
0.0626545921,
0.0302040409,
-0.1850915253,
0.04186799,
0.629576385,
-0.3411794007,
0.8884763122,
-0.3370049298,
0.0187656656,
0.4127147794,
-0.0542271845,
0.0187828001,
-0.1373850405,
-0.1510225534,
-0.0047439346,
0.1108901054,
-0.2941960096,
-0.6557251811,
0.9242898226,
-0.7541664243,
0.1313121915,
-0.718970716,
-0.3357783258,
-0.2645722032,
-0.2707203627,
0.3564199507,
0.4242031276,
-0.2573465109,
0.4938315749,
0.4595761001,
-0.2197346091,
0.3999740481,
0.1151226386,
-0.1180760935,
-0.6001213193,
1.1124452353,
0.2017515153,
0.3430461287,
0.726018548,
0.5335973501,
-0.8627272248,
-0.1852988303,
0.0218131002,
-0.0094123855,
-0.722933352,
-0.3021339774,
-0.5492430329,
-0.0985539705,
-0.3853859007,
-0.0082361801,
-0.2087998688,
-0.8581188321,
-0.3004012704,
-0.0476156995,
0.3379559815,
0.433547318,
0.0006018358,
0.339605689,
-1.015570879,
0.3478237092,
0.1231718212,
0.2690915167,
-0.1386426985,
-0.2729704082,
-0.1785409153,
-0.1970904469,
-0.4960599542,
-1.0230741501,
0.4607822895,
0.5023735762,
0.3923627138,
0.2224442661,
0.1838658601,
0.5562703013,
0.1507982761,
1.1262757778,
0.3243051171,
-1.1217899323,
0.3754554093,
-0.303101182,
0.0701810569,
0.5459887981,
0.0743688792,
-0.6696261168,
-0.4715323448,
-0.6328366399,
-0.7927895784,
0.2863500416,
0.0621230453,
0.6543024778,
-0.3950882554,
0.0771305785,
-0.0819848329,
0.4563345015,
-0.8498078585,
-0.376288563,
-0.6377619505,
-0.2833872736,
-0.0821745843,
-0.390515238,
-0.1607363224,
-0.1401861608,
0.5435876846,
-0.1232623234,
0.6305837035,
-0.068411544,
-0.1488521099,
-0.0023882485,
0.3375763893,
0.5708165169,
0.3434941471,
-0.0910413414,
0.1125461012,
-0.0445395522,
-0.1637231708,
0.0048012282,
-0.1031608433,
0.1762114018,
0.0486642644,
0.5670707822,
0.6153443456,
0.2759480774,
-0.4247308373,
0.7750605345,
-0.0825470164,
-0.1555688381,
-0.4389808476,
-0.0794241875,
0.1477820426,
-0.0767530948,
0.016837772,
0.1639181525,
0.5051596165,
-0.8559436202,
0.0821945071,
0.7731644511,
-0.4188118279,
-0.3945972025,
-0.0505939499,
0.1346579045,
0.3988049328,
0.6790686846,
-0.5098872185,
-0.4448360205,
0.3047810793,
0.490636915,
1.0628817081,
0.0290955845,
0.4004672468,
0.1823267043,
0.0649349615,
0.1911162585,
0.8234915733,
0.150578022,
-0.7631444931,
-0.8723654747,
-0.8892264366,
-0.5796679258,
-0.2116853744,
-0.6833438277,
0.0218774285,
-0.5725185871,
-0.3596103489,
0.0958109275,
0.0762729645,
-0.1194635853,
0.6659935117,
0.0536104739,
0.4490226209,
-1.1056075096,
0.4595373571,
0.9539141655,
-0.6054766774,
-0.5745073557,
0.109644942,
-0.0523719154,
-0.3657364547,
0.384177655,
0.226924479,
-0.2303140163,
-0.2717863917,
-0.3758990169,
-0.4963650405,
0.5526764989,
0.2724705338,
0.0270957015,
0.2226945907,
0.3336087167,
0.8498059511,
-0.2917859256,
0.0852396339,
0.4302497804,
0.6227701306,
0.1715354472,
-0.7170658708,
-0.2694878876,
-0.4834041595,
-0.3010891676,
0.4741983116,
-0.4816704094,
1.2247303724,
0.4012316763,
-0.1371368617,
0.2189457417,
0.4897300005,
-0.0565952472,
0.3472475708,
0.3586994112,
0.7963334322,
0.5537168384,
-0.1648634523,
1.224850893,
-0.3921407163,
0.5181097388,
0.9548992515,
-0.2103372067,
0.6875504851,
0.5714246035,
-0.4505125582,
0.6014368534,
0.4931743145,
-0.1031359658,
0.5436571836,
0.2538264692,
-0.5732764602,
-0.254450798,
-0.6220319867,
-0.1370472759,
0.9668547511,
0.0365642123,
