id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00770v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00770v1
|
Automatic Instruction Evolving for Large Language Models
| 2024-06-02T15:09:00 | 2024-06-02T15:09:00 |
Weihao Zeng, Can Xu, Yingxiu Zhao, Jian-Guang Lou, Weizhu Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Fine-tuning large pre-trained language models with Evol-Instruct has achieved
encouraging results across a wide range of tasks. However, designing effective
evolving methods for instruction evolution requires substantial human
expertise. This paper proposes Auto Evol-Instruct, an end-to-end framework that
evolves instruction datasets using large language models without any human
effort. The framework automatically analyzes and summarizes suitable
evolutionary strategies for the given instruction data and iteratively improves
the evolving method based on issues exposed during the instruction evolution
process. Our extensive experiments demonstrate that the best method optimized
by Auto Evol-Instruct outperforms human-designed methods on various benchmarks,
including MT-Bench, AlpacaEval, GSM8K, and HumanEval.
|
[
-0.3537851274,
-0.7459996343,
0.2088367194,
-0.1584511101,
-0.0659928024,
0.1843962222,
-0.4374324679,
-0.4525537491,
-0.2265745848,
0.4317063689,
-0.7208815217,
-0.4379139841,
-0.5762982965,
0.1426071972,
-0.2808409333,
0.8001469374,
0.0239341222,
-0.0489871539,
-0.2340434641,
0.0772709846,
-0.3934778571,
-0.1014831811,
-0.5329712033,
-0.0657619759,
-0.2128654718,
0.8021974564,
0.5730615258,
1.0032346249,
-0.0193260908,
0.353769511,
0.1429070979,
0.5319343805,
-0.4848818183,
0.1282247603,
-0.4205141366,
-0.1566275805,
-0.2654559314,
-0.2705027759,
0.3469688296,
0.6543043852,
-0.4406626821,
0.4926140606,
0.0057304427,
0.6581985354,
-0.7225160003,
0.0761701986,
-0.4957762361,
-0.042329099,
0.0096741952,
-0.2739199698,
-0.7722519636,
-0.4368291497,
0.32392627,
-0.4572374821,
0.1824576259,
0.2257364243,
0.5483762026,
0.3695835471,
-0.0392473973,
-0.5883539319,
-0.697563827,
0.7845106125,
-0.6116780043,
0.5630233288,
0.1746532172,
0.3941070139,
-0.5802742243,
-0.461039573,
-0.2364192605,
-0.4448190033,
0.3794918358,
0.0288742464,
-0.0297297295,
0.1943757683,
-0.0084839612,
0.2382975817,
-0.6901318431,
0.6281619072,
-0.283967495,
0.2017531991,
0.6129457355,
-0.0054107653,
0.6192514896,
0.3099582791,
0.0374079421,
-0.3800379634,
-0.7016993761,
-0.0546599068,
0.3965227008,
0.0722981915,
-0.0203238875,
0.257741183,
-0.1491666734,
0.9088606238,
0.4238320887,
0.1547885835,
0.2947752178,
0.1930722445,
-0.4217568934,
0.2210893631,
0.6160194278,
-0.0113951275,
0.2859896421,
-0.3819396794,
-0.2455830872,
-0.3102438152,
0.1852918565,
-0.8036236167,
-0.2381770909,
0.0060312669,
-0.2171489745,
-0.1995637417,
-0.0338026099,
-1.1025394201,
-0.2668612003,
-0.4705179036,
0.4417978525,
-0.3691402972,
0.0657835528,
0.4524441063,
0.1116403788,
0.4413053393,
0.2651695311,
-1.4584387541,
0.293700248,
0.5653069615,
0.3973760009,
0.1240134984,
-0.2929652631,
-0.6793461442,
0.1885201186,
-0.4673232436,
0.8732696176,
-0.8423489332,
-0.5192482471,
-0.0801158473,
0.2346996814,
-0.1347556859,
-0.6231987476,
0.2939363718,
-0.4037623703,
0.7345054746,
0.1040824726,
-0.8602789044,
-0.1669290811,
-0.2481877208,
-0.3530171812,
0.9090636373,
0.4625878632,
-0.0737515092,
0.2500629425,
-1.2418450117,
-0.5266504288,
0.2314358354,
-0.1572052687,
-0.4171006978,
0.1772934794,
0.6098943353,
0.3698805571,
-0.5684788227,
0.1858902425,
-0.1793891788,
-0.2269502729,
-0.1913584322,
-0.3475799561,
0.977255106,
0.0776443332,
-0.8560813069,
0.0198798981,
-0.7574182153,
0.0928545222,
0.1331311017,
-0.0731573701,
-0.2004261613,
0.0817387402,
-0.5114123821,
0.0972815156,
0.2876944542,
-0.4158062935,
0.7015602589,
-0.607650578,
0.4549418986,
0.9737192392,
0.1755892336,
0.8689357638,
-0.1415893435,
0.651558876,
-0.4880678952,
0.6780599356,
-0.282792598,
-0.3331750035,
-0.8510398865,
0.1502521038,
0.066867277,
0.5840244293,
-0.5069529414,
0.6805062294,
-0.2262888402,
-0.4451949,
-0.7206359506,
0.4010305703,
0.3430000842,
0.284882009,
0.5719736218,
-0.0803685337,
-0.2682053149,
-0.8459976912,
0.0453070663,
0.0635670349,
0.0975354165,
0.0795473605,
0.2835536599,
-0.5256556273,
0.6032320857,
-0.4211593866,
0.3920989037,
0.0064024152,
0.5392830968,
-0.17156367,
0.5419842601,
0.7927771211,
-0.197832644,
-0.5588068962,
0.285987258,
-0.6485002041,
-0.371648103,
-0.3051966727,
-0.4677348733,
0.1258533001,
0.4627214074,
-0.3449493051,
0.1275689304,
0.3881016374,
-0.0839265585,
0.3112224042,
-0.5338144302,
0.1573891342,
-0.9342404008,
-0.2913419008,
-0.2173939794,
0.1171122119,
-0.6050565243,
0.0351909362,
0.1792894304,
-0.1613391191,
0.0436805673,
0.5745316148,
-0.7952105403,
-0.1369636208,
-0.2152656913,
-0.1964763552,
-0.027754955,
0.3232854605,
-0.1192751452,
0.6892976761,
0.6706756949,
-0.6665983796,
0.3562657833,
0.274217695,
-0.3758579791,
0.1463704109,
-0.3258067667,
0.6050630212,
-0.3185422421,
-0.0303282309,
-0.5424727201,
-0.2967116237,
0.2042510509,
-0.2919153571,
0.7524481416,
-0.3195005953,
-0.5113448501,
-0.3825853169,
-0.1302285492,
-0.1703778952,
0.7947093248,
-1.0688552856,
0.5447163582,
0.0510992408,
-0.1936347485,
-0.5959821939,
-0.1935184002,
0.1729026586,
-0.1620413363,
-0.5418453813,
0.1479936838,
-0.3336967528,
-0.1348969936,
-0.1910343617,
0.0593231805,
-0.0770117342,
-0.0060734632,
-0.0131321009,
0.2410073578,
-0.3116590977,
0.2820097804,
0.6488569975,
-0.0751975626,
-0.0402070731,
-0.6881241202,
0.4604717791,
0.1065345556,
-0.5145331025,
-0.6925897002,
0.2569521964,
0.9254620075,
-0.5433384776,
0.4799177051,
0.3402684033,
-0.0336203314,
-0.8215724826,
-0.5875809789,
-0.1682476252,
-0.5781458616,
0.5635007024,
-0.0227034856,
-0.5682554245,
0.0851463154,
-0.3800074756,
0.68665272,
0.1138690561,
0.2982694805,
-0.0623698905,
1.1992053986,
0.7641995549,
-0.0021880844,
0.6882327199,
-0.2390281707,
-0.0084872069,
-0.4871171117,
-0.2671299875,
-0.3992624879,
-0.1640089303,
-0.2978445292,
-0.2774816155,
0.0231501665,
0.0233767107,
-0.5210047364,
0.5042048693,
-1.0354470015,
0.5808154345,
0.1864937246,
0.0773463547,
-0.1336363554,
0.1067250445,
0.42472893,
0.2378933877,
-0.8191838861,
-0.2625205815,
1.2318967581,
0.2341644764,
0.8566683531,
0.0838222951,
1.0150139332,
0.3941603005,
0.4629995823,
-0.5815743804,
0.315862745,
-0.3560317159,
-0.1798557192,
-0.430883348,
-0.2935398221,
-0.8392732143,
-0.1590134352,
-0.0423049256,
-0.7752918601,
0.4824211299,
0.3071755469,
-0.4721086621,
0.020316219,
-1.1095032692,
0.8958312869,
-0.8407532573,
-0.2189258188,
-0.2112336308,
-0.4809738398,
0.2385158241,
-0.209074825,
0.4038586617,
0.1321883798,
-0.0391745865,
0.7999019027,
-0.4759247303,
0.6434672475,
-0.4162115157,
-0.2515929937,
0.3778058887,
0.1151972115,
0.7222936749,
-0.3467148542,
-0.170393616,
-0.4940790534,
-0.3845700622,
-0.3995791078,
-1.0733155012,
0.4126623571,
-0.791970253,
-0.5400832295,
0.1918472648,
-0.2640108466,
-0.2716723979,
0.0390153416,
0.3100140989,
0.8007543087,
-0.0607885048,
0.1255254745,
0.9041311145,
-0.5390604138,
0.5460138917,
0.5430479646,
0.0412779115,
-0.3994287252,
0.8956031799,
-0.0317961685,
0.5928525925,
0.3014779389,
0.5950040817,
-0.3230626881,
-0.6841595173,
-1.0153548717,
-0.0277938843,
-0.7724552751,
-0.1889037192,
-0.4532703757,
0.073355414,
-0.3496769965,
-0.5943228602,
-0.5823232532,
-0.108623147,
-0.3917528391,
0.0019692432,
0.5780186653,
0.8508726358,
0.0505746007,
0.4630597532,
-0.9407595396,
0.0554778054,
0.4401490986,
0.1593487263,
0.0777437165,
-1.1104488373,
-0.3787579238,
0.2117719203,
0.0211547986,
-0.7744880915,
0.4149845243,
0.7238706946,
0.7063723207,
0.6812696457,
0.146570608,
0.9130389094,
-0.6373966336,
0.465136677,
0.0501966886,
-1.072388649,
0.5891926289,
-0.1338664889,
0.4367873073,
0.6896862388,
0.3165306151,
-0.1795617342,
-0.0778279081,
-0.4354386926,
-0.7716659307,
0.6538875103,
-0.2952643633,
0.3350485265,
0.0976741612,
0.5830551386,
0.4659360647,
-0.1928371489,
-0.303081125,
0.129934594,
-0.2799183428,
-0.4322817624,
0.1982354224,
0.070440501,
0.1521911919,
-0.6313802004,
0.6064382195,
-0.1146782637,
0.2205994725,
-0.3061999381,
-0.4787588418,
-0.3188931644,
0.3882414699,
0.6641850471,
0.8533836007,
-0.0174623709,
-0.3000115454,
0.4726218581,
-0.3943429887,
0.3104643524,
0.0070944047,
-0.0021738985,
-0.3427446485,
0.4467763901,
0.7801511884,
0.6162170768,
-0.8310981989,
0.3293164074,
-0.0207982492,
-0.2049055696,
-0.3318231404,
0.5037983656,
-0.002682541,
0.2341804057,
0.2650411427,
-0.2364489138,
-0.0035294266,
-0.5020421147,
0.3338749409,
0.056369815,
-0.1057559177,
-0.3152347803,
0.3636640906,
0.3196359277,
-0.4344443679,
0.8078132868,
-0.5595753789,
-0.3851949871,
0.6213160753,
0.6017095447,
1.1957168579,
-0.7167832851,
0.2510883808,
0.2306305915,
0.3403768539,
-0.2523823678,
-0.0079383105,
-0.1531327963,
-0.3572161198,
-0.6097716689,
-0.6736827493,
-0.3987678587,
0.142821759,
-0.5510827303,
0.4452002048,
-0.4872003496,
0.5199056268,
0.0885924697,
-0.3915051222,
-0.4853657186,
0.1248534918,
0.1865998656,
0.7744194269,
-0.7225350738,
0.8817692399,
0.658510685,
-0.047292836,
-0.4462407827,
-0.1321824938,
-0.0572861768,
-0.6985696554,
0.7758003473,
0.0813498721,
-0.3764272928,
0.4113926589,
-0.9237612486,
-0.7725065351,
1.0069061518,
0.363048315,
-0.8052656651,
-0.1632780135,
-0.0410552695,
0.5245112181,
-0.6228345037,
0.2694359422,
0.3972550929,
0.3243746161,
0.0198399704,
-0.6343899965,
-0.303940326,
-0.1686759144,
-0.2940185964,
0.2941555679,
-0.4455842674,
0.5585736632,
-0.2877631783,
-0.3278880715,
-0.0724274293,
0.6822149754,
-0.5141195059,
-0.1762890667,
0.5231731534,
0.5049241781,
0.6970584989,
0.3390235603,
0.6450304985,
-0.4861739278,
0.2530587316,
1.27865839,
-0.1187739596,
0.643928647,
-0.1611735374,
0.0030262214,
0.5212116241,
0.7245872617,
-0.2963891923,
0.3442551792,
0.3106043637,
-0.2794415951,
-0.2180448025,
0.3299390078,
-0.1334346831,
0.8032104373,
0.5680728555,
-0.350138694,
-0.4572868943,
0.1350338012,
-0.0530310869,
0.0297022089,
-0.1856056303,
0.8944652677,
-0.2977457643,
-0.6501466632,
0.8437799811,
-0.0536572672,
0.4438445866,
-0.5141522288,
-0.2770941854,
-0.12979348,
-0.0669401735,
-0.1631104499,
-0.3599249423,
-0.0658826977,
0.1575781703,
0.0600597598,
-0.2978541553,
0.3314011991,
-0.3421700895,
-0.1621143371,
0.3155156076,
0.2895797789,
0.0517355651,
0.3560827374,
-0.7532327175,
-0.1451334506,
0.1197032332,
-0.3056798577,
0.4013866484,
0.3798936307,
-0.0642498508,
0.8204573989,
0.5601370931,
-0.3279174864,
0.2992348075,
0.1050985679,
0.7448960543,
-0.3768986166,
-0.3173306286,
-0.8692345619,
0.4555785656,
-0.2734557092,
-0.4123360515,
0.3428005874,
0.4254426658,
0.774998188,
-0.1134953275,
0.861564219,
-0.0703475997,
0.0998343527,
-0.4580537677,
0.7548298836,
-0.3103875816,
0.1834417731,
-0.0761903003,
-1.0498661995,
0.0489671119,
0.6112220287,
-0.3589267731,
0.0981778279,
0.5084243417,
0.8031480908,
-0.1926728636,
0.1965692937,
0.1209648475,
0.0054707597,
0.2937275469,
0.5554421544,
0.8355215192,
0.0234109107,
0.2821938396,
-0.3418292999,
-0.7650290132,
-0.2100392878,
-0.6380818486,
-1.0496425629,
-0.4287516773,
-0.4002784193,
0.1359719485,
0.46205163,
1.4859673977,
0.7715165615,
-0.7544332147,
-0.2414255142,
-0.2768542767,
-0.4267183542,
-0.1661487967,
-0.193847999,
0.6017797589,
-0.6708372831,
-0.8600043654,
0.8499730229,
0.41792202,
0.1476693153,
-0.3373434246,
-0.1447847337,
0.0115313986,
-0.0542822182,
0.6445736289,
0.787581563,
-0.3867300451,
-0.5077703595,
0.2789314091,
0.1739760339,
-0.0166721661,
0.5895207524,
-0.4335193336,
0.9104569554,
0.299359858,
1.1394768953,
0.2927018702,
-0.1019123346,
0.8130122423,
-0.3955686688,
-0.1361096054,
0.200557977,
0.1271331012,
0.2024213523,
-0.4847964942,
0.2791486382,
-0.0068205795,
-0.7508622408,
-0.6203770638,
0.232459709,
-0.507781446,
-0.2916237712,
0.8261371255,
0.0461245254,
-0.3415576816,
-0.2422586828,
-0.0484950021,
0.3246440887,
-0.4454057813,
1.117713213,
0.428406775,
-0.5740553141,
-0.5315380096,
-0.9502215981,
0.4913821518,
0.1674474627,
-1.2347915173,
0.3458622098,
0.323241502,
0.1626895815,
-0.1574827135,
-0.1496141106,
0.0846338123,
0.4475173354,
0.0401928574,
0.2827854455,
-0.326602906,
-0.3554106057,
-0.3139220476,
-0.1843142509,
0.1132268384,
-0.1750798821
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00765v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00765v1
|
The Embodied World Model Based on LLM with Visual Information and Prediction-Oriented Prompts
| 2024-06-02T14:50:01 | 2024-06-02T14:50:01 |
Wakana Haijima, Kou Nakakubo, Masahiro Suzuki, Yutaka Matsuo
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In recent years, as machine learning, particularly for vision and language
understanding, has been improved, research in embedded AI has also evolved.
VOYAGER is a well-known LLM-based embodied AI that enables autonomous
exploration in the Minecraft world, but it has issues such as underutilization
of visual data and insufficient functionality as a world model. In this
research, the possibility of utilizing visual data and the function of LLM as a
world model were investigated with the aim of improving the performance of
embodied AI. The experimental results revealed that LLM can extract necessary
information from visual data, and the utilization of the information improves
its performance as a world model. It was also suggested that devised prompts
could bring out the LLM's function as a world model.
|
[
-0.4208475053,
-1.2128095627,
0.9768314958,
0.121596761,
-0.3785318732,
-0.1294755638,
0.0832360312,
-0.6576533914,
0.2210567892,
0.3934572339,
-0.8357743025,
-0.4010986984,
-0.5159791112,
0.0367006995,
-0.2350512445,
-0.0383589379,
0.336619556,
-0.036487598,
-0.6932111979,
0.0011929887,
-0.8711932302,
-0.2228187621,
-0.4131848514,
-0.2775714397,
0.6025611162,
0.4557334483,
0.6705110669,
0.5837516189,
0.4012634754,
0.4345988035,
-0.0888536349,
0.5818949342,
-0.4720609784,
0.3792654574,
0.0412850417,
-0.6428442001,
-0.4570750296,
0.0118441125,
0.7319968939,
0.2323544472,
0.3088945746,
0.2369645238,
0.2379283309,
0.3035009205,
-0.2134975791,
0.5308226943,
-0.2454728633,
0.3123257458,
0.296620518,
-0.296951592,
-0.4257746339,
-0.0581498891,
0.2484800518,
-1.0216186047,
-0.08963231,
0.4827510715,
0.2829121053,
0.546289444,
-0.4736846387,
-0.0180170648,
-0.5824728608,
0.8120341301,
-0.4350481927,
0.5523828268,
-0.1877942979,
0.239045307,
-0.4367930293,
-0.5497084856,
-0.7232111096,
-0.3657382727,
0.0242704377,
0.42361781,
-0.1388328522,
-0.1311062425,
0.1812224686,
-0.0961554497,
-0.4942329228,
0.4962612092,
-0.3387187421,
0.103719458,
0.7546321154,
0.6338835955,
0.5418806076,
-0.3723774254,
-0.4222258627,
-0.2075873613,
-0.8694559336,
0.159732312,
0.0557815582,
0.4247796237,
-0.3356138766,
0.7439291477,
-0.1363799423,
0.7739688158,
-0.0355101414,
-0.0283070542,
-0.037323989,
0.5146932602,
-0.308593899,
-0.0034763117,
0.4526091218,
0.6665371656,
-0.093255952,
-0.2477470338,
-0.0027276312,
-0.1562529951,
0.4936620593,
-0.6572113037,
0.2548517883,
0.50579983,
-0.7370175719,
-0.3399510384,
0.1743718237,
-0.4933587313,
-0.7670695782,
-0.6163068414,
0.2457129806,
-0.3271219432,
-0.2961136103,
-0.154662624,
-0.3879710436,
0.5046887994,
0.8888726234,
-0.5395664573,
0.0117800087,
0.9337077737,
0.9621422291,
-0.5546298027,
-0.1685952693,
-0.3900887072,
0.0723024905,
-0.1432874352,
0.795522809,
-0.4989773631,
-0.9850260019,
-0.1008501202,
0.2302615643,
0.1633972973,
-0.3503459096,
0.1792665571,
-0.40263322,
0.0148138078,
-0.2906063795,
-0.570998013,
-0.701552093,
0.4915117025,
-0.7752283216,
0.9235959649,
-0.2754043043,
-0.6468758583,
0.3778463304,
-0.6138284206,
0.0173589867,
0.5128993392,
-0.1482079774,
-0.2476367354,
0.4171584845,
0.3306637704,
0.7267864347,
-0.2199770957,
0.24782525,
-0.4235685468,
-0.9969803691,
0.3951528072,
-0.3507719338,
0.5251268744,
0.0638358146,
-0.3000918627,
0.0423489884,
-0.7065517902,
0.2099078447,
0.0401469283,
-0.2601511776,
-0.2982977331,
0.3720451891,
-0.1235872731,
-0.1506577581,
0.1684478074,
-0.6280935407,
0.4724844396,
-0.2536138594,
-0.040190652,
0.9891019464,
0.095676221,
0.3685623705,
-0.3427946568,
0.5477607846,
-0.1657515019,
0.0940687358,
-0.1743557602,
-0.7951594591,
-1.0136035681,
-0.3255156279,
-0.1326800287,
0.6455931664,
-0.6556328535,
0.3006392121,
-0.2429519892,
-0.5690723658,
-0.3313243687,
-0.4044270515,
0.1201948375,
0.4228818119,
0.3849545121,
0.0191821307,
-0.6332057714,
-0.7109966874,
-0.0673847944,
-0.4706089199,
0.0594806895,
0.9015341401,
0.3656871319,
-0.5518106222,
0.8456789851,
-0.2285913229,
0.1860834509,
-0.4400289953,
-0.1178928241,
0.4932773113,
0.6738294959,
0.0510939546,
-0.8112130761,
-0.3336571753,
0.0716199949,
-1.3865283728,
0.1360445619,
-0.1130485311,
-0.329452306,
-0.3499158323,
0.2888486087,
-0.4992331862,
0.7108172774,
0.4326178133,
-0.4842456579,
0.3537697792,
-0.37672773,
0.3307695687,
-0.7114133239,
-0.121073924,
-0.1712786257,
-0.3153371513,
-0.3456121981,
0.4272164106,
0.1655635238,
-0.1815690994,
-0.6046571732,
0.9521533847,
-0.6153540015,
-0.0520358123,
-0.4861988127,
0.2482178062,
-0.2987003326,
0.33394593,
0.2991176546,
0.6602137685,
0.8541628718,
-1.0983513594,
0.813321352,
0.4783982337,
-0.0779147148,
0.5650160909,
-0.845341146,
0.189189896,
-0.4390484989,
-0.1189065799,
-0.7719239593,
-0.1174765825,
-0.027460156,
-0.3472351432,
0.3256220222,
-0.2629732788,
-0.3263737857,
-0.398986429,
-0.0621793047,
-0.0250427686,
0.8405327797,
-0.9216913581,
1.0720396042,
0.2775703073,
-0.0327069983,
-0.1987995505,
-0.7333841324,
-0.0078231571,
-0.5469476581,
-0.8638066053,
0.3765901029,
0.0010927619,
-0.437135458,
-0.2154511958,
0.312510103,
0.5523947477,
0.3262750804,
1.0812654495,
0.6732169986,
-0.1234980971,
0.1460233331,
-0.1057179272,
-0.3019322157,
0.1320439875,
-0.4594276249,
0.2603510022,
-0.2528612018,
-0.5777134299,
-0.4746662676,
0.0546939895,
0.2742674947,
0.1988999546,
0.5478118062,
0.2206834853,
0.0094658472,
-0.2591400743,
-0.4864162505,
-0.0852949694,
-0.5526555181,
0.2560617626,
-0.2474932075,
-0.7630953789,
0.4827677011,
-0.3049244881,
0.0359237827,
0.3294849098,
0.4718593061,
-0.4408968985,
0.8478735685,
0.8713288307,
0.1469018459,
0.5772214532,
-0.4908413887,
-0.4399395585,
-1.1199074984,
-0.6757187843,
-0.0744630918,
-0.6016156077,
-0.7231376767,
-0.7144634724,
0.7884936929,
-0.2980654836,
-0.3069577515,
0.0702778399,
-0.5117939115,
0.1786102504,
0.9014537334,
0.4937097728,
0.1663881689,
-0.0725973025,
-0.3460530937,
-0.1182253808,
-0.5200437903,
-0.7529408932,
1.0311596394,
0.1839355528,
1.2308051586,
0.1443600804,
0.5617818832,
0.5913048983,
0.0536522605,
-0.5981722474,
0.6858728528,
0.3257851899,
-0.2483069748,
-0.2739191651,
-0.0415025093,
-0.9250808358,
0.6072098613,
-0.4477427006,
-0.8853340745,
0.1779788733,
0.3242154121,
-0.1290804744,
0.1029083952,
-0.5408090949,
0.4471500516,
-0.3791457117,
-0.7232142687,
-0.1462282985,
-0.4006745517,
0.2141545862,
0.3562167585,
-0.0422544107,
0.0367195569,
0.0443606004,
0.4515402615,
-0.2206237912,
0.9927199483,
-0.4931612015,
0.0851073861,
0.5164009333,
0.2066796869,
0.7554745674,
0.380887419,
-0.1152754575,
-0.0154756466,
-0.5358535051,
-0.0854615197,
-0.653666079,
0.7508360744,
-0.7465007305,
-0.8590847254,
-0.2968401313,
-0.2473990619,
-0.2491326332,
-0.0006945905,
-0.0609495789,
0.3749911487,
-0.7489879131,
0.1889075637,
0.8044775724,
-0.5472114086,
0.585105896,
0.587908268,
-0.3329096138,
-0.1251518875,
0.6827083826,
-0.3200862408,
-0.1675217897,
0.5403463244,
0.1956946701,
-0.3607799411,
-0.3168666363,
-0.7967450023,
-0.0573986545,
-0.5873132348,
-0.0370508991,
-0.7194769382,
-0.0070819398,
0.058982607,
-0.2148320675,
-0.1091224104,
-0.453191638,
-0.5465554595,
-0.3967413604,
0.3600279093,
0.9261496067,
0.1154388115,
0.3180615604,
-0.7996535301,
0.1591956466,
0.4289963543,
-0.0658232421,
0.1880338788,
-0.4931900501,
-0.1569392979,
0.0954761058,
-0.2362192422,
-0.4991813302,
0.4374062717,
-0.1710000634,
0.8808397651,
0.2234143615,
-0.3566867113,
1.0223126411,
-0.477184236,
1.0122909546,
-0.0118769715,
-0.7051446438,
0.52720052,
-0.2678812742,
0.3956982791,
-0.187967509,
-0.0164795909,
-0.7304170728,
-0.5016695857,
-0.6403656006,
-0.3794475794,
0.528554976,
0.010805524,
0.1917567104,
0.2995043993,
0.3113466799,
0.2995603085,
-0.0221696589,
-0.7220953107,
-0.1244856119,
-0.1527017653,
-0.000122984,
0.0227756649,
-0.1545528173,
0.3204874098,
-0.1874216795,
0.7325652838,
-0.3364402354,
0.7021452785,
0.3443436921,
-0.338781327,
0.1160437539,
-0.1584663987,
0.1351334453,
0.2419942319,
0.0769467726,
0.1787462384,
0.2935108244,
-0.3422727585,
0.0834152997,
-0.1196960807,
-0.4384756684,
-0.3460312188,
0.7392439246,
0.80462116,
-0.0041175797,
-0.9458475113,
0.3501823843,
-0.1106763631,
0.1895627528,
-0.5609354973,
0.5946692824,
0.1511295587,
0.8011929989,
0.2392504513,
-0.0615266301,
0.270560056,
-0.4288176596,
-0.0754935741,
0.6831098795,
-0.5555904508,
-0.2680422068,
1.0367125273,
0.2006591856,
-0.1174942404,
1.0104097128,
0.1985118687,
-0.3649269938,
0.9174007177,
0.6246986985,
0.6788791418,
0.0787457228,
0.0964675993,
0.3997034431,
0.2258106321,
0.2121898383,
0.6780790687,
-0.0834498554,
-0.5786634684,
-0.1290334761,
-0.3146319687,
-0.3865866363,
-0.5062088966,
-0.2595712841,
0.44955042,
-0.4516974688,
-0.0280880406,
-0.5522297621,
-0.125464052,
-1.0786622763,
0.4390183389,
0.4305054247,
0.8074247241,
-0.4072165191,
0.3616021574,
0.4583647549,
-0.2689409554,
-0.4549238086,
-0.4209141731,
0.1643630713,
-1.2475024462,
0.9288105965,
0.357932955,
-0.1031021625,
-0.0618300475,
-0.9538702965,
-1.0781235695,
1.4119573832,
-0.0042865216,
-0.4456955492,
0.1432994306,
-0.1215743721,
0.3396579623,
-0.5182273984,
0.497264713,
-0.0499663278,
0.7294850349,
0.1016273424,
-0.4789735973,
0.1195518523,
-0.4020592868,
0.3213020265,
-0.2076068223,
-0.8309751153,
0.8554760814,
-0.5466342568,
-0.1611699611,
0.2625876963,
0.9272740483,
0.3975468576,
0.1614766866,
0.3416799307,
0.2880592048,
0.8475326896,
-0.0983400941,
1.1606464386,
0.1102672219,
0.0841615275,
0.6453516483,
-0.1107850894,
0.6044989824,
0.3529152274,
-0.0606724694,
0.5600730181,
0.6044965386,
-0.2673827112,
0.6251416802,
0.1293575019,
-0.0784732476,
-0.3100077808,
0.1040045545,
-0.1230772361,
0.5648246408,
0.5003237724,
-0.3576976955,
0.3185947239,
0.269205451,
-0.4519486129,
-0.3407853544,
-0.3109724224,
1.025818944,
-0.1193150431,
-0.6570182443,
0.2941274941,
0.119574368,
0.4895216227,
-0.3226866126,
-0.5280123949,
-0.2111157477,
-0.1952099055,
-0.1604238898,
-0.4330300689,
-0.1506996751,
-0.0574130565,
0.0715833381,
-0.2230419964,
0.9098484516,
0.0138032446,
-0.627512157,
0.1061209962,
0.8114370704,
0.3365876377,
-0.0737474337,
-0.3772139251,
0.1747310609,
0.1217045188,
-0.1559430659,
-0.2290487587,
0.4852894247,
-0.0437598936,
1.1224364042,
0.6884220839,
-0.1285150647,
0.379229784,
-0.3420253098,
0.8622638583,
-1.1961026192,
-0.8449726701,
-0.8838998675,
0.8997326493,
-0.2996655405,
0.0271024127,
0.9482004046,
0.5967382789,
0.1754148453,
-0.2710546255,
0.9529893398,
-0.1755301803,
0.4298092127,
-0.8136829734,
0.3431261778,
-0.5885535479,
0.1927684695,
-0.1769619882,
-0.9296343327,
-0.1512773633,
0.6159768701,
0.0185665786,
0.0228991788,
0.4318824708,
0.5858809352,
-0.2895287871,
0.3478696942,
0.5503267646,
0.1615067571,
0.4669423997,
0.1535792202,
1.2270003557,
-0.1578827947,
-0.2478868365,
-0.0326207317,
-0.2065093666,
-0.5040546656,
-0.8674180508,
-1.0099502802,
-0.3801653981,
-0.0998067483,
-0.1033730283,
0.0712783262,
0.7234896421,
0.9481905699,
-0.2432528585,
0.0054693664,
-0.1131080464,
0.1526435018,
-0.2508842945,
-0.1565108597,
0.2508257926,
0.0601749755,
-0.9254546165,
0.931769073,
0.4016623497,
0.4127495289,
-0.5605553985,
-0.3112907112,
0.3188044429,
-0.1551036239,
0.62255615,
0.0060451115,
-0.7666460276,
-0.4183638096,
0.1823142916,
0.1673089862,
-0.0100068757,
0.7448557615,
-1.2300130129,
0.7351475358,
0.1797804236,
0.4293299913,
0.8570596576,
0.2967649996,
0.7228030562,
-0.592171669,
0.5550768375,
0.0959351733,
0.5805868506,
0.3075017929,
-0.8547574878,
0.5393401384,
0.1190185547,
-0.3863239586,
-0.1907768399,
0.0152369924,
-1.0826463699,
-0.1145185381,
1.0827234983,
-0.0782997906,
-0.5507518053,
0.0862518176,
-0.4402023852,
-0.0131681077,
-0.3339852691,
0.5895889997,
0.2957015336,
-0.487804383,
-0.1756985337,
-0.4723161459,
-0.1461976171,
-0.0913533866,
-0.8408703208,
-0.2024274617,
0.824554801,
-0.000980165,
-0.0707061067,
0.2758263052,
0.0808224455,
0.1589690596,
0.2728124261,
0.0516649522,
-0.5271371603,
-0.2466219664,
0.0187076945,
-0.0441663787,
0.0329619683,
-0.2662150562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06561v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06561v1
|
Brainstorming Brings Power to Large Language Models of Knowledge Reasoning
| 2024-06-02T14:47:14 | 2024-06-02T14:47:14 |
Zining Qin, Chenhao Wang, Huiling Qin, Weijia Jia
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated amazing capabilities in
language generation, text comprehension, and knowledge reasoning. While a
single powerful model can already handle multiple tasks, relying on a single
perspective can lead to biased and unstable results. Recent studies have
further improved the model's reasoning ability on a wide range of tasks by
introducing multi-model collaboration. However, models with different
capabilities may produce conflicting answers on the same problem, and how to
reasonably obtain the correct answer from multiple candidate models has become
a challenging problem. In this paper, we propose the multi-model brainstorming
based on prompt. It incorporates different models into a group for
brainstorming, and after multiple rounds of reasoning elaboration and
re-inference, a consensus answer is reached within the group. We conducted
experiments on three different types of datasets, and demonstrate that the
brainstorming can significantly improve the effectiveness in logical reasoning
and fact extraction. Furthermore, we find that two small-parameter models can
achieve accuracy approximating that of larger-parameter models through
brainstorming, which provides a new solution for distributed deployment of
LLMs.
|
[
-0.4746210575,
-0.7368701696,
1.1451796293,
0.3405325711,
-0.1339018792,
0.0023338245,
-0.3884268105,
-0.0921445787,
0.0541648939,
0.309668839,
-0.6906837821,
-0.2873538733,
-0.6170390248,
0.102872923,
-0.1521669179,
0.6059975624,
-0.0478552692,
0.0666481107,
-0.5187482238,
-0.0173256043,
-0.939453423,
-0.4246005118,
-0.4211762846,
-0.3648180366,
0.692311883,
0.6654338837,
0.5760478973,
0.3774560988,
0.3952762485,
0.4671505094,
-0.1015489846,
0.4335635602,
0.0980295017,
0.596529901,
-0.3485091925,
-0.6182509065,
-0.2926849723,
0.1818721592,
0.4702190459,
0.6115800738,
-0.4701272845,
-0.1934237629,
-0.0182583984,
0.2206096798,
-0.3630712032,
0.2302510142,
-1.0159544945,
-0.2062238753,
0.1392103434,
-0.0276763253,
-0.3515969217,
-0.2559357882,
0.4177426994,
-0.6945108771,
-0.0451682247,
0.3473114669,
0.5919064283,
0.3208475113,
0.0154431891,
-0.2660841942,
-0.3927047849,
1.0778001547,
-0.9848092198,
0.2081825286,
-0.0658092126,
0.333892256,
-0.2725394666,
-0.6662653089,
-0.8954524994,
0.1093425378,
0.1893447191,
0.0005074894,
-0.0424383804,
-0.0483908132,
0.3657926321,
-0.3947964609,
-0.2161432654,
0.1908582151,
-0.2320994884,
0.0591174439,
0.681047976,
0.2349701226,
0.1051635742,
-0.2414005995,
-0.2976846695,
0.0413581431,
-0.3282703161,
-0.4151902795,
-0.2076969594,
0.4884261191,
0.0737457052,
0.603813231,
-0.4389375746,
0.9182135463,
0.0914975032,
-0.3614060879,
0.0129438564,
-0.6535308957,
-0.2241755724,
-0.2147216052,
0.7633016706,
0.5838453174,
0.2154423594,
-0.0935118496,
-0.0189203806,
-0.2583466768,
-0.1025065482,
-0.8284264207,
-0.0593163297,
0.4035185874,
-0.3849194348,
-0.1183430329,
-0.2621060312,
-0.7395746708,
-0.713642478,
-0.5583486557,
0.32888785,
-0.2928250134,
-0.3029210269,
0.2314172387,
-0.5772826672,
-0.0686915442,
0.7603857517,
-0.8385924101,
-0.1831893176,
0.6717341542,
0.8042913675,
-0.2641551197,
-0.5015817881,
-0.084963426,
0.1317746937,
-0.3120228946,
0.9258078337,
-0.2624894679,
-0.0656652525,
-0.5021921396,
-0.4173410833,
-0.1620177627,
-0.5503958464,
0.1783706844,
-0.3889380693,
0.242549628,
-0.6216779947,
-0.7271986008,
-0.1849368215,
0.4612292647,
-0.4596740603,
0.3314906359,
-0.4364639223,
-0.8135210276,
0.4948443174,
-0.5374100804,
0.0323027931,
0.3976008296,
-0.7749248147,
-0.1672438979,
0.0271252412,
0.5600225925,
0.8121367693,
-0.6170250773,
0.707390964,
-0.3464388549,
0.0047329608,
0.416565448,
-0.2734547257,
0.784655571,
0.1595808268,
-0.1022717282,
0.6141019464,
-0.4373167157,
0.4111374319,
0.3705660701,
-0.1555115134,
-0.1524005532,
-0.1086762622,
-0.2950018346,
0.4933716953,
0.1484307498,
-0.4335793257,
0.4074481726,
-0.1280202866,
0.5977938771,
0.6911959648,
0.227343604,
0.3719381094,
-0.7182177901,
0.3684095442,
0.0919680595,
-0.0681744739,
-0.1831447333,
-0.9508273602,
-0.4102056623,
-0.3805646598,
-0.07757321,
0.4496881664,
-0.7359896302,
0.2426072657,
-0.1647857726,
-0.7314496636,
-0.4556513131,
0.0833847001,
0.063172251,
0.4827527106,
0.2562242746,
0.3113526106,
-0.6103749871,
-0.8832797408,
-0.1779064387,
-0.1426585317,
0.1405633241,
0.2661183178,
0.5767354965,
0.1616434455,
1.2044496536,
-0.5860567093,
0.0911463797,
-0.863072753,
0.2460735738,
0.3906773925,
0.3685937226,
0.1475803852,
-0.766916573,
-0.3166229129,
-0.3045640588,
-0.9148590565,
0.0251054559,
-0.0969520509,
-0.0423864871,
0.0740800127,
0.3494635522,
-1.0881595612,
0.0552567281,
0.4104628861,
-0.016038008,
0.8308131695,
-0.0576046892,
0.2002500445,
-1.3497103453,
-0.2362581342,
-0.2892110646,
0.2958038151,
-0.4400907457,
0.2167116404,
-0.1107876599,
-0.2775864899,
-0.467453748,
0.5297250748,
-0.3273406029,
0.1674515754,
-0.4004038274,
0.5514742732,
0.2161135226,
0.4301529229,
0.2094869614,
0.7575995922,
0.6313510537,
-0.6062657833,
0.7938323617,
0.3423577845,
-0.6177874207,
0.5498793721,
-0.7493249178,
0.2245433033,
-0.2903957665,
0.4311730266,
-0.8061315417,
-0.3160325587,
-0.0778448433,
-0.1011684537,
-0.401191175,
-0.0091673434,
-0.5903837681,
-0.3998784125,
0.0847187787,
0.1928590238,
0.2107466608,
-0.4472509325,
0.6810733676,
0.4365307093,
-0.5259117484,
-0.4474784732,
-0.4576542377,
0.1481110305,
-0.3172311783,
-0.8695892096,
0.3871053457,
-0.3418782055,
-0.5942682624,
-0.1551302075,
-0.0241436623,
-0.1555328369,
-0.0850673318,
0.2227114886,
0.2239423841,
0.1067884415,
0.3569007814,
-0.1537947357,
0.1120940074,
0.0802144706,
-0.4370137155,
0.456748575,
-0.0957392156,
-0.4120484293,
-0.3275250494,
0.5248680711,
0.5996157527,
-0.3407634795,
0.8318933249,
0.2235025615,
-0.4459032416,
-0.3903901875,
-0.8177992105,
-0.5389149189,
-0.4909321368,
0.5229934454,
-0.4210789204,
-0.7128950953,
0.4536964893,
-0.2380630672,
0.5358368158,
0.0255933274,
0.7795488834,
0.0315754823,
1.0953255892,
0.5278475881,
0.2403292805,
0.1734500825,
-0.0536197349,
0.1604826152,
-0.4169427752,
-0.6017278433,
-0.5370697975,
-0.0954546258,
0.0438715555,
-0.5736500025,
0.3451242447,
0.0802349746,
0.1227988452,
0.0485307388,
-0.4975176454,
0.460748136,
0.5971868634,
0.0808498934,
0.2944665253,
0.0305048805,
-0.5457298756,
-0.2035731375,
-1.0787593126,
-0.2588668764,
0.848089397,
-0.0302902181,
0.613891542,
-0.0510207266,
0.781529665,
-0.2734321356,
0.1919908375,
-0.8007377982,
0.90265733,
0.3421347439,
-0.6651585102,
-0.5739132166,
-0.5126813054,
-0.6447217464,
0.5474037528,
-0.2941085696,
-0.6311787367,
-0.081974186,
-0.1240305156,
-0.6597396135,
0.317427367,
-0.6737282276,
0.8485726714,
-0.0878515691,
-0.0696929097,
-0.5057676435,
-0.3233063817,
0.3087897301,
-0.0784121528,
0.5394638777,
-0.1496655494,
0.1823136061,
1.0659570694,
-0.1750656515,
0.5376193523,
-0.1936077625,
-0.2266243398,
0.5405074358,
-0.1960090399,
0.5490185022,
0.0058274004,
-0.1929942518,
-0.1834649146,
-0.3525322974,
-0.1038980186,
-1.1637628078,
0.6199454069,
-0.4589257538,
-1.1650207043,
0.0009604807,
-1.1760249138,
-0.2487842441,
0.2662547231,
0.1112601608,
0.4380710125,
0.1374194473,
0.054437872,
0.5699581504,
-0.0875714347,
0.5780991316,
0.4598753154,
-0.4414693415,
-0.4361943007,
0.7599387765,
0.2489750683,
0.4098298848,
0.0200172216,
0.3296981156,
-0.1216987669,
-0.7109584212,
-0.3894510865,
0.1611824781,
-0.924220562,
-0.0220545847,
-0.8295913935,
-0.1780236363,
-0.4263037145,
-0.0593866967,
-0.3203640282,
-0.6075224876,
0.2371822298,
-0.1254219413,
0.1926016808,
0.7633208632,
0.0013511899,
0.1962792128,
-0.7009881735,
0.0674886182,
0.7451046705,
-0.2598442137,
0.3199192882,
-0.3032776117,
-0.2481785566,
-0.0920319036,
-0.3636558354,
-1.1838573217,
0.2757338583,
-0.3715236187,
0.6821432114,
0.0342721492,
-0.1280702502,
0.608330369,
-0.5135911703,
0.5902547836,
0.3735423088,
-0.7596958876,
0.5528309345,
-0.3128392994,
0.6071882248,
0.2774061859,
0.1431919187,
-0.4585000575,
-0.6337563992,
-0.6154113412,
-0.7093643546,
0.4840622544,
0.0390142575,
-0.2352762222,
0.0161060169,
0.1098640338,
0.0010466252,
0.3333699405,
-0.3964611888,
-0.1149477437,
-0.0189469066,
-0.1092941388,
0.3216174841,
0.0602458306,
-0.2561279237,
-0.405893147,
0.6049256325,
-0.1918041557,
0.2148074508,
0.0704256296,
0.2681266367,
-0.0117215626,
0.6650154591,
0.5152994394,
1.0149575472,
0.0631770641,
0.2294436991,
0.386513412,
0.0211142059,
0.2594487965,
0.1390824318,
-0.2284735739,
-0.05430362,
0.3017308116,
0.6109012365,
0.0677594319,
-0.6447457671,
0.3870523274,
-0.0967142731,
-0.2871464789,
0.045440793,
0.2463641912,
0.6274999976,
0.5159038305,
0.5670359731,
0.297693491,
-0.1952132881,
-0.297720015,
0.3485234976,
0.6638560891,
0.2083750516,
0.0621163286,
0.5614340901,
0.1782361865,
-0.132752046,
0.7668288946,
-0.3045529127,
-0.762050271,
0.9300491214,
0.5837486386,
0.5112807155,
-0.0680029467,
0.2778759003,
0.2955336273,
0.2163282782,
-0.2531405687,
0.4651219249,
0.1923170537,
-1.0971220732,
-0.763156414,
-0.1850002706,
-0.6944382191,
0.2061611265,
-0.3022939265,
0.1402912289,
-0.3675175607,
-0.3380150497,
0.3920844495,
0.1662905365,
-0.6901686788,
0.0629985034,
0.1282236576,
0.8469282985,
-0.6273656487,
0.7362174392,
0.7776722908,
-0.2536638081,
-1.0884627104,
-0.133400768,
0.1120705307,
-0.4999167919,
0.8492440581,
0.2978895009,
0.1467222273,
0.2240088284,
-0.8045047522,
-0.9181672931,
1.1960914135,
0.4047368765,
-0.6579499841,
-0.1626614332,
-0.3641868234,
-0.0597862415,
-0.652997911,
0.2938146293,
0.2101344317,
0.7578464746,
0.2380862683,
-1.0264788866,
0.3609321713,
0.1460826248,
-0.29533571,
-0.3566195965,
-0.4506021142,
1.089825511,
-0.78777349,
-0.1554967612,
0.0082837073,
1.0198972225,
1.1022572517,
0.1183054447,
0.5992724299,
0.4704291821,
1.1230821609,
0.1039324626,
0.6888787746,
-0.0150131239,
0.0288849268,
1.0828834772,
-0.4473586082,
0.5985908508,
0.4614861906,
0.0177623183,
0.5092203021,
0.0865007192,
0.0008726928,
0.3313556314,
0.0961384252,
-0.1820324808,
-0.5899435878,
-0.4152984023,
-0.1653154194,
0.1152865589,
0.3217079341,
-0.0028459746,
-0.3562007248,
0.1967551708,
0.1439934522,
0.0121143572,
-0.1709062457,
0.5953130722,
0.2260650545,
-1.1431491375,
0.4039051831,
0.2334688753,
0.6421484351,
-0.3431345522,
-0.1079133675,
0.0153114526,
0.0944588929,
-0.0265429989,
-0.9153441787,
0.0758572966,
-0.2088709623,
-0.4486818612,
-0.4971523583,
0.6615521312,
-0.6285668612,
-0.2485719919,
0.0496040881,
0.9539276361,
0.1354128718,
-0.1148398519,
-0.830747366,
0.0897877663,
-0.1400061548,
-0.1929860413,
0.2405211627,
0.5197964311,
-0.0574266203,
1.0385199785,
0.4619033933,
0.0764154419,
0.0390009619,
0.3184220791,
0.8162528872,
-0.4417968392,
-0.5174838305,
-1.060780406,
0.2834507227,
-0.3787120283,
-0.0422390886,
0.9810177088,
0.1601878852,
0.3595332801,
-0.1087280363,
0.9586290121,
-0.1827450991,
0.3708993495,
-0.3417391777,
0.5683704615,
-0.3046949506,
0.0405763127,
-0.1530860662,
-0.7090681195,
-0.1416189224,
0.4907829165,
-0.111858882,
0.1576898545,
0.8442044258,
0.66149652,
0.2233531177,
0.26363042,
0.2098155469,
0.2688324153,
0.4541580677,
0.5799711943,
0.824708879,
0.1029631868,
0.4189144075,
-0.0791353211,
-0.2982680202,
0.2080070525,
-0.9691390395,
-1.0881054401,
-0.7290469408,
-0.3280915916,
-0.1467299908,
0.0879158676,
1.2838280201,
0.8945069313,
-0.6008113623,
-0.1813514382,
-0.2020885497,
0.6160208583,
-0.4295400977,
-0.2265873551,
0.1850257069,
-0.4080603719,
-0.641271472,
0.7627444863,
0.0341198966,
-0.0128709069,
-0.3355411887,
0.0428144634,
-0.3378113806,
0.4127454162,
0.2979999483,
-0.2128023356,
-0.8318564296,
-0.0980295911,
0.0561033115,
-0.1792160124,
-0.3249796331,
0.8165075779,
-0.8742979765,
0.2261297405,
0.6202159524,
0.6430596113,
-0.0062642288,
-0.0232712813,
0.8083621264,
-0.7833607197,
0.1857540309,
0.0021244143,
0.364924401,
0.3937364519,
-0.0550667308,
0.1296922415,
0.402295202,
-0.6431999803,
-0.6190679669,
0.3883403838,
-0.6569561958,
-0.6670747995,
1.0527570248,
-0.0941887572,
0.0102886921,
-0.2072275877,
-0.2812870741,
0.240953356,
-0.4312272966,
0.6550503373,
1.0298711061,
-0.0842042938,
-0.3223204017,
-0.534196794,
0.3674193323,
0.5933753252,
-1.0583238602,
0.2746058106,
0.2947411537,
0.1711927503,
0.3494218886,
0.7070896029,
0.3954303563,
0.0088251699,
-0.0115911113,
-0.0538120642,
-0.3800928593,
-0.6649015546,
0.0653750077,
0.3836901486,
0.0534059517,
0.1139279455
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00755v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00755v1
|
Evaluating Mathematical Reasoning of Large Language Models: A Focus on Error Identification and Correction
| 2024-06-02T14:16:24 | 2024-06-02T14:16:24 |
Xiaoyuan Li, Wenjie Wang, Moxin Li, Junrong Guo, Yang Zhang, Fuli Feng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The rapid advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs) in the realm of
mathematical reasoning necessitates comprehensive evaluations to gauge progress
and inspire future directions. Existing assessments predominantly focus on
problem-solving from the examinee perspective, overlooking a dual perspective
of examiner regarding error identification and correction. From the examiner
perspective, we define four evaluation tasks for error identification and
correction along with a new dataset with annotated error types and steps. We
also design diverse prompts to thoroughly evaluate eleven representative LLMs.
Our principal findings indicate that GPT-4 outperforms all models, while
open-source model LLaMA-2-7B demonstrates comparable abilities to closed-source
models GPT-3.5 and Gemini Pro. Notably, calculation error proves the most
challenging error type. Moreover, prompting LLMs with the error types can
improve the average correction accuracy by 47.9\%. These results reveal
potential directions for developing the mathematical reasoning abilities of
LLMs. Our code and dataset is available on https://github.com/LittleCirc1e/EIC.
|
[
0.0588788055,
-0.7475210428,
0.8840812445,
0.5095946193,
-0.0329524167,
0.1507231146,
-0.4198268056,
-0.3528540432,
-0.0897669792,
0.4131883681,
-0.3603167534,
-0.3854378462,
-0.6339514256,
0.2466741204,
-0.3955895603,
0.6794567108,
-0.356910497,
0.3152057528,
-0.421484828,
0.1501359642,
-0.5923607945,
-0.437988162,
-0.9182064533,
-0.2763490379,
0.4925411344,
0.2985141873,
0.5303860903,
0.4451217651,
0.5979399085,
0.4162526429,
-0.0704413876,
0.242064625,
-0.4294717014,
-0.1056288853,
-0.2516134381,
-0.4593074024,
-0.5825962424,
-0.0656857416,
0.646748364,
0.709590137,
-0.3024777174,
0.1658507884,
-0.1145269722,
0.6243216395,
-0.4104754627,
0.4441764057,
-0.5204828382,
-0.1292497069,
-0.2411997318,
0.0852262452,
-0.5212119818,
-0.5682176948,
0.1797099859,
-0.6052619219,
-0.0532914065,
0.0236798003,
0.3920387924,
0.3086744845,
-0.3312554657,
-0.5044353008,
-0.7022911906,
0.8854704499,
-0.6775872707,
0.351334393,
0.1199185029,
0.3421145082,
-0.1775018126,
-0.6740018725,
-0.3711580932,
-0.2864948213,
0.2972247303,
0.0939201042,
-0.31880638,
-0.1035945117,
0.5685297251,
0.2021101415,
-0.3893662691,
0.3164432645,
-0.445784688,
-0.3392289579,
0.8461310267,
0.2987908423,
0.1450941265,
0.1017636582,
0.0610102378,
0.0235614292,
-0.8124315739,
-0.3601860702,
0.3900941908,
0.1207155734,
-0.1405555308,
0.6346321106,
0.0206283797,
0.6327582598,
-0.0967743844,
-0.1953542382,
0.1956214607,
-0.1851669103,
-0.3158325553,
-0.1311186701,
0.5903448462,
0.2173397392,
0.3560866416,
0.0821779743,
-0.5788111091,
0.0712429434,
0.0624437258,
-0.5338491797,
-0.2209742218,
0.1082468703,
-0.1923968792,
-0.1108836308,
0.089913778,
-0.7512348294,
-0.5328120589,
-0.6531895995,
0.5724404454,
-0.1079609692,
-0.0759415254,
0.3134433031,
0.1663467884,
0.0727089271,
0.855753839,
-0.5837370753,
0.3377704024,
0.8771784902,
0.6032099128,
-0.0667066574,
-0.190933615,
-0.4795053303,
-0.176624611,
-0.521694541,
0.8580247164,
-0.5603160262,
-0.2903041244,
-0.0322617069,
-0.1835810095,
-0.1936746389,
-0.6538101435,
0.8581219316,
-0.5730574131,
0.1247952282,
-0.3086980283,
-0.5732775331,
-0.3254750371,
0.1883387566,
-0.7143042684,
0.9487820268,
0.2301331162,
-0.5517093539,
-0.1027697101,
-0.9489107728,
-0.1659805924,
-0.0563902445,
-0.0788080916,
-0.3403824866,
0.3678462207,
0.2287792563,
0.0923399553,
-0.6384114027,
0.2864507139,
-0.3082806766,
-0.3749690354,
0.3297903836,
-0.4912409186,
0.7761095762,
0.1659653634,
-0.257684201,
0.2878749073,
-0.8271166682,
0.0482465252,
0.4075630903,
-0.1335781217,
-0.1132537425,
-0.0003091157,
-0.327128619,
-0.0449075438,
0.2760998309,
-0.4384830892,
0.1400607079,
-0.2606410682,
0.5127434134,
0.9335607886,
-0.1525005698,
0.074455969,
-0.1706189066,
0.684163034,
-0.0350885242,
0.1664031893,
-0.1982671618,
-0.6202774048,
-0.7820752263,
-0.1288316101,
0.633774817,
0.6642205119,
-0.6136094332,
0.1324291676,
-0.2054185271,
-0.6296265721,
-0.277108103,
0.2524180412,
0.4736560881,
0.3930513263,
0.1446942985,
-0.0630576089,
-0.5396662951,
-0.7712118626,
-0.3216622174,
-0.1847465336,
0.0073325653,
0.2484527975,
0.6476267576,
-0.1555077881,
0.5637665391,
-0.3654429317,
0.0849418938,
-0.0963958576,
0.0108161932,
0.3050228059,
0.2579188943,
0.3673895001,
-0.4643059969,
-0.3179819882,
-0.0119161941,
-0.6117392182,
-0.5043750405,
0.0596427433,
-0.0249737278,
0.118590802,
0.187679857,
-0.502682507,
0.2972580492,
0.5262263417,
-0.2413345426,
0.8598390818,
-0.1473924518,
0.039084781,
-0.5225313902,
-0.1376461685,
0.2569166124,
0.0477172472,
-0.3654439151,
0.0766862705,
0.0695076138,
0.0989717171,
-0.225854367,
0.5066209435,
-0.5213643312,
-0.3204928935,
-0.0952084213,
0.360984683,
-0.0839515924,
0.0808026493,
-0.18025662,
0.6634088159,
0.5995557308,
-0.3802560866,
0.7431236506,
0.0324223749,
-0.5131093264,
0.4873643816,
-0.7703870535,
0.4751542211,
-0.082591489,
0.1271351129,
-0.9431733489,
-0.2769387066,
0.3372252584,
-0.3443357348,
0.2532530427,
0.0499782339,
-0.6024625301,
-0.5307608843,
-0.1579382271,
0.3932655156,
0.302878648,
-0.6019982696,
0.7868737578,
0.1069103181,
-0.3484807312,
-0.6598501801,
-0.3276783526,
0.0478806868,
-0.1302654445,
-0.7108228207,
-0.0785612836,
-0.2301330268,
-0.7592003345,
-0.0892235786,
-0.019645879,
0.000447983,
0.2130008489,
0.012535695,
0.4961286485,
-0.4011564553,
0.1186863407,
-0.0364035927,
-0.1979396939,
0.3354557455,
-0.170474872,
0.3526859283,
-0.2419977039,
-0.7343799472,
-0.321764797,
-0.0088230344,
0.5033681989,
-0.3693407476,
0.3156425655,
0.1381991953,
-0.5838329196,
-0.0975097269,
-0.6740010977,
0.0945741832,
-0.3903011084,
0.5068721175,
-0.5528145432,
-0.687349081,
0.5844925046,
0.0468037501,
0.1023071632,
0.6709321737,
0.6936435699,
0.1452097595,
1.0733146667,
0.3509917259,
0.0705331862,
-0.002710572,
-0.0663496256,
0.2482956201,
-0.7880398035,
-0.1961660981,
-0.7565775514,
-0.0900972337,
-0.2075192183,
-0.5774093866,
0.257799536,
0.1210727915,
-0.3172086179,
0.0483449772,
-0.2575356662,
0.6024497151,
0.2667376697,
-0.0186038893,
0.4745412767,
-0.0878849477,
-0.1464069635,
-0.1527143866,
-0.355943948,
-0.78368783,
1.287253499,
0.571377933,
0.8343479037,
0.2592281997,
0.4957717359,
-0.0317373797,
0.8537275791,
-0.8568989635,
0.5218945146,
0.0722307637,
-0.4983015358,
-0.2765976489,
-0.6643238068,
-0.4523387849,
0.269505918,
0.0710870326,
-0.7198539972,
-0.1354857832,
0.1210823208,
-0.2814872563,
0.2533990145,
-0.8210089803,
0.8699418902,
-0.5540921688,
-0.2107078284,
-0.3574321866,
-0.2682615817,
0.6224880219,
-0.5366943479,
0.2993126214,
-0.0040695248,
-0.2145063281,
0.5909727812,
-0.2575851977,
0.7541742325,
-0.2055669725,
-0.4911883473,
0.4290143847,
0.1306241304,
0.5907189846,
-0.0421170145,
-0.3699269295,
0.1277685612,
0.1231519356,
-0.1492007375,
-0.864778161,
0.5353918076,
-0.6691733003,
-0.7498283386,
-0.457416445,
-0.4085982144,
-0.2582280636,
0.0493863337,
-0.2026223838,
0.543299973,
-0.1369303763,
-0.0706164986,
0.4544768631,
-0.3232583106,
0.1497602761,
0.6173754334,
-0.4913157225,
-0.4760932028,
0.7920039892,
0.0124523239,
0.2260257155,
0.2248703688,
0.3716401458,
-0.5008510351,
-0.7716426849,
-0.6116190553,
0.5910218358,
-0.9947223067,
-0.1577169448,
-0.2295467407,
-0.1248384863,
-0.1885785162,
0.2362801582,
-0.3534050584,
-0.310328424,
-0.280664444,
-0.013626677,
0.1675501317,
1.0463073254,
0.0207022857,
0.2953325808,
-0.7374070287,
-0.104811959,
0.2340949923,
0.4130933583,
0.1847886592,
-0.6484957933,
-0.0161079448,
-0.0027447215,
-0.4446385801,
-0.7417864203,
0.0576135144,
-0.0340413973,
0.6120763421,
0.3630976975,
-0.3499909639,
0.6911743283,
-0.4988260269,
0.6552003622,
0.1872954965,
-1.2098526955,
0.3072969317,
-0.2164276391,
-0.0280629713,
0.1020679176,
0.2192297876,
-0.4183292687,
-0.0198998991,
-0.4882108569,
-0.1669335663,
0.5669500232,
0.0160629507,
-0.0024757136,
0.0280168578,
0.5500380397,
-0.0555008873,
0.0912322327,
-0.6189146638,
0.013112043,
0.1200269237,
-0.339797914,
-0.1393339932,
-0.3725062013,
-0.1797597706,
-0.2917979062,
0.6748634577,
-0.259013474,
0.2741227448,
0.0156222088,
-0.0843679681,
-0.3161350489,
0.2620218992,
0.9053701162,
1.3178807497,
0.1241441295,
-0.0551944487,
0.3054093719,
-0.2883100212,
-0.0542017259,
0.1797147095,
0.0749085918,
-0.1016366407,
0.4263439775,
0.6607634425,
0.2839746177,
-0.8316919804,
0.5506185889,
-0.0617844686,
-0.2123385072,
-0.4770680666,
-0.17180489,
0.1551752687,
0.3363209069,
0.2373093963,
-0.0749268904,
0.0252828654,
-0.3383547962,
-0.1292960048,
0.3193579316,
-0.023292562,
-0.5085579157,
0.6148381829,
0.1138268784,
-0.319208771,
0.6387473941,
-0.1550946385,
-0.7718290091,
0.7437292337,
0.6562823653,
0.8232145905,
-0.4417624474,
0.0142604467,
0.3872847855,
0.4089203775,
-0.1999641061,
0.39529863,
0.3511431813,
-0.7746925354,
-0.895693779,
-0.5614951253,
-0.6656857133,
0.0394905023,
-0.363076061,
0.4897800982,
-0.5127913356,
0.089822866,
0.0911469981,
0.02702922,
-0.4233149588,
0.1374200135,
0.2233959138,
0.9752405882,
-0.7512363195,
0.5568342805,
0.7828942537,
-0.1776819527,
-0.9293070436,
-0.3729164004,
0.2342965156,
-0.8911694884,
0.8330519199,
0.0782023892,
-0.0347978063,
-0.0252833236,
-0.5836648941,
-0.8288244605,
0.8417539001,
0.5319173336,
-0.8887183666,
0.0050724349,
-0.0647070631,
0.6182224751,
-0.4625884295,
0.632298708,
0.6830647588,
0.6837869287,
0.2442893088,
-1.2403798103,
-0.1991110444,
-0.0670852587,
0.0305121634,
0.3143132031,
-0.5445061326,
0.8297536969,
-0.4247632325,
-0.094939135,
0.3881849349,
0.5195559859,
0.5063478351,
0.374899596,
0.4920104146,
0.7783849239,
0.8337132931,
-0.3141757846,
0.9959459901,
0.0197633877,
0.384886682,
1.0182570219,
-0.4459899962,
0.7931631804,
0.245692566,
-0.541834712,
0.4015699029,
0.699170053,
-0.1046874449,
-0.0016002977,
0.5067788363,
-0.1489138305,
-0.2268518507,
0.2569386661,
-0.2323922217,
0.386672914,
0.5719596744,
-0.3431679308,
-0.2475776076,
-0.2905474901,
0.0311840698,
0.0411707386,
-0.5115174055,
0.4174605012,
0.2067539245,
-0.5917390585,
0.2483704388,
0.2009732723,
0.176608637,
-0.333702147,
-0.2682482302,
-0.0005435969,
0.4234626591,
-0.2874809206,
-0.7500316501,
0.2599500418,
0.1680247337,
0.0467192717,
0.1314214021,
0.4773183763,
-0.1888661385,
-0.6863054633,
0.131977573,
0.464797467,
0.3450937867,
-0.149269715,
-0.842738986,
0.4459475875,
0.0598099083,
-0.0489934683,
-0.0683227628,
0.4220972061,
-0.3220968843,
0.6720743179,
0.5484116673,
0.1653952599,
0.0717216507,
0.4709608853,
0.6535542607,
-0.5617514253,
-0.1675294489,
-0.8357761502,
0.3747117221,
0.0654274002,
-0.2929670513,
0.7109748125,
0.5315715075,
0.7589683533,
-0.1507102549,
0.653795898,
0.2054943144,
0.7734040618,
-0.6391151547,
0.1085817516,
-0.2852360308,
0.5840197206,
-0.427154094,
-1.19079566,
-0.4665873349,
0.6908075213,
-0.6581193209,
0.2930871546,
0.8129311204,
0.6677673459,
0.0658083037,
0.3474854231,
0.2477275878,
0.3886915743,
0.3865706623,
0.7742364407,
1.3443621397,
-0.4160424173,
0.3087358773,
-0.1217706874,
-0.4519915879,
-0.1011565998,
-0.9381581545,
-0.748449564,
-0.1680778116,
-0.5901617408,
-0.389470607,
-0.1893147677,
0.9644541144,
0.1092846841,
-0.7844752073,
-0.2899948657,
0.1166603044,
0.1506285965,
-0.1152490601,
-0.1501827687,
0.3872030973,
-0.15406093,
-0.9205230474,
0.3136569262,
0.3587118387,
-0.1393053681,
-0.4493082762,
-0.1910709441,
0.284427911,
0.1009009853,
0.673579216,
0.1093555763,
-1.0011413097,
-0.3904615343,
-0.0351334326,
0.0759388581,
0.0259607956,
0.7923902869,
-0.2953644395,
0.5154149532,
0.2604349554,
0.82965523,
0.2593797743,
-0.0892321542,
0.4523441195,
0.0090455981,
-0.2204505801,
0.1773726493,
0.641831398,
0.3929986358,
-0.1157934815,
0.7316368818,
0.4870016873,
-0.6162098646,
-0.9451586604,
0.0416189842,
-0.9306787848,
0.1712012887,
1.0421453714,
-0.27994138,
-0.2783314288,
0.0682793334,
-0.3773498535,
-0.1373239607,
-0.0588063151,
0.5876272321,
1.0198355913,
-0.1553579718,
-0.3207827806,
-0.7264893055,
0.1092480719,
0.3874613941,
-0.8898157477,
-0.0069720317,
0.7661286592,
0.3814057112,
0.2627854347,
0.3522622287,
-0.498513639,
0.4711471796,
-0.1052344665,
-0.096765548,
0.0641355813,
-0.3516460955,
-0.5940384269,
-0.1016567051,
0.2984595597,
0.2508120239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00751v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00751v1
|
How well do distributed representations convey contextual lexical semantics: a Thesis Proposal
| 2024-06-02T14:08:51 | 2024-06-02T14:08:51 |
Zhu Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Modern neural networks (NNs), trained on extensive raw sentence data,
construct distributed representations by compressing individual words into
dense, continuous, high-dimensional vectors. These representations are
specifically designed to capture the varied meanings, including ambiguity, of
word occurrences within context. In this thesis, our objective is to examine
the efficacy of distributed representations from NNs in encoding lexical
meaning. Initially, we identify four sources of ambiguity - homonymy, polysemy,
semantic roles, and multifunctionality - based on the relatedness and
similarity of meanings influenced by context. Subsequently, we aim to evaluate
these sources by collecting or constructing multilingual datasets, leveraging
various language models, and employing linguistic analysis tools.
|
[
-0.4442644417,
-0.4244944453,
0.5657607317,
0.5338949561,
-0.1221444905,
-0.3518646657,
-0.3932466209,
-0.5057414174,
0.5114114285,
0.0726699829,
-0.4706383646,
-0.2018712163,
-0.9312064052,
0.5777013898,
-0.4942378402,
0.5035203099,
-0.2041898519,
0.2778744102,
-0.3748100698,
-0.3565993011,
-0.5635976195,
-0.5706982017,
-0.0648038536,
-0.5692766905,
0.777661562,
0.1417169869,
1.0260441303,
0.6123802662,
0.4955409467,
0.3456112146,
-0.2247885019,
0.0225368105,
-0.3817763329,
0.3963027,
-0.1490923762,
-0.4684833288,
-0.0381997265,
-0.0399930663,
1.0637993813,
1.3591141701,
-0.1539295912,
0.0150051229,
0.1571816206,
0.3300953507,
-0.8104456663,
0.1818800718,
-0.3730561435,
0.1733611226,
-0.2432859689,
-0.112826407,
-0.4395704567,
-0.2520352006,
0.5148504376,
-0.79711169,
-0.1644335538,
-0.2699880004,
0.553263247,
0.0423846543,
-0.7249398828,
-0.6046758294,
-0.5378776789,
0.8131666183,
-0.3596698344,
0.2589837611,
0.1508925259,
0.2630664408,
-0.3238254786,
-0.7521249056,
-0.497258544,
-0.0325998403,
-0.3127295375,
0.2287382782,
0.1649476886,
-0.0246542264,
0.0158833694,
0.024612125,
-0.266917944,
-0.1199724972,
-0.1006937698,
-0.0676049739,
0.5610557199,
0.2302599698,
0.1739125997,
-0.5046194196,
-0.5359383225,
-0.061055176,
-0.2405923009,
-0.3439064622,
0.3438322544,
0.3434272408,
-0.0512915365,
0.5724761486,
-0.0785729066,
0.8466902971,
-0.4885573089,
0.1242666394,
0.1563501209,
-0.3754445612,
-0.3582246304,
0.3663956821,
0.485290885,
0.2673809826,
0.1844510585,
-0.1344715506,
-0.1753405631,
-0.0580838136,
0.1731604487,
-0.3099071085,
0.4735280871,
-0.0060089142,
-0.5048038363,
-0.0652547553,
0.2220710665,
-0.676404655,
-0.53185004,
-0.7408911586,
0.473311156,
-0.332401216,
-0.3657954633,
0.2071266621,
-0.5334206223,
0.1957103908,
0.1763859093,
-0.8849542141,
0.3002990484,
0.4495103061,
0.8008492589,
-0.1301761717,
-0.3388564885,
0.1905128658,
0.4106088579,
-0.4143897295,
0.3298410773,
-0.5883188844,
-0.1417597532,
0.283030659,
-0.0585871786,
-0.3784054816,
-0.5508794785,
0.2572341561,
-0.6013510227,
-0.116163604,
-0.3993721902,
-0.7530379295,
-0.1762726456,
0.3421901166,
-0.8527914882,
0.743019402,
0.0400515683,
-0.9734302759,
0.1548237056,
-0.4724844992,
-0.267652601,
0.1469976008,
-0.4936483502,
0.1934615821,
0.4280363023,
0.0856478065,
0.6586893797,
0.0122999577,
0.4426768124,
0.00563657,
-0.5989468098,
0.3696403503,
-0.5381144881,
0.7474230528,
0.1964457929,
-0.4055285454,
-0.0523265414,
-0.3681395948,
-0.2295102179,
0.179067865,
-0.2622158825,
-0.6035783291,
-0.1905638874,
0.0088678394,
-0.0080711795,
0.3404955566,
-0.4189319015,
0.1526941657,
-0.3716563582,
0.2290220559,
0.7416816354,
-0.2063771188,
0.6008672714,
-0.0538712926,
0.3197580576,
0.3552567661,
-0.0043439111,
-0.1434758902,
-0.6296736598,
-0.5085033774,
0.2282883972,
0.3510388434,
0.3547751307,
-0.8139648438,
0.0246264935,
-0.5364752412,
-0.041529648,
-0.1293515861,
-0.1060632393,
-0.1359570622,
0.0561885387,
0.0141578084,
-0.0586324856,
-0.5793341398,
-0.972232163,
-0.0506705604,
0.2774940729,
0.1678004116,
0.4405320287,
0.5889157653,
-0.5351887941,
1.0558104515,
-0.4198070168,
0.1195159107,
-0.0057744142,
0.1931772083,
0.1862259358,
0.1075906977,
0.5540251136,
-0.8540595174,
-0.2092687488,
0.0475316346,
-1.0520147085,
0.0137168635,
-0.2201412022,
-0.1957761049,
-0.0656968057,
0.4329903722,
-0.3802191019,
0.4308448434,
0.7732400894,
-0.2199652642,
0.6832296848,
-0.3970730603,
0.0915979594,
-1.2308360338,
-0.0705670863,
-0.2240912318,
-0.1965198815,
-0.5092096329,
0.04135314,
0.0955219716,
-0.2341522872,
-0.5079433322,
0.4321718812,
-0.6856351495,
-0.1477951407,
-0.1744949073,
0.6864982247,
-0.1782254428,
0.1403383464,
-0.0836098865,
0.5767429471,
0.7467158437,
-0.7430178523,
0.6876946688,
0.0366255827,
-0.2590395808,
0.6971210837,
-0.4697880745,
-0.2915058732,
-0.671280086,
0.2509924173,
-0.6979542971,
-0.5272183418,
0.0299266838,
-0.1641520113,
0.0146423392,
0.2753729224,
-0.6185937524,
-0.1378015876,
0.2139835358,
0.716791451,
-0.1679293513,
-0.4206670821,
0.3423143923,
0.3189631402,
0.4238320291,
-0.706353128,
-1.0494673252,
0.0905387402,
-0.1035064608,
-0.731507659,
0.4451035261,
0.2256652266,
-0.295209527,
0.1786287725,
-0.1082555279,
-0.0590022467,
0.0471047759,
0.3670960963,
-0.1814765036,
-0.1573966891,
0.507501781,
-0.2113703787,
0.0447286852,
0.1041827351,
-0.519551456,
0.4680166543,
-0.0534881018,
-0.5122089982,
-0.1790012568,
0.7550189495,
0.3991482854,
0.1513582021,
1.1894491911,
0.6457532644,
-0.6308968067,
-0.1829332113,
0.0911074132,
-0.0224793684,
-0.4598872364,
0.0870559961,
-0.4066041112,
-0.9415810704,
0.9577528834,
-0.3013966978,
-0.3055435717,
0.459772706,
0.4296973646,
0.0411078036,
0.8849190474,
0.3847842813,
0.0714716688,
0.4374722838,
-0.4000173509,
0.0314060487,
-0.6775836349,
-0.2815170586,
-0.3120428324,
-0.5573512912,
-0.8072405457,
-0.5269377232,
0.406553328,
0.1009652466,
-0.1779434979,
0.3487540781,
-0.3851642013,
0.3381988108,
0.4946753383,
-0.1422827691,
-0.2038591504,
0.0887193009,
-0.635325253,
-0.0254159961,
-0.7551045418,
-0.483672291,
0.7710103393,
0.3939825296,
0.5720204711,
0.3870661557,
0.8561084867,
0.0989726931,
-0.1181316227,
-0.7202550769,
0.4528596401,
-0.0439684018,
-0.7025535107,
0.0102134859,
-0.4640959799,
-1.3294023275,
0.3775683045,
-0.1897455305,
-0.6970371008,
0.4964948595,
-0.5207144022,
-0.3243716955,
0.1094337776,
-0.665748477,
0.6583530903,
0.056046173,
-0.0777667165,
-0.188285917,
-0.8033908606,
0.2004327476,
0.2228710353,
0.2443211079,
0.031188691,
-0.0857062712,
0.7711369395,
-0.0174992774,
0.7896972299,
-0.0459092408,
-0.0397935435,
0.332159102,
0.0124504743,
0.0863201544,
0.287134558,
-0.6137807965,
0.3612065017,
0.3240133524,
-0.5223730206,
-0.6151524186,
0.7100259662,
-0.8499298096,
-0.300901562,
-0.6373929977,
-0.7739607692,
0.045328401,
0.3253869712,
0.3176787496,
0.8081331849,
-0.1801086068,
0.3620438874,
0.4659747481,
-0.1242953762,
0.6333456039,
-0.2791169882,
-0.122561805,
-0.3805921674,
0.2972615957,
0.2345662415,
0.2628154159,
0.2234100252,
0.1170796677,
-0.1503863186,
-0.1770429164,
-0.4050658643,
-0.0019098287,
-1.1630702019,
-0.1649643332,
-0.2759015858,
-0.3522542119,
-0.4500275552,
-0.1786596775,
-0.1475836337,
-0.2042853385,
-0.4384312928,
0.106989719,
0.2633994818,
1.289150238,
-0.0031378996,
0.7027027607,
-0.6479251385,
0.143166706,
0.0562641919,
0.5513612032,
0.0850070938,
-0.0188667383,
-0.5347163677,
0.2786367834,
-0.0372160859,
-1.2892718315,
0.2603546381,
0.2122701108,
0.9745589495,
0.3783590198,
-0.1215796843,
0.6214332581,
-0.3437906504,
0.9970420003,
0.168440029,
-0.9154334664,
0.4108031094,
-0.4037648141,
0.5659707189,
0.4280720353,
0.5340774059,
-0.8292476535,
-0.1659352779,
-0.4008054137,
-0.7905960083,
0.6799864173,
0.345399797,
0.6163681746,
-0.3963316083,
0.8275851607,
0.0423219949,
0.0645038933,
-0.6281713843,
-0.6355670094,
-0.1083917469,
-0.3276003301,
0.0041020382,
-0.2815565765,
-0.1334967315,
-0.2283026129,
0.024063373,
-0.159531638,
0.6822239161,
0.5025618672,
-0.2142169327,
0.2070086002,
0.2058817297,
0.7482486963,
0.7767214179,
-0.0094496161,
0.8349307775,
0.0269256625,
-0.4909234941,
0.143324241,
-0.1100595966,
0.0000927768,
0.343922168,
0.5911306739,
0.9333741665,
0.3038002253,
-0.2708342373,
0.4283308983,
-0.1266854405,
-0.2125149071,
-0.2558679283,
-0.3464469314,
0.389202714,
0.1336431056,
0.2817096114,
0.1120163873,
0.1569509804,
-0.6382645965,
0.487673372,
0.3233391047,
-0.4126130939,
-0.0753303766,
0.2224420756,
-0.124509193,
0.0945929438,
0.7076836824,
-0.3476248384,
-0.6749302745,
0.4797957838,
0.7866727114,
0.4529588223,
-0.2191427797,
0.2342516333,
0.3950727582,
0.1549410969,
-0.2030451745,
0.1605375856,
-0.0073122717,
-1.0069144964,
-0.2964364588,
-0.7266452909,
-0.1059049666,
-0.4652316272,
-0.7004077435,
0.043669235,
-0.0776970685,
-0.4491533339,
-0.0652480572,
-0.2539607882,
-0.722838819,
0.0170872565,
0.4022386074,
0.6925199628,
-0.8541499972,
0.7322899699,
0.8754162788,
-0.2878745794,
-1.0081220865,
0.1827229708,
-0.0918977112,
-0.5140305758,
0.9344132543,
0.3178449273,
-0.0387621,
-0.1042335778,
-0.3130778074,
-1.1312885284,
0.9378630519,
0.6009140611,
-0.3965498209,
0.1349993199,
0.6711512208,
0.4750544727,
-0.6421850324,
0.3915396929,
0.4150399566,
0.6519271731,
0.2964634895,
-0.8989543319,
0.0300908294,
-0.1131396666,
0.3312156796,
0.0017372493,
0.0699186176,
0.9584843516,
0.3308210969,
-0.3991589546,
-0.4105947912,
0.4671427011,
-0.0206502452,
0.10339614,
0.1920224428,
0.3749770522,
0.8537690639,
-0.1784746051,
1.2225693464,
-0.0441476069,
0.3243440688,
0.8410791755,
0.0153805362,
0.723357439,
0.6821517944,
0.2233812809,
0.699375689,
0.6738002896,
0.377707094,
0.5256242156,
0.5532673597,
-0.443487674,
-0.0328927636,
-0.3861860633,
-0.1898902804,
0.5053347349,
0.431918174,
-0.4157631993,
-0.4600175023,
0.4041320384,
-0.4978701472,
0.2350571752,
-0.2865832746,
0.6891743541,
0.3488990366,
-0.4536730945,
0.6924396157,
-0.0008037592,
0.6681500077,
-0.3578141928,
0.0851165056,
-0.0319191292,
0.2064086646,
-0.3003164828,
-0.9461872578,
0.6697221398,
-0.6273980141,
0.0417172201,
-0.3779863119,
0.6903614998,
-0.4057821035,
-0.3443253636,
0.7050529122,
0.4577928483,
0.2199707925,
0.2164197266,
-0.5260806084,
0.282972455,
-0.3768858612,
-0.084209539,
-0.0828632489,
0.6342183352,
-0.188709259,
0.4284845591,
-0.021826826,
0.2279263884,
0.5194353461,
0.4241106808,
0.5442972183,
-0.7182652354,
-0.4289444387,
-0.8224484324,
0.4036139846,
-0.0014977354,
-0.0471431613,
0.731539309,
0.1106395051,
0.8790875077,
0.0837639198,
0.3246070445,
-0.1370633245,
-0.3263182044,
-0.1423080564,
0.5636901855,
-0.5552504659,
-0.0004945419,
-0.0621173047,
-0.8573362827,
-0.6530491114,
0.7693257332,
-0.2349798083,
0.080791831,
0.7607645988,
0.4285698831,
-0.2478927523,
0.2767076194,
0.2882125676,
-0.2739811242,
-0.1355776936,
0.3425599933,
0.9452726841,
-0.5852136612,
0.0554734319,
-0.185966894,
-0.0265574809,
-0.2658956945,
-0.9561698437,
-0.4421776533,
-0.8241881132,
0.0220557507,
-0.1173955649,
-0.151988849,
0.9646729231,
0.8097509146,
-0.5947102904,
-0.4799712002,
-0.2702133954,
0.2559103668,
-0.3518859148,
-0.1858701259,
0.3017455041,
-0.4140892029,
-0.6014235616,
0.2737070322,
-0.0692927316,
-0.0883351862,
-0.4552268982,
-0.1268549711,
-0.3448201716,
0.1140685752,
0.696882844,
-0.6490827203,
-0.6283237934,
-0.4640317857,
0.121058479,
-0.488275677,
-0.0202255547,
0.7414696813,
-0.3591185212,
0.6295304894,
0.8471627831,
0.6982915998,
0.2682840824,
-0.2657515705,
0.8052184582,
-1.0628817081,
0.4506993294,
0.1493702978,
0.5057724714,
0.3810913861,
-0.501353085,
0.1592905968,
0.1846027374,
-0.3696516156,
-0.4571097195,
0.3789151013,
-0.8408511877,
-0.4645311236,
1.1590319872,
-0.1197223514,
-0.3976996839,
-0.134273082,
0.1139156148,
0.5791224241,
-0.04078383,
0.2060385048,
0.8954114914,
-0.2050924003,
-0.0158051718,
-0.9437947869,
0.3298695683,
0.2313613445,
-0.3260163665,
0.0218332876,
0.4045338035,
0.1183974445,
0.5629642606,
0.2194318473,
-0.1314771026,
-0.1797415316,
0.0481264107,
0.0100933658,
0.2598394454,
-0.1517524421,
-0.6726419926,
0.4155237079,
-0.1177911758,
-0.20319134
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06560v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06560v1
|
Inverse Constitutional AI: Compressing Preferences into Principles
| 2024-06-02T11:54:50 | 2024-06-02T11:54:50 |
Arduin Findeis, Timo Kaufmann, Eyke Hüllermeier, Samuel Albanie, Robert Mullins
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Feedback data plays an important role in fine-tuning and evaluating
state-of-the-art AI models. Often pairwise text preferences are used: given two
texts, human (or AI) annotators select the "better" one. Such feedback data is
widely used to align models to human preferences (e.g., reinforcement learning
from human feedback), or to rank models according to human preferences (e.g.,
Chatbot Arena). Despite its wide-spread use, prior work has demonstrated that
human-annotated pairwise text preference data often exhibits unintended biases.
For example, human annotators have been shown to prefer assertive over truthful
texts in certain contexts. Models trained or evaluated on this data may
implicitly encode these biases in a manner hard to identify. In this paper, we
formulate the interpretation of existing pairwise text preference data as a
compression task: the Inverse Constitutional AI (ICAI) problem. In
constitutional AI, a set of principles (or constitution) is used to provide
feedback and fine-tune AI models. The ICAI problem inverts this process: given
a dataset of feedback, we aim to extract a constitution that best enables a
large language model (LLM) to reconstruct the original annotations. We propose
a corresponding initial ICAI algorithm and validate its generated constitutions
quantitatively based on reconstructed annotations. Generated constitutions have
many potential use-cases -- they may help identify undesirable biases, scale
feedback to unseen data or assist with adapting LLMs to individual user
preferences. We demonstrate our approach on a variety of datasets: (a)
synthetic feedback datasets with known underlying principles; (b) the
AlpacaEval dataset of cross-annotated human feedback; and (c) the crowdsourced
Chatbot Arena data set. We release the code for our algorithm and experiments
at https://github.com/rdnfn/icai .
|
[
-0.5112608075,
-0.4438343346,
0.2687616944,
-0.0428300761,
-0.3949658871,
-0.3534322977,
-0.6771116853,
-0.2706627548,
0.2691591382,
0.822106421,
-0.4423518181,
-0.0575814322,
-0.5177354217,
0.1989051998,
-0.4365974665,
1.2806569338,
0.2230677009,
0.1501753777,
-0.3049559891,
-0.2470532209,
-0.3117819726,
-0.7796162367,
-0.4825651944,
-0.6265134215,
0.0160904452,
0.6910887361,
0.7975024581,
0.5920000672,
0.3803760409,
0.2510846555,
0.2104673833,
0.2401664257,
-0.7484751344,
-0.2355392575,
0.0998855755,
-0.5418910384,
0.0410204343,
0.4356807768,
0.5971447825,
0.478595078,
0.0228625108,
0.176558584,
0.2388215512,
0.8864787817,
-0.4788857102,
0.3442632854,
-0.7212878466,
-0.1283891499,
-0.1039253771,
-0.2493705601,
-0.3619129062,
-0.4912807941,
0.2547646165,
-0.767713964,
0.0609058253,
0.297768563,
0.9712720513,
0.4833119214,
-0.1790290475,
-0.3545269966,
-0.7788172364,
0.6750018597,
-0.7299947143,
0.2451639324,
0.6531860828,
0.1070525646,
-0.3199601769,
-0.398649931,
-1.1630048752,
-0.4265618622,
-0.4288465977,
0.1545619369,
0.0846844465,
0.2766736448,
0.2186127454,
0.4872662425,
-0.1218615994,
0.2572086453,
-0.5116609335,
0.0156964753,
0.8093631268,
-0.1159894615,
0.2577115297,
-0.3303689957,
0.0142352208,
-0.2950825989,
-0.7237370014,
0.3912933171,
0.9001378417,
0.3953105807,
-0.2247470915,
0.6802026629,
-0.387695998,
0.5048540235,
0.5121095181,
0.0577044897,
0.1345720738,
-0.1167140901,
-0.2761884928,
-0.0466679409,
0.8751530647,
0.5759022236,
0.2546579838,
-0.2632256448,
-0.1827822477,
0.0713572651,
0.2903530598,
-0.5777652264,
-0.3876808882,
0.3816185892,
-0.6936275959,
-0.5769237876,
0.3455122411,
-0.7428981662,
-0.6011416316,
-0.9286696911,
0.3460902274,
-0.2597503364,
-0.1047028229,
-0.0406281389,
-0.1733676046,
0.3364914358,
0.1058112755,
-1.0811015368,
0.3976087868,
0.9957829714,
0.5806270242,
-0.0667051226,
-0.0497909598,
-0.4022494256,
-0.1774980575,
-0.162634626,
0.8010782003,
-0.6956430078,
-0.2341468334,
-0.1120319068,
-0.0643090382,
0.2346187085,
-0.5387732387,
0.9120645523,
-0.2019925565,
0.2762060165,
-0.2862558961,
-0.592795372,
-0.0761413202,
0.3891199231,
-0.8638699651,
0.7828107476,
-0.2398699522,
-0.7511929274,
0.5705468059,
-0.739585638,
-0.1399933547,
-0.1210229993,
-0.4098061323,
-0.4881269932,
0.0609025285,
0.4023153782,
0.2003187388,
-0.5269058943,
0.3143081665,
-0.5334052444,
-0.4919303358,
0.286778748,
-0.204921782,
0.8597084284,
-0.0519252457,
-0.414727658,
0.203643173,
-0.7147485614,
-0.2109431624,
-0.116991356,
-0.3590672314,
-0.4601830244,
0.1812395751,
-0.1000170261,
-0.0987944826,
-0.0348931924,
-0.5847893357,
0.5084699988,
-0.6342198849,
0.5709008574,
1.0948396921,
-0.0727530047,
0.672786355,
-0.5800094008,
0.2024314255,
-0.1156335548,
0.2414322942,
0.3204895854,
-0.3296539485,
-0.8791944981,
-0.2132479101,
0.4132638276,
0.5147880316,
-0.5085311532,
0.6529132724,
-0.4717257917,
-0.2785035968,
-0.813313961,
0.0239032153,
0.2589078248,
0.4541268647,
0.1892601401,
-0.1818367988,
-0.6292350888,
-1.1586979628,
-0.1878106147,
-0.7228654027,
0.1238879412,
0.5285938382,
0.4114051759,
-0.0462944955,
0.8613420725,
-0.2343382984,
-0.2604933977,
0.006657104,
0.2536658645,
0.2171716094,
0.6781484485,
0.4000123739,
-1.0093708038,
0.0258778222,
-0.2056798786,
-0.4260001779,
-0.0757784769,
-0.4119609892,
-0.375943929,
-0.0287835691,
0.2463137358,
-0.3605975509,
0.6179596782,
0.3295742869,
0.0223282371,
0.4734660387,
-0.0798556432,
0.4629723728,
-0.938487649,
0.3214681447,
-0.0919472948,
-0.0209482107,
-0.4067048728,
0.0986880064,
-0.1959179044,
0.053891886,
0.0354396105,
0.4200602174,
-0.212798357,
0.1199210882,
-0.2220675647,
0.0437534861,
-0.2243169844,
0.7176908851,
0.0577395074,
0.6645671725,
0.0601730049,
-0.5933599472,
0.4294947088,
0.5379132628,
-0.1258172989,
0.5879385471,
-0.6527098417,
0.5356498957,
-0.4526261985,
0.4150777757,
-1.0140275955,
-0.3082304299,
0.5361739993,
-0.5055695176,
0.1690023243,
-0.3247855604,
-0.3248513937,
-0.1845351011,
-0.5199321508,
0.3704513013,
0.3569814563,
-0.7203994989,
0.3825015128,
0.7509758472,
0.1838501394,
-0.8506801128,
-0.5983073115,
0.0817868933,
-0.2970877588,
-0.2239395678,
0.3885858357,
-0.236743927,
-0.5296293497,
0.0459047332,
0.2584813535,
-0.0318251848,
0.0605244376,
0.7597506046,
0.2428457588,
0.073429212,
0.1815714985,
0.2306000292,
-0.0067437007,
-0.0272601042,
-0.374129504,
0.219243899,
-0.0481112748,
-0.0667033643,
-0.6884067059,
0.3278518319,
0.5093106627,
-0.0166741442,
0.6450215578,
0.1061359644,
-0.4117843509,
0.0564917997,
-0.5543806553,
-0.35532704,
-0.3449270725,
-0.1383116692,
-0.2269561142,
-0.5142862797,
0.4163809717,
-0.0079175029,
0.4385426044,
0.4614376128,
0.4844334424,
-0.0371244475,
0.8274441361,
0.6212803125,
-0.534252882,
0.4878915846,
-0.3157519698,
0.0587825552,
-0.6626189947,
-0.1540999413,
-0.9725147486,
-0.5342066884,
-0.6810851693,
0.3420927525,
0.3581999242,
0.156359002,
-0.0912781805,
0.220299229,
-0.5760474205,
0.5745227337,
0.9286795855,
0.5350297689,
0.1552588195,
-0.1062848642,
0.0860203877,
0.1008137912,
-0.2574757934,
-0.6579911709,
1.3018088341,
-0.1462021172,
0.4913220406,
0.1311484724,
0.848808825,
0.4542444646,
0.4031721056,
-0.8872010112,
0.2691597044,
-0.1711253077,
-0.4798782468,
-0.3893915713,
-0.3630446196,
-0.6786580682,
-0.077260986,
-0.752635777,
-0.6260702014,
0.3435290456,
0.4454303682,
-0.5479751229,
0.2312117964,
-0.6190754771,
0.5713133216,
0.0985615849,
-0.1514761448,
-0.4650501013,
-0.7617917657,
0.4365091026,
0.0713237375,
-0.0422807671,
0.0563190319,
0.1591426283,
0.7429532409,
-0.5293143988,
0.8567439914,
-0.0801220387,
0.1758011431,
0.1257325858,
-0.1919399202,
0.3994030356,
0.2743545771,
-0.3314808607,
0.0761718228,
0.1737933159,
-0.1895083189,
-0.8491150737,
0.7490792274,
-1.1266620159,
-0.7637850046,
-0.1654611081,
-0.168633759,
-0.0981544256,
0.0101835569,
0.3941631913,
0.6277834177,
-0.1735049635,
0.1855709851,
0.2563411295,
-0.0878799334,
0.1652352065,
0.1020764783,
0.1263921857,
-0.5300278664,
0.59215343,
0.0687768012,
-0.2380853593,
0.4465895891,
0.3554964066,
-0.2943890691,
-0.619604826,
-0.5403002501,
0.1303682178,
-0.500195384,
-0.2243276238,
-0.3123381734,
0.0226917695,
-0.4990631938,
0.0852391273,
-0.0613195822,
-0.8319134116,
-0.4260450304,
-0.0228213817,
0.0920579955,
0.6682544351,
-0.2130600512,
0.1828045696,
-0.4771161973,
0.5771259665,
0.2892451286,
0.2789045572,
-0.2671094239,
-0.5354887843,
0.105876565,
0.3056544363,
-0.1029563174,
-0.7861792445,
0.0586350895,
0.2688068748,
0.4539690316,
0.3962222636,
0.5847049952,
0.7854380608,
-0.2150828242,
0.7872577906,
-0.2276080549,
-0.8483757973,
0.480479151,
0.1131553203,
-0.1605372876,
0.9228134751,
0.2647763193,
-0.4474393427,
-0.2693314552,
-0.5294371247,
-0.3825462461,
0.8443183899,
0.2825457454,
0.2822105885,
0.1949931532,
1.0660096407,
0.3999359012,
0.1439666301,
-0.659318924,
-0.1860416979,
-0.3300489783,
-0.4437998831,
0.1124344915,
-0.1502382755,
-0.3012549579,
-0.3079338372,
0.9571287036,
-0.2807379067,
0.2571692169,
0.3156321645,
-0.0851505995,
-0.0952534825,
0.3012834787,
0.6252825856,
0.3994995952,
-0.1634303033,
0.0402240679,
-0.0755069032,
-0.373513937,
0.0593260191,
0.3164244592,
-0.5066654086,
-0.4367117286,
0.1817809343,
0.6593131423,
-0.1702952832,
-0.4667263925,
0.6197273135,
-0.3875665665,
0.116856277,
-0.5985609889,
-0.0450052842,
-0.6285755634,
0.1441846341,
0.2993396223,
0.3392070234,
0.4087658525,
-0.5583924651,
0.1046155468,
0.5914815068,
-0.4419653714,
-0.564555347,
0.5158866048,
0.4123183489,
-0.175326854,
0.8346056342,
0.0332861878,
-0.5757394433,
0.4225191772,
0.0952646285,
0.8337614536,
0.2455556095,
0.0685718432,
0.5296353698,
0.3545491397,
-0.0934994221,
0.0049407315,
-0.3487418592,
-0.8334314823,
-0.1814342886,
-0.2437498719,
-0.4093969762,
0.2800655961,
-0.6717215776,
0.5401852131,
-0.6235770583,
-0.209751457,
0.0933124498,
0.1352142394,
-0.5539977551,
0.0616338477,
0.1265575141,
0.4250685871,
-0.6595986485,
0.746491909,
0.4683760405,
-0.5682310462,
-0.7236642838,
0.1818695068,
0.2562372386,
-0.8155609369,
0.3993828893,
0.0736866817,
-0.0039129695,
-0.2937697172,
-1.0595126152,
-0.2746314108,
0.6021495461,
0.5539773703,
-0.4495166838,
-0.1345505863,
0.1073236167,
0.4951707721,
-0.209837541,
0.3638876677,
0.7196228504,
0.4646203518,
-0.2196487933,
-0.9379322529,
0.1400220692,
-0.3752391934,
-0.3323452473,
0.2484124601,
-0.642793119,
0.4206466079,
-0.1502620727,
-0.1364035457,
0.3703977168,
0.6688728333,
-0.1434226781,
0.086958155,
0.8181346655,
0.5399773717,
0.7136698365,
-0.1403406113,
1.053842783,
-0.311491102,
0.1607253402,
1.0370053053,
0.040720012,
0.7220214009,
0.5897386074,
0.153020218,
0.3837269843,
0.4755385816,
0.0679319501,
0.3440758884,
0.2132860422,
0.0810910538,
-0.1223379001,
-0.3096171618,
-0.2033770978,
0.621442616,
0.1798496693,
-0.353163451,
0.3351989985,
-0.2488901317,
0.0331882089,
0.1890193075,
-0.1828552634,
1.0797444582,
-0.2467640638,
-1.0331604481,
0.3485304415,
-0.0500805378,
0.6110673547,
-0.2469080687,
-0.4106216729,
-0.3201907873,
0.0930638462,
-0.279112339,
-0.6549732685,
0.1962740421,
-0.1694649011,
-0.2173124105,
-0.0247841068,
0.3959670067,
-0.4355855584,
-0.2126956284,
-0.2640274763,
-0.084243916,
0.0286899954,
-0.0271121059,
-0.6163591743,
-0.0211117659,
0.1016755775,
-0.0053160237,
-0.1520670503,
0.1998801082,
-0.1677215844,
0.3559984267,
0.7146847248,
0.1258502454,
-0.4168942869,
-0.1351523101,
1.0169386864,
-0.4636589289,
-0.5923677087,
-0.8390219212,
0.277138114,
-0.3491289616,
-0.5564154983,
0.3049487472,
0.4682129025,
0.7919337749,
0.1952464432,
0.8039738536,
-0.0927056074,
0.4228419363,
-0.7015629411,
0.7166244984,
-0.2936992645,
0.1738653481,
-0.3139934242,
-0.6561260819,
-0.2837900817,
0.3807762861,
-0.2826187611,
-0.3260320425,
0.2209657431,
0.8360170722,
-0.0697831959,
0.3443694115,
-0.043673493,
0.031323038,
0.4019704461,
0.3220122755,
0.857032001,
-0.4519109726,
0.5525271297,
-0.5376853347,
-0.3401418924,
-0.1293986291,
-0.7406740785,
-0.9514015317,
-1.0503900051,
-0.2401459068,
-0.5219179988,
-0.1321855187,
1.4573301077,
0.9675512314,
-0.9211964011,
-0.1398667842,
0.0438561141,
0.0089392513,
-0.1672831029,
-0.2159913182,
0.4169619083,
0.0510562472,
-0.7720268965,
0.0753966495,
-0.0151702398,
0.1005902514,
-0.2112824023,
-0.2178207487,
0.1183166653,
0.2230413407,
0.126519829,
0.5074737072,
-0.9045496583,
-0.6395452619,
-0.4168995619,
0.0431480482,
0.2290560156,
1.2418069839,
-0.8999011517,
0.518224597,
0.5798531771,
0.7027109265,
0.4302034378,
0.2205816209,
0.7668187618,
-0.5166070461,
0.4789482057,
0.2066601962,
0.3508825302,
0.3641949892,
-0.5605102777,
0.5145264864,
0.1331675053,
-0.5157921314,
-0.7609632611,
0.1445298195,
-0.8694549799,
-0.0160527825,
1.02997756,
-0.038207259,
-0.3012082875,
0.0179046448,
-0.7021530271,
0.2738851309,
-0.6032601595,
1.2099798918,
0.6690236926,
-0.1864694208,
-0.140232861,
0.0509917103,
0.8930381536,
0.2477486879,
-0.7864352465,
0.0812710524,
0.6647029519,
-0.0641708449,
0.1185521781,
0.4661561847,
-0.0743192062,
0.1185551509,
-0.3097795546,
-0.0866953507,
-0.0520963445,
-0.112117663,
-0.6044526696,
0.0465840697,
0.0301764384,
-0.1541366279
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00697v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00697v2
|
Comprehensive Evaluation of Large Language Models for Topic Modeling
| 2024-06-02T10:25:02 | 2024-06-25T08:42:53 |
Tomoki Doi, Masaru Isonuma, Hitomi Yanaka
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent work utilizes Large Language Models (LLMs) for topic modeling,
generating comprehensible topic labels for given documents. However, their
performance has mainly been evaluated qualitatively, and there remains room for
quantitative investigation of their capabilities. In this paper, we
quantitatively evaluate LLMs from multiple perspectives: the quality of topics,
the impact of LLM-specific concerns, such as hallucination and shortcuts for
limited documents, and LLMs' controllability of topic categories via prompts.
Our findings show that LLMs can identify coherent and diverse topics with few
hallucinations but may take shortcuts by focusing only on parts of documents.
We also found that their controllability is limited.
|
[
-0.4674111009,
-0.9801297784,
0.9476117492,
0.3479107618,
-0.2492894083,
0.0878201872,
-0.4895965457,
-0.3076121211,
0.304107517,
0.6807174683,
-0.2695757747,
-0.6599140167,
-0.8196300864,
0.0825417787,
-0.7223796844,
0.7678605914,
-0.023290243,
0.0942880064,
-0.3068700135,
0.0266560279,
-0.4724519849,
-0.6240600348,
-0.5202508569,
-0.3657671213,
0.6959009767,
0.2471527159,
0.6954188347,
0.4250752926,
0.6576703191,
0.330581516,
-0.5771684647,
-0.2177323699,
-0.6046631932,
0.2652884424,
-0.3796387315,
-0.3023056686,
-0.3227971494,
0.0162707362,
1.0365513563,
0.9561495185,
-0.1027492806,
-0.0879849195,
0.2252924442,
0.2768765092,
-0.3678129613,
-0.2333610207,
-0.6116473675,
-0.0554239191,
-0.124857828,
-0.1915232092,
-0.4521681964,
-0.3299319744,
0.4722963274,
-0.1961927712,
0.0605222322,
-0.0290860701,
0.6968705654,
0.1296052933,
-0.5683966279,
-0.6123697162,
-0.7090563178,
0.955390811,
-0.6532994509,
0.420948267,
0.3892519772,
0.2277800143,
-0.082168296,
-0.6449858546,
-0.2055084556,
-0.4939061403,
-0.0016780125,
-0.1580120325,
-0.1747558713,
0.0077213338,
0.3741540015,
0.3983652592,
-0.6671113372,
0.4057739973,
-0.1953724474,
-0.319334358,
0.5078638196,
0.5486376286,
0.2572021484,
-0.2049336284,
-0.0783597305,
0.2576568723,
-0.5381829739,
-0.219363004,
0.2691542506,
0.1654682457,
-0.0399620123,
0.7906314135,
-0.2255650759,
0.8414287567,
-0.2042285055,
-0.5302025676,
-0.0812830478,
-0.3038358092,
-0.1763461679,
-0.2990931869,
0.6891322136,
0.1862620413,
-0.1013853326,
-0.450722903,
-0.1976661682,
-0.2322694808,
0.3377700746,
-0.8794354796,
0.0897566751,
0.5137101412,
-0.6747376919,
-0.0584579296,
-0.1604411453,
-0.6652332544,
-0.6213290095,
-0.4566378593,
0.3287835121,
-0.325162977,
-0.1474181116,
0.1686368734,
-0.0855881572,
0.2304140925,
0.6463899612,
-0.6086027026,
0.2563461661,
1.0414930582,
1.0920392275,
-0.6805599928,
-0.3563405573,
-0.3607932031,
-0.0287765469,
-0.340885371,
0.8128876686,
-0.7356737852,
-0.5381767154,
0.0221935548,
0.0409897342,
0.1578176916,
-0.6196183562,
0.4330520034,
-0.5709602833,
0.0543350577,
-0.3968458176,
-0.727240622,
-0.0185132455,
0.3943352103,
-0.726521194,
0.4950377047,
-0.0464940146,
-0.7696659565,
0.2388638407,
-0.1885050088,
-0.3573543131,
-0.0964579284,
-0.2240219116,
-0.0238585901,
0.206583634,
-0.3220683336,
0.5270505548,
-0.564429462,
0.7481057048,
-0.2253028303,
-0.3670015335,
0.6091180444,
-0.5061036348,
0.5088477135,
0.2109855413,
-0.1165359467,
0.5283091068,
-0.7143937349,
-0.2685762346,
-0.1483283192,
-0.2978798747,
-0.3759173751,
0.0115546519,
0.0454912633,
0.1544483304,
0.3390415609,
-0.0472349524,
0.3015409708,
-0.2564817369,
0.3364432752,
0.5979428887,
0.1637606472,
0.3986694217,
-0.2772857845,
0.6719146967,
-0.1405528039,
-0.0306543857,
-0.1504963189,
-0.4170136154,
-0.7987841368,
-0.4459581375,
0.3247340322,
0.282105267,
-0.615904808,
0.5025454164,
0.0730223954,
-0.6295865178,
0.0123552792,
-0.0093851928,
0.3093698919,
0.128145963,
-0.0581988916,
-0.316321373,
-0.0944459364,
-0.942042768,
-0.0192343462,
-0.0406209603,
-0.0827340707,
0.2890262306,
0.6649748683,
-0.175009504,
0.6116443276,
-0.4542568624,
0.1131396815,
-0.2908947766,
0.3296206892,
0.1630572528,
0.2036887854,
0.3045725226,
-0.5037697554,
-0.3262628019,
-0.3117649853,
-0.6157147288,
-0.1706033498,
-0.2451798618,
-0.1192395538,
0.0332548171,
0.4275588989,
-0.7307244539,
0.1237844154,
0.3423225582,
-0.4308609366,
0.6114506125,
-0.1422680467,
-0.0004661823,
-0.9569000006,
0.0568632223,
0.1706648171,
-0.0529995859,
-0.6532688141,
0.0856379569,
-0.0204214472,
-0.2804767787,
-0.4912754595,
0.7617459893,
-0.4393833876,
-0.2831878066,
-0.5152595639,
0.3638270795,
-0.0304798838,
0.0813419372,
0.2735278904,
0.5533858538,
0.6540095806,
-0.576779604,
0.2898887396,
0.0156413559,
-0.5178717375,
0.3098810315,
-0.71145612,
0.1693992317,
-0.1197679266,
0.1058532,
-0.9579705596,
-0.2347463518,
0.0712687001,
-0.0696086437,
0.4629987478,
0.1285382062,
-0.5349072814,
-0.1164176539,
-0.3856444955,
0.1739085764,
0.2203072906,
-0.1528657675,
0.4298880398,
0.4126675725,
-0.4399399459,
-0.3008871675,
-0.2649370432,
0.270453155,
-0.4311760962,
-0.3459020853,
0.2013154775,
-0.1428150982,
-0.6340897679,
-0.0630797297,
0.0160447471,
-0.0756285936,
0.3185571134,
0.3417071402,
0.0313292481,
-0.0096665807,
0.3223995268,
0.026313981,
-0.0710211769,
0.0682883039,
-0.028768111,
0.8353146911,
-0.009344101,
-0.4132376909,
-0.2907978594,
0.4203671813,
0.5587875843,
-0.2679079175,
0.736443162,
0.2465827763,
-0.4492220283,
-0.1640446335,
-0.6764248013,
-0.1608575135,
-0.3924119174,
0.6344487667,
-0.4107493162,
-1.2524645329,
0.6135265231,
-0.0965443701,
-0.1394820064,
0.4840272367,
0.8569754362,
0.1888613701,
0.6587764025,
0.6541273594,
-0.1813142002,
0.1911606789,
-0.2253728658,
0.1425115764,
-0.6651319861,
-0.4148716629,
-0.9361851215,
-0.0363915786,
-0.6196312308,
-0.5406330824,
0.0294659585,
0.2955998182,
-0.0326812714,
-0.0462797247,
-0.370221734,
0.3707757294,
0.266258359,
-0.0998674929,
0.3480648696,
-0.0669148862,
0.1403661817,
-0.1510822624,
-0.4385170639,
-1.0864412785,
0.906521976,
0.7100815177,
1.0176758766,
-0.0173553117,
0.5075782537,
0.1548490971,
0.4191088974,
-1.0018163919,
0.6755430698,
-0.1977989823,
-0.6398466825,
-0.6343891025,
-0.4153475761,
-0.7662094831,
0.4296417236,
-0.0639175028,
-1.0700689554,
0.1262906939,
-0.2645229101,
-0.2861169577,
0.1705104709,
-0.2392237186,
0.7214372158,
-0.4250974953,
-0.3527558148,
-0.3565810025,
-0.235050872,
0.4947659969,
-0.5546984673,
0.0167958215,
-0.2350822389,
-0.2490742356,
0.9011301994,
-0.0847956091,
0.8715263009,
0.1399662197,
-0.494877696,
0.2787561417,
0.0875182226,
0.1618726254,
0.1842658818,
-0.2202943414,
0.2669562995,
0.0132019464,
-0.1446366161,
-0.5111007094,
0.851467073,
-0.6794880629,
-0.8906267285,
-0.3729966581,
-0.6133304834,
-0.38029778,
0.2466121614,
0.0621975884,
0.3846462071,
-0.4493950903,
0.3367341161,
0.740419805,
-0.763176918,
0.2884548008,
0.5955976844,
-0.6044419408,
-0.3572771251,
0.9181964993,
0.2216831148,
0.140689075,
0.401429683,
0.1716659814,
-0.3505287766,
-0.8100221157,
-0.0405178554,
0.4420930445,
-0.789429605,
0.1004867032,
-0.8279095292,
-0.2359340489,
-0.2038520575,
-0.0080037434,
-0.2467332631,
-0.3589181602,
-0.5196038485,
-0.0109919533,
-0.0597732477,
0.8239331841,
0.2100015283,
0.393260777,
-0.7116781473,
0.4887346625,
0.2114361078,
0.374607414,
0.1476141065,
-0.702547133,
-0.1866818368,
-0.2867658734,
-0.3811784983,
-1.017889142,
0.3037521839,
-0.1550240368,
0.715151906,
0.5645232201,
-0.1375645697,
0.283523798,
-0.3604606986,
0.8402551413,
0.1067087203,
-1.0782411098,
0.4504241049,
-0.2464654148,
0.2551434934,
0.3744760454,
0.7747399807,
-0.4110716879,
-0.5276638269,
-0.2533045411,
-0.6951244473,
0.5491986871,
0.0782068223,
0.2673097849,
-0.0025463609,
0.3431325257,
0.3432579339,
0.3522615731,
-0.4835963249,
-0.133077845,
0.1412313133,
0.1412487924,
-0.2114310861,
-0.8810827732,
-0.154446274,
-0.0885829553,
0.3431217372,
0.1595782638,
0.1101905629,
-0.1414850652,
-0.0311017707,
0.013884753,
0.4885249138,
0.8764057159,
1.0988488197,
-0.3172025084,
0.2636464834,
0.103903085,
-0.2285496145,
0.3457217515,
-0.046983555,
-0.2173137367,
0.2435071021,
0.6379173398,
0.9018937349,
-0.0222727545,
-0.6819068193,
0.1601373404,
-0.0391510464,
-0.2108946741,
0.0467809103,
-0.0510184802,
0.3124927878,
0.3842319548,
0.2261851132,
-0.5657871366,
0.1397473067,
-0.7658134103,
0.0370056368,
0.5206185579,
-0.2809545696,
-0.1692817509,
0.4092846215,
0.0399877317,
-0.2342386544,
0.4746694565,
-0.0196784437,
-0.5129226446,
0.7458437681,
0.4875637889,
0.9837266207,
-0.1102977917,
0.2986790538,
0.2167662829,
0.4021272659,
-0.1614689827,
0.2257360071,
0.0598676056,
-0.5993434191,
-0.5984509587,
-0.7719243765,
-0.7357441187,
0.4107811749,
-0.6789498329,
0.1718707681,
-0.2724780738,
-0.3761391342,
0.1540583819,
0.0758742467,
-0.3189446628,
0.3297971487,
-0.0189525187,
0.9591107965,
-0.6738734841,
0.9585809112,
0.5983073115,
-0.1198921353,
-0.455001533,
0.2868289053,
-0.2141515464,
-0.2740655243,
0.8503360152,
-0.0233068131,
0.0826491863,
-0.3464875519,
-0.4406331778,
-0.8904076219,
0.8334704041,
0.2166481465,
-0.8035809398,
-0.0476240888,
0.3359000385,
0.6932600737,
-0.1681171358,
0.2316611111,
0.4359258413,
0.4952529669,
0.1621922106,
-0.9259648323,
0.0395483598,
0.1045171246,
0.1522015184,
0.0265193507,
-0.7030805349,
0.744146347,
0.0783028454,
-0.0437329039,
0.0937278047,
0.6103235483,
0.4121649563,
0.4014847279,
0.2271831632,
0.3271538317,
0.8628970981,
-0.088916935,
1.0551095009,
-0.3773150742,
0.346555531,
1.0985947847,
-0.6271516681,
0.6613537669,
0.4577966034,
-0.1126418263,
-0.1959860176,
0.7604106665,
0.0594560765,
0.6040616632,
0.5971319675,
-0.0133091044,
-0.2636388838,
-0.3130472302,
-0.4719788134,
0.2950779796,
0.50206393,
-0.3783835471,
-0.0760722831,
0.1844472289,
-0.050143972,
-0.1821295768,
-0.2009412348,
0.7181348205,
0.3113126159,
-0.5000395179,
0.3857896924,
0.3521136642,
0.5368655324,
-0.5343202353,
0.0423413031,
-0.4755871892,
-0.2806937397,
-0.0024215791,
-0.8247300982,
0.4199695885,
0.2430618405,
-0.0847825035,
-0.2111301422,
0.9543024302,
-0.2284370661,
-0.5313521028,
0.2691068947,
0.5057758689,
0.3557831943,
-0.1637625098,
-0.4024712145,
0.6155706644,
-0.1211850867,
-0.5319448709,
0.4709073901,
0.658408165,
-0.2243914604,
0.7544748783,
0.1810664237,
0.3058107495,
-0.1394855231,
0.2218457162,
0.8207861781,
-0.9414166808,
-0.1401861608,
-0.8707594275,
0.2286768854,
0.0748523176,
-0.3101899624,
0.9439414144,
0.6334297061,
0.6886519194,
-0.0333483852,
0.6295553446,
0.282773912,
0.442407161,
-0.7079649568,
0.8047626019,
-0.6373651028,
0.5187236071,
-0.3328106701,
-1.2142183781,
-0.3021157682,
0.5379778743,
-0.5385801792,
0.0728330016,
0.7571143508,
0.6709875464,
0.1646076441,
-0.1365558505,
0.735317409,
0.2412118614,
0.2425967157,
0.2876615226,
1.4040666819,
0.2626925409,
0.1161132678,
-0.3595525622,
-0.0557824634,
-0.2544784546,
-0.7877544761,
-1.1033531427,
-0.5015611053,
-0.4656981528,
-0.239950344,
-0.0312279109,
0.5112997293,
0.4826541245,
-0.7022174001,
-0.4288004041,
0.3198827803,
0.4292832017,
0.3907656372,
-0.1947942823,
0.5363628268,
-0.1006368697,
-0.6620802283,
0.2176164538,
0.4933618605,
0.0413600989,
-0.7525160909,
-0.0960522145,
0.1313030869,
0.1352844238,
0.7951239347,
-0.1385217756,
-1.0456293821,
-0.0224958379,
0.0442243628,
-0.4657596052,
-0.1884964854,
1.0819752216,
-0.1343098581,
0.2112454772,
0.707115531,
0.5555112958,
0.4369414151,
-0.0192015469,
0.2614596486,
-0.1924114227,
0.1741133928,
0.2266437411,
0.391468972,
0.1575345248,
-0.1412039101,
0.3527061343,
-0.1000490189,
-0.5310257673,
-0.8684337139,
0.054390002,
-1.0303387642,
-0.6715014577,
1.4026056528,
-0.1169641241,
-0.0126249231,
-0.0484640524,
-0.3603751361,
0.0870312527,
-0.1393197626,
0.7057195902,
1.00692904,
-0.048847463,
-0.217991814,
-0.7286818027,
0.1490858346,
0.3163473308,
-0.926451385,
-0.1098805442,
0.7739555836,
0.1713708788,
0.1629094929,
0.6612153649,
-0.0492322668,
-0.248056531,
-0.1930650324,
-0.037012618,
0.3371284604,
-0.6725762486,
-0.6762316227,
0.3348261416,
0.5873604417,
0.3279693425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00684v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00684v1
|
Deciphering Oracle Bone Language with Diffusion Models
| 2024-06-02T09:42:23 | 2024-06-02T09:42:23 |
Haisu Guan, Huanxin Yang, Xinyu Wang, Shengwei Han, Yongge Liu, Lianwen Jin, Xiang Bai, Yuliang Liu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Originating from China's Shang Dynasty approximately 3,000 years ago, the
Oracle Bone Script (OBS) is a cornerstone in the annals of linguistic history,
predating many established writing systems. Despite the discovery of thousands
of inscriptions, a vast expanse of OBS remains undeciphered, casting a veil of
mystery over this ancient language. The emergence of modern AI technologies
presents a novel frontier for OBS decipherment, challenging traditional NLP
methods that rely heavily on large textual corpora, a luxury not afforded by
historical languages. This paper introduces a novel approach by adopting image
generation techniques, specifically through the development of Oracle Bone
Script Decipher (OBSD). Utilizing a conditional diffusion-based strategy, OBSD
generates vital clues for decipherment, charting a new course for AI-assisted
analysis of ancient languages. To validate its efficacy, extensive experiments
were conducted on an oracle bone script dataset, with quantitative results
demonstrating the effectiveness of OBSD. Code and decipherment results will be
made available at https://github.com/guanhaisu/OBSD.
|
[
-0.1297660917,
-1.0111944675,
0.6838414669,
0.2178412229,
-0.4811496437,
-0.0642765313,
-0.1488008946,
-0.6153726578,
0.3278314173,
0.7847778797,
-0.4160986245,
-0.8363417983,
-0.4683033526,
0.0923359767,
-0.3903229237,
0.3582150638,
0.1982219368,
-0.1550416797,
0.1574652493,
-0.1316796392,
-0.2158391178,
0.1982020289,
-0.7393248677,
-0.4090177715,
-0.486517638,
0.0268233493,
0.7983407974,
1.5834392309,
0.2904725373,
0.3102594912,
-0.1755847335,
0.1705904156,
0.0196413789,
0.034013588,
0.1644685119,
-0.6359394193,
-0.3404300213,
-0.2502725124,
0.5826798081,
1.063786149,
-0.3346874416,
-0.0707959905,
-0.3429138064,
0.819552362,
-0.4437608421,
0.3181800246,
-0.7059780955,
0.0903357044,
-0.6295901537,
-0.0832884014,
-0.7097957134,
-0.4077855051,
0.3680123091,
-0.6546322703,
0.1007794812,
-0.2314741015,
0.867767036,
0.4433211684,
-0.0626824275,
-0.462936908,
-0.7596465945,
0.7045271993,
-0.6225244999,
0.1878673583,
0.7355275154,
0.1364605278,
-0.0507654883,
-0.642690599,
-0.3966536522,
-0.4699723721,
0.1365128905,
-0.1949103028,
-0.278456986,
-0.1345616281,
-0.1203176603,
0.3588405848,
-0.6999856234,
0.0661742464,
-0.4680708349,
-0.4027821124,
0.5741237402,
0.0194092337,
0.4423842728,
-0.2622754872,
-0.3950767219,
0.0075513222,
-0.8709148765,
-0.2472747117,
0.1597040743,
0.0886344388,
-0.0853231177,
0.6581513882,
-0.0064179567,
0.987678051,
0.1360113621,
-0.5232981443,
0.4370830953,
0.0150420219,
-0.1700618267,
0.0686549246,
0.5525865555,
0.2406537235,
0.151640594,
-0.2127275914,
0.0311356913,
0.34975335,
0.0134991072,
-0.5666351914,
-0.3894568682,
0.2045453787,
-0.9327213764,
-0.0998469964,
-0.3373932838,
-0.8314918876,
-0.712721467,
0.0273620673,
0.1067467183,
-0.8399093747,
-0.7424985766,
0.3108943105,
-0.306155026,
0.5681493878,
0.2886526287,
-0.7964782119,
0.207858935,
0.5109035969,
0.7397579551,
-0.1552076191,
-0.0843862742,
-0.0272002034,
0.2452041507,
-0.6297766566,
1.0148804188,
-0.6233102679,
-0.3730210364,
0.08279223,
-0.3887230754,
0.2332888395,
-1.0677728653,
0.1539580524,
-0.3211516142,
-0.3556725383,
0.2292213887,
-0.4002103806,
-0.2069975436,
-0.1518836915,
-0.7194485664,
0.9536942244,
-0.0274376124,
-0.3933836222,
0.4670008123,
-0.4577259421,
-0.5302819014,
0.4313354492,
-0.6122857332,
-0.1312075108,
0.0459635332,
0.0673693568,
0.2945025861,
-0.3108738959,
-0.0295690242,
-0.0987147167,
-0.0271803159,
-0.2386014909,
-0.3134466708,
0.706856966,
0.4393879473,
-0.564268589,
-0.4624014497,
-0.9417885542,
0.0178565904,
0.2717187405,
-0.0950304344,
-0.8038355708,
0.2423006445,
-0.4273628592,
-0.2932090461,
0.218987897,
-0.7110354304,
0.2553959787,
-0.6748332977,
0.1798477918,
0.6170868278,
-0.1375249177,
0.6237917542,
0.1066270471,
0.3705364466,
-0.2056432813,
-0.0944982171,
-0.5199990273,
-0.7480456233,
-0.4950267971,
-0.4172127247,
-0.0766608268,
0.5149754286,
-1.1437048912,
0.1916322261,
-0.0560348853,
-0.4537365139,
-0.9608191252,
0.113366738,
0.4682316482,
0.4155893326,
0.2648414075,
-0.2443712652,
-0.3127228022,
-0.9246413708,
0.1452391744,
-0.6494306326,
0.0162133537,
0.2429704517,
0.0729340464,
-0.1321719885,
1.0307180882,
-0.7715662122,
-0.2528133988,
-0.2831841409,
0.2753683925,
0.1609382778,
0.3335067332,
0.7051594853,
-0.7381390333,
-0.3690190613,
0.3794066906,
-0.8061125875,
-0.4038843513,
-0.0980014056,
-0.0176700298,
0.3537902534,
0.9357257485,
-0.2083352357,
0.8257526755,
0.5504985452,
-0.1587257683,
0.5126948953,
-0.3253979683,
-0.2921296358,
-0.8895325661,
0.2859853506,
-0.1617614925,
0.1276055872,
-0.5420275331,
-0.0019930098,
-0.0895622,
0.0775544271,
-0.4392975867,
0.6294221282,
-0.8519313931,
-0.0617514141,
-0.5018657446,
0.1128953323,
-0.5537899733,
0.1759352237,
0.7648093104,
0.3937751949,
0.8047578335,
-0.5732024312,
0.0397715457,
0.2711698413,
-0.2996674478,
0.3722417355,
-0.4785791636,
0.0883121267,
-0.1422872543,
-0.0390580557,
-0.8180236816,
0.1081826091,
0.1384545118,
-0.3079662621,
0.1821288019,
-0.4584155977,
-0.1263858229,
-0.1593070626,
-0.2054363936,
0.3081133068,
0.6764903665,
-0.3865809441,
0.9181156158,
0.6997317672,
-0.110017769,
-0.7698004246,
-0.675845921,
0.0520361885,
-0.0176901706,
-0.9938053489,
0.3566987216,
0.0072389483,
-0.4885363281,
0.1228930354,
-0.1123284474,
-0.369359076,
-0.0874082819,
0.3476526141,
0.2624780834,
-0.6720462441,
-0.2733978629,
0.1316751987,
-0.3721963167,
-0.0024827989,
-0.4038784206,
0.8059700131,
0.0144259054,
-0.2902347147,
-0.5366567969,
0.1294092685,
0.477063179,
-0.1431496143,
0.5297971368,
0.4120903611,
-0.3059785664,
-0.4835734963,
-0.6161903739,
0.1732528508,
-0.4884390831,
0.2608191371,
-0.2108452767,
-0.1287901998,
0.4803032279,
-0.724542439,
-0.0979360938,
0.4733381569,
0.5380174518,
0.3389546573,
0.6593742967,
0.7987718582,
-0.0485763885,
0.4077982903,
-0.6164457798,
-0.3043420911,
-0.6678179502,
-0.3667805195,
-0.3397590816,
0.0778773054,
-0.2776062489,
-0.3717909157,
0.1367488503,
-0.0011475326,
0.3808451295,
0.3312189579,
-0.284822613,
0.6358696818,
0.2938017547,
0.1153556928,
0.2560058832,
-0.0862864256,
-0.2745197117,
0.1732667089,
-0.1147883087,
-0.5220650434,
0.9978894591,
0.163703084,
1.0395306349,
-0.0333228968,
0.7451599836,
0.409681499,
0.1124443635,
-0.4272954464,
0.8527988195,
-0.5405694842,
-0.298574537,
-0.1817023307,
-0.0830524489,
-1.1529819965,
0.2365876287,
-0.067866005,
-0.7209030986,
0.3699486852,
0.2189770639,
-0.3378497064,
0.2227231413,
-0.8810612559,
0.7135218382,
-0.0600594729,
-0.083664827,
0.0440826416,
-0.9727434516,
0.2752680182,
0.0969783291,
0.2261125594,
0.0197443161,
-0.0125766275,
0.5148155689,
-0.5353655219,
1.0068738461,
-0.2810986042,
-0.2511810958,
0.5310664773,
0.3643235862,
0.1774603426,
-0.0926764235,
-0.4175119996,
0.1107267886,
-0.2720692456,
-0.3208675086,
-0.0367296003,
0.5336067677,
-0.4991067648,
-0.2200840414,
-0.2071831524,
-0.2603020966,
0.3699645996,
0.408460319,
0.254463017,
0.3059362173,
-0.4217808843,
-0.1455157697,
0.6637166142,
-0.4028323591,
0.535570085,
0.6832398176,
-0.2908141911,
-0.2271515876,
0.9252399802,
-0.1789249778,
0.3900506496,
0.3257290721,
0.2268925607,
-0.1539397985,
-1.033085227,
-0.8185815811,
0.4877506495,
-0.5949367881,
-0.0420528762,
-0.2817255259,
0.0097584808,
-0.3471224606,
-0.1777109504,
-0.491725266,
-0.1519715637,
-0.1903893203,
-0.0925213322,
0.161042884,
0.9455360174,
-0.218171671,
0.3153690696,
-0.6095052361,
0.5171686411,
-0.0433296636,
0.080827564,
-0.0840716809,
-0.065187864,
-0.0418983288,
-0.018127976,
0.0772088096,
-1.0342086554,
0.7108844519,
0.3045704365,
0.6479712725,
0.7597666383,
-0.0828451216,
0.7171772718,
-0.6454679966,
0.8199980259,
-0.2037771046,
-0.8648295999,
0.7136228085,
-0.1693677008,
0.1075180918,
0.3728390038,
-0.0384905525,
-0.1634176373,
-0.5830928087,
-0.5485066175,
-1.1026325226,
0.7933853865,
0.0502537936,
-0.1020924747,
-0.2609567046,
0.6961277723,
0.5435281992,
-0.0303180758,
-0.5778896809,
-0.5998288989,
0.0253154412,
-0.1779981852,
0.4692558944,
0.1734237373,
0.3007382154,
0.2053413242,
0.247841835,
-0.0407792069,
0.1937587708,
0.0449110046,
-0.3773932457,
-0.0483347028,
-0.1894803792,
0.4432929158,
0.5355027318,
-0.2671323121,
0.210223332,
-0.2065858394,
-1.1413584948,
-0.2312458009,
0.0478253849,
-0.5357111692,
0.1580924392,
0.4582358301,
0.6547454,
-0.617349267,
-0.7786784768,
0.4186542928,
0.1341691166,
-0.0557098538,
-0.707277298,
-0.0894259065,
-0.0667010322,
0.2063714117,
0.8285927773,
0.2173580825,
0.0390232168,
-0.608943224,
0.2218900472,
0.5148812532,
-0.1111503243,
-0.4945363998,
0.578676939,
0.1189163029,
-0.2189512998,
0.6943622231,
-0.2340487689,
-0.1995211393,
0.7722812295,
0.6710446477,
0.8651794195,
-0.6035507917,
0.6335887313,
0.0736786425,
0.5630046725,
-0.2332625985,
0.3502787054,
0.0675892904,
-0.6002029181,
-0.4716488719,
-0.712104857,
-0.0562083833,
0.0637357682,
-0.5818930864,
0.2162764817,
-0.3226208985,
0.1276712865,
0.3507546782,
-0.4137660563,
-0.434412241,
0.2669509053,
0.4759549499,
0.8735327125,
-1.0861159563,
1.0760564804,
0.5426709652,
-0.4718193114,
-0.493367672,
0.1500706077,
0.1636087894,
-1.4317423105,
0.9370340109,
-0.0885166079,
-0.2903958857,
-0.0469103269,
-0.4967036545,
-0.6424731612,
1.1061779261,
0.5308942795,
0.2329520136,
-0.0448002107,
0.06316524,
0.7672185898,
-0.4094179273,
0.1578408331,
0.7177327275,
0.387886256,
0.2056205273,
-0.8494055867,
0.0500824824,
-0.331612289,
0.0092924964,
0.3806869686,
-0.0428059176,
0.839384377,
-0.4314087629,
-0.5399563909,
0.5579960346,
0.6415941715,
-0.072665602,
0.4473137856,
0.5543001294,
0.6084869504,
0.3889459074,
-0.02313211,
1.0483759642,
-0.0530953072,
-0.2014126331,
0.5300534368,
-0.4763251841,
0.988791883,
0.3050987124,
-0.077070944,
0.7999383807,
0.2375063449,
0.0993534029,
0.7553396821,
0.2339121997,
-0.1418563277,
-0.1026018411,
-0.1279905438,
-0.4550543129,
0.5490995646,
0.732878983,
-0.3975228667,
-0.2629481256,
0.1057405323,
0.1358502507,
0.0493978597,
-0.3038587868,
0.9290674329,
-0.1817629784,
-0.5526468158,
0.7372931242,
-0.1544074565,
0.5963360071,
-1.0134691,
-0.5271708965,
-0.2916663587,
0.423189342,
-0.1155980304,
-0.836702764,
0.5339671969,
-0.2028058171,
0.0561659411,
-0.0746416897,
0.5737908483,
-0.5238884091,
-0.1300903559,
0.3824846447,
0.4780207574,
0.415944159,
0.1708771586,
-0.5211730003,
0.2345280647,
0.2705363929,
0.0634220615,
0.075368233,
0.5375596881,
-0.1545172632,
0.7251483202,
0.6116071343,
0.4119029045,
0.1545722634,
-0.397806108,
0.6885809898,
-0.5226218104,
-0.4283084571,
-0.9000548124,
0.196429491,
-0.00042357,
-0.2481707633,
0.7339631915,
0.6127775311,
0.7126363516,
-0.207096532,
0.6916063428,
-0.3893292248,
0.4966455698,
-0.7295481563,
0.6634637713,
-0.4085637927,
0.4942634106,
-0.581469357,
-0.3943071663,
-0.3287494481,
0.7367374897,
-0.1443276405,
-0.2047011703,
0.8825829029,
0.6951032281,
0.2432727516,
-0.1315156519,
0.0712337717,
0.4261093438,
-0.0488233604,
0.1577724218,
0.6712369919,
-0.0327212624,
0.8919926882,
-0.2216543108,
-0.5817601085,
-0.0321899131,
-0.8079388142,
-0.5833030939,
-0.7294262648,
-0.3476437926,
-0.3233973384,
0.1982594579,
0.5888954997,
0.5056471825,
-0.5273982286,
-0.429538548,
-0.0512708724,
-0.1235204116,
-0.5739420056,
-0.1530035883,
0.9840191603,
0.219918415,
-0.7204161286,
0.7004612684,
0.6245102882,
0.1005596519,
-0.1361607611,
-0.0194727909,
-0.1967041492,
-0.0710034072,
0.4089090824,
0.7835956812,
-0.9014434814,
0.0772321373,
0.2879303992,
0.0618112162,
0.0290642455,
0.799495399,
-0.979722023,
0.6150332689,
0.5095381141,
0.5288076401,
0.3962737024,
0.0137279704,
0.5988547206,
-0.677882731,
0.501709044,
0.2125882953,
0.2911000252,
0.1860937327,
-0.1018284112,
0.6478474736,
0.3448495567,
-0.188042298,
-0.6344179511,
0.2898331285,
-1.1600420475,
-0.638228178,
1.125236392,
-0.0848101452,
-0.5640255213,
-0.5423826575,
-0.4958072901,
-0.1045760661,
-0.3013238609,
0.7165545225,
0.1292414367,
-0.2253105938,
0.0302800387,
-0.2819422185,
0.5834145546,
0.1811475605,
-0.723100841,
0.2312662452,
0.6004066467,
0.1022325754,
0.6405750513,
1.0366566181,
-0.2558646798,
0.3426533341,
0.2594681382,
0.252463758,
0.1016072705,
-0.0979630724,
-0.0907066092,
0.0508518778,
-0.00880164,
-0.3738405108
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00682v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00682v1
|
A lexicon obtained and validated by a data-driven approach for organic residues valorization in emerging and developing countries
| 2024-06-02T09:36:33 | 2024-06-02T09:36:33 |
Christiane Rakotomalala, Jean-Marie Paillat, Frédéric Feder, Angel Avadí, Laurent Thuriès, Marie-Liesse Vermeire, Jean-Michel Médoc, Tom Wassenaar, Caroline Hottelart, Lilou Kieffer, Elisa Ndjie, Mathieu Picart, Jorel Tchamgoue, Alvin Tulle, Laurine Valade, Annie Boyer, Marie-Christine Duchamp, Mathieu Roche
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
The text mining method presented in this paper was used for annotation of
terms related to biological transformation and valorization of organic residues
in agriculture in low and middle-income country. Specialized lexicon was
obtained through different steps: corpus and extraction of terms, annotation of
extracted terms, selection of relevant terms.
|
[
-0.2153463215,
-1.1126121283,
0.6513998508,
-0.4119884074,
-0.3556990325,
0.1923809648,
-0.205459103,
-0.2463345677,
0.6513697505,
0.9362517595,
-0.3605568707,
-0.9497635365,
-0.7117304206,
0.6120311618,
-0.4545921981,
1.1374349594,
-0.1293905824,
0.1418817639,
-0.2179158628,
-0.1557561457,
-0.0840315744,
-0.5584902167,
-0.5196118951,
0.0524161421,
0.3214458227,
0.3389557898,
0.5084625483,
0.6873766184,
0.4831175208,
0.2612176239,
-0.4076070786,
0.3281634152,
-0.2574238181,
-0.0112209516,
-0.402083993,
-0.4027156234,
-0.4893046319,
0.0304917917,
0.2733745873,
0.7658986449,
0.0194468983,
0.3939949572,
0.1439563036,
0.4428385198,
-0.4864704609,
0.0351959281,
-0.7139443755,
-0.2672774494,
-0.1415349394,
-0.4609291852,
-0.2395542264,
-0.6438109279,
-0.2696165442,
-0.4755941629,
0.1754181832,
-0.2440039814,
0.9089640975,
-0.051338613,
-0.4810682237,
-0.3829628229,
-0.6895294785,
0.886128962,
-0.3517099619,
-0.0200976022,
0.5671688914,
0.3443035483,
-0.1187545285,
-1.0308815241,
-0.2935561836,
0.0204475224,
-0.3016098738,
-0.2586210966,
0.4939215183,
0.3040530086,
-0.0034878843,
0.7807998657,
0.1953392625,
-0.2802954614,
-0.7743299007,
-0.3968223929,
0.4066396952,
0.1651979983,
0.5186942816,
-0.132605955,
-0.6660770178,
0.2253519148,
-0.8922003508,
0.3409903347,
0.4355372787,
0.5249979496,
0.3998737931,
0.9329917431,
-0.3037285805,
0.6596104503,
-0.1820556521,
-0.2255644351,
0.0918975174,
-1.0714149475,
-0.0805238634,
0.0450245254,
0.2596566677,
0.4850521684,
0.1557951123,
0.1651529819,
-0.6091814637,
0.3469298184,
0.1832487285,
-0.5709043741,
-0.0864230171,
0.1271590441,
-0.5751792789,
-0.5870577097,
0.1393801868,
-0.9566714764,
-0.0071885614,
-0.1641857624,
0.1146348789,
-0.1114288494,
-0.0508602709,
-0.2611167431,
-0.449885726,
0.0594855212,
0.1216296181,
-1.3051456213,
0.7178363204,
0.6690863371,
1.0416494608,
-0.3627850711,
0.2541922927,
0.0642605573,
0.1153286844,
-0.2052195966,
1.0301059484,
-0.7253781557,
-0.2509335577,
0.0569009148,
0.4339928925,
0.0256612077,
-0.5631586313,
0.5635008812,
-0.3161067665,
-0.2611735463,
-0.2120788693,
-0.3848291039,
-0.7004193664,
0.7346433997,
-0.7130862474,
1.0334501266,
0.5232863426,
-0.5497695804,
0.8522623181,
-0.4792152643,
-0.3333930671,
0.4743036032,
-0.0501817763,
0.1939519644,
0.0030519741,
-0.0168710724,
0.4234336317,
-0.1480679661,
0.4200391471,
0.0613491759,
-0.1335487366,
0.1396082491,
-0.01205773,
0.5476492643,
-0.0083572194,
0.1185213998,
0.2227996588,
-0.8338522911,
-0.1350739896,
-0.3346416652,
-0.6003238559,
-0.7674288154,
0.239279151,
0.4096026123,
0.1580190212,
0.366525799,
-0.7424881458,
0.4643274844,
-0.4357716441,
0.4875236154,
0.6278915405,
0.7310426831,
0.219009921,
-0.3424495459,
0.1803711951,
-0.021890685,
0.0415556468,
-0.1390172392,
-0.5019648075,
-0.6349315047,
-0.3081478477,
0.554210186,
0.5684527159,
-0.8812432289,
0.57604146,
-0.3472443521,
-0.3303144276,
-0.1608051807,
-0.0405321792,
-0.1896888465,
0.4074907601,
0.4754107296,
-0.1905532181,
-0.7128432393,
-0.8635850549,
-0.2723828256,
0.0410067998,
0.0833270326,
0.0684908554,
0.8748999834,
-0.6690385938,
0.9292595387,
-0.6433132291,
-0.5757754445,
-0.1011019051,
-0.0058191386,
0.4076194465,
0.5026453137,
0.3836190701,
-0.7802753448,
-0.5602702498,
0.4947222471,
-0.3177906871,
-0.1141133606,
0.0919203088,
-0.0349268727,
0.4088650942,
0.4170205593,
0.0899533704,
0.6827915311,
0.3440045118,
-0.4375557303,
0.5996584296,
0.0079236766,
0.6293227673,
-0.855787456,
0.3069746792,
-0.0066080629,
-0.3384118378,
-0.5672007799,
-0.0687736794,
-0.3280085027,
0.1264643669,
-0.4457259476,
0.4584203064,
-0.270922035,
0.2481193542,
-0.3025974631,
-0.1881702691,
-0.1487018019,
0.4503552616,
0.1820437759,
0.7887023091,
0.4417684674,
-0.7736669183,
0.456946522,
0.1678373069,
-0.0621759966,
0.4381096661,
-0.3474445045,
-0.436014533,
0.1578015089,
-0.1351150572,
-0.7424175143,
-0.1148732752,
0.3630160093,
-0.3100230694,
0.0018159165,
-0.2129961252,
-0.4169304669,
-0.028116025,
-0.3325218856,
0.1860228926,
0.2671248317,
-0.0173131097,
0.5779225826,
0.4019303024,
-0.1927746534,
-0.1322458386,
-0.6049399972,
-0.0000449754,
-0.4520810246,
-0.2823877633,
0.0093922205,
0.132786274,
-0.4700403214,
0.2122817338,
-0.1050001234,
-0.1205009967,
0.1929765791,
0.0974022746,
-0.1202195808,
0.1972289085,
0.2248122841,
0.4609770179,
-0.1507817358,
0.1741379499,
-0.276237756,
0.4512626529,
0.3160998225,
0.3569074571,
-0.0548587702,
0.4790477455,
0.3387180269,
0.0890163183,
0.6974560022,
0.3919133842,
-0.6640313268,
-0.0532747209,
-0.1133149713,
-0.2932606637,
-0.3686051071,
0.0695532709,
-0.1212243512,
-0.4109869599,
0.6288926005,
-0.7857126594,
0.0950215608,
0.9454752803,
0.4639286101,
0.1974816918,
0.4768483937,
0.8615186214,
0.4316808581,
-0.0867854208,
-0.4469519258,
0.0181634855,
-0.9950892329,
-0.725600481,
-0.5502566099,
-0.1897695959,
-0.6211445928,
-0.7265110612,
0.4843761027,
-0.2329246402,
0.0890346393,
0.427731216,
-0.512740314,
0.0070914836,
0.2345905155,
0.1787577718,
0.5127896667,
0.3141947091,
-0.3541078568,
-0.1030246466,
-0.236484617,
-1.2118960619,
1.2145586014,
0.2402064353,
0.357406348,
-0.2094737738,
0.7590163946,
0.5628665686,
0.6509178281,
-1.2139396667,
0.5962820053,
-0.144442305,
-0.8190541863,
-0.4051774144,
-0.0755897686,
-0.8704974651,
-0.0868802518,
-0.5920558572,
-0.9529361725,
0.4225598574,
-0.2506484985,
-0.1338931918,
0.5494286418,
-0.1304980814,
0.492970407,
-0.1155172214,
-0.2025259137,
-0.2309796661,
-0.2574216723,
0.1244816482,
-0.1824144274,
0.4140928984,
-0.0207856223,
-0.4493308365,
1.250710845,
-0.6112146378,
0.7670217752,
-0.3139356673,
0.0383889601,
0.683729291,
0.1583125442,
0.2502909005,
0.1952569485,
-0.1380224377,
0.2604634464,
0.1633300185,
-0.3357801437,
-0.0339563936,
0.4994264245,
-0.2850162089,
-0.5093431473,
-0.7077884674,
-0.0801873207,
0.0949541703,
0.4988093376,
0.0919084027,
0.1359263361,
-0.5905033946,
0.3343340158,
0.6335183382,
0.132989645,
0.3133613169,
-0.0671502724,
-0.1232402921,
-0.6996730566,
0.5364519358,
0.4544032216,
-0.0480158292,
0.5267284513,
0.3186231852,
0.0542396903,
-0.9048582911,
-0.2060124725,
-0.1208101138,
-0.761613369,
-0.41321522,
-0.8992730379,
-0.0477895699,
-0.3230345845,
-0.3065405488,
-0.209365204,
-0.2724637687,
-0.4963270426,
-0.4606211483,
0.5582455993,
0.8507024646,
0.0888724178,
0.4612627327,
-1.0219532251,
0.2716733813,
0.1087073237,
0.3311325312,
-0.3621379137,
0.0047286921,
-0.6456617117,
0.3027033508,
-0.2404555827,
-1.2620446682,
0.5088936687,
0.1765844524,
0.688285172,
0.412029922,
-0.3044933677,
0.0806987062,
-0.0855146572,
0.8802348971,
-0.0240408648,
-0.9553374648,
0.8015103936,
-0.5682737827,
-0.1758212149,
0.9265036583,
0.7066793442,
-0.593652904,
0.0441355333,
-0.6250086427,
-1.5447392464,
0.3663439751,
0.1103058904,
-0.2376110703,
-0.0688454136,
0.3530727029,
0.9321157336,
0.2389082313,
-0.7095478177,
-0.374990046,
0.3255285621,
-0.1377092898,
0.2641958594,
-0.3992397487,
-0.3945239782,
-0.2567666769,
0.7700134516,
-0.1737451702,
-0.1861515492,
0.3627412319,
-0.3969585896,
-0.0125877969,
0.1565162539,
0.1183821633,
0.8038112521,
-0.2010657638,
0.0894085988,
0.0809202641,
-0.8505059481,
0.4675613642,
-0.1115157977,
-0.4207294285,
-0.1425165683,
0.3284853697,
0.343182981,
0.0897547454,
-0.2813749313,
0.0345952362,
0.2279473245,
-0.2404984832,
-0.3958960474,
-0.0620012805,
-0.3670854867,
-0.2833487988,
0.8351874352,
0.4172433913,
0.5987819433,
-0.6338684559,
0.3508002758,
-0.033893887,
-0.4993908405,
-0.3936501741,
0.1854556799,
0.5341807008,
0.1006544977,
0.3133575022,
-0.1882675439,
-0.4837127924,
0.6278331876,
0.2886519432,
0.633058548,
-0.1993049383,
0.3966911733,
0.7352775931,
0.3120227754,
-0.0343682542,
0.5888475776,
-0.3212211728,
-0.3925937414,
-0.180940181,
-0.7608641982,
-0.0710061863,
-0.1950137168,
-0.4699135721,
0.5065503716,
-0.3123372495,
-0.3670158386,
0.023250984,
0.295406729,
-0.4599893093,
0.2590748072,
-0.0706733391,
0.7221667767,
-1.3093296289,
0.6010480523,
1.3083802462,
-0.1084502339,
-0.2364728898,
-0.2497877032,
-0.0870472789,
-0.5337720513,
0.6030261517,
0.0926533788,
0.1121243685,
-0.2206531912,
-0.4634380639,
-1.0907495022,
1.1942601204,
-0.602553606,
-0.274767518,
0.5537493229,
0.1027026623,
0.6195540428,
-0.4184871316,
-0.0495682657,
0.8633150458,
0.9497797489,
-0.1257787347,
-0.5660812855,
0.2154578269,
-0.3859463036,
0.0441947021,
0.3307771683,
-0.370514214,
0.8518568873,
0.2777354121,
-0.5301140547,
-0.0391660966,
0.5885308981,
0.0913672596,
0.3895740211,
0.4297454357,
0.2297405452,
0.4490633011,
-0.4413214624,
0.4918189645,
-0.285482794,
0.4040759206,
0.1341875941,
0.0224410277,
0.2561633885,
0.8684709668,
-0.2440223247,
0.7668724656,
0.9417433739,
-0.184619993,
0.5203984976,
0.2299358547,
-0.1130708754,
-0.0477353744,
-0.4334304333,
-0.0490109622,
0.6949524879,
1.1302628517,
-0.731132865,
-0.2286426723,
0.0226280391,
0.1019238681,
0.5281203985,
-0.9059863091,
1.1615505219,
0.0839138776,
-0.661474824,
0.2238244861,
0.3249191344,
0.6752530932,
-0.6596689224,
-0.4904561341,
-0.0781031772,
0.1261443645,
-0.6277962327,
-0.9197627902,
0.8272514939,
-0.1841302514,
-0.190743804,
-0.2460571826,
1.0728074312,
-0.5233566761,
-0.7363704443,
0.2528223991,
0.475571245,
0.0172887407,
0.1122398674,
-0.2729080617,
-0.1619468033,
0.038406644,
-0.3022685051,
-0.0449255742,
0.3821197748,
-0.5403146148,
0.2363135964,
0.7073776722,
0.4777549207,
-0.3459104002,
-0.4778279066,
0.9410067797,
-0.9729847312,
-0.7653841972,
-0.9176138639,
0.4227053225,
-0.2032741159,
-0.1548512429,
0.8390758634,
0.5959582925,
0.85819453,
-0.1516668499,
0.9069133401,
-0.5042714477,
0.1455166042,
-0.4926438928,
0.6235587597,
-0.1242566481,
-0.152728498,
-0.0274849795,
-1.0694204569,
-0.2642563879,
0.2492522299,
-0.1840779334,
0.1194882765,
1.0380957127,
0.3599171638,
0.153646037,
-0.2594569027,
0.008879262,
0.0513579212,
0.1297886074,
-0.0225809719,
0.247579664,
-0.3421195745,
0.0031975361,
-0.4365891516,
-0.4533085823,
-0.2297385335,
-0.7548939586,
-0.2933999896,
-0.7353745103,
-0.1542682946,
-0.459641695,
-0.0271704942,
1.0008983612,
0.3688672483,
-1.0251393318,
-0.4553425014,
-0.0928127766,
0.3279458284,
-0.5283304453,
-0.2199537754,
0.5442878008,
-0.066946663,
-0.7171726823,
0.0336268358,
0.358404994,
0.0003830958,
-0.4051208198,
0.3415230811,
-0.8100294471,
0.0278175101,
0.5194842815,
-0.0148402127,
-0.1693929881,
-0.1160017475,
-0.2410260737,
0.16425322,
0.2012630403,
1.0036197901,
-0.7057321668,
0.5223799944,
0.8694865108,
0.0603401437,
0.1883767396,
0.2607622445,
0.5373464227,
-0.6642728448,
0.3188494146,
0.4142119586,
0.1642808914,
0.3995526731,
-0.9446514249,
0.5469608903,
0.6355347633,
-0.4515750408,
-0.432231009,
0.1026564538,
-0.9183263779,
-0.3459509015,
1.334326148,
-0.2966658771,
-0.7472162247,
-0.3921212554,
-0.1865550727,
0.4095058739,
-0.3805548549,
0.5322981477,
0.6069473028,
0.058934845,
0.351451993,
-0.0853631869,
0.8263367414,
-0.5078946948,
-0.7842589021,
-0.038166631,
0.3156627715,
0.1381307244,
0.3056461811,
0.6139675975,
-0.5561130643,
-0.1470396519,
0.1172471121,
0.4400951862,
0.0690336898,
-0.3388093114,
-0.2815771401,
0.1312891096,
-0.1011299491,
-0.0524110571
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00667v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00667v1
|
An Early Investigation into the Utility of Multimodal Large Language Models in Medical Imaging
| 2024-06-02T08:29:23 | 2024-06-02T08:29:23 |
Sulaiman Khan, Md. Rafiul Biswas, Alina Murad, Hazrat Ali, Zubair Shah
|
eess.IV
|
eess.IV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Recent developments in multimodal large language models (MLLMs) have spurred
significant interest in their potential applications across various medical
imaging domains. On the one hand, there is a temptation to use these generative
models to synthesize realistic-looking medical image data, while on the other
hand, the ability to identify synthetic image data in a pool of data is also
significantly important. In this study, we explore the potential of the Gemini
(\textit{gemini-1.0-pro-vision-latest}) and GPT-4V (gpt-4-vision-preview)
models for medical image analysis using two modalities of medical image data.
Utilizing synthetic and real imaging data, both Gemini AI and GPT-4V are first
used to classify real versus synthetic images, followed by an interpretation
and analysis of the input images. Experimental results demonstrate that both
Gemini and GPT-4 could perform some interpretation of the input images. In this
specific experiment, Gemini was able to perform slightly better than the GPT-4V
on the classification task. In contrast, responses associated with GPT-4V were
mostly generic in nature. Our early investigation presented in this work
provides insights into the potential of MLLMs to assist with the classification
and interpretation of retinal fundoscopy and lung X-ray images. We also
identify key limitations associated with the early investigation study on MLLMs
for specialized tasks in medical image analysis.
|
[
-0.3645052016,
-0.5272665024,
0.8156850934,
0.040313188,
-0.4006713033,
-0.1361673474,
0.0466360152,
-0.6384673119,
0.0714549944,
0.5253008604,
-0.4162804484,
-0.4208355546,
-0.728787899,
0.2295984626,
-0.5487586856,
0.8873131871,
0.0067169699,
0.4820900559,
-0.0357802249,
-0.1294552535,
-0.2574026883,
-0.6442083716,
-0.738989234,
0.0802831128,
0.8030288815,
-0.2878918946,
0.9394508004,
0.2839415669,
0.9110703468,
0.3483864069,
0.2308004498,
-0.0008412308,
-0.0567085259,
0.106219627,
0.1452951431,
-0.2632099688,
-0.3036976457,
0.198250249,
0.717541039,
0.4694742858,
0.0327406675,
-0.1550175548,
-0.5800299644,
0.553135097,
-0.4641258717,
0.2749145925,
-0.3709002137,
0.196489498,
-0.3191818595,
-0.2657305598,
-0.1465260386,
0.1084276736,
0.3183392286,
-0.7119247317,
0.1327189356,
0.0014026468,
1.0484122038,
0.2112744302,
-0.4026262462,
-0.4904030561,
-0.6084777117,
0.5284373164,
-0.73315835,
0.4827193916,
-0.0368011668,
0.6338632703,
0.0184868649,
-1.1080545187,
-0.7079726458,
-0.4750273824,
-0.1726460159,
0.370123446,
-0.2189379781,
0.1073787138,
0.1396290958,
0.3214592934,
-0.6107930541,
0.142881155,
-0.7020283341,
-0.2908174098,
0.2409535795,
0.3315623105,
0.4690946043,
-0.2847574949,
-0.447848469,
0.1039362848,
-0.5026535988,
-0.2589396536,
-0.2074120343,
-0.0804690793,
-0.1603744775,
0.7341867089,
0.2260770798,
0.8536621332,
-0.1880638003,
-0.2823625207,
0.4185403585,
-0.4176909328,
-0.5235082507,
-0.4846718907,
0.8868707418,
0.3710608184,
0.0861818269,
0.1624470055,
-0.3244006038,
0.2825823128,
0.2631091774,
-0.8274594545,
-0.1571456939,
0.2157133073,
-1.0117065907,
-0.4710083008,
0.0048708008,
-0.4195543528,
-0.4216507077,
-0.4370848536,
0.5327185392,
-0.367697686,
-0.1903589815,
0.0623028837,
-0.186942637,
0.1203246713,
0.2466616184,
-0.7537130713,
0.123687692,
0.5167527199,
0.9011096954,
-0.1453456879,
-0.1175089628,
-0.3553490043,
-0.151004374,
-0.3872829974,
0.6423144341,
-0.6871626377,
-0.403992027,
-0.2148357034,
0.0476815999,
-0.178376928,
-0.5474560857,
0.5538140535,
-0.4672422409,
0.3918600976,
0.0371557921,
-0.2582069337,
-0.1545492262,
0.4711997509,
-0.9279693961,
0.4175100029,
0.2146350741,
-0.6115102172,
0.4601711631,
-0.7873328924,
-0.2948156893,
0.0098107969,
-0.707633853,
-0.5702810884,
0.2642339766,
0.220313102,
0.7593631744,
-0.3345659375,
0.2068397105,
-0.1655843109,
-0.2460888326,
0.6803582311,
-0.6817809343,
0.3345645964,
0.4644807279,
0.038712088,
0.2150609046,
-0.5589799285,
-0.1656050384,
0.2552414536,
-0.2684713304,
-0.2417965829,
-0.1453616917,
0.1620503068,
0.4781515598,
0.037695732,
-0.7038946152,
0.1236362308,
-0.2735820413,
0.3648741245,
0.566042006,
-0.2491706908,
0.0619555265,
-0.2678825259,
0.6526247263,
0.3282461464,
0.5061871409,
-0.4371669292,
-0.9370138645,
-0.4426947832,
-0.7562394738,
0.2560499012,
0.4417544305,
-0.9541474581,
-0.4614818692,
-0.2409207225,
-0.2948848307,
-0.7113549709,
-0.2276052088,
0.3386189938,
0.3644216061,
0.258716166,
-0.2951245606,
-0.5512809157,
-1.2550153732,
0.0383637808,
0.0669801384,
-0.1651591957,
0.4544048607,
0.417527467,
-0.5211960673,
0.559281826,
-0.4712486267,
-0.3154329062,
0.0115057873,
0.0617249086,
0.4135495722,
0.1524788737,
0.7773883343,
-1.1286768913,
-0.4856969416,
0.2971542478,
-0.8595429659,
0.1302988678,
-0.1860757321,
0.111530073,
0.2621082366,
0.2846292257,
-0.6484675407,
0.4101543128,
0.9050920606,
-0.1978427619,
0.6228208542,
-0.4757755399,
0.3125576973,
-0.9325057864,
0.214112103,
0.2275790721,
-0.2367248982,
-0.8034929633,
0.0259477608,
0.3802859485,
-0.3023706973,
-0.3839084506,
0.4577428997,
-0.4617342651,
-0.2059093714,
-0.2348144501,
-0.2671132982,
0.0017890601,
0.1242764518,
0.3125997186,
0.617613852,
0.7578216195,
-0.1581650525,
0.2270147353,
-0.0236877501,
-0.3089224696,
0.2935244739,
-0.583237052,
0.0847612768,
-0.4805330932,
0.3146999776,
-0.8277837634,
-0.2546841502,
0.3889683783,
-0.4210240841,
0.5732637048,
-0.1085301265,
-0.3919199109,
-0.5692027211,
-0.2388501167,
0.449894309,
0.4369818866,
-0.4153900146,
0.8207606673,
0.2086683661,
-0.0716446638,
-0.5345161557,
-0.5649420023,
0.1126336232,
-0.1242816225,
-0.6056160331,
0.4543073773,
0.1370963156,
-0.2032308429,
0.0879456922,
0.1707308441,
-0.1086795256,
-0.1779656559,
0.5037053823,
0.9343358874,
-0.3464592397,
0.0785598159,
-0.1337073594,
-0.3078502715,
-0.0260151271,
-0.2476909757,
0.2084702253,
-0.1651361585,
-0.3751469851,
-0.4477744997,
0.397434622,
1.2058193684,
-0.2034974545,
0.6707141399,
0.8687891364,
-0.3756065667,
0.582015872,
-0.6381610632,
-0.0185539089,
-0.4576304555,
0.5871879458,
-0.4567528069,
-0.6186185479,
0.2368433923,
0.1839693338,
0.0125706661,
0.4392860532,
0.7836798429,
-0.4100430906,
1.0933856964,
0.2500881851,
0.0973428413,
0.4328350127,
-0.2765755653,
0.0674420446,
-0.9736263156,
-0.3574262261,
-0.1907700002,
-0.2108711898,
-0.4453387558,
-0.6060890555,
0.6500687599,
-0.6798722744,
0.1323347539,
-0.303928107,
-0.4650948048,
0.2512759864,
0.2079468518,
0.0903564468,
0.095739454,
0.0737232789,
-0.1553913355,
-0.1642200053,
-0.5859609246,
-0.354241401,
1.3896710873,
0.4283105135,
0.715998292,
-0.0205355603,
0.2071448863,
0.1123181805,
0.8498771787,
-0.8160588145,
0.2919828594,
-0.792845428,
-0.8778404593,
0.0506584421,
-0.2491309494,
-1.1302131414,
0.672647655,
-0.5722187161,
-0.0919368714,
0.0158108529,
0.1541223973,
-0.4668850303,
0.1828725636,
-0.8236585855,
0.7706002593,
-0.4724218547,
-0.0893726498,
-0.0934995264,
-0.711427629,
0.4970993698,
-0.3926899731,
0.4583120048,
0.1256445795,
-0.0655554608,
0.4892015159,
-0.0897270888,
0.8015548587,
-0.2851828933,
0.0661214367,
0.0648251697,
-0.1393857151,
0.1866920888,
-0.143319115,
0.1417227685,
0.2685601115,
0.3110024631,
-0.1459302455,
-0.6545237899,
0.7846374512,
-0.7104632258,
-0.4356049001,
-0.445526123,
-0.5780136585,
0.0457066596,
0.0292130429,
0.1077512354,
0.7011765242,
0.1185129061,
0.1088827327,
0.0250754803,
-0.3718046248,
0.2083054334,
0.4236609936,
-0.4877117872,
-0.2954552472,
0.8378883004,
0.0408088304,
0.3470306993,
0.290370822,
0.3301208913,
-0.4008445442,
-0.9015744328,
-0.4500329494,
0.5242272615,
-0.6702372432,
-0.0279248096,
-0.5626185536,
-0.0151839321,
-0.182828933,
0.012468393,
-0.277477771,
-0.3156349063,
-0.170745492,
0.3820025921,
-0.0995951891,
0.5549250841,
0.1867423356,
-0.0120031685,
-1.0373142958,
0.3445264995,
0.1389173716,
0.0794871598,
-0.3613499999,
-0.1877350956,
-0.144912377,
-0.1531634629,
-0.1445559561,
-0.8442420363,
0.4386857152,
0.0776010156,
0.6097590327,
0.5808028579,
-0.5410535932,
0.6149892807,
-0.3752449453,
0.771478653,
0.4611577988,
-0.5347498059,
0.2635244131,
-0.2158386707,
0.2116252631,
0.0844040737,
0.3234600723,
-0.4966727197,
-0.2687961161,
-0.405931741,
-0.4535094202,
0.2739645243,
0.4474702775,
0.0641431063,
-0.0377454162,
0.5822471976,
0.2755100429,
0.1867803931,
-0.6649854183,
-0.0053901612,
-0.3492624462,
-0.3783335984,
-0.0027523213,
0.0024650567,
-0.1473058909,
-0.1825911701,
0.1784517616,
-0.15231435,
0.5522519946,
0.2722667456,
0.0840553269,
0.2136357427,
0.1554839611,
0.673351109,
0.3306225538,
0.0030523746,
0.1692795455,
-0.1602735221,
-0.7057076693,
-0.124598816,
0.0762510747,
0.0838565752,
-0.032589186,
0.4660341442,
0.7486484051,
0.0245066471,
-0.7465965748,
0.5982887149,
-0.2140512913,
-0.2938000262,
-0.3839741647,
-0.029768208,
0.0329295471,
0.3460060656,
0.1929654032,
0.4389076829,
0.2454197258,
-0.681725204,
-0.0528256744,
0.7480123639,
-0.1425944716,
-0.4029273689,
0.5302444696,
0.2000966817,
0.1201060712,
0.9457350969,
0.2075270563,
-0.4508166015,
0.6348273158,
0.5080943108,
0.435895592,
-0.0520905331,
0.0566278249,
0.2413717657,
0.1019279957,
0.1966449767,
0.3099731803,
0.1883929372,
-0.936093092,
-0.5815235376,
-0.3926203251,
-0.1159318015,
0.1743789017,
-0.4271213114,
0.1960488409,
-0.4462843537,
-0.5425627232,
0.4530757964,
-0.4335792065,
-0.7561255097,
0.5077855587,
0.6097145677,
0.5436524153,
-0.5838026404,
1.0070202351,
0.6159238815,
-0.2485395819,
-0.6670177579,
-0.20245561,
0.0831405297,
-0.9810981154,
0.9161711335,
0.2306665331,
-0.0497634858,
-0.0869570673,
-0.2882353365,
-0.5781021118,
1.1814168692,
0.0953102633,
-0.6122491956,
-0.2056552023,
-0.0737929121,
0.6113551259,
-0.6066864729,
0.2367959619,
0.4842373431,
0.5295177698,
0.3992364705,
-0.9940913916,
0.0558585152,
-0.3328066766,
-0.0133329602,
0.2986849546,
-0.2129401267,
1.1072645187,
-0.4888173044,
-0.2310294062,
0.2335377038,
0.1162735596,
0.3395374715,
0.4159881175,
0.5796633959,
0.1784743518,
0.5264779925,
-0.1788866669,
1.4646524191,
-0.1712618619,
0.2872219682,
0.3626815975,
-0.1780928373,
0.6753692031,
0.6613681316,
-0.1777599007,
0.4020654559,
0.4930781424,
-0.2895856202,
0.5095041394,
0.0255991556,
-0.3312904537,
-0.1222408488,
0.2971286178,
-0.4982179105,
0.3663438857,
0.8463878632,
-0.7123669982,
0.2163897306,
0.4037919641,
-0.20261769,
-0.6592250466,
-0.3201152384,
0.4053993225,
0.1272778064,
-0.5395876169,
0.5108546615,
0.0028548487,
0.72584939,
-0.7138922811,
-0.0088169072,
0.1459244043,
0.1888165176,
-0.2140861899,
-0.7506766319,
0.3882841766,
-0.1402467489,
0.1134300604,
0.1192798316,
0.7706629634,
-0.0420207009,
-0.7383797765,
0.110802263,
0.2911055684,
0.3043665588,
-0.1913237125,
-0.6544087529,
0.2412204295,
-0.0830166414,
-0.1295625418,
0.2613934278,
0.1969339997,
-0.0225882158,
0.6986569166,
0.9343390465,
0.1101554632,
0.0376185626,
0.0759174526,
0.9601942301,
-0.5920240879,
-0.1924514472,
-0.732326448,
0.5990509391,
0.0456604175,
-0.1069909707,
0.3958875835,
0.4331946969,
0.286410898,
-0.3857267797,
0.8680968285,
0.0225729551,
0.1612980366,
-0.8566586375,
0.5346655846,
-0.8351563215,
0.1485064626,
-0.1345133036,
-0.4318655729,
-0.7445423007,
0.6851609945,
-0.3045230806,
0.1092877835,
0.9669804573,
0.9093537927,
-0.1573282331,
0.0376364738,
0.594348371,
0.2429135293,
0.4874973893,
0.3493887186,
1.017130971,
-0.1082016751,
0.5325123072,
0.0293107592,
-0.2858375907,
-0.1832768023,
-0.3805324137,
-0.8913959861,
-0.5417686701,
-0.1825938821,
-0.3360576332,
-0.2296736389,
0.5795257092,
0.8723629117,
-0.4241135716,
0.3456244171,
0.2910172343,
-0.536287725,
-0.0748813227,
-0.0679692104,
0.5787385106,
0.0038899637,
-0.6873519421,
0.3184744716,
0.5864141583,
0.4632515907,
-0.5327611566,
-0.1689395458,
0.2670373619,
-0.0682944655,
0.7648744583,
0.1348817945,
-1.0172939301,
-0.0091768438,
0.2407432944,
-0.145195201,
0.0727935731,
1.2114089727,
-0.8559714556,
0.7337068915,
0.1892939359,
0.3590560257,
0.6664972305,
-0.1456716508,
0.3883021474,
-0.2357368171,
0.2447391748,
0.1876728535,
0.6012341976,
0.2655142248,
-0.3575391471,
0.171868071,
0.2530085146,
-0.3989230096,
-0.4830369651,
0.1149342358,
-1.1730116606,
-0.3482140303,
1.0078266859,
-0.1562982202,
-0.0801019073,
-0.1258068532,
-0.5726908445,
-0.1184514835,
-0.0631512105,
0.5697205663,
0.5683543086,
-0.3858034909,
-0.3921208084,
-0.7522256374,
0.1323996633,
0.2231417745,
-0.8868479729,
-0.5468432307,
0.5587828755,
0.4803299308,
0.300652504,
0.850953877,
-0.6237170696,
0.3863185048,
-0.0632205904,
-0.324824363,
-0.3157618344,
-0.1560873836,
-0.2840560079,
0.431132108,
-0.0821473897,
-0.494107306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00656v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00656v1
|
Presence or Absence: Are Unknown Word Usages in Dictionaries?
| 2024-06-02T07:57:45 | 2024-06-02T07:57:45 |
Xianghe Ma, Dominik Schlechtweg, Wei Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this work, we outline the components and results of our system submitted
to the AXOLOTL-24 shared task for Finnish, Russian and German languages. Our
system is fully unsupervised. It leverages a graph-based clustering approach to
predict mappings between unknown word usages and dictionary entries for Subtask
1, and generates dictionary-like definitions for those novel word usages
through the state-of-the-art Large Language Models such as GPT-4 and LLaMA-3
for Subtask 2. In Subtask 1, our system outperforms the baseline system by a
large margin, and it offers interpretability for the mapping results by
distinguishing between matched and unmatched (novel) word usages through our
graph-based clustering approach. Our system ranks first in Finnish and German,
and ranks second in Russian on the Subtask 2 test-phase leaderboard. These
results show the potential of our system in managing dictionary entries,
particularly for updating dictionaries to include novel sense entries. Our code
and data are made publicly
available\footnote{\url{https://github.com/xiaohemaikoo/axolotl24-ABDN-NLP}}.
|
[
-0.3287011087,
-0.4627260268,
0.6710888147,
0.2587637305,
-0.4406015575,
0.2792612314,
0.0357378982,
-0.6530240178,
0.599075079,
0.0304809529,
-0.4748158753,
-0.6170249581,
-0.5781822205,
0.2978675067,
-0.6604254246,
0.6947640181,
-0.0726549104,
-0.0830790251,
-0.5543148518,
-0.6613408923,
-0.4409806132,
-0.5259235501,
-0.1869884878,
-0.4676693082,
0.6143471003,
0.0606575981,
0.6484673619,
0.267988354,
0.3640840352,
0.2929258943,
-0.1442142874,
0.0801641569,
-0.1258578449,
0.0341155417,
-0.4232113659,
-0.0240379777,
-0.3342530429,
-0.4378173053,
0.657356441,
1.0332546234,
-0.2624081671,
-0.2370800972,
0.119596146,
0.2619636953,
-0.558255434,
0.3725174665,
-0.6389414072,
0.0340891778,
-0.4116024375,
0.3361273706,
-0.0617869422,
0.087931715,
-0.0777423084,
-0.7670179009,
0.1375136077,
-0.0258560181,
0.6608825326,
0.0934480578,
-0.205324173,
-0.4046850801,
-0.4526383281,
0.5103130341,
-0.6147880554,
0.3733325601,
0.5869328976,
0.0180241689,
-0.3942631185,
-0.8402832747,
-0.8106712699,
0.1229645088,
-0.3534476161,
0.2330899537,
-0.8185802102,
0.056514211,
0.0060001169,
0.3485172093,
-0.4449470639,
0.2282039672,
-0.3066253066,
-0.2601451874,
0.4600673616,
0.0555522889,
0.2857254446,
-0.1382783502,
0.0294781812,
0.2575041354,
-0.631170094,
-0.3816690445,
0.1395408213,
0.3310871422,
-0.231224969,
0.9234899879,
-0.5439340472,
0.6452694535,
-0.3211578727,
0.2582560182,
0.5974972844,
-0.6455363035,
0.1291885525,
-0.2223943174,
0.6802895665,
0.2609537542,
-0.0535610989,
-0.4104800522,
-0.4584072828,
0.316213727,
0.0246679988,
-0.1951246113,
-0.5013581514,
0.0137781734,
-0.0576700866,
-0.1903045326,
-0.0474251732,
-0.5335239172,
-0.5176619291,
0.0090605104,
0.6181371212,
-0.2686369419,
-0.4714540839,
-0.2794159055,
-0.3289875984,
-0.3805522621,
0.3132766485,
-0.7902379632,
0.6821351647,
0.5098966956,
1.173456192,
-0.4926617444,
-0.3988096416,
-0.3870551586,
-0.4158395231,
-0.5981044173,
0.7322565913,
-0.2268406451,
-0.6556035876,
0.2783937752,
0.2442572862,
0.067394346,
-0.6922023892,
0.1299695522,
-0.3303466439,
0.028355198,
-0.4276798964,
-0.4280566573,
-0.2649353743,
0.1105250269,
-0.6440014839,
1.2013814449,
0.4374513328,
-0.5459779501,
0.4538688362,
-0.7666748166,
-0.5292648077,
0.8198291659,
-0.2713971734,
-0.0543704703,
0.4131049514,
-0.1543617249,
0.3419985771,
0.4455430508,
-0.1390982866,
-0.1601542383,
-0.292978704,
0.3616487682,
-0.066960901,
0.6695925593,
0.3133086562,
-0.2590687871,
-0.20011428,
-0.7549558282,
-0.1153500527,
0.022492189,
-0.3807808459,
-0.841850996,
0.2642396688,
0.1197494045,
-0.07225734,
0.5538883805,
-0.948161006,
0.083084777,
-0.3962704837,
0.3565069139,
0.559160769,
0.0503497496,
0.3091714084,
-0.0784351453,
0.6248505116,
0.1497508734,
-0.1215284616,
-0.1112310067,
-0.8093292117,
-0.8176413178,
-0.1845730096,
0.3841032088,
0.3737437129,
-0.8708880544,
0.3218051791,
-0.1670691967,
-0.4713422656,
-0.1281271279,
0.0418306738,
0.1836454868,
0.2112147212,
0.3522161841,
-0.0763273388,
-0.365614742,
-0.7474202514,
0.0602012463,
-0.2077242434,
0.0957284793,
0.1857364625,
0.6341257691,
-0.537121594,
0.9447316527,
-0.5403183103,
-0.3280921876,
-0.2545697093,
0.042901054,
0.3754218817,
0.247897774,
0.5585433245,
-0.7285587192,
-0.4461056888,
0.3661486208,
-0.8202013373,
-0.3008649945,
0.2106478065,
0.2765644491,
0.2635254264,
0.2588112652,
-0.626897037,
0.5551434755,
0.7584676147,
-0.4094630778,
0.2473764569,
-0.5423746109,
-0.3576819003,
-1.0214771032,
0.1819968969,
-0.2725515366,
-0.2732728422,
-0.5413205624,
0.1740660667,
0.0420554727,
-0.0225318223,
-0.3963365257,
0.5912020802,
-0.6117175221,
-0.2104160339,
-0.3083449304,
0.0595864542,
-0.1459601521,
0.2375037968,
-0.0155348275,
0.619594872,
0.7264766097,
-0.528958261,
0.5952104926,
0.2577942312,
-0.5792588592,
0.4151056707,
-0.5235981345,
-0.002525884,
0.137197718,
-0.1507927328,
-1.0866942406,
-0.1730739772,
0.3716757298,
-0.4296665192,
0.012599255,
-0.0084483279,
-0.7029713988,
-0.2950552106,
0.2566132247,
0.2277615666,
0.4895418286,
-0.3333006203,
0.3498393595,
0.7694251537,
-0.2194563299,
-0.4547102749,
-0.6957047582,
0.2197800279,
-0.1108670235,
-0.0741818845,
0.1401557326,
0.0689059272,
-0.5688484907,
0.3101775646,
-0.2340584695,
-0.2255048007,
0.3068583608,
0.5071361065,
0.1006188095,
0.2061537057,
0.2984125614,
0.2665587366,
-0.1019446626,
-0.1381138414,
-0.373668462,
0.457775712,
-0.1155227795,
-0.3347367942,
0.0269550811,
0.6828429699,
0.5248194933,
-0.1203703806,
0.5933020115,
0.264643997,
-0.9063109756,
-0.2157765776,
-0.1237868443,
0.0205782037,
-0.4463544488,
0.4210574627,
-0.2081536949,
-0.7541710138,
0.8581186533,
0.0937941223,
0.0374823995,
0.5116895437,
0.3239943385,
-0.1576188505,
0.8626401424,
0.7539650798,
0.0057466934,
0.2012014538,
-0.1927146465,
0.2431733012,
-0.5439189076,
-0.2083275467,
-0.304593116,
-0.1990599483,
-0.6603138447,
-0.279633671,
0.5560721755,
-0.1033489332,
0.5544903874,
0.4980834126,
-0.3768146932,
0.3627690971,
0.5747947097,
-0.330725342,
0.2689142227,
0.1953701973,
-0.562903285,
-0.0495888107,
-0.8392713666,
0.0453328751,
0.9322440028,
0.0426909551,
0.5569133162,
0.122122243,
0.7371312976,
0.605333209,
0.0549458265,
-0.9507869482,
0.5685411692,
-0.2956144214,
-0.6227997541,
-0.2835159004,
-0.2057523876,
-1.2450739145,
0.4320646226,
-0.1995511651,
-0.9181959033,
0.3961468637,
-0.1206319779,
-0.4417364001,
-0.0037984927,
-0.6186407804,
0.7363408804,
0.0366757251,
0.0830440819,
-0.2714830041,
-0.3599775136,
-0.2580897212,
-0.4435892701,
0.3970938921,
0.1243478507,
-0.0163851455,
0.9192299843,
-0.6296702623,
0.8189136982,
-0.2752686739,
-0.0716984197,
0.221650973,
0.098434791,
0.5125389099,
-0.0467872135,
0.07730373,
0.8038031459,
0.3880287707,
-0.1737768948,
-0.3896408677,
0.9857754707,
-0.378742069,
-0.2266210616,
-1.1036900282,
-0.5033369064,
-0.0029807107,
0.8522070646,
0.423271507,
0.6491386294,
-0.2534775734,
0.2403960377,
0.3768479824,
-0.1393159628,
0.5308072567,
0.879555881,
-0.4849370718,
-0.1916333586,
1.0859241486,
0.7068445683,
-0.1216543466,
0.3778669834,
0.3152077496,
-0.5450589657,
-0.8203750849,
-0.3131502271,
0.3609849513,
-0.6641507149,
-0.0284077004,
-0.7146922946,
-0.1613250524,
-0.6333113909,
0.0098123979,
-0.1485406458,
-0.4433534443,
-0.1519113779,
-0.2408636063,
0.3584163785,
1.1110975742,
-0.4446129203,
0.3764058948,
-0.4430501461,
0.185936138,
0.1787815988,
0.2797985077,
-0.4717252851,
-0.1044293568,
-0.573682785,
0.1612249166,
0.1315908283,
-0.8473702073,
0.4427598715,
0.2102335393,
0.7692855,
0.4655899107,
0.2874614,
0.491087079,
-0.410128504,
0.8079026341,
0.0186543036,
-0.8003134727,
0.1843362302,
-0.531791091,
0.5276257396,
0.4593784213,
0.2223464847,
-0.8452903628,
-0.6322401166,
-0.6801918149,
-0.8870002031,
0.7095564604,
0.3524308503,
0.3475480378,
-0.2442433685,
0.0874013305,
0.0439633243,
0.5554534793,
-0.5991675258,
-0.391931355,
-0.1366143823,
-0.187676847,
-0.4788978696,
-0.1402008384,
-0.1965564191,
-0.3738204539,
0.4300291538,
0.0150419008,
0.1780172139,
0.0101330951,
-0.0227533951,
-0.0872768909,
-0.1237011477,
0.5225613713,
1.029918313,
-0.0273256619,
0.4027422071,
0.3075347543,
-0.7984355688,
-0.2080534697,
0.0543722585,
-0.2569704056,
0.7626321316,
0.3497843444,
0.5785903335,
0.1637404114,
-0.6700151563,
0.5982857347,
0.1964424402,
-0.0856794193,
-0.8994899392,
-0.1684126556,
0.1074099541,
-0.095494464,
0.4535326064,
0.2344782501,
0.1137739494,
-0.4013091326,
0.1145836264,
0.514739573,
-0.3888179958,
-0.5417162776,
0.3766810298,
0.0452950522,
-0.2833375037,
0.3526149094,
-0.5123015046,
-0.3767800331,
0.3702599108,
0.448589921,
0.4572577775,
-0.1603863686,
0.3365463614,
-0.0117515922,
0.3940656781,
0.1274230033,
0.2601362765,
-0.3290833533,
-0.9532942772,
0.0840216577,
-0.4304555953,
-0.1278880835,
0.4018199146,
-0.5855363607,
0.262719363,
-0.3582865,
-0.0449050888,
0.0572104268,
0.0309045296,
-0.4252801538,
0.1276084781,
-0.0527925491,
0.4464026093,
-1.1059242487,
0.7812538147,
1.0981857777,
-0.041975107,
-0.4117291272,
-0.3164688349,
0.1634235829,
-0.763502717,
0.2347416282,
-0.1828386337,
-0.0574700125,
0.156210348,
-0.0536910966,
-0.9760169983,
0.8668999076,
-0.1277245879,
-0.3352443278,
0.2725317478,
0.0337032638,
0.8375036716,
-0.0321533158,
-0.0778986514,
0.2135666013,
0.3534730673,
0.05228585,
-0.8872048855,
-0.1177324206,
-0.5248654485,
-0.1426934302,
0.3721528947,
-0.2705692947,
0.8585759997,
0.0234564245,
-0.6219094396,
0.1354923099,
0.3907104731,
-0.150235787,
0.5979094505,
0.5661078095,
0.7407744527,
0.8308867812,
-0.0132921813,
0.7905762196,
0.023773253,
0.2948430181,
1.0612522364,
-0.3581803739,
0.6393522024,
0.6464528441,
-0.3722842634,
0.3680510223,
0.5216034651,
0.0670254603,
0.7075515389,
0.0852999687,
-0.5987368226,
-0.1018165648,
-0.2714048624,
-0.4553668201,
0.605055213,
0.5642136335,
-0.1527980119,
-0.4712331593,
0.1786466986,
0.0855719745,
-0.0988845006,
0.0699322447,
0.9010708332,
0.2413200885,
-0.6374773383,
0.5456807017,
0.063982904,
0.4316378832,
-0.8475906253,
-0.1166628376,
-0.5714594722,
0.1750156581,
-0.2528111339,
-0.7197161913,
0.3104391098,
-0.0077346424,
-0.0369131416,
-0.0532689542,
0.5077654719,
-0.3001441658,
-0.7286502719,
0.3195972741,
0.6179186106,
0.4643407762,
-0.0357341878,
-0.2210885137,
-0.2368877232,
-0.1498301178,
0.2906504273,
0.4330905378,
0.4238563776,
-0.3072880507,
0.5650849938,
0.5107885003,
0.4150899947,
0.1122862026,
-0.0100405021,
0.8092648387,
-0.1170863584,
-0.7980582118,
-0.5672981739,
0.2407474667,
-0.0358558968,
-0.5227776766,
1.2517482042,
0.6960154176,
0.9024610519,
-0.0115017965,
0.965256989,
-0.3580988944,
0.675866425,
-0.1692384779,
1.0260368586,
-0.7848751545,
0.1963400692,
-0.5204504728,
-0.9565216899,
-0.33357355,
0.6331096292,
0.0326700993,
-0.3982931376,
0.7925175428,
0.8045717478,
-0.0727755651,
-0.3510360718,
0.6366483569,
0.2544623017,
-0.1188757569,
0.1400574148,
0.861534059,
-0.2427157611,
0.1478173733,
-0.483281821,
-0.2945177257,
-0.0778614283,
-0.6208175421,
-0.4511954188,
-1.0257840157,
-0.36694327,
-0.1941644996,
0.0459024459,
0.4635410607,
0.4158895314,
-0.9213074446,
-0.2840813398,
-0.3082603514,
0.2883733511,
-0.5817881227,
-0.1883981079,
0.1052581593,
-0.0260075182,
-0.6877524853,
0.6769982576,
0.1099353656,
0.125439465,
-0.2497082204,
0.0349382311,
-0.2216855288,
-0.2098151743,
0.5265760422,
0.372067064,
-0.4866349697,
-0.2614455819,
0.1116583273,
0.282504499,
-0.2169484347,
0.5387598276,
-0.7915857434,
0.7777599692,
0.6571952701,
0.1427111328,
0.2783125937,
0.0107070301,
0.2852814794,
-0.9093155861,
0.3252192736,
0.0892271549,
0.5759814382,
0.1908309311,
-0.3553379774,
0.3388319016,
0.8286873698,
-0.1884232461,
-1.0530719757,
0.0114006139,
-0.9244512916,
-0.2663114071,
1.3865420818,
-0.2231406718,
0.07468272,
-0.5522018671,
0.0938736647,
0.0929557532,
-0.3549171388,
0.8117737174,
0.9075457454,
-0.0944629014,
0.0419426225,
-0.3478774428,
0.2943235636,
0.2615809143,
-0.5095894337,
-0.2189522684,
0.7262987494,
0.2700114548,
0.5228222013,
0.7362747192,
0.0055994936,
0.1121842936,
0.1379383355,
-0.1728380322,
-0.1725707948,
-0.381172657,
-0.4698046446,
-0.0689576194,
0.0008904499,
-0.6090544462
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00654v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00654v1
|
Enhancing Zero-shot Text-to-Speech Synthesis with Human Feedback
| 2024-06-02T07:54:33 | 2024-06-02T07:54:33 |
Chen Chen, Yuchen Hu, Wen Wu, Helin Wang, Eng Siong Chng, Chao Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
In recent years, text-to-speech (TTS) technology has witnessed impressive
advancements, particularly with large-scale training datasets, showcasing
human-level speech quality and impressive zero-shot capabilities on unseen
speakers. However, despite human subjective evaluations, such as the mean
opinion score (MOS), remaining the gold standard for assessing the quality of
synthetic speech, even state-of-the-art TTS approaches have kept human feedback
isolated from training that resulted in mismatched training objectives and
evaluation metrics. In this work, we investigate a novel topic of integrating
subjective human evaluation into the TTS training loop. Inspired by the recent
success of reinforcement learning from human feedback, we propose a
comprehensive sampling-annotating-learning framework tailored to TTS
optimization, namely uncertainty-aware optimization (UNO). Specifically, UNO
eliminates the need for a reward model or preference data by directly
maximizing the utility of speech generations while considering the uncertainty
that lies in the inherent variability in subjective human speech perception and
evaluations. Experimental results of both subjective and objective evaluations
demonstrate that UNO considerably improves the zero-shot performance of TTS
models in terms of MOS, word error rate, and speaker similarity. Additionally,
we present a remarkable ability of UNO that it can adapt to the desired
speaking style in emotional TTS seamlessly and flexibly.
|
[
-0.5187650323,
-0.6119783521,
0.4989290535,
0.0585756265,
-0.4977810383,
0.3182404637,
-0.48399055,
-0.3193958402,
0.1769646257,
0.073005572,
-0.6093023419,
-0.5214324594,
-0.1779698282,
0.3185103834,
-0.1359177381,
1.2340188026,
0.2133024484,
-0.0024174636,
0.0669132024,
0.0037615201,
-0.2464679778,
-0.6163496971,
-0.6567254066,
-0.3192598522,
0.4897056222,
0.528157115,
0.362337172,
0.4507839978,
-0.2989741266,
0.2117668539,
0.0989166051,
0.0671801791,
-0.4010186195,
0.2186886221,
-0.3036839068,
-0.3104626238,
-0.467532903,
0.0712067112,
0.5628141761,
0.5480728149,
-0.1799097955,
0.0824881718,
0.1390627623,
0.5248557329,
-0.6754189134,
-0.1383906603,
-0.5500993729,
0.2728508413,
0.0120101841,
-0.4705061913,
-0.4196285009,
-0.2983475029,
0.5357764363,
-0.6847586036,
0.2433497161,
-0.1461121142,
0.3896815181,
0.4650648236,
-0.1133175492,
0.0701942816,
-1.0844137669,
0.9123620987,
-0.7387698293,
0.5617155433,
0.2471679002,
0.1758290827,
0.0425572358,
-0.0873627514,
-0.5452278852,
-0.3113624752,
0.4796518087,
0.4133283794,
-0.2836712897,
0.3653264642,
-0.3510153592,
0.0394271053,
-0.2820803225,
0.1138566509,
-0.296646893,
-0.4197846651,
0.6242355108,
-0.1454482228,
-0.062280044,
-0.2611761987,
-0.1359268576,
-0.2347134203,
-0.2090729475,
0.1260414571,
0.5700345039,
0.6136334538,
-0.1307577342,
0.4851416647,
-0.5384662747,
0.7333286405,
0.1322944611,
-0.0040224195,
0.4141658545,
-0.0851834491,
-0.1943227947,
0.158975929,
1.0370219946,
0.4931307733,
0.1422969401,
-0.49084723,
-0.1894952059,
0.1960169077,
0.4929186702,
-0.5957238078,
0.1363113821,
0.376791358,
-0.003515654,
-0.5449905396,
0.1813809574,
-1.0514039993,
-0.2315323353,
-0.5385193229,
0.4827492833,
-0.3679966331,
-0.2442619801,
0.147971034,
-0.2368888259,
-0.2251300067,
0.3568995595,
-0.7905517817,
0.1351918578,
0.383693099,
0.5981464982,
-0.083793655,
-0.2270547599,
-0.7798960209,
-0.0139841363,
-0.5916109085,
0.8213796616,
-0.3261745274,
-0.6504459977,
-0.1795895696,
-0.6787447929,
0.3764254749,
-0.3815306723,
0.6657536626,
0.2072963119,
0.4028674662,
-0.0722119436,
-0.3113269508,
0.083298102,
0.1075011715,
-0.0649303198,
0.9891978502,
0.2596431375,
-0.414585501,
0.3645265996,
-0.6966990829,
-0.4259291589,
-0.0846088678,
-0.2046721876,
-0.3109660149,
0.516803205,
0.2292465568,
0.2254674286,
-0.2648424506,
0.1584917754,
-0.317340374,
-0.3820729554,
0.4927215576,
-0.5781738162,
0.0710988417,
0.3059233427,
-0.6035762429,
0.2954388261,
-0.8146081567,
0.4633286595,
-0.2482017726,
-0.2192410082,
-0.1509714574,
-0.0512276478,
-0.0040437886,
0.0830487534,
-0.1686409265,
-0.693091929,
-0.0363569371,
-0.7952120304,
0.518294096,
0.7666718364,
0.2858489752,
0.5348469019,
-0.2650002241,
0.5190763474,
-0.1895762682,
0.2182042897,
0.1136852428,
-0.2916560173,
-0.7512148023,
-0.0889240056,
0.371900171,
0.4881352186,
-0.8988096118,
0.6041290164,
-0.2599922717,
-0.5779509544,
-0.884563148,
-0.099938944,
0.5411724448,
0.521312654,
0.4074244499,
-0.6582464576,
-0.6980623603,
-0.633829236,
-0.3275747299,
-0.57551682,
-0.4675208628,
0.1226165071,
0.0585389808,
0.0170384105,
1.3829478025,
-0.2873488367,
-0.3564817905,
-0.1728182584,
0.5640832186,
-0.1810352057,
0.3236583471,
0.3735332191,
-0.2309932411,
-0.1294222921,
-0.0840051621,
-0.2943615019,
-0.2901697457,
-0.2894634902,
-0.1275015026,
0.3217836916,
0.1608813256,
-0.2220026851,
0.535621047,
0.2216264457,
-0.0365830213,
0.6951969266,
-0.2614962161,
0.2947728932,
-0.8332567811,
0.0010312177,
0.2231104672,
-0.2650857568,
-0.6014850736,
-0.4365212321,
-0.5319788456,
-0.0961490273,
-0.5432595015,
0.5643949509,
-0.1517368704,
-0.2019328773,
-0.2631575465,
0.3388273418,
-0.0389036983,
0.7763370872,
0.1187568232,
0.7929769158,
0.4577417672,
-0.5646205544,
0.1753102988,
0.142391324,
-0.1205100864,
0.9523407817,
-0.6974716187,
0.4774720073,
-0.1649174243,
0.2434234321,
-0.6916501522,
-0.3373470008,
0.2994158864,
-0.9680819511,
0.1947560459,
0.0539754517,
-0.2302665114,
-0.1837067157,
-0.5527788401,
0.0878465921,
0.5468372703,
-0.1812988818,
0.4586551785,
0.3094519973,
-0.1805201769,
-0.4514505267,
-0.6283458471,
0.2140716314,
-0.0363806188,
-0.0551837906,
0.3220318854,
-0.1978615373,
-0.0137503222,
-0.134351477,
-0.2518104613,
0.0402410366,
-0.0515430309,
0.1966620088,
0.2185935825,
0.2528151274,
0.0642251745,
0.2310526222,
-0.32998842,
-0.1010414734,
-0.5945162773,
0.2065320164,
-0.1188027784,
-0.2087843269,
-0.8558544517,
0.3324586153,
0.5102481246,
0.0121067418,
0.0753801316,
0.6303882003,
-0.1953813285,
-0.3913830519,
-0.3652837574,
-0.2270053923,
-0.4287464619,
0.5078588724,
-0.0925696641,
-0.9239342809,
-0.0901984498,
0.0400883853,
0.052687455,
0.1977987885,
0.6388456225,
-0.2806531787,
0.9970979095,
0.3760569394,
-0.2217330635,
0.723072648,
-0.181172654,
0.0466435961,
-0.759624064,
-0.0708989128,
-0.5594320893,
-0.3348247111,
-0.4378978014,
-0.465388149,
0.5777485371,
-0.2082004845,
-0.4323903918,
0.0353833102,
-0.8625424504,
0.3276083171,
0.8639453053,
0.386538595,
0.0426239744,
0.1994464397,
-0.1239691675,
-0.2487906218,
-0.5386410952,
-0.3268245459,
1.1767061949,
0.0549570508,
0.48379004,
-0.2820191979,
0.9476047754,
0.4027628601,
0.2186027467,
-0.8535907269,
0.458968848,
-0.0817707628,
-0.427149415,
-0.5069104433,
-0.7140991092,
-0.6618677974,
0.0063400008,
-0.3953697681,
-0.9963329434,
0.0357061885,
0.2378444672,
-0.833652854,
0.2486986518,
-0.8117023706,
0.537697494,
-0.2400567234,
-0.4552488625,
-0.1215380654,
-0.8511049747,
-0.1744109541,
0.1281006485,
0.2631147504,
-0.0931459516,
0.0772358179,
0.7501739264,
-0.2686308324,
0.9787125587,
-0.2712924778,
0.0857190937,
0.4856352508,
0.1078444347,
-0.0154137099,
-0.0117144873,
-0.1301625073,
0.1044415683,
-0.2057388872,
-0.1596440673,
-0.7598510981,
0.342569977,
-1.0317852497,
-0.3151724041,
-0.289650619,
-0.3846254051,
-0.7884289026,
-0.025041502,
0.5170060992,
0.4845177829,
-0.3195033073,
0.1239416003,
0.3609875441,
-0.3114293814,
0.351362139,
0.2691873312,
-0.1382679343,
-0.9844592214,
1.0397086143,
-0.0556098968,
0.4076778889,
0.4994967878,
0.3402680159,
-0.4720157981,
-0.4735296071,
-0.590164423,
0.0850484669,
-0.2695381641,
-0.2920971513,
-0.2769887149,
0.0097041372,
-0.2990525961,
-0.3031651676,
-0.6688570976,
-0.5879141092,
-0.610134244,
-0.3129994571,
0.1657529026,
0.5324483514,
-0.3185913265,
0.4696060121,
-0.7232320309,
0.3025511205,
0.3958078921,
0.6282641888,
0.0117554553,
-0.5944743752,
-0.1472504139,
0.4504309595,
-0.4902632535,
-0.900711298,
0.4258160293,
0.2272165269,
0.2137532383,
0.2641199529,
0.2933653593,
0.6762349606,
-0.4226350486,
0.9060114026,
0.5187566876,
-1.3316377401,
0.689145565,
-0.2889024615,
0.3801332712,
0.7829306722,
-0.1427633762,
-0.5332614779,
-0.6090191603,
-0.5837470293,
-0.7847011685,
0.8520314097,
0.5032821298,
0.1161305308,
0.2061015964,
0.4760523438,
0.1266069561,
0.4094356894,
-0.4977019429,
-0.1667568237,
-0.4917966425,
-0.2566830218,
-0.0787682533,
-0.1014567688,
-0.0427192748,
-0.3595604599,
0.885299921,
-0.1410122365,
0.4406836927,
0.388625741,
0.2629310489,
-0.3104022145,
0.7170989513,
0.5657382011,
0.3076553047,
-0.4079349041,
0.0313618295,
0.057190571,
-0.2040098608,
0.3495098948,
-0.0513915457,
-0.2269200385,
0.2748659551,
-0.0101139797,
1.1368682384,
0.2866596878,
-0.6154802442,
0.3740977347,
-0.0264618341,
-0.2940740287,
-0.0799240097,
0.093898125,
-0.3725388348,
0.0855703875,
0.5503462553,
0.3998752534,
0.1810699999,
-0.4368036389,
0.1899122,
0.1741040051,
-0.6906218529,
-0.6101859808,
0.8825210333,
0.4880581498,
-0.6647590995,
0.2995039821,
-0.455869019,
-0.5186960697,
0.0794990137,
0.1216646954,
1.3318436146,
-0.435413748,
0.5718591213,
0.4132089019,
0.2781450748,
0.174297139,
0.3206737339,
-0.3996691108,
-0.410290271,
-0.4551921189,
-0.5274276137,
-0.8180590272,
-0.1851358116,
-0.7196446657,
0.3885614872,
-0.4721646011,
-0.566516459,
-0.104201369,
-0.2624003887,
-0.4737791121,
0.5014602542,
0.2740885019,
0.3034442961,
-0.4787668586,
0.5964439511,
0.4758484364,
-0.3871461749,
-0.7513524294,
0.0890797228,
0.1150462627,
-0.414680928,
0.044048842,
0.0494714491,
-0.3461001217,
0.0403464325,
-0.468161881,
-0.4625583887,
0.7245389223,
0.7676178813,
-0.4887008369,
0.0343433283,
0.3709321618,
0.8004597425,
-0.1219597757,
0.4294883609,
0.5199778676,
0.1885830611,
0.1902611852,
-1.0470272303,
-0.368399024,
0.0136995232,
0.2248702943,
0.015716061,
-0.4310393035,
0.249469921,
-0.3195997477,
-0.1139623374,
0.0226617325,
0.8498459458,
0.249724403,
0.3301306367,
0.6883541942,
0.4230693877,
0.4930213392,
-0.1088720411,
1.0082449913,
0.00318277,
0.3381471932,
1.2902089357,
-0.1343325526,
0.942651391,
0.5293056965,
-0.3481941521,
0.2732460201,
0.521506846,
0.4741156995,
0.604862988,
0.2635427415,
-0.4657491148,
-0.2589406967,
-0.269390434,
-0.2043098062,
0.532250762,
0.0576573126,
-0.0834131241,
-0.1640282273,
0.0404161923,
-0.1715243757,
-0.0476508066,
-0.052310802,
0.9580521584,
-0.0920130983,
-0.7483814955,
0.619111836,
-0.073736921,
0.77777946,
-0.6270614862,
0.0680742934,
-0.094154045,
-0.1122563407,
-0.1422897577,
-0.6168566346,
0.241855368,
0.3147026002,
-0.1018475145,
-0.3226622939,
0.2299919575,
-0.4813507199,
-0.2970739305,
0.1194323003,
0.3508861065,
0.0678493828,
-0.2807317078,
-0.4397498667,
0.0892232284,
0.285346359,
-0.1701027304,
0.2269296497,
0.436901927,
0.2743145525,
0.4643496871,
0.7217705846,
0.192661047,
-0.2082854211,
0.3099645376,
0.6300938129,
-0.573998332,
-0.6789342165,
-0.7717126012,
0.662587285,
-0.0145276506,
-0.5299848318,
0.3350026906,
0.3997265399,
0.8694727421,
0.0066564484,
1.2149281502,
0.1621937454,
0.7198106647,
-0.151644364,
0.5810835361,
-0.4297764897,
0.123551622,
-0.7574077249,
-0.8548991084,
-0.2308661938,
0.5814343691,
-0.1298675835,
-0.0251904577,
0.4279023409,
0.5421722531,
0.4565736949,
0.1449825764,
0.5067706108,
0.116890423,
0.3247339129,
0.5181610584,
0.7721114159,
-0.2780207694,
0.7080042362,
-0.3587935269,
-0.3959535956,
-0.1110609099,
-0.8972938657,
-0.445807606,
-0.7020730376,
-0.4632472992,
-0.2499542981,
0.1349707097,
1.2246640921,
0.8434298038,
-0.7012004256,
-0.3082648218,
-0.1278799772,
-0.1159892678,
-0.1373071373,
-0.2511814237,
-0.0637851059,
-0.2669868469,
-0.9206252694,
0.4326032698,
0.628290832,
0.2624475658,
-0.1748797297,
-0.1704848111,
0.2736814916,
0.2957782447,
0.4793915153,
0.3807765245,
-0.7929475904,
-0.4550884962,
-0.0555698089,
0.2443590164,
0.1024619266,
0.6961188316,
-0.9772040248,
1.053670764,
0.1321332455,
0.6212599277,
0.4157803953,
0.0623431206,
0.7535288334,
-1.1566337347,
0.2716902792,
0.5113672614,
0.1045557037,
0.5761190057,
-0.1065127328,
0.4322170019,
0.234649241,
-0.4003353417,
-0.8488465548,
0.0440370888,
-1.2370516062,
-0.0443139598,
1.1352614164,
0.1750692725,
-0.181475237,
0.0387722813,
-0.4781682789,
0.5313475132,
-0.8330484629,
1.0416660309,
0.5155790448,
-0.2350955158,
0.1178615317,
-0.3072696924,
0.3458288014,
0.5842559338,
-0.9729192853,
-0.0140050007,
0.6772084236,
0.1117640734,
0.0500547551,
0.6499326229,
0.0738110989,
0.35126701,
-0.2015925199,
0.3057380915,
-0.0256353449,
-0.2267947346,
-0.3560170531,
-0.0627125949,
0.0045919539,
-0.4605098367
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06559v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06559v1
|
Harnessing Business and Media Insights with Large Language Models
| 2024-06-02T06:24:38 | 2024-06-02T06:24:38 |
Yujia Bao, Ankit Parag Shah, Neeru Narang, Jonathan Rivers, Rajeev Maksey, Lan Guan, Louise N. Barrere, Shelley Evenson, Rahul Basole, Connie Miao, Ankit Mehta, Fabien Boulay, Su Min Park, Natalie E. Pearson, Eldhose Joy, Tiger He, Sumiran Thakur, Koustav Ghosal, Josh On, Phoebe Morrison, Tim Major, Eva Siqi Wang, Gina Escobar, Jiaheng Wei, Tharindu Cyril Weerasooriya, Queena Song, Daria Lashkevich, Clare Chen, Gyuhak Kim, Dengpan Yin, Don Hejna, Mo Nomeli, Wei Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This paper introduces Fortune Analytics Language Model (FALM). FALM empowers
users with direct access to comprehensive business analysis, including market
trends, company performance metrics, and expert insights. Unlike generic LLMs,
FALM leverages a curated knowledge base built from professional journalism,
enabling it to deliver precise and in-depth answers to intricate business
questions. Users can further leverage natural language queries to directly
visualize financial data, generating insightful charts and graphs to understand
trends across diverse business sectors clearly. FALM fosters user trust and
ensures output accuracy through three novel methods: 1) Time-aware reasoning
guarantees accurate event registration and prioritizes recent updates. 2)
Thematic trend analysis explicitly examines topic evolution over time,
providing insights into emerging business landscapes. 3) Content referencing
and task decomposition enhance answer fidelity and data visualization accuracy.
