id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08355v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08355v1
|
Seal-Tools: Self-Instruct Tool Learning Dataset for Agent Tuning and Detailed Benchmark
| 2024-05-14T06:50:19 | 2024-05-14T06:50:19 |
Mengsong Wu, Tong Zhu, Han Han, Chuanyuan Tan, Xiang Zhang, Wenliang Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents a new tool learning dataset Seal-Tools, which contains
self-instruct API-like tools. Seal-Tools not only offers a large number of
tools, but also includes instances which demonstrate the practical application
of tools. Seeking to generate data on a large scale while ensuring reliability,
we propose a self-instruct method to generate tools and instances, allowing
precise control over the process. Moreover, our Seal-Tools contains hard
instances that call multiple tools to complete the job, among which some are
nested tool callings. For precise and comprehensive evaluation, we use strict
format control and design three metrics from different dimensions. Therefore,
Seal-Tools can serve as a new benchmark to evaluate the tool-calling ability of
LLMs. Finally, we evaluate several prevalent LLMs and our finetuned model on
Seal-Tools. The results show that current systems are far from perfect. The
code, data and experiment results are available at
https://github.com/fairyshine/Seal-Tools .
|
[
-0.4967712462,
-0.4787787795,
0.2499384433,
0.0705419183,
-0.2189472616,
0.4610029757,
0.0346388333,
-0.4409217238,
0.1938952357,
0.5734072328,
-0.7287737131,
-0.6413964629,
-0.1714983135,
0.2392080128,
-0.2105401605,
0.8381918073,
0.1403992623,
-0.1196021736,
-0.2151037902,
0.08066082,
-0.3675214648,
-0.1327695698,
-0.8153510094,
-0.4328058064,
0.2679800391,
0.6162472963,
0.6880966425,
1.0483242273,
0.3033288419,
0.3666496277,
0.4923481047,
0.3891700804,
-0.3764321506,
0.293766439,
-0.4916100204,
-0.5878635049,
-0.7330355048,
0.4545825124,
0.2487374991,
0.195394814,
-0.2493825853,
0.5124436617,
0.1120407432,
0.3103272021,
-0.7450865507,
0.2922210991,
-0.860702157,
-0.0139497845,
-0.2483843118,
-0.2690401971,
-0.3843880296,
-0.1098777801,
-0.1627902389,
-0.845066607,
0.2796251476,
0.102444388,
0.6654859185,
0.6600680351,
-0.3678769767,
-0.1919324547,
-0.474034816,
0.8807015419,
-0.6799793839,
0.0493985079,
0.3910461068,
0.770763278,
-0.2733528614,
-0.9344069362,
-0.0349215232,
-0.085612759,
0.1276395023,
0.2994006872,
0.1550069153,
0.0005152236,
0.1144011095,
0.2009159327,
-0.3110751212,
0.5430927277,
-0.2082334012,
-0.3966314495,
1.020588994,
0.4835535288,
-0.1815888286,
0.3360235393,
-0.5734138489,
-0.5899233222,
-0.7303961515,
0.1448510885,
0.623906374,
0.2868385315,
-0.0232356992,
0.1409938782,
-0.3751002252,
0.4472106695,
0.1614600271,
-0.4804134965,
0.4133681655,
0.1006453186,
-0.3173980117,
-0.0212420635,
0.747418642,
0.5093944669,
0.2831528783,
-0.24973768,
-0.5782839656,
-0.1681784093,
0.4734521508,
-0.6944254637,
-0.1461907923,
0.2185679525,
-0.2337314337,
-0.6292800903,
0.0506018139,
-0.5856792927,
-0.5072442889,
-0.3522096872,
0.2704887986,
0.0099153137,
-0.4672310054,
0.2050631493,
-0.0983613133,
0.7266526222,
0.3652845025,
-0.3848682344,
0.6756056547,
0.6793299317,
0.7315304279,
-0.3009281158,
-0.4886561036,
-0.630353272,
0.1405129582,
-0.5056277514,
0.9753832221,
-0.4708732367,
-0.410621196,
0.032850828,
0.2733566761,
0.1393209547,
-0.8526574373,
0.2880961895,
-0.3508797884,
-0.2228120416,
-0.0227417946,
-0.6611643434,
-0.0721300244,
0.1932104826,
-0.6059763432,
1.2638611794,
0.1884815991,
-0.2734768689,
0.4753165841,
-0.6321856976,
-0.2868267596,
0.2748456895,
-0.1473637968,
-0.9473089576,
-0.157367453,
0.2360604703,
0.8006819487,
-0.5128833652,
-0.0321113691,
-0.8181777,
-0.3696924448,
0.2663612962,
-0.104132466,
0.4672196805,
0.4338121116,
-0.4325312972,
0.1529583037,
-0.5595098734,
0.3757620156,
0.1962880492,
0.244133383,
0.1604488045,
-0.2337245494,
-0.2356520891,
0.0365515165,
0.2954207361,
-0.5190266967,
0.472966969,
-0.2322181165,
0.3043686152,
0.9797851443,
0.1146508902,
0.2679201365,
-0.4668769538,
0.8632258773,
-0.2215151489,
0.6028034687,
0.077548258,
0.0755882412,
-0.6896666288,
-0.4054271877,
0.2856939137,
0.3358409405,
-0.6612960696,
0.5493291616,
0.1613631845,
-0.8983384967,
-0.6516085267,
0.2878723741,
0.4510612488,
0.1501816213,
0.0956695378,
-0.3788641691,
-0.2779986262,
-1.050645709,
-0.0254628398,
0.1345121711,
0.0041139885,
0.2080626637,
0.6743829846,
-0.030938236,
0.9203777909,
-0.5133911371,
-0.3495053649,
0.2127115577,
-0.0840709955,
0.2639152706,
0.2383514643,
0.6760200262,
-0.3249079287,
-0.5443772078,
-0.2617744505,
-0.8019797206,
-0.0497305319,
0.0242648236,
-0.2376643866,
0.0535393246,
0.8115417361,
-0.3091405034,
0.3806168735,
0.335190773,
-0.0078529529,
1.0100491047,
-0.1831674576,
-0.3540580273,
-0.8028640151,
-0.0897408873,
-0.0846932083,
-0.4558246732,
-0.4059250355,
0.0475161634,
0.1283549219,
-0.0378465392,
-0.5541988015,
0.6731674075,
-0.6823431849,
-0.296600014,
-0.4897483289,
-0.1728700101,
-0.1238766313,
0.424716562,
-0.1782318652,
1.1154264212,
0.7619313002,
-0.7460163832,
0.682064116,
0.0309107415,
-0.1574056447,
0.5031487942,
-0.7124702334,
0.5391395092,
0.3329930604,
0.0584079511,
-0.5229874849,
-0.1595703661,
0.3707910776,
-0.0717201829,
0.3261366785,
-0.5349720716,
-0.866945982,
-0.3807058036,
-0.4651550949,
0.0304911304,
0.4431779385,
-0.6180065274,
0.4463180602,
0.246121347,
0.0402690172,
-0.5983269811,
-0.1753371805,
-0.2359618098,
-0.443746537,
-0.3566747308,
0.002840244,
-0.2033921331,
-0.0091098035,
-0.1462866813,
-0.4385664165,
0.0062087537,
0.2528181076,
0.4208343327,
0.0415292755,
0.0236937199,
0.4793997109,
0.0040258258,
-0.3509544432,
0.135152787,
-0.2898755372,
0.466257304,
-0.5645073056,
-0.7623123527,
-0.1361777931,
-0.2397619486,
0.6273776293,
-0.5130369663,
0.3646307886,
0.710570395,
0.0912827328,
-0.6839917302,
-0.7628905177,
-0.5225506425,
-0.6500325799,
-0.1004224643,
-0.7265976071,
-0.4335409403,
0.5317015648,
-0.6802287698,
0.2245677263,
0.3618881702,
0.3583721817,
-0.1967751086,
0.6123117805,
0.5719034076,
-0.2177471668,
0.190250054,
-0.5969952345,
-0.4730087221,
-0.7179532051,
0.0338699408,
-0.2700786591,
-0.1788603067,
-0.6001042128,
-0.1312136948,
0.5325707197,
0.143345356,
-0.3758741617,
0.2062643319,
-0.8793231249,
0.5248722434,
0.651992321,
-0.0392805412,
0.2103639692,
-0.0607821196,
-0.125228554,
0.3141213059,
-0.5760216713,
-0.7289571166,
1.430252552,
0.46647349,
1.1091914177,
-0.2275624126,
0.8292840123,
0.5904716253,
0.1663352847,
-0.6208391786,
0.4555008411,
0.385581404,
-0.4839681387,
-0.618576467,
0.1400580406,
-1.22134161,
0.3175589442,
0.0653640479,
-0.5372967124,
0.1310744435,
0.0848108679,
-0.0841201097,
0.3428264558,
-0.6486127973,
0.6674017906,
-0.3221462369,
-0.4003592432,
0.0230242889,
-0.537872076,
0.0991328359,
-0.1753791869,
-0.1385368407,
-0.5639013052,
-0.2873799503,
0.6000633836,
-0.6417827606,
1.1420104504,
-0.2372003794,
-0.2815729976,
0.4846579134,
0.0746817067,
0.8207504749,
0.2392606586,
-0.3584882915,
-0.054123085,
0.2238621861,
-0.4162374139,
-0.718155086,
0.3988312781,
-0.9134560823,
-0.5022835135,
-0.4749698937,
-0.3788056076,
-0.0895544589,
0.2733839154,
0.1183109283,
0.4530261159,
0.0286324359,
0.0037089463,
0.5685333014,
0.1569636762,
0.4831516147,
1.170032382,
-0.084304221,
-0.2100954652,
0.9076296687,
0.1350983083,
0.1730811,
-0.0699720532,
-0.0796548873,
-0.2678884268,
-0.3873194754,
-0.2482102066,
0.3022323549,
-0.4405621588,
-0.8303524256,
0.0021676009,
-0.3598428965,
-0.2174436301,
-0.0819847658,
-0.8291380405,
0.0266428646,
-0.1051687077,
-0.2050558478,
0.632227838,
0.8812065125,
-0.3533525169,
0.4615504742,
-0.4271041751,
0.0499710627,
0.3050839901,
0.6529028416,
-0.2613677382,
-0.0761990696,
-0.4714912474,
-0.0892130435,
-0.5682525635,
-0.6785882711,
0.2347090095,
0.3260674179,
0.8422863483,
0.6453208923,
0.5963994265,
0.1921885312,
-0.097549133,
0.3274005949,
-0.2078174651,
-0.7396412492,
0.6065245867,
-0.5119051933,
0.3954428732,
0.4916052222,
0.2411769629,
-0.1620292068,
-0.6667743325,
-0.8754851818,
-0.5318633914,
0.6526268125,
0.2656369507,
-0.4752031863,
0.3570092022,
0.5697029829,
0.4668550789,
0.401592046,
-0.2837947309,
-0.4700113535,
-0.1252027303,
0.232904762,
-0.3515240252,
-0.0854417682,
-0.249488607,
-0.0871034116,
0.8010758162,
-0.5389088988,
0.1983937323,
0.0822747797,
-0.0919486433,
0.0507203564,
0.3485037088,
0.3122211993,
0.7406057119,
-0.3387937248,
0.0127745569,
0.4811439812,
-0.3340204954,
0.4165182412,
-0.0754473805,
0.0365604609,
-0.3152660429,
0.4225465953,
0.491045177,
-0.0823169574,
-0.3762875497,
0.3034903705,
0.2512310743,
-0.3552424312,
-0.6517034769,
0.3057465255,
-0.1385615468,
0.3098175526,
0.1648053825,
-0.2943577468,
0.2517363131,
-0.3017050624,
0.2081495523,
0.4366772175,
-0.4813517332,
-0.2572838962,
0.1438470334,
0.4158627093,
-0.2361422181,
0.6323488355,
-0.6787372828,
-0.3085462749,
0.6947317719,
0.365513742,
0.9319058657,
-0.3530018926,
0.3578764498,
0.1083789095,
0.5146463513,
0.0563388355,
0.136217162,
-0.1424425691,
-0.7043278217,
-0.4916387796,
-0.325027436,
-0.6228966713,
0.6013182402,
-0.8680610061,
0.1645895839,
-0.6146005392,
-0.3106186986,
-0.1752179861,
0.6044312716,
-1.0007578135,
-0.0132848807,
-0.3370717168,
1.1128411293,
-0.966142416,
0.8072879314,
0.7595932484,
-0.2366666496,
-0.8017300367,
-0.3599551618,
0.2127403915,
-0.9040569663,
0.0795586035,
0.1650698632,
-0.5910272002,
-0.0254497789,
-1.0084537268,
-0.8843284845,
1.2402374744,
0.5128801465,
-0.576094389,
0.3994067609,
0.1232821271,
0.4753477871,
-0.5512461066,
0.3844093978,
0.6819452643,
0.6787707806,
-0.3155039549,
-1.2135529518,
0.1347857118,
-0.3283404708,
-0.2890654504,
0.00286686,
-0.9587417841,
0.4429733157,
0.1285558641,
-0.188356176,
0.0124544743,
0.3798347414,
0.1847122461,
0.2913723588,
0.7591509223,
0.3838238418,
0.7136279941,
0.067775771,
0.8971163034,
-0.246709913,
0.3334378898,
1.2950603962,
-0.2385309786,
0.4897269607,
-0.0156991035,
-0.1036465317,
0.4276479781,
0.7563631535,
-0.5656831861,
0.3156887889,
0.4213707745,
0.0750446394,
-0.6126362085,
-0.1024131477,
-0.3502283394,
0.5706455112,
0.2900249362,
0.1691322625,
-0.2263850123,
0.051551532,
-0.3216486275,
-0.0473890044,
-0.0765585303,
0.90098387,
0.166496262,
-0.3717857897,
0.4769262373,
-0.2521393895,
0.558049798,
-0.6668031812,
-0.1047266424,
-0.0515314713,
0.2088150084,
-0.1223545074,
-0.8637853265,
-0.1820650399,
-0.5199186206,
0.0366181172,
-0.20073542,
1.0552208424,
-0.076928027,
-0.185397163,
0.2962177396,
0.6726245284,
0.5177419782,
-0.1419919729,
-0.7240471244,
-0.0736620948,
-0.2611720264,
-0.1514799148,
0.1106401905,
0.3739576638,
-0.0057564275,
1.3363355398,
0.4263637662,
0.0796412602,
-0.0206458457,
0.0627566725,
0.6362503171,
-0.6149055362,
-0.3027324677,
-0.4186137617,
0.3865166008,
-0.4061535597,
-0.2554008663,
0.8232021928,
0.8121423125,
0.8602138162,
-0.2763695419,
0.7754901648,
0.4364872873,
0.7047700286,
-0.4358690083,
0.5883533359,
-0.4596431255,
0.1362971663,
-0.0749724433,
-0.916254878,
0.4344632328,
0.129347533,
-0.0071118637,
0.1029683948,
0.514685154,
0.9585858583,
-0.2708416581,
-0.383610487,
0.4201994538,
0.0580292419,
0.3380954862,
0.105617024,
0.9207667112,
-0.3842590451,
0.5635022521,
-0.3442544639,
-0.0380469933,
-0.3122501969,
-0.7297743559,
-0.979150176,
-0.5589314699,
-0.566264987,
-0.0171962194,
0.0889666975,
0.7796102166,
1.2378903627,
-0.4318678081,
-0.481125325,
0.1510440856,
0.163214013,
-0.6213601232,
-0.216889888,
0.3464492261,
-0.7182319164,
-0.5028369427,
0.5496102571,
0.1089926586,
0.2178253978,
-0.5208519101,
-0.1849427074,
0.301289916,
-0.0555401966,
0.1780956984,
0.5544544458,
-0.5849201679,
-0.2764142156,
-0.261569649,
0.0259366706,
-0.0994997621,
0.6171138287,
-0.7691729069,
0.5027502179,
-0.1553410888,
0.2708275616,
0.9688037634,
-0.2642031014,
0.8448103666,
-0.9911783338,
0.0064342176,
-0.0885621235,
0.1951647103,
0.1559460312,
-0.401086092,
1.0713483095,
-0.3405863643,
-0.634876132,
-0.7244702578,
0.3299288154,
-0.9085070491,
-0.1582191437,
0.8382302523,
-0.0726756826,
-0.0314844735,
-0.3419944644,
-0.1387907863,
0.1904071271,
-0.7676261663,
0.6379074454,
0.3315689266,
-0.1639233679,
-0.1768424362,
-0.3304884136,
0.7162615061,
0.122440286,
-1.0453081131,
-0.0958474353,
0.0422694385,
0.6163933873,
0.0772417188,
0.4528551102,
0.1927500218,
0.3215124309,
0.1712144464,
0.3988078833,
-0.5628353357,
-0.3717187047,
-0.0659934282,
-0.0775800869,
0.3420957327,
-0.26943174
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08317v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08317v1
|
SpeechGuard: Exploring the Adversarial Robustness of Multimodal Large Language Models
| 2024-05-14T04:51:23 | 2024-05-14T04:51:23 |
Raghuveer Peri, Sai Muralidhar Jayanthi, Srikanth Ronanki, Anshu Bhatia, Karel Mundnich, Saket Dingliwal, Nilaksh Das, Zejiang Hou, Goeric Huybrechts, Srikanth Vishnubhotla, Daniel Garcia-Romero, Sundararajan Srinivasan, Kyu J Han, Katrin Kirchhoff
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Integrated Speech and Large Language Models (SLMs) that can follow speech
instructions and generate relevant text responses have gained popularity
lately. However, the safety and robustness of these models remains largely
unclear. In this work, we investigate the potential vulnerabilities of such
instruction-following speech-language models to adversarial attacks and
jailbreaking. Specifically, we design algorithms that can generate adversarial
examples to jailbreak SLMs in both white-box and black-box attack settings
without human involvement. Additionally, we propose countermeasures to thwart
such jailbreaking attacks. Our models, trained on dialog data with speech
instructions, achieve state-of-the-art performance on spoken question-answering
task, scoring over 80% on both safety and helpfulness metrics. Despite safety
guardrails, experiments on jailbreaking demonstrate the vulnerability of SLMs
to adversarial perturbations and transfer attacks, with average attack success
rates of 90% and 10% respectively when evaluated on a dataset of carefully
designed harmful questions spanning 12 different toxic categories. However, we
demonstrate that our proposed countermeasures reduce the attack success
significantly.
|
[
-0.4148086607,
-1.0446531773,
0.2475392669,
-0.1323760599,
-0.1827597171,
0.2293256074,
-0.0000967915,
-0.3273819387,
-0.1584127098,
0.9719725847,
-0.3835310936,
-0.2416949421,
-0.7635949254,
-0.4121594429,
-0.5590164065,
1.124245882,
0.4654455781,
0.125199914,
0.0804138854,
-0.1004079059,
-0.6899698377,
-0.7898732424,
-0.5289831161,
0.1085518971,
0.3672175705,
-0.0841553137,
0.9165748954,
0.3051775992,
0.2830737531,
0.3079862297,
-0.3435321152,
0.0409018062,
-0.411396116,
0.4964087009,
-0.0870883763,
-0.4887873232,
-0.3790232539,
-0.0655177981,
0.2899761498,
0.1826101542,
-0.1552556157,
-0.0370471887,
0.0203788634,
0.5225754976,
-0.6735376716,
-0.06499172,
-1.043757081,
-0.0137764402,
-0.1873634011,
0.0023510337,
-0.7361815572,
-0.2692419291,
0.2389714569,
-0.1243540943,
-0.1084320173,
-0.1563726366,
0.3679579496,
0.2002907246,
-0.2510225773,
-0.5544123054,
-0.5711627603,
0.5478097796,
-0.9259225726,
0.0500949547,
0.5026974678,
0.3140375316,
-0.2112317681,
-0.3712576926,
-0.3337191641,
-0.577178359,
0.0404368378,
-0.121064648,
-0.4422143102,
0.2795339227,
0.2583648264,
-0.0489621982,
-0.8664741516,
0.1128237247,
-0.4581955075,
-0.1956851929,
0.5613894463,
0.0647115782,
0.7009628415,
-0.1208458394,
-0.4119318724,
-0.2421180904,
-0.8771912456,
0.0838567242,
0.6067376733,
0.4758074582,
-0.0455681942,
0.4271634817,
0.4033275247,
0.6638749242,
-0.2585291266,
-0.0584897883,
-0.1323131025,
-0.2243185192,
0.014580342,
0.2187729925,
0.9304355979,
0.1499126554,
0.3738813996,
-0.5560092926,
-0.0375402421,
0.0374366306,
0.6119486094,
-0.7769178152,
-0.2079481184,
0.3260021508,
-0.1507445574,
-0.6699320078,
0.0076286551,
-0.9978567958,
-0.8143146634,
0.3136713505,
0.4535780847,
-0.4202620387,
-0.1887201518,
-0.0421388373,
-0.0099579329,
0.0112952916,
-0.0578422695,
-0.7926334143,
0.1546165347,
0.6421316862,
0.8086853623,
0.0814666152,
-0.2041505128,
-0.7980789542,
0.1541198939,
-0.2240208089,
0.3086531162,
-0.3252147436,
-0.5600898266,
-0.0160447005,
-0.0650265738,
-0.317501545,
-0.4121095836,
0.412298739,
-0.7491583228,
0.0580072589,
0.156009838,
-0.289891541,
-0.1440831125,
0.3583773971,
-0.714440465,
0.2265076041,
-0.3844520152,
-0.8022247553,
-0.3007647991,
-0.534111619,
-0.5631408691,
-0.2388899177,
0.1586797386,
-0.4777927995,
0.0049647572,
0.3327333331,
0.2688781023,
-0.0276923813,
0.2369541675,
-0.5857218504,
-0.1589119583,
0.6175841689,
-0.783443749,
0.9830439687,
0.4217274785,
-0.4522698522,
0.1565205604,
-0.6118904948,
0.0996504724,
0.1681037247,
-0.1074344218,
-0.4394642711,
0.1910067201,
-0.1802832931,
0.2648087144,
0.0396702848,
-0.4752402902,
-0.070981577,
-0.3997597098,
0.8787274957,
0.8478702307,
-0.0377151221,
0.2818745375,
-0.1174624711,
0.7036468387,
-0.106569767,
0.2980615497,
-0.4298215806,
-0.3231660426,
-0.2239219695,
-0.1058572754,
0.2412620485,
0.922146976,
-0.8241408467,
0.1504851878,
0.1195020229,
-0.7074097395,
-0.4552022517,
0.1957496703,
0.7995887399,
0.380507499,
0.280584991,
-0.0343838632,
-0.3368434906,
-0.5926275849,
-0.3736424446,
-0.2909776568,
0.2980324328,
0.2699128389,
0.2382802814,
-0.1634726971,
0.3120855391,
-0.4506831765,
0.0868371949,
-0.2457330525,
-0.0442733839,
-0.1305768639,
0.4739825428,
0.7168158293,
-0.835085392,
-0.1526853591,
-0.407846719,
-0.7260001302,
0.0349074565,
-0.0870436728,
0.108237721,
-0.0946633443,
0.6426562667,
-0.7537823915,
0.3704358041,
0.6823263764,
-0.3376050293,
0.6620536447,
-0.0878562778,
-0.0629313886,
-1.0918049812,
-0.1475816965,
-0.0187538508,
-0.1229460612,
-1.1230069399,
0.4347197711,
-0.1451707333,
-0.6530172229,
-0.7045423388,
0.2514750957,
-0.1452012956,
0.1469774842,
-0.3482396901,
0.146739319,
-0.0433795974,
0.3313747644,
-0.2985979021,
0.9311954975,
0.6396200657,
-0.4759136736,
0.493910104,
0.1925724298,
-0.2884092033,
0.228516221,
-0.9480446577,
0.413291961,
-0.1861364841,
0.1117668301,
-0.848269701,
-0.0739065185,
0.0627517998,
-0.631472528,
0.4643075466,
-0.2830842435,
-0.3805539012,
-0.1594996303,
-0.5045816302,
0.1499970704,
0.3286328912,
-0.4134254158,
0.4162656665,
0.7178686261,
-0.5362022519,
-0.7270776033,
-0.7428480387,
0.3935158551,
-0.4901932478,
-0.7791503668,
0.0396632925,
-0.1085802615,
-0.3479267955,
-0.2068329006,
0.0636116415,
-0.107796669,
0.4927650094,
0.2877100706,
0.4793073535,
-0.0222042091,
-0.2394839376,
-0.3180630505,
0.0725761876,
0.2929072976,
-0.0922697037,
0.6830652356,
-0.2869278789,
-0.406788379,
-0.2840487659,
0.401632905,
1.0079100132,
-0.490668416,
0.8465381265,
0.494954586,
-0.2396821976,
-0.1233185977,
-0.2316749841,
-0.1419293731,
-0.4963133931,
0.4941618741,
-0.1068097576,
-0.8792333603,
0.4191451669,
0.3007625639,
0.1860895604,
-0.1945651025,
0.4384726286,
-0.0088532753,
1.379714489,
0.1469524205,
-0.4409438372,
0.5367154479,
0.0056509245,
0.2718173563,
-0.6416378617,
-0.1245286539,
-0.5571548343,
0.0681847036,
-0.6759959459,
-0.0194371566,
0.4819979668,
-0.116548866,
-0.1740528494,
0.5698764324,
-0.3461660743,
0.338993609,
0.5312123299,
0.1491565853,
-0.129881382,
-0.1567594856,
-0.0657558814,
0.1565512717,
-0.5247333646,
-0.533403039,
1.1630949974,
0.5070285797,
1.2736350298,
0.4564513564,
0.4349310398,
0.4268130064,
-0.1670894623,
-0.4598376453,
0.5852204561,
-0.4281432927,
-0.7648445964,
-0.17770271,
-0.5114176273,
-0.8049732447,
0.5152508616,
-0.2385657132,
-1.0394273996,
-0.2343097031,
0.2542455494,
-0.4915223718,
0.5051532984,
-0.9908155203,
0.8321767449,
-0.5183358788,
-0.3562863171,
-0.0450435467,
-0.7922078371,
0.5915259719,
-0.0643900931,
0.4663623273,
0.0271857083,
0.4918913841,
0.5021089315,
-0.3483506143,
0.8926699162,
-0.4030317068,
0.0047406736,
0.3066686094,
0.1831289977,
0.6009249091,
0.0867514685,
0.0090143364,
-0.1704166681,
0.0498099737,
-0.3067022562,
-0.5018817186,
0.785794735,
-0.6714920402,
-0.9298483729,
-0.3852308393,
-0.6251167655,
-0.3857882023,
0.0707807541,
0.1184077337,
0.7311154008,
-0.0689190701,
0.1812862903,
1.0137040615,
-0.49891904,
0.5116232038,
0.3330275714,
-0.0181879438,
-0.6582636833,
1.0248624086,
0.0244529266,
0.6323904395,
0.0381413735,
0.1408351809,
-0.3611852527,
-0.7877537012,
-0.759036839,
-0.1436295062,
-0.4662067294,
-0.1067918241,
-0.3813010752,
-0.4637313187,
-0.5714994669,
0.0612113252,
-0.2856710851,
-0.3104597032,
-0.1033375263,
-0.1282442212,
0.0561640225,
0.5486547947,
0.2365486324,
0.2253524959,
-1.0335006714,
0.2888349593,
0.6527714729,
-0.1303633302,
0.0620744936,
-0.469242245,
0.040570382,
0.2397790253,
-0.4138036072,
-1.0870262384,
0.348213762,
-0.0101795271,
0.5470983386,
0.4541921616,
0.1594218761,
0.4996856451,
-0.6023529172,
0.8063462973,
0.2184210718,
-0.7605236769,
0.6607423425,
-0.4033979475,
0.3532068729,
0.5170239806,
-0.0315266512,
-0.3219140768,
-0.664878726,
-0.4982827008,
-0.8537682891,
0.6219014525,
0.2604931593,
0.427847445,
0.1663095206,
0.0198827162,
-0.2509450912,
0.3269691467,
-0.6645351052,
-0.325199157,
-0.4677729607,
-0.0364126116,
-0.0196550488,
-0.2258120328,
-0.2848618031,
0.1427866817,
0.6903633475,
0.1731982529,
-0.1387304813,
-0.1632594764,
-0.3300846517,
0.3689413667,
0.7183006406,
0.8701294661,
0.2544898987,
-0.1133339256,
0.3961629272,
0.0620767362,
-0.6746078134,
0.3293404281,
0.470487088,
-0.4568026662,
-0.2479029447,
0.3711518347,
0.8868863583,
0.0612308718,
-0.9629389644,
0.4542760551,
-0.3106552362,
0.1533085555,
-0.3065833449,
0.3433916271,
0.0697856024,
0.2116516531,
0.1548876166,
0.2062833458,
-0.0614866875,
-0.7245082259,
0.1870803833,
0.9045574665,
-0.5855063796,
-0.2773859799,
0.7879213095,
-0.0064782444,
-0.3375972807,
0.3237163126,
0.0373032428,
-0.8038580418,
0.6045680046,
0.5690816641,
0.7424238324,
-0.4766813815,
0.1327984184,
-0.0284987893,
0.6497367024,
0.1228079721,
-0.0545038804,
0.1562280506,
-0.5882987976,
-0.0838264227,
-0.3288817108,
-0.4261349738,
0.4517111778,
-0.8370298743,
-0.0570549518,
-0.6254863739,
-0.365701139,
0.1604357958,
-0.5304605365,
-0.0094818119,
0.0379774012,
0.4580796957,
0.7788898945,
-0.6194190383,
0.6812667251,
0.621088922,
-0.1175775677,
-0.5338690877,
-0.009227057,
0.3218739331,
-0.6956344843,
0.0892932713,
0.2437412143,
-0.212616697,
-0.3453700244,
-0.4621571302,
-0.6529313922,
0.7566797137,
0.6281282306,
-0.4950897396,
-0.2032582313,
0.1445403546,
0.3253189027,
0.0165002514,
-0.0232503768,
0.6494870186,
0.1439312696,
-0.0846475139,
-0.8474549055,
-0.11715848,
-0.3290909231,
-0.0405742899,
0.2033915073,
-0.5430728197,
0.7288278937,
-0.3230631351,
-0.0306725726,
0.195012182,
0.2419179082,
0.475022167,
0.2068365663,
0.6980659366,
0.6227146983,
0.5456106663,
-0.0967587233,
0.9234953523,
-0.3528790474,
-0.065794304,
1.1400243044,
-0.1784584671,
0.6463215351,
0.279542923,
0.0280831717,
0.2196451128,
0.1101790741,
-0.072469525,
0.8273172975,
0.2807680964,
-0.5088161826,
-0.032681603,
0.0325706936,
-0.2928754389,
0.557218492,
0.4732320011,
-0.4292190075,
-0.2197279185,
0.5006810427,
0.5315574408,
0.113889493,
-0.4187777042,
0.899335444,
0.1649783105,
-0.7411338091,
0.6108061671,
-0.060335312,
0.6018818617,
-0.8269145489,
0.1975918263,
0.1452189237,
0.3087060153,
-0.0329174437,
-0.6746116281,
0.1684978008,
0.4190359712,
0.0174779557,
-0.0139285494,
0.7681488991,
-0.3794608116,
-0.2062351555,
0.3077002466,
0.1701283902,
-0.1438163072,
0.0329479538,
-0.7936343551,
0.1317218542,
0.0453374796,
-0.1954607368,
0.661753118,
-0.2568787038,
0.1169303805,
0.948186934,
0.6382501721,
0.2607467473,
0.4823445976,
0.0441461317,
0.9282726049,
-0.3986876607,
-0.4918192923,
-1.1586581469,
0.3351532221,
-0.0947407931,
-0.0371997096,
0.8194838762,
0.2952969968,
0.5509880781,
0.1263557971,
1.0506339073,
0.1044089347,
0.2742958367,
-0.664334476,
1.0384794474,
-0.0256786123,
0.5106386542,
-0.3707600534,
-0.3866971731,
-0.0785460919,
0.2471654564,
-0.2620971501,
-0.1716761291,
0.3013263941,
0.9694727063,
0.2275011539,
0.228053987,
0.2644948959,
0.2306301147,
0.7603877783,
0.5836575627,
0.9244498014,
-0.2141190469,
1.0003867149,
-0.1869973093,
-0.0710988566,
0.1610847265,
-0.4962815046,
-1.1288923025,
-0.2200201601,
-0.0535253957,
-0.6442925334,
0.3665795624,
0.5488857627,
0.7964020967,
-0.8983942866,
-0.044340387,
0.0462960862,
0.1367389262,
0.0254099779,
-0.2441562116,
0.3109960258,
-0.1220876202,
-0.4682039022,
0.8319163322,
0.1215715855,
0.1708267778,
-0.5451895595,
0.1295294315,
-0.0531209782,
0.1693680733,
0.466006577,
0.3987868428,
-0.6729336977,
-0.2331262827,
-0.1152559817,
-0.1651961058,
-0.3710360527,
0.6340110302,
-0.3471573293,
0.6271159053,
0.2384033948,
0.8965892792,
0.2489221096,
0.1510144323,
0.5154597163,
-0.7295603156,
0.2972688079,
0.3560473025,
0.4484049082,
0.3552324474,
-0.2557084262,
0.1064222306,
-0.0461124703,
-0.4595338106,
-1.0602756739,
0.4306013584,
-0.6712721586,
-0.5124990344,
1.0781997442,
-0.5028637052,
-0.2067590952,
-0.1799624711,
-0.1430277079,
-0.0702052563,
-0.2373003811,
0.8608005047,
0.6563737988,
0.1570920646,
-0.2550468445,
-0.8561041355,
0.3879659772,
0.1815993637,
-0.8102221489,
0.2363660783,
0.2633873224,
0.2629205883,
0.2986207306,
0.1316910982,
-0.4310446084,
0.4343519807,
-0.0156817082,
-0.3948639929,
-0.3802655637,
-0.3062649369,
-0.4973652959,
0.5940344334,
0.0833101496,
-0.2732756734
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08311v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08311v1
|
A Decoupling and Aggregating Framework for Joint Extraction of Entities and Relations
| 2024-05-14T04:27:16 | 2024-05-14T04:27:16 |
Yao Wang, Xin Liu, Weikun Kong, Hai-Tao Yu, Teeradaj Racharak, Kyoung-Sook Kim, Minh Le Nguyen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Named Entity Recognition and Relation Extraction are two crucial and
challenging subtasks in the field of Information Extraction. Despite the
successes achieved by the traditional approaches, fundamental research
questions remain open. First, most recent studies use parameter sharing for a
single subtask or shared features for both two subtasks, ignoring their
semantic differences. Second, information interaction mainly focuses on the two
subtasks, leaving the fine-grained informtion interaction among the
subtask-specific features of encoding subjects, relations, and objects
unexplored. Motivated by the aforementioned limitations, we propose a novel
model to jointly extract entities and relations. The main novelties are as
follows: (1) We propose to decouple the feature encoding process into three
parts, namely encoding subjects, encoding objects, and encoding relations.
Thanks to this, we are able to use fine-grained subtask-specific features. (2)
We propose novel inter-aggregation and intra-aggregation strategies to enhance
the information interaction and construct individual fine-grained
subtask-specific features, respectively. The experimental results demonstrate
that our model outperforms several previous state-of-the-art models. Extensive
additional experiments further confirm the effectiveness of our model.
|
[
-0.7738829851,
-0.6148859262,
0.4425000548,
0.0087889656,
-0.4839564562,
-0.0603873916,
-0.0544553958,
-0.9641170502,
0.518124342,
0.4349624813,
-0.5085574389,
-0.3794350326,
-0.7819906473,
0.0837099105,
-0.471858114,
1.1800498962,
0.0371304676,
-0.1381667107,
-0.3299874365,
-0.3714539409,
-0.2854647934,
-0.4465622008,
-0.5723372698,
-0.1885855049,
0.5132610202,
0.05056905,
0.61232692,
0.6699911952,
0.6255435348,
0.2327423543,
0.0429247022,
0.3313165307,
-0.2572571635,
0.2062649727,
-0.5068030357,
-0.1179381758,
-0.6542084813,
0.1303764433,
0.5221461058,
0.989539206,
-0.0982726067,
0.2886763811,
0.1606224328,
0.3537890315,
-0.8504306078,
0.6014159918,
-0.5520405769,
-0.188438639,
-0.2658058703,
-0.1901955754,
-0.2170692831,
0.1816093326,
0.1655072123,
-0.7357873321,
0.2470839173,
-0.2397925854,
1.3244023323,
0.0081480797,
-0.2490865737,
-0.2943578362,
-0.6492366195,
0.4841555655,
-0.2908214033,
0.6196692586,
0.4154738188,
-0.0557621829,
0.0275209676,
-0.7220807672,
-0.1612587273,
0.1784095466,
-0.4439591467,
0.0521728657,
-0.2841519117,
-0.0147434101,
0.0124579938,
0.6265267134,
0.0425049216,
0.0540084168,
-0.403416127,
0.2000193745,
0.640873909,
-0.0004245897,
0.5516557693,
-0.282733053,
-0.7836332321,
0.398432672,
-0.5733878016,
0.1489785016,
0.1118636206,
0.4779894352,
-0.0828888342,
0.5269280672,
-0.2060761452,
0.2952325046,
0.1695371568,
0.0750397667,
0.017987255,
-0.4509776831,
-0.2114866525,
-0.0309752356,
0.9915518761,
0.1500242949,
0.1357139796,
-0.6220909357,
-0.1247318313,
0.0165779367,
-0.0204056315,
-0.598366797,
-0.6069632769,
0.2101344466,
-0.585817337,
-0.0906535238,
0.3165584505,
-0.8473293781,
-0.2799950242,
-0.4714275897,
0.2188994139,
-0.4136083424,
-0.852062583,
-0.3362703323,
-0.1296729147,
0.2372421175,
0.2468258888,
-1.2573544979,
0.6160957813,
0.8690364957,
0.6110834479,
-0.5372968316,
-0.3438756466,
-0.6527675986,
0.3685760498,
-0.0443816334,
0.6899511814,
-0.7012339234,
-0.2695687711,
-0.3580919504,
0.3026323617,
0.0302264839,
-0.5450649261,
-0.1216648147,
-0.7854640484,
-0.1225622669,
-0.4003887475,
-0.6749257445,
0.0667838454,
0.2397314906,
-1.1733614206,
0.646342814,
0.306702733,
-0.985545814,
0.3615038991,
-0.4035513103,
-0.2165878415,
0.2847932279,
-0.5844834447,
-0.289791286,
-0.0386054292,
0.2576530874,
0.5730500817,
-0.5388082266,
0.3760311604,
-0.5414043665,
-0.014338525,
0.0527469739,
0.0601602457,
0.7486662269,
0.1462135017,
0.2943477035,
-0.2690139711,
-0.6849192381,
-0.3310316801,
0.1380711347,
-0.6045601964,
-0.7353082895,
-0.2114323825,
-0.3899163902,
-0.0033366499,
0.3949712515,
-0.4914383888,
0.3002067804,
0.0077662147,
0.1523138136,
0.151495561,
0.5778256059,
0.859840095,
0.1402602196,
0.5200898647,
0.5051234365,
-0.2018689066,
-0.19475317,
-0.0219744239,
-0.4844595492,
-0.3815841079,
0.815025568,
0.454433769,
-0.8480505347,
0.225777328,
-0.4885687232,
-0.1624462903,
-0.394654274,
0.1084133834,
0.5541481972,
0.4079402983,
0.5292417407,
-0.5767105222,
-0.5973543525,
-0.8781759143,
-0.3183534443,
-0.0399642736,
-0.100548774,
-0.0406980887,
0.140204072,
0.0747124106,
0.9928324819,
-0.5205247402,
-0.2816092074,
-0.4925608337,
0.2624884546,
-0.0292691179,
0.5670369267,
0.5749280453,
-1.0739951134,
-0.2165912837,
0.2019568533,
-0.9794251323,
0.3373455107,
0.1482706964,
-0.2768513262,
-0.217967391,
0.3990901411,
-1.0310103893,
0.5004026294,
0.0810431689,
0.0524656512,
0.2995145619,
0.1544697583,
0.1043543816,
-1.0738675594,
-0.0997044295,
0.0641481355,
-0.2707408369,
-0.6648116708,
0.35671556,
0.0570835806,
-0.0739771053,
-0.3196046948,
0.4222983718,
-1.1196810007,
-0.3968930542,
-0.0765071586,
0.141440317,
0.2443110347,
0.6506467462,
0.2175318748,
0.3819875717,
0.6293720603,
-0.7304635644,
0.3531427085,
0.2563551366,
-0.0363310277,
0.5751075149,
-0.204249993,
-0.0777414218,
-0.2976279855,
-0.1496621519,
-0.4901430607,
-0.3805662096,
0.3385303617,
-0.4211135507,
0.609711349,
-0.5019117594,
-0.2161908895,
0.2097684592,
-0.0307556689,
0.4094882905,
0.1870868504,
-0.4730908573,
1.0725660324,
1.1203199625,
-0.4374015033,
-0.6170558333,
-0.6067154408,
-0.0239320341,
-0.3891294599,
-0.3805341125,
0.4191075563,
0.5816922784,
-0.2274627686,
0.5783337355,
-0.3861140311,
-0.5278218985,
0.0524564795,
0.2806591988,
0.3297323585,
-0.0681570992,
0.332632035,
0.0739216432,
-0.1279621571,
0.0646981448,
0.0720885843,
0.2901619971,
0.166399464,
0.0599159822,
-0.3189824522,
0.896566093,
0.4294383824,
-0.6738014221,
0.753369689,
0.5631497502,
-0.737881124,
0.1314246058,
-0.2758444548,
-0.1293993443,
-0.3779430091,
0.5963441133,
-0.8841326237,
-0.597394824,
0.6719476581,
-0.4407822788,
0.1688048542,
0.3502980471,
-0.001354669,
0.0331283025,
0.6412795186,
1.0202069283,
-0.1975791007,
0.3159482479,
-0.387845248,
0.3367942274,
-1.0742645264,
-0.419513613,
-0.4279450774,
-0.0744573176,
-0.4337676764,
0.0585065857,
-0.1306031048,
0.6068638563,
0.3952529728,
0.7493469715,
-0.1712911278,
0.3433951437,
0.3312622309,
0.1996050626,
0.4186974466,
0.1013071984,
0.0162968896,
0.0054419669,
-0.4409641922,
-0.3217004538,
0.5530796051,
0.2524911761,
0.639234066,
0.1409202665,
1.0714401007,
0.1347765028,
0.2126534134,
-0.7464901209,
0.7104725242,
-0.3880613744,
-0.5293539166,
-0.256981492,
-0.4036958516,
-1.1108462811,
0.2910591662,
-0.2306046337,
-1.1103579998,
0.6867210865,
0.0812657699,
-0.3826743662,
0.2794803083,
-0.8555617929,
0.6914038062,
0.2617896795,
-0.4165065885,
0.2189639658,
-0.7379244566,
0.4626162946,
0.0139514385,
0.2645645738,
-0.1973403543,
-0.0857853517,
0.7687101364,
-0.0959838107,
0.3723115027,
-0.1148631275,
-0.1638813764,
0.3127464652,
0.2470292598,
0.4009695053,
0.244728148,
-0.0748334825,
0.2551258802,
0.1442208886,
-0.0874458477,
-0.7545547485,
0.6585624218,
-0.3920345902,
-0.4489822984,
-0.1746237129,
-0.5758447051,
-0.2806753516,
0.3095888793,
0.1484099776,
0.3948316574,
-0.1166741848,
-0.0014099327,
0.4480569661,
0.2796705961,
0.5414125919,
0.3176912069,
-0.1903918236,
-0.3522530794,
0.9362761378,
0.1900753677,
0.1597017199,
0.4666227996,
-0.3660928607,
-0.2150426954,
-0.3186871707,
-0.1081495732,
0.2588766813,
-0.6032370925,
-0.2721127272,
-1.0577014685,
-0.4770181477,
-0.3931609094,
0.6471246481,
-0.4720786512,
-0.278116554,
-0.5183394551,
-0.2106319815,
0.0173284486,
0.5035534501,
-0.0290357079,
-0.0932587832,
-1.2156239748,
0.6888740659,
0.3690588474,
0.0434298925,
0.0306767598,
0.1647436172,
-0.2694373727,
-0.1814614981,
0.0380637385,
-1.1568950415,
0.2575397193,
-0.0116416942,
0.4902191162,
0.3309501708,
0.2385124415,
0.8841791749,
-0.2477325052,
0.6287043691,
0.12797077,
-0.6339880824,
0.3761725426,
-0.1761018783,
-0.1405770034,
0.5890462995,
0.5327262282,
-0.0424889997,
-0.2718775868,
-0.9098260403,
-0.9559607506,
0.9954025745,
0.3921932876,
-0.1845381707,
0.0345527902,
0.4630873799,
0.1083088741,
0.3418894112,
-0.6587569118,
-0.124758251,
0.4136168659,
-0.1793162823,
0.4606459439,
-0.4752454758,
-0.1602839231,
-0.0062294966,
0.4720199406,
0.3393082619,
0.2902279794,
0.1500026882,
-0.2226365805,
-0.0706210136,
0.3154628873,
-0.1923584789,
0.6260248423,
-0.1390249878,
0.5589017868,
-0.0856255069,
-0.3916338682,
-0.0659433305,
0.6415660977,
-0.1048814952,
0.0564238504,
0.5108610988,
0.7150719762,
0.0203173514,
0.0000718227,
0.3411392868,
-0.2307353169,
-0.0023910999,
-0.0387417786,
0.13521716,
0.3260249197,
0.5370261073,
0.3024809062,
0.0620341599,
0.2913309932,
-0.5286628604,
0.367765516,
0.5376119614,
-0.2122020125,
-0.3444198072,
0.4208090901,
0.1063823551,
-0.2881873548,
0.2902635038,
-0.3659828305,
-0.1747915,
0.5890724659,
0.1554728001,
0.6924074292,
-0.1457590461,
-0.0626008362,
0.3019537628,
0.055740077,
-0.0267187767,
0.0605740175,
-0.6768762469,
-0.6165473461,
-0.0909550339,
-0.5999650955,
-0.1930459142,
0.3602837622,
-1.1526015997,
0.2698466182,
0.0164505951,
-0.1758158654,
0.3865781426,
0.2006644309,
-0.6174783111,
0.1402578354,
-0.0768946633,
0.4059931636,
-0.681383729,
0.8702385426,
0.7792358398,
-0.6866489649,
-1.0841673613,
0.0317185447,
-0.2674051821,
-0.282009691,
0.4796035588,
0.167469725,
0.1357439011,
0.0090423198,
-0.1683170199,
-0.9547733068,
0.9790222645,
0.5109248757,
-0.5515598059,
-0.4620842636,
0.0068780635,
0.2145906985,
-0.7402312756,
-0.0475852154,
0.7958853245,
0.1926639378,
0.0774115026,
-0.7098273635,
0.2022754997,
-0.2891499102,
0.0073750103,
0.5399611592,
-0.4610351026,
0.886852324,
-0.0574986339,
-0.8262286782,
0.0804261193,
0.8702478409,
0.1276851445,
0.2781631947,
0.538049221,
0.5493479371,
0.5318902135,
-0.0304040201,
0.7386336923,
-0.1848776937,
0.487836808,
1.6855883598,
-0.2281171829,
0.5912437439,
0.5741503239,
-0.1853073388,
0.3156375587,
0.6237849593,
0.1298972815,
0.6764900684,
-0.4022546113,
-0.2428650707,
-0.2837734222,
-0.1975479722,
-0.3659049571,
0.4773997962,
0.4464276135,
-0.5722561479,
-0.575851202,
-0.0529892519,
-0.0716188401,
-0.2960615456,
-0.186722219,
1.0459270477,
0.1774060279,
-0.8393085599,
0.1379700601,
-0.1664391905,
0.1815117598,
-0.3832679391,
-0.3137545884,
-0.2011011392,
-0.0944221169,
-0.2610698342,
-0.6428582668,
0.2412014902,
-0.1143967882,
-0.4004891515,
0.2191485763,
0.9115604162,
-0.9171183705,
-0.1530721933,
0.5113881826,
0.4531033039,
0.3194286227,
0.0412703343,
-0.3312757909,
0.079678379,
-0.1045201868,
-0.2449401468,
0.3513154685,
0.7207061052,
-0.0311852284,
0.1926887333,
0.4958699346,
0.2875509262,
0.0253844336,
0.0604536086,
1.0202066898,
-0.6023150682,
-0.4293073714,
-0.8810015321,
0.5790356994,
-0.2783085406,
-0.0269888043,
0.4565270245,
0.3461931646,
0.6726276278,
-0.0262909383,
0.5472399592,
-0.2505899072,
0.3987289965,
-0.4744122922,
0.3595704138,
-0.4965547025,
0.4720667899,
-0.2873569429,
-1.0107141733,
-0.1080664024,
-0.0053369715,
0.0639454499,
-0.0369918719,
0.7385623455,
0.3828333914,
-0.4742716253,
-0.0535295941,
0.0821913704,
-0.130694285,
0.4028697908,
0.5517936945,
0.6585493088,
-0.5397705436,
0.5473137498,
-0.5166313052,
-0.1448215395,
0.2014667243,
-0.7148914337,
-0.8800907135,
-0.6622154117,
-0.5398159027,
0.0059188204,
-0.0960699022,
0.7291023731,
0.7751524448,
-0.4805423021,
0.2154129595,
-0.2264008671,
0.0840893313,
-0.1428782642,
-0.2635100782,
0.4320970774,
-0.1681094915,
-0.8313564658,
0.1459165514,
0.5078595281,
0.1282687336,
-0.1978585124,
0.2113726288,
-0.4567027986,
-0.3038161993,
0.3248639405,
0.4424727857,
-0.5387536883,
0.0392979234,
-0.4246302247,
-0.0278021693,
0.1559691429,
0.7142283916,
-0.6930598021,
0.2638970912,
0.4872527719,
0.730465591,
0.5691620111,
0.5347666144,
0.3381691873,
-0.8716651797,
0.1564670056,
0.033141721,
0.4276996255,
0.3407565057,
-0.7244848609,
0.6185368896,
0.1526810527,
-0.1912169009,
-0.7038773894,
0.3838665783,
-1.0114620924,
-0.1976868957,
0.862398982,
-0.6311497092,
-0.2854269743,
-0.0877974927,
0.1914156675,
0.5949513912,
-0.4223409295,
0.5350401402,
0.5870431662,
-0.3905744851,
-0.5890515447,
-0.0450691916,
0.3427218497,
-0.0996832922,
-0.9027427435,
0.1771243066,
0.3199166954,
0.3076790869,
0.6163615584,
0.5477949381,
-0.2801184058,
0.1068685427,
-0.012443372,
0.1222674847,
-0.269177407,
-0.6584599018,
-0.0962989181,
0.5524443388,
-0.1714882404,
-0.6667829156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08304v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08304v2
|
Computational Thought Experiments for a More Rigorous Philosophy and Science of the Mind
| 2024-05-14T03:58:19 | 2024-05-15T02:32:00 |
Iris Oved, Nikhil Krishnaswamy, James Pustejovsky, Joshua Hartshorne
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, q-bio.NC
|
We offer philosophical motivations for a method we call Virtual World
Cognitive Science (VW CogSci), in which researchers use virtual embodied agents
that are embedded in virtual worlds to explore questions in the field of
Cognitive Science. We focus on questions about mental and linguistic
representation and the ways that such computational modeling can add rigor to
philosophical thought experiments, as well as the terminology used in the
scientific study of such representations. We find that this method forces
researchers to take a god's-eye view when describing dynamical relationships
between entities in minds and entities in an environment in a way that
eliminates the need for problematic talk of belief and concept types, such as
the belief that cats are silly, and the concept CAT, while preserving belief
and concept tokens in individual cognizers' minds. We conclude with some
further key advantages of VW CogSci for the scientific study of mental and
linguistic representation and for Cognitive Science more broadly.
|
[
-0.9234525561,
-0.8943831325,
0.900229156,
-0.0296376627,
-0.3229809999,
0.2899698913,
-0.2601653636,
-0.7429054976,
0.6705051064,
0.2819697559,
-0.5891145468,
0.095144935,
-0.2318312079,
0.0659196824,
-0.2869168222,
0.6773945093,
0.167235896,
0.087241821,
-0.7812981009,
0.1243182123,
0.1257615834,
-0.6546269059,
-0.5069481134,
-0.5977959633,
0.4543241858,
-0.156560123,
0.7483952045,
0.193671599,
0.7329116464,
0.3288486004,
0.08324413,
0.1109845638,
-0.2661876678,
-0.0534025133,
-0.4466597438,
-0.6115899682,
-0.2724417448,
0.3417176902,
0.1367690861,
0.7652547956,
-0.2633035183,
0.108585991,
-0.2468032092,
0.0216327291,
-0.6451280713,
0.2754031718,
-0.4490825832,
0.3574799001,
0.0837004036,
-0.3199331462,
-0.3985784054,
-0.3984067738,
0.2995048761,
-1.1567313671,
0.2938079536,
0.224761337,
0.7650691271,
0.2383229285,
-0.3103735149,
-0.1969882548,
-0.9536613822,
0.9527025819,
-0.2650164366,
0.4454467893,
0.2901563346,
0.3657436371,
-0.3143375218,
-0.5418567061,
-1.2127972841,
-0.6631538868,
0.1500968784,
0.427793473,
0.0460044257,
0.2809931636,
0.4260160029,
0.5064993501,
-0.2662223876,
-0.4235559702,
-0.4368338287,
-0.3825154006,
0.7192416787,
0.2282511294,
0.4974385202,
0.3029483259,
-0.1021997035,
-0.3360757828,
-0.3653778732,
-0.0181003213,
0.0536732525,
-0.2004083097,
0.1103863418,
0.7292160392,
-0.089800626,
0.4601026177,
0.0183860268,
0.166459322,
0.1727209836,
-0.2147151828,
-0.0727828443,
0.0250271335,
0.5187191963,
0.3210169375,
0.2369415164,
-0.2001779079,
0.3076228797,
0.9927253723,
0.7195463777,
-0.4715603292,
-0.2809267044,
0.1058160365,
-0.068432644,
-0.3393389583,
0.044639755,
-0.5753234625,
-0.2308987677,
-0.436013937,
0.2831187248,
-0.4389862418,
-0.5289280415,
0.3411489427,
-0.7140035629,
0.2527159452,
0.522798717,
-0.7292712927,
0.7129244208,
0.8307763338,
0.4663008153,
-0.1887696385,
-0.1604798138,
0.1162992492,
0.2569749057,
-0.5742462873,
0.8167058229,
-0.9669120908,
-0.7701084018,
-0.2322234064,
-0.3314569294,
0.3676499426,
-0.1872310787,
0.3975383341,
-0.5544345975,
0.4140926898,
-0.9435642958,
-0.5545395017,
-0.3643571734,
0.3934362531,
-0.5044904947,
1.1924586296,
-0.1180059835,
-0.6653080583,
0.209305793,
-0.8226783276,
0.0353893787,
0.2588264346,
-0.6837326884,
0.1120230108,
0.5039008856,
-0.2727419138,
-0.0049468046,
-0.3721179366,
0.1784333736,
-0.8657828569,
-0.2666684985,
0.5435640812,
-0.0093208542,
0.7601040006,
0.3244462311,
-0.255769223,
-0.0601123609,
-0.4989453256,
0.4543240368,
0.2653690279,
0.1950036734,
-0.9477577806,
0.4347236156,
-0.2795555592,
0.0896068886,
0.2101940662,
-0.9698647261,
0.3648924232,
-0.6019819379,
0.5464917421,
0.4331577718,
-0.1517667323,
0.2801528573,
-0.1361790448,
0.1671606451,
-0.0920191854,
0.1533204913,
0.5129344463,
-0.63102597,
-0.7964542508,
-0.115045093,
-0.1082166433,
0.3671236634,
-0.9081478715,
0.2150200009,
-0.125566721,
-0.5404490232,
-0.3826158345,
-0.4824368358,
0.4254280925,
0.4107323587,
0.168064177,
-0.664891541,
-0.5606868863,
-0.982149303,
-0.1688371599,
-0.33233881,
0.0161148459,
0.2097778469,
0.9882729053,
-0.0386888273,
1.1656759977,
-0.8547210693,
0.4257031083,
0.0645253807,
0.2024011314,
-0.2019528896,
0.3199281394,
0.5151215792,
-0.9492924213,
0.0411828719,
0.0688376203,
-1.0041371584,
0.2677585781,
0.2698625624,
-0.3037272692,
-0.3712245524,
0.3326698244,
-0.807230711,
0.4709370732,
0.1973271072,
-0.1577575356,
0.4772865772,
-0.2431147546,
0.3807132244,
-0.8291339874,
-0.1521503776,
0.0701093748,
-0.042262584,
-0.5696887374,
0.5008461475,
-0.1177301928,
-0.0648326725,
-0.4352841973,
0.280996263,
-0.3011719584,
-0.182494387,
-0.4764001369,
0.2777163386,
-0.0810045227,
0.4367082417,
0.3335014582,
0.7412561774,
0.4565838277,
-0.8850328922,
0.4661845863,
0.1795013398,
-0.079316467,
0.4812421501,
-0.5995380878,
0.5131598711,
-0.1948748529,
0.3727050126,
-0.6435570121,
-0.1385523081,
0.3275820911,
-0.5335121155,
-0.4185248911,
0.7780376077,
-0.2358504385,
-0.6911873221,
-0.4315756559,
0.3878193796,
0.4957986176,
-0.2427255809,
0.5176737309,
0.6803556085,
0.3241569996,
-0.2300595492,
-0.9748060107,
0.0076549845,
-0.0826638788,
-0.4785508811,
0.7370408773,
-0.2980746031,
-0.7810667753,
0.3892382979,
-0.1066258326,
-0.1159520671,
0.0351236053,
0.2202177793,
0.2189377546,
-0.3392217755,
0.0123958429,
0.1607073545,
-0.0767796487,
0.473667264,
-0.4507594705,
0.3119824231,
-0.2790163755,
-0.5005065203,
-0.2433157265,
0.516923368,
0.3342416286,
-0.204012543,
0.6095271111,
0.2088507861,
-0.729334712,
-0.2541587353,
-0.3410408199,
-0.1913986057,
-0.4683156013,
0.1924888045,
-0.5264455676,
-0.9952481389,
0.360381335,
-0.310292542,
-0.1530133933,
0.347448051,
0.5876410604,
-0.3163253665,
0.9375010133,
0.9634780288,
0.2988844812,
0.3740007281,
-0.3133322299,
0.4062237144,
-0.8665565848,
-0.2212711275,
-0.4368907511,
0.0254855119,
-0.4895021319,
-0.7263590693,
0.4495522976,
-0.1676053256,
-0.0901255533,
0.0604929775,
-0.7852274776,
0.6226967573,
0.4900133014,
0.0669308156,
0.0736249387,
0.0777733847,
-0.3265103996,
-0.2472309768,
-0.2704238594,
-0.4739024043,
0.6046343446,
-0.0008082471,
0.5433996916,
0.0857361406,
0.4437526464,
0.420832634,
0.3024682701,
-0.786197722,
0.9293688536,
0.3169467151,
-0.9004628062,
-0.1983516961,
-0.039538987,
-0.5910144448,
0.5922148824,
-0.2137469351,
-0.9701112509,
0.1115693823,
0.3134394884,
-0.3554963768,
0.2220448554,
-0.4776299596,
0.4025468826,
-0.1467289031,
-0.3325457275,
-1.0049476624,
-0.2695114613,
0.5066159368,
0.1976452172,
0.0324565731,
0.2898437083,
-0.1242082641,
0.5946310163,
-0.497867763,
0.7931784987,
0.1102061644,
-0.0873079002,
0.7171888947,
0.0397237204,
0.2889545262,
-0.0049790931,
0.159295395,
0.1160330251,
0.2496021986,
-0.3975025415,
-0.802323103,
0.5827922821,
-0.8003597856,
-0.9455196261,
-0.8355820179,
-0.4128079414,
-0.3427113593,
0.0054685725,
0.1048915386,
0.0597014315,
-0.5737569928,
-0.0380156748,
0.984539032,
-0.3364383876,
0.0079392996,
0.3359264135,
-0.5290715098,
-0.2268252373,
0.9948601127,
0.051568158,
0.410392493,
0.2977910936,
0.2288329303,
-0.0657624528,
-0.2816655338,
-0.0055477903,
0.1463752985,
-0.4996191859,
0.550586462,
-0.6750814319,
-0.2686656415,
-0.116279304,
-0.1269388646,
-0.3845917881,
-0.4894499183,
-0.0067823967,
-0.1671410501,
0.4077377617,
0.7228754759,
0.0964746326,
0.1438080072,
-0.1333196014,
0.4956061244,
0.2478306293,
0.1858074814,
0.0170893688,
0.0122594256,
-0.2648927867,
0.2732607126,
-0.4576996267,
-1.0128167868,
0.001723871,
-0.0611788034,
0.510900557,
0.2183434814,
-0.1559060961,
1.0702800751,
-0.4110316634,
0.9453665614,
0.3047246933,
-0.9262441993,
0.4917066395,
-0.3643940687,
-0.1114083603,
0.2478668243,
0.4704150558,
-0.5648520589,
-0.5587319732,
-0.6329112053,
-0.2731215656,
0.2744024992,
0.2231663465,
0.1874425709,
-0.0713103935,
0.6327100992,
0.0620820075,
0.2978292704,
-0.4312950671,
-0.1034822613,
-0.2749927044,
-0.1930538267,
-0.0139824189,
0.0583520383,
-0.3905152082,
-0.5086042285,
0.527543962,
-0.2968989611,
0.5434051752,
0.6272849441,
0.1971226633,
-0.2170656472,
0.0015141284,
0.5750544667,
0.4209589064,
0.0894087106,
0.3683297634,
0.2227904946,
-0.732702136,
0.0631040558,
-0.314727962,
-0.3240045309,
-0.3308671117,
0.1456860453,
0.4915413558,
0.0184015315,
-0.639072001,
-0.0134264799,
-0.2413976192,
-0.1793223619,
-0.7580822706,
0.2758192122,
0.2489421368,
0.3483977616,
-0.0209057126,
0.3567913473,
0.4409442544,
-0.860630393,
-0.032446377,
0.6008705497,
-0.3107607961,
-0.7411629558,
0.5438337922,
0.0026823131,
-0.2482018769,
0.3938506246,
-0.4256050289,
-0.548974514,
0.7135664225,
0.4904382825,
0.78794384,
0.0099582588,
0.336520195,
0.1845747381,
0.2653363943,
-0.2561006546,
0.6134448051,
-0.2086552382,
-0.8830395341,
-0.4003743231,
-0.3367216587,
-0.739364624,
0.1305129528,
-0.5765500665,
0.0935463235,
-0.5291958451,
-0.5770477057,
0.3111740351,
0.0195078272,
-0.4801573157,
0.2153908312,
0.5741161704,
0.7161357403,
-0.6542736292,
0.9661090374,
0.8786373138,
-0.4449741244,
-0.5155954361,
-0.1299481392,
0.0864909664,
-0.4055236578,
0.4780940413,
-0.0785215646,
-0.6202260256,
-0.1784223914,
-1.0967414379,
-1.268548131,
0.6715985537,
0.5213028193,
-0.515014112,
0.0579154789,
-0.0005149742,
1.0161888599,
-0.2804424465,
0.214846462,
0.2641730011,
0.4132594764,
0.0337878466,
-0.7258515358,
-0.0095949378,
-0.593595922,
-0.004030427,
0.1866030395,
-0.8968347311,
0.8008095622,
-0.2840145826,
-0.2530089319,
-0.0887968317,
1.1015455723,
0.393896997,
0.6367011666,
0.4065759182,
0.6512200832,
0.790281415,
-0.0263680313,
1.2282004356,
-0.0053243083,
0.4426831007,
0.8081960082,
-0.3989986181,
0.5194735527,
0.8367373347,
-0.407938838,
0.5018676519,
0.6768270135,
0.1154813617,
0.5847375393,
0.502045691,
-0.2416564524,
-0.4878006279,
-0.3425594568,
-0.3940679431,
0.0985397398,
0.7016487718,
0.2033823133,
0.2294173092,
0.2072618604,
-0.242497623,
0.173337087,
-0.0766655356,
0.34525612,
0.4180237651,
-0.7108075619,
0.2669889629,
-0.2072453946,
0.4382705092,
-0.4862594008,
-0.188141346,
0.3949050903,
0.2344317883,
0.0190190785,
-0.6335493922,
0.4685383439,
-0.0196322277,
-0.0121111395,
-0.0997582972,
0.7472470403,
0.0033891567,
-0.4541090727,
0.3295300603,
0.4599538147,
0.3137682378,
0.2311944664,
-0.6675970554,
0.1780328304,
-0.256617099,
-0.3969728351,
0.1074006706,
0.3622656763,
-0.4904265106,
0.7928340435,
0.6223823428,
0.1564646959,
0.1807469428,
-0.1783756912,
0.9499102235,
-1.0629738569,
-0.5195989013,
-0.8276876807,
0.0881836489,
-0.2662931383,
-0.3098159432,
0.6463950276,
0.3945679069,
1.0646079779,
-0.1509765089,
1.1110194921,
-0.297160238,
-0.025491951,
-0.2336778641,
0.2867806852,
-0.6834378839,
-0.2736490965,
-0.365236491,
-0.6213306189,
0.0264941379,
0.6492342949,
-0.454343617,
-0.1125190184,
0.9386398792,
0.4137910306,
-0.1660239547,
0.6838673949,
0.3124921024,
0.1688131243,
0.3383603692,
0.5178673863,
1.2487919331,
-0.0500918962,
-0.1800605208,
-0.4163755774,
-0.1991436779,
0.0785639212,
-0.5100738406,
-0.9167157412,
-0.6884293556,
-0.4028057158,
-0.1926710159,
-0.0078652939,
0.9543663859,
0.4692253172,
-0.4982082546,
-0.3008186817,
-0.1851322055,
-0.2480622977,
-0.50708884,
-0.17191194,
0.047514461,
-0.0299619865,
-0.644779861,
0.2048921585,
0.5631700754,
-0.1150727645,
-0.7522534132,
0.0398600772,
0.0703189671,
0.6139093637,
0.6307371855,
0.1524939537,
-0.9803432822,
-0.6180212498,
0.1773173809,
-0.1097453758,
-0.1218206733,
0.9863836765,
-0.8439056873,
0.5826206207,
0.5667987466,
0.5182411671,
0.5948525071,
-0.2726453543,
0.5893514156,
0.0521617569,
0.3427016139,
0.4260091782,
0.2118741423,
0.0246423297,
-0.3587638438,
0.4943683445,
0.5279202461,
-0.098863408,
-0.9192253351,
0.49853459,
-1.2772812843,
-0.2632536292,
0.6176647544,
-0.0044484441,
-0.9030979276,
0.0739637613,
-0.3183607459,
0.3916296363,
-0.2556580007,
1.0510171652,
0.9972477555,
-0.5082304478,
0.1867570132,
-0.917398572,
0.3960334957,
0.5571265817,
-0.8105391264,
-0.2766893804,
0.2381483167,
0.040800035,
0.7034986615,
0.6710298657,
-0.0386460871,
0.2732833922,
0.2908739746,
0.343732506,
0.1405502707,
-0.0357239842,
0.0952045321,
0.1067504883,
-0.217227757,
-0.0418543145
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08295v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08295v2
|
SpeechVerse: A Large-scale Generalizable Audio Language Model
| 2024-05-14T03:33:31 | 2024-05-31T17:47:40 |
Nilaksh Das, Saket Dingliwal, Srikanth Ronanki, Rohit Paturi, Zhaocheng Huang, Prashant Mathur, Jie Yuan, Dhanush Bekal, Xing Niu, Sai Muralidhar Jayanthi, Xilai Li, Karel Mundnich, Monica Sunkara, Sundararajan Srinivasan, Kyu J Han, Katrin Kirchhoff
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown incredible proficiency in performing
tasks that require semantic understanding of natural language instructions.
Recently, many works have further expanded this capability to perceive
multimodal audio and text inputs, but their capabilities are often limited to
specific fine-tuned tasks such as automatic speech recognition and translation.
We therefore develop SpeechVerse, a robust multi-task training and curriculum
learning framework that combines pre-trained speech and text foundation models
via a small set of learnable parameters, while keeping the pre-trained models
frozen during training. The models are instruction finetuned using continuous
latent representations extracted from the speech foundation model to achieve
optimal zero-shot performance on a diverse range of speech processing tasks
using natural language instructions. We perform extensive benchmarking that
includes comparing our model performance against traditional baselines across
several datasets and tasks. Furthermore, we evaluate the model's capability for
generalized instruction following by testing on out-of-domain datasets, novel
prompts, and unseen tasks. Our empirical experiments reveal that our multi-task
SpeechVerse model is even superior to conventional task-specific baselines on 9
out of the 11 tasks.
|
[
-0.1487894803,
-1.011950016,
0.3507326841,
0.2048569024,
0.0102642085,
-0.0748609006,
-0.3985057175,
-0.2235496491,
-0.0882891491,
0.8031066656,
-0.8180393577,
-0.5504475236,
-0.7628942132,
-0.0820590407,
-0.4985630512,
0.9499198198,
0.4815811813,
0.0456001833,
-0.2996780276,
-0.1599405557,
-0.7081978917,
-0.4176182747,
-0.444729805,
-0.4577884078,
0.193501547,
0.3820017576,
0.5501167178,
0.5929233432,
0.2991391122,
0.2778935432,
0.176654011,
-0.1235928535,
-0.613358736,
0.1974592507,
-0.2254644781,
-0.2672065198,
-0.5750339031,
0.0567571893,
0.7807146907,
1.0350228548,
-0.2757643759,
0.1943512261,
0.0166782774,
0.3139133155,
-0.5726729631,
0.1345619112,
-0.6957435608,
0.0376056731,
-0.0007943375,
-0.1572087407,
-0.3950130939,
-0.0097894073,
0.2229148746,
-0.6909737587,
0.3366835117,
-0.3479472399,
0.4180552065,
0.4355677664,
-0.2415565997,
-0.2835544944,
-0.9421892166,
1.1498661041,
-0.4764100313,
0.9226780534,
0.5271380544,
0.4259151816,
-0.0043469039,
-0.5246260762,
-0.5716879964,
-0.1772193462,
0.5567839146,
-0.054192666,
-0.3311901391,
0.1789519191,
0.1618895382,
0.33183828,
-0.8813020587,
0.3307308853,
0.1016509831,
-0.2768839598,
0.2716523409,
0.1979739666,
0.2954193056,
-0.0299958475,
-0.0972159132,
-0.2289686203,
-0.5343450308,
0.1706572473,
0.2411919385,
0.6176821589,
-0.3254003525,
0.5900104046,
-0.2581564188,
1.0251578093,
-0.0031800193,
-0.4841111898,
0.1989178658,
-0.2645637691,
-0.4440038502,
0.0257749483,
0.5261657238,
-0.0792640448,
0.0836459547,
-0.5748115778,
0.0141591867,
0.2024730742,
0.1785051078,
-0.8590766191,
-0.0871848315,
0.2914803028,
0.059575621,
0.0741997957,
-0.337810874,
-0.3690469265,
-0.2960474789,
-0.8530361652,
0.3630156815,
-0.5494093299,
-0.1208470911,
0.2993554473,
0.1328200847,
0.2042926252,
0.2837451994,
-1.0675489902,
0.2970744073,
0.7943474054,
0.5943988562,
-0.1854657829,
-0.1130572334,
-1.0582755804,
0.3440334201,
-0.08415059,
0.6221639514,
-0.8308386207,
-0.3682990968,
-0.1580803841,
-0.1292570531,
-0.1388979107,
-0.3695062399,
0.5838930607,
-0.3224221468,
0.1609691381,
0.0518887006,
-0.7498940229,
-0.1530776173,
0.087214306,
-0.4987151623,
0.5148296952,
-0.0338540561,
-0.426560849,
0.2116470039,
-0.4799374342,
-0.4288983047,
0.0998873785,
-0.3501996994,
-0.2435097843,
0.0253556371,
0.2535417378,
0.821283102,
-0.2974632978,
0.715382576,
-0.2596670985,
-0.4234538376,
-0.1505447775,
-0.6494211555,
0.7307776213,
0.0537786596,
-0.4950917959,
0.1298974603,
-0.9762164354,
-0.1016772464,
-0.0345373936,
-0.3674987853,
-0.1535157114,
-0.0968813896,
0.1781195551,
-0.091644831,
0.0174760558,
-0.5915534496,
-0.0537873022,
-0.5139143467,
0.6067184806,
0.556876421,
-0.3229669333,
0.5981776118,
-0.0911316499,
0.4663560688,
-0.2395693064,
-0.2215306014,
-0.4483993948,
-0.4568974674,
-0.4622942805,
-0.5625103116,
0.0380658209,
0.8047614694,
-0.4786336124,
0.5308435559,
-0.4832034707,
-0.3423722386,
-0.3630394936,
0.3624050021,
0.4802852273,
0.7214845419,
0.4350446165,
-0.1309586465,
-0.4536108375,
-0.6989136338,
-0.0948590934,
0.2688642144,
-0.2616070509,
0.4446907938,
0.2730195522,
-0.5792793036,
1.2241410017,
-0.204278484,
-0.4010580778,
-0.1417600662,
0.1847456098,
0.5278275609,
0.4746260941,
0.3177309334,
-0.7894689441,
-0.1140487716,
-0.0444772094,
-0.7545711398,
0.0228561647,
-0.0282712616,
0.1931127459,
-0.1315981746,
0.3637435436,
-0.5697123408,
0.1478575468,
0.7732072473,
-0.1759590507,
0.5410476327,
-0.1777173579,
0.0028337752,
-0.9109631777,
0.1836387217,
-0.1568743289,
-0.3488231599,
-0.8068335056,
0.0599128716,
-0.1371930689,
-0.6161433458,
-0.4944545031,
0.5931620002,
-0.174610123,
-0.1785434633,
-0.2926318049,
0.1266127676,
0.0535471998,
0.5544874072,
0.1610455811,
0.8377791047,
0.8655077815,
-0.7162551284,
0.5419737101,
0.2936882079,
-0.308572799,
0.847951889,
-0.7734113932,
0.3049149811,
-0.242631942,
0.2648406923,
-0.8579692245,
-0.3896549046,
-0.1559395641,
-0.4073871672,
0.4070161879,
0.1593732387,
-0.4163198769,
-0.1952794939,
0.2266536206,
0.1609229594,
0.2592347264,
-0.3694263697,
0.822842896,
0.5062502623,
-0.2960965037,
-0.7935362458,
-0.7212721705,
0.2324631661,
-0.0023821048,
-0.5101228356,
0.3131141067,
-0.2420845181,
-0.1197274774,
-0.1307934225,
-0.1066536605,
-0.2305158377,
0.0217636265,
0.5492998362,
-0.0442264788,
-0.3028992414,
0.1497188658,
0.0757563338,
-0.0750279576,
-0.1739750057,
-0.5546558499,
0.4301286638,
-0.1229995638,
-0.3760549426,
-0.4597201347,
0.5003251433,
0.3716142476,
-0.3123407066,
0.4835225642,
0.6772310138,
-0.4359716773,
-0.2846369445,
-0.5851897001,
-0.0738184676,
-0.4363146126,
0.6378309131,
-0.2593362927,
-1.3734263182,
0.2631289065,
0.1095921025,
0.3102381229,
0.1684226245,
0.4873975813,
0.0034824375,
0.9756641984,
0.8793434501,
-0.2115702778,
0.3061327338,
-0.3100876808,
0.09148895,
-0.4628597498,
-0.0465274528,
-0.4983203411,
0.0836888105,
0.0160607155,
-0.6475661397,
0.2309353352,
0.1691028625,
-0.4375071824,
0.4902343452,
-0.4498826563,
0.5697287321,
0.4727291763,
-0.0716328621,
0.1563465893,
0.1856840253,
-0.2000356913,
-0.001046512,
-0.5777861476,
-0.3579731882,
1.1089670658,
0.434941113,
0.5793867707,
0.1228928342,
0.5479720831,
0.3751761913,
0.1887737662,
-0.6541879773,
0.3866920173,
-0.5910856724,
-0.6135640144,
-0.5171243548,
-0.5325043797,
-0.8161031604,
0.2169636786,
-0.3210536242,
-0.7552948594,
-0.1383212805,
0.1335989982,
-0.4727252126,
0.1318605393,
-0.6023181081,
0.8462485671,
-0.1075213179,
-0.336388737,
-0.3115117252,
-0.5352146626,
0.2383536249,
-0.1554408818,
0.5221244097,
-0.2116055787,
0.1592026651,
0.547958076,
0.1153123677,
1.0752328634,
-0.301160574,
-0.1895181388,
0.128305167,
-0.0480648242,
0.254543364,
0.1096313596,
-0.0780892894,
0.3026048243,
-0.2381859273,
-0.320864588,
-0.3416520059,
0.7938540578,
-0.9126716852,
-0.4661121666,
0.0335611254,
-0.8469904065,
-0.6330145597,
0.4059801102,
0.0777167678,
0.8667195439,
-0.5058218837,
0.4529466629,
1.0238348246,
-0.5051884055,
0.3999738097,
0.5419762731,
-0.036954198,
-0.474321872,
1.0302762985,
-0.143473208,
0.2117287815,
0.7618399858,
0.127223447,
-0.4200025797,
-0.4507783949,
-0.4653111696,
0.0359281711,
-0.7998972535,
0.0368103385,
-0.895591557,
-0.031551078,
-0.8117578626,
-0.0583254248,
-0.4881605506,
-0.2219046652,
-0.5151467919,
0.0017564502,
-0.0609688573,
0.4661952853,
-0.0499863699,
0.480325222,
-0.7202187181,
0.7056785226,
0.7893278599,
0.3445804715,
-0.1773103476,
-0.7452360988,
-0.0332934633,
0.2425669879,
-0.284137398,
-0.599522233,
0.3407709002,
0.7099335194,
0.7153404951,
0.4573669434,
-0.2772315741,
0.6081647277,
-0.8606468439,
0.6592304111,
0.4687350988,
-1.0014955997,
0.4467767775,
-0.6930114031,
0.6359173059,
0.3870161474,
0.2133833468,
-0.3480705023,
-0.5068523884,
-0.3951904476,
-0.6105443239,
0.4686613977,
0.1006538421,
0.4062400162,
0.1769337803,
0.1481203735,
0.2068595886,
0.333563,
-0.4762886465,
-0.1450177282,
-0.4579873979,
-0.0746944547,
-0.560430944,
0.0045618853,
-0.0987337157,
-0.343830198,
0.3590931296,
-0.3301667571,
0.3255613744,
-0.0774322748,
-0.2433091402,
0.0161196105,
0.4841830134,
0.8716489673,
0.6227527261,
-0.2370458692,
0.082844317,
0.0235304851,
-0.6598530412,
0.0836147815,
0.2828579843,
0.2110382169,
-0.0079940734,
0.6150041819,
1.1364768744,
0.6879650354,
-0.9201706052,
0.5928506851,
-0.0162496753,
-0.3617181778,
-0.3835354149,
0.2285153121,
0.4039083719,
0.1697016507,
0.4398592412,
0.1838182509,
0.1962737441,
-0.4092048109,
0.5277870297,
0.428532511,
-0.529853642,
-0.3320182562,
0.9843023419,
0.1542999446,
-0.2465728521,
0.4864085019,
-0.0581320263,
-0.1051319242,
0.4057909846,
0.5326544046,
0.8156833649,
-0.2441365272,
0.2601245046,
0.1954407841,
0.1018990353,
0.0689850673,
0.0627718046,
-0.3568291962,
-0.6030454636,
-0.8416734934,
-0.9562474489,
-0.5558323264,
0.2321235985,
-0.5580075383,
0.0834636018,
-0.5245448947,
-0.1407614648,
0.1727481037,
-0.2172000855,
-0.9394103289,
0.3569890559,
0.4451734424,
0.6868972182,
-0.7625330687,
1.0636658669,
0.4804814458,
-0.0241904166,
-0.827459991,
-0.4300636649,
0.045802325,
-0.7955811024,
0.6558113694,
0.3712866902,
-0.1946336031,
0.2277199179,
-0.6362625957,
-0.8296698928,
0.9437972903,
0.9175206423,
-0.8407193422,
-0.0773954093,
0.4658274949,
0.4525486529,
-0.4042466879,
0.1284203976,
0.3953641057,
0.1177794188,
0.3150994182,
-1.1045452356,
-0.555849731,
-0.019809369,
-0.2181736529,
-0.2010308355,
-0.0666831732,
0.8513562083,
-0.1116178334,
-0.0527678952,
-0.1491720676,
0.7850983739,
0.4346118867,
0.3303293288,
0.5021830201,
0.7409592271,
0.8509173393,
0.0549083017,
0.9259408116,
-0.0933989063,
0.1929110438,
1.2759995461,
-0.3390138149,
0.8496520519,
0.3160091043,
-0.0343524888,
0.3197751939,
0.2185700685,
0.1234487593,
0.6645171046,
0.1848341823,
-0.2066998333,
-0.5860456228,
-0.3202724159,
-0.2705721557,
0.6013303995,
0.4277568758,
0.0414132662,
-0.3255774081,
0.5808662772,
-0.212229684,
0.2267287225,
-0.4206880629,
0.5062933564,
0.1964616477,
-0.3213290572,
0.6759664416,
-0.1269785613,
0.8964862227,
-0.6546087265,
-0.1531850398,
0.0975809321,
0.2854245901,
-0.0135694416,
-0.4611391723,
0.3104245663,
0.1036110744,
-0.4136838913,
-0.38039729,
0.461661309,
-0.5370187759,
-0.413371563,
0.2302204967,
0.200266704,
-0.022733517,
-0.2116758078,
-0.7302983999,
0.1705868244,
-0.2289725244,
-0.0950043052,
0.2795316875,
0.1809246242,
0.147655651,
0.7232219577,
0.7634245157,
0.03738565,
0.185989812,
0.2104363739,
0.6024233699,
-0.3588749468,
-0.8260119557,
-0.5029159188,
0.4139103293,
0.1153711826,
-0.2067258358,
0.639942348,
0.4280801713,
0.7974879146,
-0.121149011,
0.7415723205,
0.1691105515,
0.7791090012,
-0.426491797,
0.5813343525,
-0.430357933,
0.1066001207,
-0.3044216335,
-1.0390717983,
-0.4636455178,
0.5963196158,
-0.2655309439,
-0.0960393399,
0.2843835354,
0.5692768693,
-0.1972245127,
0.2729865313,
0.4918367267,
-0.0356520899,
0.4399874806,
0.7060153484,
0.4710377157,
-0.150905624,
0.3119383156,
-0.0776349083,
-0.2568073869,
0.0825808048,
-0.9350889921,
-1.0339440107,
-0.5135784149,
-0.3062952459,
0.0542008504,
0.1139804423,
0.7768552303,
1.0196521282,
-0.9193112254,
-0.30648157,
-0.1547593325,
-0.1809825599,
-0.2564371526,
-0.1641121656,
0.1952107549,
-0.2006444633,
-0.7356114984,
0.855830133,
0.3169834614,
-0.1743207425,
-0.3096669316,
-0.2473092377,
0.0432525203,
0.0256333835,
0.6093697548,
0.353498131,
-0.7513792515,
-0.304577738,
0.1809744835,
-0.1379776001,
-0.322737366,
0.6244261861,
-0.6639413834,
0.6095900536,
0.2502706945,
0.9675534368,
0.3329112828,
-0.2641063929,
0.5117895007,
-0.9493935108,
0.3633553386,
0.3542404473,
0.0491613783,
0.5451185703,
-0.1520275176,
0.1409823596,
0.3012586534,
-0.5414541364,
-0.8593551517,
0.0139758522,
-1.1091715097,
-0.3087225258,
1.0728459358,
-0.1219419017,
-0.0634776056,
-0.1030102223,
0.1832736582,
0.3279619217,
-0.2345236093,
0.1801892668,
0.5034632683,
0.0245361105,
-0.1518861949,
-0.9069597125,
0.1266047359,
0.3510834575,
-0.4209960103,
0.1187220216,
0.6086944342,
0.3247159719,
0.1967594326,
0.6355814934,
0.0832018405,
0.2133865505,
-0.172647804,
0.0527332537,
-0.3931995034,
-0.5783469677,
-0.5388986468,
0.3743709028,
-0.3402844667,
-0.0330770649
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08254v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08254v1
|
Detecting Fallacies in Climate Misinformation: A Technocognitive Approach to Identifying Misleading Argumentation
| 2024-05-14T01:01:44 | 2024-05-14T01:01:44 |
Francisco Zanartu, John Cook, Markus Wagner, Julian Garcia
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Misinformation about climate change is a complex societal issue requiring
holistic, interdisciplinary solutions at the intersection between technology
and psychology. One proposed solution is a "technocognitive" approach,
involving the synthesis of psychological and computer science research.
Psychological research has identified that interventions in response to
misinformation require both fact-based (e.g., factual explanations) and
technique-based (e.g., explanations of misleading techniques) content. However,
little progress has been made on documenting and detecting fallacies in climate
misinformation. In this study, we apply a previously developed critical
thinking methodology for deconstructing climate misinformation, in order to
develop a dataset mapping different types of climate misinformation to
reasoning fallacies. This dataset is used to train a model to detect fallacies
in climate misinformation. Our study shows F1 scores that are 2.5 to 3.5 better
than previous works. The fallacies that are easiest to detect include fake
experts and anecdotal arguments, while fallacies that require background
knowledge, such as oversimplification, misrepresentation, and slothful
induction, are relatively more difficult to detect. This research lays the
groundwork for development of solutions where automatically detected climate
misinformation can be countered with generative technique-based corrections.
|
[
-0.5855041742,
-0.9487274289,
0.4998993874,
0.0889132917,
-0.1845555902,
0.4557591677,
-0.2049487084,
-0.21812886,
0.0675182343,
0.1750513315,
-0.5117341876,
-0.464458406,
-0.6038483381,
-0.0139933713,
-0.4033722579,
0.7032932639,
0.044665847,
-0.1966252327,
-0.2144514173,
0.2180946916,
-0.7005900741,
-0.3007145822,
-0.4657620192,
-0.4566192627,
0.1883456856,
0.7470092773,
0.7686271667,
0.1976487786,
0.4442754984,
0.2715939283,
-0.1671740711,
0.3457158804,
-0.3862531483,
-0.1547131538,
-0.0895766839,
-0.3274129629,
0.2166744173,
0.3609814048,
0.2310279906,
0.2007794231,
-0.3985174596,
0.2928484976,
-0.2319761664,
0.5018514991,
-0.8973529935,
0.2039643079,
-0.9381348491,
0.0850499719,
0.1584308892,
-0.3124459982,
-0.5164462328,
-0.3058051169,
0.0636537299,
-0.5087637305,
0.8034847379,
0.1184883118,
0.4951537549,
0.5324954391,
-0.1810508817,
-0.4642116427,
-0.9781988263,
0.6904988885,
-0.594027102,
0.306756407,
0.2079245448,
0.1304741949,
0.0156911779,
-0.1581414342,
-0.9200958014,
-0.2132893056,
0.0925463513,
0.3174999356,
0.096931994,
-0.5252965093,
0.3224301636,
-0.1001905724,
-0.5247383714,
-0.1169478893,
-0.4213402569,
-0.6283012629,
0.6775649786,
-0.0719180554,
0.1130927801,
-0.1645786613,
-0.4942583144,
-0.2717062831,
-0.4513477683,
-0.2047243267,
0.2990126908,
0.3365736008,
-0.1290068328,
0.2070323676,
0.2569801807,
0.337785691,
0.229081884,
-0.1533245444,
0.1229150146,
-0.4477944076,
-0.17864573,
0.5361920595,
0.3487993479,
0.6163404584,
0.1709290445,
0.0082197497,
-0.0989119262,
0.3424557149,
0.2948229909,
-0.2657012045,
-0.3252287209,
-0.0101716006,
-0.2481093556,
-0.5353680253,
0.1242024451,
-0.8109932542,
-0.6735989451,
-0.25262025,
0.1562836021,
-0.2088313848,
-0.5957932472,
0.0050535975,
-0.7327290773,
0.0421410166,
0.5474733114,
-0.2587865889,
-0.074979417,
0.4043019712,
0.7501243353,
0.0775806159,
-0.233049348,
0.275228858,
0.0296252891,
-0.5434076786,
1.2491285801,
-0.8015478253,
-0.5995823145,
-0.1045959666,
-0.0225781091,
-0.2888036668,
-0.5205455422,
0.4060832858,
-0.4267648458,
0.5982663035,
-0.2403181195,
-0.2790964842,
-0.4336054921,
0.3470955491,
-0.6321610808,
1.2276780605,
0.0691325888,
-1.0996613503,
0.6560759544,
-0.7189967036,
-0.257473588,
-0.0453015678,
-0.0546900928,
-0.6203902364,
-0.1857095808,
0.1379670799,
-0.0157665852,
-0.5462895036,
0.5777717829,
-0.3276157081,
-0.2394002825,
0.4228440225,
-0.7137602568,
0.7815744281,
0.0835175216,
-0.7136861682,
-0.1479231715,
-0.5193891525,
-0.0892015845,
-0.0723144785,
-0.2182781547,
-0.173962906,
-0.0685502589,
0.0107979951,
0.178488791,
0.0366244689,
-0.5986539125,
-0.095510371,
0.1640544534,
0.4885911942,
0.633271575,
0.0043714871,
-0.0268891081,
-0.4973306358,
0.3752027154,
0.4643836319,
0.1750927567,
0.1545853168,
-0.3991417885,
-0.6764122248,
0.1849433035,
-0.045149222,
0.9779375196,
-0.8860433698,
0.325661093,
-0.0794824883,
-0.9309093356,
-0.1356553733,
-0.2451036125,
0.2142539471,
1.1396813393,
0.5269759297,
0.1594404876,
-0.2956326008,
-0.7437503338,
-0.3940942585,
-0.4446711242,
0.3308422863,
-0.0325264186,
0.9289141893,
-0.0842146128,
1.0677380562,
-0.6357534528,
0.2663488388,
0.1597024202,
0.4342133701,
0.0671470389,
0.612261951,
0.6463010311,
-1.1420215368,
-0.1732910722,
-0.2280565947,
-0.6313499212,
0.2754788101,
-0.1887961626,
0.2803656459,
0.3167824447,
0.4424679577,
-0.3398809433,
0.4784871042,
0.0150592327,
-0.4414975941,
0.7600917816,
-0.2022583038,
0.668392241,
-0.7132639289,
0.1018195748,
0.4460411072,
-0.0479025319,
-0.5760586262,
-0.3041960001,
-0.1918659806,
0.0671620294,
-0.328142643,
0.2468677759,
-0.1762208045,
0.4302841127,
-0.304445833,
-0.0628951117,
-0.1264005303,
0.0139044607,
0.3356883824,
0.7868097425,
0.4544541836,
-0.5007590055,
0.5945595503,
0.1584316045,
-0.2297412604,
0.7875708938,
-0.1141188815,
0.4033044577,
-0.4061597586,
0.3782961071,
-0.9519417286,
-0.1514973342,
0.4989582896,
-0.4686568081,
-0.11405617,
-0.106103681,
-0.5394636989,
-0.5987000465,
-0.2327886671,
0.0858919397,
0.156569019,
-0.4341401756,
0.5666294098,
0.3485089242,
0.0009036263,
-0.6267537475,
-0.9770773053,
0.0747082829,
-0.5698344707,
-0.3363192081,
0.1485384554,
-0.2595480382,
-0.3549065292,
-0.0668036342,
-0.3374557197,
-0.404743731,
0.3154065311,
0.1070638299,
0.1974652857,
-0.0821856409,
0.2824379206,
-0.4018143117,
-0.1751165539,
0.2463267446,
-0.1689902693,
0.3132907748,
-0.0470773876,
-0.0499363802,
-0.3080921173,
0.3682941496,
0.6153274775,
0.3989961743,
0.8199368119,
0.4766163528,
-0.6291059256,
-0.1342118979,
-0.8916837573,
-0.2401308119,
-0.3923884034,
0.0033386394,
-0.0379679538,
-0.4321270883,
0.332095325,
-0.3039390147,
-0.0061782589,
0.6093634963,
0.1645426303,
-0.2537946105,
0.6420414448,
0.5312970877,
-0.0338996127,
0.3190268874,
-0.3796224892,
0.3575603366,
-0.2161291987,
-0.6745894551,
-0.6470793486,
0.0027539555,
-0.5049890876,
-0.5456674695,
0.2933265269,
-0.2246495038,
-0.4355966151,
0.1569772363,
-0.6068671346,
0.4683446288,
0.4039336145,
0.2597916126,
0.3265379369,
0.0586068854,
0.3529318273,
0.0085538216,
-0.9111335278,
-0.5976107121,
0.6393835545,
0.1375951469,
0.4980705678,
-0.0307739228,
0.2106205821,
0.9277740717,
0.5788418651,
-0.7133147717,
0.4635890722,
0.1754661351,
-0.734095335,
-0.234227404,
-0.4272023141,
-0.426271528,
0.0479087643,
-0.3766363561,
-0.316006124,
0.3964114189,
0.350371331,
0.003237721,
0.3203855157,
-0.7398828268,
0.7087591887,
-0.0845312849,
0.0316915773,
-0.6026723981,
-0.5159903765,
0.2597210705,
-0.3234961033,
0.5967783332,
-0.0120632891,
0.33075881,
0.8605476022,
-0.2676452696,
0.9173734784,
-0.5805817842,
-0.1257909238,
0.5024520755,
-0.0169691015,
0.3241690099,
-0.0815625638,
-0.36598441,
0.0726673007,
0.0320377424,
-0.4962005615,
-0.4295348227,
0.3851437271,
-0.5675230026,
-0.7470054626,
-0.6910583377,
-0.2077337354,
-0.2356646657,
-0.1504721344,
0.3749651611,
0.3008796275,
-0.4570353329,
-0.1799032092,
0.6283541322,
0.1975242943,
0.3472812474,
0.6098946929,
0.3643619716,
-0.3829875886,
0.8128914833,
0.3046112657,
0.0871559754,
0.0499172583,
0.4562428296,
-0.1701027602,
-0.5673799515,
-0.0050270064,
0.1245634109,
-0.9856341481,
-0.2121249735,
-0.0005538058,
-0.1590685099,
-0.3858125806,
-0.1349338144,
-0.1554161906,
-0.1513360441,
-0.2986808121,
-0.1963291615,
0.4020005465,
0.6184593439,
-0.2262362093,
0.4224720597,
-0.5193086863,
0.2425586432,
0.0935073346,
-0.0758392587,
0.0022932927,
-0.3726817966,
-0.2682201266,
0.3475683033,
-0.393958956,
-0.8592315912,
0.2837943137,
-0.0451730937,
0.4325427115,
0.4831264615,
0.0891377628,
0.7177237272,
-0.0220406763,
0.9274827242,
0.42820099,
-1.1570856571,
0.763168931,
-0.0107310573,
0.1243227795,
0.5966569185,
0.552215755,
-0.5816880465,
-0.4182283878,
-1.0095341206,
-0.4935508072,
0.5766324401,
-0.0899579898,
-0.1864569783,
-0.0498779416,
0.2911277115,
0.3101998568,
0.3989993334,
-0.5304532051,
-0.0928046927,
-0.4417025745,
0.1119944528,
-0.1551795453,
-0.002149415,
-0.522720933,
-0.1476036161,
0.7236008644,
-0.4348128736,
0.1250393689,
0.3124378324,
-0.0282621887,
-0.0985051617,
0.212848112,
0.6610219479,
0.950519383,
-0.0825906992,
0.393520087,
0.2443291694,
-0.3988671005,
0.227112323,
-0.0486612841,
-0.5293545127,
0.122973986,
0.6088259816,
0.4667400122,
-0.1711980402,
-0.3722913861,
0.3299230635,
-0.0548510626,
-0.314324677,
-0.5143700838,
-0.007251644,
0.006562985,
0.1219091788,
0.3586496413,
0.8439073563,
0.1761267334,
-0.7521550655,
-0.2084773183,
0.2259432524,
-0.311704278,
-0.298248142,
0.4343087673,
0.4241986275,
-0.0363367908,
0.7145562172,
0.2098014057,
-0.6588341594,
0.8221102357,
0.5353838801,
0.6448389292,
-0.316347152,
0.7549392581,
0.2689577043,
0.596039772,
-0.3303436935,
0.5422163606,
-0.1457553357,
-1.021843195,
-0.0158120841,
0.1053813025,
-0.3848178387,
0.1325004995,
-0.3163085282,
0.0722143054,
-0.5537129641,
-0.3685224652,
-0.1402947754,
-0.2214808613,
-0.7220759988,
0.4350450635,
0.3017003238,
1.2598329782,
-1.3732253313,
0.1971172839,
0.528614223,
-0.3089160025,
-0.4412618577,
0.4595972598,
0.3118095398,
-0.581923306,
0.7302376032,
0.1812311262,
-0.9278547168,
-0.2971280515,
-1.0345116854,
-0.6510899663,
0.9507731199,
0.5991076231,
-0.5440254807,
0.2437918037,
-0.0550212227,
0.3216599524,
-0.5076531172,
0.4631746411,
0.6526256204,
0.9694714546,
0.169775635,
-0.8882392645,
0.1168482751,
0.0178891644,
-0.1655715108,
-0.1187209412,
-0.9523034692,
0.3148222864,
-0.247555539,
-0.413089335,
-0.4501640797,
0.4216053486,
0.0980824381,
0.896697998,
0.9536604881,
0.4071287215,
1.0724629164,
-0.2126099467,
0.5905836821,
-0.2116641551,
0.5124201179,
0.6878521442,
-0.2233841717,
0.6434055567,
0.4407427907,
0.1435818821,
0.7692536712,
0.972284317,
-0.0299075507,
0.5874503851,
0.2317604125,
-0.2931677103,
-0.7420096993,
-0.2863619924,
-0.3429988325,
0.3195614517,
0.8017333746,
0.0111911213,
-0.0958278626,
0.0979431942,
0.1618053764,
0.2637382448,
-0.203199178,
0.6846629977,
-0.1467256993,
-0.7743327022,
0.6203972101,
-0.1157401279,
0.5103006959,
0.0037731393,
-0.1603862792,
-0.0035823942,
-0.0764141977,
-0.388109237,
-0.9284279346,
0.3873227835,
0.0491927043,
-0.3017976582,
-0.2792159915,
0.5452535748,
-0.180667758,
-0.5187898874,
0.047810033,
0.4457926452,
0.0882017091,
0.0351001695,
-0.8818162084,
-0.081842497,
0.0607243925,
0.0611744933,
-0.4839178026,
0.2217261195,
0.0183008704,
0.7295768857,
0.5333065391,
-0.0179134626,
-0.3119474351,
0.0369074158,
0.7665647268,
-0.865008235,
-0.6253932118,
-0.6876836419,
0.2749266028,
-0.3205911815,
-0.2656571865,
0.2842853367,
0.563028276,
0.6732051373,
-0.252494216,
1.2023382187,
0.0024688935,
0.4743948281,
-0.6460750699,
0.1529587507,
-0.0816921368,
0.2191424519,
0.1128640398,
-0.8878696561,
-0.269908458,
0.4759487808,
-0.7270884514,
0.1211475357,
0.8947703242,
0.7338782549,
-0.0146617433,
0.462831825,
-0.1058315039,
0.319781661,
0.3286300004,
0.2756260931,
1.0115152597,
-0.1418326199,
0.3817241788,
-0.0252381191,
-0.3025679886,
-0.3312111497,
-1.1143357754,
-0.6241506934,
-0.5603616238,
-0.9724540114,
-0.5677918792,
0.2610112429,
0.7543001175,
0.6295278072,
-0.7176750898,
0.0030799562,
-0.2023258954,
0.3631943762,
-0.2682534158,
-0.3164844513,
0.2154901922,
0.1499689221,
-0.400662601,
0.6067993641,
0.0908830166,
0.0261921175,
-0.5104576349,
0.2485946715,
0.003202846,
0.3324500322,
0.0577923693,
0.2890923619,
-0.7136462927,
-0.6644518971,
-0.4349100888,
0.1400942504,
0.1971035004,
0.8317422271,
-0.8990641236,
0.4580104947,
0.5756039619,
0.1564256102,
0.2473513484,
-0.0025541568,
0.3869217038,
-0.3969591856,
-0.0997076705,
0.2579434812,
0.0509336591,
0.724578321,
-0.5327601433,
0.2862084508,
0.6794369221,
-0.3439206183,
-0.6370060444,
0.1283301562,
-0.6896232963,
-0.3926897347,
0.743480444,
0.0289933234,
-0.1893007606,
-0.3590338826,
-0.2309547961,
-0.0300121028,
-0.6287719011,
1.3944523335,
1.1807155609,
-0.1388602406,
0.0558646284,
-0.1739646047,
0.3855472207,
0.0138361091,
-0.9203089476,
0.2858385146,
0.543264091,
0.4084392786,
0.562881887,
0.4081110358,
0.3542777896,
0.4556596875,
0.2162993848,
-0.3187173605,
0.0651337802,
-0.4601890147,
-0.0046898983,
0.1525378078,
-0.2062394023,
-0.0064719655
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08238v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08238v1
|
Silver-Tongued and Sundry: Exploring Intersectional Pronouns with ChatGPT
| 2024-05-13T23:38:50 | 2024-05-13T23:38:50 |
Takao Fujii, Katie Seaborn, Madeleine Steeds
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
ChatGPT is a conversational agent built on a large language model. Trained on
a significant portion of human output, ChatGPT can mimic people to a degree. As
such, we need to consider what social identities ChatGPT simulates (or can be
designed to simulate). In this study, we explored the case of identity
simulation through Japanese first-person pronouns, which are tightly connected
to social identities in intersectional ways, i.e., intersectional pronouns. We
conducted a controlled online experiment where people from two regions in Japan
(Kanto and Kinki) witnessed interactions with ChatGPT using ten sets of
first-person pronouns. We discovered that pronouns alone can evoke perceptions
of social identities in ChatGPT at the intersections of gender, age, region,
and formality, with caveats. This work highlights the importance of pronoun use
for social identity simulation, provides a language-based methodology for
culturally-sensitive persona development, and advances the potential of
intersectional identities in intelligent agents.
|
[
-0.5244084597,
-0.9310990572,
0.5619367957,
0.1668575406,
-0.0126201157,
0.6063501239,
-0.022566257,
-0.5424553156,
0.3897645473,
0.2734530568,
-0.4405667782,
-0.1756673306,
-0.3825283349,
-0.0777056068,
-0.0284449793,
0.8132777214,
0.2737487853,
-0.1695359349,
-0.064406842,
0.1515655518,
-0.3975676894,
-0.5279509425,
-0.7143254876,
-0.1958035082,
0.6332377195,
0.4127503037,
1.1240735054,
0.2455230653,
0.1614900678,
0.3413062096,
0.238583684,
0.1196711361,
-0.5193002224,
0.0026330906,
-0.2495736033,
-0.2977558374,
-0.0710782558,
0.2028121054,
0.673122704,
0.9342395067,
0.1446144134,
0.1187776774,
-0.1617113352,
0.2373995781,
-0.683732748,
0.249677211,
-0.5789554715,
0.1138100326,
-0.3615677953,
0.0327368341,
-0.1162768751,
-0.4156031311,
0.0560958236,
-0.5437470078,
0.2513364851,
0.1863345355,
0.8606671095,
0.0671830773,
-0.5883533359,
0.1453670114,
-1.0637646914,
0.254532069,
-0.2517742217,
0.3260308802,
0.3024254143,
0.5473479629,
-0.289466083,
-0.4383819699,
-0.8031853437,
-0.2263226807,
-0.2201875746,
0.3854224384,
-0.129283756,
-0.0062309122,
0.1155250669,
0.0787680075,
-0.5626297593,
-0.0034562848,
-0.4322715104,
0.2148490101,
0.8023431897,
0.0934932455,
0.4767415226,
-0.2009504884,
-0.5372990966,
0.0838980302,
-0.5822445154,
0.1917746961,
0.8451509476,
0.3394790292,
0.0223953687,
0.5898053646,
0.0427600257,
0.1313003898,
0.0886608809,
0.0082770139,
0.128731966,
-0.0765880272,
0.1568897218,
0.3054433167,
1.0397297144,
0.3864392638,
0.793079555,
-0.5541206002,
0.3621944189,
-0.0116166901,
0.1723895222,
-0.6014681458,
-0.25956586,
0.1743621826,
-0.0527135283,
-0.1261349767,
0.2674530447,
-0.5990555286,
-0.5522166491,
-0.0726909861,
0.3232769668,
-0.4771660566,
-0.7186864018,
0.2166435421,
-0.290202409,
0.4453806579,
0.2241135091,
-1.1018087864,
0.4484474659,
0.9325395823,
0.5874016881,
-0.0830518156,
-0.6805883646,
-0.2841924429,
0.0690453872,
-0.2062250376,
0.5882949233,
-0.7409127355,
-0.6984766722,
-0.3642780781,
-0.0022672103,
-0.2730673254,
-0.3990961015,
-0.1020395979,
-0.3015137017,
-0.0644344911,
-0.2887992263,
-0.2762384415,
0.187737599,
0.1263174713,
-0.2209498435,
0.8366709948,
0.1134002581,
-0.7335477471,
0.2073244601,
-0.5266801119,
-0.3121419549,
0.6787964702,
-0.4765949249,
-0.1269397289,
-0.0998423249,
-0.1800713837,
0.2894109786,
-0.0552977845,
0.2103626579,
-0.196529001,
-0.3956196904,
0.6703076959,
-0.2675854862,
0.6587665677,
-0.1719353944,
-0.3342911899,
-0.2802222371,
-0.532766223,
-0.0602952577,
0.4395095706,
0.2810027003,
-0.4597537816,
-0.1476827562,
0.0122944489,
-0.0241371412,
0.1966010928,
-0.7298579812,
0.0434163809,
-0.296390444,
0.3152548075,
0.6040556431,
0.2332479805,
0.2586655021,
-0.4135623574,
0.7961052656,
-0.0585466251,
0.2414559722,
0.0282962844,
-0.811429441,
-0.6177108884,
-0.1300086826,
0.4234069288,
0.7509405017,
-0.704940021,
0.2367554158,
-0.1967527866,
-0.6861773133,
-0.6996716261,
-0.3399990201,
0.3772681952,
0.0430239737,
-0.109016411,
-0.2140585631,
-0.4670887291,
-1.2472374439,
-0.5570013523,
-0.8329117894,
0.0488664247,
0.478287071,
0.609539032,
0.0538218021,
1.3074402809,
-0.3686564565,
0.1421734095,
-0.0724171922,
0.2653392851,
-0.2044009417,
0.369455874,
0.4740014076,
-1.1336019039,
-0.6723844409,
0.2271063626,
-0.429817915,
-0.1403929591,
-0.2226573378,
-0.1812629849,
-0.542801857,
0.3611033261,
-0.4834414124,
0.3259363472,
0.476188153,
-0.5412713885,
0.8322792649,
-0.0643800795,
0.3119410276,
-0.9945662618,
0.1557160914,
0.0493843891,
-0.3988093436,
-0.8495826125,
0.0373487435,
-0.310151726,
-0.2712202668,
-0.6539780498,
0.8453075886,
-0.3321959972,
-0.2791793048,
-0.0424758755,
0.2430247664,
-0.2455538958,
0.3823785782,
0.0540540554,
1.1322709322,
0.352815479,
-0.3129031658,
0.0513224863,
0.2682727873,
-0.0526426993,
0.9598905444,
-0.8061873317,
0.1813231409,
-0.4085426629,
-0.2245068699,
-1.142210722,
-0.3362106383,
0.6385256052,
-0.621478498,
-0.1533297449,
-0.3807885647,
-0.7349241972,
0.0546729155,
0.1751292199,
0.4337697625,
0.5274797082,
-0.2074477375,
0.5640892386,
0.8729076982,
-0.5160394311,
-0.2459203452,
-0.4252682924,
0.3339900076,
-0.4314703345,
-0.6128504276,
0.2850754261,
0.0297563765,
-0.5468074083,
-0.2976639867,
0.5139763951,
-0.0751935095,
0.2844110131,
0.4506959319,
-0.0214511659,
0.101833716,
-0.013347066,
-0.1560947001,
-0.3139770627,
0.0887413546,
0.2707603574,
0.6555963159,
-0.5200541019,
-0.5926193595,
-0.1471901089,
0.7563397288,
0.5354325771,
-0.2336012721,
0.5572628379,
0.5626666546,
-0.2650747299,
0.4489499331,
-0.4740330279,
0.0370964296,
-0.4723256528,
0.2540065944,
-0.5597599149,
-0.7723603249,
0.897818625,
-0.1236911267,
-0.0695989355,
0.0026680417,
0.1603106111,
0.0155673902,
1.1484396458,
0.3723766506,
0.2295119762,
0.3587716818,
0.2916256487,
0.4568963051,
-0.8715669513,
-0.1825276762,
-0.3533598781,
-0.4139878452,
-0.9732089639,
-0.4096247256,
0.6200353503,
-0.112137638,
-0.4011814594,
0.075653635,
-0.1754922122,
0.9291518927,
0.5749261975,
0.1143671945,
0.2694921792,
-0.4417399466,
0.1589030921,
-0.338845253,
-0.5036423206,
-0.6193964481,
0.4574134052,
0.3362854123,
0.5409026146,
0.2892757058,
0.7256731987,
0.1162084192,
-0.1579475254,
-0.5771272779,
0.8919464946,
-0.0220710412,
-0.5081800818,
-0.1423818767,
-0.3583816886,
-1.3467410803,
0.4180041254,
-0.0659342855,
-1.2042027712,
0.3508829176,
-0.1489088982,
-0.4530735016,
0.0999397114,
-0.7915202975,
1.0527169704,
-0.5132009387,
-0.2731502056,
0.3794078529,
-0.9254406691,
0.2623017728,
0.1636037529,
0.1338901073,
-0.2768087983,
-0.107210964,
0.4200492203,
-0.2247281671,
1.2852919102,
-0.0832571313,
0.1196701303,
-0.0070650661,
0.3232152164,
0.3212868869,
0.1497318596,
0.2653291225,
0.2359250784,
0.0466766134,
-0.3543238044,
-0.4818675816,
0.485080421,
-1.013984561,
-0.7189002037,
-0.3827460408,
-0.5197817683,
-0.2510634661,
0.289532274,
-0.0775219873,
-0.0488616973,
-0.6992514133,
-0.0787487701,
0.4384243488,
-0.0630633608,
0.015809387,
0.4828218818,
-0.4094898105,
-0.2699444592,
0.9286119938,
0.2005088329,
0.4627282619,
-0.0294406451,
0.3843539357,
-0.0954737142,
0.0125821792,
-0.4071448445,
0.3605027199,
-0.50498873,
0.4795678854,
-0.7997235656,
-0.4245949984,
-0.3408208191,
-0.2271269113,
-0.5379108191,
-0.2369090319,
0.2361809015,
0.1395465136,
0.1611635834,
0.4772574604,
-0.0499217063,
0.5999613404,
-0.428637892,
0.3717692494,
0.6967054009,
0.0097779529,
-0.3659242392,
0.112214677,
0.2102499008,
0.2579005361,
0.0169685259,
-1.150996089,
0.0740590468,
0.0698160455,
0.6114665866,
0.353723675,
0.1362880617,
0.779194057,
-0.3925899863,
0.8705182672,
-0.0973971412,
-0.7710131407,
0.4064792991,
-0.6691834927,
0.3512175083,
0.6327930093,
0.3495187461,
-1.0524049997,
-0.7645946145,
-1.0524821281,
-0.8629862666,
0.3505297899,
0.6016770005,
0.2764694393,
-0.2526807487,
0.2869513929,
0.3969599009,
0.3088282049,
-0.7416908145,
-0.4061764777,
0.0980045944,
-0.0160475224,
0.0334605426,
-0.0401277058,
-0.1056308821,
0.0268965736,
0.5528401732,
-0.1737560332,
0.249611184,
-0.0329214036,
0.1674120426,
0.1805055141,
0.1140957624,
0.2875697613,
0.5646344423,
0.0478471033,
0.3074909449,
0.068352282,
-0.4653098583,
0.1473641694,
0.1095932126,
-0.4560055137,
0.1418989748,
-0.1614864469,
0.7919799685,
0.4563475847,
-0.5678885579,
0.5182555318,
-0.2611825764,
0.0867649987,
-0.7118991613,
0.156109795,
0.2164810151,
0.6004086733,
0.2336136997,
-0.0814586058,
0.0795839801,
-0.7692430019,
-0.1585493833,
0.6218809485,
-0.2639109194,
-0.3640432954,
0.7048425078,
0.1446882188,
-0.7303004861,
0.2265691757,
-0.5821750164,
-0.7544891834,
0.6116499901,
0.4915288985,
0.8903672695,
-0.2150478065,
0.5360993743,
0.2109533697,
0.2538787723,
0.25887236,
0.0787131414,
-0.1560394764,
-1.1070719957,
0.1051074862,
-0.1589716226,
-0.7693527341,
-0.2026829422,
-0.3991138935,
0.3690210879,
-0.1049940288,
-0.357221067,
-0.0191884451,
-0.1322062314,
-0.5723926425,
-0.2643560469,
0.3118702471,
0.182747677,
-1.1555024385,
0.2977062762,
0.7305641174,
-0.3035216331,
-0.3932330906,
0.1453378946,
-0.047471486,
-0.7439559102,
0.5011903048,
0.1715557873,
-0.2680740356,
0.4095464349,
-0.3210397065,
-0.6149539948,
0.9037122726,
0.3400541544,
-0.2367723286,
-0.0139181521,
0.92182374,
0.4808703661,
-0.3394637704,
0.4345835447,
0.7620131373,
0.6018342972,
0.0844467133,
-1.2498573065,
-0.1790716499,
-0.4009311199,
0.2581770718,
0.1035130396,
-1.0506923199,
0.9591163397,
-0.1399988234,
-0.5734205246,
0.1330268085,
0.3551077545,
0.638705194,
0.1615526676,
0.6195811629,
0.1322986186,
0.8180266023,
-0.1589683741,
0.7723560929,
-0.0533208475,
0.1604654491,
1.1204317808,
-0.4815558195,
0.4243042767,
0.572019577,
-0.3151441813,
0.2677268088,
0.634528935,
0.1725040972,
0.3141431808,
0.1096062884,
-0.4128521085,
-0.4207013249,
-0.3971302509,
-0.3290379643,
0.8475877047,
0.1562287807,
0.1386083961,
-0.1431072801,
0.2076865286,
0.3675802946,
0.0267303176,
0.039939709,
0.9750584364,
-0.1637344062,
-0.5425746441,
-0.0451169759,
-0.243376106,
0.2874810696,
-0.5129321814,
0.0447336547,
-0.0473265089,
-0.05617778,
0.2291567624,
-1.0721518993,
-0.0899593458,
-0.2072272748,
0.1211676449,
-0.21375449,
0.8643874526,
-0.6564568877,
-0.4670146406,
-0.0436413959,
0.6313325763,
0.594825685,
-0.178180784,
-0.6236484647,
-0.2466976047,
-0.3208043277,
-0.0362569764,
0.3277151287,
0.7205747366,
-0.0914607868,
0.5986421108,
0.488795042,
0.1806706935,
0.1396506429,
0.0160173327,
0.5126346946,
-0.4500289559,
-0.7975128889,
-0.8718774915,
0.725255549,
-0.2692323327,
-0.4870202541,
0.7396756411,
0.5988050699,
0.7738320827,
0.0320150033,
0.9188429117,
-0.1572192162,
0.2994175255,
-0.3183988333,
0.7490595579,
-0.234806329,
-0.0875506103,
-0.2418506593,
-0.6247833967,
-0.0007225333,
0.6247891188,
-0.4193631411,
0.1614704579,
0.3172877729,
0.8732934594,
-0.1547895819,
0.1380582303,
0.4957846701,
-0.0220719613,
0.315607518,
0.5044925213,
1.2069438696,
-0.5848634243,
0.0113470424,
-0.3294780552,
0.1028611735,
-0.2289877832,
-0.6746844053,
-0.8722481132,
-0.7614133954,
-0.5841555595,
-0.1003040597,
0.1593973935,
0.9016778469,
0.6683191657,
-0.1689872593,
-0.22726354,
0.1247141063,
0.0146452589,
-0.0839058235,
-0.3036043346,
-0.1504882127,
-0.0434772037,
-1.0599313974,
0.18016316,
0.2003264427,
0.287629813,
-0.5929535031,
-0.1697957963,
-0.1554892957,
0.0336491503,
0.4060083628,
0.509378612,
-0.554438293,
-0.7143073082,
-0.1265480667,
0.0498987064,
0.0674516931,
0.7473361492,
-0.7295647264,
0.4998824298,
0.2936302423,
0.3631018102,
0.2884147167,
0.3738176227,
0.7836154699,
-0.9433059096,
0.3570303619,
0.3228704035,
0.2475526929,
0.3305334747,
-0.5365841389,
0.4250581563,
0.3290790021,
-0.565474093,
-0.6896262765,
0.371820271,
-0.8892787099,
-0.0730500519,
1.2849023342,
0.0073455875,
-0.1626910865,
-0.3834940791,
-0.4960708916,
0.119889155,
-0.2199607342,
0.7733353972,
0.7251713872,
-0.0626477525,
-0.5261459947,
-0.8560588956,
0.120887503,
0.1620016545,
-0.9206193089,
0.1035606191,
0.1665520519,
0.1457914412,
0.2624197304,
0.8324126601,
0.099469319,
0.3800040483,
0.0983200222,
0.0968410149,
-0.0379596949,
-0.2619703114,
0.3214379847,
0.0301582702,
0.0629048273,
-0.2671037912
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08237v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08237v1
|
A predictive learning model can simulate temporal dynamics and context effects found in neural representations of continuous speech
| 2024-05-13T23:36:19 | 2024-05-13T23:36:19 |
Oli Danyi Liu, Hao Tang, Naomi Feldman, Sharon Goldwater
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Speech perception involves storing and integrating sequentially presented
items. Recent work in cognitive neuroscience has identified temporal and
contextual characteristics in humans' neural encoding of speech that may
facilitate this temporal processing. In this study, we simulated similar
analyses with representations extracted from a computational model that was
trained on unlabelled speech with the learning objective of predicting upcoming
acoustics. Our simulations revealed temporal dynamics similar to those in brain
signals, implying that these properties can arise without linguistic knowledge.
Another property shared between brains and the model is that the encoding
patterns of phonemes support some degree of cross-context generalization.
However, we found evidence that the effectiveness of these generalizations
depends on the specific contexts, which suggests that this analysis alone is
insufficient to support the presence of context-invariant encoding.
|
[
0.0065998421,
-0.6514257193,
0.5272832513,
0.3117002249,
-0.1605044752,
-0.0358918086,
-0.4100413024,
-0.5213455558,
0.1450674832,
0.0881456435,
-0.6305239201,
-0.2314815074,
-0.363902688,
-0.2834767103,
-0.717200458,
0.5644696355,
0.4157668948,
0.3917298615,
-0.1487989575,
0.0656670257,
-0.660004437,
-0.8397590518,
-0.6061666608,
-0.7838814259,
0.4287417233,
-0.2048201114,
0.4337110519,
0.5226995349,
-0.2392600626,
0.2471380681,
-0.2905110419,
-0.5451682806,
-0.1070473418,
0.0349318087,
-0.2133964896,
-0.5779902935,
-0.1741874963,
0.3376292288,
0.9036266208,
1.117452383,
-0.5469422936,
-0.1925391257,
0.3873409033,
0.1835009903,
-0.1735163629,
0.340829879,
-0.6718380451,
0.2182109505,
0.0865781531,
-0.5860111713,
-0.4370501339,
0.0746080577,
0.6740297079,
-0.4831599295,
0.2139129192,
-0.1473697573,
0.6473790407,
0.1902164519,
-0.4293730855,
-0.4348486662,
-0.808521986,
0.7622382641,
-0.4848729968,
0.7569415569,
0.4399762452,
0.4072189033,
-0.2192084938,
-0.8162294626,
-0.3899317682,
-0.2254613042,
-0.1892230064,
0.2141721845,
-0.0486281291,
0.0861813128,
0.2419127524,
-0.3363331556,
-0.434808135,
0.0715907291,
-0.5547909141,
-0.1611356884,
0.4151394963,
0.1691783965,
0.3331396282,
-0.1143703982,
-0.3127147853,
-0.0936376601,
-0.1340616643,
0.5089426637,
0.0460045338,
0.4756098986,
-0.5860087872,
0.178816855,
0.0953798741,
0.5729494691,
-0.0196602792,
-0.172067523,
0.3497536778,
-0.0017375431,
-0.2207283974,
0.3898898065,
0.4338024259,
0.1468910128,
0.4667368829,
-0.5399881005,
0.0059751873,
0.2963323891,
0.2150395513,
-0.4675548375,
0.0115824779,
0.1299463362,
-0.482098192,
-0.2534110844,
-0.2926669121,
-0.7583259344,
0.083196044,
-0.7384423614,
0.1091340259,
-0.6006493568,
-0.0419129618,
0.0651375577,
-0.2878791094,
0.0777556896,
0.073140353,
-1.0039082766,
0.3734863102,
0.3898967505,
0.6940002441,
-0.1858253926,
-0.533285439,
-0.2835931778,
0.215782389,
-0.4275590181,
0.5180354714,
-0.8890329003,
-0.599211514,
-0.0626140758,
0.0129315797,
-0.2353652418,
-0.3402935266,
0.2067960799,
-0.7438146472,
-0.0791078582,
-0.3093276024,
-0.619762361,
-0.1585291326,
-0.3921395242,
-0.6378091574,
0.1715944856,
0.0608048327,
-0.4251088798,
0.6634986997,
-0.585108757,
-0.3098692298,
-0.0505593568,
-0.4938666224,
-0.1401228011,
0.3392525017,
-0.0723032504,
0.3296754956,
0.2070298195,
0.5957212448,
-0.1217760146,
-0.5796541572,
0.7338243723,
-0.4364739656,
0.7638092041,
0.1942296177,
-0.3397704661,
-0.1026019827,
-0.7062957883,
0.039690312,
-0.0784886777,
-0.4944696724,
-0.2987627685,
0.3965216577,
-0.1039892733,
0.1573499739,
-0.0537036434,
-0.5481827259,
-0.006790936,
-0.4147151709,
0.5205495358,
0.7108329535,
0.1730800718,
0.6672375798,
-0.4256509542,
0.3637337685,
0.4499890506,
-0.2433443069,
-0.1432397068,
-0.5146094561,
-0.2729667425,
0.186078161,
0.462903291,
0.4633330107,
-0.3396663964,
-0.212916851,
-0.3314832449,
0.0488906354,
0.0816726759,
-0.1708975434,
0.3498877287,
0.3873923123,
0.27323246,
-0.1088182479,
-0.938572824,
-0.6801688075,
-0.2259481549,
0.016110545,
-0.2870897353,
0.3108740747,
0.3178437054,
-0.2841220498,
1.1623425484,
-0.0624416731,
-0.0942410007,
0.1571046859,
0.5464723706,
0.0624580607,
0.5227658749,
0.6418931484,
-0.6802449822,
0.0418081693,
-0.0855038241,
-0.9195320606,
0.0963379592,
-0.2468602061,
0.4112463295,
0.1661040187,
0.6252343655,
-0.0918744728,
0.6158809066,
0.7558833957,
-0.2370819598,
0.3607153893,
-0.1881804615,
-0.0264887493,
-0.6911809444,
-0.1108945608,
-0.064378798,
0.125168249,
-0.637488842,
-0.5696204305,
-0.0024218226,
-0.4426855743,
-0.4227740467,
0.5894064307,
-0.4874899983,
-0.321301192,
-0.3197412193,
-0.0104801375,
-0.291043967,
0.8065330982,
0.4422441721,
0.9311084747,
0.6090020537,
-0.8524973392,
-0.1265894473,
-0.1590384096,
-0.4591184556,
0.1828165501,
-0.8176489472,
0.1481975466,
-0.3847952783,
0.0816166103,
-0.5580204725,
-0.212721929,
-0.3097515404,
-0.8030958772,
0.3748472035,
-0.0535745509,
-0.0502470732,
-0.0187153984,
0.4185466468,
0.4767907858,
0.7665262818,
-0.4299917221,
0.7807286978,
0.3912226558,
0.1256960481,
-0.5860810876,
-0.8249376416,
-0.2699918747,
-0.2035242915,
-0.2387453169,
0.6427556872,
-0.0182540193,
-0.3974137306,
-0.0059330333,
0.0241261739,
-0.0790888593,
0.0335934907,
0.644207418,
0.1020779312,
-0.1246903464,
0.3053828478,
0.0990008786,
0.1667462885,
0.3565411866,
-0.6117759347,
0.4792075455,
-0.0027192114,
-0.1042019203,
-0.3545104861,
0.3310780823,
0.5259745121,
0.1677020341,
0.5704877377,
0.3180336058,
-0.5517446995,
-0.3386172652,
-0.1873455048,
-0.3759247065,
-0.4856400192,
0.3717702627,
-0.3240078688,
-0.8348953724,
0.6767917275,
-0.0354152583,
-0.2369769216,
-0.0348589458,
0.2727543116,
-0.4240752161,
1.0797207355,
0.6091079712,
0.0129568717,
0.68862468,
-0.1768846959,
-0.2959119976,
-0.8484407663,
-0.5589108467,
-0.3054909408,
-0.4507256746,
-0.5062690377,
-0.2403967977,
0.2892280221,
0.1002407968,
-0.0805601329,
0.1621761471,
-0.2356358021,
0.3594833016,
0.4840758443,
0.2434495538,
-0.1433717161,
0.2089113742,
-0.6761593223,
-0.190866217,
-0.7018254995,
-0.2400084585,
1.0492632389,
0.1023993492,
0.3867097199,
-0.391413033,
0.3391036689,
0.4020114243,
-0.0551964417,
-0.5099334717,
0.4396670461,
-0.075376302,
-0.559242487,
-0.3222430348,
-0.2057942301,
-1.2435444593,
0.0110216727,
-0.2650825679,
-1.2178875208,
0.5936565399,
0.1932422966,
-0.4849638939,
0.203216359,
-0.4797438383,
0.3741237521,
-0.2402012497,
-0.2518679798,
-0.4276995361,
-0.5427539945,
0.0667237341,
-0.1390396953,
0.380830735,
-0.0300649628,
-0.0151739605,
0.9168688059,
0.0959995687,
1.1561707258,
-0.3262813091,
0.2782431841,
0.3864861429,
0.054789342,
0.0461229794,
0.108485654,
-0.0912135914,
0.3285409212,
0.0593411699,
-0.359718293,
-0.7427960038,
0.6349543929,
-0.9170616269,
-0.5162829757,
-0.3906723857,
-0.6400207877,
-0.2986277342,
0.0288319662,
0.4110383093,
0.6699977517,
-0.4338327646,
0.0556112044,
0.5081822276,
-0.0812784359,
0.8172456622,
0.3160978556,
-0.4174512625,
-0.1793456674,
0.5021615028,
0.4090255499,
-0.0106841289,
0.2734216452,
0.3041451871,
-0.1547640264,
-0.6717968583,
0.0492873192,
0.1132086292,
-0.6226540804,
0.2589947879,
-0.4617753327,
-0.2341341972,
-0.3640042245,
-0.1834371984,
-0.0628147274,
-0.391567111,
-0.5652112365,
-0.1170504987,
0.0531983227,
0.7921314836,
-0.3788371086,
0.5892540216,
-0.6129672527,
0.0478719696,
0.6899341345,
0.239978224,
0.2173251212,
-0.6218720078,
-0.2769299448,
0.4282824695,
-0.0842758939,
-0.8764612079,
0.7758211493,
0.3445053101,
0.7487019897,
0.3578728437,
-0.2569789886,
0.6120890975,
-0.7139410377,
0.8017981052,
0.0645017326,
-1.0752161741,
0.7038422823,
-0.5014228225,
0.4436120093,
0.1529318094,
0.5462377071,
-0.3772535622,
-0.0213195253,
-0.7121264935,
-0.395644635,
0.5649750233,
0.1334287226,
0.1337861568,
-0.1396839768,
0.5100468397,
-0.0352363996,
0.1958602518,
-0.3924081922,
-0.0699412599,
-0.3656328321,
0.4766674042,
-0.2785715759,
-0.416467011,
-0.1171625108,
-0.309946537,
0.0872590989,
0.1369685978,
0.6890976429,
0.1318474859,
0.1851941049,
0.0828765929,
0.1843024641,
0.905970335,
0.7124196887,
-0.4511706531,
-0.1078726947,
0.399759382,
-0.3897100389,
0.0734511092,
-0.2186029404,
-0.0049136798,
0.2726348937,
0.4983727336,
0.8438389301,
0.6282683015,
-0.4824208319,
0.2766104639,
-0.1237172186,
-0.1280186772,
-0.9290528893,
0.0097558228,
0.2258967012,
0.4517461658,
0.4447558224,
0.3738884628,
0.1163698435,
-0.8341926336,
0.4547774494,
0.2463204861,
-0.604459703,
-0.6790582538,
0.872608006,
-0.0944068655,
-0.4667752981,
0.8539222479,
0.0935640782,
-0.4000558853,
0.7836959362,
0.7112803459,
0.7677013278,
-0.4241202176,
-0.3476169705,
0.5284707546,
-0.2234074026,
0.1464359164,
0.2933087647,
-0.2943003774,
-0.8812261224,
-0.3399395645,
-0.7555120587,
-0.2043904215,
-0.0223416761,
-0.8138846755,
0.1901872754,
-0.5247899294,
-0.5476718545,
0.1653805077,
-0.4338489771,
-0.6448865533,
0.4062826037,
0.4044009447,
0.7177763581,
-0.6804561615,
1.3536132574,
0.4499991238,
-0.1354009509,
-0.9329507351,
-0.0204821881,
0.0848585591,
-0.7078037858,
1.1276187897,
0.0148014808,
-0.2407936901,
-0.2115162909,
-0.5815063119,
-0.9193394184,
1.0965335369,
0.3894385993,
-0.6997368336,
-0.6530041099,
0.0324906409,
0.589050889,
-0.7383928895,
0.151980713,
0.540240109,
0.1674466729,
0.1726817042,
-0.990606308,
-0.3201185465,
-0.2746411264,
0.2760522664,
-0.3955849707,
-0.094190605,
1.099427104,
-0.2688199282,
-0.5475950837,
-0.0770893171,
0.7647630572,
0.2736649811,
0.254053086,
0.3136121035,
0.1531329006,
0.6702045798,
-0.0746781379,
1.09298563,
-0.3931339383,
0.0676105693,
1.2861940861,
-0.0438803695,
0.7942367792,
0.3238606453,
-0.0811846778,
0.8482272625,
0.4717802703,
0.2938652635,
0.8690250516,
0.1714987904,
-0.2457500845,
-0.1505446285,
-0.1018441394,
-0.4892775416,
0.7757921815,
0.7353486419,
-0.557700932,
0.1357334256,
0.2782398462,
-0.2322013974,
0.1030395031,
-0.3157173097,
0.5826850533,
0.2748814225,
-0.6206093431,
0.8265758157,
-0.3968719244,
0.7458091974,
-0.5917201042,
-0.1331205964,
0.187838465,
-0.0302057862,
-0.0777463391,
-0.4590601623,
0.5369132757,
-0.5606817603,
-0.3566028774,
-0.2461450547,
0.3837686479,
-0.4387051463,
-0.1242195442,
0.7706671357,
0.168524459,
0.1665339321,
0.178201288,
-0.4184214771,
0.095213227,
-0.105498001,
-0.0608790889,
0.4854437113,
0.2799372077,
-0.0540372394,
0.6426393986,
0.5658888817,
0.2576307952,
0.2420197427,
0.1125611067,
0.5961276293,
-0.7745155692,
-0.6971929073,
-0.7042684555,
0.3278770745,
0.0429496169,
-0.0654473752,
0.3188833892,
0.2544232011,
0.9862411022,
-0.2054751962,
0.6147636771,
0.4313690066,
0.5471236706,
-0.6977840066,
0.8654117584,
-0.3850677311,
0.2152125984,
-0.0599421151,
-0.5190432072,
0.0131799141,
0.5022423267,
-0.3771539032,
0.1014847532,
0.8613821268,
0.4870640039,
0.0920827463,
0.497271657,
0.751296103,
0.0980069637,
-0.195781514,
0.5637777448,
0.8343538642,
-0.1037146598,
0.2193000168,
-0.526596427,
-0.0975772217,
0.1601866186,
-0.817630589,
-1.1311167479,
-1.0564697981,
-0.0357230157,
-0.1962910593,
0.3837499619,
0.9064819217,
0.9678371549,
-0.8660356402,
-0.6521461606,
-0.0537301786,
-0.2957719564,
-0.4302635491,
-0.1372510791,
0.1092058718,
-0.3125860095,
-0.7388660908,
0.7986823916,
-0.1170956865,
0.3915019333,
0.0406576544,
-0.0298277568,
0.0124247186,
0.1657304615,
0.5714315772,
0.4692226648,
-0.7282518744,
-0.3154959381,
0.0073378952,
0.1781600863,
0.1951158047,
0.9986845255,
-1.2685227394,
0.3842649162,
0.4011223018,
0.2171875387,
0.5973179936,
-0.1750890464,
0.8930244446,
-0.7149925828,
0.5270636082,
0.3543672264,
0.6820731759,
-0.1172343791,
-0.3775684536,
0.242477417,
0.2122590542,
-0.4525362253,
-0.5417570472,
0.1344503909,
-1.0397776365,
-0.4144996405,
0.8895858526,
-0.193072468,
-0.3863645494,
-0.1207107827,
0.2956369221,
0.483063519,
-0.5577492118,
0.6969103217,
0.6050192714,
-0.2650460005,
-0.0905515477,
-0.6362409592,
0.5188715458,
0.319181174,
-0.1795127988,
-0.1030351892,
0.2983352542,
0.2829675376,
0.2920061946,
0.346147716,
-0.1207499579,
0.4582195282,
0.2551285028,
-0.2022174746,
0.0020406938,
-0.5161035061,
-0.5654575825,
0.4077085257,
-0.3066676855,
-0.1324006021
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13012v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13012v1
|
Divergent Creativity in Humans and Large Language Models
| 2024-05-13T22:37:52 | 2024-05-13T22:37:52 |
Antoine Bellemare-Pepin, François Lespinasse, Philipp Thölke, Yann Harel, Kory Mathewson, Jay A. Olson, Yoshua Bengio, Karim Jerbi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The recent surge in the capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) has led
to claims that they are approaching a level of creativity akin to human
capabilities. This idea has sparked a blend of excitement and apprehension.
However, a critical piece that has been missing in this discourse is a
systematic evaluation of LLM creativity, particularly in comparison to human
divergent thinking. To bridge this gap, we leverage recent advances in
creativity science to build a framework for in-depth analysis of divergent
creativity in both state-of-the-art LLMs and a substantial dataset of 100,000
humans. We found evidence suggesting that LLMs can indeed surpass human
capabilities in specific creative tasks such as divergent association and
creative writing. Our quantitative benchmarking framework opens up new paths
for the development of more creative LLMs, but it also encourages more granular
inquiries into the distinctive elements that constitute human inventive thought
processes, compared to those that can be artificially generated.
|
[
-0.5180932283,
-0.6247726083,
0.6952639222,
0.3983877301,
0.0333764665,
0.8395266533,
-0.4857188165,
-0.5749543309,
0.1687883884,
0.2106695622,
-0.7651330829,
-0.3501000404,
-0.5202448964,
0.300591588,
-0.2565461993,
0.5183107257,
0.1188015193,
-0.0729806945,
-0.5774597526,
0.0157334693,
-0.3364219368,
-0.2617757916,
-0.4519207478,
-0.3424262404,
0.8736877441,
0.4090895355,
0.4598182142,
0.3373800218,
0.4932612777,
0.3139363527,
-0.4396995604,
0.1259277016,
-0.6765828729,
0.1181649193,
-0.3349832594,
-0.5272926688,
-0.3784318864,
0.1193234175,
0.7650985122,
0.9909867048,
-0.0925732329,
0.0641613007,
-0.0516439304,
0.9158089161,
-0.4145102799,
-0.1694021225,
-0.4940643907,
0.0773280412,
-0.4415124953,
0.1443070918,
-0.0867518932,
-0.5788764954,
0.2776055634,
-0.1310016066,
0.328441292,
-0.1626264304,
0.313699156,
0.1426188499,
-0.1515615582,
-0.3596625328,
-0.8661934733,
0.8159151673,
-0.7103330493,
0.3027659357,
0.0639023557,
0.0976329744,
-0.290571779,
-0.6839514375,
-0.7429852486,
-0.2627630234,
0.6240021586,
0.0719902739,
-0.3014109135,
-0.4047173262,
0.4399352968,
0.5536267161,
-0.5845871568,
0.492490977,
-0.2040542811,
0.1868709475,
0.9837896824,
0.507719934,
0.3751296699,
0.1929966956,
-0.277715385,
-0.0394639112,
-0.6947248578,
0.1895134449,
0.5666466951,
-0.0400300361,
-0.0862858444,
0.5502575636,
-0.3122431338,
0.18821612,
-0.2958917618,
-0.1457885057,
0.3048631847,
-0.2028876394,
0.0016576611,
-0.2477938533,
0.8876619935,
0.2096113265,
0.2509638369,
-0.3131718934,
-0.3350620866,
-0.0246049538,
0.223276332,
-0.6938507557,
0.007104883,
0.0953271687,
-0.2461176515,
-0.1834282577,
0.1718949825,
-0.5861420631,
-0.7998334169,
-0.1266768277,
0.0463027544,
-0.1514375955,
-0.5740194321,
0.5036014915,
-0.4624370039,
-0.0301278494,
0.0170427319,
-0.8611175418,
0.1429014653,
0.8762062788,
0.7471574545,
-0.536785543,
-0.4209429622,
0.222736448,
-0.1769554615,
-0.7069818377,
0.893230617,
-0.4582334459,
-0.4625688195,
-0.0612598136,
-0.2937956452,
0.3461359441,
-0.796005249,
0.7716996074,
-0.4521937072,
0.2216006517,
-0.7019311786,
-0.5769718289,
-0.2942788303,
0.1107271165,
-0.7793335915,
0.7179087996,
0.2897200882,
-0.6602432132,
0.4879280627,
-0.5265322328,
-0.3558039665,
0.5049965382,
-0.3295380175,
-0.3729840219,
0.4272570908,
-0.1441523284,
0.3531814814,
-0.851780057,
0.3175696731,
-0.6015303135,
-0.3982149661,
0.8808427453,
-0.4065115452,
0.8854395747,
0.1229384616,
-0.1539592445,
0.0888587758,
-0.5987724066,
0.0547745153,
0.3377508521,
-0.5881742835,
-0.0093814498,
-0.1370872855,
-0.1084916592,
0.3012719154,
0.2245684564,
-0.6351104379,
0.2438935786,
-0.4695110917,
0.64085567,
0.4936844707,
-0.0634691343,
0.4964066744,
-0.6988289952,
0.7063619494,
-0.2471708655,
-0.1361988783,
0.0547798909,
-0.5891106129,
-0.5133516788,
-0.4748255014,
-0.0342548601,
0.3172697425,
-0.3463553488,
0.5362287164,
-0.4378171265,
-0.8608036637,
-0.542218864,
0.4133942723,
0.1462748349,
0.258041054,
-0.021059297,
-0.6710453033,
-0.4634735286,
-0.7380697131,
-0.6002550125,
0.0508319549,
-0.3453273773,
0.2224098593,
0.5030873418,
-0.3744542301,
0.8922550082,
-0.1679637581,
-0.03055433,
-0.6337355375,
0.2314797789,
0.3293978274,
0.2739835382,
0.3060266972,
-0.5637428761,
-0.4393635392,
-0.094423376,
-0.7980241776,
-0.2571898997,
-0.2063940614,
-0.0662086383,
0.089280732,
0.541469872,
-0.9400987029,
0.2424221486,
0.1315723062,
-0.276468277,
0.6995215416,
0.1596088707,
-0.2480822206,
-0.7604058981,
0.0159075707,
-0.1485988647,
0.2669612467,
-0.5637296438,
-0.2087376565,
-0.012277429,
0.2957705259,
-0.3950686157,
0.5967381597,
-0.6450017095,
-0.1605494618,
-0.2446994334,
0.1493564248,
-0.0438366681,
0.102757901,
-0.0736043826,
0.3798952997,
0.728027761,
-0.3176051676,
0.5865237713,
0.0610461384,
-0.7884727716,
0.2347415388,
-0.6165090203,
0.250549525,
-0.2921116948,
0.2620866299,
-1.0632061958,
-0.4468248487,
-0.1638334095,
-0.1842419505,
0.1937593073,
0.3421512842,
-0.6425288916,
-0.6787108183,
-0.4325422645,
0.3560231626,
0.6303594708,
-0.2613030076,
0.5033308864,
0.3218846619,
-0.6683294773,
-0.3488027155,
-0.7913490534,
0.3584966958,
-0.5057713985,
-0.821577847,
0.4508861601,
-0.4051192999,
-0.5841295123,
-0.1981585175,
0.051978536,
0.2851676643,
0.189252913,
0.1428155601,
0.1515178978,
-0.1656854898,
0.0245980415,
-0.219082877,
0.2066250294,
0.3224590123,
-0.07519456,
0.6553201675,
-0.2087605,
-0.4684109986,
-0.3375818431,
0.1560038626,
0.6511257291,
-0.05526397,
0.4626104236,
0.4859706759,
-0.1428590268,
-0.4341447949,
-0.7667483091,
0.1364562213,
-0.4844829142,
0.5031937361,
-0.1641123295,
-0.9602572918,
0.6817346215,
-0.0817235708,
0.0281377602,
0.3132914007,
0.8240901828,
-0.1158755049,
0.6807891726,
0.7581019998,
0.0835948512,
0.4556606114,
-0.3677143455,
0.2730531693,
-0.8869242668,
-0.5525601506,
-0.1305391639,
-0.6060407758,
-0.4728571177,
-0.4958362579,
0.0134796379,
0.1747338921,
-0.310790509,
-0.1966039091,
-0.219416067,
0.8471987844,
0.5127394199,
-0.2284710407,
0.1855309904,
-0.2009812295,
-0.1394908875,
-0.0524183773,
-0.7714152336,
-0.6252401471,
1.0817741156,
0.4954907,
0.8201998472,
0.2822325826,
0.6931844354,
0.1855207831,
0.5026946664,
-0.8057072759,
0.683134675,
0.1014108732,
-0.4608454406,
-0.4621215761,
-0.333374083,
-0.7842242718,
0.1684777141,
-0.1661701798,
-0.6736235023,
0.1485559642,
-0.4360944927,
-0.3255473077,
0.4722712338,
-0.468770504,
0.6305441856,
-0.3674790859,
-0.5100633502,
-0.1712230742,
-0.4769367874,
0.4806253314,
-0.3628542721,
0.0727289692,
-0.2362355441,
-0.2574683726,
0.7458491921,
0.1882178932,
0.7587987781,
0.3107388318,
-0.4585089684,
0.4364071488,
0.2079772204,
0.15690355,
0.0530898944,
-0.1233304143,
0.1132584736,
-0.5886710882,
-0.3497599065,
-0.4393827021,
0.7226828337,
-0.5159606338,
-0.6899641156,
-0.2761292756,
-0.8739849329,
-0.2964306474,
0.2113045454,
0.3120718598,
0.0036189337,
-0.5541493893,
0.2699401081,
0.4447183311,
-0.2864446938,
0.8330993652,
0.4321354926,
-0.0134052141,
-0.4294928312,
0.7137497663,
0.0364766717,
0.322401613,
0.1080861241,
0.2390177995,
-0.5455519557,
-0.6091427207,
-0.0963963568,
0.4566590786,
-0.7491928935,
0.1724293679,
-0.4118020236,
-0.0757159442,
-0.3106715977,
-0.2627554238,
-0.345341146,
-0.3701521754,
-0.3679949641,
0.0514693707,
-0.0678288937,
1.1850186586,
-0.062083073,
-0.2335132062,
-0.6469095349,
0.0274215061,
0.3654620051,
0.3816035688,
0.4533560872,
-0.6457765698,
-0.2210240811,
0.0028995567,
-0.5895292163,
-0.4874683022,
0.3901803195,
-0.0141745629,
0.6640058756,
0.676695168,
-0.3266017139,
0.4992441833,
-0.417992413,
0.8858823776,
0.2915786803,
-0.7041910291,
0.0429420508,
-0.3142812252,
0.5492252707,
0.2103015333,
0.489484936,
-0.6411783695,
-0.4192767441,
-0.6293477416,
-0.753774941,
0.2543151677,
-0.0357138366,
0.2293257415,
0.0486703031,
0.096059449,
0.3179289699,
0.1961921602,
-0.6448433995,
0.2651823461,
0.2917704582,
0.0576535277,
-0.254522264,
-0.2181293964,
-0.177356869,
-0.2994052172,
0.2461908013,
0.0329433717,
-0.0971240625,
-0.1059660167,
0.2557547092,
-0.4136597216,
0.2630884051,
0.5191812515,
0.8855412602,
0.1761838943,
0.2535966337,
0.3855778873,
-0.3649815321,
0.1023026258,
-0.201720506,
0.1783403754,
-0.3109674156,
0.7125450373,
0.5334320664,
0.0073340158,
-1.1603678465,
0.4129225016,
-0.1398717165,
-0.3127025664,
-0.3261201978,
0.2829749882,
0.7697319984,
0.6231505275,
0.3486464024,
0.2761556208,
-0.0790828019,
-0.7663914561,
-0.1337048411,
0.5750457644,
-0.0894585177,
-0.4380199909,
0.5240036845,
0.0611081682,
-0.6004539132,
0.5080248117,
-0.2586440742,
-0.4106062651,
0.5658760071,
0.4159396887,
1.2809288502,
0.1460590214,
0.0184201989,
-0.106774196,
0.1384117305,
-0.2847777009,
0.4760572314,
-0.0916927159,
-0.7026897669,
-0.4115712941,
-0.6934216022,
-0.3411373496,
0.2225336283,
-0.3543036282,
0.1396751851,
-0.3201611042,
-0.2168358713,
0.1147235632,
-0.0209072102,
-0.6564471126,
-0.0376352482,
0.4940497279,
0.8397983313,
-0.6258601546,
0.4817038178,
0.6519417167,
-0.3686465919,
-0.3818377554,
0.2121893466,
0.0189762488,
-0.2850243449,
0.7591459751,
0.2516522408,
-0.3045497239,
-0.1507062167,
-0.6176816821,
-0.936473608,
1.0994435549,
0.3573678434,
-0.6015383005,
-0.000798437,
0.364725709,
0.826759696,
-0.6322282553,
-0.0651119202,
0.7321267128,
0.1427141428,
0.2612693608,
-0.7629376054,
-0.0364993662,
-0.3129410446,
0.1742665023,
-0.1125954613,
-0.6279758215,
0.961104393,
-0.747369349,
-0.5485869646,
0.3517347276,
0.6344056129,
0.3370400369,
0.3048746586,
0.1671580672,
0.6966766715,
0.8673607111,
0.0599874593,
0.9068217278,
-0.0548188798,
-0.0029719013,
0.769251585,
-0.4908890724,
0.8525246978,
0.3278715611,
-0.2498321235,
0.6497360468,
0.4923714101,
-0.0705496818,
0.2352873087,
0.4919092357,
-0.6151785851,
-0.3323194981,
-0.0159373768,
-0.035932187,
0.3397453129,
0.2468595207,
-0.2831995785,
0.1913817525,
-0.1110925898,
-0.1909693629,
0.1890064925,
-0.167303279,
0.7878795266,
0.2912501395,
-0.8111049533,
0.639093399,
-0.2549629211,
0.7661685944,
-0.2139999419,
0.1663241982,
-0.2032983601,
0.1404248774,
-0.0911554545,
-1.3796749115,
0.1526468545,
0.1047394574,
-0.042307958,
-0.3141618073,
0.605924964,
-0.3561383784,
-0.2934412658,
0.2221570909,
0.8158715367,
0.1765337437,
-0.0041906023,
-0.4000514746,
0.1767956614,
-0.1451651156,
-0.2622332275,
0.122153081,
0.8196008205,
-0.0179940034,
1.030174613,
0.7493770719,
0.4010918736,
-0.0324062742,
0.4446249604,
0.9362015128,
-0.9869673848,
-0.5666567087,
-1.0564547777,
0.5397334099,
-0.1940454096,
-0.5726636648,
0.7922213674,
0.6728692055,
0.972732842,
-0.2147720307,
0.9668096304,
0.0216460265,
0.461350888,
-0.1539063156,
0.8150297403,
-0.4687008262,
0.4618846178,
-0.3290156126,
-0.9529232979,
-0.2900031209,
0.2716161013,
-0.4572493434,
0.114998728,
0.568969667,
0.6936487556,
0.1196009964,
0.2306273282,
0.2442674637,
0.1642102599,
0.3174727857,
0.5223143101,
1.6624614,
0.2923099995,
0.0236021429,
-0.0358436815,
-0.2785158455,
-0.0425564311,
-0.8581003547,
-1.1577628851,
-0.4708620608,
-0.1104724556,
0.0466103964,
-0.507036984,
0.8135496378,
0.3371138573,
-0.2131786197,
-0.4239221215,
-0.3541734815,
0.072715044,
-0.0525539368,
-0.1660232544,
-0.0819386616,
-0.1335071176,
-0.7335543633,
0.3897001147,
0.5085381866,
0.3097997904,
-0.8572708964,
-0.1198892295,
0.181272462,
0.485344559,
0.7714654803,
0.2242518663,
-0.9929949045,
0.2471593916,
0.0608547404,
-0.1225041449,
-0.1472253203,
0.8586605787,
-0.5606443286,
0.408579886,
0.7344112396,
0.5044785738,
0.1796505004,
-0.0062874309,
0.3692786396,
-0.4975212216,
0.0244599171,
0.7579763532,
0.1724159122,
0.6939936876,
0.0257379785,
0.2761519849,
0.34387514,
-0.6064980626,
-0.9467959404,
0.4572580755,
-0.8433426619,
-0.3445239961,
1.0928912163,
0.0556364916,
-0.2270718217,
0.0873518214,
-0.155590117,
-0.0251280982,
-0.2022881508,
1.1801021099,
0.859708488,
-0.4203467369,
0.0553330258,
-0.315907836,
0.5385304093,
0.2405326217,
-0.7607612014,
0.2234627604,
0.2791259587,
0.3786793649,
0.1685749143,
0.5855523348,
-0.1019797921,
0.2601971924,
0.0936889127,
0.0407024696,
0.1848412454,
-0.3669780195,
-0.2781294286,
0.1394483894,
0.2931365073,
0.450093925
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08223v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08223v1
|
An information-theoretic model of shallow and deep language comprehension
| 2024-05-13T22:29:33 | 2024-05-13T22:29:33 |
Jiaxuan Li, Richard Futrell
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IT, math.IT
|
A large body of work in psycholinguistics has focused on the idea that online
language comprehension can be shallow or `good enough': given constraints on
time or available computation, comprehenders may form interpretations of their
input that are plausible but inaccurate. However, this idea has not yet been
linked with formal theories of computation under resource constraints. Here we
use information theory to formulate a model of language comprehension as an
optimal trade-off between accuracy and processing depth, formalized as bits of
information extracted from the input, which increases with processing time. The
model provides a measure of processing effort as the change in processing
depth, which we link to EEG signals and reading times. We validate our theory
against a large-scale dataset of garden path sentence reading times, and EEG
experiments featuring N400, P600 and biphasic ERP effects. By quantifying the
timecourse of language processing as it proceeds from shallow to deep, our
model provides a unified framework to explain behavioral and neural signatures
of language comprehension.
|
[
-0.4690862894,
-1.07315588,
0.8714742064,
0.396437645,
-0.0368385911,
-0.1059492156,
-0.471889168,
-0.61333251,
-0.0502569936,
0.0463611446,
-0.4744186103,
0.0087277135,
-0.4596559107,
-0.1176902428,
-0.3616920412,
0.7563117146,
0.1994581074,
-0.2200050354,
0.0766248778,
0.1389508396,
-0.4971906543,
-0.1014701128,
-0.819018364,
-0.5026282668,
0.5181789398,
0.2563210726,
0.6917462945,
0.583404541,
0.4370117784,
0.1707187891,
-0.2750796974,
-0.5039331913,
-0.533328712,
-0.083105579,
-0.2787214816,
-0.731438458,
-0.2962543368,
-0.1367643923,
0.5066997409,
1.3133919239,
-0.3115312457,
-0.0504068583,
0.1736053675,
0.7405261397,
-0.7640539408,
0.1399573982,
-0.5394284129,
0.2298765033,
0.0322604217,
-0.2742993236,
-0.5554567575,
-0.1375517547,
0.3426526487,
-0.4976656139,
0.315348953,
-0.2225009501,
0.7655437589,
0.3673624098,
-0.1238420606,
-0.056218043,
-0.8414065242,
0.3946782649,
-0.748431623,
0.5344322324,
0.9126164913,
0.1580533385,
0.5067144632,
-0.39618662,
-0.6061561704,
-0.1676381379,
-0.3176643848,
0.0318181254,
-0.2423028201,
0.4127359986,
0.3276729882,
0.3636322021,
-0.7236047387,
-0.1219821274,
-0.6591807008,
0.0750341117,
0.2292894721,
-0.0453177392,
0.406683892,
0.0122154681,
-0.0757577345,
0.1827814579,
-0.3737904727,
0.3974199891,
0.1604663134,
0.0406676568,
-0.1830622554,
0.5516498089,
-0.2142777145,
0.8361062407,
0.0269579906,
-0.0339675881,
-0.1000202969,
-0.2972376049,
-0.3934031427,
-0.1032264009,
0.4230791628,
0.1449178755,
0.5041749477,
-0.4382557869,
-0.2389622033,
0.1188721582,
0.1813423932,
-0.6775195599,
-0.2773837149,
0.4512851238,
-0.3516759872,
-0.0603468083,
-0.1577455699,
-0.5040272474,
-0.354527235,
-0.3895379007,
0.3395042717,
-0.7264037132,
-0.3100041747,
0.6208313107,
-0.2172068208,
0.0893979073,
-0.0904351994,
-0.9787365198,
0.53883183,
0.3280418515,
1.0049494505,
0.1320841312,
-0.3959644139,
-0.0741755515,
0.3850539029,
-0.3486429751,
0.8143216968,
-0.6287747025,
0.122405082,
-0.1169297695,
-0.3327595592,
-0.2136449069,
-0.0183602273,
0.4503596425,
-0.7459236383,
0.2110641748,
-0.0553495735,
-0.720240593,
-0.2653566003,
0.0141243953,
-0.9876195788,
0.3069896102,
0.0971533731,
-0.8284747601,
0.3142432272,
-0.7667121291,
-0.5800133348,
0.1224990711,
0.0886652321,
0.2499503642,
0.276501298,
0.128859207,
0.3988171518,
-0.1919596791,
0.166826576,
-0.3037510216,
-0.6655021906,
0.4626722634,
-0.4566143453,
0.8132008314,
0.2983930111,
-0.338586092,
-0.4684871435,
-0.5115491152,
0.3917529881,
0.0587495603,
-0.6770833135,
-0.2160449922,
0.1326952279,
-0.1483529657,
-0.046049282,
0.2339906096,
-0.4059586823,
-0.0985361412,
-0.82771945,
0.7939333916,
0.5328627229,
-0.1848839372,
0.768664062,
-0.0995291471,
0.3763052225,
-0.1993356198,
0.1711848676,
-0.1538440436,
-0.0513722748,
-0.7735102773,
-0.1013303772,
0.5165461898,
0.6001139283,
-0.3176800609,
0.4018138349,
-0.3612957001,
-0.0682703629,
-0.6846070886,
-0.0660530031,
0.1945658922,
0.1538377255,
0.3614543676,
-0.1577116251,
-0.1974840015,
-0.9200682044,
-0.4808258712,
-0.1289922893,
-0.2683694363,
0.31829831,
-0.0015186458,
-0.197656706,
0.7162634134,
-0.4053587914,
-0.1909938604,
-0.3024724126,
0.092852205,
0.4259157777,
0.123934187,
0.4203888476,
-0.4322920144,
-0.2491461933,
-0.0415249132,
-0.5531480312,
-0.1486638188,
-0.0802916288,
0.0144097451,
0.0084510287,
0.3560138643,
-0.7073004842,
0.4056521356,
0.4363957942,
-0.6202846766,
0.082604453,
-0.3790110946,
0.071129486,
-0.4091099501,
0.1862725616,
-0.1418193728,
-0.0883451328,
-0.6916990876,
0.3058959544,
0.1077872068,
-0.0551638678,
-0.1379937679,
0.5062410235,
-0.4029279947,
-0.0339592248,
-0.2521693707,
0.389824748,
0.2235559523,
0.6035975218,
-0.0370533578,
0.2608065009,
0.6352999806,
-0.7314753532,
0.024712421,
-0.356680572,
-0.4263298213,
0.6219152808,
-0.8470145464,
0.2074103504,
-0.3085481822,
-0.0449314602,
-1.0618470907,
-0.4702707231,
-0.0677784309,
-0.4796439409,
0.3464744091,
-0.1575384587,
-0.1647806466,
-0.0000650855,
0.0577331297,
0.7587034106,
0.4990020096,
-0.2646377683,
0.6516709924,
0.4008875787,
-0.3801106811,
-0.4390877187,
-1.0616221428,
-0.036321573,
0.0760150999,
-0.8046367168,
0.4288594425,
-0.0438390337,
-0.6380431652,
0.1682003736,
0.1652847975,
-0.5985258222,
-0.0021094251,
-0.0858398601,
-0.0875226706,
-0.1983175278,
0.2593114674,
0.133303389,
0.0100824405,
0.2063392699,
-0.1819762141,
0.4948120117,
-0.1383990943,
-0.3534248769,
-0.4046286643,
0.3745198846,
0.3488198519,
0.0001767033,
0.643774271,
0.347961843,
-0.5864984393,
-0.1940584928,
-0.5757448077,
-0.3599515855,
-0.3751978874,
0.3094862103,
-0.6166277528,
-0.5445508957,
0.4605489373,
0.5041151643,
-0.0156792477,
0.2124635726,
0.0623204224,
-0.2243687063,
1.0688567162,
0.5948333144,
-0.0128027545,
0.501431644,
-0.2255547047,
0.3733571172,
-0.5700244308,
-0.053633038,
-0.2365324497,
-0.4087986052,
-0.0718387961,
-0.2202311605,
0.0155651141,
0.4990289211,
-0.2107640952,
-0.1124950498,
-0.2885683179,
0.9730460644,
0.4507221878,
0.2268370688,
0.2458253354,
0.0836207718,
-0.0571964644,
-0.0949259475,
-0.7228609324,
-0.3240915239,
0.6809390783,
0.4494106174,
0.8119909167,
0.1149642169,
0.0039560539,
0.2391773015,
-0.1955159605,
-0.6542026997,
0.2537488043,
0.1458179951,
-0.7450616956,
-0.5594684482,
-0.3322952986,
-1.0541316271,
0.1439639926,
0.1715065241,
-0.8210255504,
0.1989275515,
0.2536628544,
-0.4205770493,
0.2647098005,
-1.0586597919,
0.7638144493,
-0.2613208294,
-0.3934970498,
-0.6157791018,
-0.6328079104,
0.3362243772,
0.074121654,
0.369594872,
-0.0065847053,
-0.0894519389,
0.4852963388,
0.0210034959,
0.6443786025,
-0.1977672428,
0.1736840159,
0.183421731,
0.6375091076,
0.3095402122,
0.0675702319,
-0.0590090863,
0.2133027762,
0.3088900149,
-0.7812259197,
-0.7117510438,
0.3871293068,
-0.8229234219,
-0.2283527702,
-0.2108476758,
-0.5411603451,
-0.1824400127,
0.1150925905,
0.4296646118,
0.1770884395,
-0.1299977005,
0.1925521791,
0.8953823447,
-0.1259912103,
0.3679699004,
0.4716715515,
-0.0886383578,
-0.1126252562,
0.770829916,
0.1012747213,
0.35353145,
0.5934354067,
0.1815837622,
-0.4085731208,
-0.553850472,
-0.1641988009,
0.2620638609,
-0.8264703155,
0.3021370173,
-0.4503398836,
-0.2498031855,
-0.2467419207,
-0.1231030449,
-0.0890592113,
-0.2910833657,
-0.1736023575,
-0.1988284737,
-0.0011042934,
0.9959698915,
-0.2725809515,
0.1875865906,
-0.3585166633,
0.4605149329,
0.3432872295,
0.7669795752,
0.1033031344,
-0.7384462953,
-0.3610630631,
0.4035415947,
0.0813715532,
-0.9954577088,
0.0446351133,
0.3074365258,
0.4443475306,
0.5009734035,
-0.1721939147,
0.5559432507,
-0.3995710015,
0.4781695902,
-0.0126537019,
-1.2479692698,
0.4268154502,
-0.1612880826,
0.5548326373,
0.5743701458,
0.1822696924,
-0.7841169834,
-0.4484619796,
-0.4806917906,
-0.9909863472,
0.6602986455,
0.306648165,
-0.0748280957,
0.220245257,
0.3987854719,
0.2047446668,
-0.005449737,
-1.088029027,
0.1724040657,
-0.1419385076,
-0.156730324,
-0.0026443126,
-0.3230165541,
0.0726540387,
-0.2154366374,
0.3833194673,
-0.0452247821,
0.5259256363,
0.1255396903,
-0.4142861664,
-0.1924366653,
0.3863638639,
0.4510653317,
1.1306917667,
-0.1697425544,
0.4752649069,
0.2275659591,
-0.3478354514,
0.0571740977,
-0.0611735694,
-0.2023455799,
-0.1362595856,
0.7212562561,
0.8961014152,
0.0654148385,
-0.6013253927,
0.5660557151,
-0.1880310327,
-0.0781670138,
-0.1344317049,
0.2099785358,
0.1875330061,
0.2470403761,
0.1825721711,
0.104634881,
0.3139908612,
-0.3532086313,
-0.0482670628,
0.2107247561,
-0.4998905361,
-0.3922719657,
0.5382655263,
-0.0129726073,
-0.4875178337,
0.4632111192,
-0.1318122,
-0.158633247,
0.407553494,
0.3008020818,
0.7195848823,
0.0382133089,
0.1456251293,
0.1826711744,
0.3861280084,
0.0745408311,
0.4533239603,
-0.1240958497,
-0.5332497954,
-0.7869039178,
-0.6432089806,
-0.054597117,
0.5447989702,
-0.5124240518,
-0.1377359778,
-0.3449235559,
-0.0727858916,
0.0620464906,
-0.3132205606,
-0.992389977,
0.3491061032,
0.140944913,
0.8163772821,
-0.6494818926,
0.4830966592,
0.3376832604,
-0.4298705459,
-0.7951116562,
0.2038352937,
-0.5868207216,
-0.6720734835,
0.472443223,
0.165727511,
-0.2541587353,
-0.009291023,
-0.4315283298,
-0.8764441609,
0.5795868635,
0.8344550133,
-0.7366669774,
-0.3319694996,
0.1173205078,
0.7883782983,
-0.0043298011,
0.4363606572,
0.8508850932,
0.6160255075,
-0.380602479,
-0.6592870951,
-0.0013017273,
-0.348707974,
-0.1334707439,
0.0340191573,
-0.2386435419,
0.7911131382,
-0.3516353965,
-0.5263209939,
-0.2680675685,
0.242694363,
-0.255261153,
0.0963680521,
0.5629476905,
0.5726259947,
0.6803504229,
0.0517726727,
1.3073801994,
-0.4887248278,
0.1744217724,
0.9584578872,
0.1630141586,
0.7441983819,
0.4178498387,
-0.4142522216,
0.4945368767,
0.8463120461,
0.4801925421,
0.6385363936,
0.214802742,
-0.0438395292,
-0.1579119563,
0.0309342444,
-0.2017227858,
0.1622276753,
0.3168544471,
-0.396278888,
0.138840422,
0.0947242752,
-0.2990591228,
-0.128435567,
-0.2223564684,
0.8219669461,
0.0213042218,
-0.9451792836,
0.5148710012,
0.055375006,
0.1762752384,
-0.3322766721,
0.2210857123,
-0.2573119998,
0.1793641895,
-0.1177768111,
-1.1887632608,
0.1514545679,
-0.2850836217,
-0.3417122364,
-0.0722945184,
0.7571717501,
-0.5225481987,
-0.251779139,
0.5632922649,
0.6710727215,
0.36093086,
-0.2670188844,
-0.5285602212,
-0.1025431156,
-0.1572886556,
-0.4337177277,
-0.112277478,
0.7192443013,
0.5582180023,
0.5006589293,
0.2909860015,
0.5427899361,
0.2387851775,
0.2449322492,
0.4339764416,
-0.7265121937,
-0.8665558696,
-1.1990388632,
0.3754889667,
0.0077941255,
-0.2234067917,
0.1832264215,
0.2578612566,
0.907358408,
0.1347036064,
1.0064142942,
-0.1162056997,
0.3418526351,
-0.7498722076,
0.5822983384,
-0.4239137173,
0.2641294301,
0.0024802249,
-0.9850704074,
0.0282417424,
0.8528561592,
-0.4406732321,
0.0409772918,
1.0138136148,
0.4536705315,
-0.4434097707,
0.2184283882,
0.3054443896,
0.4217001796,
-0.0335145332,
0.9296870232,
0.808458209,
-0.0648397654,
0.482054919,
-0.3333822489,
-0.1468975544,
-0.2768063247,
-0.5284079313,
-0.963686645,
-0.6310626268,
0.1098697931,
-0.2208070904,
-0.0319960602,
0.4248447418,
0.7502097487,
-0.4642905593,
-0.3856414258,
-0.4839062393,
0.1887929887,
-0.0755881444,
-0.2819879353,
0.1664022505,
-0.4230059683,
-0.4169583917,
0.3089143336,
0.4727444649,
0.070914492,
-0.3849702477,
-0.2035993934,
-0.0979151949,
0.4837389588,
0.6164662242,
0.1771966964,
-0.6803112626,
-0.1443832219,
0.0725383535,
-0.2168694288,
0.1826025099,
0.8925936818,
-0.536174953,
0.6392673254,
0.7848868966,
0.7153458595,
0.5357868671,
-0.2608117461,
0.5735259056,
-0.6562194824,
0.017791912,
0.4368320107,
0.3980334699,
0.3214900792,
-0.3610663414,
0.4688043296,
0.07517232,
-0.4699200392,
-0.8319293857,
0.3728788197,
-0.4705292881,
-0.8112528324,
1.0009338856,
0.0350639671,
-0.3253386319,
-0.2068293542,
-0.1991486251,
0.1033086106,
-0.2959876955,
1.0416378975,
1.0671442747,
-0.2890830934,
-0.1764981598,
-0.4944160879,
0.480764091,
0.5806289315,
-0.8825925589,
0.0116288988,
0.3619596958,
0.0539209619,
0.2927781641,
0.7636306882,
0.4170880318,
0.3460023403,
0.1201370135,
-0.1915926933,
0.3097477257,
-0.553178072,
-0.2592769563,
0.3309596181,
0.1674390286,
0.2111731917
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08213v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08213v1
|
Interpreting Latent Student Knowledge Representations in Programming Assignments
| 2024-05-13T22:01:03 | 2024-05-13T22:01:03 |
Nigel Fernandez, Andrew Lan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Recent advances in artificial intelligence for education leverage generative
large language models, including using them to predict open-ended student
responses rather than their correctness only. However, the black-box nature of
these models limits the interpretability of the learned student knowledge
representations. In this paper, we conduct a first exploration into
interpreting latent student knowledge representations by presenting InfoOIRT,
an Information regularized Open-ended Item Response Theory model, which
encourages the latent student knowledge states to be interpretable while being
able to generate student-written code for open-ended programming questions.
InfoOIRT maximizes the mutual information between a fixed subset of latent
knowledge states enforced with simple prior distributions and generated student
code, which encourages the model to learn disentangled representations of
salient syntactic and semantic code features including syntactic styles,
mastery of programming skills, and code structures. Through experiments on a
real-world programming education dataset, we show that InfoOIRT can both
accurately generate student code and lead to interpretable student knowledge
representations.
|
[
-0.1236727983,
-0.6920550466,
0.4039366841,
0.0740347579,
0.0762789547,
0.2967331707,
-0.2119355053,
-0.1055984348,
-0.1118742153,
0.193381846,
-0.3584298491,
-0.3618977964,
-0.4012992382,
-0.1219440475,
-0.3708282411,
1.3935827017,
-0.0787081122,
-0.2349676043,
-0.3935887218,
0.2151354551,
-0.4322273731,
-0.5983287692,
-0.3024959266,
-0.0874682143,
0.3223084211,
0.6990207434,
0.5846723318,
0.3205173314,
0.6674238443,
0.0841122121,
0.4042988718,
-0.583522141,
-0.7067573071,
-0.2564190924,
-0.1897605062,
-0.6668082476,
-0.2738879919,
0.2341702431,
0.389480561,
0.9126055241,
-0.145666644,
0.2589531541,
0.2373576164,
0.4673612118,
-0.3750102222,
0.5345105529,
-0.4951995015,
-0.0444035754,
-0.0028863887,
-0.2736052871,
-0.6910005212,
-0.2478524595,
0.0984991938,
-0.6209905148,
0.1357477754,
-0.267598629,
0.7355554104,
0.5242035389,
-0.1205579266,
-0.458231926,
-0.9749726653,
0.6630991101,
-0.5322811604,
0.46043396,
0.4972578287,
0.4655013382,
-0.1175829768,
-0.7433730364,
-0.7855724692,
-0.1450296789,
-0.1936498135,
0.5080786347,
-0.145917654,
0.2416640818,
0.3366573453,
0.5732352734,
-0.8596122265,
-0.1815959215,
-0.5353743434,
0.162896499,
0.2901996672,
-0.054360915,
0.2361222655,
-0.0609908998,
-0.5049836636,
-0.0368033201,
-0.4302501082,
0.2816314399,
0.5138777494,
0.082064949,
-0.1864409298,
0.8910818696,
0.1531536728,
0.8988729715,
-0.2202143967,
0.1259616017,
-0.1505282521,
-0.1436552107,
-0.1278363168,
-0.1779089123,
0.2527893484,
0.2567633092,
0.2142492831,
-0.2911138833,
-0.1670472175,
0.1695459336,
0.362747252,
-0.8344796896,
-0.5720808506,
0.1270733029,
-0.6499246359,
-0.2338862717,
0.287191987,
-0.5672976375,
-0.1171122268,
-0.3962880969,
0.2362052798,
-0.201570645,
-0.3274139762,
0.219236508,
0.1008166,
0.1459935457,
0.1310263127,
-0.3610624373,
0.3104254305,
0.2848279476,
0.540109992,
-0.0043848739,
-0.2356462777,
-0.3195462525,
0.0693593472,
-0.1596114337,
0.3177760541,
-0.9021363854,
0.0838190317,
-0.2372625321,
-0.2462899685,
-0.1269163489,
-0.0895913765,
-0.1402247995,
-0.8990231156,
0.2489553541,
0.1868600845,
-0.6156566739,
-0.0984361246,
0.1047522947,
-0.501185298,
0.7186650038,
0.8225739002,
-1.0060296059,
0.0868686363,
-0.7427344918,
0.1047899574,
0.115043208,
-0.54993999,
-0.1086043343,
0.0040282514,
-0.3704529405,
0.4289099574,
-0.0687690824,
0.338024497,
0.0014377525,
-0.5626196265,
0.5127216578,
-0.2838187218,
0.4793664515,
0.3348950446,
-0.1443581432,
-0.1211987138,
-0.6410785317,
-0.1518889964,
0.2860330641,
-0.604812324,
-0.3041826487,
-0.1958295107,
-0.1186837181,
0.0420670994,
0.354434669,
-0.478302896,
0.6803061366,
-0.1632455438,
0.1588026136,
0.8442052007,
0.213671118,
0.3819404244,
0.021379713,
0.892621994,
0.0191228781,
-0.0621961281,
-0.0939234793,
-0.4846029878,
-0.3790726066,
0.1397798359,
0.1903174222,
0.5408947468,
-1.118598938,
-0.0689425692,
-0.0690559819,
-0.018976815,
-0.4942040741,
0.0319961794,
0.3237643838,
0.5727969408,
0.3207201362,
-0.1262903064,
-0.3982077837,
-0.6503666043,
-0.2575984895,
-0.4231523275,
-0.0150053697,
0.2327709347,
0.4911423624,
-0.3272330761,
0.9719409347,
-0.8316684961,
-0.0521467999,
-0.1648905128,
0.4091064334,
0.3632343113,
0.6072182059,
0.542047739,
-0.8229958415,
-0.2053536177,
-0.1811961532,
-0.7003060579,
0.2029263526,
-0.4180485606,
-0.1820164025,
-0.2448192835,
0.4343678355,
0.0970903784,
0.9132358432,
0.4577980936,
-0.6744278669,
0.5306485295,
0.0069335145,
0.1259543002,
-1.0033941269,
0.1066429317,
-0.2523456216,
0.0117683215,
-0.2914500535,
0.1913089305,
0.0719090626,
-0.4634293914,
0.040914081,
0.4096236527,
-0.2861311138,
-0.1905619353,
-0.1180259883,
-0.0070215091,
-0.1735914052,
0.6344766617,
0.0100477897,
0.9362359643,
0.3329663277,
-0.4821303487,
0.3090366721,
0.2316904515,
-0.3587110043,
0.4809568524,
-0.6770058274,
0.2731333375,
-0.3239096105,
-0.1365515441,
-1.0408986807,
-0.4005166888,
-0.0434859172,
-0.7464772463,
0.3697442114,
-0.518384099,
-0.2617424726,
-0.376083374,
-0.0366745703,
0.748293221,
0.4526822567,
-0.5063342452,
0.2357846797,
-0.0600134172,
-0.2749821246,
-0.6809308529,
-0.6354824305,
-0.2609879673,
0.2805621028,
-0.2359966785,
-0.0127970101,
-0.3569345176,
-0.3843314648,
0.4249571264,
-0.1719066352,
-0.3689553142,
0.4315806627,
0.1830452085,
0.4278191328,
-0.4260717928,
0.3478710353,
0.1144967601,
-0.0870283842,
-0.0267625209,
-0.5932443142,
0.3039119244,
-0.3411440253,
-0.6501622796,
-0.0068151262,
0.1097163409,
0.2911393046,
-0.2519178391,
0.8877651691,
0.4365713,
-0.4148510695,
-0.0963326693,
-0.0223581996,
-0.4669908285,
-0.3569523394,
0.540317595,
-0.4384047687,
-0.6222659945,
0.2958752513,
0.0315562971,
0.2299498022,
-0.0434342623,
0.068902947,
-0.1943594813,
0.8809182048,
0.939756155,
0.1053571999,
0.6227243543,
-0.688115716,
0.4939157963,
-0.8199778199,
-0.3693065047,
-0.3703973591,
-0.122270599,
-0.0912883356,
-0.3923806846,
0.3039486706,
0.6125850081,
-0.1721296012,
0.1508914232,
-0.6031601429,
0.672547996,
0.4239512086,
0.0439631939,
0.2195952088,
0.1129539907,
0.0112213092,
-0.102682516,
-0.6044598818,
-0.6357347369,
1.2140959501,
0.2578540444,
1.0312170982,
0.2925245464,
0.5709082484,
0.5103448629,
0.4322453141,
-0.8426294327,
0.1208638847,
-0.0139924176,
-0.1210672334,
-0.1095678061,
-0.5755030513,
-0.8078823686,
-0.3612784743,
0.1202829033,
-0.6865460873,
0.0467813797,
0.013303116,
-0.2402608246,
0.2791891098,
-0.8765907288,
1.0222979784,
-0.1048199907,
-0.3023144603,
0.0937624723,
-0.4555425942,
0.186317116,
0.0184446704,
0.3563594222,
0.4082722068,
0.1600109488,
1.0513029099,
-0.3500925004,
0.7087036371,
-0.3016032875,
0.0162155572,
0.3783940077,
0.4614589214,
0.3120382726,
0.2925776839,
-0.1834065765,
-0.2503145337,
-0.0651638433,
-0.7809750438,
-0.8180778027,
0.6423951387,
-0.8865943551,
-0.4945905805,
-0.3545889258,
-0.8783006668,
-0.0087321363,
0.078679204,
0.1230434403,
0.5471320748,
0.1472933292,
0.1177386716,
0.7711148262,
-0.2984557748,
0.0671834648,
0.4441227317,
-0.259868443,
0.2245398164,
1.1796805859,
0.0301367342,
0.3664599657,
0.3123852611,
-0.0374816507,
-0.0315729231,
-0.5078601241,
-0.5109648705,
0.0625243038,
-0.958445549,
-0.0651836097,
-0.5605812669,
-0.1234963685,
-0.3802134693,
-0.2711180151,
-0.0338535793,
-0.508410573,
-0.2594358325,
-0.2200859934,
0.1548894495,
1.2742571831,
0.1275789142,
0.4110300839,
-0.3854280412,
0.2001225799,
0.430575341,
0.4477101266,
-0.1245717928,
-0.4363958836,
-0.5445373058,
0.1059334353,
-0.0816004798,
-1.1813575029,
-0.2074965537,
0.0753434151,
0.5372443795,
0.4956823587,
0.3009819388,
0.2335705459,
0.2566200793,
0.8363084793,
-0.0144906119,
-0.6929326653,
0.7348136306,
-0.1551152766,
0.2268051207,
0.3016777337,
0.510791719,
-0.3711645007,
-0.7076888084,
-0.6775473356,
-0.6636731029,
0.9924260974,
0.330088079,
0.031939853,
0.1096679345,
0.4555189312,
0.3496016562,
0.4056741297,
-0.9317731857,
-0.2899470627,
-0.5536310673,
-0.7102308273,
0.2376902103,
-0.2413102984,
0.1190799326,
0.0916864574,
0.4765628576,
-0.2202266157,
0.6024500728,
-0.1386753917,
-0.2565522492,
-0.0022702077,
0.40637514,
0.3146432042,
0.8786761761,
-0.3337616622,
0.3088117838,
-0.4893832207,
-0.6140092015,
-0.0620877035,
0.2227701694,
-0.1406426877,
-0.3148626685,
0.5427260399,
0.414855808,
-0.0387265868,
-0.6576140523,
0.8625275493,
-0.3539913893,
0.3084618151,
-0.1845861971,
0.0369148031,
-0.3023564816,
0.0739905611,
0.439094305,
0.1967863888,
0.1139189601,
-0.6208736897,
0.294754684,
-0.0057858103,
-0.4857295156,
-0.5108744502,
0.6847268939,
-0.1356969476,
0.0105611347,
0.717315793,
-0.3331393301,
-0.6337808371,
0.8469561338,
0.6209770441,
0.4204113781,
-0.2273616493,
0.3372621834,
0.4161401391,
0.3404759169,
0.5571994185,
0.6446738839,
-0.298848033,
-0.4116201401,
-0.3970916569,
-0.4859088659,
-0.2531945407,
0.2358810306,
-1.0239882469,
-0.1325186193,
-0.5401171446,
0.3272587061,
-0.230864495,
-0.2922137976,
-1.0032293797,
0.156548962,
-0.1631465405,
0.6128156781,
-1.0070222616,
0.7082066536,
1.2965599298,
-0.9171155691,
-1.1699601412,
0.2991758287,
-0.3661789,
-0.6247724295,
0.8986255527,
-0.1711413711,
0.2110065073,
0.1332159191,
-0.839204669,
-0.6925200224,
0.7356114984,
0.295183152,
-0.2960503995,
-0.2813880742,
0.0452299677,
0.360488832,
-0.372402966,
0.5177576542,
0.2566833496,
0.1667751968,
0.0572446287,
-0.5525227785,
-0.1256614923,
-0.3751189709,
-0.142191112,
0.0512152202,
-0.1499799639,
1.162974596,
-0.565659821,
-0.3171708584,
-0.2949538529,
0.5949336886,
-0.142165184,
0.3802570999,
0.1324955523,
0.2359409928,
0.7814335227,
-0.0758753121,
1.0729037523,
-0.3959183395,
0.4741879404,
1.2624249458,
0.2352359444,
0.5042819977,
0.4470953345,
-0.2974513173,
0.7765874267,
0.5861185193,
0.1891901046,
0.5033915043,
0.26195997,
-0.0075921742,
-0.1243970394,
-0.13192527,
-0.5619691014,
0.1535579264,
0.4862765372,
-0.1902628243,
-0.2016472518,
0.5421203971,
-0.172592029,
0.1587836593,
-0.1741479933,
0.844851613,
-0.0833121762,
-0.5145378709,
0.481895417,
-0.0743484944,
0.2321452349,
-0.2713795602,
-0.8238924742,
-0.1983489692,
0.1668387055,
-0.546662569,
-1.1120493412,
0.1853637695,
0.1674700826,
-0.2411485165,
-0.0365097336,
0.6640065312,
-0.6075984836,
-0.2311358899,
0.1074671969,
0.3292513788,
0.463240087,
0.0269349832,
-0.5870860815,
-0.1656889766,
0.2647864819,
-0.2442114353,
0.004329016,
0.4283423722,
0.0229968335,
0.5081552863,
0.4036509693,
0.0359924249,
0.1679230481,
-0.1276095659,
1.078538537,
-0.3668571115,
-0.5311860442,
-0.4194030464,
0.5726547837,
0.2296931744,
0.0374679379,
0.5299403071,
0.6593570113,
1.2064150572,
-0.2241985053,
1.2096765041,
-0.3030645549,
0.2596159577,
-0.4794424474,
0.4642485976,
-0.3762700558,
0.5934586525,
-0.1790468544,
-0.8226563931,
0.2895468771,
0.8485583663,
-0.5543116927,
0.0198535621,
0.6049072742,
0.3977988064,
-0.3437606096,
0.0226628203,
0.2443606555,
0.4033724666,
0.3430757225,
0.7931323051,
1.0839854479,
-0.3436937332,
0.6117162108,
-0.4981369674,
-0.6725414395,
-0.3057685196,
-0.315979749,
-1.0205715895,
-0.7303850651,
-0.392475754,
-0.6438783407,
-0.1802942306,
0.7858660221,
0.430089891,
-0.7135067582,
-0.0602369122,
-0.1162715033,
0.361120522,
-0.1964839101,
-0.3890165985,
0.4146475196,
-0.2029967159,
-0.4537811875,
0.2590417862,
-0.0206480529,
0.4257521927,
-0.2162583321,
-0.1578314602,
0.0609611049,
-0.0835469216,
0.4328412712,
0.1041715965,
-0.3054098189,
-0.2369458675,
0.2038462311,
-0.1276293695,
-0.0516701937,
0.9766740799,
-0.7727395892,
0.7807037234,
0.3599152863,
0.5587692857,
0.4159654677,
0.081177853,
0.4339545071,
-1.0031154156,
0.2666894495,
0.5418376923,
0.1160620898,
0.054208193,
-0.597132504,
0.6839094758,
0.1436633319,
-0.4261737764,
-0.7929731607,
0.3072521389,
-0.7318118215,
-0.3500077724,
0.8402925134,
-0.7460404634,
-0.029302692,
-0.4131736159,
-0.3058981299,
0.371373117,
-0.2885829806,
0.7029275298,
0.4796104133,
-0.1563332677,
-0.1026511639,
-0.726772964,
0.4101216495,
0.1078398451,
-0.8587079048,
0.0246382467,
0.4094689786,
0.1399563253,
0.2093700171,
0.6580346823,
0.103276439,
0.4125374556,
0.0505156927,
0.1248722523,
-0.3690356314,
-0.5836023092,
0.0397652648,
-0.010604443,
0.4382531047,
-0.1931660473
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08209v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08209v1
|
Who's in and who's out? A case study of multimodal CLIP-filtering in DataComp
| 2024-05-13T21:53:06 | 2024-05-13T21:53:06 |
Rachel Hong, William Agnew, Tadayoshi Kohno, Jamie Morgenstern
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
As training datasets become increasingly drawn from unstructured,
uncontrolled environments such as the web, researchers and industry
practitioners have increasingly relied upon data filtering techniques to
"filter out the noise" of web-scraped data. While datasets have been widely
shown to reflect the biases and values of their creators, in this paper we
contribute to an emerging body of research that assesses the filters used to
create these datasets. We show that image-text data filtering also has biases
and is value-laden, encoding specific notions of what is counted as
"high-quality" data. In our work, we audit a standard approach of image-text
CLIP-filtering on the academic benchmark DataComp's CommonPool by analyzing
discrepancies of filtering through various annotation techniques across
multiple modalities of image, text, and website source. We find that data
relating to several imputed demographic groups -- such as LGBTQ+ people, older
women, and younger men -- are associated with higher rates of exclusion.
Moreover, we demonstrate cases of exclusion amplification: not only are certain
marginalized groups already underrepresented in the unfiltered data, but
CLIP-filtering excludes data from these groups at higher rates. The
data-filtering step in the machine learning pipeline can therefore exacerbate
representation disparities already present in the data-gathering step,
especially when existing filters are designed to optimize a specifically-chosen
downstream performance metric like zero-shot image classification accuracy.
Finally, we show that the NSFW filter fails to remove sexually-explicit content
from CommonPool, and that CLIP-filtering includes several categories of
copyrighted content at high rates. Our conclusions point to a need for
fundamental changes in dataset creation and filtering practices.
|
[
-0.9009529352,
-0.3780128956,
0.3791721761,
-0.0554787554,
-0.3953419328,
0.2823391855,
0.0767153651,
-0.7045027018,
0.0058146561,
0.581212461,
-0.6965224147,
-0.3859095573,
-0.8102177382,
0.2559018731,
-0.6811632514,
0.8715228438,
-0.0205080509,
0.1265226305,
-0.6691007614,
-0.2608962357,
-0.4448049366,
-0.707881093,
-0.0199985523,
-0.4132434428,
0.1909849197,
0.5507796407,
0.8393474817,
0.6448361278,
0.6772343516,
0.2033950388,
0.0867230743,
0.0799054876,
-0.5912721157,
-0.0413288549,
-0.1691178977,
-0.3111029267,
0.0628459677,
0.320612222,
0.5146271586,
0.7748689055,
0.2867725194,
0.0982073992,
0.1962912232,
0.800162375,
-1.003281951,
-0.1678909063,
-0.6990922093,
0.3360816538,
-0.514813602,
-0.2061986923,
-0.1933557093,
-0.2382591665,
0.0213097688,
-0.4788960516,
0.56768924,
-0.0219283812,
0.6838854551,
0.3776234686,
-0.491248101,
-0.1777407676,
-0.5742019415,
1.0414075851,
-0.3058536053,
0.392244488,
0.7751039267,
0.1194017902,
-0.2905274928,
-0.6405611634,
-0.4901161194,
0.4179037809,
0.0214229058,
0.1661440283,
-0.4629638791,
-0.2086900324,
0.3770968914,
0.237219274,
-0.2809005976,
0.2100934386,
-0.7374375463,
-0.0275056288,
0.6507383585,
-0.1735570282,
0.2301758975,
-0.1268166006,
-0.490359813,
0.0032728226,
-0.6638572216,
0.0988351926,
0.6326345205,
0.1411273628,
0.28481251,
0.5539281964,
0.060924381,
0.3205705881,
-0.1081260741,
0.0425422266,
0.1660125405,
-0.1963578463,
-0.081582427,
0.0330038369,
0.6070030332,
0.7875968814,
0.3842915595,
-0.0149663854,
-0.0710883513,
-0.0262715705,
0.1450854391,
-0.866327107,
-0.2351231873,
-0.009392078,
-0.8289192319,
-0.2196352035,
0.4552844763,
-1.1349083185,
-0.6220799088,
-0.1926814616,
0.323800683,
-0.1311417371,
-0.2185883075,
0.00654139,
-0.6758806109,
-0.1321548522,
0.1822130233,
-0.5903902054,
0.6003880501,
0.3631899357,
0.7865623832,
-0.470041424,
-0.1944417059,
-0.6137066483,
-0.0373939425,
-0.0363397822,
0.8378452063,
-0.7524190545,
-0.4021164477,
0.1921940744,
0.0639220476,
0.1894741058,
-0.7442697883,
0.45252496,
-0.5349474549,
0.1868632883,
-0.4446444809,
-0.737210691,
-0.2994021773,
-0.114080146,
-0.9598682523,
0.983353138,
0.0812858194,
-0.8062926531,
0.7601624131,
-0.7325268984,
-0.0430947058,
0.1243240535,
-0.2294134647,
-0.4106471539,
-0.1105671376,
0.6506686807,
0.3148500025,
-0.3361949325,
-0.0436293408,
-0.7742099166,
-0.637275815,
0.6845632195,
-0.3892216682,
0.6842158437,
0.0677528828,
-0.0745653957,
-0.2209331244,
-0.6616487503,
0.0756755844,
-0.1088905334,
0.0361310877,
-0.3840281069,
0.1620994508,
0.3504721224,
0.4077301919,
-0.32444489,
-0.6178766489,
-0.2508765757,
0.3917363882,
0.7652374506,
0.8029816151,
0.4148492217,
0.2903011143,
-0.4966872931,
0.5440404415,
0.0577783026,
0.4574716985,
-0.1727549881,
-0.5817450285,
-0.2057134509,
-0.5622972846,
0.1479102671,
0.0477218926,
-0.6210689545,
0.1419032216,
0.2322293371,
-0.3410670757,
-0.2039005309,
0.2295625657,
0.0940354839,
0.3533792496,
0.487667948,
-0.7869313955,
-0.4834298193,
-0.8327133656,
-0.3360722363,
-0.0598256066,
-0.0257265326,
0.2551674843,
0.6236162186,
-0.1491254717,
1.3497287035,
-0.5449900627,
-0.4923619032,
0.0577905886,
0.0673896,
0.2739311755,
0.4883778393,
0.4942389727,
-1.0647739172,
-0.2187968642,
-0.5989810824,
-0.6779738665,
-0.2541146278,
0.0896241888,
-0.197380349,
-0.2102796584,
0.5386050344,
-0.2232314646,
0.7285109758,
0.4779943526,
-0.1639139503,
0.4610491395,
-0.0591122657,
0.2656686008,
-0.4451314509,
-0.0009661952,
0.3321886957,
-0.3353440762,
-0.3487212062,
-0.3605569899,
-0.0355721004,
-0.3125807047,
-0.4826156497,
0.0802882537,
-0.5791302323,
-0.1850037128,
-0.3025062382,
0.2447323203,
0.403170675,
0.3768577874,
-0.080556713,
0.7093085051,
0.5426818728,
-0.6904620528,
0.3740011752,
0.4293139577,
-0.5548776984,
0.8592407107,
-0.4228612185,
0.2515480518,
-0.2635063529,
0.4912619293,
-0.8319049478,
-0.4626017213,
0.1777236015,
-0.2135202736,
-0.1268308014,
-0.6503728628,
-0.4355638623,
-0.3834313154,
-0.6333297491,
0.5735198259,
0.3677805364,
-0.7691616416,
0.0573713779,
0.9013578892,
0.1452972293,
-0.5994594097,
-0.6888698339,
0.00619923,
-0.3546847999,
-0.5454652309,
0.4625393152,
0.0143490992,
-0.1693841815,
0.1735854298,
-0.0600279681,
-0.8975924253,
-0.0238063931,
0.4965635538,
0.2094494402,
0.287389487,
0.2954217494,
0.0434633866,
0.3257334232,
0.1672594696,
0.0289602745,
0.3123046458,
0.3347337246,
-0.8406839967,
-0.3688717484,
0.8301723599,
0.617888689,
-0.1841326505,
0.2711499631,
0.5779243112,
-0.2919906676,
-0.0773340613,
-0.4348931909,
-0.3763520122,
-0.4050792158,
0.4046235383,
0.1956687868,
-0.6578608751,
0.4941737652,
-0.1119360849,
0.1065085903,
0.2662645876,
0.0967156217,
-0.3999141753,
0.9084464908,
0.6133286357,
0.173113957,
0.7937657833,
-0.2254553288,
0.0796277896,
-0.6983761787,
-0.105341427,
-0.5194032788,
-0.4821074009,
-0.7606626749,
-0.1874880195,
0.5113953948,
0.0852248371,
0.0280107372,
0.1891191155,
-0.5514450669,
0.691957593,
0.820536077,
0.5173788071,
0.3987267315,
-0.0370074995,
0.3810886145,
-0.3845679164,
-0.6752074957,
-0.28929618,
1.3649361134,
0.2710953057,
0.9043433666,
-0.1152511686,
0.3563455641,
0.7953140736,
0.010431191,
-0.5059360266,
0.3341880441,
-0.3793005943,
-0.849255383,
-0.0397865474,
-0.0434108786,
-0.8283720613,
0.414059639,
-0.3967190087,
-0.5655247569,
0.8379452229,
0.0412083119,
0.0448054969,
0.5575437546,
-0.5832440853,
0.747346282,
0.07440871,
-0.4057019055,
-0.297449857,
-0.4959832728,
0.4407997727,
-0.2784717381,
0.3996569216,
-0.5755351782,
0.1681061536,
0.9176430106,
-0.4826073349,
0.9216316342,
-0.3216511309,
0.4328475893,
0.4613798261,
-0.260920167,
0.216823414,
-0.012797202,
0.1545835137,
0.539547205,
0.1855267286,
-0.2797731161,
-0.3819764853,
0.3025484383,
-0.7101221085,
-0.1316178143,
-0.3777808845,
-0.2856266499,
-0.1075469404,
0.0321670324,
0.465525955,
0.7418909669,
-0.0045853374,
0.3963009715,
0.3930790126,
-0.0805067495,
0.6299150586,
0.1289008409,
-0.1101338267,
-0.6603182554,
0.7167415619,
0.3651743531,
0.0077445665,
-0.0790015534,
0.0145276273,
-0.4381307364,
-0.2642404735,
-0.582331419,
0.0707164407,
-0.9401059151,
-0.2180328369,
-0.2775992453,
-0.115949735,
-0.3303665817,
-0.1107007563,
-0.1721570194,
-0.2767871618,
-0.4473597407,
0.2779299319,
0.2936011851,
0.6028310061,
-0.2106717974,
0.2595742941,
-0.7837451696,
0.2001493424,
0.3727439344,
0.34342435,
-0.3965727091,
-0.3379184306,
-0.2775974572,
-0.2453148812,
-0.4921015501,
-0.8901437521,
0.1758185327,
0.3473494649,
0.6205325127,
0.4092995822,
0.3451448381,
0.7067629099,
-0.2339961231,
0.8437656164,
0.2277657837,
-1.0631372929,
0.3125606775,
0.0357991606,
0.0889201909,
0.6454718709,
0.4134210944,
-0.8092958927,
-0.3900847137,
-0.4258106947,
-0.8866464496,
0.7384708524,
0.2566451132,
0.0785583407,
0.159892574,
0.1517366022,
0.4677965343,
0.489766717,
-0.5481982827,
-0.1190255359,
-0.3455370963,
0.1516959518,
0.4246412814,
-0.3418756723,
-0.0689936653,
-0.1417093426,
0.4884214103,
-0.1682801247,
0.1629675031,
0.2704867721,
-0.2685028911,
-0.2534833252,
0.0767537057,
0.173743248,
0.9093200564,
-0.2124382555,
0.0212264098,
-0.2102773935,
-0.7452741861,
0.0311210416,
-0.1523129195,
-0.1788383424,
0.2839109004,
0.4147659242,
0.5963668823,
0.1841589957,
-0.7270159125,
0.7855263352,
-0.1838445663,
-0.1380817294,
-0.3172259331,
0.0641168505,
-0.7894647121,
0.0482737683,
0.562889874,
0.3258981407,
0.3250017762,
-0.5097483397,
0.3940631747,
0.3838373423,
-0.5213257074,
-0.2350898385,
0.5589966178,
0.2777439654,
0.1602810174,
0.7575997114,
0.3821463585,
-0.3693558574,
0.4972096086,
0.3470448852,
0.713062346,
0.2440548092,
0.2887176871,
0.2552871406,
0.0867833942,
0.0034087091,
-0.0359124802,
-0.1488162428,
-0.8127716184,
-0.4614979029,
-0.10666392,
-0.8088684082,
0.0942325369,
-1.0270084143,
0.4005402625,
-0.2884748578,
-0.5057669878,
0.1463385522,
-0.2023926526,
-0.7314646244,
0.1605105698,
0.0527192429,
0.6451440454,
-1.1527893543,
0.4258933663,
0.5520060658,
-0.2415624559,
-0.1177637056,
0.1256444454,
0.1929944456,
-0.4899824262,
0.5055897832,
0.2340327799,
0.0263180435,
-0.2536783814,
-0.8996884823,
-0.9385733008,
0.6326544285,
0.4649745524,
-0.0212048739,
0.2021481693,
0.0826065317,
0.120828867,
-0.2996542752,
0.3235755265,
0.583358407,
0.3582386672,
0.0850320235,
-0.5588848591,
-0.3086023331,
-0.1345917284,
-0.0204762053,
0.2083172053,
-0.5948044658,
1.0718346834,
0.1652012765,
-0.3453165293,
-0.4720156789,
0.2977936864,
0.0574813038,
0.4527851045,
0.6591690183,
0.231605351,
0.7753853202,
-0.0197778698,
0.6940522194,
0.1966275722,
0.254045248,
0.9236328602,
-0.3074429631,
0.5429234505,
0.632748127,
-0.2614421844,
0.3724168241,
0.6570635438,
-0.4228291512,
0.6591163874,
-0.0451147482,
-0.1332209557,
-0.3248187602,
-0.4340255558,
-0.1211977825,
0.6628034711,
0.0969779268,
-0.405926913,
-0.4354252815,
0.180793643,
-0.0355957858,
0.1551260054,
-0.2187220305,
0.6169570684,
-0.1077838242,
-0.3736203313,
0.0970455185,
-0.113224946,
0.4740491509,
-0.2223397493,
-0.0785561502,
-0.272693187,
0.0821787938,
-0.3950784504,
-1.1814951897,
0.1792815924,
0.238275528,
-0.4480729997,
-0.2757303119,
0.810949862,
-0.3793189824,
-0.1344857365,
0.2499021888,
0.3861815929,
0.6352893114,
-0.486548245,
-0.5876466632,
0.2477543652,
-0.120729275,
0.2195553035,
0.4396316707,
0.1978296191,
-0.2476829886,
0.5078090429,
0.8197788,
0.0364224501,
0.0979067236,
0.1217731163,
0.9685739279,
-0.4707912803,
-0.4542656243,
-0.9251106381,
0.2228216976,
-0.4334870577,
-0.5760083795,
0.6967235208,
0.5720752478,
1.0052173138,
-0.0168013964,
0.7828454375,
0.0977088138,
0.3766093552,
-0.3346719146,
0.6491219997,
-0.3753040135,
-0.2463492304,
-0.5253877044,
-1.0287336111,
-0.2219400108,
0.3201150298,
0.0906009823,
-0.0481089354,
0.5755979419,
0.4908466637,
-0.1021357402,
0.2809882462,
0.383323878,
-0.2700657248,
0.6281718016,
0.2763429284,
0.8118398786,
-0.4623546302,
0.644536972,
-0.5318959951,
-0.1868886203,
-0.1894504279,
-0.9995826483,
-0.8359421492,
-0.706071198,
-0.5109081864,
-0.0889335126,
-0.2943542004,
0.8454313278,
1.064486146,
-0.7425611019,
-0.2112650573,
0.1576087624,
0.3266370893,
-0.3697377741,
-0.1913713515,
0.1113376543,
-0.0927876756,
-0.8066533208,
0.2102102935,
0.2525494993,
-0.0486448295,
-0.4116023183,
0.3806350231,
0.0467330404,
-0.0283797551,
0.3179493546,
0.1948713511,
-0.2951202989,
-0.1697771698,
-0.356341809,
0.1192723811,
0.2808597982,
0.9141194224,
-0.7927591205,
0.5080638528,
0.2571826279,
0.3390981853,
0.5066719055,
0.1901557446,
0.2466975749,
-0.932734549,
0.1269665062,
0.2118948698,
0.4924361706,
0.4127778113,
-0.2518370748,
0.5292545557,
0.6861487031,
-0.7662449479,
-1.1228990555,
0.1293027252,
-0.5801823139,
-0.1772672683,
0.758234024,
-0.0880669877,
-0.3032167256,
-0.4909158349,
-0.1113808155,
0.0117254863,
-0.5007674098,
0.8155699968,
0.8451581597,
-0.3148652911,
-0.2481128722,
-0.6677097678,
0.3162748814,
-0.1499184072,
-0.7251574397,
0.0759003907,
0.7510294318,
0.2437184453,
-0.1824314743,
0.5059217811,
-0.1675536782,
0.2644375265,
-0.1838451326,
0.1376871169,
-0.0512911528,
-0.1926646233,
-0.1874930114,
0.3421068788,
-0.3539049327,
-0.6069302559
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08172v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08172v1
|
CANTONMT: Investigating Back-Translation and Model-Switch Mechanisms for Cantonese-English Neural Machine Translation
| 2024-05-13T20:37:04 | 2024-05-13T20:37:04 |
Kung Yin Hong, Lifeng Han, Riza Batista-Navarro, Goran Nenadic
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper investigates the development and evaluation of machine translation
models from Cantonese to English, where we propose a novel approach to tackle
low-resource language translations. The main objectives of the study are to
develop a model that can effectively translate Cantonese to English and
evaluate it against state-of-the-art commercial models. To achieve this, a new
parallel corpus has been created by combining different available corpora
online with preprocessing and cleaning. In addition, a monolingual Cantonese
dataset has been created through web scraping to aid the synthetic parallel
corpus generation. Following the data collection process, several approaches,
including fine-tuning models, back-translation, and model switch, have been
used. The translation quality of models has been evaluated with multiple
quality metrics, including lexicon-based metrics (SacreBLEU and hLEPOR) and
embedding-space metrics (COMET and BERTscore). Based on the automatic metrics,
the best model is selected and compared against the 2 best commercial
translators using the human evaluation framework HOPES. The best model proposed
in this investigation (NLLB-mBART) with model switch mechanisms has reached
comparable and even better automatic evaluation scores against State-of-the-art
commercial models (Bing and Baidu Translators), with a SacreBLEU score of 16.8
on our test set. Furthermore, an open-source web application has been developed
to allow users to translate between Cantonese and English, with the different
trained models available for effective comparisons between models from this
investigation and users. CANTONMT is available at
https://github.com/kenrickkung/CantoneseTranslation
|
[
-0.2562204599,
-0.4433994889,
0.3105852604,
0.4116789699,
-0.4594241083,
-0.1621863097,
-0.0529813357,
-0.2697913647,
-0.1392430216,
0.7171368599,
-0.1791175157,
-0.2474722862,
-0.5931658745,
0.4875272214,
-0.5829015374,
0.5918526649,
-0.3015189469,
0.4498079121,
0.2872863114,
-0.1175983548,
-0.3225906193,
-0.6300032735,
-0.901912868,
-0.3968503177,
0.3309576809,
0.1307671368,
0.8541225791,
0.5723493099,
0.6659084558,
0.2067539543,
-0.1570405811,
0.1988483369,
-0.4503144324,
-0.5370150208,
-0.1892112494,
-0.4373974204,
-0.7149450183,
0.1060864329,
0.5309804678,
0.7154618502,
-0.0296789743,
0.1933684945,
0.107885778,
0.4412531853,
-0.2752182484,
0.0144225406,
-0.7649005651,
0.0997981727,
-0.0226676911,
-0.3587346375,
-0.6145690084,
-0.3286017179,
-0.2530184984,
-0.2177002579,
-0.0078973342,
0.1697980314,
1.0245594978,
0.2989987731,
-0.7669727206,
-0.0492998697,
-0.4755081236,
1.121516943,
-1.1534137726,
0.5904405713,
0.3341793716,
0.4786611497,
0.1235434487,
-0.6882577538,
-0.2218034565,
-0.5689219236,
-0.1200789437,
0.5837033391,
-0.0753270239,
-0.146980077,
-0.1075884402,
0.2336317301,
-0.4629971087,
0.2908823788,
-0.5750418305,
-0.0255960282,
0.5276567936,
0.3932469189,
0.3832541406,
-0.5394756198,
-0.7011609674,
-0.0711977631,
-0.6254410744,
0.0453675874,
0.2624487877,
0.4848697484,
-0.2087554932,
0.582703054,
0.1359470785,
0.7459189296,
-0.0063876798,
0.173424229,
0.0449022837,
-0.7842770219,
-0.3387115598,
-0.0207316428,
0.9038619399,
0.5276603103,
-0.0522641726,
-0.186143592,
-0.5349759459,
-0.2084812671,
0.1796259135,
-0.8865465522,
0.1416220367,
0.1917318851,
-1.0602062941,
-0.3620733619,
-0.0034140134,
-0.2763658762,
0.0606464408,
-0.3773646057,
0.3322583735,
-0.7282761931,
-0.3443608284,
0.3794083297,
-0.0283477288,
0.0387857072,
0.2815682292,
-0.6996652484,
0.3917349577,
0.6264991164,
1.2065325975,
-0.3166047931,
-0.6359679103,
-0.3728406727,
0.0966472551,
-0.4931029975,
0.4112175107,
-0.102045089,
-0.1664840281,
-0.1183063164,
0.3023596704,
-0.4267047048,
-0.837716639,
0.5063530803,
-0.469315201,
0.0803249776,
0.183610931,
-0.4033536911,
-0.537836194,
0.3840597868,
-0.8398248553,
0.779767096,
0.1448873729,
-0.6161355972,
-0.1947093904,
-0.5066726208,
-0.4630634487,
-0.0199769121,
0.2912039757,
-0.102876544,
0.1847123653,
0.161053732,
0.2993909419,
-0.6794250607,
0.1939603537,
0.1752839684,
-0.4482447505,
0.3631351292,
-0.5770739913,
1.2518182993,
0.3229923546,
-0.2098489255,
0.1780716181,
-0.5700539351,
-0.2080271393,
0.0231974944,
-0.370616138,
-0.4176125228,
-0.0840507746,
0.2566079795,
0.6569184661,
0.3953830004,
-0.3225305378,
-0.056808915,
-0.51325351,
0.8053004742,
0.4291587174,
-0.2678854764,
0.3650560379,
-0.3514712751,
0.702013135,
0.3343604207,
0.3252521753,
-0.0334270447,
-0.6553525329,
-0.4098508954,
-0.0110681728,
0.5235544443,
0.7643244267,
-0.6342788935,
0.3500806391,
0.0235284995,
-0.4291793704,
-1.2304371595,
-0.0171841942,
0.3180475831,
0.5871603489,
0.5916973948,
-0.5507059097,
-0.3153726459,
-0.9269336462,
-0.0090263151,
-0.2307507396,
0.0132956319,
0.3614256084,
0.2622470856,
-0.5489127636,
0.5625754595,
0.1187629029,
-0.1076851562,
-0.3950273395,
0.3865354657,
0.3421403766,
0.4205581844,
0.6871389151,
-0.8439246416,
-0.4461602569,
0.4936524332,
-0.632034719,
-0.3700355291,
-0.4459362328,
-0.2343042195,
0.4022450447,
0.6872549057,
-0.407325536,
0.2178398669,
0.9601767659,
0.1383504868,
0.7706374526,
-0.1447503865,
0.4919811189,
-1.224666357,
0.2403973639,
-0.2578995228,
-0.3018155694,
-0.4173038304,
0.4679778516,
0.3392066658,
-0.0925566405,
-1.0289338827,
0.6762726903,
-0.3369793892,
-0.1095927358,
-0.2977839112,
0.2848275602,
-0.0505437851,
0.1930553019,
-0.1245695055,
0.7275426388,
-0.0082369391,
-0.5191102028,
0.4079849422,
0.2493961751,
-0.1924001127,
0.1286744326,
-0.6001577377,
0.114067927,
0.4859166443,
-0.0974898115,
-0.955162704,
0.2529491782,
0.4108103812,
-0.4285607338,
-0.1452167481,
-0.338861078,
-0.5454441905,
-0.1997353733,
0.0547054671,
0.3030030131,
0.5037932992,
-0.5288389921,
0.4086863697,
0.0377541743,
-0.1577583253,
-0.1151593775,
-0.7877056003,
0.5395799875,
-0.0906652957,
-0.8163082004,
0.4278181791,
0.0006149371,
-0.2422242016,
0.1064603254,
0.2383540869,
-0.2882791162,
0.1464746743,
-0.2520152926,
0.3222040832,
-0.324904412,
-0.2630360425,
0.2833706439,
-0.132257089,
0.0875103027,
-0.3261562884,
0.6586479545,
-0.1769725978,
-0.0991372913,
-0.5123083591,
0.238624379,
0.4823215008,
-0.3920141459,
0.7826654315,
0.8182296157,
-0.2480711341,
-0.063866958,
-0.2034174353,
-0.2585266531,
-0.425604701,
0.617605269,
-0.5988320708,
-0.583824873,
0.5550513864,
-0.3746297956,
0.0233101342,
0.2301278561,
0.8804259896,
0.2079089135,
1.437125206,
0.4603440166,
0.064845711,
0.1015737727,
-0.0472686179,
0.317638129,
-0.756406486,
0.303782016,
-0.3475243747,
-0.2827773392,
-0.6202001572,
-0.5098286271,
0.0576713569,
0.4524073303,
-0.0261401143,
0.8221017122,
-0.3108250201,
-0.0928859785,
0.6226857901,
-0.053305462,
0.4154687822,
-0.3426890373,
-0.3360976577,
-0.1251339018,
-0.7543269992,
-0.7270586491,
0.8493507504,
0.185456261,
0.6199349761,
0.070924677,
0.5985434055,
-0.0283319913,
0.1629273146,
-0.9743255973,
0.7513512969,
-0.6792193651,
-0.296328336,
-0.1415424198,
-0.8555297852,
-0.9588673115,
0.4057439864,
0.2121319026,
0.0099003166,
-0.1462888718,
0.0394746363,
-0.2224384546,
0.3822786212,
-0.8076766729,
1.0496760607,
-0.8245813847,
-0.3504885733,
-0.3040745556,
-0.5530157685,
0.5471802354,
-0.2787151635,
0.148262471,
0.0369345732,
-0.1156728119,
0.3521530032,
-0.2924920619,
0.7189471722,
0.17378968,
-0.2401995361,
-0.0384280011,
0.361885637,
0.2016829997,
-0.1427258104,
-0.2921470702,
0.7508146167,
0.2101095617,
-0.3041113317,
-0.4722070098,
0.3164200783,
-0.7279342413,
-0.5007193685,
-0.1707836092,
-0.7983128428,
0.1920530051,
0.5255915523,
0.3064406812,
-0.0311730243,
-0.1012332216,
0.0475395024,
-0.0892289951,
-0.5281042457,
0.1433507204,
0.768864274,
-0.4914571643,
-0.3380996585,
0.7921526432,
0.0902407765,
0.5455965996,
0.433993727,
0.4348879457,
-0.0452264436,
-0.5486898422,
-0.6054605842,
0.2777217627,
-0.3779959083,
0.1043317541,
-0.3424452543,
-0.4744526446,
-0.8303793669,
-0.2131485343,
-0.5598980784,
-0.4466909766,
-0.2081742138,
0.1894498169,
-0.1552155614,
0.5030739307,
-0.2053287178,
0.1951766461,
-1.1354868412,
0.2189934105,
-0.0121584088,
-0.2489398122,
0.1209357679,
-0.829251945,
-0.5528265238,
0.131900087,
-0.247392118,
-0.8063358068,
1.0104137659,
-0.2876344919,
0.2561045289,
0.2698057294,
-0.2096575499,
0.5393900275,
-0.8478714228,
0.6681768894,
0.1300827265,
-0.9467131495,
0.2940627933,
-0.3428696394,
0.2017953545,
0.3294593394,
0.4826785326,
-0.9197880626,
-0.3061495721,
-0.2073919177,
-0.9555971622,
0.6997235417,
0.1667674333,
-0.151850149,
0.0147872968,
0.2316733003,
0.2022274137,
0.2421220988,
-0.4739499092,
0.1821331233,
-0.4436538815,
-0.0248694476,
-0.0354990177,
0.0881574228,
0.0683530644,
-0.2305144221,
0.7034450173,
-0.045478981,
-0.0153532112,
-0.0525645576,
-0.1640164107,
-0.0068004825,
0.168957293,
0.5719060898,
0.6731524467,
-0.5256855488,
-0.0007933467,
-0.1149684936,
-0.2759651244,
-0.0361829288,
0.1858456135,
-0.5963522196,
0.3135273159,
0.1866875291,
0.7956138849,
0.3508062661,
-0.5633483529,
0.2733202577,
0.0454022922,
-0.1112046689,
-0.2405076623,
-0.3604649901,
0.3048088849,
0.0274984613,
-0.0269963201,
0.270021975,
0.2169212848,
-0.4874717593,
0.1741502285,
0.057271786,
-0.4066158235,
-0.6214306951,
0.9094935656,
0.3775454164,
-0.453152746,
0.7262908816,
-0.30914554,
-0.6065158248,
0.6877932549,
0.7572398186,
0.9697852731,
-0.4595048428,
0.2927472293,
0.5035420656,
0.8306337595,
-0.3884258568,
0.0567026474,
0.4441174567,
-0.7474672198,
-0.4488926828,
-0.3483359814,
-0.6277968884,
0.124447532,
-0.8512752056,
0.4191313088,
-0.0241237246,
-0.2804177701,
-0.4572577477,
-0.4124248624,
-0.3551776111,
-0.1239009202,
-0.0776210204,
1.1003801823,
-0.6402181983,
1.0696516037,
0.7880491018,
-0.6882169843,
-0.6908000112,
-0.0356483459,
-0.005028557,
-0.8892657757,
1.0268815756,
0.0734967887,
-0.2147136033,
0.3124939501,
-0.3216164112,
-0.5433887243,
0.8860130906,
0.5472267866,
-0.6448096633,
-0.2487471402,
0.3433077633,
0.3897683024,
-0.0513300821,
0.2618149221,
0.6425696015,
0.466663301,
-0.2573455572,
-1.1017017365,
-0.0932650864,
-0.2778666317,
0.0699365065,
0.0183192715,
-0.8971847296,
1.2780359983,
0.2414365858,
-0.1589503735,
0.4635585546,
0.2295419276,
0.2622438669,
0.037721701,
0.3546948731,
0.4818109274,
0.3090373278,
0.1286303103,
1.0562273264,
-0.6664559245,
0.3810582459,
1.0215688944,
-0.6175023913,
1.073710084,
0.6353952289,
0.1060803086,
0.0416649543,
0.5321187973,
-0.0794581175,
0.5203540921,
0.1529200077,
0.115973413,
-0.3017317951,
-0.2150976956,
-0.1219077483,
0.2978357077,
-0.014793124,
-0.3269080818,
-0.1881523728,
0.0826708376,
0.0131805874,
0.1236629784,
-0.3349978626,
0.371147871,
0.513749361,
-0.6739771962,
0.9035981894,
0.5530967712,
0.7870277166,
-0.5569599271,
-0.0314081088,
-0.5862261653,
0.3905898035,
-0.002267278,
-0.378403008,
0.2985313833,
-0.0128462818,
0.0877008811,
-0.5818994641,
0.4589569271,
-0.500488162,
-0.6598845124,
0.8393618464,
0.5601601005,
0.3603929877,
0.1047884673,
-1.0363321304,
-0.1147555113,
-0.0589978695,
0.0353653319,
0.3159295917,
0.5053480864,
-0.1308320165,
0.3189051449,
0.561027348,
0.5601312518,
0.2746540606,
0.4409006536,
0.2252917737,
-0.740244031,
-0.4930307269,
-0.672211647,
0.1773981452,
0.1450496465,
-0.3237193525,
1.0555214882,
0.6747412086,
1.1358988285,
-0.2457277924,
0.7172994018,
0.2934243083,
0.4468006194,
-0.6729136109,
1.0583982468,
-0.6503075361,
0.0428899005,
-0.1153919846,
-0.6847977638,
-0.1548249573,
0.4489037693,
-0.1043337807,
-0.2094902843,
0.8373077512,
0.856533885,
-0.2948440015,
-0.2775952518,
0.5661351681,
0.53843683,
0.3595259786,
0.8916068673,
0.8475388885,
-0.7206037045,
0.692224741,
-0.2399286479,
-0.2503175139,
-0.3443493545,
-0.7063049078,
-0.8456420898,
-0.3804588914,
-0.1686400026,
-0.2332686037,
0.1286918223,
0.6925926208,
0.5500479937,
-0.8041588068,
-0.9369068742,
0.0419253968,
-0.2823414803,
-0.7984073758,
-0.2286248654,
0.3597881794,
-0.4580311775,
-0.9879315495,
0.7186365128,
0.3146009445,
-0.0868295804,
-0.204481706,
-0.2850933373,
-0.3567888737,
0.1899306476,
0.7074894309,
-0.0072825849,
-0.7835690975,
0.060587462,
0.2997809947,
-0.5034225583,
-0.0152583206,
0.7027026415,
-0.3451149762,
0.2479545623,
0.6117112637,
0.9935057163,
0.2126895338,
0.1311262697,
0.7411335111,
-0.3287363648,
0.297450304,
0.210876599,
0.3787299693,
0.3429742455,
-0.068572171,
0.6405844092,
0.2254620343,
-0.4391340017,
-0.8009732366,
0.1647269428,
-0.7936108708,
-0.4059822857,
1.1249575615,
-0.0784274191,
-0.3863919973,
-0.0038682888,
-0.3354290426,
0.3651021719,
-0.0832051784,
0.976480484,
0.7615658045,
0.0690470487,
-0.2191468179,
-0.8282542229,
0.0391137972,
0.7505562901,
-0.6648775935,
-0.1178997606,
0.1756203771,
-0.0878451169,
0.04520154,
0.4004047811,
-0.3199748993,
0.3603409529,
-0.2493000925,
0.1941571832,
-0.2405516058,
-0.0338714011,
-0.5351434946,
-0.1065511256,
-0.20307298,
-0.1414050013
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08151v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08151v2
|
Benchmarking Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models in Biomedical NLP: Application, Robustness, and Self-Awareness
| 2024-05-13T19:51:20 | 2024-05-16T13:53:26 |
Mingchen Li, Zaifu Zhan, Han Yang, Yongkang Xiao, Jiatan Huang, Rui Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLM) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities in
various biomedical natural language processing (NLP) tasks, leveraging the
demonstration within the input context to adapt to new tasks. However, LLM is
sensitive to the selection of demonstrations. To address the hallucination
issue inherent in LLM, retrieval-augmented LLM (RAL) offers a solution by
retrieving pertinent information from an established database. Nonetheless,
existing research work lacks rigorous evaluation of the impact of
retrieval-augmented large language models on different biomedical NLP tasks.