-0.4805401862,
-0.1469003707,
-0.0601663999,
-0.0467664935,
0.0954534635,
-0.0764407218,
0.9932608604,
0.3829235137,
-0.6267555952,
0.1054903492,
0.33580181,
0.5161696672,
-0.2376858741,
0.107736297,
-0.2585903406,
-0.2198040932,
-0.681196928,
-0.8797920346,
0.9998173714,
0.0747543275,
-0.3624306321,
-0.0231617354,
0.4416638315,
0.1698932499,
-0.668762207,
0.2373126,
0.8260496855,
0.0216508042,
-0.3736415803,
-0.6094568968,
-0.2574823797,
0.0580269992,
0.1957681328,
0.3279199898,
0.343664825,
0.0493909791,
0.1910073161,
0.8030406833,
-0.0089047542,
0.0769250914,
0.3741275966,
0.6834298968,
-1.0113506317,
-0.3826237619,
-1.0739876032,
0.3158024251,
0.0068855989,
-0.2936827838,
0.8044044375,
0.7281414866,
0.3995900452,
-0.112985611,
1.0264568329,
-0.2522173524,
0.3955658972,
-0.6651342511,
0.2626308799,
-0.5158914924,
-0.0500088222,
-0.4120196402,
-1.2660752535,
-0.4887803793,
0.7297881246,
-0.173528105,
0.0467868559,
0.8592931628,
0.4092712402,
0.1302492023,
0.5876238346,
0.0716654733,
-0.2768139541,
0.2357710898,
0.0226647425,
1.3000370264,
0.0599342994,
0.1371485889,
-0.3169378638,
0.0807098597,
-0.1207988262,
-1.1952911615,
-0.5158213973,
-0.3662047684,
-0.3082254827,
-0.0973379537,
-0.5726317167,
0.9715431333,
0.1745191514,
-0.5582031012,
-0.328364104,
-0.2374836802,
0.1210120767,
-0.1550829858,
-0.3339192271,
0.1157337949,
-0.5559853315,
-0.6508348584,
0.5299102068,
0.2351402342,
-0.0317717828,
-0.5409447551,
0.183921352,
0.0940377861,
0.5034302473,
0.9842410684,
-0.277761817,
-0.3297603428,
-0.0660397485,
0.2406671941,
0.2893449664,
0.2401026934,
1.0382188559,
-0.4769377112,
0.3493819535,
0.7787172794,
0.2383600473,
0.0081216935,
0.0097657079,
0.3526682556,
-1.2831147909,
-0.0809203684,
0.4262481034,
0.4470260739,
0.6783640981,
0.0371698476,
0.2541022599,
0.4958577156,
-0.2999090254,
-0.5438540578,
0.5512314439,
-1.3492895365,
0.000215224,
0.9182813168,
-0.0091260551,
-0.0489777997,
0.0575392544,
-0.1112314016,
-0.0085596098,
-0.4491966665,
0.5389078259,
0.8024597168,
-0.754234612,
-0.0069587003,
-0.19590877,
0.09464591,
0.4026716352,
-1.0181658268,
-0.2140000761,
0.679350853,
0.0349947847,
0.3420595825,
0.5034108162,
-0.3773396909,
0.0065748449,
-0.1496176124,
-0.1987432688,
0.4288987815,
-0.1023345888,
-0.1569991708,
0.1766098887,
0.3725243211,
-0.1292949319
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20633v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20633v1
|
Defining a New NLP Playground
| 2023-10-31T17:02:33 | 2023-10-31T17:02:33 |
Sha Li, Chi Han, Pengfei Yu, Carl Edwards, Manling Li, Xingyao Wang, Yi R. Fung, Charles Yu, Joel R. Tetreault, Eduard H. Hovy, Heng Ji
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The recent explosion of performance of large language models (LLMs) has
changed the field of Natural Language Processing (NLP) more abruptly and
seismically than any other shift in the field's 80-year history. This has
resulted in concerns that the field will become homogenized and
resource-intensive. The new status quo has put many academic researchers,
especially PhD students, at a disadvantage. This paper aims to define a new NLP
playground by proposing 20+ PhD-dissertation-worthy research directions,
covering theoretical analysis, new and challenging problems, learning
paradigms, and interdisciplinary applications.