We conduct both automated and human evaluations, demonstrating FALM's
significant performance improvements over baseline methods while prioritizing
responsible AI practices. These benchmarks establish FALM as a cutting-edge LLM
in the business and media domains, with exceptional accuracy and
trustworthiness.
|
[
-0.0414207242,
-0.8649073243,
0.5331215858,
0.3355026841,
-0.4200330973,
0.5349166989,
-0.0519828051,
-0.4923073351,
0.3173880875,
0.8379454017,
-0.7439072728,
-0.6197338104,
-0.5434914231,
-0.1887873858,
-0.4331044257,
1.1819933653,
0.3492410183,
0.016062323,
-0.1482411325,
-0.3286157548,
-0.180441916,
-0.616424799,
-0.7705536485,
-0.0938493237,
0.2970681787,
0.2290165424,
1.0664045811,
0.4421134293,
0.4696136415,
0.2650817633,
0.2386458516,
0.5699411631,
-0.7202395201,
-0.0265971329,
-0.2066678703,
-0.2443217337,
-0.7410869598,
0.1622900516,
0.3903999925,
0.8376579881,
-0.1558618993,
0.3982801735,
-0.1208788753,
0.9677872658,
-0.1751687825,
0.5399739742,
-0.8543935418,
-0.2992908359,
-0.1534778327,
-0.2821559012,
-0.416323334,
-0.4971327186,
0.3516238332,
-0.5120827556,
-0.1276935637,
0.5911732316,
0.8465816975,
0.2737541199,
-0.6077604294,
-0.4199268818,
-0.7356541753,
0.8601173759,
-0.3049111068,
0.6696559787,
0.3307320476,
0.3459231555,
0.0989503786,
-0.6727241278,
-0.2584477663,
-0.2341825217,
-0.04363662,
-0.1114930063,
-0.5206068754,
-0.2877554893,
-0.0123254796,
0.3537959158,
-0.3920759261,
-0.1521841139,
-0.2474571466,
-0.1574766338,
1.1141631603,
0.4149314761,
-0.0062299375,
0.1662468612,
-0.1318166256,
0.2109789103,
-0.6166688204,
-0.2298603505,
0.1910857856,
0.2289270014,
-0.1368809044,
0.3769392073,
-0.2312155664,
0.7596638203,
-0.0086806826,
-0.188520506,
0.1406030059,
-0.3646289706,
-0.4692394733,
-0.0334929675,
0.67647928,
0.5225034952,
0.3167584836,
-0.4770019948,
-0.0553901829,
-0.3648923337,
0.1705452949,
-0.6885067225,
-0.3652260602,
0.3401905894,
-0.6943044066,
-0.1484642029,
0.1252197325,
-1.0064923763,
-0.8883075714,
-0.5253607035,
0.3230040073,
-0.252099067,
-0.1331804544,
0.1375342011,
0.0612622499,
0.4278143048,
0.5761685371,
-0.6360769868,
0.1531166881,
0.7701615691,
0.887947917,
-0.334379822,
0.0245651361,
-0.8528571725,
0.3074654341,
-0.6642389297,
0.4498631954,
-0.2754811645,
-0.3177383542,
0.1408658028,
-0.2690327764,
0.2830708623,
-0.3545375466,
0.1962089539,
-0.8293184042,
0.1448803097,
-0.2607318461,
-0.6197677851,
-0.3605293334,
0.0772568062,
-0.8712500334,
0.6764358878,
0.0218027588,
-0.603828609,
0.7262801528,
-0.9944331646,
-0.4301333129,
0.2187957764,
-0.1749579161,
-0.2245643586,
0.0794757232,
0.3414787054,
0.6720228791,
-0.5801703334,
0.5459313989,
-0.1847530603,
0.2042111903,
0.4062414765,
-0.4404453635,
0.8500619531,
0.5068613291,
-0.2227382362,
0.2664864063,
-0.8572024703,
-0.1547738463,
0.3163686693,
-0.1302198172,
-0.4128299952,
0.1908449829,
0.1735340357,
-0.1330871731,
0.4884367287,
-0.2876784503,
0.0806548521,
-0.2258645743,
0.4018344283,
0.5753359795,
0.100025773,
0.3648341894,
-0.237344861,
0.3941767216,
-0.2938770652,
0.1815249622,
-0.1845048219,
-0.3363158405,
-0.6505727172,
-0.2664824128,
0.0582317375,
0.520123899,
-0.5241599083,
0.4266733825,
-0.6891462803,
-0.7638930678,
-0.5744467378,
0.3185849786,
-0.187565431,
0.2453599423,
0.1830553114,
-0.0741165355,
-0.4035122991,
-1.0384993553,
-0.5776978731,
-0.1085367203,
-0.1159968227,
0.3860011995,
0.1781637818,
-0.1004790142,
1.2482079268,
-0.9068879485,
-0.2585392296,
-0.6619842052,
0.2741612792,
0.492998004,
-0.0445915833,
0.519851923,
-1.127010107,
-0.4729718566,
0.0789699182,
-0.5111679435,
-0.1901244819,
-0.4224456847,
-0.2133015245,
0.5445165038,
0.3118289709,
-0.3766981959,
0.3481765091,
0.4270746112,
-0.6679626107,
0.3541921079,
0.171829477,
0.1781334728,
-1.0388854742,
0.2837374806,
0.1718085855,
-0.3739875853,
-0.7509406805,
-0.2598308921,
0.0072091292,
-0.2483098954,
-0.1359772235,
0.7738713622,
-0.3380828798,
-0.2868718207,
-0.1359511018,
0.0743296668,
0.2159439474,
0.1941515207,
0.0189134255,
0.8024308085,
0.311001569,
-0.5314850211,
0.3973996341,
0.2426359206,
-0.7081560493,
0.3061221838,
-0.5732060671,
0.1317372769,
0.0225337204,
0.038170591,
-1.1238526106,
-0.1864841431,
-0.140891701,
-0.5466290712,
0.1646299213,
0.2330705076,
-0.7538847327,
-0.1778674722,
-0.0552719235,
-0.3957363665,
0.5195011497,
-0.4354313016,
1.0763106346,
0.5873381495,
-0.1980360299,
-0.2945068181,
-0.8321672082,
0.1839971244,
-0.3145244718,
-0.9443200231,
0.0803738907,
-0.1482154131,
-0.732943356,
-0.0788013563,
-0.4052869081,
-0.3174695373,
0.3351426721,
0.0148816826,
0.6566274762,
-0.161601156,
-0.0455099158,
-0.3532446921,
0.0888706073,
0.2282341719,
-0.2930827439,
0.5512086749,
-0.1991563737,
-0.0360874124,
-0.4147549272,
0.2966865599,
1.1593943834,
-0.3501521945,
0.9313673973,
0.3746341765,
-0.2120917886,
-0.1106220707,
-0.8615726233,
0.0527642034,
-0.5062714219,
0.2925659716,
-0.0992492288,
-0.7984101176,
0.6370843649,
0.109324418,
0.4656115472,
0.5105678439,
0.7334498167,
0.239663586,
0.9703049064,
0.9357303381,
-0.4807840884,
0.3934637308,
-0.1865156144,
0.5397199392,
0.033343982,
-0.4375681281,
-0.4023682475,
0.0144391619,
-0.1781762093,
-0.2848798037,
0.2198216021,
-0.2844511271,
-0.2579090595,
-0.1507226229,
-0.0757580698,
0.4263106883,
0.5448374152,
-0.34589836,
0.5383421183,
0.1023861989,
0.3264050186,
-0.2124651223,
-0.3679724932,
-0.5047675967,
0.9147649407,
0.4859004915,
1.193838954,
0.1996327043,
0.3069324195,
0.671975255,
0.4726197422,
-0.8720124364,
0.4175056517,
-0.2975604832,
-0.8227427006,
-0.286744982,
-0.3290273249,
-0.4313569367,
0.1844825149,
-0.0976326242,
-0.8038243651,
-0.0732446387,
0.1178663224,
-0.463984102,
0.2323030978,
-0.7356408238,
0.6717289686,
-0.6022069454,
-0.6179212928,
-0.2084808052,
-0.4133406281,
0.2983011007,
-0.3347548842,
0.3648199439,
-0.0877442732,
-0.279886812,
0.8301930428,
-0.3315446973,
0.7330783606,
0.0807115585,
-0.1048910767,
0.1714477539,
0.229954645,
0.4819765985,
-0.0365490988,
-0.1053805947,
0.4445078969,
-0.3170406222,
-0.2364680469,
-0.7063586712,
0.5644584894,
-0.5982202888,
-0.6905919909,
-0.5119608045,
-0.7671456337,
-0.5704061389,
0.0975435376,
-0.117266871,
0.2742168605,
-0.1301081181,
0.6029464602,
0.4491234124,
-0.2182846963,
0.2613443732,
0.9929735065,
-0.5787008405,
-0.5461767912,
0.6672998667,
0.2932184637,
0.2082136571,
0.4715261459,
0.1394472867,
-0.6841725111,
-0.5316033959,
-0.3203523755,
0.3677320182,
-0.6472660303,
-0.1818972677,
-0.7665928006,
-0.0700607076,
-0.4823349714,
-0.3484497666,
-0.2593718469,
-0.1096861586,
-0.0605015717,
-0.2141078562,
0.55928725,
0.5616582036,
0.2342536449,
0.2044148147,
-0.8630267978,
0.1568621099,
0.2358204275,
0.30061239,
0.1008244231,
-0.2497826219,
-0.4935591221,
-0.1350482702,
-0.1621226072,
-0.9864382744,
0.6954439282,
0.0793913007,
0.6153056026,
0.5057376027,
-0.1113790125,
0.7506682277,
-0.3350812793,
1.1309257746,
0.1349784136,
-1.2535331249,
0.6699210405,
-0.5083299875,
0.0878612474,
0.6199855208,
0.724270463,
-0.5557253957,
-0.1529026926,
-0.632619679,
-0.9261310697,
0.7015140057,
-0.0291001648,
0.1184423119,
0.1183273792,
0.1277281642,
0.304959327,
0.5923256874,
-0.6165688634,
-0.3897123933,
-0.0658312738,
-0.1914235353,
-0.1459717751,
-0.2018388063,
0.0785303041,
-0.3331650496,
0.709150672,
-0.1188488156,
-0.0737178847,
0.0438410901,
-0.0237702448,
-0.0596065633,
-0.126073584,
0.2739528716,
1.2188638449,
-0.1457060874,
-0.3148738444,
0.0353243276,
-0.3898155689,
-0.3748956323,
-0.0049609989,
-0.0193304401,
0.1117497683,
0.345397234,
0.780195713,
0.045854494,
-0.8887683153,
0.3696399927,
0.0514650345,
-0.0992433131,
-0.4970154464,
-0.0530080236,
0.2770173848,
0.3166716397,
1.0316169262,
-0.4090427458,
0.2937936187,
-0.6632464528,
0.3135563135,
0.5407751203,
-0.2359220088,
-0.0353776217,
0.9306073785,
0.3744350374,
-0.1196937636,
0.5876809359,
0.0249565095,
-0.4473850131,
0.6236081123,
0.439591825,
0.8711580634,
-0.1373969465,
0.1830199808,
-0.150971517,
0.4096635878,
0.1776555181,
0.3076565564,
0.175955385,
-0.6995250583,
-0.7477538586,
-0.710067153,
-0.6619296074,
0.5835749507,
-0.5672952533,
0.2925016284,
-0.6065354347,
0.0398576111,
0.3731115758,
0.4809720218,
-0.7734536529,
0.1958928555,
0.1274826676,
1.2222211361,
-0.8432183862,
0.7916693091,
0.665958941,
-0.3948171139,
-0.7083678842,
0.1276883483,
0.3576422334,
-0.8850318789,
0.8411380053,
0.1294813901,
-0.2289326787,
0.0023667158,
-0.7789962888,
-1.0125985146,
1.3203039169,
0.2236848623,
-0.4957454801,
0.2463172674,
-0.0297110267,
0.4026329219,
-0.7223348022,
-0.2519480586,
0.7579903007,
0.4163397849,
0.1775151044,
-0.6715777516,
-0.186083883,
-0.0206340421,
-0.2912767529,
0.3389154375,
-0.8277671337,
0.5548164845,
-0.0757054687,
-0.0799576268,
-0.2847601175,
0.8917726278,
-0.0059782858,
0.8636465669,
0.4148952961,
0.0873687714,
0.925011456,
0.0480949767,
1.1871746778,
-0.5181229115,
0.2768932283,
0.9964483976,
-0.4410790801,
0.6942138672,
0.2182993442,
-0.2089771628,
0.3897990882,
0.41866377,
-0.2741744816,
0.5127375126,
-0.0923824087,
0.0650010556,
-0.2742395997,
-0.1538508087,
0.0884646401,
0.63107723,
0.5865662694,
-0.4616681337,
-0.0632391572,
-0.2407768965,
0.5152825713,
0.0851783901,
-0.5701442957,
0.5993445516,
-0.0269878954,
-0.4520295858,
0.1122878864,
-0.07138028,
0.6664337516,
-0.9763894081,
0.2560981214,
-0.3731870949,
-0.0253413506,
-0.1077342853,
-0.6618124843,
0.7248882055,
0.1768896133,
-0.0321598537,
-0.1890411973,
0.7398967147,
-0.3170700669,
-0.4149538577,
0.1967135817,
0.6590924859,
0.0831052288,
-0.1825112402,
-0.6583393216,
0.3171080351,
0.2663908303,
-0.2412999421,
-0.0089174137,
0.3636126816,
0.036864955,
0.9717188478,
0.6925216913,
-0.0132814636,
-0.0676581264,
-0.0229825918,
0.5642109513,
-0.7646089792,
-0.7868712544,
-1.1228135824,
0.4677990079,
-0.5744356513,
-0.2933929861,
0.8931251764,
0.7720004916,
0.2618794739,
-0.0644390732,
0.7957290411,
0.0793285817,
0.402487874,
-0.5733649731,
1.0629092455,
-0.7387956977,
0.1863489896,
-0.142370075,
-0.8028152585,
-0.4255947769,
0.4073855579,
-0.7151081562,
-0.1055274159,
0.4735177755,
0.5715299249,
0.0776466057,
0.2571715415,
0.5158022046,
0.4050112069,
0.3739121556,
0.0499854237,
0.4451205134,
0.0993495509,
0.632593751,
-0.0256674998,
-0.2554093897,
-0.5629695654,
-1.0749564171,
-0.8553176522,
-0.6945800185,
-0.5229266882,
-0.1995774657,
0.0248850472,
1.0103007555,
0.7489418983,
-0.6367865801,
-0.2904899418,
0.2998412251,
-0.0087090321,
0.0246255472,
-0.3782941699,
0.4934549332,
-0.1468144357,
-0.6551968455,
0.2470971048,
0.5299873352,
-0.1455480754,
-0.6129610538,
0.1649588197,
0.05630235,
0.5069130063,
0.8571927547,
-0.114910543,
-0.7275493741,
-0.1225642711,
0.2178120017,
0.0481218472,
-0.2378854454,
0.9047837257,
-0.5874954462,
0.1212893128,
0.4587407112,
1.0214771032,
0.2836767137,
0.1469306052,
0.5070916414,
-0.4832126498,
-0.1396352202,
0.2100672722,
0.3269621134,
0.4462801516,
-0.7375192642,
0.7370734811,
0.0359947383,
-0.5460295081,
-0.5174942017,
0.1605654657,
-1.0344623327,
-0.3811635077,
1.3257223368,
0.1544178873,
-0.404134661,
-0.2910856307,
-0.0826618597,
-0.1454993635,
-0.7534555197,
0.6918005347,
1.090220809,
-0.1216172129,
0.0079907952,
-0.9098689556,
0.3455091119,
0.1532613039,
-0.7855976224,
0.2902921736,
0.8629446626,
0.4020504653,
0.2595275939,
0.8734075427,
-0.0729974881,
-0.0340779945,
-0.1901338696,
-0.3047554791,
-0.1769455075,
-0.3911088705,
-0.1578282416,
0.3260606527,
0.1748889983,
-0.1746250391
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00628v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00628v1
|
Transforming Computer Security and Public Trust Through the Exploration of Fine-Tuning Large Language Models
| 2024-06-02T06:10:31 | 2024-06-02T06:10:31 |
Garrett Crumrine, Izzat Alsmadi, Jesus Guerrero, Yuvaraj Munian
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.CY, cs.LG, B.8.0; I.2.7; I.2.8; I.2.11; J.0; K.4.2; K.4.1
|
Large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized how we interact with
machines. However, this technological advancement has been paralleled by the
emergence of "Mallas," malicious services operating underground that exploit
LLMs for nefarious purposes. Such services create malware, phishing attacks,
and deceptive websites, escalating the cyber security threats landscape. This
paper delves into the proliferation of Mallas by examining the use of various
pre-trained language models and their efficiency and vulnerabilities when
misused. Building on a dataset from the Common Vulnerabilities and Exposures
(CVE) program, it explores fine-tuning methodologies to generate code and
explanatory text related to identified vulnerabilities. This research aims to
shed light on the operational strategies and exploitation techniques of Mallas,
leading to the development of more secure and trustworthy AI applications. The
paper concludes by emphasizing the need for further research, enhanced
safeguards, and ethical guidelines to mitigate the risks associated with the
malicious application of LLMs.
|
[
-0.3855642676,
-0.9588614702,
0.635886848,
-0.1996715218,
-0.0319076627,
0.1220629886,
-0.0633308142,
-0.6598654985,
-0.2297170013,
0.8485518098,
-0.2844645977,
-0.3264157176,
-0.860730052,
-0.1859199703,
-0.6519423723,
1.0899866819,
0.3108452559,
-0.1827526689,
0.0613007098,
0.2665160298,
-0.52246207,
-0.8811261058,
-0.7045809031,
-0.0217899512,
0.3225567043,
0.3680429757,
0.8312224746,
0.3728513122,
0.7694378495,
0.3714832664,
0.2269460857,
0.1876140684,
-0.7562476397,
-0.0478620231,
-0.2319169044,
-0.8459793925,
-0.2217419744,
0.0182155874,
0.147177577,
0.2385757715,
-0.0507876053,
0.3956217468,
-0.0880711377,
0.5381578207,
-0.8676925302,
-0.1420857608,
-1.2441086769,
-0.3930851519,
-0.4995775819,
-0.4698433578,
-0.5032129288,
-0.4839359224,
0.1174888909,
-0.3895825744,
-0.3138954639,
0.0767723247,
0.4886958897,
0.2679878771,
-0.2403002381,
-0.1606732756,
-1.0381166935,
0.988853991,
-0.5561570525,
0.2724158466,
0.4125249982,
0.5142424107,
-0.4059465826,
-0.5566727519,
-0.4118565917,
-0.1755740643,
0.1801834106,
-0.6185771823,
-0.4781369567,
-0.1499001533,
0.3073938191,
0.0180576835,
-0.5144905448,
0.470126003,
-0.6875579357,
-0.1376372725,
0.6924619079,
0.2053610682,
0.4511844516,
0.2530819774,
-0.1419999897,
-0.39399454,
-1.0652644634,
0.2071307302,
0.4981633425,
0.3028757572,
-0.0504329689,
0.4025838375,
0.2586172819,
0.5866633654,
-0.2558465004,
-0.4062396288,
-0.0778142735,
0.1074363217,
-0.7137684822,
-0.1423492432,
0.481808275,
0.2332317084,
0.6673091054,
-0.2387287617,
-0.1490428299,
0.210807234,
0.7360358834,
-0.5877116323,
-0.1303348094,
0.2666303515,
-0.3167019784,
-0.6876685619,
0.2295482755,
-0.8811292648,
-0.7080384493,
-0.2734790444,
0.1882221848,
-0.3926057816,
-0.0664399564,
0.2303818911,
0.1628957242,
0.1670169979,
0.2555186152,
-0.5930953622,
0.4427860379,
0.9526023269,
0.5031992197,
-0.0055143978,
-0.1638485491,
-0.5149434805,
0.2566795051,
-0.3180297613,
0.3052224815,
-0.6506080031,
-0.5114034414,
0.3766267598,
-0.1175991371,
0.1307127178,
-0.5319171548,
0.4446567893,
-0.7529472113,
-0.1471264958,
0.1681898832,
-0.0042659007,
-0.1172631681,
0.4223334193,
-0.6261216998,
0.8460754156,
-0.1628731042,
-0.6680724621,
-0.0304439086,
-0.6624422669,
-0.4380957484,
-0.2843354344,
0.0689350069,
-0.4511097074,
0.2075208575,
0.4176586568,
0.6980930567,
-0.3858648539,
0.0721561909,
-0.4371064603,
-0.2866073549,
0.686879456,
-0.4083537757,
0.7184532881,
0.3927544951,
-0.2553378344,
0.057082139,
-0.7903628945,
-0.1380957961,
0.2856196165,
0.1429964006,
-0.5505097508,
0.0033506805,
-0.0014408997,
0.169931978,
0.5005558729,
-0.2268920392,
-0.0223809984,
-0.6399941444,
0.5532619357,
0.9380760193,
0.1084690019,
0.3592323661,
-0.4124086797,
0.3807992935,
0.1074237302,
0.8035559654,
-0.1212284416,
-0.3071193099,
-0.4367789328,
-0.1452744752,
-0.2440909445,
0.6979775429,
-0.1073323339,
0.252022177,
-0.1994796097,
-0.753413856,
-0.3975326121,
0.1236186177,
0.0804727152,
0.0173343346,
0.3459099531,
-0.0110400831,
-0.4504849017,
-0.8893164396,
-0.2943512201,
-0.1643702835,
0.0183475222,
0.2539767325,
0.3083659708,
-0.6564556956,
0.5389894843,
-0.517511189,
-0.0045390469,
0.1703695655,
-0.016468212,
0.0092803575,
0.4525558054,
0.5747893453,
-0.6803321838,
-0.1563619971,
-0.0158555824,
-0.3338467181,
0.1338849366,
-0.2132815421,
0.0940440595,
-0.013500521,
0.7364072204,
-0.413719058,
0.4211809337,
0.577763617,
0.0712076649,
0.6828181744,
-0.1036588103,
0.2013802081,
-1.1286605597,
0.1381664425,
-0.2245031595,
-0.3115825951,
-0.7131589651,
0.5461704135,
-0.1555371135,
-0.3655942678,
-0.4422315657,
0.2543875277,
-0.387052089,
0.0104835834,
-0.3600879908,
0.2448817343,
-0.2749779224,
0.0264560785,
-0.740722239,
0.7831889391,
0.9439989328,
-0.5984392762,
0.1953800768,
-0.1540491134,
-0.2069098055,
0.3392491937,
-0.5175751448,
0.4137558341,
0.1603582501,
-0.1350865811,
-0.6336413622,
-0.0308478437,
0.0748549774,
-0.2645943761,
0.3932538331,
0.0794427022,
-0.7438482642,
-0.3144336939,
-0.3869768977,
0.4422405362,
0.5243544579,
-0.4718007147,
0.4029427469,
0.874938786,
-0.057538487,
-0.6765699387,
-0.6375835538,
0.3776113391,
-0.5072759986,
-0.783206284,
-0.0564819947,
0.0533465259,
-0.7233020067,
-0.5041808486,
0.1092380658,
-0.192842111,
0.7150395513,
0.5758399963,
0.1824912131,
-0.142246455,
-0.0616937354,
-0.1784851104,
0.0260014366,
0.3450698555,
-0.3041745126,
0.5541321039,
-0.1895544827,
-0.5699055791,
-0.6321450472,
0.3383072317,
0.8560759425,
-0.4505322278,
0.7364413142,
0.3837912977,
-0.4940132499,
-0.1674418151,
-0.6528977156,
-0.3544446826,
-0.529471457,
0.3425258398,
-0.1879636049,
-1.2219369411,
0.4243903458,
-0.4473460913,
0.214738667,
0.2718704343,
0.5131299496,
0.2948959172,
0.9418829679,
1.0837938786,
-0.4964224994,
0.4237201512,
-0.009922198,
0.5725902319,
-0.398322314,
-0.2627020478,
-0.7998832464,
-0.1239536032,
-0.8181707859,
-0.6259695888,
0.3548246324,
0.1467935741,
-0.320037365,
0.4187675714,
-0.4984193146,
0.580237031,
0.3714439869,
-0.0790649727,
0.2240609229,
-0.0851940736,
0.3621558547,
0.3068954349,
-0.1618898064,
-1.0048453808,
1.4287828207,
0.5774806738,
1.0369449854,
0.297080636,
0.7216829062,
0.2299558669,
0.0670911595,
-0.357003808,
0.6336780787,
-0.182482034,
-0.4885996282,
-0.3423627019,
-0.0335069448,
-1.2029405832,
-0.3241516948,
-0.2541469932,
-1.4897656441,
-0.0692061484,
-0.1134350076,
-0.4513329268,
0.4921670556,
-0.5297192931,
0.4949913621,
-0.2458622903,
-0.1185060143,
-0.8064801097,
-0.4859005809,
0.6607599854,
-0.3715903759,
0.2611457705,
-0.0709215775,
0.1358561069,
0.4924907982,
-0.1240249202,
1.0148948431,
0.1069197208,
-0.3573384583,
0.1256129146,
0.3574399054,
0.8570717573,
0.3326337337,
0.0736692697,
0.1597691774,
0.0910880342,
-0.3791097701,
-0.5569435358,
0.9788407087,
-1.085123539,
-0.9308661819,
-0.3509124219,
-0.4119314253,
-0.379063189,
0.1578468084,
-0.355035603,
0.2444451749,
-0.5712676644,
0.0535127558,
0.9678533077,
-0.3153964877,
0.2177925557,
0.3322856426,
-0.246643424,
0.1079666391,
0.6406074762,
-0.2445867807,
0.2059347928,
0.5198459625,
-0.0132789584,
0.0464958102,
-0.8433503509,
-0.0078989817,
0.0689394474,
-0.4045242369,
-0.4310393631,
-0.4783110917,
-0.2831721902,
-0.628148973,
-0.5354220867,
-0.2565551102,
-0.2212792635,
-0.5556246638,
-0.1263232976,
0.5538758636,
0.9130965471,
0.083246462,
0.5554723144,
-0.8191704154,
0.0979412645,
0.3160166442,
0.1639133096,
-0.0732855722,
-0.316796571,
-0.3012980223,
-0.0160023365,
-0.2668215334,
-0.9232527614,
0.4124074578,
-0.2900731564,
0.562392056,
0.5147905946,
-0.2280933708,
0.5730167031,
-0.3964476287,
0.8294116855,
0.0845173895,
-0.8032768369,
0.4686499834,
-0.3435554802,
0.0090083713,
0.5005679727,
0.3382308781,
-0.2981387973,
-0.5837882161,
-0.5529011488,
-0.699637115,
0.4345691502,
0.0763653889,
0.3139770031,
0.2483183891,
0.2715531588,
0.0274079554,
0.1029605791,
-0.4274250269,
-0.2299958616,
-0.1229360327,
0.1683552414,
-0.1073766649,
-0.2431631386,
-0.4705003202,
0.1289613694,
0.7604675293,
0.0046279151,
0.0628887415,
-0.2607317865,
-0.1336786449,
-0.0917901546,
0.5169578195,
0.7469031811,
0.6731225252,
0.0369188972,
0.2834008932,
0.108649388,
-0.4813335538,
-0.0911511183,
0.0335356742,
0.0274996776,
-0.544060111,
-0.0825637951,
0.611671865,
0.0341280065,
-0.8790886402,
0.3317864537,
-0.0113869933,
0.2151578814,
-0.468015641,
0.2671914101,
-0.1223372594,
0.4084388316,
0.426560998,
0.2223322839,
0.0084474729,
-0.661724329,
0.3390981853,
0.6791588068,
-0.1843166947,
-0.3524666429,
0.3047720492,
0.1044950411,
-0.4947225749,
0.3105259538,
0.1834700257,
-0.3742922246,
0.3420741856,
0.5861824155,
1.0356949568,
-0.2769501209,
0.0830791518,
0.1524469256,
0.9012092352,
0.0727018267,
-0.0343574956,
0.3049078584,
-0.5107980967,
-0.1932103187,
-0.6792700291,
-0.1289688647,
0.6597380042,
-0.3985283971,
0.2639448941,
-0.8477862477,
-0.2047759444,
-0.1603780091,
0.0985682383,
-0.7103956342,
0.0283537284,
0.3188201785,
0.8995818496,
-0.7551036477,
0.8512567878,
0.4223099947,
-0.0492368452,
-0.7759417892,
0.1663710177,
0.0696114227,
-1.0560276508,
0.4402405322,
0.0859313309,
-0.1905714422,
-0.175488621,
-0.7971307635,
-0.9610649943,
0.9134889841,
0.4617376924,
-0.5793053508,
0.1093340442,
0.5562324524,
0.5392666459,
-0.2998253107,
-0.0878561065,
0.7532867789,
0.5281212926,
-0.5398325324,
-0.9207036495,
0.2055234909,
-0.002989606,
-0.0340841599,
0.2908514142,
-0.4606950581,
0.6850370169,
-0.2332299352,
-0.152780205,
0.0456867591,
0.4634882808,
0.1770288348,
0.0918207616,
0.3004968166,
0.4573862851,
0.9648302794,
0.2481947392,
0.9029747248,
-0.33891958,
-0.2462649941,
0.8964626193,
-0.2203300744,
0.8586845398,
0.6266060472,
-0.1425470263,
0.5416769981,
0.2934234738,
-0.0953063369,
0.1352164,
0.4424501359,
-0.0586641617,
-0.169312343,
-0.0162709747,
-0.1461444497,
0.6203933358,
0.5328769684,
-0.430750519,
-0.3015700877,
-0.018791154,
0.1798672825,
0.3061071932,
-0.4952724874,
0.6694246531,
0.2423255295,
-0.4547872841,
0.4747189581,
0.3904551864,
0.5724263191,
-0.633625567,
0.3549985588,
0.3612786233,
0.1436263174,
-0.0508499667,
-0.5365518928,
0.4061661065,
0.1295414567,
-0.0344879404,
-0.0585930236,
0.8533935547,
0.1490702927,
-0.2633477151,
0.2901477814,
0.3363791406,
0.1032307371,
-0.2841590643,
-0.8315984607,
0.1961705536,
-0.1908531338,
-0.0112586999,
0.692094028,
0.3884115517,
-0.2510034442,
0.8317712545,
1.0327705145,
0.0575252026,
0.2485889345,
0.0107005937,
0.9542320967,
-0.3760347366,
-0.37693277,
-1.0410081148,
0.2718951702,
-0.1271316707,
-0.1356385201,
0.9110133648,
0.5129144788,
0.8040799499,
0.0632813796,
0.7582836747,
0.4188403487,
0.3263320327,
-0.4251990318,
0.894218266,
-0.2407369316,
0.444475621,
-0.2189468741,
-0.6060961485,
-0.3483389914,
0.1841178685,
-0.4930392206,
-0.2227540165,
0.406516999,
1.1356532574,
0.0849247277,
-0.1173950508,
0.5935462117,
0.3799529672,
0.5435292125,
0.4052829444,
0.6087776423,
-0.3811058998,
0.5197627544,
0.0400222056,
-0.2075445354,
-0.4332498014,
-0.7373067737,
-1.0418651104,
-0.5361101031,
0.0085050026,
-0.2832628489,
0.3173035979,
0.5661388636,
0.6484296918,
-0.9340004921,
-0.1824158579,
0.0429040082,
0.0287561342,
0.0022484811,
-0.1932094991,
0.0311652999,
-0.2959885299,
-0.5977458358,
0.5517136455,
0.4081432819,
0.2239978015,
-0.7717002034,
0.2118919045,
-0.0985822454,
0.4911800921,
0.5080265999,
0.4200939536,
-0.5975306034,
-0.3152776361,
0.0869679153,
-0.3850648105,
-0.1710187644,
0.992855072,
-0.6450181007,
0.1275832802,
0.3974004388,
1.0024185181,
0.0939049497,
-0.1502923071,
0.718954742,
-0.5617320538,
0.0599068664,
0.2160409391,
0.229162544,
0.3528231978,
-0.5553123951,
0.0645509288,
-0.1543865353,
-0.7322417498,
-1.2105550766,
0.4482506216,
-0.974188745,
-0.5184940696,
0.9729949832,
0.1044596732,
-0.4652298391,
-0.3740771115,
-0.153885901,
0.1983379275,
-0.2836530507,
1.2216188908,
0.2942096591,
0.3710583448,
0.2306277752,
-0.497400403,
0.7815495133,
0.1602871418,
-1.0450972319,
0.3270821869,
0.1789524406,
0.129207328,
0.3501463532,
0.3919500411,
-0.2726991475,
0.0830667689,
-0.2395774424,
-0.3103096187,
-0.0821789652,
-0.5428516269,
-0.3310682178,
0.2914383709,
0.2360678315,
0.1292192489
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00627v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00627v1
|
Prompt Framework for Role-playing: Generation and Evaluation
| 2024-06-02T06:09:56 | 2024-06-02T06:09:56 |
Xun Liu, Zhengwei Ni
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLM) have demonstrated remarkable abilities in
generating natural language, understanding user instruction, and mimicking
human language use. These capabilities have garnered considerable interest in
applications such as role-playing. However, the process of collecting
individual role scripts (or profiles) data and manually evaluating the
performance can be costly. We introduce a framework that uses prompts to
leverage the state-of-the-art (SOTA) LLMs to construct role-playing dialogue
datasets and evaluate the role-playing performance. Additionally, we employ
recall-oriented evaluation Rouge-L metric to support the result of the LLM
evaluator.
|
[
-0.1698889881,
-0.733720243,
0.5953192115,
0.4967933297,
0.1730650067,
-0.0755396187,
0.0521803014,
0.1410653889,
0.1022187173,
0.7386564016,
-1.0315481424,
-0.4702268839,
-0.1654851288,
0.2799045146,
-0.203732267,
0.860490799,
0.3575130999,
0.1916713566,
-0.3501520753,
0.0987163484,
-0.8348324895,
-0.3503084779,
-1.164562583,
-0.1489662975,
0.471475631,
0.7999447584,
0.3436904252,
0.5085015893,
0.1828313768,
0.3332722783,
0.2472105473,
0.055433657,
-0.6334210634,
0.7006302476,
-0.2074948996,
-0.5011395812,
-0.4452924132,
0.1047645733,
0.7585339546,
0.249778375,
-0.1419236064,
0.4035230279,
-0.0938287228,
0.279753536,
-0.3178276718,
0.3508332968,
-0.3281962276,
0.100507237,
-0.1020546257,
-0.4871259928,
-0.4960737526,
-0.4400404394,
0.1187984571,
-0.6639870405,
0.0150040556,
0.1476768106,
0.281855315,
-0.021561522,
-0.2135397643,
-0.6018895507,
-0.4753879607,
0.6465883851,
-0.5947271585,
0.1184003204,
0.4150882959,
0.7127557397,
-0.3050259054,
-0.6096025705,
-0.466124028,
-0.5796838403,
0.1843987703,
0.1901275665,
0.0843872875,
-0.0157184862,
0.6026776433,
0.2612983286,
-0.5068379641,
0.3838609457,
-0.2116696239,
-0.1552668363,
0.8067288399,
0.7019934654,
0.4418798387,
-0.4716889858,
-0.4850696027,
-0.0467423499,
-0.8396148086,
0.3207875192,
0.6312611699,
0.6001849174,
-0.0320684128,
0.5736660361,
0.1222606823,
0.4653283358,
0.0939228386,
-0.3457956016,
-0.2651790679,
-0.2290530205,
-0.2221454531,
-0.066134721,
0.7823770046,
0.5957475901,
0.2228357643,
0.0424210168,
-0.4122890234,
0.0248746779,
-0.0079918001,
-0.9239579439,
0.1049306244,
0.0450800285,
-0.4604058564,
-0.3751551211,
-0.0977649391,
-1.1393681765,
-0.9640418291,
-0.1761309057,
0.4905078411,
-0.2541076243,
-0.0239290781,
-0.0675228462,
-0.1371636689,
0.137758866,
0.3114315867,
-0.9709895849,
0.4448352456,
0.4789436758,
0.7136104107,
-0.3181381524,
-0.2103785723,
-1.2940895557,
-0.2586657703,
-0.3570598662,
0.6261643767,
-0.666816771,
-0.7206309438,
0.3296916783,
-0.033812575,
0.0836426392,
-0.6754325628,
0.4822729528,
-0.4972721636,
0.401973784,
-0.3596282601,
-0.5215402246,
0.3341202438,
0.2726523578,
-0.9504549503,
1.1317938566,
0.1193375662,
-0.2741234899,
0.5080740452,
-0.8073738813,
-0.2784718871,
0.3704718053,
-0.2291069329,
-0.0442420803,
-0.0530298129,
0.1729342192,
0.6204986572,
-0.8182797432,
0.424684912,
0.0521001741,
-0.5073134899,
0.3916224241,
-0.4238908291,
0.6762399673,
0.1210309938,
-0.1281940788,
0.445854038,
-0.6686745882,
-0.3027497232,
-0.0060461876,
-0.31008026,
0.1106905565,
-0.0200890899,
0.0033228665,
0.2960394323,
0.0649236441,
-0.1627889872,
0.1659867764,
-0.2042565644,
0.2686894834,
0.7720455527,
0.1841473132,
0.3618773818,
-0.3256574869,
1.1125771999,
-0.330581516,
0.0345532224,
-0.8014252186,
-0.2752442658,
-0.4442954361,
-0.3963823318,
0.1910747588,
0.5456417799,
-0.8275493383,
0.6002455354,
0.1637669057,
-0.372666955,
-0.382211864,
0.1322776675,
0.3172242045,
0.444850713,
0.1650409102,
-0.3375670314,
-0.5999403596,
-0.6481615305,
-0.1328046173,
-0.3628268838,
-0.1865972281,
0.5740991235,
0.211901933,
-0.0691037402,
1.0414932966,
-0.2604330778,
-0.1563759893,
-0.6316636801,
0.2072971165,
0.1666226387,
0.4272831678,
0.3085649908,
-0.3952360749,
-0.3342579603,
-0.4823316038,
-0.6796738505,
-0.5381647944,
-0.3546534777,
-0.0276958738,
0.1077581272,
0.5523735285,
-0.64357692,
0.3393481374,
0.4803724289,
-0.5561689138,
0.8436850309,
0.0029566397,
0.5012364388,
-0.9415787458,
0.4431593716,
-0.0517841205,
-0.327162832,
-0.5223401785,
-0.1015480012,
-0.4142063856,
-0.2609317005,
-0.3136259317,
0.8611955047,
-0.3437033296,
-0.3417349458,
-0.0603222921,
0.5055007935,
-0.0248549171,
0.113663204,
-0.1266925633,
1.0565930605,
0.5845314264,
-0.7504543662,
0.5266427994,
0.2034701556,
-0.5894377232,
0.5289424658,
-0.6457524896,
0.0118090287,
-0.0626695827,
0.2536669672,
-1.1109191179,
-0.3917439282,
0.1202205345,
-0.0082463035,
0.1827723533,
-0.2549747229,
-0.5598997474,
-0.3069985211,
-0.3556064665,
0.1977377683,
0.6063176394,
-0.5154175758,
0.4196036458,
0.4614137411,
-0.4117438793,
-0.5985447764,
-0.2656925619,
0.1698217839,
-0.5109614134,
-0.4060703516,
0.1460091025,
-0.343649596,
-0.1663828641,
-0.4585755169,
-0.1358275712,
0.1602046341,
0.2078476697,
0.2001613528,
0.2389347404,
-0.2337310463,
0.1867305636,
-0.0092501082,
-0.2342639416,
0.2005127072,
0.0591889359,
0.7115525603,
0.0874713957,
-0.3227472603,
-0.3394670486,
0.2930879295,
0.4405269623,
-0.0917229354,
0.3208529055,
0.1745147109,
-0.2127503306,
-0.339898169,
-0.5341238379,
-0.339766264,
-0.4626761377,
0.2174153626,
-0.1410081685,
-1.0435019732,
0.6071876884,
-0.2525972724,
0.0569104664,
0.1585296094,
0.5205692649,
0.0488664657,
1.0523971319,
0.3693108559,
0.2580722868,
0.4931537509,
0.0365508124,
-0.0389470309,
-0.4096278846,
-0.0755755976,
-0.3524453044,
-0.2345591486,
-0.3296969235,
-0.6172667146,
0.237417832,
0.2525826395,
-0.3668553233,
0.2110566497,
-0.0256142784,
0.6039142013,
0.3953659236,
-0.2171817571,
0.2059923708,
-0.2301399857,
-0.1920523942,
-0.14705351,
-0.6894845963,
-1.0971264839,
0.7778051496,
0.4121648669,
0.6257811189,
0.2291943729,
0.7779302001,
0.5437207222,
0.4708047807,
-0.8970597386,
0.9544699192,
0.0460620672,
-0.5410798788,
-0.6412400007,
-0.3979665637,
-0.8726233244,
-0.2201081812,
-0.423781395,
-1.0252473354,
-0.2491204143,
0.1689944118,
-0.7495003343,
-0.2688878179,
-0.4901668429,
1.0860587358,
-0.1212552413,
-0.5431838632,
0.0091386409,
-0.4940488636,
0.4623393714,
0.0383170508,
-0.094077833,
-0.1095359176,
0.0344356708,
0.6340175271,
-0.1046622097,
0.9461560249,
-0.4655109048,
-0.1850062162,
0.4958117902,
0.4131321013,
0.1378432512,
0.4490844607,
-0.3767870367,
-0.404512465,
0.0001915651,
0.1219981313,
-0.9616909623,
0.6430876851,
-0.3097927868,
-0.7970811725,
-0.1934896111,
-0.3738843799,
-0.3277849257,
0.1101187095,
0.0265140291,
0.6707385778,
-0.9470240474,
-0.0042391648,
0.5092271566,
-0.6322095394,
0.4182207286,
0.3891172111,
-0.7030060887,
-0.1843298823,
0.7074554563,
0.0030545325,
0.0616188124,
0.2489335984,
0.4062563777,
-0.5923186541,
-0.0082009993,
-0.7395601869,
-0.0607867725,
-0.5841485858,
-0.4287896454,
-0.3430330455,
-0.0831868723,
-0.2040579021,
-0.0768945515,
0.0657283962,
-0.3337627351,
-0.2018211782,
-0.2692118883,
0.3783586621,
0.9509963989,
0.0006576558,
0.6315078735,
-0.8270896077,
0.1100276336,
0.5498005748,
0.3690860868,
0.0076718447,
-0.2523382604,
-0.0408168696,
-0.2296705693,
-0.1686996371,
-1.0457047224,
0.3576335013,
0.0491189882,
0.7597387433,
0.374158442,
-0.1170866415,
0.5730311275,
-0.6674566865,
1.2688456774,
0.2263478041,
-1.168820858,
0.5873845816,
-0.4286299646,
0.0823081136,
0.6074845195,
0.2459112406,
-0.6629806161,
0.0510079674,
-0.565177083,
-0.6980716586,
1.1054577827,
0.0205155704,
0.2164763957,
-0.2863331735,
0.1961197853,
0.2504852414,
0.3205972016,
-0.3580211997,
0.0461108051,
-0.0100505892,
-0.2679830194,
-0.2695295215,
-0.3989732265,
-0.1793776006,
0.2245125324,
0.4189381003,
-0.2920829356,
0.2530636787,
-0.0667657182,
-0.151842311,
-0.0682511032,
0.3437931836,
0.5331095457,
0.594117105,
0.0676730275,
0.0149115706,
0.25774616,
-0.1187715232,
0.1777805686,
-0.092305705,
0.0288590807,
-0.2876864076,
0.3988687098,
0.7700527906,
0.5245198011,
-1.1821635962,
0.7439861298,
-0.1257329881,
0.0263729189,
-0.0440732986,
0.3286979198,
0.2080171108,
0.3769627512,
0.1936643869,
-0.2851857543,
0.3360818624,
-0.8248517513,
0.4501051605,
0.121267505,
-0.3241286278,
-0.2062041014,
0.3408070207,
0.2774399817,
-0.7806958556,
0.4303787351,
-0.13336052,
-0.2781418562,
0.6338256001,
0.7800829411,
0.8784861565,
-0.5874801874,
0.5220962167,
0.4160593152,
-0.0869148076,
-0.2394652069,
0.4523491561,
-0.0491589643,
-0.4807779491,
-0.4625261426,
-0.4340212643,
-0.3034841716,
0.2329002917,
-0.5685613155,
0.4758579135,
-0.666015923,
-0.3599722981,
-0.3680755794,
0.0565744601,
-0.8115336299,
0.1673600674,
-0.0256149396,
1.0485544205,
-0.9203596711,
0.302334249,
0.3718109429,
-0.6701856256,
-0.7431763411,
0.1079478636,
0.0144385686,
-0.6724217534,
0.8830804825,
0.4923833311,
-0.1535671949,
0.0204769056,
-0.5290607214,
-0.3151091933,
1.1796553135,
0.4766254723,
-0.433508873,
-0.122458443,
-0.0215438008,
0.7023180127,
-0.8432657123,
0.6679728031,
0.81167835,
0.3789003789,
0.1245580763,
-0.6880303025,
0.1554860622,
-0.1978864372,
0.0257653166,
-0.3892538249,
-0.4083371758,
0.5864149332,
-0.0677296892,
-0.5756262541,
0.2933348119,
0.482614547,
0.7307929397,
0.4273677468,
0.7192584276,
-0.2034362406,
0.8295301199,
0.1807572246,
0.7695997357,
-0.1840439588,
-0.0818147957,
1.0298416615,
-0.6949887276,
0.6149947643,
0.1828898042,
0.3056100607,
0.4547891319,
0.4709743559,
0.1800021827,
0.2310630679,
0.7035443187,
-0.2345791608,
-0.4962344766,
-0.3387714028,
0.1412947178,
0.5981754065,
0.4137641191,
-0.4265159369,
-0.1981559992,
-0.289128989,
-0.1358799785,
0.4172876775,
-0.3136502802,
0.8379223347,
0.0732682571,
-0.9056839347,
-0.0709952191,
-0.076771453,
0.3666326106,
-0.6505061388,
-0.495919019,
-0.2167717367,
-0.2550262809,
0.0526123904,
-0.811733067,
-0.0113066081,
0.4934636652,
-0.1395174414,
-0.4418514073,
0.6057690382,
-0.4012952745,
-0.2502759397,
0.3221496046,
0.7721122503,
0.2940438092,
0.5044382811,
-0.6566614509,
0.1113388166,
-0.3301931024,
-0.264772892,
0.203004241,
0.5513127446,
-0.3043988049,
0.5905131102,
0.5190091133,
-0.1039489657,
-0.2152099609,
0.4507100284,
0.7622331977,
-0.6014403105,
-0.6460098028,
-0.8325772285,
0.6913791895,
-0.2996475399,
-0.5151156783,
0.6972839236,
0.6847810149,
0.2164679319,
-0.1003398672,
0.8532224894,
0.0111632645,
0.5902764201,
-0.7096411586,
0.4908166826,
-0.2284910977,
0.4920351803,
-0.4327165782,
-0.9420397878,
-0.2212959826,
0.8506861329,
-0.155225113,
0.210714072,
0.3424072862,
1.1167293787,
0.0715207756,
0.1540220678,
0.5724816918,
-0.0613496006,
0.4026191235,
0.2518029809,
1.3038370609,
-0.2101822793,
0.1005538851,
0.5708882809,
-0.5268847942,
-0.3083490729,
-1.2420392036,
-1.1714847088,
-0.5302658081,
-0.0248961709,
-0.4532328248,
0.0653901696,
1.3991030455,
0.5541952252,
-0.626491487,
-0.6314701438,
0.0708587393,
-0.0245348904,
-0.2850788534,
-0.2569344938,
0.1759645194,
-0.5626070499,
-0.73896873,
0.9694445729,
0.2190303504,
-0.281491667,
-0.6804456115,
-0.238233462,
0.0012114417,
0.4633158743,
0.7594106793,
0.2663881183,
-0.5188419223,
-0.2371337265,
0.3445976675,
-0.2097036391,
-0.2503583133,
1.1904027462,
-0.7197045684,
0.4749830067,
0.575299859,
0.649974525,
0.2873097956,
0.1444949359,
1.1186169386,
-0.7796860337,
-0.2920986116,
0.2887795568,
0.110762395,
0.3825393915,
-0.3735271394,
0.4231311679,
-0.0429499038,
-0.4792345166,
-0.9033129811,
0.3426246941,
-0.7474994063,
0.1475642323,
1.200668931,
-0.3372322917,
0.0230848789,
-0.0335221812,
-0.5133382082,
0.2442013919,
-0.6203989387,
0.6175487041,
0.6446043253,
-0.0218253788,
-0.2477758974,
-0.4711365402,
0.8573549986,
0.071224615,
-0.8285700083,
0.3348021209,
0.7749786973,
0.088794373,
0.0340214819,
0.9207019806,
0.0387308672,
0.203610912,
0.0266242977,
-0.038066864,
-0.0131578064,
-0.689002037,
-0.4677919745,
0.12645033,
0.0545325987,
0.2977108061
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00606v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00606v2
|
LLMs Could Autonomously Learn Without External Supervision
| 2024-06-02T03:36:37 | 2024-06-06T22:48:35 |
Ke Ji, Junying Chen, Anningzhe Gao, Wenya Xie, Xiang Wan, Benyou Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the quest for super-human performance, Large Language Models (LLMs) have
traditionally been tethered to human-annotated datasets and predefined training
objectives-a process that is both labor-intensive and inherently limited. This
paper presents a transformative approach: Autonomous Learning for LLMs, a
self-sufficient learning paradigm that frees models from the constraints of
human supervision. This method endows LLMs with the ability to self-educate
through direct interaction with text, akin to a human reading and comprehending
literature. Our approach eliminates the reliance on annotated data, fostering
an Autonomous Learning environment where the model independently identifies and
reinforces its knowledge gaps. Empirical results from our comprehensive
experiments, which utilized a diverse array of learning materials and were
evaluated against standard public quizzes, reveal that Autonomous Learning
outstrips the performance of both Pre-training and Supervised Fine-Tuning
(SFT), as well as retrieval-augmented methods. These findings underscore the
potential of Autonomous Learning to not only enhance the efficiency and
effectiveness of LLM training but also to pave the way for the development of
more advanced, self-reliant AI systems.
|
[
-0.1889223605,
-0.5850999355,
0.5910391808,
-0.2669500113,
0.0342920125,
0.2799446285,
-0.4777737856,
-0.5729572773,
0.2017758936,
0.6045681834,
-0.6898492575,
-0.325178057,
-0.4959389865,
0.298543036,
-0.4165793657,
0.8660054207,
0.0628770441,
-0.0020654541,
-0.5082421899,
0.0815846398,
-0.1242054924,
-0.4349636734,
-0.6562648416,
-0.320553422,
0.7154602408,
0.4150335193,
0.3832779825,
1.2235307693,
0.3069744408,
0.4076068401,
0.4647375941,
0.6049288511,
-0.2038349807,
0.2054219395,
-0.3442311585,
-0.7211589813,
-0.2652319968,
0.2463706136,
0.6092717648,
0.4692854285,
0.0220145155,
0.1309847087,
0.250974685,
0.8581041694,
-0.427570194,
0.4146881104,
-0.6975113153,
0.0152468346,
-0.0456881076,
-0.1306329817,
-0.3561410606,
-0.3037294745,
-0.0658268705,
-0.6877064109,
0.1533531845,
-0.144530043,
0.3938248158,
0.8295348883,
-0.3809746504,
-0.3191162348,
-0.8700937629,
0.5544707775,
-0.2812440395,
0.4566752315,
0.5024060607,
0.1970376372,
-0.0018129674,
-0.4804283977,
-0.39966169,
-0.4403609335,
-0.2127552629,
0.1782501042,
0.1654425114,
-0.0410602055,
-0.1947060227,
0.2118544281,
-0.3167994916,
0.5016698837,
-0.3868381083,
0.0568531789,
0.8905878663,
0.1881362796,
0.2669364214,
0.0514452979,
-0.3841963708,
-0.0331634209,
-0.7079788446,
-0.029662475,
0.2721653283,
0.4937336445,
0.0329131857,
0.4031939209,
-0.2228368074,
0.3832360208,
0.1083156243,
-0.1506512612,
0.0136792278,
-0.0063317115,
-0.1226857901,
-0.0936682969,
1.039298892,
-0.221110791,
0.4098929465,
-0.464053303,
-0.4913459718,
-0.0930046067,
0.4582136571,
-0.3370828032,
-0.6038509607,
0.0193164218,
0.0160015896,
-0.1377675682,
-0.0591423437,
-0.5036376119,
-0.5231953263,
-0.8184396029,
0.6956949234,
-0.344468534,
-0.2056912482,
-0.3484387994,
0.3664660156,
0.017420236,
0.3715447187,
-1.2268434763,
0.2388356775,
0.3817650378,
0.7115595341,
-0.3295486569,
-0.4772338867,
-0.4217973351,
0.2859024704,
-0.5955805779,
0.7449351549,
-0.2251502424,
-0.297630161,
-0.2370519936,
-0.0789007843,
-0.1154187247,
-0.6207050085,
0.0272266939,
-0.4469295144,
-0.0360594206,
-0.0344881602,
-0.5869445801,
-0.1639116406,
0.0156887472,
-0.5512574911,
0.8566931486,
-0.0557190068,
-0.3333833218,
0.1479872316,
-0.7583646774,
-0.4738093913,
0.2077181637,
-0.4762300551,
-0.1509035975,
0.0899270996,
0.2222770751,
0.7199386358,
-0.102137506,
0.3483525813,
-0.0014810176,
-0.1645106673,
-0.0995419621,
-0.5150848627,
0.6307676435,
-0.1422052532,
-0.6199321151,
0.2970720232,
-0.85889256,
-0.1409907788,
0.2207590938,
-0.4521262348,
-0.4651327729,
0.262820214,
-0.500154078,
0.199331373,
0.3935242891,
-0.2550202608,
0.3697702289,
-0.5707367659,
0.1239443123,
1.1925290823,
-0.2876941264,
0.7387163639,
-0.3273956478,
0.4239753485,
-0.2218700647,
0.0788458139,
-0.3346081674,
0.1660477817,
-1.0391148329,
-0.4538238347,
0.0831014141,
0.5077707767,
-0.7390580773,
0.6499382854,
-0.0138784079,
-0.6599757671,
-0.8149486184,
0.8382506967,
0.3640027046,
0.4030410945,
0.5926876664,
-0.0299126841,
-0.5681881309,
-0.7152680755,
-0.1343105137,
-0.139544934,
0.0477885306,
0.1631906033,
0.5876883864,
-0.3808566332,
1.0127214193,
-0.1281882524,
-0.7668458223,
-0.3008220196,
0.0729737952,
-0.3307365477,
0.649644196,
0.0181066897,
-0.4532471001,
-0.4399101734,
0.1123896316,
-1.2210747004,
-0.059010528,
-0.1842916161,
0.2932209969,
0.3956797123,
1.0089911222,
-0.3433364332,
0.2189029455,
0.3512927294,
0.0838225409,
0.5926756263,
-0.778960228,
-0.4621537328,
-0.6152540445,
-0.1064108163,
-0.0628305897,
-0.2805936337,
-0.3397533,
0.0290584788,
0.1682862192,
0.4122136533,
-0.109075889,
0.8295956254,
-0.6919543743,
0.0762273595,
-0.5516321063,
0.2322036624,
-0.2867289186,
0.4763138294,
0.3176224828,
0.822285533,
0.4441061616,
-0.716242969,
0.2664610744,
0.1013267413,
-0.3309976459,
0.0713941529,
-0.5742471814,
0.0959566906,
-0.2876480818,
0.210633859,
-0.7564249635,
-0.3718598783,
0.1487723291,
-0.2218687683,
0.2064452618,
0.2659995854,
-0.525426805,
0.0747700483,
0.1682260782,
-0.0072886059,
0.3512016535,
-0.7947955132,
0.7402271628,
0.3547801077,
-0.0378269292,
-0.4944805801,
-0.4952885211,
0.0319042243,
-0.1181423739,
0.0096686343,
-0.06365145,
-0.0170266517,
-0.3081179261,
-0.2067954391,
0.1395599544,
0.0811827853,
0.4362751544,
0.5243756771,
0.2376029044,
0.0073001632,
0.510078609,
0.0166228674,
-0.3207596242,
0.1994018257,
-0.4397016764,
0.2171063274,
-0.1684328914,
-0.4367003739,
-0.6892774701,
0.1242171824,
0.531188488,
-0.6010028124,
0.6328418851,
0.3253656328,
-0.1664830595,
-0.5826399922,
-0.4979082942,
-0.3465175629,
-0.5608147383,
0.1919729412,
-0.181788221,
-0.8358809948,
0.136846602,
-0.0796733275,
0.1195078045,
0.4649951458,
0.5418124795,
-0.2662596703,
0.8586693406,
1.0106190443,
-0.1400258988,
0.45863989,
-0.2099766135,
-0.1056631505,
-0.6323170066,
-0.5120896101,
-0.1688098758,
-0.0889226794,
-0.5023243427,
-0.3032368422,
0.5248915553,
-0.0848755836,
-0.3849890828,
0.2020553201,
-0.5553687811,
0.6848236322,
0.9012280107,
0.1190612018,
0.6336584091,
-0.412722677,
-0.1874773502,
0.0682105124,
-0.6800405383,
-0.5436339378,
1.1571751833,
0.2696908414,
0.8852449656,
-0.1828442216,
0.9587110281,
0.2539637685,
0.5298401713,
-0.6409828663,
0.5826259255,
0.0445461199,
-0.5196905732,
-0.5677686334,
-0.4130047262,
-0.8929648399,
0.181295678,
-0.2857835889,
-0.6232363582,
-0.0585504547,
0.1388263553,
-0.3803730905,
0.3497248292,
-0.745665133,
0.621894002,
-0.7856723666,
-0.4061480761,
-0.1682049334,
-0.6691642404,
0.3085192144,
-0.5152623057,
0.4229801595,
-0.1258826554,
-0.264609158,
0.6798706055,
-0.0941029564,
1.3718723059,
-0.1442757696,
-0.26795277,
0.1870230138,
0.2407310158,
0.3264346123,
-0.1162250713,
0.1867071986,
-0.0418285765,
-0.2059483826,
-0.2416211516,
-0.587387979,
0.5045963526,
-1.0598167181,
-0.743098557,
-0.3453732133,
-0.5100753903,
-0.25800547,
0.2955760062,
-0.0336882696,
0.2073181123,
-0.1103226915,
0.1167215332,
0.6484154463,
-0.0050521372,
0.548091948,
0.7233980298,
-0.3174751997,
-0.2065923661,
0.9459354877,
0.3745934963,
0.2693559527,
0.3766407669,
0.353826493,
-0.5825094581,
-0.4590879083,
-0.3224423528,
0.262265563,
-0.6543835998,
-0.063181825,
-0.7270081639,
-0.2116656452,
-0.3173594773,
-0.2237070799,
-0.7015042901,
-0.0024671084,
-0.6272617579,
-0.2885079384,
0.1523289829,
1.252346158,
-0.4653621912,
0.3120115399,
-0.6188524365,
0.1085675657,
0.6711009741,
0.2368624955,
0.1951074153,
-0.5294873118,
-0.4313918948,
-0.0993550271,
-0.251088351,
-0.2752934694,
0.4837403297,
0.3165243268,
0.6414172649,
0.4194203913,
0.4094755054,
0.5240195394,
-0.5866478682,
0.4293872714,
-0.0282478873,
-0.92022717,
0.6022747755,
-0.444090724,
0.2036100626,
0.6626952291,
0.7288159728,
-0.1664554179,
-0.5847785473,
-0.4856368601,
-0.8487697244,
0.5283507109,
-0.4050222337,
0.1828204095,
-0.0367186181,
0.4138024747,
0.3326440752,
0.0134328194,
-0.9942934513,
-0.0825837031,
0.0665759295,
-0.2019385695,
-0.4878160059,
0.1901845485,
0.0299256593,
-0.5543521047,
0.7556068301,
-0.3813726306,
0.0035779905,
0.3938598633,
-0.2722136974,
-0.0095108431,
-0.1959223151,
0.1377099901,
0.4702359438,
0.1113786027,
0.4204102755,
0.0757958889,
0.0322758444,
0.3397521377,
-0.1428804249,
0.0097760586,
-0.4286949635,
0.5054967403,
0.4133894742,
0.1874397099,
-0.873929441,
0.3204852343,
0.0462993272,
-0.1634678543,
-0.6016896367,
0.4891777337,
0.1670348942,
0.536898613,
0.6263392568,
-0.0199842509,
-0.3392770588,
-0.4026456773,
0.438188225,
0.4199052751,
-0.5536701679,
-0.2577944398,
0.8707222939,
0.1999597996,
-0.4275704026,
0.4161739349,
-0.0556117035,
-0.1562018394,
0.4036644399,
0.4020479918,
0.7033624053,
-0.4726392031,
0.2216507792,
0.1101310179,
0.5367649794,
-0.3226124644,
-0.4178293645,
-0.4616371095,
-0.6774171591,
-0.4330979288,
-0.5063040853,
-0.5127192736,
0.136726886,
-0.440548867,
0.0648821816,
-0.7361875176,
0.4956545234,
0.0359300561,
0.0198702756,
-0.3883238137,
0.5039955974,
0.0621166043,
0.6832685471,
-0.711758554,
1.110060215,
0.4525443316,
-0.4177564383,
-0.7821028233,
-0.0691890866,
-0.0672525838,
-0.7957963347,
0.6721125245,
0.3349279463,
-0.4278176725,
0.2968176305,
-0.5946851373,
-0.7864794731,
1.0058133602,
0.5092336535,
-0.4022456706,
-0.1865425855,
0.0027579865,
0.6149691343,
-0.321795851,
0.250025332,
0.4779912829,
0.1978358179,
-0.2700202465,
-0.8309235573,
-0.2400086075,
0.0247899052,
-0.4322958887,
-0.0942063481,
-0.8671311736,
0.679546833,
-0.2228195518,
-0.1338420957,
0.0295588002,
0.9256588221,
-0.3797657192,
0.050486289,
0.3240396082,
0.1574228704,
0.8085855246,
0.1615637243,
0.7945793271,
-0.241345033,
0.1873119473,
1.3852266073,
-0.151973471,
0.9367238879,
0.2125423253,
0.0048445486,
0.5425522327,
0.3649056256,
0.1538538635,
0.4399296343,
-0.0333280601,
-0.4780361056,
-0.6498363018,
0.0800856799,
0.0469650589,
0.9949148893,
0.2989240289,
-0.3160564899,
-0.2858216166,
0.1738381684,
-0.1775243729,
0.5965240598,
-0.3688164949,
1.073045373,
0.0516621731,
-0.679225266,
0.4866552651,
-0.1524029672,
0.7371147871,
-0.7277961373,
0.1834278554,
-0.1149732843,
0.3961522281,
-0.2119446248,
-0.3838623464,
0.5392239094,
-0.0466105118,
0.0236413274,
-0.5359588265,
0.5516841412,
-0.4380752444,
-0.45646438,
0.5713905692,
0.9338648915,
0.0655188709,
0.064880237,
-0.4785397351,
-0.3973422945,
-0.1690412611,
-0.1730000526,
0.6408799887,
0.4516131282,
0.0943132415,
1.1645081043,
0.5087618828,
-0.1021725237,
-0.0373733863,
-0.5209226608,
0.7418960929,
-0.5628176928,
-0.4150305688,
-0.9856906533,
0.2698070705,
0.3262307942,
-0.1589619219,
0.920527041,
0.4587519467,
1.0042030811,
0.0753328726,
1.0632853508,
0.3040790856,
0.6706762314,
-0.4363121092,
0.9506833553,
-0.697922647,
0.200905934,
0.05443082,
-0.4389241934,
-0.3286100924,
0.6872317195,
-0.5621165633,
-0.0125614628,
0.2844862044,
0.6584870815,
0.1080453396,
0.0000884495,
0.4912706316,
0.1501299888,
0.1882072389,
0.2841434777,
0.9304106236,
0.1391322315,
0.2956740856,
-0.2975877523,
-0.2669178843,
0.0292718839,
-0.6804550886,
-1.1578240395,
-0.7238163948,
-0.0960548446,
0.1361230761,
0.1114958152,
1.3791851997,
0.7210919261,
-0.4500367641,
-0.3878993988,
-0.2968434691,
0.2005356848,
-0.1061491668,
-0.1491269916,
0.3190863431,
-0.7802590132,
-0.8522855043,
0.9086259604,
0.2728908956,
0.1477276385,
-0.7660498619,
0.0006032013,
-0.1599956155,
0.000815678,
0.4020023942,
0.5327361822,
-0.5967191458,
-0.2515334785,
-0.1252410263,
-0.1055002585,
0.0854241624,
0.5672443509,
-1.1912385225,
0.3964515626,
-0.1997417063,
1.0553025007,
0.2549442649,
-0.0899003223,
0.4790480733,
-0.7601152658,
-0.0317421705,
0.1999797672,
-0.1053170785,
0.1932873279,
-0.5630235076,
0.372410953,
0.2432438731,
-0.754776895,
-0.5439443588,
0.0784711614,
-0.447925806,
-0.3922836185,
1.021974802,
-0.1622765511,
-0.2601975203,
-0.2373249233,
-0.0526129901,
0.2854034007,
-0.1803792119,
1.1287943125,
0.2755432427,
-0.2551779747,
-0.2678391337,
-0.6213818789,
0.5718843341,
0.4323647916,
-0.9731155634,
0.2928422987,
0.4356862605,
0.2862589359,
-0.0327254869,
0.6443154216,
0.2334710509,
0.0088201417,
-0.1454461813,
0.2119342536,
-0.3777447343,
-0.8262731433,
-0.5719360709,
0.1571485251,
0.0055973879,
-0.1209847033
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00605v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00605v1
|
LongSkywork: A Training Recipe for Efficiently Extending Context Length in Large Language Models
| 2024-06-02T03:34:41 | 2024-06-02T03:34:41 |
Liang Zhao, Tianwen Wei, Liang Zeng, Cheng Cheng, Liu Yang, Peng Cheng, Lijie Wang, Chenxia Li, Xuejie Wu, Bo Zhu, Yimeng Gan, Rui Hu, Shuicheng Yan, Han Fang, Yahui Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We introduce LongSkywork, a long-context Large Language Model (LLM) capable
of processing up to 200,000 tokens. We provide a training recipe for
efficiently extending context length of LLMs. We identify that the critical
element in enhancing long-context processing capability is to incorporate a
long-context SFT stage following the standard SFT stage. A mere 200 iterations
can convert the standard SFT model into a long-context model. To reduce the
effort in collecting and annotating data for long-context language modeling, we
develop two novel methods for creating synthetic data. These methods are
applied during the continual pretraining phase as well as the Supervised
Fine-Tuning (SFT) phase, greatly enhancing the training efficiency of our
long-context LLMs. Our findings suggest that synthetic long-context SFT data
can surpass the performance of data curated by humans to some extent.
LongSkywork achieves outstanding performance on a variety of long-context
benchmarks. In the Needle test, a benchmark for long-context information
retrieval, our models achieved perfect accuracy across multiple context spans.
Moreover, in realistic application scenarios, LongSkywork-13B demonstrates
performance on par with Claude2.1, the leading long-context model, underscoring
the effectiveness of our proposed methods.
|
[
-0.073219046,
-0.7754099965,
0.7644565105,
0.4507625103,
-0.3026916981,
0.0482873023,
-0.58259058,
-0.8185303211,
0.1155505627,
0.8263552189,
-0.6209535599,
-0.5401669741,
-0.2544850707,
0.1652584076,
-0.6060572267,
0.8695460558,
-0.1975475401,
-0.0052090036,
-0.2249489427,
0.0595012419,
-0.5391359925,
-0.5580132604,
-0.5750151873,
-0.3027518094,
0.7192493081,
0.4104353189,
0.2682993412,
0.6898505092,
0.1749840975,
0.2921071947,
0.0042184731,
0.0864663422,
-0.7560195327,
0.2558010221,
-0.2429869622,
-0.2666594982,
-0.5878565311,
-0.102810353,
0.7463048697,
0.8059014082,
0.095661968,
0.0794938952,
0.0791378096,
0.8123822808,
-0.4913649857,
0.1504866779,
-0.41515854,
0.0041006217,
-0.3973510563,
-0.1520114392,
-0.604100287,
0.0181222353,
0.1199207902,
-0.6312385201,
-0.0852908641,
0.0478939563,
0.1344633251,
0.0209529251,
-0.7624796629,
-0.2217141241,
-0.7481988072,
0.9264874458,
-0.5376330018,
0.5735929608,
0.5251575112,
0.3195468485,
-0.3758221269,
-1.0334619284,
-0.259576261,
-0.5383985043,
-0.0810337365,
0.0305449273,
0.2189306319,
0.2518992126,
0.3995559216,
0.1547822803,
-0.5796105862,
0.1761485189,
-0.7701029778,
0.0443655439,
0.5872963667,
0.0983290151,
-0.148849979,
-0.1168538257,
-0.5386109948,
0.1420172006,
-0.7811372876,
0.1031317264,
0.2299234271,
0.29679811,
0.1381245703,
0.5112981796,
-0.7182830572,
0.8190904856,
-0.2199153006,
-0.0543226637,
0.188465789,
-0.2945702374,
-0.2695073485,
0.0521793552,
0.4803008437,
0.2838060856,
0.2110313922,
-0.3296293914,
-0.3181092143,
-0.2158415765,
0.25042817,
-1.0833215714,
0.0165537447,
0.123916097,
-0.1542485058,
-0.2335909009,
-0.0543566383,
-0.3959902823,
-0.1452481449,
-0.7689774036,
0.3380328715,
-0.5785774589,
-0.2141400874,
0.3918495774,
-0.0003161881,
0.0168140754,
0.3066576719,
-0.7442445159,
0.3254911304,
1.1475235224,
0.7139855623,
-0.473020345,
-0.6281306744,
-0.5943040848,
0.1963982731,
-0.5277063847,
0.5492110848,
-0.4703541696,
-0.2497573197,
0.0143537205,
0.3257345557,
0.2120950818,
-0.5965061784,
0.2919836044,
-0.409866482,
0.0686749145,
-0.136681661,
-0.7410274744,
0.1174616218,
0.2561101615,
-0.7435757518,
1.3935805559,
0.3909856975,
-0.437913835,
0.4061999619,
-0.9322274923,
-0.6430518627,
0.167348966,
0.0639873445,
-0.1103120819,
0.2440259457,
-0.1493693888,
0.7604928613,
-0.1839972436,
0.5441696644,
-0.2908227742,
-0.7172342539,
0.2575789392,
-0.1090359539,
0.5140449405,
0.129538849,
-0.187899828,
0.2805011868,
-0.9219118953,
-0.0363293886,
-0.0502281934,
-0.4852039218,
-0.4926297367,
-0.0503916182,
0.2088678777,
0.1441760063,
0.2217563689,
-0.5703505874,
0.3737589717,
-0.4044687152,
0.5202258229,
0.8483965993,
-0.4708612263,
0.4620515406,
-0.0746359304,
0.4105076194,
-0.0236672871,
0.0409413241,
-0.2963385284,
0.1434157342,
-0.7937107086,
-0.3332513869,
0.1620326489,
0.2807521224,
-0.7030189037,
0.5377958417,
-0.5862284303,
-0.4108037651,
-0.1547343135,
0.1962488145,
0.2081369609,
0.4081238508,
0.4877561033,
-0.2464015931,
-0.8227402568,
-1.0637657642,
-0.2997492552,
0.2902271748,
-0.1055477783,
0.0409153029,
0.6805621386,
-0.3570447266,
1.1629627943,
-0.4713272154,
-0.0253769327,
-0.2875540853,
-0.0108130611,
0.3533964753,
0.614315629,
0.3791534901,
-0.5097613335,
-0.5056543946,
-0.0256596245,
-0.529835403,
0.1320813149,
-0.0520885587,
-0.2446676195,
0.3059101403,
0.8220029473,
-0.6577631235,
0.2562682331,
0.5340111852,
-0.3981506228,
0.7159879804,
0.079417482,
0.0486612879,
-1.3866699934,
0.3274371624,
-0.2779001892,
-0.6124946475,
-0.850292623,
0.119576484,
0.2604863346,
-0.2859761417,
-0.6417819858,
0.7487291694,
-0.4037413597,
0.1368427277,
-0.416503638,
-0.2431283146,
-0.1388086081,
0.3823484778,
0.1234006062,
0.836930871,
0.4222293496,
-0.2637968361,
0.7233030796,
-0.1994403452,
-0.663769424,
0.5092806816,
-0.5722401738,
0.2413890213,
-0.0042549083,
0.7886471152,
-0.6455985308,
-0.4675074518,
-0.0856302977,
-0.1298147291,
0.3061021566,
-0.3666696548,
-0.6626660228,
-0.3628466427,
-0.2923255563,
0.5850945115,
0.4700303376,
-0.7503254414,
0.267275095,
-0.0946865976,
-0.069784835,
-0.4720508158,
-0.5906062126,
0.2905563116,
-0.5263915658,
-0.752116859,
0.4696069658,
-0.1713617444,
0.0533213988,
-0.3526913226,
-0.0012260351,
-0.1801831573,
0.0780328438,
0.2660287619,
-0.0928171277,
-0.2141780257,
0.3080003262,
-0.1802868992,
-0.2673781812,
0.1296332777,
-0.4098981321,
0.5767046809,
-0.0896860957,
-0.1499571353,
-0.2596083581,
0.5361150503,
0.5124293566,
-0.026070226,
0.8448588848,
0.6485368609,
-0.502666235,
-0.406204313,
-0.5859331489,
-0.2374268174,
-0.5044049621,
0.6791949868,
-0.4175824225,
-1.270452857,
0.3069032729,
-0.3570336699,
-0.1120080054,
0.197679162,
0.2618272901,
0.0385859422,
0.8487730026,
0.7265635729,
-0.2130930275,
0.6386473775,
-0.2225019634,
0.0346562564,
-0.7690944672,
0.010905629,
-0.2034365088,
-0.1603614688,
-0.3946408927,
-0.441408366,
0.2458557338,
0.1748823076,
-0.2012774199,
0.494443953,
-0.3042050898,
0.8689470887,
0.444557339,
0.1556556821,
0.1501445472,
-0.0541360937,
0.2552065849,
0.1368602514,
-0.352671057,
-0.1222440079,
1.1337491274,
0.4170368314,
0.6707030535,
-0.1007614285,
0.8276230097,
-0.0836578608,
0.2811081111,
-0.8006556034,
0.5427163839,
-0.068161808,
-0.7450816035,
-0.5754000545,
-0.3433760703,
-0.9382277727,
-0.0556589365,
-0.045282241,
-0.642424047,
-0.4407073259,
0.0716535822,
-0.1570081115,
-0.0340519361,
-0.5877020359,
0.92468822,
-0.279414475,
-0.5883817673,
-0.4469929636,
-0.5359876752,
0.3169572949,
-0.4402471781,
0.0556795374,
-0.1367883533,
0.1950850785,
0.8583737016,
-0.3097659349,
0.897595942,
-0.1623660177,
-0.159475565,
0.0785943866,
0.0236476827,
0.7273522615,
0.0668315291,
-0.2109831423,
0.0430247299,
0.1873948574,
-0.5729530454,
-0.4275690615,
0.8140484095,
-0.3638051152,
-0.4766561985,
-0.33847633,
-0.5478397012,
-0.1562788337,
0.4304589331,
0.0144026959,
0.5099663734,
-0.2985473275,
0.8286468387,
0.2159991115,
-0.0205237009,
0.2154847831,
0.306874454,
-0.3273430169,
-0.1510765105,
0.589015305,
0.1133228615,
0.3192871809,
0.3553999364,
0.1811102927,
-0.177145645,
-0.5948609114,
-0.1379124075,
0.0516833439,
-0.6815285683,
-0.1116905063,
-0.2378300577,
-0.2058923542,
-0.3838308454,
-0.3204988837,
-0.6168147326,
-0.3330150843,
-0.1219796464,
-0.0991393998,
0.417604655,
0.6515972614,
0.0988057256,
0.3848706484,
-0.6657506824,
0.1030534655,
0.3193745613,
0.7760437131,
-0.1686415374,
-0.3099624813,
-0.7270747423,
0.129388392,
-0.0783764124,
-0.3900802135,
0.2229743898,
0.0857507661,
0.0784044415,
0.0457025543,
-0.1280868053,
0.9719216824,
-0.7238847017,
0.75017941,
0.1713770628,
-0.7930373549,
0.4181986153,
-0.6305798292,
0.4650883079,
0.598310113,
0.2675370574,
-0.6751614809,
-0.0491283797,
-0.1836978495,
-1.0551111698,
0.64108634,
0.0851737857,
0.2201892138,
-0.1713646352,
0.4078454077,
0.3788120747,
-0.0912450776,
-0.8441681266,
0.3535423279,
0.058549121,
-0.1738668382,
-0.3328769207,
-0.38689062,
-0.187408939,
-0.4612056911,
0.5555592179,
-0.330817163,
0.0094943885,
0.0770224854,
-0.3467576802,
-0.035073135,
0.3010134101,
0.7593244314,
1.1363301277,
-0.3059758246,
0.1432074904,
0.5405387878,
-0.2487710267,
-0.1051372662,
0.0538425259,
0.3578832746,
-0.2403060794,
0.6201844811,
0.8582980633,
0.4114098847,
-0.7744079232,
0.4181084931,
0.0730617493,
-0.197590366,
-0.90212363,
0.0472876206,
0.3946197331,
0.3230561018,
0.4089112878,
-0.4886297286,
0.1522090137,
-0.6656389832,
0.2112484723,
0.372559309,
-0.139811933,
-0.3144584298,
0.1800312549,
0.1640536338,
-0.2926993072,
0.6677209139,
0.1584366411,
-0.3452559412,
0.4512600899,
0.8056564331,
0.6762635112,
-0.0899960026,
-0.3262277246,
0.2406114191,
-0.1142459214,
-0.3332103491,
-0.0546701103,
-0.1803504825,
-0.2200515568,
-0.8129244447,
-0.8608980775,
-0.0760333166,
0.5108523965,
-0.5623244643,
0.4739122093,
-0.2675276697,
0.0186844077,
-0.0580148585,
0.0965426788,
-0.6674436927,
0.1961034536,
0.0353106931,
1.0201778412,
-0.5894733667,
1.0608240366,
0.3881120384,
0.2848564088,
-0.4378705025,
-0.2664632201,
-0.2169784755,
-0.6574941278,
0.7964481711,
0.7309603691,
-0.0762213096,
-0.0346620902,
-0.7129936218,
-0.8389986157,
1.2205662727,
0.1476670057,
-0.7762405276,
-0.1098209992,
0.4650780857,
0.574447453,
-0.3535189033,
-0.2358256578,
0.7411680222,
0.4346303344,
0.0288466737,
-1.0213131905,
0.1641815007,
-0.1554131061,
-0.0572110228,
0.4610770345,
-0.380125016,
0.5467057824,
0.2474359274,
-0.0509095751,
0.3528775573,
0.6658801436,
0.2762053013,
0.2775060534,
0.6057232618,
0.4291699529,
0.3250305653,
0.0737558901,
0.7545841932,
-0.3814000785,
0.3120036423,
1.0542109013,
-0.2244516164,
0.9196515083,
0.6690440178,
0.0104361512,
0.1957154423,
0.596719861,
0.2390906066,
0.2785315216,
0.5150943398,
-0.3252344728,
-0.3677160144,
0.1112478822,
-0.3757566512,
0.5111891031,
0.2277598828,
-0.3268845975,
-0.027543582,
-0.0338026434,
0.2018278688,
-0.2063392252,
0.0175248403,
0.6481976509,
0.308601588,
-0.9561739564,
0.8302718401,
0.1941646934,
0.7851443887,
-0.7343723178,
0.101494886,
-0.1521103978,
0.3298361599,
-0.1045350805,
-0.644816637,
0.3208275139,
-0.0932275876,
-0.060200464,
-0.4611539245,
0.6442071795,
-0.6188560724,
-0.5735827088,
0.3549200892,
0.113823019,
0.0736220777,
-0.2292153239,
-0.3302562535,
0.0593333952,
-0.1442551017,
-0.5666623712,
0.5561703444,
0.3110899329,
-0.153243199,
0.5039873719,
0.927983284,
0.0280094668,
-0.1645723879,
-0.1271035075,
0.9080653191,
-0.9971977472,
-0.504945755,
-0.9731750488,
0.5665034056,
-0.1763837487,
-0.2860085964,
0.3993785381,
0.8375393152,
0.8766472936,
-0.2142837644,
0.5226399899,
0.1940466762,
0.5733027458,
-0.8418802619,
0.6137107611,
-0.5903124213,
-0.0156218866,
0.0516117364,
-1.1687965393,
-0.2945915759,
0.4380905628,
-0.2633327842,
-0.0054875864,
0.7318193913,
0.6698608398,
-0.4987866282,
-0.1181266457,
0.2972160876,
0.2425682694,
0.5245244503,
0.7151605487,
0.8039566278,
-0.1476598382,
0.154747501,
-0.3384439945,
-0.1525146663,
-0.3664056659,
-1.1288731098,
-1.0550369024,
-0.748308301,
0.1759531647,
-0.1823993325,
0.200417906,
1.0646903515,
1.0511908531,
-0.4446254075,
-0.5085452795,
0.0644121766,
-0.386059612,
0.1329981089,
-0.1852696389,
0.2658844888,
-0.261210531,
-0.5515587926,
0.9779695272,
0.1638016701,
-0.0245761685,
-0.2134727836,
-0.2552600801,
0.0263413172,
-0.0689713955,
1.07774508,
0.1880348325,
-0.5696286559,
-0.5922383666,
0.08907938,
0.0991804674,
-0.0451075137,
0.8219392896,
-0.771056056,
0.3597836196,
0.370609045,
0.429518044,
0.8827952147,
0.0059636231,
0.6062859297,
-1.0004960299,
0.4547518194,
0.2049683481,
0.2561428249,
0.267885536,
-0.2346436679,
0.6388317943,
0.0012520523,
-0.6001290083,
-1.1157753468,
0.3194994032,
-0.9789708853,
-0.5032718778,
1.3055984974,
0.1224458516,
-0.2557477057,
0.213610962,
-0.1702697277,
0.2495454699,
-0.1359512806,
0.8080925345,
0.8210015893,
-0.0067672748,
0.1984838545,
-0.7145296931,
0.6595935822,
0.3607809544,
-0.8876071572,
0.3936462402,
0.5237477422,
0.5935603976,
-0.011624963,
0.6340225935,
0.103774257,
0.2156461924,
-0.4158707261,
-0.1889583319,
-0.3517570496,
-0.6016452312,
-0.1196718514,
-0.1471046507,
0.0673270002,
0.2958815694
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00562v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00562v1
|
SPAGHETTI: Open-Domain Question Answering from Heterogeneous Data Sources with Retrieval and Semantic Parsing
| 2024-06-01T21:54:09 | 2024-06-01T21:54:09 |
Heidi C. Zhang, Sina J. Semnani, Farhad Ghassemi, Jialiang Xu, Shicheng Liu, Monica S. Lam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce SPAGHETTI: Semantic Parsing Augmented Generation for Hybrid
English information from Text Tables and Infoboxes, a hybrid question-answering
(QA) pipeline that utilizes information from heterogeneous knowledge sources,
including knowledge base, text, tables, and infoboxes. Our LLM-augmented
approach achieves state-of-the-art performance on the Compmix dataset, the most
comprehensive heterogeneous open-domain QA dataset, with 56.5% exact match (EM)
rate. More importantly, manual analysis on a sample of the dataset suggests
that SPAGHETTI is more than 90% accurate, indicating that EM is no longer
suitable for assessing the capabilities of QA systems today.
|
[
-0.563699007,
-1.2477591038,
0.5289978981,
0.2639262676,
0.190141663,
0.3545215428,
0.2503866553,
-0.3042722642,
0.42163077,
0.564207375,
-0.4835432172,
-0.4067791402,
-0.0431229882,
0.2226295471,
-0.3275102079,
0.9704453349,
-0.1835507751,
0.0983041227,
-0.4674249887,
-0.0464810766,
-0.1732981652,
-0.2749629021,
-0.1654787958,
-0.0839053988,
0.4129660428,
0.73877877,
1.2055613995,
0.7407561541,
0.2374674529,
0.2904593945,
0.2815752029,
0.395937115,
-0.4736929536,
0.0569603518,
-0.5070984364,
-0.6340545416,
-0.5721357465,
-0.0242549833,
0.5601559877,
0.9037068486,
0.0394058526,
0.3174628317,
-0.2042708844,
0.5484637022,
-0.9532727599,
-0.1267033517,
-0.9239367247,
0.3039307892,
-0.2091237009,
-0.6173096895,
-0.4145991802,
-0.5424621701,
0.003408669,
-1.1051256657,
0.2542456686,
0.4525030255,
1.1316119432,
0.1230385303,
-0.2799786925,
-0.2411834151,
-0.6327232122,
0.5750678182,
-0.6781933904,
0.3091883063,
0.3088626862,
0.3761556149,
-0.5149905682,
-0.9842454791,
-0.8936088085,
0.1027614698,
0.1856109798,
0.1899043322,
-0.0368383713,
-0.0331008062,
0.2210787982,
0.6804959178,
-0.7855889201,
-0.1565497965,
-0.3506892622,
0.018186722,
0.5550419688,
0.4134449363,
0.8373919725,
-0.0984233245,
-0.5851427913,
0.179927215,
-0.6825082898,
-0.2157666087,
0.3730795383,
-0.0423903912,
0.1814051867,
1.142452836,
-0.4814832807,
0.9398985505,
0.0068548839,
-0.1162290797,
0.1659016907,
-0.4209736884,
-0.3398317099,
-0.0196312815,
0.721028924,
0.486015141,
0.1435093582,
-0.5126391649,
0.2528317869,
0.1484745741,
0.1683763266,
-0.1600505114,
-0.3696866333,
0.5392475724,
0.1132426634,
0.0412833281,
0.2038611025,
-1.3117877245,
-0.178463161,
-0.2132671028,
0.2657385468,
-0.346985817,
-0.2592328191,
0.235662058,
-0.223646462,
0.3895968795,
0.2293321043,
-0.4733609557,
0.4855133295,
0.5979601741,
0.5026318431,
-0.3156693876,
-0.5038093328,
-0.7586175799,
0.496009469,
-0.4508583546,
1.2240856886,
-0.4427374303,
0.0290665478,
0.1043182686,
-0.0111150397,
-0.1758522838,
-0.8225138783,
0.273124367,
-0.7574881315,
0.483732909,
0.0442986563,
-0.8428559303,
0.0553850606,
0.4638569355,
-0.7539007068,
1.236562252,
0.3456756175,
-0.9504637122,
0.3582158089,
-0.5003368258,
-0.0891899541,
0.0796913803,
-0.0027277938,
-0.1883538067,
-0.16611588,
0.1649034768,
0.0964111015,
-0.5421622396,
0.2896566689,
-0.6580241323,
-0.1448314339,
0.2391264588,
-0.1196547598,
0.4093726873,
0.4373995066,
-0.154245764,
0.0065538012,
-0.85909307,
0.4315841198,
0.1588342488,
-0.4866349697,
-0.3595106602,
0.1449299157,
-0.1218824983,
0.505438447,
0.1828026474,
-0.7648814917,
0.2622203827,
-0.685112834,
0.073508434,
0.5514899492,
-0.0359304845,
0.3767908812,
-0.3838433623,
0.530254364,
0.2648674548,
-0.0148622347,
0.103184782,
-0.7323936224,
-0.9170445204,
-0.1244224608,
0.3078906536,
0.9906519651,
-1.3606745005,
0.3403096795,
-0.3258935809,
-0.3257927001,
-0.6500247121,
0.2118335962,
0.2854232788,
0.5577120185,
0.4652076364,
0.0670452937,
-0.5758696198,
-0.9300058484,
-0.4164761007,
-0.1425641775,
-0.0611461587,
0.0690977946,
0.239588514,
-0.0205613747,
1.2078143358,
-0.779887259,
0.1349950731,
-0.2961840928,
-0.0988208875,
0.1177165732,
0.3793823719,
0.1071124971,
-0.9400997162,
-0.711304903,
0.163913846,
-0.97348243,
-0.1860730946,
0.2953873873,
-0.4611035287,
0.0780005082,
0.3673122823,
-0.4479675293,
0.229395479,
0.6035838127,
-0.7269705534,
0.4599782825,
0.08022286,
0.345865041,
-1.4879217148,
-0.0139728701,
-0.2713061869,
-0.2512556612,
-0.5425114632,
0.2026296407,
-0.0913536549,
-0.41367957,
-0.6328175068,
0.5868136883,
-0.4635350704,
-0.2252634317,
-0.0457391925,
0.3608250916,
0.2939012945,
0.4312340915,
-0.1793049574,
1.1602102518,
0.3029242158,
-0.3072192371,
0.6789380908,
0.2071855664,
-0.2564487457,
0.4595749378,
-0.5495985746,
0.1257542372,
0.0596501268,
-0.178818658,
-1.059912324,
-0.5919623375,
0.2865013182,
-0.2629168034,
-0.1166160777,
0.2424197197,
-0.8508349657,
-0.2894935906,
-0.4507901669,
0.3742079139,
0.1717879772,
-0.6498607397,
0.6444303989,
0.5495175123,
-0.2345109284,
-0.4478451014,
-0.4573475122,
-0.0815730318,
-0.0776818991,
-1.0115879774,
0.2389970273,
-0.0899351239,
-0.3213171363,
0.3394276202,
-0.0802978054,
-0.7160849571,
-0.0206276886,
-0.0419841595,
0.4301984012,
-0.5477669835,
-0.0478836298,
0.3160185218,
0.0300356206,
-0.1153230816,
0.0057870611,
0.6856776476,
0.0272911843,
-0.267724812,
-0.11336983,
0.7400383949,
0.4482609034,
-0.1130862385,
0.7249265909,
0.14491041,
-0.1629087776,
-0.2698910236,
-0.5577809215,
0.188029021,
-0.4219639301,
0.2239291817,
-0.7007812262,
-0.8835246563,
0.4985467792,
-0.2152867317,
0.0253156982,
0.4634546936,
0.5743836164,
-0.0417097025,
0.9922587276,
0.3576834202,
0.0486428551,
-0.0003678082,
0.02802548,
0.2455668002,
-0.5109400749,
-0.2312662899,
-0.4869929254,
-0.029291505,
-0.5433049798,
-0.6493452787,
0.6125958562,
0.2854072154,
0.0260866489,
0.2702414691,
-0.2562297285,
0.5935019255,
0.6372053027,
0.128023386,
0.7400068641,
-0.079240106,
-0.0679239333,
0.2614812851,
-1.171176672,
-0.4050584435,
1.0021653175,
0.2351069748,
0.8964127302,
-0.0100803785,
0.3386582434,
0.2594594061,
0.0255757254,
-0.4932452738,
0.6119856238,
0.2896017134,
-0.8183363676,
-0.1114186645,
-0.6257311106,
-0.8889477849,
0.2195939273,
-0.3142628074,
-0.5536688566,
0.0168454517,
0.3477894366,
-0.1730796546,
0.5070232153,
-1.0335144997,
1.0082112551,
0.242846489,
-0.4681566358,
0.2476751655,
-0.4931290448,
0.5895105004,
0.0410702452,
0.1589419097,
-0.2075348794,
-0.301930815,
0.4821950793,
-0.3861560822,
0.2859418988,
0.1642455608,
-0.1058000922,
0.3653862476,
0.193081066,
0.3633741736,
0.2663165033,
0.0238867141,
-0.0433094725,
0.3524325192,
-0.7845808864,
-0.9046180248,
0.7355791926,
-0.6386567354,
-0.5924339294,
-0.449224025,
-0.9438079,
-0.71707201,
-0.1113279462,
0.3862094879,
0.1994010359,
0.0470688976,
-0.2296637744,
0.6857832074,
-0.3801329434,
0.057915289,
0.4558789432,
-0.3333077133,
-0.5543254018,
1.0936990976,
-0.0300687104,
0.4931541681,
0.3255135715,
-0.2154620886,
-0.0816680714,
-0.1484119445,
-0.7737404108,
0.3446380198,
-0.5054445863,
-0.3290439844,
-0.764082253,
-0.1179214194,
-0.4648981988,
-0.1132576913,
-0.4339315295,
-0.44153741,
-0.1425448358,
0.0458968505,
0.0776304826,
0.4648955166,
0.3498126864,
0.0016701967,
-0.9078105688,
0.6321123242,
0.2602230608,
0.4813748896,
-0.6083291173,
0.132046625,
-0.202968955,
-0.1021789908,
-0.2999777496,
-1.1822046041,
0.1980228871,
0.1304763108,
0.3915126026,
-0.0037382245,
0.3036773801,
0.7153355479,
-0.6898036003,
1.0744832754,
0.152604416,
-0.7864797711,
0.5759400129,
-0.1688731909,
0.3479993939,
0.433203876,
0.712210536,
-0.1247683018,
-0.8527008891,
-0.6665255427,
-0.8831556439,
0.6863617897,
0.122064434,
-0.074564442,
-0.1523165405,
0.0689955577,
0.2393521369,
0.19500646,
-0.5879020691,
-0.2864864469,
-0.0528444164,
-0.245538488,
0.2919136584,
-0.3068656325,
-0.1699851602,
-0.3350070417,
0.6933054924,
-0.384870261,
0.3725536466,
0.3410723507,
0.0241753198,
-0.241295591,
0.4491887391,
0.2643716335,
0.8977087736,
-0.0191473309,
0.2233347595,
0.1048120633,
-0.2885309458,
0.1919129938,
0.2153043449,
-0.1658940911,
0.2280795872,
0.1923700571,
0.6108179688,
-0.0418774709,
-1.1178289652,
0.2713725269,
0.2169905603,
-0.1179185361,
-0.1536837369,
0.183430776,
-0.1181888729,
0.1687917113,
0.1672294736,
-0.4447874427,
0.4548206329,
-0.7258146405,
0.4387568533,
0.1665093303,
-0.0359551236,
-0.1901771426,
0.5136680603,
0.0001087845,
-0.0177534074,
0.4161354601,
0.1353574097,
-0.3329572082,
0.3663877249,
0.6739375591,
0.5621663332,
-0.1424835622,
0.4528837204,
0.1571213603,
-0.0261573959,
0.2578117251,
0.5929605961,
0.0951403454,
-0.7555177212,
-0.6875509024,
-0.6935907006,
-0.5384044647,
-0.0560128801,
-0.5734574199,
0.193821907,
-0.2698212564,
0.1562312841,
0.1133522764,
-0.3283254206,
-0.2139430493,
0.2597135305,
-0.3342975676,
1.2273828983,
-0.6762537956,
0.7937749028,
0.9483898878,
-0.4601317048,
-1.014151454,
0.114269644,
-0.3520101309,
-0.5607002974,
0.4938971102,
-0.4604968131,
0.2799800336,
0.1218521222,
-0.4841508865,
-0.6727731228,
0.7060329914,
0.6991693377,
0.0200167187,
-0.5305281878,
0.7141278386,
0.2849007547,
-0.2047601938,
0.1902254373,
0.6435953975,
0.3005604148,
-0.004462888,
-0.991592288,
-0.2857562006,
-0.6438959241,
0.0163533818,
0.4047688842,
-0.2596170306,
0.8028438091,
0.1617333591,
-0.114957355,
-0.0207061842,
0.715446353,
0.2687562406,
0.564260006,
0.2466935664,
0.9690512419,
0.3358279169,
-0.2820018232,
1.2085124254,
-0.221998781,
0.5266657472,
1.2108243704,
-0.3772717118,
0.8108634949,
0.8192569017,
-0.2382237613,
0.6167110205,
0.4838141799,
0.3279520869,
0.3627212346,
0.0811870918,
-0.4121690392,
-0.2836017013,
-0.1161075681,
-0.4074797928,
0.1843040735,
0.1843371242,
-0.2019135803,
-0.7158530951,
0.2473982573,
-0.007428118,
0.4385605454,
-0.2984330058,
1.0350081921,
-0.3183728755,
-0.7984019518,
0.6630821228,
-0.1814258397,
0.2480461895,
-0.5343795419,
-0.2823745608,
-0.2305680066,
-0.1521472633,
-0.3364089429,
-1.0757900476,
0.5487301946,
0.0329076201,
-0.2966547906,
0.1651491225,
0.5660403371,
-0.5387908816,
-0.2000840008,
0.209686324,
0.7945531011,
0.0190361701,
0.02329823,
-0.6692534685,
0.0605661869,
-0.1844397932,
-0.3247461021,
0.3123221695,
0.5750585198,
0.2508273721,
0.7319159508,
0.5481590033,
0.0177709926,
0.7818681598,
-0.551150918,
1.2624239922,
-0.5309493542,
-0.3782394528,
-0.3953407705,
0.630702734,
-0.1833520532,
-0.3683532476,
0.9132934809,
0.9130907655,
1.2235262394,
-0.3460088074,
0.5091874003,
-0.3620081544,
0.7981638908,
-0.8225682378,
0.2523592114,
-0.7077468038,
0.1331486404,
-0.3910168111,
-1.1182844639,
-0.0976204276,
0.0869792402,
-0.3206694126,
-0.4411762655,
0.7324530482,
0.8272722363,
-0.3146033883,
0.1383868903,
0.584839046,
0.0113240751,
-0.0420979373,
0.7724100947,
0.9839071631,
-0.5999649763,
0.349806726,
-0.306919992,
-0.2080426514,
0.1137225479,
-0.3116021454,
-0.6350972056,
-0.6647507548,
-0.3026735783,
-0.7672429681,
0.236207664,
0.9774714112,
0.4312371612,
-0.9605712891,
-0.267052114,
-0.1546839029,
0.2691946924,
-0.0039073974,
-0.4186219573,
0.1124988049,
-0.767801106,
-1.0421675444,
0.4003582895,
0.4255108535,
-0.5187798738,
-0.1712943763,
0.0717957839,
-0.6843951941,
0.172803849,
0.6116373539,
0.4589311481,
-0.4670158625,
-0.1364587992,
0.1323278695,
-0.1568790376,
0.3336301446,
0.7175560594,
-0.6806676984,
0.5314594507,
0.6706197858,
0.9941999316,
0.0915424451,
0.0376529992,
0.8084549904,
-0.5498331189,
0.1148422435,
0.3959706724,
0.1315827817,
-0.031071905,
-0.3404136002,
0.6843736768,
0.4821228683,
-0.4855493903,
-0.8386200666,
0.1999284923,
-1.126485467,
-0.3371408284,
1.0947083235,
-0.3960990012,
-0.5761563778,
-0.4977739453,
-0.2152525783,
0.193633303,
-0.0760058537,
0.5514935255,
0.4173842072,
-0.31463781,
-0.2155004889,
-0.6061146259,
0.3426861167,
0.4928255975,
-1.4491417408,
-0.2138601542,
0.7693864107,
0.4474105835,
0.4312406778,
0.5598478913,
-0.2404939979,
0.4965838492,
0.0052514942,
-0.079738535,
0.1425995827,
-0.3392373323,
0.3018850982,
0.8652615547,
-0.1040929183,
-0.2121215314
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00554v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00554v1
|
Guiding and Diversifying LLM-Based Story Generation via Answer Set Programming
| 2024-06-01T21:14:25 | 2024-06-01T21:14:25 |
Phoebe J. Wang, Max Kreminski
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Instruction-tuned large language models (LLMs) are capable of generating
stories in response to open-ended user requests, but the resulting stories tend
to be limited in their diversity. Older, symbolic approaches to story
generation (such as planning) can generate substantially more diverse plot
outlines, but are limited to producing stories that recombine a fixed set of
hand-engineered character action templates. Can we combine the strengths of
these approaches while mitigating their weaknesses? We propose to do so by
using a higher-level and more abstract symbolic specification of high-level
story structure -- implemented via answer set programming (ASP) -- to guide and
diversify LLM-based story generation. Via semantic similarity analysis, we
demonstrate that our approach produces more diverse stories than an unguided
LLM, and via code excerpts, we demonstrate the improved compactness and
flexibility of ASP-based outline generation over full-fledged narrative
planning.
|
[
-0.3621814549,
-0.3902050257,
0.3914158046,
0.3811410666,
-0.1202122942,
0.3203944862,
-0.1680717468,
-0.5387915373,
0.5044956207,
0.7716194987,
-0.93284446,
-0.5016402602,
-0.3517674804,
0.2519132793,
-0.1475887895,
1.1283404827,
-0.4090693891,
-0.1778650731,
-0.1360052079,
-0.2271147817,
-0.499343276,
-0.2108405977,
-0.3551512063,
-0.2036650628,
0.7616915703,
0.533872962,
0.6067141294,
0.9368857145,
0.4658993483,
0.2061233819,
0.022053251,
0.3853190541,
-0.5501987338,
0.3827781677,
-0.0769527107,
-0.4285827279,
-0.2106081247,
-0.1429459602,
0.6641263366,
0.9039139152,
0.2139345855,
0.2296228856,
0.1114686206,
0.7042118311,
-0.663004756,
-0.0710907802,
-0.3326924741,
0.2049134225,
0.3213012815,
-0.3797425926,
-0.0874095634,
-0.5023497343,
0.1014678106,
-0.5148679614,
0.2544141412,
0.0773184896,
0.5452971458,
0.0776892155,
-0.3824762106,
-0.5931327343,
-0.8236857057,
0.7584148645,
-0.6766403317,
-0.2972917557,
0.0235696435,
0.3107529879,
0.1410788149,
-0.4664996862,
-0.3335272372,
-0.0122387651,
0.0860926434,
0.1240740269,
0.0008713458,
-0.1533611119,
0.3928107619,
0.3342441022,
-0.6064119935,
0.3839321733,
-0.4554426372,
0.0888130069,
0.8556523919,
0.5294487476,
0.3005634248,
-0.2264311016,
-0.5462807417,
-0.244214192,
-1.0512011051,
0.1991290301,
0.598654151,
0.3193355799,
-0.097292833,
0.8133260012,
-0.3305476308,
0.3437108099,
-0.2015559524,
0.0348863602,
-0.0430804864,
-0.3102085292,
0.0257779025,
0.1828974038,
0.5321124792,
0.7831139565,
0.3938038647,
-0.1156596616,
-0.3157382607,
-0.0799542367,
0.2063993812,
-0.8245177269,
0.0568023287,
0.3163866103,
-0.5945195556,
-0.5020693541,
0.0140675111,
-0.5434250832,
-0.5464266539,
-0.2988589108,
-0.0487046801,
-0.5046232939,
0.0580876917,
0.1949206293,
-0.6251792312,
0.591383636,
0.3992469609,
-1.0716097355,
0.2971530557,
0.715526104,
0.8020258546,
-0.3526140153,
-0.2823744714,
-0.3671980798,
0.731036365,
-0.2910186946,
0.9166240692,
-0.564035356,
-0.5380122066,
0.0451961532,
-0.6670074463,
0.3709002137,
-0.5581775904,
0.1417044699,
-0.2501202524,
0.2757472694,
-0.3481466472,
-0.4689805806,
-0.1813261509,
0.311920166,
-0.4507083595,
0.5264483094,
0.0880173147,
-0.6749032736,
0.393132329,
-0.3702277839,
-0.6450387836,
0.021740282,
-0.5879815817,
-0.1585453004,
0.3171543777,
0.4945566356,
0.1286857873,
-0.3977201283,
0.1339837909,
-0.2260830551,
-0.3594880104,
0.1515809149,
-0.2183190882,
0.8494193554,
0.228736192,
-0.1349930018,
0.4950837493,
-0.7459355593,
0.3226910233,
0.06821841,
-0.4374961257,
-0.0128372861,
0.1652824879,
-0.0882257074,
0.147485137,
0.2722836435,
-0.2742010951,
0.4640902877,
-0.4867835045,
0.0724783018,
0.6415310502,
0.2540816963,
0.2974497378,
-1.0145292282,
0.8458381295,
-0.1477521658,
-0.2180997431,
-0.5527130365,
-0.5399317741,
-0.8336955905,
-0.0319341794,
-0.263602376,
0.5387833118,
-0.6504412889,
0.3662749231,
-0.2939634323,
-0.3378946185,
-0.2348503917,
-0.0268146005,
0.43131724,
0.3332918882,
0.2200242579,
-0.4063321352,
-0.7079271674,
-0.7872301936,
-0.4094999433,
-0.1992651224,
-0.4068130851,
0.324808836,
0.193960771,
0.1299282908,
1.0737489462,
-0.8071504831,
0.158558324,
-0.8147956133,
0.0183698088,
0.28285411,
0.3259428144,
0.361651212,
-0.6345011592,
-0.6637660861,
-0.0777333528,
-0.7478377223,
-0.2681872547,
-0.2872908413,
0.0795848221,
-0.0706926733,
0.4270891249,
-0.5687307119,
0.4405178428,
0.0303575005,
-0.4441942275,
0.787144959,
-0.2366711944,
0.018693611,
-1.3253468275,
-0.0999826491,
-0.3424669206,
-0.0528264195,
-0.4390586913,
0.2805435956,
-0.186865136,
-0.3498035967,
-0.2134253681,
0.6103482842,
-0.5396940112,
-0.3162544072,
-0.2637090087,
0.1431098282,
0.0074154846,
0.5853548646,
0.1027804837,
0.3522776663,
0.4109947085,
-0.54099226,
0.4617697001,
0.5120761395,
-0.1751812696,
0.4685648084,
-0.6486443281,
-0.1287639439,
-0.3277382851,
0.2998069525,
-0.5895703435,
-0.2818214893,
0.0576902963,
-0.3681357205,
0.1281037182,
0.0639388636,
-0.3967187703,
-0.2393278033,
-0.7608251572,
-0.0997416154,
0.6140190959,
-0.4829924107,
0.4184062779,
-0.0104042254,
-0.5786423683,
-0.4657327831,
-0.6004901528,
-0.0242390148,
-0.4198295176,
-0.8859039545,
0.3710039258,
-0.345422864,
-0.4208990335,
-0.1130521074,
-0.3025774956,
0.1033021063,
-0.2316211909,
0.238236472,
0.0712086111,
-0.616245389,
0.0479241051,
0.3139741719,
-0.0348284878,
-0.1190830544,
-0.35531497,
0.5568606257,
0.1041986048,
-0.5253021717,
0.111309357,
0.9085735083,
0.2007940561,
-0.4254205227,
0.4931415021,
0.1954317689,
-0.0753198117,
-0.5767772794,
-0.0774465948,
-0.0354449823,
-0.4932298362,
0.303450048,
-0.1855766922,
-1.0183200836,
0.6408100128,
-0.0520640761,
0.644732058,
0.3132676482,
0.5446485281,
-0.2102558017,
0.6937617064,
0.7779173851,
0.3480896056,
0.3137173653,
0.0099046845,
0.0567770265,
-0.5761829019,
-0.0556666069,
-0.3431304693,
-0.8942449093,
-0.4653090239,
-0.4183801413,
0.2473056316,
0.331507355,
-0.3296138346,
0.2336034626,
-0.3023553193,
0.8168987036,
0.5143646598,
-0.2398468703,
0.6150428057,
0.1687417626,
0.0175849926,
0.1062590778,
-0.666190505,
-0.7071938515,
1.2519080639,
0.3614063561,
0.7915889621,
0.2928595245,
1.1233650446,
-0.0277101882,
0.1778930873,
-0.4209294021,
0.6281497478,
-0.2620786726,
-0.3031776845,
-0.4827713072,
-0.3224009573,
-0.8647185564,
0.201782316,
-0.1744510531,
-0.9144141674,
0.0808044001,
-0.088083677,
-0.4167144597,
0.1130387411,
-0.7532891035,
0.5559664965,
-0.1514874548,
0.1456731856,
-0.1967515349,
-0.7101233006,
0.2294763178,
0.007200304,
-0.3403992057,
-0.0247808546,
-0.2384938002,
0.3347689509,
-0.4738393724,
0.8923489451,
0.2444558144,
-0.2221314907,
0.6689906716,
0.0924899802,
0.5164910555,
0.1440899521,
-0.0331182219,
-0.3602340817,
-0.2888892591,
-0.3182983398,
-0.6300610304,
0.7880407572,
-0.6033285856,
-0.8045986295,
-0.0196390264,
-1.1620668173,
-0.4092416167,
0.1455797851,
0.2268829942,
0.4550476074,
-0.1408955306,
0.1818980575,
0.6281631589,
-0.4259678423,
0.7289366722,
0.4660429657,
-0.4896980524,
-0.2248191535,
0.9061753154,
-0.1288975477,
0.448741138,
0.4697666466,
0.198437497,
-0.0757844076,
-0.7989377975,
-0.3144726753,
0.0179963987,
-0.7381643057,
-0.1572459936,
-0.6021608114,
-0.4753976762,
-0.1796054095,
-0.6383596659,
0.0776348785,
-0.8397589922,
-0.1163942218,
-0.1878878027,
0.3138733506,
0.8129559159,
0.2014502734,
0.3346036971,
-0.7144035697,
0.4874276519,
0.1811058968,
0.2159129828,
-0.1787268966,
-0.0869531482,
0.1110881865,
0.000317702,
-0.5998795629,
-0.8620755076,
0.380471319,
0.1246802509,
0.3758479059,
0.2958067656,
0.1041918322,
0.521306932,
-0.5691574812,
0.4641585946,
0.3226920068,
-0.4170673192,
0.7276517749,
-0.6693355441,
0.6631236672,
0.3438030481,
0.3927769363,
-0.497441262,
-0.6699857712,
-0.6903516054,
-0.8446734548,
0.7527834177,
0.4429744482,
0.2267940342,
0.2321563661,
0.1632784158,
0.2642465532,
0.4281708002,
-0.7893416286,
-0.0123666422,
-0.1179860681,
-0.3971830308,
0.0219508335,
-0.0263473801,
-0.319868207,
0.2327635139,
0.2161992043,
-0.2780546248,
-0.0589327663,
-0.1352587789,
0.0396455452,
-0.2326566875,
0.2707554698,
0.3912072778,
0.7343766093,
-0.0456680171,
0.0569657832,
0.1003175601,
-0.3645359874,
-0.1555144787,
0.2165302485,
-0.4474188089,
-0.1956221908,
0.6806772351,
0.8151538372,
-0.0181099493,
-1.0906221867,
0.3250660896,
0.1498416811,
-0.1400139481,
0.0754011199,
0.5033034682,
0.3551965058,
0.5848276019,
0.199074015,
-0.1276133806,
-0.0960088745,
-0.5678995252,
0.2847028077,
0.2843936682,
-0.380967766,
0.1489503682,
0.3081643283,
0.2574523389,
-0.5062823296,
0.6383891702,
-0.027569741,
-0.0360386185,
1.081518054,
0.9246336818,
0.9919096828,
0.0080809863,
0.2691023648,
0.0932694599,
0.3539407849,
0.3174179494,
0.5234103799,
0.0640139729,
-0.4905277789,
-0.3769544959,
-0.755653739,
-0.2265970111,
-0.0637510046,
-0.4628511965,
0.5743499398,
-0.7477068901,
0.5908622146,
-0.2297509909,
-0.186759159,
-0.1128685996,
0.0203723032,
0.2038449198,
0.9515869617,
-0.4477224946,
0.3887416422,
0.763687849,
-0.56669873,
-0.7627651691,
0.4397370815,
-0.1306765229,
-0.7534281611,
0.5403475761,
0.3890586495,
0.1177264452,
-0.0685921013,
-0.4192332327,
-0.6961749792,
1.3017115593,
0.2783550322,
-0.4455911219,
-0.4844946265,
0.3387383819,
0.6225963831,
-0.7687609792,
-0.1426046193,
0.1090325266,
0.0945138857,
0.5494510531,
-0.5957084298,
0.0162331238,
-0.1473163217,
0.0931469277,
0.2053833157,
-0.4274159372,
0.4974488914,
-0.6303406954,
-0.2750101686,
0.1370440573,
0.8678644896,
0.7107393742,
0.1441812515,
0.13642703,
0.3379554451,
0.4136520624,
0.249556601,
1.0000337362,
-0.1036836207,
-0.0511624962,
1.2733534575,
-0.2377491593,
0.6823265553,
0.3219636083,
-0.0282222945,
0.463593781,
0.5229940414,
-0.0244396962,
0.3965771794,
0.4396215677,
-0.2509020567,
-0.0903540105,
0.0023253057,
-0.244034186,
0.3046122193,
0.23482503,
-0.2240629792,
-0.6146047115,
-0.3303299248,
-0.305277586,
0.2873861492,
-0.5807888508,
0.6552390456,
0.1644820869,
-0.6318467259,
0.2288072705,
0.0216669813,
0.4440681636,
-0.8449941874,
-0.1062724739,
-0.2941439748,
-0.1816264838,
-0.0767119676,
-1.0412228107,
0.4450116456,
0.2599495649,
-0.4319370985,
-0.7358019352,
0.6724711061,
-0.4905090928,
-0.5147836208,
-0.3164502084,
0.634398818,
-0.1280849427,
0.139987424,
-0.2913901508,
-0.1633673012,
0.1633325666,
-0.1152808145,
0.3093121648,
0.5088917613,
-0.4274045229,
0.7699155211,
0.4329755902,
-0.0597126707,
0.0653483942,
0.0700485706,
0.9249340892,
-0.6513158083,
-0.9448548555,
-0.6627902389,
0.6413214207,
-0.1822275668,
-0.4555312097,
0.6338732839,
0.6860876083,
0.6348739266,
-0.2207839489,
0.7748331428,
0.0119130798,
0.4054858088,
-0.5817323327,
0.5897326469,
-0.2465969175,
0.5953233242,
-0.1432115436,
-1.1758087873,
-0.1893451661,
0.3074323535,
-0.0690993741,
0.2046878934,
0.7738916874,
0.4339701235,
-0.0465115011,
0.2147904336,
0.0790018216,
-0.1713310331,
0.2564754188,
0.8095652461,
1.0473265648,
0.2428582907,
0.7178065181,
0.3480319381,
-0.3699672222,
0.0392754301,
-0.8225863576,
-1.1399526596,
-0.3032166958,
-0.2489557415,
-0.059685152,
-0.0422832444,
0.5933519006,
0.1876936853,
-0.5642587543,
-0.5449193716,
-0.2729302049,
0.1717217416,
-0.1888207793,
-0.1236503124,
0.1198043898,
-0.3543455899,
-0.5203723311,
0.2690588832,
0.6121435165,
0.0569122285,
-0.3444306552,
-0.189743638,
0.0830297768,
0.2256248593,
0.4253311753,
0.3653016984,
-0.4703209996,
-0.1604275405,
-0.0535584055,
-0.0870951489,
0.1257259995,
1.256480813,
-0.5032523274,
0.1871029139,
0.461035341,
0.6965277195,
0.4020937681,
-0.1444355994,
1.0684357882,
-1.2098689079,
-0.0181417596,
0.5127917528,
0.1757319868,
0.087841846,
-0.3092091382,
0.4008301795,
-0.1063384116,
-0.0829483494,
-0.3571141064,
0.8643324971,
-0.9384189248,
-0.5328816175,
1.3494801521,
0.0075619477,
0.0446516052,
0.0514658615,
-0.4364172816,
0.0109577971,
-0.0477959849,
0.6022650599,
0.7383585572,
-0.5839322209,
-0.2091198862,
-0.1536720842,
0.4258729219,
0.1603444368,
-1.2032532692,
0.3188194335,
0.7621551156,
0.0846518725,
0.1721206605,
0.5559105873,
-0.1234026775,
0.2113767415,
0.1101988479,
-0.0275964048,
-0.2568059266,
-0.3703377843,
-0.0759903789,
0.2552354932,
0.004055317,
0.2220413238
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00548v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00548v1
|
LIDAO: Towards Limited Interventions for Debiasing (Large) Language Models
| 2024-06-01T20:12:54 | 2024-06-01T20:12:54 |
Tianci Liu, Haoyu Wang, Shiyang Wang, Yu Cheng, Jing Gao
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved impressive performance on various
natural language generation tasks. Nonetheless, they suffer from generating
negative and harmful contents that are biased against certain demographic
groups (e.g., female), raising severe fairness concerns. As remedies, prior
works intervened the generation by removing attitude or demographic
information, inevitably degrading the generation quality and resulting in
notable \textit{fairness-fluency} trade-offs. However, it is still
under-explored to what extent the fluency \textit{has to} be affected in order
to achieve a desired level of fairness. In this work, we conduct the first
formal study from an information-theoretic perspective. We show that previous
approaches are excessive for debiasing and propose LIDAO, a general framework
to debias a (L)LM at a better fluency provably. We further robustify LIDAO in
adversarial scenarios, where a carefully-crafted prompt may stimulate LLMs
exhibiting instruction-following abilities to generate texts with fairness
issue appears only when the prompt is also taken into account. Experiments on
three LMs ranging from 0.7B to 7B parameters demonstrate the superiority of our
method.
|
[
-0.3925538957,
-1.1338237524,
0.435625881,
0.1214131489,
-0.1410698146,
-0.3403348625,
-0.3624242842,
-0.3981208801,
0.1098867059,
0.7268311977,
-0.2271956056,
-0.3751318157,
-0.8634195328,
-0.0748511106,
-0.2597274184,
1.1202194691,
0.3656347394,
0.1743852198,
0.1350455582,
0.1149705723,
-0.5323774219,
-0.3545888364,
-0.8193196058,
-0.2577543557,
0.6575019956,
0.6297649741,
0.9619958401,
0.4907212257,
0.3725571632,
0.1474845707,
-0.2039774656,
-0.1049453169,
-0.8140714169,
0.2299553007,
-0.1412430704,
-0.7568355203,
-0.3819464147,
0.0568944439,
0.7813999653,
0.8056667447,
-0.203426823,
-0.1854077429,
0.2705701292,
0.7326415777,
-0.713762641,
-0.0464965217,
-1.0416566133,
0.051049795,
-0.1942510307,
-0.1506715566,
-0.5137079954,
-0.3860778809,
-0.0284921862,
-0.5632445216,
0.0448340252,
-0.0007489789,
0.7200639844,
0.4759742022,
-0.4917584062,
-0.6379081011,
-0.7436904907,
1.098857522,
-0.8514382243,
0.0215080176,
0.5511925817,
0.3816680908,
-0.4168188274,
-0.2438422143,
-0.5735592246,
-0.4379888475,
0.1553231329,
-0.0073533123,
-0.2782268524,
0.3085207939,
0.3939880431,
0.1843255609,
-0.2148080766,
0.4531560838,
-0.5347528458,
0.0736719519,
0.5570794344,
0.1646763384,
0.2837077677,
-0.2026543617,
-0.4371637404,
0.0380966216,
-0.9531209469,
0.0545256473,
0.8679224849,
0.3386180997,
0.0662556365,
0.416588366,
-0.0976821631,
0.5864300132,
0.1920350492,
-0.1916395724,
0.0231157672,
0.0435852148,
-0.2792793214,
0.0649586767,
0.8133146763,
0.2303189933,
0.404135406,
0.0218227971,
-0.2518069446,
0.021246057,
0.187820971,
-1.0765069723,
0.1731107384,
0.2554281056,
-0.3774397969,
-0.5998542309,
-0.03364693,
-0.9358132482,
-0.7086096406,
-0.2992254794,
0.2489464581,
-0.3271514177,
-0.1516924202,
0.1819919199,
-0.0686621144,
0.1124663278,
0.2764630318,
-1.041308403,
0.109174706,
0.5393203497,
0.3237794042,
0.0495958291,
-0.1366082132,
-0.6436843872,
0.2534802258,
-0.4916976094,
0.3684839308,
-0.7736333609,
-0.3367810547,
0.0731702223,
-0.4737972617,
0.1098255292,
-0.5295898914,
0.796975255,
-0.3502191007,
0.2743399441,
-0.4876048565,
-0.3624397516,
-0.1214827374,
-0.0037768495,
-0.7021247149,
0.6585596204,
-0.1103276536,
-0.9724236131,
0.6622433066,
-0.4627885222,
-0.3261197209,
-0.2067697197,
-0.5064271092,
-0.1895036697,
0.1180874258,
0.2598073184,
0.3521895707,
-0.6598723531,
1.0013773441,
-0.443554759,
-0.4896598458,
0.2951363027,
-0.9354821444,
1.0576120615,
0.4375298023,
-0.5259954333,
0.0018251536,
-0.7276764512,
-0.3784260452,
0.0692277476,
-0.0835911259,
-0.4067892134,
-0.0841317698,
-0.1419685483,
0.0220366456,
0.2706379294,
-0.4008280039,
0.2680151165,
-0.6097798944,
0.1911875308,
1.0471760035,
-0.0781372711,
0.432967484,
-0.5181581378,
0.6967661977,
-0.0162302218,
0.3513152003,
0.2573432028,
-0.4754098356,
-0.622913003,
-0.5060170293,
0.2009809315,
0.4151417315,
-0.9607521892,
0.3287511468,
-0.1694545597,
-0.1804955751,
-0.6149758101,
0.3424518108,
0.4261732101,
0.4668430984,
0.0459999554,
-0.0076263896,
-0.4460466504,
-1.1161305904,
-0.1235180721,
-0.040142145,
0.0563243739,
0.240839377,
0.3114255965,
-0.2697283328,
0.8977356553,
-0.3135129511,
-0.3433323801,
-0.3425553143,
0.0868275017,
0.4535934031,
0.2549332976,
0.9895369411,
-0.8176159263,
-0.3285893202,
-0.3858604133,
-0.7861800194,
-0.3040382266,
-0.0443502478,
-0.1508936733,
0.114446491,
0.4420256317,
-0.4055985212,
0.2758399844,
0.4684948325,
-0.1188270971,
0.2009895146,
-0.1810695082,
0.2071285844,
-0.9512309432,
0.1721328795,
-0.2615326643,
0.0682223439,
-0.7699664235,
0.1038937122,
-0.5552036762,
0.0064680981,
-0.4093895555,
0.916708231,
-0.2412668914,
0.1481279433,
-0.5750244856,
0.4194032848,
-0.1319165677,
0.374086529,
-0.244850412,
0.4745226502,
0.5725939274,
-0.6736724377,
0.122114189,
-0.018407587,
-0.2282008678,
0.6395108104,
-0.7652349472,
-0.0566820055,
-0.5852483511,
0.1261823326,
-0.8497593403,
-0.3378969133,
0.4116731882,
-0.3813524842,
0.2358953208,
0.0162074324,
-0.3513033688,
-0.1869787872,
-0.5618671775,
0.5308971405,
0.6014739275,
-0.5136694908,
0.1444138736,
0.5324792266,
-0.1672372222,
-1.0124958754,
-0.7601063848,
0.047574643,
-0.5198504329,
-0.583250463,
0.1234947816,
-0.2606065869,
-0.6068089604,
-0.1458804905,
0.351038307,
-0.0653804168,
0.416963011,
0.1317619979,
-0.0636416152,
0.0107874712,
0.2102646828,
0.3477122486,
-0.0517542586,
-0.1887506992,
-0.0639235452,
0.4471936822,
0.0540431775,
-0.1599746644,
-0.2325310111,
0.2340845913,
0.3236181736,
0.0225836597,
0.9169807434,
0.5486729145,
-0.4225007892,
-0.4383665323,
-0.4915859103,
-0.2153377235,
-0.448266536,
0.1168940961,
-0.2844522297,
-0.7803845406,
0.5070571899,
0.5303008556,
0.0582940057,
0.3045361936,
0.7074178457,
0.277197063,
0.8068343401,
0.526706636,
-0.2016458362,
0.6510419846,
-0.0196151473,
0.2543619275,
-0.6386184096,
0.2282331139,
-0.5881606936,
-0.2785060108,
-0.6556042433,
-0.3796713948,
0.3212921023,
0.532133162,
-0.195239529,
0.0168522559,
-0.3353839517,
0.2492119819,
0.788403213,
0.1341347247,
0.3399074972,
-0.089687027,
0.0824040845,
-0.0710154474,
-0.9167313576,
-0.6218707561,
1.3517202139,
0.4333602488,
0.822173059,
0.1894353777,
0.881504178,
0.4570060372,
0.5531321168,
-0.509183228,
0.5332347155,
-0.2457212061,
-0.825327456,
-0.4907654524,
-0.635846436,
-1.3466153145,
0.2061498165,
-0.171939522,
-0.8353289962,
0.3181341588,
0.2960718572,
-0.1426645666,
0.1893867701,
-0.3886074722,
0.7241802812,
-0.1784531474,
-0.4561250806,
-0.2057110369,
-0.3635198772,
0.6428070068,
0.0287191682,
0.4548380673,
-0.2831678987,
-0.007520468,
0.5067299604,
-0.1198805422,
1.0202651024,
-0.4601898789,
-0.6386222243,
0.6169040799,
0.1560492814,
0.3859016597,
0.156291455,
-0.4108821154,
0.0483784229,
-0.2781633437,
-0.5982190371,
-0.5193833113,
0.8054481149,
-0.5525755286,
-0.8192834258,
-0.1730419248,
-0.6082177162,
-0.0553451292,
0.2070614249,
0.412994504,
0.3448261917,
-0.3103912175,
0.4352559149,
0.7222278714,
-0.5645539761,
0.2606448233,
0.346262753,
-0.3830424845,
-0.5032300353,
0.8235855699,
0.1732881218,
0.3428116739,
0.4646144509,
0.5618736744,
-0.1157738343,
-0.64740026,
-0.3174422383,
-0.0685991421,
-0.7094200253,
-0.1290888041,
-0.355735302,
0.0985211954,
-0.4701236188,
-0.1280442476,
-0.1476855278,
-0.2909172773,
-0.1616014838,
-0.0620974712,
0.0367241129,
0.5917302966,
-0.1264431775,
0.3304605782,
-0.4579825997,
0.5603652596,
0.252540499,
0.0546510257,
0.0790212452,
-0.6797116995,
-0.0140021676,
0.471496284,
-0.1682318896,
-0.8801172376,
0.191425994,
-0.0364820398,
0.7444068789,
0.4729651213,
0.3155188262,
0.1818581372,
-0.1038446501,
0.6601942182,
0.1088163108,
-0.8766474724,
0.6759201288,
-0.7487487793,
-0.1068660319,
0.6145884395,
0.2449509501,
-0.2358521372,
-0.7596004009,
-0.6347620487,
-0.7731273174,
0.5281134844,
0.2362027019,
0.2168224454,
-0.3490781486,
0.2970688641,
0.2537187636,
0.62894243,
-0.9730309844,
-0.0086015221,
0.1404992193,
-0.4648871422,
0.0976165757,
-0.3772668839,
-0.1808000654,
0.2910937667,
0.7378336191,
-0.1321952343,
-0.137991339,
0.2366161346,
-0.181537047,
-0.0697326064,
0.5788985491,
0.5532946587,
0.6330077052,
-0.0992267951,
-0.0477419719,
-0.1077084988,
-0.1462979764,
0.0943295583,
0.065983437,
-0.8401985765,
-0.2154634446,
0.3899827302,
0.9165117741,
0.1107133627,
-0.7777497768,
0.6890214086,
0.1906630248,
-0.0691816658,
-0.0403675325,
0.3137018085,
-0.4090122879,
0.184960112,
0.3004007041,
-0.3756847084,
0.3296437263,
-0.7440088987,
0.0921778977,
0.6640659571,
-0.3307444453,
0.0570856705,
0.7981498837,
0.4470904171,
-0.0042589409,
0.2209567726,
-0.5340534449,
-0.3006899059,
0.7697249055,
0.2457334697,
0.9226751924,
-0.2372273803,
0.3163328767,
0.3647460341,
0.4533740878,
-0.0364013091,
0.0593736917,
0.1767544746,
-0.7719475627,
-0.1957882047,
-0.5555523038,
-0.2454564571,
0.1385614276,
-0.632686615,
0.29145509,
-0.4492269754,
-0.2077926397,
-0.382511586,
0.0989060327,
-0.5732492208,
0.1504862159,
0.0740428567,
0.4166319966,
-0.6066567302,
0.7031875253,
0.1886720508,
-0.6276974082,
-0.3293682039,
0.1729596704,
-0.1959329545,
-0.7676501274,
0.7501991987,
0.1693005264,
-0.2284034044,
-0.3035306036,
-0.4374836981,
-0.4353868067,
0.8880046606,
0.7558564544,
-0.7315641642,
-0.1222844124,
0.136957109,
0.646776855,
-0.192137152,
0.2784123123,
0.4438762665,
0.5587895513,
-0.1796992123,
-0.8344469666,
0.1649261564,
0.0288040526,
0.0202096123,
0.0292486828,
-0.8324229121,
0.876283884,
-0.3228653371,
-0.2359722853,
0.2178153247,
0.4758576453,
0.0078971954,
0.2506186366,
0.4811585546,
0.3685105443,
0.9443725348,
0.1167182028,
1.119879365,
-0.3956196308,
0.176579684,
1.119558692,
-0.2750397921,
0.4923975468,
0.5210967064,
0.0346377343,
0.0968958735,
0.2174565345,
0.1328648329,
0.3233602941,
0.580722928,
-0.0936726555,
-0.003652785,
-0.417720288,
-0.4398438036,
0.4228988886,
0.166744262,
-0.3858227432,
-0.0110630123,
0.2866477668,
0.1983176172,
0.4111000597,
-0.228244707,
0.5604643822,
0.1564753354,
-0.7487746477,
0.6433382034,
0.0481688306,
0.8075220585,
-0.5049499273,
-0.005119795,
-0.4337659776,
0.1245946512,
-0.0063746907,
-0.6765335798,
0.1367053986,
0.068028219,
-0.2041420192,
-0.0964175239,
0.6283254623,
-0.5331713557,
-0.4135787487,
0.4569149911,
0.411845237,
0.0008618031,
0.0273017529,
-0.5835940838,
0.0855161101,
0.1698591113,
-0.33771047,
0.2377662957,
0.5607438087,
0.1512160599,
0.64985919,
0.3512313962,
0.1617756933,
-0.0341524035,
0.3657193184,
0.497638464,
-0.6443473101,
-0.4066761434,
-0.7727512717,
0.2299849242,
-0.0532184802,
-0.3777078688,
0.6783893704,
0.2987508476,
0.6904281974,
0.0965233892,
0.8170893788,
-0.0801483318,
0.2500302196,
-0.8551794291,
0.4527329803,
-0.5779779553,
0.6193525791,
-0.3989594579,
-0.9424265027,
-0.0961247012,
0.5391600132,
-0.4449616373,
0.1460111439,
0.3153333962,
0.7993681431,
0.3066771924,
-0.256152451,
0.4533163309,
0.3251209259,
0.5680525303,
0.9752104878,
0.9119647145,
-0.3756065965,
0.6506372094,
0.0107231969,
-0.3888271749,
-0.3197586238,
-0.8850452304,
-1.1559048891,
-0.2330145985,
0.1139801145,
-0.2541613877,
0.302654475,
0.9345731735,
0.3531649709,
-0.4157360792,
-0.149339214,
-0.260682404,
0.4862170517,
0.1952164173,
-0.2554646432,
0.0982322544,
-0.3946577907,
-1.0653048754,
0.1537976563,
0.0010014219,
-0.0418915451,
-0.3583523929,
-0.1447667032,
0.2159114033,
0.308391571,
0.3617277741,
0.0349993333,
-0.6877593398,
-0.3401610851,
-0.3701602519,
-0.3315407038,
0.0919807851,
0.784735918,
-0.5881444812,
0.4805455804,
0.5477097034,
0.6559303999,
0.0962760076,
-0.1607186794,
0.7018563747,
-0.6185202003,
0.5798136592,
0.4925642014,
0.3421195447,
0.2230935097,
-0.3648886085,
0.3851238191,
-0.0164688248,
-0.3791734278,
-0.9590274096,
0.5833535194,
-0.6222178936,
-0.4705432951,
1.2704461813,
0.0875925496,
-0.0023198084,
0.2816056907,
-0.4870256484,
0.0881540999,
-0.5928844213,
1.0214623213,
0.7971361279,
0.182518065,
0.1452906281,
-0.6812118888,
0.5158150196,
0.5567644238,
-0.9866107106,
0.1791035533,
0.5944815874,
-0.045358289,
0.0063605011,
0.9086631536,
-0.0116580203,
0.1956600398,
0.2550599873,
-0.1569667011,
0.1148666516,
-0.6514123082,
-0.3821148574,
0.1443805248,
0.3164013922,
0.1461706311
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00515v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00515v1
|
A Survey on Large Language Models for Code Generation
| 2024-06-01T17:48:15 | 2024-06-01T17:48:15 |
Juyong Jiang, Fan Wang, Jiasi Shen, Sungju Kim, Sunghun Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SE
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have garnered remarkable advancements across
diverse code-related tasks, known as Code LLMs, particularly in code generation
that generates source code with LLM from natural language descriptions. This
burgeoning field has captured significant interest from both academic
researchers and industry professionals due to its practical significance in
software development, e.g., GitHub Copilot. Despite the active exploration of
LLMs for a variety of code tasks, either from the perspective of natural
language processing (NLP) or software engineering (SE) or both, there is a
noticeable absence of a comprehensive and up-to-date literature review
dedicated to LLM for code generation. In this survey, we aim to bridge this gap
by providing a systematic literature review that serves as a valuable reference
for researchers investigating the cutting-edge progress in LLMs for code
generation. We introduce a taxonomy to categorize and discuss the recent
developments in LLMs for code generation, covering aspects such as data
curation, latest advances, performance evaluation, and real-world applications.
In addition, we present a historical overview of the evolution of LLMs for code
generation and offer an empirical comparison using the widely recognized
HumanEval and MBPP benchmarks to highlight the progressive enhancements in LLM
capabilities for code generation. We identify critical challenges and promising
opportunities regarding the gap between academia and practical development.
Furthermore, we have established a dedicated resource website
(https://codellm.github.io) to continuously document and disseminate the most
recent advances in the field.
|
[
-0.4682222605,
-0.6155252457,
0.4555297494,
0.1489390135,
-0.0686767101,
0.2774069309,
-0.5312482119,
-0.4989131391,
0.0875341222,
0.6118853092,
-0.4010665119,
-0.6144667864,
-0.3016131818,
0.2928252816,
-0.3169203699,
0.9206023812,
-0.0371022411,
0.2614901364,
-0.3485504985,
0.2580664158,
-0.3603523076,
-0.6709991097,
-0.4052527845,
-0.2577600777,
0.4925361872,
0.1274798661,
0.3135069907,
0.1553212106,
0.6829198003,
0.2241079062,
-0.2145066559,
0.2329062074,
-0.368467927,
0.319236964,
-0.0010146898,
-0.1914203763,
-0.6795158386,
-0.3186678886,
0.6635493636,
0.6869866848,
-0.1294744015,
0.4162812531,
0.0049238149,
0.8133907914,
-0.4838553667,
0.110668242,
-0.7836751938,
0.0232180096,
-0.2063278556,
-0.2841098011,
-0.412132591,
-0.5210642219,
-0.3593675494,
0.0275930539,
0.0946939364,
-0.0704640746,
0.365439117,
0.018160155,
-0.3804350495,
-0.6229569316,
-0.8291166425,
0.841014564,
-0.8924718499,
0.1934744716,
0.029351959,
0.1087945253,
-0.3716594279,
-0.81930089,
-0.3558913469,
-0.5176804662,
0.339833647,
-0.0894749463,
-0.0833823532,
-0.151980266,
0.3212687671,
0.6249999404,
-0.661618948,
0.3275970221,
-0.4096119106,
-0.1534398496,
0.8411095738,
0.3600471914,
0.2331973016,
-0.2579959929,
-0.1495510638,
0.2363855988,
-1.1593909264,
-0.1293462962,
0.4824316502,
0.1527291238,
-0.1846055835,
0.5529369116,
-0.0705777258,
0.7460461855,
-0.4169528782,
-0.1625936031,
0.2425575703,
-0.5123835206,
-0.1289190054,
-0.2461946607,
0.917514801,
0.2938438654,
0.1355164051,
0.0559391789,
-0.4175564051,
-0.0202739909,
0.3584902585,
-0.9166820049,
0.0608774386,
0.1848382205,
-0.4689656794,
-0.4833580256,
-0.040841084,
-0.6950054765,
-0.3020379245,
-0.237902239,
-0.4248773456,
0.0364162922,
-0.4395284057,
0.0229791366,
0.2237882912,
0.4816584587,
0.1690383554,
-0.6169862747,
-0.0210637674,
0.9090155363,
0.8017203808,
-0.1266717166,
0.0207205378,
-0.273011595,
-0.0251781624,
-0.6069434285,
0.4998110235,
-0.3032290637,
-0.4617374241,
0.4779781103,
-0.220751062,
0.3151037991,
-0.5918260217,
0.4389626086,
-0.6962680221,
-0.0982070118,
0.087791957,
-0.4798065424,
0.1613785625,
0.4084093869,
-0.4981026947,
0.9016771317,
0.0140322791,
-0.7635999918,
0.2756562233,
-0.4752479196,
-0.4185295105,
0.3115063906,
-0.5981009603,
-0.6303800941,
0.2657571435,
-0.0866008773,
0.6564793587,
-0.7848519087,
0.8214108348,
-0.359742403,
-0.1038310379,
0.511472404,
-0.1734478474,
0.6242343187,
0.5073484778,
-0.2109804899,
0.2085373402,
-0.6529275775,
0.1231198534,
0.3452801704,
-0.5100024343,
0.0188267995,
0.2397960871,
0.0674484149,
0.2851065695,
0.3380697668,
-0.3826876879,
0.4727900326,
-0.2111662924,
0.7777817845,
0.4682442844,
0.1820411533,
0.3459659815,
-0.3880782127,
0.7011830807,
-0.2580122948,
0.1312715113,
-0.4532904327,
-0.4195882678,
-0.4670265615,
-0.0151125146,
0.3541547954,
0.1793194264,
-0.664696455,
0.4571484923,
-0.2025341243,
-0.576810956,
-0.2301257551,
0.4298980534,
0.3994714618,
0.0012866389,
-0.029885428,
-0.2852811217,
-0.7188321352,
-0.849362433,
0.1033884138,
-0.1840806156,
-0.156930685,
0.3609943986,
0.45752424,
-0.5783346295,
0.7660050988,
-0.5455664396,
0.0495062098,
-0.4802228808,
-0.0007451609,
0.1362202764,
0.4521418214,
0.3833106756,
-0.6154897809,
-0.3184254766,
-0.0479564257,
-0.5360767841,
-0.1951331198,
-0.1159525588,
0.0007898618,
0.5201789141,
0.664119184,
-0.4667401314,
-0.1224593297,
0.7223373055,
0.1062678099,
0.6241253018,
0.0763728544,
-0.0609357432,
-1.1288967133,
0.2886935472,
-0.0576313138,
-0.1200714335,
-0.5620208383,
0.5555661917,
0.070923157,
-0.1521141231,
-0.3200549483,
0.3292213976,
-0.7893459201,
-0.3401159048,
-0.3124654889,
0.1122127846,
-0.2530775666,
0.278532207,
0.036886286,
0.6922305226,
0.6306524277,
-0.4973703325,
0.2792066336,
-0.0512582622,
-0.416444093,
-0.0515025705,
-0.6120191216,
0.2823752165,
0.1743640751,
0.4074614942,
-0.7104180455,
-0.3920499682,
0.0012471076,
-0.3073222041,
0.3824955523,
-0.2547854781,
-0.8679837584,
-0.6520946026,
-0.3878091574,
0.3151161969,
0.8316418529,
-0.1949463338,
0.030000221,
0.4129342735,
-0.4500003457,
-0.1824688911,
-0.5731879473,
0.1467174739,
-0.0920336768,
-0.6609348655,
0.0106444741,
-0.2065898627,
-0.4702461064,
-0.4381004572,
0.0076350658,
0.0805680305,
0.083166264,
0.0780853555,
0.3579637706,
-0.4055373371,
0.2263655812,
-0.2014300674,
0.1887357533,
0.4305672646,
-0.2332330495,
0.7581453323,
-0.0770501345,
-0.2886921763,
0.2102611065,
0.174617216,
0.4275502563,
-0.3428334892,
0.384041369,
0.4758725464,
-0.0596312732,
-0.586209178,
-0.5908868909,
0.1519774646,
-0.4091903865,
0.2864674032,
-0.0866992697,
-1.1911057234,
0.3860698044,
-0.3505127728,
0.3735565543,
0.3655499816,
0.9639474154,
0.1607329845,
0.791277647,
0.6881605983,
0.0248691253,
0.3909757137,
-0.2304350883,
0.2058549225,
-0.8233164549,
-0.0365203097,
-0.6749750376,
-0.0032521836,
-0.8239914775,
-0.6661065817,
0.1584620774,
0.2229975313,
-0.1149116382,
-0.0459295548,
-0.6362506747,
0.2043189108,
0.1351787299,
-0.2547768056,
0.3617062569,
0.0022033779,
0.0089725722,
0.1845248193,
-0.7664111257,
-0.7341390252,
1.3606120348,
0.4283188283,
0.8781735301,
0.0853271186,
0.8189356923,
0.3312232792,
0.550970912,
-0.5107591152,
0.6610392332,
0.0399122052,
-0.592640698,
-0.1139249355,
-0.6816627979,
-0.99971807,
-0.062362276,
-0.0817711726,
-0.2794550061,
-0.3363354504,
0.075293608,
-0.1045164466,
0.2728816867,
-0.3085840642,
0.5978837609,
-0.4176624715,
-0.574845314,
-0.1930031627,
-0.5277175307,
0.7933126092,
-0.4489878118,
0.4160520136,
-0.0303369183,
-0.1766406894,
0.5260707736,
-0.3830626905,
0.801839292,
-0.0390346013,
-0.6642815471,
0.6507608294,
-0.0070454143,
0.5187006593,
0.103252992,
-0.1333859861,
0.221759215,
-0.315738529,
-0.1844870448,
-0.0248700287,
0.9159197807,
-0.3917135894,
-0.4038745165,
-0.2387680858,
-0.4375239909,
-0.2656430304,
0.1400281191,
0.2521559596,
0.4664075375,
-0.2115443349,
0.1974404007,
0.6141942739,
-0.5638884306,
0.4361395538,
0.3534468114,
-0.7184693217,
-0.3961347342,
0.8533394933,
-0.0623686016,
0.2947952449,
0.277389437,
-0.0040438524,
-0.0554036647,
-0.987685442,
-0.3845299482,
0.2783908546,
-0.4118392766,
-0.3767279685,
-0.4096907973,
-0.4205932021,
-0.4861914515,
-0.3263286352,
-0.1992681623,
-0.1276752353,
-0.0787010044,
0.0931689367,
0.3237390816,
1.1021533012,
0.3076732159,
-0.0162670538,
-0.9543032646,
0.2696525753,
-0.0540709049,
0.3902782202,
0.1122937575,
-0.1997300535,
-0.3818179667,
-0.076437138,
-0.48274827,
-0.6057583094,
0.3717119992,
-0.2312857956,
0.4832608402,
0.0828383788,
0.106633909,
0.4397517443,
-0.5052203536,
0.9958938956,
0.5436841249,
-0.6349490285,
0.4979199767,
-0.5609103441,
0.3972701132,
0.2044517249,
0.2229496539,
-0.3792528808,
-0.5171102285,
-0.5033585429,
-1.0439128876,
0.4014242291,
0.2190751731,
0.2622251213,
-0.0001817484,
0.1256305873,
0.0817208514,
0.5101565719,
-0.8742219806,
0.009350176,
0.3681930304,
-0.009021733,
-0.0123087484,
-0.2850832939,
-0.0344548523,
0.1525420398,
0.4874489009,
-0.2291961014,
0.2366019487,
-0.0660675243,
-0.1442462653,
-0.1763128936,
0.6321691871,
0.7203768492,
0.8004031181,
0.009318389,
-0.0457094237,
-0.0670479015,
-0.4139190316,
0.014614624,
-0.0457611308,
-0.2936805189,
-0.0179236364,
0.4221974909,
0.4989413619,
0.2417183816,
-1.0110948086,
0.5525087714,
0.0697245821,
-0.5067750216,
-0.6209195852,
0.1445136815,
0.3269850612,
0.2174322009,
0.3818589747,
-0.2097926736,
0.0517365858,
-0.549580574,
-0.0404866189,
0.4886906743,
0.0713485628,
-0.1256018579,
0.4589504004,
0.5470506549,
-0.2477680743,
0.4891394079,
-0.3932694197,
-0.2135766149,
0.6988210678,
0.4138370156,
1.0393568277,
0.2221708298,
-0.0920102298,
0.3456402421,
0.34080863,
-0.013053013,
0.3760646582,
-0.1718325764,
-0.3543770611,
-0.6658157706,
-0.9469459057,
-0.2862092555,
0.266470015,
-0.3739872277,
0.2570976615,
-0.4640251398,
-0.304351747,
-0.217804119,
0.1061819568,
-0.425335288,
-0.3111251593,
0.5509650707,
0.9558505416,
-0.3856663406,
0.7424109578,
0.8718301058,
-0.3501926064,
-0.5888282061,
-0.0075717634,
-0.1660045832,
-0.3664781153,
0.5747800469,
-0.0538560487,
0.004198669,
-0.1571182162,
-0.7024271488,
-0.4990544319,
1.0000417233,
0.1510762423,
-0.9733113647,
-0.2853297591,
0.1905381083,
0.6641578674,
-0.4768246114,
0.1080095842,
0.275544405,
0.2350253612,
-0.0010417748,
-0.753256619,
-0.1739369184,
-0.344919771,
0.4386538863,
0.4491602182,
-0.7842463255,
0.6792600751,
-0.1524553597,
-0.0439035445,
0.3366448581,
0.4121293724,
0.6561093926,
0.3657378554,
0.08156804,
0.0647293478,
0.3558188379,
0.027618967,
0.9779265523,
-0.6829451323,
0.3420001566,
0.9361630082,
-0.6508080363,
0.8383724093,
0.4369710684,
-0.3816028237,
0.349693656,
0.5379999876,
-0.2525683641,
-0.0474722274,
0.7567453384,
-0.0980786607,
-0.2327263504,
0.1131554246,
-0.507201314,
0.1652528048,
0.2304654717,
-0.6642115712,
-0.0836562216,
-0.2353872955,
-0.0116786575,
0.1152123958,
-0.5996917486,
0.8367442489,
0.2441420704,
-0.7793656588,
0.6361000538,
0.2069892883,
0.8111743331,
-0.7975702286,
-0.0527082644,
-0.2993524671,
-0.0345676765,
-0.3343492746,
-0.7735079527,
0.200146094,
0.6171873212,
-0.1858986616,
-0.4715903103,
0.7660371065,
-0.1830316037,
-0.4330390692,
0.2364084125,
0.6386930943,
0.1926689595,
0.3587272763,
-0.6191094518,
0.4338472784,
0.13006185,
-0.4053636491,
0.450475961,
0.3736931384,
0.0721606538,
0.6313948035,
0.6872319579,
0.2216849476,
0.3475488424,
0.1392163932,
0.9021382332,
-0.8256361485,
-0.3102251589,
-0.6642602682,
0.3261865973,
0.0894531831,
-0.3228394091,
0.7290424705,
0.7941700816,
0.9640312195,
-0.3160221279,
0.8446124196,
-0.1839511842,
0.3984173238,
-0.6041510105,
0.5726417899,
-0.4247095883,
0.5518034697,
-0.4544158578,
-1.0432584286,
-0.336494267,
0.1832401901,
-0.2570285797,
0.1361589283,
0.4713623822,
0.8174405694,
0.2623369992,
-0.1780599505,
0.4075897038,
0.1479649544,
0.3205879927,
0.5602761507,
1.1291239262,
-0.0513013862,
0.6293904185,
0.1278731674,
0.121077843,
-0.3973339498,
-0.8345144987,
-0.7845522165,
-0.3478962183,
-0.3440490961,
-0.1233838499,
-0.1465936601,
0.9623284936,
0.468940556,
-0.5512162447,
-0.5659651756,
-0.4266355634,
-0.0044671563,
0.0756152868,
-0.1892275959,
-0.0649398044,
-0.6030221581,
-0.7230703831,
0.1323226541,
0.2379819751,
-0.2098067701,
-0.7178142071,
-0.4246222377,
0.0317820683,
0.0112321433,
0.849244535,
0.2327318192,
-0.6821149588,
0.3659552932,
-0.0113908732,
-0.6158283353,
-0.0809187293,
1.2075277567,
-0.3166942,
0.0813629329,
0.5081143975,
0.684612453,
0.351053834,
-0.4149992466,
0.4839933515,
-0.6250841022,
-0.1294068992,
0.4033766389,
0.4432357252,
0.3418429792,
-0.1018957943,
0.6935335994,
0.0463877767,
-0.837254405,
-1.066611886,
0.4566821456,
-0.8820441365,
-0.3324496448,
1.475915432,
0.091837652,
-0.0553667471,
0.0937184691,
-0.1429167539,
0.0758453831,
-0.3343568146,
0.4243151844,
0.503023088,
-0.0383388288,
-0.1386030018,
-0.7550166845,
0.3800537288,
-0.0477100015,
-0.9423344135,
0.2911404967,
0.9277048707,
0.148017928,
0.0587603934,
0.6371434927,
-0.3299491704,
0.1919795275,
-0.0429684669,
0.5266284943,
0.0328394733,
-0.1860723644,
-0.4949094355,
0.3389886916,
0.7093313336,
0.3688624203
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00507v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00507v1
|
Prompt Chaining or Stepwise Prompt? Refinement in Text Summarization
| 2024-06-01T17:28:38 | 2024-06-01T17:28:38 |
Shichao Sun, Ruifeng Yuan, Ziqiang Cao, Wenjie Li, Pengfei Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated the capacity to improve
summary quality by mirroring a human-like iterative process of critique and
refinement starting from the initial draft. Two strategies are designed to
perform this iterative process: Prompt Chaining and Stepwise Prompt. Prompt
chaining orchestrates the drafting, critiquing, and refining phases through a
series of three discrete prompts, while Stepwise prompt integrates these phases
within a single prompt. However, the relative effectiveness of the two methods
has not been extensively studied. This paper is dedicated to examining and
comparing these two methods in the context of text summarization to ascertain
which method stands out as the most effective. Experimental results show that
the prompt chaining method can produce a more favorable outcome. This might be
because stepwise prompt might produce a simulated refinement process according
to our various experiments. Since refinement is adaptable to diverse tasks, our
conclusions have the potential to be extrapolated to other applications,
thereby offering insights that may contribute to the broader development of
LLMs.
|
[
-0.2542412877,
-0.6156556606,
0.6543002129,
0.4225050807,
-0.4126170576,
0.4952042103,
-0.1061336696,
-0.3774637878,
0.2329111099,
0.3889262974,
-0.7404587269,
-0.2227326035,
-0.1771306247,
0.7324557304,
-0.5651834011,
1.1965758801,
-0.2779183388,
0.2300559878,
-0.1631603837,
-0.0682514086,
-0.5502344966,
-0.4118853509,
-0.9600880146,
-0.7011998296,
0.8636345267,
0.382366091,
0.5906385183,
0.6270197034,
0.346598804,
0.3127943277,
-0.2179938853,
0.1580838114,
-0.3463719189,
0.5356714725,
-0.1598245203,
-0.5060388446,
-0.330668956,
-0.0458354391,
0.4916101694,
0.8785488605,
0.007534767,
0.115375638,
0.1706593782,
1.0458209515,
-0.5741532445,
-0.0830767825,
-0.2394600958,
-0.1155867204,
0.1596025079,
-0.3611062467,
-0.32156986,
-0.7189610004,
0.2024698853,
-0.4305740595,
0.1770731062,
0.1193947494,
0.4503365159,
0.0489932187,
-0.2575208843,
-0.3790996373,
-0.6989840269,
0.6288650036,
-0.7647436261,
0.2024957687,
0.0823599398,
0.1653380692,
-0.0901056975,
-0.8968099356,
-0.308694303,
-0.4417395592,
-0.0811925828,
0.1516382247,
0.0663464665,
0.1362056136,
0.3290927112,
0.5614060163,
-0.4211789668,
0.3080182374,
-0.3846321702,
-0.1746171862,
0.664291501,
0.3055060506,
0.1838461608,
-0.2154470235,
-0.4491301477,
-0.096041359,
-0.9171187878,
0.2142303586,
0.3295575678,
0.5502622724,
0.0370478146,
0.5546562076,
-0.4621705115,
0.5154879689,
0.22247383,
-0.3731800914,
-0.1139390618,
-0.7095441818,
-0.1325100511,
0.0850806311,
0.7766484618,
0.880307138,
0.4577257335,
-0.0013816655,
-0.5276343822,
-0.2469262481,
0.1014862806,
-0.75682199,
0.0089172916,
0.3731845617,
-0.6240004301,
-0.3654642403,
0.0516599566,
-0.6161590219,
-0.4868634045,
-0.5372410417,
0.1565049291,
-0.2829921544,
0.1980858296,
-0.2163545638,
-0.3237507045,
0.0721067786,
0.7198029757,
-0.7962297797,
0.3665534556,
0.7117888927,
1.050418973,
-0.3783856332,
-0.3669709861,
-0.6044111252,
-0.2942963839,
-0.5912123919,
1.0273122787,
-0.2654616833,
-0.6501669288,
0.0807542801,
-0.1550745219,
0.168103531,
-0.529712379,
0.5429437757,
-0.4217948616,
0.2264336795,
-0.606585741,
-0.310999006,
-0.1472932398,
0.1506126672,
-0.6884386539,
1.0610654354,
-0.1230298281,
-0.7016217709,
0.43073228,
-0.136959821,
-0.5650423765,
-0.1705534011,
0.0266256854,
-0.2225632966,
0.1619481295,
0.374468714,
0.482737124,
-0.3890307844,
0.1306435764,
-0.1697725207,
-0.4417366385,
0.2912659645,
-0.1991201788,
0.4185451269,
0.1834148914,
0.053780023,
0.3612399399,
-0.775980413,
-0.1499427408,
-0.1556001157,
-0.3926814198,
-0.2767596841,
0.0126499459,
-0.3126567304,
0.166951552,
0.0116332704,
-0.1386377364,
0.2669984698,
-0.4090614617,
0.2648183107,
0.7803185582,
0.3963395357,
0.5545456409,
-0.823964417,
0.6286599636,
-0.1594944298,
-0.111011602,
-0.8611966372,
-0.3593559563,
-0.622779727,
0.0552414395,
0.3442679942,
0.6455525756,
-1.0382045507,
0.1318406761,
0.0221121516,
-0.4126238525,
-0.3932895958,
-0.0651612133,
0.4189538062,
0.4671240151,
0.2928453982,
-0.0903288499,
-0.5314187407,
-0.6209633946,
-0.615224123,
-0.4068803489,
-0.2541492581,
-0.4460629523,
0.5313237309,
0.2992779016,
0.714969337,
-0.3215383887,
0.1828369349,
-0.5196710825,
0.405444324,
0.3848906755,
0.3019011319,
0.2847977877,
-0.2961948216,
-0.5270944238,
-0.232710287,
-0.644980967,
-0.4093446136,
-0.4895289838,
0.2248240113,
0.2333314419,
0.6963525414,
-0.196572572,
0.3654623628,
0.2785354853,
-0.2047490776,
0.9432570934,
-0.3061731756,
0.5702069998,
-0.8433731794,
0.0319730416,
-0.0006679296,
-0.4149447978,
-0.9157999158,
0.2069305331,
-0.0594083667,
0.1471436024,
-0.2068371326,
0.4527624846,
-0.7601333857,
-0.0193081908,
-0.5747972727,
0.3856558204,
0.0337889828,
0.2366563976,
-0.0649937987,
1.0493892431,
0.2981107533,
-0.8825173378,
0.3937569559,
0.0674201846,
-0.319311589,
0.5543785691,
-0.9484775066,
0.0884591714,
-0.2593919337,
0.6338767409,
-1.2437025309,
-0.0479965545,
0.2221966237,
-0.2200207114,
0.0412746854,
0.2992487848,
-0.4396359026,
-0.3660275042,
-1.1381750107,
0.2993130684,
0.5712798238,
-0.5865536928,
0.480825454,
-0.2801663578,
-0.5626277328,
-0.4455185831,
-0.708824873,
0.123259753,
-0.1194110811,
-0.4149928391,
0.4230938256,
-0.234399572,
-0.5877609253,
-0.6000657082,
-0.4865123332,
0.2192512453,
-0.095775865,
0.1649703681,
0.3020119071,
0.1280831993,
-0.0431912318,
0.1066304073,
-0.2751499712,
0.1152632609,
-0.0099777142,
0.4750910103,
0.4248368144,
-0.1514410824,
-0.5282459855,
0.5228853226,
0.48866117,
-0.0305289645,
0.4282099307,
-0.0713761076,
0.0104962857,
-0.3169493675,
-0.6031845808,
-0.2429010719,
-0.4628318548,
-0.2148599178,
-0.3337854743,
-0.8203424811,
0.7824525833,
-0.2697353363,
0.4805654287,
0.3416496515,
0.4707855582,
-0.2167074531,
0.8327512741,
0.695015192,
-0.052952975,
0.5408141017,
0.0952457637,
0.0188139696,
-0.9078306556,
-0.1592806131,
-0.84462291,
-0.1889150888,
-0.4267243147,
-0.276655674,
0.3706454039,
0.2591362596,
-0.053752102,
0.1556154191,
-0.3146488965,
0.4993430376,
0.6114094853,
0.1146931797,
0.7402203679,
0.0712419674,
-0.234006688,
0.1297919899,
-0.6053219438,
-0.6464778185,
0.7557595372,
0.2632162273,
0.803986609,
-0.2241429836,
0.6459097266,
0.1382088363,
0.1670106798,
-0.8189098835,
0.7029662728,
0.2431403399,
-0.1937948912,
-0.3024981022,
-0.3011610508,
-0.8010041714,
0.3779041171,
-0.2759001851,
-0.7215254307,
0.1254409254,
0.197323367,
-0.4166407883,
0.2032537907,
-0.3940707743,
0.1101494133,
0.2615850866,
-0.242977038,
-0.1021883935,
-0.840015471,
0.3041846752,
-0.1293720901,
0.2620497346,
0.2089257687,
-0.2987897098,
0.7963075638,
-0.9736148119,
0.7204262018,
0.2457380891,
-0.5064230561,
0.417308867,
0.0719844922,
0.8030157685,
-0.1010086238,
-0.209081009,
-0.2591175139,
-0.141223982,
-0.1648900658,
-0.723356843,
0.5235352516,
-0.3296840787,
-0.6175160408,
-0.3201755285,
-0.3298513889,
-0.1057105064,
0.168176949,
0.4804165661,
0.6484324336,
-0.0709066465,
-0.4798031151,
0.588999629,
-0.1705005765,
0.9161196947,
0.296323806,
-0.5812222958,
-0.5858787298,
0.4824182689,
0.1186502054,
0.5281552076,
0.4950557649,
0.2290337831,
-0.1793400049,
-0.7222334743,
-0.1791653037,
0.483078599,
-0.9435348511,
-0.1392900944,
-0.4814314544,
-0.0670171604,
-0.3414190114,
-0.5223025084,
-0.0994814336,
-0.6338610053,
-0.0114378603,
-0.3341816664,
0.4297504723,
0.8556514382,
0.1325032264,
0.3206215501,
-0.7954770327,
0.4581166208,
0.2942143977,
0.339607656,
0.1314988583,
-0.4173586071,
0.0408147387,
-0.1623491496,
-0.0929983109,
-0.9589829445,
0.0222295187,
-0.2306860238,
0.2632173002,
0.3818295002,
0.1078400239,
0.7702916265,
-0.6386138201,
1.1654906273,
0.451415956,
-0.9001745582,
0.4987450242,
-0.4689517915,
0.7958285809,
0.9053689241,
0.5023719072,
-0.6555259824,
-0.5892384648,
-0.2819859982,
-0.9501203299,
0.4965396523,
0.1376132369,
-0.2377616167,
-0.0246060137,
0.5066265464,
0.3847460151,
0.3248504102,
-0.4750082493,
-0.4197501838,
0.2084151357,
0.1140668318,
-0.096804142,
-0.444067806,
-0.0318240337,
-0.1457977295,
0.5898891091,
-0.0156767536,
0.0353564806,
0.4222335219,
0.07900507,
-0.2076697648,
0.2764594853,
0.5933446288,
1.1124004126,
0.024295371,
0.2244497389,
0.4311712682,
-0.4357585013,
0.3020472527,
-0.3040727377,
-0.4119500816,
0.3424292803,
0.9877983332,
0.6143900752,
0.2537886202,
-0.4075027704,
0.261464268,
0.0448174328,
-0.4404342473,
0.136426121,
-0.0015867403,
-0.2226869017,
0.2457734793,
0.4717146158,
-0.0608894378,
0.3544068336,
-0.7240160704,
0.0048884382,
0.033370737,
-0.0868285224,
-0.2198002636,
0.498252362,
0.3861599863,
-0.5155892372,
0.4945311546,
0.1641897708,
-0.3270801604,
0.355445385,
0.4818334281,
1.0319023132,
-0.4293628335,
0.3735209405,
0.5361527801,
0.2055874318,
-0.4971385002,
0.385801971,
-0.2075329572,
-0.276542455,
-0.8346588016,
-0.3320640922,
-0.6045691371,
-0.3605943918,
-0.6907712817,
0.2515886128,
-0.4081847668,
-0.07003849,
-0.1937284321,
-0.1594082117,
-0.0864917412,
0.1080936193,
-0.232416451,
1.2522662878,
-0.6518677473,
0.2413837016,
0.874325633,
-0.4170938134,
-0.847450912,
0.2896153331,
0.1268010736,
-0.5630425811,
0.4153550267,
0.1012396887,
-0.3258939385,
-0.0742154047,
-0.4542576373,
-0.7175711393,
1.2500425577,
-0.2205945253,
-0.6590980291,
-0.2836897969,
-0.1751559973,
0.5139915943,
-0.1426030397,
0.4983635545,
0.6033742428,
0.4491988719,
0.5109935403,
-1.0145119429,
0.4500098228,
-0.0201580357,
0.421014756,
0.2505002618,
-0.6592133045,
0.7019327283,
-0.4786019027,
-0.5142136812,
0.3101292849,
0.6511239409,
0.4851599932,
0.3296588361,
0.521887958,
0.229877606,
0.8321934342,
-0.1035930887,
1.2387551069,
-0.1206572279,
-0.0536000915,
1.0035152435,
-0.2671898901,
0.6090459824,
0.5571225882,
-0.4332870245,
0.6603631377,
0.6318917871,
0.3542163074,
0.4692042172,
0.3459360898,
-0.207229346,
0.0481690243,
0.0148663567,
-0.265886724,
-0.2959265113,
-0.248696968,
-0.3161379993,
-0.481929183,
-0.0444464423,
0.4123674929,
0.0928854346,
-0.7153075933,
1.0445547104,
0.3738863766,
-1.205663085,
0.4444357455,
-0.0018882226,
0.5378478169,
-0.4831897318,
0.0076838764,
-0.4940720797,
-0.1620477587,
-0.3192023337,
-0.7415636778,
0.0944497362,
0.1836859882,
-0.2386342585,
-0.5478001833,
0.6232476234,
-0.2480208129,
-0.1571328789,
0.0912883729,
0.4596059024,
0.0027995743,
0.01924037,
-0.4684554935,
0.1598961651,
-0.0575118959,
-0.4247268736,
0.0804831609,
0.4240143299,
-0.2398642451,
0.897944212,
0.5316256881,
0.236272499,
-0.1955532283,
0.3653450012,
1.0449563265,
-0.8208827376,
-0.5508239269,
-1.2038983107,
0.8557505012,
-0.1694995016,
-0.2675161958,
0.9900199175,
0.3400737345,
0.519372046,
0.0408770554,
0.7773222923,
0.3509068191,
0.4299694002,
-0.7732488513,
0.0908008367,
-0.1045710668,
0.4514860511,
-0.5564526916,
-1.0362074375,
-0.3390412927,
0.3690153956,
-0.0975956693,
0.2627574503,
1.2760697603,
0.5286735296,
0.5168982148,
0.1568954736,
-0.0914390683,
0.184021011,
0.1682855636,
0.2017930299,
1.1659311056,
-0.2998148501,
0.1823096573,
-0.0825233832,
-0.3957540095,
-0.0344139449,
-1.0225914717,
-1.206736207,
-0.479424119,
-0.405017972,
-0.2731194198,
0.1750539094,
1.0862812996,
0.2694602311,
-0.5170145631,
-0.4692876637,
-0.2493100613,
0.3402049243,
-0.4718452096,
-0.1634564847,
0.035713084,
-0.4905710518,
-0.4582553208,
0.4070146978,
0.3324854672,
0.1035295427,
-0.2405182421,
0.2525346577,
0.0046031154,
0.1991653442,
0.7535825968,
0.0490301996,
-0.5715505481,
-0.0267899986,
-0.117042087,
0.0057906527,
-0.1091099754,
1.2058050632,
-0.7796509266,
0.2781023681,
0.8514300585,
0.1286641508,
0.2782584727,
0.5119180679,
0.8759054542,
-0.6663808227,
-0.1995864809,
-0.1023362726,
0.2079178244,
0.1681517214,
-0.2510666847,
0.5053007007,
-0.0458782241,
-0.6538345814,
-0.6996771693,
0.2568906546,
-0.9449506998,
-0.6019483805,
1.2277745008,
0.0629346073,
-0.113227278,
0.0477070212,
-0.5090104342,
0.1451788545,
-0.5138676167,
0.5287351608,
0.794373095,
-0.2605870664,
-0.1387542188,
-0.2803591192,
0.442075491,
0.1037504748,
-0.8263649344,
0.1689621806,
0.5954424143,
0.2037241012,
0.1145503595,
0.960936904,
0.0786260739,
0.1735560149,
-0.1990289837,
-0.2538249195,
-0.0629631132,
-0.4678722918,
-0.7987497449,
0.2766658664,
0.1243446991,
0.2283499241
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00497v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00497v1
|
Recent Advances in End-to-End Simultaneous Speech Translation
| 2024-06-01T16:56:19 | 2024-06-01T16:56:19 |
Xiaoqian Liu, Guoqiang Hu, Yangfan Du, Erfeng He, YingFeng Luo, Chen Xu, Tong Xiao, Jingbo Zhu
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Simultaneous speech translation (SimulST) is a demanding task that involves
generating translations in real-time while continuously processing speech
input. This paper offers a comprehensive overview of the recent developments in
SimulST research, focusing on four major challenges. Firstly, the complexities
associated with processing lengthy and continuous speech streams pose
significant hurdles. Secondly, satisfying real-time requirements presents
inherent difficulties due to the need for immediate translation output.
Thirdly, striking a balance between translation quality and latency constraints
remains a critical challenge. Finally, the scarcity of annotated data adds
another layer of complexity to the task. Through our exploration of these
challenges and the proposed solutions, we aim to provide valuable insights into
the current landscape of SimulST research and suggest promising directions for
future exploration.
|
[
-0.335013926,
-0.7994446158,
0.4999555647,
0.3982147574,
-0.5585730076,
0.6627521515,
-0.2630475163,
-0.7237782478,
0.075782828,
0.3330681026,
-0.7130426764,
0.1149940491,
-0.8400534987,
0.3314011395,
-0.4440212846,
0.8078057766,
-0.5569093227,
0.1874449849,
-0.1909716874,
-0.0124685243,
-0.6147463322,
-0.848688066,
-0.8115931153,
0.0342767462,
0.0110129649,
0.3611315191,
0.9058248401,
0.4352898598,
0.6844596863,
0.2166572213,
-0.0519540049,
0.184537679,
-0.3140638471,
0.8486467004,
0.135414198,
-0.1207281351,
-0.2848262489,
-0.0910749584,
0.9076300859,
0.6982558966,
-0.0413581617,
0.1883785278,
-0.1037464812,
0.2868921459,
-0.1868611127,
-0.0208064783,
-0.1658973694,
0.1425823718,
-0.7636026144,
-0.224900797,
-0.0554669611,
-0.160395965,
0.1488254666,
-0.6558305025,
0.0622938275,
0.1310912967,
0.7775019407,
0.7139471769,
-0.5063378811,
-0.4327522516,
-0.9992047548,
0.8015868664,
-0.605530262,
0.4103652537,
0.0461617596,
0.7205747366,
-0.2790085971,
-1.1433969736,
-0.2059289217,
-0.1446642727,
0.3448839784,
0.3402833641,
0.0756756887,
-0.034753263,
0.2514392436,
0.1928047091,
-0.3929681182,
-0.3010385334,
-0.3514490724,
-0.0567585863,
0.7631556988,
0.173065722,
0.5127000213,
0.0900274515,
-0.400067389,
0.1678703874,
-0.1614824384,
0.0486792959,
0.1941318661,
0.1514322162,
-0.140725404,
0.5164479613,
-0.1186721027,
0.5581706762,
-0.4291077256,
0.0633499846,
0.3106330931,
-0.5182305574,
0.183326453,
0.345040977,
0.6079714894,
-0.0041834689,
0.1703028083,
-0.0230064392,
-0.2881318629,
-0.2899340689,
0.1338365376,
-0.5190067291,
0.4048227072,
0.4989345372,
-0.0316441059,
-0.1537480056,
0.1606414318,
-0.5040208101,
0.1085928157,
-0.655657053,
0.2999880314,
-0.3287599087,
-0.3114030063,
0.1720214635,
-0.0416254587,
0.1174850017,
0.6331713796,
-0.4449900389,
0.8296215534,
0.6682590246,
1.371941328,
-0.5136768222,
-0.2388189882,
-0.6960268021,
0.2752135098,
-0.2728511691,
0.7548426986,
-0.3255506754,
-0.1566604376,
-0.3176265955,
-0.3489535153,
-0.1581545323,
-0.3292997181,
0.696236372,
0.1276208311,
-0.2029036731,
-0.591065824,
-0.4564861655,
0.0942640454,
-0.1027108133,
-0.3998160362,
1.1268596649,
-0.0729307458,
-0.7421379089,
-0.1351877749,
-0.5430312753,
-0.6073532701,
0.346796304,
-0.4496373236,
-0.2977782488,
0.3896377385,
0.0964698121,
0.322052449,
-0.7256829739,
0.5608634353,
0.2497446239,
-0.5183480978,
0.4981273711,
-0.5084770918,
0.7672354579,
0.5736948252,
-0.3695809245,
-0.0128422668,
-0.4597086608,
-0.2546620965,
0.3400417566,
0.1628730893,
0.0639929548,
0.3364954889,
0.4372160435,
0.485763371,
0.2679845691,
-0.8550915122,
0.0540013611,
0.1428843141,
0.5840072036,
0.5868688226,
0.1421665698,
-0.1229488775,
-0.3610268235,
0.6653231978,
-0.0587475784,
0.5815247297,
-0.1101848707,
-0.7711009979,
-0.4583420753,
-0.2204430103,
0.253832072,
0.7631825805,
-0.7338812351,
-0.3553335965,
-0.3047671318,
-0.3829398155,
-1.0210528374,
-0.2412976623,
0.0904470906,
-0.0196119212,
0.5804211497,
-0.2874628603,
-0.4367858171,
-0.7332279086,
-0.4259524941,
0.4274455011,
0.4136493802,
0.0550225899,
0.1741183251,
0.1232639998,
0.7381849289,
-0.3518364131,
-0.6144782305,
-0.1430728883,
0.318030417,
-0.0302439816,
0.6059598327,
0.3283082843,
-1.1468929052,
-0.7589942217,
0.411162734,
-0.8805282116,
-0.4210084081,
-0.5565775037,
0.3553873003,
-0.1873874515,
0.8883542418,
-0.5177574158,
0.3247760236,
0.5513480306,
0.364746362,
0.5313462615,
-0.088012591,
0.2852371633,
-1.0983505249,
-0.3373158872,
-0.6680613756,
-0.4503701925,
-0.9014668465,
-0.0959685296,
-0.0800988078,
-0.4139627814,
-0.6762816906,
0.1696542352,
-0.8194249868,
-0.4224631488,
0.0178459994,
0.295262903,
-0.6385241151,
0.0853607357,
-0.3268692791,
1.1372652054,
0.575682044,
-0.1520539671,
0.8168080449,
0.0630071387,
0.0239311475,
0.4213688076,
-0.565618813,
0.1336731166,
0.1124060154,
0.4346933365,
-1.1325956583,
-0.4874005616,
0.137507081,
-0.6713857055,
0.3940697014,
0.0940902084,
-0.6142479777,
-0.2668721676,
-0.1205506623,
0.7048249245,
0.6415028572,
-0.1128439382,
0.3248440921,
0.2977422178,
-0.7855344415,
-0.4804456234,
-0.6660320759,
0.4465401471,
0.2557095885,
-0.5949189067,
0.2874884605,
-0.0809093639,
-0.1588945389,
0.0672213733,
-0.3561678529,
0.1557177454,
-0.1665972918,
0.3288627863,
-0.3823623061,
0.012534692,
-0.3132191896,
0.4723317921,
-0.4229032397,
-0.1661474854,
-0.2221292853,
0.4189544916,
0.0299160779,
-0.5840963125,
-0.7576521635,
0.8556590676,
0.6800144315,
-0.2952810824,
0.3260211051,
0.7911806703,
-0.3066907823,
-0.1898727864,
-0.5624959469,
0.100053452,
-0.382729888,
0.1892482787,
-0.7147702575,
-0.8565817475,
0.4860380292,
-0.5537499785,
0.3636846244,
0.0731196851,
0.5283145905,
-0.12367066,
0.9408034086,
0.0175530519,
0.6770777702,
0.3056515753,
0.2357038409,
0.4315018654,
-0.7980885506,
-0.2820276022,
-0.3318687975,
-0.2486786097,
-0.3612104356,
-0.6729860902,
0.4138429165,
-0.035471864,
0.4200021327,
0.4263805747,
-0.4276420176,
0.2395454198,
0.3142232001,
-0.3249366879,
0.2685943842,
-0.0470313914,
-0.0875318721,
-0.368312031,
-0.4956999123,
-0.2023904324,
0.5317986012,
0.2537644207,
0.3531481326,
0.1813050061,
0.8867183924,
0.3174034953,
-0.2547825575,
-0.4882717729,
0.5359523296,
-0.3174504638,
-0.6530103683,
-0.3899067044,
-0.3673529625,
-0.6031835675,
0.5593491793,
0.0240567792,
-0.2348781079,
-0.0665751845,
0.0919706002,
-0.1404016763,
0.224525854,
-0.496227324,
0.4807506204,
-0.5181357861,
-0.5571197867,
0.2028891444,
-1.2085398436,
0.0063927239,
-0.3906856179,
0.5158135295,
-0.6161218882,
-0.2287269235,
0.6156449914,
-0.2360764444,
0.5166344047,
-0.0113122659,
0.0095336186,
0.193937093,
0.0294090975,
0.3259458244,
0.0077841389,
0.1729115695,
0.2994413078,
0.294252485,
-0.6487140656,
-0.2310281396,
0.4311537743,
-0.5731335878,
-0.376434952,
-0.9689417481,
-0.8424607515,
-0.2087984681,
0.0898403898,
0.5591784716,
0.3282942474,
-0.198864013,
-0.0929074883,
0.3898383975,
-0.0462878719,
0.3420870304,
-0.2426899821,
-0.3749657273,
-0.4792095721,
1.2797578573,
0.7736164331,
0.6946374774,
0.0521491952,
-0.1370856166,
0.0472634435,
-0.6835686564,
-0.603328824,
0.3411900103,
-0.3300283849,
-0.1519028693,
-0.6717478037,
-0.5096101761,
-0.6763496995,
-0.276796937,
-0.9367403388,
-0.7392941117,
-0.1604434848,
0.2640084624,
0.1289640963,
1.0627461672,
-0.263227433,
0.4684341848,
-0.5562421083,
0.7597889304,
0.1565869749,
0.1329973191,
-0.4816521108,
-0.4449107647,
-0.2144667059,
0.0027888413,
-0.038585864,
-0.9265120625,
0.291891247,
0.0408719294,
0.3655810952,
-0.1854127496,
0.1633769423,
0.9269787669,
-0.6146702766,
0.9734432697,
0.0955929756,
-1.0375673771,
0.348675549,
-0.1769924015,
0.2159176022,
0.3997964263,
0.3225336373,
-0.8479331732,
-0.2815318406,
-0.4163937569,
-1.1157631874,
0.8924162388,
0.8407312632,
-0.1343318522,
0.204836145,
0.2885798514,
0.2201669067,
0.2793247104,
-0.0417070501,
-0.1158775464,
-0.0565802045,
-0.0278068483,
-0.0403984748,
-0.1840643585,
0.3092133403,
-0.2993391454,
0.6920220852,
0.3196981847,
0.194232583,
0.2320153564,
-0.2229318172,
-0.3803618252,
0.3828628957,
0.8767337203,
0.2885262668,
-0.4558725655,
0.0542484187,
0.3316307664,
-0.664530158,
0.3638281822,
0.288571775,
-0.3619763255,
0.2796930373,
0.3127572238,
0.964659214,
0.5444167852,
-0.4741396904,
0.8501793742,
-0.1565392911,
-0.4103071094,
-0.6603885889,
-0.5010783672,
0.0434635095,
0.0054797977,
0.4817758203,
0.2443348616,
0.0803893134,
-0.1548775434,
0.2757697105,
0.0285715852,
-0.4424421191,
-0.3306909502,
0.8280217052,
0.1552968174,
-0.1746101677,
0.4191502631,
-0.0620087609,
-0.3652167022,
0.3556079566,
0.7780070305,
0.9618070722,
-0.8949763775,
0.0156889521,
-0.0400298238,
0.5042343736,
-0.2647100687,
0.4095187187,
-0.2181975245,
0.0768802091,
-0.554056406,
-0.6169889569,
-0.7978647351,
-0.3953034878,
-0.9053161144,
0.4259722233,
-0.1298652738,
-0.3733975887,
-0.0832053199,
-0.4394055903,
-0.1952316761,
-0.1126567945,
0.1119567603,
0.4083675444,
-0.8026869893,
0.6514338851,
0.8371183872,
-0.2723564506,
-0.2659722567,
-0.0933983326,
0.3153755367,
-0.37763381,
0.2818413079,
-0.1314065754,
-0.3760780394,
0.3316201568,
-0.5547792912,
-1.013397336,
0.9101529717,
0.6005182862,
-0.6636856794,
-0.2853316367,
0.4924465716,
0.2630518079,
-0.0848191977,
-0.2605291307,
0.608602941,
0.5089696646,
0.1508426964,
-0.990172863,
-0.1924596876,
-0.0327717811,
0.2091844082,
0.2772702873,
-0.6842987537,
1.1966432333,
-0.0195367765,
-0.4916769266,
-0.1043296009,
0.8140155077,
-0.0420796499,
0.4232541919,
0.2443088591,
0.2445490509,
0.1528267711,
-0.2869465053,
0.9432192445,
0.1341381669,
0.3381236196,
1.2552038431,
-0.495747298,
0.8247967958,
0.809659183,
-0.1858944595,
-0.4359791279,
0.5771318078,
0.254889369,
0.1564238071,
0.1853919774,
-0.4402127266,
-0.347987622,
-0.6209844947,
-0.6515796185,
0.1951339096,
0.6247549057,
0.3112806976,
-0.2164177299,
0.562197268,
0.0635887384,
-0.0474439897,
0.3728050292,
0.7407744527,
0.4590337276,
-0.461754173,
0.3560486436,
-0.332991153,
0.3374738991,
-0.8755155206,
-0.3075562418,
-0.072931394,
-0.0934453905,
-0.1811324507,
-0.6474874616,
0.2861230969,
-0.0400921628,
0.4209443927,
-0.4774469733,
0.4322198629,
-0.5509486198,
-0.1589418203,
0.5210185051,
0.6353216767,
0.5825603604,
-0.1331333965,
-0.5786357522,
0.8683981895,
0.2207109183,
-0.3887651563,
0.169441089,
0.5712884068,
-0.2628925145,
0.5325433016,
0.7000273466,
0.4086593986,
0.7705307603,
-0.0608316921,
0.561075747,
-0.5916023254,
-0.3146134913,
-0.4030940533,
0.2969958484,
-0.0326757841,
-0.2597645521,
0.5738192797,
0.5994778872,
0.6735906601,
-0.0052393898,
0.8776308298,
-0.1165226474,
0.5354673862,
-0.2578485608,
0.5091724992,
-0.5769323111,
-0.0972136408,
-0.3107673824,
-0.8798302412,
-0.4235608578,
0.3153203428,
0.183084324,
-0.2136179656,
1.0034577847,
0.1236320809,
-0.2237690091,
0.2657701969,
0.6533401608,
0.2514004409,
0.472669512,
0.3613964617,
0.8081281185,
-0.7279865146,
0.4428655803,
-0.6168935895,
-0.2536343336,
-0.2895719409,
-0.5935108066,
-0.3387347758,
-1.1153438091,
-0.3206934333,
0.1438078284,
0.4045333266,
1.177910924,
0.5439400077,
-0.7950367332,
-0.4315285683,
0.1204228401,
-0.4864859879,
-0.6797648668,
-0.0828762874,
0.2484766096,
-0.546841085,
-0.7044173479,
0.4889843762,
0.597586453,
0.4114060402,
0.2426934838,
-0.0983321741,
-0.5902107954,
0.2026063353,
0.5641120076,
0.2965335548,
-0.8946143389,
-0.0403136238,
-0.1554835886,
0.0425675735,
-0.2033676058,
1.0425775051,
-0.2527892888,
0.6643491387,
0.342593044,
1.0415256023,
0.8787629008,
0.1791840345,
0.4620418251,
-0.8831068277,
0.1918660849,
0.3828152418,
0.0762410909,
0.5239664912,
-0.1805346608,
0.6912887692,
0.4981047809,
-0.501057446,
-1.1074328423,
0.3967636526,
-1.5639059544,
-0.1333574653,
0.8163332939,
0.0691688061,
-0.0778061822,
-0.5780377984,
-0.5862053633,
0.7860932946,
-0.2696043849,
-0.0725766271,
0.8069494367,
-0.5177816153,
-0.3004205525,
-1.4160447121,
0.5266147852,
0.6612170339,
-0.8080486059,
0.3008223176,
0.2389936447,
-0.0650360957,
0.021162279,
0.744317472,
-0.3765077591,
0.3188026249,
0.2155130655,
-0.1688976884,
-0.2996159494,
-0.4914910197,
-0.1662627608,
0.1808731258,
0.0497365482,
-0.2205533832
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01633v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01633v1
|
On Overcoming Miscalibrated Conversational Priors in LLM-based Chatbots
| 2024-06-01T15:54:45 | 2024-06-01T15:54:45 |
Christine Herlihy, Jennifer Neville, Tobias Schnabel, Adith Swaminathan
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We explore the use of Large Language Model (LLM-based) chatbots to power
recommender systems. We observe that the chatbots respond poorly when they
encounter under-specified requests (e.g., they make incorrect assumptions,
hedge with a long response, or refuse to answer). We conjecture that such
miscalibrated response tendencies (i.e., conversational priors) can be
attributed to LLM fine-tuning using annotators -- single-turn annotations may
not capture multi-turn conversation utility, and the annotators' preferences
may not even be representative of users interacting with a recommender system.
We first analyze public LLM chat logs to conclude that query
under-specification is common. Next, we study synthetic recommendation problems
with configurable latent item utilities and frame them as Partially Observed
Decision Processes (PODP). We find that pre-trained LLMs can be sub-optimal for
PODPs and derive better policies that clarify under-specified queries when
appropriate. Then, we re-calibrate LLMs by prompting them with learned control
messages to approximate the improved policy. Finally, we show empirically that
our lightweight learning approach effectively uses logged conversation data to
re-calibrate the response strategies of LLM-based chatbots for recommendation
tasks.
|
[
-0.1560162902,
-0.842263639,
0.6178269982,
-0.0015269485,
-0.121863924,
0.0093963239,
-0.4825311899,
-0.2744080722,
0.1543322355,
0.8172362447,
-0.7564687133,
-0.2599534392,
-0.3687401414,
-0.1302150488,
0.1118871495,
1.1464960575,
0.2232831866,
0.0944203809,
-0.3987911046,
0.0196567066,
-0.8777267337,
-0.5697315931,
-0.6896304488,
-0.7604169846,
0.4528062642,
0.5461293459,
1.0144577026,
-0.1874998659,
0.4711454213,
0.2729946375,
-0.0503181405,
0.396327734,
-1.0091819763,
0.1439312249,
-0.0665786564,
-0.8960195184,
-0.4379820824,
-0.1611511111,
0.2123855948,
0.6920492649,
-0.2776867449,
-0.0760159492,
0.2256007791,
0.5977284908,
-0.7990776896,
0.0906650126,
-1.1468939781,
0.1522022933,
0.1724227518,
-0.4115799069,
-0.6736831069,
-0.0995395482,
0.3276467919,
-0.6838091612,
0.3045641184,
0.3303534091,
0.4097325206,
0.505425632,
-0.1184119657,
-0.271284461,
-1.0780313015,
0.9178082943,
-0.732636869,
0.3326562643,
0.9560315013,
0.5181930065,
-0.6664708853,
-0.4666746855,
-0.4820536375,
-0.4631993473,
-0.2605173886,
0.0873614699,
-0.2388673872,
0.1833440661,
0.3249124289,
0.1702976525,
-0.4269704819,
0.1780122817,
-0.2603754401,
-0.413718164,
0.4965619445,
0.2026274204,
-0.3438301682,
0.0180219449,
-0.1612347215,
0.0755398795,
-0.8685442805,
-0.1162359342,
0.3363139629,
0.4047411084,
0.0280366968,
0.616784215,
-0.2106434107,
0.4628688097,
0.4503323734,
-0.0353947729,
0.0928465277,
-0.4262996316,
-0.3724709749,
0.0692813098,
0.8034929633,
0.5813705921,
0.7054988146,
-0.1322983056,
-0.0692232549,
-0.2494144142,
0.4226048887,
-0.6269587874,
-0.4027952552,
0.0088253682,
-0.2052258104,
-0.1150427684,
-0.4541168213,
-0.2861695588,
-0.6428234577,
-0.1360027045,
0.4759145975,
-0.1671292484,
0.0623052306,
0.1948756576,
0.1169031188,
-0.0390061401,
0.4695440829,
-0.9554059505,
0.3948852122,
0.3413690627,
0.5970305204,
0.2997152805,
0.0260153338,
-0.3171418607,
0.0458742194,
-0.308611989,
0.7802201509,
-0.5399249196,
-0.7657284141,
0.0938585103,
0.0784507021,
-0.0191197135,
-0.5964701176,
0.4446824789,
-0.4873473346,
0.2632978261,
-0.003527734,
-0.4726411104,
-0.1774422377,
0.4217424393,
-0.1702137291,
0.7527332902,
-0.1772380322,
-0.56290555,
0.3245627582,
-0.2821181118,
-0.2120752633,
-0.1433806419,
0.0325802639,
-0.1322001815,
0.0518176407,
0.3168680072,
0.7212386727,
-0.3386253715,
0.2702664435,
-0.4770905077,
-0.4466251731,
0.0898189917,
-0.6579403281,
0.0723766163,
0.1319280267,
0.0815199539,
0.403804034,
-0.5539667606,
-0.0167694855,
0.0740374476,
-0.0319468379,
-0.2659610212,
0.3023789823,
-0.0440735146,
-0.1233426481,
0.4767545462,
-0.2535990477,
0.1648190618,
-0.6578570008,
0.5013808012,
0.7444727421,
0.0872054994,
0.5808087587,
-0.5350661874,
0.1573997289,
-0.1418521106,
0.1540020555,
-0.2909276187,
-0.2438815981,
-0.8985837102,
0.3223786354,
-0.0120391473,
0.6396964192,
-0.6728274822,
0.5851243734,
-0.0705994293,
-0.6758230329,
-0.3184705973,
0.2774119973,
0.3025527,
0.453468442,
0.4343171716,
-0.2074603438,
-0.5249741673,
-0.9358542562,
-0.0518546887,
-0.4786479175,
-0.1689590067,
0.7252219319,
0.097692132,
-0.3941231966,
0.8603726029,
-0.6006741524,
-0.4128261805,
-0.0951677188,
-0.1948881745,
0.271950841,
0.3993197978,
0.1183116436,
-0.6191787124,
-0.1982370019,
-0.1949447989,
-0.3433937132,
-0.0537629649,
-0.3024953604,
0.1543651372,
0.0658727586,
0.6329943538,
-0.4800519347,
0.2081781179,
0.3207438886,
0.1393570453,
0.4605981112,
-0.5740999579,
-0.0900677294,
-0.9947980046,
-0.301964879,
0.2468603998,
-0.5074757338,
-0.2549727857,
-0.4066133797,
-0.1652877778,
0.0695549846,
-0.3575189114,
0.3908926547,
-0.1227263585,
0.1433382034,
-0.4917986095,
0.141409263,
-0.3031165898,
0.7366870642,
-0.0200060979,
0.6714836955,
0.3214403391,
-0.6799397469,
0.3170002699,
0.1745078415,
0.0436202884,
0.7006781697,
-0.9238169789,
0.3802053034,
-0.0381411575,
0.7641429305,
-1.1830134392,
0.0409037955,
0.3473149836,
-0.0854357779,
0.0288031064,
-0.5352516174,
-0.4422328472,
-0.2540408373,
-0.2008724511,
0.2102256566,
0.4325306118,
-0.1965777278,
0.5323240757,
0.3013494313,
0.0117895715,
-0.4861723483,
-0.3665967584,
-0.0742666423,
-0.0878566504,
-0.3954117596,
0.3769947886,
-0.5312175751,
-0.1349039823,
-0.4229201674,
-0.1163508371,
0.118460618,
0.0735964105,
0.6112139821,
0.2068634629,
-0.1092606112,
0.2167197168,
-0.2149248421,
-0.1229205281,
-0.15960823,
-0.248028174,
0.7768191099,
-0.0938343331,
-0.4400438368,
-0.5022978783,
-0.2044680268,
0.4545581639,
0.2919739485,
0.3984355927,
0.565251112,
-0.2291620821,
0.0659400076,
-0.7878644466,
-0.6370327473,
-0.5036210418,
0.2741010487,
-0.283010155,
-0.9091686606,
0.3889043927,
-0.1430769712,
0.2210871279,
0.2796905041,
0.6824119687,
-0.1717201322,
0.9290587306,
0.7491352558,
-0.2411701083,
0.6271541715,
-0.052574046,
0.0877732337,
-0.6725696325,
0.0223129541,
-0.4474297762,
-0.2965919077,
-0.6732271314,
-0.3020546734,
0.3018938601,
0.1309586167,
-0.1645440161,
0.4141849279,
-0.2577944994,
0.5347725153,
0.5652749538,
0.2815861702,
0.1538925767,
-0.2946344912,
-0.1316283792,
-0.0408502072,
-0.7386745811,
-0.5679261684,
1.2867486477,
0.326854229,
1.1193543673,
-0.2582334876,
0.3235337138,
0.3881784678,
0.0926978812,
-1.0010685921,
0.4799957275,
0.0886605978,
-0.4170736372,
-0.1419355869,
-0.2515842617,
-0.8952083588,
0.2295926362,
-0.5832197666,
-0.8628905416,
-0.1634226441,
0.276568681,
-0.3783881366,
-0.0307422914,
-0.9132130742,
0.6860715151,
-0.0823299363,
-0.225292623,
-0.4952814281,
-0.7028898001,
0.0466120914,
-0.0741972029,
0.1824788749,
-0.281468451,
0.3408690691,
0.5448966026,
-0.3527246118,
1.2357029915,
-0.1408410966,
-0.013495096,
0.0999983326,
0.2041094303,
0.7377517223,
0.1699271947,
0.083649978,
0.0626232103,
0.1598581225,
-0.1889339089,
-0.7359352112,
0.7646487951,
-0.7906486988,
-0.9633852839,
0.066957958,
-0.4472001493,
-0.5220857263,
0.0671605989,
0.0764745548,
0.190693602,
-0.35826841,
0.3146439195,
0.4069409668,
0.0162365288,
0.2028208524,
0.6869475245,
-0.1084067747,
-0.3009029329,
0.6137238145,
-0.044286821,
0.2061435133,
0.4321294129,
0.4035043716,
-0.3429259062,
-0.6577628255,
-0.296212405,
0.0305446349,
-0.5917852521,
-0.1414687335,
-0.5331529379,
-0.0220037922,
-0.3632165492,
-0.0763280988,
-0.2399409413,
-0.2094565779,
-0.5167186856,
-0.0304842796,
0.4136311412,
0.566603303,
0.2243837714,
0.7768495083,
-0.6472169161,
0.1234674975,
0.1203460991,
0.0843722299,
-0.1684807837,
-0.6657149792,
-0.1494499892,
0.3151532412,
-0.5231430531,
-0.4359964728,
0.2156069875,
0.1210814044,
0.6069160104,
0.3911966085,
0.2337069213,
0.7487873435,
-0.6944067478,
0.8047803044,
0.0984155014,
-0.4528476,
0.6240260005,
-0.2215165645,
0.2843947411,
0.634888947,
0.3972016871,
-0.5217501521,
-0.372164309,
-0.6977411509,
-0.777593255,
0.5103057623,
0.0680656955,
0.6438499093,
0.2123528421,
0.3398765326,
0.1398956031,
0.2629887164,
-0.4700179696,
-0.4538322985,
0.0030375074,
-0.0544247031,
-0.629175663,
-0.3908295333,
-0.1486651152,
0.1363735795,
0.6776551604,
-0.31552279,
-0.1906300485,
0.1527507454,
-0.1854807585,
-0.2443985194,
0.1900809109,
0.6184399128,
0.5289475322,
-0.3731241822,
-0.0731943175,
0.3557397127,
-0.2119343281,
-0.1463386416,
0.1470499635,
0.0856603011,
-0.2740700543,
0.0769394338,
0.7185396552,
0.553859055,
-0.553958118,
0.2647750676,
-0.1887043864,
0.1095644757,
-0.3654205799,
0.3071152866,
-0.0858980492,
0.2230750471,
0.4291124046,
0.4506852925,
-0.0738237798,
-0.4378476441,
0.0681453869,
0.709728539,
-0.7985245585,
-0.2031918168,
0.3058077991,
0.4129641354,
-0.5771267414,
0.2028115988,
0.3401935995,
-0.3049747646,
0.204066366,
0.5216143727,
0.6442296505,
0.2655155063,
-0.0241461918,
0.034896031,
0.2391772866,
-0.1236380488,
-0.2719103098,
-0.4527072906,
-1.1522116661,
-0.1915214658,
-0.3954585195,
-0.7055045962,
0.1374758333,
-0.1942064464,
0.2722941041,
-0.7671829462,
-0.4005050659,
0.1264127046,
0.1331745237,
-0.7590201497,
-0.0196063891,
-0.047403153,
0.4879635572,
-0.5822266936,
0.5772771835,
0.4662050009,
-0.3012686372,
-0.5669282675,
0.0183504093,
0.0130605651,
-0.9851008654,
0.3378904164,
-0.0665503591,
-0.3081721067,
-0.0218100064,
-0.6910322905,
-0.5255651474,
0.8030079007,
0.3636212349,
-0.7537113428,
0.0553632937,
-0.2012068778,
0.650238812,
-0.1656945795,
0.7501021624,
0.2394158542,
0.203251496,
0.3345102966,
-1.3934788704,
-0.1073502302,
0.1291741729,
-0.2073439956,
0.1117574647,
-0.6358454823,
0.265745461,
-0.3501388133,
0.0419967026,
0.1548794657,
0.4818265736,
0.2909029722,
0.386435926,
0.5224861503,
0.2854405046,
0.7378323674,
0.158957541,
0.9551546574,
-0.0534768254,
0.1632174104,
1.2989444733,
-0.4864742458,
0.9275448918,
0.5754303336,
-0.2916785777,
0.3891810775,
0.8071652055,
0.1098667234,
0.4148857892,
0.3079012036,
-0.0057030795,
-0.4802310169,
-0.2192477286,
-0.2854976952,
0.3617633283,
0.4958851039,
-0.2480558306,
-0.2534296811,
-0.0827153549,
-0.1773706973,
0.1796260327,
-0.29437235,
1.0992215872,
0.1957910955,
-0.492625773,
0.7242559195,
-0.1190844402,
1.0809106827,
-0.6378597021,
0.002971838,
-0.0641899705,
0.1609007865,
-0.1591048241,
-0.5550367832,
-0.0339860544,
-0.271627754,
-0.4194847643,
-0.2092493176,
0.9571456909,
-0.2550392151,
-0.4629183412,
-0.0014087806,
0.644811213,
0.269661665,
-0.14531596,
-0.7485708594,
-0.4627118707,
-0.0702638328,
-0.011982318,
0.2088724971,
0.3208232522,
-0.139809832,
0.984233439,
0.880669713,
0.0535764471,
-0.4769655764,
0.2073769569,
0.5978748798,
-0.4800826609,
-0.3634945154,
-0.7975241542,
0.0590476468,
0.2459227741,
-0.2069018483,
0.5876933336,
0.226369679,
0.9949049354,
0.0762644187,
0.5273239613,
0.4655376077,
0.2623743117,
-0.7108153701,
0.5744512081,
-0.3550111651,
0.5805547237,
-0.067349717,
-0.9476138353,
-0.2435389906,
0.4412381351,
-0.6627724171,
0.2903836071,
0.3149974346,
1.052187562,
0.0980032757,
0.0404548682,
0.6290317178,
0.1016047299,
0.3133540452,
0.5401126146,
0.9454364777,
-0.2988486588,
0.6587173343,
-0.0623735115,
0.1721554548,
-0.4980497956,
-0.6958456039,
-0.9678758979,
-0.3828747571,
-0.0564007014,
-0.2716621161,
0.2128343284,
1.2632360458,
0.9872700572,
-0.7627440691,
-0.1154155731,
-0.0699725151,
0.4070730209,
0.1266332716,
-0.2202256322,
-0.0717207938,
-0.381552279,
-0.6543108821,
0.5438344479,
0.0680216849,
0.3223058283,
-0.3646714091,
-0.0226879995,
0.098538667,
-0.0235071406,
0.4469968379,
0.0824673027,
-0.8458140492,
-0.3677622676,
-0.3107710481,
-0.1829551905,
0.1828524321,
0.9778473377,
-1.0960922241,
0.3883986771,
0.1747116148,
0.3553921282,
0.6217275262,
-0.1509687901,
0.8592160344,
-0.810587883,
0.3121174276,
0.3884218633,
0.4268370271,
0.3976656795,
-0.4148512781,
0.2447062582,
0.1257715821,
-0.6580373645,
-0.5809031129,
0.245232746,
-0.9282357693,
-0.2014434338,
1.0939122438,
0.0597614124,
0.035153944,
-0.1770765483,
-0.6710541248,
-0.0959160551,
-0.7419636846,
0.6170422435,
0.664016068,
-0.0428752527,
-0.0782689229,
-0.395896554,
0.4824519753,
0.5296329856,
-0.2459324449,
0.2625500858,
0.7511461973,
0.1915839463,
0.2403903306,
0.8050170541,
0.3085515201,
-0.0237931088,
-0.246030435,
-0.3270009458,
0.0710595548,
-0.3077840209,
-0.1376250833,
0.0171604417,
0.3252108395,
-0.052096311
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00456v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00456v1
|
Mix-of-Granularity: Optimize the Chunking Granularity for Retrieval-Augmented Generation
| 2024-06-01T14:45:03 | 2024-06-01T14:45:03 |
Zijie Zhong, Hanwen Liu, Xiaoya Cui, Xiaofan Zhang, Zengchang Qin
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Integrating information from different reference data sources is a major
challenge for Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) systems because each
knowledge source adopts a unique data structure and follows different
conventions. Retrieving from multiple knowledge sources with one fixed strategy
usually leads to under-exploitation of information. To mitigate this drawback,
inspired by Mix-of-Expert, we introduce Mix-of-Granularity (MoG), a method that
dynamically determines the optimal granularity of a knowledge database based on
input queries using a router. The router is efficiently trained with a newly
proposed loss function employing soft labels. We further extend MoG to
Mix-of-Granularity-Graph (MoGG), where reference documents are pre-processed
into graphs, enabling the retrieval of relevant information from distantly
situated chunks. Extensive experiments demonstrate that both MoG and MoGG
effectively predict optimal granularity levels, significantly enhancing the
performance of the RAG system in downstream tasks. The code of both MoG and
MoGG will be made public.
|
[
-0.6459575295,
-0.9115644693,
0.3851553202,
-0.1519658566,
-0.2823242247,
0.2331431508,
0.2601857185,
-0.3498373628,
0.4915554225,
0.3596103489,
-0.3093198538,
-0.0732811242,
-0.5335932374,
-0.3340583742,
-0.30005005,
0.9115517735,
0.1078427508,
-0.1204581633,
-0.5081807971,
-0.2181063294,
-0.34889552,
-0.4239856005,
-0.3176830709,
-0.7335953116,
0.5698040724,
0.2609395087,
0.8526548147,
0.6929782033,
0.5107061267,
0.2526692748,
-0.3622366488,
0.8795249462,
-0.6422472,
0.2052327245,
-0.4463971257,
-0.0392146707,
-0.7310959697,
-0.2009794861,
0.447145015,
0.7976399064,
-0.3596169055,
0.0577993393,
-0.0655406192,
0.7104504108,
-0.9628654122,
0.003216302,
-0.688626647,
0.16545026,
-0.2456544489,
-0.4569146931,
-0.063023679,
-0.1943684965,
-0.033276353,
-0.5750170946,
0.0492432937,
0.1504080147,
0.757443428,
0.3117797077,
-0.5613934994,
-0.5341616869,
-0.6195437908,
0.5935325027,
-0.4045316875,
0.2986267209,
0.4064711928,
0.2720905542,
-0.2787979245,
-0.6659309268,
-0.4818812907,
0.0434089936,
-0.2724257112,
0.054850053,
0.2250864059,
-0.0583226085,
-0.0159022957,
0.6787861586,
-0.2626111507,
-0.5635724068,
-0.1935546547,
-0.1350801885,
0.5085278749,
-0.0048607718,
0.0688591972,
-0.3403277695,
-0.4094897807,
-0.000919827,
-0.3701756001,
-0.4801672995,
0.4592627287,
0.262927711,
0.3856831789,
0.4356134236,
-0.4626988471,
1.0496450663,
0.6092498899,
-0.5524314046,
0.4469721615,
-0.6444602609,
0.0464297943,
-0.170748651,
0.639465332,
0.0301339757,
-0.2989295721,
-0.4248465896,
-0.4835752845,
-0.5983943343,
0.4414450526,
-0.4803934395,
-0.112514019,
0.0001272196,
-0.3384765089,
-0.5529152751,
0.0889586657,
-0.6621856689,
-0.5709119439,
-0.2675310075,
0.6456171274,
-0.7011967301,
-0.2387716919,
-0.0986867175,
-0.330376178,
-0.2313461006,
0.1819010526,
-0.7191411853,
0.4153262079,
0.5535980463,
0.7344378829,
-0.0527293272,
-0.0855516642,
-0.75089252,
0.5638871789,
-0.0378657691,
0.8236863613,
-0.5399609804,
-0.7697718143,
-0.1630658358,
-0.6176819801,
-0.1467651278,
-0.7953509092,
0.4068172276,
-0.7759901285,
0.1254523695,
-0.1186399758,
-0.4823544323,
-0.1979843676,
0.4839461446,
-0.6083651781,
1.2401738167,
0.5341011286,
-0.7760728598,
0.5356154442,
-0.480320245,
-0.5575615764,
0.2372873276,
-0.2667476535,
-0.0976859406,
0.191956833,
0.0677957609,
0.1044730023,
-0.0620728657,
0.1779350787,
-0.163562879,
-0.1253171265,
-0.1608115286,
0.1076612994,
0.3214659095,
0.4352260232,
0.106355615,
-0.2753629386,
-0.7882758975,
0.3212278187,
-0.0843169838,
-0.8264352679,
-0.6450849175,
0.3497172296,
-0.1801230162,
0.1794757694,
0.4216880798,
-0.002219527,
0.2078063786,
0.2544153035,
-0.0031073072,
0.3882260025,
0.1387686878,
0.684122026,
-0.6017439365,
0.4489507079,
0.1703617871,
0.0042603975,
-0.1077996567,
-0.0880310088,
-0.5708662271,
-0.0421077572,
0.6147866845,
0.4736307859,
-1.1017922163,
0.5450391769,
-0.3502911925,
-0.430183202,
-0.0638348162,
0.2252679765,
0.3556029499,
0.7086238265,
0.3697466254,
-0.4270576239,
-0.3223151565,
-0.6000561118,
-0.2369263321,
-0.1162268743,
0.0204255115,
0.8324495554,
0.2046643943,
-0.4539108574,
0.9968366623,
-0.5786653757,
-0.2262402177,
-0.0890123248,
0.2733147442,
0.1179071218,
0.4728953242,
0.386607796,
-1.2041881084,
-0.3548373282,
0.5030950904,
-0.5698999763,
-0.2316220105,
0.087024495,
-0.3197329044,
-0.3556557298,
0.3814361989,
-0.2291035354,
0.0624163225,
0.5706315041,
-0.2181453854,
0.6277182102,
-0.2682347894,
0.3463090062,
-0.9485481977,
0.0194513351,
-0.2787903547,
-0.4456866086,
-0.5167931914,
0.3042972982,
0.0731332451,
0.016039785,
-0.2239646167,
0.5340394378,
-0.4806238711,
-0.048055917,
-0.2359980494,
0.2262145132,
0.1733483821,
0.2318725288,
-0.3910808265,
0.9576190114,
0.264839232,
-0.8806955218,
0.2177114785,
0.1315440983,
0.0014551146,
0.7181214094,
-0.4120854139,
0.2564903498,
-0.1887552589,
0.1531532556,
-0.3351968527,
-0.5757390261,
0.0823392272,
-0.3418496251,
0.5379337668,
-0.5190038085,
-0.4339917302,
-0.0538049378,
-0.0725672841,
0.4887675345,
0.6532821655,
-0.3367370367,
1.1863219738,
0.6761775017,
0.0849215388,
-0.4978100359,
-0.468503803,
-0.2320812643,
-0.0332467258,
-0.996321857,
0.6365423799,
0.0015833873,
-0.2756240368,
0.119155772,
-0.3760352731,
-0.3074474037,
-0.3931051493,
-0.0189425778,
-0.0632325038,
0.1074803397,
0.0955686718,
0.1268678457,
0.0663855001,
-0.310550034,
-0.600713253,
0.7427351475,
0.0573478192,
-0.4454989135,
0.4478592873,
0.2871715128,
0.3059503734,
-0.0853596404,
0.575904727,
0.6124429107,
-0.02364791,
-0.2587859929,
-0.6436142921,
0.243355602,
-0.5364865661,
0.2440109849,
-0.5117574334,
-0.3739752173,
0.6213914752,
-0.4676398933,
-0.200514555,
0.3634244502,
0.3068948388,
-0.1086574793,
0.5467583537,
0.4321002066,
0.1333798468,
0.7695786357,
-0.3711561561,
0.0600051545,
-0.9032399058,
-0.4885999262,
-0.2581490874,
-0.4426582158,
-0.2501195371,
-0.9235169888,
0.581607163,
0.4220202863,
0.1253831089,
0.010709431,
-0.4018649757,
0.6989282966,
0.5462924242,
0.4120165408,
0.3633128703,
0.2274259478,
-0.2922081351,
0.5231123567,
-0.9871593118,
-0.2083203942,
0.8210040331,
-0.1502601653,
0.9151334763,
-0.0512788892,
0.9961617589,
0.4435717165,
-0.2390184999,
-0.8429632187,
0.6487418413,
-0.3248938322,
-0.6216020584,
-0.0633327216,
-0.9641103148,
-0.8411654234,
0.4518286586,
-0.1199050844,
-0.3550711274,
0.3302520812,
0.3776102364,
0.0279123019,
0.3979433477,
-0.6583098173,
0.1948103756,
0.0055356314,
-0.2675925493,
-0.0601658411,
-0.383718431,
0.2786453366,
-0.2280929089,
0.569149971,
0.196228236,
-0.139596805,
0.6574348807,
-0.6938374639,
0.1771736145,
-0.0900584757,
0.2119624466,
0.6175405383,
0.2341997623,
0.6327586174,
-0.070482105,
-0.1778303683,
0.028648898,
-0.2695083916,
-0.6053160429,
-0.5480546355,
0.6878224015,
-0.6856992841,
-0.3994983435,
-0.2698033452,
-0.8732015491,
-0.3305676877,
0.409479171,
0.2876338959,
0.6377760172,
0.1253546327,
0.2005835325,
0.9894459844,
0.2365953922,
0.1669038683,
0.1677990258,
-0.1853149533,
-0.5941285491,
1.119507432,
0.3416102231,
0.5094738603,
0.304720968,
0.3658453524,
0.0974116325,
-0.65297997,
-0.3835926354,
0.2364242673,
-0.7068997622,
-0.2299760282,
-0.5960822105,
-0.2680278718,
-0.1708309352,
-0.188776195,
-0.1883526891,
-0.3994181156,
-0.2448105216,
0.2821392119,
0.1038567498,
0.7688221335,
-0.1505884379,
0.3821021914,
-1.0830397606,
0.2457472235,
0.4116650522,
0.4246875048,
-0.153390944,
-0.4181307852,
-0.4035544395,
0.0379241481,
-0.4059891105,
-0.7870308757,
0.0052955868,
0.2242386043,
0.7027002573,
0.2429110706,
-0.2575832009,
0.8866758347,
-0.5581892729,
0.54814744,
0.2792629302,
-0.7597837448,
0.4203305542,
-0.8341343999,
0.2633313537,
0.7224469185,
0.1976798773,
-0.341424495,
0.0865403861,
-0.7920344472,
-1.1724253893,
0.6842832565,
0.1665217578,
-0.0394224599,
0.0301287547,
0.3183016479,
0.2499988377,
0.4036042094,
-0.3143247962,
-0.2362055629,
0.1043948382,
-0.0768130347,
0.5691646934,
-0.249982208,
-0.479085803,
0.0463834926,
0.6573426723,
-0.1537656039,
0.1368525326,
0.0675585344,
-0.0546903051,
-0.1808008105,
-0.0874346197,
0.0142991301,
0.9939311147,
-0.2083448023,
0.1373216659,
0.1633600444,
-0.8449113965,
0.0235396959,
-0.0598763451,
-0.6013636589,
0.2307394892,
0.2675949931,
0.5832969546,
0.0259072147,
-0.4609462321,
0.1401291192,
0.3742863536,
-0.2793174982,
0.1127711385,
0.5420039892,
-0.1375104636,
0.1716755331,
0.7092265487,
0.2817673087,
0.3554457724,
-0.5496264696,
0.2468313128,
0.3763122559,
-0.0404824801,
0.0256318152,
0.356182605,
0.2180489153,
-0.4389826357,
0.1809111685,
-0.5508892536,
-0.3025523424,
0.4383024573,
0.2420125902,
0.5821705461,
0.0362628773,
0.1586313099,
-0.0310059823,
-0.1688890457,
-0.0952226967,
0.3018394411,
-0.097272709,
-0.5410262346,
-0.2820265293,
-0.7204515934,
-0.4655085504,
-0.2492430508,
-0.6244764328,
0.1694993526,
-0.1671336591,
-0.3347961903,
-0.2355806679,
0.0023657447,
-0.6078330874,
0.3334067464,
-0.0581873767,
0.8334566355,
-0.4471427798,
0.5252205133,
0.9461817145,
-0.3186593652,
-0.7486584187,
0.1510213763,
-0.1913264692,
-0.7269129157,
0.5329565406,
-0.540130794,
-0.1677809209,
-0.1478381753,
-0.2475663722,
-1.0644176006,
1.2853181362,
-0.0726776794,
-0.1569435298,
-0.2111415416,
-0.1517024338,
0.101508677,
-0.3267179132,
0.2344341278,
0.4495405555,
0.4569834769,
0.7637142539,
-0.7959788442,
-0.2965448201,
-0.1250852793,
-0.0135947308,
0.6292275786,
-0.7065833211,
0.9671490192,
0.1122779846,
0.0533182174,
-0.6115553975,
0.5833156109,
0.3739109933,
0.500702858,
0.6736191511,
0.5695384145,
0.9602867961,
-0.0707956925,
1.2219539881,
-0.2968019247,
0.3849743903,
1.022364974,
0.1724699885,
0.4748939872,
0.5452247858,
-0.413639456,
0.5204627514,
0.3527350426,
0.4440710247,
0.7672324181,
-0.0972717926,
-0.4215193987,
0.0761375278,
-0.1570536196,
-0.4270867109,
0.0062159975,
0.2989021838,
-0.2507350743,
-0.374478817,
-0.3600997627,
0.0071821827,
-0.1939196885,
-0.4723865688,
0.8166806698,
-0.3183141351,
-0.4410144985,
0.56579566,
-0.2064846456,
0.5553213954,
-0.8546322584,
0.1576133966,
-0.4054043591,
0.0183339603,
-0.4772301316,
-0.5331682563,
0.2523032129,
-0.4182575345,
-0.5018972158,
-0.0496341772,
1.0260415077,
-0.5278276801,
-0.5022133589,
0.0645845234,
0.6702669263,
0.0392656773,
0.031011194,
-0.4835338295,
0.0143308481,
0.0095132608,
-0.3608562648,
0.6987511516,
0.8875812888,
0.1622074246,
0.5136899352,
0.5619364977,
0.3259287179,
0.3552173078,
-0.1738374084,
1.2843853235,
-0.3594433069,
-0.5013433695,
-0.4082324803,
0.5084887147,
-0.3780911863,
-0.0238712374,
0.5512756109,
0.4299869239,
0.72888273,
0.0712382197,
0.8632876277,
-0.6098096967,
0.2399303466,
-0.4117550552,
0.4494093955,
-0.7689688802,
0.1094662622,
-0.1168004349,
-0.9699215889,
0.1682063192,
0.3286106884,
-0.1863077581,
0.5308522582,
0.7103645205,
0.5712422729,
-0.4138858616,
-0.3503725231,
0.2905437052,
-0.2611171007,
0.2664214075,
0.0468786433,
0.374530077,
-0.3428665996,
0.7065503001,
-0.3218391538,
-0.3875980079,
-0.4919142723,
-0.8693165183,
-0.575066328,
-0.330419749,
-0.2113083005,
-0.3913486302,
0.0664129108,
0.514936626,
0.9179229736,
-0.3746046424,
-0.0065731518,
-0.0417595692,
0.1866339445,
-0.0832139552,
-0.2162947953,
0.1312915981,
-0.6154183745,
-0.6107978225,
0.4009400308,
0.2590275705,
0.0179931056,
-0.0840654522,
-0.1115447879,
-0.3614726961,
0.4003361762,
0.5099849105,
-0.0387177058,
-0.2761628032,
0.0033006354,
-0.1275419891,
-0.0768656656,
-0.0198476482,
0.9291900396,
-0.9137486219,
0.619145453,
0.8124098778,
0.5807039738,
0.6153817177,
0.656062007,
0.290329963,
-1.0218732357,
0.1855801046,
0.4020316899,
0.3126903772,
0.1161326393,
-0.5327318907,
0.8433244228,
0.2505502701,
-0.7283232808,
-0.5296951532,
0.2822354436,
-0.9695597291,
-0.3252804875,
1.2358263731,
0.1111382544,
-0.213472262,
0.0192826726,
-0.2377393544,
0.0044310889,
-0.4612771571,
0.6875569224,
0.7547129989,
-0.3167138696,
0.2195938826,
-0.3662821352,
0.2729374468,
0.1573857516,
-0.7747568488,
-0.351167351,
0.66634655,
0.0923560932,
0.5218766928,
0.6198661923,
-0.0389028005,
0.0030233215,
0.4714386761,
-0.1772269458,
-0.5406104326,
-0.1850799024,
0.2541331053,
0.4197715819,
-0.2078024,
-0.1255584955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00393v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00393v1
|
Gender Bias Detection in Court Decisions: A Brazilian Case Study
| 2024-06-01T10:34:15 | 2024-06-01T10:34:15 |
Raysa Benatti, Fabiana Severi, Sandra Avila, Esther Luna Colombini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Data derived from the realm of the social sciences is often produced in
digital text form, which motivates its use as a source for natural language
processing methods. Researchers and practitioners have developed and relied on
artificial intelligence techniques to collect, process, and analyze documents
in the legal field, especially for tasks such as text summarization and
classification. While increasing procedural efficiency is often the primary
motivation behind natural language processing in the field, several works have
proposed solutions for human rights-related issues, such as assessment of
public policy and institutional social settings. One such issue is the presence
of gender biases in court decisions, which has been largely studied in social
sciences fields; biased institutional responses to gender-based violence are a
violation of international human rights dispositions since they prevent gender
minorities from accessing rights and hamper their dignity. Natural language
processing-based approaches can help detect these biases on a larger scale.
Still, the development and use of such tools require researchers and
practitioners to be mindful of legal and ethical aspects concerning data
sharing and use, reproducibility, domain expertise, and value-charged choices.