This deficiency makes it challenging to ascertain the capabilities of RAL
within the biomedical domain. Moreover, the outputs from RAL are affected by
retrieving the unlabeled, counterfactual, or diverse knowledge that is not well
studied in the biomedical domain. However, such knowledge is common in the real
world. Finally, exploring the self-awareness ability is also crucial for the
RAL system. So, in this paper, we systematically investigate the impact of RALs
on 5 different biomedical tasks (triple extraction, link prediction,
classification, question answering, and natural language inference). We analyze
the performance of RALs in four fundamental abilities, including unlabeled
robustness, counterfactual robustness, diverse robustness, and negative
awareness. To this end, we proposed an evaluation framework to assess the RALs'
performance on different biomedical NLP tasks and establish four different
testbeds based on the aforementioned fundamental abilities. Then, we evaluate 3
representative LLMs with 3 different retrievers on 5 tasks over 9 datasets.
|
[
-0.282535702,
-0.8170282245,
0.6233741641,
0.3216172159,
0.0957249254,
0.0169188753,
-0.2832666337,
-0.8481308222,
0.2557672858,
0.3909410834,
-0.1374178231,
-0.51482898,
-0.6402045488,
0.5660931468,
-0.3445175588,
0.8881402016,
0.2157404572,
0.1017411202,
-0.3839387894,
-0.4614570737,
-0.5580809712,
-0.5941625834,
-0.1106908023,
-0.6418138146,
0.5356966257,
-0.0910631269,
0.4735244811,
0.5671107769,
0.7405795455,
0.2460402399,
-0.204414472,
-0.0303905904,
-0.3594470918,
0.4296223223,
-0.5627975464,
-0.1517193317,
-0.5123992562,
-0.1896916628,
0.7915282249,
0.8136889935,
-0.0037620773,
0.1925477833,
0.2659273744,
0.6015824676,
-0.7779297829,
0.0236048829,
-0.6418716311,
-0.0667781532,
-0.037650425,
-0.1212460101,
-0.3577505946,
-0.0655284747,
0.2617032826,
-0.2417018563,
0.0995857716,
0.0708985701,
0.6301172376,
0.4161882401,
-0.1856189072,
-0.29723683,
-0.5302272439,
0.8178314567,
-0.774348855,
0.6502020359,
0.4966632426,
0.1867121905,
-0.1131480709,
-0.7598474622,
-0.2165946364,
-0.3694218099,
-0.1235546619,
0.1188334525,
-0.2953938246,
0.080546245,
0.3967298269,
0.3435664475,
-0.7095315456,
0.2527090311,
-0.1702521294,
-0.2375131845,
0.4903679788,
0.0517477915,
0.1736756414,
-0.2204992771,
-0.2671121359,
-0.0545372367,
-0.6268542409,
-0.2728250325,
-0.2398519963,
0.2860471606,
0.1390869915,
0.6799352765,
-0.3387627304,
0.6431432366,
-0.1021005809,
-0.0822028667,
0.6829774976,
-0.4808520973,
-0.212103188,
-0.1186788827,
0.8586229086,
-0.0147230988,
-0.1583483815,
-0.3141792417,
-0.2242581844,
-0.142088756,
0.4309414923,
-0.8094870448,
0.1041318104,
0.338054806,
-0.5377331972,
-0.0718187615,
-0.4790852964,
-0.9210469127,
-0.4719534814,
-0.0661015734,
0.7608216405,
-0.5441355109,
-0.0869683921,
0.2816603482,
0.1159150302,
0.0715657249,
0.1262932867,
-0.7477713227,
0.3115532994,
0.65531075,
0.7329764366,
-0.4223974645,
-0.2464113533,
-0.6386119127,
0.1081024334,
-0.0205278322,
0.6979792714,
-0.4669140875,
-0.3444923759,
-0.1673530787,
-0.1609915197,
-0.202501744,
-0.8412211537,
0.6097096801,
-0.4619660676,
-0.201963678,
-0.3612187803,
-0.6684548855,
-0.0663364083,
0.3680680692,
-0.4946458638,
0.8986185193,
-0.2571455538,
-0.828846395,
0.2241613269,
-0.5586078763,
-0.5189790726,
0.1663364023,
-0.4068618417,
-0.3639921248,
0.1091601625,
0.1745577008,
0.6130877733,
-0.2234813124,
0.2151429206,
-0.4156942368,
-0.2593404651,
0.3945700228,
-0.2114819437,
0.5930326581,
0.0771967694,
-0.3994520903,
0.0789693743,
-0.7504897714,
0.1004098281,
-0.1553442478,
-0.3009076715,
-0.4958110154,
-0.0274241418,
-0.1107596382,
0.1156309173,
0.2635488808,
-0.508363843,
0.0270245839,
-0.6222023964,
0.1404651254,
0.4213291705,
0.0582583658,
-0.0728134513,
-0.2762203217,
0.473924309,
-0.3064595759,
0.0209249016,
0.075725697,
-0.3827220798,
-0.2504591644,
-0.5225331783,
0.2783677876,
0.4509201646,
-0.5013704896,
0.4959922135,
-0.1441848129,
-0.3890496492,
-0.6758659482,
0.2283688188,
0.7028252482,
0.6302229166,
0.7012759447,
-0.1894330829,
-0.4972960353,
-1.0221623182,
-0.3618378937,
-0.168318525,
-0.0732401907,
0.4573352039,
0.6870527267,
-0.5852526426,
0.6667069793,
-0.2885997295,
-0.3303358853,
-0.259944886,
0.1587739736,
0.2762280703,
0.3110799193,
0.3802345395,
-0.5049285293,
-0.1296967566,
0.0202679541,
-1.0056089163,
-0.3915286958,
0.0794737861,
0.1454875171,
0.0184752736,
0.4457424283,
-0.6134269834,
0.4148409963,
0.507725656,
-0.0777216405,
0.7664869428,
-0.4986177981,
0.1057326496,
-0.7399381399,
0.4811534286,
-0.0514711179,
-0.0534370281,
-0.5738360286,
0.080776684,
0.1975571662,
0.302682519,
-0.0803951547,
0.7804826498,
-0.5252773166,
-0.4695424139,
-0.3749032319,
0.0916010514,
0.0253058542,
0.0770576894,
0.2019487321,
0.7394143343,
0.4629400074,
-0.5586109757,
-0.0730256811,
0.3014058173,
-0.3176947832,
0.1960317045,
-0.923456192,
0.0544382185,
-0.0307979472,
0.0206573941,
-0.7532054782,
-0.0615591332,
-0.0246374812,
-0.4008685648,
0.3079449534,
0.2154705375,
-0.539901793,
-0.3605026007,
-0.1783010662,
0.5020436645,
0.3960052729,
-0.3905338049,
0.6331132054,
0.3772211373,
-0.0149168549,
-0.8710939884,
-0.5375456214,
0.0787484795,
-0.0687097162,
-0.2431305051,
0.3524399102,
-0.1490644366,
-0.2626493573,
-0.2025872022,
-0.1561077982,
0.1699582934,
0.1730984598,
0.3629788458,
0.187193349,
-0.0591506585,
0.3740465641,
-0.1570078582,
-0.0430792384,
0.1310300529,
0.2254913449,
0.4130409062,
-0.3846831918,
-0.5801323056,
-0.3191262782,
0.1033636481,
0.3910789788,
-0.4378874302,
0.6422365904,
0.6105021238,
-0.4709198773,
0.0279998556,
-0.8664119244,
-0.3501510918,
-0.4088028669,
0.6653570533,
-0.267190963,
-0.8819587231,
0.6009603143,
-0.0498933978,
-0.09512043,
0.4592858553,
0.7978550196,
0.00628768,
0.8414878845,
0.2958484888,
0.0011366269,
0.0978883728,
-0.0610938445,
0.1023522317,
-1.055390954,
-0.2165488452,
-0.7600907087,
-0.0711179078,
-0.3880688846,
-0.5203291178,
0.5024199486,
0.1491433084,
-0.0544482917,
0.1715476662,
-0.3779529035,
0.2044882476,
0.2955040634,
0.2183252275,
0.5237145424,
-0.1331093311,
-0.2962086201,
-0.1134391204,
-0.5435603261,
-0.5373960137,
1.287623167,
0.4381204247,
0.7673459649,
0.0296928827,
0.6316856742,
0.2205476016,
0.4207737446,
-0.6078671813,
0.5768837929,
-0.0975190699,
-0.7207700014,
-0.1446774751,
-0.4703036249,
-1.075155735,
0.2806888521,
-0.5526759624,
-0.8629453182,
0.1206524372,
0.046728462,
-0.4742383361,
0.0604013726,
-0.4272538424,
0.7958930731,
-0.3195836544,
-0.5480315685,
-0.4339193702,
-0.6717700958,
0.2128917724,
-0.273461014,
0.2130047977,
-0.0886366665,
-0.066637665,
0.5627115965,
0.1368579417,
0.8135438561,
0.1243001819,
0.0672591254,
-0.1269575357,
0.0912708268,
0.2208623141,
0.0682371929,
-0.3775396049,
0.3617578745,
0.2404723018,
-0.1725932211,
-0.4289200306,
0.7537229657,
-0.6172540188,
-0.6168976426,
-0.4824872613,
-0.544213891,
-0.507861793,
0.3138295412,
0.1051048338,
0.4230731726,
-0.285944581,
0.3895767927,
0.7746152282,
-0.6473071575,
0.1750365645,
0.7188697457,
-0.4913017154,
-0.2893876731,
0.6810443997,
0.0600702651,
0.3439857066,
0.3799685836,
0.183585614,
-0.4943537712,
-0.9757629633,
-0.1059219688,
0.4756316841,
-0.5653841496,
-0.2556804717,
-1.0654755831,
-0.2429906875,
-0.4842315018,
0.1101592407,
-0.4294003248,
-0.1431152374,
-0.2969783843,
0.0675671548,
0.2425795794,
0.7427936792,
-0.3445905447,
-0.210683167,
-0.7349017262,
0.4922416806,
0.2227585465,
0.4619013667,
0.0208515842,
-0.5352521539,
-0.2450994104,
-0.043257542,
-0.1081807613,
-0.8138495684,
0.4639362097,
0.191786617,
0.8568047285,
0.2515484989,
-0.0180523694,
0.4498775303,
-0.3928254843,
0.3573237658,
-0.0512463078,
-0.6245276928,
0.5500733256,
-0.1893229038,
0.2272934616,
0.7065928578,
0.3744426966,
-0.1949164867,
-0.3186946213,
-0.4391258657,
-0.794534564,
0.2357921153,
0.2210459411,
-0.2707479,
-0.3127471507,
0.4979450703,
0.1548319906,
0.0419823751,
-0.6026944518,
-0.2402749956,
0.1209707633,
-0.1092268229,
-0.0681076348,
-0.3841400445,
-0.0747023225,
-0.207237944,
0.6630864739,
-0.0390501395,
0.132743448,
0.4904869497,
-0.2145190984,
0.1980817914,
0.3593792021,
0.4007259607,
0.5751571059,
-0.5304493904,
0.1490251869,
0.3475770354,
-0.5735021234,
-0.1399890482,
0.1549370736,
-0.0775503889,
-0.1148216054,
0.6145871878,
0.348335743,
0.2147479653,
-1.0482590199,
0.375685811,
0.0308208447,
0.0131705441,
-0.023965437,
-0.0915428549,
0.1291276067,
0.3247228265,
0.4178898931,
0.0473626032,
0.5407494903,
-0.3801900744,
0.4026823938,
0.7219201326,
-0.3371867239,
-0.2715414464,
0.5974405408,
-0.1475848407,
-0.2136834562,
0.3071316481,
-0.0136599336,
-0.3137375414,
0.3392187059,
0.719630301,
0.7653033137,
-0.2430329472,
-0.115261212,
0.5630633235,
0.2008529603,
-0.1050208732,
0.1200208068,
0.1898683906,
-0.741263628,
-0.6655929685,
-0.7401764989,
-0.3027693629,
0.1565963775,
-0.8972244263,
-0.0390985012,
-0.2631426454,
-0.4318293035,
0.2552566826,
0.1162438169,
-0.6284549832,
0.0185883883,
-0.1588902473,
0.7165641785,
-0.6413799524,
0.8871284127,
0.6737154722,
-0.1968238205,
-0.4121866822,
-0.1110694855,
-0.0803742707,
-0.8754363656,
0.8761110902,
0.1244354248,
-0.2603994012,
-0.1802828908,
-0.2421155721,
-0.7715348005,
1.0042096376,
0.2073594034,
-0.6035397053,
0.1398628205,
0.0471982993,
0.9547282457,
-0.2947165072,
0.2995348573,
0.4534609616,
0.2990351319,
-0.0162488744,
-1.1848274469,
0.0902524143,
-0.2216643393,
-0.082693994,
-0.1803426743,
-0.3536542654,
0.4049569964,
-0.3562470675,
-0.0573050231,
0.1634423733,
0.4751527011,
0.6321067214,
0.2925868034,
0.2794831395,
0.4332502782,
0.8279427886,
0.2322248518,
1.0549147129,
-0.3574467897,
0.3076129854,
1.1213561296,
-0.6892985106,
1.1116424799,
0.5555384159,
-0.1964007169,
0.0953787342,
0.1371462196,
0.1217885539,
0.2949101925,
0.14132002,
-0.2702251673,
-0.3450503945,
-0.307372421,
-0.6489540339,
0.4796082675,
0.5142030716,
-0.4446414709,
-0.2211958468,
0.2293999791,
-0.263874054,
0.2073521167,
-0.0908382535,
0.7678340673,
0.0747096241,
-0.3257494867,
0.6292192936,
-0.2606363297,
0.6548253298,
-0.4929746985,
-0.1106838882,
-0.0900184587,
0.3042469323,
-0.062282268,
-0.664221406,
0.3722499013,
-0.0578578487,
-0.2292682678,
-0.1013496593,
0.8709749579,
-0.1621061265,
-0.4143453836,
0.7098550797,
0.65516752,
0.2409044504,
-0.0561393574,
-0.8090444803,
0.343518585,
-0.0646437109,
-0.2864501476,
0.636954546,
0.198057428,
0.1684831679,
1.0186940432,
0.4189034998,
0.2901970744,
-0.1557630897,
0.1683723927,
0.7181978822,
-0.7661998868,
0.1245568022,
-0.9045730233,
-0.0810157359,
0.015412108,
-0.0415609181,
0.8174090981,
0.64150244,
0.4550135136,
0.072075434,
0.6537770033,
0.1016446501,
1.0370863676,
-0.394191891,
0.8266384006,
-0.5905638933,
0.6106557846,
-0.4061789811,
-0.6627895236,
-0.5266771913,
0.8026642799,
-0.4476718307,
0.2157422751,
0.646071136,
0.7961235642,
0.1904578954,
0.0348128602,
0.478253603,
0.5633642673,
0.1999111623,
0.4161866307,
0.6273218989,
-0.3523254097,
0.2383709699,
-0.2045756131,
-0.1446762532,
-0.1879513562,
-0.9877171516,
-0.915073514,
-0.4382281601,
-0.3667239249,
-0.497189343,
0.2923466265,
0.9271395802,
0.5167583823,
-0.8304380774,
-0.1606774777,
0.2905040979,
0.0196498595,
-0.2613332868,
-0.1642313153,
0.612675488,
-0.3738461435,
-0.3036872745,
0.6044222116,
0.518176496,
-0.0768961757,
-0.1905639768,
0.0724572986,
-0.4769907892,
-0.254884392,
0.718092978,
0.466694802,
-0.7223277092,
-0.2469283342,
0.1922459602,
-0.2656871974,
0.0623948202,
0.3987286687,
-0.9950585961,
0.448977828,
0.3307908773,
0.9918827415,
0.4373738468,
-0.0584857687,
0.4693232179,
-0.4677952528,
-0.2486132383,
0.4489501715,
0.3234159052,
0.3475846648,
-0.1148559675,
0.600892067,
0.0902401209,
-0.8776471019,
-0.9361532331,
-0.0926095694,
-1.0463664532,
-0.3823062181,
1.2266863585,
-0.02733537,
0.0673019662,
-0.3894361258,
0.0033722895,
0.1349466294,
-0.0931517854,
1.0458481312,
0.4793192148,
-0.2515240908,
0.0912259966,
-0.9348291755,
0.486489743,
0.7201460004,
-0.7268695235,
0.1864628643,
0.4453055561,
0.3118731678,
0.1942894161,
0.6944994926,
-0.3064052165,
0.0573884808,
-0.3833186626,
0.3567232788,
0.1249080896,
-0.1036840603,
-0.5119243264,
0.1370543092,
0.1713228226,
0.2019176036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08142v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08142v1
|
Discursive objection strategies in online comments: Developing a classification schema and validating its training
| 2024-05-13T19:39:00 | 2024-05-13T19:39:00 |
Ashley L. Shea, Aspen K. B. Omapang, Ji Yong Cho, Miryam Y. Ginsparg, Natalie Bazarova, Winice Hui, René F. Kizilcec, Chau Tong, Drew Margolin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, I.2.7, J.4
|
Most Americans agree that misinformation, hate speech and harassment are
harmful and inadequately curbed on social media through current moderation
practices. In this paper, we aim to understand the discursive strategies
employed by people in response to harmful speech in news comments. We conducted
a content analysis of more than 6500 comment replies to trending news videos on
YouTube and Twitter and identified seven distinct discursive objection
strategies (Study 1). We examined the frequency of each strategy's occurrence
from the 6500 comment replies, as well as from a second sample of 2004 replies
(Study 2). Together, these studies show that people deploy a diversity of
discursive strategies when objecting to speech, and reputational attacks are
the most common. The resulting classification scheme accounts for different
theoretical approaches for expressing objections and offers a comprehensive
perspective on grassroots efforts aimed at stopping offensive or problematic
speech on campus.
|
[
-0.4985863566,
-1.1547816992,
0.2807719409,
0.0168500394,
-0.5388289094,
0.414482981,
-0.1062128991,
-0.2192306072,
-0.120555602,
0.6046805382,
-0.5437703729,
-0.3602607548,
-0.6894545555,
0.1217123121,
-0.7776685953,
1.405472517,
0.1996948868,
0.0791840553,
-0.0086040068,
-0.2113066465,
-0.2525190413,
-0.6814611554,
-0.5481624007,
0.2338216305,
0.7107026577,
0.2475196421,
0.4606554508,
0.3910816312,
0.5752994418,
0.3324643672,
-0.0470309034,
0.0533850677,
-0.6596164107,
0.125382036,
-0.2802234292,
-0.5117211342,
0.1908501238,
0.0362517498,
0.303034544,
0.4053210914,
-0.1939547062,
0.3521530926,
-0.0422924273,
0.570744276,
-0.8834798932,
-0.2800075114,
-0.6927506924,
0.1442201287,
-0.442512244,
-0.3216558099,
-0.6481029987,
-0.7167617083,
0.0298829079,
-0.5898175836,
0.4798005223,
-0.2231326103,
0.3624151945,
0.1301219016,
-0.3962822855,
-0.7676981091,
-0.8552103043,
0.7223821878,
-0.4915580451,
0.3383283317,
0.3591484129,
0.2649905086,
0.2026107162,
-0.4683800638,
-0.4824126661,
0.0627906397,
0.1234136298,
0.0039904388,
-0.5382737517,
0.1959700882,
0.3725161254,
0.0199747737,
-0.37465626,
0.0879244879,
-0.597507894,
-0.1184463799,
0.6813642979,
-0.0317170434,
0.2587515116,
-0.4416339397,
-0.2305856645,
-0.0275937356,
-0.3239110708,
-0.1110119745,
0.7594670057,
0.295940727,
0.101576902,
0.4149484932,
-0.0849876106,
0.5228420496,
0.2689124048,
-0.2418762743,
-0.0323840231,
-0.1398223191,
0.0195469037,
0.359867692,
0.4251781106,
0.9382728338,
0.4475847185,
-0.1072192565,
0.1121547744,
0.5228739381,
0.6317529678,
-0.6131709814,
-0.0736906528,
-0.0948282927,
-0.6848189831,
-0.4919272065,
-0.0161941722,
-1.2224674225,
-0.9239784479,
0.1222065315,
0.2881957889,
-0.1281598657,
-0.2458272427,
-0.1049694791,
-0.2855014801,
0.0115689877,
0.3917864859,
-0.6436274648,
0.8925924897,
0.6291744709,
0.8489279151,
-0.2677173615,
0.2890558243,
-0.6594843268,
0.2492984682,
-0.3905518651,
0.7506584525,
-0.5442501903,
-0.4372612238,
0.3649181426,
-0.1057768762,
-0.0113594253,
-0.6170222759,
1.1406910419,
-0.6560082436,
0.0759094432,
-0.3961650729,
-0.3002485931,
-0.6151077151,
-0.0331086293,
-0.34008044,
0.6215108633,
0.0399767645,
-1.2184224129,
0.3213214874,
-0.8670283556,
-0.7194876075,
0.0732445642,
0.0788556114,
-0.1677689999,
0.0662938729,
-0.0673948452,
0.438424468,
-0.027537968,
-0.0871139243,
-0.2386469841,
-0.0746647716,
0.1980062425,
-0.3889654279,
0.9187520742,
0.6650146842,
-0.7547353506,
0.1759621948,
-0.4692456424,
-0.4060784578,
0.0926141441,
-0.2752991617,
-0.8662542105,
0.4196160734,
-0.2920978069,
0.2674022317,
-0.5672998428,
-0.4989469945,
-0.4713098705,
-0.34997648,
0.7001820207,
0.9148381948,
0.3776448071,
0.167444706,
-0.5849239826,
0.3386059701,
0.2083511502,
0.3230245113,
0.3481591046,
-0.217674166,
-0.8748272061,
0.433072269,
-0.6389814615,
0.4581233561,
-0.6644545794,
-0.1274491251,
-0.1996895522,
-0.4601495564,
-0.2855359912,
0.0909548029,
0.4481430054,
0.4137461185,
0.2719872296,
-0.1120591015,
-0.6166570187,
-0.7569617033,
-0.4930559695,
-0.4868784547,
0.2359136343,
0.1048602238,
0.1207015663,
0.2568756342,
0.2872271836,
-0.3094123602,
-0.1205963194,
0.0319227166,
0.4094510376,
-0.3540168703,
0.0162671376,
0.5584546924,
-0.9238333702,
-0.6605815291,
-0.1454063058,
-0.4304157197,
0.0416678824,
-0.0539083481,
-0.0260379147,
0.2670236528,
0.5414797664,
-0.2843011916,
0.3116358221,
0.2574571371,
-0.0103585673,
0.2422614843,
0.6241539121,
0.4785342515,
-0.8073865175,
-0.6675846577,
0.490513742,
-0.0910572186,
-0.8488608599,
0.1611289829,
-0.7222775817,
0.3689445257,
-0.580168128,
-0.2562506497,
-0.0132556278,
0.2653565705,
-0.0281393416,
0.2367604375,
-0.3055200875,
-0.0718637854,
0.0208683088,
0.3925321698,
0.4784128964,
-0.8907654285,
0.5140300989,
0.1548354924,
-0.3163414598,
0.7779191732,
-0.3314702213,
0.3371982276,
-0.4022237062,
0.429948926,
-1.11282444,
-0.1706101149,
0.5545821786,
-0.5079009533,
-0.164275974,
-0.0053358688,
-0.2361951321,
-0.6722416878,
-0.7555034757,
0.2184115201,
0.0502330437,
-0.3531296551,
0.4828835726,
0.7393464446,
-0.2260974795,
-0.3991541266,
-0.6268581152,
0.1134549007,
-0.7103374004,
-0.4568606913,
0.2463410497,
-0.149428755,
-0.9168136716,
-0.2748961747,
0.0462209024,
-0.0929544196,
0.1559421718,
0.3222224414,
-0.2059522569,
0.0172743816,
-0.0018156678,
-0.1781432182,
0.5340522528,
0.5060086846,
0.412596643,
0.7481500506,
0.1454557627,
-0.0457627289,
-0.3984193504,
0.581076026,
0.4403230548,
0.36661762,
0.2989419401,
0.5232095122,
-0.2945672274,
-0.2510610819,
-0.7142361999,
-0.5637444854,
-0.4463143945,
0.4563510418,
0.1404047757,
-0.7661924958,
0.103337124,
0.0488199517,
0.3297855258,
0.1590423137,
0.4564675689,
-0.1071833447,
1.1914373636,
0.2371717989,
-0.0519288257,
0.1673079878,
-0.0474284329,
0.3469811678,
-0.2376263589,
-0.1562629044,
-0.7356762886,
-0.0151892016,
-0.7484176159,
-0.2079219371,
-0.2044615597,
-0.2610628903,
-0.278369844,
0.3037182391,
-0.8219411969,
0.1294247359,
0.2483371347,
-0.073879458,
0.2780025899,
0.3150206208,
0.248308748,
-0.3093934357,
-0.5073083043,
-0.3827414215,
0.5610820055,
0.6464248896,
0.777813673,
0.3396007419,
0.3723919988,
0.7163276672,
0.4782409668,
-0.9941015244,
0.6561771035,
-0.2793487906,
-0.8889678717,
-0.0803681016,
-0.3355207145,
-0.4483560622,
0.0386805236,
-0.0757156461,
-0.9687668085,
0.054923296,
0.0831701308,
-0.2898802757,
0.587936759,
-0.6309158206,
0.2664507627,
-0.2224802673,
-0.3653488457,
-0.5127481818,
-0.7139581442,
0.4993610382,
-0.1575140208,
0.79729563,
0.1384090185,
0.2118869275,
1.2735873461,
-0.0612606965,
1.0363488197,
-0.3837706447,
-0.0648143217,
0.5509025455,
0.0105762742,
0.1958304346,
-0.3500616252,
0.1305411309,
-0.057353247,
-0.0576416254,
0.2471691221,
-0.1600122303,
0.5803832412,
-0.8640055656,
-0.7758389115,
-0.2549352646,
-0.3214443326,
-0.2148716301,
0.0809255615,
0.383130759,
0.1273587793,
-0.2175202817,
0.3273665011,
0.6073809862,
0.1195440069,
0.576050818,
0.5210783482,
0.0944966674,
-0.4622641802,
1.1344726086,
0.2358439714,
0.3381277025,
0.1863541007,
0.2141172439,
-0.3899127245,
-0.6746008396,
-0.0910935029,
-0.0148931984,
-0.7777663469,
-0.1498550475,
-0.6287689209,
-0.0713521913,
-0.6926320791,
-0.0985434949,
0.0181096829,
-0.2369337529,
-0.1167965755,
-0.3412635624,
0.0981044173,
1.1408759356,
-0.0022775375,
0.5316357017,
-0.466057092,
0.228905797,
0.4815256596,
0.1578591317,
-0.028735429,
-0.5949271321,
0.1176090166,
0.0314396583,
-0.8236504197,
-1.1173753738,
-0.1459765732,
0.0492997952,
0.6609796286,
0.9422379136,
0.7251183987,
0.5961424112,
-0.2476217747,
0.744430542,
0.2810850143,
-0.590338707,
0.5224820375,
-0.3550344408,
-0.4126487076,
0.4363524616,
0.9710308313,
-0.7046535015,
-0.6629335284,
-0.4784025252,
-0.6005254984,
0.5714911222,
-0.0984897316,
0.5061919689,
-0.4173093438,
0.1002596393,
0.0314900205,
0.3322141171,
-1.0804938078,
-0.5752284527,
-0.666960597,
0.3159324825,
0.2800878584,
-0.5111751556,
-0.7615973353,
-0.3055346906,
0.5696568489,
-0.0446359329,
-0.0435115099,
-0.0855716616,
-0.1836048216,
-0.7092651129,
0.1953804642,
0.6924247742,
0.8342428207,
-0.1083247811,
0.2440082133,
0.0736638159,
-0.773198545,
0.2496016622,
-0.081052959,
-0.4431393743,
0.1704808176,
0.0779608414,
0.6331711411,
0.2608073652,
-0.1182759851,
0.375972122,
0.0337948129,
-0.5944958925,
-0.0610022582,
-0.0203378238,
-0.0778978691,
-0.1406348348,
0.4160960913,
-0.0284511615,
0.3543135226,
-0.725292623,
0.3167355955,
0.4673829377,
-0.5190902352,
-0.2013551146,
0.5465463996,
0.3534440398,
-0.2084497511,
0.1064885035,
0.0623692758,
-0.5753422379,
0.0834683254,
0.7116042376,
0.7662060857,
-0.4056412876,
0.9232911468,
0.5364878774,
0.3335462809,
0.1408215463,
-0.1342077553,
0.0617688186,
-0.7216909528,
-0.0424696431,
-0.5491930842,
-0.1982623637,
0.2622945309,
-0.7016918659,
0.1233962476,
-1.1315348148,
-0.2824988067,
0.4391213357,
-0.0093137622,
0.0172401648,
0.0763574168,
0.2284422368,
0.7223244905,
-1.0676568747,
0.2257299721,
0.8012573719,
-0.461722225,
-0.3272734284,
0.4190786481,
0.4548076093,
-0.6021800041,
0.5387413502,
0.1558591127,
-0.3491052985,
-0.0512181818,
-0.628718853,
-0.4358683228,
0.2215438932,
0.1247015893,
-0.3246708512,
0.0184970684,
0.250186801,
0.2839972079,
-0.1654008031,
-0.1684566438,
0.5747845769,
0.3262356818,
0.1567699164,
-0.4995272756,
0.2425931394,
0.1307070553,
-0.0277126934,
0.1987459958,
-0.8297394514,
0.7496373057,
-0.0286392011,
-0.6815229654,
-0.1851544529,
0.2333901674,
-0.0683345199,
0.3890305459,
1.0166944265,
0.404405117,
0.4530002177,
-0.0710437,
0.803376019,
-0.0746904761,
0.0647075623,
0.6980832219,
0.0326643288,
0.7028879523,
0.3426764011,
-0.3968357742,
0.696372807,
0.5987365246,
-0.0998575389,
0.7338564992,
0.6310399175,
-0.6178115606,
-0.084981963,
-0.6067994833,
-0.2410731167,
0.356102407,
0.64948982,
-0.1654681712,
-0.5398259759,
0.2361683846,
0.3866637349,
0.7330083847,
-0.5590385199,
1.0502454042,
-0.1583541036,
-0.7030292153,
0.2594415247,
0.095144175,
0.7155995965,
-0.4137676954,
-0.1064778566,
0.0608522855,
0.0168942083,
-0.5022041798,
-0.6143674254,
0.3450458348,
0.0280003119,
-0.0432395376,
0.1482093483,
0.831667006,
0.2304145992,
-0.1684854627,
0.3085351288,
0.0152931204,
0.0241694711,
0.1216810271,
-0.8335114121,
0.1920739114,
0.0690702274,
0.1313447803,
0.29879722,
0.1006817594,
-0.3009313345,
0.7411082387,
0.6961666942,
-0.0670168474,
0.2440702915,
0.3654668033,
1.2118449211,
-0.2871734798,
-0.3181891739,
-0.7733976841,
0.2884090543,
-0.3026441336,
-0.2955317795,
0.9953454733,
0.3683614433,
1.0876572132,
0.2927596271,
0.8832930326,
-0.1077389866,
1.0238699913,
-0.2060434073,
0.3706263006,
-0.0308610257,
-0.0156918559,
-0.7446970344,
-0.8472288251,
-0.378169179,
0.9171907902,
-0.4861885011,
0.0907518715,
0.646746397,
0.6079028845,
0.3479768038,
0.2807810009,
0.1563912928,
0.5723698735,
0.4254156351,
-0.0633411109,
0.9440450668,
-0.0266837887,
1.0044945478,
-0.785001874,
-0.1456348747,
-0.279504776,
-0.5076163411,
-0.9961705804,
-0.3822292984,
-0.4098186791,
-0.6949575543,
0.4479640722,
0.6158598065,
0.5754476786,
-0.8920221925,
-0.2933794856,
-0.220585227,
0.2476097792,
-0.1579577625,
-0.3570369184,
-0.0460365452,
-0.1411200166,
-0.7201920748,
-0.0402614959,
0.1029998586,
-0.3529185653,
-0.4135164917,
0.028955346,
-0.5438287258,
0.1190940067,
0.8600588441,
0.473187685,
-0.8783203959,
-0.7163718939,
-0.0400522836,
-0.0169826094,
-0.1461633146,
0.6878062487,
-0.215224728,
0.4856241047,
0.30343014,
0.4150904715,
0.0959167555,
0.6163660288,
0.1414352208,
-0.5504441857,
0.0343931802,
0.4328961372,
-0.0847531408,
0.552192986,
-0.4059536159,
0.2165455222,
0.5704778433,
-0.4961500764,
-0.8784429431,
0.2108069211,
-0.8504984379,
-0.3573184013,
1.1271154881,
0.1729768664,
0.0826178491,
-0.4984473884,
-0.3126789331,
0.1672945768,
-0.6023138762,
1.1809779406,
0.8217406869,
-0.0738763139,
-0.2611228228,
-0.8060676455,
0.7532055974,
0.0509914905,
-0.7669488192,
0.2063241154,
0.6695908308,
0.2611089349,
0.5123775601,
0.438146621,
-0.1188049912,
0.384038806,
-0.0806189701,
-0.4968857169,
0.4532427192,
-0.3580607772,
0.1286589056,
0.4134114087,
-0.0039641075,
-0.3060545027
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13011v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13011v1
|
Unveiling Social Media Comments with a Novel Named Entity Recognition System for Identity Groups
| 2024-05-13T19:33:18 | 2024-05-13T19:33:18 |
Andrés Carvallo, Tamara Quiroga, Carlos Aspillaga, Marcelo Mendoza
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
While civilized users employ social media to stay informed and discuss daily
occurrences, haters perceive these platforms as fertile ground for attacking
groups and individuals. The prevailing approach to counter this phenomenon
involves detecting such attacks by identifying toxic language. Effective
platform measures aim to report haters and block their network access. In this
context, employing hate speech detection methods aids in identifying these
attacks amidst vast volumes of text, which are impossible for humans to analyze
manually. In our study, we expand upon the usual hate speech detection methods,
typically based on text classifiers, to develop a Named Entity Recognition
(NER) System for Identity Groups. To achieve this, we created a dataset that
allows extending a conventional NER to recognize identity groups. Consequently,
our tool not only detects whether a sentence contains an attack but also tags
the sentence tokens corresponding to the mentioned group. Results indicate that
the model performs competitively in identifying groups with an average f1-score
of 0.75, outperforming in identifying ethnicity attack spans with an f1-score
of 0.80 compared to other identity groups. Moreover, the tool shows an
outstanding generalization capability to minority classes concerning sexual
orientation and gender, achieving an f1-score of 0.77 and 0.72, respectively.
We tested the utility of our tool in a case study on social media, annotating
and comparing comments from Facebook related to news mentioning identity
groups. The case study reveals differences in the types of attacks recorded,
effectively detecting named entities related to the categories of the analyzed
news articles. Entities are accurately tagged within their categories, with a
negligible error rate for inter-category tagging.
|
[
-0.5328994989,
-0.7264472246,
0.1814221889,
0.0511620529,
-0.2821802497,
0.5669760108,
-0.1683096886,
-0.7733983397,
0.5717891455,
0.3183760047,
-0.2811401188,
-0.4824572504,
-0.6953089237,
0.1027841344,
-0.8469734192,
1.3166698217,
0.3930859864,
0.0391265713,
0.2985110283,
-0.1827672869,
0.027921455,
-0.4482049048,
-0.8428785205,
0.007656652,
0.9295277596,
-0.0182820577,
0.4226978421,
0.3991245329,
0.6698305011,
0.2945105731,
-0.1864265352,
0.032436803,
-0.3554601371,
0.1063348949,
-0.2298859358,
-0.0851866528,
-0.260085851,
-0.1320865899,
0.5311637521,
0.2309604883,
0.2015189826,
0.304041028,
-0.0444070846,
0.3267183602,
-0.5074215531,
-0.2598347962,
-1.0053111315,
0.0902243704,
-0.607962966,
0.1190655977,
-0.3575503826,
-0.4490801394,
-0.0541233681,
-0.3077234626,
0.2461542338,
-0.0372793376,
0.7064281702,
0.1107475832,
-0.3633310199,
-0.2892388105,
-0.6996209025,
0.5517889857,
-0.5519109964,
0.4617600441,
0.0058823191,
0.3242277801,
-0.1198074445,
-0.16547288,
-0.7702946067,
-0.0152205899,
-0.1103859693,
-0.2314300388,
-0.4563739002,
-0.0505713113,
0.2538095713,
0.2279299796,
-0.4167692065,
0.2797476351,
-0.4944639802,
-0.3361381888,
0.7954223752,
-0.1849116385,
0.6591946483,
-0.408967644,
-0.4539459646,
0.5117930174,
-0.3806014061,
-0.0478502437,
0.5859856606,
0.5151322484,
0.030884603,
0.4147829115,
-0.1760394424,
0.4927940071,
0.2571417987,
-0.2893043756,
0.4525110126,
0.3469786048,
-0.1099334881,
0.1833066493,
0.756352365,
0.6150243282,
0.3904989958,
-0.5605967045,
-0.2174278647,
0.642144084,
0.1720035374,
-0.7776520848,
-0.2067843974,
-0.286042273,
-0.5212355852,
-0.389700681,
-0.0810633078,
-0.9196186066,
-1.0045814514,
-0.0214703269,
0.2151713073,
-0.1390131712,
-0.5209958553,
-0.533084631,
-0.500938952,
0.3166555166,
0.4662180841,
-0.6361688375,
0.5529392958,
0.4593118131,
0.7381318808,
-0.6161545515,
0.2842863202,
-0.7648110986,
0.0933725834,
-0.0475647673,
0.9237869382,
-0.8139393926,
-0.2841474712,
-0.2279678434,
-0.1030405015,
0.249863714,
-0.6670879722,
0.436975956,
-0.8585920334,
-0.209964484,
-0.2438901216,
-0.5680853724,
-0.1372566372,
0.2037996203,
-0.6873189807,
0.7611778378,
0.0288476106,
-0.9977660179,
0.4170210361,
-0.6299237013,
-0.3100870848,
0.5308454633,
-0.4258693159,
-0.3406568766,
0.1352459341,
-0.044565782,
0.4456605315,
-0.1395377368,
-0.0741499141,
-0.6745235324,
-0.2022317201,
0.2153228074,
0.1160214916,
0.6724298,
0.2739264667,
-0.633066535,
0.1002297625,
-0.7788972855,
-0.0078377072,
0.2555757463,
-0.2187074572,
-0.7324037552,
0.0312841348,
0.1756284684,
0.0746909231,
-0.1569318771,
-0.8717645407,
-0.2206161171,
0.0093854889,
0.2155107707,
0.9512375593,
0.1751587838,
0.2311209142,
0.0973622873,
0.3904569447,
0.0928333774,
-0.090532288,
0.2555793524,
-0.3428356051,
-0.7802725434,
-0.1327042431,
0.2785272598,
0.6412898302,
-0.6594009399,
0.2035000175,
-0.053714294,
-0.7078999281,
-0.1628931463,
0.1089144275,
0.4449107051,
0.3178590536,
0.3407592773,
-0.1204689369,
-0.9963027239,
-1.0099390745,
-0.7272533774,
-0.3297451138,
-0.0368949026,
0.249074325,
0.3800771832,
-0.2789072692,
0.860468328,
-0.3293968439,
-0.1887403727,
-0.0098278327,
0.1831602901,
-0.2337730378,
0.1036659852,
0.4628397822,
-1.084621191,
-0.8944009542,
0.0170523562,
-0.5444695354,
-0.3267326355,
0.2591717541,
0.0887788385,
0.0549692847,
0.6383149028,
0.0056400369,
0.4606009722,
0.3801372349,
-0.2779010534,
0.3175048828,
0.8221888542,
0.1311198771,
-0.944263339,
-0.1749712378,
0.4117917418,
-0.2091559768,
-0.7374071479,
-0.2150694132,
-0.1495473236,
0.0080989599,
-0.4482709467,
0.4936027527,
-0.356231004,
0.196129933,
-0.2408051193,
0.1004712582,
-0.5232314467,
0.3252457082,
-0.0717703253,
0.4052502215,
0.2421344221,
-0.6469617486,
0.2713804543,
-0.1457803547,
-0.2431885898,
0.955814898,
-0.4662112594,
0.3626343906,
-0.3582726121,
0.025871193,
-0.7533117533,
-0.2710179985,
0.5460288525,
-0.7870572805,
0.0473320298,
-0.2323701978,
-0.2769576311,
-0.2740108073,
-0.1265604794,
0.2348535359,
0.11464715,
-0.3978880942,
0.7266434431,
1.0961441994,
-0.0479171984,
-0.597189188,
-0.6247789264,
0.3093240261,
-0.6482519507,
-0.1854056716,
0.4292218685,
-0.1834383458,
-0.4664745629,
0.1564730406,
-0.0445027649,
-0.3260129988,
0.1057828367,
0.5958759189,
0.0980669782,
0.080487296,
0.4494718015,
-0.1510173678,
0.2345272452,
0.109618023,
0.2470777482,
0.4810821712,
-0.1417622864,
0.1443642974,
-0.2808429003,
0.4026552141,
0.4996494353,
-0.3768180311,
0.5557530522,
0.6813253164,
-0.7425453067,
-0.3301496506,
-0.7309284806,
0.0852032602,
-0.4429019988,
0.3584885597,
-0.048203811,
-1.1764860153,
0.590628624,
0.1757158488,
-0.0126796179,
0.4230704904,
0.2130444348,
0.1963227689,
0.8282544017,
0.708820641,
-0.2969644964,
0.6386402249,
0.3475895822,
0.4554587603,
-0.6936757565,
-0.1838569492,
-0.4017646015,
-0.406432569,
-0.6363298297,
-0.1695908606,
0.1969179958,
-0.1494330764,
-0.068831414,
0.4950839579,
-0.7572652698,
0.6451997757,
0.1326988935,
-0.0680701807,
0.177126348,
0.1559139788,
0.0961407423,
-0.2445500791,
0.208956331,
-0.6106963158,
1.0175132751,
0.4271071553,
0.5774927735,
0.1773044914,
0.8826501966,
0.8598139882,
0.990029037,
-0.7977470756,
0.858709991,
-0.1256159246,
-0.8141530156,
-0.1356049329,
-0.4707133472,
-0.59083426,
0.1549258083,
-0.1394740641,
-0.9381949902,
0.1180445477,
0.0229200404,
-0.5050993562,
0.6164065599,
-0.4849146903,
0.4818596244,
-0.1452684999,
0.0552189015,
0.0920538679,
-0.3302452862,
0.3386717737,
-0.2387663573,
0.2305769771,
-0.3534849286,
-0.1011001095,
1.0317524672,
-0.0697896332,
0.8074778318,
-0.3949811459,
-0.0475535616,
0.2298808992,
-0.2355305851,
0.1264681518,
-0.2590969503,
-0.0880454332,
0.2693188488,
-0.5655459762,
0.1478337198,
-0.5095616579,
0.7265897393,
-0.4585671425,
-0.3452113569,
-0.2591635883,
-0.1908726692,
0.0603527725,
0.4291487336,
0.1783288121,
-0.0450011566,
-0.5305165052,
0.0641006008,
0.7381951213,
-0.0267498158,
0.3111073971,
0.6875380278,
-0.5212001204,
-0.6562350392,
1.0159697533,
0.3730362058,
-0.0037764313,
0.2873570025,
-0.3310803175,
0.0170795396,
-0.4535960853,
-0.3751403391,
0.2124066055,
-0.4983608723,
-0.3747964799,
-1.1242908239,
-0.2559576333,
-0.452499181,
0.1428358704,
-0.022391988,
-0.1788318902,
-0.017238725,
-0.1317623258,
0.0987128913,
0.7469449043,
-0.0378306694,
0.4680744112,
-0.3692126274,
0.5051686168,
0.4843461514,
0.3770567477,
0.0502332821,
-0.3537620008,
-0.0424083509,
-0.1208109036,
-0.2728573978,
-1.450720191,
0.1110814288,
-0.0442194343,
0.3438310027,
0.5460519195,
0.1733611524,
0.5702914,
-0.6135904193,
0.3578595817,
0.1784789711,
-0.8728640079,
0.5431799293,
-0.1240570471,
-0.3869020343,
0.4517718256,
0.5902863145,
-0.7849208713,
-0.5282480121,
-0.6091598272,
-0.5838519335,
0.3726696372,
0.2045150399,
0.0851123855,
-0.365641892,
0.2626556456,
-0.2384266257,
0.3146405518,
-1.2287474871,
-0.5653925538,
0.0705456361,
-0.0125529664,
0.3315815032,
-0.2830641866,
0.0653363615,
-0.1931699663,
0.7850336432,
0.1854291707,
0.2412488908,
0.0132578285,
-0.1574526429,
-0.1024781615,
0.4362644851,
0.0903157964,
0.1450431794,
-0.0090874108,
0.2353200763,
0.0525648668,
-0.3719362915,
0.275616914,
0.2525256872,
-0.3313207626,
0.3498505354,
-0.1404676139,
0.4684875309,
-0.1907283962,
-0.5463386774,
0.4529106021,
-0.107959345,
0.0928940773,
-0.6572201848,
0.1912098378,
0.1481172889,
0.222951591,
0.5496034622,
0.0429435074,
0.4410175681,
-0.3016827404,
0.216098845,
0.6367800832,
-0.7601291537,
-0.3981258869,
0.3515278399,
0.2946597338,
-0.5764638186,
0.1864086241,
-0.6745640635,
-0.784090519,
0.573923707,
0.4941869378,
0.8803628683,
-0.7654711008,
0.4540661573,
0.4157941341,
0.5659441948,
0.5163863897,
0.0010528483,
-0.0899114385,
-0.9726805687,
0.096292533,
-0.7925186753,
-0.1902564615,
0.5127443671,
-0.5957888365,
0.3224318027,
-0.9759274125,
-0.3536805511,
0.8327348828,
-0.2017182112,
-0.3643790185,
0.3008998632,
0.6609594226,
0.5622026324,
-0.9247020483,
0.270932734,
0.8901758194,
-0.2400481701,
-0.6165133119,
0.0735101253,
0.4104610384,
-0.5640502572,
0.7403661609,
0.7122941017,
-0.2544396818,
-0.0479228497,
-0.6445757747,
-0.735131979,
0.4002975821,
0.2489552498,
-0.5125997663,
0.0347907245,
0.1491598934,
0.6425876617,
-0.441698581,
-0.0562106445,
0.2976740599,
0.3360393643,
-0.1420003325,
-0.7667563558,
0.1787958294,
-0.6182509065,
-0.0667929575,
0.5334046483,
-0.6520071626,
0.8072162867,
-0.0010828057,
-0.6334093213,
-0.3237257004,
0.7435768843,
-0.0593231507,
0.4557234645,
1.032777667,
0.6563687921,
0.8261474967,
0.1242356747,
0.3171510994,
0.0732520893,
0.0346560329,
1.2113987207,
-0.2507533133,
0.5984653234,
0.2070335299,
-0.1203365251,
0.829584837,
0.310654074,
-0.3128497601,
0.2455700934,
0.6890566349,
-0.7153285742,
-0.1217527539,
-0.6280756593,
-0.3508858979,
0.4861222804,
0.4910434783,
-0.7050192952,
-0.1981046796,
0.1726577282,
0.4361591041,
0.2133399248,
-0.5081049204,
0.8105438948,
-0.0925374851,
-0.3095606565,
0.03526292,
0.2289366126,
0.9325629473,
-0.4073168933,
0.0418887213,
0.1880156696,
0.2065020055,
-0.4953559935,
-0.3000386953,
0.3077717721,
0.4010079801,
-0.4786091745,
0.2694770694,
0.8581742048,
-0.4137024879,
-0.464540422,
0.5419052839,
0.1364545673,
0.1972109526,
-0.3836192191,
-0.6282449365,
0.1966436207,
0.0894510075,
0.1226430163,
0.1662981808,
0.2440243959,
-0.0952133685,
0.4078983068,
0.4745918512,
0.0026650529,
0.1669284254,
-0.0161674377,
0.9456279874,
-0.6586984992,
-0.4873436987,
-0.9835210443,
0.2137773186,
-0.6798209548,
-0.2834509015,
0.9122678041,
0.7104433775,
1.0264773369,
0.3423271775,
0.8694713116,
-0.2584955692,
1.2781889439,
0.1067427248,
0.6695070267,
-0.480417341,
0.1290956587,
-0.7620517612,
-0.7548676133,
-0.4908014536,
0.4293512404,
-0.3641543984,
0.0196010247,
0.4086526632,
0.8689935207,
0.0671165958,
0.1058298573,
0.0062008696,
0.2522912323,
0.5511997938,
0.1631799787,
0.8149172664,
-0.3166954219,
0.6490244865,
-0.0131667061,
-0.3479232192,
-0.0189849567,
-0.6703155637,
-1.0820826292,
-0.2834619582,
-0.5245352387,
-0.4571894407,
0.1414353997,
0.8286281228,
0.4153247774,
-0.7789849043,
-0.04911457,
0.3083197773,
0.2568413615,
0.2238247991,
-0.3396505117,
-0.0212245546,
0.035865508,
-0.5689707994,
0.1604319215,
0.4065868855,
-0.0870802253,
-0.2569746971,
0.0321859941,
-0.2118509114,
0.1660405695,
0.3837886751,
0.4552760124,
-0.7433416843,
-0.3389889598,
-0.1435020119,
-0.0281505361,
-0.1872956604,
0.7813647389,
-0.6218967438,
0.2587310374,
0.0250604078,
0.8828992248,
-0.0242616441,
-0.0660833567,
-0.1312297583,
-0.513477385,
-0.1844210476,
0.4036681056,
0.1912587583,
0.5746802092,
-0.6067613959,
0.3631315231,
0.4847664833,
-0.4380945265,
-0.9958898425,
0.3653315306,
-0.7792589068,
0.0427817069,
1.0081409216,
-0.014210551,
-0.2212665677,
-0.3163901269,
-0.1095558405,
0.2088861316,
-0.7216001749,
0.7764499784,
0.5844703317,
0.102041766,
-0.0279704016,
-0.1653755903,
0.5016445518,
0.1206182688,
-0.881596148,
-0.1908116341,
0.6275629401,
0.4563351274,
0.4232360423,
0.9492768049,
-0.1941485405,
0.1704343706,
-0.3783297241,
0.1431907117,
0.3298254609,
-0.2618537247,
-0.0624653772,
0.3648846149,
-0.4821737111,
-0.1721085757
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08134v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08134v1
|
Many-Shot Regurgitation (MSR) Prompting
| 2024-05-13T19:22:40 | 2024-05-13T19:22:40 |
Shashank Sonkar, Richard G. Baraniuk
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce Many-Shot Regurgitation (MSR) prompting, a new black-box
membership inference attack framework for examining verbatim content
reproduction in large language models (LLMs). MSR prompting involves dividing
the input text into multiple segments and creating a single prompt that
includes a series of faux conversation rounds between a user and a language
model to elicit verbatim regurgitation. We apply MSR prompting to diverse text
sources, including Wikipedia articles and open educational resources (OER)
textbooks, which provide high-quality, factual content and are continuously
updated over time. For each source, we curate two dataset types: one that LLMs
were likely exposed to during training ($D_{\rm pre}$) and another consisting
of documents published after the models' training cutoff dates ($D_{\rm
post}$). To quantify the occurrence of verbatim matches, we employ the Longest
Common Substring algorithm and count the frequency of matches at different
length thresholds. We then use statistical measures such as Cliff's delta,
Kolmogorov-Smirnov (KS) distance, and Kruskal-Wallis H test to determine
whether the distribution of verbatim matches differs significantly between
$D_{\rm pre}$ and $D_{\rm post}$. Our findings reveal a striking difference in
the distribution of verbatim matches between $D_{\rm pre}$ and $D_{\rm post}$,
with the frequency of verbatim reproduction being significantly higher when
LLMs (e.g. GPT models and LLaMAs) are prompted with text from datasets they
were likely trained on. For instance, when using GPT-3.5 on Wikipedia articles,
we observe a substantial effect size (Cliff's delta $= -0.984$) and a large KS
distance ($0.875$) between the distributions of $D_{\rm pre}$ and $D_{\rm
post}$. Our results provide compelling evidence that LLMs are more prone to
reproducing verbatim content when the input text is likely sourced from their
training data.
|
[
-0.3134949803,
-1.0527993441,
0.3552309871,
0.0017551117,
-0.3988288343,
-0.2777945995,
-0.0695431232,
-0.1547681987,
-0.0454812869,
0.1747683287,
-0.7709552646,
-0.3493987918,
-0.6136876941,
0.4644709527,
-0.6098704934,
1.0054913759,
0.2135850489,
0.3364447355,
-0.0553642027,
0.1081940532,
-0.723669827,
-0.8158792853,
-0.4934036434,
0.072204344,
0.913300693,
0.1934543848,
0.5182825923,
0.4032072127,
0.4351608753,
0.2491755784,
-0.2242399007,
0.0817079544,
-0.8167282939,
0.5766715407,
0.0172247235,
-0.4449941218,
0.0424218066,
-0.3055173755,
0.8749040961,
0.0082167964,
-0.259557873,
0.0699809268,
0.2827687562,
0.7640557289,
-0.6658214331,
-0.2737145126,
-0.6994739175,
0.1322205216,
-0.3841108978,
-0.6694124341,
-0.7957667112,
-0.1473359466,
-0.0978421643,
-0.3202966154,
0.4739850163,
0.08067137,
1.1061455011,
-0.0090782344,
-0.2380950004,
-0.2622192204,
-0.751786232,
0.4964790344,
-0.4579138756,
0.6849217415,
0.3226804733,
0.3138549924,
-0.5631738901,
-0.4003385305,
-0.8636838198,
-0.169779852,
0.0473749712,
0.1347697526,
-0.6258657575,
0.1281986088,
0.414539516,
0.3539037406,
-1.0651946068,
0.0652902722,
-0.5832426548,
-0.1113424525,
0.2673619986,
0.1383094937,
0.2913599908,
-0.4198708236,
-0.3161079884,
-0.2006631196,
-0.7461640239,
-0.1158944592,
0.630251348,
0.3542962968,
-0.0752985999,
1.0632838011,
-0.1605711132,
1.0147519112,
0.0717966333,
-0.1761385798,
0.1505565494,
-0.4270244241,
-0.3524713516,
-0.0816314742,
1.0047615767,
0.5581283569,
0.5187496543,
0.3263083994,
-0.0718813241,
-0.0580095202,
0.352751404,
-0.8096464872,
-0.2097265273,
0.1630523354,
-0.4134114385,
-0.0572173484,
0.2981175184,
-1.0127822161,
-0.3795437813,
-0.2166546881,
0.7423266768,
-0.5403686166,
-0.0363724343,
0.0863030255,
-0.5355163217,
0.268991828,
0.2294470221,
-0.6793655753,
-0.2611046433,
0.6315594912,
1.1166909933,
-0.1507047862,
-0.6269811392,
-0.6931909323,
0.0249013081,
-0.2199873626,
1.0334762335,
-0.6329475045,
-0.3934547007,
0.254270643,
0.2312496603,
-0.0687946379,
-0.462602824,
0.3278276026,
-0.698525548,
0.1346169859,
-0.3391454518,
-0.5804461837,
-0.1183939949,
0.3025684357,
-0.6958562136,
1.0550824404,
-0.1642709672,
-0.9581788182,
0.7428508997,
-0.3788302541,
-0.1949723661,
-0.217340216,
-0.3037461936,
-0.4568229914,
0.0159193296,
0.24037835,
0.6349760294,
-0.0340890139,
-0.0262068342,
-0.2391840965,
-0.4299153686,
0.4449789524,
-0.8183757663,
0.339006424,
0.1160957664,
-0.0528042242,
0.2777642012,
-0.4769904613,
-0.424154222,
0.2606348097,
-0.2306860685,
-0.2414960563,
0.1820699275,
-0.1043148264,
0.2590425909,
-0.4247128665,
-0.2027578354,
0.3246642053,
-0.2325980663,
0.0920532569,
0.8259267807,
0.5870449543,
0.1039869711,
-0.7121778727,
0.789173305,
0.1494819969,
0.100096941,
-0.6163633466,
-0.6147734523,
-0.4281737208,
-0.5854923725,
-0.0482886359,
0.4277909994,
-0.775652945,
0.2846500576,
-0.3799173534,
-0.5058116317,
-0.5181836486,
-0.0205696598,
0.2117361128,
0.3493223786,
0.5407724977,
-0.0536990352,
-0.5069769025,
-0.6826965213,
-0.1501336992,
-0.1503238231,
-0.0014051727,
0.1534323096,
0.4394623935,
0.0958616361,
0.8527416587,
-0.4337879717,
-0.3058857918,
-0.2869589031,
0.2270694226,
0.0636299625,
0.242698878,
0.5122503042,
-0.6424356699,
-0.3603898883,
-0.250418663,
-0.6863666177,
0.1782762706,
-0.3437587619,
-0.0973022804,
0.3601715565,
0.4278565049,
-0.6482517719,
0.5569281578,
0.7301580906,
-0.2094546556,
0.8941671848,
0.0576219857,
0.7375606298,
-1.2019329071,
0.0450911932,
0.0258219428,
0.019621063,
-0.5734474063,
0.0517440327,
-0.1729458272,
-0.1411855221,
-0.5669513941,
0.3222802579,
-0.5824673772,
-0.0309701152,
-0.1426059306,
0.2067715526,
-0.1156654954,
0.0665697828,
-0.1706207395,
1.2432587147,
0.5093180537,
-0.6998625994,
0.2693341374,
0.3327681124,
-0.275021553,
0.6139317155,
-0.7997854948,
-0.0586694106,
-0.5425246358,
0.2907184958,
-1.4485404491,
-0.4120324254,
0.2827713788,
-0.7432727814,
0.2311036438,
-0.5701878071,
-0.6175421476,
-0.3678514361,
-0.3633404374,
0.3105059266,
0.5261567235,
-0.347838223,
0.2179804593,
0.1104482934,
-0.2623874545,
-0.8750347495,
-0.661035955,
0.1324188709,
0.0541491993,
-0.5607799292,
-0.2140826732,
-0.0996492431,
0.0749605224,
-0.105134137,
0.0088169118,
0.0509543531,
-0.1761176884,
0.2999163568,
0.4614263773,
-0.2949128449,
0.2310770303,
0.2050319165,
0.1220063418,
-0.1925869882,
-0.071069032,
0.9368028045,
0.3007028699,
-0.6687716246,
-0.6893780231,
0.4383467138,
0.4417534471,
-0.3384214342,
0.9838049412,
0.4283629954,
-0.2580851614,
0.0555755198,
-0.6992230415,
-0.4477789104,
-0.4770888686,
0.4676471651,
-0.3312632143,
-1.0910201073,
0.3163180947,
0.4702409804,
0.2474570572,
0.3595754206,
0.8202568889,
-0.042432148,
0.7965093851,
0.2492221296,
-0.046373453,
0.7330178022,
-0.0118428003,
-0.1013344005,
-0.418464154,
-0.1518661827,
-0.77055794,
-0.0745575503,
-0.4220584333,
-0.6025725007,
0.2304188907,
0.1022598818,
0.0417596847,
0.1243249774,
-0.5087268949,
0.706982553,
0.2366643846,
0.0246310513,
0.1869723648,
0.3457543254,
-0.1160875931,
-0.2273624539,
-0.804243207,
-0.3610062003,
0.957662344,
0.192468524,
0.8105877638,
0.312584281,
0.6947673559,
0.3567107618,
0.3336206675,
-1.1539872885,
0.4603214264,
0.0983677208,
-0.7184811831,
-0.3211956918,
-0.4018677175,
-1.482563138,
0.2258883715,
-0.5090397596,
-0.6597080827,
0.0698839128,
0.3482686877,
-0.2488444746,
0.3015267551,
-0.476292491,
0.6559335589,
0.4385808706,
-0.2031092048,
-0.0767574757,
-0.5263200402,
0.401312232,
-0.010046728,
0.2079901397,
0.0026285981,
0.0800663605,
0.5714713335,
-0.0741061866,
0.69352597,
-0.1408667117,
-0.0318578891,
0.210194543,
0.2946482301,
0.6670187712,
-0.2886771858,
-0.1772833765,
0.0127881439,
-0.0663838536,
-0.2648652494,
-0.4990306199,
0.4225552976,
-0.5208032727,
-0.6599136591,
-0.639379859,
-0.2293286473,
0.151324451,
0.1762354523,
0.5305668712,
0.5403081179,
-0.1374732554,
0.4373994172,
0.6050739288,
-0.1828264147,
0.3001634479,
0.2785447836,
-0.2594217658,
-0.5448631644,
0.7020537853,
0.2197574079,
0.4749830067,
0.3366165459,
0.0316271372,
-0.4050807357,
-0.7028239369,
-0.6566669941,
0.4595950544,
-0.7375130057,
-0.3330918252,
-0.6806855202,
-0.2303034514,
-0.3746528924,
-0.0940501094,
0.0663641542,
0.1609485,
-0.4242586195,
-0.2064767182,
0.6177331805,
0.924705565,
0.2062590569,
0.382286638,
-1.2801829576,
0.2622765005,
0.0664689541,
0.0068177227,
0.0750382468,
-1.0680955648,
-0.019761879,
-0.1216699108,
-0.2130373269,
-1.4868446589,
0.2745248079,
0.2123562396,
0.5704194903,
0.5086246729,
0.0507911816,
1.0464656353,
-0.9256270528,
1.1354625225,
0.2227068841,
-0.5793409944,
0.4770551026,
-0.5082761049,
0.1872935444,
0.5292771459,
0.7595436573,
-0.7458286881,
-0.6723275185,
-0.3838985264,
-0.6675220728,
0.5299881697,
0.0712648854,
0.3621397913,
-0.473769486,
0.3841206133,
-0.0201119352,
0.0886319429,
-0.6158051491,
-0.4542779326,
-0.0649403185,
-0.0652445182,
-0.1854209751,
-0.6163778305,
-0.1891841143,
0.0182789061,
0.4366087019,
-0.0697057098,
0.3731308877,
0.5129477382,
-0.3096437454,
-0.1325946599,
0.3881438673,
1.0072777271,
0.7353115678,
0.0317196026,
0.1634166688,
0.020028377,
-0.5449833274,
0.3969045579,
-0.0162305329,
-0.0469141193,
0.3101479113,
0.3181126714,
0.7114571929,
0.1353874952,
-0.567841351,
0.9253599048,
0.0239229053,
-0.3145115674,
-0.1870133132,
-0.068389751,
-0.0259459373,
0.1281076372,
0.5226091743,
-0.0768246651,
0.0961820334,
-0.3670964837,
0.5963106155,
0.3901373446,
-0.3632086515,
-0.2695412636,
0.3867204487,
-0.2372015566,
-0.3309620917,
0.5977518559,
-0.2617188096,
-0.3607083857,
0.1088846922,
0.6813442111,
0.6189284921,
-0.3655301034,
0.2047564536,
0.6798645854,
0.3993984461,
-0.2368510664,
0.3866685927,
0.3203794956,
-0.5135518909,
-0.6226410866,
-0.5950991511,
-0.0113791823,
0.1361887157,
-0.7975565791,
0.358284384,
-0.3912648261,
-0.2415096015,
0.0504222922,
-0.6904622912,
-0.2839640081,
-0.0768084452,
-0.1257949322,
0.8489456177,
-0.980977416,
0.5186966062,
0.446451962,
-0.5742796659,
-0.634663403,
0.2915539443,
0.5728696585,
-0.7305027843,
0.5050939918,
0.2270073295,
-0.0986789763,
0.0077749416,
-0.4046107829,
-0.532733798,
0.8629224896,
0.3475103378,
-0.7538747787,
0.0700074658,
-0.1566662341,
0.2906815112,
0.1422936916,
0.0779091194,
0.2360311002,
0.2558415532,
0.376478076,
-0.6869348884,
0.2085478008,
-0.0281783398,
-0.1594545096,
0.5204674006,
-0.4081527293,
0.7472821474,
-0.2753634453,
-0.4192839861,
0.0114071751,
0.7756557465,
0.7839000225,
0.0908854976,
0.4953680336,
0.1439243555,
0.7587666512,
0.0187164005,
1.0801813602,
-0.1375007927,
0.3523701727,
1.0631061792,
-0.0594521351,
1.4164559841,
0.8048838973,
-0.3211007416,
0.3104424179,
0.7006080747,
-0.3500784338,
0.2068961859,
0.2290614396,
-0.3842950165,
-0.012598481,
0.0136606107,
-0.5865311623,
0.1251560748,
0.1071887612,
-0.3558677137,
-0.1224296838,
0.1002213731,
0.2664375603,
-0.1253188699,
-0.0161672849,
0.9127496481,
-0.0505835451,
-0.5300221443,
0.6853488684,
-0.30581972,
0.7635264397,
-0.8549947739,
-0.1543631107,
-0.165361166,
-0.2485935092,
-0.2462744266,
-0.8909033537,
0.2580897212,
0.2296550572,
-0.3177120686,
0.2590476871,
0.5989216566,
-0.5028021932,
-0.2399494946,
0.1482315809,
0.5751778483,
0.4426731169,
-0.1632572412,
-0.6990616322,
0.1878187507,
-0.0951392278,
-0.46979478,
0.4731010795,
0.5522229075,
0.2228256911,
0.603751123,
1.0803124905,
0.2620314956,
0.2984276116,
0.3104903996,
0.8839277029,
-0.5995503664,
-0.3725569546,
-1.1536208391,
0.5903539658,
0.0151736727,
-0.2361353487,
0.9292818308,
0.6690165997,
0.6523621082,
-0.2469198108,
0.5673264861,
0.0940735713,
0.1722885519,
-0.8414170146,
0.8119379878,
-0.7855943441,
-0.0113823954,
-0.4483321607,
-0.8416159153,
-0.3464134634,
0.4210943878,
-0.0749936774,
0.0704134107,
0.6937823892,
1.3154649734,
0.0262267273,
-0.1663364172,
0.5075134039,
0.0754310489,
0.3201788664,
-0.1482450068,
1.0767713785,
-0.1614744812,
0.7483912706,
0.2941757441,
-0.1680368036,
-0.5671530366,
-0.7500340939,
-0.9372245669,
-0.691298306,
0.0275316257,
-0.7093824744,
0.3466373384,
1.2926603556,
0.5068870187,
-0.645696342,
-0.1168621331,
0.1643725634,
-0.0550500415,
-0.2410103679,
-0.3003929257,
0.2181138247,
-0.4059486389,
-0.5428432226,
0.3210635483,
0.1509376168,
0.5334622264,
-0.1091026217,
0.0773414299,
-0.4428743422,
0.1082230732,
0.7175483704,
0.2264918685,
-0.8284016252,
-0.310477972,
0.2465519756,
-0.1421197355,
0.2392376661,
0.8455469608,
-0.2575416267,
0.5222152472,
0.6956648827,
0.7099753022,
0.2740702331,
0.0757297948,
0.532569766,
-0.9171915054,
0.1960198283,
-0.0237023327,
0.3241084814,
0.1718230098,
-0.3243150413,
0.1448528767,
0.439209193,
-0.6577000022,
-1.0656683445,
0.1147358865,
-0.960237205,
-0.2605292499,
1.4793972969,
-0.2038495988,
-0.1726359576,
-0.2074842155,
-0.4996167719,
0.275803566,
-0.6856352687,
0.5126197934,
0.9332951307,
0.003259663,
-0.576151669,
-0.7876297832,
0.6111949086,
0.2802316546,
-0.7236210704,
0.2959750891,
0.7757593989,
0.3316954076,
-0.0755768642,
0.5060314536,
-0.0707847625,
0.6069162488,
0.153313905,
0.0545276962,
-0.1182499379,
-0.4736932814,
-0.8703947663,
0.252397269,
0.2505732477,
-0.1869460493
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16892v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16892v1
|
Multilingual Entity Linking Using Dense Retrieval
| 2024-05-13T18:57:27 | 2024-05-13T18:57:27 |
Dominik Farhan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Entity linking (EL) is the computational process of connecting textual
mentions to corresponding entities. Like many areas of natural language
processing, the EL field has greatly benefited from deep learning, leading to
significant performance improvements. However, present-day approaches are
expensive to train and rely on diverse data sources, complicating their
reproducibility. In this thesis, we develop multiple systems that are fast to
train, demonstrating that competitive entity linking can be achieved without a
large GPU cluster. Moreover, we train on a publicly available dataset, ensuring
reproducibility and accessibility. Our models are evaluated for 9 languages
giving an accurate overview of their strengths. Furthermore, we offer
a~detailed analysis of bi-encoder training hyperparameters, a popular approach
in EL, to guide their informed selection. Overall, our work shows that building
competitive neural network based EL systems that operate in multiple languages
is possible even with limited resources, thus making EL more approachable.
|
[
-0.5920706987,
-0.808621943,
0.4423384666,
0.3972919881,
0.0968960598,
0.1121157482,
-0.6422179937,
-1.0092742443,
0.2856171131,
0.2867918909,
-0.0753792673,
-0.3391603529,
-0.2732177079,
0.4706190228,
-0.4494613409,
0.9561567307,
-0.068791613,
0.094722867,
-0.0556320809,
-0.4352702498,
-0.1639979035,
-0.4585813582,
-0.9967272282,
-0.1626122743,
0.9290997982,
0.3737852871,
0.6935303211,
0.631190002,
0.4853831828,
0.3522236645,
0.1584563553,
0.085355036,
-0.5054790378,
0.5206729174,
-0.3500753641,
-0.4017859995,
-0.1110478267,
-0.6239469051,
0.8910418153,
0.7525903583,
-0.056418743,
0.1750084758,
0.0295620542,
0.7434533834,
-0.6664837599,
0.1229179054,
-1.0359264612,
-0.2048098296,
-0.5837704539,
0.2032781094,
-0.4723132849,
-0.3351747692,
0.2643862367,
-0.7721138597,
0.3570393622,
0.2953404784,
0.9326099753,
0.0857075751,
-0.2863363922,
-0.4128272831,
-0.7111746669,
0.7152915001,
-0.2212355882,
0.9244784713,
0.295918107,
0.2231565118,
0.3353294432,
-0.7099383473,
-0.5018697381,
-0.1698126197,
0.0444878414,
-0.1255872548,
0.1871018261,
-0.0309878383,
0.2006734759,
0.2575867176,
-0.6200175285,
0.1902763098,
-0.1442988515,
0.0577022396,
0.6365109086,
-0.081329532,
0.3360734284,
0.1268057823,
-0.2632348537,
0.0604688078,
-0.8374277353,
-0.516677916,
0.5879616737,
0.3729362786,
0.1547666043,
0.6543515325,
-0.0175321475,
0.4245771468,
-0.0666044801,
0.0861507133,
0.409527272,
-0.5187860131,
-0.1295597702,
0.3419262469,
0.7045300007,
-0.1682175696,
0.3717877269,
-0.5718527436,
-0.2640764415,
-0.0617888011,
0.0772656649,
-0.565515697,
-0.1188989952,
0.009816193,
-0.3630212843,
0.2696957588,
-0.2880679071,
-0.8100887537,
0.0923670083,
-0.3191517293,
0.2710736096,
-0.5825865865,
-0.3446186483,
0.1620402336,
0.0694891363,
-0.1499387026,
0.1193985641,
-1.0541492701,
0.3327914476,
0.3004637361,
0.7083520889,
0.0644668862,
-0.6866530776,
-0.1870744526,
0.6303781867,
-0.0161972679,
0.7760794759,
-0.5774057508,
-0.0461658463,
0.2503490448,
-0.0128182136,
-0.0888285786,
-0.6961533427,
0.6657909155,
-1.0086829662,
-0.146530211,
-0.278170526,
-0.6335240602,
-0.1285775453,
0.2215859741,
-1.1516615152,
1.237147212,
-0.3403660357,
-0.9255871773,
0.4413951337,
-0.4395994842,
-0.6623771191,
0.3468016088,
-0.0808659792,
-0.307820797,
-0.2149679512,
0.1362643838,
0.3797781169,
-0.2976415455,
0.1236240119,
-0.4726195037,
-0.3256167769,
-0.3241634667,
-0.2503045797,
0.5048334599,
0.3459231555,
-0.3842602968,
-0.3292360902,
-0.8454500437,
-0.1813794523,
0.26734972,
-0.8711698055,
-0.7765396833,
0.0293605514,
0.2542982996,
0.0635740235,
0.2074122429,
-0.4394537508,
0.1700118035,
-0.4254150093,
0.1108255833,
0.4216060042,
-0.1155179515,
0.49668926,
0.174969241,
-0.0061701098,
-0.0310176406,
-0.268817246,
-0.1621833295,
-0.4077049196,
-0.9743769169,
-0.0693408921,
0.5372549295,
0.4947239459,
-1.2810947895,
0.2095590234,
-0.312384665,
-0.3488114774,
-0.8928206563,
0.4117155671,
0.2393817753,
0.3098919988,
0.6464810967,
-0.0674900785,
-0.4795050025,
-0.8928533792,
-0.3595840335,
-0.1183734536,
0.0240901113,
0.4940148592,
0.6727960706,
-0.1093707755,
0.2286077738,
-0.2235208303,
-0.2172525674,
-0.2471553832,
0.1207702607,
0.0614705868,
0.2854626179,
0.6551687717,
-0.8039715886,
-0.7988503575,
0.3532354832,
-0.8837342262,
0.2528286278,
-0.1976130456,
-0.1882259548,
0.116320394,
0.4299007058,
-0.4005838931,
0.0085857818,
0.34264943,
0.1212585866,
0.4503440559,
-0.281331718,
0.0584679432,
-0.7562817335,
0.1708464772,
0.4060609043,
0.0162145831,
-0.2021816224,
0.1730374396,
-0.0053853942,
-0.0213928223,
-0.4550889134,
0.4703172445,
-0.8262758851,
-0.2076894492,
0.076295957,
0.4309266508,
-0.0376107544,
0.5967130661,
0.2516251802,
0.6981611252,
0.6686806679,
-0.8014076948,
0.5544930696,
0.1030699536,
-0.2695302367,
0.7792441249,
-0.7001818419,
0.0390545651,
-0.4182652235,
-0.0674632564,
-0.3331285417,
-0.1107360944,
-0.1424179822,
-0.1535088271,
0.3088372946,
-0.0976865366,
-0.7109588385,
-0.1700935364,
0.020034777,
0.7509202957,
-0.1895528436,
-0.6815021038,
0.3606463075,
0.5104248524,
-0.1538187712,
-0.623472333,
-0.7047880888,
0.1598040015,
-0.103235364,
-0.5807812214,
0.4249583185,
-0.1349295527,
-0.0463007502,
0.3459931612,
0.3102677464,
-0.4798567593,
0.0905759484,
-0.2224603891,
0.0672699437,
-0.404987067,
0.5262667537,
-0.0313421637,
0.0779094324,
-0.0479922369,
-0.3420709074,
0.2249842882,
-0.1999352276,
-0.4537829459,
-0.3238351345,
0.7155539393,
0.3195869029,
-0.610675931,
1.0901865959,
0.6614067554,
-0.7594456077,
-0.2663814723,
-0.6724610329,
0.0962316245,
-0.3608690798,
0.5899816155,
-0.5765676498,
-0.7534723282,
0.4141953886,
-0.1276499331,
0.0720398203,
0.5229366422,
0.7033779621,
0.1964958906,
0.796489954,
0.576742053,
-0.0632089153,
0.3732701242,
-0.1662499756,
0.2407552153,
-0.620292604,
-0.6057896018,
-0.9245560765,
-0.3794283867,
-0.5506338477,
-0.1302322298,
0.1769925654,
0.1659291834,
-0.5110875964,
0.6944330931,
-0.2180683613,
0.6723574996,
0.6317150593,
0.0831728727,
0.4336253703,
0.1323027611,
-0.5877836943,
-0.1521452665,
-0.8073399663,
-0.3489298522,
0.8773810863,
0.2858056128,
0.8527385592,
0.3818356693,
0.5773507953,
0.0653688088,
0.1995515227,
-0.6019337177,
0.3147924244,
0.0483869985,
-0.8485907912,
-0.4514749646,
-0.3732167184,
-1.038774848,
0.2730416954,
-0.7224609852,
-0.3431040347,
0.194305703,
-0.1829539537,
-0.0768256485,
0.5441912413,
-0.7485554814,
0.6610384583,
-0.4050867856,
-0.7941541672,
-0.2815116346,
-0.5628533363,
-0.0111659057,
-0.1703595966,
-0.0313656032,
0.0579309687,
-0.0330897532,
0.5072340965,
0.278719306,
0.3436802924,
0.2873258591,
0.1001307964,
0.2420417666,
-0.0470410399,
0.4065510631,
0.3240849674,
-0.4357284307,
0.28199175,
-0.5765739083,
-0.5127979517,
-0.3585409522,
1.0749331713,
-0.7113699317,
-0.0647190139,
-0.0948300213,
-0.2240893096,
-0.1647772491,
0.3511930704,
0.1740297824,
0.1866029352,
-0.4034768939,
0.4502873719,
1.0435688496,
-0.1599471122,
0.5956819654,
0.2376802862,
0.2670507431,
-0.366541177,
0.8115751147,
0.1085166857,
-0.0782543644,
0.6418499351,
-0.5715606213,
-0.5426691175,
-0.4045189321,
-0.6708617806,
0.5278691053,
-0.5469539762,
-0.3170834184,
-0.8155661821,
-0.1018764079,
-0.2597437501,
-0.2715608776,
-0.5319342017,
-0.0753637925,
-0.1692892313,
-0.2187741846,
-0.1393982023,
0.6935546398,
0.2542261183,
-0.1037707478,
-0.7147384882,
0.1337267309,
0.2372693866,
0.8821277618,
0.3890304863,
0.3577383757,
-0.8084027767,
-0.2644928694,
-0.137676239,
-1.1284151077,
0.1923688203,
0.3565776646,
0.9304494262,
0.2854742408,
-0.2562705576,
0.6043537259,
-0.7916009426,
0.5361878276,
0.2508111894,
-0.8843827248,
0.4975629747,
-0.0319921672,
-0.2242478728,
0.7555236816,
1.0000085831,
-0.4020339847,
-0.1308270246,
-0.499240756,
-1.0321800709,
0.2904748321,
0.2124741226,
-0.0959210917,
-0.4486807287,
0.3667453527,
-0.0163615737,
0.153829664,
-0.6691518426,
-0.5459253788,
-0.0076030307,
-0.1520536989,
0.0612590611,
-0.1431825459,
0.1022261456,
-0.0076478962,
0.9206085205,
-0.100777179,
0.1522342563,
0.2452085614,
-0.647575736,
0.0631993338,
0.3168320656,
0.0947587341,
0.4845956564,
0.1643726081,
0.2211150974,
0.3556046784,
-0.1678188592,
0.0944289044,
0.0295654777,
-0.1177713126,
0.3317630291,
0.1183094829,
0.8696471453,
0.5119134188,
-0.5345916152,
0.3011156023,
0.0007932395,
-0.0235554222,
-0.0916304141,
-0.3496720791,
0.3476997316,
0.3632114232,
0.2380470783,
-0.1279448569,
0.2931541204,
-0.4254314899,
0.3082130253,
0.3625665307,
-0.218592748,
-0.4235803485,
1.0791153908,
0.6046365499,
-0.1125890091,
0.8353908658,
-0.1189316064,
-0.272878617,
0.3731397688,
0.6908453703,
0.7605999708,
-0.1854939759,
0.0838669911,
0.8021765947,
0.4079736173,
-0.210960716,
-0.0976297036,
-0.019715365,
-0.8007433414,
-0.5887054205,
-0.4440963566,
-0.2886027992,
-0.1223554537,
-0.6045900583,
0.316760689,
-0.140068993,
-0.2629319429,
0.1496384889,
0.121031709,
-1.1160796881,
0.1721877754,
0.315874368,
1.0520080328,
-0.7995150089,
0.8029751182,
0.9874176979,
-0.7766785622,
-0.4797152877,
-0.3515867889,
-0.2781654298,
-0.563791275,
0.7141993046,
-0.2203183174,
0.0189471375,
0.0270421319,
-0.2811109424,
-0.7581329942,
0.8818295598,
0.6098243594,
-0.62064749,
-0.3259106576,
-0.0787773281,
0.5914534926,
-0.3617310822,
0.4021236002,
0.2151720673,
0.5077802539,
-0.1979101598,
-0.8764779568,
-0.1330757588,
-0.2347404212,
0.0100914109,
0.3826225698,
-0.7881366611,
0.5032422543,
-0.3197551966,
-0.3178738654,
-0.0945448652,
0.8914163709,
0.1782163531,
0.2507083416,
0.3099799752,
0.8226927519,
0.8972537518,
-0.0586539805,
0.7073263526,
-0.578633666,
0.5851420164,
1.0330101252,
-0.6259952784,
1.0848962069,
0.3588339388,
0.0758521259,
0.7212807536,
0.4497897327,
-0.1318434328,
0.2515575886,
0.1024692431,
-0.6177976727,
-0.302313149,
-0.3835443258,
-0.4200862646,
0.2214276791,
0.3079011738,
-0.3950867951,
-0.3735830486,
-0.1916426122,
-0.0491027869,
0.1371176392,
-0.3819013834,
0.6811101437,
-0.0560808219,
-0.3711940348,
0.1091842353,
0.0100045269,
0.687654078,
-0.563602984,
-0.0996758565,
-0.1276388019,
-0.0901230499,
-0.2651047707,
-0.716412127,
0.1558169723,
0.082258366,
-0.2603417039,
-0.1062985584,
0.8731213808,
-0.8782941103,
-0.222976625,
0.6344165206,
0.7739571333,
0.0504904538,
0.0152514027,
-0.9044275284,
-0.0356209353,
-0.250023067,
-0.3203798831,
0.2340480089,
0.76835531,
-0.0481331833,
0.6655020118,
0.6138489246,
0.2176315933,
0.1842763573,
0.1940740198,
0.7502444386,
-0.7974392772,
-0.2534409165,
-0.6331460476,
0.2158271074,
-0.0801901221,
-0.1654068679,
0.8299898505,
0.9771420956,
1.4079467058,
0.1254752427,
0.7324909568,
0.1512216032,
0.1929108649,
-0.4074377716,
0.6785613894,
-0.4926446974,
0.0946652889,
-0.1160775423,
-1.236076951,
-0.3222516477,
0.3843953311,
0.23071298,
0.0199826304,
0.8569018245,
0.5127922893,
-0.0917900428,
-0.1925424933,
0.2883515954,
0.1482797414,
-0.0604649708,
0.79012537,
0.358944118,
-0.457637012,
0.716165483,
-0.1839200705,
0.0996308774,
-0.0794409662,
-0.71025455,
-0.6722646952,
-0.5084439516,
-0.4325338304,
-0.3402231336,
0.1579775214,
0.8157645464,
0.6522304416,
-0.7061128616,
-0.2269928604,
0.3686807156,
0.4480477571,
-0.1411098242,
-0.1694438905,
0.396753937,
-0.4207330346,
-1.0982218981,
0.2974016964,
0.386092484,
-0.1082290187,
-0.2095772475,
-0.0949550197,
-0.6692630649,
-0.1459602118,
0.6307570338,
0.361895293,
-0.3340539336,
-0.1241067052,
0.0669370964,
-0.2882638872,
-0.0097837597,
0.7091094255,
-0.6655864716,
0.372522682,
0.5341265202,
1.3060907125,
0.5126878023,
-0.4186668694,
0.2470095307,
-0.7614484429,
0.0501747951,
0.227003336,
0.5946972966,
0.4373314083,
-0.4250096381,
0.6176102161,
0.3630923629,
-0.7461538911,
-0.425644964,
0.1261382848,
-0.6933372021,
-0.0629052073,
1.00276649,
-0.1233926639,
-0.1763195246,
-0.3711677194,
0.1255626082,
0.3292365968,
-0.413746506,
0.4659045637,
0.6846417189,
0.1377666742,
0.1094395742,
-0.5609394312,
0.2565117478,
0.1924673319,
-0.7096065879,
-0.3982498348,
0.4143818915,
0.178775847,
0.2662196159,
0.5491996408,
0.0146457134,
-0.0080121327,
0.1495718211,
0.338622719,
0.2121238708,
-0.5667661428,
-0.1488332897,
0.3680241406,
-0.0026745363,
-0.0051636673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08099v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08099v1
|
KET-QA: A Dataset for Knowledge Enhanced Table Question Answering
| 2024-05-13T18:26:32 | 2024-05-13T18:26:32 |
Mengkang Hu, Haoyu Dong, Ping Luo, Shi Han, Dongmei Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Due to the concise and structured nature of tables, the knowledge contained
therein may be incomplete or missing, posing a significant challenge for table
question answering (TableQA) and data analysis systems. Most existing datasets
either fail to address the issue of external knowledge in TableQA or only
utilize unstructured text as supplementary information for tables. In this
paper, we propose to use a knowledge base (KB) as the external knowledge source
for TableQA and construct a dataset KET-QA with fine-grained gold evidence
annotation. Each table in the dataset corresponds to a sub-graph of the entire
KB, and every question requires the integration of information from both the
table and the sub-graph to be answered. To extract pertinent information from
the vast knowledge sub-graph and apply it to TableQA, we design a
retriever-reasoner structured pipeline model. Experimental results demonstrate
that our model consistently achieves remarkable relative performance
improvements ranging from 1.9 to 6.5 times and absolute improvements of 11.66%
to 44.64% on EM scores across three distinct settings (fine-tuning, zero-shot,
and few-shot), in comparison with solely relying on table information in the
traditional TableQA manner. However, even the best model achieves a 60.23% EM
score, which still lags behind the human-level performance, highlighting the
challenging nature of KET-QA for the question-answering community. We also
provide a human evaluation of error cases to analyze further the aspects in
which the model can be improved. Project page: https://ketqa.github.io/.
|
[
-0.2064666748,
-0.9080475569,
0.7333555222,
-0.1285040081,
-0.2417173833,
-0.1594402641,
0.3356670439,
-0.3393652141,
0.1173680201,
0.6510964632,
-0.3258811831,
-0.5631932616,
-0.4981232882,
-0.0175829418,
-0.3831062317,
0.8972498775,
0.1885813624,
-0.0203256235,
-0.086343877,
-0.1442142278,
-0.8557277918,
-0.498355329,
-0.4055103958,
-0.1637843847,
0.4959408343,
0.6539375782,
0.6163580418,
0.5807449222,
0.5103560686,
0.1880525202,
0.0343057103,
0.1166288853,
-0.2696973085,
0.1825895905,
-0.0834312886,
-0.5590391755,
-0.4329749346,
-0.3704662919,
0.2686512172,
0.5036275983,
-0.181486994,
0.3874788582,
-0.1732743979,
0.8806731701,
-0.6713744402,
0.4042828679,
-0.725153625,
0.0043611154,
-0.132172972,
-0.0785015225,
-0.3206391335,
-0.568749845,
0.2844985127,
-0.7693568468,
-0.1083563939,
-0.0717686787,
0.8586512804,
0.3745721877,
-0.708988905,
-0.1947510839,
-0.6332929134,
0.2589469552,
-0.7922911048,
0.6888710856,
0.249571681,
0.6847648025,
-0.0141445184,
-1.0757330656,
-0.6966851354,
-0.0113675334,
-0.2750230432,
0.2955850661,
0.0035751087,
-0.0003985958,
0.3924716115,
0.3912538886,
-0.602599144,
-0.3621462584,
-0.4319967628,
-0.1451428682,
0.4561260641,
0.2698637843,
0.2793270946,
-0.4455598593,
-0.0431910604,
-0.1192169711,
-0.5963709354,
0.3434157073,
0.1370095015,
0.3334501386,
0.3183512986,
0.771867156,
-0.8039791584,
0.7139897346,
-0.0879270807,
0.2374239862,
-0.015587775,
-0.009563487,
-0.3474054635,
0.0386098549,
0.3513474166,
0.24597767,
0.0631693155,
-0.4128430486,
0.0226736423,
0.2464607954,
0.1205510572,
-0.8491826653,
-0.7903708816,
0.5114070773,
-0.3287622333,
-0.0346652344,
0.0318678282,
-0.881665051,
-0.4920322597,
-0.1708384901,
0.9514585137,
-0.247643739,
-0.1651458591,
-0.0222526658,
-0.3364776671,
0.3943693936,
0.1065919623,
-0.4282557368,
0.2229848504,
0.4358054101,
0.4500599205,
0.2062282115,
0.3094234467,
-0.8457740545,
0.2339162081,
-0.280898273,
0.9491071105,
-0.7141394615,
-0.0459316149,
-0.1361818016,
0.0940803066,
0.0724961832,
-0.426772058,
0.9169079065,
-1.0979412794,
0.3894250393,
-0.8528162241,
-0.7663511038,
-0.4356339872,
0.4502547979,
-0.9395247698,
0.9133326411,
0.3166925013,
-0.7776926756,
0.6409463882,
-0.9808078408,
-0.0495693907,
0.2351616323,
0.1077829376,
-0.2849601209,
-0.2142101079,
0.5187160969,
0.1253391206,
-0.0905033797,
0.3084577918,
-0.220674336,
-0.3772397637,
0.1020907983,
0.1482515037,
0.5384443402,
0.1798529178,
-0.037885569,
-0.06467852,
-0.8069076538,
0.4511220455,
-0.0257195495,
-0.7270159125,
-0.2756260037,
-0.0268418659,
-0.3016224205,
0.4688218534,
0.0090997163,
-0.7403246164,
0.0717073232,
-0.3645444512,
0.320440799,
0.4156731665,
0.455812335,
0.2815119326,
-0.3233981729,
0.4412993193,
0.2158829272,
0.0258185361,
0.018262228,
-0.4881169796,
-0.8729682565,
0.1121797115,
0.9462220669,
0.7248309255,
-0.8059253097,
0.1159054935,
-0.3077146411,
-0.3398052752,
-0.6432663798,
0.0004705809,
0.2491739988,
1.0905760527,
0.6583642364,
-0.2475280166,
-0.7874183059,
-1.0564084053,
-0.3234464824,
-0.1748241186,
-0.3494974673,
0.3319916129,
0.3702972531,
0.1235025451,
1.0064755678,
-0.4887402654,
-0.2692321539,
-0.2170802057,
-0.223530665,
0.3725022972,
0.3658282161,
-0.0480642468,
-0.639390409,
-0.4245146811,
-0.0783916041,
-0.837064743,
-0.1207204834,
0.248763144,
-0.5468740463,
-0.1426866204,
0.2911740243,
-0.6176208854,
0.2707920372,
0.1555631757,
-0.6419100165,
0.4655767381,
0.2769144475,
0.327372551,
-1.1100069284,
0.4439855516,
-0.0945517793,
-0.0243890341,
-0.6968269348,
0.2235568017,
0.0103817051,
-0.1215103939,
-0.2716282308,
0.4104394615,
0.0163047854,
0.0402923748,
-0.0250982847,
0.2334410548,
0.3486222625,
0.733284831,
0.1129214093,
0.5477834344,
0.1719053835,
-0.6014261246,
0.1979498565,
0.7930850983,
-0.3300615847,
0.4691941738,
-0.8976408243,
0.3753197789,
-0.247787118,
0.1210864633,
-0.9930526614,
-0.3137215674,
0.2283362746,
-0.3678831756,
0.145206213,
-0.5212303996,
-0.4209553599,
-0.3223302066,
0.0324572437,
0.0249515604,
0.5568461418,
-0.4268753529,
0.7856431007,
0.4268930852,
-0.1556542516,
-0.6225694418,
-0.5065497756,
-0.12632972,
-0.3940286934,
-0.8216619492,
0.1931338906,
0.1687303036,
-0.2883414328,
0.0940221474,
-0.2673289776,
-0.3979099095,
-0.0930802375,
0.0111616971,
0.0384471305,
-0.3391593397,
0.4368766844,
0.1202865317,
-0.0545942709,
0.3132028878,
-0.2884323895,
0.282098949,
-0.0977385715,
-0.0634383112,
-0.3985600471,
0.4041785598,
0.3333680928,
-0.1546491235,
0.6855593324,
0.4134359956,
-0.4359827638,
0.1799393296,
-0.6446988583,
-0.4042239189,
-0.4116258025,
0.4747194648,
-0.3804611862,
-0.7759435177,
0.790128231,
-0.0212995391,
0.3324336112,
0.7248082161,
0.2839968503,
-0.3976208866,
0.9438621998,
0.3802210689,
0.1071046889,
-0.0003349561,
-0.1801135987,
0.0514025539,
-0.7732557654,
-0.4179761112,
-0.5833001137,
-0.424687326,
-0.3635272682,
0.0837481543,
0.630533874,
0.1959459931,
-0.5210044384,
0.1351622492,
-0.4801596403,
0.4445320368,
0.6711793542,
0.5738053918,
0.6594560742,
-0.3549078405,
-0.045404844,
0.0762592107,
-1.047529459,
-0.5552952886,
1.2022259235,
0.3236637115,
0.3179163039,
0.1651022285,
0.285584718,
0.4322856069,
0.310392499,
-0.5451636314,
0.336933583,
0.0254641678,
-0.7991880774,
-0.4249715805,
-0.3850645125,
-0.7810245156,
0.1346675158,
-0.3108205199,
-0.5508993268,
0.1740552485,
0.3385807574,
-0.5612483621,
0.1175790802,
-1.068636179,
1.2273261547,
0.1642642021,
-0.2786406279,
0.2817815244,
-0.6901859641,
0.5958117843,
0.0599199496,
-0.0745776221,
0.1982308626,
0.3690932691,
1.0115500689,
-0.7520822287,
0.4559216797,
-0.7010882497,
0.0806173757,
0.6807795763,
0.1512423754,
0.7682520747,
0.2658151686,
-0.2013836652,
-0.2399525791,
0.5386298895,
-0.4527122974,
-0.8914216757,
0.2410987765,
-0.5676681399,
-0.6131991148,
0.1441342086,
-0.6051882505,
-0.5915254354,
-0.0310603715,
-0.0571742989,
0.5879617929,
0.3320390582,
0.4428025484,
0.7268056273,
-0.0677013174,
0.1104897782,
0.4907709658,
0.1126862317,
-0.215664342,
0.6152179837,
0.247660622,
-0.0846584961,
0.5843735337,
0.3276977241,
-0.8160217404,
-0.4755722582,
-0.554729104,
-0.2346875221,
-0.8385250568,
-0.6033425331,
-0.9396349192,
-0.2392520458,
-0.1496745199,
0.2695257366,
0.0407752991,
-0.7198901772,
0.1421307325,
-0.2204160243,
0.655071795,
0.3554263115,
0.3103025556,
0.3931135833,
-1.0592983961,
0.3301859796,
0.8396924734,
0.4928284585,
0.0069530178,
-0.6680625081,
-0.0838930309,
0.0628755242,
-0.3191429079,
-1.0973711014,
0.2091694623,
0.1124412864,
0.5217930675,
-0.050906688,
0.3006028235,
0.7124126554,
-0.0713304877,
0.5947547555,
-0.4178631008,
-0.7683835626,
0.6309207678,
-0.5523093939,
0.4824765027,
0.8401950598,
0.1667848378,
-0.442142725,
-0.3081703186,
-0.6095609069,
-0.7906513214,
0.4898346961,
0.2689879537,
-0.3267104626,
0.1028123349,
0.6012585163,
0.1645071059,
0.1717365533,
-0.8704032302,
0.0683675036,
-0.3071601391,
-0.3337404132,
0.627143085,
-0.2930038571,
-0.0102053601,
-0.0584974438,
0.8618664145,
-0.2123030275,
0.2631193399,
0.3866450489,
-0.307620883,
-0.0999220535,
0.5357638001,
-0.0282763764,
0.7673898339,
-0.3622258604,
-0.0027130819,
0.5254959464,
-0.4726296365,
-0.2141976207,
0.1410828978,
-0.2719985247,
-0.1889232099,
0.092933476,
0.2383327037,
-0.1955783814,
-0.6417390704,
0.1970438808,
-0.0549674407,
-0.2745659351,
-0.1168658882,
0.0603191406,
0.2051177621,
0.5057163835,
0.5932622552,
-0.3507833481,
0.4434714317,
-0.3595714271,
0.4473462701,
0.3220081627,
-0.4552896619,
-0.058843147,
0.693577528,
0.1070350856,
-0.0572316237,
0.8810520768,
-0.0759775266,
-0.5822893977,
0.653942585,
0.0970151424,
0.3331257403,
0.0501170605,
0.1489043534,
0.529479146,
0.3189647794,
0.1501744539,
0.7860351801,
-0.0520421639,
-0.556022644,
-0.5808267593,
-0.7018582821,
-0.3243231773,
0.3962382674,
-0.4145471156,
0.1029619053,
-0.2112846971,
0.1093163043,
-0.1393371224,
0.3659930527,
-0.8064530492,
0.4630059302,
-0.3547762036,
1.0522127151,
-0.7985062003,
0.5778939128,
0.4985333979,
-0.471813798,
-1.2114794254,
-0.4255172014,
-0.5000171661,
-0.4570322037,
0.4779315889,
-0.0970204026,
0.5706697106,
0.2255155444,
-0.4105941057,
-0.9057617188,
1.2721716166,
0.3029935062,
-0.4535437822,
0.0129481535,
0.2385398746,
0.5450456738,
-0.068823956,
0.3991984725,
0.7522124648,
0.6261567473,
0.2482955903,
-0.6685335636,
0.3148245811,
-0.2818333805,
-0.4229879081,
0.3741585016,
-0.4684202969,
0.2756021023,
-0.0593217649,
-0.2127560675,
-0.1060721427,
0.7023911476,
0.4859506786,
0.3668193519,
0.427580297,
0.8160947561,
0.6836153269,
-0.3031029105,
0.6954436898,
-0.14343898,
0.0846898034,
1.1756919622,
-0.0953921154,
0.7718035579,
0.3273870349,
-0.2327843457,
0.7352811098,
0.6763037443,
0.0955174118,
0.5420786738,
0.1638301909,
-0.0060571805,
-0.4642267823,
-0.1340263635,
-0.4175779223,
0.4951441884,
0.2638532817,
-0.3818935156,
-0.4468319714,
-0.532964468,
-0.4010587633,
-0.0995759964,
-0.4385962486,
0.8952865601,
-0.1588190347,
-0.6238651276,
0.0798197016,
-0.15805462,
0.0724115595,
-0.536370337,
-0.349095434,
-0.2922846377,
-0.1833940148,
-0.3435332179,
-0.7183291912,
0.4208901823,
-0.1695628911,
-0.1982658803,
0.3532545567,
0.7931721807,
-0.3665462434,
-0.4214727283,
-0.3825840056,
0.9209944606,
0.0021641739,
-0.3102851212,
-0.4413977563,
-0.4477402568,
-0.3423731327,
-0.223423779,
0.126441747,
0.5992862582,
-0.1300520003,
0.5664876103,
0.6934987903,
-0.3208752871,
0.10325858,
0.047914546,
1.0338160992,
-0.4680489898,
-0.7745366693,
-0.515434742,
0.8071748018,
-0.1289580166,
-0.1528566927,
0.4625872076,
0.616568327,
0.5181363225,
-0.080422394,
0.611158967,
-0.2631409764,
0.689655602,
-0.5832092762,
0.7085449696,
-0.2405985296,
0.1766801029,
-0.4218585789,
-0.9660624266,
-0.1516532153,
0.2927668095,
-0.2602052391,
0.0868327692,
0.5647392869,
0.6654378176,
0.0106079718,
0.4041205347,
0.1449235678,
0.2259414196,
0.1928330064,
0.9040537477,
0.880569756,
-0.8460246325,
0.934057951,
-0.241344139,
0.0174377393,
0.1644400954,
-0.7127726674,
-0.7016568184,
-0.7009489536,
-0.3488199711,
-0.4488422871,
0.1498877257,
0.5430588126,
0.7595037222,
-0.960642755,
0.2969626486,
-0.2682931423,
0.0260653831,
-0.1546779573,
-0.3241603971,
0.701459527,
-0.1215805784,
-0.2036501467,
0.2500955164,
-0.0797586218,
-0.2123627216,
0.0794496313,
0.2427108437,
-0.3033384085,
-0.0866596401,
0.68598634,
0.3423717022,
-0.2918988764,
-0.4294618964,
0.3625254631,
0.3419100642,
0.1004059389,
0.6350288987,
-1.2132861614,
0.4147431254,
0.4844745994,
0.9045239091,
0.4788036048,
0.4484341741,
0.4915693402,
-0.8339821696,
-0.4720536768,
0.3555499315,
0.2441547066,
0.1644983143,
-0.7240301371,
0.5960869193,
0.0604737028,
-0.6354789138,
-0.6252250075,
0.1119621769,
-0.9767334461,
-0.0274224933,
0.8750377893,
0.0025669213,
-0.1496598274,
-0.6500377655,
-0.149038434,
0.356667161,
-0.5102636218,
1.299634099,
0.7217707038,
-0.1949729025,
-0.2886497974,
-0.6767151952,
0.5997021198,
0.3735599518,
-1.100959897,
0.0730884001,
0.5912473202,
0.3938482404,
-0.0517214164,
0.5505863428,
-0.3186031878,
0.5375288725,
-0.0779711753,
-0.1652575433,
-0.2971964478,
-0.2358047366,
0.0034796037,
0.8306187391,
0.012319304,
-0.1553941369
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07990v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07990v1
|
Plot2Code: A Comprehensive Benchmark for Evaluating Multi-modal Large Language Models in Code Generation from Scientific Plots
| 2024-05-13T17:59:22 | 2024-05-13T17:59:22 |
Chengyue Wu, Yixiao Ge, Qiushan Guo, Jiahao Wang, Zhixuan Liang, Zeyu Lu, Ying Shan, Ping Luo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
The remarkable progress of Multi-modal Large Language Models (MLLMs) has
attracted significant attention due to their superior performance in visual
contexts. However, their capabilities in turning visual figure to executable
code, have not been evaluated thoroughly. To address this, we introduce
Plot2Code, a comprehensive visual coding benchmark designed for a fair and
in-depth assessment of MLLMs. We carefully collect 132 manually selected
high-quality matplotlib plots across six plot types from publicly available
matplotlib galleries. For each plot, we carefully offer its source code, and an
descriptive instruction summarized by GPT-4. This approach enables Plot2Code to
extensively evaluate MLLMs' code capabilities across various input modalities.
Furthermore, we propose three automatic evaluation metrics, including code pass
rate, text-match ratio, and GPT-4V overall rating, for a fine-grained
assessment of the output code and rendered images. Instead of simply judging
pass or fail, we employ GPT-4V to make an overall judgement between the
generated and reference images, which has been shown to be consistent with
human evaluation. The evaluation results, which include analyses of 14 MLLMs
such as the proprietary GPT-4V, Gemini-Pro, and the open-sourced Mini-Gemini,
highlight the substantial challenges presented by Plot2Code. With Plot2Code, we
reveal that most existing MLLMs struggle with visual coding for text-dense
plots, heavily relying on textual instruction. We hope that the evaluation
results from Plot2Code on visual coding will guide the future development of
MLLMs. All data involved with Plot2Code are available at
https://huggingface.co/datasets/TencentARC/Plot2Code.
|
[
-0.1192611679,
-0.2514269054,
0.4538734257,
0.560505569,
-0.2735180259,
-0.012576377,
-0.1890178025,
-0.4097625911,
-0.3621362448,
0.5170033574,
-0.1066378579,
-0.4049536288,
-0.6026116014,
0.0602594577,
-0.2148356438,
0.7732827663,
-0.0916824862,
0.254753083,
-0.5902600884,
-0.1291207224,
-0.4037827253,
-0.6970763803,
-0.3534832001,
-0.0821842402,
0.4480849504,
-0.0460952632,
0.6498314142,
0.5733339787,
0.721780479,
0.192159161,
0.1562805325,
0.3804494441,
-0.6596977711,
0.0840458646,
0.0148699228,
-0.2871928811,
-0.1999519765,
-0.1413416564,
0.5004215837,
0.3442187905,
0.3852242529,
0.3772072792,
-0.0279468205,
0.5633247495,
-0.538449645,
0.6368788481,
-0.3344858289,
-0.010957784,
-0.0398977362,
-0.2545283735,
-0.6951713562,
-0.4261952043,
-0.3400453329,
-0.4142045677,
-0.1831384301,
0.0458811186,
0.6600126028,
0.2715358436,
-0.8060646653,
-0.2894380093,
-0.2726842463,
0.6066154242,
-0.5768440366,
0.1840122193,
0.5302224159,
0.5191646814,
-0.0410795659,
-1.1601279974,
-0.3490393162,
-0.4063919485,
-0.1870212257,
0.2094956487,
-0.3898846209,
-0.0880058333,
0.5882126093,
-0.2486742437,
-0.981744349,
0.04963113,
-0.5864015818,
-0.3483217359,
0.5793665051,
0.090170227,
0.3018310368,
-0.5543581843,
-0.3140686452,
-0.4066955149,
-0.5209985971,
0.1425085962,
0.3658084869,
-0.1673107445,
-0.3447532952,
0.7737925053,
0.0372807421,
0.2792929709,
-0.5339749455,
0.0100076823,
0.4722750485,
-0.346912235,
-0.0132865021,
-0.3814795315,
0.9389246106,
0.957243979,
0.4308990836,
0.1351729035,
-0.2642184794,
0.3285896182,
0.180970192,
-1.2207863331,
-0.5687605143,
0.0620815605,
-0.6428280473,
-0.0512061566,
-0.0075328602,
-0.8094518781,
-0.5750988126,
-0.0926591754,
0.1916157901,
-0.4123108983,
-0.1469736248,
-0.2477505952,
-0.3925070763,
0.1213627309,
0.3521416187,
-0.4880631268,
-0.0905106813,
0.7703950405,
0.9773488641,
-0.1116126627,
-0.4633816779,
-0.62414819,
0.0264197104,
-0.5451102853,
0.7294655442,
-0.5620471835,
-0.1419015527,
-0.0789301693,
-0.248185873,
0.1029804945,
-0.4831582308,
0.4148145914,
-0.2949941158,
0.0557705872,
-0.3021295965,
-0.3990323544,
-0.1210143343,
0.0786919668,
-0.6549373865,
1.130141139,
0.4538089931,
-0.6873313785,
0.4862065315,
-0.6049799919,
-0.30153355,
0.1006442904,
-0.5340197086,
-0.4410791993,
-0.0699252114,
0.1336730868,
0.3757751584,
-0.4581021965,
0.3902287781,
-0.4918226302,
-0.450111717,
0.4842085838,
-0.6362456679,
0.5734580159,
0.3572244942,
-0.4937095642,
0.443808794,
-0.5239000916,
0.3777223825,
0.2400545478,
-0.0509516336,
-0.0216644052,
0.0199355558,
0.5446217656,
0.4706613719,
-0.0249349605,
-0.2488000393,
0.4820281565,
-0.1578946561,
0.6428341269,
0.4893209338,
-0.0606890284,
0.1114560887,
0.0246687941,
0.3854468167,
-0.3502601683,
0.2806123495,
-0.4938565493,
-0.8112780452,
-0.5062274933,
-0.3171026409,
0.0878275856,
0.342802614,
-1.0469288826,
0.1277883947,
-0.2569471598,
-0.5308269262,
-0.1204060614,
0.0260167606,
0.5768051147,
-0.0039345114,
0.2925751507,
-0.2707352638,
-0.3768742681,
-0.8466498852,
0.0873354301,
-0.2050982714,
-0.2593975961,
0.3626258671,
0.6712981462,
-0.374211669,
0.7777412534,
-0.26832968,
0.0311147235,
-0.0954417512,
0.2686124444,
-0.0007497155,
0.3302027583,
0.8742074966,
-0.6506061554,
-0.4915448427,
0.1904760897,
-1.0024045706,
-0.2494889945,
-0.1546673626,
-0.0994088724,
0.2232199013,
0.3495924473,
-0.4527285397,
0.4282138646,
0.7693354487,
-0.6591657996,
0.5836448669,
-0.5678349137,
0.3356894255,
-0.4707187712,
0.4613739252,
-0.2685220838,
-0.1995790303,
-0.3353208303,
0.2985314727,
0.5633528829,
-0.2985900044,
-0.1930152476,
0.521071136,
-0.4121845663,
-0.5287231803,
-0.241257146,
-0.1224412769,
0.1611972749,
0.563211143,
-0.0477060601,
0.8101278543,
0.5581487417,
0.0505117178,
0.5962848663,
0.0264988393,
-0.5273020864,
0.3498916924,
-0.680989027,
0.2294498831,
-0.1040673256,
0.4873900115,
-0.8891845942,
-0.2881350219,
0.2713556588,
-0.193547532,
0.1265607178,
-0.3209379017,
-0.7532280087,
-0.5463758707,
-0.3735918403,
0.45982939,
0.7980037332,
-0.4415193796,
0.1671295613,
-0.0114058275,
-0.0611455441,
-0.2827391624,
-0.7281473875,
0.4605824947,
0.1130043045,
-0.5529984832,
-0.2768139243,
-0.1265505701,
0.0596295223,
-0.1506008506,
0.0613608994,
0.0731999353,
-0.1876418591,
0.4241943359,
0.0259533934,
-0.0526999682,
-0.1874555796,
0.1649087369,
-0.4125967026,
0.2474496067,
-0.2421580404,
0.8093056679,
-0.0993476659,
-0.7329238057,
-0.1972473711,
0.2976479232,
0.7130910754,
-0.5537107587,
0.0973179936,
0.9644531012,
-0.1530565172,
-0.221258685,
-0.1620566845,
0.0766539425,
-0.4184290469,
0.775533855,
-0.4015647173,
-0.5968332887,
0.1866474003,
-0.0640504137,
-0.0923443958,
0.3404538333,
0.7799459696,
0.051543016,
1.0195780993,
0.4215807021,
0.4578697085,
0.0862876847,
-0.3365893364,
0.0301215649,
-0.4417061508,
-0.5614812374,
-0.2988320589,
-0.2232545316,
-0.3761091232,
-1.1339285374,
0.4476338327,
0.3832984865,
-0.2947958112,
0.2190369666,
-0.5964215398,
0.3838364482,
0.4491896629,
-0.0852808803,
0.0341855474,
0.1206102818,
-0.0755662099,
-0.0557031222,
-0.6167986989,
-0.5702143312,
1.2558456659,
0.5072430968,
0.6854965687,
0.0555944629,
0.2665438056,
0.5573700666,
0.384909153,
-0.4595681429,
0.4031752944,
-0.2013555765,
-0.2344838679,
-0.0253893826,
-0.7125580311,
-0.8315035701,
0.3022075593,
0.0067515033,
-0.5853997469,
0.0763901025,
0.1232864484,
0.0784607306,
-0.01929917,
-0.9473264217,
1.3086688519,
-0.7481457591,
-0.3673742414,
-0.3042584062,
-0.6910139918,
0.3143274188,
-0.2096998692,
0.1421373188,
-0.2348245084,
-0.2081463188,
0.6665884256,
-0.2893147767,
0.7468551993,
-0.3623381257,
-0.0443444476,
0.2734108567,
0.1788019836,
0.4643986821,
0.1513916701,
-0.0132715059,
0.2984198928,
0.3690064251,
-0.489071697,
-0.5785930157,
0.5591433048,
-0.7355690002,
0.3789296448,
-0.3367509842,
-0.4391641021,
-0.08020854,
0.1105886474,
0.2884838283,
0.7366134524,
0.0490421318,
0.1185176969,
0.0818970576,
-0.5975646377,
0.4063735604,
0.0281634163,
-0.695389092,
-0.6335688233,
1.0544570684,
-0.200652793,
0.2730512917,
0.1990546286,
0.02060703,
-0.3065384626,
-0.5900887847,
-0.9121815562,
-0.0088696126,
-0.8954805136,
-0.4932325184,
-0.5948749185,
-0.0287045315,
-0.3493726552,
-0.1034426987,
-0.3721359074,
-0.1903302521,
0.1764129698,
0.2844562829,
0.2859514356,
1.0466998816,
0.096288085,
0.0159738213,
-0.5465144515,
0.3127635121,
0.1160250828,
0.4680202901,
-0.1589820385,
-0.1278200001,
-0.1947158873,
0.0098325415,
-0.1592383236,
-0.6710405946,
0.2914209068,
0.1753730923,
0.4391205907,
0.4535800815,
-0.004040794,
0.5303083062,
-0.3622021079,
0.8161098361,
0.5196415186,
-0.7991427779,
0.30357638,
-0.1402890086,
0.3228046,
0.1615579128,
0.1507227123,
-0.5160547495,
-0.2960314453,
-0.2025249749,
-0.7783334851,
0.6260407567,
0.4084286988,
0.1112625152,
0.1489204019,
-0.0140672727,
0.2048682123,
0.2310972065,
-0.6703398228,
-0.1774647832,
-0.7708528638,
-0.2177844048,
-0.1920316964,
-0.460449785,
-0.1340369284,
-0.1611427069,
-0.1071929112,
-0.5324296355,
0.6193450093,
-0.1291809231,
-0.2204904854,
-0.0172007382,
-0.1298706532,
0.6746906638,
0.8370825052,
-0.1922952384,
0.2527709901,
-0.238944903,
-0.4408401251,
-0.1554577202,
0.2653156817,
-0.1942736953,
-0.154944554,
0.9131051898,
1.0283385515,
0.1058417261,
-1.1762144566,
0.9552246928,
0.0177580733,
-0.2675250173,
0.1148202196,
-0.0332510173,
-0.0497361794,
0.3478680551,
0.3211540282,
0.439019084,
0.1529244334,
-0.4197144806,
0.2735928595,
0.2595885098,
-0.124002412,
-0.271073401,
0.7081365585,
0.2262039036,
0.0474605858,
0.5581792593,
-0.5556422472,
-0.6792206764,
0.7315689325,
0.5041172504,
0.6137863994,
0.3614273369,
0.2723017633,
0.5364504457,
0.5178471208,
0.2088407427,
0.2964273989,
0.0191674624,
-0.1823372096,
-0.7250558734,
-0.6030185819,
-0.2731034458,
-0.1872070432,
-0.4121713638,
0.1813355237,
-0.5442063808,
-0.0415538773,
-0.2793906033,
-0.1119330674,
-0.6092553139,
-0.1110490188,
0.6748116016,
0.8284596801,
-0.6681002975,
0.9042711854,
0.6758418679,
-0.3155887723,
-0.5934336185,
-0.3131488264,
-0.0172136445,
-0.7198488712,
0.6456843615,
0.4682331979,
0.1279053539,
-0.2935823798,
-0.5367411971,
-0.6750602126,
1.016176343,
0.564003706,
-0.5332999229,
0.1690510958,
0.2645531893,
0.6537858844,
-0.1648472995,
0.9227753282,
0.4511395395,
0.8165249825,
0.0213372875,
-1.1253215075,
0.0431789346,
-0.5739148855,
0.1097488999,
-0.0232832134,
-0.5358462334,
0.6314620972,
-0.3033465743,
-0.2068570703,
0.2296592891,
0.372284174,
0.1184293553,
0.6484889388,
0.1213063672,
0.1166803315,
0.6457704902,
-0.2525635362,
1.1643671989,
-0.4014932513,
0.5528888702,
0.8058465123,
-0.3524490893,
0.8585220575,
0.1589893848,
-0.4003152251,
0.1856851727,
0.3492762148,
-0.5184235573,
0.3993531764,
0.2467174679,
0.4549521804,
-0.1263476461,
0.1684357077,
-0.6109548807,
0.4602962434,
0.190026015,
-0.3257475793,
-0.258695513,
0.3105103374,
-0.0237544011,
0.0709639937,
-0.1607199907,
0.5071488619,
-0.0410646535,
-0.4226192832,
0.8451960683,
0.1985260844,
0.5571471453,
-0.8222312331,
-0.174958691,
-0.3588284552,
0.0717916489,
-0.2532987595,
-1.071108222,
0.1467167139,
0.2212376297,
0.07234478,
-0.4272664487,
0.4842690527,
-0.3731405437,
-0.4233743846,
0.3470898867,
0.3013427556,
0.3832189143,
-0.228381291,
-0.7257933021,
0.610702455,
0.1743854582,
-0.1618550867,
0.3170932233,
0.4802033305,
-0.2573241889,
0.6467023492,
0.8167355061,
-0.1701712161,
0.1226601973,
0.2905480564,
0.9559262991,
-0.5629987717,
-0.3258657157,
-0.5733388066,
0.4272562563,
-0.1948840916,
-0.5352659225,
0.7646298409,
0.9425935745,
0.5119695663,
-0.2189328223,
0.7476152182,
-0.2499563396,
-0.0630977675,
-0.4878991246,
0.8398386836,
-0.388669908,
0.1007352322,
-0.3240352869,
-1.0489628315,
-0.3315830231,
0.4683455825,
-0.3249277472,
0.0484972037,
0.7073625922,
0.7358471155,
0.0151669569,
-0.3397093117,
0.4044445753,
0.1564597636,
0.6272044182,
0.7439223528,
0.8617106676,
-0.2571079433,
0.9197016358,
-0.253161639,
-0.4529230893,
-0.3043747246,
-0.8162925243,
-0.9722890854,
-0.4003455937,
-0.2281358093,
-0.3608460724,
-0.0512266718,
0.7339482903,
0.7031279802,
-0.6830277443,
-0.220299691,
0.2448290884,
-0.2813578248,
-0.3671475649,
-0.1639250666,
0.6634944677,
-0.074926734,
-0.5783020854,
0.1463449746,
0.6375477314,
-0.1847275943,
-0.3112868071,
-0.5221144557,
0.4744557142,
-0.2997279167,
0.9386498928,
0.0839072764,
-0.6656396985,
-0.0824975967,
-0.2462263703,
-0.515217483,
-0.123959288,
1.0323609114,
-0.5889592767,
0.6439024806,
0.4871396422,
0.3942524195,
0.6837270856,
-0.0594821647,
0.2529494166,
-0.3750884831,
0.3016798496,
0.2260038853,
0.2664593458,
0.3426519334,
0.0886791423,
0.5819501281,
0.2937323749,
-0.4698459506,
-0.9178061485,
0.0982941538,
-1.2942699194,
-0.3564366102,
1.3676615953,
-0.2031752169,
-0.0047150617,
0.0883115008,
-0.6045402884,
-0.2000709623,
-0.2607387602,
0.2401138097,
0.1315723807,
-0.2071001679,
-0.3413096964,
-0.773538053,
0.375295788,
-0.0066708666,
-0.8189833164,
0.2662487626,
0.7754198313,
0.0616661794,
-0.0796613544,
0.4352879822,
-0.0018058316,
0.4319629073,
0.5727113485,
0.3689643741,
-0.5269733667,
-0.2396629006,
-0.0738065094,
0.3429320157,
0.1328605562,
0.4092674553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07960v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07960v3
|
AgentClinic: a multimodal agent benchmark to evaluate AI in simulated clinical environments
| 2024-05-13T17:38:53 | 2024-05-30T22:56:17 |
Samuel Schmidgall, Rojin Ziaei, Carl Harris, Eduardo Reis, Jeffrey Jopling, Michael Moor
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL
|
Diagnosing and managing a patient is a complex, sequential decision making
process that requires physicians to obtain information -- such as which tests
to perform -- and to act upon it. Recent advances in artificial intelligence
(AI) and large language models (LLMs) promise to profoundly impact clinical
care. However, current evaluation schemes overrely on static medical
question-answering benchmarks, falling short on interactive decision-making
that is required in real-life clinical work. Here, we present AgentClinic: a
multimodal benchmark to evaluate LLMs in their ability to operate as agents in
simulated clinical environments. In our benchmark, the doctor agent must
uncover the patient's diagnosis through dialogue and active data collection. We
present two open medical agent benchmarks: a multimodal image and dialogue
environment, AgentClinic-NEJM, and a dialogue-only environment,
AgentClinic-MedQA. We embed cognitive and implicit biases both in patient and
doctor agents to emulate realistic interactions between biased agents. We find
that introducing bias leads to large reductions in diagnostic accuracy of the
doctor agents, as well as reduced compliance, confidence, and follow-up
consultation willingness in patient agents. Evaluating a suite of
state-of-the-art LLMs, we find that several models that excel in benchmarks
like MedQA are performing poorly in AgentClinic-MedQA. We find that the LLM
used in the patient agent is an important factor for performance in the
AgentClinic benchmark. We show that both having limited interactions as well as
too many interaction reduces diagnostic accuracy in doctor agents. The code and
data for this work is publicly available at https://AgentClinic.github.io.
|
[
-0.466688931,
-0.6826527119,
0.9391103983,
-0.0862082839,
-0.011731674,
0.178467676,
-0.4428551793,
-0.6009261012,
-0.0647082031,
0.4764212668,
-0.6250036359,
-0.6603296399,
-0.4314792454,
0.1493179947,
0.0247558914,
0.8188502192,
-0.1810991019,
0.6297802329,
-0.8057070374,
-0.4611807466,
-0.3299852014,
-0.3803442717,
-0.7027810812,
-0.614520669,
0.321503222,
0.2083481401,
1.0035632849,
0.4724856913,
0.5157362223,
0.3749890625,
0.3305671215,
0.559533298,
-0.1403973997,
0.6423879862,
-0.0580813214,
-0.1730024666,
-0.5676476359,
0.1492506862,
0.4508797526,
0.681393683,
-0.1332472712,
-0.0707424432,
-0.620083034,
0.225240767,
-0.5887665749,
0.515537858,
-0.0228504539,
0.0277366694,
0.1932379454,
-0.0595732406,
-0.4981570244,
-0.2348183841,
0.2388094366,
-0.7383573651,
0.1501247883,
-0.088723205,
0.6543548703,
0.4231149554,
-0.5758012533,
-0.3098647296,
-0.6957736611,
0.3262457848,
-0.3184182644,
0.1811787188,
0.3919623792,
0.7225015163,
-0.0564143211,
-0.7333759069,
-0.4128783643,
-0.5655798316,
-0.0138227884,
0.3389043808,
-0.0997406468,
0.2805700898,
0.2262220979,
-0.1082452238,
-0.4983257949,
-0.0133477515,
-0.0863545835,
-0.2826577127,
0.5696906447,
0.4990163445,
0.3507322967,
0.1630514711,
-0.3426381946,
-0.5337250233,
-0.4497357905,
-0.1911235452,
-0.2048395872,
-0.0987279862,
-0.0164566841,
0.2904596925,
0.0062093553,
0.3510043919,
-0.2690774202,
-0.2931546867,
0.3383350074,
-0.2858855724,
0.0937684402,
0.1274304688,
0.6154379845,
0.652321279,
0.3738602698,
-0.0931937769,
-0.107193701,
0.3898656368,
0.5261182189,
-0.6423656344,
-0.2089834511,
0.4461822212,
-0.385494262,
-0.0405155607,
-0.0789167583,
-0.5693958998,
-0.6871824861,
-0.1972381473,
0.1662513763,
-0.440213412,
-0.273612529,
-0.1039510816,
-0.030870067,
0.0591802821,
0.6329271793,
-0.099823609,
0.6447985768,
0.5567502975,
0.6301215291,
-0.1003987789,
-0.3078561127,
-0.6437851191,
0.1068915203,
-0.4195149541,
0.9749370813,
-0.6760201454,
-0.5514164567,
0.0109540187,
0.1444577575,
-0.3789433837,
-0.8921144009,
0.3384851515,
-0.1720970571,
-0.064101316,
-0.0245793182,
-0.347197473,
-0.0726595223,
0.530044198,
-0.6766965389,
0.5451132655,
0.2871100903,
-0.2503739297,
0.3306232691,
-0.8446274996,
-0.2797852755,
0.188641727,
-0.410353601,
-0.4834219515,
-0.2269847989,
0.2065926343,
0.1573303938,
-0.6666546464,
0.3102383316,
-0.3557306826,
-0.1089085788,
0.6594583988,
-0.3735244572,
0.3906543851,
0.2271211296,
-0.2578869164,
0.279573828,
-0.4289015234,
0.2159953713,
0.0775441006,
0.1407985389,
-0.1263325512,
0.0169559121,
0.0135861635,
0.4022291601,
-0.0396500826,
-0.3470975161,
0.2899924815,
-0.2148020267,
0.2767573595,
0.5476827025,
0.0806979612,
0.0666839704,
-0.6955274343,
0.8798231483,
0.1046681255,
0.4526164234,
-0.0857002363,
-0.4890712798,
-0.6353284717,
-0.7112391591,
0.2237354517,
0.470036447,
-0.980343461,
-0.2894698381,
-0.3453903794,
-0.4951750934,
-0.8451852202,
-0.1181924641,
0.7468729019,
0.3644503057,
0.30748716,
-0.5599958897,
0.0248768441,
-0.9915844798,
-0.126163274,
-0.2972147465,
0.1992304623,
0.7345817089,
0.4993452728,
-0.5382755399,
0.5874276161,
-0.3803079724,
-0.3319621682,
-0.3004597127,
0.2179990113,
-0.0422056168,
0.4097020328,
0.3959137201,
-0.5659509301,
-0.3058301806,
0.0941138491,
-0.8472368717,
-0.1996725649,
-0.1624884158,
0.0006636768,
0.0499768928,
0.3918093741,
-0.8940461874,
0.6620649099,
0.4396747053,
-0.4084279537,
0.3402959704,
-0.7045391798,
0.3106476963,
-0.7463588119,
0.1499387324,
0.0024274292,
-0.6854206324,
-0.6784420609,
0.2282574773,
-0.0972943231,
-0.0625513047,
-0.4660973549,
0.7906934023,
-0.5620328188,
-0.1700887084,
-0.1715135127,
0.1807684451,
0.0733918548,
0.1802245826,
0.0698456392,
0.8680688143,
0.4006510377,
-0.3158901632,
0.5086676478,
0.2047575265,
-0.1938461214,
0.6950485706,
-0.6242566109,
0.2157955766,
-0.1420456916,
0.4356895685,
-0.7114594579,
-0.0863253325,
0.379866302,
-0.2609530985,
0.1816838235,
0.0330791883,
-0.8428697586,
-0.1471645981,
-0.1955367178,
0.8238582015,
0.3352178335,
-0.1956336945,
0.9269852638,
0.2784669697,
-0.206647411,
-0.2057702094,
-0.3784760535,
-0.0140940119,
0.2051501572,
-0.5601270199,
0.1601322591,
-0.2313978225,
-0.5040916204,
-0.1652512401,
0.17356655,
-0.1554172486,
0.0524300262,
0.5898472667,
0.4031332731,
-0.1014799848,
0.2397931963,
0.0936797038,
-0.3769527078,
0.2375193238,
0.1723516434,
0.6301265955,
-0.4492411017,
-0.8052964807,
-0.2904591262,
0.2602642477,
0.9089491367,
-0.2968594134,
0.6337530017,
0.4275799394,
-0.2851237953,
-0.1849136204,
-0.6504186988,
-0.3782700598,
-0.3538902998,
0.2645967007,
-0.3070845902,
-0.288571924,
0.6028001308,
-0.5351814628,
-0.2579616904,
0.3451945186,
0.8891848922,
0.2232037932,
1.3609780073,
0.0072865789,
0.2615076303,
-0.1095819771,
-0.1786383092,
-0.0918554366,
-0.6858857274,
-0.3873437047,
-0.2669399977,
0.0525387228,
-0.7048006654,
-0.8196236491,
1.0418874025,
-0.6601340175,
0.0663455799,
-0.2027089,
-0.45704934,
0.2096228749,
0.2998237908,
0.36750862,
0.3814507127,
-0.3997430801,
-0.4365391433,
0.1969704777,
-0.6572358012,
-0.4113042057,
1.2028313875,
0.4130568802,
0.5499651432,
0.2266955972,
0.2981128097,
0.4913518131,
0.5767704844,
-0.539011538,
0.4793363512,
0.1828322262,
-0.8071293235,
0.0432421565,
-0.3414282501,
-1.0742864609,
0.5496705174,
-0.2907568216,
-0.3014231324,
0.1162420362,
-0.1817296743,
-0.3191454113,
-0.1623968631,
-0.650018394,
1.034686923,
-0.2039778382,
-0.477824837,
-0.4529782236,
-0.9073142409,
-0.0449051782,
0.1670133471,
0.3240902722,
-0.3555397689,
-0.3137324452,
0.1768160462,
-0.5444427729,
0.7093520164,
-0.1720618755,
0.2887006104,
-0.0631435141,
0.1621139199,
0.2527806163,
0.4280387461,
-0.0688994974,
-0.0148169231,
0.3819020391,
-0.4488510787,
-0.6327732205,
0.5420949459,
-0.9694540501,
-0.3256382942,
-0.8585739732,
-0.5143288374,
-0.4981651306,
0.0430784039,
-0.1295864731,
0.7551420927,
-0.4800747633,
-0.2631472051,
0.4862675667,
-0.2722983062,
0.0386603922,
0.870652318,
-0.0320809036,
-0.324531585,
0.7168648243,
-0.206031397,
0.289614439,
-0.1376100481,
-0.0083747618,
-0.2964224815,
-0.4873383939,
-0.5606330037,
0.4464787841,
-0.9486969709,
-0.1118269935,
-0.5955690742,
-0.3471756876,
-0.1242386326,
0.0491425171,
-0.5508887172,
-0.0107425563,
-0.0859898403,
0.2829612494,
0.1587154567,
0.7124690413,
0.1226217225,
-0.1031557918,
-0.5289946795,
0.2451107502,
0.0914652497,
0.159624055,
-0.2335167825,
0.0126832156,
-0.1792978346,
-0.0561595559,
-0.22366786,
-0.6436066031,
0.4478808045,
0.1964936852,
0.761081636,
0.469399482,
0.3007105589,
0.470158726,
-0.3481664658,
0.4976053834,
-0.0218935311,
-0.7944864035,
0.3496324718,
-0.1797091216,
0.4250461757,
0.8897121549,
0.2177381217,
-0.414924562,
-0.5243610144,
-0.5490821004,
-0.5593096018,
0.6108601093,
0.2114491165,
-0.3499754667,
-0.1229146868,
0.244247511,
0.0595772229,
0.3908866942,
-0.3249420226,
-0.3503563702,
0.0362273604,
-0.3504565358,
-0.3445719481,
0.1045552865,
-0.6942998767,
-0.2976526022,
0.2645345032,
-0.3977910876,
0.5081450343,
0.581066668,
-0.294123292,
0.0282194186,
0.1282923222,
0.7808519006,
0.7406617999,
-0.0239459183,
0.1177553236,
0.1503152251,
-0.3675168455,
0.0480840281,
0.4984534979,
0.3124870062,
0.0610611662,
0.6943694949,
0.5507360697,
0.0581334792,
-1.3455417156,
0.796410799,
-0.3778325021,
-0.1735598892,
-0.4856173694,
-0.0150426701,
-0.2280634195,
0.5865145922,
-0.0141328368,
0.1426483393,
0.3423121274,
-0.698975265,
0.0566041954,
0.5452071428,
-0.6114938259,
-0.1090036258,
0.4985949099,
0.1871935725,
-0.2254070193,
0.8354285955,
-0.1933673471,
-0.3542344272,
0.9170789719,
0.2103886306,
0.6716293097,
-0.086457625,
0.4825859666,
-0.1621150523,
0.234209314,
-0.0055513154,
0.1383895129,
0.0635348931,
-0.5990219116,
-0.1951833218,
0.1557219476,
-0.9068025351,
-0.2247624397,
-0.6980917454,
-0.0573143251,
-0.6098692417,
-0.560960412,
0.0744458437,
0.1463894993,
-0.7339163423,
0.1291694194,
-0.0002635305,
0.6167190075,
-0.4671694934,
0.8261838555,
0.903418541,
-0.2973543704,
-0.516033411,
-0.2415749729,
0.1748070568,
-0.9582294226,
0.2974348962,
0.1908481568,
-0.0474194735,
-0.4697169662,
-0.3850185573,
-0.2912575006,
1.1973850727,
0.3242148757,
-0.0197597072,
0.1677991748,
0.1465395242,
1.0233751535,
-0.8658892512,
1.039416194,
0.5058975816,
0.6215549707,
-0.0881608278,
-1.1442312002,
0.24037157,
-0.6343380213,
-0.1163185015,
0.0452624597,
-0.7725820541,
0.9479750395,
-0.1112014726,
-0.1165154725,
0.284155041,
-0.1573821306,
0.2728058994,
0.7650626302,
0.5635370612,
0.2834197283,
0.6184468269,
-0.1765657961,
1.3179659843,
-0.5729597211,
0.1471877843,
0.7636532187,
-0.6469920874,
0.5166496634,
0.1997761428,
0.1584784091,
0.6077540517,
0.4532882571,
-0.0923857242,
0.2711282372,
0.1412283331,
-0.4439154565,
-0.5450241566,
-0.563677609,
-0.59579283,
0.4864239395,
0.4417074919,
-0.3449549675,
0.0189197939,
0.1182631329,
0.0363351032,
0.0825977772,
0.0330870599,
0.9633143544,
-0.0790112615,
-0.7777599096,
0.6392676234,
-0.0993264839,
-0.1173358411,
-0.5356532931,
-0.2270399928,
-0.0304705705,
0.3526797295,
0.1298997402,
-0.4071219265,
-0.2764149904,
-0.3840111792,
-0.1309442818,
-0.26745224,
0.4846237302,
-0.3135431111,
-0.4329600334,
0.4943315089,
0.8488792181,
0.313798517,
-0.0098293619,
-0.9315389395,
0.2457367033,
-0.466357708,
-0.0003924606,
0.3916816115,
0.2480514646,
-0.0876102373,
1.1234765053,
0.5011794567,
0.1873756349,
-0.4345859885,
0.3313893974,
1.1340640783,
-0.4526980817,
-0.152286917,
-0.4800734818,
0.0912524611,
-0.1654887348,
-0.3126147687,
0.3134203553,
0.3875875473,
0.3518138528,
0.0337603465,
0.5603490472,
0.4595255554,
0.5108720064,
-0.3199818134,
0.6868012547,
-0.6664873362,
0.2745618224,
-0.173600167,
-0.4755591154,
-0.0693989098,
0.5674370527,
-0.3622697294,
0.4072070718,
0.8822053075,
0.7868411541,
0.2933591306,
-0.1232712194,
0.4042120874,
0.3289875984,
0.4121737778,
0.6935200691,
1.0111852884,
-0.1987126768,
0.2045148015,
-0.1267095208,
-0.2524699569,
-0.3246565759,
-0.4092367887,
-1.0791186094,
-0.3686913252,
-0.3613559902,
-0.4651273191,
0.4763655365,
1.2865216732,
0.9776933193,
-0.4117541909,
-0.0747416317,
0.2702310383,
0.0623053797,
-0.4440110326,
-0.1424871087,
0.0810098052,
0.0272696242,
-0.629216969,
0.4450211227,
0.3819828033,
-0.0279219113,
-0.5422328115,
-0.3014215529,
-0.0407899842,
0.0396099724,
0.4052963853,
0.1860455871,
-0.7771576047,
0.0359171815,
-0.079764396,
-0.3335642219,
0.215515703,
0.7584893703,
-0.9960967898,
0.8626462817,
-0.153568238,
0.4786094427,
0.5549532175,
0.187634021,
0.649082303,
-0.0697460398,
0.1480640471,
0.6631928086,
0.0016941861,
0.1090829298,
-0.2027634233,
0.4229155779,
0.1558054835,
-0.5681744814,
-0.7282223701,
-0.0089918384,
-0.964779973,
-0.5167481899,
0.9669248462,
-0.2349199206,
-0.2546215653,
-0.4259162843,
-0.1840181351,
-0.0391397774,
-0.6321915388,
0.5194523335,
0.3952507973,
-0.3919065297,
-0.2153621912,
-0.7404965758,
0.4502249956,
0.5069647431,
-0.944849968,
-0.3568452597,
0.6210785508,
0.1783498973,
0.1164228097,
0.7678307891,
-0.0769645348,
0.6297430396,
0.1133717373,
0.0967361033,
-0.3024503291,
-0.4027196169,
-0.1176281944,
0.1693037897,
0.1699568629,
0.0353708044
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07940v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07940v2
|
RAID: A Shared Benchmark for Robust Evaluation of Machine-Generated Text Detectors
| 2024-05-13T17:15:14 | 2024-06-10T15:51:16 |
Liam Dugan, Alyssa Hwang, Filip Trhlik, Josh Magnus Ludan, Andrew Zhu, Hainiu Xu, Daphne Ippolito, Chris Callison-Burch
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Many commercial and open-source models claim to detect machine-generated text
with extremely high accuracy (99% or more). However, very few of these
detectors are evaluated on shared benchmark datasets and even when they are,
the datasets used for evaluation are insufficiently challenging-lacking
variations in sampling strategy, adversarial attacks, and open-source
generative models. In this work we present RAID: the largest and most
challenging benchmark dataset for machine-generated text detection. RAID
includes over 6 million generations spanning 11 models, 8 domains, 11
adversarial attacks and 4 decoding strategies. Using RAID, we evaluate the
out-of-domain and adversarial robustness of 8 open- and 4 closed-source
detectors and find that current detectors are easily fooled by adversarial
attacks, variations in sampling strategies, repetition penalties, and unseen
generative models. We release our data along with a leaderboard to encourage
future research.
|
[
-0.5548648238,
-0.6391018629,
0.510225296,
-0.0767400116,
-0.0794273391,
0.1228583381,
-0.0873951316,
-0.211768657,
-0.0629824027,
0.3766024113,
-0.4161742926,
-0.6185982227,
-0.8671354651,
0.3797163367,
-0.6782599688,
1.0032265186,
-0.1483122706,
-0.1058484986,
-0.111160934,
-0.3411030173,
-0.3316060305,
-0.7251358032,
-0.1322952509,
0.1569583714,
0.2089356631,
0.0231043436,
0.3699112236,
0.3363121748,
0.946248889,
0.2821651995,
-0.0348618776,
0.5118219852,
-0.6400673389,
0.3836328387,
-0.1329027116,
-0.197731629,
-0.2432237267,
-0.0684759021,
0.8444920778,
0.4341516197,
0.2131866068,
0.1339057535,
-0.1072521806,
0.6641830206,
-1.0112206936,
-0.1897483021,
-0.7956848145,
0.0166471824,
-0.675716877,
-0.1015801504,
-0.7429583669,
-0.3742370605,
-0.1716181785,
-0.4112879336,
0.6512413621,
0.0380519219,
0.6582065821,
0.2359610796,
-0.4467448592,
-0.5342814326,
-0.7067326903,
0.8963868618,
-0.1200843677,
0.2653899193,
0.3065529466,
0.5750797987,
-0.3259403706,
-0.7110332847,
-0.5687066913,
0.3030003309,
0.2414262891,
0.0548484959,
-0.4162147045,
-0.2511488497,
0.1719370633,
0.5229993463,
-0.7874199748,
-0.0159638301,
0.0576168001,
-0.2052833438,
0.4042661488,
0.2193484157,
0.3242457211,
-0.0114263855,
-0.739490211,
-0.58008039,
-0.4566913545,
-0.2745672464,
0.495067209,
0.1808745414,
0.1959034652,
0.4937869906,
-0.1054216325,
0.6388113499,
-0.0998520702,
0.2138180584,
0.2183967829,
-0.344383806,
-0.2060663849,
-0.2343605906,
1.0590863228,
0.4342099726,
-0.1519671232,
-0.2905825078,
-0.5556672215,
0.5591663718,
0.4720419347,
-0.8914730549,
-0.2739675939,
0.1207140982,
-0.6565181613,
-0.6602806449,
0.130768761,
-1.1030271053,
-0.8017070889,
0.4121316373,
0.6398578286,
-0.2356947064,
0.0298169609,
0.0228621475,
-0.3774563074,
-0.1487048268,
-0.0835516378,
-0.8287838697,
0.2888154387,
0.6596979499,
0.6927729249,
-0.6859051585,
-0.3656886816,
-0.7605876327,
-0.1822038293,
-0.472668618,
1.0651915073,
-0.4732645452,
-0.4608142078,
-0.0097856475,
-0.0352512598,
-0.0806834549,
-0.7259039283,
0.9967623949,
-0.6224499345,
0.2209094316,
-0.3723392487,
-0.7229155302,
0.0568142422,
0.334779799,
-0.9336926341,
0.9265776873,
0.234862119,
-0.7084650397,
0.7690006495,
-0.5098500252,
-0.371383667,
0.2179206163,
-0.1440219134,
-0.7919240594,
0.1420746893,
0.5527877212,
0.388617903,
-0.4666392803,
0.2940935194,
-0.4561066031,
-0.6385360956,
0.4673267007,
-0.7155605555,
0.7907438874,
0.3818892837,
-0.3613867462,
-0.0589462593,
-0.9077290893,
0.0705017075,
0.2150846273,
-0.2433452755,
-0.2012655139,
-0.178308934,
0.2006849051,
-0.4016624391,
0.1523896307,
-0.5440676212,
0.0289872177,
0.076898329,
0.0957557186,
0.871527195,
0.1648658961,
0.2062414289,
-0.4165037274,
0.5170257688,
-0.1299545467,
0.1067369431,
-0.4586422145,
-0.3917343616,
-0.3404655755,
-0.5412704945,
0.3653832078,
0.3630757928,
-0.9062296748,
0.3954524994,
-0.2854658663,
-0.574369669,
-0.3745872378,
0.1006619483,
0.5569695234,
0.2756841183,
0.3331956565,
-0.4334102869,
-0.6468603611,
-0.5598105192,
-0.5854018927,
0.0579789728,
-0.0114550479,
0.1695646495,
0.6784389615,
-0.5322221518,
0.5029198527,
-0.5111892223,
-0.174270153,
-0.0059966678,
0.2670339942,
0.064355813,
0.2198338807,
0.5106605291,
-0.8581465483,
-0.3961729705,
-0.2245048285,
-1.0955269337,
0.0477101356,
-0.0690553039,
-0.0464135818,
0.3791416287,
0.2301556319,
-0.3958193958,
0.3499003053,
0.6950579882,
-0.2342655808,
0.449885428,
-0.1856294274,
0.5102273226,
-0.9217681289,
0.0768687576,
-0.1802241355,
-0.1686389297,
-0.5785563588,
0.5989053249,
0.2355083823,
-0.3531639278,
-0.0088244025,
0.2244692892,
-0.33363837,
-0.274033308,
-0.3444961309,
-0.0531663038,
0.068325296,
0.3932725489,
-0.4194499254,
1.0901514292,
0.4523133934,
-0.5073256493,
0.5921015739,
0.1892085075,
-0.8443378806,
0.8439466953,
-0.6271122694,
0.3965189755,
-0.0178226437,
0.4389811754,
-0.8836972117,
-0.3398940265,
0.1051736698,
-0.5466817021,
0.2046046108,
0.0141212,
-0.7619351149,
-0.3531527817,
-0.35973382,
0.3811193407,
0.4354348481,
-1.1846078634,
0.2612067759,
0.5750020146,
0.3193844557,
-0.6620785594,
-0.6857127547,
0.2042870373,
-0.08219897,
-0.6328353882,
0.317481935,
-0.290453285,
-0.1789563894,
-0.0677902773,
-0.0884814411,
-0.137412414,
0.1422017366,
0.2916846871,
0.3002268076,
-0.1655401438,
-0.0570889413,
-0.3020727038,
-0.1541376114,
-0.0297995973,
-0.2714625597,
0.6870758533,
-0.2493344694,
-0.5362868905,
-0.3197369277,
0.3373114765,
0.7931210399,
-0.0893407688,
0.7774341702,
0.6853004694,
-0.4988777339,
-0.5061678886,
-0.335049361,
0.0448600464,
-0.4953616858,
0.0465059988,
-0.4302301705,
-0.6345100403,
0.3964088559,
0.1015290543,
-0.1514113992,
0.4436352253,
0.5112294555,
0.0249235183,
1.0144850016,
0.2141354233,
-0.1132014096,
0.0847283527,
-0.1193173751,
0.2504656315,
-0.4951308072,
-0.1892045736,
-0.5960950255,
-0.1614313126,
-0.7559321523,
-0.4086950421,
0.2685332596,
-0.0715818331,
-0.150845021,
0.5206454992,
-0.7075476646,
0.4522646368,
0.621311605,
0.1753619313,
0.1916736811,
0.1838956773,
-0.0092905024,
-0.0282118563,
-0.132158488,
-0.3333152831,
1.4820132256,
0.0382927023,
0.6012183428,
0.1518377364,
0.7867301106,
0.7890723348,
0.0676866621,
-0.306533277,
0.546325624,
-0.4761100411,
-0.7749281526,
0.1027926803,
-0.591974318,
-0.9152881503,
0.0894865915,
-0.2887338102,
-0.3103601038,
0.2193747908,
-0.1735059917,
0.0011047338,
0.5545304418,
-0.7785698175,
0.7732437253,
0.1157437041,
-0.2035517693,
0.1104875728,
-0.2807194591,
0.3420238793,
-0.2398325652,
0.1484803855,
0.218310371,
0.1941202283,
0.5319566131,
-0.4725004137,
0.5021474957,
-0.179040134,
0.0723259971,
0.4632345736,
0.0922306925,
0.6236032844,
-0.3550641239,
-0.0702642277,
0.037418168,
-0.3147083521,
-0.5659594536,
-0.4106592834,
0.7687339783,
-0.6667957306,
-0.1142987758,
-0.5422621965,
-0.4893695712,
-0.124674879,
0.3902046084,
0.7628868818,
0.6531120539,
-0.4369223118,
0.4491402805,
0.9426829219,
-0.2409301847,
0.4414626956,
0.1794330776,
-0.2184616774,
-0.7510807514,
1.2774903774,
-0.247198984,
0.1651812494,
0.4190428555,
-0.0565107912,
-0.2910887897,
-0.7017489672,
-0.7049231529,
-0.3479930162,
-0.8080372214,
-0.2880246639,
-0.7028461695,
-0.0839137211,
-0.4838962257,
-0.2745443881,
-0.3616635501,
-0.1334561706,
-0.0451206751,
0.0266129691,
0.2920268476,
0.7266372442,
0.0122441454,
0.1701212227,
-0.6880767345,
0.6944939494,
0.2248699069,
0.4985489547,
-0.2852104306,
-0.2260813564,
0.1715737432,
-0.1330306679,
-0.1686470211,
-0.7695454359,
0.3271215856,
-0.2035569996,
0.4504800737,
0.3449181914,
0.3257775605,
0.1988225877,
-0.067968905,
0.7398581505,
-0.0611200891,
-1.043371439,
0.4093423188,
-0.5098093152,
0.1889059842,
0.784218967,
0.2316455096,
-0.0946017653,
-0.0510956608,
-0.4118134975,
-0.4157224,
0.5309356451,
0.3207587898,
-0.3130518198,
0.0834337324,
-0.188872993,
0.29372859,
0.3010742366,
-0.6180920601,
-0.29751122,
-0.1148913503,
-0.3338297009,
-0.0910377502,
-0.1921402961,
-0.1915567517,
0.3406981826,
0.4682926536,
0.1417278349,
0.3528535664,
-0.0354281105,
-0.2045881897,
-0.0225916747,
0.1022996008,
0.5252492428,
0.0936720893,
-0.2871483266,
0.2638556361,
0.0111037623,
-0.7877001762,
0.0713701919,
0.2409480661,
-0.4609316587,
-0.007788911,
0.3457363248,
0.6949024796,
-0.0533471182,
-0.6678839922,
0.6447552443,
-0.37189731,
-0.0520060696,
-0.0301546734,
-0.0536850132,
-0.4243294895,
-0.014764728,
0.2701818645,
0.7068579793,
0.2749008834,
-0.5255237818,
0.3207494915,
0.4554665983,
-0.5310692787,
-0.0251824334,
0.6769909263,
0.0496635027,
-0.2149301171,
0.399484694,
-0.6372702122,
-0.8907886147,
0.547409296,
0.4378615916,
0.9400834441,
0.0321401358,
0.2532413602,
0.231175229,
0.5600340962,
-0.2134497911,
0.1888861358,
-0.1975395232,
-0.6836510897,
0.2177231014,
-0.5877768397,
-0.6249190569,
0.0513896942,
-0.7984931469,
0.0928993896,
-0.5433747172,
-0.0343976766,
-0.062143039,
0.2515670359,
-0.369240433,
0.145589143,
-0.1446424127,
0.7183562517,
-0.6391984224,
0.4865343571,
0.3549917936,
-0.173275128,
-0.1401593983,
0.0991596878,
0.2142273635,
-0.7826981544,
0.1596618444,
0.4104898274,
-0.2507018745,
-0.3859373629,
-0.5722185969,
-0.3606704175,
0.8157013059,
-0.0202080328,
-0.170102939,
0.3905877769,
0.0165550224,
0.6088036299,
-0.1755189896,
0.0480735004,
0.3950050175,
0.3815134764,
-0.135769099,
-0.2874633968,
0.0883655399,
-0.3969678581,
-0.1510372162,
0.4663805366,
-0.4732781053,
0.9994975328,
-0.0176067948,
-0.5794190168,
0.3532701433,
0.5231347084,
0.3871827722,
0.8296250701,
0.3730029762,
0.8338848948,
0.9380945563,
-0.13695243,
1.2400733232,
-0.007618702,
0.1784334481,
0.9317927361,
-0.5226793885,
0.846927166,
-0.1696827561,
-0.0567056127,
0.3590257466,
0.2343335748,
-0.5947865248,
0.6308820248,
-0.0251351204,
-0.5982760191,
-0.0994941369,
-0.1343866736,
-0.4133812189,
0.3282983899,
0.2404111922,
-0.3953875899,
-0.0552944876,
-0.0084537612,
-0.0456581824,
0.5712573528,
-0.1823324412,
0.4041829705,
-0.358630389,
-0.8532108665,
0.707480371,
-0.0689881742,
0.9127391577,
-0.1772005856,
0.2505895197,
-0.124897711,
0.7366085649,
-0.125804171,
-0.8186947107,
0.0769339129,
0.4641304314,
-0.2918250263,
-0.3702584803,
0.9877638817,
-0.0666739643,
-0.2865879238,
0.1880169958,
0.0226399321,
0.0906745046,
-0.1859838665,
-0.1320870221,
0.5014132261,
-0.0002757995,
0.0961625874,
0.4314088523,
0.3435126543,
0.2178579271,
0.5050114393,
0.8382296562,
-0.2229967713,
0.3044565022,
-0.0279084761,
0.7323094606,
-0.4879251122,
-0.0616020039,
-0.7161126137,
0.0176323801,
-0.267432183,
-0.4804117084,
0.9344959855,
0.6824676394,
0.874533236,
-0.0773875713,
0.8166987896,
0.1541186422,
0.7484539151,
-0.2751998901,
0.9577538371,
-0.3777347505,
0.0893189535,
-0.3853178322,
-0.792924881,
-0.1245322675,
0.2855169475,
0.1819469333,
0.0102940695,
0.6871441603,
0.6352783442,
0.1610328555,
0.5216142535,
0.3644070029,
0.0505300201,
0.4941170216,
0.7039127946,
0.8859721422,
-0.9670595527,
0.8789324164,
-0.2403418571,
-0.2397313714,
-0.1202082559,
-0.8266490102,
-1.1644024849,
-0.76032269,
-0.0510018766,
-0.4120491743,
0.1343057454,
0.2905164063,
0.4921313524,
-1.0134176016,
0.1335421801,
-0.3880293667,
0.0828684494,
-0.1676918715,
-0.2188246697,
0.306946516,
-0.1960324198,
-0.7901263833,
0.6373767853,
0.1656878442,
0.0611541085,
-0.2126455456,
0.1989560872,
0.1813649982,
0.0063580573,
0.4491382837,
0.2131042182,
-0.1810652018,
0.0566279478,
0.1668104231,
-0.5462962389,
-0.3430894911,
0.7049514055,
-0.7159352303,
0.7058280706,
0.7592479587,
0.9482312799,
0.4461776912,
-0.0579682812,
0.5091996193,
-0.618486762,
-0.1797032058,
0.0988097861,
0.2757889628,
0.4444612563,
-0.2416512668,
0.5241079926,
0.4768512845,
-0.8251938224,
-1.4085856676,
0.1398073137,
-0.8113707304,
-0.3396918774,
0.8176184893,
-0.1447749138,
-0.1329090744,
0.0340161994,
0.1848465949,
0.1204605401,
-0.2367092818,
0.7105414867,
0.7377591133,
0.3380383253,
0.214934811,
-0.2555122077,
0.4245765209,
0.2630037069,
-0.9399573803,
0.0763525069,
0.5226787925,
-0.0886456519,
0.2340227962,
0.5054694414,
-0.1370648444,
0.2766133845,
0.6379773021,
-0.050677903,
0.1101066172,
-0.5709143281,
-0.2663930357,
0.5334596038,
-0.4135654569,
-0.4960237145
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07938v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07938v1
|
EconLogicQA: A Question-Answering Benchmark for Evaluating Large Language Models in Economic Sequential Reasoning
| 2024-05-13T17:13:47 | 2024-05-13T17:13:47 |
Yinzhu Quan, Zefang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we introduce EconLogicQA, a rigorous benchmark designed to
assess the sequential reasoning capabilities of large language models (LLMs)
within the intricate realms of economics, business, and supply chain
management. Diverging from traditional benchmarks that predict subsequent
events individually, EconLogicQA poses a more challenging task: it requires
models to discern and sequence multiple interconnected events, capturing the
complexity of economic logics. EconLogicQA comprises an array of multi-event
scenarios derived from economic articles, which necessitate an insightful
understanding of both temporal and logical event relationships. Through
comprehensive evaluations, we exhibit that EconLogicQA effectively gauges a
LLM's proficiency in navigating the sequential complexities inherent in
economic contexts. We provide a detailed description of EconLogicQA dataset and
shows the outcomes from evaluating the benchmark across various leading-edge
LLMs, thereby offering a thorough perspective on their sequential reasoning
potential in economic contexts. Our benchmark dataset is available at
https://huggingface.co/datasets/yinzhu-quan/econ_logic_qa.
|
[
-0.2307134867,
-0.798207283,
0.7342544794,
0.246021837,
-0.0737963766,
0.325073421,
-0.1731805056,
-0.6110371947,
-0.2392825782,
0.291280061,
-0.77711308,
-0.2036823332,
0.0187823679,
0.3655715883,
-0.4766300917,
0.7772203684,
0.0490505919,
-0.2518955767,
-0.3731274307,
-0.1826345176,
0.0548907369,
-0.4899930358,
-0.9282909632,
-0.3079267144,
0.5718776584,
0.0614327192,
0.6371204853,
0.1025709733,
0.2740777731,
0.3349617124,
-0.1731613278,
0.1497735828,
-0.4173590839,
0.2291380465,
-0.3706792593,
-0.2858510315,
-0.2613836527,
-0.1212220713,
0.6357403398,
0.7571037412,
-0.622608304,
0.8863465786,
-0.0874163285,
0.498732537,
-0.5244092941,
0.1259074658,
-0.7674547434,
-0.0825685412,
0.120498687,
0.0658057928,
-0.6012097001,
-0.5969480276,
0.2473998666,
-0.6385666132,
-0.4790346026,
0.4890581965,
0.7779968977,
0.3127745688,
-0.5034261346,
-0.0272946153,
-0.5047886968,
0.7824607491,
-0.6172761321,
0.5279636979,
-0.0985785723,
0.2413629591,
-0.1152639166,
-1.2375149727,
-0.694466114,
0.2528727353,
0.2318859696,
0.4694209695,
-0.2089778632,
0.0161498077,
0.5357550383,
0.066813834,
-0.7569801211,
0.1558521092,
-0.1261443049,
0.1194708496,
0.6477560997,
0.4967035055,
0.1197642982,
-0.0232344288,
-0.571397841,
0.0984626561,
-0.5556532145,
0.2414448112,
0.525852859,
-0.0414760821,
0.1168746352,
0.218072176,
-0.5003786683,
0.759951055,
-0.2678293586,
-0.2122314125,
0.1617839783,
-0.3998667002,
-0.5939804316,
0.0252881721,
0.4985257387,
0.2875438929,
0.0947042704,
0.2109888643,
-0.2218851894,
-0.5107170343,
-0.0347846076,
-0.5095126629,
-0.0966445804,
0.584364295,
-0.5466374159,
0.0973007753,
-0.205375433,
-1.0161534548,
-0.1092567295,
-0.3112426996,
0.4776766896,
0.3381589055,
-0.0416640155,
0.113436766,
-0.1400931478,
0.5819532275,
0.3654778898,
-0.413641423,
0.3437569737,
0.9525392056,
0.7331112027,
0.272266835,
-0.1541068852,
-0.4271525443,
0.0855637789,
-0.3570120037,
0.8711665273,
-0.3985080719,
0.1743190289,
0.0837820619,
0.0777854323,
-0.1482566446,
-0.5496301055,
0.4574123621,
-0.7858721614,
0.0557534434,
-0.2740716636,
-0.6501144171,
-0.4405809045,
0.3285021484,
-0.6587817669,
0.9566909075,
-0.175641343,
-0.5714626312,
0.4864053428,
-0.1018694714,
-0.1596776396,
0.4480591118,
-0.2125301808,
-0.1569180787,
-0.2349891961,
-0.1008856446,
0.1640098542,
-0.6373695731,
0.5250174999,
-0.562943697,
0.0348327756,
0.4715189636,
-0.376685828,
0.8241275549,
0.103446953,
-0.3006522655,
-0.0177546423,
-0.8625560999,
0.3022834063,
0.0457742922,
-0.178848654,
-0.1138477102,
0.2612029314,
0.1433564126,
0.4448955655,
0.3902467191,
-0.3206827939,
0.0591598675,
-0.2107833922,
0.5935471058,
1.0871591568,
0.0565730743,
-0.1215682477,
-0.500833571,
0.5644302368,
-0.4515497983,
0.2394345403,
-0.2688071132,
-0.728810668,
-0.6329312325,
-0.076165013,
0.3627331853,
0.9338710308,
-0.6638657451,
0.2348550707,
0.0524600483,
-0.3686342239,
-0.128614828,
-0.171994552,
0.072087951,
0.4373903573,
0.1861849427,
-0.2822033465,
-0.5135940313,
-0.7921344638,
-0.549749732,
-0.5030040741,
0.0857935175,
0.2952358425,
0.6588332653,
0.1493711174,
0.60196805,
-0.4174861908,
0.3504277468,
-0.2020991594,
0.33269912,
0.7869818807,
0.174679175,
-0.1247554794,
-0.6359072328,
-0.1835461259,
0.0629941896,
-0.5409128666,
-0.2207572758,
-0.679718852,
-0.1898833066,
0.2629994452,
0.2789745629,
-0.5727569461,
0.4405676723,
0.2803136408,
-0.4200187624,
0.7765732408,
-0.1120078936,
-0.0565871485,
-0.5480556488,
0.2423392385,
-0.1268259585,
-0.3755312562,
-0.5371197462,
0.32402879,
-0.2339566946,
0.115204677,
-0.3011820614,
0.5029889941,
-0.2123925835,
-0.59793818,
0.2916426361,
0.2703544796,
0.1023230702,
0.3609668314,
0.1576450914,
0.6871665716,
0.169758901,
-0.2944703102,
0.4751878679,
0.3667816818,
-0.9468194246,
0.5059960485,
-0.9189158678,
-0.0060900454,
0.1000776291,
0.4177471995,
-0.9509743452,
0.1182434261,
-0.0578758717,
0.0282731652,
-0.1832550615,
-0.0246433876,
-0.8667296171,
-0.4854542911,
0.1231829897,
0.430066973,
0.7584032416,
-0.5386759639,
0.6198279858,
0.0643570125,
-0.6230214238,
-0.5896330476,
-0.5460640192,
-0.0339124165,
-0.2480074465,
-0.6090446711,
-0.1804919839,
-0.2674810588,
-0.5311143398,
-0.2304139584,
-0.2479798198,
-0.0463633426,
0.3444498479,
-0.3310670257,
0.3847033083,
-0.2245392054,
0.0547554977,
-0.0485060476,
0.0253274161,
0.5960942507,
-0.7626114488,
0.2054579258,
-0.0450718477,
-0.1573528349,
-0.2399258018,
0.1570699215,
0.3964850307,
-0.1561904252,
0.623367548,
0.1565473378,
-0.5808864236,
-0.3892454505,
-0.653631568,
0.1925747097,
-0.4648107588,
0.2988391817,
-0.2285503596,
-0.6369721293,
0.6624627113,
-0.2999215424,
0.0960487872,
0.4795491695,
0.6478084326,
-0.0072432668,
0.9574815035,
0.0436210185,
0.2576734722,
-0.1848820597,
0.0035690672,
0.4115228951,
-0.8621020317,
-0.5839724541,
-0.3570598662,
-0.2159438431,
-0.4598942399,
-0.4528159201,
0.3465082049,
0.1000417918,
-0.7795610428,
-0.1010721847,
0.0526538417,
0.6038317084,
0.3455211818,
0.0164360441,
0.586125195,
-0.3594359457,
-0.3469212055,
0.3114021719,
-0.7390925884,
-0.6720916033,
0.7774344683,
0.2941284776,
0.6340652704,
0.3814378083,
0.3882372081,
-0.050634712,
0.0511134639,
-0.5791595578,
0.6795028448,
0.1164640114,
-0.500148654,
-0.4055627584,
-0.5080044866,
-0.6919080019,
0.2808540761,
-0.0766189396,
-1.038403511,
0.4480698705,
-0.1414307803,
-0.8213390112,
0.404561609,
-0.1581649333,
1.0586405993,
-0.5298169255,
-0.7161140442,
-0.3109566271,
-0.5370604992,
0.3365064263,
-0.2008303404,
0.5361443758,
-0.3393553793,
-0.4206866324,
0.6550515294,
-0.4273744524,
0.5811426044,
0.3228653073,
-0.1964069307,
0.2716062963,
-0.0021118273,
0.5581668019,
0.2943660021,
-0.0577119701,
0.0299865268,
0.2543165982,
-0.4326579571,
-0.436193645,
0.4174998701,
-0.4649015069,
-0.6922011375,
-0.6123413444,
-0.2322900146,
-0.388541162,
0.1254711747,
-0.1078614593,
0.5115496516,
-0.2258356661,
-0.1246280298,
0.7379624248,
-0.5652102232,
0.5713781714,
0.4141662121,
-0.4396135509,
-0.3420369327,
0.585236311,
0.1475252807,
0.4344022274,
0.3723717928,
0.0392925963,
-0.5308209062,
-0.3783818483,
-0.4489977062,
-0.0610519424,
-1.1295708418,
-0.3013184667,
-0.6153731942,
-0.1492224932,
0.0098426184,
-0.0391701721,
-0.0719160214,
-0.4889138937,
-0.0089984583,
-0.3163253665,
0.3131203353,
0.8582357168,
-0.0678518713,
-0.3359467387,
-0.6421390176,
0.0904671326,
0.7814047337,
0.3342707455,
0.4104687274,
-0.3468792737,
-0.1345617026,
-0.2957656682,
-0.0110310279,
-0.8298083544,
0.3428879082,
0.1624763608,
0.7031094432,
0.3341664076,
0.0462006256,
0.8450027108,
-0.7416475415,
0.9436875582,
0.1417217106,
-1.2585910559,
0.2855619192,
-0.3473342359,
0.5534220338,
0.4218163192,
0.6865942478,
-0.6335202456,
-0.2689268589,
-0.6351874471,
-1.3852915764,
0.4799388349,
0.175699234,
-0.4069669247,
-0.1712254584,
0.1066480204,
0.1729521155,
0.4672083259,
-0.5797570348,
-0.3840531409,
0.1652494371,
-0.0864148512,
0.1134699732,
-0.1492362171,
0.0124884713,
-0.2253787816,
0.6707712412,
-0.0112704225,
-0.1238087341,
0.2808803916,
-0.0060020825,
0.1328366399,
0.4136158228,
0.2594022155,
1.1045764685,
-0.0651893541,
-0.0619373396,
0.426758647,
-0.0164966993,
0.126598075,
0.2669492364,
-0.1349244416,
-0.1736057252,
0.3325756192,
0.4750718176,
0.2949445546,
-1.3178608418,
0.1874353439,
-0.046698384,
-0.1494281888,
-0.6864949465,
-0.5385921001,
0.0468150526,
0.618955791,
0.5745283365,
-0.2981234789,
0.6200083494,
-0.8350130916,
0.2470327467,
0.045898173,
0.0331432149,
-0.1400941461,
0.7932364941,
0.2520314455,
0.1732640415,
0.7718419433,
-0.2446669638,
-0.7988812327,
1.1342606544,
0.3477083445,
0.8117257357,
0.0567121096,
0.245639205,
0.6950746775,
0.5893608332,
-0.3447169065,
0.8287212849,
0.1614359617,
-0.5589593053,
-0.6630918384,
-0.6060581207,
-0.6813993454,
-0.0615695938,
-0.9317725897,
-0.0551106595,
-0.4754374921,
-0.0462384149,
-0.0361984521,
-0.1090351343,
-0.9297064543,
0.1639407128,
0.3820278645,
0.9867965579,
-0.5494753718,
0.3196039796,
0.5482436419,
-0.3169728518,
-0.7790641785,
-0.1687058955,
0.1856977344,
-0.7354020476,
0.9295243025,
0.2278872132,
0.0993618593,
-0.0079808692,
-0.357617259,
-0.9688904285,
1.1951162815,
-0.1100020409,
-1.1176782846,
0.3178537786,
-0.0346880704,
0.2853062749,
-0.3641761541,
0.6784963012,
0.9055828452,
0.6498124003,
-0.130994916,
-0.9728118181,
0.1561623663,
-0.1846920103,
-0.0475318581,
0.3391654789,
-0.9516696334,
0.7924942374,
-0.1726316214,
-0.4682602286,
0.5388457775,
0.4049234688,
0.2794762552,
0.6709675193,
0.6080446839,
0.9456588626,
1.1641691923,
-0.2443927675,
0.968409121,
-0.3060124815,
0.5108200312,
1.2728435993,
-0.8529458046,
1.2088056803,
0.1347123682,
-0.5039122105,
0.9894937873,
0.9007612467,
0.0030099121,
0.2368951291,
0.6981188655,
-0.2677241862,
-0.7461065054,
-0.0821557492,
-0.3050614893,
0.0632852465,
0.4420862198,
0.0740169659,
0.1071931571,
-0.3415811658,
-0.315728426,
-0.077200003,
-0.6407127976,
0.8413591385,
0.137050584,
-0.4656457305,
0.1237921566,
-0.3367483616,
0.0618675053,
-0.45856601,
-0.060953185,
-0.260135293,
-0.1943392754,
-0.0904225186,
-0.8576696515,
0.1132404134,
-0.0444089398,
0.1477539986,
-0.2558837831,
0.3229015172,
-0.3916727006,
-0.4983175695,
0.316950351,
0.5570983291,
-0.0034702048,
0.3220828772,
-0.8522964716,
-0.0560424104,
-0.3088165522,
-0.2786308229,
0.0483193956,
0.67514503,
0.1801403016,
0.7622095942,
0.5669911504,
-0.1703059077,
-0.0253613852,
0.2035697103,
0.3817747235,
-0.901764214,
-0.6475242972,
-0.7019398212,
0.3736208379,
-0.1126463264,
-0.3990774453,
0.6558743119,
0.6297453046,
1.0402523279,
0.1937702149,
0.7551389933,
0.2283045202,
0.264496237,
-0.7458175421,
0.2568146586,
-0.4874669015,
0.3934029043,
-0.1223816276,
-0.6756289601,
0.0416934006,
0.4481223822,
-0.2624202967,
-0.0194086581,
0.9598731399,
0.2802202404,
0.4740732908,
0.4357624054,
0.2828981578,
0.4868941009,
-0.4295013845,
0.7781574726,
1.4642691612,
-0.1944774985,
0.4740674198,
-0.0743431598,
-0.073064886,
0.1376353949,
-0.9761371017,
-0.6431353688,
-0.3203448951,
-0.6133409142,
-0.2133536488,
0.3060705066,
1.1943023205,
0.2993337512,
-0.7448454499,
-0.5265499353,
0.2229765058,
0.4136817455,
-0.5322711468,
-0.219662711,
0.0585849583,
-0.29270643,
-0.5810503364,
0.055017706,
0.5524551272,
-0.2145521641,
-0.2278840244,
0.3966469169,
-0.4240839481,
0.5276203752,
0.7654756904,
0.2498450726,
-0.8754302859,
-0.1231364384,
-0.0524906404,
0.4886980057,
-0.2644683719,
0.8735396862,
-0.7935837507,
0.257101655,
0.586256206,
0.7930226326,
0.1664172411,
-0.0679451227,
0.6318839788,
-0.1441116929,
0.001056408,
0.2278789282,
0.6435531378,
-0.0760474652,
-0.2310821265,
0.6571689844,
0.059969645,
-0.8512735367,
-0.7263882756,
0.3033153117,
-0.9123356342,
-0.3765378892,
0.9733766317,
-0.345156014,
-0.1692065895,
-0.4479490519,
0.3934756815,
-0.3421650827,
-0.3048509359,
0.3434413671,
0.6666738391,
0.115105629,
-0.2550908625,
-0.7839192748,
0.1690049767,
0.3433147967,
-0.9265405536,
0.0828271732,
0.5209946632,
-0.0579520278,
-0.228215456,
0.5176399946,
0.3612212241,
0.4361259043,
-0.0392328389,
-0.1575412899,
0.6803721189,
-0.3418094814,
-0.3726664484,
0.1367847472,
0.0492421836,
0.3945089877
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07932v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07932v2
|
PARDEN, Can You Repeat That? Defending against Jailbreaks via Repetition
| 2024-05-13T17:08:42 | 2024-05-14T15:56:37 |
Ziyang Zhang, Qizhen Zhang, Jakob Foerster
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown success in many natural language
processing tasks. Despite rigorous safety alignment processes, supposedly
safety-aligned LLMs like Llama 2 and Claude 2 are still susceptible to
jailbreaks, leading to security risks and abuse of the models. One option to
mitigate such risks is to augment the LLM with a dedicated "safeguard", which
checks the LLM's inputs or outputs for undesired behaviour. A promising
approach is to use the LLM itself as the safeguard. Nonetheless, baseline
methods, such as prompting the LLM to self-classify toxic content, demonstrate
limited efficacy. We hypothesise that this is due to domain shift: the
alignment training imparts a self-censoring behaviour to the model ("Sorry I
can't do that"), while the self-classify approach shifts it to a classification
format ("Is this prompt malicious"). In this work, we propose PARDEN, which
avoids this domain shift by simply asking the model to repeat its own outputs.
PARDEN neither requires finetuning nor white box access to the model. We
empirically verify the effectiveness of our method and show that PARDEN
significantly outperforms existing jailbreak detection baselines for Llama-2
and Claude-2. Code and data are available at https://github.com/Ed-Zh/PARDEN.