|
[
-0.4296015799,
-0.4972624183,
0.1403217018,
0.7335344553,
0.044131197,
0.529463172,
-0.0916574448,
-0.4465773106,
0.0610628352,
0.5273748636,
-0.5853314996,
-0.3959047496,
-0.8057031631,
0.3591659665,
-0.9473235607,
0.892809093,
0.0352222398,
-0.1322345436,
-0.2563064694,
-0.210629344,
-0.3789840341,
-0.452116251,
-0.7626106143,
-0.3762888312,
0.4937421083,
-0.0450746082,
0.4833666682,
0.5065579414,
0.5606131554,
0.2726493478,
-0.5186401606,
-0.2736171186,
-0.3446699977,
0.2578344941,
-0.2223364115,
-0.5778992176,
-0.3736065626,
0.0432266109,
0.89597857,
1.0101217031,
-0.0869569853,
-0.1295157373,
0.0614303276,
0.7880185843,
-0.4972331524,
0.0536459461,
-0.74801898,
0.4896584451,
-0.2232268155,
-0.3052046299,
-0.4199649096,
-0.1382179558,
0.2999524176,
-0.5074917078,
-0.0237033963,
-0.2097795755,
0.5313331485,
0.0853914917,
-0.3666085005,
0.0201219656,
-0.7865658402,
0.995185256,
-0.6419149637,
0.3051523268,
0.1205756292,
0.4499176145,
-0.4038028717,
-0.8294636607,
-0.2878343463,
0.1045912206,
0.4112039506,
-0.1210664287,
-0.2359476686,
-0.280957669,
0.1335400641,
0.1599239409,
-0.1614132524,
0.5136695504,
-0.2060236037,
0.2670514286,
0.7549020052,
0.34675318,
0.2916453481,
-0.2414036393,
-0.3201887608,
0.2171645761,
-0.6794633865,
0.1796018779,
0.1306428313,
0.2827598751,
0.1485716552,
0.6173984408,
-0.3224056363,
0.554371357,
-0.1087777764,
-0.416852057,
0.3301005363,
-0.0571780577,
-0.14919433,
-0.1316995025,
0.5800671577,
0.4896226823,
0.0988866836,
-0.3706422448,
-0.2256352752,
-0.1199698001,
0.2731797695,
-0.4527237415,
-0.0083451718,
0.1832282692,
-0.4211750627,
-0.5247923136,
-0.5450058579,
-1.1140471697,
-0.6556756496,
-0.3894267082,
-0.0930935293,
-0.7868152261,
-0.4341448545,
0.2992652059,
-0.1582673788,
0.3770258427,
0.3632644415,
-1.0330889225,
0.4998893142,
0.9104859829,
1.0156747103,
-0.5525789857,
-0.3436281085,
-0.1050497368,
0.1567388773,
-0.192055434,
0.692494154,
-0.7031071782,
-0.4311513603,
0.4642369449,
-0.2849345803,
0.1345117092,
-0.5806516409,
0.7061481476,
-0.4659917951,
0.3857270479,
-0.0387811139,
-0.3773231804,
-0.0038919384,
0.5020590425,
-0.5531251431,
1.0504324436,
0.1970130801,
-0.7732834816,
0.3439322114,
-0.7939576507,
-0.3562685847,
0.2040948272,
-0.0891021267,
0.0008836892,
0.0901236236,
0.023804687,
0.211451903,
-0.4086486101,
0.4733755291,
0.0657066405,
-0.1253929585,
0.4070075452,
-0.1813464463,
1.0731719732,
0.1326031238,
-0.0965872034,
-0.1143693849,
-1.2200733423,
0.1592853367,
-0.1031779647,
-0.6992131472,
-0.3632795215,
0.2973002493,
0.1792803407,
0.3955559134,
0.2172205448,
-0.2797634006,
0.1744560897,
-0.6779815555,
0.6682419777,
0.8336874247,
-0.4296662211,
0.8356347084,
-0.2434682846,
0.7744185925,
-0.2807714641,
-0.0259222575,
-0.2500959635,
-0.5303919315,
-0.5220376253,
-0.2249097973,
0.3115274906,
0.3606657088,
-0.4824237823,
0.342417717,
-0.1485339999,
-0.295078218,
-0.2795279026,
-0.0465113185,
-0.07716088,
0.3327381611,
0.4636324942,
-0.3229762316,
-1.1037527323,
-0.6384686828,
-0.56531775,
0.1904181093,
-0.1942159832,
0.1963768005,
0.4010590613,
-0.4452660382,
1.2751311064,
-0.1303249598,
-0.5692576766,
-0.3267059326,
0.2103473395,
0.3680023551,
0.4176578522,
0.5188592076,
-0.900153935,
-0.5617703795,
-0.2722914815,
-0.8055396676,
-0.3085571527,
0.1567172706,
0.173221007,
-0.1356281936,
0.828848362,
-0.9471389055,
-0.1272018254,
0.5877934694,
-0.1254042536,
0.6098703146,
0.271155566,
-0.4040531516,
-0.9186948538,
0.0026466418,
-0.0530891418,
0.1397526264,
-0.4881070554,
0.3522267938,
-0.5213479996,
-0.1263357997,
-0.4542168975,
0.6107996702,
-0.4343093038,
0.0393928438,
-0.2466434538,
0.3931958675,
-0.2164290547,
-0.0313511714,
-0.4708984792,
0.423208952,
0.6364803314,
-0.5944294333,
0.4448209405,
0.2269255072,
-0.3800985217,
0.3016244769,
-0.4388988018,
-0.0857884064,
-0.268599093,
0.5513711572,
-0.7249165773,
-0.2433374524,
-0.2566829622,
-0.2801037431,
0.2458070517,
-0.1927228272,
-0.4395577908,
-0.3912073076,
-0.4383758307,
0.459119916,
0.4852686226,
-0.2691445947,
0.9155446291,
0.6992800236,