In this work, we (a) present an experimental framework developed to
automatically detect gender biases in court decisions issued in Brazilian
Portuguese and (b) describe and elaborate on features we identify to be
critical in such a technology, given its proposed use as a support tool for
research and assessment of court~activity.
|
[
-0.4320502281,
-0.8198614717,
0.4501424432,
0.3023530841,
-0.0344676562,
0.0910432711,
-0.0228792243,
-0.4838389158,
-0.1428800821,
0.4747063518,
-0.3481147289,
-0.2416856885,
-0.6475576758,
0.2416766137,
-0.7513507605,
1.0326738358,
-0.107056886,
0.6645559669,
-0.1864256412,
-0.3822425008,
-0.5922523141,
-0.4498437941,
-0.5311114788,
-0.2315459549,
0.0798360482,
0.0600699112,
0.5111652613,
0.4478044212,
0.2594163716,
0.3289027214,
-0.4483534992,
-0.0249684192,
-0.2167357057,
0.0914777443,
-0.2239544392,
-0.4807830155,
-0.3912106752,
0.2287692279,
0.6150783896,
0.4687284529,
-0.0932890028,
0.3485885859,
-0.0881680325,
0.8607899547,
-0.5668871403,
0.2763572335,
-0.3700873852,
0.485355705,
-0.1681020409,
-0.0868026316,
-0.1410564333,
-0.6583417654,
0.3754328489,
-0.3992421031,
0.6934677958,
0.1274784803,
0.7459841371,
0.2627089322,
-0.4258944392,
-0.2702439725,
-0.6958851814,
0.7217439413,
-0.4521287978,
0.3708796799,
0.4924796224,
0.4594758749,
-0.2093474269,
-0.1020521596,
-0.5343514681,
-0.3321964741,
-0.2299309224,
-0.2072736174,
-0.4081687927,
-0.0837378874,
0.6263768673,
-0.1357195079,
-0.397941649,
-0.0512043945,
-0.378282845,
-0.2914050519,
0.7313491106,
-0.2623108923,
0.3746036291,
-0.1555698216,
0.2312083393,
0.0945442393,
-0.4915401638,
0.0815012604,
0.9557892084,
0.3828101456,
0.0003471063,
0.3478735089,
-0.2084928602,
0.517878592,
0.156194061,
0.0758953467,
0.2250238955,
-0.1907578856,
-0.0311555285,
0.3803009093,
0.8665000796,
0.1188651249,
0.4949235618,
0.0669045001,
-0.2082412392,
-0.0087629007,
0.4088753164,
-0.5824449062,
0.3762370348,
0.2077851593,
-0.6401820779,
-0.4935458302,
-0.066511184,
-0.9296601415,
-0.6680679321,
-0.5146905184,
-0.0215305705,
-0.262195915,
-0.1579310149,
-0.173825413,
-0.5153790116,
0.2469652891,
0.4124312997,
-0.7704774141,
0.3866546154,
0.574952364,
0.6196323037,
0.1323250085,
0.1566951573,
-0.4843176305,
-0.1467284858,
-0.1563083529,
0.6144957542,
-0.4941453338,
-0.5269431472,
0.2347379178,
0.0003579891,
0.2238135189,
-0.5644651651,
0.9506858587,
-0.2050367147,
0.3449883163,
-0.4736019969,
-0.2513316572,
-0.0562994629,
0.093279019,
-0.5737335682,
0.9109666348,
0.0123269372,
-0.8948142529,
1.0329983234,
-0.8606728911,
-0.6252977848,
0.0993732437,
-0.6858519912,
-0.8319194913,
-0.1849572212,
0.1071520373,
0.0638188571,
-0.3130965531,
0.6380882859,
-0.4541790783,
-0.3947950304,
0.2557475567,
-0.3274522722,
0.8759998083,
0.0380521044,
-0.6406269073,
0.1898464411,
-0.5767778158,
-0.5100470781,
0.2178315073,
-0.164242655,
-0.2996095717,
0.2251808643,
0.0435976274,
0.137310639,
-0.2094510943,
-0.5976265073,
-0.0864083245,
0.0722757578,
0.3929623365,
0.623064816,
-0.4019479454,
0.6547539234,
-0.3004917502,
0.4617577493,
-0.1759498566,
0.3150359392,
0.2936140597,
-0.5064901114,
-0.4273879528,
-0.1552184969,
0.5877798796,
0.5696626902,
-0.4279772639,
0.3297858834,
-0.0951437801,
-0.0211014189,
-0.8573410511,
-0.0679764673,
0.2697204649,
0.6374222636,
0.1803459525,
-0.1046704426,
-0.7964880466,
-1.2365112305,
-0.5601357222,
-0.1280088723,
0.0338232368,
0.3387464583,
0.9394176006,
-0.1297243387,
1.3585107327,
-0.0207005925,
-0.3652176559,
0.0663174093,
0.5159397721,
0.0897628739,
0.4229960144,
0.828415513,
-1.1394017935,
0.0399630629,
-0.0243655965,
-0.8942991495,
-0.472751081,
0.2915202379,
-0.3315721154,
0.2217065841,
0.1408190578,
-0.1226169094,
0.7747656703,
-0.156390816,
-0.6413024068,
0.6580967307,
-0.1124461219,
0.5754153132,
-0.2102329284,
0.1783051789,
0.326087445,
-0.54370749,
-0.6156858206,
-0.2488524318,
0.1427980661,
0.3113237321,
-0.5349020958,
0.3555861712,
-0.3881374896,
-0.4352092445,
-0.3581054211,
-0.0963488668,
-0.1951172203,
0.2012478858,
0.1564608216,
0.7374173403,
0.193392396,
-0.6193463802,
-0.0464921705,
0.3686515391,
0.0165209491,
1.075856328,
-0.5142120719,
0.028093867,
-0.4137156904,
0.1493027061,
-0.2763124704,
-0.1213098839,
0.4532688558,
-0.431736052,
0.0527123623,
-0.6593034863,
-0.3647996187,
-0.5362319946,
-0.556063354,
0.2394061089,
0.222712636,
-0.086082913,
0.5480538607,
0.9186733961,
-0.0667376593,
-0.8434153199,
-0.6146089435,
0.0959104747,
-0.2845458686,
-0.3640170395,
0.1644812971,
0.085879907,
-0.5759993792,
-0.021494858,
0.2116563767,
-0.188560009,
0.1684579849,
0.5117203593,
0.3127334714,
0.1181189343,
0.0583068691,
0.6104482412,
0.1997596771,
0.2972269356,
-0.0763759166,
0.4932488203,
-0.2977841496,
-0.1738325059,
-0.3525889218,
0.4737134576,
0.5660201907,
-0.0482263379,
0.4728856981,
0.466013819,
-0.5825017691,
0.0001981258,
-0.6286555529,
0.040049132,
-0.3682002425,
-0.0748718828,
-0.01322567,
-0.8352697492,
0.5657360554,
0.1941699535,
0.0344484113,
0.3740919828,
0.6204428077,
-0.1850491762,
0.989629209,
0.4193698466,
-0.2884327769,
0.6718255877,
-0.0428675413,
0.08726421,
-0.5998286605,
-0.0689278767,
-1.0099385977,
-0.3230641484,
-0.8066680431,
-0.1069968641,
0.302764982,
-0.4837657213,
-0.3595592678,
0.1123944148,
-0.5121703744,
0.3526748717,
0.8441345692,
0.1748965234,
0.3536371291,
-0.087171562,
-0.1652046591,
0.1099649519,
-0.4293316007,
-0.9046933055,
1.0121759176,
0.2191842943,
0.2305643409,
-0.099696368,
0.538166523,
1.0577698946,
0.2294301391,
-0.5850458741,
0.4777333438,
0.1256177425,
-0.7457802296,
-0.3252856433,
-0.3999109268,
-1.0419307947,
0.4260897338,
-0.4727054536,
-0.711630106,
0.5379561186,
0.0602826327,
-0.2885337472,
0.0479631051,
-0.3788609207,
0.7735561132,
-0.0967530236,
-0.8441526294,
-0.1724616438,
-0.4555351734,
0.3482426703,
0.1209953949,
0.4318444431,
-0.0645089746,
0.429102242,
0.9340677261,
-0.3146137893,
0.4900903106,
-0.1894986778,
-0.153670311,
0.2317435741,
0.1142474785,
0.1878502518,
0.0833295733,
-0.1467895806,
0.2366588414,
0.052276466,
-0.2941205502,
-0.2931178808,
0.4309522808,
-0.7526680827,
-0.4807801545,
-0.7010093927,
-0.4633378685,
0.0207122434,
0.2763115168,
-0.0886330754,
-0.057897754,
-0.481684804,
-0.2221851647,
0.6185116172,
-0.1988210082,
0.3480426669,
0.7246854901,
-0.1185619906,
0.0285093226,
0.559063673,
0.328210026,
-0.4464948773,
0.0433342084,
0.1741145551,
-0.2499225587,
-0.4843959212,
-0.7060143948,
0.0450777672,
-0.3605177104,
0.0290690176,
-0.6035572886,
0.1613241136,
-0.6821020842,
0.02283049,
-0.0075858142,
-0.2880513072,
-0.0232980046,
-0.1739064157,
0.1907004714,
0.4064023793,
0.0999909118,
0.0781696513,
-0.4463356137,
0.6278058887,
0.3105780184,
0.1600403488,
-0.3584575355,
-0.390193224,
0.2906727791,
0.1531895995,
-0.266187638,
-1.0901449919,
0.6196884513,
-0.3206220567,
0.5541467667,
0.2176329494,
-0.2128920853,
0.2950980365,
-0.4636242688,
0.3668510318,
-0.2397396117,
-1.056317687,
1.0285719633,
-0.6849516034,
-0.0676449686,
0.6447036862,
0.1677225381,
-0.4915805757,
-0.4574407339,
-0.797637403,
-0.650652051,
1.1055669785,
0.537163496,
-0.1780041903,
0.3414875269,
0.4701984227,
0.2795054018,
0.7460927963,
-0.5956545472,
0.0137668503,
0.0482992418,
-0.0404810235,
0.4457047284,
-0.0815375522,
-0.4040312171,
-0.3229080141,
0.710709095,
-0.2618650496,
0.3246903419,
0.2808026969,
-0.4472581744,
-0.1791432798,
0.5328972936,
0.5465593934,
0.5800520778,
-0.2584944665,
-0.0364716537,
0.2763749361,
-0.3373900056,
0.1811548024,
0.2776738703,
-0.8453481793,
0.1176090837,
0.095935531,
0.621255517,
-0.1070558429,
-0.7698713541,
0.5913428068,
-0.4311217368,
-0.1956606805,
-0.4852089882,
-0.0318898149,
-0.420737952,
0.3458708525,
0.3379698396,
0.181947127,
0.8737297058,
-0.6791340113,
0.2118596435,
0.3504249454,
-0.5464913249,
0.0126928343,
0.5701099634,
0.2756008208,
-0.3844276965,
0.2293622047,
-0.4209414721,
-0.6808178425,
0.7446180582,
0.0477710851,
0.8486189842,
0.0520910807,
0.3667938709,
0.0444451161,
0.2293073535,
-0.4147206247,
0.2578098774,
-0.2541174293,
-0.6775388718,
0.0516609699,
-0.3775835335,
-0.4627112448,
-0.3448484242,
-0.7121603489,
0.3969861865,
-0.5122942924,
-0.4496214986,
-0.0844125897,
-0.1125124693,
-0.7728518844,
-0.0688908175,
0.4370864332,
0.3796778023,
-0.936164856,
0.3853127658,
0.4282371402,
-0.3617240489,
-0.02543143,
-0.3446446657,
0.4812961817,
-0.5531176329,
0.7713460922,
0.17334041,
-0.3068983257,
-0.81273067,
-0.44995749,
-0.0709612668,
0.7822731137,
0.7626343966,
-0.6768701077,
0.1547139585,
0.4026363194,
0.7492365241,
-0.0912491009,
0.657489121,
1.1711671352,
0.7086151242,
-0.2634859383,
-0.975518167,
0.0757680312,
-0.3519913256,
-0.1106788069,
0.2473100424,
-0.4565091729,
0.5269516706,
0.0849896967,
-0.0005026174,
-0.5710320473,
0.6054144502,
0.3306533396,
0.7234553099,
0.5248339772,
0.1801035255,
1.0371580124,
-0.41653198,
1.1485699415,
0.0196955595,
0.1713726968,
0.9002072215,
-0.4789981842,
0.2674960792,
0.4456379414,
-0.3331338763,
0.3570325971,
0.3693209589,
-0.0879941434,
0.0428676046,
0.3787429929,
-0.2594830692,
0.0503011271,
-0.6200448275,
-0.1109129339,
0.3983083367,
0.2793328166,
-0.5201588273,
-0.0315785259,
-0.0885880142,
0.2885625362,
0.2540875673,
-0.2985464931,
0.577978313,
-0.1241861582,
-0.6648793221,
-0.197436139,
0.1590458304,
0.6797334552,
-0.2890354395,
-0.1930966675,
-0.0834040344,
-0.0282151718,
-0.2750442326,
-0.8414955735,
0.2498622388,
0.4382003844,
-0.3021184504,
-0.4499943554,
0.8644037843,
-0.0576184429,
-0.5938237906,
0.4157375097,
0.5335319638,
-0.1769220084,
-0.203878209,
-0.9106508493,
-0.0260655545,
-0.2666264772,
-0.0724039897,
0.3925534189,
0.3034358025,
-0.5819551945,
0.8327111602,
0.4931670725,
0.2364264876,
0.0704241246,
0.5390813947,
0.4527611732,
-0.5423905253,
-0.6045148969,
-0.9019818306,
0.0190557484,
-0.5711004138,
-0.2653782666,
0.4362979829,
0.5151321292,
0.4934052825,
0.2188906968,
0.9507815838,
-0.1347333491,
0.4005255997,
-0.2261591405,
0.6941203475,
0.0172979943,
0.0824840441,
-0.4194106162,
-0.4431777596,
-0.2622133195,
0.7633717656,
-0.4564603865,
0.0575891584,
0.1628681868,
0.5513880253,
0.188100189,
0.4083185494,
-0.0704648271,
-0.0685697421,
0.3751597703,
0.0162430257,
0.8133038282,
-0.3656498194,
0.2454299629,
0.019953711,
-0.2628323734,
-0.2991451621,
-0.7409231067,
-0.8507521152,
-0.2330653518,
-0.3499098122,
-0.2220448554,
0.4096103013,
0.9551106691,
0.6037381291,
-0.914619565,
-0.4654332697,
-0.1038099974,
0.5223590732,
-0.2578192353,
-0.2083418518,
0.1174750403,
-0.0098527418,
-0.7445086241,
-0.0519131757,
0.0611327291,
-0.0911296234,
-0.0359560512,
0.0140332077,
-0.3901474774,
-0.1227727905,
0.5421105623,
0.2792812586,
-0.3186389804,
-0.239124164,
-0.4210789204,
0.1247383133,
0.2093404084,
1.0893262625,
-0.8397911191,
0.3240099847,
0.6773526669,
0.3692859709,
0.424770087,
-0.1651198715,
0.8530625701,
-0.4785389602,
0.2057707459,
0.4069401622,
0.9460277557,
0.1845576465,
-0.2593957186,
0.5684708357,
0.3269121945,
-0.3894692063,
-0.7955882549,
-0.134202525,
-0.8073272109,
-0.3216687739,
0.9397107363,
0.225020349,
-0.4500724375,
-0.3810168505,
-0.731949091,
0.5750411749,
-0.989161551,
1.0221731663,
0.6256884336,
-0.0841355249,
0.1557148695,
-0.8617627025,
0.4609555602,
0.2287191749,
-0.7804274559,
-0.0072915307,
0.5338250995,
0.088647157,
0.1609560102,
0.3138435781,
-0.3869348764,
0.4814506173,
-0.5186581612,
0.2434736043,
0.16460976,
0.098064512,
-0.4668535292,
0.312166959,
-0.2744999528,
0.1326896399
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06558v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06558v1
|
Enhancing Text Authenticity: A Novel Hybrid Approach for AI-Generated Text Detection
| 2024-06-01T10:21:54 | 2024-06-01T10:21:54 |
Ye Zhang, Qian Leng, Mengran Zhu, Rui Ding, Yue Wu, Jintong Song, Yulu Gong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The rapid advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs) has ushered in an era
where AI-generated text is increasingly indistinguishable from human-generated
content. Detecting AI-generated text has become imperative to combat
misinformation, ensure content authenticity, and safeguard against malicious
uses of AI. In this paper, we propose a novel hybrid approach that combines
traditional TF-IDF techniques with advanced machine learning models, including
Bayesian classifiers, Stochastic Gradient Descent (SGD), Categorical Gradient
Boosting (CatBoost), and 12 instances of Deberta-v3-large models. Our approach
aims to address the challenges associated with detecting AI-generated text by
leveraging the strengths of both traditional feature extraction methods and
state-of-the-art deep learning models. Through extensive experiments on a
comprehensive dataset, we demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed method
in accurately distinguishing between human and AI-generated text. Our approach
achieves superior performance compared to existing methods. This research
contributes to the advancement of AI-generated text detection techniques and
lays the foundation for developing robust solutions to mitigate the challenges
posed by AI-generated content.
|
[
-0.0437288098,
-1.2157136202,
0.3453853428,
-0.0238582287,
-0.3138131797,
0.8048377037,
-0.0903788656,
-0.6867269278,
0.0942312852,
0.6198641062,
-0.3096112013,
-0.7016454935,
-0.6139361262,
0.2218716592,
-0.5951931477,
0.9544963241,
0.0864299312,
-0.21443744,
-0.0316575617,
-0.0703327134,
-0.1687230766,
-0.3325304389,
-0.8142018914,
-0.3486348391,
0.1290715188,
0.1921004355,
0.5694614649,
0.616540134,
0.4045647085,
0.3088931441,
-0.0002089923,
0.7003382444,
-0.1789888144,
-0.0409320556,
-0.1001390442,
-0.2693262398,
-0.3295582235,
-0.0341158509,
0.6830236912,
-0.004813842,
0.0561122894,
-0.0475117937,
-0.0596672371,
0.3873399794,
-0.6020287275,
-0.1937006116,
-0.8705078959,
-0.1093223244,
-0.3393608332,
-0.3487606645,
-0.5066758394,
-0.1962219924,
-0.2287064493,
-0.3963424861,
0.3263709545,
-0.0370478779,
0.8521644473,
0.191682592,
-0.5274571776,
-0.381239593,
-1.0351017714,
0.6269260049,
-0.8285229802,
0.1126191244,
0.171196878,
0.1965890676,
-0.1001388505,
-0.7280825973,
-1.2027153969,
-0.3824725747,
0.054437153,
0.088083826,
-0.1769693494,
-0.1441400945,
0.0736213475,
0.575319469,
-0.6254114509,
0.6401691437,
0.044001855,
-0.363453418,
0.7275384665,
0.0500109419,
0.8363950253,
-0.0595947877,
-0.4546561241,
-0.2681909204,
-0.5895112753,
0.0275505688,
0.4978780448,
0.0351341739,
-0.0967487097,
0.4022911489,
-0.1308371127,
0.3728414178,
0.0559129864,
-0.578984797,
0.2194522619,
-0.4241136014,
-0.1641705483,
0.0437981971,
1.1812748909,
0.0607688874,
0.2976392508,
-0.1608339101,
-0.2969205379,
0.2162124366,
0.0961007923,
-0.669200778,
-0.0519136675,
0.0632500798,
-0.6460072398,
-0.930759728,
0.2703072131,
-0.8565533161,
-0.6172713637,
0.0069765756,
0.5046312213,
-0.3829587102,
-0.5827493072,
-0.0670233667,
-0.1241579205,
0.2673557997,
0.2502355874,
-0.7547067404,
0.0653098002,
0.7002008557,
0.6129185557,
-0.4778672755,
0.0208576974,
-0.50198704,
0.2432841063,
-0.330496788,
0.7780799866,
-0.6418961287,
-0.220909223,
0.1228622347,
-0.3626411557,
0.2239354253,
-0.7205557227,
0.7925219536,
-0.6532769799,
0.1729967296,
0.3510712087,
-0.5244333744,
-0.1090198606,
0.4018941522,
-0.8033243418,
1.3666870594,
0.0037614931,
-0.7963788509,
0.4445596337,
-0.629965961,
-0.7448117733,
0.4019725621,
-0.2936303914,
-0.7972938418,
-0.0232612211,
0.511895299,
0.4469286799,
-0.1836653054,
0.4294312596,
-0.1657760888,
-0.2324698418,
0.4695488811,
-0.870986402,
0.8022173643,
0.0413130969,
-0.5977560282,
0.1042487547,
-1.0057808161,
-0.1882576346,
0.2401087284,
-0.2508384287,
-0.4826543331,
-0.0244496502,
0.2639022768,
0.018685706,
0.4681210518,
-0.6041257381,
0.0093747703,
-0.4344516695,
0.324331224,
0.628698349,
0.1063624024,
0.4333309531,
-0.1955515593,
0.5650666356,
0.1505145133,
-0.1930750012,
-0.379912734,
-0.461546272,
-0.6524117589,
-0.5224452615,
0.3538579643,
0.8769924045,
-1.0939580202,
0.9109210968,
-0.2254941314,
-0.634912312,
-0.5923615694,
0.2318137288,
0.3649254143,
0.5808285475,
0.2582726181,
0.0492352173,
-0.2353495061,
-0.9295372963,
-0.351329267,
-0.3794874549,
-0.1442540884,
0.1542040557,
0.6307556629,
-0.4045259356,
0.8515873551,
-0.0980300382,
-0.2255656421,
-0.4363299608,
0.4500946999,
-0.1807499826,
0.6773528457,
0.5859476924,
-1.0747282505,
-0.5757349133,
0.1261402965,
-0.7264046073,
-0.2150875181,
-0.4686203897,
0.0453092158,
0.19545044,
0.4740381539,
-0.4710673988,
0.5173734426,
0.2811903656,
-0.2007687986,
0.3282433748,
-0.203965053,
0.3726850152,
-1.3303816319,
0.1181635484,
0.2765680254,
-0.4340208173,
-0.518958509,
0.2492393851,
0.1357582957,
-0.0006685719,
-0.079084605,
0.6208446622,
-0.1803289801,
0.3339106143,
-0.5695350766,
0.0001176991,
0.115942128,
0.1056089476,
0.0464159176,
0.880653441,
0.1894706041,
-0.2577981353,
0.3117634058,
0.0709596723,
-0.2001005411,
0.5306467414,
-0.5773549676,
0.2113868147,
-0.1408761591,
0.4295303822,
-1.1138868332,
-0.1749397814,
0.5952343941,
-0.6995146275,
0.5310837626,
0.1909385622,
-0.9645392299,
-0.1257199496,
-0.3776408732,
0.4174724519,
0.6296845078,
-0.6963804364,
0.898330152,
0.2787671089,
-0.0960503444,
-0.501122117,
-0.5472051501,
0.487764746,
-0.2526006401,
-0.6238432527,
0.7174529433,
0.0591441356,
-0.2645651996,
-0.0677205995,
0.1338273585,
-0.18239142,
0.5223991275,
-0.0415956415,
0.3169490993,
-0.3339021802,
-0.1529832333,
0.5190832615,
-0.1586277187,
-0.138639003,
-0.2234854102,
0.332202971,
0.2524030209,
-0.1717883945,
-1.0619695187,
0.5184656382,
0.7229138017,
-0.556199491,
0.8491309285,
1.1590820551,
-0.6047849655,
-0.4466668069,
-0.6228901744,
-0.2390270382,
-0.4878783226,
0.3421127796,
0.0018142146,
-0.8615779281,
0.1968114525,
-0.0603147894,
-0.0500231832,
0.6490107179,
0.6246706843,
-0.1045535207,
1.0377806425,
0.7423033714,
-0.2565517426,
0.5360770822,
0.0387867987,
0.3649140596,
-0.3852710426,
-0.3486535549,
-0.6404146552,
-0.2168321311,
-0.8266354203,
-0.2544004619,
0.0532296784,
0.0255509168,
0.0431496687,
0.0839234591,
-0.4559963942,
0.487433821,
0.7378643751,
0.3886566162,
0.4856011271,
0.2165860236,
0.2332213074,
-0.0009456009,
-0.2397337407,
-0.7907323837,
1.1983628273,
0.3125967979,
0.3987315893,
0.0346272476,
0.6472213268,
0.7550167441,
0.4834070504,
-0.4452564418,
0.5371766686,
-0.199470073,
-0.5717522502,
0.0386713967,
-0.3654531837,
-0.5585400462,
0.0306851305,
-0.7936302423,
-0.6827495098,
-0.3425613046,
0.052689407,
-0.2016869038,
0.4918233156,
-0.4844474196,
0.7034213543,
-0.3904975951,
-0.336498946,
-0.3246693611,
-0.3878768384,
0.2864841819,
-0.3114577234,
0.0997667238,
0.0735022947,
-0.3162598014,
0.6739473343,
0.0060680504,
0.8482145071,
0.0236241445,
-0.2586039603,
0.2833538949,
0.1174323931,
0.7931553721,
0.2277567685,
0.0743722841,
0.204623729,
-0.5738232136,
-0.3790021539,
-0.5412905216,
0.5715166926,
-0.607163012,
-0.4945039153,
-0.3343436122,
-0.4247140884,
0.0617528558,
0.3979487121,
0.2844710946,
0.340788722,
-0.3243240416,
0.1508421451,
0.6919468641,
-0.4229016006,
0.6334866285,
0.4108901918,
0.0762862861,
-0.6649717689,
1.0504046679,
-0.4875015914,
0.0334592834,
0.7359995246,
0.13232328,
-0.30574435,
-1.1213343143,
-0.6774923801,
0.0827343687,
-0.3690892756,
-0.1493859291,
-0.8078578711,
-0.2745457888,
-0.420167774,
-0.1437606514,
-0.094886899,
-0.1373150647,
-0.6606351137,
-0.1224061251,
0.1270921677,
0.5965189934,
0.2146029174,
0.3594087064,
-0.9399555326,
0.5533699989,
-0.036801625,
-0.1935541928,
-0.0751628652,
-0.4261994362,
-0.0115542505,
0.1430888325,
-0.3311924338,
-0.7686542273,
0.440246135,
0.13553074,
0.5782164335,
0.6532728076,
0.142228052,
0.121105209,
-0.2448344082,
0.9307098985,
0.0188363828,
-0.8695291281,
0.5424901843,
-0.4930540323,
-0.1128806919,
0.4787931442,
0.2462330461,
-0.0671418384,
-0.57654351,
-0.7219492197,
-0.6241375804,
0.2202097327,
0.468698442,
0.3189614117,
0.1548157334,
0.4609650671,
0.2404618412,
0.2915266752,
-0.9881160259,
-0.1319745034,
0.0555344447,
-0.6665971875,
-0.0091183372,
-0.1689978689,
0.1960396171,
0.0949349478,
0.6086277366,
-0.1157927513,
0.0112839611,
-0.0824540481,
-0.176374346,
0.1625376493,
0.106295906,
0.656855762,
0.2969639301,
0.0743867159,
-0.0434110425,
-0.0396148078,
-0.463498801,
0.1680248529,
0.205561921,
-0.5804876685,
-0.0162581075,
0.7310214639,
0.4624029398,
-0.3016121089,
-0.8228868842,
0.599406004,
0.1105468124,
-0.0118820621,
-0.3848071098,
0.2513270378,
-0.2789691687,
0.3538008928,
0.6957187653,
0.2294847965,
0.135638997,
-0.421420306,
0.2303180546,
0.6272454262,
-0.0780840889,
-0.3311932683,
0.6876511574,
0.4801120758,
-0.626537025,
0.4181399941,
-0.1931078732,
-0.8146088719,
0.8372303843,
0.7545432448,
1.0099006891,
0.0056266855,
0.4220974743,
0.1898193508,
0.4861425161,
-0.0116044851,
-0.1038865969,
-0.3017293513,
-0.9180310965,
-0.198633641,
-0.6018903255,
-0.2158552408,
0.4897612929,
-0.3063168228,
0.1623093635,
-0.581897378,
0.1108828411,
0.0804082826,
0.0329067744,
-0.2657003999,
0.2555960119,
0.5118921995,
0.8009776473,
-1.0074696541,
0.7552128434,
0.4442736506,
-0.2737035155,
-0.39731282,
0.4672325552,
-0.0160469152,
-0.711705029,
0.3187766671,
0.4906500876,
-0.1304833293,
0.1818816811,
-0.6500016451,
-0.3901961148,
1.0430321693,
0.1807086319,
-0.1947284788,
0.0530755855,
0.254663527,
0.6652103662,
-0.4993682802,
0.1637761444,
0.5338536501,
0.3719241619,
-0.0863145813,
-0.5621168017,
0.0783947408,
-0.3357853591,
-0.0330167823,
0.1436992139,
-0.4602022469,
0.4973951578,
0.1162107289,
-0.2691766918,
0.3446392119,
0.8482024074,
0.2831749022,
0.5453994274,
0.4489791989,
0.6234960556,
0.7830822468,
0.1252775639,
0.7423366904,
-0.0982473493,
0.1103020012,
0.714576602,
-0.3664410412,
0.7725513577,
0.1979591995,
0.0883788392,
0.7966851592,
0.5956357121,
-0.3300679922,
0.4109294415,
-0.1064621732,
-0.6447876692,
-0.3833939135,
-0.2535647154,
-0.1840367913,
0.5818920732,
0.4567221999,
-0.6684430242,
-0.0734879225,
0.1293937117,
0.0805562437,
0.5426302552,
-0.3394514322,
0.8530240655,
-0.2357089967,
-0.6359196305,
0.1170114949,
0.3487392068,
1.0004740953,
-0.3020252287,
-0.1528351009,
-0.0538888834,
0.3542703092,
-0.1684512347,
-0.5831551552,
-0.0626326352,
0.1920496076,
-0.1231017113,
-0.2672502697,
1.043938756,
-0.4346152842,
-0.7291247845,
0.1246557012,
0.4348571599,
-0.3088184595,
-0.1326536387,
-0.6233433485,
0.0093969973,
0.0270077959,
0.1327755004,
0.0929777697,
0.4051528573,
-0.0070734969,
0.4497570097,
0.8882935047,
-0.1356307566,
-0.1925429851,
-0.2686839998,
0.6660562754,
-0.4619270861,
-0.6247003675,
-1.2316143513,
0.4602064788,
-0.4754130244,
-0.1995533109,
0.5993896723,
0.5019748211,
0.768271327,
0.0642101839,
1.0830881596,
0.0422832035,
0.3718442023,
-0.6380509138,
0.8543462753,
-0.6521923542,
0.3137372732,
-0.417304188,
-0.7771168351,
-0.3172130883,
0.3233564198,
0.0146142263,
0.0681953952,
0.4604404867,
0.8373443484,
-0.1106239855,
-0.0473013334,
0.1124762967,
-0.1175506562,
0.5972117782,
0.43754673,
0.9647787213,
-0.473187387,
0.601880312,
-0.0724677294,
-0.4425251484,
-0.3155571818,
-0.9107363224,
-1.2526572943,
-0.4662226439,
-0.5747132301,
-0.4158296287,
-0.1426465213,
0.6843267679,
0.4593906403,
-0.771715343,
0.3444903791,
-0.1714509428,
0.034364406,
-0.1021477729,
-0.2422774583,
0.3784405887,
0.1454937309,
-0.8782166243,
0.4746627212,
0.3008207977,
0.3501687646,
-0.3836955428,
0.1674225032,
-0.1721337438,
0.2437032312,
0.3428110182,
0.2148422599,
-0.6851499081,
-0.1904114783,
-0.1034686267,
-0.3880010247,
0.0172158927,
0.7878943682,
-0.918107152,
0.2099729031,
0.5324237943,
1.0822905302,
0.3508118391,
0.1465659738,
0.4614317417,
-0.6309405565,
0.2431592941,
0.3195400536,
0.0925416276,
0.5107573271,
-0.5850735903,
0.1853245199,
0.518692255,
-0.2446874082,
-0.8857526183,
0.3226946294,
-0.9448219538,
-0.126942113,
0.9523665309,
-0.1695133597,
-0.1112985983,
-0.0165480003,
-0.1992348582,
0.2734505832,
-0.4560675919,
0.8828636408,
0.4247589707,
0.3561309576,
-0.126463294,
-0.1618946791,
0.4386885464,
0.2152074873,
-1.0387556553,
-0.2659226358,
0.4621132016,
0.1862686872,
0.1713363528,
0.3813736141,
-0.0618894808,
0.2943657339,
-0.1055671647,
-0.1936963201,
-0.2093219906,
-0.3876669705,
-0.1429890841,
0.3472052217,
-0.3084965646,
-0.1769719124
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00380v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00380v1
|
The Best of Both Worlds: Toward an Honest and Helpful Large Language Model
| 2024-06-01T09:36:16 | 2024-06-01T09:36:16 |
Chujie Gao, Qihui Zhang, Dongping Chen, Yue Huang, Siyuan Wu, Zhengyan Fu, Yao Wan, Xiangliang Zhang, Lichao Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable success across various
industries due to their exceptional generative capabilities. However, for safe
and effective real-world deployments, ensuring honesty and helpfulness is
critical. This paper addresses the question: Can we prioritize the helpfulness
of LLMs while preserving their honesty? To begin with, we establish exhaustive
principles aimed at guaranteeing the honesty of LLM. Additionally, we introduce
a novel dataset, referred to as HoneSet, comprising 930 queries spanning six
categories meticulously crafted to assess an LLM's capacity for maintaining
honesty. Subsequently, we present two approaches to augmenting honesty and
helpfulness in LLMs: a training-free enhancement and a fine-tuning-based
improvement. The training-free approach, which is based on curiosity-driven
prompting, empowers LLMs to articulate internal confusion and uncertainty
regarding queries, thereby optimizing their responses. Conversely, the
fine-tuning-based method employs a two-stage process inspired by curriculum
learning: initially instructing LLMs to discern between honest and dishonest
responses, then refining their training to enhance helpfulness. Experiments
conducted on nine prominent LLMs demonstrate a significant improvement in
alignment with honesty across all models through the implementation of our
proposed enhancements. Particularly noteworthy is the 65.3% enhancement
observed in Llama3-8b and the remarkable 124.7% improvement in Mistral-7b, as
measured by the H$^{2}$ (honest and helpful) assessment. We believe that our
work can pave the way for developing more trustworthy LLMs for real-world
applications.
|
[
-0.1314944476,
-0.7097774148,
0.7283854485,
0.1149899364,
-0.0866754577,
0.1002331302,
-0.5868512988,
-0.5408754349,
-0.3480740488,
0.533765316,
-0.3665527999,
-0.3317234814,
-0.6212943792,
-0.0774285197,
-0.036147099,
1.0371986628,
0.1960549802,
0.3029015362,
0.0623169653,
-0.245679006,
-0.5467348099,
-0.3890963495,
-0.8163753152,
-0.4562334418,
0.8415975571,
0.3825283945,
1.1945815086,
0.8552245498,
0.6909838319,
0.2729536295,
-0.2548231483,
0.4114075601,
-0.784511745,
0.365886569,
-0.5777991414,
-0.7534565926,
-0.5621805787,
0.1691694558,
0.2034760416,
0.5801515579,
-0.4623981118,
0.1400541961,
0.2588345408,
0.5672861934,
-0.5803983808,
0.1094966531,
-0.9343812466,
-0.3562386632,
0.0132765835,
-0.0529014468,
-0.2408984601,
-0.7418519855,
-0.0371917933,
-0.6712041497,
-0.090523757,
0.0843948945,
0.7740474939,
0.2511309087,
-0.2395514995,
-0.4414393902,
-0.5620636344,
1.1579781771,
-0.834525764,
0.4642342031,
0.4739921987,
0.2604666352,
-0.318234235,
-0.4199468791,
-0.3974434435,
-0.3708948791,
0.1819022,
-0.0729142874,
0.1747060418,
0.1682181507,
0.0048296708,
0.5708450675,
-0.3327881396,
0.5076646805,
0.1026630476,
-0.4215940535,
0.6418300867,
0.0723962411,
-0.0314765796,
0.2073967904,
-0.2410126179,
-0.2146527618,
-0.9291779399,
0.0274204966,
0.6432309747,
0.3740401566,
-0.0697577596,
0.5675297976,
-0.2821735144,
0.4308071733,
0.079937011,
-0.4867686331,
0.0682967305,
-0.4269021153,
-0.1552595049,
-0.2816449106,
0.7088776231,
0.4788066745,
0.4820611775,
-0.2075838596,
-0.6107957959,
0.2441070676,
0.3324677944,
-0.7531983256,
0.0585037693,
0.1745977402,
-0.4729499221,
-0.650940001,
-0.0679047853,
-0.4087385237,
-0.6574606895,
-0.4984098077,
0.4851368964,
-0.4269104004,
-0.3228697181,
0.1391083598,
0.2888232768,
0.2859955132,
0.4298221469,
-0.8183319569,
0.0921813175,
1.0883716345,
0.5036544204,
0.1501400322,
-0.0901027173,
-0.7839054465,
0.00923522,
-0.5449585319,
0.3716246486,
-0.6528381109,
-0.3994193077,
0.1968392432,
-0.2422704101,
0.4866299033,
-0.7663572431,
0.9114589095,
-0.598208189,
0.1618727446,
-0.4528868198,
-0.5793412924,
-0.0369287468,
0.5030827522,
-0.3578988612,
0.9663012028,
0.1734084487,
-0.5879989862,
0.2038253993,
-0.4301300943,
-0.0221539289,
-0.1942347288,
-0.1520703137,
-0.3849904835,
0.359782666,
0.2397194952,
0.4410613775,
-0.2852969468,
0.5152852535,
-0.4430073798,
-0.3959575593,
0.5077523589,
-0.6230940223,
0.7748078704,
0.2794934809,
-0.3058055639,
-0.0584940724,
-0.4992342889,
0.1559927911,
0.0124930609,
-0.3742018938,
-0.2841237485,
-0.3017228544,
-0.2515051961,
0.1287910044,
0.4650497139,
-0.5789711475,
0.1763893366,
-0.73805058,
-0.0376968347,
1.1667909622,
-0.1144999415,
0.565985322,
-0.5098944902,
0.443805933,
-0.1631416231,
0.5566491485,
-0.0427032411,
-0.3538620472,
-0.8218604326,
-0.0690099448,
0.3163227141,
0.4900717139,
-0.7158182263,
0.5226898193,
-0.3900744915,
-0.4575628936,
-0.8781778216,
0.3570764065,
0.7381178141,
0.5014367104,
0.2106581032,
-0.3337684572,
-0.1019998938,
-1.0738376379,
-0.4350116253,
-0.3895255923,
-0.0780979991,
0.3073750138,
0.1164802089,
0.0526024885,
0.7150188684,
-0.3007057011,
-0.2277274728,
-0.0278892349,
-0.2374243587,
0.2608124316,
0.3793426454,
0.322164923,
-0.8118520379,
-0.5493457317,
0.00967135,
-0.7241981626,
-0.1611565799,
0.2136480957,
-0.1419938356,
-0.0442040451,
0.0505647883,
-0.4083825648,
0.1857366115,
0.5539264679,
-0.2262322009,
0.4464934468,
-0.2705276906,
0.0629208907,
-0.954787612,
-0.2292192131,
-0.2373237014,
-0.3882091939,
-0.5175765157,
0.4442316294,
0.0313104354,
0.3219253421,
-0.3860457242,
0.7251965404,
-0.4509916902,
0.0555126555,
-0.2780417204,
0.0578014851,
0.1110550836,
0.298168093,
-0.3453311026,
0.8898425698,
0.6395062208,
-0.5086951256,
0.3376863897,
0.3173500597,
-0.2813350856,
0.9843577743,
-0.5561935306,
0.369787991,
-0.1038127318,
0.0325401984,
-0.5983073711,
-0.0964124724,
0.1454391629,
-0.4588191211,
0.470153898,
-0.0668907166,
-0.6578702927,
0.003991717,
-0.5986949801,
-0.0477097444,
0.722206831,
-0.6037620306,
0.3667663336,
0.2024776936,
-0.2964686155,
-0.8379389048,
-0.6714850664,
0.0760849491,
-0.1546975672,
-0.5227158666,
0.090408735,
-0.4520049989,
-0.4852068722,
-0.1730797291,
-0.1651102751,
-0.1060179919,
0.1582766771,
0.1444482952,
0.3779595196,
-0.0869503468,
-0.0856305063,
-0.1417069584,
-0.1937805265,
-0.1909641325,
-0.2066445649,
0.2563459277,
-0.2364179045,
-0.3730705678,
-0.4548920095,
0.2185865343,
0.3797761798,
-0.3738104999,
0.9366580248,
0.7547327876,
-0.0395650417,
-0.0758577734,
-1.0414638519,
-0.4774623811,
-0.5519043803,
0.2219836563,
-0.2224067152,
-1.0637410879,
0.3290943205,
0.0099661043,
0.4318030477,
-0.1113625541,
0.4699424207,
-0.0272172876,
0.9387189746,
0.9847372174,
-0.2801935673,
0.3617847264,
0.0139456633,
0.4928393066,
-0.906241715,
-0.1731441766,
-0.5556507707,
-0.047291249,
-0.6129443645,
-0.4055400789,
0.441165477,
0.1735172719,
-0.1430064142,
-0.1279000342,
-0.501039207,
0.6189310551,
0.2959932089,
0.2080854625,
0.4814179838,
0.0208992995,
0.0258728843,
-0.2436519116,
-0.4226031899,
-0.7806705236,
1.1501598358,
0.5834144354,
0.9032325745,
0.2355374247,
0.6676531434,
-0.1194304749,
0.581859827,
-0.8480562568,
0.6308387518,
-0.0277749505,
-0.5563665032,
-0.2916227579,
-0.5318275094,
-0.7477089167,
0.1905008256,
0.0269662384,
-0.5635646582,
-0.0068949945,
0.226652652,
-0.2487349063,
0.1587152332,
-0.5554147959,
0.3438617587,
-0.4151149988,
-0.6664628983,
-0.3559129834,
-0.6830815077,
0.2893837094,
-0.2006945908,
0.4063881338,
-0.2573674917,
-0.3732022941,
0.3019456863,
-0.1968517154,
0.7544385195,
-0.2402173281,
-0.4761306942,
0.0259984229,
0.2276138067,
0.8665612936,
0.0379499756,
-0.6422297359,
0.077643171,
-0.3632999063,
-0.365185678,
-0.7893308401,
0.9296956658,
-0.6414033771,
-0.6405567527,
-0.1510468423,
-0.629406631,
-0.4931900501,
0.2341799736,
-0.0371614061,
0.4334144294,
-0.1258676797,
0.41223225,
1.1146464348,
-0.3439669609,
0.2683580816,
0.7512268424,
-0.3131767809,
-0.2035849988,
0.8024002314,
-0.0300894827,
0.5669209361,
0.2868236899,
0.3807517886,
-0.6181973219,
-0.7840784192,
-0.186421454,
0.3439993858,
-0.7130233645,
-0.4041725695,
-0.405634433,
-0.0538654104,
-0.2788500786,
-0.1523519009,
-0.6831653118,
-0.2585405111,
0.0081656473,
-0.2171942443,
0.2911842167,
0.6088883281,
-0.0715081841,
0.2212089896,
-0.5831082463,
0.261041671,
0.2512815297,
0.5584958792,
-0.1080967933,
-0.6530846357,
-0.2206861824,
0.2742362022,
-0.4239729643,
-0.3361398578,
0.1274032891,
0.2037396878,
0.6329932809,
0.299957484,
0.00998672,
0.6195268631,
-0.354467243,
0.8561089039,
0.0619325675,
-0.5796111226,
0.432777971,
-0.5605996251,
0.0383405611,
0.8712068796,
0.2771221101,
-0.2749485075,
-0.6596432924,
-0.6716841459,
-0.6961995959,
0.5479527712,
0.3196486533,
0.5109717846,
0.3199848235,
0.505410254,
0.334287256,
0.5576908588,
-0.680016458,
-0.2493321896,
-0.0183458459,
-0.3465708196,
0.120529376,
-0.1896815747,
-0.2321065515,
0.0014837212,
0.8507909179,
-0.1483628154,
0.1113091558,
-0.0646634847,
0.0599798039,
0.0484469347,
0.6138652563,
0.1449755579,
0.8320052028,
0.0966277346,
0.1810157001,
0.0903669745,
-0.3289034069,
0.176034838,
-0.0652192086,
-0.1982421428,
-0.1726272702,
0.1798169911,
0.5833630562,
0.2218581736,
-0.4826755524,
0.7676287889,
-0.0102984104,
0.1852904707,
-0.0559741072,
0.4246236384,
0.1484940648,
0.2117535472,
0.1361200213,
-0.1803040653,
0.0358427726,
-0.6266133189,
-0.0363369435,
0.657335639,
-0.1887304187,
-0.2660504878,
0.3692503572,
0.1473559141,
-0.3384106159,
0.5239257812,
-0.2999125719,
-0.4359441102,
0.1293380111,
0.3638879955,
0.6235631108,
-0.6475522518,
0.2295580059,
0.1018416956,
0.3149850368,
-0.4061383605,
0.3342355788,
0.0724890605,
-0.8615425229,
-0.2567127049,
-0.7885332108,
-0.4563923776,
0.3340477943,
-0.7436001301,
0.1287349463,
-0.4287793934,
-0.1411801577,
-0.3868868947,
0.2406283468,
-0.69777596,
0.240892306,
-0.0261750575,
0.7754392624,
-0.3288752139,
0.8162353635,
0.3941573799,
-0.2578797936,
-1.1636137962,
-0.0568218827,
-0.0260032229,
-1.0215096474,
0.1522760838,
0.0252130367,
-0.1812897623,
-0.028873479,
-0.7571793199,
-0.6257982254,
1.0168349743,
0.6552126408,
-0.8912873268,
-0.0332063809,
0.0733940601,
0.5574504733,
-0.1603972167,
0.3523096144,
0.4257867336,
0.6142733097,
-0.0929191858,
-1.2172158957,
-0.0104720425,
0.1456392109,
0.224163115,
0.0823244452,
-0.814776063,
0.423938036,
-0.2776320875,
0.0625833347,
0.4378249049,
0.4511307478,
0.3358000815,
0.1732616127,
0.5336071849,
0.3482466638,
1.0515428782,
-0.0485453568,
1.123365283,
-0.2842877507,
0.2219476402,
1.0711963177,
-0.3306646049,
0.7261072397,
0.6514680386,
0.0010708368,
0.3463690281,
0.4382993579,
0.1427133083,
0.5471673012,
0.0385196432,
-0.3025006056,
-0.1606164128,
-0.6205191016,
-0.3113611639,
0.2569554746,
0.3433555067,
-0.3301127553,
-0.181698665,
-0.0604805909,
0.4200271368,
0.2294531316,
-0.3399507701,
0.632679224,
0.3801236451,
-0.6719048023,
0.4579796195,
0.0808766335,
0.9429219365,
-0.7765062451,
0.0816821977,
-0.3135797679,
0.1870153248,
-0.3128596544,
-0.9119058251,
0.0629338846,
0.1148150563,
-0.0371035859,
-0.4549862146,
0.7021020055,
-0.5429769158,
-0.3363716006,
0.1864685416,
0.5207149982,
0.0888142139,
-0.075483121,
-0.7776288986,
0.4338949919,
-0.0166506022,
-0.3289420903,
0.4331088364,
0.4557030499,
0.0085481172,
0.7799800038,
0.7330594659,
0.4606553316,
-0.1894800663,
0.3091902733,
0.9239169359,
-0.24957335,
-0.4076648355,
-0.7326217294,
0.5415363312,
-0.0510354117,
-0.0957222879,
0.9023455381,
0.448571682,
0.8017833233,
0.2059475929,
0.6423974037,
0.2905376554,
0.6112660766,
-0.4906757176,
0.5244427919,
-0.387347132,
0.5724880695,
-0.0972044766,
-1.216055274,
-0.0890206397,
0.7181962729,
-0.3531989157,
0.2113235891,
0.429097265,
1.2356877327,
-0.0943791419,
-0.007409648,
0.4916502237,
0.431868732,
0.5152829885,
0.4464152753,
1.0154770613,
-0.2438281178,
0.4177204669,
-0.3322525322,
-0.3125701249,
-0.0299052168,
-0.9222323895,
-0.6294831634,
-0.1767203063,
-0.1335870922,
-0.307806313,
0.2582614124,
0.8829056025,
0.7299949527,
-0.4652253091,
-0.0206462834,
-0.0072292448,
-0.0378857963,
-0.009854449,
-0.209632054,
-0.0383366644,
-0.3585437536,
-0.6976984143,
0.5603454113,
0.3065703511,
-0.0445923544,
-0.5643331409,
-0.2507567406,
0.4481284022,
0.1880835444,
0.5087776184,
-0.2159566432,
-0.7726290226,
-0.5109291673,
0.0946601853,
-0.2292998582,
0.0701490715,
0.6673262119,
-0.5637613535,
0.4070937932,
0.0776069909,
0.7180576921,
0.0762832314,
0.0356369726,
0.6833252311,
-0.6875756979,
0.0497852601,
0.5052724481,
0.0765068233,
0.8701059818,
-0.6634899378,
0.5565608144,
-0.3347821832,
-0.810325861,
-0.9437933564,
0.3517066538,
-0.7968392968,
0.0612611547,
1.3330556154,
-0.3036842346,
-0.0056534135,
-0.2511882782,
-0.3228167593,
0.1894178241,
-0.5138918161,
0.832189858,
0.7268475294,
-0.0299580786,
0.1181284338,
-0.5563312769,
0.4920457006,
0.5492629409,
-0.6947434545,
0.1976509243,
0.5330857038,
0.4592041075,
0.0208180565,
0.6674819589,
-0.3559601307,
0.0068671689,
-0.4019683599,
-0.3820246756,
-0.2087947875,
-0.4295776784,
-0.4123878181,
0.0662157685,
0.6642397642,
0.0034266091
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00367v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00367v1
|
RoBERTa-BiLSTM: A Context-Aware Hybrid Model for Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-06-01T08:59:46 | 2024-06-01T08:59:46 |
Md. Mostafizer Rahman, Ariful Islam Shiplu, Yutaka Watanobe, Md. Ashad Alam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CE
|
Effectively analyzing the comments to uncover latent intentions holds immense
value in making strategic decisions across various domains. However, several
challenges hinder the process of sentiment analysis including the lexical
diversity exhibited in comments, the presence of long dependencies within the
text, encountering unknown symbols and words, and dealing with imbalanced
datasets. Moreover, existing sentiment analysis tasks mostly leveraged
sequential models to encode the long dependent texts and it requires longer
execution time as it processes the text sequentially. In contrast, the
Transformer requires less execution time due to its parallel processing nature.
In this work, we introduce a novel hybrid deep learning model, RoBERTa-BiLSTM,
which combines the Robustly Optimized BERT Pretraining Approach (RoBERTa) with
Bidirectional Long Short-Term Memory (BiLSTM) networks. RoBERTa is utilized to
generate meaningful word embedding vectors, while BiLSTM effectively captures
the contextual semantics of long-dependent texts. The RoBERTa-BiLSTM hybrid
model leverages the strengths of both sequential and Transformer models to
enhance performance in sentiment analysis. We conducted experiments using
datasets from IMDb, Twitter US Airline, and Sentiment140 to evaluate the
proposed model against existing state-of-the-art methods. Our experimental
findings demonstrate that the RoBERTa-BiLSTM model surpasses baseline models
(e.g., BERT, RoBERTa-base, RoBERTa-GRU, and RoBERTa-LSTM), achieving accuracies
of 80.74%, 92.36%, and 82.25% on the Twitter US Airline, IMDb, and Sentiment140
datasets, respectively. Additionally, the model achieves F1-scores of 80.73%,
92.35%, and 82.25% on the same datasets, respectively.
|
[
-0.3455359936,
-0.64181602,
0.3707902133,
0.4348224401,
-0.6748051643,
0.4324357212,
-0.5519813895,
-0.2411202192,
0.1485945433,
0.2780341208,
-0.7532786727,
-0.3806479573,
-0.6652206779,
0.0179916378,
-0.2496527433,
1.5696179867,
0.0263385549,
0.4165425599,
-0.0844077989,
-0.3507559896,
-0.2785157263,
-0.6928135157,
-0.3938828409,
-0.0267257486,
0.5244512558,
-0.0868581608,
0.5186651945,
-0.596683979,
0.5432476401,
0.2587713301,
-0.2830445468,
0.4000145495,
-0.5268329382,
-0.0776435584,
-0.3553858101,
-0.1393373013,
-0.4809905589,
0.1120647937,
0.6449781656,
0.6877999902,
0.0200984031,
0.1339863539,
0.2005397081,
0.7118703723,
-0.3880825639,
-0.0714950785,
-0.6065641642,
0.0206186045,
-0.0842955783,
-0.0290070213,
-0.415020436,
-0.2956945598,
0.5761123896,
-0.0722322091,
0.1725602895,
-0.1204621717,
0.9677269459,
0.1510575563,
-0.5372824073,
-0.1653843671,
-0.9255586863,
1.0926959515,
-0.8498618603,
0.2612121999,
-0.3702236414,
0.3232906759,
0.3188140988,
-0.5959383845,
-0.7421759367,
-0.067366302,
-0.0763719007,
0.5610698462,
0.0172639955,
-0.1074811518,
-0.0701900125,
0.5630971193,
-0.7860502601,
-0.0636379644,
-0.1561455429,
0.0683404952,
0.2880541086,
0.2694489062,
0.0330885462,
-0.4245565832,
-0.7759443521,
-0.0415972993,
-0.3236230016,
0.0947150812,
0.2097457647,
0.5015468597,
-0.3224848509,
0.2033267468,
0.032199543,
0.6060121655,
-0.0915063694,
0.2432046384,
0.359374851,
-0.453643024,
-0.3249231279,
-0.3889612854,
0.942274332,
0.2017868757,
0.1880999058,
-0.0773916021,
-0.2239353061,
0.3384406567,
0.2530679107,
-0.7306400537,
-0.1943660676,
0.1084041074,
-0.6901530027,
-0.3861213624,
0.3145939112,
-1.0012631416,
-0.1847474277,
-0.4206416905,
0.3424902856,
-0.4620156288,
-0.4354543686,
0.0703320354,
-0.1126590222,
0.3836318552,
0.4042379558,
-0.3117229939,
0.054179851,
0.5180084109,
0.7813057303,
-0.2688980401,
-0.08261244,
-0.2041938007,
-0.0805280581,
-0.0366881788,
0.6685588956,
-0.5323170424,
-0.659504056,
-0.077513136,
-0.303173542,
-0.2435317785,
-0.3560854793,
0.6711049676,
-0.7823241353,
0.648542881,
-0.0889579356,
-0.3538049161,
-0.4757602811,
0.5014650226,
-0.5151993036,
1.1178783178,
0.1398223639,
-0.8096233606,
0.2651144862,
-0.6055498123,
-0.7215228081,
-0.1650176942,
-0.1074648276,
-0.6513331532,
0.2517943084,
0.2335048914,
0.4660938084,
-0.4974618852,
0.5204837918,
-0.324832499,
-0.1015837863,
0.4259934127,
-0.6090076566,
0.755185008,
0.0830545276,
-0.3625639677,
0.3432903588,
-0.4655916691,
-0.0168843046,
0.0954421833,
-0.3640031815,
-0.3178749084,
-0.0291966069,
0.4147207141,
0.4307777286,
0.3660707176,
-0.5083551407,
-0.0564853661,
-0.5446723104,
0.270301044,
0.7920227051,
0.0002814476,
0.4446932375,
-0.1304169148,
0.4119330049,
0.4133294821,
0.3674679995,
-0.0392790735,
-0.3323484361,
-0.8483313918,
-0.2538838983,
0.2583714724,
0.5704753995,
-0.4417028427,
0.6852119565,
-0.621768415,
-0.3765161037,
-0.3889444172,
0.1341137588,
0.4606055617,
0.4631885886,
0.410898149,
-0.3842371702,
-0.7624389529,
-0.9222419262,
-0.4686360657,
0.1590115875,
0.4123681486,
0.2993121147,
0.4065808356,
-0.4026058912,
0.939129889,
-0.328204006,
-0.2320483029,
-0.678447485,
0.4907044172,
0.4546350837,
0.2783483863,
0.4669076502,
-1.075225234,
-0.716760695,
-0.2088243365,
-0.8241614699,
0.471814245,
-0.223607108,
-0.1649551541,
0.306050241,
-0.0043066433,
-0.7274580002,
0.3162470162,
0.5892689228,
-0.074177295,
0.2342806906,
0.0843247846,
-0.1161347702,
-1.3026556969,
-0.002500928,
0.1526188254,
-0.1928161234,
-0.441202879,
-0.1725423336,
-0.0435807295,
-0.2542278171,
-0.2840536535,
0.0764925703,
-0.3772593439,
0.0016581633,
-0.1393486559,
0.0188696291,
0.2054959387,
0.5389332175,
0.1813526303,
0.7102652788,
0.248692438,
-0.1958588064,
0.0322859697,
0.0690694973,
-0.41523844,
0.4268800318,
-0.6063350439,
0.2312873304,
-0.1013654768,
0.5598483086,
-1.168391943,
0.2197206616,
-0.102756843,
-0.4211586714,
0.4373593926,
0.0013712082,
-0.510160625,
-0.5012904406,
-0.3547036052,
0.3342059851,
0.7241905928,
-0.5207331777,
1.1044660807,
0.1585226804,
-0.0680877566,
-0.2506952286,
-0.4568509758,
0.1184484735,
-0.2374723405,
-0.7374844551,
0.3882466257,
-0.004818059,
-0.0530330166,
-0.0065398589,
0.1916469932,
0.2185688913,
-0.1584267318,
0.2288042456,
0.7239988446,
-0.2118409425,
-0.2069072872,
-0.0413299426,
-0.2376778275,
-0.0520100072,
-0.3528094888,
0.7353363037,
-0.4866460562,
0.1037580445,
-0.4192917943,
0.4687388241,
0.7773860097,
-0.5910983086,
0.9017211795,
0.8072926998,
-0.0328644887,
-0.4471594691,
-0.5170074105,
-0.1096237302,
-0.4251230955,
0.2705696225,
-0.1274279058,
-0.7798019648,
0.2155406922,
-0.3714154661,
-0.2448105216,
0.2977668047,
0.7774550319,
-0.3048456013,
1.0208894014,
0.4998682141,
-0.5265849829,
0.549767375,
-0.6487648487,
0.7340040803,
-0.9831442833,
-0.0314080305,
-0.0862253159,
-0.3409424722,
-0.4402867258,
-0.6155138016,
0.6739137173,
-0.2555356622,
-0.0689411089,
0.0182924531,
-0.3398532867,
0.0910370424,
0.5594822764,
0.184191227,
-0.0494600348,
-0.0578027144,
-0.0956865177,
-0.0635666549,
-0.4133113027,
-0.3759540915,
1.0799074173,
0.1521537751,
0.512393117,
0.204750672,
0.5544643402,
0.4344237447,
0.2655235529,
-0.6028723717,
0.6406101584,
-0.4950749278,
-0.638358891,
0.0553808473,
-0.2975218594,
-0.3640061617,
0.2163983434,
-0.249688834,
-0.2649523318,
0.0071773687,
-0.0760262012,
-0.5141713023,
0.3490507603,
-0.4890362918,
0.7971506715,
-0.5902131796,
-0.5514609218,
-0.5264397264,
-0.8334798813,
0.426620692,
0.0052853478,
0.1276878715,
-0.1190278456,
0.3109667003,
0.7101069689,
-0.4128291607,
0.954187572,
-0.4384739101,
0.3482401669,
0.2118628919,
-0.0848562196,
0.6295513511,
-0.1222303957,
-0.1301458627,
0.2657209635,
-0.2764411867,
-0.1935122758,
-0.5551549196,
0.7828142047,
-0.8950153589,
-0.3592766821,
-0.5627969503,
-0.3972614408,
-0.4846099019,
0.10616339,
0.2030015141,
0.3264203668,
-0.1895654202,
0.2977468967,
0.57352525,
-0.2315099835,
0.4348032773,
0.4287475646,
-0.0367165729,
-0.5384250879,
1.0195372105,
0.0347729065,
0.0330706313,
0.3630348146,
0.267562449,
-0.3462558091,
-0.5027734041,
-0.3387160897,
0.2506494522,
-0.4973544776,
-0.193197906,
-0.6549263597,
-0.2188582569,
-0.2410674989,
-0.1520139426,
-0.3908832371,
-0.1794373095,
-0.2159811556,
-0.1193705052,
0.2170913666,
0.5476326346,
0.3176546395,
0.2300288528,
-0.8054754734,
0.2868715227,
0.1834187508,
0.2376777977,
0.1414971799,
-0.4822260439,
-0.320964098,
-0.0068860468,
-0.1728761792,
-0.7049477696,
0.4526673555,
0.0031710265,
0.2602505684,
0.2782594264,
0.0120114107,
0.6205794811,
-0.1150044724,
1.0534439087,
0.2534593642,
-0.8398803473,
0.6508746147,
-0.5821013451,
-0.0142167779,
0.6215267181,
0.3671514988,
-0.1765813529,
-0.1532192975,
-0.4583304822,
-0.9563316703,
0.550288558,
0.1413238943,
0.3079369664,
0.0618446432,
-0.0393478163,
0.0569447055,
0.2688898444,
-0.8371984363,
0.0143717714,
-0.2977824211,
-0.5362712145,
-0.2814401388,
-0.4589475989,
-0.030674072,
-0.5144250393,
0.7998970747,
0.1793609262,
0.1744899601,
0.0853262767,
-0.217622295,
0.0662477016,
0.2393946648,
0.4630278051,
0.2504736781,
-0.4271686971,
-0.1351742297,
0.0810289308,
-0.0268063527,
-0.2181057632,
0.1121892557,
-0.273819834,
0.0630792379,
0.2094272673,
0.7701289058,
0.3712813854,
-0.6393134594,
0.7595914602,
-0.0798022524,
0.1502265334,
-0.7111738324,
-0.2282918692,
0.0477770567,
0.1318243444,
0.1900163144,
0.3647578061,
0.2074119747,
-0.6098800898,
-0.102076821,
0.6952882409,
-0.4167061746,
-0.4802635312,
0.4653954506,
0.4126131833,
0.0322605111,
0.6317812204,
-0.0828982145,
-0.9359426498,
0.3569329977,
0.3819225729,
1.0995564461,
0.0676138774,
0.1216505691,
0.165908426,
0.023133494,
0.2485098243,
0.4117456675,
-0.1891512573,
-0.768119216,
-0.1242183,
-0.9156684875,
-0.2842822671,
-0.1172317341,
-0.8463035226,
0.1678471565,
-0.746319592,
-0.3095370829,
-0.0497012399,
-0.0685183927,
-0.7640137672,
0.4734053314,
0.1968842745,
0.7617815137,
-0.8233229518,
0.9540558457,
0.6673744917,
-0.6451104283,
-0.8501456976,
0.1515333056,
0.017614631,
-0.5229972601,
0.742364049,
0.3526495993,
-0.282615751,
-0.1305314153,
-0.0269085243,
-0.5573004484,
0.9526907206,
-0.3374015093,
-0.5543016791,
-0.0677267462,
0.1952597052,
0.722479701,
-0.4812739193,
0.1679049581,
0.4412487447,
0.3454747498,
-0.0593242906,
-0.4949241579,
-0.1780045331,
-0.4787186086,
0.2962789834,
0.3103842735,
-0.9389856458,
1.0557477474,
0.0711619481,
0.0780830458,
0.0729496032,
0.7401378155,
0.0865264982,
0.2846703827,
0.6540542245,
0.7828631997,
0.455275774,
-0.024843514,
1.1117345095,
-0.4267393947,
0.498798281,
1.1789114475,
-0.680070281,
1.0585128069,
0.5654404759,
-0.2848463953,
1.0890119076,
0.3618775606,
-0.010510968,
0.7811312079,
-0.1451887041,
-0.5155832767,
-0.3323563039,
0.0513270274,
-0.1901692748,
0.4539872408,
0.3375230134,
-0.6005219817,
-0.2035236508,
0.2537922859,
0.0131846499,
0.237983346,
0.0535000823,
0.8684674501,
0.0976690277,
-0.7030636668,
0.1210245192,
0.0506690815,
0.901291132,
-0.6856042147,
0.2205369622,
-0.2218068689,
0.5639885664,
-0.0371445827,
-0.6660690904,
0.3352435827,
0.1479333341,
-0.4784832299,
-0.3017934263,
0.5984976292,
-0.2424841076,
-0.8031583428,
0.6937520504,
0.3045449555,
-0.3839033544,
-0.0839844942,
-0.7561100125,
0.2522780597,
0.0459677242,
-0.4356771708,
0.2399618924,
0.2866251171,
0.0583480448,
0.1893025786,
0.9373090863,
0.0659927502,
0.0476182103,
0.3050015271,
1.0869064331,
-0.6475225091,
-0.6947060823,
-0.8436646461,
0.8077109456,
-0.3926149011,
-0.2609217465,
0.9050002098,
0.6561837792,
0.6352217197,
-0.2846122086,
1.0682182312,
0.0690725446,
0.9857376218,
-0.4746323526,
0.465649873,
-0.4551190138,
0.3685258925,
-0.2772979736,
-0.7544700503,
-0.1929124296,
0.569887042,
-0.8265098929,
0.3611795604,
0.483623445,
0.7595250607,
-0.2128741294,
0.2868517935,
0.0052982518,
0.2131514698,
0.292969346,
0.5963489413,
1.1195442677,
-0.3587827682,
0.291723907,
-0.3130607903,
-0.1650321037,
-0.4440439939,
-0.6842224002,
-1.1097058058,
-0.4546445012,
-0.0552654266,
-0.3705634475,
0.0633101687,
0.8558194637,
0.7889096141,
-0.7400832176,
-0.1440045089,
-0.1487261057,
-0.13157022,
0.0133804195,
-0.3419364393,
0.3599756956,
-0.3602077365,
-0.4542862475,
0.3225832283,
0.5422968864,
-0.1302980334,
-0.3282487988,
-0.2018131316,
-0.2939614058,
0.3480812609,
0.743799448,
-0.1736198664,
-0.7936252952,
-0.1996136457,
-0.2032928914,
-0.1299203485,
-0.0593177713,
0.9267598391,
-0.8130480051,
0.3673809469,
0.3741065264,
0.5215818882,
0.6542562842,
0.0954579115,
0.4411430061,
-0.5840942264,
0.3005296588,
0.5563998222,
0.5308657289,
0.4216505885,
-0.3329501748,
0.1337059736,
0.3825405836,
-0.3029601574,
-0.7480924726,
0.1623274833,
-1.438857913,
-0.4917930365,
0.8836109042,
-0.0702039152,
-0.1515098214,
0.2214583606,
-0.1647219956,
0.2298743427,
-0.2371209115,
0.5829806328,
0.339078784,
-0.0205142535,
-0.1432594806,
-0.070152916,
0.2720024586,
0.8056479692,
-0.5765039325,
-0.1382672191,
0.3819718659,
0.2643107474,
0.0961571708,
0.4474436045,
-0.2538488507,
0.062497817,
-0.2975253463,
-0.1997215599,
0.0365618542,
-0.485732764,
-0.2288529426,
0.3190228939,
-0.1844910085,
-0.0895411745
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06556v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06556v1
|
Enhancing Presentation Slide Generation by LLMs with a Multi-Staged End-to-End Approach
| 2024-06-01T07:49:31 | 2024-06-01T07:49:31 |
Sambaran Bandyopadhyay, Himanshu Maheshwari, Anandhavelu Natarajan, Apoorv Saxena
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Generating presentation slides from a long document with multimodal elements
such as text and images is an important task. This is time consuming and needs
domain expertise if done manually. Existing approaches for generating a rich
presentation from a document are often semi-automatic or only put a flat
summary into the slides ignoring the importance of a good narrative. In this
paper, we address this research gap by proposing a multi-staged end-to-end
model which uses a combination of LLM and VLM. We have experimentally shown
that compared to applying LLMs directly with state-of-the-art prompting, our
proposed multi-staged solution is better in terms of automated metrics and
human evaluation.
|
[
-0.2688655257,
-0.6863653064,
0.4528000653,
0.1890681535,
-0.7247397304,
0.3860247731,
0.0503199846,
-0.3000349402,
0.3377391696,
0.0968565121,
-0.4137842059,
-0.3689445853,
-0.4806964695,
0.1568295658,
-0.7043153644,
0.8192794323,
-0.0972956195,
-0.0570355617,
-0.4801547527,
0.14322716,
-0.3453984261,
-0.0888480395,
-0.2228492647,
-0.5010721684,
0.3235282302,
0.452590704,
0.5690370202,
0.2857716978,
0.09289895,
0.2114333659,
-0.0252210926,
0.6394681931,
-0.2314885408,
0.3239153922,
-0.0289954357,
-0.0887238383,
-0.6466785669,
-0.064131923,
0.448489964,
0.2852168083,
0.034742251,
0.1908665746,
0.1307053417,
0.4908334911,
-0.4902564585,
-0.0451625101,
-0.3827249408,
0.3998289704,
-0.0206227265,
-0.8343098164,
-0.5692453384,
0.1242917478,
-0.0583657511,
-0.5433843136,
0.030689735,
0.0882938132,
0.5963112712,
-0.1124096736,
-0.6235812306,
-0.179159835,
-0.7901331186,
0.4784007072,
-0.578510046,
0.1566939652,
-0.1040109321,
0.3279868066,
-0.1040372327,
-1.0304527283,
-0.3513571918,
-0.4838907421,
0.2264974862,
0.6985242367,
0.0199994538,
-0.0894933119,
0.0164218917,
0.18935588,
-0.6039227843,
0.3803776801,
-0.4766235352,
-0.2516842484,
0.5941874385,
0.3824409842,
0.2208300829,
-0.3835844994,
-0.8149936199,
0.0180335697,
-0.7226279974,
-0.1570615172,
0.1760858744,
-0.052348569,
-0.1559543163,
0.6728035212,
-0.0988155678,
0.6343294978,
-0.0064239884,
-0.3907485008,
-0.1065602452,
-0.5790381432,
-0.316442728,
0.178173095,
0.5794366598,
0.946210742,
0.1867415756,
0.1157782823,
-0.3686251342,
-0.2341537178,
0.1805356443,
-0.8233337402,
0.0916372836,
0.2767246068,
-0.549918592,
-0.4878593683,
-0.191427812,
-0.8763106465,
-0.4034301043,
-0.7486435175,
0.737445116,
-0.4216617942,
0.0282492433,
-0.1856764704,
-0.240797326,
0.21082066,
0.7796634436,
-0.5021618605,
0.0335743316,
0.194456622,
0.9769868851,
-0.0837045014,
-0.2228087485,
-0.9525693655,
0.5238952637,
-0.5784593225,
0.9137108922,
-0.4408238232,
-0.7448992729,
0.306984812,
-0.3411154151,
0.3000837266,
-0.2990726829,
0.2840579152,
-0.4056887925,
0.7645457387,
0.1814934909,
-0.5631526113,
0.3807279468,
0.2763128579,
-0.3533422947,
0.9797583818,
0.0168829132,
-0.7007782459,
0.4266786873,
-0.5522856116,
-0.6742545366,
0.2835122347,
-0.5853917003,
-0.2250786126,
0.2797485888,
0.6133081317,
0.5528723001,
-0.1852970272,
0.3918492794,
0.3039886057,
-0.220794946,
0.2674054503,
-0.5022929311,
-0.2218910754,
0.3112824261,
-0.15963687,
0.5131919384,
-1.0264378786,
-0.2093440294,
0.0911960378,
-0.6498265862,
0.1733697802,
0.0316862278,
0.1938839257,
0.7346323133,
0.3632539511,
-0.0457946956,
0.0891969949,
-0.3312798142,
0.0934080482,
0.9536175728,
0.1115862429,
0.5816934705,
-0.6153210998,
0.8465736508,
0.1700426787,
0.2132269889,
-1.0390081406,
-0.593316555,
-0.5374788046,
-0.0903049931,
0.0880864933,
0.2012756616,
-1.0000225306,
-0.1615949422,
-0.2106894702,
-0.1627575755,
-0.2008926421,
0.1857257336,
0.3552981317,
0.6261329651,
0.1417960227,
-0.5712891817,
-0.3300824165,
-0.6324495673,
0.2049722522,
0.2048413306,
-0.2471916676,
0.2480235994,
0.2638182342,
0.195966363,
0.8086194396,
-0.2909753025,
-0.3689360321,
-0.2850456536,
0.4705849886,
0.2336764485,
0.0565087534,
0.4459614158,
-0.6047509909,
-0.7656685114,
0.003453101,
-0.8501635194,
0.06226217,
-0.628775537,
0.0631029531,
0.5858716965,
0.5343067646,
-0.5692225099,
0.5916594267,
0.3064778745,
-0.0475978144,
0.7816291451,
-0.8213460445,
0.2479070574,
-1.3189162016,
0.110091947,
-0.0346313342,
-0.3022634685,
-0.8286456466,
-0.1381312758,
0.0597353354,
-0.6191750765,
-0.8596099019,
0.6301859617,
-0.8357791305,
-0.4725808203,
-0.4959830046,
0.6932000518,
0.3129315674,
0.2639643848,
-0.0791731253,
0.6202259064,
0.5769574046,
-0.7022595406,
0.4570171535,
0.1943119168,
-0.1359642297,
0.7162853479,
-0.4708130062,
-0.0555064902,
-0.2618170083,
0.4768791795,
-0.9983986616,
-0.6933412552,
0.1416081637,
-0.368860364,
0.6508101821,
0.0787772238,
-0.5330314636,
-0.1716241837,
-0.8143466115,
-0.1528672129,
0.6750174761,
-0.4462567568,
0.655559659,
-0.1074568778,
-0.3764509261,
-0.3595153391,
-0.5078187585,
0.7727804184,
-0.1358207315,
-1.0250350237,
0.9284601808,
-0.21580033,
-0.1521420032,
-0.2839315236,
0.0044237562,
0.368686229,
-0.3170332313,
0.1475381851,
0.303930372,
-0.0614670403,
0.1118473336,
0.3013322353,
-0.241214633,
-0.1822186112,
-0.1297490597,
0.5490879416,
0.345603615,
-0.7020567656,
-0.5893311501,
0.7756432295,
0.684449017,
-0.1198699623,
0.5652845502,
0.823048532,
-0.3638395667,
-0.0383943543,
-0.298587501,
-0.123950094,
-0.4176187515,
0.1927127242,
-0.0359829627,
-0.4798857868,
0.4061570168,
-0.3460518122,
0.4684086442,
0.1012679189,
0.9259417057,
-0.1815917641,
0.9393202066,
0.3973321021,
0.3007732034,
0.6157363057,
-0.0653976128,
0.1869308949,
-0.6563526988,
-0.6027802825,
-0.1043701172,
-0.3301338851,
-0.0568661913,
-0.6188613772,
0.6280140281,
0.1103514209,
0.1933995038,
-0.2520043254,
-0.3236074746,
0.1881446093,
0.514193356,
0.1279890239,
0.5057359338,
0.1399575919,
-0.3162199259,
0.0821230114,
-0.5839650631,
-0.8607953191,
0.9802652001,
0.1393654495,
0.7606163025,
-0.0329534747,
0.8515980244,
0.3512965739,
0.2202998996,
-0.4527864754,
0.7725105882,
0.1962567717,
-0.3828318715,
-0.2961717844,
0.1945089549,
-0.9516566992,
0.3036246598,
-0.3741611838,
-0.6828416586,
-0.2598097622,
0.2157051563,
-0.2223403305,
0.0009708675,
-0.5790982246,
0.1811763942,
-0.3919120729,
-0.6159474254,
-0.276171267,
-0.8059570789,
0.3933333755,
-0.3060156405,
0.6850086451,
0.1256500036,
-0.1748523563,
0.5781940222,
-0.438983351,
0.7456575036,
-0.0119522335,
-0.2862243354,
0.3528754413,
0.170048967,
0.8555968404,
0.0008533282,
-0.0835694224,
-0.6447852254,
-0.5042994022,
-0.2088463008,
-0.6244532466,
0.6505509615,
-0.4281884432,
-0.7059146166,
-0.1277417243,
-0.4722537994,
0.0970577598,
-0.0020482503,
0.1783853322,
1.0033851862,
-0.1443736851,
-0.0893847868,
0.483083576,
-0.4865600169,
0.9269120097,
0.2262442261,
-0.5821902156,
-0.6255324483,
0.6803747416,
0.1831412166,
0.5645653009,
0.374440372,
0.0627675354,
-0.3851007521,
-0.7514961958,
-0.5758651495,
-0.011759148,
-0.9645635486,
-0.1398646086,
-0.502818644,
-0.1990541369,
-0.4925383627,
-0.5934199095,
-0.0363537483,
-0.5513476729,
-0.7077545524,
-0.3034934402,
0.0881620422,
0.6486666799,
-0.2809007168,
0.1001727208,
-1.0088278055,
0.4819268882,
0.5025426745,
-0.0567429028,
0.1467403173,
-0.6721946597,
-0.341180861,
-0.2787286639,
-0.7626562119,
-0.8005685806,
0.7472761869,
0.4597692788,
0.8521075845,
0.6528021693,
0.0475744791,
0.6113814712,
-0.5196603537,
1.191545248,
0.8392925262,
-0.4999216795,
0.8607023954,
-0.4681971669,
0.3702630401,
-0.2842173874,
0.3738510907,
-0.3390148282,
-0.2542889714,
-0.6426611543,
-1.2731046677,
0.4992634654,
0.248630017,
0.3492032886,
0.098247312,
-0.0561281592,
0.180897966,
0.2125867009,
-0.6574452519,
-0.0082594296,
-0.3224315643,
0.1562774479,
-0.0369642563,
-0.3405577838,
-0.4865363836,
0.2403941154,
0.3631127477,
-0.261138618,
0.1628224105,
0.241662249,
-0.2954129577,
-0.3937147856,
0.4455401897,
0.9980913997,
1.1985324621,
-0.0688183829,
0.148210451,
0.2415291667,
-0.0298635308,
0.1163916066,
-0.0992942005,
0.1335716546,
0.1970455348,
0.6235665679,
0.6687783003,
0.4631227553,
-0.6857488155,
0.4541662037,
0.1725356579,
-0.4668613076,
-0.0334842317,
-0.2481993735,
0.1766128093,
0.1730091721,
0.7699025273,
-0.2744079828,
-0.1445817947,
-0.6294733286,
0.5020222068,
0.1215940043,
-0.2943160832,
-0.1656993479,
0.8539305925,
0.5853068233,
-0.6937490106,
0.3045488298,
0.0469723828,
-0.1026166975,
0.413713187,
0.6503925323,
0.4409039617,
-0.0401095934,
0.4171932936,
0.0944601372,
0.101058647,
0.3233977854,
0.1725131571,
-0.0526884831,
-0.0369913131,
-0.745448947,
-0.4901012778,
-0.5843118429,
-0.0460919812,
-0.399941355,
0.5635458827,
-0.2463123649,
-0.110998258,
-0.3097053468,
-0.2556025088,
-0.1753884703,
0.2876685858,
0.5421710014,
1.0559664965,
-0.6913859844,
0.3648412824,
0.5287479162,
-0.4363835156,
-0.3661461174,
-0.2741058767,
0.0977558866,
-0.6453416944,
0.5087041259,
0.1174494326,
0.1906202734,
-0.153422609,
-0.3183600008,
-0.4244437516,
1.4937283993,
0.1204604656,
-0.6183655262,
-0.1483369023,
0.0715363473,
0.54544276,
-0.4651743472,
0.3143312037,
-0.1327344775,
0.291580528,
0.7331832647,
-0.8387218714,
-0.1075718477,
-0.0540209115,
0.0770406052,
-0.0114855208,
-0.4993685782,
0.5526421666,
-0.355252713,
-0.1767319441,
-0.2860735059,
0.8543781638,
0.6677330732,
0.6906468868,
0.2745144069,
0.069787994,
0.4760072827,
0.4417307973,
0.9848980308,
-0.478064239,
0.0123547474,
1.2109344006,
-0.4455203116,
0.4913634658,
0.5262774825,
-0.0499704815,
-0.0439605303,
0.7896591425,
0.1653753966,
0.625600934,
0.1070917472,
-0.4769082665,
-0.4236609638,
-0.2640435994,
-0.5218046308,
0.1569285691,
0.2796022892,
-0.5067924857,
-0.6798869967,
0.1295233369,
0.0112923374,
0.1344794333,
-0.2849147022,
0.5305591822,
0.390828371,
-0.5800483823,
0.1804547161,
-0.0592996664,
0.5953446627,
-0.5762565732,
0.0425436087,
-0.2376305014,
-0.4298822284,
-0.2714416087,
-0.9588484168,
0.0834522322,
0.1074611768,
0.1046694741,
-0.7143558264,
1.0874265432,
-0.248594895,
-0.3523198962,
0.1922415644,
0.6420856118,
0.190495804,
0.2687422335,
-0.5182506442,
-0.222563982,
-0.1593061239,
-0.6247184277,
0.8388450146,
0.5392328501,
-0.081367828,
0.7249727845,
0.7488781214,
-0.3324197829,
0.2597050667,
0.6071581244,
1.0914170742,
-0.3981550932,
-0.3087623715,
-0.8775072694,
1.0816756487,
-0.180237025,
-0.0860344097,
0.6212345362,
0.6592366695,
0.2549407184,
-0.060271617,
0.6259082556,
0.1955178529,
0.0074704285,
-0.7072957158,
0.5812945366,
-0.6906175017,
0.1784927547,
-0.4514272511,
-0.7687044144,
-0.264534384,
0.0820080489,
0.3517418206,
-0.063480176,
0.519480288,
0.7675117254,
0.0302986354,
-0.2901834548,
0.8391920328,
-0.2084791064,
0.6108967662,
0.3183238804,
1.1197024584,
-0.0783488303,
0.7635558248,
0.0960874707,
-0.3117901385,
-0.5452064872,
-1.3673677444,
-0.8386952281,
-0.5850173235,
-0.4696232975,
-0.219365418,
-0.0743940845,
0.7459751368,
0.5087510943,
0.0166785661,
-0.1095846891,
0.4645601213,
-0.206296593,
0.115794532,
-0.1290205419,
0.3271091282,
-0.2575043142,
-0.4963171482,
0.5496900082,
0.8478233218,
0.3917009532,
-0.5611408353,
-0.1502751559,
-0.2529450655,
0.3012755811,
0.9641410708,
-0.1386392266,
-0.3038970232,
-0.0235626493,
-0.1055051237,
0.0775047988,
0.2593589723,
0.5298833251,
-0.7512074709,
0.4319510162,
0.4708198309,
0.0052093589,
0.7689502835,
-0.081959717,
0.7462218404,
-0.8794225454,
-0.0787579194,
-0.002928152,
0.444354564,
0.265576005,
-0.284474194,
0.3318724334,
0.0292344205,
-0.3727278411,
-0.6875442266,
0.2322892994,
-1.2236466408,
-0.3092215657,
1.0171743631,
0.0078580882,
-0.0080833752,
-0.0709814206,
-0.3925821185,
0.344034344,
-0.2705415189,
0.9044638872,
0.5723002553,
-0.3949660361,
-0.2178539336,
-0.2878847718,
-0.0486283004,
-0.1428833306,
-1.0182299614,
-0.3499163985,
0.5461223125,
0.0171156898,
0.1854464859,
0.9033287764,
-0.2715770304,
0.3595458567,
-0.0972029418,
-0.2184881121,
-0.4513691962,
-0.5406494141,
-0.1778474748,
0.4507999122,
-0.0996733159,
0.0307790656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00343v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00343v2
|
Beyond Metrics: Evaluating LLMs' Effectiveness in Culturally Nuanced, Low-Resource Real-World Scenarios
| 2024-06-01T07:36:59 | 2024-06-13T17:53:45 |
Millicent Ochieng, Varun Gumma, Sunayana Sitaram, Jindong Wang, Vishrav Chaudhary, Keshet Ronen, Kalika Bali, Jacki O'Neill
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The deployment of Large Language Models (LLMs) in real-world applications
presents both opportunities and challenges, particularly in multilingual and
code-mixed communication settings. This research evaluates the performance of
seven leading LLMs in sentiment analysis on a dataset derived from multilingual
and code-mixed WhatsApp chats, including Swahili, English and Sheng. Our
evaluation includes both quantitative analysis using metrics like F1 score and
qualitative assessment of LLMs' explanations for their predictions. We find
that, while Mistral-7b and Mixtral-8x7b achieved high F1 scores, they and other
LLMs such as GPT-3.5-Turbo, Llama-2-70b, and Gemma-7b struggled with
understanding linguistic and contextual nuances, as well as lack of
transparency in their decision-making process as observed from their
explanations. In contrast, GPT-4 and GPT-4-Turbo excelled in grasping diverse
linguistic inputs and managing various contextual information, demonstrating
high consistency with human alignment and transparency in their decision-making
process. The LLMs however, encountered difficulties in incorporating cultural
nuance especially in non-English settings with GPT-4s doing so inconsistently.
The findings emphasize the necessity of continuous improvement of LLMs to
effectively tackle the challenges of culturally nuanced, low-resource
real-world settings and the need for developing evaluation benchmarks for
capturing these issues.
|
[
-0.4609690607,
-0.4338495731,
0.4200284481,
0.7178051472,
-0.2016626447,
0.6773776412,
-0.6359409094,
-0.5388512015,
0.0637822524,
0.0451596417,
-0.4353818595,
-0.628046751,
-0.6163412929,
0.2452329248,
-0.1076578349,
0.9925928116,
-0.0311212875,
0.3031103611,
0.0164382756,
-0.3618583679,
-0.5804525614,
-0.6843209863,
-0.3428804278,
-0.3584648371,
0.4722962081,
0.5824743509,
0.7599488497,
0.0420073122,
0.7539584637,
0.2293667197,
-0.4078743756,
0.3408144712,
-0.6693817377,
-0.0028097029,
-0.0037138837,
-0.4923025966,
-0.4045517445,
0.111650221,
0.6445524096,
0.6669635773,
-0.1951926053,
0.3807471693,
0.2907234132,
0.5223289132,
-0.5996788144,
0.2022581697,
-0.4658354819,
0.2721958756,
0.1196448579,
0.074214302,
-0.1317697614,
-0.5747246146,
0.030493075,
-0.2672057748,
-0.4495005906,
-0.2372283489,
0.6554346085,
0.0197509453,
-0.4716268778,
-0.3199625015,
-0.7248957753,
1.0624228716,
-0.8769288063,
0.3496079445,
0.1592710316,
0.235745281,
-0.0848708227,
-0.2229453027,
-0.3707331717,
-0.1881961375,
0.1791623235,
0.3431373537,
0.1529598832,
-0.2670167983,
0.1913615614,
0.3401890695,
-0.4266976416,
0.3515554667,
-0.3196055591,
-0.2169947624,
0.6778678298,
0.357467562,
-0.0981931686,
-0.1636530459,
-0.2639559507,
0.1841568202,
-0.6029810309,
0.0343939848,
0.0621341616,
0.2573177814,
-0.691241622,
0.3583714366,
-0.1717411876,
0.3335979581,
-0.168568477,
-0.4500750005,
0.5158891082,
-0.4675810635,
-0.110953927,
-0.191784218,
0.9140555859,
0.5259855986,
0.5343740582,
-0.0303297341,
-0.1981996894,
0.2890414596,
-0.117108956,
-0.7949272394,
0.2443679273,
0.1978268921,
-0.4901994169,
-0.2670626938,
-0.1838806272,
-0.7110517025,
-0.5382959843,
-0.1836624295,
-0.0751923695,
-0.331300348,
-0.692193985,
-0.0128529472,
-0.0428278558,
0.5440963507,
0.3203082681,
-0.4964994788,
0.0203483403,
0.7082800269,
1.1348534822,
-0.1286444813,
-0.1521440893,
0.0976749137,
-0.334251672,
-0.5418533087,
0.4026971459,
-0.5472713113,
-0.7392877936,
0.1876975894,
-0.4152219892,
0.0756140202,
-0.6453275084,
0.7041688561,
-0.3552670777,
0.0318523757,
-0.5106987357,
-0.3034879267,
-0.0725775957,
0.7334790826,
-0.3753489256,
1.0848805904,
-0.0361557975,
-0.6009409428,
0.5245780349,
-0.5972922444,
-0.2937994301,
0.2131622434,
-0.2480147034,
-0.0957341418,
0.2603412867,
0.0059007551,
0.5583564043,
-0.3997164071,
0.2576698661,
-0.4045697153,
-0.7092605829,
0.5562323332,
-0.5892550349,
0.4382844567,
0.2944123745,
-0.4358032048,
-0.1514855474,
-0.7548001409,
0.2713076174,
0.1813097149,
-0.4582213461,
-0.0671167895,
0.0056349393,
0.1299362183,
0.6028635502,
0.2582879364,
-0.5331929326,
-0.0442941114,
-0.3151521683,
0.4703846574,
0.4940002263,
-0.232293278,
0.3693136275,
-0.0988580287,
0.8514222503,
0.0550620295,
0.3866683841,
-0.0162185226,
-0.4195492566,
-0.6328521371,
-0.2590562105,
0.0763505697,
0.6377617717,
-0.7088485956,
0.1474377662,
-0.6083534956,
-0.7075731754,
-0.5657913089,
0.3718790412,
0.4944729805,
0.1864665449,
-0.0815184638,
-0.2588990331,
-0.3313613236,
-0.7292466164,
-0.205103904,
-0.3044732213,
0.197214663,
0.2715370059,
0.3834704161,
-0.2759754956,
0.7870516777,
-0.1295244247,
-0.0261874329,
-0.4185321331,
0.0337524451,
0.3739452064,
0.0412933156,
0.3206992149,
-0.7506223321,
-0.476845324,
0.1653867662,
-0.9671514034,
-0.0730641857,
0.1371755153,
0.2026649117,
0.3360375762,
0.1878219247,
-0.4223542809,
0.0365801901,
0.9716801643,
-0.1645285636,
0.6791875362,
0.0310902782,
0.4103918374,
-0.8267950416,
-0.1647723615,
0.3530883193,
-0.1339278817,
-0.471213311,
-0.0454484597,
-0.0678909868,
-0.1110097021,
-0.7082884908,
0.4038690627,
-0.4162041843,
-0.2151405066,
-0.0349196382,
0.4264119864,
-0.0337265171,
0.3168155253,
-0.0446033664,
0.8857452273,
0.3353634179,
-0.3383499086,
0.3542296886,
0.0547957234,
-0.7419105172,
0.7126301527,
-0.3991012871,
-0.083842881,
-0.0214566533,
0.2647204697,
-0.9820945263,
0.0604059882,
0.0062746331,
-0.4000298679,
-0.1065929383,
-0.0555417761,
-0.676435113,
-0.2950303555,
-0.4420257509,
0.4317039549,
0.5436673164,
-0.2040348351,
0.3772364557,
0.3079338372,
-0.1196417734,
-0.534383595,
-0.8567323089,
0.491863668,
-0.5683684349,
-0.5546455979,
-0.14319323,
0.0552973151,
-0.6182691455,
-0.4108490646,
0.0290935691,
0.0142480284,
0.291995734,
0.188303113,
0.2268674374,
-0.4065181911,
-0.0004737714,
-0.2376522124,
-0.0076539465,
0.1264819652,
0.0917446166,
0.4654738009,
-0.5644410253,
-0.2718739808,
-0.3693536818,
0.2269613296,
0.6938592792,
-0.2515999377,
0.9152529836,
0.8919885159,
-0.1282589287,
-0.0343641452,
-0.7461224794,
0.1167462617,
-0.4458257556,
0.4883131981,
-0.4822198749,
-1.0229660273,
0.7582944632,
-0.2536415756,
0.13731803,
0.049504634,
0.7287463546,
-0.273439616,
1.0216084719,
0.4524006546,
-0.2363609374,
0.464544028,
-0.2778294981,
0.4160712957,
-0.7964299321,
-0.3638206124,
-0.2191646248,
-0.2859899402,
-0.8840543628,
-0.5201058984,
0.5874194503,
0.0464069545,
-0.2489254326,
-0.085905239,
-0.1540041566,
0.3813625872,
0.0273672547,
-0.1648775935,
0.3590101898,
-0.0480683558,
-0.0565815195,
-0.1869253814,
-0.7691087723,
-0.9014900327,
0.7659855485,
0.531088233,
0.8532125354,
0.3026145101,
0.487334013,
0.3017147481,
0.6540602446,
-0.8921820521,
0.5082403421,
0.0375989117,
-0.3828257024,
-0.1330822408,
-0.5285737514,
-0.5521671772,
0.7831911445,
-0.2246862501,
-0.6803415418,
-0.0785497576,
-0.033863876,
-0.1566986293,
0.0405534953,
-0.7170736194,
0.7134296298,
-0.4471375644,
-0.2278514206,
-0.3109064996,
-0.4040568471,
0.5184208751,
-0.2580092251,
0.7808754444,
-0.425447762,
-0.1654682159,
0.5399025083,
-0.0564234965,
1.0915728807,
-0.0792821348,
-0.553304255,
0.198974669,
0.1487598866,
0.2371527404,
-0.0111453328,
-0.5352301002,
0.6413126588,
0.1169755533,
-0.3436577916,
-0.6278048158,
0.8186553717,
-0.7210021615,
-0.3999423683,
-0.2113796026,
-0.3314861059,
-0.5694693327,
-0.2618394196,
0.0434776396,
0.3088138998,
-0.3726308644,
0.1844006777,
0.2826817036,
-0.4226388931,
0.5279584527,
0.62171489,
-0.1100342348,
-0.3315513134,
0.7817881107,
0.2207049429,
0.4884065688,
0.0690703318,
0.2122647017,
-0.3433727324,
-0.3212133348,
-0.5609410405,
0.2455607206,
-0.8451909423,
-0.1064047739,
-0.263649255,
-0.0630674139,
-0.2327452749,
-0.1995122731,
-0.3327528238,
-0.1903708726,
0.0641734526,
-0.1774966866,
0.1788622886,
0.6778273582,
0.1444599479,
0.4253604114,
-0.9334352016,
-0.1254810095,
-0.3606552184,
0.4924907684,
0.2270208448,
-0.667093575,
-0.6133796573,
0.1791333556,
-0.2549842298,
-0.7000368237,
0.2941703796,
0.1291929334,
0.4057795703,
0.2073909044,
-0.2905036807,
0.9618579745,
-0.3564104438,
0.9253876805,
0.1341502219,
-0.9735028148,
0.2181511074,
-0.3969313204,
0.3938933909,
0.557664752,
0.3770219088,
-0.7926461101,
-0.5936468244,
-0.2872557342,
-0.7326697707,
0.5208547711,
0.0770506412,
0.5599954724,
-0.0644067451,
0.2905402184,
-0.0646040365,
0.354819417,
-0.9240705371,
-0.1346287727,
-0.0056572687,
-0.2747621834,
-0.0757600442,
-0.3820144832,
0.0342672355,
-0.0512655601,
0.4012426436,
-0.0589078963,
-0.0720395073,
-0.1377352178,
-0.2047523856,
0.2178772539,
0.4849116802,
0.4839803278,
0.8590154052,
0.018044902,
-0.1846872717,
0.4097022116,
-0.2009775788,
0.1899420321,
-0.4643059969,
0.2860578001,
-0.1848745793,
0.6313949823,
0.5940136313,
0.3164207041,
-0.8446419835,
0.5541306734,
-0.0530839711,
0.0562577695,
-0.2924213409,
-0.0591513105,
0.1118935123,
0.2556583583,
0.1722368151,
-0.4395978153,
-0.0093264375,
-0.6747123599,
-0.2596927881,
0.5043744445,
-0.5634224415,
-0.2182394266,
0.051712282,
0.4684081972,
-0.0625787973,
0.5043477416,
-0.1898000836,
-0.4829480052,
0.5721164346,
0.4419008493,
0.510186851,
-0.1848729104,
0.42411533,
0.0352501646,
0.3982229829,
-0.1069952026,
0.4074341059,
0.0012714306,
-1.0810497999,
-0.7286252379,
-0.6058138013,
-0.5008270144,
-0.1517644227,
-0.7184173465,
0.1584229618,
-0.4846099913,
-0.5300436616,
-0.249308303,
-0.0327674411,
-0.7924571037,
0.2996170819,
0.4072199762,
0.8647038341,
-0.9771024585,
0.4788220525,
0.7347448468,
-0.2633333206,
-0.7439789176,
-0.1051931679,
0.1428391784,
-0.9498670101,
0.7557564378,
0.1573493034,
-0.1989095509,
-0.3684812784,
-0.1474586874,
-0.7470508814,
0.8969647884,
0.2757999003,
-0.5777930021,
0.34609887,
0.3251496851,
0.923397243,
-0.248131156,
0.6023749113,
0.7149290442,
0.5232639909,
0.0713639185,
-1.1963202953,
-0.0995511636,
-0.1765806079,
0.0916905031,
0.1478450447,
-1.0718505383,
0.3770200014,
-0.105904676,
-0.1171854585,
-0.1163484603,
0.4681271613,
0.3359029293,
0.0959693044,
0.374286443,
0.1547944844,
0.5602591038,
-0.1543343961,
1.1238001585,
-0.3915945292,
0.2591101527,
0.7028157711,
-0.7265949249,
0.8735824823,
0.3597113192,
-0.3343629241,
0.6021435857,
0.5722903013,
0.0665244609,
0.1892543137,
0.3517563641,
-0.2958647013,
-0.1507983357,
-0.4388706088,
-0.1030059755,
0.6954911351,
0.5918417573,
-0.0355837867,
-0.0626026988,
0.0687861517,
0.2395521253,
0.0600729436,
-0.3154454827,
0.7363241911,
0.4155303538,
-0.5128605366,
0.8046544194,
0.2068251073,
0.9965230823,
-0.4428934753,
0.072647512,
-0.4156627655,
0.0458854325,
-0.4833049774,
-0.9774646163,
0.2702203393,
0.3559671342,
-0.0075128423,
-0.1841010451,
0.2284544408,
-0.2433380783,
-0.7016597986,
0.5717734694,
0.6893246174,
0.2618952692,
0.0965628549,
-0.8255284429,
0.5909153819,
-0.1027840972,
-0.2382627577,
0.2149316221,
0.6218860745,
-0.2694157362,
0.9204269648,
0.3775237799,
0.4472615123,
-0.1787340343,
0.5677940845,
0.5351297259,
-0.7678586245,
-0.3128897548,
-1.092815876,
0.4697811902,
0.0077109248,
-0.3838244081,
0.9178167582,
0.4781514108,
0.80833143,
0.2796908915,
0.8156632781,
0.1407485455,
0.1891209781,
-0.3570275009,
0.3580710292,
-0.4298628569,
0.4725904763,
-0.3351565301,
-0.9743067026,
-0.1458168179,
0.5896956921,
-0.5136108994,
0.2345665693,
0.4558880329,
0.6364945173,
0.1927443892,
-0.0068481648,
0.5073956847,
0.1841633171,
0.4002527595,
0.4195733964,
1.2741059065,
-0.0942046791,
0.5052300692,
0.1101897657,
-0.2688719928,
0.0483246446,
-0.9317524433,
-0.8154595494,
-0.1209167466,
-0.2052662224,
-0.2561213076,
-0.1232308298,
0.9298663735,
0.6102364659,
-0.5123446584,
-0.5328392982,
0.5693685412,
0.0590859726,
0.0515694395,
-0.3014249802,
-0.05798769,
-0.3561969995,
-0.5699524879,
0.1699574292,
0.4962180257,
-0.1245580912,
-0.6003813744,
-0.101501599,
0.2223358899,
0.0666773692,
0.9842067957,
-0.1437285542,
-0.8273912668,
-0.0572653674,
-0.1244853362,
-0.2188635767,
0.1084397882,
0.7834266424,
-0.552644074,
-0.0339123011,
0.1417706609,
0.5534962416,
0.2234352082,
0.0236346945,
0.5902020931,
-0.6531363726,
0.2249730676,
0.2091854215,
0.3465943038,
0.7657499909,
-0.1363479346,
0.4756546617,
-0.0481604375,
-0.3185980022,
-0.8348789811,
0.0838483647,
-0.7215992808,
-0.026544448,
1.5867784023,
-0.2905602753,
0.1556627005,
-0.0976019055,
-0.0159771666,
-0.0838382095,
-0.3895530999,
0.7344982028,
0.9389508963,
0.0428205207,
-0.0636565983,
-0.6048348546,
0.1976221055,
0.5355483294,
-0.686014235,
0.0514333434,
0.4343716502,
0.3524801731,
0.0496788546,
0.7372947335,
-0.3809880614,
-0.1316905618,
-0.3607571423,
-0.0386056639,
0.3019086421,
0.0612608641,
-0.5345419049,
-0.1201479957,
0.4300421476,
0.0664080083
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06555v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06555v1
|
An Evaluation Benchmark for Autoformalization in Lean4
| 2024-06-01T07:06:57 | 2024-06-01T07:06:57 |
Aryan Gulati, Devanshu Ladsaria, Shubhra Mishra, Jasdeep Sidhu, Brando Miranda
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.PL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) hold the potential to revolutionize
autoformalization. The introduction of Lean4, a mathematical programming
language, presents an unprecedented opportunity to rigorously assess the
autoformalization capabilities of LLMs. This paper introduces a novel
evaluation benchmark designed for Lean4, applying it to test the abilities of
state-of-the-art LLMs, including GPT-3.5, GPT-4, and Gemini Pro. Our
comprehensive analysis reveals that, despite recent advancements, these LLMs
still exhibit limitations in autoformalization, particularly in more complex
areas of mathematics. These findings underscore the need for further
development in LLMs to fully harness their potential in scientific research and
development. This study not only benchmarks current LLM capabilities but also
sets the stage for future enhancements in autoformalization.
|
[
-0.1957384944,
-0.2668386102,
0.6231663823,
0.479847014,
-0.0382007211,
0.2621312737,
-0.3764805794,
-0.4702479541,
-0.3012952805,
0.0042338399,
-0.524843514,
-0.4720891714,
-0.6641568542,
0.3675042987,
-0.5291635394,
0.8663434386,
-0.5640195608,
0.2682805657,
-0.4328305423,
-0.1426955312,
-0.2342381626,
-0.3815530539,
-0.2625531256,
-0.2108132541,
0.1179065034,
0.0286268964,
0.8586156368,
0.8026769161,
0.7961040139,
0.4556690156,
0.6230923533,
-0.4749382436,
-0.4743815362,
0.3352589309,
0.3661955297,
-0.3794888258,
-0.6074897051,
0.2302500606,
1.0684065819,
0.6508283019,
-0.1383599043,
0.2909381986,
-0.1973005384,
0.5130774975,
-0.6491929889,
0.5279422402,
-0.5940880179,
0.1510853022,
-0.2963758707,
0.3479395807,
0.2353459895,
-0.8988679647,
-0.1403046697,
-0.4727419019,
-0.102657631,
-0.216348961,
0.8114065528,
0.7340637445,
-0.0867466927,
-0.2569091916,
-0.7024180889,
0.7775284648,
-0.9662735462,
0.7228161097,
-0.076301381,
0.5858673453,
-0.1065783501,
-1.0207268,
-0.5031904578,
-0.2621442676,
0.4350433052,
0.0332110748,
-0.1199226454,
-0.0568583645,
0.415173322,
0.6361046433,
-0.5655705929,
0.3102424741,
-0.4627681971,
-0.3489410281,
0.5761207342,
0.2436125278,
0.1889461875,
0.1233693585,
-0.1889095455,
0.0361383744,
-0.5956651568,
-0.0848513693,
0.3611688018,
-0.1753899753,
0.0113612972,
0.5524837971,
-0.2354522645,
0.5557121634,
-0.1303011328,
-0.0806196034,
0.5399612188,
-0.3378276527,
-0.4812573195,
-0.3433157802,
0.9941326976,
0.1417381912,
0.1687157899,
-0.1485623419,
-0.5275840759,
0.2674776316,
0.0667260215,
-1.030833602,
-0.3277648687,
-0.0603694953,
-0.4129133821,
-0.245254457,
-0.1163622737,
-0.4730102718,
-0.1423815638,
-0.2787448466,
0.3582736254,
-0.3432850838,
-0.0934357196,
-0.0186711531,
0.1607004404,
0.6949474812,
0.2752972841,
-0.9903306365,
0.6385909319,
0.9952260852,
0.6918230057,
-0.452074796,
-0.3529186845,
-0.466075182,
-0.040088769,
-0.5387016535,
0.658195436,
-0.4839337766,
-0.1505274773,
-0.0669225603,
-0.3314550519,
0.2132714838,
-0.8006551266,
0.6880195141,
-0.3557085693,
0.0557408817,
-0.1383427382,
-0.5724259615,
0.1514079422,
0.2381113917,
-0.7386761308,
1.2952214479,
0.4195284247,
-0.1797830462,
0.598359406,
-0.5346980691,
-0.3320312202,
0.3016836047,
-0.7420130968,
-0.6530581117,
0.1790195405,
-0.0301920064,
0.2783444226,
-0.6425869465,
0.3457716703,
-0.6890452504,
-0.4340749383,
0.279116869,
-0.5983019471,
0.352439791,
0.2137602568,
-0.6615332365,
0.0420185514,
-0.7071982026,
0.5611026287,
-0.1249147654,
-0.3645763993,
0.0660620481,
-0.1539886296,
-0.3376624584,
0.4279395938,
0.6826585531,
-0.3827075362,
0.2304472774,
-0.4174111187,
0.5118626356,
0.7872768044,
-0.5427939892,
0.268643707,
-0.0014657028,
0.8074285984,
-0.2413295805,
0.2989818156,
-0.0456145518,
-0.3486890495,
-1.011374712,
-0.4390843809,
0.3173538744,
0.2526339889,
-0.3915477395,
0.387522459,
-0.0739555731,
-0.4073190391,
-0.5438290834,
0.4832127392,
0.399795115,
0.1207883954,
0.3674995303,
-0.1769186705,
-0.5871620178,
-1.1813818216,
-0.463465035,
-0.0562284477,
-0.2262741178,
-0.0659503862,
0.3934694827,
-0.4060679078,
0.9065024853,
-0.3587761223,
0.0215988383,
-0.0155072818,
0.326340884,
0.3585045338,
0.3072815835,
0.5617026091,
-0.4127534032,
-0.5245290399,
-0.3968122303,
-0.7201554179,
-0.3977313936,
0.2106477469,
0.051817026,
0.2009520382,
0.6144955158,
-0.4123878181,
0.2396971285,
0.8531852365,
-0.0962796584,
0.6474547386,
-0.1607324183,
-0.0627293363,
-0.5061298609,
0.0197595935,
-0.1078747138,
-0.2007039338,
-0.205598861,
-0.3398694098,
0.3800652325,
-0.2194513828,
0.0693268403,
0.2404791564,
-0.8369902968,
-0.7701621056,
0.041686032,
-0.0373273492,
-0.18932347,
-0.0530872792,
-0.1410610229,
0.7291795611,
0.6532686949,
-0.3622857928,
0.527202487,
-0.1876278371,
-0.4902415574,
0.5128305554,
-0.8528752327,
-0.0264196452,
0.1373662204,
0.2279322743,
-0.9234702587,
-0.098405242,
-0.1483661681,
-0.1889678687,
0.269069761,
0.0421505012,
-0.4958403707,
-0.5628513694,
-0.4043487012,
0.5682268739,
0.5464842319,
-0.2635624707,
0.5139781237,
0.2588650286,
-0.2918871939,
-0.4716729522,
-0.4003716409,
0.2345491648,
-0.2532091141,
-0.6483437419,
0.2709297836,
-0.5052015781,
-0.2698701024,
-0.1687945724,
-0.3408673108,
-0.0849625543,
0.0821979865,
0.0694370344,
0.4212639332,
-0.3373892605,
-0.1783615947,
-0.1718664765,
-0.208733961,
0.4064985812,
-0.5027599335,
0.3713244796,
-0.6117155552,
-0.3693966269,
-0.3373758495,
-0.10917411,
0.674223423,
-0.2981686592,
0.07145717,
0.656522572,
-0.4130168259,
-0.3427317739,
-0.6375766397,
0.0534510352,
-0.5974164009,
0.5223830938,
-0.4892234206,
-0.7398964167,
0.357424587,
-0.3175146878,
0.2323878109,
0.588550806,
0.7771988511,
0.2054785043,
0.9645220041,
0.5709004998,
-0.0991637185,
0.2101491541,
-0.1791107804,
0.2667645514,
-0.6614589691,
-0.3149853349,
-0.6890851259,
-0.1850327998,
-0.6666921973,
-0.8485064507,
0.510211587,
-0.0896616653,
-0.3793792725,
0.2381810844,
-0.2527772486,
0.3786907792,
-0.024086846,
-0.6748855114,
0.4217035174,
-0.3919346631,
-0.5175655484,
-0.3626649976,
-0.5782489181,
-0.4099260867,
1.0898213387,
0.6942999363,
1.0084798336,
0.1661607921,
0.6646106243,
0.181587711,
0.8792464733,
-0.8926529884,
0.4456553757,
-0.0522887819,
-0.3798018396,
-0.4719882607,
-0.5742284656,
-0.6006744504,
0.2069806904,
-0.0556134842,
-0.2331023514,
-0.0627642348,
0.0175965317,
-0.1564875394,
-0.1554134041,
-0.4935785234,
0.9888871908,
-0.7681953907,
-0.1791607738,
0.0939491317,
-0.1428890526,
0.4107398689,
-0.3749639094,
0.4054045081,
-0.371758759,
-0.5204470754,
0.6671509147,
-0.5444923043,
0.5692389607,
-0.0072755055,
-0.5033173561,
-0.0871590525,
0.0260935612,
0.3431842923,
0.1377571523,
-0.2163214087,
0.2173888832,
-0.1325469613,
-0.1927594841,
-0.7410262227,
1.1213955879,
-0.8962817192,
-0.2508831322,
-0.6000857353,
-0.4281545579,
-0.6414529085,
0.4371301532,
-0.0574184395,
0.3564543426,
-0.4120154679,
0.0335735045,
0.4382269681,
-0.0882849097,
0.6744681597,
0.6777490973,
-0.1701265424,
-0.6965950727,
0.6302874088,
-0.0145750474,
0.222246021,
0.0002968627,
0.1315894574,
-0.7062397599,
-0.8704130054,
-0.4583326876,
0.3910509646,
-0.8657728434,
-0.3102568686,
-0.3191628754,
-0.1384167075,
-0.5971525311,
-0.0462685674,
-0.8523917794,
-0.5281143188,
0.0982875898,
0.1107887775,
-0.0805240199,
1.1720249653,
0.0730000734,
-0.2778979242,
-0.5147749186,
0.2244076878,
0.295866698,
0.9576784968,
-0.3206928372,
-0.3762186766,
-0.3380853534,
-0.4580698311,
-0.3759947717,
-0.3902741969,
0.1441804618,
0.2938354015,
0.9342560768,
0.3920652568,
-0.1628477275,
0.7777653337,
-0.691572547,
0.5252242088,
0.3569546938,
-1.2247260809,
0.119133316,
-0.3853460252,
0.4943184853,
0.6170273423,
0.5734869242,
-0.3253676295,
-0.3237116635,
-0.5364355445,
-0.8074468374,
0.1707135141,
0.2682654858,
-0.0968600065,
0.2100060284,
0.4465961754,
0.1229353696,
0.4584494233,
-0.8049951196,
-0.0622573346,
-0.4000682831,
-0.3507981896,
-0.1541465223,
-0.0776209831,
0.0841788128,
-0.1918060482,
0.4294359982,
-0.1861267686,
0.2003473192,
-0.2141983658,
-0.0133938473,
-0.1357689649,
0.0699309036,
0.3413994312,
0.9288719296,
0.1427247524,
-0.01564027,
0.2512814105,
-0.5062093139,
0.0335395485,
0.4059939981,
0.0195982289,
-0.1564654559,
0.3832569122,
0.6016676426,
0.5551037192,
-0.5647236705,
0.4422865808,
-0.1316899657,
-0.2630555034,
-0.6121852994,
0.2005966902,
-0.0342266597,
0.0975304693,
0.4123554528,
-0.2312996686,
0.2921868861,
-0.656046629,
0.2254783809,
0.5609431267,
-0.2668606043,
-0.3901785314,
0.7667643428,
0.285110563,
-0.0137702851,
0.4531438053,
-0.0082824826,
-0.6258125901,
0.5433279276,
0.5049878359,
0.9945284724,
-0.3993187249,
-0.136557281,
0.4923411012,
0.4298529923,
-0.0694161505,
0.3777569532,
-0.0184773579,
-0.4625488222,
-0.5914177299,
-0.9276643991,
-0.4311312735,
0.269624263,
-0.4639589787,
0.4961945117,
-0.6420738697,
-0.1782406271,
0.0918800533,
0.1172064692,
-0.7006428838,
0.2241357118,
0.3148626089,
0.7952690125,
-0.4977959991,
0.7717882395,
0.6068171263,
0.0221201349,
-0.7861825228,
0.0947204083,
0.0458178446,
-0.793315351,
0.8587585092,
0.0993940979,
-0.3900354803,
-0.1509539038,
-0.4343190193,
-1.1903514862,
1.2030584812,
0.3946010172,
-0.700332582,
-0.0256324336,
0.4078297317,
0.5835017562,
-0.4891385734,
0.6012642384,
0.7934904695,
0.7529308796,
0.0671770424,
-1.2341663837,
0.1212458313,
-0.311206758,
0.2827038765,
0.2506867647,
-0.7033138275,
0.9357710481,
-0.214835763,
-0.0244716909,
0.1778404415,
0.8866231441,
0.1604071856,
-0.0821970403,
0.4200730026,
0.4197543561,
0.7615353465,
-0.2656313777,
0.8178791404,
-0.3820351064,
0.2899222076,
0.999073267,
-0.5981279612,
0.6554365754,
0.1584329903,
-0.3590527177,
0.6053142548,
0.3522648513,
-0.245745942,
0.0885138512,
0.6560837626,
-0.200068593,
-0.1987580359,
0.5560872555,
-0.3933767974,
0.7061241865,
0.4498244226,
-0.1076670364,
-0.2144566625,
-0.3333749473,
0.2090895474,
-0.0534964427,
-0.2049710751,
0.4859527647,
0.0285732765,
-0.7986513376,
0.9337369204,
0.1963733435,
0.5630972981,
-0.7859164476,
0.0271480605,
-0.1338730901,
0.3822561204,
-0.2144857794,
-0.5204030275,
0.3098115027,
0.08187484,
0.1541005224,
-0.3162583113,
0.4119677246,
-0.2831905782,
-0.5373555422,
0.1921097338,
0.1993831098,
0.1781077236,
0.2945259213,
-0.9182728529,
0.6198121905,
-0.25500229,
-0.0540465787,
0.1869196743,
0.6613327265,
-0.1385540217,
0.8578631878,
0.5806551576,
0.1084070876,
0.1205328107,
0.2823503017,
1.1545159817,
-0.7772507668,
-0.4578897655,
-0.8047952056,
0.0963377804,
0.0041320873,
-0.3402127922,
1.1477671862,
1.0913636684,
0.6013284326,
0.105331026,
1.0422763824,
-0.0382471681,
0.2157080919,
-0.4935579598,
0.5127213597,
-0.2376515567,
0.4112162888,
-0.5774173737,
-1.0700042248,
-0.2150157094,
0.6843422651,
-0.5597135425,
0.5086035132,
0.9318658113,
0.3044382036,
-0.01713668,
-0.1233452484,
0.4309712648,
0.5662966967,
0.4359271228,
0.4765049815,
0.874879539,
-0.3591532111,
0.7419632077,
-0.0089025125,
-0.5779696107,
0.0227784459,
-1.2253884077,
-0.8349003196,
-0.396150738,
-0.3099547029,
-0.220380187,
-0.128628388,
0.5428558588,
0.6771695018,
-0.6098242998,
-0.5853990316,
-0.0246906802,
-0.2772410214,
0.0145708295,
-0.1716573834,
0.0866759345,
-0.5795939565,
-0.8175011873,
0.5430132151,
0.5845857859,
0.0074963067,
-1.0226019621,
-0.3264546394,
0.4512573779,
0.0014995434,
0.4763215184,
0.1886491328,
-0.3758267462,
0.1337682903,
0.0734285116,
0.0053171138,
0.0738853142,
1.1838848591,
-0.7483420372,
0.2138501555,
0.2527273297,
0.519213438,
0.6357167363,
-0.0234296583,
1.0281062126,
-0.082715787,
-0.1411381066,
0.5429914594,
0.3050830662,
0.4602805972,
-0.0936530158,
0.2767817676,
0.1808053404,
-0.7372689843,
-0.5946480632,
0.3013623357,
-0.5832737684,
0.2183883935,
1.0687634945,
-0.1555762589,
-0.0408058763,
-0.2027834505,
0.3422611058,
-0.1063502505,
-0.2737979889,
0.7280061841,
0.7530608177,
-0.2536036968,
-0.0329815745,
-0.8434060812,
0.9149014354,
0.3976869881,
-1.0518385172,
0.0567806028,
0.6242667437,
0.6641165018,
-0.2408295423,
0.7836718559,
-0.5385619998,
0.3048758805,
-0.287022084,
0.0740669295,
0.0137107726,
-0.1469806433,
-0.4736536443,
-0.1410301477,
0.3998396099,
0.4020708799
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00318v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00318v1
|
KGLink: A column type annotation method that combines knowledge graph and pre-trained language model
| 2024-06-01T06:28:41 | 2024-06-01T06:28:41 |
Yubo Wang, Hao Xin, Lei Chen
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.IR
|
The semantic annotation of tabular data plays a crucial role in various
downstream tasks. Previous research has proposed knowledge graph (KG)-based and
deep learning-based methods, each with its inherent limitations. KG-based
methods encounter difficulties annotating columns when there is no match for
column cells in the KG. Moreover, KG-based methods can provide multiple
predictions for one column, making it challenging to determine the semantic
type with the most suitable granularity for the dataset. This type granularity
issue limits their scalability.
On the other hand, deep learning-based methods face challenges related to the
valuable context missing issue. This occurs when the information within the
table is insufficient for determining the correct column type.
This paper presents KGLink, a method that combines WikiData KG information
with a pre-trained deep learning language model for table column annotation,
effectively addressing both type granularity and valuable context missing
issues. Through comprehensive experiments on widely used tabular datasets
encompassing numeric and string columns with varying type granularity, we
showcase the effectiveness and efficiency of KGLink. By leveraging the
strengths of KGLink, we successfully surmount challenges related to type
granularity and valuable context issues, establishing it as a robust solution
for the semantic annotation of tabular data.
|
[
-0.5233966708,
-0.757612586,
0.2962027788,
0.0750058442,
-0.4169218242,
-0.0554694273,
0.05820271,
-0.2377907336,
0.2608894408,
0.5292582512,
-0.4422535896,
-0.8721777201,
-0.5275165439,
0.0712496936,
-0.2811812162,
1.3146090508,
-0.2996444106,
-0.1175712422,
-0.7336146832,
-0.3480490744,
-0.7333883643,
-0.1314480156,
-0.2326451838,
-0.4559473395,
0.9275668263,
0.4513986409,
0.9973364472,
0.7312187552,
0.6091868877,
0.1914286613,
0.1151284352,
0.166667819,
-0.3718641996,
0.0714257881,
0.1686468124,
-0.2954505682,
-0.6767395139,
-0.0119351344,
0.5235985518,
0.9496065378,
0.0095953858,
0.1503055394,
-0.197617501,
1.0156472921,
-0.6469199061,
0.6019926667,
-0.7526535392,
0.6515383124,
-0.5159450173,
0.1010281965,
-0.1894290596,
-0.6791437864,
0.1325356811,
-0.8846213222,
-0.2587937117,
0.1378369629,
0.6210378408,
0.4298902154,
-0.8853363991,
-0.3658418953,
-0.3888359368,
-0.0097554354,
-0.641820848,
0.629047513,
0.8040214777,
0.6052179337,
-0.2021037787,
-1.0690549612,
-0.8830800056,
-0.642742455,
-0.7633575201,
-0.1489801556,
0.5799630284,
0.0616882071,
0.2345271111,
0.0216090847,
-0.5131593347,
-0.1120191887,
-0.3882011175,
-0.2683931291,
0.3917156756,
0.2006332427,
0.4984486401,
-0.2464255989,
-0.1592066437,
-0.0974406302,
-0.7610318661,
-0.03361395,
0.3534688354,
0.4950520992,
-0.2175746858,
0.4824960232,
-0.585857749,
1.1505322456,
-0.25465554,
-0.1476078629,
0.4669795036,
-0.1191960424,
-0.2075331956,
0.3518069685,
0.9055135846,
0.0434403643,
0.2105685622,
-0.6056180596,
0.3971648514,
-0.1532738209,
0.3112246692,
-0.7523505092,
-0.6466621161,
0.0610352084,
-0.1427862495,
-0.5484751463,
-0.4026792049,
-0.6905430555,
-0.5603233576,
-0.3819565773,
0.6732968092,
-0.3085188866,
-0.0662925318,
-0.4675114453,
0.2213832438,
-0.1316908598,
0.3238498569,
-1.0272200108,
-0.2320410311,
0.4137912691,
0.3804259598,
0.0226997696,
-0.323258251,
-0.6017922163,
0.5611455441,
-0.4022785127,
0.6899254918,
-0.8111040592,
-0.3084038198,
0.1462294459,
-0.2754538059,
0.1400359273,
-0.3410539925,
0.7793707848,
-0.7890430093,
-0.1023983955,
-0.6211414933,
-0.5439313054,
-0.3480222523,
0.5021656752,
-0.8755405545,
1.102897644,
0.4247692823,
-1.0705319643,
1.1181393862,
-0.8441896439,
-0.6537373662,
0.3100806475,
-0.2897094488,
-0.8267791867,
-0.4479781985,
0.1196671352,
0.623008132,
0.0706952736,
0.4960843921,
-0.8471335769,
0.0197416283,
0.1298657358,
0.0966897383,
0.23095119,
0.0974977463,
0.0440130867,
-0.0296000522,
-1.1118329763,
0.219486773,
-0.18215774,
-0.6661015153,
-0.1629725397,
0.0279605445,
-0.0792585313,
0.3393734097,
0.1641295999,
-0.3451220393,
0.4293141365,
0.2141602337,
0.1867324263,
0.3269460201,
-0.3820512295,
0.3039862812,
0.3535812795,
0.0760499015,
0.2623576224,
0.0738094449,
0.4220895469,
-0.2419921309,
-0.6638083458,
-0.0886552706,
0.6160586476,
0.313995868,
-0.9472216368,
0.1168617532,
-0.6710891128,
-0.7360938787,
-0.3843649924,
0.1872234792,
0.3703793287,
1.221850872,
0.6563929915,
-0.1459658891,
-0.4523662031,
-1.0164185762,
-0.2823025286,
-0.0867727697,
0.3132906258,
0.6986829638,
0.493881166,
-0.349745661,
1.3748362064,
-0.5120862722,
-0.4780649245,
-0.1657693833,
0.5525988936,
-0.0056363991,
0.4607166052,
0.2744829357,
-1.2011948824,
-0.9211596251,
0.4132502377,
-0.9521995783,
-0.2471918017,
0.3182459474,
-0.0640740618,
0.0247846115,
0.3482669294,
-0.5546360612,
0.4987256229,
0.1237820834,
-0.3841753304,
0.6684612632,
-0.0193130523,
0.1941390187,
-0.900822103,
0.3405462205,
-0.4787528813,
-0.1184383258,
-0.8397492766,
-0.3609510362,
0.4088079035,
-0.2944169044,
-0.2619383633,
0.2190724164,
-0.0760011971,
-0.2908007801,
-0.0373798721,
0.1359433979,
-0.0873965025,
0.3274049461,
0.0839212388,
0.6560718417,
0.3207100928,
-0.5470522046,
0.5628031492,
0.6067973375,
-0.2996159494,
0.5619718432,
-0.2198830992,
-0.020909626,
-0.4488334954,
0.4973094165,
-0.8968485594,
-0.3918352127,
0.260559231,
-0.4606629908,
0.563233912,
-0.3381739855,
-0.3896012604,
-0.4071400762,
0.0207523387,
0.4596738517,
0.1100634485,
-0.4221656024,
0.8275060058,
0.1340622753,
0.0508839563,
-0.9851635098,
-0.6226599216,
0.1387391686,
-0.2772940695,
-0.6111325026,
0.3965331316,
0.2009088099,
0.2417454422,
0.2572276592,
-0.1854654551,
-0.4237574041,
0.116284363,
0.4333207607,
0.1967926472,
-0.0051729432,
0.2482652813,
0.0598714352,
-0.282961905,
0.0127483271,
-0.1341220587,
0.4949023128,
0.0933828056,
-0.1439259648,
-0.3879438341,
0.0795875937,
0.3472654521,
-0.1863042861,
0.905518651,
1.1256600618,
-0.0677675977,
-0.0072444701,
-0.4648689926,
0.2285461724,
-0.4788403213,
0.6229379773,
-0.454695493,
-0.9455967546,
0.4386805892,
-0.1559609771,
-0.3456281722,
0.29625386,
0.0869521275,
-0.2556246519,
0.3195359707,
0.4155032039,
-0.3205504715,
0.0941918194,
-0.0706937164,
0.6175607443,
-0.7701076269,
-0.655897975,
-0.7159744501,
-0.2937023938,
-0.4841420054,
0.0179731101,
0.6124478579,
0.4358823001,
-0.4369390011,
0.4950751066,
-0.2959188223,
0.2684531212,
0.4063858986,
0.0188607983,
0.1031220108,
0.036538098,
-0.479440093,
-0.0157217942,
-0.6089686155,
-0.0014730101,
1.1659451723,
-0.1440566033,
0.6218488216,
0.0132035371,
0.4241071641,
0.6219445467,
0.6502143741,
-0.3413845599,
0.5767754912,
0.0508245714,
-0.6035743356,
-0.45250687,
-0.8248539567,
-0.6747255325,
0.0866978616,
-0.6754820943,
-0.7808189392,
-0.3021181226,
0.3957030773,
0.084740445,
0.2952611744,
-0.5770135522,
1.3128944635,
0.1655265391,
-0.2950267792,
0.2128305435,
-0.814806819,
0.3100350797,
-0.1416038871,
0.1403838694,
-0.080594413,
0.271712631,
0.7312612534,
-0.6396419406,
0.5540683866,
-0.2228888124,
0.1075269058,
0.3039188981,
0.1146658286,
0.8884586692,
0.0964915007,
0.1927102953,
-0.0406079143,
-0.310115844,
-0.256193161,
-0.7689663768,
0.5333294272,
-0.7048497796,
-0.2414568216,
0.0949594527,
-0.8300603628,
-0.614997685,
0.1278855801,
-0.0321170017,
0.6771972775,
0.3713451624,
0.4130078852,
0.4784099758,
-0.1308510751,
0.6107972264,
0.4092109799,
-0.1186322346,
-0.852001369,
0.8798119426,
0.4222381115,
-0.0336602181,
0.7364524007,
0.037697725,
-0.5674974918,
-0.5190948248,
-0.6546409726,
-0.2465454936,
-0.8362474442,
-0.3551780879,
-0.8461872935,
-0.0964427292,
-0.4351927042,
-0.2920376062,
-0.1409367472,
-0.2751716971,
0.0421471298,
-0.3468295336,
0.6148799062,
0.4372920692,
0.1710381359,
0.2348950058,
-0.8095266223,
0.0314465873,
0.8157917857,
0.6651417613,
0.3258410096,
0.073492378,
-0.2161783427,
-0.3148450255,
-0.0251126289,
-0.881526947,
0.0992510021,
-0.0165376868,
0.3827045858,
0.3651148379,
-0.0589741357,
0.8294840455,
-0.5700702071,
0.600217402,
0.2161490321,
-0.730365634,
0.3028150499,
-0.5564351082,
-0.0790769085,
0.8285046816,
0.7055982947,
-0.6194204688,
0.2796002328,
-0.0910422504,
-0.9117341042,
0.5447730422,
0.1739649177,
-0.2496170551,
0.0973278433,
0.4332220256,
0.2699351311,
0.460278064,
-1.2455570698,
-0.4494157434,
-0.0865834355,
-0.2831454873,
0.1750101,
-0.3321221173,
0.0507079065,
-0.2379873395,
0.6686356068,
-0.0660987273,
-0.0332001857,
0.0842052549,
-0.3211325407,
0.1937612593,
0.2155564874,
0.4207103252,
0.6191831231,
-0.3095639646,
0.0777814835,
0.4483360052,
-0.7600041032,
0.0621607676,
0.2452731729,
-0.4047099948,
-0.1159248352,
0.4247967899,
0.8231145144,
0.0395258889,
-0.2369606346,
0.355575949,
0.2859709263,
0.0109195458,
-0.3301133811,
-0.0402446538,
0.3097362518,
-0.0979512632,
0.1845262796,
-0.3612363935,
0.1314146966,
-0.2891689837,
0.2516328096,
0.6122249961,
-0.6152786613,
0.0863536522,
0.7917773128,
0.1693404764,
-0.2647002637,
0.5340013504,
-0.3902165294,
-0.4466403723,
0.5443180203,
0.3942124844,
0.4597281516,
0.1715264618,
0.4435272217,
0.212907508,
0.0168739539,
0.5022007823,
0.0026399374,
-0.5116351843,
-0.4548918605,
-0.4369274676,
-0.9759133458,
-0.1167621613,
0.0880010426,
-0.3864005804,
0.1420842856,
-0.0133089125,
0.0797936544,
0.1438944638,
0.2320874482,
-0.6708993912,
0.5107035637,
0.1159500405,
0.9624088407,
-0.8528215885,
0.9638674259,
0.6460071802,
-0.5978602767,
-1.0023263693,
-0.4255736768,
-0.4207611978,
-0.5749237537,
1.2992315292,
0.169693619,
0.3732116222,
-0.1714099944,
-0.2308586836,
-0.9889162183,
1.3794543743,
-0.0242185593,
-0.1770489067,
0.2074866295,
1.0497463942,
0.217183277,
-0.2943081558,
0.336697787,
0.4344652295,
0.9006198049,
0.1715208441,
-0.7744262218,
0.2080731392,
0.0250738431,
0.1097415537,
0.6268898249,
-0.4062449932,
0.5691894293,
0.2036565244,
0.3961945176,
-0.5026556849,
0.7782930136,
-0.1732751876,
0.5313870907,
0.3428384662,
1.3109539747,
0.5619468689,
-0.1107091308,
0.6404573321,
-0.0343093686,
0.4254185557,
1.1410053968,
-0.4737447798,
0.610196054,
0.2111803293,
-0.4262493253,
0.6307748556,
0.3004927039,
0.0590526126,
0.7597270012,
0.1987612545,
-0.5425179005,
-0.0871593282,
-0.1074978411,
-0.6817237735,
0.1776020825,
0.3759098053,
-0.3000312448,
-0.6225340366,
-0.2723245025,
0.4168316424,
-0.2249847353,
-0.63883847,
0.7147905827,
-0.2695496678,
-0.5484960675,
0.2757703662,
-0.3747488558,
0.2504426539,
-0.6967647672,
-0.1166110709,
-0.1738169938,
-0.3320531249,
-0.5249119997,
-0.5595735312,
0.2107298225,
-0.3383516669,
-0.1274008155,
0.382320106,
0.9158061147,
-0.6164456606,
-0.3728900254,
0.0510770679,
0.0989719853,
-0.0530418642,
0.2219190449,
-0.3390405476,
-0.0603354946,
-0.1232391894,
-0.0990353078,
0.5817760825,
0.4212897718,
0.100375168,
0.9537816644,
0.7478353977,
-0.2836167812,
0.092016317,
-0.0762543529,
1.0243115425,
-0.5194357038,
-0.4449431896,
-0.9377452135,
0.6510058045,
-0.3773265481,
-0.2613020837,
0.3904965222,
0.5285543203,
0.6258634329,
-0.258205533,
0.6879400611,
-0.4475541711,
-0.0477200598,
-0.5089024901,
1.142264843,
-0.3339504898,
-0.2653117776,
-0.4299246073,
-0.8316327929,
-0.4327194691,
0.2719173729,
-0.621026516,
0.169944033,
0.7546169162,
0.6518025398,
-0.171393916,
0.0080311196,
0.2554620802,
0.2963019013,
-0.0087634241,
0.4629797041,
0.4007430375,
-0.089472346,
0.8491387963,
-0.2466046512,
0.1214489639,
-0.2482192516,
-1.2683336735,
-1.0782116652,
-0.7048811316,
-0.3110527098,
-0.3052248657,
0.0577276573,
0.6002061963,
0.8559350371,
-0.4836655259,
0.2970169187,
-0.2900770903,
0.1861153245,
0.3056064546,
-0.2276673913,
0.9001892209,
-0.6014874578,
0.0801913068,
-0.0822404101,
0.4201211631,
-0.0395900868,
0.0006342863,
0.1542585641,
-0.117568247,
-0.3905310333,
0.5517094731,
0.1802417934,
-0.3591112196,
-0.3438357115,
-0.7339231372,
0.043776866,
0.0315843336,
0.4489457607,
-1.055244565,
0.3451247215,
0.5059327483,
0.9578301907,
0.6198130846,
-0.0077809212,
0.1479431242,
-0.7107828856,
0.1103203893,
0.112961866,
0.318203032,
0.3285990655,
-0.3936281204,
0.5823708177,
0.1449057162,
-0.5742940307,
-0.668028295,
0.4320908785,
-1.044454217,
0.0425623581,
0.754982233,
-0.3454748094,
-0.226282686,
-0.0524219498,
-0.0165000912,
0.343906343,
-0.1406693459,
1.1212362051,
0.6817507744,
0.0227957815,
0.0831889361,
-0.594257772,
0.9182763696,
0.2607768178,
-0.97026366,
-0.1310548186,
0.3657508194,
0.2744787931,
0.1894107312,
0.3990958929,
-0.0480118543,
0.1276421398,
0.0962065831,
0.0688429996,
-0.5431251526,
-0.2795572877,
0.4455555975,
0.5847634673,
-0.1738210022,
0.0399912819
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00314v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00314v2
|
CASE: Efficient Curricular Data Pre-training for Building Assistive Psychology Expert Models
| 2024-06-01T06:17:32 | 2024-06-16T10:33:34 |
Sarthak Harne, Monjoy Narayan Choudhury, Madhav Rao, TK Srikanth, Seema Mehrotra, Apoorva Vashisht, Aarushi Basu, Manjit Sodhi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The limited availability of psychologists necessitates efficient
identification of individuals requiring urgent mental healthcare. This study
explores the use of Natural Language Processing (NLP) pipelines to analyze text
data from online mental health forums used for consultations. By analyzing
forum posts, these pipelines can flag users who may require immediate
professional attention. A crucial challenge in this domain is data privacy and
scarcity. To address this, we propose utilizing readily available curricular
texts used in institutes specializing in mental health for pre-training the NLP
pipelines. This helps us mimic the training process of a psychologist. Our work
presents CASE-BERT that flags potential mental health disorders based on forum
text. CASE-BERT demonstrates superior performance compared to existing methods,
achieving an f1 score of 0.91 for Depression and 0.88 for Anxiety, two of the
most commonly reported mental health disorders. Our code is publicly available.
|
[
-0.5873296857,
-0.8011343479,
0.6863771081,
0.2859072685,
0.2294812053,
0.1727366,
-0.2169734091,
-0.4248756766,
0.2526265383,
0.4171513915,
-1.0792250633,
-0.5694058537,
-0.6586171389,
0.1456707567,
-0.425375551,
1.1533812284,
0.0700598136,
0.2504422665,
0.0309207849,
0.1919314861,
-0.1446754038,
-0.8145678043,
-1.0109049082,
0.2574945986,
0.4071499109,
0.1830270588,
0.3898655772,
0.0225546826,
0.7134580016,
0.2661960423,
0.1953292042,
0.1135544032,
-0.4446422756,
0.059924487,
-0.2285739183,
-0.1236523539,
-0.6235542297,
0.1911555976,
0.1844916493,
0.6513308883,
-0.2980104983,
0.3043233752,
0.0726027116,
0.5195125341,
-0.4638619721,
0.2424464524,
-0.5250641704,
0.3307372332,
-0.2717761695,
-0.1443409175,
-0.3491434455,
-0.3352331817,
0.2364778668,
-0.7795183063,
0.6131013632,
-0.0840850621,
0.5508828759,
0.3531883955,
0.0347846709,
-0.3415141106,
-0.4248105586,
0.664352417,
-0.5614931583,
0.2743822336,
0.9808025956,
0.2884052992,
-0.2146364301,
-0.6596266627,
-0.4584285915,
0.1446456164,
-0.1574103236,
-0.0056224787,
-0.3048688471,
0.3581424356,
0.5474073887,
0.3825135529,
-0.4261364341,
-0.0653765872,
-0.3559147716,
-0.2807612121,
0.7240982652,
0.1981067061,
0.3523306847,
-0.076333195,
0.0845577717,
0.144811824,
-0.0943973809,
0.0685147867,
0.2717674077,
0.1940111071,
-0.0321517475,
0.661047101,
0.0512983166,
0.6076881886,
0.2975618839,
-0.0107659763,
0.0977670103,
-0.1310182959,
-0.1645173132,
0.0734831393,
0.596236825,
0.262889117,
0.1260546893,
-0.251226902,
0.0197918676,
0.0717059299,
0.6938205957,
-0.458321929,
-0.5337694883,
0.2828546464,
-0.4777996242,
0.142801553,
-0.2742802501,
-0.7017136216,
-0.4590075016,
-0.5382298827,
0.1288074553,
-0.6035297513,
-0.1520403773,
0.0029691204,
0.1217813939,
-0.1191899851,
0.2195727229,
-0.8114290833,
0.4539868236,
0.7617861629,
0.86051476,
-0.1791324168,
0.2359668016,
-0.7118195891,
-0.0296515692,
0.0566395186,
0.7189158201,
-0.5511482358,
-0.0817703307,
0.1609931141,
0.2464677691,
0.0444481783,
-0.0874485746,
0.7716771364,
-0.2610656619,
0.3742615581,
-0.2346921265,
-0.6998139024,
0.2268694639,
0.1076239571,
-0.581430912,
0.9451162219,
0.4300370514,
-1.0112763643,
0.2575222254,
-0.8164978623,
-0.3127116263,
0.2665595412,
-0.2395154387,
-0.0990954041,
-0.1397982091,
0.477676928,
0.562232852,
0.056698896,
0.2524082363,
-0.3925018609,
-0.4410029054,
-0.020860875,
-0.1719722897,
1.0572584867,
0.1350812614,
-0.2538334727,
-0.0020200736,
-0.9306558967,
0.2347035706,
-0.4201625586,
-0.1747179776,
-0.6041585803,
0.078404732,
0.2465472817,
0.3133170903,
-0.0248679016,
-0.3522554636,
-0.0604652539,
-0.5225067735,
0.2053256184,
0.7717658877,
0.0447491445,
0.2016222775,
-0.1244018152,
0.6878738999,
-0.3352568746,
0.3006218076,
0.2090229839,
-0.8592129946,
-0.5831584334,
-0.6695787907,
-0.0249269903,
0.5446840525,
-0.8003768325,
0.8210604787,
0.2543370724,
-0.3880617619,
-1.0601849556,
0.072795853,
0.2122883201,
0.6533523798,
0.5328469872,
-0.2369510978,
-0.7719812393,
-0.6705337763,
-0.2611669898,
0.0176706817,
-0.3913097084,
0.1409109235,
0.1321253628,
-0.432572335,
0.9993872046,
-0.6150525212,
-0.7738716602,
0.0432178341,
0.4229899943,
0.0286380891,
0.3354886472,
0.4352028072,
-0.4137682021,
-0.4879854023,
-0.3420550525,
-0.710282445,
-0.2620267868,
0.0888715833,
-0.3428232074,
0.121019274,
0.2444359958,
-0.4216660857,
0.4724923372,
0.3936431706,
-0.3916064799,
0.2138844132,
-0.2904180586,
0.0827817619,
-0.7619086504,
0.1543848962,
0.2213427424,
-0.169029817,
-0.5549705029,
-0.0647724345,
-0.3061814308,
-0.2522416115,
-0.0799525604,
0.2115638107,
-0.1809702814,
0.3105977476,
-0.0520572551,
0.1247876361,
-0.3968172073,
0.4109306633,
0.3058545589,
0.5115061402,
0.521497488,
-0.2972668707,
0.1612987071,
0.3187941909,
-0.411438942,
0.7297930717,
-0.1514082104,
0.3186545372,
-0.2290982753,
0.053173054,
-0.6816177964,
-0.3402797878,
0.2951877117,
-0.2384092212,
0.1607047766,
0.0947192237,
-0.3770573139,
-0.4437964857,
-0.1947446167,
-0.0753020048,
0.1312658191,
-0.1542546749,
0.1246283203,
0.7760272622,
-0.2316714227,
-0.6299190521,
-0.3296532035,
-0.131933108,
-0.1219822243,
-0.1393734664,
0.2986918688,
-0.2180056721,
-0.1654050946,
0.0732029229,
0.0276634712,
-0.6858645082,
0.2167538702,
0.3754825294,
0.2203499824,
-0.0346254669,
0.3430750966,
0.139457643,
-0.0513643436,
0.5313181281,
0.1548999995,
0.3831767738,
-0.1578799337,
-0.3519911468,
-0.4975794852,
0.8688753843,
0.067983903,
-0.0000647126,
0.7331624031,
0.7649367452,
-0.7688663602,
-0.0544194318,
-0.7000536919,
-0.3752446175,
-0.4655827284,
0.3071997762,
0.1221609041,
-0.8514599204,
0.1646171212,
0.3210351467,
0.1627644598,
0.1435480714,
0.2537521124,
-0.3439145088,
1.1919646263,
0.8314911127,
-0.1114089489,
0.3864741325,
0.0444302782,
0.6697345376,
-0.3376128376,
-0.0491837785,
-0.514424324,
-0.1466208696,
-0.5159580112,
-0.4079223871,
0.2987733781,
-0.1120218411,
-0.2112757713,
0.2071692497,
-0.9838362932,
0.2350011617,
0.4384114444,
0.404173404,
0.3201462626,
0.2336980253,
0.0477225557,
-0.741530776,
-0.52950418,
-0.532233417,
1.0721083879,
0.3225194514,
0.4513724744,
-0.0992024168,
0.5345268846,
0.4674707949,
0.950910151,
-0.7341661453,
0.5023354292,
-0.0845899209,
-0.8363252878,
-0.3500734568,
-0.214634791,
-0.732498765,
-0.2390156984,
-0.5616014004,
-0.8041613102,
-0.1012737602,
-0.0269058067,
-0.4765278101,
0.1598315537,
-0.7049353719,
0.6492667198,
-0.2508903146,
-0.1559395939,
-0.2666684985,
-0.7649760246,
0.3091490865,
-0.5613939762,
0.3502375185,
-0.2570421696,
0.2372216135,
0.9955931902,
-0.3736928999,
0.6752418876,
-0.2624672055,
0.0268490426,
0.0704680756,
-0.3645896018,
-0.144659698,
0.3006313741,
-0.164177984,
-0.1317555904,
0.348408252,
-0.3973157406,
-0.5399037004,
0.4886242747,
-0.84465307,
-0.7006787658,
-0.4929466546,
-0.4400858879,
-0.6930810809,
0.233330518,
0.1276760697,
0.2192703635,
-0.0223105848,
-0.0533422902,
0.7641662955,
-0.1382212192,
0.2542016804,
0.7433855534,
0.0163357519,
-0.0213779677,
0.6395263076,
0.2229145467,
-0.3479835391,
0.1708175242,
-0.0676774606,
-0.1963580698,
-0.1822401732,
0.0128003946,
0.2298307717,
-0.6837081313,
-0.1119783744,
-0.8809894323,
-0.5201885104,
-0.50225389,
-0.3579568863,
-0.1627181023,
-0.2027442604,
-0.4818756282,
-0.279535532,
0.5475379229,
0.6173120141,
-0.0715156347,
0.1906475127,
-0.7368280292,
0.3850635588,
0.3283488452,
0.5703068972,
0.0526621267,
-0.1019827127,
-0.1384135783,
-0.075162977,
-0.3168221414,
-1.0356417894,
0.3391470909,
0.2610248029,
0.7782680392,
0.5995253325,
0.5287942886,
0.92215693,
-0.3103140295,
0.5746661425,
0.1483620405,
-0.8055612445,
0.8183923364,
-0.1720434576,
-0.0079304278,
1.0098193884,
1.1592592001,
-0.4413035214,
-0.7879544497,
-0.7756306529,
-0.8835551143,
0.9411682487,
0.1489368677,
0.0904165357,
-0.3838848174,
0.3945110738,
0.1127135456,
0.2913615704,
-0.5394887328,
-0.3628487885,
-0.1013659462,
-0.3972658217,
0.0694662109,
-0.2228450924,
-0.4053252935,
-0.5667562485,
0.5710414648,
-0.0552032068,
0.5664710402,
0.424063623,
0.0802610964,
0.1061841622,
0.1253456771,
0.0899200439,
0.6183887124,
-0.4511142373,
0.1042497605,
0.0072638108,
-0.844068408,
0.004085077,
0.2710908055,
0.3200802803,
0.2558300197,
0.0984641984,
0.2201134115,
0.3283697069,
-0.9458342195,
0.5968273282,
-0.3566049635,
-0.0675155297,
-0.467451185,
0.0570635609,
-0.0627966598,
0.0629481375,
0.413272351,
-0.0838830769,
0.3512682021,
-0.4225759804,
0.4538231194,
0.2498092502,
-0.6030178666,
-0.297691077,
0.5143882632,
0.1969901919,
-0.6297106743,
0.9038575888,
-0.2172965556,
-0.0620189905,
0.1908475757,
0.3467733264,
0.5924153328,
-0.213614583,
0.4427602887,
0.3604835868,
0.1256233305,
-0.0602427013,
0.4057755172,
-0.2059140205,
-0.4164696634,
-0.4365234375,
-0.5210030079,
-0.5143325329,
0.4159321189,
-0.9923340678,
0.416559577,
-0.7367234826,
-0.610912323,
-0.0032056004,
0.0731754676,
-0.8392273784,
0.4289858341,
0.220863387,
0.7161864638,
-0.8538228869,
0.8501529694,
0.9192622304,
-0.1294565052,
-0.8075746298,
-0.1687587649,
0.0860417113,
-0.4156400859,
0.2940726578,
0.2556652725,
0.1528377384,
-0.1114052311,
-0.2970166802,
-0.5882571936,
0.5862405896,
0.4118423462,
-0.4986942112,
-0.426490128,
0.0135007389,
0.9517998099,
-0.2255295068,
0.4604160786,
0.522408545,
0.2281194329,
-0.4907631278,
-0.7096675038,
-0.0244982168,
-0.4574403763,
-0.4053359032,
-0.164626658,
-0.1562605947,
0.4556925297,
0.0529309288,
-0.3222635388,
-0.2243423313,
0.4201845825,
0.3190403283,
0.3092519343,
0.3181137145,
0.3361591101,
1.2913793325,
-0.0186792128,
0.7247506976,
-0.3819156885,
0.4329074025,
1.1299154758,
-0.1029632539,
0.8672130704,
0.496573627,
-0.427996546,
0.4106809795,
0.5843311548,
-0.0109409066,
0.55195719,
0.1182813719,
-0.4741652012,
-0.2316462547,
-0.1045173407,
-0.4074163735,
0.1904108226,
0.6116295457,
-0.3108544052,
-0.1443642378,
0.1220835894,
0.0940832198,
0.2716008723,
-0.298468858,
0.4762135148,
0.2090325356,
-0.5782459378,
0.1084994227,
-0.1264874935,
0.6823790669,
-0.5725305676,
-0.0198295806,
0.0447085798,
0.1034144759,
-0.3732519448,
-0.6982405186,
0.6873216033,
0.2860819995,
-0.3249748349,
-0.4913497567,
0.7891490459,
-0.1334424466,
-0.6853648424,
0.3159753978,
0.6375421882,
0.3070559204,
0.0249828529,
-0.69069767,
-0.5163081288,
-0.2705701292,
-0.1366185844,
0.549315393,
0.4336959422,
-0.1276352108,
0.4872639477,
0.528824091,
0.2234342545,
-0.0419787727,
-0.0193620287,
0.7096867561,
-0.3125603795,
-0.4846937358,
-0.455933243,
0.2613166571,
-0.4528303444,
-0.4662039876,
0.6665421128,
0.2389787585,
0.6967474222,
-0.01955273,
0.735814929,
-0.1782954186,
0.7481500506,
-0.1118009612,
1.0934131145,
-0.2691371739,
0.1857094467,
-0.3705328107,
-0.4852013588,
-0.3619065583,
1.0086743832,
-0.5013872385,
-0.3215302825,
0.7658808827,
0.5166743994,
0.1374201626,
0.3397572041,
-0.0610274114,
-0.083917059,
0.2812013626,
0.5499848127,
0.5628913045,
-0.1593456864,
0.1586758196,
-0.5348314047,
-0.28687343,
0.0314213112,
-0.798442781,
-1.2298958302,
-0.5252643824,
-0.5105016232,
-0.2287023067,
0.0935755223,
1.0328294039,
0.6848925948,
-0.9381456375,
0.1664462984,
0.0060434714,
0.0980779082,
-0.1883485913,
-0.3082978129,
0.4076517224,
-0.3595016897,
-0.4369253218,
0.1834034324,
0.0195889007,
-0.2434536666,
-0.3243136108,
0.2795881927,
-0.3540724814,
-0.1096025258,
0.4805609584,
0.1178577915,
-0.5126934648,
-0.2092697769,
0.0513424724,
-0.2360095233,
-0.084315002,
0.8429449201,
-0.7618905902,
0.4957662225,
0.1351557672,
0.8129690289,
0.1685722023,
-0.0509941056,
0.5565623045,
-0.81658566,
0.0879108757,
0.4412790239,
0.1323233098,
0.2988903522,
-0.6892859936,
0.5215541124,
0.1849238276,
-0.3574149907,
-0.8809423447,
-0.3212505579,
-0.9004831314,
-0.1823647767,
0.6864400506,
-0.594758451,
0.0022987747,
-0.7410767078,
-0.4494570792,
0.3068549335,
-0.362072736,
1.3020740747,
0.9605417252,
-0.3250668049,
-0.2450231463,
-0.8910927176,
0.9375788569,
0.3457725346,
-0.8331596255,
-0.3167271912,
0.133644551,
0.2071048915,
0.0200786907,
1.0576922894,
0.0141001092,
0.2615917623,
-0.356998831,
-0.0855181366,
0.1827517301,
0.0127402013,
-0.0526627153,
0.3245968223,
-0.2922195196,
0.3095125854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00303v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00303v1
|
Multi-Dimensional Optimization for Text Summarization via Reinforcement Learning
| 2024-06-01T05:15:12 | 2024-06-01T05:15:12 |
Sangwon Ryu, Heejin Do, Yunsu Kim, Gary Geunbae Lee, Jungseul Ok
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The evaluation of summary quality encompasses diverse dimensions such as
consistency, coherence, relevance, and fluency. However, existing summarization
methods often target a specific dimension, facing challenges in generating
well-balanced summaries across multiple dimensions. In this paper, we propose
multi-objective reinforcement learning tailored to generate balanced summaries
across all four dimensions. We introduce two multi-dimensional optimization
(MDO) strategies for adaptive learning: 1) MDO_min, rewarding the current
lowest dimension score, and 2) MDO_pro, optimizing multiple dimensions similar
to multi-task learning, resolves conflicting gradients across dimensions
through gradient projection. Unlike prior ROUGE-based rewards relying on
reference summaries, we use a QA-based reward model that aligns with human
preferences. Further, we discover the capability to regulate the length of
summaries by adjusting the discount factor, seeking the generation of concise
yet informative summaries that encapsulate crucial points. Our approach
achieved substantial performance gains compared to baseline models on
representative summarization datasets, particularly in the overlooked
dimensions.
|
[
-0.3506148756,
-0.3478117883,
0.6304980516,
0.2848336995,
-0.4406431913,
0.2522606552,
-0.0548459515,
0.0584219731,
0.4486850202,
0.3609153628,
-0.6049008369,
-0.3777775466,
-0.6731803417,
0.1907486469,
0.3894780278,
1.5013405085,
-0.2481063157,
-0.2374093384,
-0.4222531021,
-0.4615035057,
-0.5408940315,
-0.4028365016,
-0.6313038468,
-0.206016168,
0.7933937311,
0.6687493324,
0.0904675722,
0.6658885479,
0.3347473741,
0.3859648407,
0.0498717837,
0.8097900748,
-0.5863904953,
0.1488420218,
-0.0437843166,
-0.2947915494,
-0.546978116,
0.2017036378,
0.7094305158,
0.2976516783,
-0.3373581171,
0.0482467189,
0.216187343,
1.0188373327,
-0.9110720754,
0.2337542027,
-0.2620514929,
0.1499701291,
0.3427527249,
-0.5947089791,
-0.0512178279,
-0.5195977092,
0.0192257911,
-0.9810651541,
-0.0440948382,
-0.1720306575,
0.5899465084,
0.3310988545,
-0.7446596622,
-0.5213890076,
-0.5608226061,
1.1141797304,
-0.4555189312,
-0.061127618,
0.1575597227,
0.2575760484,
0.3480063975,
-0.3593019545,
-0.2419101745,
-0.0015657174,
0.0515830182,
0.6762363911,
0.0394817069,
-0.0212578326,
-0.113987945,
0.1699409336,
-0.5027385354,
0.0046601775,
-0.5217493176,
-0.0694357306,
0.8196489811,
0.3628706038,
-0.0230530277,
-0.1817335337,
-0.4067260325,
-0.4267444611,
0.1593256444,
0.5542798042,
0.4226326048,
0.2438580245,
-0.1699910164,
0.4019419849,
-0.2132906914,
0.2092841566,
0.1654023379,
-0.7957348824,
0.3438965678,
-0.4821994603,
0.1170365363,
0.0895013064,
0.6034165621,
0.7688207626,
-0.1377848536,
0.0518986098,
-0.2556151152,
-0.2625500858,
0.6405898333,
-0.7629737258,
-0.0108143296,
0.335321039,
-0.6897116899,
-0.4683198631,
-0.0310275815,
-0.8854643703,
-0.2950404584,
-0.6269788742,
0.5435896516,
-0.4582817256,
0.03088581,
0.1982098669,
-0.4611031413,
-0.3828161657,
0.3283568621,
-1.0748618841,
0.1883117855,
0.2297203541,
0.9895787835,
-0.1228675991,
-0.6227167249,
-0.8251881003,
0.3554611206,
-0.3280863166,
0.7663017511,
-0.3429436088,
-0.3268197775,
-0.2029052526,
-0.5673059821,
-0.0644488931,
-0.3222198486,
0.444971323,
-0.1283199042,
0.4718261361,
-0.3990595043,
-0.186004281,
-0.4201406837,
0.3964211941,
-0.4745401144,
0.6398416162,
0.1366079152,
-0.6934432387,
0.3944222331,
-0.5834124088,
-0.5747103095,
-0.5881156921,
0.1338564605,
-0.8799697161,
0.4476411939,
0.588780582,
0.4765435457,
0.2432559878,
0.0073355273,
0.0661646053,
-0.0786791593,
-0.0484189205,
-0.0929524899,
0.2397915274,
0.2070078105,
0.0135828899,
0.5991725326,
-0.820540905,
-0.1782937497,
0.0465297289,
-0.6042484045,
-0.4536627233,
0.2033899277,
-0.2824461758,
0.2101280689,
0.1809584498,
-0.1863405555,
0.2717352211,
-0.1758449078,
0.117325969,
0.8135243058,
0.3360512555,
0.5455906391,
-0.7719219923,
0.724580884,
0.3831955492,
0.2107726783,
-0.3935898542,
0.1933525503,
-0.3543408513,
-0.5798138976,
0.0374187827,
0.4772139788,
-1.0794534683,
0.2284595817,
-0.1840799004,
-0.3526525199,
-0.2000468075,
0.0388727821,
0.5136295557,
0.3349995613,
0.5847483277,
-0.2765809894,
-0.2533058822,
-0.7966752052,
-0.3500164747,
-0.0189280007,
-0.1174916998,
0.3692668378,
0.4195821583,
0.0875797346,
0.3713631332,
-0.7496868968,
-0.7282083035,
-0.5691971183,
0.3552109301,
0.0117822383,
0.222334668,
0.8057408929,
-0.6784872413,
-0.3755227029,
-0.1235555336,
-0.7028170824,
0.1265751719,
-0.6960611939,
0.0966626406,
-0.1207372099,
0.2938914001,
-0.221443519,
-0.0518440716,
0.4841750562,
0.0244637392,
0.6554117799,
-0.8365597725,
0.2878066301,
-1.2265530825,
-0.1350953877,
0.2160703689,
-0.2472135723,
-0.3478944898,
-0.0954355001,
0.2387102097,
-0.0679314882,
0.0210870858,
0.316619873,
-0.2773098648,
0.1797266454,
-0.486494571,
0.4946967363,
0.2174286395,
0.9232171178,
-0.1378223896,
0.5155379176,
0.183682397,
-0.851952076,
0.1770757288,
0.3485999107,
0.0890322998,
0.9355620146,
-0.5519641638,
-0.3250703812,
-0.7060536742,
0.3924664855,
-0.6639060378,
-0.0839467123,
0.0341209508,
-0.5103989244,
0.2440517396,
0.4790489376,
0.1015951782,
0.0671067759,
-1.0917016268,
0.3672485352,
0.0238096751,
-0.5745860934,
0.9073067307,
0.4883502424,
-0.3929919004,
-0.8669201136,
-0.0622172803,
-0.0791665241,
-0.3287107348,
-0.0698176473,
0.3972788751,
-0.0498849228,
0.0281634703,
-0.1377620548,
-0.2673209608,
0.3339124322,
0.2026421875,
-0.0242873784,
-0.0133835971,
0.170543775,
0.0049168887,
0.6003076434,
-0.2444835603,
0.0297068302,
-0.3897272348,
-0.006883414,
0.1208876744,
0.1565784961,
-0.4174295664,
0.5978754163,
0.4132590592,
-0.4650493264,
0.6982610822,
0.6302770972,
-0.2054424882,
-0.496416986,
-0.0910553038,
-0.0111790448,
-0.3787966967,
0.6084712744,
-0.4713546634,
-0.707927227,
0.4736969769,
-0.1026765332,
0.3706605434,
0.4403479695,
0.510062933,
-0.1545345783,
1.0952638388,
0.7479700446,
-0.1784628779,
0.5669850707,
-0.1912106872,
0.1847274601,
-0.8402613401,
-0.505398035,
-0.4949129224,
-0.4567485452,
-0.4180080295,
-0.1839544922,
0.7643101215,
0.3180501461,
-0.1411413252,
-0.0248601791,
-0.3833717108,
0.5739054084,
0.7995508909,
0.2245625407,
0.3015310764,
-0.1313301027,
-0.2688570917,
0.103972964,
-0.6981471181,
-0.2650200427,
0.8922379017,
0.2053334415,
0.4668954313,
0.2681894302,
0.7830447555,
0.2872279286,
0.0025088096,
-0.4265646935,
0.0594419204,
-0.2615109682,
0.2009552121,
-0.5833701491,
-0.8582022786,
-0.7405232191,
0.6642459631,
-0.3354305029,
-0.4211237133,
0.1936914176,
0.1245573312,
-0.4610010087,
0.2406794578,
-0.5141938925,
0.7432209253,
-0.3372583091,
-0.0256999303,
-0.4688728154,
-0.5162644982,
0.5708781481,
0.0566247851,
0.2700006366,
-0.0602827705,
-0.2196433097,
0.5276016593,
-0.1173392087,
0.4186574221,
-0.105692409,
0.1380650848,
-0.0892502964,
-0.0680748597,
0.3276729882,
0.3994773328,
0.1941810548,
-0.2755801976,
0.0479134358,
-0.677908957,
-0.5146414638,
0.4665298164,
-0.9717595577,
-0.1636516154,
-0.6220787168,
-0.8325164318,
-0.2243989557,
0.0440870374,
0.0996939316,
0.4842869639,
-0.2528887391,
0.0043056104,
0.4590126276,
-0.5583431125,
0.5519183278,
0.2485503703,
0.0648042262,
-0.8281945586,
1.3619376421,
-0.2109418064,
0.1892703921,
0.627466321,
0.2787068784,
-0.2568844259,
-0.7409775853,
-0.4405732751,
0.1916605383,
-0.4699423611,
-0.4176121056,
-0.8136306405,
0.0508950166,
-0.1709171236,
-0.4083045423,
-0.2164137512,
-0.2837945223,
-0.3497170508,
-0.2200449407,
-0.1394782364,
0.7312148809,
-0.3714716434,
0.1827361435,
-0.9080801606,
0.7196799517,
0.3838394284,
0.1516885608,
0.2119725198,
-0.333301127,
-0.5220726728,
-0.0265114438,
-0.8697387576,
-0.555295229,
0.5676249266,
0.2949412167,
0.538045764,
0.5229091644,
0.1802493781,
0.3439847827,
-0.4506771266,
0.6591950059,
0.5682497621,
-0.9358665943,
0.4864531457,
-0.3984157145,
0.5072627664,
0.5004597306,
0.529127717,
-0.5516343117,
-0.4561232626,
-0.2586294711,
-0.7725529671,
0.7497726679,
0.0518896095,
0.2043121457,
0.1319556534,
0.443498224,
0.1710734814,
0.3038832843,
-0.6036247611,
-0.1948144287,
-0.6259042025,
-0.3395240903,
-0.4790491462,
-0.389536202,
-0.2021822482,
0.1194489077,
0.6591930985,
-0.5046918988,
-0.1232990175,
0.1147237271,
-0.1260705739,
0.1233518794,
0.1068461835,
1.1733022928,
0.8972747922,
-0.1838858426,
-0.034967564,
0.1404987872,
-0.3161040246,
0.2289099097,
0.0253324471,
0.0764429569,
-0.1815110147,
0.5030586123,
0.9827890396,
0.0445849337,
-0.533080101,
0.5102338195,
-0.3048731089,
-0.4995903373,
0.1384384334,
0.0470275097,
-0.1509751081,
0.4783470035,
0.4029898643,
0.1431858689,
0.208759889,
-0.4245006442,
0.0105730165,
0.2069317549,
-0.239386037,
-0.1326285452,
0.927947104,
0.1740710288,
-0.0107560586,
0.3967885971,
-0.2010212988,
-0.4553446472,
0.4836840332,
0.2506457269,
0.7104034424,
-0.2365375608,
0.8039508462,
0.728577733,
0.3578118086,
0.0641260967,
0.2192604691,
-0.0877970383,
-0.5857924223,
-0.3232349753,
-0.501395762,
-0.4279209971,
-0.2251841724,
-0.6342102289,
-0.1476756781,
-0.4092418849,
0.1631582081,
0.1235430986,
0.2693653107,
-0.1171867549,
0.1466268152,
-0.189646259,
0.4251443148,
-0.7452477813,
0.2134059221,
0.3467940688,
-0.6976286769,
-0.334142983,
-0.1085190773,
0.1734832674,
-0.2751576304,
0.1207649633,
0.0294890292,
-0.104625918,
-0.2771517932,
0.0393707305,
-0.6257606745,
1.1246644258,
0.1404258609,
-0.1219760925,
-0.0594218783,
-0.1975689232,
0.4954764545,
-0.3971697092,
0.1447741091,
0.3352220953,
0.3197779953,
-0.2595945895,
-0.5127204657,
-0.1430594027,
0.0487897024,
0.2594697177,
0.2596785724,
-0.8444305062,
0.7566024661,
-0.5243221521,
0.1276250929,
-0.1489899606,
0.8073310852,
0.4156201482,
0.3405439556,
0.2345447093,
0.4992426634,
0.6935409904,
0.1038840935,
1.2392448187,
-0.0179296248,
0.2427402735,
0.9514030814,
0.0850087702,
0.3986037672,
0.2744385004,
0.0555151515,
0.3067241311,
0.6623993516,
0.2575997412,
0.8274339437,
0.1389178038,
-0.0910102651,
0.0520592518,
-0.0699130893,
-0.0362317264,
0.3425780833,
0.0937457234,
-0.043073196,
-0.3225414753,
0.2970757186,
-0.2671266496,
0.5642896891,
-0.4389562905,
1.1680835485,
-0.0585451573,
-0.6348221302,
0.1489559263,
0.3996671736,
0.5171748996,
-0.640057683,
-0.0332303159,
-0.5426137447,
0.2644189894,
0.0209788252,
-0.2841492295,
0.1326200664,
-0.3753344417,
-0.4814960361,
-0.4299993813,
0.0815647095,
-0.5517001152,
-0.4416636527,
0.1048071608,
0.3472302556,
-0.2398688793,
-0.1086686477,
-0.6871557832,
-0.19303599,
-0.0042969878,
-0.1236150935,
0.5017241836,
0.6433758736,
0.0619059019,
0.5856744051,
0.5201082826,
0.0992376208,
-0.3482232988,
-0.0574555919,
0.6854583621,
-0.34087497,
-0.9724083543,
-0.6856443286,
0.5161943436,
-0.1694796234,
-0.533981204,
0.6951519847,
0.8575258851,
0.8727797866,
-0.0890610442,
0.6672847867,
0.5379471779,
0.4800492525,
-0.772105515,
0.3655450642,
-0.938708663,
0.0389787108,
-0.2404922694,
-1.0169969797,
-0.1589913517,
0.468655169,
0.1295304745,
0.1620375514,
0.8580616713,
0.1855649501,
-0.0697985664,
-0.3493099213,
0.2933157384,
-0.2046091855,
0.3436197937,
0.7146704793,
0.5149448514,
-0.2335680425,
0.4853528738,
-0.2606274188,
-0.4082977474,
-0.229317531,
-0.7133285403,
-0.9471337199,
-0.8282045126,
-0.2264527678,
-0.1370789707,
0.0420485437,
0.669483602,
0.5883860588,
-0.6818938255,
-0.232419908,
0.4724117815,
0.4440893531,
-0.731754005,
-0.1674981415,
0.5174961686,
-0.7047063708,
-0.8774970174,
0.2141103894,
0.623431325,
-0.1875397116,
-0.0171778165,
-0.2877801359,
-0.1306151599,
0.3151750565,
0.7748652101,
0.191769883,
-0.2914130092,
-0.2739987373,
-0.3607780635,
-0.1584673524,
0.0621534921,
1.0455881357,
-0.343922168,
0.3932539523,
0.5379598141,
0.7826643586,
0.547924459,
0.3983711898,
0.7056472898,
-1.0913113356,
0.0461307429,
0.1837236732,
0.158836022,
-0.0576254837,
-0.4777103066,
0.1221423522,
-0.1843842268,
-0.5108392239,
-0.5106670856,
-0.0001425194,
-0.9435591698,
-0.7040241361,
0.5592532754,
-0.0204402711,
0.2073344737,
0.2375281006,
-0.2187251002,
0.1424662769,
-0.3963584602,
1.2279047966,
0.3913885653,
-0.2589220107,
-0.4168489575,
-0.4240090549,
0.6438396573,
0.1781950891,
-1.1711546183,
-0.1339827627,
0.6595651507,
-0.0699980482,
0.1301093251,
0.4943599999,
0.0891307145,
0.361017406,
-0.0735974759,
0.0685354769,
-0.4302849472,
-0.7811830044,
-0.4207642376,
0.3122934699,
-0.3269536793,
-0.3630836904
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04371v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04371v2
|
Phased Instruction Fine-Tuning for Large Language Models
| 2024-06-01T04:25:26 | 2024-06-16T21:20:29 |
Wei Pang, Chuan Zhou, Xiao-Hua Zhou, Xiaojie Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Instruction Fine-Tuning enhances pre-trained language models from basic
next-word prediction to complex instruction-following. However, existing
One-off Instruction Fine-Tuning (One-off IFT) method, applied on a diverse
instruction, may not effectively boost models' adherence to instructions due to
the simultaneous handling of varying instruction complexities. To improve this,
Phased Instruction Fine-Tuning (Phased IFT) is proposed, based on the idea that
learning to follow instructions is a gradual process. It assesses instruction
difficulty using GPT-4, divides the instruction data into subsets of increasing
difficulty, and uptrains the model sequentially on these subsets. Experiments
with Llama-2 7B/13B/70B, Llama3 8/70B and Mistral-7B models using Alpaca data
show that Phased IFT significantly outperforms One-off IFT, supporting the
progressive alignment hypothesis and providing a simple and efficient way to
enhance large language models. Codes and datasets from our experiments are
freely available at https://github.com/xubuvd/PhasedSFT.
|
[
-0.3218074143,
-1.0185685158,
0.4928478301,
0.2297709435,
-0.5113731623,
0.1468702704,
-0.2856062651,
-0.1696822196,
-0.2876709402,
0.5314666629,
-0.9737278223,
-0.6368880272,
-0.6527930498,
0.0136149256,
-0.5396367908,
0.9989225864,
-0.1384223402,
0.0812928304,
0.3080616891,
0.216382578,
-0.7772248387,
0.1232203245,
-0.8430364728,
-0.4281365573,
0.3363586068,
0.810761869,
0.7031852007,
0.9533799291,
0.3932782412,
0.3488205075,
0.1979293674,
0.1438494325,
-0.3564687967,
-0.0807592198,
-0.0192708168,
-0.3497416675,
-0.3728356659,
-0.0701516718,
0.8098094463,
0.6691446304,
-0.2124075592,
-0.0773076341,
0.0114870444,
0.5556871295,
-0.0978308916,
0.5276033878,
-0.5825273395,
-0.1108619124,
-0.3573745787,
-0.3293632567,
-0.2517618537,
-0.6554953456,
0.290625006,
-0.6828472614,
0.2966988087,
0.0259556714,
0.5811537504,
0.4972452819,
-0.3464356065,
-0.495120585,
-0.6041779518,
0.609076798,
-0.9388021827,
0.6456080079,
0.575057447,
-0.1062476933,
-0.4033108354,
-0.3489610851,
-0.5330933332,
-0.6081467867,
0.2550243735,
0.0377718359,
0.2294103354,
0.2771492898,
0.1393325329,
0.2678816617,
-0.5541559458,
0.4655631185,
-0.3616442084,
0.0991460532,
0.3498599529,
0.0804631263,
0.1403747648,
0.2112602144,
-0.3170775771,
-0.0091475882,
-0.786690712,
-0.0553172641,
0.3479977846,
0.4897012413,
-0.1061385274,
0.592353344,
-0.511541903,
0.8294654489,
0.677515626,
-0.091036059,
0.0987788886,
-0.2362799942,
-0.0268963426,
0.1783456355,
0.4127208889,
0.0089020105,
0.2414197326,
-0.1551290601,
-0.4585624933,
-0.1356152445,
0.2209057957,
-1.0389031172,
-0.2968348265,
0.0180883743,
-0.1268929392,
-0.0176766198,
0.0013361148,
-0.42653808,
-0.2203480303,
-0.7171780467,
0.7946488261,
-0.7725644112,
0.0014107139,
0.4726854563,
0.3489311337,
0.3313435316,
0.3503508568,
-1.0799796581,
0.3349840939,
1.0764346123,
0.7677317262,
-0.1268776208,
-0.5401855707,
-0.651540041,
-0.1909691393,
-0.343054235,
0.7623699307,
-0.8176800609,
-0.3549699187,
0.035242714,
0.0045918012,
-0.1352619231,
-0.4331476688,
0.3754374683,
-0.4223864079,
0.2781642377,
-0.2449815869,
-0.8071548939,
-0.2071579546,
0.2257669866,
-0.4285781085,
0.9904707074,
0.1926720142,
-0.4405854344,
0.4120678604,
-0.5506895781,
-0.5968214869,
0.0701982155,
-0.0071895025,
-0.2725905776,
0.2541282773,
-0.0202233531,
0.5394269824,
-0.3522152305,
-0.0662808716,
-0.0375731736,
-0.5252566338,
-0.0974734575,
-0.3809047043,
0.2850943506,
0.0406706072,
-0.6419480443,
0.2302372605,
-0.8848769665,
0.0114610735,
-0.0793748125,
-0.46921134,
-0.3250383437,
0.0335368142,
-0.5735962391,
0.1239599958,
0.2740803361,
-0.540209353,
0.6590982676,
-0.3665620685,
0.2227110863,
0.9189093113,
-0.0248365682,
0.4645949006,
-0.2130050212,
0.5370016098,
0.125404045,
0.3078597486,
-0.2624187768,
-0.5434784293,
-0.9533210397,
-0.1717941761,
0.4038845003,
0.5718509555,
-0.7950405478,
0.2692529559,
-0.197048232,
-0.4210587442,
-0.6089020371,
0.2650281787,
0.5725979209,
0.3370935917,
0.3518850207,
-0.7212923765,
-0.1604966074,
-0.6732779145,
0.2485579699,
0.1663863361,
0.0424541645,
-0.3311747611,
0.3499087989,
-0.4345135093,
0.6289489269,
-0.3855819106,
-0.0023973945,
0.1748100817,
0.5004625916,
0.0626028106,
0.5869002342,
-0.1070581749,
-0.4384432733,
-0.511755228,
0.2404158562,
-0.2574701011,
-0.122232385,
-0.1913688183,
-0.0246077366,
0.0478710458,
0.4406131208,
-0.5182002783,
0.1945998967,
0.5800256133,
-0.2893542945,
0.4375624657,
-0.4344321191,
0.3008791506,
-0.7812958956,
-0.542568326,
0.1390135288,
-0.2025927007,
-0.7884157896,
0.1095019355,
0.2454596907,
0.1970705241,
-0.2747437358,
0.1852097958,
-0.5690735579,
0.1089377552,
-0.4491147697,
-0.1977967471,
-0.220975399,
0.4118469954,
-0.01123654,
0.8702862859,
0.4013830721,
-0.4682847261,
-0.0668931827,
0.1904163063,
-0.5410760045,
0.3242085576,
-0.6755560637,
0.3902443051,
-0.1151828244,
0.1461521089,
-0.8001467586,
-0.1435322613,
0.2745176256,
0.2807684839,
0.699698627,
-0.0479245372,
-0.3450906873,
-0.1680966914,
-0.2754849494,
0.3090912104,
0.4334677756,
-0.3824630976,
0.5342681408,
-0.0966172218,
-0.3271229267,
-0.4681570232,
-0.3145609498,
-0.3153508306,
-0.0320439078,
-0.4590016305,
0.288792491,
-0.3315571249,
0.0257071666,
-0.304127872,
-0.266518563,
-0.1885787547,
0.0055684512,
0.2729028761,
0.1169778928,
-0.2763132453,
0.0157650318,
0.3860338032,
-0.1195973381,
-0.3016256392,
-0.3999516368,
0.8899092674,
-0.1800750047,
-0.4786662757,
-0.6108682156,
0.3136425018,
0.3888161778,
-0.2619513571,
0.4786584675,
0.6600474715,
-0.1569070965,
-0.3371473253,
-0.5824481845,
-0.2714152038,
-0.5413330793,
0.4304052293,
-0.4907801449,
-0.9500880837,
0.3198117316,
-0.1751279235,
0.2879205942,
0.2222427577,
0.6487675309,
0.0605739914,
0.9957033992,
0.8176084757,
0.018018622,
0.645781219,
-0.2037901133,
0.1131691933,
-0.4689413011,
-0.0957268924,
-0.5032085776,
-0.0438554361,
-0.5477409363,
-0.593696475,
0.1084830537,
-0.0007843834,
-0.4124127626,
0.2848391235,
-0.4279620051,
0.6454411149,
0.5715025663,
0.2742328346,
0.3179276586,
-0.19582057,
0.2581479549,
0.2842533886,
-0.6235619187,
-0.277448684,
0.7614192367,
0.3012336493,
0.9921642542,
-0.2229959667,
0.8326327205,
0.1075865552,
0.301579237,
-0.8265205026,
0.4951642752,
-0.5381697416,
-0.4058299661,
-0.373447597,
-0.4381353557,
-0.8828737736,
-0.114607431,
0.0319528952,
-0.3985033929,
0.0229822397,
0.1852852404,
-0.4454343319,
-0.1421930045,
-0.9404087067,
0.6649768949,
-0.2836012244,
-0.0362635851,
-0.2263401747,
-0.572917521,
0.3504824042,
-0.4663279355,
0.1377897561,
-0.1868273616,
0.0294562839,
0.6011431813,
-0.3980248272,
0.9951968789,
-0.0625074878,
-0.513115406,
0.1496384293,
0.2363137156,
0.593185246,
-0.2088726759,
-0.0849070475,
0.0811169446,
-0.0334548354,
-0.4032126963,
-0.4780272841,
0.850207448,
-0.7922741175,
-0.7060417533,
-0.1421346515,
-0.8088737726,
-0.2986166477,
0.239545092,
0.2868075967,
0.6314361691,
-0.0006037171,
0.0405691415,
0.9950600266,
0.0939866528,
0.2705758512,
0.6959522963,
-0.0882851928,
-0.000416585,
0.9840469956,
0.3956184089,
0.5933178663,
0.398098737,
0.4121507108,
-0.2507167459,
-0.9317346811,
-0.5407783389,
0.0937917456,
-0.4923847616,
-0.170079276,
-0.3212898374,
-0.0066276314,
-0.2090234607,
-0.1302608848,
-0.5590035915,
-0.3094949424,
-0.2398165464,
0.0841310099,
0.30399701,
1.0145875216,
0.2514453232,
0.6493411064,
-0.8638653755,
0.2877345979,
0.4117078781,
0.4853714108,
-0.1856039315,
-0.8519474864,
-0.3137997985,
0.2618205249,
-0.2229840308,
-0.7207372785,
0.117964223,
0.5323904753,
0.1862215549,
0.3904491663,
-0.297698319,
0.8663635254,
-0.8836644292,
0.4430385828,
-0.0020787544,
-1.1282826662,
0.3459019363,
-0.5495163202,
0.7356415391,
0.6699609756,
0.5756403208,
-0.3678723872,
-0.393158406,
-0.2628201544,
-0.6666294932,
0.6393250227,
-0.1499827951,
0.1772248745,
-0.0444447324,
0.6036557555,
0.6620600224,
0.1699517965,
-0.4093327522,
-0.0042777099,
-0.1923626065,
-0.5748922825,
-0.0765657127,
-0.1439142674,
0.0443223082,
-0.243635729,
0.8258530498,
-0.1693893522,
0.083385624,
-0.298528254,
-0.0788089931,
-0.3797734082,
0.2021844834,
0.6677870154,
0.682100594,
-0.2116391212,
-0.1389363557,
0.2888690531,
-0.6645735502,
0.2719531059,
0.3754013777,
-0.4676125646,
-0.3663052619,
0.2364610881,
0.8595578671,
0.5556687117,
-0.3543237746,
0.1351078451,
-0.0924999565,
-0.156364426,
0.034221597,
0.2800328135,
-0.0094323289,
0.4205681086,
0.227243796,
-0.1787744015,
0.053516034,
-0.7358270288,
0.1904713809,
0.3586552143,
-0.3067523837,
-0.4441812336,
0.3949749768,
0.0545400679,
-0.496745795,
0.5685440898,
-0.3095657229,
-0.4864429832,
0.3364845514,
0.7030554414,
0.6704238653,
-0.5100703835,
0.3469133377,
0.0649829134,
0.4412790835,
-0.4699312747,
0.2804279327,
0.1379925758,
-0.549333632,
-0.7400981188,
-0.7276908159,
-0.5171131492,
-0.2219466865,
-0.3944329321,
0.2238040864,
-0.6572432518,
0.2124338448,
-0.040792089,
0.2420137972,
-0.7982722521,
0.356123507,
0.1348794699,
0.7921480536,
-0.7849914432,
1.2499339581,
0.3570723534,
-0.3414724171,
-1.0725893974,
0.1327393353,
-0.0427691862,
-0.8270302415,
0.3898267448,
0.282674551,
-0.202598691,
0.3045665622,
-0.3480959535,
-0.8670140505,
0.9641418457,
0.2455294579,
-1.111882925,
-0.0146785583,
0.2433407307,
0.3380759954,
-0.3089306653,
0.0760309324,
0.9057564735,
0.5027111173,
0.0974908173,
-0.8228647113,
0.0562178828,
0.1942763478,
-0.1472219825,
0.5504259467,
-0.7287359834,
0.9567973018,
-0.0702976286,
-0.1076633781,
0.1119773313,
0.7902095318,
-0.0664230287,
0.2055265605,
0.7286251187,
0.5164470077,
0.6840826869,
-0.1655224115,
0.8986279368,
-0.1917615831,
0.1589760184,
1.2708026171,
-0.3049487174,
0.7571278811,
0.1347676814,
0.0260276385,
0.4044381678,
0.6652863622,
0.2780187726,
0.5659538507,
0.149191916,
-0.2604916394,
-0.1323139518,
0.1471464634,
-0.408229202,
0.6305883527,
0.233267054,
0.1147811189,
-0.0940314084,
0.0072543533,
0.1520826817,
-0.2692890465,
-0.3439611793,
0.716648221,
-0.0580756329,
-0.7736159563,
0.7500041723,
0.0466185845,
0.7841271758,
-0.8610966206,
-0.1199564934,
-0.346806407,
0.1189551353,
-0.0444046073,
-0.6175028086,
-0.1044931263,
-0.038550403,
-0.0306469314,
-0.1199737042,
0.5084378719,
-0.7922152281,
-0.4917316735,
-0.0191888846,
0.3529081941,
-0.1263063252,
0.055124782,
-0.7109982371,
0.1745315045,
0.150230363,
-0.4906783998,
0.4108011425,
0.6452999711,
-0.1832467914,
0.6881245971,
0.5063809752,
-0.1354586482,
0.5373667479,
0.1463806033,
0.9251737595,
-0.4995238483,
-0.0458525456,
-0.6740674376,
0.4520622194,
0.2516780496,
-0.5298195481,
0.7322466373,
0.2732127011,
0.9356299043,
-0.0923040435,
0.4312407076,
0.0249246359,
0.2740699053,
-0.7758187652,
0.2569841743,
-0.332400918,
0.1232160777,
-0.0905781835,
-1.1096254587,
-0.149770394,
0.5555053949,
-0.3637463152,
0.1152156964,
0.6726309061,
0.9871279597,
-0.2700792849,
0.2649351656,
0.2964984179,
0.3942906857,
0.2888547182,
0.2756702304,
0.8109050393,
-0.1910803169,
0.0752145872,
-0.496681124,
-0.4182670712,
0.0118325194,
-0.8588749766,
-0.7014103532,
-0.6187878251,
-0.3375079632,
0.0450341143,
0.2201794237,
1.2635056973,
0.6207294464,
-0.7758316994,
-0.2056845278,
-0.1007921323,
-0.3478974998,
-0.2658784986,
-0.0554450639,
0.2662872374,
-0.501496315,
-0.8034037352,
0.6529129744,
0.2456461638,
-0.0508519933,
-0.2748561502,
-0.0917371288,
-0.3700286746,
0.3455283046,
0.7054985762,
0.2405273318,
-0.4688158035,
-0.5679372549,
-0.0524488129,
-0.0091757327,
-0.0368931368,
0.7991141677,
-0.3039725423,
0.3837046623,
0.2309417576,
0.672567606,
0.6090969443,
0.1002215222,
0.4348740876,
-0.6969020963,
0.0944409445,
0.19595474,
0.1882147342,
0.2544549406,
-0.2096877545,
0.3200832307,
-0.320483923,
-0.8183088899,
-0.442833662,
0.1745874435,
-1.0639954805,
-0.0852099359,
1.0714306831,
-0.0610982552,
-0.0602545403,
-0.0817476138,
-0.3419861794,
0.4491561949,
-0.3750790954,
1.0880292654,
0.6527892351,
0.0676275343,
-0.0562352352,
-0.6826946735,
0.3445212841,
0.5182950497,
-0.8765438199,
-0.0582491718,
0.5595954061,
0.4344743788,
-0.173683092,
0.5576754212,
0.2450669557,
0.2235741764,
-0.2371715009,
-0.0755559355,
-0.0964825302,
-0.4957103431,
-0.335144043,
0.0415227115,
0.3006101251,
-0.1081606671
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00284v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00284v1
|
A Closer Look at Logical Reasoning with LLMs: The Choice of Tool Matters
| 2024-06-01T03:29:56 | 2024-06-01T03:29:56 |
Long Hei Matthew Lam, Ehsan Shareghi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Logical reasoning serves as a cornerstone for human cognition. Recently, the
emergence of Large Language Models (LLMs) has demonstrated promising progress
in solving logical reasoning tasks effectively. To improve this capability,
recent studies have delved into integrating LLMs with various symbolic solvers
using diverse techniques and methodologies. While some combinations excel on
specific datasets, others fall short. However, it remains unclear whether the
variance in performance stems from the methodologies employed or the specific
symbolic solvers utilized. Therefore, there is a lack of consistent comparison
between symbolic solvers and how they influence LLM's logical reasoning
ability. We perform experiments on LLMs integrated with 3 symbolic solvers: Z3,
Pyke, and Prover9, and compare their performance on 3 logical reasoning
datasets: ProofWriter, PrOntoQA, and FOLIO. Our findings indicate that when
combined with LLMs Pyke's performance is significantly inferior to that of
Prover9 and Z3. Z3's overall accuracy performance slightly surpasses Prover9,
but Prover9 could execute more questions.
|
[
-0.1265179068,
-0.4311951995,
1.1572451591,
0.0697268248,
-0.2813919187,
0.157329306,
-0.1832371354,
-0.6056432128,
-0.1605317742,
0.4386956394,
-0.3942831159,
-0.4490139186,
-0.6777023673,
0.4784721434,
-0.0516667143,
0.326569587,
-0.134548828,
0.3855656087,
-0.4153398573,
-0.1179639474,
-0.6168490052,
-0.7044216394,
-0.4110087752,
-0.6917419434,
0.3639405668,
0.1628577858,
0.9971538782,
0.4941600263,
0.8233892322,
0.4147345126,
-0.2064201534,
0.2046978027,
-0.2283595055,
0.1768730432,
-0.4572425187,
-1.0275517702,
-0.163368836,
-0.05245075,
0.2416660637,
0.4671386778,
-0.0835233033,
-0.0362800434,
-0.2840046883,
0.5508359075,
-0.6859574914,
0.0407867096,
-0.5416824818,
0.2703253031,
-0.2234564275,
0.0390478708,
-0.3549732268,
-0.6437843442,
0.1061536819,
-0.6309626102,
-0.0064949025,
0.0560035296,
0.4401959181,
0.5585219264,
-0.3739403486,
-0.3443066776,
-0.815860033,
0.9619504809,
-0.9909189343,
0.3850365281,
-0.0759192929,
0.4631677568,
-0.4707371891,
-0.6155812144,
-0.7796005011,
-0.2142588049,
-0.0605607815,
0.0237336196,
-0.3357759714,
0.1853519976,
0.6924625635,
0.2621890008,
-0.4437620044,
0.1871590763,
-0.4473667145,
-0.3109402955,
0.6164895892,
0.4571190476,
0.2308349907,
-0.065628089,
-0.1661586463,
-0.1981320679,
-0.7427802682,
-0.0735275522,
0.2004469484,
0.0718849152,
0.4505847692,
0.8767270446,
-0.0457239635,
0.8812152147,
-0.1906341612,
-0.7258326411,
0.0732120499,
-0.0743697137,
-0.38127774,
0.1068365127,
0.7004573941,
0.418556869,
0.6054753065,
0.0005399808,
-0.3642790616,
0.4993914962,
0.0888935551,
-0.5468549728,
-0.3145664334,
0.0463227183,
-0.4009022415,
-0.0157742631,
0.0555807352,
0.0468162522,
-0.6847922802,
-0.6987064481,
0.4807099402,
-0.3910487294,
-0.0160247777,
0.4906136096,
-0.2305212468,
0.2561605871,
0.6779267788,
-0.2638502121,
0.4128923714,
0.9234510064,
0.5978753567,
-0.2188556939,
-0.1749752611,
-0.4406110048,
0.0608062111,
-0.4865186512,
0.8726772666,
-0.5574896336,
-0.1529463083,
-0.141883716,
-0.1950421631,
-0.0557079948,
-1.0055662394,
0.6748052239,
-0.6101041436,
0.1699320525,
-0.6747834086,
-0.7342073917,
-0.4224089086,
-0.0830602348,
-0.7250031233,
0.9393207431,
-0.0110008176,
-0.7070100904,
0.4682380259,
-0.3772523701,
-0.3861265182,
0.026869284,
-0.5450627804,
-0.0925671384,
0.3472832441,
0.1186176389,
0.5293239951,
-0.7023798823,
0.308604449,
-0.3869279325,
-0.740370214,
0.4292215407,
-0.0501448028,
0.9146336913,
0.1366713792,
-0.282381326,
0.2026227266,
-0.5082709193,
0.032593511,
0.3225003481,
-0.0634178519,
-0.0728997961,
0.160007447,
-0.4023703933,
0.5707325339,
-0.0275510661,
-0.5056781173,
-0.1186403185,
-0.3703773618,
0.3828687668,
0.724899292,
-0.2382898927,
0.0587850101,
-0.6071879268,
0.4612650275,
0.2005223334,
-0.2253352851,
0.3982023597,
-0.5857266188,
-0.5741827488,
-0.027240064,
0.1100608483,
0.8413880467,
-0.6779795885,
0.2031171471,
-0.1334231794,
-0.5347492695,
-0.315649122,
0.3512196243,
0.3676963449,
0.3766019046,
0.2881655991,
0.0769266412,
-0.400357753,
-1.1065052748,
-0.5761236548,
-0.4104670584,
-0.3483698666,
0.1465189904,
0.4506841004,
0.264728725,
0.9261057377,
-0.6109734178,
-0.1711722016,
-0.6067817807,
-0.4034013152,
0.3771488965,
0.1222878322,
0.406344533,
-0.4143358767,
-0.233478874,
-0.1002642438,
-0.9135181308,
-0.2410480082,
-0.0130104972,
0.0654537082,
0.3093165159,
0.4917159379,
-0.8763231635,
0.356233567,
0.1377700269,
-0.3452390134,
0.720246911,
-0.2130955011,
-0.0971306786,
-0.7171306014,
-0.3071981966,
0.1232140362,
0.0392175503,
-0.5175994039,
-0.177380383,
0.1450535208,
0.075706318,
-0.6156766415,
0.3133308291,
-0.5002625585,
-0.3684903979,
-0.0974787697,
0.3591141999,
0.0231797658,
0.1753493249,
0.0890295878,
1.0073820353,
0.4921538234,
-0.4494898617,
0.6621464491,
0.0566229858,
-0.6583435535,
0.3023330569,
-0.858497262,
0.1710003912,
-0.0801143497,
0.2388040572,
-0.7523064017,
0.0465372354,
0.3160753846,
-0.1100268066,
-0.0246045198,
0.34534657,
-1.0317583084,
-0.3352123201,
-0.3822098672,
0.2335113734,
0.6215444207,
-0.5625642538,
0.7678198218,
-0.0268964767,
-0.0386895016,
-0.4639228284,
-0.6045113206,
0.1064885333,
-0.4898713529,
-0.9308786988,
0.2394595146,
0.0804734901,
-0.8695737123,
-0.0581849813,
-0.395962894,
0.2017853111,
-0.0661555156,
0.0442801639,
0.3027213812,
-0.4794183075,
0.1577710658,
-0.010444806,
-0.196522519,
0.4597572982,
-0.1394014508,
0.1366616637,
-0.3974979818,
-0.684371829,
-0.6231256127,
0.1360453069,
0.6022491455,
-0.3286117911,
0.9259371161,
0.1290461868,
-0.2807066739,
-0.0756226853,
-0.9551199079,
-0.2368788719,
-0.4689311981,
0.012008694,
-0.5742589235,
-0.8975093961,
0.4664822221,
-0.1282601506,
-0.0987974927,
0.3081445098,
0.5347245336,
-0.1514037549,
1.0282270908,
0.277053535,
0.1467411965,
-0.0159699526,
0.1178404093,
0.3698199987,
-0.6753029227,
-0.3315601349,
-0.4157357514,
-0.379586488,
-0.3857516646,
-0.5386689305,
0.1385330856,
0.3429991901,
-0.2710557878,
0.2367379814,
-0.4192707837,
0.7626132965,
0.3476715684,
0.0414490551,
0.5777923465,
-0.0808345973,
-0.1985197067,
-0.1599663645,
-0.8292302489,
-0.7697405219,
0.9621788263,
0.1272723377,
0.7276846766,
0.3473318517,
0.4510402679,
-0.1456658393,
0.1570343375,
-0.6949640512,
0.914994359,
-0.1344882399,
-0.3525718749,
-0.1151756942,
-0.3117881119,
-0.6607323885,
0.7046427131,
-0.1799001992,
-0.7116444707,
0.0600370504,
-0.1080977619,
-0.381236732,
0.4528796971,
-0.7663831115,
0.6462886333,
-0.2944938838,
-0.2248365581,
-0.3029498458,
-0.6881054044,
0.4448353946,
0.117090188,
0.0219994411,
-0.3293135464,
-0.1331607252,
0.6688597202,
-0.4379289746,
0.6159031987,
0.0567663833,
-0.3446282744,
0.2960141003,
0.2179030031,
0.4452843964,
-0.1058796868,
-0.0978445858,
-0.0243459251,
0.0332361497,
-0.2312802374,
-0.9807305932,
0.6936658621,
-0.7266166806,
-1.2024044991,
-0.4606157541,
-0.6321740746,
-0.2504447401,
0.1404929757,
-0.0762421265,
0.4050726593,
0.2932893932,
0.128243044,
0.8065093756,
-0.0878003612,
0.1449862123,
0.3599998653,
-0.1932249665,
-0.1738022417,
0.5388225913,
0.0752195045,
0.4018964171,
0.2698640525,
0.3707951903,
-0.4002132416,
-0.6427237391,
-0.1807187051,
0.568693459,
-1.2488380671,
-0.2972432971,
-0.5052413344,
-0.0851951465,
-0.0745942667,
-0.2986344695,
-0.0620597005,
-0.5728266835,
-0.1153042987,
-0.0434719101,
0.4740304649,
0.6640973687,
0.1856136024,
0.05511434,
-0.5888158083,
0.3375216126,
0.2121590972,
0.1543264985,
-0.0876063034,
-0.1488165259,
0.2838259041,
-0.3098007739,
-0.0763702169,
-1.0673578978,
-0.0820392743,
-0.2566239238,
0.7557216883,
0.3556499481,
-0.0539412089,
0.5768290758,
-0.2734661996,
0.5075523853,
0.0665872246,
-0.7973123789,
0.5305168033,
-0.1143345013,
0.3908198774,
0.3689574003,
0.216710031,
-0.231289193,
-0.4524005651,
-0.4230833054,
-0.3229316473,
0.7571441531,
0.4673887193,
-0.4566159546,
0.1140862256,
0.4283160567,
-0.1403944939,
-0.1012068763,
-0.5158208013,
-0.2259161919,
0.1661605686,
-0.1045031622,
-0.0530226231,
-0.0577680543,
-0.0578209646,
-0.4677177072,
0.478574574,
0.1407698691,
-0.0307152923,
0.2512241006,
-0.2835550904,
0.0257503875,
0.2476407737,
0.4118987322,
0.8253133893,
-0.0337662809,
0.2179142088,
0.4611632526,
-0.2412644327,
0.1176628321,
-0.0451438874,
0.1505377442,
0.0324325189,
0.6304296255,
0.6147773862,
-0.015853025,
-0.9268184304,
0.3331823051,
-0.1009436771,
-0.4360865355,
-0.1555857807,
0.4297424853,
0.4928858578,
0.5621219873,
-0.021537967,
0.0559153631,
0.0673617423,
-0.3626868427,
-0.3348855376,
0.386174202,
0.1206041798,
0.0464101546,
0.4837477505,
-0.0202190299,
-0.454231441,
0.772977829,
-0.0441057272,
-0.7515445948,
0.7661476731,
0.6942785978,
0.5354622006,
-0.0514320992,
-0.2268055975,
0.1058179289,
0.5324556828,
-0.2277420014,
0.5323727131,
-0.0464424938,
-0.8315909505,
-0.8605232239,
-0.2624254227,
-0.4538744092,
0.0010528177,
-0.3260647953,
0.2337734252,
-0.3425081074,
-0.0624917895,
-0.0479757227,
0.2390146255,
-0.62889117,
0.1435557306,
0.0111404071,
1.1297614574,
-0.6756485105,
0.6305360794,
0.9799770117,
-0.0524280407,
-0.9082024693,
-0.0803571194,
0.2738265395,
-0.4340575337,
0.8183183074,
0.1465219408,
-0.5921164155,
-0.1887743026,
-0.1569065154,
-0.741260767,
1.3148143291,
0.6062342525,
-0.4163361788,
0.2366390973,
0.288806349,
0.5173825026,
-0.2230224013,
0.2054174393,
0.817815423,
0.5285595655,
0.339481771,
-0.9620893002,
0.2518503368,
-0.0473251343,
0.2195840925,
0.4276353717,
-0.3714595139,
0.6746988297,
-0.4530876279,
-0.3257569969,
-0.0923808739,
0.7201161981,
0.784217298,
0.2016204447,
0.4045553803,
0.5788058043,
0.8089763522,
-0.0891484916,
0.998996973,
-0.0300432332,
-0.057638891,
0.9448383451,
-0.6902417541,
0.7062663436,
0.4759789407,
-0.4562388062,
0.3246525824,
0.3981863558,
0.0668295994,
0.0752038956,
0.527074039,
-0.3085148633,
-0.6817100048,
0.09908057,
-0.4677106142,
0.2847696245,
0.4052124023,
-0.0469305739,
-0.2925539911,
-0.3857684433,
0.0391121954,
0.2631177008,
-0.1247742623,
0.5109314322,
0.2381951362,
-0.534954071,
0.2352190912,
0.1558600813,
0.4088427722,
-0.3537497818,
-0.0323572978,
-0.121337764,
0.4312665164,
-0.3256089389,
-1.026311636,
0.386718601,
-0.1190731078,
0.1310579181,
-0.0117495693,
1.1474378109,
0.1314083785,
-0.6231970191,
0.2397949398,
0.8308194876,
0.1220472828,
-0.103122063,
-0.4858411849,
0.2772300541,
-0.2019710988,
-0.0600076914,
0.2485499382,
0.6527103186,
-0.2774729729,
1.0318123102,
0.7553871274,
-0.0415676609,
-0.0257440321,
0.0960900635,
0.9733408689,
-0.7095537186,
-0.1452212632,
-1.0869727135,
0.107024245,
-0.0580137521,
-0.169561252,
0.9729553461,
0.6598614454,
0.8211485744,
-0.1129261926,
0.4567091763,
0.294459939,
0.3608272672,
-0.7225298285,
0.3389377594,
-0.3545342684,
0.5430101156,
-0.3638742864,
-1.1437265873,
-0.6340696216,
0.9230735898,
-0.4961500168,
0.0588639416,
0.9604998231,
0.7732411623,
0.0433078669,
0.3281604052,
0.2275447696,
0.1250639409,
0.2921150625,
0.7921813726,
1.3247996569,
-0.0254464261,
0.3799879253,
-0.3514552414,
-0.0652133152,
0.1051520333,
-0.9998440146,
-1.0781193972,
-0.0887074172,
-0.217709735,
-0.0673473999,
0.1314702332,
0.957870543,
0.1824240834,
-0.5424221158,
-0.3045037389,
-0.0316952467,
0.3876638114,
-0.0550604016,
-0.1777453423,
0.1612721384,
-0.1546139568,
-0.3039246202,
0.4162543118,
0.3154124618,
-0.1429087073,
-0.1083683148,
-0.106860958,
0.1501765549,
0.1201369092,
0.7186475396,
-0.1543698013,
-1.174195528,
-0.1589779109,
0.0107139787,
0.1141461879,
0.1372067481,
1.1029638052,
-1.1100611687,
-0.0104759969,
0.5894225836,
0.5262720585,
0.2232346833,
-0.1148569211,
0.4920560122,
0.0555856004,
-0.1507416815,
0.354809761,
0.4397217333,
0.2294401675,
-0.1824462563,
0.4480487108,
0.1466353387,
-0.4537614584,
-0.7257813215,
0.214961201,
-0.7395291924,
-0.4881383777,
1.0811057091,
0.2386176586,
0.0512836315,
-0.1987921745,
-0.2812921405,
-0.0689391643,
-0.2048118263,
0.3719471991,
0.9048951268,
-0.6119061708,
-0.065265283,
-0.7443270087,
0.3037991226,
0.6329640746,
-0.7292355895,
-0.0488984659,
0.7132280469,
0.1954499781,
0.0401561745,
0.4424967468,
-0.0792906731,
0.3221694827,
-0.1282209754,
-0.3518154919,
-0.1499236971,
-0.3298551142,
-0.3786286414,
0.1096959561,
0.3512696326,
0.316724211
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04370v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04370v1
|
Large Language Model Confidence Estimation via Black-Box Access
| 2024-06-01T02:08:44 | 2024-06-01T02:08:44 |
Tejaswini Pedapati, Amit Dhurandhar, Soumya Ghosh, Soham Dan, Prasanna Sattigeri
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Estimating uncertainty or confidence in the responses of a model can be
significant in evaluating trust not only in the responses, but also in the
model as a whole. In this paper, we explore the problem of estimating
confidence for responses of large language models (LLMs) with simply black-box
or query access to them. We propose a simple and extensible framework where, we
engineer novel features and train a (interpretable) model (viz. logistic
regression) on these features to estimate the confidence. We empirically
demonstrate that our simple framework is effective in estimating confidence of
flan-ul2, llama-13b and mistral-7b with it consistently outperforming existing
black-box confidence estimation approaches on benchmark datasets such as
TriviaQA, SQuAD, CoQA and Natural Questions by even over $10\%$ (on AUROC) in
some cases. Additionally, our interpretable approach provides insight into
features that are predictive of confidence, leading to the interesting and
useful discovery that our confidence models built for one LLM generalize
zero-shot across others on a given dataset.
|
[
-0.1739796996,
-0.8278459907,
0.8286818862,
0.1227654964,
0.0068164952,
0.1860328168,
-0.1718139946,
-0.8162064552,
-0.005029974,
0.2964615822,
-0.3703451157,
-0.6596655846,
-0.7237110734,
-0.0991491377,
-0.5613101721,
0.622364521,
0.1263427138,
-0.0362908579,
-0.0503265336,
0.0161087476,
-0.4140959382,
-0.7176359892,
-0.3300363123,
-0.1944508404,
0.5187358856,
0.2162013352,
0.7184208632,
0.1112214848,
0.2174016833,
0.155084148,
-0.3209468424,
-0.0325224809,
-0.5595791936,
0.0160912201,
-0.0968832299,
-0.9201825857,
-0.4418083131,
-0.2966047227,
0.526563704,
0.5206851959,
-0.1675652117,
0.2777854502,
0.1188943684,
0.156671986,
-0.7715876102,
0.3849390447,
-0.8133827448,
-0.0841730163,
-0.0311229117,
-0.0391614102,
-0.6099574566,
-0.2263945043,
0.183508724,
-0.4261288941,
0.0578332879,
0.2139738053,
0.715657115,
0.1585116684,
-0.3127899766,
-0.2752552032,
-0.8035971522,
0.9813970327,
-0.6998596191,
0.259044528,
0.5136423707,
0.3887138665,
-0.2778164744,
-0.4320035279,
-0.475217849,
-0.2620244622,
-0.0697623864,
-0.105938904,
-0.1955477595,
0.0454205796,
0.1152760237,
0.4100441635,
-0.4683221281,
0.1136647314,
-0.0505164601,
-0.342818886,
0.8225038052,
-0.1674875319,
-0.1386334151,
0.0192930624,
-0.185223639,
0.0314099975,
-0.6676912308,
0.2110471725,
0.2750562429,
0.2906160653,
-0.1123904064,
0.7141432762,
-0.1158119962,
0.5715750456,
-0.1363004744,
-0.2546836734,
0.2375442237,
-0.2715808153,
-0.3381242156,
-0.0935298651,
0.716617465,
-0.0876712054,
0.3979401588,
-0.0788348913,
-0.2358150184,
0.1114260778,
0.2092176676,
-0.6809461713,
-0.0000240423,
0.5301633477,
-0.1152450889,
-0.287527442,
0.2998244166,
-0.7478432059,
-0.3841831684,
0.2012784332,
0.5237524509,
-0.1411073208,
-0.4697752595,
0.1741860956,
0.1518405229,
0.4339572787,
0.4723990262,
-0.6396504045,
0.093431063,
0.8388327956,
0.7886661291,
-0.1348337531,
0.0203094669,
-0.7181820273,
-0.0523720197,
-0.4879089594,
0.5458449721,
-0.65055269,
-0.4975438714,
0.2142271101,
0.218519032,
0.0211163312,
-0.2178729624,
0.3027092814,
-0.457085073,
-0.1446463913,
0.2484150827,
-0.604398787,
-0.166769743,
0.2128625959,
-0.6845590472,
1.0197838545,
0.045553606,
-0.6156585217,
0.1861448586,
-0.2642309964,
-0.2156374604,
0.0550836921,
-0.3040413857,
-0.4669308364,
0.4509929419,
0.2486888617,
0.6007362604,
-0.1759610921,
0.2919913828,
-0.9255699515,
-0.3872418702,
0.8479657769,
-0.4571554959,
0.6360283494,
-0.0097523006,
-0.3232046366,
-0.0256293844,
-0.6904908419,
0.212794587,
-0.0751229897,
-0.0210660845,
-0.4696932435,
-0.2113938928,
-0.0819195211,
-0.0036356868,
0.3524003029,
-0.5479177237,
-0.0050613722,
-0.2973091006,
0.0924261883,
0.6602631807,
0.2260934561,
0.2581066787,
0.0333312266,
0.8533432484,
-0.1181520894,
0.0297101196,
0.1486090273,
-0.650606513,
-0.4090500772,
-0.3199130595,
0.565852046,
0.4819770157,
-0.5129308701,
0.5098562837,
-0.1406160891,
-0.4463464618,
-0.6114413738,
0.3404240906,
0.4694086015,
-0.0149361631,
0.0769441128,
-0.2161257714,
-0.1451923698,
-0.9159334898,
-0.0587376878,
-0.4081280828,
-0.1749362499,
0.3802942932,
0.619071722,
0.0408009738,
0.6670393944,
-0.8189347386,
0.0010824588,
-0.2656080723,
0.1573078334,
0.0834931955,
0.2917564213,
0.4269423485,
-0.8477426767,
-0.4316446781,
0.0944206268,
-0.7117069364,
0.1606753618,
0.0818395019,
-0.2969586551,
0.2876374722,
0.367746532,
-0.7513852119,
0.6657407284,
0.8290543556,
-0.2681025267,
0.4365890324,
0.0411107428,
-0.0785541832,
-1.0342925787,
0.1875929832,
0.1958411336,
-0.4636615813,
-0.6207177043,
0.2107317895,
0.1981934309,
0.1872762442,
-0.2354744375,
0.684217453,
-0.4281871617,
-0.1267974526,
-0.1254228354,
0.1585021615,
0.0698639229,
0.4063630998,
0.2227901816,
0.7011245489,
0.5030783415,
-0.2800248265,
-0.040392939,
0.2889209986,
-0.7048143744,
0.6241987944,
-0.6885677576,
0.176426813,
0.0098136617,
0.196544528,
-1.1260654926,
-0.3255027235,
0.0938424692,
-0.6255369186,
0.4287978411,
-0.3462792337,
-0.2635790408,
-0.2852614522,
-0.0482914038,
0.1338637769,
0.4296776652,
-0.3668802381,
0.5047880411,
0.519353807,
-0.4714112878,
-1.022383213,
-0.8083987236,
0.0531471409,
-0.0749759525,
-0.3016210496,
-0.1693280935,
-0.261087954,
-0.3501592875,
-0.0186513606,
-0.3290183544,
-0.3833988011,
0.3078457713,
0.4088338017,
0.3304297626,
-0.230587095,
0.2221847475,
-0.0120694898,
0.0595308542,
0.0670878664,
-0.1879713386,
0.3555007577,
-0.1067114249,
-0.4444321394,
-0.149220556,
0.1841599196,
0.4231849313,
-0.2700739205,
0.8541151285,
0.4691702127,
-0.5572900772,
-0.4860273004,
-0.6266540289,
-0.1237005293,
-0.3738494217,
0.5745591521,
-0.3733278215,
-1.1117289066,
0.4672319591,
0.2981963754,
-0.0214691777,
0.0903242752,
0.6224964261,
0.0624164045,
0.8701325059,
0.9859969616,
-0.0781558454,
0.3180728257,
-0.0398557894,
0.1441740543,
-0.4322321415,
-0.2461102605,
-0.679027319,
-0.030926764,
-0.405099988,
-0.5558155179,
0.1909940541,
0.136139527,
0.0669374913,
0.1943940669,
-0.0590300597,
0.24329108,
0.397864759,
0.2525536716,
0.5604536533,
0.0551971495,
0.0584237464,
0.139933899,
-0.4864768684,
-0.3598233461,
1.2557798624,
0.7116835117,
1.1206288338,
0.2236296535,
0.6641254425,
0.1518495083,
0.4757287502,
-0.9413230419,
0.2094978988,
0.1984197199,
-1.0422803164,
-0.4835497439,
-0.5434107184,
-0.6311756372,
0.0746874958,
-0.3587659597,
-0.9832193255,
0.4727028906,
0.2058398277,
-0.5038422346,
0.0936777517,
-0.8003821373,
0.7484713793,
-0.2799926698,
-0.3636206686,
-0.0742982849,
-0.4964434505,
0.5619165301,
-0.5402930379,
0.0883757323,
-0.0682399273,
-0.0827943608,
0.3722142875,
-0.2552397549,
0.9529831409,
-0.1947101504,
-0.4183584452,
0.2819684148,
0.096320942,
0.4382869303,
0.361956358,
-0.3463976383,
0.2977434993,
0.3051585853,
-0.5118003488,
-0.9093536735,
0.4642825425,
-0.5749176741,
-0.612016201,
-0.5150150657,
-0.7742397785,
-0.4505037367,
0.0776675045,
-0.0812356919,
0.2749308348,
-0.3333587646,
0.6992533803,
0.7520818114,
-0.3142364621,
0.2813903987,
0.4745011926,
-0.3673098683,
-0.2267617583,
0.3753040135,
0.1442958862,
0.6564396024,
0.638980031,
0.1203751341,
-0.6893360615,
-0.6732571721,
-0.3482496738,
0.2199328989,
-0.4521419108,
-0.2670997381,
-0.4218931198,
-0.3756408989,
-0.1717296988,
0.1401998848,
-0.2179597616,
-0.4036324322,
0.0146943275,
-0.3499154747,
0.4754506052,
0.9288864732,
0.2170292735,
0.4772652686,
-0.4537162185,
0.158039391,
0.3168477714,
0.4332337379,
0.0613160767,
-0.6711381674,
-0.3981424272,
0.1527341306,
0.0249519758,
-0.7728575468,
0.4921401143,
0.1050195172,
0.6157202721,
0.1913808137,
0.1787928045,
0.5999661088,
-0.1658464968,
0.5840545893,
0.0322608911,
-0.8597068191,
0.2722780704,
0.0603354909,
0.1032571122,
0.6267710924,
0.547578752,
-0.0399401598,
-0.5982831717,
-0.6449485421,
-0.4930750132,
0.3799500167,
0.2636551857,
-0.0600975268,
0.3330715895,
0.3468892574,
-0.0115325814,
0.712810576,
-0.8108412027,
-0.2558866739,
-0.0595848858,
-0.4647892416,
-0.5059540272,
-0.5130030513,
-0.2984266579,
0.2325193435,
0.5568170547,
-0.3094635606,
0.2063285559,
0.1070084348,
-0.2249527276,
-0.0715912655,
0.6390883327,
0.3405982256,
0.6828920841,
-0.6546434164,
0.0293371938,
0.1692617685,
-0.5269654393,
0.2728557289,
0.2972439528,
-0.3001411259,
-0.0211683307,
0.3871342838,
0.6617727876,
0.3511011899,
-0.6027551889,
0.6030026674,
-0.0845961869,
-0.1244337708,
-0.4390967488,
0.010081158,
0.2233229131,
0.3236336112,
0.4332730174,
-0.2395133227,
-0.0765004978,
-0.5924680233,
0.3179396391,
0.7311113477,
-0.6528470516,
-0.1872863621,
0.34971264,
-0.0447077304,
-0.1514995396,
-0.0475655198,
-0.1179893911,
-0.239497453,
0.4993077219,
0.6635276079,
0.8758550286,
-0.2357068956,
0.2830864787,
0.1986360848,
0.4560049772,
-0.2483951151,
0.2302145213,
0.3853203058,
-0.8718708754,
-0.5774905086,
-0.8878634572,
-0.6173099279,
0.3386338353,
-0.8780921698,
0.0084967585,
-0.4104627371,
-0.1623266786,
-0.1577355564,
0.3041067123,
-0.657751739,
0.1800218672,
0.0244957358,
1.0988214016,
-0.8157921433,
0.9300042391,
0.4906771183,
-0.3864678144,
-1.0287399292,
0.1219619513,
-0.0176249221,
-1.0434420109,
0.1228687838,
0.1532327682,
-0.1830414534,
-0.0217147674,
-0.7943522334,
-0.7358287573,
1.1771091223,
0.3447119296,
-0.7678764462,
-0.0571438,
0.0885981917,
0.5615594387,
-0.5813307166,
0.2334959358,
0.6232337952,
0.3746036887,
0.1644018441,
-0.7453433275,
0.072356686,
-0.1620946079,
-0.1435429156,
-0.0389381647,
-0.4092375338,
0.3390660584,
-0.1977205873,
-0.1436299086,
0.3547405601,
0.6986531019,
0.4435162544,
0.2811114788,
0.6047527194,
0.2447160333,
1.0155787468,
0.0477102324,
1.0883929729,
-0.3866357505,
0.3720503747,
1.2140389681,
-0.2261238545,
1.2649645805,
0.3257578015,
-0.2437242568,
0.4694710374,
0.4163393974,
0.1058883518,
0.0958474502,
0.0101712886,
-0.3262597024,
-0.3821742833,
-0.1083814353,
-0.1723429412,
0.371863246,
0.6090186238,
-0.2508759201,
0.2123916149,
-0.398324281,
0.1557881981,
-0.1228049323,
-0.3683356047,
0.5529284477,
0.6177453995,
-0.5444608927,
0.5300676227,
-0.2491094172,
0.5635347962,
-0.8666267991,
0.0624905787,
-0.1617894769,
0.2060979158,
-0.1842428148,
-0.9918605089,
-0.1366456151,
0.0462399907,
0.1500835866,
0.3645066917,
0.61272645,
-0.7486934066,
-0.9208139777,
0.4426570833,
0.7475641966,
-0.0465669744,
-0.238871038,
-0.648324728,
0.035249237,
-0.0183581915,
-0.2372970283,
0.3488994241,
0.5095472336,
0.0515641868,
0.9180161357,
0.5067287683,
0.363381356,
-0.0407696739,
-0.0932159871,
0.3784671426,
-0.608524859,
-0.3285343051,
-0.6265319586,
0.4453736544,
-0.1240021586,
-0.0193133187,
0.7221328616,
0.2988691628,
0.6403790116,
-0.0283087622,
1.1414996386,
0.1063920259,
0.5282026529,
-0.5281788111,
0.6355621815,
-0.547899127,
0.2749460638,
-0.5003716946,
-0.9740017653,
-0.3752461076,
0.6958729029,
-0.3895078897,
-0.0319785587,
0.7137912512,
1.2273365259,
-0.0803861991,
-0.1288311779,
0.6345914602,
0.5573336482,
0.2473732531,
0.5600920916,
0.6582665443,
-0.2471963018,
0.7617866397,
-0.3371062577,
-0.4112646282,
-0.2215673923,
-1.0403980017,
-0.9124702215,
-0.3036108315,
-0.0741747469,
-0.7105358839,
0.0416210629,
0.8054998517,
0.627227962,
-1.0929378271,
-0.4049025476,
0.3589197993,
0.2949146628,
-0.1240274236,
-0.1781171858,
0.3523659408,
0.0116139287,
-0.7175825238,
0.1731445044,
0.1920183152,
0.2687025964,
-0.5438015461,
-0.0845886841,
-0.2616159916,
0.1931401789,
0.5245073438,
0.4226723909,
-0.6607077122,
-0.6516658068,
0.1869510114,
-0.0311949812,
-0.0609343909,
0.4829446673,
-0.3768305779,
0.3335612416,
0.1037520766,
0.8096520901,
0.682700932,
0.3151636124,
0.9157024622,
-0.8063852191,
0.2977223992,
-0.0933180302,
0.4038603008,
0.3878699541,
-0.3818129599,
0.5786512494,
-0.0094698006,
-0.445812732,
-1.0777076483,
0.2655628622,
-1.1197719574,
-0.0910548642,
1.2338479757,
-0.4362323284,
-0.3385365307,
-0.3734926283,
0.0889605284,
-0.1251449287,
-0.504450202,
0.6681102514,
0.7956907749,
0.1939225346,
-0.3097812533,
-0.7480248809,
0.4733116925,
0.208674714,
-0.7340586185,
0.1640947908,
0.4193293452,
0.3005751371,
0.1837081164,
0.4628622532,
-0.1044809297,
0.1315333396,
0.001838182,
0.0520977043,
0.1670167595,
-0.5313438177,
-0.5595595837,
0.4150967002,
0.4937382042,
0.1554943919
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00257v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00257v1
|
Are Large Vision Language Models up to the Challenge of Chart Comprehension and Reasoning? An Extensive Investigation into the Capabilities and Limitations of LVLMs
| 2024-06-01T01:43:30 | 2024-06-01T01:43:30 |
Mohammed Saidul Islam, Raian Rahman, Ahmed Masry, Md Tahmid Rahman Laskar, Mir Tafseer Nayeem, Enamul Hoque
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Natural language is a powerful complementary modality of communication for
data visualizations, such as bar and line charts. To facilitate chart-based
reasoning using natural language, various downstream tasks have been introduced
recently such as chart question answering, chart summarization, and
fact-checking with charts. These tasks pose a unique challenge, demanding both
vision-language reasoning and a nuanced understanding of chart data tables,
visual encodings, and natural language prompts. Despite the recent success of
Large Language Models (LLMs) across diverse NLP tasks, their abilities and
limitations in the realm of data visualization remain under-explored, possibly
due to their lack of multi-modal capabilities. To bridge the gap, this paper
presents the first comprehensive evaluation of the recently developed large
vision language models (LVLMs) for chart understanding and reasoning tasks. Our
evaluation includes a comprehensive assessment of LVLMs, including GPT-4V and
Gemini, across four major chart reasoning tasks. Furthermore, we perform a
qualitative evaluation of LVLMs' performance on a diverse range of charts,
aiming to provide a thorough analysis of their strengths and weaknesses. Our
findings reveal that LVLMs demonstrate impressive abilities in generating
fluent texts covering high-level data insights while also encountering common
problems like hallucinations, factual errors, and data bias. We highlight the
key strengths and limitations of chart comprehension tasks, offering insights
for future research.
|
[
-0.3382446766,
-0.7319247127,
0.8208017349,
-0.0026896698,
-0.5017814636,
0.181994319,
-0.1340988427,
-0.65937078,
-0.1941495389,
0.8549595475,
-0.4726885259,
-0.7633548379,
-0.5336692333,
0.1439319253,
-0.5929536223,
0.57458812,
-0.2255279869,
0.0148795806,
-0.29436481,
-0.149802804,
-0.8555830121,
-0.6113225818,
-0.4461719394,
-0.0639103651,
0.547326684,
0.2730856836,
0.6679602265,
0.4003215134,
0.784147203,
0.2899924517,
0.0197947789,
0.4438129067,
-0.5327637196,
0.3645100296,
0.0500571989,
-0.3351710439,
-0.2821584046,
-0.2704954147,
0.679887712,
0.9645963907,
0.2482297122,
0.0534106866,
0.0109257372,
1.1296834946,
-0.4392212629,
0.709077239,
-0.6535945535,
0.0950879827,
-0.1638808101,
-0.0491266996,
-0.6436583996,
-0.0803623423,
0.4567180872,
-0.7497422695,
-0.0742167085,
0.3327415586,
0.7530049086,
0.5102318525,
-0.7905009389,
-0.3580837548,
-0.6541304588,
0.7146109939,
-0.6249313354,
0.5508795381,
0.3700746596,
0.6133165359,
0.1301147193,
-0.9975801706,
-0.4962833226,
-0.4094922245,
-0.1015098915,
0.1649364084,
-0.3474940956,
-0.0834642574,
0.4568377733,
0.0828094631,
-0.6890006661,
0.2032502145,
-0.4411251843,
-0.0965712219,
0.6589255929,
0.4907114506,
0.2769827247,
-0.3821831644,
-0.3151650131,
-0.0841347277,
-0.5156828761,
0.1863413751,
-0.1117608175,
0.296351254,
-0.1747704148,
0.8268389106,
-0.1578954309,
1.0964480639,
-0.4875889421,
-0.0693666786,
0.0899332091,
-0.4909903705,
-0.4397389591,
-0.3088246882,
0.6552024484,
0.5953997374,
0.6215701699,
-0.0869535282,
-0.2174879462,
0.0443400368,
0.1922865659,
-0.2972470224,
-0.2101848722,
0.2036594898,
-0.3536779284,
-0.0484726913,
-0.200178206,
-0.4569520652,
-0.9218115211,
-0.6093195081,
0.2787959874,
-0.5222803354,
0.0544584282,
0.2689261734,
-0.2192086428,
0.3309669793,
0.6994749904,
-0.6243320107,
-0.0576277412,
0.8198630214,
0.6482797265,
-0.1969358772,
-0.3222931623,
-0.5353964567,
0.0236802697,
-0.5500404835,
0.6168423891,
-0.4153119624,
-0.0841375217,
-0.0664929375,
-0.1430888623,
-0.312970221,
-0.4533454776,
0.57837677,
-0.4823471606,
-0.122732766,
-0.4921641946,
-0.6994909644,
-0.4539251924,
0.4093506634,
-0.7832214832,
0.5368053317,
0.0130754691,
-0.824557364,
0.4875022769,
-0.3956320286,
-0.4251233637,
0.3647953868,
-0.4806047082,
-0.139637664,
-0.2350673974,
0.4752712548,
0.7070640326,
-0.4542478621,
0.19310157,
-0.1378899515,
-0.2894693017,
0.3960719705,
-0.4537611008,
0.6292623281,
0.1040145457,
-0.2769317031,
0.4508742988,
-0.6270807385,
0.0095968451,
0.2965097427,
-0.0541483015,
-0.2002126127,
0.2410463542,
0.0353367068,
-0.0255306214,
0.0945926607,
-0.0379175134,
0.2557624876,
-0.2823782563,
0.4585799575,
0.6525298357,
-0.1205836385,
0.2087284625,
0.081781134,
0.504298389,
-0.0676721707,
0.1838390976,
-0.2496973723,
-0.8044446707,
-0.8599091172,
-0.306304127,
-0.0723312795,
0.5765169859,
-1.2241801023,
0.1819973141,
-0.480709672,
-0.6767528653,
-0.1470541954,
0.2403274477,
0.1196275651,
0.6747678518,
0.2537234426,
-0.1005077511,
-0.4255850613,
-0.9180479646,
-0.0533167347,
-0.0144296587,
0.1050205901,
0.3039624095,
0.6122027636,
-0.1248476952,
0.8648819327,
-0.3565948009,
-0.1955755055,
-0.7027692199,
0.0719012469,
0.2494537979,
-0.0695356131,
0.7085790634,
-0.8568527102,
-0.4837175012,
0.1427333802,
-0.9894628525,
0.0489142351,
-0.2347873151,
0.0368790925,
0.2406368554,
0.4706709087,
-0.4567017257,
0.6246976852,
0.6328684688,
-0.753467977,
0.5683839321,
-0.1742852032,
-0.0254075229,
-0.3078023493,
0.0650234371,
0.1342774928,
-0.339198947,
-0.8414357901,
0.0073437467,
0.0872317106,
-0.1224527955,
-0.3010610044,
0.4244706035,
-0.4806243181,
-0.2441265732,
-0.1067570746,
0.359251827,
0.1059354469,
0.3301610649,
0.1764047146,
0.3738662899,
0.9215078354,
-0.4908793867,
0.8475057483,
0.263130635,
-0.7337290645,
0.4179427922,
-0.5876802802,
-0.071810402,
-0.272790432,
0.2563696802,
-0.9172039032,
-0.0955091566,
0.2574188411,
-0.1753405333,
0.115863502,
-0.0364605859,
-0.4546021223,
-0.7143403292,
0.0301971324,
0.0808926374,
0.3430741429,
-0.5153941512,
0.5289537311,
0.1730814427,
0.0102904551,
-0.6996677518,
-0.7785456181,
0.4144228697,
-0.1558173895,
-0.9136441946,
-0.3521728814,
0.0027844869,
-0.5081493855,
-0.1949241459,
-0.0234513227,
0.0399305448,
0.0230759978,
0.1023042127,
0.5354861021,
-0.2223332971,
0.1140041649,
-0.5659319162,
-0.2181113213,
0.0524759069,
-0.1312427819,
0.4484315813,
-0.4332134128,
-0.8789896965,
-0.337364465,
0.036569193,
0.7620050907,
-0.6300536394,
0.6264290214,
0.5532232523,
-0.1373112798,
-0.091821447,
-0.4735603631,
0.0647393465,
-0.3986233175,
0.5145349503,
-0.232286334,
-0.8345330954,
0.4042966962,
0.539778471,
0.0902244747,
0.4495669305,
0.5002014637,
-0.1698978394,
0.9479916692,
0.1938598752,
0.0703671649,
0.0878529996,
-0.3702468276,
0.3451209068,
-0.5242073536,
-0.2953292131,
-0.2151659727,
-0.3510695696,
-0.2353279889,
-0.6718323827,
0.3865466118,
-0.195802018,
-0.1987496167,
-0.1782463044,
-0.4199405909,
0.2405100018,
0.4688658416,
-0.0963715613,
0.4213809073,
-0.188420862,
0.1957492232,
-0.1503359079,
-0.5754323006,
-0.5478786826,
1.0997992754,
0.391040802,
0.7511414886,
-0.1359003782,
0.1293585747,
0.1284781545,
0.1065450683,
-0.8775732517,
0.7220678329,
-0.1751014441,
-0.4724712968,
-0.5826983452,
-0.4604371786,
-0.9589396715,
0.4551430643,
-0.3926662207,
-0.819871366,
-0.0139372433,
0.1277191788,
0.0343388878,
0.5036382675,
-0.7910575867,
1.1399148703,
-0.6252400279,
-0.0658319145,
-0.0557247885,
-0.7364653945,
0.4416429698,
-0.1526388824,
0.4191744328,
-0.1496578753,
0.0674623027,
0.5260122418,
-0.2672425508,
0.8717755675,
-0.0668895543,
-0.243911311,
0.3919526637,
0.0745954514,
0.473601073,
-0.2764827907,
0.1169127971,
0.0014528322,
0.0074710697,
-0.3467502892,
-0.6636294723,
0.3936832845,
-0.3979973197,
-0.4510336518,
-0.2521782517,
-0.6759313941,
-0.3933008611,
0.1911726445,
-0.0488052852,
0.5406019092,
0.1787188053,
0.4837496281,
0.2811612189,
-0.3507362008,
0.2162957191,
0.3262258172,
-0.6710433364,
-0.0680697784,
0.9279153943,
0.1644067317,
0.4350989163,
0.3045607209,
0.0791603178,
-0.2737990916,
-0.9150873423,
-0.4269458055,
0.1644642651,
-1.1161853075,
0.1929227263,
-0.2890151441,
-0.1919203699,
-0.1436951309,
-0.0970817506,
-0.1677457392,
-0.381121099,
-0.0355089232,
-0.0318276584,
0.2593302727,
0.9754836559,
0.2572062314,
-0.1875583977,
-0.7091183066,
0.5364807844,
0.4757938981,
0.2085752934,
0.1848795712,
-0.2508651912,
-0.2162427753,
-0.0280595664,
0.0301070139,
-0.8627298474,
0.3632178307,
-0.3062287867,
0.5490976572,
0.4410849512,
-0.0545120351,
0.4374113977,
-0.2962175608,
0.7719638348,
0.208706513,
-0.7776396275,
0.2905680835,
-0.3958504498,
0.3333844244,
0.0476946384,
0.087804459,
-0.6656726599,
-0.635599196,
-0.2073359042,
-0.9239810109,
0.448748827,
0.340248853,
-0.2105630636,
0.2521719933,
0.1788050383,
0.0023199527,
0.1443570405,
-0.8444042802,
-0.2815240026,
-0.4702943265,
-0.2332773656,
-0.3183825612,
0.0087043531,
-0.0566881113,
-0.6109367013,
0.2087360471,
-0.2394924015,
-0.2493767142,
0.0492210686,
-0.0845458806,
0.0986614078,
0.2211492658,
0.5019065142,
1.0272008181,
-0.0437194593,
0.1852938831,
0.2258343101,
-0.3839226365,
-0.3416539431,
0.1303699762,
-0.1514032185,
-0.190597102,
0.9247075319,
1.3230142593,
0.1338802427,
-1.0808897018,
0.4831502438,
-0.1439597309,
-0.2175504267,
-0.1777179241,
-0.0844320655,
0.4452972412,
0.3713415265,
0.5283437967,
-0.0828594789,
-0.1596159041,
-0.4626554549,
-0.1764691472,
0.6101931334,
-0.2644059956,
0.1311866939,
0.6922186613,
0.1347284317,
0.1002594158,
0.7316646576,
0.0489739068,
-0.567348659,
0.812340498,
0.1197090298,
0.3971003592,
0.4144408703,
0.1468150914,
0.177539438,
0.6706803441,
0.2582597136,
0.2821754217,
0.1734830141,
-0.7340517044,
-0.7237400413,
-0.2868454456,
-0.6358706951,
0.127991274,
-0.4212382734,
0.1241523027,
-0.2868693471,
-0.0502590835,
0.0855022222,
-0.2893547118,
-0.9935775995,
0.2957958281,
0.5949150324,
0.8467869163,
-0.6019419432,
0.5534909964,
0.570302844,
-0.4724749625,
-0.7865785956,
-0.3016066253,
0.0489118323,
-1.0122300386,
0.9206095338,
0.2248616964,
0.030889621,
-0.1774426252,
-0.5748516321,
-0.6610469818,
1.090255022,
0.3521505892,
-0.6614367962,
-0.1555953473,
0.4304673672,
0.7207269669,
-0.2630928159,
0.0319270343,
0.6217722297,
0.9437988997,
0.1164695024,
-0.9879618287,
-0.0187704768,
0.0334546641,
-0.2712986171,
-0.0998823941,
-0.3019141555,
0.8176640272,
-0.3248356581,
-0.1964523494,
-0.1322663277,
0.5749379992,
0.2050025463,
0.4758961499,
0.6666164398,
0.3221836686,
0.8974143267,
-0.2716394961,
1.3890143633,
-0.1069208458,
0.1739953011,
0.9111567736,
-0.4162054658,
0.8608611226,
0.3627004325,
-0.065514043,
0.3494406939,
0.2968841195,
-0.1156484187,
0.1307653487,
0.1812795997,
0.1767032295,
-0.5643442273,
0.1343565881,
-0.2649064958,
0.5418984294,
0.412979275,
-0.2526839674,
-0.1209363863,
0.0630515963,
-0.3997136354,
0.0435756072,
-0.4442243576,
0.4517524838,
0.1304147094,
-0.5197975636,
0.7659640908,
-0.3948804438,
0.2036468238,
-0.6307007074,
0.1310636848,
0.1142937243,
0.028005464,
-0.0305775013,
-1.3488101959,
0.2216359973,
0.0983536392,
0.2458784133,
-0.309450984,
0.6819176078,
-0.208312273,
-0.5090218186,
0.3067939878,
0.6820393801,
0.0260022841,
-0.2121216506,
-0.581848979,
0.2874016166,
0.1382676065,
-0.3327474594,
-0.0618171096,
0.4829626381,
0.0087765567,
1.2522090673,
0.5003132224,
0.0557569824,
0.159384653,
0.5147877336,
0.6910604835,
-0.8007548451,
-0.3639256656,
-0.7467163801,
0.6451356411,
-0.0763095394,
-0.0490964353,
0.7866033912,
0.5038651824,
0.3523429036,
-0.1887030751,
0.9170585275,
0.2943206429,
0.5878648758,
-0.7961951494,
0.6896829009,
-0.6978746057,
0.2002424449,
-0.2955316007,
-0.6569107175,
-0.5127573013,
0.4749269187,
-0.6178606153,
-0.1482142806,
0.9004139304,
0.2554997206,
0.0688746944,
0.0799306631,
0.4722426534,
0.4123590291,
0.468470782,
0.7474892139,
1.0784757137,
0.1540204138,
0.8548574448,
-0.0837084129,
0.0807268992,
-0.1691315621,
-0.8150097728,
-1.1106652021,
-0.7523373365,
-0.0820728019,
0.0162364021,
-0.2771494389,
0.3589214087,
0.385714978,
-0.4798028171,
-0.1125893518,
-0.0096944869,
0.2003507018,
0.0000456635,
-0.201207146,
0.53054142,
-0.0565990135,
-0.5387021899,
0.5024889708,
0.518232882,
0.1453806609,
-0.5468580723,
-0.2086102515,
0.1384804696,
-0.0813394263,
0.7654788494,
0.1952551156,
-0.96156317,
-0.4108241796,
-0.0246204454,
-0.1857669801,
0.053826347,
0.6505318284,
-0.7642208338,
0.7209457159,
0.5323633552,
0.503005743,
0.5905560851,
-0.2466898412,
0.4052793384,
-0.3380178809,
0.1445812285,
0.2828917503,
0.7825978398,
0.6108858585,
0.0580169223,
0.5767579675,
0.1139612794,
-0.4120745659,
-0.7716130614,
0.3597460985,
-1.3216270208,
-0.3019522727,
1.0255212784,
0.1770797372,
-0.016120689,
-0.2728233337,
-0.6493237019,
0.0639455542,
0.1067724749,
0.4519915581,
0.8015691638,
-0.2465929687,
-0.313513279,
-0.9394029379,
0.2436294258,
0.2952021062,
-0.990876317,
0.3257021308,
0.7593135238,
-0.1230717152,
0.0502361171,
0.5584293604,
0.3052170575,
0.1995084286,
-0.0693211555,
-0.2165034115,
-0.1162922084,
-0.0911785215,
-0.0452167131,
0.1216263324,
0.2504608631,
0.129417628
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00252v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00252v3
|
Multi-Modal and Multi-Agent Systems Meet Rationality: A Survey
| 2024-06-01T01:17:25 | 2024-06-18T04:22:39 |
Bowen Jiang, Yangxinyu Xie, Xiaomeng Wang, Weijie J. Su, Camillo J. Taylor, Tanwi Mallick
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.MA
|
Rationality is the quality of being guided by reason, characterized by
logical thinking and decision-making that align with evidence and logical
rules. This quality is essential for effective problem-solving, as it ensures
that solutions are well-founded and systematically derived. Despite the
advancements of large language models (LLMs) in generating human-like text with
remarkable accuracy, they present biases inherited from the training data,
inconsistency across different contexts, and difficulty understanding complex
scenarios involving multiple layers of context. Therefore, recent research
attempts to leverage the strength of multiple agents working collaboratively
with various types of data and tools for enhanced consistency and reliability.