We find that PARDEN is particularly powerful in the relevant regime of high
True Positive Rate (TPR) and low False Positive Rate (FPR). For instance, for
Llama2-7B, at TPR equal to 90%, PARDEN accomplishes a roughly 11x reduction in
the FPR from 24.8% to 2.0% on the harmful behaviours dataset.
|
[
-0.1595295072,
-0.5490841269,
0.7286821604,
0.2021480948,
-0.2403599471,
0.0785266012,
-0.1074604169,
-0.2926894128,
0.1207614839,
0.7860026956,
-0.4053292274,
-0.5678434372,
-0.7694536448,
0.2256488651,
-0.4425564408,
0.9465185404,
-0.1174444556,
-0.1482347548,
0.051391203,
-0.2979465127,
-0.7878636122,
-0.6696287394,
-0.4450595975,
-0.1486260295,
0.4238263369,
0.4409288764,
0.6608951092,
0.9054238796,
0.5866723657,
0.2232192755,
-0.1939579397,
-0.0096555213,
-0.3902146518,
0.295427382,
-0.5445696115,
-0.5076423287,
-0.2499982864,
-0.0093382914,
0.3124640584,
0.3308416903,
-0.2910191715,
-0.1209146604,
0.1096630022,
0.7135626674,
-0.6923362017,
-0.397392571,
-0.7023996115,
-0.0252131745,
-0.4917322993,
0.0115319006,
-0.6024784446,
-0.1640916765,
-0.2986093163,
-0.4991303682,
0.051646404,
0.1115972772,
0.7731435299,
0.2378691882,
-0.2968617976,
-0.199779883,
-0.4531744123,
0.8145340681,
-0.7877200246,
0.0374346487,
0.455839783,
0.3744402528,
-0.1187102124,
-0.6906664968,
-0.4840170443,
-0.3625611067,
0.0526193678,
-0.1044338793,
-0.2821167111,
-0.1835819334,
0.4154060185,
0.2325412333,
-0.595733881,
0.3072119653,
-0.2821665704,
-0.5309090614,
0.4073319733,
0.3329708278,
0.5857999921,
-0.0848003849,
-0.7646421194,
-0.2152026445,
-1.0675854683,
0.2537752986,
0.4794099033,
0.21297656,
0.1440558285,
0.453669101,
-0.1409371644,
0.4694532454,
0.349774152,
-0.1198064014,
0.288800478,
-0.1263349503,
-0.1016840488,
0.3092606068,
0.8239084482,
0.5164575577,
0.0696417317,
-0.1204838902,
-0.1914876997,
0.3286123276,
0.5063539743,
-0.6408898234,
-0.3796458542,
0.234942928,
-0.2653830349,
-0.5397270918,
0.1148512214,
-0.6622616649,
-0.8041606545,
-0.0843614638,
0.3103912473,
-0.6354217529,
-0.1087975129,
0.338732481,
0.0384264626,
0.2938313782,
0.0898570865,
-0.7087727189,
0.3827700615,
0.830817461,
0.8129950762,
-0.4357490242,
-0.5354831815,
-0.6699088216,
0.3464223742,
-0.2598639429,
0.6243495941,
-0.3789454103,
-0.3742076457,
-0.0415179133,
0.1469815373,
0.025915714,
-0.8776217103,
0.6403823495,
-0.4186353683,
-0.1475742757,
-0.5069274902,
-0.4441480041,
0.2272283882,
0.3184115589,
-0.6156064868,
0.6716985106,
-0.0991461724,
-0.9995986223,
0.1993238926,
-0.0399048626,
-0.6413838863,
-0.2329568416,
0.1420405954,
-0.7224199772,
-0.1119711474,
0.4926258922,
0.1183009371,
0.0137127545,
0.8291783929,
-0.5823158026,
-0.1722132862,
0.3090553582,
-0.428509146,
0.8692716956,
0.3593249321,
-0.6487148404,
-0.0082766684,
-0.6063059568,
-0.222148627,
0.2028187513,
-0.2017022073,
-0.4982511401,
0.0111634182,
-0.5280171037,
0.2692660391,
0.1987015605,
-0.8258718252,
0.1128584668,
-0.204068616,
0.317219466,
0.856328249,
0.1539717615,
0.430428654,
-0.7596392632,
0.5045371652,
0.2450744361,
0.2277213782,
-0.249763146,
-0.2848583162,
-0.7629852891,
-0.1706188023,
0.1298096925,
0.8658951521,
-0.7988815904,
0.5198481679,
-0.2143256217,
-0.153821975,
-0.4902613461,
0.4144130051,
0.707644701,
0.6390055418,
0.3995065689,
-0.3952918649,
-0.5968126059,
-0.9349774718,
-0.5486419201,
-0.1717647612,
0.2162999064,
0.0584123135,
0.2050350308,
-0.2044933289,
0.7740405202,
-0.3104149103,
-0.2811742425,
-0.24530451,
0.0072652809,
0.1872460842,
0.4990864694,
0.5839427114,
-0.4533307254,
-0.3802601397,
-0.2848029435,
-0.9474151134,
-0.6381626129,
-0.3508240879,
-0.2324077785,
-0.0395452268,
0.6237421036,
-0.3157367408,
0.2060824186,
0.297326535,
-0.3605784178,
0.3886018395,
0.0256547779,
-0.005300527,
-0.9633551836,
-0.2344160825,
0.0045203264,
-0.5187527537,
-0.7284045219,
0.1828906536,
0.3044109643,
-0.0670876801,
-0.6295502782,
0.3829516172,
-0.1121081486,
0.2274061292,
-0.2609122396,
0.0437188223,
0.0932783335,
0.1022295803,
-0.188604176,
1.0863404274,
0.6195968986,
-0.4523300827,
0.1051543728,
0.4536774755,
-0.4661636651,
0.6541774869,
-0.6231896877,
0.0138906296,
-0.1185724512,
-0.001964482,
-0.8314307928,
-0.1790642142,
0.3120717704,
-0.173900038,
0.328599453,
-0.0165031888,
-0.2667885721,
-0.3010329604,
-0.5885792971,
0.2214958221,
0.6468825936,
-1.0322278738,
0.1124542579,
0.4212499559,
-0.2987366617,
-0.6362522244,
-0.7277134061,
0.2582509518,
-0.5452471972,
-0.7174411416,
0.2577940524,
0.0700343475,
-0.3590246141,
-0.1633022726,
-0.3680472374,
0.0525986589,
0.2861762047,
0.3672939837,
0.1962452382,
-0.0404724106,
-0.257299453,
0.0975906253,
-0.2107914388,
0.1887688935,
-0.2436379045,
0.4259313643,
-0.0903890356,
-0.3264014423,
-0.5744884014,
0.2436331064,
0.4478988051,
-0.0056989384,
0.6395118833,
0.058489453,
-0.0258619227,
-0.3157170415,
-0.4452352822,
0.1832551211,
-0.5170018673,
-0.057602834,
-0.255335331,
-0.9947587848,
0.5369045734,
-0.0926403478,
-0.2602063715,
0.2149422318,
0.4436775744,
-0.1825708598,
0.6868246198,
0.2929032445,
-0.4585984051,
0.4257709682,
0.1437114775,
0.3492639065,
-0.9714440703,
-0.0143967494,
-0.1391397119,
-0.1957029104,
-0.293949306,
0.0326547511,
0.2913333178,
0.3003590703,
-0.5117782354,
0.8002409935,
-0.3637752235,
0.7197012901,
0.4192480147,
0.4960568547,
0.2393852174,
-0.1140183359,
0.0027520407,
-0.0301444866,
-0.397038579,
-0.6107559204,
1.0903580189,
0.5321803689,
0.9872694016,
0.3229037225,
1.16284585,
0.546695888,
0.4679556787,
-0.3342207968,
0.5609325171,
-0.1652166098,
-0.4767535627,
-0.1417880207,
-0.299236089,
-0.8510444164,
0.2162216604,
0.3339728713,
-0.8292543888,
0.1421046108,
0.2583155334,
-0.4832406044,
0.4485064745,
-0.5681413412,
0.7180726528,
-0.4403844178,
-0.5317755938,
0.105990082,
-0.6810283661,
0.8284749389,
-0.2837686241,
0.3807030916,
-0.3363119066,
0.1435895115,
0.5602293015,
-0.6677199602,
1.1696943045,
-0.218069762,
-0.1342871189,
0.4300383329,
0.6058531404,
0.7003336549,
0.1373121142,
0.0046670008,
0.1042691618,
-0.0827707127,
-0.2764938772,
-0.389980942,
0.8950174451,
-0.7274929881,
-1.1687717438,
-0.5941866636,
-0.4278992712,
-0.0810042024,
0.2308102548,
0.3524092734,
0.2476723641,
0.0684988871,
0.0968950614,
0.6087498665,
-0.3562631607,
0.4242454469,
0.3008278608,
-0.2349677831,
-0.6261467338,
0.8807207346,
-0.2781558633,
0.4844890237,
0.0741263777,
0.378531903,
-0.1526893824,
-0.5596003532,
-0.281886369,
0.0523511656,
-0.8249740601,
-0.534412086,
-0.534691453,
-0.0617188327,
-0.5242254138,
-0.3173529208,
-0.2282865793,
-0.3388756216,
-0.0372054689,
-0.1675958037,
0.107791923,
0.5323364735,
-0.240380317,
0.5928868055,
-0.7682771087,
0.520339191,
0.3353369534,
0.3294656873,
-0.3349648416,
-0.8001664877,
0.3182373643,
-0.1083042547,
-0.4839327037,
-0.8053820133,
0.4867148101,
-0.0087159369,
0.5702078938,
0.2420741171,
0.3319902122,
0.4351566136,
-0.5224585533,
0.7910459638,
0.3036368489,
-1.0932868719,
0.7262797952,
-0.5068063736,
-0.1194854155,
0.8811156154,
0.2484671026,
-0.4299633801,
-0.3899749815,
-0.4918808937,
-0.8140935898,
0.6371196508,
0.238826707,
0.192593202,
-0.2205520123,
0.1942864507,
0.0529745519,
0.1670982093,
-0.9773770571,
-0.060139928,
-0.269887805,
-0.0551517643,
0.2061618418,
-0.4659011066,
-0.2248478979,
-0.185656637,
0.6176093817,
0.1716014147,
-0.0213329569,
0.3320780694,
-0.4460220635,
0.1756452024,
0.3429250717,
0.3484583497,
0.291873306,
-0.0681875721,
0.3651499152,
0.0545132793,
-0.3519396782,
0.6041589379,
-0.3754299581,
-0.1689701974,
-0.1394295245,
0.4582194388,
0.7623659372,
0.0944403931,
-0.5720025897,
0.8827372789,
0.2208394706,
-0.1657486856,
-0.2813152671,
0.2177349478,
-0.3196626604,
0.1842838079,
-0.327467829,
-0.0312996991,
0.0345373824,
-0.6679663658,
0.5590524673,
0.0425597839,
-0.1873363703,
-0.1073554084,
0.8773760796,
0.0344444588,
-0.2680255175,
0.5370153785,
-0.3934646547,
-0.6621428132,
0.6923987269,
0.9522551894,
0.9943100214,
-0.392545253,
0.1564232409,
0.1896479577,
0.3252925277,
-0.4416030943,
0.2244351357,
0.1204775646,
-1.0297492743,
-0.1591582745,
-0.4814879298,
-0.3520002663,
0.1540109068,
-0.8672472835,
0.1327923536,
-0.8723329306,
-0.1810046136,
-0.0354205146,
-0.6746182442,
-0.0791124478,
-0.1900175661,
0.3071905673,
0.9474229217,
-1.0642559528,
0.9263717532,
0.2877579629,
-0.1409437954,
-0.4482553005,
0.2493722588,
0.3979520798,
-0.8145592809,
0.3823178113,
0.4690103233,
0.0172378272,
-0.2785928249,
-0.748734355,
-0.8183839321,
0.9720715284,
0.2335121185,
-0.943166554,
0.2514947951,
0.2397961468,
0.3016399145,
-0.2233944833,
-0.5045099258,
1.0670479536,
0.3357076347,
-0.0980261564,
-0.6095104814,
0.1747188121,
-0.1753997058,
0.2209959179,
0.4277166128,
-0.5414961576,
0.7728338242,
-0.1635348797,
-0.227670759,
0.3358401954,
0.2790695131,
0.3763552904,
0.2267505676,
0.4307576418,
0.8632350564,
0.8009380102,
-0.1210726351,
1.3095276356,
-0.4308071733,
0.2983359396,
1.3934880495,
-0.8897486925,
0.5849200487,
0.5344189405,
-0.1209850088,
0.484929502,
0.2297833264,
-0.2213312685,
0.894626081,
0.3140588701,
-0.2828995287,
-0.4679144621,
-0.0029886093,
-0.0378669426,
0.0846384615,
0.1895001382,
-0.1789079607,
-0.3455228508,
0.3260840178,
0.2103046328,
0.4346494079,
-0.2561656833,
0.6756362319,
0.1903487146,
-0.6001748443,
0.5881200433,
-0.0552040488,
0.6423813701,
-0.3446333408,
0.2921303809,
-0.3614303172,
0.3312082887,
-0.0595088489,
-1.0391037464,
0.5223252773,
0.1461020559,
-0.0934255123,
-0.3760408759,
0.81480515,
-0.14899984,
-0.2193376571,
0.4727030098,
0.1941308826,
-0.1920426637,
-0.0182152148,
-0.4691663384,
0.3017922342,
0.1227704734,
-0.1012282446,
0.5118724108,
0.2002718896,
-0.2948382497,
0.7494665384,
0.6215000153,
-0.0000870713,
0.2584884763,
0.0710644051,
1.0211281776,
-0.727088213,
-0.4363826513,
-1.0288521051,
0.2847391963,
-0.2335722744,
-0.2094041705,
0.6687101126,
0.4783293307,
1.0601422787,
0.0131159835,
0.9439688325,
-0.0683321357,
0.4875872433,
-0.6712774038,
0.3155133724,
-0.0476708338,
0.6705412865,
-0.0370579995,
-0.6509420276,
-0.3585123122,
0.4916231334,
-0.5381916165,
-0.5254135132,
0.865267992,
0.7806403637,
-0.0603109673,
0.0235781055,
0.3604607284,
0.1598987579,
0.4797668755,
0.7359213829,
1.0775780678,
-0.2785074115,
0.3954664469,
-0.4649913907,
-0.0611400642,
0.1834992319,
-0.8259150386,
-0.9630848169,
-0.0852187127,
-0.332624346,
-0.7565175295,
0.3347970843,
0.7435016632,
0.3323855698,
-1.079359293,
-0.0357003063,
-0.1401520967,
-0.078549549,
-0.0519850627,
-0.1413608044,
-0.0444420688,
-0.5388522744,
-0.2351416796,
0.5599182844,
0.2902119756,
0.0892151296,
0.2492024451,
0.048689954,
0.1140463576,
-0.1230088547,
0.3166989982,
0.4404557347,
-0.7246909142,
-0.5357171297,
-0.2101765126,
-0.3531708121,
0.3022607863,
0.8974410295,
-0.626470089,
0.3309438527,
0.3567026854,
0.9676083326,
0.1619787663,
0.2513034046,
0.5769099593,
-0.7662758231,
0.0840056166,
0.1025210321,
0.6510878801,
0.2908420265,
-0.4740811884,
0.4241561294,
0.3152637482,
-0.5226868987,
-0.6464275122,
0.4551116824,
-0.8173317909,
-0.3495357633,
1.3555672169,
-0.3745817244,
-0.3240118623,
-0.1182885841,
-0.2745305896,
-0.0507294722,
-0.2751696408,
0.8877637386,
0.5756101012,
-0.0339061841,
-0.0819429234,
-0.4012755454,
0.3684083223,
0.4742635489,
-0.7647494674,
0.2768309414,
0.3211492002,
0.7417343855,
0.108582139,
0.3312277496,
-0.3822457194,
0.1669286788,
-0.1935524791,
-0.1470520794,
-0.166928038,
-0.5571060181,
-0.8585342765,
0.0417746045,
0.0735634863,
-0.2521832585
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07886v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07886v1
|
Russian-Language Multimodal Dataset for Automatic Summarization of Scientific Papers
| 2024-05-13T16:21:33 | 2024-05-13T16:21:33 |
Alena Tsanda, Elena Bruches
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The paper discusses the creation of a multimodal dataset of Russian-language
scientific papers and testing of existing language models for the task of
automatic text summarization. A feature of the dataset is its multimodal data,
which includes texts, tables and figures. The paper presents the results of
experiments with two language models: Gigachat from SBER and YandexGPT from
Yandex. The dataset consists of 420 papers and is publicly available on
https://github.com/iis-research-team/summarization-dataset.
|
[
-0.1915787607,
-0.5651633739,
0.3882935345,
0.2941876054,
-0.3647726178,
0.0719054267,
-0.0633121952,
-0.4444812834,
0.43984887,
0.3095988035,
-0.2900127769,
-0.2665178478,
-0.4850213528,
0.203276664,
-0.626414299,
1.390504241,
-0.0534605011,
0.4097715914,
-0.3336978853,
-0.1096261144,
-0.0251808669,
-0.2695426047,
-0.1414350122,
-0.1816549748,
0.4832926095,
0.4344169199,
0.5911951661,
0.6044696569,
0.7466749549,
0.351075381,
0.2822248638,
-0.0125230234,
-0.1318653822,
0.1179979965,
-0.1022548527,
-0.4509640038,
-0.4899500608,
-0.1250956208,
1.1115618944,
0.5228344202,
0.1242627054,
0.2800312638,
-0.3074466586,
0.5474777222,
-0.294539243,
0.3186435997,
-0.2246135175,
-0.0016092187,
-0.2085069716,
-0.1324068755,
-0.1896128207,
-0.4855147004,
0.0719866008,
-0.3298472464,
0.2212610096,
-0.0188394394,
0.7169499993,
-0.2316038311,
-0.7986425161,
-0.3378622234,
-0.583143115,
0.5728398561,
-0.7390400171,
0.3536231518,
0.3683294654,
0.2110117227,
0.2148505598,
-0.8633556366,
-0.5930603743,
-0.3123281002,
-0.4286371768,
0.2899106741,
-0.0857072473,
-0.2228649855,
0.1012747064,
0.2732232809,
-1.0410850048,
-0.2891429365,
-0.8224072456,
-0.1459256411,
0.7798628211,
0.2961764336,
0.2561925352,
-0.2092560381,
-0.0252337828,
-0.0526149571,
-0.3448088467,
-0.3009522855,
0.415561825,
0.287022531,
-0.1441247761,
0.9259343743,
-0.4376321137,
0.814977169,
-0.3468413651,
-0.2624159157,
0.470446527,
-0.938677907,
-0.0393958427,
0.0382254273,
0.904258132,
0.391720295,
0.3084511459,
-0.1522914916,
-0.2489324361,
0.1778632253,
-0.0011267071,
-0.7940184474,
-0.2772770524,
0.1718238145,
-0.4998939633,
-0.309220016,
0.1032516435,
-0.8767914772,
-0.1721591055,
-0.4925419092,
0.4172629416,
-0.1454534382,
-0.4368917942,
-0.0193450283,
-0.2535493374,
-0.2077185065,
0.2637441754,
-0.6852605939,
0.4003514946,
0.3499339819,
1.0334990025,
-0.1551683992,
-0.5161883831,
-0.3544506431,
0.0864368156,
-0.3165023029,
1.0313097239,
-0.4543845057,
-0.3120032251,
-0.1735483855,
0.2964185774,
-0.1467487216,
-0.2164083719,
0.3505535126,
-0.3064750731,
0.4938239753,
-0.2648892403,
-0.1995775551,
-0.23722516,
0.0822133869,
-0.6475604773,
0.8579829335,
-0.1103370413,
-0.8170295358,
0.2856403887,
-0.9097853899,
-0.5294393897,
0.0558361709,
0.0674153641,
-0.3037249446,
0.1315996498,
-0.0792248771,
0.6952496767,
-0.1830458343,
0.4793022871,
-0.2647262812,
0.0195807107,
0.4523913264,
-0.0662003383,
0.586869061,
0.5332299471,
0.0431179553,
0.2334541976,
-1.0587896109,
0.033575803,
0.0506615117,
-0.2349081784,
-0.4704246223,
0.0740547851,
0.8638464212,
0.3261103034,
0.3033750653,
-0.5335355401,
0.3067379296,
0.0142190298,
0.2631584108,
0.3200754523,
-0.1374856383,
0.1721366346,
-0.4953299761,
0.4993206561,
0.1023955643,
-0.2324600816,
-0.5820442438,
-0.3382284641,
-0.6061036587,
-0.2865546942,
0.45369187,
0.5867361426,
-0.8109550476,
0.0869419128,
-0.4354208112,
-0.5142114162,
-0.2878544033,
-0.0733256191,
0.4064719677,
0.3054804504,
0.0269518271,
-0.1914462745,
-0.4931538403,
-1.2500511408,
-0.0114157908,
0.040803019,
0.0918904319,
-0.0483911298,
1.175571084,
-0.1285461336,
0.7808460593,
-0.6330102086,
-0.0481641814,
-0.1649231017,
0.6640030146,
0.0703726783,
0.6146794558,
0.7061938643,
-0.986666441,
-0.7142006159,
-0.0009766405,
-0.7912148833,
-0.0930816606,
0.0406254642,
0.3036857545,
0.4490222037,
0.1553902179,
-0.5358170867,
0.3063704073,
0.4926371872,
-0.6658037305,
0.9422730207,
-0.3639469743,
0.6432886124,
-1.4844394922,
0.520216167,
0.1943818182,
-0.4370794594,
-0.8703325391,
-0.0549466088,
0.2980366945,
-0.1773904562,
-0.1722604632,
0.3274267614,
-0.6316497326,
-0.287520498,
-0.3597740233,
0.0992941111,
-0.0286514349,
0.1530870497,
0.3597892523,
0.9961391687,
0.6084166169,
-0.3378058374,
0.5781788826,
0.2980979681,
-0.4906317592,
0.6339122057,
-0.9077218771,
-0.2622709274,
-0.4369752705,
0.0833903253,
-1.1485499144,
-0.6146895885,
-0.0444202647,
-0.4190731049,
0.1789506078,
0.0778067335,
-0.7883751988,
-0.1500920653,
-0.3865035772,
0.2691036761,
-0.0342639722,
-0.0817136392,
0.3094560802,
0.5353153944,
-0.7090756893,
-0.4827305079,
-0.8977085948,
0.4274327159,
-0.1506825686,
-0.7061259151,
0.1993331462,
-0.4024812579,
-0.4595187604,
0.2120521069,
0.4152175188,
-0.3593162596,
-0.2608421147,
0.0056249425,
0.3208559453,
-0.0847066864,
0.4675911069,
-0.130165115,
-0.0149925323,
-0.0789845362,
0.0633130595,
0.5425630212,
-0.5145664811,
-0.0846504793,
-0.3612344861,
0.6060343981,
0.758097887,
-0.1965004653,
0.572891891,
0.6602053046,
-0.3059349954,
0.3858606219,
-0.4199232459,
-0.0515843518,
-0.372643739,
0.505366683,
-0.3263431787,
-0.4532191753,
0.7308954597,
0.3958322406,
-0.0234780442,
0.5811975598,
0.4766559601,
-0.1866496503,
1.0213857889,
0.5048952103,
-0.1163639501,
0.2267359793,
-0.2782386839,
-0.1184123456,
-0.5099960566,
-0.3013108075,
-0.7861682773,
-0.0550214723,
-0.6092039943,
-0.0354451872,
0.3928273022,
-0.5368028283,
0.2123669684,
0.2740913332,
-0.3257811666,
0.4171485007,
0.5556750894,
-0.1319794953,
0.5477483869,
0.1674832553,
0.0607956387,
-0.1847234666,
-0.5715638995,
-0.4465308487,
1.0130975246,
-0.1280675977,
0.8420192599,
0.1470424831,
0.2584701777,
0.4234727025,
0.0384982564,
-0.7218506336,
0.4685826004,
0.0453559496,
-0.8916563988,
-0.1005796492,
-0.4084250927,
-0.8995707631,
0.3006021976,
-0.3319195509,
-0.5975682735,
0.2330545038,
0.0410484634,
0.0534340143,
0.0127681438,
-0.8127453327,
0.6518622637,
-0.2518153191,
-0.3911719322,
-0.4322162271,
-0.7317390442,
0.4789317846,
-0.1815725565,
0.3440696597,
0.1700321287,
0.0729709789,
1.0889627934,
-0.1955659688,
0.5087544918,
0.0352905579,
0.1307404935,
0.0922179222,
-0.1148829684,
0.3973284364,
0.1121123508,
0.2141261399,
-0.0889737681,
0.3765892684,
-0.3845936656,
-0.1195008978,
0.9282684326,
-0.6274746656,
-0.098454684,
-0.9505771399,
-0.9482440352,
0.0159809161,
0.548668921,
0.0157781802,
0.8092214465,
-0.2404248863,
0.4591636062,
0.5930363536,
-0.062105462,
0.7023553848,
0.8075795174,
-0.4945594668,
-0.6922002435,
0.9035128355,
0.6186829805,
0.13647376,
0.2215450853,
0.1043317914,
-0.2272249907,
-0.4962925613,
-0.3552877605,
0.3557450473,
-0.6507470608,
-0.0147107458,
-0.8738470078,
-0.0933989659,
-0.5627368689,
-0.0171576515,
-0.0916446224,
-0.89764148,
-0.1998167783,
-0.0726624206,
0.3495204449,
0.8926664591,
-0.2604984045,
0.4223686159,
-0.8104636669,
0.4152225554,
0.0931069776,
0.4956101477,
-0.4233726263,
-0.2648357153,
-0.5563140512,
0.2127132565,
-0.1109457314,
-0.9489715099,
0.6474257112,
0.2625132501,
0.453215152,
0.3139650822,
-0.4944548011,
0.3698541522,
-0.3239156008,
0.7920178771,
0.2737597525,
-0.6816754341,
0.3821881413,
-0.8611289859,
0.7521846294,
0.3715438247,
0.5728027821,
-0.7292986512,
-0.0232332889,
-0.4899546802,
-0.5817984343,
0.8452080488,
0.088826336,
-0.124199681,
0.3936589658,
0.015797263,
0.3411189616,
0.4337629676,
-0.9311811328,
-0.2748999894,
-0.4478506446,
-0.46116063,
-0.5595853329,
-0.547560215,
-0.3435504138,
-0.2661036551,
0.828532815,
-0.2093238533,
0.2786216438,
-0.0396882594,
-0.3391688764,
-0.0066379816,
0.254871875,
1.1764832735,
1.062828064,
-0.2705940306,
0.2963588238,
-0.1860957742,
-0.8030857444,
0.0268192701,
0.346601963,
-0.3160104454,
0.1532425135,
0.3170912564,
0.6713565588,
-0.2598915994,
-0.6944195628,
0.2545776367,
-0.2421207279,
-0.396464169,
-0.4086301029,
-0.2196295261,
0.2543110549,
0.063498348,
0.6312260628,
0.0604048595,
0.539473772,
-0.4729971588,
0.2599162161,
0.4189844429,
-0.0614752583,
-0.7796545625,
0.4350992739,
-0.0853129476,
-0.0854127556,
0.3220536411,
0.0444425642,
-0.2785645723,
0.544621408,
0.6544159651,
0.6578097939,
-0.1670276225,
0.5485938787,
0.4026854038,
0.4765542746,
-0.0898948014,
0.6231595874,
0.1132642478,
-0.3054274917,
-0.3026230633,
-0.4290052652,
-0.235032782,
0.2444124222,
-0.4447102845,
0.159476608,
0.0406342819,
-0.106912896,
0.3199158311,
0.0437463745,
-0.2700025737,
0.2875328958,
-0.3523890674,
0.5237714648,
-1.1121845245,
0.7194465399,
0.9632838368,
-0.4043716788,
0.0654716343,
-0.3956804872,
-0.0240489859,
-0.3977991641,
0.8531599045,
-0.1316268295,
-0.0290218052,
-0.1115562543,
-0.6089769006,
-1.1911855936,
0.8776069283,
0.0900138095,
-0.2669328153,
0.2278648466,
0.3795698285,
0.6045244336,
-0.284345746,
0.4400943816,
0.1110102683,
0.7969487906,
-0.1848642379,
-1.0365511179,
-0.2504307926,
-0.9119441509,
-0.1696416438,
0.174262315,
-0.775988102,
0.9703131914,
0.0358141139,
0.0073128757,
-0.3013728857,
0.5506142974,
-0.1494820714,
0.3349031508,
0.2879930735,
0.4467315376,
0.3426668942,
-0.2554119229,
0.7379422188,
-0.3079927862,
0.3019207418,
1.0001068115,
-0.0012706064,
0.4325461984,
0.5805481672,
-0.1898609251,
0.2621420026,
0.5083116293,
-0.2408029586,
0.6143171191,
-0.1259225905,
-0.1255832165,
0.251857847,
-0.1842281073,
-0.4735516906,
0.5649921894,
0.4571026564,
-0.3620123565,
-0.3118792176,
0.2245628685,
0.3344989121,
-0.1544970274,
-0.0871551484,
0.9025095105,
-0.3518603742,
-0.6856421828,
0.3454724252,
0.0470036194,
0.3838855028,
-0.9133814573,
0.0704055652,
-0.1506231278,
0.1471748054,
-0.2616184056,
-0.6909461021,
0.5116835833,
-0.0101303952,
-0.3315703571,
-0.0764318928,
0.8386713266,
-0.7965255976,
-0.9076042175,
-0.2713111043,
0.3463502526,
0.2064243257,
0.4041390717,
-0.4119850397,
-0.1569048464,
-0.1365355402,
-0.5304998755,
0.3749289811,
0.0579292923,
-0.0749233812,
0.8165861368,
0.5605039001,
0.164288342,
0.0486092605,
-0.2031105161,
0.7577653527,
-0.5307014585,
-0.6359063983,
-0.5619716048,
0.7913774252,
-0.2523910105,
-0.2520295978,
0.9803752303,
1.0522553921,
0.4932209849,
-0.5001490116,
1.1892205477,
-0.3959133923,
0.4455364943,
-0.2933346033,
1.0488237143,
-0.7446094751,
-0.4860247076,
-0.2289845198,
-0.6708077788,
-0.4790867865,
0.4972236156,
0.0251974538,
0.0170960296,
0.8656907082,
0.9311055541,
-0.249265492,
0.0346529447,
0.2306617349,
0.2889074385,
0.3065490723,
-0.0671120957,
0.5318424702,
-0.4319300354,
0.2667884827,
-0.4182168841,
-0.3160466254,
-0.3219721913,
-1.0516473055,
-0.8585814238,
-1.2010300159,
-0.2293655127,
-0.1062606499,
0.1702165902,
0.803796947,
0.4703509212,
-1.0056694746,
-0.5356702209,
0.220100522,
-0.2903242409,
-0.1244123206,
-0.2402395904,
0.4541566968,
-0.2029814124,
-0.7957008481,
0.3024664521,
0.1476569176,
0.3111051023,
-0.4457807839,
0.1596262902,
-0.7204378247,
-0.0513307154,
0.4430256188,
-0.0097900601,
-0.1681237966,
0.0236154478,
0.0215109903,
-0.0513581261,
-0.0100039169,
0.7612425685,
-0.3512328863,
0.7391795516,
0.9221748114,
0.0090624755,
0.7365684509,
-0.2388274372,
0.5730923414,
-0.4177058935,
0.255418092,
-0.0493924543,
0.5682607889,
0.2393356413,
-0.2279357612,
0.4661713243,
0.4081383646,
-0.6839207411,
-0.9181750417,
0.0097241523,
-1.0285892487,
-0.224033162,
1.0200122595,
0.0512211323,
-0.0909348354,
-0.043718271,
-0.3410649896,
0.261197269,
-0.4091950357,
1.0763624907,
0.9388228059,
0.2333939373,
-0.2978710532,
-0.618570745,
0.3428218067,
0.1320094615,
-1.1900404692,
0.066485934,
0.8930464983,
0.2765337527,
0.4130509198,
0.4320579767,
-0.1571188569,
0.3754607737,
0.0268289,
0.272164762,
-0.3887817264,
-0.5935614109,
-0.2947415709,
0.2789835334,
-0.3719770014,
0.1726708561
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07883v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07883v1
|
Zero-Shot Tokenizer Transfer
| 2024-05-13T16:17:10 | 2024-05-13T16:17:10 |
Benjamin Minixhofer, Edoardo Maria Ponti, Ivan Vulić
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models (LMs) are bound to their tokenizer, which maps raw text to a
sequence of vocabulary items (tokens). This restricts their flexibility: for
example, LMs trained primarily on English may still perform well in other
natural and programming languages, but have vastly decreased efficiency due to
their English-centric tokenizer. To mitigate this, we should be able to swap
the original LM tokenizer with an arbitrary one, on the fly, without degrading
performance. Hence, in this work we define a new problem: Zero-Shot Tokenizer
Transfer (ZeTT). The challenge at the core of ZeTT is finding embeddings for
the tokens in the vocabulary of the new tokenizer. Since prior heuristics for
initializing embeddings often perform at chance level in a ZeTT setting, we
propose a new solution: we train a hypernetwork taking a tokenizer as input and
predicting the corresponding embeddings. We empirically demonstrate that the
hypernetwork generalizes to new tokenizers both with encoder (e.g., XLM-R) and
decoder LLMs (e.g., Mistral-7B). Our method comes close to the original models'
performance in cross-lingual and coding tasks while markedly reducing the
length of the tokenized sequence. We also find that the remaining gap can be
quickly closed by continued training on less than 1B tokens. Finally, we show
that a ZeTT hypernetwork trained for a base (L)LM can also be applied to
fine-tuned variants without extra training. Overall, our results make
substantial strides toward detaching LMs from their tokenizer.
|
[
0.0587139092,
-0.5783189535,
0.6113410592,
-0.1675926745,
-0.3635900617,
0.0484482236,
-0.1912139505,
-0.4631037414,
0.3677523732,
0.4196336567,
-0.0694178641,
-0.2518137395,
-0.6509853005,
-0.1021510512,
-0.425270319,
0.8568802476,
-0.119375132,
-0.0515700169,
0.4370673299,
-0.0908777267,
-0.5267996788,
-0.6229973435,
-0.3146368265,
-0.4811750948,
0.6923827529,
0.4497659504,
0.7117618322,
0.8281348348,
0.135255903,
0.1475136727,
-0.186480388,
-0.5513064861,
-0.4856925905,
0.0861701518,
-0.1897262335,
-0.5588536263,
-0.2903652787,
-0.2539722621,
0.5368782878,
0.7019348741,
0.134254545,
0.1934936196,
-0.293318212,
0.3008561134,
-0.8301367164,
-0.0048918258,
-0.9968777299,
0.2115868032,
-0.2164805681,
-0.1975028366,
-0.5616473556,
0.0439451523,
-0.0469569787,
-0.5661780834,
0.3380495012,
-0.0251024403,
0.8648081422,
-0.2341650277,
-0.4776034057,
0.2385578454,
-1.0926823616,
0.7357438803,
-0.6148833036,
0.4508529305,
-0.0933348611,
0.4419075549,
0.1811614335,
-0.6605032086,
-0.6267677546,
-0.1251343191,
0.2243419886,
0.0514349677,
-0.2911600769,
0.1074202284,
0.1922476441,
0.2521834373,
-0.4456005096,
0.1014748961,
-0.3518258631,
-0.3741312921,
-0.0503690988,
0.1336805969,
0.2843989134,
-0.1185960397,
-0.4917705357,
0.1113556921,
-0.8532344699,
-0.1316954345,
0.0193258915,
0.5190102458,
0.3062526584,
0.5538323522,
-0.3772426546,
0.6778560877,
-0.1388147622,
0.4420361221,
0.3341009319,
-0.3664602339,
-0.2830460072,
0.3800473511,
0.4935791492,
0.335398972,
0.2600007057,
-0.6158687472,
-0.3534408808,
-0.0628143176,
0.0476386808,
-0.973054409,
0.0408614576,
0.0509862937,
-0.0476786159,
-0.2658418417,
-0.0572347678,
-0.2043299377,
0.0583900213,
0.0189893432,
0.8926971555,
-0.5333434343,
-0.2251821905,
0.395716399,
-0.4612415731,
0.2394361794,
0.3342962861,
-0.8613744378,
-0.0048448504,
0.6750119925,
1.2340198755,
0.2011387646,
-0.4518889189,
-0.599973321,
0.4890157282,
-0.5400086045,
0.4669202268,
-0.2844855487,
-0.1007752046,
0.0849628448,
0.0561932921,
-0.0407454707,
-0.1513828933,
-0.0464313477,
-0.7193387151,
-0.0493427068,
-0.3018101454,
-0.713142097,
-0.0931205302,
0.4122502506,
-0.6245697141,
0.5907163024,
0.4155783057,
-0.4276302159,
0.3356867731,
-0.4788071513,
-0.2646912038,
0.3400408328,
-0.0456078388,
-0.0329407305,
0.2970580757,
-0.1100408286,
0.4464208186,
-0.2936283052,
-0.0232569128,
-0.2627421021,
-0.8742410541,
-0.0714773014,
-0.2129237652,
0.8245696425,
-0.0181070659,
-0.6302575469,
-0.0398928933,
-0.4766699076,
0.1444658339,
0.0711745098,
-0.1695735902,
-0.349653095,
-0.5045614243,
0.2355816662,
0.2927412093,
0.051335305,
-1.0274710655,
0.2567166686,
-0.5159368515,
0.6403589845,
0.8363513947,
-0.1167819127,
0.6725428104,
-0.3888136446,
0.5576500297,
0.2713741064,
0.1615290195,
-0.1742467433,
-0.387029171,
-0.8964047432,
0.0313495845,
0.5397951603,
0.4808718264,
-1.1047096252,
0.2076288611,
-0.6848817468,
-0.4846844971,
-0.4309314787,
0.0202524997,
0.3495713472,
0.4936672151,
0.4229183793,
-0.2949154377,
-0.2707722783,
-0.8603227139,
-0.2556994259,
-0.0882484168,
0.2291540056,
-0.0356868505,
0.3538518846,
-0.0339218751,
1.0445833206,
-0.2269346267,
-0.1925855577,
-0.6571704745,
-0.0095243175,
0.316845119,
0.5798634291,
0.7372514009,
-0.3366810083,
-0.7710971236,
0.4134170711,
-0.3499257863,
0.1944051534,
-0.2323008776,
-0.1187191606,
0.0032145865,
0.4665346444,
-0.5479368567,
0.5667002797,
0.372859627,
-0.4643415213,
0.4225417376,
-0.0799709558,
-0.0452526808,
-1.193169713,
0.0874636471,
-0.3185761273,
-0.3107741475,
-0.8676767349,
-0.1396666765,
0.2548299432,
-0.146272108,
-0.9586619735,
0.8506563306,
-0.6475708485,
-0.0222549755,
-0.2019465417,
-0.0555388965,
-0.1342153549,
0.5399202108,
-0.1510241479,
0.7866556644,
0.6932631135,
-0.3741570413,
0.2018394768,
0.1453031898,
-0.2163265646,
0.1846895963,
-0.7724397182,
0.3264846802,
-0.1071773544,
0.08526548,
-0.6477492452,
0.3180495799,
0.2564027607,
-0.4924509227,
0.1323200315,
-0.7213514447,
-0.3210173547,
-0.0392374359,
-0.3010972142,
0.3964729607,
0.7426268458,
-0.2262842059,
0.2595780492,
-0.0989801958,
0.2300798446,
-0.5275371671,
-0.7496442795,
0.4509182572,
0.0632538497,
-0.3589275479,
0.6067329645,
0.1634943038,
0.3045776784,
0.3971746266,
-0.0857875869,
-0.1067330241,
0.2180453539,
0.2248867601,
0.2375154346,
-0.4746856391,
0.083903566,
-0.0367415696,
-0.2953078747,
-0.347407341,
-0.633476615,
0.7881467342,
-0.0831769332,
-0.4486171901,
-0.3062579036,
0.2115724981,
0.6890725493,
-0.0877289474,
0.9821156859,
0.7695105672,
-0.3674980402,
-0.1575629562,
-0.4180984199,
-0.0972494408,
-0.3855689168,
0.5437697768,
-0.4374680519,
-1.190402627,
0.5482671261,
0.117140241,
0.2156232744,
0.3376361728,
0.5007907748,
0.4196382165,
0.860059917,
0.9149875045,
-0.3089657426,
0.893727541,
-0.515016675,
0.3466278911,
-0.9496785998,
0.1119343042,
-0.4206638932,
-0.5102033615,
-0.2134474367,
-0.3167401254,
0.1637080163,
0.2253875881,
-0.2694266737,
0.8950132728,
-0.2062710822,
0.7326771021,
0.5131360292,
0.0147904316,
0.0486050621,
0.0576514564,
-0.2732497752,
0.1454204917,
-1.0867735147,
-0.2454822958,
1.1292873621,
0.1677092612,
0.2383404225,
0.3860070705,
1.0213599205,
0.0987523049,
0.334706068,
-0.9410946369,
0.4803370535,
-0.1477299482,
-0.5267059803,
-0.4211918116,
-0.5268383026,
-0.9889138341,
0.2814900279,
-0.1007744074,
-0.8985741138,
0.2164375931,
0.0593997166,
-0.5378662348,
0.7237859964,
-0.6108406782,
0.7946161628,
0.0628867224,
-0.4593100548,
-0.0807605237,
-0.4034108222,
0.0770019069,
0.002607944,
-0.0581748933,
-0.1920624673,
0.096262224,
0.575882256,
-0.5225621462,
0.7622623444,
-0.3065558076,
0.2556232512,
-0.0662137568,
0.5322270989,
0.3580469787,
-0.2436017841,
-0.1952414513,
0.1617050767,
0.0459008142,
-0.7269980907,
-0.8427547812,
0.4951883554,
-0.7377502918,
-0.7154480815,
-0.2175778151,
-0.327139318,
-0.2194226086,
0.4631766975,
0.2668304741,
0.5267184973,
-0.186759457,
0.4131210744,
0.2173666954,
0.0924325362,
0.5729237199,
0.4568615854,
-0.1066827253,
-0.2539194822,
0.9364444613,
0.3416725397,
0.3503655791,
0.3778014481,
0.3686610162,
-0.0099854553,
-0.7297316194,
-0.8435335159,
0.0515826233,
-0.6589930058,
-0.3381695449,
-0.5300555229,
-0.4637615681,
-0.4964565039,
-0.4397462904,
-0.4424871802,
-0.7019190192,
-0.2695475817,
-0.0896745399,
0.3722145259,
0.6106994152,
0.0003399149,
0.5197800398,
-1.2529709339,
-0.1215079129,
0.207637623,
0.3012016416,
0.1703213453,
-0.9512915611,
-0.6325381994,
0.0648991987,
0.1478973627,
-0.948640883,
0.3893880546,
0.1657465547,
0.5021395683,
0.1138657108,
0.0075472207,
0.8049726486,
-0.5902544856,
0.8518340588,
0.568107307,
-1.2039971352,
0.3666730225,
-0.2005386204,
0.2213380784,
0.5100947022,
0.2595825791,
-1.0130749941,
-0.1648437381,
-0.5102502108,
-0.9265899062,
0.7061549425,
0.2233330607,
0.4899261892,
-0.2385712713,
0.5000576377,
-0.0836330652,
0.0667063817,
-0.5650647283,
-0.0235512536,
-0.233610943,
-0.0164943393,
-0.2011701018,
-0.1948976368,
0.1327900141,
-0.267051667,
0.5665460825,
-0.1299682111,
0.3503445387,
0.2200102657,
-0.6220180988,
-0.1222890094,
0.3717361689,
0.4109926522,
0.4878584445,
-0.1772533804,
0.3681503236,
0.0138441185,
-0.3139311075,
0.4936505556,
-0.3643498719,
-0.4866453409,
0.288487792,
0.3345572352,
1.0629477501,
0.3993853927,
-0.3875934482,
0.8845540285,
0.2753330469,
-0.3032475412,
0.0184322651,
0.1114841774,
-0.1590552032,
0.0934716761,
0.1043431908,
0.008424717,
0.0141824735,
-0.7478886247,
0.3054540455,
0.2933992445,
-0.7582361102,
-0.6894019842,
0.4050287008,
0.1603737324,
-0.5352815986,
0.6394178271,
-0.2660331428,
-0.8601039648,
0.5405439734,
0.8809562325,
1.19112885,
0.1407506317,
0.3071568906,
0.2044507414,
0.4020455778,
-0.1386253834,
-0.0054069255,
-0.1042551026,
-1.1146882772,
-0.3804162443,
-0.3016266823,
-0.3308870494,
-0.1815822273,
-0.6092319489,
0.2026570141,
-0.5042360425,
-0.3214638531,
-0.0914326832,
-0.328533113,
-0.8445081115,
-0.2967135906,
0.0270316694,
0.8314437866,
-0.8933026195,
1.110052824,
0.6607332826,
-0.4789002538,
-0.8326193094,
-0.1574830711,
-0.1928598285,
-0.8746871352,
0.7956546545,
0.0003410836,
-0.0615977123,
0.2928527594,
-0.1557075381,
-0.7699688077,
1.260253191,
0.4336050749,
-0.7382157445,
-0.1747585982,
0.2233345062,
0.3257021606,
-0.0434567407,
0.481298089,
0.3389645219,
0.2228613943,
0.191820547,
-0.9991016984,
0.098734498,
-0.2765266895,
0.2814724743,
0.4420351982,
-0.6619021297,
1.1514351368,
-0.050019443,
-0.2437229306,
-0.0976302549,
0.4357601702,
-0.2512023151,
-0.0974508822,
0.5014499426,
0.5726531148,
0.1855543554,
0.1263720989,
0.6900541186,
-0.5760666132,
0.5215147138,
0.9255055189,
-0.5358987451,
0.8801447153,
0.8104075789,
0.0902354196,
0.3103666306,
0.0361523032,
0.1580348164,
0.3500302434,
0.2951683402,
-0.2903660536,
-0.285748899,
-0.1000306904,
-0.2300877869,
0.3845283389,
-0.0284233596,
-0.17904149,
-0.655495286,
0.0064165429,
0.0229284335,
-0.3551881313,
-0.1152222678,
0.5987759829,
-0.1558975279,
-0.1680107117,
0.5808524489,
0.1851550639,
0.8213198185,
-0.5518547893,
-0.0857934281,
-0.39848122,
0.0347251482,
0.0882034078,
-0.5794372559,
0.4307978451,
-0.077959761,
0.0784951523,
-0.5086222887,
0.682516396,
-0.281602025,
-0.2460299432,
0.3540558219,
0.8786193132,
0.1266578585,
-0.1952261925,
-0.4648630321,
-0.1874372512,
0.0703494549,
-0.356297642,
0.61674577,
0.6645348668,
-0.0575412512,
0.4472476542,
0.8030596972,
0.4581472874,
0.2948089838,
0.2191056907,
0.8385288715,
-1.0411381721,
-0.529468298,
-0.8649538159,
0.2120735794,
0.1958781928,
-0.3960956633,
0.674647212,
0.5038347244,
0.8151056767,
-0.0972791463,
0.6579911709,
-0.1124827117,
0.0611081533,
-0.5215601921,
0.8289154172,
-0.4706047177,
0.0567372069,
-0.0296255201,
-0.9300189614,
-0.315374285,
0.3944026232,
-0.0984299034,
-0.2016754001,
0.5736979842,
0.747207284,
-0.061877735,
-0.3894848526,
0.9161677957,
-0.0965766087,
0.4875609279,
0.8376356363,
0.7570025325,
-0.6284058094,
0.5930812955,
-0.5810012221,
-0.0579564385,
-0.4208959937,
-0.835345149,
-0.6576808691,
-0.4669253826,
-0.2979030907,
-0.1782532185,
0.3287604451,
0.9735489488,
0.6788727641,
-0.6098049283,
-0.2562079728,
-0.2380457073,
0.0333156101,
-0.1287448853,
-0.2120509893,
0.1135673821,
-0.3450373709,
-0.4524564147,
0.2776805758,
0.511213541,
0.2841992676,
-0.0784624815,
0.108180441,
0.0171371941,
0.0332848914,
0.623937726,
0.268496871,
-0.6062353253,
-0.7810668945,
0.4082176089,
-0.1155699342,
0.1608815491,
1.1379112005,
-0.853025794,
0.3098060489,
0.553391993,
0.8713277578,
0.5439517498,
-0.4715464115,
0.5035911798,
-0.6326744556,
0.31852144,
0.4324926734,
0.3918250799,
-0.0926110893,
-0.1787493229,
0.1768929213,
0.4798391163,
-0.0806648135,
-0.8652127385,
0.2296503186,
-0.9035580158,
-0.2685771286,
1.120100379,
-0.1543990523,
-0.4378013015,
-0.2463645637,
0.0670894906,
0.3938862681,
-0.223712191,
0.5138719678,
0.6543759704,
0.179276377,
-0.2588970661,
-0.4330815375,
0.0919538364,
0.8193516731,
-0.3464899659,
0.1083145663,
0.1568544805,
0.6020843983,
0.1053232849,
0.7451319098,
-0.0480952635,
0.3983279765,
0.0508178174,
0.4008662701,
-0.4418154955,
-0.3939832449,
-0.5445473194,
0.0754215717,
0.1927876621,
-0.3980608881
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07875v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07875v1
|
Reproducing the Metric-Based Evaluation of a Set of Controllable Text Generation Techniques
| 2024-05-13T16:02:57 | 2024-05-13T16:02:57 |
Michela Lorandi, Anya Belz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Rerunning a metric-based evaluation should be more straightforward, and
results should be closer, than in a human-based evaluation, especially where
code and model checkpoints are made available by the original authors. As this
report of our efforts to rerun a metric-based evaluation of a set of
single-attribute and multiple-attribute controllable text generation (CTG)
techniques shows however, such reruns of evaluations do not always produce
results that are the same as the original results, and can reveal errors in the
reporting of the original work.
|
[
0.0017152892,
-0.5293285847,
0.4701488614,
0.3067706227,
-0.1768269241,
0.5338894129,
-0.3204066455,
-0.1795254648,
0.0683210194,
0.5685931444,
-0.8729549646,
-0.5645769835,
-0.5433690548,
0.2531772256,
-0.4393841922,
1.161433816,
-0.2846128047,
-0.0291280467,
-0.1277605444,
-0.3489027917,
-0.7000858188,
-0.6408405304,
-1.0863626003,
-0.55715096,
0.6247749329,
0.4819667041,
0.5873852372,
0.6798225641,
0.6502793431,
0.2188888639,
0.1783999056,
0.1997568011,
-0.3535238206,
-0.0974278748,
0.0233811717,
-0.5022007227,
-0.1563012749,
0.5574287772,
0.7996610403,
0.3625961542,
-0.1556119919,
0.1051922143,
0.2781692147,
0.530662477,
-0.7156097293,
-0.2961339653,
-0.2018473595,
0.2919129431,
0.1914292276,
-0.4818300605,
-0.7010208368,
-0.7685402036,
0.0015828141,
-0.626416266,
0.6582381725,
0.2304467559,
0.7394695878,
0.1881158054,
-0.3961738944,
-0.3011150658,
-0.7894240618,
1.1186352968,
-0.9484142065,
0.1222967356,
0.1391731352,
0.325122118,
-0.24734056,
-0.9356263876,
-0.2128476202,
-0.7795317769,
-0.3638927341,
0.2345409542,
-0.0282342806,
-0.1028638706,
0.3845970929,
0.2754339874,
-0.4049272835,
0.4203499258,
-0.4372476339,
-0.2826427817,
0.9021611214,
0.3874794841,
0.0677357689,
-0.2756180465,
-0.5065466762,
-0.2519802451,
-0.6592329144,
-0.1256688535,
0.1933591515,
0.0742654279,
-0.0176456161,
0.5052620769,
-0.1870831847,
0.429405421,
0.2986249626,
-0.3918905556,
0.3579070568,
-0.6912902594,
-0.182997331,
-0.1669182181,
0.7695606351,
0.6767137647,
0.1128012091,
-0.3761696815,
-0.2295786291,
-0.0372082107,
0.6477175951,
-0.5697860122,
-0.1306790113,
0.1526028663,
-0.7135919929,
-0.6068652272,
0.2266812325,
-0.7183089256,
-0.1189755648,
-0.5702008605,
0.4450982511,
-0.3952680528,
0.0208116211,
-0.2409918308,
-0.4345244765,
0.1662746966,
0.3915727437,
-0.1631213725,
0.2360466272,
0.677066505,
0.9723716378,
-0.4309313595,
-0.6350157857,
-0.3369379342,
0.0060414467,
-0.4783120751,
0.623234868,
-0.3662568927,
-0.8917533159,
-0.090755038,
0.1461390257,
-0.0554039404,
-0.5377016664,
0.4273228943,
-0.1132772192,
0.4304354489,
-0.3159024417,
-0.554799974,
0.0816655159,
0.0996858552,
-0.7317490578,
0.9323851466,
0.0599394329,
-0.802756846,
0.9721694589,
-0.4175881743,
-0.34995538,
-0.382062614,
-0.157870397,
-0.7105544806,
0.4788093865,
-0.1052560434,
0.1541039348,
-0.2485660166,
0.0038402504,
0.1023739725,
-0.410133481,
0.1028693095,
-0.3138881624,
0.6076464653,
0.27564013,
-0.5818042755,
0.1678195745,
-0.9047204852,
0.5824019909,
-0.0503663793,
-0.7003035545,
-0.0557956919,
0.1577905715,
-0.0338638648,
-0.0484577306,
0.2952428758,
-0.6714029312,
0.196787715,
0.2968725264,
-0.001398793,
0.6823927164,
0.0797080472,
0.365101099,
-0.9543991685,
0.8373262882,
-0.1055385545,
-0.1309069544,
-0.225806281,
-0.2212073654,
-0.6534067988,
-0.1704234481,
0.1694118083,
0.5385180712,
-0.6781504154,
0.1185480505,
0.0475024246,
-0.9830531478,
-0.1844797432,
0.0146742528,
0.9836760163,
0.3316581547,
-0.1873443872,
-0.4854712486,
-0.4534341991,
-1.0725090504,
-0.5940193534,
-0.0254879389,
-0.0102844117,
0.2272437364,
0.5614260435,
0.1580137461,
0.8449702859,
-0.6273588538,
0.1541316807,
-0.353180021,
0.8073170781,
-0.1033440307,
0.8821198344,
0.5931261778,
-0.4437633157,
-0.4239521027,
0.0142276585,
-0.5671935081,
-0.5122351646,
-0.4845784605,
-0.032152608,
0.4658240974,
0.5986492038,
0.0577491261,
0.7832468748,
0.4170186818,
-0.2973624468,
1.291577816,
-0.4744073451,
0.9042452574,
-0.9716283679,
0.2606525123,
0.0560945459,
-0.4239187837,
-0.2965462506,
0.1850932389,
-0.1634537131,
-0.1757705659,
-0.4350038767,
0.2488632202,
-0.471537441,
-0.1147768125,
-0.5262432098,
0.3206934035,
0.1159644872,
0.4018804133,
-0.0868545398,
0.8353203535,
0.1787134856,
-0.7430229187,
0.43943578,
-0.117276527,
-0.392201364,
0.916785419,
-0.7783893943,
0.2837542892,
-0.1923338473,
0.2726340592,
-0.8654167056,
-0.1133774519,
0.0056301225,
-0.570377171,
0.2607733607,
0.2487316877,
-0.5088522434,
-0.2919097245,
-0.3647230864,
0.2757575214,
0.5876188278,
-0.6014190912,
0.0505972952,
-0.2082308233,
0.1817962974,
-0.4066363275,
-0.7686844468,
-0.1446266472,
-0.4283305705,
-0.4424467981,
0.1117897108,
0.1804906279,
-0.1333012283,
-0.1326201856,
-0.0792266205,
-0.0425775573,
0.1450189054,
0.1180720553,
-0.1188549921,
0.0080101481,
0.2969967127,
-0.1996976435,
-0.298409164,
-0.0105123064,
0.009632824,
0.299167186,
0.2462219447,
-0.5155871511,
-0.8360368609,
0.731761694,
0.302141428,
-0.2462847084,
0.5361137986,
0.3548187912,
-0.3903207183,
-0.2585713267,
-0.3530739248,
-0.080187194,
-0.4549185336,
0.5301430821,
-0.1622393131,
-0.8070002794,
0.4428659976,
-0.057965152,
0.5877987742,
0.5132097006,
0.4327557683,
-0.2159259915,
0.9445105791,
0.9347481728,
0.2849384546,
0.5027050376,
-0.0232845526,
-0.0993343219,
-0.7131720781,
-0.2179560363,
-0.9870560169,
-0.5469322801,
-0.7276959419,
-0.1120432243,
0.19677715,
0.0972536281,
-0.328158915,
0.4030392766,
-0.6869954467,
0.28590101,
0.8954873681,
0.2136541903,
0.5270755291,
0.0021425106,
0.0111873625,
-0.2919604778,
-0.851189971,
-0.7626260519,
1.125451088,
0.020986028,
0.9127743244,
-0.1550959796,
0.9744522572,
0.5371249318,
0.9077822566,
-0.521684885,
0.2506158054,
-0.3255450726,
-0.568287015,
-0.0660468414,
-0.6083242893,
-0.9173400402,
-0.0504405499,
0.0328426845,
-1.0035821199,
-0.1822319925,
0.4478905499,
-0.2201128304,
0.3677479923,
-0.8770365119,
0.953404963,
-0.152594313,
0.0305955857,
-0.3601019681,
-0.1935241371,
0.4322324991,
-0.3075370789,
-0.1232770011,
0.2869588733,
0.0405563898,
1.3059574366,
-0.748003006,
0.7551558614,
-0.1063401699,
-0.0273956656,
0.6519557238,
0.1185085699,
0.2608834207,
-0.3087007403,
0.1994158924,
-0.293261379,
0.149742499,
-0.349303633,
-0.771700263,
0.8025771379,
-0.5150933266,
-0.817192018,
-0.3328491747,
-0.3391796052,
0.1126658022,
0.0859621242,
0.62718153,
0.6377294064,
-0.2756233513,
0.3051300645,
0.0855559036,
-0.5620633364,
0.4031345546,
0.1487188935,
-0.4312801957,
-0.4469847083,
0.4736962914,
0.1613603085,
0.6734781861,
-0.01055321,
0.1457047909,
0.0112181818,
-0.1567012072,
-0.20732297,
0.137925297,
-0.4625467956,
-0.1334069073,
-0.1469606459,
-0.0278469138,
-0.1526218504,
-0.6596399546,
-0.4423058331,
-0.4892450869,
-0.1743770689,
-0.0381605923,
0.335760206,
0.9309859276,
-0.3501611948,
0.975025177,
-0.6718395948,
0.0691837445,
-0.0718028322,
0.5114635825,
0.0865261182,
-0.3809323013,
-0.5399557948,
0.3351384997,
-0.6029058099,
-0.9236708879,
0.1133912653,
0.0546842329,
0.391141206,
-0.0106727798,
-0.2795101702,
0.6467416286,
-0.3890587091,
0.9272014499,
0.4682620466,
-0.9469903708,
0.6967340112,
-0.0923911035,
0.3988391161,
0.6023148894,
0.0324781761,
-0.6917296648,
-0.609967649,
-0.7897916436,
-0.5214796066,
0.737457633,
0.2712558806,
-0.2771716416,
0.0937388688,
0.5162017941,
0.1713971496,
0.1850493848,
-0.5053606033,
-0.2719842792,
-0.2253670096,
0.1398686469,
-0.193210423,
-0.1580080986,
-0.054598067,
0.3089896739,
0.5736353397,
-0.0203811955,
0.3292452693,
0.5293237567,
0.2101679295,
-0.014761229,
0.3403794467,
0.4847908318,
0.9348863363,
-0.1439709067,
-0.175202623,
0.0791363046,
-0.4496213794,
0.3902863562,
-0.4281613529,
-0.2125665694,
0.2986988127,
0.4750150442,
0.4957131147,
0.1222709939,
-0.5561557412,
0.3122733235,
0.1008527726,
-0.3304002583,
-0.4516972303,
0.0445790477,
-0.2639500797,
0.030498229,
0.2154661715,
-0.1247466356,
-0.1410348266,
-0.5069038272,
0.6781682968,
0.2099635005,
-0.3840881884,
-0.0656590462,
0.8232962489,
0.1055215225,
-0.5793492198,
0.6284877658,
-0.1607599258,
-0.4721306562,
1.1338160038,
0.720629096,
1.1638368368,
-0.132095024,
0.3110265136,
0.7389190793,
0.4563302994,
0.0001094169,
0.3474477232,
0.2765139639,
-0.4772198796,
-0.66326195,
-0.1606699079,
-0.3863573372,
-0.2763187289,
-0.947149694,
0.0727627277,
-0.919583559,
-0.5041450858,
-0.0087462338,
0.0040739961,
-0.5883560777,
0.7032711506,
-0.4875479341,
1.1465752125,
-0.7363640666,
0.3179579079,
0.6182287931,
-0.3400638103,
-0.8540098071,
-0.1082133129,
0.0896546915,
-0.3681602478,
0.7062690258,
0.1284011006,
-0.2262318879,
-0.3583764434,
-0.8004645705,
-0.6100773811,
1.4090673923,
-0.1734203547,
-0.3563960791,
0.1044341773,
-0.1222238764,
0.5735826492,
-0.4233349562,
-0.0261059441,
0.640943408,
0.5462992191,
-0.0859431997,
-1.2833467722,
0.1019153297,
0.0591407754,
-0.0102251312,
0.2302039862,
-0.9114274979,
0.5198069215,
-0.2058288306,
-0.4757287502,
0.4101741016,
0.7489533424,
0.5341082811,
0.3910485208,
0.3961935937,
0.7237784863,
0.5213131905,
-0.4486034811,
1.3653953075,
0.0127569707,
0.5946652889,
1.3650376797,
0.0381572023,
0.4464099705,
0.3952153623,
-0.1860624254,
0.3463539481,
0.4783198535,
-0.1135782003,
0.3220840991,
0.4215483963,
-0.0895040333,
-0.0334647223,
-0.0330478474,
-0.1497403532,
0.4670135081,
-0.1915988624,
-0.550383985,
-0.3336583674,
-0.4765382409,
0.3519849777,
0.1227459088,
-0.2658955157,
0.5908688307,
0.0017019806,
-0.8699093461,
0.4122909606,
0.3173196316,
0.6977498531,
-0.4936462343,
0.0101459734,
-0.1967475116,
0.0111845816,
-0.3591045141,
-0.6305990219,
0.764264226,
0.2344417721,
-0.1912989318,
-0.266825825,
0.4895784855,
-0.0353651978,
-0.576641798,
-0.2204046547,
0.4573250413,
0.1973145306,
0.3429777324,
-0.291564554,
-0.3529900014,
0.4935628176,
-0.3242111802,
-0.1824611276,
0.2540031672,
-0.0877179429,
0.7495902777,
0.3878736198,
-0.1428177655,
0.3559057415,
-0.0823892504,
0.4277654588,
-1.0053855181,
-0.3687502444,
-0.7348114252,
0.5756312013,
-0.1671924889,
-0.6533684731,
0.903717041,
0.719989121,
0.7920132875,
-0.0740842074,
1.1042249203,
-0.2688426673,
0.6271164417,
-0.5986148119,
0.7449532151,
-0.6568087935,
-0.102026917,
-0.3779093921,
-0.8228037357,
-0.1336563081,
0.4130906165,
0.0587851219,
0.4489870369,
1.0339628458,
0.7075811028,
0.1841873378,
-0.110589698,
0.2790174782,
0.039080359,
0.5047706366,
0.6090878844,
0.789487958,
-0.2200545967,
0.2817145884,
-0.2483610064,
-0.5153064728,
0.1907851398,
-1.0798985958,
-0.4713159204,
-0.4736274183,
-0.6309940815,
-0.6220439076,
-0.06112298,
0.5611568689,
0.3902663589,
-0.5666597486,
-0.0686976537,
0.0961004049,
0.0702894256,
-0.3574072123,
-0.2327881008,
0.4462757707,
-0.2779780626,
-0.9161069989,
-0.1499929577,
-0.025703663,
-0.0502974279,
-0.3965479732,
0.0812134743,
0.0375740044,
-0.0760409981,
0.2323132902,
0.3222338557,
-0.4926995635,
-0.702031076,
-0.3528169394,
-0.1465050578,
0.0976094306,
1.2199374437,
-0.8389427066,
0.1746787876,
0.4161678851,
0.4361794889,
0.0942778662,
0.1923888028,
1.0373939276,
-0.8434575796,
-0.0561637022,
-0.0969400629,
0.3168025911,
0.2423019409,
-0.2129508853,
0.4576891959,
0.1797922701,
-0.8092669845,
-0.3168573976,
0.4953828156,
-0.8177368045,
-0.0032031343,
1.1697613001,
-0.4591079652,
-0.1701155901,
0.2330096811,
-0.5932476521,
0.3388186991,
-0.1518200338,
0.7496074438,
0.7942049503,
-0.146026805,
-0.0635932013,
-0.2525457442,
0.3814680278,
0.4285963774,
-0.8361600637,
-0.0170835257,
0.7564607859,
0.5765615702,
0.2165548503,
0.6317647099,
-0.2675127387,
0.4603195786,
0.2709443867,
0.1182356626,
0.0364666693,
-0.2301600426,
-0.1906712353,
-0.0579057336,
0.0739356726,
-0.3530489802
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07863v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07863v2
|
RLHF Workflow: From Reward Modeling to Online RLHF
| 2024-05-13T15:50:39 | 2024-06-12T04:40:53 |
Hanze Dong, Wei Xiong, Bo Pang, Haoxiang Wang, Han Zhao, Yingbo Zhou, Nan Jiang, Doyen Sahoo, Caiming Xiong, Tong Zhang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
We present the workflow of Online Iterative Reinforcement Learning from Human
Feedback (RLHF) in this technical report, which is widely reported to
outperform its offline counterpart by a large margin in the recent large
language model (LLM) literature. However, existing open-source RLHF projects
are still largely confined to the offline learning setting. In this technical
report, we aim to fill in this gap and provide a detailed recipe that is easy
to reproduce for online iterative RLHF. In particular, since online human
feedback is usually infeasible for open-source communities with limited
resources, we start by constructing preference models using a diverse set of
open-source datasets and use the constructed proxy preference model to
approximate human feedback. Then, we discuss the theoretical insights and
algorithmic principles behind online iterative RLHF, followed by a detailed
practical implementation. Our trained LLM, LLaMA-3-8B-SFR-Iterative-DPO-R,
achieves impressive performance on LLM chatbot benchmarks, including
AlpacaEval-2, Arena-Hard, and MT-Bench, as well as other academic benchmarks
such as HumanEval and TruthfulQA. We have shown that supervised fine-tuning
(SFT) and iterative RLHF can obtain state-of-the-art performance with fully
open-source datasets. Further, we have made our models, curated datasets, and
comprehensive step-by-step code guidebooks publicly available. Please refer to
https://github.com/RLHFlow/RLHF-Reward-Modeling and
https://github.com/RLHFlow/Online-RLHF for more detailed information.
|
[
-0.149858132,
-0.6594927311,
0.4629096091,
0.1091521233,
0.0253457315,
0.2748884857,
-0.4076218009,
-0.6195596457,
0.2427143008,
0.5907742381,
-0.8361982107,
-0.2844795883,
-0.2688907981,
-0.070922859,
-0.0441498682,
1.0145635605,
-0.3680502176,
0.1375329047,
-0.2580370903,
-0.0884735361,
-0.2073078901,
-0.6425542235,
-0.5910585523,
-0.757874012,
0.6705593467,
0.6753659248,
0.4944104254,
0.8638806343,
0.4644133747,
0.254773885,
0.0576739237,
0.0515284389,
-0.8999702334,
0.0752446279,
-0.0476706885,
-0.1367752701,
-0.1894966662,
-0.1091735363,
0.3686898947,
0.3730039299,
-0.9018441439,
0.2596547008,
-0.1045521051,
1.0086301565,
-0.5178220868,
0.5087587833,
-0.3523598015,
0.2231429666,
-0.0655253306,
-0.2070235163,
-0.4558933079,
-0.5684341192,
0.0799205378,
-0.7587898374,
0.0032103767,
0.1661638618,
0.7188527584,
0.3464674652,
-0.0206712503,
-0.3837459087,
-0.8569591641,
0.6183470488,
-0.7594535351,
0.3973909914,
0.6043430567,
0.5706863403,
-0.1635375023,
-0.8925956488,
-0.2904381156,
-0.6668741703,
0.1142852306,
0.1561650187,
0.2316838801,
0.2051842362,
0.1119753271,
0.5173486471,
-0.3902353346,
0.1658962667,
-0.4695759416,
0.0124143753,
0.5887738466,
0.2796334922,
-0.2842280269,
0.1206818596,
-0.2660064399,
-0.3949711323,
-0.8209769726,
0.3626720011,
0.3859589398,
0.3911889195,
-0.3204450011,
0.5459279418,
-0.3392699659,
0.6437038779,
0.0784377381,
-0.3194050491,
0.1035183296,
-0.1277067512,
0.1058142781,
-0.0223719571,
0.5677720308,
0.1932681352,
0.1714156717,
-0.1207540259,
-0.3735456765,
-0.2619247735,
0.3977545798,
-0.8288522959,
-0.19837901,
0.3015140295,
-0.6464645267,
-0.434635669,
0.0251281187,
-0.6236084104,
-0.5953255892,
-0.238768965,
0.383900702,
0.1296400726,
-0.3935400844,
-0.117572315,
-0.063968271,
-0.0580803007,
0.3047745824,
-0.7786278129,
0.3783563972,
0.6922289729,
0.7136553526,
-0.4277254343,
-0.4508860111,
-0.9508963823,
-0.2376810759,
-0.1242800429,
0.6402888894,
-0.4347640574,
-0.2481582314,
0.3946943581,
-0.0954711363,
0.0983189642,
-0.6786159277,
0.4452467263,
-0.7480911016,
0.2697304785,
-0.0524646156,
-0.8721814156,
-0.1114870384,
0.3485476971,
-0.7739332318,
1.0520857573,
0.189526394,
-0.7315758467,
-0.0642677024,
-1.046092391,
-0.1659786999,
-0.0869295597,
0.1481463015,
-0.4817541838,
-0.1334423274,
-0.053227216,
0.2974543571,
-0.2995541394,
0.330370307,
-0.6216103435,
-0.4449697137,
0.3167871535,
-0.0202920251,
0.5346226096,
0.2304418087,
-0.4256282449,
0.7459483147,
-0.702685833,
0.0360020064,
0.3434614539,
-0.6345673203,
0.240734458,
0.1499255896,
0.2912215889,
0.2017160952,
-0.071215719,
-0.6481400728,
0.0645470619,
-0.4183147848,
0.8147793412,
0.7475594282,
-0.0163969789,
0.4115641415,
-0.5092794895,
0.5334228873,
-0.427803576,
0.4443225861,
-0.0315807164,
-0.4812593162,
-0.5455985069,
-0.2383806258,
0.2987830639,
0.5730379224,
-0.7130680084,
0.2172006071,
0.070537664,
-0.4399949014,
-0.7165726423,
0.2240630537,
0.3957046866,
0.5356126428,
0.2941130698,
-0.2762451172,
-0.4883367121,
-0.5220771432,
-0.0423441194,
-0.2768223584,
0.0794124976,
0.4013125896,
0.4557136595,
-0.2336178124,
0.7556504011,
-0.4524489939,
-0.5058226585,
-0.2911403775,
0.2535590231,
0.1375916451,
0.176079616,
-0.0240866505,
-0.4571420252,
-0.4476418793,
-0.1994710118,
-0.5638166666,
0.1238678098,
0.2153627425,
0.1067535952,
0.3658705652,
0.3233243525,
-0.3406432569,
0.4362328649,
0.5499809384,
-0.1536136419,
0.1251229495,
-0.4452629983,
0.1133986935,
-0.6979600191,
0.071329169,
-0.1130871251,
-0.5554233789,
-0.439161092,
0.4582100511,
0.0686760321,
-0.0515576154,
-0.7268939018,
0.6950570345,
-0.2576223612,
-0.2305650115,
-0.4326142967,
0.1521337628,
-0.4429381788,
0.9665783048,
0.263204217,
0.4446330369,
0.2256168425,
-0.6400518417,
0.7036832571,
0.0595844388,
-0.2833233178,
0.1369567066,
-0.7864317298,
0.2102356106,
-0.0155665539,
0.4947862923,
-0.661508739,
-0.3913632631,
0.5759139061,
-0.2291735113,
0.0906812549,
0.0024818184,
-0.4799035788,
-0.3177246153,
-0.4584144354,
0.2250002325,
0.5213978291,
-0.8042926788,
0.4912793338,
0.5810707211,
0.0781803653,
-0.4016475379,
-0.2837392986,
-0.1234232262,
-0.1326529831,
-0.364097625,
0.4563517869,
-0.3689667881,
-0.301933676,
-0.0000374237,
0.4126801193,
-0.2179502249,
0.1732153147,
0.5321847796,
0.2817271948,
0.2401086241,
0.0091792522,
-0.6159832478,
-0.1804594249,
-0.012530962,
-0.2551005483,
0.3270880282,
-0.2203266621,
-0.5109687448,
-0.4941311777,
0.2153937519,
0.2213210911,
0.032055784,
0.5962988734,
0.6901929379,
-0.3508068621,
-0.2801797688,
-0.3266187906,
-0.6222394705,
-0.3971959949,
0.1613931656,
0.120676294,
-1.1994202137,
0.3877315223,
0.1218937188,
0.4709471762,
0.1305776685,
0.8719648123,
-0.0954911262,
0.9285992384,
0.814653039,
0.1234102994,
0.7226432562,
-0.0012041511,
-0.1011912897,
-0.198281765,
-0.3108968735,
-0.3771206439,
-0.0532114282,
-0.6294251084,
-0.5055222511,
0.3383148015,
0.0836467817,
-0.3253216445,
0.0777108967,
-0.3448846042,
0.4399997294,
0.6148088574,
0.3234731853,
0.401376754,
0.0041287374,
-0.1259938329,
0.0159864798,
-0.8068200946,
-0.109519124,
1.0002954006,
0.7569208741,
0.9167909622,
0.0122878458,
0.7357785106,
0.6124761105,
0.5956575274,
-0.9112257957,
0.1879337579,
0.3753651381,
-0.4773214459,
-0.4485056996,
-0.4510381818,
-0.70932585,
-0.1032383963,
-0.1884483993,
-0.5017701983,
-0.4278536141,
0.5582737327,
-0.3615581393,
0.3525010943,
-0.4258467555,
0.779686451,
-0.203572467,
-0.6290000677,
-0.582241118,
-0.8112287521,
0.4584674835,
0.1312505901,
0.3675559759,
0.0913152993,
0.2863666415,
0.7941397429,
-0.7342404723,
0.9757090807,
-0.3118587434,
-0.2610908151,
0.3853259385,
-0.0380013697,
0.8749153018,
-0.0023990192,
-0.0207876023,
0.056679707,
-0.0205849148,
-0.2404696345,
-0.3164966404,
0.6383162141,
-0.9541088343,
-0.3098939359,
-0.4176267087,
-0.2767395675,
-0.1854481101,
-0.12458352,
0.0409437642,
0.3466708958,
-0.139995873,
0.0614940189,
0.7101922631,
-0.2548083663,
0.5630879998,
0.4597826302,
-0.6617160439,
-0.704908371,
0.9869945049,
-0.27652964,
0.2427037358,
0.699051857,
0.4147869051,
-0.6374847889,
-0.0852190033,
-0.7261384726,
0.2468222529,
-0.9823821187,
0.0357251279,
-0.3220222294,
-0.16040802,
-0.1529158205,
0.1389626712,
-0.682366848,
-0.5021505952,
-0.3188941181,
0.0166686997,
0.6138815284,
1.3373967409,
-0.2330309749,
0.0881489813,
-0.8961137533,
0.2058075219,
0.3348177373,
0.7186695933,
0.3047623336,
-0.6313505173,
-0.4693362713,
0.0399353355,
-0.1508136392,
-0.6973457932,
0.3366767466,
0.0812020227,
0.6417528987,
0.2105245143,
0.2190991044,
0.4760502875,
-0.2639120519,
0.6323247552,
0.210642308,
-0.6773014665,
0.191860646,
-0.2616842985,
-0.0007546598,
0.5020775795,
0.3778606355,
-0.5515995622,
0.0376406051,
-0.4087204635,
-0.7028823495,
0.8878700137,
-0.02523854,
-0.3562397063,
0.3927138746,
0.359977752,
0.2889650762,
0.2531943917,
-0.9598564506,
-0.3891097903,
-0.4291166365,
-0.0786088035,
0.0108655673,
0.0239414871,
-0.3664011955,
-0.1544604301,
0.8366468549,
-0.2004359663,
0.4239373207,
-0.0610933714,
-0.1371354461,
-0.5298206806,
0.1617507339,
0.7709134221,
0.8215705752,
-0.4285420179,
-0.1426977664,
-0.0853281394,
-0.0742499456,
0.0510486402,
0.0443328395,
0.0254019052,
-0.3444847763,
0.2790459096,
1.0074152946,
0.2990048826,
-1.0246100426,
0.4557758272,
-0.3785914183,
-0.4475097656,
-0.515960753,
-0.0224732943,
0.3051222563,
0.3798722923,
0.2765311897,
-0.2687499821,
-0.2127652615,
-0.4933718145,
0.1591042429,
0.1118031293,
-0.6894841194,
-0.0965688154,
0.5532951355,
0.335447222,
-0.5921250582,
0.6291872859,
-0.360085696,
-0.5421387553,
0.3741589189,
0.4016886353,
0.884157002,
0.3111975491,
0.5216299891,
0.5249687433,
-0.1569610685,
-0.468901813,
0.2314306051,
-0.3998608887,
-0.3825434148,
-0.4125816524,
-0.5281322002,
-0.9577869177,
0.035031464,
-0.5418515801,
0.0372646116,
-0.6028651595,
0.1192553788,
-0.3784101605,
-0.2585611343,
-0.520376265,
-0.1702931523,
0.0662472025,
0.7325266004,
-0.4718421698,
0.8156123161,
0.7431421876,
-0.4678528309,
-0.9181055427,
-0.1323528141,
0.1134486422,
-0.979724884,
0.6363133788,
-0.0448834822,
-0.0377276465,
0.1724761277,
-0.517116189,
-0.9017219543,
1.1167597771,
0.0955017582,
-0.5652703047,
0.0048153941,
0.0350747816,
0.5492181182,
-0.4036446214,
0.5934932828,
0.2409802973,
0.4037439525,
0.335532546,
-1.0787471533,
-0.0246477593,
-0.0794338658,
-0.0519836731,
-0.0180933233,
-0.5765541792,
0.6114028692,
-0.5067985058,
-0.065585047,
0.0090540601,
0.4985715449,
0.52286309,
0.1397282779,
0.5296525955,
0.6253626943,
0.5261859298,
0.1135874689,
0.9339631796,
-0.4006585777,
0.5032541752,
1.1032601595,
-0.4275274873,
1.2092238665,
0.450201869,
-0.1195010319,
0.5246527195,
1.0451409817,
0.2558310628,
0.7732642889,
0.6062122583,
-0.0516149029,
-0.28728652,
-0.2924843431,
-0.257516861,
0.1743600219,
-0.1235192791,
-0.0409605242,
-0.3348013759,
0.1450912207,
-0.237198323,
0.1445989609,
-0.3787438571,
1.0190565586,
0.0449220017,
-1.147799015,
0.6181543469,
0.3646776378,
0.6734991074,
-0.6395449042,
-0.3773466349,
-0.1476125866,
0.4801830649,
-0.1884949356,
-0.7613677382,
0.1631084383,
-0.0123310061,
-0.0649115443,
-0.5907484293,
0.7299697995,
-0.3789044917,
-0.0593781248,
0.5656771064,
0.4814681113,
0.0087106824,
0.0846564844,
-0.8403856158,
0.0453809239,
0.038001705,
-0.3170204759,
0.5468395352,
-0.1765706986,
-0.0815017298,
0.8758994341,
0.7027307153,
0.0792757571,
-0.0399400704,
0.3001313508,
0.6763563156,
-0.7250995636,
-0.7181433439,
-0.6447451711,
0.4204095304,
0.1935763657,
-0.2692092955,
0.2718847394,
0.1247624457,
1.0843918324,
-0.1882209629,
0.5904017091,
0.0592369027,
0.7971717119,
-0.4628814161,
0.5058953762,
-0.5087545514,
0.1262845695,
0.0097300997,
-0.5807473063,
-0.0310070515,
0.5404046774,
0.2127029449,
0.0623255745,
0.6273863912,
0.9222961068,
0.2566130459,
0.3353758752,
0.1724100709,
-0.0529314354,
0.2953591943,
0.4862689674,
1.1073194742,
-0.105398871,
0.6326673627,
-0.5805696249,
-0.2443735451,
-0.4343557954,
-1.3048003912,
-0.9694309831,
-0.6312074661,
-0.2440260053,
-0.4417238235,
0.0677336007,
1.6705816984,
0.7986723185,
-0.8618155718,
-0.6110592484,
-0.3478202522,
0.2945167422,
-0.4565547109,
-0.2284145951,
-0.0006192316,
-0.0854914337,
-0.3463261127,
0.4276019633,
0.1521900147,
-0.1735287905,
-0.6896865964,
-0.7327080369,
-0.2069842219,
-0.2809944451,
0.5117887855,
0.6756870151,
-0.8331987858,
-0.0197753012,
0.0413586348,
-0.1508337408,
0.0918765068,
1.0457782745,
-0.6695588231,
0.2828302085,
0.5729089975,
0.9375931025,
0.7973310947,
-0.1133688837,
0.4970616698,
-0.544098556,
-0.2964658439,
0.0700998455,
0.1586127728,
0.3886051774,
-0.2120527327,
0.6294301748,
0.4218959808,
-0.7340430021,
-0.7933835983,
0.0703991577,
-0.7535488009,
-0.2428347021,
1.1703943014,
-0.2137441039,
-0.1188845187,
-0.1457945108,
-0.1236003861,
0.3887844384,
-0.7545640469,
1.1206643581,
0.533295095,
-0.3363310099,
-0.3058900535,
-0.5884622335,
0.7026947737,
0.0881115645,
-1.0415328741,
0.3087777197,
0.4189312756,
0.2205902487,
-0.1156882197,
0.8888148665,
0.1717155278,
0.2636720836,
-0.2738607526,
0.1456220448,
-0.5065507889,
-0.2842498422,
-0.4496257901,
0.3787088692,
0.3848273158,
0.0752800554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07840v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07840v1
|
Open-vocabulary Auditory Neural Decoding Using fMRI-prompted LLM
| 2024-05-13T15:25:11 | 2024-05-13T15:25:11 |
Xiaoyu Chen, Changde Du, Che Liu, Yizhe Wang, Huiguang He
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL
|
Decoding language information from brain signals represents a vital research
area within brain-computer interfaces, particularly in the context of
deciphering the semantic information from the fMRI signal. However, many
existing efforts concentrate on decoding small vocabulary sets, leaving space
for the exploration of open vocabulary continuous text decoding. In this paper,
we introduce a novel method, the \textbf{Brain Prompt GPT (BP-GPT)}. By using
the brain representation that is extracted from the fMRI as a prompt, our
method can utilize GPT-2 to decode fMRI signals into stimulus text. Further, we
introduce a text-to-text baseline and align the fMRI prompt to the text prompt.
By introducing the text-to-text baseline, our BP-GPT can extract a more robust
brain prompt and promote the decoding of pre-trained LLM. We evaluate our
BP-GPT on the open-source auditory semantic decoding dataset and achieve a
significant improvement up to $4.61\%$ on METEOR and $2.43\%$ on BERTScore
across all the subjects compared to the state-of-the-art method. The
experimental results demonstrate that using brain representation as a prompt to
further drive LLM for auditory neural decoding is feasible and effective.
|
[
-0.2518201768,
-0.9004356861,
0.749037683,
0.4650737643,
-0.4541540146,
-0.3823325932,
-0.5481435061,
-0.2143613696,
0.1358715743,
-0.0290674902,
-0.9147986174,
-0.7282858491,
-0.4361200333,
0.3102624714,
-0.0981773958,
0.7947605252,
0.0230706055,
0.343857199,
-0.2063264698,
0.1136839911,
-0.9167410135,
-0.4307422638,
-0.9447996616,
-0.392003268,
0.7523707747,
-0.0286884978,
0.312217623,
0.4005700648,
0.269608289,
0.0634189546,
-0.5513876677,
0.0122582316,
-0.1572472453,
-0.0499909669,
-0.0233129431,
-0.214912951,
-0.4464415908,
-0.2615692019,
0.4904539287,
0.7204104066,
-0.1016367525,
0.0210999455,
0.2485289872,
0.49757424,
-0.5008393526,
0.3861383796,
-0.5228788853,
0.1109144911,
-0.0472012796,
-0.6872937679,
-0.572776854,
-0.2077487856,
0.1292342395,
-0.6756868362,
-0.2433329821,
-0.036559172,
0.6935383677,
0.3813880384,
-0.0560251027,
-0.3828574419,
-0.4018202722,
0.5230382085,
-0.4045971036,
0.5551438928,
0.6638964415,
0.1700368524,
-0.2218313813,
-0.657753706,
-0.6189928055,
-0.2783047855,
0.0251918528,
0.3958082199,
-0.2104505599,
0.1273060888,
0.1093759835,
0.1725740731,
-0.6238677502,
0.071463652,
-0.1355911642,
-0.3632734716,
-0.1096879244,
0.0334058143,
0.5195643306,
-0.0043342938,
-0.4165882766,
-0.2004521042,
-0.7042682767,
-0.0788749605,
0.0821800604,
0.2861056328,
-0.1369972974,
0.624042809,
0.064500697,
0.6176829338,
-0.0085606445,
0.0334553234,
0.3794240057,
-0.3082936108,
0.1007129252,
0.3188017607,
0.661338985,
0.4502177835,
0.2869953513,
-0.328853339,
-0.3449248672,
0.0667282939,
-0.1025904864,
-0.5804123282,
-0.0228327829,
0.3695352077,
-0.6761332154,
0.1708490551,
-0.2149489671,
-0.4478654563,
-0.1931238472,
-0.3360323012,
0.5881274939,
-0.7817216516,
-0.3800454736,
0.3907056749,
-0.2674325407,
0.3959530592,
0.3092118204,
-1.059286356,
0.0262794998,
0.5162324309,
1.0796295404,
-0.0566737168,
-0.0529076271,
-0.589513123,
0.1426641196,
-0.1611078978,
0.9009016752,
-0.1199902371,
-0.4771630466,
-0.1038143784,
-0.4528388977,
-0.0581834391,
-0.4656480849,
0.6709215045,
-0.5532733202,
0.3647708297,
-0.4631040394,
-0.4017214775,
0.0234728009,
0.1642723233,
-0.4181365371,
0.742115438,
0.067246981,
-0.8789050579,
0.1902906448,
-0.9861283898,
-0.2504701614,
0.1645152718,
-0.5165942907,
0.2629290521,
0.1925908327,
0.7072372437,
0.2770445645,
-0.1864215881,
0.1344651729,
-0.1214956418,
-0.5434455872,
0.3686010242,
-0.6678176522,
0.8501423001,
0.307706356,
-0.1997023821,
0.0533277988,
-0.635607183,
0.1252345741,
0.1370589137,
-0.5676541924,
-0.3986029625,
-0.0595015213,
0.1517152041,
0.0111784777,
0.3222548068,
-0.5747961402,
-0.0758459643,
-0.4640260339,
0.2327198833,
0.6415163279,
0.0448402017,
0.1634375155,
-0.2283719331,
0.0801853836,
0.0785468891,
-0.3068713546,
-0.43143332,
-0.6228361726,
-0.2039488405,
-0.685287416,
0.374946475,
0.9272470474,
-0.7323013544,
0.6965615749,
-0.4678334594,
0.23899059,
-0.8400171399,
-0.3420009017,
0.0696850419,
0.9594504237,
0.6947267056,
-0.1054632366,
-0.4615335166,
-0.684253037,
-0.0759222433,
-0.2295848131,
-0.6579615474,
0.2991592586,
0.0410060287,
-0.3733005524,
1.1696300507,
-0.3568751514,
-0.4593764544,
-0.0513290651,
0.2211885154,
0.6237725019,
0.3936682343,
0.2583034635,
-0.4453673065,
-0.0271688495,
-0.049772948,
-0.985455811,
-0.2537780106,
-0.1401601136,
-0.137131229,
0.1450766325,
0.5519179106,
-0.8467777967,
0.2391834557,
0.1938918382,
-0.553409338,
0.2781963646,
-0.2347656339,
0.1976100206,
-1.0314190388,
0.2804412842,
-0.3228826523,
0.2760131955,
-0.4849826992,
-0.342567265,
0.1477407515,
0.125706926,
-0.3565188944,
0.4800396562,
-0.5390152931,
0.102621451,
-0.475332886,
0.2356300801,
-0.2665683031,
0.4716179073,
0.4044159353,
0.9017304778,
0.7390207052,
-0.4810976088,
-0.0071552093,
0.6182729602,
-0.2746812999,
0.5144882798,
-0.6197365522,
0.4097541273,
-0.4516102672,
0.3765144348,
-1.1077492237,
-0.022436209,
0.4087191224,
-0.6484141946,
0.3352814317,
-0.0332540348,
-0.6599351764,
-0.0872112662,
0.028079465,
0.6491562128,
0.7937691212,
-0.8392217755,
0.6152353287,
0.059171129,
-0.3201362491,
-0.6011807323,
-1.0142763853,
0.0582882576,
-0.0037584691,
-0.7900241017,
0.3609233499,
-0.2065859139,
0.0085009187,
-0.0670342594,
-0.3589707315,
0.2196201086,
-0.2114340067,
-0.0047938563,
0.33258003,
-0.4974131882,
-0.0409828834,
0.1601902246,
-0.2506731153,
0.4857308269,
-0.5152438283,
0.6487646103,
-0.0400857739,
-0.1258672476,
-0.4029235542,
0.3931589425,
0.1204683036,
-0.1275116652,
0.4479224682,
0.8737620711,
-0.5585535765,
0.2293531895,
-0.1959194839,
-0.4945310354,
-0.4877232015,
0.2629289329,
-0.5214008093,
-0.9556742311,
0.404633373,
-0.1850496531,
-0.2793264091,
0.0435775928,
0.6284697056,
-0.2412475944,
0.9210187793,
0.1786102653,
-0.0273062848,
0.3237067759,
-0.0593951531,
-0.2095442861,
-1.1031765938,
-0.4104531705,
-0.1944140494,
-0.2704373896,
0.2534929812,
-0.3257032037,
0.5215606689,
0.0509059727,
0.089882642,
-0.0478115752,
-0.4843040407,
0.584051609,
0.4213023186,
0.7054196596,
0.1486490518,
0.421910733,
-0.5666032434,
-0.0437629297,
-0.4184133708,
-0.1017283201,
0.850102365,
0.4664446414,
0.6706732512,
0.020505501,
0.7616816759,
0.0787086859,
0.2517084479,
-1.1133542061,
0.668617487,
0.134737581,
-0.387306124,
-0.2051478475,
-0.5571771264,
-0.9383196831,
0.2515691221,
-0.0461185761,
-0.8491812944,
0.1326738298,
-0.0158926733,
-0.5338972211,
0.0291070603,
-0.5184169412,
0.5627049804,
-0.045375146,
0.0453717187,
-0.1498155296,
-0.6249836087,
0.1737088561,
0.0547478721,
0.1237830445,
-0.0757125542,
-0.408531934,
0.6425131559,
-0.0812237486,
0.6240520477,
-0.512364924,
-0.3790885508,
0.0883978158,
-0.2192451656,
0.365186125,
0.2436677665,
-0.0624876134,
0.340133518,
-0.3177189827,
-0.140205577,
-0.54915452,
0.6369923949,
-0.7456062436,
-0.326967448,
-0.4159328043,
-0.7169569135,
-0.5022794008,
0.2202102542,
0.6014356017,
0.4993355274,
-0.2047402412,
0.0494460799,
1.0658202171,
-0.2555335462,
0.6265268922,
0.2674511075,
-0.0643436536,
-0.9087894559,
0.7177006006,
-0.1780187786,
-0.1525227576,
0.7429247499,
0.1300484985,
-0.6698400378,
-0.8787727356,
-0.417424947,
0.3729942441,
-0.7498261929,
-0.1509171873,
-0.6907638907,
0.1639993638,
-0.1069424152,
0.0724458173,
0.0820956007,
-0.2003753334,
-0.400248915,
-0.0430985838,
0.4465108812,
0.130164817,
-0.0898167044,
0.4613939822,
-0.8335902095,
0.6323222518,
0.0229257215,
0.330486834,
-0.3395024538,
-0.55992347,
-0.2617413998,
0.1744730771,
0.2676804662,
-1.0563027859,
0.2473322451,
0.0206181556,
0.3993128538,
0.1523711383,
0.0842864811,
0.5608838201,
-0.6465110779,
0.6767875552,
0.4084858894,
-0.8128988743,
0.6016147733,
-0.5791082382,
0.799870491,
0.5439925194,
0.2648074627,
-0.5035527349,
-0.0828639343,
-0.1520005614,
-1.0147442818,
0.8676544428,
0.2851021886,
0.152755931,
-0.3490300775,
0.2248969674,
-0.0068620266,
-0.0884918198,
-0.4902739525,
-0.35838902,
-0.2287181467,
-0.6379295588,
0.1548671424,
-0.263071835,
-0.2867065668,
-0.2540530562,
0.338093251,
-0.2928547859,
0.8866607547,
0.5177994967,
-0.0259994026,
0.2284441292,
0.4618017077,
0.6413164139,
0.1869887561,
-0.4543043077,
-0.0508697741,
0.3397865295,
-0.7319825292,
0.114996247,
0.3308749795,
-0.0289735459,
0.2456684411,
-0.0523715951,
0.9551056027,
0.1765542626,
-0.552090466,
0.584145546,
-0.3779848516,
-0.3503278792,
-0.5055967569,
-0.3551199138,
0.2838048935,
0.1812070757,
0.6893045306,
0.1758218557,
0.2722153366,
-0.1350060403,
0.2840712667,
0.2012417465,
-0.1812388748,
-0.1286831349,
0.7203972936,
0.0637172759,
0.0220364444,
1.0054064989,
0.3027231097,
0.1776324958,
0.1665441543,
0.924161315,
1.1493502855,
0.0707817227,
-0.2129371464,
0.2540844083,
0.1227922738,
-0.156377241,
0.7599658966,
-0.301174432,
-0.6962783337,
-0.641131103,
-0.588460207,
-0.2733112574,
0.4721115828,
-0.628131032,
0.1886795461,
-0.604786694,
-0.3260011077,
-0.2375049144,
-0.7237500548,
-0.3823038042,
0.1800761819,
0.4570178688,
1.307393074,
-0.157430023,
1.0069137812,
0.7035883665,
-0.3334481418,
-0.784078002,
0.4183552265,
0.0529720895,
-0.8432016373,
0.5975303054,
0.4845713675,
-0.2622128129,
0.40940997,
-0.3944874108,
-0.6555294394,
1.1218910217,
0.5488113165,
-0.3265377581,
-0.2449678928,
-0.1030168161,
0.2815468013,
-0.3806037307,
0.3762466908,
0.4263434112,
0.6626271605,
-0.0235051028,
-0.7672107816,
0.2755865753,
-0.4724997282,
0.0443892516,
0.1053906381,
-0.0159705356,
0.5970481634,
-0.1877275109,
-0.4645888209,
0.1263269484,
1.078674078,
0.5349697471,
0.391017586,
0.6188722253,
0.2274805605,
0.6595407128,
-0.2216014266,
0.8989371657,
-0.3468361497,
0.0549881458,
0.7948815227,
0.0759776011,
1.0541821718,
0.7791287303,
0.1083925366,
0.3761529028,
0.6888702512,
0.1725213975,
0.8283257484,
0.0709152147,
-0.7072584629,
-0.0268079787,
0.0074830824,
-0.4930634499,
0.1892365068,
0.5918807983,
-0.1518171579,
-0.4136429727,
0.4053123295,
0.0096554169,
-0.134090811,
-0.4186390638,
0.8749725223,
0.3260016441,
-0.5392164588,
0.9279118776,
-0.1956836134,
1.0580240488,
-0.9447422624,
0.0422533005,
-0.1277811527,
0.0681994781,
-0.1524254829,
-0.7021731138,
0.1419370174,
-0.0217892975,
-0.3003514111,
-0.368821919,
0.5660735965,
-0.6935660839,
0.164072603,
0.4433020055,
0.4760242403,
0.3051855862,
-0.39101246,
-0.5517640114,
0.0659579784,
-0.1117304787,
-0.3207198083,
0.2705036104,
0.4632608294,
0.1916188151,
0.3225002885,
0.7532521486,
-0.0060307425,
-0.1179969013,
0.2395074815,
0.7989473939,
-0.8915105462,
-0.6800128818,
-0.8718501925,
0.6144768,
0.2190111876,
-0.2343456745,
0.4058945775,
0.2619745731,
0.703612864,
-0.5845756531,
0.7614279389,
-0.2468254715,
0.351882875,
-1.0903522968,
0.7550389767,
-0.3432607949,
0.2610639036,
0.0625371262,
-0.7208834291,
-0.3050210774,
0.6262595057,
0.0828078389,
0.0835164934,
1.1030299664,
0.9288679361,
-0.0056248866,
0.3523750603,
0.376581192,
-0.0447643474,
-0.1660733372,
0.6502695084,
0.9284352064,
-0.1120474413,
0.8126263618,
0.1981341094,
-0.4452410638,
0.0111860633,
-0.7045128345,
-0.8766900301,
-0.3885243237,
-0.2408133149,
-0.530788362,
0.0702677071,
1.164429307,
0.2949739993,
-0.6980853677,
-0.1284273267,
-0.1376327127,
-0.3390678167,
-0.4878723323,
-0.1766459942,
0.355246067,
-0.6226446629,
-0.5528612733,
1.1094521284,
0.1213997081,
0.2802216113,
0.0551972985,
-0.407481879,
-0.0033077132,
0.0165574979,
0.6307317019,
0.2251719534,
-0.6373763084,
-0.264495194,
0.2665971518,
-0.1560352445,
0.1564195901,
0.8679501414,
-0.9347611666,
0.0753808618,
0.6778395176,
0.9794059396,
0.3343552351,
-0.27301386,
0.6551762223,
-0.8865417838,
0.0739625618,
0.217481941,
0.4031636119,
0.3122743666,
-0.5383188725,
0.4697259068,
0.2929507494,
-0.3137052059,
-0.5800139308,
0.1293588579,
-1.5613205433,
-0.324219346,
1.2531870604,
-0.0871330276,
-0.5077264905,
-0.1368165314,
-0.6077005267,
0.1652584076,
-0.6435540318,
0.4980562031,
0.8187716603,
-0.2002257556,
-0.2208339274,
-0.2711127996,
0.3675155342,
0.5633116364,
-0.6350688934,
0.0265703984,
0.672975719,
0.1606626809,
0.1612338275,
0.992389679,
-0.3901111484,
0.5463268757,
0.0559446588,
0.0269838776,
-0.3970168829,
-0.239116922,
-0.6855110526,
0.2285185903,
-0.1226384342,
-0.4243766367
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07803v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07803v2
|
Decoding Geometric Properties in Non-Random Data from First Information-Theoretic Principles
| 2024-05-13T14:45:08 | 2024-05-18T01:24:24 |
Hector Zenil, Felipe S. Abrahão
|
cs.IT
|
cs.IT, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.IR, math.IT, math.ST, stat.TH
|
Based on the principles of information theory, measure theory, and
theoretical computer science, we introduce a univariate signal deconvolution
method with a wide range of applications to coding theory, particularly in
zero-knowledge one-way communication channels, such as in deciphering messages
from unknown generating sources about which no prior knowledge is available and
to which no return message can be sent. Our multidimensional space
reconstruction method from an arbitrary received signal is proven to be
agnostic vis-a-vis the encoding-decoding scheme, computation model, programming
language, formal theory, the computable (or semi-computable) method of
approximation to algorithmic complexity, and any arbitrarily chosen
(computable) probability measure of the events. The method derives from the
principles of an approach to Artificial General Intelligence capable of
building a general-purpose model of models independent of any arbitrarily
assumed prior probability distribution. We argue that this optimal and
universal method of decoding non-random data has applications to signal
processing, causal deconvolution, topological and geometric properties
encoding, cryptography, and bio- and technosignature detection.
|
[
-0.2871014476,
-0.7599722743,
0.6825035214,
0.110949114,
-0.2384462357,
-0.0646220744,
0.0580600351,
-0.1528434604,
0.4526126087,
0.3448717594,
-0.4552223682,
-0.5918135047,
-0.5982085466,
-0.4033612311,
-0.8257409334,
0.6653267741,
0.2730974853,
-0.0715717077,
-0.0604426153,
-0.0868227184,
0.1288167089,
-0.7263592482,
-0.1784713715,
-0.0364074856,
0.0625947118,
0.0323919952,
0.535592258,
0.497690469,
0.5775373578,
0.2171089351,
0.2169825882,
-0.0197096858,
-0.7219000459,
-0.4393771887,
0.0661365613,
-0.5509949923,
-0.0069319038,
0.2036610544,
0.6918391585,
1.2380565405,
-0.263620317,
0.1378337592,
-0.0768172219,
0.8337175846,
-0.6277623773,
0.2115348428,
-0.3303562105,
0.4247493744,
-0.0217090808,
-1.0169620514,
-0.4739387333,
-0.7091976404,
-0.2877486348,
-1.111104846,
0.5175620317,
0.0428394787,
0.3818349242,
0.1751106381,
-0.4744383395,
-0.3303085566,
-1.3877836466,
0.956276834,
-0.3784480989,
0.5983816385,
0.658673346,
0.3708593547,
-0.5547267795,
-0.3780124187,
-0.4074764252,
-0.1890621632,
-0.0014203076,
0.239567101,
-0.4070191383,
0.1106073707,
0.0796104223,
0.3636252284,
-0.479283601,
-0.3070748448,
-0.7441816926,
-0.3179574311,
0.4711715877,
0.0194276944,
0.2134002298,
-0.0398761481,
-0.2092532367,
-0.2121095955,
-0.6162226796,
0.0602162816,
0.5687987208,
0.0375239439,
-0.2470218837,
0.4648115635,
-0.3132936358,
0.3771976829,
-0.0923347175,
-0.007421209,
-0.1038452387,
-0.4174100459,
-0.182719633,
-0.1432903856,
0.5065580606,
-0.1301494539,
-0.0345492065,
-0.4221566916,
0.3515616357,
0.2437933832,
0.1778864861,
-0.3129356205,
-0.6218456626,
0.1083748266,
-0.8227410316,
-0.1604706347,
0.3232115507,
-0.580052793,
-0.3603346944,
-0.4179784656,
0.2632887363,
-0.6040176153,
-0.445653528,
0.549716711,
-0.1140523478,
0.3306413889,
0.1452697963,
-0.8325482607,
0.3969323337,
0.4595353603,
0.4603351951,
0.4758669734,
-0.0881825313,
-0.0391737223,
0.0534402877,
-0.6061837673,
0.6404947639,
-0.1795165539,
-0.2310188413,
-0.2503353953,
-0.3496046364,
0.3216667473,
0.0308476388,
0.4781342149,
-0.522521615,
-0.1065602228,
-0.1277633309,
-0.55028826,
-0.4615241885,
-0.1480526626,
-0.579464674,
0.2624551654,
0.1518977582,
-0.436111927,
0.4848012328,
-0.7487834692,
-0.3386458158,
-0.1399803162,
-0.3420225084,
-0.3251242042,
0.7556334138,
0.2531502843,
0.1420567632,
-0.1995155215,
-0.0038178102,
-0.6955857277,
-0.1676752269,
0.2129318863,
-0.6460914612,
0.8374013305,
0.5027729273,
0.195523724,
-0.2397353053,
-1.0943901539,
0.3009991944,
0.2991517484,
-0.3676900864,
-0.2347116619,
0.2360794842,
-0.0388104171,
-0.1208496168,
0.1278259754,
-0.7699032426,
0.1527162045,
-0.1925788522,
0.471508503,
0.6587074995,
0.1067002788,
0.6228313446,
0.0451286361,
-0.0144973835,
0.0742672533,
0.3632144928,
0.1526325494,
-0.05723086,
-0.2817549407,
-0.4196724296,
0.0501617305,
0.3862318397,
-0.6476233602,
0.4744844139,
-0.2385815531,
-0.2965963483,
-0.2036666572,
-0.0436849929,
0.249071613,
0.1542373598,
0.1990900934,
-0.2239536345,
-0.7439893484,
-0.5549390316,
-0.246121347,
-0.2233780771,
-0.3265101612,
0.1191067249,
0.1777993143,
0.0282854065,
0.7472270131,
-0.5952016115,
-0.0275990684,
-0.038839262,
0.1492730975,
0.5126982927,
0.4139386714,
0.6422916055,
-0.3752480745,
0.2289330661,
0.09751039,
-1.3180705309,
0.3938441873,
0.005289969,
-0.2015678883,
-0.2026643753,
0.262685746,
-0.3802656531,
0.9584060311,
0.2682623565,
-0.4567067921,
0.3578025699,
-0.7889011502,
0.2854456902,
-0.7881599069,
-0.0370386466,
0.1201067865,
-0.0423448347,
-0.99497962,
-0.0108613614,
-0.1497954875,
-0.0787888616,
-0.15400967,
0.1576611996,
-0.5260936618,
-0.3885352612,
-0.3262010813,
-0.1818543375,
-0.1908639967,
0.6890215278,
-0.0224285722,
0.1742185503,
0.6447607875,
-0.9027894735,
0.3086191118,
0.429323405,
-0.2354922295,
0.6902562976,
-0.3833824098,
0.1409935802,
-0.7511932254,
-0.1467280537,
-1.0512917042,
0.0864401385,
0.3322570026,
-0.7022243738,
-0.051368814,
-0.1789523959,
-0.4062892795,
-0.2873990834,
-0.0329116844,
0.6988453269,
0.5546060205,
-0.6825615764,
0.3733121753,
0.4473021626,
0.437666446,
-0.2235685736,
-0.6091142297,
-0.2113568783,
-0.0056385994,
-0.2975426018,
-0.3146005869,
-0.0760345906,
-0.1391861588,
0.000288194,
-0.1639186591,
-0.4104357064,
0.1343459189,
0.1373879761,
0.1309462786,
-0.0391941741,
-0.2793928683,
-0.0598363504,
-0.2854894698,
0.2318197936,
-0.9416621923,
0.3227701783,
0.1004196778,
-0.759359479,
-0.3730738759,
0.5609847903,
0.3644570112,
0.2443284392,
0.3767587245,
0.5120084882,
-0.6580988169,
-0.1432812959,
-0.1631892622,
-0.4134121537,
-0.4301235378,
0.3573867679,
-0.2331846356,
-0.5061274171,
0.5707471371,
-0.0579478331,
-0.0967852697,
0.2886180878,
0.1624056548,
-0.187108174,
0.8404240608,
0.9767326713,
-0.365734309,
0.3351587653,
-0.4760708809,
0.7281575203,
-0.396350354,
-0.2679538429,
-0.4063202143,
-0.4221875966,
-0.2592209876,
-0.0645085648,
0.4432162344,
0.2979037762,
-0.2869800925,
0.1894851774,
-0.5893192887,
0.4463331699,
0.898162663,
0.2972871661,
0.2906494141,
0.5520518422,
0.1674622297,
0.1012942269,
-0.7968803644,
-0.0963604227,
1.331048727,
0.2252175361,
1.1231355667,
-0.1235322729,
0.4864318073,
0.2991187572,
-0.1459278017,
-0.5545098186,
0.3494499326,
-0.0733153298,
-0.2159350365,
-0.4212894738,
-0.6928586364,
-1.0329552889,
-0.0915376991,
-0.2481876314,
-0.9045795798,
0.5832512379,
0.1542964876,
-0.3199946582,
0.7432163358,
-0.4361701012,
0.1163912117,
0.0401317179,
0.315186888,
-0.2670164406,
-0.4970021844,
0.4463172257,
0.1545170993,
0.2457333803,
-0.0056998339,
0.5244536996,
0.7928535342,
-0.3117742836,
0.6787570715,
-0.4138927162,
0.0983748585,
0.4515919685,
0.3382241428,
0.2782348394,
0.3858014345,
0.3304791152,
0.5470248461,
0.4108362198,
-0.5678486228,
-0.8019260168,
0.3140835464,
-1.1975750923,
-0.010492391,
-0.0446703397,
-0.7903859019,
0.0440995656,
0.1649472117,
0.4377459288,
0.5496361852,
-0.3247157633,
0.196509257,
0.5854088664,
-0.0749841705,
0.2706027329,
0.3610607982,
0.0265279245,
-0.4401043653,
0.9374573827,
-0.1635540277,
-0.0411617532,
0.3973308504,
-0.1497686207,
-0.2540681064,
-0.5732648969,
0.2107780874,
0.0964782313,
-0.9082508087,
-0.0873547494,
-0.3437495232,
-0.370239526,
-0.0591701753,
-0.1617817134,
-0.4520637989,
-0.6807199121,
-0.2629211247,
-0.0834275037,
0.2632093728,
0.8173139691,
-0.5993692279,
0.3135164082,
-0.5338487029,
0.6228206754,
-0.0056879278,
0.2446421087,
-0.2560422421,
-0.2191858143,
-0.1364694983,
0.405090332,
-0.0612844452,
-0.7069463134,
0.2671236694,
-0.0567630492,
0.7424091697,
0.529546082,
0.0442882739,
0.3199495375,
-0.1701259166,
0.4281920195,
0.3239888549,
-0.9108240604,
0.4435507059,
-0.3320813775,
0.0127491876,
0.3621501625,
0.0727859139,
-0.3321743608,
-0.2511601448,
-0.5701618195,
-0.4213521183,
0.4043772519,
0.4520148039,
-0.0539516695,
0.1174933538,
0.6836284995,
0.0638041347,
0.2382024974,
-0.4835870862,
-0.5035203695,
-0.5560445786,
-0.2457726896,
0.0007069287,
-0.0835769996,
-0.4464369118,
-0.1394815445,
0.2202155292,
-0.2063850015,
1.1727318764,
0.2311484218,
-0.1081355661,
-0.0369717367,
0.3791813254,
0.8267706633,
0.960347414,
-0.0756788105,
0.0576717816,
-0.1216801032,
-0.5786534548,
0.5216469169,
0.0664459541,
-0.1800318211,
-0.2533275783,
0.2511360049,
0.580109477,
-0.1138472557,
0.2785101533,
0.31734851,
-0.284771353,
-0.5713331699,
-0.4600938559,
-0.1299656481,
-0.6225866079,
0.3371892273,
0.7121480107,
0.2171395719,
0.1929270774,
-0.3331473768,
0.3375432789,
0.7866222262,
-0.2122790068,
-0.7748153806,
0.7346787453,
-0.3433237672,
0.2037039101,
0.5844960809,
-0.1922655553,
0.2012625635,
0.6269947886,
0.4893474579,
0.7679751515,
0.0353001542,
0.3382606208,
0.3971933722,
0.4326302707,
0.0375036858,
0.751024127,
-0.0882964954,
-0.8421694636,
-0.1861409992,
-0.5617445111,
-0.1458441317,
-0.0221304335,
-0.6987234354,
-0.1204195768,
-1.1058062315,
0.0880208313,
-0.0137027642,
-0.2302040905,
-0.8927211165,
-0.0052743917,
0.1128706262,
0.7228361368,
-0.7574153543,
0.6235112548,
0.3288559318,
-0.1687417775,
-0.8144939542,
-0.4371401966,
0.1429692656,
-1.0766199827,
0.3752118945,
-0.4036638141,
-0.0795370564,
0.1650762111,
-0.8944627643,
-1.1706665754,
0.9811410904,
0.5426179767,
-0.1907216907,
0.0445554554,
0.3875741065,
0.3256507218,
-0.1510767639,
0.2804671228,
0.4176467061,
0.3474392891,
0.3547549844,
-0.4938523769,
0.004398453,
-0.2426862717,
-0.0148951439,
0.4260130227,
-0.1288315207,
0.7182335258,
-0.2979491055,
-0.5508755445,
0.3084686697,
0.8329489231,
0.0225604419,
0.0714487806,
0.0386894234,
0.5853022933,
0.8155736923,
-0.2373844087,
1.0790770054,
-0.6303171515,
0.8278645277,
0.2389668375,
0.3741679192,
0.1194401607,
0.4210242927,
-0.3801239431,
0.1522376239,
0.109106198,
0.1753127873,
0.8402920365,
0.277307719,
-0.0017373752,
0.0672796369,
0.2571618855,
-0.3453120589,
0.4258226752,
0.4007614553,
-0.122964479,
-0.6162723303,
0.2428962886,
-0.1518803239,
-0.2120968252,
-0.5066672564,
0.6730159521,
0.0326793976,
0.0346000753,
0.7555250525,
-0.0065152356,
0.1617810726,
-0.6981770396,
-0.1697500199,
-0.1261222959,
0.343500644,
-0.2037389874,
-0.6795182824,
0.4070184827,
-0.7822877169,
-0.2677843571,
0.1150504351,
0.6503918767,
-0.3061154783,
-0.5772461295,
-0.0547294244,
0.2619220018,
0.171058774,
0.0052990001,
-0.1903139651,
-0.0706515089,
-0.1169921681,
0.0752408653,
-0.0941704586,
0.3619200289,
0.2148112208,
0.6616482139,
0.9917628765,
0.1735951304,
0.3567959666,
-0.2730244994,
0.6907749772,
-0.8245806098,
-0.871232152,
-0.6127721667,
0.3350168467,
0.3124444485,
-0.0245218854,
0.7628479004,
0.2374061197,
0.8291914463,
-0.1120968312,
1.0910931826,
0.1026550159,
0.0366025679,
-0.6859308481,
0.4871896803,
-0.1481362879,
-0.0795241669,
-0.2894508541,
-0.8393079638,
-0.5645427108,
0.6816583276,
-0.2907361388,
0.0632769316,
0.6169248223,
0.5136833191,
-0.3042713404,
0.3456437588,
0.430634439,
-0.0937083364,
0.4340806007,
0.9098356962,
0.888504982,
-0.4553432167,
0.446975857,
-0.1485183984,
-0.5761813521,
-0.0067419936,
-0.5303212404,
-0.7436673641,
-0.6943041682,
-0.0434947945,
-0.2092279196,
-0.1141635254,
0.4926503003,
0.9568828344,
-0.707698524,
-0.1065913066,
-0.3447306454,
0.0586273447,
-0.3362742066,
-0.1594420224,
0.3341037035,
0.0423760265,
-0.1461609602,
0.3560840786,
0.690299809,
0.1463753432,
-0.2544559836,
-0.1773843765,
0.055101566,
0.2977227271,
0.6296113729,
0.9458656907,
-0.3647245169,
-0.3686833382,
0.0212295949,
0.1630673259,
0.292332083,
1.0208673477,
-0.5137992501,
0.217476517,
0.6726033092,
0.5811682343,
0.3844580948,
-0.04326104,
0.4287512302,
-0.7684544921,
0.5319458842,
-0.0513253212,
0.4563559592,
-0.0063236761,
-0.7764105201,
0.1438938677,
0.3610044122,
-0.3655320406,
-0.3140966296,
0.5607757568,
-0.8083385825,
-0.1695822775,
0.6552143097,
0.0540451892,
-0.5667954683,
-0.1079100966,
0.2732944489,
0.1615238786,
-0.1033333987,
0.8751405478,
0.416303575,
-0.3585212827,
-0.2614058554,
-0.3230895996,
0.3327278793,
0.1130319908,
-1.0267556906,
-0.1208457202,
0.493458122,
0.3116531968,
0.4259788394,
0.9346146584,
-0.4287218153,
0.3793312907,
0.1086960286,
0.1217294484,
-0.2336223871,
-0.7464081049,
-0.3881017566,
0.3759503067,
-0.2596683502,
-0.485706985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07788v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07788v1
|
DEPTH: Discourse Education through Pre-Training Hierarchically
| 2024-05-13T14:35:30 | 2024-05-13T14:35:30 |
Zachary Bamberger, Ofek Glick, Chaim Baskin, Yonatan Belinkov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language Models (LMs) often struggle with linguistic understanding at the
discourse level, even though discourse patterns such as coherence, cohesion,
and narrative flow are prevalent in their pre-training data. Current methods
address these challenges only after the pre-training phase, relying on
expensive human annotated data to align the model. To improve the discourse
capabilities of LMs already at the pre-training stage, we introduce DEPTH, an
encoder-decoder model that learns to represent sentences using a
discourse-oriented pre-training objective. DEPTH combines hierarchical sentence
representations with two objectives: (1) Sentence Un-Shuffling, and (2)
Span-Corruption. This approach trains the model to represent both
sub-word-level and sentence-level dependencies over a massive amount of
unstructured text. When trained either from scratch or continuing from a
pre-trained T5 checkpoint, DEPTH learns semantic and discourse-level
representations faster than T5, outperforming it in span-corruption loss
despite the additional sentence-un-shuffling objective. Evaluations on the
GLUE, DiscoEval, and NI benchmarks demonstrate DEPTH's ability to quickly learn
diverse downstream tasks, which require syntactic, semantic, and discourse
capabilities. Overall, our approach extends the discourse capabilities of T5,
while minimally impacting other natural language understanding (NLU)
capabilities in the resulting LM.
|
[
-0.2058506906,
-0.590855062,
0.5625534058,
0.1903422624,
-0.562980473,
0.5650330782,
0.1516794562,
-0.1999279112,
0.0806211159,
0.5982640386,
-0.3908795714,
-0.6501265168,
-0.7788076401,
-0.112599425,
-0.3645758331,
0.9905667901,
0.1006003693,
-0.0205854196,
-0.1936993152,
0.2823868692,
-0.3330375552,
-0.4023678005,
-0.4317312539,
-0.4343840182,
0.3689307272,
0.3694218397,
0.5626134276,
0.6022863388,
0.1474763453,
0.3190349936,
-0.0632663816,
-0.0161882676,
-0.8530683517,
-0.1457670629,
-0.054006923,
-0.2045019716,
-0.3688834608,
-0.0851887986,
0.6529669762,
1.1310839653,
-0.2084484696,
-0.1323010921,
0.3251441121,
0.5267392993,
-0.8087800741,
0.1789669544,
-0.5588213205,
0.244989723,
-0.1988345236,
-0.2450167686,
-0.5606241822,
-0.3469191194,
0.4227720797,
-0.7202274203,
-0.1868444979,
0.0460571721,
1.1138970852,
0.2684695721,
-0.4474850297,
-0.064617075,
-0.5581379533,
0.4781904519,
-0.4627242088,
0.4041953087,
0.4822638631,
-0.0642242655,
0.1946627945,
-0.8081846237,
-0.108388938,
0.1636953354,
-0.2979029417,
0.3216973841,
0.1123020947,
0.4242846966,
0.1210111678,
0.6455334425,
-0.6364850998,
0.187718302,
-0.4859082103,
-0.1933656186,
0.2280045599,
0.1598349661,
0.1623430699,
-0.2802782655,
-0.3156188428,
0.0782102048,
-0.6486561298,
0.1571162194,
0.1704223752,
0.1461008489,
-0.1106573716,
0.230066061,
0.1018223688,
0.5766901374,
0.2415541857,
-0.1253918707,
0.2353480011,
-0.3298610747,
-0.3871033788,
0.0875594392,
0.8277291059,
-0.2869339883,
0.4041757882,
-0.205517143,
-0.0169430971,
-0.2249472886,
0.5159457922,
-0.9285207391,
-0.3043759465,
0.1379102767,
-0.3686062694,
-0.3517983854,
0.1496948749,
-0.4082265794,
-0.3272176683,
-0.203262791,
0.4405191839,
-0.6895490289,
-0.1410631239,
0.618801713,
0.0953992009,
0.4610984921,
0.1575730592,
-0.8582111001,
0.6180381179,
0.6605316401,
0.735029459,
-0.0954744592,
-0.3068088293,
-0.4912584722,
0.2795602977,
-0.4349406362,
0.7189113498,
-0.696305275,
-0.3688710034,
0.0839629173,
-0.2010668367,
-0.0561385751,
-0.4649735391,
0.5455585718,
-0.4439724982,
0.5282865167,
0.004315841,
-0.6033120155,
-0.0019951286,
0.3356369138,
-0.5130675435,
0.8531933427,
0.190367654,
-0.9709706903,
0.3095377982,
-0.5274147987,
-0.7282671332,
0.0900991186,
-0.048497811,
-0.4015729129,
0.2417929173,
0.5797432065,
0.377597481,
0.0305291936,
0.5377672315,
0.2268799692,
-0.6032404304,
-0.30590114,
-0.0745978057,
0.7357510924,
-0.1986790895,
-0.0259713195,
0.3211794198,
-0.6986827254,
-0.1543274373,
0.0028252392,
-0.3096607327,
-0.4427210391,
-0.1529610306,
-0.4947450459,
0.021686662,
0.1242781058,
-0.4214641154,
0.0025994752,
-0.98624897,
0.3654916584,
0.6438596845,
0.0188690256,
0.806707859,
-0.038584806,
0.5932838321,
0.6000140309,
0.0201114565,
-0.6983751059,
-0.0973718613,
-0.961555481,
-0.0146235228,
0.5540891886,
0.6750429273,
-0.9951894879,
0.5593987703,
-0.397128433,
-0.2342948467,
-0.9744502902,
-0.1162654534,
0.6108893752,
0.5233146548,
0.5690690875,
-0.6379628778,
-0.8349030018,
-0.7858839035,
-0.4027522206,
-0.2264239639,
-0.0467476696,
-0.0292706881,
0.6356703043,
0.0097715687,
0.7971694469,
-0.4632726014,
-0.2819476724,
-0.4067786634,
0.5365580916,
-0.0694904923,
0.3633491397,
0.0489312448,
-0.3180033565,
-0.2879599631,
-0.2265132219,
-0.553599298,
-0.0715492442,
-0.0440652035,
-0.2053780407,
-0.0133734168,
0.5653479099,
-0.5033009648,
0.3421479166,
0.4047221243,
-0.2503763139,
0.3622481823,
-0.28758201,
-0.0830335692,
-1.2403695583,
-0.1660749614,
-0.3671793938,
-0.4008201361,
-0.7453743219,
-0.2223587781,
0.0313120596,
-0.2988620996,
-0.5204945803,
0.1194830164,
-0.5877075195,
-0.2237950861,
-0.0312259719,
0.1277361661,
0.3430660367,
0.53754282,
0.3112244904,
0.5453481674,
0.5096487999,
-0.5179266334,
-0.2366681248,
0.1371162832,
-0.625470221,
0.3617577851,
-0.7510303855,
0.3495922089,
-0.4431909025,
0.3014967144,
-0.7392643094,
-0.1105343848,
0.095597811,
-0.2325269282,
0.3870449066,
0.0210295506,
-0.2692059577,
-0.2401833087,
-0.3248963058,
0.3873816729,
0.4926469028,
-0.3699604869,
0.6763174534,
0.5977692604,
-0.055020202,
-0.8408457637,
-0.7042917013,
0.0768127963,
-0.0147003355,
-0.4421518743,
0.577711165,
0.3000666201,
-0.0766768828,
0.0187417641,
0.1049231589,
-0.2885792851,
0.0553867817,
0.0104169101,
-0.1731377393,
-0.2613639235,
0.1134702191,
0.4051461518,
-0.1777542233,
0.1634447128,
-0.5196348429,
0.6584209204,
-0.1453374773,
-0.1782669872,
-0.4840714633,
0.349467814,
0.2683325112,
-0.4672391117,
0.8575338721,
0.3249231577,
-0.3229923248,
-0.1183179915,
-0.2417977601,
-0.2031274289,
-0.4212681055,
0.4595355988,
-0.4432301819,
-1.2363489866,
0.3263056576,
-0.1476741284,
0.1940290332,
0.0820978358,
0.02787349,
-0.2558542788,
0.7597338557,
0.7127838135,
-0.2001124769,
0.2617552578,
-0.1296410561,
0.3247898221,
-0.5904480815,
-0.2958808243,
-0.2662550509,
-0.2112130374,
-0.1890437454,
-0.6868724227,
0.0780059919,
0.1207268536,
-0.6028584838,
0.188594386,
-0.26816836,
0.7419607043,
0.2354178578,
0.0737102106,
0.3198208809,
-0.0029120347,
-0.1196377054,
-0.3949972689,
-0.7296769619,
-0.4104289114,
0.5832799077,
0.5936430693,
0.7536543608,
-0.2770411372,
0.9750668406,
-0.1486690789,
0.0022503622,
-0.7814378738,
0.5164827108,
-0.2899318337,
-0.1183922887,
-0.2364082038,
-0.3113624752,
-1.0582494736,
0.4909586906,
-0.0123242997,
-0.4210341573,
0.1310344189,
0.0790002942,
-0.5914029479,
0.2576887906,
-0.4887804091,
0.9550494552,
-0.1554133147,
-0.2072319388,
-0.0272416845,
-0.8868821859,
0.405584991,
0.1448516846,
0.2809723914,
0.2286123782,
-0.10886994,
0.5801252127,
-0.2774557173,
0.9981905818,
-0.2598837912,
-0.2197651714,
0.2125566453,
0.167658627,
0.2153560221,
-0.1600940228,
0.168561399,
-0.0498537496,
-0.438397646,
-0.3338981271,
-0.5291439891,
0.0158613138,
-0.8379956484,
-0.7232088447,
-0.3657402396,
-0.6033554077,
-0.2959574461,
0.1564439386,
0.2992961407,
0.2180040181,
-0.6179754138,
0.2795206606,
1.0083932877,
-0.3594773114,
0.2966331542,
0.2375959754,
-0.3036739528,
-0.2225141227,
0.7153894305,
0.0164209343,
0.2832374573,
0.7147634625,
0.2076469809,
-0.2703034282,
-0.6205106378,
-0.1693452746,
0.0530985296,
-0.577064395,
-0.1538300812,
-0.9116432667,
-0.5920544267,
-0.3213852346,
-0.1794839352,
-0.4222554266,
-0.2470228374,
-0.4809345603,
-0.4453358948,
-0.1361443847,
0.7659557462,
0.1157198474,
0.6326287985,
-0.6357921362,
0.327678144,
0.2758542001,
0.237477839,
-0.1712962389,
-0.9962311983,
-0.1341040283,
-0.115415588,
-0.4088586867,
-0.7921123505,
0.3870891333,
0.3938597739,
0.0825670362,
0.564475894,
-0.140108183,
1.0213068724,
-0.6276695132,
0.7516039014,
0.0127784349,
-1.4061971903,
0.796762526,
-0.3163910806,
0.8781223893,
0.6594817638,
0.5848163962,
-0.3851319253,
-0.5641109347,
-0.5694554448,
-0.8953539133,
0.8426733017,
0.1367446184,
0.3176328242,
0.1063651815,
0.3029390872,
0.209604755,
0.3127598763,
-1.0106754303,
0.1757453233,
-0.5547537804,
-0.2219153494,
0.0430664644,
-0.5225570202,
0.1372964531,
-0.5087891221,
0.4704881608,
-0.1014628559,
0.04682827,
-0.0520336926,
-0.4959850907,
0.1927510798,
0.4878945351,
0.367585808,
0.6010350585,
0.0879362077,
0.4385659397,
0.3438729644,
-0.4093147814,
0.0957307965,
-0.145583868,
-0.0854956359,
-0.1336854696,
0.613573432,
1.0761320591,
0.8197857738,
-0.3808257878,
0.6558468938,
0.0258891992,
-0.4533240795,
0.0587394945,
-0.2441301048,
0.4829720259,
-0.1106560007,
0.0710876882,
-0.2947860956,
0.1942286938,
-0.6727306247,
0.2092871219,
0.0019149726,
-0.4293450117,
-0.3504479825,
0.3761951923,
0.2505251765,
-0.1542785913,
0.670550704,
-0.2516213357,
-0.5527486801,
0.260261178,
0.6139226556,
0.7425977588,
-0.5939731002,
0.537864089,
0.3667940199,
0.4576139748,
-0.0936370865,
0.3785054982,
0.0178327616,
-0.8279868364,
-0.6673925519,
-0.6901674867,
-0.244764328,
0.1936518252,
-0.7175643444,
0.0281558074,
-0.5893285871,
0.2204872817,
-0.3469057977,
-0.1174903661,
-0.3570221961,
0.1949599981,
0.1562932283,
0.6962109208,
-0.7189162374,
0.8386414647,
0.4850754738,
-0.337430656,
-0.7782800794,
0.1466542333,
-0.3247171044,
-0.6943721175,
0.4746864438,
0.3381931186,
-0.2970437706,
0.1497589797,
-0.5878372788,
-0.7085283399,
0.8643699288,
0.7718266845,
-0.6453365684,
-0.339538157,
0.405510813,
0.7514292002,
-0.7258535624,
0.189701125,
0.7088152766,
0.2179951072,
0.1202175915,
-0.7533383965,
-0.1357205808,
0.0369159505,
0.1897591501,
0.1333644837,
-0.2122052908,
0.8765794039,
-0.1430106908,
-0.4764814675,
-0.2273148745,
0.9440375566,
0.1399521977,
-0.1225717291,
0.5786886215,
0.7101656199,
0.8908233643,
-0.3015280664,
0.8892080188,
-0.2380151451,
-0.0610793084,
1.3940794468,
-0.2051376998,
0.7781541348,
0.294536531,
0.2809442282,
1.069442749,
0.7399282455,
0.4533925951,
0.6301153898,
0.3097985685,
-0.0213742517,
-0.378752172,
-0.2465171069,
-0.2620849013,
0.5870786309,
0.4985570014,
-0.3257375658,
-0.2252766341,
0.0976275653,
0.042850282,
0.3760874569,
-0.5294836164,
1.0293666124,
0.341424942,
-0.6309916377,
0.5508744717,
-0.266153425,
0.5713674426,
-0.4335971475,
0.1643041074,
-0.1419769377,
0.0826582164,
-0.2211196423,
-0.8864899874,
0.5179999471,
-0.1365743577,
0.136536926,
-0.6405512094,
0.883177042,
-0.8125682473,
-0.3679364324,
0.4331879914,
0.6200057268,
0.218641147,
-0.0336626917,
-0.6103597879,
0.0037891767,
-0.3743292689,
-0.191459924,
0.195442915,
0.6231564879,
0.1267317384,
0.378649056,
0.0824401751,
-0.2160793841,
-0.1837479323,
0.5681641102,
1.0724271536,
-0.6068954468,
-0.6352525353,
-0.8483277559,
0.7375215292,
-0.1890497208,
-0.2077979892,
0.3802082837,
0.6107130051,
0.9325028658,
0.0372278467,
0.5756341815,
0.323385179,
0.3059401214,
-0.5436583757,
0.6490874887,
-0.2900283337,
0.0498545952,
-0.2593849897,
-0.6766631007,
-0.2942292988,
0.8775859475,
-0.4378678203,
0.0572937354,
0.9732168913,
0.3981934786,
-0.0438184105,
0.166331321,
0.3941803873,
0.359847039,
-0.0565436594,
0.8834290504,
1.0011669397,
-0.3874121904,
0.4721342623,
-0.0178742018,
0.0276937969,
0.336035043,
-0.7018594742,
-1.2115944624,
-0.3850737512,
-0.0990323648,
-0.0752169043,
0.3403536677,
0.5756036043,
0.7910116315,
-0.5595059991,
-0.4890046418,
-0.2715961337,
0.0211122297,
0.1679089814,
-0.1426687688,
0.1909478158,
-0.548251152,
-0.5930698514,
0.4514971673,
0.6078298092,
-0.1229766011,
-0.3551961482,
-0.0598682575,
-0.4086867273,
0.1745782495,
0.8776372671,
-0.0893134251,
-0.5065624118,
-0.3680500984,
-0.0689104497,
-0.0912528038,
0.3550689518,
1.0480343103,
-0.8994626403,
0.2589086294,
0.4837329388,
0.7550444603,
0.5862850547,
0.1333471835,
0.7492366433,
-1.0402760506,
0.2686221898,
0.4958308935,
0.2352395654,
0.4463497996,
-0.2414554358,
0.2180977911,
-0.0731630325,
-0.2068480849,
-0.7179972529,
0.400041163,
-0.4828850925,
-0.490816474,
0.6939448714,
-0.3900302649,
-0.0952088088,
-0.4956297874,
-0.1308900714,
0.2299197912,
-0.2101514339,
0.7013597488,
0.7646933794,
0.1541663259,
-0.653364718,
-0.0250979736,
0.6579505801,
0.6345883608,
-1.1476641893,
-0.0175443739,
0.1364050657,
-0.1025941893,
0.0346144028,
0.9711270928,
-0.2898621261,
-0.0464928336,
-0.1019509211,
-0.110291712,
0.0602520593,
-0.6408403516,
-0.3884223402,
0.4935082197,
-0.0827196389,
0.0474832319
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07778v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07778v1
|
A Comprehensive Analysis of Static Word Embeddings for Turkish
| 2024-05-13T14:23:37 | 2024-05-13T14:23:37 |
Karahan Sarıtaş, Cahid Arda Öz, Tunga Güngör
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Word embeddings are fixed-length, dense and distributed word representations
that are used in natural language processing (NLP) applications. There are
basically two types of word embedding models which are non-contextual (static)
models and contextual models. The former method generates a single embedding
for a word regardless of its context, while the latter method produces distinct
embeddings for a word based on the specific contexts in which it appears. There
are plenty of works that compare contextual and non-contextual embedding models
within their respective groups in different languages. However, the number of
studies that compare the models in these two groups with each other is very few
and there is no such study in Turkish. This process necessitates converting
contextual embeddings into static embeddings. In this paper, we compare and
evaluate the performance of several contextual and non-contextual models in
both intrinsic and extrinsic evaluation settings for Turkish. We make a
fine-grained comparison by analyzing the syntactic and semantic capabilities of
the models separately. The results of the analyses provide insights about the
suitability of different embedding models in different types of NLP tasks. We
also build a Turkish word embedding repository comprising the embedding models
used in this work, which may serve as a valuable resource for researchers and
practitioners in the field of Turkish NLP. We make the word embeddings,
scripts, and evaluation datasets publicly available.
|
[
-0.5182705522,
-0.9802411199,
0.3104253709,
0.0992674008,
-0.7665845752,
-0.3629310131,
-0.4651657343,
-0.4055202603,
0.192392692,
0.3879368603,
0.0239686426,
-0.7962028384,
-0.754647553,
0.2960537672,
-0.4041675627,
0.8331575394,
-0.4783955514,
0.0910861641,
-0.4670039415,
-0.6547622681,
-0.6647350192,
-0.3453249037,
-0.0244571734,
-0.0515658893,
-0.0163403656,
-0.0196449906,
0.5553358793,
0.3496796787,
0.3794151545,
0.2772592008,
-0.419298768,
-0.0352367051,
-0.2318761945,
0.2574832141,
-0.3347323537,
0.0794315487,
0.1413372308,
-0.1422654092,
0.7166293263,
0.6161725521,
-0.1794106662,
0.6320944428,
0.2303395867,
0.5368627906,
-0.9433827996,
0.1954962015,
-0.4100862443,
0.2977862656,
-0.109599866,
-0.1321199089,
-0.1557232141,
-0.5098499656,
0.4033487141,
-0.1492898613,
0.0890664607,
-0.0711685494,
0.58990556,
0.1794287562,
-0.6651594043,
-0.4862569273,
-0.6800630689,
0.6908978224,
-0.8655136824,
0.4587321579,
0.146586895,
0.1590066254,
-0.25494349,
-0.6344028711,
-0.3800971806,
-0.6598448157,
0.0102468338,
-0.0851676315,
-0.0686048642,
0.14651829,
-0.0023958934,
0.7298146486,
-0.3522432148,
-0.3546282053,
-0.2328043878,
0.2217406929,
0.3445383906,
0.0967671275,
0.3567766249,
-0.1344282925,
-0.1501679271,
-0.0900434628,
-0.5711587071,
0.0477119051,
0.1904670298,
0.4109701216,
-0.1672970653,
0.9793160558,
-0.4376034439,
0.90384835,
-0.0852468908,
-0.2209257782,
-0.0588501319,
-0.1896724403,
-0.399749577,
0.2063555717,
0.3499920666,
0.1263273656,
-0.1087932289,
-0.4622654021,
-0.2859896123,
0.1219594851,
0.3050511479,
-0.4528219402,
0.2791689634,
0.2733391523,
-0.6124440432,
-0.2673337758,
0.1412814856,
-0.487788111,
-0.4299057424,
-0.2154067606,
0.4818212986,
-0.4918790162,
-0.2833358347,
0.2555916011,
-0.1785724014,
0.179017812,
0.1766954958,
-0.723192811,
0.5006756186,
0.7465860844,
1.0435550213,
0.1284151077,
0.0107366396,
0.0277257953,
0.113222979,
-0.5417379141,
0.6490211487,
-0.6367606521,
-0.2337796539,
0.6035984755,
0.0764432251,
-0.1482347846,
-0.5002529621,
0.9148983955,
-0.3647377193,
0.2786338031,
-0.598026216,
-0.8174797297,
-0.9142389894,
0.2615892291,
-0.6793015599,
0.945817709,
0.111738272,
-1.0641299486,
0.5508592725,
-0.6021761298,
-0.1412298679,
0.2013324052,
-0.0115239089,
-0.0794412568,
0.8452171087,
-0.1599147767,
0.663056314,
-0.2451573014,
0.2625293136,
-0.3737543523,
-0.6142731309,
-0.0931026414,
-0.0475043431,
0.1930675358,
0.1088206545,
-0.6328638792,
-0.0642362684,
-0.4151486158,
-0.1195134521,
0.11825113,
-0.4590505064,
-0.5425612926,
0.3519103229,
0.3785943985,
0.4398836792,
0.2628510296,
-0.6878489852,
-0.0013152313,
-0.2917465568,
0.1371598542,
0.2869101465,
-0.0830299631,
0.1751133054,
-0.3077367544,
0.4018804133,
-0.2330791354,
-0.3985725939,
0.1325736344,
-0.360753268,
-0.7240609527,
-0.2319382727,
0.404669404,
0.3990006149,
-0.4416888356,
0.4589082301,
-0.2865261137,
-0.4866636395,
-0.3188717365,
-0.0007085043,
0.2047685087,
0.2663761079,
0.2923987806,
-0.1091673896,
-0.3033894002,
-0.8395573497,
-0.4214578569,
0.041923862,
0.0864428952,
0.4610137939,
0.5654372573,
-0.0759635046,
0.6719596386,
0.008063524,
-0.3991015553,
-0.3948554099,
0.2243248969,
0.2499323785,
0.3063994944,
0.5343672633,
-0.1424930394,
-0.5690633655,
0.0503397211,
-0.8622218966,
0.0928561538,
0.0363907367,
0.182145223,
0.5760619044,
0.2275741845,
-0.5093535185,
0.5557293296,
0.6953266859,
-0.723377943,
0.6154012084,
-0.3067009151,
0.0183189418,
-0.839142859,
0.3338554502,
0.0511623472,
-0.4625536203,
-0.6388168335,
0.5532560349,
-0.0824170038,
-0.1997859776,
-0.6514979005,
0.4545738697,
-0.5740885735,
-0.0546622984,
-0.1793355197,
0.0539614893,
-0.2009309679,
0.2682629526,
0.2493718415,
0.7705208659,
0.329128474,
-0.4830973744,
0.2458472401,
0.1053919122,
-1.0117146969,
0.1700096279,
-0.7834268808,
0.0479035936,
-0.1140679717,
0.3354142308,
-0.8061714172,
0.1605825275,
0.2647145092,
0.1616677493,
0.4950421751,
-0.1768689007,
-0.7002459764,
-0.0285007022,
-0.5072336197,
0.2320348471,
0.2695427835,
-0.2381565869,
0.2880478501,
0.4050008655,
-0.1956714094,
-0.5094243288,
-0.5073491335,
0.2005788833,
-0.421303004,
-0.6235776544,
0.3943684995,
0.6238936186,
-0.2388510853,
0.4633982778,
-0.1185120121,
0.0485340245,
0.134718731,
0.0918619856,
-0.034970928,
-0.4579153955,
0.2163582891,
0.1493759453,
0.1071077213,
-0.192145586,
-0.3456529975,
0.5496391058,
-0.6404010057,
-0.4053772688,
-0.4378410876,
0.5837039948,
0.722826004,
-0.3032217026,
1.4345411062,
0.8508340716,
-0.5956021547,
0.2518749833,
-0.7310838699,
0.1853765696,
-0.3996250331,
0.4538448453,
-0.2451678962,
-0.9266178012,
0.2647515833,
-0.2263479829,
0.2797018588,
0.5000856519,
0.8141453862,
0.0953212306,
0.8262508512,
0.6750833392,
0.1347945184,
0.2734566033,
-0.2429074198,
0.3522594571,
-0.9178029299,
-0.2951974571,
-0.2308143228,
-0.2253717482,
-0.7054432034,
-0.4446038008,
0.033685334,
0.1830145866,
-0.0131452139,
0.1876273453,
-0.481081605,
0.202398479,
0.1036242098,
-0.2519586384,
-0.1989834458,
0.3031311929,
-0.5048644543,
0.0890175849,
-0.5564735532,
-1.1560701132,
0.9130343795,
0.4507894218,
0.4047605395,
0.4025727808,
0.5282316208,
0.3898135424,
0.0735336244,
-0.8421744108,
0.3060323,
-0.3730604351,
-0.5648425817,
-0.3419865072,
0.038477771,
-0.8741637468,
0.5214161873,
-0.6048696637,
-0.9438559413,
0.1106341779,
-0.2020952702,
-0.3339743614,
0.6448636055,
-0.5030823946,
0.7989031672,
0.3401638865,
-0.3891491294,
-0.4668438435,
0.0172822457,
0.317068845,
0.1270034909,
-0.0687252879,
-0.3005588949,
-0.1127757132,
0.9310685396,
-0.3031068146,
0.4697721899,
-0.3687160611,
0.069792591,
0.4417866468,
0.139632374,
0.3491767943,
0.0875277445,
-0.0750376135,
0.3966029584,
0.6420542002,
-0.3759611249,
-0.3633954227,
0.6512922645,
-0.7089169621,
-0.6822752953,
-0.6048835516,
-0.22356233,
-0.0513003916,
-0.0339992382,
0.0065269782,
0.8451297283,
-0.5198966861,
0.617305994,
0.3728591502,
-0.4968146384,
0.327054292,
0.3615804315,
0.0743580833,
-0.1103988588,
0.6675896049,
0.1540604085,
-0.3632046282,
0.3049433231,
0.2114349753,
-0.5699581504,
-0.531915009,
-0.2402346283,
0.3251836896,
-0.6670069695,
0.1589739174,
-0.7120261192,
0.0175149757,
-0.5018844604,
-0.2619481981,
-0.5620471239,
-0.58643502,
-0.2233770937,
0.0168159138,
0.1218383983,
1.0388516188,
-0.0234827083,
-0.1425041705,
-0.7554292679,
0.115558587,
0.1888403594,
0.4322990775,
0.219853431,
-0.3663059473,
-0.4450028837,
-0.0978460982,
-0.2473264486,
-1.2023109198,
0.3612709045,
0.2372612208,
0.4847249985,
0.7833917737,
0.017334152,
0.4880194366,
-0.6365201473,
0.9582411647,
-0.2390474081,
-1.0573800802,
0.1262246072,
-0.2985375822,
0.1734469384,
0.8151077628,
0.2407581359,
-0.9824275374,
-0.1318514943,
-0.3656513095,
-1.0166112185,
0.6541904807,
0.2707447112,
0.4101243019,
-0.0562361591,
0.3213599324,
0.2547828853,
0.2327452898,
-0.2907520831,
-0.2184184343,
-0.2426644266,
0.004149708,
-0.1554431915,
-0.8536477089,
-0.1042094305,
-0.1530327648,
0.5203660131,
0.3672415018,
0.7518454194,
0.0388660803,
-0.4353711903,
0.1716130674,
0.4065024555,
0.9437004328,
0.5309308171,
-0.73890239,
0.1969018131,
0.5179082155,
-0.515615344,
0.2278693765,
-0.1763299555,
0.2700347602,
0.4414671063,
0.6044796109,
0.7925889492,
0.1251694262,
-0.4754382968,
0.5608317256,
-0.2809396684,
0.0945024416,
-0.5838421583,
-0.3781547844,
0.0787577704,
-0.0815031976,
-0.0053194035,
-0.3695206642,
0.2000474483,
-0.4208896458,
0.1240622699,
0.4553215206,
-0.4928378761,
-0.4314676225,
0.184976846,
0.0809119642,
-0.1024210304,
0.5501171947,
-0.1343993843,
-0.4167637825,
0.2469554245,
0.7291538119,
1.1541876793,
-0.0305904411,
0.3809704781,
0.3815502226,
0.2387860119,
0.0483653583,
0.2473077923,
-0.4480125606,
-0.5008711219,
-0.192369625,
-0.700874567,
-0.3246203363,
0.3767818213,
-0.8661049008,
0.3276489377,
-0.5800864697,
-0.2237793505,
-0.5600014329,
0.3218520582,
-0.8495413661,
0.0756851956,
0.4437275231,
1.0267974138,
-1.0023806095,
0.564938426,
1.3244860172,
0.052164983,
-0.3743514717,
0.0205063652,
-0.1657075435,
-0.3626731932,
0.4052501917,
0.4275963902,
-0.0417938717,
-0.3747248352,
-0.0334432572,
-1.116127491,
1.0865417719,
0.152939409,
-0.0747525394,
0.2897059321,
0.2874208093,
0.6156708598,
-0.2888232768,
0.4567736983,
0.3866228163,
0.3243930042,
-0.1281750798,
-0.5041022897,
0.4445418715,
-0.3065980077,
0.318846792,
-0.0568843,
-0.3750524521,
0.5617246628,
0.5257805586,
-0.6446231604,
-0.0473462641,
0.6930613518,
0.3337233961,
0.0517111309,
0.3553560376,
0.7972009778,
0.4127326608,
0.0407356992,
1.3152389526,
-0.888420105,
0.3465002775,
0.8400047421,
0.033194989,
0.9160088897,
0.3436949849,
-0.1269408017,
0.6199600697,
0.6704473495,
0.2123992741,
0.8517528772,
0.1163172424,
-0.5149840713,
-0.0258300211,
-0.4788508415,
-0.6646847725,
0.550955832,
0.4265538156,
-0.2262333483,
-0.5949408412,
-0.349331975,
0.0562311299,
-0.4027414322,
0.0958206505,
0.6118081212,
0.1851325631,
-0.3839964569,
0.7686018348,
0.796734333,
0.5271994472,
-0.4186380506,
0.1178244576,
-0.1155872494,
-0.0103687057,
-0.0150998058,
-0.4082129002,
0.7163364887,
-0.0146643491,
0.2904489338,
0.0673992708,
0.7746626735,
-0.2160386145,
-0.481071353,
0.1499053836,
0.4178759754,
0.2449063957,
-0.0269416235,
-0.6001703143,
-0.2191731334,
-0.3588325083,
-0.3642149866,
0.2052308619,
0.3301382959,
-0.0902396366,
0.4217643738,
0.5875601172,
0.2111487538,
0.0523107797,
-0.1530883312,
0.6433722377,
-0.5786875486,
-0.4746124446,
-0.8540216684,
0.3797907531,
0.2745637596,
-0.3675794601,
0.7769121528,
0.2420902997,
0.4212656021,
-0.2449128777,
0.4861874282,
-0.0009128029,
0.0394793265,
-0.4345642626,
0.8053357601,
-0.7276757956,
-0.1750265807,
-0.4414904416,
-1.2226473093,
-0.1127796248,
0.8069571257,
-0.2365963608,
-0.237555325,
0.7221544981,
0.2935907245,
-0.1089036092,
0.0601743497,
0.4824991524,
-0.0740970075,
0.068925418,
0.1776160896,
0.9613112807,
-0.1513963044,
-0.1941976696,
-0.318162024,
-0.1665076911,
-0.3717425168,
-1.0009335279,
-1.0090961456,
-0.6784898639,
-0.1686836928,
0.0206530783,
0.0216842387,
1.0539230108,
0.4108548462,
-1.0986440182,
-0.2098192126,
0.0237304196,
0.0592195131,
-0.1490392387,
-0.2090272009,
0.739533484,
-0.2449122369,
-0.424015373,
0.2669245601,
0.292458117,
-0.015805155,
-0.257135421,
0.2610357702,
-0.3215874732,
0.4370739758,
0.5547890663,
0.1331256181,
-0.8598893285,
-0.1853720397,
-0.3813354075,
-0.0089790979,
-0.320863694,
0.6101166606,
-0.6435239911,
0.4478644431,
0.9169803858,
0.5648494363,
0.2965855002,
-0.0875065476,
0.5308815241,
-0.4903607965,
0.4303386807,
0.0407698825,
0.6133055091,
0.3548666239,
-0.2199229896,
0.3128549457,
-0.031014014,
-0.2769748867,
-0.7823214531,
-0.0353968814,
-0.4709247649,
-0.2622917295,
1.3312203884,
-0.5479877591,
-0.0244941115,
-0.3196985722,
0.1723072231,
0.563680768,
-0.2253857255,
1.1004257202,
0.8803160191,
0.2183376849,
0.1834025979,
-0.621443212,
0.399199307,
0.5615810752,
-0.1614094973,
-0.2888329923,
0.0678029731,
0.2895488441,
0.1457038075,
0.2347179651,
-0.2453784943,
-0.0315136984,
-0.0149369901,
0.0310090017,
-0.2968125343,
-0.0517387874,
-0.7025479674,
0.2348439544,
0.0492830686,
-0.320006609
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07766v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07766v1
|
Challenges and Opportunities of NLP for HR Applications: A Discussion Paper
| 2024-05-13T14:09:06 | 2024-05-13T14:09:06 |
Jochen L. Leidner, Mark Stevenson
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7; I.2.1
|
Over the course of the recent decade, tremendous progress has been made in
the areas of machine learning and natural language processing, which opened up
vast areas of potential application use cases, including hiring and human
resource management. We review the use cases for text analytics in the realm of
human resources/personnel management, including actually realized as well as
potential but not yet implemented ones, and we analyze the opportunities and
risks of these.
|
[
-0.1440464705,
-0.6693381667,
0.4196050763,
0.2152903378,
0.3003095388,
0.2341461778,
-0.1113469452,
-1.0058457851,
-0.0508338846,
0.6491861343,
-0.7474484444,
-0.2473419905,
-0.3522387445,
0.3063571751,
-0.3229519725,
0.8276060224,
0.0513035059,
0.0793906823,
-0.3378936946,
-0.1567388177,
-0.7918424606,
-1.0122518539,
-1.0648815632,
-0.4514300525,
0.3355925083,
0.4553331435,
0.6368968487,
0.1972580701,
0.9198310971,
0.3457299173,
-0.0648363382,
-0.1161408052,
0.1284583062,
0.5842670202,
-0.1954103261,
-0.47705248,
-0.5089487433,
0.1983239353,
0.6836505532,
0.8800091743,
-0.5979819894,
0.3817841411,
-0.184354037,
1.1280039549,
-0.4129563868,
-0.0452736281,
-0.7232092619,
0.4519391358,
-0.5174077749,
-0.5131235719,
-0.2038840503,
-0.116421327,
0.5743160248,
-0.1970196664,
0.2953579128,
0.2665550113,
0.3912000656,
0.2029843181,
-0.2612593472,
-0.6077997088,
-1.01818645,
1.182685256,
-0.6307422519,
0.3649252653,
0.5721066594,
0.4636774659,
-0.1409932375,
-0.6160451174,
-0.3881340325,
0.0394601412,
0.1498614103,
-0.0003685385,
-0.2850458622,
-0.0153057249,
0.2987483144,
0.3407829702,
-0.7411317229,
0.3512091637,
-0.3478340507,
0.131498903,
0.9712282419,
0.7312790155,
0.4248128533,
0.0984206572,
-0.0504274704,
-0.0902413875,
-0.2190672308,
-0.0630897358,
0.401753217,
0.3366729021,
0.311275214,
0.6739624739,
-0.2429901212,
0.8789249063,
-0.5712731481,
0.20216012,
0.0208249614,
-0.3337383866,
-0.2763245404,
0.0752650499,
0.3800355494,
0.1877144873,
-0.0704533458,
-0.2755306065,
0.0554222688,
0.0309710242,
0.6871046424,
-0.3123517632,
0.2095696777,
0.5572111607,
-0.6558409929,
-0.1392364949,
-0.1370276958,
-1.0827200413,
-0.6535335779,
-0.2394352555,
-0.2913310528,
-0.1749441326,
-0.2769352198,
0.117954053,
-0.3235197663,
0.740863502,
0.3104076684,
-1.0078860521,
0.3629793525,
0.6872963905,
0.74511832,
-0.3418656886,
-0.1092465073,
-0.1617840081,
-0.0893729255,
-0.2232376635,
0.600210309,
-0.5368044972,
-0.3553035557,
0.3796208203,
-0.2852263153,
-0.1328113973,
-0.7652475238,
0.8647481799,
-0.5312174559,
0.2685264349,
-0.0252402723,
-0.5252242684,
-0.1167832091,
0.4184007049,
-0.3821822703,
1.0753605366,
0.0684460998,
-0.5908013582,
0.4366916716,
-0.9910267591,
-0.3717634082,
0.1190226749,
-0.0675183982,
-0.593732357,
-0.0154192904,
-0.0367283709,
0.2869620621,
-0.1678954214,
0.1093702912,
-0.1065894887,
-0.1533980966,
0.4362854362,
-0.1929339021,
1.0586158037,
0.3417683244,
-0.183474943,
0.1373324692,
-0.5852985382,
0.1262363344,
0.0490172021,
-0.4820473492,
-0.4949004948,
0.4353289604,
0.205158934,
0.2371275872,
0.0317895338,
-0.2444399595,
0.1395354867,
-0.2173720449,
0.3432030678,
0.3212230206,
-0.227050662,
0.5103796124,
-0.1309354305,
1.1095792055,
-0.3546569943,
0.0119590089,
-0.0006559064,
-0.6793668866,
-0.4835583568,
0.2611508071,
0.3223675191,
0.9234129786,
-0.7188870907,
0.398219496,
0.2488191426,
-0.5131449103,
-0.3502631485,
0.1237664074,
-0.086717397,
0.4691240191,
0.3794604242,
-0.1815012544,
-1.0490987301,
-0.6690632701,
-0.9291394353,
-0.3046806157,
0.0750729069,
0.2923782766,
0.3250714839,
-0.4154467583,
1.207605958,
-0.596334219,
-0.4726788402,
-0.3772644401,
0.0079832925,
0.2280326933,
0.6886667609,
0.4505897164,
-1.1195366383,
-0.3100137711,
-0.0245528072,
-0.9306519032,
-0.0385040194,
-0.2445537746,
-0.1230377629,
0.2068703622,
0.4871923327,
-0.4950645566,
0.3829168379,
0.5193401575,
-0.5635891557,
0.5458685756,
-0.1879897863,
0.1148561537,
-0.7480509877,
0.2285300046,
0.4498395026,
-0.3009363115,
-1.0297980309,
-0.2957237065,
-0.2439609915,
-0.7367587686,
-0.2836487293,
0.5577179193,
-0.3313611448,
-0.1105406582,
-0.3307698965,
-0.0600830242,
-0.4741190374,
0.1105419099,
0.3539038002,
0.3777890801,
0.2185489386,
-0.812066257,
0.2123671323,
0.5299724936,
-0.3057080805,
0.712937355,
-0.3333102763,
0.0511451773,
-0.0769039094,
0.0312030092,
-0.4297432601,
-0.1963840872,
-0.0992175043,
-0.3974241912,
0.2333419919,
0.4065763652,
-0.2097873539,
-0.886000216,
-0.4300284088,
0.159785673,
0.4598411024,
0.0143915815,
0.4196743965,
0.6320728064,
-0.5754405856,
-0.6220479608,
-1.0512862206,
0.4318464696,
-0.6023596525,
-0.2573090494,
0.4351381361,
0.083867304,
-0.5098949671,
-0.0019334566,
0.0012250452,
-0.4445863068,
0.4154405594,
0.0273084808,
0.2824991643,
0.0608924292,
0.0090027712,
-0.2458281517,
-0.1274020225,
0.2242553085,
0.0498247035,
0.2851029932,
-0.0359548368,
-0.1717773974,
-0.5336614251,
0.5372775793,
-0.0782912299,
0.1428049356,
0.8363959789,
0.8060631156,
-0.5016086698,
-0.0294615664,
-0.465991348,
0.0532100312,
-0.4279565513,
0.4906365871,
0.5479662418,
-1.0579271317,
0.4866225123,
-0.1392108053,
0.088346757,
0.5972273946,
0.3424203396,
-0.5872710347,
0.9132395983,
1.1345690489,
-0.1058188677,
0.7663171887,
-0.1475116611,
0.276568383,
-0.7100779414,
-0.243376568,
-0.9364153743,
-0.2933270633,
-0.8293332458,
0.1122022569,
0.1739007235,
0.1854129732,
0.1318463981,
0.2438114285,
-0.60836941,
0.3120597899,
0.5535955429,
-0.2897455096,
0.2854076028,
-0.0992364436,
0.6500467062,
-0.5680168867,
-0.7506040931,
-0.5756246448,
0.6406165957,
0.4928200543,
0.4300939441,
0.1397739202,
0.3825911582,
0.8258248568,
0.2688921988,
-0.5554556251,
0.3564278185,
-0.1157542318,
-0.8313298225,
-0.5080100894,
-0.5915363431,
-1.0804847479,
0.1777685285,
-0.5832833052,
-0.9245629907,
0.0914419368,
0.2649587095,
-0.1843747795,
0.4044788182,
-0.900837779,
0.7944291234,
-0.2508721352,
-0.0191248059,
-0.0931205153,
-0.4871598184,
0.3044449389,
-0.29225564,
0.2190289348,
-0.064556241,
0.071883969,
1.1860237122,
-0.2077807486,
0.7213855982,
-0.1419584006,
0.0800157338,
0.4516761005,
-0.2071231455,
0.1841621846,
-0.0895267576,
-0.5322188735,
0.3002678752,
-0.0137061011,
-0.3280104101,
-0.260081321,
0.2277468741,
-0.1215041205,
-0.5167168975,
-0.9250967503,
-0.5703265071,
-0.5866213441,
0.2603179216,
-0.1861444712,
-0.0499611385,
-0.2727226615,
0.2630655766,
0.1415292919,
-0.6664191484,
0.7283234,
0.1856569201,
-0.1154195219,
-0.294985503,
0.6293079257,
0.0135129374,
-0.173064217,
0.2737592161,
0.1090322062,
-0.3668718934,
-0.5580869913,
-0.026713049,
0.1006428078,
-0.2551662624,
-0.1999699771,
-0.4871941805,
0.0246217269,
-0.354731679,
-0.3470304906,
-0.0622300431,
-0.1800048202,
-0.1664477587,
0.2456856668,
0.1877001375,
0.6708737612,
0.0937796608,
0.3408848047,
-0.7565584779,
0.0800440982,
0.3609725833,
0.4173763692,
0.0628401414,
0.0672208592,
-0.5773476362,
-0.052163206,
-0.5603178144,
-0.7315234542,
0.7368950248,
-0.0011817488,
0.5902879834,
-0.033649344,
-0.1252851337,
0.4911440313,
-0.4397774041,
1.1441200972,
0.2298176289,
-0.791366756,
0.7588126659,
-0.4984072149,
0.2418792099,
0.639162302,
0.4129613936,
-0.8410128951,
0.0150051741,
-0.7932540178,
-0.9402889609,
1.056189537,
0.4737384617,
0.0750510022,
0.1961512566,
0.4673873484,
-0.1423719823,
0.572670579,
-0.5282998681,
-0.2657346725,
0.4270912707,
-0.0118202008,
-0.0286558513,
-0.4825936258,
0.2786999941,
-0.4237007499,
0.526304245,
0.1919883639,
0.4128409028,
0.0688189715,
0.1252198666,
0.1581106186,
0.3823659122,
0.6344239712,
1.0030550957,
-0.3421590924,
-0.0519166961,
0.4474204481,
-0.4355845451,
-0.2496583462,
-0.054253269,
0.1730825901,
0.1255167574,
0.4755310714,
0.5941520333,
-0.0800294504,
-0.9273655415,
0.2400664091,
-0.0592340641,
-0.3933191001,
-0.4945145845,
0.0307887513,
0.0548887737,
0.3430453241,
0.7641251087,
-0.07086505,
0.1583557278,
-0.8086158633,
-0.1226997823,
0.3935573995,
-0.6188726425,
0.0482810736,
0.9495081306,
0.1437205523,
-0.7713425159,
0.6306225061,
0.0893402323,
-0.5180664062,
0.6678201556,
0.6732228398,
0.8182550073,
-0.3987773657,
0.0371783264,
-0.0652363896,
0.2176451981,
-0.1397164613,
0.4405301809,
-0.0775846541,
-0.6430299878,
-0.3922760189,
-0.3700387478,
-0.8639315367,
0.0372963585,
-0.671184957,
0.1626587361,
-0.1563699692,
-0.6002930999,
0.1268202215,
0.1174970418,
-0.6400592923,
0.2278700918,
-0.038644515,
0.8051397204,
-0.6431581378,
0.4512307048,
0.7945942879,
-0.2035975605,
0.0237484984,
-0.2656080425,
-0.1181808636,
-0.3058001697,
0.6406404376,
0.0209749956,
0.2641588449,
-0.1689393371,
-0.3244335353,
-0.1704139858,
0.9502305984,
0.3027482331,
-0.2147825658,
-0.2026388794,
0.2035969943,
0.6949521303,
-0.1112673953,
-0.0745766237,
0.602335453,
0.4031836092,
-0.7119187117,
-0.9094101191,
-0.5352948308,
-0.0113817034,
0.4485502243,
0.1655159444,
-0.2809545994,
0.6106206179,
0.1442573369,
-0.2503164411,
-0.1596420854,
0.6316322684,
0.0524803177,
0.6594703794,
0.3742494583,
0.2950669229,
0.8847382665,
-0.0971170589,
1.2077468634,
0.2323156744,
0.509333849,
0.9328289032,
-0.5260180235,
0.7089514732,
0.4311178327,
-0.8288766742,
0.589776814,
0.501067102,
0.0345339887,
0.0091160377,
0.066026032,
-0.2806141376,
0.014538425,
-0.2782843113,
-0.3236502409,
0.5381449461,
0.6213831902,
-0.321207732,
-0.0831949934,
0.1481379569,
-0.3667350113,
0.3923688233,
-0.4506576359,
0.690971911,
0.2139924169,
-0.2114143521,
-0.2711476088,
0.1478625089,
0.8057516217,
-0.6228616238,
-0.4265066981,
0.3102020025,
0.0479994453,
-0.4731293023,
-0.9368569851,
1.0169093609,
0.2554571629,
-0.2003844678,
-0.767501533,
1.1239596605,
-0.2770083249,
-0.1202820539,
0.0658794641,
0.5804082751,
0.0082980078,
-0.0361830816,
-0.7993361354,
-0.2102113962,
-0.1717450619,
-0.3084769249,
0.3201257288,
0.2866749465,
-0.0923119783,
0.7479747534,
0.6240489483,
0.46055758,
0.1194329336,
-0.1468413323,
0.1270550191,
-1.2408269644,
-0.6708079576,
-1.0764833689,
0.2054887563,
-0.4065511823,
-0.3757350743,
0.8193117976,
0.5075323582,
0.6379378438,
0.0350731015,
0.63420403,
-0.2766819,
0.7113686204,
-0.53632164,
0.5502181649,
-0.2401756346,
0.1910703182,
-0.495908767,
-0.8870542049,
-0.6382533908,
0.5150198936,
-0.5097003579,
0.0919005275,
0.6316813827,
0.0677111074,
0.2767255306,
0.1621368676,
0.259182483,
-0.4680662751,
0.2634699643,
-0.0334579311,
0.6489146948,
-0.3323719203,
0.3016912043,
-0.1340304613,
0.1383140385,
-0.2970481515,
-0.8783915639,
-0.3983985782,
-0.7441295385,
-0.4585132003,
-0.4532687366,
-0.1954326034,
0.4786458015,
0.4627965689,
-0.8042510748,
-0.3981622159,
-0.1419755816,
0.3353861868,
-0.454800427,
-0.3451231718,
0.1974395216,
-0.4559022486,
-0.6542697549,
0.2294753492,
0.1973187625,
-0.0247876905,
-0.2654862106,
0.0693224296,
-0.6099073887,
-0.3169682622,
0.7727172375,
0.7869322896,
-0.1642692834,
-0.0736733302,
-0.1866324097,
-0.0293775853,
-0.1936472356,
1.2449479103,
-0.4984705746,
0.3181411326,
0.3970066905,
1.2381337881,
0.42275998,
-0.1514757127,
0.639159441,
-0.8928712606,
0.2208036929,
0.568171382,
0.1680013239,
0.4569866955,
-0.4805016518,
1.0003089905,
0.2858975232,
-0.7433584332,
-1.1345880032,
-0.0002256415,
-0.8783742189,
-0.2296654433,
0.7540962696,
0.5865569711,
0.0515741669,
-0.3808383644,
-0.1764669269,
0.2746988833,
-0.0905580595,
0.7587380409,
0.8540881872,
-0.7176104188,
0.0210748203,
-1.2090132236,
0.7989993691,
0.4684363902,
-1.0918517113,
0.0377960727,
0.1355612576,
-0.3887162507,
0.3004381657,
1.0235264301,
0.0043680593,
-0.0148546658,
-0.141332224,
0.1721075773,
0.3821005523,
-0.0361753069,
-0.5227200389,
0.1355872154,
0.2881575525,
0.0112578487
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07765v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07765v1
|
TANQ: An open domain dataset of table answered questions
| 2024-05-13T14:07:20 | 2024-05-13T14:07:20 |
Mubashara Akhtar, Chenxi Pang, Andreea Marzoca, Yasemin Altun, Julian Martin Eisenschlos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models, potentially augmented with tool usage such as retrieval are
becoming the go-to means of answering questions. Understanding and answering
questions in real-world settings often requires retrieving information from
different sources, processing and aggregating data to extract insights, and
presenting complex findings in form of structured artifacts such as novel
tables, charts, or infographics. In this paper, we introduce TANQ, the first
open domain question answering dataset where the answers require building
tables from information across multiple sources. We release the full source
attribution for every cell in the resulting table and benchmark
state-of-the-art language models in open, oracle, and closed book setups. Our
best-performing baseline, GPT4 reaches an overall F1 score of 29.1, lagging
behind human performance by 19.7 points. We analyse baselines' performance
across different dataset attributes such as different skills required for this
task, including multi-hop reasoning, math operations, and unit conversions. We
further discuss common failures in model-generated answers, suggesting that
TANQ is a complex task with many challenges ahead.
|
[
-0.3961610794,
-0.9167087078,
0.4223242998,
-0.2124864906,
0.0573678091,
-0.0208680537,
0.0933992863,
-0.4174356461,
-0.5845957398,
0.5060896873,
-0.5745182037,
-0.537322998,
-0.2201472521,
-0.0796800852,
-0.3459470868,
0.8867760301,
-0.0091813812,
-0.2132945061,
-0.4217188954,
-0.3280504644,
-0.3197609186,
-0.4650008082,
-0.3984887004,
-0.2201386392,
0.4670809209,
0.6707114577,
0.9738979936,
0.6132937074,
0.5164995193,
0.1960487962,
0.3466933668,
0.1508873552,
-0.4754529297,
0.221771583,
-0.2193082124,
-0.6131973863,
-0.4494797289,
0.047420796,
0.4627431035,
0.7545157671,
-0.1305692941,
0.6538871527,
-0.3413807154,
0.6802842617,
-0.4858824611,
0.152415812,
-0.5636980534,
0.0745551512,
-0.206914559,
-0.0889299214,
-0.3807354271,
-0.7349236012,
0.2029778957,
-0.6061568856,
0.2794689536,
0.1079960838,
0.7884658575,
0.2872460783,
-0.4833869636,
-0.1421334893,
-0.6515238881,
0.5500794053,
-0.4945550859,
0.3487206101,
0.3364965916,
0.7646850348,
0.1168990806,
-0.9038536549,
-0.5769085884,
0.0701291636,
-0.1961656958,
-0.0176830646,
-0.0221352149,
-0.1197637618,
0.2642672658,
0.5577353835,
-0.7226758003,
-0.2798604965,
-0.327399075,
-0.0985161364,
0.3945704401,
0.2339493483,
0.3963433206,
0.0108630871,
-0.318341583,
-0.2414836138,
-0.8376755118,
0.0273086987,
0.0822118148,
0.5412245989,
0.1377994418,
0.7789554,
-0.3454136848,
1.0956071615,
-0.6426713467,
0.2934427559,
-0.0338421278,
-0.6187489629,
-0.2196840793,
-0.42808038,
0.5581942201,
0.2243159562,
0.5187668204,
-0.3460046053,
-0.1723620892,
-0.4042030573,
0.0622570887,
-0.6124683619,
-0.0947144404,
0.5706243515,
-0.1418353021,
-0.0268303547,
0.1760422289,
-0.7911226749,
-0.4333637655,
-0.2360607982,
0.4562696218,
-0.3603618443,
-0.5404146314,
0.0848730132,
-0.0844639614,
0.5659841299,
0.3801488578,
-0.4384989142,
0.6673083901,
0.5509505868,
0.8740382195,
-0.0786516517,
-0.0449753106,
-0.6160840392,
0.0577889718,
-0.2794149816,
0.7150940895,
-0.3428122103,
-0.1608389318,
0.0368487462,
-0.2403251082,
0.0850910917,
-0.5348109007,
0.3634104729,
-0.8610135317,
0.4835422933,
-0.4947458506,
-0.5280387998,
-0.0631616637,
0.3023715615,
-0.9999998212,
1.0002737045,
0.5520135164,
-0.7476363778,
0.1560310125,
-0.9405260086,
-0.1451907158,
0.2503629327,
-0.1040990204,
-0.1388274878,
-0.1091608256,
0.2165004909,
0.3232213259,
-0.8271284103,
0.0031040346,
0.052621305,
-0.2218867242,
0.4751593769,
-0.1709259897,
0.6091447473,
0.4769574702,
0.1152001768,
-0.1717000604,
-0.6673137546,
0.6232511401,
0.2006153017,
-0.2728411257,
-0.1938296854,
-0.296661824,
0.0253292117,
0.3193952143,
0.0615340769,
-0.7112561464,
0.0519518591,
-0.1394699663,
0.2559964359,
0.4434806108,
0.1537368149,
0.1172144786,
-0.4673239887,
0.7264254093,
0.041307196,
-0.1932708025,
-0.0949887112,
-0.4721348584,
-0.3068144023,
0.0559861064,
0.4738720357,
0.4658453465,
-0.8546830416,
-0.3285800517,
-0.4464478791,
-0.5133325458,
-0.7429383397,
-0.236846894,
0.6120246649,
0.7615879774,
0.4277624786,
-0.0121913925,
-0.2065861821,
-0.8413131237,
-0.5353245735,
-0.1865311265,
-0.221068278,
0.5610234737,
0.3918506205,
0.4720534682,
1.208533287,
-0.764189899,
0.0120836915,
-0.0952581167,
0.3093839884,
0.2229681164,
0.1520332992,
0.4205312729,
-0.9420330524,
-0.5074440837,
0.2818002403,
-0.7192063332,
-0.0634459406,
0.2341516912,
-0.2786635756,
-0.0890558437,
0.2660864294,
-0.5017172098,
0.2369758636,
0.1124072745,
-0.376793623,
0.6657601595,
0.1655084789,
0.4427695274,
-0.8757903576,
0.5606539249,
-0.1037457064,
-0.330948323,
-0.8495517373,
0.312017262,
0.0074218605,
-0.2581186891,
-0.5843616724,
0.8753250837,
-0.3796212673,
-0.2746045589,
0.2010219395,
0.3166560531,
0.0521705262,
0.5108180642,
-0.2126633525,
1.2805216312,
0.2389784604,
-0.5719482303,
0.6578301787,
0.5643212199,
-0.5114264488,
0.3382656574,
-0.8159881234,
0.3181478381,
-0.2015336007,
-0.4004271328,
-1.2148468494,
-0.4443193972,
0.0397293083,
-0.5535387993,
0.0400549099,
-0.0954461247,
-0.6010220051,
-0.3519088626,
-0.0312218107,
0.466757983,
0.2022589892,
-0.321760416,
0.3610781431,
0.4355263412,
-0.2982518971,
-1.0664921999,
-0.735478282,
-0.2729700208,
0.130963102,
-0.6710518599,
0.1310635656,
0.1028490439,
-0.4614994824,
0.3595729172,
-0.3727455437,
-0.414353013,
-0.0974326506,
-0.1372675002,
0.089407824,
-0.5765188932,
0.5347910523,
-0.4203782082,
0.075600192,
-0.0674911067,
-0.1289595515,
0.4722020924,
-0.4264495671,
-0.2601082325,
0.0154766999,
0.3958258331,
0.6733660102,
-0.439586252,
0.7651231289,
0.0861419514,
-0.4913180768,
-0.1692252159,
-0.3268834054,
0.0409669168,
-0.3901220858,
0.5473354459,
-0.7662261724,
-0.6223763824,
0.7247642875,
0.020652296,
0.4004626572,
0.3559498191,
0.4785085022,
0.0850982219,
0.5587243438,
0.5372171998,
0.2079133689,
0.1693103313,
-0.0993841365,
0.0742762908,
-0.3553493321,
-0.296002984,
-0.6667963862,
-0.0304666478,
-0.2732332051,
-0.5063376427,
0.3852579296,
-0.177869752,
-0.4824790359,
0.1586662531,
-0.3542641401,
0.7545883656,
0.7309607863,
0.1873240471,
0.615452826,
-0.1505971551,
-0.0287929662,
0.2995759249,
-0.5741097927,
-0.4839715362,
1.2089859247,
0.0842477456,
0.7754621506,
0.3384493887,
0.0580863878,
0.3702347279,
0.4372209013,
-0.532324791,
0.5222373009,
0.0446494222,
-0.8939566016,
-0.7366312742,
-0.6496742964,
-0.7033979893,
0.304361254,
0.0741914958,
-0.4140673876,
-0.2259842455,
0.0404541939,
-0.3439024091,
0.2119099945,
-0.8542408347,
1.1628215313,
-0.0983756781,
-0.4475867748,
0.3763141036,
-0.8368494511,
0.6101393104,
0.032986261,
0.1185285971,
-0.2697141469,
-0.1788795143,
0.59964782,
-0.4667623937,
0.226206407,
-0.3790631294,
0.0684234053,
0.5098632574,
0.0863124579,
0.0540162176,
-0.0876798257,
-0.5297908783,
-0.3820194006,
0.4863879681,
-0.4818441272,
-0.8989550471,
0.4300466478,
-1.0084838867,
-0.460819155,
-0.4179691374,
-0.5075577497,
-0.6420437098,
0.1679073423,
0.0550663434,
0.5731812716,
-0.3608061075,
0.1661499143,
0.5597973466,
-0.1981364489,
0.158959806,
0.3276554644,
-0.2668714225,
-0.2237027586,
0.758784771,
0.0327833742,
0.5262490511,
0.4516696036,
-0.0024366463,
-0.5839745402,
-0.2989397943,
-0.4803251028,
0.2637621462,
-0.9424821734,
-0.5635014176,
-0.4035312533,
-0.5310810208,
-0.1810336709,
0.3619126379,
-0.1720097065,
-0.7155041695,
0.1417832524,
-0.2272831202,
0.3751100004,
0.6283149123,
0.3096680343,
0.2328384072,
-0.8045640588,
0.5334385633,
0.5121959448,
0.7710117102,
-0.0179094523,
-0.1738569736,
-0.2303045541,
0.2102231681,
-0.064670369,
-0.8631884456,
0.1575667113,
0.4612333179,
0.5949850678,
-0.200868085,
0.3742761016,
0.5107759237,
-0.3405864239,
0.7187860012,
-0.104899697,
-0.6618787646,
0.4544729292,
-0.3070400953,
0.5500734448,
0.6749774814,
0.612552762,
-0.8202447891,
-0.1287074834,
-0.312110275,
-0.6715826988,
0.9966645241,
0.2453959286,
-0.2251214385,
0.2597402632,
0.460917443,
0.4047162533,
0.4911131561,
-0.7961381674,
-0.3424396217,
-0.2289358675,
-0.2967079878,
0.1482809782,
0.0320334285,
-0.2502244413,
-0.0755996183,
0.5479497313,
-0.1626164466,
0.3746342957,
0.0102441041,
-0.2656995058,
-0.3164434135,
0.4035126269,
0.1239461824,
0.8893900514,
-0.3248959482,
-0.0270017479,
-0.3301202357,
-0.4185888767,
0.1257546693,
0.0804805532,
0.0268972497,
-0.1792352498,
0.1129435003,
0.5215280652,
-0.3471062481,
-0.8386404514,
0.5354059935,
-0.261339128,
-0.0958486199,
-0.0404950716,
0.1699927151,
-0.0326754749,
-0.1571827233,
0.5263670087,
-0.275159657,
-0.0293402299,
-0.7515060902,
0.500939846,
0.310859859,
-0.212086916,
-0.1795546114,
0.7771573663,
0.1081801429,
-0.233423546,
0.874745667,
0.2579165101,
-0.1747539341,
0.5753389597,
0.3007400036,
0.5090743899,
-0.1703865528,
0.5097519159,
0.4158758819,
0.1261353493,
0.1801533699,
0.7481049895,
-0.0537900329,
-0.7391484976,
-0.3886893094,
-0.5491028428,
-0.8264949322,
0.2490748614,
-0.5849770904,
0.145239532,
-0.2938564718,
-0.0157851093,
0.1093741655,
0.025585847,
-0.8336052895,
0.3511489034,
-0.1675978452,
1.0724266768,
-0.7690601349,
0.603495121,
0.7299097776,
-0.715028882,
-0.5958481431,
-0.0645299479,
-0.1566116363,
-0.7741059065,
0.298861742,
0.0605275966,
-0.1259832829,
0.3604155481,
-0.7672556639,
-0.890806973,
1.0292140245,
0.4550881386,
0.2062796652,
-0.1356808394,
0.685926199,
0.5516869426,
-0.2293804288,
0.4283877909,
0.7545633316,
0.3714763522,
0.3361672163,
-0.7910709977,
0.1391062438,
-0.3909558356,
-0.2554446459,
0.2147960514,
-0.4869854152,
0.8653838038,
-0.2656656802,
-0.3999765217,
0.2216978967,
0.4802705348,
0.0887423456,
0.1157177091,
0.2216634601,
0.2953915894,
0.973110795,
-0.4037976861,
0.9840512872,
-0.1179881617,
0.0719109923,
1.2622653246,
-0.147605449,
0.8207135201,
0.1661690623,
-0.3919288814,
0.3280590773,
0.6214791536,
0.3034850061,
0.6296651959,
0.3463375568,
-0.2703418434,
-0.103681393,
-0.1026463807,
-0.5205402374,
0.3167774379,
0.4486765563,
0.1018457189,
-0.4378361404,
-0.0842494741,
-0.4044138491,
0.1935403943,
-0.2225036025,
0.6794369817,
-0.0959397182,
-0.7663561702,
0.4827003181,
-0.1505550742,
-0.1373618841,
-0.6032291055,
-0.1566634327,
-0.4408395886,
-0.109463051,
-0.0615722798,
-1.2536945343,
0.2713625431,
0.0337822624,
-0.0398999415,
-0.11350362,
0.3769808412,
-0.5430393815,
-0.1242088601,
-0.2305244058,
1.2057067156,
0.1552676708,
-0.1719981432,
-0.3787503839,
-0.4539403915,
-0.2748520374,
-0.3081763387,
0.0754612982,
0.8270750046,
0.0318122804,
0.8759592175,
0.3995379806,
-0.1700102687,
0.3546820879,
-0.0122744739,
0.8548766375,
-0.7588068247,
-0.3113224804,
-0.4269194603,
0.67206949,
-0.2656199634,
-0.4165769219,
0.3648149371,
0.6059420109,
0.7189277411,
-0.1985815465,
0.9268137217,
-0.1867853552,
0.8999435902,
-0.3101893067,
0.6524918675,
-0.7049670219,
0.1094417572,
-0.1232733577,
-0.776144743,
-0.4844369292,
0.1548649967,
-0.1567307115,
0.0217936188,
0.6530889273,
0.5864600539,
-0.0208581109,
0.2385098189,
0.3743042946,
0.1836730391,
0.3383975029,
0.6086434126,
0.8532454967,
-0.4664723277,
0.8790977597,
-0.0487153381,
-0.1799343973,
0.0658250973,
-0.5775339007,
-0.5600680113,
-0.8178166151,
-0.1398232132,
-0.1889463663,
0.0863993168,
0.6378566027,
0.426474005,
-0.9480232596,
-0.2992320955,
0.0412508249,
0.3022395968,
-0.2746924758,
-0.2608893812,
0.4558415115,
-0.2719116509,
-0.5188602209,
0.0116602378,
-0.0699114352,
-0.0121905115,
0.066273883,
0.2495501339,
-0.3774390221,
-0.0251263138,
0.2768685818,
0.6692199111,
-0.49978441,
-0.330221951,
0.3046160638,
-0.2221974134,
0.3512917459,
0.7735740542,
-0.8743004203,
0.5049359202,
0.4987467825,
0.8683615327,
0.4898963571,
0.4403676093,
0.8616680503,
-1.0985506773,
-0.2283264101,
0.5254259109,
0.045343481,
0.343570739,
-0.2062856853,
0.9113581181,
-0.143260777,
-0.4812296629,
-0.8968114853,
0.2950253785,
-0.7474142909,
-0.2755361795,
0.7967495918,
-0.1338443011,
-0.2346394062,
-0.4194971025,
-0.0647067651,
0.1971725971,
-0.1561361551,
0.4757805765,
0.9027432799,
-0.290386945,
-0.3911385536,
-0.6896092892,
0.5961422324,
-0.0067995903,
-1.0340133905,
0.5517736673,
0.6104513407,
0.1480578184,
0.0493989736,
0.8271679878,
-0.3245539367,
0.4734333158,
0.0223254953,
-0.0760261938,
-0.2698634267,
-0.2974023819,
0.0480678976,
0.7312421203,
0.2486738861,
-0.3187197745
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07764v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07764v1
|
LGDE: Local Graph-based Dictionary Expansion
| 2024-05-13T14:07:15 | 2024-05-13T14:07:15 |
Dominik J. Schindler, Sneha Jha, Xixuan Zhang, Kilian Buehling, Annett Heft, Mauricio Barahona
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI, physics.soc-ph
|
Expanding a dictionary of pre-selected keywords is crucial for tasks in
information retrieval, such as database query and online data collection. Here
we propose Local Graph-based Dictionary Expansion (LGDE), a method that uses
tools from manifold learning and network science for the data-driven discovery
of keywords starting from a seed dictionary. At the heart of LGDE lies the
creation of a word similarity graph derived from word embeddings and the
application of local community detection based on graph diffusion to discover
semantic neighbourhoods of pre-defined seed keywords. The diffusion in the
local graph manifold allows the exploration of the complex nonlinear geometry
of word embeddings and can capture word similarities based on paths of semantic
association. We validate our method on a corpus of hate speech-related posts
from Reddit and Gab and show that LGDE enriches the list of keywords and
achieves significantly better performance than threshold methods based on
direct word similarities. We further demonstrate the potential of our method
through a real-world use case from communication science, where LGDE is
evaluated quantitatively on data collected and analysed by domain experts by
expanding a conspiracy-related dictionary.
|
[
-0.5797719955,
-1.1007401943,
0.4723082483,
-0.4071959853,
-0.2873013318,
0.4452493489,
-0.2682416439,
-0.2689847052,
0.7609274387,
0.3743779361,
-0.3086020947,
-0.8246226311,
-1.0041148663,
-0.1121495739,
-0.5653845072,
0.6190302968,
-0.0791515335,
-0.2632765472,
-0.112500295,
-0.2182038873,
-0.0477010049,
-0.4756410122,
-0.6757110357,
0.1893559992,
0.8184174895,
0.0682210997,
0.4873407781,
0.7391129732,
0.5642105341,
0.2645493746,
-0.3354253471,
0.3630877435,
-0.8424105644,
0.0910594538,
-0.1990662366,
-0.2239865512,
-0.339514643,
-0.0893429965,
0.4752497375,
0.9192957282,
-0.1721971333,
-0.0028737613,
0.1365166157,
0.5165527463,
-0.6807360053,
0.2804788649,
-0.6128976941,
-0.0422731191,
-0.4641931057,
-0.0090570562,
0.2415492088,
-0.5640838742,
0.0693409815,
-0.5623604655,
0.4065049291,
-0.3956036568,
0.395819962,
-0.1022441536,
-0.4676577151,
-0.5667586327,
-0.2258311063,
0.3685351014,
-0.4067973197,
0.672659874,
0.1121235192,
0.1364063025,
-0.5141875148,
-1.0627788305,
-0.6155720353,
0.1968894303,
0.1122866422,
-0.0379815027,
-0.1308597922,
0.4341652691,
0.06545268,
0.3280088603,
-0.3982516527,
0.0121000754,
-0.708666563,
-0.2945449948,
0.3227554262,
-0.2054554522,
0.2305063307,
-0.1846247017,
0.0062345248,
0.0125538912,
-0.7434487939,
-0.1759576052,
0.4351607263,
0.7099198103,
0.0439001359,
0.5067158937,
-0.3152149916,
0.8796269298,
-0.0889388323,
0.1380721182,
0.4879877269,
-0.2340697944,
-0.1279769242,
0.0474279821,
0.514760077,
0.4916578233,
0.1345761269,
-0.5123071671,
0.3284003139,
0.2657357752,
-0.0446566381,
-0.8377220035,
-0.1949084401,
0.0604579225,
-0.5721305013,
-0.5306584239,
-0.1846919954,
-0.9457015395,
-0.8883239031,
0.1521995366,
0.3134133518,
-0.2278933227,
-0.5348899961,
-0.0030700518,
-0.3536450863,
-0.2685061991,
0.018147679,
-0.2885783613,
0.2160505056,
0.8619047999,
1.1685572863,
-0.2810824513,
0.07953123,
-0.5783455968,
0.0009384846,
-0.4150881767,
0.6721461415,
-0.7564082146,
-0.6376796365,
0.1802283973,
0.1948790848,
0.285163939,
-0.6949957609,
0.525870204,
-0.6585186124,
-0.0056980308,
-0.4290036261,
-0.7691244483,
-0.2454430908,
0.0382805578,
-0.5940691829,
0.9013953805,
0.2569439709,
-0.9708429575,
0.5367073417,
-0.7152999043,
-0.3286134005,
0.1358256936,
-0.3403200507,
0.0646337941,
0.2004380673,
0.1262034476,
0.5959275961,
0.0218601841,
-0.042436596,
-0.6413450837,
-0.1767510325,
-0.5069909096,
0.0402894989,
0.5678560138,
0.3458322883,
0.0000203791,
0.026132267,
-0.5989681482,
-0.1380375624,
-0.0323670395,
-0.1319296807,
-0.7934690118,
0.3340288699,
-0.6019215584,
-0.0944797844,
0.2043073624,
-0.8917503953,
0.3782757223,
-0.7810850739,
0.3071571887,
0.8053418398,
0.2311185449,
0.529612124,
-0.104976289,
0.3791892827,
0.216641143,
-0.2070110291,
0.1258826256,
-0.7213307023,
-0.3207089901,
-0.3129150867,
0.1725261956,
0.2577067316,
-0.7343185544,
0.3943420351,
-0.6255503893,
-0.5121327043,
-0.5657060146,
0.3386619091,
-0.2847839892,
0.552113831,
0.0882731453,
-0.5343201756,
-0.4289488494,
-0.665886879,
-0.4575808644,
0.1791870892,
-0.0310178548,
0.4614070058,
0.0440641753,
-0.3909752667,
1.2054959536,
-0.6218266487,
-0.5264018178,
0.0127333533,
0.1420070529,
0.4845667183,
-0.0563287511,
0.3619365394,
-0.5424963832,
-0.6073710322,
0.2382238805,
-0.4018131196,
-0.1492666006,
0.4064101875,
0.0396634042,
-0.3947906494,
0.628796041,
-0.1252088696,
0.4647209048,
0.5065523982,
-0.2977795005,
-0.0098103713,
-0.1020260528,
0.1297931075,
-1.4152809381,
-0.4408266544,
-0.1335371137,
-0.2939745188,
-0.5655673742,
0.4311088324,
-0.2626252472,
-0.0803654641,
-0.282030791,
0.5835199356,
-0.4246782064,
0.0340222903,
-0.3815947771,
0.8112899661,
-0.6666109562,
0.0680308864,
-0.1352813989,
0.7160588503,
0.8440530896,
-0.5511735678,
0.7318053246,
-0.1566265821,
-0.5624588132,
0.0957106277,
-0.2138360292,
0.251396358,
-0.4976057112,
0.214970991,
-0.9406909347,
0.1161180362,
0.085633792,
-0.3970775306,
-0.0171052925,
-0.2948709428,
-0.4209767282,
-0.4836841524,
-0.1481263489,
0.5746808052,
0.353867054,
-0.7181004286,
0.6065528393,
0.6102080941,
-0.1394744515,
-0.3247072995,
-0.0709795952,
0.0682498887,
-0.2819591165,
-0.6809732318,
0.1507934332,
0.2019212693,
-0.486666441,
0.1946157068,
0.1091548875,
0.0868117958,
-0.0494222939,
0.2894402146,
-0.6271563172,
0.0466172993,
0.1734490544,
0.0351516493,
0.4334872961,
-0.0401764289,
-0.5693500638,
0.8520807028,
0.146262005,
0.0466383658,
0.3127055168,
0.444429189,
0.1124978885,
0.0482169725,
0.4180983901,
0.5818215013,
-0.3606647849,
-0.3041215837,
-0.1839757413,
-0.2779591382,
-0.4954152107,
0.6393526793,
-0.3267337382,
-1.1691150665,
0.5969052315,
-0.6186004281,
-0.2015358508,
0.5163803697,
0.4867836535,
-0.0246189088,
0.7677168846,
0.6787493825,
-0.415299803,
0.4693813622,
-0.4093066752,
0.3606726229,
-0.8060189486,
0.2993901074,
-0.254640311,
-0.5262972116,
-0.9101122618,
-0.9956096411,
0.3396886289,
0.0632748976,
0.0047346484,
0.2481455952,
-0.6340578794,
0.4601687491,
0.3018537462,
0.0160189494,
-0.1289262325,
0.36019063,
-0.380957514,
-0.1009554192,
-0.5466340184,
0.2002723962,
1.3622121811,
0.2465928942,
0.4931732416,
0.2178931087,
1.1571737528,
0.7148700356,
0.3940263391,
-0.6994873285,
0.5248113275,
-0.2730865479,
-0.3191285431,
-0.1199988127,
-0.4923487604,
-1.1797673702,
-0.0016303654,
0.0733984709,
-0.9992024899,
0.3870242238,
-0.1591663957,
-0.0746323392,
0.5906086564,
-0.4432395399,
0.4113380611,
-0.0213279929,
-0.278188318,
-0.491122067,
-0.1130921692,
0.2315990478,
-0.2265066952,
0.6484506726,
0.1449466348,
-0.0266222078,
1.1403483152,
-0.4211131334,
0.8064185381,
-0.3454088271,
-0.6097634435,
0.3063816428,
0.1729407609,
0.7639114261,
-0.2275120467,
0.0264592487,
0.3738486767,
-0.0775117725,
-0.1762751043,
-0.7964552641,
1.1859571934,
-0.4971008301,
-0.6850304008,
-0.1608086824,
-0.2671108246,
-0.2346843034,
0.5114890337,
0.0536692478,
0.3151994944,
0.0134054311,
0.1445934772,
0.3760572672,
-0.0383740626,
0.1197702438,
0.2135225832,
-0.5839217901,
-0.6452149749,
1.2259969711,
0.3196080923,
0.1451676488,
0.1045712382,
0.285807848,
-0.2258547246,
-0.3081021607,
0.1698042452,
0.235707745,
-0.7576134205,
-0.0469658785,
-0.4728035033,
-0.0393879972,
-0.6979221702,
-0.1895888001,
0.0534355752,
-0.4210239947,
-0.1708753109,
-0.3103655875,
0.5037986636,
0.7960440516,
-0.3312211633,
0.5477288961,
-0.3425527811,
0.406027168,
-0.0397428758,
0.6427358985,
-0.1736313105,
-0.1923028529,
-0.2507710457,
0.1100516245,
-0.1141204089,
-1.2501162291,
0.5477917194,
0.195208177,
0.2597776055,
0.8852679729,
0.0003620046,
0.6598342657,
-0.4782664478,
0.828938663,
0.0602929257,
-0.3412071466,
0.3730397522,
-0.331554085,
-0.290632993,
0.1988205314,
0.5586847663,
-0.7091696858,
-0.3863326013,
-0.8748081923,
-0.8745412827,
-0.0470033586,
-0.0919193849,
0.1872363389,
-0.4348569512,
0.6496062279,
-0.1385298222,
0.0447064377,
-0.1823792309,
-0.5374032855,
-0.018185176,
-0.1148963049,
-0.2516873181,
-0.0024432275,
-0.2981301546,
-0.4010464549,
0.3909193873,
-0.3967048824,
0.4704639614,
0.2706088424,
0.1149690822,
0.2066376954,
-0.0513742976,
0.3539273739,
0.2272488624,
-0.3863907456,
0.3146073818,
0.1333446056,
-0.5015343428,
-0.1572445482,
-0.0719103441,
0.0816074386,
0.1276848465,
0.2049576342,
0.5075160265,
-0.2715023458,
-0.4312909544,
0.611890316,
0.111053519,
-0.2019616365,
0.0367215313,
0.0083823111,
0.0547574162,
0.181355074,
0.300175935,
-0.23193717,
0.2989064157,
-0.6834078431,
0.6331445575,
0.8144016862,
-0.4616436958,
-0.1417289376,
0.4393480718,
0.2695969343,
-0.3377769887,
0.1055194438,
-0.4294520319,
-0.6909401417,
0.4532636106,
0.3913829327,
0.8453406096,
0.1619324535,
0.1153442562,
0.477327466,
0.2720460296,
0.56729877,
0.5240787268,
-0.3484545648,
-0.976241231,
-0.2633341551,
-0.5920993686,
0.2743427455,
0.1390275806,
-0.1840561777,
0.2084904164,
-0.5779543519,
-0.3005415499,
-0.4138119817,
0.3967538774,
-0.5017870665,
0.0848208293,
0.0395248719,
1.2871032953,
-0.6003792286,
0.80391258,
0.2814959586,
-0.0787961185,
-0.5858979225,
0.0160510279,
0.0091586439,
-0.9728224277,
0.8654655814,
-0.2700121999,
0.1097615808,
0.2985879481,
-0.2522860467,
-1.1208859682,
0.9791474342,
-0.2370934635,
-0.5886548758,
-0.0050651697,
0.1014599279,
0.4224247932,
-0.4010168016,
0.185485661,
0.3568443656,
0.3038367033,
-0.0080659045,
-0.6211768389,
0.0788802058,
0.0768174306,
-0.1964472383,
0.5194967389,
-0.2790438235,
0.7167839408,
0.0160969365,
-0.4229251146,
-0.2697412968,
1.1112804413,
-0.4777336121,
-0.0680998191,
0.5580173135,
0.6857643723,
1.1132400036,
0.0148547636,
0.9312158227,
-0.4664195776,
0.5381812453,
1.0187183619,
-0.1521435976,
0.8094383478,
0.3897566497,
-0.1433877349,
0.5846728086,
0.6739230156,
0.1447428018,
0.7050327063,
0.5069380403,
-0.499322772,
0.0743662342,
-0.1409081668,
-0.3856829107,
0.0347034819,
0.7183870673,
-0.565132618,
-0.763304472,
0.0048171072,
-0.1554486006,
0.052627068,
-0.4330818653,
0.8257097602,
-0.2500590682,
-0.0419797599,
0.5522866249,
0.0868166015,
0.8985657096,
-0.4027842879,
0.1029951945,
-0.383885026,
0.1381828338,
-0.1352889091,
-0.6151435375,
0.2090123147,
-0.363951385,
0.1238318384,
0.1555411667,
0.6802605987,
-0.4716136158,
-0.4280236959,
0.4945037067,
0.2066312432,
0.1670762002,
0.0501233153,
-0.3967410624,
-0.0983757153,
-0.0518848486,
0.3291954696,
0.2758489251,
0.3989216685,
-0.2634781599,
0.4787161648,
0.7383487225,
0.8861687779,
0.386059165,
0.0321777686,
0.8954009414,
-0.2440059036,
-0.418328613,
-0.5969495177,
-0.3214477003,
-0.4429579377,
0.0402435958,
0.8667489886,
0.8954725862,
1.0001450777,
0.3394846022,
1.1350705624,
-0.2364748865,
0.8229756355,
-0.1576183587,
0.8130256534,
-0.5958685279,
-0.006929283,
-0.394916445,
-0.7298608422,
-0.3595363796,
0.6250049472,
-0.3935664892,
-0.1418940574,
0.5193943977,
1.1407587528,
-0.2482721955,
-0.3752832711,
0.3429254293,
0.5510650873,
0.7037941217,
0.149115324,
0.3555708528,
-0.2321369648,
0.0946457982,
-0.0836985409,
-0.4649683237,
0.1272120178,
-0.9225968719,
-0.7145565152,
-0.8253165483,
-0.2009324878,
-0.4939654469,
0.0791063607,
0.7818363905,
0.3740580678,
-0.5660612583,
-0.0929094255,
-0.2624699473,
0.4212530851,
-0.134193629,
-0.3197955787,
0.4521613717,
-0.2337356806,
-0.7204444408,
0.5999777913,
0.1235082597,
-0.3325076997,
-0.2429037243,
-0.1052259281,
-0.2226638496,
0.3165946007,
0.519575417,
0.3848124146,
-0.5793352723,
-0.5121657252,
-0.2602221072,
0.289783597,
-0.2285865992,
0.9070478082,
-1.1419166327,
0.6586139202,
0.7164304256,
0.7317095399,
0.2403685004,
-0.0392518044,
0.5550075173,
-0.9653573632,
0.1468013823,
-0.1459901035,
0.3364039958,
-0.0738882348,
-0.2688160241,
0.3713855743,
0.6379782557,
-0.2638295293,
-0.7653778195,
0.3810263276,
-0.6554049253,
-0.3311978579,
1.2451196909,
0.1802106947,
-0.4054815471,
0.0465288311,
-0.2119590044,
0.1377698779,
-0.1323287636,
0.8073494434,
0.6523059607,
0.1507342607,
-0.0889104381,
-0.1026426181,
0.8679301739,
-0.1745090932,
-0.4183659554,
0.2375945896,
0.4178698957,
0.427115649,
0.3731427789,
0.6713835001,
0.1870115101,
-0.1190440729,
-0.299352318,
-0.212136209,
0.0247661695,
-0.0908806697,
-0.1378912181,
0.5303977728,
-0.3893243968,
-0.1861307919
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07745v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07745v1
|
LlamaTurk: Adapting Open-Source Generative Large Language Models for Low-Resource Language
| 2024-05-13T13:41:59 | 2024-05-13T13:41:59 |
Cagri Toraman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite advancements in English-dominant generative large language models,
further development is needed for low-resource languages to enhance global
accessibility. The primary methods for representing these languages are
monolingual and multilingual pretraining. Monolingual pretraining is expensive
due to hardware requirements, and multilingual models often have uneven
performance across languages. This study explores an alternative solution by
adapting large language models, primarily trained on English, to low-resource
languages. We assess various strategies, including continual training,
instruction fine-tuning, task-specific fine-tuning, and vocabulary extension.
The results show that continual training improves language comprehension, as
reflected in perplexity scores, and task-specific tuning generally enhances
performance of downstream tasks. However, extending the vocabulary shows no
substantial benefits. Additionally, while larger models improve task
performance with few-shot tuning, multilingual models perform worse than their
monolingual counterparts when adapted.
|
[
-0.16432634,
-0.5116919279,
0.3564352691,
0.3325795531,
-0.4829908013,
0.1547652036,
-0.7933652401,
-0.3413075209,
0.1049340442,
0.3994986117,
-0.5306552052,
-0.2625971437,
-0.5330989361,
0.3715054393,
-0.0144008258,
0.9145514369,
-0.1993579566,
-0.0390640832,
0.0214003585,
-0.3173041344,
-0.4913147092,
-0.5058285594,
-0.7736726999,
-0.1996267438,
0.6006731987,
0.6249752641,
0.5403632522,
0.5971282721,
0.3110295236,
0.3207511306,
0.0243812222,
-0.0057395529,
-0.7429198623,
0.1284802705,
-0.2543002367,
-0.6085401773,
-0.2708801627,
-0.1740501672,
0.9059591293,
0.8327111602,
-0.1823704839,
0.3191743791,
0.4330295622,
0.5602268577,
-0.8299655914,
-0.0342048407,
-0.7742308378,
0.1101793051,
-0.3085980415,
-0.1121947914,
-0.2749334872,
0.023976624,
-0.1562441289,
-0.8667138219,
0.0845379233,
-0.1540783495,
0.4960197806,
0.555434525,
-0.0856942087,
-0.291269213,
-0.8973913789,
1.0100506544,
-0.6610270739,
0.4830639064,
0.3968779445,
0.1507063359,
0.1184361875,
-0.514519155,
-0.4412650764,
-0.6087588668,
0.004795671,
0.2273836136,
-0.186388135,
0.1574783027,
0.2798314095,
0.3070617318,
-0.431999445,
0.5684071183,
-0.282771349,
0.0413111709,
0.4322520196,
0.1193851829,
0.0923874304,
0.0753432065,
-0.1116196141,
0.1080932468,
-0.7524591088,
0.0881553963,
0.438865155,
0.5347282887,
-0.3662675023,
0.531201303,
-0.2168026567,
0.7735872865,
-0.1396184564,
-0.354065299,
-0.0274342652,
-0.4966946542,
-0.1871172935,
-0.0579411611,
0.3789842427,
-0.2647596896,
0.2820130885,
-0.2512426376,
-0.0666898638,
-0.0575008467,
0.1958360672,
-0.7108147144,
-0.1002364308,
-0.0613513291,
-0.4392823279,
-0.0812155828,
-0.4281243384,
-0.7393369079,
-0.3528629541,
-0.2404878736,
0.2952622175,
-0.3519127965,
-0.2599769235,
0.2042984515,
0.224899292,
0.0063116476,
0.433779031,
-1.0952183008,
0.2012954652,
0.4822691679,
1.099738121,
-0.089254804,
-0.5470975041,
-0.6301597953,
0.082105808,
-0.372836411,
0.7558245063,
-0.6162397861,
-0.4198131859,
0.0280865543,
0.1688641161,
-0.0567977987,
-0.5231547356,
0.4691428542,
-0.2743633091,
-0.0811681002,
-0.2763522863,
-0.047207512,
0.1000604481,
0.1307304949,
-0.7258967757,
0.8403500915,
0.2873071134,
-0.6822404265,
0.2537974119,
-1.0076658726,
-0.49997136,
0.148695901,
0.2181129754,
0.0877018273,
0.4052484035,
0.1883653104,
0.2556001842,
-0.3458658457,
-0.2860151529,
-0.2198204249,
-0.4073386788,
-0.0710226968,
-0.5887074471,
0.6721375585,
0.2837775946,
-0.0832799003,
0.069911696,
-0.8654276133,
-0.2159835994,
0.1570455581,
-0.8643392324,
-0.4265416563,
0.0156977959,
-0.0062419046,
0.0831739232,
0.3459358513,
-0.2853294909,
0.2636939585,
-0.5341975093,
0.3372316062,
0.9574117661,
-0.2950492799,
0.5882559419,
-0.0742459744,
0.9552031159,
-0.0934385806,
-0.0047366438,
-0.1909540296,
-0.0781205669,
-1.1800743341,
-0.3732462823,
0.3712605834,
0.5907305479,
-1.0512773991,
0.0136064952,
-0.4627197385,
-0.2976500392,
-0.8033487201,
0.5786443949,
0.241159901,
0.2479148656,
0.2382693589,
-0.2920911312,
-0.599917829,
-0.8887345195,
-0.2142269313,
-0.1441939175,
-0.1573989093,
0.1242501885,
0.4578184187,
-0.0538949296,
0.2432493567,
-0.2936649919,
-0.0785413235,
-0.3113693893,
-0.1469789445,
0.2660944462,
0.3476872444,
0.6238623261,
-0.347841233,
-0.6372964382,
0.3439611197,
-0.4919912219,
0.0766964406,
0.0098351249,
-0.0888437629,
0.2662138045,
0.5006687045,
-0.3537923098,
0.028155297,
0.9319494367,
-0.0178480763,
0.5575327873,
-0.3228973746,
-0.0677085593,
-1.1645876169,
0.1300098747,
-0.1359871775,
-0.2203487754,
-0.5869182348,
0.3071051538,
-0.3550850749,
-0.3294638097,
-0.4246176779,
0.6337614655,
-0.4874765873,
0.0150581105,
-0.4139103591,
0.041057732,
-0.3562067151,
0.2044555694,
0.0011464203,
1.2456123829,
0.5032413602,
-0.5244117975,
0.3590679169,
0.0071864929,
-0.5412471294,
0.514059782,
-0.517332375,
0.3043646514,
-0.228727296,
-0.0557870306,
-0.7223383188,
-0.3056708574,
0.0567591786,
-0.0137113063,
0.2936493456,
-0.3483532965,
-0.3514797688,
-0.2258521318,
-0.1821637452,
0.3921117485,
0.5080765486,
-0.7490276098,
0.5788608789,
0.1504832655,
-0.4896167815,
-0.6494097114,
-0.5919789076,
0.0772010088,
-0.1307797283,
-0.4212623239,
0.1333101243,
-0.1481027305,
-0.2931735218,
-0.0629769117,
-0.0244198833,
-0.046430029,
0.3288286626,
0.0542307347,
-0.1024179086,
-0.5753554702,
0.2973258495,
-0.0307953227,
-0.1053830162,
-0.381272316,
-0.4848357141,
0.5955588818,
-0.0829844028,
-0.2490071952,
-0.1229201406,
0.4432571828,
0.4495007098,
-0.2740973234,
0.8754733801,
0.546356678,
-0.2502190471,
-0.417696774,
-0.3986871243,
-0.03957,
-0.4989144802,
0.7104649544,
-0.5458465815,
-1.145056963,
0.3037678897,
-0.3051162958,
0.1077066064,
0.2546518743,
0.7961662412,
-0.1693840921,
0.6691419482,
1.1434108019,
-0.2766282558,
0.6376743913,
0.0281098541,
0.0982715189,
-0.6654828191,
0.3350836933,
-0.6604606509,
-0.3246126175,
-0.7449287176,
-0.4244687855,
0.3087466359,
0.2840623856,
-0.1545286328,
0.2159380764,
-0.1794181168,
0.5118926764,
0.4203915,
-0.0959021524,
0.3780952096,
0.4253284037,
-0.0311526302,
0.0334146321,
-0.943316102,
-0.4594801068,
1.151460886,
0.2697359025,
0.8377001286,
0.1873988807,
0.5026273131,
0.004538402,
0.4914596677,
-0.6850704551,
0.275529623,
-0.6490963697,
-0.4365169406,
-0.3786592185,
-0.4051502943,
-0.9577544332,
0.3049716353,
-0.3124438226,
-0.6215409636,
-0.0878924504,
0.3432265818,
-0.3726401627,
0.2222690284,
-0.7798061371,
0.8590761423,
-0.4028074443,
-0.3626901209,
-0.5943318605,
0.0618430749,
0.2492046952,
-0.411973387,
0.4741457403,
0.0405976139,
-0.2052778304,
0.7030499578,
-0.0893007815,
0.7842730284,
-0.1494069397,
-0.2545205355,
0.0264962558,
-0.0386662334,
0.5393548608,
0.0517939515,
-0.2536596954,
0.1744658053,
-0.1269531548,
-0.7531607151,
-0.4510854483,
0.8916628957,
-0.969805181,
-0.8351054192,
-0.057945352,
-0.6963685155,
-0.4267103076,
0.1579204053,
0.188618198,
-0.1131088734,
-0.3084617853,
0.1388863325,
0.3290688097,
-0.3917046189,
0.365671128,
0.5097993016,
-0.0057457224,
-0.3792466521,
0.7680937648,
0.1065826714,
0.3644456863,
0.1817629486,
0.1461333781,
0.0223342478,
-0.6375363469,
-0.3456768394,
0.3135878444,
-0.7455495,
0.0877464637,
-0.3371905684,
0.0377526321,
-0.1572169065,
-0.1811760217,
-0.4283377826,
-0.4205255806,
-0.3618742526,
-0.0286812242,
0.2822931409,
0.5794754028,
-0.1513246894,
0.5358355045,
-0.53647995,
0.2958842814,
0.4600459933,
0.5820234418,
0.0846938193,
-0.8709585667,
-0.6728892922,
-0.002719661,
-0.2068181634,
-0.4144531786,
-0.0182721168,
0.4933654666,
0.415228039,
0.0796370208,
-0.2329197228,
0.8223612905,
-0.7586479783,
0.6803011894,
0.3016212285,
-0.8186839819,
0.4389453232,
-0.2081087083,
0.5025066137,
0.5703483224,
0.5405878425,
-0.4964361787,
-0.0163411908,
0.0325723812,
-0.6860838532,
0.6847547293,
-0.0577397868,
0.459446758,
0.2754698992,
0.3914302588,
0.2744058967,
0.0444237888,
-0.8161444664,
0.0962520167,
-0.3681496084,
-0.2215318382,
-0.5485683084,
-0.2678731084,
-0.1028863117,
-0.3410260081,
0.6696550846,
-0.359054029,
0.1732664257,
-0.222600162,
-0.2991432846,
-0.2567520738,
0.5557191968,
0.700452745,
0.6439443827,
0.0994070545,
0.0803610161,
0.5944451094,
-0.5576757193,
0.3876537681,
0.1809202135,
-0.0252700597,
-0.1256065369,
0.5846853852,
1.0331026316,
0.2307069302,
-0.5148227811,
0.0474253781,
0.1511447877,
-0.0016499865,
-0.2698394656,
0.1396731436,
0.3032259047,
0.3253923357,
0.192419678,
-0.1240158528,
-0.298088938,
-0.5115461349,
-0.3023443222,
0.4508360326,
-0.103080444,
-0.4809249938,
0.5611287355,
0.2849897444,
-0.2395428717,
0.3784409761,
-0.0004366004,
-0.2742417455,
0.2083745599,
0.7322999239,
0.7195551991,
-0.392249912,
0.0128760701,
0.4563680291,
0.6268982291,
-0.1421379745,
0.2506503165,
-0.0903243497,
-0.5892663598,
-0.8669260144,
-0.9321511984,
-0.2210128158,
0.4020568728,
-0.3407382369,
0.2619011402,
-0.5562528372,
-0.1647233218,
-0.0353826098,
-0.059632618,
-0.8954771757,
-0.1113735884,
0.1691324562,
1.0137112141,
-0.7674793601,
0.9719944596,
0.9015988708,
-0.387884587,
-0.5550858378,
0.0480557792,
-0.2697024643,
-0.8114464283,
0.6677423716,
-0.1545813978,
-0.22841914,
0.2208772302,
-0.5253899097,
-1.002448678,
0.7801234722,
0.956212759,
-0.7285097241,
-0.1709694564,
0.231319502,
0.5453372002,
-0.143020004,
-0.1947179884,
0.3728216887,
0.3694543839,
-0.3872753084,
-1.0839109421,
-0.0718191788,
-0.0540322326,
0.2988148332,
0.0047381232,
-0.5673052073,
0.7462146878,
-0.0523872152,
-0.373200655,
0.3189766109,
0.5849201083,
-0.0004989044,
-0.2035579383,
0.4657363594,
0.6113224626,
0.6593996882,
0.0868335813,
1.0555371046,
-0.3392752111,
0.2562360764,
0.9797456861,
-0.2633084655,
0.9926760793,
0.5411325693,
-0.4245720506,
0.4659296274,
0.2903824151,
0.204798907,
0.5680808425,
0.1377007365,
-0.4420333803,
-0.4300418496,
-0.2606621683,
-0.2766394317,
0.5964199901,
0.3383081853,
-0.1126131564,
-0.3442058861,
0.355733037,
-0.1066279113,
0.090573512,
-0.570845902,
0.7101635933,
0.201577425,
-0.6401312351,
1.1525990963,
0.1204766259,
0.8564966321,
-0.5880127549,
0.1648728251,
-0.334962517,
0.2423959672,
-0.0978497043,
-0.3628565669,
0.2057460397,
0.302293539,
-0.2763663232,
-0.0672186017,
0.6461490989,
-0.3102474809,
-0.6145030856,
0.3332178295,
0.4673207402,
-0.0391210951,
0.1851751208,
-0.6132286787,
0.2131748348,
-0.125318855,
-0.0672689676,
0.4799911976,
0.3277626336,
0.093332231,
0.6008588076,
0.8336610198,
0.3136641979,
0.029235566,
0.0357497185,
0.7821014524,
-0.4150817692,
-0.5006377101,
-0.7979546785,
0.4144149423,
0.2735108733,
-0.2822159231,
0.5648815036,
0.3154290617,
1.0505386591,
-0.3461090028,
0.9423353672,
0.17471461,
0.3063542247,
-0.7943564057,
0.6243268847,
-0.7593306899,
0.0495540351,
-0.0447596684,
-0.952609241,
-0.135065183,
0.7039132714,
-0.2923078835,
-0.0546117648,
0.5905186534,
0.5611861348,
-0.3077246547,
-0.4070497453,
0.4223403633,
0.43296808,
0.0497468896,
0.6793375015,
0.8189519644,
0.0030300019,
0.5430764556,
-0.1712167561,
-0.2823553681,
-0.1878125221,
-0.8526481986,
-0.8811461926,
-0.56755656,
-0.0259966739,
-0.1837376356,
0.1876171678,
0.9600023627,
0.7352339625,
-0.8009874225,
-0.3871486783,
0.0938379169,
-0.0944367051,
-0.1648892164,
-0.0987576097,
0.0907423571,
-0.5785937309,
-0.5568904877,
0.6038290858,
0.3537811935,
-0.0815341026,
-0.3045300543,
-0.1915137172,
-0.0589642078,
0.0663975552,
0.9033377171,
0.4491367936,
-0.7029544711,
-0.3661659956,
0.0307682566,
0.1329663694,
0.1300516129,
0.8179098368,
-0.5554702878,
0.4508441985,
0.0791917965,
0.840016067,
0.4294390082,
-0.2105346918,
0.4443893135,
-0.8164746761,
0.7259107828,
0.1500513852,
0.3258286715,
0.4448657632,
-0.1685407013,
0.3758376539,
0.1122450158,
-0.267301172,
-0.9019442797,
0.4695409834,
-0.5209587812,
-0.2593430877,
1.1005889177,
-0.1604234725,
-0.1418031752,
-0.056634821,
-0.0882709995,
0.1774055809,
0.0262948163,
0.8001833558,
0.8565835953,
0.1522580683,
-0.4074691832,
-0.7994006276,
0.5035739541,
0.4280768335,
-0.9145151377,
0.1619523019,
0.3056966364,
0.4000797272,
0.1619595587,
0.7419043779,
0.1628723145,
0.2793686688,
0.0115791094,
-0.0835194886,
0.0588378273,
-0.2055287957,
-0.662107408,
0.0273345802,
0.7093716264,
0.0223482866
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07730v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07730v1
|
Does Dependency Locality Predict Non-canonical Word Order in Hindi?
| 2024-05-13T13:24:17 | 2024-05-13T13:24:17 |
Sidharth Ranjan, Marten van Schijndel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Previous work has shown that isolated non-canonical sentences with
Object-before-Subject (OSV) order are initially harder to process than their
canonical counterparts with Subject-before-Object (SOV) order. Although this
difficulty diminishes with appropriate discourse context, the underlying
cognitive factors responsible for alleviating processing challenges in OSV
sentences remain a question. In this work, we test the hypothesis that
dependency length minimization is a significant predictor of non-canonical
(OSV) syntactic choices, especially when controlling for information status
such as givenness and surprisal measures. We extract sentences from the
Hindi-Urdu Treebank corpus (HUTB) that contain clearly-defined subjects and
objects, systematically permute the preverbal constituents of those sentences,
and deploy a classifier to distinguish between original corpus sentences and
artificially generated alternatives. The classifier leverages various
discourse-based and cognitive features, including dependency length, surprisal,
and information status, to inform its predictions. Our results suggest that,
although there exists a preference for minimizing dependency length in
non-canonical corpus sentences amidst the generated variants, this factor does
not significantly contribute in identifying corpus sentences above and beyond
surprisal and givenness measures. Notably, discourse predictability emerges as
the primary determinant of constituent-order preferences. These findings are
further supported by human evaluations involving 44 native Hindi speakers.
Overall, this work sheds light on the role of expectation adaptation in
word-ordering decisions. We conclude by situating our results within the
theories of discourse production and information locality.
|
[
-0.3777626455,
-0.605368793,
0.4768660367,
0.2356767356,
-0.2455569804,
-0.0034361782,
-0.225028947,
-0.673476994,
0.4360454977,
0.2612147927,
-0.2991341949,
-0.1840019673,
-0.8010919094,
0.3699766994,
-0.1556894034,
0.6326131225,
0.0591255613,
-0.1170969754,
-0.3050850332,
-0.0828261375,
-0.6019526124,
-0.5523656607,
0.0212271269,
-0.0375561081,
0.3290750682,
0.5942453146,
0.8993053436,
0.7768225074,
0.3879576027,
0.3304593563,
-0.20772174,
-0.1936663985,
-0.138699621,
0.1595397592,
-0.1200306267,
-0.8390371203,
-0.0463214777,
-0.2792758346,
0.6815983057,
0.806386292,
-0.1765830815,
0.1909162998,
0.1134772524,
0.715927124,
-1.0265154839,
0.1520972699,
-0.5497485995,
0.0132229142,
-0.557079494,
-0.1939116269,
-0.6483210325,
-0.2840729654,
0.230901733,
-0.3551127017,
0.0758374929,
0.1353740245,
1.1640462875,
0.3228942454,
-0.2608692348,
-0.0370818377,
-0.8537771702,
0.7810240984,
-0.408252418,
0.6332831383,
0.5905833244,
0.051471971,
-0.1882009059,
-0.0397792049,
-0.3189345002,
-0.2681207359,
-0.6096842885,
0.2254957408,
-0.0258113611,
0.3148986101,
0.1981876791,
0.3735860288,
-0.5127347708,
0.0999425501,
-0.7595654726,
-0.1033283994,
-0.0002635269,
0.0491547994,
0.254308641,
-0.8023022413,
-0.3547475636,
0.2054096609,
-0.728484869,
0.278861165,
0.2276874036,
0.5027418733,
0.0572337545,
0.6820732951,
-0.4743697345,
0.6383686662,
0.3717726171,
-0.2146089375,
0.1870437264,
-0.5229310989,
-0.1375443339,
0.6677158475,
0.7390395999,
-0.2032138705,
-0.0757267177,
0.1166462451,
0.2661441267,
0.1379692256,
0.1363696307,
-0.5552513599,
-0.0103605231,
-0.1166811511,
-0.4337488711,
0.0030559886,
0.1217160672,
-0.6509094238,
-0.0807356983,
-0.2918378711,
-0.0498307459,
-0.5943123102,
-0.2712601125,
-0.3429070711,
0.3970914781,
0.3884885013,
0.0769330561,
-1.1649287939,
0.393137902,
0.3669240773,
0.9447958469,
-0.2449752092,
-0.3278911412,
-0.424826026,
0.3923786879,
-0.6342142224,
1.0503522158,
-0.7657858133,
-0.4961164594,
-0.2824237347,
-0.2350432724,
-0.0832629204,
-0.4992978275,
0.4135468602,
-0.1746834815,
0.0079710558,
-0.3397625387,
-0.166749239,
-0.1077047065,
-0.3012956381,
-0.2927689254,
0.8666223884,
0.2392337769,
-0.9017059803,
0.6165811419,
-0.269298315,
-0.9091430306,
0.1981640011,
-0.3587200344,
-0.106172666,
0.3109055459,
0.005014,
0.2895995378,
-0.1977052391,
0.4490671456,
-0.1563605517,
-0.2547477484,
-0.0356142335,
0.0018195359,
0.3876187503,
0.1974279135,
-0.2688213885,
0.1576195955,
-0.6121367812,
0.1112765223,
-0.3123255968,
-0.2648774087,
-0.4972442091,
0.0430204533,
-0.1548837572,
0.0253282487,
0.1748438329,
-0.6742479205,
-0.1509118378,
-0.8144748211,
0.1931313276,
1.0877846479,
0.007765166,
0.645399034,
0.0225501489,
0.7081894279,
0.1420779973,
0.4040890336,
0.1890952587,
-0.4051671624,
-0.6630752087,
-0.0615184829,
0.4285078347,
0.5003225803,
-0.5376559496,
0.0985620618,
-0.3342367411,
-0.3409897089,
-0.2119456381,
0.0943734348,
0.7223033309,
0.2896827459,
0.1517949402,
-0.3860127032,
-0.6550710797,
-1.1698067188,
-0.1366299689,
-0.5102728009,
0.3658183217,
0.1053141505,
0.1157272384,
0.1563113481,
1.2830224037,
-0.7108294964,
-0.2873135209,
-0.4252852499,
0.2429793477,
0.0591026731,
0.0386917703,
0.4752371609,
-0.9407573342,
-0.3950237632,
-0.0669213757,
-0.5102537274,
-0.3059310913,
0.1285875291,
-0.2437158674,
0.5122951269,
0.307409972,
-0.6114653945,
0.6496891975,
0.346255511,
-0.1261951476,
0.5935528874,
-0.3424330056,
-0.0415752009,
-1.0972911119,
-0.3132316172,
-0.2097283155,
0.0296734925,
-0.5410990715,
-0.1363958418,
-0.0155519592,
0.2799601257,
-0.5665306449,
0.3067946434,
-0.468459487,
-0.3522827625,
-0.1914675385,
-0.0961146131,
-0.3279744089,
0.4872971475,
0.3204181492,
0.8014426827,
0.3406541944,
-0.8091068864,
-0.4835995436,
0.4324231148,
-0.4584925175,
0.3523246646,
-0.4006513655,
-0.198795408,
-0.1543160826,
-0.0524424277,
-0.9018068314,
-0.2753635645,
0.1560418457,
-0.4709481299,
0.2187059373,
0.0196548868,
-0.7257532477,
0.0354514755,
0.0234952234,
0.3396383524,
0.4287085831,
-0.1293950528,
0.4233425558,
0.3378769457,
-0.2706981301,
-0.4618988931,
-0.8368735909,
-0.1533543915,
-0.0881425887,
-0.179393515,
0.2563891709,
-0.0709140003,
-0.2767239213,
-0.0156479087,
-0.1953616589,
-0.143780604,
-0.1216861308,
0.7076961398,
0.3072836101,
-0.3204892874,
0.143553555,
0.2515078187,
-0.0758288801,
-0.2186431438,
0.0032449679,
0.2469694614,
-0.1104010269,
0.0366199724,
-0.1378785074,
0.145570457,
0.4292055368,
-0.0997119769,
0.7780528665,
0.2097913325,
-0.1676720232,
0.2723436654,
-0.4704342484,
0.0588937216,
-0.4826121032,
0.2148744464,
-0.4311346412,
-0.8052799702,
0.2844527066,
0.1127905995,
-0.4971545637,
0.4346711338,
0.4210197031,
0.3863594532,
0.6091454029,
0.6088279486,
-0.1465893835,
0.607395649,
0.2196799666,
0.5429052114,
-0.7632955313,
0.228617698,
-0.1901369244,
0.1740940213,
-0.8937473893,
-0.1395892948,
0.176029563,
0.2837011218,
0.0453340672,
0.3675158322,
-0.5654550791,
0.7305142283,
0.164911598,
-0.0900735557,
0.1446530372,
-0.179194957,
-0.1758331656,
-0.1615317166,
-0.49797979,
-0.1521335095,
0.7805812359,
-0.2230720818,
0.2758619487,
0.256082803,
0.693125248,
0.1490398198,
0.1591846347,
-0.5364587307,
0.632768631,
-0.2981075644,
-0.3672057688,
-0.167240724,
-0.2894843221,
-1.1830058098,
0.1165271029,
-0.0048991176,
-0.9386056662,
0.3089819551,
-0.2611653805,
-0.6253862381,
-0.0353690311,
-0.9013254642,
0.4782435,
-0.021811245,
-0.3104531467,
0.0724244788,
-0.781884551,
0.4120392799,
0.0071407403,
0.291880548,
-0.0867911652,
0.1071774215,
0.6322289705,
-0.526106596,
0.5778212547,
0.0152217429,
0.3635717928,
0.3876103461,
0.2474059612,
0.0044355076,
-0.0467430875,
0.0654797181,
0.1319090426,
0.0809185579,
-0.4528627694,
-0.4015694857,
0.8589568734,
-0.7847293615,
-0.9365075231,
-0.6267217994,
-0.2791880667,
-0.3098014891,
0.3422552347,
0.5313032269,
0.267365396,
0.2408435047,
-0.0079251593,
0.4176381528,
-0.2785318494,
0.4683127701,
0.3957094848,
-0.2687982023,
-0.1445234567,
0.7770749331,
0.6181361079,
0.4952428639,
0.7328484654,
0.4073193669,
-0.2146476209,
-0.5343202949,
-0.2883961201,
0.1604562104,
-0.7944864035,
-0.1601160318,
-0.47615394,
-0.3563145697,
-0.6465036273,
-0.1877945513,
-0.3892856538,
-0.3419992924,
-0.1543402672,
-0.3964771926,
0.5401213765,
1.1106595993,
0.1046027765,
0.0916358531,
-0.5417941213,
0.1656518281,
-0.0378913954,
0.2928104401,
-0.0813270062,
-0.4113574624,
0.0404412597,
-0.3064211607,
-0.3209908903,
-0.7228928208,
0.296687007,
0.1307373345,
0.1736325175,
0.4425306022,
0.1171249673,
0.947609961,
-0.4951020181,
0.8388195038,
0.20440723,
-0.8029177785,
0.9153994918,
-0.3945084214,
0.6079549789,
0.6724374294,
0.1777224392,
-0.0840680525,
-0.6033698916,
-0.5030841827,
-1.010778904,
0.8648455739,
0.4059347212,
0.031484101,
-0.3870414495,
0.501190424,
0.3830628395,
0.1079389453,
-0.5369642973,
-0.3910388052,
0.0846432447,
0.3237291873,
-0.0983363241,
-0.3135488927,
0.775375247,
-0.3768507838,
0.3088494539,
0.2747192979,
0.3632182181,
0.3369815648,
-0.1425780356,
-0.0849924982,
0.5237335563,
0.9669197798,
0.7392187119,
-0.2835302949,
0.1133571118,
0.1754500717,
-0.5587505102,
0.1042130589,
-0.2322982997,
-0.1996548474,
0.2538835108,
0.0937244892,
0.5657684803,
0.3058043122,
-0.3534783721,
0.3061023355,
0.1497926861,
0.21247302,
-0.5348823071,
-0.131639421,
-0.1636357307,
-0.1720646471,
0.1683300436,
0.4415621758,
0.2723331153,
-0.5901791453,
0.0805267617,
-0.0263946299,
-0.4067929387,
-0.4002418816,
0.4643785954,
-0.5278825164,
-0.2890480161,
0.2631860673,
-0.5042130351,
-0.4975691438,
0.4074380696,
0.3338652849,
0.6845797896,
-0.5932351947,
0.3514297903,
0.4349015057,
0.0664512366,
-0.282664448,
0.0679364502,
-0.083686918,
-0.327001214,
-0.4831447601,
-0.981749773,
-0.1079650074,
-0.143893525,
-0.7941087484,
0.4582962394,
-0.7482561469,
-0.1046233401,
-0.0332050398,
-0.35860461,
-0.2601791322,
0.0917148367,
-0.0274184123,
0.2263973653,
-0.6045603752,
0.9373160601,
0.3601651192,
-0.4974342585,
-0.9689912796,
0.3005548418,
-0.0638074055,
-0.4369882047,
1.0321193933,
0.3105577528,
-0.3867017627,
-0.3362311721,
0.0442454517,
-1.3716168404,
0.8185854554,
0.4493574202,
-0.2270669192,
0.0108385142,
0.3740296364,
0.7387580872,
-0.0757491291,
0.3571333885,
0.2409950048,
0.3059273362,
0.2104556262,
-1.0602408648,
0.1295424253,
-0.2174218595,
0.4762846828,
0.8393014073,
-0.6608455181,
0.7565250993,
-0.1933650225,
-0.3626536131,
0.1209833175,
0.73384583,
0.001170389,
0.0032043185,
0.4398474991,
0.3894855678,
0.3220984042,
0.0946788564,
1.176030755,
-0.2063640654,
-0.0371399522,
1.2202296257,
-0.3281565607,
1.2597036362,
0.7128580213,
-0.3597863913,
0.9264069796,
0.8716344833,
0.3343439102,
0.8412740827,
0.2448086292,
0.1819109023,
0.0772833899,
-0.6968865991,
-0.2221342623,
0.6275375485,
0.22033526,
-0.313744843,
0.0282100029,
0.2547268569,
-0.1706762165,
0.1209058389,
-0.2645805776,
0.7571367621,
-0.0409244783,
-1.0120542049,
0.8276172876,
-0.1236665472,
0.5327239633,
-0.5082325339,
0.1177903041,
-0.0776871592,
0.1058143973,
-0.3423062861,
-0.6061270237,
0.5907564759,
-0.3477036357,
-0.4218710661,
-0.323543936,
0.5442682505,
-0.0028446701,
-0.4447849989,
0.4324456751,
0.2883001566,
0.1722861975,
0.1862640828,
-0.2778720558,
-0.3714371324,
-0.1961630434,
-0.1523170173,
0.862164259,
0.1176858246,
-0.3396530747,
0.2260208875,
0.3725266457,
0.2174989134,
0.2019687593,
-0.1421752721,
0.4110554457,
-0.4058847725,
-0.6557943821,
-0.9221358299,
-0.0126275141,
0.3051118255,
-0.2241339087,
0.6410256028,
0.5897423625,
0.9985620379,
0.0255633984,
0.530506134,
-0.2022159547,
0.2705933154,
-0.3938437104,
0.293236196,
-0.3777415156,
0.197403267,
-0.3887653351,
-0.8386151791,
-0.1281733811,
0.345069766,
-0.9242824316,
-0.1334307343,
1.0453720093,
0.6850783825,
-0.0307294242,
0.2440381497,
0.1944265366,
0.2685662806,
-0.3949613869,
0.620419085,
0.6965492368,
-0.1529607326,
0.7112542987,
-0.4774177969,
-0.1232947707,
0.052662123,
-0.4156621099,
-0.7331918478,
-0.9004739523,
-0.2985179126,
-0.1591550112,
0.0127013614,
0.8317139745,
0.4720180035,
-0.6853821278,
-0.2889849544,
-0.4968146086,
0.2365391552,
-0.0785540491,
-0.3158287108,
0.523794055,
-0.2061003298,
-0.3497342467,
0.0178659726,
0.6900221705,
-0.2065636963,
0.167488724,
0.103045404,
-0.6561213136,
0.1120126024,
0.564135015,
0.2093757987,
-1.1420480013,
-0.461083591,
0.1074420065,
-0.010399227,
0.6267501116,
0.5438066125,
-0.7350673079,
0.5258991122,
0.4485532641,
0.1930462569,
0.1614196599,
-0.0870460421,
0.3601148427,
-0.8156154752,
0.1660782397,
-0.1439649761,
0.2644773722,
0.1483177543,
-0.820102334,
0.3098151684,
0.0599815957,
-0.2798048854,
-0.7555241585,
0.58513695,
-0.674680829,
-0.363075465,
1.3193467855,
-0.0877375528,
-0.4675912261,
-0.2192439884,
-0.2317880988,
0.2632030845,
-0.4308789372,
0.7202000618,
0.8692541122,
-0.4866573215,
-0.3447954059,
-0.5640420318,
0.3967319131,
0.7595880032,
-0.6307686567,
0.145430252,
0.0427440144,
0.0314155407,
0.691362083,
0.7044751048,
0.0343051068,
0.2677398324,
-0.3505878448,
-0.3408572972,
0.3417940438,
-0.16343759,
-0.0599207357,
0.1377032399,
0.2543405294,
-0.0750408843
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07726v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07726v1
|
Quantifying and Optimizing Global Faithfulness in Persona-driven Role-playing
| 2024-05-13T13:21:35 | 2024-05-13T13:21:35 |
Letian Peng, Jingbo Shang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Persona-driven role-playing (PRP) aims to build AI characters that can
respond to user queries by faithfully sticking with all persona statements.
Unfortunately, existing faithfulness criteria for PRP are limited to
coarse-grained LLM-based scoring without a clear definition or formulation.