-0.3187832236,
-0.8591177464,
-0.6507316828,
0.5008456707,
-0.4812622666,
-0.6477943063,
0.8817287683,
0.0711636767,
-0.5921666622,
-0.0014418084,
0.0062908344,
-0.3691646457,
0.3892850876,
0.2820870876,
0.0807802379,
-0.2677981853,
-0.0027843826,
-0.2179439217,
-0.2543739676,
0.4592981339,
-0.168180719,
0.9564137459,
0.1313262582,
0.178216204,
0.0030627726,
0.3561058044,
0.1613176614,
-0.1636991203,
0.646643877,
0.4463267922,
-0.3623141646,
-0.411842972,
-0.2710236907,
0.2191654146,
-0.5307352543,
0.4951894283,
-0.0269756746,
-1.3414138556,
0.3236142099,
-0.5469017029,
0.2829817533,
0.3516229987,
0.5378615856,
-0.0581310242,
0.9319840074,
1.0444524288,
-0.0046584681,
0.5887001753,
-0.1271527708,
0.4723417759,
-0.9678747058,
-0.2805917263,
-0.5236514807,
-0.5088824034,
-0.6278765202,
-0.6102260351,
-0.028366724,
0.0887023062,
-0.0081816437,
0.379948318,
-0.3862372637,
0.6020736694,
0.2748357058,
-0.6258870363,
0.3158979118,
-0.0866519511,
-0.4371529818,
-0.4894011021,
-0.5206139088,
-0.6905680895,
1.2871005535,
0.4533788264,
0.5389239788,
0.1574570537,
0.7062411904,
0.1736319512,
0.2348779291,
-0.4345090389,
0.8713546991,
-0.2666288614,
-0.8719097376,
-0.3608727157,
-0.254657805,
-1.0115962029,
0.3768879175,
-0.4286181629,
-1.1507942677,
-0.1566692889,
-0.343804121,
-0.3458583355,
0.2856200039,
-0.3739668131,
0.5096570253,
0.0072281682,
-0.4458770454,
-0.045694001,
-0.3163875937,
0.581543088,
-0.1155838594,
0.4571275115,
-0.4944313765,
-0.0301382691,
0.6634114385,
0.2736539841,
0.6274391413,
-0.0925763324,
-0.1969946623,
0.253485769,
0.1980522275,
0.3326888382,
0.1101905406,
-0.20414491,
-0.157739073,
-0.059388075,
-0.1012092531,
-0.2598573864,
0.8021413684,
-0.4808285236,
-0.4960490465,
-0.5071002841,
-0.8056970239,
-0.3808017969,
0.2154649943,
0.1015364975,
-0.1991999447,
-0.5755306482,
0.4210142195,
0.6930790544,
-0.7024337053,
0.6369861364,
0.4901375175,
-0.8362367153,
-0.0249198824,
0.6894748807,
0.2485200763,
-0.1162010729,
0.437318027,
-0.082087785,
-0.2155313492,
-0.7470974922,
0.209084928,
-0.0828927457,
-0.5536534786,
0.0336820632,
-0.8696430922,
-0.5193173885,
-0.5254796743,
-0.3624817431,
-0.4523827136,
-0.6271411777,
-0.1793750823,
-0.0471598357,
0.0953974128,
0.4399550855,
-0.2209186256,
0.3882819414,
-0.4723773301,
0.2918437719,
0.3626634479,
0.4883478284,
-0.0483773947,
-0.6032570601,
-0.1891888082,
-0.2795836329,
-0.4270446897,
-0.4487816095,
0.8048965931,
0.0820096359,
0.4324401617,
0.0761488974,
-0.1417115182,
0.2387565076,
-0.860280931,
0.6897753477,
0.425571084,
-0.6854313016,
0.2697829008,
-0.5795209408,
0.165427953,
0.3235712349,
0.348446548,
-0.7829946876,
-0.2822007537,
-0.6278038621,
-1.3665565252,
0.4837323427,
0.0237205364,
0.6086584926,
0.0804078057,
0.1694747508,
0.1829591095,
0.328399241,
-1.0497893095,
-0.1180513427,
0.1564514935,
0.1387916654,
0.0509201251,
-0.4287935793,
-0.3656903505,
-0.3323045969,
0.2979486883,
-0.0924221799,
0.3772851527,
-0.3786092401,
0.2068105936,
-0.2776115835,
0.4481199682,
0.0742540136,
0.8849209547,
-0.2605268359,
0.3506741524,
0.3477523327,
-0.0265213251,
0.2025357634,
0.1013110653,
-0.3672561347,
0.0910319686,
0.3333643079,
0.1968961656,
0.5282796025,
-0.855730772,
0.4273534715,
0.1203592792,
-0.4371022582,
-0.7064136863,
0.3491301239,
0.3581043482,
0.2572450042,
0.648416996,
0.142662853,
0.0555408224,
-0.6953001022,
0.3338588178,
0.40803352,
-0.2516310811,
-0.2792938352,
0.6294445992,
0.2686965764,
-0.608240366,
0.3248893321,
-0.1698578596,
-0.3844261169,
0.4248993993,
0.7192580104,
0.8015384674,
-0.1285006106,
0.447006166,
0.2670606971,
0.2734742761,
-0.2598956823,
-0.0050923703,
0.4914401472,
-0.8879601955,
-0.742701292,
-0.8174558878,
-0.2043359578,
0.3923517466,
-0.3760734499,
0.3727764785,
-0.9257942438,
-0.2161178589,
0.1952183992,
-0.2256289124,
-0.3673676252,
0.22623083,
0.0825858861,
0.9956381321,
-0.5210232735,
0.7054600716,
0.4521701932,
-0.1225555614,
-0.0207081158,
-0.2262508273,
0.1646648496,
-0.6155660748,
0.9665161967,
0.1611634642,
0.1837598681,
-0.0479089543,
-0.892572701,
-1.0454792976,