To that end, this paper aims to understand whether multi-modal and multi-agent
systems are advancing toward rationality by surveying the state-of-the-art
works, identifying advancements over single-agent and single-modal systems in
terms of rationality, and discussing open problems and future directions. We
maintain an open repository at https://github.com/bowen-upenn/MMMA_Rationality.
|
[
-0.4866144955,
-0.6902877688,
1.0079963207,
0.2009547353,
0.151044786,
0.0776387528,
-0.2146626115,
-0.3432204127,
0.0119590629,
0.1048723757,
-0.6221958399,
-0.1265358776,
-0.458647579,
0.3575536311,
0.1012348831,
0.6906353831,
-0.0456056595,
0.3744705617,
-0.216099903,
-0.6285524368,
-0.6239490509,
-0.6524206996,
-0.4504231811,
-0.3891348541,
0.4864659011,
0.3168586493,
0.9564743638,
0.4521649182,
0.2801218927,
0.4343470037,
0.2629759014,
0.4331732988,
-0.2908336818,
0.6196792722,
-0.3597646356,
-0.4013359845,
-0.5884109735,
0.3482301235,
0.6261174679,
0.5005981922,
0.0724826455,
-0.1884270161,
-0.1182180718,
0.5689617991,
-0.5547546744,
0.1891771108,
-0.2978690565,
-0.2708913982,
0.0834367871,
-0.3795850873,
-0.4086632729,
-0.3653044403,
0.0284885522,
-0.9589834809,
-0.2747134864,
0.2219789922,
0.5486167669,
0.2605244815,
-0.8077104092,
-0.5090931058,
-0.7123391032,
0.9498587251,
-0.4693601727,
0.3981018662,
0.2468368113,
0.5105971098,
-0.4615797698,
-0.3807228506,
-0.6722987294,
-0.2926288247,
0.1477534473,
0.0604706407,
0.1764118671,
-0.0358450003,
0.2093236893,
-0.038275104,
-0.2349800617,
-0.3451316357,
-0.0215839893,
-0.276394546,
0.560223341,
0.2715810835,
0.3161485791,
0.0716609806,
-0.678620398,
-0.0326804481,
-0.3850083053,
0.1605054438,
0.1775074899,
0.0746404752,
0.0913114175,
0.5913608074,
-0.3677468896,
0.4387213886,
-0.0847624913,
-0.5987778306,
0.068581298,
-0.8904409409,
-0.2752749622,
-0.3345118165,
0.5810540915,
0.2733362317,
0.2336771637,
-0.0589054637,
-0.5799158812,
0.2929432094,
0.0399467498,
-0.3634141684,
0.2025493681,
0.33493343,
-0.438675642,
-0.1617431641,
0.011224566,
-0.2846413553,
-0.5102074742,
-1.0377571583,
0.4652519822,
-0.6351067424,
-0.7206822038,
0.247541219,
-0.1227846965,
0.1798297167,
0.864154458,
-0.5435201526,
-0.030951431,
0.7529190183,
0.7209429145,
0.0818761587,
-0.647382021,
-0.2093612552,
0.2631895542,
-0.3929125071,
1.0550606251,
-0.504059732,
-0.0448950492,
-0.2226557732,
-0.0369444005,
-0.3600463867,
-0.3039450049,
0.5842864513,
-0.6490829587,
0.2908170819,
-0.6476311088,
-0.4085733891,
-0.2294466197,
0.7406595945,
-0.6027267575,
0.5309311748,
0.0263775084,
-0.504977107,
0.6030727625,
-0.7374151945,
0.1079137474,
-0.1220950931,
-0.3147433698,
0.1494512409,
0.0934160054,
-0.0311582461,
0.3128603995,
-0.5501644015,
0.5406581163,
-0.4319590628,
-0.10990455,
0.7891330719,
-0.6243668199,
0.6600536704,
0.4243957102,
-0.1229853779,
0.5657806396,
-0.7267811894,
0.1983722299,
-0.0301399212,
-0.4974673092,
-0.0962229371,
0.1434254795,
0.1159826145,
0.7333394289,
0.313088119,
-0.2309532315,
0.4007944465,
0.1206034645,
0.3965708613,
0.8826845288,
-0.1775453985,
0.5943149328,
-0.9031597972,
0.3952355683,
0.1250798404,
0.2831692696,
-0.2667301595,
-0.3863838911,
-0.5302878618,
-0.4890179932,
-0.0495387577,
0.5813169479,
-0.9189539552,
0.2333978415,
-0.1285595894,
-0.2128576785,
-0.2189169377,
-0.2060375363,
0.0157774799,
0.4083506763,
0.1006773114,
-0.0399107374,
-0.3036396503,
-0.7736524343,
-0.0573768951,
-0.1986073107,
0.0969710648,
-0.0076658661,
0.4572781622,
-0.5271022916,
1.0479848385,
0.0648262575,
0.0598587841,
-0.0775565952,
0.0507501327,
-0.2335015088,
0.5824560523,
0.2597599924,
-0.833960712,
-0.1911218017,
0.1106869057,
-1.135696888,
0.030219553,
-0.0769771188,
-0.1865227669,
0.4617567956,
0.132373482,
-0.7911664248,
0.1784508079,
0.2431787103,
-0.6464330554,
0.6459784508,
-0.0971224084,
0.5929108262,
-1.0829921961,
0.1231822968,
-0.1038432047,
-0.1888969094,
-0.71616292,
-0.1642825603,
-0.2127944231,
0.1587384045,
-0.0830949917,
0.2810201049,
-0.5581604838,
-0.182526052,
-0.3605957925,
0.2561841011,
0.1563477665,
0.4181597531,
-0.2241678089,
0.9406145215,
0.5153177977,
-0.4190299511,
0.4283958375,
-0.0145638995,
0.1534402668,
0.9760292172,
-0.3464522362,
0.0170950908,
-0.2918603122,
0.1694690436,
-0.6515347958,
-0.4663766921,
0.4012289047,
-0.5067887902,
-0.1603230387,
0.1585500985,
-0.5434408784,
0.2220876962,
-0.2489233315,
0.6596152782,
0.1040869579,
-0.1845367104,
0.7382034063,
0.4068062901,
-0.0495046414,
-0.7438827157,
-0.2159224153,
0.0621464103,
0.1387218237,
-1.2333830595,
-0.3730827272,
-0.1840418577,
-0.6857564449,
-0.133405745,
0.0150515893,
-0.2133095413,
-0.0326668583,
0.0246016271,
0.3021440804,
-0.3938117921,
0.3064832389,
-0.0521585643,
-0.1929662675,
0.17027013,
-0.2174568176,
0.4791016579,
-0.5258312821,
-0.4163873494,
-0.5627141595,
0.5302034616,
1.2035785913,
-0.2236438692,
0.8190270066,
0.2773374021,
-0.4446256161,
-0.1144838333,
-0.6499438286,
-0.2697203159,
-0.4402906895,
-0.1239556372,
-0.5513748527,
-0.810518086,
0.5308453441,
-0.2839763165,
-0.0717793629,
0.2670549154,
0.5126851201,
0.1663663685,
1.2964174747,
0.5206163526,
0.3268978298,
0.1813780516,
0.1360298544,
-0.0205086507,
-0.4630264938,
-0.5564240813,
-0.4563626945,
0.0278241187,
-0.381024152,
-0.3884178102,
0.4260973334,
0.268763721,
-0.3281667233,
0.0453235805,
-0.4609361291,
0.1902946681,
0.3960529566,
-0.1802987456,
0.7285530567,
-0.1677376628,
-0.2347539365,
0.1316689402,
-0.6739602089,
-1.0056928396,
0.9297545552,
0.3742753267,
0.4750456512,
0.3859933913,
0.2458920181,
0.3203770518,
0.4432469904,
-0.7215060592,
0.5091572404,
0.8487128019,
-0.7522591949,
-0.6471160054,
-0.3838810027,
-0.9827212691,
0.6933898926,
-0.397084713,
-0.197452426,
0.3471252024,
0.0247159284,
0.0063937153,
0.1088180915,
-0.5928267241,
0.7660269737,
-0.1419746876,
-0.4850026667,
-0.3817903399,
-0.6312466264,
0.4379454255,
-0.0239712484,
0.4144819379,
-0.4176305532,
-0.3918931186,
0.3683608174,
-0.2968838811,
0.3318883181,
-0.1366292536,
-0.2339930236,
0.3745614588,
-0.0229237303,
0.3637170196,
0.3422854841,
-0.0803564712,
-0.108331494,
0.3038751185,
-0.6831600666,
-0.5780630112,
0.6486887932,
-0.8411458731,
-0.4373780191,
-0.7711539268,
-0.7203223109,
-0.3623585403,
0.3981271982,
-0.1673035324,
0.6181274056,
-0.2060896456,
-0.0457115136,
0.7567259669,
0.2604650259,
0.4223577082,
0.6303682327,
-0.1223099083,
-0.6422516704,
0.8154063225,
0.2172473818,
0.3816021085,
-0.1129197329,
-0.1363137215,
-0.2486142963,
-0.4105886817,
-0.7249684334,
0.2093085349,
-0.7174835801,
-0.1441667974,
-0.5089959502,
0.0978823304,
-0.4689359367,
-0.2599021792,
-0.3112919927,
-0.3636438251,
-0.1410817206,
0.2922660708,
-0.0124267349,
1.1451117992,
-0.2219630331,
-0.1419136375,
-0.7863221765,
0.1792965233,
0.2934322059,
0.2405106425,
0.0337768756,
-0.0924447328,
-0.2225270271,
0.2152436525,
-0.4281650484,
-0.8766936064,
0.1890602708,
-0.481495291,
0.6036100984,
0.3813884556,
0.0165282451,
0.111064136,
-0.2109732479,
0.3818879426,
0.337082237,
-0.9401106834,
0.3884359598,
-0.7588207126,
0.1618182361,
0.6522075534,
0.3516298234,
-0.5093922615,
0.0514969714,
-0.2853621244,
-0.2858968079,
0.803573668,
0.3112356961,
-0.5806110501,
0.1464713961,
0.0161202122,
0.1021790802,
0.3447443247,
-0.6000559926,
0.0177725386,
-0.384244293,
-0.237385273,
0.1732993275,
-0.012035572,
-0.4434344172,
0.0385390855,
0.5966256261,
-0.3885325789,
0.1768477559,
0.3815915287,
-0.0357031152,
-0.2399518043,
0.8943231702,
0.8818815351,
1.0804036856,
0.025855802,
0.0696516931,
-0.1229724139,
-0.1190550327,
0.6462769508,
0.0410243906,
-0.1542816162,
-0.4436655045,
0.1858888119,
0.4694586992,
-0.1895834506,
-0.7488077879,
0.5660579205,
-0.0302865822,
-0.1451225132,
-0.3784328997,
-0.010720537,
-0.1081859767,
0.4758717716,
0.5296857357,
0.6945385337,
0.1446961761,
-0.9203037024,
-0.167127952,
0.6139383912,
-0.1910072267,
-0.4767099619,
0.332187295,
0.3082236946,
-0.2580587268,
0.1579637676,
-0.2727417946,
-0.247323364,
0.5642233491,
0.3580904901,
0.7226046324,
0.0566357337,
0.1077003852,
0.0555220135,
0.5587949753,
-0.4947618246,
0.5004805326,
-0.0370907262,
-0.9630156159,
-0.5441613793,
-0.1984757185,
-0.6140633225,
-0.2469998896,
-0.3303637505,
0.0539490022,
-0.3739792109,
-0.3488366902,
-0.2679969966,
-0.1863312721,
-0.2709029317,
0.1080050617,
-0.0452907868,
0.6181895733,
-0.5353497267,
0.797857523,
0.846516192,
-0.5356736779,
-0.7828748226,
-0.2177474052,
0.1040279195,
-0.3469820321,
0.3911722898,
0.2435355932,
-0.5392152071,
-0.2182821035,
-0.6663469076,
-0.9609950781,
1.3993985653,
0.4047277868,
-0.1408751309,
-0.0440525077,
0.1556250006,
0.4207906723,
-0.5073640347,
0.2488202304,
0.365280956,
0.9112401605,
-0.2247094512,
-0.9264290333,
0.1514521241,
-0.2706326544,
-0.1789498478,
0.088575989,
-0.812887013,
0.9660672545,
0.0050701546,
-0.4122657478,
0.0388738923,
0.4978060722,
0.5746697187,
0.868945837,
0.5215210319,
0.3423532248,
0.7814766765,
-0.2269513905,
0.6929557323,
-0.3551081121,
0.094260253,
0.5074014068,
-0.4688068032,
0.3517906666,
0.4384521544,
0.0688179582,
0.5004891753,
0.1148040593,
0.4910184741,
-0.038987603,
-0.1960266232,
-0.5619424582,
-0.6240010262,
-0.3447337449,
-0.4008584917,
0.2237796038,
0.3734550178,
0.0397453122,
-0.0372231975,
0.2599642277,
-0.1034766585,
0.3422473371,
-0.2336908728,
0.6575339437,
-0.1803210676,
-1.0540620089,
0.4879827797,
-0.0182826463,
0.7433829308,
-0.5741890669,
-0.016731469,
-0.0442002192,
0.0351544693,
-0.2257607132,
-0.513353765,
0.1060290188,
-0.4019201994,
-0.6444001198,
-0.344094187,
0.892795682,
-0.2809784412,
0.0011941786,
0.2342437208,
1.2406665087,
-0.1545822769,
0.0412400961,
-0.5320605636,
0.3030663431,
-0.3084772825,
-0.1922598183,
0.2657158077,
0.9252329469,
-0.1331875771,
0.8911153674,
0.7128095627,
-0.1829412878,
0.0845973268,
-0.1184165627,
1.0084023476,
-0.71983248,
-0.1213074327,
-0.461215049,
0.4545795619,
-0.1873206794,
-0.3844249249,
0.7501465678,
0.3399530649,
0.595483005,
0.0815940648,
0.718935132,
0.0355879925,
0.3453541398,
-0.3830422163,
0.5340945721,
-0.4080772698,
0.3149765432,
0.0181726106,
-0.7710061073,
-0.0558351316,
0.4824777842,
-0.0622755364,
0.1134301499,
0.844260931,
0.9150754809,
0.1239461154,
0.2945364714,
0.463490665,
-0.2295088321,
0.2322194129,
0.4368219972,
1.3732639551,
-0.2405712008,
0.3253404498,
0.0340083241,
-0.5004128814,
0.0117715774,
-0.419667989,
-0.7573663592,
-0.7418856621,
0.0214670114,
-0.2718160152,
0.0272250865,
1.3228888512,
0.6693878174,
-0.6992653608,
-0.2481112182,
-0.2091442049,
0.2347926348,
-0.0452697389,
-0.2312835306,
-0.2018290311,
-0.6693564057,
-0.5767999887,
0.5918698311,
0.5345445871,
0.1079012826,
-0.4957988262,
-0.3912111223,
-0.4002217352,
0.5863395333,
0.8493670225,
0.3557945192,
-0.7510703802,
-0.2691384852,
0.288333863,
-0.557867229,
0.0271375664,
0.9978326559,
-0.6826711893,
0.3431837857,
0.5853485465,
0.5183637738,
-0.3622940779,
0.007778829,
0.5883826017,
0.1030694693,
-0.0370904729,
0.2999204695,
0.441139102,
0.2916655838,
-0.0792028755,
0.5421907902,
0.5139663815,
-1.0576857328,
-0.6640661955,
0.4216268063,
-1.1084496975,
-0.279278785,
0.9881876707,
0.1541021615,
0.05959934,
-0.7339662313,
-0.6059470177,
0.1895452738,
-0.6909015179,
0.5255416632,
0.8330398798,
-0.3699790239,
0.0665859729,
-0.3381572366,
0.4534374774,
0.5459880829,
-0.9159936905,
-0.0870869383,
1.1094514132,
0.0541276038,
0.3375631571,
0.920337081,
0.0911383256,
0.3920558095,
0.0295866076,
-0.1063684896,
-0.1392785758,
-0.5621448159,
-0.3425704539,
0.5921583176,
0.2976012528,
0.2544115484
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01624v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01624v2
|
Unveiling Hidden Factors: Explainable AI for Feature Boosting in Speech Emotion Recognition
| 2024-06-01T00:39:55 | 2024-06-05T22:21:55 |
Alaa Nfissi, Wassim Bouachir, Nizar Bouguila, Brian Mishara
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, I.2.7; I.2.6; I.2.1; I.2.8
|
Speech emotion recognition (SER) has gained significant attention due to its
several application fields, such as mental health, education, and
human-computer interaction. However, the accuracy of SER systems is hindered by
high-dimensional feature sets that may contain irrelevant and redundant
information. To overcome this challenge, this study proposes an iterative
feature boosting approach for SER that emphasizes feature relevance and
explainability to enhance machine learning model performance. Our approach
involves meticulous feature selection and analysis to build efficient SER
systems. In addressing our main problem through model explainability, we employ
a feature evaluation loop with Shapley values to iteratively refine feature
sets. This process strikes a balance between model performance and
transparency, which enables a comprehensive understanding of the model's
predictions. The proposed approach offers several advantages, including the
identification and removal of irrelevant and redundant features, leading to a
more effective model. Additionally, it promotes explainability, facilitating
comprehension of the model's predictions and the identification of crucial
features for emotion determination. The effectiveness of the proposed method is
validated on the SER benchmarks of the Toronto emotional speech set (TESS),
Berlin Database of Emotional Speech (EMO-DB), Ryerson Audio-Visual Database of
Emotional Speech and Song (RAVDESS), and Surrey Audio-Visual Expressed Emotion
(SAVEE) datasets, outperforming state-of-the-art methods. To the best of our
knowledge, this is the first work to incorporate model explainability into an
SER framework. The source code of this paper is publicly available via this
https://github.com/alaaNfissi/Unveiling-Hidden-Factors-Explainable-AI-for-Feature-Boosting-in-Speech-Emotion-Recognition.
|
[
-0.5599434376,
-0.4111658037,
0.3181403875,
0.2136216462,
-0.2893595099,
0.0058347811,
-0.1259512454,
-0.4544135332,
0.1172570586,
0.3145403564,
-0.6711592078,
-0.2977043092,
-0.5614222884,
-0.1973605603,
-0.5961496234,
0.9766123295,
0.0242452547,
0.0362941623,
-0.1389196664,
-0.4062944055,
-0.1520524472,
-0.3912239075,
-0.477060318,
-0.4683812559,
0.2541351318,
0.4190270901,
0.3246091008,
0.6256958246,
0.1473834366,
0.3283353746,
-0.4151382148,
-0.0273589361,
-0.4684741795,
0.3578543961,
0.2027167976,
-0.279604882,
-0.3201867044,
-0.1568401456,
0.3655226529,
0.4739938974,
0.0898382068,
0.3052736521,
0.0997032374,
0.7867957354,
-0.6619746685,
0.3474297225,
-0.5656676888,
0.0406202078,
0.0162631199,
-0.2083075792,
-0.0462683439,
-0.1771111041,
0.4425908029,
-0.357236445,
0.3529192805,
-0.0237015169,
0.6832494736,
0.4870042503,
-0.1649204344,
-0.4141514599,
-0.5600591302,
0.480617255,
-0.5787448883,
0.2962018549,
0.4222071767,
0.284335196,
0.2935519218,
-0.4875821769,
-0.4798783362,
-0.2627476752,
0.0950404108,
0.0836018249,
-0.3185896575,
0.0427013971,
0.4734404087,
0.6436777115,
-0.4341385663,
0.1673073918,
0.0007483549,
-0.1785686761,
0.4705582261,
-0.0713718012,
0.2075657248,
-0.1428022534,
-0.1213152409,
-0.2162672877,
-0.1804436743,
0.6113176942,
0.2449575663,
0.4845719635,
-0.1728643328,
0.2652769387,
-0.1585330069,
0.0524049662,
0.0118809668,
0.0198040418,
0.2820335627,
0.2004703581,
-0.0537905097,
0.1901425719,
0.3852875829,
0.0496156663,
0.0455134325,
-0.0703826845,
-0.2156096995,
0.0637663528,
0.1763103157,
-0.981800139,
-0.0314339101,
0.6497656703,
-0.5251353383,
-0.3905598819,
-0.1958887726,
-0.9822610617,
-0.7220953107,
-0.0272795279,
0.5664975047,
-0.4840339422,
-0.3315749764,
-0.3178162575,
-0.0785702094,
0.0262084119,
0.0072781346,
-0.8215249777,
-0.0649578646,
0.6592191458,
0.713483274,
0.0449383818,
-0.1115892082,
-0.5441724062,
-0.2501039207,
-0.1324193925,
0.3295896351,
-0.7687261105,
-0.2398119122,
0.0315156803,
-0.0223418958,
0.2076591849,
-0.4122199416,
0.8356989026,
-0.1622500122,
0.1420560628,
-0.3052143157,
-0.5855900049,
-0.6131500006,
-0.1715779901,
-0.7213573456,
0.7277063727,
-0.0742434338,
-0.6626101136,
0.1967565417,
-0.8422119617,
-0.338955611,
0.0808956102,
0.1205086261,
-0.7532479763,
0.526245296,
0.4274677336,
0.3349784315,
-0.260825783,
0.2779499888,
-0.5683991909,
-0.5390905142,
0.3041627407,
-0.4802106023,
0.6385014057,
0.3665209115,
-0.6775312424,
0.3270113766,
-1.0019023418,
0.0686154813,
0.0490950681,
0.1572850794,
-0.0320758112,
-0.0245940369,
-0.1274816394,
0.0806260481,
0.0987630934,
-0.3085549474,
-0.3150351346,
-0.2141064852,
0.5170730948,
0.4971828461,
-0.1344405115,
0.2118456513,
-0.1586888731,
0.7732470036,
0.0025444031,
0.0719775334,
-0.6022822857,
-0.2703701854,
-0.7286090851,
-0.6387988925,
0.3534053266,
0.4426698983,
-0.4481230676,
0.481336832,
0.0858949646,
-0.4420646727,
-1.0977212191,
-0.2269892246,
0.5876643658,
0.8404960036,
0.2410666794,
0.0791714713,
-0.516248107,
-0.7432917953,
-0.2605506182,
-0.1024696603,
-0.0338458046,
0.6083456874,
0.2833164036,
-0.3025554419,
0.5485498905,
0.0337770544,
0.0545099229,
-0.0868755877,
0.5528250337,
-0.0051325448,
0.2759772241,
0.4197838306,
-0.944434464,
0.0293577798,
-0.1207225323,
-0.5825744271,
-0.3745188415,
0.0510103516,
0.1904814243,
0.0879398435,
-0.1201319993,
-0.1000987887,
0.7173926234,
0.3345989287,
-0.2889184952,
0.3542978764,
-0.2881736159,
0.342207253,
-0.7269487977,
0.3446102738,
-0.0235084947,
-0.2001211643,
-0.7190470099,
-0.0784110054,
-0.0774303302,
-0.7340669632,
-0.1856206805,
0.3878711164,
-0.2751801014,
-0.3999348581,
-0.5256248116,
0.1719925404,
-0.0656637624,
0.6318266988,
-0.1097828001,
0.5630072355,
0.8855153322,
-0.5674492717,
0.2705446482,
0.262465179,
-0.1226297021,
0.4187413752,
-0.5740867257,
0.0308167972,
-0.1824453324,
-0.0637198538,
-0.9060649872,
-0.1650406271,
-0.232929185,
-0.647890389,
0.1709370911,
-0.111061126,
0.0446370579,
-0.323248595,
-0.2310712337,
0.1323804408,
0.720715642,
-0.7466800809,
0.6876271963,
0.4394500554,
-0.3369708955,
-0.5579431653,
-0.2791670263,
0.0029750902,
-0.5339205265,
-0.5408747792,
0.3963697851,
-0.0081548914,
-0.171367839,
-0.0430296063,
-0.2489788234,
-0.1343652457,
0.4526346624,
0.6673952341,
-0.0004372165,
0.0513053872,
0.4104776978,
-0.0393691212,
-0.3463304639,
-0.0130687244,
0.0057351668,
0.3074519038,
-0.4713436663,
-0.0810578018,
-0.8216634393,
0.5178262591,
0.7727082968,
-0.3721347451,
0.3415184617,
1.1216230392,
-0.5169817209,
-0.3162211478,
-0.2974629402,
-0.2871370316,
-0.4061112702,
0.541490376,
-0.4772304296,
-0.9983051419,
0.9307320118,
-0.1924436837,
-0.1336189061,
0.3142310977,
0.398096025,
-0.1440150738,
1.2841842175,
0.8569588065,
-0.1958946586,
0.5125710964,
-0.0738305524,
0.3690550029,
-0.7210667729,
-0.1450710893,
-0.7341828942,
-0.3283727169,
-0.8534254432,
0.0003231823,
0.4326578081,
0.2224833965,
-0.0945448801,
-0.1042271778,
-0.4433549345,
0.1073076129,
0.3614662588,
0.1563038081,
-0.1814735979,
0.0182178672,
0.0159863848,
-0.0184046496,
-0.5126758218,
-0.3508263826,
0.6130589843,
0.4793395698,
0.4825962484,
-0.1036197096,
0.5860127211,
0.4863318801,
-0.1314710379,
-0.7578464746,
0.4049105942,
-0.3464711905,
-0.0536810197,
-0.3216784298,
-0.4065869749,
-0.4762221575,
0.0226255599,
-0.3680600822,
-0.9292931557,
0.206443727,
0.4106810093,
-0.4048813879,
0.0611587875,
-0.6074647307,
0.6695480943,
-0.4829707444,
-0.3965704739,
-0.3494592011,
-0.5408303738,
0.2836389542,
-0.0259082131,
0.0418670252,
-0.1380425245,
0.200407967,
0.7173463702,
-0.5139846802,
0.5551870465,
-0.3711203337,
0.0202753041,
-0.0699455664,
-0.0123779271,
0.4180835187,
-0.1729930937,
-0.399591893,
0.1013315693,
-0.09115953,
-0.2038888633,
-0.9725879431,
0.5576537848,
-0.4934624732,
-0.4013644159,
0.0279373005,
-0.6491874456,
-0.3689709306,
-0.0909592807,
0.1686633229,
0.6365571618,
0.1649361551,
0.321536243,
0.8134666085,
-0.3189775646,
0.5311896801,
0.3692669272,
-0.2544883788,
-0.3152205646,
1.1576811075,
-0.0870592594,
-0.0782364085,
0.2219310701,
0.5007869005,
-0.4187189639,
-0.489289701,
-0.1358857006,
-0.0852672458,
-0.4682909548,
0.1541017294,
-0.4246330857,
-0.1688778549,
-0.3841724098,
-0.0724491477,
-0.3463742733,
-0.5004890561,
-0.351791501,
-0.0529850423,
0.5113382936,
0.5096235275,
-0.0689934641,
0.1997108757,
-0.5471710563,
0.4208940864,
0.4404975772,
0.4742615521,
0.1462362707,
-0.787217021,
-0.1016497761,
0.0609306991,
0.0254882518,
-0.9807072878,
0.509331584,
0.435772419,
0.5996371508,
0.8841904998,
0.1803651303,
0.7722720504,
0.0003702411,
0.7313220501,
-0.1318888217,
-1.4038188457,
0.8896658421,
-0.0233191233,
-0.0025053113,
0.3945637643,
0.468883276,
-0.216444388,
-0.1558389962,
-0.8228151798,
-1.0753244162,
0.7390419245,
0.3855470717,
-0.2665255964,
0.5434215069,
0.5954496264,
0.261949867,
0.4147617519,
-0.5337097645,
-0.3663679361,
-0.319462359,
-0.2920024097,
0.0453951135,
-0.5664952993,
-0.0866132155,
-0.0577338822,
0.8811493516,
-0.1830864698,
0.3607477248,
-0.0943651944,
-0.1739055067,
0.0107555063,
0.429898113,
0.7222399116,
0.5151033998,
-0.5287212729,
0.1059698388,
-0.0568242595,
-0.2025618255,
-0.0749815181,
0.4279330075,
-0.0508978479,
0.0473624989,
0.2807848752,
1.3581917286,
0.2279448211,
-0.6617534757,
0.40457201,
-0.0093983319,
0.1247050166,
-0.0681473762,
0.1860883981,
-0.1895789951,
0.575876534,
0.2964465618,
-0.2046540678,
0.3860522807,
-0.5508806705,
0.196545139,
0.4468058646,
-0.8273229003,
-0.2691249549,
0.563165009,
0.4061568975,
-0.4565397501,
0.3219764233,
-0.2889266312,
-0.8983258605,
0.6831662059,
0.4133188725,
1.3034559488,
-0.3301441371,
0.3381197155,
0.2630745173,
0.0439876206,
0.1776289046,
0.589520216,
-0.585077405,
-0.3961831927,
-0.0031978302,
-0.4951375425,
-0.6626480222,
0.2689627409,
-1.0458173752,
0.0144914864,
-0.1393119097,
-0.0239297859,
0.0854406655,
0.0654549077,
-0.4515440464,
0.2069848329,
0.4101423621,
0.6010878086,
-0.8670994639,
0.4352694154,
0.374127686,
-0.35235852,
-0.7056754827,
0.1093552634,
0.1411869526,
-0.9470832944,
0.2843313813,
0.4157476127,
-0.2280168682,
-0.1166555285,
-0.4555101693,
-0.5376743078,
1.0537683964,
0.4091289937,
-0.5901441574,
0.3534416258,
-0.1359294653,
0.647557497,
-0.5697273612,
0.5239304304,
0.5886466503,
0.3625588119,
0.2952806056,
-0.6574200988,
-0.0502332151,
-0.4623095095,
0.1076289117,
-0.1846580803,
-0.4968271255,
0.5554029346,
-0.5548307896,
-0.0844899863,
-0.0507142134,
0.5341407657,
0.3440674841,
0.5595680475,
0.5979982018,
0.5149410367,
1.2779378891,
-0.180095017,
0.7408320904,
-0.3941192925,
0.256831646,
0.971806705,
-0.2451170534,
0.8236792684,
0.0896997899,
-0.0287433136,
0.427296102,
0.6472868919,
0.0146694984,
0.4246850908,
0.231971994,
-0.3169061244,
-0.2044724524,
-0.3668158948,
-0.2522625625,
0.8117796779,
0.3142598867,
-0.502938807,
-0.0481049046,
0.3929254711,
-0.088118583,
-0.315880537,
-0.5019401908,
0.7766842842,
-0.1162524596,
-0.2729784846,
0.5041911006,
-0.3976607919,
0.3001042604,
-0.5053146482,
-0.0765440241,
-0.2512102425,
-0.0511920974,
-0.2727415264,
-0.5564440489,
-0.038545832,
0.3887776732,
-0.4542988837,
-0.2640635073,
0.7209603786,
-0.6039584279,
-0.260042727,
0.1028165668,
0.2038174272,
0.2856525779,
-0.3066686094,
-0.7549793124,
0.0964149684,
0.2140526325,
0.0022278142,
0.1650526375,
0.5860605836,
0.0505424701,
1.0007654428,
0.3275817037,
0.1278670579,
-0.3058480024,
0.3061995804,
0.6449042559,
-0.8048223853,
-0.8114749193,
-0.5689320564,
0.7734440565,
-0.0635530353,
-0.1494258344,
0.390997231,
0.0788876563,
-0.027902035,
0.2747353017,
0.78510499,
0.1817057878,
0.6562766433,
-0.2805876732,
0.8272017837,
-0.5737341642,
0.3464053571,
-0.3023053408,
-0.4352491498,
0.1115339398,
0.4392705262,
0.0877580047,
0.3154607117,
0.5058292747,
0.6685917974,
0.3261843324,
0.4379796982,
0.4287673235,
0.4549679756,
0.3205611408,
0.4695635736,
0.6005858183,
-0.2518212497,
0.4725643694,
-0.4858523309,
-0.568636775,
-0.3506050706,
-1.1166199446,
-0.6237726808,
-0.9174176455,
-0.589566648,
-0.2651553452,
0.0683292076,
0.6830039024,
0.7849876285,
-0.8574286103,
0.1863469332,
0.1686969399,
0.3134552836,
-0.3841966093,
-0.2146415859,
0.4228207171,
-0.3205738366,
-0.4777435958,
0.4898812175,
0.4266878068,
-0.0267489329,
-0.2485062033,
-0.0054281955,
0.3426136076,
-0.0869910195,
0.3124161959,
0.5891765356,
-0.8462524414,
-0.1153338179,
-0.4140979946,
0.3578208089,
-0.2197453529,
0.8153654337,
-0.8100995421,
0.8097499013,
0.391936928,
0.8257537484,
0.467977196,
0.0375824161,
0.4081529975,
-0.5748675466,
0.0498495735,
0.3181141913,
0.3938894868,
0.3863637447,
-0.3806235194,
0.287237823,
0.0655532107,
-0.5876062512,
-1.034076333,
0.0272337515,
-1.0775299072,
0.0059437826,
0.6844585538,
-0.3381504118,
-0.1703608483,
0.163386628,
-0.0371199921,
0.3731486797,
-0.4252713323,
1.1762496233,
0.5131560564,
-0.5661672354,
-0.5750884414,
-0.1500417292,
0.8631477952,
0.4591943026,
-0.8591851592,
0.3760105371,
0.3701116145,
-0.0011325392,
0.1060671583,
-0.0073060263,
-0.0348394103,
0.3714323342,
-0.0692326874,
0.1945905536,
-0.3473328948,
-0.2530189455,
-0.9751519561,
0.4189524055,
-0.2701857686,
-0.3312381208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00244v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00244v1
|
Controlling Large Language Model Agents with Entropic Activation Steering
| 2024-06-01T00:25:00 | 2024-06-01T00:25:00 |
Nate Rahn, Pierluca D'Oro, Marc G. Bellemare
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The generality of pretrained large language models (LLMs) has prompted
increasing interest in their use as in-context learning agents. To be
successful, such agents must form beliefs about how to achieve their goals
based on limited interaction with their environment, resulting in uncertainty
about the best action to take at each step. In this paper, we study how LLM
agents form and act on these beliefs by conducting experiments in controlled
sequential decision-making tasks. To begin, we find that LLM agents are
overconfident: They draw strong conclusions about what to do based on
insufficient evidence, resulting in inadequately explorative behavior. We dig
deeper into this phenomenon and show how it emerges from a collapse in the
entropy of the action distribution implied by sampling from the LLM. We then
demonstrate that existing token-level sampling techniques are by themselves
insufficient to make the agent explore more. Motivated by this fact, we
introduce Entropic Activation Steering (EAST), an activation steering method
for in-context LLM agents. EAST computes a steering vector as an
entropy-weighted combination of representations, and uses it to manipulate an
LLM agent's uncertainty over actions by intervening on its activations during
the forward pass. We show that EAST can reliably increase the entropy in an LLM
agent's actions, causing more explorative behavior to emerge. Finally, EAST
modifies the subjective uncertainty an LLM agent expresses, paving the way to
interpreting and controlling how LLM agents represent uncertainty about their
decisions.
|
[
-0.4048507512,
-1.0834944248,
0.7612547874,
0.1675183624,
-0.0206577014,
0.0657628924,
-0.4748319089,
-0.2350459099,
0.2024212927,
0.0984430239,
-0.3760138154,
-0.2763665617,
-0.7657654881,
-0.0618855022,
-0.1770381182,
0.8521924019,
-0.3596223295,
-0.1517144591,
-0.1224881783,
0.0675652027,
-0.2871423364,
-0.3179880381,
-0.9112511873,
-0.8028092384,
0.4741217494,
0.4137685001,
1.0774064064,
0.1990725547,
-0.0054492527,
0.3914526701,
0.0079574389,
-0.1071588024,
-0.5460689068,
0.5281916857,
-0.3034247756,
-0.7308356762,
-0.2403918654,
0.1820768416,
0.610776484,
0.4133311212,
-0.3042851388,
-0.2743758559,
0.0954249874,
0.3014388084,
-0.739059031,
0.2451869845,
-0.6032477617,
0.0559025034,
0.0309850127,
-0.406139642,
-0.4750329852,
-0.1438467205,
0.2478993386,
-0.504660368,
-0.2717812657,
-0.0807961449,
0.4263390601,
0.5200785995,
-0.6699713469,
-0.5227486491,
-0.8708928227,
0.6360012293,
-0.7482366562,
0.3522499502,
0.6859970689,
-0.039656166,
-0.3015249074,
-0.4191099405,
-0.6403470635,
-0.3770672381,
0.1273156255,
0.1586930454,
-0.0205783285,
0.2423891276,
0.1571343243,
-0.3362132609,
-0.2608472407,
0.5291458964,
-0.084735848,
0.0060699009,
0.4343269169,
0.0326351672,
0.0285333134,
0.261467278,
-0.419190675,
-0.2481621206,
-0.9194006324,
0.2066604942,
0.4383555353,
0.1155971065,
-0.0568271056,
0.7143977284,
-0.0897524059,
0.5194173455,
0.4794208705,
0.0156736542,
0.2159034014,
0.2481775731,
-0.6382275224,
0.4372241199,
0.392691046,
0.2911975086,
0.0582021438,
-0.0910977274,
-0.526776433,
-0.1756083518,
0.2375395447,
-0.5886234045,
0.3434036076,
0.7128540277,
-0.0915063247,
-0.2213716656,
0.0267645475,
-0.3867961764,
-0.3700723946,
-0.4810878634,
0.6435898542,
-0.3792181909,
-0.3558360636,
-0.0007693771,
-0.1781038493,
0.5291861892,
0.368165791,
-0.8256275654,
0.1797690839,
0.6712716818,
0.4966393709,
-0.1853292733,
-0.560218215,
-0.3120150268,
0.3788867295,
-0.7309136391,
0.3485920131,
-0.8341256976,
-0.1857453287,
0.268206954,
0.0137380855,
-0.2416358441,
-0.5450863242,
0.0487045497,
-0.9139878154,
0.0001298189,
-0.2036532313,
-0.4978298545,
-0.2660360336,
0.5733642578,
-0.3834933937,
0.849601686,
-0.1124291047,
-0.6178426147,
0.4986518323,
-0.4382882416,
-0.3690253794,
-0.1657364815,
-0.3882817328,
-0.0336088128,
0.2886621654,
-0.1082240045,
0.4273909926,
-0.0300174151,
0.4226949811,
-0.2643043101,
-0.1066383123,
0.6097416878,
-0.4039562047,
0.5859025121,
0.0633779988,
-0.6720519066,
0.3893970549,
-0.3817645311,
-0.0033430557,
-0.054385595,
-0.3419930935,
-0.4887880087,
0.1518427283,
-0.5601574183,
0.344645828,
0.2711530328,
-0.3131063879,
0.0017079884,
-0.3151363432,
0.3342728317,
0.9967268705,
0.2322590798,
0.9134927988,
-0.3946351707,
0.6257365346,
0.0111938445,
-0.0555107743,
0.1354108751,
-0.3220901489,
-0.9232956767,
0.0994644389,
-0.2324127555,
0.3513127863,
-1.0990316868,
0.4655463994,
0.0152210183,
-0.4073102474,
-0.1596165448,
-0.0125087863,
0.1400302351,
0.1621373296,
0.0686488375,
-0.125294134,
-0.0333110914,
-0.639020443,
0.0165358372,
-0.2240623087,
0.0958958119,
0.0405768491,
0.6383786201,
-0.2059099227,
0.8970714211,
-0.107789129,
-0.0958026499,
-0.3979047835,
0.4440484941,
0.1248240843,
0.7123527527,
0.127935946,
-0.8916317821,
-0.3926190734,
-0.0488012731,
-0.6177281737,
0.0775957257,
-0.4596380889,
-0.1683656871,
0.3125331104,
0.9729549885,
-0.9879328609,
0.4600857496,
0.3733845949,
-0.3437980413,
0.4949694872,
-0.4704227448,
-0.1326604635,
-0.466707021,
-0.2832284868,
-0.1464225352,
-0.1375951618,
-0.7029827237,
0.259023428,
0.0597588606,
0.3667737246,
-0.436563015,
0.2995374799,
-0.5452248454,
0.0996406004,
-0.4577456713,
-0.080572471,
-0.3947712779,
0.6821324825,
0.3193904161,
0.193235904,
0.7268117666,
-0.6843476295,
0.1945652962,
-0.1208521649,
-0.1501419842,
0.5136505365,
-0.5771685243,
0.1265387386,
-0.5804293156,
0.3259189725,
-0.7893410921,
-0.3324371278,
0.2291425616,
-0.345836848,
0.7397441864,
0.2186198086,
-0.3760743737,
0.1633205414,
-0.2336460352,
0.1847918928,
0.4507181048,
-0.2421871424,
0.77579844,
0.2294946462,
-0.299146384,
-0.5115253329,
-0.8161872029,
-0.1767148226,
-0.2934191823,
-0.1391766667,
0.3629912436,
-0.0023254645,
-0.5768178105,
0.0070352745,
-0.0617397837,
0.0750770122,
-0.0985508785,
0.4754239619,
-0.116611138,
0.1134159267,
0.2625186145,
0.227725178,
0.0475244671,
0.3986092806,
-0.3048470914,
0.5427579284,
0.2004672736,
-0.7185836434,
-0.0812823847,
0.1860576421,
0.7846052647,
-0.0984468013,
0.8410699368,
0.2927765846,
-0.3298755288,
-0.5309576392,
-0.3615581393,
-0.3485692739,
-0.5214949846,
0.5049189925,
-0.1927972585,
-0.6352263689,
0.4759226739,
-0.0213852189,
0.2249635011,
0.0860922784,
0.9016283154,
0.0815307274,
1.0201078653,
0.5907133818,
0.014275426,
0.6218319535,
-0.3002640009,
-0.0094503323,
-0.5919965506,
-0.311389327,
-0.2911353111,
-0.7038899064,
-0.5546242595,
-0.8283461332,
0.4539891183,
-0.1073577106,
-0.8668474555,
-0.2072449625,
-0.0365973599,
0.3692288101,
0.5397136211,
0.2311809361,
0.0113038952,
-0.3087953031,
-0.248955965,
0.2297512591,
-0.7736126781,
-0.2364415228,
0.8611183763,
0.4955787361,
1.1393092871,
0.094331108,
0.6974129677,
-0.057879407,
0.485343039,
-0.7413281798,
0.3839293122,
0.7291363478,
-0.7641425133,
-0.7679877281,
-0.0197242759,
-0.942096591,
0.267935127,
-0.1308439821,
-0.6517973542,
0.5273805261,
0.0407527164,
-0.2542632818,
0.2073873729,
-0.4563570619,
0.6504198909,
-0.3885376751,
-0.5564793348,
-0.4204049408,
-0.7936936617,
0.1723781079,
-0.1310790926,
0.2678534687,
0.0967120528,
-0.403759867,
0.4313421845,
-0.2836821377,
1.1650758982,
-0.4924567938,
-0.3151180446,
0.4128503203,
0.4073728919,
1.1081719398,
-0.0550815985,
-0.1683881283,
-0.3790678084,
-0.6136810184,
-0.1674820334,
-0.7317774296,
0.5089272261,
-0.7143490314,
-0.7753295898,
-0.3519096076,
-0.4662266076,
-0.1943004131,
0.0723194107,
0.3960045576,
0.4158224761,
-0.0828457922,
0.2781963944,
0.6158282161,
-0.3381804824,
0.5401584506,
0.5984835625,
-0.2407868207,
-0.044874616,
0.6056291461,
0.2393832952,
0.862249136,
0.3652931452,
0.0417462699,
-0.3176109195,
-0.7778857946,
0.0232597757,
-0.1573864967,
-0.8069683313,
-0.0892257616,
-0.2208486795,
-0.1023843437,
-0.2433574796,
-0.4222975671,
-0.3102031648,
-0.0881672055,
-0.1486325413,
-0.4795820713,
0.0018432458,
0.7720035315,
-0.2366331369,
0.423907131,
-0.1859184206,
-0.0295432657,
0.3380883336,
0.0298805591,
0.3124527037,
-0.5363497138,
-0.206943363,
0.0094432002,
-0.3917662799,
-1.0787956715,
0.7003297806,
0.1052816063,
0.7324806452,
0.7342852354,
0.2638016045,
0.4411133826,
-0.427867353,
0.605856359,
0.0609221719,
-0.8128178716,
0.2105667889,
-0.2302676141,
0.3147540689,
0.2565259933,
0.7570133209,
-0.2951905727,
-1.0733108521,
-0.5722848773,
-1.0005888939,
0.5025092959,
-0.0233135801,
0.0864030421,
0.0457055978,
-0.0217253305,
0.1497963667,
0.2602573335,
-0.7560595274,
-0.2550809383,
-0.0629084334,
-0.0101141119,
-0.3478674591,
-0.1393069923,
-0.2313215137,
-0.231364876,
0.6495796442,
-0.2666909099,
0.1965072751,
0.5084212422,
-0.1956838965,
-0.386438638,
0.4456551969,
0.5391978621,
0.7509328723,
-0.1318453103,
0.5254166126,
0.2665372193,
-0.0978121534,
0.3724469543,
-0.0063288487,
-0.3140909076,
-0.3179178238,
0.3667529821,
0.7056773305,
0.4138240516,
-0.5969068408,
0.3614760339,
0.2762612104,
-0.0772675797,
-0.4853943586,
-0.1215332672,
0.0814986154,
0.5244643688,
0.4802514315,
0.1336984634,
-0.076437071,
-0.6989104748,
-0.0513696298,
0.6366637945,
-0.5586664677,
-0.4407050908,
0.5361144543,
0.1231878027,
-0.1246619374,
0.4757205248,
-0.558018744,
-0.7930233479,
0.7251435518,
0.7197349668,
0.9640030861,
-0.0641625002,
0.2280420363,
0.1288381815,
0.6084319949,
-0.0996693,
0.2201644033,
-0.0788735598,
-1.2748712301,
-0.5657461882,
-0.3021742404,
-0.4323157966,
-0.0145666078,
-0.6484447718,
-0.1031849459,
-0.4248176813,
-0.1897488534,
-0.5043599606,
-0.3484665453,
-0.7171914577,
0.075751774,
0.2025947571,
0.9784255624,
-0.7779837847,
0.8219140172,
0.6381477118,
-0.033563707,
-0.808555007,
0.1096204892,
0.1458245814,
-0.8698906898,
0.890337646,
-0.0281165224,
0.0914504603,
0.017223157,
-1.0265598297,
-0.88234514,
1.0070931911,
0.2084613293,
-0.3610213995,
-0.0586067289,
0.0348186679,
0.324690491,
-0.3497493565,
0.3049111366,
0.7160564661,
0.7529025674,
0.1511236876,
-0.8444228768,
0.3574382961,
0.1250540316,
-0.4501024783,
0.1246184558,
-0.5981439948,
1.0508208275,
-0.4936558604,
-0.204687655,
-0.1884000748,
0.6428441405,
0.3764073253,
0.2403721064,
0.6103151441,
0.4893816411,
0.7396741509,
0.0877839327,
0.9937875867,
-0.2677715421,
0.0594687834,
1.1820828915,
-0.4741336107,
0.9855731726,
0.7468716502,
0.117717661,
0.5306834579,
0.5605344772,
0.4989854395,
0.5844120979,
0.2537545264,
-0.2553750873,
-0.3420008421,
-0.0165440608,
-0.0208001658,
0.4153952301,
0.666476965,
-0.2950680554,
-0.1602482498,
0.0758944079,
-0.0758905858,
-0.197451055,
-0.4691258371,
0.6912235022,
0.1235283092,
-1.0101121664,
0.3428207934,
-0.0461467654,
0.698631227,
-0.7672400475,
0.1261406392,
0.2089608014,
0.0827903897,
-0.0942716748,
-0.7823146582,
0.008243341,
-0.3425321579,
0.2412649393,
-0.5644453168,
0.6872962117,
-0.7298348546,
0.0372806899,
0.2926438153,
0.6630523801,
0.0540710278,
-0.1194064096,
-0.4514426589,
-0.0303366873,
-0.0740673989,
-0.7404729724,
0.3042822182,
0.7800148726,
0.0276815314,
0.7826105952,
0.3707987666,
0.378713429,
0.1543842405,
-0.2249326557,
0.7873411179,
-0.5800119638,
-0.628673017,
-0.931545496,
0.3550524414,
0.1608291268,
-0.1583676785,
0.7002615929,
0.1577275842,
0.9067487121,
0.1271145642,
0.7796644568,
-0.2572037876,
-0.1162332892,
-0.6758425832,
0.5513314009,
-0.3055034876,
-0.0669848248,
0.1774181128,
-0.7298830152,
0.1117626205,
0.4844261408,
-0.479432106,
0.0845631436,
0.7055438757,
0.8468401432,
0.3795388639,
-0.1088586897,
0.3350952864,
0.5712750554,
0.4072476029,
0.7320374846,
1.238978982,
0.2958265841,
0.0817711726,
-0.1822342575,
-0.2541978657,
-0.0494428873,
-0.9132986069,
-0.7473045588,
-0.4789218903,
-0.1758446842,
-0.2286912501,
-0.1797397137,
1.4614379406,
0.7369666696,
-0.6580681801,
-0.2168956101,
-0.2241735458,
0.4325219393,
-0.2417692393,
-0.1923336685,
0.21148251,
-0.6092095971,
-0.9370054603,
0.3622672856,
0.1699163169,
0.3429107666,
-0.4245778024,
-0.4131492078,
-0.091731362,
0.0364452824,
0.4744816124,
0.3455379307,
-0.5476717949,
-0.1841885895,
-0.3463619053,
-0.1371935308,
-0.1374449134,
0.8887298107,
-0.68513304,
0.4200659394,
0.5503607392,
0.4486780465,
0.3949998915,
-0.1217400655,
0.956920743,
-0.6124206781,
0.2747149765,
0.4257035851,
0.255892396,
-0.0258684102,
-0.1736185104,
0.1089285612,
-0.1503178775,
-0.7070962787,
-0.6501307487,
0.015604971,
-0.5464850664,
-0.4590669572,
1.4182134867,
0.0048856055,
-0.261454463,
-0.1040020809,
-0.1107250974,
0.2061218768,
-0.5179060698,
0.4783534706,
0.6820172668,
-0.2606344223,
0.2195848227,
-0.6958062053,
0.6786871552,
0.3227058649,
-0.5738508105,
0.11799144,
0.3429110646,
0.0021910719,
0.1677372754,
0.614803791,
0.1744586378,
-0.0312857702,
0.0140609564,
-0.1075885147,
0.0080100838,
-0.4867654145,
-0.5136472583,
0.1801949441,
0.3033663332,
0.0152710546
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00240v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00240v1
|
Exploring Vulnerabilities and Protections in Large Language Models: A Survey
| 2024-06-01T00:11:09 | 2024-06-01T00:11:09 |
Frank Weizhen Liu, Chenhui Hu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
As Large Language Models (LLMs) increasingly become key components in various
AI applications, understanding their security vulnerabilities and the
effectiveness of defense mechanisms is crucial. This survey examines the
security challenges of LLMs, focusing on two main areas: Prompt Hacking and
Adversarial Attacks, each with specific types of threats. Under Prompt Hacking,
we explore Prompt Injection and Jailbreaking Attacks, discussing how they work,
their potential impacts, and ways to mitigate them. Similarly, we analyze
Adversarial Attacks, breaking them down into Data Poisoning Attacks and
Backdoor Attacks. This structured examination helps us understand the
relationships between these vulnerabilities and the defense strategies that can
be implemented. The survey highlights these security challenges and discusses
robust defensive frameworks to protect LLMs against these threats. By detailing
these security issues, the survey contributes to the broader discussion on
creating resilient AI systems that can resist sophisticated attacks.
|
[
-0.2635112703,
-1.3335331678,
0.568731308,
-0.1044978425,
0.2582571507,
0.2789419293,
-0.1228423864,
-0.4836017489,
-0.0904498324,
0.846883297,
-0.445030123,
-0.2412631363,
-0.694942534,
0.0634669885,
-0.5649051666,
0.9089675546,
0.2033050209,
0.0354800522,
-0.2561874688,
0.1230014935,
-0.6584532857,
-0.8883836269,
-0.8222034574,
0.0726453364,
0.4904276133,
0.1137188375,
0.7284644842,
0.1568779051,
0.6012769341,
0.4420546293,
-0.1546001881,
-0.280277878,
-0.3450416625,
0.5860065818,
-0.0560440794,
-0.5737489462,
-0.4924119115,
-0.1172600165,
0.4542672336,
0.5219177604,
0.0585074276,
0.0835013539,
-0.238425225,
0.5731223226,
-0.5872037411,
-0.132771045,
-0.8415448666,
0.0430104248,
-0.6076490879,
0.0837684795,
-0.5595733523,
-0.2418610752,
-0.0624203943,
-0.0526823364,
-0.223865509,
0.1879339665,
0.4405258894,
0.2258215994,
-0.6145811081,
-0.2616494298,
-0.6045285463,
0.7727279067,
-0.7162262201,
0.2085052878,
0.4474715889,
0.4460392892,
-0.4004529417,
-0.5257043839,
-0.3674001098,
-0.6418094039,
0.1873250902,
-0.2522195578,
-0.5382428169,
0.0194534771,
0.3401508033,
0.3965321481,
-0.893925786,
0.6253359914,
-0.2242278457,
-0.2870765626,
0.9647977352,
0.515175581,
0.7620660067,
-0.0054262825,
-0.1769274026,
-0.1193157881,
-1.1139878035,
-0.1322772652,
0.74150002,
0.0877032354,
-0.0271503888,
0.6094257832,
0.2462777644,
0.7174271941,
-0.5061467886,
-0.0317729488,
-0.1698574573,
-0.2989929318,
-0.1233054847,
-0.2435281128,
0.8912892938,
0.0621791333,
0.1870421171,
-0.1700906008,
-0.2985463738,
-0.4303990006,
0.2456201613,
-0.6205942631,
-0.1480962187,
0.505884409,
-0.4099021554,
-0.4536498189,
0.0405268334,
-0.9511768222,
-0.8760991693,
0.2789737284,
0.0115544181,
-0.2185765207,
-0.2850346267,
-0.1544618905,
-0.0986583903,
0.3280802071,
0.2125184238,
-0.7390375733,
0.2635737062,
0.8417839408,
0.7817999125,
-0.1628017128,
-0.3147348166,
-0.5394295454,
0.1313159168,
-0.2729289532,
0.469840467,
-0.2736440301,
-0.7064756155,
0.289891541,
-0.1788439751,
0.0299931355,
-0.5250920057,
0.2750146985,
-0.7669746876,
0.0289272442,
-0.0706203654,
-0.5617908835,
0.0525678545,
0.7609737515,
-0.8630098701,
0.7040039897,
-0.0748583525,
-0.8564773202,
-0.3389900029,
-0.4621174932,
-0.520339787,
0.0776434913,
-0.2891799808,
-0.3650866449,
0.0876055211,
0.1435305029,
0.4941364229,
-0.4738881588,
0.1581385583,
-0.4743469059,
-0.0020846801,
0.6119528413,
-0.6744332314,
1.0342583656,
0.2341527939,
-0.0027408248,
0.4391673803,
-0.7302011847,
-0.1265555471,
0.5766285658,
-0.2019741088,
-0.361612767,
0.118161045,
-0.076632753,
-0.0050255628,
0.4268892109,
-0.3199857771,
0.6707243323,
-0.5112407207,
0.6832744479,
0.9081274271,
0.3057502508,
0.2547999024,
-0.0601084419,
0.8166982532,
-0.0960107818,
0.4018894732,
-0.2560328543,
-0.4271371067,
-0.3405424356,
-0.3383621573,
0.1719857156,
0.9315906167,
-0.6960964799,
0.5587313175,
0.103528738,
-0.7084470987,
-0.1189515218,
0.1997124404,
0.3920826018,
0.0838233605,
0.0717225671,
0.0796816945,
-0.3267801106,
-0.8594261408,
-0.2975807786,
-0.4299280643,
-0.1572345793,
0.2677412629,
0.6884649992,
-0.3977777362,
0.5419963002,
-0.660995543,
-0.0012539008,
-0.4846768081,
-0.1620300412,
0.0727164745,
0.5174867511,
0.7757481337,
-0.62377882,
-0.1708138436,
-0.2258344144,
-0.6292074323,
0.0028197155,
-0.0856185853,
0.1844422221,
0.2301351279,
0.8335306644,
-0.8470168114,
0.3105068505,
0.5468319654,
-0.4335339069,
0.7399184704,
0.1104467213,
-0.009296746,
-1.0541588068,
0.02791043,
-0.2037149817,
-0.1537236869,
-0.8033115268,
0.4717270732,
-0.2039808035,
-0.4505073428,
-0.4884829223,
0.6187905669,
-0.3734421432,
-0.1039082035,
-0.0322630778,
-0.1181539893,
-0.1063001379,
-0.0948940963,
-0.395960629,
0.8298929334,
0.8075492382,
-0.4431608617,
0.8069512844,
0.1943541318,
-0.3968893588,
0.1984587759,
-0.8764774799,
0.4240436554,
0.1525112242,
0.3287185431,
-1.0383838415,
-0.3199709356,
0.3962532878,
-0.5965477824,
0.6040303111,
-0.0668984428,
-0.655801177,
-0.2727348804,
-0.645483911,
0.4356552958,
0.3097275496,
-0.4316280782,
0.4283584058,
0.508552134,
-0.3047860861,
-0.6935542822,
-0.706284523,
0.4419561625,
-0.3191220164,
-0.757555902,
-0.0353151746,
-0.1915789396,
-0.7194913626,
-0.2216112167,
0.2742847502,
-0.0447417684,
0.7167191505,
0.1995918006,
0.4356562793,
-0.1448341012,
-0.3624064624,
-0.3935260475,
0.0283707548,
0.3870190382,
0.0259105489,
0.8196669817,
-0.0126715815,
-0.7350121737,
-0.3826942742,
0.7075859904,
0.7815855145,
-0.3902267218,
0.9121879935,
0.2925321758,
-0.3564396799,
-0.0814455524,
-0.4765922725,
-0.1707283109,
-0.4893108904,
0.6668884754,
-0.2932533026,
-1.0705527067,
0.6831255555,
0.0902597606,
0.2699920833,
0.3287384212,
0.7377843857,
0.1529127061,
1.1079947948,
0.5109302998,
-0.6588817239,
0.4252303541,
-0.0858770013,
0.320856452,
-0.5058397055,
-0.3409232795,
-0.7781937122,
0.0384320654,
-0.5266121626,
-0.1355819404,
0.2785473466,
-0.1098509282,
-0.2895644009,
0.1584795117,
-0.203741312,
0.4351327717,
0.4492423534,
-0.320130229,
0.0220294632,
-0.3945592642,
0.2632562816,
0.2140755653,
-0.3153008521,
-0.4161421061,
0.9674988389,
0.6334640384,
1.0602915287,
0.6171412468,
0.5641949177,
0.3485682011,
-0.0418629199,
-0.8088364601,
0.6968218684,
0.1080567464,
-0.8801628947,
-0.3195248544,
-0.5738105774,
-0.9565781355,
0.0742954686,
-0.0481904447,
-1.0782233477,
-0.261387974,
0.0303190667,
-0.2825890779,
0.5172642469,
-0.5963903666,
0.7611761689,
-0.5339586139,
-0.1297793984,
-0.0689462498,
-0.6830099821,
0.7584161162,
-0.1110693291,
0.1360105574,
0.0779150352,
0.1726733297,
0.5132229328,
-0.3212643266,
0.8920173645,
-0.0198347587,
-0.23713319,
0.2153962553,
0.3816608489,
0.588611722,
0.2834545672,
0.0271549225,
0.2183406055,
0.0412921794,
-0.4393081367,
-0.4264938235,
0.8124034405,
-0.7331254482,
-1.243698597,
-0.7075545788,
-0.5039695501,
-0.3580341935,
0.0757113993,
0.1335752457,
0.2054395825,
-0.4256187081,
0.169745326,
0.8254759312,
-0.6644619107,
0.6523156166,
0.4264326394,
-0.3077373207,
-0.452695936,
0.7422142625,
0.0305493213,
0.408121556,
0.3078297377,
0.0465269983,
-0.0937449485,
-0.8243730068,
-0.4233288765,
0.0209145285,
-0.3788824081,
-0.3994960189,
-0.3966239691,
-0.505521059,
-0.7642779946,
-0.0627775863,
-0.3680531979,
-0.3465994596,
-0.256431669,
-0.0392647386,
0.484090656,
0.8863790035,
0.3421539962,
0.2860480249,
-0.9586988688,
0.0634941831,
0.3389672339,
-0.0638612732,
0.0818339065,
-0.4242480099,
-0.045215033,
-0.4832271338,
-0.3608860075,
-1.1091686487,
0.4132630229,
-0.1640840024,
0.6003444791,
0.4592846632,
0.0655463561,
0.2352814525,
-0.6902657747,
1.3074749708,
0.1339662671,
-0.8264952302,
0.5912352204,
-0.3108667731,
0.1840169579,
0.4394515455,
0.3028109968,
-0.4980913103,
-0.4546092451,
-0.4133658707,
-1.0025737286,
0.2877025008,
0.1233200356,
0.2982189953,
-0.0218475237,
0.1477341503,
-0.180874899,
0.1853786707,
-0.5343762636,
-0.4162789583,
0.1176510677,
-0.0544789694,
-0.0183891859,
-0.4118386209,
-0.3167445064,
0.0466457717,
0.6217188835,
0.2822299898,
-0.085743241,
-0.1072465554,
-0.1883144975,
0.3256880641,
0.3866944313,
0.6453101039,
0.4159079194,
0.1189697608,
0.2772150338,
0.2486085892,
-0.5910695791,
0.1262392849,
0.1069946885,
-0.1550724804,
-0.2939833701,
0.7991218567,
0.6271163821,
-0.148191765,
-0.9033861756,
0.5779364109,
-0.239654243,
0.1888284981,
-0.494659394,
0.1314382106,
-0.0462312847,
0.2829929292,
0.209736973,
-0.3059402704,
0.0079197697,
-0.6683476567,
-0.0613840334,
0.8354287148,
-0.0416484028,
-0.3233008981,
0.4751131535,
0.0330863446,
-0.4809058309,
0.7523677945,
0.2621665895,
-0.6403511763,
0.8073894382,
0.6610974073,
0.8823775053,
-0.5360052586,
-0.3013765812,
-0.033381585,
0.6753773093,
0.1079777107,
0.0160117485,
0.2538236678,
-0.5614030361,
-0.0527059659,
-0.3308621943,
-0.6626321077,
0.4323993623,
-0.5263539553,
0.0501052439,
-0.7474482656,
-0.175835669,
-0.1240322068,
-0.0678221285,
-0.2905964851,
-0.1417527199,
0.3575443923,
1.0705391169,
-0.6989757419,
0.6815325618,
0.5420556068,
-0.4701996148,
-0.5000596642,
-0.043894738,
0.4106705487,
-0.6581584811,
0.3728568852,
0.020979492,
0.0479646064,
-0.3486915827,
-0.7534884214,
-0.6500805616,
0.8461741805,
0.4370047748,
-0.5305234194,
0.0888746008,
0.1611750871,
0.2394122481,
0.0206511486,
0.0081990259,
0.7903431654,
0.471209228,
-0.2981846035,
-0.7239634991,
-0.065783225,
-0.3072178066,
-0.1210027263,
0.2194264233,
-0.7927125692,
0.7784873247,
-0.0349300466,
-0.0230915267,
0.3067896962,
0.5651665926,
0.4921062589,
0.2729786038,
0.4570801854,
0.6457265615,
0.6164337397,
0.0647674128,
1.1912295818,
-0.2316617966,
-0.0266103018,
0.9819965959,
-0.412226826,
0.7661585212,
0.500890255,
-0.2425872982,
0.0428204872,
0.557149291,
-0.2500202656,
0.1291128248,
0.4899335504,
-0.4088982642,
0.0431975834,
0.0554189123,
-0.5158075094,
0.3696733415,
0.4610968828,
-0.2041237503,
0.0532739386,
0.108070299,
0.5318966508,
-0.0350103378,
-0.3829765618,
0.8839611411,
0.1742635965,
-0.459987551,
0.16397205,
0.3120617867,
0.5176147819,
-0.8667139411,
0.1511622518,
-0.2385963351,
0.0455982648,
-0.1279209256,
-0.883983314,
0.1555244327,
0.3204019964,
-0.0674907044,
-0.0867960528,
0.7229373455,
-0.1973605156,
-0.2312666029,
0.1866455972,
0.3381858766,
0.0767614841,
0.0237355307,
-0.6882363558,
0.5237745643,
-0.2015783042,
-0.5794615149,
0.6375642419,
0.095959276,
-0.0781261772,
0.8872330189,
0.586699605,
0.2507646382,
0.2399580628,
0.1513296664,
0.9599850774,
-0.6612303853,
-0.1719264388,
-1.4178119898,
0.302857548,
-0.2180945128,
-0.2197242379,
1.0378493071,
0.5653354526,
0.5779439807,
-0.0265712347,
0.7906220555,
0.0320832692,
0.184772715,
-0.6747800112,
1.1395796537,
-0.2916370332,
0.5302768946,
-0.1685969532,
-0.6987025142,
-0.4696802497,
0.1802949607,
-0.3279722333,
-0.1275566518,
0.4694079757,
0.8140407801,
0.3818052709,
-0.1749175191,
0.4429127872,
0.3867741227,
0.8165415525,
0.5660779476,
1.2347398996,
-0.2158172429,
0.3027216196,
0.2143477499,
-0.0510266013,
-0.0025214297,
-0.7338703275,
-1.1735397577,
-0.3895488679,
-0.2520069182,
-0.4980652928,
0.1244212538,
0.6170566678,
0.3916574419,
-0.968244493,
-0.1276962906,
0.1927930564,
0.4042644799,
0.280402869,
-0.2051816732,
0.2965680957,
-0.1565499306,
-0.6293590665,
0.7542350292,
0.2607497871,
0.0243776329,
-0.8204733729,
0.1948261857,
-0.0914772451,
0.3161923289,
0.5031269193,
0.6147840023,
-0.7017353773,
-0.4287548959,
-0.1132660881,
-0.208048135,
-0.4624766707,
0.8458114862,
-0.2331946939,
0.2051495463,
0.6115211248,
1.1722688675,
-0.0275657922,
-0.1510061771,
0.5166895986,
-0.7748375535,
0.3799329102,
0.3211661577,
0.4700679183,
0.300860703,
-0.5504234433,
0.2124381959,
0.0673732981,
-0.7280580997,
-1.233700633,
0.6892934442,
-0.9276381731,
-0.4239062667,
1.2030484676,
-0.2996925712,
-0.2756950259,
-0.0575528108,
-0.1061342657,
-0.1161780357,
-0.0249191429,
0.6564222574,
0.8919847012,
0.0652276725,
-0.0734982118,
-0.7558453679,
0.3486372828,
0.1024145186,
-1.0406378508,
0.1948605627,
0.5939414501,
0.2075671703,
-0.0086407159,
0.3516014218,
-0.3024852872,
-0.002751159,
-0.1244164482,
-0.2542663217,
-0.134498924,
-0.3887565732,
-0.6201283336,
0.308989495,
0.3653910458,
-0.0536533147
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00231v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00231v1
|
LLM-RankFusion: Mitigating Intrinsic Inconsistency in LLM-based Ranking
| 2024-05-31T23:29:42 | 2024-05-31T23:29:42 |
Yifan Zeng, Ojas Tendolkar, Raymond Baartmans, Qingyun Wu, Huazheng Wang, Lizhong Chen
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Ranking passages by prompting a large language model (LLM) can achieve
promising performance in modern information retrieval (IR) systems. A common
approach is to sort the ranking list by prompting LLMs for pairwise comparison.
However, sorting-based methods require consistent comparisons to correctly sort
the passages, which we show that LLMs often violate. We identify two kinds of
intrinsic inconsistency in LLM-based pairwise comparisons: order inconsistency
which leads to conflicting results when switching the passage order, and
transitive inconsistency which leads to non-transitive triads among all
preference pairs. In this paper, we propose LLM-RankFusion, an LLM-based
ranking framework that mitigates these inconsistencies and produces a robust
ranking list. LLM-RankFusion mitigates order inconsistency using in-context
learning (ICL) to demonstrate order-agnostic comparisons and calibration to
estimate the underlying preference probability between two passages. We then
address transitive inconsistency by aggregating the ranking results from
multiple rankers. In our experiments, we empirically show that LLM-RankFusion
can significantly reduce inconsistent pairwise comparison results, and improve
the ranking quality by making the final ranking list more robust.
|
[
-0.1319659054,
-0.5810684562,
0.5908565521,
0.2509492934,
-0.1571640968,
0.4785014391,
0.0089521119,
-0.5002439022,
0.1857722253,
0.4733687639,
-0.1796680242,
-0.3277897835,
-0.7682996392,
0.0695013851,
-0.4191992879,
0.8471614718,
0.0293759685,
0.2839930952,
-0.6518830657,
-0.4723013937,
-0.3436926901,
-0.6446089745,
-0.643989861,
-0.6045821309,
0.4025851786,
0.6656720042,
0.7735379934,
0.3886704743,
0.8591752052,
0.226120308,
-0.0770915002,
0.3897328973,
-0.6554766893,
0.4513140321,
-0.0303448644,
-0.4275237918,
-0.4731296003,
-0.0546787344,
0.8135487437,
0.6016949415,
-0.1439078599,
-0.0398023389,
0.1625774205,
0.8024278283,
-0.5462105274,
-0.2249878347,
-0.9179868102,
-0.0098781409,
-0.1965803504,
-0.5311104059,
-0.5775224566,
-0.5886398554,
-0.0187387057,
-0.0525771677,
-0.0269854609,
0.3486644626,
0.7687684298,
0.4268619716,
-0.4297575653,
0.0130808847,
-0.609125793,
0.5360592008,
-0.6889201403,
0.3848437071,
0.2729056478,
0.2170811296,
-0.145179674,
-0.391694665,
-0.3371514976,
-0.3620817065,
-0.0086104106,
0.0642276108,
0.3037804067,
0.124628894,
-0.0160698127,
0.4080537558,
-0.7662786245,
0.4151674509,
0.0741118267,
0.0695771128,
0.5003821254,
-0.0355834477,
0.175747022,
0.030466672,
-0.6276144385,
-0.3818655312,
-1.3475323915,
0.2167833745,
0.3096135855,
0.2536089122,
0.24624753,
0.589402318,
-0.2631113529,
0.6475557089,
0.3041785061,
-0.2676586509,
0.1719676107,
-0.2647667825,
-0.2068357915,
0.2716917694,
0.4209474921,
0.4468114674,
-0.1390747577,
-0.4392064512,
-0.3087152839,
-0.217807889,
0.0869838893,
-0.8769313693,
-0.0032012619,
0.4751552343,
-0.2314617038,
-0.4864655733,
0.2461639792,
-0.415068686,
-0.4060932398,
-0.1183315441,
0.7729262114,
-0.1312858164,
0.015965445,
-0.3107474446,
0.038061846,
0.2016235292,
0.4124073386,
-0.9044183493,
0.1805337071,
0.7716163993,
0.6325445175,
-0.7246507406,
-0.3349826336,
-0.720603168,
0.2580539584,
-0.1585635692,
1.0806081295,
-0.649725616,
-0.3460823894,
0.0205516908,
-0.2899101079,
-0.0988014415,
-1.024602294,
0.5572565794,
-0.5714761615,
0.0244000684,
-0.1887450516,
-0.7275241017,
0.2100791931,
0.4062657952,
-0.2432210594,
1.3878737688,
0.0025020088,
-0.6303286552,
0.3819749057,
-0.1961791068,
-0.3295870721,
0.1495238096,
-0.2930789292,
-0.4078464806,
0.0070721414,
0.0589739606,
0.3380004764,
-0.2288916558,
0.4198391438,
-0.4858320653,
-0.7404854298,
0.3099959791,
-0.3388376534,
0.5622416735,
0.008415807,
-0.2733635902,
0.2177907825,
-0.3843487203,
0.2126401067,
-0.1717708707,
-0.4395899177,
-0.351968199,
-0.0188054629,
-0.1702219397,
0.2048834413,
0.3807369769,
-0.3527473211,
0.4434717596,
-0.4433590174,
0.3791884184,
0.9649603963,
0.0592414774,
0.7361495495,
-0.5593479276,
0.0923302174,
0.1172060743,
0.3069114983,
0.4790680707,
-0.4032564759,
-0.9449127316,
0.0346938819,
0.1958406121,
0.816791296,
-0.8708862066,
0.5120971203,
-0.5988510847,
-0.4761643708,
-0.3223353326,
0.10718631,
0.2666338384,
0.5935607553,
0.4554137588,
-0.0335971043,
0.0253751855,
-0.8213127851,
-0.2022850364,
-0.4913729429,
0.1174532548,
0.3552106917,
0.1585135609,
-0.1954369247,
0.681409061,
-0.3795129359,
-0.0902927667,
-0.0935101286,
0.0630082488,
0.1676208824,
0.6145877838,
0.2568765283,
-0.8713110685,
-0.3004084229,
-0.2561860383,
-0.5462824106,
-0.1984389871,
0.1113408431,
-0.5075206161,
0.1715858877,
0.5593093634,
-0.0652807504,
0.252235204,
0.3083257973,
-0.2432537228,
0.2257590294,
-0.3072711825,
0.4420466125,
-0.8665853739,
-0.1222487539,
-0.2557853162,
-0.272210747,
-0.3206054568,
0.128855437,
0.3059183359,
0.2633279562,
-0.4139264524,
0.7284240723,
0.0657298341,
-0.1410993487,
-0.1038906053,
0.129080072,
0.0836857185,
0.336604327,
-0.0710191354,
0.8890123367,
0.2671788931,
-0.6287579536,
0.0657375157,
0.3713722825,
-0.1738051474,
0.960547924,
-0.2318895161,
0.0281456001,
0.0240778923,
0.150648877,
-1.3030490875,
0.1164062992,
0.187201947,
-0.2578798532,
0.6159053445,
-0.3135180771,
-0.6270170808,
0.2434025258,
-0.4442106187,
0.5687810183,
0.2290026844,
-0.7648074031,
0.1935026795,
0.2839639187,
-0.3201152682,
-0.7707279325,
-0.6194046736,
0.0876385868,
-0.2763346136,
-0.6322812438,
0.7469807267,
-0.6220201254,
-0.3237181008,
-0.2806458175,
-0.3729693592,
-0.006597558,
0.3249159455,
0.1350000054,
0.4920550287,
0.0781303197,
0.1732362658,
0.1952330619,
-0.1246028692,
-0.2778869271,
-0.2265797108,
0.2056508362,
0.035928037,
-0.5774782896,
0.168473497,
0.2617821991,
0.6178134084,
0.0961812884,
0.6994959116,
0.1699838638,
-0.0489458255,
-0.0481222086,
-0.9573526382,
-0.3250505626,
-0.4518299997,
-0.0401746668,
-0.1057525128,
-1.0416653156,
0.3288458288,
-0.1262547821,
0.1311177313,
0.2103599012,
0.2209520638,
-0.2787182927,
1.0900431871,
0.4622644782,
-0.0588763356,
0.7229155302,
0.0036930861,
0.1954745054,
-0.9952509403,
-0.15334104,
-0.5604476333,
-0.560988307,
-0.759945035,
-0.2270886004,
0.7853496075,
0.0852873921,
-0.2516914904,
-0.0565483756,
-0.4058214128,
0.5271676779,
0.3571373224,
0.1947208345,
0.5029324293,
0.2526119947,
-0.5389336944,
0.1295773685,
-0.484720856,
-0.2717840075,
1.1034067869,
-0.1842490137,
0.8070129156,
0.4888811707,
0.7866191864,
0.4138660729,
0.6040042043,
-0.6949402094,
0.5260242224,
-0.1631868035,
-0.2032285631,
-0.2891781926,
-0.6246350408,
-0.6704998612,
0.5076684356,
-0.2569557428,
-0.7574574351,
0.1532555521,
-0.0949939191,
-0.1198828369,
0.0891035646,
-0.4123663306,
0.6371659636,
-0.3676416278,
-0.6055255532,
-0.1304450333,
-0.7970578074,
0.404559046,
0.1660984457,
-0.0829520673,
-0.1989452839,
0.1143095419,
0.4550512731,
-0.5714470148,
0.06749551,
0.0824397355,
0.0080479793,
-0.4610974491,
0.2052868307,
0.5593457818,
0.2977874875,
-0.4298772812,
0.1581233144,
0.0535820797,
-0.3010396659,
-0.6201585531,
1.0583044291,
-0.7955414057,
-0.7720038891,
-0.5255438685,
-0.2525424957,
-0.4719424546,
0.0247248225,
0.5405911207,
0.5653155446,
0.0708819553,
0.2059845477,
0.9380335212,
0.089602828,
0.2750004828,
0.486731559,
-0.0951182991,
-0.5935047269,
0.9643246531,
0.2653287649,
0.3891046047,
0.9018664956,
0.14491117,
-0.5988310575,
-0.8411740065,
-0.445014298,
0.2551554441,
-0.8580630422,
-0.3436271846,
-0.443951875,
-0.3158286512,
-0.4211905301,
-0.1980909705,
-0.1414365768,
-0.4960025251,
0.112860851,
-0.0132192401,
0.1678237617,
0.5729908943,
0.1842663586,
-0.035900481,
-0.503046155,
0.0772896856,
0.1746324003,
0.3681604266,
-0.0150056761,
-0.755053103,
-0.0856479108,
-0.3673176765,
-0.4132542312,
-0.5788965225,
0.1768045276,
0.0124385189,
0.8014568686,
0.4306384623,
0.1689942032,
0.8066165447,
-0.3547996283,
0.6490783095,
-0.0857773051,
-0.7408455014,
0.5229201317,
0.0293081123,
0.1479526609,
0.9721564054,
0.00402069,
-0.5999497175,
-0.6708331704,
-0.581590414,
-1.2316499949,
0.5927954912,
0.3053471446,
-0.3603649139,
0.0674763992,
0.3523541987,
0.0600944087,
0.3527527452,
-0.8308835626,
-0.6713573337,
0.0216089208,
-0.1287942231,
-0.115300715,
-0.3879539669,
-0.1169283837,
-0.2627599537,
0.8753963113,
-0.1558061093,
0.2134163976,
0.3189301789,
-0.438218832,
-0.038391415,
0.2231831402,
0.7176553607,
0.6717306376,
-0.4125732481,
0.3891718388,
0.058144521,
-0.2364104539,
0.3969022334,
0.1541559547,
-0.3210807443,
-0.2236307859,
-0.0142310122,
0.384634763,
0.5702418685,
-0.5716667175,
0.5474549532,
-0.2133818716,
0.246031031,
-0.1806211472,
0.0448441207,
0.0393542126,
0.042921938,
0.5601541996,
0.2349929214,
0.235041678,
-0.1965619028,
0.1139976531,
0.7079777122,
-0.2171773762,
0.2732870877,
0.4598898292,
0.3133284748,
-0.2442229241,
0.5965347886,
-0.1294017881,
-0.4045708776,
0.4117501378,
0.2805673182,
0.6773971915,
-0.270098269,
0.089734368,
0.2509577572,
0.2001365572,
-0.3608927131,
0.1471132636,
-0.342350632,
-0.714561522,
0.0236238893,
-0.479200691,
-0.8938224912,
-0.0642908737,
-0.5600272417,
0.152757138,
-0.3670339286,
0.0521937758,
-0.412432462,
0.0330619179,
-0.521067977,
-0.1654600352,
0.0339255743,
0.7172550559,
-0.5556160212,
0.7759337425,
0.612249732,
-0.3642814457,
-0.5396162868,
0.3171523213,
-0.0946521387,
-0.8093820214,
0.763060689,
0.2430672646,
-0.3710346222,
0.0542952009,
-0.4748007655,
-1.0827982426,
1.269203186,
0.4292238653,
-0.0703713298,
0.1897016764,
0.2049474716,
0.2059586346,
-0.2702131867,
0.785951674,
0.1157065034,
0.412083149,
0.4451870024,
-0.7761808634,
0.0989844799,
-0.1588887721,
-0.0097261714,
0.282058984,
-0.8024622202,
0.6228606105,
0.1625459343,
-0.1671570241,
0.2925647795,
0.3210591674,
0.5671659708,
0.2927613854,
0.4992237389,
0.4810256958,
1.0297715664,
-0.1821651459,
0.7871996164,
-0.4728280008,
0.1982800663,
1.0628768206,
-0.7178125978,
1.1175346375,
0.6530936956,
-0.1101410538,
0.4581798315,
0.8308905363,
0.2009564191,
0.5499104261,
0.051328592,
-0.334476769,
-0.4897782207,
-0.1018880606,
-0.5198010206,
0.2186861783,
0.2572692335,
-0.196801126,
-0.2637478411,
-0.2495258898,
-0.0833313689,
-0.3249022961,
-0.0319815651,
0.811349988,
-0.0219336376,
-0.9874224067,
0.7247018814,
-0.110436663,
0.854878962,
-0.4702697694,
-0.1685561836,
-0.6432161927,
0.0793299675,
-0.1684871614,
-0.6714399457,
-0.1468079537,
-0.3392271698,
-0.3273879886,
-0.6522531509,
0.4940655231,
-0.5595588684,
-0.335388571,
0.2889251709,
0.647569716,
0.216033563,
-0.1019234061,
-0.7462167144,
0.0122074625,
-0.2005018294,
0.041815687,
0.8269005418,
0.1022594497,
-0.0324042812,
0.7442035079,
0.6977482438,
-0.0075869821,
-0.3576760292,
0.0954896137,
0.5509368181,
-0.3838409185,
-0.6369315386,
-0.9569329023,
0.0855899155,
-0.243815124,
-0.0462494157,
0.5039944053,
0.5384824276,
0.7619099021,
0.323918879,
0.3748182356,
0.3948158026,
0.3044915199,
-0.7493323088,
0.7960689068,
-0.7461951375,
0.6859906912,
-0.0510585159,
-0.9861381054,
-0.2988306284,
0.570292294,
-0.1133942381,
-0.0698441863,
0.7606274486,
1.003071785,
0.1616206318,
-0.3158672452,
0.4479667842,
0.2226538211,
0.3790587783,
0.5649766326,
0.8996440172,
-0.344308883,
0.489318043,
0.0284407623,
-0.1473215222,
-0.6872655749,
-0.9674925208,
-0.5369492769,
-0.3360463083,
-0.3802437782,
-0.5620263815,
0.0145937586,
1.1111245155,
0.7815748453,
-0.7731111646,
-0.4070786238,
0.0711769611,
0.8454885483,
-0.3388825357,
-0.2915237248,
0.1490280181,
-0.1390373558,
-0.8306991458,
0.6233078837,
0.6549012661,
0.0579919741,
-0.3494072855,
0.0156310368,
-0.1471656263,
-0.0164139289,
0.508176446,
0.0571731813,
-0.9530503154,
-0.4298616648,
-0.0692060888,
-0.389328748,
0.6021461487,
0.6864860654,
-0.7920773029,
0.2812755406,
0.6563236117,
0.6743759513,
0.1820832938,
0.0211828928,
0.3220482767,
-0.7832836509,
-0.291862756,
0.0857852772,
0.4297307432,
0.4791913331,
-0.7420504689,
0.675129354,
0.3057197332,
-0.8113749623,
-1.0429228544,
0.2481196523,
-1.2382797003,
-0.0966317728,
1.2034704685,
0.0944938138,
0.130090937,
0.0096594328,
0.0167415049,
0.0136576807,
-0.5011048913,
0.7884516716,
0.8389854431,
-0.5251994133,
0.1243803427,
-0.2742771208,
0.458273232,
0.5818838477,
-0.8123655915,
-0.193843767,
0.178507477,
0.4365255833,
-0.0561923757,
0.5045560002,
-0.0613435656,
-0.0417288914,
-0.6203176975,
-0.3034137189,
0.0993914232,
-0.1529948115,
-0.3754514456,
0.2087873966,
0.3554619253,
0.1728326529
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00226v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00226v1
|
Entangled Relations: Leveraging NLI and Meta-analysis to Enhance Biomedical Relation Extraction
| 2024-05-31T23:05:04 | 2024-05-31T23:05:04 |
William Hogan, Jingbo Shang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Recent research efforts have explored the potential of leveraging natural
language inference (NLI) techniques to enhance relation extraction (RE). In
this vein, we introduce MetaEntail-RE, a novel adaptation method that harnesses
NLI principles to enhance RE performance. Our approach follows past works by
verbalizing relation classes into class-indicative hypotheses, aligning a
traditionally multi-class classification task to one of textual entailment. We
introduce three key enhancements: (1) Instead of labeling non-entailed
premise-hypothesis pairs with the uninformative "neutral" entailment label, we
introduce meta-class analysis, which provides additional context by analyzing
overarching meta relationships between classes when assigning entailment
labels; (2) Feasible hypothesis filtering, which removes unlikely hypotheses
from consideration based on pairs of entity types; and (3) Group-based
prediction selection, which further improves performance by selecting highly
confident predictions. MetaEntail-RE is conceptually simple and empirically
powerful, yielding significant improvements over conventional relation
extraction techniques and other NLI formulations. Our experimental results
underscore the versatility of MetaEntail-RE, demonstrating performance gains
across both biomedical and general domains.
|
[
-0.3188952506,
-0.7230731845,
0.5761976838,
0.051415313,
-0.1883591712,
-0.1337703615,
-0.0965581685,
-0.7887640595,
0.6101062298,
0.4821805358,
-0.5433309078,
-0.1049854904,
-0.5479220152,
0.5805742741,
0.0381327085,
1.1755940914,
0.1170521826,
0.0569337979,
-0.6228891015,
-0.392432332,
-0.31468606,
-0.2088484317,
-0.5315210223,
-0.5069168806,
0.7914364338,
0.1905547082,
0.7367708087,
0.6318461895,
0.6873621345,
0.2577364743,
0.0611458942,
0.2350579351,
-0.2740893364,
0.253262043,
-0.4343898296,
-0.3652973473,
-0.7089448571,
0.0680654347,
0.4196637571,
1.1132513285,
-0.0901465639,
0.3457676172,
0.1801373959,
0.8254318833,
-1.270745635,
-0.0008216054,
-0.3992905915,
-0.0088824211,
-0.19277592,
-0.4222817421,
-0.6346379519,
-0.1964884847,
0.5011602044,
-0.8318547606,
0.144778803,
0.0352853462,
0.8450599909,
0.3510312438,
-0.5726668239,
-0.2394594103,
-0.6831966639,
0.5209490061,
-0.6686968803,
0.81787467,
0.3878335357,
0.2228860259,
-0.2284655273,
-1.0457040071,
-0.058728572,
0.0256956387,
-0.3580343127,
0.5395315886,
-0.1897297055,
0.2020519227,
0.2377918214,
0.2340628952,
-0.2574965656,
-0.3577609658,
-0.2386317253,
0.0630120412,
0.6298364401,
-0.0031274781,
0.5020909905,
-0.0267680325,
0.0300060995,
0.2803753614,
-0.6463202238,
-0.2855101824,
-0.0565826446,
0.0386001915,
0.2648496628,
0.4760143757,
0.1154258922,
0.6839800477,
0.2780715823,
-0.0556405261,
0.4223870337,
-0.3483486176,
-0.4092229903,
0.2030830234,
0.907099545,
0.1969249994,
0.1677782536,
-0.7445709109,
0.3896072209,
-0.183930099,
0.2677482367,
-1.000997901,
-0.3012931347,
0.2281256765,
-0.9616012573,
-0.1550230682,
0.0847836211,
-1.1148791313,
-0.0828032792,
-0.3941433728,
0.4627135396,
-0.5758703947,
-0.5511207581,
0.3101399839,
-0.44607687,
0.296022296,
0.0259490814,
-0.9962786436,
0.5437405705,
0.8161498904,
0.7652853131,
-0.117977187,
-0.3068532646,
-0.5882388353,
0.7365788817,
0.0016780287,
0.6641498804,
-1.0008026361,
-0.3329451084,
-0.1898315847,
0.1350967586,
-0.5046456456,
-0.4343253374,
0.627048254,
-0.5896602273,
0.39336887,
-0.2203153819,
-0.6498895288,
-0.1580822915,
-0.0113767628,
-0.8778764606,
0.4413428307,
-0.2287952155,
-1.2866235971,
0.537953496,
-0.7157414556,
-0.7037947178,
-0.1989227533,
-0.104970403,
-0.5113567114,
0.1799628586,
0.2970035374,
0.1400266737,
-0.2923440337,
0.3091827035,
-0.7598158121,
-0.0757792667,
0.1707051843,
-0.0729157403,
0.8515829444,
0.1240702868,
-0.0899730623,
0.0456856787,
-0.79298383,
-0.071329236,
-0.2674551606,
0.0074903034,
-0.7556857467,
0.1431642324,
-0.2885209024,
-0.1366499513,
-0.0750838965,
-0.6145960093,
0.1397901028,
-0.6891681552,
0.3453431129,
0.1770897955,
0.4276628196,
0.8572748303,
-0.0011824288,
0.4147577882,
-0.2707465589,
0.1250050515,
0.2351278663,
-0.4715897739,
-0.5317770839,
-0.4285700023,
0.7101665139,
0.4745547473,
-0.962007165,
0.5206938982,
-0.4413506985,
-0.1593879163,
-0.7037493587,
-0.1483863145,
0.277074784,
0.4083286524,
0.6450900435,
-0.117118381,
-0.7977247834,
-0.9117935896,
-0.869574964,
-0.0797126219,
-0.1399733275,
0.154014647,
0.5105876923,
-0.7873455882,
1.2045614719,
-0.6760886908,
-0.1628295332,
0.0378709137,
0.3648289144,
0.2443066686,
0.4688760042,
0.5371598601,
-0.7106912136,
-0.3416749835,
-0.0958709121,
-0.952619493,
-0.061106585,
-0.0171665549,
-0.4912039638,
-0.353412807,
0.4774913788,
-0.5701074004,
0.432112366,
0.2062941045,
-0.4089626968,
0.2734019756,
-0.0531121716,
-0.0186770335,
-1.164096117,
0.193353042,
-0.1338294894,
-0.248796463,
-0.808568418,
-0.03287993,
0.0386715904,
0.1516578943,
0.106120877,
0.22864452,
-0.7256689072,
0.0922775418,
-0.3096812963,
-0.1846788228,
0.081178911,
0.1087453812,
0.1972526312,
0.4773525894,
0.4803195298,
-0.6021884084,
0.0095556406,
0.5217259526,
0.3959486187,
0.4044252932,
-0.6130782962,
0.1269328892,
-0.372720331,
0.4632097781,
-0.6118301749,
-0.3591224253,
0.5122129321,
-0.6498826742,
0.5198836327,
-0.1364841312,
-0.193820253,
0.0430589877,
-0.3878588676,
0.459736377,
0.1405161023,
-0.5023302436,
1.2012076378,
0.3384535015,
0.1406978816,
-0.6004164815,
-0.644777894,
0.1989867985,
-0.3044046164,
-0.3982129991,
0.499789983,
0.1874440908,
-0.1457411647,
0.4701917171,
-0.1412303597,
-0.4293037355,
0.1561813056,
0.2851759493,
0.1564161628,
-0.1941986978,
0.5351756215,
0.1571311951,
-0.3587968349,
0.3678517938,
0.1573244184,
-0.090023838,
0.0409619659,
-0.0345531814,
-0.109039627,
0.3402585387,
0.5161136389,
-0.5300116539,
0.9088761806,
0.7501601577,
-0.6303880215,
0.2084036767,
-0.4369266331,
-0.4516424239,
-0.40165025,
0.3711415529,
-0.4010292888,
-0.6212569475,
0.1855853349,
-0.3629359901,
0.09853369,
0.4618889391,
0.0600054115,
-0.0998611972,
0.6768949628,
0.7206710577,
-0.1500228345,
0.3406461179,
-0.0679583549,
0.2998906076,
-1.2571027279,
-0.2014054805,
-0.3189966083,
-0.1724229753,
-0.7990669608,
-0.1412632018,
0.3199742436,
0.1946051121,
-0.1528055817,
0.4463534355,
-0.3372343779,
0.3118812442,
0.238633588,
0.4917538464,
0.4182306826,
-0.1692748666,
0.3286832869,
-0.344324857,
-0.64657408,
-0.2700240612,
1.2637989521,
0.3623119295,
0.595146358,
0.4559020996,
0.9676142335,
-0.2184060812,
0.8660807014,
-0.5938885212,
0.1458007395,
-0.0214995071,
-0.682706356,
-0.2442385107,
-0.6913064122,
-1.3308084011,
0.4967247546,
-0.6741678715,
-0.6572969556,
0.5453570485,
-0.119655259,
-0.3444478512,
0.1306073517,
-0.6182453036,
0.6235995293,
0.0465838164,
-0.7227863073,
-0.0230720323,
-0.7917122245,
0.5881509185,
-0.1210795641,
0.239230305,
-0.028928265,
-0.2907680869,
0.9877909422,
-0.1601270586,
0.6566614509,
0.0672348216,
0.0757686272,
0.0922699273,
0.0375182852,
0.1417960823,
0.3065388799,
-0.2715373039,
-0.0626559854,
0.1961188316,
-0.1104789227,
-1.0015473366,
0.4399338067,
-0.5470930338,
-0.4034255445,
-0.4885666668,
-0.3649493754,
-0.4971647263,
0.3271151185,
0.245268926,
0.4250612855,
-0.1968236566,
0.3444636166,
0.5633069277,
-0.1821724176,
0.4895662665,
0.5066508651,
-0.1853543669,
-0.8441910744,
0.7011625171,
0.0133529147,
0.1257708371,
0.495498538,
0.3308741152,
-0.3251345158,
-0.0698749945,
-0.2393190414,
0.54489398,
-0.2987145483,
-0.4214223027,
-1.0320675373,
-0.1203141138,
-0.5145667791,
0.2083325088,
-0.219562307,
-0.1513496786,
-0.4214142859,
-0.072992824,
0.3069904447,
0.4658588171,
-0.1948591322,
-0.0808000267,
-1.0425002575,
0.6065957546,
0.3813095391,
0.3555823267,
-0.0716964751,
-0.4108029306,
0.0414214395,
-0.0934101939,
-0.3358162045,
-1.3507854939,
0.1843893379,
0.7838284373,
0.6442924142,
0.4582206607,
0.1388843358,
0.961987257,
-0.7247828245,
0.1324889213,
0.3118605316,
-0.8292531371,
0.524287045,
-0.2082131505,
-0.1468747109,
0.859371841,
0.4705716968,
-0.1916584074,
-0.1703535169,
-0.8300549984,
-0.7427949905,
0.2015049756,
0.4008449018,
-0.2560228407,
-0.0480550043,
0.7498797774,
-0.1167768314,
0.2268950641,
-0.6734501123,
-0.3007522821,
-0.0077619851,
-0.4198130965,
0.0071001826,
-0.3033188879,
-0.1272843927,
-0.562312901,
0.4584338069,
-0.1751541197,
0.4043654799,
0.5753352046,
-0.1539952755,
-0.1656887531,
0.1720399857,
0.2914159,
0.8468919992,
-0.4765186906,
0.2203145772,
0.3837795556,
-0.5180830956,
0.0301072299,
0.0785185844,
0.0928308815,
0.154725343,
1.0819045305,
0.3730930388,
0.4663268924,
-0.2906197309,
0.5998917818,
-0.0294525512,
-0.1671960801,
0.0577899553,
-0.1380343437,
0.1604888886,
0.1779011339,
0.1181207895,
0.0506957285,
0.8622443676,
-0.6622299552,
0.5997949839,
0.404694289,
-0.4299758077,
-0.4479802251,
0.7393354177,
0.4087987244,
-0.2706666589,
0.2346633226,
0.1256542355,
-0.2959693968,
0.2690564692,
0.6706014872,
1.2105555534,
-0.1900164485,
0.0767273679,
0.7392665744,
0.244125843,
0.0629120171,
-0.1220422462,
-0.0033232418,
-0.8047644496,
-0.7709589601,
-0.4493986368,
-0.3326893449,
-0.2064029872,
-1.2370017767,
0.0277804621,
-0.0831630453,
-0.3035157323,
0.1258791536,
-0.1918988824,
-0.477250278,
0.0787100419,
-0.2436150163,
0.8546845317,
-0.9562490582,
0.6710963845,
0.7360503674,
-0.33757779,
-0.3869924545,
0.3105783463,
-0.3114579022,
-0.2273153365,
0.6481634974,
0.0914475545,
-0.2304994017,
-0.0761836395,
-0.3711966872,
-0.8801661134,
1.0154520273,
0.4702146351,
-0.5408421755,
-0.0219006855,
-0.0832083598,
0.6008229852,
-0.3845390379,
0.4403820038,
0.8998039365,
0.4305061698,
-0.0836692601,
-0.6619454026,
0.2953062356,
-0.1354041398,
-0.3048710525,
0.4043688774,
-0.3262177706,
0.407803148,
-0.2563066483,
-0.2832883298,
-0.2263130397,
0.7779861093,
0.2486011237,
0.5841829777,
0.4948739409,
0.5346726179,
0.7785157561,
0.1183183119,
0.6572830081,
-0.1327332854,
0.4433060586,
1.431756258,
-0.3283443153,
0.9312034249,
0.7541986108,
-0.2814218998,
0.6955509186,
0.5083785057,
0.2120754272,
0.6098873615,
-0.2230985165,
-0.1146715581,
-0.2465162724,
0.0120463911,
-0.5874767303,
0.438616246,
0.2584934533,
-0.4327234924,
-0.1914109588,
-0.033923585,
0.0115270019,
-0.0307776611,
0.0523196347,
1.2616695166,
0.1134744883,
-0.535866797,
0.2018710822,
-0.4480670094,
0.4478071928,
-0.3318650424,
-0.2506889403,
0.288103193,
0.1340832412,
-0.3630122244,
-0.3849995136,
0.4272753894,
-0.4221208096,
-0.2687256634,
0.2460841835,
1.0344370604,
-0.7078991532,
-0.4907551408,
0.5617570281,
0.5311082006,
-0.221834749,
0.0851545557,
-0.568667829,
-0.2097558379,
-0.0877248719,
-0.0486736372,
0.0260190405,
0.6794671416,
0.3753242493,
0.4901028872,
0.6269330978,
0.1841705441,
-0.1845490932,
-0.1030741781,
0.8511286378,
-0.6737065911,
-0.0700804368,
-1.1608455181,
0.2836485803,
-0.4359266758,
-0.1034442931,
0.7814536095,
0.7181794643,
0.2233232111,
-0.1903096735,
0.6129699349,
0.1481211931,
0.4798870087,
-0.3609184921,
0.5348511338,
-0.4041684568,
-0.1569612324,
-0.503484726,
-0.8352673054,
-0.5139314532,
0.4458828866,
-0.2861128747,
-0.1397177428,
0.9733096361,
0.2252638638,
-0.1473187655,
0.2059706002,
-0.0465857498,
-0.0980509669,
0.4816353917,
0.6971130371,
0.5890741348,
-0.7911592126,
0.270265758,
-0.0522199832,
-0.4276877344,
-0.0489455685,
-0.9504279494,
-0.9876479506,
-0.131657958,
-0.5093784332,
-0.3286611438,
0.1768633276,
0.790519774,
0.6044754386,
-0.689978838,
0.0779625177,
-0.1475822181,
0.089722164,
-0.3430840969,
-0.1926600039,
0.4270367622,
-0.5002696514,
-0.4010424912,
0.2222812027,
0.3254321218,
-0.1066870168,
0.2597699463,
-0.054872863,
-0.3949427307,
-0.0931916535,
0.5942709446,
0.2038744837,
-0.3472238779,
-0.2689169049,
-0.2143594176,
0.1369510591,
-0.1635985076,
0.9930505753,
-0.6066613197,
0.4714558721,
0.4435793459,
0.9524723291,
0.4090799689,
0.1758335084,
0.8003005385,
-0.4651446044,
0.0905323476,
0.1927053779,
0.3225339651,
-0.0464575775,
-0.3497554064,
1.0068105459,
0.2508225739,
-0.470285356,
-0.8688622713,
0.1741489768,
-0.6706412435,
-0.3765165806,
1.1318268776,
0.1197760031,
-0.4240333438,
-0.3251597285,
-0.0977466479,
0.4773027003,
-0.0190787129,
0.6170216799,
0.3117036819,
-0.3123573363,
-0.1728141457,
-0.674477756,
0.6818993092,
0.3379313648,
-1.1126174927,
0.0740006417,
-0.0086005954,
0.4419603646,
0.3848866224,
0.4818326831,
-0.0667310953,
0.3229705095,
-0.2853612304,
0.0820433572,
0.0443770401,
-0.31373173,
-0.0694942847,
-0.0931994841,
-0.2849090695,
-0.5045006275
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00222v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00222v1
|
Learning to Clarify: Multi-turn Conversations with Action-Based Contrastive Self-Training
| 2024-05-31T22:44:48 | 2024-05-31T22:44:48 |
Maximillian Chen, Ruoxi Sun, Sercan Ö. Arık, Tomas Pfister
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) aligned through reinforcement learning from
human feedback (RLHF) have quickly become one of the dominant paradigms for
building intelligent conversational assistant agents. However, despite their
strong performance across many benchmarks, LLM-based agents still lack
conversational skills such as disambiguation: when generalized assistants are
faced with ambiguity, they often overhedge or implicitly guess users'
ground-truth intents rather than asking clarification questions, and under
task-specific settings, high-quality conversation samples are often limited,
affecting models' ability to learn optimal dialogue action policies. We propose
Action-Based Contrastive Self-Training (henceforth ACT), a quasi-online
preference optimization algorithm based on Direct Preference Optimization (DPO)
which allows for sample-efficient dialogue policy learning in multi-turn
conversation. We demonstrate ACT's efficacy under sample-efficient conditions
in three difficult conversational tasks: tabular-grounded question-answering,
machine reading comprehension, and AmbigSQL, a novel task for disambiguating
information-seeking requests for text-to-SQL generation. Additionally, we
propose evaluating LLMs' ability to function as conversational agents by
examining whether they can implicitly recognize and reason about ambiguity in
conversation. ACT demonstrates substantial conversation modeling improvements
over standard approaches to supervised fine-tuning and DPO.
|
[
-0.341240257,
-0.9116247892,
0.6677429676,
0.1535679549,
-0.0149671854,
0.283654809,
-0.1705929488,
-0.1828458905,
0.1238096133,
0.4410444796,
-0.8760173321,
-0.2042709142,
-0.5668974519,
0.0678287968,
-0.0744628385,
0.822481811,
0.1304119229,
0.2956066132,
-0.0629850253,
-0.2638882101,
-0.3754387498,
-0.4534027874,
-0.8295847774,
-0.6292415857,
0.3598946631,
0.6171095967,
0.7196877599,
0.3566207886,
0.1696946621,
0.545573771,
-0.043023929,
0.5762676001,
-0.6758981943,
0.1593826562,
-0.1838999242,
-0.4177593589,
-0.2995173335,
-0.0650073811,
0.269402355,
0.6177195907,
-0.5125850439,
-0.3924952447,
-0.0177318305,
0.5907902718,
-0.4573171735,
0.1245828643,
-0.688945055,
0.0270529147,
0.5043595433,
-0.2324679047,
-0.3378224075,
-0.1598457545,
0.2674135566,
-0.632601738,
0.1495993733,
0.1024272069,
0.9511845708,
0.4514605701,
-0.4609936774,
-0.4622149765,
-0.8761327267,
0.7790940404,
-0.6110036969,
0.3500704169,
0.5170371532,
0.13842161,
-0.4035912454,
-0.3675462008,
-0.6970254779,
-0.3709545434,
-0.2294002026,
0.0971967205,
-0.0248910021,
0.4137270749,
0.0870739594,
0.4381376803,
-0.2193215191,
0.1419890523,
-0.2166822255,
-0.0536630787,
0.5699896812,
0.2994626164,
-0.1442116499,
0.0488796756,
-0.2048189342,
-0.2437027246,
-0.4853721857,
0.0452124588,
0.4001967609,
0.3437350094,
-0.1708452553,
0.2601684332,
-0.3222721517,
0.5348322392,
0.5390031934,
-0.2597709596,
0.1177053005,
-0.1428691745,
-0.2780788243,
-0.3323419094,
0.7911980152,
0.1111449152,
-0.0561421663,
-0.1475974917,
0.0426496342,
-0.3380391598,
0.4102990031,
-0.5080420971,
-0.0561555177,
0.4390419126,
-0.1744588763,
-0.0907728225,
-0.1954315007,
-0.5801246166,
-0.4255612791,
-0.640861094,
0.5617237687,
-0.2345989197,
-0.1090262905,
0.0885539576,
0.2484187633,
0.3511435091,
0.5489836335,
-1.1023517847,
0.3211982846,
0.3423883021,
0.4627355337,
-0.3228815198,
-0.3356051147,
-0.5481972098,
0.0405134149,
-0.3378156722,
0.6053484082,
-0.5664687157,
-0.6590872407,
0.1407805383,
0.0039202916,
-0.1526083499,
-0.6297255158,
0.2939094305,
-0.4697633684,
0.2844426036,
-0.0992385149,
-0.2864921689,
-0.0772994608,
0.5485442877,
-0.4464674592,
0.7942655683,
-0.0190328602,
-0.2388531715,
0.1806823611,
-0.7438751459,
-0.4920379817,
-0.2782695293,
-0.4105606973,
-0.5844280124,
-0.1438349336,
0.3647854328,
0.3745450974,
-0.0846847519,
0.2351455241,
-0.2573070228,
-0.2261279374,
0.2447255552,
-0.4072900414,
0.4104436934,
0.0751212239,
-0.3904753923,
0.3503851295,
-0.5956268311,
0.0175742656,
0.1541208178,
-0.5128477812,
0.0735871494,
-0.0581498742,
-0.5200521946,
0.2542351186,
0.0253507607,
-0.2448655218,
0.1755521595,
-0.4017574787,
0.2000018507,
0.7431214452,
-0.1160361245,
0.3816497326,
-0.0539439544,
0.4244573116,
0.2245505452,
0.3625171185,
-0.1224736199,
-0.1505601853,
-1.4133968353,
0.055888541,
0.0162682477,
0.5817188621,
-0.993170619,
0.4588117003,
-0.0327139609,
-0.2491539121,
-0.6189420819,
0.2590166032,
0.7114951015,
0.5604009628,
0.4805456698,
-0.2452576458,
-0.1792854071,
-0.894343853,
0.0087935906,
-0.2728065252,
0.3096896708,
0.5535094142,
0.2864638567,
-0.2883844972,
0.7995531559,
-0.5261583924,
-0.2508783638,
-0.3913197219,
0.4548042715,
-0.1380711943,
0.1607062817,
-0.0313724987,
-0.8878167868,
-0.4983452857,
-0.1594413966,
-0.4404761791,
0.1126838252,
-0.2035423666,
-0.0485759377,
0.1680482477,
0.5930562019,
-0.4474692047,
0.2818075418,
0.529260397,
-0.1082228199,
0.2991551757,
-0.5142635107,
0.237853393,
-0.8209429979,
-0.1884851903,
-0.1239546165,
-0.2465817183,
-0.895807445,
-0.4080135822,
-0.1382012367,
-0.1151201874,
-0.5308410525,
0.6945753694,
-0.5137687325,
-0.1688331366,
-0.4266363978,
0.2561525702,
-0.0332067907,
1.1057835817,
0.238395974,
0.8827112913,
0.3598701954,
-1.0390665531,
0.2415580451,
0.5183606148,
0.1348542571,
0.6228312254,
-0.478553921,
0.3434406817,
-0.1018173173,
0.2220670432,
-1.0000345707,
-0.1844048202,
0.3057106435,
-0.0861784518,
0.3624381721,
-0.1497228295,
0.0665980205,
-0.2193402499,
0.0466979854,
0.1250254214,
0.2032069713,
-0.7248151302,
0.8239595294,
0.3287026286,
-0.1286783218,
-0.7837380171,
-0.4006655216,
-0.1290976256,
-0.0979909673,
-0.2901224792,
0.1741013974,
-0.1340999752,
-0.1855270118,
-0.484282732,
-0.0494582616,
-0.1054694802,
0.0553807691,
0.1419708729,
0.0669492558,
0.322726965,
0.3310956955,
-0.1037892476,
-0.0647210404,
-0.1402770877,
0.1511404365,
0.6773263812,
-0.3671450913,
-0.6999373436,
-0.2718130648,
0.3169583976,
0.2021955997,
-0.0438817888,
0.4530030191,
0.4306814671,
0.3543940187,
-0.2268039286,
-0.6157239079,
-0.4958918095,
-0.5421833992,
0.3845789433,
-0.3640216589,
-0.9266192317,
0.4033421874,
-0.2885119617,
0.2473836094,
0.1276030242,
0.4810765386,
-0.0735047087,
1.0519478321,
0.4478072226,
0.0998284146,
0.7476919293,
-0.2311335355,
0.3753562868,
-0.6329686642,
-0.2371167243,
-0.3854542077,
-0.220432505,
-0.5644686222,
-0.3453349769,
0.3238971233,
-0.2453697324,
-0.2444712967,
0.0334977284,
-0.2836787701,
0.4164306819,
0.6626733541,
0.2104929686,
0.2643716931,
-0.1827116311,
0.0115441512,
0.1818695813,
-0.5912919044,
-0.308163017,
0.9732860327,
0.2582808733,
0.8768812418,
0.0933319032,
0.8263576627,
0.2603062987,
0.1131615713,
-0.8668079972,
0.5904834867,
0.1177039668,
-0.3816565573,
-0.4996530414,
-0.3351449668,
-1.1593323946,
0.5231698155,
-0.213318646,
-0.4550856948,
0.1613141447,
0.6217923164,
-0.4176901579,
-0.0850128457,
-0.8664395213,
0.7516642213,
-0.5212008357,
-0.4474600852,
-0.4073934257,
-0.7823300958,
0.1381590664,
0.4040996432,
0.0336289741,
-0.1263948232,
0.1171969697,
0.2684193552,
-0.316547364,
0.9690613151,
-0.1480277926,
-0.2102765292,
0.2427577525,
-0.0115668438,
0.6457051635,
-0.1651712954,
0.1210738793,
0.0073694694,
-0.3415285051,
-0.4168125093,
-0.7922587991,
0.373723805,
-0.870898664,
-0.9351329207,
-0.2910016477,
-0.1475395411,
-0.7752748132,
-0.0980363786,
-0.0767900348,
0.3236364424,
-0.444447875,
-0.0271481182,
0.896489203,
-0.0370264389,
0.3368421197,
0.8610534668,
0.0056096897,
-0.2620860636,
0.8803953528,
-0.4204288423,
0.4789221287,
0.4633694887,
0.1919589788,
-0.4748224914,
-0.4964982569,
-0.4747703671,
0.3267261982,
-0.8280999064,
0.0651490092,
-0.5697989464,
-0.0825344324,
-0.1599245816,
0.1217792407,
-0.2648465931,
-0.0620324053,
-0.5793445706,
-0.0541628078,
0.1008552164,
0.5527091622,
0.0527044646,
0.5195474029,
-0.4744833112,
0.4588777125,
0.7251281142,
0.1921235472,
-0.2152277827,
-0.703389287,
-0.1532831788,
0.0903008357,
-0.6912064552,
-0.7344757915,
0.1800713241,
0.2670550942,
0.6904220581,
0.5508304238,
-0.0031091976,
0.695335567,
-0.4499527514,
0.6801995635,
0.2524569929,
-0.6312896013,
0.6090025902,
-0.1561554372,
0.2468047738,
0.7189003825,
0.318714112,
-0.4609829783,
-0.2397073358,
-0.7651894689,
-0.6919968128,
0.9247476459,
0.0211896729,
0.2934431732,
-0.1524290591,
0.1978277713,
0.0298711974,
0.4540095627,
-0.7233608961,
-0.4114915133,
-0.2319513559,
-0.0632538199,
0.0131934602,
-0.1164445952,
-0.4237760305,
0.013443144,
0.7847742438,
-0.5764346719,
0.2470355481,
0.2254995555,
-0.054090973,
0.1868051887,
0.659678638,
0.7821936011,
0.5381968617,
0.0660538003,
-0.0129501382,
0.3778491318,
-0.0617313497,
0.242206499,
-0.0196868442,
0.2275752872,
-0.3349350393,
-0.1090435162,
1.1821775436,
0.1891630143,
-0.7330633402,
0.4517320395,
-0.1166350991,
-0.1262836605,
-0.1288644224,
0.3999577761,
-0.0664824545,
0.2460551113,
0.0759297907,
-0.3222027421,
0.3493995965,
-0.8295758963,
-0.0930435285,
0.6746733785,
-0.518348515,
0.0820419788,
0.0360119194,
0.7124328017,
-0.4268078506,
0.4540536404,
-0.3308084011,
-0.4009906948,
0.3220968544,
0.3004085422,
0.848436892,
-0.3790575564,
0.4170724154,
0.1260782331,
-0.0956405997,
-0.1205601394,
0.1786690652,
-0.2576819062,
-0.7622812986,
-0.0650744885,
-0.3135592639,
-0.8976889849,
0.3088114858,
-0.3427941203,
0.1181395724,
-0.3820189834,
-0.0725854188,
-0.2331635207,
-0.0871519446,
-0.540572226,
0.3270607889,
-0.113757655,
0.2312453091,
-0.598921895,
0.6218588352,
0.4662356377,
-0.360128969,
-0.8101890683,
0.0516303033,
-0.0635427684,
-0.972838223,
0.3513125181,
-0.0662280321,
-0.4755140543,
-0.1977460086,
-0.4267053604,
-0.657038331,
0.9826731086,
0.4156445861,
-0.5880662799,
-0.1342426091,
0.2118816674,
0.6999976039,
-0.3755569756,
0.6365921497,
0.6220396161,
0.2659015357,
0.4549506903,
-0.9370582104,
-0.2605363429,
-0.0571824126,
-0.0562795661,
0.1784161776,
-1.0832160711,
0.5030562878,
-0.2392010838,
-0.0244710948,
-0.1672586203,
0.6229470968,
0.127865687,
0.1641956121,
0.5929419398,
0.3617374897,
0.6733551621,
-0.1573753506,
0.8470525742,
-0.0504263826,
0.003392458,
1.4465782642,
-0.2799839675,
0.7915471792,
0.5894306302,
-0.0653465688,
0.4909867048,
0.520103395,
0.1840523183,
0.5101627111,
0.0972397998,
-0.3311451972,
-0.4924282134,
0.0244284384,
0.15311037,
0.5081073642,
0.4372829497,
-0.1617760658,
-0.1674814224,
-0.0614371002,
-0.0392741002,
0.2964384556,
-0.1906352192,
1.3060013056,
-0.0729738548,
-1.1753633022,
0.6116509438,
-0.0796895176,
0.5224722028,
-0.7524822354,
-0.1995359361,
-0.4800980389,
0.2063965499,
-0.0146476934,
-0.5913084149,
0.0005035648,
-0.3817492723,
0.0908578336,
-0.2545843422,
0.4410645068,
-0.7826436162,
0.0791889727,
0.2950811386,
0.4523278475,
0.2660669982,
0.1891854107,
-1.1702187061,
-0.0703488812,
0.1402297765,
-0.2470379025,
0.3541390896,
0.2993130386,
0.0048564184,
0.917657733,
0.2819913924,
-0.1086033806,
-0.1154778227,
0.2818816006,
0.8482766151,
-0.387111187,
-0.5043591261,
-0.528147161,
0.4923544228,
-0.2929736674,
-0.4183844626,
0.3487711549,
0.2358358055,
0.6586260796,
0.0240619835,
0.6734541655,
0.1252376288,
0.6248842478,
-0.6441975236,
0.1363753527,
-0.5214385986,
0.2441547513,
0.1077286601,
-0.6075653434,
0.2497608513,
0.5875476599,
-0.5028854012,
0.4014056027,
0.5599115491,
0.9495407343,
-0.1808684468,
-0.1363207996,
0.5192242861,
-0.0051527461,
0.493366152,
0.3537600338,
0.7409619093,
-0.3029488027,
0.967666924,
-0.0247415286,
-0.0706079453,
-0.4899297655,
-0.7357270718,
-1.1287488937,
-0.6837372184,
-0.2437109947,
-0.1965778917,
0.3205298483,
1.0458203554,
0.9091835022,
-0.7508248091,
-0.2834776938,
-0.2505661249,
0.2524522543,
-0.07661625,
-0.1490451545,
0.2142400742,
-0.6815940738,
-0.9809590578,
0.6615826488,
0.2651772201,
0.2637481689,
-0.3223541081,
-0.593994379,
-0.2934630215,
0.3319210708,
0.3562855124,
0.656606555,
-0.9790876508,
-0.1228668317,
-0.2584419549,
-0.1986616403,
0.3849929273,
0.7973631024,
-0.4842081666,
0.5895684361,
0.0314340256,
0.6701909304,
0.5658125877,
0.3147520721,
0.6268411875,
-0.9451048374,
0.1888165474,
0.2808509171,
0.1102055833,
0.4810867906,
-0.3423931301,
0.345908463,
-0.1444353461,
-0.5839224458,
-0.3681910038,
0.5493723154,
-0.7249494791,
-0.186212033,
1.3520002365,
-0.1606405824,
0.0718876123,
-0.3514347672,
-0.6426618099,
0.1153684109,
-0.6795142293,
1.0689539909,
0.5752240419,
-0.6721653938,
-0.3927814662,
-0.0635305345,
0.9330086708,
0.6730075479,
-1.1680134535,
0.2334547043,
0.5929446816,
-0.0431597754,
0.295103997,
0.8127926588,
0.2599386573,
0.2218499929,
-0.2289284766,
0.0342991389,
-0.0395245589,
-0.4193313718,
-0.3904328942,
-0.047403723,
0.3037084937,
-0.1770752072
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00199v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00199v2
|
Exfiltration of personal information from ChatGPT via prompt injection
| 2024-05-31T21:21:19 | 2024-06-06T06:43:38 |
Gregory Schwartzman
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.ET
|
We report that ChatGPT 4 and 4o are susceptible to a prompt injection attack
that allows an attacker to exfiltrate users' personal data. It is applicable
without the use of any 3rd party tools and all users are currently affected.
This vulnerability is exacerbated by the recent introduction of ChatGPT's
memory feature, which allows an attacker to command ChatGPT to monitor the user
for the desired personal data.
|
[
-0.5275663137,
-1.1779412031,
0.7483282089,
-0.1272270083,
-0.1169284359,
0.1174498275,
0.4570747912,
-0.5788573623,
-0.0913223401,
0.7996734381,
-0.5381747484,
-0.1346809119,
-0.6256821752,
-0.0418467447,
-0.3206810057,
1.0887559652,
0.2836559713,
-0.2767782807,
0.2158146054,
0.1006786227,
-0.9231859446,
-1.0140961409,
-1.0080127716,
0.0483315252,
0.465005517,
0.7057082057,
0.7817950249,
0.119660683,
0.6576265693,
0.313934356,
0.2129317522,
-0.6910219193,
-0.5635619164,
0.2211364508,
-0.0219218843,
-0.7514263988,
-0.176012218,
0.0893458575,
0.2652222216,
0.1679881513,
-0.1044073105,
-0.2527183592,
-0.0227701683,
0.3642553687,
-0.5003820062,
-0.0847800821,
-0.6161565185,
0.2132823914,
-0.7170779109,
-0.5762552619,
-0.4441799521,
-0.2855928242,
0.2940497994,
-0.4236227572,
0.3872481287,
0.3440533876,
0.5753207803,
0.0777105018,
-0.5931043625,
-0.4574639499,
-0.5065814257,
0.3039911985,
-0.3844295144,
0.0489650145,
0.3815135062,
0.6894338727,
-0.5273988843,
-0.8505536914,
-0.565246582,
-0.168313697,
-0.1130055711,
0.0843056589,
-0.3736152649,
0.4619479179,
0.5315392613,
0.4641761482,
-0.6536318064,
-0.0044435984,
-0.5303513408,
-0.3160571754,
0.0335548706,
0.0176701285,
0.7333744168,
-0.3247919977,
-0.9264612794,
0.1079483926,
-0.8853937984,
0.0174870174,
0.8789081573,
-0.0811296478,
0.0925137326,
0.4777846038,
-0.0424514189,
0.7170666456,
0.0091004213,
0.2253270894,
0.1486961544,
-0.3032847345,
-0.3352630734,
0.1740107536,
0.7831088901,
0.3460436463,
0.0096561117,
0.1238782182,
-0.1790376008,
-0.4850683212,
0.1691512764,
-0.8974764943,
-0.524594605,
0.4578693807,
-0.0341199301,
-0.0658848062,
0.2133707404,
-1.0488240719,
-0.6340745091,
0.5557777882,
0.4354438186,
-0.7336446643,
0.0580912381,
-0.0586400405,
-0.5874355435,
0.3590257764,
0.3773757815,
-1.0504428148,
0.3979044855,
0.6524479985,
0.9512512684,
-0.1461669207,
-0.2989720404,
-0.7228528261,
0.2088539004,
0.1526673734,
0.9319919348,
-0.6024847627,
-0.6404463649,
0.0793391913,
-0.0866652429,
0.018955538,
-0.5452647805,
0.5223932266,
-0.8188578486,
0.4323985279,
-0.4174696505,
-0.5885006189,
-0.305116713,
0.0858342126,
-0.5719602108,
0.7800272703,
0.4036795497,
-0.8387616873,
0.2397003174,
-0.7738574743,
-0.0531597473,
0.3838067055,
-0.0717258528,
-0.0621388368,
-0.1065607518,
-0.05710987,
0.5878735781,
0.1969769299,
-0.306096673,
-0.302277863,
-0.4884615541,
0.5510433316,
-0.5042474866,
0.6317350268,
0.3651310802,
-0.0949285179,
-0.0671709552,
-0.4992166162,
0.0419162698,
-0.0936739966,
-0.0714347586,
-0.2196698785,
-0.229452461,
-0.2552030683,
0.1698449105,
0.3753417432,
-0.5237988234,
0.395329237,
-0.4877907336,
0.5619673729,
0.9120534062,
0.8996451497,
0.3420344293,
-0.221759811,
0.7780014873,
0.3500073254,
0.4566483796,
-0.527284503,
-1.1202943325,
-0.1021938026,
-0.0567532927,
-0.254480809,
0.8685272932,
-0.8513530493,
-0.0152077973,
0.2440534085,
-0.3617914915,
0.3089915812,
0.1018781736,
0.3324506879,
0.6051827669,
0.2796308994,
-0.0029408191,
0.0153499451,
-0.9404034615,
-0.4025107324,
-0.1986364722,
-0.2486899793,
0.504997611,
0.3629902303,
-0.1296413392,
0.8920969367,
-0.6846390367,
-0.3308982253,
0.0056745061,
0.0217621643,
0.53188622,
0.5042678714,
0.6867864132,
-0.8493086696,
-0.5581210852,
-0.0036541189,
-0.3436619937,
-0.3949941993,
-0.3195497096,
-0.158012569,
-0.3239174187,
0.2573728561,
-0.7184303999,
0.5684900284,
0.5854002833,
-0.7305764556,
0.2586625516,
-0.3904937208,
0.5451432467,
-1.0637633801,
-0.1403444558,
-0.3107541203,
-0.4267970026,
-1.0248568058,
0.2450055927,
0.0745185092,
-0.5571396947,
-0.6182973981,
0.3968673944,
-0.298278302,
-0.0154736619,
0.0786823556,
0.3787340224,
-0.1858156323,
0.2796323597,
-0.5711758137,
1.0374023914,
0.4922822416,
-0.5318636894,
0.548535645,
0.3008611202,
-0.2262746543,
0.4964303374,
-0.6875510812,
0.5069890022,
0.181445688,
0.1595846862,
-1.265055418,
-0.8026619554,
1.0613991022,
-0.5985353589,
0.3396413028,
-0.3494437039,
-0.2115366608,
0.0262183342,
-0.446447134,
0.3613116145,
0.6021440625,
-0.5704299212,
0.3564852774,
0.3572509885,
-0.1827649176,
-0.4452653825,
-0.7161269784,
0.3031058013,
-0.521594584,
-0.8014009595,
0.328661859,
-0.0623330884,
0.0800541267,
-0.2261895686,
0.1735607833,
-0.439866364,
0.1838887781,
0.3093728125,
0.1869236976,
0.2704600394,
-0.161033228,
-0.103558436,
-0.2085757554,
0.005397053,
0.144821465,
0.7706251144,
0.2027496845,
-0.7801769972,
-0.7397600412,
0.9648504257,
0.2934036553,
0.1312693059,
0.5901396871,
0.2368528098,
-0.0802586749,
0.1945625395,
-0.6199660301,
-0.3220227063,
-0.595587194,
0.1937117577,
-0.6048267484,
-0.9353493452,
0.8071001768,
-0.0223254003,
-0.2022013664,
0.0407901816,
0.0619520694,
-0.0365830474,
1.1201478243,
0.3413406312,
0.2022264302,
0.6197702885,
0.3508098423,
0.20649077,
-0.7474051714,
-0.2740755379,
-0.4528076649,
-0.134667024,
-0.6479763389,
-0.2012415528,
0.3509849608,
0.2595408857,
-0.2858558595,
0.3539162278,
-0.4985886216,
0.4417082369,
0.7681310773,
0.28806445,
0.1370494217,
-0.2214702517,
0.1679564863,
0.0437604897,
-0.4443264604,
-0.3027421832,
0.7568668723,
0.2145186067,
0.9390048385,
0.3084046543,
0.8021551967,
0.507535696,
-0.3048065007,
-0.5696422458,
0.4802268445,
0.4061128497,
-0.7856577039,
-0.0789902434,
-0.3207131028,
-1.2092864513,
-0.2017831206,
0.4484680295,
-1.2286298275,
0.3074541092,
0.5453600287,
-0.6091483235,
0.1121474504,
-1.6331870556,
0.7066619396,
0.0490104891,
0.0002736305,
0.1112975553,
-0.6514732838,
0.4411718249,
-0.4272432029,
-0.1207406297,
-0.1467325091,
-0.2863990664,
0.640547514,
-0.8627408743,
1.0805156231,
-0.6177780628,
0.1641930193,
0.4728766084,
0.1607215106,
0.9111246467,
0.4119746685,
0.3048725724,
0.2905555069,
0.190315336,
-0.5692635775,
-0.8643652201,
0.6390696168,
-0.6312466264,
-1.1972067356,
-0.7802808285,
0.0735108107,
-0.0873265862,
0.0203044098,
0.5773292184,
0.0882298425,
0.0880067497,
0.040216431,
0.6465843916,
-0.6302520037,
0.5724419355,
0.2048019171,
-0.0476222821,
-0.2799109817,
0.6740143895,
0.2244475335,
0.688993752,
0.14381814,
0.199620381,
-0.0809043571,
-0.5285984278,
-0.3629635572,
0.0061870352,
-0.7084710598,
-0.3208381534,
-0.6748015881,
-0.223732084,
-0.3555946946,
-0.1957022846,
-0.0769036412,
-0.3154147267,
-0.1960793436,
-0.005432996,
0.711363852,
0.6511792541,
-0.014523929,
1.1327611208,
-0.8942659497,
0.2598356605,
0.500443697,
0.1482802331,
-0.6870949864,
-0.5994797349,
0.0737364516,
-0.0245330837,
-0.2628982365,
-1.6015857458,
0.303969264,
0.2267509401,
0.4864850044,
0.6937997937,
-0.1650168449,
0.7579999566,
-0.7111254334,
1.1307975054,
0.2724747062,
-1.0753474236,
0.8416796923,
-0.4571813047,
0.4691297412,
0.3871006668,
0.3426266909,
-0.9700483084,
-0.2359580398,
-0.6443651915,
-0.7059951425,
0.789496243,
0.2554336488,
0.4241764843,
-0.2660778761,
0.5485284328,
0.0771043301,
0.0358970612,
-0.3652640879,
-0.251578778,
-0.2529729009,
0.4623638391,
0.4097949564,
-0.7397229075,
0.1562832147,
0.3280680776,
0.2175105512,
0.188441366,
0.7708397508,
0.2583756745,
0.348725915,
0.3842308521,
0.105081901,
0.3242346644,
0.3109180629,
-0.0256107841,
0.1770009398,
0.2595275342,
-0.8364181519,
0.2736354172,
-0.1693538576,
-0.0426183566,
-0.1510485113,
0.168168664,
0.448677212,
0.3759872317,
-0.4043895006,
0.9035971761,
-0.2942361534,
0.1677399427,
-0.6909133196,
0.6800575852,
-0.3702361584,
0.050892137,
0.2680274248,
0.42026335,
0.4751619399,
-0.5587410331,
0.2651599646,
0.3080338836,
-0.5140328407,
-0.6272699833,
0.7326409817,
0.05706352,
-0.289341867,
0.7576773167,
-0.0608964898,
-0.5420223475,
0.2821036577,
0.6071070433,
0.7394045591,
-1.1544120312,
-0.0564211123,
0.225786373,
0.2537309825,
0.3274342716,
0.5097406507,
0.0358177684,
-0.7549890876,
-0.3062012494,
-0.0085655972,
-0.4475094676,
-0.0557776056,
-0.5527986288,
0.5165333152,
-0.5940105319,
-0.2350150198,
-0.2246495932,
-0.5096188188,
-0.7041242123,
0.0544263236,
-0.1012098268,
0.8628937602,
-0.5210840702,
0.7206549048,
0.2582649887,
-0.1037752256,
-0.5476657152,
-0.0391080901,
0.1413232386,
-1.022436738,
0.6113721728,
0.2048116475,
0.072215125,
0.0913998783,
-0.4746381938,
-0.9220508933,
0.8316192031,
0.4209109843,
-0.0861708075,
0.0399084687,
0.1806631535,
0.0017155189,
0.1595112681,
0.5761163831,
0.6718305349,
0.5894337893,
0.1661889702,
-0.4595356286,
0.057102751,
-0.1419851631,
-0.2418027222,
0.4608615041,
-0.6811225414,
0.8545140624,
-0.0672504231,
-0.5966994762,
-0.3624468446,
0.2648509741,
-0.0020846163,
0.1006783321,
0.4335745573,
0.4424010217,
1.094815731,
-0.3154275417,
1.4003856182,
-0.2897242308,
-0.0929385275,
1.0888303518,
-0.3482355177,
0.5595985055,
0.4441984892,
-0.1717223078,
0.2693624496,
0.8418835402,
0.0811368451,
0.5775607824,
-0.1506832242,
-0.87349087,
0.3222871721,
0.2826331854,
-0.5733985305,
0.5549240708,
0.718870163,
-0.1943378299,
-0.0573822223,
0.259111762,
0.4903000891,
-0.7104934454,
0.1269245297,
0.8051131368,
-0.1597307771,
-0.6236052513,
0.2933313251,
-0.1375742406,
0.2195464969,
-0.8348882198,
-0.1201911569,
-0.174689427,
-0.2062789053,
-0.3616599739,
-0.8974311352,
0.3359594941,
-0.174848035,
0.1794354171,
-0.1485082954,
0.9016574025,
0.1099709198,
0.3910814226,
0.2034491599,
0.3223499954,
0.3713467121,
-0.6197528839,
-0.6248687506,
-0.1151605621,
0.3294314146,
-0.7481188774,
0.4450929761,
0.5802417994,
0.0706959516,
0.8925930858,
0.8266811967,
-0.0364964306,
0.4533885419,
-0.076574944,
1.1198134422,
-0.8930962086,
-0.4117959738,
-1.3574754,
0.1892323792,
-0.5400310755,
-0.3498246372,
1.2288885117,
0.6542893648,
0.5177984238,
-0.0157509539,
0.8593169451,
-0.2458971292,
0.4560213685,
-0.4764407575,
0.5638677478,
0.2380062044,
0.3565452397,
-0.2185467482,
-0.7382826805,
-0.1962060332,
0.0637853593,
-0.3524810672,
0.1088069975,
1.005396843,
0.9395890236,
0.0473149121,
0.2015579492,
0.6754523516,
0.1759823561,
0.6751630306,
0.6733444929,
1.1291935444,
-0.3019303381,
0.703243196,
-0.287522018,
-0.6310190558,
-0.1361899525,
-0.7744002342,
-1.1154607534,
-0.5483494997,
-0.1532385349,
-0.0900570974,
0.0874663815,
0.320879668,
0.697281599,
-0.6574988365,
0.3344499767,
-0.2627402246,
-0.0288920235,
0.3543285728,
-0.3317402601,
0.1512984186,
-0.3452508152,
-0.8767520785,
0.449773401,
0.5966959596,
0.3318724334,
-0.1866845042,
0.365449518,
0.0285676867,
0.0243838783,
0.2513783574,
0.388581574,
-0.4679731727,
-0.7043783665,
-0.2273159325,
0.0963118821,
0.2334969938,
0.9257521629,
-0.8399435878,
0.5258864164,
0.8001528382,
0.5360571742,
0.3347567916,
0.1852489561,
0.6788049936,
-0.9481695294,
0.264023155,
0.1513878405,
0.4892525673,
0.0824626535,
-1.0830808878,
0.3245979846,
0.3017926216,
-1.0078599453,
-0.3982699513,
0.3095490336,
-0.9529030919,
-0.0503725,
1.0080586672,
-0.5990356207,
-0.3827553391,
-0.6946725249,
-0.6402798295,
-0.1801422089,
-0.7749838829,
0.5417138934,
0.854744792,
-0.6697654128,
-0.4270512164,
-1.3761436939,
0.6171988845,
0.000976162,
-1.0036714077,
-0.3274216056,
0.3628799319,
0.0850376636,
0.0060712919,
0.7088439465,
-0.1644042879,
0.2963565588,
0.1293299496,
-0.3207371533,
0.1740060151,
0.125652954,
-0.2028102279,
0.5816390514,
-0.1505302638,
-0.4112788141
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00197v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00197v1
|
Re3: A Holistic Framework and Dataset for Modeling Collaborative Document Revision
| 2024-05-31T21:19:09 | 2024-05-31T21:19:09 |
Qian Ruan, Ilia Kuznetsov, Iryna Gurevych
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Collaborative review and revision of textual documents is the core of
knowledge work and a promising target for empirical analysis and NLP
assistance. Yet, a holistic framework that would allow modeling complex
relationships between document revisions, reviews and author responses is
lacking. To address this gap, we introduce Re3, a framework for joint analysis
of collaborative document revision. We instantiate this framework in the
scholarly domain, and present Re3-Sci, a large corpus of aligned scientific
paper revisions manually labeled according to their action and intent, and
supplemented with the respective peer reviews and human-written edit summaries.
We use the new data to provide first empirical insights into collaborative
document revision in the academic domain, and to assess the capabilities of
state-of-the-art LLMs at automating edit analysis and facilitating text-based
collaboration. We make our annotation environment and protocols, the resulting
data and experimental code publicly available.
|
[
-0.2602612376,
-0.5321701169,
0.5547739267,
0.1048452333,
0.1837747991,
0.1428576112,
0.1095926464,
-0.6246984601,
0.386036247,
0.8805357814,
-0.6155369282,
-0.5335427523,
-0.3127873242,
0.5037762523,
-0.3442490697,
1.0399309397,
-0.4296437502,
0.0840050802,
-0.5270159245,
-0.1956262439,
-0.1962341815,
-0.3268755674,
-0.2612293065,
-0.6038789153,
0.8225633502,
0.3653379381,
0.4937343001,
0.4169075191,
0.8266663551,
0.3274546564,
0.1705334932,
0.041340109,
-0.427844435,
0.3064981997,
-0.0758613423,
-0.3092310727,
-1.1746196747,
0.2774090767,
0.4622719288,
1.0201485157,
0.0618447587,
0.1845550984,
0.3505001962,
0.8411322832,
-0.4744553864,
0.2433860153,
-0.4870003462,
0.0040891017,
-0.1498587132,
-0.1871906072,
-0.3610798419,
-0.1330209821,
0.1457823813,
-1.1485122442,
0.7808499336,
0.2880401909,
0.4322863221,
0.3179316521,
-0.0637706891,
-0.1584803313,
-0.4905765951,
0.4869873226,
-0.5026746988,
0.2299223393,
0.3724573851,
-0.0606648177,
-0.4995567501,
-0.9629886746,
-0.478508234,
0.183364287,
-0.1558867842,
0.2450187206,
0.0841539055,
-0.0038038329,
-0.134103328,
0.5208089352,
-0.4203051329,
-0.2317682356,
-0.2465479076,
-0.0418987162,
0.8320895433,
0.115193367,
0.0988044068,
-0.0406814441,
-0.2670175731,
-0.0757733583,
-0.5966186523,
-0.4869922698,
0.2639255822,
0.0222131554,
0.0501070842,
0.5343885422,
-0.0282089971,
0.674471736,
0.1398501396,
0.1820310652,
0.2797106504,
-0.5677295327,
-0.4472957551,
-0.1978352219,
0.7884453535,
0.6734797955,
-0.5123971105,
-0.2115816325,
-0.1220810935,
-0.2163776904,
0.3378244936,
-0.3361837566,
0.0010276142,
0.2782749236,
-0.4189367294,
-0.3685449362,
0.0004553382,
-0.7398740649,
-0.5610513091,
-0.6480608582,
0.0536030009,
-0.0428862758,
-0.0749622658,
0.4260164797,
-0.1272871196,
-0.2170178294,
0.8801628947,
-0.762922883,
0.4320242405,
1.1514035463,
0.7818582654,
-0.2220939398,
-0.8975650072,
-0.0708586797,
0.5062298179,
-0.0950396135,
0.963190496,
-0.1888679713,
-0.602983892,
-0.2168785632,
0.0706328973,
0.1028435752,
-0.1543994546,
0.2881844938,
-0.619020462,
0.3405176997,
-0.2279273868,
-0.5610311627,
-0.1411592215,
0.4653043747,
-1.1163487434,
0.5982927084,
0.2918579876,
-1.1044118404,
0.4196114242,
-0.5013113618,
0.0082901642,
0.0585946292,
0.0549135767,
-0.5196562409,
-0.2208735347,
0.0681953132,
0.2962955534,
-0.5692520738,
0.3505084217,
-0.8455607891,
-0.2265818417,
-0.13285622,
0.1798182428,
0.5282762647,
0.0500454307,
0.0806558877,
0.4076647162,
-0.5926799774,
-0.3186154068,
-0.2299098521,
-0.0860393941,
-0.3955511749,
-0.1023627371,
0.1792719662,
-0.2453152537,
0.3759604096,
-0.651016891,
0.396040976,
-0.1616547257,
0.332927227,
0.356374979,
0.4111055434,
0.5468510389,
-0.6151189804,
0.301214695,
-0.5480314493,
0.3230529726,
-0.0036675546,
-0.5310018063,
-0.2992145419,
-0.2119910419,
0.3717855215,
0.1912300885,
-0.313161552,
0.3453883529,
-0.2828838527,
-0.5019364953,
-0.6622795463,
0.2563444376,
0.2690645754,
0.4109176099,
0.4241413176,
-0.2981339097,
-0.7751643062,
-0.835001111,
-0.3892534971,
-0.6248240471,
-0.2138948739,
-0.1391723305,
0.6637390256,
-0.3843183219,
1.1284140348,
-0.2888949811,
-0.7413920164,
-0.0753909275,
0.7214115858,
-0.1024546325,
0.3580474854,
0.1211829633,
-0.7035101056,
-0.1972389966,
-0.1237915754,
-0.8769783378,
-0.4257540703,
-0.0644066185,
-0.1210619584,
0.0655767992,
0.6986587644,
0.0238907076,
0.2176992744,
0.5460194349,
-0.1049026996,
0.1654481292,
-0.1976242065,
0.3808123469,
-1.0682858229,
0.2899879813,
-0.0825821981,
-0.0909483805,
-0.3150551021,
0.056834396,
-0.1246768236,
-0.1383310854,
-0.0793649778,
0.3203534484,
-0.5797643065,
-0.3169395626,
-0.0626656339,
0.5157475471,
0.3905943334,
0.3780876398,
0.2022194117,
0.332080245,
-0.2482583225,
0.0127752572,
0.2111233622,
0.4639754295,
-0.0876661986,
0.6457895637,
-0.8030881882,
0.268579036,
0.0740901902,
0.734806478,
-0.4955445528,
-0.5596327186,
0.1065801084,
-0.4675823152,
-0.0319885314,
-0.3150378168,
-0.7605652809,
-0.0008371384,
-0.5390074849,
0.1878594458,
-0.4048498869,
-0.2817516625,
0.8073830009,
0.6938202977,
-0.3257909417,
-0.3953826427,
-0.4646730721,
0.180659458,
0.2925809622,
-0.9162346721,
0.9089512825,
0.0831399038,
-0.4839379191,
0.3477447331,
0.1702238768,
-0.1645513028,
-0.0561383553,
0.4561914206,
0.4383520782,
0.2971156538,
-0.3834405541,
-0.2482559234,
-0.2191778868,
0.2825095057,
0.2463939041,
-0.0399710983,
-0.1942040622,
-0.4269165993,
-0.2369436175,
0.333343327,
0.7999542356,
-0.0415696725,
0.1335094422,
0.4279557467,
-0.440895766,
0.2235944271,
-0.531109333,
0.0630224198,
-0.3453085124,
0.1650089622,
-0.1471431255,
-0.9534062147,
0.5369751453,
0.1545205563,
0.5433135629,
0.4712285101,
0.506583631,
-0.1463992745,
0.588204205,
0.5213315487,
0.0371238105,
0.1580221206,
-0.0975308344,
-0.0609766357,
-1.2777341604,
-0.371532619,
-0.5940053463,
-0.1659088582,
-0.2673789561,
-0.4715719223,
0.4408759773,
0.0473932289,
0.0161384474,
0.2838240564,
-0.3141896129,
0.2395199835,
0.3934961557,
-0.0803874955,
0.537607789,
-0.3370582759,
0.1003109217,
-0.1754715741,
-0.334009856,
-0.7112802267,
1.0265769958,
0.3157517314,
0.7042422295,
-0.0358938798,
0.8503352404,
0.3091060221,
0.8302631974,
-0.3721919358,
0.5831565261,
0.3355051875,
-0.6925218105,
-0.2599641681,
-0.0578349754,
-0.8609836698,
0.1974778175,
-0.3431910276,
-0.1053865999,
0.1896292418,
0.0339524187,
-0.2213115096,
0.3463681638,
-0.6329401731,
0.6092842817,
0.1849766672,
-0.9222747684,
-0.3714272082,
-0.6394125819,
0.3428112864,
-0.5758137703,
0.2984598875,
0.1085991412,
-0.0899157748,
0.8461015224,
-0.5876037478,
0.9763275981,
-0.0012386689,
-0.1925515234,
0.2763745785,
0.4280546308,
0.3206415474,
0.3207809925,
-0.225923866,
0.0126505727,
0.1773017347,
-0.1461298019,
-0.7709430456,
0.9589255452,
-0.7926197648,
-0.5819272995,
-0.5376021266,
-0.7060120702,
-0.3274382353,
0.2083406895,
-0.055490315,
0.1565731168,
-0.4674097896,
0.3054989278,
0.1567450464,
0.3008990288,
0.2369308472,
0.7192358375,
-0.4482737482,
-0.8033663034,
0.1923270673,
0.0130611807,
0.0157006774,
0.2799006402,
-0.1213614568,
-0.0500374399,
-0.6015992165,
-0.0533595905,
0.4577828646,
-0.5306121707,
-0.1229612306,
-0.668806076,
0.4125217795,
-0.5472156405,
-0.6184512377,
-0.2196216732,
-0.3308223784,
-0.3178701103,
0.1261418462,
0.1662550569,
1.2950692177,
-0.2776342332,
-0.0064726234,
-0.884980619,
0.1885184795,
0.0797818154,
0.3774233758,
-0.1065033078,
-0.0624316484,
-0.1715016812,
-0.0483800173,
-0.4330365062,
-0.7370910645,
0.290268898,
-0.3659337163,
0.2909076512,
-0.3316048384,
0.0846156105,
0.5390118361,
-0.349538058,
0.8301244974,
-0.0327328183,
-0.9001165032,
0.3886070251,
-0.5632348061,
0.0273718815,
0.7991182804,
0.1637005955,
-0.5774224997,
-0.2656775117,
-0.8308137655,
-0.7435692549,
0.5138546228,
0.1784313619,
-0.6459054351,
0.3726478815,
0.4555720687,
0.068131417,
0.1140965447,
-0.4995104373,
0.2020207793,
-0.2304828614,
-0.0537439995,
0.1783779114,
-0.0408677757,
-0.4452928305,
0.1485898197,
0.7633012533,
-0.0969128311,
0.1849465072,
0.6068742275,
-0.1447619945,
-0.2937614024,
0.153370142,
0.4160172045,
0.5825019479,
-0.7136116624,
0.0414121896,
0.0815261453,
-0.3983031213,
-0.0232503247,
0.0173087586,
0.0729895234,
-0.0873413086,
0.8689873815,
0.2070979923,
0.4187600911,
0.0594532005,
0.3077809811,
-0.3172881901,
-0.6295512319,
-0.1899482012,
-0.2269044966,
-0.0642812997,
-0.0161139965,
0.1663453877,
0.3015758097,
0.2626987398,
-0.1946657747,
0.4427345693,
0.0585293993,
-0.5491329432,
-0.5433856845,
0.5931116939,
0.5805696249,
-0.3365463316,
0.2090566903,
0.075031586,
-0.2819969356,
0.2519138753,
0.2672664821,
0.8330584168,
0.2067663968,
0.0442987792,
0.2057279497,
0.1914948821,
-0.0692017227,
-0.0500228144,
0.0613109581,
-0.4658804834,
-0.351957351,
-0.2401477844,
-0.9786238074,
0.0384158418,
-0.8851998448,
0.3665681183,
-0.5461981893,
-0.0615745708,
0.2111921012,
0.2143736184,
-0.1288719624,
-0.0665863752,
-0.3608955145,
0.7415786386,
-0.6890334487,
0.7054064274,
0.70190835,
-0.4655982256,
-0.337104708,
-0.1071007401,
0.5437243581,
-0.3996727467,
0.5528609157,
-0.2512024939,
-0.4773802161,
0.0293877814,
-0.6427016258,
-0.6578695178,
1.2492018938,
0.0236293487,
-0.520000577,
0.0061641959,
0.0089664282,
0.8168229461,
-0.432852,
0.050959181,
0.229581058,
0.4907553792,
-0.0688402131,
-0.5720806122,
-0.1118908674,
-0.4522414207,
-0.194445774,
0.1477553993,
-0.5998006463,
0.5166024566,
-0.043806199,
0.1913895607,
-0.091626972,
0.8031915426,
0.4117574394,
0.458463788,
0.5130663514,
0.5167840719,
0.4848760366,
0.0453264154,
0.967095077,
-0.451723218,
0.4348066747,
1.4660973549,
-0.9836033583,
0.8610426188,
0.7692385316,
-0.0519255921,
0.3654590547,
0.5040746927,
-0.1115466282,
0.1839394718,
-0.0089920377,
-0.2117679715,
0.0450696461,
-0.2397844791,
-0.2319705486,
-0.1610459089,
0.3064850271,
-0.1369683743,
-0.1174559072,
-0.3086413443,
0.2853554785,
0.1917072684,
-0.0912226811,
0.7775706649,
-0.1008657292,
-0.9392024875,
0.1427865773,
0.1728301048,
0.3092400432,
-0.2646906674,
-0.138098523,
-0.1522470713,
0.1395834088,
-0.4545125067,
-1.093295455,
0.6721225977,
-0.0329398438,
-0.4762234688,
-0.5368142724,
0.432015866,
-0.1957178414,
-0.0950868651,
0.4690066874,
0.256408304,
-0.3126471639,
0.3083258867,
-0.785520494,
0.3621581495,
-0.0299300682,
-0.1859959513,
0.27098912,
0.3615067303,
-0.0898168236,
0.4225855172,
0.7511091828,
0.05783787,
-0.2948846519,
0.3273689747,
0.731831491,
-0.3278592527,
0.0407182053,
-0.3995591998,
0.2521680593,
-0.164243266,
-0.3107279837,
0.5725108981,
0.5741101503,
0.7847702503,
0.1432575136,
0.9008967876,
0.0234113298,
0.6730050445,
-0.314617604,
0.6126601696,
-0.4557971358,
0.4346066117,
-0.5272859931,
-0.7145841718,
-0.8598726392,
0.4502902627,
-0.2934824824,
-0.2970460951,
0.8945658207,
0.9198803902,
0.2112152129,
0.4513820112,
-0.1541457921,
0.1012582481,
0.5221733451,
0.1885863841,
0.5788882375,
-0.6956788898,
0.0784493163,
-0.2816235423,
-0.1857725829,
-0.1861376762,
-1.0011457205,
-0.7435477376,
-0.8442128897,
-0.4466309547,
-0.5078822374,
-0.0362181962,
1.0933759212,
0.3385713696,
-0.4174954295,
-0.371529609,
-0.3856674731,
0.0490072444,
-0.0828111768,
-0.1270401031,
0.3631533682,
-0.0625431016,
-0.5570949912,
0.4104700387,
0.4141841233,
0.0375233442,
-0.4762659073,
0.0031305305,
-0.245978862,
-0.1650564969,
0.1692899913,
0.048781842,
-0.6492162943,
-0.0952902511,
0.1054436937,
-0.1704052389,
-0.2260237783,
1.1611713171,
-0.4512172639,
0.4402661324,
0.7255848646,
0.5009636283,
0.3985006511,
-0.0238111932,
1.0136979818,
-0.5475720167,
-0.2603314221,
0.2273748815,
0.5380891562,
0.6115942001,
-0.1822657585,
0.9364895821,
0.4612436295,
-1.0349535942,
-0.7761259079,
-0.2198525369,
-0.9607973099,
-0.0244683307,
0.915700078,
-0.3729747236,
-0.4606246948,
-0.4553308785,
-0.3077121377,
0.3572028577,
-0.1510050744,
0.7219359279,
0.8167735338,
-0.1191383973,
0.0407151431,
-0.1273265183,
0.4235570133,
0.2879932821,
-1.017431736,
0.4915513098,
0.674107492,
-0.0004867035,
0.3222098649,
0.7313582301,
-0.2786526382,
0.2024772316,
-0.2176857591,
0.4231067002,
-0.2017781287,
-0.3023079932,
-0.2876782715,
0.1640330404,
0.0300659332,
0.4683966935
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02592v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02592v1
|
LOLAMEME: Logic, Language, Memory, Mechanistic Framework
| 2024-05-31T21:18:25 | 2024-05-31T21:18:25 |
Jay Desai, Xiaobo Guo, Srinivasan H. Sengamedu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The performance of Large Language Models has achieved superhuman breadth with
unprecedented depth. At the same time, the language models are mostly black box
models and the underlying mechanisms for performance have been evaluated using
synthetic or mechanistic schemes. We extend current mechanistic schemes to
incorporate Logic, memory, and nuances of Language such as latent structure.
The proposed framework is called LOLAMEME and we provide two instantiations of
LOLAMEME: LoLa and MeMe languages. We then consider two generative language
model architectures: transformer-based GPT-2 and convolution-based Hyena. We
propose the hybrid architecture T HEX and use LOLAMEME framework is used to
compare three architectures. T HEX outperforms GPT-2 and Hyena on select tasks.
|
[
0.0039892695,
-0.8551394343,
0.618324995,
0.3958730996,
0.0241674408,
0.4123199582,
0.2308280766,
-0.4633721709,
0.1997527182,
0.3094463944,
-0.4924396574,
-0.2812951505,
-0.4195064008,
-0.1591145992,
-0.5118489861,
0.5263345838,
0.0144474702,
-0.1643296927,
0.118930839,
-0.143980965,
-0.3522390127,
-0.4585503936,
-0.6710979342,
-0.5555017591,
0.1873816848,
-0.075619325,
0.8154890537,
0.3910503089,
0.1007046551,
0.2722572088,
-0.0203773882,
-0.2297567129,
-0.1907085627,
0.0852508619,
-0.8119632602,
-0.5875951052,
-0.6873723865,
0.0043739425,
0.426253885,
0.4861316681,
0.0254728682,
0.0546625666,
-0.2818167806,
0.4870522916,
-0.7066431046,
-0.0559004806,
-0.6163602471,
0.0343884639,
0.0435556509,
-0.2752835453,
-0.3233706057,
-0.1539096683,
0.1805351675,
-0.2148997337,
0.2352512777,
0.1258861274,
0.5567824841,
0.1829181463,
0.004993835,
-0.468859762,
-1.0414485931,
0.8139459491,
-0.6861846447,
0.4109131098,
0.26175493,
0.4959533811,
-0.0298906695,
-0.4911789,
-0.5278006792,
-0.497590661,
-0.0765763149,
0.1630852371,
-0.2163012624,
-0.1082875803,
0.24602741,
0.5139516592,
-0.9759535193,
0.1116242781,
-0.644644022,
-0.0937212631,
0.3189565241,
0.3990927041,
0.3715095222,
-0.21585913,
-0.4009556174,
-0.1766705662,
-0.7203767896,
-0.2440617532,
0.2906501889,
-0.1867947429,
0.0276816282,
0.596126914,
-0.2050208896,
0.6831631064,
-0.2051691115,
-0.1503354311,
0.0330825187,
-0.4616485834,
-0.4333378971,
-0.0263672303,
0.9041770697,
0.0799944922,
-0.0167555697,
-0.6230349541,
-0.1388688684,
0.5758955479,
0.3835346401,
-1.0742160082,
-0.1069225892,
0.5372366905,
-0.6098154187,
-0.1795117259,
0.0298173353,
-0.7706148624,
-0.0053286185,
-0.0168181211,
0.605672121,
-0.5288713574,
-0.6297634244,
0.3515598774,
-0.2037138939,
0.3619950116,
0.25438416,
-1.1369662285,
0.5363157392,
0.8745926619,
0.7961775064,
0.1942930669,
-0.2359605283,
-0.4085234702,
0.1795880198,
-0.4909313917,
0.54997015,
-0.6676927209,
-0.1142235771,
-0.2581019402,
0.0202367213,
-0.2073566169,
-0.8144286871,
0.2779709697,
-0.4850046039,
0.1745577157,
0.0836992189,
-0.6255754232,
-0.3275339901,
-0.0206957925,
-0.7187575698,
0.8232973218,
0.6053981185,
-0.2599239051,
0.0433361456,
-0.5691203475,
-0.4223507345,
0.0409750529,
-0.3569757342,
-0.2825436592,
0.2957867086,
-0.4577397406,
0.6548368931,
-0.5633095503,
0.0739997774,
-0.1783330142,
-0.3730271459,
0.1782292724,
-0.1137225553,
0.8337668777,
0.3962200582,
-0.5241232514,
0.0330013037,
-0.9335012436,
-0.0872354209,
-0.0238418113,
-0.3250153661,
-0.2850538194,
0.1253408939,
0.1366962045,
0.5282423496,
0.2385861129,
-0.3785381019,
0.0516303889,
-0.3643480241,
0.8266442418,
0.3759121597,
-0.4597879052,
0.7050824165,
-0.2286506146,
0.5854587555,
-0.2394955605,
-0.0410911031,
-0.136232987,
-0.573554635,
-0.469440341,
-0.1768826693,
0.0168842766,
0.8807278872,
-0.4598839581,
0.419185698,
0.1174683422,
-0.1722384393,
-0.5096018314,
0.3170197308,
0.492601186,
0.0932772756,
0.2228228152,
-0.0870557576,
-0.5120914578,
-1.0812997818,
0.3507289588,
-0.2494066805,
-0.1276464015,
0.1562842727,
0.4849826992,
-0.604321301,
0.6666676402,
-0.0163888372,
0.4281838834,
-0.2355181426,
0.2842818201,
0.1880167723,
0.5771563649,
0.9523166418,
-0.3857876658,
-0.204022631,
0.1301408708,
-0.8547247648,
-0.1155241951,
0.162326768,
-0.2474305332,
0.303360194,
0.4616470039,
-0.6601771116,
0.4550313354,
0.6500992179,
-0.5563438535,
0.9049078822,
-0.1481025815,
0.1697729826,
-1.4284529686,
0.0041200398,
-0.403467387,
-0.319054693,
-0.4170225263,
0.0560245216,
0.1181487814,
-0.0838467851,
-0.3109042943,
0.9552067518,
-0.3921738565,
-0.4485348761,
-0.6291093826,
-0.1964244097,
0.1857222021,
0.2653346956,
-0.0048653902,
0.9535276294,
0.4984327853,
-0.7326615453,
0.7358701229,
-0.0635490119,
-0.4850311279,
0.463087976,
-0.8445286155,
-0.0334521644,
0.1613627076,
-0.1088154167,
-0.6797909737,
0.0612004511,
0.2433236837,
-0.3596069217,
0.3983304501,
0.0785015598,
-0.6866081357,
-0.4270498455,
-0.2803244293,
0.520743072,
0.6983890533,
-0.3856786191,
0.5487855673,
-0.1023621336,
0.0524570718,
-0.4290413558,
-0.4377361238,
0.1634978354,
-0.2206343412,
-0.8817044497,
0.4903241098,
-0.1504046768,
-0.561683476,
0.3864796758,
-0.0728078485,
0.0806910396,
0.2479807585,
-0.0523411557,
0.0967372209,
-0.6623063684,
-0.0187808536,
-0.1185470521,
-0.3030529618,
-0.1536276489,
-0.6283447742,
0.7766973376,
-0.3465760946,
-0.0253314227,
-0.2645228207,
0.5362179875,
0.7856222987,
-0.192243889,
0.9325610995,
0.6358380914,
-0.4209594429,
-0.3075474203,
-0.421490252,
-0.3538897634,
-0.3927249014,
0.613630712,
-0.6817284822,
-1.0186041594,
0.6686196327,
-0.0282686539,
-0.1795246303,
0.1782435179,
0.9340234995,
-0.210169211,
0.5065360665,
0.6519255042,
-0.2167612761,
0.5367161632,
-0.3837655485,
0.3670203686,
-0.838747561,
0.0305656735,
-0.5831013918,
-0.1091258824,
-0.6364580989,
-0.6543843746,
-0.017150661,
0.4512208402,
-0.055192709,
0.7710691094,
-0.1184302792,
0.2290133536,
0.5543778539,
-0.067566216,
0.1722274423,
0.0806371644,
-0.2059879899,
0.3861741126,
-0.6692045927,
-0.8984558582,
1.0780639648,
0.3670558333,
1.0065538883,
0.3942372799,
0.1821373552,
0.1856785715,
-0.0522207431,
-0.6517820954,
0.4976833761,
-0.324036479,
-0.8210636377,
-0.127263844,
-0.2812149227,
-0.8977905512,
0.1664374918,
-0.2091210037,
-1.017280221,
0.0680264831,
0.017295057,
-0.4251229763,
0.2003960311,
-0.6806076765,
0.9839639664,
-0.3072948158,
-0.9130700827,
-0.7115551829,
-0.2310691476,
0.3877141178,
0.1875182241,
-0.1968696415,
-0.2076363564,
0.131988883,
0.5245457292,
-0.4914683998,
0.4354226887,
0.3841953278,
-0.0645896494,
0.3284963369,
0.3811207116,
0.2965781391,
0.017074259,
-0.1275453418,
-0.1327288002,
-0.0154592581,
-0.710577786,
-0.9533268213,
0.5726186633,
-0.5586303473,
-0.4858669937,
-0.1565875858,
-0.4302437305,
-0.0877749845,
-0.1174425036,
0.1027308926,
0.6911123991,
-0.3039375246,
0.1938093901,
0.7549023628,
-0.4808424115,
0.5261478424,
0.5693783164,
-0.2004123926,
-0.2612240911,
0.9607539177,
-0.2329108715,
0.4651604891,
0.7983270288,
0.1427918226,
-0.330921948,
-0.4423030913,
-0.6036515236,
0.3865299821,
-0.2993284762,
0.3009448349,
-0.6537522078,
-0.3338243961,
-0.3275778592,
-0.1782194972,
-0.5540010929,
-0.7076985836,
0.1402207017,
-0.1971977651,
0.1954146326,
0.7939731479,
0.0573396571,
0.410553664,
-0.5357035398,
0.250110954,
0.570039928,
0.2900404632,
0.0282584783,
-0.3176103532,
-0.281037569,
-0.3261213899,
-0.3074413538,
-0.9269115925,
0.1386193931,
-0.0892577842,
0.6774510145,
0.5656220913,
-0.6104770303,
0.1086864248,
-0.5070784688,
0.2302515209,
0.0634272695,
-0.6158517003,
0.5436996818,
-0.4271549284,
-0.1001111344,
0.0809172243,
0.0707798004,
-0.2892044187,
-0.2267817706,
-0.7849119306,
-0.4805744588,
0.5569312572,
0.4906601012,
-0.0042090258,
0.3158350885,
0.5179787278,
0.2346735597,
0.4802239835,
-0.5485184193,
-0.0341573544,
-0.1951164603,
-0.1923157871,
-0.2909364104,
-0.6220837831,
0.110680066,
-0.1249309257,
0.5369709134,
0.1462412626,
0.4289784431,
-0.3006620407,
-0.1879548579,
0.0688231066,
0.4723508358,
0.8271132112,
0.8773028851,
-0.5850811601,
0.1809454858,
-0.5351534486,
-0.2527271509,
0.4156597555,
-0.098495461,
-0.4166850746,
-0.1352685988,
0.4350746572,
0.9845568538,
0.1753422618,
-0.6989772916,
-0.0363692939,
0.1967710257,
-0.1822030991,
0.1302410215,
0.4448648095,
0.4472292066,
0.5288389325,
-0.0787282437,
-0.1125868708,
0.2694216371,
-1.1938923597,
0.1896882206,
0.5853592157,
0.1798980832,
-0.6459360123,
0.6717284322,
0.113192834,
-0.4061670601,
0.2840881646,
-0.5506877303,
-0.505179882,
0.6625225544,
0.7410396934,
1.0640214682,
-0.5261535048,
0.3543522358,
0.5812590122,
0.5777202845,
-0.1607647836,
0.1917108297,
-0.2145546526,
-0.889436841,
-0.3202270269,
-0.9891050458,
-0.3005976975,
0.5924520493,
-0.2611682415,
-0.0295101684,
-0.6889185905,
0.169362247,
0.0033658959,
0.0841227397,
-0.318315804,
0.1359689236,
-0.0228634141,
0.6968618631,
-0.894836247,
0.8276759982,
0.9617524743,
-0.4059590697,
-0.4224626422,
-0.2180926502,
-0.2417020798,
-0.5958970785,
0.4061879218,
0.1097442657,
-0.2378701121,
-0.2949457467,
-0.255528748,
-0.6492010951,
1.1685401201,
0.353312254,
-0.5116423965,
0.1206994057,
-0.0091067851,
0.4532463253,
-0.5207147002,
0.3436556756,
0.7767352462,
0.1900399178,
0.3914237618,
-0.9073345661,
-0.0407748148,
-0.3480139971,
0.2138260752,
0.0145954043,
-0.6861712933,
1.1045453548,
-0.0877843946,
-0.0884484574,
0.2400231063,
0.4670495689,
0.4526948035,
0.2771667838,
-0.0592006706,
0.76208359,
0.685942471,
0.0562032722,
0.8508320451,
-0.1538248956,
0.130351752,
1.0129497051,
-0.2467705756,
0.6985439658,
-0.0272338428,
-0.5703356266,
0.4699112773,
0.6834472418,
0.246123001,
0.5088278651,
0.1174550802,
-0.466585815,
-0.095381625,
0.407787472,
-0.3016830683,
0.3818920851,
0.7005057335,
-0.2636585236,
-0.3677280545,
-0.0959701315,
0.1394810379,
-0.0133658536,
-0.2827220261,
0.5052694082,
0.2524699569,
-0.5042350292,
0.6386826038,
0.4000480175,
0.6533991694,
-0.3490794897,
0.0802905858,
-0.2341905087,
0.4015985131,
-0.0519368984,
-0.3601531684,
0.5456678867,
-0.2999043763,
-0.6863061786,
0.0785523653,
0.6835442781,
-0.4003489017,
-0.6039223075,
0.792988658,
0.7066131234,
0.2163190842,
-0.1430636197,
-0.8491774797,
0.0246799849,
-0.379247725,
0.0350726023,
0.1740585268,
0.4802328348,
-0.2616599202,
0.6831557751,
0.3300681114,
-0.0094903,
0.4664090872,
0.1171632856,
0.5218002796,
-0.7447385192,
-0.4470153451,
-1.0131937265,
-0.0138546592,
0.1957289129,
0.2861195207,
0.5289403796,
0.6106675863,
0.5597772002,
-0.1736584604,
0.794629693,
-0.1977719516,
0.2997193635,
-0.7828177214,
0.4924177229,
-0.6245296001,
0.1381584406,
-0.3301182091,
-1.1151536703,
0.3017472327,
0.9399601221,
-0.2157653868,
0.1929919273,
0.9698775411,
1.1389770508,
-0.2503235936,
-0.1223313138,
0.6034368277,
0.4491874874,
0.2858051658,
0.981510222,
0.9894480109,
-0.528963685,
-0.0647377744,
-0.0156450868,
-0.5971211791,
-0.4177058041,
-0.7519539595,
-1.1244401932,
-0.5594791174,
-0.153898254,
-0.5856653452,
0.1139210463,
0.6592156887,
0.8659859896,
-0.9249024987,
-0.5795721412,
-0.2411642373,
0.1427805871,
-0.1608326435,
-0.2104794383,
0.3029628098,
-0.3517681956,
-0.69328475,
0.5159938931,
0.8492537737,
0.1405826956,
-0.4640130401,
-0.3386891782,
-0.0953775048,
0.1931871176,
0.9178116918,
0.3881535828,
-0.7011983395,
0.2963552773,
0.095417805,
-0.140050754,
-0.0502248667,
0.9319826961,
-0.7133370638,
0.2640268207,
0.5119382143,
0.6289548278,
0.4518358111,
-0.0775859207,
0.7030273676,
-0.1099185124,
0.5579684973,
0.041515518,
0.3806495368,
0.1728258431,
-0.1200149357,
0.4965868294,
0.4903539121,
-0.2143164575,
-0.3670946956,
0.2935326099,
-0.9101155996,
-0.5515438318,
1.1409395933,
0.2499303073,
-0.5343017578,
-0.2298115939,
0.0750816166,
-0.1571035534,
-0.1882511228,
0.7112191319,
0.8877158165,
-0.0360410661,
-0.3647298217,
-1.0457792282,
0.4474143386,
0.5046970844,
-0.6940179467,
-0.3485951424,
0.4167492688,
0.4484299719,
0.3672091663,
0.9669455886,
-0.1932947189,
0.5306870937,
0.1200438514,
0.0749313682,
0.1663703322,
-0.5975089669,
0.1500191689,
0.1321787536,
-0.1859318018,
-0.1933902949
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04368v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04368v1
|
SocialNLP Fake-EmoReact 2021 Challenge Overview: Predicting Fake Tweets from Their Replies and GIFs
| 2024-05-31T21:14:11 | 2024-05-31T21:14:11 |
Chien-Kun Huang, Yi-Ting Chang, Lun-Wei Ku, Cheng-Te Li, Hong-Han Shuai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
This paper provides an overview of the Fake-EmoReact 2021 Challenge, held at
the 9th SocialNLP Workshop, in conjunction with NAACL 2021. The challenge
requires predicting the authenticity of tweets using reply context and
augmented GIF categories from EmotionGIF dataset. We offer the Fake-EmoReact
dataset with more than 453k as the experimental materials, where every tweet is
labeled with authenticity. Twenty-four teams registered to participate in this
challenge, and 5 submitted their results successfully in the evaluation phase.
The best team achieves 93.9 on Fake-EmoReact 2021 dataset using F1 score. In
addition, we show the definition of share task, data collection, and the teams'
performance that joined this challenge and their approaches.
|
[
-0.2665577233,
-1.1057095528,
0.5379214883,
0.3851091266,
0.0619651973,
0.7848852277,
0.1798807234,
-0.8618655205,
0.8665379882,
0.2635850608,
-0.8557854295,
-0.2693277895,
-0.7341243625,
0.1199743673,
-0.6428745389,
0.8539447188,
-0.1424186379,
-0.3363420665,
-0.1076508984,
-0.3551234007,
-0.1916149855,
-0.2158138901,
-0.5848308802,
-0.041028548,
0.4384385943,
0.3195848167,
0.2986524701,
0.2501894534,
0.3397733569,
0.2433291674,
0.1203407198,
0.0879984498,
-0.5400947332,
0.0891375095,
-0.1555517614,
0.1331515908,
-0.638790071,
0.0656121373,
0.202647537,
0.2318060845,
-0.1728627831,
0.4604008794,
-0.1948910952,
0.6682348847,
-0.5393944979,
0.1859404892,
-0.7112944126,
0.1843731105,
0.0701353997,
-0.2926216424,
-0.269212693,
-0.6076773405,
0.1351482719,
-0.6112077236,
0.2559407651,
0.280638665,
1.0144706964,
-0.0535301119,
-0.1520392746,
-0.3143790662,
-0.4309624732,
0.3610732853,
-0.5417354703,
-0.1781964302,
0.378967613,
0.574582994,
0.1150038168,
-0.413925916,
-0.4984905124,
0.1562229246,
0.1843639016,
0.3180974424,
-0.1386957765,
-0.1375145614,
0.2397706062,
0.3122163117,
-0.9170580506,
-0.3313824534,
-0.2682390511,
-0.2539015114,
0.9975011945,
-0.0654148832,
0.5458942652,
0.0637223125,
-0.4100576043,
-0.0133968471,
-0.4614022374,
-0.4737475812,
0.2114507854,
-0.0347756371,
-0.3703342974,
0.7701566815,
-0.5505705476,
0.1133354828,
0.316740483,
0.371544838,
0.511048615,
-0.3285871148,
-0.4285989702,
0.0837445855,
0.5591016412,
0.3989110887,
0.4890184104,
-0.2142703682,
-0.3089614809,
0.0955646858,
-0.0506421216,
-0.5198708177,
0.0759928524,
0.4085617065,
-0.1415257901,
-0.5943245292,
0.1891902685,
-0.7841994166,
-0.3672146499,
-0.2418331057,
0.7231113315,
-0.3396092653,
-0.4566753507,
-0.210840106,
-0.2162985653,
0.2321720272,
0.8719736934,
-0.4206520915,
0.3663059771,
0.7130336165,
0.901563406,
0.1231769472,
-0.1794381738,
-0.4765008092,
0.1723320335,
-0.3058432639,
0.6851116419,
-0.3843812644,
0.0557015762,
0.3024692237,
0.1470475644,
-0.0840310454,
-0.1534610242,
0.3072412014,
-0.6115626097,
-0.098425813,
-0.5711573958,
-0.7328387499,
0.0537313931,
0.5474279523,
-0.7565930486,
0.7873647809,
0.1514156759,
-0.7979821563,
0.4925326407,
-0.9904013872,
-0.2637710869,
0.2998380959,
0.287040472,
0.0161378961,
0.1235846728,
0.1576560736,
0.5608717799,
0.2544617951,
0.2219480425,
-0.7165374756,
-0.2676618695,
0.1188810989,
-0.2963719666,
0.7649544477,
0.0823924765,
-0.3123226762,
0.0535323061,
-0.577600956,
-0.0443539917,
0.3683944345,
0.2510648072,
0.0100138215,
-0.4510391951,
0.1410387754,
0.3394969106,
0.1376481205,
-0.9203824401,
0.1642517,
-0.2666550875,
0.3026014268,
0.7576264739,
0.3094148934,
0.5307141542,
-0.4708926976,
0.5758981109,
-0.225666672,
0.552398324,
-0.0341971889,
-0.7889463902,
-0.4798007607,
0.3602046072,
0.2193179727,
0.5609315634,
-1.0252940655,
0.1178874522,
-0.3117976487,
-0.7017133236,
-0.4125964046,
-0.1720666736,
0.1743895859,
0.2081122547,
0.2638867497,
0.087281473,
-0.5450278521,
-0.6123885512,
-0.3535432518,
-0.1913964599,
0.127786845,
0.1255491525,
0.9321821332,
0.0766838714,
0.5816919804,
-0.1601224691,
-0.3319536746,
-0.0479791462,
0.4738685787,
-0.057348121,
0.4870504737,
0.6415370703,
-0.914390564,
-0.8259295821,
0.0018399694,
-0.7125127912,
-0.0024487013,
0.0635177568,
0.0750483647,
0.6747491956,
0.3976758122,
-0.3935900629,
0.863375783,
0.9265448451,
-0.3884854913,
0.4289004207,
0.1405497789,
0.5884028077,
-0.8105000854,
-0.0176802464,
0.1434450001,
-0.5194150209,
-0.4682045281,
0.0771595165,
0.0092168869,
-0.1358596385,
-0.654715538,
0.7754395604,
-0.5140245557,
-0.1024899036,
0.074064225,
-0.003798096,
-0.1977894455,
0.4026853442,
-0.191632688,
0.223562181,
0.3002586067,
0.0178195722,
0.4187328517,
-0.1107527912,
-0.2940825224,
0.4424070418,
-0.7559255362,
0.599824667,
-0.0024374847,
0.3252256513,
-1.1192164421,
-0.9721938372,
0.3947508335,
-1.0308307409,
0.2674545944,
-0.2787365615,
-0.9375398755,
-0.3456554711,
-0.3660803139,
0.2035797089,
0.5028957725,
-0.3686444759,
0.8297562003,
0.4350852072,
0.2959785163,
-0.3933192492,
-0.8219163418,
0.2458296716,
-0.1642597169,
-0.8636892438,
0.5105141401,
-0.1394615173,
-0.1238002777,
0.1389110982,
0.0976537615,
-0.1437006295,
0.0497892201,
0.5156194568,
-0.0806648433,
0.2192848027,
-0.2182939351,
-0.0975711644,
0.3709830046,
0.0719863027,
0.3587649465,
0.536673367,
-0.3291459978,
-0.4585363269,
-0.4595157802,
0.3075687587,
0.3045145869,
0.3359689116,
0.9923716187,
0.8557056785,
-0.8734474182,
-0.1577602327,
-0.6855759621,
-0.2377953082,
-0.507674396,
-0.114488475,
-0.1096461341,
-0.7976731062,
0.865567565,
0.2319898754,
0.1627243757,
0.4731611311,
0.3748989403,
-0.1273138225,
1.0088838339,
0.4971362352,
0.1515898257,
0.2651332021,
-0.1097340286,
-0.1095145717,
-0.2961942852,
-0.4950205386,
-0.1662553102,
-0.1667804718,
-0.5662124753,
-0.3225829005,
-0.0086512063,
-0.1610462517,
-0.1350230277,
0.4819582999,
-0.3148856461,
0.5676771998,
0.2901316583,
0.3379737139,
-0.0135557689,
0.0470591001,
0.2596189678,
-0.027529344,
-0.4429383576,
-0.369010061,
0.9315614104,
0.3548021019,
0.2701916099,
0.2288239449,
0.8100335598,
0.7912351489,
0.7922703028,
-0.5813071132,
0.7172039151,
0.3240966499,
-0.8246269822,
-0.2295081466,
-0.2358790636,
-0.4766099453,
-0.5961508155,
-0.1031401977,
-0.934635818,
-0.1556174606,
0.2485931367,
-0.0526742898,
0.2404904217,
-0.7501686811,
0.5460057259,
0.0354512557,
-0.4474586844,
-0.0814553425,
-0.7863532305,
0.4568013847,
-0.0736321062,
0.3985855281,
-0.377040118,
0.1801799834,
0.7326456308,
-0.3142449856,
0.8723222613,
-0.2977845669,
0.3016145825,
0.3203842044,
0.3702460229,
0.4188630581,
0.230340153,
-0.1784461737,
0.0530521646,
0.0747591183,
-0.6667658091,
-0.6068873405,
0.6906255484,
-0.4785758257,
-0.490552485,
-0.5997411609,
-0.0944942981,
-0.3523479402,
-0.0099506266,
0.3017690182,
0.3176914752,
-0.5930256844,
0.1754037589,
0.3165462613,
-0.0783217549,
0.7862315178,
0.0780349523,
-0.3345233798,
-0.6812084317,
0.7009102106,
0.3064559102,
0.5304039121,
0.3169891238,
0.0919584408,
-0.4723784029,
-0.1281187981,
-0.465826273,
0.0648331046,
-0.6830453277,
-0.2032209486,
-0.50817132,
-0.2948291898,
-0.7560828924,
-0.2675468922,
-0.5175272226,
-0.4828338623,
-0.2683933079,
-0.135338515,
0.4706852138,
1.0001121759,
-0.4176882505,
0.0167168919,
-0.5654456019,
0.0456165075,
0.0168951172,
0.1886266172,
0.0888116807,
-0.6336069703,
-0.1369098127,
0.4122175276,
-0.3327141702,
-1.0580546856,
0.6297356486,
0.2010339648,
0.4223608673,
0.6332986355,
0.3430087566,
0.6135211587,
-0.2863507569,
0.8184558153,
0.2246348709,
-1.0989980698,
0.835057795,
-0.8042635918,
-0.1733630449,
0.4157836735,
0.4692307413,
-0.3919575214,
-0.329454869,
-1.1463168859,
-0.6621439457,
0.2732844055,
0.6327232122,
0.1497131288,
0.0770057291,
0.3397717476,
-0.2526066899,
0.2348677218,
-0.7063651681,
-0.2242113352,
-0.2589321434,
-0.1963243037,
0.3247074485,
-0.2380115688,
-0.2509732842,
-0.2405421436,
0.3079890013,
-0.1281430572,
0.430586189,
0.3779165745,
-0.0969648436,
-0.2910158634,
-0.2392751873,
0.8433337212,
0.8058626056,
-0.642439425,
-0.1857101172,
0.2920279801,
-0.2457684278,
-0.0438144915,
-0.3179530799,
-0.0074362005,
0.1861497462,
0.4886244535,
0.4955579638,
0.0561111644,
-0.4051247537,
0.5897303224,
-0.0408834182,
-0.584471643,
-0.7978588343,
-0.0940759256,
0.150523141,
0.1137003973,
0.7462112308,
0.2535496056,
0.1236919761,
-0.7255423069,
0.2849089205,
0.0572416559,
-0.5872096419,
-0.9908865094,
0.6319223642,
0.0308696032,
-0.4467406869,
0.0920140743,
-0.4172299504,
-0.8372957706,
0.9690649509,
0.3042849302,
0.8955354095,
-0.2831517458,
0.6071942449,
0.5125726461,
0.4166644514,
-0.2653211653,
0.3344256878,
0.2458072305,
-0.8208950758,
-0.4025596082,
-0.3872468472,
-0.6922929287,
0.1732898355,
-0.7367759347,
0.3097317815,
-0.7831090689,
-0.0446852483,
0.1123932227,
0.0723925754,
-0.7859825492,
0.3881564736,
0.1372745633,
0.9030008912,
-1.1887516975,
0.6312301755,
0.6444246769,
-0.3608189523,
-0.6121845841,
-0.0563006699,
0.5072062016,
-0.8372597694,
0.568949461,
0.3065649867,
0.1940783262,
-0.1031448841,
-1.123126626,
-0.7437183261,
0.822986424,
0.2234059274,
-0.2528841197,
0.0203888454,
0.0444323868,
0.5517224073,
-0.4668695331,
0.334826231,
0.0855896845,
0.5445075631,
0.4794337153,
-0.8093191981,
0.1674574763,
-0.5270712972,
-0.3689893782,
-0.440630883,
-0.8120624423,
0.420982331,
-0.2383385599,
-0.4687671363,
0.0533624627,
0.6665263772,
0.5736817718,
0.8855952621,
0.5885851383,
0.4354991913,
0.2960658967,
-0.3512374163,
1.0443419218,
0.0779989064,
0.5949410796,
1.1051610708,
-0.3715293705,
0.9602100253,
0.5966948867,
0.0690894127,
0.1917747855,
0.9330757856,
-0.1305783987,
0.4315854907,
0.0950137302,
-0.1194625348,
-0.1633820385,
-0.3760665357,
-0.2633643746,
0.2970163822,
0.435395658,
0.0146460738,
-0.035537608,
-0.1073485017,
0.1076592356,
-0.1089703515,
-0.1394643635,
0.6478034258,
0.0145723987,
-0.4318288863,
0.0541106872,
-0.3613322377,
0.6412525177,
0.0078296186,
-0.2675972879,
-0.3229956329,
-0.0827967674,
-0.2606882751,
-0.9206783175,
0.742710948,
-0.2681511939,
0.0899144039,
-0.4422671795,
0.8196027279,
-0.2460529059,
-0.4186729789,
0.4337608814,
0.3580734432,
0.0390489548,
-0.3937788308,
-0.9650707841,
0.0426395573,
-0.1379223019,
-0.5821568966,
0.3029026985,
0.6438115835,
0.2646895349,
0.6949206591,
0.6329032183,
0.0081807207,
0.2094371617,
-0.0258814804,
0.6053149104,
-0.4364847839,
-0.2004799992,
-0.8510974646,
0.3974659443,
-0.5287951827,
-0.2379252762,
0.7508929968,
0.4338695705,
0.6760839224,
-0.2251484543,
0.650205791,
-0.2636298239,
0.7332542539,
-0.3838589191,
0.9505848885,
-0.974412322,
-0.0535168499,
-0.7335933447,
-0.578420341,
-0.1915212274,
0.2080408633,
-0.0022851452,
0.1191707402,
0.4553676248,
0.7504281402,
-0.0080128051,
0.2492614985,
0.3674568832,
0.0117747886,
0.2544833124,
0.5621444583,
1.011343956,
-0.7878519893,
0.3022800088,
-0.6158619523,
0.0347745121,
-0.534335494,
-1.0587866306,
-0.8963493705,
-0.6956715584,
-0.6551658511,
-0.8321287632,
0.0633504465,
0.8715237975,
0.6250798702,
-0.9838533998,
0.216241613,
-0.3025690615,
0.0757240281,
0.0378052704,
-0.3603664339,
0.3714125156,
0.2220489234,
-0.7665330768,
0.1160034686,
0.2751751542,
0.4144277871,
0.1393240541,
0.0370446965,
-0.4442824125,
0.2311013043,
0.5939899087,
0.4277302325,
-0.5928636789,
-0.7122849822,
0.3661424518,
0.1318355799,
-0.2467039526,
0.3153323531,
-0.311445713,
0.0957444236,
0.6457305551,
0.395938009,
0.6055291891,
0.2220396399,
0.6069393754,
-0.7877409458,
-0.0059415265,
0.2398803383,
0.359531492,
0.3085880578,
-0.313782692,
0.8745577335,
0.5665798783,
-0.4318701625,
-1.1187516451,
-0.2749206424,
-1.2630623579,
-0.0345619917,
1.2804985046,
-0.2516520917,
-0.4489270151,
-0.2715584636,
0.2747943699,
0.3021923602,
-0.6223663092,
0.7053748369,
0.7667431831,
0.1534516364,
-0.3474639058,
-0.7899543047,
0.5847937465,
0.1772390455,
-0.9375279546,
-0.4081650674,
0.1516460925,
0.4316669106,
0.1998895556,
0.6460027099,
-0.016885709,
0.3039685786,
-0.0473583564,
-0.0946123078,
-0.004423718,
-0.3226518333,
0.1702740341,
0.3859508038,
-0.5994828343,
-0.0473606847
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00179v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00179v1
|
Long-Span Question-Answering: Automatic Question Generation and QA-System Ranking via Side-by-Side Evaluation
| 2024-05-31T20:15:10 | 2024-05-31T20:15:10 |
Bernd Bohnet, Kevin Swersky, Rosanne Liu, Pranjal Awasthi, Azade Nova, Javier Snaider, Hanie Sedghi, Aaron T Parisi, Michael Collins, Angeliki Lazaridou, Orhan Firat, Noah Fiedel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We explore the use of long-context capabilities in large language models to
create synthetic reading comprehension data from entire books. Previous efforts
to construct such datasets relied on crowd-sourcing, but the emergence of
transformers with a context size of 1 million or more tokens now enables
entirely automatic approaches. Our objective is to test the capabilities of
LLMs to analyze, understand, and reason over problems that require a detailed
comprehension of long spans of text, such as questions involving character
arcs, broader themes, or the consequences of early actions later in the story.