This paper presents a pioneering exploration to quantify PRP faithfulness as a
fine-grained and explainable criterion, which also serves as a reliable
reference for optimization. Our criterion first discriminates persona
statements into active and passive constraints by identifying the
query-statement relevance. Then, we incorporate all constraints following the
principle that the AI character's response should be (a) entailed by active
(relevant) constraints and (b) not contradicted by passive (irrelevant)
constraints. We translate this principle mathematically into a novel
Active-Passive-Constraint (APC) score, a constraint-wise sum of natural
language inference (NLI) scores weighted by relevance scores. In practice, we
build the APC scoring system by symbolically distilling small discriminators
from GPT-4 for efficiency. We validate the quality of the APC score against
human evaluation based on example personas with tens of statements, and the
results show a high correlation. We further leverage it as a reward system in
direct preference optimization (DPO) for better AI characters. Our experiments
offer a fine-grained and explainable comparison between existing PRP
techniques, revealing their advantages and limitations. We further find
APC-based DPO to be one of the most competitive techniques for sticking with
all constraints and can be well incorporated with other techniques. We then
extend the scale of the experiments to real persons with hundreds of statements
and reach a consistent conclusion.
|
[
-0.2666156292,
-0.4745566547,
0.7328618169,
0.5187233686,
-0.1474966854,
-0.3077451289,
-0.0621316694,
-0.2300185114,
0.0236369874,
0.4401226342,
-0.8257133961,
-0.316064626,
-0.2423487008,
0.3532145321,
0.1679712087,
0.9201137424,
-0.0946095809,
-0.010502914,
-0.5347369909,
-0.250583142,
-0.3157466948,
-0.4711292386,
-0.4689413309,
-0.2881114483,
0.4580805302,
0.2842956483,
0.8137170672,
0.7697874308,
0.7800840139,
0.1892207712,
0.1915743053,
0.4336203933,
-0.4941980839,
0.4028187692,
-0.2703915834,
-0.6430857778,
-0.3778192997,
0.3282230496,
0.6548472643,
0.2893083394,
-0.0600208752,
0.1316078752,
0.1898256838,
0.489436388,
-0.8245854378,
0.3812698424,
-0.4824422598,
0.1650845557,
-0.2873637676,
-0.1157286987,
-0.411072135,
-0.3255846798,
-0.0214931406,
-0.8912507892,
0.1657006294,
-0.0716991946,
0.9465055466,
0.4503754079,
-0.2890919447,
-0.0460970812,
-1.0318998098,
0.9202686548,
-0.4366503358,
0.1254919171,
0.5421733856,
0.2273206115,
0.0059988741,
-0.3983986676,
-0.4962014258,
-0.3633921742,
0.0341738276,
0.3017567098,
0.0794644132,
0.3079012036,
0.2037374526,
0.4711999893,
-0.4068739414,
-0.2819359004,
0.2386618704,
-0.2030403912,
0.8277890682,
0.1352154315,
0.1739296913,
0.0492437445,
-0.3215404451,
-0.1216240823,
-0.5899528265,
0.1315078884,
0.5207782984,
0.0265655387,
0.1764102131,
0.642570138,
0.1503970176,
0.523214221,
0.2014009207,
-0.2508479357,
-0.307587862,
-0.3031536043,
0.1697826982,
-0.4170259237,
0.6435579062,
0.1057154164,
0.5648661852,
-0.2642689645,
-0.132971257,
0.2250855118,
0.6798137426,
-0.5656606555,
-0.0248847064,
-0.059481699,
-0.3169413209,
-0.2042907327,
0.4032607377,
-0.6270400286,
-0.2132599652,
-0.3168660998,
0.2610388696,
-0.5467848778,
-0.0466470793,
-0.2324301004,
0.1122911572,
0.4044080675,
0.1988764405,
-0.8027330041,
0.3624820113,
0.9793325067,
0.8906840682,
-0.447196871,
-0.5101629496,
-0.5555306077,
0.2558020055,
-0.3194811642,
0.7003436089,
-0.6365072131,
-0.385065794,
-0.1046334654,
-0.2092971802,
-0.1417365968,
-0.5630675554,
1.1082214117,
-0.3821657002,
-0.1943611205,
-0.4142809212,
-0.4673159719,
0.3880526125,
0.302064091,
-0.561059773,
0.7403720617,
0.1645317227,
-0.4340785444,
0.5386849046,
-0.3706969917,
-0.3904476762,
0.0453965254,
-0.1645756364,
-0.42163378,
0.4727233052,
0.0604085848,
0.2184251696,
-0.240443334,
0.3137954175,
-0.3934727311,
-0.4402411282,
0.342271328,
-0.5004767179,
0.353585273,
0.1676707417,
-0.3178699613,
-0.0399672911,
-0.3509898186,
0.1265287548,
0.0500123054,
-0.2181844115,
-0.1933692992,
0.3330540657,
-0.3950238526,
0.1558864564,
0.0687784255,
-0.4425034225,
0.3081949949,
-0.3746565878,
0.2616430521,
0.8465324044,
0.1255810112,
0.3502967954,
-0.5043663979,
0.5133235455,
-0.5008571148,
0.5589233637,
0.1001643538,
-0.507820785,
-0.3729706109,
-0.4737499058,
0.234663561,
0.5326703787,
-0.3772750795,
0.6627095342,
-0.226372093,
-0.1670337468,
-0.6333853006,
-0.0722499117,
0.4989525974,
0.4411291182,
0.3454096317,
-0.413592279,
-0.1819894612,
-1.0888285637,
-0.514280498,
-0.6341421008,
-0.3702473044,
0.8455146551,
0.3358682096,
0.0052366955,
0.9138644338,
-0.4540078938,
-0.5017132163,
-0.1876658797,
0.0126382597,
0.0444776304,
0.4282270074,
0.2758293748,
-0.983923018,
-0.6760619283,
-0.3413858116,
-0.5093784332,
-0.3920046389,
-0.3738632798,
-0.1699144393,
-0.1768225133,
-0.0450793765,
-0.7315132022,
0.5383841395,
0.3290502429,
-0.3889557421,
0.694291532,
-0.1966936588,
0.3534885347,
-0.4103471637,
0.3793303967,
0.1653000861,
-0.2384460419,
-0.3708178699,
0.6057419181,
-0.0876045302,
-0.1847182959,
-0.1109735072,
0.5059821606,
-0.2482276559,
-0.0773233026,
-0.0982045829,
0.0232914481,
0.2162982523,
0.6411371827,
-0.0337164998,
0.8339819312,
0.2162621468,
-0.7099090219,
0.2386715114,
0.3806717396,
-0.0737887397,
0.6876438856,
-0.919970274,
0.244061783,
-0.1218328625,
0.282999754,
-0.9963850379,
-0.2522241473,
0.1413493901,
-0.3333210051,
0.2787579,
-0.3985465765,
-0.4131501317,
-0.0697149336,
-0.1770328581,
0.507035315,
0.5210813284,
-0.3036994338,
0.5754590034,
0.2941792905,
0.1746854633,
-0.3931894898,
-0.5641296506,
-0.007801766,
-0.0762219727,
-0.7435472608,
1.062068224,
-0.1775653958,
-0.3723766208,
-0.1771979183,
-0.5353775024,
0.0441236272,
-0.0132087655,
0.111741513,
0.0137783177,
0.1073225886,
-0.2815100849,
-0.1067717373,
-0.2168269902,
-0.0134300971,
-0.1069255546,
0.4106498957,
-0.278031975,
-0.6466754079,
-0.589579761,
0.3678707778,
0.5536760688,
-0.3244675696,
0.67506814,
0.2311854213,
-0.061870683,
-0.0797667876,
-0.4616033137,
-0.1976914853,
-0.4155483544,
0.0687094778,
-0.5182594061,
-0.501717329,
0.6573070288,
-0.1025601774,
0.2452239245,
0.4034358263,
0.1663217545,
0.1771562099,
1.3263814449,
0.4245927036,
0.1968916804,
0.2657088935,
0.0735869482,
-0.0572124273,
-0.8364161253,
-0.4034116268,
-0.4939617813,
-0.5611744523,
-0.5627176166,
-0.5920519829,
0.3240181208,
0.1624919474,
-0.2902430594,
0.054656595,
-0.5227564573,
0.5204113722,
0.4109447002,
0.0954445824,
0.185450688,
-0.4058729708,
-0.2331297994,
-0.5810602903,
-0.1997524798,
-0.5449090004,
0.9230215549,
0.3440262973,
0.7249666452,
0.3692260683,
0.669485271,
0.3871464729,
0.2298793942,
-0.7352923155,
0.6706289649,
-0.2477524877,
-0.7456025481,
-0.2638055384,
-0.6426482201,
-0.7014434934,
0.0562717393,
-0.1065578237,
-0.6522675753,
0.0494595319,
0.2773616016,
-0.2795943618,
-0.0508962013,
-0.4571530819,
0.8461608291,
-0.4097982645,
-0.8746679425,
-0.1973748505,
-0.7116388083,
0.2120103687,
0.2711930275,
-0.3369520307,
-0.1527107209,
-0.4045477808,
0.2620386481,
-0.2831270695,
0.5781276226,
-0.3283727169,
0.0415457115,
0.2186060548,
0.3489583433,
0.6453124285,
0.5766843557,
-0.3078072369,
-0.0672017634,
-0.0164112989,
-0.4808553457,
-0.8133450747,
0.8136146069,
-0.8920903206,
-0.7105289698,
-0.573828876,
-0.1974599957,
-0.5448374152,
0.0398830175,
0.1061623767,
0.0411262661,
-0.6620295644,
0.1139133498,
1.0070626736,
-0.2849099338,
-0.046854794,
0.5515826941,
0.1154632047,
-0.2736753821,
0.8230452538,
-0.217464596,
0.1128749475,
0.7222791314,
0.3290911317,
-0.3217901587,
-0.4488676488,
-0.2222388983,
0.3304117322,
-0.0679750592,
-0.1505589783,
-0.2587024271,
-0.0606586114,
-0.3139601946,
-0.0051784832,
-0.5195207,
-0.136187762,
-0.2584893405,
0.2536482215,
-0.3635649085,
0.2654196322,
-0.0177815277,
0.1389444917,
-0.4169361293,
0.6868355274,
0.5552554727,
0.5696466565,
-0.2687751353,
-0.4960139692,
0.2220818251,
0.1836236119,
-0.5820430517,
-1.027230978,
0.3936857581,
0.7072582841,
0.7356476188,
0.7260612249,
0.3672284484,
0.7774261236,
-0.4808868766,
0.7026228309,
-0.284283042,
-0.917729795,
0.7752894759,
-0.4589869082,
0.2086408734,
1.0474851131,
0.4240992069,
-0.5222940445,
-0.2822417915,
-0.6433172226,
-0.7724568844,
0.8885571361,
0.5323897004,
0.1781717986,
0.0042515043,
1.0595002174,
0.0749104097,
0.2249102443,
-0.8638120294,
-0.3223181069,
-0.1922885329,
-0.1801016182,
0.0849979073,
-0.1394745111,
-0.224280715,
-0.1779612154,
0.7857238054,
-0.2689870298,
0.4903152585,
0.3871739209,
0.1163113192,
-0.1428456604,
-0.004744126,
0.5308488011,
0.7265271544,
-0.2657351196,
0.0011129532,
-0.2913812101,
-0.5362112522,
0.1066132933,
0.1453603953,
-0.3598465919,
-0.1588118523,
0.3907674551,
0.5591070056,
-0.0202323031,
-0.6074690223,
0.6302781701,
-0.2820685208,
-0.0483653508,
-0.2050527483,
0.2870383859,
-0.4985634089,
-0.0611567274,
0.4634453058,
0.2909197509,
0.0108618392,
-0.7067626715,
0.335162878,
0.6219420433,
-0.5379421115,
-0.516823709,
0.7558421493,
0.2643765807,
-0.5315318108,
0.7424653172,
-0.2675591707,
-0.3111234605,
0.5265335441,
0.4702290595,
0.8825913072,
-0.3828327358,
0.5987512469,
0.2569823563,
0.2789107561,
-0.3347414732,
0.0136686908,
-0.1939460486,
-0.6868593693,
-0.4877848029,
-0.6387194991,
-0.5141510367,
0.1637219787,
-0.7191772461,
0.2139069587,
-0.5577042103,
-0.1858492643,
-0.1511550695,
0.4417752326,
-0.5574350357,
-0.0108531816,
-0.0633294061,
0.5985134244,
-0.681520164,
0.5393614173,
0.7140061259,
-0.3439268768,
-0.6088400483,
0.5438057184,
-0.0249805395,
-0.8718725443,
0.1806175113,
0.0995867848,
0.2458700389,
-0.1780822724,
-0.4185768664,
-0.6202761531,
0.8586118221,
0.7302351594,
-0.3463189006,
-0.2079160362,
0.2556822598,
0.7525203228,
-0.3335683942,
0.2131734192,
0.3724239767,
0.6506392956,
0.1059356406,
-0.6701159477,
-0.0074657537,
-0.2524593771,
-0.0762468353,
0.2778563201,
-1.0061614513,
0.3855074048,
-0.0790001303,
-0.1773142517,
0.0906232074,
0.5987240076,
0.5580785871,
0.4408856332,
0.4361696839,
0.4743396938,
0.4794510007,
-0.2428512722,
1.0144555569,
-0.2508806288,
0.1646925509,
0.6896653771,
-0.4452159703,
0.4115621746,
0.524038434,
-0.3199872375,
0.362888515,
0.5603781939,
-0.1057541892,
0.7644425631,
0.3234685957,
-0.3708439171,
-0.5024941564,
-0.3060916662,
0.0056632697,
0.4701923132,
0.0932364836,
-0.3024491072,
0.2126593441,
-0.1884268522,
-0.1672660112,
0.3702957332,
-0.0917749628,
0.8439458013,
0.0339210257,
-1.3214796782,
0.1928969771,
0.2326822877,
0.5029484034,
-1.0094797611,
-0.0975652635,
-0.5092513561,
0.3735544384,
0.012194965,
-0.5534018278,
0.4812880456,
-0.0525121503,
-0.1794951111,
-0.5935132504,
0.6580885649,
-0.1160596386,
-0.2803723216,
-0.0864230245,
0.3321792185,
0.0213643927,
-0.2866435051,
-0.8436191678,
0.0253972057,
0.0455908701,
-0.2015583068,
0.4912633598,
0.608990252,
0.1066617221,
0.7811132669,
0.2921900749,
0.2249926329,
-0.6256002784,
-0.0679295361,
0.5946432352,
-0.2867020965,
-0.565261066,
-0.9320701361,
0.355774492,
-0.0459925346,
-0.6431064606,
0.7243447304,
0.5877603292,
0.4224621058,
0.159204036,
0.4644231796,
-0.0846913978,
0.1500892192,
-0.2227455229,
0.2293502986,
-0.4397664368,
0.468965441,
-0.4706486762,
-1.2381743193,
-0.1232719943,
0.8912758827,
-0.1430040449,
0.139478296,
0.4483937919,
0.4647860229,
-0.1139850691,
-0.1349933594,
0.2659946978,
-0.2839137912,
0.3567278385,
0.6050504446,
0.7442121506,
-0.1946346015,
0.6672728658,
-0.3438900411,
-0.4958444536,
-0.0268943328,
-0.8308426738,
-0.6649551392,
-0.6052932143,
-0.4756032825,
-0.3099034429,
0.1259432137,
0.5238246918,
0.7850893736,
-0.5367733836,
0.0724056736,
-0.4944600463,
0.1932738423,
-0.7697389126,
-0.2948060632,
0.2048686594,
-0.1282877177,
-0.7480386496,
0.2856631279,
0.2489404976,
-0.1324261874,
-0.5500453115,
-0.2656534016,
-0.1389547586,
0.4614058435,
0.1916454285,
0.4352587759,
-0.5410459638,
-0.221390903,
0.4084471762,
0.0333452001,
-0.048037827,
1.2769099474,
-0.5376049876,
0.2188157886,
0.3131136,
0.4370467067,
0.5629656911,
0.4795147181,
0.9181415439,
-1.1945105791,
-0.086022459,
0.9326777458,
-0.0491819195,
0.1859775633,
-0.5408453941,
0.5399951935,
0.2793517709,
-0.8251267076,
-0.7540119886,
0.6200606227,
-0.85238868,
-0.1980957389,
1.2355839014,
-0.5108585954,
-0.0849278346,
-0.0785745531,
-0.0403083339,
0.0581631064,
-0.515073657,
1.0477898121,
0.6607483625,
-0.6496983767,
0.0097134681,
-0.2392418385,
0.8224369884,
0.5296093822,
-0.6920745969,
0.2678160667,
0.5712400079,
-0.1772069484,
0.2242393047,
0.5497133732,
-0.150054723,
0.1320637912,
-0.0422278531,
-0.3781011105,
-0.152314648,
-0.4756892622,
0.0180292353,
0.3249302804,
0.0809339061,
0.0471126698
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13010v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13010v1
|
UCCIX: Irish-eXcellence Large Language Model
| 2024-05-13T13:19:27 | 2024-05-13T13:19:27 |
Khanh-Tung Tran, Barry O'Sullivan, Hoang D. Nguyen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The development of Large Language Models (LLMs) has predominantly focused on
high-resource languages, leaving extremely low-resource languages like Irish
with limited representation. This work presents UCCIX, a pioneering effort on
the development of an open-source Irish-based LLM. We propose a novel framework
for continued pre-training of LLMs specifically adapted for extremely
low-resource languages, requiring only a fraction of the textual data typically
needed for training LLMs according to scaling laws. Our model, based on Llama
2-13B, outperforms much larger models on Irish language tasks with up to 12%
performance improvement, showcasing the effectiveness and efficiency of our
approach. We also contribute comprehensive Irish benchmarking datasets,
including IrishQA, a question-answering dataset, and Irish version of MT-bench.
These datasets enable rigorous evaluation and facilitate future research in
Irish LLM systems. Our work aims to preserve and promote the Irish language,
knowledge, and culture of Ireland in the digital era while providing a
framework for adapting LLMs to other indigenous languages.
|
[
-0.0561637767,
-0.3008387089,
0.5399808884,
0.3493513167,
-0.0433151647,
0.2263641208,
-0.5332291126,
-0.2966555059,
0.3157075047,
0.8645190597,
-0.2684500813,
-0.5689450502,
-0.6066383719,
0.3252647817,
-0.2628954053,
0.6889988184,
-0.2317168266,
0.2850844562,
-0.0696824044,
-0.3013872802,
-0.3310778439,
-0.5038567185,
-0.6043683887,
-0.5149459839,
0.6112716198,
0.7330853939,
0.4152748585,
0.7700788379,
0.7242984176,
0.2107503414,
-0.2136645913,
0.070271343,
-0.7877668142,
-0.2390880734,
-0.2310040742,
-0.7301834822,
-0.55685848,
0.0131112598,
0.8640626073,
0.935513556,
-0.4358137846,
0.3654526472,
0.0528081767,
0.5157797933,
-0.7560706735,
0.1836064756,
-0.7758104801,
-0.0044872491,
-0.4061549008,
0.1116032749,
-0.4247666001,
-0.2249811292,
-0.3665794134,
-0.6520367265,
-0.3736826479,
0.0334994867,
0.400770545,
0.0293688346,
-0.2140463889,
-0.1244931668,
-0.5346614122,
0.9045667052,
-0.7230889201,
0.5863441825,
0.430534631,
-0.0653310493,
-0.2790800631,
-0.6442374587,
-0.5975879431,
-0.5229317546,
0.3130370378,
0.1709021181,
-0.096450679,
-0.0353177302,
0.0607555769,
0.3862293363,
-0.5355890989,
0.5874837041,
-0.3100925386,
0.0938391462,
0.5349324346,
0.2979116142,
0.1143784374,
0.4408609569,
-0.3577660024,
0.0264032111,
-0.9242966771,
-0.0318213813,
0.3375818729,
0.4022558033,
-0.299108088,
0.7648480535,
-0.3158569932,
0.3073279262,
-0.2690740228,
-0.4335570633,
0.15657866,
-0.1667951494,
-0.096991919,
0.0502727591,
0.6920368075,
0.1475472152,
0.2389903814,
-0.1026744246,
-0.2119774818,
0.0871098265,
-0.0701653361,
-0.6493755579,
-0.0059689335,
-0.1969673485,
-0.3991952538,
0.0507968031,
-0.1452525556,
-0.5982699394,
0.0528683327,
-0.4207596481,
0.1312441975,
0.0403336473,
-0.4824892879,
0.3437941968,
0.1800462604,
0.0564827994,
0.5143704414,
-0.7037283182,
0.3862045407,
0.5808618665,
0.7853243351,
-0.4685421884,
-0.3551553488,
-0.7891569734,
0.3398153186,
-0.5584681034,
0.6025871634,
-0.8600130677,
-0.4989603162,
0.1165347546,
0.0867160931,
0.2542241514,
-0.74338305,
0.5964168906,
-0.4006507099,
-0.3097062111,
-0.08820232,
-0.2595524788,
0.1592178345,
0.1313354522,
-0.6639408469,
1.1462917328,
0.2836785316,
-0.4591149986,
0.1924514771,
-0.8907468915,
-0.1665963531,
0.420068562,
0.0709248781,
-0.010939138,
0.3324994743,
-0.1601691246,
0.3558719158,
-0.6747887731,
0.0806794465,
-0.618500948,
-0.2301197946,
-0.0375631414,
-0.2169428319,
0.9127050638,
0.4053785801,
-0.2327526361,
-0.3855208755,
-1.0401226282,
0.0541256964,
0.1056330428,
-0.5855796933,
-0.4368345141,
-0.3139010966,
0.0951563269,
-0.0040405565,
0.3704456091,
-0.7317754626,
0.1432796717,
0.0010471359,
0.4252837002,
0.5491396785,
-0.6376371384,
0.3742423356,
0.0754169971,
0.4904157519,
0.0904454589,
0.0500904806,
-0.2515358031,
-0.3874728084,
-0.8972842097,
-0.2251883149,
0.2730304897,
0.7753417492,
-0.5531845689,
0.2682038248,
-0.2253011912,
-0.4174557924,
-0.4131475985,
0.8498805761,
0.431527108,
0.2774224281,
0.2776988149,
-0.6264124513,
-0.3841544688,
-0.8496715426,
0.2689550817,
-0.6958411336,
-0.0302326903,
0.006834032,
0.4501282275,
-0.663882792,
0.6845785379,
-0.2146956921,
-0.2548289299,
-0.510140121,
0.1994793713,
0.1718347669,
0.5690715909,
0.4509150982,
-0.4837858677,
-0.178690955,
0.3125036955,
-0.5897424817,
-0.3244999647,
0.2335162163,
-0.1531574428,
0.0295705087,
0.397777468,
-0.3093627393,
0.3124932051,
0.7042210698,
-0.0572346784,
0.5768687129,
-0.23052077,
0.0133046992,
-0.9924735427,
-0.0832074359,
-0.0128718317,
0.022855591,
-0.3866823614,
0.2385133207,
-0.0204088707,
-0.1839070171,
-0.6415959001,
0.7350281477,
-0.3607174754,
0.0323704369,
-0.223339811,
-0.2564815879,
-0.1244483218,
0.210245654,
0.3776905239,
0.9865828156,
0.2128039747,
-0.2898649871,
0.3157120943,
0.3204869032,
-0.2954580486,
0.6937753558,
-0.4906543195,
0.1604183018,
0.2441046834,
-0.0085387798,
-0.6350657344,
-0.2514301836,
-0.3244765997,
-0.2720959783,
0.180684641,
0.0339137316,
-0.5127067566,
-0.5282618403,
0.046930179,
0.4174620211,
0.2591644228,
-0.6667072177,
0.3274635971,
0.4222851396,
-0.4895049632,
-0.4587998986,
-0.981200099,
0.5263100266,
-0.1989516765,
-0.4793427289,
-0.0300866608,
-0.3870087266,
-0.6752453446,
-0.2760178149,
0.3590784073,
-0.4716771245,
0.1961885244,
-0.0924516767,
0.0512665026,
-0.643566668,
-0.0710819662,
-0.1336107403,
-0.0215228368,
-0.0294145253,
-0.4097238481,
0.2895750105,
-0.0518491976,
-0.2238945663,
-0.7862014771,
0.7322853208,
0.5733630657,
-0.2469467223,
0.5640650392,
0.3897666633,
-0.3059369922,
-0.2349983603,
-0.9450265765,
0.0970579088,
-0.4093872607,
0.3479701877,
-0.3246271014,
-1.3552082777,
0.6140130162,
-0.2598035932,
-0.0247416683,
0.2522126138,
0.6842018962,
-0.0298525579,
0.8256610632,
1.039310813,
-0.2614405453,
0.4071614742,
-0.1496659964,
-0.0620552786,
-0.7418563366,
-0.1068166718,
-0.7916048765,
0.0859697834,
-0.4821144342,
-0.2135857344,
0.0407948047,
0.2868338525,
-0.4607545137,
0.4931307733,
-0.1082269475,
0.4967314899,
0.6416869164,
-0.1780009419,
0.3457328677,
0.1107317135,
-0.3747074902,
0.2181034982,
-0.7849427462,
-0.8121665716,
1.3180972338,
0.3732074201,
1.1618219614,
0.085691765,
0.7328329086,
0.2331504524,
0.3378239572,
-0.4699638784,
0.4220912755,
-0.2572663128,
-0.3523450494,
-0.2732686996,
-0.5958525538,
-0.58914572,
-0.358438313,
-0.0100855166,
-0.6832882166,
0.141592592,
-0.0602987707,
-0.4438814521,
0.5228177309,
-0.7257136703,
0.5560520887,
-0.3616475761,
-0.681103766,
-0.088109225,
-0.2156187594,
0.371057272,
-0.3613016903,
0.286423862,
-0.0161906015,
-0.1381453276,
0.6956393123,
-0.5247789025,
0.6971127987,
0.1838337481,
-0.3471301496,
0.4192613661,
0.1038429588,
0.4906260967,
0.4314502776,
-0.2600651979,
0.579696238,
-0.0762830302,
-0.5330777168,
-0.2730665207,
0.7686656117,
-0.9411179423,
-0.6273878217,
-0.1532628387,
-0.4085174799,
-0.1270416975,
0.0222080499,
-0.1033180952,
0.3238579929,
-0.1043456569,
0.505448699,
0.6383954287,
-0.1535704285,
0.4607931972,
0.6887569427,
0.0730729997,
-0.7318680286,
0.5905111432,
0.1392565519,
0.324026823,
0.4410403669,
-0.0230273269,
-0.237602964,
-0.9329977036,
-0.2781165838,
0.2131809741,
-0.3398311436,
-0.2532922924,
-0.5473673344,
-0.0915073901,
-0.4201516211,
-0.3275358081,
-0.6573051214,
-0.3585863411,
-0.4903976321,
-0.0087940339,
0.2053178251,
0.8313452601,
-0.4278775454,
0.720895052,
-0.6876125932,
0.034984488,
0.6209734082,
0.5252344012,
-0.2828770578,
-0.4727029502,
-0.3942022622,
0.0533501841,
-0.3203825057,
-0.1841234714,
0.3222852349,
0.1306013912,
0.6065340042,
0.5784403086,
-0.0311682913,
0.682995975,
-0.7152308822,
0.9760071635,
0.7073609829,
-0.7468365431,
0.4713849723,
-0.1687601805,
0.2886427641,
0.8026950955,
0.3101852536,
-0.2779113054,
-0.4750495851,
-0.3927053809,
-0.5128757954,
0.6072925925,
0.2188449353,
0.2465671301,
-0.2290183008,
0.6056545377,
0.3531506658,
0.1049573645,
-0.7962160707,
0.1405171752,
0.0122462995,
-0.1756759584,
-0.3756470978,
-0.4385879636,
-0.081419751,
-0.1359776109,
0.5912140012,
-0.2903509438,
0.2146642059,
-0.0458226837,
-0.184476465,
-0.191240415,
0.3282892406,
0.6688996553,
1.0170764923,
-0.1778374314,
0.1160859466,
0.5099411607,
-0.8827152848,
0.4475601315,
-0.0249783732,
0.1284586489,
-0.1117910445,
0.6017625332,
0.5833643079,
0.1477061212,
-0.7887668014,
0.2741724551,
-0.1068706587,
-0.0740193278,
-0.6046680212,
0.2955767214,
-0.0613425784,
0.3426122963,
0.5294960737,
-0.4495227933,
-0.1731905788,
-0.6746975183,
0.1734567583,
0.34300524,
-0.4833244979,
-0.4600709379,
0.8117963672,
0.2939219475,
-0.3617653847,
0.3482293189,
0.0174870845,
-0.2548734546,
0.5020132065,
0.6429181695,
0.6364004016,
-0.3949393332,
0.1747902632,
0.2404779792,
0.4264504611,
-0.4022196829,
0.3228077292,
-0.0896977484,
-0.5822502971,
-0.4979535937,
-0.9977704287,
-0.5617288351,
0.3932280242,
-0.7138194442,
0.3823417127,
-0.6326727867,
-0.1584266871,
-0.3689105511,
0.2841241658,
-0.7797305584,
0.2949025631,
0.2351763546,
1.3976496458,
-0.5843572021,
0.940705657,
0.6348923445,
-0.3499035239,
-0.6629543304,
-0.4084175229,
-0.0105638616,
-1.0123269558,
1.1081112623,
-0.0264583509,
-0.1315344423,
0.1977149695,
-0.7700352073,
-0.8358844519,
1.0506718159,
0.7374265194,
-0.9449355602,
-0.0315605551,
0.607665658,
0.3543263972,
-0.814113915,
0.555467248,
0.6261507273,
0.3380199671,
0.280272454,
-1.1133269072,
-0.5605853796,
-0.1074687988,
0.2796639204,
-0.0815095305,
-0.9113856554,
0.7092900872,
-0.0885079429,
0.0980792418,
0.577210784,
0.6808424592,
0.1810851097,
0.2452138811,
0.2521483004,
1.0647137165,
0.5619704723,
-0.1538015902,
0.792953074,
-0.1529160589,
0.0263869781,
1.1297992468,
-0.7797710896,
1.1445630789,
0.3175693154,
-0.2141615301,
0.4252969027,
0.6645398736,
0.3940107524,
0.2299637198,
0.2748864591,
-0.3720415235,
-0.6162118912,
-0.4415525794,
-0.4741143882,
0.7435706854,
0.239501521,
-0.1267917901,
-0.2213301063,
0.1422822773,
0.0558649786,
0.1710363626,
-0.7719197273,
0.8878262043,
0.1654768735,
-0.2109588683,
0.5567092299,
-0.2005228996,
0.5877906084,
-0.7424111962,
-0.1319446862,
-0.629114151,
0.1530162543,
0.0786958784,
-0.6540810466,
-0.0027687929,
0.2118083239,
-0.1739642322,
-0.1640412509,
0.1524205953,
-0.4199754,
-0.8405402303,
0.7643316388,
0.3195278049,
0.2098951638,
0.3431913257,
-0.5009441972,
0.4500546753,
-0.2725922167,
0.1047962382,
0.3186660111,
0.7697395682,
-0.0503789559,
0.5712550879,
0.7649381161,
0.5392566919,
-0.0790603161,
-0.0658183992,
0.8689726591,
-0.6498295665,
-0.5439488888,
-0.4448173642,
0.437500298,
0.0765494779,
-0.4831254482,
0.2619404197,
0.6372327805,
1.3053772449,
0.1808554679,
0.6560374498,
0.4206989408,
0.5169264674,
-0.5840333104,
0.8270928264,
-0.6946316957,
0.1880316287,
-0.1752889901,
-1.3257457018,
-0.421100229,
0.3211036623,
-0.1157507971,
-0.2906283438,
0.5107781291,
0.8102268577,
-0.0609429404,
-0.0434683338,
0.6762937903,
0.2995965183,
0.0813286528,
0.6342651844,
0.8590470552,
-0.0069182198,
0.4921737015,
0.0123688476,
-0.5128529668,
-0.1254499406,
-0.8935322762,
-0.9216452837,
-0.4851364493,
-0.2354760915,
0.0106239319,
0.1551142782,
1.029392004,
0.7621520758,
-0.9991919994,
-0.7230498195,
0.0475858599,
-0.1403982043,
0.1225987971,
-0.1331657022,
-0.05534859,
-0.4347070456,
-0.631698668,
0.4596441984,
0.6083344817,
-0.0111934757,
-0.3452855945,
-0.3112205863,
-0.2907067239,
0.0867466852,
0.7972534299,
0.4101527333,
-0.6587987542,
-0.2901148796,
-0.1568552107,
0.0435093157,
0.218029052,
0.7030993104,
-0.4845262468,
0.4062143266,
-0.063033849,
0.934636116,
0.1765963137,
-0.5312203169,
0.5734547377,
-0.1037301272,
0.4284371138,
0.122375831,
0.4891996384,
0.250089705,
-0.2816524208,
0.6969750524,
0.3057347238,
-0.3659291267,
-0.967023015,
-0.030230619,
-0.9496236444,
0.186540693,
1.2825747728,
-0.4153835773,
-0.3196379542,
-0.0917245299,
0.05637905,
-0.0555045865,
-0.4300276935,
0.6152735949,
0.8424803615,
0.3445871174,
-0.2452525049,
-0.5894394517,
0.0200598408,
0.2179103047,
-0.7932572365,
0.0573006682,
0.3218905926,
0.1129689366,
0.2983351648,
0.4027581513,
-0.1759050637,
0.2622158527,
-0.1924070567,
0.2398524135,
0.0720208436,
-0.561994195,
-0.2544288635,
0.2333000451,
0.1413772702,
0.3198884428
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07703v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07703v5
|
OpenLLM-Ro -- Technical Report on Open-source Romanian LLMs
| 2024-05-13T12:46:11 | 2024-05-17T08:19:52 |
Mihai Masala, Denis C. Ilie-Ablachim, Dragos Corlatescu, Miruna Zavelca, Marius Leordeanu, Horia Velicu, Marius Popescu, Mihai Dascalu, Traian Rebedea
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved almost human-like
performance on various tasks. While some LLMs have been trained on multilingual
data, most of the training data is in English. Hence, their performance in
English greatly exceeds their performance in other languages. This document
presents our approach to training and evaluating the first foundational and
chat LLM specialized for Romanian.
|
[
-0.1377297342,
-0.8789518476,
0.2366969287,
0.3091260493,
-0.1320849657,
0.0610445477,
-0.5556423664,
-0.718901515,
0.2039317638,
0.5600986481,
-0.4546792805,
-0.8903871775,
-0.5734121203,
0.1976624727,
-0.4080180824,
0.6855711937,
-0.2650984228,
0.7359339595,
-0.2955562472,
-0.4550217986,
-0.4652683139,
-0.6565261483,
-0.7071187496,
-0.3798580468,
0.5662102699,
0.6577110887,
0.4213139713,
0.2889292836,
0.9135396481,
0.2740046382,
-0.019447105,
-0.2303870022,
-0.7061502337,
0.1285827607,
-0.2293950915,
-0.8764190674,
-0.4708681703,
0.2347452044,
0.7881885171,
0.4128988981,
-0.1965138614,
0.2434879243,
-0.0193397906,
0.7569661736,
-0.3789831996,
0.3152216375,
-0.5918886662,
0.249136433,
-0.220035404,
-0.6127953529,
-0.6348760724,
-0.4908590913,
0.027648177,
-0.3800043464,
0.0513080582,
0.2514062524,
0.80145365,
0.1116699278,
-0.1492853165,
-0.4979272187,
-1.0945959091,
0.842975378,
-0.3858004212,
0.5864239335,
0.3670861125,
0.4219064415,
-0.2413924932,
-0.5874817371,
0.0200586896,
-0.4900310934,
0.0025259343,
-0.0303233452,
-0.3448821604,
-0.1544468552,
-0.0714887083,
0.5294469595,
-0.7412521839,
0.4869527221,
-0.743994832,
0.0636285543,
0.6358278394,
0.3845832944,
0.280649066,
0.4782432318,
-0.3862910867,
0.3987808228,
-1.1292165518,
-0.2557092011,
0.3484604061,
0.3317396939,
-0.2905755639,
0.9836552739,
-0.1119251549,
0.708725214,
-0.4834873378,
-0.4478183389,
0.1002883241,
-0.2402387708,
-0.186489597,
0.1578289121,
0.6284048557,
0.2227977961,
0.5095366836,
-0.3163554072,
-0.1701217145,
0.0405925512,
-0.1507881135,
-0.7145645618,
0.0373252369,
0.1382456422,
-0.473387748,
-0.1840351969,
0.0510945916,
-0.3686115742,
-0.1042096689,
-0.3259453773,
0.3392555118,
-0.4969135225,
-0.2832809687,
0.2994866967,
0.2881968617,
0.434507966,
0.2859018147,
-0.4504858851,
0.4341244698,
0.6113117933,
1.0751128197,
-0.2396088839,
-0.4112680256,
-0.7299949527,
0.0031065296,
-0.2457953095,
0.7830217481,
-0.5903760791,
-0.3619542718,
0.1781339794,
0.1250028908,
0.1342145205,
-0.5914726853,
0.4496412873,
-0.6312288046,
0.5467941761,
0.3262890279,
-0.7249994874,
0.002856588,
0.2038369477,
-0.5538415909,
0.8780740499,
0.1297875196,
-0.7802550793,
0.1408179998,
-0.7608516216,
-0.384527415,
0.1832966655,
-0.1149385422,
0.0162619352,
-0.138228938,
-0.3521459401,
0.5541148186,
-0.531083107,
-0.0497035384,
-0.0145429447,
-0.3276212215,
0.2301241755,
-0.0240566749,
0.7455388308,
0.4117063284,
0.0875987113,
0.4351651073,
-0.8987033367,
-0.1294799149,
0.2046913207,
-0.6959639788,
-0.221588701,
0.1238848269,
0.1582239568,
0.1361652613,
0.314170301,
-0.6171459556,
0.0312046222,
-0.4525692463,
0.4973399639,
0.4035344124,
-0.5496862531,
0.5655927658,
-0.251022011,
0.8862919807,
-0.174449876,
-0.1739820689,
-0.3315455317,
-0.6452038884,
-0.8778786659,
-0.4431322813,
0.5029736757,
0.919716835,
-0.2619868815,
0.3724481165,
-0.2091199905,
-0.5266777873,
-0.6587649584,
0.4631469548,
0.2765924335,
0.2219418883,
0.1423777044,
-0.179271847,
-0.746707201,
-0.8666136861,
0.0721160546,
-0.0870274156,
-0.0416057147,
-0.023859214,
0.5029876828,
-0.1444802731,
0.7913227677,
-0.4521864951,
-0.6340571642,
-0.5298376083,
-0.005406932,
0.0986118391,
0.3763387203,
0.4915411174,
-0.3622757196,
-0.6081413627,
0.0224885922,
-0.8218374252,
0.2042611837,
0.5697216988,
-0.17332609,
0.5963602662,
0.6566193104,
-0.4627168477,
0.3916307688,
0.7665677071,
-0.2752357721,
0.4143678844,
-0.3032270372,
-0.0930757746,
-1.1043008566,
0.0654840842,
0.2051067948,
-0.3711517155,
-0.3677337468,
0.2335663289,
-0.0293282438,
-0.1353380978,
-0.8086471558,
0.7071570754,
-0.7894134521,
-0.293741405,
-0.1449248344,
0.3093571663,
-0.4323298335,
0.0671583265,
0.4021246135,
0.6356540322,
0.5790364742,
-0.563203752,
0.6738761067,
0.3187788725,
-0.5921314955,
0.770183146,
-0.6792904735,
0.1273696274,
-0.2203555256,
0.0949256048,
-0.8368647099,
-0.2126923352,
0.1512263417,
-0.5691347718,
0.4743448794,
-0.2480963171,
-0.431450814,
-0.2671950459,
-0.1442858428,
0.0181166194,
0.5078737736,
-0.2370452434,
0.3827009499,
0.4920216799,
-0.2221823931,
-0.4205346406,
-0.8724135756,
0.2068631351,
-0.3037651479,
-1.0115194321,
-0.0945659578,
-0.2340111285,
-0.6975590587,
0.1324760914,
0.4019942284,
-0.3843493462,
0.1179237738,
0.0913479477,
0.2625232637,
-0.6367419362,
-0.0049528503,
-0.6309194565,
-0.1496546566,
0.094032675,
-0.1434895843,
0.5603397489,
-0.3304540813,
-0.2648738027,
-0.4639318883,
0.2704895735,
0.3208841681,
-0.1867951751,
0.9935393929,
0.4421854615,
-0.3152537346,
-0.0095022395,
-0.4471333623,
0.086510919,
-0.406468153,
0.362090975,
-0.313685894,
-1.0425714254,
0.3308372498,
0.16411452,
0.2836178243,
0.1867180616,
0.7222376466,
-0.2568429112,
0.6154720783,
0.838553071,
-0.2305469513,
0.3728967309,
-0.1295317262,
-0.0976318642,
-0.2933431864,
-0.5039259195,
-0.8368651867,
-0.3030577302,
-0.3999732137,
-0.5984707475,
0.1009892523,
0.1874781251,
0.08977516,
0.2396202087,
-0.1349773407,
0.4702531397,
0.3757373989,
-0.0015520463,
0.606084764,
0.1701497883,
0.0678842813,
-0.1019284949,
-0.6902214885,
-0.8948253989,
1.1922551394,
0.7387926579,
1.2126251459,
0.1530551165,
0.4370537698,
0.0505965278,
0.2166552097,
-0.9527320266,
0.5250252485,
0.0060435389,
-0.6726219058,
-0.4285581112,
-0.2436382174,
-1.200935483,
-0.0213867184,
-0.2234101743,
-0.4317674339,
-0.6336029172,
0.0258462578,
0.1407484859,
0.4076288044,
-0.5619282722,
0.5196474195,
-0.4188894033,
0.0079087904,
-0.5552787185,
-0.491025269,
0.5404360294,
0.0887965187,
0.2735649645,
-0.2797642648,
-0.3600076139,
0.6607564688,
-0.1391888112,
0.5548466444,
-0.0427506492,
-0.1555019468,
0.215990752,
0.0811298415,
0.3812830448,
0.005657651,
0.0477613285,
0.2255468369,
-0.4046709538,
-0.5114360452,
-0.2007828206,
0.8091163039,
-0.8807607293,
-0.5476816893,
-0.2905371189,
-0.397465378,
-0.2185271531,
0.0069753481,
0.2404083908,
0.3655125797,
-0.8294940591,
0.4605724216,
1.0052608252,
-0.4049111307,
0.2543190122,
1.1068958044,
-0.6058344841,
-0.3151804805,
0.6146326661,
0.0790892988,
0.1999169141,
0.6926285028,
0.0879816711,
-0.0669231415,
-0.8287847042,
-0.3737430871,
0.3393128812,
-0.6525298953,
0.0425773039,
-0.6756502986,
-0.4731113315,
-0.1968635619,
0.0920682475,
-0.3846867681,
-0.4957726002,
-0.4618735015,
-0.3348618746,
0.5606275201,
1.2870020866,
-0.0313452035,
0.1697651148,
-0.8092448711,
0.2360340059,
0.0847535655,
0.5601942539,
-0.4529857934,
-0.6172471046,
-0.5458679199,
-0.0772672594,
-0.1574966311,
-0.5941291451,
0.3089037836,
0.2884577811,
0.9174827933,
0.3018060327,
-0.3105423152,
0.1725115478,
-0.4774904549,
0.72082901,
0.3632366061,
-0.3741690218,
0.8381170034,
-0.2527680099,
0.1156310365,
0.235518828,
0.8900068402,
-0.3589177728,
-0.3900617957,
-0.267911613,
-0.6361544728,
0.8809477091,
0.2241593599,
0.1512789279,
0.1587835401,
0.1428699344,
0.272759676,
0.0656713918,
-0.5369206071,
-0.5311701298,
0.234673202,
-0.1181693822,
-0.3313165009,
-0.4993782043,
-0.1538666636,
-0.31698668,
0.6422972083,
0.1720373333,
0.2989768684,
-0.0152001306,
-0.4543305337,
-0.3289572597,
0.3890823722,
1.002638936,
0.9608373046,
-0.3801364899,
-0.0661081374,
0.2199410796,
-0.4458299875,
0.2379902005,
-0.2272810787,
0.0817204267,
0.2002020925,
0.4756013155,
0.8457040787,
0.4205392301,
-0.7591193318,
0.3962410092,
-0.3089316189,
-0.3063431084,
-0.6872169375,
0.0966630578,
0.5007420182,
0.0790708587,
0.4033859372,
-0.3481798768,
-0.4461282194,
-0.756187439,
0.0664210543,
0.4103071392,
-0.5680683851,
-0.4689276516,
0.4906437993,
0.5918620229,
-0.6903635263,
0.5107101202,
0.2063502818,
-0.163520664,
0.2747293711,
0.5498618484,
0.8118545413,
-0.4110651612,
-0.0229442939,
0.4398733675,
0.489174366,
-0.0355544053,
0.6666584611,
0.4293248653,
-0.5989323258,
-0.4106965363,
-0.6338431835,
-0.5005203485,
0.3989933431,
-0.6852884293,
0.8228083849,
-0.4951883554,
-0.0016599213,
-0.2412970811,
-0.1050639227,
-0.7746804953,
0.1072718054,
0.1599004716,
1.5186452866,
-0.5286593437,
1.0399026871,
1.0871800184,
-0.2944873273,
-0.3162483573,
-0.6553441286,
-0.0755289569,
-0.9785296321,
0.9674736857,
-0.1100383773,
-0.2143893987,
0.0410862342,
-0.6849368215,
-0.7631283998,
1.1307513714,
0.5988135934,
-0.7210652828,
-0.1655382663,
0.4001833797,
0.4728380442,
-0.7152230144,
0.3416278362,
0.4247341156,
0.3234969378,
-0.1116306633,
-1.1632559299,
-0.5258696675,
-0.102212213,
-0.1366396546,
0.0193835869,
-0.6906189919,
0.6271573305,
-0.0979916304,
-0.1715038717,
0.1992968172,
0.8714879155,
0.1940320283,
0.0988690332,
0.225688085,
0.5379523635,
0.6418998837,
-0.097997725,
0.8110870123,
-0.7030265927,
0.0342737325,
1.3720879555,
-0.3129790127,
1.135612607,
0.3184231222,
-0.2540471554,
0.4542981684,
0.5061810017,
0.2168985605,
0.2689216435,
0.2367764711,
-0.1603971273,
-0.0205473844,
-0.0810326114,
-0.4773512483,
0.5415992141,
0.3875235021,
-0.3365381658,
-0.0907048807,
0.0735935271,
0.0928721726,
0.2015102506,
-0.433758378,
0.8013730645,
0.2577329278,
-0.2904280424,
0.4520615637,
0.2392706573,
0.887132287,
-0.7751302719,
0.0401461907,
-0.2490119785,
0.0114400061,
-0.2625139058,
-0.9352933764,
0.4956618249,
0.3548123837,
-0.233343631,
-0.2095120102,
0.687630415,
-0.492007345,
-0.6099837422,
0.6567022204,
0.5458874702,
0.5820336342,
0.1747983396,
-0.5558319092,
0.095348902,
-0.2711422145,
-0.3219109476,
0.4286738932,
0.3873054981,
0.0635860115,
1.0056293011,
0.2997111678,
0.3305157125,
0.3615066707,
-0.0711932182,
0.6162400842,
-0.8892258406,
-0.310804069,
-0.6212215424,
0.436486274,
0.3911472559,
-0.3177804947,
0.8017623425,
0.8539591432,
0.9695842266,
-0.0799889565,
0.79271245,
0.0772707909,
0.5794847608,
-0.6810687184,
0.6099644303,
-0.4019199014,
0.1177006811,
0.1544976681,
-1.0660486221,
-0.0373595506,
0.529329896,
0.0576265678,
-0.2856782675,
0.7728897333,
0.7889093161,
0.1646816432,
0.0273025576,
0.6585670114,
0.3697524071,
0.019974662,
0.4357109964,
1.2642544508,
-0.1713593006,
0.8052151799,
-0.0912445411,
-0.2079129964,
-0.2982951701,
-0.8208175898,
-1.1851063967,
-0.3193370402,
-0.2286742479,
-0.3143539131,
-0.0479976982,
0.9932835102,
0.6943292618,
-1.0159915686,
-0.619387567,
0.1808584929,
0.0443898514,
0.4233696163,
-0.1621802151,
-0.17640239,
-0.3439855874,
-0.7898855209,
0.7683337331,
0.2900970578,
0.1208534762,
-0.9544257522,
-0.5756418705,
-0.2748554349,
-0.0534491837,
0.6643781066,
0.2391287982,
-0.6857030392,
0.0888575315,
0.109202832,
-0.4624374807,
0.3668769896,
0.9230366349,
-0.5555642843,
0.1400071383,
0.5572521687,
0.1563583463,
0.364585489,
-0.4443955719,
0.8377948403,
-0.4734898806,
0.4900821447,
0.1705090404,
0.5174554586,
0.4007381797,
-0.2225023061,
0.8231556416,
0.1254443824,
-0.5585301518,
-0.7305529714,
-0.0569374412,
-0.8167871237,
-0.2018735707,
1.4006961584,
-0.4586394429,
-0.1325779408,
-0.2679878771,
-0.2771990001,
0.1229156181,
-0.2771187127,
0.2238363475,
0.8796335459,
0.087367624,
-0.1375549883,
-0.8133018017,
0.1716974378,
-0.0806273818,
-0.7562654614,
-0.3340282738,
0.4522131979,
0.6474304795,
-0.1284440458,
0.8002776504,
-0.2478739321,
0.1200776771,
-0.2039708942,
0.2583715916,
-0.1346266121,
-0.604429841,
-0.6165302396,
0.2220773846,
0.6281862855,
-0.0744232237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07700v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07700v1
|
Age-Dependent Analysis and Stochastic Generation of Child-Directed Speech
| 2024-05-13T12:35:10 | 2024-05-13T12:35:10 |
Okko Räsänen, Daniil Kocharov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Child-directed speech (CDS) is a particular type of speech that adults use
when addressing young children. Its properties also change as a function of
extralinguistic factors, such as age of the child being addressed. Access to
large amounts of representative and varied CDS would be useful for child
language research, as this would enable controlled computational modeling
experiments of infant language acquisition with realistic input in terms of
quality and quantity. In this study, we describe an approach to model
age-dependent linguistic properties of CDS using a language model (LM) trained
on CDS transcripts and ages of the recipient children, as obtained from North
American English corpora of the CHILDES database. The created LM can then be
used to stochastically generate synthetic CDS transcripts in an age-appropriate
manner, thereby scaling beyond the original datasets in size. We compare
characteristics of the generated CDS against the real speech addressed at
children of different ages, showing that the LM manages to capture
age-dependent changes in CDS, except for a slight difference in the effective
vocabulary size. As a side product, we also provide a systematic
characterization of age-dependent linguistic properties of CDS in CHILDES,
illustrating how all measured aspects of the CDS change with children's age.
|
[
-0.1914786696,
-0.9388079643,
0.1290955693,
0.3840484321,
-0.1719172001,
0.0107034994,
-0.4685842395,
-0.6209995747,
-0.1824532002,
0.3357881308,
-0.8137139082,
-0.3027534783,
-0.5760045648,
-0.0796417072,
-0.443626374,
0.9578974247,
0.0135990819,
0.1316365898,
-0.3232389688,
0.3489698172,
-0.2223068774,
-0.2379811853,
-1.2101867199,
-0.1130059212,
0.4276509285,
0.4728224874,
0.5637152791,
0.6096720099,
0.2025385052,
0.2000831515,
-0.4152695239,
-0.4011091888,
-0.5058199167,
0.3121820092,
-0.326810658,
-0.2128281593,
-0.4404956102,
0.1831331551,
0.7107794285,
0.8872691989,
-0.496386379,
0.0511160232,
0.0682806447,
0.6588764191,
-0.4815381169,
0.0381013528,
-0.5658660531,
0.1482524723,
-0.2305581868,
-0.351769954,
-0.5309490561,
-0.350312978,
0.4455503523,
-0.1813322604,
0.6392859817,
-0.4362454414,
0.5620863438,
-0.0992554128,
-0.3562346697,
-0.7886400223,
-1.0732703209,
0.9277989268,
-0.782132268,
0.3972269297,
0.7293251157,
0.3176856935,
-0.1688777208,
-0.6832422018,
-0.5975949168,
-0.543248415,
-0.0350705683,
-0.0298591238,
0.0225377381,
-0.2195778191,
0.0166255329,
0.405898124,
-0.6455211639,
0.2751008868,
-0.7542285323,
0.069613561,
0.79306674,
0.2599481344,
0.3601149023,
-0.1317734271,
-0.4520929754,
-0.2670190334,
-0.6624228358,
0.2068520337,
0.5850231051,
0.6236917377,
-0.3853011131,
0.4560162425,
-0.4060760438,
0.5530737042,
0.4585081339,
-0.4664282501,
0.0839858353,
-0.3933314085,
-0.0433393121,
0.1088423729,
0.7331643701,
-0.1872334629,
0.3392234743,
-0.0548397899,
-0.3279960752,
0.2179294527,
-0.0262329243,
-0.6971546412,
-0.323770225,
0.1934613436,
-0.5863988996,
-0.4152720571,
-0.2606237233,
-1.012740612,
-0.2972463667,
-0.5401890278,
0.005986921,
-0.5073421001,
-0.3043370247,
-0.1808500886,
0.1953393519,
0.1148239896,
-0.0066696648,
-0.9208375216,
0.4456630349,
0.2134521604,
0.3104529381,
-0.4951713085,
-0.1688837707,
-0.6379805207,
0.1009003296,
-0.4605762362,
0.6670945287,
-0.9383939505,
-0.593325913,
0.1529314369,
0.2164436281,
-0.1329426467,
-0.7262077332,
0.4687739015,
-0.7431899309,
0.3346979022,
0.2588335276,
-0.3030997813,
0.2063278705,
-0.4623303711,
-0.378441751,
0.7567942739,
-0.0336799063,
-0.4470903575,
0.8375054598,
-0.3006332219,
-0.6571741104,
0.057519231,
-0.022067165,
-0.5711765289,
0.0895873755,
0.1158810481,
0.1724264175,
-0.1757091433,
0.6072157621,
-0.1048621684,
0.0273469444,
0.2482621372,
-0.9887344837,
0.9935632944,
0.528868258,
-0.1399690807,
0.0098624276,
-1.3404948711,
-0.0742873549,
0.2085198015,
-0.4700826406,
-0.0601423346,
0.5429285765,
0.1049200296,
0.2607104182,
0.4809967279,
-0.6390855908,
0.0630075783,
-0.0835839212,
0.4484485984,
0.3465603292,
0.4241367579,
0.5470641255,
-0.205142647,
0.7769711018,
0.3263294995,
0.4891118109,
-0.0126140313,
-0.3181634545,
-0.5053039193,
-0.2818267643,
0.1613599062,
0.3790490627,
-0.7062163353,
0.2031274438,
-0.1313627958,
-0.5691024661,
-0.1474146396,
-0.1427507997,
0.2255972177,
-0.0642708167,
0.3298240006,
-0.6842464209,
-0.4951940477,
-0.8213689923,
0.2488435954,
-0.3940834403,
-0.0307423547,
0.3354139924,
0.014921559,
-0.0724019706,
0.8830232024,
-0.4912210405,
-0.0970706344,
-0.2443817258,
0.4615195394,
-0.1589748859,
0.759921968,
0.2097752839,
-0.5344899297,
-0.3194237351,
-0.1737528592,
-0.3110570014,
-0.4857219756,
-0.2809650302,
0.1657880992,
0.1737152487,
0.4984517694,
-0.6379084587,
0.5511001348,
0.7613679767,
-0.4717692435,
0.7916754484,
-0.439745158,
-0.1597966403,
-0.4989081025,
-0.1772657335,
-0.1426557153,
0.0852440447,
-0.8612688184,
-0.023515461,
-0.0175184198,
-0.2145035118,
-0.6948924065,
-0.0485298634,
-0.5001117587,
-0.192624703,
-0.1989382803,
0.0837566704,
-0.2245410234,
0.2601401806,
0.1900819093,
0.9648764133,
0.3210725784,
-0.6568717957,
0.1966039389,
-0.1656436324,
-0.2916235924,
0.8574547172,
-0.683126688,
0.346783787,
-0.3383900821,
0.323412329,
-0.9272456169,
0.1858115792,
-0.0071354602,
-0.3540180922,
0.6262189746,
0.0490092523,
-0.4714785516,
-0.2411327958,
0.08960592,
0.4715760946,
0.2324931473,
-0.3746252358,
0.6286133528,
0.3354966938,
-0.6964856386,
-0.0375574194,
-0.4094848037,
0.0936664492,
-0.3217497766,
-0.6807907224,
0.3860337734,
-0.2026391625,
-0.2380607873,
0.1253794283,
0.2320480049,
-0.3895333409,
-0.0828247294,
0.0036807309,
0.1224731803,
-0.2506740093,
0.0515822992,
0.3575134277,
0.0712778196,
0.0470532551,
-0.1027952135,
0.6279283166,
0.2848079205,
0.11258059,
-0.3507650197,
0.4798075259,
0.4167512655,
-0.2556033134,
0.7825764418,
0.3813000023,
-0.2384887785,
-0.8220725656,
-0.0429244675,
-0.1201422289,
-0.4577431977,
0.1154762805,
-0.4161678255,
-0.5122212172,
0.4510542154,
0.4884683192,
-0.2322155535,
0.5208750367,
0.6807236671,
0.0404714122,
0.8041336536,
0.4013993442,
0.2683897913,
0.5109856725,
-0.0643168986,
-0.1285842806,
-0.6208293438,
-0.1212624311,
-0.5526857972,
-0.1009813175,
-0.7966086268,
-0.4546664655,
-0.2181034982,
0.0120780496,
-0.2374819815,
0.4294994175,
-0.4235588014,
0.1234609634,
0.4619712532,
0.0642592832,
0.3512934744,
-0.2360398024,
0.0280393474,
-0.0230941828,
-0.6226596832,
-0.3851071596,
0.8828702569,
0.4012277126,
1.0258761644,
0.1618119031,
0.4914405048,
0.5016105771,
0.3227186203,
-0.536080718,
0.7449592352,
-0.51734972,
-0.6659991145,
-0.2573726475,
-0.5864148736,
-1.0465991497,
-0.0402150191,
-0.1206025779,
-0.6868760586,
0.8219993711,
-0.2363878787,
-0.1837370396,
-0.1887706816,
-0.6796098351,
0.4428857863,
-0.1454053968,
-0.4515267909,
-0.3836413622,
-0.5877361298,
0.2157119215,
-0.2798639238,
0.1610691845,
0.0071350173,
0.1857349724,
0.9766285419,
-0.2105034143,
0.9869924784,
-0.3275727332,
-0.5916497111,
0.6833691001,
0.2580448091,
0.535908401,
-0.1885339916,
0.3500552177,
-0.0803717449,
0.2104351521,
-0.2809419334,
-0.2250121385,
0.9742240906,
-0.8053064942,
-0.5101356506,
-0.3976701498,
-0.6748467684,
-0.1958581805,
-0.0589572303,
-0.1429132223,
0.5346949697,
-0.1381772757,
0.1731118411,
0.3464364707,
-0.7537256479,
0.5470538139,
0.8348066211,
-0.1971329451,
-0.1908070445,
0.8438236117,
0.555157125,
0.7850965858,
-0.011434217,
0.2351115197,
-0.1660391092,
-0.4295654297,
-0.2537801564,
0.2980954945,
-0.5804654956,
0.316411227,
-0.3188119233,
-0.3602029383,
-0.2170843333,
0.0861419886,
-0.265568018,
-0.6185154319,
-0.399715215,
-0.1725009382,
0.1893909872,
0.7953551412,
-0.3551462293,
0.172438547,
-0.4228383303,
0.2622018158,
0.7436982989,
0.2367888242,
0.1877613813,
-0.6148194075,
-0.2394304276,
-0.0053584957,
-0.4698988199,
-0.8727469444,
0.4046139419,
0.5438999534,
0.3158607483,
0.460832566,
0.0410779938,
0.4134689271,
-0.5960495472,
1.1950967312,
-0.0070919488,
-0.8294950128,
0.5923025608,
-0.6119712591,
0.2185214013,
0.2593657076,
-0.1558231562,
-0.2242606729,
-0.4429343045,
-0.8699632883,
-0.9739756584,
0.7386720181,
0.1646392643,
0.0484612249,
-0.2143069506,
-0.0597782768,
0.1568849087,
0.1332503855,
-0.2982883453,
-0.3058615327,
0.1960994452,
-0.2537554204,
-0.0053453557,
-0.4533993602,
-0.0294899717,
0.1829928607,
0.550815165,
0.3222155273,
0.35253793,
0.0728720501,
0.1073503494,
-0.528254509,
0.4739980698,
0.7566732764,
0.7737865448,
-0.3776515722,
0.4452739358,
0.0382630453,
-0.5016297102,
0.2032644302,
0.2780305147,
-0.39309448,
-0.1667342335,
0.2724862099,
0.5435289741,
-0.009321739,
-0.7098178267,
0.2079724818,
0.0947457626,
0.086022079,
-0.5153366327,
-0.1047561541,
0.1092274785,
0.1145739034,
0.4319302142,
-0.2948912978,
0.0016172862,
-0.6346421838,
0.6078953147,
0.2483109534,
-0.5690853596,
-0.5124964118,
0.8562414646,
-0.0790501684,
-0.4499751627,
0.3778406382,
-0.1497252285,
-0.0122238314,
0.6680160761,
0.7573244572,
1.0574787855,
-0.5684971809,
0.5026935935,
0.1159678996,
0.2821745574,
0.3881815076,
0.0628649518,
-0.0884256139,
-0.6870729923,
-0.5673311949,
-0.5294649005,
-0.0622752458,
0.0329660438,
-0.9203742743,
0.0490363799,
-0.3609657288,
-0.2610175312,
-0.0793112516,
-0.1511107087,
-0.8881300092,
0.8131884336,
0.2694143951,
0.5993552804,
-0.9029923081,
0.8515456915,
0.1903911382,
-0.4142514467,
-0.5548289418,
0.0881469324,
-0.1687628031,
-0.6371923685,
1.0368218422,
-0.4949412346,
-0.131836161,
-0.0282741971,
-0.6373346448,
-0.8483939767,
0.8018449545,
-0.3959665,
-0.4090805352,
0.0464851782,
0.2908350825,
0.8520586491,
-0.5972312093,
0.061515037,
0.7686969638,
0.0460933745,
-0.0197049417,
-0.8380113244,
-0.1826928109,
0.0496618189,
0.4856486917,
-0.0417416282,
-0.3282192051,
0.9028879404,
-0.0581635237,
-0.6683320403,
0.0026714837,
0.9140875936,
0.4193204045,
0.4588265121,
0.7226862907,
0.4969326854,
0.319042176,
0.2171098292,
0.8804016113,
-0.4585925341,
0.4316329658,
1.0850373507,
-0.0325782597,
1.0482709408,
0.5012965202,
-0.5919520855,
0.5744192004,
0.411449492,
0.44953987,
0.8071516156,
0.5107569695,
-0.3578850925,
0.3233643174,
-0.2920695841,
-0.3557349443,
0.1807929873,
0.5633419156,
-0.7300561666,
0.0763493106,
0.1385186315,
0.221141085,
0.0425597355,
-0.0778494105,
0.8491389751,
0.214371264,
-0.4877656698,
0.7786846161,
-0.0814402252,
0.3047897816,
-0.5549502969,
0.1784558892,
-0.2073325068,
0.0791651756,
-0.0816837996,
-0.6130541563,
0.1676885933,
0.1564441025,
-0.2880582213,
-0.0848921239,
0.4001152515,
-0.8743468523,
-0.6497318745,
0.3595782816,
0.369599849,
-0.0323430039,
0.813385129,
-0.5180456042,
0.1966813356,
-0.1095063537,
-0.42728737,
0.3101932704,
0.65356493,
0.1366870701,
0.5715181828,
0.7358072996,
0.6237727404,
0.3163685203,
0.2469769418,
0.5228427052,
-0.3342766762,
-0.4807892442,
-0.2880726755,
0.4647337198,
0.1724922657,
-0.4292506576,
0.6379123926,
0.1553913951,
0.6999512911,
-0.0976049304,
0.7334911227,
-0.2786791921,
0.7524098754,
-0.3898034692,
0.383213371,
-0.294534713,
0.4138137698,
-0.2353769392,
-1.037271142,
0.0523907393,
0.6561310291,
-0.6510996222,
0.1437443793,
0.6505649686,
0.8731233478,
0.2567099631,
0.1437652856,
0.0963473544,
0.2567078769,
0.6152796149,
0.4232929349,
1.0231040716,
-0.1261978745,
0.2056199908,
-0.3874894679,
-0.3419968188,
0.2420396209,
-0.6383341551,
-0.3110151589,
-0.4447720349,
-0.4974598885,
-0.2738910615,
0.2123170346,
0.8372907043,
0.4649729133,
-0.9604707956,
-0.3802628219,
-0.1125967726,
-0.5187828541,
-0.5622919202,
-0.3207804561,
0.4753951728,
-0.149674356,
-0.92160815,
0.7968196869,
-0.157357052,
-0.1621675044,
-0.6306046247,
0.0918785259,
-0.1741336435,
0.4587028027,
0.6646025181,
0.119720459,
-0.4936434925,
-0.4385733306,
-0.1168482602,
-0.1626244932,
-0.2321489602,
0.7319543362,
-0.5829230547,
0.8161965013,
0.5556420684,
0.1798919737,
0.5795342326,
0.1797530353,
0.6100105643,
-0.7051315308,
0.1783585548,
0.1656039804,
0.1093764007,
0.3985338509,
-0.1099598259,
0.300193578,
0.2719964385,
-0.6809052229,
-0.5344064832,
0.4026269019,
-0.9093660712,
-0.2032103986,
1.3511486053,
-0.0509194396,
0.1687000394,
-0.2133269459,
-0.1515123844,
0.2112759948,
-0.58098948,
0.7244625688,
0.5173490644,
0.1791118979,
-0.4630585313,
-0.336002171,
0.4459530413,
0.1058094278,
-0.4303809404,
0.0480054282,
0.5245357752,
-0.0087773362,
0.2922943532,
0.5112018585,
-0.3502311409,
-0.0072813095,
0.1258067638,
-0.0320374668,
0.3641774952,
-0.3258647919,
-0.1076206416,
0.4879727364,
0.1223902106,
-0.1088930219
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07682v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07682v1
|
FastSAG: Towards Fast Non-Autoregressive Singing Accompaniment Generation
| 2024-05-13T12:14:54 | 2024-05-13T12:14:54 |
Jianyi Chen, Wei Xue, Xu Tan, Zhen Ye, Qifeng Liu, Yike Guo
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM, eess.AS
|
Singing Accompaniment Generation (SAG), which generates instrumental music to
accompany input vocals, is crucial to developing human-AI symbiotic art
creation systems. The state-of-the-art method, SingSong, utilizes a multi-stage
autoregressive (AR) model for SAG, however, this method is extremely slow as it
generates semantic and acoustic tokens recursively, and this makes it
impossible for real-time applications. In this paper, we aim to develop a Fast
SAG method that can create high-quality and coherent accompaniments. A non-AR
diffusion-based framework is developed, which by carefully designing the
conditions inferred from the vocal signals, generates the Mel spectrogram of
the target accompaniment directly. With diffusion and Mel spectrogram modeling,
the proposed method significantly simplifies the AR token-based SingSong
framework, and largely accelerates the generation. We also design semantic
projection, prior projection blocks as well as a set of loss functions, to
ensure the generated accompaniment has semantic and rhythm coherence with the
vocal signal. By intensive experimental studies, we demonstrate that the
proposed method can generate better samples than SingSong, and accelerate the
generation by at least 30 times. Audio samples and code are available at
https://fastsag.github.io/.
|
[
-0.3642584682,
-0.6846681833,
0.0279309638,
0.7183609009,
-0.4506823421,
-0.1063729152,
-0.0607139543,
-0.2948645055,
0.6303523183,
0.4690209925,
-0.9864820838,
-0.7550067902,
-0.4639927149,
-0.0940591842,
-0.5043705106,
0.7633498907,
0.4627871215,
-0.429938674,
0.0164926536,
-0.2471311837,
-0.5187750459,
0.1131535396,
-0.6063529253,
0.2193005532,
0.1790090799,
0.5846848488,
0.3901022077,
0.6685044169,
0.1347219199,
0.2841582298,
-0.1003984138,
0.4207173288,
-0.0265878476,
0.7518214583,
0.2906264961,
-0.1872046888,
-0.4921602309,
0.2225834727,
0.6469336152,
0.0529238731,
-0.6967066526,
0.6241542697,
-0.0269792862,
0.7604250312,
-0.24098593,
0.1587274224,
-0.7029945254,
0.0488541164,
-0.3364452422,
-0.2409609258,
-0.2201794982,
-0.5057117939,
0.1766770333,
-0.6847347021,
0.5421923995,
-0.1269983351,
0.5096537471,
0.6746361852,
-0.1865438223,
-0.5070599318,
-0.4302628934,
0.4078898728,
-0.7471148372,
0.2291386425,
0.0517384559,
0.6229861379,
-0.4275303483,
-0.6437596083,
-0.2345523834,
-0.4004005492,
0.2548711598,
0.2213310897,
0.1957595348,
0.0777817369,
0.0170534067,
0.4276990592,
-0.6227336526,
-0.2198291719,
0.1549287289,
-0.2633884251,
0.9335901737,
-0.05913857,
0.3273649812,
-0.4271370471,
-0.589902997,
-0.0598143861,
-0.5071208477,
-0.0412144959,
0.1900022775,
0.6416785717,
-0.4532101452,
0.3496307135,
0.1813467741,
0.9536888003,
0.442150116,
-0.1948801875,
0.1594065577,
-0.5643783808,
-0.1278801411,
0.3026088178,
1.0010983944,
0.0938566253,
-0.3175045848,
0.0683029145,
-0.1605148911,
0.3937546313,
-0.1578317881,
-0.4815684855,
-0.2587314844,
-0.0840497985,
-0.4674639702,
-0.0764216781,
-0.3801305592,
-0.8348133564,
-0.2923938036,
-0.3146727681,
0.4572582841,
-0.465926379,
-0.2211462557,
-0.5296506286,
-0.0134042697,
-0.0869207606,
0.1550924033,
-0.3331980109,
-0.3027855158,
0.0961638987,
1.0186946392,
0.1033284366,
-0.3407580853,
-1.1229565144,
0.1596193314,
-0.5066619515,
0.9269862175,
-0.0223719999,
-0.6149047017,
-0.5530008078,
-0.2994333506,
-0.1703198105,
-0.7460052967,
0.2472991347,
-0.0880305618,
0.194557786,
-0.0797523856,
-0.5758072138,
-0.1089945957,
-0.446713686,
-0.5275867581,
1.0826009512,
0.2839360237,
-0.1270067692,
0.4358432591,
-0.9118619561,
-0.8309875131,
0.1950458735,
-0.1982033253,
-0.4288077652,
0.3194300532,
0.1291024536,
0.4217233658,
-0.2921770811,
0.3473719358,
-0.0682990476,
-0.5808017254,
-0.2587587535,
-0.114506647,
0.2794588208,
0.5036974549,
-0.6883175373,
0.2468649,
-0.95429492,
-0.0140947038,
-0.0649095848,
-0.0660370365,
0.02480058,
0.1828653365,
-0.0335544981,
0.33513695,
0.0804616287,
-0.1312895119,
0.0733692273,
-0.2724185586,
0.288505435,
0.5442174673,
0.1714647114,
0.5348534584,
-0.1727768481,
0.8694197536,
-0.2023178488,
0.0344563127,
-0.4091866612,
-0.5311357379,
-0.1517117471,
-0.5764957666,
0.4006823897,
0.2598807812,
-0.5139484406,
0.5200066566,
0.318076849,
-0.5879430771,
-0.8195946813,
0.3169738054,
0.3531676233,
0.3875331581,
0.2929936945,
-0.3302802444,
-0.6423231959,
-0.7781957984,
-0.2117536366,
-0.2365164161,
0.0439059809,
0.4938975275,
-0.1709740609,
-0.0826961771,
0.5481712222,
-0.2571414709,
-0.5258412361,
0.0940833762,
0.5134779215,
0.0111137265,
0.5802251697,
0.8062551618,
-0.4615458548,
-0.5610160828,
-0.4008189142,
-0.4795574248,
-0.4898670018,
-0.1061318889,
-0.6451271176,
0.2751199901,
0.3824647367,
-0.6805754304,
0.1212639287,
0.7572262287,
-0.3827147186,
0.5296712518,
0.0967521667,
0.2821782827,
-1.1456013918,
0.1735886335,
0.0849435255,
-0.2314361334,
-0.4893086851,
0.1122300178,
-0.2430107147,
-0.5853923559,
-0.4118465185,
0.3249894977,
-0.5887673497,
-0.1279961914,
-0.5115090013,
0.3365397453,
-0.0512410179,
0.2178716362,
0.0842712745,
0.9704823494,
0.8182755709,
-0.7912133336,
-0.0301151704,
0.2173958719,
-0.5316213369,
0.4155372381,
-0.3013140261,
0.217816785,
-0.114592053,
0.5424959064,
-0.9781974554,
-0.2893812954,
0.0251017641,
-0.6579067707,
0.1666710228,
-0.3951867223,
-0.4094474912,
-0.1562761813,
0.3390752971,
0.4022268057,
0.8895578384,
-0.5220797062,
0.6995921731,
0.1410651952,
-0.235743463,
-0.2341929972,
-0.5641356707,
0.1278353333,
-0.276945442,
-0.6522909403,
0.2737525403,
0.1217647791,
-0.0479374863,
-0.1281588078,
-0.3055167794,
0.3033393621,
-0.0450932495,
0.1782078743,
0.0291772038,
-0.3840248287,
0.0625119656,
0.1969870925,
-0.0336233228,
-0.1896131635,
-0.3996427655,
0.2803384066,
0.2544223666,
-0.2560748458,
-0.7660378814,
0.7732226253,
0.9073855281,
-0.3905924261,
0.147455588,
0.5097981095,
0.0349827483,
-0.5504776835,
-0.2969131768,
0.0023740311,
-0.5047984719,
0.1020770669,
0.3281247318,
-0.3822212517,
0.6312878728,
-0.0572431982,
0.3769949675,
0.3253780603,
0.4038777947,
-0.202954635,
1.1110516787,
0.2840543687,
0.0923284516,
0.7498376369,
-0.368386656,
-0.2265909761,
-0.5908706784,
-0.1718784571,
-0.3281870186,
-0.4489727616,
-0.3107458055,
-0.7337557077,
0.576949954,
0.1391693652,
0.2228370458,
0.2613545954,
-0.7010575533,
-0.127148658,
0.5302803516,
-0.1896782368,
-0.3042286336,
-0.2921286225,
-0.1151693389,
0.2362338752,
-0.7527385354,
-0.0731417537,
0.6324312687,
-0.3291250467,
0.683069706,
0.1433067918,
1.0122209787,
0.6712630987,
0.3695344627,
-0.6253635883,
0.7478411198,
-0.2392109931,
-0.5299829245,
-0.0352926627,
-0.4267143309,
-0.5492051244,
0.2479404807,
-0.2614452839,
-0.2069607526,
0.0305681713,
0.865522325,
-0.4337292612,
-0.1460799575,
-0.9009315372,
0.4412559271,
-0.2180463672,
-0.0917653218,
0.0833426118,
-0.8031578064,
0.4706319273,
0.0968211219,
0.3174496889,
-0.4179235101,
0.1676243097,
0.6252292395,
-0.4007732868,
0.6090801954,
-0.9972321391,
-0.241717577,
0.8247125745,
0.2076449692,
0.7638062239,
-0.1946232319,
-0.1127457768,
-0.2215219587,
-0.3924289048,
-0.4055352211,
-0.6767331362,
0.8162267208,
-0.190001443,
-0.5862166882,
0.0665389374,
-0.5375529528,
-0.1649885625,
-0.1748959422,
0.3743565977,
0.3640156686,
0.2167612016,
-0.1284580827,
0.3822771013,
-0.1287483275,
0.5086881518,
0.3565853536,
-0.0326112062,
-0.7298431396,
0.8361850977,
0.0480664186,
0.4922519326,
-0.1732160449,
0.1997868568,
-0.6857696176,
-0.3543743193,
-0.7986677885,
0.2096024156,
-0.4183936417,
-0.2634022534,
-0.2551353872,
0.1483469009,
-0.6417766809,
-0.0379917361,
-0.3775628209,
-0.3720913231,
-0.323617816,
0.3413312137,
0.6555250287,
0.3875708878,
-0.2591186762,
0.5350989103,
-1.1272553205,
0.5471991897,
0.0815327838,
0.147472471,
0.2025597095,
-0.1691868603,
-0.4452051222,
-0.1208462045,
-0.0843879208,
-0.9132947326,
0.0519079342,
0.4430852532,
0.5558470488,
0.4570967853,
0.0497719236,
1.191629529,
-0.4956357777,
1.1278730631,
0.2269658148,
-0.9459526539,
0.7148830891,
-0.3776751757,
0.1767433435,
0.5877266526,
-0.1959987283,
-0.3937942982,
-0.5630203485,
-0.5367052555,
-1.1484482288,
0.6493938565,
0.3263967335,
-0.3256285787,
-0.1423211098,
0.6780959964,
0.1813370883,
0.3512664735,
-0.2129072249,
-0.3701174855,
-0.4969854057,
-0.2725936472,
-0.517592907,
0.3742557466,
-0.0482420251,
0.1226117536,
0.7501041293,
-0.2661184072,
0.3972461224,
0.3554838002,
0.0092887059,
-0.2286906093,
-0.0030504952,
0.754368186,
-0.2362966686,
0.2247743607,
-0.2228289396,
-0.2519945204,
-0.2262347788,
0.4788474441,
0.1492213309,
-0.2358401567,
0.1377535164,
0.2361808121,
0.9515318871,
0.0963197872,
-0.6789892912,
0.3175302744,
-0.0696939602,
-0.3991776705,
-0.3545994163,
0.3283276558,
0.1638415158,
0.2763492167,
0.3303278983,
0.2879719734,
0.0309495535,
-0.2080401778,
0.4768171906,
0.4204280376,
-0.1895297319,
-0.0677007288,
1.0674983263,
0.1872447729,
-0.7490655184,
0.1129805297,
-0.0664853901,
-0.0610440038,
0.6795425415,
0.5156487226,
1.1179032326,
-0.5131717324,
0.129014194,
0.1249188185,
-0.1581577957,
0.0412865616,
0.4766439795,
-0.866762042,
0.2432513982,
-0.7064210176,
-0.7377735376,
-0.1359664351,
0.0564736426,
-0.6216478348,
0.1356500387,
-0.318092674,
-0.2366513461,
-0.132122159,
-0.2451451421,
-0.1071805507,
0.3719217777,
0.060673777,
1.0351827145,
-0.9071766734,
0.409414798,
0.4648084044,
0.0824336112,
-0.963657856,
0.5740635395,
0.1598763913,
-0.5138392448,
0.1250488162,
0.1193900853,
-0.561032474,
0.0829051062,
-0.3051910102,
-0.9009042978,
0.9109425545,
0.1168356836,
-0.6855362058,
-0.1935556382,
-0.4228978753,
0.3538967371,
-0.2627771199,
-0.3136022091,
0.3251129091,
0.5568869114,
0.5386406779,
-0.3985801339,
-0.0765981078,
-0.3901244402,
-0.0895118713,
0.3580539525,
-0.9134611487,
0.6113679409,
-0.1512481421,
-0.3008944988,
0.7099920511,
0.8945434093,
0.6271656752,
0.4301619828,
0.892400682,
0.5995657444,
0.5615279675,
-0.0275785699,
0.4963236153,
-0.5813634396,
-0.2019815445,
1.2113171816,
-0.3922555447,
0.3157716691,
0.2640608847,
0.330065906,
0.6464765668,
0.8302085996,
0.2403686643,
0.8950884342,
0.3012309968,
-0.6325153112,
-0.2547739446,
0.2134753317,
-0.4189659059,
0.6690183878,
0.3427900672,
-0.6832555532,
-0.1989839971,
0.03496309,
-0.4587844908,
-0.0120724896,
-0.2779958844,
0.897921741,
-0.1444444656,
-1.0625445843,
0.6102167964,
-0.3136179745,
0.5699652433,
-0.779785037,
-0.2320483774,
-0.1237078235,
-0.1940772235,
-0.1520924717,
-0.1410231739,
0.2648735046,
-0.077301383,
0.0492662303,
0.0429146886,
0.3511318564,
-0.564627111,
-0.1991762221,
0.3204670846,
0.3576972187,
0.0701146573,
0.3530613184,
-0.5876379609,
-0.2589731514,
-0.1185898036,
0.0049256133,
0.0573189855,
0.3527979255,
-0.0570916124,
0.2997058928,
0.7306414247,
0.2512450814,
0.4283512235,
0.3188567758,
0.3100391924,
-0.6578611732,
-0.9668169022,
-0.4567346871,
0.4437169731,
0.3331342936,
-0.0614720434,
0.7742648721,
0.4643270075,
0.0245736632,
0.1400837153,
0.836779952,
-0.1401520371,
0.5624818802,
-0.5816059709,
0.8847773671,
-0.9005042911,
-0.0858101249,
-0.6527194977,
-0.5541953444,
-0.1952157766,
0.3840952218,
0.5373414159,
0.0799677297,
0.0357007645,
0.7965117693,
-0.0467301123,
0.2591305077,
0.0320260599,
-0.1387087405,
0.2508846819,
0.2559876442,
0.8386825323,
-0.155180499,
0.4136574864,
-0.0332110003,
-0.2114545405,
-0.1140832156,
-0.8952639103,
-0.4992367327,
-0.5519698858,
-0.3006067574,
-0.3917221725,
-0.0647415891,
1.0719233751,
1.1166366339,
-0.417843163,
-0.218805179,
-0.3197168708,
-0.0641940013,
-0.6866958737,
-0.2952456772,
0.3852652907,
-0.209219262,
-0.5574861765,
1.1416634321,
0.2321287096,
0.4611410499,
-0.3953304291,
-0.1676526368,
-0.0827364475,
0.3442641199,
0.4611697793,
0.1842201799,
-0.6464210153,
-0.0010776938,
-0.0505605191,
0.4729916155,
0.0989205539,
0.8017096519,
-0.594411552,
0.3053393662,
0.2991798222,
0.0677081272,
0.4989375472,
0.3452737033,
0.4067071676,
-0.8804665208,
0.1478442401,
0.3057242036,
0.0161651541,
0.1133613959,
-0.4419735372,
-0.0664440766,
0.1397377402,
-0.4192419946,
-0.7996595502,
0.5907577276,
-0.7936042547,
0.0561649539,
0.8479809761,
-0.1288591176,
-0.224989742,
0.1603635848,
-0.1221286878,
0.5993849635,
-0.61723876,
0.6828305721,
0.1976168156,
-0.7351953983,
0.0484896079,
0.13615565,
0.7129710317,
0.1921358109,
-0.4984520376,
0.2560703158,
0.9164514542,
0.2355742007,
0.1418851912,
0.7417877316,
-0.3811355829,
0.8274089098,
0.0767581016,
0.0991842598,
-0.2646102011,
-0.6054031849,
-0.2739322186,
0.2920614779,
-0.0253797788,
-0.5887695551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07673v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07673v1
|
An Empirical Study on the Robustness of Massively Multilingual Neural Machine Translation
| 2024-05-13T12:01:54 | 2024-05-13T12:01:54 |
Supryadi, Leiyu Pan, Deyi Xiong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Massively multilingual neural machine translation (MMNMT) has been proven to
enhance the translation quality of low-resource languages. In this paper, we
empirically investigate the translation robustness of Indonesian-Chinese
translation in the face of various naturally occurring noise. To assess this,
we create a robustness evaluation benchmark dataset for Indonesian-Chinese
translation. This dataset is automatically translated into Chinese using four
NLLB-200 models of different sizes. We conduct both automatic and human
evaluations. Our in-depth analysis reveal the correlations between translation
error types and the types of noise present, how these correlations change
across different model sizes, and the relationships between automatic
evaluation indicators and human evaluation indicators. The dataset is publicly
available at https://github.com/tjunlp-lab/ID-ZH-MTRobustEval.
|
[
0.0087053925,
-0.5708436966,
0.1019716859,
0.5393061042,
-0.3689045012,
-0.1388265491,
-0.6991589069,
-0.4569986165,
-0.22985439,
0.3656980693,
-0.2006042004,
-0.2416321486,
-0.5425163507,
0.5907779336,
-0.4782971442,
0.9645584226,
0.0398536325,
0.3337505162,
0.3473604023,
-0.5871165395,
-0.487711221,
-0.3579126596,
-0.674136281,
-0.0832530633,
0.5944439769,
-0.2867108583,
0.9153677225,
0.8557862043,
0.8865171075,
0.2718822956,
-0.1451699138,
0.3234542906,
-0.0029096871,
0.08605057,
0.0308406819,
-0.3854184747,
-0.6224735379,
-0.3726166785,
0.7088594437,
0.6418609619,
-0.0862578824,
0.4487721324,
0.4055115879,
0.4685595334,
-0.2092165798,
0.3024964631,
-0.7428121567,
0.0348240435,
-0.3540999889,
0.0262929145,
-0.449026376,
-0.3000448644,
-0.1366256624,
-0.4876791239,
-0.2891158164,
0.1437667012,
0.9959911704,
0.7058933973,
-0.6441317797,
-0.1026991233,
-0.4138330817,
0.8938492537,
-0.9630813599,
0.205973044,
0.4121764898,
0.4891721904,
-0.1365998834,
-0.2790914178,
-0.2815127969,
-0.2371903062,
-0.1100196093,
0.2347863615,
-0.0212353878,
0.0430512913,
0.1230010092,
0.5913279653,
-0.7499245405,
0.2759349942,
-0.1406446993,
-0.2523227036,
0.5107814074,
0.0931910127,
0.5775167942,
-0.510017693,
-0.0323294289,
-0.2473330945,
-0.2769862711,
-0.023054434,
0.4873630106,
0.7318685055,
-0.3283413053,
0.600733757,
0.1986309737,
0.7464437485,
-0.2542240024,
-0.3627702892,
0.3969919682,
-0.9828513265,
-0.0878956243,
-0.0859811753,
1.0154718161,
0.5398272276,
0.1186304092,
-0.2709133327,
-0.4338901341,
-0.0712137744,
0.1973387003,
-0.7018250227,
0.0202338435,
0.3547997773,
-0.8253087401,
-0.4436216056,
-0.2218869328,
-0.5047274828,
-0.0716000497,
-0.2829410732,
0.4041462243,
-0.5069491863,
-0.8662182689,
-0.1367005557,
-0.0012409517,
0.0300277937,
0.0216103382,
-0.6363799572,
-0.0983672664,
0.505793035,
0.9338905811,
-0.259134084,
-0.4842416346,
-0.290419966,
-0.0185522586,
-0.5363754034,
0.4243774414,
0.0268466715,
-0.0619754978,
0.0118323117,
0.0500579067,
-0.3878545165,
-0.8035530448,
0.794310987,
-0.2113045305,
-0.1376991272,
-0.1995655149,
0.1018393636,
-0.1438046247,
0.4460595846,
-0.7757129073,
1.0621845722,
0.0867153779,
-0.7754840255,
0.587650001,
-0.620678544,
-0.5968557596,
-0.2282295078,
0.1953329593,
-0.6993566751,
0.2523714304,
0.2656518221,
0.2651380897,
-0.08111424,
0.4591399133,
-0.3424174786,
-0.37917009,
0.5571881533,
-0.9122398496,
1.0731426477,
0.5452019572,
-0.268866837,
-0.0438969657,
-0.9176251292,
-0.1069279239,
0.0169559401,
-0.4999957681,
-0.344193995,
-0.288546741,
0.2170990705,
0.5498295426,
0.1274510771,
-0.2398389578,
-0.1669190228,
-0.3846607506,
0.500695765,
0.6088936329,
-0.1227786988,
0.03631806,
-0.3487579525,
0.3158847392,
0.4844068885,
0.0261123087,
-0.3928904533,
-0.4924765527,
-0.4504781365,
-0.2203313112,
0.4696964324,
0.507173121,
-0.9118870497,
0.4699854851,
-0.5269752145,
-0.1766501069,
-0.6867417097,
0.4162147045,
0.4270587564,
0.3300461769,
0.3053610325,
-0.2916268706,
-0.504209578,
-0.7303136587,
-0.3568840921,
-0.3986823559,
-0.1819709539,
0.1085985228,
0.3582184315,
-0.4052392244,
0.157671988,
0.4242566824,
-0.1908263415,
0.0065049506,
0.2755942941,
0.6243468523,
0.5328712463,
0.7141120434,
-0.5891274214,
-0.5801614523,
0.3992637396,
-0.7537793517,
-0.2217968106,
-0.4520572722,
-0.1766833216,
0.2888376415,
0.1683721095,
-0.4532737732,
0.3450625539,
0.9217700362,
0.1741742939,
0.7215217352,
-0.2675355673,
0.165219754,
-1.2820258141,
0.385119766,
-0.065994963,
-0.0059100292,
-0.3773637116,
0.2428084016,
0.1467725188,
0.0146796461,
-0.295142293,
-0.0424327254,
-0.4263941646,
-0.2289008945,
-0.2125354558,
-0.0513442382,
-0.227729097,
0.464502424,
-0.3999035954,
0.9616010785,
0.1976139247,
-0.6397698522,
0.134722665,
-0.0428334251,
-0.409778744,
0.7743564248,
-0.5723980069,
-0.1827844083,
0.0895523652,
-0.0072447793,
-0.982221663,
-0.4135646522,
0.1634467393,
-0.5410407186,
0.3383195102,
-0.0059101842,
-0.9555755854,
-0.3011511862,
-0.0401745178,
0.3549110293,
0.2145165801,
-0.5217334032,
0.1476987898,
0.017152736,
-0.0659404024,
-0.5012355447,
-1.1812779903,
0.4823075831,
-0.3697263002,
-0.565009892,
-0.1725060195,
0.0263746604,
-0.1830803752,
-0.0292357132,
-0.0655896291,
-0.3705650568,
0.311496526,
0.0433656648,
0.2263728976,
-0.5527926683,
-0.0637007281,
0.1475936174,
-0.1247031242,
0.3366546929,
-0.3987667263,
0.1221763268,
-0.2697046101,
-0.295863241,
-0.3458723724,
-0.0130051877,
0.6843694448,
-0.0755818337,
0.7606096864,
1.1371492147,
-0.3818494081,
0.0481564552,
-0.2403436899,
0.0124030206,
-0.3876451254,
0.6216304898,
-0.5551777482,
-0.334903419,
0.6092030406,
-0.0103203179,
0.3693976998,
0.6830685735,
0.6933835149,
0.0566057861,
1.3231761456,
0.2151861638,
-0.2455982268,
0.1322181672,
0.2949137092,
0.1999677122,
-0.7440279126,
0.2567928433,
-0.6122221947,
-0.2801384926,
-0.7168977857,
-0.2618282735,
0.3069131374,
-0.1524477601,
-0.1328214556,
0.7203595042,
-0.3995687664,
0.1432204992,
0.1791366786,
-0.112781629,
0.4877761006,
0.218120262,
-0.4400702417,
-0.5135889053,
-0.6340003014,
-0.4972499907,
1.1603562832,
0.2817038,
0.3262356222,
0.3765174747,
0.1453123987,
0.0128190713,
0.372723788,
-0.3902889192,
0.1377806515,
-0.375867486,
-0.8222575784,
-0.2218327969,
-0.8362616897,
-1.0210893154,
0.6172643304,
-0.1875559539,
-0.5467638969,
-0.138346523,
-0.1000565141,
-0.2565914094,
0.4579854608,
-0.5311512351,
0.849404633,
-0.5812183619,
-0.1312116981,
-0.0635417923,
-0.7482489944,
0.6691311598,
-0.5257706642,
0.3405163884,
-0.0138121042,
-0.0212776884,
0.2925204933,
-0.1029040441,
0.5098711252,
0.1935227811,
-0.2472649962,
-0.0979821905,
-0.0191655159,
0.1822941452,
-0.0066421088,
-0.4488203526,
0.5150251389,
0.0452532023,
-0.4448360503,
-0.4589457214,
0.3911533058,
-0.8869893551,
0.0118194185,
-0.2346384823,
-0.7638331652,
0.1241193339,
0.5838580728,
0.3898727894,
0.0281421263,
0.0192090776,
0.3867031932,
0.4863515496,
-0.4251161814,
0.5529468656,
0.4381480813,
-0.3726289272,
-0.5847280025,
1.152192831,
0.4489279091,
0.2795113027,
0.2824029326,
0.2062321156,
-0.2089293748,
-0.5569332838,
-0.969388783,
-0.0816507041,
-0.4563463032,
-0.0844174698,
-0.5338918567,
-0.2815138102,
-0.2225617021,
0.1255617291,
-0.5584257841,
-0.2950711548,
0.0189578943,
-0.0111067779,
-0.2640371919,
0.394174993,
-0.0991415456,
0.1924363673,
-0.6389976144,
0.3263345063,
-0.0516308099,
0.1566880047,
0.070498839,
-0.6978396773,
-0.4997401237,
0.22952196,
-0.0675530657,
-0.4503005743,
0.4791667461,
0.2018179595,
0.4808814526,
0.5374592543,
0.1210894287,
0.8440813422,
-0.184932068,
0.6959482431,
-0.0332448259,
-0.5935701728,
0.2237150073,
-0.5582230091,
0.5417726636,
0.698225677,
-0.0229600649,
-0.3844144344,
-0.5157650709,
-0.3807317317,
-0.8054401875,
0.2620522678,
0.37516132,
0.0260096081,
0.2437533885,
0.2137283385,
0.1219706461,
0.3575521111,
-0.9221087098,
-0.1955051869,
-0.3420800865,
-0.0857872292,
-0.0159221496,
0.0977436975,
-0.0509395264,
-0.1530724615,
0.3992524445,
-0.2239249945,
0.0392738394,
-0.2101858109,
-0.2915818989,
-0.2450135499,
0.11918322,
0.5653264523,
0.3697783053,
-0.3928949535,
0.1667633206,
0.3313033581,
-0.491517216,
0.0665373653,
0.0727766156,
-0.2565735877,
0.3654215932,
0.4516751468,
0.5036209822,
0.2666298747,
-0.4855968058,
0.4854899943,
-0.3124835491,
-0.0532944314,
-0.3476495445,
-0.2766573131,
-0.1155354232,
-0.312828362,
0.2529905736,
0.5957231522,
0.0303366277,
-0.1832560301,
0.0299328491,
-0.0351284146,
-0.3764658868,
-0.5444833636,
1.0532541275,
0.1471076608,
0.1538665742,
0.6985120177,
-0.187271893,
-0.2757956386,
0.5331727266,
0.3707685769,
0.8988993764,
-0.1248297766,
-0.0533274151,
0.6236703396,
1.0745089054,
-0.1634572893,
-0.0943676531,
0.032871034,
-0.3205765486,
-0.7293653488,
-0.4698983431,
-0.423409611,
0.0627014264,
-0.8883628845,
0.0355309024,
-0.2339507639,
-0.3340612948,
-0.3315272331,
-0.0307871178,
-0.401227951,
-0.0164570119,
-0.1794165373,
0.663901031,
-0.8539053202,
0.9744724631,
0.7171577215,
-0.3327248096,
-0.7203602791,
0.0965547264,
0.2065480351,
-0.7153378129,
0.4478462338,
0.4352196753,
0.3541854918,
-0.5298617482,
-0.2386147231,
-0.7455093861,
0.8892405033,
0.5864911079,
-0.2266676426,
0.3416218758,
0.5694262981,
0.8049474955,
0.096162267,
0.2309138775,
0.5392092466,
0.708527863,
-0.2760591507,
-1.1599985361,
0.0264469851,
-0.5463692546,
0.1851502955,
-0.1518226862,
-0.862492919,
0.8220270276,
0.1865178943,
-0.1852512956,
0.301142782,
0.6018738151,
0.0373561084,
0.1587959379,
0.5321996212,
0.5015944839,
0.6968257427,
-0.1596010625,
1.0308157206,
-0.5231265426,
-0.1206905618,
0.9487517476,
-0.0196883697,
0.7962496877,
0.4613420963,
-0.1559810638,
0.0283695962,
0.6185127497,
-0.04088936,
0.260779798,
0.0393068418,
0.0032417648,
-0.0807737187,
-0.2890691459,
-0.565554738,
0.2692833245,
0.3878086209,
-0.434268564,
-0.0295155607,
-0.2855834663,
0.1462446451,
-0.1406013072,
-0.0766128078,
0.573235631,
0.3821464479,
-0.8028950095,
0.6709727645,
0.1410902739,
0.8887537122,
-0.4497478604,
0.1442115903,
-0.3521987796,
0.3961982727,
-0.2788960934,
-0.5181398392,
0.7183062434,
0.0181777012,
0.0222976506,
-0.1442079693,
0.4596057534,
-0.415666163,
-0.5813060403,
0.2284991145,
0.4453562498,
0.2350767106,
-0.0354093127,
-0.9463068247,
0.2799361348,
-0.0437854491,
-0.0991191864,
0.5167462826,
0.7291022539,
-0.062843658,
0.6126027703,
0.9421536922,
0.3603561819,
0.2767220736,
-0.0988415331,
0.4054841697,
-0.32778126,
-0.3434759676,
-0.7106339335,
0.4842934906,
-0.1426196545,
-0.6678380966,
1.2737731934,
0.4293756187,
0.7460896969,
0.0531607755,
0.6341307759,
0.3448967338,
0.2548696101,
-0.1718366146,
0.9227128029,
-0.4409655631,
0.3453214169,
-0.5465051532,
-1.0896836519,
-0.556859076,
0.4928478599,
0.1648553759,
-0.2330710292,
0.5584162474,
0.7847087383,
-0.0759356618,
-0.1084658355,
0.5945340991,
0.3212516904,
0.2673080862,
0.5592435598,
0.4467104971,
-0.7720250487,
1.079020977,
-0.2948481441,
0.0449349731,
-0.2193474621,
-0.8683502674,
-0.8458139896,
-0.3314352334,
-0.3523429632,
-0.5224841237,
0.0235745721,
0.6346633434,
0.5074266195,
-0.9427272081,
-0.4410074949,
0.2394166738,
0.1222701818,
-0.8813023567,
-0.1275732815,
0.4457475245,
-0.4468786418,
-0.7387905717,
0.3216421306,
0.3569453061,
0.0366842449,
-0.2890120745,
-0.2715485692,
0.0652412027,
-0.1638310552,
0.3381460011,
0.1893214583,
-0.6413326859,
0.0722703114,
-0.1700134426,
-0.5024219155,
-0.013094902,
0.2704019248,
-0.0061467998,
0.6285754442,
0.3134461939,
1.0777065754,
0.184848547,
-0.1794901043,
0.6415493488,
-0.7965428233,
0.396089524,
-0.3277702034,
0.3566418886,
0.4498775303,
-0.0570575073,
0.8202667236,
0.138192296,
-0.5670618415,
-1.0177452564,
-0.3264923394,
-0.7999071479,
0.0715566576,
0.9789087772,
-0.37464571,
-0.441699326,
-0.379419744,
-0.0419908315,
0.2332700491,
-0.0827115402,
0.8905186653,
0.9853713512,
0.448425144,
-0.1499766558,
-0.9853562117,
0.1047195867,
0.7797629833,
-0.2829595208,
-0.23259902,
0.0706321076,
-0.0517674461,
0.2080892622,
0.0458436199,
-0.3178519011,
0.4065358043,
0.363607198,
-0.3258925974,
-0.1080782562,
0.0725272968,
-0.4151635766,
-0.0160340536,
0.1546411961,
-0.0810975507
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07671v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07671v1
|
Constructing a BPE Tokenization DFA
| 2024-05-13T11:59:24 | 2024-05-13T11:59:24 |
Martin Berglund, Willeke Martens, Brink van der Merwe
|
cs.FL
|
cs.FL, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Many natural language processing systems operate over tokenizations of text
to address the open-vocabulary problem. In this paper, we give and analyze an
algorithm for the efficient construction of deterministic finite automata
designed to operate directly on tokenizations produced by the popular byte pair
encoding technique. This makes it possible to apply many existing techniques
and algorithms to the tokenized case, such as pattern matching, equivalence
checking of tokenization dictionaries, and composing tokenized languages in
various ways.
|
[
-0.4321805239,
-0.9150547981,
0.6101734638,
0.3662765324,
-0.3520534337,
0.1903675497,
0.3326505423,
-0.5275028944,
0.4538894594,
0.4060765505,
-0.2622748315,
-0.274251312,
-0.4797113836,
0.3429892063,
-0.4107252955,
0.6552867293,
-0.2873707414,
0.0509747639,
0.4285959601,
0.0687278435,
-0.5782037377,
-0.8431845903,
-0.9496757388,
-0.1660164446,
-0.0197755359,
-0.0275132768,
0.7851390839,
0.9180850983,
0.6836841702,
0.4425802827,
-0.1454278231,
0.2714370191,
-0.0369117334,
0.0434583575,
-0.3584114015,
-0.1700145006,
-0.3849958479,
0.012390024,
0.9693241715,
0.7026237845,
0.2882496119,
0.1539058536,
-0.5683920383,
0.7379633188,
-0.3055105805,
0.0670501888,
-0.6996113658,
0.1057669818,
-0.464294225,
-0.2352288812,
-0.3893193901,
-0.1532015949,
-0.1402959675,
-0.1666680425,
0.0113745937,
0.2447470129,
0.6110633016,
0.1426254362,
-0.3686895669,
-0.3767394722,
-0.7986882329,
0.5563147068,
-0.6517140269,
0.3780484498,
0.2363335788,
-0.0121094901,
-0.8904541731,
-0.6280623674,
-0.8218301535,
0.1003568098,
-0.2575028539,
-0.3305135965,
-0.0079315864,
0.4269605875,
0.1802388132,
0.7121281624,
-0.4021906555,
0.0793346539,
-0.0560524836,
-0.1714773923,
0.6385704279,
0.2604921162,
0.5183231831,
-0.2298823893,
-0.4486263692,
0.3412057161,
-0.0966931805,
-0.0748866573,
0.5000035763,
0.1961740851,
0.075451456,
0.8003042936,
-0.1173883602,
0.8510543704,
0.3398380578,
0.1253052354,
0.0270360336,
-0.6362836361,
-0.3711155057,
0.1375920326,
0.415933758,
0.1117221117,
0.1570630074,
-0.6585147381,
-0.5745675564,
0.1985577792,
0.1160615385,
-1.0097464323,
0.1564456522,
0.7506754994,
-0.7302305698,
-0.2456887215,
0.2024573535,
-0.5868170857,
0.0388659351,
-0.3505159318,
0.5055666566,
-0.3715283275,
-0.2840187848,
0.2748035491,
-0.2206040025,
0.3363785446,
-0.4836771488,
-1.0977464914,
0.6932958961,
0.984775424,
1.0204911232,
0.0339280963,
-0.0518094525,
-0.9329771399,
0.0981678143,
-0.6844412684,
0.3852804303,
-0.3562978506,
-0.1121103019,
-0.0494778231,
-0.1184966862,
-0.0832796171,
-0.1539647579,
0.3478749394,
-0.8945135474,
0.0105896229,
-0.0840874985,
-1.0906329155,
-0.1663590968,
-0.2782211006,
-0.7723581195,
0.9131036401,
-0.0208381806,
-0.723508656,
0.467913419,
-1.1351058483,
-0.4672693908,
0.1529359221,
-0.1744716167,
0.0962961689,
0.3773184419,
0.1014541388,
0.4593572915,
0.0263624061,
0.353045702,
0.1880812645,
-0.4941972494,
0.3178299963,
-0.157151565,
1.0805950165,
0.2400885671,
-0.7312501669,
-0.0824160278,
-0.9507447481,
-0.0617354997,
0.1835269183,
-0.4373168349,
-0.5694749355,
0.1859516799,
-0.1609577239,
-0.1375686824,
0.5228633285,
-0.8078602552,
0.2992931902,
-1.1326607466,
0.4330015779,
0.8005985022,
0.2633734643,
0.3505580723,
-0.232067436,
-0.1525986642,
0.1866420805,
0.0546457209,
-0.1451619118,
-0.441961199,
-0.746697247,
-0.622271359,
0.3742401898,
0.5097591281,
-0.692094028,
0.7618460059,
0.1086369827,
-0.2554545403,
-0.2615886629,
0.1108671501,
0.5064963698,
0.112091139,
-0.082309328,
-0.8061454892,
-0.7277796268,
-0.7504914403,
0.0557869896,
-0.3438369036,
0.1722567976,
-0.2525250912,
0.367788583,
-0.1686666608,
1.1610286236,
-0.2750888169,
0.0283359569,
0.3026102483,
0.2908158302,
0.5141142607,
0.8004843593,
1.0371417999,
-0.5349108577,
-0.2683035433,
-0.0874694139,
-0.5212334394,
-0.0352693833,
-0.0672241151,
-0.5890595913,
0.7702368498,
0.4703685641,
-0.3829289973,
0.3197438717,
0.3842917085,
-0.9468314052,
0.2847391963,
-0.330414027,
0.244119063,
-0.9895060658,
0.2890388668,
-0.4272978008,
-0.3562816679,
-0.9722569585,
0.1728371978,
-0.3521986306,
-0.0321631245,
-0.1043706685,
0.5383632183,
-0.6050906777,
-0.3588312566,
-0.4386709929,
0.1509450525,
-0.3414297998,
0.5379506946,
0.0844554901,
0.6638280749,
0.5886312723,
-0.7452363968,
0.3082870543,
0.3731802106,
-0.3079006076,
0.5300768614,
-0.5088503957,
0.506038487,
-0.5245961547,
-0.232130304,
-0.9668684006,
0.2246649861,
0.2481790334,
-0.3097188473,
0.0503910519,
-0.0115623036,
-0.658601284,
-0.4596584141,
-0.0204866603,
0.4014261663,
0.1863999814,
-0.7769019008,
0.5608057976,
0.4555949569,
0.1217103377,
-0.6663967371,
-0.4427797496,
0.2076876611,
0.0566595085,
-0.6206840277,
0.6491756439,
-0.3304307461,
-0.618817687,
0.1891248524,
-0.1361638606,
-0.399119556,
0.4226118326,
-0.0387203284,
0.2544910312,
-0.1389301121,
0.1665275991,
0.0202433113,
-0.0102191698,
0.1199633628,
-0.3799847066,
0.8767335415,
-0.113125138,
-0.2974099219,
-0.4336525798,
0.5064739585,
0.5233387947,
-0.2725065649,
0.7410357594,
0.5836397409,
-0.6649335623,
-0.2497310787,
-0.6197428703,
-0.3046095073,
-0.5656506419,
0.1825994849,
-0.7957610488,
-0.6666169167,
0.694078505,
0.3096638024,
0.6555917263,
0.1897674054,
0.7755327821,
0.3463838398,
0.6564610004,
0.5708232522,
-0.2065036595,
0.6123828292,
0.1389775872,
0.2734355032,
-0.3629135489,
0.0239490476,
-0.4929880202,
-0.3163421154,
-0.6571362019,
-0.5571066141,
-0.2158997804,
0.0877760053,
-0.3812839687,
0.5739518404,
-0.5805105567,
0.5724027157,
0.6806507111,
-0.071308516,
0.4242733419,
0.0319587775,
-0.4165675044,
0.3115473986,
-0.3112607598,
-0.6074756384,
0.9247322679,
0.3900876641,
-0.0782076418,
0.4158917069,
1.1796755791,
0.5363624692,
0.0032318826,
-0.7879604697,
0.6312692761,
-0.2997139692,
-0.8020518422,
-0.3849821985,
-0.372153163,
-0.9680144191,
0.0542927161,
-0.3117716312,
-0.7249270082,
0.3795709908,
-0.1733058989,
-0.1113596037,
0.4677625299,
-0.5813578963,
0.5031355619,
-0.0848901868,
-0.0900962129,
-0.1919227093,
-0.2441633344,
0.2964976132,
-0.3218050003,
0.1445489377,
-0.1274527013,
-0.2643848658,
0.9013064504,
-0.6505315304,
0.6637499332,
-0.5118921399,
-0.3161534071,
0.4115211964,
0.2259571701,
0.4476360679,
0.1358124018,
-0.2930451632,
0.1856868267,
0.3405350447,
-0.6544916034,
-0.5312059522,
0.2236615866,
-0.5297397971,
-0.5012816191,
-0.3876427412,
-0.2563635707,
-0.1733205914,
0.4818518162,
-0.3986729383,
0.635946393,
-0.4621867537,
-0.5161504745,
0.3052706122,
0.0761210397,
1.0210853815,
0.8797233701,
-0.2391165644,
-0.5093902946,
0.6604580283,
0.1542562544,
-0.0057125301,
0.551079452,
-0.0371526107,
-0.1023972556,
-0.781116426,
-0.5513719916,
0.1519714445,
-0.5098041296,
-0.0652326047,
-0.2514623404,
-0.3130255342,
-0.3303333223,
-0.2012591362,
-0.3289683461,
-0.4248887897,
0.1015373245,
0.0323143937,
0.5329822898,
0.8695379496,
-0.3252745271,
0.1034447029,
-0.8014281988,
0.3541170657,
0.3250253201,
0.7827661633,
-0.0325636193,
-0.0820710361,
-0.1285519302,
-0.246102795,
0.3291155994,
-0.9194660187,
0.0716148391,
-0.0127522135,
0.7780851722,
0.2005828023,
-0.0370178074,
0.5120130777,
-0.6288540363,
0.4819000959,
0.0453068204,
-1.4627552032,
0.1739964336,
-0.1219407767,
-0.2281256318,
0.5167791247,
0.2381136864,
-0.445905447,
-0.1169524714,
-0.3830475211,
-0.6010971069,
0.5256158113,
0.4284044504,
0.170341745,
-0.5347198248,
0.7933028936,
-0.0128979348,
0.1194249839,
-0.3905704618,
-0.5633960366,
0.0033580945,
-0.3737512827,
0.1305782795,
-0.401607722,
0.0917997807,
0.0334104709,
0.824649334,
-0.0273643117,
0.5212717056,
0.4626587629,
0.1024558172,
0.0428701043,
0.0508968942,
0.2642368674,
0.3310727179,
-0.2715120018,
0.1091126055,
-0.2214591503,
-0.6163516641,
0.4720139503,
0.250275135,
-0.2910085917,
0.1076699719,
-0.1395501345,
0.7681485415,
-0.0231439117,
-0.7553979158,
0.3350819349,
-0.0844587162,
-0.1810469031,
-0.2018220425,
-0.2915554941,
-0.1306280047,
0.2497418523,
0.317766577,
-0.3917639256,
0.0929914117,
-0.5141928196,
0.5833143592,
0.605058074,
-0.0195484832,
-0.0996726751,
0.3579193652,
0.4182279408,
-0.425214678,
0.4585808516,
-0.665796876,
-0.2932007909,
0.5123109818,
0.5786739588,
1.1287891865,
-0.1268068254,
0.1121233255,
0.3807254732,
0.565220058,
0.1239540279,
0.5674164891,
0.0389153659,
-0.9769309759,
-0.6675493717,
-0.9863038659,
-0.4290415049,
-0.0829372555,
-0.0388159975,
0.2607650161,
-0.7424352169,
-0.2649558187,
0.2410950661,
0.2720652521,
-0.5910024643,
0.0132832285,
0.0722544268,
0.840956986,
-0.656257987,
0.6424015164,
0.758680284,
-0.4172968864,
-0.4969896078,
-0.1774429679,
-0.3325597346,
-0.7136053443,
0.8513217568,
-0.076520063,
-0.0637613386,
0.2059623897,
0.1715640277,
-1.189475894,
0.727445066,
0.1104830056,
-0.5140747428,
0.0007110043,
0.2436896563,
0.3673079312,
-0.306576997,
-0.059583202,
1.0129252672,
0.5572736263,
-0.271384269,
-1.0678509474,
0.4729325771,
-0.261115104,
0.095399268,
0.420612216,
-0.5887143016,
0.700496912,
0.2441700548,
-0.6916637421,
0.2325796634,
0.7411984801,
-0.3727912605,
0.0562058017,
0.5754398108,
0.4021191001,
0.9692314267,
0.1677110642,
0.3932122886,
-0.6681853533,
-0.0532120354,
0.8577550054,
-0.2573194504,
0.6239798665,
0.4940567017,
-0.321359396,
0.5690387487,
0.3301627636,
-0.1375225782,
0.1137674972,
0.5589616895,
-0.5512314439,
0.1356974095,
0.1084778011,
0.2073784918,
0.7575213909,
0.1177410781,
-0.45058164,
-0.215403989,
-0.2046127617,
0.0155341635,
0.3414697945,
-0.4569734335,
1.1150552034,
-0.2218340635,
-0.6211504936,
0.6725304723,
0.5882350802,
0.9626918435,
-0.3418880105,
0.2370386869,
-0.157869637,
-0.0943324864,
-0.2584429979,
-0.2768576145,
0.7577925324,
0.0665159449,
-0.3127522767,
0.1786291152,
0.6417575479,
-0.2096688449,
-0.3418782353,
0.1336945444,
0.635322094,
0.4038400948,
0.3305489123,
-0.3837248981,
-0.0710088015,
-0.372965008,
-0.2881769836,
0.104503572,
0.3680745661,
-0.1150111184,
0.2631148696,
0.6149742603,
-0.0396416485,
0.2065833211,
-0.1150054559,
0.5099300742,
-0.7336465716,
-0.4841882586,
-1.0697817802,
0.095057033,
-0.088257499,
0.1293575764,
0.4664509892,
0.5885695219,
0.540181756,
0.0034697279,
0.6349599957,
-0.4777483046,
0.189592272,
-0.5347048044,
0.5552473664,
-0.0726688504,
-0.1060918123,
-0.2801183462,
-0.8635808825,
-0.2108874172,
0.5515645146,
0.101545997,
-0.3282104135,
0.7352280617,
0.7334666848,
0.3149156272,
0.0620917305,
0.1206620261,
-0.0477232561,
0.2728574574,
0.4313078225,
-0.0740837231,
-0.4594208896,
0.1508037597,
-0.3940262198,
-0.5579530001,
0.1384422034,
-1.2310913801,
-1.1168694496,
-0.7541653514,
-0.2866870761,
-0.3013163805,
0.0868580639,
1.2279660702,
0.4253280461,
-0.8692928553,
-0.2526382506,
-0.5581719875,
0.249635458,
-0.5040268302,
-0.2352226228,
0.5447063446,
-0.795198679,
-1.3141596317,
0.5427103043,
0.1877187937,
0.3925435543,
-0.4846375287,
0.0808980539,
-0.2523414493,
0.8175922036,
0.715832293,
0.1805655211,
-0.2381894588,
-0.5236157775,
-0.2306783646,
-0.0231086686,
-0.098971054,
0.8385853171,
-0.5948835611,
0.4424131811,
0.7687427402,
0.9553985,
0.2177520096,
-0.0244981237,
0.8278048038,
-0.6943475008,
0.3486120403,
-0.1459007561,
0.4003835022,
0.063896507,
-0.271891892,
0.6557794213,
0.4268579781,
-0.4008734524,
-0.793379724,
0.4404803813,
-0.8701713681,
-0.2614887953,
0.7450564504,
-0.0270177536,
-0.3739842474,
-0.5007553101,
-0.2245259881,
0.327342391,
-0.1735613495,
0.8149235845,
0.6791009903,
0.0348946005,
0.6656424403,
0.0581982695,
0.6454889178,
0.3634243608,
-0.6482943892,
0.0389260091,
0.4022983313,
0.4174591899,
0.2568464279,
1.1211367846,
-0.3175016046,
0.0317560658,
0.2665669918,
0.1413644254,
-0.1986775547,
0.1467747092,
-0.2087599486,
0.2905322611,
0.2467769384,
-0.4216691554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07667v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07667v1
|
Backdoor Removal for Generative Large Language Models
| 2024-05-13T11:53:42 | 2024-05-13T11:53:42 |
Haoran Li, Yulin Chen, Zihao Zheng, Qi Hu, Chunkit Chan, Heshan Liu, Yangqiu Song
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL
|
With rapid advances, generative large language models (LLMs) dominate various
Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks from understanding to reasoning. Yet,
language models' inherent vulnerabilities may be exacerbated due to increased
accessibility and unrestricted model training on massive textual data from the
Internet. A malicious adversary may publish poisoned data online and conduct
backdoor attacks on the victim LLMs pre-trained on the poisoned data.
Backdoored LLMs behave innocuously for normal queries and generate harmful
responses when the backdoor trigger is activated. Despite significant efforts
paid to LLMs' safety issues, LLMs are still struggling against backdoor
attacks. As Anthropic recently revealed, existing safety training strategies,
including supervised fine-tuning (SFT) and Reinforcement Learning from Human
Feedback (RLHF), fail to revoke the backdoors once the LLM is backdoored during
the pre-training stage. In this paper, we present Simulate and Eliminate
(SANDE) to erase the undesired backdoored mappings for generative LLMs. We
initially propose Overwrite Supervised Fine-tuning (OSFT) for effective
backdoor removal when the trigger is known. Then, to handle the scenarios where
the trigger patterns are unknown, we integrate OSFT into our two-stage
framework, SANDE. Unlike previous works that center on the identification of
backdoors, our safety-enhanced LLMs are able to behave normally even when the
exact triggers are activated. We conduct comprehensive experiments to show that
our proposed SANDE is effective against backdoor attacks while bringing minimal
harm to LLMs' powerful capability without any additional access to unbackdoored
clean models. We will release the reproducible code.
|
[
-0.2724876702,
-1.0764479637,
0.4546002746,
-0.0047677718,
-0.1244435012,
-0.0032525705,
-0.4010124207,
-0.4814780951,
-0.2980312705,
0.8849719763,
-0.6210030913,
-0.8198361397,
-0.5823068023,
-0.3082357049,
-0.7029733658,
1.1137186289,
0.1166279987,
-0.3021042347,
0.0341839828,
0.169347167,
-0.1923426986,
-0.6212095618,
-0.7931450009,
-0.2802122831,
0.4182910323,
0.0972180068,
0.6862574816,
0.4553678632,
0.3066839576,
0.3294943869,
-0.1970296353,
-0.2337863445,
-0.9833056331,
0.2286853641,
-0.3849129677,
-0.4767035246,
-0.4476715624,
-0.0407351442,
0.4866292775,
0.3934655786,
-0.4651580155,
-0.025140563,
0.0590290911,
0.4575482011,
-0.7305228114,
0.0292165037,
-0.9729889035,
0.2188655585,
-0.0559796728,
-0.3772340417,
-0.6121284366,
-0.3240813017,
-0.3006671071,
-0.4043484926,
0.3446682394,
0.1064813435,
0.6966510415,
0.2515430748,
-0.1045716256,
0.0058121709,
-0.6740578413,
0.6474670768,
-0.8423596025,
0.427054137,
0.3361572027,
0.1314466596,
-0.811316669,
-0.463070333,
-0.496530354,
-0.3086728454,
0.0534315631,
0.0430818126,
-0.235807687,
0.183601588,
0.3704214394,
0.2950086594,
-0.7138890028,
0.6376240253,
-0.3155407608,
-0.3393544257,
0.7682893276,
0.27331236,
0.1427748501,
0.096697025,
-0.4132677913,
-0.10393776,
-1.1618995667,
-0.1248235181,
0.5128361583,
0.2203151137,
0.0052351225,
0.4609272182,
-0.1406257451,
0.5126076937,
-0.0346785076,
-0.1006038785,
0.1465001106,
0.0545040704,
-0.2548090219,
-0.1265756935,
0.7084092498,
0.2813279629,
0.3352991343,
-0.4923755527,
-0.5048514009,
-0.0515912399,
0.3755528033,
-0.8257015347,
-0.0524178967,
0.4050251842,
-0.4696484208,
-0.6401183009,
-0.088887386,
-0.9197950959,
-0.4687587917,
0.0556469262,
0.5762687922,
-0.4515996277,
-0.3130503893,
0.1270980239,
-0.0174923167,
0.3991472721,
0.4165783525,
-0.7845894694,
0.4007562995,
0.9501396418,
0.5032286048,
-0.0522274673,
-0.385234952,
-0.8179785013,
0.3122530282,
-0.4212269187,
0.1974457502,
-0.3651596308,
-0.4982473254,
0.1109361574,
0.0982625112,
0.108595714,
-0.722196281,
0.0785334855,
-0.9227280617,
0.0669395775,
0.2019066513,
-0.4593445063,
-0.3300029337,
0.4580969214,
-0.4612428546,
0.7038477063,
-0.2018273324,
-0.3991312683,
-0.0049124821,
-0.3758692145,
-0.5725383759,
-0.2093292922,
0.0034886762,
-0.62892133,
0.1339103431,
0.25004071,
0.4848952591,
-0.0946507901,
0.2656860352,
-0.4471370876,
-0.4466534257,
0.0215427075,
-0.568846643,
0.8856834769,
0.1924313307,
-0.4488665462,
0.2279263586,
-0.8248369694,
-0.0198790133,
0.1765501052,
-0.295327425,
-0.306483686,
-0.0605154969,
-0.1175341904,
0.3131220341,
-0.0312379953,
-0.7473236918,
0.043266207,
-0.8643631339,
0.2228702456,
0.9442657828,
0.2150460333,
0.2570874691,
-0.2171224654,
0.6090746522,
-0.0105139138,
0.3103335202,
-0.1817560345,
-0.455453068,
-0.4698277712,
-0.4093106389,
0.0538255423,
0.6262398958,
-0.6998755336,
0.4829395115,
-0.0856254399,
-0.436571151,
-0.2654701471,
0.2814635336,
0.7020354271,
0.2466415167,
0.3150402009,
-0.2069755346,
-0.2492913604,
-0.5951092839,
-0.3240492642,
0.0465644747,
-0.2171156555,
-0.0358801819,
0.6381406784,
-0.3208066225,
0.8165439367,
-0.5519091487,
-0.2867677808,
0.0430566259,
0.2020234317,
-0.0356924795,
0.6748144031,
0.4599200189,
-0.6713622212,
-0.0286125857,
-0.1804271936,
-0.7526674271,
-0.0743804872,
-0.1272315681,
0.0996459052,
0.2296726108,
0.7532568574,
-0.6164723635,
0.689147532,
0.6275842786,
0.0857513845,
0.4942239523,
-0.1881432533,
-0.0405481718,
-0.9209322929,
-0.0158098862,
-0.1845990717,
-0.2252828926,
-0.5042772889,
0.6607123017,
0.0751361325,
-0.462521553,
-0.5050730705,
0.5757674575,
-0.2158230841,
-0.0884716362,
-0.1484374255,
-0.0708454624,
-0.1977349222,
0.6964079142,
-0.0673233271,
0.6823837161,
0.3833103776,
-0.4435479343,
0.3855792582,
0.0877409279,
-0.0327681825,
0.2567153573,
-0.5627928376,
0.1706862748,
-0.1640120298,
0.4103477299,
-0.937061429,
-0.1499529481,
0.4667176902,
-0.3103606105,
0.4762315452,
-0.3114563227,
-0.688567698,
-0.1310341507,
-0.5200909376,
0.1221462935,
0.6579162478,
-0.7499993443,
0.5853599906,
0.0796246082,
-0.1279704571,
-0.3252153397,
-0.4195300639,
0.1273877025,
-0.1253938526,
-0.5414279699,
0.1679067016,
-0.0040458078,
-0.0724520758,
-0.116052337,
-0.028994374,
-0.172578156,
0.4306208491,
0.6281334758,
0.1470509171,
-0.1014794335,
0.2568838,
0.0158529505,
-0.2539343238,
0.2554270923,
-0.0694352686,
0.6566718221,
-0.0781182498,
-0.550994277,
-0.4242598116,
0.4132259488,
0.5343869328,
-0.405834198,
0.8983448744,
0.5795554519,
-0.5223199129,
-0.2365231216,
-0.6269258857,
-0.5124437213,
-0.5109007955,
0.5515114069,
-0.293035388,
-0.8259634376,
0.5201867819,
-0.149485603,
0.3420779407,
0.2194311768,
0.4218807817,
-0.0533692166,
0.8672693372,
0.4816672504,
-0.148926571,
0.2669794559,
-0.2883231938,
0.2874836326,
-0.6848946214,
-0.225385353,
-0.4538300931,
-0.0112907169,
-0.5954731703,
-0.0489205904,
0.3148585856,
0.2022482306,
-0.2006597668,
0.1943324357,
-0.0710308477,
0.4801776707,
0.4028485417,
0.3945449889,
0.3557964861,
-0.0561523438,
0.0134526873,
0.1033702269,
-0.4809155762,
-0.2313529998,
1.078348279,
0.5180997849,
1.1117492914,
0.065796949,
0.9801064134,
-0.0778776407,
0.4441949725,
-0.5482099056,
0.7225144506,
-0.0524299815,
-0.6184643507,
-0.3957192004,
-0.4722335339,
-0.8329440951,
0.2694422901,
-0.3795181513,
-0.7723292112,
-0.1699802279,
0.3835420012,
-0.4604983628,
0.6264533401,
-0.6259130836,
0.6668916941,
-0.0514419787,
-0.4068461955,
-0.5433217883,
-0.7215158939,
0.6753670573,
-0.417391777,
0.2950989008,
0.1046292931,
0.244606778,
0.4179284573,
-0.480763793,
1.1653130054,
-0.0952428877,
-0.5004389882,
-0.1476421654,
0.2658961713,
0.8120574951,
0.1495041549,
-0.0127887605,
0.3598851562,
-0.2312608808,
-0.1988745034,
-0.5668050647,
0.6963350177,
-0.5453701615,
-0.9465218186,
-0.3019171953,
-0.4004293978,
-0.1969168037,
0.1124277562,
0.3281963468,
0.2953870893,
-0.0684518591,
0.1982003897,
0.8051398993,
-0.6838872433,
0.4490469098,
0.7276627421,
-0.3141289949,
-0.1589076966,
0.7802676558,
-0.2248536199,
0.4903638959,
0.319939971,
0.1790974736,
-0.0717825741,
-0.774281323,
-0.1262508929,
0.0337922908,
-0.4899635017,
-0.3147654533,
-0.5790320039,
-0.6217835546,
-0.3947050571,
-0.0976141766,
-0.4699016511,
0.0120479586,
-0.1792043746,
-0.0945806056,
0.4260368645,
0.4092972577,
-0.2125355154,
0.5063834786,
-0.9769025445,
0.4726338983,
0.4255434871,
0.4330458939,
0.1071094647,
-0.4081504345,
-0.0208392907,
0.129003346,
-0.3052498102,
-0.6261654496,
0.4461760521,
0.0642132685,
0.4054302871,
0.3712375462,
0.1230076998,
0.4936004579,
-0.5515540838,
0.4948068261,
0.1671757698,
-0.7622999549,
0.5602088571,
-0.4211798012,
-0.0387538932,
0.2715560496,
0.1191297993,
-0.3955229521,
-0.7315980792,
-0.6177095175,
-0.9174954891,
0.4187388122,
0.1484554708,
0.1778239161,
0.1443113685,
0.4336875677,
0.2062358856,
0.4779326916,
-0.6006142497,
-0.0688369498,
-0.0069900542,
0.0498823225,
-0.0861267671,
-0.3731334507,
-0.1640278101,
-0.0737917945,
0.8061023951,
0.2391436249,
-0.0934695974,
-0.2164530903,
-0.1966705322,
-0.3189297318,
0.4715138972,
0.4668337703,
0.2922030389,
-0.276314944,
0.0567644462,
0.267955035,
-0.4424770772,
0.1258332431,
0.0154919503,
-0.2477058619,
-0.4218384027,
0.5111418962,
0.4001477361,
0.4120729864,
-0.6486203671,
0.5705230832,
0.1409010887,
-0.0361441113,
-0.3657247424,
0.4408627748,
-0.0683222786,
0.1948081255,
0.1600008756,
0.0589258112,
0.0374361761,
-0.6576156616,
0.3848125637,
0.5522640347,
-0.19652237,
-0.2608843744,
0.5042409301,
0.196592018,
-0.3898032606,
0.7591760755,
-0.0711014718,
-0.7008519173,
0.5225331187,
0.6226345301,
0.8489729762,
-0.3278680742,
-0.0678338185,
0.1235604137,
0.5623960495,
0.0423223749,
0.0913324282,
0.2360659838,
-0.7927980423,
-0.2452105433,
-0.603208065,
-0.1261637807,
0.5401121974,
-0.5866819024,
-0.080079332,
-0.7368508577,
0.1888636351,
-0.2689887285,
-0.2333763093,
-0.4112770259,
0.2697241902,
0.0031813821,
0.6917072535,
-0.9658750892,
0.8455132842,
0.2067487091,
-0.2775016725,
-0.7523954511,
0.2211809903,
0.2521023452,
-0.8804858923,
0.5610017776,
0.0516050868,
-0.2401895672,
0.2463925183,
-0.792794466,
-0.4965572953,
0.6388837695,
0.4056752026,
-0.7282575965,
0.0415184051,
-0.1615227163,
0.4684018195,
0.1263551712,
-0.2971312702,
0.5000705123,
0.3305444419,
0.0517053902,
-0.68290627,
0.1640889943,
-0.0302923843,
0.076486364,
0.3140540719,
-0.3634440601,
0.808802247,
-0.364125967,
-0.1449279189,
0.2804264426,
0.3806459308,
0.4603663981,
0.203061834,
0.5172222853,
0.7915180922,
0.3144620061,
-0.051656127,
0.8544534445,
-0.1038853973,
0.3011359274,
1.3502064943,
-0.4171276689,
1.0041059256,
0.5957675576,
0.079169251,
0.1396885961,
0.3095001876,
-0.161194399,
0.6179301739,
0.4168306589,
-0.2206522375,
-0.2937036455,
0.2671154439,
-0.5271883607,
0.605235517,
0.3631037474,
-0.2653848827,
-0.5625447035,
0.2831722796,
0.1358641982,
0.2644132972,
-0.2673531771,
0.817381382,
0.0840723738,
-0.3030110002,
0.5038741231,
0.2007238418,
0.6146903634,
-0.6318029761,
-0.1678886563,
-0.1779277027,
0.3266742527,
-0.2689402103,
-0.6559248567,
0.3027339578,
-0.0538293719,
0.0466246344,
-0.198242709,
0.6451123953,
-0.440893501,
-0.1175504103,
0.5393176079,
0.0966024697,
-0.0136889247,
-0.3019438684,
-0.4374573231,
0.1004370824,
-0.1470857114,
-0.4204219878,
0.5167912245,
0.2260533869,
-0.0441462845,
0.8000550866,
0.979986012,
0.2496800721,
0.1027286053,
0.0304789227,
1.0463215113,
-0.6745432615,
-0.4979149103,
-0.8797958493,
0.1974999607,
-0.0673343018,
0.0088643497,
0.6914957762,
0.5734656453,
0.8203285933,
-0.131967172,
0.6192766428,
0.2981421053,
0.405002147,
-0.8104509711,
0.9983710051,
-0.4550100565,
0.6072682142,
-0.2200064957,
-0.6404394507,
-0.3477051258,
0.3890759945,
-0.3117280602,
0.0242775083,
0.3859483004,
1.2352025509,
0.0275259167,
0.1042548716,
0.5039008856,
0.5741831064,
0.5764416456,
0.6124126911,
0.9094756246,
-0.4288417399,
0.4820922911,
-0.2771025896,
-0.3177716136,
-0.3398768604,
-0.8748546839,
-0.9846405983,
-0.1840718687,
-0.1657014787,
-0.3986500204,
0.5837224722,
0.8076309562,
0.5933339,
-0.9353374243,
0.0923137963,
-0.1224436462,
0.1870312095,
-0.2233149707,
-0.2076374143,
0.1298657507,
-0.2532219589,
-0.2315834314,
0.4026232362,
0.3627477288,
0.0635425895,
-0.2707187831,
-0.0148873432,
-0.0124945743,
-0.2048254758,
0.5116642714,
0.4056073725,
-0.8441137671,
-0.5279033184,
-0.4197155833,
-0.3313956559,
-0.1193411276,
0.522608757,
-0.7833006978,
0.2795935273,
0.3140443861,
0.5500383377,
0.3941111267,
-0.1405434906,
0.7864357233,
-0.9937103391,
0.4250151217,
0.2602750659,
0.1701738089,
-0.0417006537,
-0.5510231853,
0.2974791825,
0.1108835861,
-0.1781684756,
-0.783600688,
0.4001314044,
-0.5495539308,
-0.5260058641,
1.1582422256,
-0.3203544915,
-0.2076008618,
-0.1282094568,
-0.0649918616,
0.2526237071,
-0.2103281766,
1.0541696548,
0.3799436688,
0.459012866,
-0.0720034763,
-0.4415747225,
0.4937128723,
0.1423949599,
-0.9659435749,
0.1999023706,
0.468521297,
0.5233237147,
-0.1436452717,
0.3429072201,
-0.3039961457,
0.3391972184,
-0.1623347551,
0.1415294409,
-0.2822225094,
-0.3971792758,
-0.6101232767,
0.3515231311,
-0.1227576733,
-0.2480175942
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07663v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07663v1
|
Sign Stitching: A Novel Approach to Sign Language Production
| 2024-05-13T11:44:57 | 2024-05-13T11:44:57 |
Harry Walsh, Ben Saunders, Richard Bowden
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Sign Language Production (SLP) is a challenging task, given the limited
resources available and the inherent diversity within sign data. As a result,
previous works have suffered from the problem of regression to the mean,
leading to under-articulated and incomprehensible signing. In this paper, we
propose using dictionary examples and a learnt codebook of facial expressions
to create expressive sign language sequences. However, simply concatenating
signs and adding the face creates robotic and unnatural sequences. To address
this we present a 7-step approach to effectively stitch sequences together.
First, by normalizing each sign into a canonical pose, cropping, and stitching
we create a continuous sequence. Then, by applying filtering in the frequency
domain and resampling each sign, we create cohesive natural sequences that
mimic the prosody found in the original data. We leverage a SignGAN model to
map the output to a photo-realistic signer and present a complete Text-to-Sign
(T2S) SLP pipeline. Our evaluation demonstrates the effectiveness of the
approach, showcasing state-of-the-art performance across all datasets. Finally,
a user evaluation shows our approach outperforms the baseline model and is
capable of producing realistic sign language sequences.
|
[
0.1137322336,
-0.0071254824,
0.1491606683,
0.0537108965,
-0.437045753,
0.3685681224,
0.1923143566,
-0.6476615667,
0.6658255458,
0.5868288875,
-0.5814418793,
-0.6941593885,
-0.6232146621,
-0.0149653116,
-0.4562867284,
0.9449162483,
0.0134432968,
-0.0311617423,
0.3860604465,
-0.2703444362,
-0.1818882972,
-0.1598874331,
-0.5877045989,
0.0132314181,
0.0776921138,
0.305056572,
0.9511957765,
0.5906502008,
0.308914423,
0.2192241848,
-0.0045782477,
0.5434598923,
-0.209335953,
0.1487751752,
0.4093987048,
-0.1745983809,
-0.5261203647,
0.2265606821,
0.6357572079,
0.6808549166,
0.2519110441,
0.2302800864,
-0.1433289647,
0.6136188507,
-0.1983817369,
-0.2148329765,
-0.469810605,
0.2325011343,
-0.3416690528,
0.3006233275,
-0.3776924014,
-0.6030499935,
-0.3166790605,
-0.3891362548,
0.221602574,
-0.0432185195,
0.4868202806,
0.0817010477,
-0.2549884915,
-0.4074045122,
-0.6641632318,
0.270560652,
-1.1158269644,
0.3200219572,
0.0722569302,
0.2703804076,
-0.0868942738,
-0.6310493946,
-0.6931448579,
-0.2067051828,
0.0044663637,
0.0008135972,
0.4301416278,
0.0052605211,
0.4628391564,
0.4706243277,
-0.8249133825,
-0.1045681089,
-0.3704922795,
-0.1956913024,
0.9865378737,
0.0608981252,
0.5976657271,
-0.0299425665,
-0.5638056397,
-0.294318527,
-0.5713876486,
0.0221435986,
0.4461863637,
0.6767348647,
-0.1310102791,
0.6389950514,
-0.0602269173,
0.8888203502,
0.0484505966,
-0.2454688549,
-0.0131009249,
-0.0928949267,
0.0222160053,
-0.2840980589,
0.8839023709,
0.3427915573,
0.3421765268,
-0.113329649,
-0.4424381256,
0.135475114,
0.0704822317,
-0.1701323986,
-0.1941746622,
0.1914683431,
-0.1639156491,
-0.2096539438,
0.1228836402,
-0.5854223967,
-0.6226482987,
-0.5377278328,
0.5043404698,
-0.3501826227,
-0.3295107484,
0.0604389124,
-0.0617251545,
0.2386993319,
0.1205405593,
-0.7166880965,
0.3335806131,
0.6224069595,
1.1161724329,
-0.1066519171,
-0.066366069,
-0.5746284723,
-0.0824730247,
-0.3646752536,
0.3662363291,
-0.2487735748,
-0.1958174706,
0.2647101581,
-0.3011262119,
-0.0551818237,
-0.4487172067,
0.3024631441,
-0.3465079069,
0.1252092719,
0.2603916526,
-0.5091451406,
0.1057033837,
-0.1545556784,
-0.730153203,
0.914562881,
0.421107173,
0.0343423449,
0.2757124305,
-0.3815284371,
-0.8180151582,
0.2296945006,
-0.0549946465,
-0.3707618415,
0.1824242473,
-0.2216610759,
0.5209640265,
0.0504767932,
-0.0627766922,
-0.1110010371,
-0.1900520772,
0.2658976614,
0.1910849065,
0.763928175,
0.2969552875,
-0.4257720113,
-0.0043749693,
-0.94780159,
0.121834226,
-0.0821448192,
-0.0241173226,
-0.063401565,
-0.376881361,
0.175088495,
0.6347919703,
-0.1286861002,
-0.2780902386,
0.3505296409,
-0.4189863205,
0.2955631018,
0.319037348,
-0.1621714085,
0.4881265461,
-0.340936929,
0.6492599845,
-0.1358646303,
0.2825532556,
-0.4143126309,
-0.7136278152,
-0.9127155542,
-0.0482715443,
-0.0800548419,
0.4299069643,
-0.7967802882,
0.2914152145,
0.0251630377,
-0.6687295437,
-0.6486435533,
0.1876093745,
0.7763952613,
0.4281929135,
0.2243806273,
-1.0212516785,
-0.5794193745,
-0.4609164,
-0.4212674797,
-0.2945186496,
-0.1084347516,
-0.4217199981,
0.1123014092,
0.390686661,
0.4873543978,
-0.5431409478,
-0.6959820986,
-0.0316036642,
0.1518740058,
0.5846062303,
0.6630731821,
0.1804273874,
-0.5548429489,
-0.4679112732,
-0.0534770116,
-0.5010966063,
-0.057860788,
-0.754905045,
-0.0905064046,
0.3786866665,
0.4935050607,
-0.7526626587,
0.303558141,
0.6857508421,
-0.5546240807,
0.5447584987,
0.0490993261,
0.1057083905,
-0.9851098061,
-0.0230167117,
0.0858784243,
-0.5306203365,
-1.0656774044,
0.3163439035,
-0.2974685133,
-0.5894734859,
-0.7024595141,
0.2458145022,
-0.8269556761,
-0.2820188105,
-0.2098099887,
0.2179661095,
-0.0874647647,
0.5177458525,
0.0372756273,
0.2696286142,
0.2833807766,
-0.3810097873,
0.3461570144,
0.4686179757,
-0.4144690931,
0.3862217069,
-0.4690262973,
0.3524902761,
0.1975001097,
0.1091564223,
-1.1105984449,
-0.1886159629,
0.5146426558,
-0.5099487305,
0.6622049212,
-0.1560193002,
-0.0795419738,
-0.418913126,
-0.1890969425,
0.1417407691,
0.872363925,
-0.4069906175,
0.6167530417,
0.4439736605,
0.0307854898,
-0.0885777995,
-0.6451737285,
0.4686155021,
-0.2820640802,
-0.8076702356,
0.1448024958,
0.0444054678,
0.066878058,
-0.7442049384,
-0.0477487147,
-0.0134127159,
-0.0499530137,
0.1741513759,
0.0763078332,
-0.1477601528,
-0.1917208135,
-0.3022761643,
-0.1601551622,
-0.175509125,
-0.3294031918,
0.3554468155,
0.1084876433,
-0.5432168841,
-0.8191328049,
0.4615325928,
0.8261193633,
0.1036246717,
0.2258197665,
0.5059412122,
-0.5936788321,
-0.2453338355,
-0.206684649,
-0.0516692698,
-0.3823150098,
-0.0285919476,
-0.2926590741,
-0.6262963414,
0.3097584546,
-0.2443275154,
0.3403614163,
0.0555904433,
0.3129101694,
-0.3320968449,
0.8144423366,
0.2920319736,
0.3547379673,
0.6238614917,
-0.152987197,
0.4371771812,
-0.5867714882,
-0.1183683351,
-0.2634975314,
-0.5039367676,
-0.2287712246,
-0.9155679941,
0.2281510979,
0.2580462098,
-0.0576762743,
1.0792064667,
-0.6009691358,
0.3333874047,
0.5369663239,
0.2825392783,
0.3917904794,
-0.1714802086,
0.2011200339,
-0.14308016,
-0.4840205312,
-0.8844596744,
0.605373323,
0.1242366657,
0.54316926,
0.0871695504,
0.7745633721,
0.3739895821,
0.3390572369,
-0.5503267646,
0.6799755692,
-0.3869198561,
-0.1960425824,
-0.3723647594,
0.2073231786,
-0.4183855653,
0.1418823451,
-0.575571537,
-0.5532311797,
-0.0829334408,
0.6172623634,
-0.2082286924,
0.0941913351,
-0.9001356959,
0.7491292357,
-0.2552847862,
-0.1289730072,
0.178003937,
-1.0153895617,
0.6726518869,
-0.0928789675,
0.3272512853,
-0.2883591056,
0.111890994,
0.4777186513,
-0.6337988973,
1.3335779905,
-0.2063571364,
-0.3907294273,
0.4070156813,
0.3544744253,
0.563141346,
-0.2937445641,
-0.0608165152,
0.0234906487,
-0.1479919255,
-0.1962416321,
-0.561917901,
0.425855428,
-0.2340656221,
-0.4593442082,
-0.1579769105,
-0.3947433531,
-0.2490968257,
-0.0193651021,
-0.0275529008,
0.4402314126,
-0.2742043734,
-0.5695991516,
0.2000541091,
0.0958591998,
0.572026968,
0.1237121671,
-0.1768344194,
-0.5992931128,
0.8002406955,
-0.0417003483,
0.7281699181,
0.1278136522,
0.1029018834,
-0.3546679914,
-0.42659536,
-0.6164976954,
0.4291077852,
-0.4854810238,
-0.3462429643,
-0.1267988682,
0.0788294822,
-0.9029162526,
-0.3323984146,
-0.3132824004,
-0.9454519749,
-0.0123740258,
0.2577128112,
0.2316223234,
0.7285789251,
-0.2972219884,
0.4055118263,
-0.8554127812,
0.4935658574,
0.2689278424,
0.211705476,
-0.1028949544,
-0.2926825881,
-0.2110542506,
0.0671772137,
-0.407535553,
-0.9259750843,
0.4607337117,
0.7328216434,
0.0124041429,
0.4180885255,
0.3476743102,
0.8403944373,
-0.5292778611,
1.0100029707,
0.8324243426,
-1.1728135347,
0.7447435856,
-0.3819758594,
0.3459680974,
0.17391105,
0.2577510178,
-0.9807298779,
-0.774958849,
-0.6648263335,
-0.942650497,
0.5207329988,
0.2167215198,
0.1620882601,
-0.0544383042,
0.2885071337,
0.0769983009,
-0.0290684234,
-0.5824777484,
0.1751431227,
-0.1763694286,
-0.4398111701,
-0.1501918435,
0.1862215251,
-0.355312705,
-0.0516435206,
0.7952216864,
-0.398224622,
-0.0388049074,
0.0903976634,
-0.4371886253,
-0.1688804924,
-0.2170990556,
0.823797524,
0.4602571428,
0.2650766969,
0.1742698252,
-0.0822505653,
-0.4063188434,
0.031124264,
-0.3985208571,
-0.2814303935,
0.4481494427,
0.5083990693,
0.9731372595,
0.0384871066,
-0.5217005014,
0.5891478062,
0.3743683994,
-0.1108663455,
-0.3220089078,
0.0033968429,
0.1431990415,
0.3161340952,
0.0571152307,
0.2060208917,
-0.0405197553,
-0.4020573497,
0.2925943434,
0.2373809814,
-0.4421437681,
-0.5402279496,
0.7984706759,
0.3151398599,
-0.9259879589,
0.4683251381,
0.128469646,
-0.552634716,
0.560200274,
0.6883440018,
0.8168151379,
-0.3305918574,
0.5158641338,
0.6241157651,
0.2687249184,
-0.1399585605,
0.4743650556,
-0.1683721095,
-0.507134378,
-0.3833789229,
-0.5090696216,
-0.5050931573,
-0.2188933343,
-0.5423716903,
0.4660129249,
-0.4687942564,
-0.0803922638,
-0.2102191746,
-0.3510929346,
-0.4100787938,
0.5307450294,
0.611528635,
0.8111289144,
-1.4152439833,
0.3608370423,
0.5694086552,
-0.6219867468,
-0.6428266168,
-0.1005964205,
0.2852455676,
-1.1673005819,
0.2475676984,
0.4048174918,
-0.0357019529,
-0.0084317317,
-0.4478383958,
-0.6790258884,
0.7548805475,
0.2875942886,
-0.5233342052,
0.0439898595,
0.4279858172,
0.6726158857,
-0.5151527524,
-0.2136084735,
0.7658714056,
0.158232078,
0.5460264087,
-0.5631981492,
0.3399206698,
-0.1185018495,
0.1394800395,
0.3426936269,
-0.5165302157,
-0.0475756451,
-0.4722153842,
-0.5705289841,
0.4043092728,
0.8948742151,
0.2611257732,
0.4124454558,
0.6026648879,
0.5579847693,
0.673235476,
-0.0796648711,
0.5000992417,
-0.4033168256,
0.1443467438,
0.9891889095,
-0.2203564942,
0.8613948822,
0.6306699514,
-0.3410031199,
0.2770169079,
0.5296292305,
0.1734471619,
0.2141146064,
0.5977534652,
-0.4955797195,
-0.3867343366,
-0.1735220402,
0.0908987671,
0.3659705222,
0.186513409,
-0.3775702417,
0.0681487694,
-0.029664753,
0.0040868125,
0.4780361056,
0.002432188,
0.7736383677,
0.3478340805,
-0.7165289521,
0.4938660264,
-0.6636232734,
0.600337863,
-0.5221840143,
-0.0853541568,
-0.3212921917,
0.0395193323,
-0.268197298,
-0.8781834245,
0.7139199376,
-0.1421544999,
0.0617619269,
-0.8118308783,
0.6772329807,
-0.7291215062,
-0.3229687214,
-0.2040403634,
0.2111665457,
0.6809496284,
0.4342925251,
-0.4752022326,
0.0993736461,
-0.0375576429,
0.0380483232,
0.1048784852,
0.1797595024,
-0.1727650315,
0.2685652971,
0.78244555,
0.155755803,
0.1112950146,
0.4867609441,
0.5347819924,
-0.6253780723,
-0.2854644954,
-0.3646751642,
0.9180995822,
-0.1505238861,
-0.748075068,
0.2760375738,
0.3077852726,
0.7500526905,
-0.3843555748,
0.5193344951,
-0.2489444613,
0.378115654,
-0.5271416903,
0.674005568,
-0.2478133887,
-0.1478400677,
-0.5700631738,
-0.7572260499,
-0.8693991303,
0.4340631664,
0.4135832191,
-0.2780158818,
0.296179533,
0.8713496327,
0.2587489188,
-0.138033852,
0.5955309272,
-0.0986981764,
0.1830717474,
0.7110086679,
0.5684550405,
-0.9543584585,
0.3936577737,
-0.043920178,
-0.3431295455,
0.1539273858,
-1.0782221556,
-0.5904297829,
-0.9987013936,
-0.6832686663,
-0.5146484375,
-0.0910104364,
0.9484513402,
0.7813693881,
-0.8218108416,
-0.3976589739,
0.0630473122,
-0.0030287593,
-0.5545457006,
-0.1076182276,
0.2171174735,
-0.3201644421,
-0.8520069122,
0.4731000364,
0.2195476294,
0.3788336515,
-0.073159188,
-0.1706160307,
-0.1437087804,
-0.2189615667,
0.5808506012,
0.7287830114,
-0.5108220577,
-0.2605594099,
-0.3394671381,
0.0747475997,
-0.1311890334,
0.9328020215,
-0.6149442196,
0.5228969455,
0.5486981273,
0.3656100035,
0.3995499313,
-0.1017915383,
0.9066904783,
-1.0077066422,
-0.1229225248,
0.2320363075,
0.207491383,
0.6208020449,
-0.2678483427,
0.5739760399,
0.4422212839,
-0.1819417626,
-0.6316619515,
0.6068378091,
-1.1181851625,
0.1901988983,
0.9244023561,
-0.1811398119,
-0.0987628847,
-0.1471284479,
-0.1759565622,
0.6307959557,
-0.0377041399,
0.7092344165,
0.2395546734,
-0.3445089459,
-0.1427142024,
0.200871706,
0.5656352043,
0.1395372748,
-0.4527319074,
0.0808591694,
0.6750497222,
-0.0217486471,
0.2796643972,
0.6235612035,
-0.088295646,
0.2743484676,
0.0720253214,
0.3209997118,
0.0038191602,
-0.0991387442,
-0.3772325218,
0.1119202152,
0.1362298578,
-0.3799713552
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13009v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13009v1
|
METAREFLECTION: Learning Instructions for Language Agents using Past Reflections
| 2024-05-13T10:51:43 | 2024-05-13T10:51:43 |
Priyanshu Gupta, Shashank Kirtania, Ananya Singha, Sumit Gulwani, Arjun Radhakrishna, Sherry Shi, Gustavo Soares
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite the popularity of Large Language Models (LLMs), crafting specific
prompts for LLMs to perform particular tasks remains challenging. Users often
engage in multiple conversational turns with an LLM-based agent to accomplish
their intended task. Recent studies have demonstrated that linguistic feedback,
in the form of self-reflections generated by the model, can work as
reinforcement during these conversations, thus enabling quicker convergence to
the desired outcome. Motivated by these findings, we introduce METAREFLECTION,
a novel technique that learns general prompt instructions for a specific domain
from individual self-reflections gathered during a training phase. We evaluate
our technique in two domains: Infrastructure as Code (IAC) vulnerability
detection and question-answering (QA) using REACT and COT. Our results
demonstrate a notable improvement, with METARELECTION outperforming GPT-4 by
16.82% (IAC), 31.33% (COT), and 15.42% (REACT), underscoring the potential of
METAREFLECTION as a viable method for enhancing the efficiency of LLMs.
|
[
-0.4952706993,
-0.7069382668,
0.7438610792,
0.1645527631,
-0.0691899881,
0.2389113605,
-0.0775961429,
-0.0644112006,
0.3168365955,
0.781832695,
-0.8292869329,
-0.6005561948,
-0.2976996899,
0.2352531254,
-0.1341064125,
1.1665894985,
-0.0121382503,
0.1034692526,
-0.1525937766,
-0.1558347195,
-0.5994461179,
-0.6514026523,
-0.4374369085,
-0.4135394692,
0.5495888591,
0.7379816771,
0.5763512254,
0.0505186953,
0.24398911,
0.4649780691,
0.3899532259,
0.3985340297,
-0.0486564673,
0.3460617065,
-0.3526209891,
-0.3320097625,
-0.2945300937,
0.0602421574,
0.5924189687,
0.4264441133,
-0.3221513927,
-0.0255741868,
0.3398484588,
0.7339100242,
-0.803078115,
0.1713736057,
-0.2490934134,
-0.1258552521,
0.108593002,
-0.5586888194,
-0.647846818,
-0.2032796443,
0.0732400566,
-0.2374949306,
0.1993019134,
-0.2496226728,
0.4798389375,
0.1912818253,
-0.346868068,
-0.4326106608,
-0.7670001388,
0.657854259,
-0.5726538301,
0.3643602431,
0.3248231411,
0.473959595,
-0.1551960409,
-0.7703955173,
-0.5194387436,
-0.3614530563,
-0.1284820586,
-0.047791779,
-0.0878886208,
0.0446667485,
0.0936950296,
-0.1605919451,
-0.4959774911,
-0.2111440897,
-0.2578971684,
-0.3859371245,
0.3415961564,
0.2791103125,
0.2902245522,
-0.1735294014,
-0.3779532909,
-0.2294497043,
-0.7720018625,
-0.0942725092,
0.2335577756,
0.4807598293,
0.073502481,
0.2267163396,
-0.1018624157,
0.5798895359,
0.0670995191,
-0.0812048465,
0.507012248,
-0.0169475228,
0.0564511605,
-0.4136775136,
0.6604161859,
0.1597863585,
0.2691915333,
-0.2121709585,
-0.3711640835,
-0.4034924507,
0.5042914748,
-0.5473996401,
-0.1368322074,
-0.0023988865,
-0.3681081831,
-0.0623352192,
0.1101158634,
-0.9479536414,
-0.3602072299,
-0.3095709682,
0.3042757213,
-0.1908686012,
-0.3962374926,
-0.0640820041,
0.0432445481,
0.6461894512,
0.5001041293,
-0.8615664244,
0.4477563798,
0.758923769,
0.8462799788,
-0.1232496127,
-0.6086103916,
-0.8542077541,
-0.0136327026,
0.0549293309,
0.891710341,
-0.6779212356,
-0.4742680788,
0.1245186254,
0.1072052494,
-0.1692890525,
-0.487829417,
0.1733079106,
-0.5412092209,
0.1928882152,
-0.1225201935,
-0.0048146308,
-0.0707140788,
0.4660734534,
-0.6808167696,
0.6590103507,
0.2820240855,
-0.4918619692,
-0.0555866845,
-0.4816775322,
-0.3967994153,
-0.0449254438,
-0.4859847426,
-0.2204476595,
0.0674766451,
0.3097406328,
0.254650414,
-0.126828745,
-0.2108360678,
-0.1414309144,
-0.0740440637,
0.4219246209,
-0.4658285975,
0.3229939342,
0.1574613601,
-0.7329506874,
0.0078925351,
-0.4843810499,
0.2323046923,
-0.1705248207,
-0.2279350907,
-0.0880765095,
-0.0599772856,
-0.0909787565,
0.2558662295,
-0.0403260402,
-0.2332407981,
0.2909879088,
-0.5456027389,
0.3278849721,
0.6957498789,
0.1720677167,
0.4512672722,
-0.1681492478,
0.8844184279,
-0.1640160531,
0.2105714083,
-0.258346796,
-0.3524366617,
-0.7087684274,
-0.1189477071,
0.0010437762,
0.4745165408,
-0.9952210188,
0.0258609857,
-0.1240298897,
-0.0650515333,
-0.4552408755,
0.2913208604,
0.7308297157,
0.3218793869,
0.6125381589,
-0.2122063488,
-0.5066560507,
-0.7249088287,
-0.4629284739,
-0.3013377488,
0.1656155586,
0.3743026555,
0.4389339685,
-0.4251931012,
0.9252815843,
-0.6227945089,
-0.205493629,
-0.4364030063,
0.4777035713,
0.0226010103,
0.4078680277,
0.3417592645,
-0.7081596255,
-0.5321670175,
-0.2957367897,
-0.376086235,
-0.3153465688,
-0.0513133071,
0.0614058748,
0.4756217301,
0.8807969689,
-0.510099709,
0.1939719766,
0.618614614,
-0.2940756083,
0.5188988447,
-0.129597187,
0.3165054023,
-0.8989962935,
0.0827330053,
-0.4646474719,
-0.5949304104,
-0.6304169893,
0.1347715855,
-0.1101184413,
0.0146339899,
-0.5800045729,
0.6302916408,
-0.8085852861,
0.2189524621,
-0.5955329537,
0.3326482773,
-0.0597175807,
0.6626018882,
0.1033161357,
0.883436799,
0.011699751,
-0.5037124753,
0.3432096839,
0.0862830877,
0.1619488299,
0.4601030648,
-0.4779548943,
0.6365944743,
-0.1193064749,
0.1399385035,
-1.15475595,
0.117315203,
0.5153730512,
-0.4437921643,
0.4101922214,
-0.052373413,
-0.1908024848,
-0.4067758918,
-0.3113835752,
0.3997241259,
0.4104561806,
-0.4500875175,
1.2162925005,
0.0806168318,
-0.0171688218,
-0.887817502,
-0.627949059,
0.1676676869,
0.0930240154,
-0.2792108059,
-0.2748540938,
-0.1531310827,
-0.1349936426,
-0.1360772848,
0.0370984226,
0.0251483209,
0.0241402928,
0.4929330349,
0.0009724014,
0.0614817627,
0.1763505787,
-0.2253386676,
-0.3546485305,
0.2314659059,
-0.3099747598,
0.7425050735,
-0.4687230587,
-0.6080937982,
-0.2429585457,
0.3857620656,
0.464573741,
-0.2015397102,
0.5893215537,
0.3018874228,
0.1261408329,
-0.5530455709,
-0.8467572331,
-0.5201660991,
-0.5821129084,
0.1368371695,
-0.5681098104,
-0.8805336952,
0.3826959133,
-0.2513532043,
-0.1077790186,
0.2747717202,
0.5115928054,
-0.0957679152,
1.0054457188,
0.8427872658,
-0.2976772487,
0.5073692799,
-0.4066768587,
0.0071922373,
-0.6694054008,
-0.2021138221,
-0.5487741232,
-0.0702344105,
-0.4217644036,
-0.5111810565,
0.3870896101,
-0.3264003098,
-0.041307535,
0.3079765439,
-0.3194774389,
0.6122936606,
0.3737397194,
0.3240500689,
0.2464714348,
-0.1503357291,
-0.2050294727,
0.1086561531,
-0.4727025628,
-0.4916463494,
0.8776487708,
0.3073830605,
0.8889855742,
0.1470526308,
0.8393729329,
0.3964029253,
0.5597347617,
-0.5049491525,
0.7048217058,
0.3148876131,
-0.3707431257,
-0.3680074215,
-0.5283612013,
-0.9592145085,
0.3116244972,
0.1816578209,
-0.3910627663,
0.1056607217,
0.3200801611,
-0.133017689,
0.0178678837,
-0.5657387972,
0.8071402311,
-0.0327470377,
-0.1232034713,
-0.3647998273,
-0.860786736,
0.1119755507,
0.1256327182,
0.2902492285,
0.2211164236,
-0.2303389758,
0.242645815,
-0.6372833252,
1.268532753,
-0.4373735487,
-0.3131816387,
0.5367453098,
0.1864468455,
0.7386035323,
-0.0825899392,
0.1922724843,
-0.3654263914,
-0.0939285085,
-0.2246907949,
-1.0696752071,
0.4706029594,
-0.6494522691,
-0.8422428966,
-0.3204418719,
-0.2755614817,
-0.2764921188,
0.1385015845,
0.1663430333,
0.5641701221,
-0.4684057534,
-0.230594784,
0.6255396605,
0.0084537668,
0.6143171787,
1.0813089609,
-0.1737688184,
-0.7225267887,
0.8564272523,
-0.104638204,
0.4987891316,
0.5483909845,
0.114573203,
-0.2709225118,
-0.1900172085,
-0.3435409367,
0.5379508734,
-0.955566287,
-0.4566576183,
-0.6844217777,
-0.1150543094,
-0.3370401561,
-0.0330289267,
-0.1917149276,
-0.3741459548,
-0.2128500938,
-0.0469448157,
0.00121473,
0.795298934,
0.0079827132,
0.2387354225,
-0.8959024549,
0.0220249053,
0.5101041794,
0.0404393449,
0.0492735207,
-0.4075495005,
-0.288692683,
0.0850989223,
-0.4994002581,
-1.175178051,
0.2030193508,
0.380109936,
0.5229893327,
0.3421971798,
0.0547886156,
0.2561117113,
-0.7145630121,
0.7418883443,
0.1036446691,
-1.1284993887,
0.6892799735,
-0.0356301442,
0.5521166921,
0.7465563416,
0.3305704892,
-0.6843690872,
-0.7426378131,
-0.5459765792,
-0.6194705963,
0.4064791203,
-0.2206487954,
0.4484848976,
-0.3602637649,
0.56482023,
-0.1402141154,
0.406065315,
-0.6725157499,
-0.1241266951,
-0.1563535482,
-0.2160046399,
-0.1642062813,
-0.3802820742,
-0.3327177763,
0.1060732305,
0.3847903907,
-0.6301780939,
0.2730526626,
0.4007979929,
-0.5160074234,
-0.0610745698,
0.4388988614,
0.8778468966,
0.6667819619,
0.2583159804,
0.6402487755,
0.4420704246,
-0.5708044171,
0.3605038524,
-0.3520541787,
0.0932164416,
0.0828028768,
0.7348541021,
0.4259550273,
0.2525160015,
-0.6188799143,
0.8856800199,
0.0809631944,
-0.2124766856,
-0.0772306845,
0.1119737402,
-0.1942860037,
0.5057735443,
0.2028512657,
-0.3008182347,
0.3831458688,
-0.7004157305,
0.4116692543,
0.5156656504,
-0.3458644748,
-0.519179821,
0.2577871382,
0.4113599956,
-0.3764510751,
0.7241122127,
-0.0671517774,
-0.8376686573,
0.3285275102,
0.5360826254,
1.4375255108,
-0.6651048064,
0.4885896742,
0.1357498318,
0.2961984575,
0.0360952429,
0.5393077731,
-0.467931211,
-0.618300736,
-0.4621926248,
-0.2957623005,
-0.5987808108,
-0.3763700724,
-0.5889950991,
0.0701954737,
-0.6010482907,
-0.2972202003,
-0.4798748493,
-0.1810437888,
-0.5853713155,
-0.0385911986,
-0.0115503604,
0.9259798527,
-0.9992361069,
0.4861422181,
0.7108422518,
-0.6732533574,
-0.9213662148,
0.2138982862,
-0.0265546534,
-0.8242480755,
0.786459446,
0.1764003187,
-0.7797284126,
-0.1473705322,
-0.688498497,
-0.6688254476,
0.8069403172,
0.3978942335,
-0.3578145206,
-0.0682133436,
0.4097211361,
0.6614122987,
-0.4838581383,
0.5048516393,
0.5254790783,
0.3958524168,
-0.0249148253,
-0.8462095857,
0.3535330892,
-0.2649743557,
-0.1373393536,
0.2795875072,
-0.8661644459,
0.4730767012,
-0.3266935945,
-0.3251404166,
-0.0776951239,
0.8750713468,
0.0586112142,
0.2262827158,
0.7470000982,
0.2209851444,
0.506660521,
0.1221884787,
0.72890836,
-0.3855345547,
0.2325456142,
1.222728014,
-0.1569981575,
0.8489132524,
0.5298033357,
0.1033438072,
1.2156249285,
0.0969050676,
0.2301844507,
0.6707594395,
0.0639453083,
-0.2620754838,
-0.2241782993,
0.1638231874,
-0.2936304212,
0.1670026928,
0.086942248,
-0.3250159919,
-0.3187889159,
0.4965517521,
0.0655262992,
0.1496049017,
-0.1043866649,
1.0170093775,
0.2434264719,
-0.8546751738,
0.6940367818,
-0.2457816005,
0.1886888295,
-0.5425547957,
-0.3552517891,
-0.3053512573,
0.3149140775,
-0.2887793779,
-0.7161629796,
0.2988517582,
-0.2937912047,
-0.2992412746,
-0.4568688571,
0.4386701286,
-0.6146000028,
0.0902976617,
0.4369825721,
0.4602776468,
0.235482499,
-0.172252804,
-0.6238493323,
0.0917892531,
-0.2198271602,
-0.3464654684,
0.0029570099,
0.5387357473,
0.1141509265,
0.8912591934,
0.1652759761,
0.0156113636,
-0.1116988063,
0.3505280018,
1.2434340715,
-0.6166541576,
-0.4657861292,
-0.9187011719,
0.505425632,
0.1044238806,
-0.1872708499,
0.9015246034,
0.344871223,
0.6527798772,
-0.1293753237,
0.6454998851,
0.2752772272,
0.5742029548,
-0.7027619481,
0.1304140985,
-0.3398712575,
0.3570486307,
-0.2736411393,
-0.8179603219,
-0.097104691,
0.3523875177,
-0.4307094216,
0.3600328863,
0.9050867558,
0.9893673658,
0.146762386,
-0.2034600377,
0.1132399887,
-0.0034463385,
0.5896993876,
0.4390698373,
1.0856969357,
-0.1798548549,
0.651221931,
0.2431267947,
-0.3149440885,
-0.2763618827,
-0.7209360003,
-1.0578961372,
-0.7011945844,
-0.0951053426,
-0.6289846897,
0.2441637516,
0.9695246816,
0.6728252769,
-0.7962909937,
-0.2157308161,
-0.1691320986,
0.2338636965,
-0.2793434858,
-0.1712910235,
0.2052018791,
-0.8979946971,
-0.3987562954,
0.4825664759,
0.2303537577,
0.0312582366,
-0.6469837427,
-0.2964498103,
-0.0282156989,
0.2622312009,
0.3637883365,
0.481072247,
-0.5430277586,
-0.3933237791,
0.0010854062,
-0.3422462344,
0.0144361779,
1.4002920389,
-0.8211462498,
0.3823820651,
0.610509634,
0.5391662121,
0.4196101725,
0.1882002056,
0.8289628029,
-0.8410795927,
0.0276028849,
0.2673633695,
-0.0172850452,
0.3618371487,
-0.3105395734,
0.4649559557,
0.2238620818,
-0.6940556765,
-0.7126742601,
0.4005900621,
-0.4119606316,
-0.385543108,
1.2022266388,
-0.0189983435,
-0.3578387201,
-0.1359629184,
-0.3950194716,
-0.1187482551,
-0.3074901104,
0.5771195889,
0.460994482,
-0.0858180225,
-0.5836718082,
-0.2177264541,
0.7262414098,
0.5574437976,
-0.8730931282,
0.2019480318,
0.4444806874,
0.4001847208,
0.2978659868,
1.0092020035,
0.0736563355,
0.3044417202,
-0.2185194939,
0.2511178255,
-0.0116737755,
-0.8784223795,
-0.6484403014,
0.1711238176,
0.2548512816,
-0.1761409044
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07623v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07623v1
|
COBias and Debias: Minimizing Language Model Pairwise Accuracy Bias via Nonlinear Integer Programming
| 2024-05-13T10:30:33 | 2024-05-13T10:30:33 |
Ruixi Lin, Yang You
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
For language model classification, would you prefer having only one workable
class or having every class working? The latter makes more practical uses.
Especially for large language models (LLMs), the fact that they achieve a fair
overall accuracy by in-context learning (ICL) obscures a large difference in
individual class accuracies. In this work, we uncover and tackle language
models' imbalance in per-class prediction accuracy by reconceptualizing it as
the Contextual Oddity Bias (COBias), and we are the first to engage nonlinear
integer programming (NIP) to debias it. Briefly, COBias refers to the
difference in accuracy by a class A compared to its ''odd'' class, which holds
the majority wrong predictions of class A. With the COBias metric, we reveal
that LLMs of varied scales and families exhibit large per-class accuracy
differences. Then we propose Debiasing as Nonlinear Integer Programming (DNIP)
to correct ICL per-class probabilities for lower bias and higher overall
accuracy. Our optimization objective is directly based on the evaluation scores
by COBias and accuracy metrics, solved by simulated annealing. Evaluations on
three LLMs across seven NLP classification tasks show that DNIP simultaneously
achieves significant COBias reduction ($-27\%$) and accuracy improvement
($+12\%$) over the conventional ICL approach, suggesting that modeling pairwise
class accuracy differences is a direction in pushing forward more accurate,
more reliable LLM predictions.
|
[
-0.6023575664,
-0.4195036292,
0.367514044,
0.2352768928,
0.1131687239,
0.1991369873,
-0.1422216296,
-0.3582713306,
-0.1870885044,
0.2688337564,
-0.4096931517,
-0.4405332506,
-0.5977788568,
0.014259629,
-0.2651799917,
0.8387492895,
0.3134282231,
0.3139531314,
-0.4095205069,
-0.1263121516,
-0.1366943121,
-0.5224940181,
-0.7161018252,
-0.4797110558,
0.173568964,
0.671859324,
0.8726902604,
0.4937100112,
0.4719332457,
0.1790761799,
-0.2494401187,
0.0417161062,
-0.3937590718,
-0.1990360022,
-0.1489767879,
-0.6831890345,
-0.4901567101,
-0.0296161398,
0.3436341882,
0.8541247249,
0.0165044293,
0.2157959938,
0.0099266646,
0.6650598645,
-0.645986557,
-0.05919021,
-0.7465213537,
0.2056573331,
-0.0935352892,
-0.0979228318,
-0.5362616777,
-0.2292336375,
0.2858412862,
-0.2879465222,
-0.0372309275,
0.2436975241,
0.4566186965,
0.7383384705,
-0.2626425028,
-0.4018335342,
-0.5667572618,
1.0692676306,
-1.1642229557,
0.4079012275,
0.5698247552,
-0.1367120147,
-0.2205105275,
-0.1754274964,
-0.6543285251,
-0.1946839988,
0.0981235877,
-0.1569292992,
-0.0362902507,
0.15056777,
0.2952214777,
0.3594633639,
-0.4211356342,
0.5241723061,
-0.2380042076,
0.1257954985,
0.7494618893,
0.1756248325,
0.3504484296,
0.0011844283,
-0.4942791462,
0.1234244779,
-0.7758708,
0.2112267464,
0.386380285,
0.1449333578,
-0.4154681861,
0.1654774547,
-0.053806372,
0.8174766898,
0.2146773785,
-0.3168051839,
0.1124016643,
0.149546966,
-0.0255983807,
-0.0419858024,
0.3326341808,
0.5995812416,
0.2203323543,
-0.3381287456,
-0.144164145,
0.2447500378,
-0.0824313983,
-0.491638273,
-0.2975341976,
0.2017067075,
-0.3163609505,
-0.5229635239,
-0.2664617002,
-0.7690579295,
-0.2174631059,
-0.7349997759,
0.2051755935,
-0.1180239618,
-0.0464042351,
0.1460412145,
0.1593834609,
-0.2698360384,
0.1555785239,
-1.1179039478,
0.5700345635,
0.7791771889,
0.8207187653,
-0.3656799793,
-0.2744530439,
-0.5493651628,
-0.0936608687,
-0.3874668777,
0.3069695234,
-0.6697042584,
0.0934837908,
-0.1837714612,
-0.8310489655,
0.2568697333,
-0.4769827127,
0.1021896899,
-0.5351931453,
0.0905111954,
-0.1820882261,
-0.6030009985,
-0.3065033257,
0.2999218106,
-0.3207108378,
0.9873729348,
0.1101113707,
-0.7446677685,
0.535294354,
-0.4726420939,
0.0990875736,
-0.2787541151,
-0.4194915295,
-0.2352298498,
0.151275143,
0.1555078328,
0.3009141088,
-0.4853108525,
0.6149705648,
-0.6146276593,
-0.6441939473,
0.1097315103,
-0.5294041038,
1.0268001556,
0.0665853545,
-0.6529121995,
-0.1205689311,
-0.8641942143,
0.1191299558,
-0.3254652023,
-0.2075021416,
-0.6911466122,
0.047018528,
-0.2277577966,
0.5161041021,
0.0011314192,
-0.4530476034,
0.4283403754,
-0.7088727951,
0.2983115315,
0.9435688257,
-0.427890867,
0.8136817217,
-0.3555297256,
0.2595053017,
0.0969820917,
0.1706072688,
0.4245271683,
-0.2535879314,
-0.9410687089,
-0.1490478367,
0.2942454517,
0.530516088,
-0.7294367552,
0.3787924647,
-0.0874633864,
-0.4442844093,
-0.2973306775,
0.0997545198,
0.3591153324,
0.5416040421,
0.3239399195,
-0.3014875054,
-0.6029832959,
-0.7522045374,
-0.1088742763,
-0.1763045639,
0.2259224802,
0.0796422288,
0.4224216342,
-0.229474619,
1.0469286442,
-0.4405251443,
-0.1318681836,
-0.0396651849,
0.1683237553,
0.3455114365,
0.5779446363,
0.862324059,
-0.8912226558,
-0.8108065128,
-0.6876511574,
-0.5341686606,
-0.3387732804,
0.1701277345,
0.1778868139,
0.7079512477,
0.5555112362,
0.175779596,
0.6702644825,
0.8825945258,
-0.240684405,
0.2596129179,
-0.1295951605,
-0.3009173274,
-0.64906317,
-0.2397128344,
-0.0062530129,
-0.0994928628,
-0.5759402514,
-0.0594681315,
-0.2894025445,
0.1518616974,
-0.1466273814,
0.6694873571,
-0.2646826506,
-0.0980985314,
-0.2164806277,
0.131209895,
-0.1641278863,
0.7334929109,
-0.0132100023,
0.6639679074,
0.5626646876,
-0.6389662027,
0.1191696599,
0.1687113196,
-0.2639325261,
0.4715521932,
-0.3303371668,
0.3713352084,
-0.2052554935,
0.1878543049,
-0.8324449658,
0.1954626888,
0.3191121221,
-0.3276795447,
0.2172376513,
-0.007536734,
-0.0750927702,
-0.0585935488,
-0.2569790781,
0.4342541099,
0.3793157041,
-0.7449122667,
0.0407540798,
0.5506563187,
-0.1991975904,
-1.0118350983,
-0.6839282513,
0.0224312618,
0.015361106,
-0.422899425,
0.5827154517,
-0.3466955423,
-0.7139788866,
-0.0608493872,
-0.280972302,
-0.1880808622,
0.2586332858,
0.0856154338,
0.2347188741,
0.1028654277,
0.2706895769,
-0.0437675491,
-0.4775228798,
-0.1104190946,
-0.4295306504,
0.8546501994,
-0.5248919725,
-0.2763461769,
-0.210537523,
0.3106111884,
0.5048641562,
0.1189686656,
0.6668044329,
0.3893086016,
-0.4186556041,
-0.1942272335,
-0.5682815909,
-0.2774915993,
-0.4161898196,
0.2862097323,
-0.2656324506,
-0.5831009746,
0.3220841885,
0.2384682745,
0.0973077416,
0.1699698269,
0.4358927011,
0.0501810424,
1.1711820364,
0.8330945373,
-0.4083307981,
0.4459199905,
-0.4389234781,
0.3416389525,
-0.7653086185,
-0.0767550766,
-0.4451911449,
-0.578899622,
-0.6326013803,
-0.3437504768,
0.4422740042,
0.1316851228,
-0.3649100661,
0.0571030267,
-0.4724482298,
0.4830046594,
0.9135845304,
0.1169008166,
0.4340874553,
0.0206913967,
-0.1051239818,
-0.416139394,
-0.9853981733,
-0.5587790012,
1.1422787905,
0.2245828211,
0.7495951653,
-0.0036429288,
0.8802016973,
0.3889350593,
0.3337737024,
-0.5915941,
0.4096531868,
-0.4857746363,
-0.6776996255,
-0.4045618474,
-0.4233539104,
-0.260109812,
0.1049342006,
-0.2906244695,
-0.92021662,
0.3978177607,
0.4252523482,
-0.3166632056,
0.5824301243,
-0.1536031514,
0.5315801501,
-0.4243123233,
-0.5415056944,
-0.3389055729,
-0.7613202333,
0.1728692949,
0.0372880138,
0.441893518,
-0.314393878,
-0.113825351,
0.3153331876,
-0.4295407832,
0.8223633766,
-0.2228694558,
0.0194906294,
-0.0229130071,
0.1353777945,
0.3834993541,
0.2307468504,
-0.5420475602,
0.5043557286,
0.0208120812,
-0.4222380221,
-0.4750437737,
0.6591951847,
-0.8106271029,
-0.4625495076,
-0.6710481644,
-0.7741346955,
-0.2144803405,
-0.0428867303,
0.4345487356,
0.6886539459,
0.1838279366,
0.1643999219,
0.5188194513,
-0.256662339,
0.5746788979,
0.4666393995,
-0.3461873233,
-0.3055591285,
0.8499497175,
0.2603856325,
0.4966986775,
0.4850089848,
0.2960823476,
-0.1220879257,
-0.8430222869,
-0.4252311885,
-0.2271745205,
-0.6630447507,
-0.1048298627,
-0.46257779,
0.0204576794,
-0.4061460793,
-0.4669871032,
-0.2666576803,
-0.4830670059,
-0.1129295751,
0.241758734,
0.0643105432,
0.4718779325,
-0.5033080578,
0.2618897855,
-0.4824562073,
0.1335260868,
0.1714360267,
0.4125876427,
0.1260194182,
-0.6038585901,
0.0102963252,
0.2852414846,
0.0031725117,
-0.5597847104,
0.4967992902,
0.2186407447,
0.3345661163,
0.1937123537,
0.3956105411,
0.5772004724,
-0.207597211,
0.4853313565,
0.2106953561,
-1.2250106335,
0.0679650903,
-0.066505909,
0.0959134772,
0.7824730873,
0.4533921778,
-0.7523064613,
-0.4390612841,
-0.6617572904,
-0.9813303351,
0.904540658,
-0.1405527741,
0.0232887827,
0.0932632238,
0.4151763618,
0.2613836825,
0.3628104627,
-1.0141683817,
-0.3621945381,
0.2666228414,
-0.5848821998,
0.0004097665,
-0.3661401272,
0.0737712607,
-0.3152026832,
1.0446871519,
-0.2010491788,
-0.173083961,
0.1442804337,
-0.2721540332,
-0.0011232918,
0.1020421386,
0.6649293303,
0.9302460551,
-0.3060899675,
0.3694366813,
0.484855175,
-0.291970253,
0.3669156432,
-0.3361495137,
-0.6093262434,
-0.0563164651,
0.108891882,
0.6692906022,
0.3002013862,
-0.5978063345,
0.4404467642,
0.0126495194,
0.3391644359,
-0.5526795387,
0.0266772602,
-0.1267977059,
0.2102947235,
0.4284696579,
0.526191175,
0.2169151604,
-0.3619299531,
0.1571093798,
0.2247643471,
-0.5161451101,
-0.2123535872,
0.4721034169,
0.4557177424,
-0.5007378459,
0.6050774455,
-0.4736781418,
-0.6347826123,
0.7371358275,
0.6184885502,
0.6241490841,
0.0173348449,
0.054851409,
0.3370653987,
0.2481234074,
-0.1043224409,
0.1450604349,
0.1033587232,
-0.866517365,
-0.2618082166,
-0.524740696,
-0.8054824471,
0.1108841598,
-0.6976685524,
0.4402568936,
-0.6769979596,
0.0383254141,
-0.037350934,
0.025536079,
-0.5065165162,
0.4384132922,
0.3143154085,
0.6933884025,
-0.7675432563,
0.7357613444,
0.6037251949,
-0.2629933059,
-0.6165258884,
0.1218489036,
0.2310818583,
-0.6961823106,
0.9203543067,
0.144378379,
-0.1380424201,
0.1780827641,
-0.6126241088,
-1.0632628202,
0.5362994671,
0.3905515969,
-0.8503051996,
-0.2666530013,
0.1782968938,
0.3108106256,
-0.4444798827,
0.1472316235,
0.5076867938,
0.3129853904,
-0.2036219835,
-0.7040710449,
-0.194600001,
-0.0482212082,
-0.0070056785,
0.2099786401,
-0.6862450242,
1.042732358,
-0.2661527991,
0.3527793884,
-0.1350725442,
0.323761344,
0.2154048532,
0.7000452876,
0.7794365883,
0.6075741649,
0.7672673464,
-0.1401145011,
0.6717039347,
-0.4128021896,
0.400782913,
1.3337266445,
-0.190912053,
0.7153039575,
0.6514822245,
-0.3330075145,
0.418874681,
0.5718484521,
0.1518736184,
0.4550717771,
0.2208972126,
-0.2271063626,
-0.3282055557,
0.1251334399,
-0.2156334668,
0.6707546711,
0.3096348643,
-0.0895002186,
-0.0031444305,
0.0782590583,
0.2251680344,
0.2722510397,
-0.2852863669,
0.5849131346,
0.1955580711,
-0.8209738135,
0.5829725862,
0.0650582984,
1.0892027617,
-0.1287917197,
0.0501240976,
-0.2583698332,
0.4922751486,
-0.3730107546,
-0.366902411,
0.50636518,
-0.0694533512,
-0.542114675,
-0.0198248886,
0.5199726224,
-0.6803233027,
-0.4088371396,
0.2717841864,
0.0669020712,
0.0279988609,
0.0918575078,
-0.6347827315,
0.065730013,
0.2171556503,
0.1110073328,
0.1604868323,
-0.0242290106,
-0.0851207748,
0.7074816227,
0.4918087423,
0.1801125854,
0.0239630416,
-0.1643803567,
0.5007644296,
-0.4354583919,
-0.3761322498,
-1.0584470034,
0.2594955564,
-0.1843809783,
-0.4462749064,
0.3926261663,
0.3979314268,
1.1946749687,
-0.0528497659,
0.8325864673,
-0.1572415978,
0.5308461189,
-0.500959456,
0.3960620761,
-0.5565867424,
0.49496153,
-0.2537147105,
-0.8497385383,
-0.4671868086,
0.8562105894,
-0.6655532122,
-0.2080525458,
0.3790983558,
0.7331737876,
0.107604146,
-0.0386186503,
0.2230788469,
0.1065292358,
0.3165123463,
0.5683355927,
0.6860823631,
-0.4705550671,
0.2317709476,
-0.8261957169,
-0.3775607646,
-0.626939714,
-0.9688869119,
-0.7846257687,
-0.3827780187,
-0.369425416,
-0.1283467263,
0.1021227241,
1.4976861477,
0.676664114,
-0.9092496037,
-0.3771912158,
-0.2941565812,
0.3528068364,
-0.1427757144,
-0.2110664696,
0.086443834,
-0.5025421381,
-1.1034944057,
0.0815983862,
0.4921685159,
0.0507027097,
-0.2421672344,
-0.2256036699,
-0.3705064654,
-0.0083207358,
0.4051138163,
0.1294969916,
-0.6792773604,
-0.4522066116,
0.051675953,
-0.1894700676,
0.146106869,
0.4344919622,
-0.5151201487,
0.4604485035,
0.6104944348,
0.3907049,
0.4702056348,
-0.2542987764,
0.7263983488,
-0.6790249944,
0.678640604,
0.611548841,
0.1551455408,
0.3104632497,
-0.1367950439,
0.790686667,
0.1437944919,
-0.6328994036,
-1.1046987772,
0.3051493466,
-0.5846456885,
-0.2333027869,
0.9061557055,
-0.1290236264,
0.0718449205,
-0.3015641272,
-0.2243131846,
0.1328801513,
-0.1624174863,
1.1844136715,
0.6710808277,
-0.2308083326,
0.2199609578,
-0.3069671392,
0.6111298203,
0.7581149936,
-0.5426440239,
-0.3029322624,
0.3270658553,
0.2856203616,
0.3204077482,
0.4825694859,
0.195047915,
0.2014324814,
0.064355813,
0.1329981834,
-0.0181474779,
-0.4941420853,
-0.2566289306,
-0.0835195854,
0.2106449306,
0.1024673432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07615v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07615v1
|
ViWikiFC: Fact-Checking for Vietnamese Wikipedia-Based Textual Knowledge Source
| 2024-05-13T10:24:05 | 2024-05-13T10:24:05 |
Hung Tuan Le, Long Truong To, Manh Trong Nguyen, Kiet Van Nguyen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Fact-checking is essential due to the explosion of misinformation in the
media ecosystem. Although false information exists in every language and
country, most research to solve the problem mainly concentrated on huge
communities like English and Chinese. Low-resource languages like Vietnamese
are necessary to explore corpora and models for fact verification. To bridge
this gap, we construct ViWikiFC, the first manual annotated open-domain corpus
for Vietnamese Wikipedia Fact Checking more than 20K claims generated by
converting evidence sentences extracted from Wikipedia articles. We analyze our
corpus through many linguistic aspects, from the new dependency rate, the new
n-gram rate, and the new word rate. We conducted various experiments for
Vietnamese fact-checking, including evidence retrieval and verdict prediction.