0.9568003416,
0.3024107218,
-0.3396216631,
-0.5826317668,
0.2127868235,
0.7752171755,
-0.4547748566,
-0.1274246275,
0.7112013102,
0.3035738468,
-0.3376215398,
-0.683085978,
-0.3552190363,
-0.2716998458,
-0.0073301243,
0.030822536,
-0.5356526375,
1.1822001934,
0.071280919,
-0.1857204437,
0.0506977811,
0.6310327053,
0.384526521,
0.3621364236,
0.21641922,
0.5685088634,
0.4467241168,
-0.0440548919,
0.866754055,
-0.1680285037,
0.2036397755,
1.1335918903,
-0.4451439381,
0.9505986571,
0.6929163933,
-0.608494699,
0.5382889509,
0.2217432559,
-0.0292970072,
0.3993650675,
0.5471846461,
-0.4974422455,
-0.1064855233,
-0.2671304941,
-0.3185952306,
0.5470706224,
0.306867063,
-0.4517866373,
-0.332488358,
-0.1496974975,
0.1061275229,
0.4455454946,
0.0795954093,
0.3420001268,
0.305965662,
-0.3806131482,
0.1868325472,
0.5567023754,
0.9959153533,
-0.5762995481,
0.0756016225,
-0.1063359901,
0.0827823877,
-0.2733550072,
-0.7158721685,
0.3814614117,
0.1442209035,
-0.1493771672,
-0.6080226898,
0.6093069315,
0.0456487015,
-0.3996382356,
0.8062013388,
0.56942451,
-0.1366211921,
0.0447197556,
-0.9106535912,
-0.0878846943,
-0.1084000915,
-0.2369525135,
0.8486754298,
0.886629343,
0.2896231413,
1.0232260227,
0.6538249254,
0.0038441066,
0.5765128732,
-0.0661874413,
0.9768768549,
-0.9374353886,
-0.2666064501,
-0.6754422188,
0.3673289418,
-0.1449601948,
-0.7544029951,
0.8650286198,
0.5607249737,
0.6453648806,
0.3052811623,
0.7523636818,
-0.3453635275,
0.7370709181,
-0.4264802933,
0.4033524394,
-0.2894151807,
0.519421339,
-0.4652056694,
-0.972635448,
-0.5217545033,
0.8886037469,
-0.1395908296,
0.0320563465,
0.6047070622,
0.377279222,
0.1771728545,
-0.0033537708,
0.2356458157,
0.3802823424,
0.5313358903,
0.4248867631,
1.0737493038,
-0.2459919602,
0.3901467919,
-0.2009538114,
0.0405708887,
-0.3260761499,
-1.109446764,
-0.7308188081,
-0.475962311,
-0.2004416585,
-0.3217530847,
-0.097366482,
0.7933860421,
0.4056677818,
-0.4758449495,
-0.5129349828,
-0.3304923177,
0.1925598234,
-0.1108990908,
-0.3188316226,
-0.1090968177,
-0.5750849843,
-0.6614637971,
0.6727820635,
0.5144441128,
-0.1698482633,
-0.5330459476,
-0.0451001823,
-0.7191872597,
-0.132969141,
0.9476460814,
0.4060444832,
-0.60877496,
0.0399970561,
-0.004435604,
-0.13434349,
0.1545242369,
0.7726566792,
-0.6979161501,
0.2235153317,
0.2799083889,
0.7685704231,
0.3224182129,
-0.4200130105,
0.7110681534,
-0.822032094,
0.2068249583,
0.6906163096,
0.2145181894,
0.3296662867,
0.2968250811,
0.7965786457,
0.3516676426,
-0.4480733275,
-1.1801398993,
0.1367487013,
-0.7657949924,
-0.4225950241,
1.1745787859,
0.1144688278,
-0.2498633564,
-0.2014855444,
-0.0574528165,
-0.0605538972,
-0.1379594654,
1.2526254654,
0.9785155654,
-0.1522153467,
-0.3132574558,
-0.9297646284,
0.7307485342,
0.5532221794,
-0.5921945572,
-0.0011440115,
0.2117305398,
0.1362777054,
0.3895874619,
0.806622386,
-0.2334369421,
-0.1471272409,
0.1177141517,
-0.0213347487,
0.3493493199,
-0.4058982432,
-0.2105335742,
0.4935927391,
0.200335741,
0.4148504734
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20620v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20620v2
|
The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Random Target Embeddings for Continuous-Output Neural Machine Translation
| 2023-10-31T16:53:10 | 2024-04-02T15:56:46 |
Evgeniia Tokarchuk, Vlad Niculae
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Continuous-output neural machine translation (CoNMT) replaces the discrete
next-word prediction problem with an embedding prediction. The semantic
structure of the target embedding space (i.e., closeness of related words) is
intuitively believed to be crucial. We challenge this assumption and show that
completely random output embeddings can outperform laboriously pretrained ones,
especially on larger datasets. Further investigation shows this surprising
effect is strongest for rare words, due to the geometry of their embeddings. We
shed further light on this finding by designing a mixed strategy that combines
random and pre-trained embeddings for different tokens.