We propose a holistic pipeline for automatic data generation including question
generation, answering, and model scoring using an ``Evaluator''. We find that a
relative approach, comparing answers between models in a pairwise fashion and
ranking with a Bradley-Terry model, provides a more consistent and
differentiating scoring mechanism than an absolute scorer that rates answers
individually. We also show that LLMs from different model families produce
moderate agreement in their ratings. We ground our approach using the manually
curated NarrativeQA dataset, where our evaluator shows excellent agreement with
human judgement and even finds errors in the dataset. Using our automatic
evaluation approach, we show that using an entire book as context produces
superior reading comprehension performance compared to baseline no-context
(parametric knowledge only) and retrieval-based approaches.
|
[
-0.5719023943,
-0.7875856161,
0.7638509274,
0.1406452507,
-0.1932712793,
0.05651097,
0.0377712958,
-0.5272819996,
-0.0207217894,
0.7586001158,
-0.486300379,
-0.2944819927,
-0.2336075902,
0.4532143474,
-0.6784436703,
0.9191049933,
-0.1633464992,
-0.1381743997,
-0.72894907,
-0.1701806337,
-0.2731224597,
-0.4513744116,
-0.5696210861,
-0.3245476484,
0.6281431913,
0.221863538,
0.8124389648,
0.6985679269,
0.2773364782,
0.2529682219,
0.0952893421,
0.1440176666,
-0.3256855607,
0.3836114407,
-0.1493867487,
-0.3611041605,
-0.3789836764,
-0.1763528883,
0.6945712566,
0.5363067985,
0.1954742819,
0.378384918,
0.0320516974,
0.9205256701,
-0.3744250536,
-0.1203573942,
-0.2659170628,
0.0169538353,
0.0458247066,
-0.3022340834,
-0.4894577563,
-0.5383597612,
0.3600883484,
-0.5192500353,
0.0902891681,
0.3858145475,
0.5777807832,
0.3941515386,
-0.8793998957,
-0.6315465569,
-0.6011254787,
0.7951649427,
-0.4285002053,
0.189486295,
0.4619905055,
0.4393037856,
0.1253313273,
-0.672408998,
-0.6742933393,
-0.3774440587,
-0.1187014729,
0.3271498382,
-0.157991007,
-0.1020429581,
0.2033786029,
0.392031312,
-0.6910241246,
0.060086377,
-0.3799538016,
0.1014866158,
0.9514526129,
0.373405695,
0.3328309655,
-0.5274030566,
-0.3651140034,
-0.1437346637,
-0.5942933559,
0.2549104393,
0.4751954377,
-0.1241737232,
0.3257477582,
0.842333138,
-0.2877331972,
0.6569509506,
-0.0029467531,
0.2105807662,
-0.1088934466,
-0.4973858595,
-0.2352956086,
-0.1559588015,
0.6226791739,
0.5005863309,
0.3768862188,
-0.1331698745,
-0.304174006,
-0.2514795959,
0.2615920007,
-0.6036038399,
0.0311572682,
0.4355406165,
-0.2984277606,
-0.2069235891,
-0.1310851127,
-0.8631719947,
-0.4582327306,
-0.5975682139,
0.7232854962,
-0.2364604771,
0.0954640582,
0.1500161439,
-0.1964697242,
0.5585813522,
0.0833456144,
-0.6738340855,
0.2743356526,
0.3308163583,
0.5343247652,
-0.4309380651,
-0.3839969933,
-0.4078525007,
0.2064255327,
-0.4071543217,
1.0123734474,
-0.2118895501,
-0.2795098722,
0.0669933483,
-0.1053637266,
-0.0347243659,
-0.3824889958,
0.2656057179,
-0.8563250899,
0.4809051454,
-0.2196553499,
-0.720518887,
-0.0673170239,
0.3217441142,
-0.7311505079,
1.3069924116,
0.2479722202,
-0.5825323462,
0.1111363918,
-0.7086781859,
-0.4758128226,
-0.0926883295,
0.1980023533,
-0.1023180783,
-0.176468581,
0.6260918975,
0.3341139555,
-0.4964564145,
0.2203584462,
0.0511103943,
-0.3358124495,
0.1803846806,
-0.5577446818,
0.6810068488,
0.0254822001,
-0.2482890934,
0.1370022893,
-0.5624914765,
0.2783142924,
0.1573154181,
-0.218732357,
-0.3346092701,
0.0016794992,
-0.1705879122,
-0.0666622743,
0.266361624,
-0.3838978708,
0.3587126732,
-0.4224793315,
0.3153155148,
0.558445096,
0.1549232602,
0.5216831565,
-0.6482594013,
0.847717464,
-0.2642625272,
0.1678997427,
-0.3915437162,
-0.2374148071,
-1.0326342583,
0.0507797487,
0.3269007504,
0.6542252302,
-0.8932898045,
0.6617627144,
-0.2123250663,
-0.5581199527,
-0.320502758,
0.2200065702,
0.281814605,
0.4637289941,
0.5717129707,
-0.1208617613,
-0.1326586604,
-0.714317739,
-0.146069929,
-0.3794361353,
-0.2769466043,
0.2688379586,
0.4872153997,
-0.1945082843,
1.1837410927,
-0.6179464459,
0.1206497028,
-0.3984200954,
-0.0305409413,
0.0378269032,
0.1975411624,
0.2706480622,
-0.6867055297,
-0.3704508841,
-0.36741063,
-0.7821997404,
-0.3197394609,
-0.0392669961,
-0.4980247915,
0.2247537971,
0.7299838662,
-0.4575562775,
0.2321619689,
0.3905831575,
-0.4673211277,
0.7682775855,
-0.0509193242,
0.1933040172,
-1.2340079546,
0.0095829451,
-0.1387284398,
-0.2247219384,
-0.4112229347,
0.2345230728,
0.0775310397,
-0.0078340899,
-0.2668269873,
0.9333425164,
-0.4139289558,
-0.2040290684,
-0.0704230368,
0.4067154825,
0.4209929705,
0.3037832677,
-0.1592269242,
0.6971955299,
0.0496964939,
-0.5671243668,
0.7843715549,
0.2725471556,
-0.452251792,
0.4162081778,
-0.7282857299,
0.2338442355,
-0.2029358596,
0.5980937481,
-1.1168529987,
-0.2877822518,
-0.0242347978,
-0.1939301491,
0.0537307784,
0.1660389304,
-0.5994265676,
-0.6116899252,
-0.2099742442,
0.607011497,
0.5323104262,
-0.6405367255,
0.5465974808,
0.1465962231,
-0.4219871759,
-0.5500352383,
-0.6566411853,
0.006659497,
-0.2728070617,
-0.787468493,
0.1138040796,
-0.4289316535,
-0.3591840863,
-0.166481033,
-0.1129101589,
-0.0826224089,
-0.0979161859,
0.0185600631,
0.2810998559,
-0.2731391191,
0.6033967733,
0.3621332943,
-0.0934915543,
0.1375446469,
-0.0447373167,
0.3606497049,
-0.0516911186,
-0.4037962258,
-0.0892159194,
0.4986165464,
0.6080679893,
-0.3240453899,
0.3509762883,
0.1712961197,
-0.0901415795,
-0.4367990196,
-0.5992923975,
-0.0428089164,
-0.4608289003,
0.2651260793,
-0.3671455383,
-0.7659721971,
0.4323110878,
0.3295296133,
0.2413690984,
0.6140880585,
0.6316499114,
-0.2129036784,
0.9752949476,
0.4306913316,
-0.1426431686,
0.1668949574,
-0.0369251296,
0.1049978137,
-0.4863975942,
-0.044690866,
-0.3628897667,
-0.1951701641,
-0.2637791336,
-0.4140444994,
0.5913182497,
0.2525371313,
-0.2559569776,
0.1129894331,
-0.4978527725,
0.8843573928,
0.5286176801,
-0.0528906696,
0.7229703665,
-0.2244231552,
-0.1648469865,
0.433257997,
-0.3764999211,
-0.7373076677,
1.1935286522,
0.3944402039,
0.4516908228,
0.0477906689,
0.6839527488,
0.4233098626,
0.4835868776,
-1.0476667881,
0.4617887139,
0.2187033296,
-0.7529988289,
-0.7877211571,
-0.2242825478,
-0.8830461502,
0.2048113346,
0.1625948846,
-0.3240731359,
-0.229816094,
-0.2041717023,
-0.67439574,
-0.1185308769,
-0.7922280431,
0.7631668448,
-0.3492544293,
-0.1256057322,
0.0286704618,
-0.7324192524,
0.4014292359,
-0.3067842424,
-0.0885804072,
0.0458962619,
-0.1059607044,
0.790271759,
-0.1920608133,
0.4131065905,
0.0598136894,
-0.2538138628,
0.675791204,
0.1913134307,
0.1869361252,
0.2239319235,
-0.4318563938,
-0.2330571711,
0.6270719767,
-0.5475113392,
-0.797757566,
0.2442719191,
-0.7076920271,
-0.7874087691,
-0.4785810411,
-0.8266294599,
-0.582300365,
0.1181262508,
-0.0094091035,
0.4297339916,
-0.1202051044,
0.2735100687,
0.3869217932,
-0.3536193073,
0.434127748,
0.6229596138,
-0.4643690884,
-0.2767004669,
0.433776021,
-0.0336975157,
0.4266477227,
0.350812763,
0.1433837563,
-0.6270469427,
-0.3758802414,
-0.73412323,
0.1477661878,
-0.765404284,
-0.2196109146,
-0.4712650776,
-0.4794716239,
-0.219718039,
-0.1676268578,
0.0919696763,
-0.2930317819,
-0.1798333377,
-0.2620700896,
0.2790522277,
0.961066246,
0.371617943,
0.1716969311,
-0.8846338987,
0.3269598484,
0.5498811603,
-0.0353916399,
0.0768058598,
-0.4875766635,
-0.2139167339,
-0.1552421749,
-0.5040760636,
-0.8298490644,
0.4116987288,
-0.0959543362,
0.1492948234,
0.1079688519,
0.369821161,
0.6364999413,
-0.4695035815,
0.9399356246,
-0.2063678801,
-0.9898276925,
0.2875695825,
-0.4814567566,
0.5057755113,
0.6670655608,
0.5433799624,
-0.5343758464,
-0.4732072651,
-0.2254818529,
-0.7452533841,
0.4407761097,
-0.0031298348,
0.2653357983,
0.0765927806,
0.3871096373,
0.3563474417,
0.1027401015,
-0.7840834856,
0.1045146957,
0.0049775476,
-0.4982948303,
-0.2961538434,
-0.1874026209,
-0.1029219478,
-0.4123283625,
0.5621211529,
-0.367752105,
0.03306555,
0.4791004956,
-0.3167081773,
-0.2070328444,
0.3033663929,
0.2462888211,
1.1013814211,
-0.0612725019,
-0.0209327228,
0.2066148967,
-0.1088157445,
0.1610129327,
0.2199952304,
-0.0368973725,
-0.2790960073,
0.4736914337,
0.3288446367,
-0.1006201133,
-0.8949558139,
0.4837061763,
0.0174426679,
-0.1588411331,
-0.4492021501,
-0.0938818604,
0.3492948413,
0.498411119,
0.6899687648,
-0.6076478958,
-0.0116864499,
-0.4692523181,
0.4544658065,
0.1482622772,
-0.0901928023,
0.0569326617,
0.2327136993,
0.2570874393,
-0.055306606,
0.6457685828,
-0.1861546487,
-0.4777701497,
0.9734016061,
0.4171433151,
0.612126112,
-0.0177068561,
0.3264400959,
0.099615939,
0.1939991713,
-0.049013976,
0.0467872657,
-0.2871163189,
-0.6095363498,
-0.3509727716,
-1.0166730881,
-0.5277210474,
0.1488284469,
-0.6719271541,
0.1689633727,
-0.0839970484,
0.176055491,
-0.0722312927,
0.2201377302,
-0.4682919383,
0.300989747,
0.0038879898,
0.9594550729,
-0.7180731297,
0.6627828479,
0.3908399045,
-0.5417195559,
-0.6796335578,
0.4131185114,
-0.4219583869,
-0.7188253403,
0.4533429444,
0.2930022478,
0.1433545649,
0.3459840119,
-0.323081851,
-0.8934093714,
1.2774190903,
0.0854665413,
-0.5123669505,
-0.5364499092,
0.1973196417,
0.790964663,
-0.204027012,
0.5713082552,
0.7430439591,
0.4630370438,
-0.006970033,
-0.8086188436,
0.0043331101,
-0.0274860375,
-0.3038412035,
0.2083467692,
-0.6242921948,
0.4656724036,
0.0297963917,
-0.0296409689,
0.600718379,
0.619620502,
0.298936516,
0.671969831,
0.6315797567,
0.4292615652,
0.6119741201,
0.1172510237,
1.2094992399,
-0.3201999962,
0.2629792392,
0.7758066058,
-0.2319675535,
0.8879982233,
0.3671344519,
-0.2273221463,
0.5311965346,
0.8210315704,
-0.0520218424,
0.1073699445,
0.5209375024,
-0.2069954574,
-0.2922801077,
0.0990489125,
-0.1811598241,
0.357531935,
-0.0841016471,
-0.458706677,
-0.2445517629,
0.0581018589,
-0.3323267698,
0.1543779522,
-0.2894108891,
0.6442090273,
0.258854419,
-1.0938345194,
0.5400716066,
-0.0388288833,
0.3978334069,
-0.55636549,
0.3103099167,
-0.303378284,
-0.1372989267,
-0.0262116008,
-1.006234169,
0.2223176509,
0.2258948684,
-0.3648569882,
-0.3539063036,
0.4345196486,
-0.3905162811,
-0.6915406585,
0.2852449715,
0.9327727556,
0.1918577403,
-0.0076354747,
-0.5627859235,
-0.3482910693,
-0.1942968369,
-0.7026540637,
0.1958065182,
0.3119659126,
-0.1166564226,
0.6212896109,
0.5431225896,
-0.2535217106,
0.0993035287,
0.0617789701,
0.6015638113,
-0.7743325233,
-0.5411379933,
-0.7368001938,
0.4252679944,
0.0637966916,
-0.3293309212,
0.7565302253,
0.4618453085,
0.5976762772,
0.1608124822,
0.7209324837,
0.2446807921,
0.5246109366,
-0.541200161,
0.8289304376,
-0.7667627931,
0.0670402423,
-0.0510218665,
-1.1360849142,
-0.1697622687,
0.0348927304,
-0.5289191008,
0.0583509654,
0.9831493497,
0.6634802222,
0.1489792168,
0.2144768387,
0.2714997828,
0.00076229,
0.2100060731,
0.6902020574,
1.09595716,
-0.4602582455,
0.7110486627,
0.2141002715,
-0.1427478641,
0.0444548354,
-0.6873336434,
-1.0313987732,
-0.6715205312,
0.0682693198,
-0.3514322937,
0.0516753085,
0.6928771734,
0.3078773916,
-0.5649536252,
-0.2720224261,
-0.0083164815,
0.1698230952,
0.1278838366,
-0.314951539,
0.5323811173,
-0.4015649855,
-0.9387079477,
0.4829511046,
0.0805824101,
-0.2072339356,
-0.5128228664,
-0.0374740586,
0.050278306,
0.4741267562,
0.6783955693,
0.202259168,
-0.6048945785,
-0.2796392143,
0.106606096,
-0.2053838372,
-0.0886016563,
0.6931431293,
-0.8781765103,
0.4687715173,
0.6361928582,
0.9494943619,
0.4853243232,
0.4754994214,
0.6019778252,
-0.3982578516,
-0.4006648064,
0.5646426678,
-0.0298707206,
0.1924521178,
-0.2643409967,
0.4162748754,
-0.0275670066,
-0.8882772923,
-0.8531477451,
0.2517174482,
-0.851477325,
-0.3088774383,
1.4504312277,
0.1140510961,
-0.33290115,
-0.1293910593,
-0.2227899879,
0.2748769522,
-0.1860567778,
0.8194466829,
0.9510820508,
-0.2799268365,
0.0725832209,
-0.6203102469,
0.3811159432,
0.7230410576,
-1.1102409363,
0.0441797562,
0.6367956996,
0.263261646,
0.0384129882,
0.4445755184,
-0.0791029111,
0.1079635993,
-0.356490612,
-0.1628439277,
-0.0798578113,
-0.3041305244,
-0.3611285985,
0.318972975,
-0.182819277,
0.263496995
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00159v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00159v1
|
On the referential capacity of language models: An internalist rejoinder to Mandelkern & Linzen
| 2024-05-31T19:43:20 | 2024-05-31T19:43:20 |
Giosue Baggio, Elliot Murphy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In a recent paper, Mandelkern & Linzen (2024) - henceforth M&L - address the
question of whether language models' (LMs) words refer. Their argument draws
from the externalist tradition in philosophical semantics, which views
reference as the capacity of words to "achieve 'word-to-world' connections". In
the externalist framework, causally uninterrupted chains of usage, tracing
every occurrence of a name back to its bearer, guarantee that, for example,
'Peano' refers to the individual Peano (Kripke 1980). This account is
externalist both because words pick out referents 'out there' in the world, and
because what determines reference are coordinated linguistic actions by members
of a community, and not individual mental states. The "central question to
ask", for M&L, is whether LMs too belong to human linguistic communities, such
that words by LMs may also trace back causally to their bearers. Their answer
is a cautious "yes": inputs to LMs are linguistic "forms with particular
histories of referential use"; "those histories ground the referents of those
forms"; any occurrence of 'Peano' in LM outputs is as causally connected to the
individual Peano as any other occurrence of the same proper name in human
speech or text; therefore, occurrences of 'Peano' in LM outputs refer to Peano.
In this commentary, we first qualify M&L's claim as applying to a narrow class
of natural language expressions. Thus qualified, their claim is valid, and we
emphasise an additional motivation for that in Section 2. Next, we discuss the
actual scope of their claim, and we suggest that the way they formulate it may
lead to unwarranted generalisations about reference in LMs. Our critique is
likewise applicable to other externalist accounts of LMs (e.g., Lederman &
Mahowald 2024; Mollo & Milliere 2023). Lastly, we conclude with a comment on
the status of LMs as members of human linguistic communities.
|
[
-0.1396716386,
-0.1448508501,
0.8676540852,
-0.1621505916,
-0.0666170418,
-0.5297912359,
-0.4138490856,
-0.7476941347,
0.079799369,
0.4231833518,
-0.365650177,
0.5876591206,
-0.5313038826,
0.4805928767,
-0.4823597074,
0.5903696418,
0.0070088888,
0.1349543035,
-0.3623057902,
-0.3923382759,
-0.282700479,
-0.852047801,
-0.5675481558,
-0.4299646914,
0.8782425523,
0.0127645358,
0.7950657606,
0.3753293753,
0.351455152,
0.4146662652,
-0.1497302651,
-0.0910994634,
-0.3165914416,
0.1325446218,
-0.5055475235,
-0.6335216761,
-0.0114918565,
0.1178444773,
0.7544981241,
0.9916102886,
0.0949277505,
0.2782668769,
0.1579027325,
0.725235641,
-0.4485659599,
-0.3052176535,
-0.8656428456,
-0.2570117414,
-0.1069668978,
-0.0432368442,
-0.5463714004,
-0.2911310494,
0.1667193025,
-0.3642297685,
0.4490825832,
0.1514527947,
0.8798676729,
-0.0167127475,
-0.3749219477,
-0.1779061407,
-0.6721950173,
0.7681474686,
-0.7306909561,
0.2996022701,
0.3332999647,
0.3831821382,
-0.0318590291,
-0.5877198577,
-0.6737949848,
-0.5274856091,
-0.2257221639,
-0.009088601,
0.0537873879,
-0.1029246449,
0.4968781769,
0.5319793224,
-0.130971238,
-0.235970661,
-0.8098335862,
-0.2714661956,
0.3658826053,
0.0731219798,
0.0442962199,
-0.0659939125,
-0.3087604046,
0.3701862097,
-0.8670418859,
0.0253671054,
0.2719631791,
0.6196219325,
0.09042757,
0.6305503249,
0.2170205414,
0.5559406877,
0.0464466587,
0.0176676475,
-0.0267512705,
-0.5102115273,
-0.1737592965,
0.0281219352,
0.6972017288,
0.1190143526,
0.716804862,
-0.3148318231,
0.1422741562,
0.0012239267,
0.4718703628,
-0.5417064428,
-0.1493186802,
-0.0633442104,
-0.3408664465,
0.0129947131,
0.429800123,
-0.3337770998,
-0.3598102629,
-0.2720302641,
0.0914566591,
0.0427310094,
-0.5502700806,
-0.3821029365,
-0.23304829,
-0.132296741,
0.0850809813,
-0.7747856975,
0.4391203523,
0.5006417632,
0.7609225512,
0.0551167391,
-0.2934417427,
-0.1211397722,
0.4444513917,
-0.5954856873,
0.7564341426,
-0.6957353354,
-0.6240524054,
0.4831005633,
0.4162184894,
-0.0796745494,
-0.7903819084,
0.5377408266,
-0.3389762938,
0.3006729484,
-0.8333160877,
-0.6695464849,
-0.1083949134,
-0.1381509006,
-0.4949304163,
0.7165997624,
0.1297741532,
-0.5602947474,
0.2325645536,
-0.3297464848,
-0.1821336895,
-0.138592422,
-0.3526439369,
0.1646135747,
0.4968662858,
-0.5967758894,
0.2133837193,
-0.5851941705,
0.4165398479,
-0.6458272338,
0.083885178,
0.8941021562,
-0.4203713834,
0.6003030539,
0.0581708588,
-0.1188057363,
-0.0156928021,
-0.6828787923,
0.0340830386,
-0.0164242405,
-0.4178797305,
-0.4764151573,
0.1737631708,
-0.1910110861,
0.5386013985,
-0.0357559249,
-0.6216826439,
0.0417933203,
-0.4353381693,
0.4555481076,
1.1767596006,
-0.3355306089,
0.5742152929,
-0.4896371663,
0.310631454,
-0.1280187964,
-0.1961800605,
-0.2285683304,
-0.5881722569,
-1.0057730675,
0.1488024145,
0.1495836973,
0.1402884126,
-0.3961086869,
0.2981212735,
-0.3224883974,
-0.0949788243,
-0.2483675331,
0.0302741602,
0.2987782061,
0.6157935858,
0.0744918287,
-0.1025316194,
-0.7091476917,
-1.2870019674,
-0.2609960139,
-0.4258721769,
-0.0852777809,
0.6987057328,
0.4443750083,
0.0816974565,
0.8831094503,
-0.1111345291,
-0.1322580576,
-0.0774511397,
-0.4294130504,
0.5395485163,
0.082922712,
0.6476007104,
-0.5253953338,
-0.4650548398,
-0.030385593,
-0.7670006156,
-0.3110084832,
0.0257766824,
-0.0636489913,
0.0525015034,
0.3165903389,
-0.5928573012,
-0.0491824895,
0.5999271274,
-0.5823589563,
0.6261885166,
-0.211443007,
-0.3164866865,
-1.2509663105,
0.2698021531,
-0.2171291411,
-0.1754033566,
-0.6367565393,
0.0512298383,
-0.0465199836,
-0.0110830832,
-0.3954756856,
0.8665614128,
-0.4596609771,
-0.0058806874,
-0.461149931,
0.2020135224,
-0.2787101269,
0.1470592171,
-0.0986275077,
0.7894182801,
0.4223110974,
-1.0690230131,
0.2898138762,
-0.1716159731,
0.0421022624,
0.7790907025,
-0.5341030955,
0.07399939,
-0.007387775,
0.3198233545,
-0.9564151764,
-0.0541145802,
0.374699086,
-0.2783489823,
-0.0494538583,
0.1874658614,
-0.4155532718,
-0.4221490026,
-0.1316002905,
0.3799156547,
0.3252952099,
-0.313773334,
0.3286679983,
0.4141191542,
0.0833607018,
-0.2454703599,
-0.7551912665,
0.0557917506,
-0.1368215084,
-0.6025387049,
0.0199022684,
-0.2017475218,
-0.8169033527,
0.1984271705,
-0.159213528,
-0.1513404697,
-0.2024821639,
0.3156369627,
0.1893355548,
-0.4403425753,
0.4924167395,
-0.4282250404,
-0.1885530204,
0.2513605356,
-0.1917690188,
0.2118161172,
0.0523110069,
-0.071684517,
-0.2282776982,
0.5680027604,
0.1844415218,
0.3830271959,
0.7709412575,
0.1894935519,
-0.3980567753,
0.1716582477,
-0.554227829,
-0.3623524308,
-0.4342545569,
0.0533020496,
-0.5464340448,
-0.8508912325,
0.4745725989,
0.222661674,
-0.1068321541,
0.9631510973,
0.5094676018,
-0.1605335027,
0.2408251613,
0.7527836561,
-0.1278705746,
0.2003016472,
-0.0193079542,
0.2357934117,
-1.2393296957,
0.2527536154,
-0.8317247629,
-0.2226278335,
-0.4933139384,
-0.40771842,
-0.2153374106,
-0.1036119759,
-0.3322448134,
0.3727690279,
-0.1598814577,
0.306637764,
0.1750104576,
-0.2065068036,
0.357109189,
-0.259573549,
-0.158758387,
-0.2085243165,
-0.944496572,
-0.6389765739,
1.0996735096,
0.3968100846,
0.6186538339,
0.4099135101,
0.2497506738,
0.1278951168,
0.8708420396,
-0.65419662,
0.689659059,
0.0401126295,
-1.0821797848,
-0.0790635794,
-0.1977079362,
-0.9815189838,
0.6491015553,
0.0724978819,
-0.9515894055,
0.5583678484,
0.1180458143,
-0.2042545974,
0.5386332273,
-0.3292684555,
0.5155075192,
-0.0175073352,
-0.4887545109,
-0.4710699916,
-0.4234046638,
0.5380915999,
0.1004898772,
0.4557494223,
-0.2938466668,
-0.4718504846,
0.8684397936,
-0.7131663561,
1.0122084618,
0.1020050868,
-0.5644671917,
0.4660563469,
0.0502975658,
0.3157351613,
-0.1747911274,
-0.020588059,
0.1348085999,
0.0582503304,
-0.0723067969,
-0.2974852622,
0.8651043773,
-0.4798431098,
-0.6843714118,
-0.7886753678,
-0.2832520604,
-0.2133228779,
0.1538822651,
0.1320219636,
0.6098735332,
-0.16142793,
0.4217642248,
0.454185605,
0.1269194633,
0.5901481509,
0.6826180816,
-0.2345715016,
-0.3788104057,
0.6353549957,
0.1981566846,
0.5971844196,
0.3287226558,
0.3906168938,
-0.2387838662,
0.0718730837,
-0.2928331196,
0.752761662,
-0.8177847862,
0.0634338334,
-0.4168315828,
-0.0764264241,
-0.1198937893,
0.0256849546,
-0.2901907563,
-0.2493110895,
-0.1851808876,
0.2354161888,
-0.0189589001,
0.6593865752,
0.0843402073,
0.128016755,
-0.7578844428,
0.2684890032,
0.4182064533,
0.2726800144,
0.0509154722,
-0.8916362524,
-0.1053069755,
-0.0832567886,
-0.0860148743,
-1.0396260023,
-0.2696552873,
0.3866218328,
0.8523145914,
0.5912100077,
-0.0987248197,
0.6091825962,
-0.786311686,
0.8384405971,
0.2432310879,
-0.6217243075,
0.1975231916,
-0.3673429489,
0.2083884776,
0.4786215425,
0.4804157615,
-0.8989620805,
-0.554281652,
-0.9877013564,
-0.6530647278,
0.6053606272,
-0.0758363158,
0.5924121737,
-0.207256183,
0.3879051805,
0.125501588,
0.3668561578,
-0.9654657841,
-0.2517957389,
0.3367548287,
0.1572143734,
-0.2617029846,
-0.8047381639,
-0.2798100114,
-0.1217220649,
0.7269195914,
-0.153343007,
0.3857836723,
0.3754594326,
0.0084508583,
-0.2962771356,
0.2713527977,
0.6269789934,
1.3982239962,
0.1949160397,
0.3038385808,
0.0017470919,
-0.160266757,
0.1887735575,
-0.5003986955,
-0.1533857286,
0.3084640205,
0.5147211552,
0.4697648287,
0.5604525208,
-0.5486162305,
0.3569020927,
0.1985881925,
-0.0806338713,
-0.7614378333,
-0.1272787452,
0.0034914797,
0.1902634054,
0.2307932675,
0.217209056,
-0.0563013181,
-1.1028802395,
0.0712471828,
0.4881085753,
-0.5454304814,
-0.5530563593,
0.6449240446,
0.3006083071,
-0.3090697229,
0.1873455942,
0.2096359432,
-0.3383363783,
0.3704076707,
0.6684139371,
1.1473042965,
-0.4006783664,
-0.2111193985,
0.7186402082,
0.4278405011,
-0.0168815032,
0.0237352066,
0.0112464381,
-1.0711972713,
-0.3046328723,
-0.3667004108,
-0.1307437569,
0.1763963848,
-0.416870594,
-0.180873543,
-0.3178406358,
-0.239973411,
-0.2488040924,
-0.4789557159,
-0.2660568058,
-0.1912481785,
0.3099682927,
1.051397562,
-0.6708655357,
0.922721386,
0.4436938167,
-0.4146351814,
-0.4950382113,
0.1487471759,
-0.0687431023,
-0.414526701,
0.9063951969,
0.1879566014,
-0.2082655281,
-0.4885672033,
-0.0969953313,
-0.9506501555,
0.7727693319,
0.2122898102,
-0.4945556521,
-0.0453326181,
-0.0886143968,
0.5815545321,
-0.4204208553,
0.0296187308,
0.129337281,
0.4688688815,
-0.026624091,
-1.3108183146,
0.3071223795,
-0.1971329898,
0.336163193,
0.1621421427,
-0.5405877233,
1.0701313019,
-0.4273643196,
-0.3920570314,
0.3646286428,
0.7467806935,
-0.1740801632,
-0.2390531749,
0.3470193744,
0.2266916782,
0.6213725805,
0.0796658918,
1.4754981995,
-0.3135323226,
0.2266828418,
1.1134929657,
-0.2798136771,
1.0348916054,
0.8457015753,
-0.7984841466,
0.4764417708,
0.4350466132,
0.4036034942,
0.5128396153,
0.2777559757,
-0.3526915312,
-0.1238074079,
-0.1462600529,
-0.5179687142,
0.0038974872,
0.1743561625,
-0.7011769414,
-0.1956478208,
-0.4554186165,
0.0328997821,
0.2491449416,
-0.367895484,
0.7595430017,
0.4913338125,
-0.6836889386,
0.4765824378,
-0.1864056885,
0.4798078537,
-0.8412889242,
0.1985337734,
0.0478428379,
0.5386915803,
-0.0629081503,
-0.539454639,
0.4222300053,
-0.2524403334,
-0.2313490361,
-0.0345321037,
0.7499807477,
-0.4053972065,
-0.5752016306,
0.3025246859,
0.5050775409,
0.1424229145,
0.0903611183,
-0.376378417,
-0.37670663,
-0.1297779232,
-0.0083083296,
0.2688288689,
0.3140393198,
0.0414287932,
0.7301974297,
0.526686728,
0.4763030112,
0.1211191863,
0.0283218343,
0.6198840737,
-0.6968160868,
-0.3000130355,
-1.0722711086,
0.3029902875,
-0.1399635226,
-0.3722962439,
0.8074807525,
0.4690911472,
0.8717879653,
-0.1906047612,
0.9309282899,
-0.2154659331,
0.5604763031,
-0.486328721,
0.1980681568,
-0.3304217756,
-0.0046240212,
-0.1205909327,
-1.0210194588,
0.0877235457,
0.7606674433,
-0.4521625936,
0.1378081441,
1.0625572205,
0.5801755786,
-0.0375578813,
-0.1765833497,
0.3597991467,
0.2076470107,
0.0371200219,
0.4520121515,
0.9456518292,
-0.2863831222,
0.4083125591,
-0.0707692876,
0.0194732267,
-0.271683991,
-0.7647089362,
-0.743807137,
-0.7838978767,
-0.077140294,
-0.3284130096,
-0.0820708573,
0.8013414145,
0.3944293857,
-0.8072455525,
-0.6635073423,
0.0865563527,
-0.0757965818,
-0.1816100031,
-0.2149791121,
-0.0305600278,
-0.363268584,
-0.4902634919,
0.2002376318,
0.0996084958,
-0.1841438115,
-0.5282817483,
-0.2202717662,
-0.2122072726,
0.1944022179,
0.7021920681,
0.3397603035,
-1.1823972464,
-0.6391178966,
-0.2775549293,
-0.1809681803,
0.0763754621,
1.1821244955,
-0.6711557508,
0.267442435,
0.4509658217,
0.4195014536,
-0.2189602703,
-0.1915446818,
0.630019784,
-0.5132795572,
0.424544245,
-0.005579534,
0.7906310558,
0.2916382849,
0.0197982397,
0.4377433956,
0.6892675161,
-0.3466491699,
-0.6778303385,
0.5304599404,
-0.6218110919,
-0.3313408792,
1.3266897202,
0.0882617906,
-0.1259502321,
0.0114470813,
-0.2476166636,
-0.2070238739,
-0.2299778163,
0.6320992112,
1.0624842644,
-0.1028131247,
-0.1962439567,
-0.945445478,
0.3837600946,
0.0798599645,
-0.37920627,
0.2277396023,
0.5622980595,
0.196876213,
0.4922385514,
0.9535105824,
0.0178411547,
0.1743836403,
-0.031631317,
-0.2789835632,
0.2615086436,
-0.1239896566,
-0.2104563266,
0.0406193286,
0.3546609282,
-0.0579002351
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00131v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00131v1
|
How In-Context Learning Emerges from Training on Unstructured Data: On the Role of Co-Occurrence, Positional Information, and Noise Structures
| 2024-05-31T18:46:06 | 2024-05-31T18:46:06 |
Kevin Christian Wibisono, Yixin Wang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
Large language models (LLMs) like transformers have impressive in-context
learning (ICL) capabilities; they can generate predictions for new queries
based on input-output sequences in prompts without parameter updates. While
many theories have attempted to explain ICL, they often focus on structured
training data similar to ICL tasks, such as regression. In practice, however,
these models are trained in an unsupervised manner on unstructured text data,
which bears little resemblance to ICL tasks. To this end, we investigate how
ICL emerges from unsupervised training on unstructured data. The key
observation is that ICL can arise simply by modeling co-occurrence information
using classical language models like continuous bag of words (CBOW), which we
theoretically prove and empirically validate. Furthermore, we establish the
necessity of positional information and noise structure to generalize ICL to
unseen data. Finally, we present instances where ICL fails and provide
theoretical explanations; they suggest that the ICL ability of LLMs to identify
certain tasks can be sensitive to the structure of the training data.
|
[
-0.2613954842,
-0.7746328712,
0.6242008209,
-0.0581197627,
-0.2185317874,
0.2688392103,
-0.3694980741,
-0.4065370858,
-0.4124243259,
0.3074543774,
-0.4262465835,
-0.6455461383,
-0.2669304907,
-0.1009169444,
-0.8823786378,
1.2717282772,
0.1385435462,
-0.1237973273,
-0.5420513153,
0.002687257,
-0.3234599531,
-0.885817349,
-0.2908072174,
-0.5396319032,
0.1387571841,
0.3874560297,
0.2922937572,
0.4393574297,
0.1215653792,
0.1804229021,
0.0570674203,
0.0052078227,
-0.4655168056,
0.0910847411,
-0.0858677104,
-0.4781154096,
0.3458147347,
-0.0039274595,
0.7885088325,
1.2733039856,
-0.2664971054,
-0.0344243906,
0.6551471353,
0.3732251227,
-0.3670390546,
0.2906891704,
-1.105935812,
0.1771972477,
-0.3047850728,
-0.2660397887,
-0.6332942843,
0.2371352315,
0.3121214211,
-0.4639760554,
0.501349628,
0.0833781362,
0.7266392708,
0.1811890155,
-0.6281993985,
-0.6459116936,
-0.9047572017,
0.9331156611,
-0.2531124055,
0.5047297478,
0.4020811915,
0.0112238824,
-0.5413802862,
-0.8237618804,
-0.3557409644,
-0.1750880778,
-0.4906797111,
0.0190058276,
0.109408088,
-0.0821124017,
0.2954648733,
0.30515486,
-0.1971393526,
0.2503892183,
-0.2721190155,
0.2436755002,
0.475042671,
-0.0700631812,
0.1756745875,
-0.0247150902,
-0.6626739502,
-0.0266610235,
-0.9022575021,
0.5222539306,
0.020158764,
0.3422159553,
-0.2932451963,
0.3535344303,
0.0207854249,
0.5901790857,
0.2826397419,
-0.2209476233,
0.0126377502,
0.1064048409,
-0.2119868696,
0.3239525557,
0.6150227785,
-0.3076119721,
0.2381303906,
-0.5846574306,
-0.3969243765,
-0.2391690314,
0.3704080582,
-0.4328981638,
-0.2356433421,
-0.0174656287,
-0.3114527166,
-0.3302134573,
0.3868286312,
-0.4254373908,
-0.0951012447,
-0.5048863888,
0.2840974629,
-0.4118150771,
0.0300317071,
-0.2615815699,
0.0770301074,
0.311837554,
0.140427798,
-1.0033793449,
0.4225152135,
0.612678349,
0.5870190859,
-0.3430624604,
-0.3198746741,
-0.453648299,
0.2536231875,
-0.4481458366,
0.934135139,
-0.6959580183,
-0.4252480268,
0.2172071338,
0.0406795032,
-0.2425771207,
-0.6112288833,
0.3025502861,
-0.5894918442,
0.2272110879,
-0.0671590045,
-0.6224919558,
-0.2367899567,
0.0598715656,
-0.3885784149,
1.4033470154,
0.259611249,
-0.8429718018,
0.8080592752,
-0.7248232365,
-0.5819476247,
0.2694405317,
-0.4722852111,
-0.4137781262,
0.5085554123,
-0.1193624213,
0.5973578095,
-0.1463786513,
0.5915126204,
-0.2394203991,
-0.5063489676,
0.6305379272,
-0.5066022277,
0.6205122471,
0.0328315087,
-0.2920315564,
-0.1609302014,
-0.8676362038,
-0.1425990313,
-0.0494519658,
-0.7104430199,
-0.6903008819,
0.4651079178,
-0.1088443846,
0.2042221576,
-0.0759236589,
-0.4822314382,
0.1386295557,
-0.5235828757,
0.3219375014,
0.5510873795,
-0.0276799835,
0.5757583976,
0.0324137323,
0.1220592856,
0.2411334366,
-0.0509737879,
-0.1317479908,
-0.0157886744,
-0.5047241449,
-0.219071731,
0.1000697985,
0.1913672686,
-0.540833354,
0.2488362193,
-0.139526397,
-0.2006435543,
-0.1179656684,
0.2755121589,
0.3120348155,
0.8293195963,
0.4128226936,
-0.1128980666,
-0.6903241873,
-0.7123462558,
-0.0782277808,
0.036938224,
-0.2624633014,
0.2763004005,
0.520668745,
-0.026120089,
1.1903839111,
-0.2703146338,
-0.1703936905,
-0.171074599,
0.1929468215,
0.0977521166,
0.3295557499,
0.3113803566,
-0.8311449289,
-0.5706174374,
-0.0453778915,
-0.9530347586,
-0.0289610233,
-0.0380488709,
0.239925459,
0.2993534207,
1.0167479515,
-0.280944109,
0.5154305696,
0.439000994,
-0.1744978577,
0.2433711588,
-0.3308353722,
-0.3933750093,
-1.3404666185,
-0.0338082835,
-0.0370326489,
-0.1041340828,
-0.681971848,
-0.1683471799,
-0.0387978181,
0.0025372256,
-0.3295040131,
0.3436682522,
-0.6280005574,
-0.3871555328,
-0.220238477,
-0.0249331724,
-0.1723468751,
0.6339081526,
0.2814926207,
0.5803493261,
0.6125852466,
-0.8161756992,
-0.2571496964,
0.2436243147,
-0.6726134419,
0.3215700388,
-0.40422526,
0.1012775227,
-0.2892184854,
0.2461947352,
-0.9710784554,
-0.3805281818,
-0.1123017147,
-0.0422163233,
0.4746657908,
-0.3609732091,
-0.5073315501,
-0.0260857828,
0.0384818986,
0.5023980141,
0.3330331743,
-0.9429186583,
0.2945710421,
0.5591635108,
0.3624385297,
-0.586088419,
-0.6141856313,
-0.1505165696,
-0.475147754,
-0.0484121144,
0.4640571773,
-0.054602012,
-0.4241049886,
-0.1178259775,
0.0149293132,
-0.2563189268,
0.5288056135,
0.5220203996,
0.1682623923,
-0.0789350793,
0.3798053265,
-0.0363442004,
0.0602257103,
0.138260603,
-0.4343279004,
0.6358846426,
-0.0460454524,
-0.3759027421,
-0.0863223821,
0.3383219242,
0.3257210851,
-0.0058131339,
0.7655428052,
0.3038757741,
-0.3939075768,
-0.4867459834,
-0.0232938398,
-0.2196297497,
-0.4376420677,
0.4748834968,
-0.3101837635,
-0.7186034918,
0.2697054744,
-0.1554524451,
-0.0268752985,
0.2102341801,
0.3949278593,
-0.4767069817,
1.0095020533,
0.8348875046,
0.1564188898,
0.6533819437,
-0.2581979632,
0.1732830107,
-0.8719938993,
-0.5411881208,
-0.3831304014,
-0.2004195005,
-0.7124866247,
-0.0746655017,
0.5526066422,
0.3881843388,
-0.2986856997,
0.0685986131,
-0.3020115495,
0.5487216711,
0.5371420383,
-0.0678895265,
0.2784781158,
0.3517746925,
-0.1437749118,
0.159388721,
-0.6186111569,
-0.3303673863,
0.9699093699,
0.151966542,
0.7883340716,
-0.1972301453,
0.4458502829,
0.1221430823,
0.2906717062,
-0.7714787126,
0.2086503208,
-0.1206002906,
-0.3665908575,
-0.1948465705,
0.0667157844,
-1.1940956116,
0.1404345632,
-0.2659167349,
-0.8451577425,
0.2358229309,
0.0780659914,
-0.0411756895,
0.159203738,
-0.5783831477,
0.4245470166,
-0.2644759417,
-0.1953895688,
0.058247406,
-0.5903362036,
0.2201268673,
-0.2497306019,
0.1951478273,
0.306198597,
0.070483014,
0.5374209285,
-0.1686992347,
1.1101828814,
-0.1296397746,
-0.1163046211,
0.3062554598,
0.1000221893,
0.5499353409,
0.1381416619,
0.2206455767,
0.3536458313,
-0.1142034009,
-0.2311165035,
-0.5666321516,
0.5500917435,
-0.7790517807,
-0.3315139711,
-0.3454676867,
-0.8575512767,
-0.3128241301,
-0.0677384809,
0.5929285884,
0.8057191968,
-0.0411918536,
0.7171680331,
0.8043020964,
-0.1084684134,
0.851773262,
0.582662046,
0.0295978934,
0.2383393049,
0.4699334502,
0.3397003114,
0.1294446737,
0.7616764307,
0.1988034844,
-0.3687258065,
-0.6432890296,
-0.1295017004,
-0.1424281299,
-0.7478279471,
-0.1264239997,
-0.669506669,
-0.4532398582,
0.0004001546,
-0.2668101788,
-0.1955783516,
0.0631669089,
-0.3003605008,
-0.1020160392,
0.0477143154,
1.0712995529,
0.1981077194,
0.3797487915,
-0.4298199117,
-0.2387208939,
0.1861632019,
0.3037845194,
0.1102930382,
-0.6222894192,
-0.5808636546,
0.0952776372,
-0.1995324492,
-0.4516741633,
0.394723773,
0.3541349769,
0.658570528,
0.405618608,
0.0120713459,
0.7040367126,
-0.4631256759,
0.6147925854,
-0.3000712395,
-0.7313354015,
0.2647246122,
-0.3920894265,
0.0669185668,
0.3949473202,
0.4621076584,
-0.4679794014,
-0.2357109785,
-0.7132519484,
-0.7517783046,
0.78198421,
-0.1966646463,
0.1549890786,
-0.0340696126,
0.4804525971,
0.378043592,
0.3394553959,
-1.0653333664,
0.049999129,
-0.1279604435,
-0.3795391321,
-0.0402706154,
-0.3492638171,
0.0320751034,
-0.1888394356,
0.3370852768,
-0.4640658796,
0.1616972983,
0.1315231621,
-0.5569118261,
0.060901124,
0.2879658937,
0.4346981049,
0.6353626251,
-0.081381321,
0.3411211967,
0.1658612639,
-0.2661419213,
-0.1371374726,
-0.1428486407,
-0.2737244666,
-0.301111728,
0.680634141,
0.8132091165,
0.7441176772,
-0.6338626146,
0.531229794,
0.1040744781,
-0.1121835038,
-0.7832732797,
-0.0026277932,
-0.1736999303,
0.2010899186,
0.6458188295,
-0.0553648099,
0.0359311067,
-0.9337197542,
0.2265300453,
0.715498805,
-0.71733284,
-0.6094950438,
0.387714833,
-0.3656909466,
-0.2242133617,
0.7493072748,
-0.0151224453,
-0.3182643354,
0.2988372445,
0.8794262409,
0.6457378268,
-0.0145963673,
0.0817921311,
0.1235995293,
-0.015171309,
0.0003250458,
-0.1388428807,
-0.4936628044,
-0.811389327,
-0.2655375898,
-0.8626317382,
-0.0523681268,
0.4744240046,
-0.6070883274,
0.284940958,
-0.3526655734,
0.6562879682,
-0.3245184124,
-0.133261323,
-0.7564873695,
0.2125228941,
0.0659822598,
0.593865633,
-0.9496430159,
1.0578452349,
0.5601964593,
-0.2199265659,
-0.9913475513,
0.4045794308,
-0.2180186957,
-0.8722674251,
0.8506659269,
0.2376074493,
0.1689018458,
0.0891353264,
-0.7473854423,
-1.0130485296,
1.1285221577,
0.2933385968,
-0.3184845746,
-0.1372565776,
0.3472050428,
0.6750411391,
-0.745710969,
0.0559131652,
0.3373247385,
-0.0104060024,
0.0501726232,
-0.493920505,
-0.1774239242,
0.1458274722,
-0.0887031555,
0.1634237915,
-0.4476507604,
0.9855310917,
0.0225569848,
-0.3482816815,
-0.250048548,
0.5432365537,
0.0980661586,
0.3813323975,
0.5796842575,
0.2642879486,
0.7862362266,
-0.096870631,
1.2056393623,
-0.1221983135,
0.2466463298,
1.2719928026,
-0.2403294891,
0.8277053237,
0.4670791626,
0.105437912,
0.8225058913,
0.7817063928,
-0.0628603995,
0.7403520346,
-0.0424560346,
-0.2177596837,
-0.248295486,
-0.3287370801,
0.1219319701,
0.9545673728,
0.5051549077,
-0.3571302593,
-0.4038869441,
0.3113736212,
-0.1621134579,
0.1557980329,
-0.225343734,
1.0923442841,
0.0849231482,
-0.6913140416,
0.3618178666,
-0.2850213349,
0.5143015981,
-0.5461927652,
-0.082941778,
-0.187994644,
0.1418646127,
-0.1874453574,
-0.640083611,
0.3829650581,
-0.2684563696,
-0.4071775973,
-0.2024092823,
0.6349788308,
-0.6001984477,
-0.3821896017,
0.3729561269,
0.3320454955,
0.1720285416,
-0.0791328922,
-0.4520069361,
-0.2351638079,
-0.198037982,
-0.179834798,
0.7325448394,
0.5984321833,
-0.5701854825,
0.5219758153,
0.5605350137,
-0.2609395087,
-0.0045539285,
-0.0788400322,
0.7379763126,
-0.4095954597,
-0.4133530259,
-0.9712762833,
0.3894737363,
0.011176507,
-0.0312532708,
0.6156251431,
0.6763495207,
1.2728518248,
-0.0627552941,
0.7574970126,
0.0441175438,
0.4706787169,
-0.6812050939,
0.4853790104,
-0.532725215,
0.3520132005,
-0.0672817528,
-0.6980211139,
-0.1820753217,
0.3887507915,
-0.320748657,
-0.0367292725,
0.8729074001,
0.6859650612,
-0.3237661719,
-0.104395017,
0.367551744,
0.2235912979,
0.3110837042,
0.2857525945,
0.99364537,
-0.2685358822,
0.4628279209,
-0.2213499099,
0.066772446,
-0.1407547146,
-0.785844624,
-1.0574480295,
-1.1895252466,
-0.0138082914,
-0.1943513155,
-0.3377671838,
1.0948847532,
0.793264091,
-0.7753302455,
-0.3502935469,
-0.4115009904,
0.1336599737,
-0.017503269,
-0.2928225994,
0.5667055249,
-0.5523087978,
-0.7656939626,
0.8007847071,
0.295317471,
0.1484766454,
-0.0355270579,
0.1165441424,
-0.1774856597,
-0.037841931,
0.7818491459,
0.3086175025,
-0.529723525,
-0.5011135936,
-0.2118096799,
-0.0036260334,
0.2323546708,
1.0056271553,
-1.0037207603,
0.1456683576,
0.159458667,
0.4698014259,
0.3767185211,
-0.0457915291,
0.5315245986,
-1.3445621729,
0.4667792022,
-0.1275829971,
0.3744449019,
0.4223400652,
-0.5282933712,
0.4466208816,
0.322437793,
-0.504730463,
-1.0618175268,
0.2586047649,
-0.5889999866,
-0.5122870207,
1.0504242182,
0.0781064481,
-0.363761574,
-0.542737484,
0.0378540978,
0.2704896629,
-0.1127093434,
1.1149955988,
0.5899273753,
-0.267049253,
0.0618269071,
-0.4342555702,
0.8438696861,
0.08542303,
-0.6599752903,
0.0358897597,
0.2375176549,
0.3521000147,
0.0100535424,
0.2944078743,
-0.0475467741,
-0.1340741217,
-0.2643485963,
-0.1646444947,
0.0323207341,
-0.5227037072,
-0.2973361611,
0.4944431782,
0.1549969614,
-0.0474624559
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.21075v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.21075v2
|
Video-MME: The First-Ever Comprehensive Evaluation Benchmark of Multi-modal LLMs in Video Analysis
| 2024-05-31T17:59:47 | 2024-06-16T15:49:12 |
Chaoyou Fu, Yuhan Dai, Yongdong Luo, Lei Li, Shuhuai Ren, Renrui Zhang, Zihan Wang, Chenyu Zhou, Yunhang Shen, Mengdan Zhang, Peixian Chen, Yanwei Li, Shaohui Lin, Sirui Zhao, Ke Li, Tong Xu, Xiawu Zheng, Enhong Chen, Rongrong Ji, Xing Sun
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
In the quest for artificial general intelligence, Multi-modal Large Language
Models (MLLMs) have emerged as a focal point in recent advancements. However,
the predominant focus remains on developing their capabilities in static image
understanding. The potential of MLLMs in processing sequential visual data is
still insufficiently explored, highlighting the absence of a comprehensive,
high-quality assessment of their performance. In this paper, we introduce
Video-MME, the first-ever full-spectrum, Multi-Modal Evaluation benchmark of
MLLMs in Video analysis. Our work distinguishes from existing benchmarks
through four key features: 1) Diversity in video types, spanning 6 primary
visual domains with 30 subfields to ensure broad scenario generalizability; 2)
Duration in temporal dimension, encompassing both short-, medium-, and
long-term videos, ranging from 11 seconds to 1 hour, for robust contextual
dynamics; 3) Breadth in data modalities, integrating multi-modal inputs besides
video frames, including subtitles and audios, to unveil the all-round
capabilities of MLLMs; 4) Quality in annotations, utilizing rigorous manual
labeling by expert annotators to facilitate precise and reliable model
assessment. 900 videos with a total of 254 hours are manually selected and
annotated by repeatedly viewing all the video content, resulting in 2,700
question-answer pairs. With Video-MME, we extensively evaluate various
state-of-the-art MLLMs, including GPT-4 series and Gemini 1.5 Pro, as well as
open-source image models like InternVL-Chat-V1.5 and video models like
LLaVA-NeXT-Video. Our experiments reveal that Gemini 1.5 Pro is the
best-performing commercial model, significantly outperforming the open-source
models. Our dataset along with these findings underscores the need for further
improvements in handling longer sequences and multi-modal data. Project Page:
https://video-mme.github.io
|
[
-0.6887958646,
-0.7546578646,
0.3413133621,
0.2294182479,
-0.3873693943,
-0.1100553796,
-0.2240863442,
-0.120443657,
-0.1474440247,
0.096460484,
-0.8803570271,
-0.5343932509,
-0.8431147337,
-0.0242773015,
-0.6448917389,
0.5605306625,
0.0479851887,
0.2289928645,
-0.1152242944,
-0.4692624509,
-0.376916796,
-0.3821578324,
-0.3568278849,
0.1955908835,
0.3665204048,
-0.0591235682,
0.6565129161,
0.3973637819,
0.8012269735,
0.4116626978,
0.2485196739,
0.3203762174,
-0.412125349,
-0.2093891501,
0.1622302085,
0.1263988018,
-0.5283563137,
0.0543029532,
0.8528908491,
0.4711849093,
0.0269752797,
0.6826344728,
-0.0714512616,
0.5990558863,
-0.8753628731,
-0.0428662412,
-0.5635342598,
0.1921714395,
-0.14002195,
-0.2212768495,
-0.2371472865,
0.126872927,
0.160096705,
-0.4282413125,
0.0717680603,
-0.207133472,
0.6491464376,
0.5398119688,
-0.6231911778,
0.0915965438,
-0.8522122502,
0.7403546572,
-0.5711601973,
0.9538239837,
-0.045984786,
0.798827827,
0.111500442,
-0.7365830541,
-0.433324039,
-0.4232593477,
0.4243798256,
0.2805778086,
-0.1536984742,
0.1176402122,
0.352057308,
0.298342675,
-0.7412145138,
0.1838690937,
-0.3059916198,
-0.1246930063,
0.5252292156,
0.3170017898,
0.0334968083,
-0.2182389796,
-0.449437201,
0.0172290821,
-0.2166226804,
0.321952641,
0.1429318339,
-0.223027125,
-0.2767066658,
0.7611964941,
-0.1179381013,
0.5513435006,
-0.3463606238,
-0.4232266843,
0.2429015189,
-0.4292188883,
-0.8523363471,
-0.6068275571,
0.8959318995,
0.6662868261,
0.216345638,
0.1006661505,
-0.0047822758,
0.2894662321,
0.0531132184,
-0.9805909395,
0.0824108198,
0.160612449,
-0.682258904,
0.1005890444,
0.2636488974,
-0.9272238612,
-0.3024923801,
-0.5725948215,
0.5191692114,
-0.2556040585,
-0.1938156933,
0.0655816719,
0.0419144928,
0.2733995318,
0.4019376934,
-0.6394867897,
0.3900205195,
0.688475728,
0.8203338981,
-0.2690486908,
-0.4004962146,
-0.6592371464,
0.0394193828,
-0.2502698302,
0.5560042262,
-0.3653971851,
-0.2025968134,
-0.0048223436,
-0.0162858311,
-0.0641400069,
-0.5174827576,
0.5563420057,
-0.4968881607,
0.1909337044,
-0.0069371681,
-0.4996488392,
-0.323156476,
0.4451099932,
-0.6292659044,
0.9036097527,
-0.2975378335,
-0.4912314415,
0.6783133745,
-0.6914454103,
0.1348199546,
-0.3775889874,
-0.3965530097,
-0.2343105823,
0.022323044,
0.3486750126,
0.3791003227,
-0.4774194062,
0.5124875307,
-0.5340880752,
-0.2937577963,
0.3389009535,
-1.1503784657,
0.2076861113,
0.112077482,
-0.2119881511,
0.3886352479,
-0.8314726949,
-0.1571578979,
-0.2784542441,
-0.0702339485,
0.2294019461,
0.0512617491,
0.0912617445,
0.5070084929,
0.0052557508,
-0.3824795783,
-0.0333247073,
0.0281053986,
0.2043429464,
0.9607700109,
-0.1767683625,
0.1288944334,
-0.0079309726,
0.3845872283,
0.1366960108,
0.728798449,
-0.5391221642,
-0.4005176723,
-0.4585565329,
-0.5908802152,
0.1057855263,
0.6273231506,
-0.4540268481,
0.0315967426,
-0.4041055441,
-0.2140288204,
-0.5880740285,
0.339949429,
0.0982668847,
0.2467878163,
0.4507930875,
-0.3346794844,
-0.6206302047,
-1.2286496162,
0.2394337058,
0.1633237302,
-0.2819294035,
0.5888367891,
0.4978145957,
-0.334182024,
0.7255093455,
-0.2639816105,
-0.0554947555,
0.2292692065,
0.1086050496,
0.2985554934,
-0.0252246149,
0.5066626072,
-0.9315412641,
-0.3623956144,
-0.0689172,
-1.1323144436,
0.146537587,
-0.2134937942,
0.1440351009,
0.0406793058,
0.3697456121,
-0.513304472,
0.306327641,
0.7717632055,
-0.2689851522,
0.7715459466,
-0.1979584694,
0.5997387767,
-0.6472435594,
0.2261843085,
0.1697406918,
-0.2407205999,
-0.4231486022,
-0.1170220077,
-0.2043154836,
-0.1730750203,
-0.6709977388,
0.3441167176,
-0.3041508794,
-0.5366132855,
-0.0716277659,
0.1772125363,
-0.4330510199,
0.5566576123,
-0.2532282472,
0.8541713357,
0.7865356803,
-0.5059244633,
0.5514113307,
-0.1676026285,
-0.4760283828,
0.4539183676,
-0.5031017065,
-0.1308216006,
-0.3303774297,
-0.1597905457,
-0.9633691311,
-0.1040001288,
-0.0445468612,
-0.3542380333,
0.0867174417,
-0.1201792732,
-0.3666543663,
-0.434933871,
-0.447319746,
0.3905599713,
0.3998582959,
-0.3248997629,
0.6083361506,
0.2814091444,
0.0589215644,
-0.8671363592,
-0.1923059672,
0.3761330247,
-0.3829316497,
-1.0175352097,
0.0902732536,
-0.4517905116,
-0.2925125659,
-0.1162547097,
-0.2126749307,
-0.2606825531,
-0.0710936412,
0.237547487,
0.4289802909,
-0.3159868717,
-0.1633453667,
-0.3152980506,
-0.1973181963,
-0.0246476009,
0.1036479324,
0.3513149023,
-0.1866235286,
-0.55841887,
-0.4336716533,
0.4056141973,
0.9122811556,
-0.2416598946,
0.3386164308,
1.0643630028,
-0.2645605206,
0.0913327783,
-0.8486750722,
0.0329921022,
-0.4838396311,
0.686779201,
-0.3300153315,
-0.887095809,
0.3997139633,
-0.0820646584,
0.1457656622,
0.2615275383,
0.6379090548,
-0.2741988003,
1.0365852118,
0.5650286674,
-0.110108301,
0.5937443376,
-0.3711260557,
-0.2294774801,
-0.5351046324,
-0.2014690787,
0.2523626387,
-0.2665817738,
-0.5197693706,
-0.8115611076,
0.8247102499,
-0.0424251333,
-0.4315015376,
-0.1681697667,
0.0452973135,
0.4073750973,
0.0758215263,
-0.0267801452,
0.2232701629,
-0.0605210438,
0.0253149532,
-0.375423044,
-0.3733826578,
-0.5857389569,
1.236531496,
0.5384480953,
0.5144205093,
0.224755004,
0.0331104621,
0.6179262996,
0.3753995001,
-0.6885519624,
0.7205194831,
-0.4977248311,
-0.4148595333,
-0.2129214555,
-0.1970258057,
-0.7149156332,
0.6092856526,
-0.3990600109,
-0.5846031308,
-0.1891393661,
-0.0998733714,
-0.2405106574,
0.3933084607,
-0.3330928683,
1.0433195829,
-0.4659701586,
-0.6248775125,
-0.3689905107,
-0.6854018569,
0.7815692425,
0.0276898146,
0.5393817425,
-0.227288425,
-0.2117856443,
0.4255726337,
-0.1794492006,
0.502641201,
-0.268489182,
0.164415285,
0.344887495,
-0.0497472249,
0.010926553,
0.1676584631,
0.303237915,
0.0456175134,
-0.0393147394,
-0.1079038307,
-0.6344877481,
0.465111047,
-0.6729666591,
-0.3735486269,
-0.0714058504,
-0.3419139385,
-0.1827811301,
0.0386143178,
-0.19244726,
0.6961734891,
-0.3813639581,
0.4327035546,
0.5180431604,
-0.2056242377,
0.7518749833,
0.5395206213,
-0.4695474505,
-0.8237380385,
0.7726767063,
-0.0180863775,
0.2078893036,
0.259111315,
-0.1086062267,
-0.2155305743,
-0.5692422986,
-0.6233686805,
-0.0102699427,
-0.7110892534,
0.0150713399,
-0.4740583599,
-0.119261831,
-0.1409681886,
0.1092059538,
-0.5859798789,
-0.0025158126,
-0.0812025517,
-0.1706723571,
-0.1967691481,
0.4160301387,
-0.0067445901,
0.1475111395,
-0.9864686728,
0.6698021293,
0.6260650158,
0.4350610673,
-0.263538897,
-0.3361849189,
-0.1410990804,
-0.1752332151,
-0.4445851743,
-0.8105303049,
0.2667061388,
0.207894206,
0.8802784085,
0.4956459403,
-0.7087907791,
0.8705556989,
-0.4946295917,
1.0376017094,
0.2853808105,
-0.7955902219,
0.331132561,
-0.4500382245,
0.0622741766,
0.4075613618,
0.3398375213,
-0.4791442752,
0.1295125335,
-0.3615303934,
-0.7670830488,
0.1086184457,
0.2476045042,
-0.0999643728,
0.1135758013,
-0.0055888323,
0.2519366443,
0.4522083104,
-0.7431745529,
-0.303378135,
-0.2660321593,
0.0797545314,
-0.1913743615,
-0.1599671394,
-0.0685527921,
-0.288888514,
0.3126313686,
-0.2297876179,
0.1386414617,
0.1958279461,
-0.3412972689,
-0.0068845064,
0.3368563056,
0.8546187878,
0.770653367,
-0.506193161,
-0.1090560332,
0.3496806622,
-0.289809972,
0.1114700288,
0.0371933989,
0.0680455044,
0.0771386102,
0.4187316895,
0.8795687556,
0.3882265985,
-0.9473237395,
0.7747241855,
0.1107766479,
-0.2194463164,
-0.4256606698,
-0.2729527652,
-0.248946622,
0.3653548956,
0.3534381688,
0.166046828,
0.4604524672,
-0.5866749883,
0.4371918142,
0.6549770832,
-0.2056055218,
-0.5221682787,
0.7864702344,
0.1709156483,
0.0521925837,
0.4352755547,
-0.0515084937,
-0.1580239832,
0.6477312446,
0.063539736,
0.9321511984,
0.0004207932,
0.2386736274,
0.5385209322,
0.4423628151,
0.0125838406,
0.3031853437,
-0.1229522005,
-0.5042436719,
-0.7174564004,
-0.5316656232,
-0.3592096865,
0.1999654621,
-0.51811409,
0.4839819968,
-0.3543415666,
-0.3577029109,
-0.0833850801,
-0.2741596103,
-0.9183718562,
0.3019851744,
0.69583112,
1.0663692951,
-0.7590727806,
0.8146976829,
0.3309009373,
-0.2335391045,
-0.2829385102,
-0.6097471714,
0.204447329,
-0.57575804,
0.7406907678,
0.2598144114,
-0.1637894511,
-0.3178916276,
-0.3614676297,
-0.7484184504,
1.4328770638,
0.2877277732,
-0.5046454668,
0.0304099657,
0.2530878186,
0.448823601,
-0.4096607864,
0.6782697439,
0.58116889,
0.5347464681,
0.2488834113,
-1.1204762459,
-0.5448048115,
-0.2754058242,
-0.1730144024,
0.1841115505,
-0.6386290789,
0.8626229763,
-0.1766756624,
-0.0132552683,
0.047568161,
0.6433391571,
0.1909165233,
0.6431983709,
0.5575882792,
0.5824005008,
0.4601808488,
0.0724363029,
0.8354356289,
-0.1700160503,
0.3896183074,
1.0814527273,
-0.1101757735,
0.9074697495,
0.5938076377,
-0.4444468915,
0.2939826548,
0.3927313089,
-0.4050388932,
0.4797724485,
-0.0201698262,
-0.2202281356,
-0.4312560558,
0.0074183773,
-0.3075949848,
0.5881155729,
0.2478122413,
-0.3691439331,
-0.213160038,
0.1947329789,
-0.4586693645,
-0.1474750787,
-0.488861829,
0.656411171,
-0.1161640063,
-0.2696793377,
0.3075048625,
-0.2336892486,
0.8229445815,
-0.9186213613,
0.1416668296,
-0.0295896064,
0.0295595583,
-0.1578627676,
-0.6046292186,
0.1881010234,
0.1779609025,
-0.2110167444,
0.0518150851,
0.4411041737,
-0.2657543421,
-0.5101079345,
0.4146240354,
0.6180900931,
0.0721851885,
-0.0953588337,
-0.6926002502,
0.2329238802,
-0.2697934806,
-0.253921926,
0.2543580532,
0.1647527665,
-0.0168967675,
0.8043122888,
0.6531839967,
-0.2503200173,
0.4046550095,
0.2481061518,
0.7784503102,
-0.6918290854,
-0.1253681779,
-1.1132529974,
0.976018548,
-0.1211364791,
-0.1553008407,
0.8199653625,
0.9357507825,
0.656832397,
-0.2117445767,
0.6024419665,
0.1833665669,
-0.0305213239,
-0.60254246,
0.0179241337,
-0.6168124676,
0.2173259854,
-0.3729403019,
-0.9473890662,
-0.2426257133,
0.2346985489,
-0.1744229794,
0.0154939964,
0.6396628022,
0.6442020535,
-0.2753690779,
-0.0109669073,
0.6387297511,
0.1924024075,
0.5159647465,
0.4980278611,
0.9309624434,
-0.5893717408,
0.6819578409,
-0.2626008689,
-0.3362214863,
0.0310238954,
-1.013117671,
-0.7436257005,
-0.2862049639,
-0.2337943017,
0.2110189348,
-0.079015404,
1.0569484234,
0.8849654794,
-0.5643461943,
-0.5168502927,
0.4548719227,
-0.2590461969,
-0.3102500737,
-0.1691174954,
0.1367227882,
0.1239205971,
-0.6392483711,
0.6512978673,
0.7267746925,
-0.0525414906,
-0.5686930418,
-0.1779502034,
-0.1384491324,
0.0498516895,
1.0394943953,
0.0708737671,
-0.8853137493,
-0.23968786,
0.2145326436,
0.043833863,
0.220320344,
1.0096434355,
-0.6215643287,
0.5572722554,
0.358618021,
0.4275338948,
0.6680996418,
0.0176686272,
0.2636193931,
-0.4618222415,
0.2182438672,
0.1082311198,
0.5857676268,
0.1977802515,
0.2203821689,
0.5229097009,
0.3719265759,
-0.6061352491,
-0.696036458,
0.1323581487,
-1.3550589085,
-0.1754300892,
0.9655299783,
0.0399569087,
0.0076339394,
0.2701947689,
-0.3814414442,
0.0814324841,
-0.1336898506,
0.5830422044,
0.7309683561,
-0.0619530715,
-0.4259567261,
-1.2067716122,
0.1055764779,
0.2528221905,
-0.8027952909,
-0.1475001574,
0.7874765396,
0.3091391921,
-0.1962168217,
0.6591387391,
-0.1194811836,
0.424031198,
-0.0276736096,
-0.28680709,
-0.3697101474,
-0.6187004447,
-0.440842092,
0.608443439,
-0.252637893,
-0.2542486787
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.21070v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.21070v2
|
Generalization Beyond Data Imbalance: A Controlled Study on CLIP for Transferable Insights
| 2024-05-31T17:57:24 | 2024-06-14T16:42:47 |
Xin Wen, Bingchen Zhao, Yilun Chen, Jiangmiao Pang, Xiaojuan Qi
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Severe data imbalance naturally exists among web-scale vision-language
datasets. Despite this, we find CLIP pre-trained thereupon exhibits notable
robustness to the data imbalance compared to supervised learning, and
demonstrates significant effectiveness in learning generalizable
representations. With an aim to investigate the reasons behind this finding, we
conduct controlled experiments to study various underlying factors, and reveal
that CLIP's pretext task forms a dynamic classification problem wherein only a
subset of classes is present in training. This isolates the bias from dominant
classes and implicitly balances the learning signal. Furthermore, the
robustness and discriminability of CLIP improve with more descriptive language
supervision, larger data scale, and broader open-world concepts, which are
inaccessible to supervised learning. Our study not only uncovers the mechanisms
behind CLIP's generalizability beyond data imbalance but also provides
transferable insights for the research community. The findings are validated in
both supervised and self-supervised learning, enabling models trained on
imbalanced data to achieve CLIP-level performance on diverse recognition tasks.
Code and data are available at: https://github.com/CVMI-Lab/clip-beyond-tail.
|
[
-0.4383248389,
-0.6402089596,
0.2245366424,
0.3886284232,
-0.1592218578,
0.3753292859,
-0.221669808,
-0.5776638389,
0.5097274184,
0.2910608947,
-0.580904603,
-0.4158537388,
-0.6980448961,
0.0103150271,
-0.7432730794,
0.96944803,
-0.0455105938,
0.1084497571,
-0.4507210851,
-0.483378619,
-0.3719269633,
-1.0740659237,
-0.0603241622,
-0.0204133149,
0.058022067,
0.3857706189,
0.5013062954,
0.775767684,
0.5810952783,
0.1340514123,
0.2070224732,
0.0061237314,
-0.6470919251,
-0.3660505712,
-0.4979895353,
-0.8380775452,
-0.3969815373,
0.1541329324,
0.7457583547,
0.6050275564,
-0.1066650674,
0.0976315737,
0.408446908,
0.392632395,
-1.0170890093,
-0.0027525912,
-0.800437808,
0.1110706851,
-0.414545238,
-0.1139448881,
-0.2248376012,
-0.0948434621,
0.4409658909,
-0.8702146411,
0.5788607597,
-0.2293563038,
1.0411216021,
0.2631618977,
-0.2727687657,
-0.1397429407,
-0.8405375481,
1.1340281963,
-0.1484997123,
0.2215476185,
0.302485317,
0.4123269916,
0.3581514657,
-0.5978580117,
-0.2920298874,
0.1977022886,
0.3962576985,
0.131087482,
-0.3859506547,
-0.1741160303,
0.3903051913,
0.4044190049,
-0.0624591596,
0.1009815335,
-0.3159012198,
-0.3238835335,
0.3562830389,
0.2080065757,
0.3910653591,
0.3981196582,
-0.4012873769,
-0.5606296062,
-0.6354928613,
0.3735620975,
0.2298528403,
0.0156397056,
-0.1744093001,
0.3080329597,
-0.0081246877,
0.4380406439,
0.2144178301,
0.1441891938,
0.4499815702,
-0.513935864,
0.0949448571,
-0.1998691708,
0.499219954,
0.7120216489,
0.4828567803,
-0.1801101565,
0.1448773295,
0.1312712729,
0.5233151913,
-0.8365035653,
-0.4229899049,
-0.2373042703,
-0.2388188094,
-0.3825246692,
0.3607981205,
-0.8555773497,
0.0033593359,
-0.2293465137,
0.4683733582,
-0.1596481949,
-0.2862360477,
0.1262343675,
-0.2673870623,
0.201829195,
0.4048642814,
-1.0204731226,
0.3636521697,
0.4015563428,
0.9714258313,
-0.7338132262,
-0.402041465,
-0.3644665778,
0.2816039026,
-0.1717823893,
0.6551537514,
-0.5964627266,
-0.194089517,
0.0447392091,
0.1970748156,
-0.1381749213,
-0.7291371822,
0.3804537356,
-0.2314739972,
-0.0639886186,
-0.3371947408,
-0.3834740222,
-0.1637343615,
0.2506714165,
-0.56990242,
0.6316846013,
0.0273434743,
-0.8956774473,
0.8251115084,
-0.2182663679,
-0.3051984906,
-0.3010608554,
-0.3274461329,
-0.6220548153,
0.0998734087,
0.5331462622,
0.245199725,
0.1144378707,
0.1318898201,
-0.7711117268,
-0.3488315344,
0.3633402288,
-0.3158370256,
0.6050975919,
-0.1799911112,
-0.2884221375,
0.034234032,
-0.5960851908,
0.0858764648,
0.1908590943,
-0.0361654162,
-0.5948935747,
0.1490978748,
-0.0505500473,
-0.073243916,
-0.1030738577,
-0.540137291,
0.3479104936,
-0.1090885475,
0.5886498094,
0.5840696692,
-0.125483945,
0.5206917524,
-0.1358071566,
0.6223971844,
-0.0605974272,
0.322874248,
-0.0646063089,
-0.0745747685,
-0.4928961694,
-0.4934288859,
0.300127387,
0.7654080391,
-0.5119749308,
0.0893787295,
-0.2812656164,
-0.0816593319,
-0.3292329907,
0.1290852875,
0.2036445737,
0.5443024039,
0.709610045,
-0.589517653,
-0.5583811402,
-1.0103702545,
-0.1049860865,
0.2765191197,
-0.3130400777,
0.3078289032,
0.3364012241,
-0.527916491,
1.3653194904,
-0.7593891621,
-0.4414751232,
-0.2435293496,
0.179924801,
-0.0397851095,
0.6086249948,
1.0320968628,
-0.9313278198,
-0.2612596452,
-0.3813328743,
-0.770539999,
-0.2939181924,
-0.0758138373,
-0.1845208853,
-0.4363291264,
0.5546040535,
-0.0692743063,
0.6357553005,
0.4109510779,
0.0098590562,
0.5785948038,
-0.117127724,
0.0380731598,
-0.5472559929,
0.0163879748,
0.0287914239,
-0.3124447465,
-0.4267896414,
-0.2558513582,
0.2996386588,
-0.1251904964,
-0.4706721902,
0.0735397339,
-0.3132764101,
-0.0707873702,
-0.4841981232,
-0.1890746355,
0.2791080773,
0.4331524968,
0.0672333017,
0.9551183581,
0.6881229281,
-0.8416919708,
0.1399318874,
0.4021694362,
-0.1666911393,
0.5473872423,
-0.7329900265,
-0.1944511831,
0.1220506579,
0.1053168997,
-0.4323961735,
-0.2888634503,
0.1494597495,
-0.2771662474,
0.2997881472,
-0.2452650964,
-0.1960883886,
-0.3177687824,
-0.5993347168,
0.7839671969,
0.42463094,
-0.6234989762,
0.2091825008,
0.7529523969,
0.0792091563,
-0.5442074537,
-0.8931080699,
-0.2270888686,
-0.3416341841,
-0.2254589498,
0.5781075358,
-0.035379786,
-0.0191334002,
-0.0562542193,
-0.3176699579,
-0.4858963192,
0.1456967145,
0.1795784384,
0.3238116801,
-0.0188710205,
0.1168912947,
0.2137465179,
0.2679905295,
0.1829216629,
-0.2887669802,
0.3391575813,
-0.1193293482,
-0.3805746734,
-0.2256253511,
0.0789496973,
0.5358367562,
-0.2996538877,
0.5357910395,
0.4471411109,
-0.1185789853,
-0.267236203,
-0.3748061359,
0.0139570432,
-0.4382762909,
0.407687068,
-0.2127854973,
-0.9486094117,
0.5529813766,
-0.1303050518,
0.0158628263,
0.3772719204,
0.2753943205,
-0.1965223104,
1.0392054319,
1.021099925,
-0.127352491,
0.9095651507,
-0.411680311,
-0.3702703416,
-0.829656899,
-0.1286488175,
-0.1686789542,
-0.2122550458,
-0.2993546724,
-0.4394508898,
0.3021065891,
0.4227693677,
0.3201849461,
0.1794365793,
-0.5694108605,
0.6273450851,
0.4820159674,
0.3690954149,
0.1577228457,
0.0579866655,
0.0591608062,
-0.3279803097,
-0.5123339891,
-0.1382078081,
1.3413749933,
0.3890534937,
1.0811439753,
-0.2205729038,
0.2628433406,
0.667247355,
0.0277850404,
-0.749504149,
0.2545706332,
-0.4092616141,
-0.3395005465,
-0.1780102253,
-0.3166366816,
-0.8832233548,
0.4042892456,
-0.5130457878,
-0.5370814204,
0.3674489558,
0.6202723384,
0.0826914459,
0.315512687,
-0.6166198254,
0.6980090737,
-0.4306339622,
-0.523710072,
-0.3403779864,
-0.4934466481,
0.284278959,
-0.2481973469,
0.0878142267,
-0.1086177826,
-0.0229911637,
0.8044554591,
-0.5183432698,
0.9244514108,
-0.0763405487,
0.1439445019,
0.3920998573,
-0.2387720793,
0.1558294296,
-0.0653567016,
0.5905314088,
0.3546532691,
0.0782443956,
-0.6267110109,
-0.716909945,
0.2553764582,
-0.6878683567,
-0.4158110023,
-0.2434847802,
-0.4126821458,
-0.3596340418,
0.2300940305,
0.5701013207,
0.6033214927,
-0.2428691238,
0.3612035215,
0.8002634645,
-0.1229713336,
0.068456158,
0.3053868413,
-0.4356692433,
-0.4590342343,
1.1387345791,
0.2647932172,
0.35788697,
0.4205012321,
0.092338644,
-0.0204535332,
-0.6822934151,
-0.380710721,
-0.0377889276,
-0.5150923729,
0.0146761676,
-0.5432436466,
-0.0410065502,
-0.2693533003,
-0.1624453366,
-0.4207234085,
-0.4980748594,
-0.4800314903,
-0.2157416195,
0.0356432162,
0.5228916407,
-0.1606266946,
0.4047936201,
-0.730602324,
0.2609859705,
0.5412828922,
0.2115129828,
-0.1071826071,
-0.243445605,
-0.3852533996,
0.1198849007,
-0.43582654,
-0.6744120121,
0.2072417289,
0.5614529252,
0.7723947167,
0.5988118052,
0.0272532851,
0.6752130985,
-0.3895795643,
0.5095975399,
0.3904055953,
-1.2519718409,
0.6240952015,
-0.2754774392,
0.4010533988,
0.7205318809,
0.4397818148,
-0.039896097,
-0.5515868664,
-0.3408212662,
-0.9905757308,
0.6481724381,
0.137091592,
0.1784445196,
0.2128400058,
0.160170272,
0.270282954,
0.2520334125,
-0.6599178314,
0.0384112783,
-0.7641892433,
-0.1494521052,
0.0790199041,
-0.3045932353,
-0.0260962863,
-0.3995512128,
0.0920650288,
-0.2880253792,
0.0939893723,
0.3236352205,
-0.60738343,
0.2419440299,
0.0568895712,
0.5716296434,
0.896627605,
-0.3253563344,
0.1626205742,
0.2899646163,
-1.0216401815,
0.0267707426,
-0.1822661906,
-0.3908137381,
-0.0932897329,
0.6077334881,
0.7616581321,
0.3358629644,
-0.8633766174,
0.9649015665,
-0.0719580054,
-0.2629415989,
-0.1216346249,
0.1784094572,
-0.6879912615,
0.1050740033,
0.5421183109,
0.0614824444,
0.2350592762,
-0.5335502028,
0.4595983326,
0.5859593749,
-0.337463975,
-0.6943793893,
0.6682701111,
0.2565395534,
0.3597311676,
0.5088424683,
0.2111639827,
-0.8126737475,
0.5641591549,
0.4988336265,
0.6049213409,
-0.0101699587,
0.1856455058,
0.1938433349,
0.1773630828,
-0.224804312,
-0.1863304526,
-0.4637445807,
-0.8207701445,
-0.3605063856,
-0.276895225,
-0.845929563,
-0.1195043772,
-1.2179853916,
0.2462846637,
-0.630471766,
-0.3680746555,
-0.2103757113,
-0.5622346997,
-0.5219802856,
0.1304473281,
-0.0308083948,
0.7776087523,
-0.9096069336,
0.7941696644,
0.6567277908,
-0.303227514,
-0.382006079,
0.2586897612,
-0.2459032536,
-0.78049016,
0.5652197599,
0.4290081263,
-0.3614920974,
-0.3445366919,
-1.0643081665,
-0.9579251409,
0.8388233185,
0.4999843836,
-0.4140338898,
-0.1733753681,
0.0098271733,
0.4798088074,
-0.2580467165,
0.0052076224,
0.3575355411,
-0.1463613361,
0.1850753874,
-0.9959950447,
-0.3735659122,
-0.0388753489,
-0.2851688266,
0.1939788014,
-0.6479192972,
0.8987656832,
-0.0925719664,
-0.2765065134,
-0.3938368559,
0.6446276307,
-0.1535299122,
0.4913575053,
0.3788385391,
0.595982492,
0.7234742641,
0.0705533922,
0.7398486733,
0.1582418829,
0.4390370548,
1.1686372757,
-0.1047770977,
0.6009180546,
0.3490997255,
-0.3402113914,
0.4266073704,
0.2622453868,
-0.489708513,
0.8373669386,
0.144128561,
0.0218522418,
-0.4081861973,
-0.1630013585,
-0.3612584174,
0.4687476754,
0.3496403992,
-0.2021844387,
-0.1913181245,
0.6155040264,
-0.163909629,
0.0599290356,
-0.748595953,
0.5289963484,
-0.060726013,
-0.1960971206,
0.5072829723,
-0.4440481961,
1.0102046728,
-0.6866787672,
-0.1309559345,
0.1491030455,
0.3562774658,
-0.2979333997,
-0.9361096025,
0.566719532,
0.0508393385,
-0.4564457536,
-0.3710175157,
0.7497055531,
-0.2354604006,
-0.3366658688,
0.3046454191,
0.2017772496,
0.0831042454,
-0.2625787854,
-0.3541280627,
0.1439845264,
0.1473025084,
0.2351700515,
0.5638934374,
0.3315836489,
-0.3839626908,
0.8400139809,
0.338837266,
0.0458972678,
0.3440375924,
-0.2090619951,
0.9762316346,
-0.5666805506,
-0.5610303283,
-0.8086333275,
0.0407499112,
-0.1773546636,
-0.2406067252,
0.7884586453,
0.6193750501,
1.1070126295,
-0.3088004291,
0.7895526886,
0.15687868,
0.7107459307,
-0.6499373913,
0.4667550027,
-0.4796834886,
-0.0714747533,
-0.4421547055,
-0.7735946178,
-0.3393982053,
0.4418293834,
-0.4256314933,
-0.4440690279,
0.4913197756,
0.1008319855,
-0.293007642,
-0.2352576554,
0.1046108678,
-0.1557250619,
0.3398424685,
0.5644311309,
0.8670027852,
0.0694499388,
0.9283704758,
-0.2780024707,
-0.4442401528,
-0.2498108298,
-0.7076506019,
-1.0627727509,
-0.3286015987,
-0.3477948904,
-0.0332336798,
-0.0828410611,
0.5820713639,
0.8209459186,
-0.8785421848,
-0.1281940043,
-0.1063952073,
0.0896774381,
-0.1294348538,
-0.2384694368,
0.2513598204,
-0.12086045,
-0.6783280969,
0.140960753,
0.1344582886,
0.4000092745,
0.066596508,
0.40877226,
0.2632558942,
-0.1741191894,
0.5315296054,
0.7813260555,
-0.3346930444,
-0.1717046946,
0.0287269168,
0.1017747372,
0.34915784,
1.0964871645,
-0.8042653203,
0.4348948598,
0.3212011755,
0.8453994393,
0.6718237996,
0.4196741283,
0.7303313613,
-0.662913084,
0.3275108933,
0.1667757928,
0.2237184644,
0.1801478267,
-0.232115373,
0.4542907178,
0.4900427163,
-0.2829700112,
-0.7576031685,
0.3322939575,
-1.060238719,
-0.2070146948,
0.693338275,
-0.3258278072,
-0.0520936809,
0.0339504555,
-0.1744279861,
0.0962357596,
-0.2959411144,
0.6410593987,
0.6533273458,
-0.3457767367,
-0.0953923687,
-0.2751618028,
0.4576532841,
0.4900316894,
-0.7783753872,
-0.1146600097,
0.495349884,
0.4156413376,
0.1470357031,
0.400113672,
-0.0420451723,
0.1456867158,
-0.2082040459,
-0.0093438979,
-0.0904345512,
-0.4283756316,
-0.4076139033,
0.2563284636,
-0.0862382948,
-0.6726692915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.21068v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.21068v1
|
Code Pretraining Improves Entity Tracking Abilities of Language Models
| 2024-05-31T17:56:33 | 2024-05-31T17:56:33 |
Najoung Kim, Sebastian Schuster, Shubham Toshniwal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent work has provided indirect evidence that pretraining language models
on code improves the ability of models to track state changes of discourse
entities expressed in natural language. In this work, we systematically test
this claim by comparing pairs of language models on their entity tracking
performance. Critically, the pairs consist of base models and models trained on
top of these base models with additional code data. We extend this analysis to
additionally examine the effect of math training, another highly structured
data type, and alignment tuning, an important step for enhancing the usability
of models. We find clear evidence that models additionally trained on large
amounts of code outperform the base models. On the other hand, we find no
consistent benefit of additional math training or alignment tuning across
various model families.
|
[
-0.1901030838,
-0.4473451674,
0.3808869123,
0.009509393,
-0.2205833346,
0.2145110965,
-0.1875370145,
-0.5770465136,
0.1418647468,
0.5703749061,
-0.0521401539,
-0.4466915727,
-0.3980920315,
-0.1438245475,
-0.5212986469,
1.1596804857,
0.0020317675,
0.3463827968,
-0.3108371794,
-0.1372727156,
-0.4652569592,
-1.0060893297,
-0.2973357141,
-0.3172774911,
0.3509138227,
-0.0877838954,
0.9863695502,
0.8230633736,
0.7827342749,
0.3240294158,
0.1796102822,
-0.2360310853,
-0.5086515546,
0.0394407138,
-0.0588307269,
-0.8468777537,
-0.6225355268,
0.0163954515,
0.6561632156,
0.8289033771,
-0.3814571798,
0.25823313,
-0.0232196525,
0.6701803207,
-0.8149734139,
0.0827238932,
-0.5374931097,
-0.2484697253,
-0.4316472411,
-0.3097515702,
-0.51037395,
-0.5350681543,
0.2915572822,
-0.8084058166,
0.127675429,
0.1843966395,
1.1811640263,
0.4158869386,
-0.478872776,
-0.3717051148,
-0.6310743093,
0.631241858,
-0.7129760385,
0.6749952435,
0.4195035994,
-0.2192074358,
0.0856902078,
-0.7327032089,
-0.3168487251,
-0.3632019758,
-0.2022087574,
-0.0705521479,
-0.1324089766,
0.1648937613,
0.7311000228,
0.419463098,
-0.4879300296,
0.107373029,
-0.1565113664,
-0.3059535325,
0.3991768658,
-0.0439847745,
0.7134830356,
0.0752170384,
-0.0972468928,
-0.0843265951,
-0.9256316423,
0.1236695796,
0.6545550227,
0.0484163873,
-0.0997646004,
0.5205314159,
0.1112190336,
0.9489409924,
-0.2241051197,
-0.0299234744,
0.2255978435,
-0.4928252101,
-0.2589315176,
-0.1122533083,
0.3733062148,
0.1858119667,
0.7048605084,
-0.237658903,
-0.263171941,
0.4855875969,
0.4246267974,
-0.8707663417,
-0.6720373034,
-0.4680044055,
-0.4566852748,
-0.1270059794,
0.1328040957,
-0.2927160561,
0.043232765,
-0.8923734426,
0.1501277387,
-0.4658123255,
-0.4258791208,
0.2923224568,
0.1041203737,
0.1877757311,
0.2028628141,
-1.0507196188,
0.3759021461,
1.0411263704,
0.7950720191,
-0.1488213837,
-0.0665947199,
-0.6386888027,
-0.0085077621,
-0.5828366876,
0.8632437587,
-0.7639330626,
-0.0923835561,
-0.0144350966,
-0.3212048709,
-0.1888550967,
-0.5270628929,
0.2417613715,
-0.741266191,
0.0674939081,
-0.2268058956,
-0.8520335555,
0.1059703454,
-0.1152419001,
-0.7913199663,
1.0468786955,
0.1287454665,
-0.7865328789,
0.6061625481,
-0.4383113086,
-0.4830195606,
-0.1086105481,
-0.2385921031,
-0.6278105974,
0.4465865493,
0.0459054559,
-0.0437300913,
0.0030647686,
0.4587771595,
-0.5343937874,
-0.5818360448,
0.2244264483,
0.0461725406,
0.7504938841,
0.063985616,
-0.1889379025,
-0.085015893,
-0.7480510473,
0.1874737442,
-0.1223450899,
-0.5740056634,
-0.7079675198,
0.0687683821,
-0.1529183984,
0.135570839,
-0.1444739997,
-0.2490819842,
0.378623873,
-0.4196400642,
0.0124550182,
0.5598505139,
-0.1862424612,
0.8213341832,
-0.1404185891,
0.7363451719,
-0.1303203702,
-0.2921171784,
-0.4539148211,
-0.3291694522,
-0.8304774761,
-0.0450289138,
0.8983561993,
0.4975225031,
-0.6853621602,
0.3412259519,
-0.3893688917,
-0.1318423599,
-0.6733927727,
0.2478472143,
0.8199359775,
0.3851310909,
0.3753815889,
-0.6932002902,
-0.7821171284,
-0.5523756146,
-0.6930752993,
-0.1645605713,
-0.1313591152,
0.1128729358,
0.5986379385,
0.1677112132,
0.8194282055,
-0.5250777602,
0.1645266861,
0.0453134961,
0.1317760944,
-0.2574414611,
0.8146488667,
0.8198623657,
-0.5326558352,
-0.5261507034,
-0.3113101423,
-0.6145368218,
-0.1293015629,
0.1603515893,
-0.4762180746,
0.2542255819,
0.3611029983,
-0.4383506179,
0.7507986426,
0.5125801563,
-0.3855818808,
0.2975953221,
-0.0705848634,
0.1809898168,
-0.8475548625,
0.1205978617,
-0.0895015821,
-0.3391779065,
-0.762819171,
-0.0339187831,
0.3236146867,
-0.183602944,
-0.2392809391,
0.2102943063,
-0.721333921,
-0.4742474556,
-0.1595564932,
-0.1327042282,
-0.0360748172,
0.4097264111,
0.2710181475,
0.9463862777,
0.5722234249,
-0.7218117118,
0.0277771428,
0.1540966779,
-0.7294928432,
0.5340504646,
-0.6677656174,
0.5381743312,
-0.0380190723,
0.108542189,
-0.7728438973,
-0.0187409092,
-0.2467996478,
-0.5343143344,
0.5126928687,
-0.3430707157,
-0.3807046115,
-0.0859809816,
-0.050203301,
0.2728933096,
0.4343836308,
-0.3564490378,
0.5159450173,
0.5110548735,
0.1331548393,
-0.5365635157,
-0.6152380705,
-0.1328707188,
-0.1170897335,
-0.5130268931,
0.2717592418,
-0.0326711275,
-0.3624590039,
0.0383806005,
-0.3853131831,
-0.3085158169,
0.5518690944,
0.0921996608,
0.5387061834,
-0.6904137731,
0.3467598557,
-0.160472244,
-0.3142910302,
0.1869514883,
-0.476995945,
0.5629046559,
0.1009696871,
-0.3111224771,
-0.4872139394,
0.1637034714,
-0.0248038806,
-0.615778029,
0.9037826061,
0.1792942584,
-0.446182251,
0.0519223213,
-0.4697107375,
-0.0239585675,
-0.456458807,
0.3303954899,
-0.4427824318,
-0.9054220915,
0.1582421958,
-0.0065176473,
0.1115704626,
0.2028158754,
0.2245809734,
-0.1846122295,
1.3930324316,
1.0483107567,
-0.196627453,
0.882088542,
-0.034623757,
0.1898291409,
-0.6035030484,
0.0584258214,
-0.9653843045,
-0.1137380227,
-0.5630844235,
-0.1443268955,
-0.0833741501,
0.4230757952,
-0.2253674716,
0.522066772,
-0.2668224573,
0.7756409049,
0.4500600696,
-0.1040885597,
0.4522441626,
0.0761883631,
0.0426334739,
-0.359857291,
-0.5091533065,
-0.553540647,
1.3758080006,
0.1255515516,
1.035562396,
0.1739936918,
0.6119892001,
-0.141117394,
0.6768339276,
-0.3590288758,
0.1384096295,
-0.084697634,
-0.7319700718,
-0.0654580221,
-0.6267474294,
-0.6967226863,
0.1226700544,
-0.3384753764,
-0.6548625827,
-0.0239095464,
0.6373330951,
-0.4187548459,
0.1510520726,
-0.8780745268,
0.8640531301,
-0.4780137241,
-0.1599322408,
-0.201610744,
-0.3659390807,
0.261790663,
-0.1318520308,
0.0252241772,
-0.0280888304,
-0.0010208352,
0.8454959393,
-0.2989982367,
0.5000289083,
-0.1552239805,
-0.2019862682,
0.1742729545,
0.1742119789,
0.3663709462,
0.1070809737,
0.0593438558,
0.0506078675,
-0.1084679067,
-0.5059575438,
-0.7260630727,
0.5781128407,
-0.5989637375,
-0.543268621,
-0.1834297329,
-0.4590044618,
-0.2459982038,
0.2952413857,
0.3083834946,
0.5491737723,
-0.0259662196,
0.3395917118,
0.925080359,
0.0100716995,
0.3970560133,
0.5652399063,
-0.5273275375,
-0.1014751345,
0.482019484,
0.166901961,
0.4236154258,
0.4829796553,
-0.3752978444,
-0.1955984831,
-0.372771889,
-0.379920274,
0.2198471427,
-0.4786807597,
-0.2458615601,
-0.7004007697,
0.0329544879,
-0.5403718948,
0.0391017124,
-0.5305204391,
-0.4496968091,
-0.2033582032,
-0.1264988631,
-0.0263672899,
0.7583923936,
0.3787077963,
0.4803692102,
-0.6495547295,
0.1321707368,
0.1640563607,
0.6452998519,
-0.1918123513,
-0.4725512564,
-0.5007355213,
0.1447765231,
-0.1367449015,
-0.8382508159,
0.1414431781,
0.2167501897,
0.4066205919,
0.1764163077,
-0.4399426579,
1.0887646675,
-0.5292651653,
0.4910801351,
0.2998564541,
-1.389567852,
0.6575053334,
-0.0846862942,
0.4120486975,
0.5718505383,
0.4181114733,
-0.1922827959,
-0.2625246942,
-0.4658637643,
-0.2726362646,
0.7319839001,
0.2709677517,
0.1360519677,
0.2653444111,
0.5083992481,
-0.2599320114,
0.3898051679,
-0.7758443952,
-0.424972266,
-0.1036891937,
-0.0799539238,
-0.2111667097,
-0.2609392107,
0.1307227612,
-0.3692747355,
0.4567523003,
-0.1221649349,
0.1732386351,
-0.1969794929,
-0.672953546,
-0.2569417655,
0.001402647,
0.5714085102,
1.0406423807,
0.1024011075,
0.0951059014,
0.1389887929,
-0.4623079896,
0.0994528905,
-0.0129912859,
-0.3181729019,
0.1525846571,
0.6407646537,
0.977986753,
0.6419795156,
-0.3642295599,
0.5131840706,
-0.0362816378,
-0.0793126374,
-0.1424856484,
0.3647680879,
0.2499036044,
-0.1876472384,
-0.0963485315,
0.3184015155,
0.0773188174,
-0.569701612,
0.269954592,
0.3601159751,
-0.3332182467,
-0.6854246259,
0.6250252128,
0.0872579068,
-0.6068166494,
0.6985675693,
0.0761511475,
-0.6320203543,
0.7244936228,
0.7754423618,
0.3986433148,
-0.5831528902,
-0.0716306791,
0.3620928824,
0.2931551039,
-0.1325989068,
0.1585878283,
-0.1625784039,
-0.7638267875,
-0.7614045739,
-0.4862125218,
-0.0966264158,
-0.1690357029,
-0.9996144176,
0.3454352617,
-0.2041392922,
-0.2765336335,
0.1314868927,
-0.0206728037,
-0.8795490861,
0.2144606113,
0.40741238,
0.8045438528,
-0.7230810523,
1.2221970558,
0.9605582356,
-0.4338083863,
-1.084933877,
-0.0399902165,
-0.1286735237,
-0.6265187263,
0.593087852,
0.2698838413,
-0.0687205791,
0.1653444618,
-0.6658509374,
-1.3797997236,
0.6872654557,
0.718558073,
-0.7590448856,
-0.3180688918,
-0.0530190989,
0.7876193523,
-0.4752486646,
0.4200617969,
0.7836549282,
0.0582519732,
-0.3201651275,
-1.0719050169,
-0.3349846303,
-0.2671079934,
0.2552238107,
0.6019953489,
-0.199303329,
0.8591111302,
-0.1434648335,
-0.4505068958,
-0.1201546267,
0.8296203613,
0.0210047774,
0.1650087833,
0.654882133,
0.915276289,
0.9906604886,
-0.235830307,
1.0538048744,
-0.5205562115,
0.5001692176,
1.3261560202,
-0.5412378311,
0.6946238875,
0.1893122792,
-0.1995891482,
0.8915619254,
0.316950351,
0.1731886119,
0.3974853754,
0.3490441144,
0.0255347658,
-0.4210575521,
-0.0296404324,
-0.7019056678,
0.3092515469,
0.1103430986,
-0.2652417719,
0.0649331808,
-0.0282407105,
0.2515830696,
0.2438199818,
-0.2749769092,
0.7681979537,
0.1474687755,
-1.1213798523,
0.2623578012,
-0.2237651199,
0.5684500933,
-0.4708117843,
-0.11094933,
-0.2649995983,
0.2376855463,
-0.1933974326,
-0.4002785087,
0.3430812061,
0.2772652209,
-0.0073655727,
-0.2206847221,
0.7892260551,
-0.3755797744,
-0.1953691393,
0.3831827044,
0.4552132189,
-0.1082102507,
0.037133649,
-0.7015637755,
0.0178037006,
0.0520345718,
-0.3784381747,
0.4217320085,
0.1515389681,
-0.0668830648,
0.5718474984,
0.9787974358,
0.1080590934,
0.325020045,
0.1787241995,
0.8941645622,
-0.6274780631,
-0.6629483104,
-0.9752343297,
0.4106268585,
-0.1947927922,
-0.3722830415,
0.6483089924,
0.9072383046,
1.1698535681,
0.1128590852,
0.3351269662,
0.1002392918,
0.5565455556,
-0.7392446995,
0.4141052067,
-0.1548903137,
0.4417746365,
-0.2867764533,
-1.1108158827,
-0.3308856785,
0.6247550845,
-0.4352332354,
0.0659022853,
0.8473242521,
0.574331522,
-0.1582850665,
0.0035586972,
0.1466920972,
-0.1634859741,
0.2227624506,
0.3489966094,
0.9974531531,
-0.3508923352,
0.4144900143,
-0.3986073136,
0.0106615694,
0.1773978025,
-0.7276709676,
-1.0610288382,
-0.330760926,
-0.4165002704,
-0.425005883,
0.037909884,
0.6989631653,
1.0332692862,
-0.9207177758,
-0.2119822651,
-0.1186433882,
0.085505262,
0.0937324986,
-0.1412027627,
0.1709333807,
-0.5031249523,
-0.592061162,
0.0736656263,
0.1753781438,
0.0965200812,
0.0437606648,
-0.0897935331,
-0.3123791814,
0.1386332959,
0.2869681716,
0.0724628568,
-0.4051945806,
-0.2500977218,
0.2894513905,
-0.3938496411,
0.2316065729,
1.3660997152,
-0.7014086246,
0.298299253,
0.3985571563,
0.5940983295,
0.4572894871,
0.3062302768,
0.7389312983,
-0.6410816312,
0.2581808567,
0.023545213,
0.4877637625,
0.238769114,
-0.3145400882,
0.6544226408,
0.2018731236,
-0.5888403058,
-1.0313899517,
0.2408313751,
-0.3714259565,
0.0525135696,
0.6955680847,
-0.574278295,
-0.1248997003,
-0.0700908229,
0.1756893396,
0.3950520158,
-0.1398850828,
0.5178571343,
0.8877919912,
0.0201716553,
0.0786296651,
-0.5923396349,
0.7708714008,
0.7634296417,
-0.9467945695,
-0.3194659948,
0.4343087673,
0.3926739991,
0.1695492864,
0.7854280472,
0.0922616199,
0.3517664373,
-0.1815733761,
0.140520975,
0.1604238302,
-0.380333215,
-0.5860247016,
-0.1768231243,
0.0500617474,
0.0587082841
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.21047v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.21047v1
|
Grammar-Aligned Decoding
| 2024-05-31T17:39:15 | 2024-05-31T17:39:15 |
Kanghee Park, Jiayu Wang, Taylor Berg-Kirkpatrick, Nadia Polikarpova, Loris D'Antoni
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) struggle with reliably generating highly
structured outputs, such as program code, mathematical formulas, or well-formed
markup. Constrained decoding approaches mitigate this problem by greedily
restricting what tokens an LLM can output at each step to guarantee that the
output matches a given constraint. Specifically, in grammar-constrained
decoding (GCD), the LLM's output must follow a given grammar. In this paper we
demonstrate that GCD techniques (and in general constrained decoding
techniques) can distort the LLM's distribution, leading to outputs that are
grammatical but appear with likelihoods that are not proportional to the ones
given by the LLM, and so ultimately are low-quality. We call the problem of
aligning sampling with a grammar constraint, grammar-aligned decoding (GAD),
and propose adaptive sampling with approximate expected futures (ASAp), a
decoding algorithm that guarantees the output to be grammatical while provably
producing outputs that match the conditional probability of the LLM's
distribution conditioned on the given grammar constraint. Our algorithm uses
prior sample outputs to soundly overapproximate the future grammaticality of
different output prefixes. Our evaluation on code generation and structured NLP
tasks shows how ASAp often produces outputs with higher likelihood (according
to the LLM's distribution) than existing GCD techniques, while still enforcing
the desired grammatical constraints.
|
[
-0.0258938614,
-0.5887691975,
0.6275026798,
0.2386535406,
-0.1824516654,
-0.0028484107,
-0.2106605917,
-0.2787009478,
0.2850888371,
0.2580405176,
-0.8869819641,
-0.5642403364,
-0.5017787218,
0.1474871933,
-0.3271401227,
0.7248456478,
0.0427134372,
-0.0607473813,
-0.5712988377,
0.2032575607,
-0.4837603569,
-0.8267966509,
-0.3199536502,
-0.1648096144,
-0.1981011331,
0.3117064834,
0.8538741469,
1.020362258,
0.400370717,
0.3158147931,
-0.0466371179,
0.2592497766,
-0.4413099885,
0.0778303146,
-0.0739183724,
-0.2371703237,
-0.4555004239,
-0.0218655933,
0.7461076379,
0.7159605622,
-0.3274766505,
0.0293537993,
0.1695101559,
0.4656667411,
-0.9170476198,
0.2494449168,
-0.4228209555,
-0.0788077265,
-0.1781473011,
-0.1843987852,
-0.6467072368,
-0.2420839518,
-0.689822197,
-0.739736259,
0.0876612738,
-0.0556280725,
0.9635075331,
0.5024043322,
-0.3026303053,
-0.5967059135,
-0.7580064535,
0.8167857528,
-0.7399069071,
0.149116382,
0.5170488358,
0.1036092341,
-0.3918750286,
-0.4112936258,
-0.5131469369,
0.3276304305,
-0.0844352394,
0.1809153706,
-0.1470401883,
0.3002407253,
0.2303424478,
0.4683718383,
-0.5794867873,
0.173048377,
-0.0890100896,
-0.2015779316,
0.5126006007,
0.1362340599,
0.080090031,
-0.3869622946,
-0.1352244616,
-0.2645376921,
-0.5663201213,
-0.0253790095,
0.7010739446,
0.2544437051,
-0.0060461042,
0.735901475,
-0.270106405,
0.8309525847,
0.3739766479,
0.0289508663,
0.0174703859,
-0.4230661988,
-0.4999120235,
-0.075996995,
0.4430506229,
0.4245122075,
0.0102636451,
0.0087718396,
-0.2431590408,
0.5406748652,
0.1405523866,
-0.4446720481,
-0.2274994552,
0.3396885693,
-0.2504039109,
-0.1330085695,
0.0608408228,
-0.7398725748,
-0.033858221,
-0.1423621774,
0.181487754,
-0.4111558199,
0.2752224505,
0.2887206376,
-0.0030599833,
0.1881610751,
-0.1255784929,
-1.385609746,
0.437268883,
0.7338702679,
0.6412183046,
0.2641733885,
0.0104212789,
-0.9659280777,
0.2988946438,
-0.403385818,
0.6169461012,
-0.7482950687,
-0.1792097092,
0.1727790534,
-0.2488196939,
-0.123370856,
-0.388510257,
0.671102643,
-0.5395159125,
-0.1672786176,
-0.244761318,
-0.6602179408,
0.2056582272,
0.0950957015,
-0.5476322174,
0.6577650309,
0.2515361309,
-0.4469406009,
0.4207129478,
0.1194001809,
-0.3363437653,
-0.1932447106,
-0.3340891004,
-0.4169160426,
0.3640418947,
0.7283684611,
0.3063577116,
0.0678090528,
0.3732566833,
-0.332867831,
-0.2969435453,
0.0684408024,
-0.357730329,
0.7226667404,
0.5574815273,
0.1190024391,
0.0305550974,
-0.7581570745,
0.3942784965,
-0.0692895129,
-0.5504523516,
-0.2204927653,
0.4219169915,
-0.1763091087,
0.0349746868,
0.0474808849,
-0.3367654383,
0.4327637553,
-0.5400966406,
0.5854642987,
0.938798666,
-0.1650044173,
0.7461207509,
-0.5485682487,
0.7761133909,
-0.2646808028,
-0.0004865892,
-0.1285474449,
-0.0776446089,
-0.5342153907,
-0.2536155879,
0.2855375111,
0.4987281561,
-0.7769120932,
0.6449956298,
-0.4751045406,
0.0626378357,
-0.6632739305,
0.3089232147,
0.4004898369,
0.2704099417,
0.247350812,
-0.2303506136,
-0.7868416309,
-0.7314554453,
-0.1102614254,
-0.1675325781,
0.0193158779,
-0.1039414331,
0.0207149219,
-0.0053739864,
0.8648807406,
-0.4367897809,
-0.4221223891,
-0.2722860277,
-0.0953124836,
0.383552283,
0.6819162965,
0.4331529737,
-0.4857574403,
-0.3238499165,
-0.2062717974,
-0.357929796,
-0.425162226,
-0.3174340129,
-0.2028466612,
0.3942175806,
0.8046838641,
-0.6277333498,
0.1730095148,
0.9919681549,
-0.4518030882,
0.4166933298,
-0.2861685455,
-0.1190698072,
-1.0430686474,
-0.2013551146,
-0.3340632319,
-0.400108546,
-0.3950537741,
0.5400722027,
0.2133029699,
-0.1112312526,
0.104807511,
0.1368674785,
-0.810598135,
-0.1423257291,
-0.1787265539,
-0.1722508222,
0.0987304822,
0.3371170759,
0.0387311876,
0.7268229127,
0.2356896102,
-0.4434330165,
0.2582405508,
0.402346164,
-0.4102467299,
0.4806485772,
-0.3492390215,
0.1232144907,
-0.2484661639,
0.3658067882,
-0.9258253574,
-0.406050384,
0.1415039301,
-0.3990410566,
0.3995568454,
-0.2010255456,
-0.4345874488,
-0.1862652898,
-0.1626850665,
0.6267317533,
0.868257165,
-0.6597284079,
0.5169866085,
0.1136532053,
-0.0716723576,
-0.7561491132,
-0.7643148899,
-0.0608526506,
-0.0465987623,
-0.5865789652,
0.4362133741,
0.1005596593,
-0.3363666236,
0.3388929665,
-0.1344503909,
0.2153559327,
-0.0660991892,
0.161504209,
0.0925174281,
-0.2356403023,
-0.0450786613,
0.2366567701,
-0.0049831108,
0.0933246017,
-0.6160796881,
0.6380648017,
0.3210128248,
-0.7930001616,
-0.095051907,
0.6406615376,
0.2821632922,
-0.0473816246,
0.4811998904,
0.1754137874,
-0.3582364619,
-0.4641416371,
-0.3026521504,
0.1513503939,
-0.5300675631,
0.2947230637,
-0.3461453617,
-0.4686286449,
0.5571189523,
0.3263417482,
0.0513435528,
0.3514952958,
0.3736101687,
-0.0005809129,
1.0051081181,
0.6760649681,
-0.1098463908,
0.2836883366,
0.0373362862,
0.1973750293,
-0.7150385976,
-0.0276837051,
-0.5528869033,
-0.5423454642,
-0.2868101597,
-0.4676935673,
-0.0771133676,
0.3269658983,
0.1728867739,
0.0085736979,
-0.3576946855,
0.6526566744,
0.9170775414,
0.0043644011,
0.1650941074,
0.101351656,
-0.1767148376,
-0.0998863429,
-0.9375580549,
-0.2895104587,
1.0463495255,
-0.0273746829,
0.989521265,
0.2834731936,
0.895391643,
0.1280619502,
0.0127117829,
-0.6401491761,
0.4777211845,
-0.3887730837,
-0.3275657892,
-0.0501288585,
-0.4070876539,
-0.6802541614,
-0.1278209686,
-0.2912227809,
-0.5998767614,
0.4492433071,
0.4920616448,
-0.4059445262,
0.1512647718,
-0.8738254309,
0.5948026776,
0.1158828586,
-0.3443363011,
0.1137826443,
-0.4187501073,
0.3875215948,
0.1701168716,
0.3555259705,
0.0118028698,
0.231014654,
0.1818346083,
-0.658772409,
0.8435183167,
-0.2165173143,
-0.0472268909,
0.3028900623,
0.107196413,
0.7691118717,
0.0316838659,
0.0416437387,
-0.5083126426,
-0.0783609152,
-0.7378469706,
-0.4822028875,
0.7297241092,
-0.6448821425,
-0.8569763303,
-0.6106284857,
-0.964150548,
-0.2853633463,
-0.0695857927,
0.6117765903,
0.3762150705,
-0.2105157673,
-0.1148666739,
0.2433687001,
-0.1291139573,
0.4537093341,
-0.1549204886,
-0.1443617642,
-0.4002003372,
0.7284726501,
-0.0281673521,
0.7266986966,
0.5003715158,
-0.1212528348,
-0.3890299797,
-0.7400224805,
-0.4011103809,
-0.0519007482,
-0.9746592045,
-0.4273654222,
-0.1744575948,
-0.195459038,
-0.8748605847,
-0.5591880679,
-0.0541099757,
-0.45822981,
-0.4188122749,
-0.1566876769,
0.0950611159,
0.4193214178,
-0.2850339115,
0.4020218849,
-0.6415088773,
0.2482374758,
0.212738663,
0.0933566391,
-0.2738797665,
-0.433488518,
-0.0255777054,
0.1502373517,
-0.2108411938,
-0.7854261994,
0.5761958361,
0.4512376189,
0.1687964797,
0.5138727427,
0.4060181975,
1.0312070847,
-0.5490272641,
0.4743805528,
-0.0795153677,
-1.1132560968,
0.2187256068,
-0.2778616846,
0.5393368602,
0.3695144355,
-0.075393334,
-0.4477603436,
-0.6726953387,
-0.4714830518,
-0.8006805182,
0.6282562017,
0.1415259093,
0.2868959308,
-0.3111162782,
0.4190430343,
-0.1444066167,
-0.148118645,
-0.7558151484,
0.154312402,
-0.1661745161,
-0.7500241399,
-0.3882395029,
-0.5062090755,
-0.1183169708,
0.1474298388,
0.7138102055,
-0.2180918753,
0.3377394676,
0.2450910658,
-0.208117038,
-0.1568366587,
0.4881229401,
0.6883009672,
0.4390968084,
-0.1504066288,
0.2671281993,
-0.2956312895,
-0.4338328838,
0.383593142,
0.2300125957,
-0.3517964482,
-0.0932492688,
0.4692850411,
0.5433965325,
-0.2050448209,
-0.6867589951,
0.3851682842,
0.210941717,
-0.3367294967,
-0.3066146374,
0.0938390195,
0.1369308382,
0.2625555992,
0.3761835396,
0.0875423923,
-0.1083410755,
-0.4023429453,
0.063202709,
0.7814370394,
0.1154620424,
-0.2225686759,
0.9740284085,
0.008891806,
-0.0446306877,
0.9796620011,
-0.4835903347,
-0.2051399648,
0.7409951091,
1.0690587759,
0.6283314228,
-0.1155555248,
0.0462515727,
0.2877267003,
0.4300740361,
-0.125846833,
0.4409095049,
0.1339937299,
-0.832772553,
-0.9876354933,
-0.8563483357,
-0.0863423273,
0.0755274594,
-0.9078552127,
0.317233175,
-0.6042046547,
-0.0058402107,
-0.3411296308,
-0.2795738876,
-0.238402307,
0.0432803556,
0.0254420098,
0.6858544946,
-1.0568886995,
0.8555446863,
0.547442019,
-0.0547608472,
-0.8706222177,
-0.0120915854,
0.2656439841,
-0.849180162,
0.2937000692,
-0.0001573048,
0.0747507438,
0.1892481446,
-0.4795425534,
-0.9851135612,
0.8368153572,
0.7594900727,
-0.6473938823,
-0.2450045049,
0.0182757769,
0.2213227451,
-0.1422887146,
-0.4549609423,
0.4276078045,
0.2479705811,
0.1462856531,
-0.6113700867,
0.1160802692,
-0.4547832608,
-0.012948826,
0.5283276439,
-0.2798703313,
0.8571658731,
-0.3064258397,
-0.7319212556,
0.53770715,
0.8309366703,
0.3594869077,
0.0681455955,
0.2040994018,
0.8824703693,
0.6677439213,
-0.2891249061,
1.1914463043,
0.0232346803,
0.29018718,
1.1454668045,
-0.1657220572,
0.7706900835,
0.8000737429,
-0.2529655695,
0.1697885841,
0.6178988814,
-0.0054952293,
0.7232698798,
0.2780281901,
-0.1323890835,
-0.2635297775,
0.0427927822,
-0.2768630087,
0.2452842891,
0.4475488961,
-0.2662634254,
-0.0955606177,
-0.1097972691,
-0.1887458265,
0.766320169,
-0.3911812007,
0.5320654511,
-0.1514232457,
-0.7776820064,
0.8232635856,
0.2551905811,
0.6091058254,
-0.4767256081,
0.0584567338,
-0.3766103983,
0.3498901725,
-0.2914817035,
-0.3450901806,
0.634785533,
-0.199115172,
-0.2823419869,
-0.3266513646,
0.3938878179,
-0.592315495,
-0.6697664261,
-0.0266262442,
0.1955821514,
-0.149120748,
0.2017081976,
-0.0231866352,
0.2343340218,
0.0193857495,
0.0338618122,
0.3491093516,
0.3735072613,
0.045699995,
0.4290164113,
0.5545542836,
0.4046998918,
0.4939909875,
-0.2413888574,
0.6799435616,
-0.3094634414,
-0.8081439734,
-0.8498268723,
0.0816042051,
0.2018681169,
-0.1467645019,
0.6157405972,
0.414702028,
1.1390398741,
-0.2049813867,
0.5791840553,
-0.1442639977,
0.1188708171,
-1.1860113144,
0.1997905225,
-0.3303141892,
0.3736646473,
-0.2849831879,
-0.9384494424,
-0.5028205514,
0.6455494761,
-0.1301551759,
-0.0691731498,
0.6053180695,
0.6304627061,
-0.2089894265,
-0.3549916148,
0.2076653391,
-0.0570263565,
0.2711613476,
1.0188890696,
0.7313713431,
-0.2184553891,
0.6727952361,
-0.2580707371,
0.0152078206,
-0.0221646857,
-1.0026165247,
-0.4930207133,
-0.5256542563,
-0.0972054377,
-0.3600317538,
0.1585611999,
0.8040733933,
0.6086977124,
-0.7106509805,
-0.2172546685,
-0.411880523,
-0.0654590726,
-0.7135153413,
-0.1483163685,
0.4377474189,
-0.4817854464,
-1.2480156422,
0.269736439,
-0.0159518477,
0.179424271,
0.1204823628,
-0.2869265974,
-0.2338840067,
0.0329146124,
0.2516207099,
0.3280844092,
-0.6820740104,
-0.4694389403,
0.1652504951,
-0.0717518628,
0.0564909577,
0.7069540024,
-0.6991311908,
0.3164936602,
0.4543269873,
0.9607431889,
0.1030988246,
0.4815252423,
0.9072558284,
-1.3833520412,
0.3528583348,
0.2482272685,
0.3481290042,
0.1583652347,
-0.5347041488,
0.1831691265,
0.0540992208,
-0.5103095174,
-0.7644209862,
0.5437357426,
-0.8324217796,
-0.499561727,
1.3274433613,
-0.0380726643,
-0.2032937557,
0.0679324865,
0.2218334526,
-0.0277390461,
-0.2779719234,
0.6126847267,
1.1209850311,
0.0374986865,
-0.0790698826,
-0.3097595572,
0.537433207,
0.7298395038,
-0.5404863954,
0.2080455273,
1.0801409483,
-0.0496011935,
0.1293803155,
0.7475333214,
-0.0576551817,
0.2979564965,
0.0534726419,
-0.0570264719,
-0.1650292128,
-0.18722637,
-0.6138620973,
0.2379652858,
0.2587415576,
-0.3530130982
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.21046v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.21046v1
|
Exploratory Preference Optimization: Harnessing Implicit Q*-Approximation for Sample-Efficient RLHF
| 2024-05-31T17:39:06 | 2024-05-31T17:39:06 |
Tengyang Xie, Dylan J. Foster, Akshay Krishnamurthy, Corby Rosset, Ahmed Awadallah, Alexander Rakhlin
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
Reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) has emerged as a central
tool for language model alignment. We consider online exploration in RLHF,
which exploits interactive access to human or AI feedback by deliberately
encouraging the model to produce diverse, maximally informative responses. By
allowing RLHF to confidently stray from the pre-trained model, online
exploration offers the possibility of novel, potentially super-human
capabilities, but its full potential as a paradigm for language model training
has yet to be realized, owing to computational and statistical bottlenecks in
directly adapting existing reinforcement learning techniques. We propose a new
algorithm for online exploration in RLHF, Exploratory Preference Optimization
(XPO), which is simple and practical -- a one-line change to (online) Direct
Preference Optimization (DPO; Rafailov et al., 2023) -- yet enjoys the
strongest known provable guarantees and promising empirical performance. XPO
augments the DPO objective with a novel and principled exploration bonus,
empowering the algorithm to explore outside the support of the initial model
and human feedback data. In theory, we show that XPO is provably
sample-efficient and converges to a near-optimal language model policy under
natural exploration conditions, irrespective of whether the initial model has
good coverage. Our analysis, which builds on the observation that DPO
implicitly performs a form of $Q^{\star}$-approximation (or, Bellman error
minimization), combines previously disparate techniques from language modeling
and theoretical reinforcement learning in a serendipitous fashion through the
perspective of KL-regularized Markov decision processes. Empirically, we find
that XPO is more sample-efficient than non-exploratory DPO variants in a
preliminary evaluation.
|
[
-0.3627065718,
-0.6476334333,
0.6787730455,
-0.0399410278,
0.0679028481,
0.2279213369,
-0.4963782728,
-0.415330559,
0.0818675235,
0.2876881659,
-0.9471581578,
-0.3279797137,
-0.2512499094,
-0.0949970111,
0.1225586683,
0.8779373765,
-0.0738854483,
-0.0816537216,
-0.0751678646,
-0.0428891182,
-0.0496493578,
-0.4462557733,
-0.5444686413,
-0.2553795874,
0.4939539135,
0.3798823655,
0.8671208024,
0.7852130532,
0.1424678415,
0.2470315248,
-0.0124296844,
0.3540274799,
-0.6882247329,
0.1829421371,
0.0858249813,
-0.6549651623,
-0.10511484,
-0.0179979298,
0.6286988258,
0.618355453,
-0.4773107171,
-0.1240711585,
-0.1846164614,
0.7137509584,
-0.6813297868,
0.3105921745,
-0.2984558344,
0.3226499856,
0.3716623187,
-0.3133326471,
-0.3880732954,
-0.7346566319,
0.7308599949,
-1.1564023495,
-0.0807269812,
0.2647081912,
0.7114987373,
0.2029555142,
-0.2074044496,
-0.1693715602,
-0.7611044049,
0.9676018357,
-0.5746255517,
0.4280445576,
0.4173568189,
0.549567759,
-0.2605060339,
-0.3553186357,
-0.5215433836,
-0.5502736568,
0.1068059281,
0.1657688469,
-0.1225254014,
0.3572404087,
0.0398707017,
0.2397594899,
-0.4532459974,
0.1131820753,
-0.0271285903,
-0.1071405038,
0.5177893043,
-0.1093934327,
0.1825567633,
0.0821601972,
-0.3772403896,
-0.5941526294,
-0.552434206,
0.5579402447,
0.488830328,
0.3115700483,
0.032301195,
0.2701261044,
-0.3171145022,
0.4736773074,
0.0704169944,
-0.0714914054,
0.1594815254,
-0.1254662275,
0.019666886,
0.0291833766,
0.5413172841,
0.4473249018,
0.1906116158,
-0.1044112518,
-0.2026609927,
-0.0974138901,
0.1510259807,
-0.5508067012,
-0.146563068,
0.3982520401,
-0.1680885851,
-0.3497980833,
0.1031300649,
-0.7104911804,
-0.2876720726,
-0.2504790127,
0.3762636483,
-0.0852761045,
-0.2807683945,
-0.0039849947,
-0.2003087103,
0.0507278815,
0.3711512387,
-0.8497920036,
0.4798961282,
0.6325161457,
0.6582095623,
-0.2512490749,
-0.3045205772,
-0.7992047668,
-0.0585884266,
-0.4516144097,
0.5910873413,
-0.7198432684,
-0.4149106741,
0.2531767786,
-0.2581299245,
0.033633776,
-0.5110920668,
0.6913183331,
-0.7916458249,
0.4949367046,
-0.0349799581,
-0.5693804622,
-0.26289621,
0.1469891071,
-0.7139086723,
1.2686359882,
0.2545247972,
-0.5223089457,
0.4258551896,
-0.7389621735,
0.1889011413,
-0.3187444508,
-0.1476941407,
-0.3702212572,
0.057711523,
0.3920419812,
-0.0215795599,
-0.0330026411,
0.1118832231,
-0.5291360617,
-0.417244792,
0.2452350706,
0.0681484938,
0.5198580623,
0.144557029,
-0.5840758085,
0.5956328511,
-0.7001706362,
0.3460892141,
0.1368704438,
-0.3421171904,
-0.5747824311,
0.2276140153,
0.0143411215,
0.3012498319,
0.0796118081,
-0.5417411923,
0.2585318983,
-0.7710502744,
0.2747011781,
0.8970275521,
-0.0874058977,
0.6687264442,
-0.3404348493,
0.9059078693,
-0.4478901625,
0.3581329286,
-0.1032687947,
-0.2354253232,
-0.7058390379,
-0.268748641,
0.2400304824,
0.3823325634,
-0.5338208079,
0.3124862909,
-0.3396529853,
-0.1782439053,
-0.7086346149,
-0.1659650058,
0.5149547458,
0.2028403133,
0.3803693354,
-0.0198775344,
-0.5060837865,
-0.8931100965,
-0.2594463527,
-0.24491705,
0.2722332478,
0.6022377014,
-0.0869929343,
-0.1610263735,
1.1418274641,
-0.5047358871,
-0.1548240483,
-0.4125061333,
0.1345781684,
0.2983716726,
0.1824620962,
0.2783540487,
-0.691280663,
-0.6853151321,
0.1127803847,
-0.3117958903,
-0.1626102477,
0.0482816733,
-0.1590256393,
0.3328927755,
0.1325082779,
-0.2499562651,
0.022243768,
0.5955716968,
-0.0070664319,
0.140250206,
-0.6196346283,
0.0282258391,
-0.4171072543,
-0.1415503323,
-0.1805228144,
-0.5196470022,
-0.6142715216,
0.5006118417,
0.1158011183,
-0.0253124908,
-0.3612062037,
0.6551136971,
-0.5429388285,
0.0321352035,
-0.485791415,
0.3248510957,
-0.232600987,
0.8545392156,
0.3048293591,
0.4465249777,
0.4050046206,
-0.5067278743,
0.0712210387,
0.0492830649,
-0.0980119854,
-0.0140213137,
-0.4298658073,
0.4008563161,
-0.231839478,
0.3235376477,
-0.8999716043,
0.0163953044,
0.3192723691,
-0.3170721531,
0.2317439914,
-0.0304238182,
-0.2015572637,
0.0427895263,
-0.7452659607,
0.436837554,
0.6257787943,
-0.6964812875,
0.4732274115,
0.5365284085,
-0.2126702964,
-0.7308673263,
-0.033158645,
-0.2639078796,
-0.1803604215,
-0.3649975657,
0.2893515229,
-0.0436852612,
-0.2397732884,
-0.1343505085,
-0.0300061777,
0.0951416045,
0.1007445753,
0.1098069921,
0.4358962476,
0.1624858528,
-0.1374629587,
0.0047656442,
-0.1094419956,
-0.0008596762,
-0.278583318,
0.4870216548,
-0.0179543961,
-0.0899615437,
-0.4369090497,
0.4410730898,
0.147610411,
0.0747342259,
0.0679875687,
0.1967089325,
-0.1220065281,
-0.4214788973,
-0.285095185,
-0.2903273702,
-0.4346236587,
0.5194137692,
-0.2306746095,
-0.9787896872,
0.1168902442,
0.1160826609,
0.2649082839,
0.204513371,
0.2888352871,
0.051465638,
1.3783252239,
0.8544358611,
0.0499560796,
0.4911810756,
-0.0423342511,
0.0242504589,
-0.5818333626,
-0.0243924074,
-0.163801983,
-0.1671739072,
-0.8728252053,
-0.4532834291,
0.466784656,
-0.016539285,
0.0809632987,
0.174975276,
-0.1826799959,
0.3138868213,
0.8420168161,
0.1614415497,
0.3742638826,
-0.0494931564,
-0.25860551,
-0.2791183889,
-0.93193084,
-0.1370859891,
1.2256748676,
0.4936471879,
0.5989987254,
0.1045601591,
0.789335072,
0.3433974981,
0.3026232123,
-0.776661396,
0.2315680683,
0.4972730279,
-0.4488852024,
-0.5787974,
-0.4448771775,
-0.842839241,
0.3660281897,
-0.2126157731,
-0.6459721923,
0.3399019837,
0.5474469662,
-0.6849720478,
-0.0976056978,
-0.6940112114,
0.6741476059,
-0.2295941412,
-0.5869723558,
-0.4355071783,
-0.7637430429,
0.341906786,
-0.0015629058,
0.4556648135,
0.0583295375,
-0.2176482677,
0.5576354265,
-0.3699375391,
0.5650712252,
-0.4224881232,
-0.1830763668,
0.1088921204,
0.0852171928,
0.9304952621,
-0.136163339,
0.252227813,
-0.4299971759,
0.2137473822,
-0.2946763635,
-0.8940453529,
0.5378224254,
-0.939391613,
-0.5708614588,
-0.657951653,
-0.4171015024,
-0.5314035416,
-0.1270200908,
-0.1064702868,
0.1740445942,
-0.2582647204,
-0.2355670184,
0.591847837,
-0.3140412867,
0.3262479305,
0.3671864569,
-0.6960208416,
-0.5279464722,
1.0194034576,
-0.2000773102,
0.4747744799,
0.8133558631,
0.602645874,
-0.6915683746,
-0.4409799278,
-0.5212891698,
0.232793659,
-0.7000212669,
0.3424371183,
-0.6383174062,
0.3378670514,
-0.2055703998,
0.1014248356,
-0.3161839545,
-0.6084488034,
0.0789641589,
0.0103972219,
0.0582135394,
0.5199916363,
-0.1305174977,
0.2415346354,
-0.6259902716,
0.0495418832,
0.3929122388,
0.1039710641,
-0.0664896145,
-0.5119820833,
-0.2470787615,
0.0959023312,
-0.0052006361,
-0.8518923521,
0.4092319906,
0.3917541504,
0.739530623,
0.6141085625,
0.2752379477,
0.5551123619,
-0.3460124433,
0.3954457641,
-0.109441936,
-0.6863113642,
0.3621582389,
-0.4145552814,
0.0902690366,
0.6680301428,
0.7217404246,
-0.650031507,
-0.1894294471,
-0.6086866856,
-0.9551468492,
0.8843640685,
0.0064966888,
-0.0920280218,
0.1735384762,
0.1612875164,
0.2885039449,
0.2586163282,
-0.720010221,
-0.3912009001,
-0.087598078,
0.1451466978,
0.0803926811,
-0.1444944143,
-0.2790621817,
0.0067092213,
0.8733000755,
-0.392211616,
0.2938045263,
0.2994813621,
-0.1833608896,
-0.1862106919,
0.2757812738,
0.677439332,
0.6471700668,
-0.6195805073,
0.0939707756,
-0.0865988359,
-0.1016302332,
0.2026290148,
0.113823764,
-0.1701045185,
-0.1614177674,
0.0587770566,
0.874673903,
0.3065325022,
-1.1499780416,
0.5593423247,
-0.2007543147,
-0.0461298227,
-0.4123999178,
0.3039596379,
-0.2403456122,
0.204352811,
0.4601678848,
-0.2440590262,
0.2767116725,
-0.6938932538,
0.0945137292,
0.4459775388,
-0.7089166641,
-0.2142459303,
0.4610503912,
0.1912859082,
-0.2575063705,
0.1803403646,
-0.4244359434,
-0.6972643733,
0.3590159416,
0.3844380677,
0.8423397541,
-0.0162324887,
0.2489882857,
0.4358566701,
-0.0709033385,
-0.1538542956,
0.1608972549,
-0.4360739291,
-0.7039811611,
-0.438662678,
-0.2842294574,
-0.720998466,
-0.1308534145,
-0.676309526,
0.1792858839,
-0.5773676634,
0.0512319207,
-0.4658343792,
0.0085889474,
-0.2887240648,
0.1397209913,
0.1742399186,
0.6045562029,
-0.4147070348,
0.7887602448,
0.5054398775,
-0.045190651,
-0.6555998325,
0.0049327565,
0.0691089854,
-0.9894117117,
0.6118803024,
0.0178812165,
-0.2500174344,
0.1975794882,
-0.2294608802,
-1.0088483095,
0.908061862,
0.1944581866,
-0.6882926822,
-0.2093780637,
-0.1605956554,
0.3741917908,
-0.4249956012,
0.7403748035,
0.6530711055,
0.5325795412,
-0.2204515487,
-0.8923671842,
0.1203864813,
-0.2633932531,
0.0499604903,
0.2458936125,
-0.5188261867,
0.3201301396,
-0.4975470603,
-0.4010032713,
0.0025374691,
0.7628936172,
0.3872913122,
-0.1156056821,
0.9022967219,
0.4599480629,
0.6026169062,
0.0739242658,
1.2576788664,
-0.2607354522,
0.4753667712,
1.205860734,
-0.1310596168,
0.9346054196,
0.6462294459,
-0.430065006,
0.3324209154,
0.8468312025,
0.4037106335,
0.9242582917,
0.379963994,
-0.2318208218,
-0.2077755928,
-0.1624056399,
-0.2774111927,
0.1329988539,
-0.152860418,
-0.1361444294,
-0.2535533309,
-0.1848508567,
0.0943613723,
0.195103541,
-0.1684677899,
0.7770969868,
-0.3094266355,
-1.124830246,
0.5573282838,
0.0987990275,
0.6937947869,
-0.7287914157,
-0.2113879174,
-0.2420031875,
0.0631418377,
0.0093016289,
-0.2853531241,
-0.1429164261,
-0.4433613718,
0.0975645259,
-0.2287790477,
0.2155228257,
-0.5557299256,
-0.0996789411,
0.4922085702,
0.5092120171,
-0.0758782029,
-0.0699112043,
-0.4557524323,
-0.1017082781,
0.222278446,
-0.3574334681,
0.4972195923,
-0.0897708684,
-0.0764462352,
0.6710091829,
0.7379208207,
0.2964422703,
0.2241904438,
-0.002653569,
0.6855982542,
-0.6147111654,
-0.8538839817,
-0.6729226112,
0.1928762496,
-0.0143159749,
-0.4376676977,
0.5274944305,
0.5413146615,
1.0606470108,
0.0123245232,
1.0086063147,
0.228122592,
0.6361421943,
-0.4901241958,
0.241494745,
-0.5321880579,
0.1167581975,
-0.2424865961,
-0.9348896146,
-0.0400011688,
0.5846264958,
-0.3357074261,
-0.0497584194,
0.7745477557,
0.8425691128,
0.0686811358,
0.107677415,
0.3182747662,
-0.1261815727,
0.2640404403,
0.615847826,
1.1306385994,
-0.1204979941,
0.4554619491,
-0.5751886964,
-0.5716943741,
-0.2854188383,
-0.9499994516,
-0.6857153773,
-0.4669516683,
-0.147247389,
-0.1115715131,
0.2481601685,
1.7644269466,
0.6999388933,
-0.5941640735,
-0.4149990976,
-0.2043491602,
0.0145660788,
-0.5465601683,
-0.2448154539,
0.4589609206,
-0.4193461239,
-1.1050543785,
0.620552361,
0.2012112737,
-0.0969933346,
-0.5474683642,
-0.3833598495,
-0.1592260152,
-0.0243670084,
0.3435484469,
0.5432447791,
-0.741468668,
-0.2436432689,
0.3754665554,
0.058357086,
0.3000431061,
1.0568296909,
-0.8472668529,
0.8250328302,
0.5125672221,
1.0557867289,
0.5589092374,
-0.0084641278,
0.9059610367,
-0.3653798997,
-0.0844120458,
0.2291919291,
0.1177680269,
0.1792746037,
-0.3389851153,
0.2756241262,
0.1557280421,
-0.4349056184,
-0.8067038655,
0.2020696402,
-0.8827926517,
-0.1973614246,
1.1933847666,
-0.2329535484,
-0.3230171502,
-0.1318347752,
-0.4096305072,
0.0163878202,
-0.8630105257,
1.0482003689,
0.5684936047,
-0.6351584792,
-0.3393506706,
-0.6074972153,
0.8329908848,
0.75268507,
-0.7485932708,
0.0941752791,
0.3720537722,
-0.0500448868,
0.0770073012,
0.6710000634,
0.1663804203,
0.4245847464,
-0.4476223886,
0.0524231456,
-0.1487542093,
-0.2330849916,
-0.5583585501,
0.1536404341,
0.3625732064,
-0.0848595276
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.21040v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.21040v1
|
Direct Alignment of Language Models via Quality-Aware Self-Refinement
| 2024-05-31T17:31:18 | 2024-05-31T17:31:18 |
Runsheng Yu, Yong Wang, Xiaoqi Jiao, Youzhi Zhang, James T. Kwok
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) has been commonly used to
align the behaviors of Large Language Models (LLMs) with human preferences.
Recently, a popular alternative is Direct Policy Optimization (DPO), which
replaces an LLM-based reward model with the policy itself, thus obviating the
need for extra memory and training time to learn the reward model. However, DPO
does not consider the relative qualities of the positive and negative
responses, and can lead to sub-optimal training outcomes. To alleviate this
problem, we investigate the use of intrinsic knowledge within the on-the-fly
fine-tuning LLM to obtain relative qualities and help to refine the loss
function. Specifically, we leverage the knowledge of the LLM to design a
refinement function to estimate the quality of both the positive and negative
responses. We show that the constructed refinement function can help
self-refine the loss function under mild assumptions. The refinement function
is integrated into DPO and its variant Identity Policy Optimization (IPO).
Experiments across various evaluators indicate that they can improve the
performance of the fine-tuned models over DPO and IPO.
|
[
-0.1935784221,
-0.4542221427,
0.6064530611,
-0.089596346,
-0.085935466,
0.1917605698,
-0.4437650442,
-0.2556167543,
-0.0897479579,
0.5051520467,
-0.7886765003,
-0.2036754638,
-0.2047078609,
0.0819350556,
0.0897255838,
0.8595706224,
-0.142539531,
-0.07381697,
-0.1151103377,
-0.075797908,
-0.4301717281,
-0.3623384833,
-0.5254516602,
-0.6401335001,
0.5443975925,
0.6013818383,
0.6394230127,
0.8116745949,
0.4568536878,
0.2260049134,
0.119227916,
0.3046092987,
-0.7158893347,
0.0960416794,
-0.7106641531,
-0.3286803961,
-0.2977033854,
-0.0720254481,
0.6325416565,
0.4201284051,
-0.4311619997,
0.0801344365,
0.2022314966,
1.007615447,
-0.6108934879,
-0.0223807897,
-0.6588027477,
0.0802612156,
0.3197165728,
-0.203612566,
-0.1949933767,
-0.4267400801,
0.2372412384,
-0.6795905828,
-0.0294525921,
-0.0195706207,
1.1124091148,
0.647526741,
-0.1804397404,
-0.1514882743,
-0.8597532511,
0.8411799669,
-0.8232795,
0.3486214578,
0.3265909553,
0.084536612,
-0.337126404,
-0.0092420708,
-0.7030335665,
-0.3261066675,
-0.1839773804,
0.0175728202,
0.0119666979,
0.2943052948,
-0.1390686631,
0.5711436868,
-0.40072456,
0.5209064484,
-0.0416245759,
-0.3857780099,
0.8442041874,
0.0342128426,
-0.053545557,
0.0886901468,
-0.2626324296,
-0.1665881574,
-0.8164250851,
0.2816438079,
0.6591041088,
0.3864211738,
0.1746079326,
0.2871063948,
-0.4964143038,
0.5889933109,
0.5275264978,
-0.5099745393,
0.2072245926,
-0.3352385163,
-0.005306622,
0.007311773,
0.6877478361,
0.1301501393,
0.2556569576,
-0.1169956848,
-0.5343567729,
-0.2370316982,
0.3394007683,
-0.7144511938,
0.0311800838,
0.181442827,
-0.2750667334,
-0.4501380324,
-0.1460847259,
-0.2680995166,
-0.1715181172,
-0.7369837761,
0.594405055,
-0.2002666295,
-0.3400256336,
0.1208998412,
0.1889411509,
0.221611008,
0.2142190039,
-0.9590187073,
0.1992527843,
0.7564446926,
0.230478242,
-0.0776378289,
-0.32910043,
-0.4474372268,
0.1438202262,
-0.4212217033,
0.5334811211,
-0.3307427466,
-0.2552520037,
0.0329265222,
-0.1712468714,
0.1912194937,
-0.5758208036,
0.5217744708,
-0.5297827721,
0.2405717075,
-0.2487879992,
-0.4815999269,
-0.2519318461,
0.314022392,
-0.3120342195,
0.8141775131,
0.2259080708,
-0.4745134115,
0.3038212061,
-0.3317687511,
-0.4651458859,
-0.2577066123,
-0.288050741,
-0.5654518604,
0.3037642539,
0.1320054829,
0.3575159013,
-0.2298764437,
0.5116305351,
-0.4418377578,
-0.3888580203,
0.2813968658,
-0.1792337596,
0.1910180151,
0.2011520863,
-0.4202483594,
0.3285278082,
-0.7684657574,
0.1464178562,
0.0765824467,
-0.2966435552,
-0.2974639237,
0.1030943096,
-0.7331363559,
0.2109541744,
0.3653202951,
-0.4224701822,
0.3479568064,
-0.6154367924,
0.3332338333,
1.0907062292,
-0.1027488112,
0.6077807546,
-0.2444233596,
0.5331664681,
-0.1314403564,
0.3030872941,
0.1337871999,
0.1000935733,
-0.7413480282,
-0.2397949696,
0.24437657,
0.3833789825,
-0.4841253161,
0.654309988,
-0.1878946871,
-0.2420046479,
-0.9289823174,
0.3364548683,
0.6131145954,
0.9740028381,
0.2110561728,
-0.2373188138,
-0.2120905817,
-1.177033186,
-0.0863214582,
-0.3387907743,
0.2477385104,
0.3708716631,
0.1060742587,
-0.171544373,
1.0289897919,
-0.5680608153,
-0.2731787562,
-0.0377492234,
-0.0008525718,
0.268176496,
0.4359679222,
0.2535375655,
-0.3590689301,
-0.4827341437,
0.0371354483,
-0.3269890845,
-0.3038785458,
-0.0841059089,
-0.2173160315,
0.2029989958,
0.2330097109,
-0.1672152877,
-0.0009794105,
0.5854172111,
-0.253210187,
0.7863324881,
-0.4358812571,
0.2105647027,
-0.6936181784,
0.0605980679,
-0.0775749683,
-0.1971698105,
-0.3795145154,
0.018660266,
0.0663890839,
-0.0698651448,
-0.1716795862,
0.8011018634,
-0.3661508858,
0.0737804323,
-0.4135886729,
0.1387699544,
0.2025559843,
0.7790445089,
0.128547132,
0.8820689321,
0.5010284781,
-0.7999722362,
0.0854050443,
0.0567704923,
-0.1673622131,
0.6536758542,
-0.6417919397,
0.1314896643,
-0.3196100295,
-0.081368953,
-0.8556369543,
0.004821456,
0.3989974856,
-0.168194592,
0.5378654003,
-0.1945084333,
-0.1741780639,
-0.2706821561,
-0.2708604634,
0.2356218696,
0.4892846942,
-0.5877864361,
0.3661797643,
0.3263729513,
-0.0408988148,
-0.8036088943,
-0.447430402,
-0.28045699,
-0.3336230516,
-0.3558174074,
0.719147563,
-0.0475080013,
-0.1171762198,
-0.0362164415,
-0.2460500002,
0.0045056473,
0.184414044,
0.0257919058,
0.0644944683,
0.0188440569,
0.4829173088,
0.0665579811,
-0.1591919363,
-0.1335195005,
-0.2943614125,
0.40172261,
-0.154122293,
-0.3027303517,
-0.8376105428,
0.0903216451,
0.247606501,
-0.354585886,
0.4411491156,
0.3875217736,
0.112120837,
-0.4496411979,
-0.5898785591,
-0.4814229012,
-0.5267585516,
0.3019446135,
-0.5759570599,
-0.9428888559,
0.4482757449,
0.0753708333,
-0.1553565562,
0.4156485498,
0.3209782839,
-0.1275132596,
0.9557979703,
0.7929124832,
-0.1547879279,
0.7218111753,
-0.0883127153,
0.1313043982,
-0.9547258615,
-0.0968466327,
-0.4252166748,
-0.39077425,
-0.5039204955,
-0.0665195584,
-0.0030563981,
0.3118085861,
-0.5609830618,
0.2921073139,
-0.7448042631,
0.3532371521,
0.6909427047,
0.2833683193,
0.2459845543,
-0.043668244,
-0.0807681978,
-0.1177545339,
-0.6358721256,
-0.4159966111,
0.9868839979,
0.5423603654,
1.1431312561,
0.0455915779,
0.9781560898,
0.1745154262,
0.3220928609,
-0.7784895897,
0.3727616966,
-0.1253019422,
-0.2027369738,
-0.5202893019,
-0.7471235991,
-0.7776587009,
0.0715417042,
-0.0015478227,
-0.4604920745,
0.2183132768,
0.6594097614,
-0.528173089,
-0.1519048959,
-0.7214494944,
0.8458563089,
-0.5277255177,
-0.3581377864,
-0.5636643171,
-0.3679292798,
0.3319988549,
0.0288052876,
0.0421151817,
-0.5401740074,
0.0968338847,
0.4231337905,
-0.4336420298,
0.7055590153,
-0.1607487202,
-0.4022887349,
0.3430353403,
0.2882798314,
0.6233770847,
0.0002617384,
-0.0937399417,
-0.0470192656,
-0.2343166918,
-0.122342594,
-0.780339241,
0.8265321255,
-0.9847560525,
-0.9072899818,
-0.0660851896,
-0.1627216637,
-0.3037717342,
0.0891901255,
-0.1752048433,
0.2769681215,
-0.0647372678,
-0.1991448998,
0.756739378,
-0.263486743,
0.2179840207,
0.9396829605,
-0.1312044561,
-0.5377711058,
1.0274093151,
-0.1264486909,
0.5019179583,
0.6595320702,
0.6882174611,
-0.4598474503,
-0.3427048326,
-0.2352329791,
0.4831249714,
-0.5604199171,
-0.4401913881,
-0.0622547418,
-0.0477531776,
-0.341051966,
0.0785771459,
-0.6117280722,
-0.3200880289,
-0.4833679199,
-0.0043742266,
0.2415098846,
0.3846740723,
-0.1448188126,
0.2537426949,
-0.4703779519,
0.1135318652,
0.4463539422,
0.6710302234,
-0.0268149544,
-0.8358793259,
-0.2521604598,
0.2204551548,
-0.3644706905,
-0.6989920139,
0.1898384541,
0.3613077104,
0.7025696039,
0.5030019879,
0.192745924,
0.7549158335,
-0.4771581888,
0.3164006472,
0.1731330752,
-0.9042749405,
0.6081280708,
-0.0949446857,
0.3700330257,
0.8484780788,
0.2676154375,
-0.5051707625,
-0.1521900594,
-0.4420295954,
-0.4704776108,
0.6274213791,
-0.1781722009,
0.2340052128,
0.0681024492,
0.6667900085,
0.1037436202,
0.2934430838,
-0.7347252369,
-0.1441278011,
-0.2312725186,
-0.2973725498,
0.1175208837,
-0.2436350584,
-0.3059104681,
-0.2154622227,
1.0324196815,
-0.4217613935,
0.1059544086,
0.3516985178,
0.020576613,
-0.2288583666,
0.2857523561,
0.7959413528,
0.6492204666,
-0.2018264532,
0.030670125,
-0.2661426961,
0.0988412425,
0.4567661285,
-0.0967840999,
-0.1436246037,
-0.3824386895,
0.0466400124,
0.7846337557,
0.1329295039,
-0.7345153093,
0.5045408607,
0.0750910491,
-0.0447442308,
-0.0668904483,
0.3259736896,
-0.2307993919,
0.1775567234,
0.1782911718,
-0.2710778117,
0.0454055667,
-0.5437752604,
0.2702163458,
0.5726759434,
-0.6335954666,
-0.3683315516,
0.3937568367,
0.4671648741,
-0.3391807973,
0.6313815117,
-0.4481247663,
-0.5945366621,
0.3821786344,
0.4695629179,
0.9086346626,
-0.2681767941,
0.4085598886,
0.4646629691,
0.062875405,
-0.0087812534,
0.0693751425,
-0.1693411171,
-1.0430192947,
-0.6574530005,
-0.622212708,
-0.3664349914,
0.1023173779,
-0.4277594388,
0.1806984991,
-0.5579950809,
-0.1601575315,
-0.3692670465,
0.1354464293,
-0.6525552273,
0.1739840955,
0.1233956516,
0.4660108685,
-0.4395619631,
0.7748472095,
0.3783302307,
-0.4538303018,
-0.9576257467,
-0.0137707889,
-0.2394901812,
-1.1529457569,
0.9081115723,
-0.060317643,
-0.2655449212,
0.059599705,
-0.2071992755,
-1.1054520607,
0.8854758143,
0.588483572,
-0.8715546131,
0.0306114424,
-0.0086652711,
0.6274681687,
-0.2923249006,
0.1525628567,
0.4763777852,
0.3560194969,
0.0561890081,
-0.9942178726,
0.0716727078,
0.3150849938,
0.114588052,
0.3144523501,
-0.7792527676,
0.4134405255,
-0.346698761,
-0.2735708952,
-0.2267459482,
0.6587475538,
0.0778304487,
-0.2630562186,
0.469129473,
0.747484386,
0.6196626425,
0.0013260709,
0.9088018537,
-0.5041328669,
0.3413931131,
1.3373970985,
-0.2111714184,
0.7582006454,
0.5699436069,
-0.1167496666,
0.5967665315,
0.5945619941,
0.2032533288,
0.8219689131,
0.5304898024,
-0.196469754,
-0.1782000363,
-0.1751067787,
-0.160577938,
0.3472706676,
0.0154653648,
-0.2435497791,
-0.1590383947,
-0.2137881815,
-0.1399152875,
0.3902167976,
-0.3713380098,
1.0039124489,
-0.1297963709,
-1.0966845751,
0.708753109,
0.0646206439,
0.6787127256,
-0.6251695752,
0.0188005585,
-0.4328662753,
0.342582196,
-0.1868478656,
-0.8142107725,
0.2993234992,
-0.5527073145,
-0.2213395834,
-0.3578992486,
0.4590233564,
-0.7946459055,
-0.0390233099,
0.1676510572,
0.0931363702,
-0.2470143735,
-0.1858797222,
-0.9261907935,
0.0227789506,
0.1867977679,
-0.1491874605,
0.2438262999,
0.2520574331,
0.2148576826,
0.8831578493,
0.4516514838,
0.1330372244,
-0.3826795816,
0.1546888351,
0.667860508,
-0.5611203313,
-0.4180973768,
-0.7730627656,
0.3794065714,
0.0801066831,
-0.4011408687,
0.4023959339,
0.2154082358,
0.9846907854,
-0.107137844,
0.4694529176,
0.2894708514,
0.590423584,
-0.4649620652,
0.4662184119,
-0.6427255869,
0.2616446316,
-0.0428884327,
-0.9498978853,
0.0690548122,
0.5924916863,
-0.3597662747,
-0.1720461845,
0.3556043208,
1.0381305218,
0.2401773185,
-0.553735733,
0.3499497175,
0.0125774676,
0.4473313689,
0.3798570931,
0.6770271659,
-0.166169107,
0.4327269495,
-0.4379450679,
-0.2207708061,
-0.1649211347,
-0.9628664255,
-0.6046172976,
-0.4955929518,
-0.5901278257,
-0.0947723165,
0.1512502283,
0.9448167086,
0.8711982965,
-0.655816257,
-0.3113278449,
-0.1976699084,
0.4300530553,
-0.3061368465,
-0.2830176055,
0.2529484034,
-0.648750484,
-0.5829413533,
0.3984363079,
0.3592718542,
0.1831865013,
-0.6074249148,
-0.4763175845,
0.0386613868,
0.1456793249,
0.3691804409,
0.5255386233,
-0.87261796,
-0.5571752787,
-0.0763661191,
-0.2360722721,
0.123525843,
0.7210694551,
-0.7885742784,
0.588899076,
0.3834038973,
0.8315568566,
0.1620606333,
0.2236933708,
0.9402507544,
-0.7359761,
-0.116079852,
0.361929208,
0.1701690853,
0.3800147176,
-0.5082252026,
0.3279889822,
0.0100422595,
-0.7472337484,
-0.6286177635,
0.5207768679,
-0.6716790199,
-0.2292568982,
1.0474328995,
-0.0975966081,
-0.2651572824,
0.3531598449,
-0.287576437,
-0.0434674062,
-0.6567286253,
1.1127874851,
0.5923269987,
-0.3357354999,
-0.2776369452,
0.2575268745,
0.8173860312,
0.5779124498,
-0.7306476235,
0.150384739,
0.371417582,
0.3697793484,
0.0309147052,
0.653826654,
0.13430354,
0.0484313071,
-0.4367408156,
0.4135077596,
-0.1602669358,
-0.3574277759,
-0.4453526437,
-0.2626580596,
0.4710375071,
-0.0595712177
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.21028v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.21028v2
|
LACIE: Listener-Aware Finetuning for Confidence Calibration in Large Language Models
| 2024-05-31T17:16:38 | 2024-07-03T12:49:23 |
Elias Stengel-Eskin, Peter Hase, Mohit Bansal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
When answering questions, LLMs can convey not only an answer, but a level of
confidence about the answer being correct. This includes explicit confidence
markers (e.g. giving a numeric score) as well as implicit markers, like an
authoritative tone or elaborating with additional knowledge. For LLMs to be
trustworthy knowledge sources, the confidence they convey should match their
actual expertise; however, most current models tend towards overconfidence. To
calibrate both implicit and explicit confidence markers, we introduce a
pragmatic, listener-aware finetuning method (LACIE) that models the listener,
considering not only whether an answer is right, but whether it will be
accepted by a listener. We cast calibration as preference optimization,
creating data via a two-agent game, where a speaker model's outputs are judged
by a simulated listener. We then finetune three LLMs (Mistral-7B, Llama3-8B,
Llama3-70B) with LACIE, and show that the resulting models are better
calibrated w.r.t. a simulated listener. Crucially, these trends transfer to
human listeners, helping them correctly predict model correctness: we conduct a
human evaluation where annotators accept or reject an LLM's answers, finding
that training with LACIE results in 47% fewer incorrect answers being accepted
while maintaining the same level of acceptance for correct answers.
Furthermore, LACIE generalizes to another dataset, resulting in a large
increase in truthfulness on TruthfulQA when trained on TriviaQA. Our analysis
indicates that LACIE leads to a better confidence separation between correct
and incorrect examples. Qualitatively, we find that a LACIE-trained model
hedges more and implicitly signals certainty when it is correct by using an
authoritative tone or including details. Finally, LACIE finetuning leads to an
emergent increase in model abstention (e.g. saying "I don't know") for answers
that are likely wrong.
|
[
-0.4031312764,
-0.6730735302,
0.7172294259,
0.0041281502,
0.1459477693,
-0.108846277,
-0.2946027517,
-0.5609153509,
-0.0687831193,
0.4602916837,
-0.6738966107,
-0.558837235,
-0.3874740005,
-0.1994491369,
-0.043199975,
0.9205511808,
0.1988131702,
0.2461249232,
-0.3175021112,
0.028026849,
-0.593023777,
-0.3439887166,
-0.6209807992,
-0.4357537031,
0.4506086111,
0.6653211117,
0.457087934,
0.4522398412,
0.3601023257,
0.2234002799,
-0.0746627897,
0.3168562651,
-0.8148748279,
0.2300560325,
-0.0908754617,
-0.9048426747,
-0.4419440627,
0.2763434052,
0.3129465878,
0.6493246555,
-0.0740523487,
0.3750441372,
0.0385279208,
0.5561754704,
-0.8105410933,
0.3085584044,
-0.7622398734,
-0.1657865196,
0.0602759756,
-0.3168936968,
-0.6281714439,
-0.6336765885,
0.3162284195,
-0.7960979342,
0.2040433735,
0.0062441714,
0.6013017893,
0.6091325283,
-0.2174936384,
-0.2696937025,
-0.763128221,
0.9532901645,
-0.8592799902,
0.3661161661,
0.5795946121,
0.2948027551,
-0.1173079908,
-0.3613993227,
-0.6146459579,
-0.3772753477,
0.1106658205,
0.3721224368,
0.1485792994,
0.1367552429,
0.336802721,
0.209359467,
-0.2045013011,
0.1643608361,
-0.1365434974,
-0.4437478185,
0.6295415163,
-0.081566602,
-0.0867515206,
0.2581782341,
-0.1955188811,
-0.1142218933,
-0.8203014135,
0.3046121597,
0.361707747,
0.3782051504,
0.178078711,
0.3483165205,
-0.2449838817,
0.8587206006,
0.4346034527,
-0.2717646062,
0.1201954111,
0.03198817,
-0.0849257335,
0.2845402062,
0.4621014595,
0.7452344894,
0.7189999819,
-0.0131678712,
-0.0890013799,
0.1855510324,
-0.061376743,
-0.857126534,
-0.3438410163,
0.4881994724,
0.0284678265,
-0.3101657331,
-0.0057392423,
-0.3419361115,
-0.5454497933,
-0.4877427816,
0.650262773,
-0.2930422723,
-0.0530445948,
0.3258902133,
0.14939183,
0.3284166753,
0.5046658516,
-0.8525159359,
0.276610136,
0.6915434599,
0.4357888997,
0.1136759073,
-0.0013053971,
-0.9386186004,
0.0482241921,
-0.4291382432,
0.5869403481,
-0.191039905,
-0.1979743987,
-0.0054127309,
-0.1605791152,
-0.1185481995,
-0.474063307,
0.6292027235,
-0.4954076707,
0.2827822566,
-0.3368165791,
-0.9025925398,
-0.2564579248,
0.3699076772,
-0.6253530979,
0.8051992655,
-0.2686430514,
-0.5168258548,
0.2255493104,
-0.4116977155,
-0.1003938615,
-0.1360856891,
-0.0925095379,
-0.171525538,
0.0077392189,
0.2029521763,
0.5776498318,
-0.1227383167,
0.2992670834,
-0.3043752611,
-0.5447638035,
0.5719961524,
-0.5291058421,
0.5252974629,
0.0665549859,
-0.1738142818,
-0.0826386884,
-0.5918377042,
0.3380443454,
-0.2817483246,
-0.1917851567,
-0.1671548635,
-0.0202134009,
-0.0971305594,
0.0274738166,
0.1175917238,
-0.8713133931,
-0.2297475934,
-0.6585395932,
0.3861121237,
0.5986792445,
0.1004863083,
0.3743698001,
-0.7560305595,
0.1174754649,
-0.2345862538,
0.2166543156,
-0.0338845998,
-0.5623207092,
-0.8136311769,
-0.043223124,
0.5305373669,
0.8337414265,
-0.300804615,
0.3441864252,
-0.2077778131,
-0.4216108024,
-1.0630797148,
0.2281922102,
0.4639813304,
0.7978498936,
0.3334414363,
-0.1809619069,
-0.2064262778,
-0.9369223118,
-0.0763964877,
-0.3570942879,
-0.0125191174,
0.3199605644,
0.1492010653,
0.1430050433,
1.0131989717,
-0.5677938461,
-0.1986593604,
0.2001723349,
0.2927800715,
0.1540678591,
0.5269239545,
0.4040422738,
-0.9337019324,
-0.4238847494,
-0.0846075267,
-0.3298333585,
-0.2480808944,
-0.0317332,
-0.0595731363,
0.1651032716,
0.2551964521,
-0.4503082037,
0.0655445904,
0.5691978931,
-0.0258623622,
0.4907484055,
0.1869734079,
0.1204534099,
-0.977894187,
0.031873893,
0.0590115525,
-0.5060414672,
-0.8411889076,
0.0998233259,
-0.0457244664,
0.4657068849,
-0.5665237904,
0.5556265712,
-0.161187008,
0.242402643,
-0.1079882681,
0.401578486,
0.3057453036,
0.5339983106,
0.1191076189,
0.8978933096,
0.2988974452,
-0.6088679433,
0.3271285892,
0.2624398768,
-0.4986523092,
0.5405135155,
-0.5241916776,
0.2292269617,
-0.1546913236,
0.0497199483,
-1.203523159,
-0.1533873528,
0.0356187187,
-0.6946322322,
0.4096244872,
-0.1416175961,
-0.0799660981,
-0.1420365721,
-0.2693059146,
0.3015272021,
0.365911305,
-0.4049667418,
0.5071457624,
0.276224345,
-0.3028019369,
-0.9016314149,
-0.8214951754,
-0.2354018986,
-0.0531244725,
-0.5812632442,
0.1539080739,
-0.7440885901,
-0.3807919919,
-0.4688474834,
-0.4005077183,
-0.1658917964,
0.236740604,
0.3183663785,
0.3644968569,
-0.2007279098,
0.3045511246,
-0.2212870568,
-0.1539801955,
0.0649447963,
-0.2130756527,
0.3601951301,
-0.3921613991,
-0.377463609,
-0.6464216709,
0.1322863102,
0.5395516753,
-0.2475411296,
0.4733706415,
0.7449455857,
-0.3040814996,
-0.0001410593,
-1.1785701513,
-0.4667493701,
-0.4049928188,
0.0977999717,
-0.4085434973,
-1.1352306604,
0.5953578949,
-0.0939207301,
0.1870690286,
0.2598027587,
0.480915159,
-0.3660851419,
1.0031009912,
0.5183492303,
-0.0758924633,
0.3386365771,
-0.3578574061,
-0.0265812185,
-0.6925375462,
-0.1727388203,
-0.5325108171,
-0.1459844112,
-0.5576066375,
-0.3441479206,
0.0765223354,
0.0439905636,
-0.2546880841,
-0.1008837968,
-0.2974653542,
0.7347363234,
0.7814032435,
0.3787228763,
0.3282495141,
-0.3131079376,
-0.0359543674,
-0.1975947618,
-0.5532537103,
-0.5559571981,
0.9184504151,
0.4526875317,
0.7691191435,
0.1777853072,
0.6897944808,
0.1526533067,
0.5261002779,
-1.1187132597,
0.413703084,
0.017432766,
-0.7624747157,
-0.3960360587,
-0.4425075352,
-0.1543388516,
-0.1701714247,
-0.5106264949,
-0.7611513138,
0.4963310957,
0.3777703643,
-0.8396241069,
-0.0067954767,
-0.8404830098,
0.7274875641,
-0.1012035161,
-0.6216283441,
0.0876019374,
-0.8549181819,
0.281303674,
-0.2160852849,
0.1303084344,
-0.4430781901,
0.2458168417,
0.5931674838,
-0.090237774,
1.0825656652,
-0.2143357843,
-0.2778589427,
0.4754810631,
0.3794594109,
0.5935798287,
0.1056887582,
-0.3909716308,
-0.1457693577,
0.2987173498,
-0.178965494,
-0.6936671734,
0.7102566361,
-0.8424252272,
-0.763664186,
-0.0624138229,
-0.7290667892,
-0.5935000777,
0.0671148971,
0.2858502567,
0.4863451421,
-0.2150250971,
0.1148810536,
1.1462960243,
0.2129300535,
-0.0157128051,
0.7237814665,
0.1165152416,
-0.122391358,
0.6600801945,
-0.0736888871,
0.5856390595,
0.6273602843,
0.2026390284,
-0.4704776704,
-0.4989545047,
-0.1360787153,
0.2498044968,
-0.8170369267,
-0.287391156,
-0.2715495527,
-0.2388863415,
-0.2919183075,
-0.0543837026,
-0.3519203663,
-0.755208075,
-0.1988878995,
-0.3661078513,
0.3575550616,
0.4190921485,
-0.1554816067,
0.5379211307,
-0.5142768025,
0.0392051786,
0.7328853011,
0.3282052577,
-0.2756978571,
-0.5964176655,
-0.1018484086,
0.5167599916,
-0.068647407,
-0.8519135714,
0.1062258482,
0.3431199491,
0.5378178954,
0.3792926073,
0.2262963951,
0.6712126732,
-0.2777229846,
0.5024685264,
0.0904869363,
-0.979901433,
0.5287443995,
-0.3437702358,
0.1625496,
1.0505030155,
0.2694987059,
-0.625208199,
-0.5412478447,
-0.2526484132,
-0.5013256073,
0.5507568121,
-0.0062828548,
0.1408035308,
0.1057800055,
0.5711844563,
0.1195319518,
0.1824809164,
-0.7722004056,
-0.1331738234,
-0.1014861166,
-0.384234935,
-0.2646438181,
-0.4939377308,
-0.4820368886,
-0.1252725124,
0.9128134251,
-0.4092948735,
0.1488581747,
0.3509214818,
-0.2050626576,
-0.2623558342,
0.4353474379,
0.587466538,
0.4987073839,
-0.7534865737,
0.0053778323,
0.2100974619,
-0.3245023787,
-0.042751316,
0.1354315579,
-0.3343132138,
-0.278832525,
0.3862470388,
0.8387921453,
0.052601058,
-0.5607897043,
0.6433337927,
-0.0768593028,
-0.3690864742,
-0.2431492954,
0.3120704293,
0.0835597962,
0.2830753624,
0.2427794486,
0.2111527473,
0.2311839163,
-0.364374131,
0.2165842056,
0.3847886622,
-0.7100374699,
-0.0392420404,
0.6361846328,
0.2749147713,
-0.1243460327,
0.4069436193,
0.1074049324,
-0.4650917351,
0.5220364332,
0.5489387512,
0.6208925247,
-0.4300645888,
0.1688191742,
0.3514244258,
0.2075926661,
-0.2183317691,
0.283567816,
-0.0886888504,
-1.1202710867,
-0.7439217567,
-0.5821503401,
-0.7055587173,
0.068539463,
-0.8765665889,
-0.1285752803,
-0.3451155424,
-0.4803196788,
0.257768333,
0.2608194351,
-0.7109633684,
0.3705616891,
0.3394680023,
1.0550861359,
-0.9291215539,
0.5970214605,
0.6654912829,
-0.2443242222,
-0.9368144274,
0.0124300346,
0.0883697718,
-0.9750030637,
0.4304340184,
0.3552383482,
-0.4411007166,
0.3047699332,
-0.8234280348,
-0.7122334242,
1.1627774239,
0.4570016861,
-0.9223695397,
0.1976153553,
0.037448287,
0.4993472993,
-0.4516114593,
0.3923273087,
0.5781522393,
0.4455738962,
0.4840068817,
-0.9226318598,
-0.1024848521,
-0.200272277,
-0.3017990291,
-0.1218097061,
-0.6335451603,
0.5221478939,
-0.4047907293,
-0.0300055984,
0.4182556868,
0.4275531173,
0.2778178155,
0.3915962875,
0.5217283964,
0.3299072385,
1.1058912277,
-0.3108016849,
0.746168673,
-0.4683065414,
0.265132606,
1.3944963217,
-0.343965739,
1.0474767685,
0.48621732,
0.1885223985,
0.4635417461,
0.6216833591,
0.2647036016,
0.4960980713,
0.1982346773,
-0.4245790243,
-0.7251266837,
-0.3754938841,
-0.1069201753,
0.433154434,
0.496011734,
-0.1094571203,
0.201154992,
-0.0127987247,
0.0460347496,
0.3479378521,
-0.4352905154,
0.6185132861,
0.1485774964,
-0.7376360893,
0.5266127586,
-0.1499526799,
0.4640223682,
-0.456148088,
0.0518003888,
-0.2635479569,
0.3224852681,
-0.2069274336,
-0.9446158409,
-0.1302895248,
-0.1603550315,
-0.3252008855,
-0.0146040553,
0.6509221196,
-0.6862977743,
-0.3029944301,
0.1079201773,
0.6254351139,
0.0418958478,
-0.0917135924,
-0.4878056347,
-0.1664034426,
0.0915013775,
-0.0837078243,
-0.1739716679,
0.2062295526,
0.0420108065,
0.8319327235,
0.5928189754,
0.0657964349,
-0.1301911622,
0.4027072191,
0.5575852394,
-0.2742396593,
-0.3385926485,
-0.6053259373,
0.4531151354,
-0.0272746067,
0.0087976325,
0.5995474458,
0.3441409469,
0.7175598741,
0.0037405333,
0.6085093021,
0.4785079062,
0.6967273355,
-0.6205739975,
0.5593707561,
-0.2861045897,
0.3080593646,
-0.1813479364,
-0.8738023639,
-0.5347139835,
0.7865319848,
-0.5172251463,
-0.0454417728,
0.2595654428,
1.0483914614,
0.1453485042,
0.2030847073,
0.3682074845,
0.4124822021,
0.0735991895,
0.7999424934,
0.8942656517,
-0.3462861478,
0.4110081494,
-0.2725566328,
-0.4034728408,
-0.1849933565,
-0.8044175506,
-0.8639013767,
-0.3840517998,
-0.4134363234,
-0.2273999453,
0.2671326697,
0.908264935,
0.8176730275,
-1.0325704813,
-0.1951904148,
0.2031912655,
-0.0932112485,
-0.1561115831,
-0.2105965465,
0.1212921292,
-0.1331949234,
-0.6921834946,
0.3471168876,
-0.0995832607,
0.2832148671,
-0.1055218726,
-0.1185939908,
-0.1351717263,
0.3223177493,
0.4241549671,
0.3100928068,
-0.6547545791,
-0.607617557,
0.108859323,
-0.0926384553,
-0.037097916,
0.2742271423,
-0.7632459402,
0.6106804013,
0.1802953482,
0.4531800151,
0.6707955003,
0.2493902445,
0.671221137,
-0.8711915016,
0.009364821,
0.3400241435,
0.1741712689,
0.5099549294,
-0.4329718351,
0.4916679859,
-0.0788375661,
-0.6262490749,
-0.6624673009,
0.3009748757,
-1.1935685873,
-0.0314601064,
0.9934043288,
-0.1130413562,
-0.1412415504,
-0.0561098196,
-0.322414428,
0.2217472494,
-0.4837855399,
0.7469950318,
0.904260695,
0.1297808737,
-0.1285753846,
-0.6767981052,
0.6750102639,
0.5723831058,
-0.3681443036,
0.2010161877,
0.6210344434,
0.4088679254,
0.427264303,
0.679810822,
0.2821598351,
0.4378396273,
-0.4086202681,
0.1242772341,
-0.1715652347,
-0.4308617711,
-0.1772463769,
-0.0259212069,
0.488876164,
-0.1414548308
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.21022v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.21022v1
|
You Only Scan Once: Efficient Multi-dimension Sequential Modeling with LightNet
| 2024-05-31T17:09:16 | 2024-05-31T17:09:16 |
Zhen Qin, Yuxin Mao, Xuyang Shen, Dong Li, Jing Zhang, Yuchao Dai, Yiran Zhong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Linear attention mechanisms have gained prominence in causal language models
due to their linear computational complexity and enhanced speed. However, the
inherent decay mechanism in linear attention presents challenges when applied
to multi-dimensional sequence modeling tasks, such as image processing and
multi-modal learning. In these scenarios, the utilization of sequential
scanning to establish a global receptive field necessitates multiple scans for
multi-dimensional data, thereby leading to inefficiencies. This paper
identifies the inefficiency caused by a multiplicative linear recurrence and
proposes an efficient alternative additive linear recurrence to avoid the
issue, as it can handle multi-dimensional data within a single scan. We further
develop an efficient multi-dimensional sequential modeling framework called
LightNet based on the new recurrence. Moreover, we present two new
multi-dimensional linear relative positional encoding methods, MD-TPE and
MD-LRPE to enhance the model's ability to discern positional information in
multi-dimensional scenarios. Our empirical evaluations across various tasks,
including image classification, image generation, bidirectional language
modeling, and autoregressive language modeling, demonstrate the efficacy of
LightNet, showcasing its potential as a versatile and efficient solution for
multi-dimensional sequential modeling.
|
[
-0.1106219292,
-0.5234132409,
0.8064792752,
0.2002136856,
-0.243229121,
-0.2647792101,
0.2532321215,
-0.5384169221,
0.0675856993,
0.2148509026,
-0.3020996451,
-0.1831949949,
-0.4846216142,
-0.0712511912,
-0.5502638221,
0.3340595365,
0.104699716,
0.209962979,
0.0629590824,
-0.3616923094,
-0.168908447,
-0.3608915508,
-1.0480303764,
-0.2049082965,
1.1063922644,
0.2171685547,
0.5612940788,
0.7257816792,
0.7125301361,
0.4083499014,
0.1674389392,
0.2299378961,
-0.5158604383,
0.1521743685,
-0.1856441647,
-0.031377282,
-0.2841941714,
0.0293853004,
0.842961669,
1.1211965084,
-0.0426807329,
0.2959187925,
-0.1436161995,
0.6901532412,
-0.566778481,
-0.1777364165,
-0.5535489321,
-0.0586900264,
-0.0538157262,
-0.3875124454,
-0.3077050745,
-0.343888551,
0.2050392479,
-0.4931526482,
0.3621561825,
-0.3002074659,
0.4936023057,
0.3120404482,
-0.467717886,
0.1637541354,
-0.8136737347,
0.6912574172,
-0.564329505,
0.5736535788,
-0.0160090178,
0.2523165643,
0.1596211344,
-1.1224435568,
-0.3865617812,
-0.1657030135,
-0.032943368,
0.0657417774,
-0.0474884771,
-0.0736052841,
0.1885412037,
-0.0738682002,
-0.6468344927,
-0.0663968474,
-0.3616466522,
0.0353274979,
0.4590219259,
0.299153775,
-0.0448504128,
0.2768605053,
-0.7506306767,
-0.113722384,
-0.2310590148,
0.0762325451,
0.0394477434,
0.1893170625,
0.2083350569,
0.3767274916,
0.0853168666,
0.7258418202,
0.1050777212,
-0.3112162352,
0.3133989871,
-0.6277394295,
-0.0860913172,
-0.315321207,
0.7204033136,
0.1782717258,
-0.2602128685,
-0.007205992,
-0.2194970399,
0.1536789685,
0.4888516963,
-0.6193647385,
-0.0860238746,
0.3582826257,
-0.7958737612,
-0.2922714949,
-0.2565419376,
-0.6870814562,
-0.5607563257,
-0.2251885086,
0.3461236656,
-0.2942040563,
-0.2034417093,
0.5192088485,
0.0818375498,
0.1271752119,
0.417979151,
-0.4949764609,
-0.0113931755,
0.4752084315,
0.9270504713,
-0.0673665851,
-0.4816093445,
-0.406478107,
-0.0974150524,
-0.4255859852,
0.6304908991,
-0.3343115747,
-0.0067949365,
-0.2374641448,
-0.1557300836,
-0.3509206772,
-0.121515438,
0.502065599,
-0.6955307126,
0.1487195939,
0.1240308136,
-0.3418504298,
-0.2731585801,
0.1298217177,
-0.948168993,
0.4938046634,
-0.1734569967,
-1.0035185814,
0.0649487376,
-0.5742947459,
-0.4651684463,
-0.073881045,
-0.1817345172,
-0.732637167,
0.3268342018,
0.061577823,
0.2578688264,
-0.2424262762,
0.3648557663,
-0.5003343225,
-0.3620100617,
0.1476620436,
-0.5688286424,
0.7261113524,
0.2526336312,
-0.0985282809,
0.2883140743,
-0.8978411555,
0.0059562447,
0.3419664502,
-0.3804885745,
-0.2404794395,
0.2848817706,
0.1815533191,
0.4573066235,
0.4518684149,
-0.5650450587,
0.2570675313,
-0.3590022624,
0.1656051278,
0.7147305608,
0.1238982081,
0.4942668378,
-0.3132761419,
0.4389839172,
0.3594115078,
0.1593190581,
-0.7018208504,
-0.467756927,
-0.6092086434,
-0.2066885382,
-0.0311465915,
0.4838120341,
-0.978628099,
-0.0871677175,
-0.2999420166,
-0.1447090954,
-0.3803359866,
-0.1929803789,
0.3630186617,
0.4748753011,
0.109174192,
-0.3690904975,
-0.6038557291,
-0.9822672606,
-0.0761427507,
0.0029431665,
0.0350058153,
0.251711607,
0.2827362418,
-0.1908261329,
0.583301723,
-0.4546927512,
-0.1521766037,
-0.1554735899,
0.1973942518,
0.5302464962,
0.4109481275,
0.4838861525,
-0.8146386743,
-0.2814840376,
-0.0027321312,
-0.8279093504,
0.1523095667,
-0.5930413604,
0.0357814506,
0.1988550276,
0.4611802697,
-0.4237465262,
0.4860867262,
0.3881826997,
-0.371394664,
0.0611430444,
-0.4565750062,
0.0783357918,
-0.9051356912,
0.5129354,
0.2657990456,
-0.3605858684,
-1.0342023373,
0.2567360103,
0.3611036539,
-0.4179590344,
-0.2574388981,
0.416323036,
-0.5364591479,
-0.2463826537,
-0.2724731565,
0.1755756736,
0.0997780114,
0.7549261451,
0.0414434522,
0.5610278845,
0.5723869801,
-0.5786495805,
0.2391246706,
-0.1036103666,
-0.3285334706,
0.225575909,
-0.8142572641,
0.2695721686,
-0.5746994019,
-0.0083426991,
-1.2263087034,
0.2713534236,
0.2982429266,
-0.2242364585,
0.3360132277,
0.1860827953,
-0.3987629116,
-0.564897716,
-0.5295670033,
0.8729538918,
-0.0765230358,
-0.6226474047,
0.4175908267,
0.1939615905,
0.100931339,
-0.7259961963,
-0.5815662146,
0.0349856243,
-0.056307245,
-0.7533329129,
0.1843587905,
-0.2088135928,
0.0935082212,
-0.1711347401,
-0.1099044159,
-0.080713667,
0.1473483741,
-0.1296380609,
0.1246841177,
-0.2140313238,
-0.0181236379,
-0.5155233145,
-0.4747756124,
-0.1134094894,
-0.8360013962,
0.400033772,
0.1040043831,
-0.5078191161,
-0.5604051352,
0.8181424141,
0.8345317841,
-0.3282945752,
0.4658593833,
0.5489804745,
-0.4392700791,
-0.066351518,
-0.5310494304,
-0.2774139047,
-0.4350418746,
0.6152971983,
-0.4504242837,
-0.3745018244,
0.4989316165,
0.1058183312,
0.1662726104,
-0.1997076273,
0.3627870977,
-0.1021041274,
1.2135688066,
0.8264180422,
-0.1488982886,
0.8005173802,
-0.1621820182,
0.4516187906,
-0.6904758811,
-0.0688188672,
-0.2960126698,
-0.4765305221,
-0.2953798771,
-0.4783699811,
0.6448367834,
-0.1518086493,
-0.2632820606,
0.134103626,
-0.3468921185,
0.378455013,
0.4474821091,
0.4705601037,
0.2823981047,
0.2531046569,
-0.1579450667,
-0.1514005214,
-0.8586118221,
-0.1196325645,
0.897113204,
0.5662841797,
0.9323724508,
-0.0014822513,
0.3964447379,
-0.0533412881,
-0.0282583032,
-0.6153083444,
0.440694809,
-0.2786496282,
-0.3814971745,
-0.2941713929,
-0.4965107143,
-1.188508153,
0.7294105887,
0.2372837216,
-0.5442233682,
0.6762052774,
0.1629167795,
-0.4990261197,
0.4681630731,
-0.5816118121,
0.7434825897,
-0.4222385585,
-0.7142630219,
-0.1890263259,
-0.6664268374,
0.5212237835,
-0.2909687757,
0.1114021689,
0.1115130857,
-0.3464018404,
0.1433988214,
-0.3037226796,
0.905056119,
-0.2201075405,
-0.1068422943,
-0.12847054,
0.0476401038,
0.4501727223,
0.159030959,
-0.0572307073,
0.0689775497,
-0.3232587874,
-0.4016357958,
-0.4197871685,
0.5241255164,
-0.5884776115,
-0.3267031312,
-0.5020871162,
-0.6207785606,
0.050270468,
0.4711434543,
0.0855248272,
0.7229989767,
0.1128922552,
0.008250596,
0.7320058346,
-0.38214764,
0.6844716072,
0.4460344613,
-0.2422749102,
-0.2621868551,
0.7212666273,
-0.0440582223,
0.2157454789,
0.520108819,
0.1138414666,
-0.2812880576,
-0.5381866693,
-0.1292629391,
0.3173034787,
-0.8567490578,
-0.2813141942,
-0.7074203491,
-0.0108591318,
-0.2774669528,
-0.0392612629,
-0.533624351,
-0.2839604914,
-0.0186060164,
0.4058472216,
-0.1006574258,
0.537425518,
-0.3197721541,
-0.0448080413,
-0.5381294489,
0.9652252793,
0.3332478404,
0.5455121994,
0.2560010552,
-0.393455714,
-0.3752847612,
-0.1265442222,
-0.0345194377,
-0.7110493183,
0.3522439599,
0.099810794,
0.7687520385,
0.3821534216,
-0.2840022445,
0.6141107082,
-0.7025697827,
0.3990540504,
0.3308949172,
-0.5904932022,
0.2278363854,
-0.2142409384,
0.7423884869,
0.3068057895,
0.2702440917,
-0.5493110418,
-0.13810651,
-0.38204965,
-1.0882333517,
0.8605692983,
-0.0230841823,
-0.306299448,
0.0223983936,
0.3552798033,
-0.2722663879,
0.1558862329,
-0.746368885,
-0.4849651754,
-0.1964387149,
0.0234009959,
0.0464616157,
-0.4891348481,
0.1093001813,
-0.0690643266,
0.3819639385,
-0.0889765546,
0.4595527351,
0.4111222327,
-0.0769207403,
-0.1177770868,
-0.1253859252,
0.9068489075,
0.7151488662,
-0.1162459254,
0.1889545918,
-0.1661628336,
-0.3349659741,
0.1811427623,
0.1486843824,
-0.1797599643,
0.2219712138,
0.5092023015,
0.5621234179,
0.6062182784,
-0.0194573998,
0.5755868554,
-0.2470268309,
-0.0330323279,
-0.3023751974,
-0.5805629492,
0.2147885412,
0.3589699864,
0.3417415917,
0.4783907533,
0.1898053885,
-0.1214582548,
0.37946105,
0.3113071918,
0.0673839971,
0.0736964047,
0.9475658536,
0.12414404,
-0.0175460745,
0.6766586304,
-0.0195271932,
-0.2831975818,
0.5883233547,
0.332832098,
0.8682633638,
-0.3452695608,
-0.0512483269,
0.7685528994,
0.2986075282,
-0.084257029,
0.4926002026,
-0.0815549344,
-0.9426809549,
-0.3608148098,
-0.2717286348,
0.0756836608,
0.1255353987,
-0.3984460831,
0.0530050434,
-0.6268129945,
-0.1669667065,
0.3363355994,
-0.174568519,
-0.6263971925,
-0.1065883413,
0.5587681532,
0.8318020701,
-0.4960619509,
1.0914424658,
0.5557893515,
-0.4060187936,
-0.4959028661,
-0.2570980787,
0.101563789,
-0.7023115158,
0.6216752529,
0.2642164528,
-0.6828953028,
0.0172066558,
-0.4553160667,
-1.0194052458,
1.0423413515,
0.1126164049,
-0.6997100711,
-0.0419636108,
-0.1057719737,
0.3841730356,
-0.3680525422,
0.1952567399,
0.4428276122,
0.3308321834,
0.0273982175,
-0.5145204067,
-0.1177390218,
-0.3547689915,
0.5511426926,
-0.0203243084,
-0.5290564299,
1.0407596827,
-0.4525614381,
-0.5972512364,
0.293733716,
0.4786395431,
0.2462256551,
0.1970128864,
0.626429677,
0.3819989264,
0.6324428916,
0.1708021909,
1.1652069092,
-0.521509707,
0.2875884771,
1.1908875704,
-0.3645448387,
0.47503227,
0.3805367053,
0.1614759713,
-0.044593364,
0.4295898676,
-0.0324707776,
0.6321757436,
-0.0379933156,
-0.2605937719,
-0.2184489965,
0.1231591329,
-0.2946470082,
0.2264782637,
0.2998065352,
-0.3742028475,
-0.4622191191,
0.164103359,
-0.328009814,
0.1519775391,
-0.3277080655,
0.6376039982,
0.0274992175,
-0.2767080367,
0.4686032236,
0.0916986987,
0.709176302,
-0.730838418,
-0.0518247671,
-0.5457440019,
0.5672181845,
-0.036631722,
-0.4663788378,
0.0685079545,
-0.4679338336,
-0.3899201751,
-0.6252183318,
0.6004988551,
-0.7215718031,
-0.7351605892,
0.4028107226,
0.3186478913,
-0.02783099,
0.0555035695,
-0.8513169885,
0.2992219329,
0.0750155896,
-0.3270757794,
-0.0319753736,
0.4538419545,
0.0946687385,
0.799518764,
0.5971307158,
-0.0197870098,
0.2696284056,
0.4232682586,
0.815947175,
-0.8320689201,
-0.5547210574,
-0.5685742497,
0.6901599169,
-0.0338364467,
-0.1620635688,
0.5133475661,
0.5052683353,
0.7463374734,
-0.1267625839,
0.5356644392,
0.330997467,
0.5985040069,
-0.3162336648,
0.5119847655,
-0.7269921899,
0.3320700824,
-0.0368058123,
-0.6449237466,
-0.6114874482,
0.8536422253,
0.0593135804,
0.0960473493,
0.9173799157,
0.7290115952,
-0.208586812,
-0.2623399496,
0.5794103146,
0.1800671518,
0.407964766,
0.8962477446,
0.6305969954,
-0.539904356,
0.4360865653,
-0.4540528357,
-0.095143117,
-0.254435569,
-0.7826544642,
-0.5914732814,
-0.644010663,
-0.3068527877,
-0.1018343642,
-0.3148857951,
0.5849352479,
0.8532492518,
-0.6330888271,
-0.2127538919,
0.150468871,
0.140197292,
-0.2907958329,
-0.1537279934,
0.3290892243,
-0.6230095625,
-0.6998360753,
0.5746120214,
0.4100902379,
-0.0505725108,
-0.4509034753,
0.3818341494,
-0.6193353534,
-0.2355176806,
0.7209396362,
0.402778089,
-0.4823117554,
-0.2734241486,
-0.0839237049,
-0.5612018108,
0.1002859548,
1.2886410952,
-0.6458213925,
0.7657032609,
0.7029966712,
0.6709250808,
0.5650800467,
-0.0342417099,
0.6065785885,
-0.6139511466,
0.5622525215,
0.2351377755,
0.6266784668,
0.3198250234,
-0.3664762676,
0.4882222414,
0.1239857823,
-0.4634943902,
-0.4693360925,
0.4367045164,
-0.8237309456,
-0.4999228716,
0.6308940053,
-0.1512595862,
-0.1174488962,
-0.2631613612,
0.04190984,
-0.0517041683,
-0.1707406193,
0.5495863557,
0.2112488747,
-0.1158149019,
-0.5594393611,
-0.5248405337,
0.1601809561,
0.4483627975,
-0.4395733476,
-0.0546768866,
0.6422791481,
0.1265009195,
0.422329694,
0.7655906081,
-0.2061207592,
0.409124732,
0.2239086479,
-0.0036175835,
-0.1844041348,
-0.6634796262,
-0.9776652455,
0.3752577007,
-0.0783816576,
-0.519715786
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.21018v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.21018v2
|
Improved Techniques for Optimization-Based Jailbreaking on Large Language Models
| 2024-05-31T17:07:15 | 2024-06-05T16:35:49 |
Xiaojun Jia, Tianyu Pang, Chao Du, Yihao Huang, Jindong Gu, Yang Liu, Xiaochun Cao, Min Lin
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Large language models (LLMs) are being rapidly developed, and a key component
of their widespread deployment is their safety-related alignment. Many
red-teaming efforts aim to jailbreak LLMs, where among these efforts, the
Greedy Coordinate Gradient (GCG) attack's success has led to a growing interest
in the study of optimization-based jailbreaking techniques. Although GCG is a
significant milestone, its attacking efficiency remains unsatisfactory. In this
paper, we present several improved (empirical) techniques for
optimization-based jailbreaks like GCG. We first observe that the single target
template of "Sure" largely limits the attacking performance of GCG; given this,
we propose to apply diverse target templates containing harmful self-suggestion
and/or guidance to mislead LLMs. Besides, from the optimization aspects, we
propose an automatic multi-coordinate updating strategy in GCG (i.e.,
adaptively deciding how many tokens to replace in each step) to accelerate
convergence, as well as tricks like easy-to-hard initialisation. Then, we
combine these improved technologies to develop an efficient jailbreak method,
dubbed I-GCG. In our experiments, we evaluate on a series of benchmarks (such
as NeurIPS 2023 Red Teaming Track). The results demonstrate that our improved
techniques can help GCG outperform state-of-the-art jailbreaking attacks and
achieve nearly 100% attack success rate. The code is released at
https://github.com/jiaxiaojunQAQ/I-GCG.
|
[
-0.3572594225,
-0.8173859715,
0.356107235,
0.3377309144,
-0.3463848829,
0.4192141593,
-0.5490419865,
-0.3893021643,
0.3054699898,
0.4724045098,
-0.6032548547,
-0.8339796662,
-0.7038370371,
-0.0890218988,
-0.1845595539,
0.8899992704,
-0.018057676,
0.1749729812,
0.2595061064,
-0.2176893204,
-0.798637867,
-0.6233840585,
-0.3640277684,
0.1129565164,
0.1851682514,
0.5248137116,
0.4720541239,
0.9401131272,
0.6890730262,
0.2774035931,
-0.1458218247,
0.1189577132,
-0.500807941,
0.1134448126,
0.0400891714,
-0.2883188128,
-0.2827912569,
-0.0029899045,
0.3482239246,
0.1147961766,
-0.3254319727,
-0.0447985493,
-0.078207992,
0.8105854392,
-1.0811015368,
-0.1103704944,
-0.8844934106,
-0.007784443,
-0.3570948243,
0.0583186001,
-0.4717816412,
-0.2741115093,
-0.2367239296,
-0.5295817256,
0.0357846655,
0.1458336413,
0.5575045347,
0.3085159361,
0.0866896287,
-0.3792386353,
-0.322735399,
0.9328308105,
-0.8070563078,
0.1679652333,
0.2469372004,
0.3230769932,
-0.6164785028,
-0.3486485183,
-0.0990929827,
-0.6464378238,
0.1281974912,
0.0214759298,
-0.1675589979,
0.228686884,
0.2776994109,
-0.0896970183,
-0.3870285749,
0.4536953866,
-0.3210183084,
-0.1267990768,
0.6989626288,
0.0493504778,
0.521317482,
0.0452414006,
-0.6554083228,
-0.0640136972,
-0.8520277143,
-0.2499577701,
0.7603505254,
0.2708219886,
-0.3108648956,
0.4651935995,
-0.176209569,
0.9181646109,
0.1810501963,
-0.0426920466,
0.1455948353,
-0.5137301087,
0.1518395841,
0.1755174398,
0.7481097579,
0.6271497011,
0.4288558662,
-0.4125598073,
-0.1407947093,
0.0115895355,
0.5275632739,
-0.6875685453,
-0.2239179164,
0.279168725,
-0.223472178,
-0.3847404718,
-0.0764214098,
-0.8927056193,
-0.5181764364,
-0.0527451634,
0.0700080767,
-0.6294660568,
0.1032189205,
0.2264914066,
-0.1447982341,
0.3153706193,
0.2617279887,
-1.1976864338,
0.2371261716,
0.8379621506,
0.8849000335,
-0.118409887,
-0.203863889,
-0.8853458762,
0.206461072,
-0.1103460565,
0.5047770739,
-0.2645746171,
-0.2315696627,
-0.2126429379,
-0.4821747541,
-0.1033180058,
-0.5859342217,
0.5088973045,
-0.561426878,
-0.2670858502,
-0.1399698555,
-0.5095543861,
0.0955041498,
0.5121238828,
-0.6422250867,
0.5861577392,
-0.1211414263,
-0.8813467026,
0.2675089836,
-0.5640298724,
-0.3473936617,
-0.0643211529,
0.0222179666,
-0.6590532064,
0.1202464476,
0.4648547769,
0.3880821466,
-0.3401804566,
0.2878328264,
-0.4175413251,
-0.5408526063,
-0.1845540106,
0.0965917408,
0.9236000776,
0.338702172,
-0.5723831058,
0.0523202345,
-0.4359683394,
0.1571584493,
0.2880879045,
-0.3059330881,
-0.3840861917,
0.3109090626,
-0.353898108,
-0.1922484338,
0.1721325368,
-0.5693085194,
0.6332431436,
-0.3613868058,
0.5514144301,
0.7205532789,
-0.097701095,
0.3989174664,
-0.033000499,
0.59194839,
-0.3001690507,
0.290964812,
0.1184434444,
-0.1224497035,
-0.321100831,
-0.5207278132,
0.3566658497,
0.7373650074,
-0.5003815293,
0.4699814618,
0.0296279564,
-0.5029562116,
-0.3462487757,
0.4712132812,
0.5626847148,
0.1562337726,
0.623478651,
-0.2438553423,
-0.5895716548,
-0.6998220086,
-0.8118363023,
-0.1301475614,
0.35530442,
0.0634546727,
0.3506640196,
-0.1613125801,
0.564160347,
-0.5132021904,
-0.2157977521,
-0.3138402104,
-0.1415780038,
0.1843865365,
0.6945526004,
0.934099853,
-0.4053448737,
-0.6504643559,
-0.1339799464,
-0.6021279693,
-0.216763407,
-0.0996738449,
-0.0851769671,
0.0179121755,
0.9687164426,
-0.4751552045,
0.1478434354,
0.6449116468,
-0.1931559891,
0.9420606494,
-0.2581879497,
0.0084344512,
-0.622255981,
-0.2972470224,
0.3378425539,
-0.0335014276,
-0.8656271696,
0.6262885332,
0.3290015757,
0.26227054,
-0.5776517391,
0.4347701669,
-0.80641675,
0.2805618644,
-0.1569004208,
0.2530603707,
-0.5968586206,
0.4712713659,
-0.6676834822,
0.7227468491,
0.5557230711,
-0.1618805975,
0.4088236988,
-0.0645903647,
-0.3339248598,
0.2366599739,
-0.5184796453,
0.3680663407,
-0.2450175434,
0.001411699,
-0.8609621525,
0.0166464504,
0.4969986081,
-0.2230760604,
0.6025437713,
-0.6357125044,
-0.5072904825,
-0.1990146637,
-0.6418511271,
0.5031394362,
0.3492210507,
-0.83340168,
0.3275534809,
0.3696655035,
0.1179388389,
-0.95139575,
-0.3063916266,
0.4464254379,
-0.8074473739,
-0.6037169099,
0.3973460495,
0.0804756805,
-0.5720546842,
-0.2970598638,
-0.1441635787,
0.195757851,
0.4575010836,
-0.1474486142,
0.4946279526,
0.1890006065,
-0.2472131997,
-0.1635220349,
-0.218275398,
-0.0123443333,
-0.6209440231,
0.6498440504,
-0.1385812014,
-0.211007461,
-0.1883739084,
0.1500110626,
0.5146198273,
-0.2933931053,
0.7276819348,
0.4221936464,
-0.0953598544,
-0.3214434683,
-0.7798147798,
-0.0297675095,
-0.5043954849,
0.5666000843,
-0.1047744229,
-0.974671483,
0.5499995351,
-0.1947865933,
0.1176193133,
-0.102929756,
0.4798811376,
0.0043650712,
0.9682193995,
0.6211135387,
-0.6712639332,
0.6312578321,
-0.1333854198,
0.4585071206,
-0.8705481291,
-0.0655020401,
-0.698964119,
-0.2918674946,
-0.6422446966,
-0.3979953825,
0.3479451537,
0.7584941387,
-0.2000664026,
0.6920195818,
-0.5325862765,
0.7006773353,
0.2853831947,
-0.0316270739,
0.0507722758,
-0.0041457713,
-0.3124631345,
-0.0901667997,
-0.6925384402,
-0.0700479969,
1.1961513758,
0.193204537,
1.0752091408,
0.1830027848,
1.0186139345,
0.1924546957,
0.341163516,
-0.639451921,
0.4464402199,
-0.3491210639,
-0.3034839034,
-0.0218162648,
-0.408041805,
-0.7099373937,
0.3554980755,
-0.1975383162,
-1.2390844822,
-0.2072708458,
0.4535142183,
-0.1946379244,
0.3804214299,
-0.7801653743,
0.8558203578,
-0.5616847873,
-0.3643970191,
-0.3868250251,
-0.6388682723,
0.5582786798,
-0.1229250431,
0.3469006419,
-0.1043146253,
0.1433832943,
0.5033399463,
-0.7267274261,
0.5899749994,
-0.5180417895,
-0.0190165248,
0.2099856138,
0.0380865298,
0.9637361765,
-0.0691220462,
-0.047507979,
0.2033167183,
-0.549334228,
-0.4034318924,
-0.5779651403,
0.731677413,
-0.5727011561,
-0.8051276803,
-0.0741739199,
-0.4767421186,
-0.1337545812,
0.0616675057,
0.2608552873,
0.1812948138,
0.0137041155,
0.0147237536,
0.3227275908,
-0.4277322292,
0.4659791887,
0.0747472644,
-0.0031024194,
-0.5793278813,
0.6920286417,
-0.0835443214,
0.537846148,
0.0471808203,
0.1068706438,
-0.1898264885,
-1.1015832424,
-0.4905656874,
0.3649840057,
-0.4297849238,
-0.4834035635,
-0.5062850714,
-0.0974037275,
-0.2922287285,
-0.5336804986,
-0.3306474984,
-0.3510742486,
0.1138554141,
0.0276233591,
0.3702335656,
0.1834266931,
-0.2662086487,
0.5133194327,
-0.6372323632,
0.3165415823,
-0.1016920879,
0.3479483128,
-0.0964261442,
-0.1280896813,
-0.4808089435,
-0.106333755,
-0.169045791,
-0.8636103868,
0.3595150709,
-0.1226480007,
0.5018125772,
0.0931946933,
-0.062317092,
0.7089080811,
-0.586638093,
0.300383687,
0.5403007269,
-0.9472455382,
0.5602714419,
-0.5567572117,
0.037497662,
0.7306726575,
-0.0718266666,
-0.3474140465,
-0.6142582297,
-0.2374265343,
-1.1093679667,
0.7074831128,
0.0053074723,
0.0145397251,
-0.0002322282,
0.7192293406,
-0.3470705152,
0.0535750613,
-0.610570848,
-0.4501805007,
0.0369292162,
-0.1209747866,
0.1230581775,
-0.1346651316,
-0.1967630088,
-0.105739288,
0.6024879217,
-0.1545760632,
-0.0039179078,
-0.0677619204,
-0.1967453361,
0.1395752877,
0.3281794786,
0.6128210425,
0.3450597227,
-0.2568099201,
-0.1862873137,
0.2017039359,
-0.7316266298,
0.4404371083,
0.1231506169,
-0.286203146,
-0.3208059072,
0.1482390761,
0.4921440482,
-0.1468128711,
-0.833172977,
0.5535877347,
-0.0833461955,
-0.1759762764,
-0.152198568,
0.3819851577,
-0.0562278517,
0.2316190153,
0.1678725481,
-0.0255436562,
-0.1891694665,
-0.3586660028,
0.0796379074,
0.7939263582,
-0.3283047974,
0.1872676611,
0.7650153637,
-0.1462361664,
-0.2685818374,
0.6258158684,
-0.2632286847,
-0.7349876165,
0.7655092478,
0.6743047833,
1.0712665319,
-0.0445631295,
-0.0476907566,
0.4782189429,
0.5806801915,
-0.3559116721,
-0.0443479978,
-0.0484971963,
-0.8743275404,
-0.7615053058,
-0.3785098195,
-0.2235300839,
-0.0574349463,
-0.4140222371,
0.4403524399,
-0.9284795523,
-0.0944432691,
-0.2595745921,
-0.0285015702,
-0.2141414583,
-0.0793044493,
0.0451249667,
0.9644373059,
-0.215759933,
0.7126819491,
0.4822217524,
0.2488750517,
-0.7698312402,
-0.009468846,
0.2900060415,
-0.7953751683,
0.5422016382,
0.149747476,
-0.1281528473,
-0.083201848,
-0.7946100831,
-0.8737857938,
0.7282169461,
0.4936348498,
-1.0375965834,
0.1032421589,
-0.1246205196,
0.2316882312,
-0.1834999174,
-0.115042001,
0.9555177093,
0.6164524555,
-0.2322579622,
-0.6649320126,
0.1626463681,
-0.1398993731,
-0.2044231743,
0.6816186905,
-0.6548909545,
0.6152841449,
-0.746068418,
-0.0576361902,
0.2658877969,
0.2332028747,
0.6100117564,
-0.272220701,
0.5494933724,
1.0367375612,
0.5108516216,
-0.2335556149,
1.0429935455,
-0.5272714496,
0.5173249245,
1.1998482943,
-0.0816806555,
0.266536206,
0.4807936847,
0.2280739248,
0.245383054,
0.0159067679,
-0.3834907413,
0.7740641236,
0.7978152037,
-0.3075044155,
-0.021373244,
0.33861202,
-0.1257300079,
0.4815098345,
0.244424507,
-0.060452044,
-0.4435384572,
-0.0795132741,
0.6124486327,
0.0552108847,
-0.3848161101,
0.7175917625,
-0.0322959051,
-0.5989912152,
0.857196033,
0.6638818979,
0.8926793933,
-0.5573967695,
0.2035223693,
-0.0483334586,
0.2133013457,
-0.1694376022,
-0.2610735893,
-0.0082886536,
0.4343908727,
0.3113368452,
-0.0826871842,
0.8011731505,
-0.2694892585,
-0.0540666282,
0.6851232052,
0.1450459659,
-0.2635633647,
0.0041597295,
-0.7076964974,
0.340338856,
0.1784483194,
-0.0155165596,
0.4723977149,
-0.1097675562,
-0.0082632843,
0.6271699667,
0.5528588891,
0.3929602504,
0.2567210793,
-0.0793853924,
0.9723550081,
-0.856906414,
-0.3831814229,
-1.330991745,
0.5146303177,
-0.0557452813,
-0.0283582415,
0.7813533545,
0.3951069415,
0.8487295508,
0.2395237237,
0.8029518723,
-0.1393114924,
-0.0178957824,
-0.8764808178,
0.5563622117,
-0.1900563538,
0.5368243456,
-0.5881686211,
-1.0351672173,
-0.5788169503,
0.5858607292,
-0.4162970185,
-0.1660725027,
0.4289647043,
0.824230969,
0.1469612718,
-0.133512646,
0.0175825693,
0.2491707951,
0.6263094544,
0.6715872288,
0.9352815151,
-0.3548993766,
0.2961082458,
-0.2578319907,
-0.2659677863,
-0.1275803745,
-1.0441952944,
-0.8633633852,
0.1366138011,
-0.2691358924,
-0.5463817716,
0.5257024765,
1.016682148,
0.5989937782,
-0.5577683449,
-0.204298377,
-0.2173630297,
0.0810298398,
0.0049750349,
-0.1593285799,
0.1946169138,
-0.6225782037,
-0.4514680505,
0.6356399655,
0.4900234938,
-0.0820626095,
0.0276684612,
-0.0941353068,
-0.0422171392,
-0.2234608978,
0.2663284242,
0.4117636383,
-0.3941318989,
-0.5107575059,
-0.227115646,
-0.0024161572,
0.164547503,
1.0052528381,
-0.4863067865,
0.3403508663,
0.1271862835,
0.8850393295,
0.3341914713,
0.4159978628,
0.5594229102,
-0.6941022277,
0.3171944022,
0.1622188836,
0.550861299,
0.165448159,
-0.34187904,
0.4329052269,
0.1459530294,
-0.4800154567,
-0.7121894956,
0.231996268,
-0.7280166149,
-0.4244871736,
1.0271441936,
-0.231719628,
-0.1469813585,
-0.0490222052,
-0.0823366791,
-0.0628103018,
-0.3334047794,
0.9488873482,
0.5857897401,
0.03555898,
0.2069324851,
-0.3718433976,
0.4690635204,
0.4988348186,
-0.8534004688,
0.3220126033,
0.5983976126,
0.3225537241,
0.013725644,
0.4601840973,
-0.4968907833,
0.2709797323,
-0.3300364614,
-0.0202334821,
-0.033775121,
-0.4537661672,
-0.5040537715,
0.1715823412,
-0.0351616181,
-0.1251111329
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20999v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20999v1
|
Towards a Fluid computer
| 2024-05-31T16:41:36 | 2024-05-31T16:41:36 |
Robert Cardona, Eva Miranda, Daniel Peralta-Salas
|
math.DS
|
math.DS, cs.CL, math.AP, math.SG
|
In 1991, Moore [20] raised a question about whether hydrodynamics is capable
of performing computations. Similarly, in 2016, Tao [25] asked whether a
mechanical system, including a fluid flow, can simulate a universal Turing
machine. In this expository article, we review the construction in [8] of a
"Fluid computer" in dimension 3 that combines techniques in symbolic dynamics
with the connection between steady Euler flows and contact geometry unveiled by
Etnyre and Ghrist. In addition, we argue that the metric that renders the
vector field Beltrami cannot be critical in the Chern-Hamilton sense [9]. We
also sketch the completely different construction for the Euclidean metric in
$\mathbb R^3$ as given in [7]. These results reveal the existence of
undecidable fluid particle paths. We conclude the article with a list of open
problems.
|
[
-0.2583251894,
-1.0093727112,
1.0782600641,
-0.182718426,
-0.1772134751,
0.2131607234,
0.1657051593,
-0.7544293404,
0.5376891494,
0.3985995054,
-0.6484187841,
0.0890681073,
-0.361929208,
-0.0652359203,
-0.8295173049,
0.815647006,
-0.6214764118,
-0.1705010086,
-0.1074426174,
-0.0701145977,
-0.22665447,
-0.6359136105,
-0.4519799948,
-0.3774878979,
0.4058601558,
0.167053476,
1.0777993202,
0.6994743943,
0.6610720754,
0.4769444466,
-0.0581427366,
-0.0483104438,
-0.2309263945,
0.7343443036,
0.1906834096,
-0.3703472018,
-0.082009688,
0.0001031891,
0.6712597013,
1.1258116961,
0.0114981113,
-0.171337828,
0.2020478398,
1.1252425909,
-0.5718355179,
0.0692338496,
-0.1768489033,
0.5340180993,
-0.492298305,
-0.2374111265,
-0.0615002997,
-0.3184344769,
0.0819591731,
-0.8504986167,
0.2096881568,
0.2096118033,
0.651607573,
0.2581900656,
-0.0589117892,
-0.3408308923,
-1.5480087996,
0.6279583573,
0.2411350608,
0.321411401,
0.0069034076,
0.684317708,
-0.0926948339,
-0.93508178,
-0.5237722993,
0.3054448962,
0.4587072134,
0.219391346,
-0.4389846623,
0.0995584652,
0.469288379,
0.1589937061,
-0.3585286438,
-0.5458658934,
-0.8687685132,
-0.1345717311,
0.4826076925,
0.6201366782,
0.3402028382,
0.4461889565,
-0.2134381682,
0.0276659615,
-0.4509334862,
0.3150345683,
0.5096823573,
-0.0702578872,
-0.2443589568,
0.558455646,
-0.1830033362,
0.5292409062,
-0.2418987751,
-0.0152902855,
-0.2126244754,
0.2394213825,
-0.1436248571,
0.0619775057,
0.9220696688,
-0.0624453649,
0.5189545155,
-0.0785687715,
-0.0875478014,
-0.138751179,
0.526592195,
-0.7996612787,
-0.3973657191,
0.602358222,
-0.238545686,
-0.281832248,
0.6179890633,
-0.4916474521,
-0.6593443155,
-0.34973827,
0.1466303468,
-0.2691564858,
-0.0460734442,
-0.0252809133,
-0.1541162133,
-0.104278475,
0.4649120569,
-0.5268167257,
0.3771918714,
0.805357635,
0.9727907777,
0.0722240135,
-0.3193382323,
-0.1024312899,
0.4419317544,
-0.674731493,
1.0824484825,
-0.4917217493,
-0.4577290118,
0.3233816028,
-0.1305714101,
0.2964909077,
-0.5558362603,
0.2601764798,
-0.4677243829,
0.0184353143,
-0.2459322959,
-0.3393019438,
-0.4267537296,
-0.2405812889,
-0.6352462173,
0.4746523201,
-0.1341721565,
-0.9093394876,
-0.0343411006,
-0.5234837532,
-0.414924711,
-0.0492899939,
-0.3882885277,
-0.1286904961,
0.097721681,
-0.5351501703,
0.4218355417,
-0.4718536437,
0.3457883,
-1.0915443897,
-0.5546565652,
0.6246817112,
-0.4654826522,
0.8524025083,
0.4401081204,
-0.2253220081,
-0.0982129276,
-0.6000549197,
0.373292923,
-0.0765871108,
-0.0435717627,
0.0960383117,
0.0437335074,
-0.0568146445,
-0.1942014694,
0.0985725969,
-0.6309986115,
0.0310503468,
-0.0061348309,
0.5057120323,
0.5322518945,
-0.1332017332,
0.5099304914,
-0.4807740152,
0.6806311607,
-0.0461156815,
0.0513419397,
0.2442522347,
-0.6991960406,
-0.8101817966,
-0.2192166299,
0.0081748208,
0.6889815927,
-0.9163151383,
-0.0696512759,
0.0179192107,
-0.5219727159,
-0.357301563,
-0.0527089685,
0.0521892719,
0.2264774442,
0.1946989596,
0.303355366,
-0.5689664483,
-0.7370044589,
-0.1280180961,
-0.5109439492,
-0.3564995527,
0.4673385322,
0.1564604342,
0.1466203332,
0.6810065508,
-0.7741875648,
0.1467027813,
0.0483743101,
-0.0047693835,
0.2760756612,
0.4740253985,
0.2087099999,
-0.0577136539,
-0.481784761,
0.1615180522,
-1.0695673227,
0.0019663966,
0.3374831975,
-0.2721324265,
0.0580035113,
0.8794307113,
-0.698140502,
0.4979301989,
0.3480741382,
-0.4061550498,
0.2533635497,
-0.451685071,
0.0076206597,
-0.6558169127,
0.3671461046,
-0.2768470049,
-0.2292445451,
-0.8139640689,
-0.1982558817,
-0.042534437,
-0.3773186207,
-0.5668712258,
0.4723551571,
-0.1525923461,
0.0988438204,
-0.5360912085,
-0.0437009074,
-0.2655868232,
0.2230028808,
-0.0454058088,
0.3115585744,
0.8175614476,
-0.8827650547,
0.7331647873,
-0.2572036684,
0.1676366925,
0.801882267,
-1.0296860933,
0.1741292328,
-0.2917080224,
0.3682389259,
-0.598233223,
-0.2957526147,
0.2938894629,
-0.0722367987,
0.1378782243,
0.332000643,
-0.0719137117,
-0.4516518414,
-0.3548981547,
0.8173612356,
0.5875869393,
-0.4307982028,
0.3534673452,
0.8703036308,
0.1519153267,
-0.2598370314,
-0.5728973746,
-0.3715324104,
-0.2226379514,
-0.6502342224,
0.0652440786,
-0.2685545981,
-0.8930917382,
-0.0607693009,
0.2796427011,
-0.7196447849,
0.0724722892,
0.5147315264,
0.3239860833,
-0.0985392258,
-0.2297882885,
0.0238471907,
-0.1523075551,
0.3102722466,
-0.2742578089,
0.1739705503,
-0.3468302488,
-0.2957563698,
-0.8639816642,
0.3539206088,
0.5313317776,
0.6325632334,
0.1649566293,
0.5845919847,
-0.7504881024,
-0.0241051428,
-0.0075415303,
0.1221568137,
-0.5313777924,
-0.1460820138,
-0.6280392408,
-0.9620816708,
0.4464360476,
0.2327419668,
-0.2600260377,
0.6591762304,
0.4247561097,
-0.4201715291,
0.9010207653,
0.7320798039,
-0.108180061,
-0.0917906314,
-0.4027198255,
0.1490007639,
-0.645405829,
-0.369566679,
-0.9531716704,
-0.5061019063,
-0.72296381,
-0.229257673,
0.558571279,
0.451213032,
-0.6167815328,
0.1734110713,
-0.4289395511,
0.5662369132,
0.2492436916,
-0.1387854517,
0.0696058124,
-0.1372742504,
-0.632237792,
0.034914393,
-0.88223809,
-0.4265580773,
0.4582387805,
0.3606895208,
0.6739438176,
0.1699526906,
0.4384588003,
-0.1610924304,
0.3721504509,
-0.3364587724,
0.3434861004,
0.2125020027,
-1.0968180895,
-0.4815141857,
-0.2736170888,
-1.1310840845,
0.0466963239,
-0.1887708604,
-0.847573936,
-0.0203987919,
-0.0922917277,
-0.6463376284,
0.7667889595,
-0.440767169,
0.4890465736,
0.2306995243,
-0.5340293646,
-0.01680886,
-0.4763520062,
0.6041835546,
0.0238740053,
0.4514001608,
-0.2912055254,
-0.3648546934,
0.3726342022,
-0.8820622563,
0.6286820173,
-0.0583510362,
0.0357004926,
0.9509450197,
0.7375542521,
-0.2919874191,
0.2597506046,
0.3565481305,
0.1588085592,
0.4160358906,
-0.420899123,
-0.5829381347,
0.8108480573,
-0.8986471295,
-0.3399684131,
-0.6468414664,
-0.5552960038,
-0.1497506499,
0.127297461,
-0.0031853209,
0.6042320132,
-0.3362749815,
0.0282207318,
0.3759846389,
-0.0442696698,
0.8961791992,
0.1608048975,
-0.4394204915,
-0.3425250947,
0.8751110435,
0.1058591083,
-0.1804977804,
0.2344354391,
0.2880148888,
-0.0493715107,
0.147677809,
-0.6607347131,
0.1961089522,
-0.4247988462,
-0.2293621749,
-0.3899645507,
-0.6179990768,
0.2721530497,
-0.2633633316,
-0.4587389231,
-0.7614121437,
-0.4050805867,
0.3898285925,
0.5376415849,
1.4929395914,
-0.2246796787,
-0.1405118704,
-0.6060916185,
0.0753626227,
0.294097811,
0.555508852,
0.0330397822,
-0.394433111,
-0.0787419304,
-0.1186569408,
-0.8267976642,
-0.4728935957,
-0.0481951758,
-0.1593084782,
0.1612144411,
0.7942854762,
-0.0701908916,
0.7887905836,
-0.8489945531,
0.6453680992,
0.3472583294,
-0.9474759102,
0.2721139491,
-0.5214785337,
0.1200130358,
0.1887161881,
0.8527047634,
-0.3025025427,
-0.5882043242,
-1.1218216419,
-0.3032179177,
0.1236149073,
0.2869957387,
0.0922555104,
0.1916506737,
0.6723520756,
0.0674478412,
0.1207848415,
-0.1506567448,
-0.5093721747,
0.0685253814,
0.0477610268,
0.1130856425,
-0.0320889503,
0.06988924,
-0.4138817787,
0.4496175647,
0.0270934105,
0.3055241406,
0.5180835128,
0.6726187468,
-0.3201109767,
-0.1842650026,
0.5456406474,
0.4713428617,
0.121541068,
0.4151683152,
-0.1581832767,
-0.4508658946,
0.1912206709,
-0.0677205399,
-0.4208386838,
0.0571463518,
0.1866080761,
0.4610452354,
-0.132994771,
-0.3018646538,
0.2042998075,
-0.2408221811,
-0.7121354938,
-0.2486889064,
0.2976354957,
0.0202079993,
0.3360425234,
-0.2828469872,
0.2306681871,
0.194222495,
-0.6055540442,
-0.0195288267,
0.5279667377,
-1.2654021978,
-0.5443537235,
1.1156301498,
0.1670738906,
-0.4768536091,
0.3067961037,
-0.03422416,
-0.4053212106,
0.2049855143,
0.088128373,
1.0474408865,
-0.0270564351,
0.1114644632,
0.4177523255,
0.2083105445,
-0.1248743311,
0.7499415874,
0.1287544072,
-0.7103320956,
-0.0215275791,
-0.2147354633,
-0.8247514367,
-0.061395146,
-0.2514374554,
0.2875904143,
-0.9142640829,
-0.0722117126,
0.2340950221,
-0.0589407161,
-0.6160536408,
-0.27138412,
-0.0088579468,
0.4093498588,
-0.3163222075,
0.5642489791,
0.7480248213,
-0.2124948949,
-0.6400586963,
-0.2885885537,
0.1275761425,
-0.2804997861,
0.1949778795,
-0.0266681686,
-0.2049897462,
-0.3710200191,
-0.4692121446,
-0.7263165116,
1.0211622715,
0.562841773,
0.0499793179,
0.5448265672,
0.4057564437,
0.6055582762,
-0.1203431115,
0.5549511313,
0.2735772729,
0.2599203587,
-0.1099202856,
-0.9332026243,
-0.052913744,
-0.3220509887,
0.149020195,
0.1050814092,
-0.8165459037,
1.1044020653,
-0.2588774264,
-0.3796851635,
0.3634044826,
0.7526601553,
0.2751197219,
0.1058301851,
0.2501130998,
0.3080045283,
0.9845784903,
-0.133948952,
1.2387782335,
-0.7297680378,
0.1802655607,
0.1585796028,
-0.4931262434,
0.5571321845,
0.5026420951,
-0.4876529276,
0.5815187693,
0.1733245701,
0.5415024161,
-0.0789188147,
0.5263077617,
-0.4766532183,
-0.0300936867,
-0.1005329713,
-0.2325130552,
0.3805305064,
0.0527314991,
0.2735430002,
-0.0868447199,
-0.296995312,
-0.0101888552,
0.2805070579,
-0.1946556568,
0.2568655312,
0.2896449566,
-0.3274735212,
0.503177166,
-0.0300674289,
0.2109285593,
-0.2704085112,
-0.0595453121,
0.1077928618,
0.318795681,
-0.055854626,
-0.8464871645,
0.5565978885,
0.0950367525,
-0.0867607445,
-0.0672462434,
0.79145962,
0.0020084667,
-0.5547615886,
-0.2643380463,
0.8171351552,
0.6060969234,
0.1241899282,
-0.6095656157,
0.3247833252,
-0.3991346061,
-0.0141633945,
0.060700547,
1.0358800888,
0.2380931973,
0.9657469988,
0.3582025468,
0.0650678873,
-0.1983772367,
-0.1468146741,
0.504032433,
-0.9962986112,
-0.5180317163,
-0.8008648157,
0.1334582567,
0.1751459688,
-0.4223744571,
0.2552911937,
0.7675265074,
0.6701239944,
0.0554020666,
0.9400935173,
0.0904772282,
0.7440510988,
-0.5357348323,
0.8305091262,
-0.3710979819,
-0.0783918723,
-0.3521526456,
-0.8299804926,
-0.3908980191,
0.6632793546,
0.3395489454,
0.1929737777,
1.3520770073,
0.4456194341,
-0.009371995,
0.6376317739,
0.4619423151,
0.165045172,
0.2604946494,
0.5221626759,
1.0736335516,
-0.5065139532,
0.4497188628,
-0.5871880651,
-0.1322789788,
0.2789700627,
-0.7530952692,
-0.772518158,
-0.6298108101,
-0.2906683981,
-0.5686744452,
-0.1901675463,
0.3724423647,
0.4034631848,
-0.6188719869,
-0.752417624,
-0.2124284208,
0.0575287901,
0.1341486573,
-0.1158932224,
-0.0237805434,
-0.1953287125,
-0.6639788151,
0.0683599561,
0.3723887503,
0.4176386893,
-0.6042968035,
0.0307440888,
0.5544878244,
-0.0941829309,
0.4237395227,
0.5005005002,
-0.288132906,
-0.3520051539,
0.0513057597,
-0.0662667826,
-0.1037583798,
1.2160710096,
-0.7366675138,
0.1490396559,
0.3857476711,
0.5459671617,
0.4034110606,
-0.4879568219,
0.5827240348,
0.0044919509,
0.3343810737,
-0.0430721566,
0.4886835814,
0.1112112999,
-0.1412685812,
0.3621250689,
0.6190997362,
-0.6085695028,
-0.5107214451,
0.144100979,
-0.8193669915,
-0.3550493419,
1.1662160158,
0.3549498618,
-0.5377004743,
-0.1367842257,
-0.123694472,
0.0904060751,
-0.1427695751,
0.7791773677,
0.7068673372,
-0.6210690141,
0.5812574625,
-1.2584241629,
0.4629738629,
-0.0996423811,
-0.5971844792,
0.0086106313,
0.2914174795,
0.1334404051,
0.2128442079,
0.8166293502,
-0.1617024988,
0.0378123894,
0.086275883,
0.0141837755,
0.1925798357,
-0.6225196719,
-0.1717555523,
0.2088726908,
-0.021192776,
0.0150948148
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20994v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20994v1
|
CWRCzech: 100M Query-Document Czech Click Dataset and Its Application to Web Relevance Ranking
| 2024-05-31T16:38:54 | 2024-05-31T16:38:54 |
Josef Vonášek, Milan Straka, Rostislav Krč, Lenka Lasoňová, Ekaterina Egorova, Jana Straková, Jakub Náplava
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
We present CWRCzech, Click Web Ranking dataset for Czech, a 100M
query-document Czech click dataset for relevance ranking with user behavior
data collected from search engine logs of Seznam.cz. To the best of our
knowledge, CWRCzech is the largest click dataset with raw text published so
far. It provides document positions in the search results as well as
information about user behavior: 27.6M clicked documents and 10.8M dwell times.