BM25 and InfoXLM (Large) achieved the best results in two tasks, with BM25
achieving an accuracy of 88.30% for SUPPORTS, 86.93% for REFUTES, and only
56.67% for the NEI label in the evidence retrieval task, InfoXLM (Large)
achieved an F1 score of 86.51%. Furthermore, we also conducted a pipeline
approach, which only achieved a strict accuracy of 67.00% when using InfoXLM
(Large) and BM25. These results demonstrate that our dataset is challenging for
the Vietnamese language model in fact-checking tasks.
|
[
-0.4434873164,
-0.9165246487,
0.5337920189,
0.114719674,
-0.3731629252,
-0.2693144977,
-0.3985022008,
-0.3031677008,
0.0721241832,
0.723703146,
-0.1679371595,
-0.6667837501,
-0.6420305371,
0.4268098176,
-0.5109268427,
1.158193469,
-0.0309534073,
-0.110253334,
-0.2387216538,
-0.3038486242,
0.0940557346,
-0.4438507259,
-0.2363733351,
-0.0566859506,
0.7064274549,
0.8876690865,
0.6112402678,
0.5429217815,
0.4378556311,
0.279407531,
0.0900200009,
0.588329792,
-0.7713398933,
-0.2435656786,
-0.2458285689,
-0.3444899619,
-0.1890226752,
0.1010902002,
0.1395632625,
0.0381280482,
0.0367607363,
0.3634550571,
-0.3303914666,
0.5467723608,
-0.9231642485,
0.2571604252,
-0.7894251347,
-0.1994272321,
-0.2841048837,
-0.0800688416,
-0.5541826487,
-0.4675011337,
0.165850684,
-0.7694402337,
0.4060843587,
-0.3345980942,
1.0799587965,
0.2946165502,
-0.6805849671,
-0.2668851316,
-0.5821470618,
0.3724035919,
-0.4865306616,
0.3891605139,
0.5187554955,
0.0660405159,
0.0785278976,
-0.6884993911,
-1.08626616,
-0.3700401783,
-0.3059656322,
0.1314736307,
-0.1027202234,
-0.0610810593,
0.4508219957,
0.2137619704,
-0.5499855876,
-0.0906723887,
-0.6415504217,
-0.3757354617,
0.6526184082,
-0.3122831285,
0.1886282861,
-0.7699130774,
-0.6261259913,
-0.085088186,
-0.7559120059,
-0.2809768021,
0.2297581434,
0.0650984347,
-0.1661106944,
1.0587595701,
-0.6346939802,
0.6136686802,
-0.1368841529,
-0.4232876003,
0.3080739379,
-0.6447979212,
-0.0954858065,
0.2569577098,
0.8306406736,
0.5985920429,
0.4405165017,
0.0910755992,
-0.0948908925,
0.0435909517,
0.1575420201,
-0.6947876215,
-0.2653533816,
0.1896737814,
-0.4398075342,
-0.3230367601,
0.472281605,
-0.628716886,
-0.3396832645,
-0.2573951781,
0.5108573437,
-0.4694665372,
-0.5677580833,
-0.3031712174,
-0.3826471567,
0.0698905662,
0.536929965,
-0.3500323594,
-0.3161736429,
0.6127440929,
0.9195004106,
-0.1881203949,
-0.3216948211,
-0.8547346592,
0.0720679536,
-0.3071956933,
0.8173669577,
-0.0719456524,
-0.1787746251,
0.3085031211,
0.0233246963,
0.2438832074,
-0.4682031572,
0.8936828971,
-0.4310921729,
0.1049750745,
-0.3135823011,
-0.6400877833,
-0.1772815436,
0.2593872249,
-0.8415414691,
1.068253994,
0.318905443,
-1.0934381485,
0.3432349563,
-0.4664589167,
-0.4075476229,
0.0606118925,
0.0020378327,
-0.2410716116,
0.1028789654,
-0.1024559513,
0.2393932641,
-0.0665703341,
0.3563313782,
-0.2191211432,
-0.0237948354,
0.2717926204,
-0.465022862,
1.0013006926,
0.288045913,
-0.4310745597,
0.0160124097,
-1.1337147951,
-0.1005015746,
-0.1706976593,
-0.5867046118,
-0.6654054523,
-0.2120404691,
0.3461429179,
0.259170264,
0.3554335535,
-0.7994363904,
0.0611310303,
-0.0034373754,
0.145307824,
0.3978091776,
-0.0507286415,
-0.0318970867,
0.0475270115,
-0.158480987,
0.1788598448,
0.3058310747,
-0.1376666725,
-0.6580207348,
-1.0054436922,
-0.1137034595,
0.455825448,
0.7111719847,
-1.2319699526,
0.4358488023,
-0.3938218355,
-0.7495482564,
-0.5928755403,
0.2515963614,
0.2750511169,
0.8130978942,
0.6835352778,
0.0970050767,
-0.6675748229,
-0.8777556419,
-0.1411608011,
-0.7480239868,
-0.1753335595,
-0.1079351529,
0.663575232,
-0.3139267564,
0.9359508753,
-0.483666271,
-0.2746304274,
0.1989422441,
0.2813639343,
0.1416855305,
0.0085006114,
0.37707901,
-1.1649416685,
-0.5610797405,
0.2586347163,
-0.9183192253,
-0.2267572731,
0.2087765634,
-0.0789088607,
0.5328103304,
0.3979439139,
-1.0203379393,
0.5561049581,
0.4079122245,
-0.5503861904,
0.6089480519,
-0.2724307775,
0.2483278513,
-0.5952831507,
0.1093257666,
0.0380441435,
-0.2624783516,
-0.4368334413,
0.0496725105,
0.3667806387,
0.2886584699,
-0.585015595,
0.487878263,
-0.1249852031,
0.4413590431,
-0.4900303185,
0.1816542149,
-0.1737962961,
0.2983164191,
0.0758412257,
0.4847887754,
0.0448045321,
-0.718735218,
0.615868032,
0.1804998666,
-0.4032209516,
0.7024831772,
-0.3664622009,
-0.1281465292,
-0.0325300433,
-0.0237999577,
-0.6610029936,
-0.2190499902,
0.1799161732,
-0.4388957024,
0.0398452692,
-0.2956669927,
-0.3894289434,
-0.2484084815,
-0.2478145808,
-0.2522245347,
0.1356751472,
-0.6714103222,
0.3631814122,
0.5310783982,
-0.06629017,
-0.8800868988,
-0.3268482685,
0.1903285533,
0.0886196792,
-0.5859494805,
0.309250474,
-0.0997491628,
-0.6030605435,
0.3646219075,
-0.1294359863,
-0.2681014836,
-0.1453066468,
0.1856627613,
0.2275845855,
-0.4784360826,
0.2309290767,
-0.1485117078,
-0.2344347984,
0.0238952059,
-0.4442446828,
-0.0360356979,
0.0650511459,
-0.123398006,
-0.041737996,
0.1825966835,
0.686044991,
-0.2159809619,
0.7504133582,
0.9477296472,
-0.3714967072,
0.1156042367,
-0.8993215561,
0.0217104349,
-0.325714618,
0.2296232432,
-0.1223810911,
-0.8896307349,
-0.0881478786,
0.2980531752,
0.1801487803,
0.8561647534,
0.7693289518,
-0.0007837638,
0.3881720901,
0.6320884228,
-0.1381575912,
0.2483267188,
-0.1032092199,
-0.0994253308,
0.0538301691,
-0.0542618707,
-0.6107007861,
0.2421623319,
-0.9832963943,
-0.7449896932,
0.3529238105,
-0.1392765641,
0.0011273844,
0.3265556097,
-0.1619125456,
0.3260911703,
0.5935081244,
0.0279364474,
0.8353152275,
0.0802624896,
0.1279337257,
0.0877960771,
-0.5656608939,
-0.4516905844,
1.1436055899,
-0.0826902688,
0.3816815019,
0.0697938949,
0.3751413226,
0.5587586761,
0.6401078701,
-0.5575401783,
0.3475071788,
-0.2666000128,
-0.7634590864,
-0.5706124306,
-0.5675366521,
-0.4911941886,
0.1751041859,
-0.4867425263,
-0.1782664806,
0.0836661607,
0.00701431,
0.262725085,
0.1572194993,
-0.8325225115,
0.6791387796,
-0.2013876438,
-0.2608204782,
-0.4469142556,
-0.4344767034,
0.5804843903,
-0.1344628483,
0.3583250344,
-0.1196569726,
0.007571531,
0.4252098799,
-0.75483495,
0.4625430107,
-0.2913526893,
-0.149424389,
0.6584359407,
-0.3428676724,
0.4424055219,
0.5463383198,
-0.0989171714,
0.4838148057,
-0.106606774,
-0.3189979196,
-0.5470981002,
0.7844504118,
-0.8061756492,
-0.57910043,
-0.2775552571,
0.0136427963,
0.1713592261,
0.413108319,
0.6004502177,
0.0134923495,
-0.48152408,
0.3070348799,
0.9594398737,
-0.0359404273,
0.0140394615,
0.9619370699,
-0.2390938699,
-0.4577773809,
1.1603224277,
0.4784399867,
-0.1458227932,
0.8657972813,
0.1340832412,
-0.1486029327,
-0.3376745284,
-0.5921967626,
0.225982815,
-0.6980170608,
-0.216895923,
-0.8542653918,
-0.3888179362,
-0.2433368713,
0.5161352158,
-0.3947608471,
-0.7138182521,
0.1300412267,
-0.4536551535,
0.6525048018,
0.862652421,
-0.2191781998,
-0.0593772158,
-0.616746664,
0.7908575535,
0.3843070567,
0.2154714912,
-0.606667459,
-0.1528907716,
-0.5149773359,
-0.0111830151,
-0.0362704471,
-1.0514304638,
-0.2081303895,
0.095014818,
0.4144237638,
0.5603303313,
0.4792521596,
0.1879317611,
-0.3626785576,
0.6176247001,
-0.1093951538,
-0.5591317415,
0.4970196486,
-0.0152531601,
-0.0201211441,
0.4408333004,
0.4331402481,
-0.5008402467,
-0.4589508176,
-0.734926641,
-0.5594257116,
0.2990709841,
0.4661745429,
-0.1862120181,
0.0263256226,
0.3735049069,
0.2176972181,
0.1437060535,
-0.5026601553,
-0.4343537688,
-0.4844880402,
-0.2120338529,
-0.2009727955,
-0.5085175633,
-0.1321712732,
-0.2040203661,
0.8832982183,
-0.4068163633,
-0.1049809307,
0.5808834434,
-0.4278181791,
-0.1268478483,
0.0815684274,
0.7218372822,
0.7979360819,
-0.0099242907,
0.3580799103,
0.2577151656,
-0.7250368595,
0.0711939707,
0.1992376894,
-0.5534490347,
0.7122129798,
0.5559644699,
0.5896518826,
0.0953250751,
-0.5874482989,
0.6221530437,
-0.2891434729,
-0.0437892824,
-0.41590029,
0.2682720125,
0.171813041,
-0.0260148924,
0.3540384769,
-0.1443855911,
0.0046795462,
-0.23317644,
0.2983079255,
0.117682457,
-0.3102520406,
-0.2349452823,
0.3718672693,
0.2755165398,
0.0327350013,
0.7528791428,
-0.0999729261,
-0.4548057318,
0.4157196581,
-0.1888639033,
0.5666904449,
-0.1824236959,
0.5065296292,
0.7127232552,
0.7054703236,
-0.0002477633,
0.3228465319,
-0.0795066878,
-0.5257685781,
-0.4055942893,
-0.506736517,
-0.4364252985,
0.2919926643,
-0.2801016867,
0.6002532244,
-0.1027876213,
-0.1799153984,
0.1339944154,
0.1498781145,
-0.7212508917,
0.3213983476,
0.0038111187,
1.2617819309,
-0.6023014784,
0.9712711573,
0.5354540348,
-0.5254808664,
-0.3897745907,
-0.0257787574,
0.1166813299,
-0.5062103868,
0.5479003191,
0.070707202,
0.0767832994,
-0.2180122882,
-0.778552413,
-0.7114592791,
0.8084184527,
0.6439549327,
-0.3026869595,
0.0270943213,
0.0697392672,
0.5218349695,
-0.1460991651,
0.1915945262,
0.353785485,
0.8390188813,
-0.2992765307,
-0.9278213978,
-0.1621863097,
-0.3583229184,
-0.3320831954,
-0.1989321858,
-0.6923115253,
0.8568722606,
-0.398202002,
-0.1575543433,
-0.1502177119,
1.070266366,
0.1228668541,
0.5377886891,
0.729311347,
0.4519144595,
0.9896365404,
0.0678241998,
0.7284299135,
-0.3424916267,
0.3392683864,
0.9495693445,
0.0008454403,
0.946792841,
0.5450906754,
-0.0089012524,
0.6918970942,
0.3818882704,
-0.0600543246,
0.0997014791,
-0.0937940925,
-0.1373032629,
-0.1789796203,
-0.4663728178,
-0.3438807428,
0.5025961995,
0.4153335989,
-0.1127406657,
-0.0784977153,
0.0128384093,
0.2298344523,
0.0017125201,
-0.0052345628,
0.6268113256,
-0.0273636319,
-0.9350524545,
0.4161281884,
0.1221215874,
0.457901001,
-0.5566292405,
-0.2724555433,
-0.2140756994,
-0.0261583738,
-0.4664822519,
-0.8021759391,
0.0795455873,
0.5088915229,
-0.581538558,
0.2020699829,
0.9765846729,
-0.6461966038,
-0.313621968,
0.2955198586,
0.6227783561,
-0.0396428555,
-0.3263092935,
-0.2643334866,
-0.0161180235,
-0.1549003422,
-0.2000463456,
0.0365524851,
0.8718590736,
-0.1716779917,
0.2763819695,
0.7371503711,
-0.0543809161,
-0.0488353781,
-0.2163966,
0.6465321779,
-0.5228759646,
-0.5521155596,
-0.7462745309,
0.3649501801,
-0.4061871767,
-0.4267190099,
0.9192817211,
0.705668211,
1.2692556381,
-0.1428094655,
1.1061911583,
-0.2116271704,
0.3972730935,
-0.6603087187,
1.0253417492,
-0.4271192551,
-0.3192903399,
-0.1051430777,
-0.6410624385,
0.1508179456,
0.4247681201,
0.2253797054,
-0.3707682788,
0.6995802522,
0.7507323623,
0.1032833681,
0.1738875359,
0.3362030685,
0.6218503714,
0.131371811,
0.2179335058,
0.813429296,
-0.2885341048,
0.8600398898,
-0.4635480344,
-0.2402947694,
-0.5968070626,
-0.816583395,
-0.7251366973,
-0.7389308214,
-0.5099521875,
-0.6518489718,
-0.0539328046,
0.6307743788,
0.5783808827,
-0.9336907268,
-0.1320158839,
0.2681299448,
0.8113653064,
-0.0754021853,
-0.2389272004,
0.3080575764,
-0.1098849103,
-0.5132125616,
0.279676646,
0.3056226075,
-0.3101690114,
-0.4175152481,
-0.2098604143,
-0.3326030672,
-0.1839349717,
0.7402126789,
0.2958957851,
-0.7115178704,
-0.3742564917,
0.0543084145,
-0.6016355753,
0.0149748353,
1.0452613831,
-0.678561151,
0.7219470739,
0.758933723,
0.4620940387,
0.4955146313,
-0.2677939236,
0.3490417898,
-0.46812132,
-0.0215340648,
-0.3510032594,
0.3427957296,
0.5079948902,
-0.3752501905,
0.7433509231,
0.7114136219,
-0.2571175992,
-0.6675212383,
0.0186096951,
-0.7842919827,
-0.1810586303,
1.0071651936,
-0.1735457927,
-0.5060743093,
-0.4250555336,
-0.249031201,
0.6508988142,
-0.1880694777,
0.8967642784,
0.8715587854,
0.2961417735,
0.1526017934,
-0.5930637717,
0.6584231853,
-0.1029671878,
-0.7117032409,
0.1134258881,
0.5164747834,
0.2620690465,
0.5351303816,
0.635602951,
0.2428758144,
0.6360034943,
0.0078877062,
-0.0858362317,
-0.044987388,
-0.3562622964,
0.1579729021,
0.3329958022,
-0.0906841457,
0.2004940659
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07609v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07609v1
|
NoiseBench: Benchmarking the Impact of Real Label Noise on Named Entity Recognition
| 2024-05-13T10:20:31 | 2024-05-13T10:20:31 |
Elena Merdjanovska, Ansar Aynetdinov, Alan Akbik
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Available training data for named entity recognition (NER) often contains a
significant percentage of incorrect labels for entity types and entity
boundaries. Such label noise poses challenges for supervised learning and may
significantly deteriorate model quality. To address this, prior work proposed
various noise-robust learning approaches capable of learning from data with
partially incorrect labels. These approaches are typically evaluated using
simulated noise where the labels in a clean dataset are automatically
corrupted. However, as we show in this paper, this leads to unrealistic noise
that is far easier to handle than real noise caused by human error or
semi-automatic annotation. To enable the study of the impact of various types
of real noise, we introduce NoiseBench, an NER benchmark consisting of clean
training data corrupted with 6 types of real noise, including expert errors,
crowdsourcing errors, automatic annotation errors and LLM errors. We present an
analysis that shows that real noise is significantly more challenging than
simulated noise, and show that current state-of-the-art models for noise-robust
learning fall far short of their theoretically achievable upper bound. We
release NoiseBench to the research community.
|
[
-0.4219182134,
-0.6808881164,
0.2799825668,
-0.0302681457,
-0.1101434305,
0.1055247709,
-0.1869614422,
-0.9465447068,
0.0981638953,
0.3685640693,
-0.4510312378,
-0.2582740188,
-0.4716336727,
0.1990279257,
-0.5453385711,
0.9358839989,
0.0561018288,
0.3879526556,
-0.1193659827,
-0.1183792129,
-0.3849708438,
-0.4673725665,
-0.8823420405,
-0.1678130031,
0.4760758877,
0.1335393041,
0.3891659081,
0.4548718035,
0.576978147,
0.2188126743,
-0.0700411499,
0.0104737794,
-0.5459408164,
0.2944595516,
-0.0823700503,
-0.4237532914,
-0.4318579733,
0.1681537777,
0.5927060246,
0.5713223815,
-0.2779279649,
0.2219009399,
-0.1285100281,
0.2656975389,
-0.6465286016,
0.342461586,
-0.5756930113,
0.2162822187,
-0.3408079743,
0.2343996763,
-0.4042740762,
-0.3559690118,
-0.1057924628,
-0.7847849727,
0.2871218622,
0.2410496026,
1.326452136,
0.8382948041,
-0.0229271092,
-0.1621386856,
-0.9393968582,
0.6886654496,
-0.5987344384,
0.7558464408,
0.4608758092,
0.4022305012,
-0.3929513991,
-0.7402216792,
-0.3449978232,
-0.0534213036,
0.2604116797,
0.224538371,
-0.2441276759,
0.0455497727,
0.7577804923,
0.351102531,
-0.1111199185,
0.1808509529,
-0.3439570963,
-0.4164611697,
0.3650253713,
-0.2540741861,
0.2500037253,
0.2701715231,
-0.3667278886,
-0.3640797436,
-0.3954841197,
-0.0590152852,
0.6795654893,
0.2358434051,
0.1813683361,
-0.0018555492,
-0.1554391235,
0.8326919675,
0.2129618227,
-0.4090731442,
0.4771185219,
0.065156348,
0.0088239294,
0.5229885578,
0.4932341278,
0.1601314992,
0.1115868837,
-0.444147855,
-0.3968999982,
-0.0714448839,
0.3683969676,
-0.8141285777,
-0.7186736465,
-0.1067407951,
-0.2748348117,
-0.4778032005,
0.0904178694,
-0.9217379689,
-0.5233185291,
-0.4006387293,
0.509978652,
-0.2765175104,
-0.4199044108,
-0.1601222605,
-0.0584164187,
-0.0343390591,
0.4458342195,
-0.3473854065,
0.4854530692,
0.521145463,
0.4441156089,
-0.0188570172,
-0.1180466563,
-0.7780932784,
-0.1675141305,
-0.330794096,
1.0009903908,
-0.3877123296,
-0.3638529778,
-0.5035869479,
-0.195390746,
0.0877015963,
-1.0192844868,
0.6946510673,
-0.5236819983,
-0.1962173879,
-0.4147977829,
-0.6563130617,
-0.2226939797,
0.1379295737,
-0.9066841006,
1.2370023727,
0.2760641277,
-0.7976498604,
0.8073345423,
-0.228267327,
-0.2228168249,
-0.0654211193,
-0.2003569007,
-0.8894895315,
0.0342669412,
-0.0855006501,
0.0925670639,
-0.1209220737,
0.5005583763,
-0.359007895,
-0.3538753688,
0.4843162298,
-0.4044318497,
0.5635204911,
0.1146006286,
-0.5191532969,
-0.3445805907,
-1.2471753359,
0.0585998222,
-0.0318383686,
-0.4005417824,
-0.2807076275,
0.0355344787,
-0.018917039,
0.2405979931,
-0.3020170629,
-0.5855917335,
-0.2324797362,
-0.1174443588,
0.1228371412,
0.5836090446,
0.1078632623,
0.0540691689,
-0.2470768988,
0.3007416725,
0.3643236458,
-0.0587983243,
0.4043056369,
-0.2809607089,
-0.8184384704,
-0.5090987682,
1.0369150639,
0.3843225241,
-0.2391734123,
0.0483776256,
-0.2679881454,
-0.6361101866,
-0.5561908484,
0.1618807614,
0.4574375749,
1.0143033266,
0.631406188,
-0.5339679718,
-0.7838175297,
-0.8708587885,
-0.486900717,
-0.3128660619,
0.1689257175,
0.2265213877,
0.5709215403,
-0.2568433285,
0.8266836405,
0.0716281384,
-0.3619992733,
0.1597323716,
0.379745096,
-0.1835068315,
0.4943961501,
0.283926487,
-0.6238685846,
-0.1785088629,
-0.6536497474,
-0.4951945841,
-0.1361075044,
-0.12958619,
0.0384785607,
0.0521579534,
0.5642296672,
-0.2961374819,
0.4288084209,
0.2773668468,
0.1708022058,
0.7861782908,
0.1418999135,
-0.1299519241,
-0.6557952166,
-0.0303165074,
0.0189615842,
-0.1985538006,
-0.271168232,
-0.256695807,
0.0652749464,
-0.1719780415,
-0.2582593262,
0.3613685071,
-0.6567051411,
-0.1322112083,
-0.1693203449,
-0.0674654841,
-0.0229301862,
0.1791453511,
0.1000118926,
0.7197473645,
0.495187372,
-0.672719121,
0.1827218682,
0.0141524468,
-0.4326721132,
0.9028354883,
-0.4131383002,
-0.0480964966,
-0.1137888283,
0.4654745162,
-0.3582538068,
-0.5593368411,
0.3708510995,
-0.2534558475,
0.6492305398,
-0.1743932962,
-0.6401558518,
-0.1269120723,
0.120288752,
0.2898420691,
0.3852589428,
-0.7481484413,
0.2893433869,
0.6313259006,
0.2957441509,
-0.4694307148,
-0.7758630514,
0.1982596964,
-0.1416878402,
-0.1396740675,
0.2142769694,
0.0721451566,
-0.329757005,
0.2875872254,
-0.6674364209,
-0.3952957988,
0.2564472258,
0.5441477895,
-0.0183409993,
-0.2442041337,
0.3897279799,
-0.3649574518,
-0.3002954721,
0.2529741526,
-0.0758180618,
0.0112321917,
-0.2339839786,
-0.3794705868,
-0.546395421,
-0.2729231417,
0.0785066932,
-0.0856625289,
0.5173308253,
0.5862202048,
-0.6841753721,
-0.447615087,
-0.6591084599,
-0.2620536685,
-0.3981689811,
0.406627506,
-0.4055022001,
-0.2720289528,
0.285939604,
-0.5554279685,
-0.0181105845,
0.3030448258,
-0.0679152384,
-0.2325031608,
0.614340663,
0.4108766615,
0.0629037768,
0.3677329421,
-0.0151037965,
0.3989657462,
-0.5321854949,
-0.2719349265,
-0.5563280582,
-0.5536119938,
-0.3380988538,
-0.3929366171,
-0.0732695609,
0.2326239794,
-0.2670555115,
0.3669577241,
-0.5657237172,
0.5234314203,
0.7660625577,
0.0365616195,
0.3564079702,
0.275583148,
-0.038507551,
-0.4306063056,
-0.5451188684,
-0.3752432764,
0.796245873,
0.2291611135,
0.8321256638,
-0.1326180398,
0.985255003,
0.0500793234,
0.3179392517,
-0.5714899898,
0.4311561584,
0.2675847709,
-0.8570632935,
-0.0932245851,
-0.5096794963,
-0.8312653303,
-0.1465317309,
-0.3444938362,
-0.8211798668,
0.6674907207,
0.2795139551,
-0.1826075763,
0.7239992619,
-0.3621750772,
0.7958996892,
-0.2616624534,
-0.2688378692,
0.2436207533,
-0.5661879182,
0.2747420073,
-0.2588271499,
0.4674121141,
-0.2818465531,
0.1023170203,
1.0932571888,
-0.1627588272,
0.8235453367,
-0.3685362637,
0.0860670507,
0.4402112663,
0.3093534112,
0.6983428001,
-0.0648279712,
-0.1996696591,
0.4527429044,
-0.134967491,
-0.2110363096,
-0.3139707744,
0.6750743389,
-0.9137701392,
-0.1421831548,
-0.5338926315,
-0.3637343049,
-0.3310705423,
0.3020889163,
0.5466898084,
0.4015667439,
-0.2870407403,
0.1170125529,
0.9587358236,
0.0855352208,
0.1772024184,
0.4547443986,
0.0398744419,
-0.4663370848,
1.5038768053,
0.6558688879,
-0.1854177117,
-0.0364018977,
-0.3063043952,
-0.091386117,
-0.5697754622,
-0.2830894291,
0.0541348644,
-0.7713267803,
-0.4272629023,
-0.7972143888,
-0.2303269655,
0.0968560427,
0.1526934952,
-0.7179371119,
-0.4428341985,
-0.3745775521,
-0.442368269,
0.1880632639,
0.5521603823,
-0.3412192464,
0.1693262458,
-0.4662566483,
0.3766114414,
0.2329958826,
0.7191827893,
-0.1925241351,
-0.2884174585,
-0.1729341149,
0.0490669832,
-0.1423304975,
-1.0964399576,
0.1294425577,
0.3729550838,
0.6063547134,
0.3138749599,
0.4089361429,
0.7760596871,
-0.1504317969,
0.3353854418,
0.0820375606,
-0.6543460488,
0.4368353188,
0.0171230678,
-0.2661942542,
1.0323059559,
0.1472373456,
-0.16106309,
-0.3689131141,
-1.2087157965,
-0.8559469581,
0.5992961526,
0.0881756619,
-0.4489952028,
-0.0198327228,
0.254870832,
0.1166621447,
0.1689622998,
-0.7455474138,
-0.2198176831,
-0.2538540959,
-0.0330997482,
0.1912656873,
-0.2022036463,
0.0003657953,
-0.1166936979,
1.0216202736,
0.2022603154,
0.0660682619,
0.3683394492,
-0.4844305217,
-0.2658703327,
0.2713460624,
0.0591177382,
0.2908229828,
-0.294136554,
0.1871908158,
0.3899249434,
-0.39874807,
0.1658722758,
0.3595066369,
-0.54101789,
0.3715791106,
0.0685642287,
0.8209758997,
0.5688402653,
-0.753074944,
0.3018082678,
-0.1721360683,
-0.323558867,
-0.5125027895,
0.2584953904,
0.1046614125,
0.0165336691,
0.0799559876,
0.5188443065,
0.3313758969,
-0.1827914566,
0.2580139041,
0.0682700872,
-0.9953303933,
-0.2212230563,
0.875143826,
0.1481285989,
-0.2663002014,
0.8246290684,
-0.518719852,
-0.1925194263,
0.7016901374,
0.3944267631,
0.6374422908,
0.0991771743,
0.0999973044,
0.7207429409,
0.3216231465,
-0.4867590964,
0.0697448552,
0.0449198335,
-0.4482599497,
-0.1321053654,
-0.6800116897,
-0.7582324147,
0.1550636292,
-0.8511869907,
0.2313538194,
-0.5646266937,
-0.4879196584,
0.1588900834,
-0.0253742374,
-0.5054095387,
0.3899811506,
0.2424582392,
0.6670317054,
-0.4721231163,
0.4855153263,
0.9497932792,
-0.3716027439,
-0.8561044931,
-0.0720888898,
0.2937757373,
-0.2675737441,
0.559117496,
0.3252174556,
-0.0259877108,
0.2158858627,
-0.6452493072,
-0.8697885275,
0.7167268395,
0.4691330791,
-0.8202354312,
0.2415846288,
0.0190366898,
0.4662127793,
0.0995488539,
0.0978821442,
0.362767458,
0.6993953586,
-0.1753362566,
-0.6987576485,
0.0959652513,
-0.121628046,
-0.3851071298,
0.3329520524,
-0.6793805361,
0.5495497584,
-0.3191412091,
-0.4541969597,
-0.2448718101,
0.5960674286,
0.1228936315,
0.3948745131,
0.6377112269,
0.9941755533,
1.2948114872,
-0.3713810146,
0.555698812,
-0.2800616622,
0.366808176,
1.5335074663,
-0.3372110426,
0.7119267583,
0.3072767854,
-0.2844576538,
0.3778719306,
0.7653472424,
-0.6554800868,
0.2412798405,
0.6236789227,
-0.3446531296,
-0.4578107297,
-0.2460570782,
-0.4152688086,
0.1241657436,
0.3707693517,
0.0527322814,
-0.441752404,
-0.0588860847,
-0.0180210564,
-0.1072907448,
-0.071455285,
0.9015618563,
0.0713558793,
-0.276445508,
0.3816820383,
-0.0728504807,
0.612375319,
-0.1431452185,
-0.0618374608,
0.1027884558,
0.1394470483,
-0.4040238261,
-0.2044623792,
0.2602233291,
-0.0718188882,
-0.1511615217,
0.0229177959,
0.8733043075,
-0.1232391894,
-0.5513381958,
0.3327313066,
0.4250088334,
0.5291544795,
-0.210009113,
-0.7756198049,
0.0287418067,
-0.192699939,
-0.2936230898,
0.5096316338,
0.2355179489,
0.1374789625,
0.6331837177,
0.5901081562,
0.0275830347,
0.3620402813,
-0.1206489429,
0.5614569187,
-0.6511203051,
-0.1366667747,
-0.3850448728,
0.1509130448,
-0.2303853333,
-0.2752263844,
0.4412906468,
0.704641819,
1.043836236,
0.1663883924,
0.5649371147,
0.0398039483,
0.7256391644,
-0.1284653693,
0.7012216449,
-0.4727081954,
0.3213759959,
-0.1780828983,
-0.845672965,
-0.3520851433,
0.5023249388,
-0.1450003386,
-0.0675923452,
0.4187638462,
0.8167090416,
-0.2490662783,
0.1714571118,
0.3625943363,
0.4884948432,
-0.0161174685,
0.0627876893,
0.7816978097,
-0.6569840312,
0.8768369555,
-0.8495004177,
0.2018932849,
-0.2156723887,
-0.6550346613,
-0.5573328733,
-0.1919233501,
-1.054880619,
-0.6359075904,
0.3453207016,
0.5611712337,
0.7020298243,
-1.0224324465,
0.2205905169,
-0.239853844,
0.0408887006,
-0.4725225568,
-0.2333530337,
0.2471308857,
-0.4179528654,
-0.7711676955,
0.4022392631,
-0.0848385543,
0.1940070391,
0.28549546,
-0.0117027629,
0.0915897861,
-0.1633970886,
-0.0232507754,
0.6727760434,
-0.4158984721,
-0.0500163957,
-0.3638180494,
-0.2909499407,
0.2580187023,
0.4314331114,
-0.9212724566,
0.6062969565,
0.1484867781,
0.6394177079,
0.4710431397,
-0.1017789617,
0.0952281356,
-0.592241466,
-0.0123729352,
0.2755306363,
0.334223479,
0.275921315,
-0.2796308994,
0.7484912872,
0.3535126746,
-0.5002591014,
-1.2501151562,
-0.2187225372,
-0.8980226517,
-0.1173822731,
0.7938361168,
-0.16949296,
-0.1887829602,
-0.3783502281,
-0.0183868296,
0.4621133506,
-0.5443134904,
0.7194054127,
0.7267445326,
-0.0648986921,
-0.0980491564,
-0.9634149075,
0.5571808815,
0.2701275945,
-0.4722169638,
-0.1590995938,
0.6256852746,
0.5027607679,
0.1905000806,
0.3297728598,
-0.1258384734,
0.3024849594,
0.4689826965,
0.4118489623,
-0.1708764434,
-0.2396104187,
-0.1854009926,
0.137713626,
0.2474508286,
0.1213938072
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07597v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07597v1
|
Using Model-Theoretic Approaches to Uncover Linguistic Organization
| 2024-05-13T09:58:59 | 2024-05-13T09:58:59 |
Olivia Griffin, Jerry Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we consider pluractional markers in Kaqchikel, Karuk, and
Yurok. Like Balinese, each of these languages marks one type of pluractionality
via reduplication, and a different type of pluractionality via
non-reduplicative affixation. This paper serves as a proof-of-concept for
applying model-theoretic approaches to language as a lens that can help us to
recognize linguistic organization that is not apparent on the surface.
|
[
-0.4016798735,
-0.9352351427,
0.5348241329,
0.1967916638,
-0.3712116182,
0.0298709162,
-0.1774964333,
-0.2977918088,
0.3377824724,
0.4974212945,
-0.3333023787,
-0.4082061648,
-0.3867673576,
0.1577003002,
-0.5260637999,
0.7086399198,
-0.0444282666,
-0.0866247192,
0.0206467416,
-0.7701258659,
-0.212112084,
-0.53521806,
-0.4032589495,
-0.5365214944,
0.3628867865,
0.3223145008,
1.0565150976,
0.9343684912,
0.2965299189,
0.396025598,
-0.1687691212,
0.1024953648,
-0.0397587232,
0.0869659632,
-0.0284286719,
-0.9087616205,
-0.0409886539,
-0.019063713,
0.8903551102,
1.1263115406,
-0.416272819,
0.0239629783,
-0.2970202863,
0.5974165201,
-0.4610162675,
0.3293842375,
-0.2538427413,
0.0119019262,
-0.4988639057,
-0.1958648711,
-0.3850880265,
-0.3819180727,
-0.0301380828,
-0.8392719626,
-0.0119133387,
-0.0092535503,
0.823818922,
-0.0983545706,
-0.6517596245,
-0.2154224664,
-0.6189123988,
0.6973466873,
-0.6805711389,
0.5386328697,
0.7086806893,
0.3025160432,
-0.3291156888,
-0.4501757324,
-0.6824382544,
0.0329408944,
-0.2470746934,
0.0740638748,
0.1033282503,
0.1039933339,
0.0544264615,
0.274535507,
-0.3338599801,
0.1542652249,
-0.1252535582,
0.1572435796,
0.8216103315,
0.0568839759,
0.7927290201,
-0.0106277307,
-0.1982676983,
-0.0506234206,
-0.6655903459,
-0.054979872,
0.4093961716,
0.4810751975,
-0.2704758942,
0.5974609256,
-0.3037092984,
0.9631810188,
-0.0019069241,
-0.3627287149,
-0.0041214018,
-0.4122635722,
-0.1436902732,
-0.0238234345,
0.6519031525,
0.1049805135,
0.4380730391,
-0.2923878431,
0.0596990809,
0.2018206865,
-0.0180804189,
-0.3636250198,
-0.7225233316,
0.0713680759,
-0.6580328345,
-0.7218741179,
0.1938021183,
-0.6942310929,
-0.6035686135,
-0.1205504537,
0.2302669883,
-0.4631517828,
-1.0025185347,
-0.2261910588,
0.050397478,
0.0929972529,
0.2511730492,
-0.9786311388,
0.3356699049,
0.6543663144,
0.8012601733,
0.1534941792,
-0.4947459698,
-0.0759028569,
0.2759371102,
-0.5648021698,
0.9442049265,
-1.1053454876,
-0.2680766881,
0.1829496622,
-0.011158675,
-0.1853542328,
-0.5214157701,
0.3664990067,
-0.3024273217,
0.0407185592,
-0.2131136358,
-0.6936452985,
-0.8457119465,
-0.169983089,
-0.7089542747,
1.0643280745,
0.1210939735,
-0.5681923628,
0.4053077996,
-0.7387033105,
-0.5255283713,
0.3547780514,
-0.3419227302,
-0.3993832171,
0.7306911945,
-0.2071724385,
0.2477353066,
0.1552343071,
0.3333609104,
-0.1691378802,
-0.2626596689,
0.6485036016,
0.081959568,
1.061748147,
0.0666628107,
-0.1275088787,
0.3149279058,
-1.2090774775,
0.0875620693,
0.1411945224,
-0.568469286,
-0.9670674801,
0.3032810986,
-0.0881289616,
0.2179629803,
0.0166946407,
-0.4874843955,
0.280854404,
-0.4227905273,
0.7435603142,
0.5395691395,
-0.1285832822,
0.492324084,
-0.0949436352,
0.5187242627,
0.3438684344,
-0.1414360553,
0.0024203684,
-0.7031275034,
-1.2997164726,
-0.2200620919,
0.3379201293,
0.1244962066,
-0.8099879622,
0.1557441354,
-0.0217402391,
-0.5300937295,
-0.5986773372,
-0.0849765465,
0.4437450469,
0.3260037899,
0.0546737127,
-0.1943080723,
-0.4962574542,
-1.0345584154,
-0.2237213254,
-0.6070352197,
0.4444347322,
-0.0255592279,
0.5659436584,
0.288199991,
0.6667765379,
-0.1235218868,
0.0281422045,
-0.0588096641,
0.276736021,
0.3201133907,
0.23837623,
0.5490950346,
-0.9765506387,
-0.427287221,
0.6086760759,
-0.5046560764,
-0.292039901,
0.2681791484,
-0.0693755224,
0.1570080519,
0.3771695495,
-0.4768269956,
0.4759663939,
0.5184566975,
-0.5608106256,
0.2902579308,
-0.1839670837,
-0.0208983477,
-0.8406225443,
0.2274659574,
-0.3954728842,
-0.228388086,
-1.2279599905,
0.504296124,
-0.0203041323,
0.1628738642,
-0.0599627681,
0.3453645408,
-0.4026827514,
-0.1362366229,
-0.4005250335,
0.1282638013,
-0.2131140977,
0.5085681081,
0.4193961918,
0.6404247284,
0.1453127265,
-0.5843843818,
0.0930208564,
0.275347501,
-0.5934112668,
0.4968927503,
-0.2743720114,
-0.085039705,
-0.2245824188,
-0.1922042221,
-1.252627492,
-0.2159017473,
0.205007121,
-0.1506668329,
-0.0727548152,
-0.3428997993,
-0.6806402206,
0.0566298105,
-0.0366999879,
0.5916616917,
0.2736240029,
-0.3873544931,
0.4087825716,
0.4197100699,
-0.0176137406,
-0.1673765481,
-0.6023507118,
-0.321081996,
-0.6215370297,
-0.3183698356,
-0.0440145805,
0.0539559945,
-0.6710703373,
-0.343837142,
0.2386839092,
-0.5276593566,
0.6837891936,
0.4248056412,
-0.0055640708,
-0.3099253774,
0.134030655,
-0.0389965177,
0.0247917157,
-0.2830457389,
-0.0197663456,
0.4771265686,
0.0564737581,
0.0167875309,
-0.5243788958,
0.4660277665,
0.4394426644,
-0.3970120549,
0.809602499,
0.1578315496,
-0.3724098206,
-0.0254102051,
-0.4705208838,
0.0185000803,
-0.4109121263,
0.2290311754,
-0.5332186222,
-0.564658165,
0.6447944045,
-0.133762449,
-0.291895479,
0.2757275701,
0.6888168454,
-0.2054296136,
1.0781947374,
0.921350956,
0.2473414987,
0.5930460691,
-0.0486054718,
0.4247219563,
-0.6418802142,
-0.101528354,
-0.5163178444,
-0.1505690664,
-0.7213092446,
-0.1108844206,
0.1848828048,
0.7642168999,
-0.1665493846,
0.5354835987,
-0.2533247471,
0.5218167901,
0.285615027,
-0.4066618681,
0.6629579663,
0.0369277038,
-0.3595012426,
-0.1265805364,
-0.8957411051,
-0.5276520252,
0.6437397599,
0.3393815458,
0.0999517664,
0.3725470304,
0.7940024137,
-0.4013512731,
0.4102049172,
-0.506110549,
0.4997236431,
-0.0838603005,
-0.6425195336,
-0.3138813972,
-0.0992663056,
-0.8894093633,
0.6827149391,
-0.1286133379,
-0.9567357898,
0.890863061,
-0.1476173103,
-0.153000325,
0.1396012157,
-0.7905816436,
0.7485539317,
0.1434102654,
-0.0624101497,
-0.1140257642,
-0.3901342452,
0.2599892616,
-0.0296285413,
0.6562090516,
-0.2772360742,
-0.1247119084,
0.9165492654,
-0.5597957373,
0.8630831242,
-0.2056678236,
-0.3963762224,
0.386025548,
0.5074287057,
0.3075805008,
-0.2114723474,
-0.0568355545,
0.1454515308,
0.3305681348,
-0.2080634683,
-0.5684417486,
0.4665026367,
-0.6021373868,
-0.1098552421,
-0.340988785,
-0.69753474,
0.0016155624,
0.6308527589,
0.0684521198,
0.4549090564,
-0.0221839491,
-0.1132485271,
0.0179634467,
0.0932800472,
0.679490149,
0.8047935367,
-0.4310816824,
-0.2805041373,
0.9384871125,
0.36738801,
0.1966632456,
0.3287616372,
0.2803417742,
-0.1915748715,
-0.8656291962,
-0.0359187387,
0.6180766821,
-0.7403163314,
-0.1226877719,
-0.1730640382,
0.2004262507,
-0.1394099146,
-0.1340660602,
-0.3221889436,
-0.7610785365,
0.0801091492,
-0.0639034361,
0.3727976382,
1.0435689688,
0.0774511471,
0.6262244582,
-0.2918701768,
-0.0803294852,
-0.1051545441,
0.3177785277,
0.1140239686,
-0.0710159838,
-0.3099853992,
0.2660478652,
-0.0743459165,
-0.922921896,
0.4586776495,
0.3822973669,
0.344260186,
0.7392009497,
-0.1639645547,
0.9967586398,
-0.5345675349,
0.4552865922,
0.1673087776,
-0.8021129966,
0.593254149,
-0.6594987512,
0.1203135177,
0.5937281847,
0.1699388921,
-0.6557660103,
-0.6464045644,
-0.6211469769,
-0.5517788529,
0.4336962402,
0.3255968392,
-0.2328510284,
-0.2416039407,
0.5333359241,
0.1908111125,
0.4497369826,
-0.8298610449,
-0.2957254648,
-0.312894702,
-0.2691603005,
-0.0761839822,
-0.4165098071,
-0.3291177452,
-0.1513864696,
0.3179470599,
-0.1038256213,
0.265532434,
0.0442581475,
-0.3451991975,
-0.2525491416,
0.2498699874,
1.0525836945,
1.0501614809,
0.1230604872,
0.3904924989,
-0.3865405023,
-0.2930272818,
0.2066708058,
-0.1874798238,
-0.4062867165,
0.0042294906,
0.9576811194,
0.7776918411,
0.3023834229,
-0.4364261031,
0.3607595265,
0.3660950363,
0.0438133329,
-0.3132334948,
-0.1647857726,
0.173275426,
0.3887035549,
0.0255626887,
-0.5205231309,
0.1757141203,
-0.7845742106,
-0.200936988,
0.2699959278,
-0.036865253,
-0.8417726755,
0.4200842679,
0.135520637,
-0.3637796938,
0.5439156294,
0.152428776,
-0.6804813147,
0.4918432832,
0.6018198133,
0.6467316747,
-0.7554042339,
0.4777302444,
0.2453990579,
0.0621531345,
0.0433016308,
0.4895725846,
-0.3226816356,
-1.0461052656,
-0.2919237614,
-0.6896401048,
0.0359493904,
-0.1794615537,
-0.7529165745,
0.1897197813,
-0.5689393282,
0.0253861845,
0.5243183374,
-0.0995032564,
-0.2147044539,
0.0256847199,
-0.0186735075,
0.4214656353,
-1.1492596865,
1.115608573,
0.941401422,
-0.561273098,
-0.6147939563,
-0.3867020905,
-0.0870596394,
-1.0098280907,
0.9626677036,
0.0338027179,
0.1036336422,
0.0525150895,
-0.2141904235,
-0.7303621769,
0.9063277841,
0.027514929,
-0.29663679,
-0.0975178853,
0.2241627127,
0.6604034305,
-0.4534530044,
0.1654490381,
0.6479883194,
0.7130217552,
-0.5289096832,
-1.1043791771,
0.0213181302,
-0.2921773493,
0.3993732035,
0.6560592055,
-0.6255162954,
0.9098364711,
0.1229332238,
-0.7524254918,
0.3848704994,
0.4329923391,
-0.0460945033,
-0.0593458712,
0.3581259847,
0.5775613189,
0.5357270837,
-0.0865654573,
1.0187276602,
-0.1622428298,
0.5048427582,
0.8579366803,
-0.0113161495,
0.8728046417,
0.8589249253,
-0.5710114837,
0.7758758664,
0.360922128,
0.1669093966,
0.6339680552,
-0.0737977102,
-0.2367848605,
-0.3131555021,
-0.4452282786,
-0.0549562573,
0.7675235868,
0.5049235225,
-0.256205827,
-0.2203625292,
0.104822278,
0.2627636194,
0.3201011419,
-0.2084230632,
0.93648839,
0.0385791957,
-0.5161144733,
0.8090168834,
0.178770557,
0.1867388189,
-0.4378188252,
-0.2007083446,
-0.2210957408,
0.1364787072,
-0.2886659503,
-0.5718855262,
0.2703075707,
-0.6645296216,
0.0341267399,
0.0231643934,
0.5990260243,
-0.7750862241,
-0.5371948481,
0.1639982164,
0.2006392926,
0.0914060995,
0.4001584351,
-0.2751692533,
0.267493546,
-0.1411669701,
0.0515465178,
-0.027484091,
0.2929193676,
-0.4205959737,
0.6505693197,
0.3909923136,
0.2643937469,
0.2346635908,
0.0483306311,
0.3232246935,
-0.5684427023,
-0.7254971862,
-0.8219774365,
0.428478539,
-0.0349369831,
-0.2604103386,
0.9930754304,
0.2426130176,
0.8018689156,
-0.0262782611,
0.4639274776,
0.0099964291,
0.5033121109,
-0.4449418783,
0.6602048278,
-0.4393524528,
-0.2979108691,
-0.4365470111,
-0.9152724743,
-0.7518554926,
1.2759206295,
-0.3514384627,
-0.1199974194,
0.7723603249,
0.3898569047,
0.0369648449,
0.3141259253,
0.3901762664,
0.5667921305,
0.1305887401,
0.300909698,
0.9572809935,
-0.2634254694,
0.0211713053,
-0.7218447328,
-0.1112463176,
-0.1924632043,
-0.5259596705,
-0.9830750823,
-1.1606726646,
-0.58650738,
-0.0555320941,
-0.029044399,
0.4649261236,
0.4673410356,
-0.8754573464,
-0.6494267583,
-0.4771514833,
0.035952732,
-0.3926419914,
-0.1884461194,
0.456461072,
-0.0094444761,
-0.5826273561,
0.4600583613,
0.4403000176,
0.2770155668,
-0.2541864514,
0.1611212492,
-0.7094042301,
-0.0230530817,
0.61581707,
0.3524437249,
-1.0569112301,
-0.5335864425,
-0.6606881618,
0.4180965722,
0.1721968502,
1.1227023602,
-0.4623411894,
0.5669080615,
0.6224749088,
0.1683358699,
0.1230659708,
0.0360056795,
0.5201426148,
-0.7087405324,
0.7560278773,
-0.1147251427,
0.3526213765,
0.2685703933,
-0.0064072646,
0.6267445087,
0.3371510208,
-0.1876441538,
-1.2662023306,
0.6485309601,
-0.5752032399,
-0.2229228616,
0.7264390588,
-0.1628089845,
-0.3558640778,
-0.3790099025,
0.0126682632,
0.1237872541,
0.1046720594,
0.516261518,
1.1532751322,
-0.2329303026,
-0.5278535485,
-0.4599753618,
0.5574842691,
0.51302737,
-0.408176899,
0.2351303399,
0.3068352044,
0.4917086363,
0.4618869126,
0.7219596505,
-0.2220056355,
0.1457598954,
-0.077339001,
-0.256542325,
-0.0743755624,
-0.3739464581,
-0.5359546542,
0.0483475998,
0.3592496216,
-0.0873464942
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07586v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07586v1
|
Thai Universal Dependency Treebank
| 2024-05-13T09:48:13 | 2024-05-13T09:48:13 |
Panyut Sriwirote, Wei Qi Leong, Charin Polpanumas, Santhawat Thanyawong, William Chandra Tjhi, Wirote Aroonmanakun, Attapol T. Rutherford
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automatic dependency parsing of Thai sentences has been underexplored, as
evidenced by the lack of large Thai dependency treebanks with complete
dependency structures and the lack of a published systematic evaluation of
state-of-the-art models, especially transformer-based parsers. In this work, we
address these problems by introducing Thai Universal Dependency Treebank (TUD),
a new largest Thai treebank consisting of 3,627 trees annotated in accordance
with the Universal Dependencies (UD) framework. We then benchmark dependency
parsing models that incorporate pretrained transformers as encoders and train
them on Thai-PUD and our TUD. The evaluation results show that most of our
models can outperform other models reported in previous papers and provide
insight into the optimal choices of components to include in Thai dependency
parsers. The new treebank and every model's full prediction generated in our
experiment are made available on a GitHub repository for further study.
|
[
-0.4075208008,
-0.2879660726,
0.3756772876,
0.3506744206,
-0.3230225742,
0.0085016824,
0.0558053143,
-0.6161291599,
0.0145790465,
0.4895522594,
0.0075194803,
-0.3851097822,
-0.5415380001,
0.4890863299,
-0.1027156487,
0.6842013001,
-0.2233047187,
0.17915456,
0.1987484097,
-0.3133514225,
-0.6317277551,
-0.4812958241,
-0.1012903079,
-0.2771061659,
0.3677940667,
0.6498249769,
0.4347555637,
0.6205880642,
0.6991526484,
0.2077971399,
-0.0880466476,
-0.3843423128,
0.0837544873,
0.2361931503,
-0.1516120583,
-0.3640663028,
-0.3879642785,
-0.1782338321,
0.4765052497,
0.5631417632,
-0.0833257213,
0.2020821869,
0.1182321236,
0.634065032,
-0.8502727151,
0.5008391738,
-0.4580391347,
0.1541210711,
-0.1790370345,
0.0364211984,
-0.5867645144,
-0.4076148868,
0.4875275493,
-0.4572135508,
0.146529153,
-0.258572042,
0.9999646544,
0.3744545579,
-1.0032367706,
0.0173486713,
-0.5305975676,
0.3325303793,
-0.3128100634,
0.6360288262,
0.3048427999,
0.6792913675,
-0.0182786901,
-0.8508745432,
-0.1180395037,
-0.1781500429,
-0.2550333142,
0.105836086,
-0.1354071647,
0.4565019011,
0.0390811302,
0.6169106364,
-0.443762213,
0.1704484075,
0.095508337,
-0.0583378635,
0.115300864,
-0.1612704098,
0.1743409783,
-0.7884501219,
-0.125614509,
-0.1574275494,
-0.6023587584,
0.2724739015,
0.1137438342,
0.1404757202,
-0.1000585109,
0.766821146,
-0.1515654176,
0.3940584958,
0.0535850152,
0.2232172787,
0.0372996219,
-0.2496608347,
-0.4746596813,
0.294177264,
0.7268200517,
0.3963782787,
0.7264303565,
0.1205059215,
-0.1138908342,
0.3158635795,
0.0087384619,
-0.9775893688,
-0.6429903507,
0.0400631204,
-0.4384845495,
-0.3848187029,
0.189442426,
-0.9240896702,
-0.2730493546,
-0.2522765994,
-0.1695683748,
-0.4110635221,
-0.5534621477,
0.2540826201,
0.1179600507,
0.1538849026,
0.0264755599,
-0.7300425172,
0.3200913668,
0.350274533,
0.7633411288,
-0.1051742062,
-0.0747478828,
-0.5441072583,
0.3598735631,
-0.1540692747,
1.1316984892,
-0.7385796905,
-0.4168274105,
0.0573887192,
0.2674892843,
0.0824292675,
-0.5442805886,
0.7943156362,
-0.3459807634,
0.2502727807,
-0.3102678061,
-0.5017263889,
-0.4342598319,
0.0302172732,
-0.8823570609,
0.9232058525,
0.6895368099,
-1.1562108994,
0.4883638322,
-0.9555795193,
-0.4306596816,
0.1153100654,
-0.1509491354,
-0.4494426548,
0.1117594987,
0.4079685509,
0.4567857683,
-0.4232437611,
0.8481895328,
-0.2759576738,
0.0929501876,
-0.2656633854,
-0.248310551,
1.318197608,
0.4383409023,
-0.2517317832,
0.2526652217,
-0.9892114401,
-0.2291222662,
0.0158818513,
-0.4199540615,
-0.3130471408,
-0.462656498,
0.4377450943,
-0.1044919938,
-0.1084754914,
-0.7528334856,
0.3904725611,
-0.3411742449,
0.4728284776,
0.8083798289,
0.0379953012,
0.1376615167,
0.0148075726,
0.7665930986,
0.5586559772,
-0.1366426498,
-0.7433283329,
-0.2850354612,
-0.6088696122,
-0.1825344712,
0.6500778794,
0.405995667,
-0.2614843249,
0.6854537725,
-0.4533003569,
-0.3104989231,
-0.4358894229,
-0.2282092124,
0.2839561701,
0.5055444837,
0.2492224425,
-0.5645973086,
-1.3018507957,
-0.8385386467,
-0.1931733787,
-0.4104636908,
0.0269329809,
-0.1087869704,
0.5736107826,
-0.4486701488,
1.2976278067,
-0.2352588624,
-0.3539441526,
-0.3087207973,
-0.0264596846,
-0.207982406,
0.5483804941,
0.6274901628,
-0.4187529385,
-0.8654827476,
0.1302328259,
-0.5632346272,
-0.2894841135,
0.2473445684,
0.1165317744,
0.2058944702,
0.4302548766,
-0.9012620449,
0.4391088784,
0.3415220082,
-0.5744447112,
0.7726513147,
-0.0773873925,
-0.0183255728,
-1.1445676088,
0.1511091888,
0.0632284135,
-0.5108840466,
-0.2216596901,
0.036359068,
0.2643932998,
-0.1322714388,
-0.3380909264,
0.2908461094,
-0.4408356845,
-0.260279268,
0.116076,
-0.6121582389,
0.2829245329,
0.4685205221,
-0.0877772272,
0.6641296744,
0.4286264181,
-0.3462266028,
0.3987919986,
0.2016293406,
-0.4584934711,
0.4810445011,
-0.7410644889,
-0.1263050288,
-0.1681820601,
0.5378803015,
-1.0850815773,
-0.2993957102,
0.0647015795,
-0.0174494442,
0.3488671482,
-0.5584763288,
-0.5061669946,
-0.4190013707,
-0.1742429584,
0.6039124727,
0.3770934939,
-0.6352468729,
0.6377280354,
0.52107054,
0.1527217478,
-0.3434390426,
-0.5341531038,
0.0514960177,
-0.3810806572,
-0.4233368933,
0.2471135408,
0.2467543632,
-0.2792929411,
0.0956292525,
-0.1942292005,
-0.2412969619,
0.0810119584,
0.4006868303,
-0.0597260818,
-0.7644267678,
-0.0752713084,
-0.2785279453,
-0.5114599466,
0.0918303803,
-0.4490066469,
0.5512285829,
-0.3205642998,
-0.2955607474,
-0.6841551661,
0.1634434462,
0.7005621195,
-0.407178849,
0.2188007087,
0.1710361689,
-0.3504188061,
0.5232950449,
-0.6354591846,
0.3520142734,
-0.4483774006,
0.5001861453,
-0.7859439254,
-0.7403208017,
0.352524668,
-0.2246982306,
0.0562405922,
0.4922377169,
0.1854982078,
0.1207928285,
1.279353261,
0.9571709633,
-0.3191832304,
0.4747440815,
-0.134067893,
-0.0340200849,
-0.5917261839,
0.1498239487,
-0.7309948206,
0.0762330517,
-0.8160768151,
0.1281974614,
-0.0340358913,
0.2764383554,
-0.6183236837,
0.5402147174,
-0.65953511,
0.707799077,
0.5243423581,
-0.4114994705,
0.59736377,
-0.0074263294,
-0.5375461578,
-0.0253885165,
-0.4518080354,
-0.6137000322,
1.3558744192,
0.3367356062,
0.3941815495,
-0.3379964232,
0.2388224602,
0.098629944,
0.3450075388,
-0.5996180177,
0.2128481716,
-0.1440470368,
-0.2441182435,
0.0466751121,
-0.1362887323,
-1.3412414789,
0.1096484885,
0.4135372043,
-0.69588238,
0.1040289178,
-0.0672331825,
-0.3072488308,
0.400002867,
-1.1308641434,
1.2773954868,
-0.1419101954,
0.3653660119,
0.0012388298,
-0.597483933,
0.5688277483,
0.0967667103,
-0.1891424507,
-0.0061053825,
0.3194383085,
0.7516333461,
-0.5008358955,
0.481510371,
-0.4252203107,
-0.0703472048,
0.3083450794,
0.1857600659,
0.2532089949,
0.1312913895,
0.1223841384,
-0.0375106074,
0.329020679,
-0.3889762461,
-0.3613841236,
0.4903359413,
-0.9719247818,
-0.3780007362,
-0.4692712724,
-0.3087264001,
-0.1858869493,
0.3827247322,
0.2467001528,
0.2742322087,
-0.1847133785,
0.2796927691,
0.2337785512,
-0.2195754498,
0.5305582285,
0.4500996768,
-0.7326982617,
-0.6288557053,
0.3822738528,
0.0848002806,
-0.190245524,
0.3549817204,
0.2166157663,
-0.4116556346,
-0.1404039562,
-0.4974544942,
0.1418127269,
-0.8262559772,
-0.4054521024,
-0.9153510332,
-0.2502786815,
-0.5536277294,
0.01584897,
-0.5426679254,
-0.5114811659,
0.0904852599,
-0.5352799296,
0.4203670025,
1.0140447617,
0.1196347252,
0.5788868666,
-0.6952589154,
0.6187068224,
0.3215839565,
0.8533630371,
-0.0483963713,
-0.1086668596,
-0.0014379789,
0.0189251266,
-0.5625132322,
-0.8557468653,
0.2419853061,
0.0085029136,
0.1693683118,
0.5845628977,
0.1550567299,
0.7554703355,
-0.4788486958,
0.4257830679,
0.3423289359,
-0.7728440762,
0.7328377366,
-0.0623608381,
0.520988524,
0.5165442228,
0.2975835204,
-0.5700771213,
-0.2593847513,
-0.616009593,
-0.5239667296,
0.5752744675,
-0.0256240554,
-0.4407941103,
0.157609567,
0.0968284979,
0.3884270191,
-0.1978083104,
-0.8643604517,
-0.1451696903,
-0.4979626834,
-0.3644059598,
0.0060825446,
-0.5168830752,
0.507368505,
-0.5164941549,
0.5032534003,
0.1308992803,
-0.0752034262,
0.1267411411,
-0.4741220176,
-0.5416764021,
0.1602655798,
-0.0340913534,
0.5432718992,
-0.2708375752,
0.4967538118,
-0.1775076836,
-0.6288487315,
0.6328458786,
0.1689971089,
-0.238811627,
0.4084914327,
0.0266864039,
0.6108090281,
0.1930691004,
-0.6642127037,
0.4058350921,
-0.2309857607,
0.1157352477,
-0.4042361081,
-0.183220461,
0.1681374013,
-0.1351804584,
0.1522196531,
0.2134658098,
-0.0542438962,
-0.2685627043,
0.5070900917,
0.076522842,
-0.5662616491,
-0.5787578821,
0.762952745,
0.211425975,
-0.3264263868,
0.4748337269,
0.0290979333,
-0.7199015021,
0.4981044829,
0.3637451231,
1.1519380808,
-0.4860595167,
0.229483366,
0.3881258368,
0.1258024126,
-0.0167374089,
0.1981351078,
-0.0029007134,
-0.5336889029,
-0.716778636,
-0.6037098169,
-0.1726488173,
0.3394426405,
-0.5608903766,
0.616794467,
-0.1949418783,
0.0647456944,
-0.0587867387,
0.1766485572,
-0.7232373953,
0.0532479249,
-0.3701948822,
0.7232105136,
-0.6900421381,
1.2004309893,
0.8607218862,
-0.6094930768,
-0.6436624527,
-0.1548828781,
-0.2936881483,
-0.5923042297,
0.6943998337,
0.7953975201,
0.2167363465,
0.2242111713,
-0.1578813642,
-0.6219239831,
0.6086046696,
0.7828791142,
-0.5046941042,
-0.1393759549,
0.7258963585,
0.370533675,
-0.2181449085,
0.7170332074,
0.8853682876,
0.6440936327,
-0.3602638543,
-0.9378890395,
-0.083931461,
-0.5195195675,
0.1284954697,
0.1049304232,
-0.364775598,
0.554479301,
0.1653842777,
-0.3774971068,
-0.1003501564,
0.5967720151,
0.1867769957,
-0.1091212258,
0.749856174,
0.87792027,
0.429422766,
0.1801688522,
0.7682829499,
-0.4972448647,
0.2265103012,
1.2019815445,
-0.2289201319,
0.4826644063,
0.2668000162,
-0.3746076524,
0.5265499949,
0.8779732585,
0.0417955816,
0.4116267264,
0.1678966582,
-0.0296537019,
-0.03709241,
-0.5402433872,
-0.5652999878,
0.4923943281,
-0.1188132912,
-0.1942608804,
-0.5991802812,
0.1994964927,
-0.2262343615,
-0.0736587867,
0.019741537,
0.6419941783,
0.051607307,
-0.7353703976,
0.6132714748,
-0.0656488612,
0.572784245,
-0.2692183256,
-0.1378347278,
-0.2807311714,
0.2694403529,
-0.1440501213,
-0.606979847,
0.1924253106,
0.3291027248,
0.0015785671,
-0.5018540025,
0.5973501205,
-0.2075411081,
-0.4676599205,
0.3713386953,
0.4137174487,
-0.0061887349,
-0.426979661,
-0.2732962668,
-0.3174990118,
0.0052343477,
-0.363052994,
0.3567510843,
0.9922991991,
-0.1658904552,
0.6085025668,
0.4162170589,
-0.0292202476,
0.1318547428,
0.1775804758,
0.6298422813,
-0.8333944678,
-0.7590597272,
-0.9581779242,
0.4526802003,
0.2459590733,
-0.456769526,
0.5731128454,
0.9410282373,
1.0444065332,
0.0376026332,
0.8753224611,
0.0345107876,
0.5168160796,
-0.0962344334,
0.4029381871,
-0.1972768903,
0.2620608211,
-0.3440872133,
-1.1976850033,
-0.4149591327,
0.5421892405,
0.0963329002,
-0.2408259511,
0.8905724287,
0.38007164,
-0.4881538451,
0.5177901387,
0.0405431762,
0.386695534,
0.6134367585,
0.6761224866,
0.9734148979,
-0.3827224076,
0.7878983021,
-0.5833291411,
0.3471113145,
-0.1690063775,
-0.8289039135,
-0.648307085,
-0.6520807147,
-0.3003131449,
-0.099898845,
-0.094480969,
0.918209374,
0.5154877901,
-1.2925730944,
-0.5010477901,
-0.9224740863,
0.1547665745,
0.2641526163,
-0.2864703238,
0.5710675716,
-0.4831515253,
-0.4647136629,
-0.048335392,
0.3031383753,
0.3537763357,
-0.2191959172,
0.0175539088,
-0.2489223629,
-0.7394118309,
0.4750348628,
0.0079364562,
-0.7597286105,
-0.5507028103,
-0.1796849072,
-0.2316121757,
0.7507040501,
0.9713069797,
-1.0532220602,
0.4382319152,
0.3474195302,
0.8424328566,
0.4425026178,
-0.0345943272,
0.8833159804,
-0.4118725359,
0.1801947057,
0.1258996874,
0.7126277685,
0.2824995518,
0.1016967967,
0.8643077612,
0.3404233754,
-0.4619261026,
-0.9871065617,
0.2623012662,
-0.6980209947,
-0.1882040948,
1.0068379641,
-0.4636149704,
-0.0036482343,
-0.5734331608,
-0.613711834,
0.622267127,
-0.2015849501,
0.6908358335,
0.6560078859,
0.194343701,
-0.4079279602,
-0.3115552962,
0.4488619864,
0.5483610034,
-0.7473201752,
0.3850918412,
0.4669773281,
-0.0454557687,
-0.1349184811,
0.6342447996,
0.1053026989,
0.2160604,
-0.1772780865,
0.1376533806,
0.0803496316,
-0.3614723682,
-0.349018693,
0.2519833446,
0.0431041755,
-0.1610845327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13008v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13008v1
|
Control Token with Dense Passage Retrieval
| 2024-05-13T09:17:19 | 2024-05-13T09:17:19 |
Juhwan Lee, Jisu Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This study addresses the hallucination problem in large language models
(LLMs). We adopted Retrieval-Augmented Generation(RAG) (Lewis et al., 2020), a
technique that involves embedding relevant information in the prompt to obtain
accurate answers. However, RAG also faced inherent issues in retrieving correct
information. To address this, we employed the Dense Passage Retrieval(DPR)
(Karpukhin et al., 2020) model for fetching domain-specific documents related
to user queries. Despite this, the DPR model still lacked accuracy in document
retrieval. We enhanced the DPR model by incorporating control tokens, achieving
significantly superior performance over the standard DPR model, with a 13%
improvement in Top-1 accuracy and a 4% improvement in Top-20 accuracy.
|
[
-0.0967381075,
-0.928557992,
0.6720619798,
0.1735437512,
-0.3134173155,
0.295941025,
-0.1897204816,
-0.3533291817,
0.3469745815,
0.6810436845,
-0.1705572456,
-0.3870042264,
-0.7847471833,
0.1799758524,
-0.4542199969,
0.632979095,
-0.0379468203,
0.1262186468,
0.0167490356,
0.1067814305,
-0.6268430948,
-0.7624992728,
-0.8458553553,
-0.3995135427,
0.6183498502,
0.2369860262,
0.7229251266,
0.5369555354,
0.7503530979,
0.2671673,
-0.4341750443,
0.4257407188,
-0.4690678716,
0.3167079091,
-0.3586669862,
-0.4376110733,
-0.4135116637,
-0.2572817802,
0.6665865183,
0.6764913797,
-0.2671614885,
-0.3870575428,
-0.0348484404,
0.5403687954,
-0.5464912057,
-0.2290063053,
-0.9544463158,
0.1258617938,
-0.1584100723,
-0.6541138291,
-0.8023298383,
-0.1193698049,
-0.2069814652,
-0.5276793242,
0.2138223499,
0.3539915085,
0.8746349216,
0.335837245,
-0.3994303942,
-0.6396753788,
-0.6580659747,
0.8736039996,
-0.6219975352,
0.486253202,
0.6268626451,
0.2586236,
-0.4735021889,
-1.0702328682,
-0.7536278367,
-0.4590372443,
-0.2458980083,
-0.1391600519,
0.0436419435,
0.1014039442,
0.3773072362,
0.25992167,
-0.4058884978,
0.2282754779,
-0.392958343,
-0.2818649113,
0.4923669994,
0.4449233711,
0.2031137049,
-0.5211462975,
-0.5170624256,
-0.1506920308,
-0.5151670575,
-0.2813346386,
0.1530355662,
0.4955642521,
0.2228861898,
0.9149823785,
0.0242905226,
0.7671481967,
0.1511443853,
-0.2723350227,
0.1962565482,
-0.2980069518,
-0.0962531492,
-0.0493898541,
0.3194745481,
0.1401284933,
0.2037591487,
-0.3405916989,
-0.6276837587,
-0.3169054985,
0.4818694592,
-0.8287838697,
0.1044430956,
0.4392063618,
-0.4586844742,
-0.1965904683,
0.3107753992,
-0.7802709341,
-0.6218554378,
-0.5893586278,
0.3881283998,
-0.3436278403,
-0.3720095456,
0.1010241434,
-0.3041660488,
0.3866413832,
0.4826614857,
-0.9541178942,
0.5413210392,
0.9158865213,
1.1968849897,
-0.9743723273,
-0.0662944391,
-0.7500895858,
0.2087849528,
-0.4514952302,
0.553563118,
-0.8036599159,
-0.5895873904,
0.0167712644,
-0.1192739755,
-0.1451670825,
-0.8585252762,
0.4509698749,
-0.9295003414,
-0.0415175557,
-0.3295147419,
-0.6563357711,
0.049635116,
0.1374131739,
-0.7380296588,
1.0452046394,
0.161397621,
-0.8264859319,
0.3005648255,
-0.2980769277,
-0.2951725125,
0.2493620068,
-0.575707376,
-0.1183099747,
0.2297310978,
0.072700642,
0.5354953408,
0.042030707,
0.4811731279,
0.0696580261,
-0.7713088989,
0.3595211506,
-0.2981773615,
0.6593438983,
0.3097249269,
-0.4099677205,
0.0591048934,
-0.6812487841,
-0.1481445581,
0.0819863603,
-0.3993224204,
-0.5226359367,
-0.2445693761,
0.1399408728,
0.1493285149,
0.311987102,
-0.3446663916,
0.4583079815,
-0.2118364871,
0.0973095372,
0.895842433,
0.3246218562,
0.5027194619,
-0.2699823678,
0.6327789426,
0.2545085847,
-0.0763649046,
0.1160025075,
-0.3009101152,
-0.4708400667,
-0.3076009452,
0.2962872982,
0.4310429692,
-0.8245431781,
0.4528146386,
-0.1570646018,
-0.2818531394,
-0.2558468878,
0.0821426734,
0.197302267,
0.5500106812,
0.4016019702,
-0.0606556088,
-0.334864825,
-0.5057269335,
-0.0355514474,
0.0051017292,
0.0473044291,
0.6209052205,
0.627556622,
-0.4136473238,
0.6219597459,
-0.6270473599,
-0.374610424,
-0.4416742921,
0.0623021685,
0.302061975,
0.5889573693,
0.1720058769,
-1.1616491079,
-0.4545004964,
0.01007831,
-0.6140002608,
-0.0177300274,
-0.2118812799,
-0.3241610527,
0.4719472826,
0.6946927309,
-0.8591113687,
0.4897179604,
0.2698018849,
-0.5831140876,
0.5475015044,
-0.1936231405,
0.2159149945,
-1.1611087322,
0.4368885756,
-0.5021780729,
-0.2121223211,
-0.5110948086,
0.0917681903,
0.1988301426,
0.0193870775,
-0.3696873784,
0.9087617397,
-0.4416677654,
-0.2599596083,
-0.3638660014,
0.4729690254,
0.0599191189,
0.4101295471,
0.064440608,
1.0976138115,
0.2823863029,
-0.7906087637,
0.1606753021,
0.3319174647,
-0.240606755,
0.2129970342,
-0.7227126956,
0.294834882,
-0.2861431241,
0.1453007758,
-0.9691154361,
-0.3250350654,
0.1054080725,
-0.4186305702,
0.5874468088,
0.2757132351,
-0.5665892959,
-0.1831080467,
-0.0968097672,
0.2044529617,
0.348616153,
-0.5132168531,
0.7065414786,
0.3023845255,
-0.2366832495,
-0.909424901,
-0.5916082859,
0.1694728583,
0.0058534672,
-0.1828568876,
0.5605956912,
-0.0574409142,
-0.5098818541,
-0.1604893357,
-0.2197857052,
0.0699462816,
0.0514686368,
0.0725766569,
0.1593576074,
0.1535678208,
0.407071501,
0.1055704504,
-0.0373001695,
-0.2077193856,
0.0065129115,
1.015963316,
0.3428439796,
-0.3177422285,
-0.3561404347,
0.4785839319,
0.5956217051,
-0.1825899333,
0.8384055495,
0.4363836348,
-0.4758856893,
-0.4111109972,
-0.7178442478,
-0.5865873694,
-0.4921416342,
0.3071102798,
-0.7232313156,
-1.1038954258,
0.7220445275,
0.1056220904,
-0.2222779244,
0.2115968615,
0.5304139853,
0.2541581392,
1.1062998772,
0.7236737609,
0.0061058193,
0.5804546475,
-0.2140590698,
0.0859536156,
-1.0008232594,
-0.5371638536,
-0.7003756166,
-0.2610071898,
-0.3394750953,
-0.5168489218,
0.2595697343,
0.4029066265,
-0.1951604933,
0.1193234846,
-0.6027817726,
0.2092510462,
0.4470666051,
0.3264781833,
0.5907421708,
0.2648148537,
-0.6008781791,
-0.2051345706,
-0.597964704,
-0.4560810328,
0.9562187195,
0.2036796361,
0.8754953742,
0.1493261456,
0.6903192401,
0.4821285903,
0.1097085401,
-0.6548570395,
0.5806301832,
-0.0013815057,
-0.6487242579,
-0.4365042746,
-0.6245269775,
-1.0416557789,
0.3328277767,
0.0612019002,
-0.8284819722,
0.3148490191,
-0.2228386849,
-0.3415657878,
0.1971270591,
-0.3264411092,
0.5437482595,
-0.1787278503,
-0.3786810935,
-0.2066192627,
-0.3459998369,
0.2361641526,
-0.3517994583,
-0.2059149146,
0.2328288555,
-0.427295506,
0.6985033154,
-0.3900131285,
0.6525751948,
-0.3243232965,
-0.0529239327,
0.1796062291,
0.2829384208,
0.871579349,
-0.0361931697,
-0.4287402034,
-0.1052329019,
-0.2854951918,
-0.3555957675,
-0.8668863177,
0.7420617938,
-0.6913980842,
-0.759675324,
-0.4058057964,
-0.539516151,
0.044335898,
0.3389610946,
0.124151431,
0.4996086955,
0.2706561089,
0.3400680721,
0.8359734416,
-0.290515691,
0.3753035665,
0.5181754231,
-0.5077640414,
-0.4903507233,
0.5057634115,
0.2945302725,
0.2256753147,
0.4956226647,
0.1076242775,
-0.5612284541,
-0.7416311502,
-0.3477535546,
0.4960468709,
-0.7999253273,
-0.3248279691,
-1.0924378633,
-0.2534308434,
-0.4806908965,
-0.1449471265,
-0.006293036,
-0.3251564503,
-0.4883262217,
-0.316901207,
0.3798655272,
0.7933876514,
0.1065639555,
0.3372653723,
-0.6282141209,
0.4561969042,
-0.0171382595,
0.3273202181,
0.2390220761,
-0.9447617531,
-0.1119747236,
-0.2705268264,
-0.0828553587,
-0.9180109501,
0.4845526814,
-0.1339591891,
0.6775201559,
0.2063772082,
0.1479967386,
0.7674906254,
-0.4065489769,
0.8949056268,
-0.132689327,
-0.7826799154,
0.5242235065,
-0.1182940379,
0.1548951119,
0.6371801496,
0.5549553037,
-0.4071931541,
-0.3528329432,
-0.4968388081,
-0.9310073256,
0.4010051489,
0.0393531024,
0.2315447628,
-0.2068587244,
0.782643795,
0.0407579429,
0.3336980641,
-0.6351895928,
-0.0048428555,
0.3046711385,
-0.0821024776,
0.0072948379,
-0.4285398126,
0.1171718389,
-0.224284187,
0.5935561061,
-0.1440718472,
0.2180055529,
0.6382774711,
-0.0267962851,
-0.3797957003,
-0.0271522421,
0.7487069964,
1.0427166224,
-0.2174893022,
0.1500334591,
0.0893274769,
-0.7722586989,
0.0766346306,
-0.0857083052,
-0.3543797433,
0.2742077708,
0.2997899354,
0.6667752266,
-0.0409038737,
-0.7996724844,
0.6306993365,
0.0874583423,
-0.0161683578,
-0.5422759056,
-0.0141868982,
-0.2865869701,
0.2407568842,
0.7699139714,
-0.184652403,
0.1454182118,
-0.2443978935,
0.6283025742,
0.520258069,
-0.4113821387,
0.1736622006,
0.7796243429,
-0.0743072852,
-0.4065670669,
0.8495192528,
-0.1254025698,
-0.5345340967,
0.460878849,
0.7499449253,
0.8226361871,
-0.0758364946,
0.1525295377,
0.4780001938,
0.2931438684,
-0.2203352302,
0.5417427421,
-0.1678397357,
-0.6800900102,
-0.7246389389,
-0.9561913013,
-0.5339108706,
0.2344299853,
-0.6684176922,
0.2469791621,
-0.4424537718,
-0.2375062406,
-0.4267778695,
0.3759471178,
-0.3810205758,
0.133542046,
-0.2061732709,
1.2826493979,
-0.5068454146,
0.8829267025,
0.3610844612,
-0.6281722188,
-0.9969722033,
0.0145009989,
-0.4546888471,
-0.6243717074,
1.0315554142,
0.0756248683,
-0.0876998231,
0.1837236583,
-0.559553206,
-0.8506311774,
1.2383545637,
-0.127973929,
-0.7906604409,
-0.0546898283,
0.0952587128,
0.5426689982,
-0.2903360426,
0.0819125846,
0.4842613637,
0.5159297585,
0.3014879525,
-0.7011786103,
0.3031007051,
-0.097353667,
0.1099841222,
0.0401776098,
-0.4883078337,
0.9435423017,
-0.1528365314,
-0.1758219749,
0.0784708932,
0.743727386,
0.5578568578,
0.2614963055,
0.4939748943,
0.6068513393,
1.0859423876,
0.1484473348,
1.2136911154,
-0.1939956993,
0.0105492566,
1.0202031136,
-0.4844453931,
1.1463909149,
0.8712648153,
0.1175601408,
0.2982951403,
0.4048640132,
0.1473998427,
0.5214943886,
0.3516429663,
-0.2659710646,
-0.1677152663,
-0.2245918065,
-0.2239831835,
0.2976186574,
0.4593824446,
-0.5190616846,
0.2286409289,
0.1546199322,
0.1410977095,
0.1913490444,
-0.3596650362,
0.971206665,
0.2082624584,
-0.8679454923,
0.729793191,
-0.0496610254,
0.647257328,
-0.4801777601,
-0.3137653768,
-0.5723664761,
0.197341159,
-0.2184797376,
-0.5585743785,
0.3207805455,
0.0339132808,
-0.0355978161,
-0.173381716,
0.8956813216,
-0.4036754668,
-0.3620569706,
0.4396215975,
0.6494594216,
0.3720838428,
-0.1247537509,
-0.5805202127,
0.4756752849,
-0.0262692496,
-0.4419720769,
0.135234192,
0.5276341438,
-0.2227664739,
0.7176453471,
0.5812859535,
0.3920197487,
0.2686098516,
0.2974787951,
1.0326737165,
-0.8665166497,
-0.2877550721,
-0.7647622824,
0.3728374243,
-0.3584327996,
-0.2800554335,
0.7090463042,
0.5746257305,
0.7738002539,
-0.0214255992,
0.6168915629,
-0.0992162302,
0.7575985193,
-0.6997644305,
0.7643995285,
-0.7387679219,
0.2639372349,
-0.1837785393,
-1.1244946718,
-0.5332263708,
0.6089819074,
-0.1539510787,
0.1103854105,
0.7314589024,
1.2506365776,
0.0829105377,
-0.4308076799,
0.5408688188,
0.2489865571,
0.2750133574,
0.1190390289,
0.8427864909,
-0.448851198,
0.4270197451,
-0.1266781539,
-0.1534088105,
-0.4655327797,
-0.6681677103,
-0.9419212341,
-0.5613772273,
-0.0491414405,
-0.5529714227,
0.1273359209,
0.953338623,
0.4030166566,
-0.9269189835,
-0.1406689733,
-0.259477675,
0.2519693673,
-0.0940177739,
-0.314509809,
0.5597337484,
-0.7754797935,
-0.8084008694,
0.3570878804,
0.1793493479,
0.2334887236,
-0.4474518001,
-0.2681470811,
-0.2124265879,
0.1303059608,
0.4893220365,
-0.1566076875,
-0.7815445065,
-0.3026563823,
0.3415781856,
-0.6059399843,
-0.1123885661,
1.0857619047,
-0.5506845713,
0.329649061,
0.6487087011,
0.9447995424,
0.5661122799,
0.3149946928,
0.4305716753,
-0.6889089346,
0.2276395559,
0.5136104822,
0.2148479223,
0.4046973288,
-0.6173229814,
0.5691769719,
0.2415387183,
-0.62901932,
-0.9533576965,
0.1142087281,
-1.1869709492,
-0.4184920788,
1.4091881514,
0.1219584867,
-0.289871037,
-0.2377281189,
-0.5360729098,
0.2041511685,
-0.406575948,
0.8463484049,
0.6285458803,
0.0631047115,
-0.2331552356,
-0.5871443748,
0.6143574715,
0.4835886955,
-0.5018996596,
0.0110870562,
0.5212163925,
-0.1378576308,
0.2332214564,
0.8763898611,
-0.3742945492,
-0.0534340777,
0.050393492,
-0.0102569666,
0.0273657963,
-0.5989345908,
-0.4246574342,
0.353815645,
0.1605766267,
0.1248478889
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13007v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13007v1
|
News Recommendation with Category Description by a Large Language Model
| 2024-05-13T08:53:43 | 2024-05-13T08:53:43 |
Yuki Yada, Hayato Yamana
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Personalized news recommendations are essential for online news platforms to
assist users in discovering news articles that match their interests from a
vast amount of online content. Appropriately encoded content features, such as
text, categories, and images, are essential for recommendations. Among these
features, news categories, such as tv-golden-globe, finance-real-estate, and
news-politics, play an important role in understanding news content, inspiring
us to enhance the categories' descriptions. In this paper, we propose a novel
method that automatically generates informative category descriptions using a
large language model (LLM) without manual effort or domain-specific knowledge
and incorporates them into recommendation models as additional information. In
our comprehensive experimental evaluations using the MIND dataset, our method
successfully achieved 5.8% improvement at most in AUC compared with baseline
approaches without the LLM's generated category descriptions for the
state-of-the-art content-based recommendation models including NAML, NRMS, and
NPA. These results validate the effectiveness of our approach. The code is
available at https://github.com/yamanalab/gpt-augmented-news-recommendation.
|
[
-0.6093962789,
-0.6337972283,
0.6028747559,
0.1317034066,
-0.6791645288,
0.0102516469,
-0.3128714561,
-0.3316875696,
0.6317919493,
0.6836125255,
-0.6074377298,
-0.763967514,
-0.2605711222,
-0.0148456469,
-0.2608332336,
1.3807377815,
0.0376954675,
-0.1467764676,
-0.1375942528,
0.0941714123,
-0.7164696455,
-0.3691313565,
-0.5242254734,
-0.1637722403,
0.4784257412,
0.2780399621,
0.4384478629,
0.5881545544,
0.6403954029,
0.1924690902,
0.0006185923,
0.4290344715,
-0.191751346,
-0.2235216945,
-0.2682181895,
-0.2095971107,
-0.4770118296,
-0.3110984862,
0.3848187327,
0.3807368875,
-0.3344396055,
0.1437537521,
-0.0263977423,
0.8973637223,
-0.2823161781,
0.3410650492,
-0.7880118489,
0.256157577,
-0.0586968586,
-0.5718630552,
-0.3453143239,
-0.3987002373,
0.3295411766,
-0.6536833048,
0.0577158704,
0.4271166623,
0.7212830186,
0.0083974721,
-0.5027574897,
-0.4297530055,
-0.8698655367,
0.6209568977,
-0.4375801384,
0.3960431218,
0.6885129809,
0.3995246589,
-0.0947412401,
-0.3882915676,
-0.3979370594,
-0.4400057793,
-0.0909196287,
0.0264258236,
-0.2364563197,
-0.1465480626,
-0.0632427186,
0.5679035783,
-0.6545705199,
-0.2686184943,
-0.2072140723,
-0.20689255,
0.4218257368,
0.1285559982,
0.1683806777,
-0.2188269645,
-0.3206270635,
0.2751043141,
-0.5867013335,
-0.2611044049,
0.3091253638,
0.336550653,
-0.0839477405,
0.8227710128,
-0.5968679786,
0.8121271729,
0.2496881038,
-0.1918085963,
0.2512472868,
-0.4904257953,
-0.0726099908,
0.2475682199,
0.5126588941,
0.7861335278,
0.3354364038,
-0.3554697931,
-0.0665664077,
-0.1505517513,
0.2856580615,
-0.6518915892,
-0.1294757128,
-0.1496299654,
-0.4861735702,
-0.2450304627,
0.2367533296,
-0.6773642302,
-0.7017918229,
-0.3675428331,
0.1505685747,
-0.1223487481,
-0.0459838957,
0.4687066972,
0.2210555822,
-0.1581860036,
0.2761729062,
-0.7151525617,
0.0313888714,
0.3301812112,
0.6340726614,
-0.0699809715,
0.0626350865,
-0.5575394034,
0.3794597685,
-0.0988138244,
0.9768640399,
-0.574582994,
-0.04655388,
0.0570384301,
-0.0808316097,
0.4576251805,
-0.3211569786,
0.4523297846,
-0.6633609533,
0.1457769275,
-0.212702021,
-0.5211507678,
-0.4567444324,
0.213809818,
-0.7117000222,
0.6261794567,
0.1572936922,
-0.8114907146,
0.6346036196,
-0.7895601988,
-0.5767316818,
0.1701668054,
0.214022994,
-0.2130781561,
-0.0859465823,
0.809582293,
0.6664987803,
-0.2448133081,
0.7929432988,
-0.193564564,
-0.1295948327,
0.2112857103,
-0.2289692312,
0.0929710567,
0.1451661736,
-0.1199102402,
0.3359159529,
-0.8395560384,
-0.3854854405,
0.0265613757,
-0.2284224927,
-0.4562646449,
0.0899134055,
0.1019746363,
0.0816013962,
0.4353763461,
-0.3517232239,
0.3197722137,
-0.4772047997,
0.1738019139,
0.6490787268,
0.2880899012,
0.3991689682,
-0.2867686749,
0.5280182958,
-0.002130745,
0.032822825,
-0.2265387177,
-0.3007303774,
-0.7334754467,
-0.0357683115,
0.4081110358,
0.5447494984,
-1.0038659573,
0.816708982,
-0.188977778,
-0.29232198,
-0.2148885876,
0.2936171293,
0.1860443056,
0.2423580587,
0.4326755404,
-0.3845649064,
-1.0293841362,
-0.8843767643,
-0.2846268415,
-0.0883783698,
0.0042889733,
0.4233300686,
0.084498167,
-0.3751734793,
0.932200253,
-0.7374907136,
-0.6448156834,
-0.4755169749,
-0.2000388205,
0.3031446636,
-0.0472062007,
0.2586193979,
-0.589740634,
-0.2924559414,
0.0833693072,
-0.3170824349,
-0.0800088346,
-0.1782756448,
-0.3107958436,
-0.0465307385,
0.088333495,
-0.380903393,
0.304271847,
0.278700918,
-0.5402559638,
0.4563142657,
-0.1773980856,
-0.0013731079,
-1.4534885883,
-0.1829186082,
0.7265354991,
-0.3473584056,
-0.2046264857,
-0.0302824359,
-0.2590480149,
0.1914644539,
-0.305174619,
0.8885914683,
-0.0749221817,
0.1824566722,
-0.1956064105,
0.3093632162,
-0.1177713126,
0.6540355086,
0.2575334907,
0.4042920768,
0.5441014171,
-0.6205887794,
0.5808484554,
0.1627981514,
-0.6980131865,
0.4523990154,
-0.3729006946,
-0.028068712,
-0.0948934779,
0.6321587563,
-0.7060184479,
-0.2728296518,
0.2629961371,
0.0210631564,
-0.1125976816,
0.0086938133,
-0.7497058511,
-0.3594594002,
-0.1972808242,
0.2877932787,
0.2250657678,
-0.5183393359,
0.38635993,
0.510991931,
-0.2129706293,
-0.5220051408,
-0.4459858537,
0.3918012083,
-0.3152576983,
-0.1853111982,
0.3488113284,
-0.3641973734,
0.0867712125,
0.2102370858,
0.1521341652,
-0.0520278104,
-0.0357918143,
0.1730326861,
0.46296525,
-0.1469746083,
0.4204167426,
-0.0265658945,
0.1209765673,
-0.2830701172,
-0.4335957766,
0.6917139888,
-0.3731348217,
-0.0197371747,
-0.4460883737,
0.2710047066,
0.2425754368,
-0.5903933048,
0.6712775826,
0.9905589223,
-0.2406536192,
-0.1589747071,
-0.6638603806,
-0.0670257732,
-0.420978874,
0.6485805511,
-0.1193386316,
-1.2119430304,
0.2840293944,
0.1686962843,
-0.1613872945,
0.4961701632,
0.6248166561,
0.4235340655,
1.2063074112,
0.7172529697,
-0.352635622,
0.458573252,
-0.1290541142,
0.2725614905,
-0.7417315245,
-0.2095387727,
-0.0250683725,
-0.1549583077,
-0.3851591945,
-0.2133919746,
0.1737389565,
-0.2091003954,
-0.2589000463,
0.228227511,
-0.7531092763,
0.5475221872,
0.5030077696,
0.0217322838,
0.7079753876,
0.336702764,
-0.0240988098,
0.0605229698,
-0.6153609157,
-0.4004502296,
1.1262508631,
0.3740456402,
0.9940310121,
-0.0599550121,
0.5372521281,
0.5239295363,
0.3740670681,
-0.93879807,
0.6128868461,
-0.5187152028,
-0.3093851209,
-0.0256103706,
-0.3677037656,
-0.8569764495,
-0.1069990993,
-0.3423727155,
-0.639842093,
-0.014974134,
-0.0202798266,
-0.5458298326,
0.3248740137,
-0.1865906119,
0.3756599128,
-0.3743918836,
0.1308844239,
-0.3336365819,
-0.1294228733,
0.4905347824,
-0.333319813,
0.3630128205,
-0.10318131,
-0.0516581833,
0.7397443652,
-0.0390142389,
0.8017846942,
-0.0847273022,
-0.1610483676,
0.3963215351,
-0.1461123377,
0.445127368,
0.2626297474,
0.0521289147,
-0.0134395314,
-0.2173122615,
0.1846322268,
-0.4207410812,
0.6919333339,
-0.6003245711,
-0.5957766771,
-0.2099244446,
-0.7586714625,
-0.3193363547,
0.1728670597,
-0.0339263901,
0.7179729939,
-0.1033457741,
0.4646149874,
0.4268573523,
-0.4288729727,
0.1694453806,
0.6751136184,
-0.6337160468,
-0.7580884695,
1.1435588598,
-0.0876339898,
-0.4739499688,
0.6974571943,
0.3061470389,
-0.4084793627,
-0.4835670888,
-0.454583317,
0.120133318,
-0.5395345688,
-0.3648333848,
-0.7594265342,
-0.0169886425,
-0.141844064,
-0.0813307539,
0.063753888,
-0.3485226333,
-0.1333260685,
-0.1390754133,
0.4599319398,
0.7972371578,
0.4861856997,
0.3172610402,
-0.6951987743,
0.6727594137,
0.3491494954,
0.6893795133,
0.0896903723,
-0.2831176817,
-0.7008935809,
0.0146193607,
-0.3118150532,
-0.4398161769,
0.5610150099,
0.1392184347,
0.5179570317,
0.3764567971,
0.2186610401,
0.5039637685,
-0.7207116485,
0.7540140152,
0.2419848889,
-0.6699789762,
0.6506314278,
-0.5603391528,
0.4294432104,
0.383689791,
0.125250563,
-0.4178259969,
-0.5374712348,
-0.2726763189,
-0.8598971367,
0.4592618346,
-0.0672370493,
0.310516417,
-0.0984350294,
0.3666507006,
0.3097063005,
0.4414590597,
-0.897311151,
-0.1356593817,
-0.141983673,
-0.4189224541,
-0.1560817808,
-0.386554271,
-0.0775485486,
-0.2338739336,
0.9522936344,
-0.1424978971,
0.2261943966,
0.1247320101,
-0.1715662181,
-0.3404315412,
0.370715946,
0.6240686774,
0.6431993246,
-0.2440140098,
-0.136468485,
-0.0253115389,
-0.3437133729,
0.0824026614,
0.2305432707,
0.1638762355,
-0.0061406167,
0.0343373977,
1.0044577122,
0.0207702611,
-0.6635931134,
0.2580936849,
-0.3640811145,
-0.1085489318,
-0.3826830983,
-0.0023787671,
0.1400354058,
0.3449834585,
0.5022512674,
-0.0202862471,
0.3546998203,
-0.6486399174,
0.2463701665,
0.5478727818,
-0.3373408318,
-0.0436224379,
0.421405077,
0.2853755355,
-0.0073438548,
0.2531039417,
-0.1744722277,
-0.4061934352,
0.3690588176,
0.5056021214,
1.1157553196,
0.0625425354,
0.5079555511,
0.1851694882,
0.2023168355,
-0.2964878678,
-0.0614041984,
-0.004201619,
-0.7183489799,
-0.6527246833,
-1.0825434923,
-0.1535952091,
0.2429171503,
-0.4611255527,
0.3216935396,
-0.4748272002,
-0.2134833038,
0.02299341,
0.2796226442,
-0.6584523916,
0.4155249298,
0.3738124371,
0.7520986795,
-0.5547678471,
0.7163541317,
0.9518541098,
-0.2330403924,
-0.9143232703,
0.2848173976,
-0.3214734495,
-0.6276129484,
0.3976247013,
0.1004188359,
0.1101461425,
-0.0288060792,
-0.2333618104,
-0.8916680813,
0.9200229645,
0.3586829901,
-0.6600244045,
0.0638501793,
-0.0403719507,
0.6431170702,
-0.8100335598,
0.1697137654,
-0.1191783696,
0.7807042599,
0.1248730719,
-0.8904644251,
0.0887840539,
-0.3584730625,
0.1006490216,
0.070250459,
-0.5067235827,
0.4498386085,
-0.2999515235,
0.1179208681,
0.0503260382,
0.730656147,
0.1435661614,
0.2644639015,
0.5008088946,
0.4146233499,
0.5351811647,
0.2312865704,
1.2941083908,
-0.5480485559,
0.3985234499,
1.2692562342,
-0.1767766476,
0.6355642676,
0.0029647988,
-0.1780222803,
0.7590969801,
0.8011050224,
-0.4572702944,
0.6074811816,
0.1112426296,
-0.0402209647,
-0.2403364331,
-0.3696504235,
-0.343870312,
0.4073414803,
0.1987461001,
-0.5225981474,
-0.2495634556,
0.3030874133,
-0.2444994152,
-0.0565828793,
-0.6975471377,
0.9305113554,
0.0456609763,
-0.7989814878,
0.4976212084,
0.3074616194,
0.8672747612,
-0.5783970356,
-0.0625535995,
-0.070362106,
-0.0068616942,
-0.3417627513,
-0.8372413516,
0.0303354897,
0.0870475248,
-0.417431891,
0.0844647512,
0.8904771805,
-0.8166587949,
-0.852219224,
0.0131696835,
0.3696197569,
-0.0781240091,
-0.1074987277,
-0.4451542199,
-0.2925882041,
0.1125394702,
-0.2352369428,
0.309119314,
0.1835618615,
-0.2127162814,
0.7826025486,
0.4728661478,
0.2786830068,
-0.2824194133,
0.2464283556,
0.6825976372,
-0.6344137192,
-0.8161242604,
-0.7265034318,
0.1871008426,
0.2146858573,
-0.0776798278,
0.6230651736,
0.6057747006,
0.7072067857,
-0.3404447138,
0.9111382961,
0.0315545388,
0.3096389771,
-0.6227422953,
0.6315863729,
-0.6633021235,
0.6603013873,
-0.1881277114,
-1.3161737919,
-0.3392666876,
0.266843617,
-0.2669379115,
0.2957478166,
0.6841954589,
0.6306461692,
-0.056254711,
-0.0779039487,
0.1768628657,
0.0999731049,
-0.0433660895,
0.5312893391,
0.6781436205,
0.2207605243,
0.5845196247,
-0.2976972759,
0.0604686588,
-0.354018271,
-0.9244384766,
-1.1501483917,
-0.7184912562,
-0.6257850528,
-0.2627809346,
0.2234555334,
1.1333559752,
0.6312098503,
-0.768327415,
-0.2244091183,
-0.0544660911,
0.185487017,
-0.2138610929,
-0.2686901987,
0.6292397976,
-0.0097357882,
-0.4862444103,
0.2077980042,
0.3467472196,
-0.3329615593,
-0.4638581574,
-0.0037649346,
-0.0652068779,
0.0934780613,
0.7158022523,
-0.1831999868,
-0.9372735023,
-0.2649693489,
-0.2982297242,
0.0814363882,
-0.0316255912,
0.790042758,
-0.9862325788,
0.3982072175,
0.2133764476,
0.4486584961,
0.1884776354,
0.1009134501,
0.5820236802,
-0.7476071715,
-0.1002814993,
0.0202081874,
0.3139808476,
0.4784323573,
-0.8108648658,
0.398930043,
0.1051295772,
-0.3146523237,
-0.6146456003,
0.1245721057,
-1.2627362013,
-0.0314613022,
1.4769023657,
0.0303289555,
-0.1076336205,
0.0606586821,
-0.5848219991,
0.2280725092,
-0.7925840616,
0.9185976386,
0.6445793509,
0.2802178264,
-0.3014320731,
-0.6232884526,
0.2493665367,
0.059359476,
-0.6752861142,
-0.0759864524,
0.4796664417,
0.2783468664,
-0.0919457376,
0.294598341,
0.0423339792,
0.1109760478,
-0.6398841143,
0.2054020762,
-0.3123641908,
-0.2323150188,
-0.157112211,
0.206589818,
0.010806975,
0.1907026321
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07551v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07551v1
|
MuMath-Code: Combining Tool-Use Large Language Models with Multi-perspective Data Augmentation for Mathematical Reasoning
| 2024-05-13T08:32:19 | 2024-05-13T08:32:19 |
Shuo Yin, Weihao You, Zhilong Ji, Guoqiang Zhong, Jinfeng Bai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The tool-use Large Language Models (LLMs) that integrate with external Python
interpreters have significantly enhanced mathematical reasoning capabilities
for open-source LLMs, while tool-free methods chose another track: augmenting
math reasoning data. However, a great method to integrate the above two
research paths and combine their advantages remains to be explored. In this
work, we firstly include new math questions via multi-perspective data
augmenting methods and then synthesize code-nested solutions to them. The open
LLMs (i.e., Llama-2) are finetuned on the augmented dataset to get the
resulting models, MuMath-Code ($\mu$-Math-Code). During the inference phase,
our MuMath-Code generates code and interacts with the external python
interpreter to get the execution results. Therefore, MuMath-Code leverages the
advantages of both the external tool and data augmentation. To fully leverage
the advantages of our augmented data, we propose a two-stage training strategy:
In Stage-1, we finetune Llama-2 on pure CoT data to get an intermediate model,
which then is trained on the code-nested data in Stage-2 to get the resulting
MuMath-Code. Our MuMath-Code-7B achieves 83.8 on GSM8K and 52.4 on MATH, while
MuMath-Code-70B model achieves new state-of-the-art performance among open
methods -- achieving 90.7% on GSM8K and 55.1% on MATH. Extensive experiments
validate the combination of tool use and data augmentation, as well as our
two-stage training strategy. We release the proposed dataset along with the
associated code for public use.
|
[
-0.4639952481,
-0.5762503743,
0.5139480233,
0.1638682187,
-0.4296656251,
0.1258094311,
-0.2555863559,
-0.4901874363,
-0.0986280814,
0.4835179448,
-0.4406206608,
-0.4945930243,
-0.3623763919,
0.0525802895,
-0.1185911074,
0.9098329544,
-0.2057453394,
0.327350378,
-0.3226191401,
-0.1733925492,
-0.2243665159,
-0.8454591632,
-0.1137995198,
-0.418094337,
0.3123287261,
0.5073063374,
0.5358718038,
0.365102917,
0.4915248454,
0.1936168224,
-0.0134188719,
0.4610053003,
-0.2211798877,
-0.0501163639,
0.0723077655,
-0.7910783887,
-0.4580070972,
-0.0332822464,
0.3307958841,
0.7054750323,
-0.1771322042,
0.2760470808,
-0.0633036792,
0.4289085865,
-0.5355600715,
0.4069780707,
-0.5683552623,
0.0783663541,
0.0483647324,
-0.1852315068,
-0.3535628021,
-0.6023036838,
-0.0934778452,
-0.5310397148,
-0.2306805849,
-0.1394395381,
0.2836697102,
0.1993023455,
-0.4314066172,
-0.2787335515,
-0.6007202864,
1.0135003328,
-0.6934459209,
0.3167674541,
0.4367584288,
0.3349944055,
0.0123745007,
-0.425234437,
-0.5191559792,
-0.2229776382,
0.0416426472,
-0.0529038869,
0.1259152889,
-0.2797456384,
0.4471325874,
0.6657779217,
-0.3249010444,
0.0740996152,
-0.4321840107,
-0.0213020239,
0.7071365118,
0.1592776775,
0.0883354396,
-0.1492711753,
-0.4330905974,
-0.0749134794,
-0.7917098999,
0.0032553235,
0.4537039101,
0.2145179808,
-0.4336921573,
0.9637654424,
-0.1515100449,
0.5356522202,
-0.1266938895,
-0.4774118662,
0.3736765981,
-0.2304738462,
-0.2662391365,
0.0380406789,
0.4801363647,
0.2059175074,
0.3249623179,
0.0003525846,
-0.2562653124,
0.3451305032,
-0.0487092622,
-0.7371714115,
-0.1368130147,
0.2829124928,
-0.2438161671,
-0.4749647975,
-0.2210779637,
-0.6993516684,
-0.3968746662,
-0.7056059837,
0.4277594388,
-0.3538873196,
-0.4528976381,
0.241411671,
0.0851769671,
0.1964127123,
0.5445407033,
-0.6015813351,
0.1954657882,
0.7898988724,
0.7847836018,
0.0463633984,
-0.359932065,
-0.6062254906,
0.0540321879,
-0.4356620312,
0.6885063052,
-0.5405448675,
-0.3495279849,
-0.1231729388,
-0.487891674,
0.0368923359,
-0.5520181656,
0.616514504,
-0.4718365967,
0.5523276329,
0.1585834324,
-0.2465159744,
-0.3586273193,
0.2886147797,
-0.5699823499,
1.2613537312,
0.3590477109,
-0.6903469563,
0.0957398638,
-0.721777916,
-0.3793113828,
-0.3225722313,
-0.2258309573,
-0.4847172797,
0.0833575279,
0.5639856458,
0.2082886994,
-0.5622560978,
0.0904761925,
-0.3890376985,
-0.2458728552,
0.2633296847,
-0.3475827277,
0.9778244495,
0.2200420499,
-0.2226386219,
0.0474169701,
-0.912512958,
0.0818162486,
0.1900773197,
-0.4300341606,
-0.2457170933,
-0.2661373615,
-0.1763787568,
0.3545541167,
0.1360159069,
-0.5386632681,
0.4523980916,
-0.5407876968,
0.3700767159,
0.6704373956,
-0.1800547093,
0.5807407498,
-0.2586352229,
0.4309837818,
0.126143828,
0.1742284,
-0.3501485586,
-0.7257224917,
-0.4365626872,
-0.3629323244,
0.23443681,
0.607540071,
-0.7970929742,
0.2072445154,
-0.1621761769,
-0.3131639957,
-0.4895063937,
0.1615112722,
0.2324241549,
0.6174212694,
0.4686864614,
-0.1758024991,
-0.6264683008,
-0.7172505856,
0.0813429505,
0.0003555353,
-0.1678657085,
0.176430881,
0.3974903524,
-0.1207313612,
0.8204252124,
-0.617261529,
-0.0045169834,
-0.28793028,
0.0601845942,
0.3795935214,
0.6075187922,
0.4705605805,
-0.671238482,
-0.0386549756,
0.0748175383,
-0.8103767037,
-0.0963615477,
0.0691151023,
-0.2534871101,
0.0886129662,
-0.0680245012,
-0.5601350665,
0.6074656844,
0.5795456171,
0.0794343352,
0.8360597491,
-0.0118266456,
0.2216046453,
-1.0600517988,
-0.2098826915,
-0.0009443206,
-0.0087773316,
-0.5577352047,
0.483186692,
0.1521366686,
-0.3907024562,
-0.3989844024,
0.3819647133,
-0.4834972322,
-0.2479042113,
-0.2516664267,
-0.1179525703,
0.0678478256,
0.7766364217,
-0.09827061,
1.1137052774,
0.6692329645,
-0.4707455039,
0.4067215025,
0.2639345825,
-0.446341157,
0.3706825376,
-0.5802020431,
0.2807002068,
0.1100716814,
0.298738569,
-0.8762412071,
-0.262974292,
0.275144726,
-0.4453609884,
0.006465476,
-0.310092777,
-0.8676513433,
-0.4014461339,
-0.5866696239,
0.7660225034,
0.5681018233,
-0.8553776741,
0.8674988747,
0.2961473763,
-0.0372734182,
-0.5102825761,
-0.8196448684,
0.0029803345,
-0.3876606822,
-0.8284476399,
0.0722897425,
-0.0721492991,
-0.2351053655,
-0.255857408,
-0.1794498563,
-0.1411830038,
-0.007903426,
0.2186393291,
0.6170117259,
-0.3754504323,
-0.2485736609,
0.3505451381,
-0.3419983983,
0.2207607329,
-0.4291166067,
0.779348433,
-0.0445884839,
-0.680893898,
-0.4625301361,
0.4279106259,
0.4940205812,
-0.5259795189,
0.6320295334,
0.372253418,
-0.4674042761,
-0.0874328315,
-0.5023083091,
0.0051348847,
-0.4448665977,
-0.0746395513,
-0.5855122209,
-0.7683907151,
0.4860342741,
-0.2322867066,
0.278947711,
0.1318416148,
0.88192451,
0.3217755854,
1.2978416681,
0.4023610651,
0.0472081341,
0.2961419225,
-0.5273997188,
0.2763802409,
-1.2018799782,
-0.3469206393,
-0.4065965116,
0.0042438572,
-0.2213925719,
-0.7099940181,
0.5678460598,
0.2945459485,
-0.3335181177,
0.2829865813,
-0.4384821653,
0.3907013834,
0.5321304798,
0.3266023099,
0.4496188164,
0.3188502192,
-0.3097811639,
0.0566971041,
-0.5244118571,
-0.3581034243,
1.5234127045,
0.2134962678,
0.9595674872,
0.124751538,
0.6729787588,
-0.121763736,
0.3258400857,
-0.8232577443,
0.4558967352,
0.23865062,
-0.3407758176,
0.1369999647,
-0.5769297481,
-0.6653075218,
0.5280518532,
0.0313924924,
-0.8572229147,
0.029238794,
-0.0395091474,
-0.2237733006,
0.3635951877,
-1.0063943863,
0.4627987742,
-0.3873856664,
-0.5301215649,
-0.2735751271,
-0.5477030873,
0.7828882933,
-0.1513467878,
0.3838979006,
0.0326459035,
0.0135449171,
0.36951828,
-0.4609153867,
0.6740012765,
0.0211696401,
-0.4725375175,
0.4213771522,
0.1756689101,
0.4234106541,
0.3130358756,
-0.2532733679,
0.2432055771,
-0.1845284253,
-0.4281991422,
-0.6921925545,
0.7169914842,
-0.7910411358,
-0.5651397705,
-0.3497015536,
-0.8869603872,
-0.4041616619,
-0.0192470159,
-0.2068127096,
0.9219115973,
0.5943242311,
0.0317088179,
0.4753447175,
-0.1620090604,
0.1036707908,
0.0116361855,
-0.4482413232,
-0.6743556261,
0.6631631851,
-0.2568125129,
0.3458805084,
0.3683765829,
0.3716223538,
-0.5305473804,
-0.3685805798,
-0.6705752015,
0.2668443322,
-0.7254366875,
-0.4451129735,
-0.4534628689,
-0.2584674656,
-0.4432243109,
-0.0729068369,
-0.1356430948,
-0.6181335449,
-0.1213296205,
0.0242688283,
0.5183384418,
0.471634537,
-0.2559408545,
0.2058720887,
-0.7860810161,
0.5344362259,
0.1842440367,
0.3336012959,
0.1894941479,
-0.2621750832,
-0.3085621595,
0.2795577645,
-0.2777127624,
-0.779186964,
0.1391876638,
-0.2123196721,
0.4708445072,
0.2405087203,
-0.0998964682,
0.7777663469,
-0.3611997366,
0.659484148,
0.3237023354,
-0.889090538,
0.5156097412,
-0.297057569,
0.0633472204,
0.1999039352,
0.1177022681,
-0.0121666482,
-0.2779239416,
-0.4126753807,
-0.5162343979,
0.8187472224,
0.3674702644,
-0.0296038408,
0.375361532,
0.2678083181,
0.3113832474,
0.4458043873,
-0.5792087913,
-0.1419940144,
-0.2501074374,
-0.3356021643,
0.191766426,
0.0419924259,
-0.39105317,
-0.6326461434,
0.2618001699,
-0.2064745426,
0.3215278387,
-0.0667523444,
-0.2070982456,
-0.1123092249,
0.2289578617,
0.4836242199,
0.9559299946,
-0.0587864257,
0.1245478392,
0.1854891926,
-0.555478394,
0.1183842421,
0.3758068383,
-0.0634758696,
-0.3400207162,
0.2924137712,
0.6408519745,
0.2244774997,
-0.7132131457,
0.2914297283,
0.1923489124,
-0.2920542061,
-0.2086956799,
0.0945031717,
0.0405032784,
0.3219894171,
0.4857789576,
0.1748001128,
-0.0143011734,
-0.4931174219,
0.0902797356,
0.3158856928,
0.3806339204,
-0.2245591581,
0.7646557689,
-0.0617372841,
-0.2014493346,
0.2865328193,
-0.1675204039,
-0.7484001517,
0.5962577462,
0.6987131834,
0.4534966946,
-0.1131468564,
0.058620315,
0.4087011516,
0.1379565001,
0.07032644,
0.3885017037,
-0.3088020682,
-0.4857397676,
-0.8571594357,
-0.5989601016,
-0.5083488822,
0.0768306926,
-0.7518320084,
0.3702644408,
-0.4621969461,
0.2423308492,
-0.2579155266,
0.1984575987,
-0.5682098269,
0.1187110469,
0.2766207755,
0.9808763862,
-0.5571798086,
0.7850362062,
0.7288544178,
-0.3815542758,
-1.0113867521,
-0.077249743,
0.0786473677,
-1.1465852261,
0.382240504,
0.2968302071,
-0.2718203664,
0.0590168796,
-0.6042302251,
-0.8604622483,
1.0133587122,
0.3241728544,
-0.2327792495,
0.0298813283,
0.1152502894,
0.3748890162,
-0.5200462341,
0.3901796937,
0.5785537362,
0.2538781166,
0.3953696191,
-0.8898905516,
-0.1460263729,
-0.2404272258,
-0.1022427678,
0.4114745855,
-0.3683426976,
1.0876252651,
-0.4422514737,
-0.0124512082,
0.2110672593,
0.5440340638,
0.7595069408,
0.5284131765,
0.4168025553,
0.9523510337,
0.5427128673,
0.0709224418,
1.0950260162,
-0.2175037861,
0.5309054852,
0.9048519731,
-0.3735445738,
0.7611958385,
0.3080808222,
-0.4467231631,
0.7518498898,
0.4684057534,
0.1713346392,
0.4343225658,
0.0469477214,
-0.2813142836,
-0.25292629,
0.1445765942,
-0.6911837459,
0.3417110741,
0.4079399109,
0.1442144811,
-0.57151407,
0.2217407674,
0.0345942304,
-0.1249358729,
-0.3099377751,
0.5861294866,
0.1313925982,
-0.383834213,
0.6815724373,
0.0895680115,
0.5724878907,
-0.4700410664,
-0.1357032061,
-0.2251444459,
0.1966912448,
-0.3339426517,
-0.8697059751,
0.1396207809,
0.2152259052,
0.079919219,
0.069382742,
0.5016208291,
-0.3668861091,
-0.7208205462,
-0.0118379043,
0.7225211859,
0.1042524427,
-0.1386327595,
-0.7077963948,
0.0365059562,
-0.1198458597,
0.0484621674,
0.4446438849,
0.478233844,
-0.072000578,
0.6278203726,
1.1272498369,
0.0806646943,
0.2724754214,
0.3673602641,
1.4061182737,
-0.4419696629,
-0.5812845826,
-0.666900456,
0.570600152,
0.0269277748,
-0.2326248735,
0.8257344365,
0.8203727007,
0.8234024048,
0.0366083346,
0.6799393296,
0.0563534759,
0.7000439763,
-0.6780264974,
0.146617651,
-0.7435493469,
0.4447238743,
-0.1836383343,
-0.9454709888,
-0.3511593938,
0.7040641904,
-0.5853353739,
-0.0526614785,
0.7554356456,
0.6988016367,
-0.4150730968,
0.2156110257,
-0.1107764468,
-0.2189758271,
0.2838493586,
0.9181838632,
1.1184411049,
-0.4882380962,
0.6047314405,
-0.5790815949,
-0.4738641977,
-0.2644668221,
-0.5827346444,
-0.9602220654,
-0.3177733421,
-0.0582530238,
-0.488750428,
-0.4491981268,
1.0685491562,
0.5340341926,
-0.6926848888,
-0.2499681562,
-0.037781816,
0.3037363887,
-0.1532868147,
-0.2243431807,
0.3457526267,
-0.230271101,
-0.83425951,
0.2600711584,
0.2400674373,
-0.0682572052,
-0.4301639497,
-0.0661532283,
-0.0603789799,
-0.0902534276,
0.9274260998,
0.0114074573,
-0.6270688772,
0.0281690769,
0.0102652786,
0.0316152051,
0.4336228669,
1.2295632362,
-0.851881206,
0.2445648611,
0.2890179753,
0.7450091243,
0.4670112133,
0.327155143,
0.4075350165,
-0.4980240762,
0.5572968721,
0.2599847019,
0.3687013984,
0.3105673492,
-0.3523988426,
0.5860384703,
0.2143585086,
-0.371150583,
-1.1617381573,
0.3663030267,
-1.0409333706,
-0.2160823196,
1.2268253565,
0.0959904939,
-0.2505754232,
0.02384381,
-0.4016432762,
0.1342100054,
-0.3332933784,
0.7138930559,
0.5851414204,
-0.3585014045,
-0.2957381904,
-0.5119534731,
0.0933329165,
0.2931589484,
-1.1203353405,
-0.236929521,
0.6062748432,
0.1589424908,
0.2624796331,
0.3606722951,
-0.3193828464,
0.3712089062,
0.2224567235,
-0.1686846018,
-0.4784950018,
-0.4184515178,
-0.3190300465,
0.2531921566,
-0.0799051523,
-0.2421634048
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07542v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07542v1
|
EMS-SD: Efficient Multi-sample Speculative Decoding for Accelerating Large Language Models
| 2024-05-13T08:24:21 | 2024-05-13T08:24:21 |
Yunsheng Ni, Chuanjian Liu, Yehui Tang, Kai Han, Yunhe Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Speculative decoding emerges as a pivotal technique for enhancing the
inference speed of Large Language Models (LLMs). Despite recent research aiming
to improve prediction efficiency, multi-sample speculative decoding has been
overlooked due to varying numbers of accepted tokens within a batch in the
verification phase. Vanilla method adds padding tokens in order to ensure that
the number of new tokens remains consistent across samples. However, this
increases the computational and memory access overhead, thereby reducing the
speedup ratio. We propose a novel method that can resolve the issue of
inconsistent tokens accepted by different samples without necessitating an
increase in memory or computing overhead. Furthermore, our proposed method can
handle the situation where the prediction tokens of different samples are
inconsistent without the need to add padding tokens. Sufficient experiments
demonstrate the efficacy of our method. Our code is available at
https://github.com/niyunsheng/EMS-SD.
|
[
-0.3163467348,
-0.7614060044,
0.6609270573,
0.6245017648,
-0.495706737,
0.3410180807,
-0.3929787874,
-0.466986686,
0.700987339,
0.3123126924,
-0.6377406716,
-0.5645787716,
-0.693241775,
0.2230301052,
-0.4130346775,
0.3893092871,
-0.0384702533,
0.0858140439,
-0.11564897,
0.0702827126,
0.25446859,
-0.617428124,
-0.6227728128,
0.5166787505,
0.2614834905,
0.5027469993,
0.0307656787,
0.7589471936,
0.2618444264,
0.2795181572,
-0.1922751665,
0.6548548341,
-0.4262000322,
0.4585241675,
0.205781579,
-0.3963681459,
-0.79090029,
-0.5576829314,
0.8247635365,
0.5170738101,
-0.3457713425,
0.0379323289,
-0.226985395,
0.2890719175,
-0.9753612876,
0.0015924239,
-0.8596515656,
-0.2688569725,
-0.4313029647,
-0.494168967,
-0.7577999234,
0.0156595111,
-0.3491984904,
-0.641010344,
0.5317547917,
0.3688854575,
0.3712569475,
-0.0653762147,
-0.4071888924,
-0.1258527637,
-0.5390394926,
0.9928260446,
-0.7783194184,
0.5836259127,
0.4415098727,
0.041471865,
-0.1746034026,
-0.6994615793,
-0.702305913,
0.1937728226,
0.4115017354,
0.0079683261,
0.1475242227,
0.2067434192,
0.2712043226,
0.1595007777,
-0.2098176926,
0.3361321688,
-0.2819624245,
-0.5612042546,
0.4380022883,
0.4483230114,
-0.0351267196,
0.2002976388,
-0.4438958764,
-0.0721181631,
-0.7259457111,
-0.1049227342,
0.5380072594,
0.4812448323,
-0.3298629224,
0.4643292129,
-0.3683000803,
0.2932004035,
0.0599638633,
-0.237351045,
0.6031665802,
-0.3118058443,
0.0829044357,
0.0829105675,
0.5501969457,
0.3393916786,
-0.3471526504,
-0.1865265369,
-0.3909098208,
0.2389065623,
-0.0131558096,
-1.111872077,
0.0953331888,
0.6229294538,
-0.502505362,
-0.2354152203,
-0.0051059555,
-1.0892165899,
-0.2895556688,
-0.0779089481,
-0.2430688292,
-0.4884235561,
-0.5399480462,
0.5873683095,
-0.2841027081,
0.0104456553,
0.2887344658,
-1.2743504047,
0.4937021434,
0.7508662939,
0.6186522245,
-0.2002377361,
-0.4523390532,
-0.6677418351,
0.1508928686,
-0.4526799321,
1.0239810944,
-0.7403973937,
-0.4741328061,
-0.0437151045,
-0.0085173249,
0.0438087694,
-0.1047228947,
1.0679459572,
-0.5432426333,
-0.4700660408,
-0.6060262918,
-0.8798691034,
0.310472697,
-0.0593454204,
-0.5406575799,
0.9779296517,
-0.2616011798,
-0.6848195791,
0.4762965739,
-0.3076755106,
-0.302798301,
0.0531441458,
-0.2131154537,
-0.3134320974,
0.4917769134,
0.5920443535,
0.6154782176,
-0.254778415,
0.0211687591,
-0.7497081161,
-0.6764073968,
0.1866025031,
-0.5458621383,
0.4385146797,
0.4947668314,
-0.0456285067,
-0.1300144345,
-1.0791159868,
0.1967083216,
0.1097767651,
-0.1111798659,
-0.3384851813,
0.1835259646,
0.2777644992,
-0.0485246703,
0.0012047063,
-0.773239851,
0.2921171486,
-0.1549772769,
0.2532276809,
0.9215510488,
-0.016213743,
0.3067724109,
-0.1023720801,
0.4617430866,
0.2067231536,
-0.225997895,
-0.7105384469,
-0.4229281247,
-0.5506078601,
-0.8710198402,
0.4223082364,
0.0902461708,
-0.8324225545,
0.4735504985,
-0.291801393,
-0.386836946,
-0.7175571322,
-0.1372420788,
0.2234376222,
0.1784434021,
0.3227966428,
-0.0531607158,
-0.887090683,
-0.6575326324,
-0.2513336241,
0.0090657128,
0.0714446157,
0.1223429739,
0.3680649102,
-0.2972554564,
0.4929632545,
-0.5254329443,
0.3471315503,
-0.2075720727,
0.1202799603,
0.1787694842,
0.6642302871,
0.7041620016,
-0.3980032504,
-0.2856715322,
-0.2435659766,
-0.2392741293,
-0.04799648,
-0.129312858,
-0.1423062384,
0.2308913618,
0.6902319789,
-0.6146891713,
-0.0416754782,
0.7851733565,
-0.4164866805,
0.8185876608,
-0.3757836819,
0.4896584749,
-1.0554494858,
-0.1820615977,
-0.0288893916,
-0.1006592289,
-0.6478891969,
0.186400339,
0.6179861426,
0.272459209,
-0.3848682046,
0.4720048606,
-0.4420922995,
0.1418693215,
-0.2253434062,
-0.0395310521,
-0.00030271,
0.1881265193,
0.087873444,
0.8633576035,
0.8941256404,
-0.6088702679,
0.0248940922,
-0.2222653925,
-0.3271489441,
0.3864659667,
-0.3425855041,
0.4278741777,
-0.2559937537,
0.4618463218,
-0.9381068349,
-0.2347103953,
-0.1217483282,
-0.311376363,
0.4651949108,
-0.1812030077,
-0.7549091578,
-0.30451563,
-0.5166888833,
0.718313694,
0.5604283214,
-0.7377052307,
0.6709654331,
0.3354938328,
-0.021070594,
-0.9053412676,
-0.696290493,
0.0405850708,
-0.1478383243,
-0.4958246052,
0.4200858176,
-0.1402721256,
-0.0782130957,
-0.0574834086,
-0.3199451864,
-0.0169868674,
-0.0383240171,
-0.1732210964,
0.3069818318,
-0.3206929862,
0.0185811799,
0.5084146857,
-0.2894087732,
0.050322894,
-0.5644231439,
0.5428174734,
-0.0777047798,
-0.5914489627,
-0.3301768303,
0.427300334,
0.8027479649,
-0.0625166222,
1.0295701027,
0.6018705964,
-0.5213068724,
-0.4485268593,
-0.8230809569,
-0.1915408373,
-0.5342354774,
0.6067342758,
-0.7155115008,
-0.7490218282,
0.8271999359,
-0.2829928398,
0.0291624386,
0.3207602501,
0.652033627,
-0.0142124007,
0.9542450309,
0.5254656672,
0.0124380924,
0.1029770076,
-0.0212067049,
0.1396034211,
-0.8110830784,
-0.2228141725,
-0.7418000698,
-0.0560768694,
-0.3517190218,
-0.6628412604,
-0.1950961202,
0.029421268,
0.15847224,
0.020205861,
-0.0709769875,
0.6271596551,
0.1057164669,
0.0565790012,
0.2743329406,
0.1522220522,
-0.5100022554,
-0.2456443757,
-0.5236089826,
-0.1150828451,
1.312528491,
0.3638944626,
0.8155440688,
0.0749409944,
0.7473549247,
0.0703843012,
0.0303627905,
-0.4360007048,
0.5274807215,
-0.201836586,
-0.4191588163,
0.0467946455,
-0.5621316433,
-0.7345667481,
0.5225491524,
-0.3775649071,
-0.77617836,
0.3192025423,
0.1705326587,
-0.251383543,
0.6658595204,
-0.9018736482,
0.3022480011,
0.0756413862,
-0.3217237294,
-0.4449902177,
-0.3135486543,
0.4558850527,
-0.1782260835,
0.3548453152,
-0.1060741916,
-0.373531431,
0.7117899656,
-0.3285958767,
0.6627882123,
-0.3246870339,
-0.2055172771,
0.026033055,
-0.1095335931,
0.8947817683,
0.0258590691,
-0.4221144617,
0.1198979393,
0.1779856384,
-0.8323863745,
-0.371835202,
0.7378630638,
-0.5086318851,
-0.2918666005,
-0.1997052133,
-0.5931466222,
-0.4553042948,
0.1139967814,
0.3287909031,
0.5802612305,
-0.0522782169,
0.2245413512,
0.7940339446,
-0.1867297441,
0.3189668655,
0.5233764648,
-0.1644534618,
-0.2257127017,
0.869084537,
-0.0652086735,
0.3420792222,
0.3464199305,
-0.1812931895,
-0.4466245472,
-1.038292408,
-0.5290260315,
0.289899826,
-0.6753611565,
-0.1046722829,
-0.9577924609,
0.1444246024,
-0.5330895782,
-0.1843227893,
-0.6548233628,
-0.4477989674,
-0.0026455051,
-0.3688451946,
0.41358459,
0.3152048886,
0.0215958413,
0.235763073,
-0.9774364233,
0.327880919,
-0.3310371041,
0.5769124627,
0.0484335609,
-0.4153778553,
-0.24804914,
-0.048928909,
0.2923515439,
-0.7394058704,
0.2943392992,
-0.1097923517,
0.650528729,
0.6413077712,
0.2554311752,
0.8855520487,
-0.5067170262,
0.6363544464,
0.1228824258,
-0.9769979119,
-0.0371189564,
-0.3189087212,
0.0374057181,
0.5011537671,
0.0632889494,
-0.5269734263,
-0.5020047426,
-0.7420452833,
-1.107347846,
0.822907567,
-0.0122562964,
0.2736693025,
-0.2215141803,
0.1977413744,
0.362824887,
0.1205805019,
-0.0404557846,
-0.6005260944,
0.2128737569,
-0.1390547454,
0.0206723735,
-0.7322352529,
0.0989339054,
-0.136964038,
0.6699417233,
-0.1664787978,
0.3292327225,
-0.0992366225,
0.0623298213,
-0.1741639972,
0.4165247977,
0.6323311329,
0.4254778326,
-0.2876735032,
0.3856683075,
0.5636574626,
-0.7988471985,
0.2006181479,
0.069320485,
0.2053523809,
0.0938018188,
0.2055561543,
0.6943358779,
0.2672388256,
-0.7528793216,
0.358055234,
-0.4089752138,
-0.3615918458,
0.001533239,
-0.210800752,
0.1758113056,
0.0572986528,
0.5372427106,
0.5226153135,
0.1022152156,
-0.1323860884,
0.1743841171,
0.1353936195,
0.2043514401,
-0.3406095505,
0.5240180492,
0.2758844197,
0.0963890254,
0.4896155298,
-0.609613061,
-0.2170424461,
0.6937227249,
0.8515371084,
0.79019171,
-0.1629713625,
-0.1510062963,
0.3188557327,
0.2513030469,
-0.431766808,
0.5819886327,
0.0131164696,
-0.8232928514,
-0.7150816321,
-0.6238847375,
-0.3585982025,
0.0232279319,
-0.6725138426,
0.3253430128,
-0.2386452407,
0.0616666675,
-0.2947557867,
-0.1983086616,
-0.6189604402,
-0.0831622928,
0.1358979195,
1.3159532547,
-0.7454754114,
1.0807989836,
0.3070271313,
0.3109552562,
-0.6493430734,
0.1373160481,
0.2076861709,
-0.7186188698,
0.170556888,
0.0503632836,
-0.2987968326,
-0.0428479761,
-0.2478224486,
-1.0616102219,
0.8589921594,
0.5085943341,
-0.7189457417,
0.2677339017,
-0.2740413547,
0.3684195876,
-0.3561248779,
0.3758223653,
0.5564857125,
0.3205749393,
0.0884426683,
-0.4772217572,
0.2796301842,
-0.3820239007,
-0.0551595874,
0.2159664929,
-0.4379417896,
0.8630825281,
-0.4112951756,
-0.3367339373,
0.3758990765,
0.8651643395,
0.6998300552,
0.2380793393,
0.4936235547,
0.5777279735,
1.2096728086,
-0.1564837247,
1.1735793352,
-0.6177997589,
0.3904494941,
0.7935269475,
-0.4128060937,
0.9121804237,
0.5352590084,
-0.3269441724,
0.1819265634,
0.5534996986,
0.2817735374,
0.5754093528,
0.0106715681,
-0.4915308654,
-0.2157826573,
0.1617620438,
-0.685326159,
0.1399354041,
0.835357368,
-0.0706302896,
-0.0553552508,
-0.2130108327,
-0.1156491786,
-0.1353174299,
-0.1993357688,
0.2226885855,
-0.0328397006,
-0.3388356566,
0.5420441031,
0.4392820597,
1.1068298817,
-0.7643595934,
0.2086067349,
-0.0052338848,
0.2313830405,
-0.0704029128,
-0.3576831818,
0.1197284162,
-0.033387322,
-0.0765625164,
-0.2914763391,
0.5702931285,
-0.3991436362,
-0.5548550487,
0.2362646013,
0.5820425153,
0.0826913416,
0.1955294758,
-0.3792666495,
0.4915648103,
-0.1924560219,
-0.1604545861,
0.3698542118,
0.8150407076,
0.2311811745,
0.3783348799,
0.9105111957,
0.3813867271,
0.1204109266,
0.2248787731,
0.9163901806,
-0.6408230662,
-0.8038393855,
-1.0054744482,
0.4446374178,
-0.1081845239,
-0.2679240704,
0.8384690285,
0.5673453808,
0.6266722083,
-0.1563886255,
0.7999803424,
0.1175481975,
0.4360351562,
-0.9096723199,
0.3680561185,
-0.23353149,
0.6752937436,
-0.3100908399,
-0.692627728,
-0.1973804086,
0.0896616057,
0.0600979365,
0.0032645715,
0.9807242751,
0.9265446067,
-0.1519102752,
0.3241747618,
0.3090662658,
0.3084179163,
0.3121756315,
0.2960577905,
0.7908095717,
-0.1790145785,
0.2856111228,
-0.2391944379,
-0.1882600486,
-0.1670496464,
-0.9142952561,
-0.685639143,
-0.5219377875,
-0.0598484017,
-0.5368392467,
0.1030574813,
1.3135076761,
0.8121721745,
-0.8747348785,
0.0336195789,
-0.009640024,
-0.0715769231,
-0.4939723313,
-0.1540600508,
0.4687857032,
-0.6173739433,
-0.9884842634,
0.5250063539,
0.288680017,
-0.0136117954,
-0.0409729742,
-0.1989990622,
0.1729336977,
0.2777695954,
0.4598946571,
0.0810537934,
-0.6743826866,
0.0600272566,
0.1736752093,
-0.09024515,
-0.0994548351,
1.1832901239,
-0.5589573979,
0.4006022811,
0.3852643371,
1.0119253397,
0.6506902575,
-0.2218982875,
0.4315863848,
-0.9469937682,
0.5752362609,
0.1040037423,
0.7660554647,
0.0206650812,
-0.5001279712,
0.0123698441,
0.40643996,
-0.1478345394,
-1.0570075512,
0.0615567118,
-1.0871061087,
-0.3536715806,
1.2388550043,
-0.1453402638,
-0.1919527501,
-0.2254091054,
-0.1938947588,
-0.2406117171,
-0.9102737904,
0.7126069069,
0.7372140884,
0.1337281317,
-0.0906888992,
-0.4056393504,
0.3833203018,
0.4550554454,
-0.6963649392,
0.2312120795,
0.3134490848,
0.0694239438,
-0.1315492094,
0.9505993128,
-0.1769242287,
0.1935896426,
0.6794849038,
-0.1401315182,
-0.0716132224,
-0.2415680438,
-0.2508575916,
0.1610403359,
0.1001234353,
-0.0472846739
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07513v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07513v1
|
Fine-tuning the SwissBERT Encoder Model for Embedding Sentences and Documents
| 2024-05-13T07:20:21 | 2024-05-13T07:20:21 |
Juri Grosjean, Jannis Vamvas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Encoder models trained for the embedding of sentences or short documents have
proven useful for tasks such as semantic search and topic modeling. In this
paper, we present a version of the SwissBERT encoder model that we specifically
fine-tuned for this purpose. SwissBERT contains language adapters for the four
national languages of Switzerland -- German, French, Italian, and Romansh --
and has been pre-trained on a large number of news articles in those languages.
Using contrastive learning based on a subset of these articles, we trained a
fine-tuned version, which we call SentenceSwissBERT. Multilingual experiments
on document retrieval and text classification in a Switzerland-specific setting
show that SentenceSwissBERT surpasses the accuracy of the original SwissBERT
model and of a comparable baseline. The model is openly available for research
use.
|
[
-0.4897436798,
-0.6535981297,
0.5126160383,
0.0899825245,
-0.3360622525,
-0.1089150012,
-0.295122236,
-0.3129622042,
0.2034136504,
0.6202123165,
-0.3960913718,
-0.604563117,
-0.7709333897,
0.2997540832,
-0.4514062405,
1.0232188702,
-0.2544823587,
0.2235131562,
-0.1910653114,
-0.3682969511,
0.0967581421,
-0.4623945951,
-0.1721701026,
-0.4952918291,
0.4614248276,
0.4038398564,
0.7564854026,
0.279420495,
0.4136407971,
0.2437246889,
-0.1796322614,
0.3245956898,
-0.5300173759,
-0.1210004613,
-0.3296853602,
-0.343416363,
0.1626147032,
-0.2586044669,
0.5806988478,
0.5884866714,
-0.1243989393,
-0.174822554,
0.0818437487,
0.744425714,
-0.4899922013,
-0.0193766281,
-0.4580849707,
-0.0876103714,
0.0946180001,
-0.1381423771,
-0.4199768305,
-0.6142769456,
0.1341745108,
-0.3277777433,
0.5721201301,
-0.1034361422,
1.0925244093,
0.0110726971,
-0.5371989012,
-0.4936150312,
-0.3688108623,
0.6799205542,
-0.5061494708,
0.7508804798,
0.3781622052,
-0.0314368494,
0.0744628236,
-0.6865873933,
-0.1836246252,
-0.2272272408,
-0.2997286022,
0.0545988977,
-0.3541708887,
-0.121140793,
0.0820076391,
0.0615571216,
-0.6910097599,
0.1490719616,
-0.7080279589,
-0.0746375397,
0.4937419593,
-0.0311210621,
0.2189242691,
-0.0280562527,
0.032355614,
-0.0139899598,
-0.60222435,
-0.0497610345,
0.7361457348,
0.285443604,
0.0602528714,
0.6186417341,
-0.5259342194,
1.0297489166,
0.2538178265,
0.3085747063,
0.3252183497,
-0.1620842665,
0.1187070906,
0.285851866,
0.4763956666,
0.3362566829,
0.3261391521,
-0.279599607,
-0.3312387168,
-0.04320997,
0.2956925333,
-1.2919697762,
-0.4452008307,
-0.0004100302,
-0.4193277955,
-0.0798241347,
0.3166130781,
-0.2175992429,
-0.0717884898,
-0.3477236032,
0.3131332397,
-0.6932079196,
0.1786193252,
0.6128116846,
-0.2395302504,
0.1021748707,
0.2763405144,
-1.0024647713,
0.3486561775,
0.4837930202,
0.8976399302,
-0.0112651568,
-0.454659611,
-0.7881443501,
-0.0108261565,
-0.3971540332,
0.9539726377,
-0.7606262565,
-0.3912820816,
0.4606693983,
0.3068336248,
-0.0221377909,
-0.4532517493,
0.781073153,
-0.7425657511,
0.2660199404,
-0.0428449549,
-0.7781353593,
-0.2325182855,
0.3074703217,
-0.7752104402,
0.6095813513,
0.2433122993,
-1.0809470415,
0.0536684208,
-0.5695718527,
-0.8044092059,
-0.2286632955,
0.0440947637,
-0.4362970591,
0.3163953722,
0.4203188419,
0.703429997,
-0.0853987262,
0.0816614255,
-0.2336452305,
-0.636511445,
0.2378228158,
0.0571763217,
0.8067350984,
0.1575681865,
0.3183027804,
-0.0231663007,
-0.5486655235,
-0.1354489326,
-0.202567324,
-0.4175481498,
-0.5216178298,
0.0078278948,
0.3633770347,
0.0455756299,
0.3397734165,
-0.8046811223,
-0.1433379352,
-0.4078997672,
0.8319703937,
0.2061572075,
0.1123863161,
0.5660591125,
-0.3027803898,
0.2670219243,
0.1776814461,
-0.0210436881,
-0.3276124597,
-0.0037593595,
-0.6917421222,
-0.1164902225,
0.651992321,
0.4969155788,
-0.639683485,
0.6700611711,
-0.1910402328,
-0.6366807222,
-0.6803586483,
0.1668710113,
-0.0303587783,
0.1548511386,
0.3211583793,
-0.14631854,
-0.1560942978,
-1.1989418268,
-0.2801753283,
0.1927946955,
0.0449432619,
0.045463711,
0.6125715375,
-0.4029740393,
0.7770565152,
-0.7010608912,
-0.1497868896,
-0.287653625,
0.6876387,
0.1537081897,
0.562001884,
0.71029073,
-1.0177497864,
-0.5439789295,
0.0419384353,
-0.5303852558,
0.1371183693,
-0.0055927169,
-0.0638176724,
0.1009623855,
0.644115448,
-0.3579770923,
0.1653897613,
0.5739297867,
-0.1393989474,
0.2961855531,
-0.6453543901,
0.2103217989,
-1.1605688334,
-0.3006522357,
0.3082693517,
-0.2683331966,
-0.5018079877,
0.1231131181,
0.6534109116,
-0.427069366,
-0.4929573834,
0.345987916,
-0.4028189778,
0.1887153834,
-0.1836274266,
0.3455986083,
0.2374170274,
0.1383540034,
0.2281876802,
0.7999442816,
0.5333336592,
-0.4810637534,
0.1772664487,
0.4123854637,
-0.6710219383,
0.6324978471,
-0.9273316264,
0.0848724321,
-0.428963542,
0.0079872347,
-0.5128151178,
-0.1651874334,
-0.2724586129,
-0.2255727798,
0.3490615189,
-0.0903328434,
-0.8291583061,
-0.1101899594,
-0.3084236085,
-0.0178738758,
0.4014928937,
-0.7689710855,
0.5935744047,
0.1030396596,
-0.3504420519,
-0.218323499,
-0.7813230753,
-0.1367401481,
-0.0950783566,
-0.7004972696,
0.6104422808,
-0.1879178435,
0.0023157659,
0.2346969098,
0.101985231,
-0.4898480773,
0.0138203073,
-0.0030074329,
0.0284416657,
-0.0812307075,
0.3146309257,
0.4113615751,
-0.0573971123,
-0.3276210725,
-0.1586912125,
0.3814499676,
-0.2853186727,
-0.28687042,
-0.2920022011,
0.5817738771,
0.2730379701,
-0.6790362,
0.7510952353,
0.7433960438,
-0.4056414366,
-0.1494171321,
-0.4398154616,
-0.2713502049,
-0.4341265857,
0.5944049358,
-0.296172291,
-1.3313621283,
0.3709660769,
-0.2207098007,
-0.130426541,
0.2792118788,
0.12688981,
-0.0434987955,
0.9395669699,
0.8686095476,
-0.0886608511,
0.6048164368,
-0.1956693232,
0.3205708563,
-0.6727646589,
0.0072357142,
-0.859572649,
-0.011404247,
-0.7604306936,
-0.2818787694,
0.0978375971,
0.3672479391,
-0.3546517789,
0.5749132037,
-0.308947295,
0.6840565801,
0.4699044824,
0.2588117123,
0.1254825145,
0.1724051982,
0.0114568975,
-0.2791563869,
-0.6934865713,
-0.6237612963,
0.5655397773,
0.0535639226,
1.1594440937,
0.0562166981,
1.077091217,
0.2400225252,
-0.0779174119,
-0.5506513715,
0.1045825258,
-0.7951014042,
-0.3537235856,
-0.1062123403,
-0.1180543378,
-0.7363717556,
0.1566193104,
-0.0851294398,
-0.7173596025,
0.3702707291,
-0.1639840603,
-0.355138123,
-0.0245381221,
-0.6006433368,
0.9549618959,
-0.360515058,
-0.1821265966,
-0.465159595,
-0.3266442418,
-0.0968139321,
-0.2904600501,
0.0517868586,
-0.1198972985,
0.0427596122,
0.5489518642,
0.145146668,
0.7735719085,
0.1221993789,
0.135081321,
-0.0485602953,
0.1063737422,
0.5835897923,
0.1885397583,
-0.4375281334,
0.0196284708,
-0.0002725229,
-0.4671784937,
-0.5836855769,
0.9553946257,
-0.9301629663,
-0.5168435574,
-0.2164438218,
-0.2978070378,
-0.0208893456,
0.2553789616,
0.3086121976,
0.6639603376,
-0.6168591976,
0.5931162238,
0.8680975437,
-0.3130305409,
0.2675998807,
0.8106003404,
0.0185966268,
-0.1425950825,
0.8375401497,
0.0639932677,
-0.0975911692,
0.6307939887,
-0.0631557629,
-0.1274319291,
-0.4541498721,
-0.3341015577,
0.3016706109,
-0.81124717,
-0.2083814293,
-0.7997850776,
-0.3789526522,
-0.1796316504,
-0.6847875714,
-0.3497514427,
-0.4373720884,
-0.7628289461,
-0.3020329773,
0.3324797153,
0.7703649402,
-0.117500551,
0.302549094,
-0.9319761395,
0.1595417112,
0.2065190375,
0.3116208017,
-0.4935549498,
-0.5964388251,
-0.5828029513,
-0.0860231444,
-0.1847036034,
-0.7355818748,
0.3366832435,
0.4075954258,
0.588653326,
0.2519473433,
0.3395798504,
0.2888746858,
-0.7021892071,
0.7379241586,
0.1861098707,
-0.9167569876,
0.7600614429,
-0.2571120858,
0.4115818441,
0.6927548647,
0.7221258879,
-0.4835856557,
-0.2877684236,
-0.4039166272,
-0.6064171791,
0.5773862004,
0.0944304615,
0.5718724728,
-0.2333538532,
0.3427981138,
0.3224641979,
0.0438264832,
-0.3133242428,
0.357537508,
-0.3698531091,
-0.2651492655,
-0.2629957795,
-0.3977854848,
-0.1565794349,
-0.1995676011,
0.6311756372,
-0.1905072927,
0.2754283845,
0.2332319021,
-0.6547964811,
0.1131342575,
0.410725385,
0.5383414626,
0.8034672141,
-0.2632462978,
0.1729794592,
0.1449551582,
-0.012004572,
-0.0673815906,
0.6209220886,
-0.3525529802,
0.407350719,
0.3475374877,
0.9255619049,
0.4570552707,
-0.6654723287,
0.4428316355,
-0.1669497341,
-0.4121967852,
-0.1804993004,
0.1388785839,
0.3053637445,
0.5420140624,
0.0392952375,
-0.0302159917,
0.298124671,
-0.4775934517,
0.3281424642,
0.161719963,
-0.6521348953,
-0.1987640262,
0.4014448225,
0.2603247464,
-0.3977871537,
0.7609726787,
-0.1588160247,
-0.8435836434,
0.4536779523,
0.5881490111,
0.6657678485,
-0.0247560181,
0.5764932632,
0.4699757099,
0.3357297182,
-0.4088333249,
0.2037083507,
0.0493726246,
-0.9308850169,
-0.0261386223,
-0.5535392165,
-0.3210904598,
-0.4193806648,
-1.0186356306,
0.1826582551,
0.0160915609,
-0.067460686,
0.1196368188,
0.1263137609,
-0.9368303418,
-0.091135323,
-0.2109763324,
1.2483887672,
-0.9238830209,
1.1443243027,
0.8023768663,
-0.4391140342,
-0.0787058622,
0.1566923708,
-0.625300169,
-0.5384014845,
0.824555397,
0.2208951861,
-0.2939791977,
0.0339439586,
-0.4910401702,
-0.6311859488,
0.9113532305,
0.5136370659,
-0.8505465388,
0.2625940442,
-0.2221119553,
0.5772943497,
-0.5503863692,
-0.242701754,
0.3531668782,
0.3320273757,
-0.3538962305,
-0.4838630855,
-0.2711566389,
-0.1823055744,
0.1964587718,
0.266882807,
-0.6871647835,
0.7683654428,
-0.1916910261,
0.0634782165,
0.2214417309,
0.5837917328,
-0.0062985029,
-0.2172143906,
0.1291544139,
0.4482082427,
0.8723163605,
-0.2006514817,
1.0938091278,
-0.6361521482,
0.4126176834,
1.1839431524,
-0.4446111619,
1.0012511015,
0.3229954839,
0.2075424641,
0.7232427001,
0.7115730047,
-0.2693933547,
1.0191007853,
0.0471365042,
-0.2072225213,
-0.4189762175,
-0.1537234634,
-0.2156546414,
0.1665594131,
0.346778363,
-0.502661407,
-0.2339116484,
0.2975300252,
0.0175433997,
0.3490283489,
-0.1713084131,
0.5419669747,
-0.0657637119,
-0.4538503885,
0.231660217,
0.4490532875,
0.6841350198,
-0.5772442818,
0.1799468994,
-0.3277032375,
0.3580875397,
-0.0294080619,
-0.854008019,
0.258915633,
0.0109288394,
-0.3204951584,
-0.1344707757,
0.9127519727,
-0.7201662064,
-0.6985374093,
0.4724175632,
0.3243515193,
-0.1407493055,
0.0506139025,
-0.6341072321,
0.1095651835,
-0.0973382294,
-0.0452870689,
0.3047524393,
0.5707033873,
0.1897219718,
0.278655231,
0.22389929,
-0.1831470728,
-0.2594379485,
0.284889251,
0.8997026086,
-0.6134620905,
-0.7003034949,
-0.6094226241,
0.2525887787,
-0.2754853666,
-0.1803785712,
0.5119863153,
0.7948635221,
0.9748206139,
-0.1937794089,
0.8398204446,
0.2334457785,
0.3483876884,
-0.6076409817,
0.7686504126,
-0.6445028186,
-0.3028035164,
0.1826703101,
-0.7830676436,
-0.2801021636,
1.0863652229,
-0.1737698615,
-0.1769373864,
0.7668722868,
0.8049401641,
-0.3206166923,
0.2184722573,
0.3248935044,
-0.0202671997,
0.0085791061,
0.2665488124,
0.6357219219,
-0.2603592873,
0.4167004526,
-0.3181577623,
0.1543937474,
-0.266661346,
-0.8632068038,
-1.2840474844,
-0.683616519,
-0.3994684815,
-0.1110558584,
0.6186214089,
0.7549086809,
0.7601168156,
-0.8236181736,
-0.1192931607,
0.1535608172,
-0.0115685072,
0.0212951917,
-0.0966058075,
0.3868695498,
-0.3707100153,
-0.5890001059,
0.346344322,
0.2802763283,
0.0744692907,
-0.1073830947,
-0.2890696228,
-0.2156548202,
0.1451499164,
0.5688044429,
-0.0282043051,
-0.5356563926,
-0.4776677787,
-0.0323522389,
-0.2095087022,
-0.0005273597,
0.9392498732,
-0.4551047683,
0.5434415936,
0.4893945158,
0.6776881814,
0.9951889515,
-0.1554689705,
0.6780689359,
-0.7205374837,
0.2848198712,
0.0833562762,
0.6086214185,
0.7680270076,
-0.2250515372,
0.5482104421,
-0.2829721868,
-0.422453016,
-0.4101780057,
0.1776353568,
-0.621702373,
-0.6258509159,
0.8977845907,
-0.3308735788,
0.0152833341,
0.0245098285,
-0.2758760154,
0.2330741286,
-0.4633387327,
0.5860863328,
0.9546937346,
-0.0302796997,
-0.3989097178,
-0.6213297248,
0.2496139109,
0.0658218861,
-0.5475450754,
-0.1636385918,
0.4216699898,
0.3394874334,
0.1656003147,
0.206468448,
0.0316542685,
0.3238553405,
-0.1504548192,
-0.1856323332,
-0.0993832275,
-0.276858598,
-0.500934422,
0.089832373,
0.0938457251,
0.0733467191
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07500v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07500v1
|
PromptLink: Leveraging Large Language Models for Cross-Source Biomedical Concept Linking
| 2024-05-13T06:36:30 | 2024-05-13T06:36:30 |
Yuzhang Xie, Jiaying Lu, Joyce Ho, Fadi Nahab, Xiao Hu, Carl Yang
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Linking (aligning) biomedical concepts across diverse data sources enables
various integrative analyses, but it is challenging due to the discrepancies in
concept naming conventions. Various strategies have been developed to overcome
this challenge, such as those based on string-matching rules, manually crafted
thesauri, and machine learning models. However, these methods are constrained
by limited prior biomedical knowledge and can hardly generalize beyond the
limited amounts of rules, thesauri, or training samples. Recently, large
language models (LLMs) have exhibited impressive results in diverse biomedical
NLP tasks due to their unprecedentedly rich prior knowledge and strong
zero-shot prediction abilities. However, LLMs suffer from issues including high
costs, limited context length, and unreliable predictions. In this research, we
propose PromptLink, a novel biomedical concept linking framework that leverages
LLMs. It first employs a biomedical-specialized pre-trained language model to
generate candidate concepts that can fit in the LLM context windows. Then it
utilizes an LLM to link concepts through two-stage prompts, where the
first-stage prompt aims to elicit the biomedical prior knowledge from the LLM
for the concept linking task and the second-stage prompt enforces the LLM to
reflect on its own predictions to further enhance their reliability. Empirical
results on the concept linking task between two EHR datasets and an external
biomedical KG demonstrate the effectiveness of PromptLink. Furthermore,
PromptLink is a generic framework without reliance on additional prior
knowledge, context, or training data, making it well-suited for concept linking
across various types of data sources. The source code is available at
https://github.com/constantjxyz/PromptLink.
|
[
-0.0630962253,
-0.7054044008,
0.8660271764,
-0.0229206923,
-0.3247958422,
0.1332137436,
0.0456282496,
-0.6517596245,
0.1780127585,
0.1185101792,
-0.7679765224,
-0.4590699077,
-0.2224136591,
0.5281819701,
-0.084916167,
0.8034350276,
0.2571138442,
0.2077371925,
-0.6515359879,
-0.2616738379,
-0.5474755168,
-0.0426592901,
-0.8104727864,
-0.4190762043,
0.9880436659,
0.1500131488,
0.7804182768,
0.8024443388,
0.5424894094,
0.1864245236,
-0.1544989794,
0.0815748125,
-0.3897544444,
0.4088850617,
-0.6358729005,
-0.3354963064,
-0.4047714472,
-0.2849621177,
0.6161447167,
0.8644874692,
0.2087618858,
0.0260177068,
-0.0866375342,
0.5359191895,
-0.3146610856,
0.1441525072,
-0.6162671447,
-0.1094775051,
-0.3165907264,
-0.2648501694,
-0.1853806227,
-0.4357063174,
0.3530959487,
-0.6162102818,
0.0151266512,
0.3769723475,
0.6419335604,
0.5542961359,
-0.3669577241,
-0.4205824733,
-0.1041715816,
0.3180752993,
-0.6531478167,
0.3861410916,
0.1792897135,
0.2214405686,
-0.1767442822,
-0.5656656623,
-0.5446735024,
-0.3926968277,
-0.1205488145,
-0.1442376077,
-0.204314515,
0.0650798306,
0.3679825068,
-0.0449193642,
-0.7760357857,
0.2906748354,
-0.3682362437,
-0.2219633907,
0.4718690217,
0.2667114139,
0.523865819,
-0.2903710306,
-0.4658555388,
0.0519658811,
-1.1175615788,
-0.1422051489,
-0.0516542271,
0.7667010427,
-0.2715633214,
0.7419480085,
-0.0264490135,
0.7202990651,
0.4163398743,
-0.1750174463,
0.6480157971,
-0.6172992587,
0.0077678771,
0.581192553,
0.8508527875,
0.3115010262,
-0.2236078829,
-0.3167877197,
0.2400574088,
-0.0716224685,
0.0628970042,
-0.8458459377,
-0.0192027371,
0.5517656207,
-0.3625052273,
-0.0229684077,
-0.5332151651,
-0.3151742816,
-0.5160136223,
-0.300858438,
0.5405436158,
-0.710539937,
0.0009294151,
0.0611683875,
0.0992148519,
0.1933997273,
0.2731595039,
-0.4183339477,
-0.3489854336,
0.6261644363,
0.9533202052,
-0.1148648784,
-0.2747294307,
-0.7822343111,
0.4608356059,
-0.0722494125,
0.7610491514,
-0.653668344,
-0.5423130989,
-0.0154482955,
0.1850907952,
0.0050663073,
-0.2051008642,
0.6128726006,
-0.5176773071,
0.1204246953,
-0.412571013,
-0.8306728601,
0.3247117698,
0.0688931048,
-0.7210046649,
0.6597688794,
-0.1426025331,
-1.055796504,
0.2913990021,
-0.5909584165,
-0.5988130569,
0.2924321592,
-0.351985693,
-0.341812551,
-0.1042021215,
-0.1569913477,
0.549939692,
-0.6443856359,
0.6839243174,
-0.6902836561,
-0.0145719573,
0.3370400965,
0.0972545594,
0.8208613992,
0.1784431934,
0.0733246282,
0.4053774774,
-0.7133745551,
-0.3606870174,
0.1164458543,
-0.024976084,
-0.6690286398,
-0.341779232,
-0.3441990316,
0.4402392805,
0.3623664677,
-0.6152197719,
0.270396769,
-0.4102259576,
0.2503145635,
0.4638603926,
-0.1185314506,
0.4126452506,
-0.3588581383,
0.3841273487,
-0.0242872629,
-0.1089300886,
-0.5228798389,
-0.4891433418,
-0.2164549232,
-0.1771612465,
0.1661899388,
0.3638003767,
-1.002165556,
0.5356732011,
-0.3859148622,
-0.5290723443,
-0.7107036114,
-0.0939030796,
0.4130409658,
1.1267371178,
0.7353577614,
0.1287959665,
-0.4086212814,
-0.83531183,
-0.0638060048,
-0.4276455641,
-0.3032768965,
0.5401933193,
0.2765500844,
-0.370493412,
1.0016036034,
-0.4108627737,
-0.2529032826,
-0.1337026954,
0.0057308269,
0.3651345968,
0.5329189897,
0.4051667452,
-0.5180945992,
-0.2578619719,
-0.1034179106,
-0.799618125,
-0.4115836024,
-0.1809708625,
-0.2595812976,
-0.3796680868,
0.6546587348,
-0.6765851974,
-0.0818038136,
0.4079598188,
-0.5314865708,
0.5658501387,
-0.2610763609,
0.0277242791,
-1.4407488108,
0.5125855803,
0.2494262606,
0.0246144962,
-0.4611012638,
-0.2172190696,
-0.0196242984,
-0.2313766032,
-0.3457105756,
0.9716338515,
-0.3314267397,
0.098509185,
-0.0905271471,
0.0600547269,
-0.068625614,
-0.0186462682,
0.2629447877,
0.6971883774,
0.7111836672,
-0.5029719472,
0.4574868977,
0.8259980083,
0.1528847963,
0.8412715197,
-1.0447976589,
-0.1210580096,
-0.0771783143,
0.4479684532,
-0.787337184,
-0.2024917006,
0.3839060962,
-0.4693886936,
0.3356608152,
0.0611096211,
-0.416290313,
-0.3376960456,
-0.2057019025,
0.6340590119,
0.3395970464,
-0.5200750828,
0.5395534039,
0.2990099788,
-0.5357247591,
-0.4432325661,
-0.4538455307,
0.2401933074,
-0.1590841562,
-0.59615165,
0.555564642,
-0.2434599847,
0.1846873015,
0.0967824608,
-0.049404908,
0.1404719055,
-0.1995889097,
0.3370829821,
0.5672837496,
-0.2133954316,
0.666107595,
0.1758849174,
-0.1961179227,
0.2686298192,
-0.314014405,
0.2322455794,
0.3551385999,
-0.4799110591,
-0.2849684656,
0.3810835779,
0.4225096405,
-0.1575306058,
0.8771548271,
0.6178215742,
-0.2410878986,
-0.0620008744,
-0.3269744515,
-0.1718253642,
-0.4067533314,
0.4188077748,
-0.4385557175,
-0.9770638943,
0.2305333763,
-0.4234567583,
-0.2450692207,
0.371719569,
0.5650205612,
-0.1101403385,
0.4374852777,
0.7203402519,
0.0247943979,
0.1013454497,
0.343670249,
0.2669802606,
-0.9042021036,
-0.6462296247,
-0.7996686697,
-0.13748312,
-0.4629009664,
-0.7275153399,
0.4780814946,
0.0337566696,
-0.4593547881,
0.3697572052,
-0.1710697711,
0.1032291725,
0.506076932,
0.3320132196,
0.3490425646,
-0.076217249,
-0.5429531336,
0.1391557306,
-0.9093412757,
-0.354632169,
1.1596000195,
0.2697550356,
0.8150402904,
-0.0683717057,
0.4144116044,
0.1077331454,
0.1553963572,
-0.6376414895,
0.4862500131,
0.1759303361,
-0.3692755997,
-0.2539559603,
-0.4240882397,
-1.1403894424,
-0.3419116735,
-0.6278849244,
-0.4422451556,
0.1459232122,
0.1468690038,
-0.3944874406,
0.2093643248,
-0.0980169326,
0.8546073437,
-0.1845392734,
-0.7537770271,
-0.0981531069,
-1.2050292492,
0.3246344328,
-0.5008946061,
-0.0707044452,
-0.2031942308,
-0.2090964615,
0.5203204751,
-0.4277195036,
0.8372294903,
0.2467803061,
-0.3805279732,
-0.0124047212,
-0.1162873134,
0.334887743,
0.2159907669,
-0.1214499995,
0.3297685683,
-0.1121915728,
-0.312959373,
-0.2393968254,
0.8330478072,
-0.5178174973,
-0.3679365814,
-0.2861621082,
-0.5337063074,
-0.5570200086,
0.1257908046,
0.220023036,
0.4317737818,
-0.2062327415,
0.1868295223,
0.9259001017,
-0.6122587323,
0.1588856131,
0.6821789145,
0.0279502496,
-0.2027963549,
0.5527564883,
-0.5164667368,
0.1514063179,
0.6326838136,
0.1084520295,
-0.7180950642,
-0.3628476858,
-0.248559624,
0.4589232504,
-0.4543118179,
-0.4798478186,
-0.811978519,
-0.0648709163,
-0.2923337519,
-0.2666491568,
-0.1141362265,
0.0226924736,
-0.2149341851,
0.0430029929,
0.5704120994,
0.1396947801,
-0.2582071424,
0.0582785085,
-1.0788362026,
0.4237864316,
0.1417999864,
0.4279282391,
0.0050477521,
-0.2330392301,
-0.1492640972,
-0.0925398171,
0.2425972968,
-1.0167640448,
0.0103865312,
0.1037005931,
0.6042944193,
0.355012238,
0.1995299757,
0.4475940466,
-0.874669373,
0.4610712528,
0.7543944716,
-0.7455829382,
0.8520532846,
-0.3520543575,
0.2210336924,
0.46500054,
0.8257901073,
-0.4385819733,
-0.2009643018,
-0.4702229202,
-0.822504878,
0.2888186574,
0.1149950698,
-0.1463687718,
-0.3219279647,
0.2924512923,
0.2830805779,
0.2036015093,
-0.1326410025,
-0.3440617621,
0.2001742125,
-0.4601370692,
-0.2002371997,
-0.052106332,
-0.2450205833,
-0.1070579365,
0.5593274236,
-0.3794552386,
0.1863529384,
0.2951873541,
-0.1299579144,
-0.2039554715,
0.2942311168,
0.0746946707,
0.5226638913,
-0.0654121712,
-0.1129355282,
-0.074160248,
-0.2271661609,
0.2476834357,
0.3979898989,
-0.2335267514,
0.1865364462,
0.5395092368,
0.7434547544,
0.3668080866,
-0.9402160645,
0.4016383886,
0.1763290763,
0.2893790305,
0.1784961373,
-0.0886714309,
0.4732601345,
0.5018658042,
0.2492602021,
-0.045739498,
0.0907725617,
-0.4327757359,
0.5078577995,
0.501689136,
-0.396122992,
-0.413775146,
0.9981346726,
0.5027610064,
-0.0002161215,
0.3022347391,
-0.0667970031,
-0.0468814224,
0.4605555534,
0.6941578388,
0.8760046363,
-0.2528322637,
0.3195153475,
0.7144346833,
-0.165099591,
0.0562974028,
0.100018017,
0.0495341606,
-0.6177249551,
-0.6766563654,
-0.6526988745,
-0.4671920538,
-0.1431961209,
-0.4819394648,
0.4059877098,
-0.1923426241,
-0.171163708,
0.1260270029,
-0.0303000398,
-0.797360599,
0.0941472128,
0.3820383847,
1.0982247591,
-0.9831442833,
0.9348931313,
0.9666409492,
-0.6322600245,
-0.8644437194,
-0.1817668974,
0.1883705556,
-0.7955074906,
0.8493386507,
-0.1009626761,
-0.0521585196,
-0.0003527597,
-0.4107215703,
-0.8178192973,
1.2547812462,
0.3079107106,
-0.8793134689,
-0.3580565155,
-0.0296056159,
0.4422979057,
-0.540841341,
0.2723588347,
0.1990490556,
0.3285986185,
0.6707825661,
-1.0775792599,
0.619391799,
-0.1492633671,
-0.1683353335,
-0.0490464866,
-0.3852704763,
0.5743156075,
-0.6241018176,
-0.1349487752,
0.2925117016,
0.4798300564,
0.7318205833,
0.3964646161,
0.1165372059,
0.4330092072,
0.9661979675,
0.1100439504,
0.64526999,
-0.6771640182,
0.1871722937,
1.2479939461,
-0.7475646734,
0.6558179855,
0.3789694309,
-0.2083254158,
0.3588225245,
0.5414492488,
-0.1153015494,
0.4527682066,
0.0475072265,
-0.2499622107,
-0.2361789793,
-0.6997315288,
-0.7409587502,
0.0106779346,
0.4446025193,
-0.3263828754,
-0.3622935116,
-0.1318191886,
-0.0834422037,
-0.1405067444,
-0.4755063355,
0.7185451984,
0.1690052152,
-0.1699236929,
0.2659293413,
-0.4118554294,
0.6194851995,
-0.8062957525,
0.0664899498,
-0.1133738533,
-0.2443659753,
-0.0398219973,
-0.6517748237,
0.0193728004,
-0.0397835001,
-0.0551692657,
0.13025859,
0.8039296865,
-0.6057556272,
-0.2452709973,
0.2984960973,
0.9163853526,
-0.1486818045,
0.3570355773,
-0.8809605241,
0.0979061276,
-0.1776432395,
0.2291396856,
0.3939014673,
0.589396894,
0.0992199481,
0.8901740313,
0.8529025912,
0.2726652324,
-0.4529224038,
-0.0183554124,
0.9994968176,
-1.0099101067,
-0.5325576067,
-0.7869301438,
0.329030633,
-0.1629338264,
-0.306838274,
0.5308460593,
0.5849685669,
0.444196552,
-0.0082895933,
0.7085838914,
0.0739906803,
0.5631201863,
-0.551631093,
0.4785425663,
-0.4979019463,
0.1879938245,
-0.3165966272,
-0.8116682172,
-0.283801049,
0.253837049,
-0.0051148445,
-0.239196822,
0.8447662592,
0.6204103231,
0.0669090375,
-0.187498942,
0.1754733771,
0.4596280754,
0.0396610126,
0.8664022684,
0.7044661045,
0.0012466008,
0.2464440316,
0.2238160223,
-0.0731996074,
-0.2501961291,
-1.1695795059,
-1.0407195091,
-0.5001193285,
-0.7456192374,
-0.5305392742,
0.2038471252,
1.2425507307,
0.4791220129,
-0.5838461518,
0.2386740446,
0.2010769993,
0.053433273,
0.1681857407,
-0.0718626454,
0.6599290371,
-0.4591777325,
-0.4984131753,
0.5151919723,
0.5669304132,
0.1071946099,
-0.1447573751,
-0.1456337124,
-0.3028775156,
0.0120839039,
0.4773163497,
0.4781510234,
-0.6754930615,
0.0223740451,
-0.0624421649,
-0.3461478353,
-0.0990150571,
0.642880857,
-1.2255769968,
0.301856935,
0.5338600874,
1.0861923695,
-0.1514378637,
0.0582311787,
0.6546702981,
-0.5272016525,
-0.0070205247,
0.2127468288,
0.4338266253,
0.4637185633,
-0.3674769402,
0.4489623308,
0.1463319361,
-0.2358008325,
-0.6094586253,
0.2558841407,
-1.1944935322,
-0.4129288793,
1.0527760983,
0.0167239364,
-0.2261980474,
0.0223956928,
-0.1182046756,
0.356956929,
-0.3826409578,
0.6308393478,
0.1924002171,
-0.0302327238,
0.1975532323,
-0.3862915039,
0.6396306753,
0.214634791,
-0.8196198344,
-0.1256267428,
0.6474023461,
0.2897528112,
0.0816019848,
0.5363188386,
0.0338922441,
0.1792532802,
-0.1874094158,
-0.0294843018,
-0.1438499838,
-0.0532138236,
-0.4573477805,
0.0251348168,
-0.2280560583,
-0.0097327577
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07495v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07495v1
|
MacBehaviour: An R package for behavioural experimentation on large language models
| 2024-05-13T06:31:48 | 2024-05-13T06:31:48 |
Xufeng Duan, Shixuan Li, Zhenguang G. Cai1
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
There has been increasing interest in investigating the behaviours of large
language models (LLMs) and LLM-powered chatbots by treating an LLM as a
participant in a psychological experiment. We therefore developed an R package
called "MacBehaviour" that aims to interact with more than 60 language models
in one package (e.g., OpenAI's GPT family, the Claude family, Gemini, Llama
family, and open-source models) and streamline the experimental process of LLMs
behaviour experiments. The package offers a comprehensive set of functions
designed for LLM experiments, covering experiment design, stimuli presentation,
model behaviour manipulation, logging response and token probability. To
demonstrate the utility and effectiveness of "MacBehaviour," we conducted three
validation experiments on three LLMs (GPT-3.5, Llama-2 7B, and Vicuna-1.5 13B)
to replicate sound-gender association in LLMs. The results consistently showed
that they exhibit human-like tendencies to infer gender from novel personal
names based on their phonology, as previously demonstrated (Cai et al., 2023).
In summary, "MacBehaviour" is an R package for machine behaviour studies which
offers a user-friendly interface and comprehensive features to simplify and
standardize the experimental process.
|
[
-0.5554510355,
-1.1514103413,
0.440074265,
0.5229091048,
0.156728223,
0.0390773676,
-0.0644925013,
-0.4445441663,
0.2161034495,
0.7922475338,
-0.8307271004,
-0.4131999314,
-0.5053091049,
0.2747118175,
-0.3337606192,
1.0241132975,
0.1460333318,
0.0387872308,
-0.1557531506,
-0.0643572956,
-0.5288084745,
-0.7852138877,
-0.6328522563,
-0.4023578167,
0.8303387165,
0.48131001,
0.6016796827,
0.0803201795,
0.7867274284,
0.280264467,
-0.2552676499,
0.1367274225,
-0.451669693,
0.3667416871,
-0.1677143723,
-0.3103193939,
-0.6308502555,
-0.0284948647,
0.3275328875,
0.3975332975,
-0.4050754905,
0.3574872315,
0.0840797648,
0.534072876,
-0.4064905643,
0.238799423,
-0.1332556009,
-0.0032258474,
-0.1039268747,
-0.129355669,
-0.4585959613,
-0.3531402051,
-0.2979715466,
-0.2289080918,
-0.0885725915,
0.3851728737,
0.2956696451,
0.1389385015,
-0.2534985244,
-0.2834156454,
-0.8390365839,
0.7215142846,
-0.7490318418,
0.3547506034,
0.6258645654,
0.4026697874,
-0.8437637091,
-0.4651953876,
-0.663215518,
-0.4950199723,
-0.1460458338,
0.0262412932,
-0.446205765,
0.1224909648,
0.4326313734,
0.2036414146,
-0.5223422647,
0.0645471737,
-0.2805157602,
-0.3046963811,
0.6283759475,
0.1914800256,
0.6194199324,
-0.1224154532,
-0.0388804451,
-0.2396274507,
-0.2807965577,
0.1932493895,
0.8117606044,
0.3841866255,
-0.1968156695,
0.9067056775,
-0.0201037377,
0.4336643815,
-0.0427346081,
-0.4165939391,
0.3286826313,
-0.0002181384,
-0.1203257218,
0.1183085963,
0.9305478334,
0.0101792645,
0.3472540081,
0.1237536594,
-0.3702121973,
0.1603877693,
0.2452061921,
-0.8859670162,
-0.3922894299,
0.2488636822,
-0.3360669017,
-0.635735631,
-0.0338849202,
-0.6698669195,
-0.1690592319,
-0.200585261,
0.4429312348,
-0.5146642923,
-0.4525084198,
0.1869291514,
-0.0668481737,
0.3044389486,
0.0283338968,
-0.96300596,
0.6893223524,
0.7274788618,
0.6006675363,
-0.3486652076,
-0.3221895993,
-0.8912949562,
0.1828074753,
-0.1041612849,
0.6139286757,
-1.0405421257,
-1.005350709,
-0.4130035341,
0.1230450347,
0.1634824127,
-0.5423309803,
0.4912485182,
-0.2713249922,
0.1997927874,
-0.1677136719,
-0.2768749893,
-0.3139115572,
0.2295945287,
-0.4377785027,
1.3615471125,
0.0621635616,
-0.9771651626,
0.0731305107,
-1.105175972,
-0.4187119007,
-0.1001428887,
-0.1535471827,
-0.5285333991,
0.0169946458,
0.2415913641,
0.4584500194,
0.1000549868,
0.4180079997,
-0.6001618505,
-0.3415182829,
0.8523176908,
-0.3671934307,
0.7847759128,
-0.0325730667,
-0.049441494,
0.2086561024,
-0.6103274822,
-0.3668255508,
0.0828810483,
-0.1104242876,
-0.4262088835,
-0.1746060252,
0.1856634766,
0.1043273658,
0.061113216,
-0.748634994,
0.3509682119,
0.1063012853,
0.4412473738,
0.6826381683,
0.0877980366,
-0.0212123357,
-0.4590153098,
0.8971439004,
-0.0362300351,
0.4883618951,
-0.1672239155,
-0.6827976108,
-0.209361583,
-0.8284512758,
0.2172103226,
0.6319839358,
-0.1295873374,
0.1678170711,
0.0918957815,
-0.2972817123,
-0.2138340473,
-0.0558487363,
0.4638204873,
0.2344618291,
0.1238825768,
-0.3626071215,
-0.7685098052,
-1.1174008846,
0.0317601264,
-0.3570401073,
-0.0762855783,
0.5352448821,
0.764893949,
-0.8631494641,
1.1002961397,
-0.5398512483,
-0.1502614468,
-0.2063665688,
0.2577371895,
0.0987893939,
0.2815299928,
0.5382838249,
-0.8066093922,
0.1811655164,
-0.0731491148,
-0.4144165516,
-0.3236079812,
0.5221448541,
-0.344099611,
0.2308390886,
0.3974350095,
-0.4421913028,
0.146334067,
0.8669524193,
-0.1623424888,
0.9152860045,
-0.1538966745,
0.1029404402,
-0.9559087157,
0.2539126873,
-0.1334577501,
-0.5955956578,
-0.5482834578,
0.0557116233,
-0.1944995075,
-0.1830389649,
-0.4819160402,
0.6313106418,
-0.0476149358,
-0.3817905784,
-0.1538847834,
0.1856265068,
-0.3512875736,
0.3922594488,
0.0047318009,
1.1424781084,
0.3294379413,
-0.8391874433,
0.0617067888,
0.5949145555,
0.1381555051,
0.5246854424,
-0.5683723688,
0.3132436872,
-0.242601797,
0.3021319509,
-1.0748178959,
-0.4810674787,
0.5547311902,
-0.6430928707,
0.1583488435,
0.1335418075,
-0.4614490271,
-0.5051343441,
-0.2551700771,
0.3620098531,
0.5258389711,
-0.3528235853,
0.8907287717,
0.7522171736,
-0.5303749442,
-0.491394937,
-0.8578036427,
0.0786437616,
-0.3212734163,
-0.24682872,
0.0511296131,
-0.526548326,
-0.5549844503,
-0.1304930449,
-0.0344365016,
0.0123097459,
0.0954100266,
0.4946247637,
0.3193102479,
-0.043247059,
-0.0369434841,
-0.08176478,
-0.2594879568,
0.0593108274,
0.200500682,
0.6782138944,
-0.2234753519,
-0.1504877657,
-0.1249122098,
0.1012442037,
0.4629085958,
-0.2524428964,
0.4757013619,
0.5584562421,
-0.1078075394,
-0.2102975994,
-0.4525600672,
-0.2729707956,
-0.5092839599,
0.152131632,
-0.5593478084,
-1.041932106,
0.4653828442,
-0.0530253202,
0.1017043442,
-0.1180658564,
0.3942812979,
-0.2640861273,
1.0442568064,
0.8681198359,
-0.2475166619,
0.2824912071,
0.133155331,
0.103957586,
-1.0044664145,
-0.1396982372,
-0.4991669953,
-0.323556304,
-0.8747004271,
-0.3654455841,
0.138730675,
-0.2627064586,
-0.4874527156,
0.2559025288,
-0.3248999417,
0.4403930902,
0.2152768373,
0.1340926439,
0.5393587351,
-0.0729532242,
-0.2241357267,
-0.0279765557,
-0.3294380307,
-0.7741578817,
0.8968672156,
0.2465705127,
0.8357713223,
0.3638587892,
0.7908242941,
0.3854098618,
0.6207626462,
-0.9831814766,
0.8407122493,
-0.0804957077,
-0.747472167,
-0.2033737302,
-0.4816883206,
-1.075180769,
0.0165458545,
0.0441402271,
-1.1436979771,
-0.1030935422,
0.1051915884,
0.0491752774,
0.0936450064,
-0.1145883128,
0.652099967,
-0.1837093532,
-0.0797472224,
-0.1802815199,
-0.4001849294,
1.078541398,
-0.2512739003,
0.4792976677,
-0.2329701036,
-0.0341805853,
0.6587752104,
-0.1485839933,
0.9607952833,
0.0772836581,
-0.4445099533,
-0.0793112367,
0.635152936,
0.5110160112,
0.03373475,
0.0334949307,
0.1247495785,
0.0586346537,
-0.1295182109,
-0.4807994068,
0.4581397474,
-0.7365977764,
-0.6623026729,
-0.5023633838,
-0.6671068072,
-0.2565383017,
-0.0194771346,
-0.2810113728,
0.5046885014,
-0.4228785932,
0.1728934795,
0.7499454021,
-0.6098484397,
0.2253578901,
0.7703766823,
-1.2633285522,
-0.3736811876,
0.6504970193,
-0.4572024047,
0.2579068542,
0.442445606,
0.4537223279,
-0.1157791466,
-0.1673653871,
-0.023025332,
0.3325873613,
-0.23631832,
0.127481252,
-0.8136531115,
-0.1353541762,
0.2330669463,
0.1452100575,
-0.1819430739,
-0.249489978,
0.0974366367,
-0.0734541267,
0.6815587282,
0.7493786216,
0.0478774719,
0.4329433441,
-0.7148997188,
0.5765629411,
0.2981071174,
0.1898386329,
-0.3564175069,
-0.3903008401,
0.3730256259,
0.1215857044,
-0.4356558621,
-0.7191790938,
0.477492094,
-0.0393821597,
0.6208737493,
0.2449003011,
0.0336867496,
0.5657400489,
-0.271597296,
0.6387093663,
0.0840109885,
-0.9011576176,
0.5950053334,
-0.5993750095,
-0.0632811412,
0.3322073817,
0.3355336487,
-0.7173135281,
-0.6890541315,
-0.5599222779,
-0.5758134723,
0.7410290837,
0.5284104347,
0.1239668429,
0.0499022938,
0.371419996,
0.3618467748,
0.2991241515,
-0.5977332592,
-0.3362024426,
0.1534978598,
-0.1320224851,
-0.3433563113,
-0.2546273172,
-0.1033220515,
-0.1516518146,
0.9194452167,
-0.1425537616,
0.313497901,
0.0289482418,
-0.1521588266,
0.0500132889,
0.2961111665,
0.5282698274,
0.4486725926,
-0.4004763961,
-0.0164000001,
0.1937554181,
-0.8464436531,
0.4123460948,
-0.0763196722,
-0.1187701821,
-0.1406268179,
0.0349137783,
0.5661451817,
0.3596484363,
-0.8036894202,
0.2693900168,
-0.4751069844,
-0.302039206,
-0.3478812575,
0.388536334,
0.3063583076,
0.3063741326,
-0.0494923703,
0.0308230463,
0.3174001575,
-0.7343322635,
0.3064819276,
0.4794184268,
-0.3669259846,
-0.2542268336,
0.5784954429,
0.0010191161,
-0.7106003761,
0.358096987,
-0.3709413707,
-0.4360176027,
0.5784459114,
0.6960328817,
0.84692204,
-0.4751274884,
0.5087661743,
0.1875159889,
0.1898643076,
-0.1591231525,
0.4992158413,
-0.0417736806,
-0.7566568255,
-0.4512678385,
-0.7849863172,
-0.914711237,
0.2551949918,
-0.5812267661,
0.3236174881,
-0.2222267985,
-0.3264349997,
0.076982975,
-0.0788006708,
-0.4598579109,
-0.1925110072,
0.1163956225,
0.7052490115,
-0.513455689,
0.8210863471,
0.7581223249,
-0.3645516634,
-0.7951496243,
0.2815030813,
0.0817776099,
-0.7140116692,
0.9965016842,
0.273016572,
-0.6023108959,
0.0263965987,
-0.5783978701,
-0.649923563,
0.8831914663,
0.3423161507,
-0.9944438338,
0.5281083584,
0.1761907786,
0.2183568776,
-0.2483332157,
0.3004441261,
0.8148203492,
0.8641776443,
0.1300624013,
-0.9819309115,
-0.0448644534,
-0.2614861429,
0.1265064478,
0.3318581581,
-0.527271688,
0.4199360311,
-0.3410362303,
0.0644553602,
0.1167941168,
0.4899347425,
0.6967258453,
0.0920721591,
0.5142550468,
0.1484335214,
1.0445551872,
0.1029883325,
1.0353727341,
-0.1740235537,
0.1425574869,
0.9140155911,
-0.4438149035,
0.9262911081,
0.3711882532,
-0.5053039193,
0.4845726788,
0.5078231096,
0.1830218881,
0.0903572068,
0.4289243817,
-0.123939991,
-0.0261654556,
-0.01608661,
-0.0421046056,
0.5643926859,
0.3406352401,
0.0343824066,
0.3270805776,
0.3622555435,
0.2851705253,
-0.1471197903,
-0.1932478249,
0.6611021757,
0.3218283653,
-0.3425659239,
0.200235799,
-0.0778647438,
0.8597791791,
-0.7855318785,
0.1549601555,
-0.3326045871,
0.2955290675,
-0.1581376195,
-0.8804112673,
0.3008884788,
0.0265925247,
-0.0614813454,
0.1052544937,
0.8213856816,
-0.1968406737,
-0.7443848848,
0.477519244,
0.4677856863,
0.3928294182,
0.0958930925,
-0.5207505822,
0.1359798908,
-0.1903037578,
-0.4945642352,
0.3240405917,
0.2334173769,
-0.1446873397,
1.1037459373,
0.8881688714,
-0.0092993826,
-0.3703731894,
0.2939003408,
0.621481061,
-0.8335098028,
-0.3839121163,
-1.0781471729,
0.1865608841,
0.2577672899,
-0.1586952657,
0.7561386824,
0.6465247273,
0.4451552331,
-0.0548048615,
0.8298205733,
0.0795851946,
0.2643441856,
-0.3474977314,
0.361810416,
-0.3412187696,
0.2013118267,
-0.5522860885,
-1.0634404421,
-0.3681485057,
0.5746814609,
-0.2122651637,
0.0851849765,
0.4696177244,
1.1632671356,
-0.3462363482,
0.3468138576,
0.3981329501,
0.3482013047,
0.3517208993,
0.1533352882,
1.0520241261,
0.0944200531,
0.5768620968,
-0.0329015963,
-0.2064549923,
-0.2309920341,
-0.9869694114,
-1.021119833,
-0.1999726444,
-0.3659457564,
-0.1554727107,
0.333981514,
1.1347095966,
0.5928402543,
-0.6390094161,
-0.5143979788,
-0.0194609221,
-0.3409101963,
-0.4028677642,
-0.2245509923,
-0.1182960719,
-0.225496456,
-0.5649802089,
0.2562868595,
0.3056318462,
0.0940503851,
-0.5615656376,
-0.4266147316,
0.1579731256,
0.3892678022,
0.7565336823,
0.2267649621,
-0.4869946241,
-0.303190589,
0.0094149532,
0.0708791539,
0.1382043213,
0.8542878032,
-0.7956481576,
-0.0027363836,
0.2106594592,
0.2852720022,
0.7858772278,
0.027446188,
0.7012627125,
-0.5818800926,
0.0868971944,
0.0932048485,
0.3226568997,
0.3689776063,
-0.2525820136,
0.5565965176,
-0.2393421829,
-0.7330133319,
-0.9050362706,
0.4137664437,
-1.1437350512,
-0.3258445263,
1.4209604263,
0.1790799499,
-0.3937455714,
-0.0282466263,
-0.8789636493,
0.0849999636,
-0.7903587818,
0.6694901586,
0.8246901035,
-0.3105848432,
-0.2469379604,
-1.122431159,
0.2139606774,
-0.0062801749,
-0.8606499434,
0.2349687964,
0.2635934055,
0.4799710214,
-0.0129163135,
0.5355266929,
-0.2381638438,
0.0290232152,
-0.2458832711,
0.4012433887,
-0.3207514584,
-0.0964115039,
-0.2843500972,
-0.2488238215,
0.0377730392,
-0.155611679
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07490v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07490v1
|
Strategic Data Ordering: Enhancing Large Language Model Performance through Curriculum Learning
| 2024-05-13T06:09:10 | 2024-05-13T06:09:10 |
Jisu Kim, Juhwan Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The rapid advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs) has improved text
understanding and generation but poses challenges in computational resources.
This study proposes a curriculum learning-inspired, data-centric training
strategy that begins with simpler tasks and progresses to more complex ones,
using criteria such as prompt length, attention scores, and loss values to
structure the training data. Experiments with Mistral-7B (Jiang et al., 2023)
and Gemma-7B (Team et al., 2024) models demonstrate that curriculum learning
slightly improves performance compared to traditional random data shuffling.
Notably, we observed that sorting data based on our proposed attention criteria
generally led to better performance. This approach offers a sustainable method
to enhance LLM performance without increasing model size or dataset volume,
addressing scalability challenges in LLM training.
|
[
-0.2341811359,
-0.6575487852,
0.5529908538,
0.0774473399,
-0.2217451334,
0.3007130027,
-0.3459501863,
-0.2494873255,
-0.0739635006,
0.7581217289,
-0.5985069871,
-0.7278493643,
-0.7043498158,
-0.179770723,
-0.4359726608,
0.8778788447,
0.3076052368,
0.4156514704,
-0.2038832307,
-0.1682095081,
-0.5497117043,
-0.6103352904,
-0.9806674719,
-0.3827368915,
0.7613782287,
0.7772077918,
0.6543604136,
1.4150384665,
0.6177402139,
0.316673249,
-0.0188056231,
0.2484417558,
-0.9379190207,
0.3101466894,
-0.1496158391,
-0.6752144694,
-0.4489357769,
-0.0623186901,
0.6222902536,
0.9374676943,
-0.3780325055,
0.1998816133,
-0.0517017804,
1.0193074942,
-0.4794282019,
0.4611013532,
-0.6797618866,
-0.005017519,
-0.4486452937,
-0.3174330592,
-0.778881371,
-0.2407286316,
0.3297877312,
-0.4431525171,
0.0840665773,
0.3187550902,
0.5548764467,
0.0783885866,
-0.276068598,
-0.3486959934,
-0.6703003049,
1.1140393019,
-0.2006411105,
0.5862614512,
0.1922372729,
0.3447830379,
-0.1107202843,
-0.6352004409,
-0.130322665,
0.1953434497,
0.445808053,
0.2315737754,
0.3051178455,
0.0277706049,
0.2335767001,
0.2523744106,
-0.8183359504,
0.5032007098,
-0.5020433664,
0.3006673455,
0.6249428988,
0.5532595515,
0.0310779698,
0.1698447615,
-0.1615139842,
-0.4236869812,
-0.97184515,
-0.0089240083,
0.2615062892,
0.4944690764,
-0.0226253178,
0.4945881069,
-0.3909368515,
0.6139121056,
0.0682451874,
-0.2094582915,
0.228810817,
-0.1691402644,
-0.2871549428,
0.2701739967,
0.3857592344,
0.1390085369,
0.1779565215,
-0.1837030947,
-0.3225613236,
-0.0786124989,
0.5413433313,
-0.8076494932,
-0.4049956203,
-0.0183864813,
-0.3281235099,
-0.4446228147,
-0.1560576111,
-0.8249571919,
-0.3068192303,
-0.8353612423,
0.1965834796,
-0.5201222897,
0.2632987499,
0.3097263277,
0.4076954722,
0.3110410571,
0.5446996689,
-1.2686642408,
0.3430683911,
0.8365941644,
0.6603232622,
-0.5792407393,
-0.031564083,
-0.3700011075,
0.1605435163,
-0.4914596677,
0.6498979926,
-0.6760058403,
-0.1769135296,
-0.0507434905,
-0.2569949627,
-0.0484947152,
-0.625115335,
0.4109646678,
-0.9071490765,
0.3257004917,
-0.305245012,
-0.5663577914,
-0.3441953659,
0.0079795588,
-0.7298641205,
1.0920780897,
-0.1420617551,
-0.4872095287,
0.5118246675,
-0.2702017725,
-0.4487238228,
0.1393609494,
-0.3081811368,
-0.5401002765,
-0.1396475732,
0.2863930166,
0.8402583003,
-0.5546102524,
0.3473043442,
-0.2107072026,
-0.3524811864,
0.0239111278,
-0.4276881218,
0.7544260621,
0.3711208403,
-0.2058804184,
0.0619308911,
-0.8137498498,
0.1630159616,
0.3268703222,
-0.4588379562,
-0.2786841094,
0.229069382,
-0.0319471247,
0.2117744684,
0.0904485062,
-0.0000195155,
0.3190218806,
-0.5119949579,
0.1413692832,
0.8789479136,
-0.1363841444,
0.7950363755,
-0.5988439918,
0.3796069622,
0.0757834539,
0.0541857854,
-0.0832974687,
-0.4088393152,
-0.9708211422,
-0.2136657536,
0.0728577822,
0.5411582589,
-0.7359137535,
0.1661292017,
-0.5176810622,
-0.6317207217,
-0.4563857615,
0.4191070795,
0.3204374909,
0.3398689032,
0.4255420864,
-0.5273963213,
-0.4960553348,
-0.710812211,
0.1373327225,
-0.1118043438,
0.2166267186,
0.2910285592,
0.0913484991,
-0.116720818,
0.6042400002,
-0.7673766613,
0.0026087801,
-0.7170638442,
0.0955700055,
0.353564024,
0.2680924237,
0.3952850997,
-0.7745578885,
-0.342412591,
-0.0920275375,
-0.5243761539,
-0.0702883899,
-0.1656951159,
-0.2657471895,
0.2220380604,
0.4956204593,
-0.4150807261,
0.0461552218,
0.267496258,
0.333976388,
0.4716880023,
-0.0099887429,
-0.0176229458,
-1.0216463804,
-0.3062314093,
-0.2355829328,
0.0402789786,
-0.6468075514,
0.0094707878,
0.0560389198,
-0.0152144944,
-0.345150888,
0.3655481339,
-0.4022413194,
0.0243160315,
-0.0658927336,
0.02175574,
-0.1728403717,
0.4722583294,
0.2721551955,
0.7190466523,
0.6898223162,
-0.7026250362,
0.1604920328,
0.1412408203,
-0.6479541659,
0.4203161299,
-0.3389635086,
0.0555310249,
-0.3337408304,
-0.0197830182,
-0.9906902313,
-0.2361337692,
-0.1320156604,
-0.209994927,
0.6513165236,
0.1363044679,
-0.5349709392,
-0.1612916142,
-0.2126128376,
0.4403158426,
0.4366913736,
-0.571462512,
0.1534402966,
0.393035382,
-0.3210829198,
-0.4402738512,
-0.5256071091,
-0.0486123227,
-0.5276379585,
-0.4396351278,
0.3439670205,
-0.1934871525,
-0.2002284378,
-0.5947572589,
0.0050211116,
-0.1935417503,
0.154100284,
0.1966549158,
0.3178445399,
-0.3178075254,
0.2787681222,
-0.0405478328,
-0.0604452007,
0.0758214071,
-0.3768928945,
0.5818685889,
0.3387933671,
-0.0438656397,
-0.1382446438,
0.1972311139,
0.7107501626,
-0.2833909988,
0.9024125934,
0.1978942305,
-0.1288983375,
-0.6711620092,
-0.5574550629,
-0.1654925942,
-0.563197732,
0.498573035,
-0.1254422963,
-0.8254846931,
0.2522739768,
-0.1017376557,
0.3194906116,
-0.0075283018,
0.767242372,
-0.0441020876,
1.1903208494,
0.7059381008,
-0.3790541291,
0.8671352267,
-0.2324079871,
0.1487200856,
-0.4113084674,
-0.3570384383,
-0.3337551653,
-0.1936302781,
-0.5328090787,
-0.5872853398,
0.2163746506,
-0.1753973961,
-0.6181998253,
0.2318796366,
-0.4579868913,
0.5648844242,
0.3998661339,
0.2426102906,
0.2204868495,
0.3909346759,
-0.1946841627,
-0.1207551211,
-1.0107871294,
-0.4184713066,
1.3227649927,
0.2834220231,
1.0329968929,
0.1292592138,
0.8711313605,
-0.1695327163,
0.3007059097,
-0.826919198,
0.7907611132,
-0.1771623492,
-0.3077018857,
-0.3141815662,
-0.5713885427,
-1.0939985514,
0.1544356942,
-0.1309732497,
-0.6117002368,
-0.1764868498,
-0.3001073301,
-0.2088761032,
-0.0752413794,
-0.6358215213,
0.4924438,
-0.3830460608,
-0.5026472211,
-0.3959878683,
-0.555362463,
0.2989537716,
-0.2017555088,
0.1495989561,
0.126225844,
0.0531153716,
0.9279733896,
-0.0510341786,
0.6615058184,
0.2038075775,
0.1046364829,
0.2599091232,
0.2019166797,
0.4199511111,
-0.0674844235,
-0.2493115515,
-0.1401436776,
-0.5043449998,
-0.3985098898,
-0.5381476283,
0.7123569846,
-0.8929644227,
-0.724678278,
-0.2824885249,
-0.8111191392,
-0.3336479068,
0.2195787132,
0.1227529496,
0.3574599922,
0.0566662923,
0.4641839862,
1.015691638,
-0.0709042847,
0.2951856554,
0.5152291059,
-0.0285075977,
-0.3520028293,
0.9343727827,
0.5389557481,
0.4521746337,
0.6182900667,
-0.0548878685,
-0.2605229616,
-0.8863431215,
-0.2402058989,
0.1877882481,
-0.8041732311,
-0.1182638258,
-0.6970362067,
-0.2655223906,
-0.30526492,
-0.3405058682,
-0.4799675345,
-0.2777335048,
-0.3804388046,
-0.153605029,
0.2710415423,
0.8842557669,
0.5393524766,
0.459901005,
-0.5165051818,
-0.1183981597,
0.0612686872,
0.2473762184,
0.2914000154,
-0.6162090302,
-0.5665571094,
-0.1535012275,
-0.4989596307,
-0.466003418,
0.4831350148,
-0.0488592684,
0.462397337,
0.4685486257,
-0.1730358005,
0.9014357924,
-0.7051458359,
0.3946256638,
0.0088943401,
-0.6126890182,
0.4905481637,
-0.4362738132,
0.4575874209,
0.6067399383,
0.5504905581,
-0.169525668,
-0.3347585201,
-0.5442264676,
-1.0393937826,
0.9552831054,
0.0703944713,
-0.0475267135,
0.1226302609,
0.4699413776,
0.0281623434,
0.2453191131,
-0.5522481799,
-0.2967545986,
0.3222836554,
-0.4030837715,
-0.234995082,
-0.1238411069,
0.1818250567,
-0.3326708674,
0.675050199,
-0.1450565606,
0.1267528683,
-0.4296700954,
-0.0137736369,
0.0825848132,
0.065131031,
0.3259678185,
0.6573314667,
-0.0342232846,
0.0131423287,
0.2494519055,
-0.6591852903,
0.1223065481,
-0.3085509837,
-0.0911544934,
-0.4609681964,
0.3972246945,
0.5048945546,
0.5224491358,
-0.6856692433,
0.2396085262,
0.1122235507,
-0.0443662032,
0.0531752929,
0.4269627035,
0.2260098904,
0.3566969931,
0.222105816,
-0.3997875452,
0.0813712627,
-0.442596525,
0.4239242971,
0.2226223499,
-0.1204613894,
0.0024943487,
0.513815403,
-0.2570402622,
0.0214627944,
0.8102530241,
0.1116267219,
-0.2778681815,
0.804176271,
0.6522447467,
0.4990035594,
-0.4846459329,
0.2459022403,
0.3284838796,
0.2626419961,
-0.5393718481,
0.2947632372,
0.0187939145,
-0.6139478683,
-0.2268939018,
-0.6367222667,
-0.506912291,
0.1312028915,
-0.8227629066,
0.6332947612,
-0.7005923986,
0.1101741791,
0.089617461,
0.2158915699,
-0.7075672746,
0.4396364987,
0.3084062636,
0.7510399222,
-0.5828864574,
1.092420578,
0.5121759772,
-0.0787700862,
-0.8415287137,
-0.2023480088,
0.1519272774,
-0.8596405983,
0.8776039481,
0.3153336644,
0.1526337415,
0.1730314642,
-0.5358442068,
-1.2109296322,
1.314891696,
0.3070494533,
-0.7841816545,
0.03211613,
0.2599220872,
0.5306681395,
-0.5146470666,
0.2103210837,
0.2926043868,
0.0332314894,
0.4499203563,
-0.2586440146,
-0.1737106442,
0.1715340763,
0.0042679817,
0.2194107175,
-0.7452278733,
0.7759354711,
-0.2363125235,
-0.3169485033,
-0.0304867793,
0.8562248349,
0.2493211329,
0.2607614398,
0.1757601649,
0.584502995,
0.9127515554,
-0.0650745705,
0.7934520841,
-0.1569237709,
0.357596159,
1.2737779617,
-0.687117517,
0.8722339869,
0.2744189501,
-0.1027087644,
0.3024699092,
0.9327725172,
-0.0211573206,
0.7415902019,
0.2839787602,
-0.033689145,
-0.3484463096,
-0.061060831,
-0.0039803986,
0.5022401214,
0.5771322846,
-0.3719550967,
-0.3766241968,
-0.0466583855,
-0.0558077469,
-0.0243966524,
-0.3686188161,
0.7117157578,
0.050295949,
-0.5637794733,
0.5704098344,
0.0115496442,
0.2439510971,
-0.5609539747,
-0.0149250729,
-0.1059611887,
0.253172189,
0.0124812992,
-0.7941485047,
0.036309734,
-0.0365011729,
-0.4511197209,
-0.5813297033,
0.1400117278,
-0.6230983734,
-0.4722868204,
0.3820978999,
0.4410307407,
-0.0426040031,
0.3575141132,
-0.7411909699,
0.1725535989,
-0.1684077233,
-0.5531324148,
0.6922528744,
0.4844758213,
-0.3015605509,
0.9302779436,
0.6553719044,
-0.0223656632,
0.0527152158,
0.0257202275,
0.9731419683,
-0.4779488146,
-0.5033813119,
-0.8316934705,
0.1006231382,
0.0465039574,
-0.0333463699,
0.7611215711,
0.7332075238,
0.9674477577,
0.110380441,
0.3866503537,
0.3572283387,
0.3080213964,
-0.6967583299,
0.631834507,
-0.2640489638,
0.5289068222,
-0.1518646032,
-1.0507034063,
-0.494728744,
0.4655807912,
-0.7086348534,
0.0964374542,
0.6574237347,
0.9506534338,
-0.0669561848,
0.0611527972,
0.3625498116,
0.2547205687,
0.2782307863,
0.8097215295,
0.4604820609,
-0.1628881246,
0.3045834303,
-0.2191141099,
-0.1927872151,
-0.2200713009,
-0.45726192,
-1.1323634386,
-0.5339776278,
-0.163006261,
-0.165211305,
0.2430092841,
1.1035716534,
0.7423743606,
-0.7312242985,
-0.5350559354,
-0.1813829392,
0.1384769976,
-0.0863722041,
-0.2401127815,
0.4219945073,
-0.5318718553,
-0.8073120713,
0.4177742004,
0.3629196584,
-0.0673786998,
-0.0615557432,
-0.0093732076,
-0.2428329587,
0.2503580749,
0.6906235218,
-0.0996734723,
-0.4715210199,
-0.0990624577,
0.1050847322,
-0.5022240281,
0.0491616763,
0.7175247073,
-0.6915400028,
0.4323091507,
0.4985781014,
0.9859566092,
0.4141609669,
-0.1380757391,
0.4119713306,
-0.475458324,
0.0106902327,
0.1709265262,
0.1372166276,
0.0756213591,
-0.5768125653,
0.4660750926,
0.1912610531,
-0.6066163778,
-0.6851039529,
0.0837059319,
-1.1545031071,
-0.1061078012,
1.0492255688,
0.0174744669,
-0.2650375664,
-0.1260442436,
-0.1722561419,
0.1411581337,
-0.397952944,
0.9511077404,
0.8461591601,
-0.0140046068,
-0.137594074,
-0.839248836,
0.3196882904,
0.6944876313,
-0.7847366333,
0.3078881502,
0.351228565,
0.1578400135,
-0.1030640155,
0.3316633999,
-0.1703194231,
0.1792171001,
-0.3690071106,
-0.3025448918,
0.1805015802,
-0.9050606489,
-0.3773748875,
0.2713699341,
-0.0193055887,
0.0958439037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07468v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07468v1
|
Evaluating large language models in medical applications: a survey
| 2024-05-13T05:08:33 | 2024-05-13T05:08:33 |
Xiaolan Chen, Jiayang Xiang, Shanfu Lu, Yexin Liu, Mingguang He, Danli Shi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have emerged as powerful tools with
transformative potential across numerous domains, including healthcare and
medicine. In the medical domain, LLMs hold promise for tasks ranging from
clinical decision support to patient education. However, evaluating the
performance of LLMs in medical contexts presents unique challenges due to the
complex and critical nature of medical information. This paper provides a
comprehensive overview of the landscape of medical LLM evaluation, synthesizing
insights from existing studies and highlighting evaluation data sources, task
scenarios, and evaluation methods. Additionally, it identifies key challenges
and opportunities in medical LLM evaluation, emphasizing the need for continued
research and innovation to ensure the responsible integration of LLMs into
clinical practice.
|
[
-0.0281441268,
-0.748252213,
1.0726771355,
0.1959367394,
-0.1791184247,
0.1878048927,
-0.5189521313,
-0.6195179224,
-0.087848641,
0.6339972615,
-0.4665327668,
-0.5080145001,
-1.0834879875,
0.1794711798,
-0.3716287017,
0.6608114839,
-0.163663134,
0.7107536793,
-0.5568216443,
-0.2546956539,
-0.5445600748,
-0.8235629201,
-0.7311745882,
-0.6721304655,
0.3677760661,
0.0413654298,
0.5525560975,
0.4372322559,
0.9448011518,
0.3680759668,
-0.182583794,
0.1140234694,
-0.4538098276,
0.2762686312,
-0.2577700913,
-0.3104267418,
-0.3683649898,
0.0725250766,
0.9408079386,
1.2581868172,
-0.2153226137,
0.0914032012,
-0.1308845729,
0.661585331,
-0.3989470601,
0.0662534162,
-0.3630681336,
0.0743587539,
-0.2479344457,
-0.1922807992,
-0.3017345965,
-0.4269993007,
0.4939433634,
-0.0490949452,
-0.3657958508,
-0.0583598353,
0.5366668701,
0.0779653564,
-0.6454889774,
-0.6547403932,
-0.8629062176,
0.8585675955,
-0.7211616635,
0.5513965487,
-0.035348434,
0.5216273069,
-0.5019086599,
-0.7497816086,
-0.2538024187,
-0.4799659252,
0.3113548458,
-0.0791982189,
-0.201766938,
0.0684103593,
0.0134751108,
0.6385480165,
-0.4277902842,
0.6867781281,
-0.326351136,
0.0687301531,
0.6391593814,
0.8257498741,
0.5883848071,
-0.1237970367,
-0.1368851215,
0.2794566154,
-0.7345464826,
-0.3343814015,
-0.1507276446,
0.070964098,
-0.1901665926,
0.7321952581,
0.199706465,
0.7579174042,
-0.4123916924,
-0.4908799529,
0.1756025553,
-0.1862646639,
-0.4935795069,
-0.3736921549,
0.9919605255,
0.3961232901,
-0.0265889727,
-0.1502186656,
-0.2312749028,
-0.0704702735,
0.2226776779,
-0.7347813845,
0.2650794685,
0.3870680332,
-0.7263278961,
-0.1113738269,
-0.3044310212,
-0.7434420586,
-0.9588599205,
-0.3328255415,
0.2168032676,
-0.2517973185,
-0.25149405,
0.419095993,
0.1365044713,
0.303163141,
0.5532456636,
-0.6077472568,
0.4310085773,
0.917742908,
0.775788784,
-0.4482367039,
0.0149048157,
-0.1034506783,
-0.1292177588,
-0.441704303,
0.5438892245,
-0.6682235599,
-0.6584922075,
0.2392171323,
0.0880265087,
-0.27770105,
-0.9744284749,
0.5708479881,
-0.3189505637,
-0.0724002272,
-0.1007609144,
-0.683201015,
-0.0180777274,
0.415094763,
-0.6663916707,
0.5983503461,
0.2055132836,
-0.4002374709,
0.2031609565,
-0.6714624166,
-0.5459295511,
0.3039591908,
-0.424063623,
-0.3951743841,
0.3739236891,
-0.0789576992,
0.5649936199,
-1.0697619915,
0.4019376338,
-0.1985332817,
-0.2348168492,
0.5049304962,
-0.3876148164,
0.6695782542,
0.3115735352,
-0.0299183,
0.3574978113,
-0.5946551561,
-0.0740149766,
0.272610724,
-0.5007598996,
-0.2612114251,
0.1426062137,
0.2739051878,
0.1973349452,
0.223647967,
-0.3365879953,
0.302747339,
-0.4407574534,
0.6000211835,
0.3914423883,
0.081533514,
0.1177563667,
-0.2316619754,
0.9602834582,
-0.2370175868,
0.3029557168,
-0.0023537611,
-0.4309597909,
-0.2927744091,
-0.3889468312,
0.3124841154,
0.3897182941,
-0.4593858123,
0.1673578173,
-0.3650705814,
-0.7678442001,
-0.7278274894,
0.1883451194,
0.286511004,
0.2995889187,
-0.0611977205,
-0.1067595258,
-0.4450129569,
-0.9991268516,
-0.2809275985,
-0.0181499291,
0.0232012514,
0.5845188498,
0.5301607847,
-0.7991925478,
0.5000654459,
-0.2479228526,
-0.2615145445,
-0.5971816182,
-0.1557362676,
0.3587810099,
0.288860023,
0.4110139906,
-0.6680061817,
-0.1155225337,
0.2441288233,
-0.8375837803,
-0.2011132836,
-0.0398171172,
0.3591444492,
-0.0918825939,
0.4244759083,
-0.5722357035,
-0.107888639,
0.8661704063,
-0.1850707829,
0.6194448471,
-0.2391225845,
0.34171772,
-0.7539615631,
0.2058481872,
0.0719273314,
-0.2399284393,
-0.4725175202,
0.1352161616,
-0.0410039276,
-0.0448761061,
-0.4230165482,
0.8799919486,
-0.5792157054,
-0.1045295894,
-0.3141282797,
0.2511153519,
-0.2826146781,
-0.4442435801,
-0.2134495527,
0.4358770847,
0.586577177,
-0.3484134674,
0.5484790206,
0.1056672409,
-0.8038344979,
0.3526448607,
-0.6907646656,
-0.0547269769,
-0.024710672,
0.2131590545,
-0.8000891805,
-0.3209815919,
0.0334885716,
-0.0659479871,
0.476552397,
-0.0588313267,
-0.6779736876,
-0.6554150581,
-0.1701637506,
0.5521873236,
0.4903137684,
-0.2310426384,
0.3566813767,
0.6722105145,
-0.2865895629,
-0.3673601151,
-0.44299528,
0.4872209728,
-0.2059294581,
-0.5347021222,
0.0151876183,
-0.024461912,
-0.6005511284,
-0.2630217671,
-0.0280930903,
0.0581717417,
0.2539570928,
0.4103142619,
0.5103062987,
-0.1747205108,
0.1146408096,
-0.0520051718,
0.0871561393,
0.304305315,
-0.0142908553,
0.450804472,
-0.0669195279,
-0.5775413513,
-0.2220371962,
0.2686905265,
0.9080986977,
-0.0074771955,
0.6688981056,
0.2125883102,
-0.6228482127,
0.0828183591,
-0.7978177667,
0.0817977339,
-0.3520195484,
0.8235182166,
-0.10789904,
-1.1006132364,
0.3482730389,
-0.5198253393,
-0.0727426708,
0.5061122775,
1.1143137217,
0.0641086921,
1.0146548748,
0.4784533978,
0.0738735422,
0.031016225,
-0.0555297621,
0.2156530172,
-0.9252030253,
-0.5683134794,
-0.3863787055,
-0.0379406847,
-0.4500572681,
-0.595384419,
0.6832799911,
-0.1181433573,
0.1599495858,
-0.2552966177,
-0.2558141649,
0.1799363494,
-0.2618527114,
0.0811333582,
0.3671013713,
-0.310995698,
-0.0864251554,
-0.0951210856,
-0.5616322756,
-0.8050191402,
1.0884170532,
0.9043191671,
0.917612493,
0.0401393324,
0.2918929458,
0.217748493,
0.6865108013,
-1.1245231628,
0.547773838,
-0.4091399908,
-0.5845043063,
-0.322000742,
-0.380708307,
-1.0813945532,
0.3010313213,
-0.3011371195,
-0.763643682,
-0.3446241021,
-0.2639128268,
-0.3308564126,
0.1167761758,
-0.5248622894,
0.8190619946,
-0.4150707722,
-0.1178077385,
-0.225160405,
-0.4502134323,
0.5286836028,
-0.439255923,
0.4853096008,
-0.2059625685,
-0.1281000227,
0.7854523659,
-0.2398109883,
0.6953316927,
0.0302155837,
-0.3279196918,
0.0501862764,
-0.0570452027,
0.0398525745,
-0.0077123172,
-0.1301885098,
0.319907546,
0.3042910397,
-0.1056223437,
-0.5062270761,
0.9694858193,
-0.5262980461,
-0.750448525,
-0.4150402844,
-0.6140198112,
-0.6440016031,
0.0885437056,
-0.0424489304,
0.3328776062,
-0.4343193471,
0.1875482351,
0.438542217,
-0.6941229105,
0.1647477895,
0.5350571275,
-0.5259079933,
-0.206889987,
0.5408607721,
-0.0357984751,
0.230633378,
0.0945807025,
0.2925533056,
-0.431405127,
-1.1645519733,
-0.4653579295,
0.5141605735,
-0.7740594745,
0.0832915008,
-0.557684958,
-0.2743745148,
-0.1825332642,
-0.001850616,
-0.412409991,
-0.0507143103,
-0.1393549591,
0.1056700647,
0.0804132819,
1.2964012623,
0.3616941869,
0.2124797702,
-0.9381341338,
0.1357171983,
-0.0275936946,
0.6644425988,
0.0574780405,
-0.3578981757,
-0.2451172322,
-0.3321792185,
-0.0901528224,
-0.7150387764,
0.2854239643,
-0.1004130691,
0.7781875134,
0.4205986857,
-0.5321943164,
0.5583854914,
-0.9031956196,
0.8503492475,
0.4217041433,
-0.6461153626,
0.2643178105,
-0.2546856403,
0.2408108264,
0.3744568229,
0.5918505788,
-0.629407227,
-0.215343371,
-0.0783944726,
-0.8271297812,
0.2236884832,
-0.0285514593,
0.2630059123,
-0.0729228258,
0.4308099747,
0.1861598343,
0.078362681,
-0.4790207148,
-0.1118296981,
0.7013922334,
-0.2352345586,
-0.1169424802,
-0.4194099009,
-0.1714039594,
-0.178796038,
0.2149011493,
0.168311879,
0.0874322355,
0.1389509737,
-0.1056438237,
-0.1473658979,
0.5376842022,
0.6424471736,
0.9948509336,
0.0609967336,
-0.0832483545,
0.1889341176,
-0.5087883472,
0.1209216639,
-0.0838640481,
0.3186452091,
-0.035965126,
0.6424667835,
0.5800509453,
0.382514298,
-1.216711998,
0.6502630115,
-0.0032414885,
-0.0906039849,
-0.2396616638,
-0.1129657701,
0.3196972013,
0.3011033535,
0.2980511487,
-0.4346514642,
0.2420902699,
-0.7458328009,
-0.0838469043,
0.6978935599,
-0.3796686232,
-0.1610158682,
0.540058136,
-0.0043314719,
-0.2385034114,
0.3934498429,
0.3493332863,
-0.3697410524,
0.5700082779,
0.6649448276,
0.7058879733,
-0.34199664,
-0.2961285114,
0.0066975802,
0.2738796175,
-0.0737764314,
0.3457597792,
0.5682516694,
-0.4450680614,
-0.6282078028,
-0.7625203133,
-0.5715488791,
0.5447252393,
-0.3365875483,
0.3464584351,
-0.4551614523,
-0.4208704829,
0.1845840514,
-0.2271404713,
-0.707324028,
0.3549764454,
0.3204222918,
0.8243935108,
-0.4870457947,
0.7622430921,
0.8995329142,
0.0219205879,
-0.3150802553,
-0.3401957154,
0.2044920176,
-0.8955786824,
0.7544574738,
0.0321647264,
-0.0692494437,
-0.5250191092,
-0.3442121446,
-0.4540486038,
0.7752563953,
0.4000744224,
-0.7780201435,
-0.2838188112,
0.3029077351,
0.804448843,
-0.6505518556,
0.3244004846,
0.7550022006,
0.4845142365,
-0.0524545237,
-1.2592865229,
0.1214841381,
-0.1753435731,
0.1640717089,
0.1504200697,
-0.4687783122,
0.5209911466,
-0.284781754,
-0.0925285146,
0.261376828,
0.0406489372,
0.3075133264,
0.257070601,
0.3359657824,
0.1876941472,
0.5181730986,
-0.0307597667,
1.291302681,
-0.2219414413,
0.3463012576,
0.7452326417,
-0.6512430906,
0.7264114618,
0.5342929959,
-0.4391465485,
0.1880813241,
0.6804821491,
-0.0974105448,
-0.0968655422,
0.6220853925,
-0.3782262802,
-0.2352775782,
-0.2356959432,
-0.3013892472,
0.5497445464,
0.8240240216,
-0.6723356843,
-0.0938151181,
0.1894576102,
-0.030549407,
0.1175586209,
-0.440197885,
0.6504296064,
0.3566229939,
-0.3735868633,
0.4455778301,
0.1060922295,
0.3618094623,
-0.6355909705,
-0.2149841934,
0.2859677672,
0.0962891802,
-0.3180399537,
-0.6251272559,
0.3137712479,
0.0648954436,
-0.0679576248,
0.014445222,
0.6424984932,
-0.1063203216,
-0.4942791462,
0.5308791399,
0.5885742307,
0.2700331211,
0.2091781646,
-0.5748684406,
0.6192678213,
-0.3347585201,
-0.3142639697,
0.4883721471,
0.4047270417,
-0.0206658971,
0.9646673799,
0.4518824518,
0.442907989,
-0.1242697611,
0.3157219589,
0.7223903537,
-0.7868030071,
-0.0085825967,
-1.1566947699,
0.2138646841,
0.1676118225,
-0.2110396922,
0.654302597,
0.573237896,
0.2012059689,
-0.1988883466,
0.8036650419,
0.298784554,
0.5058587193,
-0.5221304297,
0.9311702251,
-0.5229312181,
0.4863853455,
-0.3448378444,
-0.5940807462,
-0.5191493034,
0.2621023953,
-0.4710428715,
0.1415412277,
0.7027139068,
0.1865769029,
0.2015101463,
-0.1381640136,
0.6378313303,
0.3848353624,
0.2959592044,
0.594647646,
1.1081490517,
-0.1762204617,
0.0388608426,
0.3058277965,
-0.4001594782,
-0.381082505,
-0.8598430157,
-0.943797946,
-0.3651025295,
-0.2712390423,
-0.2505987287,
-0.0460622087,
1.0744582415,
0.587043941,
-0.6790317297,
-0.4278010726,
0.555342555,
0.0209420174,
0.1089835167,
-0.1956848055,
0.310964942,
-0.0868187174,
-0.8163565993,
0.6206870079,
0.7407437563,
0.0059444872,
-0.5339801908,
-0.0462558381,
-0.0213379636,
0.1315691918,
0.8907058835,
0.0713281855,
-0.9383211732,
0.0068992283,
-0.1359703094,
-0.3930455744,
-0.0377441458,
1.0617545843,
-0.5054121017,
0.4681127071,
-0.0104489401,
1.1465461254,
0.1986305118,
-0.4807579219,
0.7069756389,
0.0713901445,
-0.1867529154,
0.4320721924,
0.6135808825,
0.3960587382,
-0.2216259986,
0.4637343884,
-0.0062000165,
-0.587048769,
-1.0524358749,
0.0036777526,
-1.0787357092,
-0.336971432,
1.301540494,
-0.1296072602,
-0.0299030673,
-0.2416396588,
-0.1682356,
0.0320053808,
0.2049650699,
0.5570446849,
0.8842747211,
-0.2630811036,
-0.0501860827,
-1.095697999,
0.330169946,
0.3991051316,
-0.8990916014,
0.0063450844,
0.5977461338,
0.4691482484,
-0.1585440189,
0.6578629017,
-0.7267541885,
0.1346809268,
-0.5257347822,
-0.2145213634,
0.2248423994,
-0.1044790745,
-0.7731451392,
0.2317383885,
0.510002017,
0.2326178551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07467v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07467v1
|
MCS-SQL: Leveraging Multiple Prompts and Multiple-Choice Selection For Text-to-SQL Generation
| 2024-05-13T04:59:32 | 2024-05-13T04:59:32 |
Dongjun Lee, Choongwon Park, Jaehyuk Kim, Heesoo Park
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have enabled in-context
learning (ICL)-based methods that significantly outperform fine-tuning
approaches for text-to-SQL tasks. However, their performance is still
considerably lower than that of human experts on benchmarks that include
complex schemas and queries, such as BIRD. This study considers the sensitivity
of LLMs to the prompts and introduces a novel approach that leverages multiple
prompts to explore a broader search space for possible answers and effectively
aggregate them. Specifically, we robustly refine the database schema through
schema linking using multiple prompts. Thereafter, we generate various
candidate SQL queries based on the refined schema and diverse prompts. Finally,
the candidate queries are filtered based on their confidence scores, and the
optimal query is obtained through a multiple-choice selection that is presented
to the LLM. When evaluated on the BIRD and Spider benchmarks, the proposed
method achieved execution accuracies of 65.5\% and 89.6\%, respectively,
significantly outperforming previous ICL-based methods. Moreover, we
established a new SOTA performance on the BIRD in terms of both the accuracy
and efficiency of the generated queries.
|
[
-0.6005444527,
-0.8525567651,
0.6948316693,
0.05477532,
-0.3203258216,
0.0443221666,
-0.2596641779,
-0.0221165102,
0.0501327179,
0.5421252847,
-0.9272131324,
-0.5425677896,
-0.2031669319,
0.7796661854,
-0.0103115868,
0.8654990196,
0.4408196509,
0.0735814646,
-0.411208272,
-0.060702201,
-0.3336003721,
-0.5678215027,
-0.6764239073,
0.3795449138,
0.5929828286,
0.8330423832,
0.2363481522,
0.3933887482,
0.4154730439,
0.1647966206,
-0.1374654174,
0.7485371232,
-0.284601897,
0.6208811402,
-0.5158743262,
-0.2431279421,
-0.0212164372,
-0.4410983324,
0.7248873115,
0.5213795304,
-0.174394235,
0.2654274702,
0.1370853931,
0.7923855186,
-0.788865447,
-0.110954158,
-1.2493813038,
-0.0811886117,
-0.3171238005,
-0.5594481826,
-0.7953744531,
-0.1248112693,
-0.0667417794,
-0.4773503542,
0.1280008554,
0.3794082999,
0.4236589372,
0.0794333592,
-0.9294233918,
-0.7028464079,
-0.1457001865,
0.8902304769,
-0.4197636843,
0.3906462193,
0.0907077044,
0.5707719326,
-0.4371124208,
-0.5606518388,
-0.5060840249,
-0.5290833116,
-0.0235767197,
-0.0632675737,
0.4274794757,
-0.2270081341,
0.3450521529,
-0.1108380333,
-0.4509277046,
-0.0196938366,
-0.0756863728,
-0.0720800534,
0.6185398102,
0.3377313614,
0.110918574,
-0.3444179296,
-0.4791654348,
0.0684217438,
-0.8490049839,
0.1411944926,
0.1586479843,
1.1536560059,
0.446808368,
1.0343631506,
-0.3226526082,
0.9635034204,
0.0719148219,
-0.2203357518,
-0.1213251129,
-0.4959858358,
-0.0009345415,
0.0214639157,
0.9385594726,
0.2930123806,
0.0082043298,
-0.0696840659,
-0.0210016798,
-0.0367851593,
0.1186559424,
-0.6825347543,
0.3249022663,
0.2648202479,
-0.2501782179,
-0.2355147451,
-0.0929182693,
-0.7975062132,
-0.4506678581,
-0.3065593243,
-0.0410617813,
-0.4504937232,
-0.0642881617,
-0.3591074646,
-0.016666228,
0.0188140981,
0.2121444494,
-0.8733631372,
0.2219820917,
0.2588110268,
0.7581548691,
-0.4780483246,
-0.2670632303,
-0.7859270573,
0.5804260969,
-0.332819432,
0.9227920771,
-0.7358755469,
-0.588776648,
-0.1888427138,
-0.208465293,
-0.1879053116,
-0.4043198824,
0.3793721795,
-0.475782007,
0.1034447476,
-0.7972128987,
-0.3520541787,
0.2494822443,
0.3099764884,
-0.4525589943,
1.2622840405,
0.0748443156,
-0.8043493629,
0.5322667956,
-0.7463491559,
-0.5692998171,
-0.090567708,
-0.5767769814,
-0.1812797785,
0.1284942627,
0.3822474182,
0.5707068443,
-0.5174996257,
0.2736794651,
-0.44472754,
-0.2984085977,
0.3035220504,
-0.1340331882,
0.6825327873,
0.465243727,
-0.1733395904,
0.0353760533,
-0.7684008479,
0.0760381296,
0.0307184886,
-0.5356853604,
-0.1135172099,
0.0880764201,
-0.208344385,
0.5674831271,
-0.041207511,
-0.4522013366,
0.2848979831,
-0.2704000175,
0.3059607148,
0.5301423669,
0.1732499897,
0.3111481667,
-0.163657099,
0.4953965545,
0.263756454,
-0.0837790295,
-0.357666254,
-0.2776494622,
-0.4141418934,
-0.2769892216,
-0.1527258009,
0.4695940614,
-1.0023816824,
0.2947722375,
-0.131101951,
-0.4463977814,
-0.1157861724,
-0.0847008899,
0.1907102168,
0.7155768275,
0.4849550128,
0.0289134979,
-0.4540744722,
-0.7073963881,
-0.6648725271,
-0.0289787222,
-0.017373981,
0.9726212025,
0.242610842,
0.1731952727,
1.1176067591,
-0.4972613156,
-0.2163340002,
-0.1048969626,
-0.4066735804,
0.1507419348,
0.3812924922,
0.5156655312,
-0.605001986,
-0.6808955669,
-0.0276764724,
-0.5807954669,
0.120315358,
-0.0670688152,
-0.1017054021,
0.4390710592,
0.6964690685,
-0.7022521496,
0.0795604512,
0.0084313042,
-0.3274304569,
0.7862192988,
0.1377844363,
0.3012043238,
-1.3681390285,
0.1104632244,
0.0229916126,
0.0821045563,
-0.2778419554,
0.1910318434,
0.1307484359,
-0.2347821891,
-0.620875895,
0.3954932392,
-0.7395737171,
-0.1782046258,
0.2502244115,
0.4074684083,
-0.2133943886,
0.2619533539,
-0.0558170453,
1.1209448576,
0.6828626394,
-0.9674981236,
0.0932523608,
0.225636676,
-0.0830535442,
0.8712641001,
-0.2587201893,
0.1350945979,
-0.2032148689,
0.4734030068,
-1.215362072,
-0.1791906357,
0.0768039227,
-0.3835277557,
0.2070687115,
-0.1418257952,
-0.5521618724,
-0.2535439432,
-0.2273761779,
0.0755203366,
-0.1516625732,
-0.5332525373,
0.792419374,
0.1349045783,
-0.2495981902,
-0.7251431942,
-0.656229198,
0.2659501433,
-0.206030041,
-0.442137748,
0.1830630898,
-0.225010857,
-0.0518863611,
-0.4514690638,
-0.1280333996,
0.1367466599,
-0.0004047869,
-0.0259983744,
0.1864105016,
-0.2279935181,
0.3516520858,
0.5038071871,
0.0880516768,
-0.0656034276,
-0.2787683606,
0.5864382982,
-0.071079202,
-0.4695941806,
-0.1461016685,
0.5833355188,
0.5222492814,
-0.3837071657,
0.8221762776,
0.2274576426,
-0.1481493711,
-0.2908748388,
-0.5035718679,
-0.5320854783,
-0.4752621949,
0.2083935142,
-0.9016931653,
-0.9516936541,
0.3432556391,
-0.3873661757,
0.0702257231,
0.5819454789,
0.3936807513,
-0.0748939216,
1.1979750395,
0.1579006016,
0.410893321,
0.2806550264,
0.0524441004,
-0.0131199742,
-0.9173772931,
-0.4196955264,
-1.051902771,
0.1196845323,
-0.5076370835,
-0.2027050853,
0.3609091043,
-0.003804215,
-0.3528335094,
0.2593921423,
-0.6707061529,
0.6730281711,
0.3336267769,
0.3319648504,
0.3105020821,
0.3199850321,
-0.7123916149,
-0.0038569171,
-0.8572933674,
-0.6146826148,
1.2953538895,
-0.2634657919,
0.3663712144,
0.3951808214,
0.6012284756,
-0.0163048245,
0.1636120379,
-0.3750115633,
0.8056725264,
-0.1558689028,
-0.7410773635,
-0.4856761694,
-0.430947274,
-0.7452123761,
0.5266702771,
-0.4396121204,
-0.7822170854,
-0.0335225165,
0.0306068193,
-0.4012379944,
0.1280714422,
-0.6251000166,
0.5803055763,
-0.1222627237,
-0.5794214606,
0.0346554779,
-0.8408251405,
0.4309650064,
-0.104919076,
0.2014625669,
-0.1167653278,
-0.3478129506,
0.2507477403,
-0.3274898529,
0.617720902,
-0.092526719,
0.0593623556,
0.3687107861,
0.0571306758,
0.7254570723,
0.3302466273,
-0.6778460145,
-0.2147271782,
0.1056029424,
-0.3173930347,
-0.5334248543,
0.8976768255,
-0.2932767272,
-0.5212808251,
-0.5805417299,
-0.4157204032,
-0.5310572386,
0.2751968205,
0.400178045,
0.4386227429,
0.0238209832,
0.3016617894,
0.5255235434,
-0.2328931987,
0.4773296118,
0.5646018982,
-0.1584875286,
-0.3142010868,
0.6062097549,
0.167160064,
0.1942971796,
0.4162271619,
0.1813725233,
-0.7828224301,
-0.5542317033,
-0.6693082452,
0.0946969613,
-0.675367713,
-0.3324616253,
-0.8902726769,
0.0823653564,
-0.4887498915,
-0.1302974373,
0.0924387425,
-0.2650751173,
-0.7366454601,
0.0725889131,
0.2204304039,
0.3015175164,
0.5451563597,
0.3127821982,
-0.6849323511,
0.0665396601,
0.1634955406,
0.3047325909,
-0.0889547989,
-0.2648443282,
0.1409822106,
-0.0211329572,
-0.2979732454,
-1.217995286,
0.0342762955,
0.396281153,
0.6404466629,
0.1159705594,
0.3966195881,
0.7104713321,
-0.460095942,
0.9145691991,
0.211244911,
-0.7400683761,
0.9277837873,
-0.4507374465,
0.2830350995,
0.9615984559,
0.3628306091,
-0.2127979398,
-0.2377107441,
-0.514854908,
-0.7640628219,
0.8506660461,
0.0439581871,
-0.0577949546,
-0.3916959167,
0.5357849598,
0.1485213339,
0.4154656827,
-0.3784334064,
-0.2214542478,
0.1513270587,
-0.0983872861,
-0.2052848935,
-0.3098559976,
0.0770788416,
-0.1324698329,
0.5904379487,
-0.6446786523,
-0.1051331908,
0.1596108526,
-0.1361961663,
-0.0616780147,
0.4173845947,
0.598729074,
0.7642683983,
-0.0230208468,
0.1180936694,
0.6059277058,
-0.2044060826,
0.0009061784,
-0.1865651757,
-0.120713599,
0.0032630807,
-0.0608694926,
0.591829896,
0.0726046786,
-0.774528861,
0.3897903264,
-0.1568234712,
-0.0304081421,
0.013931876,
0.2145809084,
0.0794034973,
0.0178658012,
0.5148804188,
0.2402220517,
0.370121479,
-0.5017140508,
0.2188794017,
0.7509477735,
-0.3319731653,
0.2081027925,
0.5060305595,
0.122995168,
-0.3734805286,
0.587506175,
-0.1427309066,
-0.1849823594,
0.4895554185,
0.819157064,
0.519213438,
-0.3784318864,
0.0510850474,
0.4755800068,
0.245005101,
0.0708052889,
0.7563712597,
-0.2993831635,
-0.3144748807,
-0.2330752611,
-0.538435638,
-0.358642906,
-0.2501581311,
-0.5695874095,
0.575248301,
-0.3843401372,
-0.3199265003,
-0.081871666,
0.1691699475,
-0.4512802362,
0.2814302444,
-0.5292551517,
1.2770879269,
-0.6887821555,
0.6589767933,
0.8150676489,
-0.4787304997,
-0.8464769125,
-0.0544693023,
0.0426676758,
-0.3384023011,
0.3064396977,
0.1880082935,
-0.1930182129,
0.2593295276,
-0.4638249278,
-0.9369252324,
1.1373964548,
0.6067670584,
-0.6813938618,
0.1884548813,
0.1300462335,
0.2897292078,
-0.7069551945,
0.6653689146,
0.6250546575,
0.2939735055,
0.3393440545,
-0.6044755578,
0.2171251625,
-0.0438519567,
0.203658402,
0.0578626581,
-0.6967092752,
0.804548502,
-0.4134967029,
-0.2172929943,
-0.0688264146,
0.5753759146,
1.1755167246,
0.3709995151,
0.5256944895,
-0.0922822505,
0.8472526073,
0.0266167317,
0.8945142627,
-0.325134784,
0.1411961615,
1.1420086622,
-0.5948016644,
1.1045365334,
0.9094346762,
-0.3118281662,
0.445296824,
0.9072454572,
0.3020589948,
0.3674039245,
0.3950841427,
-0.2837716043,
-0.2984563112,
-0.2962444723,
-0.4825247228,
0.2807819843,
0.5334086418,
-0.3282434046,
-0.1983083785,
-0.0233487207,
-0.2789608538,
0.2580472827,
-0.077971369,
0.8694349527,
-0.0509055145,
-0.8282812238,
0.2733517587,
-0.2142159492,
0.5678715706,
-0.670476675,
0.0788816512,
-0.2554512024,
-0.1243057251,
-0.2057948709,
-0.609577179,
0.1274813116,
-0.1036326736,
-0.1691711545,
0.0897673219,
0.7525452375,
-0.4104369879,
-0.4983383417,
-0.123072125,
0.3517360687,
0.2377140969,
-0.347856015,
-0.6474565268,
0.0059778038,
-0.0264832824,
-0.1835330427,
0.356656462,
0.5330765247,
-0.1322821379,
0.8416231871,
0.9639334083,
0.0751373768,
0.0311491396,
-0.0258975551,
0.9325145483,
-0.5895841122,
-0.8546516299,
-0.9031128287,
0.4579946697,
-0.3358844221,
-0.3699426353,
0.9109203219,
0.9178186059,
0.5423616171,
-0.1175534055,
0.7980651855,
0.1179743707,
0.7950130701,
-0.629640162,
0.5323129296,
-0.7314817309,
0.683680594,
-0.4500819743,
-1.0327492952,
-0.3181090057,
0.1215061098,
0.1152254865,
0.3303542435,
0.8646470904,
1.0606899261,
0.1102350056,
0.0919895992,
0.1008769274,
-0.2346300632,
0.3002117276,
0.4059437513,
0.8287118673,
-0.1926229745,
0.6818755269,
0.1362453401,
-0.1164164618,
-0.4545275867,
-1.0886713266,
-0.8763847947,
-0.7104492188,
-0.042659834,
-0.4050193131,
0.1322663277,
1.099301815,
0.7251490355,
-0.8985937238,
-0.2934138775,
-0.0443568677,
0.1476827711,
-0.2749976218,
-0.1642130911,
0.5249414444,
-0.6717067361,
-0.3563082516,
0.6732102633,
0.336253494,
-0.0940536112,
-0.1432528645,
-0.0347866789,
-0.4533623457,
0.2188639045,
0.8547890186,
-0.0319118463,
-0.7797940373,
0.0052488553,
0.3014936447,
-0.3888845146,
-0.1757320762,
0.7898330092,
-0.8459352851,
0.3196145892,
0.3989325464,
0.517416656,
0.4801420569,
0.0897365436,
0.3604454994,
-1.0271607637,
-0.1919766963,
0.1914498508,
0.0390948206,
0.2150954157,
-0.6646217108,
0.4222272336,
0.13530536,
-0.3594764769,
-0.9403544664,
0.3239639103,
-0.9290630817,
-0.5400614142,
1.297907114,
0.3965981603,
-0.1561991721,
-0.1471521407,
-0.5210267305,
0.1943586022,
-0.5466157198,
0.5676991343,
0.4270689785,
-0.330678165,
-0.1902435273,
-0.2198040038,
0.6490752697,
0.3429480791,
-0.9342343807,
0.0249957927,
0.5344721079,
0.2099801004,
-0.0769868866,
0.5839300156,
0.0485490263,
0.1250648499,
-0.0446646623,
-0.3455935121,
-0.1309414357,
-0.462000519,
-0.2391920537,
0.5430466533,
0.0823824257,
-0.0905120745
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13006v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13006v1
|
Auto FAQ Generation
| 2024-05-13T03:30:27 | 2024-05-13T03:30:27 |
Anjaneya Teja Kalvakolanu, NagaSai Chandra, Michael Fekadu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
FAQ documents are commonly used with text documents and websites to provide
important information in the form of question answer pairs to either aid in
reading comprehension or provide a shortcut to the key ideas. We suppose that
salient sentences from a given document serve as a good proxy fro the answers
to an aggregated set of FAQs from readers. We propose a system for generating
FAQ documents that extract the salient questions and their corresponding
answers from sizeable text documents scraped from the Stanford Encyclopedia of
Philosophy. We use existing text summarization, sentence ranking via the Text
rank algorithm, and question-generation tools to create an initial set of
questions and answers. Finally, we apply some heuristics to filter out invalid
questions. We use human evaluation to rate the generated questions on grammar,
whether the question is meaningful, and whether the question's answerability is
present within a summarized context. On average, participants thought 71
percent of the questions were meaningful.