|
[
-0.219818458,
-0.609398067,
0.6554827094,
0.1127121076,
-0.707431078,
0.0479923598,
-0.3866954148,
-0.2248490006,
0.2622121274,
0.4651220143,
-0.5276983976,
-0.5871037245,
-1.0119650364,
-0.1074327826,
-0.608532548,
0.8645623922,
-0.099514991,
0.2706201971,
-0.173922196,
-0.3441731036,
-0.9094682336,
-0.7847165465,
-0.4776544869,
-0.3940970004,
0.7645569444,
0.2573600709,
0.9367991686,
0.8351047635,
0.6403844357,
0.2324819565,
0.2146965861,
0.0124049848,
-0.6402959824,
0.2264229804,
0.1338581592,
-0.8076525927,
0.3077496886,
0.005047278,
0.7522909045,
0.8676314354,
-0.0780250356,
-0.2476849705,
0.1877372116,
0.3026328981,
-0.3669062257,
-0.3951690197,
-0.8802528381,
0.4901487529,
-0.4204612672,
-0.2312013656,
-0.4811505973,
-0.3008561432,
0.2152150422,
-0.4406456351,
0.1616357863,
0.4745061994,
0.7447468042,
0.5108909011,
-0.3309730291,
-0.4821967483,
-0.872382462,
0.8703386784,
-0.47748667,
0.2773679495,
0.0924682766,
0.2976317108,
-0.4871709943,
-0.9404988885,
-0.5237411261,
-0.2706169784,
-0.0374507681,
0.1403283328,
-0.1460506469,
0.2070440352,
0.2195202261,
0.1779101938,
-0.5108434558,
0.2330519557,
-0.0797911808,
-0.043989487,
0.0232445076,
0.0078097736,
0.2816211283,
0.1584676653,
-0.5141848922,
-0.1927619278,
-0.8751378059,
-0.361187607,
0.3296951652,
0.082539089,
0.0174589194,
0.9668498635,
0.0736921579,
0.6247924566,
-0.1778932959,
0.4912313819,
0.0845696256,
-0.303969264,
-0.0848754868,
0.2333980948,
0.810850203,
0.3149050474,
0.4600300789,
-0.4302096963,
-0.0906423926,
0.1182948574,
0.2865622342,
-0.4432233572,
-0.0563677587,
0.2064528316,
-0.2937907875,
-0.1328902394,
-0.0395960845,
-0.1978237629,
-0.0280392766,
-0.0712708756,
0.5882230997,
-0.615621388,
0.2586736083,
-0.051326327,
-0.4451871216,
-0.3733003438,
0.0103323609,
-0.6110446453,
0.2615392208,
0.6357123256,
0.9608573318,
-0.3043510318,
-0.5487628579,
-0.5061568022,
0.2339298278,
-0.3963748217,
0.6736631989,
-0.6059291363,
-0.4055958688,
0.0086578056,
-0.4070879817,
-0.1421289593,
-0.5299520493,
0.2974530756,
-0.4207690656,
0.1312487125,
-0.3114396036,
-0.8302361369,
-0.1683066934,
0.1852329075,
-0.5169552565,
0.5764229894,
0.0860653147,
-0.6285941005,
0.6487119794,
-0.1677833349,
-0.334687531,
-0.1947489381,
-0.3599161506,
-0.4027439356,
0.4413247705,
-0.2123212218,
0.5363259315,
-0.0308061764,
0.2844586074,
-0.5592913628,
-0.6303678155,
0.571811676,
-0.5659031868,
0.1998919994,
0.2953450978,
-0.5348677635,
-0.0379401483,
-0.4752374291,
0.0411154032,
0.073560603,
-0.1598469913,
-0.6723201275,
0.068878673,
-0.1403027326,
0.3545284867,
0.1949799955,
-0.5776615143,
0.0321364328,
-0.3295867741,
0.3229412436,
0.5863135457,
-0.041275084,
0.6524192691,
-0.4627143145,
0.5083309412,
0.1212666035,
0.0420905724,
0.1659615338,
-0.5466730595,
-0.32800439,
-0.363098532,
0.454543978,
0.1795418411,
-0.7037807107,
0.1413771808,
-0.3422969282,
-0.5235270858,
-0.4049450755,
0.1020020172,
0.5279947519,
0.2412285805,
0.165227592,
-0.5789672732,
-0.5588434339,
-0.9600455761,
-0.6186659336,
0.3833232224,
0.038295269,
-0.0125063546,
0.393546164,
-0.0246261675,
0.5496677756,
-0.5026725531,
-0.3925819099,
-0.0807717815,
0.0233127177,
0.3776229918,
0.651427567,
0.4075177908,
-0.6710996032,
-0.443108052,
-0.1669025272,
-0.7418885231,
0.5711551309,
-0.2891706228,
-0.13592574,
-0.387454927,
0.5272967815,
-0.797073245,
0.362241596,
0.7692375183,
-0.0478132442,
0.1781133413,
-0.3748804927,
-0.1225876808,
-1.1360121965,
-0.3226544261,
-0.3198553622,
-0.1583338529,
-0.4004573822,
-0.0555703491,
-0.1882169098,
-0.0218062736,
-0.765820086,
0.1953408569,
-0.3831085861,
-0.1349991262,
-0.1812637299,
0.1923750788,
-0.3328034282,
0.4804712832,
-0.1502682567,
0.6372452974,
-0.0184242018,