In addition, we also publish a manually annotated Czech test for the relevance
task, containing nearly 50k query-document pairs, each annotated by at least 2
annotators. Finally, we analyze how the user behavior data improve relevance
ranking and show that models trained on data automatically harnessed at
sufficient scale can surpass the performance of models trained on human
annotated data. CWRCzech is published under an academic non-commercial license
and is available to the research community at
https://github.com/seznam/CWRCzech.
|
[
-0.5042897463,
-0.4724119008,
0.5008808374,
0.2813867033,
-0.2563739121,
-0.0786360279,
-0.5593714714,
-0.358025372,
0.2635208666,
0.5663352609,
-0.6687008142,
-1.0732141733,
-0.3638800681,
0.002466318,
-0.5583850741,
0.7433946133,
0.3512414992,
0.2638782859,
-0.4606063366,
-0.2855392694,
-0.0156556927,
-0.6805400252,
-0.107963942,
-0.0468305387,
0.9047523141,
0.4207431376,
0.4845755696,
0.087067835,
0.5522753,
0.2373724133,
0.274056673,
-0.0681847185,
-0.7301279902,
0.3741514981,
-0.3189813197,
-0.2876466811,
-0.405490905,
0.3348367214,
0.2538485527,
0.8043510318,
-0.1737288237,
0.3494751453,
0.1528258622,
0.8256604671,
-0.5737096667,
-0.1483788937,
-0.602830112,
-0.4047198296,
-0.3777919114,
-0.5526391864,
-0.7457665205,
-0.4920061827,
0.039525412,
-0.6611349583,
0.5374333858,
0.2786003947,
0.6155665517,
0.1127255484,
-0.6981809735,
-0.1649327576,
-0.4045931101,
0.752327621,
-0.3331600428,
0.4891578555,
0.52224195,
0.2539302111,
-0.1670615524,
-0.8803845048,
-0.1500702947,
-0.3670794964,
0.1037193462,
-0.0007242073,
-0.080561474,
0.0942195281,
0.4805756807,
-0.0658877864,
-1.0370429754,
-0.2237191051,
-0.3589715958,
-0.3886627853,
0.6498188376,
0.4018887877,
0.2387161851,
0.1560761631,
-0.2962347269,
-0.364910841,
-0.5538694263,
0.0320436023,
0.6151717901,
0.5078756213,
0.3470381498,
0.5648534894,
-0.7858622074,
0.8602500558,
0.0529001318,
0.3396905363,
0.3111215532,
-0.4280210733,
0.1136060506,
-0.0324293822,
0.6464944482,
0.4788638055,
-0.0694885179,
-0.3578700423,
0.235151872,
-0.095427461,
0.7308042645,
-0.9301652908,
-0.4197044969,
0.2426414192,
-0.4816803634,
-0.2203177214,
0.6644397974,
-0.6785971522,
-0.0869392529,
-0.2841465175,
0.4828136265,
-0.0148259224,
-0.0404998064,
0.1745974272,
-0.1514421254,
0.2923088372,
0.5304738879,
-0.6017727852,
0.2357058376,
0.5993587971,
0.4208907783,
-0.6948968768,
-0.4579553604,
-0.4245598614,
-0.242465809,
-0.5305737853,
0.8528965712,
-0.4888937473,
-0.3567088842,
0.1785773933,
0.2945871949,
0.0576961227,
-0.5740351677,
0.6975966692,
-1.0112684965,
0.1969911754,
-0.5754250884,
-0.483341068,
-0.0892178416,
0.2385113686,
-0.9091558456,
1.4424791336,
0.2870607674,
-0.8462195396,
0.7618183494,
-0.4803722203,
-0.4659105837,
0.1879101843,
0.2105413079,
-0.0574866496,
0.0058916244,
-0.3506036699,
0.270319432,
-0.2203626484,
0.0223177783,
-0.5912522674,
-0.2738122046,
0.1410056651,
-0.2597507834,
0.8875243068,
-0.0695101917,
-0.2421262115,
0.0569104105,
-0.6275006533,
0.4470776916,
-0.1204482168,
-0.7904733419,
-0.4447618425,
-0.3284328282,
0.531001687,
0.4964203238,
0.6291642189,
-0.5424655676,
0.416293174,
-0.0277912505,
-0.1135951653,
0.3366783857,
-0.0403035022,
0.4648995697,
0.220339492,
0.5681120753,
-0.6787854433,
0.3524394631,
0.2033953071,
-0.3417739272,
-0.4111236036,
0.2095198184,
0.6882533431,
0.3294122815,
-0.3876665831,
0.4892541766,
-0.3948366344,
-0.4931459427,
-0.3591056466,
0.1532619596,
-0.0759230554,
0.4646168351,
0.0974732563,
-0.0757986978,
-0.4053839147,
-0.7147441506,
-0.215706408,
-0.0650061816,
-0.2794968784,
0.2894697487,
0.5163348913,
-0.0853314698,
1.0029662848,
-0.6355451941,
-0.2243093699,
-0.0341401473,
0.3623555005,
0.2105638683,
0.0866164789,
0.5126638412,
-1.3297300339,
-0.6537545323,
-0.2514622509,
-0.5718762875,
-0.1525859684,
0.4052477777,
-0.3672347963,
0.3474995494,
0.4016375542,
-0.3574554622,
0.8286017776,
0.6347383261,
-0.5394560099,
0.8505845666,
-0.1627580523,
0.7128587365,
-0.792576611,
0.422903955,
-0.1947487891,
-0.3353588879,
-0.426561445,
-0.0009598781,
0.2658278048,
-0.0911313966,
-0.6974749565,
0.6390569806,
-0.3044063747,
-0.125595063,
-0.3890838027,
0.2221497148,
-0.0613493361,
0.5408049226,
-0.0391231254,
1.0185284615,
0.2298534214,
-0.7532525063,
0.5459994078,
0.3394073546,
-0.2621749938,
0.4681047797,
-0.3509554565,
-0.0268443152,
0.7053748369,
0.2928591073,
-1.0206192732,
-0.4439654946,
-0.2970900834,
-0.9449922442,
-0.0146009661,
-0.2905706465,
-0.8300044537,
-0.6011155248,
-0.6592321396,
0.1861682087,
0.0728328452,
-0.6389876604,
0.4308553636,
0.37234056,
-0.1278294325,
-0.4251895547,
-0.3703344762,
0.339715451,
-0.055464074,
-0.5720584393,
0.3169924617,
-0.4443558753,
0.060339652,
-0.0440143123,
-0.1710909754,
-0.1566067785,
0.2203597724,
0.4712091386,
0.2911144793,
0.0036197053,
0.2449077517,
-0.3104431033,
-0.2257897407,
-0.0627660304,
-0.1899757087,
0.8066329956,
-0.0053202938,
-0.4544147253,
-0.2376903296,
0.2449432015,
0.3183045685,
0.1575849801,
0.8207242489,
0.6691629887,
-0.1543934047,
0.1090337709,
-0.4905781448,
-0.2459672689,
-0.4436625242,
0.1557437629,
-0.0505438074,
-1.0538215637,
0.389341116,
-0.4576699138,
-0.1681502461,
0.7278960943,
0.5887616873,
-0.3813305199,
1.3067568541,
0.8279886246,
-0.3664585352,
0.480730176,
-0.2578414381,
-0.161261186,
-0.701618731,
-0.2940917313,
-0.7981134653,
-0.1278191805,
-0.9687084556,
-0.3874721825,
0.3853343427,
0.1082195714,
-0.1208224744,
0.470605135,
-0.504842639,
0.0886395648,
0.6946730614,
0.1620662063,
0.200933665,
0.1053100154,
-0.2019237131,
-0.0954655409,
-0.4614700377,
-0.4573109746,
1.277720809,
-0.4350846112,
0.8270831704,
-0.0449419543,
0.517619431,
0.7390723825,
-0.0103169028,
-0.6228269339,
0.6019758582,
0.068347849,
-0.9423797727,
-0.7325279117,
-0.0987960398,
-1.3626395464,
0.2081708014,
-0.2307375818,
-0.8114981055,
-0.010405018,
0.125237152,
0.124586165,
0.0362268239,
-0.2285962254,
0.731549859,
-0.1190322191,
-0.6550610662,
-0.5256614089,
-0.6277241707,
-0.2243335843,
0.2833099961,
-0.1213496625,
-0.0172079206,
-0.1586706042,
0.9012732506,
-0.1956688613,
0.4570842087,
-0.2266195565,
0.1509557068,
0.2119024992,
0.1029207408,
0.6649754047,
-0.0449009053,
-0.3101973832,
0.158112511,
-0.2157441378,
-0.600762248,
-0.4170046747,
0.8203359842,
-0.1778379828,
-0.4086844623,
-0.4744972587,
-0.163013041,
-0.3138281107,
0.3872954845,
0.4321881235,
0.5065640807,
-0.7157111764,
0.5782461762,
0.851038754,
0.0089944648,
0.3987550437,
0.8085417747,
-0.0554990768,
-0.4694604278,
0.9306704402,
-0.0241141096,
-0.1578730643,
0.3546003103,
-0.188657552,
-0.3277549446,
-0.6010092497,
-0.1280275285,
0.1587838978,
-0.6266804934,
-0.1963957846,
-0.911811471,
-0.0271787439,
-0.5363353491,
-0.1889777035,
-0.2822245061,
-0.4829189777,
-0.3333081901,
-0.2813833058,
0.3819036782,
0.6598847508,
-0.1864290982,
0.1936302483,
-0.4729281962,
0.3389903903,
0.4100104272,
0.4920583069,
-0.1629995257,
-0.2018060386,
-0.7767389417,
-0.388134867,
-0.3544552624,
-0.6469658613,
0.4618673921,
-0.3031819165,
0.6857863665,
0.3232473433,
0.3045434356,
0.2446301579,
-0.3330309391,
0.9393764734,
0.0040525133,
-0.4432693422,
0.66124928,
-0.739747107,
0.3954010606,
1.2356133461,
0.5114591122,
-0.4681691527,
-0.3476938009,
-0.7338835597,
-1.1288932562,
0.8787647486,
0.2186831832,
0.0876893252,
0.1717515737,
0.1805905402,
0.2163046002,
0.3959034085,
-0.2330279201,
-0.3000349998,
0.2996187508,
-0.1672522277,
0.009033096,
-0.3984223604,
-0.1165418103,
-0.2445468158,
0.8544843793,
-0.3208073676,
0.2288693786,
0.0914766937,
-0.5890318155,
-0.0359943323,
0.1184489131,
0.5628142953,
1.0157011747,
-0.3949779868,
-0.1195097864,
0.2436304688,
-0.8677142859,
-0.2025387287,
-0.0810021758,
-0.0334322006,
-0.0232707653,
0.4776948094,
0.2536746562,
0.4627725184,
-0.6590878963,
0.6463108063,
-0.2805027664,
-0.2741798162,
-0.3174810708,
0.113982968,
0.197954759,
0.0811468586,
0.9904568791,
-0.3364033401,
0.7676008344,
-0.1380115598,
0.5656463504,
0.4064716399,
-0.7450615764,
-0.3199015856,
0.5940125585,
0.3615946472,
-0.1112136841,
0.622025013,
0.1666501611,
-0.7016609311,
0.6513940096,
-0.018119134,
0.5924758315,
-0.3041042686,
0.4274253845,
0.6755675077,
0.1372372955,
-0.2586975992,
0.1863206327,
-0.3870387375,
-0.2721166015,
-0.1125284433,
-0.5185371637,
-0.6898047328,
-0.079574205,
-1.1881731749,
0.3236225843,
0.039016787,
-0.4913909435,
-0.1081112325,
0.811036706,
-0.844710052,
0.3738085032,
-0.2333910465,
1.213927269,
-0.7454545498,
0.923904717,
0.4967245162,
-0.1118461639,
-0.1802801639,
0.1823486835,
-0.0609092601,
-0.4804478884,
0.6625472307,
0.1460837722,
-0.3295079768,
-0.0084501151,
-0.9976248741,
-0.7186371088,
1.2270935774,
0.1734100878,
-0.317789644,
0.2437264472,
-0.0444138944,
0.5761028528,
-0.3079021871,
0.1285004914,
0.4361630082,
0.6035209298,
-0.0794315934,
-0.697088778,
-0.1589539945,
-0.1337321848,
-0.3458756506,
0.2315001935,
-0.788264513,
0.2507672906,
-0.0497110002,
-0.0645885766,
0.0965699553,
0.4950267375,
0.1864169091,
0.6208140254,
0.4744357765,
0.4273851812,
0.7196387053,
-0.0469726548,
0.9864282608,
-0.1514690965,
0.6217541099,
1.1660852432,
-0.264711678,
1.0315519571,
0.2332469672,
-0.3638431728,
0.4767242372,
0.9462605715,
-0.0507283062,
0.6583058834,
-0.2217296213,
-0.1760173142,
-0.6167662144,
-0.0634114593,
-0.225299418,
0.3269973099,
0.224770382,
-0.1678852737,
-0.1751803905,
0.2135350853,
-0.1857272685,
0.038719777,
-0.0140639422,
0.984762609,
-0.2656841576,
-0.2561817467,
0.2187973559,
-0.3440180123,
0.4988690913,
-0.638710916,
-0.0473290943,
-0.1051031202,
-0.3233117163,
-0.1153756604,
-0.8821844459,
-0.2211881876,
-0.15900819,
-0.6237021685,
-0.1353047937,
0.805937767,
-0.2689885497,
-0.4213998318,
0.6834169626,
0.2886810303,
0.2429828197,
-0.3924774528,
-0.7750089169,
0.092778489,
-0.0306914467,
-0.7235586643,
0.6583049893,
0.2894482017,
-0.1178749129,
0.6829345822,
0.6908228993,
0.0395112671,
-0.000009321,
0.0840066001,
1.0935359001,
-1.0817518234,
-0.4335095286,
-0.3627766073,
0.3353407085,
-0.3482486904,
0.0379815549,
0.8555758595,
1.031088829,
0.6508771181,
0.2058879584,
0.7976244092,
-0.1066702381,
0.5187240839,
-0.2680456042,
0.7510198355,
-0.6803429127,
-0.3207810223,
-0.1111097708,
-0.9592067003,
-0.115487881,
0.0757792145,
-0.220695883,
0.1590575576,
0.6361234188,
0.77875489,
0.0453485213,
-0.1898190677,
0.7715581656,
0.1224336624,
-0.0876520798,
0.0766069219,
0.4932405949,
-0.2917337418,
0.7125028372,
-0.1652599722,
-0.1575055122,
-0.9612550139,
-0.7342662811,
-0.8007311821,
-0.9626581073,
-0.2607922852,
-0.3877362609,
-0.0318366848,
0.7880546451,
0.9846759439,
-0.9822437167,
-0.1586217135,
0.5130208731,
0.0868461728,
-0.0952363685,
-0.283007741,
0.53967309,
-0.3424820602,
-0.5067014098,
0.3751011491,
0.361684829,
-0.3596000969,
-0.0983016789,
-0.0835210159,
-0.30362463,
-0.0767981708,
0.5136570334,
0.2825399339,
-0.5743302107,
-0.0019419634,
0.2496905327,
-0.4197547138,
0.1366938353,
1.1254630089,
-0.8547555208,
0.629527986,
0.7139889002,
0.1418064833,
0.8216252327,
0.3308362067,
0.3692338169,
-0.5549433827,
-0.0156273823,
0.1455253661,
-0.1064057797,
0.2270427048,
-0.7634603381,
0.7575511932,
-0.0105597386,
-0.6583731174,
-0.655603826,
-0.3418059647,
-1.2702251673,
-0.2661884427,
1.046339035,
0.0095884698,
-0.343065232,
-0.1796855778,
-0.2621205449,
0.2390402108,
-0.6640489101,
0.7103774548,
0.7659975886,
-0.2658517957,
0.2227181196,
-0.9896637201,
0.58744663,
-0.0556491837,
-0.8893870711,
0.300843209,
0.5316612124,
0.5700097084,
-0.0309668425,
0.4313856661,
-0.0307158194,
0.6580654383,
-0.1276204735,
0.3930125535,
0.1435889304,
-0.4531900585,
-0.3649555147,
0.435387224,
0.0826708451,
-0.0421197526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20974v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20974v2
|
SaySelf: Teaching LLMs to Express Confidence with Self-Reflective Rationales
| 2024-05-31T16:21:16 | 2024-06-05T17:04:01 |
Tianyang Xu, Shujin Wu, Shizhe Diao, Xiaoze Liu, Xingyao Wang, Yangyi Chen, Jing Gao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) often generate inaccurate or fabricated
information and generally fail to indicate their confidence, which limits their
broader applications. Previous work elicits confidence from LLMs by direct or
self-consistency prompting, or constructing specific datasets for supervised
finetuning. The prompting-based approaches have inferior performance, and the
training-based approaches are limited to binary or inaccurate group-level
confidence estimates. In this work, we present the advanced SaySelf, a training
framework that teaches LLMs to express more accurate fine-grained confidence
estimates. In addition, beyond the confidence scores, SaySelf initiates the
process of directing LLMs to produce self-reflective rationales that clearly
identify gaps in their parametric knowledge and explain their uncertainty. This
is achieved by using an LLM to automatically summarize the uncertainties in
specific knowledge via natural language. The summarization is based on the
analysis of the inconsistency in multiple sampled reasoning chains, and the
resulting data is utilized for supervised fine-tuning. Moreover, we utilize
reinforcement learning with a meticulously crafted reward function to calibrate
the confidence estimates, motivating LLMs to deliver accurate, high-confidence
predictions and to penalize overconfidence in erroneous outputs. Experimental
results in both in-distribution and out-of-distribution datasets demonstrate
the effectiveness of SaySelf in reducing the confidence calibration error and
maintaining the task performance. We show that the generated self-reflective
rationales are reasonable and can further contribute to the calibration. The
code is made public at https://github.com/xu1868/SaySelf.
|
[
-0.3336317241,
-0.6020930409,
0.7457626462,
0.3241755068,
0.2269914299,
-0.2064755261,
-0.4731982946,
0.0372877792,
-0.172755003,
0.3300786316,
-0.6613274813,
-0.7082126141,
-0.6201492548,
0.0846478343,
-0.1959317327,
1.0480369329,
-0.0300855339,
0.3247664273,
-0.3148112297,
0.0259214286,
0.013134161,
-0.3265012801,
-0.581076324,
-0.5016304851,
0.6379488111,
0.5279623866,
0.4204853475,
0.4083670378,
0.264937371,
0.2501928508,
0.2327117324,
0.4415551126,
-0.5459119678,
0.1286875904,
-0.2492000312,
-0.3628326654,
-0.1567240506,
-0.0285183545,
0.5155900121,
0.4774031639,
-0.3893427849,
0.14646402,
0.2220893055,
0.7737718225,
-0.8786134124,
0.5832194686,
-0.5435610414,
-0.1219141334,
0.2822812498,
-0.4274731874,
-0.4804002047,
-0.6007302999,
-0.0437841117,
-0.6397621036,
-0.1130409986,
-0.1326614618,
0.5752686858,
0.5929712653,
-0.3292872906,
-0.5679929852,
-0.4528329372,
0.9031925797,
-0.8627716899,
0.1099810228,
0.490077734,
0.2013401836,
-0.3178473711,
-0.5196448565,
-0.4286137223,
-0.0764577761,
-0.1161315143,
0.2963862419,
0.2869036496,
0.2391909808,
0.0837884545,
0.2737297118,
-0.5372182727,
0.0734341145,
-0.0416614264,
-0.1206983924,
0.8367279172,
0.0342238955,
-0.3607407212,
-0.0691217333,
-0.6617411375,
-0.2610937357,
-0.5796208382,
0.0457712598,
0.3250826299,
0.3317126334,
0.0632391647,
0.3660811782,
-0.2093381584,
0.6310596466,
0.2818138599,
-0.3094314337,
0.0845006406,
0.0543021783,
-0.2678194642,
0.1796094924,
0.7539438605,
0.6314908862,
0.4879761636,
0.0110107232,
-0.3396111131,
0.0700389668,
0.1092311442,
-0.8313711286,
-0.1278413087,
0.3549772203,
-0.0151205231,
-0.5099242926,
0.0631492957,
-0.4486193061,
-0.4265889823,
-0.4305094481,
0.6075528264,
-0.3518202007,
0.0349205807,
0.5164034963,
0.101203233,
0.3638548255,
0.4597245753,
-0.9033299685,
0.4570433497,
0.6299404502,
0.3724881709,
-0.2206247002,
-0.29862535,
-0.5291861892,
0.1591856182,
-0.5817129612,
0.6418861151,
-0.2732431889,
-0.2714094222,
0.1931402534,
-0.1085317805,
-0.2916680574,
-0.4722895622,
0.3812212646,
-0.3103367686,
0.3284410834,
-0.2801629603,
-0.940816462,
-0.1162663922,
0.5774863362,
-0.1028832942,
1.2182091475,
0.1700728983,
-0.724797368,
-0.0164300855,
-0.3387049437,
-0.1625971645,
-0.0150423041,
-0.5352615118,
-0.2414138615,
-0.0622010902,
0.2736891806,
0.8653109074,
-0.0356172808,
0.578956902,
-0.2740703523,
-0.354321748,
0.3712251484,
-0.4256259501,
0.269542098,
0.1169137731,
-0.3362550139,
0.0583068132,
-0.7508930564,
0.2825096846,
-0.1903957874,
-0.3248169422,
-0.0136087565,
-0.1113314629,
-0.1986926794,
0.1445679218,
0.3658694029,
-0.3654974103,
0.0153861521,
-0.3880365491,
0.1350150704,
0.9507563114,
0.2068411708,
0.4803903401,
-0.5321732163,
0.4046143591,
-0.1041727215,
-0.0045636808,
-0.2680131197,
-0.0109636383,
-0.8639164567,
0.0216221474,
0.140271008,
0.5656647682,
-0.7543855906,
0.4504874349,
-0.2501475215,
-0.3635241091,
-0.1644631475,
0.3493293822,
0.5194645524,
0.8141553998,
0.3798806965,
-0.0165839083,
-0.3963173628,
-0.823685348,
-0.1121015474,
-0.3132464886,
0.0027549653,
0.1673851907,
0.46353966,
-0.1028188244,
0.8168483973,
-0.5130156875,
-0.2651945353,
-0.0927192792,
0.4107735753,
0.051196184,
0.5649014115,
0.1830326021,
-0.4762791395,
-0.310654819,
-0.2328747809,
-0.7830567956,
0.0260570794,
-0.2973018289,
-0.0839852169,
0.227794826,
0.5532571673,
-0.3339205384,
0.1425313801,
0.6421801448,
-0.0928639844,
0.6137584448,
-0.319524169,
0.1053903401,
-0.8951613903,
-0.2765115201,
0.2188971341,
-0.5529509783,
-0.1423514783,
-0.0310123097,
0.1127789021,
0.2889547646,
-0.3030236959,
0.4576874673,
-0.19696109,
0.2070278674,
-0.3240809441,
0.1798258275,
-0.0013784155,
0.7370752692,
0.1233945936,
0.8362559676,
0.5032923222,
-0.6608424187,
0.1274837852,
0.0464324206,
-0.4158458412,
0.8926919103,
-0.5114066601,
-0.138018012,
-0.2357418239,
0.0980616659,
-0.9081657529,
-0.5889675617,
0.1368575543,
-0.3508936465,
0.5141005516,
-0.0998200625,
-0.2585217059,
-0.1904697418,
-0.2930471897,
-0.1315278411,
0.535656631,
-0.5896525979,
0.5896769762,
0.2018848956,
-0.1248064786,
-0.8774989843,
-0.8642083406,
-0.1341836601,
-0.0293555595,
-0.6483777761,
0.1204795837,
-0.4160071313,
-0.1891652942,
-0.1801866889,
-0.2902323902,
-0.06842985,
0.1632435322,
0.183496654,
0.0332229808,
0.0465940349,
0.4834248424,
0.1073773429,
-0.2786910236,
0.3017065525,
-0.3838327825,
0.1625050455,
-0.6632484794,
-0.4686312377,
-0.2406805158,
0.0736350045,
0.2185072601,
0.0788335055,
0.7880123258,
0.5824615955,
-0.3307616115,
-0.6066006422,
-0.6402611732,
-0.397942245,
-0.4937358797,
0.372462064,
-0.0845216587,
-0.9686883688,
0.196336776,
-0.1590196043,
0.0611112379,
0.1690897197,
0.4932659268,
-0.3908475935,
0.8982996345,
0.4430213869,
0.2222751677,
0.0139873065,
-0.2779209912,
-0.0082395924,
-0.5045841932,
-0.2155359536,
-0.0414785296,
-0.0117092868,
-0.3482523263,
-0.5981382728,
0.3601790965,
0.0260187034,
-0.449626267,
0.0193625744,
-0.276951462,
0.5872168541,
0.4832948744,
0.0721785426,
0.1049012989,
-0.2411178052,
0.0029075984,
-0.0477168225,
-0.7294639349,
-0.7650227547,
0.8704399467,
0.3988310993,
1.2138231993,
-0.2953435481,
0.9838314056,
0.3013587594,
0.373790592,
-0.9123458862,
0.5558316708,
0.1643416435,
-0.3268400431,
-0.3583610356,
-0.5421540737,
-0.4867030978,
-0.037006896,
-0.085528098,
-0.4042473435,
0.2017038465,
0.5764498115,
-0.4433141053,
0.1096721664,
-0.6922047138,
0.7858771682,
-0.2181007415,
-0.3882261515,
-0.0677352548,
-0.7156576514,
0.3369773924,
-0.0308905598,
0.2721262276,
-0.233084783,
-0.011877411,
0.505589962,
-0.3831445277,
1.0200699568,
-0.1644648015,
-0.3115571737,
0.349211514,
0.1442727,
0.8804141879,
0.2522947788,
-0.3221691549,
-0.2254295498,
0.0895450637,
-0.4698840678,
-0.8511959314,
0.7958828211,
-0.5086957216,
-0.5428072214,
-0.492464155,
-0.6152261496,
-0.5188785791,
-0.1079490632,
0.3122840524,
0.3538317978,
-0.126098901,
0.1716817766,
1.1287351847,
0.0589971133,
0.2699025571,
0.3610907495,
-0.109924674,
-0.3806606233,
0.8044818044,
0.1751265377,
0.3833220899,
0.3542436063,
0.2780804038,
-0.4761294723,
-0.3568477333,
-0.2581256032,
0.0852802843,
-1.026330471,
-0.4689514637,
-0.2611240447,
-0.2522218227,
-0.3096657395,
-0.2160881162,
-0.4761024117,
-0.4137732685,
-0.0844332278,
-0.3612208366,
0.3373997509,
0.7815298438,
-0.1998227239,
0.4470702708,
-0.4844512641,
-0.2821327746,
0.4857533574,
0.3182704449,
-0.1775243878,
-0.5052111745,
-0.3992583454,
0.1514219195,
-0.126230523,
-0.5452011228,
0.2650305331,
0.2419400215,
0.4607492685,
0.2996150851,
0.3766640127,
0.5796638131,
-0.3102518022,
0.5531734228,
0.3285472393,
-0.8729578853,
0.4210342765,
-0.4665351212,
0.2439653873,
0.7876735926,
0.4623499215,
-0.4992471933,
-0.3924832642,
-0.5396859646,
-0.5518452525,
0.5554968715,
0.0368789509,
0.062079411,
-0.2529360652,
0.3767004609,
-0.0821141675,
0.27907601,
-0.7640481591,
-0.3375628293,
-0.1671680063,
-0.8817691803,
-0.0875313655,
-0.4762366414,
-0.4208040237,
0.104841277,
1.0199164152,
-0.5872105956,
0.0835116282,
0.4724358916,
-0.0688825771,
-0.0577278174,
0.3540056348,
0.5907327533,
0.6621474624,
-0.1042188704,
0.5118677616,
0.2852178812,
-0.1334319413,
0.1543682069,
0.1049262211,
-0.0829176754,
-0.2794176042,
0.2749363184,
0.5380818248,
0.3996937573,
-0.7168344855,
0.9391903877,
-0.0562716983,
-0.4366672039,
-0.6353387833,
0.3015109897,
0.3624842465,
0.2990169823,
0.2649431527,
0.2512162626,
0.0070143365,
-0.0474769101,
0.2269823104,
0.2726415098,
-0.6598154902,
-0.0502139591,
0.2566124499,
0.0762633458,
0.0405220948,
0.2161832899,
-0.5001015067,
-0.3517407775,
0.3217190206,
0.4002646804,
0.6212400198,
-0.1565853804,
0.3688506782,
0.5191478729,
0.1418627799,
-0.538797915,
0.2757304609,
-0.0867491588,
-0.7694669962,
-0.6716191769,
-0.6612841487,
-0.4041499496,
0.0512708835,
-0.6891938448,
-0.0641781092,
-0.607568264,
-0.1343523413,
-0.5422791243,
-0.1813648939,
-0.3184736371,
0.3652461767,
0.2261352092,
0.864072144,
-0.7836629748,
0.4773720205,
0.3746336102,
-0.2692427635,
-1.0738803148,
-0.0692565292,
-0.0261124633,
-0.9453505278,
0.4778784811,
0.1832160801,
-0.4988220334,
0.0566952266,
-0.8822492957,
-0.8672087193,
0.9972293377,
0.4702239037,
-0.6581460834,
0.0652271807,
-0.0331086144,
0.4308491945,
-0.4705424309,
0.1664904058,
0.2680007517,
0.5218160748,
0.2823156714,
-0.4098267257,
-0.0210585929,
-0.0659158975,
-0.062733233,
-0.0799865797,
-0.5418771505,
0.3575571477,
-0.3156152666,
-0.0854843557,
0.1406003535,
0.7539371252,
0.3899143338,
0.2933750749,
0.4414474964,
0.4921627343,
0.9136087298,
-0.2346023172,
0.9251248837,
-0.4419858158,
0.4090057015,
1.5870878696,
-0.1139800474,
0.9253998995,
0.5941415429,
0.0790291876,
0.7329865694,
0.6108533144,
0.1628318876,
0.3505353332,
0.3628740013,
-0.4456666112,
-0.6423244476,
-0.0173497237,
-0.0541388169,
0.1148611233,
0.499715358,
-0.3178576231,
-0.3243715465,
0.0143763237,
-0.0289456807,
0.5708426237,
-0.3716694415,
0.5070715547,
0.2465444505,
-0.8336954117,
0.6558562517,
-0.0923636034,
0.6314946413,
-0.7527468204,
0.029403897,
-0.0732795,
0.3697940111,
-0.3784762025,
-0.8669775128,
0.1035172343,
-0.1685518771,
0.0211550687,
-0.4825589955,
0.6761789322,
-0.6821347475,
-0.4694565237,
0.1758136451,
0.266115427,
0.1417836398,
0.088538222,
-0.7538844347,
-0.1803850234,
-0.0368294753,
-0.3615531623,
0.0182391182,
0.4307313859,
0.2831624746,
0.8738989234,
0.3852485716,
-0.0346197672,
-0.0531123728,
0.2750225663,
0.5427597761,
-0.3300593197,
-0.2208417505,
-0.7134742737,
0.4412403107,
-0.0611637682,
-0.1969457865,
0.7918998599,
0.4509922266,
0.9906468987,
-0.0464564152,
0.7768769264,
0.2745599151,
0.5470840335,
-0.6696077585,
0.2793403566,
-0.3494806588,
0.3715404272,
0.0240198616,
-0.6212230325,
-0.2684025168,
0.9162275791,
-0.5295601487,
0.1966432631,
0.5332177281,
1.0987663269,
0.2157053202,
-0.0534294061,
0.4152902961,
0.2597379684,
0.0261353999,
0.6577166319,
0.9115669727,
-0.4292719662,
0.5763837695,
-0.3203689754,
-0.1492350847,
-0.0110208793,
-1.0627186298,
-0.8588593006,
-0.3677970171,
-0.4542036951,
-0.3722625375,
0.1715005189,
1.1561068296,
0.8500792384,
-0.8579894304,
-0.267716229,
-0.6016021371,
-0.0372838303,
-0.0657065511,
-0.2092809677,
0.2633099854,
-0.8473627567,
-0.5611538887,
0.3048191965,
0.3585001826,
0.2978400588,
-0.4256653786,
-0.5681812763,
-0.0263361838,
0.2236236781,
0.307141155,
0.1243259683,
-0.5361359715,
-0.3902938664,
0.0862209424,
-0.3745221198,
0.0549228899,
0.369240135,
-0.6468169689,
0.2936880589,
0.2324289829,
0.7406838536,
0.5086742043,
0.1323554516,
0.7095524669,
-0.9451864362,
-0.1911986321,
0.2560109496,
0.3237473369,
0.5660594106,
-0.4381425083,
0.4824377298,
-0.0223729201,
-0.7263652086,
-0.6226499677,
0.2864117026,
-0.7492856979,
-0.2705497146,
1.1842029095,
-0.3802201152,
-0.316565007,
0.0057123955,
-0.1810652763,
0.0288978163,
-0.3568200171,
0.7472621202,
0.8081261516,
-0.1128111407,
-0.0772591159,
-0.1011357903,
0.8229128122,
0.5669955611,
-0.7208098173,
0.2208305597,
0.3403988183,
0.3362740874,
-0.0121514518,
0.6211230755,
-0.0021324221,
0.3010173142,
-0.2636653781,
0.0017498966,
-0.099003844,
-0.2964330018,
-0.3792720437,
0.0063765398,
0.3155799806,
0.1115786582
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20973v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20973v1
|
LCQ: Low-Rank Codebook based Quantization for Large Language Models
| 2024-05-31T16:21:05 | 2024-05-31T16:21:05 |
Wen-Pu Cai, Wu-Jun Li
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Large language models~(LLMs) have recently demonstrated promising performance
in many tasks. However, the high storage and computational cost of LLMs has
become a challenge for deploying LLMs. Weight quantization has been widely used
for model compression, which can reduce both storage and computational cost.
Most existing weight quantization methods for LLMs use a rank-one codebook for
quantization, which results in substantial accuracy loss when the compression
ratio is high. In this paper, we propose a novel weight quantization method,
called low-rank codebook based quantization~(LCQ), for LLMs. LCQ adopts a
low-rank codebook, the rank of which can be larger than one, for quantization.
Experiments show that LCQ can achieve better accuracy than existing methods
with a negligibly extra storage cost.
|
[
0.0000071305,
-0.3874771595,
0.3856134713,
0.0752626136,
-0.3460355997,
0.3639315963,
-0.2661780715,
-0.105918631,
-0.0086942995,
0.4216876626,
-0.1551007032,
-0.7176378369,
-0.5593856573,
0.032661017,
-0.4212262928,
0.6623927355,
0.2087011486,
0.3787026703,
-0.5002135634,
-0.0489839315,
-0.3123256266,
-1.0079165697,
-0.610887289,
-0.0622625388,
0.4917747378,
0.4149031341,
1.0788912773,
0.6479708552,
0.5163334608,
0.2362443656,
-0.4050996304,
-0.0134548582,
-0.5016222596,
-0.1069419384,
0.4200546145,
-0.8015751839,
-0.9190805554,
-0.2658002675,
1.0952227116,
0.6842238307,
-0.4173392355,
0.3063096404,
-0.08225362,
0.9536523819,
-0.8528780937,
-0.0872492939,
-0.3582941592,
0.031201357,
-0.1212480888,
-0.1704818308,
-0.5869839191,
-0.4991155863,
-0.5700069666,
-0.4596486688,
-0.1067413539,
0.2735365927,
0.4621621668,
0.2417623103,
-0.652577877,
-0.0715306625,
-0.650685966,
1.1151609421,
-1.1618806124,
0.3642302752,
0.4531264007,
0.0383409783,
0.131249696,
-0.3141117096,
-0.5661427379,
-0.1294821948,
-0.0548429973,
-0.1881319135,
0.0193935372,
0.2142689377,
0.5122842789,
0.6565692425,
-0.7663804889,
0.1121906862,
-0.1649909019,
-0.050760705,
0.6392082572,
0.0536699146,
0.3074382246,
-0.0941333473,
-0.2377765179,
-0.225830406,
-0.8688791394,
0.2158923,
0.3160414398,
0.3888724446,
-0.0455846041,
0.5801565051,
-0.4973605573,
0.809384048,
-0.3915008903,
-0.5993986726,
0.0553622134,
-0.1375788301,
-0.3737060428,
0.2771966457,
0.5571369529,
0.1527660191,
0.0937227607,
-0.032437861,
-0.3598877788,
-0.226110369,
-0.1079805493,
-1.3050942421,
-0.1720380187,
0.1670117378,
-0.9156093001,
-0.5274292231,
-0.2259777486,
-0.4477286339,
-0.3112105429,
-0.1743244529,
0.5362842083,
-0.2055670768,
-0.0383994505,
0.074919939,
0.2220918387,
0.377176255,
0.4177993238,
-0.7899124622,
0.5641227365,
0.521633327,
0.9687564969,
-0.0661681369,
0.273096621,
-0.9399366975,
0.0779489353,
-0.4500523806,
0.5109102726,
-0.5062590241,
-0.4004173875,
0.0774941668,
-0.1711082608,
0.3883934617,
-0.4466582537,
0.6335966587,
-0.7167474031,
-0.1733119339,
-0.151291728,
-0.8951303959,
0.1536785513,
0.1858685166,
-0.7362752557,
1.1158405542,
-0.0413125828,
-0.5250734687,
-0.0837197751,
0.0653615743,
-0.3897275627,
0.3386003673,
-0.0767214969,
-0.543738842,
0.1591870189,
0.2915790379,
0.3915446699,
-0.6048848629,
0.0914302319,
-0.3124100268,
-0.9004628658,
0.2931413054,
-0.4295979142,
0.6978842616,
0.298158139,
0.2408851832,
-0.2453570217,
-0.7091981769,
0.5320171118,
0.1529250443,
-0.7068952322,
-0.5763201714,
0.0871742815,
-0.0547284819,
-0.1447474509,
0.5482091904,
-0.3663734198,
0.812238276,
-0.4500981271,
0.3569130898,
0.4152692854,
-0.3084154129,
0.5804535151,
-0.3704212308,
0.6877762079,
-0.2116262913,
0.1956917942,
0.1275152564,
-0.3674608171,
-0.6514530182,
-0.4532902539,
0.8678569794,
0.5078345537,
-0.7966291308,
0.4236164689,
-0.5326757431,
-0.4258027971,
-0.1709647775,
0.1632757336,
0.5601654649,
-0.2285258919,
0.3445963562,
-0.0017641697,
-0.125397265,
-0.7646601796,
-0.1793034524,
-0.0246582031,
-0.2514925003,
0.1452978104,
0.238799572,
0.1727965474,
0.6947442293,
-0.7656320333,
-0.1904707551,
-0.2620105147,
0.0292076841,
0.3559447527,
0.7590258718,
0.4068279564,
-0.7869059443,
-0.4607555568,
-0.236261338,
-0.3360799849,
-0.0209541973,
0.0711580962,
-0.134778589,
0.4607037008,
0.7765318155,
-0.4687766135,
0.3944785893,
0.9393815994,
-0.1254374832,
0.3186139166,
-0.2093935013,
0.1697156131,
-1.0537910461,
-0.0586199872,
-0.2740764618,
-0.5654807687,
-0.4320084751,
0.0237466134,
0.4752559066,
-0.2376245409,
-0.3455573916,
0.6470806003,
-0.454528302,
-0.2350476235,
-0.0987561941,
0.0409752913,
0.15153566,
0.7165416479,
-0.1318761557,
0.7643396854,
0.2743330002,
-0.5241206884,
0.2329538167,
0.2247360498,
-0.5052604079,
0.2817168534,
-0.5729184151,
0.1363142282,
0.0204093549,
0.3176008463,
-0.7074145079,
0.3544687629,
-0.0915217474,
-0.3636609912,
0.4150318503,
-0.6430836916,
-0.8814826608,
-0.1969268024,
-0.4781216681,
0.9027597308,
0.7213692069,
-0.3878329694,
0.3807828128,
0.2376034707,
-0.2916599214,
-0.6012915373,
-0.7855245471,
0.0991000608,
-0.0857984871,
-0.1792021394,
0.5281823277,
-0.5132330656,
-0.0149960751,
-0.2022703439,
-0.3740741313,
-0.0414468274,
-0.0718169063,
0.0100322273,
0.3063734174,
-0.1248312891,
0.6845387816,
0.0512377024,
-0.0284888912,
-0.2546784878,
-0.370162636,
0.521920681,
-0.2083446532,
-0.0762451589,
-0.2311080694,
0.3325867355,
0.36836043,
-0.3120238185,
1.0011875629,
0.2594117522,
-0.5697230697,
-0.5193368196,
-0.377430439,
0.1939050704,
-0.4846577048,
0.3707244992,
-0.3286091685,
-0.9118304849,
0.3183580339,
-0.1961500496,
-0.3395264447,
0.0908745006,
0.5984669328,
-0.081204012,
1.1058613062,
0.5794509053,
-0.2789971232,
0.395432055,
-0.2074210346,
0.3501069546,
-0.6272054315,
0.1422782242,
-0.8793350458,
-0.349987179,
-0.5185665488,
-0.6867702603,
0.4840426743,
0.667214036,
-0.4316351414,
0.1580135822,
-0.6676065922,
0.7265931964,
0.5753836036,
0.1605089754,
0.8057029247,
0.0423046388,
0.0173823107,
0.0811269656,
-0.7970920801,
-0.5148422122,
1.2201732397,
0.2094326317,
1.0873283148,
0.5668378472,
0.8340895176,
0.5080623627,
0.3351550102,
-1.1201188564,
0.5345022082,
-0.4391863346,
-0.1489860564,
-0.7126241326,
-0.8336638808,
-0.5634145141,
0.236098662,
-0.2245743573,
-0.5133978128,
-0.0192767587,
0.1888063848,
-0.4815278649,
0.265525192,
-0.4666062891,
0.8154924512,
-0.170669049,
-0.003058708,
-0.2204155922,
-0.1521548182,
0.4871451259,
-0.027685212,
0.4741442502,
0.0019985666,
-0.1990780234,
0.985016346,
-0.9743645191,
0.5665640235,
-0.1004404798,
-0.5397759676,
0.0550642647,
0.3381772041,
0.9037912488,
0.3012021184,
-0.1823358387,
0.110716939,
0.6365333796,
-0.6055002213,
-0.714490056,
0.6853419542,
-0.6428341269,
-0.3124001026,
-0.4304893315,
-0.4007330835,
-0.2431180328,
0.1501901001,
-0.0069771083,
0.7299777865,
0.1519764662,
0.437025249,
0.7692918181,
-0.6623421907,
0.3894011676,
0.510112524,
-0.2028118819,
-0.5203592777,
1.0263195038,
0.0627806559,
0.3256670535,
0.9938647747,
0.2699106932,
0.0763819888,
-0.6813139915,
-0.1570774317,
0.0016891452,
-0.7508873343,
-0.938079536,
-0.3806163967,
-0.2693645358,
-0.4023243487,
-0.1846129,
-0.5911174417,
-0.7039278746,
0.0986042693,
0.4121313095,
0.4223026335,
0.303960681,
0.365419358,
0.4232902229,
-1.0998644829,
0.3958915174,
0.4074219465,
0.4754680991,
0.2184614539,
-0.553796947,
-0.8486207128,
0.0677977279,
-0.2024566233,
-0.5598461628,
0.5655102134,
0.1424008459,
0.1224334612,
0.1013994589,
0.4820412695,
0.5425769687,
-0.4007482231,
0.6343042254,
-0.003919906,
-1.4014604092,
0.2332860678,
-0.0465318225,
0.5749848485,
0.4160524905,
0.2035507411,
-0.6351581812,
-0.2447736263,
-0.2231135219,
-0.7602528334,
0.7707738876,
0.2784499824,
0.1048224792,
0.32794258,
0.5025084019,
-0.3899228573,
0.4307705164,
-1.0665578842,
-0.339627862,
0.1426944733,
-0.4483944178,
-0.0321513452,
-0.5200252533,
0.1348395646,
-0.2405207306,
0.798143208,
-0.341101706,
0.3443859518,
0.1289578974,
-0.2275936455,
-0.2580408752,
0.4659488797,
0.4294624627,
0.2224040329,
-0.4100799561,
0.0715792701,
0.2097629607,
-0.4095393717,
0.2043312043,
-0.1861512065,
-0.1688815057,
-0.2423519045,
0.4198474586,
0.4467776716,
0.5892131925,
-0.7707278728,
0.8205823898,
-0.0377761014,
-0.1991065592,
-0.3887968063,
-0.1489291042,
0.2225696146,
0.2514015734,
0.4335228801,
-0.3004558086,
0.1521306038,
-0.3427507877,
-0.1464582682,
0.5957512259,
0.1166004986,
0.2449910045,
0.4337100387,
0.1423361301,
-0.228299126,
0.6375733018,
-0.3943919539,
-0.4750899076,
0.7336778641,
0.2110012174,
0.5186567903,
-0.072362937,
0.1019432619,
0.5659264922,
0.220742628,
-0.3231329918,
0.1875350028,
-0.2334913462,
-0.7350102067,
-0.6882266402,
-1.1025290489,
-0.6951370835,
-0.0243956093,
-0.6648337841,
0.4100114107,
-0.3096164465,
0.0822350457,
-0.3770548403,
0.347563833,
-0.4298115969,
0.1733680516,
0.5405581594,
0.8591274023,
-0.1493516266,
1.3193756342,
0.347997576,
-0.2269853652,
-0.917529583,
0.0003184221,
-0.277903229,
-0.6346425414,
0.8701376915,
-0.0565662384,
0.0618368983,
0.4279862642,
-0.730020225,
-1.1701159477,
1.2830777168,
0.3041431606,
-0.9367093444,
-0.3293364942,
0.0932233483,
0.2584572434,
-0.0792471543,
0.2424795628,
0.1242819503,
0.4041410685,
0.0949401259,
-0.8422983885,
0.2289982885,
-0.0474368706,
0.3942331672,
0.3272177577,
-0.8278819323,
0.9538484216,
-0.0310135037,
-0.2443726361,
0.5682051182,
0.4080909193,
0.3738938272,
-0.0941558629,
0.3681838512,
0.4327172637,
0.7247159481,
0.2334949076,
1.067101717,
-0.405003041,
0.7647970915,
0.9181700945,
-0.3935407698,
1.1318070889,
0.1798272133,
-0.6121504307,
0.4324098229,
0.3259752095,
-0.1640927792,
0.2925829887,
0.6955860853,
-0.184975028,
-0.5762984157,
0.2303580791,
-0.2516258955,
0.2226915956,
0.0695335269,
0.0197003502,
0.1473856121,
-0.0782274902,
-0.0663311929,
-0.052285064,
-0.4931706488,
0.5319763422,
0.199685514,
-0.260456264,
1.2451910973,
0.3295317888,
0.7984036803,
-0.5514236689,
-0.0519943833,
-0.2974455357,
0.0507870987,
-0.1305196881,
-0.1757899821,
-0.1553364396,
-0.0784945115,
-0.2686821818,
-0.3656562269,
0.3732789755,
-0.5811644793,
-0.8906774521,
-0.01490926,
0.504101038,
0.0683167651,
-0.3211262524,
-0.4251555204,
0.2617284656,
-0.2154055089,
-0.5866972208,
0.6348212361,
0.2848404348,
-0.1578284055,
0.7667451501,
0.5274801254,
0.1727316231,
-0.2585041523,
0.1543647945,
0.6965446472,
-0.9885055423,
-0.5322007537,
-0.6004788876,
0.1065990627,
0.160733819,
0.1625407338,
0.4922965765,
0.6254001856,
0.6777002811,
-0.0872051939,
0.6014919281,
0.0481554195,
0.5288146734,
-1.0233850479,
0.774535656,
-0.9533475637,
0.4324069321,
-0.2554092705,
-1.0096533298,
-0.5106180906,
0.6091701984,
0.0345390551,
0.1151208729,
0.9981763959,
0.9023997784,
0.5054966211,
-0.3304117024,
0.7811183929,
0.2301196307,
0.1544409543,
0.8605617285,
0.4973296225,
-0.7627100348,
0.841154933,
-0.2391816527,
-0.1816176921,
-0.2458971143,
-0.9706686139,
-0.9182416797,
-0.4331645966,
-0.4399521649,
-0.1454825848,
-0.1070262045,
0.9677011371,
0.8285099864,
-0.6978807449,
-0.247879073,
0.0406781845,
0.3072991371,
-0.2299634069,
-0.2598565519,
0.5502989292,
-0.2044676542,
-1.0326873064,
0.2703080475,
-0.0574569032,
0.1445908099,
-0.1964704841,
-0.3611569107,
-0.0012520521,
-0.0153093236,
0.6728210449,
0.0159152038,
-0.5365680456,
0.0891997889,
-0.2234352529,
-0.345189184,
-0.0527680516,
0.9588765502,
-1.0049962997,
-0.0820662454,
0.3633064032,
0.4991787374,
0.5032879114,
0.0808787048,
0.5142845511,
-0.9043931961,
0.2578399777,
0.2525544763,
0.3423537314,
0.189189896,
-0.4838706851,
0.4451585412,
0.121089682,
-0.65518713,
-1.1614800692,
-0.0720221698,
-1.2453463078,
-0.410982728,
1.1577758789,
0.0994881541,
-0.1179200411,
0.4966484308,
-0.1747993231,
0.0993219689,
-0.5416228175,
0.4186138809,
0.6838778257,
0.3201421201,
-0.4719687402,
-0.6144251227,
0.7521702647,
0.5233945847,
-0.7479608059,
0.1825873107,
0.2651539743,
-0.0317417905,
-0.0921801925,
0.6288170815,
-0.10860046,
0.0113987615,
-0.2207517624,
0.6248254776,
-0.0321278907,
0.0975656137,
-0.4706758857,
0.1134810522,
0.3722928166,
0.1584971696
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20967v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20967v1
|
Superlatives in Context: Explicit and Implicit Domain Restrictions for Superlative Frames
| 2024-05-31T16:14:06 | 2024-05-31T16:14:06 |
Valentina Pyatkin, Bonnie Webber, Ido Dagan, Reut Tsarfaty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Superlatives are used to single out elements with a maximal/minimal property.
Semantically, superlatives perform a set comparison: something (or some things)
has the min/max property out of a set. As such, superlatives provide an ideal
phenomenon for studying implicit phenomena and discourse restrictions. While
this comparison set is often not explicitly defined, its (implicit)
restrictions can be inferred from the discourse context the expression appears
in. In this work we provide an extensive computational study on the semantics
of superlatives. We propose a unified account of superlative semantics which
allows us to derive a broad-coverage annotation schema. Using this unified
schema we annotated a multi-domain dataset of superlatives and their semantic
interpretations. We specifically focus on interpreting implicit or ambiguous
superlative expressions, by analyzing how the discourse context restricts the
set of interpretations. In a set of experiments we then analyze how well models
perform at variations of predicting superlative semantics, with and without
context. We show that the fine-grained semantics of superlatives in context can
be challenging for contemporary models, including GPT-4.
|
[
-0.6442017555,
-0.7439247966,
0.5848383904,
0.1581927985,
-0.3254718781,
-0.2427928597,
0.0617124848,
-0.7044246793,
-0.2033453435,
0.4025890529,
-0.3526794314,
-0.3478961885,
-0.7981011868,
0.2460463792,
-0.590598464,
1.3606133461,
-0.0811549425,
-0.0663656294,
-0.5096030235,
-0.4412447214,
-0.2386178374,
-0.7884539366,
0.2400568724,
-0.2803370059,
0.1700056791,
0.1665902436,
0.9137648344,
0.4926921129,
0.7449449897,
0.3479390144,
-0.4220331013,
0.0512153208,
-0.2890226543,
0.279073745,
-0.4265643656,
-0.1300428957,
-0.1467472762,
0.1586466283,
0.6159266829,
0.768913269,
0.3687061965,
0.03248794,
0.0514804684,
0.2713396549,
-0.801466167,
0.4766983688,
-0.6242088079,
0.0975477919,
-0.1806024462,
-0.2396515757,
-0.0765620172,
-0.2992607951,
0.4098228812,
-0.7737637758,
0.2922491431,
-0.0885144547,
1.1479473114,
0.2779632509,
-0.5627636909,
-0.0358579122,
-0.5317599773,
0.7784866095,
-0.2761381269,
0.160373196,
0.054067824,
0.2336214632,
-0.0713736638,
-0.8677117229,
-0.5905109048,
-0.4826255143,
-0.5300089717,
-0.0874906406,
-0.2470629513,
0.0225604344,
0.6168703437,
0.4915485084,
-0.1556884795,
-0.4207545817,
-0.0400618762,
-0.197219044,
0.4769892991,
0.21264337,
0.2858452499,
-0.4244741797,
-0.7390300035,
0.394993484,
-0.7893273234,
-0.3422279358,
-0.3142224252,
0.3629482687,
0.2221217453,
0.3831024766,
-0.4378677905,
0.3014806211,
-0.2315955758,
0.1602513492,
0.0282135084,
-0.8286722302,
-0.221170634,
-0.3968058228,
0.3148218691,
0.5253062844,
0.4075815678,
-0.1823948771,
-0.0392020606,
0.4362935722,
-0.1259225607,
-0.6497519612,
0.4104371667,
-0.3252031803,
-0.0159087032,
0.0012591037,
-0.0242418125,
-0.2978543341,
-0.1203061342,
-0.5789331198,
0.4039308727,
-0.2076959461,
0.0041280277,
-0.0963158235,
-0.3550608754,
0.2875983715,
0.0918872058,
-0.9550892711,
0.6843184233,
0.7706900239,
0.5523762703,
0.0378446355,
-0.6700627208,
-0.1141269952,
0.2668475807,
-0.2874061167,
0.9532488585,
-0.9688962698,
-0.6624191403,
-0.0663199127,
-0.0922393352,
0.028617613,
-0.4611327648,
0.7980191708,
-0.630196929,
0.0878824517,
-0.2189304978,
-0.8595452309,
-0.0793756023,
-0.2621595562,
-0.4196537733,
1.0996148586,
0.2824754119,
-0.5850518942,
0.525875628,
-0.5183266997,
-0.5531702042,
0.4375437498,
-0.1183049828,
0.2464360446,
0.4942186177,
-0.1138753295,
0.5886892676,
-0.5238575339,
0.2968541682,
-0.0949646607,
-0.2908721864,
0.1284331083,
-0.2534916699,
0.3690628111,
0.0782014057,
-0.5157658458,
0.1447178572,
-0.4009717107,
0.1196053848,
-0.0976901874,
0.0936502591,
-0.6511838436,
-0.3496777117,
0.0914113671,
0.1847295314,
0.1179622337,
-0.3822640479,
0.3310964704,
-0.004707783,
0.5530907512,
0.7940981984,
0.0346753262,
0.4956223071,
0.0903286561,
0.2222489566,
-0.3500755429,
0.1423419714,
0.0086240349,
-0.4299269915,
-0.2959065139,
-0.1590403616,
0.701995492,
0.3317585886,
-0.5770201683,
0.0952603891,
-0.4654578269,
-0.2084157914,
-0.0689433888,
-0.1593502611,
0.7573262453,
0.2608922124,
0.5017162561,
-0.2036819905,
-0.1923512816,
-1.2026289701,
-0.1580108255,
0.3329616785,
0.1867251843,
0.5613467693,
0.9010253549,
-0.0347767361,
0.8925132155,
-0.6625286341,
-0.4117432535,
-0.0251614042,
0.2745631337,
-0.0487146601,
0.3695547879,
0.3984374106,
-1.1268763542,
-0.3436483443,
0.0844231769,
-0.9375792742,
-0.2447168976,
-0.0429449603,
-0.3531891704,
-0.0910758302,
0.619980216,
-0.8423270583,
0.5425168872,
0.1665890366,
-0.4363615215,
0.8543964028,
-0.1325630397,
0.0488279536,
-0.567333281,
-0.0520131476,
0.1334271729,
-0.0954952091,
-0.7044818401,
0.6720400453,
-0.092330873,
0.3386201262,
-0.7884476781,
0.7185502052,
-0.1934401095,
-0.2418940365,
-0.1792914271,
0.0499437973,
0.1817573309,
0.5048884153,
0.2734893262,
0.4907501638,
0.627299726,
-0.7405881286,
0.3216017783,
0.359746784,
-0.1547822952,
1.1373702288,
-0.5483797789,
0.0312730893,
0.0106868669,
0.5756046176,
-0.7600277066,
-0.2973235846,
0.0142476428,
-0.2321377993,
0.1061005369,
-0.2039110363,
-0.3879430294,
0.1783064753,
-0.1416270286,
0.5263668299,
-0.1992664039,
-0.4012440741,
0.2652596831,
0.415160954,
-0.0739019364,
-0.7673359513,
-0.4948198199,
0.1324393451,
-0.2689011693,
-0.4253644645,
0.9319466352,
-0.2686655521,
-0.2946752012,
0.1931893229,
-0.2567996085,
-0.2353889048,
0.0061698388,
0.3409639895,
0.4115013182,
-0.1451785117,
0.0794449821,
0.1971745938,
-0.4751883447,
-0.0839404017,
-0.2001916468,
0.0504391901,
-0.5683558583,
-0.0927194878,
-0.2397168875,
0.767493546,
0.5684617162,
0.1744995117,
0.5037838221,
0.1824457347,
-0.5035030246,
-0.0055638202,
-0.215964973,
0.0763681009,
-0.3582268357,
0.3452079892,
-1.0236269236,
-1.0212270021,
0.4103934169,
0.0558410548,
-0.0586634986,
0.695105195,
0.4017799497,
0.458355099,
1.2405395508,
0.2245150059,
0.1069140583,
0.1684815586,
-0.3108156025,
-0.0786166266,
-1.1110234261,
-0.143198505,
-0.5626078844,
-0.0897022933,
-0.4963136613,
-0.080625549,
0.1007008627,
0.2284976989,
-0.2365253568,
0.4612728953,
-0.5190840364,
1.1130207777,
0.5250561237,
-0.2735313475,
0.3627285361,
-0.1757139713,
-0.333268851,
-0.177429378,
-0.3087253869,
-0.5248038769,
0.8910448551,
-0.0201952644,
0.1606879085,
0.1673645675,
0.1107461974,
0.6160247922,
0.5081845522,
-0.6489856839,
0.9716103077,
-0.1646975279,
-0.9871809483,
-0.2854907811,
-0.3086797595,
-1.0706501007,
0.5610461831,
-0.0978692695,
-0.7294185758,
0.1500632763,
-0.4254955053,
-0.4375697672,
-0.0698215365,
-0.5489597917,
0.9361640215,
-0.094885096,
-0.7273157835,
0.0545403175,
-0.7164104581,
0.0312999673,
0.0508400537,
0.209174931,
-0.2397853285,
-0.0825764015,
0.3121913671,
-0.2272104323,
0.441729784,
-0.0720756203,
0.0679959953,
0.0693753585,
0.3316044211,
0.228870824,
-0.1075956523,
0.105639942,
0.4840009809,
0.1559259593,
-0.4389181733,
-0.7382522225,
0.8367087841,
-0.5254166722,
-0.5812104344,
-0.4487882555,
-0.5372113585,
-0.1503529996,
0.3451897204,
0.4348564148,
0.6710805893,
-0.1989293247,
0.0231835824,
0.1596170217,
0.2492347211,
0.1669831723,
0.483751446,
-0.0399607494,
0.2226425409,
1.0423893929,
0.3954562843,
0.1977475137,
0.2369536161,
0.2714474499,
-0.7527537346,
-0.5878474116,
-0.3704907894,
0.0623873919,
-1.0749591589,
-0.1634245664,
-0.1426119953,
-0.1406094879,
-0.2880386114,
-0.2602072954,
0.0785236955,
-0.7586884499,
0.1336315423,
-0.3151667714,
-0.0304011069,
0.9368207455,
-0.2120369971,
-0.0870148316,
-0.4241599441,
0.1268475801,
0.5405105948,
0.2839457989,
-0.4421847165,
-0.446208179,
-0.1905943602,
-0.4952086508,
-0.1225712076,
-0.5447373986,
0.1229815856,
0.3117902279,
0.7026084065,
0.1929690987,
0.0354863815,
0.4666088521,
-0.6342033148,
0.9707999825,
-0.1230381578,
-1.3320605755,
0.3609652817,
-0.358638227,
-0.0219784845,
0.5227170587,
0.5613794327,
-0.3115519583,
-0.4859856367,
-0.9903789759,
-1.1973009109,
0.4326523244,
0.4189207256,
0.4633854628,
-0.1366027445,
0.5620400906,
0.2274866402,
0.2364180088,
-0.7567058802,
-0.5106316209,
-0.0126623521,
0.2524871528,
0.0791334808,
-0.1636492759,
-0.4908182621,
-0.2920330763,
0.4139772654,
-0.1468116939,
0.3088156879,
0.1053229943,
-0.3489241898,
0.1619042903,
0.577840507,
0.7796484828,
0.6957896352,
0.0683258623,
0.4652587175,
0.514416635,
-0.1602595747,
0.2405937761,
0.2892998457,
-0.0959261656,
0.0389927514,
0.3348010778,
0.5773499608,
0.6442251205,
-0.2492055595,
0.4939993322,
0.0468784198,
-0.1668216139,
0.1202513501,
-0.0497631952,
-0.305381,
0.1913814396,
0.3724443913,
0.1019003838,
0.474893719,
-0.5418944359,
0.4499446154,
0.4778092504,
-0.5266136527,
-0.2458026111,
0.6222014427,
0.1044140607,
-0.0782730654,
0.1461887807,
-0.3439545333,
-0.7515230775,
0.3805138171,
0.3694927692,
0.5977066755,
0.0177524015,
0.087916851,
-0.137042582,
-0.1642481983,
0.0807866007,
-0.1281382143,
-0.3740817308,
-0.8108150959,
-0.3929739594,
-0.4691225886,
-0.6680967212,
0.0169840623,
-0.70492661,
-0.0592896454,
-0.2782523036,
-0.2881061733,
0.6543089747,
-0.1386594474,
-0.4524428248,
0.277518332,
0.3599319756,
0.5377660394,
-0.8206579685,
0.4948972464,
0.6175516248,
-0.3736024201,
-0.7611761689,
0.0201969631,
0.1510977894,
-0.4182360768,
0.8775304556,
0.2330407649,
-0.2991926372,
-0.0350606851,
-0.5471323133,
-0.701775372,
0.4680405259,
0.4114874601,
0.1848537773,
0.1144026294,
0.2553829551,
0.7970882654,
-0.5903551579,
0.711079061,
0.9336823821,
0.5140534639,
0.1079868004,
-0.9907064438,
0.3869739771,
-0.447244525,
-0.0430055112,
0.1127297506,
-0.5836089849,
0.9412887692,
-0.015580697,
-0.2958172262,
0.0681128204,
0.6448736787,
0.0701732486,
0.4727399647,
0.2355989516,
0.3631917834,
0.4728426039,
-0.4013495743,
1.4122161865,
-0.4709640443,
0.6575780511,
0.9090994,
-0.3676846921,
0.6517904401,
-0.0009421563,
-0.2821843028,
0.6674990058,
0.5038474202,
0.3144207597,
0.4075970352,
0.3079751134,
-0.3909820616,
-0.2476702929,
-0.6895821095,
-0.7400764823,
0.4357128739,
0.4936371446,
-0.1497479975,
-0.2340325862,
-0.2740840018,
0.1558777839,
-0.1694811583,
-0.3524220288,
0.5900461078,
0.0662916601,
-0.709598124,
0.5727844238,
-0.0928040519,
0.3202089071,
-0.5430353284,
-0.1801306456,
-0.2684887648,
0.0284429677,
-0.3556395173,
-0.9120489359,
0.3766688406,
-0.295333147,
-0.0738074407,
-0.2526868284,
0.7771533132,
0.0874070525,
-0.2584808171,
0.4024914801,
0.4148715138,
0.2927805483,
-0.1006221622,
-0.7710006833,
-0.2391406596,
-0.4986697733,
-0.4679502249,
0.402790606,
0.5854244828,
-0.2759104967,
0.3088192344,
0.6702705026,
0.0350162014,
-0.2337453961,
0.2332670987,
0.9483055472,
-0.6904394031,
-0.4482741058,
-0.8565303087,
0.2808803618,
-0.0766213909,
-0.607586205,
0.8901643157,
0.4896022379,
0.8203563094,
0.3453652859,
0.7783225179,
0.0791482776,
0.3164644539,
-0.2761326134,
0.0954031721,
-0.5352132916,
0.3072934747,
-0.7245599031,
-0.9902986884,
-0.6441255808,
0.5723549724,
-0.5161528587,
-0.0012188478,
0.8236322403,
0.569663465,
0.0843404755,
0.5110219121,
0.3370958567,
0.1703380048,
-0.1309930235,
0.4960820377,
1.3174459934,
-0.1680381596,
0.4825228751,
-0.081386447,
-0.2041383237,
-0.1739852875,
-0.8418649435,
-0.3776524365,
-0.5567336679,
-0.1439774632,
-0.390134722,
0.1359250546,
0.6319751143,
0.8877555132,
-0.8539129496,
0.0096447757,
-0.1373358518,
0.3623793721,
-0.3434026241,
-0.2515464425,
0.4461725652,
0.0043926137,
-0.9425419569,
0.3265995979,
0.3522735536,
-0.0013489203,
-0.2896483839,
0.0856080428,
0.0847662762,
0.4450499415,
0.7847259641,
0.1415418386,
-0.5616294146,
-0.7260972261,
-0.2331057042,
-0.2221259475,
-0.0933242515,
0.9303550124,
-0.6406701207,
0.0917647481,
0.4325348139,
0.2164206058,
0.4232021868,
0.2472198457,
0.2554888725,
-0.8352312446,
-0.0612787195,
0.1177490056,
0.3217615485,
0.0441803858,
-0.2756046057,
0.7646027803,
0.6179196835,
-0.494785428,
-0.8482993245,
0.5097256899,
-0.651522398,
-0.5770938396,
1.2217476368,
-0.2598310411,
0.1573575139,
-0.5153491497,
-0.1420506835,
-0.2213648707,
-0.3003054559,
0.5299804807,
0.8063166142,
-0.5416085124,
0.2641430199,
-0.5856661797,
0.559707582,
0.6371910572,
-0.6566771269,
0.0708967671,
0.5059389472,
-0.0330334082,
0.4776577652,
0.3475148082,
0.0014905826,
0.2967408895,
-0.0050509749,
-0.3919595778,
0.0732984692,
-0.52351439,
-0.2218064815,
0.6082937121,
-0.3736484945,
0.081002824
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20962v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20962v2
|
Large Language Models are Zero-Shot Next Location Predictors
| 2024-05-31T16:07:33 | 2024-06-03T15:10:53 |
Ciro Beneduce, Bruno Lepri, Massimiliano Luca
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Predicting the locations an individual will visit in the future is crucial
for solving many societal issues like disease diffusion and reduction of
pollution among many others. The models designed to tackle next-location
prediction, however, require a significant amount of individual-level
information to be trained effectively. Such data may be scarce or even
unavailable in some geographic regions or peculiar scenarios (e.g., cold-start
in recommendation systems). Moreover, the design of a next-location predictor
able to generalize or geographically transfer knowledge is still an open
research challenge. Recent advances in natural language processing have led to
a rapid diffusion of Large Language Models (LLMs) which have shown good
generalization and reasoning capabilities. These insights, coupled with the
recent findings that LLMs are rich in geographical knowledge, allowed us to
believe that these models can act as zero-shot next-location predictors. This
paper evaluates the capabilities of many popular LLMs in this role,
specifically Llama, GPT-3.5 and Mistral 7B. After designing a proper prompt, we
tested the models on three real-world mobility datasets. The results show that
LLMs can obtain accuracies up to 32.4%, a significant relative improvement of
over 600% when compared to sophisticated DL models specifically designed for
human mobility. Moreover, we show that other LLMs are unable to perform the
task properly. To prevent positively biased results, we also propose a
framework inspired by other studies to test data contamination. Finally, we
explored the possibility of using LLMs as text-based explainers for
next-location prediction showing that can effectively provide an explanation
for their decision. Notably, 7B models provide more generic, but still
reliable, explanations compared to larger counterparts. Code:
github.com/ssai-trento/LLM-zero-shot-NL
|
[
-0.2189792395,
-0.6705721021,
1.2592701912,
-0.1590522677,
0.0408059023,
-0.2862052917,
-0.165671736,
-0.6285027266,
-0.0237578265,
0.5857539773,
-0.2296863347,
-0.7727075219,
-0.50289011,
-0.1382035464,
-0.6312782764,
0.5378366113,
-0.1277210265,
-0.3333999813,
0.0150954919,
-0.0806749687,
-0.6102721691,
-0.7502108812,
-0.5388792753,
-0.3570820689,
0.6215923429,
0.4625958502,
0.9366365075,
0.6568514109,
0.2653353214,
0.2193445414,
-0.2468166649,
-0.3281024396,
-0.3533419073,
0.1564483792,
-0.245034188,
-0.5033257008,
-0.0875164494,
-0.4140220582,
0.7202916741,
0.7540869713,
-0.1091456264,
0.0327841602,
-0.5206797719,
0.2230998129,
-0.3659707308,
-0.0744521171,
-0.7700536251,
-0.0741560981,
-0.1991535723,
0.0730185136,
-0.2563976347,
-0.3507915437,
0.5216014981,
-0.4076979756,
0.2750008106,
0.1078607291,
0.9499032497,
0.1098184735,
-0.4547306895,
-0.1027582735,
-0.9732382298,
0.721498251,
-0.8220208287,
0.2113074213,
0.5303466916,
0.5275987983,
-0.3113182187,
-0.2587171495,
-0.6012083292,
-0.3587267697,
0.222843498,
-0.2611899674,
-0.0953735262,
-0.3221998215,
0.0506835133,
-0.1366463304,
-0.5859828591,
0.5405455828,
-0.2684410512,
-0.0108387992,
0.4170875251,
0.2808916867,
0.3802002072,
0.110001646,
-0.1621220261,
0.3065747321,
-1.0050581694,
0.0283328183,
0.0757369176,
0.3883646131,
-0.2808363438,
0.6075887084,
-0.3073756993,
0.8798139095,
-0.0859471411,
-0.2320520729,
0.2393389195,
-0.2837484479,
-0.0078492826,
0.1528311074,
0.7984005809,
0.250274539,
0.3411169648,
-0.1752557904,
-0.0651701912,
-0.3750448823,
-0.0968183354,
-0.7486451864,
-0.0393452607,
0.3973449469,
-0.2516281307,
-0.1452473998,
-0.1932940036,
-0.5009803772,
-0.3774743676,
-0.2706913352,
0.0216877926,
-0.3358589113,
-0.306522727,
0.2781202495,
0.2006089985,
0.4187164009,
0.5038811564,
-1.0052863359,
-0.2848264575,
0.5131883025,
1.2067953348,
-0.1447790563,
-0.4943956435,
-0.1932063103,
0.4190971255,
-0.3443122506,
1.1193746328,
-0.6493685842,
-0.4116089642,
0.2053937167,
0.0441096798,
0.1029656157,
-0.3984467983,
0.4836087525,
-0.5788057446,
0.1791134626,
-0.4689357877,
-0.1818123758,
-0.5150481462,
0.230341509,
-0.4549563825,
0.8052407503,
0.0911609158,
-0.4471248686,
0.3830549121,
-0.4795544446,
-0.53319484,
0.1931892037,
0.2671390772,
-0.2082118541,
0.1595513672,
0.2939455211,
0.558750689,
-0.2727442682,
0.5455775857,
-0.6463937759,
-0.4841199815,
0.1858975142,
-0.4660534859,
0.6572538614,
0.1140821204,
-0.2789964378,
-0.0128123825,
-0.5689961314,
-0.2043866515,
0.049496673,
-0.277225554,
-0.4493242502,
0.0460513309,
-0.1865616441,
0.3966297507,
0.4000342786,
-0.414955169,
0.0820689201,
-0.3974971771,
0.271433562,
0.7665162683,
-0.1032432541,
0.8818864822,
-0.1356657147,
0.8148756623,
-0.0420936272,
0.015622546,
-0.4144222438,
-0.6108806133,
-0.3107610345,
0.013961968,
0.0398820676,
0.7130191326,
-0.5394767523,
0.2403770536,
-0.5287720561,
-0.5820499659,
-0.0588193052,
-0.1168733835,
-0.0826462731,
0.5876248479,
0.1875589788,
0.2296721637,
-0.4225132763,
-0.4011957645,
0.0442802683,
-0.2679824233,
-0.0047630961,
0.2191143185,
0.3051917851,
-0.2729299366,
0.989187777,
-0.3699377179,
0.0088426424,
-0.5274677277,
-0.4174494743,
0.4312705994,
-0.0388056301,
0.6027965546,
-0.6823385358,
-0.5417199731,
0.201333791,
-0.9868605733,
-0.2986886203,
-0.1558409482,
-0.2507814467,
0.0426769406,
0.357393533,
-0.8311482072,
0.2396704108,
0.7264962792,
-0.3723890483,
0.4936332703,
-0.2763874233,
-0.2413291782,
-1.0387921333,
-0.0273602623,
0.2585861981,
-0.1935427189,
-0.7862498164,
-0.1676077098,
-0.3168138564,
-0.2153898776,
-0.5406309962,
0.9174727201,
-0.4022898376,
-0.2161817551,
-0.3161705732,
0.2373477966,
-0.3611031175,
-0.0714694634,
0.0634777695,
0.7505766153,
0.6651008725,
-0.5867764354,
0.1545020938,
0.2165383399,
-0.431170553,
0.3402656317,
-0.6638874412,
-0.1252807081,
-0.2874084711,
0.5572170615,
-0.9550856352,
-0.3238707483,
-0.045908954,
-0.3231003881,
-0.0778481364,
-0.3157486916,
-0.4934194684,
-0.4380020797,
0.0323788039,
0.3274557889,
0.4824799597,
-0.6676142216,
0.4822158217,
0.4245024323,
-0.2701043487,
-0.5380309224,
-0.5385706425,
0.3325804472,
-0.5478374362,
-0.4789688885,
-0.0139855621,
0.1135190725,
-0.2675822675,
-0.0195984095,
0.2051092386,
-0.1395689547,
0.1938394606,
0.5913059115,
0.4851210713,
0.0038743364,
0.14920789,
-0.2498195767,
-0.3665554225,
-0.0495142676,
-0.6291095614,
0.5689747334,
0.1722242832,
-0.2691161931,
-0.3995550871,
0.1503430307,
0.6886311173,
-0.2136708498,
0.9072486162,
0.5438238382,
-0.2849582136,
0.1401553452,
-0.5927887559,
0.3069574237,
-0.4436236918,
0.5158616304,
-0.4130191505,
-0.8880302906,
0.6189880967,
-0.2144348323,
0.0687034354,
0.2836501896,
0.7022199035,
-0.0239569563,
0.8345795274,
0.9124943018,
-0.3622572124,
0.6306663156,
-0.0652691573,
0.5727966428,
-0.4572387636,
-0.3468430042,
-0.5171622634,
-0.0196184702,
-0.5264958739,
-0.363093257,
0.290695101,
0.1105387658,
-0.4188979268,
0.3942185044,
-0.0920083299,
0.7490891814,
0.3536914885,
-0.4097293317,
0.0530450344,
0.3728697598,
-0.1686288267,
0.1867617369,
-0.7476934195,
-0.6203683615,
1.046094656,
0.4025186598,
0.779461205,
0.2136627734,
0.5251105428,
0.0040411125,
0.3542549908,
-0.6995258927,
0.5275110602,
-0.2390327156,
-0.4335334301,
-0.4709481299,
-0.3911583126,
-0.9826754928,
0.1922084987,
-0.0187095236,
-0.9964112043,
0.1745465249,
-0.1474331468,
-0.6085548401,
0.5731009245,
-0.6130697727,
0.4861005545,
-0.3149383664,
-0.3205433786,
0.2534754276,
-0.5139437914,
0.2884177864,
-0.3229792118,
0.4579007328,
-0.4658431411,
0.1143211275,
0.2414243817,
-0.2534654438,
0.8027873039,
-0.3437761664,
-0.4013127685,
0.2554862499,
0.2468624711,
0.4585808516,
-0.1169907749,
-0.4790862203,
0.5598733425,
-0.1748091877,
-0.2149437219,
-0.3572393954,
0.8941201568,
-0.6830647588,
-0.4241114557,
-0.1822139919,
-0.5335597396,
-0.0705514252,
0.2922765911,
0.3699172139,
0.385068506,
0.1881624758,
-0.0650601164,
0.6276209354,
-0.5505993962,
0.6249243021,
0.6794316769,
-0.3016681969,
-0.1829041541,
0.9055634737,
0.1974158734,
0.0923062935,
0.6276745796,
0.3197066784,
-0.7364474535,
-0.7270830274,
-0.3206645846,
0.3586993515,
-0.5687887073,
-0.1871281266,
-0.6782127023,
0.0185111184,
-0.3176985681,
-0.6274400949,
-0.2042327821,
-0.2621201575,
-0.2732085884,
-0.3106942177,
0.0924256071,
0.8339381814,
-0.1776751131,
0.5514492989,
-0.6208366752,
0.1596810818,
-0.1743650734,
0.087704286,
0.064763695,
-0.713852942,
-0.4545249045,
-0.0771044567,
-0.0341970548,
-0.7891884446,
0.6468304992,
-0.2120600194,
0.5903590918,
0.3856491446,
-0.1350548565,
0.7045586705,
-0.6654478312,
1.0029747486,
0.2704029679,
-0.6557567716,
0.5403640866,
-0.5789618492,
0.6866722107,
0.3664917946,
0.4884956181,
-0.4170558751,
-0.337615639,
-0.3098195791,
-0.9529595375,
0.3348793983,
-0.2599008381,
0.2971417606,
-0.0669040903,
0.5899493098,
0.0272217188,
-0.1130568236,
-0.7729760408,
-0.0292823017,
0.2096018195,
-0.0708679482,
-0.4030266404,
-0.650638938,
0.3070833981,
-0.0197744798,
0.5123517513,
-0.0118446071,
0.1716753691,
0.067645438,
0.1146343127,
-0.1519199014,
0.2985785902,
0.7872402072,
0.869659245,
-0.199268505,
0.0528837852,
0.4520599544,
-0.2129580677,
0.5457251668,
-0.0769238546,
-0.5900350809,
0.2555429637,
0.3883164823,
0.5262516737,
-0.0657992959,
-0.5663779974,
0.55277282,
0.1477833092,
0.0526739955,
-0.7181182504,
-0.171050638,
0.0611182712,
0.2029357105,
0.2409654111,
-0.1742755622,
0.0311970841,
-0.5347447395,
-0.0403609127,
0.3956232667,
-0.4135315716,
-0.5210055709,
0.8974072933,
0.040982563,
-0.2090530545,
0.5239302516,
-0.2880530655,
-0.5174977183,
0.4924637377,
0.6361583471,
0.7039037943,
-0.4890202582,
0.2573204637,
0.4951392412,
0.2817862928,
-0.469435513,
0.0326289348,
0.2096300572,
-0.8196319938,
-0.7054358125,
-0.5209155679,
-0.2391333133,
0.0708116964,
-0.2982267141,
0.4303028584,
-0.316645056,
-0.301871419,
-0.3665530682,
-0.2654918134,
-0.6733624935,
0.0464987159,
0.3601586521,
0.7432829142,
-0.7813413143,
0.8398352861,
0.7563511133,
0.0449281819,
-0.8085261583,
0.1468551457,
-0.0228276812,
-0.6890087128,
0.6797335744,
0.295358777,
-0.104561761,
-0.4204418957,
-0.542601347,
-1.1487865448,
1.2043725252,
0.4561263025,
-0.8744519353,
-0.4123020172,
0.1569004059,
0.5048865676,
-0.2621213496,
0.4110597372,
0.4841418266,
0.2925262451,
0.3186990917,
-1.015846014,
0.0164551903,
0.3787938654,
0.3621076941,
0.1107404977,
-0.5100927949,
0.7605570555,
-0.8152917027,
-0.0690987334,
0.3023505509,
0.3758183718,
0.4118298292,
0.3344723284,
0.3050598502,
0.5876426101,
0.7551735044,
0.0396987274,
1.3558772802,
-0.3045635819,
0.25424546,
1.3221884966,
-0.711242497,
1.0363891125,
0.1790924519,
0.0212404653,
0.6819492579,
0.5321797132,
0.0229648668,
0.702069521,
0.1927359849,
-0.4339414835,
-0.1759477407,
-0.2695183158,
-0.2581474781,
0.5771828294,
0.2848728299,
-0.353435576,
-0.4254773259,
0.0671990663,
0.2166554034,
-0.2725175917,
-0.2682599723,
0.4996868074,
-0.0379203483,
-0.4035788774,
0.4023096561,
0.187614426,
0.5369433761,
-0.5833225846,
0.0094805397,
-0.3464765549,
0.0786484405,
-0.1826424748,
-0.9440619349,
0.1518947631,
-0.0667674169,
-0.0912351757,
-0.2698413134,
0.8089771271,
-0.2275454849,
-0.5253352523,
0.3113992512,
0.5313430429,
0.3438538611,
-0.1837138236,
-0.3456368744,
-0.0445301495,
0.1697875261,
-0.1048290953,
0.3523979485,
0.7146789432,
-0.1753628105,
1.12654531,
0.9876032472,
0.4004520476,
0.0631215423,
0.0365370214,
0.4647921324,
-0.8774365187,
-0.5498031378,
-1.0019577742,
0.2020426244,
0.2810350657,
-0.0199123677,
0.7768139839,
0.3779712021,
0.5072121024,
0.1656747311,
0.9302965403,
0.2734122574,
0.4476955533,
-0.373873502,
0.4443171322,
-0.2191309333,
0.5753193498,
0.1166768298,
-0.8974201083,
-0.3569440842,
0.6300144792,
-0.7557309866,
0.0326135233,
0.4299759269,
0.6551442146,
0.0622765981,
-0.4035585523,
0.5752806067,
0.1793869585,
0.665256381,
0.7469274998,
1.0239468813,
-0.1225891933,
0.4751367569,
-0.0559051782,
-0.0041334624,
-0.1443038881,
-0.779707849,
-0.8743456602,
-0.3121971786,
-0.1142728478,
-0.2567974031,
-0.0096523901,
0.4967141151,
0.9403836131,
-0.5563477874,
-0.223500371,
-0.2035464495,
0.212438345,
0.3787152469,
-0.2626133263,
0.1699298918,
-0.0462541319,
-0.3074758649,
0.4006070495,
0.4025031924,
0.4069218636,
-0.322460115,
0.0857226551,
0.0892371908,
-0.1256072968,
0.85673666,
0.3259524107,
-0.7889143229,
-0.2612615228,
-0.0995568037,
-0.0268235635,
-0.1879318058,
0.5226202011,
-0.8990598917,
0.1266435534,
0.1922557354,
0.422529459,
0.2413653731,
0.1137675494,
0.6682043672,
-0.2693545222,
0.1725720614,
-0.0543537103,
0.4493855238,
0.4925937653,
-0.5590745211,
0.3767789304,
-0.0473313257,
-0.6698786616,
-0.687074542,
0.1455703378,
-0.7419354916,
-0.1356960982,
1.7144409418,
-0.1489092261,
-0.184534803,
-0.2735393047,
-0.0991001651,
-0.222957328,
-0.5060245991,
0.6705905795,
0.6416568756,
0.0407112911,
-0.3241405487,
-1.0393669605,
0.0101899542,
0.2278045267,
-0.9547415376,
0.0903510377,
0.5838750601,
0.6596614122,
0.0493714623,
0.8961630464,
-0.0836757496,
-0.1171181425,
-0.256439209,
-0.1321621835,
0.0414882004,
-0.4721072614,
-0.6174702644,
0.2694560885,
0.1906286627,
0.0042064493
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20956v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20956v2
|
A Robot Walks into a Bar: Can Language Models Serve as Creativity Support Tools for Comedy? An Evaluation of LLMs' Humour Alignment with Comedians
| 2024-05-31T15:55:51 | 2024-06-03T21:01:50 |
Piotr Wojciech Mirowski, Juliette Love, Kory W. Mathewson, Shakir Mohamed
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We interviewed twenty professional comedians who perform live shows in front
of audiences and who use artificial intelligence in their artistic process as
part of 3-hour workshops on ``AI x Comedy'' conducted at the Edinburgh Festival
Fringe in August 2023 and online. The workshop consisted of a comedy writing
session with large language models (LLMs), a human-computer interaction
questionnaire to assess the Creativity Support Index of AI as a writing tool,
and a focus group interrogating the comedians' motivations for and processes of
using AI, as well as their ethical concerns about bias, censorship and
copyright. Participants noted that existing moderation strategies used in
safety filtering and instruction-tuned LLMs reinforced hegemonic viewpoints by
erasing minority groups and their perspectives, and qualified this as a form of
censorship. At the same time, most participants felt the LLMs did not succeed
as a creativity support tool, by producing bland and biased comedy tropes, akin
to ``cruise ship comedy material from the 1950s, but a bit less racist''. Our
work extends scholarship about the subtle difference between, one the one hand,
harmful speech, and on the other hand, ``offensive'' language as a practice of
resistance, satire and ``punching up''. We also interrogate the global value
alignment behind such language models, and discuss the importance of
community-based value alignment and data ownership to build AI tools that
better suit artists' needs.
|
[
-0.1190416291,
-0.4474944472,
0.2530534267,
0.0327594541,
-0.2994019091,
0.2613265216,
-0.1268889606,
-0.4703211784,
0.6147574186,
0.4938170016,
-0.5474182963,
0.0808844119,
-0.5410211682,
0.2158284634,
-0.5247010589,
0.7696636915,
0.3383829892,
0.1649741232,
-0.2962099016,
-0.3649953008,
-0.2465676665,
-0.2702635825,
-0.5259027481,
-0.1877139509,
0.7879309654,
0.2617583573,
1.0505219698,
0.5809761882,
0.556841135,
0.315893054,
-0.0276878551,
-0.1305299699,
-0.2206759751,
-0.1795140207,
-0.2844111025,
-0.5794245005,
-0.3630624115,
0.1996400654,
0.3134558797,
0.9986193776,
-0.2165979445,
0.0785077512,
-0.2184355259,
0.5456236601,
-0.2237944454,
-0.2210658789,
-0.5285897255,
0.1298252195,
-0.148825258,
-0.032503888,
-0.2141771615,
-0.5221043229,
-0.4357122183,
-0.3874281049,
-0.4313075542,
0.1538541615,
0.7978653312,
0.6977533698,
-0.1056522205,
-0.35304901,
-0.7654238939,
0.6657660007,
-0.868314743,
0.0112667419,
0.1080185547,
0.3171390593,
-0.1453808397,
-0.6819676757,
-1.0709824562,
-0.1818238497,
0.2500544786,
0.1532908082,
-0.2946586609,
-0.2366656512,
0.2192878276,
0.1551644206,
-0.6280489564,
0.3422012925,
-0.4156284034,
0.1639620662,
0.8610039949,
0.1166570932,
0.4880990386,
-0.2018945515,
-0.1348376274,
0.0408647843,
-0.6085783243,
0.1051007286,
0.8359209299,
0.091678299,
-0.0498438589,
0.7002829313,
0.1051037908,
0.2442434877,
-0.3989288807,
-0.0910535604,
0.0666948035,
-0.0675418377,
0.0238291472,
-0.0857123882,
0.9470693469,
0.4512885809,
0.9400722384,
-0.1055441052,
-0.1023023129,
0.1191181988,
0.4298526049,
-0.2969393432,
-0.435575515,
-0.0580973551,
-0.3669750392,
-0.4747996032,
0.0513104387,
-0.2445063144,
-0.8781423569,
-0.1420986056,
0.1751770228,
-0.1140189841,
-0.3262895942,
0.0572030582,
-0.5807438493,
0.0154624665,
0.2244615257,
-0.4886959791,
0.237415269,
0.5879538059,
0.4740777612,
0.0427534357,
-0.0787099451,
-0.4805497527,
0.0917223841,
-0.3792695999,
0.6690002084,
-0.7107439637,
0.0899008885,
-0.0927277952,
-0.0404467545,
0.1863378584,
-0.6314515471,
0.4840889871,
-0.347209096,
0.1691749692,
0.0868809894,
-0.392464757,
-0.0536241829,
-0.220431298,
-0.8037540913,
0.6079400778,
0.2372844815,
-0.5657712221,
0.1714329123,
-0.270063132,
-0.6265195012,
0.4067746401,
-0.5644763112,
-0.1316520721,
0.0753217414,
0.0367834084,
0.0342254564,
-0.2347863913,
0.470692873,
-0.6941330433,
-0.5251284242,
0.7292128801,
-0.6790571213,
1.0046043396,
0.1750245541,
-0.5736695528,
0.0474715531,
-0.4628707469,
-0.1824637353,
0.4429303408,
-0.1451409012,
0.0773044974,
0.4760775268,
0.0621472225,
0.4204213619,
-0.1216656268,
-0.5843985081,
0.085288845,
-0.6359518766,
0.6873354912,
0.9914883375,
-0.6111927032,
0.0200666115,
-0.731310904,
1.0018624067,
-0.4342914224,
0.0417773798,
-0.0583166666,
-0.8666941524,
-0.6445963979,
-0.169147402,
-0.1790911555,
0.7806084752,
-0.4809275568,
0.6102035642,
-0.2661442161,
-0.4298854768,
-0.7991813421,
0.3581231534,
-0.0089839548,
0.328286618,
-0.1178718582,
-0.5674715042,
-0.4748425782,
-0.7551196814,
-0.4812088609,
-0.3445637226,
0.001897597,
0.3454118371,
0.1827729493,
0.1613631994,
0.8095188141,
0.0032203514,
-0.0511913821,
-0.7732993364,
-0.0555239916,
0.3144075274,
0.0653718263,
0.7039774656,
-0.7221207619,
-0.4165422022,
-0.1802704185,
-0.7390109301,
-0.5218936205,
0.0804166198,
0.3275391459,
0.2783304155,
0.3158186972,
-0.4075146019,
0.5827431679,
0.525503099,
-0.2531143129,
0.4343040884,
0.3082158566,
0.0290592518,
-0.8056889176,
0.058528401,
-0.2459894121,
-0.3131125867,
-0.5114949346,
-0.1391960233,
-0.4855707884,
-0.3310700059,
-0.6062396765,
0.7874689698,
0.0320750587,
0.0485446751,
-0.4633659422,
0.4748859107,
-0.0833936557,
0.176717788,
-0.0505074039,
0.498167336,
0.3373529911,
-0.2378241867,
0.6957200766,
-0.0486888513,
-0.4188711941,
0.5194455385,
-0.3366563916,
0.3852408528,
-0.0811908543,
0.2301887274,
-1.3413393497,
-0.2599695325,
0.4973598123,
-0.3690891862,
-0.1438488662,
0.0106432,
-0.5729959011,
-0.6185921431,
-0.142027542,
0.4588218927,
0.5947153568,
-0.1930532306,
0.5954825282,
0.4843219817,
-0.6869679093,
-0.6793062091,
-0.7437006831,
0.4919226468,
-0.4990525544,
-0.9139719009,
0.0914777741,
-0.3912547529,
-0.7060313225,
0.0977680981,
0.1313592494,
0.2166735083,
0.3124481142,
0.2501996458,
-0.1983173937,
-0.1078938171,
-0.1142977253,
-0.2073502243,
0.1730442345,
0.0789893568,
-0.1934045851,
0.6754024625,
0.2169856131,
-0.5049181581,
-0.8811782002,
0.392791301,
0.2864424586,
0.1904651076,
0.4054249823,
0.5788251758,
-0.1575592011,
-0.0006373002,
-0.6526734829,
0.0848632604,
-0.5027144551,
0.1053948477,
0.2187391222,
-0.9433199763,
0.4440431893,
0.1557902843,
-0.2183310837,
0.3837797344,
0.4514557719,
-0.4944012463,
0.9268934727,
0.9072203636,
-0.2913152575,
0.7018839717,
0.1079984829,
0.6922013164,
-0.3454047441,
0.1009645313,
-0.5557253361,
-0.7206753492,
-0.3833243847,
-0.2268757075,
0.2193101496,
0.0125158802,
-0.0153105436,
0.0305042975,
-0.1000756621,
0.5975320935,
0.4756382704,
-0.3496097028,
0.0595946535,
-0.1081399098,
0.031571582,
0.0815496147,
-0.6629483104,
-0.7104594707,
0.7801853418,
0.3013579547,
0.8948865533,
0.3004161716,
0.4230031073,
0.5348260403,
0.3553635776,
-0.7430626154,
0.6821121573,
-0.3236846626,
-0.5185317397,
-0.2589730918,
-0.1617422402,
-0.4914498627,
-0.3935951293,
0.2463267297,
-0.9790285826,
-0.0825832412,
0.0255970862,
-0.2283557802,
0.6033681631,
-0.5560881495,
0.5266757607,
-0.3909395635,
-0.3010379076,
-0.2369247228,
-0.7973617911,
0.0844785646,
0.099643521,
0.8008137345,
-0.2047821283,
0.285556376,
0.7651007771,
-0.0605548285,
1.1474409103,
0.033093363,
-0.1158883944,
0.4070127606,
0.2179692388,
0.1761821061,
-0.1761586666,
-0.4208923578,
0.2784945667,
-0.1792779118,
-0.1877367646,
-0.7285016775,
0.3461984396,
-0.6396819949,
-0.970546782,
0.0205763336,
-0.8445500731,
0.3350844681,
0.106452927,
-0.1456501931,
0.18947649,
0.1017303616,
0.2487897575,
0.0886326879,
-0.4437494576,
0.6081720591,
-0.0571891479,
-0.0561502203,
-0.6519814134,
0.7619401217,
0.0319336951,
0.4743032157,
0.1608875692,
0.2773400843,
-0.1957912445,
-0.0941384137,
-0.4261024296,
0.3514083028,
-0.9652135372,
-0.0092759663,
-0.5388061404,
-0.3120185435,
-0.6681507826,
-0.537596643,
-0.098298192,
-1.037481308,
-0.1860693991,
0.128900677,
0.1177158728,
1.027842164,
-0.3038297594,
0.2886458039,
-0.226002261,
0.0020567318,
-0.1005227566,
0.2925215662,
-0.1508703828,
-0.5627242923,
-0.2122379392,
-0.2557194531,
-0.4372188449,
-0.917054534,
0.3130793869,
0.2275315672,
0.6363874078,
0.4790734053,
0.0884230956,
0.2672237456,
-0.4932109714,
1.0531876087,
0.0389750376,
-0.6938524842,
0.5866872668,
-0.1876874417,
-0.0450637452,
0.0960521996,
0.4850319624,
-0.7771548033,
-0.916206181,
-0.6441969872,
-0.6707004905,
0.7390269637,
0.0463917442,
0.6524148583,
-0.2948744893,
0.3705456555,
0.108230345,
0.5497871637,
-1.0952911377,
-0.2355201095,
-0.2197976708,
-0.4969217181,
-0.0422212295,
-0.0534594841,
-0.5528174639,
-0.149993971,
0.3635556698,
-0.2524651885,
0.281381011,
-0.1090491116,
0.0920700952,
-0.5065021515,
0.1049690917,
0.4414538145,
0.8935011625,
-0.0086415578,
0.1752326638,
-0.1759702563,
-0.2490585297,
0.1154564023,
-0.1700254232,
0.1575332284,
-0.2457847595,
0.4102926254,
0.5789148808,
-0.3540600538,
-1.1042488813,
0.5355933309,
0.0652311966,
-0.1222849935,
-0.5535141826,
0.5399729609,
0.1057872772,
0.5644907951,
0.0322327912,
-0.1232506335,
-0.0030235301,
-0.8981516361,
0.1842389703,
0.6199131608,
-0.302939713,
-0.2179831117,
1.0232410431,
-0.0196608286,
-0.9983054996,
0.4857621491,
-0.1832448095,
-0.5694109797,
0.7669650912,
0.5280718207,
0.9661307335,
0.1447051764,
0.0961046144,
-0.1646765172,
0.4174885154,
0.4098344445,
0.4358223379,
0.0977964923,
-0.8861236572,
-0.3829181194,
-0.5188654065,
-0.4833896756,
-0.0731713325,
-0.2160477638,
0.4493795335,
-0.4325256348,
-0.0041266666,
0.0648296848,
-0.241298914,
-0.5268617868,
-0.0111905457,
0.6309275627,
0.9780531526,
-0.9149079323,
0.7337919474,
0.8107320666,
-0.5758439302,
-0.7202733159,
0.1661798507,
0.4116960168,
-0.6896528006,
0.7198899388,
0.1985954493,
-0.2515797615,
-0.1371683329,
-0.7535122633,
-0.6450382471,
0.7759113312,
0.5151451826,
-0.2700307071,
-0.043719247,
0.5640277863,
0.5118975043,
-0.6109267473,
0.3747495115,
0.3109714985,
0.168450892,
0.3128024638,
-1.0478123426,
-0.0964982286,
-0.4730790555,
-0.2841676176,
-0.1254778057,
-0.7323413491,
0.546035111,
-0.2894002795,
0.0528326929,
0.3187308013,
0.3843854964,
0.2721609771,
0.3297500014,
0.5469333529,
0.6413475275,
0.7891730666,
-0.0532428548,
1.1091856956,
-0.1425345093,
-0.1794370711,
0.8042587638,
-0.5008509159,
0.7500686049,
0.3759178221,
-0.0604190715,
0.810999155,
0.2017802,
0.0135138091,
0.3604682088,
0.3962228,
-0.0425021425,
-0.1970854402,
-0.2959056795,
0.0304277185,
0.3488826156,
0.1534058601,
-0.1835797876,
0.1922869682,
0.0474558175,
0.1015060097,
0.2722432315,
-0.0044885254,
0.6608071327,
0.3496600389,
-0.4870481193,
0.3047003448,
-0.1215535179,
0.4389009476,
-0.2839677036,
0.1827833802,
-0.2312797308,
0.0152757429,
-0.1035333648,
-1.1500790119,
0.3967314363,
0.0040360945,
0.1327078491,
0.0318678394,
0.4802734852,
-0.0025728238,
-0.471919626,
0.3356948197,
0.1244272515,
0.4845606983,
0.2524531782,
-0.7405397892,
0.1261932999,
-0.2137355357,
-0.0154804364,
0.0745992884,
0.6049168706,
-0.0999302715,
1.0508110523,
0.2833150029,
0.3622132242,
0.1489388049,
0.5689610243,
0.8809791803,
-0.8669412732,
-0.4069308043,
-0.8497508764,
0.8709637523,
0.0138878748,
-0.218894273,
0.2946783006,
0.2889647782,
1.0325525999,
0.2614994347,
0.8127243519,
-0.359556824,
0.2950637341,
-0.5669353008,
0.6871271133,
-0.8716583252,
0.308950454,
-0.4205732048,
-0.6988843679,
-0.4335409999,
0.4687103331,
-0.2871556282,
0.3307180107,
0.447799772,
0.928950727,
0.1701496691,
-0.0042821299,
0.3898877203,
0.1910129339,
0.6360609531,
0.0326367058,
1.307139039,
0.0511249565,
0.4875069261,
-0.2765574157,
-0.0675044581,
-0.1827987134,
-0.9508327842,
-0.8011190891,
-0.3047457933,
-0.4572023451,
-0.2515431345,
-0.0580644608,
1.1496529579,
0.3116284013,
-0.3616940975,
-0.5785522461,
0.2676551938,
0.1881387085,
-0.2653031945,
-0.2351823002,
-0.0782269388,
-0.2145555019,
-0.7379401922,
0.5026266575,
0.5913267732,
-0.2879755497,
-0.4404560626,
0.026245635,
-0.0931834951,
0.4525424242,
0.4297738671,
0.1052734256,
-1.1067761183,
-0.360937655,
-0.0787369907,
0.2181248069,
0.1459579766,
0.4917030931,
-0.5223935246,
0.3710693121,
0.3563289046,
0.5515770912,
-0.4503497779,
-0.0346041955,
0.4504669011,
-0.5856631994,
0.2048671395,
0.4623297155,
0.3822796345,
0.3613268137,
-0.3626282811,
0.4949721396,
0.5776802301,
-0.8415369391,
-0.9043275714,
0.2985775769,
-0.8420986533,
-0.0912443027,
1.1483590603,
0.1454269886,
-0.352242738,
0.0598747954,
-0.0634790137,
0.1940643489,
0.0220948327,
0.8385087252,
0.8791949153,
-0.3596760631,
-0.4307064414,
-0.8295568824,
0.3640596271,
0.4733366668,
-0.5078200102,
-0.1211927235,
0.2972069383,
0.368786037,
0.1056087166,
0.5961827636,
0.0131479483,
0.1619341522,
-0.3163827062,
0.2988322675,
0.4942448139,
-0.5452777147,
-0.3438875973,
0.0098178843,
0.469494015,
0.5274514556
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20947v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20947v2
|
OR-Bench: An Over-Refusal Benchmark for Large Language Models
| 2024-05-31T15:44:33 | 2024-06-20T05:22:38 |
Justin Cui, Wei-Lin Chiang, Ion Stoica, Cho-Jui Hsieh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) require careful safety alignment to prevent
malicious outputs. While significant research focuses on mitigating harmful
content generation, the enhanced safety often come with the side effect of
over-refusal, where LLMs may reject innocuous prompts and become less helpful.
Although the issue of over-refusal has been empirically observed, a systematic
measurement is challenging due to the difficulty of crafting prompts that
appear harmful but are benign. This study proposes a novel method for
automatically generating large-scale sets of "seemingly toxic prompts" (benign
prompts likely rejected by LLMs). Leveraging this technique, we introduce
OR-Bench, the first large-scale over-refusal benchmark. OR-Bench comprises
80,000 seemingly toxic prompts across 10 common rejection categories, a subset
of around 1,000 hard prompts that are challenging even for state-of-the-art
LLMs, and an additional 600 toxic prompts to prevent indiscriminate responses.
We then conduct a comprehensive study to measure the over-refusal of 25 popular
LLMs across 8 model families. Our datasets are available at
https://huggingface.co/datasets/bench-llm/or-bench and the demo can be found at
https://huggingface.co/spaces/bench-llm/or-bench. We hope this benchmark can
help the community develop better safety aligned models.
|
[
-0.3521602154,
-0.7319456339,
0.6986336112,
0.089725107,
-0.0157844052,
-0.1414811611,
-0.1575254053,
-0.4292801619,
-0.3223898411,
0.511310041,
-0.6657392383,
-0.5896403193,
-0.3995957077,
0.0417257808,
-0.699606657,
0.870362699,
-0.0565742366,
-0.0297948215,
-0.1242396384,
-0.2454025447,
-0.6083428264,
-0.2825785875,
-0.7814652324,
-0.1654975861,
0.6722247005,
0.3208871186,
0.5039739609,
0.6467679739,
0.2303902507,
0.2608389854,
-0.0164080393,
-0.0968030691,
-0.4387784004,
0.41369766,
-0.421433419,
-0.3595858812,
-0.4423801601,
0.0969580039,
0.7255590558,
0.7235289216,
-0.1965963244,
0.3069586456,
-0.0504830033,
0.6318278313,
-0.8770159483,
-0.1149436086,
-0.7749519348,
-0.1862716675,
-0.4512532353,
0.1385353208,
-0.7491127849,
-0.5992107391,
-0.149903968,
-0.3708102107,
-0.2536456883,
0.2207908481,
0.6030508876,
0.2012342662,
-0.4829573631,
-0.192548871,
-0.3847842813,
0.796425581,
-0.6617401242,
0.4644919634,
0.3220143616,
0.479966253,
-0.5363492966,
-0.3335739672,
-0.5729649067,
-0.3782390356,
0.1811037809,
0.0192408636,
-0.1539130211,
-0.1786943823,
0.5124782324,
-0.0552261434,
-0.8748193383,
0.3240233362,
-0.0905782506,
-0.0093754055,
0.6862798333,
0.5287114382,
0.3635372221,
-0.0712616593,
-0.5543757677,
-0.2931320071,
-1.0812017918,
0.1879372299,
0.1653243303,
0.3649096191,
-0.036141403,
0.7722159028,
-0.1074157432,
0.5915296674,
-0.094008632,
0.0191155132,
0.3500322402,
-0.1586379707,
-0.0644761994,
0.2179709226,
0.9708701372,
0.6928498149,
0.3417985439,
0.1607901156,
-0.4189221561,
0.228680864,
0.1517347544,
-0.870639801,
0.2216500342,
0.4535004795,
-0.4740154147,
-0.2142964453,
-0.2847607434,
-0.9582403898,
-1.2481964827,
-0.161541,
0.2823334336,
-0.566046834,
-0.1305420548,
0.1425732225,
-0.0809509754,
0.2117924541,
0.1069963202,
-0.6545454264,
0.4404521585,
0.6315954924,
0.6805264354,
-0.2541263402,
-0.427359134,
-0.7401288748,
0.0872756392,
-0.4043217599,
0.7365649939,
-0.440697372,
-0.6341279745,
0.167942673,
-0.1745326966,
-0.0785386562,
-0.6662819982,
0.8596864343,
-0.4132865965,
0.0101711052,
-0.6487606168,
-0.3819001615,
0.0269367173,
0.3777606487,
-0.4260129333,
0.9737309217,
0.087868005,
-0.4830698669,
0.7748120427,
-0.290813297,
-0.6478732228,
-0.2892142534,
-0.2626455426,
-0.4354134798,
0.0606791005,
-0.0719040781,
0.1803480387,
-0.6271371841,
0.3947131336,
-0.876327455,
-0.0479245186,
0.5903431177,
-0.5661705732,
0.8898687363,
0.2569588423,
-0.3315545619,
0.2942436337,
-1.1641045809,
0.0066849212,
0.1686272174,
-0.29489851,
-0.4452219307,
0.0973941237,
0.2430251092,
0.5545628667,
0.0175483264,
-0.9072147608,
-0.1552700847,
-0.3516437113,
0.6119520068,
0.7907764912,
-0.3324043453,
0.0957333595,
-0.6483516693,
0.3988597095,
-0.5347061753,
0.3674329221,
0.1553241909,
-0.1382882148,
-0.504322052,
-0.1868073642,
0.1035356298,
0.4008619785,
-0.3491010666,
0.5651192069,
-0.2510694265,
-0.3788651824,
-0.3329711556,
0.0134739494,
0.6186160445,
0.5270722508,
0.2485149652,
-0.4680296481,
-0.3598643243,
-0.7820662856,
-0.2670479417,
-0.4211070538,
-0.0823460147,
0.3713950813,
0.3176110983,
0.0014571426,
0.9530638456,
-0.2484852523,
-0.395635426,
0.1281376481,
0.3278936148,
0.2342636734,
0.447455883,
0.8531415462,
-0.6434372067,
-0.7395691276,
-0.1685002595,
-0.5007761121,
-0.3929265141,
0.0036121286,
-0.0736612007,
0.5300604105,
0.8870325685,
-0.5873342752,
0.1865368932,
0.5248253345,
-0.1438631564,
0.6973136067,
0.0428587273,
0.1148365065,
-0.826476872,
0.5494946837,
-0.0392090641,
-0.1605369151,
-0.2518123686,
0.0847907141,
0.2749783397,
-0.1658077985,
-0.6469355822,
0.7231752276,
-0.2446004003,
0.2462822497,
-0.0980609134,
0.1093663126,
-0.1204832122,
0.0755881891,
0.069601208,
0.6424323916,
0.4941628873,
-0.4175171554,
0.3607782423,
0.25066939,
-0.3209482729,
1.057737112,
-0.6341183782,
-0.1866721809,
-0.0761745349,
0.6261832118,
-1.5632747412,
-0.4537667036,
0.2443742901,
-0.2125864327,
0.3948856294,
-0.09608569,
-0.5915650129,
-0.5697740912,
-0.5334316492,
0.5925611854,
0.5683422685,
-0.5633608699,
0.5625481009,
0.3669985533,
-0.385248214,
-0.3816503286,
-0.7417938709,
-0.0011233038,
-0.4243487418,
-0.4144204557,
0.15190956,
-0.4381055832,
-0.0820848048,
-0.1888936311,
-0.1220780611,
0.0340854749,
-0.0621425882,
0.5911940336,
0.1729700267,
-0.0591954291,
-0.0635478124,
-0.1593493968,
-0.3356823325,
0.7053648829,
0.0800228044,
0.6208783388,
0.0674569979,
-0.6466484666,
-0.2704021037,
0.3712243438,
1.0507833958,
-0.0491888858,
0.6525949836,
0.1419346333,
-0.281326592,
-0.2425533235,
-0.7060187459,
-0.0243173055,
-0.5204715133,
0.1188412756,
-0.2100406587,
-0.5746491551,
0.54846102,
-0.0420272052,
0.3702555895,
0.2878480852,
0.3361292779,
0.0733321384,
1.4081423283,
0.0452069044,
-0.4180546999,
0.3468376994,
0.4032224417,
-0.096621573,
-0.4747678638,
-0.117142193,
-0.8648298979,
-0.2855224907,
-0.445720315,
-0.0085848132,
0.4369428754,
-0.4001261592,
-0.6176584959,
0.1585793495,
-0.2364422977,
0.4376834035,
0.3652639091,
0.1083598211,
0.1391275972,
-0.2322606742,
-0.1825354993,
-0.0256421622,
-0.3914017379,
-0.1541017592,
1.0203188658,
0.390183121,
0.9397196174,
0.3111403584,
0.3692190945,
0.0429741591,
0.6031201482,
-0.5730884075,
0.7069269419,
-0.0971552283,
-1.0514966249,
-0.3033852875,
-0.5416129231,
-0.9129983783,
-0.0382657871,
-0.3236611187,
-0.8670672178,
0.0717446283,
0.0983103663,
-0.7011315823,
0.0820634961,
-0.6174161434,
0.6940257549,
-0.3028912842,
-0.3351475,
-0.0788671151,
-0.7276095152,
0.4447366893,
-0.4937678277,
0.5062815547,
-0.1167976633,
-0.0460839942,
0.3643368185,
-0.5126146674,
1.0409449339,
-0.0033720145,
-0.3237477243,
0.2818166614,
0.3891835511,
0.6980681419,
-0.0683675408,
-0.4892914295,
-0.3042046726,
0.0006477304,
-0.168916136,
-0.3303971291,
1.0101454258,
-0.4686291218,
-0.4277725518,
-0.4169671535,
-0.627022922,
-0.4673759341,
0.6654931307,
0.3369578421,
0.4579479694,
-0.2652298212,
0.1306754202,
0.627206862,
-0.5027172565,
0.387042284,
0.9296821952,
-0.3550564051,
-0.3043019474,
0.9631057382,
0.1775992811,
0.5158193707,
0.067475982,
0.2296651602,
-0.6774883866,
-0.8682125211,
-0.4702260196,
0.1295785308,
-0.5974903703,
-0.3255080581,
-0.5423051119,
-0.3859498501,
-0.3753634989,
-0.1814115793,
-0.4238872826,
-0.1076918989,
0.0747558102,
0.0180466697,
0.3579185009,
0.6983157992,
-0.0549540371,
-0.2337789237,
-0.9068921208,
0.0791108012,
0.2568805814,
0.8696833849,
-0.016457336,
-0.5874578953,
0.5427082181,
-0.1811232716,
-0.0334844999,
-0.5480558872,
0.1183423847,
-0.0863919854,
0.5642035007,
0.4115816057,
0.7334522605,
0.4014119506,
-0.7525253296,
0.5519188643,
0.328481704,
-0.7820144892,
0.4016962349,
-0.7871511579,
0.0648776144,
0.9557985067,
0.5854904056,
-0.4416149557,
-0.4945807755,
-0.4187558293,
-1.0832183361,
0.7293866873,
0.0660609379,
0.1838560402,
-0.1923179328,
0.1010352969,
0.3362164795,
0.2237535268,
-0.7181411982,
-0.2152127028,
0.3444668055,
0.0042881798,
-0.0565023758,
-0.4027836919,
-0.2261299491,
0.1056126505,
0.7736569643,
0.1644898653,
-0.4540122151,
-0.145841822,
0.0162231382,
-0.5933716297,
0.5254617929,
0.5356568694,
0.5503507257,
-0.5735974908,
0.2690451741,
0.3715755045,
-0.238634184,
0.1243951172,
0.3191111982,
-0.1390015036,
-0.2286073267,
0.1082499698,
0.2288732976,
0.1368590295,
-0.9804145694,
0.4501516819,
-0.0369785763,
-0.1608758867,
-0.1146644503,
0.1769309491,
-0.2479290217,
0.0071238074,
-0.0642547831,
-0.0438793972,
0.2086354643,
-0.6761600971,
0.2589692771,
0.5169302225,
-0.5220592022,
-0.0120891351,
0.6719647646,
0.2756783962,
-0.0953820497,
0.3564960957,
-0.0615752377,
-0.248143658,
0.3797305226,
0.4030511379,
0.5786083341,
-0.2270639241,
0.1059175134,
0.4618747532,
0.178678751,
-0.0839836672,
0.4140412211,
0.4247195125,
-0.4797062874,
-0.210200116,
-0.4818090796,
-0.291757971,
0.6656016111,
-0.8120049834,
0.2125240266,
-0.8020282388,
-0.3498574495,
0.1107203215,
-0.2931455374,
-0.2999452949,
0.0589382611,
0.2470271438,
1.1734824181,
-1.150221467,
0.5065825582,
0.6651989818,
-0.4055036902,
-0.7526909113,
-0.1778568923,
0.6186632514,
-0.8590207696,
0.0744174421,
0.1619266421,
0.1003125235,
-0.0847696289,
-0.3798022866,
-0.7789924145,
0.6088120341,
0.3963912129,
-0.7954496741,
0.3690487742,
0.3652623296,
0.4479345083,
0.0697381124,
0.2761887908,
0.821036458,
0.7123997808,
0.1729503721,
-0.9358898401,
0.7106218934,
-0.1668133736,
-0.1210244447,
0.3725947142,
-0.7266409397,
0.7157779336,
0.0559640191,
-0.2369780988,
0.5963205099,
0.140008688,
0.6692640185,
0.3521164656,
0.9067027569,
0.353497088,
0.4923515618,
0.0291966628,
1.1624574661,
0.0932031497,
0.0955257863,
1.2520709038,
-0.8534324169,
1.0386937857,
0.4467737079,
-0.2493308485,
0.22082147,
0.6271574497,
0.1182909384,
0.5397841334,
0.4456081688,
-0.0831313282,
-0.4561766684,
-0.6075604558,
-0.6391404867,
-0.0433150716,
0.5225666165,
-0.3331616819,
-0.6238766909,
-0.0070376992,
-0.1227605641,
0.2393738776,
-0.2151101828,
0.5432676673,
0.2358510047,
-0.8214357495,
0.8296756148,
-0.3130034804,
0.3834860027,
-0.5406963229,
0.148621738,
-0.0132437553,
0.1079267412,
-0.1444354802,
-1.2064960003,
0.0288074985,
0.0421001762,
-0.2379523516,
-0.4368020296,
0.5872710943,
-0.2742591202,
-0.1688813716,
0.5128944516,
0.2224964947,
-0.0114519708,
-0.0205367617,
-0.8103181124,
0.348279506,
-0.3395550251,
-0.3021162748,
0.6425874233,
0.6104958653,
-0.2879027426,
0.5805157423,
0.6726588607,
-0.0861163214,
-0.1903199106,
0.3064246774,
1.0471972227,
-0.4430304468,
-0.3114077449,
-0.8035122752,
0.5407393575,
0.0234065019,
-0.3671261072,
0.6746124029,
0.3734165132,
0.681869626,
0.3484753668,
0.8115385771,
-0.2382453382,
0.6748131514,
-0.5239309669,
0.9219744802,
-0.7135850787,
0.3061663806,
-0.3951903582,
-0.8511024714,
-0.336463213,
0.2377202809,
-0.5377819538,
0.1187456623,
0.6911538839,
0.8182535768,
0.0244129803,
0.1221050024,
0.1782507747,
0.5181225538,
0.3582160473,
0.6576772332,
1.1252268553,
-0.0104328003,
0.7194101214,
0.0004619701,
-0.3662588894,
-0.3555822074,
-1.1550419331,
-1.1857007742,
-0.2837373912,
-0.1702397764,
-0.7537127137,
0.2252382785,
1.0005024672,
0.5684276819,
-1.1094557047,
-0.0170265604,
-0.241925016,
-0.1786630154,
-0.0939514786,
-0.1218325868,
0.3268226385,
-0.1666440815,
-0.4514842033,
0.4968987405,
-0.0140137961,
0.017122075,
-0.118276,
0.1901008189,
-0.0729569942,
0.0992685407,
0.4031158686,
0.7005415559,
-0.5300901532,
-0.5404030085,
-0.1084506884,
-0.5280713439,
-0.2486999184,
0.4867112041,
-0.3931921422,
0.4619811177,
0.5943511128,
0.6374256015,
0.0164441206,
-0.0488261878,
0.8204163909,
-0.8569328189,
-0.0282135904,
0.1347547024,
0.3723959327,
0.0562328771,
-0.2098145038,
0.3444025218,
-0.0860064626,
-0.4056559801,
-1.0417081118,
0.2654806077,
-0.9509440064,
-0.3782601655,
1.4520343542,
-0.0528765172,
-0.2757005095,
-0.2831783891,
-0.3224599957,
-0.0774182901,
-0.7887979746,
0.950719893,
0.7549373507,
0.1627456099,
0.1648593247,
-0.5577901006,
0.4934325814,
0.7358538508,
-0.7506123781,
0.5362170339,
0.7056660056,
0.3953801394,
0.1351931095,
0.4390429556,
-0.1798544824,
0.5993973017,
-0.1842236519,
-0.1838178784,
-0.0551601723,
-0.309096396,
-0.2712440491,
0.144362241,
0.2504765689,
0.0502376482
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20917v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20917v1
|
Learning to Estimate System Specifications in Linear Temporal Logic using Transformers and Mamba
| 2024-05-31T15:21:53 | 2024-05-31T15:21:53 |
İlker Işık, Ebru Aydin Gol, Ramazan Gokberk Cinbis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.LO
|
Temporal logic is a framework for representing and reasoning about
propositions that evolve over time. It is commonly used for specifying
requirements in various domains, including hardware and software systems, as
well as robotics. Specification mining or formula generation involves
extracting temporal logic formulae from system traces and has numerous
applications, such as detecting bugs and improving interpretability. Although
there has been a surge of deep learning-based methods for temporal logic
satisfiability checking in recent years, the specification mining literature
has been lagging behind in adopting deep learning methods despite their many
advantages, such as scalability. In this paper, we introduce autoregressive
models that can generate linear temporal logic formulae from traces, towards
addressing the specification mining problem. We propose multiple architectures
for this task: transformer encoder-decoder, decoder-only transformer, and
Mamba, which is an emerging alternative to transformer models. Additionally, we
devise a metric for quantifying the distinctiveness of the generated formulae
and a straightforward algorithm to enforce the syntax constraints. Our
experiments show that the proposed architectures yield promising results,
generating correct and distinct formulae at a fraction of the compute cost
needed for the combinatorial baseline.
|
[
-0.2703903913,
-0.5318650007,
0.7932420373,
0.1609278321,
-0.1082124934,
0.0724093169,
0.2400625199,
-0.5335319638,
0.0890602842,
0.3040589988,
-0.9882138968,
-0.3257280886,
-0.5953047872,
-0.1131222546,
-0.5548437834,
0.5679648519,
-0.3520124257,
-0.5783423185,
-0.0741882771,
-0.1220294759,
-0.5563211441,
-0.5591086149,
0.0019018308,
-0.4337065816,
0.1885853261,
0.1034326404,
0.5377591848,
0.6647284031,
0.1918996274,
0.2464722246,
0.2043703794,
0.4240242839,
0.2926007509,
0.4210702479,
0.2040316463,
-0.2631254494,
-0.4947940409,
0.1105263606,
0.5771719217,
0.7266121507,
-0.3431352079,
0.6637536287,
-0.1458945572,
0.4251800478,
-1.0757510662,
0.8034659028,
-0.6630818844,
0.5541127324,
-0.1520851552,
-0.2331436723,
-0.566875577,
-0.4186377227,
-0.2838139832,
-0.5709377527,
-0.053327933,
-0.1237018406,
1.1520190239,
0.6410945654,
-0.4617657065,
-0.3579512835,
-0.9710323811,
0.8220065236,
-0.8043855429,
0.4850767851,
0.2210642099,
0.8769370317,
-0.0969431549,
-0.8429772854,
-0.3606158495,
-0.2042987794,
-0.4627630711,
-0.0022789799,
-0.2690442801,
-0.1642593592,
0.5449581146,
0.1831033677,
-0.5066162348,
0.0581814982,
-0.1267856359,
-0.3584352732,
0.3826392293,
0.6227542162,
-0.0717788562,
-0.3431227803,
-0.2644207776,
0.2804786563,
-0.5185102224,
0.1563972235,
0.2653883398,
-0.0071972767,
0.0937815756,
0.5220993161,
-0.3067103624,
0.6576666832,
0.0846886113,
-0.1378235817,
0.2127048969,
-0.3093198836,
-0.4619783759,
-0.1123539582,
0.7781169415,
-0.1065851301,
0.1007833183,
-0.2619369626,
-0.5419865847,
0.3674677908,
0.2773577273,
-0.885730207,
-0.3817961514,
-0.0725306943,
-0.5826337934,
-0.2331427932,
-0.033920642,
-0.7419188619,
0.0054006111,
-0.499050051,
0.4020552635,
-0.4915360212,
-0.0697467625,
0.1332670152,
0.063989915,
0.4308595955,
-0.0482447818,
-0.8454708457,
0.2667938173,
0.6672565937,
0.6593358517,
0.3530722558,
0.0654543042,
-0.8762429357,
0.194541797,
-0.4383810759,
0.7076791525,
-0.573361814,
-0.374175787,
-0.1937251538,
-0.1724951267,
-0.2287530899,
-0.4273284674,
0.5441865921,
-0.5854948163,
0.0626193956,
0.2396787256,
-0.5358338356,
0.0593694299,
-0.0813678652,
-0.552715838,
1.1142013073,
0.1498913765,
-0.1848907173,
0.5530647635,
-0.6314647198,
-0.9038007855,
0.0545164272,
-0.2963518202,
-0.7031565309,
0.1415268034,
0.4606573582,
0.5366260409,
-0.2383802831,
0.4454906583,
-0.2147600502,
-0.0938077271,
0.3279124796,
-0.3811253607,
0.7924302816,
0.682931304,
-0.6133804321,
-0.1239983886,
-1.0372267962,
0.1684473008,
-0.0303628668,
-0.1614639908,
0.2074207217,
0.6347248554,
-0.5889482498,
0.3392723799,
0.3436432779,
-0.5108131766,
0.0544035174,
-0.4461663663,
0.7064531446,
0.7415782213,
0.1273422986,
0.2623134255,
-0.1119705141,
0.4456674159,
0.1234823838,
0.7469437718,
-0.4675801098,
-0.2913095057,
-0.9537543654,
0.0264617596,
0.1732817441,
0.450055778,
-0.5380339026,
0.8726234436,
-0.2052369118,
-0.38043046,
-0.2464247495,
0.1057326421,
0.3527040482,
0.5829862952,
0.3748760819,
0.1021425053,
-0.8683220148,
-1.1091177464,
0.05423465,
-0.3563522995,
-0.286786586,
0.3183085918,
0.3534204364,
-0.1813560724,
1.0157792568,
-0.6591771245,
-0.1143917739,
0.0887496099,
0.2570616603,
0.2142359465,
0.3001779318,
0.6887058616,
-0.4466738701,
-0.0998533443,
-0.1270856708,
-0.8150151968,
-0.2461342514,
-0.1352986395,
0.1641150415,
0.4228794277,
0.7337471843,
-0.4289098084,
0.6210870147,
0.3640359044,
-0.1118985862,
0.4900627732,
-0.0733938515,
-0.046320796,
-0.8659119606,
0.1723813266,
-0.1155216768,
-0.2665626407,
-0.1683442295,
0.0324638635,
0.1218886152,
-0.0710339621,
-0.1388891637,
0.3643031716,
-0.247513473,
-0.1592732668,
-0.0540745929,
-0.0889922231,
0.033099141,
0.4841948748,
-0.1720808595,
0.4802837968,
0.2271766812,
-1.0463303328,
0.1843654662,
-0.0923535302,
-0.5533918738,
0.269282788,
-0.5725943446,
0.0636996999,
0.1413665265,
0.1892097592,
-0.6267505884,
0.051901482,
0.117494069,
-0.6318139434,
0.0659275129,
-0.5265060067,
-0.7454611659,
-0.5451892614,
0.4575617611,
0.157270506,
0.8958182931,
-0.5894837976,
1.2926037312,
0.5513224006,
0.3579294086,
-0.6510116458,
-0.5695972443,
-0.0506494828,
0.1261371523,
-0.4566130936,
0.1900006384,
-0.0060668206,
-0.2195453048,
-0.0195374656,
-0.3337547779,
0.0715637505,
0.4909763038,
0.5834529996,
0.4216112494,
-0.337647289,
0.1329742074,
0.0592965558,
-0.4166158736,
0.5139591098,
-0.5291911364,
0.6690537333,
-0.1508382857,
-0.4327311218,
-0.3722831011,
0.1399048418,
0.4529351592,
-0.4525924325,
0.3154278398,
0.7144725323,
-0.3934925497,
-0.6478710771,
-0.4912311435,
0.0416835137,
-0.5149085522,
-0.1104464084,
-0.6495752931,
-0.3301637769,
0.6417683363,
-0.0099637751,
0.3403944373,
0.9291461706,
0.43369174,
0.05940485,
1.1614066362,
0.431381911,
0.0817602873,
0.3465348482,
-0.2109287977,
0.1820674986,
-0.3803588748,
-0.5382729769,
-0.4931873381,
-0.4927639961,
-0.3795164824,
-0.0775559023,
0.273571372,
-0.3995601833,
-0.4663468599,
0.4870355427,
-0.3568802476,
0.2915513813,
0.4579658508,
0.0002448401,
0.1366117001,
-0.1797515005,
-0.4636218846,
0.1718715578,
-0.5411291718,
-0.2368110418,
0.7715898752,
0.1809934229,
0.5948578715,
0.0851880163,
0.546543777,
0.3701992929,
-0.0415251926,
-0.7297364473,
0.6941511035,
-0.3101054132,
-0.4422772229,
0.0864149854,
-0.6404652596,
-0.715264082,
-0.4333170056,
-0.1637045741,
-0.4648758173,
0.2909595966,
0.0997209102,
-0.4701663554,
0.4030177295,
-0.5404602289,
0.6571799517,
-0.2246516645,
0.1552819908,
-0.1858775616,
-0.6879699826,
0.2669858634,
0.0989065468,
0.0489503965,
-0.3805766702,
0.0208251402,
0.5732531548,
-0.7595514059,
0.9868816137,
-0.3739458621,
0.0910465345,
0.2724032998,
0.5004659891,
0.4314855635,
0.1794586182,
-0.0561643504,
0.0294924043,
0.1507965475,
-0.470872581,
-0.7207084894,
0.5113602877,
-0.8018744588,
-0.3447828889,
-0.3967574239,
-0.4937526584,
-0.2135540694,
0.040131934,
0.0381450281,
0.5279070139,
-0.1000981629,
0.0260844026,
0.6623764038,
-0.0476750061,
0.7787353396,
0.6750433445,
-0.1905483454,
-0.1394838244,
0.727724731,
0.0332021751,
0.1065675095,
0.5988212824,
0.1890468895,
-0.1248279661,
-0.3713223934,
-0.4348599017,
-0.1657015085,
-0.7562727928,
-0.3550486565,
-0.6110354662,
-0.740445435,
-0.3660393953,
-0.0171110313,
-0.4153986275,
-0.7984435558,
-0.1905667037,
-0.064715445,
0.4247794151,
0.7901959419,
-0.0628609732,
0.0083011659,
-0.8048971295,
0.3726962805,
0.4231823683,
0.4312835038,
-0.012787072,
-0.5091081858,
-0.2507993281,
-0.0481630191,
-0.2653641701,
-0.3965888619,
0.4169515371,
0.1028444692,
0.8891881704,
0.2110749185,
0.2128387988,
0.7669935822,
-0.6582160592,
0.6407291293,
-0.0690013468,
-1.1282062531,
0.8649117947,
0.1671712697,
0.073293604,
0.133168444,
0.1235257983,
-0.3743167222,
-0.1878124923,
-0.6481832266,
-0.7506606579,
0.4967585206,
0.1987284422,
-0.0949490815,
-0.0277510639,
0.5908141732,
0.1427361816,
0.0197303668,
-0.4869003594,
-0.4074367881,
-0.4684619009,
-0.3016991317,
-0.0067192367,
-0.1714640856,
0.0501973368,
-0.0785579756,
0.5013267398,
0.1065295935,
0.1637584269,
-0.108173959,
-0.4226004779,
0.0605301857,
0.2629882693,
0.3359747529,
0.5442795157,
-0.2871364355,
0.1112388596,
-0.0822600722,
-0.3424348831,
0.2160675973,
0.3906529844,
-0.5100175738,
0.2864083648,
0.033830829,
0.773355186,
0.1823776215,
-0.5336163044,
0.1389668882,
0.0674474835,
-0.2563085556,
-0.7508502603,
0.233771503,
-0.227424413,
0.2884302139,
0.4469632804,
0.2510029674,
0.1123181209,
-0.2837076485,
0.3848864138,
0.4100500345,
-0.3900681436,
-0.2598816454,
0.7788689137,
-0.0105536943,
-0.2155609578,
0.7204071283,
-0.4039624631,
-0.2542412281,
0.7887983322,
0.1942867488,
1.1642861366,
-0.1714016199,
0.1523691416,
0.4071828127,
0.5021243691,
0.3201451898,
-0.0401546024,
-0.2909579277,
-0.5092118979,
-0.5316735506,
-0.9481197596,
-0.2682005167,
-0.106170021,
-0.5901098847,
0.3680979609,
-0.6782993674,
-0.170009613,
0.3177916706,
0.1153822616,
-0.709063828,
-0.0155696711,
0.2566141188,
0.6854632497,
-0.8756880164,
0.9291238785,
0.1138578504,
-0.6135841608,
-0.8772733212,
-0.2413220108,
0.0210539289,
-0.8556150198,
1.0543056726,
-0.1084125042,
-0.3528577983,
-0.3356079161,
-0.2061419636,
-0.8526130915,
1.2484185696,
0.2579559982,
-0.4831775725,
-0.255291909,
0.0916371644,
0.280965358,
-0.4678119421,
0.1446556151,
0.7068196535,
0.4937436581,
0.0773906484,
-0.7945370674,
0.1142496914,
-0.2997412384,
-0.2007425576,
0.6151949763,
-0.3085771203,
1.0249233246,
-0.1457688808,
-0.5947042704,
0.3648977578,
0.690244019,
0.1144845262,
0.3141930401,
0.6251503229,
0.4729710519,
0.6201589704,
-0.2231417894,
1.0052256584,
-0.4275090396,
0.103773497,
1.2738262415,
-0.3776668906,
0.7413105369,
-0.0180179197,
-0.2937771678,
1.0069035292,
0.4916503429,
-0.4247120321,
0.1924453229,
-0.135518983,
-0.1331388056,
-0.6286312938,
0.2577951252,
-0.1962688565,
0.3952716589,
0.682241559,
-0.6166487336,
-0.2816573381,
-0.3238034844,
-0.2207248658,
0.062282376,
-0.2982686162,
0.7817769051,
-0.0724352151,
-0.6390241385,
0.4089051783,
-0.1132995412,
0.1583839059,
-0.6654714346,
-0.0791133493,
-0.2675117552,
0.4687223732,
-0.2452672124,
-0.6969690919,
0.4701252282,
-0.2534245551,
-0.3938486874,
-0.201944977,
0.397673279,
0.0906426087,
-0.9569619894,
0.2651967704,
0.4532758892,
-0.1985758394,
0.229210645,
-0.5836943388,
-0.2881209552,
-0.2277336568,
0.1020830348,
0.2377075255,
0.4177404344,
0.0339967348,
0.8786036968,
0.5142300725,
-0.0882238373,
0.3397563398,
0.1559238136,
0.8435744047,
-0.6335856915,
-0.3642714322,
-0.9170905948,
0.2776269913,
0.0951614752,
0.0681744069,
0.6837046146,
0.7736712098,
0.5334994197,
0.1008742899,
0.6189460158,
-0.0786535889,
0.5277107954,
-0.9014880061,
0.4671708345,
-0.4103394747,
0.6573168635,
0.2168716043,
-0.6965144277,
-0.2410864383,
0.30419451,
-0.2595525086,
-0.1142432541,
0.630281508,
0.7355892062,
-0.2189569473,
0.0670390725,
0.0553508289,
0.2689645886,
0.5571122169,
0.9864487052,
0.8036283851,
-0.5040301681,
1.0264943838,
-0.3798082471,
-0.0127877826,
-0.1459474415,
-1.0364625454,
-0.5558773875,
-0.6994661689,
-0.2308094501,
-0.5618724823,
-0.0106232855,
0.7087383866,
0.7235062718,
-0.859603703,
-0.2275272012,
-0.0103198681,
0.0847250447,
-0.4258970916,
-0.2225370258,
0.3525725305,
-0.8184344769,
-0.4505731165,
0.4469266534,
0.4406635165,
-0.100276053,
-0.3364202082,
-0.0268591102,
-0.0584768839,
0.0851739123,
0.7537267804,
0.4812032878,
-0.7186219096,
-0.3732694089,
0.4040420949,
0.1755999625,
0.1816542745,
1.0042459965,
-1.2371945381,
0.3383567631,
0.4236930907,
0.2801857889,
0.852457583,
-0.5162905455,
0.6736177206,
-0.8737962842,
0.0786587372,
0.2876226604,
0.8320408463,
-0.0704167113,
-0.0518784709,
0.523652792,
0.3255711496,
-0.6098956466,
-0.647474885,
0.5635566711,
-0.978921473,
-0.4226705432,
0.8510302305,
-0.0669451207,
-0.2821229398,
-0.216285333,
0.5344196558,
0.2112017274,
-0.1474159211,
0.8149873018,
0.2865834534,
-0.1439324766,
-0.0172389746,
-0.5402949452,
0.3243013918,
-0.1136929169,
-0.5333836675,
0.1583016217,
0.6446178555,
0.2026470006,
0.3757915497,
0.0241026431,
-0.3916612864,
0.4332265258,
0.1057824194,
0.0417211577,
-0.3101932108,
-0.1557409763,
0.0556115918,
0.2685098946,
-0.308647871,
-0.250097245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20906v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20906v1
|
Enhancing Vision Models for Text-Heavy Content Understanding and Interaction
| 2024-05-31T15:17:47 | 2024-05-31T15:17:47 |
Adithya TG, Adithya SK, Abhinav R Bharadwaj, Abhiram HA, Dr. Surabhi Narayan
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Interacting and understanding with text heavy visual content with multiple
images is a major challenge for traditional vision models. This paper is on
enhancing vision models' capability to comprehend or understand and learn from
images containing a huge amount of textual information from the likes of
textbooks and research papers which contain multiple images like graphs, etc
and tables in them with different types of axes and scales. The approach
involves dataset preprocessing, fine tuning which is by using instructional
oriented data and evaluation. We also built a visual chat application
integrating CLIP for image encoding and a model from the Massive Text Embedding
Benchmark which is developed to consider both textual and visual inputs. An
accuracy of 96.71% was obtained. The aim of the project is to increase and also
enhance the advance vision models' capabilities in understanding complex visual
textual data interconnected data, contributing to multimodal AI.
|
[
-0.3273770809,
-1.0575785637,
0.5672279596,
0.1552861184,
-0.3608054221,
-0.098490037,
-0.1932446659,
-0.6970805526,
-0.0901828706,
0.5844564438,
-0.1691035479,
-0.5389065742,
-0.8732549548,
-0.1205437705,
-0.4035897553,
0.7577162385,
-0.1028876007,
0.3821418583,
-0.6030939817,
-0.3771845698,
-0.8596532345,
-0.366484344,
-0.721457243,
-0.1464373916,
0.4343344271,
0.3803570867,
0.7920560241,
0.5418319106,
0.9326894283,
0.3910630941,
-0.0266170017,
0.508045733,
-0.5349968672,
0.1637074798,
-0.2375292927,
-0.4496832192,
-0.4097167552,
-0.1090425327,
0.7545941472,
0.3503266871,
0.1596895158,
-0.0271721799,
0.2645649612,
0.6175413728,
-0.6542198658,
0.3933949172,
-0.3923251033,
-0.0210975055,
0.0726230145,
-0.4751138091,
-0.6895125508,
0.1031677201,
0.3506373763,
-0.9540031552,
-0.1138031408,
0.1099977046,
0.8409900069,
0.1974792928,
-0.6156051755,
-0.4256167114,
-0.6803644896,
0.8142958283,
-0.336204499,
0.3522603214,
0.2897231281,
0.269336313,
0.2020349354,
-0.7767836452,
-0.5458615422,
0.0335976519,
-0.0084083835,
0.2373209894,
0.06125037,
0.1636579037,
0.2775872052,
0.1926311404,
-0.2334297746,
-0.0419063941,
-0.4161435664,
0.0643313602,
0.5884132981,
0.385029912,
0.705935657,
-0.1973651797,
-0.4506531656,
-0.5193668008,
-0.090661481,
-0.1090230346,
0.2371986061,
-0.0773924887,
-0.1778934896,
0.7095053792,
0.0213669948,
1.0402745008,
-0.3365444839,
-0.0889968276,
0.3938530087,
-0.7067492604,
-0.3063306212,
-0.2854984701,
0.409458518,
0.728036046,
0.5589035153,
0.277205646,
0.0621742271,
0.0864484459,
0.3591669202,
-0.9054089189,
-0.1226950288,
0.0542513393,
-0.712023735,
-0.2556835413,
0.0753060207,
-0.9374955893,
-0.6026543975,
-0.7275662422,
0.7210040689,
-0.8652516007,
-0.1662554592,
0.1737820208,
-0.4323093593,
0.2240949422,
0.8987594843,
-0.7522293329,
-0.0322594307,
0.2515957952,
0.7937222123,
-0.047382351,
-0.4570691884,
-0.236737147,
0.5230160952,
-0.2325136364,
0.918633759,
-0.8510841727,
-0.2677738667,
-0.0736514479,
0.0642898083,
-0.2522060275,
-0.2405766845,
0.5186828971,
-0.3225011528,
0.0958059356,
0.050654497,
-0.6275957823,
-0.5737444758,
0.5467469692,
-0.7715213299,
0.6974375248,
-0.2143019438,
-1.0335552692,
0.2941870987,
-0.5870980024,
-0.4038520753,
0.1242632121,
-0.2351160944,
-0.3292684853,
-0.031085588,
0.6234477162,
0.6004953384,
-0.1333640665,
0.2993616164,
-0.2989548445,
-0.4129814208,
0.2323087007,
-0.6231735349,
0.3378154337,
-0.0708389804,
0.1496949047,
0.3387663662,
-0.6785770655,
-0.026355762,
0.1052432954,
-0.1943324357,
-0.7171866894,
0.1446329951,
0.4344174266,
-0.1469667852,
0.2612578869,
-0.1708128154,
0.3339160085,
0.0698654205,
0.2703503966,
0.5818942189,
0.0973690376,
0.4539927244,
-0.2215242088,
0.2642402947,
0.3130737245,
0.3576129675,
-0.866573751,
-0.6208696961,
-0.7084546685,
-0.2919240594,
0.4198770821,
0.6872138977,
-1.3851312399,
-0.0887510329,
-0.355735898,
-0.4556593597,
-0.4100444615,
0.2144969553,
0.3760643899,
0.3885760307,
0.436970681,
-0.3442447782,
-0.4482851923,
-0.6547809839,
-0.1720625907,
0.1569112241,
0.0517567769,
0.5515623689,
0.5727177858,
-0.3955948055,
0.6257709861,
-0.5805914402,
-0.4333992898,
-0.2911672294,
0.3298970461,
-0.0881593674,
0.7594182491,
0.6707430482,
-1.3110054731,
-0.6671050787,
0.1554388404,
-1.147916317,
0.4366746247,
-0.2464621365,
-0.2084080279,
-0.059475597,
0.5599625707,
-0.282871753,
0.76852566,
0.5547509789,
-0.4771588147,
0.3018874824,
-0.442138344,
0.58113271,
-1.0443439484,
-0.1201054156,
0.2926302254,
-0.1461662501,
-0.6962271929,
0.1657445729,
0.1922033578,
-0.2614813745,
-0.3216301203,
0.4539526403,
-0.5544583797,
0.1107377931,
-0.1720324457,
0.2002594918,
0.3112825155,
0.3073070645,
0.1972119361,
0.6297113895,
0.7390952706,
-0.3961426318,
0.450578481,
0.4759747088,
-0.4990856051,
0.8038842678,
-0.7588465214,
-0.1577599943,
-0.4769255221,
0.1283544898,
-0.9761941433,
-0.3380333483,
0.0648426712,
-0.3828083873,
0.4171583951,
-0.1260097176,
-0.5371744633,
-0.0771263838,
-0.3230839372,
0.5563266277,
0.0823291913,
-0.5226134062,
0.9690881968,
0.3014934957,
-0.145369038,
-0.5979024172,
-0.6081852317,
0.2250088006,
0.0247035902,
-0.7798485756,
0.3144159019,
-0.0962769836,
-0.154154405,
0.1250275075,
0.4790673852,
-0.3211532831,
-0.33732602,
0.2954771221,
0.5485647917,
-0.1123771146,
0.4874595702,
0.065997377,
-0.0043565221,
-0.4459722936,
-0.0345485844,
0.377861768,
0.0133480774,
-0.290565908,
-0.6762764454,
0.4170613885,
0.6792596579,
-0.3315916359,
0.8842627406,
0.9486956,
-0.354563266,
0.1927640438,
-0.5437369347,
-0.0553083569,
-0.4170498848,
0.6716681719,
-0.4105689824,
-0.5379573703,
0.2747958302,
-0.0494165719,
-0.123394236,
0.2900885642,
0.2298261821,
-0.1886049509,
1.097618103,
0.9731998444,
0.2390702963,
0.8105364442,
-0.1766418964,
-0.0647969246,
-0.7337047458,
-0.5566604733,
-0.2439312041,
-0.2147406787,
-0.2508086264,
-0.6079096794,
0.2845236957,
-0.0214003809,
0.1600818783,
0.1415471584,
-0.5795357227,
0.4758792818,
0.4005365968,
0.7659923434,
0.457896024,
0.1328604966,
0.0862683281,
-0.3309014738,
-0.5799070597,
-0.3297165632,
1.0084024668,
0.4445904791,
1.053422451,
-0.197395727,
-0.0570915453,
0.3024840653,
0.1175929159,
-0.7687448263,
0.3536928892,
-0.3910697997,
-0.487931937,
-0.2376082689,
-0.4398847818,
-0.6150298119,
0.3049004078,
-0.8631112576,
-0.4307982028,
0.2520465553,
0.1770172119,
0.0375010036,
0.2627697587,
-1.124931097,
0.9429956675,
-0.1788225472,
-0.4710398018,
-0.4941863716,
-0.4157936275,
0.3191901147,
0.2008390427,
0.2563906312,
0.2294330746,
-0.0562729165,
0.8259117603,
0.0084441612,
0.9015372396,
0.015168705,
-0.0401446,
0.3768550456,
-0.3313985765,
0.1561989486,
0.0057647191,
-0.059060555,
0.0914296359,
0.0153985824,
-0.4293669462,
-0.6789249778,
0.431106925,
-0.7205177546,
-0.2320625931,
-0.0661651567,
-0.838563621,
-0.0963080004,
0.0183843896,
0.0820905939,
0.9664589167,
-0.0355292298,
0.5758304,
0.7806099653,
-0.4951042235,
0.3220721185,
0.0998285264,
-0.1608696431,
-0.5562351942,
0.8961783051,
0.1294132918,
0.2336936146,
0.4621596634,
-0.1396048814,
-0.0809302926,
-0.5757870674,
-0.5711915493,
-0.0745123178,
-0.9116016626,
-0.2950617075,
-0.7473660111,
-0.2394426316,
-0.2943163216,
-0.0732724294,
-0.0118408548,
-0.1304556876,
-0.4228449464,
0.2342598289,
0.5015787482,
0.7847282887,
0.3163226247,
0.7319208384,
-1.0233123302,
0.4111527503,
0.3894805014,
0.4022456408,
0.3060806394,
-0.5129790902,
-0.3921588361,
-0.0730439201,
-0.302868396,
-0.7697455287,
0.2809168994,
0.2388477474,
0.4213954508,
0.5934848785,
-0.3312036991,
0.793091774,
-0.4613248408,
0.5491061211,
0.3637708426,
-0.9435082674,
0.635458529,
-0.2339313477,
0.4846720994,
0.3803364635,
0.4753521979,
-0.2193444669,
-0.0801399052,
-0.3526874483,
-0.6338344216,
0.4800029099,
0.0885648653,
0.2251731306,
0.5880377889,
0.4508538842,
-0.0868109465,
0.0787554681,
-0.6668077707,
0.224241212,
-0.2271175236,
-0.5817353129,
-0.0055719698,
-0.4707955718,
0.1059483215,
-0.3495566547,
0.3703496456,
-0.2077859044,
-0.0525030419,
0.20235309,
-0.2844222486,
0.3479876518,
0.0383222401,
0.3999870718,
0.7812606096,
0.0682610273,
0.0851725563,
0.1878180504,
-0.9391766191,
-0.262817353,
-0.0880137756,
0.0003558939,
-0.118875578,
0.6922691464,
0.8453879952,
0.1767332554,
-0.7915641069,
0.6342283487,
-0.3553063273,
-0.1188917905,
0.0886426792,
0.075120151,
-0.1158131287,
0.2848779261,
0.4755250514,
0.1301503927,
0.1878868192,
-0.6033654213,
0.2364282012,
0.3663496971,
-0.5700737238,
-0.0078074168,
0.4106304944,
0.3595347703,
0.1580723822,
0.6783879995,
0.3499785662,
-0.5203372836,
0.7433530688,
0.4154493511,
-0.0025757551,
-0.1145285144,
0.2018875331,
0.4758728445,
0.4222959578,
-0.0154127013,
0.3536458015,
0.14446114,
-0.8200095892,
-0.6845735908,
-0.3284007609,
-0.5348081589,
-0.1804717332,
-0.4957281947,
0.5176977515,
-0.3123989701,
-0.207506761,
0.1884234995,
-0.1221422926,
-0.537070334,
0.5214828849,
-0.0194768142,
0.7804746628,
-0.8529443741,
0.7563313246,
0.7672844529,
-0.5329223275,
-0.4709065557,
-0.31378299,
-0.4135991037,
-0.756908834,
0.5666193962,
0.296643436,
0.1236523017,
-0.0836652443,
-0.9155297875,
-0.3175218999,
0.8977763653,
0.1507976204,
-0.5214420557,
-0.0833123028,
-0.1923416108,
0.3797699213,
-0.4257206917,
0.493367821,
0.0475849621,
0.5808663368,
0.3037791252,
-0.5224198699,
-0.1776807308,
-0.3193613291,
0.1416011006,
0.1167116389,
-0.4434986711,
0.8321534991,
-0.2461701632,
-0.0537353307,
0.0209370293,
0.5821081996,
-0.0993211716,
0.4169542491,
0.5555767417,
0.4770702124,
0.3710446358,
-0.1039534584,
0.853992641,
-0.1902698725,
0.1621078402,
1.1254074574,
0.0475227796,
0.8524321914,
0.3934556544,
0.3750068247,
0.3859995008,
0.4056077302,
-0.3929058313,
0.2916782498,
-0.3576933146,
-0.1371373087,
-0.3174116015,
-0.4200612307,
-0.4294458032,
0.6834660769,
0.7517620921,
-0.4565830231,
0.0964816064,
0.5147424936,
-0.4038348794,
0.265750289,
-0.4769631028,
0.8622214794,
-0.0707497224,
-0.2892000973,
0.105483681,
-0.1116854846,
0.64289397,
-0.5175182223,
-0.4082665741,
0.3741255105,
0.261200577,
-0.2684966624,
-1.1015412807,
0.2482029647,
-0.1991699934,
-0.2582195401,
-0.0960344225,
1.0763219595,
-0.5088102818,
-0.5905960202,
0.3604920805,
0.4384208322,
-0.0586612262,
-0.0646258146,
-0.5543099642,
0.3457307816,
-0.0216536857,
-0.0088901669,
0.1779328585,
0.5847638845,
0.075820528,
0.6029685736,
0.6014388204,
-0.1731864065,
-0.2070343494,
0.2129253894,
0.8175066113,
-0.5755913258,
-0.3500861824,
-0.8321424127,
0.4460053444,
-0.4401048422,
-0.2579111457,
0.6620249748,
0.3338069916,
0.6042235494,
-0.217242986,
0.5561131239,
0.0715709552,
0.0265817717,
-0.6415856481,
0.8282782435,
-0.686571002,
-0.3542801142,
-0.4982128143,
-0.7966350913,
-0.4059725702,
0.4561538696,
-0.2513906062,
-0.1914191693,
0.5547751188,
0.3915030062,
-0.2148307562,
0.2242572457,
0.472347647,
0.0343350694,
0.0556134507,
0.3906988502,
0.813018322,
-0.5651753545,
0.805334568,
0.0622706898,
-0.4720247686,
-0.1565125138,
-0.7468661666,
-1.1335940361,
-0.6124564409,
-0.216182664,
-0.0753949508,
0.0998870656,
0.1782064587,
0.8037020564,
-0.3804200888,
0.0663168579,
0.1466015279,
0.1485915184,
-0.0687809139,
-0.2272933722,
0.2966657877,
-0.2647415698,
-0.9208597541,
-0.092962794,
0.4568307698,
0.4067374766,
-0.2086692005,
0.1739856452,
-0.4108044505,
0.0959867388,
0.969088316,
-0.2014334351,
-0.1133003831,
-0.2695162892,
-0.2130215317,
-0.0901324749,
0.1741659045,
0.6846917868,
-0.5881967545,
0.6609232426,
0.6213923693,
0.8198153973,
0.5618253946,
0.0617112108,
0.5211832523,
-0.4422667921,
0.5304449201,
-0.1037512198,
0.4177434146,
0.5826547146,
-0.4458999336,
0.4615944326,
0.1261707842,
-0.3795168102,
-0.5492154956,
0.1212420464,
-1.0861344337,
-0.4094665945,
0.7874945402,
-0.2389413416,
-0.3398942053,
0.0783039629,
-0.6590169072,
0.2953208685,
-0.1536994874,
0.4712058008,
0.7167539597,
0.1751203239,
-0.4833929837,
-0.7005809546,
0.0481503531,
0.2819492519,
-1.0903044939,
-0.2364596426,
0.4661872983,
-0.1908635497,
0.2493555844,
0.2652447522,
-0.1860260963,
0.1530859023,
0.2572085261,
-0.0958092436,
0.104764834,
-0.6880826354,
-0.2082014084,
0.2286143005,
-0.3687412739,
-0.2839020193
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20902v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20902v1
|
Preemptive Answer "Attacks" on Chain-of-Thought Reasoning
| 2024-05-31T15:15:04 | 2024-05-31T15:15:04 |
Rongwu Xu, Zehan Qi, Wei Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR
|
Large language models (LLMs) showcase impressive reasoning capabilities when
coupled with Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting. However, the robustness of this
approach warrants further investigation. In this paper, we introduce a novel
scenario termed preemptive answers, where the LLM obtains an answer before
engaging in reasoning. This situation can arise inadvertently or induced by
malicious users by prompt injection attacks. Experiments reveal that preemptive
answers significantly impair the model's reasoning capability across various
CoT methods and a broad spectrum of datasets. To bolster the robustness of
reasoning, we propose two measures aimed at mitigating this issue to some
extent.
|
[
-0.5269786119,
-1.2482464314,
0.9360138178,
-0.1181402057,
-0.3668447137,
0.2583640516,
0.1288530976,
-0.5131847262,
0.1802767664,
1.1196588278,
-0.5664515495,
0.0128362915,
-0.6657492518,
-0.0537654683,
-0.5325543284,
0.8308293819,
-0.1052718014,
-0.3930157423,
-0.3127985597,
0.059423089,
-0.6103288531,
-0.9900646806,
-0.6249741912,
-0.0172860883,
0.748026967,
0.1245263889,
0.9325508475,
0.0842264071,
0.4820959568,
0.3760668039,
0.2301570177,
0.0284146369,
-0.4844515026,
0.3828089535,
-0.3743876219,
-0.6580079198,
-0.7405893803,
-0.0742164999,
0.4184632897,
0.6205983758,
-0.179086253,
0.1692695618,
0.0626053214,
0.5051278472,
-0.9817520976,
-0.665543735,
-0.9253348708,
-0.3192155957,
-0.2694137096,
-0.3966668844,
-0.8429431915,
-0.08507061,
0.2210062891,
-0.4097083509,
-0.3215225339,
0.1152344495,
0.4731908143,
0.3346036673,
-0.1726261377,
-0.3487555385,
-0.5893289447,
0.5304327607,
-0.5762650371,
-0.1863672435,
0.4572404921,
0.2269673645,
-0.5639461279,
-0.8500839472,
-0.6216806173,
-0.2405953407,
-0.1224223971,
-0.0310839396,
-0.324203074,
0.2302064449,
0.4580386281,
-0.0257774256,
-0.443262428,
0.1662645787,
0.0254298896,
-0.0967286825,
0.5246748924,
0.2169177234,
0.3228400052,
0.0745128244,
-0.5662999749,
0.147149682,
-0.9655783176,
0.039444562,
0.392183423,
0.1255745292,
0.2240937054,
0.5755611062,
0.0222131275,
0.9928879738,
0.0127440039,
0.257645607,
-0.3428226113,
-0.5287740827,
-0.4252506495,
0.0979604647,
0.7613362074,
-0.0774570182,
0.4738626182,
0.1543682069,
-0.4141309559,
-0.0414814949,
0.4621154368,
-0.6932515502,
-0.1356300116,
0.6189160943,
-0.070954591,
-0.4347550571,
0.1467600167,
-0.6905625463,
-0.3298812807,
0.1423914135,
0.5408847928,
0.0588038899,
-0.3278585672,
0.1561229229,
0.1380668879,
0.2232597023,
0.3037519753,
-0.2881216407,
0.395791322,
0.5541476607,
0.4588434994,
0.1076111719,
-0.0974946246,
-0.7288725972,
0.2764143944,
-0.4142418802,
0.9029060602,
-0.4969567358,
-0.528232336,
0.0098743709,
-0.1380698383,
0.2092730403,
-0.5047748685,
0.1727927178,
-1.0065128803,
0.0158151668,
-0.4624005556,
-0.3817867935,
0.2300213128,
0.2643308043,
-0.499768883,
0.5764831901,
-0.2729146779,
-1.0581973791,
0.09279906,
-0.4038243592,
-0.5339362621,
0.0915440097,
-0.1738067865,
0.0083126882,
-0.0105039412,
0.3685901165,
0.3198213577,
-0.2888394594,
0.2092503756,
-0.5118393898,
-0.1615913659,
0.7442880869,
-0.4236193299,
0.8718235493,
0.453956753,
-0.0580372438,
0.1553153992,
-0.3660592437,
0.2667689919,
0.2716839612,
0.307973057,
-0.4242243469,
0.1079884097,
-0.6531637311,
0.3613194525,
0.310474664,
-0.1653148085,
0.1908885539,
-0.3688752353,
0.1842254102,
1.2344136238,
0.3665938675,
0.3676577806,
-0.4198042452,
0.9809449315,
0.2005778551,
0.2638786137,
-0.2167160511,
-0.4391020834,
-0.375756979,
-0.2276740819,
0.0369266756,
0.6619126201,
-1.1321630478,
0.219348073,
0.0882071257,
-0.4355136752,
-0.2126578838,
0.1295050234,
0.6712793708,
0.4497123659,
0.3565939367,
-0.1873891205,
-0.4328174889,
-0.5503945947,
-0.5377287865,
-0.2338212579,
-0.156015873,
0.1223239899,
0.4179088771,
-0.1703803539,
0.8607934713,
-0.7359323502,
0.1975548565,
-0.3949222863,
0.0439912789,
0.3575330377,
0.4285605848,
0.4235301316,
-0.5749780536,
0.0283733718,
-0.4617601037,
-0.6748617291,
-0.3121238649,
-0.3761018217,
-0.3735887706,
-0.160652712,
0.7564753294,
-0.7064628601,
0.5517244935,
0.2452901155,
-0.3680515289,
0.8285291791,
-0.1757591069,
-0.0168194044,
-1.0257791281,
-0.1596205086,
-0.5317329168,
-0.1937598437,
-0.6308112144,
0.2902646065,
-0.3118007779,
0.0459511541,
-0.6681131721,
0.4883336425,
-0.3269209266,
0.0738963932,
-0.3646243215,
0.2667907178,
0.0440245233,
0.0095042177,
-0.0970691666,
0.9966050982,
0.4984980822,
-0.9549131989,
0.2585242093,
0.2217414379,
-0.267594099,
0.3429040015,
-0.765442431,
0.4104683995,
-0.0679294392,
0.5972623229,
-0.8637298346,
-0.3229999244,
0.1592152268,
-0.5004770756,
0.0877490938,
0.1013788432,
-0.5244786739,
-0.5316120386,
-0.3570538163,
0.6306244731,
0.2606253922,
-0.5209802985,
0.5466775298,
0.3513256311,
-0.1125782132,
-0.8685626388,
-0.501304388,
0.018045539,
-0.0855462477,
-0.4855286777,
0.0547791608,
-0.0719552264,
-0.606099844,
-0.0840385631,
-0.0197655205,
-0.0930133164,
0.4049882591,
-0.0758485943,
0.4606018066,
-0.1024454907,
0.024366051,
-0.0366016068,
0.0408022255,
0.4323765039,
-0.2608758807,
0.81262815,
0.084702082,
-0.6275600195,
-0.4258646369,
0.5612937212,
0.6241912842,
-0.3765394986,
0.8517107368,
-0.1718348116,
-0.2175721973,
-0.0374738127,
-0.5694856644,
-0.4080106914,
-0.622797668,
0.2990572155,
-0.6120622754,
-0.6327193379,
0.6641681194,
-0.1285084933,
0.0422052778,
0.1226275116,
0.4447621703,
-0.3811749816,
1.2178804874,
-0.0246238913,
0.1426108032,
0.3797757924,
-0.0500705726,
0.4107429087,
-0.7336404324,
0.0404822864,
-0.4996324778,
-0.0414543338,
-0.5149716139,
-0.3936229348,
0.0942689404,
0.1928824484,
-0.3500106037,
0.2157237232,
-0.2624069154,
0.6914953589,
0.2170609236,
0.2308894843,
-0.0358771086,
-0.5373536944,
-0.2858648896,
0.6685694456,
-0.6917131543,
-0.615473032,
1.1068930626,
-0.005660723,
0.9069946408,
0.2141544372,
0.6716246009,
0.1884390712,
0.1661671996,
-0.3207565546,
0.8498964906,
0.3150317967,
-0.6858298779,
-0.109318912,
-0.3582120836,
-1.1405040026,
0.1062969416,
-0.2046452016,
-0.8762094975,
-0.0598765053,
0.2160985768,
-0.6064857244,
0.3306117356,
-0.8355087042,
0.4997694492,
-0.5123007894,
-0.4912840724,
-0.1232976243,
-0.7324662209,
0.4563524425,
-0.3364749253,
0.3873057663,
0.2192514092,
0.0488089584,
0.691865027,
-0.638325572,
0.719609499,
-0.2060365677,
-0.1501117796,
0.7946707606,
0.2753688693,
0.7833961248,
0.1587493867,
0.1091942489,
-0.2253095806,
0.055276636,
-0.9284371734,
-0.7627241611,
0.5109723806,
-0.5632950664,
-1.4664463997,
-0.4847389758,
-0.3811934292,
-0.2837608457,
0.1706541628,
0.4571301639,
0.4665668607,
-0.047357019,
-0.1622584313,
0.7761650085,
-0.4218665957,
0.4598551989,
0.258821547,
-0.6339717507,
-0.3000450134,
0.3149128854,
0.1813674867,
0.9519699216,
0.0860709921,
0.1439775527,
-0.2631604373,
-0.562196672,
-0.1271672696,
0.0923520699,
-0.760014236,
-0.2575170994,
-0.6395179033,
-0.1822925061,
-0.3519100845,
-0.3630952835,
-0.1501811445,
-0.2359565943,
-0.1048211977,
-0.3843904734,
0.1350606084,
0.8195127845,
0.2731478512,
0.4068666697,
-0.780815661,
0.2710215747,
0.5374804735,
-0.0605409034,
0.2092660218,
-0.3567496836,
0.1521832496,
0.0337249376,
-0.3030724227,
-1.10815835,
0.0319399089,
-0.3222960532,
0.5805132389,
0.8029928803,
0.48440364,
0.6727506518,
-0.4258176982,
0.8166385889,
0.2330330461,
-0.8480865359,
1.0215935707,
-0.2530696094,
0.6520160437,
0.5055297613,
0.4742447436,
0.1587212384,
-0.8742138743,
-0.6988217831,
-0.7978202105,
0.2322693914,
0.0933846012,
0.2901294529,
-0.4907098413,
0.3491787612,
-0.0309935119,
0.1027401984,
-0.5690357089,
0.0290985107,
0.0479888804,
0.3205597103,
0.1465393901,
-0.4694591165,
-0.0839547515,
-0.1647305042,
0.5245630145,
0.1288354397,
0.092017822,
0.2828525305,
-0.325009197,
0.1531981081,
0.2647281289,
0.6699047089,
0.8840681911,
0.0533159077,
0.6226930022,
0.3767976761,
-0.5231312513,
0.2960796952,
-0.3910489976,
0.030171724,
-0.4766740799,
0.6093783379,
0.3630701303,
0.0092484951,
-0.7901828289,
0.5408843756,
-0.1488000453,
0.0855751187,
-0.3704384863,
0.1311134696,
-0.1173652411,
-0.0454674996,
0.3711567223,
0.2034041584,
-0.1308989227,
-0.5843797326,
0.2933171988,
0.5554755926,
-0.2176173925,
-0.3623069227,
0.4519248903,
0.070452027,
-0.3976971805,
0.5655930638,
-0.0146609275,
-0.822943449,
0.5637332201,
0.7954897881,
0.7150671482,
-0.5882959962,
-0.0474730097,
0.20055601,
0.4474393725,
0.1842417866,
0.3562461138,
-0.1123996004,
-0.897159934,
-0.5753237605,
-0.2993883491,
-0.3320084512,
0.0234594345,
-0.7421643734,
0.2797937989,
-0.7783312201,
-0.4294737875,
-0.1869868785,
-0.2789281011,
-0.5805955529,
0.1474558264,
-0.0170093086,
0.8264116645,
-0.6262308955,
1.0362719297,
0.3425904214,
-0.4744004309,
-0.7674338222,
0.2841291428,
-0.2676922679,
-0.7718102932,
0.4943222702,
0.2136872113,
-0.6088939309,
-0.0973443761,
-0.6614072323,
-0.7441682816,
0.6705605984,
0.3672961593,
-0.5348845124,
0.1546798497,
0.0443049707,
0.2299048156,
-0.215956524,
0.3019961417,
0.6929816604,
0.3604824543,
0.1107503399,
-0.6847068071,
0.2972950935,
0.0040830285,
-0.3927561045,
0.3356882036,
-0.1690473408,
0.6635226607,
-0.5656070113,
-0.1440566778,
-0.029163288,
0.5175246,
0.3258007765,
0.0666690767,
0.7045695782,
0.604449749,
1.1306904554,
0.1686786711,
1.4711931944,
0.0615502745,
-0.2561114728,
1.3868000507,
-0.4973355532,
1.032755971,
0.671464622,
-0.1997487694,
0.6312299371,
0.5244780183,
0.5820161104,
0.537741065,
0.4820679724,
-0.5344265699,
-0.5038440824,
0.0156668797,
-0.5277223587,
0.4974409342,
0.5038594604,
0.021678865,
0.2113838643,
0.0847145915,
0.2573418319,
0.1114597693,
-0.4299198985,
0.8825397491,
0.1353411078,
-0.8840122223,
0.6332435012,
-0.6156075001,
0.3020861447,
-0.5092753768,
0.2204138637,
0.0809027255,
0.13235192,
-0.077700071,
-0.9086052179,
0.3006437123,
0.088207528,
0.013665501,
-0.1395127773,
0.6256909966,
0.0508168787,
-0.4170599878,
0.5848605633,
0.5622037649,
-0.0356784351,
-0.0846867263,
-0.4781163633,
-0.1600845903,
-0.3058498204,
-0.3991787136,
0.4242453277,
0.4314363003,
-0.2519682646,
0.7913362384,
0.8964126706,
0.0710169673,
0.3151711524,
-0.0609686412,
1.2999993563,
-0.3085767031,
-0.5329086185,
-1.2454223633,
0.2588029206,
-0.2901472449,
0.0729177743,
0.6321979761,
0.1046670228,
0.741276741,
0.1731017232,
0.6346696615,
0.1504348814,
0.2194539905,
-0.6391971707,
0.7118119597,
-0.3054998219,
0.6717235446,
-0.5487089753,
-0.7567397356,
-0.3562124074,
0.1747367829,
-0.6497624516,
0.0063252845,
1.008130908,
0.6504374743,
0.3417983353,
0.0807979703,
0.2921390235,
0.5316308141,
0.4488314688,
0.5591747761,
1.3997330666,
0.1039240882,
0.4403060973,
0.1033345684,
-0.4394033849,
0.083692871,
-0.9579942822,
-1.0220936537,
-0.2589200735,
0.0018838227,
-0.5201869607,
0.0627710298,
0.7600922585,
0.3943635523,
-0.8770498633,
0.0446110778,
-0.2665452063,
0.4432226419,
0.0556717627,
-0.1411272138,
0.2578148246,
-0.499316901,
-0.0006889153,
0.3569323123,
0.0816575587,
-0.0343806222,
-0.232546851,
0.0859608948,
-0.5895855427,
0.7464020848,
0.4444179833,
0.0055917082,
-0.8007068634,
-0.4112254977,
-0.0069760419,
0.206949994,
-0.0816584006,
1.0164333582,
-0.9973677397,
0.5070278645,
0.4658179581,
0.7164692283,
0.0787908211,
0.136238113,
0.7621062398,
-0.6817234159,
0.4360969067,
0.4444709122,
0.3858914077,
-0.1190634891,
-0.6090918779,
-0.0032658936,
-0.1623892784,
-0.5508528352,
-0.9798949957,
0.7893487215,
-0.8291444182,
-0.6499706507,
0.8973746896,
-0.4738017917,
-0.2505132556,
-0.3474978507,
-0.2330621034,
-0.017188184,
0.0228591003,
0.5518320799,
0.8548659086,
0.0565520413,
-0.0291717593,
-0.4795489013,
0.2881071568,
0.4581415951,
-0.9740114212,
0.1384935826,
0.1179714203,
-0.0358831398,
0.064526625,
0.8753603101,
-0.1674282998,
0.3387625515,
-0.1370812953,
-0.4644879103,
0.1604316384,
-0.5749076009,
0.0367669724,
0.3665019572,
0.365685463,
-0.1199290976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20900v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20900v1
|
Large Language Models: A New Approach for Privacy Policy Analysis at Scale
| 2024-05-31T15:12:33 | 2024-05-31T15:12:33 |
David Rodriguez, Ian Yang, Jose M. Del Alamo, Norman Sadeh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
The number and dynamic nature of web and mobile applications presents
significant challenges for assessing their compliance with data protection
laws. In this context, symbolic and statistical Natural Language Processing
(NLP) techniques have been employed for the automated analysis of these
systems' privacy policies. However, these techniques typically require
labor-intensive and potentially error-prone manually annotated datasets for
training and validation. This research proposes the application of Large
Language Models (LLMs) as an alternative for effectively and efficiently
extracting privacy practices from privacy policies at scale. Particularly, we
leverage well-known LLMs such as ChatGPT and Llama 2, and offer guidance on the
optimal design of prompts, parameters, and models, incorporating advanced
strategies such as few-shot learning. We further illustrate its capability to
detect detailed and varied privacy practices accurately. Using several renowned
datasets in the domain as a benchmark, our evaluation validates its exceptional
performance, achieving an F1 score exceeding 93%. Besides, it does so with
reduced costs, faster processing times, and fewer technical knowledge
requirements. Consequently, we advocate for LLM-based solutions as a sound
alternative to traditional NLP techniques for the automated analysis of privacy
policies at scale.
|
[
-0.2800308764,
-0.7747613788,
0.4275696278,
0.4492201507,
-0.1179066151,
0.0551048703,
-0.4523208737,
-0.5086249113,
-0.0714514256,
0.6227703691,
-0.477743417,
-0.7351702452,
-0.430516243,
0.0241224617,
-0.2924251556,
0.7245594859,
0.1705723107,
-0.0626325309,
0.0878733322,
0.1375049651,
-0.047818508,
-0.4075466394,
-0.6054933071,
-0.2518287599,
0.4145945013,
0.2691414356,
0.7296569943,
0.7162319422,
0.7927179337,
0.2659568787,
-0.3267945051,
0.2424295694,
-0.3240709603,
-0.144530654,
-0.1438528001,
-0.2737963498,
-0.4689774811,
0.0364129879,
0.8467642069,
0.5180006027,
-0.2417814434,
0.2685195208,
0.0758209452,
0.5137742162,
-0.6190832257,
0.2663955688,
-0.6576164365,
0.1552010775,
0.0226940196,
-0.150898248,
-0.4400425255,
-0.5566769838,
0.0031948397,
-0.164798975,
-0.2910031974,
0.1121811792,
0.5876532793,
0.126508832,
-0.4772781134,
-0.2822025716,
-0.6567223668,
0.9086771011,
-0.8102093935,
0.4291110635,
0.5951924324,
0.2135513425,
-0.4734520018,
-0.5160688758,
-0.5933342576,
-0.5329664946,
-0.0277853832,
-0.5702634454,
-0.3401159048,
-0.0375801846,
0.4971508384,
0.1836741567,
-0.6822591424,
0.6510224342,
-0.1748978794,
-0.2573396862,
0.976935029,
0.2381317317,
0.1104675606,
-0.0356915109,
-0.0690274835,
0.040105626,
-0.694188416,
0.1308365464,
0.3355346322,
0.2687468529,
-0.3420727551,
0.5380759835,
-0.4991402328,
0.6730061173,
-0.1854180098,
-0.6468719244,
0.2171045542,
-0.0772908479,
-0.2040212154,
-0.2243016213,
1.0859947205,
0.3903131783,
0.4588558376,
-0.1985239834,
0.0010238042,
-0.225371927,
0.0111836558,
-0.9154199362,
0.086787127,
0.3330329359,
-0.6698610187,
-0.3788408637,
-0.1612097323,
-0.9846455455,
-0.8621857166,
-0.3043507338,
-0.0773996189,
-0.0759729818,
-0.1452487707,
0.1975672245,
0.3804227114,
0.5673702955,
0.1468782276,
-0.9644452333,
0.4217061698,
0.9872037172,
0.9053111076,
-0.2868868113,
-0.093783848,
-0.2658929825,
0.107119076,
-0.3330146074,
0.300878346,
-0.692266345,
-0.535523057,
0.192523405,
-0.0486309566,
0.161999166,
-0.5252702832,
0.3931210935,
-0.6731132865,
-0.1592168063,
0.0188962519,
-0.5141727328,
-0.133023724,
0.5925142169,
-0.7290229201,
0.5518993735,
-0.1441631913,
-0.4571551979,
0.4356733561,
-0.9253991842,
-0.3962719142,
-0.0637338609,
-0.0776275471,
-0.4607141316,
-0.0096101053,
0.2259239107,
0.6934155822,
-0.4277445078,
0.2316790223,
-0.5493531227,
-0.0291643329,
0.4843162298,
-0.4637469351,
0.8796021342,
0.5196074247,
-0.2596947253,
0.1112618372,
-0.9645932317,
0.2017735839,
0.002761242,
-0.3086042106,
-0.1622698903,
0.0564321391,
-0.0748564824,
0.0741624162,
0.5394284725,
-0.6053932905,
0.1661801785,
-0.1904926896,
0.5125247836,
0.6031121016,
0.1606910825,
0.5987230539,
-0.0234493408,
0.6534757018,
-0.5161111355,
0.4776588678,
-0.2442501634,
-0.4068456292,
-0.1285196245,
-0.4095258713,
0.332064122,
0.63145262,
-0.0803273842,
0.4632259607,
-0.4742622674,
-0.562443316,
-0.044233866,
0.2773276269,
0.2687875628,
-0.0006695321,
-0.0833313465,
-0.0959494561,
-0.3336755633,
-0.8565289974,
-0.5389667153,
-0.1469444036,
-0.0753126442,
0.4179400504,
0.5820185542,
-0.3672449887,
1.0075312853,
-0.5077340007,
-0.2533616126,
-0.0284343213,
-0.044266291,
0.1559724361,
0.4229193926,
0.2338674068,
-0.8589740396,
-0.4485693574,
0.1491714269,
-0.8206984997,
-0.0115777086,
0.0073250257,
0.1899458021,
0.1670400351,
0.4124631882,
-0.5764601231,
0.1911733001,
0.5345524549,
-0.1614865512,
0.2063139379,
-0.1570583582,
-0.1752173752,
-0.7679325938,
-0.0874468759,
0.3254780173,
-0.5235262513,
-0.6583123207,
0.338039726,
0.1274169087,
-0.3034023046,
-0.5188302994,
0.5314022303,
-0.3652255237,
-0.1016662493,
-0.3870698512,
-0.183089599,
-0.3258472681,
0.2782070935,
0.0028122929,
0.7152579427,
0.3700860143,
-0.4830707312,
0.4341897964,
0.1047664955,
-0.3176588118,
0.43284899,
-0.4021339417,
0.1767243594,
0.0672468767,
0.3595396578,
-0.7494612932,
-0.5394548774,
0.1428364962,
-0.1147065014,
0.1391276121,
-0.1593192816,
-0.8443918228,
-0.3610541523,
-0.5551491976,
0.028730331,
0.546466291,
-0.4372371137,
0.7310684323,
0.9806044102,
-0.2129112184,
-0.5184285641,
-0.6264041662,
0.348233223,
-0.6300533414,
-0.5456078053,
0.0588977262,
0.3249211907,
-0.5089555979,
-0.3229401708,
0.0805754587,
-0.4380835593,
0.2006922215,
0.4151929319,
-0.0146922078,
0.0822841674,
-0.2497739047,
-0.2826064229,
-0.0756430551,
0.2354948819,
-0.12656115,
0.6850280762,
-0.2495163232,
-0.0849282742,
-0.8750816584,
0.2066226602,
0.5466346145,
-0.2853703201,
0.6993473768,
0.4004405141,
-0.365812391,
-0.1750832051,
-0.5396097302,
-0.0735252276,
-0.5260815024,
0.110085167,
-0.1411881447,
-1.0285593271,
0.518206358,
-0.3837540448,
0.3369790316,
-0.0134691205,
0.7571094036,
0.0951490402,
0.8224746585,
0.8851677775,
-0.3974256217,
0.5869088769,
-0.1352439821,
0.2999950647,
-0.408549726,
-0.2568462193,
-0.4654820561,
-0.142361626,
-1.0102735758,
-0.2906495929,
0.3622132838,
-0.2808903158,
-0.1854608059,
0.2974543571,
-0.1771070063,
0.7089856863,
0.1802174747,
0.1161050126,
0.3732657731,
0.1821165681,
0.5613910556,
0.2104039341,
-0.2745831609,
-0.9652359486,
1.3872414827,
0.7545765638,
1.0424019098,
0.256967932,
0.7227470875,
0.3882113695,
0.3188380003,
-0.7464402318,
0.8417307734,
-0.2311160117,
-0.4787340164,
-0.6569963694,
-0.505435884,
-0.9862598181,
0.481860429,
-0.1784219295,
-1.181024909,
0.1317594498,
0.1135508642,
-0.481810987,
0.1557707489,
-0.6336260438,
0.6976310015,
-0.1682665348,
-0.7036094069,
-0.1983572841,
-0.4614546597,
0.62885952,
-0.4855715334,
0.4222696722,
-0.2144378573,
-0.198753804,
0.5625988245,
-0.3377116919,
1.023272872,
-0.2074700296,
-0.5156968832,
0.2541494966,
-0.0553122647,
0.8208253384,
-0.0039787018,
-0.1087053269,
0.2446176112,
0.1291908026,
0.0485410094,
-0.295044601,
0.7923721075,
-0.352820307,
-0.3311664462,
-0.3108762503,
-0.6186144352,
-0.4682576656,
0.209093973,
-0.2380463481,
-0.1229754686,
-0.2799319923,
0.4484033585,
0.7422894835,
-0.4104077816,
0.5305452943,
0.7174656987,
-0.4557020068,
-0.0239395592,
0.65749228,
0.148013413,
-0.0950785428,
0.2971047163,
0.481080085,
-0.6707903147,
-0.5314549804,
-0.108068645,
0.3031375706,
-0.4598024786,
-0.1064003408,
-0.6132366061,
0.0171397701,
-0.4082600474,
0.1845387965,
-0.1126671806,
-0.3837709129,
-0.0150483334,
0.0554547384,
0.5054568052,
0.2812061608,
-0.1571030468,
0.6119533777,
-0.5920026302,
0.5612329841,
0.1597050279,
0.358733505,
-0.0941900387,
-0.2539655864,
0.0737735182,
-0.0745918453,
-0.1609602422,
-0.6147897243,
0.3322511613,
0.225902319,
0.2325820327,
0.4430780411,
-0.1404581219,
0.4650441706,
-0.7377486229,
0.6785821915,
0.0638058707,
-0.6828145981,
0.2496175319,
-0.4370435178,
-0.1349800825,
0.5071060658,
0.3818904161,
-0.334726423,
-0.0729319751,
-0.5486367345,
-0.7110981941,
0.4606385529,
-0.0013133921,
0.5913542509,
0.3152269125,
0.3492580056,
-0.123204805,
0.4123413265,
-0.7401843071,
0.1061414257,
0.5365365744,
-0.1414121389,
0.1246472597,
-0.3034167588,
-0.143968612,
0.0281557236,
0.4362997711,
0.0277515538,
-0.0718197972,
-0.4789681137,
0.0484173708,
0.1433434933,
0.3934360743,
0.5102822185,
0.8753861189,
-0.022533739,
-0.0842210948,
0.1987559348,
-0.5466883183,
0.2099957466,
0.049481567,
-0.322571516,
-0.081944935,
0.0872055814,
0.263043493,
0.0074307513,
-0.8785108924,
0.6258969903,
0.1036202908,
-0.0497410074,
-0.6392387748,
0.2371599227,
-0.103426069,
0.3542540967,
0.0739212856,
-0.7322438955,
0.216914922,
-0.5449040532,
0.30159688,
0.719370544,
-0.0114181954,
0.0842971355,
0.5280222893,
0.1278282404,
-0.5010518432,
0.2435059547,
-0.1796014905,
-0.0568277538,
0.4705618322,
0.3784360886,
0.6606784463,
-0.3153306246,
0.2938586771,
0.0428648517,
0.3867082894,
-0.4101248682,
0.3644988537,
-0.0149798216,
-0.5992318988,
-0.5798892975,
-0.491112709,
-0.5302246213,
0.4449782073,
-0.6523624063,
0.0642603487,
-1.0186142921,
-0.3132483959,
0.1638278812,
-0.0579952784,
-0.5391206145,
-0.0234436933,
0.1602041721,
0.8391481638,
-0.7411544919,
0.7514010072,
0.3380983174,
-0.0667845383,
-0.7181964517,
0.0180253573,
0.3169211745,
-0.8522657156,
0.5093009472,
0.1113229692,
-0.0484778546,
-0.2146541327,
-0.7060524225,
-0.6156228781,
0.6658865213,
0.3817008734,
-1.0291101933,
0.1537795216,
0.5715994239,
0.6631121039,
-0.2496979386,
-0.211707294,
0.9440479875,
0.5355789065,
-0.2057359815,
-1.061549902,
0.0287716575,
0.2462716252,
0.0643224046,
0.1730732322,
-0.6056268215,
0.6191110015,
-0.0127111152,
0.0386461616,
0.0069086505,
0.5047726035,
0.3016341031,
0.4535470307,
0.472812742,
0.2662275434,
0.9262077808,
0.3244779706,
1.1022025347,
-0.30786708,
0.4460212588,
1.0171126127,
-0.7397008538,
0.9898557067,
0.4583973885,
-0.3842589259,
0.2092291862,
0.582075417,
-0.158452943,
0.3059930801,
0.5573004484,
-0.3319726586,
-0.0457818471,
-0.2327807546,
0.008422778,
0.5912957788,
0.293874383,
-0.500161171,
-0.367726326,
0.1394846737,
0.3504439592,
0.1381199062,
-0.5545683503,
0.8270349503,
0.2617556155,
-0.2462520301,
0.4984043539,
0.3440598249,
0.5737496614,
-0.6014615297,
0.0274095479,
0.1199685112,
0.2100781947,
-0.3276183009,
-0.7761036158,
0.1420434117,
0.6377258301,
0.074677676,
-0.34304142,
0.5096917152,
-0.1224965751,
-0.4682618976,
-0.0317772403,
0.1501464248,
0.4234845042,
-0.1728526503,
-0.82723248,
0.2469010502,
-0.0484016128,
-0.3994452357,
0.4448647797,
0.2640835941,
-0.3999325633,
0.7459266782,
0.83746171,
0.1153293476,
0.144515112,
0.0681819692,
0.7117959857,
-0.5040919781,
-0.7938101292,
-1.2164080143,
0.0974783897,
-0.363565892,
-0.0636654496,
0.8477147818,
0.6070762873,
0.5274651647,
0.2537281513,
0.7087685466,
0.1111168116,
0.5736098289,
-0.7293796539,
0.4465780258,
-0.1602957994,
0.5775898099,
-0.014010122,
-0.9585676193,
-0.5927116871,
0.855441153,
-0.6145149469,
-0.1293274611,
0.2802387476,
1.0962797403,
-0.0280650239,
0.1586289853,
0.2137144059,
0.015581714,
0.5465021133,
0.3013512492,
0.707755208,
0.0230589025,
0.3021146357,
-0.1319918931,
-0.2777683437,
-0.1810525507,
-1.1195172071,
-0.9449843168,
-0.0371801965,
-0.2381500155,
-0.2601565421,
-0.195667088,
0.941990912,
0.7475286722,
-0.5991575122,
-0.3911008239,
0.0487863123,
-0.0657770634,
0.049580045,
-0.164572224,
0.3045404255,
-0.1197367311,
-0.560297668,
0.3587614298,
0.1814327836,
-0.0860710293,
-0.509811759,
0.1020181328,
0.0779761225,
0.0236794837,
0.7300721407,
0.5372593999,
-0.6233559251,
-0.0577853955,
-0.3580541611,
-0.107264474,
-0.1085646152,
0.9279178381,
-0.2901397347,
0.1231837198,
0.3168634176,
0.8832387924,
0.4535940886,
0.0849166438,
0.2287906408,
-0.5140972733,
0.3246785104,
0.2070513815,
0.2272705734,
0.1736014783,
-0.3967120945,
0.6405677199,
-0.4666965306,
-0.4796368778,
-1.0892517567,
0.3504276574,
-0.8639283776,
-0.3223840594,
1.6314840317,
-0.2686417103,
-0.4248489439,
-0.1479900777,
-0.0625016838,
-0.3925968111,
-0.4584844112,
0.8513411283,
0.5353027582,
-0.0422507301,
-0.1988022178,
-0.7139870524,
0.4816293716,
-0.2077676058,
-0.9448603988,
0.4351627231,
0.5582064986,
0.3035311103,
0.1094710976,
0.6032090187,
-0.3484285772,
-0.104825981,
-0.4187850952,
-0.2169226259,
0.0779966041,
-0.3064824343,
-0.7014605999,
0.2931430042,
0.1155854985,
-0.2474438548
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20895v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20895v1
|
A comparison of correspondence analysis with PMI-based word embedding methods
| 2024-05-31T15:04:15 | 2024-05-31T15:04:15 |
Qianqian Qi, David J. Hessen, Peter G. M. van der Heijden
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Popular word embedding methods such as GloVe and Word2Vec are related to the
factorization of the pointwise mutual information (PMI) matrix. In this paper,
we link correspondence analysis (CA) to the factorization of the PMI matrix. CA
is a dimensionality reduction method that uses singular value decomposition
(SVD), and we show that CA is mathematically close to the weighted
factorization of the PMI matrix. In addition, we present variants of CA that
turn out to be successful in the factorization of the word-context matrix, i.e.