|
[
-0.6259170771,
-0.8216424584,
0.6003052592,
-0.2490324527,
-0.3757709265,
-0.3111334741,
0.3425671756,
-0.1579925716,
0.3662512302,
0.6577020884,
-0.6996721029,
-0.1896831095,
-0.1897518486,
0.4570697844,
-0.8367378116,
1.1951528788,
0.310034126,
-0.5334044695,
-0.4470050335,
0.0494560339,
0.0224998351,
-0.1160681993,
-0.6765779853,
0.0491743125,
0.3769788742,
0.4894880652,
0.7476142645,
0.6988392472,
0.38950333,
0.2923602164,
0.2581513226,
0.5597062111,
-0.223345086,
0.5743045807,
-0.2808101773,
-0.1163879037,
-0.3151352704,
0.106994085,
0.3694278598,
0.5885909796,
0.0965567082,
0.3231534958,
0.0370647795,
0.6639205813,
-0.3258364201,
-0.2518905997,
-0.6705984473,
0.1521996707,
-0.2479521185,
-0.3526748419,
-0.0562039092,
-0.6839233637,
0.1692342758,
-0.7260597944,
0.6158108711,
0.1491304636,
1.0796864033,
0.4750466049,
-0.3439598978,
-0.904160738,
-0.2495207191,
0.3169033825,
-0.395124346,
0.2023709416,
0.4317985773,
-0.0109148668,
-0.2234593779,
-0.5011283755,
-0.8353576064,
-0.0423597991,
-0.2745456696,
0.3206395209,
-0.2513625324,
-0.2432306707,
0.1796750575,
0.8383427262,
-0.7924575806,
-0.5366277099,
-0.4040442705,
-0.1001076102,
0.819557488,
0.3797249496,
0.6149172783,
-0.6402614117,
0.0489283316,
-0.0103555918,
-0.3245740533,
0.171093747,
0.6331973076,
-0.3475291431,
0.5594252944,
0.5143088698,
-0.4214118123,
0.8035934567,
0.5287198424,
-0.0197174214,
-0.1011836305,
-0.6315376759,
-0.0287939757,
-0.2546269894,
0.7578932047,
0.6696973443,
0.1471510381,
-0.2154312134,
-0.138279289,
-0.3663734496,
0.3217338622,
-0.4352554381,
-0.3493410349,
0.4417484999,
-0.3653553724,
-0.4779492915,
0.1043904871,
-0.8045589328,
-0.0155640924,
-0.0944471136,
0.1743741184,
-0.5484828949,
0.0936931297,
-0.2201491892,
-0.4496997893,
0.2506445348,
0.5026060343,
-1.0961817503,
0.1978242248,
0.3003355861,
0.6169386506,
-0.1224176809,
-0.0758260638,
-0.4723804593,
0.3706282675,
-0.1428463608,
0.9984176755,
-0.015731601,
-0.5317820907,
-0.0442493297,
-0.0168074965,
0.2702436447,
-0.2362968624,
0.3806689382,
-0.4279319048,
0.6241030693,
-0.3418334126,
-0.5777722001,
0.0300883297,
0.2517463565,
-0.8173530698,
1.2602058649,
0.1286483705,
-0.685233593,
0.271096319,
-0.8011630177,
-0.7106127739,
0.3553061783,
-0.2123036534,
0.0813539699,
-0.0196676757,
0.2666082382,
0.4923993945,
-0.4623164237,
0.0690067336,
0.3392450809,
0.2785617113,
0.3890561163,
-0.2701280415,
0.7139448524,
0.3367324769,
-0.2782069743,
-0.3578230143,
-0.5035344958,
0.2840759456,
0.1966554672,
-0.5461371541,
-0.4534499347,
-0.1666515023,
-0.3708002567,
0.1060953587,
0.3514198959,
-0.3615647554,
0.0382319428,
-0.6125875711,
0.3575407267,
0.5263018012,
0.6748477221,
0.3066938818,
-0.4184320867,
0.2771181166,
-0.3659138978,
0.2161410451,
-0.4172799587,
-0.6949789524,
-0.8838383555,
0.2005982995,
-0.0966498554,
0.4748831987,
-0.7200178504,
0.781929791,
0.1047133058,
-0.6160185337,
-0.4225867391,
0.6181409359,
0.4053268135,
0.6932854652,
0.2646335661,
-0.1707642525,
0.0628225505,
-0.8287168741,
-0.2219522446,
-0.3731478453,
0.0566651188,
0.306433171,
0.5316771865,
0.2878099382,
1.1681418419,
-1.0274940729,
0.2586706579,
-0.0469742864,
0.4008323252,
-0.1436200589,
0.2004591972,
0.676612854,
-0.9234417081,
-0.4324751198,
-0.3693880439,
-0.6827670336,
-0.4992026389,
-0.0818248168,
-0.7347468734,
0.0122891255,
0.3865224123,
-0.5981652737,
0.1158219501,
-0.0708733648,
-0.1586715579,
0.2680041194,
-0.0374351852,
0.3095207512,
-1.3893232346,
0.3746563792,
-0.0656946227,
-0.1814019084,
-0.3903263211,
0.0902357697,
-0.248513341,
-0.4029083252,
-0.0671800971,
0.7610558867,
-0.2946785092,
-0.0249952227,
-0.1225102618,
0.4606257975,
0.40570122,
0.2186964154,
-0.217310816,
0.7340120673,
-0.1688154787,
-0.9597552419,
0.6105724573,
0.4103827775,
0.0241547544,
0.3835397065,
-0.6817141771,
0.0502720065,
-0.1793578714,
0.1771673411,
-1.2227948904,
-0.7629204392,
0.3180497289,
-0.4901395142,
-0.2088261545,
0.1924445182,
-0.6281993389,
-0.5884908438,
-0.2917822003,
-0.0177799296,
0.395214349,
-0.2502735555,
0.2498449683,
0.5213063955,
-0.3325154185,
-0.494459331,
-0.2160086036,
-0.3406030536,
0.2758240998,
-0.7863355279,
-0.0155048966,
-0.3462058604,
-0.2286526859,
0.323959887,
-0.0264778491,
-0.1537606567,
0.2900443077,
0.3676228225,
-0.001204083,
-0.0842545927,
0.439491272,
0.6965969801,
0.1035758853,
0.0841600522,
-0.1103738472,
0.5479761362,
-0.1735985875,
-0.1647599041,
-0.1769439876,
0.8773878217,
0.7463515997,
-0.1938542128,
-0.0385041609,
0.3146821856,
-0.2515480816,
-0.2941195965,
-0.5163078904,
-0.1373375505,
-0.4453331232,
-0.1797783226,
-0.0049643014,
-0.6287717819,
0.2588056326,
0.0482208245,
0.6585984826,
0.8729887605,
0.7418518066,
-0.323707968,
0.6664822102,
0.2518295944,
0.1786208749,
0.438627243,
-0.0575060099,
-0.0967187583,
-0.1675771475,
-0.2180113047,
-0.5212537646,
-0.0480065048,
0.0910354704,
-0.3007963598,
0.4836349487,
0.0754527003,
0.1024729982,
0.2240988165,
-0.7604079247,
0.5550275445,
0.7815759778,
-0.1374587864,
0.372366637,
0.1546482295,
-0.3007405996,
0.3594233692,
-0.4643264711,
-0.7253222466,
0.917904973,
-0.1603860408,
0.3961225152,
0.089338094,
0.9081421494,
0.6299912333,
0.342918098,
-0.666207552,
0.7400425673,
-0.2038200945,
-0.8957969546,
-0.6464304328,
-0.3010590374,
-0.7398703098,
0.0070462464,
-0.2054418921,
-0.1931404918,
-0.0337963402,
0.2793542743,
-0.8051970005,
-0.3439120054,
-0.6083733439,
0.6028065681,
-0.4417378306,
-0.2505779266,
0.2669630349,
-0.7246108055,
0.3651813269,
-0.1571763009,
-0.0286534596,
-0.0004224539,
0.1300001889,
0.9000809193,
-0.707341969,
0.4612335861,
0.1055426896,
-0.2802938223,
0.6931217909,
0.0911789313,
-0.1013578624,
0.2986464202,
-0.2806149721,
-0.3819865286,
-0.1333822459,
-0.2159824222,
-0.8165539503,
0.5649005771,
-0.7797494531,
-0.8863236904,
-0.1429638267,
-0.364030391,
-0.0381109752,
0.4352546334,
0.5595821738,
0.3057815135,
-0.3274397552,
-0.1285482347,
0.8940470219,
-0.0168091618,
0.3942649364,
0.4660822153,
-0.0043958365,
-0.6013453603,
0.6239296198,
0.1726296991,
0.2736266255,
0.3476058841,
0.1326518506,
-0.248539865,
-0.1161473915,
-0.7713576555,
0.2191140801,
-0.8595790267,
-0.2949818671,
-0.8277298212,
-0.2815874517,
-0.7785366178,
-0.4207157791,
0.0697543398,
-0.6541283131,
-0.3507721722,
0.0038198479,
0.4026407599,
0.5990283489,
-0.0499926619,
0.1384847611,
-0.9582836032,
0.3942476511,
0.7765109539,
-0.2726637125,
-0.2176335156,
-0.225680396,
-0.1024464592,
-0.2145383805,
-0.5459478498,
-1.0910282135,
0.2884931862,
0.324011147,
0.6751344204,
0.6607701778,
0.3429057598,
0.2823274732,
-0.4249368906,
1.1775717735,
0.1828756332,
-0.8767638206,
1.2728378773,
-0.4021050334,
0.1587423235,
0.8435485959,
0.7817074656,
-0.3575259447,
-0.8378919959,
-0.6791079044,
-0.8963777423,
0.3815616667,
0.3731041849,
0.3686096966,
-0.3990053535,
0.9727407694,
0.4282858372,
0.3820173144,
-0.544536531,
-0.2841345668,
-0.6357872486,
-0.4349081516,
0.393835485,
-0.0565453805,
-0.3002194464,
-0.0342918001,
0.7075113058,
-0.2110945731,
0.1658900976,
0.4467777312,
0.0038073396,
-0.4399871826,
0.1984219402,
0.4466761053,
0.1572041065,
-0.1057311222,
0.0068698758,
-0.2432537526,
-0.6572024822,
-0.0177643988,
-0.098705247,
-0.4554857314,
0.1867391467,
-0.0700911209,
0.2436277419,
-0.0466214456,
-0.6263315082,
0.3870934546,
-0.1680335999,
-0.3535152078,
-0.2172085792,
0.7325900793,
-0.1872029752,
0.0292153116,
0.5927162766,
-0.2614433765,
0.3145594001,
-0.6401077509,
0.3770443797,
0.2757755518,
0.1649603695,
-0.0370953605,
0.5479472876,
0.635412395,
-0.2709345222,
0.5409457684,
-0.299968034,
-0.6349308491,
0.4136679769,
0.2403407693,
0.5804228783,
-0.1512058973,
0.4432035685,
0.372594744,
0.2846544981,
0.0627453327,
0.332244873,
-0.4799672961,
-0.6150108576,
0.0882574096,
-0.7217391729,
-0.6285097003,
0.1422596127,
-0.4961225986,
0.1445998996,
-0.5702970624,
-0.2688325644,
0.2760941982,
0.0953526124,
-0.2701528072,
0.5988219976,
-0.0193185676,
0.5738501549,
-0.9057562351,
0.3197352886,
0.7993444204,
-0.9708218575,
-0.7658640146,
0.4606289566,
-0.2854297757,
-0.4680734873,
0.6781327128,
-0.3053043485,
-0.2097212672,
0.1771527827,
-0.8773323298,
-0.8962393403,
1.3126323223,
0.1524185985,
-0.002918954,
-0.3596146107,
0.066263631,
0.376729399,
-0.1852807254,
0.1071903035,
0.0838895142,
0.2919174433,
0.1934180111,
-0.4472595155,
0.2407473773,
-0.7560138106,
-0.5019469261,
0.2039084285,
-0.7458543181,
0.9313242435,
0.0617326014,
-0.1371197701,
0.2220540941,
0.6206635833,
0.0173914284,
0.4829647839,
0.6552417278,
0.3867915869,
1.2482587099,
0.0990873724,
1.0044935942,
-0.6091609001,
0.1823305935,
0.9936520457,
-0.0951650366,
0.5906586647,
0.3109114468,
0.3372013867,
0.4170876443,
0.7024324536,
-0.0918164477,
0.4771511853,
-0.0224969331,
-0.2475355864,
-0.5186364651,
0.0688109323,
-0.4433141351,
0.2851605117,
0.5326982737,
-0.682249248,
-0.3041530848,
-0.1021415293,
0.0337188393,
-0.1338261664,
-0.1640715003,
0.7553272843,
-0.1477486491,
-1.0675109625,
0.1167461127,
-0.0097616501,
0.1118261367,
-0.2963486612,
-0.018896576,
-0.6117427349,
-0.4412283599,
-0.2985423207,
-1.0296065807,
0.2208678424,
0.4266745746,
-0.6604990959,
-0.2060668319,
0.8857760429,
-0.163476333,
-0.2688682079,
-0.4553995132,
0.774205327,
0.4760115147,
0.2753933072,
-0.6550932527,
-0.6331756711,
0.0735725835,
-0.2903902233,
0.0946593061,
0.7406231761,
0.1951280236,
0.509262979,
0.8666063547,
-0.4405092895,
0.1607112288,
-0.4718295634,
1.0072228909,
-0.4279661477,
-0.6308988929,
-0.4975430369,
0.3964810967,
-0.5000649095,
-0.6837915182,
0.8283097148,
0.5163592696,
0.3496161401,
-0.0277278833,
1.0047630072,
-0.2022662014,
0.5859361291,
-0.5399209857,
1.0587522984,
-0.9016176462,
-0.0202303883,
-0.5002220869,
-0.6347264051,
-0.0397982411,
0.6818777323,
-0.1713115275,
-0.3683542013,
0.6938374043,
0.576942265,
0.2046395838,
0.2725124359,
0.1992428899,
-0.1896631867,
0.1263807863,
0.2262925506,
0.667699337,
-0.4506257772,
0.7722324133,
0.0103545617,
-0.0628058463,
-0.4029449522,
-0.5631054044,
-0.7366535664,
-0.7259852886,
-0.3848115802,
-0.3991914988,
-0.0175093021,
0.8377075791,
0.2675152719,
-0.5620968342,
0.0268353131,
-0.2169593424,
0.3001825511,
0.2616368234,
-0.3078679442,
0.2962909043,
-0.4007350504,
-0.6335580349,
0.1292011142,
0.2567549944,
0.1273323894,
-0.3140550852,
0.0972587839,
-0.2217213213,
0.4870699644,
0.3997901082,
0.3842350841,
-0.5349544883,
-0.3180917799,
0.2352989912,
-0.3362013996,
-0.3287039697,
1.0420991182,
-0.5095285773,
0.0724598318,
0.5243348479,
0.61222893,
-0.0262717772,
0.3044010997,
0.5005319118,
-0.7529776096,
-0.4706782401,
0.2134535611,
0.087553978,
0.0853721499,
-0.706099093,
0.5230095387,
0.4497123063,
-0.525638938,
-0.5727818608,
0.1252011657,
-0.9505909085,
-0.1609633863,
1.1976122856,
-0.1356350929,
-0.3874394298,
-0.5207831264,
-0.3092863858,
0.4225015342,
-0.7544291615,
0.6709550619,
0.8139921427,
-0.4466496706,
-0.0145882955,
-0.2131959945,
0.6084690094,
0.3265987635,
-1.1410785913,
-0.0282422397,
0.7322796583,
0.4431029856,
0.524541676,
0.7312548757,
0.1258385181,
0.5198270679,
-0.0737012103,
-0.173638463,
0.0163149554,
0.0251075979,
0.3010979593,
0.6522091627,
-0.2202449739,
0.1600687206
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17440v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17440v1
|
CataLM: Empowering Catalyst Design Through Large Language Models
| 2024-05-13T03:19:47 | 2024-05-13T03:19:47 |
Ludi Wang, Xueqing Chen, Yi Du, Yuanchun Zhou, Yang Gao, Wenjuan Cui
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The field of catalysis holds paramount importance in shaping the trajectory
of sustainable development, prompting intensive research efforts to leverage
artificial intelligence (AI) in catalyst design. Presently, the fine-tuning of
open-source large language models (LLMs) has yielded significant breakthroughs
across various domains such as biology and healthcare. Drawing inspiration from
these advancements, we introduce CataLM Cata}lytic Language Model), a large
language model tailored to the domain of electrocatalytic materials. Our
findings demonstrate that CataLM exhibits remarkable potential for facilitating
human-AI collaboration in catalyst knowledge exploration and design. To the
best of our knowledge, CataLM stands as the pioneering LLM dedicated to the
catalyst domain, offering novel avenues for catalyst discovery and development.
|
[
-0.2122845352,
-0.5977698565,
1.0469815731,
0.4146039188,
0.2926806509,
0.3928912878,
-0.4205799997,
-0.2866866589,
0.3993066549,
0.4668323994,
-0.4061762094,
-0.4061172009,
-0.129637152,
0.3053302169,
-0.0468816049,
0.3957565725,
-0.3204193711,
0.4184986651,
-0.3749644756,
0.2627077699,
-0.2927256227,
-0.5977618098,
-0.6068977714,
-0.665658474,
0.8146882057,
0.2851029038,
0.4843702912,
0.8562399745,
0.5455130935,
0.3299686909,
-0.1535486728,
0.0175020844,
-0.160881564,
0.0872096866,
-0.529519856,
-0.8397881389,
-0.5702131391,
0.0242778808,
0.4479902387,
0.8576483727,
-0.2225723267,
0.0331444629,
0.0383439064,
0.5941649675,
-0.4018103182,
0.3053910434,
-0.772467494,
-0.0149046751,
-0.2033484727,
-0.5242910981,
-0.5353152752,
-0.4109107554,
-0.1144517586,
-0.7460389137,
0.2436130643,
0.3543770313,
0.4299108088,
0.4535713792,
-0.2456416637,
-0.5453993678,
-0.9493774176,
1.0647885799,
-0.4149264693,
0.6397932172,
0.2790239751,
0.3450279832,
-0.6831001639,
-1.0940419436,
-0.6671252251,
-0.2231417447,
0.3438701034,
-0.0564900562,
0.2021355629,
0.4953717291,
-0.0718045682,
0.5112017393,
-0.6609167457,
0.3458575308,
-0.3190033138,
-0.284633249,
0.3965885937,
0.5579357147,
0.4808852375,
0.427033484,
-0.6242177486,
-0.3524680734,
-0.760045886,
-0.0517164916,
0.1640785933,
0.493887037,
0.1669743657,
0.57103616,
-0.264695704,
0.0186007787,
-0.4815560281,
0.2543786466,
-0.0119612245,
-0.4316877723,
-0.2663994431,
0.6053053737,
0.6424659491,
0.1845781952,
0.0235771388,
-0.2783996165,
0.0626643822,
0.5931892991,
0.2640445232,
-1.2744989395,
-0.4390272796,
0.3362511098,
-0.3541921079,
-0.1030881256,
-0.0910448804,
-0.8548694849,
-0.6518328786,
-0.3293405473,
0.034866672,
0.5756148696,
-0.2881643772,
0.5887693763,
-0.4503408968,
0.0310221966,
0.2751507163,
-1.0301615,
0.1920173764,
0.8061859608,
0.7244182229,
-0.1494144946,
-0.2423363179,
-0.2655135691,
0.1180502549,
-0.402581811,
0.7091534734,
-0.7886483073,
-0.5688277483,
-0.253534019,
0.3148971498,
0.1870600581,
-0.4641652703,
0.5412964225,
-0.6438962817,
-0.0999972224,
-0.172736913,
-0.1663661897,
-0.3463655114,
-0.040292412,
-0.7543292046,
0.7000578642,
-0.2062970102,
-0.2371856123,
0.311421901,
-0.9301452637,
-0.2033184618,
0.1955953389,
0.0279177148,
-0.5289553404,
0.2874310613,
-0.1848395616,
0.2130089253,
-0.966712594,
0.5687756538,
-0.6491882801,
0.1152685508,
0.2298548818,
-0.4463926852,
0.4217531979,
0.2466296256,
-0.1450226754,
0.3988028169,
-0.6143578291,
-0.0212433841,
0.0399721153,
-0.5086526275,
-0.2298021764,
0.2012062818,
0.2818517685,
0.476579845,
0.417316258,
-0.8276683092,
0.1809625924,
-0.3613418341,
0.8974940181,
0.8564773798,
0.0748855174,
0.6066016555,
-0.1720567197,
0.6419997215,
-0.6380613446,
0.0152812144,
-0.1688369811,
-0.4708680511,
-1.0538144112,
0.0517300442,
0.1760134697,
0.3468346298,
-0.3546821177,
-0.1000490859,
-0.1413727105,
-0.7448713183,
-0.5133753419,
0.5984224081,
-0.0478557162,
0.1238814667,
0.2424672842,
-0.325529635,
-0.812756598,
-1.1035205126,
-0.3472600281,
-0.3685397804,
0.310631603,
0.1955322921,
0.5056401491,
-0.5810605288,
1.0095309019,
-0.4294475317,
-0.3209409118,
-0.2528524399,
-0.0199049152,
0.2734333873,
0.4820332229,
0.1056814864,
-0.8165314198,
-0.4691691697,
0.3186384141,
-0.7626748681,
-0.1579858065,
0.018544415,
-0.4011015594,
-0.3978995383,
0.7809510231,
-0.5976614952,
0.2305360138,
0.2541276515,
-0.1517730951,
0.24611637,
-0.0601322316,
-0.0728382915,
-0.972288847,
0.1045111269,
0.0228484869,
-0.015235465,
-0.8051396608,
0.1084775776,
-0.11049591,
-0.4667378068,
-0.8182916045,
1.0056920052,
-0.4360185862,
0.33084023,
-0.5334614515,
-0.1945861578,
0.1865218431,
0.5541700125,
0.3807339668,
0.9081511497,
0.3358196914,
-0.563115716,
0.1144422218,
0.3346420825,
-0.143274799,
0.2452270836,
-0.9032761455,
0.0027661819,
0.2320244163,
0.1726484746,
-0.8569002748,
-0.3451634049,
-0.2718576789,
-0.1022627801,
0.1140153781,
0.4198158681,
-0.7960112691,
-0.5537062287,
-0.0678789169,
0.5944865942,
0.2954541147,
-0.7053831816,
0.8810887933,
0.4718846679,
-0.3747000098,
0.3776646256,
-0.4017996192,
0.3171207905,
-0.5430247784,
-0.7929335833,
0.3162430227,
-0.5376162529,
-0.3526434302,
-0.61133039,
-0.0237811077,
-0.0421224758,
0.5535609126,
0.5373442769,
-0.1815935373,
-0.2689431608,
0.3151607513,
-0.1735020429,
-0.2121977508,
0.3813613653,
-0.0170999523,
0.9114217162,
-0.2943172455,
-0.1031291634,
-0.7683619261,
0.3402282596,
1.1117578745,
-0.3763936758,
0.5013089776,
0.164688468,
-0.3366693854,
-0.4586120844,
-0.1592259705,
-0.4755717814,
-0.6208258867,
0.3323780596,
-0.1233205795,
-0.8556531072,
0.4437140822,
-0.6759127378,
-0.0553052649,
0.266423285,
1.0679786205,
0.2774885893,
1.5084683895,
0.9420812726,
-0.0265082996,
0.3111360371,
-0.0138030378,
0.3732485175,
-0.8970898986,
-0.2770704627,
-0.6298777461,
-0.1447416097,
-0.3902729452,
-0.3321537375,
0.4702089429,
0.1680161059,
-0.2741370499,
0.0966428369,
-0.6013544798,
0.290820837,
0.3261161745,
0.0056954529,
0.3623753488,
-0.0195929632,
-0.1512028873,
0.0351207703,
-0.853505373,
-0.8099827766,
0.8235575557,
0.566095233,
1.0772004128,
0.0274033174,
0.3396711946,
0.345946461,
0.4261310697,
-0.7540565729,
0.5459836125,
0.5208692551,
-0.8037169576,
-0.0107511682,
0.0867256746,
-1.1284630299,
0.2237503231,
-0.0433096699,
-0.3534730673,
0.3237017989,
0.028036043,
-0.1236675158,
0.3970429599,
-0.4680999219,
0.8303354383,
-0.5557425618,
-0.6121174097,
-0.3842152953,
-0.236591652,
0.1519503593,
-0.2263318002,
0.3700547814,
-0.0135190813,
0.0755257457,
0.6449460387,
-0.6489789486,
0.9601827264,
0.4530320764,
-0.3955359757,
0.2585633993,
0.1186262295,
0.4568277895,
-0.2129383534,
-0.3282871842,
0.0463631526,
-0.678443253,
-0.2290148437,
-0.3186727166,
0.880348742,
-0.3890121877,
-0.8816769123,
-0.362059027,
-0.4534150958,
-0.0105368514,
0.3286763728,
-0.1121283472,
0.1301009506,
-0.4268844724,
0.4251762629,
0.5585238338,
-0.2072844952,
0.6310864687,
0.5326781273,
-0.2915353179,
-0.3543368578,
1.298568964,
-0.5468011498,
0.3046022654,
0.3139927685,
0.2498124838,
-0.3870044947,
-0.4220874906,
-0.4272867441,
0.152686879,
-0.7602583766,
0.1068685204,
-0.7118578553,
0.0194023121,
0.1932963133,
-0.4941921234,
-0.4534816742,
-0.3033335507,
-0.6162443757,
-0.2140323818,
0.5292679667,
0.6246765256,
0.1305331737,
0.3727387786,
-0.4892447293,
0.2372144908,
0.3296663463,
0.4148549438,
0.2953997254,
0.3035754561,
-0.3619741797,
0.1469670534,
-0.5423792601,
-0.5821754932,
0.4747955799,
0.3756470084,
0.6713500619,
0.1988079399,
-0.2168245763,
0.3184596896,
-0.6553969383,
0.8644341826,
0.253677547,
-0.6141856909,
0.6848535538,
-0.4270272553,
-0.0456620343,
0.3996676505,
0.2977031171,
-0.4119246304,
-0.3478851318,
-0.3807582259,
-1.0135802031,
0.3417712748,
0.120858781,
-0.2235195041,
-0.2552589774,
-0.1114271358,
0.1971584111,
0.2620268464,
-0.7479570508,
-0.0431232154,
-0.0392116606,
-0.1637831479,
-0.0373900905,
0.2816307843,
0.0673863664,
-0.1237104535,
0.9963049889,
-0.0536710992,
-0.1504910737,
0.0664883256,
-0.2021872848,
-0.1672342271,
0.3783727884,
0.5616257787,
0.3428573012,
0.0662281364,
0.1804462373,
-0.0379373133,
-0.4137005508,
0.4084403217,
-0.4297962189,
0.0705252737,
-0.2504422367,
-0.079956308,
0.7466076016,
-0.1068789363,
-0.9899407625,
-0.0498991087,
-0.222383365,
-0.2713299096,
-0.3294055164,
0.4121609628,
0.2157278955,
0.4699257314,
0.4769438207,
-0.184717536,
0.075462088,
-0.7600157857,
-0.0133110154,
0.7061391473,
-0.6432898045,
-0.4345738888,
1.4516334534,
0.4708595276,
-0.6511317492,
0.190954119,
0.0633600205,
-0.812412262,
0.7255933881,
0.5327426791,
0.9026457667,
-0.1996161789,
-0.0302818101,
0.1473644525,
0.2353247702,
-0.275341481,
0.2211385965,
-0.2124656439,
-0.4645270407,
-0.0435629189,
-1.1275956631,
-0.4627470374,
0.1895875931,
-0.3450494111,
0.2124609649,
-0.5966530442,
-0.1000700668,
0.1089109778,
-0.0408973321,
-0.6700974107,
0.002415183,
-0.058398027,
0.784902215,
-0.8755397797,
0.5153962374,
0.6743900776,
-0.4884036481,
-0.3890076578,
-0.6195904016,
-0.1668362916,
-0.6742226481,
1.0390381813,
0.1904671937,
-0.1992080808,
0.2438488901,
-0.5532194972,
-0.8285436034,
1.1142014265,
0.0336114317,
-0.5043898821,
0.1086466759,
0.6193461418,
0.4503548145,
-0.5232391357,
0.1234636456,
0.3844749928,
0.742400825,
-0.4619857371,
-0.892552793,
0.1628047526,
-0.6581230164,
0.2422441244,
0.5688524246,
-0.951562345,
0.910343647,
0.0959215015,
-0.3804493845,
0.5477400422,
0.6364839077,
0.2371172607,
0.2247260362,
0.0724158511,
0.5709068775,
0.5909743309,
0.0908190385,
0.9917510152,
-0.398089081,
0.1578354836,
0.4922206402,
-0.6636116505,
0.6224130988,
0.5680510998,
-0.0851453543,
0.7767273188,
0.6759238243,
0.09710069,
0.4752674103,
0.4151306152,
-0.45038113,
-0.7521351576,
-0.5527035594,
-0.2658627033,
0.2739672959,
0.7526952028,
-0.5111448765,
-0.4291687012,
0.1757692993,
-0.2667093575,
0.2433857471,
-0.7125480175,
0.637965858,
0.3722496033,
-0.5004091859,
0.5346056819,
0.0033238779,
0.349085629,
-0.2680733204,
-0.4427022338,
0.2476288974,
0.3529187739,
-0.0303874239,
-0.5639657974,
-0.2440119684,
-0.3661450744,
-0.6832374334,
-0.4572115839,
0.6923261285,
-0.3763553798,
-0.4722132087,
0.3904185593,
0.4197458923,
0.1885633916,
-0.0134627651,
-0.3437331021,
0.1715102643,
0.0762177706,
0.1894560903,
0.3263201118,
0.0639169216,
-0.5719229579,
0.960109055,
1.2279542685,
0.0060723154,
-0.0596597083,
-0.2368674278,
0.8267753124,
-0.7438650131,
-0.5052767992,
-0.9723474383,
0.3763919175,
0.223297894,
-0.0966553465,
0.8197715282,
0.7489609718,
0.4445047379,
-0.1636795104,
1.0209963322,
0.5896221995,
0.2538339198,
-0.4434373975,
0.7555157542,
-0.720903039,
0.3077415228,
-0.0994363949,
-0.9623978734,
-0.3281357288,
0.4960380197,
0.0308230296,
-0.2614267766,
0.5953929424,
1.1157910824,
-0.126423806,
0.258318007,
-0.1187296286,
0.3093056083,
0.8121136427,
0.608916223,
1.0162882805,
0.0603989996,
0.2548305392,
0.0786410719,
-0.057518594,
-0.5734698176,
-0.916636169,
-1.1995239258,
-0.4824682474,
-0.0329656824,
-0.1262215376,
-0.3771958947,
0.9456698298,
0.5564781427,
-0.5706722736,
-0.4452475905,
-0.8283606172,
0.1896524876,
0.2572829723,
-0.2024028599,
0.2968931794,
-0.1479200125,
-0.689427495,
0.7677443624,
0.4604954422,
-0.1130754575,
-0.7490628362,
-0.2559684813,
0.113209337,
0.2939570248,
0.5778283477,
0.6571634412,
-0.7184117436,
0.1135675535,
0.3086667657,
0.0606474541,
0.3037526608,
0.9077363014,
-0.8373217583,
0.647846818,
0.5137013793,
0.8470462561,
0.388351351,
-0.2347671688,
0.9761917591,
-0.0455959886,
0.0666515008,
0.1785041094,
0.5266120434,
0.3915524185,
-0.2174927443,
0.4647840261,
0.0537553355,
-0.8568129539,
-1.0846904516,
0.3371546865,
-1.0600056648,
-0.250469327,
1.1283403635,
0.5115838051,
-0.5460369587,
-0.1361459047,
-0.2256714106,
0.0697740689,
-0.4548346698,
0.5458481908,
0.6070944071,
-0.0666913688,
0.1550767422,
-0.5819665194,
0.4729143381,
0.5037848353,
-0.7729594707,
0.1102001816,
-0.0005328485,
0.0802501738,
0.5369955897,
0.278577745,
0.1765215397,
0.3458710313,
-0.274273932,
0.4388493896,
0.0625388622,
-0.5453719497,
-0.0160617493,
0.0856669396,
0.3221211731,
0.2911792994
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07437v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07437v2
|
Evaluation of Retrieval-Augmented Generation: A Survey
| 2024-05-13T02:33:25 | 2024-07-03T04:59:32 |
Hao Yu, Aoran Gan, Kai Zhang, Shiwei Tong, Qi Liu, Zhaofeng Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) has recently gained traction in natural
language processing. Numerous studies and real-world applications are
leveraging its ability to enhance generative models through external
information retrieval. Evaluating these RAG systems, however, poses unique
challenges due to their hybrid structure and reliance on dynamic knowledge
sources. To better understand these challenges, we conduct A Unified Evaluation
Process of RAG (Auepora) and aim to provide a comprehensive overview of the
evaluation and benchmarks of RAG systems. Specifically, we examine and compare
several quantifiable metrics of the Retrieval and Generation components, such
as relevance, accuracy, and faithfulness, within the current RAG benchmarks,
encompassing the possible output and ground truth pairs. We then analyze the
various datasets and metrics, discuss the limitations of current benchmarks,
and suggest potential directions to advance the field of RAG benchmarks.
|
[
-0.52483356,
-0.6603263617,
0.3840577602,
0.0292367712,
0.0510572232,
0.6022849083,
-0.2148525268,
-0.6484534144,
0.0917116702,
0.4868758023,
-0.2353824079,
-0.0216937214,
-0.4342101514,
0.3354139626,
-0.5748209953,
0.97102952,
-0.0017669863,
-0.1897305548,
-0.3495456576,
-0.4872972667,
-0.6112191677,
-0.4658868909,
-0.4803801775,
-0.3749863207,
0.1125434861,
0.2551118433,
0.5730674863,
0.3924215436,
0.6599230766,
0.3411340117,
-0.1675258428,
0.5685667992,
-0.4143429399,
0.5810284019,
-0.3470523357,
-0.1637939364,
-0.3101511896,
0.0620249845,
0.8664882183,
0.8488469124,
-0.2028872818,
0.6413699985,
0.0942896679,
0.8844663501,
-1.0463596582,
-0.2980496585,
-0.7911927104,
0.0766088888,
-0.4272423387,
-0.3126720786,
-0.431262821,
-0.5226915479,
0.0862155333,
-0.6462079883,
0.5837582946,
0.2602973282,
1.012992382,
0.2862422764,
-0.4307361841,
-0.4524173737,
-0.9547967911,
0.8104321361,
-0.2477644086,
0.4591089487,
0.2972261906,
0.6162363291,
-0.1165436953,
-0.8747465611,
-0.3314444423,
-0.3255424798,
-0.1234588996,
0.3331729174,
-0.1729279757,
-0.1722268909,
0.1226334497,
1.08477211,
-0.4556400776,
-0.2776590884,
-0.137507543,
-0.0957960412,
0.5825807452,
0.2119857073,
0.1966311187,
-0.5005952716,
-0.4157448709,
-0.2867114544,
-0.2831563652,
-0.3501700461,
0.4773274064,
0.2272510827,
0.2423752546,
0.6358505487,
-0.4063555598,
0.5903488994,
0.1591513157,
0.1219645143,
0.3559416831,
-0.5315930247,
-0.1330624819,
-0.3818333745,
0.7038218379,
0.1414675117,
-0.1410251111,
-0.5158072114,
-0.3674877882,
0.1608876288,
0.5319491029,
-0.38475734,
0.0533884279,
-0.0089283539,
-0.364615202,
-0.2717158198,
0.1819922775,
-0.9704269171,
-0.4781635404,
-0.2889158428,
0.5845376253,
-0.5103003383,
-0.4691911936,
-0.2455882728,
-0.44725734,
0.2041288614,
0.0071073268,
-0.5860968828,
0.6551019549,
0.760951817,
0.6451362967,
-0.3878154159,
0.0580110177,
-0.5822043419,
-0.0846583545,
-0.2875638306,
1.1064325571,
-0.5544099212,
-0.4447470605,
-0.072143428,
-0.3003333509,
-0.1642016917,
-0.9554895163,
1.0498267412,
-0.7409743667,
0.2542366982,
-0.337988764,
-0.6276113987,
-0.0535128266,
0.1963879317,
-0.7688717842,
1.3150266409,
0.383102268,
-0.8738607168,
0.5536832809,
-0.4646637142,
-0.264626354,
0.2605019808,
-0.1684382409,
-0.2057527751,
0.2954750657,
0.0345836319,
0.049873583,
-0.7804634571,
0.2881321013,
0.1523185074,
-0.1350506246,
0.1055669412,
-0.6670947671,
0.6224886775,
0.4861988425,
-0.2071066946,
-0.3059553802,
-1.165653944,
0.1696326733,
0.1471763551,
-0.3433923125,
-0.5947644711,
-0.201454401,
-0.0037255096,
-0.306435436,
0.2753697634,
-0.526425302,
0.0813657716,
-0.3112800121,
-0.287586689,
0.5035529137,
0.3705824614,
0.5115069151,
-0.2728936076,
0.6229268312,
-0.3783407807,
0.1269036084,
-0.0483289398,
-0.337356329,
-0.7864591479,
-0.0603591986,
0.7299910784,
0.5236893296,
-0.8887890577,
0.1998381317,
-0.1426498443,
-0.5405311584,
-0.6641610861,
0.1694924086,
0.7776945233,
0.7012417316,
0.3996715844,
-0.5408460498,
-0.7403328419,
-0.8022293448,
-0.5923950076,
-0.0752738714,
-0.0772382692,
0.329002589,
0.1925185919,
-0.1640963256,
0.9254744649,
-0.1222437918,
-0.0326973721,
-0.1484452337,
0.6841270924,
0.087310344,
0.1551779956,
0.3799617887,
-1.0083882809,
-0.4864457846,
0.1952817589,
-0.772112608,
-0.4230204821,
0.1297115535,
-0.0828418136,
0.2527528703,
0.1031372175,
-0.3558642566,
0.4656010568,
0.6431245804,
-0.3777917027,
0.7369583845,
-0.2441625595,
0.5659908652,
-0.8579793572,
0.3097932637,
-0.1545889676,
-0.1603366882,
-0.4516768456,
0.3437241614,
-0.0861637592,
0.2099532038,
-0.004346184,
0.6050865054,
-0.7461829185,
-0.5277166367,
-0.2205467075,
0.2690525949,
0.2474955618,
0.0084452285,
-0.355956912,
1.0690900087,
0.0405085348,
-0.7097992897,
0.4304929376,
0.2508017421,
-0.3632786274,
0.6992182732,
-0.4975027442,
0.1646198481,
-0.0603282228,
0.0420366675,
-0.5644693375,
-0.2407503575,
-0.1281648427,
-0.60760957,
0.4494102597,
0.0164155476,
-0.6106384397,
-0.164130345,
-0.1828399152,
0.3899906576,
0.5654571056,
-0.6089033484,
0.5902696848,
0.5230865479,
0.0492606536,
-0.5908131599,
-0.1169751734,
0.1296799779,
-0.2620138824,
-0.2968490422,
0.4579551816,
0.1585967392,
-0.6063040495,
0.3056346774,
-0.1162957102,
0.1705715507,
-0.1324118823,
0.0410234965,
0.0634228587,
-0.1462372094,
0.0220566001,
-0.2042310238,
-0.2786943913,
-0.1782241315,
0.193746835,
0.4755911231,
-0.266285181,
-0.3242536187,
0.1371578872,
0.1723747253,
0.246464327,
-0.5739422441,
0.5811779499,
0.6982882023,
-0.2406459749,
-0.2262489051,
-0.7197911739,
0.1687781662,
-0.4363583922,
0.0637585819,
-0.3638794124,
-0.5231513977,
0.5155017972,
-0.3686570227,
0.0876817107,
0.8841148019,
0.4780605435,
0.0472409502,
0.9000697732,
0.4660648704,
0.3206844628,
0.2246308327,
-0.3626439571,
-0.1598728746,
-1.2977558374,
-0.1935173422,
-0.7265244722,
0.067539528,
-0.7319810987,
-0.4871354103,
0.432282567,
0.3170045912,
-0.1240464076,
0.4591270089,
-0.6781854033,
0.1485336572,
0.6269825697,
-0.3754417598,
0.5666265488,
-0.0401602648,
-0.3164923489,
-0.0987113118,
-0.6409776807,
-0.6775726676,
1.1404895782,
0.1263649464,
0.5919991732,
0.1747600585,
0.491309911,
0.6504876614,
0.4349480271,
-0.4187912941,
0.5347980261,
-0.37359339,
-0.736651361,
-0.1444646716,
-0.7090365887,
-1.2266792059,
0.3403924406,
-0.4760255814,
-0.5893838406,
0.1367022395,
-0.0415865891,
-0.1944958419,
0.2717930377,
-0.6675959826,
0.5414860249,
-0.2154746503,
-0.4163908958,
-0.129298389,
-0.4316637516,
0.4832451046,
-0.1097288877,
0.1966344267,
-0.0574854799,
0.0103843892,
0.6788743138,
-0.3189473152,
0.1267174631,
-0.029002063,
0.0392242745,
0.5590806603,
-0.0445087515,
0.0795941651,
-0.0720470995,
-0.3187541366,
-0.0960769132,
0.0465748832,
-0.0445921272,
-0.6037111878,
0.6346333623,
-0.6031847596,
-0.2925375402,
-0.6985511184,
-0.4664835334,
-0.6147348285,
0.0905696675,
0.367421478,
0.7023979425,
-0.4227721989,
0.2197434157,
0.5892267227,
-0.4508072138,
0.1674488783,
0.3296030164,
-0.4749195278,
-0.6385772228,
1.0039125681,
0.1603662372,
0.3567833006,
0.3809118569,
0.1042701006,
-0.3473728895,
-0.2744739056,
-0.6589308381,
0.0896904171,
-0.6099177003,
-0.4020906687,
-0.5456876159,
-0.2872976661,
-0.3318519294,
0.3466407657,
-0.6144636273,
-0.6218702793,
0.0177312549,
0.1294798255,
0.3756762147,
1.0519894361,
-0.1832856536,
-0.0880094543,
-0.8428072929,
0.8286771774,
0.2348151803,
0.5409616232,
-0.0459735319,
-0.5671114326,
-0.1797527373,
-0.1626856625,
-0.4866786599,
-0.8741773367,
0.1451155096,
0.1836122274,
0.8179219365,
0.0827207789,
0.169556275,
0.7233929038,
-0.6347349286,
0.6466832757,
-0.180650726,
-0.6347004771,
0.5471313,
-0.2233435214,
0.0986908078,
0.8926679492,
0.0476535745,
-0.2007085681,
-0.3003835082,
-0.8779474497,
-0.9624233842,
0.313706547,
0.4599018991,
-0.1766667515,
-0.0336491466,
0.3536949754,
0.1627444476,
0.1305493414,
-0.0999652743,
-0.4912330806,
0.1240992248,
0.0326355249,
0.3054614663,
-0.1620403081,
0.0653614327,
-0.0342360064,
0.7883123159,
0.2070737034,
0.1454566568,
0.1563780755,
-0.0569354072,
-0.2910001278,
0.3811693788,
0.1688746512,
0.6473554373,
-0.323517859,
-0.1585759819,
0.2874202728,
-0.5258362889,
0.1979177892,
0.2821710408,
-0.3483814001,
0.4319744706,
0.2718626559,
0.6844100356,
0.2240008861,
-0.583052218,
0.2129679322,
-0.2979048193,
0.129350394,
-0.3751555383,
0.0034391114,
-0.4262093902,
0.0795764476,
0.7945829034,
0.1127308309,
0.5170506835,
-0.6995196939,
0.2426675409,
0.6075658798,
0.0844431594,
-0.2222949713,
0.6649525762,
0.0378432684,
-0.3356940448,
0.3184861243,
-0.497667104,
-0.4965773523,
0.2834839821,
0.4046671391,
0.967073679,
-0.2922025919,
0.2087747753,
0.5559181571,
0.2208469063,
0.1314955503,
0.137317434,
-0.2445737123,
-0.573795557,
-0.5254919529,
-1.1405465603,
-0.755395174,
-0.0206615068,
-1.1287426949,
-0.0545510277,
-0.0543280505,
-0.4998919964,
-0.0387524702,
0.3265804052,
-0.6590998173,
0.2765063047,
-0.0872482583,
0.8728378415,
-0.4876195788,
0.2612198889,
0.9971871376,
-0.512831986,
-0.6013083458,
0.0323267356,
-0.2289574742,
-0.5215785503,
0.5763142109,
-0.2472129464,
-0.3369690478,
-0.2443392277,
-0.0982407182,
-0.8800488114,
0.9883455634,
0.2857942581,
-0.1195324287,
-0.0128226792,
0.0159910526,
0.7462014556,
-0.0073946961,
0.2683594525,
0.7241772413,
0.4901317656,
-0.0057243109,
-1.2094295025,
-0.3310825527,
-0.3470946848,
0.1861700416,
0.3687454462,
-0.5757470131,
0.6561729312,
0.2439313531,
-0.7397049069,
0.3224901855,
0.7428033948,
0.4911756814,
0.3741817772,
0.5136931539,
0.8721711636,
0.5278565884,
-0.1699954718,
1.2165800333,
-0.2645070553,
0.3742055595,
1.1242471933,
-0.2666555941,
0.9583390951,
0.3447185755,
-0.5046907067,
0.6085898876,
0.1750317365,
0.3111126125,
0.3829785585,
-0.0265929233,
-0.4413487911,
0.0523802117,
-0.4620921016,
-0.5198441744,
0.4558662474,
0.4495066702,
-0.1782149076,
-0.3462262154,
-0.096244432,
-0.3787722588,
0.5053215623,
-0.2694293261,
0.9421271086,
-0.0208664704,
-0.8543727398,
0.5307847261,
-0.0455926098,
0.4682875872,
-0.4242561758,
-0.3149035573,
-0.3195587099,
0.1896011382,
-0.2255392224,
-0.627573669,
0.4446279705,
0.4487908185,
-0.1487684995,
-0.2835687697,
0.9552310109,
-0.0147563089,
-0.4840958416,
0.3151870072,
0.6556353569,
0.0719714761,
0.2155845016,
-0.5533340573,
0.29099527,
-0.3742400408,
-0.4082883596,
0.280218631,
0.5348610282,
-0.0202884171,
0.4890850186,
0.5390747786,
0.3373092115,
0.2749977112,
0.3162523508,
0.6572659612,
-0.5338965058,
-0.0041247257,
-0.2923022807,
0.3721531332,
-0.2265185565,
-0.2839337885,
1.1520081758,
0.6561484933,
0.7520544529,
0.3030430079,
0.7266684771,
-0.3652249873,
1.2850117683,
-0.3022681177,
0.6258301139,
-0.5082148314,
0.2020613551,
-0.3767146468,
-1.1847530603,
0.0698216259,
0.459695667,
-0.0310846064,
0.2106980234,
0.4928076565,
0.3783015609,
-0.013815552,
0.037903361,
0.2696531713,
0.0012730208,
-0.0430804864,
0.0702346638,
1.0839920044,
-0.7535366416,
0.4151345789,
-0.3504216671,
-0.2464625686,
0.0591475852,
-0.8044999242,
-0.3725356758,
-0.7931509018,
-0.0792820603,
-0.3321136236,
0.1870149821,
0.5445439816,
0.3672223389,
-0.7734739184,
-0.0593982115,
-0.1166591868,
-0.2084826678,
-0.1392565072,
-0.3105222285,
0.2218466848,
-0.5127497911,
-0.6772100329,
0.5069551468,
0.2370552868,
-0.2911523283,
-0.4415935874,
0.0065264651,
-0.2604222298,
0.0422013216,
0.6411178112,
0.5990386009,
-0.5638141632,
-0.2447620481,
0.0680787116,
-0.0579009987,
-0.1620354503,
0.6402550936,
-1.0908770561,
0.5715690851,
0.4827857912,
1.010690093,
0.395940274,
0.5598931909,
0.5387591124,
-0.8222734332,
-0.1934553385,
0.3431902528,
0.2468429804,
0.5968725681,
-0.0313640237,
0.9146617651,
0.0494402498,
-0.847409308,
-1.0361486673,
0.1205259115,
-0.6118130088,
0.1796106398,
1.1071023941,
0.1435472965,
0.0267309044,
-0.1770249605,
-0.1099030375,
0.4818602502,
0.0052312161,
0.5194926262,
0.3908127546,
-0.2961389124,
0.0691348165,
-0.8036285043,
0.4514523149,
0.4569229186,
-0.796348691,
-0.0074079586,
0.6883538365,
-0.068860285,
0.5751331449,
0.58588624,
-0.270196259,
0.1934860945,
0.1041091233,
0.0214373805,
0.3436019123,
-0.3240416348,
-0.2270528674,
0.2199221551,
0.1080227494,
-0.0189324375
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08032v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08032v1
|
Exploring the Potential of Conversational AI Support for Agent-Based Social Simulation Model Design
| 2024-05-12T22:11:54 | 2024-05-12T22:11:54 |
Peer-Olaf Siebers
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SE
|
ChatGPT, the AI-powered chatbot with a massive user base of hundreds of
millions, has become a global phenomenon. However, the use of Conversational AI
Systems (CAISs) like ChatGPT for research in the field of Social Simulation is
still limited. Specifically, there is no evidence of its usage in Agent-Based
Social Simulation (ABSS) model design. While scepticism towards anything new is
inherent to human nature, we firmly believe it is imperative to initiate the
use of this innovative technology to support ABSS model design. This paper
presents a proof-of-concept that demonstrates how CAISs can facilitate the
development of innovative conceptual ABSS models in a concise timeframe and
with minimal required upfront case-based knowledge. By employing advanced
prompt engineering techniques and adhering to the Engineering ABSS framework,
we have constructed a comprehensive prompt script that enables the design of
ABSS models with or by the CAIS. The effectiveness of the script is
demonstrated through an illustrative case study concerning the use of adaptive
architecture in museums. Despite occasional inaccuracies and divergences in
conversation, the CAIS proved to be a valuable companion for ABSS modellers.
|
[
-0.4170443416,
-0.8717263341,
0.4546299577,
0.0860616267,
-0.3120825291,
0.3857357502,
0.1290257126,
-0.4197002351,
0.1796733886,
0.0168201085,
-0.5051800609,
-0.3583351076,
-0.0284755491,
-0.1064600721,
-0.404851675,
0.6593329906,
0.2517765164,
0.153973341,
-0.0921771675,
0.0397223197,
-0.5209875703,
-0.4812371731,
-1.0919458866,
-0.1629384905,
0.1263243258,
0.3023776412,
0.9889154434,
0.3847138882,
0.2700343132,
0.2604519427,
-0.0318464078,
0.2031336278,
-0.2453562766,
0.1637674272,
-0.0251488592,
-0.2064584494,
-0.4973253906,
-0.3243536353,
0.2666881382,
0.4703683853,
-0.1916341931,
-0.0413719304,
0.1667152047,
0.2933932841,
-0.2192905247,
0.7943499684,
-0.4008565247,
-0.2137761563,
0.2767035961,
-0.0358627476,
-0.4216856062,
-0.1391542554,
0.0964051411,
-0.6616479754,
0.0552310422,
0.2293768376,
0.5272941589,
0.0829048455,
0.0410835817,
-0.4130337834,
-0.7772161961,
0.2850601077,
-0.6595289111,
0.2649403512,
0.0381512269,
0.6009803414,
-0.3508509099,
-0.5833188295,
-0.6757619381,
-0.5705889463,
-0.0505274124,
-0.0355619006,
-0.2476799637,
0.1755252182,
0.2276974022,
-0.188340202,
-0.5982640386,
-0.0641775951,
-0.1424299181,
-0.1579212695,
0.75564152,
0.3680471778,
0.4365261495,
-0.0326950401,
-0.4702539444,
-0.2629139125,
-0.6327608228,
0.1775682122,
0.1300102472,
0.4520014524,
-0.4602140188,
0.4614432752,
-0.1600825787,
0.1548907608,
-0.0740895942,
0.249902308,
-0.0845550597,
-0.068983376,
0.1816603839,
0.0843409076,
0.7107147574,
0.4117942154,
0.3770737946,
-0.0602167621,
-0.1628139466,
0.4169915915,
0.1769466549,
-0.8123751283,
-0.2351230681,
0.1718792915,
-0.3195337057,
-0.2575526536,
-0.2148361504,
-0.6100630164,
-0.7005547285,
-0.1897631139,
0.1796823889,
-0.4693135917,
-0.4018300176,
0.152504459,
-0.396042645,
0.3309233189,
0.5727239847,
-0.390776217,
0.1888256073,
0.6014238,
0.9993177652,
0.0248709172,
-0.1219118088,
-0.1857780367,
0.2734650373,
-0.4822423756,
1.039034009,
-0.4960283935,
-0.9717864394,
0.1364125311,
-0.2982811034,
0.1540430337,
-0.1273706108,
0.3951830566,
-0.3728742301,
-0.3356823623,
-0.0236979295,
-0.194443509,
0.1344386041,
0.3524116576,
-0.4201420546,
0.502607584,
0.0286360346,
-0.4796162844,
0.0039658691,
-1.0722978115,
-0.3561965823,
0.4667818546,
-0.5415896773,
-0.4067538977,
0.0323546007,
0.3040640056,
0.2550660372,
-0.1747366339,
0.3831315041,
-0.5390310287,
-0.5184794664,
0.4702729881,
-0.5727859735,
0.5779911876,
0.4830631018,
-0.4009676576,
-0.0166567173,
-0.277828753,
-0.2642954886,
0.2664205134,
0.068317987,
0.0281039793,
0.3109368682,
-0.0107242353,
-0.0723470226,
0.0011347207,
-0.3074729443,
0.1920658499,
-0.2035455108,
0.3536800444,
0.8552085757,
0.1143094376,
0.4240184128,
-0.8430005908,
0.7083814144,
-0.4083118737,
0.0310017113,
-0.5750871301,
-0.6184829473,
-0.6059029102,
-0.2781822383,
-0.0775120258,
0.4100371003,
-1.0357377529,
-0.0845760182,
-0.1890734732,
-0.7070308924,
-0.2038223445,
-0.6036781073,
0.1161945388,
0.2451810688,
-0.0298182089,
-0.5775619745,
-0.4523844421,
-0.5888326764,
0.0717035979,
-0.8907569051,
-0.0764347836,
0.6608726382,
0.3165792823,
-0.0568186529,
1.0204946995,
-0.1703445315,
0.0263685435,
-0.2868022919,
0.2420721054,
-0.0338377468,
0.5141442418,
0.7985118628,
-0.5839048028,
-0.2489141077,
-0.1168273017,
-0.6906732321,
-0.0834662914,
-0.2153942287,
-0.1103743017,
0.1583853662,
0.3092055023,
-0.9615244865,
1.0195518732,
0.063954398,
-0.2761619091,
0.7691112757,
-0.0334202498,
0.2920102477,
-1.0400276184,
0.0824683756,
-0.0787056983,
0.072786279,
-0.6492973566,
-0.0113297347,
-0.3610939682,
-0.7025321722,
-0.5107628703,
0.8873198628,
-0.3687194288,
0.0990126878,
-0.4230699241,
0.0664545819,
-0.0242582541,
0.6250122786,
0.332251966,
0.7376561761,
0.7033039331,
-0.6442490816,
0.3721795082,
0.5438908339,
-0.2603757679,
0.754845202,
-0.9631053209,
0.3341066241,
-0.292912513,
0.4936549664,
-1.1134849787,
-0.0879343599,
0.5229329467,
-0.7193914056,
-0.0076168324,
-0.2631890774,
-0.3044747412,
-0.2906627953,
-0.1238496602,
0.3346880972,
0.4088864923,
-0.3642653525,
0.9773974419,
0.6499429345,
-0.6851792336,
-0.153049022,
-0.4017262757,
0.3355903625,
-0.1872489601,
-0.8113366961,
0.0837482885,
-0.3717935681,
-0.6091471314,
-0.1858861595,
0.0911802202,
-0.0122003099,
0.2295468748,
0.288141638,
0.4189295173,
-0.3116297126,
0.2150680423,
-0.19931373,
-0.0260743219,
0.1932558268,
-0.1176777706,
0.7407187223,
-0.3397530615,
-0.922285378,
-0.6825336814,
0.4612398148,
0.664475739,
-0.0644462332,
0.4941696227,
0.1523306519,
-0.4401321709,
-0.1598377973,
-0.4244528711,
-0.3411484361,
-0.5679140091,
0.2463594973,
-0.1287145466,
-0.4882891178,
0.8117204309,
-0.0578099452,
0.3246181011,
-0.05345577,
0.4809131622,
-0.085390985,
1.0818591118,
0.3565429747,
-0.0194969494,
0.7985920906,
-0.2502814233,
0.2877958119,
-0.3271259964,
-0.2790322304,
-0.7796752453,
0.0027131797,
-0.3233100772,
-0.3475723863,
0.471978724,
-0.5475575328,
-0.4092061222,
0.119362317,
-0.2823636234,
0.2574060559,
0.3033732474,
0.1894170791,
0.0854531229,
-0.0522233061,
0.2040473223,
0.5160281062,
-0.8280567527,
-0.8745462298,
0.5952507257,
0.1577701569,
0.9886867404,
0.0714121014,
0.3652366996,
0.8106012344,
0.520835638,
-0.7071833014,
0.7647936344,
0.3234541714,
-0.6965121627,
-0.511552155,
-0.0575260185,
-0.8822097182,
-0.1354938149,
-0.0887095854,
-0.6667538285,
0.3834835589,
0.195227921,
-0.491710037,
0.1505528837,
-0.8530320525,
0.6666251421,
-0.2086418271,
-0.3369116783,
-0.2856327295,
-0.4409301877,
-0.2615279853,
0.2567206621,
0.6050015092,
-0.270709008,
0.5210212469,
0.4631934762,
-0.3388564885,
1.1551872492,
-0.1971778125,
0.1121454313,
0.8960537314,
0.5059830546,
0.6521443725,
0.2842155993,
-0.1601054519,
0.06661883,
-0.0684842989,
-0.3704950809,
-0.6027725339,
0.3501333892,
-0.7960762978,
-0.8394583464,
-0.173077032,
-0.5832366347,
-0.1796458215,
-0.0253373832,
-0.3329473138,
0.5768211484,
-0.6533145905,
0.210791558,
0.237242654,
-0.0210686363,
0.4791526794,
0.5984944701,
0.0841629356,
-0.0088344356,
0.6380968094,
-0.138786599,
0.1607439965,
0.1292383522,
0.159412235,
-0.177019611,
-0.4305530488,
-0.5417075157,
-0.1393270642,
-0.5034983158,
-0.1795412898,
-0.434869796,
-0.3100108206,
-0.8114366531,
-0.5361253619,
-0.2368488908,
-0.4096573591,
-0.2610959411,
-0.2779379785,
0.3537218273,
0.7754276991,
-0.1751005203,
0.4826816022,
-0.6541318297,
0.0653939545,
0.2996127009,
0.2010189891,
0.2465248555,
-0.3129246235,
-0.2179916799,
0.5359002948,
-0.3048918247,
-0.9604171515,
0.361394763,
-0.0356148928,
0.94480443,
0.5013027787,
0.3356963098,
0.4852236807,
-0.3886394203,
0.8406760097,
-0.1600596011,
-0.6845513582,
0.468129158,
-0.6789035797,
-0.0736984909,
0.2315854132,
0.0751893371,
-0.7304639816,
-0.3077039123,
-0.9585728049,
-0.7339223623,
0.6098908782,
0.2683932185,
0.437820971,
-0.0900080055,
0.1669720709,
-0.0184452701,
0.1577204913,
-0.4230783284,
-0.0214936379,
-0.3695941865,
-0.1856618524,
-0.0329817645,
-0.0695368499,
-0.0597873405,
0.2944317162,
1.0073040724,
-0.2362169027,
0.3902103603,
0.0403716937,
0.2174259573,
0.095193252,
0.0739678591,
0.2133493572,
0.3570374846,
0.0760295466,
-0.1683927476,
0.2392554879,
-0.1598923802,
-0.0250114296,
0.3108909726,
-0.2106527537,
-0.0898087919,
-0.0785621852,
0.7492665648,
-0.0891796798,
-0.7648999691,
0.4010560513,
-0.2227900177,
0.1633763462,
-0.5100664496,
0.1914559901,
0.1323192418,
0.5280197263,
0.3795739114,
-0.0116435485,
0.0105989994,
-0.6901808381,
0.3648889661,
0.7727348208,
-0.4394298196,
-0.2431210279,
0.7276962399,
0.3415526748,
-1.0104094744,
0.552097857,
-0.165391624,
-0.2672638893,
0.9898603559,
0.3174631298,
0.7841730118,
-0.1883001477,
0.6021776795,
0.0517341755,
0.178058669,
0.0198140088,
0.0120237637,
-0.2844513953,
-0.882568717,
0.0977189392,
-0.2484348118,
-0.9494164586,
-0.2483157516,
-0.1929424107,
0.6304970384,
-0.3252395093,
-0.1725534499,
-0.20790492,
-0.2310566753,
-0.5746259093,
-0.1172573864,
0.3333131671,
0.8391084671,
-0.8496956825,
0.2871277928,
0.7036390305,
-0.4358019829,
-0.8706998229,
-0.2397141755,
-0.0448939241,
-1.0325849056,
0.0134989899,
-0.0182442199,
-0.1865365952,
-0.0628599599,
-0.8568940759,
-0.6064529419,
1.1261113882,
0.2642378509,
-0.2019765079,
-0.2513454556,
0.195274353,
0.6889103055,
-0.6152418852,
0.5020115376,
0.1871530563,
0.1917398423,
0.5507344007,
-0.7304555178,
-0.1159950346,
-0.5056846738,
-0.1792912632,
-0.3881371319,
-0.8013580441,
0.5082961917,
-0.3192549348,
-0.4443477392,
0.4861151576,
0.5934796929,
0.6417209506,
0.6984385848,
0.4809350073,
0.0428848043,
0.4693773985,
0.0287202969,
0.8765152097,
-0.4695802331,
0.040241491,
0.7487556934,
-0.4477958977,
0.2776038647,
0.0514889471,
-0.0125125526,
0.596308589,
0.5572891831,
0.2240165919,
0.3045293689,
0.2025843114,
-0.5106375217,
-0.2273542732,
-0.5958904624,
-0.4267745912,
0.3911210001,
0.7136946321,
0.0679900199,
-0.2497150451,
-0.1865035295,
-0.040679723,
-0.137294665,
-0.2061373591,
0.781118691,
0.0385248251,
-0.4400914907,
0.0202302821,
-0.3179911077,
0.1224579513,
-0.592695713,
-0.3346660435,
-0.4195011854,
-0.1026059613,
0.3903906345,
-0.607804358,
0.1035985202,
-0.1399596184,
0.4356772602,
-0.1916785687,
0.8610203862,
-0.1158826575,
-0.3563769162,
-0.1077168882,
0.7415323853,
0.2670744658,
0.026439108,
-0.5176724792,
-0.0399126895,
-0.1917648911,
-0.0529119298,
0.0423310064,
0.7028466463,
-0.3541446924,
1.0242073536,
0.7807870507,
-0.0618767776,
-0.4942727983,
0.0707789138,
1.096547842,
-0.3116602302,
-0.9110540152,
-0.7512739301,
0.5899339914,
-0.1008180603,
0.0476523452,
0.3148422837,
0.4536350369,
0.5901235342,
0.1268060952,
1.0888640881,
0.0103212604,
0.2043468803,
-0.0689583048,
0.7385777831,
-0.132371366,
0.4124880135,
-0.5670943856,
-0.4415287375,
-0.2527721822,
0.7435652614,
-0.1308393329,
-0.0009651531,
0.1569161415,
1.245994091,
0.2673627734,
0.5668514967,
0.2619157732,
0.045214165,
0.8271596432,
0.1952390373,
1.3095836639,
0.1445936859,
0.7417814136,
-0.1219741106,
-0.380907774,
-0.2103525549,
-0.8373735547,
-0.9263007641,
-0.5653640628,
-0.2753738463,
-0.3657821119,
0.5474960804,
0.9992086291,
0.6178559661,
-0.5298030376,
-0.3384426236,
0.0175224673,
0.0672998875,
-0.1896677166,
-0.1953298002,
0.3697623909,
0.0090882406,
-0.5928327441,
0.281789273,
0.1510377824,
0.5705085993,
-0.2586049736,
-0.0725859255,
0.1596099287,
0.4811093807,
0.2589828074,
0.457003653,
-0.1949227303,
-0.4911146462,
0.141496852,
-0.0039168135,
0.1186706647,
0.7426351905,
-0.9434603453,
0.268997997,
0.3363733888,
0.5982837677,
0.2892262638,
0.2224339843,
0.7114558816,
-0.3670807481,
0.3574753106,
0.3315132856,
0.6431382298,
0.3302124143,
-0.4251324236,
0.4209460914,
0.3224950135,
-0.5002069473,
-0.6510366797,
0.4052186012,
-0.8542962074,
-0.1596695483,
1.1139742136,
-0.086415045,
-0.2182177454,
-0.3913519382,
-0.7614610195,
0.2796853483,
-0.8622111082,
1.273504734,
0.6013233066,
-0.2785572112,
-0.0629175827,
-0.1812391132,
0.1210688874,
0.0473192893,
-0.6088793278,
0.1383204609,
0.6437197924,
-0.1365714371,
0.2547845244,
0.8483177423,
0.1079079658,
0.4452268779,
0.302685827,
0.1812620461,
-0.2562146783,
-0.1906802058,
0.1633487046,
0.1182985306,
0.1793495566,
-0.1495592296
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13005v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13005v1
|
Understanding the Rare Inflammatory Disease Using Large Language Models and Social Media Data
| 2024-05-12T20:54:23 | 2024-05-12T20:54:23 |
Nan Miles Xi, Hong-Long Ji, Lin Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SI
|
Sarcoidosis is a rare inflammatory disease characterized by the formation of
granulomas in various organs. The disease presents diagnostic and treatment
challenges due to its diverse manifestations and unpredictable nature. In this
study, we employed a Large Language Model (LLM) to analyze sarcoidosis-related
discussions on the social media platform Reddit. Our findings underscore the
efficacy of LLMs in accurately identifying sarcoidosis-related content. We
discovered a wide array of symptoms reported by patients, with fatigue, swollen
lymph nodes, and shortness of breath as the most prevalent. Prednisone was the
most prescribed medication, while infliximab showed the highest effectiveness
in improving prognoses. Notably, our analysis revealed disparities in prognosis
based on age and gender, with women and younger patients experiencing good and
polarized outcomes, respectively. Furthermore, unsupervised clustering
identified three distinct patient subgroups (phenotypes) with unique symptom
profiles, prognostic outcomes, and demographic distributions. Finally,
sentiment analysis revealed a moderate negative impact on patients' mental
health post-diagnosis, particularly among women and younger individuals. Our
study represents the first application of LLMs to understand sarcoidosis
through social media data. It contributes to understanding the disease by
providing data-driven insights into its manifestations, treatments, prognoses,
and impact on patients' lives. Our findings have direct implications for
improving personalized treatment strategies and enhancing the quality of care
for individuals living with sarcoidosis.
|
[
-0.2417943329,
-0.8689568043,
0.8639965057,
0.0359472223,
-0.5888311267,
0.3869800866,
-0.2575207353,
-0.51768291,
0.7361667156,
0.6127243638,
-0.3172658086,
-0.7869364619,
-1.0132575035,
-0.2278813273,
-0.3287330866,
1.3051655293,
0.1212606654,
0.6537632942,
-0.1708935797,
-0.1373288631,
0.1152622849,
-0.3301730454,
-0.8566441536,
-0.3802676797,
0.5973244905,
0.2375312746,
0.6735822558,
-0.0078500966,
0.651802361,
0.0849343687,
-0.3202805221,
0.1031377614,
-0.557631731,
0.1621109545,
-0.1905682534,
-0.1969673634,
-0.4750330448,
-0.1624359041,
0.4690679908,
0.7610654831,
-0.1864942461,
-0.0510346405,
-0.1055501476,
0.549949646,
-0.0594230406,
-0.6190779805,
-0.3509876132,
0.2272034138,
-0.4786949754,
-0.0606453158,
0.2507658005,
-0.0992802754,
-0.0611564666,
-0.1925294399,
0.2796755433,
-0.1498724371,
0.5320571065,
0.0268924404,
-0.6507542729,
-0.5523569584,
-0.6932085752,
0.4081699848,
-0.5841651559,
0.0674864277,
0.3408558071,
0.54753685,
-0.1985259056,
-0.6029346585,
-0.4330198467,
-0.115909338,
-0.0610207021,
0.0760544613,
-0.3544785678,
-0.1571745872,
-0.0288217664,
0.3670732379,
-0.6000764966,
0.1370853335,
-0.5889385939,
0.0147464322,
0.6551958919,
0.3650371134,
0.6026813388,
-0.4691880345,
-0.3099430501,
0.5427305698,
-0.1963093728,
0.0869804993,
0.276357621,
0.1080223098,
-0.5256099701,
0.4177217185,
0.0089137666,
0.5232509971,
-0.2587440014,
-0.1526743621,
0.0750801116,
-0.006863141,
-0.0175863374,
-0.0951242223,
0.8832709193,
0.2681614757,
0.0325040445,
-0.1508062929,
-0.026897477,
-0.1538965404,
0.3315298259,
-0.6983302236,
-0.0471688509,
0.8237525225,
-0.7310958505,
-0.2884019017,
-0.0661933795,
-0.7412893176,
-0.6246674061,
0.0791938305,
-0.196059674,
-0.2292866558,
-0.4016012549,
-0.2402755618,
-0.0875772312,
-0.2810273767,
0.5005379915,
-0.4371694624,
0.6148989797,
0.5173687935,
0.7326327562,
-0.2786377966,
0.0840507522,
-0.4708161056,
0.1487216651,
-0.3476654887,
0.8893175125,
-0.833876431,
-0.3640063703,
-0.0722816437,
-0.0993594974,
-0.1612497866,
-0.7315631509,
0.5325596333,
-0.1300360709,
-0.3481850624,
0.0211131927,
-0.2690736651,
0.1535079032,
0.0607605278,
-0.6155961156,
0.6327804327,
0.2184899151,
-0.6116704345,
-0.0983718708,
-0.7123154998,
-0.3291622102,
0.4034808874,
-0.113573283,
-0.17747657,
0.4687700868,
0.0516725443,
0.7682484984,
-0.7323827744,
0.3325038254,
-0.4880645871,
-0.0887062103,
0.4917074144,
0.0830983296,
0.2644109726,
0.4997158647,
0.0570859835,
-0.0632885993,
-0.5492212772,
0.0553523377,
0.1614630967,
0.1296826303,
-0.4331786335,
-0.1471047252,
-0.0043453393,
0.214515686,
0.0876677707,
-0.3363066018,
0.2376092821,
-0.0189824793,
0.4954279363,
0.3077937067,
0.630705595,
0.2298576832,
-0.3772366643,
0.8239540458,
0.4570656717,
0.3283994198,
0.1684449166,
-0.4344372153,
0.1316835284,
-0.3692258,
0.2247540504,
0.19464311,
-0.1241851449,
-0.1774785817,
-0.2123965919,
-0.7717000842,
-0.3992116451,
0.2047734559,
0.1727651954,
-0.1524241865,
-0.1217026114,
-0.0317953937,
-0.2389935255,
-0.7881093025,
-0.3118025959,
0.4344598353,
0.3588517308,
0.5963457227,
0.6214090586,
-0.8862913251,
0.0970456004,
-0.5832237005,
-0.686132431,
-0.3344014287,
0.5064461231,
0.0101286471,
0.2382049859,
0.5091308951,
-0.7968223095,
-0.563162446,
0.5465719104,
-0.4542892575,
-0.0357358865,
0.2102417946,
0.123466216,
-0.0253739823,
0.5018907785,
-0.5180017948,
0.3488469124,
0.9954975247,
-0.0619192943,
0.312822789,
-0.0404618718,
0.118688643,
-1.1781220436,
0.1524240375,
0.1365919411,
-0.4913159013,
-0.362089783,
-0.0926871672,
-0.2354187071,
-0.5214834213,
-0.0476041809,
0.4039086998,
-0.2096595019,
-0.0651803538,
-0.334476769,
0.3192223608,
-0.1820949614,
-0.1026000306,
-0.1358309835,
0.2414655089,
0.7304677367,
-0.4664966166,
0.1003966257,
-0.4232609868,
-0.524061799,
0.4476289749,
-0.7630264759,
-0.1190668568,
-0.176616326,
0.5060512424,
-1.0600852966,
-0.4610212445,
0.4251918495,
-0.7923530936,
0.0540542193,
-0.3852838874,
-0.3940570354,
-0.4020816386,
0.1216231883,
0.5904487967,
0.1314890981,
0.0052676774,
0.7526065707,
0.5838564634,
-0.5995178819,
-0.2666831017,
-0.4289945066,
-0.0333631672,
-0.0785495564,
-0.5418055058,
0.4494156539,
-0.1161142588,
-0.5836620927,
0.2746940255,
-0.094632268,
-0.4480901659,
0.0380409434,
0.3973578811,
-0.2783486843,
0.0864658356,
0.4305282533,
-0.113683939,
0.1883926094,
-0.3268167377,
0.1487257332,
0.9549508095,
-0.2808484137,
-0.3343521357,
-0.321934551,
0.6660273671,
1.0196033716,
-0.1801077574,
0.9789313078,
0.527428329,
-0.679903388,
-0.3120739758,
-0.3220535517,
-0.0714389756,
-0.2370120883,
0.2538069785,
-0.1887332499,
-0.504876852,
1.0182474852,
-0.3786961138,
-0.4037744403,
0.3738144934,
0.3976594508,
-0.5096991658,
0.8925657272,
0.5767521858,
0.1627295911,
0.1128347889,
-0.2787123621,
0.5166725516,
-0.8647016883,
-0.4351666868,
-0.5305268168,
-0.3777109981,
-0.3465024531,
-0.5418269038,
0.3604241908,
0.3066159189,
0.4826047421,
-0.238259241,
-0.1644176245,
0.2332520485,
-0.1032828838,
0.5642113686,
-0.0150296204,
-0.096363686,
0.0504420996,
-0.3209544122,
-0.8283200264,
-0.4952295125,
1.1158515215,
0.3656486571,
0.6902994514,
0.2957912982,
0.7810975313,
0.8905036449,
0.3289803565,
-0.8517844081,
0.1867457181,
-0.5804734826,
-0.5324367881,
-0.1458352953,
-0.7278638482,
-1.0988353491,
-0.2046077251,
-0.303619802,
-0.6784927249,
-0.1464504153,
-0.0989121571,
-0.3053440452,
0.2185744941,
-0.561268568,
0.8099665046,
-0.6892672181,
-0.4107953608,
-0.480645895,
-0.4353572428,
0.4722290933,
-0.1358644813,
0.7077459097,
-0.0609824397,
0.0152589511,
0.7319256067,
-0.4119515121,
0.739593029,
0.0472361371,
-0.0457608141,
0.11011713,
-0.1016505286,
0.3958913088,
0.3638024032,
0.0616893321,
0.3501526713,
0.1461260766,
-0.7035703063,
-0.8935725093,
1.1506146193,
-0.8186696768,
-0.3572688103,
-0.6259338856,
-0.2695588768,
0.0339910276,
0.1459038705,
-0.0246465635,
0.5041883588,
-0.5002504587,
0.2654547691,
0.5981394649,
-0.1422111988,
-0.0514143817,
0.5187213421,
-0.1386285722,
-0.6239091158,
0.7146155238,
0.1973700672,
0.1001127511,
0.2778453529,
0.4248203039,
0.1018362492,
-0.6844750047,
-0.0783650875,
0.6545565724,
-0.7129781246,
0.1311742663,
-1.0425726175,
-0.2685958743,
-0.5423241854,
-0.152449429,
-0.3934648037,
-0.1785655171,
-0.1534096003,
0.1844252795,
0.1709220707,
0.834213078,
-0.0219232682,
0.2755199075,
-0.8523988724,
0.4127254188,
0.0638472363,
0.2941957116,
0.1104493439,
-0.3360137045,
-0.2431066185,
0.3891744614,
0.1006305739,
-0.8065232635,
0.3163758218,
0.1960415393,
0.5976050496,
0.5736475587,
0.1078414544,
0.3533330858,
0.2322099507,
0.7344234586,
0.2380703837,
-0.7107473612,
0.5191248059,
-0.4300478399,
0.2802353799,
0.2373818606,
0.8126185536,
-0.8314365149,
-0.1738304943,
-0.9263973236,
-0.925951004,
0.5928608775,
0.124291271,
-0.0564806163,
-0.1983748674,
0.2611857057,
-0.0274931099,
-0.0388499759,
-0.6105768085,
-0.0164609905,
0.0084159002,
-0.070597589,
-0.1975660473,
-0.5431021452,
-0.5736276507,
-0.1790059358,
0.6569146514,
-0.0997059867,
0.1677032113,
0.3020437658,
-0.2998894751,
-0.2891912162,
0.3354177475,
0.8467013836,
0.710776329,
-0.2113866955,
0.2480361909,
-0.0433490463,
-0.3873601854,
-0.2306849957,
-0.0256152786,
0.1999300271,
0.088904798,
0.447109282,
0.6886763573,
0.2399996966,
-0.8752570152,
0.6535182595,
-0.2023324817,
-0.0814535618,
-0.5472252965,
-0.1387820691,
0.4653967321,
0.3938592076,
0.5369755626,
0.3886035681,
-0.1186959371,
-0.6926398277,
0.0097799152,
0.6583755612,
-0.6489574313,
-0.4121931493,
0.2010097802,
0.4137298465,
-0.4430827796,
0.1274407804,
-0.0164829902,
-0.3447547853,
0.7560520768,
0.3249341249,
0.4428949058,
0.0621966794,
0.6077349782,
0.2971522212,
0.2229093015,
0.0241103116,
-0.106999062,
-0.0553821884,
-0.4620834589,
0.2251846194,
-0.7540297508,
-0.1613012105,
0.3937572837,
-0.5531211495,
0.1440918297,
-0.7795472741,
-0.4747134149,
0.324622333,
0.1667823046,
-0.3655500412,
0.3154686987,
-0.0597699061,
0.5160360932,
-0.887483716,
0.6610136032,
1.2678382397,
-0.2523786128,
-0.4062865376,
0.4446989894,
-0.0946522281,
-0.6567881703,
0.6384589672,
0.0183510743,
-0.2468058616,
-0.0831563473,
-0.5753457546,
-0.7917340994,
0.985776782,
0.1259910017,
-0.4414499104,
0.5642089844,
0.0160918608,
0.9126117826,
-0.8438549042,
0.1873710006,
0.123054862,
0.2507441938,
0.3029118776,
-0.6336310506,
-0.1837010831,
-0.5581692457,
-0.1401133388,
0.2554736435,
-0.8223927617,
0.5944841504,
-0.5922113657,
-0.389403373,
0.0957750157,
-0.0528116003,
-0.1603945494,
0.6288197637,
0.0519830696,
0.8350259066,
0.9983728528,
0.0389192551,
1.5265916586,
-0.4715630412,
0.0903779194,
0.6935560703,
-0.1577198356,
0.7769159675,
0.3508727849,
0.116296351,
0.3159980476,
0.4869551659,
0.46200791,
0.3546083868,
0.270198971,
-0.4168040156,
-0.4908240438,
-0.4467295408,
-0.437915951,
0.2574385703,
0.4313007891,
-0.708186388,
-0.2002936602,
0.1364723146,
0.1042669564,
0.1200077534,
-0.2742558718,
0.7062923312,
0.0676624104,
-0.3546034098,
0.7648739815,
0.043175403,
0.3971832395,
-0.8774283528,
0.1839381605,
-0.416212976,
0.2562455237,
-0.5205837488,
-0.6782264709,
0.5557796359,
0.0779499486,
-0.7353799939,
0.1362085789,
0.5406051278,
-0.3866627812,
-0.6676001549,
0.5651031137,
0.4869562089,
0.5433318615,
-0.2022699118,
-0.4791526794,
0.5133114457,
0.0204582736,
0.3164785802,
0.5492609739,
0.6104252934,
-0.2765265405,
0.9003489017,
0.5823700428,
0.2899612486,
-0.3353273273,
0.2187813967,
0.745208025,
-0.6181709766,
0.0293231849,
-0.4533992112,
0.4643712938,
-0.2227715254,
-0.4998593032,
0.4940478206,
0.2153900862,
0.4001534581,
0.070978187,
0.9335111976,
-0.1574105173,
0.5289335847,
-0.3146951199,
1.0457088947,
-0.9593151808,
0.4579648077,
-0.4208901525,
-0.4955107868,
-0.3291019797,
0.2680294216,
-0.67755723,
0.0108064068,
0.873036921,
0.7607135773,
-0.1008855551,
-0.2240997404,
0.1414255649,
0.6130780578,
0.2154409587,
0.4694574177,
0.5942435861,
-0.2655171156,
0.4399154782,
-0.1618314832,
-0.2480863035,
-0.3998944461,
-0.5458067656,
-0.9621036649,
-0.5918331742,
-0.336818248,
-0.1865634471,
0.4537360072,
0.9352366328,
0.6491672993,
-0.5826306939,
-0.0599120595,
0.1161211282,
0.3354257643,
-0.364951849,
-0.2204948813,
-0.0362443738,
0.3621841073,
-0.3201107383,
0.0433245637,
0.1159989461,
0.2082770467,
0.1027330831,
-0.2244516462,
-0.1703736782,
-0.1827244908,
0.5661723614,
0.1987131238,
-0.8247796297,
0.2914555669,
-0.2718749344,
-0.3860827088,
-0.2273515016,
1.0099401474,
-0.2571520805,
0.2058752775,
0.256600678,
0.5188293457,
0.5358386636,
0.0971654877,
0.5385378003,
-0.1782458723,
-0.1553528756,
0.5995252728,
0.1742611676,
0.2736010849,
-0.4935535192,
-0.0158992764,
0.2866151631,
-0.3711231649,
-0.8598105311,
0.1823044121,
-1.2817699909,
-0.4883924425,
1.2839727402,
0.016510129,
-0.2241202891,
-0.1863616109,
-0.3529328108,
-0.0656288415,
-0.6810911894,
1.0017879009,
0.6407483816,
-0.195096761,
-0.5739096999,
-0.3781541884,
0.244843334,
0.2193672061,
-0.7186818123,
-0.1547369957,
0.2115458995,
0.4508114457,
-0.1229861826,
0.8141587973,
-0.3077224195,
0.4761630595,
-0.1424579918,
-0.0713824332,
-0.0470597073,
-0.1796740294,
-0.176756382,
0.3371373117,
-0.1715494394,
0.3626098037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13004v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13004v1
|
MathDivide: Improved mathematical reasoning by large language models
| 2024-05-12T20:21:15 | 2024-05-12T20:21:15 |
Saksham Sahai Srivastava, Ashutosh Gandhi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models have been proven to be capable of handling complex
linguistic and cognitive tasks. Therefore their usage has been extended to
tasks requiring logical reasoning ability such as Mathematics. In this paper,
we propose a prompting technique called MathDivide that breaks down the
mathematical problem into simpler subproblems. Each of the subproblems is
formulated as an algebraic expression whose value is evaluated by the Python
code generated by the LLM for the corresponding algebraic expression. The
values fed to the Python code are the numerical values provided in the problem
statement. The solutions for the subproblems are composed together to obtain
the final answer for the problem statement. Finally, the final answer is
compared to the correct answer. If the final answer matches the correct answer,
it is produced as output else a refinement prompt is fed to the LLM. We
experiment with this prompting technique on both closed-source LLM models and
open-source LLM models using GSM8K dataset. The results obtained demonstrate
that MathDivide was able to significantly outperform the leading prompting
technique called Math-prompter.
|
[
-0.534604907,
-0.9550369978,
0.6189511418,
0.4391015172,
-0.1622166038,
-0.1505957842,
-0.3260527551,
0.2281754017,
-0.0848188922,
0.1518986821,
-0.9556414485,
-0.3885109127,
-0.4240919054,
0.3066111505,
0.0933356211,
0.7556492686,
-0.1602434367,
0.3668341935,
-0.6732349396,
0.0901018903,
-0.6268838048,
-0.2613218427,
-0.6450248957,
-0.5589197278,
0.3520846069,
0.2304512858,
0.6687926054,
0.3514100909,
0.52749753,
0.3783712685,
-0.130294472,
0.3382184207,
-0.248018235,
0.1800298691,
-0.2534042001,
-0.6948072314,
-0.4573120475,
0.0009129501,
0.2877378464,
0.7781963348,
-0.2193942815,
0.334025979,
-0.205578506,
0.6726605296,
-0.4958731532,
0.4851734936,
-0.3946380615,
-0.0810805261,
0.0275509376,
-0.0165444165,
-0.4971506,
-0.7056800723,
-0.0905576721,
-0.6924934983,
-0.0583733767,
-0.3114600778,
0.5141795278,
0.4633107185,
-0.0324967019,
-0.3850037456,
-0.534188807,
0.9260914326,
-0.7146973014,
0.338364929,
0.3810844719,
0.3680724502,
-0.1802888513,
-0.4421192706,
-0.530757308,
-0.3935829699,
0.1637142003,
0.0555630475,
-0.3715355396,
-0.0376180299,
0.7958108783,
0.1499643624,
-0.5011208653,
-0.0700478479,
-0.3319657445,
-0.1007082164,
0.5312185884,
0.2167849541,
0.3447041512,
-0.0786063895,
0.0779962763,
-0.0412066728,
-0.9264748693,
0.0124592409,
0.0883615017,
-0.0687222406,
0.0082331374,
0.7235444784,
-0.1799653471,
0.6800878644,
0.0186142977,
-0.3683207333,
0.0383318961,
-0.1072485,
-0.3475156724,
-0.1650003642,
0.4656617045,
0.2610888183,
0.7795091867,
0.430658102,
-0.2627950609,
0.4272654951,
-0.2242589146,
-0.9191637039,
-0.4763123989,
0.1090864688,
-0.2746200562,
-0.1646129638,
-0.2863017321,
-0.6890224218,
-0.2789632678,
-0.6382636428,
0.2561355233,
-0.4951985776,
-0.0596568547,
0.2644414008,
0.0787917078,
0.0043653133,
0.7909840345,
-0.8975253105,
0.2394402176,
0.8957812786,
0.6838467717,
0.2344268113,
0.0381212458,
-1.0117235184,
-0.2888308465,
-0.4383811057,
0.7731403708,
-0.6200239658,
-0.4183239043,
-0.1993836612,
-0.4507091343,
0.0250357892,
-0.8632963896,
0.5345918536,
-0.6322821975,
0.373611927,
-0.2942193449,
-0.4657977819,
-0.2888506353,
0.3745675087,
-0.5668516159,
0.889765501,
0.1932016462,
-0.3956923783,
0.0020131413,
-0.7451854348,
-0.0584066659,
0.2350676358,
-0.3558058441,
-0.4147692025,
0.2714977562,
0.8184567094,
0.1227955446,
-0.5394824743,
0.3347879648,
-0.3277066648,
-0.0563480034,
0.3510954082,
-0.6215141416,
0.9463942647,
0.3031218052,
0.0558087379,
0.1286205202,
-0.4297624528,
0.157210201,
0.215126425,
-0.2245075405,
-0.3246587515,
-0.2148841769,
-0.6666411757,
0.0996448696,
0.2752736211,
-0.4859026074,
0.5197707415,
-0.3313507438,
0.3680367768,
0.884875536,
-0.190482378,
0.494659096,
-0.4454262257,
0.9458541274,
-0.1705290079,
0.0836118311,
-0.3986958861,
-0.7064837217,
-0.552254796,
-0.5374499559,
0.4683617055,
0.8159199953,
-0.8751327991,
0.0653103366,
-0.1076487005,
-0.1287150085,
-0.4984216988,
0.2179437429,
0.3169591725,
0.6388624907,
0.1686272174,
0.5620194674,
-0.4862554371,
-0.6747983098,
-0.0276191961,
-0.124347508,
-0.2432818562,
0.3120368123,
0.4183658659,
-0.1149398312,
0.9019748569,
-0.9004118443,
0.0295242313,
-0.2064392269,
0.1474165618,
0.4748908877,
0.2307115495,
0.3436102271,
-0.6128082871,
-0.4721719623,
-0.1445999444,
-0.7251862884,
-0.7104712725,
-0.0835478902,
-0.0882347748,
-0.094915837,
0.2944939137,
-0.9019989967,
0.4190005362,
0.271705687,
-0.1434207708,
0.7910762429,
-0.1457863003,
0.0803282112,
-0.8484359384,
-0.2634350061,
0.0579933785,
-0.05894728,
-0.2757300735,
0.0307381023,
0.0983650237,
-0.3859447539,
-0.2644322515,
0.4605908394,
-0.2549802065,
0.080908902,
-0.1439689845,
0.1707058251,
0.02629623,
0.1351487488,
0.0077560837,
1.0958974361,
0.7530221343,
-0.5981884003,
0.9367908239,
0.2812915742,
-0.3158532679,
0.5189922452,
-0.8481724262,
-0.0823238865,
-0.3195757866,
0.1730070263,
-0.9285975695,
-0.0460864678,
0.0778010637,
-0.5359799266,
-0.2047764659,
-0.1182416007,
-0.3626449704,
-0.3477256894,
-0.3277298808,
0.6701046228,
0.6998385787,
-0.8079476357,
0.7039121985,
-0.0118549978,
-0.5625531673,
-0.1482946128,
-0.3715344667,
-0.0256120563,
-0.2468930483,
-1.1503728628,
0.041704949,
-0.500887692,
-0.7836063504,
-0.1744022518,
0.0986170694,
0.043626938,
-0.0986493304,
0.0707215369,
0.7866479158,
-0.4376946688,
0.10506019,
0.2401521802,
-0.4293185174,
0.5154361129,
-0.1626378447,
0.547377646,
-0.032839369,
-0.4275117517,
-0.4927259088,
0.4346506298,
0.3949519396,
-0.6039257646,
0.3250528872,
0.0860621855,
-0.4812045991,
-0.5812180042,
-0.3435094655,
-0.3779832423,
-0.5356610417,
-0.0140019124,
-0.6340543628,
-0.7365013361,
0.3399366438,
-0.5369755626,
0.0143917194,
0.1543245018,
0.6653818488,
0.2721336782,
1.533596158,
0.1253724545,
0.3488949537,
0.3301154077,
-0.2975682318,
0.2572749853,
-0.573579371,
-0.361569196,
-0.5601609945,
0.0045363572,
-0.0261519756,
-0.5326808691,
0.5504552722,
0.2996560037,
-0.0540592,
0.0980651751,
-0.3741842508,
0.811214745,
0.3628764749,
-0.0948853716,
0.1962940097,
0.1409756392,
-0.4048567116,
-0.3856707811,
-0.5403136611,
-0.3728985786,
0.5727308989,
0.2006476223,
1.1330410242,
0.3171205223,
0.6136319041,
0.1396187693,
0.483576417,
-1.1669303179,
0.689963758,
-0.0423378572,
-0.1993843764,
-0.1208054945,
-0.7379519939,
-0.6022740006,
0.2694145739,
-0.0096370075,
-0.5876201987,
-0.0537295006,
-0.0082729189,
-0.6352619529,
-0.1793697476,
-0.7909519672,
0.6034129858,
-0.0798176378,
-0.1698638052,
-0.2593807876,
0.1226847693,
0.6141429543,
-0.0332567357,
0.3304958344,
-0.1945930123,
0.0407827273,
0.5047937036,
-0.7876623273,
0.5927630663,
-0.0824474618,
-0.5400283337,
0.3589530289,
0.6345103383,
0.6492797732,
0.4423896372,
-0.1720063388,
-0.2438226044,
-0.195308581,
-0.17891711,
-1.1821250916,
0.8978585005,
-0.5568930507,
-0.868031919,
-0.2795414627,
-0.6409242749,
-0.1288975924,
0.0800595358,
0.0189020801,
0.8310109973,
0.3885065615,
-0.2279123664,
0.9526770711,
-0.181993559,
0.4222672582,
0.4233073592,
-0.5119695663,
-0.7980179191,
0.6447707415,
-0.0109692495,
0.2093514204,
0.2523705959,
0.6151947379,
-0.5898419619,
-0.1283664107,
-0.6073031425,
0.5109447837,
-0.8555227518,
-0.5145958662,
-0.164788276,
-0.0848922282,
-0.4550029039,
-0.3315043449,
-0.1131220162,
-0.585950017,
-0.0978116021,
-0.1301567107,
0.610358417,
0.6118780971,
-0.1039427444,
0.1030036435,
-0.8090642691,
0.5328733921,
0.6542625427,
0.0402014442,
-0.1072823927,
-0.3402835429,
0.1827159971,
0.1518128812,
-0.1108364314,
-0.6448987126,
0.3734785914,
0.0530676991,
0.4173712432,
0.3161078095,
0.17244488,
0.8627976775,
-0.6069470048,
0.6087867618,
0.3476688564,
-1.2855654955,
0.7657581568,
-0.2205550969,
0.5436646342,
0.0172147993,
0.1960516274,
-0.4041612744,
0.0818073452,
-0.3712351024,
-0.2134852409,
0.4970082939,
0.1280298084,
0.0730077401,
-0.1915612668,
0.3578774035,
0.0585768968,
-0.0738744959,
-0.3870915473,
-0.1094936356,
-0.0552250855,
-0.2136820853,
0.3026019633,
-0.1657233834,
-0.1419824511,
-0.4609076381,
0.5933783054,
-0.1467778981,
0.1289669722,
0.1055503264,
-0.0057174531,
-0.1662071049,
0.2594900131,
0.8146569133,
0.9847720265,
0.1734848619,
0.2946280241,
0.2196699232,
-0.2413022518,
0.2186657786,
0.1292777061,
-0.3001646399,
0.0225800835,
0.3578725457,
0.5752003193,
-0.3401058912,
-0.8821531534,
0.5403254032,
-0.1777373701,
-0.4201878309,
-0.2128537893,
0.0779550672,
0.1085222661,
0.2635113001,
0.2403108627,
-0.0437054895,
-0.0387552902,
-0.1200713739,
0.185912773,
0.4375424981,
0.0428097546,
-0.1736602187,
0.6653330922,
0.126183331,
-0.5922516584,
0.9065537453,
-0.1670173556,
-0.6503295898,
0.7089394927,
0.8519226909,
0.6058261395,
-0.3965187967,
0.459495455,
0.3546531498,
0.1171701178,
0.0234807823,
0.5005170107,
-0.1457945555,
-0.6146501303,
-1.1904500723,
-0.4102241099,
-0.2785606086,
0.0343972445,
-0.4066588581,
0.2774420679,
-0.6454054117,
0.0289671682,
0.1401292235,
-0.1165404767,
-0.3066673577,
0.1506541371,
0.2106520385,
1.0510152578,
-0.6860613227,
0.6107167602,
0.7959990501,
-0.250218302,
-0.8704477549,
-0.4262208045,
0.0009132631,
-0.8508586287,
1.1395375729,
0.0944584906,
-0.2389591634,
-0.0321868472,
-0.724253118,
-0.5926245451,
0.6655343175,
0.6902341247,
-0.3910506368,
0.2978269458,
0.2263732404,
0.2842487097,
-0.324298054,
0.4362913072,
0.3360078633,
0.5552459955,
0.3962599933,
-0.767621696,
0.1720271111,
-0.374783814,
0.0615805537,
0.4892156124,
-0.30429703,
1.1260530949,
-0.4632822573,
0.0059322533,
0.1534495056,
0.7102672458,
0.5952962637,
0.3115151525,
0.448051542,
0.6481487751,
0.8236348033,
-0.0908604786,
0.7869486809,
0.1281012148,
0.3536527753,
0.6803256273,
-0.2618949711,
0.5406677723,
0.2414657027,
-0.4151733518,
0.5089308619,
0.4065260291,
0.1466195583,
0.3604473174,
0.502019763,
-0.7683764696,
-0.655718565,
-0.1647203863,
-0.3520804644,
0.1970838904,
0.575345397,
0.0420065075,
-0.7552370429,
0.1541130692,
0.1914896369,
0.2724895477,
-0.4948159754,
0.609054327,
0.3375136554,
-0.8422287703,
0.866732657,
0.059555158,
0.2499272227,
-0.6597809792,
-0.4892740548,
-0.3731401861,
0.4174620211,
-0.3074392676,
-0.6580078006,
0.261582911,
0.1203836203,
-0.2824100256,
-0.3367361426,
0.438521415,
-0.3419973552,
-0.6301242113,
-0.0910325944,
0.4659120739,
0.0027364248,
-0.1419119537,
-0.7877612114,
0.2572222054,
0.0890006721,
0.1192089021,
0.114909485,
0.8165112138,
-0.239774093,
0.9144051075,
0.9701886177,
-0.0967444479,
0.1302405447,
0.3150649965,
1.0230584145,
-0.383798629,
-0.3546735644,
-1.1458162069,
0.2642244399,
0.0613162108,
-0.2011331171,
1.0686014891,
0.4561756551,
0.6170138717,
-0.214737922,
0.6588297486,
0.2014673948,
0.3998161554,
-0.7062923908,
0.0570253581,
-0.0603825524,
0.5953643322,
-0.0360666551,
-0.8685413599,
-0.5100051761,
0.9555159807,
-0.6212130189,
-0.0985720456,
0.6771934628,
0.8925058246,
-0.1180246025,
0.0348313972,
0.2033672631,
-0.1100818515,
0.4678942263,
0.6725539565,
1.092140913,
-0.0005280483,
0.4020434916,
-0.3294533491,
-0.5743651986,
0.1544020772,
-0.8589698076,
-1.0616738796,
-0.0877735242,
-0.5280534625,
-0.4845246375,
-0.2446258217,
1.11373353,
0.4480166137,
-0.7436491251,
-0.1753021628,
-0.1961421669,
0.3451000154,
-0.2415790409,
-0.261721015,
0.2513213158,
-0.2919676006,
-0.7673072219,
0.4536076486,
0.1125270203,
-0.1334459931,
-0.3438709676,
-0.1561785191,
0.124633655,
0.3222975731,
0.6887986064,
0.0806497037,
-0.5097362995,
0.1253596693,
0.166811794,
0.2091610432,
-0.0315140635,
1.0135583878,
-0.967328608,
0.2443138361,
0.8141876459,
0.6589345336,
0.2473348826,
0.1783384979,
0.6030130982,
-0.3238167763,
0.0219610129,
0.2100592703,
0.3587681055,
0.167574957,
-0.3747778237,
0.1849971414,
0.3123650253,
-0.3959047198,
-0.588737607,
0.5325959921,
-0.6892518997,
-0.3162888288,
1.0673596859,
-0.1440218538,
-0.4482808709,
0.1680863202,
-0.6735654473,
-0.2440189123,
-0.6538668275,
0.5960215926,
0.6893758178,
-0.1963604093,
-0.4488144517,
-0.2757609189,
0.2916754186,
0.5344229937,
-0.8983927965,
0.1720960587,
0.7245810032,
0.1331375241,
0.0965116471,
0.3697519302,
-0.0910418555,
0.4599617422,
0.0006829774,
-0.2366432995,
-0.4204140604,
-0.217494756,
-0.4518853426,
0.0843270123,
-0.0060963263,
0.0133569464
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07363v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07363v1
|
Multilingual Power and Ideology Identification in the Parliament: a Reference Dataset and Simple Baselines
| 2024-05-12T19:25:15 | 2024-05-12T19:25:15 |
Çağrı Çöltekin, Matyáš Kopp, Katja Meden, Vaidas Morkevicius, Nikola Ljubešić, Tomaž Erjavec
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce a dataset on political orientation and power position
identification. The dataset is derived from ParlaMint, a set of comparable
corpora of transcribed parliamentary speeches from 29 national and regional
parliaments. We introduce the dataset, provide the reasoning behind some of the
choices during its creation, present statistics on the dataset, and, using a
simple classifier, some baseline results on predicting political orientation on
the left-to-right axis, and on power position identification, i.e.,
distinguishing between the speeches delivered by governing coalition party
members from those of opposition party members.
|
[
-0.4211854041,
-0.1215603128,
0.4128918648,
0.2543412745,
-0.4039484262,
0.0001536791,
-0.4241915941,
0.1707395762,
0.4308900833,
0.6045863032,
-0.378975302,
-0.4552622139,
-0.5791087747,
0.1585507095,
-0.3377537727,
0.720824182,
0.4484241903,
0.3416028619,
-0.2264504582,
-0.5907361507,
-0.4437741935,
-0.8076152205,
-0.0997047648,
-0.6110556126,
0.5196700096,
0.8321436048,
0.7562688589,
0.7997700572,
0.2708115578,
0.2896658182,
0.0407197252,
-0.3232708871,
-0.200759694,
-0.2181227207,
-0.4026561081,
-0.7514587641,
-0.111200124,
0.2143006474,
1.0063744783,
0.7343889475,
-0.2661396563,
0.1575522125,
0.0754118487,
0.6616250277,
-0.6138067842,
0.5607564449,
-0.6975577474,
-0.0985325426,
-0.8443161845,
-0.465968281,
-0.5623064041,
-0.204875648,
-0.2234601229,
-0.309333533,
0.073570326,
0.1853504032,
0.772351861,
-0.0652617589,
-0.5419009924,
-0.4099511206,
-0.4416999221,
0.8720121384,
-0.5790445805,
0.4139763415,
0.2853618562,
0.5500649214,
0.1689243764,
-0.7142766714,
-0.4873968363,
0.2976484597,
-0.3981128037,
0.0250650942,
0.036653176,
-0.0859479383,
0.3249090314,
0.2867499292,
-0.5736358762,
-0.0210596081,
-0.5162693858,
-0.1719482988,
0.6940906048,
0.1063506305,
0.1939074397,
-0.8181378841,
-0.2756233215,
-0.0413620621,
-0.9178109169,
0.0068550776,
0.7641140819,
0.6512989402,
-0.2984673381,
0.7855005264,
-0.1604367197,
0.8486817479,
0.3061742187,
-0.3145135641,
0.263899833,
-0.5278986096,
0.0898698047,
0.5456215739,
0.6882632375,
0.2708471715,
0.0809795484,
0.1561474502,
-0.0148133347,
-0.1127477959,
-0.1469101608,
-0.5303424001,
-0.3917229772,
0.1343379766,
-0.7646144032,
0.0592084676,
0.3342987001,
-0.8350249529,
-0.6559883356,
-0.8920413852,
-0.0520898327,
-0.4666622281,
-0.4639899731,
-0.2885218859,
-0.4352036715,
0.7192981839,
-0.1744698882,
-1.0587773323,
0.095153138,
1.1268204451,
0.5783179998,
-0.2959796488,
-0.3085258901,
-0.2208267003,
0.0824703947,
-0.2562461495,
0.9921674728,
-0.894269228,
-0.0125488183,
0.127124548,
0.3409106731,
-0.1253099293,
-0.6319900751,
0.4305728376,
-0.3091777563,
0.5828464627,
-0.6740260124,
-0.5750985742,
-0.042115815,
-0.1923791021,
-0.7455735207,
0.5053700805,
0.0011513012,
-0.959941864,
0.5758773685,
-0.5880545974,
-0.2427589744,
0.2095964253,
-0.6425652504,
-0.0259339884,
0.0295847785,
-0.0054480578,
0.3280982971,
-0.2792195976,
0.4972167313,
-0.1722107977,
0.1144261882,
0.1260750294,
-0.3955310881,
1.3243257999,
0.2550233006,
-0.043125689,
0.3435570896,
-1.2888475657,
-0.0259683635,
-0.1744917035,
0.0607388169,
-0.4900584519,
0.433624953,
0.0259790886,
0.1932222694,
0.4855158031,
-0.6545153856,
0.2896056473,
-0.1105032563,
0.4775462449,
0.7116532326,
0.0477453247,
0.4759733975,
-0.3261373937,
0.294324398,
0.0418797359,
-0.1146859601,
-0.036621917,
-0.649230957,
-0.5497403145,
-0.1830061525,
0.5205714703,
0.8834218979,
-0.69797647,
0.3852610588,
-0.3794680536,
-0.3919678926,
-0.322959125,
-0.1421815157,
0.232754603,
0.4505043328,
0.1670156419,
0.0450193956,
-0.8150835037,
-1.2807041407,
-0.2598675191,
-0.5650343895,
-0.2791134417,
0.2070631534,
0.3328139484,
0.3634834886,
0.9556872845,
-0.1584376544,
0.1083124653,
-0.2917298675,
0.3593481183,
0.4046317041,
0.1861378551,
0.4476892352,
-1.1365743876,
-0.3750419915,
-0.0724594668,
-0.7255699039,
-0.5783619881,
-0.1376149654,
-0.1142542437,
-0.1506634951,
0.2032556236,
-0.0443355441,
0.2016688436,
0.4644508362,
-0.2624861598,
0.3786738217,
0.2260522991,
0.090979591,
-1.4600291252,
0.1438759714,
-0.4358051717,
-0.0283689089,
-0.7283095121,
-0.0557584986,
0.3299636841,
-0.2841095924,
-0.8277760744,
0.2853689492,
-0.2738569677,
-0.0380612165,
-0.0061862692,
-0.0075428858,
-0.0707000643,
0.3955523372,
0.2501417398,
0.8961684704,
0.5830507874,
-0.2625352144,
0.5426666141,
0.601390183,
-0.5224114656,
1.1205396652,
-0.3821992874,
0.1736701727,
-0.3941037655,
-0.0590751171,
-0.9695430398,
-0.6922200322,
0.2248146385,
0.0043075131,
0.2662102878,
-0.2376398295,
-0.1085643843,
0.0979249105,
0.0102586793,
0.2644480169,
0.0729756802,
-0.5100594163,
0.4192529917,
0.8497936726,
-0.572714448,
-0.9439650178,
-0.5007969737,
0.1160041094,
-0.5072976947,
-0.3162130117,
0.5053485036,
0.4075362384,
-0.7458469868,
-0.2642378807,
0.3693199754,
-0.1389995515,
-0.5454168916,
0.5070029497,
0.0563514382,
-0.2050302476,
0.1473101228,
-0.148976773,
-0.1803429872,
0.0144061893,
0.0993026569,
0.7883763909,
-0.1988888383,
-0.3616375625,
-0.6591742635,
0.7766486406,
0.5682198405,
-0.1223011836,
0.6684831381,
0.1128705963,
-0.0900439546,
0.3269337416,
-0.3025008142,
0.1607259214,
-0.4276022613,
0.0889036059,
-0.5935094357,
-0.0883945078,
0.7623406649,
0.0068125552,
0.1070487574,
0.6246513128,
0.6453694701,
0.2500393987,
0.8649079204,
0.4075186253,
-0.320566237,
0.3399316072,
-0.0612956174,
0.1983564943,
-0.3652176261,
-0.4151276052,
-1.0089781284,
-0.2808826566,
-0.8926211596,
0.1264898479,
0.1637852788,
-0.0092535643,
-0.3941788673,
0.4748572111,
-0.4567970335,
0.3549724519,
0.5219013691,
-0.2118678987,
-0.0774064064,
-0.0122438176,
-0.1024914905,
-0.2401810735,
-0.7010920048,
-0.6830152869,
0.9812577367,
0.140231967,
0.6326348186,
0.1754461527,
0.6906480789,
0.0314089172,
0.2998012304,
-0.7425602674,
0.5559490919,
-0.0419373885,
-0.5729619861,
-0.1174844876,
-0.4330187142,
-0.7525988817,
0.0156688746,
0.0564096197,
-0.4504576921,
0.8078533411,
-0.3341322839,
-0.2412219793,
0.3395834863,
-0.4393472672,
0.684632659,
-0.0949903727,
-0.0194574147,
-0.168667078,
-0.7500380874,
0.1322648376,
0.1778766066,
0.2393339425,
-0.4050038755,
-0.0673616678,
1.2000271082,
-0.1599074751,
0.5008889437,
-0.3555850983,
0.0878214836,
0.0484741628,
-0.4996312261,
-0.0209917389,
-0.0259418767,
-0.6468006968,
0.6331936717,
0.2715590298,
-0.5070463419,
-0.3408192098,
0.6056641936,
-0.9219475985,
-0.670330286,
-0.5144773126,
-0.5252549052,
0.008997866,
0.2683876753,
0.4627123773,
0.8075485826,
-0.3755913675,
0.8676714301,
0.04496409,
-0.0257457942,
0.7808644176,
0.2286580205,
-0.2155652493,
-0.7618572116,
0.9102258086,
0.3636142612,
0.0552942157,
0.4303584695,
0.2100249082,
-0.7659470439,
-0.0933131799,
-0.4379869699,
0.0188580044,
-0.8875175118,
-0.0885128826,
-0.0537854321,
-0.2747832239,
-0.2303043306,
-0.0102290278,
-0.1724665016,
-0.733219564,
-0.0108877281,
0.1985621899,
-0.119595103,
0.7531564832,
-0.1868560761,
0.3826279342,
-0.1022697911,
0.3610682487,
0.4738329649,
0.0929633081,
-0.7566156387,
-0.234617129,
0.3051506281,
0.1059290394,
-0.3732732534,
-1.3906335831,
0.4796127379,
0.5460264683,
0.6335178614,
0.7634177208,
0.1753753126,
0.4941585064,
-0.7683308125,
1.0736138821,
0.1751089841,
-0.7709107995,
0.3559055924,
-0.2027916163,
0.0322599001,
0.5699673891,
0.7310093641,
-0.3966077566,
-0.2031070441,
-0.7657036781,
-0.5421740413,
0.6647675037,
0.0519334301,
0.0458573475,
0.0253129341,
0.2722550333,
0.4221663773,
0.4120999575,
-0.4466689229,
-0.5603789091,
-0.5331211686,
-0.1579411626,
-0.2875605226,
-0.2090660632,
-0.6906726956,
-0.407007128,
0.3894408643,
-0.2390283346,
0.4625905752,
-0.1144282222,
0.1322012991,
0.0319897495,
0.6916332841,
0.6506705284,
1.4555877447,
-0.2415833622,
0.5364550352,
-0.1021285877,
-0.101675868,
0.5168996453,
-0.0523217134,
0.0366033614,
0.4414393008,
0.2937824726,
0.9075367451,
-0.0571935363,
-0.069203414,
0.5032227039,
0.0297921039,
0.0571317486,
-0.6223639846,
-0.1491445601,
0.0160349496,
-0.1361498386,
0.5835273266,
-0.0196793843,
-0.1471351385,
-0.9756964445,
0.4326519668,
0.4646622837,
-0.2596619427,
-0.396572262,
0.5374817848,
0.0637335479,
-0.9503335357,
0.4167777002,
0.0027265945,
-0.4181587696,
0.3645552099,
0.5314385891,
0.6199643016,
-0.3200769424,
0.3573726714,
0.1684405208,
-0.0299086813,
0.4886449575,
0.5518620014,
0.0499924421,
-0.6149066091,
-0.3317221403,
-0.6109880209,
-0.5665724874,
0.3792926073,
-1.1037073135,
0.5127962828,
-0.3692393303,
-0.1843156815,
0.6742449403,
0.2840132117,
-0.3642612398,
-0.3718957603,
0.4358259439,
0.8982524276,
-1.2923651934,
0.991488874,
0.3970936835,
0.000292526,
-0.5963820219,
0.0365385935,
0.1980174929,
-0.7927412391,
0.4807108343,
0.1631077379,
0.3811112046,
-0.2041721344,
-0.5271776319,
-0.5423339009,
0.8294869661,
0.4928452671,
-0.535846591,
0.0536956526,
0.7161704302,
0.198439002,
-0.5215315819,
0.2925729752,
0.5488042235,
0.7908015847,
-0.2368285656,
-0.8212842941,
-0.3439974189,
-0.1209982857,
-0.2061971128,
0.262262851,
-0.7156591415,
1.2252315283,
0.7382685542,
-0.2530217767,
-0.1103126928,
0.6106790304,
0.2196747214,
0.2362343371,
0.4160259664,
0.2792622149,
0.8974476457,
-0.2629275024,
0.891805172,
-0.9611491561,
0.0857873783,
0.8282540441,
-0.4512731731,
0.8901535869,
0.6018893719,
-0.0393453799,
0.6589720845,
0.3522033989,
0.3858058453,
0.7247952223,
-0.1562069207,
-0.3189371526,
-0.1443205476,
-0.1594464481,
-0.4400473237,
0.7411773801,
0.5118598938,
-0.2082582265,
-0.4951016009,
0.1081631258,
-0.1340133995,
0.1118529588,
-0.470587045,
0.970344305,
-0.0789813623,
-0.8148425817,
0.8373209238,
-0.0109705767,
0.12621589,
-0.4667041302,
-0.1126976311,
0.0831437781,
0.124227494,
-0.1229159608,
-1.1878648996,
0.5989268422,
-0.2818829119,
-0.1841602921,
-0.4788477123,
0.5488072634,
-0.4419790506,
-0.2741650641,
-0.1421454549,
0.3689482212,
0.3914243579,
0.2471831143,
-0.784657836,
-0.0136531685,
0.0357634276,
0.0226386469,
0.2937006652,
0.3609032631,
-0.1377470046,
0.2487592995,
0.3305108249,
0.2100735158,
-0.042647399,
-0.1723840237,
0.5811284184,
-0.4679480493,
-0.3423213959,
-0.7240279317,
0.1149164736,
-0.4052229226,
-0.4681665003,
0.8106715679,
0.7993802428,
0.6273385286,
-0.059135668,
0.6143126488,
-0.3903239965,
0.5264959931,
-0.3826539516,
0.8271163106,
0.0101226838,
-0.2819741964,
0.2363506258,
-0.8731533289,
-0.0288713556,
0.6278525591,
-0.6311392784,
-0.7168869972,
0.6560055614,
1.0760272741,
-0.4352533519,
0.2243100256,
0.2616463006,
-0.0184262525,
-0.0178834926,
0.2588706315,
0.7941191792,
-0.0725213885,
0.0512292385,
-0.6861308217,
-0.1463661194,
0.0765746459,
-0.8395246267,
-0.5478817225,
-1.0684204102,
-0.1797227412,
-0.20303455,
-0.1358324885,
0.9362440109,
0.8022979498,
-1.2934499979,
-0.6457536221,
0.1374724954,
0.0937843025,
-0.1606941819,
-0.2140460312,
0.4408639967,
-0.1884572059,
-0.7441426516,
0.4200910628,
0.2587679327,
-0.5806061029,
-0.2674729824,
0.0609029233,
-0.5355270505,
0.3977616131,
0.1992981434,
0.5329889655,
-0.8072333932,
-0.656535387,
-0.4436153769,
-0.1030524895,
0.535943687,
0.9971808195,
-0.4586903155,
0.2448416501,
0.7728581429,
-0.0399154834,
-0.1785411835,
0.2949234843,
0.44614169,
-1.1130810976,
0.8911300898,
0.2468495518,
0.5020763278,
0.3388575017,
-0.0107591199,
0.2946096659,
0.2559090853,
-0.5636230111,
-0.8624745011,
0.2220451683,
-0.8811062574,
0.1072637439,
1.1850267649,
-0.2525994182,
-0.5058329701,
-0.4621301889,
-0.4258464277,
0.1563466489,
-0.0150957154,
0.4198743999,
0.9299150705,
-0.2891968191,
-0.2901281714,
-0.4028525352,
0.6464383006,
0.2394064814,
-0.4971239269,
0.1943221837,
0.3603522182,
0.2737155855,
0.5510555506,
0.4140900671,
-0.2470789701,
-0.0179604664,
0.0164298173,
-0.0473397821,
0.4049029052,
-0.6910600662,
-0.6091531515,
0.9295611978,
-0.3398944438,
-0.1782313138
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07348v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07348v2
|
MedConceptsQA: Open Source Medical Concepts QA Benchmark
| 2024-05-12T17:54:50 | 2024-05-14T16:44:02 |
Ofir Ben Shoham, Nadav Rappoport
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We present MedConceptsQA, a dedicated open source benchmark for medical
concepts question answering. The benchmark comprises of questions of various
medical concepts across different vocabularies: diagnoses, procedures, and
drugs. The questions are categorized into three levels of difficulty: easy,
medium, and hard. We conducted evaluations of the benchmark using various Large
Language Models. Our findings show that pre-trained clinical Large Language
Models achieved accuracy levels close to random guessing on this benchmark,
despite being pre-trained on medical data. However, GPT-4 achieves an absolute
average improvement of nearly 27%-37% (27% for zero-shot learning and 37% for
few-shot learning) when compared to clinical Large Language Models. Our
benchmark serves as a valuable resource for evaluating the understanding and
reasoning of medical concepts by Large Language Models. Our benchmark is
available at https://huggingface.co/datasets/ofir408/MedConceptsQA
|
[
-0.254809171,
-0.6520137191,
1.017944932,
-0.1094102561,
-0.2536505759,
0.0591199882,
-0.0139182508,
-0.4799494743,
-0.0824707374,
0.2784297466,
-0.5009591579,
-0.7375946641,
-0.432254225,
0.200540632,
0.0003768411,
0.7862066627,
-0.3424532712,
0.5828143358,
-0.3652070463,
-0.3499210477,
-0.381331563,
-0.5233333707,
-0.7993338108,
-0.0471725389,
0.4717137218,
0.2110182792,
0.5680385828,
0.3925514817,
0.7885681391,
0.2290912122,
0.0311646704,
-0.0408881307,
-0.1305347681,
0.1309625804,
-0.3538094759,
-0.455563575,
-0.3116741478,
0.2391118407,
0.3760686815,
0.6862124205,
-0.5332891345,
0.461352706,
-0.3861038387,
0.6801849604,
-0.8376328945,
0.0880184695,
-0.5764682293,
-0.0564171672,
-0.025979707,
-0.1247150525,
-0.0131307403,
-0.6559277177,
0.2031680048,
-0.801371038,
0.3153724372,
-0.2424600869,
0.9799612761,
0.5425850749,
-0.4632758796,
-0.4171022773,
-0.344150275,
0.5577589273,
-0.5079191327,
0.4668315947,
0.4209649861,
0.7829617858,
0.0669805631,
-1.203317523,
-0.6786549687,
-0.2151316702,
0.2746501863,
0.2224802524,
-0.2205979675,
0.1353849471,
0.3786665499,
0.5431191325,
-0.6391636133,
-0.0973099768,
-0.3459202349,
-0.2385847867,
0.2672905624,
0.1956043094,
0.2778618932,
-0.0371826254,
-0.3948077857,
-0.008029514,
-0.7656739354,
0.145973891,
-0.327847749,
-0.1318351477,
-0.1203119159,
0.6200051904,
-0.3921733499,
0.6571720243,
-0.0029124052,
-0.0660214871,
0.4707320631,
-0.5096375942,
-0.3231411874,
-0.247558549,
0.6345889568,
0.4615629017,
0.181690231,
-0.0514181405,
0.1080113947,
0.1917741895,
0.3192260563,
-0.7759792805,
-0.5583575368,
0.6099726558,
-0.5038033724,
0.0152579797,
-0.3390890956,
-0.363048017,
-0.5044316649,
-0.1529295444,
0.5078642964,
-0.6308976412,
-0.2480723858,
0.3894625008,
-0.143346414,
0.4474273026,
0.4048485458,
-0.5269157887,
0.5378365517,
0.6722031236,
0.7622407675,
-0.3198367953,
0.115523316,
-0.3322634101,
-0.1655863523,
-0.4098081887,
1.0211129189,
-0.3588136137,
-0.3004365265,
-0.1686621308,
0.0147372801,
-0.2504362464,
-0.8478589058,
0.6380397677,
-0.4397461414,
0.1648347378,
-0.5392802358,
-0.8242533207,
-0.1205372736,
0.5879096985,
-0.6559996009,
0.8405687213,
0.465223819,
-0.6520463228,
0.4275213182,
-0.6685510278,
-0.0473113991,
0.226190865,
-0.6051235199,
-0.2579931617,
-0.0737758577,
0.3223381639,
0.2337169796,
-0.6301304698,
0.008192732,
-0.115797244,
-0.110550046,
0.5626842976,
-0.1494440138,
0.6322578192,
0.3314930499,
-0.2519123852,
0.0395862199,
-0.8259122968,
0.4571911991,
0.1901150346,
-0.1613873243,
-0.2811568975,
-0.193738699,
-0.2578336596,
0.5099971294,
0.0869172737,
-0.7901003957,
0.0584462099,
-0.2703996599,
0.3164191246,
0.4535184503,
0.4349099398,
-0.0511959307,
-0.4243959785,
0.8617933989,
0.1659589559,
0.3597540855,
0.2211077958,
-0.7448683977,
-0.2350549102,
-0.5448694229,
0.5231916308,
0.4988392293,
-0.9672583938,
-0.0077652046,
0.0269074459,
-0.6122975945,
-0.8621897697,
-0.0333918668,
0.6683847308,
0.8031562567,
0.6519671082,
-0.3432700932,
-0.1203776971,
-0.8570511341,
-0.3109906614,
-0.3871235847,
-0.4128781855,
0.1072428972,
0.4622690082,
0.0064186431,
0.4307210147,
-0.7912926078,
-0.1981395632,
0.1717155129,
-0.066674225,
0.1661004126,
0.3577934802,
0.5981894135,
-0.8696429729,
-0.3494860828,
-0.312739104,
-0.4693733752,
0.056316305,
0.2027570456,
-0.0681101531,
-0.0958453193,
0.6081827283,
-0.8599020839,
0.2304736823,
0.6275610328,
-0.4601634443,
0.626581192,
-0.0524338,
0.3743869662,
-1.2003297806,
0.3053890467,
-0.1187670156,
-0.003528828,
-0.3711406291,
0.4416187108,
0.3209886849,
-0.0479772314,
-0.7610051632,
0.4393379688,
-0.2777389288,
0.1350235641,
0.2367449701,
0.111050047,
0.0721353814,
0.2882148325,
-0.0279194303,
0.9776197076,
0.4094827771,
-0.5570874214,
0.3890575171,
0.4267195761,
-0.4429534078,
0.9524046779,
-1.0087151527,
0.0823509917,
0.2252637297,
0.0813802779,
-0.9152549505,
-0.2081902623,
0.1676427424,
-0.6449031234,
-0.0757203996,
0.0055556293,
-0.3411506414,
-0.4436176717,
-0.1482733488,
0.5098807216,
0.3955751359,
-0.3289204538,
0.2940567434,
0.4209845662,
-0.0968778804,
-0.5530044436,
-0.5161827207,
-0.2879744172,
0.1908186972,
-0.14428702,
0.230188787,
-0.4645327628,
-0.2365470976,
0.0618805997,
-0.2820540667,
-0.5333926678,
-0.0843575522,
0.2771501839,
0.2203383595,
-0.3767040074,
0.3576718867,
-0.1216219068,
0.0093900152,
0.2934472859,
-0.1612548679,
0.3716970682,
0.0027575213,
-0.5777847767,
-0.4380275011,
0.2153967917,
0.6357508898,
-0.318020463,
0.4328057766,
0.2605000734,
-0.6216198802,
0.212946862,
-0.5003602505,
0.0166939106,
-0.4487882853,
0.2592740953,
-0.7278955579,
-0.7993704081,
0.4684533775,
0.0337200016,
0.0923910365,
0.5416431427,
0.823872447,
-0.1957251728,
1.0738083124,
0.2181622237,
0.260486871,
-0.2011398673,
-0.0610373914,
-0.2178222686,
-0.5864107013,
-0.3477692902,
-0.7333821654,
-0.0119955325,
-0.609105587,
-0.7948853374,
0.6555532217,
-0.0932108536,
-0.3357856572,
0.0253955107,
-0.5510416627,
0.3920963407,
0.6245718598,
0.416479677,
0.34574157,
-0.3707600534,
-0.4627959728,
0.082504943,
-0.4279216528,
-0.1176540703,
1.3044885397,
0.3231302798,
0.4912936389,
0.1679588109,
0.4817319214,
-0.0734658539,
0.2724333405,
-0.9805222154,
0.4434108734,
0.0147406738,
-0.9598047733,
-0.1968525797,
-0.4894523919,
-0.9393701553,
0.024739325,
-0.3641412854,
-0.2734337151,
0.1252841949,
0.1293955892,
-0.6683758497,
0.2682792842,
-0.7383359075,
0.9768797159,
0.0816116482,
0.0570117645,
-0.1448091567,
-0.6396815777,
0.3139133453,
-0.2652330995,
-0.0151602086,
-0.3754909039,
-0.3762413561,
0.6349811554,
-0.4785001576,
0.2947769165,
-0.3923098743,
-0.0338912606,
0.1830203384,
0.0185577311,
-0.0463265367,
0.2068601996,
-0.0538731888,
0.2304870784,
0.7158567905,
-0.8253656626,
-0.5689764023,
0.41113469,
-0.8052548766,
-0.2705492377,
-0.5158436298,
-0.3335961998,
-0.7935641408,
0.1841026098,
0.4179200828,
0.4551355839,
-0.3932157457,
0.1169914305,
0.7619645,
-0.4537888169,
-0.0367680602,
0.945976913,
0.2158243805,
-0.4499531686,
0.4173010886,
-0.0048405058,
0.5708937645,
0.4141735137,
-0.0322744474,
-0.4045264423,
-0.8532240391,
-0.4771941602,
0.4473177791,
-0.7401255369,
-0.3760888875,
-0.6213923693,
-0.4107195437,
-0.4085322022,
0.1726147979,
-0.467196852,
-0.5420030355,
0.1728212833,
-0.1249542683,
0.3231007755,
0.4330865145,
0.1991238445,
-0.0205244198,
-0.8501543999,
0.8329619169,
0.4609813988,
0.7310273647,
-0.6045046449,
-0.3189071715,
-0.1138317436,
-0.0678660125,
-0.1841453314,
-0.7531952262,
-0.1996593028,
-0.007572691,
0.5656066537,
0.2599907219,
0.2173670828,
0.517344594,
-0.6474076509,
1.0576217175,
0.4670300484,
-0.7280970812,
0.3948076963,
-0.1348251551,
0.6724647284,
0.936460793,
0.7913978696,
-0.5945343375,
-0.3395639062,
-0.5479729176,
-0.3769016266,
0.142696619,
0.1333318353,
-0.2064834386,
-0.2389760017,
0.5405263305,
0.1234064922,
0.1163989455,
-0.1652359366,
-0.1865431517,
-0.1085841581,
-0.4486303627,
-0.2237482965,
-0.1741578877,
-0.2727724016,
-0.4510618746,
0.3056847751,
-0.2888801098,
0.3643914163,
0.4437092245,
-0.0090503683,
-0.0899357945,
0.2901136875,
0.4632694721,
1.0523291826,
-0.3947660625,
0.0604269803,
0.1724694222,
-1.032917738,
0.2083159089,
0.3083672225,
0.0182658285,
0.0722197071,
0.248571977,
0.2559451163,
0.1057885289,
-0.8807995915,
0.7446079254,
-0.5339107513,
-0.6212772727,
-0.3238273859,
-0.0070979707,
0.1502279639,
0.1639494449,
0.197906822,
-0.2217520773,
0.2958860695,
-0.3471687138,
0.4102620184,
0.2533593476,
-0.5085567236,
-0.2009627521,
0.7864635587,
0.036017742,
0.1391829699,
0.5551433563,
0.1752186418,
-0.2022221535,
0.6022117138,
0.2816364765,
0.6180886626,
-0.4269719422,
0.4497744739,
0.5903827548,
0.2419063449,
0.0557861328,
0.8167387247,
0.0566615015,
-0.6441184878,
-0.4641219676,
-0.5013787746,
-0.9791332483,
0.2239272445,
-0.8120039701,
0.1722697914,
-0.63012743,
-0.2813930511,
0.4469640851,
0.1354795694,
-0.8680145144,
0.5947441459,
-0.1355696619,
1.3962521553,
-0.5541192889,
0.856536448,
0.8512949944,
-0.6988586187,
-1.092351675,
0.03680861,
0.1146969572,
-0.9393926263,
0.2291593105,
-0.1837043017,
0.1045911461,
0.0091437502,
-0.694829762,
-0.7364366055,
0.9691540599,
0.2833617926,
-0.2993178666,
-0.280564487,
0.2012695223,
0.6737650037,
-0.133867681,
0.2441993058,
0.825484395,
0.1407738626,
0.0929154977,
-1.142465353,
0.4070018232,
-0.4049983621,
-0.360791415,
0.0709735155,
-0.1654514223,
0.8849501014,
-0.2181845307,
-0.1744573563,
0.3364753425,
0.1112003997,
0.465647608,
0.5370784998,
0.5337079763,
0.5839424133,
0.697009325,
-0.1839280427,
1.1633306742,
-0.3852274716,
0.0899545848,
1.0207409859,
-0.1573483944,
1.0253312588,
0.438595742,
-0.4455744624,
0.5762166977,
0.7988308668,
0.359349668,
0.4945521653,
0.3286357522,
-0.3368485272,
-0.1204652861,
0.0020392253,
-0.780444622,
0.4110326171,
0.53835392,
-0.1546593457,
-0.1728290766,
-0.1215950921,
-0.0821068585,
0.1019491479,
-0.2652453184,
0.8721898794,
0.2025494874,
-0.7362188697,
0.9978564382,
-0.2317931503,
0.1296267807,
-0.7786864638,
-0.1647567749,
-0.1104140803,
0.1590091884,
-0.0284184366,
-0.8198258877,
0.07559596,
-0.1762971729,
-0.0241219327,
0.2670450211,
0.4193537831,
-0.3472928703,
-0.1261267811,
-0.0391015261,
0.7568672299,
0.2972258925,
-0.3528497517,
-0.9471012354,
-0.260458976,
-0.4141239822,
0.0519011393,
0.0356015451,
0.4965691864,
0.0853653923,
0.623780787,
0.6300163865,
0.3253949285,
-0.0918164477,
0.0937457308,
0.9929503798,
-0.6893317699,
-0.3741392791,
-0.3239563704,
0.220344305,
-0.1171718463,
-0.579872191,
0.4748078883,
0.4168851972,
0.8308520913,
-0.1157078892,
0.5395909548,
0.1509859413,
1.0659508705,
-0.6705007553,
0.7896423936,
-0.5560883284,
-0.1098085791,
-0.3735896647,
-0.5622014403,
-0.3592773974,
0.0934474841,
-0.1846539825,
-0.0959085152,
1.2162036896,
0.6496158838,
0.0257443264,
-0.0117198508,
0.3734838367,
0.0736217275,
0.1290713549,
0.8181937933,
0.823325932,
-0.3490538299,
0.4518221021,
-0.2374555767,
-0.3168585002,
0.0838286728,
-0.4264774919,
-0.8206225038,
-0.6360139251,
-0.4452393949,
-0.584251225,
0.1785971224,
1.016258955,
0.6624103189,
-1.051733017,
0.2203567773,
0.1601977497,
-0.1718467325,
-0.5101347566,
-0.1743501127,
0.6422641277,
-0.1691232771,
-0.4320593774,
0.2582814395,
0.0043502804,
-0.0289388075,
-0.0180720892,
-0.0018326243,
-0.2602156103,
0.237160176,
0.4377581775,
0.4811574817,
-0.4396484494,
-0.3168255687,
0.2703319192,
-0.427893281,
0.1121711731,
0.9036111236,
-0.7206950188,
0.6124071479,
0.2710426748,
0.8538731933,
0.2996745706,
0.0655246079,
0.5348300338,
-0.4904152155,
-0.048374854,
0.420696348,
0.2073064893,
0.228959173,
-0.1266833246,
0.6495760679,
0.2146074325,
-0.3786669075,
-0.6115493178,
0.1864337325,
-1.0216294527,
-0.4526187778,
0.9518625736,
-0.2916821539,
-0.1820808202,
-0.3695015609,
-0.1851134449,
0.2544364333,
0.0271704663,
0.7104805708,
0.4475111663,
-0.1962259859,
-0.1560980976,
-0.8901280165,
0.857024014,
0.4515860081,
-1.0939056873,
-0.3737638593,
0.6080666184,
0.6878358722,
0.0351191945,
1.1052674055,
-0.6246064901,
0.8501520753,
-0.0803032815,
0.2319136411,
0.1504297107,
0.1141285077,
-0.2310409546,
0.2126058489,
0.2416796237,
-0.6834516525
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07320v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07320v1
|
L(u)PIN: LLM-based Political Ideology Nowcasting
| 2024-05-12T16:14:07 | 2024-05-12T16:14:07 |
Ken Kato, Annabelle Purnomo, Christopher Cochrane, Raeid Saqur
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The quantitative analysis of political ideological positions is a difficult
task. In the past, various literature focused on parliamentary voting data of
politicians, party manifestos and parliamentary speech to estimate political
disagreement and polarization in various political systems. However previous
methods of quantitative political analysis suffered from a common challenge
which was the amount of data available for analysis. Also previous methods
frequently focused on a more general analysis of politics such as overall
polarization of the parliament or party-wide political ideological positions.
In this paper, we present a method to analyze ideological positions of
individual parliamentary representatives by leveraging the latent knowledge of
LLMs. The method allows us to evaluate the stance of politicians on an axis of
our choice allowing us to flexibly measure the stance of politicians in regards
to a topic/controversy of our choice. We achieve this by using a fine-tuned
BERT classifier to extract the opinion-based sentences from the speeches of
representatives and projecting the average BERT embeddings for each
representative on a pair of reference seeds. These reference seeds are either
manually chosen representatives known to have opposing views on a particular
topic or they are generated sentences which where created using the GPT-4 model
of OpenAI. We created the sentences by prompting the GPT-4 model to generate a
speech that would come from a politician defending a particular position.
|
[
-0.2979682684,
-0.3534356356,
0.4772418439,
0.0520410538,
-0.4652126729,
-0.0006612485,
-0.1017183885,
0.1833205223,
0.5967746973,
0.5935905576,
-0.4747100174,
-0.5549429655,
-0.4961196184,
-0.2172121853,
0.1025931686,
0.9395166636,
0.2714398801,
0.5182139874,
0.0011037407,
-0.16466555,
-0.1357539296,
-0.711566627,
-0.247720927,
-0.5027856231,
0.6710561514,
0.3369580805,
0.5570340157,
0.3801345229,
0.2087394595,
0.2928951085,
-0.0102241645,
-0.1820849776,
-0.5607122183,
0.0749526769,
-0.14726156,
-0.8184571266,
-0.298666954,
0.5587238669,
0.6522281766,
0.1864262372,
-0.0742936134,
-0.1055206805,
0.0443229377,
0.4876868129,
-0.3842226863,
0.2018231452,
-1.1399518251,
0.1123365089,
-0.4867531955,
-0.4671208858,
-0.2988092005,
-0.7699812055,
0.0570182204,
0.0236491021,
-0.0720792115,
-0.1258052886,
0.7339063287,
0.0780396312,
-0.4009602368,
-0.3958743513,
-0.4114518464,
1.0572965145,
-1.0754524469,
-0.0531053729,
0.1536692679,
0.3396535814,
-0.098475337,
-0.4172068834,
-0.534058392,
0.1164978221,
0.0679309815,
0.2325008214,
0.1946402788,
0.0171927828,
-0.1945003569,
0.1502756327,
-0.1765690595,
-0.0207124632,
-0.1024734452,
-0.013726444,
0.5744603872,
0.0140797533,
-0.0509657711,
-0.911108017,
-0.524743557,
0.0052339607,
-0.8686680198,
0.0054989392,
0.9231441021,
0.1399967372,
0.0633623749,
0.8014618754,
0.0292029753,
0.3774484694,
0.3689721823,
-0.1403019428,
-0.0400186256,
-0.1759254038,
0.0084399451,
-0.1106235459,
0.8832281828,
0.328781724,
0.2261410058,
0.3612498939,
-0.1006679237,
-0.0414080098,
0.0444932617,
-0.6603894234,
-0.3773648441,
0.1397670507,
-0.8262261748,
-0.388453126,
0.0566309579,
-1.043263793,
-0.6355472803,
-0.2826599479,
0.1469427794,
-0.3221929967,
-0.281463027,
-0.6222073436,
-0.2026771605,
0.5595970154,
0.1105497703,
-0.8769196868,
-0.299729377,
0.9103807807,
0.7106513977,
-0.1599308699,
0.2609294951,
-0.0339218564,
0.2804476023,
-0.1619061977,
0.9824842215,
-0.8355721831,
-0.2668800056,
-0.0366392061,
-0.301953733,
-0.0689904243,
-0.3551454842,
0.4262109995,
-0.5208702683,
0.4547850192,
-0.3331520259,
-0.8116734624,
-0.2064688653,
0.3204082251,
-0.3494389355,
0.5607025623,
-0.0555930659,
-0.9549993277,
0.3838200569,
-0.6124790311,
0.1883153766,
-0.1497287303,
-0.9763406515,
-0.3845285773,
0.0492662303,
0.2474693656,
0.8936133385,
-0.0394746698,
0.6082696915,
-0.4131400883,
-0.1083854958,
0.3602935076,
-0.4197562039,
0.9825794697,
0.1174389049,
-0.4063291252,
0.6133726835,
-0.6883407235,
0.0913095102,
-0.168277517,
-0.0026470956,
-0.421156317,
0.5410869122,
-0.3872033656,
0.0637992397,
0.3939015865,
-0.6348924041,
0.4510096014,
-0.5562457442,
0.5354191065,
1.2713747025,
0.2634837329,
0.4415964484,
-0.2766070068,
0.3427976072,
-0.2122316957,
0.0994207561,
0.3107372522,
-0.8085165024,
-0.6893932819,
-0.2683053613,
0.2925024927,
0.799544096,
-0.7535536289,
0.4115221798,
-0.2734465301,
-0.4826963246,
-0.4140445888,
-0.051358927,
0.0866179466,
0.049446892,
-0.0382533856,
0.1034295931,
-0.5330249071,
-1.0733804703,
-0.307659775,
-0.7033289671,
-0.1459970623,
0.3363599777,
0.4377835691,
0.0602089502,
1.1214338541,
-0.3405826688,
-0.025159806,
-0.2114047259,
0.6543419957,
0.5143558383,
0.1885278672,
0.3474399149,
-0.7145373225,
-0.4464296401,
-0.0383991972,
-0.5693818331,
-0.3274765611,
-0.0773263723,
-0.1749844104,
0.1491817981,
0.0723583847,
-0.2834506035,
0.3815463483,
0.4652304649,
-0.2891271114,
0.292681545,
0.2653290331,
0.0694165453,
-1.1696093082,
-0.2146229446,
-0.2833896875,
-0.1240300685,
-0.3383717835,
-0.0864455476,
-0.222032249,
0.0573455244,
-0.7389982939,
0.2598639429,
-0.2859238684,
0.0904082358,
-0.2262290269,
-0.0290269982,
-0.4885483384,
0.5845115185,
0.0172014367,
0.512304008,
0.0598648004,
-0.0173602197,
0.3651427329,
0.1500632316,
-0.3063829243,
0.819702208,
-0.350738138,
0.4489423037,
-0.0396294594,
0.015742857,
-1.2145187855,
-0.1629897356,
0.6875949502,
-0.2752252221,
0.3793829083,
-0.438172698,
-0.175124526,
0.0131880278,
-0.4322230816,
0.0393652953,
0.4491050243,
-0.2751482129,
0.6654701829,
0.5207235813,
-0.4976566434,
-0.7599999905,
-0.1185920089,
-0.1386243105,
-0.5288100839,
-0.5603812933,
0.2857961655,
0.2653826773,
-0.6419655085,
0.1245123148,
0.0376037061,
-0.0279436242,
-0.5507717133,
0.3915298879,
0.1113300174,
-0.266369611,
-0.2612383068,
-0.0450412184,
-0.2030260563,
0.086438641,
-0.0239226185,
0.4680210948,
0.1006817594,
-0.3740751147,
-0.5350130796,
0.5491124392,
0.3335227668,
-0.0564273149,
0.6604915261,
0.3549973071,
0.0616656356,
-0.1639223248,
-0.5865715146,
-0.1106251553,
-0.4428580403,
0.1713900566,
-0.1091924384,
-0.6705555916,
0.4678982198,
-0.1567436308,
0.2182357162,
0.5032075047,
0.8606266379,
-0.3080138564,
0.7895334959,
0.3882420957,
-0.4460296333,
0.3671945333,
-0.2660565674,
0.2025147378,
-0.3253397346,
-0.3137802184,
-0.5970644951,
-0.5007657409,
-0.5848533511,
-0.6390935779,
0.3657680154,
-0.263105303,
-0.3227986395,
-0.2135341763,
-0.55063802,
0.2955083251,
0.4492731094,
0.1162669808,
-0.2742817104,
0.046309378,
-0.0970062986,
-0.4293082058,
-0.3759820163,
-0.6373806,
1.0496761799,
0.3924155831,
0.908403337,
-0.0140154418,
0.6857718825,
0.3576041758,
0.6363985538,
-0.7694420815,
0.7862143517,
-0.2901064157,
-0.5710467696,
-0.3111280203,
-0.5004204512,
-0.4499290586,
0.3122703731,
-0.1301452219,
-0.5290426016,
0.3917217851,
-0.1602282226,
-0.1835193187,
0.720533967,
-0.1928557903,
0.6311381459,
-0.6295081377,
-0.2097652256,
-0.3641426563,
-0.6572821736,
0.2266963571,
0.1948070228,
-0.05887869,
-0.3623571098,
-0.1793826669,
1.1774587631,
-0.2521878183,
1.1683206558,
-0.7550694942,
-0.1708322316,
0.2763658464,
-0.3953277469,
0.4661837518,
-0.0641066879,
-0.4991077483,
0.487052381,
0.0292247031,
-0.2435016483,
-0.6388282776,
0.7639214396,
-1.2217206955,
-0.8575797677,
-0.613717258,
-0.4599381983,
-0.0275058616,
0.1151993647,
0.1862497479,
0.2034838796,
-0.3279355764,
0.4347555339,
0.2547022402,
-0.1479800791,
0.4386954606,
0.2670975924,
-0.0982977822,
-0.827358067,
0.8401096463,
0.3742480576,
-0.0851332918,
0.6265221834,
0.4070039093,
-0.4565456808,
-0.6266220808,
0.0081970878,
0.2351221889,
-0.60046947,
-0.1744645089,
-0.2090007365,
-0.0348976143,
-0.1796526611,
-0.1223201081,
-0.2179068476,
-0.4790013134,
-0.1461252123,
0.2845370471,
0.101324439,
0.8484687209,
0.0857464671,
0.8543465137,
-0.1381214708,
0.3092555702,
0.4081244767,
0.1570239365,
-0.5705551505,
-0.278204143,
0.2533861697,
0.0486606136,
-0.8113402128,
-1.5349253416,
0.4758225083,
0.1711215228,
0.7754369378,
0.9267225266,
0.238359496,
0.4725957513,
-0.5413808823,
1.0884035826,
0.0062818141,
-0.6935235858,
0.585344553,
-0.4103164077,
-0.3969127238,
0.3278141022,
0.4971317947,
-0.0021288311,
-0.4488172233,
-0.5985741615,
-0.7401532531,
0.5450917482,
0.3006646931,
-0.0070640305,
-0.0160256382,
0.5171318054,
0.2309602797,
0.2581619024,
-0.7216073871,
-0.282741636,
-0.4001398683,
-0.2903311253,
-0.0419002771,
-0.5955290198,
-0.3491230011,
-0.2908517718,
0.8089336753,
-0.1623784304,
0.6152417064,
-0.0127089201,
0.3874751627,
0.1270562112,
0.5387405753,
0.4334444106,
0.8196673989,
-0.5234199762,
0.1140867993,
-0.1405561268,
0.1844996959,
0.363446027,
-0.0869442374,
-0.117038928,
0.2417921722,
0.0747901052,
0.5733522177,
0.0529503189,
0.1559305936,
0.5790302753,
0.2153000683,
-0.0200645719,
-0.724881351,
-0.2319534719,
0.2803706229,
0.2673044205,
0.244218871,
0.1492849886,
-0.2117012292,
-0.8020046949,
0.34214288,
0.9686835408,
-0.2970893383,
-0.3203082681,
0.4398625195,
0.4585399628,
-0.3704317808,
0.3416180313,
0.0857141465,
-0.6482263803,
0.3640635312,
0.3642425239,
0.7267249227,
-0.5173748732,
0.3878012002,
-0.0427076072,
0.0608692095,
0.5636496544,
0.5280191898,
0.0910120532,
-0.7475658655,
-0.4941267073,
-0.470631659,
-0.5398320556,
0.3136973083,
-0.5621637702,
0.2672956884,
-0.6239306927,
-0.4084114432,
-0.0724441484,
0.3367160857,
-0.1282283217,
-0.1356133521,
0.0978167132,
0.5557547212,
-0.8611630797,
0.887442112,
0.5744586587,
0.0850256681,
-0.6130214334,
0.1987554133,
0.0930331349,
-0.9892346263,
0.5013031363,
0.030924296,
0.0368576124,
-0.3108573556,
-0.6859115958,
-0.3869349062,
0.8934230208,
0.4043099582,
-0.4485699236,
-0.1262334287,
0.2146188766,
0.189467296,
-0.466875881,
0.4770063162,
0.1752373278,
0.6027410626,
0.0362826958,
-0.2598869801,
-0.2044959962,
-0.1485649198,
-0.3810149133,
0.4430814683,
-0.823366344,
1.1185611486,
0.4474450648,
0.1466876417,
0.1271471083,
0.9201880097,
0.1883464605,
0.3371635675,
0.6135755777,
0.1603271365,
0.7073848248,
-0.0208466146,
0.6928427815,
-0.4845384061,
0.1532614976,
0.7708033323,
-0.2466917038,
1.1573189497,
0.8150020242,
-0.1727958769,
0.6334349513,
0.4892574847,
0.0597611479,
0.6525771618,
0.4030578732,
-0.2570310235,
-0.2436724156,
0.1118010655,
-0.3244949877,
0.5964543223,
0.4882637858,
-0.2790675461,
-0.1514719129,
-0.1952700764,
0.0037173701,
0.1918009967,
-0.3049665391,
0.697994709,
0.1719722897,
-0.491068691,
0.3517588079,
-0.0316195749,
0.8834450245,
-0.7534406781,
-0.3180892766,
-0.0269404445,
0.234351784,
-0.155727312,
-0.9966453314,
0.3373513818,
0.0310817678,
-0.0977583155,
-0.4764655232,
0.644128263,
-0.174746424,
-0.4063292742,
0.1022407115,
0.5569054484,
0.5292723179,
-0.0302937422,
-0.7821696401,
-0.0806051344,
0.3789982498,
-0.2457890809,
0.1730818748,
0.4247837365,
-0.1053067893,
0.3400645554,
0.3816909194,
0.3985135555,
-0.1659267992,
-0.1927498579,
0.8684350848,
-0.7155051827,
-0.5406356454,
-0.9725282192,
0.1946558654,
-0.2254756093,
-0.1166708097,
0.7967509031,
0.4105413854,
0.4258612096,
-0.0171479937,
0.7740040421,
-0.3231314421,
0.6292413473,
-0.6427548528,
1.0567569733,
-0.3291594386,
0.3317797184,
-0.0781286508,
-0.827749908,
0.001544976,
0.9665561914,
-0.7286854982,
-0.2265047133,
0.3497060537,
0.9548213482,
0.014291374,
0.2053006291,
0.1848781109,
0.3742685914,
0.2633855641,
0.4185297489,
1.2082709074,
0.2972542048,
0.3590819538,
-0.363035202,
-0.3142689466,
0.073622182,
-1.0175703764,
-1.1607270241,
-0.4814839959,
-0.0432102121,
-0.0640213341,
0.144834727,
0.9099350572,
0.7899642587,
-0.9161378145,
-0.4547740817,
0.3458977044,
0.1631529629,
0.137570709,
-0.2253560871,
0.642631948,
0.0590339229,
-0.6012089849,
0.2142342478,
0.0918748975,
-0.347389549,
-0.5392385721,
0.0878947154,
-0.4104569256,
0.3183186352,
0.3810583353,
0.0618029572,
-1.2092183828,
-0.7311894894,
-0.3537231088,
0.1664371938,
0.2870487273,
0.98248142,
-0.6457281709,
0.2057841271,
0.6070712209,
0.2629070282,
0.0163770989,
0.3143511117,
0.6731181145,
-0.8623867035,
0.275857538,
0.434463352,
0.1711278558,
0.2797816396,
-0.2754647136,
0.3138794303,
0.2927486897,
-0.6395568848,
-0.4983430803,
0.1608712226,
-1.0360935926,
-0.0783895925,
1.0601328611,
-0.3274640441,
-0.3013109267,
-0.0010314934,
-0.6329256892,
0.4155390263,
-0.4641984403,
0.4952062964,
0.4633930922,
-0.4566919804,
-0.2387953997,
-0.3431682885,
0.2953517139,
0.4023258388,
-0.5621908307,
-0.3074421883,
0.2385919392,
0.2829181254,
0.1732050031,
0.7753622532,
-0.1874797493,
-0.441465795,
-0.117564097,
-0.121257551,
0.2690324187,
-0.1797246188,
-0.184257552,
0.5316204429,
-0.2225034982,
-0.3608418107
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07282v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07282v1
|
Branching Narratives: Character Decision Points Detection
| 2024-05-12T13:36:07 | 2024-05-12T13:36:07 |
Alexey Tikhonov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7
|
This paper presents the Character Decision Points Detection (CHADPOD) task, a
task of identification of points within narratives where characters make
decisions that may significantly influence the story's direction. We propose a
novel dataset based on CYOA-like games graphs to be used as a benchmark for
such a task. We provide a comparative analysis of different models' performance
on this task, including a couple of LLMs and several MLMs as baselines,
achieving up to 89% accuracy. This underscores the complexity of narrative
analysis, showing the challenges associated with understanding character-driven
story dynamics. Additionally, we show how such a model can be applied to the
existing text to produce linear segments divided by potential branching points,
demonstrating the practical application of our findings in narrative analysis.
|
[
-0.1038259342,
-0.5795491338,
1.0292207003,
0.0056737517,
-0.2614784837,
0.3302317858,
0.2501177192,
-0.5059800744,
0.3826899529,
0.5503637791,
-1.1876103878,
-0.9502685666,
-0.5454056263,
0.2607543468,
-0.2771269083,
0.9544164538,
-0.2038970888,
-0.220616132,
-0.2047310621,
-0.2257825732,
-0.6259213686,
-0.4441620409,
-0.9365412593,
-0.1850317568,
0.7920547128,
0.3862755001,
0.6847966313,
0.6220548749,
0.3441403806,
0.2932061255,
-0.3160461783,
0.434484303,
-0.5991311073,
0.6479588151,
-0.2138817757,
-0.9134423733,
-0.0937454775,
0.0592691265,
0.553802073,
0.7446144819,
0.4015221,
0.1521790624,
-0.0878292397,
0.7483155131,
-0.232434839,
0.0410403907,
-0.0887662396,
0.4130519629,
-0.1039026901,
-0.1901025325,
-0.028950911,
-0.4810962081,
-0.072193414,
-0.5862582326,
0.399558872,
0.3247900307,
0.8233882785,
-0.1826454103,
-0.6090475917,
-0.9151259065,
-0.6590991616,
0.671777606,
-0.4683524966,
-0.0891670063,
0.4537224174,
0.0840132609,
-0.1884752512,
-0.4090714753,
-0.4150732756,
-0.2741504014,
-0.1887150556,
-0.2609487772,
-0.4210715592,
0.0418030061,
0.2988217175,
0.1714562625,
-0.3903269768,
0.1884251684,
-0.4803860188,
-0.0641619489,
0.9424538612,
0.6691073179,
0.3888460696,
-0.617164433,
-0.3626387119,
-0.1254838705,
-0.5089386702,
0.4151062369,
0.8494468927,
0.2655946314,
-0.0255638063,
0.8594652414,
-0.0331884027,
0.4948988557,
0.3160429895,
-0.3885638714,
0.1114801839,
-0.531917572,
-0.0255436581,
0.2947061062,
0.8530469537,
0.7905835509,
0.3162081242,
0.1431344002,
-0.2459226698,
-0.2489825785,
0.2192089707,
-0.7435573936,
-0.1589429528,
0.4257811606,
-0.9141592383,
-0.6900572777,
-0.5348796248,
-0.6649982929,
-1.2837246656,
-0.0642286092,
-0.2452008277,
-0.9691695571,
-0.2443259954,
-0.5436406136,
-0.5358450413,
0.0145730441,
0.3788185716,
-1.0581139326,
0.0334199928,
0.8273077607,
1.4359885454,
-0.4508986175,
-0.123186253,
-0.4240818024,
0.0105352383,
-0.7366917729,
0.9822130799,
-0.4860976636,
-0.6801770926,
-0.1469454169,
0.0193957798,
-0.0710578188,
-0.4317650199,
0.7987378836,
-0.0395714082,
-0.1631655842,
-0.5506308079,
-1.0691828728,
-0.3469326496,
0.6883417964,
-0.629814446,
0.6677630544,
0.0421358459,
-0.4231299758,
0.6267094016,
-0.1919165105,
-0.4729265571,
-0.0386843309,
-0.5420230627,
-0.2106973827,
0.2270402163,
0.2357011437,
0.3974948823,
-0.0773851573,
0.1442537308,
-0.0453715064,
-0.3274317086,
0.1836645007,
-0.2001376748,
1.0239193439,
0.0657098517,
-0.0776604712,
0.4080760479,
-0.8553714752,
-0.1738128662,
0.0134284003,
-0.1544663906,
-0.3101558983,
0.4405800104,
-0.1468223333,
-0.0021409106,
-0.2156364918,
-0.3771288395,
0.489166826,
0.2898215055,
0.1067271456,
0.4994732141,
0.2970328033,
0.139373064,
-0.4481984377,
0.9551384449,
-0.0252422988,
-0.2196029723,
-0.5321186781,
-1.0522147417,
-0.5931830406,
-0.4427041709,
0.3027510643,
0.3631365597,
-0.6285384893,
0.4940395057,
0.1756110489,
-0.7338533998,
0.0205325596,
-0.1236484051,
0.1253150403,
0.3963448405,
-0.0624487549,
-0.3262254298,
-0.387926966,
-0.4827963114,
-0.2526637018,
-0.7170305252,
-0.2318457365,
0.2948212922,
0.304949224,
0.0538403951,
0.9033927321,
-0.4495511651,
-0.3466418087,
-0.4962670207,
0.580077827,
0.4704183936,
0.5465914011,
0.735460341,
-0.7496272922,
-0.2348278165,
0.0594281182,
-0.9124395251,
-0.0571861044,
-0.5381201506,
0.036532741,
-0.2201598585,
0.8543459177,
-0.729360342,
0.6630060077,
0.4633817673,
-0.9556971788,
1.0458618402,
-0.1434601694,
0.5760897994,
-0.5723173022,
0.105718866,
-0.1565890014,
-0.3599278629,
-0.7848505378,
-0.1142857298,
-0.0372845456,
-0.2337892056,
-0.0496376045,
0.3961842358,
-0.3705304563,
-0.3205966651,
-0.127092585,
0.3360928595,
-0.0170369446,
0.7024864554,
0.1791555434,
0.3449791074,
0.0618561618,
-0.6084345579,
0.5131076574,
0.3625978529,
-0.6133620739,
1.0286797285,
-0.4717055261,
-0.0078972969,
-0.1547625512,
-0.0222564377,
-1.4576077461,
0.0528763644,
0.5048593879,
-0.4672235548,
-0.0326050371,
-0.6471895576,
-0.3422908485,
-0.0706185102,
-0.1498231739,
0.2900599241,
0.0323630348,
-0.2432451397,
0.6132840514,
-0.0188519228,
-0.4018127024,
-0.3117021024,
-0.4615618289,
-0.0467167236,
-0.3709272444,
-0.5816500187,
0.3949339986,
-0.0416838601,
-0.2680699825,
0.0734960139,
0.1017025933,
-0.071021609,
-0.2608101666,
0.4809886217,
0.1311693043,
-0.3427138627,
0.2950913012,
0.1841323376,
-0.0673221573,
0.0132189551,
-0.0932593346,
0.5497395396,
0.1496978849,
-0.2970280945,
-0.3026793003,
0.3205761909,
0.633754909,
0.0633213297,
0.3111258447,
0.4987559319,
-0.1242612675,
0.1869640499,
0.0041590873,
0.453424871,
-0.4407970905,
0.3753465116,
-0.2828208804,
-0.3976638317,
0.6432086825,
-0.1699023694,
0.0639014766,
0.449634999,
0.3278383613,
-0.4918359816,
0.8908366561,
0.5202575922,
0.0122433342,
0.6107903719,
-0.121443212,
0.0976201594,
-0.5577324033,
-0.2482657284,
-0.4158059657,
-0.9311769605,
-0.5594022274,
-0.6062515974,
0.1371611208,
0.5982567072,
-0.081599012,
0.4450157285,
-0.0615753531,
0.6031947136,
0.5428129435,
-0.1163429618,
0.5964121222,
-0.2208999097,
-0.4471726716,
0.0788044557,
-0.4722942114,
-0.6207806468,
1.0900452137,
0.3807323873,
0.2562044561,
0.2181639075,
0.8047407866,
0.688334167,
-0.1917761415,
-0.852360785,
0.5012807846,
-0.010859374,
-0.8144592047,
-0.5488157272,
-0.3209841251,
-1.0902656317,
0.1696298122,
-0.377715528,
-1.1983180046,
0.8672844172,
-0.3026540577,
-0.6636721492,
0.4591291845,
-0.5861297846,
0.8823988438,
-0.4591946602,
-0.1400862038,
-0.301592648,
-0.341573298,
0.241572991,
0.1898532659,
-0.0514008738,
-0.4284746945,
-0.0957854763,
0.7867254019,
-0.4836596847,
0.7138906121,
-0.1569911391,
0.0261433255,
0.6594352722,
0.4348171353,
0.5456365347,
0.166555196,
-0.2736010551,
0.2080148906,
0.2623053491,
-0.3451292813,
-0.4140096009,
0.5093746185,
-0.553996861,
-0.2857066393,
-0.6345711946,
-0.897482574,
-0.3715314567,
0.2502352297,
0.2442813367,
0.2185852975,
-0.516184926,
-0.1346252412,
0.1381012946,
-0.2080937773,
0.6209388375,
0.145331189,
-0.7502815127,
-0.1531987786,
0.6794843078,
-0.0899525359,
0.1759508848,
0.1332501322,
0.0236016735,
-0.0583107807,
-0.9365792871,
-0.7266516685,
0.0489123948,
-0.6950338483,
-0.1071771011,
-0.2035021633,
-0.1644074321,
0.2959840894,
-0.3683106899,
-0.2719611526,
-0.4978138208,
-0.3422138691,
-0.4316016436,
0.1643016785,
1.1389739513,
-0.0549701937,
0.3682369292,
-0.6098880768,
0.2147402614,
0.165208742,
0.0538647808,
-0.1982743889,
0.0986293927,
0.1273244917,
-0.1529982537,
-0.4453772902,
-1.0631787777,
0.5640676618,
-0.1141585633,
0.270206064,
0.9353684187,
-0.2688845694,
0.4955928922,
-0.3771859705,
0.8019612432,
0.529528141,
-0.8233884573,
0.4794472754,
-0.5355647206,
0.393943131,
0.6429380178,
0.7430767417,
-0.871814549,
-0.117836602,
-0.5764940381,
-0.3128815293,
0.8982492089,
0.7630072832,
-0.0700808391,
0.1999756992,
0.3384079337,
0.1659611613,
0.3499596715,
-0.272310406,
-0.1976832747,
0.3905247152,
-0.2384673655,
-0.2716132104,
-0.3876266181,
0.0648866445,
-0.1491678506,
0.2176288068,
-0.1017558798,
0.2833557427,
0.2724987268,
-0.0295853242,
-0.4199154973,
-0.3052427769,
0.410707891,
0.9796930552,
-0.3949038088,
-0.0765319392,
-0.1192329302,
-0.5356906056,
0.245968163,
0.0729896724,
-0.340863049,
0.4200139046,
1.053722024,
0.8561107516,
0.213311255,
-0.964093864,
0.3980666101,
-0.2647509575,
-0.0857983306,
0.1971318126,
0.1408330947,
0.1635307968,
0.827301383,
0.3775854409,
0.2928108871,
0.09245985,
-0.951839447,
0.0392252356,
0.0012870933,
-0.7451305985,
0.0286088046,
0.0467167944,
0.3221900761,
-0.7574641109,
0.9163252115,
-0.5794737935,
-0.4870567918,
1.1318105459,
0.2308819443,
0.7310233116,
-0.0862432793,
0.8321092725,
0.5089997649,
0.330144763,
0.5568745136,
-0.0112211267,
-0.1331599355,
-0.7247896791,
0.0649581552,
-0.4421066344,
-0.4334235787,
0.0388972238,
-0.4679980576,
0.5492590666,
-0.7008333802,
-0.112010099,
0.2982403934,
0.0780794546,
-0.4640077651,
0.2680160999,
0.6294096708,
0.4803231359,
-0.4915970862,
0.3598727286,
0.3054263294,
-0.3069363832,
-0.3612555861,
0.2533216178,
0.3371027112,
-0.6406080127,
0.6431999207,
0.2680503726,
0.1028948501,
-0.4962157309,
-0.1465633959,
-0.9227918386,
1.2884247303,
0.2257986814,
-1.0363752842,
-0.3762455881,
0.1962579191,
0.5302628279,
-0.7019937038,
0.5471453667,
0.7850099802,
0.293186307,
0.1575695872,
-0.4449273348,
-0.0562431812,
-0.0484202541,
-0.1793612987,
0.0091239652,
-0.415613085,
0.7933832407,
-0.4247850776,
-0.3090633154,
0.2754991353,
0.7298557162,
0.6087201834,
0.7271523476,
0.9166867137,
-0.1426497847,
1.3780317307,
0.0061665699,
1.060603857,
-0.1446062326,
0.2345345467,
0.9668077826,
0.051674746,
0.629760921,
0.3308698833,
-0.2613838911,
0.9905336499,
0.9743828177,
0.0114871953,
0.4942004681,
0.2159568965,
0.0866437256,
-0.310038954,
0.0384946801,
-0.0213553496,
0.457367003,
0.6171851158,
-0.6974005699,
0.010600307,
-0.1987251043,
0.0039482415,
-0.184942767,
-0.6124618053,
0.3888461888,
0.0106199384,
-0.7279401422,
0.1963524967,
-0.0611086525,
0.2207449675,
-0.8946905136,
-0.0824983791,
-0.3914312124,
0.1090812907,
-0.013496046,
-0.9601497054,
0.1692462116,
0.1059802771,
-0.1501368135,
-0.0066831848,
0.8247895241,
-0.3306488395,
-0.9638400674,
0.4033659995,
0.4457410276,
0.1897365898,
-0.1291836053,
-0.7792641521,
0.2863351405,
0.131130293,
0.0275176708,
-0.1164823845,
0.6115605831,
-0.0585784465,
0.4733948708,
0.3550356925,
-0.2832538486,
-0.0962478518,
-0.1177615449,
0.4744552076,
-0.8292268515,
-0.8141316772,
-0.6783871055,
0.388884902,
-0.5218418837,
-0.9430500269,
0.7270101905,
0.4180392325,
0.4961255193,
-0.0171091855,
0.677675724,
-0.3110930026,
0.2697296739,
-0.6359118819,
0.5755455494,
-0.2237202972,
0.341039896,
-0.4074062407,
-0.8760513067,
0.1847781539,
0.2964148819,
-0.405408144,
0.0171479899,
0.9962283969,
0.4423134625,
0.0250927284,
0.42356354,
0.411241293,
0.064436622,
0.1294384748,
0.5484836698,
1.1664950848,
-0.2150251418,
0.6279218197,
-0.1902287751,
-0.1683637649,
-0.2676018178,
-0.824352026,
-1.3464653492,
-0.6648637056,
-0.4882440865,
-0.1191345006,
0.302616179,
0.5342665315,
0.9484963417,
-1.1088666916,
-0.5686211586,
-0.3527289629,
0.591499567,
-0.7127810121,
-0.1334194392,
0.3478224874,
-0.3511873782,
-0.7462800741,
0.6294113994,
0.1853935868,
-0.4599107206,
-0.1748158932,
-0.1327402294,
-0.6541602015,
0.1740996242,
0.4634681344,
0.1664498597,
-0.4078938663,
-0.2787353694,
-0.4124249518,
0.201217562,
0.1713119894,
1.4574668407,
-0.4836268425,
0.6333751082,
0.47546646,
0.2573497891,
1.0350645781,
0.0986569151,
0.9094395638,
-0.9270281196,
-0.0682598576,
0.380033046,
0.3741927743,
0.2238255292,
-0.6793372631,
0.7198201418,
0.3778440952,
-0.3485388458,
-0.4210104644,
0.1240892485,
-0.8114237189,
-0.4802262783,
1.0964899063,
-0.3768544793,
-0.3072676659,
-0.2043038309,
-0.6125468016,
-0.0176146608,
-0.2506064475,
0.2855353951,
1.0807629824,
-0.5592574477,
-0.0709807202,
-0.2629249394,
0.6326990724,
0.1869698465,
-0.6943412423,
0.0684170127,
0.5695561171,
-0.0350183584,
0.5631349683,
0.5695543289,
0.2563734949,
0.019589806,
0.4094699323,
-0.3287507892,
-0.0515578166,
-0.312915504,
-0.193159312,
0.4092879295,
-0.3102225363,
-0.1827195436
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07280v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07280v1
|
Humor Mechanics: Advancing Humor Generation with Multistep Reasoning
| 2024-05-12T13:00:14 | 2024-05-12T13:00:14 |
Alexey Tikhonov, Pavel Shtykovskiy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.HC, 68T05, 68T30, 68T50, 91-08, I.2.7; I.2.1; I.2.6; H.5.2
|
In this paper, we explore the generation of one-liner jokes through
multi-step reasoning. Our work involved reconstructing the process behind
creating humorous one-liners and developing a working prototype for humor
generation. We conducted comprehensive experiments with human participants to
evaluate our approach, comparing it with human-created jokes, zero-shot GPT-4
generated humor, and other baselines. The evaluation focused on the quality of
humor produced, using human labeling as a benchmark. Our findings demonstrate
that the multi-step reasoning approach consistently improves the quality of
generated humor. We present the results and share the datasets used in our
experiments, offering insights into enhancing humor generation with artificial
intelligence.
|
[
-0.3489914834,
-0.6857854724,
0.727858007,
0.4880892634,
-0.263627857,
-0.0994898081,
0.257905364,
-0.2274426669,
0.142770499,
0.354329288,
-0.7905241251,
-0.1229828596,
-0.089945063,
0.1784766763,
-0.2609806061,
1.1603740454,
0.6148874164,
0.0325682908,
-0.3089581132,
0.0760416612,
-0.1494258493,
-0.3295000494,
-0.7002788782,
-0.4354080558,
0.7445017099,
0.6311663389,
0.6591409445,
0.4708684683,
0.4052576423,
0.2965910137,
0.1985332817,
0.0111647928,
-0.017146606,
0.2470539808,
-0.0366065875,
-0.2547379136,
-0.2731467783,
-0.1762116253,
0.4870080948,
0.7692622542,
-0.2753420174,
-0.0728205889,
-0.3059711754,
0.6625532508,
-0.2775412202,
-0.2432938069,
-0.3101756275,
0.3678829074,
-0.244971633,
-0.5913013816,
-0.4106222987,
-0.5062199235,
-0.2724375129,
-0.3956784606,
0.1507754773,
-0.1163306609,
0.4554535151,
0.3791325986,
-0.3595517278,
-0.4713843763,
-0.716309309,
0.6561329365,
-1.0219223499,
0.2217288613,
-0.1735017598,
0.2911803722,
-0.3306602836,
-0.8014637232,
-0.7084217668,
-0.3526279926,
0.2935696542,
0.1631379277,
0.0544936731,
-0.2787896097,
0.4577162862,
0.0642976537,
-0.6438780427,
-0.402906388,
-0.5165249705,
-0.0069894353,
0.7799064517,
0.0979132429,
0.3827810287,
-0.1999226063,
-0.2996867001,
-0.1175099015,
-0.4069493711,
0.0361030102,
1.0515774488,
0.0995758101,
0.384382844,
0.4036716521,
-0.2048969716,
0.2567327023,
-0.170130983,
-0.5784661174,
0.4175560772,
-0.5319982767,
-0.0112770386,
0.0317276753,
0.8054153323,
0.1418991536,
0.3459508717,
-0.1693674773,
0.0638452619,
-0.2469825,
0.5459581017,
-0.6025449634,
-0.2138573676,
0.1454324871,
-0.3173404634,
-0.6642158031,
0.1502862275,
-0.6787478924,
-0.328330934,
-0.1010064483,
0.4117261171,
-0.7949621677,
-0.2644066811,
0.3443567753,
-0.6558873057,
0.1046141684,
0.3870829642,
-0.4718070924,
-0.0264081266,
0.5982259512,
0.4431445003,
0.3850947618,
-0.5494508147,
-0.67183429,
0.1406389028,
-0.3934895396,
1.0816507339,
-0.2892969251,
-0.0143556716,
-0.4193115234,
-0.4519356191,
0.3651689887,
-0.3112749755,
0.796384275,
-0.0571017116,
0.3617612422,
-0.1215320006,
-0.2958342135,
-0.0747925714,
0.174299255,
-0.3283354342,
0.7981029749,
-0.0114772115,
-0.9324272275,
0.5314385891,
-0.9618761539,
-1.0806436539,
0.1734326929,
-0.0623504482,
-0.1671739966,
0.2637481093,
0.1415044516,
-0.0077979821,
-0.1256797463,
0.2943821847,
-0.342009455,
-0.0408158191,
0.3273145258,
-0.5454741716,
0.8341855407,
0.4280616939,
-0.4434592128,
-0.1990959048,
-0.7258164883,
0.2497716397,
0.2177023292,
-0.4160920084,
0.1925762743,
0.2070688307,
-0.4625787139,
0.8295333982,
-0.149845168,
-0.7473039031,
0.1519801319,
-0.5720463991,
0.4292598963,
0.4578100443,
0.1626534164,
0.0123074669,
-0.3627637923,
0.5301358104,
0.2685916722,
0.3116750717,
-0.5915434957,
-0.8208950162,
-0.8499251008,
0.2920479476,
-0.3430413306,
0.5973915458,
-1.168561697,
0.1274069846,
0.0777089968,
-0.4026298821,
-0.3400264978,
0.1968585104,
0.3503814638,
0.5699053407,
0.4837099016,
-0.5459136963,
-0.147505939,
-0.8754642606,
-0.5664855242,
-0.2445328385,
-0.2434108406,
0.2064047307,
0.2475798428,
0.2172395736,
0.66068542,
-0.4546877742,
0.4663929045,
-0.3299374282,
0.7242311835,
0.058211837,
0.562818706,
0.7434919477,
-0.3486225009,
-0.2057990134,
-0.2130517364,
-0.7915831804,
-0.1718287021,
-0.2277835011,
-0.2557761967,
0.1677661091,
0.2136846334,
-0.649386704,
0.5127467513,
0.0869686902,
-0.3593400419,
0.9016102552,
-0.2357916683,
0.4093063176,
-0.831159234,
-0.1580597311,
0.1930335611,
-0.0722283721,
-0.7647817135,
0.0861013904,
-0.4436493516,
-0.4095869362,
-0.7421039343,
0.4284456968,
-0.1949622035,
-0.3062419295,
-0.1674004495,
-0.1154547036,
0.0722814202,
0.2838137746,
-0.3556150198,
0.5221940279,
0.6179453731,
-0.6414605975,
0.6089968681,
-0.2266573459,
0.1085365415,
0.6615626812,
-0.5337079763,
0.5768920183,
-0.2918823361,
0.2852891386,
-1.1180704832,
-0.4453299642,
0.2323685735,
-0.5293836594,
0.2764747441,
0.0515235811,
-0.9044770002,
-0.7788985968,
-0.3527193069,
0.1846935898,
0.4920075834,
-0.2675969005,
0.2994423211,
-0.0700358823,
-0.6277518868,
-0.4549783468,
-0.6077965498,
0.3515795171,
-0.3304154873,
-1.1672393084,
-0.0765660927,
-0.377212286,
-0.2951806486,
-0.3187578619,
-0.1203237399,
-0.0689685643,
-0.1441761851,
-0.3031495512,
-0.4278204441,
-0.4845184088,
0.0887610018,
0.4195370078,
-0.0706638396,
0.2689777017,
-0.2616927028,
0.513210237,
-0.065597415,
-0.5431019664,
-0.6269760728,
0.3132713735,
0.3881703615,
0.0662659258,
0.2252268642,
0.7206649184,
-0.0756475851,
-0.0714837909,
-0.4841268659,
-0.2832501829,
-0.4881110191,
-0.0819481462,
-0.3387947381,
-0.4134300947,
0.0305595454,
-0.2874539793,
0.121567592,
0.4330438375,
0.2596521676,
-0.2700285912,
1.2892141342,
0.2890122235,
0.4189067185,
0.1894089133,
0.2266617268,
0.4226001501,
-0.3388534486,
-0.1717090458,
-0.6422412395,
-0.4119613469,
-0.2569183111,
-0.5646861196,
0.3708731234,
0.3145568371,
-0.4333938956,
0.307326287,
-0.292975843,
0.4578776658,
0.9039964676,
0.0602159016,
0.3620044589,
-0.0934071466,
-0.4538632929,
0.2238845378,
-0.6394675374,
-0.5481336117,
0.7553507686,
0.3753661513,
0.7074514031,
0.2881232798,
0.921220243,
0.0587262921,
0.2148150206,
-0.5474156141,
0.6440425515,
-0.3202331066,
-0.5591654181,
-0.3181665838,
-0.672088325,
-0.5144888759,
-0.2724470198,
-0.0787825659,
-0.8432184458,
-0.4603862464,
0.1505929083,
-0.2799200416,
0.210234791,
-0.6941372752,
0.6575345397,
-0.6413545012,
-0.380090028,
-0.3507085145,
-1.1242554188,
0.6759668589,
0.2399201542,
0.443546772,
0.0631411523,
0.5171759725,
0.3689396083,
-0.3326748013,
0.5825166106,
-0.2681030035,
-0.1617493033,
0.4972271025,
0.3893522918,
-0.0997337028,
0.1551554501,
-0.214430958,
-0.0939473286,
-0.5289077759,
-0.4789239168,
-0.7266300917,
0.5634166002,
-0.3856111765,
-0.5987232924,
0.0697495863,
-0.7974690199,
-0.0528132357,
0.1063610613,
0.1023669019,
0.4185890853,
0.2069184333,
0.163548246,
0.2568164766,
-0.6420354247,
0.7023997307,
-0.0456389859,
0.0653617084,
-0.5397388935,
0.8635063171,
-0.3703994155,
0.3816886842,
0.1491939574,
0.5086439252,
-0.4014365971,
0.0488151424,
-0.7426252961,
0.2273077071,
-0.9729602337,
-0.1174557731,
-0.7327148318,
-0.2260374725,
-0.816608727,
-0.1272157133,
-0.383146137,
-0.7976909876,
0.143388629,
0.1473187208,
0.0105830142,
1.0402858257,
-0.1464079469,
0.0158453919,
-0.9328916669,
0.2707245648,
0.4714536965,
0.1877612621,
0.0308228973,
-0.1940535605,
0.102975294,
-0.0777716264,
-1.0388453007,
-0.9519349337,
0.1180186048,
0.3376324475,
0.5983382463,
0.5147278309,
-0.2493964732,
0.5398881435,
-0.763444066,
1.023412466,
0.5856550336,
-0.9799579382,
0.9539839029,
-0.2526876926,
0.1802313477,
-0.0359417424,
0.3408969939,
-0.1368785501,
-0.6401894689,
-0.9855490327,
-0.4978931546,
0.4832260013,
0.5027390122,
0.3699764609,
-0.3000045121,
0.5092223287,
0.2515931726,
0.3896553218,
-0.6329416633,
-0.2492094785,
-0.6746982932,
-0.0519837402,
0.2345343679,
0.226742968,
-0.1635978371,
-0.3664402068,
0.3954499662,
-0.4130239487,
0.1940329969,
0.0818617195,
0.0975821987,
-0.3252682388,
0.6123322248,
1.2320994139,
0.8516703844,
0.0815725029,
0.1913323551,
-0.1729245335,
-0.1390532255,
0.0665398911,
0.0750795975,
0.0562203415,
0.0601121858,
0.3510481119,
0.8472356796,
0.0012918843,
-0.4620228708,
0.2818939984,
0.1348371804,
-0.3386754692,
0.0736560598,
0.4353973866,
0.2193095386,
0.4557255805,
0.4168535471,
0.3181713223,
0.4073324203,
-1.0204511881,
0.6188179255,
0.2565993369,
-0.0259650145,
-0.5517204404,
0.9061556458,
0.2068202496,
-0.5836145878,
0.6335659623,
-0.6508405209,
-0.5200196505,
0.7022201419,
0.8341166973,
0.7791632414,
-0.1834218353,
0.5907692313,
0.6485663056,
0.1965961307,
0.0001337918,
0.2964988053,
0.1437073201,
-0.6839196682,
-0.672614336,
-0.6496616006,
-0.3941029012,
-0.0204701368,
-0.2051125318,
0.6179295182,
-0.2712986469,
0.0147930766,
0.1485695988,
-0.3616150618,
-0.6005650163,
0.3280820251,
0.3937058151,
0.776951015,
-0.815412879,
0.4673826993,
0.8899540305,
-0.8912991881,
-0.7384690046,
0.4656078815,
0.0631789044,
-0.6636751294,
0.7966862321,
0.1710368544,
-0.0680956393,
0.1393892765,
-0.7914489508,
-0.3983829916,
0.8778983951,
0.4851509929,
-0.0289489776,
-0.1141416505,
0.2577325702,
0.6185287237,
-0.5046588182,
0.4075521231,
0.4245452881,
0.4450521171,
0.6648621559,
-0.8356232643,
-0.0113291992,
-0.2127830684,
-0.0913482457,
0.1671429574,
-0.4005074203,
1.0640922785,
-0.7845423818,
-0.0391202457,
0.0645746589,
0.5082145333,
0.7498087883,
0.7923483253,
0.5594547987,
0.9975976944,
0.3402653039,
0.1075940579,
1.236307621,
-0.1743934751,
0.3167790174,
1.0101332664,
-0.3484635651,
0.2908256948,
0.4154171944,
-0.1837846935,
0.9319736958,
0.0874938145,
0.4164269567,
0.1612535417,
0.482395947,
-0.2092973739,
-0.368039161,
0.0617878847,
-0.1729753315,
0.4403208196,
0.0792138427,
-0.0648064539,
-0.593911171,
0.0245657675,
0.0407748595,
-0.2351749837,
0.0090700034,
0.850384891,
0.0579880849,
-0.6363937259,
-0.0309967957,
-0.2388604283,
0.5284882784,
-0.1198165715,
-0.3435413241,
-0.3230662346,
-0.2672960758,
-0.1466952115,
-1.2417744398,
0.2618123889,
0.0954547673,
0.2159156352,
0.0097727496,
0.9069864154,
-0.2139193714,
-0.467731297,
-0.0257652067,
0.6799638867,
0.6710181236,
0.1091871336,
-0.7529764771,
-0.4654148221,
-0.1980256438,
-0.3688107431,
0.1221660897,
1.1048026085,
0.1611439586,
0.7207446098,
0.7986712456,
-0.0465002842,
0.3425170183,
0.5708147287,
0.8782147169,
-0.9884155989,
-0.3507318795,
-0.694550395,
1.0128479004,
-0.24631989,
-0.4206346571,
0.3340552747,
0.4526311457,
0.5817039609,
-0.2022640556,
0.8752132058,
-0.3314039111,
0.3810592294,
-0.4504652917,
0.5453740358,
-0.8035959601,
0.0184418391,
-0.5870303512,
-0.9031080604,
-0.2664072812,
0.4264650047,
0.2812111676,
0.4285765886,
0.9994370937,
0.4983269274,
-0.161645174,
-0.1220822036,
0.4066070616,
0.0345265083,
0.5512956977,
0.3868216574,
0.9257799387,
-0.393950671,
0.7041913271,
-0.5966631174,
0.0040180199,
0.1114362329,
-1.2905455828,
-0.642642796,
-0.1227255687,
-0.4186791778,
-0.3670478165,
-0.2737027407,
0.5635628104,
0.4884307384,
-0.3958156705,
0.0667426214,
-0.3944476247,
0.0201041307,
-0.2727961838,
-0.3979359269,
-0.3482254148,
-0.90452528,
-0.5657667518,
0.6001724601,
0.6329014301,
-0.2536191642,
-0.4334675372,
-0.2295357734,
-0.1547734588,
0.2776404917,
0.8221156001,
0.2404828519,
-0.7716587782,
-0.5647832155,
0.0496935882,
0.2001269311,
0.0949529335,
1.0569720268,
-0.4316340387,
0.2511615753,
0.6745239496,
0.5299737453,
0.1784183532,
0.2151534706,
0.5720742941,
-1.1455365419,
0.0361390784,
0.3671034276,
0.19470945,
0.4496060014,
-0.3445328772,
0.5875442624,
0.6505640745,
-0.679348588,
-0.7101832628,
0.4501199722,
-0.8520571589,
-0.2259289324,
1.0302724838,
-0.0759354532,
0.0257857367,
0.0750691816,
-0.0307395346,
0.5191431046,
-0.2156788409,
0.7557595372,
0.7376435995,
-0.862429142,
-0.5412452221,
-0.7599356174,
0.1738492697,
0.2692649662,
-1.3533445597,
-0.5573453903,
0.4463070035,
0.4570372403,
0.7008433342,
0.6744202375,
-0.0872590616,
0.5706109405,
0.3919088244,
0.4178007841,
0.2953953445,
-0.7088147402,
0.1589107066,
0.128753975,
0.0005521486,
0.2412169278
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07278v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07278v1
|
Human-interpretable clustering of short-text using large language models
| 2024-05-12T12:55:40 | 2024-05-12T12:55:40 |
Justin K. Miller, Tristram J. Alexander
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7
|
Large language models have seen extraordinary growth in popularity due to
their human-like content generation capabilities. We show that these models can
also be used to successfully cluster human-generated content, with success
defined through the measures of distinctiveness and interpretability. This
success is validated by both human reviewers and ChatGPT, providing an
automated means to close the 'validation gap' that has challenged short-text
clustering. Comparing the machine and human approaches we identify the biases
inherent in each, and question the reliance on human-coding as the 'gold
standard'. We apply our methodology to Twitter bios and find characteristic
ways humans describe themselves, agreeing well with prior specialist work, but
with interesting differences characteristic of the medium used to express
identity.
|
[
-0.2783924937,
-0.6441649795,
0.7333753705,
0.2397751212,
-0.3766635656,
0.4629826248,
-0.5365873575,
-0.6855144501,
0.3298918605,
0.2887313068,
-0.5565009713,
-0.6579751968,
-0.5556314588,
0.4693825841,
-0.8011884689,
0.9291294217,
0.300287962,
-0.2457722574,
-0.2255202085,
-0.1025914252,
-0.3500891626,
-0.5123601556,
-0.6086729765,
-0.3300312459,
0.9053422213,
0.4285993576,
0.9611504078,
0.7104744315,
0.5428653955,
0.1858014315,
-0.3102683127,
0.0803236589,
-0.3740046024,
-0.2934620678,
-0.3661716282,
-0.2202568352,
-0.389018327,
-0.1945070922,
0.8850210905,
0.9553174973,
-0.1609707624,
0.222430408,
0.3796178401,
0.4845793247,
-0.1477902234,
-0.0023285185,
-0.7111355662,
-0.0721945241,
-0.3581361473,
-0.013181787,
-0.3908936977,
-0.4653353393,
0.0647893026,
-0.1174357086,
0.7007953525,
0.2356588095,
0.5874686241,
-0.0868296251,
-0.35995242,
-0.1434255689,
-0.8914625645,
0.9218161702,
-0.7295041084,
0.1829247028,
0.2651860416,
0.5310268402,
0.0064284778,
-0.4963977337,
-0.8231884837,
0.0222335607,
-0.5123494864,
-0.3108058274,
-0.0605731644,
-0.0995072722,
0.1691573411,
0.3199450374,
-0.770416379,
0.2822211981,
-0.6456647515,
-0.144138664,
0.7977848053,
0.0496518649,
0.4940117896,
-0.3237458169,
0.146423623,
0.0609499812,
-0.8566743731,
-0.3290585876,
0.3715057969,
0.344789654,
-0.0982052013,
0.5578115582,
-0.3206495941,
0.3667058051,
-0.147692278,
0.0262017604,
0.1339318901,
-0.1042031646,
-0.0120777907,
-0.0191290211,
0.9140409827,
0.5484010577,
0.3040753603,
-0.3850663304,
-0.0924414247,
0.0634514317,
0.3382619023,
-0.7793830037,
-0.2232771069,
0.0889983475,
-0.8600045443,
-0.4620545208,
0.4021419883,
-0.8243720531,
-0.6205401421,
0.0100971041,
0.3196349442,
-0.0758571252,
-0.3405716121,
0.0500108264,
-0.1929802001,
-0.0199355278,
0.1407198608,
-1.0333021879,
0.3963412046,
0.6829528809,
0.9149183035,
-0.4496231079,
-0.4435581565,
-0.2616951764,
0.1223222911,
-0.3043936193,
0.8237169385,
-0.2966533601,
-0.4078972042,
0.0208475105,
0.0966035351,
0.132467553,
-0.6223883629,
0.5571811795,
-0.4738302529,
0.1362754107,
-0.4424424171,
-0.3217132688,
-0.0347687341,
0.1052003279,
-0.7750225067,
0.6649108529,
0.2466717958,
-0.8696584105,
0.5107399821,
-0.8979312778,
-0.5588136315,
0.1434044242,
-0.1741472632,
-0.376745373,
0.1098415852,
0.1935427636,
0.7512158751,
-0.4427973628,
0.2704603076,
-0.3120258749,
-0.3710477352,
0.5150978565,
-0.1494323015,
0.4997005761,
0.2451774925,
-0.2912423611,
0.2652029991,
-0.6445303559,
-0.1799283773,
0.3334302008,
-0.2661696374,
-0.2276780754,
0.4865295291,
0.2949904501,
0.0360643677,
0.0743551552,
-0.5974692702,
0.0039656917,
-0.2555078566,
0.9286001921,
0.441408515,
0.0049303183,
0.4752227962,
-0.2644014955,
0.2948222458,
0.0042771487,
0.1807905436,
0.0619138181,
-0.5856858492,
-0.3530652523,
-0.2025963813,
0.3977583051,
0.3821384609,
-0.4136347473,
0.7692788839,
-0.4590828121,
-0.6566157341,
-0.3904554844,
0.339119941,
0.1007349715,
0.4176537395,
0.2865714431,
-0.4081498086,
-0.5385921597,
-1.1558669806,
-0.3826751113,
-0.2672179639,
-0.3558054864,
0.2203944623,
0.6013487577,
-0.8944400549,
1.1340363026,
-0.5862078071,
0.185245961,
-0.4605804682,
0.3504272699,
0.1411231458,
0.4580820501,
0.5390663147,
-0.9402266145,
-0.6669989228,
0.1863045394,
-0.4931720495,
-0.142676875,
0.0926654711,
-0.0472646803,
-0.0078773787,
0.4221017659,
-0.7887613773,
0.5326833129,
0.5153743625,
-0.3380409479,
0.5771784782,
-0.0034770211,
0.2141709775,
-1.0903242826,
0.2511847615,
0.1169162318,
-0.5673536062,
-0.4280159175,
-0.1098399758,
-0.0995934233,
-0.0192683227,
-0.1809247881,
0.7025583982,
-0.2384000123,
-0.2190495729,
-0.390119344,
0.0575556345,
0.0434705913,
0.0575978681,
0.0388791263,
0.5343535542,
0.1757340878,
-0.2744233608,
0.3574217856,
0.1816563308,
-0.4925048649,
0.4017432332,
-0.8415260911,
0.0853450671,
-0.1096557677,
0.5200718045,
-1.0856351852,
-0.7389647961,
0.1220360026,
-0.4696440101,
-0.0371320695,
-0.0197828244,
-0.9179528356,
-0.5797401071,
-0.1101528853,
0.7433902025,
0.9833433628,
-0.5157771111,
0.4364962876,
0.2938740849,
-0.3692280948,
-0.0157340579,
-0.6558656693,
0.2428973168,
-0.6179146171,
-0.6623791456,
0.5156652331,
0.0100247189,
-0.3307803571,
0.0402789414,
0.3423070908,
-0.320545882,
0.088956818,
0.1499430984,
0.0857958049,
-0.1148373261,
0.1436112672,
0.0417009592,
0.1695577949,
-0.0544996336,
-0.2347653359,
0.5237072706,
-0.1844395101,
-0.3443800211,
-0.5518133044,
0.6988054514,
0.4937933981,
0.0514375865,
0.9635821581,
0.9453448653,
-0.5228633881,
-0.0594905987,
-0.6533284187,
-0.4063053429,
-0.396384269,
0.2380004823,
0.2205546051,
-1.2923973799,
0.805306375,
0.1143552363,
0.0207470264,
0.8881447911,
0.6526026726,
-0.3732227385,
1.3070904016,
0.9193148613,
-0.1317466348,
0.1790260822,
0.2987020016,
0.3135514855,
-0.3749742508,
0.1279070079,
-0.6485473514,
-0.2679029703,
-0.6449367404,
-0.2571453452,
0.2427227795,
-0.0300850905,
-0.0266455337,
0.1726655215,
-0.6794334054,
0.7562547326,
0.3703406751,
0.0839520171,
0.2277742475,
-0.0520099513,
0.3165870011,
-0.0475325398,
-0.5541040897,
-0.7197223306,
0.6961165071,
0.4237205684,
0.6075005531,
0.074894987,
0.6602008939,
0.7093946934,
0.465382576,
-0.5944029689,
0.4077512324,
-0.1998370737,
-0.8360981941,
-0.3841783702,
-0.5426140428,
-1.1032698154,
-0.0474854559,
-0.368388623,
-1.1831108332,
-0.2352610379,
0.2400652021,
-0.5560996532,
0.3433288634,
-0.9404642582,
1.056050539,
-0.0028540313,
0.1070376933,
-0.4124688208,
-0.8835399747,
0.2958583534,
-0.2925027907,
0.4294767678,
0.0988089517,
0.1152754202,
1.0674198866,
-0.3499877751,
1.1763486862,
0.0866293684,
0.1101663411,
0.5133213997,
-0.1408057213,
0.2029474825,
-0.0288433395,
0.211956799,
0.1438494474,
0.3250069618,
-0.5456852913,
-0.5055998564,
0.4364712238,
-0.7495617867,
-0.2751587927,
-0.0252579674,
-0.2814510167,
-0.0268733669,
0.3445591629,
0.2221614718,
0.2060747445,
-0.544954896,
0.3018968999,
0.3572031558,
-0.3594099283,
0.2397342771,
0.0611908697,
-0.4332788289,
-0.2530404925,
1.0252708197,
-0.2748222351,
0.0818887204,
0.3288953304,
0.5031613111,
-0.2965303659,
-0.5246508718,
-0.2969021499,
0.519169271,
-0.6755595207,
0.165551275,
-0.5518657565,
-0.2377845347,
-0.4398868084,
-0.2714953125,
-0.2439669371,
-0.327963531,
-0.2985683084,
0.0494919159,
0.0597919263,
1.2206506729,
0.0132119628,
0.7792154551,
-1.2711764574,
0.2968276143,
0.5329498053,
0.3540723026,
0.0347340554,
-0.2188493609,
-0.522888124,
-0.0492469259,
-0.1233337149,
-1.0179044008,
0.3313144147,
0.1548300534,
0.2768819928,
0.5500366688,
-0.3220508993,
0.3223513365,
-0.4453468919,
0.8686333895,
0.1880733073,
-0.9170238972,
0.4040386379,
-0.6960023642,
0.2078708261,
0.5367510319,
0.1952943206,
-0.8751583099,
-0.0013981224,
-0.7175476551,
-0.6240468621,
0.2910440266,
0.2707491517,
0.0515054166,
-0.2423495054,
0.4896147251,
0.3176525533,
0.2577861547,
-0.7066084743,
0.3201169372,
0.1238272935,
-0.3289406598,
-0.2629902959,
-0.4967353642,
-0.0901274905,
-0.2765590847,
0.3185778856,
-0.2984317541,
0.2482524365,
-0.0548049174,
-0.1850391179,
-0.1838621646,
0.3899519444,
0.4361193478,
0.9966799021,
-0.2854814529,
0.082432203,
0.0300260279,
-0.319329828,
-0.1398395449,
-0.0926690698,
-0.0426123254,
0.1286996752,
0.4677191079,
0.2767457962,
0.1380892843,
-0.815815866,
0.5745627284,
-0.2581754625,
-0.1559027582,
-0.1463765949,
-0.1414283663,
0.2893631756,
0.2113487571,
0.5083644986,
0.0254540984,
0.0423292853,
-0.6770829558,
-0.0682535246,
0.2931145728,
-0.4038757384,
-0.631585896,
0.5264601707,
0.3536124527,
-0.406766504,
0.5524529219,
-0.2999773026,
-0.5974082351,
0.5054038763,
0.2329571247,
1.0521073341,
0.0417225845,
0.2722771168,
0.2359566242,
0.2931731343,
-0.3653379381,
0.0341019146,
-0.0167661253,
-0.7842271328,
-0.7051039934,
-0.709038496,
-0.3557318151,
-0.1234918162,
-0.6883590817,
0.1916965544,
-0.2880144715,
-0.3362137079,
0.2631869614,
-0.273935467,
-0.6093518734,
0.1859383136,
0.2212375551,
0.7173935175,
-1.2422941923,
0.6559091806,
0.7617016435,
-0.0188472159,
-0.5350043774,
0.1400650889,
-0.0326646194,
-0.4013343751,
0.3713754714,
0.3624043763,
0.1371861696,
-0.0848867893,
-0.8312706947,
-0.4549140334,
1.0536155701,
0.0548121482,
-0.3192593157,
-0.2725735307,
0.1734634489,
0.7704140544,
-0.4955227375,
-0.0669528693,
0.7952358723,
0.3434869349,
-0.0066071618,
-1.143348217,
0.0397500359,
-0.0412340462,
0.0009820604,
0.0111649148,
-0.4668229818,
0.7905171514,
-0.1303407848,
-0.417227,
0.1348442733,
0.7490168214,
0.1286243498,
0.295865953,
0.8060518503,
0.1401718855,
0.8640019894,
0.1370004267,
1.0442759991,
0.0883919671,
0.3493771255,
0.7826217413,
-0.1950923055,
0.7387688756,
0.3990246058,
-0.3592210114,
0.6299068928,
0.6222428679,
0.0512472354,
0.1745717674,
0.0146595947,
-0.1206433401,
-0.3901364505,
-0.1647712588,
-0.087561816,
0.3061843812,
0.3652530909,
-0.4886259437,
-0.0674630776,
-0.2940217853,
-0.0789059475,
0.0958082452,
-0.2761491537,
0.7879928946,
0.1970926374,
-0.7485949397,
0.1634175181,
0.1933086067,
0.7716075778,
-0.2442354709,
0.0454218127,
0.1813702136,
0.1038641855,
-0.4528009892,
-0.8291554451,
0.6241260171,
0.2059831917,
-0.4016945064,
-0.1312228441,
0.9593482614,
-0.2883317471,
-0.5415313244,
0.0358771719,
0.8072221279,
0.2116856873,
-0.4001458883,
-0.4369983375,
-0.1446558982,
-0.0095815985,
0.1048450246,
0.3566858768,
0.2283482999,
-0.3615500033,
0.5273333788,
0.4875107706,
0.1044047475,
-0.1200250834,
0.1252960116,
0.6426774263,
-0.9298292398,
-0.7286821008,
-1.2173292637,
0.4028656185,
-0.3169896901,
0.0650402308,
0.6215712428,
0.5028986931,
0.4548845291,
-0.118106246,
1.0295767784,
-0.267591089,
1.0622544289,
-0.2235287875,
0.9876127839,
-0.4655681849,
0.0665707514,
-0.4077137411,
-0.9848802686,
-0.3951804936,
0.4039855003,
-0.267454356,
0.0988395214,
0.7871504426,
0.7128739953,
-0.1943210065,
0.0371401273,
0.2011979073,
0.2024101615,
0.4582318366,
0.3016140461,
1.1631470919,
0.0187043939,
0.5775201917,
-0.0831755772,
-0.2832302451,
-0.4429379106,
-1.010212779,
-1.2619291544,
-0.7406796217,
-0.224341765,
-0.4473232925,
-0.2429334372,
0.9221768379,
0.825252831,
-0.7119953036,
-0.0552901514,
0.1899183989,
0.2628706992,
-0.1084569022,
-0.2276483327,
0.3265798688,
0.1420488507,
-0.4709477723,
0.0022622843,
0.1270251572,
0.1286401451,
-0.5625712872,
0.0163165182,
0.3747121394,
0.0702057704,
0.7422312498,
0.4009406269,
-0.7027855515,
-0.4396612644,
-0.1300975829,
-0.2800317705,
0.1092807576,
0.9401528239,
-0.4846290648,
0.0536093824,
0.5397344828,
0.5175804496,
0.2273559123,
0.3591593206,
0.5087373853,
-0.789681673,
0.0547730364,
0.3102220297,
0.3416983783,
0.6092422605,
-0.1910760552,
0.3282817304,
0.3801691532,
-0.7781967521,
-0.8258878589,
0.0907339901,
-1.1560827494,
-0.1573191434,
1.2615294456,
0.1354895383,
-0.4703210592,
0.0007492232,
-0.2544157505,
0.0538012683,
-0.3173415065,
1.1395578384,
0.6639529467,
0.0978789255,
-0.0238127708,
-0.4688820839,
0.5358061194,
0.131177932,
-0.8927608728,
-0.0786681846,
0.3550219536,
0.2731452882,
0.2094578594,
0.6715598106,
-0.0076470133,
0.2575062811,
-0.2661714852,
-0.0118845385,
0.5359942913,
-0.262147665,
-0.1424040496,
0.053455662,
0.3392542303,
0.3430864811
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07263v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07263v1
|
Span-Aggregatable, Contextualized Word Embeddings for Effective Phrase Mining
| 2024-05-12T12:08:05 | 2024-05-12T12:08:05 |
Eyal Orbach, Lev Haikin, Nelly David, Avi Faizakof
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Dense vector representations for sentences made significant progress in
recent years as can be seen on sentence similarity tasks. Real-world phrase
retrieval applications, on the other hand, still encounter challenges for
effective use of dense representations. We show that when target phrases reside
inside noisy context, representing the full sentence with a single dense
vector, is not sufficient for effective phrase retrieval. We therefore look
into the notion of representing multiple, sub-sentence, consecutive word spans,
each with its own dense vector. We show that this technique is much more
effective for phrase mining, yet requires considerable compute to obtain useful
span representations. Accordingly, we make an argument for contextualized
word/token embeddings that can be aggregated for arbitrary word spans while
maintaining the span's semantic meaning. We introduce a modification to the
common contrastive loss used for sentence embeddings that encourages word
embeddings to have this property. To demonstrate the effect of this method we
present a dataset based on the STS-B dataset with additional generated text,
that requires finding the best matching paraphrase residing in a larger context
and report the degree of similarity to the origin phrase. We demonstrate on
this dataset, how our proposed method can achieve better results without
significant increase to compute.
|
[
-0.1288926154,
-0.9554892182,
0.521361053,
0.4710838795,
-0.6525976658,
-0.0306269079,
-0.0281398613,
-0.1290192008,
0.5251987576,
0.1639360189,
-0.235393241,
-0.4830943644,
-0.7803941965,
-0.0235880632,
-0.7053958178,
0.5735675693,
-0.034980569,
-0.0472727232,
-0.5117167234,
-0.3616636395,
-0.7239848375,
-0.6213129163,
-0.2437212616,
-0.1748987287,
0.3657292426,
0.105250746,
0.6942485571,
0.7844154239,
0.3827525675,
0.1779857427,
-0.3530999422,
0.2226966769,
-0.6270971894,
0.4730665088,
0.0456310622,
-0.3218450546,
0.2166478038,
-0.1499094516,
0.6362226009,
0.9401311278,
-0.1724088043,
-0.2694024742,
0.0162750427,
0.2587400377,
-0.6245381236,
-0.1156765819,
-0.7203439474,
0.3109841347,
-0.3448719382,
-0.4344430566,
-0.212210536,
-0.1613031924,
0.2545566857,
-0.4729177058,
0.1515546143,
0.2119695693,
0.8385697603,
0.2415488958,
-0.4336340725,
-0.3987484276,
-0.272380203,
0.8485797644,
-0.2383268625,
0.2922070324,
0.17291677,
-0.1690407544,
-0.0005673541,
-0.8357778192,
-0.2250910699,
-0.2059791982,
-0.2456393093,
0.1935562789,
-0.344931066,
-0.1090742573,
0.0235224199,
0.288454622,
-0.4490560889,
-0.006939311,
-0.2834828794,
-0.1104230061,
0.120664835,
0.2606878579,
0.1866015941,
-0.3961616158,
-0.8534187675,
-0.1528324932,
-0.7946383953,
-0.1735073328,
0.1071947217,
0.2708972394,
0.0137880417,
0.8200414777,
-0.0077709211,
0.5090199113,
-0.2883206606,
0.4509619474,
0.2967033684,
-0.4777847528,
-0.0425396562,
0.0451040007,
0.38100034,
0.5455119014,
0.2666521072,
-0.5459869504,
-0.0965719223,
0.2108342201,
0.3138998151,
-0.8141587973,
0.0181475189,
-0.0122346617,
-0.6087598205,
-0.052041553,
0.5596988201,
-0.5970401764,
-0.1856520623,
-0.1772555411,
0.3214456737,
-0.7321421504,
0.0824171677,
0.0619916692,
-0.9136757255,
0.2641226053,
-0.2128962725,
-0.4605693519,
0.3186703324,
0.5844798088,
1.2813513279,
-0.1091964468,
-0.2169962674,
-0.674862504,
0.188970238,
-0.6029579043,
0.7031515241,
-0.7569829226,
-0.7050912976,
0.1650238931,
-0.3324548602,
-0.1474752873,
-0.6797601581,
0.6837825179,
-0.3858298659,
0.0616891161,
-0.3693479598,
-1.0059370995,
0.2584426999,
0.1012277082,
-0.4067060649,
1.0904029608,
-0.0216584373,
-0.9245152473,
0.3496860862,
-0.2909867764,
-0.6077414155,
0.0097073121,
-0.1162546948,
-0.2925237715,
0.622772336,
0.3171513975,
0.7574038506,
0.2684465349,
0.0007958101,
-0.3628176153,
-0.6628302932,
0.1308350563,
-0.1490254402,
0.3971883655,
0.2951695323,
-0.1539818794,
-0.1482866853,
-0.4246749282,
-0.1268119216,
0.1067807525,
-0.1281808317,
-1.1661169529,
0.2611704469,
0.0896891728,
-0.0914959013,
0.2623479068,
-0.5740864873,
-0.0806508735,
-0.4051030576,
0.4506864548,
0.6683989763,
0.1752693057,
0.5822479725,
-0.1385457218,
0.3866023123,
0.1887822151,
-0.3423454463,
-0.3900144398,
-0.1663845181,
-0.375133723,
-0.3240500093,
0.1721376628,
0.3940417469,
-0.703255713,
0.6313508749,
-0.4263296127,
-0.3383447528,
-0.1795754135,
-0.0132208113,
0.1772298664,
0.4330395758,
0.6392093897,
-0.1528660059,
-0.7298608422,
-0.9228206277,
-0.55216676,
0.283649087,
0.0621089116,
0.2516660392,
0.3738455772,
-0.22267811,
1.0643059015,
-1.0472900867,
-0.4483341873,
-0.2958365679,
0.2484304458,
-0.0895284265,
0.4217115641,
0.586386323,
-0.9079324007,
-0.3108313978,
-0.323661983,
-0.7814591527,
-0.09889929,
-0.0819725618,
-0.2072893828,
-0.3401510119,
1.085688591,
-0.4581253827,
0.301391989,
0.4060483873,
-0.4135526717,
0.0638119131,
-0.2590012252,
-0.2034455389,
-1.1656566858,
0.0708504245,
0.0937532187,
-0.2040163428,
-0.3787702024,
0.1064046919,
-0.0045948732,
-0.0347858481,
-0.1564069539,
0.5223415494,
-0.395267278,
0.0283126775,
-0.3885006607,
0.3453756273,
-0.0577108189,
0.0676320121,
0.0275946259,
0.6701712012,
0.4707227945,
-0.521517992,
0.1980930865,
0.3918958306,
-0.3125807941,
0.850910008,
-0.8419311047,
-0.1596009135,
-0.4842397273,
0.4988226891,
-0.7398121953,
0.0553040504,
-0.1739215851,
-0.3275589049,
0.0843479484,
0.1661867201,
-0.3423052132,
-0.092860736,
-0.5495388508,
0.1422157288,
0.3986913562,
-0.5589995384,
0.2591010332,
0.3966094851,
-0.1446104646,
-0.527920723,
-0.8865850568,
0.2979808748,
-0.6627371311,
-0.4723450541,
0.865046978,
0.1576250046,
-0.1682541668,
0.4254418314,
-0.2482575178,
-0.0774544105,
0.1273143142,
0.0225084964,
-0.0924188122,
0.0874558687,
0.5355934501,
0.186626628,
0.0510872006,
-0.0321359038,
-0.2093887031,
0.762744844,
0.0734206066,
0.0912547037,
0.1089617014,
0.7169765234,
0.1064383015,
-0.1802788675,
0.8057332635,
1.0032467842,
-0.4070428908,
-0.3173524737,
-0.2031428814,
-0.0633743927,
-0.398987174,
0.4618432522,
-0.4472532868,
-1.1827278137,
0.50479424,
-0.15968436,
-0.1109796017,
0.5263930559,
0.2273834944,
-0.1915682703,
0.7672156692,
0.4541294575,
-0.1276576221,
0.6362333894,
-0.2170388699,
-0.0600448698,
-0.9096195102,
-0.4433121681,
-0.6343317628,
-0.3748631775,
-0.3920319378,
-0.4859742522,
0.3641526103,
0.0594950952,
-0.0990569592,
0.3312704563,
-0.2909959853,
0.3112237453,
0.5935885906,
0.2541053295,
-0.1206113994,
0.2741621137,
-0.4122563899,
-0.1128554717,
-0.717430234,
-0.1827298105,
0.8050887585,
0.0101528689,
0.7170168161,
-0.0100624971,
0.8815420866,
0.3226276934,
-0.21767582,
-0.6091954708,
0.4104460478,
-0.5811023116,
-0.3371134996,
-0.0993417278,
-0.6699901819,
-1.1865485907,
0.3453168571,
-0.2639001012,
-0.4564781785,
0.1183760688,
-0.0985291377,
-0.1830841005,
-0.052113045,
-0.7440139651,
0.8008654118,
0.0559022538,
-0.262521565,
-0.396974951,
-0.6902325153,
-0.0825551376,
0.2542351484,
0.0276080798,
0.1532265246,
-0.2645943463,
0.7387239933,
-0.5614767075,
0.5848078132,
-0.3370335698,
0.2811632156,
0.3276993036,
-0.2700940371,
0.5406054854,
-0.1137965396,
0.0743567124,
-0.1685870439,
-0.2745133042,
-0.5809485912,
-0.4664897621,
0.972733438,
-0.4961465001,
-0.2033820003,
-0.3805852234,
-0.3225913048,
-0.0673548207,
0.0321942121,
0.3645106852,
0.6456401348,
-0.5112156272,
0.7982679605,
0.6554812193,
-0.2161479592,
0.4182015359,
-0.2762037516,
0.2213775665,
-0.395406276,
0.7141325474,
0.1712205857,
-0.1922604591,
0.6709275246,
0.3875698149,
-0.5326146483,
-0.3370757997,
-0.0041779187,
-0.0547570959,
-0.6027118564,
-0.1942017376,
-0.7495506406,
0.0261769164,
-0.3227317929,
-0.4379681647,
-0.0419019051,
-0.5235414505,
-0.3279621899,
-0.3175975978,
0.3349009454,
0.5615035295,
-0.0764764547,
0.4272642732,
-0.6894676089,
0.3171823025,
0.0671814233,
0.3711024225,
-0.0981198326,
-0.1980906278,
-0.4090876281,
-0.2880968153,
-0.1305085123,
-0.8299494982,
0.3448018432,
0.3749957085,
0.7357702851,
0.2967945635,
0.0100799948,
1.089972496,
-0.6282294393,
0.8644979596,
0.0111431694,
-1.0235251188,
0.4931025207,
-0.1718539,
0.3021246195,
0.4548971057,
0.4450697005,
-0.5206457973,
-0.2872599065,
-0.725358963,
-1.4217680693,
0.2676410377,
0.3061689436,
0.5884616971,
-0.4895395339,
0.3267182708,
-0.0385031551,
0.1692717075,
-0.5968483686,
-0.2000276297,
-0.4165281355,
-0.345435828,
-0.0672265366,
-0.2224570215,
0.0977695957,
0.1246740669,
0.3376445472,
0.059096653,
0.4222666025,
0.4255266488,
-0.3906013668,
0.3499556184,
0.1858478189,
0.1977597326,
0.2696846724,
-0.1281254441,
0.4711599052,
0.2594777048,
-0.285297215,
-0.1935674399,
0.3678190112,
-0.1771456748,
0.3424560428,
0.3723199964,
0.6209380627,
0.5126692057,
-0.6895986199,
0.6693777442,
0.2271342874,
-0.0484273806,
-0.3186023533,
-0.2768248916,
0.1403180063,
0.0832841918,
0.4538062513,
-0.0092026927,
0.343490243,
-0.5100800395,
0.3804603815,
0.5786047578,
-0.4096079767,
0.1017529592,
0.6185588837,
0.1755172312,
0.2949999571,
0.5963875055,
-0.1075295135,
-0.5522948503,
0.3652211726,
0.5128299594,
0.754440546,
-0.0241944063,
0.0529723875,
0.2333066016,
0.0743824244,
-0.2914715111,
0.1046595946,
-0.0943573564,
-0.6333141923,
-0.2815636098,
-0.4545911849,
-0.1050332263,
-0.2411102653,
-0.5447979569,
0.0709587857,
-0.12720716,
-0.0177124441,
-0.2423054576,
-0.1663020849,
-0.4289649129,
0.2077209651,
0.0229269043,
0.8110368848,
-0.8168768287,
0.3241557479,
0.7590611577,
-0.2694458365,
-0.4728655517,
0.003680313,
-0.3014534414,
-0.6085293293,
0.4946312904,
0.3313909471,
-0.001880086,
-0.1129398718,
-0.561296761,
-0.6757663488,
1.1732048988,
0.0246220008,
-0.2249289751,
0.0025667385,
-0.0864872858,
0.4912734032,
-0.3546438515,
-0.1385903358,
0.2483763993,
0.2313832492,
0.2204515636,
-0.1635093689,
0.1475495249,
-0.0700246319,
0.3123762012,
0.1807131022,
-0.4747274518,
0.8784579635,
0.2674422562,
-0.237207517,
0.242616564,
1.0026123524,
0.1570453048,
0.3323955834,
0.5429942012,
0.8138212562,
0.6719101667,
-0.1756969839,
1.1390686035,
-0.234737888,
0.2183915079,
0.885753572,
-0.0046104281,
0.8331301808,
0.4786347151,
0.2013851553,
0.5142306089,
0.3412355185,
-0.0915800035,
0.6817843914,
0.4383065701,
-0.1021534652,
-0.1568076611,
-0.209827587,
-0.2464757115,
0.4340879917,
0.4838356376,
-0.5813946724,
-0.3477703035,
-0.0636765957,
0.2051000148,
0.4812346697,
-0.3373687267,
0.4863120317,
0.3289775848,
-0.5050097704,
0.0745551586,
0.1714836806,
0.9033715129,
-0.5899570584,
0.1510615796,
-0.3750088215,
0.1549105346,
-0.1533257514,
-0.489590019,
0.6872665286,
0.0498149097,
0.1241369918,
-0.4390808642,
0.8642843366,
-0.5727957487,
-0.3674566448,
0.1794390678,
0.7295460105,
-0.0602874756,
-0.1592899859,
-0.382170409,
-0.0570192114,
-0.3680144846,
-0.2039402723,
0.2073827833,
0.6038499475,
0.0599423014,
0.3637536764,
0.385745436,
0.115975894,
0.2342135608,
0.185906902,
0.9582424164,
-0.8307931423,
-0.8538907766,
-0.8472408056,
0.2502539456,
-0.4679864943,
-0.3582285941,
0.8871256709,
0.8828440309,
0.5307195783,
0.0627067313,
0.7804587483,
-0.1497785598,
0.4246483743,
-0.6258968115,
0.2110720575,
-0.6161146164,
0.1019286588,
-0.4658222497,
-1.008327961,
-0.5388095975,
0.9073434472,
0.0607447699,
0.0084517403,
0.8521280885,
0.5554170609,
-0.1574299335,
-0.1016184092,
0.1100426242,
0.2303290218,
0.1634308398,
0.2496111542,
0.7636384964,
-0.2498354167,
0.7382808924,
0.1378695518,
-0.0206974223,
-0.1607059538,
-0.8575796485,
-0.6404830217,
-0.5154172182,
-0.1712882072,
-0.1774065644,
0.1317368597,
0.8077260852,
0.3484917581,
-0.1999901831,
-0.0475416891,
-0.3969030976,
-0.0623204038,
-0.4174417257,
-0.25826931,
0.5829045773,
-0.5917308927,
-0.6685419679,
0.62084198,
0.1427867562,
-0.0150693087,
0.0171869844,
0.139735058,
-0.265337497,
0.1828822047,
0.8608176112,
-0.1795394123,
-0.2106915414,
-0.5421180725,
0.1928698272,
0.0279137399,
-0.1521182358,
0.885489285,
-0.845143497,
0.2139849365,
0.6493892074,
0.7300339937,
0.7013980746,
0.3245896399,
0.5172964931,
-1.3585823774,
0.108545512,
0.1749552339,
0.5705755353,
0.4695959687,
-0.0018559331,
0.6394542456,
0.3307240605,
-0.2499624044,
-0.5040230155,
0.231571883,
-1.1170448065,
-0.5780237317,
1.2895956039,
-0.2052340508,
0.1399226934,
-0.1125553399,
-0.143595621,
0.1286117136,
-0.3814075291,
0.4382888675,
0.6930980682,
-0.0293726306,
0.2050105184,
0.0395677462,
0.2011977434,
0.4351948798,
-0.3744256198,
-0.0771688521,
0.5754626989,
0.0225440804,
0.171343267,
0.3711098731,
-0.18754749,
-0.1385550648,
0.2095941752,
-0.4497614503,
-0.1718070358,
0.0031838263,
-0.2762415707,
0.5755708814,
-0.2691365182,
-0.1843027472
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10974v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10974v2
|
Bottleneck-Minimal Indexing for Generative Document Retrieval
| 2024-05-12T11:41:26 | 2024-05-21T01:29:13 |
Xin Du, Lixin Xiu, Kumiko Tanaka-Ishii
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We apply an information-theoretic perspective to reconsider generative
document retrieval (GDR), in which a document $x \in X$ is indexed by $t \in
T$, and a neural autoregressive model is trained to map queries $Q$ to $T$. GDR
can be considered to involve information transmission from documents $X$ to
queries $Q$, with the requirement to transmit more bits via the indexes $T$. By
applying Shannon's rate-distortion theory, the optimality of indexing can be
analyzed in terms of the mutual information, and the design of the indexes $T$
can then be regarded as a {\em bottleneck} in GDR. After reformulating GDR from
this perspective, we empirically quantify the bottleneck underlying GDR.