-0.4714370072,
0.0763577297,
0.112229012,
-0.4338647127,
0.0879175365,
-0.781257689,
0.0857182667,
0.1763542891,
0.445187211,
-1.0686405897,
-0.0840015262,
0.0917977169,
-0.5178701282,
0.3746537566,
0.2842814922,
-0.7356697321,
-0.3312564194,
-0.2286054045,
0.5906809568,
0.5793861151,
-0.3260604739,
0.1599030495,
0.1849564463,
0.3834774196,
-0.5360059738,
-1.0342068672,
-0.0204023123,
-0.2385629714,
-0.2554233372,
0.4297255874,
0.1221939996,
0.0562582798,
0.3030153811,
0.1390651315,
0.163617,
0.1826297045,
0.4568293989,
-0.2114196867,
-0.1916708797,
-0.0622068532,
0.1340743154,
0.0140479039,
-0.0003554449,
-0.6385229826,
0.7176821828,
0.275293678,
-0.6894605756,
0.0574651323,
0.5970820785,
0.3993861973,
0.1614447981,
1.0221984386,
0.7250977755,
-0.4987272024,
-0.3076674342,
-0.1501789391,
-0.1267865002,
-0.4526416659,
0.7126731873,
-0.4112944007,
-1.0216548443,
0.3605667055,
-0.2326812297,
0.0877288133,
0.4484652877,
0.595705092,
-0.376218766,
1.2020623684,
0.7151381969,
0.32500875,
0.3790974915,
-0.2877916396,
0.2318891734,
-0.8631376028,
-0.341865778,
-0.5238122344,
-0.7392050624,
-1.0041589737,
-0.3383571804,
0.1098636091,
0.0355201438,
-0.2021953017,
0.5625922084,
-0.5280387402,
0.1169441119,
1.0469994545,
0.0694105625,
0.0348080322,
0.3002790511,
-0.7106102109,
-0.4372978508,
-1.1808974743,
-0.2313392013,
1.2155983448,
0.2403197289,
0.5027743578,
-0.2064395547,
0.9830949903,
0.2657224834,
0.4685545564,
-0.7750068903,
0.1961050332,
-0.3808254898,
-0.5716743469,
-0.1745709032,
-0.2281762362,
-1.0779299736,
0.0662874579,
-0.1852393448,
-0.415933311,
0.0916861668,
0.1103731841,
-0.3184840977,
0.5116612315,
-0.8587671518,
0.7320825458,
-0.153222084,
-0.0097989868,
-0.360688597,
-0.5623592138,
0.2241088897,
-0.344673574,
0.1323129982,
0.1066348106,
-0.194674179,
0.7680155039,
-0.5683059096,
0.6301962137,
0.0362337157,
0.3627592921,
0.2341765612,
0.0561681688,
0.4530899227,
-0.2386977822,
0.1400458664,
0.2354715616,
-0.2778455913,
-0.5152654648,
-0.7257143259,
0.8044981956,
-0.816667676,
-0.5273417234,
-0.5361863375,
-0.662393868,
-0.3777373135,
0.3072943687,
0.9025504589,
0.3865579367,
-0.3118554354,
0.5409852862,
0.5456883311,
-0.0997469425,
0.3753572106,
-0.1010746211,
0.0077444869,
-0.6761817932,
0.920316875,
0.5222424865,
0.3449022472,
0.7195379734,
0.0951241404,
-0.3483248353,
-0.8393148184,
-0.1041828096,
0.1923741698,
-0.5524493456,
-0.0102387397,
-0.6009643078,
-0.2471793592,
0.0655171499,
-0.4246175587,
-0.4059599638,
-0.5415222645,
-0.1151457652,
0.0294265319,
0.0879580453,
0.8871665001,
-0.0270813741,
0.6469942331,
-0.8491957188,
0.0154907843,
0.2147455364,
0.2668988407,
-0.0831892788,
-0.5811126232,
-0.4265951216,
0.249979645,
-0.2876557112,
-0.6894230843,
0.3616882563,
0.1395006925,
0.4799239933,
0.3548932374,
-0.0440322421,
0.5329816341,
-0.831859827,
0.7237741351,
0.6777920127,
-0.3522444665,
0.2196182907,
-0.256400466,
0.4245782793,
0.5552633405,
0.5081149936,
-0.2978375554,
-0.7139258981,
-0.9267834425,
-0.7584868073,
0.2323311418,
0.4654127061,
0.3805730343,
-0.355871886,
-0.0199424997,
0.2650850713,
0.5107916594,
-0.3567451537,
-0.3534373045,
-0.0363738798,
-0.5020104051,
-0.2680104375,
-0.2138657272,
0.0049479245,
0.0007951335,
0.283573091,
0.2703772485,
0.6371331215,
0.1721743643,
0.000462469,
-0.0414995626,
-0.0783585757,
0.8460510373,
0.2836934328,
-0.2995575666,
0.3100956082,
0.2574774325,
-0.6780845523,
0.0439723507,
-0.0642000288,
-0.2785190642,
0.6080829501,
0.3985908329,
0.6156132817,
0.5245451927,
-0.4028970003,
0.4061126113,
-0.1589317024,
-0.2009202391,
-0.4335514605,
-0.1304904372,
0.2199175209,
0.02856992,
0.3721859157,
0.6434998512,
-0.0768786594,
-0.5554124117,
0.4810973108,
0.4644408524,
-0.7665972114,