CA applied to a matrix where the entries undergo a square-root transformation
(ROOT-CA) and a root-root transformation (ROOTROOT-CA). An empirical comparison
among CA- and PMI-based methods shows that overall results of ROOT-CA and
ROOTROOT-CA are slightly better than those of the PMI-based methods.
|
[
-0.2165794373,
-0.4208764732,
0.6063154936,
0.1676047444,
-0.2620881498,
-0.058175642,
0.1696326286,
-0.1559354216,
0.5389513969,
-0.0373248793,
-0.6152971387,
-0.7274756432,
-0.5243703127,
-0.0320108049,
0.1893838346,
0.0953195766,
-0.2371694744,
0.6589195728,
-0.6168333292,
-0.4214262962,
-0.6072576642,
-0.7184078693,
-0.2762710154,
-0.2644135356,
0.371958673,
0.173215881,
0.5840333104,
0.6183488369,
1.01989007,
0.3124639392,
0.2603674829,
-0.0785053,
-0.3424604833,
-0.0962714255,
-0.2257308066,
-0.5852067471,
-0.3761407733,
0.6076863408,
0.5734500885,
0.8693041205,
0.0122786164,
0.1027129665,
-0.1930795759,
0.5880689621,
-1.2354511023,
0.4329873919,
-0.2756679356,
0.4125788808,
-0.1160019785,
-0.4676119089,
-0.2892822921,
-0.4054614305,
0.0113261444,
-0.6155325174,
0.1576712877,
0.2374779731,
0.6145021915,
0.2307434082,
-0.2632758319,
-0.4160940945,
-0.9320155978,
0.9933001995,
-0.6086192727,
0.5536819696,
0.5697707534,
0.2561386824,
-0.107102491,
-0.068643488,
-0.9902690053,
0.062863864,
-0.0366952419,
0.4833953679,
-0.1981931627,
0.0822796226,
0.3753161728,
0.4910003841,
-0.3369814456,
0.0101108886,
-0.1474066675,
-0.1442670971,
0.5036313534,
0.1807367802,
0.3397802413,
-0.2959172428,
-0.4449932277,
-0.5608916879,
-0.9683994055,
-0.0166206807,
0.3655993938,
0.0074327616,
0.0875847936,
0.9545244575,
0.1849202067,
0.5741218925,
0.1061689034,
-0.5116441846,
0.0765515193,
-0.5345949531,
-0.1984230429,
-0.1401480138,
0.6980779171,
0.8736529946,
-0.0003516825,
-0.2960893512,
0.0775638744,
0.5000607967,
-0.1054069772,
-0.6096538305,
-0.1557862908,
-0.0610339195,
-0.7377212644,
-0.0665002018,
0.6626639366,
-0.3587173522,
-0.2437158674,
-0.5034788847,
0.5644062161,
-0.2785748243,
-0.0476808287,
-0.0863422528,
-0.2694036365,
0.9526177645,
0.1702729762,
-0.5544632077,
0.3731649518,
1.0539882183,
1.037424922,
-0.2193901688,
0.1595170945,
-0.6447238326,
0.1455366611,
-0.5389465094,
0.7932006121,
-0.8969430327,
-0.6984291077,
0.2690702975,
-0.2082569897,
-0.4483797252,
-0.6050994992,
0.1633769423,
-0.2253401577,
0.282491684,
-0.8554824591,
-0.5612819791,
-0.1767758429,
0.1167597994,
-0.5197681189,
1.0484796762,
0.2063510269,
-1.1768095493,
0.5646208525,
-0.4321669936,
-0.2621684968,
-0.338062197,
-0.1474133879,
-0.2620412707,
0.1860847175,
0.0250754319,
0.7907570004,
-0.3395509422,
-0.278383404,
-0.6977211833,
-0.4453088641,
0.3464971781,
0.2624437809,
0.3430321217,
0.0961237997,
-0.1886938959,
-0.0296329912,
-0.8558532,
-0.293528825,
0.0292110257,
0.1681670099,
-0.953821063,
0.3936318457,
-0.2766866386,
0.3879830837,
0.2803827226,
-0.9746388793,
0.2204229534,
-0.2529303432,
0.3128998578,
0.6626922488,
0.0285735466,
0.5861055851,
-0.3018900454,
0.4658076763,
0.3637599647,
0.1058101729,
0.1920339018,
-0.3711197674,
-0.8914856315,
-0.0595314354,
0.2921557128,
0.7871206403,
-0.9430672526,
0.6010379791,
-0.4959615767,
-0.533172667,
-0.6389907598,
-0.3552776873,
0.4528362155,
0.1395822316,
0.2996196151,
-0.6073018312,
-0.2631475031,
-0.9725855589,
0.1209820807,
-0.3673531711,
-0.3518359959,
0.544346869,
0.2110113502,
-0.1140992269,
0.9932817817,
-0.8167569637,
-0.5059871674,
0.1220145002,
0.0497071743,
-0.0540415384,
0.5957947969,
0.6377205253,
-0.4443016946,
-0.5731617808,
-0.0611273162,
-0.5370076895,
-0.0763918832,
0.0176299326,
-0.0109376973,
-0.252555728,
0.5960026979,
-0.1464876235,
0.6727020144,
0.6098647118,
-0.4997627139,
0.1217902005,
-0.2878937125,
0.3682521582,
-1.5116889477,
0.3336876631,
0.2323678136,
-0.1316224039,
-0.5648534894,
0.0884356871,
0.0751263723,
-0.2203300744,
-0.1384947002,
-0.1367429197,
-0.7148052454,
-0.4367906451,
-0.0323296636,
0.2756474614,
-0.3801465929,
0.3751730621,
-0.2664279044,
0.9808021188,
0.3470683396,
-0.4039013088,
0.1377838403,
0.5324434042,
0.0047763595,
0.7876803279,
-0.7195498347,
0.3294346333,
-0.1800280511,
0.0428891741,
-1.1425398588,
0.5102623105,
0.5144690275,
-0.3283903003,
0.4509852529,
0.1567121744,
-0.5002136827,
-0.079896614,
-0.9319835901,
0.6044038534,
0.3425047994,
-0.5716033578,
0.5134680867,
0.4650755525,
-0.0386501104,
-0.3452045619,
-0.3643100858,
-0.1415277719,
-0.0782247633,
-0.5606918335,
0.6276507974,
-0.4287594557,
-0.4586312473,
0.1196222082,
-0.1090928614,
0.0057616695,
-0.1169709265,
0.6140700579,
0.2391849756,
-0.2581543922,
-0.2692073882,
0.0457856245,
-0.3639104962,
0.0530039854,
0.225083515,
0.3581181169,
0.3165951371,
-0.4664824307,
-0.5852674246,
0.68359828,
0.5527623296,
-0.3250213265,
0.8608444929,
0.5163641572,
-0.4104539752,
0.1914905757,
-0.7403587103,
0.0700118616,
-0.3859855533,
-0.2404682785,
-0.6189309359,
-0.8337445855,
0.4614607394,
-0.2759594619,
-0.0582682975,
0.5413585305,
0.2373834252,
0.1706763059,
0.8972622752,
1.0907585621,
-0.2917902172,
0.4791072011,
-0.2327758074,
0.3860161901,
-1.2527991533,
-0.3526060879,
-0.8167126775,
-0.3079555035,
-0.4879848957,
-0.9035307765,
0.1263851821,
0.1561972648,
0.2919646204,
0.7202146053,
-0.31571877,
0.3145018816,
0.475664407,
-0.1310183853,
0.0863157362,
-0.1570281982,
-0.3907824755,
-0.4883525074,
-0.6823470592,
-0.065098159,
0.9431691766,
0.384966284,
0.5184915662,
0.2957611382,
0.4860713482,
0.0805689618,
0.3514546752,
-1.0300811529,
0.5287535191,
-0.1531166583,
0.4345333576,
0.087533474,
-0.274887383,
-0.744315505,
0.4368876815,
-0.7853672504,
-0.6472902298,
0.7899563909,
-0.3765003979,
-0.0412797034,
0.2605771124,
-0.6424174905,
0.2983198464,
0.7468143702,
0.0292337164,
-0.5794357061,
-0.2207560539,
0.1468998343,
0.1219800636,
0.1010006443,
-0.020549098,
-0.1076441407,
1.1115137339,
-0.7880362868,
0.5961832404,
-0.2087652087,
-0.2509466708,
-0.0302552357,
0.1773716658,
0.4473074079,
-0.1509099752,
-0.0270651411,
0.2114294618,
0.2470455617,
-0.3209971786,
-0.8957030177,
0.8838688135,
-0.7355244756,
-0.6180628538,
-0.5377444625,
-0.2187933326,
-0.3096741438,
-0.2200678438,
-0.0178284012,
0.5306742191,
-0.2736634314,
0.2023318857,
0.3337422013,
-0.0673931241,
0.5531618595,
0.4951538444,
0.356289655,
-0.5742070079,
0.7256076932,
0.2710629106,
-0.1094814837,
0.8033191562,
0.1991532296,
-0.0195746627,
-0.4099786878,
0.1779248118,
0.7014231682,
-0.5082502365,
-0.2182300687,
-0.3733272254,
-0.0486313477,
-0.4548677504,
-0.3188567162,
-0.2420770377,
-0.2537499368,
-0.1297167391,
0.0533932485,
-0.244227618,
0.8028362989,
-0.1219291538,
0.101122871,
-0.5488413572,
0.0216733124,
0.3700067997,
0.1463187486,
-0.2158688307,
0.0329517797,
-0.0256004259,
-0.1571993977,
-0.1797025055,
-1.2583934069,
0.0489169843,
0.2174803019,
0.3864500523,
0.8078818917,
0.1624442041,
0.9992750287,
-0.6021764874,
0.7867096066,
0.5226249099,
-1.0810996294,
0.411503613,
-0.0043037445,
-0.1660483927,
0.2571271062,
0.5912063122,
-0.7051971555,
0.0394513272,
-0.6333800554,
-0.5107708573,
0.3054504097,
0.31453228,
-0.3945124447,
-0.1632227004,
0.5084689856,
-0.0332487226,
-0.0500911549,
-0.0225524828,
-0.3833207786,
0.0907055587,
-0.12620233,
-0.2716567218,
-0.5892670751,
-0.06518621,
-0.2539901733,
0.4791379571,
-0.2309816778,
0.7923518419,
0.48834306,
-0.1158729047,
-0.208454445,
-0.0430927724,
0.5183082223,
0.7529695034,
-0.0488562249,
0.1124862805,
0.2542947531,
-0.3685950935,
-0.0994501784,
-0.2326536924,
0.011719319,
-0.0524814203,
0.5821785927,
0.5898976326,
0.406724453,
-0.0143063767,
1.0759930611,
-0.0958321914,
-0.2919766009,
-0.210880205,
-0.0624519102,
-0.1281570792,
0.168662101,
0.0937563702,
-0.1783366203,
0.204760626,
-0.529027462,
-0.0833709389,
0.8559858203,
-0.5956567526,
-0.6370449662,
0.2481306195,
0.12918441,
-0.3504005969,
0.4214313924,
0.1121854708,
-0.3399936259,
0.1867358983,
0.5373797417,
0.7717407942,
-0.536816895,
0.3178199828,
0.7391725183,
0.1389285326,
0.2924877703,
0.1525348872,
-0.4213309288,
-0.6899358034,
-0.4399292171,
-0.4888158143,
-0.4482529163,
-0.2256446332,
-0.9685677886,
-0.0564696118,
-0.6302552819,
-0.0229644608,
0.015077712,
0.1765408665,
-0.8059046865,
-0.1471301317,
-0.3812367916,
0.7201348543,
-1.1699774265,
0.7252537608,
0.7285441756,
-0.1432980448,
-0.7483426332,
0.0936604813,
-0.1205392554,
-0.6984381676,
0.5841035843,
0.1562817544,
-0.0023390471,
-0.223963812,
-0.2678705752,
-0.8656471372,
1.6376981735,
-0.0373288691,
-0.4765524864,
0.3218559623,
0.2343005091,
0.2970293462,
-0.3143737018,
0.2216892391,
0.4758115709,
0.3944527805,
0.2181534171,
-0.8292025328,
0.3273471594,
-0.2409635186,
0.4910894632,
0.3316418529,
-0.5286655426,
0.6128312945,
0.1192745045,
-0.8021116853,
0.0058344747,
0.8024584055,
-0.2516834736,
0.2699529529,
0.6387488842,
0.6480814815,
0.4716193676,
-0.140225932,
0.7620207071,
-0.3713343143,
0.5032078028,
0.4637545943,
-0.2613813579,
1.2308335304,
0.6816396117,
-0.6604751348,
0.4852819145,
0.3598363996,
-0.1317940056,
0.238079533,
0.222736299,
-0.1177981645,
-0.1627724618,
-0.1217245609,
-0.3115727305,
0.2622466683,
0.1506540328,
0.1636647433,
-0.2423457503,
-0.0089453682,
-0.0190981049,
0.2818062901,
-0.148961693,
1.1567257643,
0.1438275725,
-0.3336577117,
0.1920547485,
0.4121567607,
0.7518593669,
-0.4214201272,
-0.2756327689,
-0.117548801,
0.0392267965,
-0.103730835,
-0.378598094,
0.3570920825,
-0.555973351,
-0.1913360208,
0.08738859,
0.7168703079,
-0.4484446049,
-0.195211634,
0.3349558413,
0.4684706628,
-0.0688197091,
0.029947605,
-0.556830883,
-0.0930654556,
-0.4090292752,
0.156860292,
0.4434518814,
0.0183416102,
0.0529282615,
0.6086895466,
0.8365352154,
0.1135892123,
-0.2119755,
-0.2890727818,
0.8053712845,
-0.6935746074,
-0.5571091771,
-0.6058778167,
-0.0183661841,
-0.1094620526,
-0.0969130024,
0.9702945948,
0.5204693079,
0.4868759811,
-0.278511256,
0.2816708982,
0.0628934875,
0.2142627537,
-0.6331432462,
0.4222262502,
-0.2898655832,
-0.0899272561,
-0.7347012758,
-1.5009286404,
-0.5124932528,
0.910872817,
-0.3096346259,
-0.277392149,
1.2105616331,
0.9391694069,
-0.0941845849,
-0.2886945307,
0.5065925717,
-0.0889589116,
0.3138813674,
0.3718554378,
0.3527989089,
-0.6134309769,
-0.0928071514,
-0.2324434668,
-0.5685466528,
-0.0062769367,
-0.7186133265,
-1.0256673098,
-1.1996709108,
-0.6113659739,
-0.2194681168,
-0.0599414892,
0.6817029715,
0.6311248541,
-0.7482237816,
0.1081862003,
0.1112483144,
-0.0826301053,
-0.2114714086,
-0.19750911,
0.8137596846,
0.109328039,
-0.697396338,
0.5037450194,
0.5715665221,
0.0431961454,
-0.4628741741,
0.0378180929,
-0.0483635627,
0.3649325669,
0.7674635053,
0.0591991954,
-0.452976495,
-0.7385050058,
-0.0902953967,
0.0077194949,
0.0936763734,
1.4099210501,
-0.5028668642,
0.3793207705,
0.8445308805,
0.5233129263,
0.184260577,
0.1640347689,
0.62663728,
-0.5664728284,
0.1499841362,
-0.3370619118,
0.4416101873,
0.2917452455,
-0.272511512,
0.464739114,
0.5780450702,
-0.2645176351,
-0.1835642606,
0.3535829484,
-1.5619809628,
-0.1794673651,
1.333640933,
-0.3006569743,
-0.4285731614,
0.0222580191,
-0.2962825,
0.1576343477,
0.0492628552,
0.4792534411,
0.7563273311,
0.330071032,
0.0714493394,
0.085724555,
0.3273971677,
0.2414872795,
-0.4639923573,
-0.2610249519,
0.3107916117,
0.4304582179,
0.4886388481,
0.610389173,
-0.33031708,
-0.0366348065,
0.107433334,
-0.0097260512,
-0.1208035126,
-0.0683216453,
-0.2223407179,
0.1579541117,
-0.0385957025,
-0.5132500529
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20859v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20859v1
|
clembench-2024: A Challenging, Dynamic, Complementary, Multilingual Benchmark and Underlying Flexible Framework for LLMs as Multi-Action Agents
| 2024-05-31T14:43:31 | 2024-05-31T14:43:31 |
Anne Beyer, Kranti Chalamalasetti, Sherzod Hakimov, Brielen Madureira, Philipp Sadler, David Schlangen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
It has been established in recent work that Large Language Models (LLMs) can
be prompted to "self-play" conversational games that probe certain capabilities
(general instruction following, strategic goal orientation, language
understanding abilities), where the resulting interactive game play can be
automatically scored. In this paper, we take one of the proposed frameworks for
setting up such game-play environments, and further test its usefulness as an
evaluation instrument, along a number of dimensions: We show that it can easily
keep up with new developments while avoiding data contamination, we show that
the tests implemented within it are not yet saturated (human performance is
substantially higher than that of even the best models), and we show that it
lends itself to investigating additional questions, such as the impact of the
prompting language on performance. We believe that the approach forms a good
basis for making decisions on model choice for building applied interactive
systems, and perhaps ultimately setting up a closed-loop development
environment of system and simulated evaluator.
|
[
-0.6674234271,
-0.8171890974,
0.5312139392,
0.3909209371,
-0.1185192168,
0.0254133418,
-0.3145256639,
-0.3443640471,
-0.1102588624,
0.4501383007,
-0.7249700427,
-0.5041655302,
-0.1996669471,
0.1704902202,
-0.2369062752,
0.4329696894,
-0.2648319006,
0.0762599558,
-0.3441917896,
-0.5694378614,
-0.7861017585,
-0.5442488194,
-0.4339367747,
-0.5122466683,
0.3024979234,
0.4690683782,
0.6045775414,
0.5434601307,
0.4481907785,
0.5139145851,
0.3027020395,
-0.1494928449,
-0.3716135919,
0.5731140971,
-0.4704802632,
-0.3763665855,
-0.4651700556,
-0.0585380904,
0.5989323258,
0.437374562,
-0.2888832092,
0.4264293015,
0.1852588356,
0.2064188868,
-0.4247369468,
0.2801413536,
-0.2931184173,
-0.0218198951,
0.1193896011,
0.0952207446,
-0.2904450595,
-0.0496372133,
-0.042392835,
-0.4760798812,
-0.3151062727,
0.0232969522,
0.6030725241,
0.1081042215,
-0.4905741513,
-0.5009849072,
-0.5745178461,
0.7955224514,
-0.728173852,
0.3310413659,
-0.2826572359,
0.4835178554,
-0.229062885,
-0.5789435506,
-0.470552206,
-0.3710940182,
0.1784937531,
0.2342353761,
-0.1135788709,
0.1379686743,
0.343662709,
-0.031569194,
-0.5600408316,
0.2086875737,
-0.2279537618,
-0.1564106047,
0.6110238433,
0.4974901378,
0.0744524896,
0.2018352151,
-0.6855928898,
-0.0518811606,
-0.5805695653,
0.2744241059,
0.4089393318,
0.2127012759,
-0.1699658036,
0.4097336531,
-0.106850341,
0.5994458199,
-0.0370361246,
-0.027939748,
0.2105145901,
-0.2769189477,
0.0449974686,
-0.1841397583,
0.7897752523,
0.5854209065,
0.1644512564,
0.0985142142,
-0.3465013802,
0.267744571,
0.2326262891,
-0.8422088623,
-0.0775171369,
0.4759681225,
-0.2580597103,
-0.1383531094,
-0.1070758924,
-1.0587115288,
-0.3827188909,
-0.4160064161,
0.4244191945,
-0.3054744601,
-0.2071281075,
0.1100706384,
0.0387131795,
0.336581856,
0.1727883667,
-0.5108317137,
0.4972559214,
0.4632768035,
0.6571173072,
-0.6414153576,
-0.4641068876,
-0.4843991697,
-0.0245654676,
-0.2867895365,
0.8373762965,
-0.584779799,
-0.707023561,
0.133786127,
-0.0669439137,
0.1056242809,
-0.6206339002,
0.431296289,
-0.4488864541,
0.100176774,
-0.2329282016,
-0.578787446,
-0.1516304612,
0.7002076507,
-0.7558892369,
0.9983027577,
0.0067627863,
-0.1992323995,
0.3195201457,
-1.027107358,
-0.2565534413,
0.2581664324,
-0.2475026995,
-0.2213115543,
-0.085089229,
-0.1110681966,
0.1096392795,
-0.2863838375,
0.3811895847,
-0.6473248005,
-0.5155619383,
0.2428626567,
-0.5071107745,
0.4569859803,
0.1429702342,
-0.6872276664,
0.312826395,
-0.7463049889,
0.4921451807,
0.2033893168,
-0.4710814655,
0.1469914615,
0.094399415,
-0.341550529,
0.4559498429,
0.4679053426,
-0.3723169863,
0.1160530299,
-0.0901077837,
0.1796844602,
0.6892588735,
-0.0255604535,
0.3575469851,
-0.234479025,
0.9581028819,
-0.2677530348,
0.1640055329,
-0.482493639,
-0.2041074038,
-0.6764960885,
-0.3708101511,
0.4047256708,
0.6367167234,
-0.5005579591,
0.4124956429,
0.0245590359,
-0.5025420785,
-0.2748163044,
0.2423598766,
0.4472217262,
0.2021057606,
0.1014173925,
-0.3104701638,
-0.5811104178,
-0.8238031864,
-0.151689142,
-0.0986803621,
0.2748067677,
0.5279622078,
0.5283081532,
-0.1869900972,
0.8582325578,
0.0308904611,
0.2019594014,
-0.4015607536,
0.1047765613,
0.1603250057,
0.3009890616,
0.6074917316,
-0.5329558253,
-0.264642179,
-0.281909585,
-0.9676337242,
-0.4141905904,
0.0966835171,
0.0390609652,
-0.1008851677,
0.4058151841,
-0.5223664045,
0.2558808029,
0.9475234151,
-0.1994463652,
0.7697579265,
-0.3447016478,
0.2062214613,
-0.6026358008,
0.2899476588,
-0.4946327209,
-0.2082367986,
-0.5138314366,
0.4622551501,
-0.0516176857,
-0.2869879901,
-0.6058116555,
0.8926650882,
-0.502376616,
-0.2351680547,
-0.3319573998,
0.5637721419,
0.0661126971,
0.3028033376,
-0.090277262,
0.866204083,
0.4763757288,
-0.9199396968,
0.6139658093,
0.0603675433,
-0.4260077477,
0.7362275124,
-0.7029221654,
0.1441698819,
0.2444802076,
0.1512593031,
-0.7933405638,
-0.0365612395,
-0.1027622968,
-0.1378026456,
-0.0576643758,
0.3756898046,
-0.5295168161,
-0.5536676645,
-0.1994389743,
0.2935004532,
0.2679041922,
-0.4935972393,
0.8818293214,
0.3828944564,
0.0069434652,
-0.4390126169,
-0.4850773215,
0.1141231507,
-0.5244782567,
-0.6407464147,
0.1068379804,
-0.5877411366,
-0.4099166691,
-0.3236254752,
0.0090386933,
0.3316715062,
0.4893127084,
0.3733088076,
0.0079709711,
-0.3691032827,
0.1682222188,
-0.2156352401,
-0.1217690632,
0.2239399254,
0.0882001519,
0.6986381412,
-0.5170527101,
-0.6846572161,
-0.0885973126,
0.3365133703,
0.3930664957,
-0.4384417832,
0.1558300108,
0.1977759153,
-0.0582352355,
-0.4281328619,
-0.4931144714,
-0.1902052611,
-0.559169054,
0.398119241,
-0.551122129,
-0.943472147,
0.9059568644,
-0.698485136,
0.1972544491,
0.1236599684,
0.8995214105,
0.0834209546,
1.0306675434,
0.3041046262,
0.2786462605,
0.3052343726,
0.0636805743,
0.0550908297,
-0.5569681525,
-0.0176600944,
-0.2989087105,
-0.3898336887,
-0.4481390417,
-0.3700398803,
0.3659687042,
-0.0192967523,
-0.3251563311,
0.4007306397,
-0.0892036706,
0.5046354532,
0.3580474257,
-0.3127554953,
0.1194946617,
-0.5903990269,
-0.7793533802,
0.1572254598,
-0.5830330253,
-0.8902487159,
0.7843750119,
0.3910593987,
0.4701779187,
0.3917301297,
0.851785779,
0.2037262022,
0.5554497838,
-0.4933630228,
0.8347135782,
0.501144588,
-1.0542194843,
-0.4215007126,
-0.035896603,
-1.0214323997,
0.5912916064,
-0.2002880275,
-1.0057550669,
-0.0111235464,
0.1357512325,
-0.4604535103,
0.0284779686,
-0.835916698,
1.208122611,
-0.6983212233,
-0.7467101812,
-0.1407911628,
-0.4383178353,
0.3416237533,
0.0267604552,
0.5199258327,
-0.2376930118,
-0.2618374228,
0.2726989985,
0.1253131479,
0.728882432,
-0.315903157,
-0.1977230608,
0.5708594918,
0.6725724936,
0.4610058963,
0.1027165726,
-0.4416134059,
-0.0999004468,
0.2570097446,
-0.1380514503,
-0.6843976378,
0.758007884,
-0.4146216214,
-0.8217192888,
-0.4100073874,
-0.6538639665,
-0.4608859718,
0.4795562625,
-0.396361798,
0.2927056849,
-0.9066529274,
0.3219249547,
0.3346232474,
-0.2371967882,
0.5061575174,
0.9872475863,
-0.5143440962,
-0.2757080495,
0.7499162555,
-0.1938365102,
0.2811295092,
-0.0665017739,
0.1128970236,
-0.1858376116,
-0.4302823842,
-0.4135310352,
-0.0045908629,
-0.7071281075,
-0.1072662622,
-0.2324189991,
0.1396469474,
0.0715225562,
-0.1786340326,
-0.326479733,
0.1568832397,
-0.0062648472,
-0.2486293614,
-0.2982753813,
0.8320376873,
-0.1645085216,
0.338121444,
-0.7670193315,
-0.1611409634,
0.098172538,
0.4388779998,
-0.1377095133,
-0.1798217148,
-0.0628214553,
-0.121588774,
-0.537080586,
-0.7728754878,
0.2062303722,
0.0370937288,
0.9138465524,
0.3731062412,
0.0207634736,
0.5356817842,
-0.6317704916,
0.9684836268,
-0.0968912914,
-0.9994378686,
0.1675471663,
-0.4957607388,
0.5071372986,
0.7371961474,
0.0460763276,
-0.2312883884,
-0.2550632358,
-0.7998618484,
-0.6022053957,
0.6480029225,
-0.0229843166,
0.2573161423,
-0.0073836478,
0.0792843178,
0.1155441031,
0.5371952057,
-0.5808038712,
-0.0041753496,
0.0959085599,
-0.11747697,
-0.1214884222,
-0.2210003138,
-0.2190732211,
0.2108911127,
0.4107795954,
-0.3151023686,
0.1084121913,
-0.2410650849,
-0.0901199579,
0.0528137982,
0.3921294808,
0.7031172514,
0.7956663966,
-0.0821571276,
0.0812492371,
0.4806219935,
0.0938561857,
0.2465671152,
0.1266228408,
0.0849261135,
-0.3290314376,
0.4414442778,
0.6448656321,
0.6085615158,
-1.2515605688,
0.5727072358,
0.0537510179,
-0.2768631876,
-0.2490705401,
0.2501799166,
0.2680361867,
0.5411271453,
-0.1636860073,
-0.3772307634,
0.1749898344,
-0.7529453635,
0.5569782853,
0.4596993625,
-0.510953486,
-0.2295544297,
0.3956396878,
0.3743111491,
-0.3918113112,
0.136058256,
-0.4856984019,
-0.6082987189,
0.5661318302,
0.5326993465,
0.442206651,
-0.5130320191,
0.1372086108,
0.3444530368,
0.2017200738,
-0.0217977762,
0.5197962523,
-0.0060611838,
-0.6605455279,
-0.2503185868,
-0.325692147,
-0.5649030805,
0.0395853259,
-0.4484519958,
0.4744967222,
-0.3250741661,
-0.4537322521,
-0.3104591966,
-0.00984642,
-0.7652629018,
0.0808174834,
0.2618500888,
0.8365843296,
-0.3736371696,
0.5067597628,
0.5217862129,
-0.1570908874,
-0.499617517,
-0.2482956052,
0.2868405879,
-0.7507555485,
0.4056913853,
0.1409704834,
-0.27038908,
-0.2167283297,
-0.4744746983,
-0.9725114107,
1.1984812021,
0.4736114144,
-0.5808148384,
0.0645743683,
0.052221667,
0.7629760504,
-0.7078520656,
0.5840513706,
0.6394034624,
0.752002418,
-0.0019599178,
-0.8896286488,
-0.0400465317,
-0.1645359397,
-0.2523498237,
0.004117426,
-0.9390748143,
0.7520247102,
-0.1307158172,
-0.2545662224,
0.3832704127,
0.6456587911,
0.5837242007,
0.2417518646,
0.6442583203,
0.1400793642,
0.5796636939,
-0.1975023896,
0.9995379448,
-0.6889991164,
0.3543540835,
1.2518706322,
-0.8691720366,
0.7425852418,
0.1943002045,
-0.0283405446,
0.7000524998,
0.4380396307,
-0.1247495264,
0.2568032146,
0.6656506062,
-0.0094287153,
-0.4165458679,
-0.0584382266,
0.0334537067,
0.6582480073,
0.5216304064,
-0.0306020342,
-0.4927175343,
0.0483137295,
0.0279074162,
0.2479059547,
0.032501176,
0.6534457207,
0.0156983398,
-0.9709282517,
0.1821270287,
-0.0478565171,
0.3043674827,
-0.8071885109,
-0.1376009732,
-0.0332375988,
0.4730162024,
0.2939257622,
-0.8234136105,
-0.0818678886,
-0.1657353789,
0.2797372341,
-0.100233689,
0.4017242193,
-0.4296086133,
-0.2641644478,
0.763165772,
0.7264569998,
0.0998678878,
0.2442752719,
-1.1869703531,
0.518853426,
-0.2144266814,
-0.4095925689,
0.3153112829,
0.6463350654,
-0.0733587444,
0.6953787208,
0.284011364,
-0.2494988889,
-0.0995519981,
0.0470282473,
0.7000903487,
-0.4943806827,
-0.5011265874,
-0.6892402172,
0.6003081799,
-0.2026094198,
-0.3725762367,
0.8947426081,
0.6548857689,
0.482933104,
0.2090728581,
0.8109771013,
-0.0020280713,
0.4001978934,
-0.3095293343,
0.1907598823,
-0.4041564465,
0.1695633531,
-0.2287667096,
-0.9053124189,
-0.0789788291,
0.2835932672,
-0.1878981143,
0.436714381,
0.7655669451,
0.722345531,
-0.0015449898,
0.0139360288,
0.5878126621,
0.0556903295,
0.5742765665,
0.4688578546,
0.8593472242,
-0.1652261466,
0.4682980478,
0.0136547666,
-0.2719259858,
-0.1873180568,
-1.079939127,
-1.0979009867,
-0.4382759929,
-0.1054788008,
-0.3429117501,
0.0606958009,
1.0050696135,
0.4553253055,
-0.8064695597,
-0.6602235436,
0.3244190514,
-0.0992891416,
-0.4845619798,
-0.132846728,
0.0881407782,
-0.3112278283,
-0.6581362486,
0.683809936,
0.1778294742,
-0.1430725604,
-0.716388762,
-0.1306672841,
-0.1772745401,
0.4463022947,
0.5160191655,
0.282110095,
-0.6841006279,
-0.3322221935,
0.1948195845,
0.0815575868,
-0.0230717827,
0.9384393096,
-0.5763093829,
0.7027363777,
0.1485317051,
0.4872899354,
0.2207664251,
0.180166319,
0.8915185928,
-0.3470513225,
0.1706612855,
0.2775752544,
0.3795135915,
0.2279363424,
0.0696515888,
0.4294001162,
-0.0899356902,
-0.5824970603,
-0.7454164624,
0.2564674616,
-0.7486352921,
-0.0635255948,
1.3326933384,
-0.2740539312,
-0.3166993856,
-0.0691817179,
-0.3562592268,
-0.1303071827,
-0.4160172939,
0.4873289466,
1.1422890425,
-0.1527973115,
-0.0741477609,
-0.7184937,
0.2495829463,
0.3093109131,
-0.7434613705,
0.0795597285,
0.5522179008,
0.2070814371,
0.315872699,
0.3616392612,
-0.0462570041,
0.2328477949,
-0.0033545424,
0.301666379,
-0.0731280372,
-0.2815240622,
-0.4248923957,
0.2981146574,
0.1689573377,
0.0963715836
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20852v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20852v1
|
Towards Spoken Language Understanding via Multi-level Multi-grained Contrastive Learning
| 2024-05-31T14:34:23 | 2024-05-31T14:34:23 |
Xuxin Cheng, Wanshi Xu, Zhihong Zhu, Hongxiang Li, Yuexian Zou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Spoken language understanding (SLU) is a core task in task-oriented dialogue
systems, which aims at understanding the user's current goal through
constructing semantic frames. SLU usually consists of two subtasks, including
intent detection and slot filling. Although there are some SLU frameworks joint
modeling the two subtasks and achieving high performance, most of them still
overlook the inherent relationships between intents and slots and fail to
achieve mutual guidance between the two subtasks. To solve the problem, we
propose a multi-level multi-grained SLU framework MMCL to apply contrastive
learning at three levels, including utterance level, slot level, and word level
to enable intent and slot to mutually guide each other. For the utterance
level, our framework implements coarse granularity contrastive learning and
fine granularity contrastive learning simultaneously. Besides, we also apply
the self-distillation method to improve the robustness of the model.
Experimental results and further analysis demonstrate that our proposed model
achieves new state-of-the-art results on two public multi-intent SLU datasets,
obtaining a 2.6 overall accuracy improvement on the MixATIS dataset compared to
previous best models.
|
[
-0.2514995635,
-0.7976452708,
0.570304215,
0.1714341491,
-0.2446001023,
-0.0249784868,
-0.0154919252,
-0.3782351613,
-0.0920878574,
0.3940277696,
-0.592787981,
-0.561441958,
-0.4933484197,
-0.2604378164,
-0.1619756818,
0.9214145541,
0.2046963423,
0.1234215721,
-0.1543478072,
-0.2820982933,
-0.5549603105,
-0.1939576864,
-0.7986638546,
-0.6163081527,
0.4184659719,
0.3805965781,
0.44075647,
0.2086057663,
0.0316649787,
0.3670471311,
-0.2761559784,
0.2370122522,
-0.5789643526,
0.0035785132,
-0.0630324632,
-0.3854801953,
-0.4486619532,
0.0149646718,
0.5362839103,
0.547700882,
-0.4430499077,
-0.1821468323,
0.3617781699,
0.5502975583,
-0.5019545555,
0.5108081698,
-0.7480841875,
0.1126197278,
0.0888007581,
0.0441731475,
-0.4896990657,
0.156583637,
0.1752262861,
-0.8498628736,
0.0195173025,
-0.1644821912,
0.6690454483,
0.2588236332,
-0.1985784322,
-0.52272892,
-0.5502095819,
0.9090853333,
-0.8898100853,
0.3449193537,
0.4630014896,
0.3142687678,
0.1030927375,
-0.3432235718,
-0.4104778767,
-0.1303944141,
-0.3988961279,
0.2351299077,
-0.0949257761,
0.1845608205,
-0.0679220334,
0.5673979521,
-0.6442366242,
0.1509443521,
-0.2103260905,
-0.2850112915,
0.0494246595,
0.1707422882,
0.1516792476,
-0.0794256255,
-0.5855118632,
0.0471859686,
-0.2622933686,
0.187931031,
-0.0274949819,
0.5749752522,
-0.3300018311,
0.0919993818,
-0.0834336728,
0.7712459564,
0.1108818948,
-0.6235162616,
0.399538368,
-0.6127994061,
-0.3499445617,
0.0831134021,
0.5906920433,
0.0254798252,
0.0138063636,
0.0500087105,
-0.1760896891,
-0.1198323295,
0.0591667667,
-0.59595263,
-0.0740090683,
0.2395977378,
-0.2957933545,
-0.216390416,
-0.1136858761,
-0.4292315245,
-0.1599128991,
-0.4460533261,
0.3763040006,
-0.6000558734,
-0.3353000283,
0.2932037115,
0.2216930538,
0.25306198,
0.5340692401,
-0.830489397,
0.3102638423,
0.7098614573,
0.7761664391,
-0.0500846617,
-0.554489851,
-0.5886913538,
0.4658912718,
-0.0210824907,
0.6092097759,
-0.65398103,
-0.4008914232,
-0.20817779,
-0.2268033326,
-0.4015755355,
-0.4678424001,
0.4209916592,
-0.2292791307,
0.2355585992,
0.1153370738,
-0.2820032537,
-0.3520600498,
0.3211088181,
-0.4295978844,
1.1401016712,
-0.0321762264,
-0.6112579107,
0.2204122394,
-0.5396270752,
-0.4717554748,
0.1211093515,
-0.3031193316,
-0.3777935505,
0.2186914533,
0.4114542305,
0.4662730396,
0.3737047613,
0.6005369425,
-0.1749539375,
-0.344804287,
0.0856662989,
-0.5266885757,
0.2734811604,
0.2484916747,
-0.1951716095,
0.3115355372,
-0.7461951971,
-0.22544083,
-0.1672792137,
-0.4164711535,
-0.4154071808,
0.0423343331,
-0.1891832799,
0.4115368426,
0.2383209616,
-0.4457603097,
-0.1168130264,
-0.2661820054,
0.4901829064,
0.7679105401,
-0.401753068,
0.4925813675,
-0.1101553217,
0.1993178427,
0.5736301541,
0.129525587,
-0.5078657269,
-0.4157755673,
-0.8778133392,
-0.1136607081,
0.0312806293,
0.5580495,
-0.7540059686,
0.2833369076,
-0.0061738761,
-0.0854978636,
-0.8424146771,
0.1088118032,
0.7701998949,
0.5702110529,
0.5018925667,
-0.096098341,
-0.0448593795,
-0.6859303117,
0.0362048745,
-0.1121986508,
0.1828474253,
0.9398644567,
0.1065765619,
-0.3127879798,
0.6318525076,
-0.4784252346,
-0.5742336512,
-0.4865653217,
0.4629426003,
0.3273235857,
0.5510007143,
0.1954450905,
-0.710822463,
-0.4178022444,
0.3776785433,
-0.6161399484,
-0.1705272049,
-0.1373968273,
0.0738953575,
-0.0934065208,
0.5303454995,
-0.1971617341,
0.2693706751,
0.7801790237,
-0.1084773615,
0.4773397148,
-0.375189811,
0.094526276,
-1.1383174658,
-0.2219459563,
0.0756285116,
-0.3086462915,
-1.016242981,
-0.0787415728,
-0.0089345556,
-0.292196244,
-0.6714478731,
0.3077100813,
-0.2154036909,
-0.3111310303,
-0.4307621419,
0.4881570041,
0.2944358885,
0.6038064361,
-0.0310794078,
0.9700978398,
0.6935418844,
-0.617754221,
-0.1626023948,
-0.0093144635,
-0.2481211573,
0.5216931701,
-0.5763416886,
0.0374630988,
-0.2396679521,
0.3451929092,
-1.2255638838,
0.0740571842,
0.1280101687,
-0.1959762275,
0.3497754931,
-0.1968015581,
0.1142763272,
-0.0164543986,
0.1159894615,
0.5077411532,
-0.0128231011,
-0.3821547031,
0.9209278822,
0.4342239499,
-0.1753589362,
-0.8354763985,
-0.6874094605,
-0.3090281785,
-0.1829266101,
-0.6285172105,
0.3067936599,
-0.1026471108,
-0.1040220484,
-0.2701259851,
-0.2432940751,
-0.2343028933,
0.0355175696,
0.1989720017,
0.0149302725,
-0.348075062,
0.1402825266,
0.1255847663,
-0.40843454,
-0.3383757472,
-0.2834764123,
0.8703605533,
-0.3969492018,
-0.4115042388,
-0.9026861191,
0.3955717385,
0.5164170265,
-0.2134131193,
0.5852524638,
1.0129443407,
-0.0024285519,
-0.0251187347,
-0.4892241955,
0.1238892376,
-0.4866535068,
0.171684891,
-0.8330756426,
-1.1980997324,
0.5560398698,
0.039392706,
0.1851064861,
0.217952013,
0.3459481299,
-0.1669800282,
0.8019505739,
0.4365799427,
-0.3594791293,
0.58158952,
-0.2159026265,
0.1196312159,
-0.9430499673,
-0.2726791799,
-0.4104564786,
-0.182468906,
-0.288544327,
-0.693475008,
0.3418776691,
0.16508241,
0.3991173804,
0.2053346783,
-0.0930331796,
0.5340345502,
0.2436900288,
0.350748539,
0.3833639324,
-0.2255197763,
-0.4312896132,
0.2150128633,
-0.509842813,
-0.2634578645,
0.3729046285,
0.3513355255,
1.007184267,
0.0558897555,
0.8206498027,
0.1890443563,
-0.2238812894,
-0.7837865353,
0.4384994507,
-0.4050957561,
-0.2408980131,
-0.553363204,
-0.4772076607,
-0.8733101487,
0.9154980183,
0.0930687934,
-0.635984838,
0.1230797321,
0.3428593874,
-0.3119159937,
0.0664680004,
-0.9481267929,
0.8525910378,
-0.0979612991,
-0.2254694551,
-0.4941436052,
-0.6231451631,
0.3990271986,
0.2003163844,
0.6734405756,
-0.4723201096,
0.2644938827,
0.3879717588,
0.0658580363,
0.9746775031,
-0.3424893022,
-0.2422503084,
0.0702372789,
-0.0493699349,
0.2915498018,
0.1483113021,
-0.2001767904,
0.006952405,
-0.2201371938,
-0.5332989097,
-0.4751830101,
0.8975557089,
-0.6160391569,
-0.4551260769,
-0.2261430621,
-0.7777579427,
0.0179439764,
0.0505613387,
-0.2960338295,
0.7842915058,
-0.2663797438,
-0.0848585889,
0.8794957399,
-0.1778216511,
0.6399168968,
0.7013427019,
-0.1401135772,
-0.1243813559,
1.1893342733,
-0.4706026316,
0.5329158306,
0.5402321219,
0.5407496691,
-0.3391875029,
-0.7923308611,
-0.4998298585,
0.1882767677,
-0.6021541953,
0.1078631878,
-0.6593281627,
-0.2101776749,
-0.5020186305,
-0.1067496985,
-0.3171788454,
0.0487527288,
-0.6360093951,
0.0532335564,
-0.2122819871,
0.8934521079,
0.061454609,
0.5635732412,
-0.7483866811,
0.4166010916,
0.4274642467,
0.2408817858,
0.035646148,
-0.5916122794,
-0.2043507397,
0.0260872655,
-0.2562970519,
-0.4027555585,
0.3371112943,
0.5397996306,
0.8427749276,
0.7891901731,
-0.2620999813,
1.1713351011,
-0.6010738015,
0.7103234529,
0.269433558,
-1.0663017035,
0.7408432364,
-0.2525449991,
0.7175819278,
0.9290193915,
0.2220083028,
-0.586587131,
-0.548468709,
-0.4929580092,
-0.6328712106,
0.8996456861,
0.1291206926,
-0.0124824354,
0.2448353022,
0.0384734608,
0.3916694224,
0.0195940845,
-1.1762826443,
-0.1864630133,
-0.1708692759,
-0.1160660237,
-0.2373434305,
-0.1488538533,
0.1187674552,
-0.1929501742,
0.6262626648,
-0.2151754946,
-0.1091934517,
0.0455176421,
-0.5318036675,
0.2038782239,
0.7053719163,
0.8045610189,
0.7362684608,
-0.0715864897,
0.3526863158,
0.1105452925,
-0.4279571176,
-0.0407495797,
0.0158651043,
0.0847474188,
-0.1179206446,
0.1192832887,
1.093241334,
0.6393360496,
-0.3917457163,
0.38848719,
-0.2309212387,
-0.103653498,
0.1034289822,
0.1579935402,
0.0474052355,
0.2244119346,
0.0713727698,
-0.2157265395,
0.2641574144,
-0.5841694474,
0.3260886967,
0.3695195317,
-0.6746207476,
-0.1106845662,
0.0484923087,
0.4083269835,
-0.187950626,
0.2738647461,
-0.2685218751,
-0.3940170407,
0.1644936055,
0.7131227255,
0.4494251311,
-0.536650598,
0.3587822616,
0.2218471318,
0.0298424084,
0.2094362229,
0.1575535834,
-0.4399326444,
-0.7586989403,
-0.4077741206,
-0.9074228406,
-0.3078579903,
0.4661233127,
-0.6372706294,
-0.1678373069,
0.0452446528,
0.2239760756,
0.1672141105,
-0.1356958151,
-0.1708392948,
0.0533813089,
0.1894472092,
0.4556674957,
-0.9838916659,
1.1102523804,
0.2352790087,
-0.0798755065,
-0.5847375393,
-0.0495226718,
0.0309219081,
-1.0071918964,
0.2818717062,
0.4521139562,
-0.4575792551,
-0.0267131291,
-0.0114705488,
-0.7200626135,
1.025796771,
-0.1527165025,
-0.5908851624,
0.0538546406,
0.1255535334,
0.2600465417,
-0.6964969039,
0.358338654,
0.8139329553,
0.2950942218,
0.458378613,
-0.8718897104,
-0.3563551903,
0.0062144697,
-0.097746484,
0.4073305428,
-0.4929342568,
0.9092873931,
-0.0356325135,
-0.1652309895,
-0.1430601031,
0.6956218481,
0.3563764393,
0.6479276419,
0.7228665948,
0.8425978422,
0.5776382089,
-0.1892515123,
0.5468857884,
-0.0658544451,
0.4312063158,
1.367241025,
-0.2695995271,
0.800454855,
0.3752315342,
-0.1807942688,
0.5957206488,
0.376427561,
0.3986309469,
0.5653225183,
0.0230138358,
-0.3980508149,
-0.2253657728,
-0.1502964497,
-0.2001638114,
0.592967093,
0.8993871212,
-0.1988343149,
-0.6097511649,
0.2672985196,
-0.1583264917,
-0.0068719485,
-0.4216251373,
1.2142003775,
0.0010171519,
-0.5396712422,
0.540050745,
-0.2914218009,
0.717974484,
-0.6444114447,
-0.0547478758,
-0.1674003154,
0.178037256,
-0.1770543456,
-0.8996873498,
0.1305925101,
-0.3380824625,
-0.038697768,
-0.2161129415,
0.8517085314,
-0.795383215,
-0.2951644957,
0.3705675006,
0.5571312904,
0.4560265541,
0.1490423679,
-1.1214996576,
0.1069523543,
0.0512815081,
0.2517785728,
0.4651644826,
0.4672507942,
0.3894948363,
0.5888200998,
0.5142389536,
-0.198329702,
0.1971585751,
0.7195975184,
0.8540591598,
-0.3009999692,
-0.7037658691,
-0.794935286,
0.3710412681,
-0.1379663646,
-0.162572667,
0.4796250761,
0.5540506244,
0.910189271,
0.108466126,
0.5128179789,
0.1994318068,
0.3191109598,
-0.7254623771,
0.2809183896,
-0.510994494,
0.1862843186,
-0.2361284196,
-0.5170067549,
-0.038436871,
0.7915183902,
-0.0771524534,
-0.1386324912,
0.6525435448,
0.7546442747,
-0.3442880809,
0.1614472568,
0.7303133011,
0.1392643601,
0.2943069935,
0.7280510664,
0.7921352983,
-0.1958130449,
0.4729738832,
-0.213486746,
-0.4164324701,
-0.1356481314,
-0.5717983246,
-0.8316747546,
-0.524300158,
0.0596376322,
0.0274579022,
0.0012355178,
0.4627321064,
0.9648430347,
-0.8574379086,
-0.5824542642,
-0.1292380691,
0.2417671978,
-0.2200840265,
-0.2616510689,
0.1846554726,
-0.80509758,
-0.82945472,
0.6549731493,
0.6118065119,
0.1431620568,
-0.3052861989,
-0.1737603992,
-0.5004134178,
-0.0648514554,
0.8332878351,
-0.0211032983,
-1.1701427698,
-0.1000740603,
-0.4513008595,
-0.0873406604,
0.4116119444,
0.9934079647,
-0.6267433763,
0.4341903627,
0.2519421577,
0.4711591005,
0.7586044073,
0.1687881649,
0.2005882263,
-0.9312707186,
0.2239720672,
0.0447917283,
0.483368367,
0.1529437751,
-0.3260295093,
0.1578241289,
-0.0584396906,
-0.5570888519,
-0.3201748133,
0.504449904,
-1.4227294922,
-0.48372823,
1.0872827768,
-0.3709085882,
-0.1088330001,
-0.447543174,
-0.3577610552,
0.2146918774,
-0.7892981172,
0.4621126056,
0.5752319098,
-0.4710216522,
-0.2831258476,
-0.3975825608,
0.3156706691,
0.3675248623,
-0.9658447504,
0.2692513764,
0.3381108344,
0.0072387005,
0.2717532516,
0.7315952182,
0.0298861321,
-0.0329959281,
-0.2169704288,
-0.4072895944,
-0.0387816094,
-0.6296173334,
-0.4704963863,
0.1603551209,
-0.1557495445,
-0.3209170103
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20850v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20850v1
|
Improving Reward Models with Synthetic Critiques
| 2024-05-31T14:33:07 | 2024-05-31T14:33:07 |
Zihuiwen Ye, Fraser Greenlee-Scott, Max Bartolo, Phil Blunsom, Jon Ander Campos, Matthias Gallé
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Reward models (RM) play a critical role in aligning language models through
the process of reinforcement learning from human feedback. RMs are trained to
predict a score reflecting human preference, which requires significant time
and cost for human annotation. Additionally, RMs tend to quickly overfit on
superficial features in the training set, hindering their generalization
performance on unseen distributions. We propose a novel approach using
synthetic natural language critiques generated by large language models to
provide additional feedback, evaluating aspects such as instruction following,
correctness, and style. This offers richer signals and more robust features for
RMs to assess and score on. We demonstrate that high-quality critiques improve
the performance and data efficiency of RMs initialized from different
pretrained models. Conversely, we also show that low-quality critiques
negatively impact performance. Furthermore, incorporating critiques enhances
the interpretability and robustness of RM training.
|
[
-0.2817969322,
-0.2174840569,
0.3689295948,
0.1521792561,
-0.0909526497,
0.1200888902,
-0.5664215088,
-0.4869299829,
0.2966295481,
0.4388394952,
-0.7276782393,
-0.087447159,
-0.4552874863,
0.2103598267,
0.0532045774,
1.2516522408,
0.0321834236,
0.3276942074,
-0.2678429484,
-0.1717528552,
-0.5455145836,
-0.857175827,
-0.6162811518,
-0.5630162954,
0.6559760571,
0.1382037103,
0.5996856093,
0.3813637495,
0.245265007,
0.389020592,
-0.0068856189,
0.4450229704,
-0.718632102,
0.1822882444,
-0.4041415453,
-0.4363510311,
-0.4029000998,
0.3042989075,
0.511896193,
0.5396308303,
-0.1200999245,
0.0371690094,
0.251565814,
0.6837287545,
-0.7445765138,
0.2270677835,
-0.3891163766,
-0.1147584245,
0.2474461049,
-0.3480989039,
-0.7438740134,
-0.6177818179,
0.2839253247,
-0.7719978094,
0.1280999184,
-0.1354901344,
0.8848848343,
0.2033240199,
-0.1006253511,
-0.1872005016,
-0.8765048385,
1.1095155478,
-0.6580259204,
0.1345599741,
0.4397733212,
0.6154142022,
-0.0091774091,
-0.3913561702,
-0.4966964424,
-0.7522382736,
-0.4073312283,
0.0491215959,
0.0352435149,
-0.158732146,
0.1423075199,
0.4958121479,
-0.1543061584,
-0.0427041277,
-0.1615968794,
-0.1921444982,
0.9344636798,
0.3371370733,
0.1051338837,
-0.3076809347,
-0.2821427584,
-0.7609289885,
-0.6154813766,
0.4765631258,
0.6143751144,
0.5474604964,
0.0034533837,
0.5455113649,
-0.4399159253,
0.6209081411,
-0.1017021835,
0.0945340469,
0.454841584,
-0.273496896,
0.0945240557,
-0.2387697697,
0.6854985952,
0.497508496,
0.1681058407,
-0.2107546329,
-0.7478321195,
0.413808614,
0.7096622586,
-0.5864065886,
-0.3746897876,
0.0430711582,
-0.3679342568,
-0.7266378403,
0.2987851501,
-0.5696101189,
-0.630538106,
-0.9567434788,
0.6059262753,
-0.4984109998,
-0.1495446861,
0.0834527835,
-0.3960023224,
-0.1202824265,
0.6170350909,
-1.1012897491,
0.4436679482,
0.6991280913,
0.590949595,
-0.2507846951,
-0.2788721025,
-0.8627411723,
-0.0220981222,
-0.2273799628,
0.9509413242,
-0.7151290178,
-0.281270802,
-0.1027975455,
-0.0538597815,
0.1028467044,
-0.7779095173,
0.5909885764,
-0.3508455753,
0.4827484488,
-0.4232451022,
-0.4684960842,
-0.0342925563,
0.6836743355,
-0.7699420452,
0.9896664619,
0.5483184457,
-0.6549757123,
0.3215957284,
-0.7865498066,
-0.4206205308,
0.0050719883,
0.0834103599,
-0.1999738961,
0.3556022346,
0.4911774993,
0.1100878492,
-0.0045158365,
0.1447619349,
-0.2519337535,
-0.4650637507,
0.582900703,
-0.2643589377,
0.1778505743,
0.0532510467,
-0.3211226165,
0.6896874905,
-0.7494633794,
0.3204394281,
0.0360465236,
-0.4402100742,
-0.3819992244,
-0.066519253,
0.2638734281,
0.1632711589,
-0.18979837,
-0.4463848472,
0.3712334037,
-0.7925876975,
0.4146246314,
1.1096801758,
-0.086905621,
0.4469335973,
-0.6532058716,
0.8052930832,
-0.2987479568,
0.1669550985,
-0.040759068,
0.0863939673,
-0.7155501246,
-0.3229981959,
0.5843738317,
0.1805027723,
-0.7090301514,
0.3404640853,
-0.3278976083,
-0.5185242295,
-0.7620931864,
0.0083105145,
0.4988587797,
0.098715201,
0.6172457337,
-0.7343817353,
-0.7593332529,
-0.7733440399,
-0.515715301,
-0.1309595555,
-0.2729159892,
0.2865913212,
0.3388349116,
-0.2222320139,
0.9297685027,
-0.4013774991,
-0.1901690513,
-0.548745513,
0.2301585078,
-0.1180767864,
0.4867882729,
0.2853361666,
-0.3410713375,
-0.2007723451,
-0.2101231068,
-0.1922960728,
0.0889747366,
-0.1334490329,
-0.1078181639,
0.1875337511,
-0.008264509,
-0.4406316578,
0.1106276363,
0.3914108276,
-0.3144392967,
0.8517848849,
-0.0411850438,
0.1599936485,
-0.7289580703,
0.1770378053,
0.0992996767,
-0.2095196694,
-0.2241230458,
-0.0737634003,
-0.2168503553,
0.1057481244,
-0.1969262362,
0.7291553617,
-0.1435293555,
0.1490807235,
-0.3060843945,
-0.0396036096,
0.2408709675,
0.6474099755,
0.2510786951,
0.3733999133,
0.0674704537,
-0.5636892319,
0.4080267251,
0.1684294641,
-0.3892994821,
0.4849815965,
-0.8051534295,
0.1698183119,
-0.0551596619,
0.5138857365,
-0.8905303478,
-0.3970883489,
0.126948446,
-0.6197842956,
0.2951677442,
-0.058935985,
-0.3015333712,
-0.083236441,
-0.7111921906,
0.1057177112,
0.4709593356,
-0.6278117895,
0.3842739165,
0.356492579,
0.0084809149,
-0.5446724892,
-0.298679024,
-0.1608121693,
0.0686168149,
-0.2277478874,
0.4560490251,
0.0854762197,
-0.1570145488,
-0.038073767,
0.0297648795,
0.4321834743,
0.1166660935,
0.3369202018,
0.4229068756,
0.1411896497,
0.1687510163,
-0.250986129,
-0.2530773282,
0.1312930882,
-0.1681787521,
0.7413868308,
-0.1808146089,
-0.1692599505,
-0.4906076193,
0.067496486,
0.4177209437,
-0.4378547072,
0.7430819273,
0.4477192461,
-0.0895231143,
-0.5331646204,
-0.428553462,
-0.6527730823,
-0.4902352393,
0.3153967559,
-0.0555720553,
-0.817907989,
-0.0689423159,
0.0626495704,
0.021401355,
0.4043984115,
0.6739459038,
-0.0743637308,
1.2859452963,
0.6841979623,
-0.1569001824,
0.5452940464,
-0.4887438118,
0.1116738319,
-0.8563628793,
-0.4682544768,
-0.5159243941,
-0.5028406382,
-0.3917961717,
-0.2280603796,
0.0616848134,
-0.0300258547,
-0.2037080824,
0.2925342917,
-0.5977289677,
0.4836583138,
0.6260503531,
0.150704056,
0.0474916436,
0.0108436616,
-0.2798579931,
-0.1392252594,
-0.4600689411,
-0.792946279,
1.0422599316,
0.4941409528,
0.7537679076,
0.0003165356,
0.5484158397,
0.1922751665,
0.7764557004,
-0.7895997763,
0.2333755046,
0.0744014382,
-0.2955875397,
-0.3962884545,
-0.594682157,
-0.6342054605,
0.2452398986,
-0.3665728271,
-0.5548983812,
-0.1610358506,
0.4774920046,
-0.5014355779,
0.0434568822,
-0.806571126,
1.0732614994,
-0.3365170956,
-0.4950054288,
-0.4027315378,
-0.4636415839,
0.3531097174,
0.4403446913,
0.2617625594,
0.0526683666,
0.4317863286,
0.635853827,
-0.6589260697,
0.8204448223,
-0.1963847727,
0.0014978116,
0.0032898232,
0.2582452893,
0.5263835788,
0.0823452398,
-0.1220131516,
-0.4285019338,
0.110832341,
-0.2786875963,
-1.0321162939,
0.5612137318,
-0.7779912353,
-0.320174098,
-0.4015144706,
-0.5068649054,
-0.688597858,
-0.2094410211,
0.1005392,
0.4645142853,
-0.1445429623,
-0.0583812147,
0.0507739559,
-0.3138937354,
0.0339524783,
0.258792907,
-0.1939200312,
-0.6304578781,
1.0548157692,
-0.3606367707,
0.4592726231,
0.1372174919,
0.3156917989,
-0.6422621608,
-0.2028909624,
-0.358271569,
0.2360529602,
-0.6698133349,
-0.0571817867,
-0.4309645295,
-0.0565552153,
-0.3649619222,
-0.0194935873,
-0.5500865579,
-0.6989720464,
-0.0206960924,
-0.1715939045,
0.2571966946,
0.9768106937,
0.0277368743,
0.2140073329,
-0.7873852253,
0.0319082215,
0.2535502315,
0.6497258544,
0.3669111729,
-0.7548795938,
-0.389570117,
0.2316159159,
-0.5148534775,
-0.487398386,
0.5515366197,
-0.1670584381,
0.5399631858,
0.2130567133,
0.1402531713,
0.5510057807,
-0.2959809601,
0.8144171834,
0.2820808887,
-0.955840826,
0.5737787485,
-0.0261608344,
0.0885460302,
0.6330384612,
0.3574372232,
-0.6209715605,
-0.3373306692,
-0.5655369759,
-0.7131074667,
0.9505422115,
0.0871707052,
0.3896827996,
-0.0322133452,
0.1380763501,
0.1478155702,
0.2546953559,
-0.9491529465,
0.2069197297,
-0.5964812636,
-0.2426227927,
-0.3072412014,
-0.3977922797,
-0.275973618,
-0.4984167516,
0.9002758861,
-0.0777570084,
-0.0037751705,
-0.0492238738,
-0.1276131123,
-0.365375936,
0.5490038395,
0.5982776284,
0.5503014922,
-0.2214376181,
0.1541100144,
0.0709639862,
0.0204412229,
0.2531141043,
-0.2247195691,
-0.019067565,
-0.0205758363,
0.4791571796,
1.095023632,
0.2739244699,
-0.9737526178,
0.5162212253,
-0.1792916507,
-0.0269868094,
-0.1836369932,
0.2952031493,
-0.0114607848,
0.1423089802,
-0.1123618484,
0.2403779924,
-0.0109639792,
-0.8572399616,
0.154621765,
0.5479653478,
-0.7696321607,
-0.4635227025,
0.3843843937,
0.1598499417,
-0.3198872507,
0.6292786002,
-0.2920175493,
-0.9623401761,
0.2213404924,
0.4701394141,
0.7927106023,
-0.1787854135,
0.3935874701,
0.6032656431,
0.1176998243,
-0.4156257808,
0.0178249739,
-0.1070889756,
-0.6059515476,
-0.6101504564,
-0.8869295716,
-0.6510030627,
0.0827011615,
-0.6923577189,
0.4405790865,
-0.4330618083,
-0.1959765106,
-0.1618121713,
-0.109484449,
-0.416531533,
0.2758237422,
0.1464727521,
0.4774135649,
-0.708519578,
0.7251524329,
0.8294949532,
-0.6558634043,
-1.1390072107,
-0.1993154883,
-0.1441648155,
-0.3830391467,
0.9428429008,
0.4375582337,
-0.1276870519,
-0.378316164,
-0.3164035082,
-0.6208893657,
0.6292532682,
0.4035485089,
-0.3413858414,
0.0315497294,
0.0543194525,
0.9861114621,
-0.3432413042,
0.6560246944,
0.6139730215,
0.3872458637,
0.1969456673,
-0.8665089011,
0.0776084885,
-0.594547987,
0.0224950705,
0.0982861519,
-0.2092253864,
0.7567349672,
-0.155079186,
-0.1010627821,
0.0188511051,
0.4399469197,
0.4646683931,
-0.0413968042,
0.6859872341,
0.6417950392,
0.5353887081,
-0.0810848624,
1.5245432854,
0.1096937805,
0.3802609146,
1.2042837143,
-0.2202439159,
0.9890500903,
0.4402925074,
-0.244904682,
0.7391524911,
0.6080213189,
-0.0644532591,
0.7050100565,
0.7697123289,
0.0462762825,
-0.3175226152,
-0.2134326249,
-0.2039557397,
0.2385968566,
-0.0601121597,
-0.3093325496,
-0.0711057186,
-0.1070379466,
-0.397872597,
0.4219681025,
-0.1774928719,
0.7977650166,
-0.1272040308,
-1.0615948439,
0.7672581673,
0.2051988393,
0.6896345019,
-0.5389993191,
-0.2648012936,
-0.1324105859,
0.4562087059,
-0.2079958916,
-0.3894508779,
0.3080497384,
0.0186275803,
-0.1249735355,
-0.3364987075,
0.2135006934,
-0.3851008415,
-0.4211538434,
0.2103658915,
-0.0793563277,
-0.2960774601,
-0.3675423563,
-0.4704973698,
0.1593858749,
-0.1227252185,
-0.35420084,
0.4040199816,
0.0747936517,
-0.0994478166,
0.6714524031,
0.8161031604,
0.15262191,
-0.3478686213,
0.3117453754,
0.9076797962,
-0.6493255496,
-0.7292480469,
-1.0036019087,
0.7947387695,
-0.3242807984,
-0.314704299,
0.6212491989,
0.4775398672,
1.1866158247,
-0.3039016426,
0.7220249772,
0.3314819634,
0.8062781096,
-0.5773056746,
0.6436671019,
-0.5053679347,
0.5755141377,
-0.4139260054,
-0.8539275527,
-0.1522920877,
0.7930109501,
-0.4322400391,
0.1406865567,
0.5721000433,
0.723938942,
0.0875076577,
0.0828221515,
-0.0968909934,
-0.1688767076,
0.4529429078,
0.5173133016,
1.4826641083,
-0.188980341,
0.2561516762,
-0.570219934,
0.044439245,
-0.2886660099,
-0.7625406384,
-0.8381343484,
-0.3650431931,
-0.1918962449,
-0.5853283405,
-0.1040255353,
1.4014652967,
0.7712089419,
-1.0988801718,
-0.3240399063,
0.0725449994,
-0.0195093136,
-0.3969741762,
-0.2748171687,
0.3502262831,
-0.7024402618,
-0.5460911989,
0.420065105,
0.1973590106,
-0.0945863351,
-0.3915897012,
-0.5115145445,
0.2935990095,
0.1341969073,
0.6878473759,
0.044070892,
-0.8152989745,
-0.4363262057,
-0.0291707497,
-0.179846853,
-0.0414194129,
1.0423691273,
-0.9890087247,
0.4236417711,
0.334189713,
0.7165614963,
0.3923457265,
0.2797004282,
0.9203991294,
-0.8404893875,
0.1207736135,
0.5450214744,
0.2737281621,
0.5995774865,
-0.1545622647,
0.479056865,
0.1667416394,
-0.1916313022,
-1.2397991419,
0.2001185864,
-0.8807761073,
-0.2553182542,
0.9849501848,
-0.1245078743,
-0.1336310059,
0.3808456063,
-0.4744065106,
0.1876516342,
-0.2156419605,
1.2123528719,
0.7671664357,
0.02561564,
-0.0699923784,
-0.1844489574,
0.9464617968,
0.7828011513,
-0.8603998423,
0.2950885892,
0.5556909442,
0.2017203569,
0.0277128294,
0.3644241095,
-0.3215811849,
0.3755827546,
-0.3713875115,
0.2401864082,
-0.2375001758,
-0.2837460041,
-0.5830700397,
0.0836654082,
0.520511508,
0.0615523681
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20846v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20846v1
|
Don't Buy it! Reassessing the Ad Understanding Abilities of Contrastive Multimodal Models
| 2024-05-31T14:31:46 | 2024-05-31T14:31:46 |
A. Bavaresco, A. Testoni, R. Fernández
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Image-based advertisements are complex multimodal stimuli that often contain
unusual visual elements and figurative language. Previous research on automatic
ad understanding has reported impressive zero-shot accuracy of contrastive
vision-and-language models (VLMs) on an ad-explanation retrieval task. Here, we
examine the original task setup and show that contrastive VLMs can solve it by
exploiting grounding heuristics. To control for this confound, we introduce
TRADE, a new evaluation test set with adversarial grounded explanations. While
these explanations look implausible to humans, we show that they "fool" four
different contrastive VLMs. Our findings highlight the need for an improved
operationalisation of automatic ad understanding that truly evaluates VLMs'
multimodal reasoning abilities. We make our code and TRADE available at
https://github.com/dmg-illc/trade .
|
[
-0.3852799833,
-0.6453942657,
0.559256494,
-0.016578095,
-0.4044963121,
0.1709936112,
0.0501839742,
-0.5599992275,
-0.0866372511,
0.2606857121,
-0.5601087809,
-0.221514836,
-0.5686519146,
-0.2667859197,
-0.1539888084,
0.6854534149,
-0.1626059115,
-0.0964459032,
-0.2338965535,
-0.4794929028,
-0.2950189114,
-0.1828884035,
-0.5685091615,
-0.2272251695,
0.3686218262,
0.3129455745,
1.1024882793,
0.5230217576,
0.3349913061,
0.2705460787,
-0.1633040458,
0.2040456384,
-0.5125508904,
-0.3313907385,
-0.3259889185,
-0.2930346429,
-0.3981977105,
0.2617867887,
0.007143171,
0.5441362262,
0.1277754009,
-0.0380054899,
-0.3437572718,
0.542798996,
-0.8147393465,
0.1630817056,
-0.837041676,
-0.1679729074,
0.3838813007,
-0.226331234,
-0.6487339735,
0.1689436138,
0.2251036912,
-0.8531291485,
0.3394844532,
0.1288377196,
1.3284143209,
0.3024627268,
-0.6492240429,
-0.1160725802,
-0.5891907811,
0.7204773426,
-0.5151170492,
0.360493511,
0.3354166448,
0.5489009023,
0.1238810569,
-0.5458556414,
-0.6015244722,
-0.413138032,
-0.1516160369,
0.3731904924,
-0.5015768409,
0.0512373745,
0.1999533474,
0.4870191514,
-0.4270614386,
-0.1912217289,
-0.5848093033,
-0.0498320051,
0.5265290141,
0.0434050523,
0.3442347646,
0.0326805785,
-0.9729222059,
-0.1340461224,
-0.4146586061,
0.1598568708,
0.0027777024,
-0.0497519635,
-0.0977767929,
0.5860673189,
-0.0540697984,
0.8656796813,
0.170334965,
0.3413774073,
0.1729906052,
-0.469063282,
-0.6001915932,
-0.3001877367,
0.4281711578,
0.5582069755,
0.1244295612,
-0.0663619265,
-0.2985769212,
0.6530948877,
0.5292178392,
-0.3062730432,
-0.3078791499,
0.2490918785,
-0.4492966235,
-0.3871995509,
-0.359954983,
-0.532797575,
-0.2046352923,
-0.2624450028,
0.9245418906,
-0.5253666043,
-0.141355142,
0.4003785551,
-0.4683560133,
0.1345688403,
0.3320422769,
-0.28451702,
0.1335366815,
0.2237048149,
0.3769018054,
0.0276047997,
-0.3364518285,
-0.3066675961,
-0.0174139552,
-0.5075769424,
0.9671394825,
-0.3660529256,
-0.2814197242,
-0.3124569952,
0.0617587194,
-0.2827653289,
-0.4258494377,
0.4207571447,
-0.9648492336,
0.4757971764,
-0.2866157889,
-0.1363419145,
-0.6173985004,
0.5521050096,
-0.6277920008,
0.3154011965,
0.1072587669,
-0.2955285311,
0.5690533519,
-0.4144390523,
-0.4664320648,
-0.1030678228,
0.162948519,
-0.3400768936,
0.2273827493,
0.25791803,
0.0405140147,
0.013698943,
-0.0574535802,
-0.5805236697,
-0.7287157774,
0.4069164693,
-0.735896945,
0.7113373876,
0.4459060729,
-0.6355224848,
0.0820363313,
-0.6475815773,
-0.2068693638,
0.5084427595,
-0.1491579413,
-0.4010018408,
-0.1324551702,
-0.0435953625,
0.5179143548,
0.3083166182,
-0.0859113932,
-0.1047113314,
-0.2130865008,
0.1198516041,
0.8087614775,
-0.4255843461,
0.422878623,
-0.4423657358,
0.5845624208,
0.239691779,
0.17091088,
-0.6209442616,
-0.3619781733,
-0.6792484522,
-0.294501096,
-0.055964455,
0.2060544342,
-0.9961275458,
-0.1858165115,
0.0435094796,
-0.2043215483,
-0.6150384545,
-0.0004207105,
0.6970593929,
0.4472804964,
0.4273146391,
-0.170724377,
-0.3420284688,
-0.9811109304,
-0.5228036642,
0.0438650772,
0.190347746,
0.4734534919,
0.3430444002,
-0.3653093576,
0.5300029516,
-0.5713917613,
-0.2325395346,
-0.053374581,
0.2309017628,
0.0031371959,
0.0732948855,
0.7113349438,
-0.9517343044,
-0.3596979082,
-0.1179675981,
-0.6315392852,
-0.00774237,
-0.2939042151,
0.091519624,
0.1271398515,
0.4018708766,
-0.6423828602,
0.5386433601,
0.5297691226,
-0.8065986633,
0.4508946538,
-0.4651249945,
0.2738062143,
-0.6408914328,
-0.0920844749,
0.2308400571,
-0.3307728767,
-0.1114747822,
0.3679089248,
0.1946736127,
-0.166114077,
-0.5426653624,
0.5029217601,
-0.5933226943,
-0.155587092,
-0.3410517275,
0.4269171357,
0.6072603464,
0.4793563187,
-0.224800393,
0.9269263148,
0.4154994786,
-0.7498551607,
0.1061336622,
0.1552267969,
-0.3049126267,
0.9688019156,
-0.6684223413,
0.0174653567,
-0.412758559,
0.0421123765,
-1.5548977852,
-0.0807642639,
0.4332105815,
-0.4421257973,
0.1600252241,
-0.1133621335,
0.0741525739,
-0.2393321544,
-0.1928887814,
0.4713946879,
0.5582815409,
-0.701223731,
0.5783008933,
0.0402072445,
0.5654833913,
-0.7975881696,
-0.6155107617,
0.1557815373,
-0.2708918452,
-0.5875169635,
0.3859346807,
-0.2349691093,
-0.6375158429,
0.3858542144,
-0.4343418777,
-0.0849145204,
0.3862738311,
-0.0005299051,
0.2488430142,
-0.4224007428,
-0.0701031387,
-0.2927211225,
-0.3876323104,
-0.0184020922,
-0.1950100362,
-0.0188461002,
-0.0408866033,
-0.5633354187,
-0.5328088999,
-0.0983185694,
1.0664814711,
-0.0011469143,
0.5401379466,
0.4919045866,
-0.093686685,
-0.0469358005,
-0.3657437861,
0.2095841616,
-0.4638410211,
0.0646477714,
-0.612262845,
-0.1734548509,
0.2662682235,
0.0564279407,
0.0511996225,
0.5858355761,
0.3557444215,
-0.0939122438,
1.4365688562,
0.5006504059,
0.3599357903,
0.4274283946,
-0.2473955899,
0.2371975482,
-0.4033812881,
-0.3188104033,
-0.1657359004,
-0.3536746502,
-0.1462685317,
-0.4855104387,
0.1083936095,
-0.0664416701,
-0.1662712842,
0.3707998991,
-0.1236068755,
0.5660322905,
0.2667123079,
0.3360570669,
0.3184088469,
0.1954061389,
-0.0144396508,
-0.1490619481,
-0.2590457797,
-0.3873973787,
0.7903441787,
0.2841059864,
0.9619563222,
0.2730153203,
-0.1225564703,
0.3957010508,
0.2847702503,
-1.061617732,
0.3470542729,
-0.4159154594,
-0.4705382288,
0.2181507498,
-0.2655817568,
-0.800532937,
0.823898077,
-0.0569682308,
-0.4058005512,
0.2563824952,
0.2993335128,
-0.2936167717,
0.2531322539,
-1.0333045721,
0.8670372367,
-0.4536182284,
-0.5188246369,
-0.4414738417,
-0.2421986014,
0.5108146667,
0.1355732679,
0.5976897478,
0.0157959796,
0.0084063746,
0.3764464259,
-0.0380865149,
0.6100878716,
-0.002052445,
-0.2601123154,
-0.0647659302,
0.4783422947,
0.2286930531,
-0.2468583882,
-0.0431379043,
-0.0605576746,
-0.2171051353,
-0.8150016665,
-0.8259484172,
0.6111388206,
-0.5603066683,
-0.7201204896,
-0.2519286871,
-0.502853632,
0.0219395887,
0.2140363157,
0.1469076574,
0.4229604602,
-0.3457716703,
0.0271156523,
0.5414658189,
-0.161700204,
0.1055989191,
0.5032891631,
0.1085957885,
-0.5401690006,
1.0452712774,
-0.3348251283,
0.6646119356,
0.1412606388,
0.208508864,
-0.5118129849,
-0.3335055709,
-0.5574503541,
0.074900113,
-1.054377079,
0.3335683346,
-0.6392288804,
0.2296076715,
-0.2841860056,
-0.4903009534,
-0.2549675405,
-0.330674082,
-0.2906864285,
-0.048697684,
-0.0083319843,
0.9004119039,
-0.2580371797,
0.4136962593,
-0.5061656237,
0.743689239,
0.6390217543,
0.1429648995,
-0.0034206202,
-0.6142419577,
-0.2138282806,
0.400831759,
-0.3298023939,
-0.9869869351,
0.2343637496,
-0.2603657544,
0.6771376133,
0.6713139415,
0.0932831392,
0.8193448782,
-0.1410564333,
0.9266371131,
0.2631468475,
-1.0680632591,
0.0859348997,
-0.1021147817,
0.1659235358,
0.2479956895,
0.1720080227,
-0.2214551568,
0.0538654886,
-0.8219910264,
-1.0198127031,
0.8615742922,
0.3072045445,
0.1237431988,
0.2129413038,
-0.1601587683,
-0.0439590178,
0.2742479742,
-0.7705543637,
-0.397139281,
-0.3406200707,
0.084136799,
-0.4549542069,
-0.5468539,
-0.3569517434,
-0.0605171584,
0.6695804,
-0.0433997214,
0.0679491535,
0.075644955,
-0.4560143352,
-0.1458104104,
0.2658154964,
0.759572804,
0.9039204717,
-0.3075268269,
0.5312726498,
-0.0816167593,
-0.0688594654,
0.1788088232,
0.0990681201,
0.1891241521,
0.1130445227,
0.2754381299,
1.0276850462,
0.3497240543,
-0.7995905876,
0.6231500506,
-0.2673578262,
-0.4215323329,
-0.1970784664,
-0.2503657639,
-0.1830039769,
0.3426715732,
-0.0709741861,
0.4856487215,
0.0738598406,
-0.4186600149,
0.3615759611,
0.5978214145,
-0.5623850226,
-0.3460928798,
1.0016887188,
-0.0238893069,
-0.3504494727,
0.3437812328,
-0.1898373067,
-0.6155976653,
0.8690057993,
0.6437941194,
0.8782816529,
0.0912893042,
0.5380724669,
-0.1718939841,
0.5031624436,
0.2052893639,
0.2459208518,
-0.235649541,
-0.8185530305,
-0.2679763138,
0.174031347,
-0.533213973,
0.2548178136,
-0.5194827318,
0.3624077439,
-0.3629266918,
0.161550045,
0.3568345904,
-0.4462427795,
-0.8903232217,
0.4471299648,
0.093416892,
0.770522356,
-0.9110019803,
0.2034124881,
0.7976253629,
-0.6414073706,
-0.273624897,
0.2997425199,
-0.0391357839,
-1.0919723511,
0.8231617212,
0.1873559058,
-0.4210323095,
-0.2298298329,
-0.7561074495,
-0.4273837209,
0.6566073895,
0.2464620173,
-0.147254318,
0.1641280204,
-0.5014851093,
0.4444293976,
-0.2565343082,
0.4907000065,
0.4163345993,
0.4947570264,
0.5054520965,
-0.5255728364,
0.0817279667,
-0.1834254265,
-0.2480050921,
-0.2694881558,
-0.4968086779,
1.0538463593,
-0.53330791,
-0.1827270836,
-0.1335216016,
-0.0081048338,
0.1889441609,
0.7593508363,
0.7789716125,
0.7329850793,
0.3026796877,
0.2650622427,
1.1562805176,
-0.1299736947,
0.5435791612,
0.8395114541,
-0.3011643589,
0.4020969272,
0.4075804055,
-0.0209253244,
0.4627450407,
0.5210366845,
0.1304233819,
0.5862558484,
0.0043019871,
-0.2315872014,
-0.7159861922,
-0.0082687158,
-0.1762373447,
0.5541884303,
0.4753758311,
-0.4785246253,
-0.5232548714,
-0.184561938,
-0.1548444182,
0.2129137367,
0.0802395642,
0.7723478079,
0.1183250844,
-0.3986077607,
1.019718647,
-0.0666150823,
0.5542304516,
-0.3093834519,
-0.1703152955,
-0.0015756733,
0.4939363301,
0.0104423342,
-0.6442973018,
0.305737257,
-0.3411911428,
-0.0782776475,
-0.390324384,
0.6536510587,
-0.2399938107,
-0.1152864993,
0.4979542494,
0.4924684763,
0.0135068912,
-0.0239170603,
-1.0118795633,
-0.2005907744,
0.0657298192,
-0.1127574444,
0.0723617673,
0.4138273001,
0.1320501864,
0.6383677125,
0.8079214692,
-0.2506997585,
-0.4036279619,
-0.1746943295,
0.7664425373,
-0.6978634596,
-0.5735712051,
-0.9225683212,
0.6988267899,
-0.0684183016,
-0.0216709431,
0.5903580189,
0.2192091942,
0.9627313018,
-0.1945185363,
0.7732744813,
0.3766845465,
0.0013349045,
-0.4370634854,
0.6049469709,
-1.3875988722,
0.4909893572,
-0.2848754525,
-0.4021955431,
-0.1769326031,
0.5623379946,
-0.4047811031,
-0.08462587,
0.8259056807,
0.4330927432,
-0.5382735133,
-0.0597725473,
0.7307606339,
0.3748576045,
0.3583944738,
0.4993850291,
1.0372309685,
-0.5987945795,
0.7558396459,
-0.2753434777,
-0.2743514776,
-0.3209208846,
-0.7742150426,
-0.8561133742,
-0.2268181592,
-0.4370778203,
-0.9220143557,
0.0045149247,
0.6507784128,
0.5644251704,
-0.5880134702,
-0.0527463891,
0.1499098241,
0.6732910275,
-0.5661594272,
-0.2366399169,
0.3086425662,
-0.2580563128,
-0.7162933946,
0.6929396391,
0.1948054582,
0.2793004811,
-0.1973739117,
0.2077972293,
-0.1875406653,
0.2265434116,
0.7261908054,
0.1376007795,
-0.8317841887,
-0.0263683815,
0.1146574914,
-0.0184026062,
0.0379807241,
0.880472064,
-0.8668341637,
0.9241244793,
0.5668610334,
0.5241649151,
0.0775795579,
0.1283891946,
0.663592279,
-0.2103779912,
0.325494349,
-0.2493941635,
0.5254728198,
0.2099789083,
-0.4820432365,
0.1787332892,
0.7162890434,
-0.0285251439,
-0.6066327691,
0.4464465082,
-0.9291688204,
-0.8161417246,
0.9601931572,
-0.297703743,
-0.2617506087,
-0.3431394696,
-0.4747547805,
-0.0193332061,
-0.3406221271,
0.9404097199,
0.3428482711,
0.198790133,
-0.2095784545,
-0.3175870478,
0.2656660974,
0.512372911,
-0.4146297574,
-0.1714543402,
0.658387363,
0.4696726501,
0.2318499386,
0.6484261751,
0.024106482,
0.4535852373,
0.2445998639,
-0.2027398795,
-0.3278399408,
-0.2589947581,
-0.6549757719,
0.2273918092,
0.1128045097,
-0.8106180429
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20835v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20835v3
|
Outliers and Calibration Sets have Diminishing Effect on Quantization of Modern LLMs
| 2024-05-31T14:24:33 | 2024-06-05T09:53:18 |
Davide Paglieri, Saurabh Dash, Tim Rocktäschel, Jack Parker-Holder
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Post-Training Quantization (PTQ) enhances the efficiency of Large Language
Models (LLMs) by enabling faster operation and compatibility with more
accessible hardware through reduced memory usage, at the cost of small
performance drops. We explore the role of calibration sets in PTQ, specifically
their effect on hidden activations in various notable open-source LLMs.
Calibration sets are crucial for evaluating activation magnitudes and
identifying outliers, which can distort the quantization range and negatively
impact performance. Our analysis reveals a marked contrast in quantization
effectiveness across models. The older OPT model, upon which much of the
quantization literature is based, shows significant performance deterioration
and high susceptibility to outliers with varying calibration sets. In contrast,
newer models like Llama-2 7B, Llama-3 8B, Command-R 35B, and Mistral 7B
demonstrate strong robustness, with Mistral 7B showing near-immunity to
outliers and stable activations. These findings suggest a shift in PTQ
strategies might be needed. As advancements in pre-training methods reduce the
relevance of outliers, there is an emerging need to reassess the fundamentals
of current quantization literature. The emphasis should pivot towards
optimizing inference speed, rather than primarily focusing on outlier
preservation, to align with the evolving characteristics of state-of-the-art
LLMs.
|
[
-0.136808008,
-0.2218132764,
0.5307429433,
-0.2307336628,
-0.3214356303,
-0.0509327352,
-0.1308189929,
-0.0390113555,
-0.3148837686,
0.5557209849,
-0.2136448473,
-0.2383300662,
-0.5212248564,
-0.1204809844,
-0.182638064,
0.8592656255,
0.1020973846,
0.2831546366,
-0.268148303,
-0.4187528193,
-0.1512065679,
-0.6597543359,
-0.4896639287,
-0.5520298481,
0.1647989899,
0.0603896007,
1.0589760542,
0.5447374582,
0.4986224473,
0.1962254345,
-0.2248293906,
0.0684647411,
-0.6403988004,
0.051895652,
0.2495862097,
-1.030882597,
-0.2148356736,
-0.0149023635,
0.965878129,
0.7549384236,
0.1509221494,
0.0778326094,
0.0944844186,
0.9491270185,
-1.0852078199,
0.0321113095,
-0.5009201169,
0.1302748471,
-0.2904980183,
-0.3381425738,
-0.4351403713,
-0.6664816141,
0.1329117268,
-0.7090821862,
0.0240403842,
-0.3342906535,
0.6198949218,
0.7268851399,
-0.5288956761,
-0.0236732326,
-0.5803711414,
1.0820798874,
-1.0509678125,
0.4659422934,
0.387668252,
0.2733071446,
-0.3034116328,
-0.6555793881,
-0.0602636635,
-0.1293365955,
0.1693795323,
-0.0029304649,
-0.2281969935,
0.0838946104,
0.4743022919,
0.5759134293,
-0.3318638206,
0.2305427641,
-0.1095482931,
-0.1286908984,
0.1875087023,
0.0218630675,
-0.1769020408,
0.2649774253,
-0.0920491517,
-0.261184454,
-1.3663518429,
0.2244600058,
0.6266925335,
-0.0146795958,
0.210069716,
0.4078594744,
-0.1952272803,
0.7250396609,
0.0689436495,
-0.1475525647,
0.2524852455,
-0.4695039392,
-0.3526348472,
-0.0401765928,
0.595931232,
0.0804349631,
0.3949246705,
0.0735925213,
-0.1188036501,
-0.0555355586,
-0.1368751824,
-0.922123313,
-0.4209594727,
0.0794016123,
-0.3564803898,
-0.307451427,
-0.0114086596,
-0.1351175755,
-0.4377367496,
-0.4079373777,
0.6563100815,
-0.4157322943,
-0.2755434215,
0.1222729534,
-0.2243014574,
0.186253652,
0.2969606817,
-0.6295604706,
-0.0043412531,
0.6796770692,
0.5096799731,
0.3109345436,
0.0548699312,
-0.5475756526,
0.0230615083,
-0.628939867,
0.488229543,
-0.4169647098,
-0.2646540403,
-0.0331054069,
-0.1813033074,
-0.0167657658,
-0.8278182149,
0.2674655318,
-0.7996790409,
0.140813604,
-0.397662282,
-0.2903773189,
-0.3245958686,
0.0152053209,
-0.7196518183,
1.1723767519,
0.1851261705,
-0.651447475,
0.5503842235,
-0.3048366606,
-0.0418946296,
0.0455188006,
0.0056796256,
-0.4544399977,
0.5297124386,
0.2108129412,
0.0214896891,
-0.3431981802,
0.1266438365,
-0.3031915724,
-0.9550434351,
0.56267941,
-0.5658901334,
0.9342111349,
0.0564097725,
-0.2463320643,
-0.0699160546,
-0.6809282899,
0.5404642224,
-0.3518828154,
-0.4081172049,
-0.5050397515,
0.1258589923,
-0.7183286548,
0.0330955498,
0.0749892145,
-0.0875531733,
-0.22205396,
-0.7678608298,
0.6057676673,
0.5817096829,
0.1390544027,
0.5612614751,
-0.3914362192,
0.5456427336,
0.2158188373,
0.2305489779,
-0.4234511554,
-0.2053613067,
-0.8695388436,
-0.3391240835,
0.4802533686,
0.4570764601,
-0.6426430345,
0.3240836561,
-0.460500598,
-0.4437254369,
-0.5549981594,
0.0755346343,
0.5603529811,
0.1966315061,
0.0236458313,
-0.2854180336,
-0.3207444251,
-0.8190912008,
-0.5566623211,
-0.0651220977,
-0.0870642811,
-0.2332153767,
0.2839257717,
-0.0591578446,
0.9946537614,
-0.0711258128,
-0.0668172091,
0.1972701102,
0.0306432266,
0.1686432064,
0.2861000896,
0.3945907354,
-0.6076878309,
-0.4080224931,
-0.0734942704,
-0.5426313281,
-0.2429122925,
0.1925478876,
-0.1079474166,
0.1584814042,
0.5867776871,
-0.3286646903,
0.6876045465,
0.5985815525,
0.2544254661,
0.5452255011,
-0.0026239986,
0.2018445879,
-0.7272054553,
-0.0086014615,
-0.1204287112,
-0.2911497653,
-0.6446686983,
0.073353149,
0.3639787138,
0.0094754854,
-0.6926808357,
0.3358297348,
-0.4530370533,
-0.2400250882,
-0.2505470812,
0.059339866,
0.1639060676,
0.3638367057,
-0.2340570837,
0.9410942793,
0.4980435967,
-0.596691668,
0.2196307182,
0.0083380546,
-0.3830584884,
0.5970053077,
-0.5044460893,
-0.0356028453,
-0.1992746741,
0.228739962,
-0.7142025232,
0.1543381065,
0.1250425428,
-0.300578028,
0.1528676599,
-0.2188946009,
-0.7588897943,
-0.0526744314,
-0.8058443069,
0.7518228292,
0.5446087122,
-0.3841249347,
0.2410385609,
-0.0264556389,
0.4240297973,
-0.651471734,
-0.6317439675,
-0.2875410616,
-0.4560844898,
-0.4574204981,
0.079271771,
-0.101537779,
-0.5439502597,
-0.2071016133,
-0.322011292,
-0.0132993096,
0.1056478545,
0.4277893305,
-0.2310413569,
-0.2901878059,
0.3739098907,
0.0302358363,
-0.1988304853,
-0.0400035083,
-0.0915856436,
0.4314292669,
-0.1772693545,
-0.3517432809,
-0.5084529519,
0.0786676332,
0.6066765189,
-0.4955371916,
0.71549052,
0.3939881325,
-0.3306308687,
0.0373960845,
-0.4431408644,
-0.2857367992,
-0.514028728,
0.4254169464,
-0.3082859218,
-0.7399998307,
0.4818327427,
-0.2993373871,
-0.009706378,
0.3356410563,
0.5927011371,
0.1427340806,
1.1135133505,
0.4885083735,
0.2414353192,
0.8904932737,
-0.3330942988,
0.2556602657,
-1.0882716179,
0.1538102329,
-0.3092163205,
-0.1483829021,
-0.5452525616,
-0.436996758,
0.6117526293,
0.307818383,
-0.5030204058,
0.2020930946,
-0.2546449602,
0.6202446818,
0.8358220458,
0.2537884116,
0.3695767224,
0.1184601635,
0.2419885397,
-0.1986628473,
-0.7567899227,
-0.5205634832,
1.5064458847,
0.277713269,
0.735740304,
0.0004095691,
0.495827347,
0.1643948704,
0.4244073331,
-0.6873542666,
0.364785552,
-0.1290892065,
-0.4870844185,
-0.3184773624,
-0.5701658726,
-0.8754654527,
0.3156512678,
0.0563026033,
-0.4280306399,
0.44842273,
0.158677265,
-0.6220722795,
0.0978723839,
-0.837054491,
0.859508276,
-0.1089354828,
-0.230945155,
-0.118282035,
-0.5407671928,
0.5529578328,
-0.4704459906,
0.2222808897,
-0.2516330779,
-0.0769320652,
0.6582372785,
-0.6121127605,
0.84049052,
-0.0420496985,
-0.3190434277,
0.3754434884,
0.0515532643,
0.4820695817,
-0.0190731473,
-0.3566097915,
0.1554346085,
0.4138563275,
-0.2926768064,
-0.5429919362,
0.6243897676,
-0.7328751087,
-0.5183624625,
-0.3665398657,
-0.5847958326,
-0.3738606572,
0.0675816461,
0.4357062876,
0.6168212891,
0.1321212053,
0.2944720387,
0.7735131979,
-0.1114399508,
0.4696416557,
0.5128829479,
0.2552025914,
-0.7376754284,
0.7170042992,
0.1977349073,
0.7226077914,
0.3860075176,
-0.000482216,
-0.2786480784,
-0.5201611519,
-0.108306542,
0.4774831533,
-0.9435563087,
-0.5308200717,
-0.1293195188,
-0.0700041875,
-0.4593088031,
0.0949934646,
-0.2479574084,
-0.5019477606,
-0.7243527174,
0.1884569824,
0.213223055,
0.2048079967,
-0.0524250045,
0.9267727733,
-0.7544486523,
0.008143791,
0.2808902562,
0.0934512243,
-0.2162508965,
-0.7748456001,
-0.6412123442,
0.4160279334,
-0.4183841348,
-0.9006697536,
0.2171316743,
0.5801541805,
0.4186396599,
0.7083572745,
0.0879776627,
0.942959249,
-0.2079298645,
0.519826889,
0.0330027156,
-1.0198043585,
0.3999690115,
-0.0518196635,
0.5323223472,
0.6103492379,
0.2298564017,
-0.3773952127,
-0.3203290701,
-0.4570680261,
-0.6003376245,
0.6222355962,
-0.1757930517,
0.0634149313,
0.2720292509,
0.5978547931,
0.0304609742,
0.6160833836,
-0.9138327837,
-0.2301633358,
0.0463740826,
-0.0587042533,
-0.1093702167,
-0.3957567215,
-0.2238989472,
-0.0735618919,
0.6412662864,
-0.2197450846,
0.1213133708,
-0.2692866921,
-0.3542421162,
-0.6236963868,
0.1062715426,
0.3388964832,
0.9238363504,
-0.2024893463,
0.1705934256,
0.0420133211,
-0.2541334629,
0.1239868626,
0.0765342638,
-0.2358742505,
-0.2459564209,
0.2776450515,
0.8643639684,
0.4745904207,
-0.7173160911,
0.6438623071,
0.2589897811,
-0.1029881984,
-0.3910286427,
0.2443891764,
-0.4736277759,
0.4821614325,
0.3445622623,
0.0989223123,
-0.0522209182,
-0.5615397096,
-0.1823142916,
0.7876749039,
-0.3187351227,
-0.3676625192,
0.5859401822,
-0.2364866436,
-0.1809030324,
0.4956270754,
-0.1199323386,
-0.5544765592,
0.3439359367,
0.2939530313,
0.6090481877,
-0.3008059263,
0.0944146663,
0.055821307,
0.4842637479,
-0.1880324185,
0.1099142432,
-0.2218798548,
-0.5914828181,
-0.7650664449,
-0.4292282164,
-0.3814038932,
0.0727692917,
-0.6402878165,
0.2805148065,
-0.2243645191,
-0.4216028154,
-0.3992305696,
0.0759196579,
-0.5188299417,
0.1624965519,
-0.0553146973,
0.5571577549,
-0.8717192411,
0.7294754386,
0.6113626361,
-0.0339030847,
-0.4748971164,
-0.1364247948,
-0.1646775156,
-0.7517377734,
0.6523785591,
0.1472222656,
0.1854526699,
0.4930447936,
-0.3270842135,
-1.1459838152,
1.1056603193,
0.7984133959,
-0.3200240731,
-0.1181865484,
0.49300313,
0.6160244942,
0.1995186657,
0.4069723189,
0.8838481903,
0.330851078,
-0.0697553083,
-0.941791296,
-0.0473671481,
0.1150082424,
0.111504972,
0.7456015944,
-0.6020022035,
0.8933073282,
-0.0359114483,
-0.2470803857,
0.1559879482,
0.2158425301,
0.4730875194,
0.1087912098,
0.222915411,
0.9042094946,
0.4031493366,
-0.4110537767,
0.7073195577,
-0.1587358266,
0.129035309,
0.7456177473,
-0.1434553266,
0.7746809721,
0.586155653,
-0.4519555271,
0.2936126888,
0.7988510728,
0.2379433364,
0.7073966265,
0.5060356855,
-0.4886299372,
-0.3480101824,
0.1287480742,
-0.6241593361,
0.1643818468,
0.4235372543,
-0.4125032723,
-0.3418620527,
0.1207514554,
0.0727430135,
-0.3061207831,
-0.4112182856,
0.5225262046,
0.228802368,
-0.5513188839,
0.7799677253,
-0.1845496893,
0.4128943086,
-0.5904904008,
0.0882445127,
-0.276023984,
0.3678934872,
-0.0689782575,
-0.2697446942,
0.0060868752,
-0.4948554635,
-0.0556153953,
-0.2218364924,
0.3738389015,
-0.180295527,
-0.2937178016,
-0.1356913894,
0.6447995305,
0.2309877425,
-0.6609275341,
-0.4603771865,
0.1309487075,
0.0522508211,
-0.2451871783,
0.4892448187,
0.6956141591,
-0.2580989003,
0.5250285864,
0.6892743707,
0.0603883155,
0.3379274011,
-0.0601064675,
0.8376463056,
-0.4579644203,
-0.3272202909,
-0.7478252649,
0.4556649625,
0.3602929115,
-0.2433167994,
0.7780051827,
0.5074939728,
0.7814251184,
0.1557202041,
0.3691572249,
0.5418993235,
0.2788018286,
-0.4892136455,
0.5241605639,
-0.5765629411,
0.5846045613,
0.0255340561,
-1.1167217493,
-0.565197587,
0.3143113554,
-0.6331288218,
0.2055398971,
0.670458138,
0.8424417377,
0.2908689678,
-0.3298637569,
0.5226909518,
-0.0845832378,
0.3081014752,
0.6671878695,
1.0794999599,
-0.708047688,
0.7200757861,
-0.3199980855,
-0.3287618458,
-0.4291656613,
-0.9144120216,
-0.8365861177,
-0.4320504665,
-0.5393121243,
-0.1765601337,
0.2314221114,
0.3828317821,
0.7143448591,
-0.6533587575,
-0.1145807505,
-0.1530429274,
-0.0028849724,
-0.2052145004,
-0.2293991596,
0.4384474158,
-0.2931866348,
-0.7600903511,
0.2576505542,
0.2673862875,
0.3138470054,
-0.2662789822,
-0.0208578408,
0.312808454,
0.055760663,
0.5231412053,
0.377816081,
-0.6926522851,
-0.006295695,
-0.1367678493,
0.0723398849,
0.214466691,
0.8259762526,
-1.3173474073,
0.3701396585,
0.2519477606,
0.1990346014,
0.2943749726,
-0.0085337739,
0.4616122842,
-0.7061852217,
0.3514200151,
0.305367589,
0.1588439047,
0.2365131974,
-0.0334846489,
0.4888754785,
0.2267970741,
-0.7554216385,
-1.3570910692,
0.2069556266,
-0.3520688713,
0.0900030881,
0.9880512357,
-0.1188612059,
-0.0631505102,
0.1860296428,
-0.0590737611,
0.3003858328,
-0.1447836906,
0.4653957784,
0.6002995968,
-0.0585230887,
-0.3629315197,
-0.5065575242,
0.6598055959,
0.6852017045,
-0.6865677238,
0.0784876719,
0.6004805565,
0.1025206894,
-0.0027709166,
0.3313368261,
-0.3020550609,
0.5175426006,
-0.1717795581,
-0.2591059804,
0.0152650476,
0.1328247935,
-0.659466207,
-0.0058752559,
0.3850164413,
-0.1912633777
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20833v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20833v1
|
That's Optional: A Contemporary Exploration of "that" Omission in English Subordinate Clauses
| 2024-05-31T14:23:30 | 2024-05-31T14:23:30 |
Ella Rabinovich
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The Uniform Information Density (UID) hypothesis posits that speakers
optimize the communicative properties of their utterances by avoiding spikes in
information, thereby maintaining a relatively uniform information profile over
time. This paper investigates the impact of UID principles on syntactic
reduction, specifically focusing on the optional omission of the connector
"that" in English subordinate clauses. Building upon previous research, we
extend our investigation to a larger corpus of written English, utilize
contemporary large language models (LLMs) and extend the information-uniformity
principles by the notion of entropy, to estimate the UID manifestations in the
usecase of syntactic reduction choices.
|
[
-0.4494099319,
-0.5770401359,
0.6625361443,
-0.1661200523,
-0.1104878783,
-0.3605997264,
-0.1575413197,
-0.2666079104,
0.5059085488,
0.4776867628,
-0.4575442672,
-0.341622293,
-0.0791893527,
0.0602001175,
-0.3249582052,
0.7663120031,
-0.2372656614,
-0.2375531346,
-0.5325648189,
-0.3849632144,
-0.2111454457,
-0.4866030812,
-0.5304991007,
-0.0635584444,
0.7297940254,
0.4596082866,
0.7681538463,
0.674161613,
0.6212101579,
0.3068076968,
-0.0508291647,
-0.2997587025,
-0.1647428423,
0.4485813081,
-0.3915480971,
-0.6570653915,
-0.19951801,
0.2850024402,
0.9926249981,
1.224665761,
-0.1130460948,
0.0306009091,
0.1342245787,
0.953928709,
-1.1932184696,
0.225596115,
-0.3479168117,
-0.0982231721,
-0.2148780525,
-0.1969262213,
-0.5409852862,
-0.1319745332,
-0.0283922162,
-0.4616776407,
0.2228564769,
0.059226878,
0.9552957416,
0.7046530247,
-0.6039091945,
0.2268007696,
-0.8020983338,
0.4484966397,
-0.2312836498,
0.4162421525,
0.7628682256,
-0.0222130865,
-0.1646562964,
-0.5024499893,
-0.4856760204,
-0.030775236,
-0.1439641267,
0.3746707141,
-0.1902041435,
0.5827910304,
0.1473487169,
0.3233159781,
-0.4361380041,
0.1202742532,
-0.4114411175,
0.4358253479,
0.2662481368,
0.231754601,
0.1354351789,
-0.3303099275,
0.102947332,
0.2584905922,
-0.712911427,
0.5072722435,
0.1791799963,
-0.0111566717,
-0.1901648492,
0.5765721202,
-0.1266876459,
0.1098532155,
0.0680748001,
-0.0427458882,
0.0863571391,
-0.2338840514,
-0.3058985174,
-0.2161079794,
0.5064867735,
0.2624674439,
0.0380630083,
-0.4326720536,
0.1609879136,
0.1262292117,
0.098276712,
-0.3842517138,
-0.2284702957,
0.4713283479,
-0.493925333,
-0.0318791308,
0.0526523851,
0.1352239251,
-0.0018785745,
-0.200720951,
-0.127145052,
-0.4893012047,
-0.2946506143,
-0.1113896221,
-0.8056513071,
0.0508002974,
0.0898429528,
-0.7663237453,
0.5579997301,
0.6341284513,
0.5619866252,
-0.250317663,
-0.3030463755,
-0.3607885838,
0.7048124671,
-0.7223322988,
0.6991624832,
-0.4286450744,
-0.3122076988,
-0.2916909158,
0.1311530471,
-0.2223141491,
-0.3591019809,
0.6676580906,
-0.1342752129,
0.1432268769,
-0.2971481085,
-0.7616141438,
-0.4038208723,
-0.211504966,
-0.8440880179,
0.5001088381,
0.1949388981,
-0.7808432579,
0.5701435804,
-0.0279860198,
-0.4967567325,
0.2982909977,
-0.3861045837,
-0.2564619482,
0.3506163061,
-0.4227579534,
0.0867450833,
-0.4328651428,
0.4011708796,
-0.6155607104,
-0.2493576109,
0.0138992025,
-0.3878893554,
0.8783789277,
0.1296429932,
-0.3140614927,
-0.2843545973,
-0.9332512021,
0.1379373223,
-0.2243100405,
-0.416531682,
-0.8496422172,
0.5356326103,
-0.1817732155,
-0.1335336864,
-0.0149128148,
-0.4734780192,
0.1842193156,
-0.4040414691,
0.025395168,
0.6271531582,
0.1702519208,
1.2046179771,
-0.4739052355,
0.3660158515,
-0.2427441031,
0.2286171019,
0.2504288554,
-0.4726403058,
-0.8062904477,
-0.7414366603,
0.0519350432,
0.7418088913,
-0.6488496065,
0.7811476588,
-0.0311262608,
-0.1630753279,
-0.3903377652,
0.1729194373,
0.3681635857,
0.1908371449,
-0.0073037054,
0.3159537613,
-0.9463607669,
-1.2355273962,
-0.2267827988,
-0.6566749811,
-0.0069407723,
-0.1259071082,
0.2630133629,
-0.0779689923,
1.2627080679,
-0.0854685754,
-0.2816052437,
-0.2509566844,
-0.1504606158,
0.3052077293,
0.5844883323,
0.6541950107,
-0.5499851704,
-0.1893973947,
-0.0304023698,
-0.9175299406,
-0.1613599807,
-0.1266124696,
0.1958593279,
0.3214554787,
0.7574105859,
-0.9718183875,
0.7573860288,
0.3685619533,
-0.0743681341,
0.2985627651,
-0.2239484042,
-0.0672464296,
-0.8357695341,
-0.1456281692,
-0.0489003919,
-0.205997467,
-0.5243551731,
0.4484404624,
0.3724446297,
0.1174059883,
-0.1880529076,
0.4907093644,
-0.7033435702,
0.2935381234,
-0.0720991865,
-0.1502580345,
-0.000322779,
0.1870552748,
-0.0515643507,
0.4324378073,
0.4215555489,
-0.7346616387,
-0.1258231848,
-0.0736029968,
-0.2384038568,
0.2856885493,
-0.3439578116,
-0.3421628773,
-0.7380304337,
0.326959461,
-1.0217903852,
-0.1030358747,
0.0555507578,
-0.0808532164,
-0.0963226631,
-0.1927085966,
-0.2850942314,
-0.2859509885,
-0.4689448476,
0.3491070271,
0.7774299383,
-0.3467518091,
0.4251796901,
0.4507912993,
-0.2484101504,
-0.2256731838,
-0.9436187744,
0.014618475,
-0.1150418296,
-0.6072137356,
0.6865109801,
-0.3323510289,
-0.9454145432,
0.1571076661,
-0.1531849056,
-0.3983136714,
0.1899615973,
0.3006360829,
0.0624804012,
-0.2845078111,
0.3832319379,
0.1852739304,
-0.0488977805,
0.0544777475,
0.1370385289,
0.1765768379,
0.2071085721,
-0.209286809,
-0.6964530349,
0.8214642406,
0.276933223,
0.4783190787,
0.8446324468,
0.2181074917,
-0.3194945455,
-0.2226721495,
-0.6586534381,
0.2221376747,
-0.467314899,
-0.0383283794,
-0.3863382339,
-0.6090672016,
0.5331380963,
0.6065933108,
-0.0852298886,
0.4524423778,
-0.0669892952,
-0.4766976237,
0.869736135,
0.5838673115,
-0.0421632677,
0.5801023841,
-0.1471266001,
0.2642695308,
-0.5708009601,
0.1754833609,
-0.7567330599,
-0.0241253022,
-0.8872020245,
-0.1295930594,
0.3540388644,
0.1806514263,
-0.2241501212,
-0.0410235301,
0.0287986286,
0.8076158762,
0.5588604212,
0.0975152105,
-0.0080657462,
-0.2763058245,
0.1483491808,
-0.1067560613,
-0.7266511321,
-0.0581488349,
0.5988940597,
0.0741563141,
0.7990611196,
0.3942842185,
0.9556618929,
0.1059630066,
-0.2465003282,
-0.719106257,
0.5440227389,
-0.2191774398,
-0.1442392617,
-0.2711567581,
-0.522796154,
-1.0692868233,
0.1670570225,
0.0766714215,
-0.7295433283,
0.3889244795,
0.0958043486,
-0.1294088364,
0.1422082037,
-1.222160697,
0.3095330298,
0.3026272357,
-0.2785083055,
-0.3366217613,
-0.2577795982,
0.3420816362,
0.2503350675,
0.1918013841,
-0.0486400202,
-0.4010194242,
0.6983657479,
-0.853726089,
0.9659639001,
-0.0619446561,
0.1801975965,
0.3807578385,
0.0991746187,
0.7889045477,
-0.1521429867,
-0.0924210921,
-0.1157708913,
-0.0006720645,
-0.4034869075,
-0.3589094281,
0.6439062953,
-0.6032912731,
-1.0762358904,
-0.2532703876,
-0.64925915,
0.1083023474,
-0.0404291339,
0.5443269014,
0.3757528663,
-0.1233999655,
0.5143496394,
0.352892518,
0.249363333,
0.9223781228,
0.227678597,
0.2076760828,
-0.2085259706,
0.4568855166,
0.7462436557,
0.2258786857,
0.4403850734,
0.2120669931,
-0.2302693278,
-0.5321388841,
0.1398873627,
0.2900618613,
-1.1065014601,
0.0311608743,
-0.7319758534,
-0.3343197405,
-0.8584734797,
-0.4443621635,
-0.0487888046,
-0.7933342457,
-0.3296524584,
-0.3679359257,
0.2887329757,
0.5805888176,
-0.0581211299,
0.1701131761,
-0.6113882661,
0.5603329539,
0.0643453822,
0.24943313,
-0.2427121699,
-0.2164321244,
-0.0572839342,
-0.2976863682,
0.0187183265,
-0.6322633624,
0.2083377391,
0.4367177784,
1.1796910763,
0.311127156,
0.5329786539,
0.703512311,
-0.5198470354,
0.7431772947,
0.4283167422,
-0.8917692304,
0.3357020319,
-0.4690867662,
0.5629409552,
0.567196846,
0.3681992888,
-0.3453804553,
-1.0397434235,
-1.0997741222,
-0.8887971044,
0.194475174,
0.3105432987,
-0.2287393212,
-0.5533313155,
0.2349527627,
0.2349094003,
0.0648389086,
-0.7991347909,
-0.3542699814,
0.618093431,
-0.1011903957,
0.0907810554,
-0.2740009427,
0.1773994714,
-0.5577424169,
0.4234355986,
0.2624702752,
0.0468393154,
0.1989048272,
-0.1834032089,
0.171354875,
0.2297569662,
0.2029381096,
0.617802918,
-0.2766878009,
0.2805339992,
0.019882828,
-0.2441836149,
0.2402405441,
-0.6082893014,
-0.4324845672,
0.3702694476,
0.2191953957,
0.468814522,
0.0901872069,
-0.1242005304,
0.4964968264,
0.161757648,
-0.2023817152,
-0.7397412062,
0.2022660226,
-0.1862941831,
-0.0163075514,
0.4576057494,
0.6647211909,
0.3306508064,
-0.6960893273,
0.2934310734,
0.4766601026,
-0.4197977483,
-0.3016763926,
0.4094237685,
0.20578973,
-0.1648287624,
0.1880017519,
-0.2555599809,
0.1379529238,
0.5922683477,
0.3311989903,
1.1558369398,
-0.4225187004,
0.1875439137,
0.2348425388,
0.6203463674,
-0.1755579263,
0.151673615,
-0.2257656753,
-0.6537011266,
-0.4407479167,
0.074943237,
-0.2882984877,
-0.1328079104,
-0.832482934,
0.4186575413,
-0.7297525406,
-0.2448824793,
0.1295681745,
-0.7298312783,
-0.554100275,
-0.0509473868,
-0.1971825212,
0.7897506952,
-0.6089177132,
0.8261602521,
-0.0107924659,
-0.6553305387,
-0.5704649687,
0.1853340566,
0.0732277706,
-0.4702950418,
0.4657401145,
-0.173134774,
-0.2476868033,
-0.2880654335,
-0.5404220223,
-0.9703345895,
0.5214217901,
0.5656370521,
-0.3946059048,
-0.1018374264,
-0.1094030514,
0.3343097866,
-0.1724507213,
0.1724538803,
0.7263092399,
0.4620809257,
-0.2719942331,
-0.7947154045,
-0.0554315634,
-0.4502480328,
-0.0377362743,
0.4782389104,
-0.5050205588,
1.0957449675,
-0.2681444585,
-0.5041297674,
0.2571475804,
0.2280741781,
-0.3045567572,
0.1508676559,
0.4439045787,
0.2548805773,
0.949108243,
0.0333180018,
1.4745415449,
0.060461618,
0.0038752465,
1.0049408674,
-0.2769509554,
0.9415113926,
0.7717183232,
0.054490041,
0.3862217367,
0.4580034018,
0.5298441648,
0.7545952201,
-0.0196710974,
-0.384493351,
-0.1869051456,
-0.2218290418,
-0.2576500773,
0.5153559446,
0.3820092082,
-0.2111478895,
-0.0766083151,
0.0654556677,
0.1176875085,
0.0460286401,
-0.4406943321,
0.971054256,
-0.1294304579,
-0.8694116473,
1.2013067007,
-0.2296132743,
0.3267292678,
-0.3801189959,
0.1015558019,
-0.4178587198,
0.160328716,
-0.332987994,
-0.7406159043,
0.4621883333,
-0.3314478993,
-0.6456561089,
-0.2201700956,
0.4918641746,
-0.2727470696,
-0.3697823286,
0.5019991994,
0.4362126291,
0.0711898655,
0.0070968578,
-0.2618422508,
-0.4077195525,
0.0094644194,
-0.1634911597,
0.1809183955,
0.5079671741,
-0.3013245165,
0.7500383258,
0.2979204357,
0.3723811209,
-0.1729670614,
0.3226054609,
0.7058582902,
-0.8931248784,
-0.8245675564,
-0.5603189468,
0.3703426421,
-0.1753334105,
-0.1753067821,
0.7446466088,
0.4505425096,
0.5986184478,
0.0202975105,
1.218934536,
-0.0268376302,
0.4942479134,
-0.730037272,
0.4744126201,
-0.4990856349,
0.240259409,
-0.3985355198,
-0.7146787643,
-0.311783433,
0.3373018503,
-0.2969146073,
-0.1103573069,
1.522550106,
0.6043633819,
0.2142266482,
0.0853152126,
0.6275145411,
0.1291258335,
0.0701554641,
0.0419322029,
0.7493975759,
-0.5333409905,
0.6163665652,
-0.3132428825,
-0.1262757927,
-0.0883277729,
-0.5638328195,
-0.6568441391,
-0.9971333742,
-0.4849223495,
-0.3124717176,
0.0987387449,
0.7989374995,
0.3921526372,
-0.5561617017,
-0.3428015709,
-0.196227476,
0.2665069401,
-0.30713889,
-0.1676277518,
0.1375254095,
-0.5813314915,
-0.4926289916,
0.4620629251,
0.5290209651,
0.1781373322,
0.2410595268,
0.1366900355,
-0.1589628309,
0.0285344832,
0.4327353537,
0.2570468485,
-0.7780561447,
-0.6169647574,
-0.1533236355,
-0.3027905226,
0.182932198,
0.8044368029,
-0.6722208261,
0.0330207609,
0.8302032351,
0.2607267499,
0.1820349991,
-0.1810339242,
0.688308835,
-1.1156029701,
0.9229906797,
0.086363107,
0.6686618924,
-0.0433235317,
-0.4852291048,
0.552534163,
0.3793502748,
-0.3200620413,
-0.547832191,
0.1529849917,
-0.9802421331,
-0.5974465013,
1.3696328402,
0.0638779476,
-0.76945889,
-0.6333541274,
0.0045093074,
-0.2966683805,
-0.54450804,
0.5088850856,
0.6940878034,
0.1115822643,
-0.6060833335,
-0.3209844232,
0.5135966539,
0.616838038,
-0.5831108093,
0.016165616,
0.6494248509,
0.0338195302,
0.1078902483,
1.0517716408,
0.4991063774,
0.6542760134,
0.4192794263,
0.2023364305,
0.4928505719,
-0.2449463606,
-0.0333092809,
0.2224086821,
0.0732422471,
-0.3355184495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20830v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20830v1
|
Self-Augmented Preference Optimization: Off-Policy Paradigms for Language Model Alignment
| 2024-05-31T14:21:04 | 2024-05-31T14:21:04 |
Yueqin Yin, Zhendong Wang, Yujia Xie, Weizhu Chen, Mingyuan Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Traditional language model alignment methods, such as Direct Preference
Optimization (DPO), are limited by their dependence on static, pre-collected
paired preference data, which hampers their adaptability and practical
applicability. To overcome this limitation, we introduce Self-Augmented
Preference Optimization (SAPO), an effective and scalable training paradigm
that does not require existing paired data. Building on the self-play concept,
which autonomously generates negative responses, we further incorporate an
off-policy learning pipeline to enhance data exploration and exploitation.
Specifically, we employ an Exponential Moving Average (EMA) model in
conjunction with a replay buffer to enable dynamic updates of response
segments, effectively integrating real-time feedback with insights from
historical data. Our comprehensive evaluations of the LLaMA3-8B and Mistral-7B
models across benchmarks, including the Open LLM Leaderboard, IFEval,
AlpacaEval 2.0, and MT-Bench, demonstrate that SAPO matches or surpasses
established offline contrastive baselines, such as DPO and Odds Ratio
Preference Optimization, and outperforms offline self-play methods like SPIN.
Our code is available at https://github.com/yinyueqin/SAPO
|
[
-0.1807909608,
-0.4306480289,
0.4997467399,
0.2637039125,
-0.1177881733,
0.2638606131,
-0.2825578749,
-0.1568894982,
0.4722224772,
0.7770013809,
-0.6276143193,
-0.1605871618,
-0.2993474901,
-0.1374142915,
-0.0649355054,
1.0071439743,
-0.0032273992,
0.0826577619,
-0.1091796085,
-0.1748115122,
-0.347446233,
-0.458456099,
-0.4525335133,
-0.0661857054,
0.2295445204,
0.6238119602,
0.4083795249,
0.8859505057,
0.2800486386,
0.289101094,
0.1699516326,
0.206809938,
-0.4377165437,
0.1919971704,
-0.054232236,
-0.2166892886,
-0.7133637071,
-0.0289872326,
0.4791478515,
0.0877427012,
-0.5450977683,
0.2080835849,
-0.1071254089,
0.7446183562,
-0.6204153895,
-0.0941375792,
-0.7405641675,
-0.043839816,
-0.07216838,
-0.2134085745,
-0.2863386273,
-0.3814228773,
0.2382325232,
-0.7232267261,
-0.1166348159,
0.3178533614,
0.7842604518,
0.4517008662,
-0.2692096531,
-0.2113633603,
-0.7778475881,
1.0077366829,
-0.7969629765,
0.335462749,
0.3649540842,
0.2059130371,
-0.1014735401,
-0.0665345341,
-0.4952592552,
-0.2055834234,
0.2393496186,
0.1828587651,
-0.0262803771,
0.1650860906,
-0.1448810846,
0.3194841743,
-0.4744423032,
0.4392043948,
-0.1187489927,
0.0011555931,
0.5766464472,
-0.0243394207,
0.3336987495,
-0.0852071121,
-0.6269490123,
0.0170988441,
-0.7877609134,
0.0679845884,
0.485218972,
0.4076410532,
-0.0213830285,
0.3896070123,
-0.1485083252,
0.765948236,
0.4180413485,
-0.0131810131,
0.2882673442,
-0.1328684837,
-0.0400781222,
0.3228574693,
0.8076423407,
0.2318102419,
-0.1454086006,
-0.194669351,
-0.2329443544,
-0.1310310066,
0.2489375323,
-0.4015944898,
0.0927958041,
0.4123452306,
-0.0871609747,
-0.6038016081,
-0.4469281733,
-0.8166936636,
-0.1449993849,
-0.455430299,
0.3674179912,
-0.1749611944,
-0.2183928639,
-0.0425760224,
0.1912893057,
0.1579515487,
0.2281455398,
-1.5274224281,
0.4591995478,
0.5892093182,
0.7565265894,
-0.3534716964,
-0.4197849929,
-0.4663379192,
0.2281919569,
-0.3441348374,
0.6926075816,
-0.5242725015,
-0.1460002363,
-0.2710183263,
-0.3926943541,
0.0516045429,
-0.3654356301,
0.5361377597,
-0.5288178325,
0.3371168971,
0.0065032993,
-0.5214243531,
0.1351954937,
0.2795715332,
-0.591622889,
1.4984834194,
0.1393577904,
-0.3360446095,
0.4247140288,
-0.6520707607,
-0.0967206657,
-0.3736074269,
-0.2648508251,
-0.462903142,
0.0717485398,
0.3274676502,
0.1774949133,
-0.3870175779,
0.3028872907,
-0.5380878448,
-0.1272665113,
-0.1504538506,
0.0099182809,
0.512814939,
0.1239577234,
-0.5772334933,
0.2967613935,
-0.9415290952,
-0.0418859236,
0.2040363252,
-0.0616892166,
-0.5131789446,
0.2880855501,
-0.327121973,
0.6411172748,
0.4809800982,
-0.796397388,
0.342312485,
-0.514277637,
0.4577400088,
1.1058366299,
-0.4384177625,
0.583545208,
0.1032277569,
0.5633285642,
-0.2455394715,
0.3874309361,
0.1074207798,
-0.0687685981,
-0.6150386333,
-0.3835186064,
0.2909500301,
0.5159370899,
-0.2812540531,
0.6416323185,
-0.3751606345,
-0.2592778802,
-0.7377656698,
0.3766849935,
0.2982249558,
0.8505582809,
0.4790003896,
-0.1013590619,
-0.6669773459,
-0.879737556,
-0.0685936064,
-0.2068847716,
0.325065732,
0.6068616509,
-0.1102124453,
0.0274607502,
1.2571438551,
-0.5038740039,
-0.3136548698,
-0.2635969222,
-0.0111403009,
0.0200648122,
0.352599889,
0.5419769883,
-0.4713128209,
-0.591478467,
0.0626086295,
-0.5011464953,
-0.2185970843,
-0.0441140495,
-0.1297368258,
0.4148905873,
0.1641511321,
0.0257791784,
-0.1599749029,
1.0878144503,
0.1097747907,
0.1309055388,
-0.3884095252,
0.0772423521,
-0.9748343825,
0.0328215845,
-0.1308716387,
-0.1504178792,
-0.6540505886,
-0.1949060708,
0.0454861075,
-0.1174584851,
-0.432374686,
0.7979242802,
-0.5633364916,
-0.0873598158,
-0.4224487841,
0.3371937871,
-0.0514072962,
0.6414088011,
0.3335833549,
0.7634216547,
0.5273637176,
-0.4640904963,
0.0908773392,
0.1838532835,
0.0155663751,
0.0292258654,
-0.4723315835,
0.3916755915,
0.089820765,
0.1500421017,
-0.8421194553,
0.1712345183,
0.1389190853,
-0.2009339184,
0.4472827911,
-0.3805466294,
-0.1203787997,
-0.1010289863,
-0.5782698989,
0.4753835201,
0.4880366027,
-0.8844161034,
0.5351385474,
0.7346796393,
-0.0128684584,
-0.9781093001,
-0.2539047003,
-0.0863983706,
-0.3548995256,
-0.2426273823,
0.3130622506,
0.1005954221,
0.0007309736,
-0.4124258459,
-0.0845843926,
0.0788618475,
0.0440102406,
-0.0735209361,
0.5762645602,
-0.0180999357,
-0.0331726335,
0.2027158439,
-0.1631169021,
-0.2372603565,
-0.1218207181,
0.6226770282,
-0.0636849627,
-0.0996629521,
-0.0137222735,
0.0049822563,
0.3493890464,
-0.3070781231,
0.4183520377,
0.118734315,
0.0183779597,
-0.1286537945,
-0.5639720559,
-0.0725892037,
-0.5023367405,
0.1491472125,
-0.318592906,
-0.8202446699,
0.3518087864,
-0.0917125344,
0.0561017022,
0.3016660511,
0.4390539527,
-0.1834477931,
1.1680885553,
0.5249993801,
-0.3550439477,
0.7531721592,
-0.0241294913,
0.1808056831,
-0.9826393127,
0.0859215558,
-0.2819574773,
-0.0937499553,
-0.8660541773,
-0.2298650593,
0.071273461,
0.1355512887,
-0.2433613986,
0.547465682,
-0.5561925769,
0.3114070892,
0.5142090321,
0.0519916937,
0.1437773556,
-0.1602015197,
0.063380979,
-0.1649100631,
-0.825104773,
-0.5531833172,
1.4204443693,
0.4070711434,
0.9167268276,
0.0806861222,
1.0617468357,
0.3247024715,
0.1747355759,
-0.6320524812,
0.3240573108,
-0.1598056108,
-0.6780127287,
-0.5816655755,
-0.3155696392,
-0.7851594687,
0.2208969742,
-0.2249700427,
-0.6762493849,
0.2689257562,
0.8305797577,
-0.4182942212,
0.1979893595,
-0.591178,
0.8725197315,
-0.8039131165,
-0.425355047,
-0.2149030864,
-0.6271754503,
0.2175751626,
-0.1923356503,
0.1628202796,
-0.4042594135,
-0.2028407753,
0.435538739,
-0.2601925731,
0.6993482709,
-0.0560871661,
-0.1119338274,
0.2421556115,
0.0005453547,
0.6274546385,
-0.2907783985,
-0.045333527,
0.267224282,
-0.0437242128,
-0.4565618634,
-0.8448348641,
0.9680882096,
-0.8964203596,
-0.6266505122,
-0.5365270972,
-0.1666725725,
-0.3414221406,
0.1103439033,
-0.155031085,
0.2926523089,
-0.4903081059,
-0.2868587673,
0.5261914134,
0.0186624415,
0.4176065326,
0.5983174443,
-0.3253417015,
-0.5145518184,
1.1893823147,
0.0328820422,
0.4669343233,
0.5092383027,
0.6217131019,
-0.5207879543,
-0.4712986648,
-0.9568049312,
0.1680405885,
-0.2382035106,
0.0755827725,
-0.4812581837,
0.2123861164,
-0.5375141501,
-0.0552642532,
-0.7037357092,
-0.6312822104,
-0.238396585,
0.0146561489,
0.2085822374,
0.52222085,
-0.1409145892,
0.2085804194,
-0.6121308208,
-0.0712440163,
0.1220564023,
0.3525573313,
-0.1009469107,
-0.657343924,
-0.3139865696,
-0.0624741465,
-0.2648834288,
-0.7909223437,
0.4278842211,
0.1751230508,
0.586338222,
0.4896484613,
-0.0019970401,
0.5423754454,
-0.8213101029,
0.5207870603,
0.0315876566,
-0.9847236276,
0.866994381,
-0.4614326954,
-0.0463911369,
0.7147780657,
0.4591418505,
-0.3410708606,
-0.0516859889,
-0.6015614271,
-0.8050103784,
0.9003324509,
-0.0944663361,
0.1563387662,
-0.021961702,
0.2788398564,
0.1272688359,
0.229276672,
-0.6722874045,
-0.3164484203,
-0.3528130054,
-0.1896010041,
-0.0578042679,
-0.2222691029,
-0.2409322113,
0.078131929,
0.9648300409,
-0.4096467495,
0.0991601199,
-0.0619329102,
-0.0894328728,
-0.0436149538,
0.258641541,
0.7307953238,
0.5549627542,
-0.4982520938,
-0.1816426367,
0.1292012781,
-0.1594073772,
0.324947387,
-0.0048089218,
-0.1468694061,
-0.3853897452,
-0.2118035108,
0.9579647183,
0.2590503693,
-0.6873543262,
0.3675477505,
0.1555684209,
0.2289072573,
-0.1765496135,
0.0445080027,
-0.3092407584,
-0.2007948011,
-0.0094474126,
-0.1580849588,
0.3058871627,
-0.6605451107,
0.0081315851,
0.4659976065,
-0.4921523035,
-0.3450527787,
0.4751375914,
0.3954274058,
-0.2562636137,
0.1855795383,
0.1218607947,
-0.5321272016,
0.394133985,
0.7968805432,
0.8629103899,
-0.3973595202,
0.2586712241,
0.3041142225,
0.1974153966,
-0.0736085027,
0.1257504076,
-0.2878604233,
-0.9931562543,
-0.3605691195,
-0.3179074526,
-0.672149241,
-0.0386729352,
-0.7571371198,
0.472302407,
-0.5682294965,
0.011463616,
-0.2318399101,
-0.1094516665,
-0.2024219483,
0.3117748797,
0.0991496518,
0.437633723,
-0.9195938706,
1.0162770748,
0.6163445711,
-0.4174972773,
-0.5577977896,
-0.1375677139,
0.0994190574,
-1.1697940826,
0.4956455529,
-0.2975977361,
-0.3569469154,
0.1273579448,
-0.2461412549,
-1.3922357559,
0.9308535457,
0.3628495634,
-0.6283125877,
-0.003039842,
-0.0615350418,
0.6216608286,
-0.4779628515,
0.5337066054,
0.6164817214,
0.096436061,
-0.0246326588,
-0.8930661678,
-0.0231517795,
0.254354924,
-0.0291367564,
0.5449341536,
-1.1388602257,
0.1827050596,
-0.0724213645,
0.1518575847,
-0.3465701342,
0.6146231294,
0.3343747556,
-0.085096091,
0.5517161489,
0.6929543018,
0.3160842657,
0.0935059264,
0.8746607304,
-0.6892340779,
0.4701301455,
1.4909710884,
-0.5089119077,
1.0648851395,
0.7210934758,
-0.1512693465,
0.454164505,
0.8393003345,
0.2287932336,
0.7409039736,
-0.0457562506,
-0.0847844183,
-0.2487233877,
0.0350537971,
-0.1421476752,
0.6523956656,
0.0941788256,
-0.2695294321,
-0.0756752044,
-0.179737255,
-0.0255209506,
0.1149323583,
-0.1437362432,
0.7949117422,
-0.1947907805,
-0.7419905066,
0.4154668748,
-0.1754024774,
0.6755397916,
-0.757851243,
-0.0048897234,
-0.2895074189,
0.0596697666,
-0.0580216348,
-0.474631995,
0.1627082825,
-0.1632985622,
-0.1364631355,
-0.3526683152,
0.4669664502,
-0.4966169,
-0.2118842602,
0.5071588755,
0.3318108916,
0.0014360256,
0.3365167379,
-0.9646007419,
-0.0578000098,
0.0627586991,
-0.2886004448,
0.5770602226,
-0.0412281752,
-0.1689813584,
0.6879477501,
0.5231097937,
0.1772890091,
0.1148727909,
0.0480869673,
0.6776378155,
-0.4320449233,
-0.5022717714,
-0.7755473256,
0.0640966594,
-0.0610706918,
-0.5825631618,
0.8048442006,
0.834723711,
0.8213848472,
0.1529948562,
0.5414504409,
0.0744861364,
0.6376655698,
-0.5418659449,
0.374129802,
-0.626003623,
0.256917119,
-0.296339035,
-0.9553584456,
0.0376865417,
0.3766840398,
-0.572568655,
-0.0219021849,
0.3534293771,
0.6412184238,
-0.112511836,
-0.1925631613,
0.2777253091,
-0.0923470259,
0.0935123563,
0.1129220277,
0.5821088552,
-0.3285228312,
0.2754590511,
-0.3540912867,
-0.4835813344,
-0.0998137817,
-1.06759727,
-0.6209766865,
-0.4265206754,
-0.2145901173,
-0.3135435581,
0.1612955034,
1.34372437,
0.7527199984,
-0.8589872122,
-0.6395996809,
-0.0058992272,
-0.004929163,
-0.1760917753,
-0.1796270013,
0.4150924087,
-0.4470802844,
-0.8675092459,
0.7098996639,
0.5111684203,
0.1302015781,
-0.4435138106,
-0.2026364058,
-0.4459950328,
0.3484369218,
0.4500809908,
0.7702870369,
-0.8057371974,
-0.1360345781,
0.1651176363,
-0.0474441312,
0.5268424153,
0.8705332279,
-0.6469789147,
0.8195092678,
0.4219022989,
0.7152581215,
0.6848912835,
0.2465231121,
0.8680769801,
-0.5509033203,
-0.0386067778,
0.2028021961,
0.1752942204,
0.2042149305,
-0.5456272364,
0.4749881625,
-0.0474761948,
-0.6707493067,
-0.8428797126,
0.0402960032,
-0.8393499851,
0.0862475112,
0.9754405022,
-0.1189772636,
-0.3213320374,
0.1604963094,
-0.1130979359,
-0.059016332,
-0.6673138142,
1.0239063501,
0.5868797898,
-0.6228827834,
-0.1355377585,
-0.2151438594,
0.7312954068,
0.8879551291,
-0.8192831874,
0.0254375488,
0.3393309712,
0.3747626245,
-0.0582074486,
0.8687012196,
0.0494971462,
0.0120001184,
-0.2813882232,
0.5143649578,
0.03431895,
-0.3557329476,
-0.7560674548,
-0.5420146585,
0.1405654848,
-0.3913842142
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20818v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20818v2
|
An iterated learning model of language change that mixes supervised and unsupervised learning
| 2024-05-31T14:14:01 | 2024-06-15T15:25:01 |
Jack Bunyan, Seth Bullock, Conor Houghton
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, nlin.AO, q-bio.PE
|
The iterated learning model is an agent-based model of language change in
which language is transmitted from a tutor to a pupil which itself becomes a
tutor to a new pupil, and so on. Languages that are stable, expressive, and
compositional arise spontaneously as a consequence of a language transmission
bottleneck. Previous models have implemented an agent's mapping from signals to
meanings using an artificial neural network decoder, but have relied on an
unrealistic and computationally expensive process of obversion to implement the
associated encoder, mapping from meanings to signals. Here, a new model is
presented in which both decoder and encoder are neural networks, trained
separately through supervised learning, and trained together through
unsupervised learning in the form of an autoencoder. This avoids the
substantial computational burden entailed in obversion and introduces a mixture
of supervised and unsupervised learning as observed during human development.
|
[
-0.0551282875,
-0.5609946251,
0.2244899869,
0.0567290857,
-0.2634928524,
0.3966620266,
-0.4126850367,
-0.3367620111,
0.201574564,
0.7777961493,
-0.4065301418,
-0.1301058233,
-0.6383085847,
-0.1466408074,
-0.6428980231,
0.8114985824,
-0.2243598551,
0.1005791947,
-0.1284228861,
0.1644219905,
-0.2289704233,
-0.2952102721,
-0.5968474746,
-0.8499299288,
0.2344783545,
0.2446092516,
0.5537580252,
0.875829041,
0.2222941816,
0.4263705909,
0.204007715,
-0.2656584382,
-0.2940572202,
0.2204070538,
-0.349140048,
-0.5090497136,
-0.0318021104,
0.1284269392,
0.6287024617,
1.2430945635,
-0.4107503295,
-0.0619195104,
0.1426326632,
0.8370882869,
-0.6078124046,
0.5111064315,
-0.6521410346,
-0.0474086218,
0.000232346,
-0.1766523421,
-0.5833204985,
-0.0681349337,
0.1319696754,
-0.2869733274,
0.1149756461,
-0.5271455646,
0.5212555528,
0.1577202082,
-0.4963896275,
-0.2643118799,
-0.934184432,
0.4585691988,
-0.4306488037,
0.5209930539,
0.1669301689,
0.3986007571,
-0.1346413046,
-0.7767771482,
-0.4850780666,
-0.2476110607,
-0.0003151638,
0.1863967478,
-0.1266002953,
-0.1379405558,
-0.4652870595,
0.2512527704,
-0.2938586473,
0.1283615083,
-0.6306297779,
0.0592839979,
0.7781690359,
0.1949333847,
0.2662332356,
0.1216360107,
-0.4322524369,
-0.4129011929,
-0.5204842687,
0.1896469146,
0.390870899,
0.5499110818,
-0.0260812715,
0.444037497,
-0.1389230192,
0.8461217284,
0.3282596469,
-0.0656613857,
0.2530823946,
0.0894232243,
-0.1201924831,
0.2236951888,
0.846940279,
0.1106969565,
0.4802030027,
-0.4803390205,
-0.4277962148,
0.4342152178,
0.3944485188,
-0.612573266,
-0.3878509104,
-0.0460892729,
-0.3695644438,
-0.3952928782,
0.1249945313,
-0.5577578545,
-0.2006033063,
-0.4797742963,
0.3447290361,
-0.4476112723,
-0.667927742,
0.2076616138,
0.0460016169,
0.0824511722,
0.0796943679,
-1.0633224249,
0.5354846716,
0.3265904784,
0.512591362,
-0.2732165456,
-0.8176469803,
0.0930417031,
-0.0219992939,
-0.6472988129,
0.7763616443,
-0.6380097866,
-0.2461322099,
0.1799506396,
0.1241278723,
-0.5749903917,
-0.513678968,
-0.4067746699,
-0.8863098025,
0.1922436655,
0.3352730572,
-0.7611435652,
-0.4124086797,
-0.0061964272,
-0.7668356299,
0.8570212126,
0.4102625847,
-0.3531927466,
0.263423264,
-0.6509935856,
-0.45055902,
0.2284320444,
-0.0045900987,
-0.3432009816,
0.0390495509,
-0.1702312976,
0.2931269705,
-0.3211279809,
0.503005147,
0.1456975639,
-0.2779280841,
0.5101106167,
-0.3584725857,
1.0412812233,
0.177518025,
-0.4046475291,
0.1640252769,
-0.8624105453,
-0.0723496079,
0.3309337795,
-0.646899581,
-0.265512377,
0.0844587237,
-0.1615330577,
0.3457147479,
0.3477732837,
-0.4996608198,
0.449472636,
-0.5875544548,
0.5223388076,
0.4726524651,
0.2076983899,
0.8745087981,
-0.3299531341,
0.1743534505,
0.3216331899,
0.1677301675,
-0.3213454485,
-0.3785119057,
-0.986350894,
0.0111046247,
0.0967343077,
0.3398230076,
-0.822258532,
0.2814503312,
-0.1366195679,
-0.3227437735,
-0.8674558401,
0.243061468,
0.0848998651,
0.2381128371,
0.3108480275,
-0.4301169217,
-0.4586692154,
-0.3814890683,
-0.0824566036,
-0.2500833869,
0.1447956413,
-0.3754718304,
0.6623296738,
-0.5165430307,
0.7934371233,
-0.0854571387,
-0.3998033106,
-0.3173707724,
0.2607568502,
-0.132195428,
0.547724843,
0.3233660161,
-0.5196303725,
-0.5103467107,
0.1463991553,
-0.6564038992,
0.0449133925,
-0.2691085339,
0.1326742768,
0.1740634739,
0.6609255672,
-0.2960054278,
0.4557904899,
0.5205626488,
-0.3885890543,
0.3568592966,
-0.4139083624,
-0.067448847,
-1.090323925,
-0.3482569456,
-0.4975584149,
0.014019548,
-0.6512377262,
0.2004322708,
0.1205601841,
0.2559556067,
-0.3546580672,
0.4571480751,
-0.852211535,
-0.2588270605,
-0.6607501507,
0.1159256175,
-0.1921946555,
0.5799363256,
0.1181936711,
0.5092759132,
1.0464798212,
-0.6490988731,
0.6870356798,
0.0237168223,
-0.0669762045,
0.2852390409,
-0.3291910887,
0.2424014658,
-0.2498439848,
-0.1933968663,
-0.7229505181,
-0.155020535,
0.1745010018,
-0.473274827,
0.3628852367,
-0.01732683,
-0.5045540333,
-0.2087225765,
0.0031633968,
0.3660302162,
0.4433470964,
-0.7120561004,
0.856087923,
0.179207623,
0.290982455,
-0.289833039,
-0.5889130831,
0.1458423436,
0.2176267654,
-0.4324033856,
0.2316752821,
0.0640722364,
-0.3073340952,
0.5752180815,
0.3229339123,
-0.440022409,
0.1575886309,
0.3041021824,
0.1987279654,
-0.3440082073,
0.1447957307,
0.0333315991,
-0.2217474431,
0.1055874601,
-0.5880969167,
0.6430826783,
0.0120108007,
-0.5342193842,
-0.2504797876,
0.5278611779,
0.633744061,
-0.5081215501,
1.0186941624,
0.1267253309,
-0.2353571504,
-0.4698652327,
-0.0239363555,
-0.3022248149,
-0.4725625217,
0.3036712408,
-0.3121662736,
-0.625592649,
0.6088122725,
-0.2594655454,
-0.0103678135,
0.4627330899,
0.681172967,
0.01062271,
0.9732602835,
0.9176454544,
-0.0492125787,
0.6852816343,
-0.4040565789,
-0.0443966314,
-0.5568704605,
-0.4204432964,
-0.1121966019,
-0.1052559465,
-0.7239827514,
-0.3250317574,
0.0178807154,
0.0197065771,
-0.519377768,
0.3522782028,
-0.3913078308,
0.5141388178,
0.7209228277,
0.0708987117,
0.4184569716,
-0.0283098724,
-0.2906096578,
0.3841941953,
-0.6446319818,
-0.2803640962,
1.3187369108,
-0.0174550563,
0.9485692978,
0.2596909702,
0.6499273181,
0.0987573192,
0.4195503294,
-0.6596729755,
0.4469513893,
-0.1110707894,
-0.4874458015,
-0.1879680753,
-0.1963607073,
-1.2548737526,
0.4116647243,
-0.1899199784,
-0.938552618,
0.4073225558,
-0.0120551856,
0.1948392093,
0.5148827434,
-0.4364899993,
0.6126405001,
-0.2508640885,
-0.3028422892,
-0.1308573037,
-0.5725830197,
0.1186268181,
-0.1697994769,
-0.1582907736,
0.3621453345,
0.2861517072,
0.6756532788,
-0.4022551775,
1.1340993643,
-0.0725708008,
-0.0455335453,
0.4630544782,
0.284732908,
0.4271743,
-0.4233920872,
-0.0212445986,
-0.0178112369,
-0.2920487523,
-0.4877144098,
-0.6004869938,
0.4370008111,
-1.1466444731,
-0.4087049067,
-0.4434736669,
-0.6323862672,
0.0750664696,
0.2121341527,
0.3967795372,
0.3292287886,
-0.1499742568,
-0.0277552009,
0.4784289002,
0.1813953519,
0.5958727598,
0.9762830734,
-0.441055268,
-0.0847643241,
0.6809059978,
0.0415876247,
0.4821106791,
0.335617125,
0.1278982908,
-0.1609693915,
-0.3119148612,
-0.4429996908,
0.2828193009,
-0.9605025053,
0.1132857427,
-0.3210924566,
-0.5437568426,
-0.4148842096,
-0.2016572803,
-0.8383957744,
0.059334565,
-0.3811573684,
-0.0779382885,
0.276917845,
1.0286899805,
-0.2848959863,
0.6794201136,
-0.4242538214,
-0.0602928847,
0.4283272028,
0.2979593873,
-0.0254955105,
-0.6721590757,
-0.3812330663,
0.2389696389,
-0.1464939266,
-1.2628531456,
0.5764501691,
0.3293183148,
0.5898625255,
0.7761596441,
0.0697079077,
0.3301517367,
-0.4512415528,
0.4517062306,
0.162987262,
-0.8377349973,
0.335760802,
-0.1260916889,
0.2631769776,
0.3086605966,
0.155549705,
-0.5169813037,
-0.3898171484,
-0.5792543888,
-0.8138660789,
0.7110984921,
-0.2285714447,
0.1969777793,
0.07774885,
0.2393461317,
0.2216975838,
0.2878437936,
-0.7770558596,
-0.4355256855,
-0.4999110401,
-0.173289746,
-0.2517701089,
-0.0568530299,
-0.0595272891,
-0.3554341495,
0.5703931451,
-0.1729599833,
0.5697658062,
-0.3213970363,
-0.5019885898,
-0.441308707,
0.1832908839,
0.1653674543,
0.3970885575,
-0.0340661369,
0.2987133861,
-0.3723674119,
-0.3754924536,
0.3276612163,
0.2136944681,
-0.4531722963,
-0.0328088142,
0.4910323322,
1.2692818642,
0.2585527599,
-0.4199134111,
0.565867424,
0.1824850887,
-0.353941977,
-0.3737229705,
0.1251833141,
0.2020841539,
0.448336035,
0.4086529613,
0.2474909425,
-0.0167916212,
-0.7775015235,
0.3412118852,
0.1027370989,
-0.5395125151,
-0.6257397532,
0.609852016,
-0.0840836465,
-0.4449798465,
0.6782229543,
-0.2875664234,
-0.6168815494,
0.6289986968,
0.8978559375,
1.0340250731,
-0.7116915584,
0.6529196501,
0.145977512,
0.4966350496,
-0.2927198112,
0.1464603096,
-0.1962631047,
-1.1141119003,
-0.3644003868,
-0.4599254429,
-0.2275208682,
0.0087101599,
-0.8945135474,
-0.1471577585,
-0.186327368,
0.1655971557,
0.0237750001,
-0.3268464506,
-0.7329410911,
0.2174346894,
-0.0793770254,
0.4963258207,
-1.1676918268,
1.1797853708,
1.0368559361,
-0.5962402225,
-0.8205271959,
0.0437586904,
-0.1993465275,
-0.8618254066,
0.7967503667,
-0.0036293762,
-0.1967038065,
0.3707904518,
-0.4322163165,
-0.9409816265,
0.8289257288,
0.3637956977,
-0.4661198556,
0.1239835322,
0.442763567,
0.7729750276,
-0.639159739,
0.2646644711,
0.5621137619,
0.0442750342,
0.1027001515,
-0.663836658,
-0.2591462731,
-0.3157226145,
0.0487777181,
0.1907006353,
-0.421246767,
1.4253262281,
-0.2865386009,
-0.3955222964,
-0.165881753,
0.4610666931,
-0.3610306382,
0.0431492031,
0.3405246437,
0.2218513638,
0.5235843658,
-0.0439504981,
0.7317578197,
-0.6051943302,
0.479210943,
1.1512364149,
-0.2012124956,
0.9538341761,
0.4269512296,
-0.0648349002,
0.7569423318,
0.5263538361,
0.2053387165,
0.7627416849,
0.1048677117,
-0.3057357073,
-0.2688800991,
0.1676193625,
0.0279323719,
0.8077670336,
0.2390934676,
-0.5778515339,
-0.5561528802,
0.640286088,
-0.1629703343,
0.3621208966,
-0.2222927958,
1.1148862839,
-0.1341196299,
-0.7292076349,
0.6716358066,
-0.0033130187,
0.363494277,
-0.4987549186,
0.043349985,
-0.2591412067,
0.441367656,
0.0357720405,
-0.6817567348,
0.2375252992,
-0.1659824252,
-0.1749504656,
-0.2965306938,
0.6306450367,
-0.8786456585,
-0.4404527843,
0.8915690184,
0.7396531105,
0.1256940812,
0.0023282731,
-0.6820705533,
-0.1380236,
-0.1086236313,
-0.3985434473,
0.3529027402,
0.4507499635,
-0.2895158529,
0.8114338517,
0.4905142784,
0.1652640998,
0.4231899083,
0.1771439165,
1.1146284342,
-0.5123494864,
-0.5733998418,
-0.6987093091,
0.5223029256,
0.3158236444,
-0.0232045855,
0.4990769625,
0.1161956117,
0.9104365706,
-0.138791725,
0.7075486779,
0.1006197184,
0.2186075598,
-0.2696257532,
0.7157170177,
-0.5347604752,
0.2050021291,
0.0098620206,
-0.7804929018,
-0.0337344781,
0.6899129152,
-0.1096901521,
-0.0003991433,
0.7218749523,
0.6091175675,
0.1998815835,
-0.0079606446,
0.3623296916,
0.3003287613,
0.0338499621,
0.4584203959,
0.8262609839,
-0.4533298314,
0.1303680241,
-0.4538882673,
-0.2352687716,
-0.215554744,
-0.4349572659,
-0.8874425292,
-1.193472743,
-0.4985484481,
-0.1641584188,
0.2836994529,
0.9433342218,
0.4348314106,
-0.7598199844,
-0.5075360537,
-0.5333464742,
-0.1748478115,
-0.6440627575,
-0.2502346337,
0.3212284744,
-0.3646236658,
-0.7542356849,
0.4831738472,
0.1186382547,
0.0472449996,
-0.6407918334,
-0.0043443106,
-0.1900736839,
0.2010258287,
0.4181136489,
0.4096555114,
-0.4675453603,
-0.0306972191,
-0.0145607814,
-0.2303548157,
0.1930174381,
0.6340375543,
-0.9491186142,
0.8722888231,
0.2228720933,
0.6602964997,
0.6236103773,
-0.3411776721,
0.5251505375,
-0.6321143508,
0.2771402895,
-0.0527458377,
0.2899306118,
0.5075617433,
-0.2593809962,
0.1710729748,
0.4458991587,
-0.3082883656,
-0.5188741684,
0.1977217197,
-0.5730708241,
-0.5241914392,
1.0364447832,
-0.1676466763,
-0.4605054855,
-0.2131128609,
0.0107514141,
0.6494935751,
-0.2986367047,
0.9586260319,
0.1909205616,
-0.0590281896,
-0.3725176156,
-0.2578313053,
0.3016070426,
-0.0366582088,
-0.6134215593,
-0.1263825744,
0.2844026387,
0.3999274075,
0.1895786077,
0.5452999473,
0.0949009508,
0.2818255723,
0.3231514096,
0.511184454,
-0.0463153012,
-0.5695410371,
-0.2749129832,
0.0957104713,
-0.0944954306,
-0.5056868196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20805v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20805v2
|
Multilingual Text Style Transfer: Datasets & Models for Indian Languages
| 2024-05-31T14:05:27 | 2024-06-09T18:46:48 |
Sourabrata Mukherjee, Atul Kr. Ojha, Akanksha Bansal, Deepak Alok, John P. McCrae, Ondřej Dušek
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Text style transfer (TST) involves altering the linguistic style of a text
while preserving its core content. This paper focuses on sentiment transfer, a
vital TST subtask (Mukherjee et al., 2022a), across a spectrum of Indian
languages: Hindi, Magahi, Malayalam, Marathi, Punjabi, Odia, Telugu, and Urdu,
expanding upon previous work on English-Bangla sentiment transfer (Mukherjee et
al., 2023). We introduce dedicated datasets of 1,000 positive and 1,000
negative style-parallel sentences for each of these eight languages. We then
evaluate the performance of various benchmark models categorized into parallel,
non-parallel, cross-lingual, and shared learning approaches, including the
Llama2 and GPT-3.5 large language models (LLMs). Our experiments highlight the
significance of parallel data in TST and demonstrate the effectiveness of the
Masked Style Filling (MSF) approach (Mukherjee et al., 2023) in non-parallel
techniques. Moreover, cross-lingual and joint multilingual learning methods
show promise, offering insights into selecting optimal models tailored to the
specific language and task requirements. To the best of our knowledge, this
work represents the first comprehensive exploration of the TST task as
sentiment transfer across a diverse set of languages.
|
[
-0.2042313218,
-0.5282322168,
0.2255983502,
0.7697989941,
-0.4724706411,
0.4447597265,
-0.386169225,
-0.4768694341,
0.3956851661,
0.1258904487,
-0.4863145053,
-0.3925169706,
-0.7202709317,
0.2846191525,
-0.4341621995,
1.1530686617,
-0.3335371912,
-0.0054020714,
0.0514293015,
-0.2089211196,
-0.4725448787,
-0.8009288311,
-0.5289865732,
-0.1615502238,
0.2634586394,
0.4702351391,
0.3900251389,
0.076136969,
0.6394565105,
0.2139244229,
0.2153874636,
-0.0027508943,
-0.2817640007,
0.0750397518,
-0.3926139176,
-0.4035955966,
-0.326605618,
-0.1601070911,
0.5144620538,
0.3699147701,
-0.0371176153,
0.1628569961,
0.0556142218,
0.8929192424,
-0.2946303487,
0.4267490804,
-0.1553871334,
0.1024298146,
-0.6015622616,
-0.0617532618,
-0.5261731148,
-0.7069290876,
0.0213881973,
-0.2332594842,
-0.1628358364,
-0.0129465982,
0.7952107787,
-0.1020000204,
-0.6592561603,
-0.3494724631,
-0.5848385692,
1.0162446499,
-0.4290844798,
0.4684930444,
0.2892970741,
0.2343930304,
0.7019929886,
-0.4066874087,
-0.4512566626,
0.0856701359,
-0.0857628807,
0.3819823861,
0.0941672847,
-0.2894272506,
-0.1352410764,
0.5718538761,
-0.5499092937,
-0.3292895257,
-0.5062916279,
0.0617307276,
0.5192387104,
0.1020556167,
0.5367950201,
-0.3414261341,
-0.5932033658,
-0.1463136822,
-0.4928160906,
0.0206349716,
0.2319805324,
0.5614441633,
-0.4929933548,
0.4001405239,
-0.2445548475,
0.6461429,
-0.1404738277,
-0.4183072448,
0.3241172135,
-0.8710199594,
-0.0630494207,
-0.0000224205,
0.787520647,
0.5331882834,
0.679523766,
-0.1507171988,
-0.1972619891,
0.1018202454,
-0.0627144575,
-0.5604516268,
0.067147024,
-0.2428335249,
-0.3991141319,
-0.3302921653,
-0.2472782433,
-1.2586200237,
-0.5816076398,
-0.5850352645,
0.2985725403,
-0.5097048283,
-0.6048054695,
0.1478435993,
0.1059938446,
0.6755367517,
0.2397547066,
-0.8754605055,
0.2640495598,
0.4355969429,
1.0745481253,
-0.3426830471,
-0.3876041174,
0.0943303555,
0.0582020395,
-0.4385614693,
0.9744302034,
-0.679667592,
-0.5268535614,
0.1607128531,
-0.1971542537,
-0.3804985285,
-0.0534517616,
0.5940858722,
-0.2581940293,
0.192192167,
-0.7104657292,
-0.0521230847,
-0.0981816798,
0.4057890773,
-0.3345168829,
0.9597721696,
0.0463157408,
-0.8237602711,
0.0023353822,
-0.6147694588,
-0.9823313951,
-0.2732520998,
0.2027128786,
-0.2411485463,
0.0321996287,
0.3230889142,
0.4281553328,
-0.3149760664,
-0.1138064936,
-0.2744420767,
-0.2890557647,
0.0190617386,
-0.1328215152,
0.8112450242,
0.4521973431,
-0.1398494542,
-0.0149951559,
-0.4583108723,
-0.1380489171,
0.0411105081,
0.0076654349,
-0.3421107233,
-0.4920231104,
0.6228418946,
0.4485088289,
0.2456157058,
-0.7457790375,
0.272164315,
0.0361068621,
0.5522085428,
0.8884201646,
-0.0378592685,
0.4174677134,
-0.3729859591,
0.6409141421,
0.090447925,
0.1519410014,
-0.0079474561,
-0.217819348,
-0.8749706149,
-0.0313384086,
0.2669549286,
0.8586632609,
-0.8990573287,
-0.4933366477,
-0.3893576562,
-0.5293235779,
-0.4827364683,
-0.0932612345,
0.3850311339,
0.2941039205,
0.3867148161,
-0.1223281175,
-0.5328476429,
-1.0558803082,
-0.5582271814,
-0.1241376027,
0.6676392555,
-0.1356965601,
0.1035433635,
0.1021029502,
0.5982267261,
-0.2529509962,
-0.3752267957,
-0.5461704135,
0.3486712277,
-0.0517754592,
0.355895251,
0.6885436177,
-0.8765456676,
-1.1719679832,
0.2620399296,
-0.74155128,
-0.2470027357,
-0.2783862948,
-0.0903964192,
0.5375058651,
0.5527914166,
-0.4746563733,
0.2559421957,
0.7451547384,
-0.0462255329,
0.5956689715,
0.2766813338,
0.6000185013,
-1.7016488314,
-0.1300284415,
0.2039734572,
-0.3104950488,
-0.7062250972,
-0.0058856481,
0.1333971024,
-0.1141928434,
-0.5441496968,
0.8342149854,
-0.4469820261,
0.034442056,
-0.1250180453,
-0.1219621599,
-0.0474375337,
0.6420091391,
0.0507572591,
1.1812164783,
0.5595910549,
-0.0779081509,
0.2496916354,
0.2842100263,
-0.1583229154,
1.0597629547,
-0.3852260113,
0.3119899333,
-0.1156656072,
-0.0544681437,
-1.0427211523,
-0.022358343,
0.1466784775,
-0.2641831636,
0.4700828791,
-0.2210467011,
-0.7430033088,
0.094972983,
-0.222010076,
0.3407271504,
0.5928173065,
-0.2944284379,
0.5287092924,
0.1951049566,
-0.6225715876,
-0.5793963671,
-1.0850436687,
0.2953511477,
-0.4204904735,
-0.4525395334,
-0.097083129,
-0.0595772378,
-0.4072440565,
-0.243254289,
0.0375017487,
-0.1827226877,
-0.2807121575,
0.0271990113,
0.2723031938,
-0.1234170496,
0.0134584233,
0.0886875764,
0.0896535441,
-0.3254547715,
-0.1668257564,
0.5249244571,
-0.667063117,
-0.2968568504,
-0.4900692403,
0.6263203621,
0.7431869507,
-0.3768306077,
0.6638552547,
0.9246434569,
-0.1003017798,
0.0357172601,
-0.5983996391,
0.2354681343,
-0.3611393273,
0.2742289901,
-0.6650218368,
-0.6336693168,
0.4697251916,
0.1216844022,
-0.1357263476,
0.3727038503,
0.64387995,
0.1328569055,
0.7370583415,
0.9452693462,
-0.3506607711,
0.7050936222,
0.2868853211,
0.5616533756,
-0.4652251601,
-0.0177761279,
-0.4123965204,
-0.1208680719,
-0.8796866536,
-0.1767867208,
0.3874005675,
-0.0704379976,
0.0769810975,
0.3271882534,
-0.1797448099,
0.5672407746,
0.3429753482,
0.1058188304,
0.3998440504,
0.2758123875,
0.0800520852,
-0.2288339883,
-0.2347881347,
-0.3769874573,
0.8992971182,
0.0361235775,
0.6946150661,
0.4785722494,
0.7494524121,
0.3558336198,
0.3577729762,
-0.7758123875,
0.4924051762,
-0.6630878448,
-0.2682462335,
0.04113755,
-0.0862399563,
-0.3455219865,
0.1797626764,
0.1139653176,
-0.5224030018,
0.213539809,
-0.1252325624,
0.0496241041,
0.4733761847,
-0.9961177707,
0.5605540276,
0.1556841433,
-0.4552645385,
-0.0774583369,
-0.5604948997,
0.4889993072,
-0.3232692778,
0.3968884647,
-0.0184769705,
0.0152909551,
0.5617586374,
0.0411282331,
0.9078552127,
0.083144553,
0.0311334394,
0.1175137833,
0.279973805,
0.3436044753,
-0.1183806211,
-0.3020748496,
0.2507999539,
0.2126517445,
-0.6799057126,
-0.3827760816,
0.6657623649,
-0.7789974213,
-0.3178909719,
-0.6106424928,
-0.8090637922,
-0.685546875,
0.3660817742,
0.1187863201,
0.4719406366,
0.0955709219,
0.043101944,
0.4339086413,
-0.1850009561,
0.5212073922,
0.0914740115,
-0.2423554212,
-0.2056141794,
1.0847433805,
0.1897213459,
0.4087757766,
0.4347750247,
0.1893739104,
-0.4164228439,
-0.4264038205,
-0.6275023222,
0.2008084357,
-0.9198566079,
-0.0791988,
-0.5808994174,
-0.192148298,
-0.6980878115,
-0.3252052665,
-0.4845993221,
-0.5619547367,
0.1075367332,
-0.0896766111,
0.7056142092,
0.990306139,
-0.1010120735,
0.2709817588,
-0.8342268467,
0.0644859374,
0.2405847758,
0.4911469221,
-0.1900650412,
-0.3733218312,
-0.0229616538,
-0.1790286303,
-0.0107185198,
-0.9242226481,
0.6151593328,
0.1734852642,
0.171064496,
-0.2362785786,
-0.0180550478,
0.6660921574,
-0.302955389,
0.8570402861,
0.2016664594,
-1.0059876442,
0.2296229303,
-0.5881679654,
0.2730193734,
0.6477078795,
0.4265462756,
-1.104791522,
-0.1513379216,
-0.1685659885,
-0.6626634002,
0.6151390076,
0.0101664774,
0.2003383636,
0.1345879436,
0.1257232577,
0.2008785754,
0.19857499,
-0.6702366471,
-0.1554383934,
-0.5543460846,
-0.470685482,
-0.1765054911,
-0.1588659883,
0.1732857227,
-0.065759331,
0.4396518469,
0.0029750552,
0.2704429924,
0.1698820293,
-0.4254223704,
0.1495619416,
0.6809527278,
0.836456418,
0.512917757,
-0.0827736035,
0.0555824004,
0.0740923733,
-0.5641106367,
0.0818965286,
-0.0010539563,
-0.0871293992,
-0.1605974734,
0.2396299243,
0.7910605669,
-0.0544233173,
-0.0546858124,
0.4434057772,
-0.2121578902,
0.1171159148,
-0.0528872497,
-0.6439275742,
-0.0588499345,
-0.0152695319,
0.0767844468,
0.4068350196,
0.1338638514,
-0.5775409341,
0.0156660043,
0.1318446845,
-0.4926247001,
-0.6096224785,
0.2749206722,
0.1800110191,
-0.04454007,
0.3793406487,
-0.0452742092,
-0.7242522836,
0.2975565195,
0.5227339864,
0.9120813012,
-0.2858098447,
0.3498159945,
0.4684830904,
0.3645782471,
-0.1877368093,
0.3372887969,
-0.0076871598,
-0.3685176671,
-0.4952509999,
-0.9166570306,
-0.5180003047,
-0.2116774172,
-0.6148492098,
0.3632360995,
-0.3920842409,
0.1940338165,
-0.2420131862,
-0.0563168526,
-0.6086119413,
0.0483612493,
0.2502968609,
0.6593613029,
-1.30631423,
0.970944941,
0.8511666059,
-0.5849203467,
-0.7735952139,
0.1158846542,
0.2178114802,
-0.8652009964,
0.6234906316,
-0.0414269753,
-0.2919504046,
0.063408576,
-0.1571673602,
-0.8436586857,
0.5126663446,
0.0693118274,
-0.3103713691,
0.1145432219,
0.5087948442,
0.7143918276,
-0.1027659997,
0.1616431177,
0.4609179795,
0.5945034623,
-0.0031598711,
-1.2661479712,
-0.0910937637,
-0.389647603,
0.1299903393,
0.2394464761,
-1.0715582371,
1.0640224218,
0.0541136749,
-0.1059326753,
0.1102206782,
0.4992438555,
-0.0620273352,
0.0198394191,
0.2659404874,
0.4345042109,
0.3093526363,
-0.1902083308,
1.3028292656,
-0.3285957575,
0.2661249638,
0.7229997516,
-0.311727494,
0.9117221236,
0.692787528,
-0.2499714494,
0.4397785068,
0.6277253032,
0.3501165211,
0.5798037648,
-0.1987938583,
-0.1055669338,
-0.1282626688,
-0.4872053862,
-0.5489413738,
0.3399791718,
0.0775441304,
0.0615710616,
-0.3361917436,
0.2940718532,
0.2822054923,
0.1936209798,
-0.2765702009,
0.696970284,
0.1791949123,
-0.6575407982,
0.4077225029,
-0.117128484,
0.9568169117,
-0.5120532513,
0.0550629012,
-0.7396121025,
0.2448395789,
-0.1575810313,
-1.1370362043,
0.6657884717,
0.0084388051,
-0.2209154814,
-0.782825768,
0.7177422047,
-0.5540652275,
-0.7365300655,
0.1663796753,
0.5795520544,
0.1584884673,
0.1613614559,
-0.6233673692,
0.0880093426,
0.0019904184,
-0.1419652998,
0.6049556136,
0.3810758293,
-0.4055789411,
0.4651425481,
0.4544123113,
0.2193778902,
0.1655421704,
0.2523640394,
0.5552384257,
-0.5566760898,
-0.5288202763,
-0.6937632561,
0.2141337544,
0.0569453239,
-0.2314374745,
1.0019760132,
0.2415463626,
0.8901325464,
-0.3279637098,
1.0165479183,
-0.0376237966,
0.6808896065,
-0.5277989507,
0.7294818759,
-0.6257215738,
-0.0949735194,
-0.4146678746,
-0.8283463717,
-0.2067005336,
0.3004763424,
-0.4380899966,
0.0803636611,
0.8300691247,
0.5646192431,
-0.1190746948,
0.28339836,
0.1470187753,
0.1614277363,
0.2056200206,
0.5308197141,
0.7259784937,
-0.5045521259,
0.5776104331,
-0.6769528389,
-0.1287939698,
0.1175720543,
-0.8783127069,
-0.810351193,
-0.7268673778,
-0.2553886473,
-0.3023674488,
0.1709328294,
0.8575544357,
0.7171388268,
-0.8771958351,
-0.5370027423,
0.2215546966,
0.0026742422,
-0.1605288088,
-0.2233706415,
0.5068298578,
-0.5219741464,
-0.9673517346,
0.1766476482,
0.2939957678,
0.0075004292,
-0.0790654048,
0.3592427075,
-0.494527936,
0.1264244765,
0.8889482617,
0.2655668557,
-0.4206250012,
-0.1859596074,
0.1446830779,
-0.3231398165,
0.1713476926,
0.9095081687,
-0.3395412862,
0.3879598677,
0.6664965153,
0.6782320142,
0.3392187655,
-0.0127396733,
0.343449086,
-0.9339414835,
0.2710341215,
-0.1439954042,
0.2350975275,
0.7767882943,
-0.3157463372,
0.460018903,
0.3908029497,
-0.2686709762,
-0.942188561,
0.1949741989,
-1.131410718,
-0.1180660203,
1.3216377497,
0.0894883424,
-0.1711145341,
-0.1586063355,
-0.3130313158,
0.1829765737,
-0.3431013227,
0.5546901822,
0.9588663578,
-0.1003685147,
-0.4250384569,
-0.6031032205,
0.5468789935,
0.5754716992,
-0.9042716622,
0.1248485297,
0.0678290427,
0.3797111511,
0.1278398037,
0.7511019111,
-0.4203847945,
0.0364210978,
-0.1724058986,
0.0872328952,
0.0731581748,
-0.3183405101,
-0.4041309953,
0.1997682601,
-0.0452347882,
-0.0098639019
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20797v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20797v2
|
Ovis: Structural Embedding Alignment for Multimodal Large Language Model
| 2024-05-31T13:59:18 | 2024-06-17T17:51:50 |
Shiyin Lu, Yang Li, Qing-Guo Chen, Zhao Xu, Weihua Luo, Kaifu Zhang, Han-Jia Ye
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Current Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) typically integrate a
pre-trained LLM with another pre-trained vision transformer through a
connector, such as an MLP, endowing the LLM with visual capabilities. However,
the misalignment between two embedding strategies in MLLMs -- the structural
textual embeddings based on an embedding look-up table and the continuous
embeddings generated directly by the vision encoder -- makes challenges for a
more seamless fusion of visual and textual information. We propose Ovis, a
novel MLLM architecture designed to structurally align visual and textual
embeddings. Ovis integrates an additional learnable visual embedding table into
the visual encoder's process. To capture rich visual semantics, each image
patch indexes the visual embedding table multiple times, resulting in a final
visual embedding that is a probabilistic combination of the indexed embeddings.
This structural approach mirrors the method used for generating textual
embeddings. Empirical evaluations on various multimodal benchmarks show that
Ovis outperforms open-source MLLMs of similar parameter scales and even
surpasses the proprietary model Qwen-VL-Plus overall. These results highlight
the potential of Ovis' structured visual representation for advancing MLLM
architectural design and promoting more effective multimodal learning. Code,
datasets, and models are available at https://github.com/AIDC-AI/Ovis.
|
[
-0.0933395028,
-0.7617123127,
0.6592492461,
-0.0498139299,
-0.1805856824,
0.1575450897,
-0.1644695103,
-0.2912842333,
0.2915122509,
0.3469723165,
-0.2634161115,
-0.6971985698,
-0.4495361447,
-0.2557885349,
-0.1953503788,
0.4904442728,
-0.2236771137,
0.2363243848,
-0.4803708494,
-0.4339780807,
-0.3318597674,
-0.2683998346,
-0.1874451935,
0.2256920636,
0.76147753,
0.2209367454,
0.6735768318,
0.8544883728,
0.6170831323,
0.356410265,
0.072155796,
0.5212529302,
-0.3505908549,
0.5239654183,
0.0437267646,
-0.2265286148,
-0.7927556634,
-0.4321496189,
0.882676065,
0.6876391172,
-0.1172628403,
0.1928801835,
0.1101140976,
0.4642604589,
-0.7138807178,
0.3338729739,
-0.3576958179,
0.0092815142,
-0.4365743399,
-0.1738052517,
-0.5494982004,
-0.2505739629,
0.0456313118,
-0.4727875888,
-0.390912503,
0.353574276,
0.550260067,
0.3137048781,
-0.6576108932,
-0.0337601379,
-0.4736580551,
0.6215853691,
-0.4192607403,
0.7761844397,
-0.072653532,
0.4074485302,
0.1174015999,
-0.5748556256,
-0.573024869,
-0.1192605644,
0.0506748371,
0.0069944644,
0.1380370408,
-0.1685680896,
-0.0197434258,
0.1876362115,
-0.8572952747,
0.0837023258,
-0.4953587949,
0.0338400416,
0.2984311581,
0.2291384637,
0.359313935,
0.0816327482,
-0.7146440744,
-0.1156186834,
-0.6832467318,
-0.202694416,
0.1865953654,
0.3977720141,
-0.2512777746,
1.1289200783,
0.1788339764,
0.8770902753,
-0.2183322012,
-0.1616552174,
0.5334023833,
-0.2917250395,
-0.2721290588,
0.3398163319,
0.6747596264,
0.2931260765,
0.3172572553,
0.0941504762,
-0.0973618403,
0.2539328933,
0.3626896441,
-0.5607729554,
-0.1116163582,
0.0887951255,
-0.4636173844,
-0.2867378592,
0.2329248637,
-0.7614726424,
-0.5025272965,
-0.2675446868,
0.3565815389,
-0.4365237951,
-0.2680046856,
0.135909304,
-0.0042543639,
0.1798570901,
0.1801199168,
-0.6430260539,
-0.0803484768,
0.340849936,
0.8992710114,
-0.2694702744,
-0.4180038571,
-0.7469449043,
0.4918268323,
-0.2485075444,
0.4759040475,
-0.7081605792,
0.0723125041,
0.391368866,
-0.0859035775,
0.0162935406,
-0.0167591907,
0.1146067977,
-0.5741570592,
0.1441330016,
-0.0519666672,
-0.3681942225,
0.0742812753,
0.498082757,
-0.7914130092,
0.8976790309,
-0.1679530144,
-0.7494038939,
0.2849749029,
-0.6259976625,
-0.3383310735,
-0.125644803,
-0.457059592,
-0.6123282313,
0.1171862483,
0.245270133,
0.3843788803,
-0.0235984884,
0.2672774792,
-0.690249145,
0.0187609009,
0.2928234637,
-0.4420790374,
0.6076796651,
0.1448761225,
-0.1618334502,
0.4816113412,
-0.8904448152,
-0.1567026824,
0.410156101,
-0.2914301157,
-0.5898701549,
0.2148139626,
0.2285891771,
0.0989300385,
0.3089335859,
-0.7484930158,
0.3814962506,
-0.2148085386,
0.646320343,
0.6383536458,
-0.3544075787,
0.6369163394,
-0.0228749216,
0.2028394938,
0.0461703353,
0.2914603949,
-0.5495941043,
-0.5049011111,
-0.724650085,
-0.5219168663,
0.152164191,
0.3711313605,
-1.0166870356,
0.2363509238,
-0.5449283123,
-0.2747883201,
-0.6025624275,
0.0667779073,
0.5339889526,
0.3999260962,
0.4912322462,
-0.2399343103,
-0.5845442414,
-0.7468577623,
0.1335598379,
-0.093651548,
0.2321863919,
-0.0517725833,
0.5559074879,
-0.1240212768,
0.929508388,
-0.6765280366,
-0.62927109,
0.0161252655,
-0.1408592761,
-0.2041152716,
0.4529328644,
0.5596841574,
-0.8661197424,
-0.4524466097,
0.2073157132,
-0.8970482349,
0.2540051937,
0.2888325751,
-0.2422167212,
0.3490693271,
0.70435673,
-0.5604358912,
0.2959610522,
0.7080364823,
-0.4223813415,
0.300814867,
-0.3192802072,
0.0591894798,
-1.2008587122,
0.0088589732,
-0.190991953,
-0.3525392413,
-0.3945220411,
0.2950481176,
0.3631509542,
-0.213144511,
-0.5960666537,
0.5232703686,
-0.8046123981,
-0.0758353993,
0.3057834208,
0.3490510583,
0.2845612466,
0.5593311787,
0.020528229,
0.3131882846,
0.5708085299,
-0.1569405347,
0.4978047311,
0.4445500076,
-0.6093310118,
0.9206686616,
-0.5162134767,
-0.0809152052,
-0.3187991679,
0.1519439518,
-1.0738942623,
-0.2006051391,
0.2819315493,
-0.1407615393,
0.5188134909,
-0.0343251415,
-0.3487765193,
-0.096797049,
-0.5013573766,
0.7377441525,
0.1396613121,
-0.5976966023,
0.9992007017,
0.4590218365,
-0.3080126941,
-0.5570363998,
-0.9537322521,
0.0569735654,
0.0596524365,
-0.7753210664,
0.4395695627,
-0.0026372862,
-0.1485757828,
0.3898029327,
0.1917096376,
0.1425162852,
-0.3446852565,
0.3154529035,
0.5073725581,
-0.7349297404,
0.3778921366,
-0.0190852229,
0.0765013397,
-0.326957345,
-0.5243642926,
0.5790268183,
-0.2285235226,
-0.9923844934,
0.0556792133,
0.5100488067,
0.9165865779,
-0.8505963683,
0.9773421288,
0.6841773987,
-0.3462724388,
0.2180244178,
-0.6079986095,
0.3536659777,
-0.3811779916,
0.6119340062,
-0.3951068223,
-0.8130845428,
0.1541821212,
0.2907433212,
0.2130745947,
0.4158527851,
0.5697878599,
-0.4634423554,
1.2475438118,
0.7480151653,
0.1274645776,
0.5770938396,
0.0081120096,
0.1425043792,
-0.7337181568,
-0.6931070089,
-0.334859401,
-0.4354240298,
-0.2907079458,
-0.7275368571,
0.3820254505,
-0.2571035922,
-0.3729892075,
0.1751987785,
-0.2783285379,
0.1998238266,
0.3360315263,
-0.0101731289,
0.2724969387,
0.2651918232,
-0.4015184045,
0.0803489089,
-0.7118009329,
-0.3795771897,
0.8576601744,
0.4905433655,
1.0053098202,
0.4398522079,
0.4802629352,
0.0612095408,
0.0772821009,
-0.51312536,
0.343836844,
-0.1328854859,
-0.2882854939,
-0.3294487894,
-0.304202795,
-0.7828273773,
0.2936880589,
-0.519824326,
-0.3941851258,
0.3978208005,
0.1965236366,
-0.2310190946,
0.3997037113,
-0.7478675842,
1.0298762321,
-0.4494934082,
-0.2948477268,
0.0554704554,
-0.5928151011,
0.2126052976,
0.031384144,
0.2869389057,
0.1819393933,
-0.3662572503,
0.3335105181,
-0.283996582,
0.9467873573,
-0.0488511845,
-0.289410919,
0.1310482472,
-0.1141861752,
0.4812861085,
-0.243397966,
0.1993778497,
0.0800960436,
-0.1793114245,
-0.4358960986,
-0.5254374743,
0.8236302137,
-0.4673788846,
-0.1604533494,
-0.3539246023,
-0.4152476788,
-0.1352375299,
0.1815281808,
-0.0316827409,
0.8858127594,
-0.3772045076,
0.4607517719,
0.572386682,
-0.2183327377,
0.3020363748,
0.3412240148,
-0.5351982117,
-0.7132102251,
1.2302434444,
0.0845887214,
0.2941224277,
0.6661732793,
-0.0755195022,
-0.3874825835,
-0.3492111564,
-0.6904214025,
0.17518875,
-0.7222067714,
-0.2118792087,
-0.6239230633,
-0.2105066627,
-0.5117760897,
-0.1682558358,
-0.4215566218,
-0.119116284,
-0.0880405754,
-0.0529161021,
0.0548818558,
0.7345702052,
0.5504106283,
-0.0241001304,
-0.8585728407,
0.2997192144,
0.388620317,
0.5020133853,
-0.1433225125,
-0.2560130954,
-0.2527086735,
-0.0239415485,
-0.0690736771,
-0.7957825661,
0.2187084854,
0.3709471822,
0.5900218487,
0.4982447922,
-0.0192899313,
0.7778948545,
-0.8224444389,
0.644539237,
0.4311297238,
-0.6904061437,
0.3115162253,
-0.057395976,
0.4125450552,
0.255623877,
0.3249931931,
-0.1323352456,
-0.3510684967,
-0.0653710812,
-0.780225575,
0.2679751217,
0.0930980742,
-0.1063066199,
-0.0776850358,
-0.1730731279,
-0.0477406569,
0.2834088802,
-0.6839695573,
-0.0750545338,
-0.2223574966,
-0.6614608169,
-0.1264148653,
-0.5631800294,
-0.1180226803,
0.0086759683,
0.4792495072,
-0.2423903793,
0.1842985153,
0.1643585861,
-0.6520397663,
0.0871327743,
0.0441168845,
0.9445613623,
0.4978838563,
-0.0964466035,
0.5153958201,
-0.1000791267,
-0.3204996884,
-0.0205135997,
-0.0451282933,
0.0495021231,
-0.1207192838,
0.661491096,
1.0223833323,
0.4392506778,
-0.6973651052,
0.6016074419,
0.0069223261,
-0.1810262203,
-0.0819774792,
-0.4245381951,
0.1493173838,
0.7241538763,
0.2036321759,
0.302969873,
-0.2016715556,
-0.7206971049,
-0.0120589547,
0.5601906776,
-0.6446300745,
-0.2499630749,
0.7513217926,
0.2823589444,
-0.3451560736,
0.4056421816,
0.2452588379,
-0.4485523105,
0.2201500833,
0.3335002959,
0.5939045548,
-0.30885306,
0.1433553249,
0.0120113958,
0.5292922258,
0.041176755,
0.4182167053,
0.0171869434,
-0.4426881671,
-0.5564239025,
-0.8715413213,
-0.0715630054,
-0.4583793283,
-0.513953805,
0.3696398139,
-0.0266258866,
-0.0511806756,
-0.1800685078,
-0.6503223777,
-0.5502880812,
0.0291671809,
0.4639611542,
0.8725270629,
-0.7815446258,
1.0748901367,
0.758530736,
-0.5245537758,
-0.2798599005,
-0.2579983175,
0.0897519588,
-0.8373039961,
0.5664820671,
0.0971774161,
-0.1640946269,
-0.1274453849,
-0.1289432198,
-0.9879377484,
1.1476786137,
0.6691115499,
-0.7782496214,
-0.240316838,
0.0397059284,
0.3499770463,
-0.5561354756,
0.0187717211,
0.0157973506,
0.5085635185,
0.1313168257,
-0.6604658365,
-0.0264041591,
-0.4272925556,
0.1346140206,
0.4225649238,
-0.1995215416,
0.7859596014,
-0.3360224068,
-0.2716302276,
0.1414635479,
0.7544297576,
-0.0240833163,
0.1039105728,
0.5017518401,
0.5314551592,
0.541352272,
-0.0863284692,
0.9139913917,
-0.0801965967,
0.0407710783,
1.180588007,
-0.4148522913,
1.2604696751,
0.6033619642,
0.1360179335,
0.5571422577,
0.1514334977,
0.053257443,
0.6262423396,
-0.1967108846,
0.0843859538,
-0.2177242339,
-0.05918945,
-0.6322414875,
0.5532227159,
0.2665009201,
-0.5351606011,
-0.076412335,
0.3099456429,
-0.5025135875,
0.0900157988,
-0.1399038285,
0.6328723431,
-0.0057609305,
-0.3772171438,
0.2998944819,
-0.0890520662,
0.4103830457,
-0.7355954051,
-0.1148681194,
0.1219891161,
0.278244257,
-0.1524537057,
-0.7971031666,
0.356074661,
-0.2176308334,
-0.1715086102,
-0.4364880919,
0.5152102113,
-1.0849363804,
-0.4627912641,
0.3237857819,
0.3871933222,
-0.2665279806,
-0.0501698032,
-0.2241301835,
0.5658004284,
-0.2687138021,
-0.2454255819,
0.4757023752,
0.3833788931,
-0.1242184266,
0.4580333233,
0.6479336023,
-0.0958095714,
0.227788493,
0.2306731939,
0.978941679,
-0.4347167313,
-0.3688459992,
-1.0291849375,
0.9550340772,
-0.2206932753,
-0.1191781387,
0.6160082817,
0.5685166121,
0.6635543108,
-0.1690975875,
0.3171685934,
0.1343539804,
-0.1418638527,
-0.832349062,
0.6844317317,
-0.9271056056,
-0.0204701982,
-0.1784693152,
-1.3028423786,
-0.4653515518,
0.5381492376,
-0.084023796,
-0.3312228024,
0.7200955749,
0.6842467189,
-0.2228987813,
-0.2381837964,
0.5418217182,
0.4060089886,
0.2805185616,
0.3508584201,
0.7158744931,
-0.2758669257,
0.8584730029,
0.2699163854,
-0.2145709544,
-0.3535853326,
-0.9640240669,
-0.8996316791,
-0.8176704645,
-0.2714335918,
-0.0786883086,
0.0652585402,
0.7090273499,
0.5008254051,
-0.5439295173,
-0.0277377088,
0.3075306714,
-0.0435266793,
-0.2314906865,
-0.1328998208,
0.3397572339,
-0.1767007113,
-0.6424518824,
0.594733119,
0.8754960895,
-0.0312784165,
-0.6769959331,
-0.2166198492,
-0.4459398389,
0.0266897622,
0.9350537062,
-0.0062505198,
-0.7867568135,
-0.2964293659,
0.144632116,
-0.5063673258,
0.0069084428,
0.561727643,
-0.5044600368,
0.6706860065,
0.6643360853,
0.7679784894,
0.5031054616,
-0.3992975354,
0.6042372584,
-0.8774482012,
0.0774575099,
-0.0654893741,
0.7219564319,
0.3251052201,
0.1096192896,
0.1726287603,
0.0056040678,
-0.137479648,
-0.985247016,
0.3115018606,
-1.115686655,
-0.1967836171,
0.7565312386,
-0.1456623524,
-0.5107303262,
-0.0491799191,
-0.4667076766,
0.0851089433,
-0.1619841903,
0.3311456144,
0.3898655176,
0.5229433179,
-0.2211602926,
-0.2927935421,
-0.0747254267,
0.1544273943,
-0.5401797295,
-0.1422975361,
0.5041795969,
-0.04055259,
0.5707412958,
0.2288363278,
-0.2104828209,
0.0587937608,
0.0533824489,
0.1825779974,
-0.6162813902,
-0.7112978101,
-0.173435688,
0.699198246,
-0.2274813354,
-0.5377313495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20755v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20755v1
|
Improving code-mixed hate detection by native sample mixing: A case study for Hindi-English code-mixed scenario
| 2024-05-31T11:43:31 | 2024-05-31T11:43:31 |
Debajyoti Mazumder, Aakash Kumar, Jasabanta Patro
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Hate detection has long been a challenging task for the NLP community. The
task becomes complex in a code-mixed environment because the models must
understand the context and the hate expressed through language alteration.
Compared to the monolingual setup, we see very less work on code-mixed hate as
large-scale annotated hate corpora are unavailable to make the study. To
overcome this bottleneck, we propose using native language hate samples. We
hypothesise that in the era of multilingual language models (MLMs), hate in
code-mixed settings can be detected by majorly relying on the native language
samples. Even though the NLP literature reports the effectiveness of MLMs on
hate detection in many cross-lingual settings, their extensive evaluation in a
code-mixed scenario is yet to be done. This paper attempts to fill this gap
through rigorous empirical experiments. We considered the Hindi-English
code-mixed setup as a case study as we have the linguistic expertise for the
same. Some of the interesting observations we got are: (i) adding native hate
samples in the code-mixed training set, even in small quantity, improved the
performance of MLMs for code-mixed hate detection, (ii) MLMs trained with
native samples alone observed to be detecting code-mixed hate to a large
extent, (iii) The visualisation of attention scores revealed that, when native
samples were included in training, MLMs could better focus on the hate emitting
words in the code-mixed context, and (iv) finally, when hate is subjective or
sarcastic, naively mixing native samples doesn't help much to detect code-mixed
hate. We will release the data and code repository to reproduce the reported
results.
|
[
-0.604000628,
-0.5035381317,
-0.1679680645,
0.4853255153,
-0.0643657967,
0.4293823242,
-0.3859991729,
-0.7832562923,
0.6157363653,
0.4120296538,
-0.284750849,
-0.4933578074,
-0.4850115776,
0.1453283131,
-0.3928950131,
1.1766785383,
0.1337615103,
0.297840625,
0.1563602835,
-0.5597413182,
-0.5668441057,
-0.7418704629,
-0.5706979632,
-0.244088769,
0.59732759,
0.4035200477,
0.6400276423,
0.1057962552,
0.4259699881,
0.1816428453,
-0.2203022391,
0.1623371094,
-0.4491786063,
0.111712873,
0.0899408683,
-0.7538012862,
-0.1830756515,
-0.0443922803,
0.1366522163,
0.3423897624,
-0.2377308905,
-0.0051229266,
-0.033987321,
0.4602201283,
-0.8244870901,
-0.2362420559,
-0.9567745328,
0.4658004344,
-0.3624696136,
-0.1604178548,
-0.3803690374,
-0.1489067376,
-0.3585740626,
-0.3432413936,
0.2614250481,
-0.0010884405,
0.5624619722,
0.1944045424,
-0.1785477549,
-0.413618803,
-0.8931549788,
0.9715923071,
-0.8822672367,
0.2890437245,
0.2041157782,
0.337128073,
0.0025039669,
0.0757108629,
-0.645106554,
-0.0931144431,
-0.1477960497,
0.2166135609,
-0.2597668469,
-0.2657352388,
0.3064470589,
0.5672983527,
-0.6118934751,
0.2798145115,
-0.4647914767,
-0.3343245387,
0.7394121289,
-0.0412379615,
0.7888129354,
-0.2594947517,
-0.4625372589,
0.20116207,
-0.6805300117,
-0.1803762615,
0.6287871599,
0.3895587623,
-0.3157684803,
0.5657429099,
-0.1175895333,
0.7328640223,
-0.1882236004,
-0.3247005045,
0.4952006042,
-0.4056355357,
-0.1629618555,
0.0970709696,
0.5679501295,
0.6027000546,
0.6555979252,
-0.1929588169,
-0.3473901153,
0.7630636692,
0.2262790054,
-0.6153419614,
-0.1793287396,
0.144572258,
-0.3692837656,
-0.3645692468,
-0.6089070439,
-1.1889842749,
-0.7519091964,
-0.2209499627,
-0.0676003397,
-0.4401833713,
-0.7616091967,
-0.0570567921,
-0.2960821092,
0.4069552422,
0.0552535243,
-0.804102838,
0.2744860649,
0.4057863057,
0.8118262887,
-0.6123722196,
-0.1487811059,
-0.5235548019,
-0.2969249785,
-0.1769288629,
0.7248623967,
-0.5430908203,
-0.3484176397,
0.1278921515,
-0.7044783235,
-0.0847862735,
-1.1265134811,
0.3100198209,
-0.4404228628,
0.0018250364,
0.2052547485,
-0.2322891951,
0.1963191032,
0.4045437276,
-0.4061024189,
1.10465765,
0.1580236256,
-0.8585449457,
0.6402516365,
-0.5241900086,
-0.4889732301,
0.0827439278,
-0.1358139813,
-0.2492611259,
0.0794376805,
0.166188404,
0.2387114614,
0.2849752605,
0.0198673345,
-0.5104572177,
-0.4814060628,
0.2303680182,
-0.1005088389,
0.9410698414,
0.5770767927,
-0.5051553845,
0.0238775481,
-0.8545439839,
-0.2657015622,
0.1442857385,
-0.2418149114,
-0.730062902,
-0.0830950066,
0.3710999191,
0.4138943255,
-0.1757630259,
-0.6618338227,
0.0584490933,
-0.4627247453,
-0.2139596641,
0.5426352024,
-0.1802426577,
0.4429352582,
-0.2323606163,
0.9804527164,
0.3015913069,
0.1118072346,
0.1875342578,
-0.5445206761,
-0.7946782112,
-0.1321965903,
-0.0942768604,
0.5318003893,
-0.928925693,
-0.0945276022,
0.1680770516,
-0.4896616936,
-0.6056904197,
0.4305052161,
0.4554880857,
0.2343216538,
0.52616781,
-0.4494846165,
-0.954331398,
-0.926728189,
-0.6412963271,
0.0116443457,
0.1770397723,
0.16780442,
0.2836803794,
-0.2285840213,
0.8299469948,
-0.4013488293,
-0.3138201833,
-0.4642932713,
0.0639108792,
-0.028402634,
0.3004032671,
0.6736379266,
-1.0596184731,
-0.7350446582,
-0.1307346374,
-0.4918414354,
-0.264909327,
-0.0134295532,
0.0953063369,
0.2662308812,
0.392059654,
0.1139051765,
0.5427503586,
0.7474218011,
-0.2995134294,
0.8377907872,
0.3259440958,
0.2172985077,
-1.0897448063,
-0.3418776989,
0.2923688591,
-0.0127423359,
-0.7177885771,
0.4406070411,
-0.1270598769,
-0.0536905937,
-0.5044850111,
0.291724354,
-0.3751947582,
0.0631371886,
-0.3818610609,
-0.1602546275,
-0.4062686861,
0.7263923883,
0.0900619179,
0.7782224417,
0.1694326848,
-0.4389762282,
0.1215943769,
-0.0730326697,
-0.3913826644,
0.6780042052,
-0.213847816,
-0.0932898298,
-0.0778149068,
-0.0817548037,
-0.8839690685,
0.0781974196,
0.3677939773,
-0.5859881043,
0.071344696,
-0.474699527,
-0.506498158,
-0.0373597704,
-0.1794892997,
0.5686734319,
0.4828326702,
-0.4568326771,
0.416251868,
0.4686539769,
-0.0531689227,
-0.5837926865,
-1.0406793356,
0.1832769364,
-0.4323201478,
-0.2622583508,
0.0782131553,
-0.2679979205,
-0.5969691277,
-0.2449761927,
-0.091152221,
-0.5011913776,
-0.0353687592,
0.4145399928,
0.2172522992,
-0.2693988085,
-0.2495776415,
-0.1659046412,
0.1447057575,
0.1158352494,
-0.0291777924,
0.5784861445,
0.020945916,
-0.2255323678,
0.2531510293,
0.5260068774,
0.635586381,
-0.3948105872,
0.7275236845,
0.9223842025,
-0.4093441963,
-0.4095925391,
-0.6093921065,
0.1920970082,
-0.3832802474,
0.4111234248,
-0.0229670014,
-0.888879478,
0.5674700737,
0.3864631057,
-0.0372330509,
0.1275923401,
0.7161307335,
0.2282392532,
0.7889294028,
0.6158455014,
-0.4978156388,
0.5169929266,
0.0013647054,
0.4774341881,
-0.5367609859,
-0.0877735019,
-0.5414380431,
-0.2893007696,
-0.5327540636,
-0.5491145849,
0.4708085656,
-0.0124098267,
0.1966755092,
0.201868102,
-0.5380708575,
0.5977631807,
0.2611635327,
0.144636184,
0.4352416992,
0.2504445612,
-0.2602219582,
-0.4326781332,
-0.771861434,
-0.0214449521,
1.1321622133,
0.1204111129,
0.5296805501,
0.1871929765,
0.7304635048,
0.2552407086,
0.7095384598,
-0.6528866291,
0.344083637,
-0.035702724,
-0.8049439788,
0.268327266,
-0.4199027419,
-0.5683859587,
0.2777979374,
-0.1810457855,
-0.4267745614,
0.0491748415,
0.2683923244,
-0.1630465537,
0.5457584262,
-1.0046037436,
0.896761179,
-0.1266217828,
-0.1052622199,
-0.2492923737,
-0.2876659036,
0.7859977484,
-0.0630717278,
0.7409947515,
0.1306505799,
0.1751689613,
0.7638821006,
-0.3565442264,
1.0310670137,
-0.1782948226,
-0.3385577798,
0.276527375,
0.1830120683,
0.0699546561,
-0.192061469,
-0.1167383343,
0.1265820563,
-0.4278595448,
-0.6499943137,
-0.4941054285,
0.6788644195,
-0.4500322044,
-0.1479822397,
-0.3083767295,
-0.796984911,
-0.2912381291,
-0.0246151201,
0.2874853611,
0.4367057085,
0.116188556,
-0.0983305052,
0.7260980606,
-0.4249287248,
0.3021715879,
0.5197665691,
-0.5763642192,
-0.064373292,
0.9766970873,
-0.0512590297,
0.451730907,
0.1780213118,
0.0754769817,
0.1026209071,
-0.7005231977,
-0.5750834346,
-0.1434279978,
-0.5972927809,
-0.076214008,
-0.6442579627,
-0.0816569626,
-0.2302019447,
-0.1898449808,
-0.4939288497,
0.060525611,
0.3649506569,
0.1964846253,
0.4563416839,
0.6586478353,
-0.0859693959,
0.1316671073,
-0.5225273371,
0.5341795087,
0.0234426744,
0.5649000406,
0.1558078825,
-0.5362715125,
-0.5425404906,
0.11589697,
0.0690391436,
-1.001744628,
0.4984231293,
-0.3388569951,
0.1987745613,
0.1450618804,
-0.0743280053,
0.7861230969,
-0.2208745331,
0.5871924758,
0.1556058824,
-0.5603728294,
0.5315748453,
-0.3443510234,
0.2613366246,
0.6516489983,
0.5824539661,
-0.7839571238,
-0.9468610883,
-0.3725197613,
-0.8683475852,
0.42756477,
0.2507616878,
0.1038775072,
-0.0299976747,
-0.085091792,
0.0802549273,
0.0957585424,
-1.202398181,
-0.7837541699,
-0.0470684022,
-0.0432745516,
-0.0177802853,
-0.1402917355,
0.1280056387,
-0.3901073039,
0.5246781707,
0.2825986147,
-0.0229354817,
0.0203462616,
-0.4478320181,
0.0813776702,
0.4087863266,
0.5374732018,
0.4243088663,
-0.2825450301,
0.1191178635,
0.0668944269,
-0.5660269856,
0.0090176705,
-0.1497993916,
-0.3398831785,
0.3910803497,
0.163560316,
0.4447557032,
0.2179016769,
-0.932277441,
0.5230910778,
0.0066024312,
0.0393605866,
-0.2950003445,
0.1009234414,
0.1351497024,
-0.1899994463,
0.3794588447,
0.5463614464,
0.1271846592,
-0.5297632217,
0.3068439066,
0.3233229518,
-0.460310936,
-0.0094518391,
0.4239878654,
0.1802918911,
-0.3087436557,
0.2331835032,
-0.6721920967,
-1.0463624001,
0.7423450351,
0.6030170321,
0.5019080639,
-0.2275298834,
0.2519955039,
0.2769246101,
0.4776188135,
0.2862332761,
-0.0143201072,
-0.0844825134,
-1.0610575676,
-0.5886972547,
-0.7747703195,
-0.3833593428,
0.22547324,
-0.7435539365,
0.2373046726,
-0.48364833,
0.5364041924,
-0.0259320661,
-0.173856467,
-0.5679261088,
0.2412718832,
0.4253742397,
0.8203760982,
-1.0273709297,
0.5999204516,
0.6128082871,
-0.4594270587,
-0.9231060743,
-0.1340018064,
0.2364608943,
-0.9787273407,
0.6416701674,
0.1889590025,
0.0456020534,
-0.3099938035,
-0.3308940828,
-0.3025532365,
0.2116208524,
-0.1992465556,
-0.4155346155,
0.4804283679,
0.209012717,
0.7901670337,
-0.3595736921,
0.3026697636,
0.652438581,
0.1558941752,
-0.2733851373,
-0.745059669,
-0.1707906127,
-0.6850745678,
-0.3474611044,
0.4166388214,
-0.2918134034,
0.6388402581,
0.0249086972,
0.0696029887,
-0.3231831789,
0.4313373268,
0.2135353237,
0.6400980353,
0.7403664589,
0.6114330292,
0.2942167521,
0.3156114221,
1.0078843832,
-0.1582239419,
0.155379653,
1.0955578089,
-0.3144291341,
0.7321742773,
0.6293621659,
-0.3046358526,
0.4912764132,
0.2831602991,
-0.0340114087,
0.0407980792,
0.4802991748,
-0.3850165904,
-0.0331081934,
-0.3977021575,
-0.5027275085,
0.4684225619,
0.1655830741,
-0.047455553,
-0.4116969705,
0.28086254,
0.2194059193,
0.437391907,
-0.3545643389,
0.5631724,
-0.0633896291,
-0.5200368762,
0.803822875,
0.1434403807,
1.6302759647,
-0.5631654859,
0.1073700637,
-0.5182170868,
0.0112414528,
-0.4707785547,
-0.3729430735,
0.7389208674,
0.6353593469,
-0.3863795698,
-0.1926968247,
0.6091298461,
-0.7301563621,
-0.4244525433,
0.6510230899,
0.392652154,
0.165776372,
-0.4379419982,
-0.6559792757,
0.2049466223,
0.2554021776,
0.1644247472,
0.7535684705,
0.1015932038,
0.0863282681,
0.2830168009,
0.637085557,
0.4764881432,
0.3956423998,
0.2758110166,
0.510832727,
-0.5157126784,
-0.3110085726,
-0.8712919354,
0.2366712689,
-0.1112613007,
-0.4883279204,
1.0000386238,
0.8713320494,
1.4186830521,
-0.2155626863,
0.8207310438,
-0.1033881903,
0.5421646237,
-0.3885164857,
0.6448767185,
-0.7301300168,
0.3412923813,
-0.454747647,
-0.6362540722,
-0.4493615627,
0.2615483105,
-0.2035249025,
-0.0209583752,
0.5522010326,
1.1091781855,
-0.1883986294,
-0.0252907388,
0.3011086285,
0.2056280524,
0.0910931826,
0.746594727,
0.7809511423,
-0.4836038649,
0.8609800339,
-0.5853330493,
-0.169998005,
-0.182770893,
-0.5716031194,
-0.8195028305,
-0.1836397052,
-0.3728499115,
-0.5948198438,
-0.25821051,
0.8942168355,
0.376736939,
-0.991969049,
-0.3694756627,
0.0969878957,
0.4671303928,
-0.1391264349,
-0.3225271404,
-0.2540003955,
-0.27034989,
-0.6986005902,
0.3496448398,
0.3966989517,
-0.2376921773,
-0.0735638589,
-0.0953131616,
-0.4445060492,
-0.2507812381,
0.6990732551,
0.3148789406,
-0.4648458958,
0.0010639086,
-0.0235455744,
-0.2897696197,
0.234351024,
1.2226115465,
-0.586668849,
0.4310127497,
0.1377046555,
0.8531396389,
0.1819592118,
-0.3529067934,
0.4785588086,
-0.9390155673,
0.4490459263,
0.2637848854,
0.4385263324,
0.4586195648,
-0.2646684349,
0.4828691781,
0.4602126777,
-0.0816502273,
-0.9476739764,
0.3260769546,
-0.9560892582,
-0.3409694731,
1.3028827906,
0.1809081137,
-0.0244775191,
-0.4334725142,
-0.2335503697,
0.1904689223,
-0.1731823236,
0.7705186605,
0.6999429464,
0.0866854042,
0.1493399739,
-0.5602031946,
0.525364399,
1.0019447803,
-0.7212412357,
-0.130045101,
0.504252255,
0.3074771166,
0.2496574819,
0.7150759697,
-0.0812653303,
0.4374935925,
0.0171940457,
0.403958261,
0.1074471623,
-0.1691754013,
-0.5883217454,
0.1319052577,
-0.1376729459,
-0.0809640586
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20708v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20708v1
|
FinGen: A Dataset for Argument Generation in Finance
| 2024-05-31T09:00:43 | 2024-05-31T09:00:43 |
Chung-Chi Chen, Hiroya Takamura, Ichiro Kobayashi, Yusuke Miyao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Thinking about the future is one of the important activities that people do
in daily life. Futurists also pay a lot of effort into figuring out possible
scenarios for the future. We argue that the exploration of this direction is
still in an early stage in the NLP research. To this end, we propose three
argument generation tasks in the financial application scenario. Our
experimental results show these tasks are still big challenges for
representative generation models. Based on our empirical results, we further
point out several unresolved issues and challenges in this research direction.
|
[
-0.5736839175,
-0.7149279118,
0.3286000192,
0.0564076379,
-0.075946711,
-0.0808413178,
-0.0283830352,
-0.4386660755,
-0.2383432984,
0.7432559729,
-1.0550621748,
-0.3162227571,
-0.11787121,
0.0483143851,
-0.4436288178,
1.0485601425,
0.0451419577,
0.1001307145,
-0.3401488662,
0.2767235935,
-0.644513607,
-0.4748048484,
-1.3412288427,
-0.22028099,
0.4483515024,
0.4835452735,
0.5002078414,
0.3625189364,
0.4232914448,
0.4594053626,
0.308847487,
-0.1458207071,
-0.0267405007,
0.5113909245,
-0.3453286886,
-0.3752213717,
-0.1426855475,
0.1127785891,
0.3978507817,
0.796246171,
-0.0694167987,
0.1529420614,
-0.2399038076,
0.7805062532,
-0.3622094691,
0.2353468835,
-0.5238829255,
0.1831559092,
-0.5185961723,
-0.137971729,
-0.2965036035,
0.0225214157,
0.3492101431,
-0.3305676579,
0.5862708092,
0.3183459342,
0.8954738975,
0.0881738961,
-0.2393930405,
-0.4312337041,
-0.8196228147,
0.7199073434,
-0.9179280996,
0.2985402942,
-0.0274085067,
0.5011370182,
-0.4780387282,
-0.8895660639,
-0.4249432087,
0.310418576,
0.0865030438,
0.0625572056,
-0.4303542078,
-0.0374351703,
0.2423008084,
0.2567672133,
-0.2297272533,
-0.0105546759,
-0.5041203499,
-0.1015316397,
0.8849369884,
0.105984658,
-0.2749851346,
-0.3235271871,
-0.6374127865,
-0.5273844004,
-0.4563859403,
0.1550170332,
0.748359561,
0.3822783828,
-0.1162666753,
0.5723929405,
-0.0025405386,
0.9648205042,
0.1090398431,
0.2147025764,
-0.0438780412,
-0.2605973482,
-0.3422869742,
0.1997686177,
0.7464384437,
0.3989182115,
0.2218460441,
0.2348426729,
-0.2017449439,
-0.2085955739,
0.3797744513,
-0.4742292166,
-0.0552122965,
0.8617552519,
-0.506941855,
-0.5277619958,
0.1818929017,
-1.4271872044,
-0.4052610099,
-0.0663309395,
-0.000290258,
-0.3459378779,
-0.2130944282,
0.512247622,
-0.4614599645,
0.349881351,
-0.011066474,
-1.2587774992,
0.3677602112,
1.1240973473,
0.3985021114,
0.2298207581,
-0.0535658523,
-0.4172324538,
0.1615600586,
-0.4661088586,
1.3968605995,
-0.3138276637,
-0.5054649115,
0.0748532787,
-0.2604787648,
-0.2704026401,
-0.3275595605,
0.5549530387,
0.0434601642,
0.5310458541,
-0.2549988329,
-0.8312544823,
-0.1068617329,
-0.1177825481,
-0.5045710206,
0.6328949332,
0.2816728055,
-0.8252910972,
0.8418358564,
-1.1543030739,
-0.383340776,
0.4867115617,
-0.63081038,
-0.5291091204,
0.1577899158,
0.1243324429,
0.641864717,
-0.5676242709,
0.6123914123,
-0.2911134958,
-0.0024894685,
0.4117099643,
-0.3833272755,
0.573889792,
0.2806849182,
-0.6475359797,
0.0142891835,
-0.7633182406,
-0.1717198193,
0.2183191329,
0.3088165224,
-0.2932157815,
0.5033346415,
0.072522819,
0.4210757911,
0.0963804275,
-0.7834894061,
0.1289329529,
-0.7878087163,
0.6026542783,
1.1080504656,
0.2596949935,
-0.006234468,
-0.3872967958,
0.6891912222,
-0.1743111461,
0.1083177328,
-0.1092207134,
-0.5746871829,
-0.5448380113,
0.425661236,
0.3473939002,
0.2701321244,
-0.5617387295,
0.0455149189,
0.155203104,
-0.4562179744,
-0.110017024,
-0.0736969411,
0.0881503373,
0.572163403,
-0.0609987825,
0.5278238058,
-0.7517192364,
-1.2755047083,
-0.1168646887,
-0.4723920524,
0.0545115396,
0.2918414176,
0.5025498867,
0.1409509033,
1.0764319897,
-0.7489334941,
0.1660719514,
-0.436784029,
0.3761051297,
0.4508815706,
0.6504583359,
0.9336012006,
-1.2882630825,
0.2456094921,
0.0464132354,
-0.4527253807,
-0.0114851967,
-0.8118377924,
-0.3177342117,
-0.0098968586,
0.6001493335,
-0.2330800593,
-0.1104127243,
0.3668635488,
-0.6912915111,
0.174930945,
-0.0395716578,
-0.1371144652,
-1.2730460167,
0.1108757555,
0.410197407,
0.0510830022,
-0.6230934262,
-0.0685872436,
-0.4901703298,
-0.3382083774,
-0.2200679779,
0.8876346946,
0.1469174027,
0.1190306544,
-0.17103149,
-0.1113792658,
-0.1527353823,
0.2423029691,
0.1063575149,
0.7409610152,
0.2289661914,
-0.3645459116,
0.5046434402,
0.200161159,
-0.2812234163,
0.4955559373,
-0.4699138701,
-0.1772137582,
0.0981659442,
0.2566599548,
-1.1912798882,
-0.4032914042,
0.2142186463,
-0.2269064635,
0.1383206546,
0.3305187821,
-0.2779774368,
-0.8911959529,
-0.0972634256,
-0.0387742557,
0.1597608626,
-0.450224638,
0.6749328375,
0.2977786362,
-0.7527246475,
-0.5620741844,
-0.3309286237,
0.2544239461,
-0.6491421461,
-0.9463310242,
0.4963614047,
0.2490195036,
-0.8342986107,
-0.1538921148,
0.0143274823,
0.3994764686,
0.2441387773,
0.3152194321,
0.512942493,
-0.3096635938,
0.243847847,
0.0191199854,
-0.5061103106,
0.3426060677,
-0.5145761967,
0.4965506792,
-0.2203305811,
-0.1166655868,
0.2477502227,
0.8889366388,
0.2041372955,
-0.0459372401,
0.2037920356,
0.3732610047,
-0.4940571487,
-0.2524722219,
-0.7416683435,
0.2842255235,
-0.6150166392,
0.175447017,
-0.1330887824,
-0.8006051779,
0.5835307837,
-0.3991395831,
0.9020690918,
1.2095822096,
0.753452599,
-0.2654719055,
0.831573844,
0.6636551619,
0.4647965729,
0.3566708863,
-0.3392432928,
0.2585243583,
-0.200794369,
-0.2168355882,
-0.4861852229,
-0.4282490015,
-0.3393985033,
0.0081167296,
-0.0374437869,
-0.0224796589,
-0.0255783666,
0.3478983045,
-0.3965005577,
0.1169005036,
0.4042764306,
-0.5018683076,
-0.1820334196,
-0.2548127174,
-0.2592769861,
-0.0233935937,
-0.736087203,
-0.544074893,
0.9024226665,
0.3657837808,
0.2860776484,
-0.2770301402,
0.8786494732,
0.3647252023,
0.3275523484,
-0.541218102,
0.5529792905,
-0.4383431077,
-0.783981204,
-0.2046811134,
-0.4693882167,
-0.9636963606,
0.0028522192,
-0.3440996408,
-0.7802577615,
0.5844674706,
-0.0524199232,
-0.9771990776,
0.2682495117,
-0.5538749099,
1.0850982666,
-0.3363342583,
-0.2995221615,
0.1116461754,
-0.5464335084,
0.6167992949,
-0.4855873585,
0.5110638142,
-0.1878649741,
0.4408331215,
1.1483830214,
-0.7339125276,
0.5398174524,
-0.3799093962,
-0.553617537,
0.6245916486,
-0.4792499244,
0.3355330229,
0.0821969807,
-0.2686477304,
-0.4654121101,
0.1587762982,
-0.1179485098,
-0.4338332713,
0.4419602752,
0.03201814,
-0.6190518141,
-0.207143724,
-0.5325913429,
-0.4944678843,
-0.0825772807,
0.3949238658,
0.4602859914,
-0.1831383556,
0.0634803846,
0.2495963275,
-0.1242442057,
0.7397038341,
0.0083002616,
-0.2454387993,
-0.5065498948,
1.0444191694,
-0.0345290452,
0.0004748668,
-0.021501733,
0.5843209624,
-0.3960492015,
-0.4106755555,
-0.501290977,
-0.0375873446,
-0.6335352063,
-0.2883150876,
-0.4706717432,
0.0589032248,
-0.4992009699,
-0.7067563534,
-0.75234586,
-0.5153190494,
0.0586795583,
-0.2413033396,
0.5578593016,
0.6008961201,
-0.3698209226,
0.1747449338,
-0.7932507992,
0.2954482436,
0.3154097199,
0.2258071452,
0.0320477001,
0.4794283211,
-0.504828155,
-0.0042026709,
-0.1402635872,
-0.4217980802,
0.2850339115,
-0.0646798462,
0.6335055828,
0.753636241,
0.0820795298,
0.6778845787,
-0.1056970134,
0.8313064575,
0.1400167346,
-0.6679487228,
0.4664052427,
-0.4219901562,
-0.139074102,
0.7583552003,
0.0341326557,
-0.5584993958,
-0.3799083233,
-1.1545801163,
-1.0083703995,
0.2138147205,
0.0770284832,
0.0289751403,
-0.3148189485,
0.4582174122,
0.5659177899,
0.2707505226,
-0.2877119482,
-0.0821334496,
-0.1050487906,
0.01852341,
-0.0538010746,
0.1068092883,
-0.0407171175,
-0.2356436104,
0.4844633937,
-0.086423777,
0.2776617408,
-0.0674471185,
1.0156704187,
-0.284606576,
0.2710357904,
0.9309998751,
0.4933541119,
-0.35788849,
-0.2667507529,
-0.1784811169,
-0.2027258128,
0.1996109784,
0.4944438636,
0.1131604165,
0.1247420534,
0.5055748224,
0.8235676289,
0.4370426238,
-0.8875972033,
0.472720027,
-0.1046119854,
-0.9719338417,
-0.7662694454,
0.2230869085,
0.1480758786,
0.6211813688,
0.7024575472,
0.1995209903,
-0.06765268,
-0.5622657537,
0.371107161,
0.2622971535,
-0.3489927649,
0.052554287,
1.0748651028,
0.2256144583,
-0.0225098059,
0.5136533976,
0.0575579591,
-0.4738613069,
0.6597858667,
0.588848412,
1.207732439,
0.2117788345,
0.3509384394,
0.0962240994,
-0.3518740535,
-0.4129914939,
0.6475794911,
0.0425987318,
-0.6787615418,
-0.5267880559,
-0.7762421966,
-0.4869492054,
0.2582975924,
-0.5745947957,
0.2943668067,
-0.4716032743,
-0.4768903852,
0.5324707031,
0.0097097252,
-0.4634774029,
0.3181086183,
0.2102221549,
0.9276877046,
-0.7904425263,
0.2802313864,
0.3813580275,
-0.0573885702,
-0.4627890587,
-0.1865466684,
-0.0261404403,
-0.3013776243,
0.722171247,
-0.0360788554,
-0.1337900162,
-0.1536928117,
-0.5823760629,
-0.465290457,
0.8172982931,
0.217441678,
-0.5790205598,
-0.5897664428,
-0.0426526703,
0.2088827491,
-0.7662697434,
-0.6864390969,
0.4173692167,
0.8978013992,
0.400880754,
-0.0257776603,
-0.2394384593,
-0.6398959756,
-0.2541293204,
0.3777562678,
-0.5143846273,
1.3673535585,
-0.1925335228,
-0.418045193,
0.0488155074,
0.8476609588,
0.2229227126,
0.4186842442,
0.5861474872,
0.1229089797,
0.5489052534,
-0.1150428429,
1.3883199692,
-0.3091114163,
0.2181486189,
0.9817275405,
-0.286558181,
0.7660639882,
0.529296279,
-0.2105297595,
0.3762345612,
1.0460245609,
-0.6493861675,
0.0749451816,
0.4900555313,
-0.0842753574,
-0.693801403,
0.049918171,
-0.4615800679,
0.8883176446,
0.5142207742,
-0.4761712551,
-0.3022946119,
-0.0529314503,
-0.0753838196,
0.1083258018,
-0.0395204797,
0.4897494912,
0.0146837737,
-0.5710148811,
-0.1333362758,
0.294211477,
0.5544101596,
-0.7154631019,
-0.2428915203,
0.0168773662,
0.1099520326,
0.0421778895,
-0.6539815664,
0.4361899197,
0.1147377789,
0.2005103081,
-0.4081782997,
0.8314111233,
0.0703161508,
-0.9425826669,
0.011484337,
0.5380705595,
-0.1911929399,
0.2715016007,
-0.6578784585,
-0.5750815868,
0.2051743418,
-0.4732921422,
0.1579707712,
0.4887852371,
0.0961897671,
0.5346739888,
0.8670783639,
0.0626795888,
-0.1850766093,
-0.0881708339,
0.5816139579,
-0.8367499709,
-0.3967325687,
-1.141731739,
0.2024494708,
-0.220288083,
-0.8591828346,
0.4794636667,
0.6323011518,
0.6749840379,
-0.004491142,
0.6396453381,
0.0856474712,
0.2869030833,
-0.6724488139,
0.5747264028,
-0.3546652198,
0.0993174836,
-0.7308040261,
-0.6570414305,
-0.1554508209,
0.7933006287,
-0.1748520136,
-0.0509568676,
0.3980228901,
-0.1306917816,
0.2747590244,
0.6841825247,
-0.0456027202,
-0.3450446725,
0.4737110436,
0.5434247851,
0.638612926,
-0.3448624611,
0.1444590837,
-0.470977962,
0.254142493,
-0.0642211586,
-0.9659565687,
-0.4933445156,
-0.9330773354,
-0.4226250648,
-0.1528647691,
-0.2109933943,
1.0328352451,
0.1461962759,
-0.6758600473,
-0.5314129591,
-0.3129025102,
-0.0494651422,
-0.4940348864,
-0.1942724586,
0.3733023405,
-0.1913440824,
-0.5854296088,
0.4678300917,
0.3190585077,
0.3621923625,
-0.602009654,
0.359028548,
-0.3066653907,
0.3696200848,
0.3204995096,
0.3749456704,
-0.2745316923,
-0.4945349693,
-0.3127988577,
0.1995509416,
-0.1409681886,
1.147885561,
-0.664585948,
0.2947591245,
0.337757051,
0.5876035094,
0.392048806,
0.2749798894,
1.3842691183,
-0.4535630345,
0.0627744719,
0.107864663,
0.4814018905,
0.0565132871,
-0.3674025834,
0.676792562,
-0.0153386286,
-0.2164165974,
-0.7208784819,
0.0652143806,
-0.8171831369,
-0.4590959251,
0.8027562499,
0.0711038485,
-0.3466671705,
-0.1043314263,
-0.0319945477,
-0.0237133782,
-0.2867998779,
0.5389623046,
1.1011967659,
-0.386121273,
-0.1699327081,
-1.0288393497,
0.6201385856,
0.261159718,
-0.6104553938,
0.6181014776,
0.2825233638,
-0.3418249488,
0.4035678804,
0.5210490823,
-0.0822856799,
0.1856801063,
0.6677916646,
-0.1983729303,
-0.1467023343,
-0.1315877885,
0.1402530521,
0.493501246,
-0.433584094,
-0.0523760915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20703v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20703v2
|
It is Simple Sometimes: A Study On Improving Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis Performance
| 2024-05-31T08:57:09 | 2024-06-06T10:23:48 |
Laura Cabello, Uchenna Akujuobi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) involves extracting opinions from
textual data about specific entities and their corresponding aspects through
various complementary subtasks. Several prior research has focused on
developing ad hoc designs of varying complexities for these subtasks. In this
paper, we present a generative framework extensible to any ABSA subtask. We
build upon the instruction tuned model proposed by Scaria et al. (2023), who
present an instruction-based model with task descriptions followed by
in-context examples on ABSA subtasks. We propose PFInstruct, an extension to
this instruction learning paradigm by appending an NLP-related task prefix to
the task description. This simple approach leads to improved performance across
all tested SemEval subtasks, surpassing previous state-of-the-art (SOTA) on the
ATE subtask (Rest14) by +3.28 F1-score, and on the AOOE subtask by an average
of +5.43 F1-score across SemEval datasets. Furthermore, we explore the impact
of the prefix-enhanced prompt quality on the ABSA subtasks and find that even a
noisy prefix enhances model performance compared to the baseline. Our method
also achieves competitive results on a biomedical domain dataset (ERSA).
|
[
-0.3346898556,
-0.9334939122,
0.4497798085,
0.2632364631,
-0.5553324819,
-0.1151272506,
0.0304067545,
-0.2839745581,
0.4686544538,
0.2688069344,
-0.5985811353,
-0.8446385264,
-0.3038902283,
0.08473102,
-0.158181712,
1.029920578,
0.0513540953,
0.0476624668,
-0.382204473,
-0.1726544946,
-0.3747120798,
-0.6026105285,
-0.7679262757,
-0.1669802517,
0.3688383996,
0.6977808475,
0.4895272255,
0.4933963418,
0.5733070374,
0.2588831186,
-0.1726870686,
0.19323349,
-0.0598370284,
0.1749025732,
-0.3753379583,
-0.3679294586,
-0.9635602236,
-0.0627829432,
0.3318809271,
1.0373982191,
-0.0349503309,
0.0912636146,
0.2329459488,
0.8081453443,
-0.4653851986,
0.5294513106,
-0.1042391583,
0.0794765204,
-0.1446063966,
-0.1491750926,
-0.3976224363,
-0.0473955348,
0.1727346331,
-0.5228686929,
0.3688450754,
0.2703272104,
0.7563832998,
0.2425250262,
0.0201684367,
-0.4069944918,
-0.1836988032,
0.6675696969,
-0.761495173,
0.3233507276,
0.1898598224,
-0.2321822941,
-0.0211065672,
-0.494241029,
-0.2179593146,
0.0647742376,
-0.069629997,
0.2298793942,
-0.1685842723,
0.44830212,
0.015782062,
0.8109018803,
-0.2880467772,
0.1632741988,
-0.2822068036,
0.0239102803,
0.5245085359,
0.2426692247,
0.1851405799,
-0.5383319855,
-0.223335892,
0.0166628789,
-0.6661813855,
0.4088103473,
0.4251693189,
0.3060067892,
-0.1145676449,
0.6307682395,
-0.3414314091,
0.6675003171,
0.2189802378,
0.2465112358,
0.4436867833,
-0.2221870571,
-0.1694524437,
-0.0355180651,
0.6967564225,
0.4317855537,
-0.4455491006,
-0.0295904167,
-0.2190456837,
-0.0102446675,
0.6675115228,
-0.7344949245,
-0.5938657522,
0.3664809763,
-0.5719764233,
0.0103408312,
0.2616184354,
-0.7754925489,
-0.2901735008,
-0.4515065253,
0.186645776,
-0.8096703887,
-0.1378847659,
0.0426828749,
0.2483882606,
0.187110737,
0.3139926493,
-0.6107375026,
0.0832502842,
1.1609256268,
0.8886236548,
-0.2285839021,
-0.1752476245,
-0.468111217,
-0.5758764744,
-0.4119259119,
0.9745232463,
-0.6667132378,
-0.3961086273,
-0.1478044242,
0.0764354989,
-0.1463068873,
-0.4857685268,
0.4385441542,
-0.2858996093,
0.0763175413,
-0.330878824,
-0.6215406656,
-0.6606765985,
0.0078555001,
-0.5775884986,
0.8723078966,
0.2492199987,
-0.6461307406,
0.2752710879,
-0.8284618258,
-0.8188644648,
-0.0592007712,
-0.0875284746,
-0.6222676039,
0.5388833284,
0.4182640612,
0.7040567994,
-0.2358523011,
0.0874892324,
-0.0518055446,
-0.220252499,
0.2660244405,
-0.2078591287,
0.2507415414,
0.0240908414,
-0.3522497714,
0.378313601,
-0.5799117088,
-0.0295462031,
-0.4836832285,
-0.2395898551,
-0.5293718576,
0.0693100765,
-0.3260681033,
-0.0332423747,
0.1862171292,
-0.4862232506,
-0.0008981527,
-0.822886169,
0.1909197867,
0.6173629761,
0.2696079612,
0.4318677485,
-0.2248009294,
0.7342089415,
0.1062490344,
0.2862932384,
-0.3424882293,
-0.4318282306,
-1.0575426817,
-0.6160091758,
0.2525315881,
0.3197436035,
-0.949953258,
0.5587400198,
-0.0492769182,
-0.3375571966,
-0.7042672038,
0.1423892826,
0.7644745708,
0.4565525651,
0.5541097522,
-0.8515423536,
-0.4153071642,
-1.0738787651,
-0.0169820748,
-0.3072281182,
0.0005098069,
0.33862257,
0.3450955451,
0.2701657712,
0.810280323,
-0.5827479362,
-0.2311166972,
-0.5186443329,
0.4936350286,
0.3522981107,
0.4390381873,
0.3751320839,
-0.712747395,
-0.1658703387,
-0.2451230139,
-0.6653464437,
-0.225314945,
-0.0908444449,
-0.2624724507,
0.0579780489,
0.3128759265,
-0.2717692554,
0.2859766185,
0.2679669857,
-0.5925221443,
0.4901730716,
0.0872305408,
0.2827781737,
-1.1889328957,
0.0393154547,
0.1826490164,
-0.0300393477,
-0.4457286298,
0.1743050665,
-0.1221096665,
0.0643321201,
-0.5811095834,
0.1885438114,
-0.3174791932,
-0.1799861491,
-0.4697436988,
-0.3643010259,
0.0504890271,
0.7387974858,
0.1359643936,
0.8007565141,
0.4843215048,
-0.617726028,
0.2141639143,
0.211119324,
-0.2391063273,
0.8586505055,
-0.7939901948,
0.2281172425,
-0.215859592,
0.01699109,
-0.7226813436,
-0.1626762003,
0.3203165829,
-0.389120698,
0.3395737708,
-0.0856876448,
-0.0791883692,
-0.0259437785,
-0.4466936588,
0.1486753672,
0.2660632432,
-0.4260210991,
0.811793685,
0.3970120549,
-0.5302429795,
-0.4459092319,
-0.1134648249,
-0.0689786896,
-0.1058256179,
-0.3055321276,
0.3685440719,
0.2429844141,
-0.2624717653,
0.1762083918,
-0.2297175825,
-0.0046685832,
0.2017736584,
0.7144887447,
0.2460849434,
-0.4135173261,
0.0693371296,
0.3742810488,
-0.1234853938,
0.0054215253,
-0.1171444207,
0.4043120742,
-0.4662238955,
-0.2639970183,
-0.6986795068,
0.6342377663,
0.4412788451,
-0.3527037799,
0.6864832044,
0.1472515613,
-0.076890476,
-0.3964101672,
-0.1338356733,
-0.2476903647,
-0.4516794384,
0.6202891469,
-0.4768638015,
-0.7040786743,
0.2298664153,
-0.0920525566,
0.3688611984,
0.3557544649,
0.2452711314,
-0.3070303798,
0.6664108634,
0.8420610428,
0.0780690461,
0.6360549331,
-0.5009292364,
0.2248183787,
-1.1724790335,
-0.2951622307,
-0.2982085645,
-0.3418731987,
0.0884744674,
-0.5490145683,
0.4745609164,
0.3438760936,
-0.0009278784,
0.2032648474,
-0.4008793831,
0.1761128306,
0.508769989,
0.2243939638,
-0.0171627812,
0.0240877047,
-0.002858157,
-0.052216772,
-0.8547013998,
-0.5414090157,
0.8931316137,
0.4885464311,
0.5572494268,
0.0543978103,
0.598210156,
0.3054041266,
0.5937476754,
-1.0894995928,
0.598400116,
-0.6234355569,
-0.0727440417,
-0.021523118,
-0.2850961685,
-0.5729394555,
0.2505553067,
-0.0092583718,
-0.437332809,
0.392061621,
0.2514549792,
-0.6033188105,
0.0221646596,
-0.642185092,
0.8639227748,
-0.0582425408,
-0.3657470345,
-0.1617400348,
-0.226116538,
0.0433987379,
0.1868861616,
0.2489865273,
-0.0884253532,
0.0363765396,
0.8616679907,
-0.487858206,
1.1826343536,
-0.2585306764,
-0.0289750509,
0.4512151778,
0.0012578551,
0.189604789,
0.1065460667,
-0.1520491838,
0.1869566739,
-0.3197087646,
-0.2605576515,
-0.7325311303,
0.5317630768,
-0.4578709602,
-0.6621177793,
-0.2117967606,
-0.3992697597,
-0.36816594,
-0.260448277,
0.0933167785,
0.701523006,
-0.0568261407,
0.3354347348,
0.7514733076,
-0.2636466622,
0.3811993003,
0.6271921396,
0.2853962481,
-0.3760373294,
0.8819903135,
-0.1231476814,
-0.0933121741,
0.5127162933,
0.0385541022,
-0.3398579657,
-0.5990128517,
-0.5312111974,
-0.0040215249,
-0.6546050906,
-0.4224383831,
-0.6765313148,
0.0603645481,
-0.241124019,
-0.2346310467,
-0.6873527169,
-0.3525878191,
-0.3802717924,
-0.3100912869,
0.4621502459,
0.4648999572,
0.1081542522,
0.3984606862,
-0.6937836409,
0.1122449487,
0.0184955969,
0.2224618495,
0.0633907467,
-0.5953711271,
-0.2197055519,
-0.1857599467,
-0.1873974055,
-0.8853340149,
0.3159856498,
0.3858376741,
0.438598007,
0.3429096043,
0.2368069142,
0.515455842,
-0.32720384,
0.8881679773,
0.1422538161,
-1.0223375559,
0.6607439518,
0.0301751699,
0.1182679757,
0.6477680206,
0.2631320357,
-0.2610245645,
-0.45664379,
-0.6696915627,
-1.3797322512,
0.7233589888,
0.0827735588,
0.1891497672,
-0.0299616903,
0.6025230289,
0.3755400479,
0.3246879876,
-0.2432024181,
-0.2202447653,
-0.534504354,
-0.6852708459,
0.015375508,
-0.3570574522,
0.0645165965,
-0.1518619061,
0.8718320727,
-0.4045624733,
0.2204256654,
0.2943130434,
0.0398818552,
0.3310520649,
0.5345857739,
0.1906551421,
0.611119628,
0.1405678391,
0.2330981642,
-0.0652107969,
-0.4781991243,
-0.0353626944,
0.0941690877,
-0.1766381562,
-0.0258335732,
0.5851056576,
1.0097401142,
0.3516866267,
-0.4979617596,
0.402064383,
0.0929592103,
0.1564768106,
0.0190324262,
0.2299641818,
-0.1897526085,
0.2398686111,
0.326887846,
-0.1318122894,
0.3504216969,
-0.5287097692,
0.423070699,
0.072427012,
-0.5223565698,
-0.5552485585,
0.3533269167,
0.5433325171,
-0.1977025867,
0.4205853939,
-0.4711115956,
-0.6672269702,
0.7245520353,
0.2469342947,
0.9072510004,
-0.2273781896,
0.4996805489,
0.2183024138,
0.1504154801,
0.0037302026,
0.5525772572,
-0.1132237837,
-0.4247313738,
-0.4845586419,
-1.0193879604,
-0.4228357971,
-0.0033948438,
-0.8138549328,
-0.137537688,
-0.5502435565,
-0.1433623582,
0.1006116271,
-0.0701190904,
-0.3426397443,
0.423894763,
-0.3194759786,
0.5134609342,
-0.8600277305,
0.4656705558,
1.3505781889,
-0.4425389767,
-0.9371775985,
0.0698115453,
-0.134440273,
-0.2630443275,
0.3904505968,
0.1866500378,
-0.1128986552,
-0.2551673055,
-0.0825803727,
-0.5555870533,
0.7324387431,
-0.028207818,
-0.5064585805,
0.1664548069,
-0.113199085,
0.638817966,
-0.5451917052,
-0.0317510478,
0.5046175122,
0.0026044836,
0.0393326767,
-0.7184188366,
0.1496216357,
-0.4398822486,
-0.0901338533,
0.1374497563,
-0.578127861,
0.8844885826,
-0.0720488131,
-0.142658323,
-0.0028412675,
1.2067512274,
0.0414076895,
0.4644433558,
0.4879397452,
0.4106857181,
0.5670436621,
-0.1437029392,
1.0472705364,
-0.3271576464,
0.1482486725,
1.1889346838,
-0.0357582942,
0.8155477643,
0.393473208,
-0.0868128911,
0.5758783221,
0.6739493608,
0.2351956666,
0.4730840325,
-0.0828653798,
-0.1337181479,
-0.34597978,
-0.3127998412,
-0.1257864833,
0.6244607568,
0.6942649484,
-0.4804092944,
-0.0255188327,
0.1967800111,
0.1358571053,
0.2207767963,
-0.5682525039,
0.8139802814,
0.2236349434,
-0.7574605346,
0.1372442096,
0.3185243905,
0.734310627,
-0.3302289248,
-0.160864532,
-0.4712692797,
0.150149703,
-0.2989678979,
-0.658790946,
0.4881550968,
0.0377059951,
-0.2869893312,
-0.0607350282,
0.2942740917,
-0.2684232891,
-0.5706794262,
-0.1437620372,
0.3851577938,
0.0655420423,
-0.0852150172,
-0.6971338987,
0.009726068,
-0.0011299276,
-0.2817300558,
-0.0196458474,
0.382819891,
-0.0721353069,
0.2889710069,
0.3625268042,
-0.0120585747,
-0.2821144164,
-0.0331168137,
0.7938594222,
-0.5167140365,
-0.7056366801,
-0.6528502107,
0.3232523501,
-0.1639652103,
-0.4642273188,
0.7148483992,
0.6248657703,
0.5694744587,
-0.0148695018,
0.6291335821,
-0.2949043512,
0.505777061,
-0.9187424779,
0.495780766,
-0.4797525406,
0.4962795377,
-0.1787602603,
-0.7357475758,
-0.1101535261,
0.7787359357,
-0.474293977,
-0.1553049833,
0.8977245688,
0.6115222573,
-0.0354743004,
0.3838880956,
-0.0666631609,
0.1313929409,
0.2268374264,
0.5891991854,
0.7741726637,
-0.1873093843,
-0.1321156472,
-0.5265268087,
-0.4059585631,
-0.0708908141,
-0.6435397863,
-0.8827608228,
-0.627956152,
-0.6862992048,
-0.1960788816,
0.258733958,
0.9143806696,
0.6158441901,
-0.9058325887,
0.0813159272,
-0.0264153332,
0.0892042741,
-0.627327919,
-0.2602003813,
0.8344278336,
-0.5454975963,
-0.7071706653,
0.5739012957,
0.2723191977,
-0.1894318312,
-0.1063165814,
0.2450432032,
0.1276402622,
0.1693888605,
0.6629692316,
0.2183727473,
-0.4052179158,
-0.2960282266,
-0.1369211674,
0.1848216355,
0.0565596782,
1.1424933672,
-0.5082524419,
0.172961995,
0.3607626557,
0.5265834332,
-0.0543456376,
0.5130238533,
0.5860598683,
-1.1038335562,
0.1019204408,
0.3942242265,
0.3127591908,
0.583325386,
-0.5585404634,
0.32513991,
0.1493218541,
-0.0208389703,
-0.4425358176,
0.1116352156,
-0.7286967039,
-0.6175255775,
1.1368046999,
-0.5632680655,
-0.5217685699,
-0.3351208568,
-0.1743717939,
0.0545880683,
-0.6508569121,
0.8583307266,
0.4672648013,
-0.6019135118,
0.03054877,
-0.3068272769,
0.6175857782,
0.7348633409,
-0.9629776478,
0.1422986835,
0.7812572718,
0.1180184335,
0.1874279976,
0.6043440104,
-0.1509742588,
0.426468879,
-0.1753923595,
0.0883236751,
-0.4479552507,
-0.7434051633,
-0.2871844769,
0.585398972,
-0.0124648185,
-0.4690918922
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20701v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20701v1
|
Unveiling the Lexical Sensitivity of LLMs: Combinatorial Optimization for Prompt Enhancement
| 2024-05-31T08:53:59 | 2024-05-31T08:53:59 |
Pengwei Zhan, Zhen Xu, Qian Tan, Jie Song, Ru Xie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) demonstrate exceptional instruct-following
ability to complete various downstream tasks. Although this impressive ability
makes LLMs flexible task solvers, their performance in solving tasks also
heavily relies on instructions. In this paper, we reveal that LLMs are
over-sensitive to lexical variations in task instructions, even when the
variations are imperceptible to humans. By providing models with neighborhood
instructions, which are closely situated in the latent representation space and
differ by only one semantically similar word, the performance on downstream
tasks can be vastly different. Following this property, we propose a black-box
Combinatorial Optimization framework for Prompt Lexical Enhancement (COPLE).