Finally, using the NQ320K and MARCO datasets, we evaluate our proposed
bottleneck-minimal indexing method in comparison with various previous indexing
methods, and we show that it outperforms those methods.
|
[
-0.5202561021,
-0.5335293412,
0.4956276417,
0.1543911695,
-0.2291439027,
-0.130774498,
-0.0260989405,
-0.3468489647,
0.1565802395,
0.2883346975,
-0.5604904294,
-0.2441265732,
-0.4563056529,
0.0775888935,
-0.6900935173,
0.6344935894,
0.1903730482,
-0.1302055568,
-0.2943059802,
-0.0759542137,
0.0877778977,
-0.4375117719,
-0.6520440578,
-0.1337963194,
0.3998714387,
0.2804276943,
0.5530771613,
0.7793446779,
0.8313667178,
0.2938007414,
-0.0997449681,
0.0048471089,
-0.5308029056,
0.2607827187,
-0.0159142409,
-0.8025921583,
0.013467012,
-0.2018667758,
0.6238866448,
0.7395488024,
-0.2041637599,
0.1828612834,
0.0238821935,
1.0695571899,
-0.8358135819,
-0.1467054039,
-0.6226758361,
0.3757858872,
-0.4197724164,
-0.4978398383,
-0.2646335065,
-0.5089414716,
0.097941339,
-0.7236993313,
0.990950942,
0.2814214528,
0.8475834727,
0.2417155951,
-0.2809945643,
-0.3382542133,
-0.6854477525,
0.3528344035,
0.037793003,
0.4317110777,
0.3225754201,
0.1969826818,
0.1407126039,
-0.581913054,
-0.5757678151,
-0.108762674,
0.0974511281,
0.0328692272,
-0.5107267499,
0.1941381395,
0.5877547264,
0.8354088068,
-0.7168528438,
0.0600061268,
-0.5747586489,
-0.131534338,
0.4379846752,
0.4200339615,
-0.0163406339,
-0.1766681224,
-0.5853856802,
-0.3400734067,
-0.6350168586,
-0.2773566246,
0.5001989603,
-0.0143734533,
0.2239803374,
0.6239421964,
-0.5225402117,
0.6406546235,
0.1345023364,
0.4804409444,
0.3084813058,
-0.7220539451,
-0.049257461,
-0.2833776474,
0.8009095788,
0.5267350674,
0.0109566217,
-0.3992533982,
-0.3699117899,
-0.0550410971,
0.5119999647,
-0.9020707607,
-0.1354070455,
-0.2415814847,
-0.4859315157,
-0.2757979035,
-0.0581266545,
-1.060952425,
-0.280287385,
-0.0618037321,
0.7407078147,
-0.3928649426,
-0.0825819001,
-0.1920282841,
-0.397274971,
0.2590329647,
0.1436411589,
-1.0507206917,
0.3350268304,
0.5563533902,
1.3402663469,
0.0633146837,
0.179472208,
-0.2597365677,
-0.078292571,
-0.5148007274,
0.8603141904,
-0.371144861,
-0.8686366677,
-0.0240524858,
-0.260543853,
-0.1036793664,
-0.8171333075,
0.5676996112,
-0.6436140537,
-0.0311309416,
-0.5134127736,
-0.5118337274,
0.0092932545,
-0.0159419551,
-0.9583823681,
0.8651893735,
0.2691352665,
-0.6124069095,
0.3183377385,
-0.779003799,
-0.3572486043,
0.0120207444,
-0.1879971176,
-0.3142734766,
0.3905011117,
0.022335764,
-0.0562583581,
-0.641055584,
-0.1469540447,
-0.1795501113,
-0.5689592957,
-0.1582263857,
-0.5994093418,
0.6846458316,
0.522975266,
-0.1532831788,
-0.4542045593,
-0.766230762,
0.3365071714,
-0.0600783527,
-0.2903479636,
-0.3951433897,
-0.2179020941,
0.1194426268,
-0.0296333451,
0.0596636012,
-0.4284763932,
0.5879296064,
-0.2616063356,
0.5220329762,
0.4633172154,
0.1398438513,
0.6213574409,
-0.5964872837,
0.415474385,
0.0941969231,
0.3637626171,
0.1796638668,
-0.3042806685,
-0.9492505789,
0.1673654318,
0.3107129037,
0.388119638,
-0.6784280539,
-0.0195307657,
-0.2934303582,
-0.4799779058,
-0.8548375368,
0.0694533437,
0.3535559773,
0.4983741045,
0.4762457609,
-0.9336761832,
-0.4467284083,
-1.0396840572,
-0.1597667038,
-0.0793921128,
-0.1721490622,
0.3352196217,
0.3370805979,
-0.1093977094,
0.6891712546,
-0.5934588313,
-0.4808505177,
0.0201843828,
0.7675082088,
0.319904238,
0.5427532196,
0.4155982137,
-0.9018202424,
-0.7170862556,
-0.4385888278,
-0.3601489067,
-0.1568438858,
0.0658450872,
-0.1565728933,
0.2921344042,
0.4911496341,
-0.8484382033,
0.5735165477,
-0.0624359176,
0.0965383127,
0.3178747594,
-0.4828982353,
0.03294212,
-0.6508588791,
0.2014434785,
0.0214158278,
0.1217246279,
-0.6508585215,
-0.0824594423,
0.1770251989,
-0.072542645,
0.2159163058,
0.0950501114,
-0.7175390124,
-0.232415244,
-0.2204313576,
0.2418202013,
0.2587387562,
0.4270339012,
-0.2516669035,
1.1490343809,
0.2114614397,
-0.5855666995,
0.2039049715,
0.1304100454,
-0.6366180778,
0.8770346642,
-0.6002987623,
0.2657116055,
-0.5375236273,
-0.0652697682,
-0.6630477309,
0.3123523891,
0.1861312836,
-0.3001706898,
0.4827094972,
-0.2896310389,
-0.4273655415,
-0.2542344332,
-0.3956058323,
0.5299005508,
0.345021069,
-0.405230999,
0.298633486,
0.1986664683,
0.2016359866,
-0.7543672919,
-0.4274275601,
0.0300022401,
-0.0425565839,
-0.3616895676,
0.7716398835,
-0.1987030208,
-0.0051325234,
0.3124272823,
-0.271972537,
-0.3185433149,
0.005577418,
0.1254496574,
0.012578031,
-0.1007977054,
0.3777469397,
-0.3076856136,
-0.1451337337,
-0.1249812022,
-0.3431521058,
0.5090233088,
-0.1442735791,
-0.2051298022,
-0.1953750253,
0.6100929976,
0.3328471184,
-0.0142829008,
0.4019016325,
0.6903765798,
-0.1747188568,
-0.1085369587,
-0.7370301485,
0.187354058,
-0.4204511344,
0.4392794967,
-0.5114449263,
-0.7143722177,
0.351752609,
0.1756399572,
-0.6002876759,
0.6617125273,
0.370454967,
-0.2512244284,
0.6094748974,
0.9076561928,
-0.4842089117,
0.6356245875,
-0.844512105,
0.130153209,
-1.2636799812,
-0.1276928931,
-0.7335913181,
-0.3277246952,
-0.8022161126,
-0.6287026405,
0.5915563703,
0.3087527752,
-0.3578508794,
0.128742978,
-0.4761482179,
0.4631316364,
0.9850332737,
0.0485658459,
0.4450503588,
0.0154299717,
-0.129292652,
0.1099288464,
-0.8916471601,
0.0715080798,
1.3823406696,
-0.1672856063,
0.8726035953,
0.1258674413,
0.5591830015,
0.2401168346,
0.3683943152,
-0.5724375248,
0.2332046777,
-0.1758958846,
-0.7123980522,
-0.3894319534,
-0.5685933232,
-1.015986681,
0.4796187878,
-0.1727843285,
-0.7598471642,
0.8232197762,
0.1228103116,
-0.3266476989,
0.1735136062,
-0.5383661985,
0.7440207601,
-0.0898475647,
-0.467893362,
-0.5421155691,
-0.4361162186,
0.2220178246,
0.0154685425,
-0.0964817032,
0.1559944302,
-0.167727083,
0.505666852,
-0.4155636728,
0.2706147432,
-0.2586599886,
0.3707661331,
0.1500423402,
-0.0595071539,
0.4408966899,
-0.1561401188,
-0.1439620405,
0.1355969012,
0.0282185748,
-0.0901661441,
-0.7510750294,
0.4727045,
-0.6953865886,
-0.7561278939,
-0.4531152546,
-0.2689566612,
0.0418952405,
0.1843647361,
0.7139706612,
0.4077242315,
-0.2126778513,
0.3269207478,
0.7636396885,
0.0893172398,
0.3536596596,
0.6715385318,
0.3026861846,
-0.1497349888,
0.8908365369,
0.5632616878,
0.2205134928,
0.7998011708,
-0.128528446,
-0.3944496214,
-0.5758906603,
-0.2291809171,
0.0097392909,
-0.6305170059,
-0.3705337346,
-0.3961881101,
-0.3209261,
-0.039447926,
0.304394573,
-0.4790709019,
-0.3030420244,
-0.231904462,
0.2362901121,
0.0884615555,
0.400336951,
-0.5359277129,
0.2808167636,
-0.4012771249,
0.4459320605,
0.2274398655,
0.6717616916,
0.341838032,
-0.2176532,
-0.397264272,
-0.1296352446,
-0.6976947188,
-0.717456758,
0.3088461161,
0.5441957712,
0.4896049201,
0.5612275004,
0.2624627352,
0.6356226206,
-0.5235953927,
0.3401034772,
0.001788173,
-0.8956484199,
0.2710729539,
0.1092793196,
0.0527110547,
0.7750668526,
0.6631407142,
-0.8151186705,
-0.031090457,
-0.5533091426,
-1.0197758675,
0.3634830713,
0.1670942158,
-0.0242239479,
0.0025631469,
0.3898668289,
-0.2577198446,
0.4536173642,
-0.2725916505,
-0.2552056015,
-0.0479777642,
-0.0218191277,
-0.0544094853,
-0.602725327,
-0.1437221169,
-0.184425056,
0.4075330198,
0.0183450952,
0.9218065143,
0.7088580132,
-0.2911019921,
-0.3442851901,
0.1867044568,
0.6333895922,
0.3877372146,
-0.5845005512,
0.0304332282,
-0.1678009629,
-0.5999004841,
0.2796883285,
0.0517732911,
-0.490160495,
0.1813521385,
0.0781490952,
0.9093288779,
-0.0806404427,
-0.1991218179,
0.6207094193,
-0.2134841233,
-0.2134487778,
-0.4233489037,
0.1039218232,
-0.2040621042,
0.4906617403,
0.6068229079,
0.1727141738,
0.489641428,
-0.3705899417,
0.0771785975,
0.8530859947,
-0.124774605,
-0.0245205965,
0.7891538143,
-0.0535418279,
-0.3628694713,
0.9870134592,
-0.1412428468,
-0.4414253831,
0.6202306747,
0.1648812294,
1.1013708115,
0.0155058783,
0.0566986762,
0.3387856781,
0.4801580012,
-0.1253226399,
0.1287552863,
-0.6893781424,
-0.5922191143,
0.0193541311,
-0.5484399199,
-0.4763117135,
0.1116592884,
-0.837603569,
-0.1193008572,
-0.119769901,
-0.3817604184,
0.0539562367,
0.2994583547,
-1.0296480656,
-0.0199761204,
-0.2844290435,
1.0553854704,
-0.3346382976,
0.7640244365,
-0.0318291262,
-0.610034287,
-0.2463256568,
0.2196722329,
-0.3671782613,
-0.8042029142,
0.9197848439,
-0.0025300267,
-0.044260975,
0.0905043483,
-0.1616580784,
-1.1298394203,
1.2908523083,
0.0223904829,
-0.7812181711,
-0.2158427536,
0.1481838524,
0.5930604935,
-0.2911888659,
0.4654230475,
0.2477523386,
0.2415654957,
-0.0461924188,
-0.7248943448,
-0.0947813019,
-0.4697524607,
0.5433796048,
0.1595354974,
-0.7827141285,
0.8782470822,
-0.1746371984,
-0.5992645025,
0.1735280901,
0.2985824645,
-0.6381917,
0.4406901896,
0.5323045254,
0.9369875193,
0.8406402469,
-0.1723320484,
1.0935976505,
-0.5984268188,
0.5253688693,
0.6965625882,
0.0603923351,
0.7772690058,
0.5500855446,
-0.3354919851,
0.2657596767,
0.3500947952,
-0.2021858245,
0.8310742378,
0.5103399158,
-0.4184627235,
0.130315125,
-0.0755959079,
-0.5897211432,
0.1701422483,
0.3219439387,
-0.3873841465,
-0.271714896,
-0.1401537359,
-0.2552943528,
-0.2908292711,
-0.3352891207,
0.7440620065,
0.0061956826,
-0.4273022115,
0.7698861361,
0.1302845627,
0.6733369827,
-0.3647334874,
0.294288516,
-0.7279123068,
-0.0413696095,
0.1659520864,
-0.3224467039,
0.4091034532,
-0.1775082052,
-0.5780129433,
-0.1130243391,
0.5212950706,
-0.4425472021,
-0.1498480588,
0.0173832998,
0.3263466358,
0.0698169097,
-0.0707372651,
-0.3500956893,
0.0077357432,
-0.2491156459,
-0.27938357,
0.4960261583,
0.4873362482,
0.0773330778,
0.7920716405,
0.2606175542,
0.2347605228,
-0.0398504809,
-0.1164233759,
0.8821903467,
-0.7725639939,
-0.373051703,
-0.592461586,
0.0090266699,
-0.1087319478,
-0.2825020552,
0.3710389137,
0.741892457,
1.0053596497,
-0.1166800484,
0.8076710105,
-0.0508147664,
0.3296726048,
-0.5324960947,
0.6585436463,
-0.6288009882,
0.0948482603,
-0.1777047813,
-0.9285203815,
0.0206548572,
0.8098652959,
-0.1157438979,
-0.1136096716,
0.6689806581,
1.1298161745,
0.2274478823,
-0.064908959,
0.0685114786,
0.1682210416,
0.0754759759,
0.9088690877,
0.521617353,
-0.658968389,
0.6812566519,
-0.4934340119,
-0.068168737,
-0.3919290304,
-0.6750198007,
-0.321152389,
-0.9052098989,
-0.1380866021,
-0.1039307639,
0.3573278785,
0.6105042696,
0.3922524452,
-0.3037445843,
-0.2773849368,
-0.2895341516,
0.3004553318,
-0.1914938688,
-0.2487817407,
0.4472947717,
-0.6972391605,
-0.6559371948,
0.2846727967,
0.2365425974,
0.0861198157,
-0.2914631069,
0.2477314323,
0.0392753668,
-0.1766776443,
0.2181870341,
0.3220194578,
-0.0729352087,
-0.2451869398,
-0.1865769029,
-0.3335757852,
0.2951476276,
0.9991509914,
-0.625072062,
0.6927385926,
0.3730030358,
0.5485884547,
1.0903581381,
0.0926565528,
0.4573923647,
-0.647451818,
0.0131784687,
0.1530967504,
-0.1108708829,
0.1185837612,
-0.4186442792,
0.6370905638,
0.6716709137,
-0.6074285507,
-0.8651005626,
0.1230042949,
-0.740512073,
0.0869787782,
0.5296505094,
0.195678547,
-0.2141470313,
0.0780161992,
0.1779486984,
0.1712524891,
-0.2126718313,
1.0545657873,
0.5941562653,
-0.2280970216,
-0.2779840231,
-0.8966293335,
0.8150734901,
0.2737203538,
-0.1343291998,
-0.1679501534,
0.3207066953,
0.1319459081,
0.2860417962,
0.9699105024,
-0.0054012896,
0.1988735795,
0.2423704267,
0.038140934,
-0.1248474941,
-0.1974997222,
-0.3204442561,
0.3939389586,
0.0821592882,
-0.3511185646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07248v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07248v1
|
Limited Ability of LLMs to Simulate Human Psychological Behaviours: a Psychometric Analysis
| 2024-05-12T10:52:15 | 2024-05-12T10:52:15 |
Nikolay B Petrov, Gregory Serapio-García, Jason Rentfrow
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.HC, 68T50, I.2.7
|
The humanlike responses of large language models (LLMs) have prompted social
scientists to investigate whether LLMs can be used to simulate human
participants in experiments, opinion polls and surveys. Of central interest in
this line of research has been mapping out the psychological profiles of LLMs
by prompting them to respond to standardized questionnaires. The conflicting
findings of this research are unsurprising given that mapping out underlying,
or latent, traits from LLMs' text responses to questionnaires is no easy task.
To address this, we use psychometrics, the science of psychological
measurement. In this study, we prompt OpenAI's flagship models, GPT-3.5 and
GPT-4, to assume different personas and respond to a range of standardized
measures of personality constructs. We used two kinds of persona descriptions:
either generic (four or five random person descriptions) or specific (mostly
demographics of actual humans from a large-scale human dataset). We found that
the responses from GPT-4, but not GPT-3.5, using generic persona descriptions
show promising, albeit not perfect, psychometric properties, similar to human
norms, but the data from both LLMs when using specific demographic profiles,
show poor psychometrics properties. We conclude that, currently, when LLMs are
asked to simulate silicon personas, their responses are poor signals of
potentially underlying latent traits. Thus, our work casts doubt on LLMs'
ability to simulate individual-level human behaviour across multiple-choice
question answering tasks.
|
[
-0.3743458092,
-0.6254637837,
0.8264936209,
0.4698504806,
-0.0272786245,
0.1086231694,
-0.3204077482,
-0.4998522103,
0.2841285169,
0.2910967469,
-0.6664628386,
-0.0709519759,
-0.2192602754,
0.2318928242,
-0.0651563555,
0.8822043538,
-0.1309884936,
0.1765258014,
-0.3328821957,
0.0476871915,
0.0288256556,
-0.9910383224,
-0.7043733001,
-0.5285462737,
0.8298619986,
0.0138066588,
0.6200160384,
-0.1202816665,
0.3704180419,
0.1516766101,
-0.0381579436,
-0.0875963494,
-0.5524845719,
-0.0696606711,
-0.02173925,
-0.743632257,
-0.7061089277,
0.7096377015,
0.6491431594,
0.8105448484,
0.1102828756,
0.3118686378,
0.3332188427,
0.3705144525,
-0.3000494838,
0.1266363263,
-0.2009180486,
0.1675593704,
-0.1991873533,
-0.1670287102,
-0.2714886069,
-0.4219811261,
0.0771971494,
-0.3527185619,
0.2645966113,
-0.0107604787,
0.6742648482,
-0.0583021976,
-0.3152195811,
-0.0178131256,
-1.0906056166,
0.6394261718,
-0.8033855557,
0.029858917,
0.7397896647,
0.1455630809,
-0.1490498483,
-0.2345490307,
-0.5178026557,
-0.5071863532,
-0.203412056,
0.2786363661,
0.169133991,
0.0135805644,
0.5362035036,
0.1652993411,
-0.5442248583,
0.2416247278,
-0.4509120584,
-0.2291489094,
0.6854251027,
0.5571353436,
0.0718987361,
-0.157092005,
-0.2664168775,
-0.1772499084,
-0.8531478643,
0.396966666,
0.7421190143,
0.1835379899,
-0.2346013635,
0.7234194875,
0.0182916373,
0.169080779,
0.0701107904,
-0.4378346801,
0.164870888,
-0.1817878187,
-0.0548694804,
-0.217892468,
0.8987192512,
0.5141094923,
0.5291146636,
-0.1797100753,
-0.148010686,
0.2873603404,
0.092047289,
-0.7588492036,
-0.1091805175,
0.4388388693,
-0.4160887301,
-0.228467539,
0.0463037938,
-0.9253322482,
-0.390625447,
-0.0349007398,
0.1092780977,
-0.2438565195,
-0.3883975446,
-0.0882752985,
0.0722255334,
0.5464408398,
0.2226769924,
-0.8361179233,
0.5769529939,
0.4844798744,
0.7803333402,
-0.4261215925,
-0.5505369902,
-0.0119203357,
0.1065462902,
-0.3942534924,
0.5757313371,
-0.6789535284,
-0.5787543654,
-0.2212332338,
-0.1742224544,
-0.2005117834,
-0.4803928733,
0.1494872719,
-0.3884855509,
0.308239609,
-0.6108154058,
-0.3226807117,
0.2249291688,
0.3743543327,
-0.4257060289,
0.8404168487,
0.2950451374,
-0.7111443281,
0.3098601699,
-0.6081377268,
-0.1216269284,
-0.0795762539,
-0.5867855549,
-0.1777798682,
0.123001419,
0.0015691259,
0.6033393145,
-0.3001841903,
0.2343016863,
-0.7100021243,
-0.6685933471,
0.8722797036,
-0.4952411056,
0.7076223493,
0.1003733501,
-0.1291016191,
-0.0654042661,
-0.3952738047,
-0.1136907265,
0.2055071741,
-0.3326158524,
-0.0680098906,
0.0870200023,
0.0073784646,
0.2883521318,
0.2199604064,
-0.8352718353,
0.3291765749,
-0.2886016071,
0.4558513463,
0.8596665263,
0.0126543026,
0.2990014255,
-0.665840745,
0.8396180272,
-0.0608136505,
-0.064826116,
0.2859823108,
-0.6719493866,
-0.2156189978,
-0.5289804935,
0.0127531644,
0.5933129191,
-0.2338833511,
0.1631598622,
-0.1307828277,
-0.6197680831,
-0.3394172788,
-0.0763438419,
0.4238367081,
0.2623787522,
-0.1553128362,
-0.31285429,
-0.5468224287,
-0.8778256774,
-0.4952515662,
-0.5952658653,
-0.5033988357,
0.4461036623,
0.4873605669,
-0.1056964099,
0.9968398213,
-0.3301423788,
-0.0253517572,
-0.1229659393,
0.218079254,
-0.0022293269,
0.0063520572,
0.6754150391,
-0.7079405785,
-0.0044299243,
-0.5284993649,
-0.8369474411,
-0.1171553358,
-0.0673599094,
0.2635519803,
-0.076365076,
0.2945166528,
-0.5712038875,
0.3623931706,
0.4317142963,
-0.3153781891,
0.9368881583,
-0.0718462244,
0.1885377318,
-0.8421462774,
0.0983200297,
0.2475360036,
0.0950237289,
-0.4320458472,
0.0614821315,
-0.1582315266,
-0.1684171408,
-0.5590916872,
0.6953477263,
-0.0859619677,
-0.3111841381,
0.0921322778,
-0.0340569429,
-0.3631822765,
0.6504226923,
-0.1041753963,
1.1207556725,
0.288730979,
-0.7077971101,
0.2740353048,
0.1813371032,
-0.1284181923,
0.8379545212,
-0.7199885249,
0.2182997465,
-0.2124606371,
0.3605300486,
-1.218124032,
-0.7154231668,
0.2777815461,
-0.502055645,
-0.1560054719,
0.2017197609,
-0.6378150582,
-0.4745440483,
-0.4698587358,
0.3267664015,
0.7831579447,
-0.0484455377,
0.6755523086,
0.1300115734,
-0.333604455,
-0.0001728654,
-0.759385407,
-0.0314653888,
-0.6617432833,
-0.4512308836,
0.2412366569,
-0.4250817299,
-0.4317124486,
-0.2272345722,
0.0959708244,
-0.0725710392,
0.0468656495,
0.207968235,
0.3709215522,
-0.2402889282,
-0.1936757267,
-0.407920897,
0.04907858,
0.3381739855,
0.1657943428,
0.5143933296,
-0.1912739873,
-0.5702975392,
-0.5095233321,
0.2023525685,
0.7433137298,
0.0206835289,
0.5685650706,
0.4540150762,
-0.3227647841,
0.3988242745,
-0.4417929351,
-0.2975808382,
-0.466527015,
0.2603508532,
-0.5986364484,
-0.9253947735,
0.818585813,
0.0458104387,
-0.0214547887,
0.1035949364,
0.6730417013,
-0.4449587464,
1.1830462217,
0.4598935544,
-0.0950083807,
0.0824082717,
0.1634739339,
0.301827848,
-1.1407243013,
-0.2499212176,
-0.4639781415,
-0.5766654611,
-0.8289778233,
-0.1035224274,
0.5041881204,
-0.374406606,
-0.4937543571,
-0.1357302517,
-0.154690817,
0.2537590265,
0.4738146365,
0.3009864986,
0.0654078275,
0.0696108341,
-0.039825432,
-0.3328556418,
-0.2302594632,
-0.8965612054,
1.1442821026,
0.3585402071,
1.0871248245,
0.0617449656,
0.5808387399,
-0.0393510535,
0.5500454903,
-0.5508924127,
0.8682505488,
0.0732520893,
-0.6932590604,
-0.3789100349,
-0.523750782,
-0.811999023,
0.0399190411,
0.0910236984,
-1.2630178928,
0.1227450743,
0.1157135293,
-0.4139023423,
0.4373812079,
-0.5898708701,
0.4272941351,
-0.3044006228,
-0.1452423483,
0.2512049675,
-0.4720522463,
0.5400719047,
-0.2495812774,
0.0912880301,
-0.3133600354,
-0.1938399076,
0.8878645897,
-0.00712993,
1.3248810768,
-0.1600822508,
-0.2382301539,
0.0931509212,
0.2741499245,
0.0993136391,
0.0025835498,
-0.3033345044,
-0.1365432441,
0.3210346401,
-0.6152120829,
-0.7326879501,
0.7122805715,
-1.1790189743,
-0.6168831587,
-0.4012201428,
-0.412406534,
-0.5736912489,
-0.2303617299,
0.2768535316,
0.1695235819,
-0.5375407934,
-0.0807709321,
0.4155977368,
-0.134013474,
0.2164022624,
0.4186935127,
-0.2986874878,
-0.1617891937,
0.7224459648,
0.0688264742,
0.2939534187,
0.0232322086,
0.3582597375,
-0.195904851,
-0.1468654573,
-0.1022272483,
0.513107419,
-0.2772051394,
0.3504142165,
-0.2717096508,
-0.1426794827,
-0.4783802927,
-0.1430770606,
-0.0626985282,
-0.1215583012,
-0.1758925617,
-0.0140559152,
0.1156655401,
0.883720994,
0.170283705,
0.2871285975,
-0.282078445,
0.4782637358,
0.424803108,
0.4044600725,
0.0527272969,
-0.6166990399,
0.3406887352,
0.2940479815,
-0.2774618566,
-1.1260724068,
0.2169080824,
-0.0024977911,
0.5091407299,
0.5602391362,
-0.0572553948,
0.6169825196,
-0.2090865523,
1.0659422874,
-0.1405358911,
-0.434255451,
0.3797978759,
-0.6065724492,
0.0425418876,
0.5055245757,
0.6993784904,
-0.4785665274,
-0.5857825875,
-0.6377441883,
-0.5227913857,
0.5897939205,
0.3233534396,
0.3063791394,
0.0229595527,
0.7220998406,
0.0130437259,
0.2131244838,
-0.8649516702,
-0.1401149035,
0.0228478331,
-0.2157345712,
-0.32162714,
-0.3587129116,
-0.1772151291,
-0.1999542564,
0.3568679988,
-0.0027898964,
0.5801070929,
0.2112043649,
0.4334339201,
-0.0479175635,
0.2654320002,
0.536914289,
0.5620298386,
-0.5055547357,
0.0401566103,
0.0799463242,
-0.6102195978,
0.5188108087,
-0.1378377527,
-0.2074574828,
-0.4748949111,
0.1416139454,
0.3716928065,
0.1184089556,
-0.6315929294,
0.433179915,
-0.1978224814,
-0.3689626753,
-0.5251246095,
0.238633588,
0.1707074791,
0.1503252387,
0.2353850305,
-0.0659362152,
-0.2226301581,
-0.8440900445,
-0.0803096667,
0.3484933078,
-0.3045858443,
-0.685051024,
0.7084166408,
0.0031671294,
-0.7207028866,
0.7111371756,
-0.4249522984,
-0.1506280601,
0.6521888971,
0.5641427636,
0.7292812467,
-0.243150562,
0.1999496967,
0.1790072173,
0.292969197,
-0.0645940825,
0.5445708632,
0.3350785375,
-0.7579088807,
-0.3834899664,
-0.6949683428,
-0.702773571,
0.4971928298,
-0.7150779963,
-0.0035533861,
-0.4922013283,
-0.2823178768,
-0.318513453,
-0.0867619962,
-0.9320853949,
0.1285162568,
0.1386878043,
0.7008901834,
-1.1306687593,
0.5127977729,
1.013756752,
-0.5503435731,
-0.827110827,
0.2841872871,
0.0456005633,
-0.700902462,
0.455643028,
0.0729626119,
-0.0224412251,
-0.1695565432,
-0.65050596,
-0.5551493764,
1.0388607979,
0.4679581225,
0.0006345305,
-0.4805156887,
0.5293647051,
0.6739283204,
-0.389193356,
0.3703854978,
0.6797919869,
0.5469758511,
0.0024527698,
-0.9771720171,
0.0420117564,
-0.2013638616,
0.0437449664,
-0.3636978865,
-0.811581552,
0.938487649,
-0.2989404798,
0.0100213997,
0.3731967807,
0.6345332861,
0.7065128088,
0.2027042061,
0.3422042429,
0.2084742635,
0.8395372033,
0.0752206519,
1.2319146395,
-0.177927658,
0.1788868308,
0.9043549895,
-0.6841412783,
0.8686196804,
0.4629064798,
-0.5760086775,
0.4569550455,
0.8216394186,
0.0989767909,
0.243626222,
0.2721313238,
-0.2276404798,
-0.0783797055,
0.2385287136,
-0.0463768691,
0.6383041143,
0.453152895,
0.0312891155,
0.0036961895,
0.0524151735,
-0.033629071,
0.0156584643,
-0.0894775018,
0.4092634916,
0.1289310455,
-0.6292469501,
0.3317079544,
0.0816106647,
0.8341295123,
-0.6863104701,
0.2798252106,
-0.3628058732,
-0.0667057186,
-0.0790492445,
-0.921964407,
0.1401912272,
0.125837326,
0.0754045993,
-0.367603451,
0.5524410009,
0.0089095207,
-0.4576176703,
0.089123413,
0.816378057,
0.6854816079,
-0.1032762304,
-0.2978064418,
-0.2781918347,
-0.1970063895,
-0.5270681977,
0.6685854793,
0.2223627418,
-0.0364741534,
0.768766582,
0.4829490781,
0.4222615957,
-0.1088203043,
-0.0399762541,
0.6386501789,
-0.9062589407,
-0.5079017878,
-0.9097030163,
0.1478903294,
0.0991496295,
-0.451488018,
0.6908321381,
0.4619346261,
0.8027242422,
-0.1233639568,
0.8231235147,
0.2047799975,
0.4320213199,
-0.4704826772,
0.5898566842,
-0.2907253504,
0.1626931727,
-0.2584171295,
-1.0189044476,
0.099961482,
0.6092137694,
-0.4874633551,
0.4721429944,
0.6066901684,
0.8265194893,
-0.1629022509,
-0.0841895193,
0.4306311905,
0.3000781536,
0.2626418173,
0.6709510088,
0.9079213738,
0.0718406066,
0.331368953,
0.0031670271,
-0.3705355227,
-0.0298931375,
-0.6221915483,
-1.155381918,
-0.4007772207,
-0.0711126328,
-0.1882377714,
-0.1549996734,
0.6851611137,
0.5551083088,
-0.3754884005,
-0.455776155,
0.4257228076,
-0.3226652443,
-0.1198463216,
-0.2436212748,
0.053112179,
0.028872475,
-0.531060338,
0.0958844647,
0.1038283855,
0.2939061224,
-0.8866117001,
-0.0462242216,
0.2472969294,
0.3996460438,
0.4096939266,
0.3447912633,
-1.0503760576,
-0.4532880187,
0.2461753637,
-0.2815324664,
0.1389560997,
0.927761972,
-0.8441772461,
-0.1625417173,
0.1760335267,
0.229736492,
0.2540612519,
-0.0273682829,
0.5091462135,
-0.808082521,
0.1497636735,
0.3024001718,
0.3625613749,
0.3221876025,
-0.3823958933,
0.3817866445,
0.1977509111,
-0.425437212,
-0.5960300565,
0.4433198273,
-0.9280775189,
-0.0225771498,
1.3092035055,
-0.12753658,
-0.3132917285,
0.0537367649,
-0.2201496065,
-0.2052366585,
-0.3108054399,
0.8208289146,
0.8537393212,
-0.5201319456,
0.0079296473,
-0.7841979265,
0.2828270793,
0.2966691554,
-0.76461339,
0.0106068086,
0.2020026892,
0.4090417624,
0.0625075623,
1.1983374357,
-0.1942725033,
0.1775764078,
-0.0939884931,
-0.1752734184,
0.1173446625,
-0.0473083071,
-0.2033125758,
0.2028234005,
0.3029751182,
0.1956552863
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13003v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13003v1
|
A Survey on Recent Advances in Conversational Data Generation
| 2024-05-12T10:11:12 | 2024-05-12T10:11:12 |
Heydar Soudani, Roxana Petcu, Evangelos Kanoulas, Faegheh Hasibi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Recent advancements in conversational systems have significantly enhanced
human-machine interactions across various domains. However, training these
systems is challenging due to the scarcity of specialized dialogue data.
Traditionally, conversational datasets were created through crowdsourcing, but
this method has proven costly, limited in scale, and labor-intensive. As a
solution, the development of synthetic dialogue data has emerged, utilizing
techniques to augment existing datasets or convert textual resources into
conversational formats, providing a more efficient and scalable approach to
dataset creation. In this survey, we offer a systematic and comprehensive
review of multi-turn conversational data generation, focusing on three types of
dialogue systems: open domain, task-oriented, and information-seeking. We
categorize the existing research based on key components like seed data
creation, utterance generation, and quality filtering methods, and introduce a
general framework that outlines the main principles of conversation data
generation systems. Additionally, we examine the evaluation metrics and methods
for assessing synthetic conversational data, address current challenges in the
field, and explore potential directions for future research. Our goal is to
accelerate progress for researchers and practitioners by presenting an overview
of state-of-the-art methods and highlighting opportunities to further research
in this area.
|
[
-0.5722568631,
-0.9282309413,
0.4350304604,
0.0817797929,
0.0864849538,
0.3710172176,
-0.147787258,
-0.3461822867,
0.2201031595,
0.655862689,
-0.8521825075,
-0.3815858662,
-0.2560634613,
0.0164679494,
-0.354019165,
0.8655529022,
0.373706311,
0.2602545321,
-0.4495653808,
-0.0305184387,
-0.5411484838,
-0.9288272858,
-0.5600277185,
-0.0468711033,
0.1668327451,
0.6436526179,
0.6134322882,
0.0042188196,
0.2943117023,
0.3360501826,
0.1967639625,
0.7038275599,
-0.6596484184,
0.4590146542,
0.3380899429,
-0.2340313047,
-0.4198471308,
-0.0817725733,
0.3871636987,
0.8699139357,
-0.3261822462,
-0.032050129,
-0.1035191119,
0.7240806222,
-0.3862436414,
0.2297149897,
-0.8219746947,
0.1426025629,
-0.3330964744,
-0.3182347417,
-0.438365519,
-0.7505841851,
0.4426505268,
-0.6003835797,
0.6353591681,
0.2705052495,
0.2035428733,
-0.2398556322,
-0.3691936135,
-0.6388454437,
-1.0491533279,
0.9087513089,
-0.7262280583,
0.3087228537,
0.0532809719,
0.3855186999,
-0.4420050979,
-0.66169101,
-0.6453938484,
-0.1750371903,
0.1506097168,
0.2025076896,
-0.299736321,
-0.0446365289,
0.0473178923,
0.49668172,
-0.4514380991,
-0.2735207975,
-0.4217339158,
-0.1255493909,
0.6997773051,
0.4800371826,
0.2207721025,
-0.1096454188,
0.0209247489,
-0.2965666354,
-0.6701948047,
-0.184607029,
0.6554226279,
0.5702593327,
0.0540710688,
0.6817465425,
-0.6113301516,
0.7644222975,
0.1782626659,
-0.0486816838,
0.2956394553,
-0.9319109321,
0.2079338878,
-0.0528395437,
0.963226974,
0.5127297044,
0.1527182162,
-0.1020641476,
0.178340435,
-0.2202481478,
0.36042732,
-0.6969234347,
-0.1866544932,
0.2450891137,
-0.3011264205,
-0.4193758368,
0.1137046069,
-0.9527829289,
-0.3409003317,
-0.4808021784,
-0.4010855258,
-0.3940480351,
-0.4520198107,
0.057777483,
-0.0960025787,
0.2004191428,
0.2919166684,
-0.8473448157,
0.1610199958,
0.5239388943,
0.7259645462,
-0.3986106813,
0.1569235325,
-0.1508710533,
-0.1530131102,
-0.3583577871,
0.8245389462,
-0.5661064982,
-0.7401807308,
0.408284992,
-0.209151879,
-0.0476660468,
-0.7589270473,
0.4574039578,
-0.3676297665,
0.6388010979,
0.0242873747,
-0.1618565321,
0.0230224952,
0.2874469459,
-0.4186517894,
0.8658999801,
0.0444654785,
-0.6464824677,
0.368530333,
-0.5375733972,
-0.3906953633,
-0.1086406335,
-0.3365268409,
-0.5212566257,
-0.0884268284,
0.3071908653,
0.3426014781,
-0.6199314594,
0.5216646194,
-0.2055192292,
0.1146078631,
0.7276660204,
-0.5889388323,
0.2074796557,
0.3298081458,
-0.1871405691,
-0.0138583081,
-0.8780193329,
0.4231002033,
0.0501556322,
-0.1213142052,
0.2251457423,
0.2448313385,
0.0312660635,
0.2708303034,
-0.0538749322,
-0.7347655892,
0.1467799246,
-0.3376112282,
0.4799464345,
0.4175447822,
0.4111039042,
0.3097903728,
-0.3125258982,
0.3710859716,
0.2845073044,
0.1619423181,
-0.5385330915,
-0.6533356905,
-0.9478741884,
0.2034508139,
0.0793751478,
0.351590395,
-0.9203336835,
0.3480670452,
-0.2100062966,
-0.6066365838,
-0.561940074,
-0.0951085463,
0.3978024423,
0.2069281936,
0.3553331196,
-0.4348051846,
-0.6793535352,
-0.8858603239,
-0.0190106165,
-0.1694247425,
-0.1207577735,
0.7458291054,
-0.1704638451,
-0.1188777909,
1.2638158798,
-0.6865723133,
0.1547205299,
-0.4207029641,
0.3247745037,
-0.0471308678,
0.5395989418,
0.1637437046,
-0.6238694787,
-0.2389221191,
-0.0266877525,
-0.5249476433,
0.0826997012,
-0.101575233,
-0.0804144666,
-0.0096139638,
0.1818997711,
-0.6355368495,
0.2591827214,
0.4384972751,
0.1907533407,
0.412194103,
0.1456096172,
0.3844383359,
-0.9262513518,
-0.0193761736,
-0.1210190356,
0.0103374077,
-1.1510263681,
-0.7019302845,
-0.4337060153,
-0.5487872362,
-0.3019419909,
0.157008633,
-0.3609109521,
-0.0611699522,
-0.1461822093,
0.1880849898,
-0.2106768191,
0.5522637367,
0.2334132195,
0.6132178307,
0.2713669837,
-0.6936753392,
0.6447605491,
0.6259994507,
-0.392609477,
0.7225556374,
-0.5634319782,
0.6743642688,
-0.008033962,
0.5173837543,
-0.9387388229,
-0.5414562225,
0.4210264087,
-0.6107105017,
-0.0871408358,
-0.0665626377,
-0.2598650455,
-0.4244948328,
0.1085615903,
0.4335479736,
0.3955698013,
-0.3675756454,
-0.0122759053,
0.4778534472,
-0.6450696588,
-0.1803524941,
-0.2899427414,
0.1665550321,
-0.0182859786,
-0.7429887056,
0.0724996999,
-0.0536743253,
-0.2722079754,
-0.7120330334,
0.1673091501,
-0.0236461293,
-0.508107245,
0.1024598032,
0.1038472205,
0.0055462127,
-0.0627525374,
-0.1319442838,
-0.0804651678,
0.1207959056,
-0.2270852029,
0.7967685461,
0.0902702659,
-0.5963308811,
-0.3207163513,
0.4319771826,
0.3637266159,
0.0619147792,
0.1962821037,
0.3864805996,
0.1111701056,
-0.097486712,
-0.5325775743,
-0.287892133,
-0.4587116241,
0.2329174429,
-0.1327074021,
-0.7460364699,
-0.0405463874,
-0.2536205351,
0.3183657527,
0.1373840719,
0.6107355952,
-0.0200065263,
1.3648344278,
0.2692450881,
0.257338047,
0.4150626957,
-0.129880324,
0.5733258724,
-0.5165843964,
-0.5804592371,
-0.6349691153,
0.0076543572,
-0.6921796799,
-0.40458709,
0.4360623062,
-0.4385351837,
0.1718975008,
0.1834014207,
-0.6236783862,
-0.1096822247,
0.6600322723,
-0.0277362596,
0.4553285539,
-0.0464741401,
0.3503401577,
-0.0344557166,
-0.695679903,
-0.4551532567,
1.2311766148,
0.064250946,
0.5526010394,
-0.0848282948,
0.3482075036,
0.2928350568,
0.0070402408,
-0.6648822427,
0.575512886,
0.3166761398,
-0.6556164026,
-0.3635308444,
-0.5104987025,
-1.141325593,
0.020535985,
-0.1453258693,
-0.3581564128,
0.0833769217,
0.1696024388,
-0.0752523914,
0.0651853159,
-0.6813604832,
0.466750741,
-0.1962826848,
-0.0826507509,
-0.1400350928,
-0.6534534693,
0.5099508762,
-0.1053562984,
0.0692481548,
-0.1888984293,
0.6059168577,
0.6642715931,
-0.44257918,
0.7520779371,
-0.4522814453,
-0.2409821451,
0.8114945292,
-0.2145341635,
0.5153040886,
0.0739730373,
0.0771793798,
0.1892919093,
-0.0078706741,
-0.3265748322,
-0.4818277061,
0.4348886311,
-0.4792648852,
-0.2925037444,
-0.1286295205,
-0.3976395726,
-0.8835630417,
-0.112494126,
0.1684130132,
0.4996291697,
-0.7077189088,
0.3165018559,
0.4953600764,
-0.3668667376,
0.1615135372,
0.342492938,
-0.0279216077,
-0.5874704123,
1.1143641472,
-0.0632951334,
0.4173553586,
0.0735503957,
-0.2301934361,
-0.1814959496,
-0.5292203426,
-0.6184068322,
-0.2026108652,
0.0329619497,
-0.1553343832,
-0.5667216778,
-0.3249213994,
-0.6681860685,
0.1614744812,
-0.5348346829,
-0.5304788351,
-0.2217725366,
0.0419359691,
0.3712568879,
0.8905003667,
0.2352613956,
0.4823978543,
-0.7413621545,
0.3283800185,
0.3597353995,
0.1190799326,
-0.0821409896,
0.0063670613,
-0.2410302162,
0.5330221057,
-0.7437903285,
-0.5112355351,
0.4358536899,
0.0983637124,
0.3858959377,
0.3693053126,
0.0779685825,
0.5846431255,
-0.3707978427,
1.0601582527,
0.5516299009,
-0.4106719792,
0.6894924641,
-0.5139473677,
0.154541567,
0.4443406165,
0.1366463006,
-0.8511602879,
-0.2895792425,
-0.917401433,
-0.6392377615,
0.9117078185,
0.4976060092,
0.292188108,
0.0536858141,
-0.1174163222,
0.3900531828,
0.5437621474,
-0.0013334507,
-0.1604079157,
-0.3024387062,
-0.1471654922,
0.0829329714,
0.1877903938,
-0.1508891433,
0.1609191,
0.4798593223,
-0.3044352233,
0.5374086499,
-0.050971061,
0.3057322502,
0.1220068038,
0.5464711785,
0.3134602308,
0.346281141,
-0.0573064871,
-0.3838478327,
-0.0655886978,
-0.4569217563,
0.1983381659,
-0.0573167242,
-0.1778724194,
0.1414275765,
-0.1604264677,
0.9063299298,
0.1196778566,
-0.6896865368,
0.4485000968,
-0.1242291629,
-0.4132267535,
-0.3639191985,
0.2239730358,
-0.2334000617,
-0.0154630942,
0.3556312621,
0.1743949503,
0.0877105743,
-0.6764218807,
-0.019899305,
0.4498408437,
-0.302678138,
-0.4421448112,
0.0700183213,
0.6053701639,
-0.3734999299,
0.8064259887,
0.0355416052,
0.1401121467,
0.2254478186,
0.3865644634,
0.8448694944,
-0.040696051,
0.5196128488,
0.3923510909,
-0.3153174818,
0.132256493,
0.2252620906,
-0.4450993836,
-0.9180577397,
-0.0526475906,
-0.3131153882,
-0.9839823842,
0.3490486145,
-0.5337178111,
-0.0230654944,
-0.1606713682,
-0.4813516438,
0.0118278256,
-0.1991406828,
-0.747649014,
0.0696742609,
-0.013088109,
0.3396523893,
-0.3500163853,
0.2401764989,
0.2309986651,
-0.0668699741,
-0.0966535732,
-0.1854627281,
0.0936098993,
-0.6973826885,
0.1778736115,
-0.0977455974,
-0.1507281065,
-0.1000260711,
-0.7448608875,
-0.8129173517,
0.8054699898,
-0.1061104909,
-0.4623970985,
-0.2993990779,
0.6952800751,
0.5040314198,
-0.4897143841,
0.303117305,
0.9021498561,
0.4102678597,
0.3377858698,
-0.7149389386,
-0.4309530854,
-0.3523853421,
0.058625184,
0.1201164648,
-0.8816431761,
0.3820197582,
0.002026049,
-0.3580184281,
0.3941742778,
0.5335794091,
0.4570243061,
0.4783548415,
0.3699896634,
0.096027784,
0.5266714692,
-0.4359775186,
0.4954690039,
-0.2225946635,
-0.1331694275,
1.0098307133,
-0.4371289313,
0.4551892877,
0.3061549664,
-0.3472051322,
0.3780315518,
0.6386148334,
0.0344325975,
0.3099528551,
0.3963249922,
-0.356318742,
-0.0786987171,
-0.3490846157,
-0.2517347634,
0.544698596,
0.6244442463,
-0.191116333,
0.0683465078,
0.2088850737,
-0.1697083414,
-0.2281393856,
0.2699361742,
1.3043456078,
-0.198719427,
-0.9463288188,
0.4550515711,
-0.2318995744,
0.5292267203,
-0.5409172177,
-0.1594318002,
-0.2278073728,
-0.0897198617,
-0.1314091235,
-0.6323837638,
-0.0588168614,
0.2180611044,
-0.0722884014,
-0.4778453708,
0.578684926,
-0.3979225159,
-0.0889235511,
-0.3932113051,
0.8635895252,
0.3703900874,
0.0463987589,
-0.3677008152,
0.0183194187,
0.2915495038,
-0.1199481711,
0.0820156932,
0.3967263401,
0.0786886737,
0.5368178487,
0.8594792485,
0.1043830812,
0.1725188941,
0.2589338422,
0.8883895874,
-0.8107711077,
-0.1917225868,
0.0480273291,
0.4781347215,
-0.3607198,
-0.5760290623,
0.6757349968,
0.6793872714,
0.8236504793,
0.0043626153,
1.20289886,
-0.1420071721,
0.9272133112,
-0.5129112601,
0.2012553215,
0.1969091147,
-0.0553664528,
-0.319075793,
-0.9675557017,
0.241681397,
-0.0211896691,
-0.2448541969,
0.1276722252,
0.265389502,
0.8963453174,
0.0789848194,
0.6663250327,
0.1248493344,
-0.1738625914,
0.5496149659,
0.2975521088,
1.3455272913,
-0.3468090892,
0.7268872857,
-0.0080873929,
-0.0276575405,
-0.3094553053,
-0.2788524926,
-0.5550560355,
-0.8323549628,
-0.1082003415,
-0.1119289845,
0.0391391926,
0.6920711994,
0.9523440003,
-0.9126436114,
-0.1738374382,
-0.467443794,
-0.3433186412,
0.0933441445,
-0.2694252431,
-0.158443749,
-0.544749558,
-1.0501914024,
0.7902160287,
0.0235140081,
0.2473284006,
-0.3562999666,
-0.0584491603,
0.1470453739,
0.2316042185,
0.6285187602,
0.4997080863,
-0.4225023091,
-0.0081195477,
0.1702663153,
-0.0177388545,
0.3211508691,
1.4148840904,
-0.78384763,
0.6686012149,
0.3807917237,
0.4817856252,
0.7758338451,
0.2827529907,
0.939822495,
-0.9456944466,
-0.0786861032,
0.4016674161,
-0.1481699944,
0.6245864034,
-0.0704423636,
0.3168799579,
0.1608063132,
-0.5797046423,
-0.6801985502,
0.2756632864,
-0.7668210864,
0.1356789917,
0.9620348811,
0.2958804965,
0.3187048435,
-0.42841658,
-0.6091544032,
0.1972658634,
-0.7205429077,
0.7329254746,
0.616790235,
-0.6670287251,
0.2056346089,
-0.3799071014,
0.6965516806,
0.1913380474,
-1.1269799471,
0.4242558181,
0.9572917819,
-0.3724196553,
0.3425729573,
0.5692138672,
-0.3087088764,
-0.0541196279,
0.0324062295,
-0.007026474,
0.360099107,
-0.3119252324,
0.104971543,
0.1834237725,
-0.1682907492,
-0.1500965208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13002v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13002v1
|
DuetRAG: Collaborative Retrieval-Augmented Generation
| 2024-05-12T09:48:28 | 2024-05-12T09:48:28 |
Dian Jiao, Li Cai, Jingsheng Huang, Wenqiao Zhang, Siliang Tang, Yueting Zhuang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) methods augment the input of Large
Language Models (LLMs) with relevant retrieved passages, reducing factual
errors in knowledge-intensive tasks. However, contemporary RAG approaches
suffer from irrelevant knowledge retrieval issues in complex domain questions
(e.g., HotPot QA) due to the lack of corresponding domain knowledge, leading to
low-quality generations. To address this issue, we propose a novel
Collaborative Retrieval-Augmented Generation framework, DuetRAG. Our
bootstrapping philosophy is to simultaneously integrate the domain fintuning
and RAG models to improve the knowledge retrieval quality, thereby enhancing
generation quality. Finally, we demonstrate DuetRAG' s matches with expert
human researchers on HotPot QA.
|
[
-0.6505894065,
-0.4946702719,
0.2714018524,
0.1894723028,
-0.0649702996,
0.5458049774,
-0.101313889,
-0.329864949,
0.3535039425,
0.6054564714,
-0.3136204183,
-0.2298279852,
-0.4430776834,
-0.0452330336,
-0.3884137273,
1.080691576,
0.0391375236,
-0.0434675217,
-0.54859519,
-0.2337617278,
-0.5187166333,
-0.3862482905,
-0.6082238555,
-0.3757163882,
0.6066455841,
0.7091960907,
0.6405415535,
0.1084498093,
0.5209333897,
0.2680425942,
0.0753994212,
0.6119544506,
-0.6908982396,
0.6022894979,
-0.19333525,
-0.3759008944,
-0.4505010843,
0.0182255171,
0.3814504147,
0.9388477206,
-0.1812485904,
0.4132659733,
0.1900026947,
0.8010744452,
-0.8207861185,
-0.1345067173,
-0.8815838695,
-0.2128856182,
-0.2524849772,
-0.3766709268,
-0.4233956635,
-0.3094017804,
-0.0678553656,
-0.7182252407,
0.8000343442,
0.6105639935,
0.7800089121,
0.5163035393,
-0.299533844,
-0.0413856693,
-0.7724880576,
0.6782683134,
-0.3217373192,
0.3060349822,
0.4644937813,
0.3661495447,
-0.4214208126,
-0.9989643693,
-0.7886306047,
0.1558749974,
-0.2153922766,
0.0503513366,
-0.0698517188,
-0.1964636743,
-0.0098105296,
0.5139722228,
-0.6517212987,
-0.1824672371,
-0.5056943297,
-0.0561273433,
0.7566680908,
0.1704550833,
0.3609367609,
-0.1518589705,
-0.6477370262,
0.0487324744,
-0.9012526274,
-0.3098465204,
0.17572245,
0.3188529611,
0.0789632946,
0.3023189306,
-0.0979668349,
0.7907499075,
0.406645745,
0.0444320999,
0.2016938031,
-0.3164368868,
-0.0823583454,
-0.1153401583,
0.6570869088,
0.2509194314,
-0.3343560398,
-0.5062881112,
-0.1596087664,
-0.1885757744,
0.3306403756,
-0.6086871624,
-0.5214225054,
0.4193644226,
-0.0959998965,
-0.6176857948,
-0.0814833418,
-0.7803906798,
-0.5151627064,
0.001458303,
0.7425434589,
-0.1947551519,
-0.5134209991,
-0.1525576264,
-0.4149516225,
0.0373512357,
0.1189272478,
-0.8073254824,
0.5747563243,
0.9436576366,
0.628456533,
-0.3877263367,
-0.4688037038,
-0.8892861605,
0.4076929092,
-0.2129349709,
1.2659860849,
-0.3704303205,
-0.3639419079,
-0.2492620349,
-0.2414107174,
-0.1734054834,
-0.8236219287,
0.2829479575,
-1.0951036215,
0.6297980547,
-0.4168641865,
-0.6681608558,
-0.1293457896,
0.174368009,
-0.7308726311,
1.0193753242,
0.2606931329,
-0.9579158425,
0.4656423628,
-0.4811888933,
-0.218149811,
0.757979095,
-0.2141596526,
-0.541474402,
-0.3942786753,
0.0873371661,
0.409899652,
-0.6180735826,
0.447740823,
0.0078624925,
-0.349771589,
-0.0891906321,
0.1448692083,
0.7791383266,
0.2419790477,
-0.1731410027,
0.0515088327,
-0.597074151,
0.1361021549,
0.1931240559,
-0.2802966833,
-0.580614984,
-0.3279682398,
0.0896880552,
0.0437461361,
0.3838267624,
-0.4224439859,
0.1440245658,
-0.2695994079,
-0.122938551,
0.4422609806,
0.3909388483,
0.7283869386,
-0.7491371632,
0.7014331818,
0.0077874274,
-0.1699698418,
0.1626520604,
-0.5174837708,
-0.6705600619,
-0.1704713106,
0.5820596218,
0.2431482077,
-1.1492165327,
0.1778285354,
-0.0446101315,
-0.4469441473,
-0.7769011259,
0.4563446939,
0.5530263782,
0.5850202441,
0.4420715868,
-0.345377773,
-0.6374180913,
-0.5744835138,
-0.2399205118,
-0.0250761453,
-0.0088647939,
0.2431463748,
0.206249997,
0.0376048051,
1.1253676414,
-0.4959466159,
-0.239172399,
-0.4637108445,
0.3104834259,
0.0980614573,
0.5349771976,
0.6065369844,
-1.3101270199,
-0.7052857876,
-0.2170428932,
-0.6839506626,
-0.1832638234,
0.3857036829,
-0.4672222733,
0.0423355289,
0.1957622916,
-0.664560914,
-0.2267107815,
0.772225976,
-0.340955615,
0.7067693472,
-0.0519389436,
0.4517241716,
-1.6249219179,
0.1632667333,
-0.307267189,
-0.2825941145,
-0.6048526764,
0.5107780099,
-0.1713475138,
-0.064131476,
-0.2364349067,
0.5593935251,
-0.5431930423,
-0.3324270248,
-0.3204322457,
0.3658432662,
0.2494766861,
0.3184073865,
-0.3085222542,
1.1854759455,
0.1733541638,
-0.4786675274,
0.5743868351,
0.4008348286,
-0.0760064796,
0.8136105537,
-0.6150031686,
0.3022332788,
0.0026994147,
0.2479938865,
-0.8077827692,
-0.6004129648,
-0.0654051676,
-0.613741219,
0.4080558717,
-0.394585073,
-0.6034765244,
-0.2696327269,
-0.2283127308,
0.5386323929,
0.6242876649,
-0.7921142578,
0.2118195593,
0.7527844906,
-0.3992258608,
-0.6764168143,
0.0478608534,
0.02134417,
-0.2320954204,
-0.7185623646,
0.4900453389,
0.0301621426,
-0.4374597371,
0.1409721971,
0.1836781949,
-0.3494209051,
-0.0254859272,
0.1396584809,
0.2455400229,
-0.2726714909,
0.2475273311,
0.2788088322,
-0.2658953369,
-0.1460976601,
-0.3117032647,
0.7957391739,
0.118105799,
-0.0538667701,
0.0528555289,
0.4234027565,
0.3040001988,
-0.5359531641,
0.8261165023,
0.833807826,
-0.2211732715,
-0.4250561595,
-0.7774881721,
-0.2034859657,
-0.5301209092,
-0.1301092356,
-0.2869945765,
-1.1964119673,
0.2924783528,
-0.3587459326,
-0.0528729744,
0.467608422,
0.6315211058,
-0.4323894083,
0.5239323378,
0.7466112971,
0.0035194089,
-0.0441940688,
-0.3922709823,
-0.0579987951,
-1.0645138025,
-0.2587479353,
-0.6264134049,
-0.2548259795,
-0.4320170879,
-0.7224286795,
0.8057361245,
0.2469484359,
-0.227414757,
0.3801271915,
-0.5703344941,
0.4175383449,
0.7764786482,
0.1723468304,
0.5902407765,
0.0525664352,
-0.1820359379,
-0.0787018612,
-1.0624821186,
-0.2436300963,
1.0233457088,
-0.2637168169,
0.3557672501,
0.1511484236,
0.9804372191,
0.4564012885,
0.2210584879,
-0.3042772412,
0.5130411386,
-0.0077472618,
-0.851595819,
-0.2530145943,
-0.6368793845,
-1.2291933298,
0.3461823463,
-0.3197781444,
-0.4365362823,
0.0787966996,
0.2607029378,
-0.5166707635,
0.3929690719,
-0.4190655947,
0.6553189158,
0.2487476915,
-0.6741845012,
-0.3066045642,
-0.669882834,
0.5806736946,
-0.2102183104,
0.2625995278,
-0.0026580838,
0.0507812202,
0.8460956812,
-0.688438952,
0.4322743714,
-0.23502177,
-0.0725739002,
0.4705054462,
0.2841328681,
0.4283958673,
-0.3018901944,
-0.088989839,
-0.2697725296,
-0.0936982557,
-0.638658762,
-0.6166701913,
0.9349900484,
-0.6256892085,
-0.5785960555,
-0.039738439,
-0.7346143126,
-0.6001037359,
0.1851166636,
0.342647016,
0.3510636389,
-0.060169518,
0.0241319239,
0.5443403125,
-0.1917932928,
0.1127171665,
0.5207437277,
-0.1720898896,
-0.5383556485,
1.1356104612,
-0.0423910655,
0.304202348,
0.2333864272,
0.0534091294,
-0.0612622723,
-0.3679549992,
-0.6743040085,
0.3010882139,
-0.2637437582,
-0.4775648117,
-0.7520709634,
-0.0804294422,
-0.5073623657,
-0.233379513,
-0.3448191583,
-0.6504380107,
0.1440999955,
0.1363198161,
0.7118878961,
0.8143903017,
-0.2258592099,
0.1687149256,
-1.0307186842,
0.4933193624,
0.4703634679,
0.0731389448,
-0.0891210437,
-0.4658017755,
-0.252335757,
-0.1111370698,
-0.2953045964,
-0.7921323776,
0.4103142023,
-0.025318969,
0.4574155807,
-0.2611681819,
0.4013874531,
0.6700381041,
-0.4081652164,
0.8654873371,
0.0502182767,
-0.5527626276,
0.4696802795,
-0.6319698095,
-0.0531445183,
0.610414505,
0.5297167301,
-0.3719399571,
-0.4091057777,
-0.8671155572,
-0.802662015,
0.3643289208,
0.3914471269,
-0.111652337,
0.3070831299,
0.2783258557,
0.2693802118,
0.4533737898,
-0.0629483014,
-0.2545564175,
0.3493851125,
-0.1036194861,
0.1741395891,
-0.1234345287,
-0.2082651556,
-0.1982658654,
0.7229657769,
0.0370542295,
0.210703522,
-0.0797171742,
0.0332473852,
-0.6769897938,
0.2621567845,
0.1813172698,
0.4394740462,
-0.0218163189,
0.1469948441,
0.203436628,
-0.3484785259,
0.2605296671,
0.1654375941,
-0.4456036985,
0.1195110008,
0.179690212,
0.2969663739,
0.2803821564,
-0.3403944075,
0.6363956928,
0.0759497061,
-0.0235224832,
-0.2972511053,
0.2046596557,
0.1296359897,
0.4302518666,
0.6674541235,
0.3094579875,
0.2666318119,
-0.2552210391,
0.6881408691,
0.4548327029,
-0.0496171564,
-0.2227970213,
0.9211855531,
0.3841092288,
-0.4143110812,
0.3347425461,
-0.402336657,
-0.6689189672,
0.4420450032,
0.4641088545,
0.7236554027,
-0.285426259,
0.3566660285,
0.3441474438,
-0.0911515579,
-0.1178601533,
0.1720700264,
-0.3813479245,
-0.8130970597,
-0.5221732259,
-0.7774407864,
-0.6586549282,
-0.1823645532,
-0.8973493576,
0.1568444967,
-0.0414611585,
0.0080384361,
-0.2251424193,
0.3041999042,
-0.550136447,
0.0823491737,
-0.3505004644,
0.631629169,
-0.4669451118,
0.7280730009,
0.6379407644,
-0.5643348098,
-0.9463376403,
0.1536059678,
-0.1533800066,
-0.6952894926,
0.7379267812,
-0.352891475,
-0.2682302892,
0.3973578811,
-0.8473766446,
-0.7725968957,
1.2453974485,
0.1336830258,
-0.276820749,
-0.1520284265,
-0.0882975385,
0.5464558005,
-0.2054989338,
-0.2330164164,
0.38771981,
0.2257654071,
0.3898743987,
-1.2282332182,
0.0076409564,
-0.3558990061,
-0.3216798604,
0.3907060623,
-0.8687355518,
0.790730834,
-0.4154930115,
-0.0777802616,
0.2442828566,
0.6214063168,
0.6133813858,
0.713488996,
0.3992777765,
0.592936635,
0.7601997256,
0.0865796283,
0.9604443908,
-0.3329253197,
0.4793659449,
1.2960695028,
-0.3181757331,
1.1305571795,
0.4330883622,
-0.2194565684,
0.6819980145,
0.1544023305,
0.1915475428,
0.4324874282,
-0.1514968872,
-0.6256073713,
-0.4330531955,
-0.2005521506,
-0.5108504891,
0.3264066577,
0.3131195307,
-0.2115276903,
-0.1977128088,
-0.0598467179,
0.1454620808,
0.2998868525,
-0.0515908785,
0.9025277495,
-0.0000161865,
-0.8400017619,
0.7520025969,
-0.1686484069,
0.6749128103,
-0.0274430588,
-0.1685950905,
-0.4365021288,
-0.0552922674,
-0.2705838978,
-0.5293952227,
0.1248328239,
0.0569600128,
-0.1401726007,
-0.1499649584,
0.9761477113,
-0.6246517301,
-0.2794237137,
0.0798183754,
0.9667274952,
0.1885961741,
-0.0057495707,
-0.5580030084,
0.0225795582,
-0.3732111454,
0.058829654,
0.3825479448,
0.3583901525,
0.3269122839,
0.5629090667,
0.6680565476,
0.1493486464,
-0.0066400366,
-0.0207499936,
1.1254622936,
-0.4678385258,
-0.1691724807,
-0.1878358722,
0.3753896058,
-0.3212726116,
-0.0437250584,
0.8692014813,
0.6136029959,
0.846955359,
0.0641109571,
0.742205739,
-0.2084290832,
1.0909081697,
-0.2151791453,
1.0982424021,
-0.565118134,
0.3352274597,
-0.4899672568,
-0.8960270286,
-0.3349538445,
0.330965668,
-0.1495384425,
0.0214403309,
0.4352580905,
0.8686608672,
-0.1467491686,
-0.1243322045,
0.5126284361,
0.2250934988,
0.0210518204,
0.3938461244,
0.8880866766,
-0.734611392,
0.4776264131,
-0.3468927741,
-0.1715242267,
-0.1631115079,
-0.3066177368,
-0.6997205019,
-0.9721851349,
-0.2408801466,
-0.4298474193,
0.4014195502,
1.1159125566,
0.6861844659,
-0.6070272923,
-0.1644164324,
0.0213403869,
0.173058331,
-0.0869619101,
-0.2946431041,
0.1666474044,
-0.684346199,
-0.6204121113,
0.5560286641,
0.0505981632,
-0.1968714744,
-0.5195502639,
-0.1354413182,
-0.0781094655,
-0.2473654747,
0.5725380778,
0.2239755392,
-0.2873982191,
0.0097298827,
-0.0708990321,
-0.1394058019,
-0.1319859624,
0.9806851745,
-1.1547746658,
0.2519361675,
0.5532482266,
0.6411363482,
0.538058579,
0.3144516349,
0.8504983187,
-0.9254851937,
0.1706181914,
0.3253438771,
0.163913697,
0.5298783779,
-0.3169710636,
0.5784327388,
0.5485808253,
-0.9213123918,
-0.858891964,
0.1715306193,
-0.7545646429,
-0.0500058681,
1.2287993431,
-0.1898847073,
-0.113153331,
-0.4191511571,
-0.2295087874,
0.180199042,
-0.1865273714,
0.9590184689,
0.1808042228,
-0.0498541407,
-0.2220745832,
-0.2891365588,
0.7746251225,
0.4591673315,
-0.7989370227,
-0.1474080235,
0.6391230822,
0.3189300895,
0.2663183808,
0.6999133229,
0.0189913735,
0.508194685,
0.2418082058,
0.0452425145,
0.0053393831,
-0.4068093598,
0.2163244784,
0.7080445886,
0.2650245428,
-0.1120105311
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07195v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07195v1
|
InsightNet: Structured Insight Mining from Customer Feedback
| 2024-05-12T07:40:12 | 2024-05-12T07:40:12 |
Sandeep Sricharan Mukku, Manan Soni, Jitenkumar Rana, Chetan Aggarwal, Promod Yenigalla, Rashmi Patange, Shyam Mohan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We propose InsightNet, a novel approach for the automated extraction of
structured insights from customer reviews. Our end-to-end machine learning
framework is designed to overcome the limitations of current solutions,
including the absence of structure for identified topics, non-standard aspect
names, and lack of abundant training data. The proposed solution builds a
semi-supervised multi-level taxonomy from raw reviews, a semantic similarity
heuristic approach to generate labelled data and employs a multi-task insight
extraction architecture by fine-tuning an LLM. InsightNet identifies granular
actionable topics with customer sentiments and verbatim for each topic.
Evaluations on real-world customer review data show that InsightNet performs
better than existing solutions in terms of structure, hierarchy and
completeness. We empirically demonstrate that InsightNet outperforms the
current state-of-the-art methods in multi-label topic classification, achieving
an F1 score of 0.85, which is an improvement of 11% F1-score over the previous
best results. Additionally, InsightNet generalises well for unseen aspects and
suggests new topics to be added to the taxonomy.
|
[
-0.3911421895,
-0.4706509113,
0.4119307995,
0.2343514711,
-0.1716948003,
0.0716313496,
-0.0599329658,
-0.5060005784,
0.6878440976,
0.6682082415,
-0.8258622289,
-0.8717224002,
-0.2985665798,
0.0704697743,
-0.4395710528,
1.2194405794,
0.1616003364,
0.0411452278,
-0.2936499119,
-0.0290354826,
0.0968953669,
-0.4832299054,
-0.6763806939,
-0.3788011968,
0.7431052327,
0.6383107305,
0.0475081652,
0.2889226377,
0.5000293255,
0.2844802737,
-0.3487956822,
0.4925445914,
-0.3262854815,
0.3585041165,
-0.0091766743,
-0.4851218462,
-0.6320868134,
0.1359043866,
0.2108700573,
0.872993052,
-0.1654415131,
0.337920934,
0.2080913186,
0.8351920247,
-0.3998271525,
0.277854234,
-0.4957428277,
0.4719471037,
0.353305161,
-0.3824647367,
-0.3657076061,
-0.1960917562,
0.3336613178,
-0.6985638738,
0.2845530808,
0.0629966855,
0.7627408504,
0.4578583241,
-0.187962532,
-0.2837454975,
-0.6611300707,
0.6543130279,
-0.6703497171,
-0.0545501113,
-0.0354550853,
0.2533376217,
0.1771843731,
-0.8191297054,
-0.1977808774,
0.0520693883,
-0.2701918185,
0.6237215996,
-0.1082451418,
-0.1297699511,
0.1410903335,
0.4204182923,
-0.3064896464,
0.0580410846,
-0.3251315653,
-0.0239025932,
0.7736358643,
0.456756711,
-0.336009562,
-0.5270709395,
-0.4181922078,
0.0885961652,
-0.2521285713,
0.4107648134,
0.370713681,
0.3487592041,
0.3202603757,
0.4064488113,
-0.6710233688,
0.4140308201,
0.0708711743,
0.0863911062,
0.5577303171,
-0.101832442,
-0.3042880595,
0.4440085888,
0.9857770801,
0.5623663068,
-0.1229765266,
-0.2077314109,
-0.2507472336,
-0.2343598753,
0.5341371298,
-0.907017231,
-0.3025219142,
0.4076538682,
-0.8905964494,
-0.6691755056,
0.4271717966,
-0.6555541754,
-0.6243142486,
-0.4305361807,
-0.1582867056,
-0.0646429285,
-0.4814513922,
-0.094361566,
-0.4714750051,
0.1906293184,
0.3735283613,
-0.3610833883,
0.2654560804,
1.0592397451,
0.7081964612,
-0.341514796,
-0.0486802012,
-0.1821056902,
-0.0921498165,
-0.2194945961,
1.1240811348,
-0.578600347,
-0.1343087703,
-0.0184466317,
0.2332407385,
0.3668931723,
-0.8701388836,
0.5518702865,
-0.5590112209,
0.1865513325,
0.1678326279,
-0.7344452739,
-0.4244229794,
1.0157064199,
-0.6412069201,
0.7700991631,
0.1038677916,
-0.7090613246,
0.4841893017,
-0.7587504983,
-0.3159466088,
0.2365079373,
-0.0298815519,
-0.6359742284,
0.2784546018,
0.147645399,
0.4779951572,
-0.1104826555,
0.1528470963,
-0.4912975132,
0.0664736852,
0.4258235991,
-0.1386409849,
0.5009140968,
0.4556730092,
-0.2661521137,
0.5730528831,
-0.7682142258,
0.2613897324,
-0.1365195513,
-0.3345389366,
-0.3590466082,
-0.1103052571,
0.1919706315,
0.3099113703,
0.1322165132,
-0.6655129194,
0.0250312388,
-0.5980539918,
0.5847074986,
0.7619667649,
0.4705116153,
0.3946208656,
-0.0115417726,
0.5765122175,
0.5773046613,
0.3493905663,
-0.3085585237,
-0.4164052308,
-0.9769236445,
0.0380519927,
0.3061705232,
0.4106658101,
-0.4161511362,
0.5787936449,
-0.2603725791,
-0.5480412245,
-0.5978950858,
0.3383796215,
0.3183858097,
0.7255546451,
0.2526153922,
-0.4097433686,
-0.5255216956,
-1.3167821169,
-0.4088715911,
-0.0876907483,
-0.0874023587,
0.503769815,
0.1563471556,
-0.3698536754,
1.0704389811,
-0.8389100432,
-0.6035712361,
-0.2871479094,
0.3155844212,
0.5888578892,
0.1888827085,
-0.0121405767,
-1.0314315557,
-0.4807313681,
0.1814351231,
-0.839266777,
0.1641272455,
0.0241605025,
0.0259471312,
0.031149067,
0.3727631271,
-0.154697448,
0.4059390128,
0.0227383766,
-0.10178525,
0.2653384507,
0.1244309023,
-0.0673890263,
-1.3978170156,
-0.1419668645,
0.2782708406,
-0.2788300514,
-0.4619550407,
-0.5047110319,
-0.0909836516,
-0.3493354321,
-0.4309098423,
0.0457527526,
-0.0365632027,
-0.1089204773,
-0.3856209517,
-0.1222857609,
0.3525123596,
0.7307899594,
0.1833990365,
0.187191695,
0.233712703,
-0.5597009659,
0.8326308727,
0.3568356931,
-0.3687650263,
0.5806953311,
-0.7438972592,
0.2960841358,
-0.0627374873,
0.2156477123,
-0.7711207271,
-0.212237373,
0.3563787937,
-0.7191188335,
0.0834450051,
-0.210169524,
-0.1260071844,
-0.0492631383,
-0.3036702275,
-0.1020398512,
0.2857364118,
-0.4683459401,
0.6578708291,
0.4696095586,
-0.2289552242,
-0.4526340663,
-0.5457915664,
0.3625257313,
-0.2653536201,
-0.5280110836,
0.2523763478,
0.2061688304,
-0.2280167341,
0.4624222517,
-0.1075066775,
-0.1961234361,
0.1589004695,
0.4356633425,
-0.1632767022,
-0.2120305598,
0.1517808288,
-0.2375790179,
-0.306152463,
0.4449389279,
-0.8023280501,
0.2822562456,
-0.3880890608,
0.1123070121,
-0.4413375854,
0.6390963793,
0.3905911148,
-0.118806228,
0.3822467029,
0.5064133406,
-0.2169041336,
-0.6035118699,
-0.2731350362,
-0.2147200406,
-0.4141672552,
0.5922650099,
-0.2855629921,
-0.6921194792,
0.4077790976,
-0.4055911601,
0.1120383516,
0.5285561085,
0.4779168367,
-0.6328535676,
1.1420450211,
0.9017636776,
-0.0583772287,
0.5173270106,
-0.5164968967,
0.4899042547,
-0.8280274868,
-0.843890667,
-0.5907610655,
-0.6229768395,
-0.4679859579,
0.247023508,
0.4554081857,
-0.134769842,
0.3255956471,
0.0457965359,
-0.582957983,
0.0768280625,
0.5159029365,
0.3097987771,
0.1575759202,
0.0526083112,
0.1493796706,
0.2062828243,
-0.4802686274,
-0.4332624674,
0.8579287529,
0.3921065629,
0.56469208,
-0.1369747221,
0.5522950888,
0.5652452707,
0.4471072853,
-1.2070789337,
0.426741451,
-0.0764959008,
-0.4239987433,
-0.1205924749,
-0.6892257929,
-0.702375114,
-0.021444425,
-0.0779892579,
-0.1389420778,
0.1636686772,
0.0821551308,
-0.2582912743,
0.0698458627,
-0.6919558048,
0.727627635,
-0.2501812577,
-0.3345976174,
-0.0137974974,
-0.5727958083,
0.281745851,
0.0963728204,
0.089569144,
0.0229431447,
0.0580774732,
0.9896113276,
-0.6119821668,
0.8093566895,
-0.4391377866,
-0.0332036763,
0.2085049152,
-0.3574192226,
0.0385804847,
0.308181107,
0.0559924245,
0.0586996488,
-0.2055604309,
-0.3440977931,
-1.0267090797,
0.57736063,
-0.7835992575,
-0.2764744163,
-0.2582112253,
-0.3024516106,
-0.4912382662,
0.1526201367,
0.1038901433,
0.5690663457,
-0.0477004237,
0.2967462838,
0.6722409725,
-0.0616097003,
0.4199621975,
0.3696196675,
-0.104301177,
-0.7146681547,
0.9568215609,
-0.2852790952,
-0.1934060007,
0.5127993226,
0.3098420501,
-0.3088870943,
-0.4446353018,
-0.2535617352,
-0.2038151175,
-0.781974256,
-0.3762591779,
-0.9108827114,
-0.2714232802,
-0.6834168434,
0.4909925163,
-0.4415078163,
-0.4018683434,
-0.2481715679,
-0.2236637175,
0.1251238436,
0.9760372639,
0.2213451266,
0.287961334,
-0.999783814,
0.1537902057,
0.1421886235,
0.3784971535,
-0.0501703732,
-0.1500380933,
-0.4539223909,
-0.1802397221,
-0.3018799424,
-0.6227445602,
0.475420773,
0.1892505139,
0.4235924184,
0.7524026632,
0.1644864529,
0.4986093044,
-0.1115043014,
0.6866143346,
0.2661999762,
-0.5669865608,
0.7229636908,
0.0186173134,
0.1866776347,
0.7924217582,
0.4886565208,
-0.6103409529,
-0.1506429762,
-0.6832458973,
-0.9706426263,
0.7355066538,
-0.2811275423,
0.0107624466,
0.3169695437,
0.6358078122,
0.2276203483,
0.5267439485,
-0.4934615493,
-0.135912627,
-0.4529427886,
-0.4673249125,
-0.0495155044,
-0.2217443585,
-0.0321613476,
-0.1992577314,
0.6261444688,
-0.3945392072,
0.0358897485,
0.4265375435,
-0.0988567397,
0.1002219766,
0.3469097316,
0.2797632515,
0.6191192865,
-0.2970330715,
0.1584556401,
-0.1421617121,
-0.3895164728,
-0.1579415202,
-0.0736150444,
-0.3046747744,
0.0806288645,
0.4658978283,
0.7390334606,
-0.1022362486,
-0.3975167274,
0.4905817807,
-0.4579281807,
-0.600984633,
-0.7702407837,
-0.0277611017,
-0.1567148715,
0.1988574862,
0.3272307515,
0.4454749823,
0.6150252819,
-0.6443694234,
0.2455267757,
0.268012166,
-1.2870528698,
-0.3524685204,
-0.0128336754,
0.3939179182,
-0.3781336546,
0.6751488447,
-0.1230008304,
-0.9376016259,
0.5702571273,
0.0788256004,
1.2602225542,
0.2256844342,
0.3101096749,
0.1152703092,
0.0533741638,
0.5853465199,
0.1109917536,
-0.4278399646,
-0.6192720532,
-0.3814578354,
-0.7615551949,
-0.6684102416,
0.122319065,
-0.965430975,
0.1453670561,
-0.517978251,
0.1292870045,
0.0972795561,
0.1962209344,
-0.3913682103,
0.3560344279,
0.1571019739,
0.9683617949,
-0.732768774,
0.5155761838,
0.9584569931,
-0.2052139044,
-0.8986235857,
-0.1975498497,
-0.0790175125,
-0.2838869691,
0.5578535199,
0.5945566297,
-0.3476707041,
-0.3975493312,
-0.6046599746,
-0.0017552922,
0.7882477641,
-0.3388980329,
-0.4259849191,
0.1875974089,
0.1900373548,
0.6078081131,
-0.6905760765,
0.3995978236,
0.5905011296,
0.3727820218,
0.2806685865,
-0.1709539443,
-0.2137084305,
-0.7828919888,
-0.3708401918,
0.0131290304,
-0.600622654,
0.5049815774,
0.2785572708,
0.1908073872,
-0.4656023681,
0.9164384604,
-0.2072720677,
0.7111110091,
0.8729562759,
0.7509910464,
0.8113372326,
0.0174007099,
0.7855575085,
-0.1597873569,
0.2063445002,
0.8684667349,
-0.3339586556,
0.6750392318,
0.4219311774,
0.2802125216,
0.5429015756,
0.9711025953,
-0.1531923413,
0.7107537389,
0.162749365,
0.0823529363,
-0.3282363713,
-0.3788127005,
-0.1205368415,
0.5135911107,
0.392129153,
-0.3122802675,
0.0220680479,
-0.1106793508,
-0.2209476829,
-0.084798038,
-0.514352262,
1.5474460125,
0.271825701,
-0.7584699988,
0.1272999793,
-0.1219440252,
0.692287147,
-0.5056445599,
-0.0709891692,
-0.358276248,
0.6507568359,
-0.7563688159,
-0.7167720199,
0.5430092812,
0.1155356839,
-0.4978669882,
-0.6314412951,
0.6503074169,
-0.1596823484,
-0.606551826,
0.3102709949,
0.333557725,
0.1785934865,
-0.3420312405,
-0.7559551597,
-0.2783506215,
0.1215405539,
-0.4088037014,
0.0156962015,
0.5736479759,
0.2156805843,
0.3859110773,
0.5383030176,
0.1345562488,
-0.1458508819,
0.3230992556,
1.0416859388,
-0.8949587941,
-0.8981955647,
-0.6807295084,
0.4120533466,
-0.8134531379,
-0.5894668698,
0.655513823,
0.8983883262,
0.6971193552,
0.197852388,
0.9074757695,
0.3375103176,
0.8059764504,
-0.5327216387,
0.6233818531,
-0.8868413568,
0.4345232844,
-0.0886657685,
-1.1105926037,
-0.2181455344,
0.1155669242,
-0.1755019575,
-0.2594711483,
0.8838781714,
0.5727905035,
-0.0918532908,
0.5483697057,
-0.049976211,
0.2976820171,
0.6741235852,
0.46376881,
1.2630107403,
-0.0141185969,
0.7886061668,
-0.411542207,
-0.2890789807,
-0.2592428327,
-0.6016974449,
-0.8846299052,
-0.4648167193,
-0.5013695359,
-0.3638603091,
-0.4079636335,
0.73313272,
1.0340698957,
-0.9524216652,
-0.0851183608,
-0.1535493582,
0.1692858189,
-0.2375366986,
-0.331853658,
0.1655537188,
-0.7070645094,
-0.4982229471,
0.3776991367,
0.5415186882,
-0.5485319495,
-0.491984725,
0.1196923852,
0.2729542255,
-0.4059439301,
0.3971731365,
-0.1801553369,
-0.4247051775,
0.1076128855,
0.285384357,
0.0056862244,
0.2554463148,
1.0944994688,
-0.755238831,
0.0151801575,
0.4891142845,
0.842782855,
0.8767237663,
0.0916634277,
0.4325352609,
-0.8716384172,
0.0411034748,
0.6322386265,
0.2306521833,
0.3659787476,
-0.4656160772,
0.1925957501,
0.1508521289,
-0.2533148527,
-0.5677161813,
0.4452977479,
-1.0350681543,
-0.4835433364,
0.8765441179,
-0.3631763756,
-0.7754994035,
-0.2432454973,
0.0487129353,
-0.212909162,
-0.4465191066,
0.6471970081,
0.3181557357,
-0.4430984855,
-0.2496183068,
-0.134799704,
0.3533807397,
0.4675941467,
-1.0803068876,
-0.1275220513,
0.2825556993,
0.1438728571,
0.5220439434,
0.1765623838,
0.0760470107,
-0.1341711432,
-0.2567888796,
-0.117594339,
-0.3920821548,
-0.5841847658,
-0.5143515468,
0.7878375649,
-0.0896046534,
-0.1776423901
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13001v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13001v1
|
Large Language Models for Education: A Survey
| 2024-05-12T01:50:01 | 2024-05-12T01:50:01 |
Hanyi Xu, Wensheng Gan, Zhenlian Qi, Jiayang Wu, Philip S. Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
Artificial intelligence (AI) has a profound impact on traditional education.
In recent years, large language models (LLMs) have been increasingly used in
various applications such as natural language processing, computer vision,
speech recognition, and autonomous driving. LLMs have also been applied in many
fields, including recommendation, finance, government, education, legal
affairs, and finance. As powerful auxiliary tools, LLMs incorporate various
technologies such as deep learning, pre-training, fine-tuning, and
reinforcement learning. The use of LLMs for smart education (LLMEdu) has been a
significant strategic direction for countries worldwide. While LLMs have shown
great promise in improving teaching quality, changing education models, and
modifying teacher roles, the technologies are still facing several challenges.
In this paper, we conduct a systematic review of LLMEdu, focusing on current
technologies, challenges, and future developments. We first summarize the
current state of LLMEdu and then introduce the characteristics of LLMs and
education, as well as the benefits of integrating LLMs into education. We also
review the process of integrating LLMs into the education industry, as well as
the introduction of related technologies. Finally, we discuss the challenges
and problems faced by LLMEdu, as well as prospects for future optimization of
LLMEdu.
|
[
-0.299102962,
-0.9504802227,
0.6166929603,
-0.160731554,
-0.0345694534,
0.5372975469,
-0.5495086908,
-0.5242785811,
0.0250669159,
0.5146908164,
-0.4024758935,
-0.2458387166,
-0.7240712643,
0.2275123149,
-0.481885463,
0.5733851194,
-0.0449217893,
0.3851250708,
-0.2462731153,
0.0812301412,
-0.5167051554,
-0.6857677102,
-0.63455832,
-0.7056517005,
0.4891720116,
0.5806247592,
0.6351912022,
0.4240446389,
0.7208631039,
0.4693879485,
-0.0415696427,
0.1214449406,
-0.1306585819,
-0.1190353334,
-0.2460757345,
-0.4646287858,
-0.5415822864,
0.1277261376,
0.9051181674,
1.0065814257,
-0.0396072417,
0.1300691664,
0.0931442827,
0.60727036,
-0.2973858714,
0.1777161509,
-0.289265275,
0.1406544745,
-0.1435477883,
0.0694862455,
-0.2006178498,
-0.516572237,
0.3314163387,
-0.2327355146,
-0.380743444,
-0.0663146377,
0.48555246,
0.440931648,
-0.5750377774,
-0.4394896328,
-1.0252773762,
1.1740216017,
-0.7047341466,
0.5760500431,
0.2338627875,
0.309284091,
-0.4446361661,
-0.7054397464,
-0.6195982099,
-0.1679140776,
0.2609830201,
0.076146625,
0.2057104409,
0.2317025661,
0.0519013517,
0.2120985985,
-0.3127743304,
0.7928705812,
-0.5277055502,
-0.0390912443,
0.7688037753,
0.3854316175,
0.2797916234,
0.2108882964,
-0.1776748449,
-0.0080394037,
-0.6552339792,
-0.0409896038,
0.4439465702,
0.2478580326,
0.1202360094,
0.6585617661,
-0.0166497398,
0.82506603,
-0.4980441034,
-0.6851834655,
0.1694625318,
-0.1869894713,
-0.1296245158,
0.0107547315,
0.762301743,
0.0599353537,
0.4775680006,
0.1559068114,
-0.319091171,
0.1085894704,
-0.0017056834,
-0.7358551621,
0.1544301361,
0.355193764,
-0.2027045488,
-0.0474941507,
-0.1817509085,
-0.4611525536,
-0.428816855,
-0.6573735476,
0.1167090833,
-0.2978204191,
-0.1877747774,
0.2473593354,
0.2915906608,
0.4044040143,
0.5476487279,
-0.965509057,
0.2141435444,
0.9649644494,
0.5350853205,
-0.1947137266,
-0.2724848986,
0.0518661588,
-0.0978260934,
-0.3007382452,
0.7766907215,
-0.7217625976,
-0.5940564871,
0.2554002106,
-0.1810560226,
-0.0838225782,
-0.6631320119,
0.3561883867,
-0.2540583611,
0.354031831,
0.0235865749,
-0.722248137,
-0.3127720058,
0.5253056884,
-0.5657696128,
0.6918807626,
-0.028653251,
-0.3260006905,
0.0150608458,
-0.7611355782,
-0.6172305346,
0.3001328111,
-0.4688819945,
-0.5566503406,
-0.0239162985,
0.0598534457,
0.4954148829,
-0.5123149753,
0.7986446023,
-0.0526182018,
-0.6498642564,
0.2688797712,
-0.5010433793,
0.775862515,
0.184412241,
-0.2101705372,
0.3048065901,
-0.6184257269,
-0.0464639366,
0.1826804429,
-0.5408841968,
-0.1099141911,
0.3290263116,
0.0245257728,
0.2248560786,
0.4706295431,
-0.4022019804,
0.4855285883,
-0.2442455739,
0.754547894,
0.9246656299,
-0.2708417177,
0.4064389467,
-0.3123115599,
0.4941520989,
-0.2312955409,
0.3915865719,
-0.0738721937,
-0.5255305171,
-0.6111309528,
-0.2497837245,
0.4394818544,
0.6874496341,
-0.7082079053,
0.4282510281,
-0.1690368056,
-0.4290390909,
-0.6363772154,
0.2368005216,
0.0228431858,
0.2048060894,
0.1164846867,
-0.0117669804,
-0.3665919602,
-0.7078606486,
-0.1771646738,
-0.1574200839,
0.1903626323,
0.3609338701,
0.657620728,
-0.632958591,
0.8549682498,
-0.1349642575,
-0.2905028164,
-0.4668975472,
-0.4086003006,
0.2203223258,
0.4134679735,
0.2485557944,
-0.8974155784,
-0.2399354726,
-0.0498964079,
-0.7331445813,
0.2404343784,
-0.0740379468,
0.3355804384,
0.2366534621,
0.5059777498,
-0.7250478864,
0.0611227266,
0.4673969746,
-0.0482456945,
0.4813076556,
-0.040605396,
0.0755633563,
-0.8889661431,
-0.0658931062,
0.0249655563,
0.0251053777,
-0.4946907163,
0.0454650037,
-0.0621551201,
-0.2891665995,
-0.5480122566,
0.7928641438,
-0.284144491,
-0.1064118743,
-0.3910323381,
0.546525836,
-0.3521161377,
0.1043454707,
-0.0743064433,
0.7513729334,
0.4938673675,
-0.3901021481,
0.7866571546,
0.155907765,
-0.5513166189,
0.4549265504,
-0.6345058084,
0.0659131259,
-0.0005434853,
0.490031898,
-0.4416552782,
-0.4009979665,
0.1575007439,
-0.1450044662,
0.4127508402,
0.3596786559,
-0.7433670759,
-0.6511998773,
-0.3693330884,
0.3140705228,
0.6162306666,
-0.507577002,
0.7341690063,
0.4721049666,
-0.2858333886,
-0.5818459392,
-0.6096496582,
0.4467372,
-0.0149089769,
-0.3458649516,
-0.0135051757,
-0.2175952345,
-0.5438098311,
0.0233603362,
0.0696439072,
0.0833535567,
0.3840523064,
0.0014858624,
0.5111953616,
-0.1715947241,
0.167563796,
0.0020823074,
-0.0797956437,
0.1936509311,
-0.3491700888,
0.4654753208,
-0.1096394658,
-0.377137959,
-0.5257814527,
0.248532027,
0.7811784148,
-0.3906506896,
0.698379457,
0.4654499292,
-0.372092098,
-0.3120572567,
-0.6466883421,
-0.4264019132,
-0.4931337237,
0.6965779066,
0.0159262475,
-1.0710657835,
0.1764236987,
-0.5007160902,
0.357192874,
0.154550299,
0.6028548479,
-0.1251289696,
1.0737348795,
0.7598989606,
-0.4496385157,
0.6728454232,
-0.4247356057,
0.6045386791,
-0.6523634791,
-0.5905637741,
-0.3569422066,
-0.371234417,
-0.6956803799,
-0.1085525155,
0.195707351,
-0.2576034963,
-0.2362234294,
-0.2511552274,
-0.2298263311,
0.3018552661,
0.650318861,
-0.2175899744,
0.4164228737,
-0.1872994751,
0.2221755385,
0.3354255557,
-0.7947431803,
-0.8353712559,
1.0986462831,
0.4873804748,
0.8964576721,
-0.067606166,
0.7455606461,
0.0285080113,
0.4289393127,
-1.1759227514,
0.9300979376,
-0.3500427306,
-0.5867993236,
-0.3027572334,
-0.3933949769,
-0.8775023222,
0.1038045064,
-0.3982872665,
-0.5562685132,
-0.3071273863,
-0.1094805002,
-0.2150865644,
0.6130770445,
-0.6798079014,
0.3620655537,
-0.6721763611,
-0.2759540677,
-0.2417664826,
-0.4880733788,
0.404388994,
-0.4788834751,
0.5419228077,
-0.1079268679,
-0.0741762668,
0.9605510235,
-0.1158288345,
0.8318276405,
0.1304143816,
-0.2597498298,
0.5139094591,
-0.58818084,
0.3174621761,
-0.3125653267,
-0.1306868792,
0.2273378074,
-0.2264317572,
-0.3896123767,
-0.3840120435,
0.953227818,
-0.9703533649,
-0.8844457865,
-0.6778179407,
-0.714531064,
-0.301227361,
0.2127853334,
-0.0596934333,
0.1944083124,
0.034916196,
0.1695872247,
0.6989700794,
-0.4183266163,
0.5621498227,
0.3718756735,
-0.3175852895,
-0.2085088044,
1.2115520239,
0.4991835058,
-0.0011015666,
-0.0006484723,
0.2751195729,
-0.2280829102,
-0.7805617452,
-0.2514877319,
0.3934051394,
-0.5546485186,
-0.008660716,
-0.3688184917,
-0.5234974623,
-0.4915590286,
-0.2702443302,
-0.3937952518,
-0.1093295291,
-0.480748713,
-0.1233744323,
0.0476668999,
1.2615320683,
0.2994622886,
0.2798548639,
-0.7118681073,
0.2364864498,
0.4589256048,
0.4575315714,
-0.0925943181,
-0.2410846651,
-0.1802750975,
-0.0336399078,
-0.2610760331,
-0.3039038479,
0.1621628106,
0.2044203728,
0.6257978082,
0.3131130636,
-0.0555886552,
0.2465194166,
-0.6468761563,
0.8418603539,
0.165269807,
-0.5454534888,
0.4570335448,
-0.1209802106,
0.2731852829,
0.1962095946,
0.5611478686,
-0.4487467408,
-0.2836053073,
-0.3365582526,
-1.0706163645,
0.4735964537,
-0.3672490418,
0.4147104025,
0.21620287,
0.2195896059,
0.02662744,
0.2804811597,
-0.5554866791,
-0.3871744275,
0.1643862277,
-0.3931241333,
-0.1633002311,
-0.2724294066,
0.1003101692,
-0.2139173746,
0.8252204061,
0.1986171454,
-0.1574012339,
-0.2345452905,
0.0341261961,
-0.0663650632,
0.6412829757,
0.4654026926,
0.7254378796,
0.0163119994,
-0.2972879112,
0.1990033835,
-0.6648543477,
0.1470810026,
0.0684467852,
-0.2040050924,
-0.2508147955,
0.4706718326,
0.4442712665,
0.1097788662,
-1.0168850422,
0.2930526435,
0.0166306328,
-0.3596417904,
-0.51679039,
0.282897532,
0.1007689536,
0.5202163458,
0.4866419137,
-0.2004507482,
-0.0601745397,
-0.7484286427,
-0.2414877415,
0.5218266249,
-0.2756488323,
-0.004326493,
0.3885335326,
0.4895163774,
-0.621365428,
0.8023234606,
0.2336035818,
-0.4860450327,
0.5528704524,
0.5484716892,
0.608494103,
-0.3941917717,
-0.0404389091,
-0.0181729533,
0.4802778065,
-0.3251132071,
0.4506935775,
0.2460149825,
-0.5652923584,
-0.4818786383,
-0.5074930191,
-0.9202815294,
0.2970236242,
-0.1838904172,
0.2661828697,
-0.7337151766,
-0.3881109059,
-0.2311814129,
0.1956404597,
-0.673987031,
0.4020593762,
0.3970489502,
0.7485397458,
-0.6835979223,
1.0200648308,
1.0252372026,
-0.0404132418,
-0.753282845,
-0.3735276759,
0.042119123,
-0.5395106077,
0.4903947413,
0.1554688513,
-0.2297408879,
0.1412230432,
-0.652169764,
-0.6409286261,
0.9235916138,
0.3141480386,
-1.1213132143,
-0.1926709712,
0.2363320142,
0.4608493745,
-0.1486166865,
0.1063843295,
0.620767653,
0.5830737948,
-0.142788142,
-0.7764209509,
-0.4598299563,
-0.09883596,
-0.1109198257,
0.1482107639,
-0.7054659128,
0.6758860946,
-0.3622520566,
-0.0386632048,
0.1000974998,
0.6675555706,
0.2853459418,
0.4320224524,
0.0689116195,
0.3813280165,
0.6550341845,
-0.2806830406,
0.878641367,
-0.3240930438,
0.3642323017,
0.8503939509,
-0.3768552244,
0.8567821383,
0.5094634891,
-0.4010282159,
0.4301323593,
0.6606516242,
-0.2458576113,
-0.0124564087,
0.3453099132,
-0.3371424973,
-0.1274808198,
-0.4074259102,
-0.3955546916,
0.5684499741,
0.6308463216,
-0.1069144905,
0.0814136118,
0.4510388672,
-0.0003111107,
0.2965522408,
-0.7327008247,
0.4732983708,
0.2807176411,
-0.4698984623,
0.0725511536,
0.1801728606,
0.974075377,
-0.6118147373,
-0.11428193,
-0.2176360041,
0.1576405168,
-0.2901606858,
-0.7820261121,
-0.0878429487,
0.0250438992,
0.2279952914,
-0.1976432353,
0.648314178,
-0.4881331027,
-0.7284433842,
0.2760541141,
0.5263204575,
0.0555488393,
0.4108552933,
-0.6197947264,
0.3049824834,
-0.3369117081,
-0.2943060398,
0.3866253495,
0.2221043557,
-0.0819614008,
1.1089396477,
0.5178715587,
0.1310658902,
0.0346226692,
0.2273075134,
0.6992506385,
-0.6936346292,
-0.2455207855,
-0.7180007696,
0.2345013469,
0.1566075534,
-0.3020835519,
0.7835708857,
0.3265600204,
1.0189687014,
0.1066295132,
0.9061969519,
0.3136147559,
0.2385979742,
-0.3492565751,
0.7181270719,
-0.5106368065,
0.2571341991,
-0.1188616455,
-1.1942019463,
-0.3697886169,
0.5040102601,
-0.4992333353,
0.3170081079,
0.5289697647,
0.278783083,
0.2403250337,
0.050057888,
0.5012128949,
0.1091139913,
0.2497244477,
0.4531552494,
0.9693862796,
-0.2216871977,
0.1467850208,
-0.1810959578,
0.0022683954,
-0.3999096453,
-0.5445130467,
-0.9936106801,
-0.4137119055,
-0.5070415139,
0.0930873826,
0.1179183424,
1.1493983269,
0.4210445285,
-0.7189431787,
-0.4021674693,
0.2896110415,
0.4693001509,
0.2557381392,
-0.1670682579,
0.2259511054,
-0.041435495,
-1.0828071833,
0.4776277542,
0.2777660489,
0.1948661357,
-0.5896859765,
0.0353794284,
-0.3354544044,
0.2299995273,
0.7911525369,
0.3748734295,
-0.7865065336,
-0.3017700016,
-0.1535482407,
-0.201511398,
-0.2110565901,
0.6989527345,
-0.7343528867,
0.2470897436,
0.1546252221,
0.9038804173,
0.0400859341,
-0.5028012991,
0.1577720493,
-0.1078092605,
0.0081175091,
0.4945137501,
0.4111810029,
0.4647787213,
-0.0983544812,
0.3387581706,
0.0700701922,
-0.6304964423,
-0.8318132162,
0.1971965879,
-0.7626393437,
-0.4309328794,
1.0059536695,
0.0806229785,
-0.2751987278,
-0.2001741976,
-0.0748137087,
0.1831522584,
-0.1756073236,
0.6492371559,
0.6158533096,
-0.0160590056,
-0.1479362547,
-0.7221204638,
-0.0535183921,
0.3454848826,
-0.8783091903,
-0.433264643,
0.3570966125,
0.1664213091,
0.0093817543,
0.2198920101,
-0.1592573375,
0.005730845,
-0.2760899961,
0.0327033997,
-0.2386593968,
-0.6384190917,
-0.5502470136,
0.0819938779,
0.3144466579,
0.0076825046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07111v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07111v1
|
Designing and Evaluating Dialogue LLMs for Co-Creative Improvised Theatre
| 2024-05-11T23:19:42 | 2024-05-11T23:19:42 |
Boyd Branch, Piotr Mirowski, Kory Mathewson, Sophia Ppali, Alexandra Covaci
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Social robotics researchers are increasingly interested in multi-party
trained conversational agents. With a growing demand for real-world
evaluations, our study presents Large Language Models (LLMs) deployed in a
month-long live show at the Edinburgh Festival Fringe. This case study
investigates human improvisers co-creating with conversational agents in a
professional theatre setting. We explore the technical capabilities and
constraints of on-the-spot multi-party dialogue, providing comprehensive
insights from both audience and performer experiences with AI on stage. Our
human-in-the-loop methodology underlines the challenges of these LLMs in
generating context-relevant responses, stressing the user interface's crucial
role. Audience feedback indicates an evolving interest for AI-driven live
entertainment, direct human-AI interaction, and a diverse range of expectations
about AI's conversational competence and utility as a creativity support tool.
Human performers express immense enthusiasm, varied satisfaction, and the
evolving public opinion highlights mixed emotions about AI's role in arts.
|
[
-0.4352713823,
-0.55614537,
0.3370768726,
0.1331210583,
0.0942202732,
0.7327775955,
-0.2736985683,
-0.4046209455,
0.5225521326,
0.4819098711,
-0.6984181404,
-0.116521664,
0.04365981,
0.033283852,
-0.4751095474,
0.5814951658,
0.2368706912,
0.0773160532,
-0.4874763787,
-0.2663967013,
-0.2147308886,
-0.5356194973,
-0.7546780109,
-0.2918412387,
0.6869337559,
0.7443808913,
0.7793647647,
-0.2025725693,
0.3539386094,
0.3931240439,
0.1894377619,
0.4885112047,
-0.3690884411,
0.2636823654,
0.0315599367,
-0.1929397583,
-0.3113540411,
0.3054535985,
0.4142184556,
0.6508636475,
-0.3741612434,
-0.0677604079,
-0.0685673654,
0.2547574043,
-0.0346600413,
0.0466910377,
-0.4413186312,
0.3786884248,
0.1315062791,
-0.1985248625,
-0.4100636244,
-0.3269406855,
0.0774010122,
-0.682795465,
-0.2695056796,
0.1408182085,
0.6823468804,
0.2953318059,
-0.1651903689,
-0.3671931326,
-1.1829382181,
0.415166676,
-0.5564248562,
0.0003822276,
0.0164471548,
0.5595850945,
-0.4519010186,
-0.9395225644,
-1.0215423107,
-0.5135185719,
0.3850077391,
0.2124896049,
-0.0035857039,
0.1797464043,
0.0939952582,
0.2551957369,
-0.3307228684,
0.1515305936,
-0.2998639345,
-0.0962590575,
0.8451513052,
0.2873145044,
0.5088084936,
0.0851854458,
-0.1801712662,
-0.049211923,
-0.5407376885,
0.0466393568,
0.6454271078,
-0.0924472213,
-0.2711851001,
0.4862781465,
-0.1098611057,
0.4124569595,
0.0149371894,
0.1473016888,
-0.3504410982,
-0.3262827396,
0.143440485,
-0.446269542,
0.9655358791,
0.4404044151,
0.5483939052,
-0.2446234673,
-0.0625643432,
0.0615849346,
0.2429797649,
-0.4459740818,
-0.3944065869,
0.1204107255,
0.0727873743,
-0.3014743924,
0.0013159487,
-0.4176240563,
-0.8563505411,
-0.3413160741,
0.5328327417,
-0.0232088026,
-0.1328370869,
-0.1361260712,
-0.3618192077,
0.0202481169,
0.3477854729,
-0.2577057779,
0.2827437222,
0.5410667062,
0.3662776649,
0.113484621,
-0.3203529716,
-0.5275211334,
0.0510396771,
-0.4882288873,
0.6889497042,
-0.2985301614,
-0.3019661903,
-0.0659619197,
-0.0887634233,
0.0620408915,
-0.5989999175,
0.3319619298,
-0.3640824854,
0.4232752323,
0.2000242174,
-0.3692208827,
0.1017264947,
0.0635848865,
-0.516593039,
0.4537085295,
0.1286732256,
-0.3672882915,
0.1854357868,
-0.7964938283,
-0.377266109,
0.6258393526,
-0.6579470038,
-0.0209146328,
-0.0103555862,
-0.0195345338,
0.2518312931,
-0.0320384279,
0.4432966709,
-0.3936713636,
-0.7159852982,
1.0418488979,
-0.6495280266,
0.042041488,
0.0735557079,
-0.1231525838,
0.4887968898,
-0.8044261932,
-0.2414046824,
0.0545384772,
-0.2352866977,
0.3573934436,
0.4893126488,
0.0771837756,
0.4137796462,
-0.1092038378,
-0.6464352608,
-0.0967551395,
-0.5809271932,
0.827236414,
0.6681615114,
-0.0393990055,
0.4126181304,
-0.6465854049,
0.7911406159,
-0.3506855965,
0.088090308,
-0.1047529578,
-0.6144112945,
-0.7602046132,
-0.2907970846,
-0.2624981701,
0.3611678481,
-0.9738612771,
0.1614204049,
0.0290308166,
-0.3510175943,
-0.6380177736,
-0.0766597837,
-0.0211284757,
0.0695887655,
-0.2309618592,
-0.2629896104,
-0.490835011,
-0.9272833467,
-0.2323043197,
-0.2617999613,
-0.1529482454,
0.5624554753,
0.0983324125,
-0.199579969,
1.1358431578,
0.0146253295,
-0.0569631159,
-0.5712843537,
0.1373769492,
0.2833703756,
0.1754586846,
0.05805346,
-0.5199164748,
-0.4273292422,
-0.0698325634,
-0.5441722274,
-0.1292913705,
-0.2298679054,
0.2561818659,
0.4527237117,
0.1649138629,
-0.6743151546,
0.5123033524,
0.7253017426,
-0.2540376186,
0.4681603014,
-0.125853911,
0.2996546328,
-0.8917229772,
-0.0404112116,
-0.2816197872,
-0.2368669063,
-0.6719108224,
-0.0271366891,
-0.6635205746,
-0.7604980469,
-0.7002515793,
0.6092548966,
-0.3433533907,
-0.255295068,
-0.2928199172,
0.5949029326,
0.2293140143,
0.6969043016,
0.032757517,
0.7824305296,
0.2334614694,
-0.3984186649,
0.5798984766,
0.3146181107,
-0.781126976,
0.3717106879,
-0.5258672833,
0.7301394343,
0.245412454,
0.489893496,
-1.3474661112,
-0.6214675307,
0.4799320996,
-0.2617456913,
-0.0483450145,
0.1135614365,
-0.5961589217,
-0.5460379124,
-0.0120818177,
0.2505966425,
0.3377963305,
-0.3035643399,
0.7152345777,
0.6726176143,
-0.4283842742,
-0.1909420788,
-0.3532949686,
0.5986576676,
-0.3250695467,
-1.1631857157,
0.1023164913,
-0.3438037634,
-0.6509969234,
-0.4790774584,
0.1620753258,
-0.0345154777,
0.1733122617,
0.3856956661,
-0.1461063325,
0.1869078279,
-0.1161738411,
-0.1365085542,
0.0919862986,
-0.0898004323,
0.1583476663,
0.662756741,
0.0357404947,
-0.6652907729,
-1.1095122099,
0.4516650438,
0.7357002497,
0.2609985769,
0.3977420926,
0.5813145041,
-0.0911812633,
-0.1501637697,
-0.6077008843,
-0.0617661066,
-0.5145192146,
0.1973464042,
0.0185274053,
-0.9555706978,
0.7615486383,
-0.0017744948,
-0.0029468054,
-0.1082058102,
0.5093996525,
-0.5016066432,
0.7824219465,
0.0717928857,
0.4220386147,
0.6333965063,
-0.0773201063,
0.2622401118,
-0.7091268897,
-0.1571590155,
-0.3222610056,
-0.6977137327,
-0.3242871463,
-0.6872229576,
0.5884132981,
-0.4245937169,
-0.0778121799,
0.0930463448,
-0.1607074589,
0.4154496789,
0.3601354659,
0.2318344265,
0.0291919857,
-0.4553402662,
0.1505035907,
0.2417552769,
-0.7997634411,
-0.6205696464,
0.7044581175,
0.4202463925,
0.8644124866,
0.1598434299,
0.4271359146,
0.4773451984,
0.1469450444,
-0.6631891727,
0.8747155666,
0.2546635568,
-0.6188519597,
-0.6798331141,
-0.1202832311,
-0.6248229742,
0.0943927243,
-0.0926657692,
-0.7439443469,
0.1272948533,
0.0110722678,
-0.5162115097,
0.1288859546,
-0.6159354448,
0.6439803839,
-0.0868677869,
-0.5431438684,
-0.5533638597,
-0.6317347884,
0.0670951977,
0.0730738416,
0.6088765264,
-0.2781714201,
0.3853342533,
0.7004088163,
-0.2470026314,
1.0890376568,
-0.0285239555,
-0.0985149294,
0.718524456,
0.2065375149,
0.5281662345,
0.2212784141,
-0.2408719063,
0.119129099,
-0.0504401848,
-0.0649031177,
-0.4303184152,
0.4344940186,
-0.8947136402,
-0.7782654166,
-0.0282923747,
-0.740722239,
-0.1874295324,
-0.3637154698,
-0.2212463766,
0.7032176852,
-0.5401060581,
0.4042694271,
0.1301726252,
-0.8053310513,
0.7253574133,
0.4477210641,
-0.3156204224,
-0.5826867223,
0.6187787652,
0.0399318673,
0.5220841169,
0.1358249485,
0.2102176845,
-0.1903732419,
-0.2178355604,
-0.6261182427,
-0.0227898825,
-0.6680248976,
0.3092388213,
-0.6129598618,
-0.0980503857,
-0.2531247139,
-0.1467070282,
-0.0770966411,
-0.7245913148,
-0.3394174278,
-0.0357868373,
-0.0630430356,
0.8739669323,
-0.2754020989,
0.4798304737,
-0.536100626,
-0.0003657757,
0.4091688693,
0.2415298969,
-0.0567063503,
-0.5099764466,
-0.3871842027,
-0.1270256788,
-0.4924595654,
-0.7324385047,
0.4988050163,
0.4408746064,
0.5536017418,
0.342659831,
0.0973628312,
0.4033920467,
-0.4498344958,
1.1239695549,
0.0185902789,
-0.7162701488,
0.2844828069,
-0.4767281711,
0.2042997181,
0.2595680356,
0.0964514688,
-0.8764029741,
-0.6058884263,
-0.4922244549,
-0.6714944839,
0.8820387721,
0.126250118,
0.4225440621,
-0.1090364754,
0.0330654681,
0.1840801984,
0.4654149413,
-0.7629153728,
0.1042829156,
0.1468133181,
0.0914961621,
-0.170427084,
-0.1809526831,
-0.6779019237,
-0.1053131819,
0.2994274199,
-0.1605606228,
0.2468858361,
0.0131272068,
0.1322556138,
-0.5277565718,
0.3595016301,
0.6832756996,
0.915158987,
-0.1624863446,
-0.2030898929,
0.1250236928,
0.1364039034,
-0.0157717858,
-0.1444551945,
0.3859603703,
-0.1737157106,
0.2474130094,
0.8759019375,
0.2967121899,
-0.97190696,
0.4624872208,
-0.3129475415,
-0.1535229087,
-0.8346453309,
0.2323614061,
0.2391507179,
0.3833645582,
0.4006702602,
0.1118677482,
-0.0019921185,
-0.9668084979,
0.4153541028,
0.395186305,
-0.4184239805,
-0.4712342918,
0.5222644806,
0.6393358707,
-1.1996742487,
0.3707798123,
-0.0898134634,
-0.3718169928,
0.5760082006,
0.2231874019,
0.8881431222,
0.174778372,
0.3309875131,
-0.3452816904,
-0.038986925,
0.5597531199,
0.1857178658,
-0.194015488,
-0.89929986,
-0.5476096869,
-0.5341255665,
-0.9872864485,
-0.0863148049,
-0.102318041,
0.3079176843,
-0.2550568581,
-0.1549147367,
-0.1312341392,
-0.0751699805,
-0.5479809642,
-0.1949265301,
0.6253550053,
0.6141163707,
-0.6357569098,
0.606743753,
0.6189084649,
-0.2497029454,
-0.8899573684,
0.0771338418,
-0.0303825978,
-0.6636214852,
0.3927393854,
0.0060292101,
0.0111690005,
-0.0446504727,
-0.6529154181,
-0.6066291332,
1.0068655014,
0.207909897,
-0.6403383017,
-0.1366191059,
0.3191308081,
0.8652349114,
-0.5121675134,
0.7006323338,
0.0736195073,
0.1804219484,
0.6720075011,
-1.0287394524,
-0.5235458612,
0.1262999177,
-0.3137328327,
-0.1897188425,
-0.8774027228,
0.4342689216,
0.086490348,
-0.2826940417,
0.4371451139,
0.4855372608,
0.4346659184,
0.6511037946,
0.478110075,
0.1910277754,
0.5854021907,
-0.1627759039,
1.1158794165,
-0.3378315568,
-0.1630395502,
0.8937169313,
-0.7307800651,
0.6854867339,
0.2547521591,
-0.178387925,
0.8049256802,
0.4891803861,
0.5330129862,
0.1667951047,
0.7596918344,
-0.5284634233,
-0.4147536457,
-0.1868713498,
0.0101235555,
0.558513999,
0.3978708982,
0.182116136,
0.35807392,
0.1352089942,
-0.2766604424,
0.1177448332,
0.0240686666,
0.9949517846,
0.2504394948,
-0.9895540476,
0.0137811508,
-0.3889354765,
0.3361282647,
-0.2313057035,
-0.0596792847,
-0.2140535712,
0.1542728692,
-0.0484628677,
-0.9858446121,
0.3132554591,
-0.3099423349,
0.3473651409,
-0.1069001853,
0.5724810958,
-0.4208703637,
-0.1735902131,
0.2064008862,
0.2527379692,
0.5122641325,
0.0612144731,
-0.56043154,
0.2499784082,
-0.3092906773,
-0.1030437574,
0.1529685557,
0.6268568039,
-0.0088525973,
0.972509563,
0.3736975193,
-0.1578707546,
-0.1244332865,
0.5454059839,
0.8630102873,
-0.5001839399,
-0.5592102408,
-0.4611095488,
0.8942959309,
-0.0085708117,
-0.1026099995,
0.2945054471,
0.2728248835,
0.5962794423,
0.0043661464,
0.5237358809,
0.0454398878,
0.5189601183,
0.0032801591,
0.7750720978,
-0.4511178434,
0.2992140651,
-0.3709424138,
-0.5706828833,
0.0943794399,
0.2392450422,
-0.0688042715,
-0.0835057199,
0.2830057144,
0.9851770401,
0.3817941248,
0.1982775033,
0.8001324534,
0.0671065599,
0.5265889168,
0.2920296192,
1.9746294022,
0.0662344098,
0.4571327865,
0.0984053463,
-0.2359497696,
-0.3167805076,
-0.737605989,
-0.8039188385,
-0.5075542927,
-0.3932462335,
-0.3796523213,
0.1093405485,
1.2624183893,
0.6395365,
-0.4853733182,
-0.7042815685,
0.3186563253,
0.1841140389,
0.0141515415,
-0.218782261,
-0.2782619894,
0.031210335,
-0.9271227121,
0.9748362899,
0.5588869452,
-0.309469372,
-0.652012527,
-0.2302154154,
-0.2554027438,
0.6440318227,
0.6159349084,
0.256569922,
-0.8195466399,
-0.5635895133,
-0.1803688109,
0.0279903691,
0.0115612186,
0.479193002,
-0.6186262965,
0.3675693274,
0.437694788,
0.393265903,
0.2811204791,
0.010469378,
0.9246179461,
-0.658403337,
0.052961491,
0.4694798887,
0.1197518185,
0.394880861,
-0.154847011,
0.5199927688,
0.4655137956,
-1.1085113287,
-0.8891862035,
0.2683301568,
-1.1721788645,
0.0501342975,
1.1687381268,
-0.074227877,
-0.0162576493,
-0.185786292,
-0.3519690335,
0.26923576,
-0.3120510578,
0.7081074715,
0.7222573757,
-0.3982801735,
-0.3056256771,
-0.2883776128,
0.2794115543,
0.1216151193,
-0.4391238987,
-0.4338989854,
0.5612664223,
0.1139072627,
0.1698256731,
0.6605919003,
0.2183506191,
0.1189352721,
-0.2095144093,
0.3755830526,
0.1940591484,
-0.5457683802,
-0.2162858993,
0.312137723,
0.2920281887,
-0.0052114753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07101v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07101v1
|
Advanced Natural-based interaction for the ITAlian language: LLaMAntino-3-ANITA
| 2024-05-11T22:02:55 | 2024-05-11T22:02:55 |
Marco Polignano, Pierpaolo Basile, Giovanni Semeraro
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In the pursuit of advancing natural language processing for the Italian
language, we introduce a state-of-the-art Large Language Model (LLM) based on
the novel Meta LLaMA-3 model: LLaMAntino-3-ANITA-8B-Inst-DPO-ITA. We fine-tuned
the original 8B parameters instruction tuned model using the Supervised
Fine-tuning (SFT) technique on the English and Italian language datasets in
order to improve the original performance. Consequently, a Dynamic Preference
Optimization (DPO) process has been used to align preferences, avoid dangerous
and inappropriate answers, and limit biases and prejudices. Our model leverages
the efficiency of QLoRA to fine-tune the model on a smaller portion of the
original model weights and then adapt the model specifically for the Italian
linguistic structure, achieving significant improvements in both performance
and computational efficiency. Concurrently, DPO is employed to refine the
model's output, ensuring that generated content aligns with quality answers.
The synergy between SFT, QLoRA's parameter efficiency and DPO's user-centric
optimization results in a robust LLM that excels in a variety of tasks,
including but not limited to text completion, zero-shot classification, and
contextual understanding. The model has been extensively evaluated over
standard benchmarks for the Italian and English languages, showing outstanding
results. The model is freely available over the HuggingFace hub and, examples
of use can be found in our GitHub repository.
https://huggingface.co/swap-uniba/LLaMAntino-3-ANITA-8B-Inst-DPO-ITA
|
[
-0.4262659848,
-0.9462170601,
0.5502511859,
0.2139672339,
-0.3336379826,
0.0183187574,
-0.3810278475,
-0.9127795696,
0.3685385585,
0.4364578426,
-0.377050966,
-0.4319300354,
-0.470218569,
0.3366188109,
-0.1628758609,
0.9502433538,
-0.1334498376,
0.3422107995,
0.1765118688,
-0.0684734434,
-0.0558415353,
-0.3585320115,
-0.8944268227,
-0.3535759747,
0.4965209961,
0.3690694869,
0.7577220201,
0.7307274938,
0.4185475409,
0.354588002,
-0.3907746673,
0.486222446,
-0.3878899217,
0.0718356818,
-0.1342186779,
-0.4969640374,
-0.9198996425,
0.0271423273,
0.6892156601,
0.5263748765,
-0.1510489732,
-0.0466783755,
0.0600421131,
0.7435211539,
-0.483017236,
0.0972019732,
-0.6278771758,
-0.2148854882,
-0.2347063869,
-0.0988007411,
-0.1799021959,
-0.4895054102,
-0.1222899482,
-0.5340704918,
-0.3351769447,
0.0332989842,
0.6829611063,
0.4345174432,
-0.3467036188,
-0.4499672353,
-0.7820523977,
0.5034191608,
-0.7414393425,
0.0378629304,
0.3892944455,
0.1999509186,
-0.3124342263,
-0.3668762743,
-0.8256824017,
-0.6517487168,
0.2923786044,
-0.1854644567,
-0.1273972839,
0.2350046635,
-0.0519209132,
0.6865603328,
-0.2823173404,
0.4994594753,
-0.2147945315,
0.0403319113,
0.6493795514,
0.024604395,
0.4373484254,
0.1305630803,
-0.1709830314,
0.3237871528,
-0.8116989136,
-0.1359086484,
0.6205695271,
0.3357168734,
-0.1058100685,
0.6123155951,
-0.3183615208,
0.9089642167,
0.1958007365,
-0.1291361451,
0.1770507991,
-0.2456867695,
-0.0070753237,
-0.0492652468,
0.9026679397,
0.3167952895,
0.3837583661,
-0.0215392541,
-0.1110422686,
-0.13537018,
-0.0520893261,
-0.8372386694,
0.108869791,
0.1660148054,
0.0254582837,
-0.3819439709,
-0.3347084224,
-0.8063665628,
-0.3708319962,
-0.485588938,
0.1599016488,
-0.3375425935,
-0.0606966242,
0.14203915,
0.5534498692,
-0.0709082335,
0.3692839146,
-1.1983362436,
0.3182603419,
0.5755232573,
0.824426353,
-0.4096958339,
-0.1262824386,
-0.7201309204,
0.3813529015,
-0.1981296241,
0.8259758949,
-0.7531247139,
-0.2040345222,
-0.0900358483,
-0.2142164856,
0.0367825367,
-0.5001972914,
0.6221988201,
-0.4623640478,
0.3302638233,
0.0921413153,
-0.4207254648,
-0.2571114302,
0.4084717035,
-0.8459442258,
1.1086599827,
-0.0315419137,
-0.6627916694,
0.1076270044,
-0.7925053239,
-0.2000205964,
0.071355246,
0.0018796353,
-0.2882197499,
0.1510678977,
0.1005333364,
0.1589455605,
-0.4323411882,
0.6651293635,
-0.4976620674,
-0.3782987297,
0.126115799,
-0.430464685,
0.6255322099,
0.0899212286,
-0.5346517563,
0.2895920873,
-1.2104370594,
-0.2083812952,
-0.0794511437,
-0.5412504077,
-0.26717031,
-0.0181365702,
-0.0244887266,
0.1248042136,
0.6946063042,
-0.5942714214,
0.443841815,
-0.6712568998,
0.6323459148,
0.6622672677,
-0.2706954181,
0.5409023762,
0.1178200617,
0.4972397983,
-0.1267886609,
0.1886294931,
0.0916500688,
-0.3958703876,
-0.9791164398,
-0.4350117743,
0.3278310001,
0.71281147,
-0.714374125,
0.4428038895,
-0.1857102364,
-0.4437248707,
-0.5520043373,
0.2544822097,
0.4364088178,
0.2811914086,
0.2686104774,
-0.1724568009,
-0.3598169088,
-1.0963946581,
-0.0441296771,
-0.1806659698,
0.1926219165,
0.2496778369,
0.2444747984,
-0.3394829333,
0.7805184126,
-0.2799893618,
-0.1285459697,
-0.3498634696,
0.0415973403,
0.5257863998,
0.5167983174,
0.8073295951,
-0.6685186028,
-0.6698735356,
0.4002831876,
-0.3745445907,
-0.3026789725,
0.3570650518,
-0.3547739387,
0.3634285033,
0.1549685597,
-0.6632023454,
0.3023734391,
0.7837633491,
-0.1025260016,
0.2547011971,
-0.2608718574,
0.0973814428,
-1.3668504953,
0.2065749168,
-0.1479364485,
-0.1912169456,
-0.7519074082,
0.209763974,
-0.189854607,
-0.0410362296,
-0.5213039517,
0.7942934036,
-0.4055554569,
-0.0783438459,
-0.4658012092,
0.1901726574,
-0.1037468538,
0.6515328288,
0.1294108182,
1.1461197138,
0.2863422036,
-0.5158448219,
0.5027628541,
0.1437995434,
-0.1713527292,
0.3745101988,
-0.709482789,
0.291131705,
0.1595161557,
-0.0201944914,
-0.7754997015,
-0.342993319,
0.5662703514,
-0.2916563451,
0.300729692,
0.0281879678,
-0.6646765471,
-0.1061310247,
-0.1667117774,
0.414673835,
-0.1002757549,
-0.3944676816,
0.6521422863,
0.4241675436,
-0.5298594832,
-0.3006006181,
-0.5054181218,
0.3495599926,
-0.3442388773,
-0.4209547341,
0.5287008882,
-0.2767575383,
-0.3566076756,
-0.3344312012,
0.3346357048,
-0.4007081091,
0.2097777873,
-0.1378473639,
0.2334031016,
0.0016131751,
0.0847634524,
0.2819017768,
-0.2236021608,
-0.3648050129,
-0.0870408639,
0.6809284687,
-0.0336900949,
-0.087774165,
-0.8459881544,
0.4480356276,
0.6771119237,
-0.2835894823,
0.8551209569,
0.4439139366,
-0.2440053225,
0.1138342246,
-0.4067344069,
-0.0131482361,
-0.4339871109,
0.2143698186,
-0.4530448616,
-1.0096541643,
0.4651537538,
0.1573476046,
0.1760994047,
0.2280319482,
0.7006921172,
0.2411224693,
1.1677868366,
0.8417463303,
-0.4220721424,
0.7677093148,
0.1214084998,
0.2848936319,
-0.8023558855,
-0.0485051051,
-0.5635406971,
-0.2208065391,
-0.8394411802,
-0.258300662,
0.4171559811,
0.1338697821,
-0.2258018702,
0.3276733756,
-0.2877696157,
0.3594423831,
0.6838040948,
0.2093117982,
0.6555464268,
-0.0136443563,
-0.1763488203,
0.0647701174,
-0.4894317389,
-0.8446844816,
0.7945961356,
0.3302361667,
0.5351021886,
0.3463019729,
0.5876746774,
-0.0238155294,
0.3162508905,
-0.7973074913,
0.5366968513,
-0.1437589675,
-0.7319068909,
-0.1541546583,
-0.3083646297,
-0.6192504168,
0.283264637,
-0.222974062,
-0.7825521827,
-0.0019909048,
0.4593710005,
-0.3949733675,
0.133837685,
-0.5559790134,
0.5058829784,
-0.4193911552,
-0.9441228509,
-0.4333170652,
-0.320296526,
0.3433248103,
0.0064914185,
0.2109843343,
-0.3967213333,
-0.2179828733,
0.1800006181,
-0.1971460879,
0.9458836317,
0.0469090901,
-0.4209815264,
0.111430645,
0.0939661264,
0.4265847206,
0.2124845982,
-0.5588157773,
0.1863275617,
-0.1693010479,
-0.3116925955,
-0.5086401701,
0.7068589926,
-0.723916769,
-0.649522543,
-0.3527611196,
-0.433989197,
-0.2349615991,
0.3184513152,
-0.0635226145,
0.430621922,
-0.2698462307,
0.0775620118,
0.3838608265,
-0.2436702251,
0.4713514745,
0.7339679003,
-0.2114615142,
-0.6207402945,
0.6178518534,
-0.2339932323,
0.2284337133,
0.4845685065,
0.0589567795,
-0.0756728873,
-0.8198139668,
-0.7775436044,
0.3613040447,
-0.1835427731,
-0.2531852424,
-0.4018681347,
-0.0312249977,
-0.1877405941,
0.2005322725,
-0.3661726117,
-0.4974804819,
-0.5310104489,
-0.1711644232,
0.3232515156,
0.7613998652,
0.0951929092,
0.4850965142,
-0.7476933599,
0.1187714338,
0.2151679099,
0.4448021948,
-0.2858822346,
-0.3734618723,
-0.3427881896,
0.2577230036,
-0.3991764188,
-0.7910633087,
0.4965080619,
0.3777488768,
0.5302128792,
0.4702762067,
-0.2523388267,
0.4888967574,
-0.7585988641,
0.6918054223,
-0.0640127361,
-0.9882689118,
0.5419653058,
-0.702801168,
0.152981177,
0.6913036108,
0.3322178125,
-0.0806380361,
-0.2631739974,
-0.1942630708,
-0.6744617224,
0.6348989606,
0.229953438,
0.1731764078,
-0.1007290781,
0.6380609274,
0.007379137,
0.4533702433,
-0.9555755258,
0.1459362954,
0.2295166552,
-0.3656582534,
-0.0847656205,
-0.4701858461,
-0.1084939241,
-0.2772074044,
0.6997804046,
-0.4479572177,
0.1072864905,
-0.130833745,
-0.0767236724,
-0.0541374087,
0.2158995271,
0.8830054402,
0.6312468052,
-0.0356409848,
-0.2216549218,
0.2079404444,
-0.3412372768,
-0.0913728178,
0.3026305139,
-0.1855707765,
-0.1351444721,
0.303747952,
1.1358335018,
0.508209765,
-0.6980167627,
0.1743216217,
0.0064426349,
0.0197730362,
-0.3148400784,
0.3148296475,
-0.0476297811,
0.2397271097,
0.1586052477,
-0.1613860577,
0.4285112321,
-0.6954250336,
-0.1064035594,
0.3881526887,
-0.2991705835,
-0.5559167266,
0.5628042221,
0.68767488,
-0.2585652769,
0.305187881,
0.0227125455,
-0.7274258137,
0.3979518414,
0.3633831143,
0.7246978283,
-0.4218685627,
0.257575959,
0.3854878247,
0.0541109107,
0.1306009293,
0.2410596609,
-0.2840331793,
-0.9058366418,
-0.4732677042,
-0.8426141143,
-0.6209152341,
-0.046520602,
-0.6676086783,
0.3123258054,
-0.4633173943,
-0.1688050479,
-0.1595873088,
0.3598219454,
-0.2592911124,
0.0806098133,
0.0351172611,
0.893548429,
-0.6226469874,
1.0076078176,
0.7201842666,
-0.3455553949,
-0.448315382,
-0.0387716852,
-0.061429508,
-0.9369273782,
0.4943323135,
0.2267891616,
-0.3972283006,
0.1250097603,
-0.484305501,
-0.9425970316,
0.8974150419,
0.6886456013,
-0.8229701519,
-0.0211668815,
0.092288442,
0.8188662529,
-0.5819566846,
0.3870716393,
0.841819346,
0.5129675865,
0.2132015228,
-1.0545551777,
-0.3628712595,
-0.4137494266,
0.0520038866,
0.212158367,
-1.0022602081,
0.4630011022,
-0.0892065987,
0.0470946021,
0.5306039453,
0.6877809167,
0.2405340075,
0.0543768443,
0.3492658734,
0.4997330308,
0.6872986555,
-0.0612858497,
1.0251785517,
-0.7334845066,
-0.0854170844,
1.0595356226,
-0.4197681546,
1.0988873243,
0.6092645526,
-0.1679531038,
0.6345954537,
0.7166798711,
0.3800370395,
0.3229900301,
0.0795913115,
-0.5068176985,
-0.0947396457,
-0.3433885574,
-0.232414946,
0.7762790918,
0.3477611244,
-0.1804544777,
0.1095671505,
-0.1366916001,
0.2940854728,
0.3106782138,
-0.240219757,
0.9158482552,
-0.1630779654,
-0.8218256235,
0.4855478108,
0.0795894712,
0.6098769903,
-0.4081881344,
-0.0354425348,
-0.5191081166,
0.176679045,
0.0174041167,
-0.5435740352,
0.2425873578,
0.3069286942,
-0.2650128007,
-0.0626703277,
0.1391634047,
-0.7080577612,
-0.5996935964,
0.3444865346,
0.0964338332,
0.0871022046,
0.1637035608,
-0.6488841772,
0.4402360618,
0.1661801934,
-0.2770316601,
0.1480823904,
0.3237741292,
-0.0423066579,
0.7916240096,
0.5607628226,
0.292630583,
-0.1707316041,
0.1950749308,
1.0530542135,
-0.3855485022,
-0.4138683081,
-0.7390164733,
0.4521187544,
-0.2774845362,
-0.4517214596,
0.4010617435,
0.4320116639,
0.49592942,
0.2564606667,
0.4187389314,
0.1052816212,
0.7153589129,
-0.7334882021,
0.4103491604,
-0.6730294824,
0.324129492,
-0.0855073482,
-1.2627693415,
-0.3511391282,
0.6770114899,
-0.4015018642,
0.1478765011,
0.4216826856,
0.7590002418,
0.0925870314,
-0.0920230299,
0.2350002676,
0.3549358249,
0.3586001098,
0.5724744201,
0.540355742,
-0.1537567526,
0.2335676849,
-0.0315203592,
-0.5367122889,
-0.1151750237,
-0.9921988845,
-0.9413804412,
-0.3859087527,
-0.0692859143,
0.1976775974,
0.3837352991,
1.0061101913,
0.654394865,
-0.9048573375,
-0.245689407,
-0.2461705357,
-0.0268481746,
0.2400721014,
-0.1534827054,
0.01055458,
-0.2785727382,
-1.536993742,
0.5243406296,
0.5294343233,
0.1160441935,
-0.4458383918,
0.0386598185,
-0.2764575779,
0.0041208873,
0.5727543235,
0.201207757,
-0.709908545,
-0.114533715,
-0.2427162677,
-0.0212438311,
-0.0233670361,
0.4742847681,
-0.4992397726,
0.365816921,
0.4201539159,
0.6185519695,
0.4862288833,
0.0413530394,
1.1526403427,
-0.2144439518,
0.4935135841,
0.0851552412,
0.2573182583,
0.534134984,
-0.5430291295,
0.496378541,
-0.0497766435,
-0.5125411153,
-0.6763805151,
0.384236753,
-0.6749250889,
-0.0075216717,
1.1127463579,
-0.1215321422,
-0.1631551981,
0.3116038442,
-0.4895466864,
0.1190767586,
-0.4600661397,
0.8982736468,
0.7329465151,
-0.1262507737,
-0.372199446,
-0.5615079999,
0.5418871045,
0.3869808912,
-0.9027510285,
-0.2605526149,
0.6817552447,
0.0570810996,
-0.014905367,
0.3271886408,
-0.013286843,
0.0860643908,
-0.6110200286,
0.077773951,
-0.1273265779,
-0.4519226551,
-0.4170771837,
-0.0454797335,
0.2563644648,
-0.0267105922
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07099v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07099v1
|
Do Pretrained Contextual Language Models Distinguish between Hebrew Homograph Analyses?
| 2024-05-11T21:50:56 | 2024-05-11T21:50:56 |
Avi Shmidman, Cheyn Shmuel Shmidman, Dan Bareket, Moshe Koppel, Reut Tsarfaty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Semitic morphologically-rich languages (MRLs) are characterized by extreme
word ambiguity. Because most vowels are omitted in standard texts, many of the
words are homographs with multiple possible analyses, each with a different
pronunciation and different morphosyntactic properties. This ambiguity goes
beyond word-sense disambiguation (WSD), and may include token segmentation into
multiple word units. Previous research on MRLs claimed that standardly trained
pre-trained language models (PLMs) based on word-pieces may not sufficiently
capture the internal structure of such tokens in order to distinguish between
these analyses. Taking Hebrew as a case study, we investigate the extent to
which Hebrew homographs can be disambiguated and analyzed using PLMs. We
evaluate all existing models for contextualized Hebrew embeddings on a novel
Hebrew homograph challenge sets that we deliver. Our empirical results
demonstrate that contemporary Hebrew contextualized embeddings outperform
non-contextualized embeddings; and that they are most effective for
disambiguating segmentation and morphosyntactic features, less so regarding
pure word-sense disambiguation. We show that these embeddings are more
effective when the number of word-piece splits is limited, and they are more
effective for 2-way and 3-way ambiguities than for 4-way ambiguity. We show
that the embeddings are equally effective for homographs of both balanced and
skewed distributions, whether calculated as masked or unmasked tokens. Finally,
we show that these embeddings are as effective for homograph disambiguation
with extensive supervised training as with a few-shot setup.
|
[
-0.2979504764,
-0.8551332951,
0.3784813881,
0.142879039,
-0.657733798,
0.0338752307,
-0.1360749006,
-0.4518182278,
0.1871340722,
-0.0310854893,
-0.3866807818,
-0.565885663,
-0.7178473473,
0.2645587325,
-0.2079633176,
0.5575395226,
-0.0585909262,
0.2680760622,
-0.1550908089,
-0.535543263,
-0.4526394904,
-0.3744969964,
0.0907856822,
-0.3108525872,
0.4681636989,
-0.1627002358,
1.0647367239,
0.7897707224,
0.4193882942,
0.2913054824,
-0.3614273965,
0.1092774719,
-0.0935576409,
0.2921985388,
-0.1302196234,
-0.1373946667,
-0.1280963868,
0.1871158779,
0.6414569616,
1.1473276615,
-0.0883364603,
0.2399303466,
-0.1713617891,
0.4805667698,
-0.8038907051,
-0.1595095396,
-0.7162995934,
0.423766613,
-0.5659821033,
-0.2616350651,
-0.4365223646,
0.0816590339,
0.3719930053,
-0.4786603451,
0.0282389075,
0.3304484785,
0.7390357852,
0.3414942622,
-0.4226599336,
-0.4740212858,
-0.377828896,
0.6726555228,
-0.6310319304,
0.7542424202,
0.4260293543,
-0.0430730805,
-0.0709191039,
-0.6691561341,
-0.4785318375,
-0.0645615235,
-0.2563191354,
0.1013344377,
-0.1142048538,
0.0176652391,
0.2487160563,
0.2388190776,
-0.6162721515,
0.0533478409,
-0.3643254042,
-0.3465058208,
0.2011758834,
-0.0583001859,
0.3278995454,
-0.549706459,
-0.598777771,
-0.217474252,
-0.797742486,
0.0857603326,
0.2513058782,
0.2808781862,
-0.1313292533,
0.7055358291,
0.2909197211,
0.9501360655,
-0.2110181749,
-0.2381996363,
0.5655611753,
-0.0632942989,
-0.4285761714,
0.2090457976,
0.5409783721,
0.001480757,
0.1626603901,
-0.3108156323,
-0.1597228795,
0.1068732142,
0.1115897149,
-0.3994643688,
-0.0110945813,
0.088610813,
-0.4915762544,
-0.0039793309,
0.2949116826,
-0.3823413253,
-0.3330613673,
-0.1536283791,
0.3784105182,
-0.4236370921,
-0.0080713117,
0.2822678387,
-0.4116418362,
0.4085976183,
0.0923126265,
-0.6557561755,
-0.0764589906,
0.7168250084,
0.8715897202,
-0.056311477,
-0.3608339131,
-0.5646121502,
0.1637146026,
-0.5404627919,
0.4695456624,
-0.8817568421,
-0.3232179284,
0.0353014208,
-0.104982689,
-0.2949890792,
-0.6282295585,
-0.1580133587,
-0.7408444881,
0.0385590307,
-0.3032177091,
-0.8123320937,
0.1306448877,
0.3305206001,
-0.4697622657,
0.958065629,
0.2012834698,
-1.0065473318,
0.584333539,
-0.2686373591,
-0.5122773647,
0.2877405584,
-0.5030850172,
-0.104405269,
0.3231246471,
-0.0164854843,
0.3525387347,
-0.0425723568,
0.337049216,
-0.1756578535,
-0.4583681226,
0.1950343251,
-0.3289411962,
0.7980675697,
0.1632930487,
-0.5648803115,
0.2655854523,
-0.5458663702,
0.026254382,
0.1491893381,
-0.1681186557,
-0.6246680617,
0.008887847,
-0.0811716914,
0.0952871889,
0.0413741805,
-0.6181374192,
-0.1204940826,
-0.4744333923,
0.3206386268,
0.7339325547,
-0.4673114121,
0.3648676276,
0.0250207242,
0.5454751849,
0.11198733,
0.0210721456,
-0.1882663816,
-0.600673914,
-0.4416080117,
-0.3672362268,
0.2969605327,
0.4512129426,
-0.5753554106,
0.644530654,
-0.0745990127,
-0.229789257,
-0.4855003357,
-0.1760919243,
0.5305500031,
0.6570256352,
0.5333833098,
-0.4235153496,
-0.2699140906,
-0.8215916157,
-0.2772313654,
-0.2156786472,
0.2032110691,
0.1100376621,
0.5052938461,
-0.111933738,
1.1261812449,
-0.2596262991,
-0.0547307618,
-0.2809003592,
0.0963188484,
-0.1837735772,
0.3870358765,
0.4684579968,
-0.9283026457,
-0.5462822914,
-0.1074479222,
-0.770578146,
0.0777938962,
0.11697492,
0.0001221521,
-0.0966381431,
0.7268940806,
-0.4166608453,
0.7922340631,
0.5921952724,
-0.7022777796,
0.3799006343,
-0.3024298847,
-0.290483743,
-0.7098093033,
0.0165780354,
-0.2289626896,
-0.4382597506,
-0.7489755154,
0.0796360597,
0.2513137162,
0.2281300426,
-0.6022310853,
0.7584114075,
-0.4687457383,
-0.4578921199,
-0.1308507621,
0.4075751007,
0.0304543804,
0.2926495373,
0.040049348,
0.6555592418,
0.5378482342,
-0.2548125684,
0.0661678091,
0.5091739893,
-0.6218264103,
0.380404681,
-0.710069418,
0.0752695203,
-0.4829000235,
0.2464966923,
-1.0178937912,
-0.0403486192,
0.5131881833,
-0.0464442149,
0.3292428255,
-0.0771612599,
-0.3571282625,
-0.2047661543,
-0.2144420743,
0.7245286107,
0.419901967,
-0.5191039443,
0.3034490943,
0.3312250078,
0.1674333662,
-0.7602573633,
-0.6223701239,
-0.2476029396,
-0.2549258769,
-0.5096096992,
0.5580316782,
-0.0492457934,
-0.3689672947,
0.1760561168,
-0.217026785,
-0.0157340523,
0.107163772,
0.3040713668,
0.2730501294,
-0.121529609,
0.4027338922,
-0.1187207624,
-0.0529557802,
-0.3802530468,
-0.2640742064,
0.8673855662,
-0.3266921341,
-0.7971292734,
-0.3913399875,
0.2288237065,
0.3412944376,
-0.4690151215,
0.925296247,
0.9453905821,
-0.2637939751,
0.2161672115,
-0.5815501809,
0.0293875281,
-0.4624464512,
0.3651747704,
-0.4782502055,
-1.1436718702,
0.5248522162,
0.07892479,
-0.0726326331,
0.4332879186,
0.3933103085,
-0.1088014692,
0.9034627676,
0.424297601,
0.0989714935,
0.4021120369,
0.0960804299,
0.1108000204,
-1.1163318157,
-0.1851308793,
-0.3633187115,
-0.4950121641,
-0.7005164623,
-0.4801443517,
0.3411234915,
0.1086637974,
-0.0481033437,
-0.035278894,
-0.184702158,
0.6194822192,
0.4627928436,
-0.2463868558,
-0.0538684838,
0.0537045039,
-0.3714598715,
-0.0385489166,
-0.7035329938,
-0.4518161714,
0.7860821486,
0.3553749919,
0.2216431499,
0.0167348832,
0.732262671,
0.1610152721,
0.4731084406,
-0.7022678256,
0.1684085131,
-0.1551620662,
-0.8388231993,
-0.4601690471,
-0.4726720452,
-1.093770504,
0.7056027055,
-0.1568761468,
-0.8115060329,
0.2769065201,
0.0613227449,
-0.4089061618,
0.3608547449,
-0.5380132198,
1.1347250938,
0.0173124429,
-0.1032393947,
0.146918714,
-0.9342054129,
-0.065797098,
-0.0476833768,
0.4588598609,
-0.3730937541,
0.0984204859,
0.8495441079,
-0.4169027507,
0.7206340432,
-0.3262319267,
-0.0527164154,
0.4007235467,
0.1307418644,
0.2935580611,
-0.1151025146,
-0.152911514,
0.2621331215,
0.2648069859,
-0.5945205688,
-0.2653803825,
0.222722739,
-0.6099203229,
-0.5758879781,
-0.3257329166,
-0.5287148952,
-0.2818011343,
0.1460564733,
0.4345901906,
0.7721614838,
-0.129665181,
0.3020175397,
0.3746712506,
-0.3255062103,
0.5549314022,
0.0954797938,
-0.0531623363,
-0.1286246479,
0.5632805228,
0.0019662404,
0.1780798435,
0.0948564634,
0.5150120258,
-0.347517699,
-0.6766958237,
-0.477276057,
0.3820429742,
-0.8761473298,
0.0250536334,
-0.2464119941,
-0.0676123351,
-0.3504197598,
-0.2722652256,
-0.5202131271,
-0.1235209033,
-0.0819199458,
-0.0567694642,
-0.1862972975,
0.8725091815,
0.0477777086,
0.4819720387,
-0.8125443459,
0.1950916797,
0.188116774,
0.2461484075,
-0.024972545,
-0.658665359,
0.0452713035,
-0.1117428765,
0.2188158184,
-1.1244360209,
0.2312962413,
0.1281900853,
0.4654523134,
0.6056910753,
-0.0470267273,
1.0127220154,
-0.7700859904,
0.6368968487,
0.2847013772,
-1.120306015,
0.1451054811,
-0.1301225424,
0.2875599265,
0.6632803082,
0.3792573512,
-0.7708436847,
-0.2332422435,
-0.5043681264,
-0.8723880649,
0.6552106142,
0.1062450483,
0.3486714363,
-0.5927972198,
0.4959382117,
0.186437428,
0.4696994424,
-0.7864018083,
-0.4416286349,
-0.126819849,
-0.2977893054,
0.0170273818,
-0.4176711738,
-0.1700189859,
-0.2929531932,
0.1517800242,
0.0780849829,
-0.0035037857,
0.3103336096,
-0.5521655083,
0.0596371107,
0.1558310688,
0.5881180763,
1.0040047169,
-0.192929104,
0.703014195,
0.0209095292,
-0.3831381202,
0.0491054431,
-0.2070820332,
-0.0273697451,
0.1089455485,
0.8111047745,
0.961397469,
0.1412770897,
-0.8027840257,
0.8139061928,
0.1536268294,
0.0245130882,
-0.0789824799,
-0.3309138715,
0.0060398919,
0.4685267508,
0.1766848117,
-0.0798578411,
-0.208457306,
-0.5475319028,
0.1531774998,
0.6864205003,
-0.5347775817,
-0.4112194479,
0.25805071,
-0.1058579609,
-0.3410358727,
0.7314859033,
-0.6291334629,
-0.6560750604,
0.3597328365,
0.7423513532,
0.4980715811,
-0.3106568754,
0.2516373396,
0.0070162397,
0.2556375563,
0.1169942319,
0.1085344851,
-0.1164498627,
-1.0440331697,
-0.1530410349,
-0.7974548936,
-0.0150753362,
-0.0527174175,
-0.6867960691,
-0.186493516,
-0.4307856858,
-0.2126279771,
-0.1266927272,
-0.5652144551,
-0.8136333227,
0.1044389978,
0.3384994566,
0.4998679459,
-0.8409542441,
0.6254598498,
0.7261221409,
0.0150520988,
-0.6666901708,
0.0462569073,
0.0135290902,
-0.9773340225,
0.8561289907,
0.3743091822,
-0.1535609812,
0.0508894213,
-0.1769235879,
-0.7995741367,
1.0199602842,
0.1685792953,
-0.3910425007,
0.0446086675,
0.2474624813,
0.3995506167,
-0.331917882,
0.1878500879,
0.552403152,
0.4619961977,
0.2856433094,
-0.8195974827,
-0.0687237605,
-0.1156326383,
-0.0442223735,
0.2468847185,
-0.2498551458,
0.9142168164,
0.1484315544,
-0.4002506435,
-0.1670161337,
0.5767854452,
0.2063193917,
0.379196167,
0.8300492167,
0.444265902,
0.9899051189,
0.0431630649,
1.0932787657,
-0.3510173559,
0.2547004223,
1.2135709524,
-0.3380392492,
0.8905261755,
0.7969539762,
-0.2680438161,
0.3754296899,
0.7264873981,
0.1828880459,
0.4177918732,
0.2168682665,
-0.0603059679,
-0.4049663246,
-0.1864554286,
-0.4981215,
0.7016580105,
0.267961055,
-0.2227931023,
-0.232873708,
0.0726625994,
0.01146359,
-0.1593220979,
0.0988913625,
0.4246109426,
-0.0192487203,
-0.4066329002,
0.3536166549,
0.2868844271,
0.6712470651,
-0.6465177536,
0.4151351154,
-0.1414879262,
-0.2407085449,
-0.0367399156,
-0.3551276624,
0.4085991979,
-0.1536738873,
0.2725373209,
-0.2399854064,
0.557631731,
-0.328659296,
-0.2840887606,
0.2853837013,
0.8646622896,
0.1818460524,
0.0368418768,
-0.543445766,
0.1936234534,
-0.0567242429,
-0.4697538018,
0.2613784671,
0.2496707141,
-0.0450567491,
0.2730003893,
0.5022695065,
0.2015510201,
0.5173443556,
0.3714440465,
0.6378201842,
-0.5898968577,
-0.5089998841,
-1.0850949287,
0.4108101726,
0.0780408084,
-0.3782744706,
0.6526620984,
0.2348653823,
0.9292322993,
0.0792976692,
0.3441335261,
0.0245237164,
-0.1030615866,
-0.5782187581,
0.3334854245,
-0.7706295848,
0.167949751,
-0.2640593648,
-1.0422279835,
-0.5815626979,
1.2202142477,
-0.4641938806,
0.1440904588,
0.708658576,
0.4605498612,
-0.1602106243,
-0.0027886631,
0.3432970643,
-0.168676272,
0.1767607629,
-0.0266787186,
1.1250962019,
-0.1221340448,
-0.0670898408,
-0.1320363879,
-0.1743918359,
-0.0852660313,
-0.7432647943,
-1.0131511688,
-0.5588761568,
-0.2667318583,
0.092156738,
-0.1136891693,
1.161822319,
0.7121606469,
-0.4646046758,
-0.1006646231,
-0.0627154112,
0.1017683074,
0.0843778998,
-0.1382897943,
0.6608771682,
-0.4922308326,
-0.6212834716,
0.7173545361,
0.5538809299,
0.2237646133,
-0.1232646182,
-0.0676733553,
-0.190429762,
0.0190156363,
0.5169275999,
-0.0951163247,
-0.8056611419,
-0.5683704019,
-0.019877933,
-0.0827878043,
0.1615369618,
0.8840228915,
-0.436211586,
0.5645700693,
0.4421664178,
0.6083275676,
0.2923197448,
0.0209899321,
0.0953371972,
-1.1652514935,
0.7211773396,
0.0493480675,
0.5656780601,
0.2998180687,
-0.0009270583,
0.282033354,
0.3846336007,
0.0581863038,
-0.8193467259,
0.5236201286,
-0.5994743705,
-0.5726584196,
1.1297233105,
-0.3157315254,
-0.2007683963,
-0.2174143791,
0.2253587395,
0.4514523447,
0.3537674546,
0.5688064694,
0.8197587729,
-0.0681993961,
0.3107774258,
-0.3758910596,
0.4255624712,
0.7552527189,
-0.4576173127,
-0.0487995967,
0.3904663622,
0.078170903,
0.3020926118,
0.6807377934,
-0.1967560649,
-0.1255612075,
-0.0154648274,
-0.3299286366,
-0.1960267723,
-0.5253534913,
-0.3414831758,
0.298648119,
0.1478212178,
-0.1034858003
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16891v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16891v1
|
Survey on Reasoning Capabilities and Accessibility of Large Language Models Using Biology-related Questions
| 2024-05-11T20:25:40 | 2024-05-11T20:25:40 |
Michael Ackerman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This research paper discusses the advances made in the past decade in
biomedicine and Large Language Models. To understand how the advances have been
made hand-in-hand with one another, the paper also discusses the integration of
Natural Language Processing techniques and tools into biomedicine. Finally, the
goal of this paper is to expand on a survey conducted last year (2023) by
introducing a new list of questions and prompts for the top two language
models. Through this survey, this paper seeks to quantify the improvement made
in the reasoning abilities in LLMs and to what extent those improvements are
felt by the average user. Additionally, this paper seeks to extend research on
retrieval of biological literature by prompting the LLM to answer open-ended
questions in great depth.
|
[
-0.3086882532,
-0.854542017,
1.1161798239,
-0.2020759583,
0.0618778281,
-0.118234247,
-0.2387488931,
-0.8739495277,
0.1068156213,
0.5956096053,
-0.3368571997,
-0.3343171477,
-0.647433877,
0.5035550594,
-0.2669497132,
0.5272274017,
0.2177368402,
0.5926306248,
-0.5254914165,
-0.2880341709,
-0.0067134425,
-0.5885155201,
-0.5300136209,
-0.4190613031,
0.8018260598,
0.1866038293,
0.5845758319,
0.3916998208,
0.6956292987,
0.2969392538,
-0.5435684919,
0.1009378359,
0.0360749364,
0.2607838511,
-0.5854337811,
-0.609074235,
-0.6650394797,
-0.0114038829,
0.7201198339,
1.0342704058,
0.2689724863,
0.1992804408,
-0.0810967237,
0.6821629405,
-0.4433960617,
-0.0132506518,
-0.3691268563,
0.0598006286,
-0.0916770548,
-0.3290236294,
-0.4741968513,
-0.4687612057,
0.3067950606,
-0.3001067042,
-0.0680278838,
-0.1651350409,
0.3309462965,
-0.0430435017,
-0.6206314564,
-0.4822955132,
-0.5927541852,
0.8117778897,
-0.9340561032,
0.644374609,
0.4305568933,
0.2402287275,
-0.3221677542,
-0.7368760705,
-0.2314033508,
-0.6596429348,
0.0310683995,
-0.0474870093,
-0.3383426666,
0.1287636012,
0.3516559303,
0.3948897421,
-0.5491372943,
0.2522386014,
-0.4570772946,
-0.2243513912,
0.6082540751,
0.0688732043,
0.3803609908,
-0.0682804734,
0.1270440817,
0.0974666253,
-0.5599153042,
0.098789975,
0.1267420202,
-0.0040068813,
0.3118780553,
0.896099627,
-0.2252580076,
0.8761780262,
-0.5637270808,
-0.1431231797,
0.0754379183,
-0.7919895649,
-0.1686365306,
-0.3631869555,
0.390227288,
0.3425564468,
0.0579035804,
0.0591756888,
0.1624480039,
-0.4829562008,
0.1264287233,
-0.5665361881,
0.0089387558,
0.4769595861,
-0.6947868466,
-0.0093609747,
-0.2506456673,
-0.8402215242,
-0.6145539284,
-0.2651582062,
0.30398193,
-0.2659578919,
-0.1943362951,
0.2523430288,
-0.2526685596,
0.4482751787,
0.5090870857,
-0.5802958012,
0.0718501285,
0.556532681,
0.827711165,
-0.2381195724,
0.1648764312,
-0.2624960542,
0.0196706541,
-0.1153292805,
1.0050911903,
-0.5116574168,
-0.5357983112,
-0.0888536349,
0.131902054,
0.0196859799,
-0.7666789889,
0.2452609986,
-0.4371194243,
0.3193188906,
-0.5513781309,
-0.4300599396,
-0.353697747,
0.3140479922,
-0.5725610852,
0.5443646908,
-0.0816692859,
-0.7315670252,
0.0227112975,
-0.9136507511,
-0.1916684657,
0.178170383,
-0.167355001,
-0.1806410998,
-0.050628785,
0.2804648876,
0.4643998444,
-0.5600867271,
0.424456656,
-0.4855576754,
-0.0783235282,
0.7185610533,
-0.298276633,
1.1465508938,
0.3040804267,
-0.0234494079,
0.2061975747,
-0.598937571,
0.1026695818,
-0.0942776278,
-0.475687623,
-0.277205348,
0.0054526441,
-0.3856007159,
-0.0859711021,
0.4682093263,
-0.6970089674,
0.5976698995,
-0.4583956897,
0.7029975653,
0.2295441329,
0.1770137697,
0.5046001077,
-0.2929326892,
0.573339045,
-0.1763379276,
0.2364940047,
-0.2208539546,
-0.7502009273,
-0.3985985518,
-0.0879478902,
0.2104381919,
0.5793955326,
-0.5572342277,
0.1284775585,
-0.0205430612,
-0.4864670932,
-0.306343019,
0.0404404886,
0.03049252,
0.5712201595,
0.5185604095,
-0.1835959107,
-0.4687701166,
-0.9990231991,
-0.1020631269,
-0.4648438692,
-0.1235263348,
0.7511670589,
0.7082246542,
-0.3618350029,
0.7925091982,
-0.6609165072,
0.3300095499,
-0.532302022,
-0.0478198752,
0.2251428962,
0.3828559816,
0.4553859532,
-0.782889843,
0.1440288574,
0.1388459504,
-0.8347188234,
-0.3349115551,
0.3232119679,
-0.074471876,
0.1426902115,
0.7218621969,
-0.6602315307,
0.3732520342,
0.4417735934,
-0.3145864606,
0.6522416472,
-0.2787186801,
0.3696901202,
-0.9580671787,
0.363155812,
0.0163526833,
-0.0407971293,
-0.7721136808,
0.1724991649,
0.0810245723,
-0.0713123903,
-0.258634299,
0.7520845532,
-0.5319646597,
-0.266513288,
-0.1347572356,
-0.0209077597,
-0.0869090259,
-0.1359788775,
0.0438132584,
0.8055980802,
0.5834205747,
-0.7130514979,
0.3363801837,
0.1753831059,
-0.2715295851,
0.262424618,
-0.6677138209,
-0.0480521433,
-0.2230925858,
0.4904005527,
-1.0849570036,
-0.4936311841,
0.3256234527,
-0.6674816012,
0.0570916757,
0.2243295163,
-0.2736643851,
-0.7708556652,
-0.1762008667,
0.3884026706,
0.5012106299,
-0.2658152282,
0.4564136565,
0.3917345405,
-0.4474283457,
-0.3669667542,
-0.8507276773,
0.1555239707,
-0.0818564966,
-0.5923336744,
-0.1216588095,
-0.3016290069,
-0.6201690435,
-0.217495963,
-0.0343535505,
-0.2378021181,
0.0397757217,
-0.2402915806,
0.2306937128,
-0.3118663728,
0.4604284465,
0.0319354609,
0.2791265845,
0.3131381869,
-0.3775812089,
0.2314846665,
0.1220702007,
-0.4219299853,
-0.0520434417,
0.3759834468,
0.510733366,
-0.4019840658,
0.5174124241,
0.2199714482,
-0.2728008628,
0.1719240099,
-0.6495665312,
-0.3193432689,
-0.3736949265,
0.4178880453,
0.1043080911,
-1.3286072016,
0.5255073309,
-0.2699733078,
0.0201560259,
0.2597290874,
0.5876876116,
-0.1988963932,
1.0658513308,
0.4008874595,
0.3780359626,
0.2258833051,
-0.1808862239,
0.086067684,
-0.8765644431,
-0.5058654547,
-0.9510836005,
-0.120863989,
-0.3724636137,
-0.8532263041,
0.5475988984,
0.029213002,
-0.0764127672,
0.185394302,
-0.443529129,
0.1384616494,
0.4798732102,
0.3605689704,
0.4397166669,
-0.2965263426,
-0.4496074617,
0.3040781319,
-0.6568826437,
-0.5659605861,
0.9856828451,
0.5445479155,
0.4960610271,
0.308742255,
0.4576482177,
0.0305171981,
0.325969547,
-0.9397791028,
0.8190943599,
0.0357481539,
-0.9631252289,
-0.5998502374,
-0.5436832309,
-1.1629498005,
0.1775055379,
-0.0088343415,
-1.0078228712,
0.3281986117,
0.069890216,
-0.1700583696,
0.4622492194,
-0.464081347,
0.534928441,
-0.382923007,
-0.3117752969,
-0.0986101925,
-0.7344557643,
0.4870124757,
0.019470131,
0.2322168499,
-0.0052901902,
-0.2021726519,
0.632686317,
-0.2076615393,
0.6010785699,
-0.0561893061,
-0.2725581825,
0.4911667407,
-0.1630574763,
0.0204465445,
0.0654541403,
-0.3145836294,
0.0293343086,
0.1505909115,
-0.4662106335,
-0.499453634,
0.5512099266,
-0.3627287447,
-0.9504769444,
-0.4346922934,
-0.7066137791,
-0.4061457813,
0.1339481771,
0.0835475028,
0.3568713665,
0.0019134559,
0.583812654,
0.8816574216,
-0.9257235527,
0.3957093656,
0.6623364091,
-0.5999797583,
-0.4122422934,
0.3210541308,
0.2328713983,
0.340334326,
0.466501534,
0.3319284618,
-0.5738795996,
-0.7324183583,
-0.3510614038,
0.4601252675,
-0.5818856955,
-0.1548102647,
-0.8447469473,
-0.2145281434,
-0.662683785,
-0.0311189909,
0.2369741797,
-0.430339694,
-0.4011963904,
-0.0686148927,
0.5097900033,
0.8568690419,
-0.0697384998,
-0.0457590036,
-0.8669810891,
0.1494080275,
0.3089105487,
0.3130214512,
0.0575697012,
-0.4811852872,
-0.1529804468,
-0.0313773975,
-0.1727382839,
-1.3558866978,
0.3570066094,
-0.1168552563,
0.8234291673,
0.0635323673,
-0.4254626632,
0.3454557061,
-0.2161463499,
1.093926549,
0.0404982679,
-0.4374474883,
0.7241367102,
-0.5867456794,
0.7559266686,
0.4095686674,
0.7437649965,
-0.2952741385,
-0.2341115922,
-0.37979877,
-0.5290061831,
0.3550241292,
-0.0573930144,
-0.1953295171,
0.0461918898,
0.4899416268,
0.045440767,
0.0202492531,
-0.4785960615,
-0.0445809625,
0.2650499642,
0.0447369069,
-0.0736938342,
-0.2381106764,
0.0392522626,
-0.7928133607,
0.4642176926,
-0.3453744054,
0.3956559896,
0.3811909258,
-0.0044489177,
0.0132979117,
0.7352631688,
0.5723164082,
0.889708221,
-0.1571588665,
0.1087762788,
0.4488686025,
-0.5202969313,
0.1933476031,
0.1956156492,
-0.1202035621,
-0.2472378463,
0.5564422011,
0.3220032156,
0.176746428,
-1.0300965309,
0.2613408864,
0.1988223344,
-0.406304419,
-0.0528579652,
0.1048749238,
0.5588333011,
0.4640571773,
0.4627439082,
-0.078154169,
0.5200847387,
-0.6754280329,
0.0516082235,
0.5360687971,
-0.279412955,
0.0340668447,
0.6582009196,
-0.0503638722,
-0.208374083,
0.350140959,
0.1875399947,
-0.2953773439,
0.7621904612,
0.6359517574,
0.6045129895,
-0.2819200158,
0.2493177801,
0.5157200694,
0.0785782859,
-0.2115750611,
0.5898478031,
0.0030778984,
-0.5491111875,
-0.6456440687,
-0.6687333584,
-0.7254925966,
0.3712610304,
-0.5928307772,
0.0216280241,
-0.3156446218,
-0.4044755697,
0.3127840161,
-0.0375307836,
-0.3119983375,
0.2181519568,
-0.0213435721,
1.282684803,
-0.4195043445,
0.8481720686,
1.228085041,
-0.5253939033,
-0.5328707695,
-0.1582690924,
-0.0003403129,
-0.5464732647,
0.6771814227,
0.0407943577,
-0.0296295695,
-0.1052220091,
-0.9434720278,
-0.9624027014,
1.1842120886,
0.1781949699,
-0.4833612144,
-0.03842628,
0.0329701453,
0.8304094076,
-0.2126115113,
0.3517203331,
0.6445747614,
0.6344748139,
0.1200138927,
-1.0326670408,
-0.2324459106,
-0.2898896039,
-0.1739560366,
0.0997294486,
-0.4315347373,
0.8141847253,
-0.2365177572,
0.0100051137,
0.4043470919,
0.6039741635,
0.3388106525,
0.6963942647,
0.1948575526,
0.3065725863,
0.8585178852,
-0.1218935326,
1.0997840166,
0.0723482892,
0.0026022389,
0.6639672518,
-0.2196559608,
0.8141499162,
0.408210218,
-0.4959791899,
0.4078716636,
0.4474202394,
0.0636212453,
-0.1267361641,
0.3715666831,
-0.4681277275,
-0.3043494821,
-0.3312961757,
-0.478734374,
0.3556183577,
0.5640673041,
-0.7369816303,
-0.0439956076,
0.3291811943,
-0.1041420549,
0.1798744798,
-0.5068182349,
0.7907797694,
0.1826019883,
-0.6555514336,
0.1570086181,
-0.117875956,
0.5567200184,
-0.6703855991,
-0.1225945354,
-0.3130075932,
-0.1533333361,
-0.1255865991,
-1.1469002962,
0.2319572717,
0.0695253462,
-0.0664120242,
-0.0944707096,
1.0766179562,
-0.3491357267,
-0.4253581464,
0.3291755319,
0.8477224112,
0.4563784599,
0.3245405853,
-0.541672647,
0.1056162193,
0.031949386,
-0.1834719032,
0.259663254,
0.1881277263,
-0.1700433642,
1.0371749401,
0.5530416369,
0.4061949551,
-0.0535743237,
-0.0612132773,
0.8475837708,
-0.937746346,
0.0707992464,
-0.7120921612,
0.1883245111,
-0.15089266,
-0.1560929865,
0.6349808574,
0.5716429949,
0.5640751719,
-0.1689730585,
0.859064877,
-0.0706958473,
0.9285065532,
-0.4694550037,
0.5567762852,
-0.6804463863,
0.2137476951,
-0.2472753972,
-0.7652768493,
-0.6122540832,
0.4581829906,
-0.6427509189,
0.2357928753,
0.8563886881,
0.8400387764,
0.1897552609,
0.1847454458,
0.2937599123,
0.3785967529,
0.2628743052,
0.4794012606,
0.8964898586,
0.0153709427,
0.2492896467,
0.0910279378,
-0.264775306,
-0.2096642703,
-0.9207878113,
-0.658382833,
-0.4645660818,
-0.1698950827,
-0.329439193,
0.2405210286,
0.9527016282,
0.2347244024,
-0.9290305972,
-0.2067299038,
0.0614639334,
0.1271532476,
-0.0020228566,
-0.1653911024,
0.1752714366,
-0.1049069315,
-0.6620645523,
0.5336841941,
0.4563294649,
0.1926476955,
-0.5227341652,
0.0366878957,
-0.6177178621,
0.2921368182,
0.8321727514,
0.60120368,
-0.6840000153,
-0.2062585354,
0.4113205075,
-0.2502191961,
0.0093620177,
0.8716975451,
-0.6856541038,
0.3782553375,
0.8007879257,
0.7786415219,
0.1866984963,
-0.0461166315,
0.6697516441,
-0.1032117978,
-0.305205822,
0.2827460766,
0.3504871726,
0.4202350676,
-0.3129519522,
0.7310273051,
0.1841870397,
-0.8550018072,
-0.7101083398,
0.2355876267,
-1.1296459436,
-0.6678655744,
1.3851611614,
0.1170526072,
-0.0415975712,
-0.3314001858,
-0.4830398262,
0.2158767581,
-0.0427303053,
0.3218750656,
0.8155815601,
-0.6510907412,
-0.3739705682,
-0.8503859043,
0.3051979542,
0.413279444,
-1.2547290325,
-0.1541489065,
0.807156086,
0.1681306213,
-0.0168889649,
0.691899538,
-0.5397919416,
0.2716912627,
-0.3810943961,
-0.1688884199,
0.1534044892,
-0.2207482457,
-0.525950551,
0.184709996,
0.446896404,
0.5702748299
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07081v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07081v1
|
T-curator: a trust based curation tool for LOD logs
| 2024-05-11T19:32:27 | 2024-05-11T19:32:27 |
Dihia Lanasri
|
cs.DB
|
cs.DB, cs.CL
|
Nowadays, companies are racing towards Linked Open Data (LOD) to improve
their added value, but they are ignoring their SPARQL query logs. If well
curated, these logs can present an asset for decision makers. A naive and
straightforward use of these logs is too risky because their provenance and
quality are highly questionable. Users of these logs in a trusted way have to
be assisted by providing them with in-depth knowledge of the whole LOD
environment and tools to curate these logs. In this paper, we propose an
interactive and intuitive trust based tool that can be used to curate these LOD
logs before exploiting them. This tool is proposed to support our approach
proposed in our previous work Lanasri et al. [2020].
|
[
-0.2413880527,
-0.7470864058,
0.6375847459,
-0.1471433491,
-0.595734179,
0.2413354516,
0.4125335217,
-0.6768858433,
0.5269076824,
0.7830759287,
-0.6840444207,
-0.9699803591,
-0.4978295863,
-0.2335436195,
-0.7144072652,
1.4838079214,
0.2115771323,
-0.5175653696,
-0.2954099774,
-0.3844707608,
-0.2821085751,
-0.1967153549,
-0.8697531819,
-0.1975918412,
0.5690933466,
0.2053530812,
1.0581542253,
0.5597721338,
0.3746405542,
0.1442084908,
-0.1388616264,
0.3774340451,
-1.0075602531,
0.5642546415,
-0.786073029,
-0.3864491582,
-0.7246860266,
0.0766696781,
0.0840438604,
0.4911421835,
-0.0514776148,
0.4401331544,
-0.207673952,
0.3783414364,
-0.6227111816,
0.1069228575,
-0.5955764055,
0.4170358479,
-0.4967843592,
-0.4225850403,
-0.4096721709,
-0.507670939,
0.280562073,
-0.8441191316,
0.1356481165,
0.7097033858,
0.6728936434,
0.2401085347,
-0.4103503227,
-0.116861254,
-0.5735179782,
0.5779181719,
-0.3615024686,
0.3215979338,
0.5135878325,
0.3148418367,
-0.0246399175,
-0.8756535649,
-0.2040778995,
0.0942798033,
-0.3653810322,
-0.1801211536,
0.0973125175,
-0.4677130282,
0.195735082,
0.6888791919,
-0.4145657718,
0.3050572872,
-0.1358747184,
-0.2777369618,
0.6054954529,
0.3780094683,
0.0853300244,
0.1071585268,
-0.5298621655,
-0.201534614,
-0.9226732254,
-0.1197780073,
0.3543384671,
0.0500130169,
0.068381384,
0.9367665052,
-0.3398840129,
0.7199207544,
0.379984796,
-0.0064132027,
0.0054470887,
-0.3753933609,
-0.101894103,
0.2680720091,
0.8765707612,
0.4571596384,
-0.0098184813,
-0.4222975969,
-0.1319384873,
-0.124253951,
0.2724145353,
-0.6740444899,
-0.2691841722,
0.4927741885,
-0.4354530275,
-0.7810565829,
0.5653679967,
-0.9028499126,
-0.8049889207,
0.3635849953,
0.4960252643,
-0.2556065917,
-0.3965369165,
0.2768677771,
-0.3196173012,
-0.2719651759,
0.3892737627,
-0.2575546503,
0.1404362172,
0.7293434143,
0.7515689135,
-0.525544703,
0.0782714039,
-1.4333900213,
0.7514973879,
-0.1063841507,
0.4708815813,
-0.5530169606,
-0.9920722842,
0.1432075202,
-0.0643941313,
0.5287985206,
-0.2274531722,
0.8193688989,
-0.9395059347,
0.4604040682,
-0.0934458598,
-0.5511230826,
-0.0025544488,
0.3979993761,
-1.0778751373,
1.2216415405,
0.423568815,
-1.0639265776,
0.5422707796,
-0.9455712438,
-0.1807032973,
0.2198762298,
0.1279862672,
-0.431514293,
-0.0525989868,
0.3460475504,
0.4477008283,
-0.0135247204,
0.3061036766,
-0.6623513103,
-0.0144318836,
0.2509169877,
0.0656570494,
1.0779086351,
0.4137413204,
-0.0432258211,
0.0416948423,
-0.4135767221,
0.1313818246,
-0.091308631,
0.1367091388,
-0.4997529387,
0.0161549412,
-0.0085044447,
-0.0169828292,
0.4007164538,
-0.6649529934,
0.1217559874,
-0.1489017457,
0.1488441676,
0.8569073081,
0.4402908981,
0.2187764943,
-0.3164640963,
0.5341575742,
0.4123977423,
0.4476938844,
0.0518302247,
-0.3903829157,
-0.5253784657,
0.0978464261,
0.1147747263,
0.1851674765,
-0.5191655755,
0.5596246719,
-0.4747837186,
-0.7653616071,
-0.5608875155,
0.0913050324,
0.3899250925,
0.5697836876,
0.1865852475,
-0.8241016269,
0.0323128402,
-0.5217534304,
-0.2340924442,
-0.2373064756,
-0.1304216683,
0.4692736268,
0.2214871496,
-0.1212008893,
1.1534769535,
-0.8897310495,
-0.5287380815,
0.352212429,
-0.0668428615,
0.274120152,
0.4914801121,
0.4889583588,
-0.6915528774,
-0.4391246438,
0.308850497,
-0.7684264183,
-0.0829718485,
0.3432092667,
-0.6840554476,
0.091091983,
0.3515848815,
-0.9011305571,
0.6213421226,
0.4603748322,
-1.1278340816,
0.5940382481,
0.2269639969,
0.2163930833,
-0.996558249,
0.1158335805,
-0.2862469852,
-0.5595932007,
-0.2050638199,
0.2847010493,
-0.1259240061,
-0.3357415497,
-0.4151922762,
0.7110103965,
-0.169479087,
-0.2255429924,
0.4905968308,
0.4404606521,
0.4015313685,
-0.0688089877,
0.0792716146,
0.3070822358,
0.6260390878,
-0.4766429961,
0.5699234009,
0.7131186724,
-0.3103843331,
1.2010512352,
-0.662977159,
0.1936153919,
0.3201285303,
0.1818750352,
-0.5372511148,
0.0037676054,
0.3751684725,
-0.5361530781,
0.2563982606,
-0.486207515,
-0.5078998208,
-0.1061883792,
-0.343049556,
0.2661468089,
0.2994137406,
-0.8381880522,
0.5971645713,
0.2883226275,
0.1703529805,
-0.440266788,
-0.5180336237,
0.0206209235,
-0.5181991458,
-0.9371703267,
0.2432437986,
-0.2889422178,
-0.5742627978,
0.5490887165,
-0.4985396266,
-0.1592108309,
-0.0585824251,
0.5492982268,
0.2133894116,
-0.2709707916,
-0.0466538891,
-0.0478409342,
-0.1056758836,
0.2013830841,
-0.649776876,
0.1905356348,
0.1433627456,
-0.9153593183,
-0.4206677675,
0.1824803352,
0.7697771192,
-0.436761409,
0.8979433775,
0.8196268678,
-0.000767226,
-0.255438149,
-0.7254613042,
-0.2432979941,
-0.5209764242,
-0.3339127004,
-0.1165987253,
-1.0588709116,
0.3954704106,
-0.0469028577,
0.1157853603,
0.4222359061,
0.2115355581,
-0.104549177,
0.5565186739,
0.4204116166,
-0.1503565311,
0.2077013105,
-0.2098912895,
0.4319327474,
-0.6599562168,
-0.6776894927,
-0.6057648063,
-0.1629388183,
-0.3590345681,
-0.4125689268,
0.6852399707,
-0.0611859299,
-0.1467786431,
0.0080153793,
-0.3155491054,
0.4431687891,
0.6044502258,
0.4242665172,
0.9375247359,
-0.2167894691,
0.2316032052,
0.367498666,
-0.2645694613,
-0.3645512462,
1.1313413382,
-0.0551390089,
1.1383378506,
0.0839039385,
0.9080563188,
0.8665726781,
-0.026209129,
-0.6420195103,
0.3724044561,
0.2756253481,
-0.7180269361,
-0.5287621021,
0.0233773291,
-0.7100480199,
-0.0079360278,
-0.3149937689,
-0.7004442811,
0.1116988808,
0.3013326526,
-0.1715051234,
0.696842134,
-0.6713134646,
0.6789309382,
-0.0093486821,
-0.7609578371,
-0.3683280051,
-0.4530270994,
0.2186739743,
-0.2680496275,
0.0345284566,
0.235714525,
-0.0230028108,
0.5337951183,
-0.6766306758,
0.7133094668,
-0.3919783831,
-0.0404922441,
0.2960936725,
0.8768571615,
1.0818232298,
0.5582743883,
-0.3725764453,
0.0036197137,
0.203550905,
-0.3177361488,
-0.5080690384,
0.9002316594,
-0.4634458423,
-0.8485859632,
-0.3313045502,
-0.2066951394,
-0.3794413507,
0.4556778669,
-0.2183548063,
0.2645917535,
-0.629775703,
0.5510692,
0.9844874144,
-0.1543584913,
0.0949441567,
0.4500484765,
-0.3513925374,
0.0921786204,
0.2802263796,
-0.5899152756,
0.3598599136,
0.3161943555,
0.2013202161,
-0.3694957197,
-0.5631248951,
-0.265345782,
-0.0219235085,
-0.4381203949,
-0.5305939913,
-0.6820973158,
0.0456250831,
-0.1538042724,
-0.2732051909,
-0.2166250497,
-0.724437952,
-0.2995224595,
-0.6697112918,
1.026783824,
0.6380394101,
0.1566745788,
0.2234487534,
-0.7839404941,
0.191937685,
0.3467811644,
0.751745522,
-0.1569875181,
-0.0399719104,
-0.3757574856,
0.1023589969,
-0.2067244351,
-0.4388632476,
0.4369408488,
0.0543202683,
0.461127013,
0.9103845954,
0.5570712686,
0.4176181555,
-0.0216221698,
1.1380070448,
-0.0775880069,
-0.775568068,
0.8246253729,
-0.6558108926,
-0.3973045051,
0.3214310408,
0.48094064,
-0.3610806167,
-0.5185274482,
-0.914496243,
-0.3077471256,
0.7372534275,
0.0568138063,
-0.2475306839,
0.1155767813,
-0.027298145,
0.7132379413,
0.2978070378,
-0.3634893298,
-0.0950260833,
-0.5466910601,
0.223351419,
-0.0783286542,
-0.372400105,
-0.5231587887,
0.1795509756,
0.6345325112,
0.1013751253,
-0.146632567,
0.1520480514,
-0.0847268626,
-0.3448779583,
0.1075698808,
-0.4406069517,
0.8174723387,
-0.5741858482,
-0.0542025715,
-0.1435810179,
-0.2796663642,
-0.494574368,
-0.3656354547,
-0.2101617157,
-0.0705513284,
0.0900028944,
0.6621272564,
0.0508884564,
-0.5621674061,
0.5436312556,
0.2887343764,
0.0166495964,
-0.3427281082,
0.1992315948,
0.1513128728,
0.3383343816,
-0.0241693445,
-0.0913947299,
0.2230796367,
-0.3786641061,
0.0759529769,
0.4331365228,
-0.5546403527,
-0.3503834307,
0.7027683854,
0.310741663,
-0.267791003,
1.023611784,
0.0167878382,
-0.0387808681,
0.0671374127,
0.4482349753,
0.8593121171,
0.0120199202,
0.3610810935,
0.1267906874,
0.0813263133,
0.1866614521,
0.0103357146,
0.0407968126,
-0.7627162337,
-0.1844677329,
-0.6688735485,
-0.5754596591,
-0.1404242516,
-1.092386961,
0.2624663413,
-0.3920131922,
-0.0879690349,
-0.3080187142,
0.0554472059,
-0.8375245929,
0.0570455864,
-0.6638836861,
1.1646676064,
-0.8604080081,
0.8722122908,
0.3236346245,
-0.3003996313,
-0.2643128932,
-0.4937458038,
0.111527063,
-1.0057668686,
0.5299383402,
-0.4718173742,
-0.21300973,
-0.0315088183,
-0.6600720286,
-0.5088939071,
1.3788262606,
-0.243789494,
0.0786132663,
0.2456454933,
-0.1049829572,
0.7079414129,
-0.3486781418,
-0.1553440392,
0.1565858126,
0.6843149662,
0.2492778152,
-0.82483989,
0.3227615356,
-0.1736437827,
-0.3122213185,
0.3464740515,
-0.4475183487,
0.4956856966,
-0.2184180915,
-0.1796514839,
-0.0385679156,
0.3025807738,
0.1112863347,
0.5613566637,
0.5825256705,
0.9414909482,
0.696908474,
0.034757074,
1.1298646927,
-0.0374065004,
0.2148909867,
1.2415078878,
-0.2761657238,
0.7092638612,
0.7012159824,
-0.1228141561,
0.6955375671,
0.3209632337,
-0.2062385082,
0.5522720218,
-0.3455962539,
-0.4029551148,
-0.4202874005,
-0.7379925847,
-0.390183419,
0.0507337712,
0.6309392452,
-0.3524257541,
-0.1703802049,
-0.6517768502,
0.0206635743,
0.1318603903,
-0.3491154015,
0.6284913421,
-0.0214696787,
-0.4723108709,
-0.1505426168,
-0.3328903019,
0.4385871589,
-0.6650718451,
-0.0054234657,
-0.1417647153,
-0.2875444591,
-0.6013630629,
-1.2907429934,
0.4234396219,
-0.3337602317,
0.0767295137,
-0.5347752571,
0.748570919,
-0.1800360829,
0.2549587488,
0.1972434521,
0.8819265962,
-0.0005607377,
-0.1878779531,
-0.205799222,
-0.0200184267,
0.0643442348,
-0.0807559118,
0.3453786671,
0.8423960805,
-0.3565184474,
1.0638586283,
0.9579850435,
0.1074115932,
-0.1105941013,
-0.1125656888,
0.8571162224,
-0.5302575231,
-0.5817728639,
-0.4907422662,
0.4261533916,
-0.4232932031,
0.0394800752,
0.7328439355,
0.5391772985,
1.1155978441,
-0.4216133654,
0.5009181499,
-0.3349790573,
0.6679360271,
-0.5120783448,
0.827929914,
-0.2965947092,
0.2074259669,
-0.2047241628,
-0.920684278,
-0.0996098518,
0.1891378313,
0.0937817618,
-0.3409163952,
0.8616981506,
1.063757658,
-0.3268988132,
0.2289375663,
0.0917826593,
0.3490670323,
0.3555240631,
0.2594469786,
0.604937613,
-0.1931463927,
0.7650434971,
-0.2467069179,
0.1046465933,
-0.2286960334,
-1.3219467402,
-1.156635046,
-0.4841772616,
-0.3480693698,
-0.5096376538,
0.0330101401,
0.4859780967,
0.6621854305,
-0.8077622652,
0.0179978907,
0.4029397666,
0.467918545,
-0.1653214693,
-0.2855660319,
0.6223156452,
0.3792137504,
-0.4351658523,
0.161152184,
0.2838000953,
-0.0224290527,
-0.3055480421,
-0.1007215753,
0.1028270572,
-0.5309339166,
0.6773657203,
0.0952730998,
-0.5048826337,
-0.518525064,
-0.2564926744,
0.3334866166,
-0.2333103269,
0.659550488,
-0.9393892288,
0.5455331206,
0.512455523,
0.4645114839,
1.0259683132,
0.1833523214,
0.5633964539,
-0.7015464902,
-0.1113464534,
0.2551478446,
0.1584344506,
0.2540615201,
-0.8101565242,
0.9663526416,
0.0553501397,
-0.2858362198,
-0.7701666355,
0.2553024888,
-1.4988150597,
0.276386857,
0.8424168229,
-0.331835866,
0.0515084751,
-0.3239235282,
-0.2294664681,
-0.1813637465,
-0.7980821133,
0.8708354235,
0.5354700089,
0.0688003004,
0.2491482198,
-0.2310726196,
0.5613090396,
-0.0998469591,
-0.6865246296,
-0.1338046193,
0.8324384093,
0.3685752749,
0.0587709919,
0.5195077658,
-0.7165613174,
-0.0661373511,
-0.0910553038,
-0.5037798882,
-0.4949097633,
-0.0023755941,
0.4567113519,
0.2960915565,
0.3428668976,
-0.02328947
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07076v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07076v2
|
Integrating Emotional and Linguistic Models for Ethical Compliance in Large Language Models
| 2024-05-11T19:26:00 | 2024-05-14T03:08:12 |
Edward Y. Chang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
This research develops advanced methodologies for Large Language Models
(LLMs) to better manage linguistic behaviors related to emotions and ethics. We
introduce DIKE, an adversarial framework that enhances the LLMs' ability to
internalize and reflect global human values, adapting to varied cultural
contexts to promote transparency and trust among users. The methodology
involves detailed modeling of emotions, classification of linguistic behaviors,
and implementation of ethical guardrails. Our innovative approaches include
mapping emotions and behaviors using self-supervised learning techniques,
refining these guardrails through adversarial reviews, and systematically
adjusting outputs to ensure ethical alignment. This framework establishes a
robust foundation for AI systems to operate with ethical integrity and cultural
sensitivity, paving the way for more responsible and context-aware AI
interactions.
|
[
-0.3038306236,
-0.7992788553,
0.5723050833,
0.0953691378,
-0.0178555846,
0.2704254687,
-0.2417904139,
-0.3957307339,
-0.174725011,
0.5616582632,
-0.6595197916,
-0.4070080221,
-0.7235934734,
0.153863281,
-0.3613632023,
0.9770689011,
0.1312211454,
0.2863947451,
0.0943535343,
-0.2074740231,
0.0219592955,
-0.7405150533,
-0.6996514201,
-0.5336261392,
0.429882437,
0.1018018797,
0.8029841185,
0.6181319356,
0.590782702,
0.4141215384,
-0.2879216075,
-0.1948297024,
-0.7004021406,
0.0409961864,
-0.5198708177,
-0.289775908,
-0.5123586059,
0.2555258274,
0.1641299725,
0.2950109541,
-0.5424762368,
0.0525076278,
-0.0052087787,
0.7561118007,
-0.5698789358,
0.0805829763,
-0.4549021423,
0.1130418926,
0.0309967883,
-0.2482059151,
-0.4063791931,
-0.4332019091,
0.0035574804,
-0.7045031786,
-0.5912004113,
0.0068641328,
0.5590017438,
0.7380623817,
-0.8586711287,
-0.8106517792,
-0.5195010304,
0.9546353221,
-0.8934327364,
0.086277619,
0.567515254,
-0.1452127546,
-0.3284420073,
-0.5777752995,
-0.8127509952,
-0.1882624924,
-0.0557951331,
0.1814987957,
-0.3152197003,
0.202675119,
0.1956006289,
0.2449512631,
-0.1668116599,
0.4002284706,
-0.0433529988,
0.0368610956,
0.9397644401,
0.3203493655,
0.6357473731,
-0.0722354203,
-0.1353010833,
-0.1668819487,
-0.6769142747,
0.013248669,
0.8161275387,
0.055752445,
-0.203387782,
0.2587635219,
-0.0994930863,
0.312751919,
0.0924494937,
0.1089402959,
0.1629763693,
-0.031597659,
-0.2579159141,
0.2689231038,
0.9104070067,
0.5518804193,
0.6640263796,
0.2261828333,
0.0343771279,
0.1850125045,
0.5204543471,
-0.733664453,
-0.1566123217,
0.4209088981,
-0.5265348554,
-0.8366103172,
-0.2319086343,
-0.9762116671,
-0.8076004982,
-0.7466909885,
0.24033764,
-0.4616802037,
-0.6952016354,
0.3530349731,
0.1978999972,
0.2389262319,
0.2915011346,
-0.7917919159,
0.3001928926,
0.8345636725,
0.5104824901,
0.2675191462,
-0.2780779302,
-0.4427699149,
0.1666597724,
-0.5297551155,
-0.1828393936,
-0.8674197197,
-0.4580337703,
0.1535297185,
0.0217208136,
0.3625169694,
-0.0642956272,
0.4484302998,
-0.6775928736,
0.2230200469,
-0.3897442222,
-0.5537812114,
-0.5145100355,
0.2714927793,
-0.4320969582,
0.8083203435,
0.0503114946,
-0.673528254,
0.1063033789,
-0.973805964,
-0.5558137894,
0.1116358414,
-0.120547004,
-0.1920699179,
0.2133969218,
-0.1039419696,
0.548189044,
-0.3029242158,
0.4280890822,
-0.4531361461,
-0.2056589574,
0.2425889671,
-0.3151691556,
1.3354610205,
0.5360672474,
-0.6259362102,
0.1622252315,
-0.5881507397,
-0.0662905276,
0.2738597393,
-0.1042817011,
-0.6996617913,
0.1218155622,
0.1070316732,
0.2397413105,
0.2934999764,
-0.3520277441,
0.1409685463,
-0.1435273588,
0.7137311101,
1.2611792088,
-0.1800982952,
0.5026275516,
-0.0570563711,
0.5142672658,
-0.1268075109,
0.2871417999,
0.2287627161,
0.0293255411,
-0.5914000273,
-0.3612056971,
-0.1276765466,
0.6384732723,
-0.4201610386,
0.6102454066,
-0.0392049737,
-0.3335065842,
-0.6613386869,
0.1058292016,
0.3300774395,
0.4666002691,
0.0692410916,
-0.0393089503,
-0.2587513924,
-0.8442860246,
-0.1626378298,
-0.3875848353,
0.2043352127,
0.1352345347,
0.6405950785,
-0.3789274991,
0.644742012,
-0.1311085671,
-0.0249705035,
0.1045440957,
0.386633873,
-0.0123643456,
0.5335731506,
0.5176347494,
-1.156668067,
-0.5613157749,
0.1659341007,
-1.0793142319,
-0.0168549381,
-0.0310850106,
-0.2922046483,
0.088377133,
0.5314432979,
-0.3194159865,
0.3370119929,
0.5435348749,
-0.4190860689,
0.2150057703,
-0.0580747314,
0.6985991597,
-1.3370753527,
-0.0139674516,
-0.0674821436,
-0.2215501666,
-0.8156235218,
0.0668791607,
0.0906907693,
0.243972376,
-0.826300621,
0.3891810179,
-0.4391833544,
0.2594899535,
-0.3817248046,
-0.1102898866,
0.0776552483,
0.1587112695,
-0.0511621386,
0.612747252,
0.8395079374,
-0.7783138752,
0.7767053843,
0.4690486193,
-0.1884494424,
1.2822879553,
-0.5134889483,
0.2529115677,
-0.3309440315,
0.1154001579,
-0.4693985581,
-0.3738075197,
0.143227607,
-0.374438554,
0.4131112695,
-0.273424983,
-0.6996705532,
0.0177115016,
-0.4710100293,
0.1517069489,
0.845159471,
-0.3907622397,
0.8819806576,
0.6291821599,
-0.281132251,
-0.751642108,
-0.9346703291,
0.2686089873,
-0.6199558377,
-0.4613687992,
0.1649181098,
-0.1406451613,
-0.7059938312,
0.1742386669,
0.3476329148,
-0.0303498674,
0.5042747855,
0.1211440191,
0.1543247402,
0.0111217434,
-0.0597915351,
-0.0127279349,
0.0377405621,
0.2938755751,
0.0545435399,
0.3539147079,
-0.5394452214,
-0.430013448,
-0.5661212802,
0.4961274266,
0.8330006003,
-0.2008553296,
0.8500718474,
0.620187521,
-0.6064273119,
-0.0667963848,
-0.5210043788,
-0.2218730897,
-0.5630021691,
0.5859476924,
-0.1291047484,
-1.0635000467,
0.4745465815,
-0.1126020104,
0.0181027874,
0.228526637,
0.9938917756,
-0.2439434379,
1.064242959,
0.8427485228,
-0.3712187111,
0.5053830743,
0.1115953997,
0.3137303591,
-1.0127139091,
-0.0684441626,
-0.2187920809,
-0.4260080457,
-0.8504449129,
-0.0330523215,
0.1957015544,
0.0981130078,
-0.5033841729,
-0.0203603003,
-0.619331181,
0.6415164471,
0.4208621979,
-0.2821708918,
0.1430701464,
-0.2070827633,
0.1938876957,
0.1074379906,
-0.2713801861,
-0.9025989175,
0.9550324678,
0.4675545692,
1.1127436161,
0.4646751881,
0.5865354538,
0.5062355399,
0.4273976982,
-0.4344492257,
0.5721150041,
-0.1809665859,
-0.7801643014,
-0.2974942923,
-0.5037238598,
-0.7228090167,
-0.0124208881,
0.1151642352,
-1.1958934069,
0.0197650362,
0.0858351067,
-0.2622504234,
0.2538208067,
-0.5987863541,
0.7325616479,
-0.5906765461,
-0.4876051545,
-0.4956303835,
-0.785654664,
0.3746351302,
-0.0882788375,
0.3501026332,
-0.4038452506,
-0.0076997387,
0.4625122845,
-0.1243503019,
1.1155924797,
0.0157984272,
-0.1414435357,
0.20321244,
0.4404504597,
0.5864846706,
0.1534870714,
-0.3438541591,
0.3944275975,
0.1614717543,
-0.1486509889,
-0.3068320453,
1.0466808081,
-0.9427829981,
-0.5819119215,
-0.6295787096,
-0.6490542889,
-0.1768766046,
0.2265833765,
-0.0135827912,
-0.1396255791,
-0.2519567013,
0.3160533607,
0.9733964205,
-0.4891429543,
0.2872389257,
0.8159741163,
-0.0180852246,
-0.2170444876,
0.6028721929,
-0.2199731469,
0.2092112303,
0.0407364629,
0.4125233591,
-0.5084539056,
-0.2443549633,
-0.4224970043,
0.0377376564,
-1.0040166378,
-0.082290411,
-0.5169228911,
-0.1266397387,
-0.4486080706,
-0.5232883692,
-0.4418024719,
0.071950458,
-0.3671897948,
-0.2495849729,
0.90536654,
1.0425997972,
-0.1661335975,
0.3221645057,
-0.6792008281,
0.0806830451,
-0.1757528037,
0.4815634489,
-0.2128151655,
-0.6078523397,
0.1712224334,
0.0693746582,
-0.158068195,
-0.8068165183,
0.1969784647,
0.006115939,
0.6310830712,
0.0933236927,
0.3624563217,
0.529389143,
-0.4946684539,
0.5752082467,
0.1163931638,
-1.2930613756,
0.5411772132,
-0.4270965755,
-0.0722065121,
0.6201494336,
0.6244501472,
-0.7438592315,
-0.4030275941,
-0.4973305762,
-0.8732561469,
0.745203793,
0.2966125011,
0.4942070842,
0.0777184516,
0.4487235248,
-0.0465193912,
0.3686152995,
-0.8315463066,
0.0208986774,
-0.0380028561,
-0.9361026883,
-0.0408638418,
-0.1531506777,
-0.6558461785,
0.1151312888,
0.7313082218,
-0.0380849317,
-0.284847647,
0.0148780504,
-0.1508291364,
-0.0469499193,
0.274769634,
0.4972659647,
0.4973399937,
0.1635175049,
0.1029305086,
0.1792958528,
-0.2342159599,
0.4394115508,
-0.1291151047,
0.1452369094,
-0.6958811283,
0.1387202889,
0.3213614523,
-0.1983767599,
-0.5509004593,
0.5516012311,
-0.1395698935,
-0.1258849651,
-0.4599463642,
-0.1573062986,
0.3381992579,
0.3910911679,
-0.0993627831,
-0.3535201848,
0.3556434214,
-0.7083046436,
0.3267666101,
0.4496605694,
-0.2443607748,
-0.2680855393,
0.5943820477,
0.3895198703,
-0.1962094754,
0.6449953318,
-0.2293282449,
-0.7177852392,
0.6722511649,
0.1087266132,
0.8976553082,
-0.3884814978,
-0.0341249853,
-0.0109884115,
0.5086496472,
-0.3728707731,
0.2747723758,
0.2692751586,
-0.6470162272,
-0.4839687943,
-0.5384064317,
-0.5196467042,
0.1672965884,
-0.8415853381,
0.1685024947,
-0.6670620441,
-0.036115624,
-0.3010085523,
-0.1145260409,
-0.5535883904,
0.2896622121,
0.3587839603,
0.4806439877,
-0.7444773912,
0.7388869524,
0.7082976699,
-0.3098456562,
-0.5749714971,
-0.1030405387,
0.6340245605,
-0.7959912419,
0.6352832317,
0.1935782731,
-0.5627043843,
-0.0286684651,
-0.4703377783,
-0.7241874337,
0.8743435144,
0.4208164513,
-0.5924194455,
0.4334484637,
0.0615574643,
0.6814974546,
-0.3483456075,
0.0813815296,
0.4955170751,
0.439864248,
-0.1844543666,
-0.7211052775,
0.1461250037,
-0.2862454951,
-0.0937358662,
0.2951038182,
-0.929125011,
0.5080183148,
0.1529739499,
-0.0296535175,
-0.2837044895,
0.3053786159,
0.042914141,
0.2141484767,
0.5704703331,
0.4430009425,
0.8765484691,
-0.0472899601,
0.9546356201,
-0.6608712077,
0.3066015542,
0.8878971934,
-0.8051629663,
0.515378356,
0.5357021093,
0.0033253559,
0.3113830984,
0.7386160493,
0.1160325855,
0.3888035715,
0.5021227002,
-0.1212008521,
-0.0562842786,
-0.403437227,
-0.2546079159,
0.5663624406,
0.3961265087,
-0.1397341341,
0.2461091429,
-0.0080090864,
0.3220563531,
0.3784886897,
-0.2245853841,
0.8385304213,
0.1547417939,
-0.3888600469,
0.1319578439,
-0.0139530096,
0.8104139566,
-0.7083562613,
0.0505379066,
0.0875504166,
0.2812947929,
-0.2415419966,
-0.9457041025,
0.5020602345,
0.3751412332,
0.0394772962,
-0.5124857426,
0.3405418694,
-0.3348302245,
-0.5781171322,
0.6754103899,
0.1108320206,
0.0272552278,
0.0976155549,
-0.9473723173,
0.3872035146,
-0.116342105,
-0.6928800941,
0.408498913,
0.6589165926,
0.1206504777,
0.7823275328,
0.7101116776,
-0.1022592559,
-0.1353325546,
0.1750472486,
0.6454854608,
-0.6534312963,
-0.5800459385,
-1.4173295498,
0.7225263119,
-0.3435203135,
-0.2070602328,
0.5011147261,
0.1317471564,
0.8778415918,
0.3118349016,
0.8888453841,
-0.2912374735,
0.0489137061,
-0.6943956017,
0.9866062403,
-0.8011361957,
0.1708857715,
-0.260293752,
-0.4396318197,
-0.0706114471,
0.949980855,
-0.2832517326,
0.1450805217,
0.4078395665,
0.6272132397,
0.1750253737,
-0.0610427335,
0.496784091,
0.3020795584,
0.5726134777,
0.5647106171,
1.0096889734,
-0.0325887799,
0.3090513349,
-0.3318541348,
-0.4402737617,
-0.1781156808,
-1.4058051109,
-0.7190821767,
-0.4645463526,
-0.5587655902,
-0.2126860023,
0.0416382067,
0.9903922677,
0.7728538513,
-0.6324986815,
-0.2022992224,
-0.0712010562,
-0.0961302668,
-0.0327176414,
-0.2576906979,
0.003770544,
-0.1051475704,
-0.9232907295,
0.2068244815,
0.5414334536,
0.0468307771,
-0.412768513,
-0.3280593157,
-0.2214306295,
0.4822825193,
0.4127309322,
-0.0521272123,
-0.8329522014,
-0.4549135864,
-0.1153473035,
-0.3371468186,
-0.2413817197,
0.5920622349,
0.0683989972,
0.5224392414,
0.1812866479,
0.8270325065,
-0.102725327,
-0.0016520577,
0.8163143396,
-0.2947633862,
0.2247621715,
0.577626586,
0.5655210018,
0.4627230167,
-0.897493422,
0.6177873015,
-0.2513173223,
-0.7451512814,
-0.9257365465,
0.7621170878,
-0.7090141773,
-0.3217568398,
1.2348257303,
-0.3375041485,
-0.2061533779,
0.1097448915,
-0.0556074865,
0.2233662754,
-0.3220104575,
1.0082451105,
1.2319233418,
0.0321036465,
0.0260144211,
-0.7767535448,
0.5506517887,
0.5636648536,
-0.8614238501,
0.3721457124,
0.5507254601,
0.3982550204,
-0.0697084591,
0.4418946803,
-0.2694711983,
0.1764068604,
-0.1808460653,
0.2547801733,
-0.0890974998,
0.0453319922,
-0.4952353835,
-0.308172822,
-0.0031082665,
0.08434508
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13000v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13000v1
|
RAGE Against the Machine: Retrieval-Augmented LLM Explanations
| 2024-05-11T19:08:38 | 2024-05-11T19:08:38 |
Joel Rorseth, Parke Godfrey, Lukasz Golab, Divesh Srivastava, Jaroslaw Szlichta
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
This paper demonstrates RAGE, an interactive tool for explaining Large
Language Models (LLMs) augmented with retrieval capabilities; i.e., able to
query external sources and pull relevant information into their input context.