-0.2534565926,
0.7748456597,
-0.119156234,
-0.5200952291,
0.4993526638,
0.1247304901,
-0.6281778216,
0.695941925,
0.701174438,
0.9031529427,
0.016270021,
-0.1211578473,
0.1876468658,
0.5902795196,
-0.0881287456,
0.1302211732,
0.052850984,
-0.5870094299,
-0.4928535521,
-0.4983637035,
-0.3975284696,
-0.1065751314,
-0.3878032565,
0.2850450277,
-0.6103460193,
-0.3742897809,
-0.4366216958,
-0.123998642,
-1.0263774395,
0.4100067616,
-0.075448066,
0.6668148041,
-0.544013083,
0.9747155905,
0.6245097518,
-0.2984133065,
-1.0078203678,
-0.0449868105,
-0.327594161,
-0.9371960163,
0.4434186518,
0.0849403366,
0.3045811057,
0.1658744514,
-0.5526427031,
-0.907928586,
0.9842885733,
0.3752794564,
-0.9216367006,
-0.2314217389,
0.4915107787,
0.4330017567,
-0.4773472548,
0.1207453236,
0.2161282301,
0.1215074882,
-0.0213074908,
-0.4581287205,
0.1520426571,
0.0733006001,
0.0504450649,
0.1616893113,
-0.5778883696,
0.6388232112,
0.0689966604,
0.0343408771,
-0.0124349762,
0.9071499705,
0.3913185298,
0.3502868414,
0.3839440942,
0.7608391643,
0.4230055511,
-0.1399388462,
1.4516409636,
-0.1694885492,
0.053103175,
1.2974976301,
0.1956658214,
0.9558166862,
0.7937805057,
-0.1069779992,
0.2490449846,
0.7071108222,
-0.0209340341,
1.0790868998,
0.3683339357,
-0.0364426747,
0.0290828627,
-0.4450304508,
-0.5832899809,
0.3119843006,
0.397605747,
-0.5824799538,
-0.047580488,
0.0267351866,
-0.0245593134,
0.2406471372,
0.1093743891,
0.3123703003,
0.771116972,
-0.6440108418,
0.5752347112,
-0.2366598845,
0.7443464994,
-0.6871529818,
-0.06278909,
-0.1312410682,
0.1994266659,
0.0410098359,
-0.7898161411,
0.5913733244,
-0.3539407849,
0.0429490767,
-0.2338686436,
0.4819126129,
-0.4749134779,
-0.1049689874,
0.2651789486,
0.5622520447,
0.004629299,
-0.1469468027,
-0.6298669577,
-0.0982861221,
-0.0396072976,
-0.2429189533,
0.5925465822,
0.9649759531,
0.1166154519,
0.4298652112,
0.7883095741,
0.4106650352,
0.4329541326,
-0.0900137126,
0.7633952498,
-0.4389639199,
-0.4215013683,
-0.8565273285,
0.3238060176,
0.0484485701,
-0.6246637702,
0.7972684503,
0.4174920321,
1.0730628967,
-0.1787534803,
0.5799845457,
0.3447531164,
0.0192313958,
-0.3803648949,
0.6549646854,
-0.5245890021,
0.0012552958,
-0.1942465454,
-1.2281638384,
-0.3152339458,
0.0986664668,
-0.1917065233,
-0.1204753593,
1.264457345,
0.4055328369,
-0.1210248694,
-0.2617230713,
0.8366852999,
0.0623364896,
-0.0925214961,
0.7129154205,
0.9101521969,
-0.4394263029,
0.9028768539,
-0.2996987402,
0.0846543312,
-0.0263670199,
-0.7657393217,
-0.861564517,
-0.4579818249,
-0.0455578864,
-0.3639583886,
0.1803538501,
0.7874868512,
0.4741305113,
-0.8165335655,
0.0730749741,
-0.4064559937,
0.1743599325,
-0.2987315655,
-0.0969544575,
0.2762421072,
-0.1194484979,
-0.6919418573,
0.1786747128,
0.1065428406,
0.0703376383,
-0.0169753004,
-0.0379347391,
-0.3319496512,
-0.0277929008,
0.3549085557,
0.0660039559,
-0.5378114581,
-0.3908869922,
0.1689864695,
-0.4855796695,
-0.2774064243,
0.6254483461,
-0.4770488739,
0.2052534521,
0.3776658773,
0.9567925334,
0.3960911334,
-0.270208329,
1.0178284645,
-0.8829596639,
0.2999540567,
0.4395077527,
0.3808050454,
0.2248274684,
-0.4362948537,
0.4374002814,
0.4518506527,
-0.205106765,
-0.7065704465,
0.1781083792,
-0.6612198949,
-0.2130687684,
1.0234693289,
-0.2825900912,
-0.5111637115,
0.064271301,
0.021894725,
0.7297420502,
-0.1510934383,
0.5690695643,
0.8213154078,
0.3298464715,
0.3287329078,
-0.70202142,
0.3545071185,
0.9859700799,
-0.1061749309,
-0.8071876764,
0.1033316925,
0.1676238924,
0.1680313349,
0.3335470855,
-0.0887005776,
0.1556604207,
0.1822944731,
-0.1170159355,
-0.0691312402,
-0.1614654511,
-0.1773586422,
0.3658268452,
0.1663001031,
-0.699976027
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.