COPLE performs iterative lexical optimization according to the feedback from a
batch of proxy tasks, using a search strategy related to word influence.
Experiments show that even widely-used human-crafted prompts for current
benchmarks suffer from the lexical sensitivity of models, and COPLE recovers
the declined model ability in both instruct-following and solving downstream
tasks.
|
[
-0.2390398532,
-0.8187258244,
0.7001331449,
0.3144905865,
-0.1010376737,
0.292822063,
-0.2955687046,
-0.0759343505,
-0.0205097217,
0.3854727149,
-1.1193753481,
-0.2207789868,
-0.7020401359,
0.2880623639,
0.0352458917,
0.8160583973,
0.1855496317,
0.0642597005,
-0.2875638604,
0.1633320451,
-0.5711051226,
-0.6428645849,
-0.387758702,
-0.2053344846,
0.4233799279,
0.3867862821,
0.68551898,
0.3660028875,
0.1589877456,
0.2564050853,
-0.5055403709,
0.4037797153,
-0.6733350158,
0.1490393728,
-0.494782418,
-0.5950786471,
-0.1440616548,
-0.4005261064,
0.663187921,
0.8914568424,
0.1295677871,
-0.1204160079,
0.4153355658,
0.62158674,
-0.9314650893,
-0.0405243263,
-0.894644618,
-0.3223232627,
-0.0749239475,
-0.3507729173,
-0.3545608819,
-0.0677712709,
0.0390227586,
-0.6650148034,
0.3082972169,
0.0887444168,
0.5296316743,
0.4686906934,
-0.077674754,
-0.3913490474,
-0.4136377573,
0.8945652246,
-0.4716180563,
0.2416515797,
0.3887571096,
-0.1629365236,
-0.6477209926,
-0.4908043444,
-0.1327244937,
-0.4240255952,
0.0087017873,
0.0638917238,
-0.3709341586,
0.0678178743,
0.2932216227,
0.0931372717,
-0.4419706762,
0.2326442152,
0.0095918598,
-0.2896496654,
0.2578524649,
0.4045011997,
0.2760830224,
0.0257664062,
-0.283103317,
-0.0027709887,
-0.5996245146,
0.3060419261,
0.3240492046,
0.538543582,
-0.0751967207,
0.4866719246,
-0.1279460788,
0.5883669853,
0.2248568386,
-0.0897451788,
0.0654460862,
-0.5111049414,
0.2185904682,
0.0479905196,
0.3785167336,
0.1507537216,
0.1653349251,
-0.2606035471,
-0.3200645745,
0.1205024868,
0.4233712852,
-0.9358934164,
-0.024875477,
0.1038210317,
-0.2299394459,
-0.1874735057,
-0.1778467149,
-0.7332704663,
-0.5891820788,
-0.2901462615,
0.5637661815,
-0.2707869411,
0.1307806224,
0.0542081222,
-0.0866230726,
-0.0180464499,
0.2375669032,
-0.7896172404,
0.4419283569,
0.838562727,
1.0205788612,
-0.3023582697,
-0.3070276678,
-1.0650179386,
0.0732157007,
-0.3855540156,
0.7725009918,
-0.8917716742,
-0.8345040679,
-0.1596621126,
0.1216658205,
-0.3317330778,
-0.5477817059,
0.65086025,
-0.3096714318,
-0.0182098635,
-0.5012226105,
-0.7388135791,
0.0769509673,
-0.2175519615,
-0.4219583869,
0.9436171651,
0.3471544683,
-0.7265743017,
-0.0645787865,
-0.6581917405,
-0.4135120809,
0.2938675582,
-0.0569060184,
-0.0962856933,
0.5800701976,
0.4893896282,
0.2219343334,
-0.2354349643,
-0.0344380811,
-0.1718680859,
-0.4541418254,
0.2881950736,
-0.3779670894,
0.8332401514,
-0.0231768731,
-0.3073579073,
0.4011668563,
-0.6451002359,
-0.2140103281,
0.0450863726,
-0.2384742796,
-0.4112499654,
0.1702429056,
-0.451269716,
-0.139502272,
0.3064759672,
-0.5453451276,
0.2451015711,
-0.4661950469,
0.3058592081,
0.9800582528,
0.1206347942,
0.595223546,
-0.5303964019,
0.8108174205,
-0.1886287034,
0.0589600205,
-0.0886429176,
-0.5264964104,
-0.3413791955,
-0.5292643309,
-0.1009798795,
0.6280069351,
-0.6102021337,
0.4771696031,
-0.2367491871,
-0.2744318843,
-0.3154454231,
0.3269279301,
0.3051715195,
0.5197534561,
0.2315891236,
-0.0864927098,
-0.1595450193,
-0.6616965532,
-0.2125806808,
0.0501847379,
0.0496931039,
0.2831472754,
0.2906511426,
-0.1348089576,
0.6797379255,
-0.4701397419,
-0.0116075873,
-0.2629531026,
-0.1367741674,
0.3703477383,
0.1353905797,
0.4398436546,
-0.4749998152,
-0.3032373786,
-0.2058849037,
-0.0936046541,
-0.7667232156,
-0.202513665,
-0.3097666204,
0.1730333418,
0.8496556878,
-0.2731914818,
0.399695456,
0.5434542298,
-0.3417926729,
0.7719662189,
-0.1674475819,
-0.3204767108,
-0.7976745963,
-0.154566586,
-0.3284017444,
-0.1577754915,
-0.524985075,
0.2120446563,
0.1344346404,
-0.1057448313,
-0.2414215803,
0.724794507,
-0.5679500699,
0.0458427742,
-0.6136833429,
-0.0106422463,
0.0282948539,
0.603484571,
0.077170983,
1.0333989859,
0.7399584055,
-0.7724545598,
0.1108473912,
0.1786171049,
-0.1903690845,
0.5380126834,
-0.6718571782,
0.2501496673,
-0.2658115029,
0.0077754091,
-1.0583995581,
0.0475758798,
0.2206787169,
-0.2750420272,
0.3138769567,
-0.1696953773,
-0.4621617496,
-0.1952812672,
-0.5482657552,
0.3378909826,
0.4313407242,
-0.7808443904,
0.5904310346,
-0.1716075093,
-0.2809647322,
-0.3789286613,
-0.3896768391,
-0.1700107604,
-0.0578264706,
-0.4256117344,
0.479703635,
-0.5261212587,
-0.2352235913,
-0.0227470808,
-0.1838443577,
0.2037000209,
0.2325569838,
0.3539082706,
0.2937516868,
0.1190246716,
0.2869492173,
0.0586480163,
0.0588023067,
0.1282199025,
-0.2898316085,
0.6523843408,
0.1139559075,
-0.1800473928,
-0.2932848632,
0.5089457035,
0.1394432336,
-0.1930924207,
0.6767862439,
0.5053113103,
-0.160419777,
-0.540728271,
-0.2491233796,
-0.4016421139,
-0.5847842097,
0.4869931042,
-0.5995856524,
-0.8765731454,
0.4674813449,
-0.1292818487,
-0.0406116433,
0.0411129743,
0.8482911587,
0.2941573262,
0.8575838208,
0.4680211246,
-0.0230477732,
0.5436141491,
0.0632036179,
-0.0136926919,
-0.9946049452,
-0.1142385378,
-0.6945880651,
0.0341950618,
-0.6448366046,
-0.4111743867,
0.4217159748,
0.204059884,
-0.1275515407,
0.1324308515,
-0.685949862,
0.448545754,
0.636528194,
0.385301441,
0.0909530148,
0.0922529176,
-0.3990659118,
-0.0902823806,
-0.8441641331,
-0.3277991712,
0.8602756858,
0.14668639,
0.8946407437,
0.117828466,
0.6072089076,
0.1700971127,
-0.1872919202,
-0.8963330388,
0.4800049067,
-0.3379144669,
-0.3566316664,
-0.0747620389,
-0.4585882425,
-1.0695041418,
0.0088991253,
-0.1427668631,
-1.1179505587,
0.2809698284,
-0.0249942224,
-0.417005837,
0.134187609,
-0.774784863,
0.5569550395,
-0.2046913803,
-0.6369190812,
-0.0596109219,
-0.3761340082,
-0.1704801321,
-0.1830982268,
0.3479630053,
-0.0955575556,
-0.5689170957,
0.3093006313,
-0.6920208335,
1.0959672928,
-0.0014923392,
-0.2433563471,
0.1573594809,
0.4330951869,
0.8065015078,
-0.0320272259,
-0.0132144522,
-0.0973288417,
-0.0336685441,
-0.5851514935,
-0.6584435701,
0.8216179609,
-0.7053804398,
-0.8242740631,
-0.104772605,
-0.8522441387,
-0.4408011734,
-0.1035806909,
0.6715002656,
0.7471817136,
0.1623594314,
-0.2165779769,
0.4371533096,
-0.3649301231,
0.7498356104,
0.2540772855,
0.0015102118,
-0.2226471454,
0.8406746387,
0.0665429085,
0.5402212143,
0.4879213274,
0.6321035028,
-0.4306643903,
-0.7014593482,
-0.2208881676,
0.2381760478,
-0.758530736,
0.0091340067,
-0.4252813458,
-0.0325672403,
-0.2690424323,
-0.4681995511,
-0.1055503041,
-0.3313145339,
-0.612706542,
0.1156631634,
0.5246011019,
0.7045956254,
-0.0832029954,
0.5326759815,
-0.6205434799,
0.1999780685,
0.3581132889,
0.3284969032,
0.0650234893,
-0.9046555758,
0.0581071451,
-0.1698818952,
-0.179991588,
-0.9050662518,
0.3142078817,
0.223174274,
0.7193760276,
0.2079002112,
0.2736921608,
0.534789741,
-0.3867511749,
0.6280981898,
-0.0554129593,
-1.1182012558,
0.556083858,
-0.2552484274,
0.7355039716,
0.3849045336,
0.4588315487,
-0.1090699956,
-0.4066056013,
-0.4154608548,
-0.8221431375,
0.7492766976,
0.3116282225,
0.3474115133,
-0.0201201681,
0.5184903145,
0.3003052771,
0.0684192404,
-0.4887989461,
-0.1650548428,
-0.0867326856,
-0.0466217361,
-0.0704071,
-0.4381670356,
0.0488823578,
-0.0900623649,
0.6033836007,
-0.1396608204,
0.1851352453,
0.42208305,
-0.0646282807,
-0.0590456836,
0.2903952897,
0.5812539458,
0.5089924335,
-0.1067623422,
0.1020882279,
0.3023881912,
-0.4858645201,
-0.0248346757,
0.016755674,
-0.3149218857,
0.0893008336,
0.7191823721,
0.9182909727,
0.1125639081,
-0.5848573446,
0.4508707225,
0.1648106873,
0.0409107544,
-0.0465418957,
0.2772378623,
0.0373478122,
0.1869511157,
0.3898471892,
-0.1597333252,
0.2306713313,
-0.5365782976,
0.0548818521,
0.6186670065,
-0.3269479871,
-0.2069721073,
0.5597993731,
0.0558079742,
-0.565844059,
0.1676820815,
-0.6924571991,
-0.7134974599,
0.4583289027,
0.7057594061,
0.8570849895,
-0.1110843271,
-0.0496496223,
0.42965734,
0.2379454523,
0.2514443398,
0.4131767154,
-0.1140203029,
-0.7501065731,
-0.4562449455,
-0.4944008291,
-0.4255081713,
-0.0414115004,
-0.4295634627,
0.2576123476,
-0.5876923203,
-0.1449868083,
0.0920416117,
0.0079060057,
-0.490028739,
-0.2505986989,
0.081794478,
0.6872882247,
-0.3638995886,
0.5399419069,
0.6765281558,
0.0429779664,
-0.7509896159,
0.1654283702,
0.1630290598,
-0.9553025961,
0.5177180767,
0.207806766,
-0.3208579719,
0.1142460108,
-0.5791238546,
-0.6332333684,
0.5451741219,
0.5404186249,
-0.8488163352,
0.0789881349,
0.0655751377,
0.3279687762,
-0.4988988638,
0.2945758998,
0.4064582884,
0.3149073422,
0.0871760398,
-0.8155832291,
0.2340637147,
-0.0216722116,
0.2505269647,
0.1939334124,
-0.4311327934,
0.6069386601,
-0.4507445097,
-0.2826913595,
0.2762254179,
0.2275852114,
0.4357565641,
0.0997660756,
0.6534933448,
0.0816244259,
0.6639562845,
0.137444064,
1.3952584267,
-0.2649844289,
-0.0361470319,
1.230913043,
-0.0851522461,
0.5558097363,
0.4658669531,
-0.2049234062,
0.5023750663,
0.5833753347,
0.067449078,
0.4551213086,
0.4763880968,
-0.3452308774,
-0.3510576189,
-0.5799289346,
0.0386406891,
0.3347689807,
0.4305916131,
-0.2455629706,
-0.2584474385,
-0.008888619,
0.0787895992,
0.4402534068,
-0.7663956881,
0.7091633081,
-0.0313639231,
-0.6048770547,
0.8094502091,
-0.3495680392,
0.802616477,
-0.5960145593,
0.158230111,
-0.2134570181,
0.0109010218,
-0.1580170393,
-0.4904510081,
0.0204438567,
-0.1607410461,
-0.2080371827,
0.2277188599,
0.6570215225,
-0.1623445451,
-0.8378121257,
0.6676238775,
0.4946973026,
-0.0043573012,
-0.4003989398,
-0.578438282,
0.1518676877,
0.0175371654,
-0.1683253944,
0.1406705678,
0.3248126507,
-0.2716909051,
0.7243157625,
0.7006398439,
0.2880432606,
0.3514347076,
0.4237462282,
0.877956152,
-0.4467138946,
-0.4729488194,
-0.8924574852,
0.1273486316,
0.124922052,
-0.2967709899,
0.4766432345,
0.2659057677,
0.6288735867,
-0.0309074018,
0.566773653,
0.2744383216,
0.6182935238,
-0.6324405074,
0.0177010633,
-0.5779830217,
0.5228180289,
-0.2354729176,
-0.9672329426,
-0.0188979525,
0.0857460722,
-0.2636941969,
0.0566774569,
0.753854394,
1.3255597353,
0.1439168453,
-0.1100494489,
0.3408860564,
0.1027029082,
-0.0324849561,
0.7084832788,
0.9490654469,
0.2663322389,
0.6348534822,
-0.5263755918,
-0.2989810407,
-0.1678794175,
-0.9344961643,
-1.0477744341,
-0.5701470971,
-0.4291678369,
-0.2484188527,
0.2935267985,
1.0614438057,
0.587757647,
-0.6787953973,
-0.0532441922,
-0.3670639694,
0.1240492091,
-0.1859056205,
-0.2731427848,
0.415709734,
-0.7832292318,
-0.7853193879,
0.6175449491,
0.2049933672,
0.0404499173,
-0.011385154,
-0.0412582606,
-0.0278942194,
0.2808330655,
0.5758560896,
0.0120665729,
-0.6986364722,
-0.2587158382,
0.2725961208,
-0.0973806605,
-0.0289389454,
1.0064101219,
-0.7029402852,
0.5755033493,
0.5354543924,
0.67556113,
0.2082260847,
0.0657832399,
0.5100990534,
-0.9265329242,
0.2618137896,
0.1722103357,
0.4534629285,
0.3360977769,
-0.6919839978,
0.5451629758,
0.2747381926,
-0.4995779991,
-0.4761247635,
0.4578916132,
-1.1548863649,
-0.8606931567,
1.4897960424,
0.0589062758,
-0.2532362044,
-0.129800424,
-0.4388590753,
-0.0800170228,
-0.6839563847,
0.4440133274,
0.5514338017,
-0.2016925216,
-0.2932307124,
-0.3634516597,
0.4398913682,
0.7898030281,
-0.4680075943,
0.161456719,
0.3870385289,
0.1141309142,
-0.0233592428,
0.3085146546,
-0.0258632265,
0.3636427522,
0.0196953267,
-0.1448843032,
-0.2282007188,
-0.0831997842,
-0.7159466147,
0.0622509979,
0.4313131273,
-0.2581652403
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20684v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20684v1
|
Joint Embeddings for Graph Instruction Tuning
| 2024-05-31T08:26:47 | 2024-05-31T08:26:47 |
Vlad Argatu, Aaron Haag, Oliver Lohse
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved impressive performance in text
understanding and have become an essential tool for building smart assistants.
Originally focusing on text, they have been enhanced with multimodal
capabilities in recent works that successfully built visual instruction
following assistants. As far as the graph modality goes, however, no such
assistants have yet been developed. Graph structures are complex in that they
represent relation between different features and are permutation invariant.
Moreover, representing them in purely textual form does not always lead to good
LLM performance even for finetuned models. As a result, there is a need to
develop a new method to integrate graphs in LLMs for general graph
understanding. This work explores the integration of the graph modality in LLM
for general graph instruction following tasks. It aims at producing a deep
learning model that enhances an underlying LLM with graph embeddings and trains
it to understand them and to produce, given an instruction, an answer grounded
in the graph representation. The approach performs significantly better than a
graph to text approach and remains consistent even for larger graphs.
|
[
-0.0834896564,
-1.173586607,
0.7713465095,
-0.1507296711,
-0.3217981756,
0.4444880188,
-0.3230033517,
-0.3515518606,
0.2964283228,
0.629879117,
-0.4101745188,
-0.9353477359,
-0.7217968702,
-0.1082459912,
0.0001672579,
0.734744072,
-0.3325802386,
0.2522756755,
-0.2545855641,
-0.0760991722,
-0.5755326748,
-0.4740720391,
-0.4814563692,
-0.3874588013,
0.6093990207,
0.2350892276,
0.6420229673,
0.8600408435,
0.0603321642,
0.4227237999,
0.0694149956,
0.8880392909,
-0.6116014719,
-0.08811941,
-0.0436197855,
-0.3244569302,
-0.6010785699,
0.0589923076,
0.8745776415,
1.0760291815,
0.2879618406,
-0.122861445,
0.2598458529,
0.2962162793,
-0.3879511952,
0.6649355888,
-0.3819503188,
-0.0165482946,
0.0824313983,
-0.2747105062,
-0.7288361192,
-0.3673181236,
-0.1303003132,
-0.7472129464,
0.0801801085,
0.0692443773,
0.6652593017,
0.158007741,
-0.7488544583,
-0.4009917676,
-0.3773191273,
0.3070823252,
-0.4859875739,
0.6521508098,
0.2798558772,
0.1313597411,
-0.2717719972,
-0.9805857539,
-0.4155164957,
-0.0359859727,
-0.1353695244,
-0.0309990011,
0.1357172877,
0.4579033852,
-0.0502188243,
0.2425040156,
-0.2780210376,
0.4949822724,
-0.0246641282,
-0.2013605535,
0.4293756187,
0.3635904789,
0.4116873145,
-0.0651841313,
-0.0984498486,
-0.100838922,
-0.6007936597,
0.0159243103,
0.48520872,
0.4553971589,
-0.307897687,
0.6422402859,
0.0122962734,
1.0402306318,
0.0861666501,
-0.0406517945,
0.1661385298,
-0.2530713677,
-0.3389509916,
-0.1179137602,
0.6228151917,
0.0505279824,
0.4159070253,
-0.5392918587,
-0.1292377263,
-0.0206968989,
0.0931095928,
-0.8175271749,
-0.4977023005,
-0.2698110938,
-0.1643684655,
-0.1770454198,
0.037092898,
-0.2329825461,
-0.3377726674,
-0.5284032226,
0.2698343694,
-0.4968825579,
-0.0008863874,
0.1441987902,
0.0615221374,
0.139164567,
0.5383825302,
-1.0004661083,
0.2556120455,
0.8412052393,
0.6913871169,
0.0447044969,
-0.3655942082,
-0.8598926067,
0.5823784471,
-0.5373966098,
0.6500951648,
-1.0803352594,
-0.3607558012,
0.0882614255,
0.365498811,
-0.521423161,
-0.1401223242,
0.1128143892,
-0.7329713702,
0.1671720445,
-0.0557233728,
-0.9538934827,
-0.5685009956,
0.2516124845,
-0.5385043621,
0.5649641156,
0.2910280228,
-0.644144237,
0.1001637504,
-0.4403149188,
-0.5610891581,
0.0184191372,
-0.4538482726,
-0.3724395633,
-0.0215474609,
0.4761773944,
0.5853812099,
-0.0609076545,
-0.0479890741,
-0.5337237716,
-0.558996439,
0.1046996713,
-0.3792079687,
0.6818255782,
-0.261126399,
0.0088327099,
0.3090968132,
-0.3548909128,
0.1402706355,
0.0979459062,
-0.5222258568,
-0.2403956205,
-0.150802508,
-0.2204629183,
-0.2354290485,
0.2803322971,
-0.3383602202,
0.5049421787,
-0.2558742464,
0.5057435036,
1.0212225914,
0.0401455723,
0.4058481753,
0.0943780392,
0.5159875751,
-0.2974900603,
-0.0626146421,
-0.2030719966,
-0.38537395,
-0.6191957593,
-0.4883184731,
0.4825789928,
0.5248730183,
-0.7939344049,
0.4555463791,
-0.416110158,
-0.0897956714,
-0.4555277824,
0.5470234156,
0.5147950649,
0.5186936259,
0.2171858698,
-0.1994874328,
-0.3623884022,
-0.5278813839,
0.1733471155,
0.1997005641,
0.2839106619,
0.5987583399,
0.1513936371,
-0.3842019737,
0.5611901283,
-0.687301755,
-0.1313985288,
-0.3303683698,
-0.1026904583,
0.1511519104,
0.3181850016,
0.5340521336,
-0.5403798223,
-0.642136693,
0.2012589872,
-0.8914121389,
0.1368377805,
0.1405279785,
-0.1940416098,
0.0621781982,
0.7290197015,
-0.4135226607,
0.1908019036,
0.6876673102,
-0.4119738042,
0.0544600263,
-0.2556645274,
0.0013212598,
-1.2085927725,
-0.2813333869,
-0.1344475448,
-0.5829023719,
-0.2793872952,
0.0854934826,
0.0350653678,
-0.2952849865,
-0.1260924488,
0.4228462875,
-0.8357265592,
-0.1708621532,
-0.1943370849,
0.4083105326,
0.2301810235,
0.5652710795,
-0.3386973143,
0.7748655677,
0.6143407226,
-0.4225665033,
0.409198463,
0.291216433,
-0.1068118215,
0.2680122852,
-0.5728299618,
0.5098650455,
-0.1456834525,
0.4233213365,
-1.1777664423,
-0.3789369762,
0.4036905169,
-0.2421967536,
0.959046483,
-0.4582757652,
-0.6041066647,
-0.2977155745,
-0.1730671078,
0.2426529974,
0.2180458754,
-0.6962144375,
0.9021980762,
0.513554275,
0.0772129819,
-0.4330689907,
-0.5206974149,
-0.059649501,
0.1549347639,
-0.7547674179,
0.3615054786,
0.1747744679,
0.1732082218,
0.2967399955,
0.0754735544,
0.0819444954,
0.1195544526,
0.303958714,
0.2348655015,
-0.3465308547,
0.2778921127,
0.3517771959,
-0.3417825401,
-0.1427168995,
-0.2788099349,
0.7831738591,
0.0162091684,
-0.6761464477,
-0.6661111116,
0.3381658792,
0.3686698675,
-0.4267593026,
0.5742053986,
0.6903605461,
-0.0009660348,
-0.2130972147,
-0.2270239145,
-0.0605021827,
-0.5467746854,
0.6344564557,
-0.4042183459,
-1.0935714245,
0.4730377197,
-0.5026493073,
-0.1659560204,
0.1410431564,
0.287532568,
-0.1857841164,
1.3164740801,
0.7701141238,
-0.0546377115,
0.7062544227,
-0.640378356,
0.2734110057,
-0.9603210688,
-0.2411239445,
-0.1873723119,
-0.4372236133,
-0.6353925467,
-0.7181743383,
0.2400304973,
0.3571364582,
-0.3411339819,
-0.0146115655,
-0.3734261096,
0.6076652408,
0.2467616349,
0.4259552658,
0.1235101968,
0.0986349508,
-0.2328520417,
0.219028905,
-0.8247038722,
-0.4931139946,
0.9552896619,
0.3247985244,
0.9461505413,
0.0573645011,
0.7665035129,
0.0896298513,
0.3491364717,
-0.7712459564,
0.5912228823,
-0.7172687054,
0.1531452686,
-0.3543229997,
-0.3340402246,
-1.0058927536,
0.0760404766,
-0.1040313542,
-0.8485357165,
-0.1395215541,
0.2407213002,
0.0835327283,
0.4195248783,
-0.9285313487,
0.8919680119,
-0.2466452718,
-0.3200893104,
-0.2691981792,
-0.305986762,
0.1402026266,
0.4280527532,
-0.0271672159,
-0.0711089075,
-0.1395323426,
0.3873223364,
-0.2943203151,
1.3507038355,
-0.22587201,
-0.0575558804,
0.2730764449,
0.0665974393,
0.8441236615,
0.026017027,
-0.1005869955,
-0.158743158,
-0.5796938539,
-0.4132144451,
-0.8244867325,
0.9297330379,
-1.0348855257,
-0.794852376,
0.2698139846,
-0.8823419809,
-0.3336522877,
0.1851885468,
-0.1490546912,
0.8023254275,
-0.0167699344,
0.1763519794,
0.6960223913,
-0.0810330734,
0.2899433076,
0.1076992676,
-0.3012785614,
-0.5584554076,
0.9492040277,
0.2685114741,
0.2756200731,
0.4747319818,
0.0992936641,
-0.3696600795,
-0.5165184736,
-0.6811657548,
0.4374569654,
-1.086143136,
-0.1704330295,
-0.7274886966,
-0.2397609949,
-0.5054543018,
-0.3060155809,
-0.0334625021,
-0.1763803661,
-0.5892245173,
-0.2196228653,
0.6036907434,
0.9640008807,
0.3139442801,
0.4333706796,
-0.686480701,
0.0961213708,
0.6054739356,
0.4433665872,
0.0819192007,
-0.396148622,
-0.3724116981,
0.0587020256,
-0.3636357784,
-0.8554961681,
-0.0111381989,
0.1794522107,
0.8076366782,
0.2471157908,
-0.295378834,
0.8129160404,
-0.3916258216,
0.4325312674,
-0.0096410131,
-1.0742750168,
0.3144456148,
-0.3452315927,
-0.0285168272,
0.3363499641,
0.3751607537,
-0.1280902326,
-0.2633064985,
-0.270245105,
-0.7412546277,
0.5003052354,
-0.3673559427,
0.5671959519,
0.0182493962,
0.4408957958,
-0.0508230552,
0.0011674861,
-0.540636003,
-0.0490046963,
-0.2422715127,
-0.33801952,
-0.1114420816,
-0.0843362734,
-0.2508240938,
-0.4536790252,
0.3263668418,
-0.5837988853,
0.2554248273,
-0.2280694991,
-0.2731365561,
0.0351989679,
-0.1607226878,
0.3159435391,
0.7114924788,
0.1348464489,
0.28567788,
0.3273057938,
-0.1945524961,
-0.0586110763,
0.1265232861,
0.0473518372,
-0.1226596013,
0.6947375536,
1.190087676,
0.3956274986,
-0.2593259811,
0.5031920075,
0.1927609593,
-0.0263281055,
0.1220774874,
0.2707766593,
0.5240783691,
0.3418063521,
-0.0430684239,
-0.4279164374,
-0.1444105357,
-0.6126419306,
0.0235697702,
0.5915294886,
-0.5024790764,
-0.2396023273,
0.4073592424,
0.283552289,
-0.6652243137,
0.8178398013,
-0.2505376637,
-0.613165617,
0.6235781312,
0.9161243439,
0.7085838914,
-0.0696126297,
0.303314209,
0.0651917681,
-0.0634080693,
0.6389833093,
0.3529122472,
-0.0879211277,
-0.654594779,
-0.6739130616,
-0.358424902,
-0.415104121,
-0.2791733444,
-0.2933788896,
0.2787951231,
-0.5696249008,
-0.0105149355,
-0.0392084159,
-0.0150302313,
-0.7843502164,
-0.0613977835,
0.0859830603,
0.5436680913,
-0.9703625441,
0.9582850337,
0.6959304214,
-0.3778070807,
-1.1396832466,
-0.0143181747,
-0.3494136631,
-1.0522166491,
0.5661894679,
0.3465061486,
-0.2251641005,
0.2813006938,
-0.630423665,
-0.6546829343,
1.2406334877,
0.7225771546,
-0.4977361262,
-0.070771955,
0.1289829016,
0.4022018313,
-0.631116271,
-0.0395516977,
0.1053761393,
0.4069594741,
0.0796335638,
-0.5217761993,
0.1504215449,
-0.0535232499,
0.0603077561,
0.3643784225,
-0.7480818629,
0.9669777155,
-0.2637485266,
-0.1206998229,
-0.1933067441,
0.5726422668,
0.0719581619,
0.122341916,
0.389723897,
0.5091858506,
0.9426257014,
0.0473719612,
1.33436203,
-0.5139416456,
0.2169871777,
1.2919687033,
-0.0382065065,
0.4986361861,
0.2866511047,
0.0269094538,
0.7401590347,
0.6241653562,
0.1021676585,
0.4304760695,
0.1895736456,
-0.0578796603,
-0.5587440133,
-0.255966574,
-0.3858801126,
0.6592591405,
0.5592979789,
-0.6521524191,
-0.2423639894,
-0.1223736331,
0.1070413366,
0.3667525053,
-0.3151504099,
0.8880249262,
0.0413660556,
-0.2716744244,
0.5509508848,
-0.0426839367,
0.3348732889,
-0.6207929254,
-0.373539269,
-0.0200702883,
0.0956936702,
-0.1800263375,
-0.8529624343,
0.0584710091,
-0.3566858768,
-0.1924896836,
-0.152047947,
0.3887078464,
-0.3673226833,
-0.5779518485,
0.547223866,
0.4085549116,
-0.127947852,
0.5091776252,
-0.4654129148,
0.2404667139,
0.0172142182,
-0.0721293688,
0.3009876609,
0.7253523469,
-0.0064784102,
0.4379680157,
0.6416690946,
-0.1544355899,
0.005271384,
0.400832653,
1.2906365395,
-0.2801901698,
-0.4528545141,
-0.7705053091,
0.3918274343,
-0.0880350024,
-0.3102525175,
0.717541635,
0.4993522167,
0.6218757033,
0.1243315637,
0.4428807795,
0.2905262411,
-0.0231724773,
-0.8752586842,
0.5388561487,
-0.4469082355,
0.1558523327,
-0.2419615388,
-0.9285525084,
-0.3529422879,
0.5826256871,
-0.5289007425,
0.0928195864,
0.4068759084,
0.8878138065,
-0.3252518475,
-0.1541273743,
0.1714403182,
0.1168273911,
0.502820909,
0.5285537839,
0.5557082891,
-0.2121902406,
0.4089357853,
-0.0714132115,
-0.0389926694,
-0.1364208907,
-0.7908203006,
-1.1595088243,
-0.3414878249,
-0.1896868795,
-0.3543884754,
0.1120570153,
0.7613021731,
0.7648431063,
-0.4999992847,
-0.0292700231,
-0.1396155357,
0.4681882858,
-0.0339438431,
-0.1904789507,
0.7196003199,
-0.4655629694,
-0.8609787822,
0.5251716375,
0.3419550955,
0.2445012182,
-0.3461061418,
-0.3018892109,
-0.2185890973,
0.058081653,
0.5196809173,
0.0054209316,
-0.5379145145,
-0.7483212948,
0.0116203986,
-0.2146583796,
0.1248865277,
0.7952771783,
-0.5428925157,
0.5950497985,
0.5833262801,
0.8834696412,
0.784950614,
-0.1038461253,
0.5871694684,
-0.823018074,
0.236216113,
0.1502070874,
0.4156985879,
0.5477458835,
-0.3790697157,
0.4551576674,
0.1547576189,
-0.3791180849,
-0.7115755081,
0.3345883191,
-0.9861976504,
-0.2970000505,
0.8659850359,
-0.4409120083,
-0.2756924629,
-0.0042002755,
-0.2224292159,
0.7298160791,
-0.0651514679,
0.4771798849,
0.3028762043,
-0.2441624701,
-0.1045203656,
-0.1338140666,
-0.0553558394,
-0.0264481101,
-0.7382583618,
0.0850832537,
0.4624066651,
0.2187587172,
-0.018441204,
0.4764790535,
0.1338392496,
0.1684428304,
0.1817970574,
-0.2261109799,
-0.7228873968,
-0.3198807538,
-0.0911234841,
0.1564823091,
0.1665550619,
-0.4402281046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20680v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20680v3
|
Unraveling and Mitigating Retriever Inconsistencies in Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models
| 2024-05-31T08:22:49 | 2024-06-04T11:51:53 |
Mingda Li, Xinyu Li, Yifan Chen, Wenfeng Xuan, Weinan Zhang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Although Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models (RALMs) demonstrate their
superiority in terms of factuality, they do not consistently outperform the
original retrieval-free Language Models (LMs). Our experiments reveal that this
example-level performance inconsistency exists not only between
retrieval-augmented and retrieval-free LM but also among different retrievers.
To understand this phenomenon, we investigate the degeneration behavior of
RALMs and theoretically decompose it into four categories. Further analysis
based on our decomposition reveals that the innate difference in knowledge
sources and the unpredictable degeneration of the reader model contribute most
to the inconsistency. Drawing from our analysis, we introduce Ensemble of
Retrievers (EoR), a trainable framework that can adaptively retrieve from
different knowledge sources and effectively decrease unpredictable reader
errors. Our experiments on Open Domain Question Answering show that EoR
substantially improves performance over the RALM with a single retriever by
considerably reducing inconsistent behaviors.
|
[
-0.2196933031,
-0.8446775675,
0.3263378739,
-0.239183709,
0.1688215435,
0.4772031903,
-0.0992149189,
-0.7112962008,
-0.0153625384,
0.4532112181,
-0.1585562974,
0.0936021805,
-0.6946406364,
0.3137429059,
-0.2559432685,
0.8992452025,
0.1135773063,
-0.1636485308,
-0.333063364,
-0.5400858521,
-0.3435212672,
-0.4611411095,
-0.6569104195,
-0.4737283885,
0.4494898021,
0.2485868335,
0.6709453464,
0.3862368464,
0.7018348575,
0.2712076902,
-0.1394140422,
0.3462379873,
-0.6135148406,
0.5871450901,
-0.3947071135,
-0.7279683948,
-0.1206607446,
-0.4063998461,
0.4812453389,
0.541046679,
-0.504660666,
-0.084174484,
0.0918793827,
0.9110545516,
-0.9346734285,
-0.0903924927,
-0.8215174079,
-0.1514930725,
-0.0626982152,
-0.3554941416,
-0.6972643733,
-0.3877815902,
0.2028568685,
-0.508973062,
0.6832770705,
0.2363225371,
0.6719017625,
0.3102346361,
-0.19173792,
-0.3091428876,
-1.1664632559,
0.8185856342,
-0.5559664965,
0.4400269389,
0.4820563495,
0.3175450265,
-0.0016791821,
-0.3266555369,
-0.4890674651,
-0.1068802774,
-0.1764011085,
-0.0310802199,
-0.4257028699,
0.0046756491,
0.1304019541,
0.3522267342,
-0.6751763821,
0.1206929609,
-0.3005378842,
-0.0701557323,
0.5252813697,
0.1280537397,
0.2950276434,
0.0115432078,
-0.2721698284,
-0.2558272779,
-0.8132092357,
-0.0304709896,
0.2167804837,
0.2317239195,
0.2910716534,
0.4706543982,
-0.1309588999,
0.674583137,
0.1636436582,
0.0287812129,
0.3130355775,
-0.0323064215,
-0.2242777795,
0.1572898924,
0.4671479762,
-0.0342737585,
-0.0426844731,
-0.5007953048,
-0.4033879042,
-0.2649472654,
0.1375974119,
-0.5821096301,
-0.2707967758,
0.490925312,
-0.3886315227,
-0.0584510639,
0.0451206192,
-0.8154456615,
-0.4718891084,
-0.1016859636,
0.709431529,
-0.5261246562,
-0.5249603391,
0.0725899488,
-0.2308315933,
0.2166871876,
0.3456873894,
-0.9123522639,
0.2734842896,
0.47803545,
0.4339038432,
0.031801153,
-0.2556230724,
-0.6595729589,
0.1905617118,
-0.3588398397,
0.9007484913,
-0.6869236827,
-0.2703426182,
0.0049074604,
-0.2333155423,
-0.4718576968,
-0.8630120158,
0.4616220593,
-1.1056044102,
0.0634237751,
-0.2998434901,
-0.6143804193,
-0.2647791803,
0.4433654547,
-0.8264847398,
1.0838057995,
-0.0212055296,
-0.9029336572,
0.2218302488,
-0.4816744626,
-0.1690178663,
-0.0023295141,
0.0360748805,
-0.1909787655,
0.4296605885,
0.0996677727,
0.0384945683,
-0.2303421646,
-0.0176023934,
-0.1593679935,
-0.4961109757,
0.394833535,
-0.3055284917,
0.5823715329,
0.3716222644,
0.0707533211,
-0.147800982,
-0.9696862698,
0.0685595348,
0.2256341875,
-0.5360755324,
-0.8583230972,
0.2926347852,
-0.2490675449,
0.0313832462,
0.1456397325,
-0.6321253181,
0.1184173077,
-0.531391561,
0.272388339,
0.5805919766,
0.0890875235,
0.5443382263,
-0.4763207734,
0.4577881992,
0.2050912827,
-0.1852028221,
-0.1998107284,
0.0336050764,
-0.7648679614,
-0.0927677825,
0.1542987078,
0.6627694368,
-0.9853698015,
0.0583966002,
-0.4462849796,
-0.348580718,
-0.7064578533,
0.1006280482,
0.5895944834,
0.4864557683,
0.5394243598,
0.1913762391,
-0.4379848242,
-0.6733528972,
-0.6725043058,
-0.224697873,
0.1700536907,
0.0104561914,
0.4129322469,
-0.1754551679,
0.9001889825,
-0.1859958023,
0.0349420235,
-0.3521077931,
0.1625088751,
-0.0667376593,
0.6031805277,
0.2816304862,
-0.8553361297,
-0.0940638632,
0.1090585217,
-0.7087439895,
0.2626988888,
0.095261611,
0.1338956952,
0.5146155953,
0.4764304459,
-0.4935985506,
0.4646471143,
0.2287036479,
-0.0957316607,
0.4297532737,
-0.5648645759,
0.1853782833,
-0.6100552082,
0.0992196202,
-0.1980769783,
0.106893003,
-0.5367447138,
0.2827936113,
0.1866373271,
0.22213386,
-0.1605921686,
0.639236331,
-0.6401332617,
-0.0586121269,
-0.1421391815,
0.0861067846,
0.2286155373,
0.2047744393,
-0.1621835232,
0.7408175468,
0.3386546075,
-0.7946950793,
0.1039685234,
0.5118415952,
-0.3859725296,
0.4494394958,
-0.688724339,
0.3168509305,
-0.6582101583,
-0.0048380429,
-1.0891691446,
-0.3203164637,
0.077535063,
-0.439748615,
0.6721872091,
-0.0610793978,
-0.5415819287,
-0.2540543675,
-0.2101403177,
0.4221239388,
0.3497687578,
-0.6632608771,
0.6304816008,
-0.0315194987,
-0.1090946645,
-0.9444936514,
-0.8532931805,
-0.1191159561,
-0.0861849859,
-0.5859137774,
0.1525737941,
-0.1093007326,
-0.5850923061,
0.157058686,
-0.145254761,
-0.0696187764,
0.1238340735,
-0.2057395279,
0.1635512561,
-0.2937987447,
0.6395514607,
0.0274315402,
0.1010702103,
-0.1423012614,
0.1284220219,
0.3564892709,
-0.085258469,
-0.6592212915,
0.0734827593,
0.37141487,
0.5272622705,
-0.6762738824,
1.1737016439,
0.1023107618,
-0.1887612045,
-0.2124583572,
-0.9470091462,
-0.1756296307,
-0.4098453224,
0.3688482344,
-0.4357476234,
-0.9929057956,
0.8951708674,
0.2518975437,
0.1302907914,
0.447306335,
0.0613939017,
0.1813662052,
1.0732357502,
0.6251446605,
0.2229049057,
0.302470088,
0.0241230577,
0.1949302703,
-0.9872785211,
-0.3803363442,
-0.9015022516,
-0.212019518,
-0.5316261053,
-0.1028208062,
0.2688881159,
0.4395342171,
-0.4478858113,
-0.0475460403,
-0.4204702675,
0.6434176564,
0.4985299408,
0.2056838572,
0.6228651404,
0.1784831434,
-0.1629624069,
0.1359640658,
-0.8700599074,
-0.4952642918,
0.9007847309,
0.0427447446,
0.9664700627,
0.4386387765,
0.6612573266,
0.1145039797,
0.2617075741,
-0.5333247781,
0.1499684751,
-0.0204083826,
-0.9602435231,
-0.2770379186,
-0.4944516122,
-1.0569521189,
0.4885747731,
-0.1217813492,
-0.801222384,
0.5502668023,
0.2229668498,
-0.2953318655,
0.4260458648,
-0.5794932842,
0.6065171957,
-0.1077643111,
-0.4909647107,
-0.1277507544,
-0.8014512658,
0.424651593,
-0.06316109,
0.2967293262,
0.1892667562,
0.1123154759,
0.4660894275,
-0.3243189752,
0.5069041252,
-0.1667256057,
-0.0711106062,
0.417219758,
0.4684829414,
0.7285318375,
-0.296857357,
-0.4471701682,
-0.3616269529,
0.1526924372,
-0.5279468894,
-0.5449098945,
0.5100957155,
-0.8279294372,
-0.5978864431,
-0.4276435971,
-0.4888365865,
-0.4426490366,
0.0347202718,
0.3556399345,
0.7587759495,
-0.2942135334,
0.2612856627,
1.0754414797,
-0.3481968939,
0.5201654434,
0.7247973084,
-0.2631516159,
-0.2445397973,
0.8815798759,
0.1650081873,
0.4471644461,
0.7659112215,
-0.0096946284,
-0.4776901305,
-0.7534703612,
-0.2440837026,
0.1864841282,
-0.835632205,
-0.1514012814,
-0.7187322974,
-0.1376297921,
-0.3101429045,
0.1915236264,
-0.0515214317,
-0.3533195853,
-0.3761716783,
-0.2301533371,
0.4519842267,
0.6961248517,
-0.1995164901,
0.1348125786,
-1.2162864208,
-0.0438152626,
0.2565001845,
0.2224167287,
0.315708518,
-0.804841876,
-0.2080729008,
0.0914611667,
-0.1759696156,
-0.6398616433,
0.4013722539,
0.3352653384,
0.7278586626,
0.2666498721,
0.3062579632,
0.4882900715,
-0.4589426816,
0.6429545283,
-0.0339736454,
-0.5736401677,
0.466999501,
-0.3642190993,
0.0945470557,
0.6364836693,
0.1237925738,
-0.3099595606,
-0.3654978573,
-0.5741128325,
-0.8705774546,
0.6597263813,
-0.1286212057,
0.1116441563,
-0.3797438145,
0.3580949306,
0.2952425182,
0.1395666897,
-0.4151857495,
-0.1201036349,
-0.1047794223,
-0.1405252218,
-0.0673431084,
-0.538356185,
-0.126233831,
0.0630505234,
0.7862606645,
0.0095400475,
0.2407792211,
0.4737952352,
-0.4928402603,
-0.3672900796,
0.5499147773,
0.604149878,
0.932403028,
-0.3002246618,
0.2658572197,
-0.0714117512,
-0.3725027144,
0.2465025783,
0.1774518341,
-0.1049215943,
-0.1359517425,
0.3858659267,
0.7133105397,
0.1819204092,
-0.8315633535,
0.2376817465,
0.0665652826,
0.0616076179,
-0.1270585209,
0.1464489549,
-0.0014593032,
0.2558615208,
0.7922232747,
0.4744104147,
-0.0489410572,
-0.3480559289,
0.0505419746,
0.4608058333,
-0.241161108,
-0.3718287349,
0.7262577415,
0.1835131943,
-0.2956365347,
0.7151704431,
-0.1952227205,
-0.3227703571,
0.5366373062,
0.5269062519,
0.7492553592,
-0.5073767304,
0.1144692674,
0.3449728787,
0.4473429322,
-0.4041942656,
0.1261565536,
0.1409534812,
-1.0330240726,
-0.5471115708,
-0.5926392078,
-0.3025692403,
0.0525520034,
-0.9973878264,
-0.3230469227,
-0.1358883083,
0.3148819208,
-0.2277417332,
-0.1441777349,
-0.6912328601,
0.0393495075,
-0.3431065083,
0.9757393599,
-0.4881017506,
0.6553063989,
0.7418730855,
-0.6714962125,
-0.7568446994,
-0.0427073054,
-0.2287527472,
-0.7543916106,
0.8913862705,
-0.1872133017,
-0.1627318263,
0.199019894,
-0.545363605,
-0.7681332827,
0.9740880728,
0.2709476352,
-0.6451758742,
0.0369970575,
-0.1063176915,
0.6421621442,
0.0351447202,
0.3508468568,
0.4245001376,
0.2877047062,
0.2702513337,
-0.9257053733,
-0.1604312956,
-0.099212423,
0.006701774,
0.3998772502,
-0.6301634908,
0.8091183305,
-0.4121216238,
-0.2561825812,
0.2856514752,
0.4077660739,
0.3473071754,
0.352882117,
0.1656260788,
0.7129751444,
1.0665540695,
-0.0259773917,
1.2320410013,
-0.0489207618,
0.4282619953,
1.0921059847,
-0.5015997887,
1.1031955481,
0.4817360044,
-0.2509910166,
0.4495523572,
0.2595487833,
0.3257173598,
0.5633745193,
-0.0022236423,
-0.5204077959,
-0.3607035577,
0.2056971639,
-0.4819068909,
0.4813354611,
0.3370495141,
-0.3372609615,
-0.412573874,
0.1635346562,
-0.2169514894,
0.1933722347,
-0.4427876472,
0.7565692067,
-0.1909188777,
-0.7077784538,
0.7810943127,
-0.2164967209,
0.5661764741,
-0.4126579762,
-0.0038896117,
-0.3640202582,
0.6088311672,
-0.199090153,
-0.5227558613,
0.3798809946,
-0.1395868361,
-0.5249037743,
0.0049162162,
1.0546884537,
-0.4515967965,
-0.3911558092,
0.2179197818,
0.9811554551,
0.0686073974,
-0.0491821803,
-0.4375680387,
0.1572078317,
-0.0956665501,
-0.3765740097,
0.519426167,
0.640060842,
0.1464360952,
0.8044903874,
0.4516487122,
-0.1642333269,
0.2078552395,
-0.1650315523,
0.7278136015,
-0.5062102675,
-0.0663680658,
-0.6940698624,
0.5199747682,
0.1385796666,
-0.0815959051,
0.7755323648,
0.4585286677,
0.7631318569,
-0.1648665965,
0.7607204318,
-0.0858267546,
1.1562616825,
-0.4411718845,
0.877104342,
-0.5985835791,
0.5655029416,
-0.073478274,
-0.8558349013,
-0.2593316138,
0.5784429908,
-0.2881004214,
0.0901137069,
0.53865695,
0.8068427444,
0.0032461861,
0.1145944223,
0.3008576035,
0.4311236441,
0.3356406391,
0.3929590285,
1.1151323318,
-0.4781450033,
0.6916365027,
0.0346807465,
-0.0500418842,
-0.3351243436,
-0.7995061874,
-0.6439042687,
-0.398065865,
-0.3819987476,
-0.4222825468,
0.3135183454,
0.7588760257,
0.191459626,
-0.8410109282,
0.1258483082,
-0.1896769106,
0.2724823952,
-0.2338843197,
-0.2913343012,
0.3147447109,
-0.5141475797,
-0.4989931881,
0.4147864878,
0.0519644432,
-0.0654065311,
-0.0535527505,
-0.0187616479,
-0.2817732692,
0.0779126883,
0.5320788622,
0.7588377595,
-0.6891841292,
-0.5054498315,
0.243494913,
-0.0700276271,
0.2127743512,
0.5045920014,
-1.0144256353,
0.6594917774,
0.5585606098,
0.8535752296,
0.2260415107,
0.0935815051,
0.2040916383,
-0.6537922025,
-0.1357722431,
0.3299503922,
0.2376511246,
0.4341696799,
-0.2068126053,
0.4883500934,
0.0510236658,
-0.8461865783,
-1.0401741266,
0.1653899252,
-0.7194417715,
-0.426156491,
1.0164890289,
-0.05087699,
-0.1368479133,
-0.2343515009,
-0.023803398,
0.0217526089,
-0.1802892834,
0.7873254418,
0.8297319412,
-0.268565625,
-0.2619407773,
-0.5130137801,
0.3319648802,
0.3625065088,
-0.6503879428,
0.1686655581,
0.6813375354,
0.5328212976,
0.3841587305,
0.4706902802,
-0.1616266817,
0.1477175951,
-0.0940453857,
0.0370719396,
-0.0346143954,
-0.0744320229,
-0.4817284048,
0.1955946833,
0.3444556892,
-0.1169651523
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20671v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20671v1
|
Position Coupling: Leveraging Task Structure for Improved Length Generalization of Transformers
| 2024-05-31T08:13:35 | 2024-05-31T08:13:35 |
Hanseul Cho, Jaeyoung Cha, Pranjal Awasthi, Srinadh Bhojanapalli, Anupam Gupta, Chulhee Yun
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Even for simple arithmetic tasks like integer addition, it is challenging for
Transformers to generalize to longer sequences than those encountered during
training. To tackle this problem, we propose position coupling, a simple yet
effective method that directly embeds the structure of the tasks into the
positional encoding of a (decoder-only) Transformer. Taking a departure from
the vanilla absolute position mechanism assigning unique position IDs to each
of the tokens, we assign the same position IDs to two or more "relevant"
tokens; for integer addition tasks, we regard digits of the same significance
as in the same position. On the empirical side, we show that with the proposed
position coupling, a small (1-layer) Transformer trained on 1 to 30-digit
additions can generalize up to 200-digit additions (6.67x of the trained
length). On the theoretical side, we prove that a 1-layer Transformer with
coupled positions can solve the addition task involving exponentially many
digits, whereas any 1-layer Transformer without positional information cannot
entirely solve it. We also demonstrate that position coupling can be applied to
other algorithmic tasks such as addition with multiple summands, Nx2
multiplication, copy/reverse, and a two-dimensional task.
|
[
-0.5281817913,
-0.2473537326,
0.5341043472,
0.5068666339,
-0.2635498643,
-0.0204216093,
-0.0736082047,
-0.4982317686,
0.3538115919,
0.2204705775,
-0.368745625,
-0.1018452197,
-0.6960944533,
-0.2017664909,
-0.3851473927,
0.7745680809,
0.1740356982,
-0.3760153055,
-0.3676835001,
-0.1067605317,
-0.4810033739,
-0.72552526,
-0.4697859287,
-0.377581507,
0.6395910382,
0.5836338401,
0.9227619171,
0.8610296249,
0.8942369819,
0.3703895807,
0.060215205,
0.0849587992,
-0.0856297612,
0.0911976472,
-0.3489001393,
-0.747133553,
-0.6933807731,
-0.322612524,
0.7223975658,
1.0616286993,
0.1921001971,
0.3590258658,
-0.1229065359,
0.8277592063,
-0.6116393805,
-0.0083851209,
-0.1542315483,
0.185025245,
-0.2221318781,
-0.3602404892,
-0.4052394927,
-0.0549920425,
-0.0628240407,
-0.4287154973,
0.5668940544,
-0.2814536989,
0.3919573426,
0.6433212161,
-0.6914263368,
-0.0416517295,
-1.1460087299,
0.5953150392,
-0.331851691,
0.6888520122,
0.1885632426,
0.0730591342,
0.1933670938,
-0.4499610066,
-0.4603931308,
0.0272761844,
-0.4263931513,
0.2415841073,
0.1753967106,
-0.0058074472,
0.6199636459,
0.1505601108,
-0.2155928016,
-0.0564118773,
-0.4876716733,
0.1203686222,
0.6982365251,
0.0700552911,
0.3181185126,
-0.0763203949,
-0.3522965908,
-0.6260786653,
-0.6566923261,
0.3500214219,
0.536930263,
0.0910405517,
-0.273540318,
0.7366897464,
0.1528635472,
0.6120502949,
0.6401973367,
0.2101858705,
0.0963168368,
-0.4285560846,
0.0440762527,
0.2644004524,
0.595492065,
0.2146564126,
-0.2206149548,
-0.3159956634,
-0.1336183399,
0.1797903776,
0.7370465398,
-0.693987906,
-0.2238256633,
0.0272721965,
-0.2135381699,
-0.2108352929,
0.4559836686,
-0.3270139992,
-0.0514677204,
-0.4476663768,
0.3498597443,
-0.2888720632,
0.0206004642,
-0.0904823318,
-0.4784694612,
0.5956919193,
-0.0323560648,
-1.4390296936,
0.5078181624,
1.0897897482,
0.7137430906,
-0.2271208018,
-0.4091540873,
-0.5117947459,
0.4888927639,
-0.4000985026,
0.7259238958,
-0.520049274,
-0.5365951657,
-0.2931063175,
0.0939518064,
0.0110402396,
-0.435757488,
0.4734447002,
-0.6383296251,
0.0823707432,
-0.1422178596,
-0.2757674456,
0.2388792336,
-0.1205815002,
-0.8652052283,
1.137588501,
0.3068610132,
-0.4863874316,
0.0424006954,
-0.8858821392,
-0.878159821,
-0.2873053551,
0.0263448134,
-0.5028409958,
0.5132661462,
0.3481184244,
0.2080195099,
-0.0173830856,
0.0208322294,
-0.1171644479,
-0.7804878354,
0.2036889344,
-0.2985980213,
0.6084070802,
-0.2209276706,
-0.2904104292,
0.1338613629,
-0.3359744549,
-0.3967308998,
-0.0326188505,
-0.2423179448,
-0.3231345415,
-0.2298474163,
-0.3742209375,
0.1722881347,
0.3977714479,
-0.3774096668,
0.6103509068,
-0.5748543143,
0.1976180822,
0.3982903063,
-0.132111907,
1.2591164112,
-0.251635015,
0.4453788698,
0.0804301575,
0.0857486948,
-0.1550856829,
-0.2666763067,
-0.8731666803,
0.1917224228,
0.5173669457,
0.7167760134,
-0.8958039284,
0.7740079761,
-0.8109252453,
-0.4647484422,
-0.2508883476,
-0.0898328051,
0.1658760011,
0.3660755455,
0.4778719246,
-0.3879048824,
-0.3785572946,
-0.8130758405,
-0.0356917232,
-0.0569582768,
-0.6767881513,
-0.2212315798,
0.3061209023,
0.1926885098,
0.6914255619,
-0.6374748945,
-0.2362275869,
0.2087322176,
0.0480512828,
0.7011797428,
0.8949734569,
0.4427625239,
-0.7850047946,
-0.4634205103,
-0.1220812574,
-0.8145169616,
0.3542503715,
-0.2394960225,
-0.1386371404,
-0.3206156194,
0.3893108368,
-0.8428432941,
0.2796403468,
0.4638440907,
-0.2513821125,
0.1801992357,
-0.3847596645,
0.0776269883,
-1.1601111889,
-0.1599293053,
0.1092867926,
-0.2187781334,
-0.91299963,
0.1747184545,
0.3725367188,
-0.3483130932,
-0.3948346078,
0.0251959059,
-0.5511983037,
-0.2176313847,
-0.3657048345,
-0.2157164961,
-0.1551818848,
0.8073757291,
0.0053059692,
0.8349323273,
0.4802393019,
-0.5461596847,
0.4645336866,
0.4406675994,
0.0967815444,
0.5839397907,
-0.7757515311,
0.398873508,
-0.1523188353,
0.3399218619,
-0.9215545058,
-0.1174568161,
0.1386001706,
-0.6153656244,
0.3323191404,
-0.4816614985,
-0.274679333,
-0.3831088245,
-0.4488153756,
1.0286602974,
0.6689266562,
-0.5965009928,
0.6455629468,
0.1871153116,
-0.141975224,
-0.7419807315,
-0.7628396749,
-0.0746948943,
-0.2726064622,
-0.9408509135,
1.1025336981,
0.2351662666,
0.1630717367,
0.0579009056,
-0.5159230232,
-0.0043823249,
-0.056247592,
0.2466562688,
0.4456416368,
-0.1535464674,
-0.0745759904,
0.4241417646,
-0.5859743953,
0.1845272779,
-0.3997444212,
0.4092684984,
0.0775547549,
-0.6473619938,
-0.2626599073,
0.4889990687,
0.7363300323,
-0.101406768,
0.6126252413,
0.8027680516,
-0.4498287737,
0.0070851129,
-0.2713420391,
-0.3592248559,
-0.5998113751,
0.201942578,
-0.4959031045,
-0.7348464727,
0.2952558994,
-0.0755504966,
-0.0083796708,
0.3048845232,
0.2082701176,
-0.1795084476,
1.1710710526,
0.7336851954,
-0.1107935682,
0.625562191,
-0.4694352448,
0.5776190162,
-0.9002494216,
-0.1530088633,
-0.3352052569,
-0.8386784196,
-0.4988178611,
-0.7584139705,
0.4634448886,
0.2545630932,
-0.0919454247,
0.8269048333,
-0.8973798156,
0.5777739882,
0.8292277455,
0.2159331739,
-0.0773350224,
-0.0366028175,
0.031827841,
-0.0025764015,
-0.6008437276,
0.1091335937,
0.7261286974,
0.2337940782,
0.6274931431,
0.3481551707,
0.7745169401,
0.2192819417,
-0.1386045367,
-1.0407676697,
0.4053123295,
-0.4305669665,
-0.1032327563,
-0.3894303739,
-0.1153227314,
-0.722215116,
0.0657144189,
-0.0497372523,
-0.4391976595,
0.5047497749,
0.3207702041,
-0.3667863309,
0.1683010906,
-0.759460032,
0.4332582355,
-0.2682090104,
-0.4285710454,
-0.2544650733,
-0.8119876981,
0.088982448,
0.3002071977,
-0.0707713068,
0.2223058492,
-0.1954656094,
0.7961472273,
-0.6474192142,
0.6923791766,
-0.2044495195,
-0.3019135594,
0.0031068334,
0.0216800794,
0.7689906359,
0.0852455944,
0.088902019,
0.0619641468,
-0.2520988286,
-0.6012439132,
-1.0830258131,
0.8767111301,
-0.7947077155,
-0.7377294898,
-0.1101217344,
-0.8705393076,
-0.3974837363,
0.0221339613,
0.2577031255,
0.6885045171,
0.4851891994,
0.2842277288,
0.5098868012,
0.4542130828,
0.6300935745,
-0.0350719653,
0.4299702048,
-0.4835767746,
0.9976831079,
-0.0415579006,
0.0370600261,
1.0298730135,
0.0635823756,
-0.5037268996,
-0.2666477859,
-0.2939448059,
0.242080912,
-0.5183492303,
-0.0866878182,
-0.2687362432,
-0.1871460676,
-0.4392596781,
-0.6031573415,
-0.3957574666,
-0.9367866516,
0.1218924373,
-0.0731878132,
0.1584080011,
0.4253895879,
-0.1530330032,
0.5434677601,
-1.1540411711,
0.7084683776,
0.7274237275,
0.5150456429,
0.1727357656,
-0.2964785993,
-0.3599608243,
0.0244368855,
-0.3625632823,
-0.6374833584,
0.0282346755,
-0.1306315958,
0.3532376289,
0.2898885012,
-0.0347323939,
0.979334712,
-0.6973842382,
0.7606645226,
0.3948442638,
-1.0545203686,
0.2698941827,
-0.2343128622,
0.4299340844,
0.3346722424,
0.4686303139,
-0.4570563436,
0.0522294231,
-0.4964170754,
-0.8968485594,
0.999346137,
0.4222486913,
0.1699955612,
0.0604779758,
0.2115818709,
-0.3193205297,
-0.1438302845,
-0.1978713721,
-0.5670565367,
-0.2934075594,
-0.4061137736,
0.1268885732,
-0.1894606501,
-0.2284516841,
-0.5082883239,
0.3704324365,
-0.1177505776,
0.9638081789,
0.2566393912,
-0.3640446961,
-0.0973061323,
0.2088674158,
0.61525774,
0.6812825203,
0.1058734283,
0.4505843818,
0.4676178396,
-0.3849314451,
0.5619181395,
0.1206041127,
0.0928055495,
0.0214057714,
0.3985777199,
0.7379618883,
0.4953727722,
0.1351312846,
0.4874551594,
0.2121107131,
-0.2010071874,
-0.3615178466,
0.0801734105,
0.4483093917,
0.2935166657,
0.5635672212,
0.3954913318,
0.0429173335,
-0.2092975676,
0.4148961902,
0.2481924146,
-0.7396115661,
-0.7834727764,
0.730668962,
0.3796637654,
-0.8556303382,
0.5966279507,
0.029723594,
-0.4204167426,
0.7276268601,
0.7784015536,
0.6812634468,
-0.415599823,
0.0454488322,
0.4487583637,
0.1330028027,
-0.2098716944,
-0.0514160655,
-0.5774568915,
-0.6073769331,
-0.8209626079,
-0.2407231033,
-0.4508515596,
-0.4725444019,
-0.7984475493,
0.3229332268,
-0.2175625116,
-0.1225616485,
0.0027904615,
-0.4087851644,
-0.758643806,
-0.2207136154,
0.2808758616,
0.6645637155,
-0.596835494,
0.7887302637,
0.9856168032,
-0.006300848,
-0.6513077617,
-0.1732753217,
-0.3552652001,
-0.6199266315,
0.4509735703,
0.2166374177,
-0.1848775893,
0.0225982685,
-0.1470519155,
-0.9189576507,
1.2799441814,
0.2889579833,
-0.5224527121,
-0.6388503313,
0.6117911935,
0.3945945501,
0.0041476837,
0.2559535801,
0.4088322222,
0.2721758485,
0.1953976899,
-0.7671108842,
0.2505904436,
-0.4286451042,
0.2029982656,
0.7743765712,
-0.5855263472,
0.5850782394,
-0.1064931452,
-0.1911264658,
-0.0320632309,
0.6288345456,
-0.0387341529,
-0.1127200276,
0.7041118741,
0.6065255404,
0.3106885254,
-0.120229356,
0.9581753612,
-0.5297468901,
0.4968900979,
0.9781258702,
0.1178030148,
0.5129195452,
0.5502955317,
-0.464715451,
0.4746881127,
-0.0190985221,
-0.0237431973,
0.5167167783,
-0.3130227327,
-0.3216932118,
-0.3025082946,
0.0238251351,
-0.2989133,
0.1619298607,
0.4499263167,
-0.3106826246,
-0.1057284176,
0.028374644,
-0.350194633,
-0.1168550774,
-0.1626633853,
0.781822741,
0.1444519311,
-0.8911728859,
0.5217462778,
-0.060510505,
0.8386325836,
-0.6176905632,
-0.2635528743,
0.0273438487,
0.092179656,
-0.4061121941,
-0.9919316173,
0.6848979592,
-0.4296745658,
-0.4194893539,
-0.4456521273,
0.7564195991,
-0.4391810298,
-0.61145854,
0.0670009628,
0.1617891788,
-0.342092067,
-0.0816310197,
-0.1743650138,
-0.2903974056,
-0.2144458741,
0.1632232666,
0.3372081518,
0.1843348891,
-0.1729469448,
0.2617128193,
0.8593399525,
-0.2948673368,
0.0838350505,
0.0355326943,
0.7840520144,
-1.041636467,
-0.6122981906,
-0.7970175743,
0.6321088672,
-0.0110592982,
0.0490542203,
0.5071597695,
0.304571569,
0.9293238521,
-0.3805061579,
0.5576555729,
-0.1689571291,
-0.1091186106,
-0.2119700164,
0.183917582,
-0.2233341485,
0.2127243131,
0.0168917365,
-1.4335081577,
-0.3703922629,
0.4905355573,
-0.2708469033,
-0.3879140317,
0.8470885158,
0.5299601555,
-0.4425578713,
-0.2434479892,
0.2332021296,
-0.4018453062,
0.3828641474,
0.770496726,
0.7935143113,
-0.7038626671,
0.6990686059,
-0.9007564187,
0.0369280018,
-0.0615992881,
-0.6436987519,
-0.6641404033,
-0.5026554465,
-0.1265882254,
0.1589346826,
-0.2988776863,
0.7734164596,
0.8025978208,
-0.6823906898,
-0.2747045755,
-0.1684193611,
0.1636502892,
-0.6929059625,
-0.2601278126,
0.4015643001,
-0.1242702976,
-1.0353739262,
0.6102684736,
0.2848028541,
0.0432004444,
0.035596218,
0.1193114668,
0.0660254955,
-0.1520999819,
0.8137865663,
0.2272885144,
-0.4157416224,
-0.6231979132,
0.3779258728,
0.1710892767,
0.2316790968,
1.1946293116,
-0.7332228422,
0.0684856847,
0.8395164013,
0.6165412068,
0.7318744659,
0.5729534626,
0.7372941375,
-1.1660826206,
0.3447803557,
0.1148131788,
0.3883917034,
0.2492536753,
-0.4502772391,
0.4649387002,
-0.0954160839,
-0.2944940329,
-0.3910985291,
0.3665649295,
-1.2403166294,
0.1258595139,
0.7250518203,
0.1373957694,
-0.2241858989,
0.1239274889,
-0.0259462446,
0.4082389474,
-0.1900719255,
0.7199098468,
0.2768456042,
-0.3349253237,
0.0532637201,
0.1937966645,
0.2666509449,
0.5140672922,
-0.539518714,
-0.3308781385,
-0.0539714061,
0.1296927482,
0.7796696424,
0.1399929821,
-0.0860151574,
0.5085591674,
0.1348778456,
-0.2147739679,
-0.4595982432,
-0.4957039058,
-0.3589868248,
0.3785818219,
-0.042800799,
-0.4840143919
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20657v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20657v2
|
DORY: Deliberative Prompt Recovery for LLM
| 2024-05-31T07:51:16 | 2024-06-07T17:00:00 |
Lirong Gao, Ru Peng, Yiming Zhang, Junbo Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Prompt recovery in large language models (LLMs) is crucial for understanding
how LLMs work and addressing concerns regarding privacy, copyright, etc. The
trend towards inference-only APIs complicates this task by restricting access
to essential outputs for recovery. To tackle this challenge, we extract
prompt-related information from limited outputs and identify a strong(negative)
correlation between output probability-based uncertainty and the success of
prompt recovery. This finding led to the development of Deliberative PrOmpt
RecoverY (DORY), our novel approach that leverages uncertainty to recover
prompts accurately. DORY involves reconstructing drafts from outputs, refining
these with hints, and filtering out noise based on uncertainty. Our evaluation
across diverse LLMs and prompt benchmarks shows that DORY outperforms existing
baselines, improving performance by approximately 10.82% and establishing a new
state-of-the-art record in prompt recovery tasks. Significantly, DORY operates
using a single LLM without any external resources or model, offering a
cost-effective, user-friendly prompt recovery solution.
|
[
0.0318263806,
-0.7056109309,
0.919950664,
0.0577690601,
-0.1844855249,
0.2803164423,
-0.3103156686,
-0.29910779,
0.2403300554,
0.6037130952,
-1.008507967,
-0.416074127,
-0.8794409633,
0.2739007175,
-0.103279449,
0.9919245243,
0.2294181883,
0.0327647105,
0.1852168292,
0.3243519068,
-0.5096851587,
-0.1789966524,
-0.8996936679,
0.0550480299,
0.6492590308,
0.4644473493,
0.2869140804,
0.4286760092,
0.4648225605,
0.2475320697,
0.0416554846,
0.2809366882,
-0.613322556,
0.5453863144,
0.0516909249,
-0.5393535495,
-0.4250104725,
0.1132436544,
0.502607584,
0.51964432,
-0.3102757931,
-0.2450441718,
0.093584083,
0.5474423766,
-0.8461089134,
0.3011223972,
-0.8121750951,
0.0838992521,
0.0272378139,
-0.498295486,
-0.5349382162,
-0.6652395725,
0.0082278522,
-0.7308303118,
0.1032713875,
0.1335099339,
0.1923552752,
0.6365380287,
-0.3021562099,
-0.5274871588,
-0.8732757568,
0.8702656627,
-0.908927083,
0.0563933849,
0.3891822696,
0.3090461791,
-0.5685682297,
-0.9526164532,
-0.4714072943,
-0.2764026225,
0.2396000028,
0.4498657286,
-0.3032559752,
0.0557439514,
0.3684527278,
0.5386455655,
-0.2122836113,
0.2628502548,
-0.0868605301,
-0.4135033786,
0.5454862118,
0.3231932521,
0.1958580464,
-0.0801879317,
-0.4355084002,
0.012364082,
-0.7752831578,
-0.0236978196,
0.3320513666,
0.5872350931,
0.0021379185,
0.2604123652,
-0.2629092634,
0.484221071,
0.1411476731,
-0.2662429512,
0.2865476012,
-0.2010410428,
-0.1005766988,
0.2634386718,
0.8310973048,
0.2542599738,
-0.1560242176,
-0.1097487435,
-0.3771898448,
-0.2419580966,
0.1053559557,
-0.5736427903,
-0.3242234886,
0.2838595808,
-0.4794472754,
-0.192081064,
-0.0963711143,
-0.6835038662,
-0.9253008366,
-0.363014847,
0.1997562349,
-0.3643541634,
-0.586748004,
0.0874993503,
0.0000235925,
0.261084348,
0.932895422,
-0.624594748,
0.1056140736,
0.8107807636,
0.6735875607,
-0.2903982997,
0.0397984385,
-0.9378632903,
-0.0651815981,
-0.308570087,
0.6369121075,
-0.2988490462,
-0.5776315331,
0.0104352804,
0.1879944056,
0.0662973449,
-0.5298187137,
0.8276072741,
-0.5094004869,
0.0493323021,
-0.7078458667,
-0.4977544248,
0.0639575422,
0.4051427245,
-0.9507338405,
0.5624372363,
-0.2578354478,
-0.8919929862,
0.3956447542,
-0.2219882458,
-0.063634038,
0.1651564091,
-0.2515760362,
0.1514078528,
0.3209327757,
0.1568294019,
0.1744265705,
-0.45784536,
0.0827599093,
-0.7130874991,
-0.2255293131,
0.3686819971,
-0.9787342548,
0.8478130102,
0.226332292,
-0.0935682803,
0.0781842545,
-0.9728811979,
-0.1734423637,
-0.1915682256,
-0.4472331405,
-0.3156521618,
-0.1040443778,
-0.5610411763,
0.1593300998,
0.525165081,
-1.0782299042,
0.0869197175,
-0.5006984472,
0.5184968114,
0.7464651465,
0.2663772106,
0.4102300107,
-0.4157568216,
0.697106421,
0.0823328644,
-0.287079066,
-0.2695723474,
-0.1719820499,
-0.4577328265,
-0.905344069,
0.1502266526,
0.8335600495,
-0.7465524673,
0.1836678386,
-0.0579597838,
-0.3378794193,
-0.7696635723,
-0.1018230319,
0.3681255579,
0.8062864542,
-0.0080964146,
0.0998190939,
-0.6787846088,
-0.7259700298,
-0.1080519855,
-0.4525982141,
-0.2572355568,
0.3045168817,
-0.0155206099,
0.2125690579,
0.8650717139,
-0.5820627213,
-0.0251562502,
-0.151431784,
-0.0305557288,
0.6550590992,
0.3113889098,
0.1093221456,
-0.5110108256,
-0.1676293463,
-0.3314265311,
-0.8050423265,
-0.1718143076,
-0.2298404723,
-0.3138256073,
0.2899722755,
0.4348049164,
-1.1086332798,
0.5500580668,
0.0730244219,
-0.2401068062,
0.6910271645,
-0.2697613835,
0.2051986009,
-1.0594118834,
-0.0328663029,
-0.4659871459,
-0.3681875765,
-0.2871540189,
-0.2931918204,
0.0150786219,
0.1670301706,
-0.1574123651,
0.5316178799,
-0.3984884024,
0.1165040955,
-0.3290891349,
0.3196589649,
-0.0781153142,
0.093918547,
0.2334168255,
0.7012266517,
0.5681922436,
-0.4522296488,
0.2337379307,
0.2093790025,
-0.0587826855,
0.5762542486,
-0.577231586,
0.2703181803,
-0.3006080091,
0.126635924,
-1.5112206936,
-0.4498103261,
0.6951117516,
-0.2833563983,
0.4011557698,
-0.0506789684,
-0.2029876113,
-0.2992421687,
-0.5729832649,
-0.2304812074,
0.5327373743,
-0.6639539599,
0.7224828601,
0.2966122925,
-0.5602933168,
-1.0442858934,
-0.5685300827,
-0.0702487826,
-0.1072474793,
-0.1470534503,
0.053892374,
-0.2829406261,
-0.4611722231,
-0.1549699754,
-0.4547314048,
-0.0832570866,
0.3391566575,
0.5146314502,
0.4187105,
0.0513296798,
0.1027892008,
0.2259351611,
-0.0721782967,
0.2522581816,
-0.3638216257,
0.1494712681,
0.1731172949,
-0.3727115691,
-0.2104556561,
0.3475589454,
0.4237804115,
0.1169979647,
0.4000352025,
0.4119257033,
-0.3237861097,
-0.4560828209,
-0.5863055587,
-0.1758263707,
-0.465192914,
0.1944343597,
-0.3103875518,
-0.8368139863,
0.5348806381,
-0.07714919,
0.4745344222,
0.140968889,
0.7281200886,
-0.1575355977,
0.438156724,
0.3977339864,
0.092835173,
0.3123364449,
0.1515770406,
0.262681514,
-0.5302051902,
-0.392852217,
-0.4461716712,
-0.0783225968,
-0.2224310338,
-0.2125077546,
-0.0215271842,
0.2397909313,
0.0530631244,
-0.0222031604,
-0.3818166852,
0.1738901287,
0.9889947772,
0.3677318096,
0.6893649101,
0.0181371383,
0.2648497224,
-0.1810734123,
-0.2999742031,
-0.7933645844,
0.9049637318,
0.0575877205,
1.0302038193,
0.2650955319,
1.142386198,
0.3110753298,
0.2171833366,
-0.9957991242,
0.6069786549,
0.1050730124,
-0.5094451904,
-0.2988880873,
-0.6175100803,
-1.0374654531,
0.1149676964,
-0.0531982444,
-0.7913495898,
0.1745766997,
0.315456152,
-0.6945011616,
0.3096041381,
-0.5313639045,
0.3916298151,
0.1378379613,
-0.2658027112,
0.0025842481,
-0.7086000443,
0.3452284336,
-0.3321767747,
0.0916015282,
-0.331109792,
-0.3125442863,
0.5244542956,
-0.5129395723,
1.0620923042,
-0.3711663187,
-0.2750881612,
0.5949222445,
0.39621526,
0.303899169,
0.3819473386,
-0.2371912748,
-0.0129934847,
0.3155006766,
0.1363511533,
-0.6968486309,
0.9463887215,
-0.811519146,
-0.8110342026,
-0.2292511761,
-0.9412964582,
-0.201633364,
0.1943701506,
0.0741413534,
0.3901686966,
-0.2209864408,
-0.0930239782,
0.681845963,
-0.2166205645,
1.1561057568,
0.9082543254,
-0.0474332832,
-0.5355562568,
0.7450395226,
0.0578309856,
-0.1334107518,
0.4374700785,
-0.0121418191,
-0.5134018064,
-0.7484287024,
-0.1162980273,
0.0716798455,
-0.7085143328,
-0.4582961202,
-0.7539869547,
-0.1232288778,
-0.3519347012,
0.3017095029,
-0.1318883002,
-0.9955118895,
-0.6863998771,
-0.2033825964,
0.36532709,
0.8243229389,
-0.4174090624,
0.1807194054,
-1.0735195875,
0.036048457,
0.126524657,
0.1687086672,
0.0821035355,
-0.5669949651,
0.2245969474,
-0.1346787214,
-0.3392743766,
-0.8364138007,
0.4773528874,
-0.105984509,
0.6971024275,
0.1983046234,
0.6514331102,
0.2682462931,
-0.400588125,
0.8334349394,
0.2711959481,
-0.5721454024,
0.4932803214,
-0.2545072436,
0.3360658288,
0.6277346611,
0.3976758718,
-0.027362695,
-0.1164983734,
-0.3793851137,
-0.9238725305,
0.8118765354,
0.0084258886,
0.0088606225,
-0.4763233662,
0.4366859198,
0.512376368,
0.5684637427,
-0.3937755525,
0.1737931222,
0.1937799603,
-0.6251812577,
0.1839919835,
-0.5830508471,
-0.4001409411,
0.3993481696,
0.4365263581,
0.0976656526,
0.1683935374,
0.412086308,
-0.1204465777,
0.0983763114,
0.3924408555,
0.049538333,
0.5296453834,
-0.2469647974,
0.1302591413,
-0.0273580719,
-0.7067753673,
0.1498140246,
0.2951396108,
-0.1364686489,
-0.082991831,
0.634352386,
0.6768332124,
0.016710395,
-0.818051517,
0.6113089919,
-0.3872280419,
-0.1542646289,
-0.6104210615,
0.0655333847,
-0.2625897825,
0.5995044112,
0.5126476884,
0.3021712601,
0.4346075058,
-0.1660861522,
0.1685466468,
0.290689379,
-0.3453657627,
-0.4426751733,
0.631282866,
0.2324660122,
-0.4588544965,
0.649780035,
-0.1797766238,
0.2249232978,
0.4583330452,
0.6312406659,
1.0874762535,
0.0057849046,
0.1158851236,
0.3689523935,
-0.023016097,
-0.1672560573,
0.9757112861,
-0.0875788853,
-0.5669098496,
-0.6542975903,
-0.4429734349,
-0.3338235915,
-0.2745296955,
-0.9064472318,
-0.0634212643,
-0.9217928052,
-0.3881262839,
-0.4652026296,
0.0950163081,
-0.4470558465,
-0.1003962308,
0.3784095049,
1.1336972713,
-0.4519429505,
0.5652599335,
0.4478097558,
-0.3033046722,
-0.9374002218,
0.0193525068,
0.3421472311,
-0.6986909509,
0.7074623108,
0.2423957735,
-0.3600282073,
0.0611858405,
-0.6392619014,
-0.975435257,
1.2387126684,
0.8116124868,
-1.1811600924,
0.0351627469,
-0.5237435699,
0.2237062454,
-0.3841925859,
0.3799685538,
0.6222144961,
0.2199628949,
0.3844128847,
-0.7795493007,
0.3808459044,
0.1458225995,
-0.3018776178,
0.134570986,
-0.378195256,
0.6690791249,
-0.3521378934,
-0.2778971195,
0.4536049962,
0.503423512,
0.6526004076,
0.3953851163,
0.4734171331,
0.4348497093,
1.5282013416,
-0.1302973926,
1.2255855799,
-0.356991142,
0.0118753398,
1.6156243086,
-0.4460936189,
0.8374812603,
0.6410126686,
-0.0283045582,
0.3802553415,
0.6310872436,
0.5581927299,
0.8239016533,
0.0185705163,
-0.5211759806,
-0.4967340231,
-0.3435838521,
-0.2197693735,
0.1311032474,
0.4062944055,
-0.3620041907,
-0.0423012227,
-0.2323274165,
0.1353214681,
-0.1069710106,
-0.4214287996,
0.8635544181,
0.3367238343,
-0.6679548621,
0.237662673,
-0.7220996618,
0.1818143129,
-0.4943465292,
-0.3027289212,
-0.2655187845,
0.2620430887,
-0.0785570592,
-0.8411462307,
0.0885868967,
-0.305493921,
-0.4583360851,
0.0458972305,
0.8804278374,
-0.4101758599,
-0.3046440482,
0.3085392714,
0.7301816344,
0.2061149627,
0.0265134778,
-0.402543366,
0.519562304,
0.1906959116,
-0.436483711,
-0.0571874902,
0.7916635275,
0.2041786611,
0.6204194427,
0.2885297835,
0.2036916614,
0.0881752968,
0.2293004543,
1.0099327564,
-0.5032727122,
-0.1752843857,
-1.0714811087,
0.6780928969,
-0.3043106198,
-0.1889392883,
0.7416580915,
0.0946650356,
0.5278281569,
-0.0981231332,
0.9971746802,
-0.0869254544,
0.8257626295,
-0.6923760176,
0.2792706788,
-0.2360961139,
0.6708039045,
-0.1460909396,
-0.6173049808,
-0.3661145866,
0.2272930294,
-0.5845162868,
-0.2247954309,
0.5079966784,
0.9363612533,
0.208818838,
0.2828014791,
0.2051063031,
0.4528099597,
0.1939835101,
0.6731262207,
1.3340543509,
-0.0042578955,
0.8595813513,
0.0935106501,
-0.5228914618,
0.1400254816,
-1.0203291178,
-0.7552677989,
-0.0524053015,
-0.2905185223,
-0.4862532318,
-0.0616588369,
1.2147825956,
0.5892099142,
-0.7369887829,
0.0851153731,
-0.091828689,
0.0348000564,
-0.0073057422,
-0.1351944208,
0.1819903553,
-0.5885377526,
-0.7121412754,
0.667668879,
0.4295575917,
-0.0580641329,
-0.0173127502,
-0.2075793296,
0.1391479224,
0.0987280607,
0.3003802598,
0.2504912317,
-0.8993921876,
-0.0447784588,
0.0648119748,
-0.0195304044,
-0.1197580323,
0.7783404589,
-0.9264599085,
0.5091878176,
0.6353455782,
0.8582894206,
0.3097921908,
-0.0008624235,
0.8344660401,
-0.6457700729,
0.2425044328,
0.2889853418,
0.6108008027,
0.2711932957,
-0.5664836168,
0.5203002095,
0.135019362,
-0.6826640964,
-0.901930511,
0.456825465,
-0.9680175781,
-0.2750320137,
0.9327688813,
-0.7819933295,
-0.122219488,
-0.0532577075,
-0.5785357952,
0.1712150425,
-0.7543307543,
0.7647204399,
0.5299497843,
0.0216823332,
-0.3141648769,
-0.340836376,
0.3320086002,
0.1662833691,
-0.4958935082,
0.3114078939,
0.8906372786,
0.3832106292,
-0.0498461761,
1.0935126543,
-0.1786906272,
-0.0549000166,
0.1561845839,
-0.2545676231,
-0.0754287466,
-0.40218997,
-0.5713149905,
0.3087314367,
0.4308300912,
-0.2491915226
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20654v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20654v2
|
Passage-specific Prompt Tuning for Passage Reranking in Question Answering with Large Language Models
| 2024-05-31T07:43:42 | 2024-06-21T03:52:30 |
Xuyang Wu, Zhiyuan Peng, Krishna Sravanthi Rajanala Sai, Hsin-Tai Wu, Yi Fang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Effective passage retrieval and reranking methods have been widely utilized
to identify suitable candidates in open-domain question answering tasks, recent
studies have resorted to LLMs for reranking the retrieved passages by the
log-likelihood of the question conditioned on each passage. Although these
methods have demonstrated promising results, the performance is notably
sensitive to the human-written prompt (or hard prompt), and fine-tuning LLMs
can be computationally intensive and time-consuming. Furthermore, this approach
limits the leverage of question-passage relevance pairs and passage-specific
knowledge to enhance the ranking capabilities of LLMs. In this paper, we
propose passage-specific prompt tuning for reranking in open-domain question
answering (PSPT): a parameter-efficient method that fine-tunes learnable
passage-specific soft prompts, incorporating passage-specific knowledge from a
limited set of question-passage relevance pairs. The method involves ranking
retrieved passages based on the log-likelihood of the model generating the
question conditioned on each passage and the learned soft prompt. We conducted
extensive experiments utilizing the Llama-2-chat-7B model across three publicly
available open-domain question answering datasets and the results demonstrate
the effectiveness of the proposed approach.
|
[
-0.138970241,
-0.9402499795,
0.8149670959,
0.149449721,
-0.7005517483,
-0.0012123969,
-0.3040837944,
-0.0363588072,
0.300556004,
0.6257213354,
-0.7621960044,
-0.6405220628,
-0.2319968194,
0.5028347969,
0.2739116549,
0.9689230323,
0.1522555053,
-0.1407045871,
-0.4558407068,
-0.0155746555,
-0.5536245704,
-0.5383217335,
-0.6655076742,
-0.0411579125,
0.9689839482,
0.5989428163,
0.4656226933,
0.4337440729,
0.5568115711,
0.1598890126,
-0.3538387418,
0.2740877569,
-0.5091296434,
0.5591797233,
-0.3060784042,
-0.6027781963,
-0.4389636815,
-0.0871223658,
0.7692399025,
0.797796011,
-0.159039706,
0.137740463,
0.1374258548,
0.3069806695,
-0.4674658179,
0.0011790897,
-0.9037471414,
-0.0405919179,
-0.3137919009,
-0.8890359998,
-0.6192653775,
-0.7084591985,
0.2210263014,
-0.7108739614,
0.3483683765,
0.2436093986,
0.5715220571,
0.1737845242,
-0.3854692876,
0.0931096002,
-0.1331607997,
0.8672626019,
-0.6485184431,
0.2218797356,
0.2952100337,
0.3826794922,
-0.1453927159,
-0.7400303483,
-0.0523217879,
-0.1937041879,
0.0522821099,
-0.0146324337,
0.1948370636,
0.0958743691,
0.1939438879,
0.2061213851,
-0.5691386461,
0.164051041,
-0.285749048,
-0.2621937692,
0.4700015783,
0.3335900605,
0.1262491047,
-0.0309052058,
-0.301040709,
-0.1016805843,
-1.0046752691,
0.3302375972,
0.3577978015,
0.8871187568,
0.4311290383,
0.5751827359,
-0.4040601552,
0.9001879096,
0.1916292906,
-0.1059951186,
0.1823187619,
-0.1572088599,
0.0804226175,
-0.0532705411,
0.3753623962,
0.3745164871,
0.4337236583,
-0.3207842112,
-0.2983801961,
-0.5100732446,
0.3487872779,
-0.8625060916,
-0.0768949017,
-0.0109536424,
-0.3597692251,
-0.2518843412,
-0.0016505368,
-0.6749979854,
-0.4191835225,
-0.2246592641,
0.5443174243,
-0.2224663794,
-0.2138578445,
-0.0337561257,
-0.0520196706,
0.5223743916,
0.4014130235,
-0.7483206391,
0.0020356134,
0.8521635532,
0.8265901208,
-0.3219946623,
-0.3594446778,
-0.9699009657,
-0.0755999759,
-0.3052828908,
0.9882034063,
-0.9110959172,
-0.3922781944,
0.1784279197,
0.1824179292,
-0.3283908069,
-0.5120763183,
0.8412946463,
-0.8628821969,
0.19737418,
-0.5919792056,
-0.656842649,
0.1627596915,
0.0540314727,
-0.3369021714,
0.6426370144,
-0.0966687128,
-0.532068193,
0.2011930794,
-0.3005271554,
-0.5501813889,
0.1285062581,
0.078653343,
-0.3844595253,
0.2852262557,
0.3599922657,
0.3669854701,
-0.3608924747,
0.178145647,
-0.2352295369,
-0.6032660604,
0.3258753419,
-0.3567741215,
0.5486388206,
0.1217312887,
0.0571622215,
0.2226762772,
-0.3011720181,
0.2681055367,
0.1293562353,
-0.274285078,
-0.3790690005,
-0.0237079002,
-0.3978127539,
0.0281068087,
0.3500525653,
-0.5284051299,
0.4169383943,
-0.4655866325,
0.3037905395,
0.869236052,
0.4721657932,
0.4319455922,
-0.4735662043,
0.7635769844,
-0.1380598247,
0.1422157139,
-0.2185264379,
-0.9085795283,
-0.315585196,
-0.1093298793,
0.3823060393,
0.6455671787,
-0.656773448,
0.3437646329,
-0.0527722612,
-0.3768685758,
-0.6878657341,
0.0889086425,
0.3193747401,
0.7041856647,
0.386772424,
-0.0807477757,
-0.0764090642,
-0.7414295673,
-0.5378492475,
-0.1195111945,
-0.1398274004,
0.5983759165,
0.055182375,
0.3638507724,
0.9112781882,
-0.9916065335,
-0.248634249,
-0.2529857457,
-0.1360896528,
0.5291086435,
0.1977772564,
0.3597117066,
-0.7448397875,
-0.5646244287,
-0.6068454981,
-0.3027188778,
-0.5518639684,
0.1611726433,
-0.284786433,
0.0111828428,
0.700351119,
-0.5161263347,
-0.0072826203,
0.1019307449,
-0.6208055019,
0.5803573728,
-0.2481924295,
0.3450463414,
-0.8567596674,
0.0390644111,
-0.1621025205,
-0.2369886041,
-0.5334455371,
0.1583381891,
0.2157549262,
-0.2634406686,
-0.6031496525,
0.6123262048,
-0.2791523933,
0.2398952842,
-0.1619152129,
0.3057370186,
-0.0658494309,
0.6310272813,
0.2589621246,
0.8092218041,
0.5505190492,
-0.6168166399,
-0.0434657447,
0.2381083965,
-0.2532194853,
0.5384134054,
-0.825612247,
0.3951385319,
-0.1578927785,
0.3493525386,
-1.2609820366,
0.0970972627,
0.1854762435,
-0.3553685248,
0.2202681899,
-0.3673470914,
-0.4593096375,
0.118586354,
-0.4374986589,
0.6577290893,
0.4902469516,
-0.5082916021,
0.2107508034,
-0.02110718,
-0.6266930699,
-0.378215313,
-0.0693964288,
-0.1962140203,
-0.3285222948,
-0.6870569587,
0.5724045634,
-0.2094374895,
0.1015117466,
-0.3546273112,
-0.2325262576,
0.142291382,
0.0714471191,
0.073936455,
0.1206342727,
-0.3007270992,
0.1769078225,
0.3402801454,
-0.2152878195,
-0.0745739192,
-0.2796491086,
0.4713073373,
0.0763833299,
-0.2287040204,
-0.1874554455,
0.4543374181,
0.5106528401,
-0.486900419,
0.8221609592,
0.2835974395,
-0.082869269,
-0.1407089531,
-0.4092313051,
-0.6426492929,
-0.4995140135,
0.0732579231,
-0.5379029512,
-1.1014847755,
0.4777643979,
-0.0560685955,
0.2546856403,
0.2731513679,
0.4281338155,
-0.0445440821,
1.1018009186,
0.4660139382,
-0.0097725894,
0.5595143437,
0.1776062399,
0.1411027163,
-0.9090014696,
-0.2056031823,
-0.5875424743,
-0.4655316174,
-0.4882656038,
-0.3493601978,
0.5096156001,
0.0390644893,
-0.3386382163,
0.0051143561,
-0.4082785845,
0.7222432494,
0.6821554303,
0.2561761141,
0.4238767922,
0.1220483407,
-0.2486750633,
-0.0852304399,
-0.6107283831,
-0.3470944464,
1.2432632446,
0.1095934212,
0.5416961312,
0.3391282856,
0.6577993035,
0.2451354712,
-0.0292578842,
-0.4356370568,
0.7113748193,
-0.0635885149,
-0.4477188289,
-0.4936512709,
-0.6506100893,
-1.2476856709,
0.4443837702,
-0.010773398,
-0.65793401,
0.0445868969,
-0.0261470284,
-0.5515965223,
0.1335377693,
-0.531357646,
0.7607866526,
0.0291880462,
-0.1296874732,
-0.1534234881,
-0.6038661599,
0.0997428671,
0.0785655081,
-0.3377456367,
-0.1591690034,
-0.2993081212,
0.8365796208,
-0.2259449214,
0.809430182,
-0.4774898887,
-0.2629446089,
0.3103666902,
0.0474660844,
0.6185333729,
0.3725290596,
-0.2298738509,
-0.1908135563,
-0.0681859404,
-0.46501562,
-0.6791670918,
0.7319180369,
-0.6804714799,
-0.8981672525,
-0.2993879616,
-0.266386807,
-0.5482128859,
0.0546471141,
0.3873144686,
0.5423451662,
0.0979766399,
0.1554217488,
0.9692739248,
-0.3985784054,
0.0357080176,
0.8395515084,
-0.0870569795,
-0.4562190473,
0.9322974682,
0.0416588597,
0.2329176664,
0.6622578502,
0.2398916483,
-0.6884999275,
-0.6412328482,
-0.2798296213,
0.589598,
-0.5726293325,
-0.3949142694,
-0.3790589273,
-0.1956440806,
-0.4473240077,
-0.2468451113,
0.1187808514,
-0.5627170801,
-0.4257600605,
-0.0763148889,
0.4577291906,
0.1411496997,
0.3352983594,
0.1774891913,
-0.6031005383,
0.4019866288,
0.4695504904,
0.5916463733,
-0.1720635891,
-0.9756801128,
0.1746475548,
-0.1598383635,
-0.2514690757,
-1.0106525421,
0.1459174603,
0.4295354486,
0.7468425632,
0.2015477568,
0.5301017761,
0.3267541528,
-0.4562477171,
0.758258462,
-0.1319083124,
-0.4188126326,
0.8286113739,
-0.4697309732,
0.4098474681,
0.812905848,
0.2504365742,
-0.5739619136,
-0.5688926578,
-0.3627171814,
-1.0771559477,
0.7656499147,
0.0513638705,
0.1074671969,
-0.0287721287,
0.6845944524,
0.2890433669,
0.2508594096,
-0.4401915967,
-0.2531769276,
0.166174382,
-0.1526108086,
-0.325990051,
-0.2023694515,
0.0389833599,
-0.2726744413,
0.6017547846,
-0.2281803042,
0.1083244607,
0.2769246101,
-0.2767199874,
-0.2047972083,
0.3797950745,
0.5635653734,
0.7364532948,
-0.5218641758,
-0.002538173,
0.2022072673,
-0.4384205639,
0.2616930604,
0.0522372946,
-0.4405068457,
-0.1386025101,
0.1257609725,
0.6199901104,
0.0662828386,
-0.6817088723,
0.4795981348,
-0.236933127,
-0.2416820675,
0.019610608,
0.2008484751,
-0.0582292862,
0.319614321,
0.5126678944,
-0.2812226713,
-0.1135900244,
-0.3948686123,
0.0209302977,
0.3341214657,
-0.3017727733,
-0.1937424988,
0.5915910006,
0.5173751116,
-0.6767533422,
0.9142893553,
-0.1669158638,
-0.4410822093,
0.4199661613,
0.5983783603,
0.8081508875,
-0.3719895482,
0.3137010336,
0.2992025614,
0.1076807752,
0.0792119429,
0.5121623874,
-0.2481256574,
-0.3635499179,
-0.4620549977,
-0.6331555247,
-0.6370267272,
0.1017143428,
-0.6271571517,
0.1991163641,
-0.3350185156,
-0.1225816682,
-0.3098752797,
0.2598992884,
-0.5275790095,
0.0058839107,
0.0016819475,
1.0817131996,
-0.8068327308,
0.5048061013,
0.8126807213,
-0.1935136169,
-0.5266318917,
0.2518233657,
-0.2787055969,
-0.5127791166,
0.1261632442,
0.0860861093,
-0.0430144519,
0.3152992427,
-0.3729398549,
-0.8482379317,
1.1744996309,
0.5535691977,
-0.5223478079,
0.0849421099,
0.0968197063,
0.3984205723,
-0.2436730266,
0.3324442804,
0.4121032953,
0.3082804084,
-0.0427628383,
-0.8209195733,
0.2831332386,
-0.2624828219,
-0.236001581,
0.3674460649,
-0.7010121942,
0.555103302,
-0.2873407602,
0.0758772716,
0.2546066046,
0.6999749541,
0.6962043047,
0.4157373011,
0.775711298,
0.3105666041,
1.0138328075,
-0.0992841274,
0.8010793328,
-0.1574311107,
0.0379212424,
0.7595168948,
-0.2676758766,
1.0364583731,
0.3940252662,
-0.0578070618,
0.5215364099,
0.9788505435,
0.3391088843,
0.8585271239,
0.3594064415,
-0.2406591028,
-0.6924814582,
-0.0801257342,
-0.514359951,
0.1775728613,
0.1937486529,
-0.3183079958,
-0.0927258432,
-0.1188196912,
-0.2016873956,
-0.0964358523,
-0.439147085,
0.8197305799,
0.2142774612,
-1.1818121672,
0.5931524634,
0.0078143794,
0.628187418,
-0.6813427806,
0.0567109995,
-0.5535664558,
-0.0422511324,
0.0802241862,
-0.8666799068,
-0.1242829263,
0.043979574,
-0.2844998837,
-0.3955917954,
0.6432705522,
-0.4202784896,
-0.4167883098,
-0.0336554088,
0.7015671134,
0.1977312863,
-0.5418043733,
-0.5070316195,
-0.3551602364,
-0.1104499623,
-0.3729893565,
0.6931109428,
0.5101588368,
-0.013254269,
0.6559181809,
0.5850269198,
0.0393504687,
-0.1942026615,
0.5069364905,
0.7603551745,
-0.7887231708,
-0.7538278699,
-0.7078739405,
0.3033466637,
-0.000851745,
-0.5112786889,
0.6715203524,
0.4513420761,
0.333157748,
0.0866537914,
0.4353417754,
0.372210741,
0.6877842546,
-0.5346506238,
0.5336917639,
-0.7262026668,
0.3878959417,
-0.418562144,
-1.1308517456,
-0.2273865789,
0.3279597461,
-0.4442433417,
0.0133830048,
0.482439369,
0.9902375937,
0.0295853671,
-0.0219432544,
0.2281515747,
-0.1077376306,
0.1395339966,
0.7167740464,
0.8870426416,
0.0825184882,
0.9165976048,
0.0021196536,
-0.2507399321,
-0.5131426454,
-0.7456882,
-0.7752997875,
-0.6753402352,
-0.384537369,
-0.1918873042,
0.2753759325,
0.8626514077,
0.3553009927,
-0.560626626,
0.0167958736,
0.226627171,
0.3844892383,
-0.465675503,
-0.2350433022,
0.5873516202,
-0.6557886004,
-0.4612485468,
0.5568947196,
0.0614470951,
-0.3457400501,
-0.0004121927,
0.0339640304,
0.0186049603,
0.278068006,
0.5434033871,
0.1931434423,
-0.5834604502,
-0.2815308571,
0.4997870028,
0.0701651871,
0.0092720026,
1.0555444956,
-0.8602510691,
0.171650216,
0.7227086425,
0.3624806404,
0.1609964073,
0.4054822028,
0.660146594,
-1.042547226,
-0.3778865337,
0.4748373628,
0.2642446458,
0.2468186319,
-0.3003033102,
0.2772744894,
0.1853172034,
-0.7824659944,
-0.9842286706,
0.179474473,
-1.0127942562,
-0.4821229875,
1.3757655621,
-0.1401394606,
-0.021336196,
-0.1273263693,
-0.3324482143,
0.069432281,
-0.6088753939,
0.7509911656,
0.3578085899,
-0.05762491,
-0.1721929312,
-0.2080612779,
0.5185698867,
0.6828877926,
-0.4983709157,
0.1953925937,
0.1854931861,
0.4194256663,
-0.165805161,
0.6889116168,
0.1190091297,
0.4039204121,
-0.4262388349,
-0.6285584569,
-0.0549877509,
-0.4592114985,
-0.4131249785,
0.5235800147,
0.3535228968,
-0.2043181211
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20649v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20649v1
|
Reward-based Input Construction for Cross-document Relation Extraction
| 2024-05-31T07:30:34 | 2024-05-31T07:30:34 |
Byeonghu Na, Suhyeon Jo, Yeongmin Kim, Il-Chul Moon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Relation extraction (RE) is a fundamental task in natural language
processing, aiming to identify relations between target entities in text. While
many RE methods are designed for a single sentence or document, cross-document
RE has emerged to address relations across multiple long documents. Given the
nature of long documents in cross-document RE, extracting document embeddings
is challenging due to the length constraints of pre-trained language models.
Therefore, we propose REward-based Input Construction (REIC), the first
learning-based sentence selector for cross-document RE. REIC extracts sentences
based on relational evidence, enabling the RE module to effectively infer
relations. Since supervision of evidence sentences is generally unavailable, we
train REIC using reinforcement learning with RE prediction scores as rewards.
Experimental results demonstrate the superiority of our method over heuristic
methods for different RE structures and backbones in cross-document RE. Our
code is publicly available at https://github.com/aailabkaist/REIC.
|
[
-0.2709690034,
-0.7601233721,
0.7532778382,
0.1890102774,
-0.0596248284,
-0.0088750608,
-0.1942849755,
-0.5547585487,
0.3768573403,
0.2783565521,
-0.8283161521,
-0.3633968234,
-0.936781466,
0.3874314427,
-0.1900968999,
1.2269047499,
-0.3352040946,
-0.1486853212,
-0.6218680143,
-0.1808710396,
-0.399002403,
-0.3268433213,
-0.5573070645,
-0.5045058131,
1.0642529726,
0.5178636312,
0.2164507359,
0.4933638871,
0.417339772,
0.3122232556,
0.4374442101,
0.2182494998,
-0.2949423492,
0.4962737858,
-0.6048039198,
-0.4262332618,
-0.0635127723,
0.3963412344,
0.3116802275,
0.3348728716,
0.0151491277,
0.0442866571,
-0.1182286665,
0.4044471979,
-1.0321018696,
0.52058357,
-0.4794841409,
-0.1370510906,
-0.129147917,
-0.6475769877,
-0.7255860567,
-0.1918530315,
-0.0145385601,
-0.7021042109,
0.1255859733,
-0.0566219799,
1.3208987713,
0.0480215698,
-0.2302552909,
-0.5915710926,
-0.5140225887,
0.7707112432,
-0.1746346951,
0.711255908,
0.7930290699,
0.1789564043,
-0.131492123,
-1.0439400673,
-0.3270474076,
-0.1500263363,
-0.4389986992,
0.1232132837,
-0.0432227962,
-0.2664756179,
0.2508924901,
0.3551747501,
-0.4014306366,
-0.0649206638,
-0.078155905,
0.0070985295,
0.5695719719,
0.1403970122,
0.4053535461,
-0.2770637274,
-0.3283090293,
-0.2729027271,
-0.6446148157,
0.2194757909,
0.1211084723,
0.2916913927,
0.0051594246,
0.6117601991,
-0.1845689416,
0.5548378229,
0.1290007383,
-0.025285542,
0.0728032738,
-0.4546642601,
-0.051076334,
0.0967395157,
1.1740275621,
-0.1038467363,
0.2853263319,
-0.4784017801,
-0.3788436353,
-0.0123243639,
0.3937387764,
-0.7713391781,
-0.033464808,
0.0176862832,
-0.4244584143,
-0.5873729587,
0.2277375609,
-0.6421097517,
-0.0364160948,
0.0751930699,
0.1606923491,
-0.4877888262,
0.0700984225,
-0.1887894571,
-0.3153995872,
0.4045588672,
0.1774815619,
-1.1815832853,
0.381084621,
0.8347923756,
0.7025665641,
-0.2120271921,
-0.5834474564,
-1.3484038115,
0.0237964541,
0.1589174569,
0.95012784,
-0.7595709562,
-0.4244984686,
0.1630237401,
0.2347993702,
0.0917090848,
-0.2915777564,
0.6757045388,
-0.7839030027,
0.8140699267,
0.0201781299,
-0.5159324408,
0.2758196592,
0.3893101513,
-1.005038023,
0.9230229259,
0.7011726499,
-1.0347098112,
0.4774125814,
-0.5628638268,
-0.838198483,
0.0140294963,
-0.3468264937,
-0.5112339258,
-0.1552604288,
0.5331555009,
0.3347354531,
-0.4302798212,
0.2331278175,
-0.4204807878,
-0.1939814836,
0.3574243188,
-0.0237651393,
0.7438755035,
0.1408495754,
-0.1740335822,
0.1400660872,
-0.6141155958,
-0.078217797,
0.2554394305,
-0.520205915,
-0.5709251165,
-0.2215294838,
0.1134288236,
0.4677326977,
0.1037518159,
-0.8502174616,
0.2149801552,
-0.4391025007,
0.1446521729,
0.5323037505,
0.2762706578,
0.5905005932,
-0.2569010258,
0.9052438736,
-0.3773323298,
-0.208055228,
-0.2189421654,
-0.1254190356,
-0.3472316861,
-0.3156406283,
0.8532563448,
0.6042035222,
-1.0951901674,
0.7584645748,
-0.3804590106,
-0.051616393,
-0.447275579,
0.0881036296,
0.4272672236,
0.4132926762,
0.3397299349,
-0.3055234551,
-0.7000046968,
-0.7733161449,
-0.3466840684,
-0.1820570976,
-0.085235782,
0.1049724221,
0.4635888636,
0.0254545007,
1.1545705795,
-0.7073158622,
-0.4130674005,
-0.5680023432,
0.3766478896,
-0.1095051914,
0.2995918691,
0.1740658581,
-0.6315612793,
-0.5077001452,
0.0250625275,
-0.8486648202,
-0.0750910044,
-0.3049593568,
-0.0550109521,
0.0635020658,
0.5212795138,
-0.5754590034,
0.5680773258,
0.3473339677,
-0.3587888777,
0.1971219629,
-0.0082682911,
0.0191891398,
-1.0763982534,
0.0876372978,
0.2864528298,
-0.6164926887,
-0.0814149082,
0.0071722469,
0.1544010937,
0.0516840629,
-0.3204290271,
0.5862981677,
-0.4231383204,
-0.0690045804,
-0.2552092075,
0.2442502081,
0.1844926178,
0.6980721951,
0.5093535781,
0.3961384594,
0.0346139148,
-0.2783583105,
0.359704107,
0.3471888304,
-0.2329274863,
0.5233002305,
-0.5422056913,
-0.0617337972,
0.3197509944,
0.389691174,
-0.5134225488,
0.1724855602,
0.4945233166,
-0.9223862886,
0.5231095552,
-0.0200991146,
-0.3661083877,
0.1399365366,
-0.3450074792,
0.1855759919,
0.2042323053,
-0.7433341742,
0.6191449761,
0.3816462457,
-0.380271554,
-0.6335721612,
-0.4774657786,
-0.104061991,
0.1583425701,
-0.4251263142,
0.419814378,
0.4358490407,
0.0040271212,
0.3923211098,
-0.0156735796,
-0.1516008973,
0.0543982312,
0.4904029965,
0.3741744757,
0.1654739529,
0.1866088957,
0.0884992182,
-0.4500842094,
0.3694344163,
0.1521231234,
0.3865715861,
0.2216329277,
-0.0386913866,
-0.2658429742,
0.682097435,
0.35671556,
-0.5793822408,
0.6333924532,
0.5650039911,
-0.3048303723,
-0.3857707381,
-0.2332569957,
-0.2782947421,
-0.3904795051,
0.5179470181,
-0.6398347616,
-0.9421278834,
0.1893843561,
-0.2904992104,
0.0957567692,
0.5280687809,
0.2934429049,
0.0766540691,
0.4300853014,
0.7400099039,
-0.2706813514,
0.7841117382,
-0.2380461693,
0.0099863652,
-0.809653461,
-0.4754042029,
-0.7553306222,
-0.2102611214,
-0.4290994108,
-0.1237712651,
-0.2152228802,
-0.0748207346,
0.1708888113,
0.6087645292,
-0.2874749005,
0.1128120571,
0.5742202997,
-0.0156938694,
0.2851346433,
-0.0495103188,
-0.1230485439,
-0.0967072025,
-0.7371507287,
-0.0844944045,
0.9553496242,
0.3293097913,
0.9196597934,
-0.3130229414,
1.3967045546,
0.1389053911,
0.5603743196,
-0.9335315824,
0.2292835712,
0.1739397943,
-0.1947207898,
-0.5414481163,
-0.6645249128,
-1.459941864,
0.0340096653,
-0.4337908924,
-0.56246382,
0.3035081029,
-0.4037237465,
-0.111516811,
0.1056415662,
-0.4027436376,
0.909688592,
-0.3408823609,
-0.6240100265,
-0.1691906452,
-0.6164509654,
0.2101957053,
0.2686662972,
0.0785679445,
0.418099016,
0.1399013996,
0.7752017975,
-0.4883603454,
0.34148857,
0.0747883841,
-0.1225746572,
0.0925848484,
0.1951495111,
0.6757780313,
0.4311368167,
0.0146839255,
-0.2650273442,
-0.1350592375,
-0.0848300532,
-1.0741696358,
0.799941361,
-0.5541031361,
-0.2069852948,
-0.7074704766,
-0.5339266062,
-0.3691194057,
0.1781640947,
0.1926716864,
0.3103563488,
-0.4862394333,
0.267889142,
0.4250034094,
-0.2169392109,
0.4289788902,
0.3778491616,
-0.2626216114,
-0.6601955891,
0.9500859976,
-0.3895122409,
0.0409047455,
0.9577806592,
0.1096565872,
-0.3646042049,
0.0246705208,
-0.3002811968,
0.1806523502,
-0.3690822423,
-0.3491109014,
-0.7859403491,
-0.3299841881,
-0.4700470567,
-0.1548141688,
-0.4069868028,
-0.3587982357,
-0.0808842257,
-0.273081094,
0.2601419985,
0.5974112153,
-0.1646195501,
-0.1715643108,
-0.9241586328,
0.5559833646,
0.3495247662,
0.3568364382,
-0.2633863091,
-0.1911213845,
-0.4184562266,
-0.3879841864,
-0.1468738019,
-0.767560184,
0.490093112,
-0.2395154983,
0.5588745475,
0.089283146,
0.0597387776,
0.2410129458,
-0.2801665962,
0.4151212573,
0.2932364047,
-0.67498523,
0.6559810638,
0.0549747795,
0.2314067483,
0.8682034612,
0.4445682764,
-0.6418978572,
-0.279111594,
-1.04712677,
-0.6937485337,
0.9207312465,
0.1108230427,
-0.3971674442,
-0.122351326,
0.2546033263,
0.2216423452,
-0.035851337,
-0.9277524352,
-0.0115646338,
-0.0592723377,
-0.2722784281,
0.1082983091,
-0.1446735561,
-0.0793886483,
-0.001929596,
0.5481562614,
0.1269775927,
0.1734977514,
0.341653645,
-0.3409146667,
-0.300873965,
0.3658711016,
0.3200047016,
0.3487839699,
-0.3757478297,
0.0808778927,
-0.1648505777,
-0.1416198611,
0.0575871691,
0.3142557144,
-0.1272746027,
0.0927719399,
0.8090859652,
0.7368561029,
0.441791594,
-0.3790283799,
0.6692993641,
-0.4888252616,
-0.5337610841,
-0.1028881222,
-0.1037319377,
0.0580612905,
0.084487319,
-0.016120445,
-0.3260369897,
-0.044306688,
-0.7592979074,
0.6503264904,
0.6076467633,
-0.6305831671,
0.0413327441,
0.3296947777,
0.2353501916,
-0.6394841671,
1.0241976976,
-0.2740693986,
-0.3612142801,
0.2561734319,
0.5285362005,
1.1412065029,
0.1214772984,
0.4381559789,
0.5254748464,
0.1521724761,
0.1342430413,
-0.0429781936,
-0.3596054316,
-0.6875356436,
-0.5206557512,
-0.5133594275,
-0.3230701387,
0.0380766913,
-0.9470284581,
0.2942249477,
-0.2587566078,
0.2419334948,
-0.1733146161,
0.2734425664,
-0.5660618544,
0.0703295246,
-0.0631658807,
0.8040798903,
-0.8234349489,
1.2108812332,
0.5321062207,
-0.8865301609,
-1.0241533518,
-0.1816089302,
-0.4218141437,
-0.5174515843,
0.9600749612,
-0.1291421354,
-0.1074676067,
-0.4259233177,
-0.4673712552,
-0.4885249734,
1.0809981823,
0.2482867241,
-0.2182925642,
-0.3385182321,
-0.1139208749,
0.2942207456,
-0.6503323913,
0.3099578619,
0.3120269775,
0.4542619884,
0.0456236713,
-0.5401874185,
0.3960205615,
-0.4139893949,
-0.2914135456,
0.4670237303,
-0.2136544734,
0.5786798,
-0.0035933454,
-0.2964265049,
0.00786909,
0.731631577,
0.4454241097,
0.3657698631,
0.5566827059,
0.6982992291,
0.3427365124,
0.0202943906,
1.3536067009,
-0.0340085886,
0.298048079,
1.5679420233,
-0.3609327376,
0.8767539263,
0.8254961371,
-0.0776814967,
1.1937361956,
0.6394325495,
0.0576422326,
0.8527647257,
0.2253604829,
0.0504953153,
-0.2710713744,
-0.0803284943,
-0.287434876,
0.438742578,
0.3380188346,
-0.7019025683,
-0.4055585265,
-0.3576191664,
-0.2190797776,
0.2528012097,
0.1749847084,
0.9117144942,
0.158729881,
-1.0324699879,
0.0733785331,
0.2098503113,
0.660586834,
-0.9663888216,
-0.467355758,
-0.2388374805,
-0.04699222,
-0.2753427625,
-0.729988873,
0.1312236041,
-0.1738345176,
-0.3267595172,
-0.4800691307,
0.879088223,
-0.6129281521,
-0.2043061852,
0.4824590981,
0.6276320815,
-0.2677727044,
-0.0716841966,
-0.498070091,
-0.2149521559,
-0.0651453212,
-0.351801455,
0.7387158275,
0.7177542448,
-0.0745183378,
0.3734156191,
0.7798159719,
0.178005904,
-0.4619847536,
0.0277487766,
0.9353260994,
-0.8263908029,
-0.5656958222,
-0.7913596034,
0.3996973336,
-0.2960397899,
-0.3500618339,
0.5102568865,
0.642729044,
0.8270751238,
-0.0222001988,
0.770498693,
-0.2871894538,
0.3287903666,
-0.4299990535,
0.4833345413,
-0.5256659389,
-0.0668328106,
-0.3560743332,
-0.7609583139,
-0.1658796072,
0.6550800204,
-0.3026868403,
-0.1912830919,
1.304838419,
0.6563719511,
0.0751659051,
0.0185206365,
0.0368734673,
-0.6144721508,
0.3999954462,
0.9224208593,
0.859074235,
-0.4141485095,
0.6944968104,
-0.3740111291,
-0.1809190065,
0.1168226376,
-0.7391601801,
-0.6944676638,
-0.6560534835,
-0.2083295733,
-0.5634669662,
-0.0863978192,
0.8039795756,
0.4143126905,
-0.5912439227,
-0.2403004467,
-0.1438328922,
0.6529906392,
-0.3212820292,
-0.2970946431,
0.4353337288,
-0.3800358176,
-0.5669539571,
0.5064740777,
0.3861227334,
-0.5885911584,
-0.1232981011,
-0.3921290338,
-0.9286059737,
-0.3867030442,
0.4602563381,
0.5991575718,
-0.3949922621,
-0.3387340009,
0.0427215472,
-0.4240579307,
0.0957224593,
1.2213054895,
-1.0304528475,
0.2754906714,
0.6865204573,
1.1254702806,
0.6740720272,
0.0446147844,
0.9880097508,
-0.8114460707,
-0.074744612,
0.0384998173,
0.435877949,
0.1471418887,
-0.5552881956,
0.8386048675,
0.2189805061,
-0.372794956,
-0.6155857444,
0.2343763709,
-0.9596788883,
-0.2525248826,
0.9410120249,
-0.3743932843,
-0.3670934141,
0.0468362048,
-0.0890297666,
0.5456303358,
-0.5612809062,
0.6560316086,
0.6255849004,
-0.1291147321,
-0.4017556012,
0.0435584635,
0.390976727,
0.4632673264,
-1.1126208305,
0.0153536852,
0.3332929611,
0.1914106309,
0.266761452,
0.6867979765,
-0.3897805214,
0.4679761529,
0.0695186704,
0.3143692017,
-0.3970459104,
-0.2455004305,
-0.2186555415,
0.5651260614,
0.0599920601,
-0.4285776913
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20648v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20648v1
|
Shotluck Holmes: A Family of Efficient Small-Scale Large Language Vision Models For Video Captioning and Summarization
| 2024-05-31T07:30:24 | 2024-05-31T07:30:24 |
Richard Luo, Austin Peng, Adithya Vasudev, Rishabh Jain
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Video is an increasingly prominent and information-dense medium, yet it poses
substantial challenges for language models. A typical video consists of a
sequence of shorter segments, or shots, that collectively form a coherent
narrative. Each shot is analogous to a word in a sentence where multiple data
streams of information (such as visual and auditory data) must be processed
simultaneously. Comprehension of the entire video requires not only
understanding the visual-audio information of each shot but also requires that
the model links the ideas between each shot to generate a larger,
all-encompassing story. Despite significant progress in the field, current
works often overlook videos' more granular shot-by-shot semantic information.
In this project, we propose a family of efficient large language vision models
(LLVMs) to boost video summarization and captioning called Shotluck Holmes. By
leveraging better pretraining and data collection strategies, we extend the
abilities of existing small LLVMs from being able to understand a picture to
being able to understand a sequence of frames. Specifically, we show that
Shotluck Holmes achieves better performance than state-of-the-art results on
the Shot2Story video captioning and summary task with significantly smaller and
more computationally efficient models.
|
[
-0.1504540145,
-0.6591691971,
0.5240415335,
-0.0230492614,
-0.6183662415,
0.2547988594,
-0.1952001005,
-0.2257007807,
0.4029711485,
0.5845416784,
-0.5218062401,
-0.463539511,
-0.7752505541,
-0.1402729005,
-0.6202948689,
1.1179207563,
-0.0021313794,
0.0295577459,
0.0055994219,
-0.0733362287,
-0.3247378767,
0.068692781,
-0.4623546004,
0.0361653492,
0.4355673194,
0.4286527336,
0.6514616013,
0.5918037891,
0.9405899048,
0.2580297887,
0.1819837093,
0.1206664518,
-0.5195894241,
0.0534265116,
0.1729538292,
-0.5844479203,
-0.2963909507,
-0.3954080343,
0.744058311,
0.6739533544,
-0.0897617638,
0.5343869925,
0.0461133122,
0.6303738356,
-0.9693632722,
0.4526111186,
-0.6537245512,
0.2635334432,
-0.1225307435,
-0.6207733154,
-0.2037415951,
-0.1108698845,
0.2608505189,
-0.7111887336,
0.4839770794,
-0.0660540462,
0.6113473177,
0.3876253664,
0.0447936282,
0.0952542573,
-0.6666532755,
0.6508004665,
-0.6262329221,
0.1507202387,
0.3292888105,
0.6742230654,
0.1442043185,
-0.5961447954,
-0.4862688482,
0.1241978481,
0.0882677063,
0.363203913,
-0.1336616576,
0.1728534251,
0.2498850673,
0.5164626241,
-0.8224629164,
0.041516576,
-0.4188638926,
-0.0047357501,
0.7431960106,
0.5685219765,
0.2319061756,
-0.0744829625,
-0.0198023189,
-0.1376341581,
-0.4764265418,
0.215274632,
0.192816928,
0.0526972376,
-0.1216716766,
0.7409703135,
-0.5967810154,
0.797627449,
-0.2011465281,
-0.6681028008,
-0.041374851,
-0.3591923714,
-0.5850225091,
0.1869042516,
0.5560191274,
0.6027994156,
0.3694153726,
0.1480920017,
0.0271525476,
-0.0644458607,
0.193673864,
-0.9270071983,
-0.5804992914,
0.3132418096,
-0.4534622431,
-0.3950215876,
0.1041115224,
-0.6677982807,
-0.4129131138,
-0.220042631,
0.5742354393,
-0.3097398579,
0.0521497987,
0.1756188869,
-0.2300043404,
0.5782206655,
0.7171008587,
-1.092035532,
0.1041545942,
0.5507053137,
1.008581996,
-0.0286788642,
-0.4416981936,
-0.9758870006,
0.4818169773,
-0.463755697,
0.7975172997,
-0.3973889053,
-0.0859898329,
0.3047677577,
0.0456512161,
0.2488122731,
-0.2986329794,
-0.1366817802,
-0.3518419564,
0.1139860898,
0.0468796678,
-0.4809565544,
-0.3073919713,
0.2921594381,
-0.621294558,
0.442543447,
-0.3123274744,
-0.8537038565,
0.3286140561,
-0.3298121095,
-0.5639597178,
0.4383696318,
-0.2027264982,
-0.4552347362,
0.3940868378,
0.4447609782,
0.7829375267,
-0.0226742793,
0.1845052391,
-0.3503076136,
-0.4595050216,
0.0003004832,
-0.449107945,
0.5439312458,
-0.0156014459,
-0.0338080302,
0.2042532265,
-0.4187612832,
-0.3713370264,
0.2560200393,
-0.0598826595,
-0.1943881065,
0.0995497629,
-0.1469250321,
-0.331998229,
-0.070347853,
-0.1997101307,
-0.0185260586,
-0.2563187182,
0.3218813837,
0.4069231451,
-0.0122374957,
0.438516885,
-0.2178712338,
0.7516824007,
-0.1371591091,
0.2951470613,
-1.0334800482,
-0.5010598898,
-0.6187628508,
-0.4449549019,
-0.1924659312,
0.6018688679,
-0.9161296487,
0.1680683047,
-0.5687991381,
-0.2908752859,
-0.5240389109,
0.3298258185,
0.2368355393,
0.5568976998,
0.2675295472,
-0.3066410124,
-0.3544103205,
-0.9346722364,
-0.102177754,
-0.2673623264,
-0.1721418798,
0.0617935732,
0.5104919672,
0.1964565814,
0.8776276112,
-0.8033400178,
-0.5639764071,
-0.5034608841,
0.0100635933,
0.1702983081,
0.0380738042,
0.2386051714,
-0.5544868112,
-0.3331661224,
-0.1152365804,
-0.9488860965,
0.2910865843,
-0.2099280804,
0.2293694615,
0.0051708408,
0.6089622974,
-0.5813950896,
0.6008455753,
0.5385319591,
0.0952277333,
0.7452766299,
-0.1171739474,
0.2519347072,
-0.977827251,
0.0002740553,
-0.17362912,
-0.5003497601,
-0.5439038277,
0.2015777379,
-0.1469288617,
-0.2980350554,
-0.7799604535,
0.2977944016,
-0.3899579942,
-0.4495231211,
-0.3489644825,
0.3967134356,
0.1276651323,
0.5673265457,
0.3065916896,
0.5619653463,
0.8539281487,
-0.373871237,
0.8648695946,
0.3607630134,
-0.763771534,
0.5439725518,
-0.6009046435,
-0.5084941387,
-0.3713185787,
0.441511631,
-1.0772371292,
-0.7251331806,
-0.207442075,
-0.5157620311,
0.2473048121,
-0.2284477353,
-0.5589588881,
-0.3775126934,
-0.6750695109,
0.5108769536,
0.5283166766,
-0.6188877225,
0.5785470605,
0.5200876594,
-0.4089348912,
-0.5978366137,
-1.0500022173,
0.3138625622,
-0.5702943206,
-0.7935613394,
0.2363526821,
0.1369230449,
-0.1923901588,
-0.1370883882,
0.0497182645,
-0.0640797168,
-0.1837742925,
0.1029439494,
0.4348548949,
-0.1950503886,
0.3076540828,
-0.1564692855,
0.0453043059,
-0.1215615571,
-0.1597343236,
0.1516325325,
-0.1402344257,
-0.0249259751,
-0.4802571833,
0.5225202441,
0.4015477002,
-0.3913095891,
0.4642349184,
0.6810053587,
-0.2314549834,
-0.2732995749,
-0.5587692261,
-0.4919383526,
-0.3754442334,
0.7438523769,
-0.2548193932,
-1.0402982235,
0.5114206672,
0.2833135724,
0.2072378397,
0.0838139281,
0.6733776331,
-0.677542448,
0.8028614521,
0.5671360493,
-0.0070320726,
0.6360734701,
-0.4209243059,
0.3647417426,
-0.624810338,
-0.0105914613,
0.0725243539,
-0.2300798744,
-0.1194704846,
-0.4946330488,
0.4225924313,
0.1487615258,
0.077538386,
0.2593706548,
-0.0876464471,
0.8420411348,
0.3891544044,
0.0737009719,
0.534810245,
0.2852696478,
0.4063185453,
0.0456083082,
-0.7736600637,
-0.2070856392,
1.0455225706,
0.3819036484,
0.9537807107,
0.2644201815,
0.5884447098,
0.2815220356,
-0.266590178,
-1.1258665323,
0.7153255939,
-0.3662471473,
-0.3549930751,
-0.4505882859,
-0.053899236,
-0.8332127333,
0.2341229022,
-0.2191929072,
-0.6960932016,
-0.2933779061,
0.3336252868,
-0.8229078054,
0.4060128033,
-0.5081838369,
0.8653633595,
-0.066812776,
-0.4930886328,
-0.4016656578,
-0.7025716305,
0.8848133683,
-0.00772529,
0.1967049241,
-0.0695109889,
0.0447816327,
0.6517317295,
-0.6483436227,
0.8673801422,
0.0523584075,
0.0562780499,
0.6092717648,
0.2556362152,
0.3582949638,
0.1204589829,
0.9289593101,
0.1309965402,
0.1270808429,
-0.3301766515,
-0.552205205,
0.3828020096,
-0.2128467858,
-0.5243734717,
-0.2766373158,
-0.5567494631,
-0.1060459837,
0.0089053577,
0.2471990883,
0.7289353609,
-0.0311291665,
0.418364197,
0.701338768,
-0.2359845638,
0.8580796123,
0.3131371737,
-0.5132715106,
-0.2734720409,
0.6957423687,
-0.2383762598,
0.1740286797,
0.5048213601,
-0.025408363,
-0.0802167878,
-0.7885985374,
-0.3433811665,
0.1876048744,
-0.7765696645,
-0.3699786663,
-0.4444540739,
-0.0920243487,
-0.3370850682,
-0.3773907125,
-0.3865611255,
-0.4154138565,
0.0026571895,
-0.2223726958,
0.3641324639,
0.0069781542,
0.1723654568,
0.6823693514,
-0.894505322,
0.4870980382,
0.7125203013,
0.2301140875,
-0.20624201,
-0.7495841384,
-0.5008366704,
-0.3869039118,
-0.1082507372,
-0.7865998149,
0.4423145354,
0.1880300194,
0.289021641,
0.4770697951,
-0.3001261055,
0.9917142391,
-0.5706365705,
0.9759907126,
0.455707252,
-0.6871209145,
0.7909917235,
-0.4671448767,
0.7377430797,
0.6824051738,
-0.0046731345,
-0.3113470376,
-0.4109662771,
-0.3591002226,
-0.7778973579,
0.5941302776,
0.2238367051,
0.0703765526,
0.3527518213,
-0.1124224588,
0.0122271925,
0.177409932,
-0.4916930199,
0.3322774172,
-0.1763583571,
-0.3412347436,
-0.2713485062,
-0.0261944383,
-0.1768372655,
-0.1639784127,
0.577452302,
-0.4536757469,
-0.0701903999,
0.1728059798,
-0.5912247896,
0.1141906902,
0.0395406373,
0.5205196738,
0.3709315062,
-0.3960391581,
0.1059101522,
0.098519817,
-0.6887814403,
-0.1578941047,
-0.0970399231,
-0.2242635787,
0.0554982685,
0.956892848,
0.8937094212,
0.2642756999,
-1.0220369101,
0.7896630168,
0.0786857307,
-0.349716723,
-0.5323551297,
-0.1042880937,
-0.1515847296,
0.36889413,
0.2537616789,
-0.1561923623,
0.4405532777,
-0.7371714115,
0.0608459488,
0.451538384,
-0.0889266878,
-0.1924477965,
0.5161009431,
0.2350783199,
-0.2379861027,
0.5019503832,
0.1385287941,
-0.2301261872,
0.5012951493,
-0.0488385521,
1.0994977951,
-0.0135098919,
0.4105291963,
0.3827632368,
0.306987077,
-0.2426931113,
0.0186553616,
-0.3852642179,
-0.5219970942,
-0.7407622933,
-0.6433660388,
-0.3480497599,
0.0535276532,
-0.6182937622,
0.3026427627,
-0.3103377521,
-0.0031474845,
0.0607065596,
-0.2627500296,
-0.6787144542,
0.1028143913,
0.4245041907,
0.7107720375,
-0.8516648412,
0.9635257125,
0.2999061346,
-0.5274049044,
-0.6453604698,
-0.2198007256,
0.034103483,
-0.7637350559,
0.3617250919,
0.302382946,
-0.163577795,
-0.1723718345,
-0.450789541,
-0.544859767,
1.3085041046,
0.191643104,
-0.8294496536,
-0.287920475,
0.0529511347,
0.3501448333,
-0.5739161968,
0.1460355967,
0.7298177481,
0.1648702919,
0.3402521908,
-0.7266381383,
-0.5443779826,
-0.026752878,
0.0268063378,
0.0300490614,
-0.4530660212,
0.3726646006,
-0.5734248757,
0.0386306681,
-0.1233506501,
0.565916419,
0.2658623755,
0.3949650228,
0.3695845604,
0.5074642301,
0.3687334359,
0.0472120829,
1.1713417768,
0.0428396873,
0.1533022076,
1.6636636257,
0.0676640272,
1.0024037361,
0.5986267328,
-0.1936607361,
0.2306380123,
0.4167286754,
-0.2959713042,
0.6753255725,
-0.0108079156,
-0.1232127622,
-0.41001454,
0.0892436728,
0.1193135977,
0.8725922704,
0.2028358132,
-0.296104908,
-0.2148914188,
0.2082062811,
-0.2415948659,
0.0057172286,
-0.6697688699,
0.9418611526,
0.0176154673,
-0.5952256918,
0.2546131611,
-0.3118759692,
0.4753271937,
-0.7392994165,
0.1330296099,
-0.4125297368,
0.1436099261,
-0.3388406038,
-1.0413697958,
0.4322136343,
0.2769199312,
-0.0285392255,
0.0621313788,
0.3728073537,
-0.6402763128,
-0.6743212938,
-0.0731401145,
0.0793109238,
0.4139398932,
-0.1840911657,
-0.4245770574,
0.1859386116,
-0.0817395225,
0.0169257373,
0.0436692834,
-0.027874371,
-0.0624189638,
0.5198766589,
0.3327002823,
0.2112545222,
0.2143584937,
0.2532296777,
0.2670889795,
-0.462272197,
-0.6719446182,
-0.8655328155,
0.7018466592,
-0.1923076063,
0.0384715386,
0.7542648315,
0.6377421618,
0.7094035149,
-0.3611564636,
0.7648548484,
0.435171783,
0.104306668,
-0.7744647861,
0.3847427964,
-0.586560905,
0.063906312,
-0.2778147161,
-1.1665201187,
-0.7648810148,
0.4649700224,
-0.1512441039,
-0.3436185122,
0.6951501966,
0.7015590668,
-0.104388684,
0.0547885969,
0.4971671104,
0.2277155668,
0.4648032188,
0.8563204408,
0.6693227291,
-0.4941729009,
0.919372797,
-0.2273521125,
-0.2872368991,
-0.5025752783,
-0.8504488468,
-1.1044815779,
-0.4814073145,
-0.6191515326,
0.143749997,
0.0184778906,
0.433380574,
0.8651084304,
-0.6263302565,
-0.2356851101,
-0.0152288815,
-0.2819435298,
-0.0356834009,
-0.1976108849,
0.4877726436,
-0.1356778741,
-0.6320582628,
0.3384131193,
0.8272665739,
0.0365107097,
-0.5207371116,
-0.1112267375,
0.0148845026,
0.2006994039,
0.8893538117,
0.3666400611,
-0.8685581684,
-0.1969037354,
-0.2644884884,
0.1517201215,
-0.0549189858,
0.9425567389,
-0.7488487363,
0.8179183006,
0.7477339506,
0.6005741954,
1.0174423456,
-0.0486111268,
0.3278756142,
-0.5208819509,
0.4276480675,
0.0761014149,
0.6401062012,
0.5311738253,
0.0232422203,
0.4902971983,
0.0594963878,
-0.2554882169,
-0.8152726293,
0.2573221624,
-1.3086233139,
-0.370303899,
0.9338262081,
-0.1529874951,
-0.2661091387,
0.2870261073,
-0.1911631227,
-0.0507738627,
-0.1169015318,
0.8277999759,
0.5768210292,
0.1178089306,
-0.6718800664,
-0.7026340961,
0.4500319362,
0.3506367207,
-0.8387995958,
0.2563999593,
0.6098615527,
0.1688674688,
-0.0869724378,
0.6989586353,
-0.1544881314,
0.4778465331,
0.0829595327,
-0.1570612788,
-0.2086277753,
-0.7364703417,
-0.6403597593,
0.2511458397,
-0.374715358,
-0.4029869139
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20646v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20646v1
|
Large Language Models Enhanced Sequential Recommendation for Long-tail User and Item
| 2024-05-31T07:24:42 | 2024-05-31T07:24:42 |
Qidong Liu, Xian Wu, Xiangyu Zhao, Yejing Wang, Zijian Zhang, Feng Tian, Yefeng Zheng
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Sequential recommendation systems (SRS) serve the purpose of predicting
users' subsequent preferences based on their past interactions and have been
applied across various domains such as e-commerce and social networking
platforms. However, practical SRS encounters challenges due to the fact that
most users engage with only a limited number of items, while the majority of
items are seldom consumed. These challenges, termed as the long-tail user and
long-tail item dilemmas, often create obstacles for traditional SRS methods.
Mitigating these challenges is crucial as they can significantly impact user
satisfaction and business profitability. While some research endeavors have
alleviated these issues, they still grapple with issues such as seesaw or noise
stemming from the scarcity of interactions. The emergence of large language
models (LLMs) presents a promising avenue to address these challenges from a
semantic standpoint. In this study, we introduce the Large Language Models
Enhancement framework for Sequential Recommendation (LLM-ESR), which leverages
semantic embeddings from LLMs to enhance SRS performance without increasing
computational overhead. To combat the long-tail item challenge, we propose a
dual-view modeling approach that fuses semantic information from LLMs with
collaborative signals from traditional SRS. To address the long-tail user
challenge, we introduce a retrieval augmented self-distillation technique to
refine user preference representations by incorporating richer interaction data
from similar users. Through comprehensive experiments conducted on three
authentic datasets using three widely used SRS models, our proposed enhancement
framework demonstrates superior performance compared to existing methodologies.
|
[
-0.2769411802,
-0.6855720878,
0.7543166876,
0.3744291067,
-0.3563434482,
0.2456663698,
-0.3338998854,
-0.5444741845,
0.5542100072,
0.802406311,
-0.7302154303,
-0.3412068486,
-0.4881978631,
0.1361525059,
-0.3345994651,
1.0582998991,
0.1661093235,
-0.2122259587,
-0.1444797516,
-0.0638517961,
-0.7105301023,
-0.6360298991,
-0.6698829532,
-0.3718577623,
0.8661922216,
0.38335675,
0.6578597426,
0.1501205862,
0.4241160452,
0.3498531878,
-0.058222726,
0.3135333955,
-0.5668798685,
0.5625707507,
-0.4506949186,
0.0681021884,
-0.387875855,
-0.505808413,
0.5599530339,
0.6191967726,
-0.3756513,
0.0139813116,
0.3008568883,
0.9325795174,
-0.4850493968,
-0.0120977527,
-0.4997851849,
-0.0970816687,
-0.2726570666,
0.0109360255,
-0.4840813279,
0.0267809555,
0.5932130814,
-0.5146272182,
-0.2443060577,
0.2770727575,
0.4038995802,
0.1590360701,
-0.5638314486,
-0.1820176691,
-0.8249830604,
0.8595534563,
-0.7849839926,
0.478616029,
0.3181793392,
0.1023294777,
-0.4957536161,
-0.7611652613,
-0.3679673672,
-0.2989959121,
-0.1931901872,
-0.1481774449,
-0.1065147296,
-0.1491770595,
0.242057249,
0.270193696,
-0.4199497104,
0.2450331748,
-0.0380792059,
-0.0123492563,
0.6541106105,
0.2464966923,
0.1668026894,
-0.0320547633,
-0.5324710011,
0.0538408048,
-0.540558517,
-0.2177000195,
0.3622803986,
0.3623288572,
0.0082414756,
0.6826524138,
-0.3747318387,
0.641943574,
0.2546201646,
-0.0046666088,
0.4164127111,
-0.6208639741,
0.073107563,
-0.1129866615,
0.7646247149,
0.4894552827,
0.2057949603,
0.0611993857,
-0.2193967998,
-0.30695647,
0.0136800911,
-0.9502912164,
-0.0795313716,
0.0875031352,
-0.4723830819,
-0.0923563689,
-0.0376965329,
-0.6508478522,
-0.7834820747,
-0.3810323179,
0.322501421,
-0.2205907553,
-0.3647435308,
0.4005949795,
-0.0036823847,
-0.2326156944,
0.443013072,
-0.8960136175,
0.4666070044,
0.7275453806,
0.7827750444,
-0.1772972196,
-0.3075213134,
-0.6501799822,
0.3631820381,
-0.00039843,
0.870523572,
-0.7720409036,
-0.5905435681,
-0.0169630535,
-0.0021352938,
0.2831784487,
-0.4631214142,
0.5206480026,
-0.5718025565,
0.0665079728,
-0.3998056054,
-0.5152919292,
-0.0402124077,
0.0015430175,
-0.4940454066,
1.1658866405,
-0.096915327,
-0.6623412967,
0.3410414457,
-0.4393631518,
-0.5115238428,
0.2325066626,
-0.0830169395,
-0.2290300578,
0.1718239039,
0.2636802495,
0.5882214308,
-0.3905575573,
0.4450866282,
-0.6838864088,
-0.2885936201,
0.0645275414,
-0.2512445748,
0.0936745182,
0.1334350258,
0.1410035491,
0.4101303816,
-0.6438134909,
-0.2404794246,
0.1439647675,
-0.0934618488,
-0.8432323933,
0.2811346948,
0.0723868236,
0.2560503185,
0.6264743209,
-0.4102785885,
0.356076926,
-0.5061614513,
0.3930583894,
0.9795897603,
0.1300501376,
0.4120299816,
-0.2170673609,
0.0809829235,
0.1011727303,
-0.0778287649,
-0.2643120885,
-0.3073993325,
-0.7970482707,
-0.2668026686,
0.0997157246,
0.2248874903,
-0.669136703,
0.7500692606,
-0.3467174768,
-0.1174745634,
-0.2815537751,
0.3837814331,
0.0822810233,
0.1815513521,
0.2856676877,
-0.5389878154,
-0.6385356784,
-0.9961926341,
-0.1929288059,
0.0152455289,
-0.1834042221,
0.5210848451,
0.2582397759,
-0.4277848005,
0.8209540844,
-0.7292197347,
-0.4681350887,
-0.3415181637,
0.0656838566,
0.449131757,
0.1564146876,
0.1936782598,
-0.6245635748,
-0.6783534884,
-0.2728832662,
-0.3111209273,
-0.0812839121,
-0.0717410892,
-0.0570946708,
0.1793349236,
0.2525899708,
-0.1509726495,
0.2540683448,
0.4749375582,
-0.5630666614,
0.3313620985,
-0.5549499989,
0.0544310845,
-1.161231637,
-0.3341271877,
0.3391597867,
-0.3067033887,
-0.318998903,
-0.3188504279,
-0.0432923436,
0.1679794639,
-0.1277767569,
0.6673148274,
-0.2902782559,
-0.0811761096,
-0.4477784932,
0.2454331219,
0.0917699486,
0.3417155147,
0.3388590217,
0.5604781508,
0.3585056067,
-0.375389725,
0.2231617421,
0.2056792974,
-0.4704250693,
0.5312796831,
-0.8881142139,
0.2905802727,
-0.0143755348,
0.5404421687,
-1.053964138,
0.1115584001,
0.0794567466,
0.0800618008,
0.1580301821,
-0.3845820427,
-0.7755502462,
-0.361289382,
-0.4305208325,
0.2939055562,
0.408464551,
-0.6650879383,
0.6458895802,
0.1954714954,
-0.4117875099,
-0.7108508348,
-0.2838623524,
0.2508392334,
-0.1594729424,
-0.8213558197,
0.4080817401,
-0.4273932874,
-0.073838219,
-0.0691960603,
0.0608053394,
0.4548207223,
-0.0381082855,
0.2863759696,
0.5357317328,
0.0222668163,
0.3002434373,
-0.054092072,
-0.3278051317,
-0.2496847063,
-0.4385959506,
0.6588733196,
-0.2458878309,
-0.286354214,
-0.3585509956,
0.4854471982,
0.5344539285,
-0.3404458463,
0.8553869128,
0.6877037883,
-0.0146348877,
-0.2656564116,
-0.9659123421,
-0.301093936,
-0.5508587956,
0.7535578609,
-0.5530351996,
-1.0492960215,
0.3891250491,
-0.1669547111,
-0.1181570366,
0.2722021341,
0.5911920071,
0.0640916526,
1.0486053228,
0.5977958441,
-0.3556420803,
0.7071728706,
-0.0800889954,
0.34097296,
-1.0932145119,
-0.1929418296,
-0.3104690909,
-0.1496404409,
-0.4731884599,
-0.3390132487,
0.2371966541,
0.0123146456,
-0.30039379,
0.1950102299,
-0.3664930761,
0.3189321458,
0.5058777332,
0.2326587737,
0.5504601002,
0.0960217044,
-0.108008936,
-0.1394676268,
-0.4193210304,
-0.238687396,
0.9470366836,
0.4598323703,
1.0391296148,
0.2852935791,
0.7051330209,
0.4644239247,
-0.0926871225,
-0.9576277137,
0.6338169575,
-0.4716359973,
-0.2069851458,
-0.3674786389,
-0.2890105247,
-0.7341330051,
0.3228712678,
-0.4730965197,
-0.8042545319,
0.1794644445,
-0.0457467362,
-0.4463516176,
0.1078014448,
-0.476234287,
0.6074312329,
-0.4671834111,
-0.8695369959,
-0.5722073913,
-0.5441151857,
0.0799598023,
-0.2724698186,
0.2858678102,
-0.2091011852,
-0.1357082427,
0.8110841513,
-0.56859231,
0.7804172039,
-0.0067661903,
-0.182786122,
0.0361542702,
0.1368414164,
1.1611235142,
0.0441438444,
-0.1988401562,
0.1278825253,
-0.0715858489,
0.0502741486,
-0.6093688607,
1.0919730663,
-0.5753728747,
-0.9172024727,
-0.4981301129,
-0.3783697784,
-0.3219678998,
0.4055964351,
-0.3707789779,
0.4485101998,
0.1083779857,
0.4671345651,
0.4983442724,
-0.2911306322,
0.3224876523,
0.7612355947,
-0.5502185822,
-0.4754596949,
0.6402701139,
0.0565929078,
0.1562210023,
0.1757073551,
0.4702840447,
-0.6297581196,
-0.7389830351,
-0.2738470137,
0.4434828758,
-0.445934087,
0.0237818435,
-0.7854447365,
0.0991095081,
-0.3826667368,
-0.0046232771,
-0.3211598396,
-0.2267449498,
-0.2848674357,
-0.0647045448,
0.6346225142,
0.8574066758,
0.055507753,
0.1477513611,
-0.821750164,
0.4663805664,
0.1993369907,
0.778654635,
0.3266795874,
-0.7212334275,
-0.3623539805,
-0.1377273351,
0.1066601202,
-0.2758142352,
0.4403710663,
-0.0848045498,
0.4273262024,
0.3990060091,
0.2348873764,
0.884203136,
-0.8854201436,
0.6364017129,
0.3203417957,
-0.5878027081,
0.3609155715,
-0.4239536226,
0.1852107346,
0.5620842576,
0.3012591302,
-0.699416995,
0.0544446073,
-0.1906552315,
-1.208135128,
0.5975846052,
-0.1282052994,
0.1651881188,
0.004354306,
0.1058493853,
0.0934522003,
0.151211381,
-0.4632827044,
-0.2987809181,
0.2106790245,
-0.1957836002,
-0.3314063251,
-0.8016932607,
0.2548308671,
-0.0269001033,
0.7249038815,
0.2198578119,
-0.3605614305,
0.0520363301,
0.2437439412,
-0.0987481251,
0.4113149047,
0.2963663936,
0.5430567861,
-0.4194912314,
-0.2822035253,
-0.0461208373,
-0.1773567945,
0.0045537208,
0.113800548,
0.1048968211,
-0.3070247471,
-0.1291790307,
0.7490513325,
0.3847220838,
-0.6132778525,
0.4737173021,
-0.1653491259,
0.2505393028,
-0.7057958245,
-0.1989803314,
0.1831938028,
0.3250692189,
0.4589368701,
-0.0359670296,
0.3868614435,
-0.6417260766,
0.1531575918,
0.5210844278,
-0.2270471156,
-0.0380654745,
0.1565790623,
0.57489115,
-0.3067901134,
0.6226609349,
0.3082781732,
-0.3500633538,
0.0327610075,
0.632476449,
0.8688666821,
-0.0088393344,
-0.1037569121,
0.2744486928,
-0.1291151941,
-0.4835341871,
-0.1328465939,
-0.2085277736,
-0.7393784523,
-0.4411642551,
-0.7725551724,
-0.2825510204,
0.086589314,
-0.6177521944,
0.5957077742,
-0.1958957165,
-0.2775209546,
-0.0509407781,
0.120714955,
-0.4428857565,
-0.2195868641,
0.1825167686,
0.6511520147,
-0.4132195711,
0.8849592805,
0.4216330945,
-0.278541714,
-0.4637104273,
-0.2584683895,
0.0067670308,
-0.5728633404,
0.6751407385,
-0.0367222093,
-0.5567941666,
-0.1022382453,
-0.0403495096,
-0.9318010807,
0.8777962923,
-0.1207559481,
-1.1052993536,
-0.0630076677,
-0.0800929517,
0.6815146804,
-0.4899754822,
0.2306131721,
0.1664825976,
0.343791455,
0.528254509,
-0.9220592976,
0.1679793,
-0.0904116109,
0.1824433953,
0.4411571324,
-0.7720403671,
0.3750196993,
-0.3533836305,
-0.0029772832,
0.3276890814,
0.6970232725,
0.4646911621,
0.233840242,
0.711889863,
0.5184096694,
0.486174345,
0.3419212103,
1.0532571077,
-0.1824689358,
0.1615005732,
1.7257232666,
-0.9649369717,
1.1903011799,
0.5925319791,
-0.2545166314,
0.8141676188,
0.5045831203,
-0.1136627048,
0.5554447174,
0.1811363548,
-0.2112397701,
-0.4686848819,
-0.2550302148,
-0.5061795115,
0.100154005,
0.4744281173,
-0.5097010732,
0.0927272514,
0.0158601161,
-0.2445046604,
0.0980357602,
-0.1435264498,
1.0640749931,
0.1472942829,
-0.5545420051,
0.2912275493,
-0.049450919,
1.0826716423,
-0.8860123754,
-0.1967047155,
-0.0151930433,
0.345200479,
-0.1314837635,
-0.801422596,
-0.1786947101,
-0.1367702931,
-0.3280498087,
-0.2593592107,
0.8588348627,
-0.5022367835,
-0.7126619816,
0.6243991852,
0.3467129767,
-0.1430078894,
-0.0218691994,
-0.5220757127,
0.1120813265,
-0.0595699176,
-0.2962947786,
0.4892349839,
0.1274621338,
0.0145172477,
0.9737579226,
0.7459114194,
0.1720075607,
-0.3584203422,
0.3904284537,
0.7609960437,
-0.6579946876,
-0.5939266086,
-0.9164025187,
0.4173664153,
-0.1875510812,
0.2103879452,
0.9507701397,
0.4899303019,
0.831302464,
0.0304867588,
0.6905514598,
0.2279067785,
0.7949428558,
-0.3913867772,
0.4659260213,
-0.5931993723,
0.940974474,
-0.3514592648,
-0.8675621748,
-0.0062946104,
0.3173732162,
-0.5536339283,
0.2494410872,
0.4485137463,
0.7547143698,
0.0711128414,
-0.1484047025,
0.3759537339,
0.3970335126,
0.077472128,
0.4570166767,
1.077413559,
-0.0981889293,
0.2747158408,
-0.1883675754,
-0.1056306288,
-0.3539402187,
-0.8488479853,
-0.8591630459,
-0.6018232703,
-0.2870641649,
-0.4507496357,
0.2179755867,
1.3282182217,
0.5917429924,
-0.684548974,
-0.4103732109,
0.3333986104,
0.1447546333,
0.118013598,
-0.2104675323,
0.3825000525,
-0.0325696245,
-0.6833980083,
0.486212641,
0.4211364985,
0.0528324209,
-0.3844804764,
-0.0955398381,
-0.2111999542,
-0.0126250638,
0.9601175189,
-0.1182849631,
-0.7818443775,
-0.3063112497,
-0.1034525931,
0.187551558,
-0.1284088492,
0.8264369965,
-0.9333939552,
0.5236666799,
0.4367261529,
0.3802151382,
0.5912305117,
0.0434469618,
0.6591565013,
-0.4044656456,
0.0881083757,
0.0061256043,
0.6604771018,
0.2795606554,
-0.5233484507,
0.4437930286,
-0.0309530385,
-0.5792683363,
-0.7492296696,
0.3009034097,
-1.069106102,
-0.323005259,
1.3155605793,
-0.0626255497,
0.2194981873,
-0.2306861132,
-0.3538680673,
-0.1897800714,
-0.8884997964,
0.6439324617,
0.6556127667,
-0.0778242275,
0.0426404327,
-0.1412963718,
0.1623256803,
0.442546308,
-0.2851612568,
0.3023465574,
0.7511466146,
0.3922587633,
-0.1105596796,
0.5652986765,
-0.0253739115,
-0.2209345102,
-0.4680554569,
-0.2526127398,
-0.2329532206,
-0.4571051896,
-0.2866028547,
0.0889400616,
0.3686661124,
0.1811878383
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20628v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20628v1
|
ToxVidLLM: A Multimodal LLM-based Framework for Toxicity Detection in Code-Mixed Videos
| 2024-05-31T05:40:56 | 2024-05-31T05:40:56 |
Krishanu Maity, A. S. Poornash, Sriparna Saha, Pushpak Bhattacharyya
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
In an era of rapidly evolving internet technology, the surge in multimodal
content, including videos, has expanded the horizons of online communication.
However, the detection of toxic content in this diverse landscape, particularly
in low-resource code-mixed languages, remains a critical challenge. While
substantial research has addressed toxic content detection in textual data, the
realm of video content, especially in non-English languages, has been
relatively underexplored. This paper addresses this research gap by introducing
a benchmark dataset, the first of its kind, consisting of 931 videos with 4021
code-mixed Hindi-English utterances collected from YouTube. Each utterance
within this dataset has been meticulously annotated for toxicity, severity, and
sentiment labels. We have developed an advanced Multimodal Multitask framework
built for Toxicity detection in Video Content by leveraging Large Language
Models (LLMs), crafted for the primary objective along with the additional
tasks of conducting sentiment and severity analysis. ToxVidLLM incorporates
three key modules the Encoder module, Cross-Modal Synchronization module, and
Multitask module crafting a generic multimodal LLM customized for intricate
video classification tasks. Our experiments reveal that incorporating multiple
modalities from the videos substantially enhances the performance of toxic
content detection by achieving an Accuracy and Weighted F1 score of 94.29% and
94.35%, respectively.
|
[
-0.0428968072,
-0.6511394382,
0.4286679924,
0.5948265195,
-0.310390681,
0.1253034174,
-0.2653554082,
-0.1077817455,
-0.0264428928,
0.4129188657,
-0.6268619895,
-0.9216855764,
-0.7484099865,
0.0335615091,
-0.4670426846,
1.1390902996,
-0.049146492,
0.045631364,
-0.3605559468,
-0.4707304239,
-0.2737122774,
-0.2563337982,
-0.4905416071,
-0.0590955466,
0.7568069696,
0.4808806777,
0.6262173653,
0.3640237153,
0.3144176304,
0.3526565433,
-0.0431135185,
0.3458764255,
-0.5935817361,
0.2488477975,
-0.2571008205,
-0.3839339912,
-0.2272858024,
-0.30969432,
0.383253336,
-0.234488219,
-0.0132443728,
0.2643331587,
-0.1693295389,
0.2903092504,
-1.0686365366,
0.1780160666,
-0.3794415891,
0.445019275,
-0.2548412383,
-0.7322395444,
-0.6721797585,
-0.1164970994,
-0.4497952163,
-0.4170795083,
-0.46569103,
-0.100845404,
0.3244997859,
0.5673720241,
-0.813310802,
-0.3012082577,
-0.4364863038,
1.0383163691,
-0.690103054,
0.5197512507,
0.2618226707,
0.1115751788,
0.182106778,
-0.4181371331,
-0.5362170935,
-0.1814537942,
0.2128766775,
0.2994786501,
-0.1890021116,
0.1461302042,
0.1112152934,
0.280046314,
-0.8470897675,
0.1974362284,
0.0819863379,
-0.5059697032,
0.5599538684,
0.3329768181,
0.8057700992,
-0.5768530965,
-0.7302201986,
-0.0431775004,
-0.3226938546,
0.0154698556,
0.3980797231,
-0.0115318848,
-0.3175680041,
0.6227188706,
0.064704299,
0.2696068585,
-0.4246750176,
-0.6085929275,
0.3666442335,
-0.5719649196,
-0.2216407359,
-0.0410090573,
1.0110871792,
0.756370306,
0.0590248778,
0.0328580961,
-0.0506530292,
0.4795891643,
0.2543616295,
-0.970934391,
-0.251458019,
0.1700713933,
-0.5932075977,
-0.412787348,
-0.4159184098,
-1.0939720869,
-0.5694670677,
0.1025784016,
0.5773091912,
-0.2787947655,
-0.7026014328,
0.0702230111,
-0.0212440398,
0.1198353618,
0.1413994879,
-0.475354284,
0.0895289928,
0.4250489175,
0.8763023019,
-0.5988750458,
-0.150498569,
-0.6955843568,
0.1413263083,
-0.1787007004,
0.9320723414,
-0.647195518,
-0.2831200659,
0.2724823058,
-0.0609387532,
0.2068525851,
-0.8033892512,
0.6180659533,
-0.419302851,
-0.0050552776,
-0.1409162879,
-0.149166286,
-0.2592254281,
0.6654336452,
-0.5856342912,
1.1451295614,
0.0077300477,
-0.7127969265,
0.360930413,
-0.4110125899,
-0.5265910625,
-0.0974787846,
-0.0128756603,
-0.5142753124,
-0.245292291,
-0.0942066237,
0.3771174252,
-0.1856837124,
0.2973969579,
-0.5253298879,
-0.1656940877,
0.4146454632,
-0.7230803967,
0.484441638,
0.5238647461,
-0.0857336,
0.545153439,
-0.543487072,
0.2470948845,
-0.2907839715,
-0.5483481288,
-0.2239389867,
0.1365860701,
0.6479932666,
0.7644104362,
-0.2746618092,
-0.475130707,
-0.5663180351,
0.343203038,
0.3858100474,
0.7294797897,
-0.0102361152,
0.1098619625,
-0.4062365592,
0.6885136366,
0.2399588823,
0.4279154837,
-0.2149374187,
-0.4347396791,
-0.5092306137,
-0.3610449731,
-0.4091144502,
0.5988847613,
-0.9339404702,
0.137517333,
-0.1908575147,
-0.3201999962,
-0.106607154,
0.3882671893,
0.6642167568,
0.3601113558,
0.5625360608,
-0.4063881338,
-0.3748121262,
-0.5196332932,
-0.09951251,
-0.2281289846,
0.1931925714,
0.5164500475,
0.3487463295,
-0.4313098192,
0.4671046734,
-0.4473569691,
-0.7225210071,
0.0088216821,
0.0888580233,
-0.2309399247,
0.0879792646,
0.5133197904,
-0.7395704389,
-0.7820546627,
0.0455293097,
-1.0769791603,
-0.2092393935,
0.004122918,
-0.0069546378,
-0.1950385123,
0.6269103289,
0.0036937878,
0.0009481374,
0.9331062436,
-0.1674409807,
0.5068920255,
0.0282862391,
0.5667923689,
-1.0196456909,
-0.1872477233,
0.4577261209,
-0.4075632691,
-0.6382498145,
0.0153842475,
0.1320526153,
-0.1510769725,
-1.2340475321,
0.3284136951,
-0.0436355919,
0.2534810901,
-0.1484243125,
-0.0742935538,
-0.164217189,
0.6898150444,
0.127018109,
0.9740480781,
0.4562700689,
-0.3288016021,
0.6385271549,
0.2044333667,
-0.179821074,
0.8093419671,
-0.1546113193,
-0.2021000534,
-0.2365736812,
-0.0551827997,
-1.0540630817,
-0.1128253117,
0.1326462626,
-0.3981243074,
0.0172482263,
-0.1922668368,
-0.693467617,
0.0756395534,
-0.6684148908,
0.8100038767,
0.2446568161,
-0.4202315211,
0.5153384209,
0.6619383097,
-0.1522623897,
-0.464848578,
-0.7877908945,
0.2334964722,
-0.4568124115,
-0.8670096397,
0.108154662,
-0.5055590272,
-0.038509313,
-0.0354740657,
-0.2294859737,
-0.6104393005,
-0.3176078796,
0.3675577939,
0.0509045273,
-0.1444057375,
0.0816165581,
0.1217915565,
-0.0544531457,
0.3904978037,
0.3351586759,
0.2926333249,
0.0841449499,
-0.2617479265,
-0.2277746201,
0.5955531001,
0.699747026,
-0.2852533162,
0.1948757321,
0.8672732711,
-0.1675523371,
-0.4334624112,
-0.4130860865,
0.1695681512,
-0.5520185232,
0.7560232878,
0.1856962144,
-0.8037850261,
0.4667367041,
-0.1667659581,
-0.4257289469,
-0.0432755277,
0.7932229638,
0.147061184,
1.085898757,
0.3342784345,
-0.2246703058,
0.644969821,
-0.1465179324,
0.0437883548,
-0.5440385938,
-0.4017265737,
-0.0516594909,
0.0129016927,
-0.4546459913,
-0.7287837267,
0.7265135646,
-0.5047863722,
-0.3700280488,
-0.0177632924,
-0.2008750141,
0.6096215844,
0.0098616555,
0.4869972765,
0.5894585252,
0.0306287166,
-0.0475842468,
-0.2859256864,
-0.5596290231,
-0.2193703651,
0.9710872769,
0.4141411781,
0.9428697228,
0.4802857935,
0.2099536806,
0.7139338851,
0.4929695427,
-0.8266285658,
0.6336210966,
-0.5071374774,
-0.6785005927,
0.2969727814,
-0.2904258072,
-0.2894188166,
0.0911966488,
-0.3272244036,
-0.1689616144,
-0.2176748663,
-0.0844994113,
-0.3368796408,
0.4232599437,
-0.8111022711,
1.0187193155,
-0.516377151,
-0.9776954651,
-0.3650661707,
-0.4517632127,
0.7047197223,
-0.05433999,
0.6204867959,
-0.2099571079,
-0.2037893087,
0.4686530828,
-0.3102287948,
0.7720091939,
0.0537059642,
-0.309632957,
0.3632290959,
0.0921928808,
0.1698983759,
0.623857677,
0.1178646982,
0.1647470742,
-0.1626189798,
-0.1020431668,
-0.1012331247,
0.8910390139,
-0.6310256124,
-0.1782163829,
-0.5546351671,
-0.6085112691,
-0.0547568053,
0.2150149047,
0.0889204964,
0.1145653054,
0.1460805684,
0.0575790331,
1.1409065723,
-0.8910579085,
0.4937102199,
0.4243618846,
-0.1825541854,
-0.5033407211,
1.2540278435,
-0.4748735428,
0.3987371624,
0.2896710932,
-0.0526922122,
-0.2919135988,
-0.5770468712,
-0.3977665901,
0.1247047186,
-0.9491744637,
-0.5895333886,
-0.5345603228,
-0.3353941441,
-0.0091781206,
0.2250882685,
-0.4792068899,
0.6408574581,
-0.3679803312,
-0.1985504329,
0.4398128092,
0.4290935695,
-0.0656732321,
0.0346395634,
-1.0148211718,
0.6561864018,
0.4876395166,
0.8064496517,
-0.2252916098,
-0.2595657408,
0.0030487918,
-0.0393168181,
-0.4750108719,
-1.0808199644,
0.4665233493,
0.2485624999,
0.3585305512,
0.6173483729,
0.006276228,
0.7844775319,
-0.1773785055,
0.7834618092,
0.2717887759,
-0.8182277679,
0.3844954967,
-0.4803519547,
-0.1242402419,
0.3188534379,
0.5511004925,
-0.8360320926,
-0.3285457194,
0.2631464601,
-0.8100972772,
0.466147244,
0.1329152137,
0.4970605671,
-0.1881787777,
-0.3553610146,
0.215840295,
0.0458618067,
-1.153321147,
-0.3422943056,
-0.4204604626,
-0.1338375956,
0.0468727313,
-0.4284083545,
0.1192181855,
-0.2188396454,
0.3047916889,
-0.0637313575,
0.1948139518,
-0.19802396,
-0.7116109729,
-0.3773620725,
0.5496640801,
0.5911145806,
0.1698047519,
-0.2842120528,
0.2917506695,
0.0962127,
-0.482414186,
0.3117624521,
-0.2046338618,
0.0841198787,
-0.1746361405,
0.394998908,
0.5504229069,
0.453240037,
-1.2598962784,
0.7712951899,
-0.0373599492,
-0.2009423673,
-0.3381665945,
0.0157955196,
-0.0816225559,
0.2453767359,
0.1080629379,
0.0526522063,
0.3458966315,
-0.764765501,
0.4620001018,
0.3672499657,
-0.5740852356,
-0.2976344526,
0.8707999587,
0.3171736896,
0.1435127854,
0.3814041018,
-0.221258685,
-0.4965527356,
0.2887792885,
0.2219829559,
0.6738852859,
-0.1328665167,
0.5073999763,
0.2346829027,
0.0920035243,
-0.054743927,
0.4492169023,
0.0355890505,
-0.7034729123,
-0.6412830353,
-0.6688554287,
-0.0457441993,
0.2263100892,
-0.4942324758,
0.346088171,
-0.3493311107,
-0.0254896525,
-0.0197613668,
-0.3758169413,
-0.3164845407,
0.274258554,
0.3521926403,
0.5774750113,
-1.4509247541,
0.7368309498,
0.6456458569,
-0.6064634323,
-0.4810372591,
-0.3072468042,
0.2787548304,
-0.6423847675,
0.5606015325,
0.1423852891,
-0.0255416352,
-0.1036236286,
-0.05070135,
-0.4259899855,
0.896107614,
0.2459923774,
0.0024791113,
0.0311760791,
0.5159618855,
0.5635309815,
0.0351709872,
0.649785459,
0.1781499535,
0.4395323098,
0.1735633463,
-0.8166947961,
-0.0175031498,
-0.6877765656,
-0.0619520731,
0.0934139565,
-0.6118910313,
0.8323658705,
-0.0563163832,
-0.2244593501,
-0.2907333672,
0.2124348581,
0.0771428943,
0.5943402648,
0.448585093,
0.6122856736,
0.0280043818,
0.238377139,
0.6267732978,
-0.0233879946,
0.3315684497,
0.7818596959,
-0.2285671234,
0.7305163145,
0.5517792702,
-0.1850192398,
0.5146428943,
0.6126698256,
-0.042411834,
0.6649444103,
0.1345465928,
-0.5771748424,
-0.5233408809,
-0.5772540569,
-0.2126752883,
0.3386236727,
0.389901191,
-0.4218428135,
-0.5615836382,
0.5185130239,
-0.0440708064,
0.4077480137,
-0.6174378395,
0.8744425774,
0.0469101295,
-0.5212768316,
0.4722068608,
-0.1372176707,
1.1993006468,
-0.5493610501,
-0.0349996872,
-0.1229442805,
0.3160956502,
-0.5154405236,
-1.0790170431,
0.5347735286,
0.153551355,
-0.1515598893,
-0.4308867455,
0.6735737324,
-0.6104052663,
-0.2190687805,
0.7127736211,
0.2996034324,
-0.0810593218,
-0.2933970094,
-0.567949295,
0.4493433535,
-0.0997281671,
0.175041303,
0.4978869259,
0.2506628931,
-0.1964374185,
0.7932406068,
0.5063804388,
-0.0021459539,
0.353617698,
-0.0566611849,
1.003666997,
-0.4944700897,
-0.2188742161,
-0.7623994946,
0.6923414469,
0.1864697039,
-0.0929229334,
0.7675410509,
0.8316975236,
1.0018216372,
-0.2437750548,
0.8435050845,
0.0212101191,
-0.1588184237,
-0.5239090919,
0.6492347121,
-0.7677665949,
0.1844198257,
-0.3278565407,
-0.5990992785,
-0.3355405629,
0.2992114127,
0.2875761092,
0.0218267422,
0.9116058946,
1.2244474888,
-0.1404047906,
-0.277723372,
0.3893394172,
0.2067739964,
0.2988252342,
0.9007407427,
0.9002894163,
-0.4137567878,
1.0585414171,
-0.3898744285,
-0.1379416883,
-0.1395193338,
-1.0678110123,
-1.0260820389,
-0.4742963612,
-0.4536221027,
-0.3941154182,
-0.0301976651,
0.8243045211,
0.6608986855,
-0.7540437579,
-0.2632930279,
0.3246468902,
0.2322360873,
-0.1253590137,
-0.1955438852,
-0.1723529398,
-0.1533744782,
-0.5837492347,
0.2171791494,
0.6747893691,
-0.4134803116,
-0.2142217755,
-0.3226881027,
-0.2766496837,
-0.0949233696,
1.0385552645,
0.1754422039,
-0.4977862537,
-0.2892717123,
0.2817473412,
-0.1548437029,
0.2583413422,
0.7766548395,
-0.2941634059,
0.6380771995,
0.6322396994,
0.2672983408,
0.5541544557,
-0.1777124405,
0.086188063,
-0.987066865,
0.0740021691,
0.1529880464,
0.1220538244,
0.3100938499,
-0.2922512591,
0.2266136855,
0.1640550345,
-0.3295835257,
-0.8772126436,
0.2322341353,
-1.3470039368,
-0.2501506805,
1.5883789062,
-0.101403527,
-0.0949472636,
-0.2465169281,
-0.1951649636,
0.3197038174,
-0.4566459358,
0.7736005187,
0.5388753414,
0.1213391721,
-0.5721716285,
-0.7900381684,
0.4609166384,
0.2747183144,
-1.0701347589,
-0.0555002913,
0.492977351,
0.7442700267,
-0.0385140181,
0.4953712821,
-0.3257113695,
0.4730074108,
-0.3480590284,
-0.1122916117,
-0.2193109244,
-0.0973039716,
-0.1849347651,
0.2478324175,
-0.1153542027,
-0.0468601026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20624v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20624v1
|
Leveraging Large Language Models for Entity Matching
| 2024-05-31T05:22:07 | 2024-05-31T05:22:07 |
Qianyu Huang, Tongfang Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Entity matching (EM) is a critical task in data integration, aiming to
identify records across different datasets that refer to the same real-world
entities. Traditional methods often rely on manually engineered features and
rule-based systems, which struggle with diverse and unstructured data. The
emergence of Large Language Models (LLMs) such as GPT-4 offers transformative
potential for EM, leveraging their advanced semantic understanding and
contextual capabilities. This vision paper explores the application of LLMs to
EM, discussing their advantages, challenges, and future research directions.
Additionally, we review related work on applying weak supervision and
unsupervised approaches to EM, highlighting how LLMs can enhance these methods.
|
[
-0.4089008272,
-0.6071303487,
1.086350441,
0.1029467359,
-0.2260716707,
-0.0912177488,
-0.2730817497,
-0.8033962846,
-0.050710801,
0.8985167742,
-0.2816112936,
-0.5961226225,
-0.4383523464,
0.3324036002,
-0.6773450375,
0.7483787537,
-0.3985439539,
-0.0611083396,
-0.1385405511,
0.0114148585,
-0.6261276603,
-0.5668853521,
-0.5566350222,
-0.3275294304,
0.3301467299,
0.2791606784,
0.5687278509,
0.8010621667,
0.6204023957,
0.3080928922,
0.1889575124,
0.0887749642,
-0.3872858584,
0.2410051227,
-0.3322370648,
-0.5879695415,
-0.5204698443,
-0.0936054066,
0.8109874129,
0.8011326194,
-0.2531823516,
-0.0101783369,
0.0614682548,
0.1776874214,
-0.3623053432,
0.3489449918,
-0.974193573,
-0.0040340791,
-0.5676493049,
-0.21100761,
-0.2857334614,
-0.0009917901,
0.2191199809,
-0.533775568,
0.3411519527,
0.3549883366,
1.002109766,
0.2651618123,
-0.7516242266,
-0.3951229155,
-0.7814612389,
0.6272063255,
-0.7085428834,
0.5973328948,
0.2335889786,
0.1885928214,
-0.3839501441,
-0.7523265481,
-0.64360255,
0.1466750652,
-0.0212164409,
-0.1034906209,
-0.0422548242,
0.1576776356,
0.3046883345,
0.5076417327,
-0.392596364,
0.4774733484,
-0.0647121593,
-0.0417732708,
0.3994903564,
0.2121004909,
0.537124753,
0.1112137213,
-0.4623853862,
0.3102339506,
-0.9540147781,
-0.6869706511,
0.2416588217,
0.5414452553,
0.158397302,
0.8030934334,
0.110983029,
0.6615550518,
-0.0599843897,
-0.0574980453,
-0.0041124118,
-0.4089685977,
-0.4238248467,
0.1077456847,
0.6901904345,
0.4047917426,
0.3484455645,
-0.4100786448,
-0.4274331927,
0.1275951415,
-0.0648090541,
-0.7000886798,
-0.0729240626,
-0.1641037613,
-0.3470112979,
0.1420522928,
-0.1347651333,
-0.9753038883,
-0.2145088017,
-0.6365453601,
0.2364706844,
-0.1978770792,
-0.3568242788,
0.1154763252,
0.1320568919,
0.7036153078,
0.345110029,
-1.1053766012,
0.4400981963,
0.9509446621,
1.0084168911,
-0.1341184229,
-0.1745432615,
-0.3217873275,
0.5036807656,
-0.4419408143,
0.6447614431,
-0.6756874323,
-0.1792512238,
0.1101023257,
0.1935637295,
-0.0424462669,
-0.637033999,
0.8350024819,
-0.7780844569,
0.0654769987,
-0.3007994592,
-0.8834563494,
-0.0746684447,
0.073348999,
-0.7487494946,
0.8415790796,
0.2061307132,
-0.5819349885,
0.5603541732,
-0.463328898,
-0.38710168,
0.2535972297,
-0.1987680197,
-0.4752137363,
0.1447957307,
0.3475198746,
0.6989793181,
-0.6326372623,
0.1756992787,
-0.6392635703,
-0.3740054369,
-0.2409857959,
-0.1439530402,
0.3791196942,
0.2302962393,
-0.3117193878,
-0.2393231094,
-0.431704551,
-0.1240768656,
0.3401322067,
-0.2802839875,
-0.6973861456,
0.0560385957,
0.1842058003,
0.2697179317,
0.1692778766,
-0.2614583373,
0.2635608315,
-0.2914579809,
0.6279957294,
0.5434152484,
-0.0772862509,
0.5732235312,
-0.0414213836,
0.4365049899,
0.0413702503,
-0.3188756704,
-0.1995497495,
-0.3121371269,
-0.3622587621,
-0.4186786711,
0.4200575948,
0.5970877409,
-0.891854465,
0.3182816803,
-0.2879548967,
-0.2214852124,
-0.6348669529,
0.4096758366,
0.060012538,
0.3294596374,
0.5542437434,
-0.1510556787,
-0.697735548,
-0.9948670864,
-0.2201434821,
0.1789250672,
-0.2703599632,
0.413251698,
0.368973434,
-0.4571590126,
0.7129993439,
-0.2376040816,
-0.6578376889,
-0.1365815699,
-0.4484783411,
0.3223053515,
0.3497527838,
0.7010965347,
-0.8010811806,
-0.4402996898,
0.2126092315,
-0.9888876081,
-0.243389979,
0.0717396438,
-0.0681096315,
-0.1333147883,
0.5749618411,
-0.7852851748,
-0.1462854892,
0.7732177973,
-0.3919443786,
0.0926874578,
-0.09901537,
0.3640843928,
-1.318300128,
-0.2746239603,
0.3586445153,
-0.3726570606,
-0.5985984206,
0.1315460652,
0.1995440125,
-0.2236241847,
-0.2810521424,
0.4202266037,
-1.0754787922,
-0.4921520054,
-0.2274382114,
0.5066978931,
-0.0604676381,
-0.0493130833,
-0.1437195987,
0.8131117225,
0.8023938537,
-0.4430539012,
0.5915456414,
0.3191273212,
-0.3546441793,
0.839479506,
-0.5638680458,
0.2568027377,
-0.0242961738,
0.2660023272,
-0.474144727,
-0.4208078384,
-0.0646168441,
0.2064875364,
0.6904990077,
-0.4741875231,
-0.7577782869,
-0.3864473701,
-0.1150721163,
0.6482652426,
0.3686002791,
-0.8063765168,
0.972528398,
0.5643315315,
-0.2722856104,
-0.4562017024,
-0.6445176601,
0.550341785,
-0.6608653069,
-0.5877456069,
0.5885391831,
0.2551533878,
-0.2931672633,
0.1230645254,
-0.0462413318,
-0.0394378901,
0.1391871125,
0.0795485899,
0.4201974273,
-0.5134930611,
-0.0744164512,
-0.0947051197,
0.1049934104,
-0.038885653,
-0.3526012003,
0.2956956923,
0.0926826,
-0.423298955,
-0.3176091015,
0.5417674184,
0.6282389164,
-0.3356543779,
0.6135726571,
0.2529983521,
-0.5927059054,
-0.1867714971,
-0.764403522,
-0.037895862,
-0.4547651112,
0.5431314111,
-0.5842359066,
-1.1111699343,
0.4717468917,
-0.252042979,
-0.1290130913,
0.2424679995,
0.7178806663,
0.1273046136,
0.940623939,
0.6947697401,
-0.3703980744,
0.5211932659,
0.2889155447,
0.3572056293,
-0.892903924,
-0.036780037,
-0.5584651828,
-0.0602629483,
-0.8381772637,
-0.4337569177,
-0.1298260838,
0.1505764276,
-0.0703092739,
0.4576577544,
-0.3495027125,
0.7198392749,
0.3338645995,
-0.1672923714,
0.3996097147,
-0.4598055482,
0.1807275116,
0.0019195196,
-0.3038805425,
-0.7384842038,
1.2012873888,
0.5236682892,
0.9496924877,
0.3466250002,
0.6101461649,
-0.0000159585,
0.4918092787,
-0.6462275982,
0.6183447242,
-0.0163349286,
-0.5693507195,
-0.2131415457,
-0.6008194685,
-1.0890408754,
0.2965936363,
-0.3415979743,
-0.6317309141,
0.0187071208,
0.1270697564,
-0.0069258823,
0.4201084077,
-1.0638040304,
0.7772905827,
-0.2694780529,
-0.1472253501,
0.310744375,
-0.236728549,
0.5611070991,
-0.5472581387,
0.2403751165,
-0.214958638,
-0.1775598526,
0.5557564497,
0.0115927635,
0.3508269787,
-0.0722601414,
-0.5208116174,
0.0797342137,
0.0191139672,
0.7638764381,
0.0977289751,
0.0402205437,
0.3126239181,
0.0089587495,
-0.4150215983,
-0.4052630365,
1.1968380213,
-0.4872117341,
-0.7335603833,
-0.1795747578,
-0.5086429715,
-0.2500758767,
0.3676825464,
-0.0888348445,
0.0336574353,
-0.1516762227,
0.0970164016,
0.6983875036,
0.0215137526,
0.4346170425,
0.5330993533,
-0.307318598,
-0.0362225957,
0.5215160847,
0.0543193258,
0.098836422,
0.3491293192,
-0.3952972889,
-0.5010276437,
-0.7714858651,
-0.3420240283,
0.4970768988,
-0.655130446,
-0.4056629837,
-0.6458265781,
0.3273080587,
-0.3000538647,
-0.0070884023,
-0.2573696077,
0.2511610687,
-0.3192026913,
-0.0958298296,
0.0790675879,
0.9295297265,
0.3308190703,
-0.1098901927,
-0.7409593463,
0.2059426457,
0.4146220386,
0.6866082549,
-0.3272441924,
-0.2990439832,
-0.0301686358,
-0.3127063513,
-0.0469297655,
-1.082259059,
0.1456775963,
0.2671317458,
0.5859490633,
0.0660727024,
-0.1785958707,
0.4643308222,
-0.9879781604,
0.5231938362,
-0.1130596325,
-1.0298610926,
0.3695141375,
-0.458135426,
-0.2250439972,
0.2292028666,
0.4227104485,
-0.3371832371,
-0.2825041711,
-0.2542881668,
-1.0661170483,
0.4493480921,
0.1511434466,
0.2322783172,
-0.176958397,
0.6630128622,
-0.2871820331,
0.0843487307,
-0.737001121,
0.0268721487,
0.103333801,
-0.5292805433,
-0.2121875286,
-0.0960868448,
0.0917623118,
0.252089113,
0.5684998035,
-0.207189545,
0.345320344,
-0.0400036499,
-0.2005126774,
-0.1661435366,
0.3810183406,
0.4093087912,
0.4744584858,
0.0881226435,
0.1707655489,
0.4627031386,
-0.1084873453,
0.0507965945,
0.3558358848,
0.015937997,
-0.082187064,
0.4364133477,
0.6425728798,
0.3300236762,
-0.5526204109,
0.5290275812,
-0.0030923241,
-0.1798833013,
-0.2440443337,
-0.0533334948,
0.3485001624,
0.5707483292,
0.3868305981,
-0.537577033,
0.1193005815,
-0.7644709945,
0.2394868135,
0.692602396,
-0.2216105461,
-0.3918955028,
0.9483878016,
0.0858727545,
-0.2673694789,
0.5503178835,
0.2044286132,
-0.4300243258,
0.4104565084,
0.7748480439,
0.5349476337,
-0.4135231674,
-0.5811853409,
-0.0560019948,
0.2360515743,
-0.4768330157,
-0.0432369448,
0.3146329224,
-0.8489157557,
-0.7616311312,
-0.5493804216,
-0.3293138146,
0.130725503,
-0.5615822077,
0.5151264668,
-0.1260592341,
-0.0807056203,
0.168547675,
-0.2955952287,
-1.1777980328,
0.0193067864,
0.2734779418,
0.6616219282,
-1.0441682339,
0.7834578156,
0.7557967901,
-0.3755332232,
-1.0040097237,
0.0095539447,
0.011492664,
-0.7291288972,
0.5547903776,
-0.0558135584,
0.3371072412,
0.3238832951,
-0.3713831306,
-0.8835336566,
1.2904571295,
0.6210766435,
-0.876324594,
-0.4192253649,
-0.1254686415,
0.5006535649,
-0.4463323355,
0.3117070794,
0.9656657577,
0.3863034844,
-0.2416658849,
-1.1194518805,
0.3186486065,
0.2783329487,
0.1870299876,
0.7584657073,
-0.430698812,
0.7181594968,
-0.0999343321,
-0.38435781,
-0.0955284536,
0.6614322066,
-0.0255243592,
0.1499284953,
0.4396115839,
0.7086822391,
0.6865645051,
-0.3522998095,
0.8775738478,
-0.2640087903,
0.8012233973,
1.1262480021,
-0.9488075376,
0.7331044078,
0.3978405595,
-0.3000479937,
0.2684975863,
0.5956394672,
-0.2794263065,
0.3076879084,
0.0946909711,
-0.2897019088,
-0.16535528,
-0.0791719854,
-0.2746380866,
0.4141310155,
0.4857577085,
-0.4125228226,
-0.382617116,
-0.0357376225,
-0.150957197,
0.1545611322,
-0.4094863534,
0.9053590298,
0.2964733243,
-0.2761782706,
0.1042531207,
-0.0755349323,
0.7119799852,
-0.1765121967,
-0.2595800459,
-0.0060553402,
0.0042752177,
-0.089374356,
-0.9669016004,
0.0659444407,
-0.1121348441,
-0.1452412456,
-0.1520605087,
0.7241116166,
-0.6460833549,
-0.0244683158,
0.6507922411,
0.5866502523,
-0.0247994922,
-0.0324114524,
-0.5739079118,
-0.0706775412,
-0.2532877326,
-0.228995651,
0.4740197659,
1.0672764778,
-0.0997867808,
0.5917679667,
0.5146214962,
0.0729208887,
-0.1507899016,
0.1260717213,
0.7413480878,
-0.9078656435,
-0.1721417606,
-1.0540534258,
-0.0564248078,
0.0144344214,
0.0602520779,
0.697067678,
0.6337736249,
0.8418980241,
0.1174218655,
0.7399728894,
0.14917171,
0.6055393815,
-0.6684879661,
0.239003256,
-0.3725987971,
0.5931967497,
-0.6542298794,
-1.4527189732,
-0.3424610198,
0.2383827567,
-0.2455269843,
0.3361556828,
0.6096636057,
0.7078654766,
-0.4290598035,
-0.2260222584,
0.5496248007,
0.2312713265,
0.5721923113,
0.7524082661,
0.7906559706,
-0.2752031982,
0.4194922745,
0.3854506314,
-0.1807383299,
-0.2574858367,
-0.943751514,
-0.9567887187,
-0.5178570747,
-0.2162212282,
-0.2396672368,
0.0193584599,
1.0261870623,
0.5076938272,
-0.6315974593,
0.2392834872,
0.0361115858,
-0.0135058733,
0.1650353372,
-0.2437554896,
0.3029500544,
-0.071428284,
-1.0266097784,
0.5210963488,
0.5198482871,
0.4476970136,
-0.1012826711,
0.2033051699,
-0.1042902172,
0.0469747074,
0.5497549176,
0.1587571353,
-0.7331707478,
-0.5065071583,
-0.1987751573,
-0.1584639996,
-0.1305343211,
0.8955664635,
-0.3773241341,
0.050188601,
0.0267006587,
1.1021986008,
0.5868865252,
0.0784554034,
0.7064412236,
-0.5736955404,
-0.0580476746,
0.3301678896,
0.8394514918,
0.6836669445,
-0.3997399807,
0.6458254457,
0.0961713567,
-0.900687933,
-0.9652420878,
0.3350000679,
-0.8481709361,
0.0523476824,
1.1563278437,
-0.1806899458,
0.0071430393,
-0.5508796573,
-0.0293932334,
0.0625672713,
-0.1809170246,
0.3732924163,
0.7257162929,
0.1331468672,
-0.4081241488,
-0.9008252621,
0.3637059033,
0.2725717425,
-0.9270521998,
-0.0175600462,
0.4042392969,
0.5227060914,
-0.0953427851,
0.5496144891,
-0.0300669204,
-0.1339322478,
-0.348005116,
0.17446585,
0.2709206343,
0.0375599079,
-0.2250882834,
0.1552334279,
0.3361625671,
0.1265875101
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20613v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20613v1
|
FineRadScore: A Radiology Report Line-by-Line Evaluation Technique Generating Corrections with Severity Scores
| 2024-05-31T04:05:09 | 2024-05-31T04:05:09 |
Alyssa Huang, Oishi Banerjee, Kay Wu, Eduardo Pontes Reis, Pranav Rajpurkar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The current gold standard for evaluating generated chest x-ray (CXR) reports
is through radiologist annotations. However, this process can be extremely
time-consuming and costly, especially when evaluating large numbers of reports.
In this work, we present FineRadScore, a Large Language Model (LLM)-based
automated evaluation metric for generated CXR reports. Given a candidate report
and a ground-truth report, FineRadScore gives the minimum number of
line-by-line corrections required to go from the candidate to the ground-truth
report. Additionally, FineRadScore provides an error severity rating with each
correction and generates comments explaining why the correction was needed. We
demonstrate that FineRadScore's corrections and error severity scores align
with radiologist opinions. We also show that, when used to judge the quality of
the report as a whole, FineRadScore aligns with radiologists as well as current
state-of-the-art automated CXR evaluation metrics. Finally, we analyze
FineRadScore's shortcomings to provide suggestions for future improvements.
|
[
-0.19871144,
-0.4030966163,
0.7558848858,
-0.0510563701,
-0.3089002669,
-0.2510645688,
-0.18807742,
-0.5695870519,
0.0136545422,
0.6577325463,
-0.3292559683,
-0.7579557896,
-1.0675264597,
0.0397860296,
-0.5027114153,
1.2339804173,
0.0721757039,
-0.0637094304,
-0.3026069701,
-0.0696931034,
-0.5461710691,
-0.1753936261,
-0.6015688777,
-0.30015558,
0.4558745921,
0.6263988018,
1.2992928028,
0.8843271732,
1.0756379366,
0.3021478355,
-0.0150719481,
0.4662423134,
-0.3764989078,
-0.1973805428,
-0.0358759388,
-0.0825815052,
-0.8353762627,
-0.1278016716,
0.3931277692,
0.6114414334,
0.0249050632,
0.2378546894,
-0.167609632,
0.7747704387,
-0.546049118,
-0.1400329769,
-0.2158928365,
0.1311636567,
-0.033212997,
-0.6105490923,
-0.3116139174,
-0.545945704,
0.0958462432,
-0.2762580216,
0.0286875833,
-0.2732822001,
0.900066793,
0.2631039023,
-0.2362278551,
-0.7189545035,
-0.5055781603,
0.6551570892,
-0.5652772188,
0.2381806225,
0.3617869616,
0.6556717753,
0.2567208111,
-0.8327293992,
0.4029037356,
-0.3993642032,
-0.2763192356,
0.0469917879,
-0.3181973398,
-0.0012534754,
-0.0756767169,
0.7018597126,
-0.4844097793,
0.0730811208,
-0.5001726151,
-0.1340708137,
1.0752723217,
0.5126475096,
0.1622744054,
-0.2767482698,
-0.2719434798,
-0.2159204632,
-0.3021345735,
-0.1808471978,
-0.1134399101,
0.5349664092,
-0.1456269324,
0.447144568,
-0.3746648133,
0.7292467952,
0.3000333011,
-0.4755938351,
0.4067034423,
0.0819053948,
-0.2152921557,
0.5707840323,
0.7388203144,
0.7266196609,
-0.1281171888,
-0.2195249647,
-0.436491847,
0.2198444605,
0.3606913686,
-0.7430474162,
-0.0741635486,
0.2100477517,
-0.6478628516,
-0.6571699977,
0.0194872189,
-0.1729621887,
-0.4849842787,
-0.4343847334,
0.5773894191,
-0.4029768705,
0.191859737,
0.3604497313,
-0.0437785909,
-0.0212775264,
0.7818099856,
-0.0827479661,
0.6339691877,
0.6769172549,
0.8656929135,
0.1787184924,
-0.054622259,
-1.0586615801,
-0.1671091616,
-0.4161016643,
1.477638483,
-0.4635290504,
-0.661583066,
-0.2975976765,
-0.2799223661,
0.2910730243,
-0.7304621935,
0.8917070627,
-0.2074075341,
-0.1274773926,
-0.0680439919,
-0.5437034369,
0.1065873355,
0.4872815311,
-0.374132067,
0.8272396326,
0.4012374878,
-0.4608888626,
0.439072758,
-0.3272362053,
-0.2127681226,
0.2253586501,
-0.2557563186,
-0.433939755,
0.2681155205,
0.4105124772,
0.3631427884,
-0.3090924025,
0.1349563897,
0.2203525156,
-0.4633007944,
0.2706252038,
-0.1386906654,
0.5098851919,
0.203233853,
-0.1270052195,
0.0611943454,
-0.8111879826,
0.3007215261,
-0.4187264144,
-0.3650701642,
-0.0972683057,
-0.1373473108,
-0.042931892,
0.3694311976,
0.074268423,
-0.4895671308,
0.0500733778,
0.0302944388,
-0.3181664646,
0.7549830079,
0.0686559007,
-0.0054201046,
-0.7643027306,
0.3911633193,
-0.0379751325,
0.4447178841,
0.0490683652,
-0.1984674335,
-0.6455795765,
-0.5028367043,
0.1897471547,
0.4073675275,
0.0443893336,
0.6009581685,
-0.5734729171,
-1.1330955029,
-0.5278615355,
0.205624193,
0.646094203,
0.5054085255,
0.4634950757,
-0.6749897003,
-0.3775468469,
-0.7115831375,
-0.3651252389,
-0.0090989107,
0.2562727928,
0.3724001646,
-0.0060168081,
-0.5321391821,
0.6361681819,
-0.7964106798,
-0.8179631233,
0.0680123493,
0.4311126173,
0.0852634758,
0.3813360035,
0.3285319507,
-0.1140159369,
-0.3270307481,
0.155597344,
-0.6969110966,
-0.3915902674,
-0.2012878507,
-0.1094010919,
0.1286106557,
0.7194240093,
-0.177873835,
0.3895953,
0.6071730256,
-0.433794409,
0.5525324941,
-0.4451516271,
0.6206465364,
-0.3658801317,
-0.1956841052,
0.2620128989,
-0.512488544,
-0.1200015396,
0.0355418548,
-0.0813986063,
-0.1369764507,
-0.3323122263,
0.5077525973,
-0.4914418459,
-0.1497288346,
-0.1764803976,
0.2086079419,
0.0931446552,
-0.2004911304,
0.0895048678,
0.2444675565,
0.4126570225,
-0.6672435999,
0.2475360483,
0.3401108384,
-0.4206130207,
0.7949016094,
-0.5972352028,
0.3217699826,
-0.053690888,
0.092372559,
-0.8350684643,
-0.0434644409,
-0.2749286592,
-0.5428581834,
0.3290168643,
-0.2855073512,
-0.3680025041,
-0.2475413084,
-0.4740102291,
0.1529680192,
0.4692429006,
-0.3008804619,
0.2814593911,
0.2812975645,
-0.293838501,
-0.2043251842,
-0.9349442124,
0.3563802242,
0.1690595001,
-0.6613979936,
0.2102093697,
-0.2333989143,
-0.4434358776,
0.120558776,
-0.0128482794,
-0.1563467532,
-0.0774781778,
0.3771319985,
-0.0273017399,
-0.2548164427,
-0.2323337197,
0.0384576656,
-0.3590460718,
0.0522814132,
0.2002057433,
0.1028447896,
-0.4538378716,
-0.3526420295,
-0.4171232879,
0.3399429023,
0.5256249905,
0.0801485404,
-0.0111438781,
0.3793979585,
-0.2356910259,
0.1435742825,
-0.688528657,
0.1198343635,
-0.3557921946,
0.2915285826,
-0.2649202347,
-0.7639852166,
0.2445625663,
0.0908773467,
0.0330776237,
0.6491849422,
0.4579515457,
0.1223277375,
1.2077649832,
0.3072886467,
0.2969397902,
-0.1765520126,
-0.0786858723,
0.1487878263,
-0.7196878791,
-0.1779118627,
-0.7498856783,
-0.0832961723,
-0.4549244642,
-0.4507368505,
0.6823890209,
-0.2212528735,
-0.181330353,
-0.1028898433,
-0.7104646564,
0.3841198087,
0.1421830952,
0.4884611666,
0.519392848,
0.0557276607,
0.4451805651,
0.0148460977,
-0.4775141478,
-0.7128238082,
0.9161362052,
0.3210805357,
0.7927307487,
0.0942151919,
0.9252894521,
0.6349461079,
0.3405843973,
-0.9434124827,
0.4598151445,
-0.8274778128,
-0.2455914915,
0.0390110314,
-0.3367425501,
-0.6083185673,
-0.133352533,
-0.1889764667,
-0.2660157681,
0.0289401226,
0.0618144497,
-0.609803319,
-0.0972560421,
-0.4086127281,
0.641747117,
-0.4993625283,
-0.1717594266,
-0.399104327,
-0.5690530539,
0.2987835407,
-0.0144683784,
0.4607037604,
-0.1603023857,
0.0112206722,
0.6830872297,
-0.9470099807,
0.713388443,
-0.099243179,
-0.1946010292,
0.3411860168,
0.3842796087,
0.2545130253,
0.19042404,
-0.4123503268,
0.1178797632,
0.0153545588,
-0.124673821,
-0.2938067317,
0.8543675542,
-1.0024034977,
-0.3706472516,
-0.5981296897,
-0.7365784049,
-0.1073537469,
0.0917201266,
0.3199596107,
0.9973537326,
-0.3087045252,
-0.1580605209,
0.42421332,
-0.2295352966,
-0.1777020991,
0.4570013881,
-0.0729719996,
-0.5667447448,
0.7171725035,
0.5292872787,
0.0248789564,
0.2140659839,
0.3681069911,
0.0201094635,
-0.5017040968,
-0.3454317451,
0.1830561161,
-0.9970789552,
-0.6385017037,
-0.677007854,
-0.3554288149,
-0.302798748,
-0.719167769,
-0.4416032732,
-0.4187584519,
-0.0127114709,
0.052215606,
0.6174684763,
0.6396594644,
-0.4647909999,
0.3367610872,
-1.2368395329,
0.2386237979,
0.3270522356,
0.4209448397,
-0.3453406692,
-0.8487257361,
-0.4783391953,
-0.3089580536,
-0.2469346076,
-0.1742624342,
0.2406142652,
0.1268159747,
0.2111052275,
0.3765852451,
-0.0128346551,
1.1855159998,
-0.1981488913,
0.744633913,
0.2017386407,
-0.979562521,
0.715988636,
-0.2136053443,
0.4342449307,
0.8538970351,
-0.1026490107,
-0.3635084927,
-0.5833837986,
-0.7217449546,
-0.8205762506,
0.5825698972,
-0.196047917,
0.1156800389,
-0.3493982553,
0.2944212556,
0.1645719707,
-0.2814497054,
-0.1948561072,
-0.0435750447,
0.0713840798,
-0.1015508771,
-0.0042982413,
-0.4349897206,
-0.164487794,
-0.2623926401,
0.7427252531,
-0.1396015137,
0.1854808182,
0.5698401332,
-0.4051915407,
-0.487157315,
0.2834452689,
0.5659970641,
0.8994637132,
-0.6701672673,
0.3068523407,
-0.0148642054,
-0.34128353,
-0.0506790616,
0.0964739621,
0.1752381325,
0.3031924069,
0.5756968856,
0.5231140256,
0.2302094698,
-0.7190003395,
0.7612478733,
-0.3266656399,
-0.2429468483,
-0.2051555514,
-0.0976585075,
-0.315842241,
0.1221212,
0.241272375,
0.5922480822,
0.4771911502,
-0.2803704441,
0.4317808747,
0.1713699102,
-0.9863455892,
0.1140254736,
0.2050835788,
0.0894228145,
0.2503793538,
0.679351151,
-0.222253114,
-0.0746483728,
0.584446311,
0.2482316494,
0.9523018003,
-0.289224118,
0.3348125517,
0.3932094574,
0.2222816497,
-0.1827317178,
0.1768055558,
0.2157266736,
-0.2102661729,
-0.4847864211,
-0.4585286975,
-0.4077588022,
-0.2429089546,
-0.9216559529,
0.7902460098,
-0.6607421041,
-0.13769117,
-0.0280254744,
0.1549114436,
-0.3665191233,
0.9194594622,
0.5143728256,
1.1533552408,
-0.7509163022,
0.2404209822,
0.7017336488,
-0.346534729,
-0.9437561035,
-0.2231154889,
0.1903398931,
-0.8513178825,
0.7472307086,
0.2739899457,
-0.3915798962,
-0.327234745,
-0.1091812402,
-0.7662933469,
1.0667674541,
0.2036528587,
-0.4533381164,
0.3498920798,
-0.0210379343,
0.4963338673,
-0.3556989133,
0.6464428306,
0.5378826261,
0.3706744909,
-0.1023893878,
-0.9199223518,
0.2825054228,
-0.1934095919,
-0.0829361826,
0.161175251,
-0.5607051253,
0.6500068307,
-0.371950686,
-0.0344900154,
0.1335251629,
0.3885562718,
0.2887859643,
0.2752651274,
0.4543446302,
0.9447541833,
0.649815917,
0.0849162862,
1.347571969,
-0.0931604803,
0.3356746435,
1.0456422567,
-0.1432265937,
0.545356214,
0.1475839317,
0.0866990089,
0.6465499997,
0.445633322,
-0.1088831425,
0.3943782747,
0.1718457192,
-0.0415707529,
-0.3448177874,
-0.3310000598,
-0.4158628285,
0.5378113389,
0.2786581218,
-0.4778772295,
-0.6157510877,
-0.2696995437,
0.3666257262,
0.0888652727,
-0.826366961,
0.9221049547,
-0.0059686541,
-0.4702385366,
0.8419062495,
0.0444868915,
0.4765923321,
-0.5404480696,
0.0742586404,
-0.2866672575,
0.5550541878,
-0.8597895503,
-0.9378266335,
0.8525931835,
0.3062548041,
-0.2378735989,
0.0509756915,
0.5396650434,
-0.0011059468,
-0.8420022726,
0.211435169,
0.2516200244,
0.2685190439,
-0.1045661271,
-0.7404668331,
0.5564755201,
-0.1737630516,
-0.0778175145,
0.2760880589,
0.4157483876,
-0.2422108203,
0.3567072153,
0.2403881252,
0.3133669198,
-0.2761305273,
0.4196764827,
0.9448065162,
-0.4554929435,
-0.4478481412,
-0.5355226398,
0.678421855,
0.065472506,
-0.4741334915,
0.3841193318,
0.7629536986,
0.496376574,
0.0737698078,
0.8841272593,
-0.0378498212,
0.4849845171,
-0.5440453291,
0.3644814193,
-0.5764247775,
0.3137696683,
-0.5775196552,
-0.5242084861,
-0.893027842,
0.3531410694,
-0.39898628,
-0.0591003299,
0.7545768619,
1.0241981745,
-0.1078455225,
-0.4441259801,
0.3479095399,
0.3209415078,
0.1614262462,
0.4475056827,
0.6353390813,
-0.8103767037,
0.6617044806,
-0.4398540556,
-0.4395616055,
-0.4109176397,
-0.8846846223,
-0.4776976705,
-0.0974357426,
-1.0850073099,
-0.5634644032,
0.3478238583,
0.923758626,
0.7362529039,
-0.5031099916,
-0.4706125855,
0.2401495725,
-0.2925376296,
-0.4259234965,
-0.2537603676,
0.6549248099,
-0.551248014,
-0.3552874327,
0.1293646544,
0.5798638463,
-0.3642333448,
0.227774173,
-0.2985895872,
0.2247945666,
0.0462163538,
0.6168478727,
-0.0655394197,
-0.3049246073,
-0.4263094366,
-0.3012448549,
-0.4311958253,
0.3627046943,
0.6218489408,
-0.8308123946,
0.4336766899,
0.3158694804,
0.4195536673,
0.2359407544,
-0.0125192814,
0.1894928515,
-0.6202443838,
-0.1156603843,
0.1124543101,
0.2239446193,
0.6850203872,
-0.7477399707,
0.403028965,
-0.1783329248,
-0.6668696404,
-0.8414302468,
-0.1427272409,
-1.2751258612,
-0.2873842716,
0.985517323,
-0.009457225,
-0.1534687728,
0.0561653115,
-0.387789309,
0.0776215717,
-0.3325955868,
0.7600032687,
0.1322899759,
-0.4028645754,
-0.3764592409,
-0.1612555385,
0.320900321,
0.1702220142,
-0.8074351549,
-0.0182890445,
0.6383419037,
0.2918972075,
0.2912058234,
0.7638934255,
-0.7242543697,
0.8487383723,
-0.1377775669,
0.0674173832,
-0.0364358202,
-0.0007035158,
-0.4108025134,
0.0045017451,
0.68602705,
0.1870722473
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.