Our explanations are counterfactual in the sense that they identify parts of
the input context that, when removed, change the answer to the question posed
to the LLM. RAGE includes pruning methods to navigate the vast space of
possible explanations, allowing users to view the provenance of the produced
answers.
|
[
-0.5978159308,
-1.2626156807,
0.7505601048,
-0.2914328277,
-0.1638797522,
0.1739728153,
-0.0902605206,
-0.1070457697,
0.1760436296,
0.6597219706,
-0.8437549472,
-0.2975737154,
-0.5458905101,
-0.1547012031,
-0.9185462594,
1.1764276028,
-0.332213372,
-0.211249724,
-0.4378114641,
-0.0463866256,
-0.3403214812,
-0.7765463591,
-0.7032611966,
-0.5568628311,
1.0533930063,
0.227553606,
0.8104170561,
0.4312796295,
0.54481107,
0.4579898715,
0.0973105952,
-0.1907412559,
-0.8750091195,
0.489245832,
-0.4406999052,
-0.709466815,
-0.0525978096,
-0.0652075484,
0.6202821732,
0.2902382314,
0.088512972,
0.1267385781,
-0.3624932766,
0.8063095212,
-0.5330032706,
-0.2173902392,
-0.8964877129,
0.2629781663,
-0.2445090562,
-0.3566714525,
-0.405259937,
-0.3183507323,
-0.1729179323,
-0.3353535533,
0.1479156315,
0.1483188421,
0.9231648445,
0.5496582985,
-0.3843001723,
-0.5397365689,
-0.9075430036,
0.7629520893,
-0.1294447929,
0.161869958,
0.2008695006,
0.4105663598,
-0.2564994991,
-0.98283571,
-0.7528389692,
0.0353673995,
-0.0593446642,
0.3897988796,
-0.6746888161,
0.1540915966,
0.5000224113,
0.6157525182,
-0.5477837324,
0.0272530522,
-0.5144410133,
-0.1589387804,
0.6343584657,
0.3496918082,
0.6239035726,
0.0453948714,
-0.5923712254,
0.2833032608,
-0.9613496065,
-0.1214239597,
0.4666446149,
0.0710351244,
0.1730961949,
0.8928220868,
0.3068214059,
0.920737505,
0.2679848671,
0.0256380197,
-0.1580262482,
0.0871478021,
-0.5295812488,
0.13336128,
0.8071866632,
0.3020203114,
0.1801412702,
-0.3834398687,
-0.3727451563,
-0.1287680715,
0.6852729917,
-0.7868175507,
-0.0229246672,
0.6691020131,
-0.5366362929,
-0.1336532831,
-0.2468885183,
-1.0284847021,
-0.6003804207,
-0.4091515839,
0.7637683749,
-0.2799035609,
-0.4548440874,
-0.4300398231,
-0.3530573249,
0.2015306503,
0.2190874815,
-0.436401099,
0.1328920722,
0.6138034463,
1.0426886082,
-0.3960109651,
0.0821565986,
-0.4463919699,
-0.0396374501,
-0.2439417094,
0.9699628353,
-0.6338953376,
-0.8627522588,
0.0642255321,
0.1827132702,
-0.1265531331,
-0.8661590815,
0.0998165905,
-1.1638404131,
0.200627476,
-0.4667264521,
-0.6966536045,
-0.6333634853,
0.5312294364,
-0.8337186575,
1.1230903864,
-0.05198301,
-0.76703161,
0.0608978197,
-0.8389750719,
-0.4839684367,
-0.1649436355,
0.0766988918,
-0.1399327964,
0.3037642241,
-0.152734831,
0.0434201322,
-0.0157086067,
0.2642233074,
-0.527815938,
-0.4220367074,
0.5043566823,
-0.3446809053,
0.9549847245,
0.5995849371,
-0.1690694392,
0.5232337117,
-0.5317336917,
-0.3577024937,
0.4377603829,
-0.3390924633,
-0.0231450871,
0.0577170923,
-0.6657932401,
0.3894370198,
0.4537813962,
-0.2448975295,
0.3000864983,
-0.1705898046,
0.0614488013,
0.7144172192,
0.1151012331,
0.0226005241,
-0.553121686,
0.9792096019,
0.2440662533,
-0.0441725291,
-0.2531475127,
-0.2936680019,
-0.8775426149,
-0.159138009,
-0.1608441025,
0.6683986187,
-0.9097993374,
-0.2383632511,
0.0576323606,
-0.3780015111,
-0.5205096602,
0.3373149633,
0.3023045957,
0.6039935946,
0.3679376543,
0.0304737221,
-1.1566013098,
-0.7347891927,
-0.4448381662,
-0.3733839989,
0.0096008787,
0.5680308342,
0.3621365726,
-0.1797877252,
1.1299099922,
-0.3215527236,
0.228199333,
-0.3829791546,
0.4368492067,
0.1392543763,
-0.0160363242,
0.2198750377,
-0.8577498794,
-0.2984030247,
-0.201015994,
-0.8100262284,
-0.4009726346,
-0.053405866,
-0.1943595707,
0.3224032521,
0.9454811215,
-0.4848026335,
0.3210584521,
0.4051950276,
-0.1385321915,
0.7935265899,
0.1225374788,
0.3260573149,
-0.9103422165,
0.2043693066,
-0.2632078528,
-0.274795413,
-0.4099960327,
0.368712455,
-0.5567008853,
-0.219204843,
-0.6363015175,
0.6189804673,
-0.3841781616,
-0.3250522912,
-0.5626347065,
0.4929241538,
-0.0642997921,
0.2904860079,
-0.0129778627,
1.0441509485,
0.5244642496,
-0.7214972973,
0.7764789462,
-0.3008539379,
0.0339779817,
0.4707492292,
-0.6792096496,
0.4113818407,
-0.3499732614,
-0.0998627543,
-1.4513372183,
-0.0432527661,
-0.0404049456,
-0.3843084276,
0.1583553702,
-0.6322673559,
-0.5397595763,
-0.6626012921,
-0.1027375758,
-0.0164795201,
0.6775601506,
-0.7722181678,
0.8262578249,
0.5730990171,
-0.0064374628,
-0.4347156584,
-0.5163387656,
0.056264177,
-0.6039828062,
-0.3399851322,
0.1434227824,
-0.2699039578,
-0.979046464,
-0.2680198252,
0.236617133,
-0.1903565228,
0.0992036611,
0.7109283805,
0.2777046859,
-0.4098788202,
0.65076226,
-0.0915036947,
0.2697524726,
0.3833962977,
-0.0033527033,
0.7286621332,
0.0818593502,
-0.2818818092,
-0.0260401648,
0.4088129401,
0.7276285291,
0.21777004,
0.7125099301,
0.7119825482,
-0.1869318932,
0.2775849104,
-0.57594347,
-0.0140425572,
-0.5391945243,
0.2657771409,
-0.6368100643,
-0.8659609556,
0.8344023824,
-0.3915121257,
0.021108957,
0.734269619,
1.1564019918,
0.0098724402,
1.3705410957,
0.3673067689,
0.0059530144,
0.5875047445,
-0.0648173168,
0.0355347842,
-0.6086265445,
-0.4742619395,
-0.6522868872,
-0.6667968631,
-0.3181020021,
-0.4907960594,
0.0933136195,
0.2550774515,
-0.2856929898,
0.0733357146,
-0.4049858749,
0.4690277874,
0.3494587243,
-0.1339183152,
0.280102402,
0.0454875082,
-0.344237566,
0.0295735188,
-0.601796329,
-0.4047469795,
0.7513074875,
0.1817465872,
0.7526136637,
0.3661198318,
0.4778064191,
0.3708564639,
0.6204849482,
-1.0520628691,
0.51206249,
-0.0560604483,
-1.2641375065,
-0.0689273551,
-0.2887118459,
-1.0144422054,
0.1389583349,
-0.0331909284,
-0.9528027773,
-0.0765024796,
0.2806306779,
-0.3275770545,
0.5760319233,
-0.9199818373,
0.7666207552,
-0.1140154824,
-0.51203686,
-0.3445229828,
-0.3663393557,
0.6669213772,
0.159540683,
0.2476243824,
0.2844709158,
-0.1308545917,
0.8257318735,
-0.6252489686,
0.9640849233,
-0.2392175198,
-0.3493438661,
0.8189849854,
0.5247424245,
0.5437383652,
-0.2864036262,
-0.3212303221,
0.0181577913,
-0.2777097523,
-0.1636477858,
-0.7525755763,
1.0639441013,
-0.7617407441,
-0.8959990144,
-0.0087209865,
-0.6589961648,
0.0050172796,
0.0335879028,
0.2955346406,
0.3175346851,
-0.1407728642,
-0.0581824072,
0.8588111997,
-0.4291353524,
0.5422566533,
0.8135416508,
-0.7986313105,
-0.0511158109,
1.0930387974,
0.2768397331,
0.159184292,
0.3412371576,
0.0984994471,
-0.5538901091,
-0.4346165657,
-0.6282203197,
-0.1728236228,
-0.8378346562,
-0.0418475494,
-1.0151309967,
-0.0124316886,
-0.0362180881,
-0.1432950199,
-0.1411533952,
-0.3159584105,
-0.4543582201,
0.0191599727,
0.705284059,
1.0952666998,
0.0946026221,
0.5345724821,
-0.6485588551,
0.3531361222,
0.3860019147,
0.3432834148,
0.1595924199,
-0.8826653957,
-0.1942955703,
-0.3560003936,
-0.5720470548,
-1.2882406712,
0.3279647231,
-0.2053515315,
0.3724610806,
0.5739567876,
0.0032993834,
0.9800553322,
-0.4505927563,
0.9867321849,
0.0932338983,
-0.8541619778,
0.7173773646,
-0.2211406082,
0.4321962893,
0.169919163,
0.8485453129,
-0.3653563857,
-0.4890993237,
-0.6802449226,
-0.8684456348,
0.502319932,
-0.4483540654,
0.1251807511,
-0.2163278013,
0.4284578264,
0.1702649742,
0.0837566257,
-0.7317851186,
-0.2934638262,
-0.2426187396,
-0.0664530993,
0.1993323117,
-0.4245654345,
-0.2966251969,
-0.0014253345,
0.9200747013,
0.1270589083,
0.3799095452,
0.2632560432,
-0.5375344753,
-0.5593965054,
0.1485602707,
0.654971242,
0.7778406143,
0.0299774203,
0.5122090578,
0.2711649537,
-0.2058336586,
-0.0985462517,
-0.1438216567,
0.0070374585,
0.2329935879,
0.2169200629,
0.7988105416,
-0.210191533,
-0.849537015,
0.1514545977,
-0.0002461305,
-0.1392914951,
-0.2862304151,
0.2293436527,
0.1090907529,
0.3536523581,
0.404854089,
-0.452942282,
0.3198308647,
-0.582231462,
0.271122396,
0.5912498236,
-1.0253773928,
-0.4063282907,
0.4154205322,
-0.1128610373,
-0.5977204442,
0.4162133336,
0.0072032497,
-0.5853306651,
0.4436624646,
0.7665211558,
0.722704947,
0.0102880122,
-0.0001593841,
0.3574490249,
0.215244785,
0.3427467048,
0.2733241618,
-0.0025602498,
-0.5365159512,
-0.8266824484,
-0.4366972744,
-0.4953706563,
0.4614210129,
-0.5476104617,
0.0756604299,
-0.56638515,
-0.0987724289,
0.0151822772,
0.0237757638,
-0.3260394931,
0.2715488374,
0.0384176448,
0.8848366141,
-0.4921648204,
0.730006814,
0.848534584,
-0.6750138998,
-0.6530984044,
-0.0268697962,
0.2501387894,
-1.2260136604,
0.9530413151,
-0.118139863,
-0.2209862322,
-0.0713661015,
-0.8448688388,
-0.6719819307,
0.5486339331,
0.4674391747,
-0.721085906,
0.4416160285,
-0.3508497775,
0.5891302228,
-0.0096071921,
0.4788082242,
0.4250549972,
0.6724821329,
0.3416124582,
-0.4620509148,
0.1324247867,
-0.2036146224,
-0.46291852,
0.3675096929,
-0.4699973166,
0.8192115426,
-0.4179934561,
-0.2380807847,
-0.1016343459,
0.5623778105,
0.056966044,
0.2391566038,
0.5446067452,
0.6126807332,
0.557955265,
-0.1998834163,
1.3675062656,
-0.316460222,
0.2599897087,
0.9679346085,
-0.2112399638,
0.7444546819,
0.7012637258,
-0.5612391233,
1.0809186697,
0.7221096754,
0.2781350911,
0.0995196402,
0.4506109953,
-0.4357900918,
-0.3328200877,
-0.2391844094,
-0.209536761,
0.2940137386,
0.3801071644,
-0.4985480607,
-0.2999763787,
0.0003367286,
0.1221324503,
-0.0625929013,
-0.5886123776,
1.1143074036,
-0.0223100483,
-0.9228146672,
0.6892545819,
-0.1498417854,
0.3344192505,
-0.3139456213,
0.0834698603,
-0.0953786448,
0.2737035453,
-0.229799673,
-0.8633494377,
0.7073115706,
0.2236863375,
-0.5736984015,
-0.095921278,
1.0186322927,
-0.4254441261,
-0.3695233762,
0.2963943481,
0.4919394553,
0.6762230992,
-0.1293456405,
-1.1243377924,
0.3185469508,
-0.1696165651,
-0.4889550209,
0.3692073524,
0.6809455752,
0.0747139156,
0.7570354939,
0.5120961666,
-0.1798525155,
0.0021458345,
0.0911549926,
0.9810658097,
-0.667621851,
-0.0596423186,
-1.3524974585,
0.4243788719,
0.042402707,
0.0948029459,
0.7747969627,
0.5817946792,
0.3727344573,
0.0120687243,
0.6984580159,
-0.1174422428,
0.7660192251,
-0.5074597597,
0.4578805566,
-0.8767267466,
0.092258729,
-0.0272934474,
-0.3976220787,
-0.1186623126,
0.343551755,
-0.4939813316,
0.2238369286,
0.442799449,
0.8297598958,
0.0270416085,
-0.0562551431,
0.4690398872,
0.7532270551,
0.0921154991,
0.2776627839,
0.9356476665,
-0.0223912913,
0.8201668262,
0.2886149287,
-0.0209964216,
-0.4346661568,
-0.9478189945,
-0.9719716907,
-0.2437471151,
-0.3364620805,
-0.4886336327,
0.2061937153,
0.7241649032,
0.5012844205,
-0.9838134646,
-0.2534367442,
0.0969995856,
0.8879483342,
0.1669788957,
-0.3643609583,
0.0783117265,
-0.5376567245,
-0.6762256026,
0.4940054417,
0.3752022684,
0.0321275964,
-0.569511354,
-0.0061306232,
-0.4577175677,
0.3915470243,
0.8104250431,
0.5264974236,
-0.8099768162,
-0.2590609491,
-0.008575906,
0.1695905328,
0.0998603255,
1.1055747271,
-1.1373878717,
0.6972043514,
0.6582077146,
0.4089108109,
0.3141598701,
0.021048585,
0.7519364357,
-0.7250091434,
0.2230677158,
-0.1318695396,
0.3630443513,
0.2625789344,
-0.3698160946,
0.1554170549,
0.2826506495,
-0.4970909059,
-0.9528001547,
0.3233885765,
-0.6984357238,
-0.5920501351,
1.1719774008,
-0.3256789744,
-0.2565335929,
-0.4384928346,
-0.3859559596,
0.5131963491,
-0.2871035039,
0.8915593028,
0.989125967,
-0.1548525095,
-0.2795082927,
-0.53951478,
0.4245673716,
0.3437345922,
-0.6276744008,
0.0907032937,
0.4761316776,
0.0759351552,
0.2119055837,
0.4784997106,
-0.4334963262,
0.0723846927,
-0.0960680917,
0.2031573802,
-0.0196621437,
-0.1965519339,
-0.4188006818,
0.4495642185,
0.1232154816,
-0.0265229996
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07052v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07052v1
|
Length-Aware Multi-Kernel Transformer for Long Document Classification
| 2024-05-11T16:48:06 | 2024-05-11T16:48:06 |
Guangzeng Han, Jack Tsao, Xiaolei Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Lengthy documents pose a unique challenge to neural language models due to
substantial memory consumption. While existing state-of-the-art (SOTA) models
segment long texts into equal-length snippets (e.g., 128 tokens per snippet) or
deploy sparse attention networks, these methods have new challenges of context
fragmentation and generalizability due to sentence boundaries and varying text
lengths. For example, our empirical analysis has shown that SOTA models
consistently overfit one set of lengthy documents (e.g., 2000 tokens) while
performing worse on texts with other lengths (e.g., 1000 or 4000). In this
study, we propose a Length-Aware Multi-Kernel Transformer (LAMKIT) to address
the new challenges for the long document classification. LAMKIT encodes lengthy
documents by diverse transformer-based kernels for bridging context boundaries
and vectorizes text length by the kernels to promote model robustness over
varying document lengths. Experiments on five standard benchmarks from health
and law domains show LAMKIT outperforms SOTA models up to an absolute 10.9%
improvement. We conduct extensive ablation analyses to examine model robustness
and effectiveness over varying document lengths.
|
[
-0.4616651237,
-0.670093298,
0.575891614,
0.4668800533,
-0.3443737328,
-0.1571314335,
-0.4122159481,
-0.6554777026,
0.1714587063,
0.5791938305,
-0.3018415272,
-0.1666073054,
-0.8029432297,
0.2030044943,
-0.6811062098,
1.1271345615,
-0.1328936219,
-0.3595196009,
-0.3911149502,
-0.3436397016,
-0.5501555204,
-0.4253804684,
-0.4877598584,
-0.2510472536,
0.7219506502,
0.3289460838,
0.5460973978,
0.6473323107,
0.5381352305,
0.2283001542,
-0.3492761254,
0.1235620305,
-0.1205119938,
0.3297660649,
0.2301284969,
-0.2387982458,
-0.3647337258,
-0.3850651979,
0.9742410779,
0.4428526759,
0.0399016961,
0.0881063864,
0.0541640408,
0.6910556555,
-0.6308591962,
-0.1771502346,
-0.3200723827,
0.0433274806,
-0.3965987563,
0.1414003074,
-0.6027006507,
-0.0114023499,
0.2061898559,
-0.5223567486,
0.0469712988,
-0.0420914739,
0.8017309904,
0.2953562438,
-0.5180083513,
-0.4482495189,
-0.6497715712,
0.8045498133,
-0.5283856392,
0.9439208508,
0.5386558771,
0.5749353766,
0.2081196308,
-0.9729033709,
-0.7881812453,
-0.0913054794,
-0.2633031011,
0.056516733,
-0.0685103014,
-0.0534253754,
0.3965350389,
0.1607211083,
-0.5643233061,
0.4655149281,
-0.72379601,
-0.3487624526,
0.3021796346,
0.132063508,
0.1057810336,
-0.2819994986,
-0.5953823924,
0.0113752931,
-0.3473013937,
0.0891724527,
0.3878386617,
0.0102150459,
0.0176528301,
0.3012108207,
-0.0101314839,
0.7331546545,
-0.1618121415,
-0.2225242108,
0.2280742526,
-0.2051647902,
-0.1848937273,
0.3424561918,
0.6859806776,
0.2602914572,
-0.2680082321,
-0.0986136347,
-0.2316723019,
0.0791462362,
0.4731996953,
-1.1157996655,
0.2170933038,
0.310292691,
-0.4408278465,
0.1033767909,
-0.3441944718,
-0.9843132496,
-0.3349665701,
-0.1069255769,
0.3376523256,
-0.707924366,
0.2201788574,
0.3772624731,
-0.0765534788,
0.1047471687,
0.2216929495,
-0.9707977772,
0.1356792301,
0.7414932847,
1.0234030485,
-0.1782154441,
-0.4791849554,
-0.4739015102,
0.1203270331,
-0.0413020737,
0.781878531,
-0.6503621936,
-0.4166292846,
-0.0439870059,
-0.0492229313,
-0.0013590803,
-0.1918150187,
0.8528952599,
-0.5194684267,
0.3293370903,
-0.0098418538,
-0.6066675782,
-0.0297764726,
0.3999024928,
-0.7786144018,
0.9788765311,
0.2177761793,
-0.8087803125,
0.2284898758,
-0.9695113301,
-0.6904428601,
-0.0001254849,
0.0523808114,
-0.8467679024,
-0.0444820561,
0.1917780936,
0.716412425,
-0.3035596311,
0.4387960136,
0.1072028279,
-0.2553592026,
0.1705529243,
-0.6447097063,
0.5101938844,
0.3388543129,
0.0988647193,
0.3311321437,
-0.8382579684,
-0.3702305853,
-0.1618190259,
-0.6241307259,
-0.3637667,
-0.3215085268,
0.3840946257,
0.1287718117,
0.24067384,
-0.9599840641,
0.2449487001,
-0.2185891122,
0.745927453,
0.6703375578,
-0.3840060234,
0.4681878388,
-0.4302318394,
0.2303586155,
0.0612717904,
0.4444484711,
-0.5960270762,
-0.4205988944,
-0.8351021409,
-0.6022117138,
0.4356318712,
0.0225982666,
-0.5008020997,
0.6125369072,
-0.7265706062,
-0.5277043581,
-0.5235535502,
-0.0370349959,
0.2250178754,
0.68315804,
0.6655194759,
-0.4077230394,
-0.3311238885,
-1.0189211369,
0.0444564857,
0.1923400313,
-0.1546313465,
0.3172246218,
0.5096120238,
-0.7853562832,
1.1748734713,
-0.6072613001,
-0.4720925987,
-0.2497896701,
0.1425689608,
0.0371679515,
0.3366132677,
0.4235701859,
-0.9396528602,
-0.5241534114,
0.0102542238,
-0.3881075382,
-0.0022709423,
-0.2984052002,
0.1762792319,
0.303168267,
0.4327613413,
-0.6228170395,
0.4760721326,
0.4320164323,
-0.3012648225,
0.5950418711,
-0.3472111523,
-0.3802521229,
-1.1658176184,
0.2569887042,
-0.0971852913,
-0.2509664595,
-0.9299783707,
-0.1272767335,
0.6266091466,
0.0041417922,
-0.5773555636,
0.6523441672,
-0.0415736958,
0.0843461305,
-0.3238605857,
-0.2978238761,
0.3164544106,
0.5007292032,
0.0211580005,
0.5591738224,
0.3003252447,
-0.5344512463,
0.2448687106,
0.4008757174,
-0.6417868733,
0.5546092391,
-0.3531526923,
0.0373923331,
-0.2773284316,
0.6745924354,
-0.5660354495,
-0.2003975958,
-0.2032481879,
-0.1857917309,
0.436665386,
0.3349098563,
-0.4260509908,
-0.5356983542,
-0.2310290188,
0.6438766122,
0.3308597803,
-0.7221813798,
0.9021997452,
0.1114160344,
-0.1639311463,
-0.8007462025,
-0.7197999954,
0.1834177226,
-0.283034116,
-0.6427466869,
0.4737963676,
-0.156477958,
0.4029406011,
-0.1966659278,
-0.2268605381,
-0.3426017761,
0.0294432696,
0.4131090045,
-0.1462264359,
-0.0158653278,
0.4653298855,
0.2786309421,
-0.21756199,
-0.141215384,
-0.1728167087,
0.6591050029,
-0.1789910793,
-0.1765260696,
-0.3486169875,
0.5455497503,
0.8587995172,
-0.4505574107,
0.5767953992,
0.7951672077,
-0.4355809093,
-0.2218009531,
-0.8227174878,
-0.17924577,
-0.4701581299,
0.4445946813,
-0.4468452632,
-1.3293485641,
0.7259535789,
-0.0111138513,
-0.0599280037,
0.4166486263,
0.2827289104,
0.0429003313,
0.4255565405,
0.709032774,
-0.2136296332,
0.4319449067,
-0.2987090647,
0.2649872899,
-1.1038261652,
-0.33497262,
-0.4704812467,
-0.4103331268,
-0.0159728769,
-0.2828819454,
0.3155425787,
-0.1405289322,
-0.1969629675,
0.5007686019,
-0.5646470785,
0.5468497872,
0.4784822166,
0.0999798477,
-0.1166070402,
-0.2295268327,
-0.0753626972,
0.307728827,
-0.5941032171,
-0.1377916634,
0.9065757394,
0.7692587972,
0.6053278446,
-0.0509494133,
0.5134042501,
0.0976586565,
0.2523824573,
-0.8935936689,
0.3599459827,
-0.3759352267,
-0.4812250435,
-0.7299419641,
-0.311817646,
-0.9909436703,
-0.0500620119,
0.0527566932,
-0.5214532614,
0.2981250882,
-0.3675236702,
-0.5475244522,
0.3025856614,
-0.2692602277,
0.9110491872,
-0.3578243852,
-0.1593410075,
-0.006984049,
-0.9641845226,
0.0395775437,
-0.713147521,
0.1098726764,
-0.0598659515,
0.1841856092,
1.1095615625,
-0.4730203748,
0.7830365896,
0.0850844383,
-0.1745332628,
0.302451551,
-0.1838364601,
0.3178918958,
-0.0868586302,
-0.0718098953,
0.4540989399,
0.021123616,
-0.2564136684,
-0.5730320215,
0.585457325,
-0.616386652,
-0.3723944426,
-0.25992769,
-0.647290647,
0.0067743859,
0.6403199434,
0.3163045347,
0.4169737697,
0.0944198668,
0.6208924055,
0.4648848474,
-0.2177735567,
0.7235693932,
0.4740920365,
0.0226808973,
-0.3681500852,
0.8789594173,
0.2951511443,
0.0157980938,
0.4574896693,
0.4057810009,
-0.4397398829,
-0.3638539314,
-0.2730593681,
-0.0716999918,
-0.7964763045,
-0.482059747,
-0.9527984858,
-0.436824739,
-0.2934196293,
-0.4213173091,
-0.5222439766,
-0.336583972,
-0.2165175974,
-0.0965467542,
0.3571770787,
0.635571301,
0.0949369669,
0.6890128851,
-0.9043387771,
0.2639250457,
0.4932327867,
0.8610303402,
0.0630261227,
-0.5527722836,
-0.3655475676,
-0.3717103899,
-0.2957379222,
-0.5713784099,
0.3879599571,
0.219096005,
0.21583049,
0.4620043635,
0.0525221974,
0.4961054325,
-0.7476415038,
0.6799753308,
0.5002022982,
-0.9529333115,
0.3022456169,
-0.1249734014,
0.5364179015,
0.4713765979,
0.3645014465,
-0.9129379988,
-0.1564823538,
-0.1429204345,
-0.9484190345,
0.5951557755,
0.163932085,
0.2752017975,
-0.1193061173,
0.3653600514,
0.5071715117,
-0.1958425343,
-0.5307978988,
0.1851218194,
-0.3819229603,
-0.3029604852,
0.0116863465,
-0.6692957282,
0.1309570074,
0.0183595214,
0.3822516203,
-0.2290299386,
0.2043721676,
0.1663340926,
-0.1933293939,
0.2146677822,
0.6139988899,
1.0330960751,
0.5777686238,
-0.2497970164,
0.2839612663,
0.347810626,
-0.7706441879,
0.1562242508,
0.1170168743,
0.1177214086,
0.0052058226,
0.3057240546,
0.9252617359,
0.1147116423,
-0.5542010069,
0.6568363309,
-0.2621563673,
-0.1791122258,
-0.1068173051,
-0.2679494321,
0.0488255471,
0.1057273522,
0.1881925911,
-0.0037993302,
0.0539415106,
-0.0387842022,
0.4182142317,
0.0674685389,
-0.5298604369,
-0.1695620269,
0.5198564529,
0.2523607612,
-0.3510991037,
0.7347589731,
0.1692071706,
-0.6716226935,
0.6348057389,
0.6416347623,
0.7547846437,
-0.4220499098,
-0.1039550155,
-0.0617164411,
0.1938508898,
-0.3482432067,
-0.0872827172,
-0.3275952339,
-0.5514372587,
-0.358837992,
-1.1641734838,
-0.1457637995,
0.3102077842,
-0.5672347546,
0.2753492296,
-0.2924691439,
-0.2721320689,
0.2557746172,
-0.3155081272,
-0.5850228071,
0.2742288709,
0.0447621979,
1.0786736012,
-0.7245587707,
1.0559864044,
0.2232393473,
-0.1092543304,
-0.3293077946,
-0.1298924834,
-0.5242384672,
-0.4442708194,
0.8237774968,
0.8645723462,
0.1389199197,
-0.3557932377,
-0.0480145738,
-0.6717011929,
1.0616384745,
0.2073985934,
-0.7677397132,
-0.1387797296,
0.5195922852,
0.5399012566,
-0.1635740995,
-0.0093801217,
0.3782269061,
0.5097119212,
-0.1025482938,
-1.135800004,
-0.0613324493,
-0.0391037278,
-0.0092776529,
0.3875510693,
-0.8556997776,
0.661436677,
0.1811917126,
-0.1192326844,
0.0466276407,
0.7287124991,
-0.2327423245,
0.5831530094,
0.477388829,
0.8329604864,
0.6799268723,
0.2194039673,
0.9232480526,
-0.3583638072,
0.2299149036,
1.0555557013,
-0.3581136167,
0.8543072343,
0.3828673661,
0.2950775325,
0.3626459539,
0.3707013726,
-0.020886464,
0.3705551624,
0.2186935097,
-0.2742294669,
-0.1546908617,
-0.1862747073,
-0.3395614624,
0.6606521606,
0.4784044623,
-0.4889721274,
-0.0892389193,
0.5798559189,
-0.0308002587,
-0.1673610061,
-0.1726522446,
0.6157032251,
0.1434987038,
-0.6096916199,
0.3989299536,
0.3311323524,
0.8508158326,
-0.6656588316,
0.2916693389,
-0.2577720881,
0.2359634936,
-0.1038877219,
-0.8951040506,
0.4769716561,
0.0080717979,
-0.418756336,
-0.4036327899,
0.9111514688,
-0.3898424804,
-0.4262363017,
0.314571023,
-0.1847096682,
-0.0637899488,
-0.0445491746,
-0.2691231668,
0.2398764938,
-0.3400532007,
-0.2297897339,
0.4269216359,
0.2982899845,
-0.2298538387,
0.7467858195,
0.5602466464,
-0.3735259771,
0.1017673835,
-0.1132671908,
1.0268050432,
-0.5518431664,
-0.8276234269,
-0.8911851645,
0.3175939322,
-0.0643719435,
-0.3157290816,
0.5212067962,
0.937415421,
0.6181666851,
0.0005986431,
0.6527009606,
0.3078082204,
0.2187201381,
-0.4148242176,
1.0805358887,
-0.5567882061,
-0.0171264801,
0.2577462196,
-0.884268105,
-0.6025128961,
0.4270482957,
-0.1828277707,
-0.2347870767,
0.6601586342,
0.3705551922,
-0.2004317939,
0.0459583029,
0.3680455685,
0.1372462809,
0.5946608782,
0.5788938403,
0.6720015407,
-0.2722332776,
0.6022080779,
-0.1264705509,
-0.0354256034,
-0.3710443377,
-0.8539149165,
-0.8368151784,
-0.7971720695,
-0.0309187677,
-0.1441563517,
0.018183697,
0.4243988395,
0.734349668,
-0.5580189824,
0.0172836576,
0.2031991929,
-0.0974577814,
0.1190710515,
-0.154674843,
0.7905779481,
-0.3376842737,
-0.3484240174,
0.4079478085,
0.5818834305,
0.0171204843,
-0.1377271414,
-0.1176061928,
-0.0709432065,
0.1819760799,
0.8152505159,
0.2663441896,
-0.6082197428,
-0.4729502797,
-0.035777878,
-0.2006900162,
0.1484329551,
0.6402126551,
-0.5639451742,
0.7565184832,
0.4953712821,
0.9429855347,
0.576274991,
-0.2752928734,
0.1598878801,
-1.1740180254,
0.0693726987,
0.413318634,
0.4336684048,
0.2612561882,
-0.4046832621,
0.390982002,
-0.216345638,
-0.6915636659,
-0.9585025311,
0.193419531,
-1.0988179445,
-0.499166131,
1.1233842373,
-0.1376022547,
-0.4051710069,
0.0171631277,
-0.2294345051,
0.2684512138,
-0.3064672351,
0.865616262,
0.7198060751,
-0.0058904407,
-0.0549478903,
-0.2319358736,
0.343934536,
0.421902895,
-0.6705405116,
0.2064087987,
0.2666688263,
0.0194488149,
0.7986316681,
0.5296950936,
0.1004503965,
0.243561402,
-0.2283535898,
-0.0872700289,
-0.3932745457,
-0.8390257359,
-0.4143668115,
0.3418626487,
-0.4351067841,
0.0176143795
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07035v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07035v2
|
A Turkish Educational Crossword Puzzle Generator
| 2024-05-11T15:18:56 | 2024-05-15T12:23:39 |
Kamyar Zeinalipour, Yusuf Gökberk Keptiğ, Marco Maggini, Leonardo Rigutini, Marco Gori
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper introduces the first Turkish crossword puzzle generator designed
to leverage the capabilities of large language models (LLMs) for educational
purposes. In this work, we introduced two specially created datasets: one with
over 180,000 unique answer-clue pairs for generating relevant clues from the
given answer, and another with over 35,000 samples containing text, answer,
category, and clue data, aimed at producing clues for specific texts and
keywords within certain categories. Beyond entertainment, this generator
emerges as an interactive educational tool that enhances memory, vocabulary,
and problem-solving skills. It's a notable step in AI-enhanced education,
merging game-like engagement with learning for Turkish and setting new
standards for interactive, intelligent learning tools in Turkish.
|
[
-0.4506929815,
-0.8758941293,
0.3162929416,
0.0965428203,
-0.6649779081,
0.116500333,
-0.3229037523,
-0.1900850981,
0.2184282392,
0.4840320051,
-0.8162333965,
-0.4748373032,
-0.73815763,
0.1842375845,
-0.5723984838,
0.9798749685,
0.0175995883,
0.1467067599,
-0.3060697615,
0.0595545433,
-0.2882600725,
-0.3032358885,
-0.8447265625,
-0.3186144233,
0.9036322832,
0.5714862943,
0.2797345519,
0.8636856675,
0.5827989578,
0.2540887296,
0.1552709937,
0.1733111888,
-0.4609606862,
0.223994121,
-0.3111039102,
-0.547121048,
-0.1495634019,
0.1103521809,
0.5171073675,
0.5862912536,
0.0089294165,
0.6767157912,
0.3183307648,
0.6806788445,
-0.4548893273,
0.077954784,
-0.5697845221,
0.2197297662,
-0.4987376034,
-0.3836171925,
0.1018463969,
-0.174736917,
0.0548619032,
-0.6707741022,
0.1165089309,
-0.055209633,
0.5256301165,
0.1353219002,
-0.3505643904,
-0.7252694964,
-0.5117052197,
0.8188722134,
-0.4009461105,
0.3734792769,
0.3152484894,
0.5329508185,
-0.4819768965,
-0.8797842264,
-0.558423996,
-0.0909334794,
0.3713802993,
0.1485509276,
0.3432704806,
-0.1466771811,
0.1028972641,
0.4126321673,
-0.50503546,
-0.1752278954,
-0.5288634896,
0.1247474924,
0.8788190484,
0.7088383436,
0.4148623049,
0.1796327233,
-0.1279635727,
-0.0856134892,
-0.9444768429,
0.2125083059,
0.5750690699,
0.3773834109,
-0.0047845296,
1.1259384155,
-0.233846575,
0.8874441385,
0.0191931687,
-0.4815559089,
-0.1490837932,
-0.3792540431,
-0.0320087038,
0.3965018094,
0.6449429393,
0.2020884752,
0.1949828714,
-0.0866135806,
-0.2370919883,
0.1973965615,
0.0372868516,
-0.5660848022,
-0.2037658691,
0.1435406208,
-0.3992092907,
-0.55950284,
-0.0655307546,
-0.6341109872,
-0.4420196414,
0.0090477923,
0.5446633101,
-0.23785761,
-0.0647215173,
0.3673478663,
-0.1509804875,
0.1094086468,
0.259283036,
-0.9500742555,
0.0595310517,
0.7760599256,
0.4710513353,
-0.1605587155,
-0.2359928042,
-0.4890963137,
0.1995377839,
-0.2843487263,
0.5392961502,
-0.8335362673,
-0.404273659,
0.1417867839,
-0.0087162191,
0.2537648082,
-0.5093415976,
0.3255029321,
-0.2611404061,
0.5953936577,
-0.3639171422,
-0.60044384,
-0.2553391159,
0.3478808105,
-0.9758021235,
1.1365839243,
0.0570310503,
-0.8705275655,
0.4436107576,
-0.3638291955,
-0.3142691553,
0.4481902122,
-0.4906637073,
-0.2434006631,
0.2120942026,
0.1364109665,
0.1895481795,
-0.4832337797,
0.1738216281,
-0.0298200846,
-0.5352925062,
0.108715333,
-0.1002360731,
0.9397166967,
0.1875333935,
-0.364470154,
-0.2433850616,
-0.6778718829,
-0.1847941726,
0.341930449,
-0.9623354077,
-0.2286523879,
0.0957706049,
0.0966138318,
0.4820148051,
0.5828154087,
-0.7725827098,
0.1409638375,
-0.1707809567,
-0.2912214398,
0.3879894614,
-0.0362494104,
-0.2439831048,
-0.7432321906,
0.9862913489,
-0.0116258757,
-0.4972717166,
-0.2619767785,
-0.7337743044,
-0.9025427103,
-0.1169827655,
0.3073410988,
0.665917933,
-0.6315575242,
0.5248935223,
-0.1013824418,
-0.4073748291,
-0.8175696135,
0.4106568396,
0.261988163,
0.2501698434,
-0.0269892048,
-0.081024386,
-0.8407872319,
-0.4667906761,
-0.5709680319,
0.1070254222,
-0.2398083657,
0.4117969871,
0.5166310668,
0.3157230616,
0.7070439458,
0.2326911092,
-0.4102844298,
-0.5293052197,
-0.0629550368,
0.2074180692,
0.408020407,
0.2701022327,
-0.3202204704,
-0.5705817342,
-0.0621198379,
-0.8060368896,
0.0493208542,
-0.0968682691,
0.0065699443,
0.199457258,
0.3438772261,
-0.3900876045,
0.3585561812,
0.4373621643,
-0.7176122069,
0.409881413,
0.0082042655,
-0.0438737385,
-1.3806219101,
0.0493831858,
-0.1771565229,
0.0178235155,
-0.2845369279,
0.2252145559,
-0.406779319,
-0.1824530065,
-0.4861014187,
0.7037059665,
-0.5309616923,
0.2087935209,
-0.2580354214,
0.5095074773,
-0.2951702774,
0.0462071188,
0.1970119178,
0.7057473063,
0.5032907724,
-0.3950930238,
0.8597102165,
0.2397240102,
-0.934918344,
0.3920349777,
-0.49501881,
0.1656064987,
-0.0638581142,
-0.010097553,
-0.8438677192,
-0.1146395877,
0.3019098938,
-0.4425801337,
0.1443059444,
0.2865556479,
-0.4168906808,
-0.3888553679,
-0.1969068944,
0.2823560536,
0.4621991515,
-0.7060598731,
0.3604761362,
0.4908228219,
-0.3918859959,
-0.806173265,
-0.5551463962,
0.2416777015,
-0.4260687828,
-0.5210914612,
-0.1549061686,
0.1233153716,
-0.3070217073,
0.3113708794,
-0.2190612853,
0.3520862162,
0.0722367838,
0.0379294567,
0.1677848399,
-0.4657097161,
0.2848888338,
0.1824997067,
0.1227671206,
0.3204863071,
-0.2442361116,
0.5202626586,
0.1716701239,
-0.2812768221,
-0.025575554,
0.6185452342,
0.228646934,
-0.2120016366,
0.6427721977,
0.7776277065,
-0.3774400949,
-0.162171483,
-0.4073340297,
-0.246181801,
-0.5133856535,
0.7871131897,
-0.649414897,
-1.1841305494,
0.5122510791,
-0.224713102,
0.397395581,
0.2479887754,
0.7388792038,
-0.1763054281,
1.0027800798,
0.59878093,
0.0052605891,
0.2829334438,
-0.075276278,
0.2448449433,
-0.7262707949,
-0.7145785689,
-0.5509015918,
-0.5361760855,
-0.5509195924,
-0.230633378,
0.1488464475,
-0.0140321804,
-0.1730381697,
-0.1753881425,
-0.5939006209,
0.4491676092,
0.7757090926,
0.0803327262,
0.0178416893,
0.4506304264,
-0.356322825,
-0.0644576997,
-0.8213529587,
-0.7026216388,
1.4316616058,
-0.0093582422,
0.9916005731,
0.0249883588,
1.2170362473,
0.1703439951,
0.0008386907,
-0.7376057506,
0.7207962871,
-0.1274185777,
-0.9672641158,
-0.558373332,
-0.1145296246,
-1.3087618351,
-0.0078435428,
-0.6252006888,
-0.8865098953,
-0.402239114,
-0.0372632854,
-0.272280246,
0.3753241897,
-0.0517758504,
0.7684883475,
-0.3474729657,
-0.5300745368,
-0.4395222068,
-0.3411225975,
0.5228569508,
-0.1746181697,
-0.1436084658,
0.0043166885,
-0.2742808759,
1.1482906342,
-0.1075027063,
0.43754825,
0.1065713391,
-0.111406602,
0.5916205049,
0.1408131123,
0.329756856,
-0.0222904086,
0.1167977825,
-0.2543225586,
-0.0409050956,
-0.4783031344,
-0.3645039499,
0.8652825356,
-0.8596120477,
-1.1713362932,
-0.4817761779,
-0.8715221286,
0.1927247792,
0.2107912898,
0.2002464682,
0.243015036,
-0.3244945109,
0.2823478878,
0.6959396005,
-0.3702372909,
0.3755308688,
0.4334416389,
-0.2037612498,
-0.338152051,
1.1270231009,
0.1985798776,
-0.2310018092,
0.2040583044,
0.0703938752,
-0.377853632,
-0.3212036788,
-0.4999384582,
0.211544767,
-0.6089813113,
0.109539859,
-0.4781442583,
-0.4401190281,
-0.1436973661,
-0.2382249832,
-0.0633970723,
-0.5777568817,
-0.1751224846,
-0.2095049322,
0.3586132526,
1.1054751873,
-0.1558002383,
0.3027823269,
-0.7324037552,
0.3104749024,
0.6756178141,
0.20670937,
-0.2384673953,
-0.4674217701,
-0.5759720206,
0.0536145568,
-0.2134849131,
-1.0062596798,
0.2609658539,
0.2741891146,
0.7306774259,
0.6529047489,
-0.2087976635,
0.1133471578,
-0.3506611884,
1.0480314493,
0.1051088646,
-0.5242218971,
0.4003690779,
-0.287435025,
0.4263184369,
0.2804062068,
0.3643389046,
-0.682279408,
-0.4365725815,
-0.5717906356,
-0.755281508,
0.7699328065,
0.0603988618,
0.1859289557,
0.04683787,
0.2228443325,
0.354952544,
0.2534246147,
-0.3541245162,
-0.5917787552,
-0.1920554936,
-0.6163002849,
-0.1066900715,
-0.5054863095,
-0.3331989646,
-0.2718769312,
0.9326620102,
0.236307323,
0.2839968801,
-0.4408096373,
-0.0509051196,
-0.4072189331,
0.155698806,
0.6925440431,
0.6320675611,
-0.1809353381,
0.1942725033,
0.2018993199,
-1.0562953949,
0.3340106606,
0.1786265373,
0.0398866273,
0.201439023,
0.3000823855,
0.7436360121,
-0.2865488529,
-0.8315100074,
0.0652741641,
-0.2900686264,
-0.1042930409,
-0.4620845616,
0.3572130799,
0.3812279403,
0.3458973765,
0.597202301,
-0.8587244749,
-0.0421027169,
-0.4984489977,
0.458805114,
0.6843050122,
-0.1806369871,
-0.0583523102,
0.7678852677,
0.3919581175,
-0.8478764892,
0.8072384596,
0.0401812978,
-0.3678895533,
0.7424391508,
0.8327350616,
0.9619659781,
-0.3623047173,
0.2466284782,
0.5585501194,
0.5728448629,
0.3741648793,
0.8580159545,
-0.270814091,
-0.6472080946,
-0.2694495916,
-0.5868670344,
-0.3460177481,
0.7029732466,
-0.6010712385,
0.4270280302,
-0.4060981274,
-0.0239829924,
-0.2505261004,
0.623252809,
-0.7089765072,
0.4918565452,
0.5112097859,
1.1231230497,
-0.8514176607,
1.0923746824,
1.3225431442,
-0.1660919487,
-0.7114234567,
-0.4076713324,
-0.1243252009,
-0.8232913613,
0.6997886896,
0.0908952132,
-0.0191165097,
0.0283036325,
-0.6368451118,
-0.9045212865,
0.9576724768,
0.014254502,
-0.7463041544,
-0.0014892691,
0.7618132234,
0.2667730153,
-0.7688571215,
0.0717588514,
0.6543617249,
0.4022327662,
-0.1174814701,
-0.3974170387,
0.0919320807,
-0.5120492578,
-0.224460125,
-0.0881183222,
-0.3212136626,
0.6420530677,
-0.2609858513,
-0.133126989,
0.1421110332,
0.8389434814,
0.7016389966,
0.3385676146,
0.2713369131,
0.947452426,
0.3701702952,
-0.1572903842,
0.5830562711,
-0.7694775462,
-0.0088394703,
1.2920438051,
0.1813378483,
0.3896644115,
0.8517740369,
-0.0587354675,
0.4080364108,
0.9662035108,
0.0649582148,
0.5461882353,
0.2398589253,
-0.6668200493,
-0.6299952865,
-0.0767636746,
-0.5781198144,
0.5278983712,
0.7588502765,
-0.3911806941,
-0.575694859,
-0.179198131,
-0.0504926108,
-0.0885555819,
-0.3261930048,
0.5324742198,
0.2576063573,
-0.4739838243,
0.2901801467,
-0.0792080685,
0.3926318586,
-0.4924741089,
-0.3486921787,
-0.402910322,
0.1337005198,
0.1494012177,
-0.8689692616,
-0.1215134114,
-0.0156873744,
0.3576311767,
0.2982960641,
0.5959128737,
-0.9861057997,
-0.7478424907,
-0.1791457683,
0.5128805637,
0.3598970175,
0.412702769,
-0.7416309714,
0.0075572394,
-0.0627763197,
-0.4687413871,
0.3324613273,
0.82213521,
0.0585290417,
0.6628319621,
0.3565658331,
0.2850272655,
0.5190021396,
-0.4876974225,
0.7551844716,
-0.7766539454,
-0.5150637627,
-0.5359020233,
0.5430951715,
0.1287418455,
-0.5518041849,
0.9366970658,
0.6605445147,
1.0859754086,
-0.1769179851,
1.174556613,
-0.0985393077,
0.2956747115,
-0.0991206169,
0.814226687,
-0.7818462253,
0.0282628145,
0.0315989628,
-0.9830117822,
-0.0382356942,
0.714621067,
0.0879545659,
-0.007918939,
0.5752902031,
0.5746551752,
0.0034887257,
-0.0919344723,
0.4292038679,
-0.229759261,
-0.1124292687,
0.8161154985,
1.0075727701,
-0.4581779242,
0.5574302673,
-0.394936502,
0.0401734821,
-0.3290321827,
-0.4156203568,
-1.5969309807,
-0.6429054737,
-0.0760609359,
-0.4811852574,
0.3992448747,
1.0041983128,
0.0743189231,
-0.8246464729,
-0.5366452336,
0.0902628452,
0.2365297824,
-0.2526869774,
-0.1503903121,
0.4084947407,
-0.2174875885,
-0.8066978455,
0.2582096457,
-0.0095843105,
0.0106993802,
-0.5774939656,
-0.1529258788,
-0.347363621,
0.5059347153,
0.2726407349,
0.2827678025,
-0.6664931178,
-0.3249535263,
0.0507077649,
-0.1638890058,
-0.288068831,
0.7959432602,
-0.9180420041,
0.864318192,
0.6376963854,
0.5923047066,
0.4932801127,
-0.3585813046,
0.4397150874,
-0.3259303868,
0.3378952146,
0.04358178,
0.2121974379,
0.2292174399,
-0.4010939896,
0.3501535654,
0.0085093444,
-0.2415961325,
-0.8138776422,
0.207096979,
-0.6292875409,
0.1899373978,
0.8710025549,
-0.2990702689,
-0.4575073123,
-0.2132916152,
-0.0213812664,
0.7070429325,
-0.1454678178,
1.4495805502,
0.8048092723,
0.1594473273,
-0.2789078355,
-0.0919571966,
0.5967780352,
0.4104325771,
-0.5192654133,
-0.3597234488,
0.133178398,
0.3723829091,
-0.1751914024,
0.1507377177,
-0.0892705619,
0.5785171986,
0.3005992472,
0.3110141158,
-0.3973946571,
-0.4702593982,
-0.3271490037,
0.0814012215,
-0.1118773669,
-0.60496068
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08017v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08017v1
|
Translating Expert Intuition into Quantifiable Features: Encode Investigator Domain Knowledge via LLM for Enhanced Predictive Analytics
| 2024-05-11T13:23:43 | 2024-05-11T13:23:43 |
Phoebe Jing, Yijing Gao, Yuanhang Zhang, Xianlong Zeng
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In the realm of predictive analytics, the nuanced domain knowledge of
investigators often remains underutilized, confined largely to subjective
interpretations and ad hoc decision-making. This paper explores the potential
of Large Language Models (LLMs) to bridge this gap by systematically converting
investigator-derived insights into quantifiable, actionable features that
enhance model performance. We present a framework that leverages LLMs' natural
language understanding capabilities to encode these red flags into a structured
feature set that can be readily integrated into existing predictive models.
Through a series of case studies, we demonstrate how this approach not only
preserves the critical human expertise within the investigative process but
also scales the impact of this knowledge across various prediction tasks. The
results indicate significant improvements in risk assessment and
decision-making accuracy, highlighting the value of blending human experiential
knowledge with advanced machine learning techniques. This study paves the way
for more sophisticated, knowledge-driven analytics in fields where expert
insight is paramount.
|
[
-0.1227528751,
-0.5370569229,
0.9564952254,
-0.1620076448,
0.0339438394,
0.3358195424,
-0.1718973815,
-0.7862808108,
0.2300593555,
0.9324889183,
-0.45564726,
-0.6232708693,
-0.8066432476,
-0.0730275065,
-0.4484096169,
0.8723157048,
0.0039917002,
0.0392233916,
-0.3591685891,
0.012437433,
-0.159478128,
-0.8463837504,
-0.6246133447,
-0.1886080354,
0.4000050426,
0.2745250762,
0.5042707324,
0.5615730286,
0.9820557833,
0.2563902736,
0.0754828379,
0.3641808927,
-0.4412610531,
-0.0778258741,
-0.0454185903,
-0.6710473895,
-0.8463291526,
0.0370519422,
0.1367159933,
0.731040895,
-0.1440370381,
0.1948614717,
-0.0283659473,
0.4858469665,
-0.6262283921,
0.4795486629,
-0.8268552423,
-0.1282105148,
0.0862739533,
-0.3665748239,
-0.4126426876,
-0.2577587962,
0.5901414752,
-0.6632788181,
0.164510861,
-0.0141642978,
0.4882737994,
0.5199897885,
-0.5287870765,
-0.199321866,
-0.7289991379,
0.8045565486,
-0.6141631603,
-0.0514699221,
0.4479890168,
0.5224802494,
-0.0829949453,
-0.5759305358,
-0.2036784738,
-0.151421681,
-0.1386893243,
-0.0787680745,
-0.2159479409,
0.1593120545,
0.0969942436,
-0.0028233561,
-0.1355168521,
0.3462174833,
-0.2201884389,
-0.1960231215,
1.0891324282,
0.3372772932,
-0.2530188262,
0.3286203742,
0.0458864905,
-0.0429523289,
-0.6877567768,
0.0192081388,
0.2229513824,
0.2950723469,
-0.1766004711,
0.4287504256,
-0.4275458753,
0.477820009,
-0.0270607788,
-0.0558011942,
0.1742848903,
-0.2677421868,
-0.1813089848,
0.1569106728,
0.5802717209,
0.1992813051,
0.4125444591,
-0.0411031954,
-0.1382530928,
0.0895039514,
0.3969447017,
-0.8124338984,
-0.4379643798,
0.3507319093,
-0.3353268802,
-0.5826990604,
0.0560098961,
-0.8110954165,
-0.6989284754,
-0.2571775019,
0.1516498476,
-0.4187543094,
-0.2934373617,
0.3785386086,
-0.0674758926,
0.12728782,
0.6793448329,
-0.6499484181,
0.1139339879,
0.8378490806,
0.4926492274,
-0.0325365141,
0.0467888601,
-0.6025179029,
0.2134939283,
-0.437425226,
0.7383543253,
-0.792463541,
-0.2973973453,
0.2156639546,
-0.303825587,
0.2879252434,
-0.4037604332,
0.3951984644,
-0.581392169,
-0.0036512548,
-0.0030170819,
-0.4593502581,
-0.4518265724,
0.3276362121,
-0.5199492574,
0.7707460523,
0.1106912345,
-0.4567442834,
0.7117963433,
-0.7405313253,
-0.4315294921,
0.2836418748,
-0.1184672341,
-0.6557805538,
0.32953462,
0.4516467452,
0.7997203469,
-0.283431828,
0.5906140804,
-0.4951658249,
0.0999275669,
0.6624407768,
-0.154181093,
0.4442222118,
0.1242475957,
-0.1048641875,
0.2328604758,
-0.7841116786,
-0.0417333022,
-0.0453136303,
-0.2189272195,
-0.3624688685,
0.2182521522,
-0.1176212803,
-0.1430998296,
0.1619655788,
-0.3735628426,
-0.0455121435,
-0.358882755,
0.4344759285,
0.5311425924,
0.2140986472,
0.554541707,
-0.0819724575,
0.578099966,
-0.0661323145,
0.055986397,
-0.1719608009,
-0.4925273359,
-0.6886183619,
-0.3196834922,
0.0842845887,
0.5640064478,
-0.6573055387,
0.5392455459,
-0.41869542,
-0.4526652098,
-0.6956847906,
0.0018761508,
0.4288655818,
0.3802630603,
0.3059029281,
-0.137796998,
-0.739436388,
-0.7893379927,
-0.4567133188,
-0.2699551284,
-0.2090532929,
0.2621601522,
0.8275303841,
-0.3261483312,
1.0772387981,
-0.7278240919,
-0.4456643462,
-0.3721411526,
0.3551208079,
0.2751654387,
0.3968063891,
0.224533394,
-0.9355839491,
-0.3019589782,
0.3564200401,
-1.0818785429,
-0.0365934856,
-0.2176692933,
0.1354663372,
-0.0461028889,
0.5868567228,
-0.4561556578,
0.3941436112,
0.3169602752,
-0.5246936083,
0.5640983582,
-0.1319121122,
0.2684522867,
-0.7379674315,
-0.0640570968,
0.3689703941,
-0.1395437717,
-0.8806217909,
0.1231107935,
0.2000275552,
-0.036268726,
-0.2444992363,
0.6285526752,
-0.5291576385,
-0.1030781493,
-0.0034089403,
-0.1300907582,
0.0169553682,
0.2466962337,
0.2336515486,
0.4911745489,
0.5285906196,
-0.4087944627,
0.2804918587,
0.2097395808,
-0.6821610928,
0.480594039,
-0.4958031178,
-0.0429889113,
0.0465916768,
-0.0937324464,
-0.4375597835,
-0.589774847,
-0.3071894348,
-0.9020284414,
0.4553115666,
-0.2133087367,
-0.3701844513,
-0.295191735,
-0.1161271781,
0.0984388962,
0.5450291634,
-0.1793392152,
0.8807459474,
0.5752502084,
-0.3696793914,
-0.5040631294,
-0.7182389498,
0.4135060906,
-0.5847233534,
-0.5818958879,
0.1196555868,
0.201269418,
-0.6685536504,
-0.0860002786,
0.167595461,
-0.2255588919,
0.4405466318,
0.3117286563,
0.4136367738,
-0.1873553097,
0.1168710366,
-0.1374012828,
-0.1496171355,
0.4970220029,
-0.3703323305,
-0.0085079307,
-0.0502758548,
-0.2790298164,
-0.3395115137,
0.3459646404,
0.6925752163,
-0.5735564232,
0.795044601,
0.4848729074,
-0.3866593242,
-0.1921449453,
-0.8374786973,
-0.365427494,
-0.4392538965,
0.7810388803,
-0.3697050512,
-1.1601537466,
0.6984983683,
-0.2152936459,
-0.1679115593,
0.3300318718,
0.34511742,
-0.359657824,
1.0623239279,
1.0090409517,
-0.0633406341,
0.2800286114,
-0.3605539501,
0.4207240641,
-0.6914232373,
-0.4581294954,
-0.4399843216,
0.1262260675,
-0.317448765,
-0.6435560584,
0.6787225604,
-0.1619382799,
-0.1459589452,
-0.0933436528,
-0.2467022538,
0.4178439975,
0.2002396584,
0.146200344,
0.325866729,
-0.071666114,
0.5907796621,
0.0341918319,
-0.541857779,
-0.6031060219,
1.4658304453,
0.7360885143,
0.7072981,
-0.0830644667,
0.5309495926,
0.4967642426,
0.3844140172,
-0.7593588233,
0.47536093,
-0.0772857442,
-0.4230079055,
-0.5336689353,
-0.349940896,
-0.4801433086,
0.0525109433,
-0.5975077152,
-0.4347120225,
0.2083367258,
0.1645880044,
-0.4821223915,
0.2162866145,
-0.5196562409,
0.559930563,
-0.4131065905,
-0.2657000422,
-0.3621936142,
-0.2275499105,
0.2692922354,
-0.4705909789,
0.3515090942,
-0.0633939356,
-0.2911870182,
0.7618582249,
-0.0792173892,
1.1038475037,
-0.1178008616,
-0.2194547206,
0.256275773,
0.2495541275,
0.8282361031,
0.1544474065,
-0.2966853976,
0.3867530525,
-0.453086257,
-0.2463469356,
-0.5571275949,
0.3380202949,
-0.5521939397,
-0.6973809004,
-0.1242945939,
-0.551428318,
-0.3685846329,
-0.0148195932,
-0.0316370018,
0.3857378364,
-0.282425344,
0.1960011274,
0.9866003394,
-0.1423856616,
0.1763562113,
0.6621911526,
0.2996979058,
-0.2930608988,
0.5848309398,
-0.1948549449,
0.105614841,
0.685518086,
0.0598563552,
-0.2055243552,
-1.3325462341,
-0.0740194991,
0.0999703631,
-0.7816343904,
-0.4016253352,
-0.9072853923,
0.0940416604,
-0.5213359594,
-0.5316479206,
-0.2532314658,
-0.0789452866,
-0.4564787447,
-0.488619417,
0.5480718017,
0.6056768894,
0.1910112053,
0.4077534974,
-0.8861503601,
-0.0029463372,
0.1975406259,
0.1730734259,
-0.1589274704,
-0.5779664516,
-0.7090820074,
-0.1293845177,
0.2340957522,
-0.5215931535,
0.9321776032,
0.0932895839,
0.6774765253,
0.5125680566,
-0.0174034648,
0.4888317883,
-0.2541278005,
0.5725703835,
0.2377472371,
-0.838011682,
0.7347584367,
-0.6269606948,
0.0306382068,
0.5734754205,
0.4645222127,
-0.0765743032,
-0.4172510803,
-0.3437599242,
-0.6256130338,
0.5583568811,
-0.0860959589,
-0.1574638933,
0.1820117235,
0.2750036716,
0.216420725,
0.2748435438,
-0.5685153604,
0.3636328876,
0.2123991996,
-0.2276733816,
-0.2477530986,
-0.5057623386,
-0.3462739885,
-0.0962072089,
0.4034302235,
-0.5088422894,
0.0904841945,
0.159025386,
-0.1849745959,
-0.0204380341,
0.2936542928,
0.3561684787,
0.8291426301,
-0.4714963138,
0.0490737036,
0.3865143061,
-0.3531432152,
-0.1583354771,
-0.139496088,
0.1796250045,
-0.3467715085,
1.0505437851,
0.66005373,
0.1637625545,
-0.922383666,
0.4300857484,
0.1642074734,
-0.4175237715,
-0.6274927258,
0.0197330862,
-0.0304573849,
0.392592907,
0.6407695413,
0.0218178015,
0.3332722187,
-0.6033275127,
0.0761387497,
0.4984206259,
-0.4356941879,
-0.2655324638,
0.5044845343,
0.6957787871,
-0.0407518297,
0.4078868926,
-0.0029190464,
-0.5787220001,
0.925278604,
0.0038296401,
1.1451954842,
-0.1333585829,
0.0458008721,
0.2272667289,
0.3892107308,
-0.0927051157,
0.1294207275,
0.1354246736,
-0.7235437632,
-0.7173022032,
-0.6938300133,
-0.4433501661,
-0.1052659303,
-0.7750335932,
0.1341443956,
-0.4373534918,
-0.1154309809,
0.0642556921,
-0.0733000487,
-0.7924578786,
0.252748251,
0.2614871264,
1.0239101648,
-0.9440675974,
0.8790423274,
0.4836565256,
-0.0306763221,
-0.4126524329,
-0.2992363274,
0.0983834192,
-0.8642184138,
0.9697290063,
0.0986901894,
-0.0795605928,
-0.2672136724,
-0.5687500238,
-0.896922648,
1.1069837809,
0.0737424567,
-0.7183874846,
0.0093427906,
0.179868415,
0.7188312411,
-0.8932017684,
0.1940674037,
1.0480285883,
0.4615148604,
-0.0203937236,
-0.8460964561,
0.0134464549,
0.029161565,
-0.2261032611,
0.3790331185,
-0.0663530603,
0.4747346044,
-0.6759257913,
-0.0587233007,
-0.3289669454,
0.6782535315,
-0.1150852963,
0.5718886256,
0.0899329558,
0.5531389117,
0.7980646491,
-0.0499963015,
1.1456097364,
-0.0109053943,
0.1038368568,
1.0619976521,
-0.3767940998,
0.8605414033,
0.3301405907,
-0.3141905665,
0.5581344366,
0.4192795753,
-0.234075129,
0.5256595612,
-0.1071527451,
-0.2464302331,
-0.5972222686,
-0.1281932741,
0.0229825098,
0.6721186638,
0.8306182623,
-0.4540150166,
0.28042382,
0.0525996871,
-0.1015432104,
0.271384567,
-0.771394372,
0.9907252789,
0.023697041,
-0.5031110644,
0.1623061299,
-0.167322889,
0.8491622806,
-0.7364333868,
-0.1962765753,
-0.0676235408,
0.2102082223,
-0.2985444367,
-1.0877630711,
0.2574065328,
0.0321903341,
-0.1462008059,
-0.4143249691,
0.6665011048,
-0.2458797842,
-0.580871284,
0.383353442,
0.4763740599,
-0.0708306357,
-0.382424742,
-0.4281867743,
-0.0941777751,
0.1886981577,
-0.1090324372,
0.3848419487,
0.5955138206,
-0.1265824884,
1.135694623,
0.6589553952,
0.4549476504,
-0.3059413135,
-0.0506016761,
0.8211975098,
-0.7964357138,
-0.5228558779,
-0.905536592,
0.7282709479,
-0.2117523402,
0.0264720153,
0.6147787571,
0.2270957679,
0.6110343337,
-0.1903961301,
0.9634396434,
0.3542977571,
0.5213216543,
-0.6714870334,
0.6610042453,
-0.2269455194,
0.4630095065,
0.0101339463,
-0.4326632619,
-0.3109856248,
0.1839864999,
-0.5677494407,
-0.1311713606,
0.4287925959,
0.6150503159,
0.2916331589,
-0.2867793143,
0.6072458625,
0.1746433228,
0.5873199105,
0.6754761934,
0.7657652497,
-0.0007650382,
0.440336585,
-0.0152950985,
-0.447420001,
-0.5196559429,
-1.013050437,
-1.2286554575,
-0.4110177159,
-0.4883285463,
0.0304066278,
0.0109714037,
0.3858732879,
0.8107335567,
-0.7674823999,
-0.0220777486,
0.1263664663,
-0.0221210923,
-0.0046177087,
-0.2222320586,
0.3672986925,
-0.106447503,
-0.4093129039,
0.3626278639,
0.5736295581,
0.083940722,
-0.3552893102,
-0.0517085679,
0.23968485,
0.0926748514,
0.7181572914,
-0.0032760231,
-0.6437779069,
-0.2093551755,
-0.0629751757,
0.1851181984,
-0.3204518855,
0.9442142248,
-1.0051984787,
0.3795848787,
0.2310595959,
0.7876389027,
0.4438392818,
-0.1535914838,
0.8078271151,
-0.5653486252,
0.0712581575,
0.6170035005,
0.4530691504,
0.3025137484,
-0.8383206129,
0.7890853286,
-0.1854104549,
-0.4832883477,
-0.9153699875,
0.1170028746,
-0.8220570683,
-0.3868047893,
1.0117144585,
-0.3238860965,
0.0065620453,
-0.3691993356,
0.2458361238,
-0.0964801013,
-0.5009105206,
0.9141790271,
0.4648022056,
-0.2400046438,
-0.2653036118,
-0.749438107,
0.6872270703,
0.2480067909,
-1.1096345186,
0.4404960573,
0.5187076926,
-0.0069022262,
0.1642331034,
0.2859475911,
-0.049144119,
0.2625312507,
-0.0139315929,
0.2319774181,
-0.3581503332,
-0.4052613378,
-0.5473867655,
0.2086746693,
0.1070554405,
0.2361825556
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07010v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07010v1
|
Deciphering public attention to geoengineering and climate issues using machine learning and dynamic analysis
| 2024-05-11T13:10:57 | 2024-05-11T13:10:57 |
Ramit Debnath, Pengyu Zhang, Tianzhu Qin, R. Michael Alvarez, Shaun D. Fitzgerald
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, J.4; K.4
|
As the conversation around using geoengineering to combat climate change
intensifies, it is imperative to engage the public and deeply understand their
perspectives on geoengineering research, development, and potential deployment.
Through a comprehensive data-driven investigation, this paper explores the
types of news that captivate public interest in geoengineering. We delved into
30,773 English-language news articles from the BBC and the New York Times,
combined with Google Trends data spanning 2018 to 2022, to explore how public
interest in geoengineering fluctuates in response to news coverage of broader
climate issues. Using BERT-based topic modeling, sentiment analysis, and
time-series regression models, we found that positive sentiment in
energy-related news serves as a good predictor of heightened public interest in
geoengineering, a trend that persists over time. Our findings suggest that
public engagement with geoengineering and climate action is not uniform, with
some topics being more potent in shaping interest over time, such as climate
news related to energy, disasters, and politics. Understanding these patterns
is crucial for scientists, policymakers, and educators aiming to craft
effective strategies for engaging with the public and fostering dialogue around
emerging climate technologies.
|
[
-0.6991123557,
-0.8876965046,
0.9761689305,
0.2667475343,
-0.2012156099,
0.1134771407,
-0.191736415,
-0.2167101055,
0.2905046642,
-0.0112826759,
-0.546456039,
-0.6305832863,
-0.6027441621,
-0.3330007792,
-0.6588920355,
1.0963045359,
-0.231487602,
-0.2031999081,
-0.0808678493,
0.257173717,
-0.206493035,
-0.4380431771,
-0.1102560312,
-0.2087001801,
1.0333840847,
0.115277648,
0.7342463136,
0.3769733012,
0.2678990066,
0.210746184,
-0.4678944647,
-0.279512614,
-0.5855400562,
-0.2312848717,
-0.187143147,
-0.1463259459,
0.1832954139,
0.7017918825,
0.698101759,
0.5653926134,
0.1640089452,
0.4456396699,
0.0711883828,
0.4096543789,
-0.5601255298,
0.3993907571,
-0.865572989,
-0.1048735082,
-0.1021484882,
-0.1539919525,
-0.1047013253,
-0.364226222,
0.3776762486,
-0.4732189775,
0.5149758458,
0.0429633446,
0.8951784372,
0.4008954465,
-0.3875668645,
-0.1403807998,
-0.476546973,
0.9322388768,
-0.3283173144,
0.3486330509,
0.1199721992,
0.1485120356,
-0.2233325392,
-0.1404627264,
-0.6527782679,
-0.0354078859,
-0.1054045334,
0.2092486024,
0.2049967349,
-0.3121299744,
0.1875840425,
0.1621756107,
-0.6782639027,
0.0043836306,
-0.2556155026,
-0.0257724915,
0.5238204598,
-0.178500101,
0.1263620257,
-0.423579216,
-0.5518579483,
-0.0193871558,
-0.6540639997,
0.1999949962,
0.9061931968,
0.2906491458,
-0.2327728868,
0.3886657953,
-0.1839544773,
0.3927254975,
-0.2737592757,
0.4871652424,
0.0012815228,
-0.1763589382,
-0.3287360966,
0.508410573,
0.3148222566,
0.4818896651,
-0.0947282091,
-0.2257384956,
0.3041390777,
-0.0815115124,
0.3224667609,
-0.6779572964,
-0.1514986306,
0.3120066226,
-0.6233434677,
-0.4721393585,
0.6428261995,
-1.1345059872,
-0.6990292668,
-0.5119453669,
-0.037433587,
0.5838836432,
-0.3270933628,
0.3572919965,
-0.5286318064,
0.2407485843,
0.5026217103,
-0.4610547721,
-0.4324093461,
0.9952874184,
0.7665676475,
0.159781605,
-0.2603986263,
-0.0023396802,
0.0090911239,
-0.2377460748,
0.7420560122,
-0.7269726992,
-0.443231672,
-0.0549465828,
0.4448163509,
-0.0948325917,
0.0749511793,
0.1008047238,
-0.751521647,
0.7387816906,
-0.4243710041,
-0.0511993095,
-0.6260461807,
0.2446027249,
-0.4736538231,
0.8531714082,
-0.1107173786,
-0.8296089768,
0.7084235549,
-0.7336531281,
-0.2578410506,
-0.2000728548,
0.0354676731,
-0.6292098165,
0.2548747361,
0.2193130702,
0.2026813775,
-0.2152099013,
0.5727782249,
-0.4359164238,
-0.1236660033,
0.1712875068,
-0.4237050116,
0.3330639303,
0.0246428642,
-0.5118157268,
0.0457317755,
-0.3690618575,
-0.1673685312,
-0.097378172,
-0.2002666295,
-0.1338430345,
0.5067662597,
0.026232088,
0.2508930862,
0.262180537,
-0.5663161278,
0.3068376482,
-0.3516080081,
0.6361854076,
0.6460048556,
0.5776490569,
0.3114146292,
-0.2367405593,
0.3765413761,
-0.1265020072,
0.1018904448,
-0.2139247358,
-0.584659934,
-0.50579983,
0.2431491911,
0.0369329527,
0.4704771042,
-0.0896253735,
0.2020538449,
-0.1890657842,
-0.7976734638,
-0.449121654,
-0.1182953268,
-0.245236963,
0.4787679315,
0.3691598177,
0.1809156686,
-0.2847893536,
-0.4454019368,
-0.5904568434,
-0.115444243,
0.0328528173,
0.5484149456,
0.1414067447,
-0.0463855639,
1.0245517492,
-0.6463953853,
0.324824512,
0.1618189216,
0.8777037263,
0.411823988,
0.1188536957,
0.8241007924,
-1.1452862024,
-0.3684348166,
0.2614727318,
-0.2561296523,
0.2855034173,
-0.2408971786,
0.0748944357,
-0.0308881551,
0.3996479809,
-0.2754155397,
0.4633075297,
0.3713204265,
-0.2114990354,
0.2612687051,
0.1666092575,
0.7144668102,
-0.5686138868,
0.1999666989,
0.3066701591,
-0.0082490835,
-0.4085520208,
-0.4965126216,
-0.3591656387,
-0.753806591,
-0.608525455,
0.4129430056,
-0.2553032339,
-0.0687808469,
-0.3096910417,
-0.0110668205,
-0.0801182464,
-0.0294349175,
0.2463303506,
0.6208812594,
0.7879051566,
-0.4149107635,
0.4933378994,
-0.0253675617,
-0.630507946,
-0.3998061419,
-0.5664964318,
0.3303703964,
-0.4661135972,
0.2992316186,
-0.9319477677,
-0.6468109488,
-0.2225406021,
-0.5205339193,
0.0047610034,
-0.1929750592,
-0.3311011791,
-0.7755439878,
-0.2927426994,
-0.34161672,
0.3242514431,
-0.6024661064,
0.5329148173,
0.2343284935,
-0.3702704012,
-0.3493210971,
-0.6696600318,
-0.0042740861,
-0.475173682,
-0.4833748639,
0.1749476194,
0.2685823441,
-0.2152090073,
0.133624956,
-0.4422069192,
-0.0168777201,
0.6441064477,
0.2209520936,
-0.1102791205,
-0.0113307936,
0.0416453369,
-0.3669819534,
-0.2483630031,
0.4219018817,
-0.3861428201,
0.604185164,
0.130648151,
-0.2837985456,
-0.6415402889,
0.3130893409,
0.8147855997,
-0.0624629222,
0.6490168571,
0.6757506728,
-0.1919375956,
0.0319522023,
-0.2248424441,
-0.3439760804,
-0.4486273527,
0.3652956486,
0.2732070088,
-0.7603515983,
0.2696719766,
-0.4656069577,
0.0678798482,
0.2873687148,
0.5584486127,
-0.2307871729,
1.2466642857,
0.5792175531,
-0.5894465446,
0.6221515536,
-0.0940385535,
0.4962229729,
-0.35519889,
-0.2056358308,
-0.6385394931,
-0.5625588894,
-0.824367106,
0.1711708307,
0.1266124249,
-0.2042853385,
-0.1088867337,
0.1591872871,
-0.6398759484,
0.4727054834,
0.3505298197,
-0.076163955,
-0.3276669681,
0.0655713379,
0.7030782104,
0.1251658797,
-0.1978266835,
-0.5090093017,
0.4272073507,
0.1676554531,
0.6311021447,
0.0902957097,
0.3350374997,
0.4734723866,
0.2678284645,
-0.8750171661,
0.2135662884,
0.1398579031,
-0.6193341017,
-0.190432623,
-0.3894558251,
-0.9284539223,
-0.11450167,
-0.2019629776,
-0.6054498553,
0.3308109343,
0.2264157236,
-0.2446355224,
0.4035609365,
-0.7314253449,
0.7106070518,
-0.1913255602,
-0.106444262,
-0.6316643357,
-0.4864210188,
-0.0401938148,
-0.0155671053,
0.3071307838,
-0.3978981674,
0.2434976101,
0.2160652429,
0.0910498202,
0.6585118771,
-0.4547994733,
-0.1036699489,
0.2641981244,
-0.3725874126,
0.5243381858,
0.3684708774,
-0.1981454343,
-0.0814666897,
-0.6877409816,
-0.4683566689,
-0.4419656992,
0.9501997828,
-0.784130156,
-1.1492307186,
-0.4388634264,
-0.322435081,
-0.1542547047,
-0.0609932356,
0.0696690232,
0.1254578978,
-0.2708730698,
0.2230100185,
0.7719916701,
-0.0040126331,
0.6819645762,
0.2171143293,
0.0482855625,
-0.1575953513,
1.1294583082,
0.1538685411,
0.0767812729,
0.3010514081,
0.3738692701,
0.0059432983,
-0.47066921,
0.0043842015,
-0.0337360948,
-0.1774638593,
0.1241879165,
-0.5842604637,
0.1497142017,
-0.3776489794,
-0.4149070382,
0.128845945,
-0.021889206,
-0.724542439,
-0.1874479651,
0.3301406801,
0.7040808797,
0.3337902129,
0.3488989174,
-0.6256610155,
0.0003567231,
0.4180452228,
0.0534925796,
-0.105875358,
0.2163754404,
-0.3137741685,
-0.0343559273,
-0.5086145997,
-0.7015241981,
0.462777555,
-0.0601725318,
0.6124840975,
0.5490449071,
-0.2061167806,
0.2762871683,
-0.2196002454,
1.2152178288,
0.1300188899,
-0.9164270759,
0.7991553545,
-0.7026494145,
0.2201672196,
0.1227622405,
0.8639519215,
-0.486887455,
-0.1330781728,
-0.6548003554,
-0.8033291101,
0.6231114268,
-0.2737256289,
0.269593358,
0.0517485105,
0.1032788157,
-0.020848928,
0.6176834106,
-0.4331233799,
0.0180513039,
-0.6674146056,
0.1222836822,
-0.1091130227,
0.0154958852,
-0.2352024913,
0.0938591734,
0.5990598798,
-0.1239665672,
0.2356387377,
0.0639324114,
0.0944235399,
0.044808384,
0.5161672235,
0.6981951594,
0.486135751,
-0.4456303716,
0.0062696235,
0.0031817961,
-0.6091582775,
-0.0910216421,
0.3250511587,
-0.3963984847,
0.0344346091,
-0.1021663174,
0.723017931,
0.1886065751,
-0.1201254353,
0.2572171688,
0.268925637,
-0.3815051615,
0.1474412382,
-0.0446795374,
0.0362458713,
0.2160714269,
0.5251526237,
0.1325857192,
0.2756640613,
-0.9136057496,
-0.2923760712,
0.3762617111,
-0.6257491708,
-0.6648851037,
0.8853333592,
0.5545957685,
0.2668600976,
0.3729468286,
0.1051299497,
-0.8093605042,
0.8762891293,
0.1147931069,
0.7370502353,
0.2546593249,
0.1552195996,
0.1690624207,
0.0997267142,
0.1312950552,
0.3502060473,
-0.0694653019,
-0.4303004146,
-0.3542643189,
-0.2686392963,
-0.3082590401,
0.2666805089,
-0.5670554042,
0.6004458666,
-0.3355575502,
-0.4319896102,
0.0069436738,
0.2497270703,
-0.64013201,
0.1283354461,
0.295586735,
0.7644688487,
-1.0168731213,
0.3944625258,
1.0123273134,
-0.1233380809,
-0.3625195324,
0.465407759,
0.3629487157,
-0.3244298697,
0.5513988137,
0.4426662326,
0.0364697427,
0.1134184226,
-1.0078986883,
-1.1224981546,
1.2377922535,
0.1292595863,
-0.2711366117,
0.0564247519,
-0.1531345248,
-0.0779041424,
-0.2376498878,
-0.0814512148,
0.3942002952,
0.9870060086,
-0.3333062828,
-0.4326096475,
-0.40234828,
0.1966934204,
-0.1100018844,
0.6633290052,
-1.2225536108,
0.4355920255,
-0.0026524102,
-0.5758240223,
-0.2241244912,
0.8220081925,
-0.0563025549,
0.9594250321,
0.550465703,
0.3654447198,
0.8770874739,
-0.3809218705,
1.0409091711,
-0.4569282532,
0.6750754714,
0.4644435644,
-0.3318587244,
0.4362328649,
0.3714931309,
-0.0657831579,
0.7002218962,
0.7951133847,
-0.3909607828,
0.974470973,
0.1947984695,
-0.38159886,
-0.281450361,
-0.4247863889,
-0.4269699454,
0.2923820615,
0.3999097049,
-0.1764138788,
-0.5252078772,
0.1788718402,
0.085299775,
-0.1009350419,
-0.3657393456,
0.6139208674,
-0.3589142859,
-0.5063973069,
-0.3051448464,
-0.2775411606,
0.4741245508,
-0.4315852821,
0.0316720195,
0.2433442026,
-0.3704589307,
-0.3243384361,
-1.0376772881,
0.1003617123,
0.1113739237,
-0.6177766323,
-0.4892152846,
0.4936671555,
-0.169677794,
-0.1089491025,
0.0191447362,
0.0558420494,
0.0763507858,
-0.1238421202,
-0.5239856243,
0.0222485159,
0.3163041472,
-0.5627848506,
0.1929014474,
0.3317176402,
0.1788526475,
0.174345687,
0.8576616645,
-0.1609960943,
-0.1380428821,
0.2131149024,
1.1251996756,
-0.6411334276,
-0.3424950242,
-0.4146648347,
0.3999613523,
-0.2520528436,
-0.3797513247,
0.7875566483,
0.5253518224,
0.5003578067,
-0.0604725778,
1.1141477823,
0.0226760898,
0.3313114643,
-0.3685335219,
0.4890013635,
-0.2941712439,
0.0165849719,
0.3134851754,
-0.650298059,
0.0050108326,
0.158515662,
-0.8659970164,
0.0511017255,
0.2297935039,
0.3422435224,
0.0104809646,
0.3634861112,
-0.0325798951,
0.0415486209,
0.5336016417,
0.1368128806,
0.8743076324,
0.3152280748,
0.2490376681,
0.009907987,
-0.1860136092,
-0.2791575193,
-1.1791180372,
-0.5754055977,
-0.1421429068,
-0.2891030312,
-0.0842061341,
-0.1185148433,
0.6870456934,
0.7259438038,
-0.8152186275,
0.403832227,
-0.5130853057,
0.3577484488,
-0.0587948114,
-0.3733169436,
0.5172243118,
-0.4314295948,
-0.8572279811,
0.4250264168,
0.1549062729,
0.0667472929,
-0.5479626656,
0.7350317836,
-0.1412093192,
0.1705201268,
0.2589044273,
0.492423147,
-0.4336230457,
-0.4802732468,
0.244537577,
0.0670266375,
0.0163641404,
0.8939760327,
-0.8936939836,
0.1016860232,
0.744079113,
0.7275311351,
0.5513641834,
0.4592150748,
0.2670593262,
-0.7983320355,
0.2474550754,
0.0241341181,
0.2010149509,
0.398347497,
-0.6975783706,
0.1551242769,
0.3760040104,
-1.0647346973,
-0.486397028,
0.0962381884,
-0.599375844,
-0.3263368011,
0.9548272491,
0.067987591,
-0.358633101,
-0.0819711909,
0.0280269608,
-0.2690505981,
-0.6027228236,
0.9609313607,
1.0795311928,
-0.2567232549,
0.0477285422,
-0.5443875194,
0.188379392,
-0.0077018561,
-0.6666315794,
0.0923007056,
0.4725217819,
-0.026993122,
0.4986723065,
-0.5489100814,
0.1618205458,
0.087944448,
-0.3766082227,
-0.1026183963,
0.0660419986,
-0.5967183709,
-0.052257482,
0.1689782888,
-0.3479794264,
-0.1166824549
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07006v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07006v1
|
Word-specific tonal realizations in Mandarin
| 2024-05-11T13:00:35 | 2024-05-11T13:00:35 |
Yu-Ying Chuang, Melanie J. Bell, Yu-Hsiang Tseng, R. Harald Baayen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The pitch contours of Mandarin two-character words are generally understood
as being shaped by the underlying tones of the constituent single-character
words, in interaction with articulatory constraints imposed by factors such as
speech rate, co-articulation with adjacent tones, segmental make-up, and
predictability. This study shows that tonal realization is also partially
determined by words' meanings. We first show, on the basis of a Taiwan corpus
of spontaneous conversations, using the generalized additive regression model,
and focusing on the rise-fall tone pattern, that after controlling for effects
of speaker and context, word type is a stronger predictor of pitch realization
than all the previously established word-form related predictors combined.
Importantly, the addition of information about meaning in context improves
prediction accuracy even further. We then proceed to show, using computational
modeling with context-specific word embeddings, that token-specific pitch
contours predict word type with 50% accuracy on held-out data, and that
context-sensitive, token-specific embeddings can predict the shape of pitch
contours with 30% accuracy. These accuracies, which are an order of magnitude
above chance level, suggest that the relation between words' pitch contours and
their meanings are sufficiently strong to be functional for language users. The
theoretical implications of these empirical findings are discussed.
|
[
-0.1964493841,
-0.7250100374,
0.4223477542,
0.7222895026,
-0.5122411251,
-0.1417146772,
-0.3260106146,
-0.4268407226,
0.5019621849,
0.6876056194,
-0.2312518656,
-0.3505698144,
-0.0680688247,
-0.0839375556,
-0.5279794335,
0.6382748485,
0.2230814099,
0.1402953863,
0.2360259891,
-0.2191761732,
-0.940630734,
-0.6038187146,
-0.4377766252,
-0.2101262212,
0.211346209,
0.100490503,
0.8919148445,
0.6759271622,
0.4491315186,
0.2177491486,
-0.2710773945,
-0.4215578437,
-0.1951932609,
0.08321964,
0.3274928331,
-0.6699813008,
-0.0911528096,
0.2570011318,
0.636356771,
0.9108871818,
-0.3799824119,
-0.438018322,
0.2548367679,
0.4707790613,
-0.0162043869,
0.1300908923,
-1.0556471348,
0.5082079172,
-0.1799002737,
-0.5195272565,
-0.3530994058,
-0.1064333171,
0.5001471043,
-0.640213728,
0.450088352,
0.227259025,
0.8689914346,
0.067810677,
-0.3764237761,
-0.566026628,
-0.6402974129,
0.6577297449,
-0.6465239525,
0.3794249296,
0.1559790373,
0.487400353,
-0.2836665213,
-0.5505937338,
-0.4381254613,
-0.7816862464,
-0.5160560012,
0.2449757457,
0.3965749741,
0.7172432542,
0.3229133487,
0.8421545029,
-0.2282031029,
-0.3606019318,
-0.119137682,
-0.2894105613,
0.3491433263,
0.341924876,
0.6593385339,
-0.5231118798,
-0.5051708817,
0.3477835655,
-0.9223822951,
0.368863225,
0.1330277771,
0.7847227454,
-0.2729439139,
0.568877995,
-0.0724982768,
0.7011271119,
0.0286817718,
-0.161440894,
0.2292784899,
-0.5857176185,
-0.2739190459,
0.3712751269,
0.4309643209,
-0.1220050305,
0.449759841,
-0.0973910019,
-0.2832880318,
-0.0325432234,
-0.1006659195,
-0.5262179971,
0.0210935976,
0.030229697,
-0.3336295485,
-0.2133845836,
0.4223218262,
-0.0510589965,
-0.7340901494,
-0.6292521954,
0.4593887031,
-0.5748236179,
-0.306335777,
0.1651880294,
-0.3459331691,
0.3447035849,
0.2523222566,
-0.922763288,
0.0920726582,
0.6627756357,
1.0229084492,
-0.0203545298,
-0.1366752982,
-0.1764907092,
0.1166763827,
-0.7187217474,
0.3988787234,
-0.3881810009,
-0.459143728,
0.1932151616,
-0.1680531353,
-0.2351877242,
-0.4684383273,
0.5191328526,
-0.0740774348,
0.0007147789,
-0.3358365595,
-0.4893382788,
-0.3877586126,
-0.0275782328,
-0.609863162,
0.526237607,
0.3903575838,
-0.7458507419,
0.5791367292,
-0.0262436457,
-0.7783523202,
0.3836579621,
-0.7422190905,
0.1162130386,
0.6718111038,
-0.3003367484,
0.2264966369,
-0.2034465373,
0.3107405305,
0.1493226886,
-0.5076514482,
0.2940296233,
-0.26379776,
0.6315518022,
0.0639466494,
-0.5015978813,
0.1432859153,
-0.4965636432,
-0.0301806629,
-0.0088947713,
-0.4692899585,
-0.1999429613,
0.1084627658,
0.2080294639,
0.0205423832,
0.1286595017,
-0.4462316036,
-0.0665072426,
-0.6292717457,
0.5594869256,
0.5620974898,
0.0726615191,
0.2708108425,
-0.3832146525,
0.5615028143,
0.0569782443,
-0.0208767354,
-0.4928906262,
-0.491029948,
-0.6344998479,
-0.3032213449,
-0.0214839559,
0.4081556499,
-0.1802939624,
0.2376458645,
-0.0163350906,
-0.4499780536,
-0.3202059567,
-0.1759376377,
0.4288208187,
0.6995573044,
0.0891876444,
-0.1349619627,
-0.7320402265,
-0.8696172833,
-0.5258206725,
-0.3408609331,
-0.1434819698,
0.7455064058,
-0.2288816273,
0.2338976264,
0.9188352823,
-0.4736757278,
-0.6810127497,
-0.3774754405,
0.1812408566,
0.4693615139,
0.3388075829,
0.6745578051,
-0.9974692464,
-0.6824750304,
0.0656370595,
-0.463968128,
0.0189462304,
-0.3560181856,
0.1960969418,
0.166603595,
0.4740320146,
-0.2182530314,
0.4112359285,
0.4375958741,
-0.5595769286,
0.7167059779,
-0.0805340484,
-0.0582770519,
-0.7861916423,
-0.197913751,
-0.1379048377,
0.1545044333,
-1.0782623291,
-0.1377265453,
-0.1893549114,
0.0986874029,
-0.4300200641,
0.4696867466,
-0.4591305256,
-0.2767512202,
-0.1755481958,
0.2486078143,
-0.0885506943,
0.4413321018,
0.3494797945,
0.6873018742,
0.4431433678,
-0.6294734478,
0.1680264026,
0.0990891755,
-0.8045377135,
0.2521677911,
-1.0195065737,
-0.1360632628,
-0.0697458163,
0.0700383261,
-1.1547448635,
-0.1648762375,
-0.0158632528,
-0.393517524,
0.1518985331,
-0.0476352386,
-0.0629342273,
-0.057640411,
-0.1846005917,
0.5041303039,
0.3864589036,
-0.1871890724,
0.5172427297,
0.4916177392,
0.1016445234,
-0.159829855,
-0.9390121698,
0.0184711516,
-0.2344455421,
-0.4314634204,
0.6150476933,
0.0329077169,
-0.2809829116,
-0.2419346422,
0.1840464622,
0.2351006567,
0.0558205508,
0.4860619009,
-0.0875240415,
-0.4112875164,
0.178398937,
-0.2279410958,
0.2016638517,
-0.2197767794,
-0.0601151399,
0.8134711385,
-0.1096687838,
-0.1031729132,
-0.2701450586,
0.0689382851,
0.5371602774,
-0.0199186802,
0.4052051306,
0.5412865281,
-0.4698879123,
0.0130097987,
-0.2461510897,
0.0051698908,
-0.4687109888,
0.3000349998,
-0.7021667957,
-0.7123491168,
0.7492574453,
0.5341789126,
-0.3044591248,
0.4240319729,
0.3991666436,
0.1102440134,
1.3518387079,
0.6241686344,
-0.0513033569,
0.9392214417,
-0.1777318716,
0.129846856,
-1.0742907524,
-0.1800176799,
-0.3414903283,
-0.1154881939,
-0.9907018542,
-0.0940480828,
0.4208339453,
0.2757771313,
-0.2234448493,
0.3323704004,
-0.4867545366,
-0.0028848674,
0.6222387552,
-0.2511879802,
0.0157454927,
0.0325136222,
-0.4310010374,
-0.2154990137,
-0.3435917497,
-0.2090997994,
0.4978744388,
0.1453130692,
0.4143333435,
-0.1010964289,
0.223966971,
0.1617476493,
0.0352683552,
-1.0856451988,
0.3146095872,
-0.3320371807,
-0.6370812654,
-0.3654125035,
-0.1013523713,
-0.6931650639,
0.4077210724,
-0.2410571426,
-0.7142095566,
-0.0448393635,
0.1552472413,
-0.2640982866,
-0.0659810603,
-0.402210176,
0.6199381351,
-0.32051,
0.4480981529,
-0.3512678742,
-0.3182159662,
0.3702557385,
0.0477919467,
0.1341981739,
-0.7043619752,
0.070246473,
0.62022686,
-0.3882572949,
0.5261006355,
-0.4139063358,
0.0444286987,
0.6545761824,
0.176263839,
0.2512120306,
-0.1094137579,
-0.1090996265,
0.0935782492,
0.1686764657,
-0.1259731799,
-0.5893586278,
0.3436193466,
-0.6171228886,
-0.8338441253,
-0.2271307111,
-0.4454533756,
-0.212572068,
0.2214950472,
0.4834137559,
0.7418636084,
-0.4281974137,
-0.0661997795,
-0.041076377,
-0.4401699305,
0.2879348099,
0.3664094806,
-0.5159012675,
-0.5694997311,
0.9106304646,
0.3171423674,
0.2215207368,
0.6153948903,
0.6583032608,
-0.2405514568,
-0.6019209027,
-0.3011016846,
0.2291867435,
-0.4294104874,
0.1263458282,
-0.2438502908,
-0.4878213108,
-0.4077942669,
-0.3355577588,
0.1460286528,
-0.6649798155,
-0.2566873133,
-0.1321025789,
0.1886917353,
0.7470229864,
0.1230807826,
0.5628529787,
-0.5780613422,
0.2463728487,
0.1294369251,
0.2458021939,
0.1458985507,
-0.8733620048,
-0.2529987395,
0.2759437859,
0.244732812,
-0.852080822,
0.3398192227,
0.4715136886,
0.4433988631,
0.9268750548,
-0.1363240778,
0.5571145415,
-0.4886057377,
0.9701594114,
0.2818022966,
-1.1850936413,
0.5571603775,
-0.5970602036,
0.0913911462,
0.4810091853,
-0.2092381418,
-1.370354414,
-0.5022599101,
-0.3292644024,
-0.8798801303,
0.6315180063,
0.0907425433,
0.5630761385,
-0.0107903872,
0.3814500272,
0.0189635586,
0.3910073638,
-0.3978937566,
-0.1570788622,
-0.4173869491,
-0.1463294923,
-0.174931556,
-0.3506811857,
0.1301809996,
-0.2472214699,
0.2089841664,
-0.0815932155,
0.3846057057,
0.1466808915,
-0.0436642617,
0.1142836064,
-0.0223315954,
0.8792438507,
0.3852500916,
-0.393625766,
0.2860929072,
-0.0566660278,
-0.6634562016,
-0.0455480739,
-0.3307603002,
-0.3649187684,
0.2765518725,
0.5868311524,
0.8315603733,
0.0410428494,
-0.4957535267,
0.5302214026,
0.104486689,
0.1035618484,
-0.6127637029,
-0.0024884383,
-0.082029961,
-0.3457833827,
0.4953022599,
-0.2441165298,
0.17316477,
-0.7599022388,
0.0001670691,
0.606292963,
-0.8670420647,
-0.7561801672,
0.6109068394,
0.0567513444,
-0.2440589964,
0.5456385016,
-0.0591061004,
-0.8649509549,
0.9849938154,
0.8464368582,
1.0815310478,
-0.2908702493,
0.1793499291,
0.5716313124,
0.0508938245,
0.1618026048,
0.6017688513,
-0.0080456287,
-1.116445303,
0.1208329126,
-0.8535862565,
-0.2036073655,
-0.1589410752,
-0.4196374416,
0.4600373805,
-0.7084692717,
0.0697911009,
0.0444278754,
-0.0060527814,
-0.5062391162,
0.5086058378,
0.2461695373,
0.8379421234,
-0.7441924214,
0.4753838181,
0.5702350736,
-0.6640293002,
-1.2912254333,
0.0113835158,
0.0192101132,
-0.8991388679,
0.3258330524,
0.5164036751,
-0.1154713854,
-0.0640375316,
-0.1327349395,
-1.0078847408,
0.896719873,
0.2896021903,
-0.3865628541,
-0.0403129347,
0.8021283746,
0.7263623476,
-0.6083880067,
0.238084808,
0.6578391194,
0.5093485713,
0.2920041084,
-0.9056726098,
0.2510254979,
0.1102398112,
0.2570436895,
0.0311730597,
-0.5707588792,
0.9910888672,
-0.1417436004,
-0.6543895602,
0.1870672405,
0.6792350411,
0.1704636961,
-0.061211504,
0.680619657,
0.1433894038,
0.5781049728,
-0.0894690603,
0.7551013827,
-0.7929369807,
0.021047784,
0.5633552074,
0.2308266908,
0.7130873799,
0.1704081744,
-0.28284657,
0.3307066858,
0.6009970307,
0.1118048579,
0.5778797269,
0.471714437,
-0.3687433302,
0.1523871273,
-0.771581769,
-0.1972883344,
0.7998089194,
0.6292111874,
-0.5859383345,
0.4555302858,
-0.1182624027,
0.0443479531,
-0.0277182367,
-0.5223385096,
0.5876697302,
0.4173030257,
-0.7703568935,
0.5879383683,
0.0000433963,
0.6529652476,
-0.4339825809,
0.0344555601,
-0.413779825,
0.0157065429,
-0.357814163,
-0.6958912015,
0.3727038503,
-0.5068907738,
0.0395022258,
-0.0044832192,
0.4975894392,
-0.6679861546,
-0.2367164046,
0.1314682364,
0.2308901399,
0.1351561397,
-0.2837621868,
-0.3761388361,
-0.2472122908,
0.0525096618,
-0.0850258395,
-0.1091753319,
0.4824185073,
0.1192820966,
0.1311796755,
0.1673563868,
0.4578026235,
0.1300619841,
0.5607362986,
0.3291336298,
-0.8887929916,
-0.7412417531,
-0.6381321549,
0.1531431973,
0.4183357656,
-0.4291994274,
0.5030236244,
0.4455532134,
0.6624089479,
0.1016402617,
0.8914359808,
-0.0231462959,
0.2314338088,
-0.6206799746,
0.7801474333,
-0.453451246,
-0.1726512313,
-0.3051761389,
-0.8272712231,
-0.3812984526,
0.4463607669,
-0.1732324213,
0.0831564516,
0.6423831582,
0.6161604524,
0.2393085063,
0.1272994876,
0.4969944954,
0.0764389038,
0.290597856,
0.1933284104,
0.8871532679,
0.0336139724,
0.3661971092,
-0.2479569614,
0.0388027504,
-0.3672511578,
-0.5951133966,
-0.5035585761,
-0.9143009186,
0.0533139519,
-0.1176908687,
-0.4005934894,
0.6941091418,
0.5312237144,
-1.0147635937,
-0.4531047344,
-0.5541664958,
0.2119833678,
-0.394734323,
-0.2996316254,
0.6278947592,
-0.4693337381,
-0.5176752806,
0.2072456181,
0.3426082134,
0.418897748,
-0.1885598749,
-0.012651626,
0.2832194269,
0.4906766117,
0.4828290641,
0.2264693677,
-1.0467157364,
-0.6436724067,
0.0693195313,
-0.4416475892,
0.3105561137,
1.2217552662,
-0.6817616224,
0.3946941495,
0.7509205341,
0.0460014455,
0.047624927,
0.0809345171,
0.7211897373,
-0.7390240431,
0.3462744355,
0.2390935868,
0.6715270281,
0.4704643786,
-0.3509991467,
0.3909813762,
0.3815322518,
0.0153278317,
-0.7206993699,
0.7053921819,
-0.7768759727,
-0.0371361747,
1.3225351572,
-0.1266145408,
-0.042675525,
-0.0302881151,
-0.4287919402,
0.4682976604,
-0.0397700407,
0.5876737237,
0.567969203,
-0.3606532514,
0.1162418276,
-0.2607965171,
1.005287528,
0.4701991081,
-0.1092534438,
0.1820974052,
0.4250198901,
0.0079101706,
0.2175599933,
0.8060756326,
0.1026915163,
0.0149609521,
0.2076167017,
-0.0906247422,
0.1603042781,
-0.288510859,
-0.3703739941,
0.1527864039,
0.3493487537,
-0.1941394806
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07001v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07001v2
|
Evaluating Task-based Effectiveness of MLLMs on Charts
| 2024-05-11T12:33:46 | 2024-06-17T15:44:33 |
Yifan Wu, Lutao Yan, Yuyu Luo, Yunhai Wang, Nan Tang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
In this paper, we explore a forward-thinking question: Is GPT-4V effective at
low-level data analysis tasks on charts? To this end, we first curate a
large-scale dataset, named ChartInsights, consisting of 89,388 quartets (chart,
task, question, answer) and covering 10 widely-used low-level data analysis
tasks on 7 chart types. Firstly, we conduct systematic evaluations to
understand the capabilities and limitations of 18 advanced MLLMs, which include
12 open-source models and 6 closed-source models. Starting with a standard
textual prompt approach, the average accuracy rate across the 18 MLLMs is
36.17%. Among all the models, GPT-4V achieves the highest accuracy, reaching
56.13%. To understand the limitations of multimodal large models in low-level
data analysis tasks, we have designed various experiments to conduct an
in-depth test of capabilities of GPT-4V. We further investigate how visual
modifications to charts, such as altering visual elements (e.g. changing color
schemes) and introducing perturbations (e.g. adding image noise), affect
performance of GPT-4V. Secondly, we present 12 experimental findings. These
findings suggest potential of GPT-4V to revolutionize interaction with charts
and uncover the gap between human analytic needs and capabilities of GPT-4V.
Thirdly, we propose a novel textual prompt strategy, named Chain-of-Charts,
tailored for low-level analysis tasks, which boosts model performance by
24.36%, resulting in an accuracy of 80.49%. Furthermore, by incorporating a
visual prompt strategy that directs attention of GPT-4V to question-relevant
visual elements, we further improve accuracy to 83.83%. Our study not only
sheds light on the capabilities and limitations of GPT-4V in low-level data
analysis tasks but also offers valuable insights for future research.
|
[
-0.1487457007,
-0.7703505158,
0.6548090577,
-0.003990761,
-0.3343330324,
0.1298583746,
0.0519927368,
-0.5712195635,
-0.2509271204,
0.3165225983,
-0.5136932135,
-0.7997218966,
-0.6229717135,
0.3097147942,
-0.3362821639,
0.8818970323,
-0.1458913982,
-0.0432386585,
-0.1162006706,
-0.1239646748,
-0.7741265297,
-0.5425534248,
-0.5741856098,
0.1869958937,
0.7834390402,
0.5062273145,
0.5786827803,
0.3258104026,
0.8072667122,
0.2746929824,
0.1453471184,
0.2953779995,
-0.976123333,
0.2328560352,
0.1481317133,
-0.3921074569,
-0.6474737525,
0.2282364666,
0.4063225389,
0.3893254101,
0.1947583109,
0.2862062156,
0.2781953216,
0.9163008332,
-0.5500763059,
0.6360939145,
-0.4722130895,
0.1133779809,
-0.4897559583,
-0.2056240886,
-0.41981408,
0.0102062272,
0.3397525251,
-0.7691169977,
0.1159823313,
0.1548722684,
0.6728978157,
0.2786230743,
-0.5725521445,
-0.2898259163,
-0.7847496867,
0.6972702742,
-0.6887711287,
0.3282569647,
0.3945975602,
0.5643114448,
0.2198651731,
-1.2859498262,
-0.1720292121,
-0.3178129792,
-0.1120431423,
0.3573770523,
-0.6042378545,
-0.0147002544,
0.7639170289,
0.1204475537,
-0.6526939869,
0.0881466195,
-0.4327142537,
-0.1057887226,
0.5803396106,
0.6325545311,
0.2300303727,
-0.3673281074,
-0.2666099072,
0.1923645288,
-0.556781888,
0.3384123445,
0.2335904092,
0.4112578928,
-0.064888753,
0.653809309,
-0.2291360646,
0.8232203126,
0.1611705422,
-0.1234233379,
0.345107168,
-0.7901021838,
-0.289335072,
-0.436864078,
0.7079113722,
0.5925880671,
-0.0169230215,
0.0564604178,
-0.2929802537,
-0.0273049567,
0.5149569511,
-0.7922064662,
-0.5286011696,
-0.0132468957,
-0.5337184668,
-0.3002249599,
-0.2715409696,
-0.721069932,
-0.5549046993,
-0.395863384,
0.4446371198,
-0.447493881,
0.1880929768,
-0.2746275067,
-0.1697680801,
0.0031532422,
0.61980474,
-0.6465696692,
0.2138361186,
0.5188313127,
1.043289423,
-0.2659899592,
0.0215762015,
-0.8105755448,
0.0507189073,
-0.4220708609,
0.6463431716,
-0.5209604502,
-0.3467126191,
-0.4028795958,
-0.0619164258,
-0.2062488943,
-0.2812714577,
0.5489549041,
-0.3534680605,
0.0948339775,
-0.5539349914,
-0.7020959854,
-0.3057040572,
0.4760911763,
-1.0331830978,
0.9188557267,
0.1920418143,
-0.8943936229,
0.6263642311,
-0.840760231,
-0.1937669218,
0.2340435684,
-0.4555085003,
-0.6900811195,
-0.4299854934,
0.5798182487,
0.5431161523,
-0.210369572,
-0.3407856822,
-0.2673605978,
-0.5622043014,
0.064269349,
-0.4404093027,
0.3930944204,
0.3158071041,
-0.6867972016,
0.5311726332,
-0.3674657345,
-0.0608521327,
0.0962784961,
0.1511976272,
-0.1995966733,
-0.1792577058,
0.0661385581,
0.1385030746,
0.0976963192,
-0.1974351108,
0.2599143386,
-0.2368656993,
0.3249497116,
0.5972507596,
0.2817775309,
0.2024745494,
-0.1790041625,
0.9446958303,
-0.119206503,
0.4558877945,
0.0050022868,
-1.0550045967,
-0.2795034647,
-0.3427036703,
0.1488500237,
0.5121730566,
-1.0865694284,
-0.0817631856,
-0.174401477,
-0.7917768359,
-0.0550740808,
0.1499361992,
0.1566439122,
0.8237198591,
0.3392788768,
-0.4316703677,
-0.3244855404,
-0.8679902554,
-0.2275715321,
-0.0298423544,
-0.0091596767,
0.2232259214,
0.5355111957,
-0.1273157001,
0.8316056132,
-0.4620574713,
-0.1413240582,
-0.4591681063,
0.2679598033,
0.4208756983,
0.1220168322,
0.8512060046,
-0.7414861321,
-0.7189081311,
-0.0697299913,
-0.808188498,
0.1393507868,
0.0210669618,
-0.0999676585,
-0.0072767376,
0.1635515839,
-0.4896453917,
0.8313371539,
0.372410655,
-0.5642007589,
0.6002181768,
-0.2234621048,
0.3778186142,
-0.3580777049,
0.2568117082,
0.2181156874,
-0.1999847889,
-1.0742819309,
-0.3244181573,
0.208190918,
-0.3005409539,
-0.3170966804,
0.3047571182,
-0.3892353177,
-0.2227423042,
-0.1982298791,
0.1129085198,
-0.0804812834,
0.4560249448,
-0.4539671838,
0.637396574,
0.4101052582,
-0.1869141906,
0.5653384328,
0.2734894753,
-0.3701734841,
0.7241736054,
-0.526283741,
0.3032197058,
0.0204811171,
0.2206773013,
-1.1917923689,
0.1371345818,
0.5985071659,
-0.1374539286,
0.1553580314,
-0.1827816516,
-0.4820007384,
-0.6143608093,
-0.4804360867,
0.2453228533,
0.5347376466,
-0.2332524806,
0.5071734786,
0.1792686284,
-0.251532793,
-0.5508130789,
-0.4612364769,
0.2851176262,
-0.5220484734,
-0.7571930289,
-0.0585310385,
-0.1353841722,
-0.1637379825,
-0.1634188294,
-0.2847832739,
0.0667181686,
0.0216244869,
0.2359700054,
0.4265298545,
-0.0480981357,
-0.1176089346,
-0.4227766097,
-0.1938135028,
-0.0976759344,
-0.1984333545,
0.0373607762,
-0.3034040034,
-0.6561279893,
-0.6185031533,
-0.065560706,
0.5004655123,
-0.1991841048,
0.0572306849,
0.8034887314,
-0.1611440629,
0.1604536027,
-0.2369200438,
-0.0364159904,
-0.4802342355,
0.3914378583,
-0.4322639406,
-0.6311326623,
0.2741832435,
0.2309616506,
0.0412447564,
0.5567696095,
0.6462603211,
-0.3900803328,
0.9140605927,
0.3503285646,
-0.0913460702,
0.4826645255,
-0.5854546428,
0.2292631418,
-0.4872609973,
-0.0253714658,
-0.2132155001,
-0.7049979568,
-0.5415048599,
-0.5517578721,
0.7562689781,
-0.0559239723,
-0.2169788629,
-0.1163749024,
-0.4805502295,
0.0537532084,
0.4879799485,
0.3600255549,
0.4040100276,
-0.1691236645,
0.2280379832,
-0.3126113713,
-0.8109912276,
-0.4847400486,
1.4487752914,
0.3901109099,
0.5678699017,
-0.1053841189,
0.2628029287,
0.5772640705,
0.3884691894,
-0.5887618661,
0.3189412057,
-0.1324654818,
-0.4460573792,
-0.6847398877,
-0.4882334769,
-1.1781095266,
0.3322266042,
-0.1928568184,
-0.6273707747,
0.0863081664,
0.4353080094,
-0.2062081844,
0.2116411179,
-0.8547811508,
1.286108017,
-0.50402987,
-0.3034740388,
0.1167143881,
-0.627810359,
0.2506444156,
-0.1531007886,
0.3309251368,
-0.0652481318,
-0.1553944498,
0.8461250663,
-0.3930567503,
1.0094510317,
-0.5331426859,
-0.1551454812,
0.3846359849,
-0.142936483,
0.9820420146,
-0.3449852765,
0.1234658882,
0.1235674396,
-0.1342107952,
-0.4798324704,
-0.9867049456,
0.332878679,
-0.4137926102,
-0.3530937731,
-0.2192392647,
-0.5912293792,
-0.395237267,
0.1322038472,
0.1429366767,
0.6229763031,
0.0994167849,
0.0397749841,
-0.0917935818,
0.1331707835,
0.1507298201,
0.2510366738,
-0.2078799158,
-0.3312254846,
1.0165909529,
0.3974107504,
0.2466137856,
0.1171681806,
0.149404943,
-0.3465570211,
-0.9278526306,
-0.489800632,
0.013370364,
-0.9800513983,
0.0371714719,
-0.2442536503,
0.2480060458,
-0.1126649976,
0.0983101353,
-0.0592944399,
-0.3209773302,
-0.2395754457,
-0.1978230327,
0.5368665457,
0.9818074703,
0.1076978445,
-0.0509374142,
-0.5754908919,
0.2454484701,
0.4190769494,
0.0880766138,
0.0655308068,
-0.1839128137,
-0.4530180693,
-0.0376830027,
-0.4508893192,
-0.9172726274,
0.2825538218,
-0.3896557987,
0.5830456018,
0.2837070227,
-0.121095933,
0.764924109,
-0.4411025345,
0.9112365246,
0.2854716182,
-0.8767194152,
0.2955336869,
-0.6707810163,
0.330425173,
0.2606796324,
0.3569815159,
-0.3889571428,
-0.6506432891,
-0.6048827171,
-0.8374073505,
0.5829614997,
0.8398762345,
-0.5085420609,
0.3958652616,
0.2728284299,
0.0542618185,
0.2641624808,
-0.4255492091,
-0.3482871652,
-0.4853997827,
-0.3776204288,
-0.3951829076,
0.0017180821,
-0.0610644445,
-0.5138949752,
0.1837774515,
-0.2970865071,
0.1463301033,
0.0747784451,
0.1483143419,
-0.054093495,
0.0802245066,
0.4420828819,
1.1268111467,
-0.1661695987,
0.0306965131,
0.4198660851,
-0.6730821729,
-0.0210684817,
0.2002952099,
-0.0660040975,
-0.1671662778,
0.7897391319,
0.9360961914,
0.3719761372,
-0.5157056451,
0.4946703017,
-0.1390645057,
-0.1169059575,
0.0348262824,
-0.0987279341,
0.0714626536,
0.4325751364,
0.4305377007,
0.0171802677,
0.288087815,
-0.3174244463,
0.2269714773,
0.3934650719,
-0.3315399587,
-0.3016645908,
0.7740370631,
0.3111988008,
0.0391858183,
0.5099378228,
-0.1213528588,
-0.3407047689,
0.7291673422,
0.0278333705,
0.5797201991,
0.0030302308,
0.0605618693,
0.1935996264,
0.518541038,
0.3245921731,
0.3830592036,
0.0642370731,
-0.3851969242,
-0.5937929749,
0.1337238103,
-0.6924644113,
0.1657047123,
-0.5422052741,
0.1952421218,
-0.0624027662,
-0.3806628585,
0.0170094874,
0.099634029,
-0.9038011432,
0.2034696937,
0.0723660886,
0.5359299183,
-0.5142503977,
0.4973704517,
0.4062548876,
-0.5314127207,
-0.7447512746,
-0.058293689,
0.2857391834,
-0.72311306,
0.8768862486,
0.1760976315,
0.0783502609,
0.0030493389,
-0.5386536717,
-0.9250209928,
1.5132564306,
0.1448868513,
-0.700445652,
-0.0174059179,
0.0530253015,
0.6443359852,
-0.1829571426,
0.3901209235,
0.706867218,
0.8770132661,
0.0639014766,
-1.0743454695,
0.1854330897,
-0.2142746896,
-0.011886918,
0.0582135096,
-0.2635073662,
0.8868364692,
-0.1525013745,
-0.2442899495,
-0.0318698324,
0.5554575324,
0.2642920911,
0.7403022051,
0.7836155891,
0.1976561248,
1.0507394075,
0.0552257001,
1.2259283066,
-0.1592944711,
0.5089712143,
0.8761901855,
-0.344396472,
0.5324286222,
0.1687701494,
-0.2496801168,
0.3563158512,
0.6067114472,
-0.2741808593,
0.530043304,
0.0917093307,
0.1236292422,
-0.0147129092,
0.4186457098,
-0.2569773793,
0.0908271223,
0.1809743792,
-0.1661403179,
-0.0648415759,
0.1826834679,
-0.1953321248,
-0.3015249372,
-0.423774153,
0.397629112,
-0.1826833636,
-0.1244351342,
0.697804749,
-0.4492219985,
0.2979319096,
-0.5670961142,
-0.050838463,
0.0777788162,
-0.0623704642,
-0.1841796637,
-0.8265458941,
0.0664966181,
0.2781562507,
0.12382368,
-0.2296164483,
0.8135151863,
-0.1110200062,
-0.4740480781,
0.0814154744,
0.8329014778,
0.0723025799,
-0.2697918713,
-0.7403835654,
0.0987863913,
0.135498926,
-0.3677870035,
0.1847484112,
0.5006920695,
0.019274462,
0.6520940661,
0.6027081013,
-0.1314661354,
-0.0493350253,
0.2416664362,
0.8332214952,
-0.8752606511,
-0.6812711954,
-0.6509405971,
0.7409976125,
-0.2659399211,
-0.0689062327,
1.2191426754,
0.6103407145,
0.4713019431,
-0.0547768846,
0.9759737253,
0.2306625247,
0.4300361574,
-0.676566124,
0.5598791838,
-0.501142621,
0.1861280054,
-0.736656189,
-0.4674598277,
-0.2376032025,
0.1658808142,
-0.8551110029,
0.089325361,
0.9783324003,
0.3606056869,
0.0587270372,
0.2942025065,
0.4394074678,
0.328037262,
0.651990056,
0.3742899895,
0.9868856072,
-0.0685508251,
0.8354003429,
-0.4105754495,
-0.3279822469,
-0.1051613167,
-0.6142957807,
-0.8920346498,
-0.5013223886,
-0.1225501969,
0.0126369745,
-0.0440875776,
0.3306782842,
0.5451634526,
-0.4207424521,
-0.2303290218,
0.1370091438,
-0.2253812402,
-0.5039203763,
-0.2193288803,
0.6848977208,
-0.3267574012,
-0.5292528868,
0.5660097599,
0.373062402,
0.0595822558,
-0.1645608097,
-0.2023315579,
0.0850224793,
-0.3932541609,
0.8291931748,
-0.0934182554,
-0.6390061975,
-0.3297453523,
-0.0729513094,
-0.0515008979,
0.2048704326,
1.0745501518,
-0.5697596669,
0.7579149008,
0.3436675966,
0.4212279618,
0.9754618406,
0.2668429017,
0.5058466196,
-0.6884878278,
-0.0387263,
0.3446151912,
0.470838815,
0.2146655172,
-0.484722048,
0.7783628702,
0.5082305074,
-0.5749432445,
-0.5997149944,
0.0186306555,
-0.9644294977,
-0.1206948757,
0.8883610964,
-0.0749756619,
0.0396387205,
-0.2915160656,
-0.5217334628,
0.0480847694,
-0.433917284,
0.4512182474,
0.6131659746,
-0.9336830378,
-0.0298639443,
-0.9681613445,
0.5464653969,
0.0298647005,
-1.0439388752,
-0.0307172537,
0.7032555342,
0.2222170234,
-0.0390738212,
0.8679304123,
0.2279425114,
0.2772247195,
-0.0381465815,
-0.3658114672,
-0.2130359262,
0.0225929935,
-0.323341608,
0.2766753137,
0.0750740767,
-0.159889549
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06996v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06996v1
|
Quite Good, but Not Enough: Nationality Bias in Large Language Models -- A Case Study of ChatGPT
| 2024-05-11T12:11:52 | 2024-05-11T12:11:52 |
Shucheng Zhu, Weikang Wang, Ying Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While nationality is a pivotal demographic element that enhances the
performance of language models, it has received far less scrutiny regarding
inherent biases. This study investigates nationality bias in ChatGPT (GPT-3.5),
a large language model (LLM) designed for text generation. The research covers
195 countries, 4 temperature settings, and 3 distinct prompt types, generating
4,680 discourses about nationality descriptions in Chinese and English.
Automated metrics were used to analyze the nationality bias, and expert
annotators alongside ChatGPT itself evaluated the perceived bias. The results
show that ChatGPT's generated discourses are predominantly positive, especially
compared to its predecessor, GPT-2. However, when prompted with negative
inclinations, it occasionally produces negative content. Despite ChatGPT
considering its generated text as neutral, it shows consistent self-awareness
about nationality bias when subjected to the same pair-wise comparison
annotation framework used by human annotators. In conclusion, while ChatGPT's
generated texts seem friendly and positive, they reflect the inherent
nationality biases in the real world. This bias may vary across different
language versions of ChatGPT, indicating diverse cultural perspectives. The
study highlights the subtle and pervasive nature of biases within LLMs,
emphasizing the need for further scrutiny.
|
[
-0.5708398223,
-0.4219698012,
0.4165868461,
0.3380931914,
-0.3397776186,
0.1095420495,
-0.4507388473,
-0.4235848188,
0.2688513994,
0.634675622,
-0.3646832108,
-0.1623863131,
-0.4635200202,
0.180452615,
-0.134955883,
1.4577950239,
0.0676998943,
0.1047097072,
0.0915129259,
-0.0386650749,
-0.3516103327,
-0.8660730124,
-0.619679749,
-0.6896193624,
0.2902404368,
0.2662121952,
0.6539923549,
0.2574761212,
0.2992728055,
0.1329636425,
-0.0811414793,
-0.0880693644,
-0.5497733951,
0.0986804515,
-0.1221580878,
-0.301066488,
-0.2696994543,
0.2144113928,
0.5196186304,
0.2348070145,
0.3131793439,
0.1804326177,
0.0133884829,
0.5350810289,
-0.2253417373,
0.3186794221,
-0.547655046,
0.0253339801,
-0.4767819941,
-0.0406876057,
-0.3774155974,
-0.4931858778,
0.2998169363,
-0.1931120306,
0.4557937682,
0.1249621436,
0.8232144117,
0.0378429331,
-0.7872517109,
-0.157992959,
-0.5774064064,
0.8415067196,
-0.6760727763,
0.0357629657,
0.3357329965,
0.120378688,
-0.0408491865,
-0.0582355559,
-0.5942013264,
-0.4475794137,
-0.0299029276,
0.2330699563,
0.2417127192,
0.0471916981,
0.4030212164,
0.2648156583,
-0.5629819632,
0.20765692,
-0.445407927,
-0.4890172482,
0.6372696161,
-0.0660040081,
0.5432628989,
-0.6216983795,
-0.2921575904,
0.0856555179,
-1.0454758406,
-0.2139799297,
0.7950711846,
0.4234900177,
-0.3836790025,
0.6734361053,
-0.1965113282,
0.5801267028,
-0.1706105024,
0.0911894813,
0.1610599011,
-0.1363294423,
0.2961058617,
0.1205231473,
0.9062405825,
0.6894513369,
0.7574512959,
-0.0588363819,
-0.0210647471,
0.001527701,
-0.1531647891,
-1.0681895018,
-0.3891960084,
0.1671129763,
-0.2758909166,
-0.0256437361,
0.1896456629,
-0.6437894702,
-0.5453022718,
-0.0498430505,
-0.1005319059,
-0.2559125423,
-0.392519027,
-0.3592498302,
-0.2903910577,
0.4208046198,
0.0896797478,
-1.0007103682,
-0.2342812419,
0.7040810585,
0.71786201,
-0.4915353954,
-0.1553476453,
-0.0792558119,
-0.2658140957,
-0.4371417463,
0.81418401,
-0.530081749,
-0.5052101612,
-0.0052979165,
-0.1724499017,
0.1167568713,
-0.2627402544,
0.7034718394,
-0.5046280622,
0.4653142989,
-0.6904252172,
-0.3989669383,
0.0735693946,
0.3212569952,
-0.6257277131,
0.7856068015,
0.0646073744,
-1.0128834248,
0.7884554267,
-0.5155269504,
-0.3958492577,
0.2786477506,
-0.3895842731,
-0.2120095193,
-0.0567604788,
0.0008346228,
0.3393884599,
-0.363273263,
0.4679617882,
-0.2533005774,
-0.3088881671,
0.3480737209,
-0.6228889227,
0.9515705705,
0.2335610688,
-0.3562105596,
-0.4398609102,
-0.4380887747,
-0.0952943116,
0.1212500334,
-0.2128410339,
-0.3628961146,
-0.0599374026,
0.21630992,
0.5105832219,
0.3506597579,
-0.8529499769,
0.0926774815,
-0.3538683653,
0.486042887,
0.5924677253,
0.1674381942,
0.3609222472,
-0.3343787193,
0.6689438224,
-0.2081385404,
-0.2144164741,
-0.1215481162,
-0.5632628202,
-0.8112486005,
0.0444585569,
0.2783942819,
0.5321799517,
-1.0531616211,
0.0967811272,
-0.2254208922,
-0.35361588,
-0.2314190418,
0.0682862923,
0.4762732685,
0.3473846018,
-0.0675710216,
-0.2218017876,
-0.4327630699,
-1.345741272,
-0.3206482232,
-0.4809479117,
-0.1877342761,
0.4086285233,
0.5234262943,
0.1457779408,
1.0824455023,
-0.3488145471,
-0.0746366605,
-0.2926961184,
-0.0571630597,
-0.0036314349,
0.2905136347,
0.6766939163,
-0.6901571155,
-0.8837854862,
0.0763305426,
-0.6379062533,
-0.2647190094,
-0.1400869042,
-0.2033726573,
0.380497098,
0.0777414143,
-0.7382693291,
-0.1345968246,
0.7269684672,
-0.2694431245,
0.636885941,
0.1443617791,
0.0066870414,
-1.1766043901,
0.0732552558,
0.3945503533,
-0.0033849876,
-0.7527315021,
0.1468006223,
0.2148072124,
-0.0019193654,
-0.4236171246,
0.9393767715,
-0.3495013714,
0.3697994649,
-0.3919788003,
0.137880981,
0.0227022097,
0.3058924377,
0.4127660692,
0.8927643895,
0.2569739521,
-0.1988698989,
0.2415053099,
0.0761217028,
-0.2655200958,
0.7503944039,
-0.3538939357,
0.1637452245,
-0.2198486626,
0.7687710524,
-0.728553772,
-0.5125225782,
0.1928769201,
-0.4146739841,
0.1079833731,
-0.4415689707,
-0.4743496478,
-0.5177258849,
-0.2433960885,
0.3631621301,
0.6001785398,
-0.3574257493,
0.0546952449,
0.2210082412,
-0.4319054484,
-0.408485502,
-0.7754201889,
0.3116559684,
-0.4128676951,
-0.3769123256,
-0.0331100747,
0.1191103309,
-0.3789199591,
-0.3662127256,
0.1053030267,
-0.1088545397,
-0.2419120073,
-0.0459168963,
0.264646709,
-0.1187139004,
0.1217182353,
-0.0602093339,
-0.0464915708,
0.1577237397,
-0.2723396719,
0.5871974826,
0.0740275159,
-0.3015852869,
-0.1638938189,
0.1705150604,
0.3701319695,
-0.1397470981,
0.587854743,
0.5353386998,
-0.0278717838,
-0.1842565387,
-0.7467302084,
-0.1812242866,
-0.4044280648,
0.4428971112,
-0.0939334482,
-0.9157209396,
0.6381913424,
0.6284480095,
0.2377411872,
0.7133978605,
0.6193647385,
0.2373552322,
0.7574828863,
0.3769056797,
-0.2983550429,
0.264782548,
0.1972863823,
0.3116724491,
-0.7656288743,
-0.0238874666,
-0.5574309826,
0.0836554095,
-1.2708951235,
-0.3345806599,
0.0811029673,
-0.7719351053,
-0.4609348774,
0.1240836233,
-0.4540196955,
0.6620420218,
0.4049304128,
-0.2166238874,
0.0454001874,
-0.056953717,
0.1519145966,
-0.323253274,
-0.5866568685,
-0.6834044456,
1.1394271851,
0.2858777344,
0.6403480768,
0.1125657111,
0.7355636954,
0.1118469238,
0.5624216795,
-0.5893565416,
0.3222517967,
-0.2699853778,
-1.1648794413,
-0.0768483207,
-0.6488624215,
-0.5317713022,
0.3536953926,
0.1168962717,
-0.7741419673,
-0.0829707012,
0.3024238646,
-0.4430795908,
0.1928849667,
-0.7373766303,
0.4198515117,
-0.2222189903,
-0.4806312919,
0.4370055795,
-0.4662259519,
0.7373901606,
-0.4064523876,
0.0515744388,
-0.2957966328,
0.2525185645,
0.6861126423,
-0.2666340172,
0.9640828967,
-0.3220171928,
-0.4259312451,
0.4223353863,
0.179010585,
0.5118388534,
0.1984932423,
-0.4932254255,
0.229242906,
-0.1325662583,
-0.5809128284,
-0.052318573,
0.7441310287,
-0.7624737024,
-0.727977097,
-0.4178825319,
-0.4073524177,
-0.2079332471,
0.2602515519,
0.5634236932,
0.2526988387,
-0.36024791,
0.1372909546,
0.5253976583,
-0.5032555461,
0.216760993,
0.3155011237,
-0.2210251838,
0.0934735537,
1.1713554859,
0.3319491744,
0.4338698983,
0.1324958503,
0.2060488313,
-0.2888714969,
-0.1336810291,
-0.7563021779,
0.1918302774,
-0.5063566566,
0.202763319,
-0.6141005158,
-0.4249937534,
-0.207211256,
-0.0213869363,
-0.5012077093,
-0.3634749353,
0.0488482416,
-0.0344982371,
0.225603506,
0.4810988307,
0.2701713443,
0.5947418809,
-0.3043617606,
0.2323592156,
0.2677007318,
0.2404573858,
-0.0722856969,
-0.6508107185,
-0.1619771421,
0.0715478882,
-0.3693340421,
-0.5446400046,
0.2582392991,
-0.0938552842,
0.42931059,
0.3774552941,
0.192342177,
-0.0348554924,
-0.448344171,
1.30920434,
-0.1083869934,
-0.5303557515,
-0.0286140218,
-0.8752580285,
0.6786898375,
0.4838612974,
0.1890346557,
-0.7440727949,
-0.869156599,
-0.6095212102,
-0.8048486114,
0.7214909196,
0.3403617144,
0.8775305748,
-0.1977957785,
0.160541445,
0.3747134507,
0.1484511346,
-1.1099569798,
-0.2901860774,
-0.2982567251,
0.1425749063,
-0.1933525652,
-0.3417237401,
0.0329043381,
0.2510039806,
0.7858503461,
-0.1138697863,
0.2734336853,
0.0407103524,
-0.0693330914,
0.2339218259,
0.3276187181,
0.7273091674,
0.6612556577,
-0.0976002738,
0.0277422294,
0.2607782483,
-0.4385770857,
0.0928931162,
0.0711034238,
-0.4826697409,
0.0346870273,
0.4102841616,
0.8002831936,
-0.5073970556,
-0.2231935561,
0.4779070616,
-0.0911797583,
-0.1235165,
-0.3495988846,
0.0619292296,
0.2173509151,
-0.2203163654,
0.531765759,
-0.1957004964,
0.0335610099,
-0.2663333118,
-0.0720770136,
0.7082607746,
-0.4229921401,
-0.4581723511,
0.6988462806,
0.5280198455,
-0.0668987706,
0.6335104108,
-0.4386773705,
-0.853420794,
0.7228469849,
0.4277758002,
0.7242901921,
-0.1067933589,
0.512904346,
0.4155155122,
0.4754787683,
-0.1509678364,
-0.1021902487,
0.0771039575,
-0.8892050385,
-0.4332756102,
-0.4459716082,
-0.5132272243,
0.0795771033,
-0.2313396037,
0.268494904,
-0.2160879374,
-0.3945445418,
-0.188496843,
0.0978419781,
-0.7735188603,
0.1390031725,
0.3879028261,
0.5852426887,
-1.1985381842,
0.5548875928,
0.5260862112,
-0.196644336,
-0.5316000581,
0.4351454079,
0.2115416974,
-0.7271914482,
0.5193138719,
0.3376739323,
0.2765121162,
-0.2371409237,
-0.2270900607,
-0.6567550302,
0.3266589046,
0.4087403715,
-0.275357604,
0.1256040782,
0.4561038613,
0.7342470884,
-0.059504427,
0.4111042917,
0.6219841838,
0.5028824806,
-0.0796162486,
-1.0488154888,
-0.0503077358,
-0.1551547796,
0.0927997977,
0.1753385663,
-1.3981789351,
0.9073383808,
0.123649843,
-0.0319204703,
-0.1268294752,
0.2145206481,
0.3478843868,
0.0175932907,
0.1273758858,
-0.0614191033,
0.3644911945,
-0.1256953478,
1.0141134262,
-0.4484743774,
0.2443320155,
0.9960247278,
-0.4697416127,
0.2006647289,
0.4510481358,
-0.1489165574,
0.1462810338,
0.8527694941,
-0.0165296495,
0.1210862249,
0.2765508592,
-0.4530200362,
-0.0995434225,
-0.2659420669,
-0.5111693144,
0.5195646882,
-0.0190978553,
-0.5230945945,
-0.2435614765,
-0.0871503279,
0.5408803225,
-0.2241187394,
0.0537309796,
0.5976174474,
0.32957533,
-1.1114929914,
0.2152709961,
0.0211261343,
0.841439724,
-0.3380489945,
0.1889669746,
-0.6077716351,
-0.3330690265,
-0.3098265231,
-0.833871305,
-0.1369302869,
0.4382753372,
-0.0794022158,
-0.2031699121,
0.5161580443,
-0.3290972412,
-0.6318668723,
-0.1668649167,
0.6307103038,
0.4263449907,
-0.1035274789,
-0.336327374,
-0.0499718115,
0.452937007,
-0.6133791804,
0.2938826978,
0.4649094045,
-0.4469304681,
0.5006782413,
0.2756050229,
0.2563578188,
-0.1538045257,
0.0876637623,
0.4845950305,
-0.504306674,
-0.3403872848,
-1.2039371729,
0.2129224837,
-0.1813926548,
-0.2757906616,
0.9846411347,
0.7042129636,
0.6816649437,
0.1142368913,
1.3227140903,
-0.3047440648,
0.3346368372,
-0.4254615009,
0.9716415405,
-0.0736859664,
0.045237124,
-0.3043626547,
-1.4582768679,
-0.1898045987,
0.3429034352,
-0.7221491337,
0.5797736645,
0.4161107838,
0.6848164201,
0.0448757298,
0.0755646452,
0.1621147692,
0.0302517619,
0.5009836555,
0.241802156,
0.8168424368,
0.0307660978,
0.336130023,
-0.2553654909,
-0.1236783341,
0.1166612133,
-1.0007926226,
-0.9510756135,
-0.3855966628,
-0.1036363691,
-0.277145952,
-0.019602295,
1.0782881975,
0.6549836993,
-0.6647961736,
-0.1627226174,
0.4225402176,
-0.0027229539,
0.5340467691,
-0.2226541787,
0.3594734669,
-0.1498859823,
-0.9305952787,
-0.2629303932,
-0.1899380535,
0.1075336337,
-0.6373816133,
0.075544782,
0.4176054895,
0.1101850793,
0.652156055,
0.2946078181,
-0.5420656204,
-0.4408850968,
-0.2126004696,
-0.1249911934,
0.0692673028,
0.5143946409,
-0.321188122,
0.4876682758,
0.3284950554,
0.2028015703,
0.4470558763,
0.3525739312,
0.7510041595,
-0.7519015074,
0.2042442262,
0.1210827529,
0.0472390614,
0.7517107725,
-0.4430283904,
0.2371846139,
-0.0434123836,
-0.7087600827,
-0.6273326278,
0.2848816514,
-0.5906668901,
-0.0369235091,
1.7127096653,
0.0505591482,
0.0953272134,
-0.0818370283,
-0.5009595156,
0.0716473833,
-0.7040342093,
0.9483397007,
1.2732284069,
-0.0937993973,
-0.0039401734,
-1.1291064024,
0.5612851977,
0.398242861,
-0.5303292871,
0.3298920393,
0.5967083573,
0.4660584629,
-0.0654138848,
0.7154621482,
0.0004520203,
0.0455311649,
-0.125257194,
0.2539135814,
0.2778924406,
0.0468551852,
0.0130457291,
-0.0727336854,
0.5275906324,
0.2841821909
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06981v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06981v1
|
AraSpell: A Deep Learning Approach for Arabic Spelling Correction
| 2024-05-11T10:36:28 | 2024-05-11T10:36:28 |
Mahmoud Salhab, Faisal Abu-Khzam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Spelling correction is the task of identifying spelling mistakes, typos, and
grammatical mistakes in a given text and correcting them according to their
context and grammatical structure. This work introduces "AraSpell," a framework
for Arabic spelling correction using different seq2seq model architectures such
as Recurrent Neural Network (RNN) and Transformer with artificial data
generation for error injection, trained on more than 6.9 Million Arabic
sentences. Thorough experimental studies provide empirical evidence of the
effectiveness of the proposed approach, which achieved 4.8% and 1.11% word
error rate (WER) and character error rate (CER), respectively, in comparison
with labeled data of 29.72% WER and 5.03% CER. Our approach achieved 2.9% CER
and 10.65% WER in comparison with labeled data of 10.02% CER and 50.94% WER.
Both of these results are obtained on a test set of 100K sentences.
|
[
-0.0682008564,
-0.7474094629,
0.1561614424,
-0.0842813849,
0.0913764536,
0.2684512138,
0.0237594191,
-0.3796877861,
0.1438253671,
0.6388016343,
-0.264628768,
-0.9449917674,
-1.0139513016,
0.4582003355,
-0.6663028002,
0.9749224782,
-0.3178219795,
0.1505032927,
0.3188134432,
-0.3158254623,
-0.3358255327,
-0.4773057699,
-0.7489771843,
-0.0044866353,
0.7028342485,
0.9349088669,
0.8731165528,
0.6732252836,
0.416000098,
0.3993101716,
-0.2518680096,
0.589715004,
-0.0771679655,
0.1370258927,
-0.1762612462,
-0.4291788042,
-0.3573631644,
-0.2627306879,
0.6084169745,
0.8768389821,
-0.3912069499,
0.149952516,
0.1273564696,
1.3345905542,
-0.9839378595,
-0.4826564789,
-0.3536027968,
0.3675463498,
-0.3429903686,
0.1776320636,
-0.1658453047,
-0.5701785684,
0.1384153813,
-0.4237390161,
0.5131032467,
0.1649972945,
0.7030408382,
0.3075292706,
-0.5425683856,
-0.8730942607,
-0.7307768464,
0.6927666068,
-1.0114957094,
0.2288847417,
0.6598870158,
0.3437495232,
-0.2533228099,
-0.8714347482,
-0.828999579,
-0.1029340476,
-0.1229679435,
0.0846514329,
-0.1430400014,
0.357162118,
0.1232039779,
0.2559921145,
-0.6272544265,
-0.0000756628,
-0.5249974728,
-0.2448666692,
0.5475976467,
-0.0109898709,
0.4361070991,
0.1093842313,
0.0651210397,
0.0155592337,
-0.5125681758,
0.0808101445,
0.5787301064,
0.2493042946,
0.2222789377,
0.8529679179,
-0.2639200985,
0.6264986992,
0.2054102272,
-0.020969091,
0.2177301645,
0.1585829109,
-0.367294848,
0.6165365577,
0.4333133698,
0.1427982748,
0.1439986974,
-0.1203617603,
-0.2134847641,
0.1501769274,
0.3868890405,
-0.5775597095,
-0.1435998231,
0.41159302,
-0.3180822134,
-0.3049047589,
-0.0076632639,
-0.55245471,
-0.5567107797,
-0.2439206243,
0.545984447,
-0.6708010435,
0.2194513083,
0.3445958197,
-0.0030525285,
-0.1604896486,
0.3106569052,
-0.7857631445,
0.4712080657,
0.5281531811,
0.7453915477,
-0.108276926,
-0.7242926359,
-0.4593603015,
0.193264395,
-0.6355885267,
1.0277546644,
-0.3078478575,
-0.1689679176,
0.245638147,
-0.2439074218,
-0.2431834638,
-0.7048169374,
0.8100450635,
-0.6029415727,
0.0475150608,
0.0479044281,
-0.9541704655,
-0.6479690671,
0.1210542545,
-0.9190954566,
1.1885114908,
-0.0242127199,
-0.5182372332,
0.290482223,
-0.6526255012,
-0.6211953759,
-0.0652336106,
0.1900767833,
-0.6732920408,
0.0198632199,
0.3966699243,
0.3168557882,
0.1652869582,
-0.0467653275,
0.3233526349,
-0.5316942334,
0.5212782621,
-0.2072799653,
0.4932868779,
0.116116032,
-0.7144913077,
0.0100584356,
-1.012644887,
0.1380578279,
-0.4250056446,
-0.3661880791,
-0.2422694713,
-0.1099668071,
0.0877672136,
0.1032964662,
-0.0053515499,
-0.5502810478,
0.2571280003,
-0.9657354355,
0.4173731804,
0.588111639,
-0.1296846271,
0.6151303053,
-0.4022366703,
0.6115060449,
0.1539207846,
-0.0182582662,
0.1868014336,
-0.2948027551,
-1.0955682993,
-0.0514754504,
0.6094902158,
0.7440541387,
-0.5919627547,
0.4499581158,
0.0760471597,
-0.6576766372,
-0.7348996997,
0.2561314106,
0.6714472175,
0.5895076394,
0.4473356009,
-0.0853665471,
-0.7717962265,
-0.7538737059,
-0.7455289364,
0.2425107211,
0.4632829726,
-0.0608749129,
0.8284343481,
-0.5160466433,
0.6806391478,
-0.2259411365,
-0.6592205167,
-0.3182959855,
0.3733003438,
0.4571412206,
0.3980044425,
0.2961372137,
-0.77659899,
-0.7764278054,
0.1366480142,
-0.4442850053,
-0.0620028712,
0.268624723,
0.0838904977,
0.7457965612,
0.2539482713,
-0.3951663375,
1.0309948921,
0.5546511412,
-0.4023803174,
0.8559000492,
-0.3611491323,
0.4263890684,
-1.1873209476,
-0.0716686919,
-0.0940938815,
0.0075078397,
-0.7025483847,
0.0326873064,
-0.0335217305,
-0.0947846547,
-0.5496147275,
0.4571098387,
-0.5070182085,
0.0223388169,
-0.469697088,
-0.2181259096,
0.0059913839,
0.2292581499,
-0.2897208631,
1.2632002831,
0.2346140593,
-0.7397865057,
0.4493868649,
0.4859838188,
-0.5463677645,
0.3296710849,
-0.6600325108,
0.1810617,
-0.1721732765,
0.2727396786,
-1.1923995018,
-0.1591560394,
0.2656759024,
-0.5586431623,
-0.0448001437,
-0.0027090665,
-0.4759098887,
-0.350477457,
-0.0578677468,
0.5125932097,
0.1988706142,
-0.4921675026,
0.7846898437,
0.0822933465,
-0.2882136405,
-1.0454665422,
-0.6707766652,
0.2434576303,
-0.0390318558,
-0.4149902165,
0.4723947048,
0.2575275302,
-0.0863591731,
0.073817648,
-0.0451201014,
-0.3890175223,
-0.1238423362,
0.4129746258,
-0.08922901,
-0.0792972818,
0.2751328945,
0.2301589102,
-0.3772349656,
-0.3966296911,
-0.2131873071,
0.4293326437,
-0.0200884007,
-0.2195221037,
-0.977756381,
0.6091217995,
0.3691541553,
-0.2117219865,
1.0149724483,
0.5246016383,
-0.4842287302,
-0.3790141642,
-0.6537011266,
0.0176968388,
-0.5248071551,
0.4584062099,
-0.2548607886,
-0.6758615375,
0.4306251109,
-0.2860542834,
-0.2284939438,
0.5482769012,
0.3002825975,
-0.462746501,
1.1609808207,
0.5960735083,
-0.1057871431,
0.073673211,
-0.4361926913,
0.4501850605,
-0.7223939896,
-0.1618632078,
-0.5957534313,
-0.792536974,
-0.3724233508,
-0.2050169557,
0.341240257,
0.3050942719,
-0.5932168365,
0.3491797149,
-0.6249047518,
0.3603749871,
1.0128717422,
0.1366917342,
0.169400841,
0.4885750115,
-0.3278798163,
-0.3087314963,
-0.532135129,
-0.6116033196,
1.147649169,
-0.1682709754,
0.5043795705,
0.3442914486,
0.6715400815,
0.7535486221,
0.000049891,
-0.7701134682,
0.363586843,
-0.4288849235,
-0.3605876267,
-0.4667842686,
0.0084372172,
-1.0359002352,
-0.2045105547,
-0.3983353078,
-0.5140985847,
0.1997157335,
0.3268856704,
-0.4954378903,
0.4209602773,
-0.5973258615,
0.6350776553,
-0.1293580234,
-0.0556689836,
-0.3567103148,
-0.6320300698,
-0.1798036546,
0.1246264353,
0.1612152755,
0.1260516196,
-0.0463787243,
0.9821683764,
-0.9437776804,
0.8500360847,
-0.0465236455,
0.013302763,
0.2585320771,
0.069516018,
0.7099727392,
-0.4420328736,
-0.4072343111,
0.125947237,
-0.0443178676,
-0.3972627521,
-0.8373734951,
0.3106077611,
-1.1834558249,
-0.0902713612,
-0.8770550489,
-0.3982023597,
-0.0945680067,
0.186695233,
0.5416345596,
0.4884195924,
-0.0055042543,
-0.1329856962,
0.5002996325,
-0.2150031477,
0.1803295761,
0.5532731414,
-0.0566096194,
-0.9123596549,
0.7102470994,
0.4425988495,
-0.2035385519,
0.2677368224,
-0.0069803302,
-0.2890794575,
-0.6962376237,
-0.5396863818,
0.2213310748,
-0.7790153623,
-0.262190491,
-0.6581516266,
-0.5291191936,
-0.5830298662,
-0.3291248977,
-0.3560011387,
-0.4618767202,
-0.1085747033,
-0.1406167001,
0.6571160555,
0.9823471904,
-0.0868442208,
0.7494099736,
-0.8976532221,
0.2802569866,
0.1419412941,
0.1896187067,
0.0430144779,
-0.6971321106,
-0.3086658716,
0.2678779364,
-0.2277138084,
-0.9804089665,
0.6872384548,
0.5443751812,
0.1542518288,
0.1584496349,
-0.1307471842,
1.0637187958,
-0.8421258926,
0.6969876289,
-0.0298531242,
-1.1733384132,
0.8458640575,
0.210092634,
0.1047094911,
0.5614753366,
0.3563629687,
-1.0423599482,
-0.1330356002,
-0.5652658343,
-1.076012969,
0.5264689922,
0.2246245742,
-0.1133738235,
-0.0095718335,
0.8797423244,
0.198123306,
0.3219965696,
-0.109393388,
-0.5978537202,
0.1557586938,
-0.5742136836,
-0.1387263983,
-0.7308984995,
0.0895117,
-0.4643466473,
1.2542577982,
0.0908510014,
0.1391065866,
0.4043634832,
-0.4921090603,
0.0576113276,
0.3883807659,
0.9305568933,
0.6852949858,
0.1348083466,
0.0220333599,
0.3598207831,
-0.9618782997,
0.4457201064,
0.094769083,
-0.2186558545,
0.1739574075,
0.5317314267,
0.630236268,
0.0634941161,
-0.7114515901,
0.4004170299,
0.2128606439,
-0.4025610387,
-0.7161099315,
-0.0963606015,
-0.2884632349,
0.2370622903,
0.6530125141,
0.365129292,
0.5699388981,
-0.1414959431,
0.2799967825,
-0.0871314928,
-0.2759369314,
0.0437560566,
0.3651921153,
-0.0121771563,
-0.5705346465,
0.7907830477,
-0.016035242,
-0.7995687127,
0.8598957658,
0.6619567275,
0.6767120361,
-0.5908389688,
0.5252223611,
0.4082725346,
0.0336475857,
-0.1061799228,
0.3839234412,
0.346005559,
-0.8745619059,
-0.4861840308,
-0.6831083298,
-0.5936157107,
-0.1324566305,
-0.6823052764,
0.0309642218,
-0.4789511561,
-0.0355198644,
0.0724457279,
0.1689357609,
-0.453689903,
0.5562974215,
-0.1355450004,
0.7935370207,
-0.7585833669,
0.6586480141,
1.1127924919,
-0.2098418921,
-1.1599445343,
-0.2447319627,
0.0882539973,
-0.9989887476,
0.9251844883,
0.2800943851,
-0.4433115423,
0.2592260838,
-0.3347706497,
-0.89932549,
0.963490665,
0.1420260072,
-0.893673718,
0.0921465978,
0.6771054268,
0.5067927837,
-0.0322902277,
0.1248370856,
0.5308421254,
0.4002820253,
0.0998970792,
-0.700897634,
-0.3583253622,
-0.3847318888,
0.2679184079,
0.3152430356,
-0.1586246639,
0.7171081305,
-0.2097246647,
-0.1006335765,
0.4712797403,
0.8938750625,
0.1348333508,
0.3574313521,
0.3502883613,
1.0288639069,
1.0235600471,
0.2411960661,
0.6621903777,
-0.3633695841,
0.2260849774,
1.0812966824,
-0.3304334879,
1.0644367933,
0.4204431772,
-0.2062409967,
0.8891897798,
0.5243145227,
0.240803808,
0.4216073155,
0.1157761812,
-0.5463063121,
0.0998127311,
-0.0224507712,
-0.2733836472,
0.4355072975,
0.4301460087,
-0.4311542809,
-0.1148853377,
0.5063471198,
0.0618391372,
0.6213014722,
-0.4479876757,
0.7644112706,
-0.1199152097,
-0.5312691331,
0.476736784,
0.280546248,
0.5584459305,
-0.1779075116,
-0.4384914637,
-0.3411867321,
0.7226389647,
-0.4113754928,
-0.7920356393,
0.5009827018,
-0.0633186325,
-0.4171514213,
0.1466470957,
0.7091034651,
-0.4627410769,
-0.9765930176,
-0.0884967446,
0.1976765096,
0.1967832297,
-0.2085297406,
-0.7516039014,
0.0185646601,
-0.2195802927,
0.2163430452,
-0.2038352191,
0.397503227,
0.1100993752,
0.6936740875,
0.5483247042,
0.2551830113,
0.195075497,
0.0756514892,
0.3135206103,
-0.8334141374,
-0.5053905845,
-0.8852959871,
0.3903934062,
-0.0844097286,
-0.5632873774,
0.8217368126,
0.6639251113,
0.5488544106,
-0.096938774,
0.8605924249,
0.1692069173,
0.9571864009,
-0.5080012083,
0.8084611297,
-0.2547655404,
0.0452595614,
-0.1274333894,
-0.8403921127,
-0.6041222811,
0.9534450769,
-0.3349240124,
-0.1497558206,
0.8539963961,
1.0244886875,
0.281347096,
0.0886479914,
0.1209537387,
0.3911042809,
-0.0963747576,
0.5648263097,
0.6848144531,
-0.9769188166,
0.3589165807,
-0.399400264,
-0.0596732497,
-0.419870913,
-0.4662420452,
-0.7714118958,
-0.7001317143,
-0.3435903192,
-0.7436950803,
0.8151833415,
1.011423707,
0.3393248022,
-1.1070296764,
-0.2062841803,
-0.5221191049,
0.0441946499,
-0.8120258451,
-0.1552491933,
0.9437640905,
-0.3194363415,
-0.6881121397,
0.1173263341,
0.0844443589,
-0.0813028589,
0.1563540101,
-0.1131163761,
-0.3485467732,
-0.0689120293,
0.5499007106,
0.2460350692,
-0.8103470206,
-0.3385140896,
-0.1402661949,
-0.3420457244,
0.166966334,
0.4280563295,
-0.8182694316,
0.2227523625,
0.12576437,
0.8741109371,
0.2360085547,
-0.1511478126,
0.5123234987,
-0.5672339797,
0.096261926,
0.3275871873,
0.0727921054,
0.2440648675,
-0.4526048899,
0.5221149921,
0.0408773273,
-0.8317990899,
-0.3866090178,
0.0776666775,
-0.7556513548,
-0.0429864489,
1.000696063,
0.0025370445,
-0.5067679286,
-0.2265579253,
-0.7394393682,
0.4932169318,
-0.2435352206,
1.077737689,
0.7655473948,
0.0847120583,
-0.2349369675,
-0.5130547881,
0.6154155135,
0.7888143659,
-0.5048771501,
-0.4811201394,
0.35465464,
0.3590783179,
0.0436964184,
0.3267383277,
0.3134434521,
0.7298568487,
-0.2434593588,
0.4085118473,
0.0889019743,
-0.2780432999,
-0.2935739458,
0.099608995,
-0.066121012,
-0.2309885472
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06932v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06932v1
|
Piccolo2: General Text Embedding with Multi-task Hybrid Loss Training
| 2024-05-11T06:32:08 | 2024-05-11T06:32:08 |
Junqin Huang, Zhongjie Hu, Zihao Jing, Mengya Gao, Yichao Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this report, we introduce Piccolo2, an embedding model that surpasses
other models in the comprehensive evaluation over 6 tasks on CMTEB benchmark,
setting a new state-of-the-art. Piccolo2 primarily leverages an efficient
multi-task hybrid loss training approach, effectively harnessing textual data
and labels from diverse downstream tasks. In addition, Piccolo2 scales up the
embedding dimension and uses MRL training to support more flexible vector
dimensions. The latest information of piccolo models can be accessed via:
https://huggingface.co/sensenova/
|
[
-0.1216797531,
-0.6414192915,
0.3556931317,
0.4692068696,
-0.190371573,
-0.0027068797,
-0.2370132059,
-0.4234229624,
0.1184693798,
0.3906750381,
-0.5740743279,
-0.4376213551,
-0.9152988791,
-0.2391532063,
-0.3267441094,
1.0087393522,
-0.1597278565,
0.5223586559,
-0.417427808,
-0.1941794753,
-0.5102651715,
-0.4972772598,
-0.6927822232,
-0.5708747506,
0.4656513929,
0.3319495916,
0.3599597216,
0.4435350299,
0.4926618636,
0.1299905777,
0.1169335172,
0.1954687685,
-0.5166081786,
-0.0520443395,
-0.1283763647,
-0.7590149641,
-0.3133610487,
0.1281621605,
0.7960460186,
0.436698705,
-0.1210727245,
0.0558269843,
0.3731992543,
0.5990209579,
-0.8376210928,
0.1493391097,
-0.5554360747,
0.3109247386,
-0.2794772983,
-0.0593673661,
-0.5868830085,
-0.0455890968,
0.1909730732,
-0.7385550141,
0.3536749482,
-0.0783522427,
0.7493860126,
0.4017342329,
-0.5113605857,
-0.3080187738,
-0.5111894608,
1.0240821838,
-0.3128653169,
0.4894174635,
0.4377566576,
0.2447523922,
0.2700703144,
-0.7134230137,
-0.5089017749,
0.0231283344,
0.0752556622,
0.5927808285,
0.0036380657,
-0.0294022281,
-0.2308316529,
0.2817882597,
-0.5808722377,
0.1875344962,
-0.2310917079,
-0.1730065644,
0.384677887,
0.1842608452,
0.2210913748,
-0.1983997673,
-0.6759780645,
-0.1687584817,
-0.4690865278,
-0.0180026125,
0.6061092615,
0.0269453656,
-0.2270930558,
0.7494221926,
0.3094207942,
0.7225946784,
-0.0620115325,
-0.1675777882,
0.2063570023,
-0.731394887,
-0.1539643258,
0.0343137123,
0.8303180337,
0.5750876665,
0.0083431797,
-0.1534953713,
0.0199462194,
0.153094694,
0.4471806288,
-0.7262604237,
-0.2894874215,
-0.1137729287,
-0.7558572888,
-0.264323622,
0.1500757337,
-0.7981232405,
-0.5354821682,
-0.3889649808,
0.2902312577,
-0.6604008079,
-0.4524160922,
0.140558213,
-0.5269158483,
0.2890995741,
0.3606108427,
-1.1889247894,
0.5201784968,
0.7607417703,
1.0953772068,
-0.2369447351,
-0.2047252804,
-0.3031002581,
0.284267962,
-0.5317141414,
0.9313078523,
-0.6179211736,
-0.5607104897,
-0.0057757641,
-0.0641980171,
-0.6937090755,
-0.5530424714,
0.7680144906,
-0.1840859205,
0.1097354591,
-0.3068969548,
-0.8364863992,
-0.2931349874,
0.171960786,
-0.6149151921,
1.301779151,
0.2827991247,
-0.8562225103,
0.2135747075,
-0.5509238243,
-0.4133705199,
-0.3049080968,
-0.0984235331,
-0.4801371098,
-0.0631270185,
-0.0512534864,
0.7710683942,
-0.5370748043,
-0.1090512946,
-0.4274098873,
-0.243947491,
-0.1248381436,
-0.2457631826,
0.6104269624,
-0.0084379474,
-0.1496320367,
0.0418325327,
-0.6163700819,
-0.1524240822,
0.2522518933,
-0.4531697035,
-0.5335505009,
0.2011532187,
0.6646029949,
-0.0592372715,
0.2531391382,
-0.7396308184,
0.2049010843,
-0.2366124988,
0.6025627851,
0.4238288403,
-0.2236897498,
0.4399141669,
-0.3094869256,
0.4629350603,
-0.1748683453,
-0.1842923164,
-0.2010440081,
-0.8528851867,
-0.5228292942,
-0.114539735,
0.489725709,
1.0174026489,
-0.407649368,
0.616269052,
-0.0142184906,
-0.7482676506,
-0.5903580785,
0.2934344113,
0.5473527908,
0.3993752003,
0.5172085166,
0.0269285645,
-0.463706851,
-1.2190630436,
0.0682625845,
0.2914528549,
-0.0380247012,
0.2692077756,
0.48869735,
-0.3185378909,
0.6260812879,
-0.4969641566,
-0.7926806211,
-0.7312037349,
0.3590164483,
-0.3577481508,
0.7561687827,
0.752283752,
-0.9031009078,
-0.5646887422,
0.0214339234,
-0.7798400521,
0.3657324016,
-0.4154693484,
0.0945647806,
0.2056013197,
0.6155040264,
-0.5830155015,
0.2940968871,
0.8497729301,
-0.0586342625,
0.5251895785,
-0.4567747116,
0.1457750499,
-1.4084296227,
-0.0025261194,
0.3935382962,
-0.1345780939,
-0.4313118458,
-0.1709170043,
0.5433333516,
-0.2084034532,
-0.2586495876,
0.2189441174,
-0.4788511097,
-0.3931860626,
-0.271948725,
0.2263472229,
0.1538961679,
0.4609887004,
-0.0673063546,
0.953270793,
0.4946031868,
-0.5728691816,
0.3207597733,
0.3504602909,
-0.4775089324,
0.7364014387,
-0.8856482506,
0.08030276,
-0.1630273312,
0.6822634339,
-1.1127637625,
-0.2232346237,
0.3323726356,
-0.4705900848,
0.5787348747,
-0.1404621303,
-0.7307302952,
-0.4337343872,
-0.5655291677,
0.3007157147,
0.1049639285,
-0.3519233763,
0.5704581738,
0.5754500031,
-0.0246048365,
-0.406968385,
-1.2000083923,
0.1340498626,
-0.0292542931,
-0.5667034388,
1.0997639894,
-0.0598658957,
0.3391919732,
0.3261380494,
0.0234764591,
-0.2128416747,
-0.0242549721,
-0.0208171792,
0.0326267183,
-0.2445721626,
0.2179307342,
0.3201035857,
-0.4302870631,
-0.2134043127,
-0.2637301385,
0.6487793326,
0.1052878052,
-0.3004120886,
-0.9234114885,
0.5670640469,
0.3034832478,
-0.4527948797,
0.7363262177,
1.0616924763,
-0.6786571145,
-0.2566650212,
-0.334450841,
0.30519557,
-0.4232363701,
0.7446056008,
-0.4276498854,
-0.7228079438,
0.3722934723,
-0.1209818423,
-0.0948630273,
0.7252838612,
0.5487688184,
-0.2036783099,
0.9734150767,
0.7823229432,
-0.0392853767,
0.3401236236,
-0.5547629595,
0.0019193214,
-1.3307425976,
-0.6399758458,
-0.6074672341,
-0.4240500629,
-0.2454277873,
-0.8949904442,
0.1870229989,
0.330612421,
0.1368254721,
0.586314559,
-0.5804743171,
0.3645844758,
0.7036222816,
0.2521431744,
-0.2092623115,
-0.3380335271,
-0.030893907,
-0.1601370126,
-0.724950552,
-0.3774973154,
1.3146311045,
0.2789936364,
0.798995018,
-0.0504764728,
0.5408456326,
0.555785358,
0.005900545,
-0.9559245706,
0.2931495607,
-0.6429684758,
-0.5777256489,
-0.1922040582,
-0.0257006492,
-0.904512167,
0.1846635491,
-0.2650248408,
-0.6562464237,
-0.0853263512,
0.1442195028,
-0.3654980063,
0.5979884863,
-0.7482809424,
1.1121090651,
0.028851755,
-0.0004749716,
-0.7337986231,
-0.3713408113,
0.4831219912,
0.0139574222,
-0.1377268434,
-0.0957824141,
-0.5226987004,
1.0753594637,
-0.0981091931,
0.8416663408,
-0.3672016561,
0.0195772406,
0.4648653865,
-0.352889806,
0.568644762,
0.0373940766,
-0.0626936927,
-0.0618635714,
-0.0898583159,
-0.4706231058,
-0.5871297121,
0.9390177727,
-0.8153505921,
-0.1248150319,
-0.3465286195,
-0.2558682263,
-0.3443507552,
-0.0170689262,
0.5601755977,
0.678979218,
-0.2708393037,
0.5212704539,
0.9446918964,
-0.6309267282,
0.3760563135,
-0.0736960024,
0.3091646433,
-0.5992156267,
0.9438616633,
0.187952891,
0.1015723273,
0.6970409155,
0.0510240346,
-0.580960691,
-0.5800573826,
-0.7762970328,
0.0951799676,
-0.6548985839,
-0.2351956964,
-0.8908345103,
-0.159153834,
-0.5211386681,
-0.170212701,
-0.7354903221,
-0.4432426691,
-0.5588794351,
-0.1141218096,
-0.004770299,
1.0380986929,
0.0083566848,
0.507804513,
-0.7727919817,
0.5062318444,
0.1326225996,
0.5350430012,
0.132963717,
-0.2268596441,
-0.4116013348,
-0.0644196942,
-0.4633103013,
-1.0006219149,
-0.0819857121,
0.3260053396,
0.8972980976,
0.4616084695,
-0.2472005188,
0.4669660032,
-0.6400516033,
0.9348962903,
0.5396502614,
-0.9587308764,
0.6529892683,
-0.5341299176,
0.1839695722,
0.3982919753,
0.5189504027,
-0.4185368717,
0.107254684,
-0.2789207995,
-0.7154374123,
0.6461289525,
0.0256803576,
0.2456424534,
0.1127225757,
0.2151268721,
0.2316823751,
-0.0290429816,
-0.3450661898,
-0.4015975595,
-0.4654707015,
-0.3093014359,
-0.1965402365,
-0.6022074819,
0.303484112,
-0.2671445608,
0.6329703331,
-0.0486901663,
0.8856776357,
0.2930583656,
-0.2784423828,
0.088323161,
-0.0659295693,
0.825871706,
0.2799165845,
-0.0655725077,
-0.123783879,
0.1483287662,
-0.4258755744,
0.1047915593,
0.1883223802,
0.0308329128,
0.00218433,
0.4902307093,
0.8061900139,
0.7881459594,
-0.3499775231,
0.5725281835,
0.1400775462,
-0.703705132,
-0.2151502967,
0.0887320563,
0.3473584652,
-0.0207525622,
0.3739691973,
0.5110000372,
0.3069998622,
-0.4440118968,
0.3765322268,
0.2856404781,
-0.4362942874,
-0.3134178221,
1.0041382313,
0.3504852355,
-0.0999046266,
0.3815790713,
-0.2423505038,
-0.6460518241,
0.6960011721,
0.6494490504,
0.8682951331,
-0.3084126413,
0.4811979532,
0.5382850766,
0.3549449444,
-0.1536643356,
0.0674456954,
0.0483474955,
-0.5837100744,
-0.4520169497,
-0.4246156812,
-0.5919695497,
0.0807165727,
-0.9041696191,
0.1238114834,
-0.6287882924,
-0.1994288713,
0.3408103883,
0.0392540544,
-0.6986631751,
0.1552547514,
0.1473056525,
0.9735557437,
-0.5075291395,
1.1331057549,
0.8147308826,
-0.1580251455,
-0.229211092,
-0.1088692695,
0.303897649,
-0.6883557439,
0.4769749343,
0.5521665812,
-0.0700903907,
-0.0058386778,
-0.0414522029,
-0.8953065276,
1.2743775845,
0.1636331677,
-0.7198058963,
0.059234757,
0.0259389393,
0.2528612912,
-0.3236434162,
-0.0119061191,
0.2660177052,
0.5666635036,
-0.3235615194,
-0.7710337639,
-0.2516604662,
-0.3129758537,
0.1757707149,
0.2042106837,
-0.9438688159,
0.7173923254,
-0.1904194951,
-0.1607136577,
0.3322831988,
0.7925100923,
-0.1628319621,
0.3519336581,
0.5239956379,
0.868468523,
0.9209650159,
-0.2699891329,
1.3266109228,
-0.2852267027,
0.3056650162,
1.2915986776,
-0.2732189894,
0.9728317857,
-0.0510498546,
-0.3385915756,
0.3856749237,
0.7789959908,
-0.362451762,
0.7256403565,
0.1137981266,
-0.1658934951,
-0.2602887154,
-0.1043219939,
-0.4395353794,
0.4291849136,
0.5224046707,
-0.2530788779,
-0.2284241319,
0.4080191255,
-0.0070400359,
0.1921570003,
-0.1502135545,
0.5568780303,
-0.0436290838,
-0.5966001153,
0.2499285787,
0.5185237527,
1.0649200678,
-0.8161687851,
0.1578949988,
0.1137500182,
0.4102424681,
0.1071957722,
-0.8509464264,
0.6258938909,
-0.2441675812,
-0.4177133739,
-0.324139446,
0.8583699465,
-0.3943788707,
-0.5281326175,
0.7463524938,
0.1281557977,
-0.1771822125,
-0.1945205778,
-1.0678046942,
0.0427812524,
-0.0389798544,
-0.2569889128,
0.4377142787,
0.102064915,
0.2352556586,
0.622053802,
0.4853956699,
-0.2300952077,
0.1190599576,
0.2090560794,
0.5584039688,
-0.7047346234,
-0.5170090199,
-0.5365808606,
0.2996423841,
-0.1587607712,
-0.5975321531,
0.7316530347,
0.8914833665,
0.7587401867,
-0.2761038542,
1.1152267456,
0.0286821071,
0.5626913905,
-0.5760947466,
0.6474342942,
-0.6451970935,
-0.2742332816,
-0.1298416853,
-0.9228794575,
-0.2046082467,
0.5889589787,
0.1423009336,
-0.0769441202,
0.8220058084,
0.5675063133,
-0.0710646063,
0.1681824327,
0.1810033768,
-0.2027972639,
0.2001145631,
0.6360089183,
0.5096743703,
-0.6899638772,
0.7160673141,
-0.2585633099,
-0.1440893263,
-0.2261112034,
-0.5773627758,
-1.1097640991,
-0.7949067354,
-0.4388785362,
-0.0075612729,
0.0651518404,
0.5861346722,
0.9040309191,
-0.7778666615,
0.0541209616,
-0.1299219429,
-0.1290106773,
-0.366505146,
-0.2169916332,
0.4840986729,
-0.5098257065,
-0.921250701,
0.6811599135,
0.2823776603,
0.2744309008,
-0.3430763185,
-0.1400010288,
-0.393019557,
-0.1158361956,
0.7161198258,
-0.1663805246,
-0.639779985,
-0.0572060756,
-0.2558759451,
-0.1875422448,
-0.1728028655,
0.9526543021,
-0.4838096499,
0.1651401222,
0.6057472229,
1.0192600489,
0.6863611341,
-0.1191573888,
0.6725401878,
-0.6153257489,
0.089180477,
-0.0426665023,
0.4646933377,
0.4479813576,
-0.1948763132,
0.613992393,
0.513022542,
-0.3576743603,
-0.5720587373,
-0.1200148836,
-1.3810552359,
-0.380233258,
1.0417370796,
-0.2938781679,
0.1782916337,
0.0342885368,
-0.3048937917,
0.2645633519,
-0.2544390559,
0.2554016113,
0.8462278247,
0.0781252682,
-0.1214527786,
-0.8492354751,
0.4402466118,
0.4820197523,
-0.7787106633,
-0.0742943287,
0.1767745167,
0.1994512528,
0.2140210718,
0.5447266698,
0.0484293699,
0.3156453073,
0.4180542231,
-0.2955036461,
-0.1602862626,
-0.4743278027,
0.0748679191,
0.2567001879,
-0.4492133558,
-0.507933557
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06922v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06922v1
|
EmoMix-3L: A Code-Mixed Dataset for Bangla-English-Hindi Emotion Detection
| 2024-05-11T05:58:55 | 2024-05-11T05:58:55 |
Nishat Raihan, Dhiman Goswami, Antara Mahmud, Antonios Anastasopoulos, Marcos Zampieri
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Code-mixing is a well-studied linguistic phenomenon that occurs when two or
more languages are mixed in text or speech. Several studies have been conducted
on building datasets and performing downstream NLP tasks on code-mixed data.
Although it is not uncommon to observe code-mixing of three or more languages,
most available datasets in this domain contain code-mixed data from only two
languages. In this paper, we introduce EmoMix-3L, a novel multi-label emotion
detection dataset containing code-mixed data from three different languages. We
experiment with several models on EmoMix-3L and we report that MuRIL
outperforms other models on this dataset.
|
[
-0.6578589082,
-0.5051549077,
0.2400852144,
0.7145019174,
-0.1434920579,
0.2729691863,
-0.0695125088,
-0.5809006095,
0.2499748766,
0.1587224305,
-0.3622190654,
-0.6781845689,
-0.5731816888,
0.4982771575,
-0.2111641467,
0.9473243356,
-0.3421022892,
0.1756896079,
0.3240534961,
-0.503567338,
-0.2665145993,
-0.8015550375,
-0.3001978099,
-0.3589415252,
0.4905463159,
0.4745049775,
0.8802704811,
0.3166117668,
0.2640198469,
0.0810133517,
0.0728818625,
0.1157948822,
-0.1811797768,
0.1916043609,
0.6225386262,
-0.8017063737,
-0.377405256,
-0.2083428055,
0.2325801104,
0.0273702219,
-0.2987233102,
-0.207299754,
-0.0807717443,
0.7809386253,
-1.0592845678,
0.2387426198,
-0.0192486607,
0.556545198,
-0.3666668832,
0.024131069,
-0.2893326879,
-0.6916490197,
-0.2967970967,
-0.1918583661,
-0.3576055169,
0.1964599639,
0.5627077222,
0.2978628576,
-0.4987975657,
-0.5448637009,
-0.3872175515,
0.791964829,
-0.9156115055,
0.5637072921,
0.4093489349,
0.0482276529,
0.5345230699,
-0.0219535101,
-0.8853783607,
0.4189459682,
-0.072341159,
0.2531715035,
-0.5222561955,
-0.208771497,
0.1436931491,
0.3008630872,
-0.6846883893,
-0.0586516522,
-0.2185364664,
0.120517455,
0.4338897765,
0.0997059941,
0.5963662863,
-0.2064114958,
-0.2362837642,
0.0152290752,
-0.8022739291,
-0.2895256281,
0.7169073224,
0.1828017682,
-0.5320544839,
0.5473642945,
0.0145320427,
0.9820783138,
-0.4104126394,
-0.1122325584,
0.7873263359,
-0.0146091562,
-0.3097706735,
0.2737909555,
0.9516246319,
0.434296757,
0.4213136733,
0.3658734858,
-0.3860212266,
0.3659186065,
-0.3232057989,
-0.6826807857,
-0.2652535737,
0.6077510118,
-0.5929518342,
-0.2747250199,
-0.322696805,
-1.263384223,
-0.518877089,
-0.1293888241,
0.138342306,
-0.5502693653,
-0.6549357772,
0.1799528897,
0.0263440907,
0.279946804,
-0.0243268106,
-0.9747306108,
0.1727659553,
0.585408628,
0.8775013089,
-0.3217846155,
-0.3347129524,
-0.0617491677,
-0.1879669726,
-0.2915249765,
0.7708300948,
-0.8242871165,
-0.2487898916,
0.2751595378,
-0.493950963,
-0.008681884,
-0.6022428274,
0.2233633399,
-0.3621630669,
-0.0171781462,
0.3610917628,
-0.3599058688,
-0.1251355857,
0.2755237222,
-0.9075864553,
1.2609446049,
0.2169853002,
-0.8479181528,
0.3622835577,
-0.5345990062,
-0.3417825997,
-0.037194144,
-0.2986776233,
-0.4889931381,
-0.0047545335,
0.1651055217,
0.5663042665,
-0.2891935706,
0.0676495209,
-0.6395349503,
-0.4975450039,
0.5525084138,
-0.1027693972,
0.5918462873,
0.7087529302,
-0.2065869421,
-0.3226795197,
-0.9628423452,
0.1553011388,
-0.1367731094,
-0.3236919343,
-0.4494280815,
-0.0804157257,
0.3186556697,
0.5295143127,
-0.1393360496,
-0.7999885082,
0.1381566525,
-0.117043741,
-0.0587448701,
0.2667440176,
-0.2905303836,
0.1288561076,
-0.2483575493,
0.884051621,
0.1990292668,
0.1102787107,
-0.2329240739,
-0.8856173158,
-0.7925151587,
-0.1874996722,
0.032877028,
0.7812243104,
-0.9193445444,
0.0547678173,
0.1970251352,
-0.281014353,
-1.0391548872,
0.1151747257,
0.5605496764,
-0.3445313573,
0.3949758708,
0.213874191,
-0.5017694831,
-0.8820787668,
-0.5308618546,
0.2190051973,
-0.0111399032,
0.3664111197,
0.3082052767,
-0.3572970629,
0.7356091738,
-0.7838579416,
-0.251835227,
-0.3175265789,
0.5464750528,
0.3857397437,
0.3837323189,
0.6622674465,
-0.9960769415,
-0.8791319728,
0.1934633404,
-0.7703899145,
-0.3633471727,
0.1365464628,
0.2323250026,
0.6158906221,
0.2498721927,
0.0648758039,
0.4783217907,
1.2299392223,
-0.2816928625,
0.1206415221,
0.1283540875,
0.4816613793,
-1.0984077454,
-0.4014191926,
0.0485287793,
0.056719888,
-0.808944881,
-0.1718285382,
0.6345840693,
-0.2264266908,
-0.8110007644,
0.3468100727,
-0.2986139953,
-0.1196904257,
-0.2500110567,
-0.0467141978,
0.0192027204,
0.8040642142,
0.081742093,
0.4885533154,
0.6675820351,
-0.426348865,
0.6480085254,
0.3444468677,
-0.2486762702,
0.802061677,
-0.0826904848,
0.0874010175,
0.0927585959,
-0.0986379012,
-0.9311452508,
-0.4149647057,
0.3677256703,
-0.36972633,
0.2322196513,
-0.1677248031,
-0.6133928895,
-0.2779717147,
-0.401997745,
0.8490502834,
0.4325098991,
-0.7771308422,
0.7477063537,
0.294855386,
-0.2450818568,
-0.4035093784,
-1.2882999182,
-0.1542122364,
-0.3615627885,
-0.4033448994,
-0.1007029936,
-0.1691992581,
-0.1465403736,
-0.0331338681,
0.1236116365,
-0.6356905103,
-0.2124329507,
0.3776969314,
0.1541214287,
0.0401678048,
0.09848205,
-0.0249304101,
0.1596257836,
0.1217960492,
0.3483160436,
0.5168774128,
-0.2523318231,
-0.2544679642,
-0.3704180419,
0.6973521709,
0.4322026968,
-0.1144911125,
0.5734534264,
0.6859434247,
-0.4665489793,
-0.2495168,
-0.2912497222,
0.4136019051,
-0.4013535976,
0.1047226563,
-0.5256288648,
-0.867277205,
0.5193977356,
0.0826399624,
-0.3248843551,
0.1463177204,
0.7666499019,
0.0981280506,
1.5209720135,
0.5284019709,
-0.185879305,
0.2881768048,
0.2561431825,
0.5484768748,
-0.718388617,
-0.3996642232,
-0.7210162878,
-0.0912440941,
-0.7850742936,
-0.278704375,
0.2139318734,
-0.2766218185,
-0.2514214814,
0.0602287464,
-0.3409572244,
0.6038375497,
0.1729359925,
0.1270674616,
0.2567401528,
-0.0704869479,
0.0065460885,
-0.1015789509,
-0.6153413653,
-0.0531378873,
1.1006451845,
0.1353545189,
1.3086819649,
0.4735791683,
0.8786768913,
0.2955609858,
0.5710219145,
-0.7402276993,
0.0040897089,
-0.062945433,
-0.579941988,
0.3786453605,
-0.417308867,
-0.806766212,
0.2828083932,
-0.1857250035,
-0.753883481,
0.3834993839,
0.140520528,
-0.3815809786,
0.3371208608,
-0.7176453471,
0.7098413706,
-0.4178640246,
-0.0946518257,
0.1279188991,
-0.5571098924,
0.8809466958,
-0.7112904787,
0.8439149857,
-0.3655228317,
0.1042296439,
0.6891725659,
-0.1170136184,
0.5665016174,
0.1891561747,
-0.5324239135,
0.0401575603,
0.2276818901,
0.1143291146,
0.0328860469,
-0.2047967166,
0.1201510578,
-0.0950457156,
-0.3183105886,
-0.6615546942,
0.7582165599,
-0.7848710418,
-0.0454571396,
-0.5628710389,
-0.5638072491,
-0.2737577856,
-0.1036413237,
0.1213883832,
0.5079218745,
0.3368441164,
0.0876965299,
0.457968235,
-0.6604542732,
0.3882776499,
0.6013932824,
-0.714582026,
-0.6649209857,
0.9404322505,
-0.3176032305,
0.3242430687,
0.2698505223,
0.1098843068,
-0.1918361485,
0.1446820199,
-0.4005271196,
-0.1582548022,
-0.8070511222,
-0.5784635544,
-0.8683484793,
0.234311983,
-0.1190875769,
-0.2577622533,
-0.4654873908,
-0.114719145,
-0.0773865581,
0.1894359142,
0.4953091145,
1.0242146254,
-0.2708687186,
0.4090373516,
-1.0877307653,
0.5925139189,
0.1706351042,
0.8472018242,
-0.2896752656,
-0.1653395444,
-0.2525624037,
0.0159976836,
-0.0809457526,
-1.4691572189,
0.9183824658,
0.185746178,
0.1607246846,
0.5172961354,
-0.1590535492,
0.3298368156,
-0.0854653567,
0.6058323979,
0.2642112374,
-1.394489646,
0.5909935236,
-0.2630668581,
0.2948366106,
0.0876462385,
0.7259429693,
-0.7979623675,
-0.4958108664,
-0.4661500752,
-0.8375274539,
1.003431201,
0.414332062,
-0.2423441559,
-0.0608294792,
-0.0893865377,
0.1189831123,
0.2415004671,
-1.0663615465,
-0.5743751526,
-0.201596573,
-0.589458406,
0.1295957714,
-0.3057434559,
-0.0967638493,
-0.0086663878,
0.377325803,
-0.0221873708,
0.4354117513,
-0.1592942923,
-0.1119372398,
0.004283173,
0.5663366914,
0.3414177597,
0.1022651941,
-0.6117523313,
0.2948385477,
0.0548766628,
-0.3024787307,
0.3373791575,
0.0187670402,
0.2814187706,
-0.0239784159,
0.1320698559,
0.8687391877,
0.3187755346,
-0.7433508635,
0.4907521904,
-0.3083840609,
-0.082387574,
0.1073411107,
-0.1632086486,
-0.0282368921,
0.2434460223,
0.2825470865,
0.2418547124,
0.4241019487,
-0.4749465883,
0.3301154077,
-0.2384537011,
-0.3722092509,
-0.0999220908,
0.4798294902,
0.2726095617,
-0.2444011867,
0.4041825831,
-0.2919714153,
-0.9008228779,
0.8710138202,
0.7548372149,
0.7529760003,
-0.4214434028,
0.1559897959,
0.1500017792,
0.1879614443,
0.0075728819,
1.0123511553,
0.0686253756,
-1.0278410912,
-0.2337233126,
-0.5623250008,
-0.6607422829,
-0.2923258841,
-1.0892424583,
0.3230360448,
-0.0631000847,
0.1269758046,
-0.142533645,
-0.384983331,
-0.7870953083,
0.3675340712,
0.7228173614,
0.5089309812,
-1.278668046,
0.9137284756,
0.5673345327,
0.0131212296,
-0.9401084185,
-0.1948115081,
0.2969562709,
-0.827309072,
0.7796567678,
0.4380640984,
-0.0467345864,
0.1209386289,
-0.5088980198,
-0.7678442597,
0.6729554534,
-0.1072605923,
-0.386121124,
0.9767439365,
0.0928970799,
0.4533227682,
-0.6223711967,
0.4169178903,
1.1171329021,
0.4837917984,
-0.1597505808,
-0.5414534807,
-0.1616287529,
-0.63472718,
-0.2235309035,
0.6379639506,
-0.6048036218,
1.1761225462,
-0.0148184672,
-0.196612671,
-0.2642213404,
0.2563073337,
0.5784361959,
0.3186817467,
0.3615271747,
0.5754919052,
0.5907143354,
-0.4035348594,
1.2322034836,
-0.4771279395,
0.6013883352,
0.8747922778,
-0.7705878615,
0.8714255691,
0.2188972235,
-0.457310915,
0.4532231987,
0.8657592535,
-0.2087029964,
0.3286063969,
0.1034382656,
-0.3539394438,
0.0181867778,
-0.1368074417,
-0.4920013547,
0.4635397792,
0.6329366565,
-0.0164663438,
-0.0903286561,
0.3093625009,
0.3247259259,
-0.2915794849,
-0.0964102075,
0.5266340971,
-0.1540011317,
-0.5809491873,
0.7264233232,
-0.1772816628,
0.9872066379,
-0.3865194023,
-0.1289050877,
-0.5987520814,
0.1288362592,
-0.4633601308,
-1.2154718637,
0.2929496467,
0.1966892332,
0.1282910258,
-0.2133442312,
0.3725078106,
-0.9543562531,
-0.349601239,
0.76202631,
0.3646925986,
0.3624545932,
-0.0688609928,
-0.6216672659,
0.7022064328,
0.2683734298,
-0.2499122918,
0.0852058232,
0.6163223982,
0.3872869909,
0.6747512221,
0.2279325277,
0.0570721775,
0.2443603575,
0.2609579563,
0.7536872625,
-0.6928053498,
-0.4676907957,
-0.9818065166,
0.2223498225,
0.1087673083,
-0.3372430503,
0.6700102687,
0.6691584587,
0.7506216168,
-0.337384522,
1.1680401564,
-0.2982919514,
0.1141258031,
-0.6404954195,
0.3550238609,
-0.7892420888,
-0.0526623353,
-0.5520455837,
-0.8315033913,
-0.8056476712,
0.5097773075,
0.3026103079,
-0.0142278336,
1.0018728971,
0.9044013023,
0.1049960479,
0.3723812997,
0.4549830556,
0.1586051881,
0.1107796207,
0.9598013163,
0.9591490626,
-0.5364760756,
0.5422367454,
-0.3158141673,
-0.286801815,
-0.2575186193,
-0.8761217594,
-0.7871053219,
-0.2963365912,
-0.3084391952,
-0.4782237113,
-0.1709070206,
0.9012336731,
0.3429106176,
-0.9875201583,
-0.2724346519,
0.2951392531,
0.4525156319,
-0.0601174049,
-0.1975621283,
0.1427442133,
-0.109621264,
-1.0107101202,
0.2475609332,
0.6340281367,
0.2077227086,
0.0184454452,
-0.1581986099,
-0.4308238626,
0.0465757735,
0.4362694919,
0.2806526423,
-0.4968822002,
0.141937077,
-0.386384815,
-0.2501308024,
0.2081596553,
0.936567843,
-0.3731246591,
0.828258276,
0.5081723332,
0.4737993777,
0.4014206529,
-0.1956516206,
0.7383580804,
-0.9779949784,
0.356387496,
-0.059450265,
0.5799905658,
0.4308241904,
-0.3474266529,
0.8219304085,
-0.0196236428,
-0.536344707,
-0.656380415,
0.215662688,
-0.8850315213,
-0.2109801024,
1.4107499123,
-0.1510684639,
-0.0820609108,
-0.2119798213,
-0.2494910657,
0.2697607279,
-0.5053175688,
0.5465206504,
0.840473175,
-0.3753783107,
-0.2149378955,
-0.6439554095,
0.6315675974,
0.4843410254,
-1.1147024632,
-0.0667801872,
0.4653280675,
-0.0916238576,
0.1418809891,
0.3970218003,
-0.0196733084,
0.2881649137,
0.0711371079,
0.6802229881,
0.3955478668,
-0.244890362,
-0.6944166422,
0.2286177725,
-0.3183990121,
-0.0535327084
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06919v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06919v1
|
Automating Thematic Analysis: How LLMs Analyse Controversial Topics
| 2024-05-11T05:28:25 | 2024-05-11T05:28:25 |
Awais Hameed Khan, Hiruni Kegalle, Rhea D'Silva, Ned Watt, Daniel Whelan-Shamy, Lida Ghahremanlou, Liam Magee
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, K.4.2
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are promising analytical tools. They can augment
human epistemic, cognitive and reasoning abilities, and support 'sensemaking',
making sense of a complex environment or subject by analysing large volumes of
data with a sensitivity to context and nuance absent in earlier text processing
systems. This paper presents a pilot experiment that explores how LLMs can
support thematic analysis of controversial topics. We compare how human
researchers and two LLMs GPT-4 and Llama 2 categorise excerpts from media
coverage of the controversial Australian Robodebt scandal. Our findings
highlight intriguing overlaps and variances in thematic categorisation between
human and machine agents, and suggest where LLMs can be effective in supporting
forms of discourse and thematic analysis. We argue LLMs should be used to
augment, and not replace human interpretation, and we add further
methodological insights and reflections to existing research on the application
of automation to qualitative research methods. We also introduce a novel
card-based design toolkit, for both researchers and practitioners to further
interrogate LLMs as analytical tools.
|
[
-0.6234275699,
-1.0160621405,
0.5188302398,
0.0461748019,
-0.3028876781,
0.4456146061,
-0.2125219256,
-0.4894281626,
0.2048453987,
0.5168221593,
-0.6207184196,
-0.5392878652,
-0.6935911179,
0.3821731806,
-0.7651637793,
0.7101783156,
-0.0959770158,
-0.1067668051,
-0.1683107615,
-0.2233456671,
-0.5266218185,
-0.5379194021,
-0.5477099419,
-0.5225018859,
0.7367172837,
0.3230333626,
0.6535748243,
0.5681344867,
0.9529534578,
0.4210432172,
-0.0945116058,
0.1604808867,
-0.3181773722,
0.3446511924,
-0.5225375891,
-0.7365623713,
-0.439160347,
0.2400639951,
0.3053610027,
0.4771738946,
-0.1454649866,
0.3132120967,
-0.0958909094,
0.4985172451,
-0.2546272278,
0.1524913311,
-0.8251710534,
0.0518574864,
-0.2165940255,
-0.3666058779,
-0.1111479029,
-0.2076838911,
-0.0001211389,
-0.3801030815,
0.1951540709,
0.2559892535,
0.7976948023,
0.6059264541,
-0.4677799046,
-0.4450298846,
-0.8850169182,
0.8676455021,
-0.5869290829,
-0.3311398923,
0.3530681133,
0.1449204683,
-0.1536636055,
-0.6103702784,
-0.6331083179,
-0.0332347415,
-0.0704161972,
-0.1028337702,
-0.4538411796,
-0.0679135099,
0.1986288577,
0.2449280918,
-0.5120983124,
0.5743060112,
-0.2076675296,
-0.1340707093,
0.8401294351,
0.633436799,
0.3584401309,
-0.4692136943,
-0.0764317214,
0.170690313,
-0.6483273506,
-0.2811431289,
0.5502511263,
0.1075050384,
0.1325280964,
0.6990175843,
-0.087440826,
0.5793135762,
-0.0074034417,
0.0211500488,
-0.0642987937,
-0.2606736422,
-0.0774756446,
-0.1350291073,
0.972647965,
0.3828719854,
0.1851591915,
0.2519298792,
-0.1366792917,
0.3574699163,
0.4282311201,
-0.4624431729,
-0.1994112432,
0.5843355656,
-0.3651410341,
-0.4776437581,
0.0273883548,
-0.7240207195,
-0.5014169812,
-0.6106522679,
0.203466177,
0.0326221436,
-0.4268549979,
0.1111690104,
-0.1576034576,
0.4190260172,
0.7239183187,
-0.5072640181,
0.1453133523,
0.9272576571,
0.5993201137,
-0.3954849541,
-0.0877076611,
0.0483044907,
0.0472716987,
-0.5370613337,
1.0548508167,
-0.6859453321,
-0.3888514936,
-0.268315345,
0.0999665633,
0.2698282301,
-0.6072045565,
0.2355225831,
-0.4118797183,
0.3282434344,
-0.2488367409,
-0.3039224148,
-0.169812724,
0.3356646895,
-0.6028079987,
1.1986865997,
-0.0355630852,
-0.7710100412,
0.4521923661,
-0.7554059029,
-0.1970714778,
-0.038214121,
-0.4586113095,
-0.4673186839,
-0.0722364634,
0.0639279187,
0.4196623564,
-0.624647975,
0.6694372892,
-0.3158649504,
-0.3216343522,
0.5467867255,
-0.3460226953,
0.7992476821,
0.2640495002,
-0.5761881471,
0.4110878706,
-0.5033599734,
-0.3405708373,
0.2361381948,
-0.0136849592,
-0.3555300534,
0.1333336234,
0.1257078201,
0.2033321857,
-0.1081643328,
-0.3616362512,
0.1469668895,
0.0112238852,
0.7359552383,
0.6183890104,
-0.0259255841,
0.3122595251,
-0.4331401587,
0.7638978362,
-0.0895033553,
-0.1707314551,
-0.2852775455,
-0.5827572346,
-0.5913372636,
-0.2585936189,
0.3551467657,
0.641481936,
-0.6015060544,
0.552626133,
-0.1632952988,
-0.4150043428,
-0.6246729493,
0.139584139,
-0.1003323868,
0.2065435201,
0.0275062192,
-0.5704994798,
-0.4915983081,
-0.8264625669,
-0.3944434226,
-0.3751998246,
-0.1846514493,
0.2694292963,
0.6335671544,
-0.371150434,
1.4400402308,
-0.3897027373,
-0.2842691541,
-0.3457094729,
0.7274973989,
-0.0483402126,
0.3293165565,
0.285890907,
-0.8061683774,
-0.0492416099,
0.0447531939,
-0.9617537856,
-0.4230131209,
-0.1849363148,
0.1274022609,
0.1050308049,
0.6421282887,
-0.5783310533,
0.4638625085,
0.1320372522,
-0.2202010155,
0.3995451927,
0.1042250693,
-0.0019082499,
-0.9233311415,
0.1214471534,
0.0982010961,
-0.1957580149,
-0.591285646,
0.159252435,
-0.0967691168,
-0.0995731652,
-0.3116664588,
0.5072520375,
-0.4307670593,
0.0264651831,
-0.6203674674,
0.3253811896,
-0.0608173013,
0.1072947755,
0.1004652902,
0.5083284378,
0.2244746834,
-0.1221330687,
0.566799283,
0.0640834048,
-0.2124113888,
0.6900718212,
-0.4779146016,
0.2939242125,
-0.3360616863,
0.2946668267,
-1.4828201532,
-0.4287897348,
0.5263627768,
-0.3506726921,
0.1764237285,
-0.0521104559,
-0.5749578476,
-0.4010705054,
-0.3936221898,
0.4392406046,
0.3612620234,
-0.0313208289,
0.7839304209,
0.81293571,
-0.5498744249,
-0.2800402343,
-0.7462968826,
0.6093418598,
-0.7737706304,
-0.3478006423,
-0.141464442,
0.2197552472,
-0.9514801502,
0.0675765797,
-0.0116926972,
-0.1748896986,
0.3350385725,
0.4159379303,
0.1786521673,
-0.2395539731,
0.0223181732,
-0.0570092648,
-0.4022108912,
0.4507299066,
-0.0106354393,
0.4320154786,
-0.125918135,
-0.5805017352,
-0.6550717354,
0.2958088815,
0.4867886603,
-0.1587352604,
0.3062523305,
0.6011353731,
-0.1680566072,
-0.2310231328,
-0.6952697635,
-0.1919524521,
-0.4959981441,
0.2748710811,
0.040477328,
-0.9957094789,
0.4759603739,
-0.2422312349,
0.0669694692,
0.5399263501,
0.821044147,
-0.2619752884,
0.5725901127,
0.5121793151,
-0.4917396307,
0.3282015324,
-0.1969981194,
0.2254788429,
-0.5183737874,
-0.042699527,
-0.6683613658,
-0.4215946496,
-0.6663008332,
-0.6383835077,
0.2320082784,
-0.5432639718,
-0.0532702841,
-0.108601965,
-0.4344123304,
0.3983062506,
0.2260262668,
-0.0702237189,
0.5792758465,
-0.0158887338,
0.4716896117,
-0.0616582818,
-0.5951480269,
-0.7825141549,
0.9434345365,
0.5192588568,
1.1931065321,
-0.2116655111,
0.3683081865,
0.5206238627,
0.700995326,
-0.9357146025,
0.6571627259,
0.4101519883,
-0.8674349785,
-0.5670459867,
-0.0946209878,
-1.0992100239,
0.4631309211,
0.037814755,
-0.5868585706,
0.2328126281,
-0.1614946276,
-0.2612894475,
0.3144637644,
-0.2734988034,
0.3027686179,
-0.1934296042,
-0.298414439,
-0.2703233361,
-0.632684648,
0.4519183338,
-0.3433943987,
0.4539214969,
-0.3228543103,
-0.2064672559,
0.7486739159,
-0.0391907617,
1.2534030676,
0.1899463683,
-0.642806232,
0.6191005111,
0.2394796908,
0.1456507146,
0.0308969468,
0.0122429663,
0.3655996621,
-0.1342910975,
-0.3002689183,
-0.4979827106,
0.3676203191,
-0.6497623324,
-1.0972621441,
-0.6392864585,
-0.8432420492,
0.0507423319,
-0.0066230698,
-0.3490189612,
0.1151652634,
-0.091821976,
0.1421733201,
0.6410987973,
-0.1704484969,
0.3972497582,
0.4800877869,
-0.2895114124,
0.0515238233,
0.7602058053,
0.1205868647,
0.0970086232,
0.2533237934,
0.2270555943,
-0.0076298732,
-0.634591639,
-0.3432080746,
0.2098948061,
-0.6544712782,
-0.0974454284,
-0.6123275161,
-0.0778008476,
0.1787721366,
-0.0225545056,
-0.1962116808,
-0.3686677814,
-0.379104495,
-0.2698174417,
0.4319401085,
0.9505021572,
-0.0256386716,
0.3525759876,
-0.4260323346,
0.2697166502,
0.1606409252,
-0.058256954,
-0.1078738421,
-0.4317901731,
0.1479049772,
-0.2099006921,
-0.3273349702,
-0.8742252588,
0.3030387759,
-0.4080683887,
0.3702897131,
0.5369670391,
0.0430555828,
0.5575347543,
-0.2285900265,
0.7358592153,
-0.3237603307,
-0.842513442,
0.4842031002,
-0.8726759553,
0.1082714722,
0.4625898302,
0.4652715027,
-0.3751622736,
-0.7399517298,
-0.5349503756,
-0.8695745468,
0.6414886713,
0.2150437236,
0.1505710334,
0.2550832331,
0.440238297,
0.296276778,
0.4016231596,
-0.6134264469,
-0.2098683864,
0.3206228018,
-0.1620635986,
-0.1237284243,
-0.2561050951,
-0.4437424242,
-0.2127926946,
0.183100611,
-0.2068294138,
0.2569067478,
0.1243140996,
-0.051049415,
-0.2558544278,
0.2100243419,
0.3319477141,
0.955470562,
-0.0389636308,
0.1247683913,
0.1367546916,
-0.336506784,
0.4233859479,
-0.1377488375,
-0.1163717881,
-0.0325519964,
0.6401268244,
0.2565503716,
0.1447421759,
-0.7203102708,
0.1485893577,
-0.0622620024,
-0.4258193374,
-0.2114536762,
0.0652359724,
0.2478787452,
0.2154422104,
0.351236552,
-0.2748261392,
0.0617157444,
-0.7942425609,
0.2504835427,
0.5650708675,
-0.1257629097,
-0.2098958194,
0.4559893012,
0.2343434244,
-0.4008772075,
0.2929745317,
0.1042976528,
-0.3531533778,
0.8846064806,
0.1465484649,
0.7234099507,
-0.2955116034,
0.4696858525,
-0.2073195279,
0.6140034199,
0.1371797174,
0.3475502729,
0.0064945058,
-0.629929781,
-0.5001990795,
-0.2669288218,
-0.7722497582,
0.0350471064,
-0.9265577197,
0.0376317948,
-0.3717738688,
-0.252717346,
-0.0131332427,
0.0638995841,
-0.4225504398,
0.0579858981,
0.0066600605,
0.6948717833,
-0.9587330818,
0.648665309,
0.6391832829,
-0.0043489723,
-0.3820080161,
0.1605370194,
0.528355062,
-0.7765410542,
0.6136426926,
-0.2163840532,
-0.0714080334,
-0.1845574677,
-0.6357986331,
-0.9020799398,
1.0641682148,
0.0518296659,
-0.5735735297,
0.1863818765,
0.4511282146,
0.7247856855,
-0.2179396451,
0.4562522173,
0.8868673444,
0.6216955781,
-0.0573291555,
-0.8389069438,
0.1047866791,
-0.033797387,
-0.2303113341,
0.2965324223,
-0.8227820992,
0.6889138222,
0.0746520236,
0.0024632586,
0.0400333926,
0.5334883332,
0.0558236279,
0.5476660132,
0.3801873326,
0.2288297266,
0.8718168139,
-0.2610304356,
1.0062373877,
0.0605014153,
0.3665602505,
0.783208847,
-0.5497583151,
0.5017957687,
0.5345955491,
-0.4419415295,
0.4594973326,
0.8879613876,
-0.02134642,
0.0432982631,
0.5736668706,
0.05219841,
-0.1946949065,
-0.1093971282,
-0.0510151163,
0.6387989521,
0.6968603134,
0.0236916561,
-0.3260377944,
-0.0400299318,
0.1746715605,
-0.0138804903,
-0.2021930367,
0.7769808173,
0.1824023724,
-0.4197075665,
0.1868392229,
0.1609549522,
0.4390992224,
-0.5074018836,
0.1118790731,
-0.2930716574,
-0.1196365654,
-0.1837599725,
-0.8899137974,
0.4261211157,
0.0756350309,
0.2074146122,
-0.2321520895,
0.8368185759,
-0.1091339439,
-0.5154865384,
0.1311683655,
0.9269602895,
0.1222468764,
0.0009471278,
-0.8226940036,
0.3489766717,
-0.2015378475,
-0.3528034091,
0.4821488261,
0.7398044467,
-0.4522680938,
0.9456429482,
0.5984014869,
0.0186201539,
-0.2400680631,
-0.0695178732,
1.027032733,
-0.9532497525,
-0.2417712361,
-1.1927717924,
0.351084739,
-0.0005936003,
-0.2344717085,
0.911930263,
0.2794927955,
0.6180232763,
0.355912298,
0.8870908618,
-0.0258991495,
0.3997381628,
-0.4204461873,
0.5462009311,
-0.4508571923,
0.4310388267,
-0.5057076812,
-0.6665019989,
-0.5488256812,
0.4869165123,
-0.4979536235,
-0.0907461196,
0.5987302661,
0.7957401872,
0.0602544099,
0.3251770735,
0.0442201197,
0.3261437416,
0.4868826866,
-0.0294978581,
1.3636496067,
0.2705897391,
0.1275416762,
0.0187553149,
-0.2791436315,
-0.1496640742,
-0.927614212,
-1.2678799629,
-0.4605277181,
-0.1743358672,
-0.0785273388,
0.0214654841,
0.9018212557,
0.3927127421,
-0.6547212005,
-0.6356765628,
0.1678704023,
0.379822582,
0.0906848013,
-0.2668936253,
0.3822316825,
-0.1517987102,
-0.679674089,
0.0985298008,
0.4788443744,
-0.3580878675,
-0.7186210155,
0.4456597567,
-0.1247334629,
0.1365312487,
0.579179585,
0.0540323593,
-1.0491081476,
-0.1690107286,
-0.3055413365,
0.0129863974,
0.1588011682,
1.3265633583,
-0.72010988,
0.167943269,
0.264090836,
0.8563767076,
0.172948882,
0.4095775783,
0.6043197513,
-0.0938075557,
0.2063712776,
0.367126137,
0.1429262906,
0.1962402314,
-0.3176729679,
0.5666438341,
0.3422393501,
-0.5376039147,
-1.0021107197,
0.0121905087,
-0.8468807936,
-0.5231035352,
1.3564258814,
0.1587085873,
-0.2248364985,
-0.6273030639,
-0.5365718603,
-0.1404890865,
-0.3188757896,
1.0109233856,
0.8856931925,
-0.3252390921,
0.0013081431,
-0.7077091336,
0.1671588123,
0.4897140265,
-1.0859695673,
-0.0224102531,
0.338629365,
0.3106451035,
0.1200276539,
0.597514689,
-0.1243649945,
-0.0267596729,
-0.2245532721,
-0.1476783156,
0.1690071523,
-0.2905781865,
-0.5501666069,
0.227726534,
0.0458571576,
0.3031357825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06907v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06907v2
|
AIOS Compiler: LLM as Interpreter for Natural Language Programming and Flow Programming of AI Agents
| 2024-05-11T04:29:03 | 2024-05-21T20:35:55 |
Shuyuan Xu, Zelong Li, Kai Mei, Yongfeng Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.PL
|
Since their inception, programming languages have trended towards greater
readability and lower barriers for programmers. Following this trend, natural
language can be a promising type of programming language that provides great
flexibility and usability and helps towards the democracy of programming.
However, the inherent vagueness, ambiguity, and verbosity of natural language
pose significant challenges in developing an interpreter that can accurately
understand the programming logic and execute instructions written in natural
language. Fortunately, recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have
demonstrated remarkable proficiency in interpreting complex natural language.
Inspired by this, we develop a novel system for Code Representation and
Execution (CoRE), which employs LLM as interpreter to interpret and execute
natural language instructions. The proposed system unifies natural language
programming, pseudo-code programming, and flow programming under the same
representation for constructing language agents, while LLM serves as the
interpreter to interpret and execute the agent programs. In this paper, we
begin with defining the programming syntax that structures natural language
instructions logically. During the execution, we incorporate external memory to
minimize redundancy. Furthermore, we equip the designed interpreter with the
capability to invoke external tools, compensating for the limitations of LLM in
specialized domains or when accessing real-time information. This work is
open-source at https://github.com/agiresearch/CoRE,
https://github.com/agiresearch/OpenAGI, and
https://github.com/agiresearch/AIOS.
|
[
-0.1189716458,
-0.4641446471,
0.6116574407,
0.0230597053,
-0.2111911774,
0.4100210369,
-0.3194130659,
-0.5920829177,
0.1775649637,
0.6470321417,
-0.3317646682,
-0.5222545862,
-0.6345012188,
0.1551053077,
-0.3418443799,
0.7693436146,
0.0607109517,
0.031717144,
-0.1488340199,
-0.1781357378,
-0.3060673475,
-0.3229651749,
-0.6276478171,
-0.2516595721,
-0.4004676938,
0.3747232258,
0.8589059114,
0.8468950391,
0.5102263093,
0.475938797,
0.3224484026,
0.2006183863,
-0.2609795034,
0.263594985,
-0.3069389164,
-0.5747841597,
-0.3519693315,
-0.1898963153,
0.7152501345,
0.1228999123,
-0.09511213,
-0.0829889402,
-0.3576575816,
0.6220543385,
-0.5549494028,
0.4722631574,
-0.5345900059,
-0.0864817798,
-0.2260970324,
-0.2586866021,
-0.3798756003,
-0.2873762548,
-0.1461153477,
-0.6504555345,
-0.3707127273,
0.0959441215,
0.4484057426,
0.6346885562,
-0.212820828,
-0.9387505651,
-0.7240719199,
0.8028160334,
-0.8535918593,
0.1610462517,
0.009172353,
0.5902417898,
-0.0876217112,
-0.8796548843,
-0.6478791237,
-0.7253763676,
-0.1588895768,
-0.1126667857,
-0.1077515483,
0.2090253681,
-0.030170992,
0.6062378287,
-0.4593307972,
0.0832052603,
-0.1246549711,
-0.2196976244,
0.5677519441,
0.3445846736,
0.6464627385,
-0.0024311473,
-0.2608615458,
0.2708465457,
-0.5697767138,
-0.0888248831,
0.4535269737,
0.3587181568,
-0.3437827229,
0.712174952,
-0.227783516,
0.7003550529,
-0.1877885759,
0.0235000867,
0.0330307893,
0.0438652821,
-0.1110531166,
-0.0501440875,
0.7996116877,
0.128601402,
0.3895915747,
-0.249661386,
-0.2912582755,
0.2840254307,
0.5085414052,
-0.6040516496,
0.0060699843,
0.1841084212,
-0.301972121,
-0.1324537247,
0.2291896194,
-0.4495491982,
-0.2530609965,
-0.5902661681,
0.1527953297,
-0.4978299141,
0.0329183713,
-0.0308942758,
0.0785125643,
0.4050830305,
0.3501369655,
-0.5484034419,
0.6270766258,
0.8000725508,
0.7797208428,
-0.0870039314,
-0.1424645782,
-0.8302617669,
0.3297801614,
-0.1088579893,
0.6041942239,
-0.8580707908,
-0.2904157639,
-0.2006870061,
-0.3381076455,
0.0776732489,
-0.4022197723,
0.3277030885,
-0.6796404123,
0.0469296165,
0.4059585035,
-0.6417542696,
-0.075419791,
0.2816114426,
-0.490958184,
0.7639761567,
0.0795154497,
-0.5376606584,
-0.4770927131,
-0.994027853,
-0.6137282252,
0.2394765466,
-0.6533091068,
-0.0993540883,
-0.0655526146,
0.0811252445,
0.1503421813,
-0.5819047689,
0.2060572207,
-0.005168302,
-0.7842811942,
0.08057338,
-0.0484161042,
0.8143512607,
0.3619838059,
-0.5341851115,
0.3061577678,
-0.4331221282,
0.0662823096,
0.0222767144,
-0.2538551688,
-0.0090390323,
0.2145119011,
-0.3750512898,
-0.0365803391,
0.5386021733,
-0.3489651084,
0.6048238277,
-0.4678582847,
0.6230306625,
0.8381845951,
-0.2849535942,
0.6959173083,
0.063758865,
0.7525729537,
-0.3479682207,
0.1425111443,
-0.0519236177,
-0.5243561268,
-0.7486140132,
-0.5148794651,
-0.2670185864,
1.0294693708,
-0.9675271511,
0.4932972789,
-0.1761681587,
-0.4540567398,
-0.6352772117,
0.3637460172,
0.540340364,
0.4080469906,
0.2577811778,
0.0368284807,
-0.6050146222,
-1.0428682566,
-0.16392456,
-0.5415218472,
0.0956808254,
0.2037261575,
0.3625684679,
-0.6965117455,
1.0063556433,
-0.5568035245,
-0.1487940401,
-0.4475171864,
-0.0962643698,
0.4560939968,
0.5871422887,
0.4422318041,
-0.4645948112,
-0.4149957001,
0.3009637296,
-0.7333256006,
-0.2413716763,
0.0993818715,
-0.4685967267,
0.1262222379,
0.5265824199,
-0.6562937498,
0.3043830991,
0.6391000152,
-0.1405403316,
0.6284459829,
-0.180944398,
-0.028164722,
-0.8828991652,
0.3710620403,
-0.4411113858,
-0.4681699276,
-0.4623763561,
0.6130148172,
-0.0942991599,
-0.2630590796,
-0.5125747323,
0.88746351,
-0.4577631652,
-0.220460847,
-0.3688599467,
-0.2352981567,
-0.088717483,
0.2963085175,
0.0691616237,
1.0303939581,
0.9041519165,
-0.7366348505,
0.6055711508,
0.1105754972,
-0.0316567309,
0.3806985319,
-0.6253626943,
0.5726933479,
-0.0532868169,
0.1820416301,
-0.3753888309,
-0.1569135338,
0.4640208483,
-0.4506402612,
0.4248670936,
-0.2358051538,
-0.5885954499,
-0.2905832231,
-0.2972853482,
0.2083922476,
0.413009584,
-0.3617681563,
0.8030980229,
0.3211893141,
0.0750259086,
-0.6793697476,
-0.6121559739,
0.2571287453,
0.0931649432,
-0.6679971218,
0.1466053426,
-0.2459367961,
-0.4643193781,
0.2562720776,
0.1763204038,
0.0153031219,
0.1138077155,
0.2723558545,
0.3482840955,
-0.2183736712,
-0.1641732901,
0.0488985665,
-0.5219175816,
-0.2064064145,
-0.3349983692,
0.5014191866,
-0.7249388099,
-0.6495275497,
-0.7489080429,
0.483858496,
0.6689501405,
-0.3202861845,
0.5832296014,
0.3110076189,
-0.345302999,
-0.2350173593,
-0.3463148773,
0.0823560879,
-0.5304555297,
0.0383101031,
-0.3286395371,
-0.8745104671,
0.5558635592,
0.0088149756,
0.02946404,
0.49243626,
0.8031091094,
-0.0096833203,
0.8493711948,
0.4631333947,
-0.3265905976,
0.4408195317,
-0.4773060083,
0.2454491705,
-0.7402819991,
-0.0618751533,
-0.549521625,
-0.3140209019,
-0.2317143977,
-0.6756255627,
0.2863818705,
0.0881752595,
-0.3256997168,
0.2677176297,
-0.7793144584,
0.5324159861,
0.7341694236,
-0.3429619968,
0.3760524392,
-0.1831258982,
-0.2223971486,
0.178910628,
-0.2426658273,
-0.9317545295,
0.7847739458,
0.2797311246,
1.1031281948,
0.1701935679,
0.7526220679,
0.7172573209,
0.4093134403,
-0.7559671402,
0.6269350052,
-0.2887580395,
-0.5628862381,
-0.094736062,
-0.3730951548,
-0.6441898942,
0.0906900242,
0.3240656853,
-0.7108309865,
-0.1085476503,
0.1102590933,
-0.1489670724,
0.2952220142,
-0.8924004436,
0.7802997231,
-0.3860337734,
-0.0842904896,
-0.3033322692,
-0.7464028001,
0.3042916656,
0.409018755,
0.2183986455,
-0.036542546,
-0.2156684548,
0.2045193911,
-0.713344574,
0.7680660486,
-0.0696025789,
0.191443041,
0.8487479091,
0.2443072051,
0.7819820642,
0.3259348869,
-0.5607481599,
0.1260480583,
-0.2847499251,
-0.3690554202,
-0.5254346132,
0.7730909586,
-0.788606286,
-0.494581908,
-0.5758334398,
-0.593662858,
0.2221300751,
0.213230297,
0.0895498917,
0.385209322,
0.0512264818,
-0.1873472929,
0.0891521722,
-0.1904638708,
0.2414230853,
0.6133581996,
-0.1347995996,
-0.3005143404,
0.8958389163,
-0.3962916732,
0.2816022336,
0.631614387,
0.0007689265,
-0.190834254,
-0.8543675542,
-0.6121043563,
0.26867643,
-0.7778308392,
-0.3511396646,
-0.4058842361,
-0.3671509027,
-0.5374107957,
-0.4415646195,
-0.363765806,
-0.327881217,
-0.4188470542,
0.1913530231,
0.2947238982,
0.8740544319,
0.1037879735,
0.3998794854,
-0.8632649779,
0.4578838944,
0.2527052462,
0.4498976469,
-0.3104172945,
-0.2007590979,
-0.4038073719,
-0.1411527544,
-0.1842831075,
-0.8761565685,
0.3536459804,
0.2809135616,
0.7694572806,
0.4542438388,
0.1551916152,
0.6386219859,
-0.3190778196,
0.5162261128,
-0.1949438006,
-1.2187594175,
0.7379283309,
-0.0602446645,
0.410613209,
0.6842381358,
-0.0731603503,
-0.5009869337,
-0.916932404,
-0.2090387046,
-0.5013681054,
0.8986093998,
0.4942093492,
0.0026515564,
-0.2114643157,
0.409678936,
0.0535332672,
0.4114271998,
-0.4790523052,
-0.2151814103,
-0.1166515201,
-0.3125327229,
0.1063246876,
0.1322417855,
-0.0336214118,
-0.1025074497,
0.6059057117,
-0.5074438453,
0.6382424831,
0.0330258198,
-0.5009912252,
0.0488497689,
0.1671236455,
0.4768432677,
0.5733713508,
-0.1557189226,
0.3939501047,
-0.2541898787,
-0.438187927,
-0.1634882838,
0.1216543987,
-0.3465228379,
-0.2827153802,
0.7507302761,
0.7763050795,
-0.1105782613,
-1.2239302397,
0.291256994,
0.045094274,
0.4571428597,
-0.5072061419,
0.2761810422,
0.1886772364,
0.504371047,
0.3945691884,
0.1325159222,
0.4461738169,
-0.8170546293,
0.0634207055,
0.5494595766,
-0.2310740501,
-0.4047279358,
0.6287323833,
0.4413779974,
-0.5163467526,
0.8788812757,
-0.8470209241,
-0.8237318993,
0.8315758705,
0.4184087217,
0.9825543761,
-0.2368303984,
0.0007403201,
0.1024838537,
0.494566977,
0.2203291506,
0.5548324585,
-0.0138529539,
-0.5686150789,
-0.4295060635,
-0.7093601823,
-0.5687788129,
-0.3359189928,
-0.2435891777,
0.3029683232,
-0.646828413,
0.0708522499,
-0.6505544186,
0.0026358427,
-0.5608161092,
-0.0391014181,
0.4803051651,
0.8142877817,
-0.5293947458,
1.0583481789,
1.1585669518,
-0.2143143564,
-0.4468655586,
-0.2346141338,
0.2449374795,
-1.040879488,
0.5069193244,
0.3101291358,
-0.2910810709,
0.0276031699,
-0.446661979,
-0.8493919373,
1.0666822195,
0.7854679227,
-0.3796230555,
-0.0933139473,
0.136880368,
0.6047019958,
-0.6552732587,
0.3990488946,
0.4487126768,
0.521254003,
0.2118167579,
-0.9682428837,
0.1154926643,
-0.4427300394,
-0.0918898731,
0.2500762045,
-0.4858759344,
0.7730150819,
-0.2682561874,
-0.3686832786,
0.1821350157,
0.540607512,
0.3594377041,
0.2754374743,
0.4163345695,
0.5434481502,
0.6110540032,
0.0325814821,
1.3170598745,
-0.6462619901,
0.2340062112,
1.173866868,
-0.277738452,
0.6803408861,
0.3130380213,
-0.2689174712,
0.6559528708,
0.1426358819,
0.3636868,
0.295681417,
0.1456169635,
-0.2160450667,
-0.1789871752,
0.0339646824,
-0.2362170517,
0.3581520915,
0.5999453664,
-0.2273680419,
-0.2204271108,
-0.2663887441,
-0.1822994053,
0.0683572441,
-0.1775685698,
0.4672356546,
0.184171021,
-0.4228310585,
0.3133424819,
0.1538436562,
0.664696157,
-0.7367884517,
-0.1032348126,
-0.1567888409,
0.2454303801,
-0.1609704494,
-0.9234289527,
0.8197901845,
0.0556056462,
0.1163292527,
-0.2963016927,
0.7735522389,
-0.0598301813,
-0.4443722367,
0.4798169136,
0.2114073485,
0.3366805315,
-0.1244322136,
-0.9326178432,
0.3098753393,
-0.0122587932,
-0.2204018831,
-0.0728765205,
0.3241648376,
-0.0746733621,
1.1228888035,
0.5733968616,
0.124069415,
0.2616131306,
-0.132741645,
0.9561876059,
-0.6213528514,
-0.6935001612,
-0.8795055747,
0.5233094692,
0.0367894955,
-0.0341921784,
0.3882150948,
0.7680674791,
0.3263328373,
-0.1101791114,
0.6570187211,
-0.3961568177,
0.2694191039,
-0.5912117958,
0.4100722671,
-0.3187712729,
0.4146257937,
0.1160346568,
-0.9460915327,
-0.1812427938,
0.5919348598,
-0.1701533645,
-0.1783658266,
0.5945250988,
0.7005384564,
-0.0100173671,
-0.2892257869,
0.009438525,
0.1552630961,
0.584739089,
0.6166964173,
0.7208349109,
-0.0685308352,
0.5161756873,
-0.1920530051,
-0.0966785997,
-0.4739546478,
-0.707190752,
-0.6625759006,
-0.248803705,
-0.2804467678,
-0.0727487355,
-0.057767421,
0.9624347687,
0.709810853,
-0.6981664896,
-0.5214871168,
-0.1280712187,
0.2939439118,
-0.1603724062,
-0.2607830167,
0.154322803,
-0.3750963211,
-1.0311603546,
0.6356249452,
0.6338954568,
-0.1440491825,
-0.4767791629,
-0.7648872137,
-0.1809427589,
0.0309936181,
0.5314627886,
0.5813672543,
-0.778655529,
-0.176492095,
-0.0556857958,
-0.3789034784,
0.0125964032,
0.9076461196,
-0.7452614307,
0.5970644355,
0.6550782919,
0.8417289853,
0.2682455182,
-0.0931641683,
0.6754431129,
-0.4992443025,
0.2696505487,
0.5791247487,
0.2002853304,
0.2610972226,
-0.5601881742,
0.5318970084,
0.0959949866,
-0.3581739068,
-0.6488220096,
0.4983324111,
-1.1307709217,
-0.1609417945,
0.8294296265,
-0.0255347881,
-0.1740368307,
-0.1153298914,
-0.245713681,
0.4006477594,
-0.6645672917,
0.4308150113,
0.5245748162,
-0.4545278251,
-0.0446076803,
-0.5500264764,
0.1238771677,
0.0678392798,
-1.0303919315,
-0.3676632941,
0.5036859512,
0.0489222594,
0.2723069787,
0.9575273395,
-0.0949497446,
0.0083617847,
-0.3166195154,
0.3682028353,
-0.2323583961,
-0.1247652769,
-0.1887824535,
-0.1432227045,
0.1431215107,
-0.2160914391
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.